id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.04339v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.04339v2 | Merging by Matching Models in Task Parameter Subspaces | 2023-12-07T14:59:15 | 2024-04-13T16:31:25 | Derek Tam, Mohit Bansal, Colin Raffel | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Model merging aims to cheaply combine individual task-specific models into a
single multitask model. In this work, we view past merging methods as
leveraging different notions of a ''task parameter subspace'' in which models
are matched before being merged. We connect the task parameter subspace of a
given model to its loss landscape and formalize how this approach to model
merging can be seen as solving a linear system of equations. While past work
has generally been limited to linear systems that have a closed-form solution,
we consider using the conjugate gradient method to find a solution. We show
that using the conjugate gradient method can outperform closed-form solutions,
enables merging via linear systems that are otherwise intractable to solve, and
flexibly allows choosing from a wide variety of initializations and estimates
for the ''task parameter subspace''. We ultimately demonstrate that our merging
framework called ''Matching Models in their Task Parameter Subspace'' (MaTS)
achieves state-of-the-art results in multitask and intermediate-task model
merging. We release all of the code and checkpoints used in our work at
https://github.com/r-three/mats. | [
-0.0600671135,
0.0585732199,
0.0027855698,
0.005214307,
-0.0075544468,
0.0393818654,
0.0484342016,
-0.0160121955,
-0.0311739165,
0.0129767554,
-0.0156361964,
-0.0235953182,
0.0399536267,
0.0330755226,
0.0459755585,
-0.0212372579,
0.0365034938,
-0.028993072,
-0.043334052,
-0.0081785778,
-0.0113793593,
0.0080541177,
0.0235229898,
0.0485520884,
0.0104225865,
0.0093839038,
-0.0068431091,
0.0421294495,
0.0670428202,
0.060472995,
0.0686965436,
0.0172580015,
0.0247769225,
0.0649194866,
0.0000019812,
-0.0026044364,
0.0018076885,
0.0090247067,
-0.0136130126,
-0.0381463915,
0.0324129909,
0.0259113126,
-0.0102771437,
-0.0004362785,
0.0003895391,
-0.0150033943,
0.0712566674,
0.0220077354,
0.0438149348,
-0.0166859291,
0.0021308598,
0.0179232974,
0.0318032317,
-0.0636692047,
-0.0162071027,
-0.0350477137,
0.0658368766,
0.0045071268,
-0.031474527,
-0.089863494,
-0.0000887399,
0.0253283475,
0.0117137879,
0.0013050003,
0.0422524512,
0.0150027024,
0.0476465411,
-0.0121060526,
-0.0687463284,
0.0142994598,
-0.0801609606,
0.0007184806,
0.0659790114,
0.0117246341,
-0.0007891281,
-0.0087936511,
-0.04775583,
-0.0212344397,
-0.0275700875,
-0.0026035367,
-0.042702537,
-0.0232404619,
0.0285916477,
0.0031460854,
-0.0153455231,
0.0217942204,
0.0442210995,
0.0249461252,
-0.0046872632,
0.0052188239,
-0.030010866,
-0.0433347449,
0.0064506838,
-0.0100309057,
-0.0681584105,
-0.0496985875,
-0.0609113835,
-0.0787875876,
-0.0361046158,
0.0290113725,
0.1239474639,
0.0104753282,
0.0324869752,
0.0646905452,
-0.0187157281,
0.0132254763,
-0.0844670385,
0.0143282944,
-0.0712083355,
-0.0100993328,
-0.0652067363,
0.0052429354,
0.0056013283,
0.0003037729,
-0.0419681482,
0.0073096282,
-0.0122368429,
0.0210599061,
-0.0647403821,
-0.0331140719,
0.0150884772,
0.0117916847,
-0.0429760702,
-0.0231126565,
0.002008073,
0.0155571569,
0.0319179893,
0.0621660315,
0.0346684046,
0.0518246628,
-0.0167155955,
-0.0294483397,
-0.0364209712,
-0.0454456024,
-0.0037166618,
0.0401845947,
-0.0224418342,
0.0528004616,
-0.0229507405,
-0.0402165912,
0.0368341804,
-0.062754035,
0.0123016844,
-0.0255191382,
0.0916701779,
-0.0651413053,
0.0084266299,
-0.0077770012,
-0.0069229328,
-0.0184009019,
-0.0130775226,
0.097888194,
0.010457458,
0.0172201376,
0.0611224398,
-0.0053576119,
-0.0646859184,
0.0599938668,
-0.0149921775,
0.0215475056,
-0.0341318771,
-0.0156897493,
-0.0084599201,
0.013241631,
0.0271867178,
0.0202886499,
0.0223551821,
-0.0435037464,
0.0826049447,
-0.0175586175,
0.0206246264,
0.0017806625,
-0.0381400846,
0.0319937542,
0.0406287536,
-0.0018640191,
0.0330632851,
0.0337387882,
0.0097844061,
0.0015821948,
-0.021664232,
-0.0046173241,
-0.035786733,
0.0501461662,
-0.0618240573,
-0.0176674016,
0.0172615387,
0.1051139683,
-0.048952844,
-0.0753759071,
0.0056773145,
-0.0254512131,
-0.0074168015,
-0.0005323413,
0.0936636552,
-0.032988321,
-0.0807056129,
-0.0300344992,
0.0326326303,
-0.0591615029,
-0.0084047457,
-0.0556205809,
-0.0253946912,
-0.0042532808,
-0.010641343,
-0.0268297009,
-0.0529279485,
-0.0102038467,
0.0385065973,
-0.0484635979,
0.0025071257,
0.012586778,
0.0803184211,
-0.0166252572,
-0.079613775,
0.0325018093,
0.0010447608,
0.0072251963,
-0.0086251749,
-0.0560799539,
-0.0025865773,
0.0335786715,
-0.0161053743,
0.0092166299,
-0.0564741865,
0.0413578488,
0.0191098973,
-0.0146696437,
0.0372002833,
-0.0166484043,
0.0047528339,
-0.0027233826,
0.0346282981,
-0.0241493993,
-0.042709101,
0.0312503017,
0.025713427,
0.0139334518,
0.0038301772,
-0.0208120141,
-0.0105933864,
0.0817459151,
-0.0402665846,
-0.0608353652,
-0.032670036,
-0.0037848046,
0.0248478204,
0.0084823184,
0.0390653722,
-0.0015093688,
-0.0347108543,
-0.0063977172,
0.0242010057,
-0.0135906916,
-0.0344506428,
0.0051802406,
-0.0502476729,
-0.0363391861,
-0.0321666114,
-0.0441973209,
-0.0037170902,
-0.0329966284,
0.0023523574,
0.0243921056,
-0.0423807874,
0.0095753875,
-0.0033400967,
-0.0525402166,
0.0489052348,
0.0225423202,
0.0050748284,
0.0082179606,
-0.0049744304,
0.0200786833,
0.0582602806,
0.0345730372,
0.038768176,
-0.0176340174,
0.0044589275,
0.0008240946,
0.0126999402,
-0.0369008482,
-0.0429222547,
-0.0448004603,
-0.028468553,
0.0094088605,
0.0004755637,
-0.0354982652,
-0.0379708596,
0.0035783197,
0.0085357875,
0.0096860016,
-0.0321876556,
0.0080912961,
-0.0444281548,
-0.0340182632,
0.0476364121,
0.0884902328,
-0.0204393547,
0.0093580317,
0.0521338843,
-0.0431272052,
0.0186325815,
0.025557436,
-0.0201400872,
-0.0220501628,
0.0252566691,
-0.0407093167,
0.0068703261,
0.0651825294,
-0.0373032652,
-0.0249948408,
-0.0276379101,
0.0048283632,
-0.0259176958,
0.0021531871,
-0.0387524329,
-0.0008764788,
-0.0038596066,
0.0055624172,
-0.066390194,
-0.0638808683,
0.0659927502,
0.032200329,
-0.0011077398,
-0.0172164924,
-0.0115308696,
-0.0107501633,
-0.0273240022,
-0.0172443744,
-0.0058130408,
0.0209983587,
0.0267893448,
-0.0444628373,
0.01519519,
0.0476532765,
-0.0017391879,
0.0166310426,
-0.0333812386,
0.0126444884,
-0.0033261569,
-0.0353707299,
-0.0025367483,
0.0213158038,
0.0110830879,
0.0091537107,
-0.0058045858,
-0.0170300081,
-0.0906592011,
-0.0243032929,
0.0031196214,
-0.0106692016,
-0.0429794155,
-0.0216001309,
-0.0347032137,
0.02903766,
0.0597941279,
0.0267685205,
-0.010903012,
-0.057672929,
0.0407819375,
0.0280808304,
0.0974755213,
0.0246631652,
-0.0488311797,
-0.0387286693,
0.0558948666,
0.0129826786,
-0.0091361189,
-0.0141893709,
0.0273245387,
-0.0359110907,
0.0396644324,
0.0169008784,
-0.0015733541,
-0.0258869417,
-0.0568044223,
-0.042880293,
0.0575542673,
-0.0033623464,
0.024309054,
0.0218403935,
-0.0268568359,
0.0452057645,
-0.0014003597,
0.0391582958,
0.018006226,
0.0034150782,
-0.0415309519,
-0.0061701685,
0.0644710809,
-0.0121523095,
0.0273575615,
0.0119321262,
0.0178924277,
-0.0492627285,
-0.0258864965,
0.0073734382,
-0.0260279365,
-0.0226724651,
0.0012853589,
0.0360039063,
-0.0041807494,
-0.0357219987,
-0.0446590669,
0.0303457994,
0.0354675129,
0.0065956982,
0.0064797597,
-0.0383415818,
0.0631007776,
0.0447079577,
-0.0394995995,
0.0057269703,
0.0143012591,
0.0105049284,
0.0218412559,
-0.0153542534,
0.0731476694,
-0.0231335033,
-0.0131089771,
-0.0039029513,
0.0616585724,
0.0242005009,
0.0154479202,
-0.0249795783,
-0.0383701287,
0.0390010178,
0.0580132157,
-0.0376740508,
-0.0438320003,
-0.040723864,
0.0081004649,
-0.0373246036,
0.0169642176,
0.00156828,
-0.0110597806,
-0.0359244943,
-0.0221175477,
-0.0158711355,
0.0353176594,
0.0255072098,
0.0306951888,
0.0031433853,
-0.0131067317,
-0.0135565978,
-0.0023651854,
-0.0812492371,
0.0445313044,
0.0099975178,
0.0510249585,
-0.0509204678,
0.0141735999,
0.0058104317,
-0.0182244517,
-0.0319677219,
0.0349735804,
-0.1546884328,
-0.0655005798,
-0.0336308293,
0.0370721221,
0.0157052223,
0.0031804687,
-0.0004048391,
0.0089693647,
0.0133020924,
-0.0126934675,
0.0156231774,
0.034892723,
0.0766265839,
-0.0347126611,
0.0056134784,
0.0152444663,
-0.0684688166,
-0.0116196582,
-0.0187328421,
-0.0167961363,
-0.0035732749,
0.0222201142,
-0.0123742577,
-0.0268149171,
0.0738709196,
-0.005226695,
-0.0647485405,
-0.034811601,
-0.0003839686,
0.0218097828,
0.0026515082,
-0.0409539379,
-0.0044905841,
-0.0096688811,
0.0363471135,
0.0379259996,
0.0628443882,
0.0835361332,
-0.0103601152,
-0.071254082,
-0.0583444126,
-0.0128795607,
-0.0073956433,
0.0317881331,
0.0320601277,
0.0430133082,
0.0159891304,
0.0078559341,
-0.0134507781,
-0.0041044364,
-0.0068458356,
0.0216955319,
0.0536155142,
-0.0235404428,
0.0577353053,
-0.0683877766,
-0.079524979,
-0.0201707315,
-0.022015484,
0.0682593212,
0.003645042,
0.0687448829,
0.0042567691,
-0.027645072,
-0.0530221313,
0.0318125375,
-0.0175180621,
0.0498361178,
0.0515077747,
-0.0111867031,
0.0384567268,
-0.0204580147,
0.0539953336,
0.0164227448,
0.0324303024,
-0.0353276357,
0.0019681393,
-0.0238743592,
-0.0218267776,
0.0273471214,
0.0184807796,
-0.0127524994,
-0.0838221163,
0.0028392398,
-0.0381755307,
0.0415894464,
0.0108818663,
-0.0156209907,
0.0123738442,
0.0158045311,
-0.0035815919,
-0.0410039872,
-0.0227347389,
0.0398951173,
-0.0396041274,
-0.0178474225,
-0.0255787801,
0.0408728831,
-5.933798872e-33,
-0.007154319,
-0.0099162618,
-0.0223787334,
0.0059716906,
-0.0327285491,
0.0092715351,
0.0171597078,
-0.0139407907,
0.0217128079,
-0.0140734594,
0.0062214178,
0.0080561237,
0.0117375245,
-0.0094571952,
0.0102507779,
0.0054753139,
0.0308392998,
0.0155683281,
0.0079566306,
0.0150335999,
-0.0063427174,
0.0270824246,
-0.0334735848,
-0.0278674811,
-0.0048590456,
0.0192793924,
-0.0353193656,
0.0111238221,
-0.0399557278,
0.0286273304,
-0.0128189884,
0.0044794404,
-0.0129608782,
-0.0145556945,
-0.0393984057,
0.0515168086,
-0.0508694723,
0.042985633,
0.0234251488,
-0.0418667309,
-0.0631566793,
-0.0402264595,
0.0237694103,
0.0263347048,
-0.0100725796,
-0.060806565,
0.0519713722,
-0.0217334889,
0.0177060906,
-0.0290011708,
-0.0332842618,
-0.0247421023,
-0.0068650362,
-0.0545020625,
0.080266811,
0.0527546406,
0.0151356142,
-0.0061157267,
-0.0376272015,
0.0230923593,
-0.0370546654,
0.0035341668,
0.092100285,
0.0637599751,
0.0012170329,
0.0443243124,
-0.0150330104,
-0.0215679873,
-0.0357465707,
-0.0181885697,
-0.0081959711,
0.0686083362,
0.036798887,
-0.0057055829,
0.0203198213,
0.0213052109,
-0.0404789038,
0.0668096915,
-0.0049218331,
0.0183669049,
-0.0317447074,
0.0732353255,
0.0351147093,
0.0030827909,
-0.0166276805,
-0.0193160251,
-0.0415845104,
0.0459796339,
0.013800527,
0.0081875045,
-0.0197309386,
-0.0024214806,
0.0132873617,
-0.0251432527,
0.0526857041,
0.0042762035,
0.0198986083,
0.0070139715,
0.0160027798,
0.0157540813,
-0.0116139082,
-0.0307626203,
-0.0041674869,
0.0389533639,
0.0020829963,
0.0102978628,
-0.025648687,
0.0015318478,
-0.0105832033,
0.0136595694,
-0.053652253,
0.0102670956,
0.0519925989,
0.0154535789,
0.1133340597,
0.0115567576,
0.0339787416,
0.0101918662,
-0.0139765842,
-0.0175939593,
-0.0683899075,
0.0606155582,
-0.0210280567,
0.0093411636,
0.025770478,
0.012834534,
0.0001813271,
-0.0411108918,
0.0589081123,
-0.006903959,
-0.0445871763,
-0.0033106096,
2.679e-7,
-0.0471899398,
-0.0100818137,
0.0068931663,
-0.0335359946,
-0.0085692676,
0.042958051,
-0.0424522869,
0.0192904193,
-0.0207519419,
-0.0212726239,
-0.0180712771,
0.0124716116,
0.0887320116,
-0.0172052067,
-0.0336162485,
-0.031742271,
-0.0038598999,
0.0562817343,
-0.0160977561,
-0.0217679441,
0.0237378627,
0.023335617,
0.0501258634,
-0.0235069692,
-0.0088056419,
0.0260533132,
0.0694658309,
-0.0509088002,
0.0257251039,
0.0009786802,
-0.0232424848,
-0.0542399883,
-0.040657226,
0.0387891419,
-0.0069791311,
-0.0049975999,
0.0317510143,
0.0782893822,
0.0004714431,
-0.0044985642,
-0.0098181907,
0.0696395561,
-0.0147349546,
0.0224496834,
0.0563142039,
-0.0433125906,
0.0044781682,
-0.043992877,
-0.0217300616,
0.0042823199,
0.0406668857,
0.0032204762,
0.0293975398,
0.0179941896,
-0.0178491008,
0.026790088,
0.0079109538,
-0.0313645862,
0.0065503186,
0.0452295132,
-0.0883049965,
-0.0184378382,
-0.0298707485,
-0.0049081333,
0.053203743,
-0.0716638342,
-0.0327263363,
2.568454927e-34,
-0.0021947599,
-0.0295798313,
0.0628911778,
0.0372045115,
-0.0291529559,
-0.0139824953,
-0.0629003718,
0.0271316711,
0.0040105907,
-0.046582032,
-0.0050711036
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.04333v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.04333v4 | Is Bigger and Deeper Always Better? Probing LLaMA Across Scales and Layers | 2023-12-07T14:50:41 | 2024-01-09T07:33:07 | Nuo Chen, Ning Wu, Shining Liang, Ming Gong, Linjun Shou, Dongmei Zhang, Jia Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper presents an in-depth analysis of Large Language Models (LLMs),
focusing on LLaMA, a prominent open-source foundational model in natural
language processing. Instead of assessing LLaMA through its generative output,
we design multiple-choice tasks to probe its intrinsic understanding in
high-order tasks such as reasoning and computation. We examine the model
horizontally, comparing different sizes, and vertically, assessing different
layers. We unveil several key and uncommon findings based on the designed
probing tasks: (1) Horizontally, enlarging model sizes almost could not
automatically impart additional knowledge or computational prowess. Instead, it
can enhance reasoning abilities, especially in math problem solving, and helps
reduce hallucinations, but only beyond certain size thresholds; (2) In vertical
analysis, the lower layers of LLaMA lack substantial arithmetic and factual
knowledge, showcasing logical thinking, multilingual and recognitive abilities,
with top layers housing most computational power and real-world knowledge. | [
0.0125682531,
0.0614717938,
-0.0409172364,
0.0461390242,
-0.024012547,
0.0239449125,
0.01232873,
0.0012345139,
-0.000334803,
-0.0157359857,
-0.0608738214,
-0.0578886941,
0.0024574008,
0.0378246829,
0.0505015925,
-0.0296366401,
0.021025857,
-0.0801209435,
0.0040472862,
-0.024328867,
-0.0524844639,
-0.0356301405,
-0.0171103273,
0.0109845018,
0.0163180958,
-0.0303918421,
-0.0155401984,
-0.048474025,
0.0004564695,
-0.0250971541,
-0.0412048437,
0.0317389593,
0.0177414417,
0.050588727,
0.0000020209,
-0.0671205893,
0.0669887364,
-0.0106209954,
-0.0193377882,
0.0530149974,
0.0225729663,
0.0239533056,
-0.0047883391,
-0.0009112637,
-0.0256713144,
-0.0141466046,
0.0293995924,
0.0433537178,
-0.0021784187,
0.0450362973,
0.0072218613,
-0.0661126897,
0.0559339374,
-0.0388284661,
0.0409889258,
-0.0133152399,
0.0294669624,
0.025299333,
0.0197154693,
0.0134369414,
-0.0238903575,
0.0184554793,
0.0592095517,
-0.0055956263,
0.013180363,
0.0629531816,
-0.0004601446,
-0.0401872322,
0.0230506267,
0.052089043,
0.0021319054,
0.0110296514,
-0.013707323,
-0.0087850364,
-0.0070844218,
-0.0201410912,
-0.0634565949,
0.0395756736,
0.0215943325,
0.0257544592,
0.0418250933,
0.0164032355,
0.0438751169,
0.0034894904,
-0.0665698722,
0.1012299657,
0.0075450349,
-0.010391132,
0.0403731652,
0.0069237663,
-0.0124260997,
-0.0466725044,
-0.0034225516,
0.0163981877,
-0.0062392312,
0.0048836102,
0.0228961948,
0.0126715433,
0.0230425484,
-0.0591273606,
0.0785500184,
0.0448839068,
-0.0434359275,
0.0345715806,
-0.0301779751,
0.0460422896,
-0.0526679866,
0.0607766099,
-0.0254033394,
0.0309094768,
-0.005071999,
-0.0330730416,
-0.0048019034,
0.0272776112,
-0.0348187946,
-0.0381349064,
-0.0552154481,
-0.0007957099,
0.0013907932,
-0.0152190886,
-0.0167626459,
0.0031507746,
0.0258136652,
-0.0073246211,
-0.0580968149,
0.0140129803,
-0.0719550103,
0.0477876291,
0.022294635,
-0.055452235,
-0.0129089821,
0.0046933969,
-0.0245846957,
-0.0147695187,
0.0262076817,
0.055701904,
0.0048152255,
-0.0284396764,
-0.0244758502,
-0.0025342021,
0.0010130826,
-0.08153449,
0.0450628698,
-0.065636456,
0.0104729123,
0.0096941618,
0.0047374084,
-0.02345578,
0.025492968,
0.0125570111,
-0.0185181797,
0.0663375035,
0.0144355791,
0.0063544237,
0.0258023739,
0.0168703049,
0.0107097402,
0.0800959021,
0.0543230176,
0.0180561449,
0.0206676442,
-0.0257377066,
0.0047688996,
0.0478795916,
-0.0164751206,
-0.0421657376,
-0.0443330631,
0.0092759822,
-0.0331355743,
0.0421357006,
0.0323855616,
0.0559165515,
-0.0314383619,
-0.0009857226,
0.0595154464,
0.0935939774,
0.0061501749,
0.0356666744,
0.0215245206,
-0.0458577871,
0.0397782736,
0.0169245321,
-0.0616831258,
0.0540262237,
-0.0238403138,
-0.0015253803,
0.0304829963,
0.0227714591,
-0.0254893731,
-0.0615909658,
-0.0238301642,
0.019281799,
-0.0076472396,
0.0017312762,
0.0400775857,
-0.000168655,
-0.0083993115,
0.0107488502,
0.0270110704,
-0.0271856263,
-0.016267268,
-0.0785181671,
0.0457886569,
0.0237459578,
0.0236538388,
-0.0237103011,
0.0180755071,
0.0227345545,
-0.0044582481,
0.0732449666,
0.0453587957,
0.0139863631,
0.0003308236,
-0.0360457376,
0.0207226705,
-0.0486938395,
0.0372002833,
0.005731394,
-0.0005428361,
-0.0062456569,
-0.0065304465,
-0.0572715811,
-0.0081791254,
0.019467229,
-0.0425419733,
-0.030715866,
-0.0229281988,
-0.0093200328,
0.0171374362,
-0.0094198333,
-0.0053386651,
0.0399289019,
0.0180820283,
-0.0609641857,
-0.0466636457,
-0.0028102384,
-0.0533877164,
0.0174628031,
0.0235351399,
-0.007466468,
0.0322335474,
0.0183124803,
-0.0063409833,
-0.0033680832,
0.0458828211,
-0.0380664244,
0.0354995131,
-0.0395772904,
0.015790537,
-0.020345835,
0.0495557375,
-0.0211628061,
0.1032283977,
-0.0255434308,
0.0209769346,
0.0051238597,
-0.0034320611,
-0.0000268742,
0.0093642073,
-0.0200004689,
0.0115825674,
-0.0084267789,
0.0014049918,
-0.0475602262,
-0.0200951677,
-0.0670312643,
-0.0485637225,
-0.037453834,
0.0229210611,
-0.0052147834,
0.0313173421,
0.0323276967,
-0.012502511,
-0.0255764462,
0.0192436595,
-0.0110812113,
0.0249481983,
0.0160057675,
0.0559811518,
0.0360294357,
-0.0155276153,
-0.0269850828,
-0.0332233459,
-0.0250207633,
-0.0166268069,
0.0583730154,
0.0094524696,
0.0042477939,
-0.0303066839,
0.0406259559,
-0.0537338294,
-0.0018554131,
-0.0245597009,
-0.0336485878,
0.0381394774,
-0.0077834139,
0.0484847464,
0.0934431925,
-0.0254791025,
0.0504028983,
0.0870317146,
-0.0088354796,
0.0015327347,
-0.0029539585,
0.0061447015,
-0.0201210752,
-0.0281644166,
-0.0282559115,
-0.0416600816,
0.1071845591,
-0.0022851422,
0.0048976834,
-0.010119942,
0.039224308,
-0.0457696542,
-0.0442890376,
-0.0065580439,
0.0020617428,
-0.0264247693,
0.0958427712,
-0.0206865016,
-0.0522888154,
0.0422833376,
-0.012906244,
-0.0119567756,
-0.0051936107,
0.0208190959,
-0.0287313443,
0.0835947692,
0.0107105095,
-0.0112403641,
-0.0193874352,
-0.0193736721,
-0.0528216884,
-0.0048075821,
-0.0217377394,
-0.0462313145,
0.0358215608,
-0.0573089421,
-0.0163727514,
-0.0131223015,
-0.0327766314,
-0.0421625897,
0.0393971801,
-0.0489108302,
0.0277952906,
0.0147929788,
-0.0031684963,
-0.0374204256,
-0.0272432733,
0.0496718623,
0.0138062146,
-0.0162217915,
-0.0202162862,
-0.0000076302,
0.0210834276,
0.0263737999,
0.0513684079,
0.0928259566,
-0.0361779779,
0.0297567248,
0.0405998379,
0.0046208967,
0.0292263608,
-0.0136366589,
0.0332035534,
0.0042577735,
-0.0175354071,
-0.0195954777,
0.0346647352,
0.0800247788,
-0.0488275588,
-0.0209385287,
0.0935482606,
0.0375728309,
-0.0110679679,
0.0357969366,
-0.0768416151,
0.0289275609,
0.0605977215,
0.0308193397,
-0.0604547895,
-0.0021870949,
0.0057552191,
-0.0074927448,
-0.0232455861,
-0.0395936966,
0.0007575044,
-0.1318029761,
0.0363931656,
0.0050517027,
0.0049793813,
0.0152460691,
-0.04163846,
0.0101356655,
0.0080793407,
-0.0067160744,
0.0146687394,
-0.0044049122,
-0.004482646,
0.0061119664,
0.0025981795,
-0.0212194268,
0.06000074,
-0.0076935519,
0.0326163135,
0.0249248259,
0.0156447962,
-0.0288423821,
-0.0670254156,
0.036712639,
0.0025985031,
0.0327144191,
0.0126175946,
0.0165549945,
0.0602147281,
-0.0183474775,
-0.0391936228,
0.0346173346,
-0.0293252822,
-0.0304471217,
0.002477651,
0.0739634559,
-0.0030092949,
-0.0552113615,
-0.0096455244,
0.0200592596,
-0.061615888,
0.0493508428,
0.0660739169,
-0.0379006602,
-0.0425646044,
-0.0334597826,
-0.0214752667,
-0.0301642325,
-0.0741682127,
0.0436808653,
0.0838784575,
-0.0176249333,
-0.0462567396,
-0.02810698,
0.014373634,
0.0108981039,
0.0128136743,
-0.0121346014,
0.0159038119,
-0.0260620695,
-0.024967704,
0.0197743941,
-0.0320748016,
0.0091889221,
-0.0359543636,
0.0136884181,
0.0402321517,
-0.0366013162,
-0.0259433966,
0.0125585534,
-0.1117611974,
-0.0766800344,
0.019534396,
0.0278880559,
0.0306586642,
-0.0143685471,
0.0141441338,
-0.0664545149,
0.0469381846,
0.0196100045,
-0.0263010636,
0.0689332336,
-0.002833897,
-0.0010630022,
0.0320400633,
0.0394775383,
0.0103026843,
0.0322990902,
0.0080211749,
0.0234380346,
0.0081459023,
0.0081678713,
0.0016383582,
0.0165273231,
0.0305287112,
0.0172748845,
0.0142709976,
-0.0467843376,
0.0263061468,
-0.0376160406,
0.0048891283,
-0.0113283759,
-0.0402703173,
0.0388988815,
-0.0045901923,
-0.0010971416,
-0.0207870733,
-0.0116024856,
0.0254784189,
-0.0250181947,
0.0175504591,
-0.0002631058,
-0.0165904164,
0.0175813157,
0.007490084,
-0.0191070531,
0.0108960662,
-0.0325291455,
0.0628872365,
0.0132225137,
0.0562486127,
-0.0452517904,
-0.0112040685,
-0.0398854651,
0.0243430994,
-0.0518026687,
-0.091306068,
0.0468371138,
0.0413653292,
0.0184023287,
0.0006617061,
0.0205433387,
-0.0187014509,
0.0130781969,
-0.0027285847,
0.0203103404,
0.0068503618,
-0.0705216676,
0.0314930752,
0.0278437212,
0.0034230014,
-0.0588543788,
0.0682311878,
-0.0151479077,
0.0451315939,
-0.005961386,
0.0296448097,
-0.024540104,
-0.0618958548,
-0.032309752,
0.0176828057,
-0.025862122,
0.0024817283,
-0.0915090814,
-0.0823311135,
-0.0383062176,
0.0161972139,
0.0021104268,
-0.0331516415,
-0.0003515102,
0.0516100153,
-0.0008381489,
-0.015853364,
0.0059946892,
-0.0006991195,
-0.0011177295,
-0.001905206,
0.0313953795,
-6.622576481e-33,
-0.0255622584,
-0.0032483414,
0.0409095399,
-0.0470587276,
-0.0331951492,
0.0118250893,
-0.0352839865,
0.049728483,
-0.0422454216,
0.0094668781,
-0.0342246108,
0.0042445273,
-0.0007185406,
0.0037459498,
0.0417695418,
0.0084794015,
0.006160249,
-0.0251204353,
-0.0370397717,
0.0100394646,
0.0126295146,
-0.0086694034,
0.0499442331,
-0.0328619368,
0.008112127,
0.0135200797,
0.003435669,
0.0196178462,
-0.0537075363,
0.039841,
-0.0654326826,
0.0447009951,
0.0394093022,
-0.0345979519,
-0.0201542899,
0.0040539135,
-0.0421074405,
-0.0480377115,
0.04569076,
0.0089919753,
-0.0400493294,
-0.0329351723,
0.0609968901,
0.008180744,
0.0062918114,
-0.047255829,
0.0138480281,
-0.0454635881,
-0.0106453458,
0.0401546657,
-0.0517827943,
-0.0139340172,
-0.0079507567,
-0.005194189,
-0.0139143039,
-0.0142424637,
-0.0369038656,
-0.0012561245,
-0.0454329476,
0.0260888245,
0.0299191661,
0.0204662271,
0.0661045983,
0.0220928714,
0.0288855135,
0.061197035,
0.0380064137,
-0.0040044705,
-0.0736941546,
-0.0351397991,
0.0348371491,
0.058033336,
0.0261274204,
0.0192228388,
0.0613184012,
-0.0094253728,
-0.0870462507,
-0.0343561992,
0.022829758,
0.0392609127,
0.0482943244,
-0.0084760226,
-0.0167693142,
-0.0125596281,
-0.0416705273,
-0.0124356812,
-0.0475970022,
-0.0224002115,
0.0456100404,
-0.0202378426,
0.0096688569,
-0.0344247036,
0.0043906495,
-0.0369612165,
0.0055438634,
-0.0025540306,
-0.028989356,
0.0553975031,
0.0031659266,
-0.0082450379,
-0.0502998643,
-0.0147079341,
-0.0096641937,
0.0204628073,
0.0362915508,
0.0100500202,
0.0010634402,
-0.0013108241,
-0.0681898966,
-0.0129354848,
-0.0680146441,
-0.0111178653,
0.0726900473,
0.0554812364,
0.0483663008,
-0.0147682354,
-0.0221028477,
-0.0082070231,
-0.0046550068,
0.0051299836,
-0.0400415957,
0.0166745633,
-0.0319604538,
0.0354312994,
-0.0385681204,
-0.0183469225,
-0.0546784662,
0.0078948764,
0.0427304395,
-0.0644670501,
-0.0397713371,
0.0005422586,
2.822e-7,
0.0143591687,
0.0618624389,
-0.0117083518,
0.0435912125,
0.045757018,
0.015619047,
-0.0114986897,
0.0260994621,
0.0023012636,
-0.0570916459,
-0.0323082022,
0.0485366508,
0.0316837281,
0.046002429,
-0.0392347723,
-0.015941551,
-0.0392203368,
0.0058928505,
-0.0518185981,
-0.0412329212,
0.0268461723,
0.0649291202,
0.0182419047,
-0.0143968742,
-0.0095115937,
-0.0617372505,
0.0637536421,
-0.0020585884,
0.0266284458,
0.0112850023,
-0.0025228083,
0.0489982404,
0.0070304084,
0.0196847729,
0.0137909641,
0.0060639642,
-0.010830407,
0.0600472726,
0.0117706638,
0.0179013535,
0.0051001129,
-0.0089921588,
-0.0086188884,
-0.0965303257,
0.082248278,
-0.0578087717,
-0.0586727373,
-0.0021824325,
0.0206288993,
-0.0279136226,
0.0525429137,
-0.0214631725,
0.0252216235,
-0.0044458243,
-0.0062069208,
-0.013086508,
-0.0004587627,
-0.0407972001,
-0.0337806344,
-0.0072689503,
-0.0484948531,
-0.0512090586,
-0.0752085671,
-0.0324987732,
0.0156437624,
-0.0377055891,
0.0080862259,
2.406896545e-34,
0.0209555663,
-0.0006996459,
0.0200917721,
0.0185948014,
0.0127319051,
-0.0255529471,
0.0306093637,
-0.0048154085,
0.0019350227,
-0.1132469103,
-0.0106876055
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.04306v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.04306v1 | nerblackbox: A High-level Library for Named Entity Recognition in Python | 2023-12-07T14:04:15 | 2023-12-07T14:04:15 | Felix Stollenwerk | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We present nerblackbox, a python library to facilitate the use of
state-of-the-art transformer-based models for named entity recognition. It
provides simple-to-use yet powerful methods to access data and models from a
wide range of sources, for fully automated model training and evaluation as
well as versatile model inference. While many technical challenges are solved
and hidden from the user by default, nerblackbox also offers fine-grained
control and a rich set of customizable features. It is thus targeted both at
application-oriented developers as well as machine learning experts and
researchers. | [
0.0226565171,
0.045489423,
0.0235760957,
0.0206120145,
-0.0045101438,
0.059218213,
0.0250591841,
-0.0254149251,
0.0015529346,
-0.0426143035,
-0.014568327,
0.0011375863,
-0.0020502314,
0.048830878,
0.0108000683,
-0.0437917374,
0.0155203119,
-0.0190808102,
-0.0000997958,
0.0533657782,
-0.0361968279,
0.0183393229,
-0.0213947352,
0.0343864188,
0.0045420392,
0.0026576009,
-0.0062285163,
0.0157071389,
0.0413778238,
-0.0711284652,
0.0354632959,
0.0627659187,
-0.0252086055,
0.0625793114,
0.0000020283,
-0.0212669484,
-0.0412522331,
-0.0027122048,
-0.0357807428,
-0.0400264524,
0.0534861237,
-0.0781668499,
-0.0104693882,
0.000060052,
-0.0383138582,
-0.0402481444,
0.0703421086,
0.0678705722,
0.0411087386,
0.0723212808,
-0.0056618862,
-0.030499788,
0.0553929694,
-0.0199330803,
-0.0186255779,
-0.0184153635,
0.0402258486,
-0.0190479327,
-0.0344467908,
0.0005769472,
0.0237296782,
0.0335954018,
0.0012832033,
-0.0101749366,
-0.0154507197,
0.0455205068,
-0.0413896926,
-0.0330101289,
-0.0216317158,
0.0811284035,
-0.0280698705,
-0.0229115039,
0.0297553074,
-0.0048603285,
-0.0035704733,
0.0140281487,
-0.027887214,
0.0211127866,
-0.0225243736,
-0.0148673765,
-0.0015027126,
0.0202178825,
0.020278465,
0.0128342165,
-0.0137245795,
0.0221446082,
-0.0040330719,
-0.0004574364,
-0.0036392345,
0.0107322671,
0.0314800888,
-0.0540387481,
0.0378730334,
0.0324610844,
0.0502279475,
-0.0013839905,
-0.0166103914,
-0.0288191624,
-0.0267768707,
-0.0077685169,
-0.006899802,
0.0081021888,
-0.0204953589,
0.0730468258,
-0.0356170461,
-0.0020982262,
-0.0273014009,
0.0289824158,
0.0401549041,
-0.028181795,
-0.0426277295,
0.010407785,
-0.0231324565,
-0.0027544324,
-0.0098185511,
0.0023895011,
-0.0308111906,
-0.0027884981,
-0.0218276884,
0.0016231306,
0.0188382566,
0.0123203201,
0.0190101601,
-0.0118079204,
-0.0068318909,
0.0537711531,
0.029074084,
-0.0331771635,
-0.0152070634,
-0.0477786511,
-0.0218805112,
-0.0244140048,
0.0431841612,
-0.0505061559,
0.0503394306,
0.0487857498,
0.0306203924,
-0.1118733957,
-0.0282270387,
0.0169353615,
0.0108397417,
-0.0383218788,
0.0259709097,
-0.0404409058,
0.0392300077,
0.0145863788,
0.0313789174,
-0.0767508522,
0.0331843793,
-0.0272602253,
-0.0363988206,
0.0838318616,
-0.02596852,
-0.019360356,
0.0284960344,
0.0197822582,
0.0152471401,
0.0281196535,
0.0364683233,
0.0283432808,
0.0247377381,
-0.0245500002,
0.0177777186,
0.0274259057,
-0.0021510187,
-0.0458777323,
0.0109446943,
-0.0090082139,
-0.022385614,
-0.0105504608,
0.0204207003,
0.0277423915,
-0.0053537916,
-0.034932863,
0.0355604552,
0.0334090889,
0.0291669481,
-0.0018486778,
0.0333055183,
-0.0091587203,
0.0044471682,
-0.0698302686,
-0.0502278432,
0.0558451042,
0.0064284177,
0.0111845853,
-0.0461981222,
0.1102842242,
0.0093474425,
-0.0095429532,
0.0182750747,
-0.0260267816,
0.0109836692,
-0.0120404707,
0.069672592,
0.003529038,
-0.064632073,
0.0897697508,
0.0351225846,
-0.0329665951,
-0.026384091,
-0.0200404283,
0.0105600068,
0.0400483347,
0.0489505641,
-0.0206710901,
-0.0533407368,
-0.0620005578,
-0.0530508906,
0.0366725698,
0.0161115732,
-0.0118942056,
0.0320372321,
-0.0454374366,
-0.0097660227,
0.0475491993,
0.0334774442,
0.0269879624,
0.0379560478,
0.0225765929,
0.0454373062,
0.0069310069,
-0.0177109987,
0.0547220856,
-0.05595598,
-0.0421595462,
-0.0090165166,
0.020191431,
-0.008590905,
0.0481832661,
-0.0182895716,
-0.0250305701,
0.0542208068,
-0.0102717197,
0.0091048898,
-0.0048705419,
0.0011954417,
-0.0212279744,
0.0191229004,
-0.0221613608,
-0.0108751394,
0.0441897437,
-0.0297545064,
-0.035925813,
-0.0184359848,
0.0084395688,
0.0284013692,
-0.0097360993,
0.0306169651,
0.0204573069,
0.0480726026,
-0.018570397,
0.0419065356,
-0.0000807024,
0.0016624988,
0.0287036654,
-0.0254213661,
-0.0157225858,
-0.0164732505,
-0.0353721343,
0.0183107182,
-0.0220195409,
-0.0261315387,
-0.0008391314,
-0.0104566701,
-0.038725771,
-0.036561314,
-0.0542645603,
-0.0053778156,
-0.0027241323,
0.0459827557,
0.0126844617,
0.0344760977,
-0.043353498,
-0.0438611098,
0.0322493017,
-0.0255676862,
-0.0224180911,
-0.0205138568,
0.0154258348,
-0.0158438683,
-0.0276786294,
-0.0111944778,
-0.0210036021,
-0.0388826653,
0.0616381839,
0.0469322875,
-0.0710564405,
-0.0425704047,
-0.0040245252,
-0.0168221947,
0.0119829541,
-0.0116726756,
-0.0006535362,
-0.0286434442,
0.0356190465,
0.0205769632,
0.074497059,
0.0178600084,
0.024330236,
-0.0043225931,
-0.0099514872,
-0.0179227162,
0.0281885397,
-0.0473797731,
0.021217728,
-0.0089404685,
-0.0569008216,
0.0122832041,
0.1117537618,
-0.0538759045,
0.0187819488,
-0.0260597914,
0.0123114837,
0.0251285657,
-0.014341848,
0.0057362346,
0.032507278,
-0.0190537889,
0.0067298524,
-0.0083138477,
-0.0406458266,
0.042157013,
-0.0654065236,
-0.0347241424,
0.0142280674,
-0.0178048257,
-0.0381490961,
0.0821385905,
0.0340526626,
-0.00608999,
0.0793821961,
-0.0525931455,
0.0144852102,
0.0578290001,
-0.0010636291,
-0.0459201075,
0.0463297889,
0.0117092859,
0.0276187342,
-0.020824451,
-0.0298943259,
-0.0250622444,
-0.0055925972,
-0.0740160495,
-0.0063840845,
-0.0000976106,
-0.0462548435,
-0.0557854772,
0.0403009616,
0.0013712473,
0.0679048598,
0.0029994708,
0.0022709619,
-0.008837888,
0.0321752317,
0.0241409075,
0.0297737215,
0.0574944504,
0.0036023173,
-0.0235715769,
0.0196355004,
-0.0447235741,
0.0305538904,
-0.0074430201,
-0.0112221576,
0.0160461962,
-0.0634883344,
0.0132193035,
-0.0116679789,
0.0084461523,
-0.0503822565,
0.0002107721,
0.1269349158,
-0.0042026667,
-0.0476141348,
-0.0137675209,
-0.0039884872,
0.0115889665,
0.0095831053,
0.0288902,
-0.0925902054,
-0.0513828024,
0.0088688144,
0.0134857213,
0.0028315468,
-0.0718184933,
0.011254672,
-0.068391785,
0.026958162,
-0.0188536141,
-0.0298084505,
0.0054486906,
-0.0612259358,
0.0024312795,
-0.0741244853,
-0.034589231,
-0.0012557947,
-0.0459857881,
-0.011671776,
0.0114318002,
0.006222365,
-0.0526252836,
0.0232417174,
-0.0549548976,
0.0437968373,
0.0237553027,
0.0338416137,
-0.0213190727,
-0.0127140358,
-0.0260414369,
-0.0319466963,
-0.0281375423,
-0.0021945063,
0.0898855776,
-0.0407936238,
-0.017033346,
-0.0374504402,
-0.0082890745,
-0.0616441853,
-0.0239164941,
-0.0222001895,
0.0361515172,
0.0065329825,
-0.0150759937,
-0.0190383904,
-0.0107475705,
0.0086990995,
0.0593173988,
-0.0003788622,
0.009062279,
-0.0433754325,
-0.0084478427,
0.0105769718,
-0.0288602449,
-0.0406060219,
0.0124856066,
-0.0281344466,
-0.0669179112,
-0.051554665,
-0.0195415989,
0.0378089175,
0.0353220254,
-0.0039138286,
-0.0193323139,
0.0367156006,
0.0158259496,
-0.098107025,
0.0779704675,
0.007473595,
0.0122337248,
-0.0727573112,
-0.031429287,
0.0551311895,
0.0020277686,
-0.0509557948,
0.0255842395,
-0.0961489752,
-0.0400079526,
0.0139657287,
0.0433982238,
0.0229562428,
0.0208720285,
0.0038743545,
0.025634408,
0.012800945,
0.0611535236,
-0.0289822519,
-0.0098125497,
0.0068077841,
-0.0177515652,
-0.0359274708,
0.0027271886,
-0.0110325897,
0.0441034548,
-0.0058827316,
0.0276375711,
-0.0414129421,
-0.037917953,
-0.0184967779,
-0.0268969238,
0.0562547185,
0.0032184848,
-0.0295751523,
-0.0530273281,
0.0145149371,
0.0381130837,
0.0193603467,
-0.0223305654,
-0.0096020373,
0.0328934602,
-0.0166988391,
0.0000192022,
0.0404996797,
0.0108729359,
0.0405508541,
-0.0551063381,
0.0305399932,
0.0148890261,
0.0289026778,
0.0077142725,
-0.0758770928,
0.0255450755,
0.0440411754,
0.0465931594,
0.0679143891,
-0.0174336601,
0.0249789264,
-0.03018751,
-0.0071197776,
-0.0373502336,
0.0404118747,
-0.0536552928,
0.0265638083,
-0.0423566811,
0.0271627903,
0.031192787,
-0.0050272872,
0.0858008042,
-0.0282819476,
-0.0103197852,
0.0148723032,
0.0218948927,
-0.0123905474,
0.002473877,
0.0077121062,
0.0192333907,
-0.0290593095,
-0.0209271535,
0.0380531996,
0.0202924237,
0.0508069433,
0.0323257931,
-0.0054176552,
-0.0497081093,
-0.0244706757,
0.0081275301,
-0.031130556,
-0.0197535194,
0.0253621992,
-0.0291020069,
-0.0325351134,
0.0586700551,
-0.0248962473,
0.002343972,
-0.0155510483,
0.0034921803,
0.006300631,
0.0011950886,
-0.0340970643,
-0.0510702617,
0.0066697286,
-0.0153542049,
-0.0276099835,
-0.0322222151,
-6.440883992e-33,
-0.0614659004,
-0.0475494042,
0.0111978073,
0.0069816126,
-0.011130196,
0.0461240597,
-0.0012654803,
0.0105807483,
-0.0006529593,
-0.0190033037,
-0.006990084,
-0.0095421672,
0.0387160294,
0.0044232397,
-0.0207780711,
-0.018334683,
0.036758244,
0.0507364944,
-0.0401860587,
0.017923953,
0.0353272296,
0.0777183771,
0.1020643488,
-0.0945846289,
0.0208836142,
0.015789317,
0.0025362044,
-0.0376467519,
0.0540595502,
0.0662912503,
-0.0224189833,
-0.0429585204,
0.0153233362,
-0.0707669109,
0.0249062106,
0.022375714,
-0.1520902961,
0.0244260859,
-0.0538484454,
0.0317860059,
-0.0071281111,
-0.0059853718,
0.0441781618,
-0.0113819558,
0.0228354,
-0.014242297,
0.0369922221,
-0.0423696451,
-0.0087997094,
-0.0228540339,
-0.0671806931,
0.0542722791,
0.0013478282,
0.0072749741,
0.0584528558,
0.006666475,
0.0235154368,
0.00592044,
-0.079199411,
-0.0062894924,
0.0590078495,
0.0045860494,
0.0700733513,
0.0531979613,
0.0025395441,
0.0385874696,
0.0251492728,
-0.0174426623,
-0.0435970388,
-0.0243860018,
0.0143505009,
0.0441308543,
0.0112252748,
0.031367112,
0.0142032336,
-0.018304389,
-0.0334583968,
0.0493557863,
0.0274300855,
0.0309940297,
-0.0026992918,
-0.0237787087,
-0.0271509551,
0.0303154141,
-0.0137320422,
-0.026926659,
-0.0101166181,
-0.002080939,
-0.0062946579,
0.0302823018,
-0.0666092262,
0.0569629706,
0.0312825665,
-0.0239826478,
-0.0487649255,
0.0194895715,
0.0696451738,
0.0346608795,
-0.0256910343,
-0.0074621243,
-0.0201211106,
-0.0411295779,
0.0202168226,
-0.0140003813,
0.0459222235,
-0.0041132695,
0.0438416004,
0.0073043718,
-0.0679343268,
-0.0211140942,
-0.0180058144,
0.0335183479,
-0.0113836844,
0.0657333136,
0.003129038,
-0.0090227071,
-0.0166097675,
0.0051110066,
0.0477559268,
-0.0062355371,
-0.0172484387,
0.0313552693,
0.0421485715,
0.0282050669,
-0.0491363928,
-0.0159306992,
-0.0188499503,
-0.0032199961,
0.0050391764,
-0.0668208078,
0.0019252532,
0.0223981533,
2.624e-7,
0.060803175,
0.0514669865,
0.0160622131,
-0.003444975,
-0.0229047611,
0.0111995647,
0.0269700866,
0.024220258,
-0.0043835919,
-0.0168208107,
0.0002196055,
-0.0254073553,
0.0463149697,
0.0061730724,
-0.091451548,
-0.0455136597,
-0.0497485772,
-0.0085736001,
-0.0619764589,
0.0082752854,
-0.0011054764,
0.100630641,
0.0068087992,
-0.0221751351,
0.0011275192,
-0.010362125,
0.0451512448,
-0.0240628757,
0.0749039948,
0.0225409195,
0.0293945465,
0.0201864168,
-0.0195993967,
0.0196572505,
-0.0126020927,
0.0239455458,
0.0226547327,
0.0670267493,
-0.0162329264,
0.0259187818,
0.0032010237,
-0.0259955749,
0.0262863748,
-0.0832657367,
0.072299771,
-0.044549793,
-0.0031452582,
-0.0339695141,
-0.059958104,
0.0216292515,
-0.0045567974,
-0.0067376872,
-0.0019227068,
0.0355526879,
0.0321114585,
-0.0260272268,
-0.013504806,
-0.082452558,
0.0067085181,
-0.0070040603,
0.0055158711,
-0.0072836811,
-0.0240263958,
-0.0826744288,
-0.0012354712,
-0.0437660329,
-0.000355304,
2.604390157e-34,
-0.0211955775,
0.0251179039,
-0.0405310169,
0.0647644699,
0.0289963819,
-0.0105111245,
-0.0016333638,
-0.013770503,
-0.0485521071,
-0.0656633377,
0.0198530424
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.04302v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.04302v2 | Prompt Highlighter: Interactive Control for Multi-Modal LLMs | 2023-12-07T13:53:29 | 2024-03-20T23:32:08 | Yuechen Zhang, Shengju Qian, Bohao Peng, Shu Liu, Jiaya Jia | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | This study targets a critical aspect of multi-modal LLMs' (LLMs&VLMs)
inference: explicit controllable text generation. Multi-modal LLMs empower
multi-modality understanding with the capability of semantic generation yet
bring less explainability and heavier reliance on prompt contents due to their
autoregressive generative nature. While manipulating prompt formats could
improve outputs, designing specific and precise prompts per task can be
challenging and ineffective. To tackle this issue, we introduce a novel
inference method, Prompt Highlighter, which enables users to highlight specific
prompt spans to interactively control the focus during generation. Motivated by
the classifier-free diffusion guidance, we form regular and unconditional
context pairs based on highlighted tokens, demonstrating that the
autoregressive generation in models can be guided in a classifier-free way.
Notably, we find that, during inference, guiding the models with highlighted
tokens through the attention weights leads to more desired outputs. Our
approach is compatible with current LLMs and VLMs, achieving impressive
customized generation results without training. Experiments confirm its
effectiveness in focusing on input contexts and generating reliable content.
Without tuning on LLaVA-v1.5, our method secured 70.7 in the MMBench test and
1552.5 in MME-perception. The code is available at:
https://github.com/dvlab-research/Prompt-Highlighter/ | [
-0.0044287173,
0.0241747107,
0.0040563247,
0.0290435646,
-0.0300474428,
-0.0187413972,
0.03972321,
-0.006799099,
-0.0091772638,
-0.0388647392,
-0.0244986676,
-0.0226191524,
-0.0194477234,
0.0316980258,
0.0382911526,
-0.051675532,
0.0431706533,
-0.0359456278,
-0.0312164724,
-0.0010213223,
-0.0048743384,
0.0126334308,
-0.022948619,
0.0433046445,
-0.0464088731,
-0.0173229277,
-0.0552686788,
0.0331278816,
0.0159617905,
-0.0309353825,
-0.0051526898,
0.0556360856,
0.0347895101,
0.0140691865,
0.0000022616,
-0.0528705902,
-0.0203423817,
-0.026803134,
0.0112067517,
-0.0371897779,
0.0174681097,
0.0166605897,
0.0082804915,
-0.021140283,
-0.0180798694,
0.0548294708,
0.0513697974,
0.0438248813,
0.0651683509,
0.0416149683,
0.0023498519,
0.0090943985,
-0.0048221219,
-0.0257332381,
0.0778001025,
-0.023012504,
-0.0239612516,
-0.0193601921,
0.0257536769,
0.009283606,
-0.0112948436,
0.0403699838,
0.0464854427,
-0.0301593337,
0.0132196844,
0.0622020289,
0.069055818,
-0.0426157042,
-0.056270387,
0.083741419,
0.0195081607,
-0.0060047833,
0.0159750916,
-0.0348733142,
0.0169408694,
0.0115733594,
-0.0446967818,
0.0417017825,
-0.0304915067,
0.0148024522,
0.0037390843,
0.0014697094,
0.018131014,
0.0142692076,
0.0165560208,
0.0501723699,
0.0285709687,
-0.0036409094,
-0.0243462473,
0.006993046,
-0.0033340426,
-0.0782230496,
0.0125665478,
0.0616630241,
-0.0527807921,
0.0028167393,
-0.0596975349,
-0.0358130895,
0.0184399765,
0.0385507457,
0.0648726895,
0.0327460952,
-0.0525525361,
0.0029135635,
-0.0435776673,
0.0087428242,
-0.0446848162,
0.0305169858,
-0.0171408951,
0.0141848344,
0.0039306739,
-0.0248831622,
-0.0281723347,
-0.0103239715,
-0.0552141145,
-0.0078224773,
-0.0339486636,
0.0492263548,
0.0036176669,
0.0047314032,
-0.0119147738,
0.013358417,
-0.0511298925,
0.0061147776,
-0.0158734955,
-0.0032349189,
-0.0566743053,
-0.0008499138,
0.0664246082,
-0.0544825867,
-0.0299739484,
0.0634344593,
0.0056107496,
-0.0283179414,
-0.0359586179,
0.1102370098,
-0.0528140925,
-0.0051146648,
-0.0477390327,
-0.0869214684,
-0.0354138128,
-0.031987574,
0.0308380444,
-0.0538064726,
0.0028754252,
0.0212716796,
-0.0214926079,
-0.0190045945,
0.0205788426,
0.0049069813,
0.0261624958,
0.0364517905,
-0.0309965648,
-0.0167533755,
0.0238164105,
0.0157416631,
-0.0395910814,
0.0554816201,
0.0311400555,
0.060264226,
0.0083958479,
0.0207201615,
0.0326490141,
0.0168037023,
0.0212156847,
0.0009267485,
-0.0250428263,
-0.0421074033,
0.0005227284,
0.0300536789,
0.0654126033,
0.0280125905,
-0.028169753,
0.0106482226,
0.0624666922,
0.0174492225,
0.0376532786,
-0.0033356731,
0.0925849229,
-0.0122829983,
-0.023642756,
0.0324372686,
-0.0341573283,
0.0555370785,
-0.0132356063,
0.0350578837,
0.0349423625,
0.0147722336,
-0.017494617,
-0.0550787374,
0.0180553421,
-0.0095032314,
-0.0173002817,
-0.018165689,
0.0431262031,
0.0206258092,
-0.0366849899,
0.0616708249,
0.0315944441,
-0.0681679696,
0.0002129172,
-0.0778470859,
0.0801313668,
0.0539328456,
0.0032342132,
-0.0165283903,
-0.0140608335,
-0.0246381424,
0.0281361751,
0.0609783828,
0.0124727841,
0.0093822796,
0.0165371373,
-0.0429723412,
-0.0318945684,
-0.0498913378,
0.005835854,
0.023049226,
-0.0298555121,
-0.0156628806,
0.0374810584,
-0.0179671627,
0.0280123781,
0.0398014113,
-0.0001357756,
-0.0221785456,
0.0091913296,
0.0034978741,
0.0144584179,
-0.0064289798,
0.0197202042,
0.0278789178,
0.0116933053,
-0.0344427302,
0.0138264261,
0.0187886693,
-0.0608793162,
-0.0435080417,
0.0066261911,
-0.0308935717,
-0.0377469845,
-0.027506439,
-0.0174818132,
-0.045169007,
-0.0134260366,
-0.0285320897,
0.0228743888,
-0.060544502,
-0.014202904,
0.0506042168,
0.009633556,
-0.0334882215,
0.0870130509,
-0.0195590816,
-0.0028219859,
0.0750377029,
0.0656549335,
-0.0047201663,
-0.0465343967,
0.0338686109,
-0.0218308512,
-0.0081295287,
-0.0140226493,
0.0079187406,
0.0365468264,
-0.0585203804,
-0.0388029926,
-0.0668654069,
-0.0070078629,
-0.0453411005,
-0.0003517636,
0.0247550867,
0.0119968662,
-0.0202612281,
-0.0138771497,
-0.0366913565,
0.0197924301,
0.0194490552,
-0.0095502529,
0.0459321439,
-0.0190213732,
0.0167393051,
-0.0214637071,
0.0105444249,
-0.0083746193,
0.0312288832,
0.0367606431,
-0.0160544645,
-0.0593755953,
0.0214725677,
-0.0157509856,
-0.0163216013,
-0.0200990383,
0.0122553194,
0.0430797786,
-0.0201819539,
0.0743796751,
0.0523805991,
0.026886683,
0.0516152084,
0.0517146587,
-0.0290487856,
-0.0585381426,
0.0366952159,
-0.0086755799,
0.0180246513,
0.0056980066,
-0.015832115,
0.0260845367,
0.0832692087,
0.0280369278,
0.0118682636,
-0.0350829512,
0.0077828094,
0.0285141487,
-0.0506827421,
-0.0156723261,
0.029451197,
-0.0493567027,
0.0479878262,
-0.0202654619,
-0.0912607089,
0.0746599436,
-0.0551977195,
-0.012371189,
0.0066763959,
-0.0136283068,
-0.011858562,
0.0359440856,
-0.0203584414,
0.0143505484,
0.0253636315,
-0.0165925808,
-0.0426335856,
0.0203584507,
0.0094322516,
0.0121978261,
0.0655453727,
-0.0518662855,
-0.0081079397,
-0.0232446492,
-0.0106495703,
-0.0538855754,
-0.0587536097,
-0.0041713347,
0.0058377651,
-0.0050415681,
-0.0043934761,
0.0089583211,
-0.0034843395,
0.0493644997,
0.0218578186,
-0.0416866913,
-0.016022861,
-0.0544872731,
0.0517507307,
0.0541160218,
0.0284023713,
-0.0071484251,
-0.082227245,
-0.0095855398,
0.0416078195,
-0.0094802259,
0.0031577928,
-0.0158293042,
0.0343818925,
0.0124512203,
-0.0089650368,
-0.0089618033,
0.0584746785,
0.1138221845,
-0.0601481423,
-0.0107864682,
0.0865306929,
0.0110775102,
-0.0387454219,
0.0085533177,
-0.0103177782,
0.0809923485,
0.0050166752,
0.0056939628,
-0.0931625143,
-0.0476003364,
0.0124779502,
0.0289556403,
-0.0045116199,
-0.0079875821,
-0.0188896917,
-0.0683704317,
0.0444215052,
-0.0031314034,
-0.0209595524,
0.0268236753,
-0.0130881192,
0.0022491424,
0.0659339577,
0.0020629179,
0.0215796549,
-0.0059288386,
0.0084157186,
0.0214229245,
0.0325638615,
-0.0320420675,
-0.0307870824,
-0.0073247575,
0.0168385133,
0.0650369599,
0.0078624105,
-0.0005558806,
-0.0578622073,
0.0476917177,
0.0000526191,
0.0449844971,
-0.0346492417,
0.0116835404,
0.0041811308,
0.0041165845,
-0.0184230357,
0.0676368847,
-0.0050639301,
-0.0375963524,
0.0082233278,
0.0466821231,
-0.0412113033,
-0.0357330553,
-0.0385091901,
0.0126614776,
0.0470284186,
0.0541180409,
0.0685183033,
-0.043045681,
-0.0548460968,
-0.0544615611,
0.0016878158,
-0.0548860319,
-0.0052915607,
-0.0054374244,
-0.0113859428,
-0.0425080024,
-0.0513397194,
-0.0348078497,
0.0171230976,
0.0599541068,
-0.0219897684,
-0.014403454,
-0.0542416982,
-0.0273579881,
-0.0361393169,
0.0493161604,
-0.0000732686,
0.017994497,
-0.0505225323,
-0.0325763226,
0.0163079426,
-0.067580983,
-0.0092001092,
0.0484570563,
-0.0859599262,
-0.0732508898,
-0.0368605368,
0.0703999102,
0.0208336934,
0.0471390449,
-0.0135229388,
-0.039306771,
0.0487571806,
0.0480526574,
-0.0050529046,
0.0200172439,
0.0089476872,
0.0498799644,
-0.0130256545,
0.0179113075,
-0.0527784117,
-0.0018164431,
0.0333155207,
0.0432256646,
0.0007599359,
-0.0445134565,
0.0222049337,
-0.0133227957,
0.0349625498,
-0.0549962297,
0.0302026756,
-0.0409468748,
-0.0130637847,
-0.0114226155,
-0.0161045752,
-0.0597822405,
0.0418921448,
-0.0370533802,
-0.0363942124,
0.020133879,
-0.0159832835,
-0.0031472007,
0.0274216272,
-0.0592300594,
0.0340216719,
0.007480097,
0.0307647921,
0.0274551529,
-0.006285599,
-0.023283368,
0.0168504007,
-0.0268360451,
0.0242431462,
0.0033893548,
0.0861410499,
0.0177573171,
-0.0256389137,
-0.0179265067,
0.0372165218,
-0.0612286143,
0.0018518924,
-0.0153814266,
0.0346813761,
0.0497823246,
0.0229306351,
0.0297567844,
-0.0146439159,
-0.0051569315,
0.0014773271,
0.0782898292,
0.0363325663,
-0.0327982455,
0.0344143845,
0.0027060022,
-0.0099423993,
-0.0394208133,
0.0699564368,
-0.0262481347,
0.0177546423,
-0.0038335179,
0.0218796525,
-0.0569027029,
-0.0203477405,
0.0340296254,
0.0233018976,
0.0113577312,
-0.0005320237,
-0.0330872834,
-0.0361660123,
0.0430320203,
0.0240950566,
-0.021497488,
0.0098025072,
0.0576758161,
0.0614475422,
-0.0000573873,
-0.0587162338,
-0.0194330942,
0.0272948649,
0.0207384061,
-0.0170138441,
-0.0308673996,
-6.74639424e-33,
-0.0505848192,
-0.0620717704,
0.0159644932,
-0.0202803053,
-0.0312935635,
0.0061375266,
-0.0744371712,
0.0029821161,
0.0381980054,
0.0008560089,
0.0011892105,
-0.0301311295,
0.0122446427,
0.0308311358,
0.0050184075,
-0.0219870601,
0.0341792777,
0.0197836794,
-0.0414823815,
0.0381962433,
0.0496796072,
0.0247440562,
0.0195311718,
-0.0415393673,
0.0451311991,
-0.0071377126,
-0.0230363663,
0.0034557069,
-0.0515037701,
0.0582078025,
-0.0177869201,
0.0356262363,
0.0215207357,
-0.0035355028,
-0.0485809334,
0.0635100231,
-0.0335756652,
-0.0473709404,
-0.0045097908,
-0.0427503288,
-0.1085134596,
-0.0767488033,
0.0575712211,
-0.0018140264,
0.0058351327,
0.0162023585,
0.0440865085,
-0.0007914429,
-0.0031891731,
-0.043062102,
-0.0487156026,
0.0109514035,
-0.0121196993,
-0.0254574474,
-0.0103199463,
0.0557280965,
0.0163019616,
0.0079185534,
-0.0137218824,
0.0312997513,
0.0212181453,
0.0195697099,
0.0785172954,
0.068394579,
0.0025776916,
0.0377645046,
0.0048060897,
-0.0240056533,
-0.0505701043,
0.0100928256,
-0.0026045728,
0.0573444106,
-0.0006831139,
0.035243053,
-0.0160261262,
0.0278476216,
-0.0384973139,
0.0469197221,
0.0198973771,
0.0177116245,
0.0081101563,
0.0047866371,
0.0190067682,
0.0056829443,
-0.0286294837,
-0.036038354,
-0.0204447489,
-0.0285122227,
0.0400933698,
0.0181202609,
-0.0189645551,
-0.0318689495,
0.033698611,
0.0316665173,
-0.0028681811,
-0.0226325728,
-0.0160022713,
0.0299706217,
0.0020248492,
-0.0232526977,
-0.0114663169,
-0.0106307799,
0.0402531847,
-0.0205562543,
0.0212568063,
0.0337898135,
-0.0107967826,
0.0189496968,
-0.0469030067,
0.0032361117,
-0.0501277894,
0.0005470974,
0.00019553,
-0.0111986659,
0.0279061589,
-0.0463429429,
-0.0499142595,
0.0415833816,
-0.0177027471,
-0.002659176,
-0.0127242934,
-0.0258558188,
-0.0091985194,
0.0518469028,
-0.0322446935,
0.0124687543,
-0.0333397016,
0.0333595313,
0.0525869355,
-0.048271209,
-0.0084057888,
0.0386591442,
2.886e-7,
0.0307356566,
-0.0116422018,
0.0182840973,
0.0307286419,
0.010842138,
0.0270491987,
-0.0099405432,
0.0233892743,
-0.0189613272,
-0.0652535558,
-0.0153954457,
0.0280095506,
0.0498382822,
0.0248381756,
-0.0634658933,
0.0127424728,
-0.0372870788,
0.043184679,
-0.0423699617,
0.0058956919,
0.0987214297,
0.0244769007,
-0.0296323467,
-0.0062899957,
0.054283902,
0.00989825,
0.0551636666,
-0.0079043042,
0.0109872026,
0.0082391491,
0.0402045548,
-0.0575193465,
-0.0017561121,
-0.0020573412,
-0.0029215114,
-0.0343587846,
-0.0161134657,
0.0596112274,
0.0069792122,
-0.0598590523,
0.0024100312,
-0.0066006887,
0.0326956734,
-0.0342196636,
0.0598455928,
-0.0091409171,
0.0108559942,
-0.0451347306,
0.0057152482,
-0.0262097288,
-0.0038898734,
-0.0455952473,
-0.037154682,
0.0010584701,
-0.0178647619,
-0.0001971663,
-0.0371095911,
-0.0559343882,
-0.0450251438,
-0.0272640046,
-0.0694864914,
-0.0587123595,
-0.085414201,
0.0053296825,
0.0362098701,
-0.0830256492,
-0.0506888665,
2.904406391e-34,
-0.0084533552,
-0.0418975689,
0.0048742737,
0.0323817432,
0.0095245596,
-0.0041241031,
-0.0390575826,
0.0154055478,
0.038697999,
-0.0469180904,
-0.0576705784
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.04262v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.04262v2 | PsyChat: A Client-Centric Dialogue System for Mental Health Support | 2023-12-07T12:40:00 | 2024-03-20T01:59:39 | Huachuan Qiu, Anqi Li, Lizhi Ma, Zhenzhong Lan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.HC | Dialogue systems are increasingly integrated into mental health support to
help clients facilitate exploration, gain insight, take action, and ultimately
heal themselves. A practical and user-friendly dialogue system should be
client-centric, focusing on the client's behaviors. However, existing dialogue
systems publicly available for mental health support often concentrate solely
on the counselor's strategies rather than the behaviors expressed by clients.
This can lead to unreasonable or inappropriate counseling strategies and
corresponding responses generated by the dialogue system. To address this
issue, we propose PsyChat, a client-centric dialogue system that provides
psychological support through online chat. The client-centric dialogue system
comprises five modules: client behavior recognition, counselor strategy
selection, input packer, response generator, and response selection. Both
automatic and human evaluations demonstrate the effectiveness and practicality
of our proposed dialogue system for real-life mental health support.
Furthermore, the case study demonstrates that the dialogue system can predict
the client's behaviors, select appropriate counselor strategies, and generate
accurate and suitable responses. | [
0.1117755994,
0.0096249776,
-0.0398683548,
-0.0259872507,
-0.0291038193,
0.0299404059,
0.0327055752,
0.0151116326,
0.0897945017,
-0.0336989835,
-0.0052805417,
-0.0263459086,
-0.0164323896,
0.0476653092,
-0.0260818098,
-0.0919462293,
-0.0157269556,
0.0403033793,
0.064884387,
0.0384499878,
0.0504563898,
0.0162967276,
-0.0734641105,
0.0576934963,
0.0052614673,
-0.011085025,
0.0055414368,
0.0272645392,
-0.0067079505,
-0.0621012002,
0.0041453294,
0.0253543518,
-0.0285826921,
0.0043793321,
0.0000018657,
-0.0232402328,
-0.0029088443,
-0.0171382371,
-0.0258440897,
-0.0514559001,
0.0174842421,
-0.022417549,
0.0098529467,
0.0361110494,
0.0011047818,
-0.0184085425,
0.0434382893,
0.0632212088,
0.0952989161,
0.0484875068,
-0.0209798813,
0.0139869992,
-0.0111990301,
0.0235119518,
-0.0309212655,
-0.0281627048,
0.0187771134,
-0.0238246508,
0.0623007044,
-0.032354448,
0.0167664494,
0.0203126408,
-0.0661797896,
-0.0145025318,
-0.0229106918,
-0.0317112841,
-0.0437071957,
-0.0593178272,
-0.0024967543,
0.0740596205,
0.0524584875,
0.0398392789,
0.038946107,
-0.0242534317,
0.0090778982,
-0.0112953428,
-0.0323092751,
-0.0185265504,
-0.0366549715,
-0.0284018144,
0.0026269541,
0.0077706082,
-0.0336034,
-0.0185295679,
0.0516535006,
0.0099761654,
-0.0100457398,
-0.0417342968,
-0.0041725137,
-0.0139961941,
-0.0049463287,
-0.0750999749,
0.0368057862,
0.0571061559,
-0.0904124081,
-0.0048890216,
0.0135693299,
-0.0459003486,
0.0085070748,
0.0119791282,
0.0229652207,
0.0590367652,
-0.0022147985,
-0.0137755219,
0.0857401192,
0.012323725,
0.0651796609,
0.0065779095,
-0.0227875616,
0.0398157649,
-0.0753259882,
-0.0098391604,
-0.0505518578,
0.0201214366,
-0.0032914993,
-0.0229671393,
-0.0702004656,
0.0452957936,
-0.0062790099,
0.0234961007,
-0.0090977326,
-0.0119957486,
-0.002586361,
0.0337792635,
-0.0035060663,
0.0245853383,
-0.0344805382,
0.0012410079,
0.0264747087,
-0.0724548027,
0.041413486,
-0.0070580686,
0.0052070073,
0.0148899732,
0.0042017354,
0.0649631545,
-0.0152004976,
-0.001018345,
-0.0258038044,
-0.0407490768,
-0.0362809375,
0.0017176812,
0.0000050007,
0.0165787768,
0.0434208959,
0.0120085282,
-0.006081508,
0.0209009293,
0.0450089909,
0.018438464,
-0.0321212783,
0.0847529694,
-0.0474689417,
0.0203137081,
0.0479134098,
0.0429862067,
0.0032337047,
0.0194314588,
-0.0333219431,
0.0129705267,
0.0424141362,
-0.026472412,
0.0255091395,
-0.0337415077,
-0.0231394246,
-0.0657667965,
0.023992639,
0.0012008117,
-0.0277830847,
0.0523154661,
-0.0682324022,
0.0085067926,
-0.0304833334,
0.0236472636,
0.034893658,
0.0794487596,
0.0318268277,
0.0644110143,
0.0069625918,
0.0597193353,
0.0156281367,
-0.0283294376,
-0.0268701557,
0.0339768343,
-0.020515427,
-0.013817383,
0.0081932824,
-0.0281329583,
-0.0192049351,
-0.0473700874,
-0.0334979258,
-0.0195800047,
-0.0460687652,
0.0161807239,
-0.0416173078,
-0.0023675361,
0.0050619347,
0.0275843982,
0.0285910796,
-0.0143471211,
-0.0651151091,
-0.0371154845,
0.0387427397,
0.1348005533,
0.0468625836,
-0.0415045656,
-0.0478627868,
-0.011845544,
-0.0195708927,
0.0168863889,
0.0166057404,
0.002698381,
0.0025407276,
-0.0240912214,
-0.0128246509,
0.0685435981,
-0.0206592269,
-0.0160901025,
-0.0320466571,
0.0080142589,
-0.0321173221,
0.0730982795,
0.0223405082,
0.0423726328,
0.0378868692,
-0.022511486,
-0.0052964631,
-0.0002512264,
0.0669477284,
0.0336218141,
0.0104262978,
0.0127044711,
0.0170164425,
-0.011516952,
-0.0417436808,
0.0359008685,
-0.0481871068,
-0.0227569826,
0.0290352535,
0.0397309065,
0.006461075,
-0.0095446203,
-0.0171065573,
-0.0247380231,
0.057622578,
-0.0798018947,
0.0264766589,
-0.0186244044,
-0.0080281682,
0.0186856538,
0.0058418545,
-0.0177681185,
0.0018906577,
-0.0024925522,
0.0419320092,
0.0065283673,
-0.0250145085,
-0.0349606611,
-0.0399240255,
0.0053331903,
-0.0016953839,
-0.0533619784,
-0.0146213816,
-0.0446769185,
0.0306140054,
-0.0389661603,
-0.0041089514,
-0.1229070276,
0.0301721599,
-0.0064948495,
-0.0205544252,
0.0158693641,
-0.0014843028,
-0.0275588632,
-0.0508154593,
-0.0335638374,
0.0511934087,
0.0586732663,
0.0112990197,
0.0168147665,
0.0442359671,
-0.0158025175,
-0.0449646823,
0.0085136024,
-0.0117375972,
0.0061289696,
-0.0224699453,
-0.02063624,
-0.04448184,
-0.0264372621,
-0.0509720668,
0.0084430724,
-0.0148873348,
-0.0783445537,
0.0161307156,
-0.0023730556,
0.0273336675,
0.0074865553,
0.0685262904,
0.0217880644,
-0.0224946886,
-0.0014902195,
-0.0197945107,
0.0100317206,
0.0091261547,
-0.0447527021,
-0.0097634345,
-0.0439441428,
0.0118149444,
0.0206507128,
0.0334973224,
0.0334782973,
-0.032640148,
-0.0069326297,
0.0361170471,
0.0374656729,
-0.0264047869,
-0.0136835352,
0.0061257002,
-0.0145845367,
0.0021783123,
-0.018202303,
0.0532763191,
0.0129001653,
-0.0478869118,
-0.048721958,
-0.0659021363,
-0.0340579003,
0.023105653,
-0.0056922762,
0.0271836817,
0.0428032503,
-0.0393334925,
0.050074026,
-0.0672010258,
0.0093697459,
-0.0358769335,
-0.0232773982,
-0.053402625,
0.0086555071,
0.0156571306,
-0.0007185974,
-0.0527030639,
-0.0505061671,
-0.0502419434,
-0.0321629271,
0.011901834,
0.0130441161,
-0.0091939233,
-0.0173387174,
0.0316850096,
0.0347018726,
0.0134787858,
-0.0363830663,
0.0061559607,
0.0036337972,
0.0101844603,
0.0065832562,
-0.0032722,
0.018223403,
0.0456947312,
0.0683258772,
-0.0315845981,
0.0082353018,
0.0378603227,
-0.004599784,
-0.0102142608,
0.0087377625,
-0.0017035856,
0.010346665,
0.0420513563,
-0.0019477955,
-0.0328362025,
0.0881045759,
0.0313649587,
-0.0476186983,
-0.0090494165,
-0.0439165644,
-0.0274879057,
0.0050976318,
0.0015311929,
-0.023472758,
-0.0193269886,
-0.0476370454,
0.0750011206,
-0.0554730222,
-0.023956107,
0.0062898574,
-0.0104943858,
0.0246174056,
-0.010483834,
0.0060568871,
0.0010321576,
0.0261949394,
0.0261801612,
0.0067521934,
-0.0255922489,
0.0031700737,
-0.0078648487,
-0.0042110803,
0.0036807999,
-0.0846328884,
0.0123877721,
0.0400936566,
0.010228687,
0.0829677954,
0.0295626037,
0.0463157669,
0.0303500984,
-0.0561998971,
-0.0195596125,
0.0251710024,
0.0255969614,
0.0096293427,
0.0434676148,
0.0250075515,
0.0263027381,
-0.0652887225,
0.0611573793,
-0.0399281681,
0.0033539115,
0.0400697179,
0.0270036925,
-0.0356539041,
0.0019709519,
-0.0208635014,
0.0882217586,
0.0608548373,
0.00577525,
0.0255016442,
-0.0549354292,
-0.0476117656,
0.0008333653,
0.004310003,
0.0413059816,
-0.0052044704,
-0.0299293101,
-0.023530636,
-0.0022731659,
-0.0880278423,
-0.0194917396,
0.012559847,
0.0017193974,
-0.0490769632,
-0.0347696692,
-0.0160872675,
0.0685839653,
-0.0172813572,
0.0073548714,
0.0226208679,
0.0246709753,
-0.03882825,
0.0094877966,
0.0349178016,
-0.04257413,
0.0067807604,
0.0397513397,
0.0050398703,
-0.0026336377,
0.0445819311,
0.0269671604,
0.0144296587,
-0.0284494292,
0.0088787349,
-0.0105809551,
-0.0381966904,
0.0439418182,
-0.027116064,
-0.038026657,
-0.0046557733,
0.0917242318,
0.0018360346,
0.0167762879,
0.0124435406,
0.0580571927,
-0.010603115,
-0.0107556442,
-0.0442279764,
-0.0417816639,
-0.0094983671,
0.029480366,
0.0056353086,
0.0274831969,
-0.0519273952,
0.0509141833,
-0.0315259546,
-0.0091682421,
-0.0197954979,
-0.0284918472,
-0.002784864,
-0.0103218807,
-0.0329961702,
-0.0040487256,
-0.0540866591,
-0.0877668485,
-0.0063859681,
-0.0161810331,
-0.0067572719,
0.0319876112,
0.0040327548,
-0.0345131569,
-0.0071307677,
0.0013928845,
0.0262111258,
0.0177874416,
0.0542716421,
-0.0351239853,
0.1268970221,
-0.0228671264,
-0.020818077,
0.0553462319,
0.0417938828,
-0.0579676554,
-0.1137291044,
-0.0075301174,
0.0321202911,
0.0180246346,
0.0746603683,
-0.0059910412,
-0.0222657863,
0.0110046668,
0.0086441422,
0.0570764467,
-0.014589617,
-0.0431311578,
-0.0122389486,
0.0055709616,
-0.0251153596,
-0.0356858484,
-0.0126412036,
-0.0504005775,
-0.0164778605,
0.0062727099,
-0.0379136354,
-0.0501802899,
0.0446254537,
-0.023346493,
0.084473595,
-0.0059231166,
-0.0084345108,
-0.0324278213,
-0.0215891115,
0.0339539833,
-0.0187876262,
-0.0105308834,
-0.0207249783,
0.0350149199,
0.0104084341,
0.0137553411,
-0.0244403668,
-0.0502204075,
0.0725426748,
-0.0321235657,
0.0122204684,
-0.0519748256,
-4.842949665e-33,
-0.0126179634,
-0.0360216238,
-0.0101708155,
0.027288923,
-0.0294042118,
-0.0424592271,
-0.0069753067,
0.04763861,
0.0081352489,
0.0038239963,
0.0265646484,
0.0691990256,
-0.0125955986,
0.0215489995,
0.0247368962,
0.0024308953,
0.0134766325,
-0.0212671645,
-0.0051455195,
0.0188384186,
0.0153875491,
0.0439250953,
0.0296529159,
-0.1281846017,
-0.0035387368,
-0.0019522248,
-0.0043745637,
0.0396466665,
0.0235726703,
0.010466787,
-0.010714517,
0.0428632088,
0.0345724262,
0.0228127539,
0.0241887327,
0.032285586,
-0.0283920281,
-0.0434777699,
-0.0098100752,
-0.0178014785,
-0.0571862124,
0.0413522199,
0.0109178359,
-0.0393523984,
0.0276054665,
-0.016210068,
0.0139956959,
-0.0182787701,
0.0165092461,
0.0286650266,
0.0075269383,
-0.0108939167,
-0.021448534,
-0.0229525864,
-0.0647991449,
0.0755133778,
-0.0329149514,
-0.0268806443,
-0.0195537265,
0.0046739029,
-0.0181143675,
-0.0315661766,
-0.0254642293,
-0.0313131735,
-0.0311773457,
0.0085381819,
-0.0136784669,
-0.0106254853,
-0.0455733314,
-0.0132621052,
-0.0602900684,
0.0352839939,
0.0663754568,
0.0216282029,
-0.0215947703,
-0.0319801979,
-0.0059174523,
0.0029256849,
0.0765541419,
-0.0080174692,
0.0062967734,
0.0372353606,
-0.0365150645,
0.0052650687,
0.0013387635,
-0.0247910246,
-0.0196013786,
-0.0465099066,
0.0222131815,
0.0154270697,
-0.0220954493,
-0.0269329809,
-0.0465505198,
-0.0157232247,
0.0434990861,
-0.0079921698,
0.0117117222,
0.0250943396,
-0.0078634229,
-0.0425738432,
-0.0278494842,
0.0059811012,
0.0248167906,
-0.0174380112,
0.034042906,
-0.0121784583,
0.0117729483,
-0.0198749285,
-0.0167011395,
-0.0288565531,
0.0341176912,
0.1026453599,
-0.0230669696,
0.0176576246,
-0.0414576456,
0.002594864,
-0.0476699397,
0.0538105555,
-0.008129918,
-0.0056300419,
-0.086369954,
-0.0257488564,
-0.0003821735,
-0.0231013708,
-0.03960279,
-0.0203450657,
-0.0348304696,
0.0060324706,
0.0018580176,
0.0059108757,
0.0141277406,
-0.0139138605,
2.583e-7,
-0.009910889,
0.0303655509,
0.020852549,
0.0135665955,
0.0290296096,
0.0218379945,
0.0451356731,
0.0572023131,
0.0586417876,
-0.0459022112,
0.0170039497,
0.0003897969,
0.0384014323,
0.0420044288,
0.0086996602,
-0.0712513551,
-0.0207052939,
-0.0540184304,
-0.0506271049,
0.0328201279,
0.1087371111,
0.0232475381,
0.0140168369,
-0.0075182184,
0.027240688,
0.017141832,
0.014544053,
-0.0216671973,
0.0061733234,
0.0335922949,
0.0395186804,
-0.0158305578,
0.0286476854,
0.0195206888,
-0.0088013653,
-0.0116499634,
-0.0107167214,
0.049372714,
-0.0632587075,
-0.0633433834,
-0.000651161,
0.0295344945,
0.0352613926,
-0.0170339178,
-0.0125451842,
-0.0825746804,
-0.0159967821,
-0.0344236046,
-0.0187988225,
-0.0720766261,
0.0152288657,
-0.0036210394,
-0.0243493672,
0.0728717595,
0.0011801271,
-0.0046281475,
0.0365800932,
-0.0626826882,
-0.0005317578,
0.0280144252,
-0.0591649674,
0.005558901,
-0.003026732,
-0.0166847147,
-0.0017328637,
-0.0410789661,
0.0049324068,
1.736712777e-34,
-0.0215436555,
0.0515387133,
0.0404530652,
0.0188597757,
0.0376423895,
0.0580289476,
0.0091468375,
0.0540172048,
0.038367942,
-0.0330758393,
-0.0028775674
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.07553v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.07553v2 | Hijacking Context in Large Multi-modal Models | 2023-12-07T11:23:29 | 2024-05-13T10:42:05 | Joonhyun Jeong | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Recently, Large Multi-modal Models (LMMs) have demonstrated their ability to
understand the visual contents of images given the instructions regarding the
images. Built upon the Large Language Models (LLMs), LMMs also inherit their
abilities and characteristics such as in-context learning where a coherent
sequence of images and texts are given as the input prompt. However, we
identify a new limitation of off-the-shelf LMMs where a small fraction of
incoherent images or text descriptions mislead LMMs to only generate biased
output about the hijacked context, not the originally intended context. To
address this, we propose a pre-filtering method that removes irrelevant
contexts via GPT-4V, based on its robustness towards distribution shift within
the contexts. We further investigate whether replacing the hijacked visual and
textual contexts with the correlated ones via GPT-4V and text-to-image models
can help yield coherent responses. | [
0.0023417443,
0.0745696947,
-0.0112911863,
0.0664973855,
-0.0287373438,
0.0202444606,
0.0219075456,
0.0100341197,
-0.015538278,
-0.0752448067,
-0.0647927374,
-0.0428661369,
-0.0025341045,
0.0303044878,
0.018982783,
-0.0562062673,
0.030459201,
-0.0371049084,
-0.0312688202,
-0.0179923996,
0.0063909492,
0.0076772692,
0.0230067894,
0.0221800208,
-0.02632658,
-0.0244129989,
-0.0110230045,
0.0409114473,
0.0180120803,
-0.0182174128,
-0.0062069497,
0.0285218991,
0.0382163338,
0.0272361953,
0.0000021316,
0.0017377487,
0.0043314425,
-0.0207885988,
0.0230617616,
0.0184453819,
0.0317931399,
-0.0226021558,
0.005625891,
-0.019869132,
-0.0232397392,
0.0144696953,
0.0603233129,
0.0809082165,
0.0714582652,
0.0617189258,
-0.0281309746,
-0.0455306321,
-0.0017423915,
-0.0292440038,
0.041903276,
-0.0593304224,
0.0335260704,
0.0135215167,
0.0077497377,
0.0436121859,
-0.048670318,
0.0418619141,
0.0160268433,
0.0253029279,
-0.0366538763,
0.0430839956,
0.0190830417,
-0.0301874336,
-0.0103661045,
0.0862913057,
-0.0473682955,
0.0077261031,
-0.0107102189,
-0.0355336107,
0.0133785093,
0.0336044282,
-0.0337012187,
0.0300059244,
-0.0188435148,
0.0511183999,
-0.046789486,
-0.0157180279,
0.0415210128,
0.0349842981,
-0.0535287298,
0.0052268342,
0.0250467975,
-0.0137697794,
-0.0094519099,
0.0130109228,
-0.0716511831,
-0.0370344073,
0.0200347789,
0.0409550406,
-0.0296242535,
0.0121756308,
-0.0613700859,
-0.0142558198,
-0.0041094632,
-0.0256249625,
0.0114879338,
0.024882799,
-0.0707185939,
0.0660440847,
-0.0105711101,
0.0141484179,
-0.0632677674,
0.0307993107,
-0.0374459103,
-0.0073069795,
-0.0294392183,
-0.0182552524,
-0.0031959133,
0.0092621176,
-0.0878033116,
-0.0405495614,
-0.0113705173,
0.0400962308,
-0.0386255011,
-0.0028757732,
-0.0236775726,
0.022216022,
-0.0471025296,
-0.0461576842,
-0.0147948889,
0.0456404872,
0.0274321754,
0.0470688045,
-0.0311344862,
-0.0391797684,
-0.004376858,
0.0342056528,
-0.0060013453,
-0.0522902906,
-0.0090942057,
0.0789799988,
-0.0437850505,
-0.0469158739,
-0.0430867337,
-0.0342230126,
-0.0336427689,
-0.0569015779,
0.0302378014,
-0.0221972782,
-0.009243493,
-0.0011533384,
0.034954872,
-0.0241473727,
0.0155758336,
0.0045770705,
-0.0643106624,
0.112481609,
0.0246973261,
-0.0182031281,
0.0313502438,
0.0382829159,
-0.0214642771,
0.0675967634,
-0.0155392746,
0.0429107845,
0.0002531434,
-0.0158036258,
0.0342363156,
0.0468221121,
-0.0007216834,
0.0106397197,
-0.0268216915,
-0.0043444987,
0.0203399677,
0.004953932,
0.0373066328,
0.046754308,
-0.0310830306,
0.003775069,
0.1157193705,
0.0146441115,
0.0049994723,
0.0041910755,
0.0331640393,
-0.011447384,
-0.0309209153,
0.0507146567,
-0.1141768768,
0.0300779399,
-0.0430357456,
-0.0230405647,
0.0104057882,
0.0418963842,
-0.0312062912,
-0.0106129702,
0.0438250415,
-0.0277144983,
0.0080749588,
0.0314631574,
0.0454445481,
-0.0352222957,
-0.0523773842,
-0.0045851679,
0.0336645171,
0.0074241729,
0.0006964239,
-0.0489129648,
0.0436046831,
0.0466779321,
0.0030694581,
-0.0330824964,
0.0045143128,
-0.0094930707,
0.0332001671,
0.0275115687,
-0.0595250987,
0.0402964652,
0.0528700352,
-0.0363018475,
-0.0550034754,
-0.0320458189,
0.0054665483,
0.0176707171,
-0.0199561305,
0.002672899,
0.0159183741,
0.0213553086,
0.0530630946,
0.0431558602,
0.0471734889,
-0.0173369907,
-0.0125300065,
0.0253522936,
0.0444930606,
-0.0169803351,
-0.0086916843,
-0.0044946917,
0.0394537747,
-0.0081772804,
0.0129656261,
-0.0144576449,
-0.0880858675,
-0.0318903401,
0.0215965826,
-0.0380934887,
-0.0191544797,
0.0255795848,
-0.0408439673,
-0.0189886075,
0.005633146,
0.0090576774,
0.0282293577,
-0.0375776887,
0.0005991922,
0.0289276764,
0.0404772796,
-0.0123765292,
0.060922958,
0.0050810026,
-0.0166776776,
0.0388566554,
0.0333818495,
-0.0167828277,
-0.0178710762,
-0.0185524318,
0.0179472063,
0.0131819993,
0.0027428137,
-0.0014570928,
0.0157225858,
-0.0285402015,
-0.0200474747,
-0.0933514163,
-0.0300432611,
-0.028541835,
-0.0386978574,
0.0209663268,
-0.0015281177,
-0.0031714248,
-0.0356820226,
-0.0131920949,
0.0370854586,
0.0231621861,
0.0179978479,
0.0035478689,
0.0291815344,
0.0121240234,
-0.0138091231,
0.0030692765,
0.0133889541,
0.052101355,
-0.00141524,
-0.032097958,
-0.068009004,
0.0217513517,
0.0149988187,
0.0379776657,
-0.0213065017,
-0.00551457,
-0.0067118783,
-0.0299381204,
0.0491120555,
0.0795854628,
0.0239164643,
0.0398000628,
0.0614972413,
-0.0218327772,
-0.0223505981,
-0.0025383681,
-0.0112860883,
-0.0349361487,
-0.0363280922,
-0.0036170916,
-0.0047439155,
0.0352753885,
0.011123905,
0.0176955815,
-0.0474402197,
0.0158067122,
0.0103655253,
-0.0395295471,
-0.068192549,
-0.0017867924,
-0.0311942287,
0.0274186414,
-0.034690775,
-0.0443126298,
0.044892367,
-0.0187035482,
-0.0020770382,
0.0081733866,
0.00230057,
0.0178076159,
0.0191957355,
0.0296270512,
0.0364564881,
0.0224848669,
-0.0009101014,
-0.0664911196,
-0.0254548136,
0.0035720775,
0.0023940974,
0.0724058971,
-0.0786163136,
0.010772855,
-0.0209330823,
-0.0310591683,
-0.0161658935,
-0.0883483812,
0.010158279,
-0.0147774955,
-0.0305971764,
0.0238730516,
-0.0433760211,
0.0274892151,
0.0358699523,
0.0058011999,
-0.0109833525,
-0.0189033747,
-0.0316697657,
0.080299966,
0.053975001,
-0.0047585508,
-0.02663517,
-0.0460701585,
0.0009513038,
0.0402491651,
-0.0199523568,
-0.023526812,
-0.0350441672,
0.0456191637,
0.0063891253,
0.0600011125,
-0.0253059138,
0.0407976471,
0.0675883442,
-0.0364071876,
-0.0010203267,
0.0714916587,
-0.0113293491,
-0.0635079741,
-0.0332280993,
0.0453467704,
-0.0048324172,
0.0010964763,
-0.0161624979,
-0.0732137263,
-0.0549901649,
-0.016309157,
-0.0243123323,
0.0255567282,
0.0214492586,
-0.0058644023,
-0.063713856,
0.0376814269,
0.0339600481,
-0.0292875078,
-0.0358521678,
0.0141751999,
0.0222849771,
-0.0063613676,
0.0149596352,
-0.0188377164,
-0.0198881682,
-0.0252188649,
-0.0061539854,
0.0679092854,
-0.059234295,
0.0108983945,
-0.0171143748,
0.0121930866,
0.054206606,
0.0180857684,
-0.0320991948,
-0.0319226645,
0.0410534963,
-0.0226620473,
0.0058270381,
0.0032200655,
0.0228895079,
-0.0365112387,
-0.0233288836,
-0.00048351,
0.0488300659,
-0.0091218231,
-0.0543108732,
-0.0194309652,
0.0570708327,
-0.0230438989,
-0.016759282,
-0.0360272378,
-0.0082106739,
0.0466223806,
0.0565279946,
-0.0072445297,
-0.054140456,
-0.026885435,
-0.0262525231,
0.0010538553,
0.0253024269,
0.0139963515,
0.0191391576,
-0.0124485968,
-0.0045145587,
-0.0560055003,
-0.0163365137,
0.0128799323,
0.0170622393,
0.008835908,
0.0234637447,
0.0031034132,
0.0206821319,
-0.0086494191,
0.0552179404,
-0.0345121026,
0.0370577462,
-0.0644891784,
0.0231560394,
0.0274989363,
-0.0616850033,
-0.0202856977,
0.0471252203,
-0.0728808343,
-0.0568744428,
-0.0078963535,
0.038632039,
0.018734226,
0.0568724908,
0.0243368465,
-0.0241595376,
0.0392038859,
0.0231336281,
-0.0290751904,
0.024981074,
0.0255770143,
0.0203427728,
-0.0272247642,
0.0401335843,
-0.0433515497,
0.0494695492,
0.0377894156,
-0.0270041786,
-0.0428118594,
-0.0433684997,
0.0346842445,
-0.0302472338,
0.0707749277,
-0.0365173146,
0.0316918865,
-0.0094830813,
-0.0008664316,
-0.0032666849,
-0.0172238313,
-0.0347471498,
-0.0038221688,
0.0375108607,
-0.0085259378,
0.0005042476,
0.0001490475,
0.0171485934,
0.0498805121,
-0.0403168574,
-0.0110313306,
0.0301108621,
-0.0272608828,
0.0253229253,
0.0176272783,
0.0178711936,
0.0278591719,
0.0055941339,
0.0148053579,
-0.0208932497,
0.1155235618,
0.0253767651,
-0.0259372108,
-0.052691251,
0.0462597646,
-0.0535736792,
-0.0034371011,
-0.0475715511,
0.0297179259,
0.0543716922,
-0.0131891053,
0.0215053689,
-0.0199973732,
-0.0329506993,
-0.042925436,
0.0473696962,
0.0506501757,
0.0052895709,
0.0647146627,
0.0138727743,
0.0006478621,
0.0107979439,
0.0709502026,
-0.003013808,
0.0506510623,
0.036115136,
-0.0120583493,
-0.0380091481,
-0.0184705593,
0.0370491929,
0.0293344837,
-0.032112997,
0.0355509855,
-0.0071546151,
-0.062314067,
-0.0216885284,
-0.0098023051,
-0.025081668,
-0.0223443657,
0.0238713305,
0.0570777878,
0.0091634598,
-0.0176749844,
-0.0021471791,
0.0077193547,
0.0148034217,
0.0151972137,
-0.0184424371,
-6.805336465e-33,
-0.0444679484,
-0.0276340637,
0.0038624166,
-0.0138376513,
0.0117547708,
-0.007921231,
-0.0122020841,
0.0046374658,
-0.0195984058,
0.0012990676,
0.0073982556,
0.0027211579,
0.011554772,
0.0373290256,
-0.0175115503,
0.001773679,
0.0447520502,
-0.0190174375,
-0.008926753,
0.0214813594,
0.0408824533,
0.017169768,
0.034880612,
-0.0675547346,
-0.0118137151,
0.0001817617,
-0.0596361458,
-0.0084482813,
-0.0216532536,
0.0507105328,
-0.0591333397,
0.0245982055,
0.0389920734,
0.0125215724,
-0.023992613,
0.0641223416,
-0.0467813313,
0.0133391246,
0.0163464881,
-0.006456533,
-0.0523330607,
-0.0315383263,
0.0388649441,
-0.018686505,
0.0052267672,
-0.0277261045,
0.0360836238,
-0.0411461592,
-0.0034299998,
0.0222209357,
-0.0545391105,
0.0036405628,
-0.0094241342,
-0.0284322631,
0.0257583298,
0.0321689695,
0.0203880817,
0.0576666966,
-0.0228442177,
0.0148164863,
0.0019548631,
-0.0080349557,
0.0494688638,
0.0505975932,
0.007225839,
0.0401459709,
-0.003284238,
-0.0580472127,
-0.0392101705,
-0.0505164452,
0.0011963646,
0.0575582422,
0.0201743003,
0.0805976689,
0.0505394898,
-0.0005913021,
-0.0649811253,
0.0165268593,
-0.057320483,
0.0294192974,
0.0343258902,
0.0230446309,
0.0272427835,
0.0032699085,
-0.0226449464,
-0.0168670099,
-0.0422317646,
-0.012794259,
0.0552129932,
0.0380670279,
0.0073786573,
0.0401818305,
0.0829284862,
-0.0433073156,
-0.0254903529,
0.0117054945,
-0.0302744191,
0.011587481,
0.0043754261,
0.0233217888,
-0.0244205426,
-0.0467432328,
0.0842735395,
-0.0264300797,
-0.0127488784,
-0.0118712299,
0.0254182722,
0.0171298012,
-0.0575621128,
-0.0232730042,
-0.0512949862,
0.0057578124,
0.0091426475,
0.0308642387,
0.0389543958,
-0.0068508256,
-0.026029367,
0.0155994631,
-0.0181037504,
-0.0264918134,
-0.0202110726,
-0.0542734042,
-0.0253870543,
0.0391247496,
-0.0351123698,
-0.0006157486,
-0.0320143215,
-0.0321524739,
0.0737838224,
-0.0550893806,
-0.015785655,
0.0356853642,
2.804e-7,
0.0408402309,
0.0144084329,
-0.0244694594,
-0.0326274857,
0.0318595469,
0.0584100634,
-0.0581557527,
0.0345788449,
-0.0032260849,
-0.0475555621,
0.011936876,
0.0302131139,
0.0193582382,
0.0114362594,
-0.0077778208,
0.0212383289,
-0.0224759318,
-0.0183099695,
-0.068393074,
-0.0101467809,
0.0908125415,
0.1119133234,
-0.023215007,
-0.0374521948,
0.0551516302,
-0.0459107272,
0.1164997071,
-0.0480084866,
0.0042976155,
-0.0349207409,
-0.0308587253,
-0.0013576294,
-0.0201443844,
0.0255364534,
0.0230644252,
-0.0283260494,
0.0261226334,
0.0688786432,
-0.0052318466,
-0.0384607688,
-0.0468429886,
0.0424160548,
-0.0121425809,
-0.0689249337,
0.0939966366,
-0.0618511587,
-0.0169181228,
-0.0231324937,
-0.0539776683,
-0.050213296,
0.0191438552,
-0.0035182307,
-0.031809669,
-0.0000491916,
0.0052310382,
0.0105681922,
-0.0322457626,
-0.0928787366,
-0.0058441753,
0.0012492713,
-0.0705477521,
-0.0196499843,
-0.0603911914,
-0.0115404753,
0.0780520514,
-0.0462783575,
-0.0024206613,
2.307817753e-34,
-0.0031618853,
-0.0474809483,
0.0234638788,
-0.0063856505,
-0.0036673862,
0.0212884527,
-0.0487540103,
0.0149405738,
-0.0155469961,
-0.0805040374,
0.0091152517
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.04219v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.04219v1 | Swap distance minimization in SOV languages. Cognitive and mathematical foundations | 2023-12-07T11:10:28 | 2023-12-07T11:10:28 | Ramon Ferrer-i-Cancho, Savithry Namboodiripad | cs.CL | cs.CL, physics.soc-ph | Distance minimization is a general principle of language. A special case of
this principle in the domain of word order is swap distance minimization. This
principle predicts that variations from a canonical order that are reached by
fewer swaps of adjacent constituents are lest costly and thus more likely. Here
we investigate the principle in the context of the triple formed by subject
(S), object (O) and verb (V). We introduce the concept of word order rotation
as a cognitive underpinning of that prediction. When the canonical order of a
language is SOV, the principle predicts SOV < SVO, OSV < VSO, OVS < VOS, in
order of increasing cognitive cost. We test the prediction in three flexible
order SOV languages: Korean (Koreanic), Malayalam (Dravidian), and Sinhalese
(Indo-European). Evidence of swap distance minimization is found in all three
languages, but it is weaker in Sinhalese. Swap distance minimization is
stronger than a preference for the canonical order in Korean and especially
Malayalam. | [
0.0611977354,
-0.0341628119,
-0.0236460268,
0.0217150263,
-0.0353279337,
0.0053193527,
-0.0488085896,
-0.0007897606,
-0.0372826755,
-0.029258322,
-0.0306879971,
-0.0321819596,
0.0750573501,
-0.0462122634,
0.0163129643,
-0.061127048,
0.0544130243,
-0.0143985841,
0.0264918748,
0.0176382456,
-0.0084219286,
-0.015774997,
-0.0518942103,
-0.0176303666,
0.0051533058,
-0.0017116733,
-0.0133395065,
0.0038632918,
0.0558746345,
-0.0485591888,
-0.0520316996,
0.0327337384,
-0.008545666,
0.0277392194,
0.0000018875,
-0.0524974428,
0.0065365937,
-0.0056155724,
-0.0197575744,
-0.0001340099,
0.0261251964,
-0.0053915679,
0.0016277591,
-0.0093124118,
-0.0359099619,
0.0074195764,
0.0634710193,
-0.0129227154,
-0.0123627381,
0.072180137,
-0.0128016928,
-0.0315730497,
-0.0229060445,
0.004962943,
-0.0094878888,
0.0038912296,
-0.0060737128,
-0.0285174102,
-0.0278329682,
0.0128363464,
-0.0671982467,
-0.0040857131,
-0.0368137918,
0.0323392525,
-0.0229408983,
-0.0096566966,
-0.0423343852,
-0.0217134822,
0.030626528,
0.0459818467,
0.006565833,
-0.0277677234,
-0.0233644489,
0.0035467455,
0.0106545174,
0.0037740278,
-0.026592575,
0.0193815194,
0.0350257158,
0.0054562609,
0.0592048801,
0.006277794,
-0.0524511114,
-0.0272870678,
-0.0351870731,
0.0930420011,
0.014735084,
-0.0706855133,
-0.0173624326,
-0.0475392081,
-0.0388448238,
-0.0108282799,
-0.0026672066,
-0.0072324546,
-0.0154271973,
0.0275759213,
0.0299393367,
-0.0414644144,
-0.0234213714,
-0.0791831687,
0.0520030446,
0.0166797265,
-0.001638315,
-0.0466860756,
-0.0034682045,
0.0672784969,
-0.0035711075,
0.0297005828,
-0.0431428067,
0.0655563623,
0.034975756,
-0.0537630618,
0.0069097774,
0.0056462609,
-0.0446533933,
-0.0039613247,
-0.0605966896,
0.0240199715,
0.0193149857,
-0.0261405837,
-0.0069295312,
-0.0288248379,
-0.0102337757,
0.0327765718,
-0.020520702,
0.0184511449,
-0.0165574104,
0.0303686745,
-0.0401489101,
-0.0335098952,
0.031123668,
0.0327167958,
-0.0227469355,
0.0040919692,
-0.0717465729,
0.0413882099,
-0.0051924931,
-0.0096070692,
0.0406839214,
0.0467207544,
-0.0389499627,
-0.0207981281,
0.0146954032,
-0.0519382805,
0.0087157562,
0.0618402883,
-0.0111073833,
-0.0140398629,
-0.0072241817,
-0.02810774,
-0.041505713,
0.0151598817,
0.0693650767,
0.0598248653,
-0.0084842062,
-0.0163302515,
0.0333679803,
0.0006790574,
0.0195157044,
-0.0305483378,
0.0625947788,
-0.0398776755,
-0.0099723311,
0.0075026015,
-0.0149446158,
-0.0056741824,
0.0026204858,
-0.0004448281,
0.0060393494,
0.0425442122,
-0.0157060213,
0.0606861077,
-0.0120782899,
-0.0049828272,
0.0326328762,
0.0540536381,
-0.0237342119,
-0.0238025673,
-0.0116503183,
0.0323545001,
-0.0045662215,
0.0580186471,
0.0092847263,
0.0099122161,
0.0249579195,
-0.0180624127,
-0.0317270122,
0.0433746539,
0.0226012226,
0.0000545885,
-0.0567866825,
0.0005364575,
0.0249693654,
-0.0448687971,
-0.0047048195,
0.0291119255,
-0.0299361255,
0.0728781074,
0.0057913652,
-0.0817938522,
-0.0362686999,
0.0061525446,
0.0181143768,
-0.0029433134,
-0.0465731025,
-0.0001401032,
0.0102934632,
0.0689466894,
0.0047107316,
0.0304730739,
0.0654345006,
0.0218120869,
0.0121267131,
0.0067701121,
0.0521877147,
0.0354598686,
-0.0072036521,
0.0137899881,
-0.0260689687,
0.0176844765,
0.0305896979,
0.0272564758,
0.0096164504,
0.0111185443,
0.02553696,
0.0242359936,
-0.0292104986,
0.0450918376,
0.0390046388,
-0.0059943898,
0.0265847761,
0.0833369121,
0.0292285606,
0.0094513847,
0.0526149422,
0.0651021153,
-0.0428678356,
-0.040987663,
0.0117371706,
-0.021244783,
0.0552787334,
0.0086350953,
-0.0030452262,
-0.0092836134,
0.0591134876,
-0.0076019452,
0.0247991215,
0.0281048119,
0.0938598737,
0.018529078,
-0.0068645747,
-0.0580355041,
0.0389290825,
0.0075761722,
0.0627157763,
-0.004003684,
-0.0049661249,
0.0538948514,
0.0019328981,
0.0220215023,
0.0476323701,
-0.0144225638,
-0.0308959652,
0.0179457311,
-0.014392145,
-0.0445998535,
-0.0677828044,
-0.0512975119,
-0.0717810467,
0.0161824375,
0.0185653921,
0.0160240084,
0.010926622,
-0.0097747557,
-0.0031885132,
0.0023480968,
0.0767355636,
0.0406116582,
0.0466836952,
0.0294590592,
-0.0226502772,
-0.0368535742,
-0.0155473715,
-0.0198486838,
-0.0206612777,
0.0121415686,
-0.05670885,
-0.0253272727,
-0.0654135644,
0.0174168516,
-0.052914761,
-0.0051648123,
-0.008370081,
-0.0432862639,
0.0066938684,
0.0522904247,
0.087636292,
0.0550692417,
0.0126559353,
-0.0098315598,
0.0300091635,
-0.0369843319,
-0.0109180706,
-0.0668940023,
-0.0161486398,
-0.0168689061,
-0.0283629503,
-0.0313112177,
-0.0072656013,
0.0518812947,
0.018891992,
-0.0462156013,
-0.0101519953,
0.0013844634,
-0.0950798392,
0.0159789342,
0.0476572663,
-0.0328551047,
-0.0549874678,
0.0602882616,
-0.029881604,
0.0141848139,
0.0149412565,
0.0123132775,
-0.001213725,
-0.0687078387,
0.0412118882,
-0.0534633845,
0.0324068069,
-0.0126487371,
0.0159377046,
-0.0160197318,
-0.0260576867,
-0.1205938235,
-0.0228922348,
0.0213032141,
0.0172203612,
0.0441858508,
-0.0669223815,
0.0023761073,
-0.0422794484,
-0.0761011988,
0.0069792513,
-0.0207130574,
0.0434150994,
-0.0114639793,
0.0504238345,
-0.0243777875,
0.0379193239,
0.0235014036,
0.0079104286,
0.0128931087,
-0.0197405498,
0.0231866762,
-0.0115196295,
0.0120932609,
-0.0053599272,
0.0170423705,
0.0284301471,
0.0471858121,
0.0073555782,
0.0474291965,
-0.0047918758,
-0.0221171752,
0.0182974078,
0.0096712727,
0.0641910061,
-0.0074216444,
-0.0855405629,
-0.0011692023,
0.0141138127,
0.0275948159,
0.0290172808,
0.0557139181,
0.0296048708,
0.0212535989,
0.0839398876,
-0.0625253543,
0.0297315102,
0.0379968993,
0.023024017,
-0.0329661779,
0.06281773,
0.0088761169,
-0.0476791561,
-0.0190491844,
-0.0017274772,
-0.0346565172,
-0.0639814064,
-0.0253233425,
-0.0021325268,
-0.0674214363,
-0.0267899912,
0.0046994374,
-0.0199451316,
0.0116622783,
-0.0329953358,
0.0636989623,
-0.0516589433,
0.0152528919,
0.0325158425,
-0.0044017355,
0.0357857086,
-0.0484196171,
-0.0034989265,
-0.0632445589,
-0.0188881643,
0.0368750542,
-0.0239969809,
-0.0840955228,
0.0032978796,
0.0227480847,
0.0181924067,
0.00283224,
-0.0084174797,
0.0249385852,
0.0089249117,
-0.0467877574,
-0.0152898952,
-0.0145419957,
-0.0334157757,
0.0036434848,
0.0158128981,
-0.0084201163,
-0.0495262854,
0.0472427122,
-0.0025279897,
-0.0320829898,
-0.0138325468,
0.0197773185,
0.008956396,
0.0285922438,
-0.0014064542,
0.040716216,
0.0483009629,
-0.0431591906,
-0.0578434654,
-0.006323202,
-0.0779296383,
-0.0751239061,
-0.0482708924,
-0.0489156842,
0.0742999315,
0.0340420902,
-0.0097588114,
0.0104305064,
0.0025799652,
-0.0297342241,
-0.0660625845,
0.0087902183,
0.0218384583,
-0.04248951,
0.0186281428,
0.0392058343,
0.0460872315,
-0.0246121213,
-0.1023657471,
0.0093074292,
-0.0622839816,
0.0582712106,
0.0245384797,
0.0146527933,
-0.0504749082,
0.0602977425,
-0.0160413068,
-0.0525544025,
0.01135079,
-0.0337424614,
0.0669129044,
0.0194700751,
-0.0310538765,
0.0328657813,
0.0157035887,
0.0267357416,
-0.0273317061,
-0.0102017103,
-0.0113856969,
-0.022044342,
-0.0043616076,
0.0512560345,
0.0441324264,
0.0246910676,
-0.0271014422,
0.0218023621,
-0.047229223,
0.0260742791,
-0.0457754694,
-0.0409857258,
0.0079781264,
-0.0060916706,
0.020300122,
0.0528229065,
-0.0390232764,
-0.0033712348,
0.0123324785,
-0.0160733983,
0.0599593893,
0.0055902046,
0.044998318,
0.0481230319,
0.0266606826,
0.0764103308,
-0.0091741374,
0.0377338119,
-0.041225668,
0.0249773152,
-0.0220266897,
0.0380394869,
0.0177414846,
-0.0072356509,
-0.0128452377,
0.0374774747,
0.0370083489,
-0.0374165475,
0.0370887108,
-0.0456315838,
0.0191602428,
-0.0552008823,
0.0711789429,
-0.0600732192,
0.0158278346,
0.0012381276,
0.0303637031,
-0.0347531736,
-0.0237987339,
-0.0202796012,
0.0126112802,
0.0068831593,
0.0025804318,
0.079804562,
-0.0368667245,
-0.0310173482,
0.0092185782,
-0.0381651372,
-0.0059687714,
0.0122568607,
0.021855792,
-0.013647751,
0.0163949486,
0.0133689595,
-0.0828966796,
-0.035718143,
-0.0434408821,
-0.0342694297,
0.0243048798,
-0.0081507163,
0.015720116,
0.0862123817,
-0.0009168774,
-0.0082429871,
-0.0285995696,
-0.0176625196,
0.004862309,
-0.0217881314,
0.005847455,
-5.754997732e-33,
-0.0289997607,
-0.0176791903,
-0.0088529075,
0.0025495612,
-0.0117519367,
-0.0383240357,
0.0258289929,
0.057238806,
0.0054349108,
-0.0124145299,
-0.0058623846,
-0.0095390212,
0.0093180025,
-0.0228540897,
0.038211707,
0.0392817855,
-0.0371713676,
-0.0110720685,
-0.0414835699,
-0.0934865475,
0.067304194,
-0.020399034,
0.1142552719,
-0.0150815751,
0.031905029,
-0.0070462716,
0.0126003893,
-0.0016775412,
-0.0399852246,
-0.0139742652,
0.0232625268,
0.0054120803,
0.0239030067,
0.0090038721,
-0.0155115072,
-0.0070256903,
0.0135832261,
-0.0747859776,
0.0507482179,
0.0706810728,
-0.0007075287,
-0.0101491045,
-0.0104243839,
-0.0297942534,
-0.0456407964,
0.0233710166,
-0.0110193491,
0.0204565208,
-0.0393379703,
0.0473029763,
-0.0744547546,
-0.0131130163,
-0.0400571227,
-0.0088616461,
0.025867885,
0.0124745993,
-0.0242596995,
-0.0575141273,
-0.0422328822,
0.1108770594,
-0.044245448,
0.0754160061,
0.014490637,
-0.0130272768,
-0.0318403803,
-0.0162167661,
0.0815075189,
-0.0209386609,
0.0646446794,
0.0206988882,
0.031183457,
0.0645420775,
-0.0334239751,
0.0234969296,
0.0772174075,
-0.0340313166,
-0.0084780641,
-0.0558937043,
-0.0294386372,
0.0220749248,
-0.0134166926,
0.0335894451,
-0.0578534007,
-0.0717635006,
0.0100425249,
-0.0008986422,
-0.0136398179,
-0.0198254138,
0.0421653204,
-0.0254494492,
0.002094964,
-0.0053638364,
0.0253912844,
-0.0098700132,
-0.0499730036,
0.0001649529,
-0.0499745049,
0.0251821894,
-0.013363135,
0.0297718849,
-0.0810936317,
-0.0168284979,
-0.0286498722,
0.0171509646,
0.0061111497,
0.0125399586,
0.0245828293,
0.0107044205,
-0.0274294298,
-0.0101677543,
0.0230200738,
-0.0622816868,
0.0039007026,
-0.0015060696,
0.0218810271,
0.0140447738,
-0.0016240453,
0.0080627194,
0.0727956966,
-0.0413241349,
-0.0484346896,
-0.0116359238,
0.0036600509,
0.0140126785,
0.0143591482,
0.002449037,
-0.0163385756,
0.052687861,
0.0305757727,
-0.0167572834,
-0.0265326202,
0.0026465082,
2.919e-7,
0.0217425451,
0.040986523,
0.0399239734,
-0.0183008369,
-0.0153876198,
-0.0238907728,
-0.0164180715,
-0.0279480163,
-0.003275895,
0.0644634664,
0.0095237773,
0.012046963,
-0.0193359833,
0.0015376246,
-0.0203649588,
0.0211976413,
-0.0487387776,
-0.0109928837,
-0.0043434571,
-0.0061958688,
-0.0145613197,
0.0370627418,
-0.0183283575,
0.0181749146,
-0.0914316401,
0.0521056764,
0.021121379,
-0.0117347771,
0.0510081872,
0.007004648,
0.0050635599,
-0.0669929832,
0.0087456182,
0.0114717595,
0.0199998301,
-0.0025521915,
0.0528069548,
-0.0074417465,
-0.0022630498,
-0.0178798009,
0.0352031365,
-0.0215943586,
-0.0678620562,
-0.0507759452,
0.0054517663,
-0.0047616237,
-0.0489326045,
0.030193802,
-0.0264080707,
0.0555826724,
0.0009363159,
0.0140611427,
0.0295706932,
0.003697919,
0.009038507,
-0.0242382977,
-0.0104395226,
0.0037859885,
-0.062905699,
0.0159732383,
0.0402550884,
-0.0697810203,
0.030988194,
0.0076570041,
0.0479911081,
0.0255847052,
-0.0642368868,
2.461157777e-34,
0.0030896275,
0.0145990402,
0.0490837768,
-0.0030672525,
0.0150789032,
-0.0350646265,
0.0183834359,
0.065107353,
0.0176345222,
-0.0158207398,
-0.041629985
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.04193v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.04193v2 | Language Model Knowledge Distillation for Efficient Question Answering in Spanish | 2023-12-07T10:21:22 | 2024-03-16T17:44:27 | Adrián Bazaga, Pietro Liò, Gos Micklem | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, stat.ML | Recent advances in the development of pre-trained Spanish language models has
led to significant progress in many Natural Language Processing (NLP) tasks,
such as question answering. However, the lack of efficient models imposes a
barrier for the adoption of such models in resource-constrained environments.
Therefore, smaller distilled models for the Spanish language could be proven to
be highly scalable and facilitate their further adoption on a variety of tasks
and scenarios. In this work, we take one step in this direction by developing
SpanishTinyRoBERTa, a compressed language model based on RoBERTa for efficient
question answering in Spanish. To achieve this, we employ knowledge
distillation from a large model onto a lighter model that allows for a wider
implementation, even in areas with limited computational resources, whilst
attaining negligible performance sacrifice. Our experiments show that the dense
distilled model can still preserve the performance of its larger counterpart,
while significantly increasing inference speedup. This work serves as a
starting point for further research and investigation of model compression
efforts for Spanish language models across various NLP tasks. | [
0.0160836484,
0.0812201798,
-0.0170536898,
0.0602551661,
-0.0128405001,
0.0158226304,
-0.0306821726,
0.0295690037,
-0.0341967717,
-0.0106518976,
-0.0371103212,
0.0392306112,
-0.0168494955,
-0.0253418311,
-0.0102829365,
-0.0147952493,
0.0315870419,
-0.0512504689,
-0.0098902956,
-0.0430864207,
0.0218630694,
0.0031445289,
0.0153663708,
0.0118330996,
0.0148976129,
-0.0117479758,
0.00007397,
-0.0147706857,
-0.0327650607,
0.0426045954,
0.0283622146,
0.063655436,
0.0006964997,
0.0131782722,
0.000001963,
-0.014646587,
-0.0185595844,
-0.0002867063,
-0.0439732485,
0.0208163038,
0.014812435,
-0.0154087655,
0.0347592533,
0.005330517,
-0.0631541088,
-0.0452146977,
0.015338487,
-0.0172945447,
0.0458395332,
0.0163366105,
0.0101364972,
-0.0350018963,
0.0135396328,
-0.040069066,
-0.0275069885,
-0.038957417,
0.002031428,
0.0341152884,
-0.0042310385,
0.0119118607,
-0.0196212251,
0.0564262941,
0.0433291234,
0.0222584717,
-0.0363616198,
-0.0121285431,
-0.0638078302,
-0.0111114886,
-0.003885993,
0.0447041169,
-0.0516905636,
-0.0432557873,
0.0007937757,
0.0353785008,
-0.0100706164,
-0.0049258899,
-0.0480761901,
-0.0053748386,
0.0085791172,
0.0181626547,
0.0241066311,
0.0105765834,
0.025399195,
0.0289098043,
-0.0413870551,
0.0489684008,
0.0274959002,
-0.0128310109,
0.0184900071,
-0.0028191386,
-0.0413189009,
-0.0621531829,
0.0358083136,
0.0482887477,
0.0248891711,
0.0008999044,
-0.0229636226,
-0.0235251803,
0.0345317908,
-0.0580044053,
0.0188596547,
0.0335371085,
0.0239221789,
0.0316960625,
-0.0082153706,
0.054214295,
-0.0196454488,
0.0045360723,
-0.0503394417,
-0.0628053993,
-0.0383170843,
-0.0220359173,
-0.0814512968,
0.0334965773,
-0.0587674193,
-0.0066701923,
0.0220914334,
0.0024220576,
0.0054655569,
-0.0340553634,
0.0372791216,
0.0327470601,
-0.0058880672,
-0.0065913489,
-0.0123471506,
0.0624048524,
-0.0948122442,
-0.006202484,
0.0059560002,
-0.1010103449,
-0.0207707137,
-0.0140685597,
-0.0059380857,
-0.0428379141,
0.038941782,
0.0104162246,
-0.0013031556,
-0.0345008932,
-0.0058670649,
-0.03992147,
-0.0112040639,
-0.1227091327,
-0.010592794,
-0.1082390994,
0.0581242591,
-0.001198091,
0.0156160882,
-0.065137513,
-0.0078559257,
0.019576598,
-0.0219336357,
0.0553598739,
-0.0173926353,
0.0023262082,
0.0196677074,
0.0251365677,
0.0073515335,
0.0743647218,
0.0011839208,
0.0125532234,
0.0278591886,
-0.009468833,
-0.0242066123,
0.0468045175,
0.066185087,
0.0117625641,
-0.0178594757,
0.0567622371,
-0.0452883206,
-0.0043016993,
0.0703403279,
0.0575554371,
-0.0342128277,
0.0007224536,
0.0474684164,
0.0430838354,
0.0159323867,
0.0527692251,
0.053190764,
0.0132261813,
0.0245992504,
-0.0138210999,
-0.0309887175,
-0.0138959093,
-0.0361449793,
0.0028102403,
0.0037971826,
0.0440757722,
-0.0595183894,
-0.0422953591,
0.0245373901,
-0.0001448329,
0.0004876322,
0.0574068017,
0.0191482678,
0.0472869948,
0.0191109516,
0.0731620044,
0.0308824759,
-0.0421045534,
-0.0099073611,
-0.0443917736,
0.0144791557,
0.0144058336,
0.0209169928,
-0.0032338942,
-0.0144831371,
0.0300918426,
0.0052174358,
-0.0108324485,
0.0293407626,
-0.0312852673,
0.0317769796,
-0.0386811867,
0.0039649955,
0.0101139145,
0.0244674105,
-0.0052108834,
0.0744859353,
0.0384368226,
0.0050920909,
-0.0684921816,
-0.010170822,
-0.0028080314,
-0.0273014363,
-0.0673025325,
-0.0187919345,
0.0136331143,
0.0089601222,
0.0158355329,
-0.0136166392,
-0.025666276,
0.0732445642,
-0.0329499058,
-0.0055702147,
-0.0263539515,
-0.0253481157,
-0.0995539799,
0.0254872832,
0.0050522783,
0.0209534019,
0.0579223409,
-0.0279673636,
-0.0308463741,
-0.0021514739,
-0.0277273599,
0.0454023704,
-0.0431007668,
0.0278253444,
0.0006040223,
0.027210407,
-0.0321762301,
0.0391347595,
-0.0504766367,
0.0458733551,
0.03571257,
-0.0467766486,
0.0100649241,
-0.0246580262,
-0.0491627268,
0.0354692489,
-0.006867467,
0.0212876089,
0.0314425752,
0.0048783747,
0.0277566332,
-0.0024845318,
-0.0828240439,
0.0391935557,
-0.0332230367,
0.0094348229,
0.0525650419,
0.0602976084,
0.0038356641,
-0.0335051008,
-0.0246916246,
-0.014845632,
0.0322908387,
0.0273815282,
-0.0106515568,
0.0212980229,
-0.0059379335,
-0.050806269,
-0.0329843536,
0.0408355854,
0.0588908084,
-0.0459640734,
-0.0262337476,
-0.0324949585,
-0.0191871449,
-0.0373790041,
0.0548259877,
0.0145084802,
-0.0595423058,
-0.0293151047,
0.0115257343,
0.0326737612,
0.0470652357,
-0.0376005135,
0.0152619146,
0.0297355317,
0.0108589306,
-0.0563887358,
0.0360732526,
-0.0116679193,
-0.0165212546,
-0.0483717881,
-0.0514346883,
0.0139801512,
0.0916429386,
-0.0169423912,
-0.0223584753,
-0.0186825879,
-0.0255764462,
-0.0085518984,
-0.0405834727,
-0.0196329672,
0.0222767964,
0.0194639824,
0.043504227,
-0.042499505,
-0.0324147195,
0.0317449123,
-0.0363605209,
-0.0126160411,
-0.0530704036,
-0.0303067025,
-0.0229533371,
0.0542420819,
0.0404395238,
0.039514903,
-0.0140281711,
0.0410302468,
-0.0280156601,
-0.0327808857,
-0.0194946956,
-0.0272312537,
0.0497810617,
-0.0462624356,
0.0090760868,
0.0073624635,
-0.0617823936,
-0.0282759629,
-0.0082611861,
-0.0478280298,
0.0298901573,
0.0258380584,
-0.0026743393,
-0.0058143768,
0.0065825526,
-0.0036402829,
0.0637743995,
-0.0056913672,
-0.0056064795,
-0.0149679091,
0.0502446108,
0.0402644724,
0.0077300714,
0.0123095335,
-0.0146764955,
0.0248332173,
0.0416587256,
0.0070185498,
-0.0130259022,
-0.0374500901,
0.0124340067,
0.0399510823,
-0.0318958014,
-0.047275994,
-0.0115901036,
0.0393112041,
-0.0497896858,
-0.0232029445,
0.0791080743,
0.0269017871,
-0.0234730504,
-0.0073326039,
-0.0066308859,
0.084751457,
0.0272200815,
0.0533253849,
-0.043509189,
-0.0550859869,
0.0060860198,
-0.0119473748,
0.0312559679,
-0.003798574,
-0.0234119892,
-0.1047213376,
-0.0073860688,
-0.0407381244,
-0.0103045302,
-0.0284025427,
-0.0177016556,
-0.0206744168,
-0.0280521717,
-0.0132445842,
0.0236183628,
-0.0210798308,
0.025749227,
0.0127658322,
-0.0242299456,
0.0018151198,
0.0154653117,
-0.0223198403,
-0.010425996,
0.0357418507,
0.0188290942,
0.0143680805,
0.0016722854,
-0.0149891796,
-0.0133651998,
-0.0006400181,
-0.0242442545,
0.060411524,
0.0280685648,
-0.003009812,
-0.0038035768,
-0.0042523616,
-0.0477637537,
0.0119982492,
0.0232785847,
0.0747552216,
0.0111193182,
-0.0096127475,
-0.0134802582,
-0.0406381525,
-0.0164142996,
0.0815955997,
0.0599073246,
-0.0191719122,
-0.0444671176,
0.017643366,
-0.0450652353,
-0.0297753941,
-0.0278963353,
0.008337874,
0.0021914868,
-0.0263439305,
-0.0604447313,
-0.0316098705,
0.0228130128,
0.0160217602,
-0.0055028005,
0.0247963034,
0.0279630106,
0.0100686727,
-0.0694523752,
0.0225405581,
-0.0292776581,
-0.005479522,
-0.0307469647,
-0.0081843715,
-0.016386291,
0.0044642463,
-0.0339186825,
-0.0005795377,
-0.1315253824,
-0.0381721631,
-0.0004743029,
0.0784369558,
0.0354715064,
0.0528301261,
-0.0423971452,
-0.0520140417,
0.0510325953,
-0.0175243039,
-0.050549157,
0.0319202691,
0.0368022136,
-0.0485571437,
0.0097603463,
0.0735714436,
-0.0056408639,
0.0184279848,
-0.0055283448,
0.0341700986,
-0.0536897741,
-0.0408935957,
0.0182427298,
0.0114251617,
0.0062201284,
-0.0090733888,
-0.0007724629,
0.0038647333,
0.008619817,
-0.0015543181,
-0.0037770343,
-0.0398010947,
0.0179646574,
0.0263766218,
0.0282067657,
-0.0063364087,
0.0311457384,
0.028598154,
0.0015451211,
-0.0191181004,
-0.0190405454,
0.0453067794,
-0.0261785686,
0.0208597407,
0.0290242136,
-0.0062606703,
0.0207705759,
-0.0192120951,
0.0291249622,
-0.0591853298,
0.0067095389,
-0.0033395614,
-0.0068721636,
-0.03712501,
0.0480055064,
-0.0336385779,
-0.0887204409,
0.0084009469,
0.0378847905,
0.0583475232,
-0.0198370293,
0.0246791299,
0.0146829039,
-0.0301572289,
-0.0225376822,
-0.0177173894,
0.040353138,
0.0061450186,
0.068193242,
0.018060891,
-0.0026006058,
-0.007479039,
0.1117969975,
0.0229069125,
0.0732994974,
-0.0089278091,
0.0060796933,
-0.0227867458,
-0.0284315404,
-0.015989067,
-0.0114301387,
-0.0216960721,
-0.0127263414,
-0.0215716884,
-0.0856551006,
-0.0148748066,
-0.0385715552,
-0.0217680242,
-0.0240901001,
0.0722264498,
0.0601489395,
0.0273048356,
-0.0697283521,
-0.0430503786,
0.0137095451,
-0.0360463299,
-0.0158495624,
0.0224493239,
-5.980280857e-33,
0.0112882163,
0.0194415152,
0.017839849,
-0.0340101868,
0.0031749529,
0.0192337465,
-0.0162804388,
-0.0308899228,
-0.045058649,
0.0223941375,
-0.04681205,
0.0316864811,
0.019142013,
0.0321386643,
-0.0176919866,
0.018951457,
0.0402809493,
0.0074634128,
-0.007386914,
-0.0066992459,
-0.0087752305,
0.05449659,
0.0509389713,
-0.0011948977,
-0.0262174495,
-0.0304871537,
0.0076492,
0.0345769376,
0.0272036903,
0.0628429577,
-0.0422269888,
0.0449343957,
0.0263340399,
-0.0553375185,
-0.0187229197,
0.0378926881,
-0.1160881892,
-0.0571156256,
0.0619598031,
0.0222376231,
-0.0270960219,
-0.0222689845,
0.0292944442,
-0.0043074405,
0.0408324897,
0.0137872091,
0.0012534409,
-0.0278297104,
-0.0034690672,
0.0015781141,
-0.0434840135,
0.0152115365,
0.0085883755,
-0.0430758558,
0.0564376079,
0.0392066203,
-0.0410266928,
-0.0114007192,
-0.0123209646,
-0.0325524211,
0.0136251217,
0.0909551978,
0.0460391492,
0.0224958472,
-0.0081896968,
0.0257564653,
-0.0044775307,
-0.0432009473,
-0.0034159569,
0.0369424894,
0.0181535333,
0.0600402616,
0.0365470648,
0.058414124,
0.0704706386,
0.0103884134,
-0.0778153166,
-0.009913736,
0.0035888983,
0.0229689479,
0.001291014,
-0.0215796717,
-0.0212636851,
-0.0033719453,
-0.0579869151,
-0.0150340078,
-0.0133976536,
-0.0214825254,
0.0348049663,
0.0179155618,
-0.0372228026,
0.0048243515,
0.0277063753,
-0.0658422187,
-0.0151790753,
0.0604591444,
-0.023480976,
0.0033839147,
0.0358493216,
0.0736088902,
-0.0511972494,
0.0339637659,
-0.0078139091,
0.0176497493,
-0.0074980604,
0.0265610553,
0.0521501265,
0.0027470361,
-0.0513032675,
0.0042663547,
-0.0520744957,
0.0357788317,
0.0054366994,
0.0590784214,
0.0298511591,
0.0490940474,
-0.0113188494,
0.0294576474,
0.0244369823,
0.0082266005,
-0.0308403205,
-0.0166469701,
0.02530347,
0.0470017605,
-0.0219658874,
-0.028642226,
-0.0607932135,
0.0229381099,
-0.0317449123,
-0.0484814532,
-0.0211058129,
0.0167836323,
2.482e-7,
0.0720559731,
0.0000094169,
0.0100748548,
0.0355784148,
0.0055519352,
-0.0080537964,
0.0319608226,
0.0176059902,
-0.0114962067,
-0.0274421629,
-0.0249093901,
0.0727134496,
0.0341900028,
0.0454634875,
-0.067617327,
-0.0414898321,
-0.0234030765,
-0.0306708254,
-0.0284016058,
-0.0507752039,
0.0205064323,
0.1174836308,
0.0181774497,
-0.0306138713,
-0.0159879494,
-0.0407439657,
0.051825881,
0.0164958686,
0.0154789472,
0.0351621397,
0.0458816178,
0.0113086523,
-0.0126305781,
0.0103756236,
0.0000593271,
0.0033319439,
-0.0067565287,
0.0817227438,
-0.0166044589,
0.0219588559,
0.0216154363,
-0.0751997232,
-0.0194052644,
-0.0742118284,
0.0959718153,
-0.0287517086,
0.0115712686,
-0.0043976256,
-0.009846352,
-0.006061689,
0.0254109912,
-0.0163697004,
-0.0089574186,
0.0374196805,
0.0370282307,
-0.0310860947,
-0.0333636925,
-0.0673147291,
-0.0353297405,
0.0147139905,
-0.0344046615,
-0.0282658916,
-0.0529594384,
-0.047064431,
0.0013346374,
-0.050647404,
0.0306369215,
2.1094315e-34,
-0.0046796678,
0.0165967476,
0.004882507,
0.0280730128,
0.023264328,
-0.0442275628,
-0.0214658733,
-0.0246060845,
-0.0119891549,
-0.0793248862,
-0.0094957007
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.04134v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.04134v1 | Using a Large Language Model to generate a Design Structure Matrix | 2023-12-07T08:48:54 | 2023-12-07T08:48:54 | Edwin C. Y. Koh | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | The Design Structure Matrix (DSM) is an established method used in dependency
modelling, especially in the design of complex engineering systems. The
generation of DSM is traditionally carried out through manual means and can
involve interviewing experts to elicit critical system elements and the
relationships between them. Such manual approaches can be time-consuming and
costly. This paper presents a workflow that uses a Large Language Model (LLM)
to support the generation of DSM and improve productivity. A prototype of the
workflow was developed in this work and applied on a diesel engine DSM
published previously. It was found that the prototype could reproduce 357 out
of 462 DSM entries published (i.e. 77.3%), suggesting that the work can aid DSM
generation. A no-code version of the prototype is made available online to
support future research. | [
0.0050854897,
0.0177026913,
-0.0302640367,
0.0557949655,
-0.0369968265,
-0.0048239245,
0.0028654675,
-0.0274931658,
0.0332597718,
-0.0424000286,
0.010418457,
0.0332478657,
-0.0001439135,
0.0604947656,
0.0264832433,
-0.0000032659,
-0.0023801746,
-0.0165983792,
-0.0692257881,
0.0122654801,
0.0062299795,
-0.0120131345,
0.0020323538,
0.0269607194,
-0.0275630839,
0.0013985304,
-0.025911158,
0.0336350091,
0.0273152366,
-0.0197701473,
0.0129461112,
0.0846320838,
0.044300124,
0.0227578096,
0.0000022,
-0.0013746035,
0.0000280568,
0.0144866994,
0.0095718447,
0.0444396026,
0.0200077128,
0.0327706933,
-0.0023354657,
-0.0098213311,
0.0196355227,
-0.0361073762,
0.0021522283,
0.0177406184,
0.0540350713,
0.0109741576,
-0.0090505509,
-0.0148511054,
-0.0153570687,
-0.0112179574,
-0.0843025669,
0.0059846444,
0.0177275911,
0.1020473093,
0.0549992882,
0.0113326237,
0.0154716512,
0.0165374316,
-0.0017519393,
-0.042786479,
0.0577576645,
-0.030843297,
0.0619339794,
0.0200650934,
0.0290672965,
0.0712005273,
0.0651216879,
0.0275991037,
0.0002966732,
-0.024507843,
-0.031380605,
0.0231626406,
-0.0436827093,
-0.0537303872,
-0.0107498402,
0.0050460543,
-0.0002044512,
-0.0220700819,
-0.0346594192,
-0.0642145649,
0.0011396451,
0.0664155856,
0.0057833497,
0.0052274596,
-0.0396064855,
-0.0240762234,
0.0659623817,
-0.0292270593,
0.0209072959,
-0.0143840155,
-0.0416715518,
0.0111164236,
0.0518373549,
-0.0114151118,
0.0493194833,
-0.0960161164,
0.076963231,
-0.033702068,
0.0150185963,
-0.0323553458,
-0.043432612,
0.0454185717,
-0.0288044233,
-0.0713424832,
-0.0458828323,
0.0342361704,
-0.06116708,
-0.0085161328,
-0.0498438068,
0.0295712724,
-0.0394899435,
0.0035483046,
-0.0756174028,
0.0735662058,
-0.0310868826,
0.0267367195,
0.0114394827,
-0.0072903694,
0.0391126461,
-0.0284772757,
-0.0160400383,
0.0154677117,
0.0319850259,
0.0292071439,
-0.0484139808,
0.0062641068,
0.0407261699,
0.0480578206,
-0.0124799572,
-0.0256947782,
-0.0020517237,
0.0789962783,
-0.0170906652,
0.0224096123,
-0.0316814855,
-0.0366497599,
0.0108694825,
-0.0070306119,
-0.003803801,
-0.0709647685,
-0.0342530943,
0.0053396327,
0.0115059856,
-0.0214389879,
-0.0088787414,
-0.0240351819,
0.0206658617,
0.0206364691,
-0.0284546521,
0.0638888106,
-0.0092696827,
0.0014963552,
0.0279751457,
0.0317862742,
0.0089866016,
-0.0046270769,
-0.0090385005,
-0.0132764447,
-0.0101526724,
0.0409677811,
-0.0535264425,
0.0140239699,
-0.056759771,
0.0352836512,
-0.0223433599,
-0.0174786355,
-0.0157398582,
-0.0313678943,
0.036368452,
0.0764358416,
0.0402135625,
-0.0767086968,
0.0752737299,
0.0417898819,
0.0152977537,
0.0834717378,
0.0134130353,
-0.0363729522,
0.0457113087,
0.0141772674,
0.0192576274,
-0.0139073413,
-0.0229022298,
0.0358422324,
-0.0027577702,
-0.0257412381,
0.0040785205,
-0.0268891323,
-0.0161810722,
-0.0018182265,
0.0486521982,
-0.020964399,
-0.0490266979,
0.0215318743,
0.0083265202,
0.0065972884,
-0.0564935282,
-0.0308220964,
0.0169476233,
0.0736107603,
0.0461038984,
-0.0511001684,
-0.0626817942,
0.0442372002,
0.007077293,
0.0102240285,
0.0334024243,
-0.0014463657,
-0.0344697759,
0.0184895508,
-0.0382908769,
-0.0297739785,
-0.0052586994,
0.0082190447,
-0.0316144675,
-0.0494409613,
0.0113049299,
0.0105866818,
-0.0510011464,
-0.0032070011,
0.0118776951,
0.0123849092,
0.0226097926,
0.0017649441,
0.0298284255,
0.0463795774,
-0.0400833525,
0.0246508345,
0.0251451433,
-0.0772385895,
-0.0367549472,
-0.0391037092,
-0.0094393007,
0.0813797265,
0.0012034698,
-0.0330452137,
0.0142477751,
0.0307631437,
-0.0068932548,
-0.0505325347,
0.039468158,
-0.0178728588,
-0.0159707088,
0.0184795354,
0.0286771804,
-0.0332689285,
0.0135256071,
-0.0306138527,
0.0392023958,
0.0165346526,
-0.0107233552,
-0.0327402167,
0.0229923464,
0.0668888688,
0.0254966598,
-0.000173444,
0.0559418015,
0.0147302309,
0.0064293593,
0.0073970268,
-0.0137810148,
-0.0012153162,
0.0025454494,
-0.0422414206,
-0.012207537,
0.0646008179,
0.0369157307,
0.0170483328,
-0.0171700008,
0.0143661899,
0.0311993342,
0.0020059722,
0.0790088028,
-0.0295406412,
-0.0434056818,
0.0198783334,
0.0114347264,
-0.0965224877,
0.0189683735,
-0.0149686709,
0.0016896081,
0.0463822335,
0.0252589677,
-0.0064041386,
-0.1110012457,
0.1095983535,
-0.0002433942,
0.0045128362,
-0.0101376725,
-0.0100652948,
-0.0134270117,
0.0174780674,
0.0413978361,
-0.0156534743,
-0.0384472013,
-0.0318335593,
0.0474232882,
-0.0610149428,
-0.0489701554,
-0.0181482323,
0.0211680792,
0.0438824557,
0.0011275581,
-0.0262500402,
-0.0185348615,
-0.0146591906,
-0.025619261,
-0.0059391977,
0.0276536606,
-0.0088672573,
0.0089385984,
0.0228681844,
0.0100364331,
-0.0591233857,
0.0164883789,
0.0699454322,
-0.0194105301,
-0.0266536977,
0.0149853686,
-0.0251726434,
0.0097668907,
-0.0351911932,
-0.0151074249,
-0.0275070537,
0.0526187755,
-0.0143079115,
-0.0118776187,
0.0207178071,
0.052183345,
-0.021816073,
0.0161356032,
0.004515884,
0.0173433777,
0.0217876919,
-0.0292663872,
0.0394310988,
-0.0191905703,
-0.0006651305,
-0.0286734793,
0.0620403625,
-0.0558364056,
0.0287126005,
0.0125597063,
-0.0256077442,
0.0074258833,
0.0455194004,
0.0447794907,
0.0185559932,
0.0291024353,
-0.0171272494,
-0.0272768606,
-0.0040000654,
0.0011261427,
-0.0615832768,
0.034012869,
0.0184033886,
0.0466656499,
0.0074815494,
-0.0382859334,
0.0213290397,
-0.0873652324,
-0.0615380257,
0.0057799504,
0.0613497756,
-0.033925198,
0.010337688,
-0.0596686676,
-0.0481013395,
-0.0074147843,
-0.007990405,
0.0139602749,
-0.0155388331,
0.0265698433,
0.0363351889,
0.0387223102,
0.0164129231,
0.0610714667,
-0.0576075017,
0.0171516743,
-0.0019076081,
0.01829293,
-0.0430928618,
-0.004770895,
0.0031835567,
-0.0448074788,
0.0289399475,
-0.0244268179,
-0.007757599,
-0.0099695818,
-0.0358039923,
-0.0154082747,
0.0270444173,
-0.0515500493,
0.0536704808,
-0.0190078765,
-0.044357907,
0.0283460617,
-0.0699716061,
-0.0762081593,
0.0281661991,
0.0204746481,
0.0015583829,
0.0333335623,
0.0085484199,
-0.0208874233,
-0.0274528023,
0.0756408796,
0.0155601995,
0.0285662189,
-0.0492393784,
-0.0172850396,
0.0540962443,
-0.0107353944,
-0.0560361072,
-0.0238762759,
-0.0766304955,
-0.0062717693,
0.0503544025,
0.1009819657,
-0.0223088562,
0.0041573709,
-0.0408496968,
-0.0312335473,
0.0181387551,
-0.0217829924,
0.0003038704,
-0.0251625068,
-0.003587056,
0.0258983579,
-0.0720674023,
-0.0323736444,
0.0059055523,
0.0107431486,
-0.0329281352,
0.016865069,
0.0072193844,
0.0530581959,
0.013255965,
-0.0128140636,
-0.0293324962,
0.0048473263,
0.0491087101,
-0.0275330674,
-0.0463053212,
0.0097267535,
0.012915371,
0.0542732961,
0.00283011,
-0.0212101508,
0.0342432521,
0.0115945339,
-0.011938435,
-0.0093186107,
-0.0014877605,
-0.0249974038,
0.0152680529,
0.0811437294,
0.0177757237,
-0.0583751351,
-0.0059552584,
-0.0711521804,
-0.0387774333,
0.0123324208,
0.0164426751,
0.004069705,
-0.0484681763,
-0.0002178695,
0.0035069522,
-0.0306890029,
-0.0233670231,
0.0451792963,
0.0510565974,
-0.0054189255,
0.0295908563,
-0.009374517,
-0.0114741838,
0.0756176561,
-0.0570557304,
-0.008490365,
-0.0020595852,
-0.0408123694,
0.0415931568,
-0.0517280474,
-0.038000267,
-0.0651288331,
0.0613554083,
-0.0553968884,
-0.0408442654,
0.0379188024,
-0.0453882478,
-0.0322119407,
0.0233519711,
0.0078813322,
0.08457762,
0.0395788811,
-0.0115350112,
0.048892729,
-0.0280687492,
0.0084157372,
-0.0252274815,
-0.0018639519,
-0.0085817445,
-0.0008167193,
0.0169617292,
0.0058704535,
-0.0130762057,
-0.0690244958,
0.018948596,
0.061120633,
-0.0622000843,
-0.0453797132,
-0.0548589081,
0.0370290019,
0.0743081868,
0.0344991423,
-0.0521879531,
0.0182530675,
-0.0188297722,
0.0625118688,
-0.0155270323,
0.0324717015,
0.003763828,
0.0242832582,
-0.0103215221,
-0.0382276587,
0.0353390239,
0.0440346524,
-0.0488627031,
-0.0417625494,
-0.0746791288,
-0.0522481538,
-0.0241132099,
0.051372353,
0.0085573792,
-0.0641153231,
-0.0081620589,
-0.1079943702,
-0.0569307692,
-0.0150830587,
0.0102325007,
0.0376773439,
-0.0214191824,
0.0143403113,
0.0409656204,
0.0924178287,
-0.0367914326,
0.0102567365,
-0.0570739657,
-0.0287773591,
-0.0234849788,
0.0307610109,
-5.594122514e-33,
-0.0167267863,
-0.0446983986,
-0.0018782727,
-0.0060228403,
-0.002835074,
0.0122924419,
-0.0231568571,
0.0259684119,
0.0333226696,
0.0122128138,
0.0114477342,
-0.0237302464,
-0.0159375295,
-0.0264274366,
0.0572424345,
0.0640902445,
0.0094748782,
-0.0029644917,
-0.0031042912,
0.0294125546,
0.0291639846,
0.0268247332,
0.0060930108,
-0.0788069144,
0.0224936362,
-0.0190704279,
0.0063298084,
0.0267478097,
-0.0003583383,
0.021755185,
-0.038227953,
0.0340948775,
0.0063076136,
0.0084104305,
-0.0183303561,
-0.0015462233,
-0.002992207,
-0.0103070652,
0.0138523867,
0.0023961011,
0.0427493192,
-0.0066389823,
0.061754711,
0.0226900373,
-0.0059256526,
0.0288681984,
0.0255643427,
-0.0306377634,
0.019067863,
-0.0333704315,
-0.1109187081,
0.0109425765,
0.0076993424,
0.0088530472,
0.0020732228,
0.0474174544,
-0.0255525038,
-0.0167690367,
0.0278239436,
0.0094528403,
0.0499704778,
-0.0155499419,
0.0585789867,
0.0232344102,
0.0298043322,
-0.0299311411,
-0.0159735512,
0.0284492467,
-0.0099996738,
-0.0197278894,
0.0083731143,
0.0863748789,
0.0167271458,
0.0000789425,
-0.0360740796,
0.0359263048,
-0.0894433558,
0.0121722668,
-0.0454345495,
0.0557855368,
0.0698785111,
0.0106728356,
0.0310985334,
-0.0253540818,
0.0080015119,
0.0593601204,
-0.0160893984,
-0.0218618475,
-0.0055844574,
0.016290253,
-0.0612429716,
-0.0087910378,
0.0154055646,
-0.0568880551,
0.0124624046,
-0.0258238874,
-0.0321248807,
-0.0248469431,
-0.0163080115,
-0.0046838466,
-0.0206483547,
-0.0328488573,
-0.0335612185,
0.003914719,
0.0294173639,
-0.0251332242,
-0.0264223237,
-0.0183342844,
-0.0168009046,
0.0142159294,
-0.0433180854,
-0.0480444953,
0.005649392,
0.0417365059,
-0.0289201885,
-0.0175838545,
-0.0084818089,
-0.0460554436,
0.0106042009,
-0.0251227207,
-0.0236532129,
0.0107981525,
-0.0163376369,
0.0104066841,
0.0152528714,
-0.0191665236,
-0.0239976142,
0.0028860434,
0.0741150752,
0.0110344123,
-0.0375132933,
0.0174770486,
2.917e-7,
0.0231033582,
0.0390721373,
-0.0464304797,
0.0397060513,
0.0431120917,
0.0374566987,
-0.0057543148,
-0.0279118773,
-0.015169356,
0.0153028127,
0.0032543284,
-0.0038669354,
0.0412397832,
-0.0159808565,
-0.0307752434,
-0.0176589414,
0.0333750695,
0.026022058,
-0.0412779115,
-0.0152757503,
0.0245659314,
0.0161318164,
0.0269906912,
-0.0243016277,
-0.026117349,
0.0027065007,
-0.0022217333,
-0.0197923258,
0.024377631,
0.0382042788,
0.0314608365,
-0.0539426506,
-0.0114052147,
0.0892924815,
0.0201423876,
-0.0302419122,
-0.0304365419,
0.0356078334,
0.0082143024,
0.0224530846,
0.0658572838,
-0.0300581772,
-0.0206012987,
-0.0565179363,
-0.0160604436,
-0.0528806895,
-0.0314929076,
-0.0159675833,
-0.059421014,
-0.0236754362,
-0.0231950153,
-0.0021274744,
0.0611980297,
0.0412145779,
-0.0509473383,
-0.0505138747,
0.0170646422,
-0.0018900447,
0.0064609749,
0.0398541763,
-0.043515034,
-0.0705675706,
-0.0038458337,
-0.0134017393,
0.022581093,
0.0430459976,
0.0791561827,
2.533824909e-34,
-0.0095945718,
0.0099747125,
0.0016083949,
0.0747118816,
0.0155007401,
0.0007742056,
-0.0447171368,
0.0423359908,
0.0039415746,
-0.0897417888,
-0.0133480942
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.04127v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.04127v2 | Analyzing the Inherent Response Tendency of LLMs: Real-World Instructions-Driven Jailbreak | 2023-12-07T08:29:58 | 2024-02-23T07:32:27 | Yanrui Du, Sendong Zhao, Ming Ma, Yuhan Chen, Bing Qin | cs.CL | cs.CL | Extensive work has been devoted to improving the safety mechanism of Large
Language Models (LLMs). However, LLMs still tend to generate harmful responses
when faced with malicious instructions, a phenomenon referred to as "Jailbreak
Attack". In our research, we introduce a novel automatic jailbreak method
RADIAL, which bypasses the security mechanism by amplifying the potential of
LLMs to generate affirmation responses. The jailbreak idea of our method is
"Inherent Response Tendency Analysis" which identifies real-world instructions
that can inherently induce LLMs to generate affirmation responses and the
corresponding jailbreak strategy is "Real-World Instructions-Driven Jailbreak"
which involves strategically splicing real-world instructions identified
through the above analysis around the malicious instruction. Our method
achieves excellent attack performance on English malicious instructions with
five open-source advanced LLMs while maintaining robust attack performance in
executing cross-language attacks against Chinese malicious instructions. We
conduct experiments to verify the effectiveness of our jailbreak idea and the
rationality of our jailbreak strategy design. Notably, our method designed a
semantically coherent attack prompt, highlighting the potential risks of LLMs.
Our study provides detailed insights into jailbreak attacks, establishing a
foundation for the development of safer LLMs. | [
0.0375376679,
0.0447306186,
-0.0168780461,
0.0327670425,
-0.0344090313,
-0.0273635201,
-0.0098773884,
-0.0117216278,
0.0219556522,
-0.0020086183,
-0.0060780188,
-0.0026944617,
0.01682996,
-0.0123189874,
0.052186951,
0.0319064073,
0.0617285594,
-0.045904018,
-0.0237995293,
0.0187325254,
0.0053169918,
-0.0098522743,
0.0422421955,
0.0221437961,
0.0207718238,
-0.0084635653,
-0.0372752026,
0.0632586256,
0.0317484178,
-0.0469028428,
-0.011309796,
0.0067865509,
-0.0093839653,
0.0077867173,
0.0000023745,
-0.0173895527,
-0.0439714566,
0.0462335646,
-0.0097281719,
0.0824717507,
-0.0053364886,
-0.0239980314,
-0.0371846892,
0.0132335583,
0.0066515738,
0.0105790347,
0.0263238214,
0.0507312343,
0.0552186333,
0.0751122609,
0.0101687266,
0.0011954512,
0.0468510576,
0.0167784188,
0.0052171978,
-0.0400157347,
0.0064374814,
-0.0159037914,
0.0191220995,
0.0483534969,
0.0048945546,
-0.0594957098,
0.0143105472,
-0.0128511051,
-0.0906797349,
-0.0118406061,
-0.0178814363,
0.0133719621,
-0.0085945409,
0.0281480309,
-0.0551016517,
-0.01262578,
0.0247521754,
-0.0032540478,
0.0003213461,
0.0217392109,
-0.0048655528,
0.055462122,
-0.0002243779,
-0.0121056056,
0.0345768146,
-0.0030549243,
0.0541992523,
-0.0282030459,
-0.0255954396,
0.075103499,
0.0142409429,
-0.040971715,
0.0111522274,
-0.0752796084,
-0.0127926851,
-0.0461908467,
-0.0475201607,
-0.0003064192,
0.006321718,
0.0274626072,
-0.0690828934,
0.0211465675,
0.0509550571,
-0.0687269419,
-0.0074426439,
0.0422038622,
-0.0192241836,
-0.0336114541,
-0.0375242159,
0.0140875913,
-0.0241564438,
0.019636225,
0.0084587829,
0.0418978184,
0.0034676983,
-0.0038547688,
-0.0026876982,
0.0656274706,
-0.0100657037,
0.0298547894,
-0.0590820685,
0.0412586592,
-0.0450695865,
0.0490688346,
-0.0491251536,
-0.0113408538,
0.0239524394,
0.0518947281,
0.0468962453,
-0.0307617337,
-0.0225075092,
-0.0346448384,
-0.0261645131,
-0.0571718588,
-0.0120216943,
0.0171142314,
-0.0985430032,
-0.0260829255,
-0.0138188144,
0.1255272925,
0.0443113782,
0.0182157196,
-0.0734660923,
-0.1070195213,
-0.0360764526,
-0.0243507698,
0.0057313121,
-0.0820767581,
-0.0590190776,
-0.0141176805,
0.0097741121,
-0.016768463,
0.0151671423,
-0.0137764011,
-0.0338162556,
0.0454683341,
0.0231575854,
-0.0239956509,
-0.0370808728,
0.0532201417,
0.0533570796,
0.0430463925,
-0.0191363823,
0.0587614477,
0.0526027828,
-0.0309432019,
0.0471270867,
0.0253154151,
-0.009677588,
0.0274636932,
-0.0153233502,
0.002071836,
0.0400644802,
-0.0519993752,
-0.00961331,
0.0350860544,
0.010648828,
-0.0299734417,
0.0334822237,
0.0281358976,
-0.0799694806,
0.0460230745,
0.0030413878,
-0.0163108334,
-0.0171815846,
0.0285561178,
-0.059338212,
0.0129844155,
-0.0985235199,
-0.0019168296,
-0.0349157527,
0.0205586962,
-0.0144157112,
0.0271878634,
0.0036868409,
-0.0173813049,
-0.0134637384,
-0.0089259809,
-0.0163514167,
0.0126083987,
0.0163426101,
0.0496555641,
0.0468839891,
-0.0318387337,
-0.0410564132,
-0.095391266,
-0.0247577615,
0.034927249,
0.0383028053,
-0.0130853737,
-0.0069340575,
0.0222699735,
-0.0308165792,
0.0005436732,
-0.0295991004,
0.0285872445,
0.0084591946,
-0.0017717027,
0.0111183785,
-0.0279549416,
0.0370375253,
0.0458812378,
-0.0004245513,
0.0054471409,
-0.001015508,
-0.0042498349,
-0.0481971428,
-0.0086019533,
0.0127499914,
-0.024906436,
0.0324033424,
0.0290141609,
0.0088117365,
0.0090080397,
-0.0495085195,
0.0373458788,
0.0713863298,
0.0196130555,
0.0206562746,
0.0228312239,
-0.0302018877,
0.0102548823,
0.0176806375,
-0.0280133989,
0.0278054066,
0.0319603421,
-0.031072408,
-0.01897786,
0.0842377692,
-0.0478340872,
0.0093205869,
0.0335251577,
0.0481469892,
0.0026875236,
0.0318607837,
-0.0237191301,
-0.0271827094,
-0.0129580656,
0.0110765006,
-0.000538901,
0.0260204934,
0.0154030519,
0.0301512573,
-0.0669681206,
-0.0071682916,
-0.047262758,
0.0140871648,
0.0126090366,
0.0370053723,
0.0133536197,
-0.0483171865,
-0.0372887515,
-0.0178473368,
-0.0133849075,
0.0263437442,
0.0484046079,
0.0527234152,
-0.024138337,
-0.0221797004,
0.0205778629,
-0.0218510255,
0.0042974763,
0.0140777407,
0.0095597487,
-0.0427948087,
-0.0807257444,
-0.0001816671,
-0.0043255007,
-0.0038688236,
0.045865234,
-0.0366191454,
0.0068465243,
-0.0384535082,
-0.0072382316,
0.0015959666,
0.0000881812,
-0.0262991209,
-0.0826854482,
0.0343426354,
-0.0032904758,
-0.0029127535,
0.0536677726,
-0.0161154903,
0.0385092162,
0.0870500877,
-0.0030181096,
-0.04878176,
-0.0232133102,
0.0289339833,
-0.051172629,
-0.0409745649,
-0.1116970778,
0.0292264577,
0.0766731054,
0.0604243763,
0.0000215821,
-0.0105224391,
-0.0272747204,
0.0081178993,
-0.0100883562,
0.028759256,
-0.0347606689,
-0.0326098427,
-0.002985066,
-0.0170580447,
-0.0883739814,
0.0706409067,
-0.0585731305,
0.0263132732,
-0.0128110517,
-0.0328374356,
-0.013670438,
0.0197217464,
-0.0555965789,
0.0140987206,
0.0477038994,
-0.0271920655,
-0.0048201475,
-0.0446269698,
0.0173362251,
-0.0008473101,
0.0618853718,
-0.0492953472,
-0.0314764678,
-0.0178098176,
0.0179610401,
-0.0293778069,
-0.0631493479,
0.0165919308,
-0.0219951328,
0.0618146621,
-0.0549963899,
0.0307855848,
0.0012006701,
0.0630275235,
-0.0214000922,
-0.0164403506,
-0.0159497857,
-0.017843144,
-0.0192204919,
0.0202347916,
-0.0950631872,
-0.007319279,
0.0069586309,
0.0579855293,
0.0751142129,
0.0568688661,
0.0055533987,
-0.0238094386,
0.0201845262,
0.0086165732,
0.0036327771,
-0.0232241303,
0.060058374,
0.0695955679,
-0.0118938955,
-0.0321486257,
0.0376923233,
0.0273419041,
0.0148412716,
0.0418711267,
-0.0214865133,
0.0444578268,
0.0156208677,
0.0503441319,
-0.0446394235,
-0.0068796277,
0.0011544029,
0.048533842,
-0.0307501387,
-0.0101476591,
-0.0116038127,
-0.0963289216,
0.025360195,
0.0279412996,
-0.0255896263,
-0.014828153,
-0.0418267436,
-0.0071405815,
0.0657779053,
0.0216391031,
-0.0185525175,
0.0086725922,
-0.017584078,
0.0018451855,
-0.08059562,
0.0120694162,
0.0416397825,
-0.0341284238,
0.0381870344,
0.0602648295,
-0.030154055,
-0.0400178283,
0.0380788967,
0.0424620435,
-0.0212200284,
0.0182022564,
-0.0098982202,
-0.0181014147,
0.0633595735,
-0.0016870846,
0.0182752442,
0.0074714096,
-0.0025822902,
-0.0307943597,
0.0480690598,
0.0386784226,
-0.0199309625,
-0.0201371145,
-0.0335926116,
0.0052317409,
0.0232487097,
0.0152466223,
0.0079809614,
-0.0328688361,
-0.0418768749,
-0.0703696236,
-0.0450231172,
-0.0445423685,
-0.0223028045,
0.0100232037,
-0.0232085548,
-0.0323864184,
-0.0287728813,
0.0196993276,
-0.0687241927,
0.0273136273,
0.0761509016,
-0.0254927669,
-0.0048677884,
0.0037348326,
-0.0235906821,
-0.0348839611,
-0.0010985895,
0.0400209203,
-0.0374537706,
0.0432962216,
-0.0034764677,
-0.0037781328,
0.0006656839,
0.0135037424,
-0.0206039939,
-0.0851004794,
-0.0133605478,
0.0991933197,
0.0204233713,
0.0036079844,
-0.0273914747,
-0.0271626282,
0.0329425298,
0.0388086997,
-0.0515676141,
0.0277052019,
0.0859341994,
-0.0129741412,
0.0242864694,
-0.0226684939,
-0.0201435089,
-0.0136719365,
0.1055254936,
-0.0065458841,
-0.0555750579,
0.0023689331,
0.0143466592,
0.0661941096,
-0.0020272995,
-0.0211118553,
0.0220685825,
0.0550293513,
0.0573355705,
-0.0252164099,
-0.0305251256,
0.0090357568,
0.0031887237,
0.0200849883,
-0.038424056,
0.0376490802,
0.0082748784,
-0.0195123963,
-0.0340811796,
0.0176370889,
0.0448400751,
0.0219127927,
0.0770168751,
0.0709168315,
0.0256344918,
-0.0245307926,
0.0383490063,
0.0040488392,
0.028408695,
-0.0099694766,
0.0261131357,
-0.0281034689,
0.0003631831,
-0.0074115973,
0.0331679173,
-0.0349480063,
-0.0186879635,
0.0129254283,
0.0632968247,
-0.004908117,
0.0161167141,
0.0218510386,
0.0073122471,
0.0425478294,
-0.052402366,
-0.0004252004,
-0.0230080709,
-0.052893538,
0.0038125492,
-0.0164640713,
-0.0108319679,
-0.0093911299,
0.038559407,
-0.0110266665,
0.0277644917,
0.0240027905,
-0.0332301669,
-0.0304308496,
-0.0105733154,
0.0915293694,
0.0032769258,
-0.0661772415,
-0.0395555273,
-0.0706925541,
-0.0729727075,
-0.0283495467,
0.000992752,
0.0576729402,
0.008761283,
-0.0400574803,
0.0447946228,
0.0126551762,
0.0280243419,
-0.0841202885,
0.0239477474,
-0.0259894896,
-0.0579598993,
0.0293516945,
-6.227063039e-33,
0.0038764838,
-0.0193941034,
-0.0582921281,
-0.0264799967,
0.0147911217,
-0.0044261361,
-0.0641281307,
0.0312821306,
0.0022507154,
-0.0377454609,
-0.0013103408,
-0.0217302106,
0.0035595654,
-0.0077743721,
-0.0300930403,
-0.0060361219,
-0.0312977098,
0.037984129,
-0.0351533927,
0.0443828441,
0.053263858,
-0.0183837004,
0.0132036665,
-0.0543536544,
0.0397349745,
-0.0452274941,
-0.0138195232,
-0.0025650568,
-0.0350230597,
0.0547970757,
0.0339509808,
0.0084750894,
-0.00217097,
-0.0160940941,
-0.0133387567,
0.0408496819,
0.0049435375,
-0.0262172725,
0.039284043,
-0.0183404908,
0.0203056019,
-0.0553434305,
0.0043453202,
0.038304925,
0.0153065985,
-0.0173021723,
-0.0014931182,
-0.0051666712,
-0.0032095029,
-0.0160123426,
-0.0132419243,
0.0015367311,
-0.0374016315,
0.0116417641,
-0.0223228876,
-0.0196574181,
0.0056495122,
-0.0188293364,
0.0019223788,
0.0502721407,
0.0553339273,
0.0370989032,
0.0422864929,
0.0060303048,
-0.0114240367,
0.0226643663,
-0.0437340997,
-0.0074889231,
0.011550555,
0.0233401414,
0.0205082148,
0.048154071,
0.0224405173,
0.0469603278,
0.0596311353,
-0.0231389925,
-0.066927515,
0.0178899486,
0.0479871929,
0.0340278521,
0.0290435366,
-0.0131659815,
-0.0596056059,
0.0026202833,
0.0126303956,
0.0157157965,
-0.0265415143,
-0.068707265,
0.0129124476,
-0.0009032619,
-0.0342274271,
-0.0370907597,
-0.0037733389,
-0.0562823191,
-0.0085421531,
-0.0011610012,
-0.0148057379,
-0.0247883219,
-0.0296181981,
-0.0022462432,
0.0476816855,
-0.0257794112,
-0.0022381337,
-0.0855798572,
0.0337615013,
0.0034999475,
0.0102408137,
0.0355801731,
-0.0743005052,
-0.0170039888,
-0.0171078276,
0.0264553297,
-0.015035769,
0.0044431998,
-0.0143120568,
-0.0064373855,
-0.0107203042,
-0.0144414725,
0.0041239713,
-0.0393555649,
-0.0459434502,
0.0434915982,
-0.0211922117,
0.0625194684,
-0.010622086,
0.0327648297,
0.0172242131,
0.02236191,
0.0150982905,
-0.0693892539,
-0.031624727,
0.0097285863,
3.299e-7,
-0.0326458216,
-0.0208746158,
0.0501435511,
0.0359484479,
-0.0004294737,
0.0572563633,
-0.0328929313,
0.0841418579,
-0.0079553444,
-0.0604928434,
-0.0375650674,
-0.0362000763,
0.054362081,
0.0261089448,
-0.0333385356,
0.0534936748,
-0.0621642135,
0.0251015574,
-0.048000183,
0.0040888293,
0.0341390632,
0.0530716926,
-0.0216388442,
-0.0309931748,
-0.0149349682,
-0.0149742486,
-0.031855125,
0.0032108021,
0.0019795387,
0.0061626416,
-0.025232451,
0.0026465533,
0.0220601596,
0.0600793995,
-0.0517386235,
-0.0335416868,
-0.0586410128,
0.0629168451,
0.0301056765,
-0.0096791424,
-0.0256611872,
-0.0514801145,
-0.0002417381,
-0.0399345085,
0.0378041118,
0.0196032096,
-0.0189659875,
0.0085592428,
0.0095344195,
-0.0212680046,
-0.0001595288,
-0.0338472985,
0.0152917877,
0.0030380909,
0.0369521305,
0.0072697201,
0.0437538512,
-0.0432423241,
-0.0353455245,
0.01868614,
-0.0037109579,
-0.0375098772,
-0.0047988836,
0.0368721969,
0.0131312292,
-0.0081897425,
0.0136200152,
3.621516261e-34,
-0.0045638871,
-0.0543710887,
-0.0018930957,
0.0207455214,
0.0272313021,
0.0141241979,
-0.014694469,
0.0452187881,
0.0228233282,
-0.0004155835,
-0.0423263013
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.04103v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.04103v2 | Enhancing the Rationale-Input Alignment for Self-explaining Rationalization | 2023-12-07T07:37:15 | 2023-12-15T03:04:04 | Wei Liu, Haozhao Wang, Jun Wang, Zhiying Deng, YuanKai Zhang, Cheng Wang, Ruixuan Li | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Rationalization empowers deep learning models with self-explaining
capabilities through a cooperative game, where a generator selects a
semantically consistent subset of the input as a rationale, and a subsequent
predictor makes predictions based on the selected rationale. In this paper, we
discover that rationalization is prone to a problem named \emph{rationale
shift}, which arises from the algorithmic bias of the cooperative game.
Rationale shift refers to a situation where the semantics of the selected
rationale may deviate from the original input, but the predictor still produces
accurate predictions based on the deviation, resulting in a compromised
generator with misleading feedback.
To address this issue, we first demonstrate the importance of the alignment
between the rationale and the full input through both empirical observations
and theoretical analysis. Subsequently, we introduce a novel approach called
DAR (\textbf{D}iscriminatively \textbf{A}ligned \textbf{R}ationalization),
which utilizes an auxiliary module pretrained on the full input to
discriminatively align the selected rationale and the original input. We
theoretically illustrate how DAR accomplishes the desired alignment, thereby
overcoming the rationale shift problem. The experiments on two widely used
real-world benchmarks show that the proposed method significantly improves the
explanation quality (measured by the overlap between the model-selected
explanation and the human-annotated rationale) as compared to state-of-the-art
techniques. Additionally, results on two synthetic settings further validate
the effectiveness of DAR in addressing the rationale shift problem. | [
-0.0185708236,
0.0818131045,
0.0019722909,
0.0326304026,
0.0124692535,
0.0251330175,
0.0304936543,
-0.0185223911,
-0.0715742856,
0.0268857162,
0.020417653,
0.0018808312,
-0.0072568986,
0.0178583656,
0.0048423475,
-0.0540427193,
0.037078362,
-0.0130703114,
0.0264455862,
-0.0104352823,
-0.0112644052,
0.0128989238,
-0.0088526988,
0.027866669,
0.0049999934,
-0.0575927421,
-0.0447959602,
0.0241229814,
0.0141119445,
-0.0082175964,
-0.0345422477,
0.0028072288,
0.0270479564,
0.0302767102,
0.0000024466,
-0.0265339557,
-0.0458621979,
-0.0081304396,
-0.0858227611,
-0.0085547017,
-0.0238718167,
0.0261719096,
0.0156645942,
-0.0050001079,
-0.0241418406,
0.056525778,
0.0612776205,
0.0595025979,
0.05522497,
0.0599337816,
0.0142503753,
-0.0356114097,
-0.0040315166,
-0.0285868347,
-0.0389229767,
-0.0076760431,
-0.0353380516,
0.0359465964,
-0.0546584576,
0.01661052,
-0.0210060477,
-0.0075691463,
0.0467502624,
-0.0366259776,
0.0438807383,
0.0209244303,
0.0351899117,
-0.0291045271,
0.0295805242,
0.0753881559,
-0.0333496444,
-0.0333652608,
0.0317402966,
-0.0381186493,
0.0183868166,
-0.0094338031,
-0.0397398509,
0.0229016431,
0.0283929557,
0.0530552194,
0.0419393517,
0.0295216944,
0.0645687431,
0.0131295947,
-0.0349475779,
0.0395145006,
-0.0229622778,
-0.00749854,
-0.0152796004,
-0.0172283389,
-0.0112739382,
-0.0697083175,
-0.0288460348,
0.0566110425,
-0.0513507836,
0.0123544112,
-0.0029804369,
0.014131966,
-0.0119959516,
-0.0150586125,
0.0038900033,
0.0163242538,
0.013786789,
0.0375219993,
-0.0084817493,
0.0609399863,
-0.019773094,
0.0586507618,
-0.023560524,
0.0084872181,
-0.0359716304,
-0.0450850204,
-0.017336268,
0.0399621911,
-0.048605442,
-0.0047876816,
-0.0448635817,
0.0321147554,
-0.0646774024,
0.0308889039,
-0.0031574671,
0.063638255,
-0.0295487791,
-0.0287195612,
-0.0455337092,
0.0244685523,
-0.0786314756,
0.0057199756,
0.0652019233,
-0.0301624257,
-0.0254674274,
0.0064935209,
-0.0016605341,
-0.0221475512,
-0.0217582695,
0.0617888905,
-0.0214645751,
0.0216836352,
-0.0240267906,
-0.0579001009,
-0.0073131146,
-0.06368801,
0.0054322965,
-0.0047877571,
0.0060831625,
-0.0303779729,
-0.0041980017,
-0.0801634863,
-0.0085395658,
-0.0156916846,
0.0012531333,
0.1224905029,
-0.0522329584,
0.0006258931,
0.0099299205,
0.0185431466,
-0.0423467942,
0.0596559197,
0.0209585875,
0.0171604399,
0.0436956771,
-0.0593830496,
0.0214507878,
-0.0415877029,
0.0194300711,
-0.0452823639,
-0.0254352987,
0.0096594114,
-0.0699671581,
0.0813281536,
0.0494981073,
-0.0108078727,
-0.0113402316,
-0.0203924552,
0.0253061969,
0.0430043116,
0.0606352948,
0.053638041,
0.0223070886,
0.0194728877,
-0.0443808995,
0.0369994789,
-0.058070343,
0.0607432798,
-0.013570304,
-0.0022211641,
0.0047948696,
-0.0034093999,
-0.0260691978,
-0.0836985037,
0.0185676832,
-0.0186228286,
0.0187732726,
0.0201804116,
0.0361532643,
-0.0108570568,
-0.0250043347,
0.0171510018,
0.018695116,
-0.0285047572,
-0.0019581004,
-0.0674020946,
0.068610847,
0.0586680844,
0.012481736,
-0.0421100035,
-0.048166614,
-0.0108417673,
0.0247753598,
0.0175855923,
0.0483219065,
-0.0092153689,
0.0167577602,
-0.0408860184,
-0.0545424521,
-0.0693267584,
0.0218054373,
0.0034240985,
-0.0060941381,
-0.0152932974,
0.024532754,
-0.0413682498,
-0.0018240871,
0.027067082,
-0.0017935224,
-0.0582118332,
0.0097372066,
0.0315428078,
0.0370818526,
0.0451748893,
0.0238605663,
0.0127560226,
0.0102249086,
-0.0055331481,
-0.0281362515,
0.0446396135,
-0.0817891061,
-0.0002604031,
0.0283385087,
0.0064116307,
-0.0396883897,
0.0286187511,
-0.0210582111,
-0.0550284609,
0.0656933635,
-0.011144774,
-0.0360165276,
-0.0283361096,
0.0103300801,
0.0069752117,
0.0087629473,
-0.0286865104,
0.0468541794,
0.0397693366,
-0.0243776236,
0.0055248663,
0.0019469082,
0.0284840316,
-0.0577930249,
0.0653979778,
0.0274586044,
-0.0432996266,
0.0015915156,
0.0169835463,
-0.0660623387,
-0.0303915832,
0.0187517684,
0.0097590229,
-0.0054390882,
-0.0193582065,
-0.0167605821,
0.0208286308,
-0.0224381797,
0.031299036,
-0.0056096278,
-0.0226340052,
0.0214793794,
-0.0155613078,
-0.0026231871,
0.0704691634,
-0.018845005,
0.0092735244,
-0.0282979179,
0.0112549607,
-0.0075667533,
0.0385571755,
0.0083880089,
0.0615919717,
-0.0556037501,
-0.0360733382,
-0.0179841816,
-0.0148287695,
-0.0262284633,
-0.0397321954,
0.0355783924,
0.0058936477,
-0.032940276,
0.0813486427,
0.0221086685,
0.0463489592,
0.0310937371,
0.0138502894,
-0.0674002245,
0.0196731649,
-0.02561884,
0.0381551944,
-0.0269699637,
-0.0341694914,
0.0096053332,
0.0664634556,
-0.0343196802,
0.0268196315,
-0.0748578534,
0.061193198,
0.0160899125,
-0.0475131087,
-0.0316214785,
-0.052786123,
-0.0051044333,
0.0651583821,
-0.0317450427,
-0.0329007693,
0.0969083235,
-0.0143425362,
-0.0121515663,
0.0054163695,
-0.027675923,
-0.0022531222,
0.056925714,
-0.0243329685,
0.0130136991,
0.0374950282,
-0.0047924942,
-0.0377228856,
-0.0832912326,
0.0476459712,
-0.0075769434,
0.0702837929,
-0.0530331954,
-0.0354778841,
-0.000728853,
-0.0383564793,
-0.0507578477,
-0.0535113215,
-0.0149181979,
0.0084563931,
-0.0194348413,
-0.0354181007,
0.003529954,
-0.0212711226,
-0.0067645791,
0.0169952475,
-0.0101459902,
0.0041861287,
-0.0028051615,
-0.0081516206,
0.0392950103,
0.0752548277,
0.0379784182,
-0.0078315903,
0.0957665145,
0.0169589203,
-0.000300669,
-0.0601337068,
-0.0812551156,
-0.0057616462,
-0.0217699483,
-0.0267181136,
-0.0124664465,
-0.0028686645,
0.0847161785,
-0.042475149,
0.0170493722,
0.0925377235,
0.001898649,
0.014711244,
0.0081169959,
-0.0242902525,
0.0307942051,
0.0058567491,
-0.0104983533,
-0.0354704335,
-0.0443205647,
0.0298557151,
0.0362261832,
0.0324010402,
-0.0107285604,
0.0039169979,
-0.0733635426,
0.0528713539,
-0.0038383608,
-0.0075002322,
-0.0197201967,
-0.0233995039,
-0.0294427089,
-0.057420142,
0.0053926134,
0.0043118908,
0.0279625561,
0.0026556309,
0.0371209793,
-0.0524064451,
0.0176809635,
-0.0148224402,
-0.036403317,
0.0488902442,
0.0529130325,
0.0516461842,
0.008956193,
-0.0480984636,
0.0008159387,
-0.0045909374,
0.0384520702,
0.0049043959,
0.061044842,
0.0164948814,
-0.0227619018,
-0.0001155655,
0.0448058695,
-0.010238477,
-0.0399874114,
-0.0353811979,
0.0638154522,
-0.0252058152,
-0.0083708372,
-0.0108644115,
0.0043346505,
-0.0027375454,
0.0626189262,
0.0360916033,
0.0064306566,
-0.068118453,
-0.0241666641,
-0.0004048824,
-0.1014749706,
-0.0002934058,
-0.0475052856,
0.0379693769,
-0.0037678138,
-0.0307632331,
-0.0389075466,
-0.043169722,
0.0115945814,
-0.0189662427,
0.0034609952,
-0.0267061368,
-0.0093961181,
-0.0441897586,
0.0532932542,
-0.0140878074,
-0.0038605365,
0.0386014432,
0.0146898394,
-0.0135754682,
-0.0699063316,
-0.0018778628,
-0.0039084749,
0.046418827,
-0.0278945882,
-0.0061498554,
0.0301647149,
0.0246218108,
0.0959128514,
-0.0172302872,
-0.0199551638,
-0.0019354916,
-0.003183926,
0.0045478158,
-0.0359428748,
0.0795941278,
0.0040293313,
-0.0099482909,
0.049193833,
-0.013132385,
0.0122673968,
0.0168727878,
0.0038308462,
-0.05955768,
-0.0109395571,
0.0421527661,
-0.0162030123,
0.0557270758,
-0.0028998817,
0.0098888837,
-0.037738353,
0.0071849618,
-0.0155394245,
0.0104387123,
-0.0237548482,
0.0024673962,
0.0316542462,
-0.030782897,
0.0197494514,
-0.0275677927,
-0.0300347377,
-0.0032660076,
-0.0129239624,
0.0231452286,
-0.0232759453,
0.03213403,
-0.0286926664,
0.0389176048,
0.0142688379,
0.0370029137,
-0.0139940139,
0.0329529382,
-0.0036763453,
0.0480677411,
0.03483776,
0.0232991409,
-0.0212834645,
-0.0036902442,
-0.0666334555,
-0.0699599758,
0.0290276483,
-0.0260614604,
0.0334541388,
-0.0225452445,
0.0314500593,
0.0269345175,
-0.0144756492,
0.0283764247,
0.0630012527,
0.0387140214,
-0.0248593073,
0.0266245585,
0.0211645626,
-0.0352791175,
-0.0233232062,
0.0318735577,
-0.0197966788,
0.0155185582,
-0.0141713591,
-0.0045905598,
-0.0201074462,
-0.0439335518,
-0.0145660555,
0.0246136505,
-0.0210317653,
-0.0326360464,
-0.0186712351,
-0.0640208423,
-0.0280703325,
0.0235686153,
-0.0132857095,
-0.007750982,
0.0299722385,
0.05981059,
-0.0324426889,
-0.0417840034,
0.0000386456,
0.039334029,
-0.0445764884,
0.0194822159,
-0.0084385965,
-6.791396571e-33,
0.0034634338,
-0.0324324667,
0.0202965792,
-0.0399419554,
-0.0196414925,
0.0077369949,
-0.0475239307,
-0.005800324,
-0.0369246118,
0.0655776858,
-0.0215483736,
0.0371801741,
0.015193006,
-0.0115074459,
0.0037772306,
-0.0319179669,
0.0509187728,
0.0142150922,
-0.0214151423,
0.0078472644,
0.0226671379,
-0.0037846609,
0.0288935918,
-0.0917879194,
0.0188527703,
0.0362837687,
-0.0420121439,
0.0344457179,
-0.0137624685,
0.0625940114,
-0.0048284759,
0.0069813468,
0.0043621995,
-0.064561002,
-0.0166916531,
0.0336615406,
-0.0916299745,
-0.0164899249,
0.0065592499,
-0.0080441833,
-0.0806705952,
-0.0605428293,
0.0528820977,
0.0119994851,
0.0037816542,
-0.0265869349,
0.014190414,
-0.0272743981,
-0.0062076952,
0.0284216553,
-0.0427870043,
0.0193108004,
-0.0769295916,
-0.0306538828,
0.0385838449,
0.001806419,
0.0140295653,
0.0330069363,
-0.0348585695,
-0.0148226833,
0.0271224361,
-0.0096413111,
0.0851989388,
0.0174313188,
-0.0197752826,
0.0787305981,
0.0239992179,
-0.0149489958,
-0.0790892914,
0.0016050084,
-0.049795907,
0.0733427554,
0.1122251973,
0.0518666916,
0.0725554824,
0.0086480975,
-0.0860725194,
0.0161626264,
-0.0509224087,
0.028709339,
0.0097860573,
0.0370077603,
-0.0278710648,
0.0010447038,
-0.0376667902,
-0.0162980016,
-0.0316715389,
-0.0470922627,
0.0081096077,
0.0108432444,
-0.0470501557,
0.0409906581,
-0.0166081507,
-0.0502643026,
0.0456919707,
0.0156136854,
-0.0035379673,
-0.0174526647,
0.0128662158,
-0.0238227695,
-0.0020177069,
-0.0178988893,
0.0177317411,
0.0258861333,
0.03913128,
0.023131432,
0.032427296,
-0.000192884,
-0.0061610141,
-0.0077473656,
-0.0510905199,
-0.0117061893,
-0.0324103348,
0.0219244976,
0.0340840816,
0.0014733685,
-0.028708227,
0.020140741,
0.007254784,
0.0172658656,
-0.0121107679,
-0.0097700944,
0.002180499,
0.0177471749,
-0.0079528363,
-0.0256837662,
-0.0042726276,
-0.0226189308,
0.0327007994,
-0.0663856268,
-0.0274939854,
-0.008697032,
3.021e-7,
0.0126472022,
0.0007223407,
0.03592024,
-0.0461558104,
0.0059548663,
0.0619667619,
-0.0053698965,
-0.0235191416,
-0.0299072322,
-0.0232665613,
0.0341405943,
0.050004594,
0.0437632613,
0.0201349948,
-0.0149204563,
-0.0091578653,
-0.0410241336,
0.0192071833,
-0.0092031257,
0.0071757361,
0.0607393607,
0.0459391885,
0.0231233146,
-0.0316435397,
0.0401936658,
-0.008778994,
0.0215505715,
-0.0374962464,
0.0234995168,
0.0154912304,
0.0483455136,
-0.0242435001,
-0.0103895543,
-0.007415948,
-0.0130249411,
0.0039104368,
-0.0391277336,
0.0514059737,
-0.0382083766,
-0.0618460216,
-0.059290912,
-0.0395298116,
0.0571950935,
-0.0677659661,
0.0685590729,
-0.0362605192,
-0.0469432138,
-0.0153130768,
-0.0612981878,
-0.0019030957,
0.0026609874,
0.0225570854,
0.0078526353,
-0.0010363987,
-0.0128629571,
-0.0054860725,
0.0128279747,
-0.0889923498,
-0.0473091118,
-0.0193934366,
-0.026768906,
0.0387167111,
-0.0255551431,
0.0228977799,
0.0808085799,
-0.0304500386,
0.0032766119,
2.478081911e-34,
0.0152677819,
0.0320014618,
0.0086535616,
0.0168116428,
0.0454343073,
0.0203302484,
-0.0183653794,
-0.0115716076,
0.0603425428,
0.0130707771,
-0.0139364563
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.04068v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.04068v1 | Making Translators Privacy-aware on the User's Side | 2023-12-07T06:23:17 | 2023-12-07T06:23:17 | Ryoma Sato | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | We propose PRISM to enable users of machine translation systems to preserve
the privacy of data on their own initiative. There is a growing demand to apply
machine translation systems to data that require privacy protection. While
several machine translation engines claim to prioritize privacy, the extent and
specifics of such protection are largely ambiguous. First, there is often a
lack of clarity on how and to what degree the data is protected. Even if
service providers believe they have sufficient safeguards in place,
sophisticated adversaries might still extract sensitive information. Second,
vulnerabilities may exist outside of these protective measures, such as within
communication channels, potentially leading to data leakage. As a result, users
are hesitant to utilize machine translation engines for data demanding high
levels of privacy protection, thereby missing out on their benefits. PRISM
resolves this problem. Instead of relying on the translation service to keep
data safe, PRISM provides the means to protect data on the user's side. This
approach ensures that even machine translation engines with inadequate privacy
measures can be used securely. For platforms already equipped with privacy
safeguards, PRISM acts as an additional protection layer, reinforcing their
security furthermore. PRISM adds these privacy features without significantly
compromising translation accuracy. Our experiments demonstrate the
effectiveness of PRISM using real-world translators, T5 and ChatGPT
(GPT-3.5-turbo), and the datasets with two languages. PRISM effectively
balances privacy protection with translation accuracy. | [
0.0484298132,
0.0704522207,
-0.0398854241,
0.0496950783,
-0.0515098833,
0.0102625536,
0.0804320946,
0.0078177107,
0.0078598512,
0.0038322636,
-0.0052892878,
-0.019809505,
0.0412930325,
-0.0049185511,
0.0160694811,
-0.0299238414,
0.0271383096,
-0.0044774013,
-0.0140332207,
-0.0181740019,
-0.0081283143,
0.028392842,
0.0295281522,
0.0437172204,
0.0268135779,
-0.0190197416,
-0.0133964224,
0.0188411362,
0.0194942635,
0.0240135137,
-0.0345035084,
0.0234860517,
-0.0045045991,
0.1017099395,
0.0000018077,
-0.0359322391,
-0.0415531285,
0.0537927002,
-0.0246340055,
0.0051691043,
0.0394371562,
-0.0483066551,
-0.0292168502,
0.0232659336,
-0.0412606485,
0.0120251039,
0.0477475934,
-0.0182451345,
0.0799353793,
0.0533292331,
-0.021834597,
-0.0408882461,
-0.0373365991,
-0.0108218221,
0.017825,
-0.0615603887,
-0.0226618964,
-0.0585932024,
-0.0589107946,
0.0538165905,
0.0281471703,
0.0556666218,
0.0137242107,
0.0233796649,
-0.0521123484,
0.0152883576,
-0.0217179991,
-0.0614354797,
-0.0144036012,
0.0319226198,
0.0141941486,
-0.0095962705,
0.0149520617,
0.034746673,
0.0208907556,
-0.000010886,
0.0150086218,
0.0237060357,
-0.0419883616,
-0.0185754728,
-0.0075916918,
0.0296402425,
0.0120068779,
0.0067207329,
-0.0238119997,
-0.0019034138,
0.0049328571,
-0.0185140632,
-0.0218960568,
-0.0020125809,
0.0479098707,
-0.0290840007,
0.074906081,
-0.0299801677,
0.0121590402,
0.0185454655,
-0.0591756031,
-0.0789766759,
0.0136131989,
-0.0752069131,
-0.0510062426,
0.0614887476,
0.0193383936,
0.017744692,
-0.0128759416,
0.0302678142,
-0.0219700392,
0.0144233853,
-0.0041623409,
-0.0385110378,
0.0126370564,
0.0186680686,
-0.0206600334,
0.0076448503,
-0.0598099269,
0.0218336638,
-0.0460532643,
0.0377396792,
0.0098190568,
0.0344042554,
-0.0265248623,
-0.0211806968,
-0.0410214514,
-0.0190069806,
0.006824553,
-0.0128032872,
-0.0160810445,
-0.0271432996,
0.0048814174,
-0.0677879527,
-0.005817885,
-0.0323551223,
-0.0127723059,
-0.0142915295,
-0.0405232124,
0.074951984,
0.0306384508,
-0.0003320053,
-0.0116468519,
-0.0606108122,
0.0215602499,
-0.0421230197,
-0.0248548407,
-0.0391284376,
0.0473018736,
0.0328860134,
-0.0028842483,
-0.052735772,
0.0028084777,
0.0305246394,
-0.0192136839,
0.0809404999,
0.0060111722,
-0.0070418678,
-0.0041430276,
0.0409941263,
-0.0165300015,
0.0270808376,
0.0276497491,
0.0449280962,
0.0569548272,
-0.0144296456,
0.025782384,
0.025421476,
0.0046976325,
0.0162747987,
-0.0140770786,
0.0270043928,
-0.0172263328,
-0.0361071788,
-0.020120861,
0.0595238023,
0.0232062861,
-0.0036678712,
0.093169935,
0.076697357,
-0.0080985362,
0.0613097735,
-0.0537374727,
0.0436435118,
-0.0246828087,
-0.033023078,
-0.0580767617,
0.004371196,
-0.0458569042,
-0.0499766991,
-0.0357634313,
0.0405419618,
0.0101674609,
0.0107762422,
0.0125702061,
-0.0372507907,
0.0760589167,
0.021042319,
-0.0056990436,
0.0137427161,
0.0237492584,
0.0444522612,
-0.0458659604,
-0.058085233,
-0.0241050236,
-0.0428373069,
-0.0308948625,
0.0815243125,
0.0443181619,
0.0276790448,
0.0088098757,
-0.0336519852,
-0.0370099656,
0.0166832488,
0.029457625,
0.0263197273,
0.0625745356,
-0.0198471453,
-0.0479460806,
0.0653309152,
0.0017047212,
-0.0159942564,
0.0219043493,
0.0439249687,
0.0480080657,
-0.0220394637,
-0.0140308104,
0.0090626506,
0.0103910938,
-0.0027034557,
0.0576023869,
0.0387764499,
0.00724142,
0.0461888313,
0.006719036,
-0.0090008331,
0.0098959617,
0.038814202,
0.0171241313,
0.0461468808,
-0.0018100267,
0.0245725252,
-0.0250898991,
-0.0461448207,
0.0204862989,
0.0226711519,
-0.0410421416,
0.0081597045,
0.0054062647,
-0.0200804323,
0.0173606947,
-0.0273146126,
0.0182246808,
-0.0250374936,
0.0372332484,
-0.0224296357,
-0.0146067766,
-0.0194948092,
-0.0293102842,
-0.0679444373,
-0.0242240317,
0.0564248636,
0.0209432039,
-0.0231975485,
0.0285203345,
0.0085197864,
0.0622420162,
0.0300745312,
0.0260947961,
-0.0305626262,
-0.0004019385,
-0.0258967541,
0.0152291581,
-0.0203316361,
0.0433878712,
0.0421587788,
0.0800704509,
-0.0163706895,
-0.042700924,
-0.0410947427,
-0.0216389261,
-0.0368626118,
0.0195099767,
0.0302473959,
0.0048074424,
-0.0181654077,
0.0342139937,
0.000583642,
0.0092750508,
0.0082012145,
0.008883941,
-0.0585838929,
-0.0291944072,
-0.0123423422,
-0.0193511304,
-0.0296243839,
0.0137353381,
-0.0641510114,
0.0091021769,
0.0105726905,
-0.0280820541,
0.0144520104,
0.0033844109,
-0.0001942154,
0.0226503611,
0.017474927,
-0.0238386951,
-0.0180642921,
-0.0109226946,
-0.0282145999,
-0.0130513925,
-0.0312547535,
0.0219524819,
-0.0261938218,
0.0300374366,
-0.0048930072,
-0.045799017,
0.0185996573,
-0.0317869484,
-0.0137792276,
-0.0305850729,
0.0237718206,
-0.0101336176,
0.0290443674,
-0.0169954393,
-0.0426987223,
0.0641401634,
-0.0078187995,
-0.0056282547,
-0.0449788906,
-0.0152913714,
-0.0094092563,
0.0641415268,
-0.0438284166,
0.0511263199,
0.0007645312,
-0.0388077982,
0.0238390602,
0.0215952098,
0.0604269914,
-0.0504386202,
-0.0100928238,
-0.0422409922,
-0.0428352877,
0.009370001,
-0.0219447259,
-0.0335037969,
-0.0408216305,
-0.0012724815,
-0.0302861594,
0.0134824663,
-0.0742603913,
-0.0081716878,
-0.0085938266,
0.0658264235,
0.0232516304,
-0.0149406074,
-0.0068421913,
-0.0123920608,
-0.0441587456,
-0.0636450127,
-0.0637116358,
0.0030322678,
-0.0191366244,
0.0279187243,
0.0714252219,
0.0502087437,
-0.0111803785,
0.0184446219,
-0.0485017747,
0.0029964857,
0.0019414501,
-0.0319454633,
0.0173223428,
0.0547250248,
-0.0371830799,
0.0257031117,
0.0387358554,
0.0152858449,
-0.0552789979,
-0.0351015441,
0.0098812906,
-0.0034912745,
0.0014599408,
-0.0056332606,
-0.1138188168,
0.0100713288,
0.0291693117,
0.0983740613,
-0.0318384133,
-0.0068240259,
-0.0360194594,
-0.0236260127,
0.0083029298,
0.0448247641,
-0.0152536882,
-0.0304592624,
-0.0285915062,
-0.0207875408,
-0.0016150817,
-0.0000667248,
-0.074586764,
0.0324776843,
-0.0241064932,
-0.0182670131,
-0.0180512555,
-0.0231337771,
-0.0252910443,
-0.0631018281,
-0.0127790039,
0.0560719781,
0.0335761458,
-0.0004034438,
-0.0186671764,
-0.016567573,
0.0253286045,
-0.0509381369,
-0.0012981646,
0.0412234925,
0.0170054231,
-0.007380364,
-0.0153280301,
0.0141329579,
0.0128934206,
0.0156399142,
0.0198272206,
0.0093914196,
-0.0505815856,
0.0207565296,
0.0200310107,
-0.0190412141,
0.0356473662,
0.0376394875,
-0.0276633352,
-0.0254575238,
-0.0143451607,
-0.0671602637,
0.0125151258,
-0.0387716182,
0.0091000041,
0.0309166405,
-0.0259881336,
-0.1067957059,
-0.0475803427,
-0.0033596251,
-0.0358805582,
0.0127473781,
0.0495202839,
0.0168242082,
0.0464235507,
-0.0118234847,
-0.0115656732,
-0.0313330963,
-0.0585337766,
0.0424046777,
0.0002370009,
0.0262945313,
-0.0207694564,
0.0017621632,
0.0090033198,
0.0625085756,
-0.0646754801,
-0.0504834764,
0.000110391,
0.0049883318,
0.0219123531,
0.0235277563,
-0.0843939707,
-0.0442889333,
0.0364817977,
0.0562089682,
-0.051663775,
-0.0506220125,
0.0663274229,
-0.0431614369,
-0.0142345829,
0.0106434524,
-0.0029182059,
-0.0599378385,
0.0050784531,
-0.0521977171,
-0.0107194781,
-0.0745797381,
0.0118349409,
0.0567604266,
0.0178433694,
0.007914667,
0.0399029814,
-0.0126628317,
0.0052566156,
-0.0261407122,
-0.0182694122,
0.0072217463,
-0.0159104876,
0.0426446535,
-0.0098417103,
0.0650975853,
0.0104225958,
-0.0173101686,
-0.0417275727,
0.000863941,
0.0311618652,
-0.0232848655,
0.0400648005,
0.0210374892,
0.0154831894,
-0.041113466,
0.0447643921,
0.0400508456,
0.033876501,
-0.053978458,
0.0325177126,
-0.0010867789,
0.0000029147,
0.0128540974,
0.0583374463,
-0.0370742194,
-0.0390138999,
-0.0058433549,
0.0297463313,
0.0038733864,
0.0567907207,
0.0384846739,
-0.042268116,
0.0116340742,
-0.0195210408,
0.010147403,
-0.0076718847,
-0.0196038149,
-0.048165407,
-0.0433845781,
-0.0085758287,
0.0570020489,
0.0161198303,
-0.038582243,
0.0034558356,
-0.0157933421,
-0.0768771544,
-0.0377835035,
-0.0076152626,
-0.0300840065,
0.0182711631,
-0.0389921367,
-0.0522989817,
-0.0253984723,
-0.0595687591,
-0.0450658835,
-0.0105002001,
0.0222945567,
-0.018140465,
0.0061710738,
0.0463586934,
-0.0169226378,
-0.0251037832,
-0.0947911367,
0.024362307,
0.0085932612,
0.0065072277,
-0.0025916379,
-4.977684828e-33,
0.024299318,
-0.0071653621,
-0.0249679834,
0.0188901089,
0.0423693284,
0.0004324838,
-0.0205882546,
-0.0034347035,
-0.0308052804,
-0.0285162162,
-0.0422772951,
0.0112565104,
0.0351019241,
-0.0175534785,
-0.0168855842,
0.0220667664,
0.0519008115,
0.0042559667,
-0.027830638,
0.0522250496,
0.0254624914,
0.0041724415,
0.0638120025,
-0.1105422005,
0.0783464462,
-0.0157848839,
-0.0750800744,
-0.0077670864,
-0.0304247886,
0.0212609954,
0.0107438266,
0.0057877316,
-0.0019499167,
-0.0123597179,
-0.0216804836,
0.0657715946,
-0.0714731067,
-0.0034702579,
0.0100507811,
0.0523585603,
0.0360351242,
-0.0607987307,
0.0064535323,
-0.0619734265,
-0.0256209262,
0.0098165935,
-0.0374884196,
0.0006674339,
-0.0130535504,
-0.0199831109,
0.0166135244,
0.0063718301,
-0.0215752199,
0.0080204895,
0.0687269047,
0.052313637,
-0.0084327804,
-0.0570402779,
-0.0468813777,
0.0525246374,
0.0029072319,
-0.0494764745,
0.0519695804,
0.0062685702,
-0.0071820458,
-0.0129584568,
0.0559195615,
-0.012275205,
0.0164176431,
-0.0131249614,
-0.0002889564,
0.0013457546,
0.0163466912,
0.0504579656,
0.0054099807,
-0.0745105892,
0.0002830804,
0.0681448504,
-0.0049361852,
-0.0006841904,
0.0659126192,
0.000530889,
-0.0969166309,
-0.0061665443,
-0.0323976651,
-0.0494206734,
-0.0344356261,
-0.028450748,
-0.0323319845,
0.0082830349,
-0.0516598001,
0.0259591863,
0.0310790371,
-0.0474776737,
0.0038745296,
0.0249105319,
0.009878777,
-0.0280775372,
-0.0121881953,
0.0388061777,
0.0222361106,
-0.024033729,
0.0144856209,
-0.0220209975,
0.0078353751,
-0.023974251,
0.0405300111,
0.0139981424,
-0.0586493723,
-0.0178710502,
-0.014158288,
0.0521628521,
0.008904417,
0.0082171373,
0.0184601676,
-0.0023005919,
0.0049647237,
0.0110326177,
0.0432657264,
0.0243526399,
-0.055599317,
0.0347890891,
-0.0028636286,
0.0223248955,
-0.0020691478,
0.0091009028,
-0.0083572036,
0.0220728014,
0.0977764353,
0.0263059288,
-0.0243341606,
-0.0346406437,
2.6e-7,
0.0229545999,
0.0008353869,
-0.0109377382,
0.016491184,
0.0077933809,
0.0833496451,
0.0203452073,
0.0870372057,
-0.0352840498,
0.0440076478,
0.0022344338,
-0.0138040353,
0.0958706886,
0.0750150681,
-0.0386444889,
-0.0252907835,
0.0049845302,
0.0258943308,
-0.0650388822,
0.041784253,
0.0613897741,
0.0727400482,
0.0525116622,
-0.0254868623,
-0.0239813086,
-0.0347433612,
0.0081434427,
-0.0291471686,
-0.0380723439,
-0.0481591858,
0.044353798,
0.1199258268,
0.008482866,
0.0038092721,
-0.0002344413,
-0.0148300491,
-0.0316080824,
0.0955675766,
0.0173865594,
0.015585321,
0.0095907422,
-0.077013813,
-0.0053046923,
-0.0364271775,
0.0291354675,
0.0358916335,
-0.0176611673,
0.0378568098,
0.0334961563,
-0.0402609929,
0.0508499034,
-0.0301384237,
-0.0406684801,
0.0183954462,
0.0424545147,
0.0087645175,
-0.0214524325,
-0.0443037637,
-0.0011368578,
-0.0374865569,
0.0203550272,
-0.0167270955,
0.01262582,
0.0549433492,
-0.0094820037,
0.0460818484,
0.07370013,
1.989862373e-34,
-0.0120810131,
-0.0161602683,
-0.0092281057,
0.0040684887,
0.0595911369,
0.0004012897,
0.0481467322,
-0.0074036247,
0.0108167268,
-0.0026775731,
-0.0188243706
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.04059v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.04059v1 | Comparing Large Language Model AI and Human-Generated Coaching Messages for Behavioral Weight Loss | 2023-12-07T05:45:24 | 2023-12-07T05:45:24 | Zhuoran Huang, Michael P. Berry, Christina Chwyl, Gary Hsieh, Jing Wei, Evan M. Forman | cs.CL | cs.CL | Automated coaching messages for weight control can save time and costs, but
their repetitive, generic nature may limit their effectiveness compared to
human coaching. Large language model (LLM) based artificial intelligence (AI)
chatbots, like ChatGPT, could offer more personalized and novel messages to
address repetition with their data-processing abilities. While LLM AI
demonstrates promise to encourage healthier lifestyles, studies have yet to
examine the feasibility and acceptability of LLM-based BWL coaching. 87 adults
in a weight-loss trial rated ten coaching messages' helpfulness (five
human-written, five ChatGPT-generated) using a 5-point Likert scale, providing
additional open-ended feedback to justify their ratings. Participants also
identified which messages they believed were AI-generated. The evaluation
occurred in two phases: messages in Phase 1 were perceived as impersonal and
negative, prompting revisions for Phase 2 messages. In Phase 1, AI-generated
messages were rated less helpful than human-written ones, with 66 percent
receiving a helpfulness rating of 3 or higher. However, in Phase 2, the AI
messages matched the human-written ones regarding helpfulness, with 82% scoring
three or above. Additionally, 50% were misidentified as human-written,
suggesting AI's sophistication in mimicking human-generated content. A thematic
analysis of open-ended feedback revealed that participants appreciated AI's
empathy and personalized suggestions but found them more formulaic, less
authentic, and too data-focused. This study reveals the preliminary feasibility
and acceptability of LLM AIs, like ChatGPT, in crafting potentially effective
weight control coaching messages. Our findings also underscore areas for future
enhancement. | [
0.1089589745,
0.049228169,
-0.0051437928,
-0.0143216103,
-0.0024365995,
0.0256375913,
-0.0005354224,
0.0398550108,
0.0534397103,
0.0014773392,
0.0119833108,
0.0317558758,
-0.0277799163,
0.0334299468,
0.0048863543,
-0.0259222947,
-0.0200378709,
0.0394835398,
0.0842199028,
-0.0014730404,
0.0265912618,
0.0067012892,
0.007261287,
0.0568181761,
-0.0463161506,
-0.0099392487,
0.0282693319,
0.0298446603,
-0.0177012682,
-0.073496215,
0.0421973839,
0.0258423276,
-0.0085507445,
-0.0080280229,
0.0000021583,
0.0044257408,
0.0336572602,
0.0102917207,
-0.071860157,
0.0142190931,
0.1065747812,
0.0178695042,
0.0112749534,
0.0151051488,
-0.0344243832,
0.0552576222,
0.060393896,
0.0506031364,
0.044527825,
0.0466491245,
-0.0104972897,
-0.0160017628,
-0.0476638973,
0.0079288483,
0.0115667153,
-0.0093335742,
-0.0042488575,
0.023333203,
0.0049046772,
-0.0030387377,
0.0155304344,
0.0267696977,
-0.0109460969,
0.0155326994,
-0.0124115944,
0.0372098722,
-0.0475654975,
-0.0616618134,
-0.0141705433,
0.0484220199,
0.041559577,
0.0101500964,
-0.0097149368,
-0.0243313406,
0.0410560183,
-0.0170086231,
-0.0085693635,
-0.0004957895,
0.0192242526,
0.0103818057,
-0.0346416198,
0.0255984403,
0.0169629697,
-0.0090535032,
0.0215094946,
0.0103890235,
-0.0030169415,
-0.0388507321,
0.0059488988,
0.0008776964,
0.0133259352,
-0.0573106185,
-0.0009111381,
0.0371713042,
0.0087088523,
0.0103187598,
0.0104722222,
0.004661697,
0.0366427638,
-0.0469022803,
0.0726592168,
0.0519743115,
-0.018561257,
-0.0438225567,
0.0497596897,
0.0549997613,
0.0245917216,
0.0232126266,
-0.0617247447,
0.0756601393,
-0.0852328464,
-0.0124074034,
-0.024654394,
0.0247651394,
0.0068224631,
-0.0449705645,
-0.0816437081,
-0.030836774,
-0.0587459356,
-0.0077986228,
-0.0100612938,
0.0289859511,
0.0297494475,
0.0184730645,
-0.0291336998,
0.0428015403,
-0.0194840487,
0.0410809405,
0.0161803849,
-0.0384618491,
0.0205270834,
0.0411799066,
-0.006920821,
0.0012915041,
0.0570837744,
0.0305133574,
-0.0204287767,
-0.0420646816,
-0.0040257787,
0.0059548104,
-0.0782150403,
-0.0391354598,
-0.0271692816,
-0.0407739431,
0.0224209037,
-0.0523542464,
0.0324331857,
-0.0112867067,
0.0516262203,
0.0339173973,
-0.0319985151,
0.0286309645,
-0.017602561,
0.0422013626,
0.0227150582,
0.0206301548,
0.0000222041,
-0.0044606593,
0.0283777136,
0.0418242253,
0.0078476761,
0.0000612838,
0.0007258934,
0.0183196869,
0.016146671,
-0.0041423328,
-0.0114701902,
-0.0272610616,
-0.0156873371,
0.0577630997,
-0.0542738475,
0.0668743104,
-0.0192923732,
0.0773385912,
0.1137626022,
0.0945583731,
0.0080292402,
0.0477914996,
0.0131783346,
0.0266258921,
0.0364879891,
-0.0065594483,
-0.0423075818,
-0.0106533738,
-0.0463586599,
-0.0245553404,
0.0161930397,
-0.0179566368,
-0.0304282587,
-0.0394978225,
-0.0169528201,
-0.0560946837,
0.0542951412,
-0.004959818,
0.0132011492,
-0.0027206549,
-0.0140756248,
-0.0307965763,
0.0043649478,
-0.0404782332,
-0.0210925248,
-0.0566893481,
0.0116016483,
0.0939394534,
0.0068434393,
0.0026879273,
0.0254212078,
-0.0140004018,
0.0022270004,
0.0264126714,
0.0386692099,
0.0192847885,
-0.0349387638,
-0.0157027245,
-0.0173998792,
-0.002246846,
-0.0059860679,
-0.0262618698,
-0.0256574731,
0.0372805558,
-0.0446402021,
0.087933965,
-0.0960105062,
0.0261966456,
0.0036605729,
-0.0378769003,
0.0148997754,
-0.0302376263,
0.0217791479,
0.0721015185,
0.0114358449,
0.0329901278,
0.0039668093,
-0.0106348377,
-0.0803443491,
0.0273788124,
0.0163067132,
0.0375731289,
-0.0061930269,
-0.0134894913,
0.0087286364,
-0.0021158755,
0.0050914632,
-0.0117651345,
-0.0071349284,
-0.0583205782,
0.0241846908,
-0.0011822665,
0.0115892086,
-0.0001601878,
0.0155829238,
-0.0100283455,
-0.007215119,
0.0136698792,
-0.0405169651,
-0.0043518436,
-0.044938311,
-0.0346667357,
-0.0205557533,
0.000254044,
0.0104822787,
-0.0049607637,
0.0086965133,
0.0563399345,
0.0638450012,
-0.0338117667,
-0.0221064389,
-0.1075544283,
-0.0013489471,
0.0052723014,
-0.016715128,
0.0001644518,
-0.0064013917,
0.0096017625,
0.001316212,
-0.0602662265,
-0.0080731241,
-0.0153223965,
0.0381277725,
0.0052934228,
0.0060960907,
-0.0019200649,
-0.0027013638,
0.0182379503,
0.0033723321,
0.0086488808,
0.0746366158,
-0.0148088364,
-0.0407237858,
-0.0265259407,
-0.0465557501,
-0.0331649333,
0.0033859056,
-0.0537422113,
0.0127971694,
0.0445161834,
0.0485606268,
0.0438645482,
0.0180150028,
0.0113155339,
0.0330701098,
0.0395085551,
-0.055405505,
-0.0116714397,
-0.045673877,
-0.0396748297,
-0.0473096892,
-0.094932206,
0.0374148227,
-0.0225704536,
0.0389421992,
0.0584263317,
-0.0542651862,
0.0556499697,
0.0041873665,
-0.0275380071,
-0.0303969085,
0.0055360207,
-0.0258522909,
0.0128909647,
0.0294766165,
-0.0418571047,
0.0318842083,
-0.0086944429,
-0.0104728118,
-0.0069596078,
-0.0478079282,
0.0147735905,
-0.0097183669,
-0.0011551159,
0.0491142459,
0.0595720112,
0.0166032948,
0.0384742878,
-0.032732714,
-0.0085036205,
-0.0188359916,
-0.0145030729,
-0.056482818,
0.0075872238,
0.0438439809,
-0.0015166901,
-0.0165155977,
-0.0156227769,
-0.0587815233,
-0.0299631432,
0.0563393161,
0.0045006792,
-0.064659968,
-0.0238165352,
0.0379013009,
0.0105947228,
-0.0083540902,
-0.0087458976,
0.0218099058,
-0.0723653436,
0.0282632709,
-0.0030207918,
0.019042572,
-0.0117377816,
0.0461400524,
0.0392543897,
-0.0426035449,
-0.0129583301,
-0.0025212851,
0.0074095558,
0.0204533022,
0.0331489407,
0.0306982398,
0.0162897855,
0.0465581194,
0.0219120104,
-0.0115295416,
0.0747537762,
-0.0077162706,
-0.0634588897,
0.0353723019,
-0.0035772037,
-0.023786597,
-0.0212453809,
-0.0161189921,
-0.0799061805,
-0.0350360461,
-0.0202338453,
0.0332132727,
-0.0718274042,
0.02784645,
-0.0081402212,
-0.0399977304,
-0.0081753964,
0.0135316812,
0.0262321196,
-0.0196773037,
0.012058327,
-0.0340169184,
-0.0308256429,
0.0031850114,
-0.0288430788,
-0.0091056563,
0.0270419456,
0.0038576911,
-0.0614793673,
-0.0145819904,
0.0302579161,
-0.0345717557,
0.0828044489,
0.0770969167,
0.061608132,
-0.0259162579,
-0.0245065019,
0.0310236998,
0.0460066609,
0.0053132013,
-0.0026354154,
0.041484423,
-0.0208167862,
0.0132400449,
-0.0521792695,
0.0587239489,
-0.0160277244,
-0.0163233504,
0.0515145212,
0.056049116,
0.0193990879,
-0.0548777133,
-0.0179625675,
0.0327551141,
0.0318955965,
0.0577504076,
-0.0129039306,
-0.060010083,
0.0170324277,
0.0149452789,
0.0071055382,
0.0868565142,
-0.0574596971,
0.0122391665,
-0.0676914155,
0.0366109535,
-0.020811189,
-0.053735327,
-0.0016660192,
-0.0070456215,
0.0011915248,
0.0014726085,
0.012294312,
0.026250856,
0.024740234,
0.0241696164,
-0.0256890133,
0.0227937158,
-0.0190987643,
-0.0291482601,
0.0333204493,
-0.0098386882,
0.03626775,
0.0100729009,
-0.011515975,
-0.0123694586,
-0.0081148129,
0.0920069143,
0.0172062982,
0.0177260581,
0.047511898,
-0.0214199405,
-0.0296759717,
0.0199394897,
-0.0195927341,
0.0210662428,
-0.0044383123,
0.070850268,
0.0292246882,
0.0050527328,
-0.0039467812,
0.0426349714,
0.0132518327,
0.0057368963,
-0.0329973213,
-0.0494387485,
0.0335586295,
0.0518829823,
-0.0287775919,
-0.0044933087,
-0.0167595446,
0.0169959646,
-0.0241221711,
-0.0434579998,
-0.0203816593,
-0.0469281524,
-0.0067620529,
-0.0058185244,
0.0446323715,
0.0122595122,
-0.0404841527,
-0.0838532671,
-0.0104381861,
-0.0363081768,
0.0049264068,
-0.0397172906,
0.0775609463,
-0.0228906851,
-0.0148759363,
-0.0116332797,
0.0340260789,
-0.0252781417,
-0.040857926,
0.0215852521,
0.0676176101,
0.0063472413,
-0.0108468058,
-0.0181295034,
0.0301532149,
-0.0183102097,
-0.0464779511,
0.0051393607,
0.0134278908,
0.0251634885,
0.0205113571,
0.0174316186,
-0.0163193177,
-0.003580237,
-0.015505095,
0.0159927383,
-0.0293622669,
-0.0094709303,
0.044205226,
-0.0400991812,
-0.0457620621,
-0.0323496312,
0.019173177,
-0.0288991388,
0.0263665002,
-0.006091353,
-0.044787541,
-0.0237758346,
-0.0195383411,
0.04460207,
0.0137378359,
-0.0416793749,
-0.0214886311,
-0.0548880175,
-0.0182606485,
-0.0027151643,
-0.0017720812,
0.0029723861,
-0.0363620631,
0.0246477444,
-0.0012650635,
-0.0177911874,
-0.0592748784,
0.0091731986,
-0.0064410367,
-0.0378506929,
0.0134286638,
-0.0332440622,
-5.733991648e-33,
0.0448396467,
-0.0336983427,
0.0238571875,
0.023032723,
-0.0141990148,
-0.0216292925,
-0.0331817344,
0.0162645411,
0.0342642777,
0.0603122599,
0.023995202,
-0.0008634277,
-0.0180306807,
-0.0307651013,
0.0403444283,
-0.0204547718,
0.0133538805,
-0.0327205621,
-0.0277818367,
0.0149189821,
-0.0335252956,
0.0421109945,
-0.0002045058,
-0.0689591765,
0.0583575703,
0.0035008776,
-0.041782815,
0.0008857313,
0.0123684369,
-0.012516628,
-0.0485577546,
0.0324442908,
0.0233652461,
0.0234162807,
-0.0238856729,
0.0633010268,
0.0439640731,
-0.0760231987,
0.0142057398,
-0.0587676279,
-0.0008075561,
-0.0423101932,
0.0027242228,
-0.0385981873,
-0.075869821,
0.0479773991,
0.0445878059,
-0.0278921537,
0.0207996164,
0.0074139722,
-0.0255505368,
-0.0305748079,
-0.0200138111,
-0.0023671077,
-0.0378101021,
0.0633381009,
-0.0592730716,
0.0182570014,
-0.0143876644,
0.0339074247,
-0.013834211,
-0.0565816574,
-0.0063701472,
-0.0285387002,
0.0171966664,
0.0014839235,
0.021698568,
0.0117675141,
-0.054488197,
-0.0502479225,
-0.0234182011,
0.0049756332,
0.0883051008,
-0.0072138081,
-0.0227786191,
-0.0378452279,
-0.0240806118,
-0.0094611738,
-0.0052741286,
-0.0462781079,
0.0085065002,
0.0224916451,
-0.0334624052,
-0.0416383184,
0.0117625715,
-0.0311267711,
-0.0370870158,
-0.0650091022,
-0.0152363526,
-0.0287066121,
-0.0093325702,
-0.0121615371,
-0.0322087817,
-0.0158110801,
0.0390851535,
-0.0293537378,
0.0370612554,
-0.0198164843,
-0.0112098251,
-0.0561106466,
-0.1022731587,
0.01492575,
-0.0074293953,
0.0627627969,
0.0430751182,
0.016742222,
0.029647477,
-0.012191792,
-0.0005186198,
-0.0447561629,
0.0064850282,
-0.0022910826,
0.0371102169,
-0.1011882499,
0.0033061304,
0.0471236594,
-0.0068160971,
0.0767131448,
0.0099909576,
-0.0020703552,
-0.0857523158,
0.0228467491,
0.01132809,
-0.0164897982,
-0.0643739477,
-0.0112994425,
-0.060514234,
0.0308454316,
0.0406115688,
-0.0407035835,
-0.0064868452,
-0.0472897142,
2.805e-7,
-0.0087851454,
0.0394868813,
-0.0013445389,
-0.0108674001,
0.0057189497,
0.064945586,
-0.005484879,
0.0002552477,
-0.0054440117,
0.0389387533,
0.0543785878,
0.0140613634,
-0.026672693,
-0.0132458908,
0.0355636142,
0.0033579459,
-0.0744117275,
-0.0868768394,
-0.0397822484,
0.0030793045,
0.0674968213,
0.0269587394,
0.0275913626,
-0.0179774556,
-0.01018376,
0.0296971016,
0.0477887169,
-0.0500187613,
-0.0056036431,
-0.0056178723,
-0.0064603752,
-0.0192308519,
0.0186084993,
-0.0045458893,
0.0285898689,
-0.0292819683,
0.0068024746,
0.1063312367,
-0.0376429781,
0.009827463,
-0.0004049173,
0.0528306551,
-0.0322674364,
-0.0176865682,
-0.0024666602,
-0.1249551624,
-0.0531088933,
-0.0128090503,
0.0025227466,
-0.0554224141,
0.0413113385,
-0.0268339571,
-0.0065752552,
0.0755607858,
-0.0143054025,
0.0456565693,
0.0086843818,
-0.0224988889,
0.029759651,
-0.0172310453,
-0.0282901283,
-0.0349733941,
-0.0233352985,
0.036217697,
-0.0544789545,
-0.0739580393,
0.0306228828,
1.967496756e-34,
0.0161438007,
-0.0127847698,
0.015487086,
-0.0087827295,
0.0584716797,
0.0490027703,
0.0229135286,
0.0364215933,
0.0286828261,
-0.0722301602,
-0.0289759245
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.04052v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.04052v1 | Multimodal Misinformation Detection in a South African Social Media Environment | 2023-12-07T05:20:15 | 2023-12-07T05:20:15 | Amica De Jager, Vukosi Marivate, Abioudun Modupe | cs.CL | cs.CL | With the constant spread of misinformation on social media networks, a need
has arisen to continuously assess the veracity of digital content. This need
has inspired numerous research efforts on the development of misinformation
detection (MD) models. However, many models do not use all information
available to them and existing research contains a lack of relevant datasets to
train the models, specifically within the South African social media
environment. The aim of this paper is to investigate the transferability of
knowledge of a MD model between different contextual environments. This
research contributes a multimodal MD model capable of functioning in the South
African social media environment, as well as introduces a South African
misinformation dataset. The model makes use of multiple sources of information
for misinformation detection, namely: textual and visual elements. It uses
bidirectional encoder representations from transformers (BERT) as the textual
encoder and a residual network (ResNet) as the visual encoder. The model is
trained and evaluated on the Fakeddit dataset and a South African
misinformation dataset. Results show that using South African samples in the
training of the model increases model performance, in a South African
contextual environment, and that a multimodal model retains significantly more
knowledge than both the textual and visual unimodal models. Our study suggests
that the performance of a misinformation detection model is influenced by the
cultural nuances of its operating environment and multimodal models assist in
the transferability of knowledge between different contextual environments.
Therefore, local data should be incorporated into the training process of a
misinformation detection model in order to optimize model performance. | [
0.0616172105,
-0.0030325959,
-0.0368070491,
0.0653574094,
-0.0023952273,
0.0126275709,
0.0182895064,
0.0081416126,
-0.0112460554,
-0.0708119273,
-0.0387468897,
-0.0259127673,
0.0120013934,
0.0236615762,
0.0366987623,
-0.0695758834,
0.056594573,
0.0390028879,
0.0295278318,
-0.0187355038,
0.0261210445,
0.0039363299,
-0.0040331595,
0.0152198644,
-0.0500447825,
-0.0331884772,
-0.0018639212,
0.0222002696,
0.0488099419,
-0.0269979984,
0.0284130666,
0.0323833078,
0.0669020563,
0.0324504897,
0.0000019653,
-0.0138697289,
0.0032662349,
-0.0139371576,
-0.0327551365,
0.0026872647,
0.0318601429,
-0.0398380682,
-0.0197794084,
0.013841752,
-0.0088152178,
0.0316424966,
0.0711728409,
0.0644555315,
0.1057395861,
0.0809549987,
-0.0183237121,
-0.0310243089,
-0.0003093081,
0.0265693776,
-0.0105264001,
-0.0240947753,
0.0502916984,
0.0641510263,
-0.0447710939,
0.0272856206,
-0.0362808853,
0.0074008945,
-0.0099190269,
-0.0060099182,
-0.0277623776,
-0.0156930666,
0.0177380089,
-0.0478955358,
0.0039994991,
0.0580826923,
-0.0016328176,
-0.0062247254,
-0.0302135535,
0.0300576258,
-0.0059968056,
0.0881907344,
-0.0156087335,
0.0262501612,
-0.0436741263,
0.0272877999,
-0.0541043654,
-0.0193093549,
0.0499980263,
0.0150259268,
0.0228957999,
0.0374877751,
-0.0113885412,
-0.0195098501,
-0.0106454818,
-0.0026024384,
0.0024216003,
-0.0427644663,
0.0220800936,
0.0033118816,
0.0162738226,
0.0012489519,
-0.0331659429,
-0.077249147,
0.0306296349,
-0.0952151343,
-0.0156928636,
0.0024741504,
-0.04776337,
0.0234667994,
-0.0270975623,
0.0310123153,
-0.0412625559,
0.060608346,
0.0100380545,
-0.0535659678,
-0.0506848991,
0.0026550842,
0.0222331081,
-0.0045417752,
-0.0093933251,
0.0111953709,
-0.0816370323,
-0.0082382867,
-0.0311985556,
0.0005134165,
-0.0122395074,
-0.012461693,
-0.0313364938,
-0.0074515687,
-0.0258651599,
0.0638278052,
-0.004061942,
0.0301532969,
-0.0368501842,
-0.0572849661,
0.0318791494,
0.0265119504,
-0.0136817461,
-0.0127220303,
-0.0060951621,
0.0562216304,
-0.0073029022,
-0.0062071071,
-0.1153066531,
-0.0083892727,
-0.0166012421,
-0.0265796054,
0.03639948,
-0.0266641043,
-0.0136801703,
-0.0134045184,
0.0121339569,
0.0027163695,
-0.0259279814,
0.0122197429,
-0.03765475,
0.0706406012,
-0.0076583247,
0.0079630138,
0.09345413,
0.0336567946,
-0.0033510698,
0.0655414611,
0.0091761956,
0.0839559287,
0.0499528535,
0.0012841154,
-0.0192111619,
-0.0010235873,
0.0471034944,
0.0093500251,
0.0001917824,
-0.016716497,
-0.0227210559,
-0.0465366878,
0.033146929,
0.0330870152,
-0.0219011772,
-0.0329002254,
0.0895516947,
-0.0421280116,
-0.0223866906,
-0.0078698723,
0.0415480956,
-0.0003050774,
-0.0193740241,
-0.0120603191,
-0.0229276773,
0.0344300456,
-0.0343449079,
-0.0332256183,
-0.0012404164,
0.068916209,
-0.0190693382,
0.0137599027,
0.0003184645,
-0.0061902702,
0.0328488089,
-0.030329885,
0.0248379931,
0.0159285273,
-0.0437469333,
0.028752083,
0.0432165116,
-0.0025264428,
-0.0166075286,
-0.0380377211,
0.0252178423,
0.0543380082,
-0.0136931036,
0.0198654514,
0.0075291009,
-0.0515393503,
-0.0024990796,
0.0119332923,
0.0314849019,
-0.0221529081,
-0.0270224139,
-0.0035923547,
-0.0350805409,
-0.0292232912,
-0.0073533976,
0.043229185,
0.0123339966,
0.0537047088,
-0.0116650946,
-0.0263000168,
0.0056878021,
0.0173390172,
0.0057981759,
0.0323125757,
-0.0607681759,
0.0457002707,
0.0600784719,
-0.0001567573,
-0.0034563243,
-0.0483300239,
0.0071552354,
0.0027952276,
-0.0318239331,
0.0047301836,
-0.0104448358,
-0.0176970884,
0.0060398062,
-0.0798383653,
0.0113133416,
0.0512780324,
-0.0164397266,
0.0373880528,
0.0601655692,
-0.0339443199,
0.0162295755,
-0.0491250493,
-0.0461337045,
-0.0348715745,
0.0448490605,
0.0495999977,
0.0573767312,
-0.0477767251,
-0.0345091969,
0.0091685699,
-0.0191423949,
0.0348374248,
0.0139313284,
0.0053090523,
-0.0291867889,
-0.0194881614,
0.0079460451,
0.0039198999,
-0.0315391868,
0.0115876431,
0.0264265984,
-0.0795940086,
-0.0615206286,
-0.043355085,
-0.0092141749,
0.0420665033,
-0.0168114323,
-0.0001527972,
-0.0153739266,
0.0135693857,
0.0331391469,
-0.0041940999,
0.0487028919,
0.006380728,
-0.0118681407,
0.0019840053,
0.0055246023,
0.0126502849,
0.0066987383,
0.0770724863,
0.0180185195,
-0.0865664706,
-0.0289383773,
-0.0358563438,
-0.0485918932,
0.0366088264,
-0.0458571315,
-0.0531443767,
-0.0042276983,
0.0623078495,
0.0124711012,
-0.0206112452,
0.0352247246,
0.0781983584,
0.0177064687,
0.0273304526,
0.0185490977,
-0.0253834371,
-0.0345684253,
0.008116941,
-0.0177865382,
-0.0903996751,
0.0197274499,
0.0126179289,
0.0602987111,
0.0089415219,
-0.0122559527,
0.0087940646,
-0.0002423613,
-0.0750178471,
-0.034954872,
-0.0757063255,
0.0095463088,
0.0291783903,
-0.0347212441,
-0.0260344185,
0.0765529275,
-0.0176262707,
0.0415205695,
0.0172887929,
-0.0141574489,
0.0335411169,
-0.024749564,
0.0001217379,
0.0535128824,
0.0155227976,
-0.0029446972,
-0.0037279823,
-0.0412209257,
0.089233838,
-0.0046307798,
-0.0186389424,
-0.0134253036,
0.0248899814,
0.0122769764,
-0.0139984414,
-0.0475567505,
-0.0624079853,
0.0183416754,
-0.0047237454,
-0.0179486126,
-0.0169813652,
-0.0728897452,
0.0155035397,
0.0397516787,
0.0007225955,
0.0168591999,
-0.0065609487,
0.0265875421,
0.0255131312,
-0.0081273187,
-0.0142216412,
0.0501606613,
-0.0849553645,
-0.0284205005,
0.036854852,
-0.057282608,
-0.0403179787,
-0.0331927426,
-0.0353462435,
-0.014593496,
0.026669126,
0.00596932,
0.0008128664,
0.0584220961,
-0.0045921504,
0.0076196631,
0.0575774163,
-0.0250926428,
-0.0159710757,
-0.0140824448,
-0.0108656585,
-0.0470614247,
0.0191531777,
-0.0051987465,
-0.0465305969,
-0.0107488716,
-0.0082682911,
-0.0279484577,
-0.0334776267,
-0.002884798,
-0.0180038065,
-0.0562469661,
0.0359213613,
-0.0072391285,
-0.0354545675,
-0.0643934682,
-0.0095906835,
-0.0325362943,
0.0219443832,
0.0400636494,
-0.0044309418,
0.0221085567,
-0.0424954481,
0.0229493789,
-0.0179540254,
-0.0821669102,
-0.0230263527,
-0.0122450236,
0.027990723,
0.0339340791,
-0.0000760113,
-0.0211617723,
-0.0649045929,
-0.0105614727,
-0.002255284,
-0.0022335825,
-0.0067755855,
0.0704357028,
-0.0713965297,
-0.009673872,
-0.0181999747,
-0.0061451336,
0.0181467738,
-0.0290855132,
-0.0599061176,
0.0580886453,
-0.0077900859,
-0.0317170322,
-0.0612264201,
-0.0096023334,
0.0544510484,
0.0248229988,
0.0115917372,
0.027711967,
0.0079587121,
-0.0246737693,
0.021298347,
-0.0012551693,
0.0013046981,
0.0721146092,
-0.0332196318,
-0.0503110476,
-0.0490491726,
0.0115244919,
-0.0405293331,
-0.0037628114,
0.0084995031,
-0.0340514481,
0.0412055515,
-0.0143048642,
-0.0591777042,
-0.0284597408,
-0.0246980451,
0.0615562573,
0.0075482475,
-0.0047994805,
0.0101537546,
-0.0389434844,
-0.0084105963,
-0.0365196615,
-0.0578876622,
-0.0196326301,
-0.0021303354,
0.0307541676,
0.0200909767,
0.0247888342,
0.0033251678,
-0.0429628082,
0.0567556657,
-0.0031920869,
0.0001580134,
0.0109779621,
0.0320954733,
0.0122523857,
0.011807438,
0.0039697196,
-0.0199002493,
0.0636897981,
0.0269352756,
-0.0515220985,
-0.0626930743,
0.0265081488,
0.0098820571,
-0.0119453864,
0.0449741781,
-0.0077022361,
-0.0128727993,
-0.0377281643,
-0.0316846892,
0.0266372506,
0.0048054554,
0.0107913585,
0.0045038415,
0.0233799461,
-0.0000819011,
0.0210713446,
0.0180140324,
-0.0102280928,
-0.0123694204,
-0.0347392969,
0.0022160541,
0.0574007109,
0.0456956178,
0.00352853,
0.029392112,
-0.0074681761,
-0.0009907328,
0.0176517386,
0.0096656708,
0.0094905309,
0.0641975105,
0.003371879,
-0.0311435275,
0.0216264594,
-0.0213078596,
0.0018624223,
0.0565667152,
-0.0561253615,
0.0363176726,
0.0570952483,
0.023517631,
0.0126243606,
-0.0068946905,
0.0048655369,
-0.0065752724,
0.001827602,
0.0091463476,
-0.0288076308,
0.0616684146,
-0.0096894559,
-0.0112994965,
0.0565820262,
0.060307771,
-0.025830429,
0.0275095664,
-0.0285929777,
-0.0893866643,
-0.0520576648,
0.0126912231,
0.0338563956,
0.0290834401,
-0.0022431901,
0.0299985837,
-0.0415094234,
-0.0775667801,
0.0171655081,
0.0067768502,
0.0101055261,
0.0335848145,
0.0049674027,
0.0932287648,
0.0310602393,
0.0061031091,
-0.0370864011,
-0.005268842,
-0.0150377527,
0.026619548,
0.0321716033,
-6.740169997e-33,
-0.0012726958,
-0.0754854083,
-0.0253664684,
-0.0254517663,
-0.0151464501,
0.0033821033,
-0.0167305004,
-0.0271390993,
-0.0369799025,
0.0600229725,
0.0633270368,
0.0212122146,
-0.0057601715,
0.0120186405,
-0.0465829186,
-0.026076287,
0.0488362238,
0.0284701753,
-0.0178195685,
-0.0210983697,
0.1100414321,
0.0227411222,
0.0546338819,
-0.086796321,
0.0354597531,
-0.0286536254,
-0.033130046,
0.0151993362,
0.0089242626,
0.0456637964,
-0.0373007469,
0.047309719,
0.0531041026,
-0.0290774293,
-0.0023868249,
0.0601918399,
-0.0425303392,
-0.0246030521,
0.04101092,
0.0500997752,
-0.0161963534,
0.0026267054,
0.0545920655,
-0.0116073349,
-0.0219016541,
0.0401788093,
0.0457924865,
-0.0249139238,
0.0082210265,
0.0063602976,
-0.062650308,
-0.0019831795,
0.0142031936,
0.0000491481,
-0.0239982214,
0.0981810465,
0.0300815031,
0.0055256668,
-0.1076572165,
0.0011994765,
-0.0354701132,
-0.0282390676,
0.0512928963,
-0.0164081436,
-0.0486545041,
0.0782272294,
0.011815466,
0.017983241,
-0.04035962,
-0.0150995571,
0.0015995402,
0.0042242496,
0.0363777764,
0.0914039016,
-0.0111866063,
-0.0905267596,
-0.0884891674,
0.0164986849,
-0.0064456165,
0.015237283,
0.0435790494,
-0.0112074893,
-0.008045515,
-0.010565416,
0.0015753596,
-0.0247863512,
-0.0351192579,
-0.0173422117,
0.0314609557,
0.0300324243,
-0.0004645642,
0.069189705,
0.0264625978,
-0.0443273336,
0.001420306,
0.0118010677,
0.0197858009,
0.0296823829,
0.0337671489,
0.0158897266,
-0.0418834686,
0.008604602,
0.0306982379,
0.0080082491,
-0.0065205786,
-0.0139633073,
0.077028811,
0.0452618413,
-0.0283738505,
0.0044136569,
-0.0179016218,
0.017433865,
-0.0260275211,
-0.0078179948,
0.01308442,
0.0042261397,
-0.0525140949,
0.0041982611,
0.0168618858,
0.0134027377,
0.0170121472,
-0.0113912253,
-0.0241893716,
0.0350421369,
-0.0469085015,
-0.018311752,
-0.0316017941,
0.0099830115,
-0.0056822142,
-0.0858303756,
0.0095703378,
0.038012106,
2.876e-7,
0.0020109913,
0.0534758195,
0.0079836361,
-0.0472552925,
0.0653855726,
0.0548953377,
-0.0141468942,
0.004588956,
-0.0065394416,
-0.097592324,
-0.0380541943,
0.0253793541,
-0.0124259628,
0.0607537739,
-0.0117393406,
-0.0307864249,
-0.0413783975,
-0.0233334024,
-0.0186278298,
0.0382110476,
0.0072887158,
0.0426346026,
0.0232445505,
-0.0503214337,
-0.0228068251,
0.010706096,
0.0783386528,
0.0232453439,
-0.0299590677,
-0.0344665609,
0.0337540805,
0.0078574894,
0.0261078682,
0.0490893312,
0.0008260574,
-0.0445490852,
0.0001141409,
-0.0069060279,
-0.0149743073,
0.0064093433,
-0.0360784084,
0.0055667092,
-0.0057024145,
-0.0306099486,
0.0367539935,
-0.020650886,
-0.0697007179,
-0.0375017114,
-0.0690229684,
0.0186825283,
0.0305864587,
-0.0114851734,
-0.0514950156,
-0.0070139077,
0.0189290009,
0.0329990536,
-0.038043499,
-0.0430384055,
0.0634430349,
0.0063347439,
-0.0637035519,
-0.021891145,
-0.0013209025,
-0.0601954535,
0.0674185902,
-0.0132837947,
0.0482639,
2.04958667e-34,
0.0477719344,
-0.0305920579,
-0.000823828,
-0.0242631603,
-0.0033246197,
0.0101545723,
-0.0347071029,
-0.0542250499,
0.0017191161,
0.0068698092,
0.0027782882
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.04032v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.04032v1 | RoAST: Robustifying Language Models via Adversarial Perturbation with Selective Training | 2023-12-07T04:23:36 | 2023-12-07T04:23:36 | Jaehyung Kim, Yuning Mao, Rui Hou, Hanchao Yu, Davis Liang, Pascale Fung, Qifan Wang, Fuli Feng, Lifu Huang, Madian Khabsa | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Fine-tuning pre-trained language models (LMs) has become the de facto
standard in many NLP tasks. Nevertheless, fine-tuned LMs are still prone to
robustness issues, such as adversarial robustness and model calibration.
Several perspectives of robustness for LMs have been studied independently, but
lacking a unified consideration in multiple perspectives. In this paper, we
propose Robustifying LMs via Adversarial perturbation with Selective Training
(RoAST), a simple yet effective fine-tuning technique to enhance the
multi-perspective robustness of LMs in a unified way. RoAST effectively
incorporates two important sources for the model robustness, robustness on the
perturbed inputs and generalizable knowledge in pre-trained LMs. To be
specific, RoAST introduces adversarial perturbation during fine-tuning while
the model parameters are selectively updated upon their relative importance to
minimize unnecessary deviation. Under a unified evaluation of fine-tuned LMs by
incorporating four representative perspectives of model robustness, we
demonstrate the effectiveness of RoAST compared to state-of-the-art fine-tuning
methods on six different types of LMs, which indicates its usefulness in
practice. | [
0.0350285731,
0.0926225707,
-0.0292537473,
0.043177899,
-0.0011080513,
-0.0044614887,
-0.0271014739,
0.0020389226,
0.0011373012,
-0.0620173961,
-0.0635701194,
-0.0330815427,
-0.011887202,
0.0009287774,
0.0637645274,
-0.0485584699,
0.0456341058,
-0.0140888821,
-0.0005895749,
0.0055509196,
0.016508257,
0.0067520835,
0.018082561,
0.0068680951,
-0.0033361565,
0.0051000156,
0.0109820236,
0.0322594158,
0.0054881778,
-0.0005729923,
0.0467258506,
0.0771714598,
0.0047958354,
0.0436192006,
0.0000020862,
-0.0211622585,
-0.0315082334,
-0.0031475769,
-0.0061378665,
0.0519591682,
0.0454713441,
-0.0466961004,
-0.0090357037,
0.0098250369,
-0.0522569157,
-0.0072526536,
0.0175943226,
0.0685907975,
0.0504579209,
0.0831030533,
-0.0074493927,
-0.0329758339,
0.0036692498,
-0.0599110238,
-0.067357935,
-0.0926495492,
0.0239828806,
-0.015623292,
-0.0561270416,
0.0317079276,
-0.0113006132,
0.01067858,
0.0018720506,
0.0145097794,
-0.0433446392,
-0.003532409,
-0.0055898661,
-0.0210022088,
0.0071797878,
0.0814881772,
-0.0544820018,
-0.0294330642,
-0.0323366225,
-0.0371637903,
-0.0013171298,
-0.0341127925,
-0.0319977291,
-0.017153684,
0.0511542968,
0.0422403514,
-0.0113016544,
-0.0133424876,
0.0679802373,
0.037628673,
0.0036044465,
0.0069981623,
0.0284458697,
-0.0112903975,
-0.022861287,
-0.0072354651,
-0.069616802,
-0.0199599229,
-0.0140898926,
0.0187413059,
-0.0286668781,
0.0168771036,
-0.0791806653,
-0.0454927348,
0.0279299058,
-0.0369085558,
0.0704365894,
-0.0002688713,
-0.0260075089,
0.0406587906,
-0.0254937019,
0.012918531,
-0.0179975815,
0.0594877154,
-0.0183509924,
-0.0029794171,
-0.0168567151,
-0.0027304655,
0.0000695813,
-0.0008489714,
-0.0416706279,
0.0225881245,
-0.028264815,
0.0085917553,
0.012315684,
0.0072459197,
-0.0053200028,
0.0194587521,
-0.0482072942,
-0.0295430031,
0.0087433429,
-0.0054470217,
-0.0436587706,
0.0351050794,
-0.0152035272,
-0.0797585398,
-0.0398775376,
0.0331470333,
-0.0195774399,
-0.0419185087,
0.0172303859,
0.0809075311,
0.0215858817,
-0.0640682057,
-0.0520879179,
-0.0010645128,
-0.0415365435,
-0.0573621765,
0.0157294571,
-0.0173082221,
0.0078260181,
-0.0122607201,
0.003449393,
-0.0887561738,
0.0131064374,
-0.020338662,
-0.0555912033,
0.0968814343,
0.0034941782,
-0.0370859727,
-0.0160766561,
0.006425926,
0.0196214039,
0.0889213607,
0.038451355,
-0.0040869503,
0.0471248701,
-0.0029900684,
-0.0107888728,
0.0352522843,
0.0175100751,
0.0169694722,
-0.0297562573,
-0.0039457888,
0.0290467925,
-0.0221407767,
-0.0036099956,
0.0701046586,
0.0016932475,
-0.0271296874,
0.109046109,
-0.0126831569,
0.0035262255,
0.0594745688,
-0.0058665723,
-0.0421035215,
0.0119100073,
0.022071654,
-0.0624269731,
-0.0097691296,
-0.080282867,
-0.0222626496,
0.0053288001,
0.035237208,
-0.0381047986,
-0.0460839681,
-0.0267852768,
-0.0230471212,
0.0300609935,
-0.0158607867,
0.0476205088,
0.0311730392,
-0.0194058027,
0.030736126,
0.0297919139,
-0.0224345587,
0.0147352004,
-0.0218238607,
-0.0312197339,
0.0029323003,
0.0674637705,
-0.0505338386,
0.0002563607,
-0.0284883119,
0.036212083,
0.0345436037,
0.0859735832,
0.0123730488,
0.0519968346,
-0.0475483872,
0.0014255563,
-0.059576232,
0.0521800891,
0.0093511287,
0.0359773822,
-0.020088207,
0.0285229515,
-0.0345412157,
-0.0257576946,
0.0653290227,
-0.0230945926,
-0.0508585833,
0.0032383795,
-0.0060891244,
0.0096886614,
0.0151680475,
-0.0239612963,
0.0135356002,
0.0331215747,
-0.0118669393,
0.033870142,
-0.0033112504,
-0.0164970569,
-0.0143035362,
0.0475545488,
0.0154473083,
-0.020229714,
0.0735971406,
-0.0483409315,
-0.0119441161,
0.0295467488,
0.0081874849,
0.0035028623,
-0.0423910208,
0.0214440003,
-0.0275997333,
0.0605428293,
-0.0529997461,
0.0334008969,
-0.0036126792,
-0.0042256671,
-0.0295691732,
0.0201243442,
0.0109672146,
-0.0112769548,
-0.0709724426,
0.0295978542,
-0.0139641976,
0.0281446595,
-0.0034301523,
-0.0070168041,
-0.011008515,
-0.031799905,
-0.0406629741,
-0.0142303417,
-0.0453318432,
-0.0015798811,
0.0351154208,
-0.0125198402,
-0.0047433916,
-0.0149810128,
0.0134350723,
0.0033426848,
0.0085599469,
-0.0044487282,
0.0391621813,
-0.0119412579,
0.0288100652,
-0.0537386835,
-0.0113810012,
0.0034499615,
0.0564925112,
-0.0069150063,
0.009243316,
-0.0230451375,
0.008790154,
-0.0278773103,
0.0661986619,
-0.0386048928,
-0.0564026199,
0.0024188857,
-0.0035431806,
-0.0133421617,
0.075632669,
0.0138376486,
0.0374960303,
0.0572209619,
0.0405624919,
0.0041370043,
0.0124573382,
-0.014853335,
-0.0169976801,
-0.0377756059,
0.0301936306,
0.0025512753,
0.0536773875,
-0.011007105,
-0.0269016512,
-0.0285126586,
0.0490374267,
-0.0069266679,
-0.0325928032,
0.0080558239,
0.0043667853,
-0.0451273024,
0.0082476605,
-0.0472781472,
-0.0519109406,
0.0747084841,
-0.0553551652,
0.0118739493,
-0.0084275864,
-0.0230166595,
-0.0128357224,
0.0571465716,
0.001041597,
-0.0005802721,
0.0107293725,
0.0068254047,
-0.0851951689,
-0.0580239818,
0.0319932625,
-0.0282641407,
0.0514317825,
-0.017233124,
-0.0014639097,
-0.0065264502,
-0.030937301,
-0.0551068038,
-0.063998349,
-0.0269356184,
0.0338308103,
0.0427371003,
0.0067977239,
-0.0241867695,
-0.0048563024,
-0.0117906593,
0.0299901105,
-0.0282815658,
0.0281485487,
-0.0342276581,
0.0063022859,
0.0682562441,
-0.0028705674,
0.0279283579,
-0.050724443,
0.0172101129,
0.0487989672,
-0.0165373106,
0.0115556912,
-0.0236740988,
0.0249017812,
0.0219269544,
-0.0097016618,
-0.0001288501,
-0.001851614,
0.059125822,
-0.0339126177,
-0.017521441,
0.0986154899,
0.0115424227,
-0.0136423195,
0.0244185831,
0.023031963,
0.0207563769,
0.0283036027,
0.0233816393,
-0.0276121739,
-0.0253986735,
0.0002874965,
0.0341532566,
0.0192934386,
-0.0204853509,
-0.0165846962,
-0.0905577391,
-0.0215755571,
0.0212031882,
-0.0493170954,
-0.0420144573,
0.0015382922,
0.0212448966,
-0.0186310392,
0.0558878742,
-0.0095264278,
0.0337799862,
-0.0260428283,
0.0086577768,
0.005133328,
-0.0852874964,
-0.0012471254,
-0.0630680323,
0.0384090133,
0.069527477,
0.0147171747,
-0.0134748425,
0.0073460923,
0.0794751644,
-0.0150408866,
0.0049498319,
0.0110619236,
0.0502063856,
-0.0393880755,
-0.0276667904,
0.0333300494,
0.0304303672,
-0.0040243599,
-0.0283160415,
-0.0278585665,
0.0092162024,
0.0127803972,
-0.0150107583,
0.0019861117,
-0.0146180997,
-0.0013788573,
0.0504900143,
0.0348684788,
-0.0548900142,
-0.0196634848,
-0.0556467958,
-0.0084718261,
-0.0544083044,
-0.0441839062,
0.0112589989,
0.0292868912,
-0.0040972084,
-0.0463748202,
-0.0240739007,
0.0015174502,
0.0102858515,
0.0048159347,
-0.0036413581,
-0.0157517716,
-0.0124422191,
0.019686358,
0.0173761882,
-0.0395996273,
0.0085467733,
-0.0281800199,
-0.0048071309,
0.0552369617,
-0.0276410785,
0.0072688432,
0.0058250921,
-0.0792244673,
-0.105153203,
0.0092751971,
0.0680568665,
0.016682962,
0.0527907647,
-0.0609997064,
-0.0994841605,
0.0449967571,
0.0404501334,
0.0140656801,
0.0181489289,
0.0661715344,
-0.036485035,
0.0152774211,
0.0528467596,
-0.0462639816,
0.0040643685,
0.0824619681,
0.0478030629,
-0.0042918995,
-0.0433008783,
0.0107644852,
0.0128798541,
0.0777899623,
-0.0085666599,
-0.0087840213,
-0.0118639469,
-0.0080612963,
-0.0194586422,
-0.0457556732,
-0.0234142728,
0.0245263036,
0.0297067612,
0.0074727559,
-0.0251202602,
-0.0221236814,
-0.0166846085,
0.0788285062,
-0.0255194474,
0.0103551978,
-0.0082712723,
-0.006085265,
-0.001170418,
0.0281973239,
-0.0009593218,
0.0562527068,
-0.0304901246,
0.0145596731,
-0.009348576,
0.0122761587,
0.0221869554,
0.0050755399,
-0.0537608117,
0.0272037536,
-0.0778955743,
0.0155568784,
-0.06635084,
0.0321959741,
0.0668034256,
-0.0355512463,
0.0266680345,
-0.012428659,
-0.0275110118,
-0.0317624807,
0.0235625226,
0.0315605924,
-0.0084610172,
0.0313554667,
0.0128362607,
-0.0203598253,
0.04332266,
0.064044781,
0.0081210183,
0.0608607084,
0.0064392621,
0.0049764635,
-0.0435462818,
-0.03257576,
0.0212267917,
0.0113214469,
-0.0326385312,
0.0270713065,
-0.010309536,
-0.0990417674,
-0.0015969784,
0.0183825195,
-0.0030519185,
-0.0005355991,
0.0001000997,
0.056578476,
0.0071260124,
0.0453471802,
-0.0253315177,
-0.0015062736,
0.0439097658,
-0.0093282061,
-0.0107837841,
-6.89465273e-33,
-0.0230140015,
0.0030405656,
-0.0502209291,
-0.0336061046,
0.0076112384,
-0.032247141,
-0.0274034999,
0.0191084128,
-0.0666783601,
-0.0197804589,
-0.0156296417,
0.0090251304,
-0.0141188065,
0.0290960222,
-0.0348690636,
-0.048479259,
0.0381526724,
-0.0140064787,
-0.0378429703,
-0.0399104692,
-0.0183975399,
0.0400936753,
0.052167505,
-0.0487143137,
0.0462069437,
-0.0018356219,
-0.0496853366,
0.0216020979,
-0.0331817791,
0.0610174611,
0.0052200509,
0.0274340548,
0.0066858171,
0.0199855473,
-0.015392703,
-0.0203055628,
-0.0485618003,
-0.0054526222,
0.0048422022,
0.0022023865,
-0.0068836762,
-0.0174483843,
0.0512371436,
-0.0395914465,
0.0188035592,
-0.0001781619,
0.0040394445,
-0.0349230319,
-0.031259045,
-0.0106423711,
-0.0069462555,
0.023654215,
0.0110597331,
-0.0064002974,
0.0025793645,
0.010518101,
0.0288374536,
0.0620192476,
-0.0361778177,
-0.0260807984,
0.0448965766,
0.0445632003,
0.0279676244,
0.0259897187,
-0.0089602917,
0.0503907986,
-0.037515793,
0.0290906485,
-0.0346706212,
-0.0269404035,
0.0516389087,
0.018449083,
0.0807147324,
0.0778221413,
0.0089625828,
-0.0333864763,
-0.0880236924,
-0.0078388061,
0.0107326033,
0.0166872013,
0.0316179022,
0.0456193313,
-0.0074107484,
-0.0104360636,
-0.0592142493,
-0.085494332,
-0.0382576138,
-0.0157164671,
0.0022078734,
0.0293044895,
-0.0636945143,
0.0117842639,
-0.0108266464,
-0.0551694706,
0.0089066718,
0.0155021846,
-0.0162923373,
-0.0168923475,
-0.0011998652,
0.030210007,
-0.017261181,
-0.0294697341,
0.0249210671,
-0.0337158255,
0.0136350039,
-0.0174000449,
0.0769002959,
0.0165150166,
-0.0293878652,
0.0040796269,
-0.0004631095,
0.0260900706,
0.0443147048,
0.0492997393,
0.0348476656,
-0.0010062453,
-0.0141344685,
0.0236157849,
0.037504226,
0.0013772782,
-0.0138565646,
0.0003130713,
0.0151145039,
0.0319215022,
-0.0140833631,
-0.0266948882,
0.0149662104,
-0.0069057085,
0.0348362699,
-0.0717168152,
-0.0031912467,
-0.0293604154,
2.716e-7,
0.0725752339,
0.0604106635,
0.0066340165,
0.0156291034,
0.023999257,
0.0387702659,
-0.0203731414,
0.0325904489,
-0.0102645624,
-0.0170986298,
-0.0075717438,
0.0337853245,
0.0792663768,
0.02705919,
-0.0493615121,
-0.0247096028,
-0.0741371438,
0.0424747504,
-0.0114778634,
-0.0252763554,
0.0358275473,
0.1394596994,
0.0267502926,
0.0242628604,
-0.0265650414,
-0.0556000806,
0.0588218421,
-0.043112576,
-0.005487829,
0.0080976635,
0.0426160619,
0.0278745331,
0.0013278979,
-0.0148850782,
-0.0296589211,
0.0496318601,
0.0104087349,
0.0795893744,
0.0148342624,
-0.058510758,
-0.0155019369,
0.0092562782,
0.0021767886,
-0.0597637594,
0.0951021388,
-0.0391015634,
-0.0163433794,
-0.0087611899,
-0.0092613185,
-0.0107767265,
0.0411153249,
-0.040499296,
-0.0340740569,
0.0117706517,
0.0179925337,
0.0121474294,
-0.0389338844,
-0.0796010718,
-0.0480065346,
-0.0140070124,
-0.0233777389,
-0.0204272307,
0.0152992066,
-0.0260872692,
0.0363657326,
-0.0359207317,
0.0193019304,
2.486916486e-34,
0.0540008172,
-0.0300580487,
0.0168223958,
-0.0168041978,
0.0493347682,
0.0083212014,
0.0086540841,
-0.0047094906,
0.0134996977,
-0.058208432,
-0.0276978258
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.04021v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.04021v4 | A Study on the Calibration of In-context Learning | 2023-12-07T03:37:39 | 2024-03-28T03:01:45 | Hanlin Zhang, Yi-Fan Zhang, Yaodong Yu, Dhruv Madeka, Dean Foster, Eric Xing, Himabindu Lakkaraju, Sham Kakade | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Accurate uncertainty quantification is crucial for the safe deployment of
machine learning models, and prior research has demonstrated improvements in
the calibration of modern language models (LMs). We study in-context learning
(ICL), a prevalent method for adapting static LMs through tailored prompts, and
examine the balance between performance and calibration across a broad spectrum
of natural language understanding and reasoning tasks. Through comprehensive
experiments, we observe that, with an increasing number of ICL examples, models
initially exhibit increased miscalibration before achieving better calibration
and miscalibration tends to arise in low-shot settings. Moreover, we find that
methods aimed at improving usability, such as fine-tuning and chain-of-thought
(CoT) prompting, can lead to miscalibration and unreliable natural language
explanations. Furthermore, we explore recalibration techniques and find that a
scaling-binning calibrator can reduce calibration errors consistently. | [
0.011403081,
0.0205383282,
-0.0233725738,
0.0357374512,
-0.0246660523,
0.0124615422,
0.0304376092,
-0.027023958,
-0.0332947373,
-0.0596410409,
-0.028082557,
-0.0548641011,
0.0374915339,
0.0168365519,
-0.0070729987,
-0.0536911823,
0.0319799148,
-0.0396099538,
0.0141620394,
0.0157838669,
-0.0019490306,
0.0019974036,
-0.0308435746,
0.0347251408,
-0.0190851297,
-0.0421583503,
-0.0226770137,
0.0394183248,
0.0277439225,
-0.0266032126,
0.0109743895,
0.0578000881,
0.0275882892,
0.0239730421,
0.0000022057,
-0.070603244,
0.0075243437,
-0.0156134861,
-0.0659104735,
-0.007090732,
0.0311675686,
-0.0112921577,
0.0074663595,
0.0528044105,
-0.0428093225,
0.0407896563,
0.0481313616,
-0.0078405263,
0.0044917893,
0.0356031843,
0.0156252719,
0.0031858459,
-0.0034422751,
-0.0092081055,
-0.0139708286,
-0.0825687125,
-0.0211738553,
0.0056629544,
-0.0366795771,
0.025024252,
-0.0189087689,
0.0190560799,
0.0343735255,
0.0019482832,
0.0125854462,
0.0215197299,
-0.0235185418,
-0.0312033724,
-0.0355024077,
0.0470263697,
0.0069048819,
-0.0481015928,
-0.0430023484,
-0.0470543578,
0.0202233158,
-0.007030833,
-0.0326841958,
0.0158493724,
0.0094854431,
0.0065807253,
-0.0431729145,
-0.0073594963,
0.0562664866,
0.024478443,
0.0086863823,
0.0654796138,
-0.0416682996,
-0.0173439123,
-0.0175068472,
0.00025542,
-0.028332483,
-0.0545594059,
0.0051766797,
0.0503157936,
-0.0879480541,
0.028751703,
-0.0635809824,
-0.0219004806,
0.0223600175,
-0.014723734,
0.0284299999,
0.0440105759,
-0.0131563451,
0.0401893817,
0.0071012364,
0.0596089922,
0.0302215759,
-0.0088005662,
-0.0405202359,
0.0149152083,
-0.0522815771,
-0.0182299968,
-0.0241966583,
-0.0239549167,
-0.0347742438,
-0.0145315053,
-0.0521472394,
0.0329424143,
-0.0100399526,
0.0158522855,
-0.0327226743,
0.0110367304,
-0.0426349603,
-0.0140897585,
-0.0285327733,
0.0282666236,
-0.0493642874,
0.0430730358,
0.0350446887,
-0.0703011677,
-0.0097618205,
-0.001860212,
-0.0196900424,
-0.0010314649,
0.0072290478,
0.0306377094,
0.006087929,
-0.0475812145,
-0.0194086414,
-0.0390673727,
-0.066244401,
-0.0696070194,
-0.0491419137,
-0.0615247749,
-0.0024710989,
0.0387310721,
-0.0032841975,
-0.0230676755,
0.003431174,
0.0340011977,
-0.0475776941,
0.1052644029,
-0.0304149613,
0.0097410437,
-0.0040778024,
0.0181168336,
-0.0326410905,
0.0926224068,
0.043228142,
0.0067445422,
0.0372666493,
-0.0019859977,
0.0253166091,
0.0162368827,
0.0137021691,
0.0008633694,
-0.0314636827,
0.0026989763,
-0.0092689721,
0.0388578214,
0.0139859859,
0.0316951312,
-0.0027687349,
0.0481085107,
0.0814454779,
0.062105678,
0.0006032516,
-0.018313989,
-0.0112933731,
-0.0112360083,
-0.0033780737,
-0.0231583025,
-0.103892155,
0.0119832559,
-0.0642095208,
0.0022515976,
-0.0089921458,
0.0135107851,
0.0052666594,
-0.0591742881,
-0.042255301,
0.0057990677,
0.0224628132,
0.046521578,
0.0216151495,
0.0070181182,
-0.0046849041,
0.0309419427,
0.0121514313,
-0.0287971329,
-0.0103962719,
-0.0377145447,
-0.005581541,
0.0843087956,
0.0325584188,
-0.0099212611,
-0.0137129193,
-0.0179914646,
0.0484378412,
0.0181741621,
0.0600182228,
0.0041377624,
0.0155748222,
-0.0452072211,
-0.0498998649,
-0.0288764536,
0.0206045639,
-0.0256598201,
0.0203919504,
0.008144577,
0.0193301719,
-0.0494311601,
-0.0233366489,
0.0280089434,
0.0060476647,
-0.0458036773,
-0.0015942759,
0.0205143783,
-0.00452777,
0.0158711839,
0.0179225113,
0.0027551854,
0.0134656141,
0.026866667,
0.0230665263,
0.0026907632,
-0.0547149479,
0.0074575869,
0.0477594174,
0.011632124,
-0.0222292393,
-0.036292702,
-0.0502234064,
-0.0224777218,
-0.0278085396,
-0.0163037404,
0.0056502428,
-0.0315437429,
0.0332354791,
-0.0535478257,
-0.0030041111,
-0.0585265905,
0.0554300211,
-0.0125211133,
-0.0008472282,
0.0146181257,
0.0139427576,
-0.0052831927,
-0.0198767595,
-0.0054438747,
-0.0208546016,
-0.0019237021,
0.0125822257,
0.0144369276,
0.0158593506,
-0.0527937338,
0.0079524489,
-0.0833873227,
-0.0076842606,
-0.043527808,
0.0019079671,
0.0389020778,
0.0226924215,
-0.0127548147,
-0.02897029,
-0.0071397284,
0.0183173735,
-0.0120356157,
0.0353743248,
0.0297596324,
-0.010652191,
-0.0035891985,
-0.0297044069,
0.0005890744,
-0.0378606804,
0.0363753065,
0.0275107324,
0.0215035658,
-0.0875436962,
0.037866015,
-0.0015130132,
0.0022441701,
-0.011354886,
0.0022684534,
0.0461386889,
0.0282065663,
0.0191480462,
0.0996371731,
0.0011359417,
0.0236065462,
0.0773676932,
0.0370360166,
-0.0515538864,
0.0136934035,
-0.0014812093,
-0.0685475245,
-0.0168128069,
-0.0136332493,
-0.0145874135,
0.0506117679,
-0.0014633398,
0.0057359901,
-0.0498154536,
0.0458258688,
-0.0172178857,
-0.0447796173,
-0.0860255212,
-0.0180035811,
-0.0134019889,
0.0903834701,
-0.0184772015,
-0.0773423091,
0.0785504878,
-0.0418625399,
0.0228652172,
-0.0244468469,
-0.0279675927,
0.0100380899,
0.0485783927,
-0.0218204502,
0.0012744821,
0.0306320414,
0.0003621881,
-0.0770579875,
-0.0358020626,
0.0356469825,
-0.035955064,
0.0415653214,
-0.0645607635,
-0.006390112,
0.001123104,
-0.0349474438,
-0.0600937046,
-0.0302633066,
-0.0542557761,
-0.0132688293,
-0.0031775539,
-0.0076459115,
-0.0092728734,
0.0056067165,
0.0263354722,
0.0113358526,
-0.0044958144,
-0.0385102704,
-0.0128978128,
0.0027736062,
0.0455991402,
0.0294557475,
0.0648714676,
-0.0222639814,
0.0024456566,
0.0425003208,
0.0400727801,
0.0119358841,
-0.0511874184,
0.0160638224,
0.0309400633,
0.005589731,
-0.0101488112,
0.0803210586,
0.0971360132,
-0.055553738,
-0.0309721883,
0.1392636746,
0.038969554,
-0.0588840954,
0.0183029268,
-0.0405514613,
0.0248480868,
0.0333955362,
0.0062747006,
-0.0779347047,
-0.0594201684,
0.0463544056,
0.0525974222,
0.0043463544,
-0.0156481676,
0.0060585318,
-0.1191876084,
0.0103630861,
-0.0028532981,
-0.0227807704,
-0.0405855998,
-0.0399842039,
0.0114114545,
-0.0059997551,
0.0768157542,
0.0270825028,
0.003503283,
0.0161886662,
0.0201439112,
-0.0111875273,
-0.0536772646,
0.0286149327,
-0.0644690767,
0.0488303341,
0.0668925494,
-0.0114751505,
0.0306682698,
-0.0032729716,
0.0486274101,
-0.016961148,
0.0249245595,
0.0016581877,
0.0366804227,
-0.0000902837,
0.0081033623,
-0.0145399775,
0.0392616242,
-0.0305539556,
-0.05482224,
0.0040710578,
0.0535617657,
-0.0118044224,
0.0203876272,
-0.0185867008,
0.00161584,
0.0333001465,
0.0697403625,
0.0310862828,
-0.0511046275,
-0.023552224,
-0.0298194997,
0.0164369121,
-0.0054538571,
0.0102819316,
0.0345644541,
0.0178291183,
-0.0078091621,
-0.0276178941,
-0.0368942842,
0.0223068614,
0.0428610258,
0.030313259,
-0.00857257,
-0.0034350054,
0.0290748421,
-0.0242286902,
0.0417503454,
-0.0337579623,
0.0443919748,
-0.0260618068,
0.0357265063,
0.0138592748,
-0.0232263356,
0.0047272202,
0.0469735935,
-0.0713710412,
-0.0599465221,
-0.0046756328,
0.0539221279,
0.0327879563,
0.0780725405,
-0.0302609336,
-0.057991311,
0.0318288654,
0.0486064143,
-0.0127063999,
0.0095701106,
-0.0021491454,
0.0285769515,
-0.0049033221,
0.0420996174,
-0.0533237793,
-0.018511394,
0.0115947742,
0.0460918583,
-0.069836393,
-0.0740939826,
0.0365491249,
-0.0151246358,
0.0722621456,
-0.0356068648,
-0.0462331735,
0.0181427151,
0.0240343437,
-0.0058270441,
-0.0356821977,
0.0001181201,
-0.0171905756,
0.0234995428,
-0.0259637963,
0.0048803166,
-0.0287894197,
0.0038670525,
0.0216136314,
-0.019122364,
-0.0044301138,
0.0291131046,
0.0322200134,
0.0309963003,
0.0035865901,
-0.0162807666,
0.0311625376,
-0.0171328951,
0.0484454632,
0.0229920987,
0.0731733516,
0.0220037047,
0.0023549683,
-0.0468786135,
0.0258017965,
-0.0759225935,
-0.0443718024,
-0.0119234947,
0.0452727228,
0.0408158414,
-0.0213647392,
0.0187564828,
-0.0030940778,
-0.0071365903,
-0.0132413693,
0.024940189,
0.0158864576,
-0.0196206812,
0.0411571935,
0.0179220568,
-0.005253627,
0.0107243517,
0.0498576537,
-0.0324988738,
0.0360692665,
-0.0024756149,
-0.0354277715,
-0.0069492054,
0.0031195115,
-0.0172414705,
0.0390855633,
-0.0214717332,
0.0132796904,
-0.0614696033,
-0.0781105608,
-0.0104955463,
0.0417915918,
0.0241075549,
-0.0320247933,
0.0291680209,
0.0918365121,
-0.0114736408,
-0.040172942,
-0.0072506345,
0.0202167407,
-0.004632114,
0.0091982754,
-0.0668219849,
-6.565077175e-33,
-0.0327749178,
-0.0319373272,
0.0049672262,
0.0158211496,
0.0111923264,
-0.0079920627,
-0.0149758356,
0.0303644892,
-0.0223128945,
0.0119736269,
-0.0263128206,
0.0159961693,
0.0218192954,
0.0101694399,
0.0169249028,
-0.0514238998,
0.0133618303,
-0.0062626717,
-0.0580622368,
-0.0171152614,
0.0324103348,
0.0135070765,
0.0228689462,
-0.0658841208,
0.0319803134,
0.0290186815,
-0.0157053545,
0.0429491065,
-0.0168334451,
0.0296850316,
0.0035016653,
0.0395564474,
0.0157240834,
0.0000120539,
-0.0028497546,
0.0544112511,
-0.0690615699,
-0.0216593873,
0.0275817066,
0.0432056226,
-0.02320466,
-0.0272885915,
0.0597793497,
-0.0128394458,
-0.053475745,
-0.0073613562,
0.0300455093,
-0.0496736914,
-0.0303521007,
-0.0248812865,
-0.0408657119,
-0.0167522468,
-0.0278557297,
-0.0492914245,
-0.0144369127,
0.0537629239,
-0.0096420208,
0.0180638302,
-0.0735026374,
-0.0098559884,
0.0135669019,
0.0126456795,
0.1106450036,
0.0561926924,
-0.0301900655,
0.040894594,
0.006868124,
0.0245145019,
-0.0392722115,
-0.0248768851,
0.0382862985,
0.0014028115,
0.0548445098,
0.0731848776,
0.0554623865,
0.0135643026,
-0.0499121957,
0.0188531857,
-0.0024703692,
0.0454496928,
0.0438206904,
0.0283122528,
-0.0657142773,
-0.0269522667,
-0.0733921453,
-0.0363545045,
-0.0456579179,
-0.0027181557,
0.0458675362,
0.0043114247,
-0.0234367959,
-0.0320100188,
0.0049229153,
-0.0334074199,
-0.0051096343,
-0.0049408749,
0.016195368,
0.0015366201,
-0.0031970269,
0.0189472754,
-0.0274481606,
0.001438419,
-0.0056570983,
0.0402020849,
0.0394430459,
0.006568749,
0.0371486954,
-0.0078270165,
-0.045194108,
0.0085140001,
-0.0318242982,
0.0263846517,
-0.0030322531,
-0.0098992884,
0.0589342862,
-0.0000949996,
-0.0311377496,
0.0136157144,
0.0047893864,
-0.0201005153,
-0.0086844545,
-0.0209763013,
-0.0246399287,
-0.0043361923,
-0.0358561724,
-0.0265467651,
-0.0082822507,
-0.0088715153,
0.0407796986,
-0.0648739785,
-0.0264107492,
0.0131268566,
2.866e-7,
0.06187566,
0.0565166511,
0.0077820718,
0.0052717119,
0.0018835164,
0.0591021217,
-0.0197154041,
0.0060309507,
0.0505617522,
-0.0474357717,
0.0049077938,
0.0441168174,
0.0514348969,
0.0225453544,
-0.0278682727,
-0.0322512053,
-0.0375270396,
0.0562218539,
-0.0066414513,
0.0288730413,
0.0441450663,
0.0626006573,
0.0189394001,
-0.0180939585,
0.009220669,
-0.0594555885,
0.0366373435,
-0.0622074977,
0.0415983014,
0.0019242116,
0.0196522884,
0.0301641896,
0.0180641469,
0.0525735095,
-0.0031812135,
-0.0029564784,
-0.0389277674,
0.038810797,
-0.0113366293,
-0.0155869424,
-0.0574582703,
-0.0054412545,
0.0312305596,
-0.1029151529,
0.070247978,
-0.0728973895,
-0.0052316296,
-0.0387101285,
-0.0037900824,
-0.0398466773,
0.033180628,
0.0189663917,
-0.0154250422,
0.0034871488,
0.0116776051,
0.0368644409,
-0.0386886336,
-0.0728594735,
-0.0608272627,
0.0564283691,
0.0023743501,
-0.0220975131,
-0.0224763509,
-0.0244064722,
0.0409493856,
-0.0667397901,
0.0109480089,
2.558621641e-34,
0.0215570033,
-0.0124227609,
0.0464753211,
0.0202841572,
0.019133715,
0.019921368,
-0.0023787504,
-0.0109625934,
0.0619847812,
-0.0758547708,
0.0057987799
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.07552v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.07552v1 | Large Language Models for Intent-Driven Session Recommendations | 2023-12-07T02:25:14 | 2023-12-07T02:25:14 | Zhu Sun, Hongyang Liu, Xinghua Qu, Kaidong Feng, Yan Wang, Yew-Soon Ong | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Intent-aware session recommendation (ISR) is pivotal in discerning user
intents within sessions for precise predictions. Traditional approaches,
however, face limitations due to their presumption of a uniform number of
intents across all sessions. This assumption overlooks the dynamic nature of
user sessions, where the number and type of intentions can significantly vary.
In addition, these methods typically operate in latent spaces, thus hinder the
model's transparency.Addressing these challenges, we introduce a novel ISR
approach, utilizing the advanced reasoning capabilities of large language
models (LLMs). First, this approach begins by generating an initial prompt that
guides LLMs to predict the next item in a session, based on the varied intents
manifested in user sessions. Then, to refine this process, we introduce an
innovative prompt optimization mechanism that iteratively self-reflects and
adjusts prompts. Furthermore, our prompt selection module, built upon the LLMs'
broad adaptability, swiftly selects the most optimized prompts across diverse
domains. This new paradigm empowers LLMs to discern diverse user intents at a
semantic level, leading to more accurate and interpretable session
recommendations. Our extensive experiments on three real-world datasets
demonstrate the effectiveness of our method, marking a significant advancement
in ISR systems. | [
0.0719189197,
0.0129895611,
-0.0038161837,
0.0418264642,
-0.0334537625,
-0.0166859906,
0.0391941555,
-0.0309535731,
0.0636386201,
-0.0204966459,
-0.047103487,
-0.0490257964,
0.0033195503,
0.0319465883,
-0.0195933618,
-0.0426862352,
0.0197615232,
-0.0721191764,
-0.0262248144,
0.0278318729,
0.0054969373,
0.0170261338,
0.0045376392,
0.0662250966,
0.0103531964,
-0.0256410111,
-0.0106912367,
0.0013550149,
-0.013807781,
-0.0346994363,
0.0138492854,
0.0416755788,
0.0407640561,
0.0022603427,
0.0000021736,
-0.0509060174,
-0.0270287003,
-0.0454588681,
-0.0425629728,
-0.0131237106,
0.0032641126,
0.0797337517,
0.0262314789,
0.031263005,
-0.0237471089,
0.0328977183,
0.0087201428,
0.0439832397,
0.0198890958,
0.0112158479,
-0.0133810816,
-0.0061137122,
-0.0272981413,
-0.0232647844,
0.0748362616,
-0.0395011455,
0.0192071982,
-0.0345431529,
0.0087710004,
0.013079646,
0.0252845231,
-0.0039601563,
0.0007325956,
-0.0213362239,
0.0332965516,
0.02048501,
0.019632116,
-0.0237883702,
-0.0231908374,
0.0763131455,
0.0218842309,
0.008314535,
0.0060526328,
-0.0087076947,
-0.0060017593,
-0.0091752838,
-0.0405783616,
-0.0073190178,
-0.0208128616,
0.0017906725,
0.0345396958,
0.0429393202,
0.0486126132,
0.0384078212,
-0.0194711853,
0.0656776428,
0.0212433897,
-0.0263683032,
-0.0089355158,
-0.0062422417,
0.0157502331,
-0.0547083542,
0.0279447958,
0.0269791111,
-0.1304384172,
0.0332738832,
-0.0007908805,
0.0654859766,
0.0067583481,
0.0214506369,
0.0079132067,
0.0622164011,
0.0123031437,
0.0758678094,
0.0148026953,
0.0031596222,
0.0174131133,
-0.0350997522,
-0.0636433363,
-0.0004740871,
-0.0267797988,
0.0163805597,
-0.0180569161,
0.0145425266,
-0.0389832892,
-0.0379515551,
-0.02666023,
0.0916167125,
0.0154712815,
0.0244973935,
0.0285960492,
0.0202381574,
-0.0129468339,
-0.0113541428,
-0.0495184958,
-0.0021137181,
-0.0396730974,
0.0381284617,
0.0269034933,
-0.0338782743,
0.0044509289,
0.0230652597,
0.0020682821,
-0.0285744332,
-0.0237257127,
0.0239344481,
0.0043296008,
-0.048979111,
-0.0377652124,
-0.0799503624,
-0.0040141237,
-0.0459111892,
-0.0469132587,
-0.0533332042,
0.0412059724,
0.0340288319,
-0.0021196236,
-0.0269527119,
-0.0025585552,
0.0240462832,
-0.0029809114,
0.0778159276,
0.0193126462,
0.0136462981,
0.0139745027,
0.0311531257,
-0.0203831028,
0.006965511,
-0.0265798811,
0.1078321487,
0.0412230715,
0.003183224,
0.0177200977,
0.0376132131,
-0.0276182648,
0.0103736548,
0.0239916891,
0.0312621221,
0.0248889327,
0.0221033301,
-0.0121363718,
0.0344334766,
-0.0361981615,
0.0116237756,
0.0748951957,
0.0658807904,
-0.0302644987,
0.0132480636,
0.0652971715,
0.014656553,
-0.0417111218,
-0.02040793,
-0.0214530285,
0.0331183933,
-0.0283073355,
-0.0437458754,
0.0808924586,
0.0219118726,
-0.0313410312,
-0.0361554436,
0.0277692992,
-0.0063121212,
0.0381190293,
0.0423469469,
0.0094544822,
-0.0326250903,
-0.0596810728,
0.0467281789,
0.026248442,
0.0003779575,
-0.00703402,
-0.0738148689,
0.1020789221,
0.1292878389,
0.0591861382,
-0.0403528549,
-0.0100781126,
-0.0176424123,
0.0285570584,
-0.0114017604,
0.046918124,
-0.0261437912,
0.0059710792,
-0.0388996564,
-0.0547519736,
0.0367037207,
-0.0126399165,
0.0090760179,
-0.0072596488,
-0.0001150256,
0.0138539784,
0.0115453741,
0.0101079466,
0.0012555288,
-0.0292186681,
-0.03301166,
0.0373805985,
0.0310698133,
0.0559606291,
0.0174800903,
0.0645367801,
-0.00466605,
0.006090079,
-0.0270527247,
-0.009938932,
0.0258680582,
-0.057132002,
-0.0113747045,
0.0305456817,
0.0227655787,
-0.0149443531,
-0.0187376421,
-0.0110333506,
-0.0190328099,
-0.0099738296,
0.0020937447,
0.0587796494,
-0.0291481186,
0.020118054,
0.0236265175,
0.0025942719,
-0.0176105686,
0.0625034347,
-0.0027069163,
-0.0062114932,
0.0385168493,
-0.0061824936,
0.0043479316,
-0.0238850694,
-0.0190383047,
-0.0106659019,
-0.016769927,
0.0067496868,
0.036972139,
-0.0023478926,
-0.0532706082,
-0.0042043091,
-0.0880627707,
0.0206629373,
-0.0217303317,
-0.0214669388,
-0.0002343697,
0.0540554337,
0.0088966154,
-0.0222567115,
-0.0216938518,
0.0199996438,
-0.0189618878,
0.0209829248,
0.0027339803,
0.0127632795,
-0.0282066632,
-0.0159025304,
0.0097250082,
-0.013330901,
0.0256789867,
-0.0183084533,
0.0052919351,
-0.0784415826,
0.0060194456,
-0.0242368821,
-0.0158424713,
-0.0372986272,
0.0167424381,
0.0001722681,
-0.0451185517,
0.03940567,
0.044695206,
0.0327586941,
0.0002932056,
0.0269291215,
-0.0074828104,
-0.0747522935,
0.0001899035,
-0.0296655297,
0.0066663669,
-0.0213708505,
-0.0563858785,
0.0218048934,
0.0233468153,
-0.0006018925,
0.0087502105,
-0.0495750755,
-0.0075404407,
-0.0073990053,
-0.0052635022,
-0.0657666028,
0.0158478171,
-0.0149534661,
0.0359228514,
0.0151836313,
-0.0381184183,
0.0698430538,
-0.0021230653,
0.0026835545,
-0.0330707543,
-0.0179475751,
-0.0394876413,
0.0347466618,
-0.0096057467,
0.031616468,
-0.0160358809,
-0.0317303836,
-0.0051381853,
-0.0059999712,
0.000840987,
-0.0287875757,
0.0686246976,
-0.0282595102,
-0.0013878767,
0.0369560532,
-0.0638251752,
-0.0597659498,
-0.0924406573,
-0.0298073292,
-0.0251732469,
-0.0105972337,
0.0080810003,
-0.0698393807,
-0.014347448,
0.0132855531,
0.0488017313,
-0.0266894214,
-0.0357704498,
-0.0199991949,
-0.0059255073,
0.0616641007,
0.0018462287,
-0.0131959505,
-0.0112501327,
0.0382807814,
0.0298460722,
-0.0123107154,
-0.0528728887,
-0.0057989,
0.0137109356,
0.0674571991,
-0.0087025566,
-0.0097293975,
0.0919065475,
0.0492605753,
-0.0137984324,
-0.0081704576,
0.1175026372,
0.0525985956,
-0.1089206189,
-0.0038803208,
-0.039395228,
0.0149404192,
0.0292345434,
0.0207041018,
-0.0486871935,
-0.0678752735,
0.0156134982,
0.0273964033,
0.0148764066,
-0.0325621665,
-0.0183659457,
-0.0725820735,
0.0217923373,
0.0024929205,
-0.0283278208,
0.0152872251,
-0.0648543611,
0.0109657245,
-0.0245539229,
0.0412073135,
0.0137425046,
-0.0324176773,
-0.0227199011,
0.0097624687,
-0.0165501218,
-0.0266395155,
0.0510504767,
-0.0336091891,
0.0570134856,
0.0470203869,
0.0280140582,
0.0135156531,
-0.0241328441,
-0.011686583,
0.0056396127,
-0.0048292638,
-0.0291033555,
-0.0059262533,
0.0022261427,
0.0373474732,
-0.0434317179,
0.0573340431,
-0.0513281748,
-0.0641197041,
0.032994587,
0.0755377486,
-0.0363060758,
0.0098945294,
-0.020429777,
0.0058746231,
0.0563755073,
0.0996868461,
-0.0023512687,
-0.056937404,
0.0032268453,
-0.0667376742,
-0.0421128646,
0.0229597148,
0.0140671441,
-0.0274193697,
0.0012595764,
0.0146331405,
-0.0388114266,
-0.0310926102,
0.0312025696,
-0.0105125578,
0.0003189776,
0.048147466,
-0.0187712777,
0.0047223675,
0.0303124599,
0.0351949669,
-0.0248630606,
0.0543934591,
-0.0887963027,
0.0230857022,
0.0101470351,
-0.0966816396,
0.0024291237,
0.0150670158,
-0.0338346772,
-0.0388703495,
-0.0285287201,
0.0430397019,
0.0116310203,
0.0469061099,
-0.0301300343,
-0.0550850816,
0.0232236907,
0.0008400795,
-0.0026167592,
-0.034297891,
0.0080556897,
0.063850604,
-0.0052555776,
0.0378353409,
-0.0475653894,
-0.0164427217,
-0.0176223069,
-0.0030069705,
-0.0416291319,
-0.0519282036,
0.0269970112,
0.0256861113,
0.0087401588,
-0.0192290395,
-0.010669372,
-0.0034446632,
0.0387114398,
0.0163522307,
-0.0585255474,
-0.022656763,
0.018834861,
0.0512322709,
-0.0233807862,
-0.0136037068,
0.0092851259,
-0.0105486074,
0.0061054551,
-0.0497839153,
-0.0096072797,
-0.0096770562,
-0.0132271294,
0.0410067551,
0.0016951849,
-0.0209570564,
-0.0028187076,
0.0105321165,
0.0408834182,
-0.037170954,
0.0950145796,
0.0087763527,
-0.0149035128,
-0.0352401771,
0.0548988096,
-0.0321527198,
-0.0693356022,
0.016419895,
0.0272748675,
0.0229193028,
-0.0104806703,
0.0041730506,
-0.036196705,
0.0055791624,
-0.0408292972,
0.023981275,
0.0185739864,
-0.03240918,
0.0077238046,
0.0439713672,
-0.0201647561,
0.019083593,
0.0531801693,
-0.084750019,
0.0056840559,
0.0197642967,
-0.057439521,
-0.0451168045,
0.008324774,
0.0185863264,
0.0492137149,
-0.0517002456,
-0.0304583758,
-0.0166386049,
-0.0301178768,
-0.0152635984,
-0.030764956,
-0.018599363,
-0.0087051429,
0.0453705825,
0.0818040743,
-0.0087692197,
-0.0345376581,
-0.0674886331,
-0.0209308565,
-0.0323233232,
-0.0126645286,
-0.058955811,
-6.421356827e-33,
0.0178796649,
0.001366758,
0.0315483436,
-0.0092037804,
0.0118523063,
-0.014328951,
-0.0363544337,
-0.0130509995,
0.0284038056,
-0.0157032534,
-0.0258221086,
-0.0077560865,
0.0181194935,
0.0234081037,
0.0156603437,
-0.0297121573,
0.0588947907,
0.0294360053,
-0.0238017458,
0.0533594824,
0.0464691818,
0.0139001608,
-0.0260353442,
-0.0572227128,
0.0214711856,
-0.0047289669,
-0.0034883979,
0.016585771,
-0.0174610335,
0.0481847376,
-0.0408691391,
0.0461174659,
0.0128396889,
-0.0455354974,
0.0026318696,
0.0427117869,
-0.0369289368,
-0.0088950815,
0.0362326503,
-0.0081885001,
-0.0362271518,
-0.0395071544,
-0.0317434706,
-0.0103692878,
-0.0160781518,
0.0044960356,
0.0191675629,
0.0079461662,
-0.0269641895,
0.0185387563,
-0.0330133438,
-0.0153941521,
-0.0148966601,
-0.0397720635,
0.0074987747,
0.0561861023,
-0.0057708998,
0.0364740826,
-0.0672723576,
0.0577960573,
-0.0609019026,
0.0031006301,
0.0181559008,
-0.0137367332,
-0.0101778153,
0.0420554243,
0.002431585,
-0.0174138341,
0.0131168868,
-0.0141731901,
-0.0614489689,
0.0474825278,
-0.0173315145,
0.009774955,
0.0141168246,
0.0033966128,
-0.0487113148,
0.035078045,
0.0800056234,
0.004571253,
0.0564650632,
0.0109621016,
-0.0345552489,
-0.0015184724,
-0.0222977698,
0.0383330733,
-0.0389161557,
-0.0238330308,
0.0462710112,
0.0384625457,
-0.020238651,
-0.0104678338,
0.0495138466,
-0.0384795777,
-0.037935324,
0.0234367885,
0.0053585158,
-0.0212789588,
0.0159820653,
0.0321921781,
-0.0453458875,
-0.0174469166,
0.0079148328,
-0.0873817578,
-0.0173077229,
0.0292075295,
0.0021389974,
0.0261916798,
-0.0175118912,
0.0139519358,
-0.0290512312,
0.0059488835,
-0.0248537436,
0.0371183716,
0.0641637146,
0.0123279821,
-0.0344348401,
0.081729427,
0.0222896226,
-0.0055498169,
-0.015062348,
-0.0847618356,
0.0076891733,
-0.0054740896,
-0.0211088061,
-0.0239815917,
-0.0347788334,
-0.0411402099,
0.0423651524,
-0.0384139605,
-0.0152096488,
-0.0145919425,
2.899e-7,
-0.0384960733,
0.0496380925,
-0.0680161566,
0.0262129735,
-0.0016102109,
0.0460578799,
0.0239700116,
0.0553546362,
0.0439826027,
0.0131736407,
0.0471863374,
0.0226303786,
0.0251391195,
-0.0046132114,
-0.0785321817,
0.0037050506,
-0.0323787257,
-0.0105748381,
-0.0678785071,
0.0062166322,
0.0153695541,
0.0997530967,
0.019865945,
-0.0132587161,
0.046062272,
-0.0417652875,
0.0130548729,
-0.0579251014,
-0.0259081982,
0.0092190625,
0.0445696265,
-0.0140413167,
0.003982849,
-0.0044450513,
-0.0307018589,
0.0088030184,
-0.0089655584,
0.0559380464,
0.0108179031,
-0.0367464684,
-0.0389757045,
-0.0084942998,
0.0387041681,
-0.0530540384,
0.0972269922,
0.0037759133,
-0.0054674759,
-0.0016537701,
-0.0093018916,
-0.0188019834,
0.0155265601,
-0.0002044157,
-0.0024532299,
-0.0000235522,
0.0157370288,
0.0073194872,
-0.0181494448,
-0.0916035324,
0.0101873353,
-0.0333762579,
-0.0591140427,
-0.0239115078,
-0.0533116609,
0.0401323326,
-0.0029634926,
-0.0919087753,
0.0302894749,
2.725212379e-34,
0.0096182255,
0.0295079276,
0.011909334,
0.0189043861,
0.0386985652,
0.0120177194,
-0.0316757485,
0.0399898104,
0.0581307821,
-0.0777151659,
-0.0152303353
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03987v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03987v1 | Cost-Effective In-Context Learning for Entity Resolution: A Design Space Exploration | 2023-12-07T02:09:27 | 2023-12-07T02:09:27 | Meihao Fan, Xiaoyue Han, Ju Fan, Chengliang Chai, Nan Tang, Guoliang Li, Xiaoyong Du | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Entity resolution (ER) is an important data integration task with a wide
spectrum of applications. The state-of-the-art solutions on ER rely on
pre-trained language models (PLMs), which require fine-tuning on a lot of
labeled matching/non-matching entity pairs. Recently, large languages models
(LLMs), such as GPT-4, have shown the ability to perform many tasks without
tuning model parameters, which is known as in-context learning (ICL) that
facilitates effective learning from a few labeled input context demonstrations.
However, existing ICL approaches to ER typically necessitate providing a task
description and a set of demonstrations for each entity pair and thus have
limitations on the monetary cost of interfacing LLMs. To address the problem,
in this paper, we provide a comprehensive study to investigate how to develop a
cost-effective batch prompting approach to ER. We introduce a framework BATCHER
consisting of demonstration selection and question batching and explore
different design choices that support batch prompting for ER. We also devise a
covering-based demonstration selection strategy that achieves an effective
balance between matching accuracy and monetary cost. We conduct a thorough
evaluation to explore the design space and evaluate our proposed strategies.
Through extensive experiments, we find that batch prompting is very
cost-effective for ER, compared with not only PLM-based methods fine-tuned with
extensive labeled data but also LLM-based methods with manually designed
prompting. We also provide guidance for selecting appropriate design choices
for batch prompting. | [
0.012953449,
0.0168927182,
0.0120397573,
0.0332769156,
-0.0405278131,
0.02521386,
0.0398759022,
0.0146060167,
0.0460167937,
-0.0162639134,
-0.0145034958,
-0.025504984,
-0.0166852325,
-0.0082709165,
0.0086359754,
-0.0615051314,
0.0452948064,
-0.0111129666,
-0.0074330512,
-0.0064531201,
-0.0203179959,
0.012605967,
-0.0127500007,
-0.0106421728,
-0.0205015931,
-0.0053742486,
-0.0435746051,
0.0215912536,
0.0425298475,
-0.0407155119,
0.027581403,
0.0566704609,
0.0272698496,
0.0519010238,
0.0000021199,
-0.0611021332,
-0.053811159,
0.018329557,
-0.071253106,
0.0024748109,
0.0089316834,
-0.0047600009,
-0.0052337148,
0.022376243,
-0.0049412185,
-0.0393422581,
0.0444885381,
0.0554004088,
0.0432733931,
0.0362878367,
-0.0213567205,
-0.014172948,
-0.0236574039,
-0.0313754231,
-0.0178158972,
-0.0608272851,
0.0470907986,
-0.0243664291,
0.0450383946,
-0.0086287493,
-0.0173849426,
0.0530155599,
0.0198301133,
0.0389168896,
-0.0293379091,
0.0282353275,
-0.0138127096,
0.013321572,
-0.0187656786,
0.0542818792,
-0.0126963658,
0.0096856588,
0.0252803545,
-0.010782538,
-0.0058912453,
-0.0150328632,
-0.0244685411,
-0.0395621918,
-0.021532461,
0.0132187624,
-0.0369274542,
-0.011737098,
-0.0122970566,
0.0006412379,
-0.0575051904,
0.0207137112,
0.0164457764,
-0.0342033803,
0.0104735736,
0.0034422087,
-0.0037357055,
-0.0849302337,
0.010351276,
0.0484435782,
-0.0823133513,
0.0357484035,
-0.048272159,
-0.0356692523,
-0.0130821541,
0.0015183449,
-0.034105055,
0.0253986567,
0.0228320584,
0.058789324,
-0.02915252,
0.0513159297,
-0.0001577905,
0.023496395,
-0.028612636,
-0.0204956066,
-0.0484209172,
0.0316657349,
-0.0965954438,
0.0377274342,
-0.0490691513,
-0.0233156346,
-0.0281319488,
0.0157475788,
-0.0188144185,
0.0273167565,
-0.0313592367,
-0.0344417393,
-0.0264818519,
-0.0048253955,
-0.044397071,
0.0039067538,
-0.0202527363,
-0.0151276877,
-0.0263486467,
-0.0396479443,
-0.0203891173,
-0.0366562307,
0.0275477115,
-0.0472418554,
0.0357920416,
0.0366635323,
0.0031857346,
-0.073055841,
-0.066072695,
-0.0080305496,
0.0270369761,
-0.0501241684,
-0.0672974288,
-0.0609816164,
0.0494732484,
-0.0003210838,
-0.0133330449,
-0.0339087956,
0.0070844539,
0.0211330205,
-0.0377698839,
0.0934286714,
-0.0108855059,
0.0416633524,
0.0427774563,
-0.0123757813,
-0.0129448995,
0.0558323301,
0.0086597707,
0.0026015323,
0.0104546091,
0.0039161267,
0.0201508235,
0.049193278,
0.0542630851,
-0.0005998006,
-0.0052388422,
0.0319341645,
0.0532848537,
0.0418937393,
0.0148191629,
0.0538351387,
-0.0048173927,
0.0042204834,
0.0241507217,
0.0392075554,
-0.0031752277,
-0.0286944713,
0.0089212582,
0.0222320892,
0.0023255369,
-0.001618542,
-0.0381087661,
0.0081735179,
-0.0180934537,
-0.0193972699,
0.0681259781,
0.0264413878,
-0.0681570843,
-0.0062136129,
0.0277070981,
-0.0008823518,
-0.0199962631,
0.0549951009,
0.0584692247,
0.0104221022,
-0.0710321143,
0.0223759543,
0.0149040045,
-0.0182093251,
-0.0202186685,
-0.026870558,
-0.0079963943,
0.0506601073,
0.0472976342,
-0.0322871804,
-0.0333494358,
-0.0191441923,
0.0264813323,
0.006298101,
0.0456411541,
-0.0269598085,
0.0299165715,
-0.002374809,
-0.0509033613,
0.0355550982,
-0.0312318914,
0.036341995,
0.0630510598,
0.0118814548,
0.0169653613,
-0.0551040955,
-0.0158370715,
0.0552031174,
-0.0235625487,
-0.0286949258,
0.0052356827,
0.0480167493,
0.0230272859,
0.0167868473,
-0.010839452,
-0.0294248275,
0.0272327028,
0.0099388799,
0.0300963577,
-0.0313732438,
0.0026220377,
-0.0684844553,
0.0068343501,
-0.0094419438,
-0.0570658185,
-0.037200287,
-0.0558810495,
-0.0563251264,
-0.0654420033,
-0.0141295586,
0.0333553031,
-0.0422089212,
0.0254255012,
0.0116097312,
-0.0155492229,
-0.0649236143,
0.0864843726,
0.0223467685,
0.0267840773,
0.0415721126,
0.0328020789,
-0.0076507591,
-0.0902347714,
-0.0372548178,
0.014249525,
0.0103939101,
-0.0050064223,
-0.0059912936,
-0.0162250306,
-0.0730985478,
0.0104586771,
-0.0790129378,
0.0331157036,
-0.0079055196,
0.0255655609,
-0.0109417895,
0.056080021,
-0.0325617343,
-0.0493017025,
-0.0281179287,
-0.0550444499,
0.0258244965,
0.0278258566,
0.0145228514,
0.0460631363,
-0.0442961454,
0.0115980795,
0.0033284803,
-0.0001218617,
0.0185587257,
0.0095681017,
-0.0441074334,
-0.052824609,
0.0351869501,
-0.020127723,
0.0166669935,
0.0144387288,
0.0572269261,
-0.0150259631,
0.0062403483,
0.0194531865,
0.0255631246,
-0.0200225916,
-0.0013803896,
-0.0032548315,
-0.0171542652,
-0.0960293859,
0.0394113511,
-0.0024195858,
-0.0032207856,
0.0195897613,
0.0148563366,
0.0318881236,
0.009002897,
-0.0445128344,
-0.0084525626,
-0.0561708733,
0.0233118236,
0.0282832831,
0.0190286897,
-0.0570023879,
-0.0101700574,
-0.0037889681,
0.0440432616,
-0.0411823131,
-0.0211357921,
0.0871903896,
-0.0206740368,
-0.0073482357,
-0.0264621079,
0.0235956404,
-0.005990841,
0.0245299079,
0.0108767152,
0.0169294905,
-0.0012672128,
-0.0832514614,
-0.0313939899,
0.0360492803,
0.0042514675,
-0.0355124138,
0.0597518124,
-0.0387156196,
0.059964519,
-0.0247561801,
-0.0216856524,
-0.076212056,
0.0151136136,
-0.0105241416,
-0.0020895076,
-0.0212707333,
0.0404906422,
-0.0140023436,
0.0453413576,
0.0225261431,
0.060278751,
0.0211351905,
-0.0183953624,
-0.0302443914,
-0.0026163361,
-0.0240347888,
0.0316609293,
0.0168392695,
-0.0332338214,
0.0036564788,
0.0134928748,
0.0920990929,
-0.0333025865,
0.0110659394,
0.0187599212,
0.0203667823,
-0.0775372609,
0.014670291,
0.0079639489,
0.036867518,
-0.0305794105,
0.0135895628,
0.1007837504,
0.031325642,
-0.0368849039,
-0.0255159736,
0.04409853,
0.0012355335,
0.0246294886,
0.0598248094,
-0.1098814309,
-0.0094563933,
0.0119442251,
0.0343944281,
0.0228406992,
-0.0661115125,
-0.0218862761,
-0.1385711581,
0.0309468508,
-0.0124061676,
-0.062877208,
-0.039711751,
-0.0702884346,
0.0496481545,
0.0090819607,
0.027770998,
0.025370989,
-0.0288082343,
-0.0110329948,
0.0119810607,
0.0499261022,
-0.0662057027,
0.0037126062,
-0.0808687359,
0.0247047283,
0.030462116,
0.0208109133,
0.0194941387,
-0.0186020546,
0.0029545531,
-0.0413129441,
-0.0199236553,
-0.0327307805,
0.0614696294,
-0.0127206743,
-0.0181658361,
-0.0005777387,
0.0300144386,
-0.0108080236,
-0.0102778981,
0.0161739513,
0.0699245185,
-0.0074189091,
0.051893767,
0.0183516201,
-0.0487624556,
0.0553085655,
0.0797674134,
0.0083721792,
-0.0150188273,
-0.0131535409,
0.0078619765,
0.0110256653,
-0.0075119892,
0.0572064668,
0.0058551976,
-0.0950523317,
-0.0144634955,
-0.0337513871,
-0.0322722569,
0.1218678355,
0.0741590858,
0.0140846018,
0.0204581954,
-0.0156122325,
0.0418196991,
-0.0422945768,
0.018625617,
-0.0610381737,
0.0313771255,
-0.0930122137,
-0.0169751775,
0.0021546017,
-0.018772563,
-0.0278559793,
0.0153944809,
-0.0390885472,
-0.075620085,
-0.0081545431,
-0.0007658841,
0.014584071,
0.0910189375,
-0.0112681706,
-0.0080698403,
0.036737293,
0.0412298776,
0.0062802345,
-0.0038916892,
-0.0122083519,
0.0210749879,
-0.0350597799,
0.0335514918,
-0.0511218905,
0.0359989516,
0.0252743904,
0.0161726698,
-0.0458942875,
-0.0703251511,
0.025414031,
0.0481427014,
0.015207394,
0.0011732567,
-0.0291144717,
-0.05496075,
0.0489268079,
0.000610948,
-0.0201918315,
-0.0283051953,
-0.007769736,
-0.0242589172,
0.0100347921,
0.0063845804,
0.0221009478,
0.004927183,
0.0184562132,
-0.0324085169,
-0.0086662881,
-0.0380844586,
0.0126988608,
0.0486811921,
-0.0127567705,
0.0056984602,
0.0229201447,
0.0614933111,
0.0603029132,
-0.0370194204,
0.0430169255,
0.0543944165,
0.0528389178,
-0.020285124,
-0.013704923,
-0.0129019553,
-0.0219328795,
-0.048525881,
0.0417594947,
0.0374006964,
-0.0106059769,
0.0308841597,
-0.024195103,
-0.02073518,
-0.0074073956,
-0.0127647137,
0.0142275058,
-0.0055285082,
0.0260775648,
0.0345628113,
0.0274126139,
0.0206590202,
0.0569556467,
-0.0274650715,
0.03655947,
0.0080479505,
0.0020709077,
-0.0473492369,
-0.0204093736,
0.0298767518,
-0.0184867363,
-0.0088394582,
-0.0122373011,
-0.0109216096,
-0.0438274071,
0.0046156324,
-0.0136110997,
-0.0682296231,
-0.0368131138,
0.0596498288,
0.0330786705,
0.0525623038,
0.0102891745,
0.0071838186,
-0.017659096,
0.0331697986,
-0.0599910244,
-0.0051027564,
-5.821280185e-33,
-0.0652043745,
-0.0337720551,
0.0223469026,
-0.0000095853,
0.0253695454,
-0.0015987376,
-0.0273909885,
-0.0148835741,
-0.0037827496,
-0.0330268927,
-0.0421833172,
-0.003532429,
0.0366426297,
0.0068424731,
-0.0226260629,
-0.0314214565,
0.0630660057,
0.0040354985,
-0.0211789608,
0.0340227522,
0.0000683726,
0.0560282879,
0.0409926847,
-0.0547786094,
0.0125069544,
0.0071167015,
0.0023558387,
0.0274167378,
0.0229718816,
0.0198464319,
-0.0120820543,
-0.0002709578,
0.0043979902,
-0.0436869264,
-0.0269898269,
0.0339451581,
-0.1419825256,
-0.0284147486,
-0.0329866968,
0.0336033702,
-0.0124794692,
-0.0183198731,
0.0390583761,
-0.0287248511,
0.0073992857,
0.0233704709,
0.0266969595,
-0.032514412,
-0.0143100945,
-0.0258002803,
-0.0260312576,
0.0387908444,
0.0207072441,
-0.0147621008,
0.0867490023,
-0.01614457,
0.0206770264,
-0.0067074904,
-0.0665791333,
0.0084032901,
0.0517390817,
-0.0120128021,
0.0167612173,
0.0373725221,
0.0192226749,
0.0056069954,
-0.0089162625,
-0.0047280695,
0.0264256503,
-0.0031380048,
0.0157726631,
0.0252397116,
-0.0134287607,
0.0418710373,
0.063041836,
0.0101277269,
-0.0541481711,
0.0653558895,
0.0223332178,
-0.0232264008,
-0.0210490786,
-0.0079435995,
-0.0350407436,
-0.0332789235,
-0.0337659791,
0.0083213802,
-0.0473412275,
-0.0219579637,
0.0423240624,
0.0259410907,
-0.0424884483,
0.0148882698,
0.0438913628,
-0.0219877902,
-0.0809644163,
-0.0232034177,
0.0427191034,
-0.0003114476,
0.0142772356,
0.0192522854,
-0.0371374115,
-0.0448891371,
0.0211917143,
0.0006492942,
0.0097109443,
-0.0220178906,
0.02088801,
-0.0125067607,
-0.0694295689,
0.0400458351,
-0.0161893833,
0.0549395159,
-0.02710771,
-0.0174475908,
0.0246935952,
-0.0038456365,
0.0490167886,
0.0057215663,
0.0411263369,
-0.0705200806,
-0.0494977944,
0.0395792462,
0.0095455181,
0.0225736052,
-0.0064549288,
0.0144910989,
-0.021500716,
-0.0070107393,
0.0604925901,
-0.0470687002,
-0.0109580876,
0.0339466184,
2.774e-7,
0.0283487234,
0.0174261462,
0.0537732728,
0.033492703,
-0.0129181445,
0.0103415065,
0.0081565902,
0.0249795523,
0.0247785971,
0.0173525866,
0.0262084994,
0.001796832,
0.0305534191,
0.0454950556,
-0.0883890912,
-0.0010953618,
0.0084682293,
0.0162577108,
-0.088007383,
-0.0026709014,
0.0275616143,
0.0530264825,
-0.0085198889,
-0.0068024816,
-0.0129565336,
-0.0084966235,
0.021823734,
-0.0173020232,
0.030112192,
0.0537476912,
-0.017206395,
0.0309304837,
0.005012217,
0.0936468318,
0.0088455779,
0.03422831,
0.0288271029,
0.0448077545,
0.0135166636,
-0.011263865,
0.0057627568,
-0.0217344761,
-0.0073094266,
-0.0297294352,
0.0912733823,
-0.0693048537,
0.0299901273,
0.0483571924,
-0.0103232833,
-0.0562157445,
-0.0311163832,
0.0350215584,
-0.0075560985,
0.0333625935,
0.0212217588,
-0.0077263331,
-0.0032804492,
-0.0645245537,
0.0330614671,
0.0099274833,
-0.0340641811,
-0.0218993463,
-0.0132587757,
-0.0214020927,
-0.0110900579,
-0.0275726467,
-0.0081106955,
2.842114833e-34,
-0.0140808215,
-0.0068296632,
0.003550234,
0.0196009427,
-0.0029061954,
-0.0227596574,
-0.0384025127,
0.0312513746,
0.0037939714,
-0.0462395437,
-0.0099411206
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.07551v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.07551v1 | Language Model Alignment with Elastic Reset | 2023-12-06T22:53:34 | 2023-12-06T22:53:34 | Michael Noukhovitch, Samuel Lavoie, Florian Strub, Aaron Courville | cs.CL | cs.CL | Finetuning language models with reinforcement learning (RL), e.g. from human
feedback (HF), is a prominent method for alignment. But optimizing against a
reward model can improve on reward while degrading performance in other areas,
a phenomenon known as reward hacking, alignment tax, or language drift. First,
we argue that commonly-used test metrics are insufficient and instead measure
how different algorithms tradeoff between reward and drift. The standard method
modified the reward with a Kullback-Lieber (KL) penalty between the online and
initial model. We propose Elastic Reset, a new algorithm that achieves higher
reward with less drift without explicitly modifying the training objective. We
periodically reset the online model to an exponentially moving average (EMA) of
itself, then reset the EMA model to the initial model. Through the use of an
EMA, our model recovers quickly after resets and achieves higher reward with
less drift in the same number of steps. We demonstrate that fine-tuning
language models with Elastic Reset leads to state-of-the-art performance on a
small scale pivot-translation benchmark, outperforms all baselines in a
medium-scale RLHF-like IMDB mock sentiment task and leads to a more performant
and more aligned technical QA chatbot with LLaMA-7B. Code available at
github.com/mnoukhov/elastic-reset. | [
0.0190168321,
0.0668866858,
-0.0047467062,
0.0059634247,
-0.0305342637,
0.0098875351,
-0.0382144228,
0.0000688912,
-0.0307383686,
-0.0155571261,
-0.0504856147,
-0.0128633361,
-0.0040527801,
0.0433513522,
0.0130764488,
-0.0495567881,
0.0566293709,
-0.0029877676,
0.043463856,
-0.0219385065,
0.0498797633,
0.0006918393,
-0.0325252078,
0.0369656794,
0.0184542704,
-0.0309738442,
-0.0183011219,
0.0256681256,
0.0399850793,
0.0072404565,
0.0309430864,
0.0386614725,
-0.0082726432,
0.0689117759,
0.0000019835,
-0.0457619131,
-0.0324005336,
-0.0290253349,
-0.026550835,
-0.0071688355,
0.0573176965,
-0.0313719325,
-0.0266059805,
0.0437578075,
-0.0268111564,
0.0152746523,
0.0580759533,
0.0156321898,
0.0681477264,
0.1181192771,
0.0050542736,
-0.0014756524,
0.0039792545,
-0.0246860944,
0.0001368047,
-0.0516358055,
0.0028159199,
0.0247321874,
-0.0206444394,
-0.0284559671,
-0.0358451046,
0.0137095992,
0.0008605456,
-0.0269981585,
0.020763902,
0.0245960746,
-0.0418603681,
-0.0103175705,
-0.0144186551,
0.0667963549,
-0.0358108282,
-0.0166166537,
-0.0158922132,
-0.0023350033,
0.0144029958,
-0.0413599238,
-0.0361046419,
-0.0060398933,
0.0130181778,
-0.0006278605,
0.0199338775,
-0.045146998,
0.0163318384,
0.0200921632,
-0.007741584,
0.0151877776,
0.0215682499,
-0.0465668738,
-0.0103237303,
0.0247913096,
0.0127099063,
-0.0411522649,
-0.0206827521,
0.0296706166,
-0.0629223213,
0.0310222339,
-0.0303945839,
-0.0311549585,
0.001608666,
-0.014881433,
0.0018852496,
0.0716981739,
0.0294017754,
0.040609058,
-0.0074395011,
0.1107631847,
0.0035488124,
0.0431425571,
-0.0272577778,
0.0275984593,
-0.0353343226,
-0.0153623093,
-0.0109733324,
0.0197634567,
0.0102296239,
-0.004174097,
-0.0644322336,
0.0543360375,
-0.0349894129,
0.0475852862,
-0.0288288333,
-0.0145044923,
-0.0610177182,
0.0091249598,
-0.0286842734,
0.0595883131,
-0.0186178237,
-0.0004421671,
0.0399188921,
-0.041571971,
-0.0293095913,
0.0031292953,
-0.0306984633,
-0.028529929,
-0.0071515441,
0.0539448112,
-0.0064378195,
-0.0215098206,
0.0328134373,
-0.0126217129,
-0.0133414464,
-0.0507682674,
-0.0142379934,
-0.0671896338,
0.0395543799,
-0.0077570779,
-0.0150086181,
-0.0121193063,
-0.0102268485,
-0.0016650379,
-0.0267777797,
0.0554657206,
0.0230165944,
0.0074882102,
0.0138365394,
-0.027911501,
-0.0259659085,
0.0803764239,
0.0088499784,
0.0324493274,
0.0207319129,
-0.0005252113,
-0.009338351,
0.0491868481,
0.0212623179,
0.0167665351,
-0.0240571722,
-0.0074582295,
0.0149656218,
0.0739322975,
0.0570959374,
0.0267375521,
-0.0252394006,
0.0157887582,
0.0469045378,
0.0088144289,
-0.024924336,
0.0030072106,
-0.0413539037,
-0.0127313295,
-0.0105775967,
0.0089201331,
-0.0567294434,
0.0482661575,
-0.0203904863,
0.0265733283,
0.0300803185,
0.0098543838,
-0.0368924998,
-0.022394944,
-0.0005269045,
-0.0200083088,
0.0268343668,
0.008692326,
0.0505596735,
-0.0028533982,
-0.0539433807,
0.0107587809,
0.0433182046,
-0.0061176741,
-0.0184975248,
-0.0384498052,
0.0103674196,
0.0486599915,
0.0460647792,
-0.0085436432,
-0.0723566338,
-0.0317660309,
-0.0375244915,
0.0585625209,
0.0729038268,
-0.0076391748,
-0.0537782088,
-0.0432390235,
-0.0409382284,
-0.0160463899,
0.0060369237,
0.0080153886,
0.0411295407,
0.0259403326,
-0.0230679382,
-0.0026803543,
-0.0609789863,
0.0320619754,
-0.0270731561,
-0.0060974695,
-0.0335109085,
0.0089402003,
0.0378761962,
-0.0055054398,
-0.0114580141,
-0.0110058878,
0.0049961163,
-0.0089460416,
-0.0104047144,
0.039051339,
-0.0292719714,
-0.047537595,
0.056901332,
0.0058833123,
-0.0276724678,
0.0785613805,
-0.0537286289,
-0.0275553651,
0.0132829295,
-0.0132770296,
0.0246638693,
0.02254216,
0.046893511,
-0.0533113629,
0.0056208116,
-0.0608180836,
0.0228412058,
0.0148236426,
0.042170316,
-0.0271860696,
-0.016991524,
-0.0213654451,
-0.0464608446,
-0.0203026123,
0.0268613379,
0.0055343593,
0.0439021587,
0.0591340065,
-0.0060600624,
-0.0523384102,
-0.0606252141,
-0.0782235339,
0.018351268,
-0.021299189,
0.0379799195,
0.0554025434,
0.0023619421,
-0.0055279359,
-0.0229313001,
-0.0592710413,
-0.0074222093,
0.0074105593,
0.0453656912,
0.0443999954,
-0.0214357842,
-0.0421655551,
-0.05175725,
0.0086428747,
-0.0137954988,
0.0111882314,
0.0123043247,
0.0291206036,
-0.0635217428,
0.0161016416,
-0.0507119708,
-0.0036338952,
-0.0080406973,
-0.058456935,
0.0071317409,
0.0278519485,
0.0329792537,
0.1068585962,
0.0279200114,
0.0158289727,
-0.0024560692,
0.0292260926,
-0.0899369046,
0.0059127971,
-0.0005807241,
-0.0563317463,
-0.0260660816,
-0.0402552448,
-0.0056104069,
0.0780296177,
-0.0186761934,
0.0280171204,
-0.071107395,
0.038232483,
-0.0072428947,
0.0084938919,
-0.0106008928,
0.022328496,
-0.0443057045,
0.0146815162,
-0.0475620367,
-0.0665358007,
0.1019819602,
0.0149105694,
0.0016652874,
-0.0560914688,
0.011883487,
-0.0287034716,
0.0097071528,
-0.0183199961,
0.04025089,
0.0019375057,
-0.0172450785,
-0.062271338,
-0.0173561908,
0.0239783674,
-0.0668935999,
0.0494216345,
0.0037617108,
0.0257518888,
-0.017993873,
-0.0644191429,
-0.050631322,
-0.0331601501,
-0.0206393562,
0.0070106322,
0.0008305908,
-0.0351842493,
-0.0444490947,
-0.0043680188,
0.0332478695,
0.0121316966,
-0.0275129098,
0.0030382476,
-0.0068571828,
0.0099500688,
0.0731669888,
0.0256291702,
0.013993538,
-0.0475412421,
0.0210416224,
0.0240388233,
0.0605391786,
0.0049039801,
-0.0331708565,
-0.0342165567,
0.0185252447,
-0.0503977016,
0.0119211823,
-0.0186983403,
0.0434653983,
-0.0314619318,
-0.0148237487,
0.0975578874,
0.012662435,
-0.0617154576,
-0.008565384,
-0.0033872549,
0.0807859153,
0.0257697161,
0.0486185849,
-0.0755517781,
-0.0245794766,
0.0192354005,
0.0428682975,
0.0293589756,
-0.0057238499,
0.0061307661,
-0.1292434335,
-0.022071138,
0.0071767448,
-0.0724881217,
-0.0346615799,
-0.041914627,
0.0098378668,
-0.0435881205,
0.0549509674,
0.0414052084,
-0.0012326929,
0.009196111,
0.0187083874,
0.0171805136,
-0.0137311313,
0.0306687038,
-0.0687491,
0.0764524043,
0.1113083586,
0.0249564499,
-0.0025644877,
-0.0213260669,
0.027315395,
0.0319520235,
-0.0090323631,
0.0362431183,
0.0202619061,
-0.0115991049,
-0.0349578224,
0.0157355685,
0.0219769832,
-0.0389117375,
0.0382524878,
-0.017621614,
0.0518691689,
0.0203341022,
0.0172738694,
0.005783611,
0.0006831549,
0.0037345586,
0.0611675829,
-0.0050964048,
-0.0515023693,
-0.0472744107,
-0.0336903743,
0.0055818674,
-0.0085523976,
-0.0236635711,
-0.0007584114,
-0.0373275205,
0.0237705577,
-0.0946915075,
-0.0574123412,
-0.0192412399,
0.0454257615,
0.0129642971,
-0.0113145765,
-0.0204762798,
-0.0279446021,
-0.03305218,
0.0294219535,
-0.0275448002,
0.0245678052,
-0.0495723411,
0.0137883499,
0.0027807346,
-0.0198203847,
-0.0088673411,
-0.0207118448,
-0.0906628668,
-0.0783624202,
0.0125159211,
0.034626361,
0.0164865945,
0.0875530168,
-0.0164169203,
-0.0222339835,
0.0123492936,
0.029476624,
-0.045079302,
0.0423130505,
0.0151787177,
0.0294396468,
-0.0248039514,
0.0522146747,
-0.0592579208,
-0.02929339,
0.0274247173,
0.0603289753,
-0.0017078974,
-0.0210097171,
0.0303646233,
0.0313955769,
0.0307321437,
0.0122361779,
-0.0427620672,
-0.0045182412,
0.0057138465,
0.0207555257,
-0.0336881727,
-0.012349491,
-0.0469633713,
0.0264240336,
-0.0191223733,
0.0044333986,
0.0346932299,
-0.0006890557,
0.0155946156,
-0.0234251041,
-0.0160323363,
-0.036738351,
0.0136488723,
0.0302750953,
0.0322493762,
-0.0121105313,
0.0280511882,
0.005724323,
0.0607873797,
-0.017945271,
0.0616793782,
0.0699874535,
0.0255771372,
-0.0211085379,
0.0113127222,
-0.0374329202,
-0.0481683649,
0.0048984494,
0.0044898675,
0.0576680563,
-0.011409739,
0.0686598867,
-0.0094720833,
-0.0144275278,
-0.0087529412,
-0.0039282218,
-0.0335658677,
-0.0037133035,
0.0375256725,
0.0137195345,
0.0043199128,
0.0164316371,
0.0545784645,
-0.0550757945,
0.0323720984,
-0.0160134789,
0.0260473639,
-0.0122800888,
0.0187748577,
0.039941743,
-0.0466417633,
-0.0011024441,
-0.0356519409,
-0.0242201332,
-0.0571263395,
0.0177845135,
0.0015083598,
0.0006770803,
0.0003225975,
0.0453784689,
0.0804161876,
-0.0452017821,
0.0200780034,
-0.0494863577,
-0.0174167845,
-0.0252196416,
-0.0373912677,
-0.0246759281,
-6.714065941e-33,
-0.0179577693,
0.0103101069,
0.0252899006,
0.0259643402,
-0.048339285,
0.0081681116,
-0.0196888372,
0.0139148263,
-0.0244416986,
0.0080039743,
-0.0241048206,
0.011041129,
0.0073585049,
-0.0086010154,
0.0059414846,
-0.0133831268,
0.0251991544,
-0.0244254246,
-0.0756088644,
0.0067293481,
0.0374204852,
0.0323165394,
0.0710795596,
-0.037215136,
0.0288240593,
0.0326381102,
-0.019680148,
0.0106282048,
0.019085981,
0.0292337183,
-0.0024047096,
0.0158308186,
0.0102640009,
-0.0587694459,
0.002345073,
-0.0015883166,
-0.0299782231,
-0.0110772746,
0.0089693097,
0.0475632735,
-0.0342979357,
-0.0296477564,
0.0696658641,
-0.0344426259,
-0.0372926407,
0.0084130885,
0.0135464258,
-0.0221545286,
-0.0379140861,
0.0329610184,
-0.0723933727,
0.0106797935,
-0.0231244173,
-0.0434775688,
-0.004980952,
0.0240492057,
0.01053352,
0.0363194086,
-0.0460723191,
0.0113593535,
-0.0289522465,
0.0358362421,
0.0836199671,
0.036816895,
0.0127508258,
0.0725378096,
0.0049577998,
0.0465286151,
0.0229494423,
0.0096321283,
0.0475152954,
-0.0351523645,
0.0286233891,
0.032010261,
0.0470086969,
0.0005216472,
-0.0348375775,
0.0226879958,
0.0411510728,
0.0478283018,
0.0396124385,
0.0496950261,
-0.0657768101,
0.0034672418,
-0.0480829738,
-0.0006826809,
-0.0466643423,
-0.0567080118,
-0.0036324654,
0.0408460982,
-0.0187077429,
-0.0551218316,
0.0196243189,
-0.0395728499,
0.0111942776,
0.0201491024,
-0.0573766492,
0.0065030707,
-0.0231360868,
0.0055992655,
-0.0563157499,
-0.0266118962,
-0.0193142928,
0.0338164642,
0.0273980722,
0.0172579624,
0.0324928723,
0.0270405617,
-0.0678063855,
0.0230441578,
-0.0440887026,
0.0308630262,
-0.0018412573,
0.0029960822,
0.0401043072,
0.0055164918,
0.0097117517,
0.0751780048,
0.0420793928,
-0.0093151918,
-0.0255046077,
0.0121598607,
-0.0025873638,
-0.0016681569,
-0.0396109261,
0.0020329214,
-0.0119655412,
0.0232556183,
-0.0286199022,
-0.0739770383,
-0.0161152389,
-0.0041149775,
2.87e-7,
0.0126244128,
0.0660134703,
0.0355843343,
0.0401444212,
0.0108000152,
0.0555353165,
-0.0186638739,
0.0303045716,
0.0269793589,
0.0255608782,
-0.0120422794,
0.0181416776,
0.0498295985,
-0.0086207576,
-0.0964980125,
-0.0217879713,
-0.1138767004,
0.0362797268,
-0.0260222889,
-0.005423517,
0.0032561878,
0.1154640615,
0.0261310507,
-0.0080354353,
0.0066126585,
-0.0337022357,
0.0835496485,
-0.0011178637,
-0.0489508733,
0.0416284055,
-0.0078319823,
0.0190881193,
-0.0311534051,
-0.0236346722,
0.0010993455,
0.0153881004,
-0.0087873852,
0.049299065,
-0.0019516464,
-0.0311759822,
0.0024658737,
0.0123391682,
-0.0049330723,
-0.0611484647,
0.0342987627,
-0.0506224744,
-0.0142996125,
-0.0728697255,
-0.0248288009,
-0.0126725975,
0.070230037,
-0.0336585939,
-0.0311464332,
0.0496743284,
0.0051354272,
0.0243803766,
-0.0401805118,
-0.0449748076,
-0.0435687713,
0.009671649,
-0.022674948,
-0.025889175,
-0.0251755305,
0.0132437525,
-0.0172558036,
-0.064636074,
0.0099736964,
2.798142391e-34,
0.0221880134,
-0.0345388912,
0.0095453756,
0.0383032039,
0.0123221828,
-0.0118459174,
0.0175260007,
0.0130429855,
0.0359088778,
-0.0326204263,
-0.011694788
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03912v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03912v2 | Collaboration or Corporate Capture? Quantifying NLP's Reliance on Industry Artifacts and Contributions | 2023-12-06T21:12:22 | 2024-06-22T15:27:04 | Will Aitken, Mohamed Abdalla, Karen Rudie, Catherine Stinson | cs.CL | cs.CL | Impressive performance of pre-trained models has garnered public attention
and made news headlines in recent years. Almost always, these models are
produced by or in collaboration with industry. Using them is critical for
competing on natural language processing (NLP) benchmarks and correspondingly
to stay relevant in NLP research. We surveyed 100 papers published at EMNLP
2022 to determine the degree to which researchers rely on industry models,
other artifacts, and contributions to publish in prestigious NLP venues and
found that the ratio of their citation is at least three times greater than
what would be expected. Our work serves as a scaffold to enable future
researchers to more accurately address whether: 1) Collaboration with industry
is still collaboration in the absence of an alternative or 2) if NLP inquiry
has been captured by the motivations and research direction of private
corporations. | [
0.0970487818,
0.119891867,
-0.0110177873,
-0.0094210906,
-0.0634350926,
-0.0235594995,
0.057676293,
-0.0020964385,
-0.0193182565,
-0.1178199649,
-0.0056710104,
0.0741566941,
-0.0043616719,
0.0340786502,
-0.0132525265,
-0.0004965695,
0.0074816798,
0.0748197958,
0.0090171285,
-0.0017633117,
0.0082545383,
0.0220674649,
0.0027128523,
0.0653816387,
0.0019661156,
-0.011544547,
0.058555346,
-0.0224550553,
-0.0080317529,
-0.00236815,
0.0167723987,
0.0507142507,
-0.0067066266,
0.0492061973,
0.0000015596,
-0.0834436938,
-0.0348451398,
0.0197769981,
-0.0125421491,
0.0257268846,
0.0317899585,
-0.0213188902,
0.0004697353,
-0.0070090708,
-0.0693599135,
0.0094557721,
0.0424530581,
0.0223879423,
0.006236786,
0.0513919257,
-0.0073839407,
-0.0502515249,
0.0380309671,
-0.0246569999,
-0.0654227138,
-0.0282289628,
0.0326830819,
-0.0249998737,
-0.0036915126,
-0.0091236653,
0.0056329179,
0.052040074,
-0.0007653944,
0.002194182,
0.0349171571,
0.0640130639,
-0.0345460549,
-0.0106136119,
-0.0127371438,
0.0488620438,
0.0345740579,
-0.0253261179,
0.0400838889,
-0.0316265225,
-0.0081680678,
0.0498154126,
0.0068102605,
0.0534076355,
0.008480981,
-0.004264452,
0.0302084144,
0.0110515524,
0.0190031845,
0.0460823849,
0.0034501217,
0.0501196608,
-0.0195151195,
-0.0432686731,
0.0650017038,
0.032297384,
0.0168825667,
-0.0414743721,
0.0337466039,
-0.0187375546,
0.0402804427,
0.0269833338,
-0.0053020851,
0.0247557759,
0.0127213672,
-0.0293457713,
0.0105885267,
-0.0154778548,
-0.0063328021,
0.0221683867,
-0.0245230682,
-0.0343807675,
-0.0433611944,
0.0171624981,
-0.0023405016,
0.0469008721,
-0.0762193054,
-0.0157314353,
-0.0296858195,
0.0373562202,
-0.0364853106,
-0.0527295396,
-0.0060995421,
-0.0133705894,
-0.0330522284,
0.0073692487,
-0.0064776884,
0.0548163429,
0.016734058,
-0.0067785876,
-0.0369103588,
0.0181634687,
-0.0103206336,
0.032974869,
-0.033248473,
-0.0523165241,
0.0386838168,
-0.024032969,
0.0058396962,
-0.046896521,
0.0382695459,
0.0509581603,
0.0281925779,
-0.0707738027,
0.0001983649,
-0.0227174684,
-0.0111975418,
-0.0592566095,
0.0043934751,
-0.028177239,
0.0319756083,
0.0213007536,
0.0133144911,
-0.0785739571,
-0.000538777,
0.0022225475,
-0.0479776599,
0.0436773188,
-0.0122977728,
0.0039771236,
-0.0075340467,
-0.0219157077,
0.0189536493,
0.0469177924,
0.0375342742,
-0.0228973217,
0.0647755265,
-0.0205723308,
-0.0076913782,
0.0186020564,
-0.0130116893,
-0.0358756706,
0.0240614172,
0.0035501495,
-0.0249023996,
0.0037115372,
-0.0055303606,
0.0198646821,
-0.0129905958,
0.0047538676,
0.0475414097,
0.0773366541,
0.0097760819,
0.0187793449,
0.0046409075,
-0.0074204532,
0.0117892604,
-0.0180131402,
-0.0229575261,
-0.0409534648,
-0.0263287779,
-0.0111643616,
0.0203921478,
0.0157573316,
0.0095651485,
-0.0397796929,
0.0097900983,
0.0305930637,
0.0120717837,
0.0078781135,
0.0385068059,
-0.0279458463,
-0.0392023697,
0.0459938161,
-0.0013456004,
-0.0132827451,
0.0042763948,
-0.0074042208,
-0.004645918,
0.0057290476,
0.0492814705,
-0.0027813134,
0.0326194465,
-0.0351520367,
-0.0353373513,
0.0626293048,
0.0215002261,
0.0096564796,
0.0062520676,
0.0211705919,
-0.0093850559,
-0.0486088283,
0.0116883125,
0.000109758,
0.0141840717,
0.01567965,
-0.0108366702,
0.0093933372,
-0.0384180136,
0.0460736975,
-0.0361707732,
-0.0052238787,
-0.0377904624,
-0.001736883,
0.0257620942,
0.0713454932,
-0.0301226489,
0.032214988,
0.0537932329,
-0.0392999798,
-0.0022652864,
0.0189265795,
0.0289795492,
0.0347456113,
0.014179565,
-0.0355068669,
-0.0025140252,
0.0010745131,
-0.0151369656,
-0.0183682851,
0.0417778827,
0.0114832716,
0.0933295339,
0.0023685885,
-0.0366499089,
-0.0554690845,
0.0159725193,
-0.0558619648,
0.0438468009,
0.0086184358,
0.049552124,
-0.0357768573,
-0.0310337842,
0.0059947344,
0.0164485164,
-0.0174420383,
0.0575914346,
-0.0212218538,
0.0172565114,
0.0821700171,
-0.0447295457,
-0.0374298431,
-0.0089325244,
-0.0198161732,
0.0054438096,
-0.0121690575,
0.0140569592,
0.0312454831,
-0.0213032905,
-0.0171230417,
0.0205439702,
0.019652253,
-0.05724895,
0.0083713476,
0.0221257079,
0.0317841135,
0.0190163068,
0.0076790401,
-0.0311405454,
-0.0258814637,
-0.0049348874,
0.0429660492,
0.0349369645,
-0.0293279402,
-0.06697537,
0.0287114363,
-0.0172767825,
0.0161137935,
-0.0051258551,
0.0271698255,
0.0243506096,
0.0403172374,
-0.0385239944,
0.0757495537,
-0.0270244256,
0.0398595817,
0.019429272,
0.0224741139,
-0.0651966557,
0.0026236284,
-0.0519850142,
-0.0048223939,
-0.0303895567,
-0.0184838306,
0.0691064522,
0.0386408456,
-0.0322699249,
-0.0192765817,
-0.0078942729,
0.014759752,
-0.0262270048,
-0.0493554212,
0.0063885981,
-0.0363548286,
-0.00553898,
0.0683450252,
0.0023835071,
-0.0399438441,
0.0114432545,
-0.018279152,
-0.0014179163,
-0.0685940534,
-0.0267866421,
-0.0155217238,
0.0872659311,
-0.011305782,
-0.0033917534,
0.0541206747,
-0.0454648919,
-0.0118122231,
0.0188221261,
0.0088750012,
-0.0228509177,
0.0191040747,
-0.0057651578,
0.0589813776,
-0.008860467,
-0.0023779729,
-0.006175085,
-0.0536265597,
-0.0480317585,
0.0346597061,
0.0727862939,
-0.004703851,
-0.0670290068,
-0.0107764183,
0.0137994792,
-0.0081245769,
0.0211714506,
-0.0192769933,
-0.0155182146,
0.0230581686,
0.0423306935,
0.0093157487,
0.0689380914,
0.0381649919,
-0.0332198292,
0.0407908522,
0.0629149303,
0.0327230394,
-0.0323189981,
-0.0027193432,
0.0235244967,
-0.073989585,
-0.0059295031,
-0.0167779345,
0.0353692845,
-0.0168343615,
0.0293202344,
0.0649707466,
0.0032161006,
-0.0237562563,
0.0243893769,
0.0524676479,
-0.0255647376,
0.0417865999,
0.0244939364,
-0.0569864139,
0.0060395021,
0.0098509863,
-0.0216076076,
-0.0523790233,
-0.0839474574,
-0.0445417091,
-0.1407047361,
0.0254865941,
-0.0567176826,
0.0045576463,
0.0430294089,
-0.0808202922,
-0.016272312,
-0.0536049604,
0.0095593696,
-0.034748666,
-0.041052904,
0.0017648328,
0.0431573428,
-0.0618207343,
-0.0712378323,
0.0113660954,
-0.0450553037,
0.0219927821,
0.0530584417,
0.0424671136,
-0.0373951904,
0.0013130138,
0.0002648677,
-0.0332052745,
0.013183252,
-0.0148926079,
0.0680696592,
-0.0481291302,
-0.0066689164,
0.0211228859,
0.0108609758,
-0.070937641,
0.0282973405,
-0.0140887368,
0.0158193056,
0.0116237802,
-0.0284975618,
0.0012415845,
0.0073520616,
-0.0290068481,
0.0561135001,
-0.0308372155,
-0.0276744738,
-0.0326790586,
-0.0181728583,
0.0250664484,
-0.0026968289,
-0.032062389,
-0.0137839718,
-0.0272479709,
-0.0100065479,
-0.0557117946,
-0.0969152004,
0.0515017733,
0.0241809823,
0.0242150202,
0.0155159393,
0.0375899114,
-0.0204446614,
-0.0254768543,
0.03733005,
0.0148360347,
0.026360156,
-0.0279518384,
-0.0100103896,
0.0227349773,
0.0643179566,
-0.0348326825,
-0.0063300743,
-0.035508018,
-0.0741003007,
-0.008995438,
0.0133644054,
0.028508367,
0.0077216411,
-0.0176455751,
-0.0291943513,
0.0123011768,
0.0802991465,
-0.0595767349,
-0.0105400244,
0.0170942247,
-0.0528365113,
-0.0114677139,
-0.0104653053,
-0.0301451311,
-0.0019001137,
0.0352778211,
0.049991332,
0.0045875083,
-0.0322719999,
0.0396060422,
-0.0105715813,
0.0710808113,
-0.0554451384,
0.0385326445,
-0.0388212614,
-0.0460710377,
0.0050472608,
-0.0052699419,
-0.0526221395,
-0.0259423945,
0.0236751754,
0.0226583276,
-0.0450940989,
0.0760578066,
-0.0390118957,
0.0606789924,
-0.0779236555,
0.0484594405,
0.0237687454,
0.0232572258,
-0.0046948134,
-0.0152480043,
-0.0105457371,
0.0097581511,
-0.0114854993,
0.0596328527,
0.0211309493,
0.0154822571,
0.0178541578,
0.0050166268,
0.0178181455,
0.0246179905,
-0.114478074,
-0.0708627105,
0.0195081532,
0.0069006039,
0.0465140864,
-0.0470095128,
0.0455989279,
-0.0169404913,
-0.0027023547,
0.0016542089,
0.0075307749,
0.0273383912,
-0.0140394075,
0.0118433153,
-0.0020291214,
-0.053059902,
0.0101274727,
0.0765853301,
0.0360728614,
0.0474215113,
0.0008032605,
0.0069887764,
0.000804844,
-0.067817241,
0.0272534899,
0.0243204087,
-0.0095902858,
0.0214412771,
-0.0586145334,
-0.0287071299,
-0.0129716173,
-0.02865218,
0.0165749155,
-0.0331902839,
-0.0198218245,
0.0740633309,
0.0470447652,
-0.0236359406,
-0.0420839265,
0.0088043259,
-0.0430124514,
-0.0289805103,
0.0025275741,
-6.121931967e-33,
0.0520759635,
-0.0230905823,
0.0087014176,
-0.0132876933,
-0.0212220512,
0.0450977497,
0.0038767133,
0.0106018567,
-0.0612892509,
-0.0075669922,
-0.0616345555,
-0.0026783713,
0.0148152653,
-0.0192708001,
0.0560580976,
-0.0099081071,
0.0204625446,
-0.0259524677,
-0.0112144556,
-0.0117623415,
0.0044710911,
0.022094069,
0.0950983986,
-0.0809050202,
0.078948237,
0.0238749161,
-0.0243450832,
-0.0144837936,
0.0283633992,
0.024749767,
-0.0270741824,
0.0429479741,
0.0347335339,
-0.0971949175,
0.0055622128,
0.0068676448,
-0.0550045408,
0.0022933902,
0.0379244573,
-0.0121823726,
0.0020790619,
0.0237115603,
0.0649224892,
-0.012027842,
-0.0319607109,
0.0026629709,
0.0484474152,
-0.0373060741,
-0.0327818505,
-0.0367175303,
-0.0575389713,
-0.0089601232,
-0.028546188,
0.0559169687,
0.0377378725,
0.0226272065,
-0.0183850024,
0.0424606949,
-0.0668735206,
-0.0151108485,
-0.0303217024,
0.0141560836,
0.0536551587,
-0.0245450288,
0.0276127905,
0.0663867369,
0.0318565927,
0.0338317305,
0.025001578,
-0.0168433748,
0.0392870046,
0.0809244737,
-0.0224578083,
0.0218360573,
0.0357756168,
-0.0216933526,
-0.0173832085,
0.0037743649,
0.0299244523,
-0.0027949356,
0.0306554381,
-0.0210202299,
-0.0222564172,
-0.0343781896,
-0.0037878605,
-0.0159412734,
0.0001826214,
-0.0145236021,
0.0005810052,
0.0317440517,
-0.0241346806,
0.0906565785,
0.0148035204,
-0.0755055398,
-0.0615603179,
0.0006468089,
0.0084242122,
0.0144172115,
0.0272057708,
-0.0218839198,
-0.1213873923,
-0.0136616612,
-0.0504344814,
0.0154849999,
0.0302213542,
-0.0345927551,
0.008452123,
-0.0053510964,
-0.0223863143,
-0.0078233704,
-0.027558079,
0.0329582542,
0.0223811381,
-0.0132705504,
0.0362721384,
0.0442291088,
0.0118971756,
-0.0051379921,
0.0427993163,
0.0322640613,
-0.0225192532,
0.0500543155,
0.0013668874,
0.0131300082,
-0.0172192585,
-0.036733292,
-0.0197988749,
0.0504873022,
0.0553280674,
-0.0173783563,
-0.036559388,
-0.0641338229,
2.416e-7,
0.0614433028,
0.0351182222,
0.0075513087,
-0.0159603376,
0.0218235198,
0.0224939808,
0.0025669697,
0.0502990931,
-0.0070339036,
-0.0219202992,
-0.0104609011,
-0.0372881778,
0.0209081098,
-0.0137830926,
-0.045685418,
-0.0295204017,
-0.060075935,
-0.0027963589,
-0.0765928328,
-0.0020124342,
0.0043975511,
0.0208017994,
0.0182242692,
-0.0050461739,
-0.0731988251,
-0.0447247773,
0.0523436144,
-0.0707948208,
0.0309956204,
0.0389900319,
0.0063420241,
0.0102491211,
-0.0144512579,
-0.0051836022,
-0.0177971479,
0.0454179198,
0.0075783948,
0.0261198878,
0.0233985595,
-0.0076378947,
-0.000687997,
-0.0421031192,
0.0017195917,
-0.0355962999,
0.0526771136,
-0.0328820534,
-0.0579920001,
-0.0472314283,
-0.0504267849,
-0.0142785907,
0.0047463789,
0.0156521201,
0.0017741949,
0.0165719371,
-0.0179447699,
-0.0221194662,
-0.0126536712,
-0.0654199421,
0.0003165427,
0.0128885666,
0.0050611692,
-0.0271504968,
0.0059306105,
-0.0215554703,
0.04078703,
-0.0123851756,
0.0166675951,
1.848302318e-34,
0.0110386694,
-0.0079953279,
0.0469325967,
0.0560333319,
0.0345000923,
0.0149997771,
-0.0145886531,
-0.0038297805,
-0.0301380288,
-0.0603294894,
0.0042578103
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03905v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03905v2 | A Pseudo-Semantic Loss for Autoregressive Models with Logical Constraints | 2023-12-06T20:58:07 | 2024-01-27T00:25:22 | Kareem Ahmed, Kai-Wei Chang, Guy Van den Broeck | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Neuro-symbolic AI bridges the gap between purely symbolic and neural
approaches to learning. This often requires maximizing the likelihood of a
symbolic constraint w.r.t the neural network's output distribution. Such output
distributions are typically assumed to be fully-factorized. This limits the
applicability of neuro-symbolic learning to the more expressive autoregressive
distributions, e.g., transformers. Under such distributions, computing the
likelihood of even simple constraints is #P-hard. Instead of attempting to
enforce the constraint on the entire output distribution, we propose to do so
on a random, local approximation thereof. More precisely, we optimize the
likelihood of the constraint under a pseudolikelihood-based approximation
centered around a model sample. Our approximation is factorized, allowing the
reuse of solutions to sub-problems, a main tenet for efficiently computing
neuro-symbolic losses. Moreover, it is a local, high-fidelity approximation of
the likelihood, exhibiting low entropy and KL-divergence around the model
sample. We evaluate our approach on Sudoku and shortest-path prediction cast as
autoregressive generation, and observe that we greatly improve upon the base
model's ability to predict logically-consistent outputs. We also evaluate on
the task of detoxifying large language models. Using a simple constraint
disallowing a list of toxic words, we are able to steer the model's outputs
away from toxic generations, achieving SoTA detoxification compared to previous
approaches. | [
0.0272067077,
0.1173798442,
-0.0208834279,
0.0196736529,
-0.0208366942,
-0.012667736,
-0.0071498682,
0.0003546852,
-0.0208278578,
0.0006364106,
-0.025505811,
0.0320325382,
-0.0264704805,
0.0275037736,
0.0591479354,
0.0023996383,
0.0639763921,
-0.0237782728,
-0.0043938905,
-0.034799967,
-0.0366289392,
-0.003718602,
0.0046194401,
0.0339084268,
-0.0748070702,
-0.0117268628,
0.0016034206,
-0.0056406343,
-0.0135878483,
-0.0161656961,
-0.0235716663,
-0.0059676049,
-0.0070822444,
0.0344194993,
0.000002522,
-0.016860988,
-0.019093886,
0.0019975912,
-0.0225056559,
-0.0083174389,
-0.0172404908,
-0.0115653509,
-0.0010063448,
0.0153767793,
-0.0236038882,
-0.0088462196,
0.0786057636,
0.0403406955,
0.0831773728,
0.0427816659,
-0.0020386125,
0.0119068017,
0.0572517551,
-0.0254338905,
0.0323951244,
0.0211802535,
0.0183074418,
-0.0251418892,
-0.0286078751,
-0.0913079083,
-0.0192628317,
0.0418204106,
0.0510006659,
0.0048414315,
-0.0099669956,
0.0482712239,
0.0046032756,
0.0197675377,
-0.0194445215,
0.045777984,
-0.072014831,
-0.040869806,
0.0123653775,
-0.0201587342,
-0.0019943223,
0.0043328302,
-0.0102575589,
0.0090438696,
-0.0124693215,
0.0256869905,
0.0396284163,
0.0326568522,
0.0586838908,
-0.0066374782,
-0.0080981953,
0.069676742,
0.0152002582,
-0.0171926618,
0.0099192448,
-0.0148484977,
-0.0692391917,
0.0023846074,
0.0176848304,
0.0092116958,
-0.0209916886,
0.0188501999,
-0.019315023,
-0.0140048163,
-0.0268737506,
-0.0571022704,
0.0999005586,
0.022845611,
0.0698975548,
-0.0021316316,
-0.0246540029,
0.0397174507,
-0.0130772898,
0.0706022233,
-0.0466955379,
0.024201598,
-0.0129841557,
-0.0240001474,
-0.0439233407,
0.0655930936,
-0.0060268533,
0.0060775452,
-0.0223182254,
0.017841408,
-0.0714951754,
0.0374640636,
0.0157374423,
0.0339366198,
-0.0497317314,
-0.024890339,
-0.0379363373,
-0.0054436172,
-0.0400129892,
-0.0111738266,
-0.0157770514,
0.0211122464,
-0.0149208214,
-0.0003346091,
-0.0373584814,
-0.0326908678,
0.0206721835,
0.1223000363,
0.0197861865,
-0.0180282351,
-0.06941998,
-0.0303320326,
-0.042033162,
-0.072259441,
0.0080714701,
-0.0203705579,
0.0146539882,
-0.0530931689,
-0.0158181004,
-0.0840826556,
0.0131104374,
-0.0056934943,
0.0274440367,
0.0477955528,
0.0515136123,
-0.0395082273,
0.0130114304,
0.0042564026,
-0.002398195,
0.0453614295,
0.0425957665,
0.0381831974,
-0.0244536921,
0.005313708,
0.003026654,
0.0308125801,
0.0654146746,
0.0104205702,
-0.064081341,
-0.0338292718,
0.011500163,
0.0397677496,
0.0440938249,
0.0958114639,
-0.0365503579,
-0.0476496741,
0.0474348888,
0.0297591537,
0.0256035179,
0.069199428,
0.0605219416,
-0.0712615848,
-0.0065290304,
-0.002171054,
-0.0921637341,
0.0336549692,
0.013802602,
0.0082508372,
-0.0246432554,
0.0356267281,
-0.0310477093,
-0.0867763832,
0.0476728082,
-0.0025661434,
0.0068358565,
-0.0365019776,
0.0334256142,
0.0121747479,
-0.0515398644,
0.0606812276,
0.0234457739,
-0.0294958539,
0.0130346175,
-0.0328913033,
0.0256644934,
0.0083343387,
0.0586804748,
-0.0595785938,
0.0052261702,
-0.024784239,
-0.0968187973,
0.0101396004,
-0.0236775111,
-0.0167948175,
-0.0019379781,
-0.0019221175,
-0.0066192024,
0.0247703157,
0.0384282321,
0.002438203,
-0.0141595611,
-0.0029521966,
0.004128587,
-0.0294376593,
-0.0373381525,
0.0378861167,
-0.0587276332,
-0.0677516162,
0.0414605401,
0.0332807563,
0.0361158624,
0.0099266879,
0.0025957138,
0.0488067195,
0.0246342216,
-0.0499793477,
-0.0481419899,
-0.0282328874,
-0.0545232669,
-0.0122191291,
0.0562008843,
-0.0568977185,
0.0438624322,
0.0732936934,
-0.0405352227,
-0.0239944682,
0.0499552004,
-0.058539629,
0.0475129262,
-0.0106406352,
-0.0202321205,
0.0408299044,
-0.007865265,
-0.0279709827,
0.0419598483,
-0.0395925231,
-0.0080778208,
0.0073137623,
-0.0330042578,
0.0113039901,
-0.0404309742,
-0.0339362957,
-0.0073264241,
-0.0342332572,
0.0324287117,
0.0354680158,
-0.0319743305,
-0.0065473686,
-0.0127906548,
-0.0095139397,
0.0109846005,
-0.0005837912,
0.023524791,
-0.0087369196,
-0.0050535896,
0.0200941823,
-0.0405486673,
-0.0375285596,
0.0321180299,
-0.0139323464,
0.0010223979,
0.0141442036,
0.0182892717,
-0.0065714126,
-0.0058863768,
-0.0553012565,
-0.0349060185,
0.0746290237,
-0.0193915311,
0.0127724744,
-0.0138288056,
0.0522049628,
-0.050916139,
0.0308461282,
-0.0179856513,
-0.0305189993,
-0.0161581878,
-0.0137014259,
-0.0121455891,
0.0475179479,
-0.0152318384,
0.0021309101,
0.0494877137,
0.0089118993,
-0.0262232516,
0.0273680091,
-0.0256052967,
-0.0009559915,
-0.004664626,
-0.0492415279,
0.0071910685,
0.0766906142,
0.0115484763,
-0.0217299052,
-0.0580071844,
0.0286423583,
-0.0124772936,
-0.0446032584,
-0.0212217998,
-0.004958604,
0.0051430715,
-0.006516349,
-0.0376772322,
-0.0505128987,
0.0593334027,
0.0079107741,
0.0570650212,
-0.0139025589,
-0.0254159588,
-0.0096505312,
0.0564219579,
0.0202427171,
0.0210718196,
0.0601258501,
-0.0097519793,
-0.0765440837,
-0.0063815238,
0.0256123394,
-0.004936452,
0.0464534722,
-0.0358360447,
0.0263043586,
0.0310991723,
-0.0522178225,
-0.018020289,
-0.0362216942,
0.0229761116,
-0.0223689936,
0.0092496229,
-0.0135738449,
-0.0083228722,
-0.0081835445,
-0.0108164996,
0.0512020104,
0.0080267414,
-0.0362769812,
-0.0175928455,
0.0260974243,
0.0396350697,
-0.0124096274,
0.0286629423,
-0.0002824937,
0.0202365536,
0.0425989106,
0.0024360563,
-0.0002866606,
-0.0309200753,
-0.0001405123,
-0.0149754472,
-0.0034186663,
-0.0165160727,
0.0440722518,
-0.0277314652,
-0.0304282159,
-0.0544574037,
0.0446630456,
0.022822069,
-0.0016149641,
0.0397366434,
0.0238195453,
0.0334471278,
0.0116102928,
0.0479675792,
-0.0662366748,
-0.0112290289,
0.0050224168,
0.0132796681,
-0.0131519688,
-0.0612928122,
0.0192655418,
-0.0953678787,
-0.0176461972,
0.0167970732,
-0.0517124943,
-0.0106983818,
-0.0054066167,
-0.0436848402,
-0.0928161815,
-0.001764112,
-0.0182609186,
-0.0225958712,
-0.014618759,
0.0234319884,
0.0279069133,
0.040577855,
-0.004383211,
-0.0386845693,
0.037779402,
0.039387241,
0.0269187149,
-0.010055596,
-0.0222732723,
0.0207108743,
-0.0015440907,
0.0004332045,
-0.0086689061,
0.0377613977,
0.032523945,
-0.0205153674,
-0.0114241913,
0.0366567671,
-0.0462265983,
-0.0054003405,
-0.0173367318,
0.1025469005,
-0.0060380632,
-0.0468894504,
0.0071273372,
-0.0364858545,
-0.0015450029,
0.0643476173,
0.004956502,
-0.0104390467,
-0.0562737323,
-0.0578500815,
0.0381783769,
-0.002055902,
-0.0241065845,
-0.0082302745,
-0.031336844,
-0.0883700326,
-0.0731959343,
-0.0100494865,
-0.0276656225,
0.0521870852,
-0.0026322473,
-0.041312281,
0.0314814374,
-0.0392959788,
-0.0440975502,
-0.0113205602,
-0.0451172292,
0.0066600018,
-0.0124921799,
0.0283441097,
0.022459235,
-0.0176433735,
-0.0483162962,
0.0112904133,
-0.1076907441,
-0.0372693501,
-0.0047369632,
0.0830837339,
0.0212401003,
0.0166680627,
0.0087251216,
-0.0051877759,
0.0785196647,
0.0923955441,
0.0287534464,
0.0051553948,
0.0594578795,
0.0041150628,
0.006577495,
0.0404775701,
-0.0186442845,
0.0140702976,
0.027024718,
0.0565697476,
-0.0460288227,
0.0503219329,
0.0584380701,
0.0131078335,
0.0290218033,
-0.0014156864,
-0.0481082946,
-0.0244436935,
0.0074296687,
0.0120410156,
-0.0115601616,
-0.0296259057,
0.0146889109,
0.062718384,
0.0113541521,
0.0079669878,
-0.0114275366,
0.0360983908,
0.0377876051,
-0.0099997269,
-0.0514686592,
0.0563008823,
0.0469148979,
0.0266821701,
0.0166850053,
-0.0104371216,
0.0050144461,
0.0413343944,
0.0127482554,
-0.0151994396,
-0.011535855,
0.020841362,
0.0306257941,
-0.0420821346,
0.0018367914,
-0.0436753854,
-0.0130396942,
-0.0296434369,
-0.021310417,
0.0235174391,
0.019546194,
-0.0416712053,
-0.066174455,
0.0102294832,
-0.0094385063,
0.0069910046,
0.0112999054,
-0.0124380887,
0.027478395,
0.0048530176,
0.0155285057,
-0.0513576828,
0.0859707817,
0.0258635301,
0.0980276689,
-0.0040391516,
-0.0000552041,
-0.0473616198,
-0.0453540273,
-0.029384654,
0.0348829925,
-0.0138699897,
-0.0244965423,
-0.0701559186,
-0.094460547,
0.0221515615,
0.0499376915,
0.0180219263,
0.0052628512,
0.0435075872,
-0.0176019426,
0.0071333749,
0.0112704271,
-0.0142161427,
0.0100346068,
0.0202169139,
-0.0398451388,
-0.0386680849,
-6.724979671e-33,
0.0047694449,
-0.0369625017,
0.0290225931,
-0.0163341146,
-0.0200100429,
0.0186238904,
-0.0380430706,
-0.0254611149,
0.0139160305,
0.0054775747,
-0.0096835159,
0.0134131862,
-0.0086512454,
0.0264854506,
0.0010224497,
-0.0564246178,
0.034455806,
-0.012300319,
0.0077012819,
0.0190474726,
0.0334717333,
0.0037651134,
0.0127427885,
-0.0154940402,
-0.0310826357,
0.0212582089,
-0.0337667949,
0.0174835697,
-0.0120633338,
0.0342774726,
-0.0354814902,
0.0442676693,
0.0102002211,
-0.0412980132,
-0.0033853613,
-0.0320883431,
-0.056729015,
-0.0739845037,
-0.0053223264,
-0.0519281924,
-0.0135394428,
-0.0524765216,
0.0625487864,
0.0132358624,
-0.0369139612,
-0.0060351775,
0.0039781337,
-0.028394537,
-0.0411849916,
-0.0561793037,
-0.0416989215,
-0.0039970665,
-0.000221327,
-0.0089682424,
0.0003988916,
0.015571652,
0.007460718,
-0.0313700251,
-0.0331771821,
0.0138271116,
-0.0005369087,
0.0324105099,
0.0493787378,
-0.0036032791,
0.0263092481,
0.0195623673,
0.0436934456,
-0.0153911393,
-0.0491415933,
-0.0286111142,
0.0496762581,
-0.0092120906,
0.0452168845,
0.0280151237,
0.1092500314,
-0.0096650999,
-0.0637090355,
0.0366532542,
0.0036056906,
0.0908303633,
-0.0055668512,
0.0331208929,
-0.0316100232,
-0.0148305129,
-0.0414060503,
-0.067093946,
-0.034957137,
0.0044023395,
0.0098913079,
0.0160611607,
-0.0020876245,
0.0036679842,
-0.0048352447,
-0.0323636457,
0.0041764695,
0.0594382621,
0.037346717,
0.0139452349,
-0.0125142504,
-0.0008316953,
-0.0213872883,
-0.0067287027,
-0.0312009659,
-0.0063318452,
0.0233758818,
0.0179928467,
0.0165898092,
0.0510097332,
-0.0530099273,
-0.006687189,
-0.0516147427,
0.0109028248,
0.0671994537,
-0.0322721303,
0.0271244366,
0.0092795221,
0.0043752016,
-0.0155982655,
0.0241412316,
0.0173267331,
0.0380233638,
0.0975038484,
0.0147522204,
0.0135903638,
0.008739912,
-0.0142249335,
-0.0602400228,
0.0201327875,
0.0314640403,
-0.1146197915,
-0.0257488433,
-0.0042042257,
3.155e-7,
0.0230628587,
0.0064683366,
0.0594440065,
0.0404761694,
0.0159105454,
0.0355347618,
0.0138074039,
0.0170414802,
-0.0611937791,
-0.0278760586,
0.0296379849,
-0.0055144043,
0.0384222828,
0.023353219,
-0.0621330217,
0.0501018651,
-0.0695303231,
0.0019643009,
-0.0255198851,
0.0233314764,
0.0192280039,
0.1145054325,
0.0392432883,
-0.0352015346,
0.0085294703,
-0.0275662877,
0.0438683629,
-0.0146007473,
0.0511068031,
0.0087893885,
0.0261711925,
-0.064828299,
-0.0031287291,
0.0072615328,
-0.0174438115,
-0.0137467543,
0.016661739,
0.0193855166,
0.0140237371,
-0.0639185831,
-0.004273654,
-0.0278171673,
0.0118785892,
0.0038754682,
0.0519786924,
-0.0302977357,
-0.011628869,
0.0000443427,
-0.040138036,
0.0152952224,
0.0619170405,
-0.0226438157,
-0.0186591279,
0.0136308968,
-0.0200289004,
0.0384585075,
0.0232465025,
-0.0363574699,
-0.0109833721,
-0.00723485,
-0.0275981165,
-0.0201250762,
-0.0384407938,
0.0167304259,
0.0362408422,
-0.0573052838,
0.0048279064,
3.019624582e-34,
0.0111535732,
-0.0212445296,
0.0042830603,
-0.0088366084,
0.0296302419,
0.0045374925,
-0.0626167879,
0.0197697766,
0.0411396995,
-0.0415848792,
-0.0218075737
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03897v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03897v1 | Revisiting the Optimality of Word Lengths | 2023-12-06T20:41:47 | 2023-12-06T20:41:47 | Tiago Pimentel, Clara Meister, Ethan Gotlieb Wilcox, Kyle Mahowald, Ryan Cotterell | cs.CL | cs.CL | Zipf (1935) posited that wordforms are optimized to minimize utterances'
communicative costs. Under the assumption that cost is given by an utterance's
length, he supported this claim by showing that words' lengths are inversely
correlated with their frequencies. Communicative cost, however, can be
operationalized in different ways. Piantadosi et al. (2011) claim that cost
should be measured as the distance between an utterance's information rate and
channel capacity, which we dub the channel capacity hypothesis (CCH) here.
Following this logic, they then proposed that a word's length should be
proportional to the expected value of its surprisal (negative log-probability
in context). In this work, we show that Piantadosi et al.'s derivation does not
minimize CCH's cost, but rather a lower bound, which we term CCH-lower. We
propose a novel derivation, suggesting an improved way to minimize CCH's cost.
Under this method, we find that a language's word lengths should instead be
proportional to the surprisal's expectation plus its variance-to-mean ratio.
Experimentally, we compare these three communicative cost functions: Zipf's,
CCH-lower , and CCH. Across 13 languages and several experimental settings, we
find that length is better predicted by frequency than either of the other
hypotheses. In fact, when surprisal's expectation, or expectation plus
variance-to-mean ratio, is estimated using better language models, it leads to
worse word length predictions. We take these results as evidence that Zipf's
longstanding hypothesis holds. | [
0.0174706355,
0.0482463129,
-0.0162103847,
-0.0200075284,
-0.0583109446,
-0.0255832057,
0.0162671898,
0.0373734012,
-0.095294401,
0.0282795075,
-0.0145408865,
-0.094321996,
0.0849278048,
0.0078489333,
0.0449292734,
-0.0479444563,
0.0205350816,
-0.0365461893,
0.0437350683,
-0.0087787956,
0.0273171216,
-0.043112848,
0.0067182123,
0.02690267,
-0.0076611517,
0.0384569243,
-0.0284160059,
-0.034480352,
-0.0395983979,
-0.0246615857,
-0.0234392229,
0.013156727,
0.0019338921,
0.0209896341,
0.0000018616,
-0.0598061942,
0.0553947501,
-0.0144084152,
-0.0302893259,
0.0621340722,
0.046404846,
-0.0235691648,
0.0022295727,
0.0301622581,
0.0227405559,
0.0078468174,
0.0680728778,
-0.0138743017,
-0.0794696063,
0.0296822973,
-0.0045110299,
-0.005771881,
0.0335394964,
-0.0691778883,
0.0120376805,
-0.0325627849,
0.0076412968,
-0.0090491595,
0.0020234694,
-0.033544004,
-0.0770054981,
0.0545684993,
0.0040274765,
0.0096522141,
-0.0117840823,
-0.0186768584,
0.0058047166,
-0.050879322,
0.0050314614,
0.0272547044,
0.0378467254,
-0.0174192563,
-0.0008803287,
-0.0024003752,
0.0177364647,
-0.0265840162,
-0.0097934064,
0.0037363444,
0.0265012067,
-0.008088816,
-0.0075046341,
0.0622330084,
-0.0182884149,
-0.0248856973,
-0.0080414489,
0.0674426481,
0.0096439132,
-0.0646099076,
0.0278426874,
-0.0289631821,
-0.0294649247,
-0.0234875288,
-0.0347091928,
-0.0129179228,
0.0081224758,
0.0404029675,
0.0038796302,
-0.0162851997,
0.0157105848,
-0.0407049619,
-0.0291681197,
-0.0160457175,
0.0423796773,
-0.0251348875,
0.0169014335,
0.0202416517,
0.0232497938,
-0.0331856459,
-0.0511445552,
0.0357370265,
0.0065361843,
-0.0384314843,
-0.0289070867,
-0.0056420057,
-0.0298740845,
-0.0276107192,
-0.0410057791,
-0.0210391209,
0.0152013972,
-0.0206735861,
-0.0150256418,
-0.0033871164,
-0.0381424949,
-0.0027751429,
-0.0223173145,
0.0342667401,
-0.0414432064,
0.0368940048,
-0.0001251669,
-0.0667393953,
0.0282496437,
0.0198298078,
0.0007357306,
-0.0076609943,
-0.0016259041,
0.0625229925,
-0.0126186451,
-0.0175002813,
0.0509961098,
-0.0108688092,
-0.0704153106,
-0.0330919884,
-0.0377092883,
-0.0629383773,
-0.0104055898,
-0.0086541474,
-0.0200058874,
-0.0386771895,
-0.0163536966,
-0.0462116525,
-0.0271682926,
0.0290115941,
0.0148436362,
0.0604515076,
0.0642589703,
0.0149575295,
0.0372932889,
0.0679274574,
0.0782283396,
-0.0287051797,
0.0653140247,
-0.0508556291,
-0.0102847302,
0.0506676361,
0.0433385111,
0.0005661731,
0.0140913054,
-0.0402728729,
-0.005587494,
0.0286795162,
0.0354414545,
0.073376216,
-0.020794319,
-0.0439968556,
0.0584524348,
0.0755719766,
0.0357876755,
-0.0243624672,
0.0026292331,
0.0832754821,
-0.0118704829,
0.009131738,
0.0319861099,
-0.0057008807,
0.001713447,
0.020383466,
0.1074807718,
-0.0202974454,
-0.0282222498,
-0.0338066332,
-0.044688724,
-0.0248637628,
0.0649811402,
-0.0263233166,
0.0146611277,
-0.029197624,
-0.0082260203,
0.0235107243,
0.0306712519,
-0.0285078958,
-0.0256131496,
-0.0208052564,
0.0109584127,
-0.0227013808,
-0.0151763456,
0.0431972109,
0.0650795996,
0.0046966532,
-0.0019218175,
0.069177337,
0.0577991344,
0.0093244994,
0.0335274339,
-0.0193937793,
0.0531165935,
0.0308357459,
0.0125159342,
-0.0239987858,
0.0345044583,
0.0504887588,
0.0154154915,
-0.0308939591,
-0.0125030987,
-0.0006362986,
0.0001026761,
-0.0168788098,
-0.0573235974,
0.0095054992,
0.0510831587,
-0.0235987939,
-0.0300997049,
0.0693790466,
-0.0375841111,
0.0033548297,
-0.0019467814,
0.0163699593,
-0.0201532301,
0.0244513173,
0.0220728125,
-0.0377353244,
0.0827915147,
-0.0059564011,
0.0376962274,
-0.0288923495,
0.0681658238,
-0.1001472324,
0.0952602625,
0.018295398,
0.052472394,
-0.0479344837,
0.045506835,
-0.0002416959,
-0.0199572667,
0.0087142056,
0.0259614158,
-0.0355669931,
-0.0017027693,
0.0419970714,
-0.0526303686,
-0.0256545004,
0.0304574892,
-0.0185941271,
0.0108168488,
0.0768084899,
-0.0178281721,
-0.0306551289,
-0.0206506047,
-0.0504583828,
-0.0337644033,
0.0313037895,
0.0175562501,
-0.0226920508,
0.0130005423,
-0.0255515743,
0.0351166725,
-0.0378222205,
-0.0002650472,
-0.0105595514,
0.0433640815,
-0.0027032008,
0.0243193209,
-0.0895420089,
-0.0495095216,
-0.0330438912,
0.0147738187,
0.0283399839,
0.0072503453,
-0.0741617084,
-0.0330910571,
0.0613383576,
-0.0560911223,
-0.0036483703,
0.000188129,
-0.0892933086,
-0.013060173,
0.0316905081,
0.0759446025,
0.0081863347,
0.0424483269,
0.0219809134,
0.0067080162,
-0.0078339772,
-0.0432116389,
-0.0211523306,
-0.0402151346,
-0.0352856144,
-0.0433417745,
-0.0620669685,
0.0235406011,
0.0828227624,
0.0032932241,
-0.0090382937,
-0.0528133139,
-0.0088281287,
-0.0232705958,
-0.0839454308,
0.006354949,
-0.0066553117,
-0.0334377885,
0.0603484623,
0.0010740915,
-0.0773354247,
0.0229953118,
-0.0308404732,
-0.0025546439,
-0.0113634346,
-0.0167793073,
-0.000361659,
0.0454801284,
0.007290835,
-0.0055100145,
0.0018784881,
-0.0244456418,
-0.0495375171,
-0.0108536584,
0.0399402156,
-0.0130592706,
-0.0147800324,
-0.0509266779,
-0.0046734787,
-0.0129888626,
-0.0429143384,
0.0396638922,
-0.0263248235,
-0.0342262685,
-0.0087657161,
0.0638495833,
-0.0201802757,
0.0141463606,
0.026102813,
0.0372723676,
-0.0038264955,
0.0189481564,
0.0305265151,
0.0349109434,
-0.0277384073,
0.0171191022,
0.0175298508,
0.0264853872,
-0.0441015586,
0.0172476582,
-0.0057933573,
0.0109490575,
0.0794607103,
0.0522701479,
-0.0287234113,
0.0052590305,
0.0257582758,
-0.0724779516,
0.0801414028,
0.0719430223,
-0.0095304502,
0.0048140287,
0.0488674454,
-0.0075085554,
0.0056436709,
0.0410543531,
-0.0091351029,
0.0809384584,
-0.0198912937,
-0.0000748324,
-0.0409675129,
-0.0025105213,
0.0064474852,
0.0009938602,
-0.0399273932,
0.0181725081,
-0.0609088689,
-0.1222164258,
-0.0633068234,
0.0178151559,
-0.0160271749,
-0.0267540459,
-0.024411628,
-0.0246020015,
0.0220034234,
0.0027764975,
0.0466344915,
-0.0147586204,
-0.0021879959,
0.0259123426,
-0.1304429621,
-0.0137926545,
-0.0220566411,
-0.0020431795,
0.0896283314,
-0.0093452744,
0.0146566294,
-0.0424329005,
-0.0859138146,
0.0277923625,
-0.0199834891,
-0.01799009,
0.0369913727,
0.0434621125,
0.0496862456,
0.0022418695,
-0.0233741514,
0.0067851692,
0.03314358,
0.016596267,
0.0198261701,
-0.0177584179,
0.0074309334,
-0.044471927,
0.0280999485,
0.0466526039,
0.0101662846,
0.0690724552,
0.0525427908,
-0.0636193529,
-0.0347723812,
0.0349131413,
-0.0123932362,
-0.0064900145,
-0.0103724319,
-0.0155706927,
0.0220260862,
-0.0567690581,
-0.0547699519,
-0.035787385,
-0.0129716489,
0.0582111627,
0.0150576951,
0.0132970875,
-0.0163147543,
0.0440787375,
-0.0115362061,
-0.0591788664,
0.0113657583,
0.0094652139,
-0.074675709,
0.0127074225,
-0.0270567834,
-0.037457522,
-0.005090626,
0.0141676525,
-0.1150504649,
-0.0556760058,
-0.0015082542,
-0.0327394083,
0.0334530696,
0.0069856048,
0.0319408998,
-0.0641970485,
0.0182557441,
0.009330865,
-0.0431885608,
0.0817945525,
0.0519616865,
0.0128018688,
0.0344894566,
0.0363103226,
0.012354536,
0.0156186763,
-0.0174193196,
0.0451167822,
0.0003700907,
-0.0552355759,
-0.0100114606,
0.050198134,
-0.0215331595,
-0.0305365771,
0.0070418627,
-0.0045044571,
-0.0056455499,
-0.0051635141,
0.0429952033,
-0.0108467424,
-0.0204797853,
-0.0161392391,
0.0495021418,
-0.0079928432,
-0.033687938,
-0.0178251341,
-0.002477474,
0.0798009783,
0.0405713953,
-0.0179437883,
-0.0209671445,
0.055360999,
0.0280758273,
0.0070933285,
0.0207730234,
-0.0443789996,
0.0460900962,
0.0060763904,
0.0180093925,
0.003419861,
-0.0161667448,
0.008754855,
-0.0014113936,
-0.0112527674,
-0.0352449194,
0.0433671549,
0.0408021063,
-0.022792805,
0.0137736751,
0.0335214473,
-0.0453941822,
0.0224974491,
-0.0451783761,
0.0138890315,
-0.0512022115,
0.0053546866,
0.0247294046,
0.0148776993,
-0.0567093566,
0.0139920088,
0.0708526969,
0.0240728576,
-0.0116719967,
-0.035658747,
0.0044712168,
-0.009800774,
-0.0058912858,
-0.0152624026,
0.0171944126,
-0.0092603052,
0.0109724486,
-0.0827271417,
-0.0654305592,
0.0011934385,
-0.0031453006,
0.0452708416,
0.0126458332,
0.0127454642,
0.0359410383,
-0.028855931,
0.017504843,
-0.007202907,
-0.006689277,
-0.0067958906,
0.0260664001,
0.0241555404,
-5.705691622e-33,
0.0043543619,
0.0143062975,
0.0079883216,
0.029967593,
-0.0418958627,
0.0396506712,
-0.0176505223,
0.0358598083,
-0.0158223789,
0.0101386402,
-0.0032069997,
-0.0043577608,
0.0156536233,
-0.0057349997,
0.0197970979,
-0.0004520459,
-0.0057679359,
0.0134184146,
-0.0312509276,
-0.0495680384,
0.0156005351,
-0.0163597241,
0.0416407064,
0.010218773,
0.0602346137,
0.0432696156,
-0.0118691111,
-0.010350286,
0.0528230146,
0.0274804905,
-0.0017353884,
0.0475778505,
-0.0020609284,
-0.0533038676,
-0.0050690356,
0.0229546856,
-0.0056138067,
-0.0248209089,
0.0604231581,
0.0002549225,
-0.0091564041,
0.0109666297,
0.0097477846,
-0.0179819986,
-0.0668810159,
-0.0006312767,
-0.0092514437,
-0.0087243998,
-0.0170047469,
0.0031266771,
-0.0460192114,
0.021960916,
-0.0109346285,
0.011121016,
0.0250854809,
0.0198025815,
-0.0224316344,
-0.0555547029,
-0.0183024835,
0.0645830482,
-0.0052740267,
0.0765317157,
-0.0220092032,
-0.0189067125,
0.0311979465,
0.0251391884,
0.0840679631,
-0.0233153235,
-0.0036633778,
-0.0068808612,
0.0591766685,
-0.0615409724,
0.0230275784,
0.0459939651,
0.0621343218,
-0.0787165388,
-0.025266977,
-0.0441762656,
0.0325862132,
-0.0055195191,
-0.0123711405,
0.0308515001,
-0.0940093398,
-0.0579543486,
-0.0322467647,
0.0297404267,
-0.0016907261,
-0.0278050285,
0.0238034334,
0.0019393543,
0.0507520139,
0.0043589352,
0.068397671,
0.0099249408,
-0.026631359,
-0.0135569517,
0.0083809104,
0.0250548646,
-0.0117864599,
-0.0015800135,
-0.0522181578,
0.0079648513,
-0.0045169126,
0.0672384501,
0.0212730784,
-0.0090037286,
0.0228223018,
0.0080805309,
-0.060833361,
-0.0169930756,
-0.0062641231,
-0.0268103499,
0.0550498106,
-0.0542306118,
0.043191202,
-0.0069014151,
-0.0241778046,
-0.0164341219,
0.007291398,
-0.0393975936,
-0.0155410562,
-0.0111411996,
-0.0294958726,
0.0116606103,
-0.0645404458,
-0.0183744989,
-0.0264325216,
0.0210447256,
0.050834015,
-0.0276656654,
-0.0222435854,
-0.0366330594,
2.732e-7,
0.0163893793,
0.0019067494,
0.0552977733,
0.001095572,
0.0195865761,
-0.0023935707,
0.0196008757,
-0.0081287501,
-0.0501540788,
-0.0149703585,
-0.0061133765,
-0.0142836794,
0.0512102433,
-0.0115391472,
-0.0319344699,
-0.0234838203,
-0.0973424166,
-0.0063660922,
0.0035454768,
0.0083594378,
0.0128582828,
0.0480998382,
0.0192051157,
-0.0148888538,
-0.0536966398,
-0.0140215736,
0.0054743616,
-0.0670313761,
0.000986975,
0.0190431643,
-0.0047401907,
0.0124663981,
0.0011637548,
0.0129344519,
-0.0195055418,
0.0178589318,
0.0229759421,
0.0106986314,
0.0131683564,
0.0083036693,
0.0114120189,
-0.008455771,
-0.0718447119,
0.0010719149,
0.0166003238,
0.0125758294,
-0.0367125645,
0.0012726549,
0.0298425257,
0.0231058151,
-0.0068077873,
0.0057639135,
0.0107819699,
-0.0018756718,
-0.003124716,
0.0022465573,
0.0481667146,
-0.0217729826,
-0.0280318502,
0.0419931561,
0.0144306906,
-0.0667951703,
-0.0413430408,
0.0477597825,
0.0220547542,
-0.0333729796,
-0.0071065524,
2.239465741e-34,
0.0581350997,
-0.0185053591,
0.0330592953,
-0.0271852352,
0.0301284865,
-0.0276865941,
0.0454359166,
0.0138398865,
0.0586006492,
-0.0293221734,
-0.0239173882
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.07550v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.07550v1 | Understanding (Un)Intended Memorization in Text-to-Image Generative Models | 2023-12-06T19:53:17 | 2023-12-06T19:53:17 | Ali Naseh, Jaechul Roh, Amir Houmansadr | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.LG | Multimodal machine learning, especially text-to-image models like Stable
Diffusion and DALL-E 3, has gained significance for transforming text into
detailed images.
Despite their growing use and remarkable generative capabilities, there is a
pressing need for a detailed examination of these models' behavior,
particularly with respect to memorization. Historically, memorization in
machine learning has been context-dependent, with diverse definitions emerging
from classification tasks to complex models like Large Language Models (LLMs)
and Diffusion models. Yet, a definitive concept of memorization that aligns
with the intricacies of text-to-image synthesis remains elusive. This
understanding is vital as memorization poses privacy risks yet is essential for
meeting user expectations, especially when generating representations of
underrepresented entities. In this paper, we introduce a specialized definition
of memorization tailored to text-to-image models, categorizing it into three
distinct types according to user expectations. We closely examine the subtle
distinctions between intended and unintended memorization, emphasizing the
importance of balancing user privacy with the generative quality of the model
outputs. Using the Stable Diffusion model, we offer examples to validate our
memorization definitions and clarify their application. | [
0.0190166049,
0.0738381967,
-0.0154551398,
0.0446092896,
-0.0356564894,
-0.0040535443,
0.0533517115,
-0.0065655112,
0.006295661,
0.0005358621,
-0.0226301346,
-0.0508889332,
0.0303253923,
-0.0080654975,
0.0320894457,
-0.0878326893,
0.0030296438,
-0.0338597894,
-0.0532746539,
-0.032317277,
-0.0007593328,
0.0043065809,
0.0272405948,
-0.0060232459,
-0.045272287,
-0.0438602939,
0.003857275,
0.0052507301,
0.016034767,
-0.0107241021,
-0.0264108572,
0.066224061,
0.0349937566,
-0.0027446211,
0.0000023252,
-0.0325326659,
-0.0325541943,
0.0192802772,
-0.0013586063,
0.0115325572,
0.0813115239,
-0.0427464172,
0.0131555218,
-0.0557462201,
-0.014627235,
0.0489187986,
0.0879619271,
0.0536545627,
0.0538668931,
0.0446679667,
-0.0110690994,
-0.055962082,
0.0252999477,
-0.0235181823,
0.0625050217,
-0.0254904367,
0.0144185517,
0.0125126969,
-0.060090147,
0.0129254786,
-0.0450366661,
0.0441193208,
0.0203072838,
0.0238097943,
0.0667828396,
0.0572351143,
0.0776843429,
-0.0527326465,
-0.0060002934,
0.0461309589,
0.0098440712,
0.0016872188,
0.0093082758,
0.0157692488,
0.0062843794,
0.0784632415,
-0.0298721306,
0.0115421712,
-0.0248682816,
-0.0057900399,
-0.0669910461,
-0.0041003777,
0.01678144,
-0.0236049965,
0.03480516,
-0.0358566232,
0.0138938352,
0.0180795658,
-0.0572441854,
-0.0157698318,
0.0044645648,
-0.0728215799,
0.08790043,
0.0300426185,
0.0757364109,
0.0228548944,
-0.0537762493,
-0.0602253899,
0.0365006477,
-0.0460969359,
0.0557213947,
-0.0363864191,
-0.0043343259,
0.0301856082,
-0.0404993594,
0.0354720689,
-0.0256051589,
0.0362122469,
-0.0025077956,
0.0383178219,
-0.0098867081,
-0.0268667582,
-0.0190513302,
0.0100639984,
-0.0013092532,
-0.0262995847,
-0.0303657893,
0.0128329294,
-0.0273138583,
0.0323695652,
-0.0017254045,
0.0258318279,
-0.0784051791,
-0.0197463818,
-0.0489533134,
-0.0297311265,
-0.0050215465,
-0.0143719707,
0.0344439782,
0.0039303275,
-0.0122247739,
-0.0261658262,
0.0199281015,
-0.011581785,
-0.0320807174,
0.0840870291,
-0.0392835215,
-0.0130644916,
-0.0393176302,
-0.0489900634,
-0.0164706446,
-0.0589130595,
0.0690244809,
-0.0602667704,
0.0122627774,
-0.0255021099,
0.0149041824,
-0.0848443359,
-0.0123667838,
0.0322856903,
-0.0047285715,
0.0687171295,
0.0243854057,
-0.0208527651,
0.0437405184,
0.0552193932,
-0.0150437746,
0.0201686192,
0.0349584632,
0.0776053667,
0.0304764267,
-0.0409178212,
0.0500107184,
-0.0042774016,
0.0538093075,
0.0078843841,
-0.014227001,
-0.0193474796,
-0.0023639372,
-0.0340277366,
0.0651135147,
0.0662518367,
-0.0302432831,
-0.0561757199,
0.0985041857,
0.079236351,
-0.0037350014,
0.0190028436,
-0.0026690904,
-0.0009182158,
-0.0036623448,
0.0577992052,
-0.01341986,
0.0418053269,
0.0008658039,
-0.0105432672,
-0.0136684598,
0.033191435,
-0.0219839718,
-0.0193819478,
0.019455133,
-0.0485511497,
0.0484958291,
-0.0179728698,
0.0178449415,
0.0528716668,
-0.0294590667,
0.0207898561,
-0.0321295708,
-0.0367717966,
0.0045728483,
-0.0435622334,
0.0366241857,
0.0970467255,
0.0112913018,
0.0239085443,
0.0547369495,
-0.0224020164,
0.0057688048,
0.0225582961,
-0.0174736697,
0.0264893454,
0.0477736816,
-0.0459427983,
-0.0457273759,
0.0016008263,
0.0131934742,
0.0459084027,
-0.0153288301,
-0.0047968365,
0.0047610365,
-0.0313707218,
0.0083960807,
0.0276669376,
-0.0136097269,
-0.0428648442,
-0.0008323355,
0.0154451225,
0.0045077987,
0.0127356853,
0.0051387083,
0.0003492243,
0.0091463309,
0.0185589083,
0.0116759408,
-0.0061687734,
-0.0602498278,
-0.0092640221,
-0.0454641879,
-0.0397989266,
0.0085375765,
0.010549915,
-0.0023233164,
-0.0146050509,
0.0062539559,
-0.0125092547,
0.0493114926,
-0.0303027015,
-0.0128805973,
0.0290429704,
0.0219435468,
-0.0159385242,
0.0715791434,
-0.080833137,
-0.038202852,
-0.0367840417,
0.0128338272,
-0.0289041903,
-0.0464742519,
0.0021235007,
-0.0000804844,
0.0208140388,
0.0399262235,
0.004841106,
-0.024532441,
-0.041791752,
-0.0038179073,
-0.0179816596,
-0.0051148003,
-0.0117844613,
-0.0116515597,
-0.0028631641,
-0.0264847726,
0.0117147071,
-0.0197288878,
-0.0390924327,
0.0116151851,
-0.0469969325,
0.015504648,
0.0331494771,
-0.0006493116,
-0.0074533201,
-0.0080788322,
-0.0275734477,
0.0276804417,
0.0669893473,
-0.016626209,
-0.0122075332,
-0.0384616964,
0.0349623449,
-0.0088673439,
0.0063480856,
-0.020578187,
-0.00264388,
0.011582193,
0.0140393097,
0.0466463268,
0.0786004439,
0.0492839701,
0.0508409329,
-0.0122158723,
-0.0017273633,
-0.0320132673,
-0.0243974216,
-0.0537558272,
-0.0110672861,
0.0291170888,
-0.0540318117,
0.0076224739,
0.0221739858,
0.0184493307,
-0.0049127969,
-0.0331243984,
0.0300178546,
-0.0004379912,
-0.0582589395,
-0.0323686227,
0.0011491937,
-0.0114792734,
-0.0064891046,
-0.0590910465,
-0.0921157449,
0.0432408899,
-0.0289108288,
0.0196987987,
0.0322179757,
0.0079107229,
0.0380392969,
0.0424182937,
0.0340715684,
0.0699181408,
0.0398466736,
-0.0062818523,
-0.0102584343,
-0.0091676731,
0.0419367366,
-0.0300950762,
0.0322482511,
0.0076928325,
-0.0252269376,
-0.0092556328,
0.0039485996,
-0.0251969937,
-0.0270094555,
0.056357909,
0.0040356657,
-0.0272993594,
-0.0266242493,
0.0065400181,
-0.019974051,
0.0310835838,
-0.0361079052,
0.0091595426,
-0.0293693524,
-0.0198166855,
0.0431171656,
0.0177758541,
-0.0239040852,
-0.0422618054,
-0.061777018,
-0.0054535647,
0.0834029168,
0.0347428061,
-0.0041166362,
-0.0005569541,
-0.0103801936,
-0.0225758608,
0.0577440709,
-0.015039932,
0.0371912867,
0.0814086422,
-0.0409581177,
0.0113529479,
0.0247972086,
-0.0087221749,
-0.0302464161,
-0.0105181709,
0.048371844,
0.0578258373,
-0.0224162973,
-0.0384517573,
-0.0847027823,
0.0001587466,
-0.0106743975,
0.0336661749,
-0.0254025124,
-0.0202371478,
-0.0110245347,
-0.0528405309,
0.0430587828,
0.0149692297,
-0.006790895,
0.0067060264,
-0.0325829014,
-0.0071886186,
0.0228867177,
-0.0007450855,
-0.023549147,
-0.0012901147,
-0.0301861074,
0.0263212938,
0.0301467795,
-0.0465874411,
-0.009618911,
-0.0045503099,
0.0019895269,
0.0616834685,
0.0153520387,
0.0134621644,
-0.094416298,
0.0053062756,
0.0300759152,
0.0161276292,
0.0128560169,
0.0748019964,
-0.0005832128,
0.0109562017,
-0.0304336008,
0.0466451533,
0.0298290551,
-0.0279634148,
-0.0385274217,
0.0355332531,
-0.0001936402,
-0.0354771391,
-0.0229949635,
-0.0126074292,
0.0393900387,
0.041737929,
0.019791875,
-0.0368278101,
-0.0326314904,
-0.0453388803,
0.1024913788,
-0.0416496471,
-0.0332420468,
0.0288045537,
-0.0237216614,
-0.0570028238,
-0.0731647909,
-0.0122461105,
-0.0435652919,
0.0459510759,
0.0138332741,
0.0086652543,
0.0030340122,
-0.0165138096,
-0.0453331806,
0.0284394417,
-0.0299089979,
-0.0001109508,
-0.0223752391,
-0.0601069294,
0.000151361,
-0.0398401842,
-0.0247708689,
0.0355222374,
-0.0881675184,
-0.0203440078,
0.0157117788,
0.0674555153,
0.0207832027,
0.0158372186,
0.0154206511,
-0.0506476574,
0.1094042063,
0.0525755733,
0.0210251641,
0.0165433865,
0.0231003687,
-0.0016060754,
-0.0256984998,
-0.0070403153,
-0.0046968525,
0.0166125298,
0.0270833578,
-0.0403344221,
-0.0321487673,
0.0128409425,
-0.0098683266,
-0.0202663355,
0.0113571705,
-0.0242792405,
0.0307881385,
-0.0172943678,
0.0006217858,
0.0039186468,
0.004424938,
-0.0461562499,
-0.0391340554,
0.0407639965,
0.0169814341,
0.0306403562,
-0.0274901856,
0.0414682142,
0.0436221659,
-0.0444515347,
-0.0201280359,
0.0729192495,
0.0070401351,
-0.0029744701,
0.0413634107,
-0.04640425,
0.0643665791,
-0.0499176532,
0.0405907184,
0.0093489178,
0.0659699216,
-0.0130991135,
-0.0109324232,
-0.0181168206,
0.0262987558,
-0.0415817983,
-0.0203483291,
-0.0686273351,
0.05194363,
0.0111014452,
0.0124224424,
0.0327051654,
-0.0538493097,
0.0145749571,
-0.0390025564,
0.0008351307,
0.0106782056,
-0.029187005,
-0.0097278953,
-0.0087063741,
0.0255920645,
0.0059456695,
0.0757181346,
-0.0158237554,
0.0252472945,
-0.0671836287,
-0.0432536565,
-0.0272725821,
-0.0432428345,
0.0151516655,
0.0012423237,
0.0394635722,
-0.0293320883,
-0.0488498993,
-0.0865287334,
0.0011197372,
0.0305401906,
0.0272008069,
0.0015785574,
0.043993257,
0.0291979387,
-0.0232295115,
-0.013394882,
-0.0390399359,
0.0279743131,
-0.0163047537,
0.0171324983,
0.0008474221,
-6.917060591e-33,
-0.0217943639,
-0.0415610448,
0.0026742504,
-0.0240701251,
0.0078012766,
0.0111760879,
-0.0205495767,
-0.0067552142,
0.0229424573,
-0.0038550966,
-0.0193869006,
-0.0324968249,
0.0040725796,
0.045662567,
-0.042405501,
0.0124944327,
0.0323068053,
-0.0383884199,
-0.0350335576,
0.053066574,
0.0822924748,
0.0194816925,
0.0223575309,
-0.0774145722,
0.0621664859,
0.0099520478,
-0.0630072951,
-0.038527552,
0.0002257948,
0.0625449046,
-0.0524463616,
-0.007678749,
0.0046095192,
-0.0146646723,
-0.0563028306,
0.0506912544,
-0.0765492469,
0.0136019383,
-0.002443844,
-0.0067298668,
-0.080986388,
-0.0659254193,
0.0864423141,
-0.0637148842,
-0.016657453,
-0.0247512925,
0.0323872715,
-0.0107672429,
-0.0238926783,
-0.022121422,
-0.0377608985,
0.0023329633,
-0.0154597675,
-0.013882339,
0.0237720981,
0.0165126901,
0.0223624129,
0.0046320581,
-0.0881198421,
0.0100717414,
0.0300084371,
-0.0373492241,
0.0775204673,
0.0449835174,
0.04498218,
0.062443573,
0.035230834,
0.0296786334,
-0.0057868049,
-0.0124697946,
-0.0120051,
0.0508830473,
0.0095719257,
0.0353930779,
0.0483741052,
-0.0238247458,
0.0044944431,
0.0287538804,
-0.0969106257,
-0.0088966507,
0.074331753,
0.0105808955,
-0.0297774076,
-0.0041502491,
-0.0366293378,
-0.0077389851,
-0.0145532694,
-0.0250778981,
0.0100849681,
0.0143499533,
-0.0545380116,
0.0058227889,
0.0465655476,
-0.0222979896,
-0.0586650297,
-0.0194249842,
0.0117743723,
0.0372159779,
-0.0106744869,
-0.0159780625,
-0.0208183527,
-0.0202184934,
0.0444951802,
0.0272145793,
0.0162255317,
0.0258620773,
0.0388885401,
-0.012573665,
-0.0371537767,
-0.026562212,
-0.0451626405,
0.0329037718,
0.0302200299,
0.0192306992,
0.0479418635,
-0.0330313332,
-0.0546423607,
0.0181058329,
0.0014330238,
0.0263239406,
-0.0195638631,
0.0187552087,
-0.0506401025,
0.0177069269,
-0.0091776485,
-0.0094815586,
0.0030137852,
0.0037809794,
0.1075290963,
-0.0357721783,
0.0285833366,
0.0011527678,
2.938e-7,
0.0048986319,
0.0007526472,
0.0123891346,
-0.0207846966,
0.0270985756,
0.0619264096,
-0.0227074884,
0.0546210818,
-0.0078218309,
-0.0596326478,
-0.0185347125,
0.0537982807,
0.03496591,
0.031392172,
0.001033022,
-0.0418114811,
0.003204253,
0.0417519771,
-0.0162613541,
0.0099825477,
0.0354572497,
0.0360337757,
-0.0128068663,
-0.0370320454,
0.0256595593,
-0.0385835655,
0.0989747718,
-0.0565663986,
0.0227004364,
-0.0349301472,
0.0443257578,
0.0202918705,
0.0062384396,
-0.0016409452,
-0.0119628459,
-0.0346984826,
0.0173729211,
0.0865111947,
-0.0071465117,
-0.0360081196,
-0.0065928199,
-0.0127220005,
-0.0227208678,
-0.0271215476,
0.0300197955,
-0.0233067758,
-0.0178233758,
0.0045430325,
-0.0074872947,
-0.0275543146,
0.0472463742,
-0.0053734528,
-0.039229501,
0.0078548193,
0.0001706347,
0.0213309079,
-0.0038093606,
-0.0536073335,
-0.0210677516,
-0.0325273573,
-0.0435970612,
-0.0493122377,
-0.0306849331,
0.0197712015,
-0.0072067082,
-0.0194436368,
0.0002518391,
2.476858662e-34,
-0.0083363196,
-0.0103335492,
-0.0038396239,
-0.0141017409,
0.0151192276,
-0.0208897348,
0.043763224,
-0.011627296,
0.0184878651,
-0.0724682137,
-0.0226751864
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03872v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03872v1 | The BigCode Project Governance Card | 2023-12-06T19:37:08 | 2023-12-06T19:37:08 | BigCode collaboration, Sean Hughes, Harm de Vries, Jennifer Robinson, Carlos Muñoz Ferrandis, Loubna Ben Allal, Leandro von Werra, Jennifer Ding, Sebastien Paquet, Yacine Jernite | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.PL | This document serves as an overview of the different mechanisms and areas of
governance in the BigCode project. It aims to support transparency by providing
relevant information about choices that were made during the project to the
broader public, and to serve as an example of intentional governance of an open
research project that future endeavors can leverage to shape their own
approach. The first section, Project Structure, covers the project
organization, its stated goals and values, its internal decision processes, and
its funding and resources. The second section, Data and Model Governance,
covers decisions relating to the questions of data subject consent, privacy,
and model release. | [
0.0358428657,
0.0982674137,
-0.042746257,
-0.0074139871,
-0.0289948564,
-0.0043153395,
0.0125862071,
-0.0217154045,
0.0226909444,
0.0084606297,
0.0557120591,
0.024459105,
0.0153503576,
0.1269416064,
-0.0207908414,
-0.0218786802,
0.0102522271,
-0.0011242034,
-0.0005989349,
0.0244336184,
0.0004282504,
0.016767947,
0.0030725992,
0.0284661502,
-0.0019337393,
0.0019363069,
0.0194281079,
0.0163895339,
-0.0090941805,
-0.027731875,
0.0436784104,
0.002448387,
-0.0579962917,
0.0314289145,
0.0000023453,
-0.0192690361,
-0.0397747345,
0.0156359039,
-0.0085209589,
0.0275044758,
0.0284084901,
0.0054069967,
-0.0189707857,
0.0414240956,
-0.0158202928,
-0.0522037707,
0.0995502695,
-0.0074884882,
-0.0049000513,
-0.0073392964,
-0.0006415773,
-0.0455419421,
-0.0607818663,
0.0073319771,
-0.0212710761,
0.0956228524,
0.0040406142,
0.025101915,
0.0389740467,
0.0616956055,
-0.0044971099,
-0.0017354123,
0.0183089133,
0.0032309752,
0.0344660059,
0.0570397638,
0.0191385876,
-0.0695814788,
-0.0146606332,
0.0112879025,
0.1050787121,
0.013479691,
0.0722585917,
-0.0056967903,
-0.0264564436,
-0.0128826778,
-0.0018089286,
0.0364631787,
0.0050500543,
0.009700045,
-0.0472858958,
0.0158965141,
-0.013870812,
0.0108380383,
0.0094840936,
0.0412842073,
-0.0268479288,
0.0104714297,
-0.0759742483,
0.0274011362,
0.0614377446,
-0.0614443794,
-0.0154849784,
0.0188117921,
0.0184583962,
-0.0246982537,
0.0085839313,
0.0299028531,
0.0557416119,
-0.005000629,
-0.0498387776,
-0.0213221386,
0.0024825034,
0.0166212581,
0.0682375282,
-0.0165010188,
-0.0903713256,
0.0215067677,
0.0222764146,
0.0102775292,
-0.0092309415,
0.0314349383,
0.0346260518,
0.0109919431,
-0.046123106,
0.0358129926,
-0.0232186131,
0.0095513836,
0.0106186215,
0.0475352369,
0.0161506459,
0.0430526584,
0.0162800625,
0.0256159753,
-0.0192755889,
-0.0210110843,
-0.0521161295,
0.0095259212,
0.0081467126,
-0.017925458,
-0.0097279092,
-0.0403646901,
0.0195880439,
-0.0162852071,
0.0095005305,
0.0329739116,
0.0506367683,
0.0352404974,
-0.0449540019,
-0.0709311888,
0.0020839914,
-0.0131691527,
-0.0044407533,
-0.0134885246,
-0.0362711996,
-0.0053836089,
0.0128763774,
-0.0041034869,
-0.0408973396,
-0.0193333738,
-0.0343245976,
0.001896246,
-0.0473839976,
-0.0222107377,
0.0071114777,
0.0660119653,
-0.0191534739,
-0.0116747785,
-0.0287990868,
0.0103388615,
0.0193245038,
-0.0388656408,
0.0498853475,
-0.000910824,
0.0091374097,
0.0001483068,
0.0473069884,
0.0695318878,
0.0981474221,
-0.0144249694,
-0.0392294414,
0.0416676849,
-0.0178169571,
0.0785275996,
0.0469137058,
0.0405635647,
0.0266287941,
-0.0112369414,
-0.0655418485,
0.0372778997,
-0.0182317495,
-0.0930246934,
-0.0151490709,
0.0587700866,
0.0007947074,
-0.0356521495,
-0.0952550173,
0.0364350192,
-0.0049016769,
-0.0094538424,
0.0099579589,
-0.048127301,
-0.0550659113,
0.0505348891,
-0.0020281877,
-0.0055919397,
0.0301896892,
-0.0263099689,
0.0116503285,
-0.0378829353,
-0.002096999,
-0.019631505,
0.0902898833,
-0.0009563033,
0.0466282926,
0.0018616797,
0.0226072073,
-0.0516607203,
-0.0212326441,
-0.0500378273,
0.0510231107,
-0.0087411739,
0.0129229119,
-0.014275359,
-0.0618250929,
0.0077440925,
-0.0294016972,
-0.0234133657,
0.0046316348,
0.0357531719,
-0.0452833436,
0.0785518885,
-0.0193647612,
0.0173292439,
-0.0323139913,
-0.0177648533,
-0.0024305012,
0.0023628629,
0.0316367038,
0.0296139121,
-0.0215759687,
0.0086538084,
0.0118175074,
0.0562696569,
0.0175665822,
-0.0609197281,
0.0570388883,
0.0826613978,
-0.0230021495,
-0.0484223664,
0.0017729609,
-0.0014304089,
-0.0436220542,
0.0311098713,
0.0263942368,
-0.0196798109,
-0.002362499,
0.0458183065,
-0.0047263666,
-0.0618179552,
-0.0106774122,
-0.008634665,
-0.0031226345,
0.0191357974,
-0.0023713456,
0.0164880957,
-0.0428354703,
0.0248674098,
0.0200011674,
0.0257200487,
0.0801195949,
-0.0290455911,
-0.0013021415,
0.0483555682,
-0.0016919242,
-0.0537874885,
0.0028049119,
0.0140944533,
-0.0109408647,
0.0056657153,
-0.0177451707,
-0.0260681305,
0.0546174534,
0.0001012307,
-0.0011966669,
0.0374625437,
-0.0516151227,
-0.0324166119,
-0.0362419114,
0.0083268024,
0.0179811679,
-0.0170403607,
0.0027691438,
-0.0152383493,
0.0255991183,
0.0594267212,
0.0462402292,
0.0122328904,
-0.025419211,
0.004727677,
-0.040548373,
-0.041072432,
0.0072206021,
-0.0354235098,
-0.0096181044,
0.0099271946,
0.0212105159,
0.0051000542,
-0.024233805,
0.0338832922,
0.0218329653,
-0.0446189865,
-0.0294669103,
-0.015890738,
0.0331557728,
-0.0275715198,
-0.0070365649,
0.0222358536,
0.0332812816,
-0.0211611725,
-0.0031325212,
-0.0024201598,
-0.0148822544,
0.0184347276,
-0.0388219431,
0.0096206302,
0.0087032914,
-0.0150269046,
-0.0092818253,
0.078086175,
-0.0201960243,
-0.048722066,
0.014068299,
-0.0131724291,
0.0061551468,
-0.043937929,
-0.05767278,
-0.0576711558,
0.0849650502,
-0.033711262,
0.0234565735,
-0.00160169,
-0.009816031,
0.0212095529,
-0.0318842195,
-0.0027849684,
-0.0711349249,
-0.0946261138,
-0.0194768235,
-0.039930325,
-0.0116956867,
-0.0067519033,
0.0108833238,
0.0058700228,
-0.0155573934,
-0.0285194293,
0.0883392096,
0.0005655349,
-0.0040258104,
0.0015328877,
0.0815825015,
0.022289684,
0.0415936969,
-0.0188922454,
0.0300166309,
-0.0556134917,
-0.0445712097,
-0.0446140543,
0.0549694486,
0.0325345211,
-0.0535054021,
0.0289260894,
0.0307259243,
0.0037525441,
-0.0462787077,
0.0078622783,
0.0354413725,
-0.0243568607,
-0.0003745935,
0.0510448031,
0.0442355685,
0.0043469789,
-0.0024479211,
0.0099134678,
0.0117844874,
-0.059101928,
-0.0025026554,
-0.0040647015,
-0.0250698775,
0.0120434882,
-0.0121136382,
-0.0891550481,
0.0291869156,
-0.0071785999,
0.014646044,
-0.0901812464,
-0.0396568142,
-0.0154886823,
-0.0086487643,
0.0732334927,
0.0039397604,
0.0245005172,
-0.0304733627,
-0.0358437933,
0.0196954105,
-0.0460094921,
-0.0523896627,
-0.0144824712,
0.0003202637,
-0.0007318663,
0.002004507,
-0.0511944517,
-0.0004863112,
-0.0373666808,
-0.0846805945,
0.0612302236,
0.1006073207,
-0.0032377676,
0.0011347441,
0.0369245596,
-0.0067810141,
-0.0271560941,
-0.0544368625,
-0.0107862595,
0.0096853971,
0.0177167282,
-0.0143717667,
-0.0275748894,
0.0582845025,
-0.0013902293,
-0.0075644609,
0.0305104852,
0.0481106155,
-0.0540818498,
-0.0023918976,
-0.0508186184,
-0.0255481713,
0.0356849134,
0.0317038633,
-0.0046112323,
0.0080492944,
-0.0275537856,
-0.0107148131,
0.0039179516,
-0.0061663706,
0.0208521597,
0.0146088414,
0.0274178814,
0.028286349,
0.0250464622,
-0.0050724689,
0.0347994491,
0.0166638587,
0.0375631526,
-0.0488744453,
0.0662021637,
-0.0162100215,
-0.0486883484,
0.0151188653,
0.0021536283,
0.0132208792,
-0.0383828133,
-0.0187527388,
0.0301370304,
0.041768305,
-0.0114301909,
0.0588296354,
-0.0005175569,
0.0023684578,
0.0131413685,
0.0445079803,
0.0284436848,
-0.0158304069,
-0.000890572,
-0.0438087732,
0.0168369468,
-0.0208588392,
-0.0792079046,
-0.021574894,
-0.0253206491,
0.0019170207,
-0.0402062461,
-0.0556802414,
-0.0228060409,
0.0090801548,
0.0098831393,
-0.0633511171,
0.0154649699,
0.0562415794,
0.0013146985,
-0.0039982479,
0.0148147698,
-0.0116622215,
-0.0306261871,
0.027222123,
-0.0147570781,
0.0060571479,
-0.0095685842,
-0.0110522024,
-0.0261544548,
0.037306916,
0.0141374245,
0.000169868,
0.0365538187,
0.0153680425,
0.025164606,
-0.0361045375,
0.0840722919,
0.0202198382,
0.0616610833,
0.0392057225,
-0.0156179694,
-0.0180405248,
0.022620149,
-0.0426877849,
0.0214786008,
0.023447942,
-0.0095336726,
-0.0084840422,
0.0339068137,
0.0271970406,
0.0065901545,
-0.0111527881,
-0.0747385621,
0.0304084215,
-0.010819952,
-0.0607300811,
0.0964491889,
-0.0410638675,
-0.0329250731,
0.0144253708,
-0.0403100215,
0.0120000085,
-0.0347746089,
-0.0086736111,
-0.0048578111,
-0.0103418995,
-0.0536511987,
-0.050168965,
0.0306566246,
0.0267897509,
-0.0009362845,
-0.0930094197,
0.0244855117,
-0.0030870626,
-0.000369125,
0.0507980771,
0.0160953645,
-0.0165712237,
-0.0333024301,
-0.0133945355,
0.0232222546,
-0.0365188532,
-0.0157226492,
0.0281009749,
-0.0215951186,
0.0183555875,
-0.0386212952,
0.0174787007,
-0.088853471,
0.0191721413,
-0.0277727321,
-0.0596482046,
-0.043240305,
-0.0062097092,
-6.874831691e-33,
0.0309041385,
-0.0593151227,
0.0131989149,
-0.0141733056,
-0.0318281427,
0.0347936377,
0.002099863,
-0.0421027578,
-0.0172584429,
-0.0374208093,
0.0175770763,
0.044500757,
0.0052390848,
0.0270524733,
0.0755885765,
-0.036741443,
0.0416920483,
-0.0024873586,
-0.0061981357,
0.0535145253,
-0.0598071143,
-0.0099272141,
-0.0230915807,
-0.0253004096,
0.0338113233,
0.0092939669,
-0.0248542204,
-0.004750845,
0.0135721145,
0.0610713027,
0.0066189985,
-0.0470558032,
0.0051020226,
-0.0581054986,
0.0124824857,
0.0735770911,
-0.0644490048,
0.0077170273,
-0.0135062784,
-0.0088777672,
-0.0174739473,
-0.0730103776,
0.0415182114,
0.0015042943,
-0.0457095504,
-0.0569744259,
-0.0103557771,
0.0076678446,
-0.03005879,
-0.0095135095,
0.0299406964,
0.0113354325,
-0.0384591185,
0.091251269,
0.0162340142,
0.0227663796,
-0.0098502254,
0.0426110215,
0.0449749827,
0.0386001803,
-0.0011181334,
-0.0315251835,
0.0050981301,
0.0306307394,
-0.0105792088,
0.0382035933,
-0.0116851013,
-0.0432560667,
-0.0334588066,
-0.0142094372,
-0.0178308096,
0.0784727857,
0.0227684807,
0.0283960588,
-0.081165269,
-0.0442377552,
-0.0146675147,
-0.0096751163,
0.0071412507,
-0.0008128454,
0.0013156128,
-0.0215501282,
-0.0473244414,
-0.0132244965,
0.0428941138,
-0.0842135102,
-0.0170085449,
0.0174827129,
0.0065216185,
-0.0258314945,
-0.0510890968,
0.090530023,
0.0386607535,
-0.0669082403,
0.0442237221,
0.0290589873,
0.0245659612,
0.0799796358,
0.0121893454,
0.0292218383,
-0.0372961685,
-0.0284117348,
0.0499015376,
0.0183315054,
0.0389329195,
0.0255145989,
-0.04547593,
0.0063834526,
-0.0435000509,
0.0073356405,
-0.0110005047,
0.0512208194,
-0.0265244301,
-0.0478741899,
-0.0084018577,
0.0024162377,
0.0594146736,
0.0035064239,
0.0137125645,
0.0563618802,
-0.0097603137,
-0.0112976506,
-0.0205355342,
-0.0176349655,
-0.0003480022,
-0.0228836611,
-0.0225886051,
-0.0286567528,
0.0502332896,
0.0027527269,
-0.0247982778,
0.0040861298,
3.053e-7,
-0.0002422223,
0.0430081561,
0.007035458,
-0.0184309632,
0.0056937309,
0.0010820359,
0.0248280875,
0.0323752835,
-0.0455785915,
-0.0104489625,
0.0208987575,
-0.0630726814,
0.0475533381,
0.0014918416,
0.0040307892,
-0.0594960526,
-0.0290787332,
0.0016001612,
-0.1013741642,
0.0098092165,
0.0476140603,
-0.0021780322,
0.0170689151,
0.0118379742,
0.0369980633,
0.0059840223,
-0.0244771056,
-0.0252788514,
0.0223926865,
0.0171964932,
-0.0354911312,
0.0469397791,
0.0190689974,
-0.063453719,
0.0073550302,
-0.0686555728,
-0.0571572632,
0.0363755859,
0.0478935055,
0.0206303168,
-0.0074245711,
-0.0488879308,
0.0015289451,
-0.034492407,
0.0365734361,
0.0249058977,
-0.0417135619,
0.019375287,
0.0015187279,
-0.0952541381,
0.0537077002,
0.0104102222,
0.0500150882,
-0.0062915878,
0.0020053894,
-0.0446337424,
-0.0686071888,
-0.0283215549,
0.0462003909,
-0.0315080695,
0.0197233092,
-0.0576571152,
0.0169180334,
0.0195986107,
0.0357745998,
-0.0391468741,
0.0635573268,
2.816656427e-34,
-0.002717074,
-0.0604448318,
-0.0093406411,
-0.0132258404,
0.0414348915,
0.0003398841,
-0.0035026297,
-0.0337478407,
-0.0006912373,
-0.0167310182,
0.0255671367
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03863v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03863v4 | Efficient Large Language Models: A Survey | 2023-12-06T19:18:42 | 2024-05-23T06:08:37 | Zhongwei Wan, Xin Wang, Che Liu, Samiul Alam, Yu Zheng, Jiachen Liu, Zhongnan Qu, Shen Yan, Yi Zhu, Quanlu Zhang, Mosharaf Chowdhury, Mi Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable capabilities in
important tasks such as natural language understanding and language generation,
and thus have the potential to make a substantial impact on our society. Such
capabilities, however, come with the considerable resources they demand,
highlighting the strong need to develop effective techniques for addressing
their efficiency challenges. In this survey, we provide a systematic and
comprehensive review of efficient LLMs research. We organize the literature in
a taxonomy consisting of three main categories, covering distinct yet
interconnected efficient LLMs topics from model-centric, data-centric, and
framework-centric perspective, respectively. We have also created a GitHub
repository where we organize the papers featured in this survey at
https://github.com/AIoT-MLSys-Lab/Efficient-LLMs-Survey. We will actively
maintain the repository and incorporate new research as it emerges. We hope our
survey can serve as a valuable resource to help researchers and practitioners
gain a systematic understanding of efficient LLMs research and inspire them to
contribute to this important and exciting field. | [
0.0266156867,
0.0814577267,
-0.0061010779,
0.0784960687,
-0.0302663557,
0.0027503315,
-0.0103304079,
-0.0019948801,
-0.0087484038,
-0.0690569058,
-0.0328979716,
-0.068010971,
0.0076793064,
0.0195208155,
0.0117740585,
-0.0217940975,
0.0404349267,
-0.0713552237,
-0.0195487011,
-0.0158034116,
-0.0031657969,
0.0038197876,
0.0179452822,
0.0232318453,
0.0033692038,
0.0103622926,
-0.011625506,
0.0296197869,
-0.0184627995,
-0.0125806946,
-0.0148674687,
0.0267133731,
0.015567231,
0.0665053353,
0.0000020904,
-0.050545115,
-0.0305779725,
0.0084705101,
-0.0181625169,
0.0520191677,
0.0647740364,
-0.0568849258,
-0.0086426586,
0.0240836143,
-0.0007663925,
-0.0173365753,
0.0561183207,
-0.0121576414,
0.0326244086,
0.076550588,
-0.0080167353,
-0.0499454401,
-0.0109554715,
-0.0190239418,
-0.0599642843,
-0.0481801741,
0.0433787815,
0.0200695209,
0.0042104498,
-0.0120112998,
-0.0228383876,
0.0369709507,
-0.0055996929,
0.0037779948,
-0.0052918661,
0.0266594104,
-0.007454894,
-0.0308468137,
-0.003380131,
0.0498307049,
0.0111353742,
-0.0061618132,
0.044479344,
0.0033957779,
-0.0426498465,
0.0209921636,
-0.0474151634,
0.0569572523,
0.0143125821,
0.0418641493,
0.0438556671,
-0.012762323,
0.047262229,
0.0457281247,
-0.0536806695,
0.0552941971,
0.0387650318,
0.0010698927,
-0.043765936,
-0.0051672934,
-0.0329562351,
-0.0857322365,
-0.016785603,
0.0601879619,
-0.0357006229,
0.0456587747,
-0.0510447547,
-0.0005163098,
0.0301940572,
-0.036771059,
0.0465494171,
0.0114558833,
0.0350339897,
0.0355965681,
-0.0187378004,
0.04155441,
-0.0468514711,
-0.0469322912,
-0.0634168759,
-0.0393214077,
-0.0196981821,
-0.0029535596,
-0.0489706546,
0.0417042226,
-0.0472699068,
-0.0477834679,
-0.0235267188,
0.0372086018,
0.0293866768,
0.0180116817,
-0.0055277781,
-0.0298614837,
-0.0169103965,
-0.016403297,
-0.0144062676,
0.017255595,
-0.0016637921,
-0.0077905585,
-0.0181839745,
-0.0677541569,
0.0237703212,
0.0500105657,
0.0069167032,
-0.010220658,
-0.0061404249,
0.0680604875,
0.0369815417,
-0.0200242624,
-0.0502879433,
-0.0546252467,
-0.0043209926,
-0.0718261898,
-0.0399348065,
-0.0681466535,
0.0214020275,
0.0299978945,
0.0173060279,
-0.0487975888,
0.0168846268,
-0.0026391149,
-0.038513843,
0.0410585552,
-0.0467033051,
0.0633719787,
-0.0062038847,
-0.0012160529,
0.0220174491,
0.1111546904,
0.0566240512,
0.0143757463,
0.0341287069,
-0.0212038159,
-0.027496811,
0.0698685199,
0.0009643877,
0.0040014554,
-0.0524296276,
0.0046159849,
0.0056617861,
0.0275136847,
0.013552486,
0.0974951237,
-0.0056007886,
0.017892357,
0.0471039191,
0.0280025564,
0.0113029992,
0.0056977291,
0.0831415579,
0.0107135605,
0.0027076243,
-0.0120981354,
-0.015500783,
-0.0231200866,
-0.0313992426,
0.0039411518,
0.0323445983,
0.0374524109,
-0.0133128045,
-0.0183130428,
-0.0430890173,
-0.0222584996,
-0.0103706392,
0.0386474878,
0.0523046553,
-0.0186222512,
-0.0258957874,
0.0625377223,
0.0243459865,
-0.0248905923,
0.025042899,
-0.0542773493,
0.0172953419,
0.0697194934,
0.0598855428,
0.0098326541,
-0.0370199122,
0.0276775286,
0.0145404842,
0.0236399714,
0.009339544,
-0.0475185476,
0.0067022308,
-0.0603399985,
-0.0134211555,
0.0135580534,
0.0060143848,
0.0269528385,
0.0365356132,
-0.0186118595,
0.0462894514,
-0.0271208938,
-0.0236263983,
0.0280255824,
-0.0454814322,
0.0179782882,
0.0129297664,
-0.0067141466,
0.0643600449,
0.0140846539,
-0.0198620427,
0.0046015419,
0.0239292216,
-0.0426692888,
-0.0077796816,
0.0232466161,
-0.0078812204,
-0.0194815286,
0.0388818681,
0.0279894099,
0.0213369839,
0.0031884043,
-0.0203296728,
-0.0587885901,
-0.0149914995,
-0.0655650496,
0.0602411814,
-0.0474019162,
0.0413281955,
0.0010158325,
0.0022711435,
-0.0352820903,
0.0669583827,
-0.0146190133,
0.023812525,
0.0527226217,
0.0192969013,
0.0315242,
-0.0246038456,
-0.0044743875,
0.0147896092,
0.0120931733,
0.001380751,
0.038747292,
-0.0078838887,
-0.0364387706,
-0.0368317664,
-0.05861203,
0.0452564247,
-0.0206600558,
0.0353641771,
0.0267785564,
0.0376009569,
0.007582102,
0.0400384404,
-0.0374604799,
0.010582516,
0.0647527874,
0.029269103,
0.0088877659,
0.0139140775,
-0.0904277787,
-0.0144444592,
-0.0094487257,
0.0164111368,
0.0346303508,
-0.0000465311,
-0.019343771,
-0.0706803724,
0.0206452906,
-0.0325254537,
0.0185600407,
0.0013399501,
-0.0069664372,
-0.0364296362,
-0.0264268015,
0.0346638113,
0.0003631068,
0.0083288234,
0.0246814843,
0.0270228963,
-0.0266313832,
-0.0239394773,
-0.0129954014,
-0.0272559915,
-0.0040630875,
-0.0592318736,
-0.0614111535,
0.0193570759,
0.0698854923,
-0.0032835125,
-0.0297095664,
-0.0569593571,
0.004273565,
-0.0345637277,
-0.0374016985,
-0.0129893981,
0.0008054691,
0.012124286,
0.0555201247,
-0.0222449824,
-0.0513020456,
0.0294489637,
-0.0713127106,
0.0089787384,
-0.0270463061,
-0.0160592142,
-0.054414954,
0.0506110936,
0.0261097159,
0.0533202477,
-0.0075137028,
-0.0211126022,
-0.0275493097,
0.0162561275,
0.0011624051,
-0.0307202656,
0.0648641437,
-0.0648804531,
0.0455398336,
-0.0139721604,
-0.0352534689,
-0.0503743105,
-0.0533823147,
-0.0349267535,
0.0300038978,
0.0234689377,
-0.0160686001,
-0.0115827974,
0.0425407998,
-0.0152343391,
-0.0083178263,
0.0151706384,
0.0084405812,
-0.0183486454,
0.063835606,
0.0711054504,
-0.0084563242,
0.0367901959,
-0.0287417546,
0.0318670571,
0.057644397,
0.0302835815,
0.0395603292,
-0.0135106612,
-0.0226925481,
0.0616081953,
-0.0477343835,
-0.0130460905,
0.0323756523,
0.0430776328,
-0.0291764885,
0.0093050646,
0.1558548659,
0.0297162831,
0.015123006,
0.0232942943,
0.0163535737,
0.051381629,
0.0105201481,
-0.0024948872,
-0.0686091632,
-0.0189654455,
0.0234410465,
0.0250979494,
-0.0108396523,
-0.0346797518,
-0.0238382109,
-0.0990312696,
0.0287081711,
0.0102239745,
0.0047745137,
-0.0186610911,
-0.0194619335,
-0.0039103776,
-0.0088725472,
-0.0048480639,
0.0215256289,
-0.0154876355,
-0.0039813593,
0.0347969718,
-0.0238927566,
-0.0470511056,
-0.0234300755,
-0.024450954,
0.0541748218,
0.0356195047,
0.0132993748,
0.0219760817,
0.0080130519,
-0.0187638905,
-0.0359238349,
-0.0200101156,
-0.0427598618,
-0.0339561924,
0.006152825,
-0.0189649835,
-0.0014024301,
0.0449833237,
-0.0270550139,
0.0102595501,
0.009334865,
0.0817017853,
-0.0305405762,
0.010897235,
-0.0195371881,
-0.0172982905,
-0.0099521754,
0.0919738039,
0.0150959184,
-0.0231603701,
-0.0161110125,
-0.0022592968,
-0.0228827577,
-0.0248842184,
-0.0137223033,
-0.0044679563,
-0.0178651102,
-0.0085935583,
-0.0525899827,
0.0019193355,
0.0128358407,
0.0180783458,
0.0041708001,
0.0409300327,
0.0010545627,
-0.0192197822,
-0.0340282172,
-0.0030355367,
-0.0725227594,
0.0222068559,
-0.0626490414,
-0.0242468324,
0.0687800795,
-0.0230935682,
-0.0138641801,
0.0446825214,
-0.1021126062,
-0.0895920247,
-0.0219803061,
0.0133804241,
0.0156877395,
0.0553552844,
0.0007200929,
-0.0295022558,
0.0230331514,
0.0163550824,
-0.0380680077,
0.0277525503,
-0.0058349599,
0.0252317376,
0.0027445259,
0.0643923804,
-0.0496539846,
0.0126685612,
-0.0113894176,
0.078559801,
-0.0186182447,
-0.0395039804,
0.028492773,
0.0515319966,
-0.0054814625,
-0.0743945464,
-0.0203773007,
0.0146662388,
-0.0009185995,
-0.0501143299,
-0.0357094742,
-0.0713876113,
0.0071216905,
0.0119810952,
-0.0025028377,
-0.0331560522,
-0.0151971467,
-0.0188560858,
0.05523872,
0.0162542257,
0.0262250789,
-0.044041317,
-0.0234339032,
0.0734396055,
-0.0200815834,
-0.0030329095,
0.025805423,
0.0042204126,
0.0127084926,
-0.039353855,
0.045251023,
0.0142071974,
0.0126191592,
-0.0540150218,
0.0121606579,
0.0050062025,
-0.0543268919,
-0.0080304882,
0.0499404892,
0.0785368457,
0.0023938047,
0.0747971311,
-0.0606937334,
-0.0147841247,
-0.0432027802,
0.055603452,
0.0292783771,
-0.0526511781,
0.0262800716,
0.0165781081,
-0.0392460003,
0.0159251727,
0.1028967202,
0.0486418717,
0.0290487241,
0.0000862938,
-0.0310109723,
-0.0430249944,
-0.0336586796,
0.0134130903,
-0.0186219942,
-0.0456963889,
0.036042735,
-0.0640623644,
-0.0792877078,
-0.0001342828,
-0.0056357696,
0.0058719409,
-0.0323421769,
0.0309948996,
0.0593941957,
0.0168819483,
0.0115236668,
-0.0756628588,
0.0213490166,
-0.0335588008,
-0.0211408325,
0.0197965987,
-6.539081852e-33,
-0.0205614008,
-0.0482613817,
0.0347745232,
-0.0354733989,
-0.0379771441,
0.0039800173,
-0.019120425,
0.0064001246,
0.0204849001,
-0.0258407667,
0.0203246027,
-0.0133531643,
0.0087792147,
0.0378146209,
-0.0213627722,
0.0208528582,
0.0519211814,
-0.0042895419,
-0.0023966162,
0.0349836946,
0.029656779,
0.0136232767,
-0.0045632175,
-0.0189046878,
-0.016203301,
-0.0224768165,
-0.0043312958,
0.027091587,
0.0015530158,
0.0516981073,
-0.0378365666,
0.0324077941,
0.0305548552,
-0.0252286922,
-0.0194955841,
-0.0033930524,
-0.0617959015,
0.0226381738,
0.0368843302,
0.0151919015,
-0.0094629899,
-0.0344839096,
0.0532790124,
-0.008122053,
-0.024413947,
0.0276546031,
-0.0152249346,
-0.0433342382,
-0.0386585221,
-0.014214851,
-0.0493046865,
0.0432296321,
-0.0081047574,
-0.0147344768,
0.0360854827,
0.0090900771,
-0.0075163152,
0.0202525221,
-0.00187883,
0.035154283,
0.03505335,
0.0514323823,
0.0582913943,
0.0595682785,
0.0214033872,
0.0129636629,
0.0425926894,
-0.0428565629,
-0.0158398896,
0.0204005558,
0.006035374,
0.0213443041,
0.0003444251,
0.0336157791,
-0.0149287404,
0.0016241998,
-0.1038060263,
-0.0022601529,
-0.0053866035,
0.0173642915,
0.0226768367,
-0.0132324882,
-0.0187146682,
-0.0302260127,
-0.062221963,
0.0174440034,
-0.0123794992,
-0.0139539763,
0.0293024462,
0.0050023301,
-0.0364806876,
-0.0421863683,
0.0593382418,
-0.0761198774,
-0.0693036318,
0.0273170229,
-0.0059900912,
-0.000234076,
-0.0238685403,
0.0561625063,
-0.045877669,
-0.0577167682,
-0.0086428784,
-0.0342574269,
-0.0181391519,
-0.0149585661,
-0.0170187168,
0.0305121522,
-0.0278987326,
0.0132083884,
-0.0311228633,
0.0160793364,
-0.047316011,
0.0027835369,
0.0275883675,
-0.0092752753,
0.017477043,
0.0485744998,
0.0311102401,
0.0013157008,
-0.0017566144,
-0.0190901551,
0.0035695112,
0.0373867005,
-0.0339543745,
0.0198701583,
-0.0333248489,
-0.0351840518,
0.0369259417,
-0.0213320758,
-0.0169197805,
-0.0053287018,
2.728e-7,
0.0359115079,
0.0239982679,
0.0165745057,
0.0214681979,
0.0431351997,
-0.0048488583,
-0.0086953286,
-0.0222984683,
-0.0237504877,
0.0068744509,
0.0316997804,
0.0259590372,
0.0579971746,
-0.0068822107,
-0.0705428571,
0.031383954,
-0.039034944,
0.0045311684,
-0.0548919477,
0.0024919079,
0.0040808888,
0.0825456753,
-0.0215160586,
-0.0196366981,
-0.0077199279,
-0.0151055651,
0.06920138,
-0.0260345452,
-0.028579494,
0.0498883389,
0.0367912836,
0.0181877706,
0.0082949167,
-0.029032724,
0.0175754242,
0.0287202485,
-0.0111154607,
0.0910944194,
0.0035786391,
0.0290511027,
0.0131138042,
-0.0459448621,
-0.0167222396,
-0.0435098708,
0.0792596936,
-0.0277888589,
-0.0411163457,
-0.030531371,
0.0169260763,
-0.009964685,
-0.0656577796,
-0.0096339695,
-0.0276638512,
0.0204415023,
0.023411274,
-0.0268668123,
0.0084301848,
-0.057715144,
0.0097090453,
-0.022179503,
-0.0745293647,
-0.0533091351,
-0.0237863977,
0.0026424485,
0.0052496605,
-0.0281156581,
-0.0146773877,
2.844789772e-34,
0.0327802934,
-0.0221625846,
-0.0020105205,
0.0533414148,
0.0346223116,
-0.0303868148,
-0.0505117811,
0.0023970986,
0.000027286,
-0.1181220189,
-0.0123050101
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03818v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03818v2 | Alpha-CLIP: A CLIP Model Focusing on Wherever You Want | 2023-12-06T18:59:30 | 2023-12-13T05:52:05 | Zeyi Sun, Ye Fang, Tong Wu, Pan Zhang, Yuhang Zang, Shu Kong, Yuanjun Xiong, Dahua Lin, Jiaqi Wang | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Contrastive Language-Image Pre-training (CLIP) plays an essential role in
extracting valuable content information from images across diverse tasks. It
aligns textual and visual modalities to comprehend the entire image, including
all the details, even those irrelevant to specific tasks. However, for a finer
understanding and controlled editing of images, it becomes crucial to focus on
specific regions of interest, which can be indicated as points, masks, or boxes
by humans or perception models. To fulfill the requirements, we introduce
Alpha-CLIP, an enhanced version of CLIP with an auxiliary alpha channel to
suggest attentive regions and fine-tuned with constructed millions of RGBA
region-text pairs. Alpha-CLIP not only preserves the visual recognition ability
of CLIP but also enables precise control over the emphasis of image contents.
It demonstrates effectiveness in various tasks, including but not limited to
open-world recognition, multimodal large language models, and conditional 2D /
3D generation. It has a strong potential to serve as a versatile tool for
image-related tasks. | [
0.0168402102,
0.0655698776,
0.0332894288,
0.0541180521,
-0.0359292775,
-0.0003517218,
0.0065990905,
-0.0097731417,
-0.0552523285,
-0.0701447502,
-0.0523726866,
-0.0215609614,
-0.0037070657,
0.0752111971,
0.0038382253,
-0.1174380109,
-0.0292441752,
-0.053129822,
0.0075740376,
0.017362494,
0.026789777,
-0.0033249902,
0.0107920831,
0.0137861893,
0.0008874739,
-0.0094328262,
-0.0122919772,
0.022829596,
0.051053036,
-0.0364959762,
0.003549567,
0.0560362972,
0.0312545858,
-0.0246014111,
0.0000022632,
0.0059609036,
0.0231729802,
0.0141097428,
0.0122620454,
-0.0048123901,
0.0377124362,
-0.0199586302,
-0.0217554886,
-0.056638699,
-0.0353570804,
0.0122660194,
0.0811000317,
0.0544343814,
0.0643656775,
0.055519741,
-0.0407709256,
-0.0061699422,
-0.0206262469,
-0.0407130234,
0.0295567829,
-0.0295023993,
0.0348040164,
-0.0224920511,
0.0085369349,
0.0385672748,
-0.0335250273,
0.0286980439,
0.0329268351,
-0.0109718572,
0.0240720101,
0.0591536202,
-0.0210197289,
-0.0356944762,
-0.0184959359,
0.0690040588,
-0.0763875693,
-0.0025319997,
-0.030843161,
-0.019402951,
-0.008774397,
-0.0294258874,
-0.0267278608,
0.0372503661,
0.0175206363,
0.0607366152,
-0.0446840376,
0.0220956113,
-0.0036761232,
-0.0026283113,
-0.0318367891,
-0.0046898816,
0.0149221532,
0.0085555613,
-0.0036002495,
0.0282926727,
-0.0519671887,
-0.0674936697,
0.0457180999,
0.0090348935,
0.0459043421,
-0.0121435523,
-0.0628070906,
-0.0351350494,
0.0001097888,
-0.008033704,
0.0159679037,
0.0257538073,
-0.1033845916,
0.0875630081,
-0.0361311473,
0.0218775086,
0.0144926291,
0.053277377,
-0.0147768436,
-0.0169121996,
0.028530037,
0.0046304655,
-0.0507739186,
-0.025569167,
-0.0711341947,
-0.0475413091,
0.0013077925,
-0.0303365439,
-0.0406167172,
-0.0046079927,
0.0157132,
0.0222860798,
-0.0556786098,
-0.0386762917,
0.0243514851,
-0.0353765748,
-0.0112630157,
0.0340863243,
-0.014617607,
-0.0572274625,
-0.0093106376,
0.0321262665,
0.0400717296,
-0.0237503555,
0.0016071397,
0.0571767427,
-0.0401588045,
-0.0470464677,
-0.0185183287,
0.0211033877,
-0.0351703502,
-0.0295676421,
0.0309558008,
-0.0229708832,
-0.0000240581,
-0.0278608575,
0.0025969765,
-0.0358281992,
0.0228025336,
0.0030145047,
-0.0160542876,
0.0900146812,
-0.0142342187,
-0.0116487527,
0.0037402431,
0.030119177,
-0.0407488495,
0.0295807682,
0.0292482823,
0.0504815467,
0.0034778735,
0.0337675102,
0.0156867988,
0.0679029599,
0.0081785005,
0.0015165028,
-0.0486081764,
-0.0163194481,
0.0016183042,
-0.0284198783,
0.08454936,
0.0533471853,
-0.0507875383,
-0.0366588868,
0.0768506601,
0.0260497667,
-0.0377376229,
0.0305462256,
0.0364055634,
0.0479977131,
0.0115850484,
-0.0109211104,
-0.0323333219,
0.0497278348,
0.003321219,
0.0094600273,
0.0187662076,
0.0320411697,
-0.0401309058,
0.0018047459,
0.0028639953,
-0.0044115288,
0.0467457473,
0.0147923008,
0.081452094,
0.0307423864,
-0.0414002761,
0.0075690728,
0.0060184267,
-0.0204645097,
-0.0003830161,
-0.0470622145,
-0.0029177445,
-0.0030609455,
-0.0196990557,
-0.036119163,
0.0348772965,
0.0293353219,
0.0380212441,
0.0682566687,
-0.0312477872,
0.0359810404,
0.0523738675,
-0.0470598713,
-0.0550959706,
-0.0610613115,
-0.0091262423,
0.0262459107,
0.0391953401,
0.0327119231,
-0.0128089711,
0.0280960705,
0.0023703161,
0.0405447222,
0.0340535007,
-0.0144147137,
-0.0371124558,
0.0103175044,
0.003142088,
-0.0251287706,
-0.0385898463,
-0.0016033116,
0.0112871761,
-0.0540145338,
0.0199055746,
0.0186876357,
-0.0467908233,
-0.0330576301,
-0.0070892037,
-0.0745288357,
-0.0232379958,
0.025757432,
-0.0138682257,
-0.012498145,
-0.0017774701,
0.0014799275,
0.0486050695,
-0.0269715656,
-0.0046611135,
0.0353656076,
0.0009765408,
-0.0313782468,
0.038893152,
-0.0281567797,
-0.0180954579,
0.0324461721,
0.0138270538,
-0.0235225558,
-0.0099908076,
-0.0179322902,
-0.0309205111,
-0.0129136862,
-0.0142619619,
0.0017586563,
0.0384484529,
-0.0547902659,
-0.0160949118,
-0.0132765239,
-0.0296650194,
-0.0409992971,
-0.0233882777,
0.0174860489,
-0.0264362432,
-0.0175383203,
-0.0576827303,
-0.023133304,
-0.0073671034,
-0.0085268775,
-0.0009949021,
-0.0033593394,
0.0308630541,
0.0555088408,
-0.0558975302,
0.0084408121,
0.0721966401,
0.0447848327,
0.0400940962,
-0.0552425534,
-0.01464797,
0.0679643378,
0.0286882576,
0.0421231464,
-0.0227851961,
-0.0374101959,
-0.0027707019,
-0.0431780107,
0.0506220795,
0.0947138667,
0.0004525891,
0.011747756,
0.0266310629,
-0.0209458545,
0.0130924843,
0.0057654204,
-0.0110398419,
0.0035953668,
0.0007899294,
-0.0010233058,
-0.0124007436,
0.0312584229,
0.012762716,
0.0227684211,
-0.0588909388,
0.0059246998,
-0.0268767979,
-0.0430223793,
-0.0437595397,
0.0033962196,
-0.0237270407,
0.026053749,
-0.0796697736,
-0.0519936979,
0.0108352676,
-0.024212623,
-0.0288711358,
0.0195141882,
-0.014157448,
-0.0111127356,
0.0558765084,
0.0123283919,
0.0434725322,
-0.0298807565,
-0.0251087956,
-0.0483391434,
-0.0057042269,
-0.0094829248,
-0.0027753667,
0.0203146897,
-0.0304292254,
0.0091573186,
-0.0256839171,
-0.0473875999,
-0.01606193,
0.0053352769,
-0.0348431058,
-0.000770942,
0.0383368321,
-0.0160730183,
-0.0096281674,
0.0330764912,
0.021902455,
0.0662155449,
-0.0191445407,
-0.0017798009,
-0.0021024214,
0.0445030816,
0.0535892583,
0.0102155525,
-0.0388862155,
-0.0581762418,
-0.0198412705,
0.0510814674,
-0.0004295439,
-0.0132663818,
-0.0292517841,
0.047193516,
0.0358104222,
0.0242220238,
0.0243138969,
0.0161640458,
0.0725527033,
-0.0329936892,
-0.0401996747,
0.0328275524,
0.0087377429,
-0.0671501085,
-0.0510566607,
-0.0194275808,
0.036938116,
0.0217819624,
-0.0089204898,
-0.0936186761,
-0.0435393602,
-0.0074836039,
-0.0406382307,
0.0403663702,
0.0352590382,
-0.0454964116,
-0.0511542521,
0.0641260296,
0.0087704509,
-0.0588762425,
-0.0490695238,
0.0359571502,
0.0498758443,
-0.0180775058,
-0.0474354811,
0.0036876907,
-0.0088817589,
-0.0039724656,
0.0008489164,
0.0391305387,
-0.0254632812,
0.0165429953,
-0.0382073931,
-0.0339838862,
0.0326879583,
0.0166454539,
0.0198551826,
-0.0401567705,
-0.0073517994,
0.0136195971,
0.0026944722,
0.0041502262,
0.0759909973,
-0.0116013344,
-0.0217719376,
-0.0210895501,
0.0636435449,
0.0282841455,
-0.0671078563,
-0.0289002582,
-0.0043121609,
-0.0035595912,
-0.0106490469,
-0.0442837514,
0.0249088705,
0.0438212305,
0.0433170348,
0.0284133311,
-0.0489061885,
-0.0287880972,
-0.0175424907,
0.0254808031,
-0.0759899989,
-0.0275232214,
0.0086563956,
0.002876227,
-0.001097813,
-0.038315665,
-0.0032460471,
0.05929121,
0.0084507419,
-0.0187993702,
-0.036194481,
0.0014412266,
0.0149932867,
-0.0376089215,
0.0701532662,
-0.043698702,
-0.0072225826,
-0.0347457305,
-0.0334898941,
0.003326867,
-0.0737680346,
-0.0308633335,
0.0450512953,
-0.0743632838,
-0.024741888,
0.0187690482,
0.0847390667,
0.0124332588,
0.0569062568,
0.0188798346,
-0.0467659757,
0.0373641439,
-0.010290443,
0.003604841,
0.0229803231,
0.0384759754,
-0.033053387,
-0.026262125,
0.0152796917,
-0.0407493897,
0.0532521494,
0.0216297433,
-0.0017375615,
-0.0108248163,
-0.0497981273,
0.0116025824,
-0.0709900707,
0.0636945143,
-0.012786814,
0.035453558,
-0.0677468106,
0.0001511466,
0.0023165599,
0.0158515759,
-0.0845359862,
0.027834164,
-0.0213081781,
-0.0022245555,
-0.0108967526,
-0.0099479649,
0.004731535,
0.0149007142,
-0.0295936763,
0.0045608683,
0.02115128,
-0.0181973949,
0.0314444788,
0.0335130431,
0.0239362549,
0.0426053852,
-0.0324191935,
0.0220886245,
0.0112766456,
0.0744817927,
0.0249502789,
-0.0502949059,
0.0110619189,
0.0437750667,
-0.0139570031,
-0.0210581087,
-0.055005379,
-0.0058446969,
0.0607743822,
-0.0298019443,
0.0422459021,
-0.0211631265,
-0.0411904305,
0.0197173841,
0.047088813,
0.0138232755,
-0.0602803007,
0.0400752388,
-0.0047846232,
0.0137486048,
0.0163187515,
0.0317141339,
0.0152949085,
0.0093708858,
0.0190397166,
0.0060800426,
-0.0243770909,
-0.0025162771,
0.0198532287,
0.0058761011,
-0.0058335592,
0.0446171872,
0.0042602313,
-0.0346805006,
-0.0193259846,
0.030224951,
-0.0427127965,
0.0327195823,
0.0643862933,
0.0008238765,
-0.0233324468,
-0.0238965377,
-0.0093948292,
0.0046415976,
-0.0109216105,
0.0042834627,
0.0225876253,
-6.570286819e-33,
-0.0215993635,
-0.023694722,
0.0414626077,
0.006911186,
-0.0241391659,
0.0175381992,
-0.04998805,
0.0146206552,
-0.0082060844,
0.0214449521,
0.008628808,
-0.0305732507,
0.0277341455,
0.073505722,
-0.0439090915,
0.0395315439,
0.0400959142,
0.0069017899,
0.0217902418,
0.0150342872,
0.0075973333,
0.0209933221,
0.0612911731,
-0.0459424742,
-0.0420545526,
-0.0046653594,
-0.049142383,
-0.0149109662,
0.0168568045,
0.0437351316,
-0.0261368342,
-0.0288458113,
-0.0185896028,
-0.0287318975,
-0.0150413522,
0.0248748083,
-0.0616379604,
-0.0142336814,
-0.0330886729,
0.0144221578,
-0.100549154,
-0.0188790988,
0.0357769616,
-0.01692844,
0.0339668393,
-0.037270844,
0.0482571498,
-0.0251807515,
0.0134444069,
-0.0337312184,
-0.0655145496,
0.0354854353,
-0.0094553921,
-0.0461344123,
0.0679967627,
0.0330810174,
0.0328634977,
0.0038518843,
-0.0656596273,
0.0234943964,
0.0733161718,
0.0161326788,
0.044295162,
0.060660027,
0.0176684894,
0.0618276596,
-0.0310953166,
-0.0469488204,
0.0351994894,
-0.0325693302,
0.032015238,
0.0584629625,
0.0127132535,
0.0085434038,
0.036267709,
0.0474615358,
-0.0518131815,
0.0009888618,
-0.0755707845,
0.0353760831,
0.0222919732,
0.0335557535,
0.0399190895,
0.0212707017,
-0.0245100129,
-0.0329875648,
-0.0516004451,
-0.0130547453,
0.0485788286,
0.0434641615,
-0.0110428976,
0.037832696,
0.0731616989,
0.0120355906,
0.0169985108,
0.0121286372,
-0.0523911491,
0.0545331948,
-0.0180957355,
-0.0003701164,
-0.0624538586,
0.0005361646,
0.056970492,
-0.0094985301,
-0.0079330271,
0.0248757675,
0.032936804,
0.0230000746,
-0.0353330821,
-0.0067296266,
-0.0298183654,
0.0575960465,
0.0295018908,
0.0785335228,
0.0278483536,
0.0035808224,
-0.0508477688,
0.0532052889,
-0.0151926586,
0.0078243241,
-0.0309892856,
-0.0192661174,
0.0058789831,
0.0097365258,
-0.0359427705,
0.0180679094,
-0.0475510955,
0.0120807663,
0.0433821715,
-0.0647975057,
-0.027649818,
0.0309007615,
2.777e-7,
0.0204758737,
0.0103595899,
0.005364106,
0.0193311498,
-0.0006070084,
0.0162252225,
-0.027805021,
0.0063460181,
0.0084396033,
-0.0161030926,
0.0093194181,
0.0621205159,
0.0393942147,
0.0188974999,
-0.0361909755,
0.0215444732,
-0.0387673564,
-0.0352319032,
-0.0084808627,
-0.0221793465,
0.0586289503,
0.109977968,
-0.010292978,
-0.0111257574,
0.0490428992,
-0.0152864251,
0.0792488307,
-0.0373134576,
0.0398630239,
-0.0207503475,
-0.0068623475,
0.0336534679,
-0.0473812968,
-0.0077010873,
-0.0104828021,
-0.0160854459,
0.0581758507,
0.0766374096,
-0.0304978862,
0.0036204732,
-0.0043863207,
0.0645466372,
-0.0183473453,
-0.0632461905,
0.0570621639,
-0.0871383622,
-0.0186948106,
-0.0706179515,
-0.0424056314,
0.0028588865,
-0.0140432175,
-0.0473937877,
-0.0106057553,
0.0222377088,
0.0226652026,
0.0141347703,
-0.0515188724,
-0.086742036,
-0.0548963696,
-0.0183021538,
-0.0034872696,
0.0250727721,
-0.085751079,
0.0035450312,
-0.000317162,
-0.0374521092,
0.0028585973,
2.257882432e-34,
-0.0116155623,
0.0100858482,
-0.0279377457,
0.006951822,
0.028002942,
0.0365073308,
0.0035487234,
-0.0028224571,
-0.0185396653,
-0.0433336385,
-0.0285616331
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03700v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03700v1 | OneLLM: One Framework to Align All Modalities with Language | 2023-12-06T18:59:19 | 2023-12-06T18:59:19 | Jiaming Han, Kaixiong Gong, Yiyuan Zhang, Jiaqi Wang, Kaipeng Zhang, Dahua Lin, Yu Qiao, Peng Gao, Xiangyu Yue | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.MM | Multimodal large language models (MLLMs) have gained significant attention
due to their strong multimodal understanding capability. However, existing
works rely heavily on modality-specific encoders, which usually differ in
architecture and are limited to common modalities. In this paper, we present
OneLLM, an MLLM that aligns eight modalities to language using a unified
framework. We achieve this through a unified multimodal encoder and a
progressive multimodal alignment pipeline. In detail, we first train an image
projection module to connect a vision encoder with LLM. Then, we build a
universal projection module (UPM) by mixing multiple image projection modules
and dynamic routing. Finally, we progressively align more modalities to LLM
with the UPM. To fully leverage the potential of OneLLM in following
instructions, we also curated a comprehensive multimodal instruction dataset,
including 2M items from image, audio, video, point cloud, depth/normal map, IMU
and fMRI brain activity. OneLLM is evaluated on 25 diverse benchmarks,
encompassing tasks such as multimodal captioning, question answering and
reasoning, where it delivers excellent performance. Code, data, model and
online demo are available at https://github.com/csuhan/OneLLM | [
0.0095906164,
0.0866431966,
-0.0033992454,
0.0518283807,
-0.0237814151,
-0.0015331117,
0.0222410131,
-0.0405160673,
-0.0460729636,
-0.0425404459,
-0.0442795567,
-0.0120286634,
0.0365674086,
0.0607113987,
0.0526492372,
-0.0610117503,
0.0378548801,
-0.0477104485,
-0.05656185,
0.000314272,
0.0304625072,
0.0269175936,
-0.0452435426,
0.0479735285,
-0.0167346802,
-0.0291867647,
-0.0442827567,
0.0149575677,
0.0144350454,
-0.0341737568,
-0.0218721759,
0.0338703915,
0.081970267,
-0.0250630062,
0.0000019077,
-0.0194394402,
0.0290504657,
-0.0174096823,
0.0196713787,
-0.0344394706,
0.0060849581,
-0.0474202484,
0.0313525274,
-0.0068197036,
-0.0211941674,
-0.0152709223,
0.075033918,
0.0281875953,
0.0627227947,
0.0440421626,
-0.0149633717,
-0.0385482088,
0.0187397599,
-0.0266895201,
0.0004646236,
-0.0191022754,
0.006919452,
0.0253806785,
-0.0158360153,
0.0013053471,
-0.0782290623,
0.0447128266,
0.0218110327,
0.0066969628,
-0.0025038347,
0.0333517157,
0.0331227668,
-0.0618163981,
-0.0323415473,
0.107255958,
-0.0068854294,
-0.0035790098,
-0.0222553648,
0.0263313465,
-0.0136217261,
-0.0200681072,
-0.051667247,
0.0418048128,
0.0023631076,
0.0323139355,
-0.0263300054,
-0.0255659409,
0.0320473462,
0.0018554053,
0.027769478,
0.0160542522,
0.0364270695,
0.0199923813,
-0.0257257689,
-0.0062312731,
-0.0302991793,
-0.0444130823,
-0.014559336,
0.0465094112,
-0.0344994888,
0.0128821414,
-0.0639996678,
-0.0084985979,
0.0021077394,
-0.0206281673,
0.0332184434,
0.0272727683,
-0.0466300994,
0.060990911,
-0.0100170877,
0.0505659468,
-0.0483004451,
0.0607263893,
-0.028660439,
-0.0342104062,
-0.0232725292,
-0.0078478241,
-0.0100312792,
-0.0070607737,
-0.052060999,
-0.0549156666,
-0.026338188,
0.0521678552,
-0.0005936088,
0.0115439789,
-0.0082390103,
0.0177112464,
-0.0094225025,
-0.0188382231,
-0.0032562695,
0.071126014,
-0.014837482,
0.0368058607,
-0.0266346037,
-0.0545831025,
-0.0106710698,
0.0683204904,
-0.0031651098,
-0.0270065013,
-0.0090665547,
0.0980909541,
-0.0444150344,
-0.0275484752,
-0.0141254757,
-0.0343738124,
-0.0221256316,
-0.0470701084,
0.0318488032,
-0.0469952673,
0.0471659787,
-0.0046950257,
-0.0107553834,
-0.0253916737,
0.0029709321,
-0.0031082504,
-0.0009281119,
0.0818242207,
-0.0179137867,
0.0245985743,
0.0427273884,
0.0173364226,
0.0059667304,
0.0514930114,
0.0347589925,
0.0042908671,
0.0046645533,
-0.0129937371,
-0.0110420976,
0.058742132,
-0.006211583,
-0.0110672945,
-0.0431563593,
0.0085404254,
0.0322259665,
0.055551216,
0.0612310246,
0.0306332316,
-0.014456464,
-0.0230606217,
0.0774366111,
-0.0020794014,
0.003289782,
-0.0214420948,
0.0031492533,
-0.0042099408,
-0.0153701017,
-0.0441334583,
-0.0788984373,
0.0815249756,
0.0042703608,
0.0045366189,
0.0478796624,
0.0373287536,
-0.0331570022,
-0.0072746533,
-0.0170283392,
-0.0154620418,
-0.0103343381,
0.027224455,
0.0389689058,
-0.0123775778,
-0.0439334959,
0.0553126894,
0.0034825935,
-0.0108542563,
0.0211019088,
-0.0073287296,
0.0076331599,
0.032867182,
0.0334092714,
0.006026872,
-0.0563723184,
-0.0052741244,
0.0260722619,
0.0796809942,
-0.0106711844,
-0.0172844939,
0.0624307618,
-0.0700545609,
-0.0477819778,
-0.0213237628,
-0.0175638646,
-0.0108748181,
0.0037319765,
-0.0141761452,
-0.0031516266,
-0.0400946997,
0.044423826,
0.0523991324,
0.0119755715,
0.0189774744,
-0.0589198954,
0.0039616073,
0.0205785204,
-0.0231796019,
-0.0105446912,
-0.0150554385,
0.0078560971,
-0.0418174714,
0.0209746398,
0.034890987,
-0.0464173108,
-0.0429106578,
0.0479933061,
-0.048758164,
-0.0300361458,
0.0322792754,
-0.0503045432,
-0.0250016823,
0.0090251053,
-0.0211667754,
-0.0145012196,
-0.0492049232,
-0.0151641965,
0.0173855834,
0.0308063384,
-0.0232072994,
0.0267578457,
-0.0254864767,
-0.0037139831,
0.0320641622,
-0.0047798087,
0.0161904767,
0.0078062722,
-0.0422208011,
0.017067695,
-0.0230611507,
0.0237501226,
-0.0151085574,
0.0011276306,
-0.0405037366,
-0.0101655871,
-0.1024737954,
-0.0248875953,
-0.0052349148,
-0.0102240425,
0.0264376607,
0.0004145965,
0.0064374045,
-0.0503953025,
-0.0304541457,
0.0346967094,
0.0297141057,
0.0123815797,
0.0191387255,
-0.0058424105,
-0.0183440372,
-0.0232275184,
0.0095320782,
0.0041451417,
0.0592473894,
-0.0377273969,
0.0157892499,
-0.042137295,
-0.0331240706,
-0.047624737,
0.0191358924,
-0.0283934493,
-0.0203674808,
0.0295432284,
-0.0120921107,
0.0524827503,
0.0368336253,
0.0150884818,
0.0050933072,
0.0531035438,
-0.0381571986,
-0.0313417166,
-0.0018337546,
0.0189396776,
-0.0190184303,
-0.0517050512,
-0.0112840366,
-0.0330698527,
0.0642148703,
0.016147472,
0.0259460118,
-0.0359031744,
-0.0042888783,
0.0160055254,
-0.0450775698,
-0.0460456647,
0.0186550543,
-0.0103039574,
0.0150646362,
-0.0483170897,
-0.0576619022,
0.0323080271,
-0.0576415733,
-0.0301768072,
0.0183939058,
-0.0025511715,
-0.0076534683,
0.0779156312,
0.0251492299,
0.0417105593,
-0.0492775775,
-0.0198908057,
-0.0434866771,
0.0019090809,
0.0035645636,
-0.0084153544,
0.0815671459,
-0.0668975487,
0.0073118028,
-0.0315149724,
-0.0266198851,
-0.029659491,
-0.0185792781,
-0.0340272933,
-0.0075979349,
-0.0636831969,
0.015539635,
-0.0524556004,
0.0142033752,
0.0354385935,
0.0218027271,
-0.0097425729,
-0.0019149511,
-0.0316952281,
0.0236760732,
0.0763897821,
0.0738396049,
-0.0550527312,
-0.0627534762,
-0.0087283431,
0.0449134558,
-0.0080184387,
0.004205063,
-0.0771918222,
0.0368554518,
0.0182842128,
0.0297294576,
0.0049955063,
0.0389812775,
0.0627263263,
-0.03958489,
0.0097346148,
0.0855513811,
-0.0096565578,
-0.0466498137,
-0.0128498413,
-0.0051987814,
0.0534582771,
0.0312241279,
-0.0051227966,
-0.0628614426,
-0.0838501975,
-0.0060421657,
-0.016648028,
0.0570211038,
0.0182164889,
-0.012767354,
-0.042945914,
0.0155761028,
0.0031397103,
-0.0450393707,
-0.0493700616,
-0.0039390274,
0.0111270742,
0.0071340618,
0.0217735525,
0.009087068,
0.0047939545,
-0.0032259519,
-0.0004633259,
0.0262379348,
-0.0377000719,
0.0141268941,
-0.0401718654,
0.0574447736,
0.0470448099,
-0.0113683529,
0.0116654513,
-0.036345996,
0.0196134467,
0.0527200662,
0.0023624301,
-0.0003442233,
0.0406278931,
-0.0287580676,
-0.0259361304,
-0.0057960916,
0.0269375667,
-0.0540813878,
-0.0270963181,
-0.0179072246,
0.0682392269,
-0.0433117598,
0.0206416007,
-0.0375765823,
0.0254080705,
-0.0164034646,
0.0535259061,
0.0013413659,
-0.0407989919,
-0.0045938892,
0.0088419616,
-0.0117724286,
-0.0052238093,
-0.0063863946,
0.0027435073,
0.007346686,
0.03484492,
-0.0263989102,
0.002712613,
0.0271421913,
0.0320934802,
0.0121186376,
-0.0248236358,
-0.0008203243,
-0.0017972455,
-0.0696381852,
0.0729000643,
-0.030267233,
0.0192631315,
-0.0398768373,
0.017671749,
0.048916474,
-0.0316457152,
-0.0070330342,
0.0627649948,
-0.1017702967,
-0.0490349159,
-0.0329300202,
0.0411363579,
0.0134154744,
0.051699888,
0.0248101857,
-0.0235961825,
0.0039359271,
0.0069815423,
0.0220176894,
0.0398049653,
-0.0144644771,
-0.0018991973,
-0.0046478757,
0.0270983428,
-0.0617027171,
-0.0053369352,
-0.002383729,
0.036625918,
0.0014377144,
-0.0481268764,
0.0019367937,
-0.0094548007,
0.0432349369,
-0.0297230631,
0.020964073,
-0.0415720902,
-0.001129734,
0.0182085466,
0.0052106474,
-0.0408447832,
0.0072253314,
0.0350992307,
0.0217718519,
0.0196707677,
0.0051098871,
0.0298512951,
0.0125392657,
-0.010441374,
0.006947394,
0.0049677901,
-0.05173086,
-0.0059015681,
0.0343350023,
-0.0133738657,
0.0461553372,
-0.0329370275,
0.0168063492,
-0.0243768338,
0.0850698203,
0.0314282849,
-0.0021971101,
-0.0235622488,
0.038262777,
0.0091781057,
-0.0235318374,
-0.020351531,
0.0487155318,
0.0569300912,
0.0460192338,
0.0382437557,
0.0111624608,
0.001791082,
-0.0072769234,
0.0744770467,
-0.0324941389,
-0.046281781,
0.0978072733,
0.0184102878,
0.0042031542,
-0.013727949,
0.0495502166,
-0.025408132,
0.0215770248,
-0.0135202231,
0.0328427143,
-0.0466638654,
-0.0243746769,
0.0355441049,
0.0179120544,
-0.038415391,
0.020959653,
0.0216833055,
-0.0537698939,
-0.0114624975,
0.0329506062,
-0.0243269298,
0.0009411108,
0.0434668995,
0.0427631736,
0.00366561,
-0.0521046892,
-0.0050798925,
-0.0029666808,
0.0102716768,
-0.0085858582,
-0.0036652079,
-5.958228951e-33,
-0.040907044,
-0.0090820184,
0.0567710772,
-0.0279509462,
-0.0407027304,
-0.0030790684,
-0.0330484733,
0.0373163596,
-0.039589189,
-0.0145777175,
0.0629309267,
-0.0195437688,
-0.0088875657,
0.0666085258,
0.0203795508,
-0.0132676288,
0.0013782572,
-0.0198347755,
-0.0157121681,
-0.013893351,
0.0197972488,
0.0037952173,
0.0680760071,
-0.0193429813,
-0.0010674682,
0.0237344801,
-0.0423368067,
0.0589502975,
-0.0166467261,
0.0524257906,
-0.0441217981,
0.0304313581,
0.0338995568,
-0.0027806289,
-0.0283275917,
0.0225002524,
-0.0544048883,
0.0172371864,
0.0451339893,
0.0501103438,
-0.0931417346,
-0.0237879176,
0.0670819506,
-0.0316934362,
0.0098493649,
-0.0268442482,
0.0414577611,
-0.0029283187,
0.0066479743,
0.0440573692,
-0.0446307212,
-0.0089138169,
-0.0098709147,
-0.0397689417,
0.0091956574,
0.0467814393,
0.0166410673,
0.0330429785,
-0.0528616495,
0.0163305402,
-0.0447003655,
0.0346325301,
0.1125679612,
0.0470899157,
0.0069935061,
0.0678461865,
0.0223140102,
-0.0730317608,
-0.0391057655,
0.0263716336,
0.0490582138,
0.067022033,
0.0039241938,
0.0617783293,
0.0027312431,
0.0416979901,
-0.0171388593,
0.0031777625,
-0.0420719348,
0.0419104919,
0.0315335467,
0.0291091017,
0.030697057,
0.00410676,
-0.0486231074,
0.0136026498,
-0.0406570248,
-0.0141485548,
0.0568028949,
0.0178595353,
0.0082404055,
0.0056889406,
0.0978062823,
-0.0292311292,
0.007599791,
0.0142121809,
-0.0180638283,
0.0557263717,
0.0033262966,
0.0478513241,
-0.0291380044,
-0.0212772153,
0.0652459115,
-0.0553246178,
0.0247505531,
0.0188523941,
-0.0115956105,
0.037765488,
-0.029471308,
-0.0154070016,
-0.0409240648,
-0.0174411125,
-0.0195585229,
0.0429917797,
0.0366977043,
0.0036286504,
-0.0590338744,
0.0012712642,
-0.0364921317,
-0.0054008053,
-0.042733971,
-0.0354276188,
-0.0119809872,
0.0317610912,
-0.0174576845,
0.0242758431,
-0.0606880113,
-0.0886327103,
0.0119678117,
-0.0671413168,
-0.0070088101,
0.0652245432,
2.6e-7,
0.0402156748,
0.0180915818,
0.0088629043,
0.0206139795,
0.0311104152,
0.0457312986,
-0.0260474682,
0.0545250736,
-0.0186127704,
-0.0706726387,
-0.005223175,
0.0558671691,
0.033454217,
0.0033611895,
-0.0229302663,
0.0040435297,
-0.0163831841,
0.0085943658,
-0.0389152579,
0.01722477,
0.0356273651,
0.0763690993,
-0.0283118002,
-0.0190521218,
0.0306004845,
-0.0327520818,
0.0742143318,
-0.0167141333,
-0.0278905276,
-0.0023757804,
-0.002758397,
0.0113886436,
-0.0139336176,
0.0192729346,
0.0150176855,
-0.0266244542,
0.0253010783,
0.0678773075,
-0.0403298289,
-0.0674002171,
-0.0287469737,
0.0239284299,
-0.0481358394,
-0.0540104099,
0.0465724543,
-0.0436963961,
-0.0452876613,
-0.0526368655,
-0.0144588118,
-0.0010443318,
0.0170197822,
-0.012916429,
-0.0359424166,
0.0039440021,
0.0561134182,
-0.0285184532,
-0.0452448502,
-0.0599744767,
-0.0413490832,
0.0080589261,
-0.0871014819,
-0.0019036648,
-0.057501141,
-0.0351277962,
0.0464838259,
-0.0388133824,
-0.0649607256,
1.78999114e-34,
0.0015897446,
-0.0317357592,
0.0130282938,
0.0122112827,
0.0118707446,
-0.033222191,
-0.0358975083,
-0.0072058635,
-0.0338794217,
-0.0890750736,
-0.0228869971
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03699v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03699v3 | PROMISE: A Framework for Developing Complex Conversational Interactions (Technical Report) | 2023-12-06T18:59:11 | 2024-04-08T13:32:31 | Wenyuan Wu, Jasmin Heierli, Max Meisterhans, Adrian Moser, Andri Färber, Mateusz Dolata, Elena Gavagnin, Alexandre de Spindler, Gerhard Schwabe | cs.CL | cs.CL | The advent of increasingly powerful language models has raised expectations
for language-based interactions. However, controlling these models is a
challenge, emphasizing the need to be able to investigate the feasibility and
value of their application. We present PROMISE, a framework that facilitates
the development of complex language-based interactions with information
systems. Its use of state machine modeling concepts enables model-driven,
dynamic prompt orchestration across hierarchically nested states and
transitions. This improves the control of the behavior of language models and
thus enables their effective and efficient use. In this technical report we
show the benefits of PROMISE in the context of application scenarios within
health information systems and demonstrate its ability to handle complex
interactions. We also include code examples and present default user interfaces
available as part of PROMISE. | [
0.0461743735,
0.0551485345,
-0.0327286087,
-0.0086585209,
-0.0362831429,
-0.0180796925,
0.0099194879,
-0.0036717646,
0.0616746023,
-0.0090836342,
-0.0058893817,
-0.0455124862,
0.0394397266,
0.1046698466,
-0.020727776,
-0.1003325358,
0.0419523865,
-0.0073531172,
0.0182339195,
0.0223461632,
0.0273095034,
-0.004304905,
-0.038103193,
0.0778491721,
0.0078242766,
-0.0310558975,
-0.0505485125,
0.0232794881,
-0.0079980055,
-0.0708865151,
-0.0115300007,
0.0528029017,
-0.0045343428,
0.0005675511,
0.0000020936,
-0.0628942177,
0.0217084642,
0.0246661119,
-0.0480505526,
-0.0515245311,
0.0355331078,
-0.0028294311,
-0.0380438268,
0.0158277266,
-0.0159188136,
-0.0057330998,
0.0667568669,
-0.0098585272,
0.0371131785,
0.0085096397,
-0.0325856507,
0.0613749847,
-0.0113987522,
-0.0079965489,
-0.0292231645,
-0.05207837,
0.0412193537,
-0.0311574824,
0.1027447507,
-0.0194583964,
0.0191963315,
0.0303780455,
-0.0160818417,
-0.0277682841,
-0.0179506093,
0.010292395,
0.0554558076,
-0.0478349887,
-0.0562540516,
0.0490818769,
0.0213945787,
0.0278792232,
0.02702724,
-0.011917633,
0.0115374783,
0.0357726552,
-0.0545198731,
-0.0287726223,
-0.0155925453,
-0.0117353071,
-0.0354273617,
0.0059633367,
0.0209301356,
0.0203676261,
-0.0027084621,
0.0822556168,
0.0289951712,
-0.0147303632,
-0.0265711695,
-0.0161144007,
0.0774361268,
-0.0660404116,
0.0388666429,
0.0681195483,
-0.0951596126,
0.0322605558,
-0.0144904321,
-0.0145072704,
0.0720561296,
-0.0275857691,
-0.02088576,
0.0290493648,
-0.0144529473,
0.0395263545,
0.0991334245,
0.0054490957,
0.0092676105,
-0.064859286,
0.0070226691,
0.026516458,
-0.0309972614,
-0.0165113006,
-0.0370556526,
-0.001139988,
-0.0536473468,
-0.0168305989,
-0.0324056223,
0.0705529824,
0.0150149474,
0.0593065321,
-0.0186366364,
-0.0050895335,
-0.0472576246,
0.0049359063,
-0.0525975004,
0.0274378527,
0.0074495971,
-0.0104773249,
0.0133540686,
-0.0675804839,
0.0111455573,
-0.0254105534,
0.0114113092,
0.0311489515,
-0.0449233614,
0.0480561741,
-0.0044091539,
0.0133551126,
0.011018388,
-0.0633740649,
-0.0077910754,
-0.0252620503,
-0.0235997587,
-0.0489393026,
0.0391071737,
0.0272561554,
-0.0032411413,
-0.0588549227,
0.0177510474,
0.0531628802,
-0.0185298678,
0.0466288328,
-0.053248629,
0.0083808126,
0.0152455363,
0.0376790501,
0.0241853911,
0.0136222802,
0.0260275304,
0.0078762779,
0.0260955188,
-0.0094496235,
0.0428746603,
0.0567334779,
-0.040053416,
-0.0035515807,
0.021991374,
0.0077145766,
0.0327231549,
0.0086326338,
-0.0685739294,
0.0435406938,
0.0092551932,
0.0349473581,
0.0485766567,
0.0768567845,
-0.0312134922,
-0.0152459675,
0.0180029459,
0.0303642172,
-0.0146105746,
-0.0116825467,
-0.0060382397,
0.0074069514,
-0.0031466465,
-0.0074096359,
-0.0132140722,
0.02128575,
-0.0197046846,
-0.0434285589,
0.0026922983,
-0.0221928954,
-0.0010980761,
0.0055357004,
0.0265241992,
0.0099664982,
-0.0279631913,
0.0122985551,
0.0265764538,
-0.0211864244,
-0.0040497081,
-0.0700976998,
0.0005009114,
0.1479678005,
0.0670777112,
-0.0313994251,
-0.0139202932,
-0.0185296517,
-0.0088068312,
0.050020691,
0.0291578118,
-0.0225764513,
0.0118559152,
-0.001067601,
-0.011030809,
0.0550867915,
0.0199285299,
0.0120746065,
-0.0463916287,
0.0068323943,
-0.0286233425,
0.0159455985,
0.000261803,
0.0013441463,
-0.0272194836,
-0.0013561812,
-0.0015455844,
0.0212155133,
0.0335721411,
0.0203069374,
0.0391792282,
0.0159325376,
0.0238578841,
0.0321630426,
0.0067129964,
0.0083074309,
-0.0310399868,
0.0199750792,
0.0014607046,
0.0562344044,
0.0288885087,
-0.0495077074,
-0.004636012,
-0.0456208922,
0.0175134167,
-0.021385856,
0.0417308919,
-0.0132201286,
0.0302334707,
0.0307794437,
0.0166596603,
-0.0258652512,
-0.0178536996,
-0.0207363572,
-0.0152704464,
0.0135911964,
0.0185692646,
-0.0307581946,
-0.020934552,
0.0126982359,
0.036269635,
-0.0263301451,
0.0322624221,
-0.0039565605,
0.0131534962,
-0.0071797427,
-0.0205283873,
-0.0945856497,
-0.0218118783,
-0.0099759055,
-0.0105732204,
-0.0037901979,
0.0859431922,
-0.0246505532,
-0.0347176827,
0.0096296873,
0.0087961927,
0.0709326193,
-0.0174558815,
0.0038791874,
0.0397488438,
-0.0649597645,
-0.0260279905,
0.0031069966,
-0.0130341165,
0.0268978998,
-0.0169495177,
-0.0710622445,
-0.0634919554,
-0.0330911204,
-0.004572392,
0.0190112237,
-0.0141670946,
0.0097520817,
0.0181417223,
-0.0075302827,
0.071350351,
-0.0273471102,
-0.0225019287,
0.0628619939,
0.029964678,
-0.0493841991,
-0.0323609114,
0.0189235248,
-0.0095025096,
0.0140858395,
-0.0241960138,
-0.0317136981,
0.0683002323,
0.0738408864,
0.0238062888,
0.0290506557,
-0.0064902403,
-0.0107473638,
-0.009453252,
0.0200046841,
0.0052777766,
-0.0345598944,
-0.0580733344,
0.0763802677,
0.0017760877,
-0.041166164,
0.06017261,
-0.0573866442,
-0.017825596,
-0.0279884078,
-0.0511248335,
-0.0046348674,
0.0480797105,
-0.0383536182,
-0.0049212635,
0.0666410252,
-0.0597012602,
0.0435098,
-0.0302594248,
-0.0291902758,
-0.046186626,
-0.0010744126,
-0.0546826534,
0.004633408,
0.0221218988,
-0.033015307,
-0.0211452991,
0.0281202849,
-0.0603770614,
-0.0127273137,
0.0121404976,
-0.0163807329,
-0.0257320181,
0.0234150738,
-0.0104758078,
0.0872285441,
0.0195794329,
-0.019117564,
-0.0268587079,
-0.0199191887,
0.0076205279,
0.0062453258,
-0.0298212841,
0.0041032862,
0.0729375184,
0.0298757702,
0.019057557,
-0.0076466347,
0.0176758803,
-0.0266859625,
0.0552598163,
-0.0299830157,
-0.0329825357,
0.0690430403,
0.0034993896,
-0.0634139776,
-0.0253766421,
0.0959645435,
0.0432033762,
-0.0825936124,
0.0350571424,
-0.0769692808,
0.0099603347,
0.0011266994,
0.0423288494,
-0.0920584947,
0.0101482151,
0.0062159323,
0.0196373463,
0.0016262477,
-0.009948195,
-0.017192319,
-0.0075736791,
0.0430596098,
0.0012417225,
-0.03006934,
-0.0299419872,
-0.0167799369,
0.0554880761,
0.067553252,
0.0254267789,
0.0126128318,
-0.0154609159,
-0.0437604673,
-0.0421436913,
-0.0541547574,
-0.0567527637,
0.0031034714,
0.0158377942,
0.037535686,
0.0925120041,
0.0338383242,
-0.0054539512,
-0.0062192986,
0.0025468941,
0.0196764246,
0.0095535135,
-0.0575629696,
-0.0227198396,
0.0223957002,
0.0050435551,
-0.0601436719,
0.019400863,
0.0071593267,
-0.0593537614,
0.0266252141,
0.082229279,
-0.0793229491,
-0.0234178063,
-0.0435963236,
0.0165146757,
0.0970803276,
0.0036599194,
0.0270208046,
-0.0655351505,
-0.0324042253,
-0.0228487011,
0.0141178248,
0.0106218662,
-0.0105079124,
-0.0122608049,
0.0345447026,
0.0008978299,
-0.0426431075,
-0.0239262003,
0.0330752619,
-0.000873058,
0.0136429491,
0.0132863699,
0.0725684315,
0.0220525581,
0.0160902441,
0.0118156318,
-0.0182381459,
0.0323273726,
-0.048662439,
-0.0654648021,
0.0064594261,
-0.027803475,
0.0053038099,
-0.0135571165,
-0.0034200472,
-0.0283543523,
0.0145817995,
0.0578462072,
0.0291329287,
0.0084879622,
-0.022753166,
-0.0437332727,
-0.0251372326,
-0.0033305686,
-0.0337348767,
-0.048285529,
0.0012065171,
0.037212193,
-0.0112321191,
-0.0087470431,
-0.0362685062,
0.0103779985,
-0.0360882804,
0.0227548108,
-0.0419182628,
-0.0929008499,
-0.0163369961,
0.0043411786,
0.0250038709,
-0.0136221284,
-0.0351821966,
-0.0126133366,
0.0177164525,
-0.0468955338,
-0.0023810728,
-0.0312789567,
0.0060240794,
-0.0415427908,
-0.0089623947,
0.034718059,
-0.0261416174,
-0.0733842626,
-0.0057480223,
0.0208098218,
0.0414006487,
-0.0161586609,
-0.0010511157,
0.0548245572,
-0.0063933847,
-0.0112693626,
0.0595572889,
0.0092080366,
0.0262054969,
-0.0167098083,
0.0950566232,
-0.0130690439,
-0.022308385,
-0.0070425295,
0.0436464474,
-0.0271997582,
-0.0450165272,
0.0020426407,
0.0368967764,
0.0095408047,
0.0523937009,
0.0132018626,
-0.0574642569,
0.0287018493,
-0.0093909455,
0.020899877,
0.0183996446,
-0.0645143911,
0.0128552355,
0.0289063919,
-0.0087958211,
0.0033815736,
0.0276539195,
-0.0122528384,
-0.0079854736,
-0.0200617425,
-0.0423042737,
-0.0711937398,
-0.0233176704,
0.0008431006,
0.0332707651,
-0.0830757469,
-0.0086096413,
-0.0620481968,
-0.0256848503,
0.0208595209,
-0.0014263015,
-0.0267935526,
-0.0466617867,
0.0447633043,
0.0240239874,
0.0334260613,
-0.0143663678,
-0.0273910053,
0.0060743489,
0.0139125753,
-0.0346130729,
-0.0267144144,
-5.639520106e-33,
-0.0227761026,
-0.0745594576,
0.0267859008,
0.025390625,
0.0087841628,
-0.0593070239,
-0.0811457559,
0.010997301,
0.0286466163,
-0.0077639455,
-0.0315427966,
-0.0102517875,
0.0227365624,
0.0381094292,
-0.0086480128,
-0.0008390192,
0.0689872578,
0.0144915879,
-0.0218276158,
0.0602497831,
-0.0109220799,
0.026981838,
0.0083224075,
-0.0492431857,
0.0695597976,
-0.0167719591,
0.0006189736,
0.0220541749,
-0.016482519,
0.0056470144,
-0.0460469387,
0.0482829139,
0.0304238182,
0.0000474317,
0.0017161615,
0.1048555821,
-0.0175139587,
-0.0065366141,
0.0250208974,
0.0052266303,
-0.0424080119,
-0.0231873784,
-0.0119371377,
-0.0132503929,
-0.0195292011,
0.0505885892,
0.0118040387,
-0.0125228232,
-0.0283272807,
-0.0227159224,
-0.0711631626,
0.0146246776,
-0.0104501816,
-0.010213498,
-0.0226000324,
0.0547296517,
-0.0156833567,
-0.0412130766,
0.0226729158,
0.0113942418,
0.0084347976,
0.0097115217,
0.0272491165,
0.041668281,
0.0030148695,
0.0215532668,
-0.0016886872,
0.0219105128,
-0.0346388705,
0.0353928022,
-0.0004315734,
0.030547969,
0.0156676415,
-0.0262218583,
-0.0849885941,
-0.018349953,
-0.0169754904,
0.0260040797,
0.0441197231,
0.0277829058,
-0.0102899643,
0.0051619369,
-0.0164558534,
-0.0173246376,
-0.023788061,
-0.0078141317,
-0.0044714259,
-0.0357631296,
0.0236719027,
-0.0131731573,
0.0189552829,
0.0038394318,
-0.0078367051,
0.0247337203,
-0.032183595,
-0.0105840592,
0.0560095273,
0.0066868938,
-0.0165818688,
-0.0040892721,
-0.0081157852,
0.0111607723,
-0.0014536746,
0.0157984551,
0.0311720371,
0.0200248007,
-0.0540393516,
0.0149572119,
-0.062500447,
0.0259744395,
0.0129911881,
0.0629480481,
-0.0124006653,
-0.0037645719,
0.0393147171,
-0.0198557246,
0.0000847931,
0.073539719,
-0.0157655645,
-0.0285493489,
-0.067545265,
0.0022280139,
-0.0241619758,
0.0207049903,
-0.060810931,
-0.0183824245,
-0.0692642704,
0.0380722396,
0.0462821238,
-0.012925948,
0.0121924952,
-0.0063822092,
2.783e-7,
0.0169682503,
0.044973705,
0.004517796,
0.0360260792,
0.0453393161,
0.0036030465,
-0.0227276422,
-0.0175776258,
0.0246599223,
-0.0203180965,
0.0205936562,
-0.009727953,
0.0484108143,
0.0331775099,
-0.1218986884,
-0.0416133925,
-0.0553428605,
0.0140188644,
-0.0724840239,
-0.006194144,
0.0262131952,
0.0091354093,
0.0006217774,
-0.0076471716,
0.0169558153,
0.0198748838,
-0.0078751184,
-0.0262157824,
0.0197298173,
0.020316137,
-0.0196702369,
-0.0228356626,
0.0304780696,
0.016063856,
-0.0126712024,
0.0125914142,
-0.0528219789,
0.0959616527,
-0.0103751272,
0.0128842145,
0.020059986,
-0.0195653047,
0.0135080442,
-0.0290266927,
0.0194719937,
-0.0549665987,
-0.0122040221,
-0.0128429495,
-0.0127684828,
-0.0201578345,
-0.0216313042,
-0.0126888752,
-0.0590785071,
0.0524570569,
-0.0089306086,
0.0227362365,
0.0070160464,
-0.0157038141,
-0.0093088876,
-0.004960259,
-0.037112847,
-0.040914841,
-0.0076318216,
-0.0340465903,
-0.0676794648,
-0.0352184623,
0.0195685755,
2.669387418e-34,
0.0189004708,
-0.0246626902,
0.0342397243,
0.0422906242,
0.0289012659,
0.0124817314,
0.0342661552,
0.0652341768,
0.0746005177,
-0.0541713759,
-0.0384463333
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03689v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03689v1 | Evaluating and Mitigating Discrimination in Language Model Decisions | 2023-12-06T18:53:01 | 2023-12-06T18:53:01 | Alex Tamkin, Amanda Askell, Liane Lovitt, Esin Durmus, Nicholas Joseph, Shauna Kravec, Karina Nguyen, Jared Kaplan, Deep Ganguli | cs.CL | cs.CL | As language models (LMs) advance, interest is growing in applying them to
high-stakes societal decisions, such as determining financing or housing
eligibility. However, their potential for discrimination in such contexts
raises ethical concerns, motivating the need for better methods to evaluate
these risks. We present a method for proactively evaluating the potential
discriminatory impact of LMs in a wide range of use cases, including
hypothetical use cases where they have not yet been deployed. Specifically, we
use an LM to generate a wide array of potential prompts that decision-makers
may input into an LM, spanning 70 diverse decision scenarios across society,
and systematically vary the demographic information in each prompt. Applying
this methodology reveals patterns of both positive and negative discrimination
in the Claude 2.0 model in select settings when no interventions are applied.
While we do not endorse or permit the use of language models to make automated
decisions for the high-risk use cases we study, we demonstrate techniques to
significantly decrease both positive and negative discrimination through
careful prompt engineering, providing pathways toward safer deployment in use
cases where they may be appropriate. Our work enables developers and
policymakers to anticipate, measure, and address discrimination as language
model capabilities and applications continue to expand. We release our dataset
and prompts at https://huggingface.co/datasets/Anthropic/discrim-eval | [
0.0407626927,
0.1309326291,
-0.0363217853,
0.0004475218,
-0.0209568273,
0.011638063,
0.0589660481,
0.0012703316,
0.0243248641,
-0.0584469773,
0.0394257866,
-0.0173102468,
0.0005358463,
0.0392450169,
-0.0072354702,
-0.0109266462,
0.0358134285,
0.0195235219,
0.0548633374,
-0.0390967168,
0.0085043721,
0.0336084925,
0.0272949766,
0.0717386007,
-0.0169526581,
-0.0124139674,
0.0395200625,
-0.0004135869,
-0.0066133053,
-0.0244487189,
0.0315271877,
0.1004119366,
-0.0186269749,
0.0139631629,
0.0000023618,
-0.0788535848,
-0.0004841474,
-0.0103573864,
-0.0381492749,
-0.0202817358,
0.052023109,
0.0019955265,
-0.0212317649,
0.0194070023,
-0.0354558676,
0.0189292133,
0.0469906516,
-0.0473363735,
0.0155914761,
-0.0184969604,
-0.0069560586,
0.0120790806,
-0.0362320542,
-0.0104954503,
0.002690912,
0.0164805744,
0.0468715094,
-0.0774645582,
0.0113628889,
-0.0282471552,
-0.0173948165,
0.0437236056,
0.0218696352,
-0.0243196711,
0.0126071367,
-0.0005814564,
-0.0280780066,
-0.0627077669,
-0.020599002,
0.0454812571,
0.056958098,
0.0274445731,
0.004273328,
-0.0147414282,
0.0239078794,
0.0151070375,
-0.0034810905,
0.035404399,
-0.0171093885,
-0.0149777792,
-0.040753223,
0.016462991,
0.0154171772,
0.0514897704,
-0.0011994578,
0.1032448411,
-0.0050785691,
-0.0076433239,
-0.0005044762,
-0.0020563272,
0.0435893983,
-0.0693032146,
0.0346115232,
-0.0215681326,
-0.0342052691,
0.0182000306,
0.0015324274,
0.036057476,
0.0583198518,
-0.0560020246,
0.0389806889,
0.063477315,
-0.008648973,
-0.0079309084,
0.0414129496,
0.0331939533,
0.0079455003,
-0.0114759738,
-0.0102313533,
0.0219614413,
0.0200322233,
-0.0124343736,
0.0022401579,
-0.0271768719,
-0.0458992273,
0.0730581507,
-0.0415304415,
-0.0010337946,
-0.0627340525,
0.0280760471,
-0.0283165611,
0.0091429912,
-0.0124194548,
-0.0057531344,
-0.05753351,
-0.0488632582,
-0.0463106409,
0.031273827,
0.0045870896,
-0.0658159107,
0.0453102104,
-0.0226157103,
-0.0279292874,
-0.034426257,
-0.0210728832,
0.0822359622,
0.0289408397,
0.0160532761,
-0.0075112004,
-0.0354462713,
-0.0319946781,
-0.0384677947,
-0.0250265636,
-0.0766486526,
0.0010202812,
0.012523924,
0.0147221824,
-0.1095242649,
-0.0033249846,
-0.0016783756,
-0.0314115137,
0.0561819635,
0.0067368564,
0.0008122716,
0.0418975577,
0.0439000092,
-0.0108761285,
0.0684702769,
0.0185808521,
0.0166039858,
0.0546563827,
-0.0377143882,
0.0075204605,
0.0295883939,
-0.0263305828,
0.0492845401,
-0.0383635573,
0.0395722985,
-0.0268220101,
-0.0338872969,
0.0072937673,
0.030674044,
0.0262505356,
-0.0494353324,
0.0459866598,
0.1082041264,
-0.015504133,
0.0026633779,
0.0031936846,
0.041472096,
-0.0469482876,
-0.0384750478,
-0.0472218022,
-0.0196998697,
-0.0427793115,
-0.0391377658,
-0.0065379934,
0.0421590731,
-0.0196673777,
-0.0224591307,
0.0116661945,
0.0116363345,
0.0985375792,
0.0617767237,
-0.0225257669,
-0.0226045493,
0.0241806805,
0.0285845362,
0.0338037759,
-0.044554662,
-0.023990063,
-0.0580528118,
0.0320061445,
0.0863579884,
0.0048664515,
-0.0114890346,
0.0283027459,
-0.0338258669,
-0.0169224199,
0.0554795004,
0.0529712327,
0.0021599382,
-0.0122510232,
-0.0412683077,
-0.0427682623,
0.0655010566,
0.0203549508,
0.035007719,
0.020283699,
0.0202359073,
0.0259557255,
0.0077227796,
-0.0219154414,
0.007122627,
-0.0050612306,
-0.0326059721,
-0.0284806173,
0.0020478051,
0.0011627212,
0.001202549,
0.0149161248,
0.0062467582,
-0.0366823301,
0.01900254,
0.0065164864,
-0.0110432375,
-0.0500179566,
0.0728040636,
0.019833032,
-0.0360461138,
-0.0262365956,
0.0319511592,
0.0011421139,
0.0278866589,
0.0360639803,
0.0239867475,
-0.0188049003,
-0.0137818465,
0.0136900684,
-0.0355498716,
0.0006503397,
-0.0370625481,
0.0138189374,
-0.0277278498,
0.0038288943,
0.0046126265,
-0.0162601415,
0.0062402091,
-0.0472241007,
-0.0356568247,
0.0394301116,
-0.0160217099,
0.0488297157,
0.0153274573,
0.0427831933,
0.0008267718,
0.0274650808,
-0.0579947047,
-0.0385337546,
0.0131137399,
-0.0262902658,
-0.0356796794,
-0.0070709842,
-0.0369565673,
-0.0051860022,
-0.0046678116,
-0.015856484,
0.0119361114,
0.0455944873,
-0.0126070362,
-0.0418063253,
-0.034675654,
-0.016782403,
-0.0523509607,
-0.0271818265,
0.0503776371,
0.0348325297,
0.0227931123,
-0.0075905891,
-0.0348933972,
-0.057519719,
-0.0080289692,
0.006370917,
0.0056551294,
0.0146183642,
0.0344289951,
0.0075032213,
-0.0087101394,
0.0232259072,
0.0534113832,
0.0443197787,
-0.0039625731,
-0.0639432222,
-0.0220136959,
0.016422404,
0.0356873758,
0.0112610925,
-0.0837169513,
-0.0025706843,
0.0429802313,
0.0160262305,
-0.0184710473,
-0.0644664764,
0.070803307,
-0.0683443174,
-0.0605194457,
-0.0823210031,
-0.0356119089,
-0.0280575436,
0.0849264339,
-0.0377084278,
-0.0502841696,
0.0605712421,
0.0126855839,
0.0154014863,
-0.0181942675,
-0.0097478358,
-0.0281427652,
0.051608339,
-0.0279821903,
0.0236472208,
0.0353772938,
-0.0124528036,
-0.0187905636,
-0.0450378992,
0.016331682,
-0.0482153594,
0.097680904,
-0.0488506891,
0.001457408,
-0.0209073164,
-0.0686839446,
-0.0371016972,
-0.085570395,
-0.0180620309,
0.0195786264,
0.0320708416,
0.0214682538,
0.001565656,
0.0142270606,
0.0165642109,
0.0500715487,
0.0041459389,
-0.0059493696,
-0.0061089606,
-0.0556361899,
-0.0102025587,
0.0057212678,
0.023052346,
-0.0254398957,
0.0236732662,
0.0147071825,
-0.0066166301,
0.0094459718,
0.0292798653,
0.0599810891,
0.0435318574,
-0.0277494509,
-0.0073997076,
0.0306061208,
0.0164544433,
-0.0401372053,
0.0274301283,
0.0516809188,
0.0133006293,
-0.0609939955,
0.0205396768,
-0.0426961407,
0.019574387,
0.0366702676,
0.004802736,
-0.132294789,
0.0139788203,
0.0193966758,
0.0337345861,
-0.0625305846,
-0.0344480984,
-0.0143808229,
-0.0523905754,
0.0618029162,
0.0126659349,
-0.0126736118,
-0.0008850871,
0.0040144618,
0.0066293473,
0.0100085568,
0.0170621071,
-0.0163292438,
0.0034769296,
0.0029752518,
0.0062483717,
-0.0460408106,
-0.0367171206,
0.0452337265,
-0.0267208219,
0.0226945635,
0.0492963716,
0.028982373,
-0.0203047451,
-0.0019522496,
0.0302184783,
-0.0229380336,
-0.044706773,
-0.0105100162,
-0.0243664943,
0.0203757323,
-0.0019361837,
-0.0340627134,
0.0158949438,
0.014251803,
-0.0209569447,
0.0630968735,
0.0325453058,
-0.0284811575,
-0.0274727326,
-0.0264280569,
0.0217154287,
0.0168058146,
0.071043618,
0.0289123058,
-0.0604657754,
0.0009358405,
-0.1175789163,
-0.0248390902,
-0.0061866757,
-0.0785434544,
0.0139557533,
0.0191290937,
-0.0522996858,
-0.0000627844,
-0.0418438837,
0.0072193216,
-0.0131787844,
0.0389922261,
-0.0479917526,
0.0294653028,
-0.006332933,
-0.0249997377,
0.0608126,
-0.0519053154,
0.0386220329,
-0.025796026,
0.0107895983,
-0.0465174019,
-0.0112292981,
-0.0314797908,
-0.0167613067,
0.0450791568,
-0.0498101972,
0.0667919219,
0.0161070749,
0.0394250453,
-0.0130717112,
-0.0058698948,
-0.0435091443,
0.0384324118,
0.0523605198,
0.0069255643,
0.0079443976,
0.0324284546,
-0.0133994007,
-0.0150879081,
0.021706311,
0.0083927698,
0.0690173879,
0.0052623041,
0.0100287506,
-0.0436137207,
-0.0051140939,
0.0083900085,
0.0058982177,
0.0020902271,
-0.0489766821,
-0.0469535068,
-0.0367940962,
-0.0317455716,
0.0063376348,
-0.0321972072,
-0.0127142044,
-0.0259093624,
0.0087156985,
0.0045952667,
0.0036979518,
-0.0129663395,
-0.0377740338,
0.0113530997,
-0.0075292233,
0.1064282134,
0.035703443,
0.08536309,
0.0509012192,
-0.0005811061,
-0.005968045,
0.0626288429,
-0.0447580628,
0.030344557,
0.0216449257,
0.0506444052,
-0.004653641,
0.0062666931,
-0.0120788626,
0.0212122239,
0.0044452287,
-0.0550973527,
0.0150472336,
0.0183359291,
-0.0183544587,
-0.0081707239,
-0.0141339628,
0.0120606348,
-0.0152000953,
-0.034181118,
-0.0249088984,
0.0382364467,
-0.0503274798,
0.0224202126,
-0.0049566557,
-0.0270306282,
-0.0338083282,
0.0227888823,
0.0123809315,
0.0141039798,
-0.0430245772,
-0.0178884119,
-0.0132241054,
-0.0597884357,
0.0367624275,
-0.0171680525,
-0.0458685942,
-0.0322374143,
-0.1254669279,
-0.0503599569,
-0.0532634892,
-0.0014366447,
0.011236649,
-0.0141760707,
0.0019418851,
0.0180771276,
-0.0027593626,
-0.0092871767,
-0.0326904915,
0.0230606999,
-0.0698030964,
-0.0232850667,
-0.0259078797,
-6.514068067e-33,
-0.0177532658,
-0.0238824915,
-0.0158007145,
-0.0415686332,
0.0208326802,
-0.0039047776,
-0.0124646788,
0.0088187689,
-0.0139741357,
-0.0181090701,
0.0089920936,
-0.0109160859,
0.0152959591,
0.0084871752,
0.04155875,
0.0014189248,
0.0213324949,
0.0205798391,
-0.0379455797,
-0.0084414929,
-0.0140698152,
-0.0023384793,
-0.0013620174,
-0.0368525572,
0.0807727724,
-0.0005323305,
-0.016101867,
-0.0039044076,
-0.0470158122,
0.0278792921,
-0.0156059852,
0.0564047769,
0.0054054675,
-0.0475885533,
-0.0064044604,
0.1092162952,
-0.0381599627,
-0.0246848594,
0.0220481418,
-0.0034938671,
0.0223997813,
-0.0554700904,
-0.0077837841,
0.0299834441,
-0.0747827068,
0.0177082494,
0.0375775136,
-0.0399691463,
0.0263634026,
0.0250093564,
-0.0398993194,
0.0193354487,
-0.0415417738,
0.0554137044,
-0.0024223181,
0.0819422826,
0.0062655159,
0.0291031711,
-0.0309196394,
0.0338174701,
0.0241823737,
-0.0308974851,
0.0702484027,
0.0035248364,
-0.016538756,
0.0305136312,
-0.0082289744,
-0.0116321119,
-0.0170766357,
-0.0647742227,
0.04713488,
-0.0029888689,
0.0141973617,
0.0718607083,
0.0220270231,
-0.0587026291,
-0.0014028427,
0.0194443613,
0.0350672789,
-0.0107943611,
0.0559324212,
-0.0235123225,
-0.0617999695,
-0.0591216423,
-0.0564967245,
-0.0425418578,
-0.0280643255,
-0.023235295,
0.0558283329,
-0.0234390311,
-0.0340630375,
0.0154773006,
0.0167241171,
-0.0248407871,
-0.0452533923,
-0.0080085639,
-0.0047921343,
-0.0278680902,
0.0222957879,
0.0472005494,
-0.0527780056,
0.0139291752,
0.0041636727,
0.0042082951,
0.0392640717,
0.0279970448,
-0.0281664096,
-0.0035555346,
-0.0714342445,
0.0117059285,
0.0014012298,
0.0471202359,
0.0227526762,
0.0411561392,
0.0219838955,
0.0006586611,
0.0349693671,
-0.0056142681,
0.0278528426,
-0.0115913618,
-0.0289599132,
-0.0231232457,
-0.0397554338,
0.0613802262,
-0.0310940184,
0.0014751451,
-0.0115652308,
0.0211430099,
0.0839667842,
-0.0031406828,
0.0038562154,
-0.0478224903,
2.733e-7,
0.0218456499,
0.0175393857,
-0.0331163257,
-0.0115678012,
-0.0048690643,
0.0601077378,
0.0145384921,
0.0248790141,
0.0508633517,
0.0121062612,
-0.0083925864,
0.0257655345,
0.0422286019,
0.0461737476,
-0.0369479284,
-0.0092138257,
-0.0444916189,
0.0323066041,
-0.0694195703,
0.0386638157,
0.0084616747,
0.0510155298,
0.0335624255,
-0.0155532109,
-0.0314312428,
-0.0035810447,
-0.0172325615,
-0.0845436901,
0.0327740498,
0.0038887789,
0.0294288155,
-0.0127734756,
0.0286998302,
0.0450160615,
0.0113984356,
-0.0080214301,
-0.0280293226,
0.0603051037,
0.0043980707,
0.0327987634,
-0.0283698048,
-0.0302278623,
0.0025450734,
-0.0682421997,
0.0379013419,
0.0383378342,
-0.0156098241,
-0.0358822718,
-0.0106259929,
-0.0242673177,
0.0450475961,
-0.0084843272,
-0.0433819927,
-0.0185149629,
0.0186585374,
-0.0019532116,
0.0090863397,
-0.0539717227,
-0.0016188918,
-0.0124663925,
-0.010275512,
-0.0501183383,
-0.0058709849,
0.0543454885,
-0.0254495591,
-0.0361587256,
0.0501343273,
2.760417976e-34,
0.007612376,
0.0491125919,
-0.0013648686,
-0.0486770757,
0.041729372,
0.0276295934,
0.0267475098,
0.0026761547,
0.0201621708,
0.0023895099,
0.0094047962
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03815v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03815v2 | LLM as OS, Agents as Apps: Envisioning AIOS, Agents and the AIOS-Agent Ecosystem | 2023-12-06T18:50:26 | 2023-12-09T18:10:39 | Yingqiang Ge, Yujie Ren, Wenyue Hua, Shuyuan Xu, Juntao Tan, Yongfeng Zhang | cs.OS | cs.OS, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | This paper envisions a revolutionary AIOS-Agent ecosystem, where Large
Language Model (LLM) serves as the (Artificial) Intelligent Operating System
(IOS, or AIOS)--an operating system "with soul". Upon this foundation, a
diverse range of LLM-based AI Agent Applications (Agents, or AAPs) are
developed, enriching the AIOS-Agent ecosystem and signaling a paradigm shift
from the traditional OS-APP ecosystem. We envision that LLM's impact will not
be limited to the AI application level, instead, it will in turn revolutionize
the design and implementation of computer system, architecture, software, and
programming language, featured by several main concepts: LLM as OS
(system-level), Agents as Applications (application-level), Natural Language as
Programming Interface (user-level), and Tools as Devices/Libraries
(hardware/middleware-level). We begin by introducing the architecture of
traditional OS. Then we formalize a conceptual framework for AIOS through "LLM
as OS (LLMOS)", drawing analogies between AIOS and traditional OS: LLM is
likened to OS kernel, context window to memory, external storage to file
system, hardware tools to peripheral devices, software tools to programming
libraries, and user prompts to user commands. Subsequently, we introduce the
new AIOS-Agent Ecosystem, where users can easily program Agent Applications
(AAPs) using natural language, democratizing the development of software, which
is different from the traditional OS-APP ecosystem. Following this, we explore
the diverse scope of Agent Applications. We delve into both single-agent and
multi-agent systems, as well as human-agent interaction. Lastly, drawing on the
insights from traditional OS-APP ecosystem, we propose a roadmap for the
evolution of the AIOS-Agent ecosystem. This roadmap is designed to guide the
future research and development, suggesting systematic progresses of AIOS and
its Agent applications. | [
0.0439986326,
0.0083577652,
-0.0454426333,
0.0314368792,
-0.0374411941,
-0.0215521343,
0.0128163164,
-0.0033486548,
0.056031134,
-0.0376222059,
-0.0153356539,
0.0466984063,
-0.0030975023,
0.0250538848,
-0.0145820733,
-0.0250655059,
0.0646701232,
-0.0219307002,
0.0109977843,
0.0130273225,
0.0089876791,
0.0230314769,
0.0169219989,
0.0347585678,
0.0113872299,
-0.042394504,
-0.0429785103,
0.0428792872,
-0.0361291282,
-0.0011814813,
-0.0465447493,
-0.026598746,
0.0347265787,
0.0534084328,
0.0000021165,
-0.0847132057,
-0.0028549186,
0.0161046218,
-0.0525634289,
0.0051751924,
0.0721078739,
0.0615690425,
-0.0431259908,
-0.032166373,
-0.0423243642,
0.0144770574,
0.0656756461,
0.0048496602,
0.0413399935,
0.0533189885,
-0.0033531762,
-0.0003528299,
0.0292505715,
0.0520747006,
0.0046599791,
-0.0136255929,
0.005133424,
-0.0135854194,
0.0762668923,
0.0098101553,
0.0019364101,
-0.0079698339,
0.0284118615,
0.0136820562,
-0.009669899,
0.0462263487,
0.0118594188,
-0.0539473854,
-0.0580287836,
-0.0112944776,
0.0343436636,
0.0093548931,
0.0651228204,
0.0309063513,
0.0021042677,
-0.0291923378,
-0.0091390107,
0.0503703915,
-0.0051085679,
-0.0178840701,
0.0439339131,
-0.0107154902,
0.0099465642,
0.0358022042,
-0.0183586553,
0.084473826,
-0.006860707,
-0.0007698057,
-0.0023490891,
-0.0366579518,
0.0428964272,
-0.0584374554,
-0.0051521016,
0.0859090537,
-0.0627502799,
0.0265704039,
-0.0209371448,
0.0367365703,
0.0057521053,
-0.0828931928,
-0.0370262526,
-0.0147088123,
-0.0135134505,
0.0036132587,
0.0477486402,
0.03872592,
0.0041108341,
0.025794562,
0.0023389352,
0.0144210747,
-0.0534832701,
-0.0240494553,
-0.0316780359,
0.0600940399,
-0.0213919021,
-0.0111563206,
-0.0051179724,
0.0727551654,
-0.0314817801,
0.0238076597,
-0.0540251806,
0.0063753063,
-0.008773529,
-0.0192360822,
-0.0487903431,
-0.0077232323,
-0.0497219674,
0.017840635,
0.0200693719,
-0.0438574366,
0.0507398061,
0.0110049443,
-0.0273295343,
0.0091163237,
0.0162768345,
0.1231403053,
0.0564583689,
-0.0066780713,
-0.0569888204,
-0.0536279418,
0.0698695481,
-0.072374478,
-0.0736585259,
-0.0796251297,
0.0031187357,
0.0172923617,
0.008350106,
-0.029364625,
0.0042734533,
0.0121198623,
-0.0101140356,
0.0276086032,
-0.0460510403,
0.0122086694,
0.0768736899,
0.0339053161,
-0.0056088273,
0.0106258895,
0.0551590696,
0.0309634004,
0.0449648313,
0.000365199,
0.0319026969,
0.0066052615,
-0.09471865,
-0.0277687348,
0.0569277816,
0.016322596,
-0.0114696613,
0.0071544256,
-0.066067107,
0.0500082001,
0.0251620337,
0.011588729,
0.0469595641,
0.102959834,
-0.0133855576,
0.0141215818,
0.0296471883,
0.0430637076,
-0.0108069712,
-0.0280633196,
-0.0281224903,
0.0456710756,
-0.0078534614,
0.0001360735,
-0.0361141413,
0.0455827564,
0.0111845518,
-0.0457632318,
0.0235847775,
-0.0506651662,
0.0040494017,
-0.0131137967,
0.0234077014,
0.0045382758,
0.0122525468,
-0.0327919647,
-0.0004862529,
-0.0143885249,
0.0046698176,
-0.100278005,
0.0430460498,
0.0852025822,
0.0385735147,
-0.0301780738,
0.0006483821,
0.024110768,
-0.0360421911,
0.0138211092,
-0.0006411483,
-0.009581848,
-0.0268785637,
-0.02261246,
0.0185209513,
-0.0132094324,
-0.000752645,
0.0401263312,
-0.067042999,
0.0288575869,
-0.0173777342,
0.038950853,
-0.0493895784,
0.0006627209,
-0.0070617883,
-0.0371732526,
-0.0354195572,
0.0343114287,
-0.0155282496,
0.0166264474,
-0.0194371883,
0.0039728777,
0.0609001666,
0.0129490513,
-0.0202902891,
-0.0184703805,
0.0139248017,
0.0743057951,
0.0356846787,
-0.0054635052,
0.0314985141,
0.0116180293,
-0.0102702267,
-0.0425272211,
0.0514342599,
-0.0111069884,
0.0474713072,
0.0122643998,
0.036972966,
-0.0145424148,
-0.025666561,
-0.0234540794,
0.0304162651,
0.0492450111,
-0.0485745594,
0.0054702144,
0.0340431668,
0.0320544094,
-0.0129215894,
0.0155921616,
0.0213030893,
0.0027446905,
0.040540088,
0.0547720939,
0.025411997,
0.0074947458,
-0.003950764,
-0.0935639292,
0.0328178406,
-0.0233564992,
-0.0114764133,
0.0012045059,
0.057958547,
0.0024697736,
-0.0093233362,
0.0122182425,
0.0571143255,
0.0223680586,
-0.0023953551,
0.016946055,
0.0019685372,
-0.0761946067,
-0.0162360407,
0.0275567584,
-0.0188279059,
-0.0172512233,
0.0074871155,
-0.0306520648,
-0.0757946372,
-0.0027733915,
-0.0490368567,
0.0010085651,
-0.0022708606,
0.0121098431,
0.0385379605,
-0.0319283977,
-0.0316573866,
0.0706855953,
-0.0446103401,
0.0734363049,
0.0482021794,
-0.0267699603,
-0.0124158245,
0.0108291982,
0.0205214936,
0.0097415578,
-0.0251098126,
-0.0105198631,
0.0415743366,
0.0361130089,
0.0101367505,
-0.0003620994,
0.0146671692,
0.0152497049,
-0.024092339,
-0.0116713569,
-0.0002828155,
-0.0301519409,
-0.0430906527,
0.03118046,
-0.0178191401,
-0.0740411654,
0.0940771997,
-0.0404071398,
-0.0160434432,
0.0045058029,
-0.0861569494,
-0.0559569709,
0.0755996555,
-0.0094648972,
0.0150439404,
0.0236778222,
-0.0205225069,
-0.0236154441,
-0.0028898104,
-0.0041128867,
-0.0418712087,
0.034785755,
-0.0825829655,
-0.0114218928,
0.0101976972,
-0.0211710464,
0.0226443615,
0.0351532139,
-0.05328729,
-0.0261958707,
-0.0437340327,
0.0015660395,
-0.0305320974,
-0.0200799052,
0.0493195467,
0.0426749215,
0.0308390781,
-0.034916807,
-0.0285248458,
-0.0643356889,
0.0074207215,
0.0019373214,
-0.034901049,
0.0365479328,
0.0557172857,
0.0118806949,
0.0342034325,
-0.0313160345,
0.004146968,
-0.0052410224,
0.0321319588,
-0.0193212759,
-0.0387990028,
0.0583070479,
0.0198634844,
-0.0356400535,
-0.0071769818,
0.0837814808,
0.0194397476,
-0.031004345,
0.0282946434,
-0.037130367,
-0.0401587337,
0.0590959527,
0.0784004852,
-0.0730849579,
-0.010033505,
-0.0132387243,
-0.0044623278,
-0.005166492,
-0.0032296688,
-0.0198195875,
-0.0042833393,
0.0202754159,
0.0198370125,
-0.0075657964,
0.0042985291,
-0.0613076985,
-0.0126166781,
0.0232380703,
0.0012728327,
-0.0094663966,
-0.0025153083,
-0.0209631734,
-0.0301082209,
-0.0061310297,
0.0526902936,
0.0119356727,
-0.0283333212,
0.0722402707,
0.0986720175,
0.0207959935,
-0.0035431057,
-0.0244605038,
-0.0287744757,
0.0475792512,
0.0197990891,
-0.0194337983,
-0.0440765135,
0.0027547509,
0.0110632349,
-0.0440687612,
-0.0055995118,
-0.0453841388,
-0.0199594703,
0.0247186795,
0.0673960596,
-0.0473264605,
-0.0025433174,
-0.0364639126,
-0.0485025719,
0.013549854,
0.0217697509,
-0.0449252725,
-0.0208268594,
-0.070312731,
-0.0433260612,
-0.0562705919,
0.0351868756,
-0.041853521,
0.0224581473,
-0.0427026525,
-0.0443078093,
-0.0229680613,
-0.0612632334,
-0.0213237684,
-0.0008257763,
0.0513390824,
0.0121630831,
0.0499023572,
0.0250137411,
-0.0037217664,
-0.0413991399,
-0.0210842378,
0.0402725488,
-0.0181950014,
-0.0006806749,
0.0000952105,
-0.051508069,
0.0055100117,
0.001327981,
0.0297768097,
-0.0549557097,
0.0226737484,
0.0594592355,
0.0270075165,
-0.0060966373,
0.0103354407,
-0.0386394709,
0.0200009085,
-0.0073096119,
-0.065527603,
0.0411009789,
-0.0004417152,
-0.0016249387,
0.0192416273,
0.0096164625,
-0.0897087231,
-0.0001214222,
-0.011497518,
-0.0259663556,
-0.0219030604,
-0.0131074265,
0.0145027246,
0.0255263671,
-0.0302298181,
-0.0091050835,
0.015494518,
0.0195147637,
0.0292052068,
-0.0081633879,
-0.0210455079,
-0.0166930798,
-0.0110863168,
-0.0427104346,
0.0213778727,
0.0675519481,
-0.0131680164,
0.017944539,
-0.0056701452,
0.024872249,
0.0112690385,
0.0217817947,
0.0442355126,
0.0182137862,
0.0424059853,
-0.0189173557,
0.0448487736,
-0.0148495678,
0.0758992359,
-0.0458759628,
0.060036175,
-0.0105704106,
-0.0064730612,
-0.020105198,
0.028976094,
-0.0339295156,
-0.0779620484,
0.0659085587,
0.0603617877,
-0.0013134339,
0.0264173187,
-0.0155206583,
-0.0639556125,
0.0446158014,
-0.0429465063,
0.0114094559,
0.0244175605,
-0.041129604,
-0.0617025197,
0.0190747306,
-0.016475698,
-0.0250492524,
0.0255965032,
-0.0356092937,
0.04022903,
-0.048773393,
-0.0536609963,
-0.0612117536,
0.0039656046,
-0.0064379922,
-0.0108406981,
-0.0267263819,
-0.0261484701,
-0.0548047982,
-0.0282765124,
-0.0347553901,
0.0504289195,
0.0051676999,
-0.0763702914,
0.0283185896,
0.0532419123,
0.0413833484,
-0.0481054969,
-0.0298818815,
-0.0066026072,
-0.103639394,
-0.0013132708,
-0.0021305941,
-5.197507414e-33,
-0.0210906398,
-0.0134344576,
0.0581751689,
0.0672245026,
0.0135249952,
-0.032767918,
-0.0218907222,
0.004528461,
0.0037742811,
-0.0122720711,
0.0100453813,
-0.0397571549,
0.0011949413,
-0.0397529118,
0.0435268655,
0.0395450406,
0.0050888644,
0.0013032856,
-0.0175757762,
0.0121591436,
0.0191906001,
-0.0130482493,
-0.015084384,
-0.0520972498,
0.0433156975,
-0.0287426244,
0.0520941243,
0.0094548622,
-0.0443266034,
0.0194776747,
0.0112007754,
0.0443830714,
0.0156368278,
0.0145602711,
-0.001544493,
0.0511783175,
-0.0134556005,
-0.0330391042,
0.0337359346,
0.0364051275,
-0.0204604398,
-0.0462590493,
0.0169363711,
0.0115031805,
-0.0355884917,
0.0692495033,
0.0370225944,
-0.0060482039,
0.0151804276,
0.0294042509,
-0.07531517,
-0.0042146207,
0.0121180164,
-0.0021850243,
-0.0121635934,
-0.0281783957,
-0.0429421254,
-0.0097464118,
-0.0161824971,
0.0098564625,
-0.0311817303,
-0.00548216,
0.0438619256,
0.0308073051,
0.0119155394,
0.0129659986,
0.0157632791,
0.0088915061,
-0.0065705902,
0.0124479132,
-0.0222128462,
0.0728014857,
-0.0098399417,
0.008612588,
-0.0603855737,
-0.0247255582,
-0.0254601799,
0.0220077839,
0.0749268457,
-0.0003966866,
-0.0059536085,
0.0338817649,
-0.0569588654,
0.0063179168,
0.0132198725,
0.0003353778,
-0.0296678059,
-0.0495962277,
-0.0050837779,
0.0087212604,
0.0159689281,
-0.0457807034,
-0.0099639064,
-0.059110783,
-0.0038534892,
-0.0731384531,
0.0181376729,
-0.0142205879,
0.0037883145,
-0.0065704305,
-0.0218162704,
-0.0229418967,
-0.0431389958,
0.013059482,
0.0587545186,
0.0124976803,
-0.0250437316,
0.0669099614,
0.0108850831,
0.0214854963,
-0.0274258293,
0.0010063127,
0.0257902127,
-0.0261232648,
0.0007419592,
-0.0076857712,
0.0061670542,
0.0672707856,
-0.027777316,
-0.0633626357,
-0.0228999853,
-0.0180121437,
-0.0136761935,
-0.0337622128,
-0.0589477308,
0.0036487235,
-0.0842646435,
0.0470871143,
0.0288685989,
-0.0177513622,
-0.0190395303,
-0.0138441613,
3.029e-7,
-0.0527362451,
0.0086318785,
0.0322005749,
0.010196941,
0.0243054219,
0.0630709454,
-0.0071063717,
0.0576988757,
-0.0392928571,
-0.0329074897,
-0.0207156595,
-0.0001154349,
0.0251662936,
-0.0011678785,
-0.0479569696,
0.0356277078,
0.0005439275,
0.0125505822,
-0.080382742,
-0.0083712246,
0.0632469505,
0.0284877904,
0.0295367371,
-0.00759396,
0.0080424985,
-0.0461060591,
-0.0287912469,
-0.0139826778,
0.0478493385,
0.0052219322,
-0.05985507,
0.0282968823,
-0.0075184931,
0.0051386096,
-0.0012983369,
0.031024307,
-0.0614113696,
0.0623216406,
-0.0409921333,
-0.0150247412,
0.0415651128,
-0.0417313091,
-0.0320205539,
-0.0356609896,
0.0239259563,
-0.0003594552,
-0.0106726252,
-0.0191818494,
0.0065699727,
0.0037770234,
-0.065898791,
-0.0347695015,
-0.0168509409,
-0.0095794657,
-0.0164123196,
-0.044656761,
0.0053997608,
-0.0636696815,
0.0256854035,
0.0177412126,
0.0094308462,
-0.0468246378,
-0.0688138753,
0.0143284127,
0.0406663492,
-0.0303505566,
0.0183061846,
2.329911996e-34,
-0.0288568586,
-0.0158723816,
0.0015179581,
0.0490816906,
0.0344544649,
0.0432221852,
-0.0403780267,
0.0366036855,
0.0301043801,
-0.0194504969,
-0.0209799651
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03668v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03668v2 | Integrating Pre-Trained Speech and Language Models for End-to-End Speech Recognition | 2023-12-06T18:34:42 | 2024-06-06T15:24:16 | Yukiya Hono, Koh Mitsuda, Tianyu Zhao, Kentaro Mitsui, Toshiaki Wakatsuki, Kei Sawada | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Advances in machine learning have made it possible to perform various text
and speech processing tasks, such as automatic speech recognition (ASR), in an
end-to-end (E2E) manner. E2E approaches utilizing pre-trained models are
gaining attention for conserving training data and resources. However, most of
their applications in ASR involve only one of either a pre-trained speech or a
language model. This paper proposes integrating a pre-trained speech
representation model and a large language model (LLM) for E2E ASR. The proposed
model enables the optimization of the entire ASR process, including acoustic
feature extraction and acoustic and language modeling, by combining pre-trained
models with a bridge network and also enables the application of remarkable
developments in LLM utilization, such as parameter-efficient domain adaptation
and inference optimization. Experimental results demonstrate that the proposed
model achieves a performance comparable to that of modern E2E ASR models by
utilizing powerful pre-training models with the proposed integrated approach. | [
-0.0155008426,
0.059423212,
0.0186499003,
0.0372015275,
0.0090016704,
0.0204095505,
0.0351557881,
-0.0370742232,
0.0063827261,
-0.0565848127,
-0.0652759448,
-0.0388288163,
-0.0049957787,
0.0422920398,
0.0165126622,
-0.0102063408,
0.0247974545,
-0.0388425365,
-0.0099641234,
-0.0218020417,
-0.0057030837,
0.0161580499,
-0.0001628188,
0.0193912908,
0.006634078,
0.0282035004,
-0.0144086843,
0.0149403159,
0.0238543041,
-0.0055402629,
-0.0214569662,
0.0097328201,
0.0651437417,
0.0251443014,
0.000001962,
-0.0424325615,
-0.0273941774,
-0.002483987,
-0.0756762028,
0.0085613159,
0.0363487452,
0.0388921276,
-0.0015530736,
0.0550087318,
-0.0141791617,
-0.0658421591,
0.0763700679,
0.0480139069,
0.0503002591,
0.0627745241,
-0.0139716612,
-0.0450587124,
0.0406901464,
-0.0222824886,
-0.0538741238,
-0.0695609525,
0.0315521881,
-0.0119569534,
0.0088156452,
-0.0155606521,
-0.0134662604,
0.0407869332,
0.0069427956,
0.0286186486,
-0.007309156,
-0.0119880894,
-0.0186648015,
0.0044203773,
-0.0255741719,
0.0648306906,
-0.047235243,
-0.0501727499,
0.013122268,
-0.0032621922,
-0.0535482466,
0.0149814468,
0.007060478,
-0.0074313092,
0.0492740422,
0.0074095922,
-0.0094586732,
0.0152884889,
0.0425132699,
0.0124115376,
-0.0827015042,
0.0102325818,
0.0092521785,
0.0126822796,
0.0126554947,
-0.0100256195,
0.0002783346,
-0.033099886,
0.0526086129,
0.0266628973,
0.0028336549,
0.0121185957,
-0.0524685271,
-0.0320109688,
-0.0293557774,
-0.0404139273,
0.0506199263,
0.0409288816,
-0.0613420904,
0.0360715538,
-0.0336178429,
0.0223048571,
-0.0260766316,
-0.0091568651,
-0.043492917,
-0.0275029466,
-0.0156739298,
0.009449359,
-0.0608302504,
0.0183271356,
-0.0366266705,
-0.0726160854,
-0.0273663495,
0.0147874011,
0.0232906304,
-0.0527224205,
0.0517670587,
-0.0139075685,
-0.0221743491,
-0.0367736071,
0.0345219523,
0.0200322326,
0.0311031025,
0.0620627478,
-0.0271865502,
-0.0296113435,
-0.0139686884,
0.0198698565,
0.0387765542,
-0.0002131871,
0.0213894583,
0.0642019063,
0.0099494457,
-0.0306840073,
-0.0750235915,
0.0397982672,
-0.0045002885,
-0.0557684787,
0.004588333,
-0.0394747406,
0.0645620078,
0.0079691764,
-0.0006891724,
-0.0192906782,
-0.0051430315,
-0.0514275357,
-0.0072875861,
0.0727071315,
0.0129928049,
0.0220224205,
0.0443366617,
-0.0076070246,
0.0472772308,
0.0493956804,
0.0488186553,
-0.0083566299,
-0.0124532748,
-0.0315774605,
-0.0360255465,
0.0904267877,
0.0092028948,
0.010222557,
-0.0030886775,
-0.0103270626,
0.0428749509,
-0.0107511869,
0.0360132754,
0.0252512451,
-0.0157641936,
-0.001676309,
0.0462318994,
0.0143179875,
0.0479894243,
0.0473732799,
0.0417757183,
0.0145816505,
-0.0032611021,
-0.0541078448,
-0.0222337376,
-0.0130171124,
-0.0199755728,
-0.0003890588,
0.0341225564,
0.043684531,
-0.0330582485,
-0.0039869174,
0.0140382424,
-0.0360853225,
-0.0108457943,
0.0707438365,
0.0627517179,
-0.0101328073,
-0.0792280659,
0.0743052959,
0.015591695,
-0.0332290083,
0.0518989712,
-0.0317211524,
-0.0177571513,
0.0124669531,
0.0186480246,
-0.0605737567,
-0.0037112297,
-0.0247681476,
0.0184331127,
0.0405465104,
0.0099502159,
0.0305634774,
0.0599525869,
-0.0739636198,
-0.0437916256,
0.0445569269,
0.0002384418,
0.0896249861,
-0.0265444908,
0.0441533104,
0.0415926538,
-0.0330218747,
-0.025158748,
0.0130306892,
-0.0272290017,
-0.0363974832,
0.0188869368,
0.0097270617,
0.0494023822,
0.0155309187,
-0.0458083451,
-0.0100577846,
0.0335347466,
-0.0262182616,
-0.024086671,
0.0173084568,
-0.0882247761,
-0.000591426,
0.0403526388,
0.0044790446,
0.063747108,
0.0417371728,
-0.0116009563,
-0.1028777435,
0.0066111074,
0.0108978683,
0.0652202815,
-0.0557661988,
0.0798063129,
0.0200706124,
0.0237081368,
-0.0049375403,
0.0011962177,
0.0267071277,
-0.0382174589,
-0.016758943,
-0.0011751092,
-0.010642251,
-0.0518439561,
-0.0504496954,
0.0415802263,
0.0185390003,
0.0249320772,
-0.0164162908,
-0.0086911442,
-0.0047112778,
0.0068784263,
-0.1172480807,
-0.0106664179,
-0.0395916849,
0.032748118,
0.0069056554,
0.044251278,
-0.0222646743,
-0.0133327264,
-0.0290020704,
-0.0333927646,
-0.0106930612,
-0.0131562017,
-0.0448668152,
0.0158338342,
-0.0079320278,
-0.0311333854,
-0.0009553466,
0.0108503783,
0.024695484,
-0.0233272947,
-0.0534846634,
-0.047219485,
0.0534393676,
0.0266614966,
0.0681777969,
-0.0063195857,
-0.0177849289,
-0.0649707392,
-0.0203911811,
0.0411905609,
0.0173501559,
-0.0028278283,
-0.0372156575,
0.0300702844,
-0.0232053697,
-0.058077231,
0.0071306671,
-0.012077814,
-0.0042984085,
-0.015997583,
0.0153884478,
-0.0156407077,
0.0378655083,
-0.0194433648,
0.0169600248,
-0.0094047915,
-0.0351762585,
-0.0029535401,
-0.0299531519,
-0.0227773804,
-0.0415472127,
-0.0236846823,
0.0165788867,
0.0006580574,
-0.0083485013,
0.0114459535,
-0.0980069563,
-0.0197996125,
-0.0390921421,
-0.0428616256,
-0.0386586189,
0.0029022756,
0.0053800168,
0.0200183541,
-0.0463944562,
-0.0296410285,
-0.0330404118,
0.0342884101,
0.0137420455,
-0.0388720594,
0.0384845026,
0.0009787539,
0.0413887799,
0.0017931231,
-0.000940236,
-0.0324205011,
-0.0053038527,
-0.0514189154,
0.0201408342,
-0.0158269815,
-0.0095240893,
-0.0478092544,
0.0667769387,
-0.0264579859,
0.0701453909,
0.0146145355,
0.0376373865,
-0.0318291187,
0.0556451492,
0.0378589518,
0.0162162427,
-0.0155393379,
0.0115795666,
0.0343296677,
-0.0160078686,
0.0174697377,
-0.0212860126,
-0.0687731206,
-0.0028792992,
0.0457641706,
-0.0236105788,
-0.0088030444,
-0.0051348843,
0.021877639,
-0.0602034703,
0.024100909,
0.0994177014,
-0.0095570767,
-0.0321859717,
-0.0226974711,
0.0030547597,
-0.0313456431,
0.0105100647,
0.0169855431,
-0.029962603,
-0.0429049209,
0.0219607968,
-0.0089638606,
0.0226182211,
0.0064798594,
-0.0146277715,
-0.1093658507,
-0.0064030243,
0.0341220535,
-0.0151624791,
-0.0114121903,
-0.0135449758,
-0.0055332519,
-0.0079980362,
0.0150843188,
-0.0148093468,
0.0008694868,
-0.0632182211,
0.0269953497,
-0.0238043237,
-0.0391895287,
0.0244712979,
-0.0279416908,
0.0607108697,
0.0529437363,
-0.0069051231,
-0.0360306129,
0.0236204099,
0.084334828,
-0.0242125839,
0.0154034691,
-0.0237122849,
0.0295267664,
-0.0221131761,
-0.010867185,
0.0491243042,
0.0099121146,
-0.0183245726,
0.0086682392,
0.0148928268,
0.0848829299,
-0.014220776,
0.0129385162,
0.0038489904,
0.005529291,
0.0134702092,
0.0509148724,
0.0175366737,
-0.0292543471,
-0.0048322738,
0.038680099,
-0.007929313,
0.0029026426,
0.0008940535,
0.0032763004,
-0.0298096947,
-0.0260577891,
-0.0210309569,
0.01375103,
0.0177394487,
0.0115574952,
0.0423718542,
0.0281078592,
0.0073764767,
0.0166238882,
-0.0368999131,
0.0327893645,
-0.0269173421,
0.0388579331,
-0.0757723674,
-0.0045738094,
0.0518540405,
-0.0729512498,
-0.0316134542,
0.0211258624,
-0.0324534364,
-0.05388394,
0.0088445609,
0.0020127485,
0.0215884857,
0.055494871,
-0.031903863,
-0.0420267023,
0.0848812088,
-0.0043272804,
-0.0404067002,
0.0109579973,
0.0668192208,
-0.0066691204,
-0.0391164683,
0.0126908002,
-0.0623904876,
0.0675686821,
0.0318239033,
-0.0043884204,
-0.022368595,
-0.0846154764,
-0.0220496692,
0.0313354507,
0.0566117689,
-0.0040708911,
0.0157730281,
-0.0606608428,
0.0504211709,
0.0108851846,
0.0580438226,
-0.0587501973,
0.0086563667,
0.0289731435,
0.0316295363,
-0.0088153351,
0.0022363022,
0.0023867295,
-0.0280528571,
-0.0093429843,
0.062163882,
0.0001902299,
0.020498408,
0.0349686854,
0.0037207589,
-0.0124354698,
0.0287028737,
0.0632470101,
0.014750056,
-0.0286468398,
0.0223842598,
-0.0119538419,
0.015267794,
-0.0266835354,
0.0363411903,
-0.027902877,
-0.0607387759,
-0.0281587467,
0.0668957829,
0.0423968509,
-0.033606369,
0.0436956026,
0.0104427943,
0.0093865339,
-0.060331054,
0.0285797194,
-0.0084449761,
0.0107013471,
0.02862476,
-0.0070302458,
-0.0159942191,
0.0285500176,
0.0082433112,
0.0377514325,
0.0582563691,
-0.0181769151,
0.0146647086,
-0.026059771,
-0.0371670984,
0.0140116578,
-0.0149853835,
-0.0521635562,
0.0094501209,
-0.0038925079,
-0.0912809595,
0.0210325252,
-0.0315842107,
0.0100827031,
-0.0409121551,
0.0149278175,
-0.0100970874,
-0.0250223372,
0.0486938842,
0.0261671823,
-0.014958702,
-0.0149930641,
0.0051460629,
0.0340290293,
-6.3271292e-33,
-0.0306706466,
0.0496243611,
0.0014276549,
-0.0038512552,
-0.0401186161,
0.0078987554,
-0.0050705299,
0.0014979899,
-0.0171657111,
-0.0450932235,
-0.0202334207,
0.0087545225,
0.0377964601,
0.0087053962,
-0.0512646437,
-0.0107290428,
0.0813591182,
-0.0099737048,
0.0317227431,
0.0021585687,
0.0102612954,
0.0774644017,
0.0254178885,
-0.0666265413,
-0.0574597232,
-0.007539086,
-0.0030724902,
-0.0051972973,
0.0255774688,
0.0296268482,
-0.0097149415,
0.0412962101,
-0.0063733067,
-0.0303418264,
-0.0256597083,
0.0428072773,
-0.0944433287,
0.0024459229,
-0.0018278639,
0.0420174263,
0.0088116694,
-0.0137396203,
0.0244741887,
0.0194966216,
-0.0133921932,
-0.0274798982,
0.0245148353,
-0.0211493466,
-0.0128086992,
-0.0793002248,
-0.0290682241,
0.0300625972,
0.0062798215,
-0.0195269194,
0.0715188608,
0.0152865546,
-0.0134646622,
0.0121854292,
-0.0587420836,
-0.006288508,
0.0448713936,
-0.0042730835,
0.0607762262,
0.0551800728,
-0.0015683578,
0.0129442476,
0.0099608051,
-0.065421313,
0.0082307663,
-0.0059662433,
0.0620744526,
0.0257981103,
-0.0078022275,
-0.0224281941,
0.0008320308,
-0.0400216244,
-0.0670957789,
-0.0174837224,
0.0111137899,
0.0254808031,
0.0027319391,
0.0107170213,
-0.0085797571,
-0.0012553745,
-0.0724188909,
-0.0268769171,
-0.0334250443,
-0.0099639511,
0.0668400601,
0.0027568855,
-0.0260313936,
-0.0076215728,
0.0747573748,
-0.048849687,
0.0121847922,
0.0160942432,
-0.0040296884,
-0.04304922,
-0.0233811904,
0.0791528746,
-0.0730404481,
-0.0532559939,
-0.0089095645,
0.0016111772,
-0.0142422589,
-0.0489442535,
-0.0085353795,
0.0452371836,
-0.0649601519,
-0.0073702312,
0.0030920755,
0.0109019028,
0.0319448039,
0.0684110522,
0.0535738952,
-0.0118909841,
-0.0003666334,
0.0474371091,
0.0000151678,
0.007260812,
0.0039229323,
-0.0227652304,
0.0467192344,
0.0525463782,
-0.0337393917,
-0.0027167266,
0.0030518686,
-0.0169469416,
0.0456104055,
-0.0454208441,
-0.0044516819,
0.01088023,
2.708e-7,
0.0092593422,
-0.0082492828,
0.0156157129,
-0.00483891,
-0.0026296685,
0.0043484247,
0.0034147855,
0.011335847,
0.0365719721,
0.0217552353,
0.0287665445,
0.0233758185,
0.0658842251,
-0.0245203637,
-0.0896996111,
-0.0236046724,
-0.0156703219,
0.0451274179,
-0.0200486574,
-0.0022561764,
0.0234670974,
0.1001985222,
-0.0214495491,
-0.0273208525,
-0.0175472312,
-0.066435121,
0.0707934499,
-0.0424413346,
0.0089220386,
0.0202596895,
-0.024611637,
0.0065277964,
-0.0461833514,
0.0457820296,
-0.0186994579,
0.0935434774,
0.0238310117,
0.0625579059,
-0.0052310391,
-0.0140262637,
0.0051520192,
0.0426893942,
-0.0151058212,
-0.0023436847,
0.076267913,
-0.0610194318,
-0.0066787223,
-0.0406213515,
-0.0525774993,
-0.0330619887,
0.0071371752,
-0.007611054,
0.0318298675,
0.0153437015,
0.0201391056,
-0.0545148104,
-0.0137574803,
-0.0957574844,
0.0062343162,
0.0090329424,
-0.0553493239,
-0.0013582351,
-0.0345117822,
-0.0054978821,
0.0515172407,
-0.0284611508,
0.0166230015,
2.136228868e-34,
0.0434651598,
-0.0401444919,
0.0063236966,
0.0291502587,
-0.0068179816,
-0.0366699249,
-0.0178461093,
0.033412952,
0.0000855943,
-0.1046998873,
-0.0351407751
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03664v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03664v2 | Generative agent-based modeling with actions grounded in physical, social, or digital space using Concordia | 2023-12-06T18:33:50 | 2023-12-13T20:13:25 | Alexander Sasha Vezhnevets, John P. Agapiou, Avia Aharon, Ron Ziv, Jayd Matyas, Edgar A. Duéñez-Guzmán, William A. Cunningham, Simon Osindero, Danny Karmon, Joel Z. Leibo | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Agent-based modeling has been around for decades, and applied widely across
the social and natural sciences. The scope of this research method is now
poised to grow dramatically as it absorbs the new affordances provided by Large
Language Models (LLM)s. Generative Agent-Based Models (GABM) are not just
classic Agent-Based Models (ABM)s where the agents talk to one another. Rather,
GABMs are constructed using an LLM to apply common sense to situations, act
"reasonably", recall common semantic knowledge, produce API calls to control
digital technologies like apps, and communicate both within the simulation and
to researchers viewing it from the outside. Here we present Concordia, a
library to facilitate constructing and working with GABMs. Concordia makes it
easy to construct language-mediated simulations of physically- or
digitally-grounded environments. Concordia agents produce their behavior using
a flexible component system which mediates between two fundamental operations:
LLM calls and associative memory retrieval. A special agent called the Game
Master (GM), which was inspired by tabletop role-playing games, is responsible
for simulating the environment where the agents interact. Agents take actions
by describing what they want to do in natural language. The GM then translates
their actions into appropriate implementations. In a simulated physical world,
the GM checks the physical plausibility of agent actions and describes their
effects. In digital environments simulating technologies such as apps and
services, the GM may handle API calls to integrate with external tools such as
general AI assistants (e.g., Bard, ChatGPT), and digital apps (e.g., Calendar,
Email, Search, etc.). Concordia was designed to support a wide array of
applications both in scientific research and for evaluating performance of real
digital services by simulating users and/or generating synthetic data. | [
0.0604862981,
0.0245204438,
-0.0509692021,
0.0319586135,
-0.0469533168,
-0.026629651,
0.0306329466,
-0.0249584969,
0.0726792812,
-0.0300242435,
0.0160537865,
-0.0187843665,
-0.0050074561,
0.0529251061,
0.0162081178,
-0.0323751532,
0.029351268,
-0.0004429314,
0.0152187394,
-0.0044106091,
-0.0014450139,
0.0082584424,
-0.0130874487,
0.046752762,
0.0010375965,
-0.0189963393,
-0.0412568599,
0.0072437464,
0.0104606496,
-0.022470979,
-0.0093323952,
0.0110021336,
0.0530412272,
0.0304981619,
0.0000023401,
-0.0689875484,
0.0200999044,
0.0097796479,
-0.0028770047,
-0.0202011503,
0.0735665336,
0.0234882142,
0.0002417573,
-0.0001723206,
-0.076273948,
-0.0279232319,
0.0584358014,
-0.0184368566,
0.0201079976,
0.0325961746,
-0.022972174,
-0.0162597485,
-0.0085170995,
0.0423096083,
-0.0024975301,
-0.0132712033,
0.0056134365,
0.0428409353,
0.0992512852,
0.0163848214,
0.009222582,
0.0066317576,
0.0189424399,
0.0080456603,
0.0034707075,
0.0738619715,
0.0128683075,
-0.0069668544,
-0.0418262035,
0.0209350791,
0.0657385886,
-0.0320462957,
0.0794316605,
0.0104184542,
0.0016912997,
0.0313152522,
-0.0319699869,
0.0254720505,
0.0014045986,
-0.0147634083,
-0.0097656026,
0.019164728,
0.0235279966,
0.0161827859,
0.0130048785,
0.0666246712,
-0.001554469,
-0.0099575324,
-0.0686053634,
-0.0199566148,
0.0638318881,
-0.0588400923,
-0.0080225049,
0.0595532991,
-0.0564474463,
0.013072026,
-0.0300417077,
0.0267742518,
0.0138028916,
-0.0233767983,
0.0423821509,
0.0377546921,
0.0357892998,
0.0495969392,
0.0377109535,
0.0436461307,
-0.0088102212,
0.0030443443,
-0.0059836884,
0.0326341465,
-0.0658828914,
-0.0268786419,
-0.0254352354,
0.0272067636,
-0.0304876789,
-0.0499133319,
0.0078645069,
0.0462884754,
-0.0334857963,
0.0347146913,
-0.0431811772,
0.0360167399,
-0.010294158,
-0.000666093,
-0.0519112945,
-0.0236330014,
-0.049025178,
0.0129070636,
0.0258965269,
-0.0842979476,
0.0159818642,
-0.0332944952,
0.0078788614,
0.0153276641,
-0.0039168615,
0.0778262988,
0.016486099,
-0.0181533769,
-0.009743901,
-0.0504682176,
0.0529462807,
-0.0727800876,
-0.0044713598,
-0.0762118772,
0.0544778407,
-0.0001886141,
-0.0006265294,
-0.0536336042,
0.0095230062,
-0.0047551449,
-0.0011482476,
0.0713845044,
0.0166833997,
0.0215986054,
0.0616586544,
0.0282952376,
-0.0065538869,
0.0509027541,
0.0471307859,
-0.0032670004,
0.0252179187,
0.0288471282,
0.0492020287,
0.0257391743,
-0.0158317201,
-0.0238878634,
0.0271753371,
-0.0173587073,
-0.0082053347,
0.0491285287,
-0.035866525,
0.0228740927,
-0.0399585776,
0.0096624875,
0.0921435952,
0.0801388398,
-0.0519370958,
0.0482401066,
0.0540447459,
0.0279675387,
-0.023538297,
-0.043178834,
-0.0242469199,
0.0611840896,
0.0076039191,
0.0020312013,
-0.0335657261,
0.0613134354,
-0.0282874834,
-0.0263030715,
0.0178453047,
-0.0061993473,
0.0630429238,
0.0042098267,
0.0168951824,
-0.0088850185,
-0.0270176381,
-0.0076783663,
-0.0213837959,
-0.0561340153,
-0.0098909205,
-0.0865197256,
0.0525643863,
0.1090571955,
0.0747979656,
-0.0426379554,
-0.0225522798,
0.0163476747,
0.000473638,
0.0542713702,
0.014693399,
-0.0089593148,
-0.0201573577,
-0.0231236573,
-0.0133313881,
-0.0129952626,
0.0302165095,
0.0533697978,
0.002440366,
0.0064932313,
-0.0065291775,
0.0161471497,
-0.0043766713,
0.0136009688,
-0.0253114775,
-0.0374505669,
-0.046719227,
-0.0028565039,
0.037691731,
0.015219884,
-0.0043775644,
-0.0062276893,
0.0311379768,
-0.0080439355,
-0.0401438624,
0.0412506051,
0.0274419356,
0.0581430607,
0.0301041752,
-0.005832545,
0.0441972166,
0.0279220864,
-0.0132033713,
-0.0299012158,
0.0557698086,
0.0182901323,
0.0792351365,
-0.0123291286,
-0.0004313853,
-0.0177606903,
-0.0078872489,
0.0236288011,
0.0285181534,
0.0222251453,
-0.0287131332,
-0.0141824307,
0.0341065526,
0.0077401404,
-0.033350762,
0.015013447,
0.0026502088,
-0.0123207672,
0.053780023,
0.026394248,
-0.0222388078,
-0.038794931,
0.0006910751,
-0.0757257268,
0.0040180078,
-0.0112429215,
-0.0195113514,
0.0153533043,
0.0167666189,
-0.0230847113,
0.00815304,
-0.0000065958,
0.0439866856,
0.0127709946,
0.0229384396,
0.0020698232,
-0.0120192934,
-0.0393493436,
-0.0144263292,
0.0330203548,
-0.0162107609,
0.0273744389,
0.0207173806,
0.0199505389,
-0.0546513535,
-0.0126442863,
-0.0621889345,
0.0147643462,
-0.0329789482,
-0.0476175845,
0.0567750931,
-0.0431011431,
0.0151444711,
0.0395217277,
-0.0579633228,
0.05293677,
0.0408388823,
-0.0648667663,
-0.0590095147,
0.0240664724,
-0.0196444429,
0.0090938145,
-0.0369155817,
-0.0323098786,
0.0201052595,
0.0644405633,
-0.0020765583,
0.007647024,
-0.0289883018,
0.0333366729,
-0.0179313105,
-0.0513881966,
0.0273348782,
0.0029448874,
-0.0336952582,
0.0426429026,
-0.0139844194,
-0.0116799772,
0.0575098582,
-0.0246201456,
-0.0043639489,
-0.0189825892,
-0.0175148603,
0.007230592,
0.1059313491,
-0.0061797979,
0.0063978946,
0.01675318,
0.0120452773,
-0.0100357942,
-0.0136945499,
0.047968097,
-0.0348754413,
-0.0164528005,
-0.0921365693,
0.0062635411,
0.0348558836,
0.0046158126,
-0.0039192494,
0.0441751964,
-0.0522319935,
0.0122738108,
-0.0466414057,
-0.009015182,
-0.0810159519,
0.0047206022,
0.0220635328,
0.0312592611,
0.0056647467,
-0.0350672491,
-0.0436135978,
-0.0346015431,
0.0423804708,
0.025323933,
-0.0499330759,
0.0285984594,
-0.0072595924,
0.0328312255,
-0.0106353574,
-0.0731040463,
-0.0433801711,
-0.0195128191,
0.0441863872,
-0.0054298108,
0.0045535951,
0.074709408,
0.0218436699,
-0.0498398244,
-0.0511901714,
0.0843362287,
0.0278704204,
-0.0208003968,
0.0081077516,
-0.0320092551,
0.0026122569,
0.0126397666,
0.0452307425,
-0.0496195778,
-0.0028147101,
0.0030629127,
-0.0148281371,
-0.0121822497,
-0.0357249603,
0.0138258301,
-0.0830339119,
0.0610058196,
-0.0086453902,
-0.0213117786,
-0.0129554421,
-0.0402751677,
0.0134724639,
0.0016560095,
-0.0233805925,
-0.0114501603,
0.0441797525,
-0.0169446357,
-0.0283320025,
-0.0362191759,
-0.0178879425,
0.011824945,
-0.050801795,
0.0879244432,
0.0685045794,
0.0600118563,
0.0050492608,
-0.0370767303,
-0.0611867718,
0.0432922095,
0.0237855837,
-0.0092634847,
-0.0364493877,
0.0119975759,
0.0276546888,
0.0026320082,
0.0448832326,
-0.0473799743,
-0.0601943322,
0.0227694903,
0.0728974789,
-0.0288651958,
-0.0289364364,
-0.0600636713,
0.0090914518,
0.0676535442,
0.0360830799,
-0.0131025771,
-0.0197885614,
-0.0566471294,
-0.0327061936,
-0.0108295269,
0.0223386157,
-0.0560358353,
-0.0190383028,
0.0197345037,
-0.0458004065,
-0.0475667529,
-0.0343177654,
0.0006905932,
0.0092722345,
0.01392275,
-0.0293894392,
0.0600020215,
0.0176895466,
-0.0137917101,
-0.0387412496,
-0.0320551395,
0.0244223122,
0.0353561267,
-0.0381738991,
0.038707599,
-0.068019256,
0.0062779896,
0.0252258386,
-0.0265265834,
-0.0507232063,
0.0220130831,
0.0952710435,
0.0294219237,
0.0112412181,
-0.0064591751,
-0.0095649213,
0.0172345005,
0.0485776104,
-0.0770381466,
0.0229974743,
0.0039654453,
-0.0017441098,
0.0100868167,
-0.0075349812,
-0.0604360029,
0.0309635326,
-0.0238935128,
0.0566813238,
-0.0481989346,
-0.0041276151,
0.0042318967,
-0.0254666526,
-0.0017751539,
-0.0078856051,
-0.0062413667,
-0.0046622027,
-0.004853793,
-0.0518898144,
0.000411842,
-0.0213301834,
-0.0286403205,
-0.0372123048,
0.0313936993,
0.0416914299,
-0.0207428709,
-0.0266683474,
0.0120491618,
0.0098058097,
-0.004376241,
0.0147667341,
0.0211747885,
0.0037968156,
0.0118433181,
-0.015134952,
0.0134680532,
-0.0458331555,
0.0454972535,
-0.0076046595,
0.0462727249,
0.0166893415,
-0.027583342,
-0.0369635932,
0.0216953531,
-0.0392639041,
-0.0554691069,
0.0338166133,
0.0807386413,
0.0429265425,
0.0093832836,
0.0106638065,
-0.0901686773,
0.0225616824,
-0.0042225206,
0.0008083575,
0.0281784944,
-0.0813035667,
-0.0253032595,
0.0425450988,
-0.0095926989,
-0.0294740442,
0.0381319933,
-0.0385480411,
0.0474084727,
-0.0137374578,
-0.0457806475,
-0.0410375819,
-0.0559062809,
-0.0029214213,
0.0215324126,
-0.0245123338,
-0.0433723629,
-0.0932195336,
-0.0250043515,
-0.0063866968,
0.0698364154,
-0.0150040966,
-0.0711239204,
0.028387066,
0.0457240604,
0.0168305226,
-0.0161749478,
-0.0275681298,
0.0079009263,
-0.1083726883,
-0.0063251862,
-0.0529116094,
-6.143919589e-33,
-0.0052888691,
-0.0256892685,
0.079712458,
0.0219739806,
-0.0109162377,
-0.0205673594,
-0.0572797395,
-0.0361100286,
0.0234060585,
0.017242603,
-0.0181562174,
-0.0096649798,
0.0043154284,
0.0008833379,
0.0272062197,
-0.0177914891,
0.0259917434,
-0.0184502583,
-0.0333577469,
0.030872358,
0.0043989155,
-0.0070193447,
-0.0290768128,
-0.0782366619,
0.0164105818,
-0.0429344699,
-0.0029545247,
-0.0206911545,
-0.0383377001,
0.0244530179,
-0.0356896222,
0.022051027,
0.0128913615,
-0.0140264221,
0.0149824619,
0.0231229607,
-0.0575668812,
-0.015454459,
0.0123481601,
0.0027038055,
-0.0201027766,
-0.0167560186,
-0.0261555482,
0.0082767019,
-0.0534424484,
0.0220186356,
0.0459844135,
-0.0168494824,
-0.0430004522,
-0.0237634219,
-0.1009829715,
-0.0164341126,
-0.0067587905,
-0.0165101606,
-0.0156401321,
-0.0098594595,
-0.0133570628,
0.0145633938,
-0.0540680923,
0.0428987257,
-0.0150888981,
-0.0429180562,
0.05420864,
0.0137949055,
0.0658027083,
0.0470842198,
0.0016352055,
0.0222603418,
-0.0712275282,
-0.0029208192,
0.0196600575,
0.04213636,
0.001501719,
0.0868498161,
-0.0200535711,
-0.0280608684,
-0.0153001528,
0.022761222,
0.0493067987,
0.0218545999,
0.0579872988,
0.0363016762,
-0.0307575576,
0.0022627534,
0.011108838,
0.0100530488,
-0.0041905539,
-0.0492656343,
0.0152581194,
0.0019657242,
-0.0243273713,
-0.0546081811,
0.0038270196,
-0.046357017,
-0.0376440659,
-0.0186242498,
0.0339982845,
0.0200625658,
-0.0179675296,
0.0071463855,
-0.0166112259,
-0.0454758629,
-0.0173732024,
0.0118985204,
0.0368004739,
0.0348827429,
-0.0291920993,
0.0713883862,
0.0206597578,
0.0065685934,
-0.0411584936,
0.0213256869,
0.0284984633,
-0.0510762222,
-0.004293086,
-0.0102528343,
0.0010373144,
0.0268847961,
-0.0002927756,
-0.0198816396,
-0.0013275783,
0.0053258897,
-0.0266427193,
-0.0249638949,
-0.0495335534,
-0.0034945435,
-0.1185471341,
0.0343588032,
0.0428870916,
-0.0114870165,
-0.0203162003,
0.0004838294,
3.195e-7,
-0.0344442576,
0.025963679,
-0.0066538751,
0.0116413692,
0.0420337617,
0.0525790378,
0.0073346994,
0.047839269,
0.016405968,
-0.0209788419,
0.0333303995,
0.0460327528,
0.0363761634,
0.0050405064,
-0.1105229408,
0.016413603,
-0.0166464914,
-0.0296280645,
-0.0546483435,
-0.0069758794,
0.0336133875,
0.004552946,
0.0595851541,
0.0245176535,
0.0040313751,
-0.0312748626,
0.0043976586,
-0.0519267172,
0.0494912863,
0.0039335978,
-0.0178085305,
0.009127724,
-0.0278944839,
-0.0205644164,
-0.0103151351,
0.0022112639,
-0.0383633412,
0.0587652102,
-0.0260299593,
0.0037203515,
-0.006710527,
-0.0588737503,
0.0061777355,
-0.056158822,
0.027515607,
-0.0678608268,
0.0004166384,
0.0102701494,
-0.0524179637,
-0.0123772928,
-0.0568661019,
-0.0176507495,
-0.0316693746,
-0.0084758662,
-0.029579455,
-0.0052357283,
0.0091027701,
-0.0533671752,
0.0292549543,
-0.0021505749,
-0.013613156,
-0.0424186476,
-0.0170879569,
-0.0108997682,
0.0195883531,
-0.0459623635,
0.0214703549,
2.75880764e-34,
-0.0026126716,
0.0280386489,
-0.0138820214,
0.0410072617,
0.044931367,
0.0212232377,
0.029675493,
0.0447076187,
0.0599480867,
-0.0364001133,
-0.0173264742
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03813v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03813v1 | Improving Activation Steering in Language Models with Mean-Centring | 2023-12-06T18:27:07 | 2023-12-06T18:27:07 | Ole Jorgensen, Dylan Cope, Nandi Schoots, Murray Shanahan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Recent work in activation steering has demonstrated the potential to better
control the outputs of Large Language Models (LLMs), but it involves finding
steering vectors. This is difficult because engineers do not typically know how
features are represented in these models. We seek to address this issue by
applying the idea of mean-centring to steering vectors. We find that taking the
average of activations associated with a target dataset, and then subtracting
the mean of all training activations, results in effective steering vectors. We
test this method on a variety of models on natural language tasks by steering
away from generating toxic text, and steering the completion of a story towards
a target genre. We also apply mean-centring to extract function vectors, more
effectively triggering the execution of a range of natural language tasks by a
significant margin (compared to previous baselines). This suggests that
mean-centring can be used to easily improve the effectiveness of activation
steering in a wide range of contexts. | [
0.0433822609,
0.0119248535,
-0.0223430041,
0.0475975126,
-0.018082438,
0.0182959381,
-0.0225202776,
-0.0357281975,
0.0037253851,
-0.0295724068,
-0.0435766168,
-0.0243602432,
-0.0409785919,
0.0746991783,
0.0013255924,
-0.0253940225,
0.010893614,
-0.0237092022,
0.0033045174,
0.0076919105,
0.0219836272,
0.0322287716,
0.0042067403,
0.0609773807,
-0.0020897086,
-0.0394797064,
0.0407857709,
0.0190056767,
0.0296219047,
0.0155417612,
0.0569090284,
0.0115026934,
0.016268814,
0.0347679853,
0.0000018482,
-0.0191470273,
-0.0066535203,
-0.0345373005,
0.0092663085,
-0.0135954572,
0.0833487138,
0.009302943,
-0.0200828128,
0.0018104081,
0.0110187326,
0.0014656687,
0.0392305702,
0.0798289254,
0.0282924492,
0.0598390326,
-0.0088304989,
-0.0159340017,
0.0006748558,
-0.015097294,
0.0217680689,
-0.0146757048,
-0.0027570447,
-0.0103427153,
-0.0356594883,
0.0137549862,
-0.0387676172,
0.0535695851,
0.0276719052,
-0.0173987951,
0.0353792906,
0.0601144023,
0.0100295898,
-0.0226515308,
-0.0130734686,
0.057786461,
-0.0536127761,
-0.0539835915,
0.0006967739,
-0.0279381834,
-0.0076186196,
-0.0039495672,
-0.0535762198,
0.0084156124,
0.0114946524,
0.0241638683,
0.0212413501,
0.0057508727,
0.04486214,
0.0355010368,
0.0137922736,
0.0359760076,
0.0144981081,
-0.0283337031,
0.0366553441,
0.0127979862,
-0.0136369662,
-0.0058899028,
0.0289190896,
-0.0318043418,
-0.0041942247,
0.0321046934,
-0.0305534806,
-0.0286156684,
0.0050483025,
-0.0683769286,
-0.0034412865,
0.0197075326,
-0.0255342405,
0.0428657942,
-0.0121265296,
0.0441975929,
-0.0155872861,
0.0300211441,
-0.040406242,
0.0086992141,
-0.0210962556,
-0.0250512604,
-0.0063906452,
-0.0026232256,
-0.0133831389,
-0.0320011228,
-0.0379848965,
0.0312262159,
-0.0166574009,
-0.0460533798,
-0.0181626622,
0.0563207641,
-0.0549206808,
0.0018367933,
0.015929902,
0.0221396852,
-0.0441447198,
0.0186605863,
-0.0167912114,
0.0007373784,
0.0036988554,
0.0323341154,
-0.0104809748,
-0.0493965596,
0.012119039,
0.0392385349,
-0.0143248662,
-0.0229585711,
-0.0773579404,
-0.0315923095,
-0.0234494563,
-0.0386084281,
-0.0086433375,
-0.0595166422,
0.0061775194,
0.0265750475,
0.0001677831,
-0.0241236631,
-0.0092386464,
0.0134653384,
-0.0580559149,
0.0433038101,
0.0640520006,
-0.0194388721,
0.0434834361,
0.0150756408,
-0.0215417072,
0.0766336694,
0.0277075972,
0.0627089366,
0.0436126627,
0.0203727204,
0.036846038,
0.0547111593,
0.0280866865,
0.0213182177,
0.0011257321,
-0.0367235243,
-0.0190336443,
0.0423859954,
0.0823428705,
0.0352394059,
-0.0241270699,
-0.0151942037,
0.083923012,
0.0692207143,
-0.0006166487,
0.0018101238,
0.0571018346,
-0.0073214443,
-0.0525892638,
0.0213202257,
-0.0657895654,
0.0306815952,
-0.0399740413,
-0.0081568174,
-0.0097398683,
0.0248909947,
-0.0164762307,
-0.018508967,
0.0244252738,
-0.0011534296,
0.0271287169,
0.006588731,
0.0330577567,
0.027071489,
-0.0112997079,
-0.0024835479,
0.0113267312,
-0.0532756113,
0.0437843725,
-0.0284026861,
0.0091489656,
0.0097806193,
0.0501228385,
-0.0187773164,
-0.0449683368,
-0.0259940643,
0.0496419892,
0.0511607006,
0.0073500234,
-0.0332816467,
-0.0087474585,
-0.039443735,
-0.0235451851,
-0.0039912928,
0.0050534909,
-0.0075757965,
-0.0095593696,
0.0002930394,
-0.0087767569,
-0.0531884544,
-0.0770161897,
0.0380271152,
-0.0190326162,
-0.0478090718,
-0.0141741252,
0.0173383188,
0.0246352479,
-0.0131060248,
-0.031753514,
-0.0073012379,
0.0106154131,
-0.0143357152,
-0.0526138321,
0.0540592559,
-0.0055335453,
0.0033327104,
0.0161734652,
-0.058909636,
-0.0185694974,
0.0291046556,
-0.0087612383,
-0.0167899877,
0.0350267962,
-0.0340651721,
0.0324532911,
-0.0073856055,
0.0239068475,
-0.0150898658,
-0.0210744217,
-0.0326787643,
0.05501917,
-0.0119726602,
0.0251323972,
0.0020840459,
-0.0254408959,
-0.0265483297,
0.0084353425,
-0.0153464302,
0.0236205161,
0.0335479602,
0.0106572425,
0.0651334822,
-0.0226989631,
-0.0318132639,
-0.0217410922,
-0.0738366321,
-0.0057079401,
-0.0522582866,
0.0190455485,
0.0541393422,
-0.0004213123,
-0.0128772398,
0.0121538732,
-0.0240250304,
-0.0240415186,
-0.0238465145,
0.0337505601,
-0.0150354858,
-0.0173697714,
-0.0125392415,
-0.0365615338,
-0.0011550917,
-0.01201603,
0.0484560132,
0.0097104041,
0.001077612,
-0.0137971612,
-0.0054361736,
-0.0190403443,
0.0260439292,
-0.0336225182,
-0.0412713513,
0.0012993328,
0.0130615076,
0.0435136221,
0.0747324452,
0.008426372,
0.0659399033,
0.0542221479,
0.0111685032,
-0.0545988902,
0.0145299099,
-0.0274894163,
-0.0184711218,
-0.0445234776,
-0.036139302,
0.0278212614,
0.0678842887,
0.0447225459,
0.0110609867,
-0.0352443643,
-0.0353098772,
-0.0300402083,
-0.0448854268,
-0.0353035554,
-0.0072539048,
-0.0391364321,
0.0227292925,
-0.0383380167,
-0.0619411469,
0.0768394694,
0.0102044474,
-0.0214055721,
-0.0556934252,
-0.0112372553,
-0.0058468804,
0.0622047447,
-0.0012766445,
0.0423563533,
-0.0022418473,
-0.0362738818,
-0.0550219864,
-0.0015782421,
0.0417920165,
-0.0242727417,
0.0899356976,
-0.0273462608,
0.0089691719,
0.0380431749,
-0.0309390351,
-0.0307249706,
-0.0520281829,
-0.0110085327,
-0.0300277453,
0.0223654862,
-0.0227145124,
-0.0419364944,
-0.0061647352,
0.0301750265,
0.0348482579,
-0.0202433057,
-0.0175195076,
0.0200993475,
-0.0056709144,
0.0928359851,
-0.0205139928,
-0.012279314,
-0.032596264,
0.0113698225,
0.0627527609,
-0.009023645,
-0.0229276251,
-0.0373172574,
0.033567261,
0.0486359373,
-0.0205620434,
-0.0379084051,
-0.0070128571,
0.0436071679,
-0.0426431596,
-0.0385390967,
0.0862489268,
0.0140899494,
-0.0486224927,
0.0031646113,
0.020822823,
0.0426193215,
0.0363142043,
0.0022611618,
-0.0337368436,
-0.0247143656,
-0.0109597426,
0.0545905307,
-0.0077787242,
-0.0059017455,
0.0098437555,
-0.1049234867,
0.0344642438,
0.0217859857,
-0.0593197681,
-0.0554193333,
-0.0198284537,
0.0072478577,
-0.0283096153,
0.0273905378,
-0.0043946593,
-0.0009320165,
-0.0227019321,
-0.0180748142,
0.0299864169,
-0.0203679688,
0.0209252555,
-0.0613186359,
0.0491427183,
0.0699914023,
0.0441987179,
-0.0036375013,
-0.0121875368,
0.0458324365,
-0.0422132835,
0.0162733626,
-0.0051085642,
0.0591415167,
-0.0385827124,
0.0074745598,
-0.0149874603,
0.0599027909,
0.008886775,
-0.0100297155,
-0.0359596983,
0.099921979,
-0.0222708341,
-0.0679732263,
-0.06154982,
0.0306889266,
0.0289022997,
0.0743848085,
0.0249416959,
-0.0576404594,
0.0001215483,
-0.0436769463,
0.0095979748,
-0.0225610565,
-0.0818008706,
-0.0424640626,
-0.0203878768,
-0.0242865272,
-0.0604055971,
-0.0393717214,
0.0567223951,
0.0356057733,
0.0097507965,
0.0133135691,
-0.0242892783,
-0.0308769457,
0.0020757585,
0.0494840965,
-0.0131425951,
0.0060491962,
-0.0320473649,
0.0067397798,
0.0312873125,
-0.0492584854,
-0.0225242302,
0.0300212484,
-0.066022113,
-0.1089231372,
-0.0066716243,
0.0279394686,
0.0209228303,
0.059732642,
-0.0215724744,
-0.1103344858,
0.0364938788,
0.0263646394,
-0.032044746,
0.0228939503,
0.0191567745,
0.0148916673,
-0.0208650995,
0.040180821,
-0.0629868507,
0.0301063489,
0.0604573861,
0.0273748003,
-0.0317191482,
0.0142211011,
0.006803988,
-0.0236572791,
0.0849853009,
-0.0364525653,
-0.0108167334,
-0.0849798098,
-0.0381125435,
0.0169172212,
-0.0552488603,
-0.0148814963,
0.0612802468,
0.0458793826,
0.0125636682,
-0.0651673526,
0.0347084776,
-0.0264562611,
0.0093022315,
-0.0792742074,
-0.0137806712,
-0.0084909825,
-0.0158339646,
0.0250254478,
0.0416365899,
-0.0201910604,
0.0400373004,
0.0027664013,
0.01734831,
0.0224594865,
0.0265447646,
0.0546115562,
0.0260001551,
-0.0165449623,
0.0022335637,
-0.0758606866,
-0.0118444404,
-0.0282136891,
0.0007752742,
0.0682362616,
-0.0316679254,
0.0741073787,
-0.0149136493,
-0.0233278405,
-0.0156714544,
-0.0028128128,
0.0229707137,
-0.0052841622,
0.0240923092,
0.0253764577,
0.005689417,
-0.001373479,
0.041233547,
-0.0484693944,
0.0564929806,
0.0221337471,
-0.008133552,
-0.0183068737,
-0.0042081689,
0.0282887612,
0.0098906085,
-0.0151765598,
0.016260324,
-0.0531311929,
-0.0620385632,
0.0386349,
-0.0278106146,
0.0092955474,
-0.0468912646,
0.0460828207,
0.0699645057,
-0.0002639666,
0.0046397834,
-0.0285860188,
-0.0304566175,
-0.0050937915,
-0.0202397462,
-0.0778362826,
-6.240803834e-33,
0.0067555858,
-0.0069363457,
0.0001279664,
0.0551172793,
-0.0259528346,
-0.0113273254,
-0.0204435419,
0.0349170342,
-0.0015266865,
0.0445221066,
0.0088063562,
0.0322696567,
0.0067701195,
-0.0088494113,
-0.0026512768,
-0.0176371317,
0.0479499996,
-0.0420602895,
-0.0652151108,
0.0310862567,
0.0445124395,
0.0293766912,
0.065250583,
-0.1029191986,
0.0223086532,
0.0056443894,
-0.0237321723,
0.0260568336,
-0.0014616705,
0.0469386317,
0.0011890199,
0.0745362937,
0.0268510003,
-0.0258746762,
-0.0080794562,
0.0019125311,
-0.0252219811,
-0.0125244483,
0.0350354351,
0.0100204479,
-0.0288264062,
-0.037246082,
0.0980665982,
-0.0067982213,
-0.0318644829,
-0.0317639038,
0.054350704,
-0.0016968563,
-0.0029692359,
-0.0555078872,
-0.0975932181,
0.0025320488,
-0.0099791549,
-0.0335776992,
0.0324551761,
0.0105176689,
0.0260170083,
0.0270857085,
-0.0550018735,
0.0037230251,
-0.0442451797,
0.0392615199,
0.0608658381,
0.0423542708,
-0.0022457689,
0.0778951347,
0.0177895036,
0.026327854,
-0.0520135313,
0.0267503895,
0.0574509166,
-0.0232578516,
0.033362329,
0.0255668256,
0.0582734942,
-0.0161807295,
-0.0137410015,
0.0118030757,
-0.0085363854,
0.0282795876,
0.0276600569,
0.0160582606,
-0.0523005798,
-0.0268556103,
-0.0448971577,
-0.0564179122,
-0.0350741446,
-0.0240780581,
0.0269127917,
0.024106238,
-0.0329492986,
-0.0083416076,
0.0036879329,
-0.0063842852,
0.0087894257,
0.0551529005,
-0.001504287,
0.0383095071,
0.0047948686,
0.0066451333,
-0.0512878895,
0.0195201635,
-0.0114789288,
-0.0282646343,
0.0256748646,
-0.00099379,
0.0128720701,
0.0385602824,
-0.0396723561,
-0.00134549,
-0.0495185666,
-0.0009294709,
0.0114370789,
0.0665958375,
0.0233031455,
-0.0154281631,
-0.0152244447,
0.0104945516,
0.0076036714,
0.0090093799,
-0.0277703293,
-0.0142913423,
-0.0324314497,
-0.007622302,
-0.0577824302,
-0.0238870122,
-0.0044011022,
-0.0034977088,
0.058238674,
-0.1048111767,
-0.0404095314,
0.0004934461,
2.635e-7,
0.0434947796,
0.0293409191,
0.0203710254,
0.0760701448,
-0.0102084232,
0.0301427078,
-0.0051400107,
0.0199161582,
0.0757656172,
-0.0504286513,
-0.0147599941,
0.0181099717,
0.0270115752,
0.0186864622,
-0.1063024774,
0.0198928639,
-0.0626576021,
0.0520035997,
-0.0097371889,
-0.0508073717,
0.0148353241,
0.096485734,
0.0333165154,
-0.0287598502,
0.031489227,
-0.043173302,
0.0480274446,
-0.0284460951,
0.0100204116,
0.0249023661,
0.0078532984,
0.0346286707,
-0.0433555879,
0.0143686878,
-0.0267838798,
0.014551877,
0.0094005438,
0.038826786,
-0.0027831749,
-0.0351370163,
-0.023890717,
-0.0149566829,
0.0087923603,
-0.0220562983,
0.0508436449,
-0.034303166,
0.019915197,
-0.045565702,
0.0105358185,
0.0013809524,
0.0261526406,
-0.0519378856,
-0.0331447758,
0.0027572059,
0.0243145656,
0.0123858051,
-0.0167010073,
-0.086353898,
-0.0304315537,
0.0561407581,
-0.0378240794,
-0.0543499887,
-0.0122322459,
0.0604412109,
-0.0058902376,
-0.0615421198,
-0.016342612,
2.544985907e-34,
0.0328337699,
-0.0396159515,
0.0165116917,
0.02489358,
0.0145345526,
0.0093456674,
0.0471029729,
-0.0275088176,
0.0158131439,
-0.0439677089,
-0.0395742394
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03656v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03656v2 | Interpretability Illusions in the Generalization of Simplified Models | 2023-12-06T18:25:53 | 2024-06-05T15:03:37 | Dan Friedman, Andrew Lampinen, Lucas Dixon, Danqi Chen, Asma Ghandeharioun | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | A common method to study deep learning systems is to use simplified model
representations--for example, using singular value decomposition to visualize
the model's hidden states in a lower dimensional space. This approach assumes
that the results of these simplifications are faithful to the original model.
Here, we illustrate an important caveat to this assumption: even if the
simplified representations can accurately approximate the full model on the
training set, they may fail to accurately capture the model's behavior out of
distribution. We illustrate this by training Transformer models on controlled
datasets with systematic generalization splits, including the Dyck
balanced-parenthesis languages and a code completion task. We simplify these
models using tools like dimensionality reduction and clustering, and then
explicitly test how these simplified proxies match the behavior of the original
model. We find consistent generalization gaps: cases in which the simplified
proxies are more faithful to the original model on the in-distribution
evaluations and less faithful on various tests of systematic generalization.
This includes cases where the original model generalizes systematically but the
simplified proxies fail, and cases where the simplified proxies generalize
better. Together, our results raise questions about the extent to which
mechanistic interpretations derived using tools like SVD can reliably predict
what a model will do in novel situations. | [
-0.0569809601,
0.0625822097,
-0.0352570601,
0.0213710796,
-0.0024563062,
0.0299231913,
0.0203680154,
0.0012911196,
-0.069142133,
0.0412471555,
-0.0064735808,
0.0128519898,
0.0314812809,
0.0276142843,
0.0359752849,
-0.0502800159,
0.0600931272,
-0.0449587367,
-0.0643977448,
-0.0393590331,
-0.0362651125,
-0.0449549742,
0.0039502201,
0.0691330358,
0.0127619449,
-0.0233673472,
-0.0108640958,
-0.0026572312,
-0.0203465689,
0.0490783639,
-0.0390569083,
0.0189602468,
0.0584482178,
0.0454906859,
0.0000022259,
0.0035463318,
-0.0089817718,
0.0120115886,
-0.0465741232,
0.0592042729,
0.0024972048,
-0.0803689584,
0.0084487488,
-0.0217486154,
-0.00495518,
-0.0500011742,
0.0620018505,
-0.0039013552,
0.0013615518,
0.0081099775,
0.0054420764,
-0.0496221632,
0.0216487367,
0.0137659525,
0.0053966418,
0.0094607053,
-0.0106139435,
0.000946308,
-0.0267686825,
-0.029570248,
-0.0367568843,
0.0228101593,
0.0636147186,
0.0247224513,
0.0130731184,
0.0309522822,
-0.0000489455,
0.0038047,
0.0378272943,
0.0015805002,
-0.0498721525,
-0.0261354949,
-0.0250530038,
-0.0084924642,
0.0104794689,
0.0261006188,
-0.0575477704,
0.0098969834,
0.0192914922,
0.0375926718,
-0.0331597663,
-0.007737888,
0.0664471835,
-0.0491763763,
-0.053190466,
0.0735705793,
0.0059506958,
0.0085854093,
-0.0619594902,
0.0089845126,
-0.0345585495,
0.0113236066,
0.0020929596,
0.0106533607,
0.039659515,
-0.0037094648,
-0.0316691175,
-0.0468021072,
-0.0171336737,
-0.012225708,
0.0744028986,
0.0466160215,
-0.0289292466,
-0.0049339491,
-0.0288245343,
0.0630333349,
-0.073804982,
0.0631837398,
-0.0292514805,
0.0405935422,
-0.041149877,
-0.020076286,
0.0144333364,
0.0456718281,
0.0002443153,
0.0118232993,
-0.0448421985,
-0.0110296756,
-0.0407932028,
0.0086392425,
-0.0187674575,
0.0212083757,
-0.0365291275,
0.0234552808,
-0.0105456812,
0.0496646352,
-0.0434737988,
0.0206369814,
-0.0111073237,
-0.0276682843,
-0.0379349701,
-0.0106613645,
-0.0091467835,
0.0022733456,
-0.0005748722,
0.0469311737,
-0.0030928792,
0.0301060956,
-0.0415705368,
-0.0174758621,
-0.0265870392,
-0.000088078,
0.0624032766,
-0.0569916517,
0.0225548968,
0.0166144446,
0.0205682125,
-0.0719609261,
-0.0305617992,
-0.0265164319,
0.0059306761,
0.0746952072,
-0.004634399,
-0.0215632673,
-0.0101553109,
0.0054267221,
-0.0409885347,
0.0226687342,
0.0240669828,
0.0281680655,
-0.0031102935,
-0.0608179681,
0.0552000552,
0.0159362946,
0.0191543642,
0.0050664986,
-0.0311464369,
-0.0374134369,
-0.0324655138,
-0.0190063063,
0.0502790995,
0.0234174877,
-0.0399523191,
-0.0392356962,
-0.0013020989,
0.0515549742,
0.0232949127,
0.0739624798,
0.0632193461,
0.0149219977,
-0.0063704243,
0.0692718029,
-0.061263904,
0.003929507,
-0.0250185039,
-0.0125075141,
-0.0577195957,
-0.0006833145,
-0.034967456,
-0.0844169483,
-0.0031940788,
-0.0153219337,
0.0277386103,
-0.0175428893,
0.0800457895,
-0.0084121646,
-0.0015208843,
0.0681848973,
0.0227061436,
-0.0433292799,
0.0144469859,
-0.0529492609,
0.0030510703,
0.0089317225,
0.0129179936,
-0.038871415,
0.0030605968,
-0.0037066792,
-0.0593496822,
-0.0633851364,
-0.0058946386,
-0.0018291174,
0.0287207793,
0.001925785,
-0.0246439315,
-0.0313634463,
0.0291970689,
0.013477426,
-0.034222912,
-0.0786772147,
0.0058488292,
-0.0831683278,
-0.0190238953,
0.0200154427,
0.0192089491,
-0.0208769552,
0.0257578213,
0.0141492169,
0.0300039984,
-0.0070771379,
-0.02307727,
0.0023511776,
0.0317501538,
-0.0200385805,
-0.0169972554,
-0.0035363438,
-0.0729238167,
-0.0403651148,
-0.010176966,
-0.0689489767,
0.0136512779,
0.0819393471,
-0.0013998976,
-0.0344503671,
0.0519598015,
-0.0416893288,
0.0442928188,
0.0219411012,
0.026178157,
-0.0514249578,
0.0444858968,
0.0027804493,
0.0500994176,
-0.024931673,
-0.0124860136,
0.0086667463,
-0.0094781229,
0.0331166834,
0.0176013764,
-0.0280938093,
0.0002479598,
-0.0481283739,
0.0033828213,
0.015896799,
-0.0296122469,
0.0200598165,
0.0469485559,
-0.0331608467,
-0.0189509727,
-0.0330325067,
0.005649271,
0.0196926501,
0.0003074715,
0.0420767963,
-0.004369027,
0.0126085002,
-0.017424237,
-0.0128211798,
0.0092906076,
0.034457799,
-0.0132790226,
-0.0515405089,
-0.0183267184,
-0.0469205864,
-0.0450200103,
0.0828759596,
-0.0455268025,
0.0248707943,
-0.0336631238,
0.0676910505,
0.0293275751,
0.0139656616,
-0.0383493863,
-0.0242123641,
0.0309320837,
-0.0140647022,
-0.0036279883,
0.0733532012,
-0.0439297855,
0.0701620281,
0.0384690687,
0.0730979219,
-0.0483413041,
-0.0225832742,
-0.0153630655,
-0.0157689359,
-0.0398530439,
-0.0531154238,
-0.002530776,
0.0558521785,
0.000216101,
0.0097596562,
-0.0623357929,
-0.0069994726,
-0.0093205888,
-0.0360666588,
-0.0236957371,
-0.0231767334,
0.0008597346,
0.0476149246,
-0.0093621854,
-0.0655605942,
0.0517242104,
-0.0151834879,
-0.0267294813,
-0.0160223413,
-0.0335519202,
-0.0070901262,
0.068896167,
0.0116600972,
-0.0143187577,
0.0010111642,
-0.0286167543,
-0.0417809784,
-0.0082493974,
-0.0134342583,
0.0068414016,
0.0503514446,
-0.0229033213,
-0.031340085,
-0.0122763766,
-0.0265199617,
-0.0272478219,
0.0146225309,
0.0229557306,
0.0265390631,
0.0504934229,
-0.0441573225,
0.0107968524,
-0.0025986081,
0.0458815657,
0.0154364845,
-0.0033007404,
-0.0266254656,
-0.0182411876,
-0.002671872,
-0.0170160942,
-0.0322144292,
0.0411282703,
-0.0548283271,
0.0177399758,
0.0169477724,
0.0271568075,
0.0396570303,
-0.0792265609,
0.0293893591,
0.0231145117,
0.017684672,
-0.0409086123,
0.0328752548,
0.0526606217,
-0.0537812114,
-0.0332292691,
0.0261987261,
0.005736555,
-0.0356582366,
0.0627561659,
0.0042618252,
0.0286643207,
0.0188618992,
0.0136447018,
-0.0747388601,
0.0020896366,
0.0009600017,
0.027009584,
0.0233534463,
-0.0198396537,
0.0582855679,
-0.048299849,
0.0330086425,
0.0248384085,
-0.0568282343,
-0.0509322546,
-0.0201614331,
-0.0090924511,
-0.0143085783,
0.0269223135,
-0.000198997,
-0.0082933279,
0.0157306828,
0.0067981258,
-0.0279524252,
-0.0425758697,
-0.0010030678,
-0.0146814883,
-0.0175313093,
0.0538854115,
-0.0326924324,
-0.034097597,
-0.0417681709,
-0.0007672968,
0.0511789434,
0.0336276516,
0.0052879243,
0.0202597417,
0.0649582669,
-0.0224255044,
0.0040200017,
0.0317682847,
-0.0224804785,
-0.0095819775,
-0.0523426756,
0.0805734172,
-0.02491327,
-0.0749132559,
0.0019361016,
-0.0493485369,
-0.0315894075,
0.0505135097,
0.0590530224,
-0.0197370928,
-0.0599805713,
-0.0530163161,
0.0232881308,
0.0030138912,
-0.0657035708,
0.0295397136,
0.0499058329,
-0.0507384688,
0.0034453669,
-0.0004686479,
0.0207129121,
0.0335411429,
-0.011958207,
-0.0606375821,
0.0100675058,
-0.0164961945,
-0.0241797864,
0.0392813794,
0.0121999076,
0.0113665331,
0.0060676811,
-0.0215615593,
-0.0006806815,
-0.0289011262,
-0.0455608293,
-0.0436853655,
-0.0600258224,
-0.021922674,
0.0458635017,
0.0231760647,
0.0314486921,
0.0210334975,
0.0098552024,
-0.0539041832,
0.033931341,
0.0119903442,
0.0017831955,
0.032131914,
0.0728816763,
-0.0442945473,
0.0137931192,
0.0200305078,
-0.0227190405,
0.0368694887,
0.0297379773,
-0.0274805855,
-0.0454411954,
0.0451793708,
0.032530807,
0.0047695716,
0.0703584254,
0.0503058285,
-0.0151438722,
0.0299057569,
0.0083531458,
0.0312793702,
0.000070331,
-0.05953376,
-0.0170138441,
0.0381879136,
0.0640160888,
0.0051760133,
0.0469700284,
0.042691879,
0.0064408369,
-0.0441241562,
0.0205704421,
0.0525038689,
0.0430694483,
0.0420924462,
0.0351707786,
-0.0231153388,
0.0467335023,
-0.0246128887,
0.0208134651,
0.0080570029,
-0.0062571708,
-0.0094653526,
0.0584180392,
-0.0688410252,
-0.0177825168,
-0.0896756127,
-0.1022725925,
0.0177351348,
-0.011707725,
0.014497702,
0.0161071997,
0.0037761112,
-0.0253584459,
0.0133833801,
-0.029767869,
0.0264173783,
0.0004560047,
-0.0102612749,
0.0198782738,
0.0106885703,
-0.0068326634,
-0.0436715931,
0.0623883195,
-0.0104072085,
0.030953344,
-0.0611810237,
0.007400373,
-0.0300201774,
-0.0332851782,
0.0145406965,
0.0375543572,
-0.0057433192,
-0.0415513515,
-0.0381668173,
-0.0850114748,
-0.0133401882,
0.0163540039,
0.0414420851,
-0.0458489247,
0.0132182334,
0.0753461868,
-0.0413169786,
-0.0182753261,
0.0151784429,
-0.0081249541,
0.0647250786,
-0.0185610745,
-0.0246029366,
-6.338888552e-33,
0.0205206256,
0.0003645887,
-0.0120059485,
-0.0315425098,
0.0286281649,
-0.0203264989,
-0.0397848152,
0.01249565,
-0.0302120727,
0.0123371985,
-0.0258017629,
0.031349387,
0.0031774405,
0.0442631282,
0.0126094716,
-0.018700324,
0.0607022792,
0.0057444307,
-0.0104141096,
0.0129739735,
0.0274953507,
0.0361753963,
0.0574533194,
-0.0634099469,
-0.0059712445,
0.0070266956,
-0.0029794155,
-0.0151142878,
-0.0113084624,
0.0341754444,
-0.026951652,
0.0210926123,
0.007143815,
-0.0535478517,
-0.0469471999,
-0.0137130721,
-0.0214763302,
0.0012117991,
0.0158066787,
0.0131653547,
-0.0526347421,
-0.0307378508,
0.1085756198,
0.0121741164,
-0.0504642166,
-0.0156999584,
0.0210240744,
-0.009429981,
-0.0013798667,
-0.0151317976,
-0.0679222196,
-0.0066018635,
-0.0217624847,
0.0068408754,
0.0195754804,
0.0472419038,
-0.0187656116,
0.0366194509,
-0.036482539,
0.0039801123,
0.0505363159,
-0.0043891217,
0.0835321024,
0.0082829166,
0.0176286586,
0.0562818274,
0.0840212256,
0.0060510575,
-0.0560074449,
-0.0389610678,
0.0615940802,
0.0661686882,
0.034587536,
-0.003875853,
0.0772252306,
0.0090124262,
-0.0735670105,
-0.0055167456,
-0.0142237414,
0.0297778584,
0.0205746256,
0.0449066237,
-0.0544602089,
-0.0448726043,
-0.0235973503,
-0.0499920622,
-0.0169980917,
-0.026948439,
0.0165754091,
-0.0133173643,
-0.0619835816,
0.0489287674,
0.0287470482,
-0.0618261993,
0.0197250359,
0.0099530872,
0.0137149179,
0.0648706779,
0.0274651013,
-0.0175371189,
0.0248441696,
-0.0261994787,
-0.007192208,
0.0069328151,
0.0743883178,
0.0333312787,
0.0348536223,
0.0304975901,
0.0007535642,
-0.016118383,
-0.0314936675,
-0.0672345236,
0.0277387872,
0.0331158005,
0.0810652152,
0.0027481255,
-0.0105637955,
0.0181097724,
-0.0100660082,
0.0312593468,
-0.0394852944,
0.0380690731,
-0.0019648664,
0.0496686287,
-0.0107915336,
-0.0628805682,
-0.044403445,
0.0158238783,
0.0873250216,
-0.07427641,
-0.0473442301,
-0.0143796252,
2.973e-7,
0.0437582731,
-0.0241254866,
0.0152361654,
0.0066106007,
0.0247518197,
0.037023209,
-0.0035270781,
0.0103204185,
-0.0224444289,
-0.0369201228,
0.019691756,
0.0233412795,
0.0230828039,
0.0100316405,
0.0109426789,
-0.0090999221,
-0.035390228,
0.0452916436,
0.0068236794,
0.0212552398,
0.0229794737,
0.0818372369,
-0.0129054114,
-0.0011341328,
0.0531582348,
0.0058922837,
0.0227919761,
-0.0133220227,
0.0637085214,
-0.0040680687,
-0.0490720123,
-0.0083585624,
0.0087807635,
-0.0020702039,
0.015933957,
-0.0007732288,
-0.0040668109,
0.0563627146,
-0.0183637869,
0.0443377085,
-0.0305880103,
-0.0287711006,
0.0103898924,
-0.0580914505,
0.0548862554,
-0.0827344805,
-0.0138456402,
-0.0069196732,
-0.0328343511,
0.026400879,
0.0264590792,
0.0126877632,
0.0424386151,
0.0191082079,
-0.0175515153,
-0.0286752935,
-0.0118595306,
-0.0362841822,
-0.0201655775,
0.0177697446,
-0.0810276344,
-0.0219242107,
-0.056337133,
-0.0268372484,
0.0518375635,
0.0224923082,
-0.019641187,
3.270306558e-34,
0.0213657916,
0.0284251254,
0.059927877,
0.0188958514,
0.0159418788,
-0.0637206286,
0.0165617708,
0.0061595892,
0.0269869585,
-0.0336406007,
-0.0466920175
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03633v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03633v3 | Exploring the Reversal Curse and Other Deductive Logical Reasoning in BERT and GPT-Based Large Language Models | 2023-12-06T17:29:45 | 2024-07-01T18:13:24 | Da Wu, Jingye Yang, Kai Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | The term "Reversal Curse" refers to the scenario where auto-regressive
decoder large language models (LLMs), such as ChatGPT, trained on "A is B" fail
to learn "B is A," assuming that B and A are distinct and can be uniquely
identified from each other, demonstrating a basic failure of logical deduction.
This raises a red flag in the use of GPT models for certain general tasks such
as constructing knowledge graphs, considering their adherence to this symmetric
principle. In our study, we examined a bidirectional LLM, BERT, and found that
it is immune to the reversal curse. Driven by ongoing efforts to construct
biomedical knowledge graphs with LLMs, we also embarked on evaluating more
complex but essential deductive reasoning capabilities. This process included
first training encoder and decoder language models to master the intersection
and union operations on two sets and then moving on to assess their capability
to infer different combinations of union and intersection operations on three
newly created sets. The findings showed that while both encoder and decoder
language models, trained for tasks involving two sets (union/intersection),
were proficient in such scenarios, they encountered difficulties when dealing
with operations that included three sets (various combinations of union and
intersection). Our research highlights the distinct characteristics of encoder
and decoder models in simple and complex logical reasoning. In practice, the
choice between BERT and GPT should be guided by the specific requirements and
nature of the task at hand, leveraging their respective strengths in
bidirectional context comprehension and sequence prediction. | [
0.0201565139,
0.049030181,
-0.031209765,
0.0307,
-0.0565419644,
0.036251206,
-0.0174077787,
-0.019730771,
0.0117114289,
-0.032325767,
0.0110843126,
0.0159951951,
-0.0029036896,
0.0163614601,
0.0176868923,
-0.0013373406,
0.0714895353,
-0.0083184605,
-0.005224661,
-0.0390974507,
-0.0265212916,
0.0133747635,
-0.0290707033,
0.0065938262,
0.0288823396,
-0.0129700238,
0.0048590885,
-0.022219602,
-0.0038463874,
-0.0246627871,
-0.0334441587,
0.055291865,
0.035739094,
0.0602846742,
0.0000018743,
-0.0471392237,
-0.0078109195,
0.0074663702,
-0.0564354546,
-0.0193054136,
-0.0602598637,
-0.0230162274,
0.0025320156,
-0.002804436,
-0.0251026116,
-0.0362111405,
0.0379648022,
0.0393846668,
0.0339291282,
0.0582697988,
-0.0017391706,
-0.0724621192,
0.0544761978,
-0.031632401,
0.0312525332,
-0.0236787144,
0.0372832976,
0.0354989208,
0.0011553416,
-0.0546240807,
-0.0065345922,
0.0262679607,
0.0505674407,
0.0571755879,
-0.0356493406,
0.0606714413,
-0.0540325604,
-0.0317007042,
-0.0008260976,
0.0414155088,
0.0088394228,
-0.0322412364,
-0.0192467235,
0.0230301823,
0.0022541948,
0.0089431144,
-0.0450848192,
0.0448978245,
-0.0338722803,
0.0347891301,
-0.0134527609,
-0.0291079581,
0.0464702658,
-0.005713264,
-0.065926373,
0.0487016737,
0.0340163447,
-0.0294824857,
-0.0161807593,
0.0239626225,
-0.0476503745,
-0.0205578767,
0.0309950486,
0.0144519294,
0.0013355943,
0.033746887,
0.0072381622,
-0.015980674,
0.0439477265,
-0.0014950777,
-0.0021970295,
0.0486142561,
-0.0099077551,
0.024188716,
-0.062302731,
0.0263449773,
-0.0495550558,
0.0602087677,
-0.0105540408,
-0.0014768749,
-0.06036897,
-0.0530114248,
-0.0254015271,
0.0439682007,
-0.0025165428,
-0.0003055086,
-0.0383118317,
0.0081918864,
-0.0048718033,
0.0061971643,
0.0076226434,
-0.0043817381,
-0.013809911,
-0.0144240083,
-0.0290773716,
0.0457371548,
-0.0156073514,
0.0377386436,
0.0132083409,
-0.0438598767,
-0.0164449252,
-0.0210212842,
-0.0080424398,
-0.0202414989,
0.0062524737,
0.0876501426,
-0.009923256,
-0.0185261089,
-0.03993598,
-0.0377163738,
-0.019379776,
-0.0661681145,
0.068121925,
-0.047406733,
0.040280018,
0.0413773283,
-0.0082694348,
-0.0231849197,
0.0270987954,
0.0015172504,
-0.002332903,
0.081072703,
0.0127956504,
-0.0005053622,
0.0240445249,
0.0257456489,
-0.0245816,
0.0475411229,
0.0242798738,
-0.0069966726,
-0.0094748428,
-0.012027774,
-0.0251767486,
-0.0071455808,
0.0434303656,
-0.0196263529,
-0.0495708697,
-0.0108983833,
0.0239179563,
0.0460569374,
0.0109667554,
0.0449727252,
-0.0481585152,
-0.0362001434,
0.0432821065,
0.0340901911,
0.0083229616,
0.0213222057,
0.0113926679,
-0.0385444574,
0.0020856753,
0.0171460491,
-0.0396020897,
0.0115246233,
-0.0436952785,
0.0177925862,
-0.0168745648,
0.007045967,
-0.0137381135,
-0.0123597346,
-0.0134701664,
-0.0007843506,
0.0294153299,
0.0021442533,
0.0685921907,
-0.0054473444,
-0.0487513319,
0.0524202995,
0.0136256292,
-0.0746887103,
-0.0100457463,
-0.0627367496,
-0.0179322083,
0.0437699407,
0.0535262749,
-0.0080237985,
-0.0625424311,
0.0141116502,
-0.0427745134,
0.0228532888,
0.0214753579,
0.024506608,
-0.0107691623,
-0.0484327786,
-0.0282771569,
0.0211062003,
0.0032030996,
0.0299632382,
-0.0097254999,
0.0118845133,
-0.0041447505,
-0.0559811443,
0.0564535521,
0.0259303153,
-0.053861063,
-0.0013740909,
-0.0410339907,
-0.0055223992,
0.0372795947,
0.0002843177,
-0.0017433626,
0.0536659695,
0.0521378778,
-0.0343922079,
-0.05831597,
0.0377255641,
-0.0614924468,
-0.0959758535,
0.0321963914,
-0.0464115888,
-0.062596187,
0.0326338001,
-0.0203622952,
-0.0600458048,
0.0148047665,
-0.0747164562,
0.0737739652,
-0.0289306547,
0.0148739452,
0.0097754765,
-0.03836786,
-0.0159004778,
0.103869915,
-0.0292275194,
0.0087890122,
-0.0331142098,
-0.0339777917,
0.0260599833,
-0.0597276352,
-0.001439063,
0.0282229912,
0.0082431333,
-0.0118088573,
-0.0021809626,
-0.0193278678,
-0.0372315161,
-0.0043711611,
-0.0886437669,
0.0070013315,
0.004878873,
0.0263413191,
-0.0126120532,
-0.0375744253,
-0.002932912,
-0.0068907291,
-0.0144029483,
0.0057937428,
0.0149282375,
0.0570109487,
0.0080240127,
-0.0002503731,
-0.0528061315,
0.0245918892,
-0.0271000471,
-0.0690119267,
0.0372547768,
-0.0022703137,
-0.0156579558,
0.007486186,
0.0198250562,
-0.0178095382,
0.016528707,
-0.0338472985,
-0.0433929004,
0.0521188341,
0.0065079643,
0.0198198035,
0.0575129241,
-0.0450613573,
0.0328306369,
0.0524544194,
-0.0032166815,
-0.007820663,
0.013186343,
-0.0185478274,
-0.02450395,
-0.0227113497,
-0.0371937118,
-0.0631485134,
0.0418436006,
0.0356325917,
-0.0072671678,
-0.0593709834,
-0.0233824551,
-0.0020781714,
-0.0237921551,
-0.044947613,
-0.0476889461,
0.0017982306,
0.0547513217,
-0.0369608365,
-0.0114413863,
0.0927859023,
0.0125000654,
0.0111742234,
-0.0559118874,
0.0386778377,
-0.0136648212,
0.0800082907,
0.0086832689,
0.0197956767,
-0.0057113837,
-0.061561875,
-0.0357320458,
-0.0001062528,
0.0420176163,
-0.0440147556,
0.031942334,
-0.043186754,
0.0109575009,
0.0007758089,
-0.049048271,
-0.0464141928,
0.0412989818,
-0.0145699028,
0.0199797843,
0.0039556641,
-0.0016752117,
-0.0609377027,
0.0075606434,
0.0465716235,
0.0112888077,
0.0177877843,
0.0131386295,
-0.028425619,
0.0039788927,
-0.0097166728,
-0.0154103506,
0.0172104891,
-0.0312259812,
-0.0090788873,
0.0518831499,
0.0282976683,
0.0240139775,
-0.0060451776,
0.0467720293,
0.0147374338,
-0.0304387994,
-0.0350339375,
-0.0204979554,
0.0192750711,
-0.0722280294,
0.0079016853,
0.1005741805,
0.0222407673,
-0.0150852902,
0.0027912068,
-0.0141952401,
-0.0139879249,
0.0113305598,
-0.0305797141,
-0.1112495512,
-0.04394475,
0.0051159742,
-0.010923381,
-0.0128368419,
-0.0466985926,
0.0127856629,
-0.119344689,
0.0157088339,
0.0182390288,
-0.039492663,
-0.068563059,
-0.0627338365,
-0.0156234829,
-0.0021393858,
0.0197265539,
0.019207323,
-0.0240936913,
0.0044127074,
0.0165773481,
0.0034947132,
-0.0188875478,
0.0360301659,
-0.0216701012,
0.0099077579,
0.0811216533,
-0.0009427014,
-0.0346592404,
-0.0225839969,
0.0209571067,
0.0014864935,
0.0149887986,
0.0060958066,
0.0114198802,
0.001885549,
0.0107191782,
-0.0643088743,
0.0208326019,
-0.0312656164,
-0.0366899781,
-0.0204008631,
0.123323299,
-0.0263058823,
-0.0392114371,
-0.022947168,
0.0079260552,
-0.025039345,
0.1019043326,
0.0269824583,
0.0355731286,
-0.0463441834,
0.0122677684,
0.0427561514,
-0.0309592392,
0.0105147939,
0.0636639595,
0.0035582182,
-0.0545571893,
-0.0231549237,
-0.0231011584,
0.0398043692,
0.0008298055,
-0.0005807023,
0.0512319915,
0.0569754951,
-0.0136047425,
-0.0744258612,
0.0158666745,
0.0137310857,
-0.0051773502,
-0.0280367658,
-0.0084965415,
0.032235425,
0.0054900618,
-0.0252006501,
0.0156281777,
-0.0052600414,
-0.0547623187,
0.0061211642,
0.0232861452,
0.0335568711,
0.0004333085,
0.009839802,
-0.0135154864,
0.0060736435,
0.0571843795,
0.0202624202,
0.0160267595,
0.0338154137,
0.0019536845,
-0.0057070237,
0.0288521722,
-0.0137207163,
0.0026053456,
-0.0024218892,
0.0513739549,
-0.0506899841,
0.0083001601,
0.0436432511,
0.06133065,
0.0227123685,
-0.0064901165,
0.0124464137,
-0.0122666731,
0.0349864475,
-0.0452685505,
0.0212605279,
-0.0238503721,
-0.0224840268,
0.0615310967,
-0.0046042479,
0.0060119387,
-0.0293631013,
-0.0226484444,
-0.0090734893,
-0.0591582991,
0.0639803484,
0.0143858893,
0.0102010407,
0.0538933314,
-0.0262380093,
-0.0245755948,
0.0137893483,
-0.011913253,
-0.0013376614,
-0.0187868662,
0.0512555502,
0.0500242785,
0.0216842424,
-0.0487519465,
-0.0078472076,
-0.0564839318,
-0.0144725516,
0.0348253883,
0.0224675313,
0.0464880839,
0.0260747019,
0.0216215625,
-0.025364371,
-0.0087856054,
0.0118542118,
0.0159231517,
-0.0051052878,
-0.0064116712,
0.0537331402,
0.0310755353,
-0.0025480874,
-0.0519547872,
0.0884192213,
0.0236765277,
0.1092349738,
-0.0026582035,
-0.0247111358,
-0.0122580025,
-0.0627327114,
0.0620211475,
0.0018552421,
-0.0303026736,
0.0343220308,
-0.0495747626,
-0.0780106634,
-0.0130021125,
0.0161340944,
0.027381327,
-0.0020409357,
0.020467218,
0.067864269,
0.0138599705,
-0.1073607281,
0.0193775669,
0.0797388107,
-0.0394694917,
0.0042259065,
-0.0130271595,
-6.177922233e-33,
-0.031053884,
-0.0150664859,
0.0473409146,
-0.0364090949,
-0.0349667408,
-0.0232266281,
-0.043206308,
0.0041651498,
-0.0351540819,
0.0410260633,
0.0120221404,
0.0359911136,
0.0096758241,
0.0165920891,
0.0074591162,
-0.0093740793,
0.0191015936,
0.0268984474,
0.0102495346,
0.0035312662,
0.0390492119,
0.0256213322,
0.0517137423,
-0.0301496759,
-0.0269151311,
-0.0384966359,
0.0251650866,
0.0323828124,
-0.0916841626,
0.0286571477,
0.0006853291,
0.0124809658,
0.0258170329,
-0.0216394868,
-0.00534902,
0.0241774842,
-0.0524222776,
-0.058758311,
0.0581269376,
-0.0127570163,
-0.0148315588,
-0.0350642093,
0.072843805,
-0.0008270907,
-0.0101235285,
-0.0045028101,
-0.0085604386,
-0.0098188026,
-0.0358101837,
0.0102629,
-0.0424055494,
0.0060560806,
0.0061951131,
-0.014823081,
0.0080196625,
-0.0374696441,
-0.0085952524,
-0.0209672377,
-0.0397176072,
0.0021732119,
0.0395846702,
-0.0118777128,
0.0438447371,
-0.0101774372,
0.0217371024,
0.0295266118,
0.0302498341,
0.006015793,
-0.0197947118,
-0.007914451,
0.0047152312,
0.0993070081,
0.008107475,
-0.0028500664,
0.0232795514,
0.0025834562,
-0.1085761264,
-0.0103338473,
-0.0067591541,
0.0582837723,
0.0221934561,
0.0350765623,
-0.0262537897,
-0.0164118521,
-0.0422552191,
0.0027202056,
-0.0122508993,
0.0025708496,
0.0132847587,
-0.0216665063,
0.015958989,
0.0188738592,
0.0181295034,
-0.0250802245,
0.0115168784,
0.0471913964,
0.0123389009,
0.0007541376,
-0.018082099,
0.0799829066,
-0.0617657676,
-0.041166909,
0.0388929062,
0.0057993974,
0.0167658664,
0.010819545,
0.038005203,
-0.0237189438,
-0.006204417,
-0.0245312937,
-0.0541264862,
-0.0188692771,
-0.0083515048,
-0.0206416752,
0.0579557158,
0.0506916307,
0.0103418538,
-0.0300977062,
0.0122624151,
0.0179253556,
-0.0592832342,
0.0127476295,
-0.0161921494,
0.0118242865,
0.012555724,
-0.0162885208,
-0.0413269624,
0.0212217998,
0.0318764299,
-0.0563620441,
-0.0205239691,
0.0274456032,
2.773e-7,
0.0812919587,
0.0445796773,
0.0547098778,
0.0748645738,
0.0266300812,
0.0282643121,
-0.0565786399,
0.0110920435,
0.0449390411,
-0.0197606105,
0.0198443625,
0.0665137991,
0.0050415802,
0.0466055498,
0.0086038467,
-0.0118501438,
-0.0429262146,
-0.0184333827,
-0.0405422784,
0.0361081809,
0.075402312,
0.0200076774,
-0.0073442943,
-0.0108174691,
0.0256748963,
-0.0148952277,
0.0433967561,
-0.0046802871,
0.0134901479,
-0.0083402535,
0.0002589416,
0.0045590247,
0.0314977206,
0.0933035091,
0.0149938585,
-0.0058232252,
-0.0167054012,
0.0287757888,
-0.0589420609,
-0.0232647546,
0.0164153799,
-0.0240260959,
-0.0195839144,
-0.0390156098,
0.0782036185,
-0.0819076449,
-0.0657771677,
0.0488164164,
-0.0379795283,
-0.0165897943,
0.0158701725,
0.0173874162,
-0.0241854135,
0.0083375918,
0.0072997669,
0.0095892288,
-0.0231757928,
-0.0802067071,
0.0202257466,
0.0433747433,
-0.0624242797,
-0.0496344417,
-0.0333108678,
-0.0082444865,
0.0446364358,
-0.0787791908,
-0.0266702045,
2.551026616e-34,
0.0206157155,
-0.0256788712,
0.0180528313,
0.0131659564,
0.0562779307,
-0.0338580422,
-0.0174929071,
0.0424693041,
-0.0187970083,
-0.0778359324,
-0.0183591601
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03577v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03577v1 | Improving Bias Mitigation through Bias Experts in Natural Language Understanding | 2023-12-06T16:15:00 | 2023-12-06T16:15:00 | Eojin Jeon, Mingyu Lee, Juhyeong Park, Yeachan Kim, Wing-Lam Mok, SangKeun Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL | Biases in the dataset often enable the model to achieve high performance on
in-distribution data, while poorly performing on out-of-distribution data. To
mitigate the detrimental effect of the bias on the networks, previous works
have proposed debiasing methods that down-weight the biased examples identified
by an auxiliary model, which is trained with explicit bias labels. However,
finding a type of bias in datasets is a costly process. Therefore, recent
studies have attempted to make the auxiliary model biased without the guidance
(or annotation) of bias labels, by constraining the model's training
environment or the capability of the model itself. Despite the promising
debiasing results of recent works, the multi-class learning objective, which
has been naively used to train the auxiliary model, may harm the bias
mitigation effect due to its regularization effect and competitive nature
across classes. As an alternative, we propose a new debiasing framework that
introduces binary classifiers between the auxiliary model and the main model,
coined bias experts. Specifically, each bias expert is trained on a binary
classification task derived from the multi-class classification task via the
One-vs-Rest approach. Experimental results demonstrate that our proposed
strategy improves the bias identification ability of the auxiliary model.
Consequently, our debiased model consistently outperforms the state-of-the-art
on various challenge datasets. | [
0.0487391092,
0.0449322052,
-0.0162797328,
0.0320712999,
-0.0018107035,
0.0379803553,
0.0414533615,
-0.0336714536,
0.0465227477,
-0.0632184595,
-0.0263039283,
0.0061541549,
-0.021380892,
-0.0220228601,
0.0035644898,
-0.0624619573,
0.0742195621,
0.021157356,
0.0928361639,
0.0027215474,
0.020798618,
0.0236667451,
-0.0153986625,
0.0196858104,
-0.0212341882,
0.0105534177,
0.0246581361,
0.0232617296,
0.0004887635,
-0.0056772926,
0.0786262825,
0.0579099953,
0.0515712388,
0.0396290645,
0.0000018305,
-0.0446430407,
-0.0192092638,
-0.009672245,
-0.0867975652,
-0.0630817935,
0.0649753436,
-0.0387805663,
0.0565881953,
-0.0071091764,
-0.0132225938,
-0.0507344641,
0.0741381422,
0.0543311052,
0.0357649364,
0.0602924004,
0.0003554131,
-0.0555818602,
-0.0374765284,
-0.0127147455,
0.0084333681,
-0.049471464,
0.0296346471,
0.0059314324,
-0.0652701855,
-0.0168078803,
-0.0101907235,
0.0035745176,
0.0224686917,
0.0496864691,
0.0255353861,
0.0174521599,
-0.0191523395,
-0.0442373119,
-0.0086346203,
0.0740885362,
-0.06887988,
-0.0316703096,
-0.0267948527,
-0.024843039,
0.022887487,
0.0057192603,
-0.0256044362,
0.0059297914,
-0.0156695433,
0.0270939525,
0.0210054964,
0.02075685,
0.0391466208,
0.0483205542,
-0.0039913314,
0.0218458008,
-0.0227437057,
-0.0107888067,
0.0383088961,
0.0526004732,
0.0127023645,
-0.004544829,
0.0153816361,
0.0061812913,
-0.0302205011,
0.0403059945,
-0.0174225159,
-0.0225843955,
0.0019129288,
-0.0444572456,
-0.0201925952,
0.0002920201,
-0.0510330684,
0.0548727624,
-0.0068752761,
-0.0323593095,
0.0067324555,
0.0392487198,
-0.0240031425,
-0.0121483756,
-0.0483087525,
-0.0035288257,
-0.0621648766,
0.0362604074,
0.0054346966,
0.015726164,
-0.007298464,
-0.0212124288,
-0.0217264071,
0.0169733465,
0.0122062871,
0.0398061238,
-0.0480402708,
-0.0099584041,
0.0051465235,
0.0628216341,
-0.0399615429,
0.0660928264,
-0.0375655815,
-0.1073835641,
-0.034536805,
0.0149181644,
0.0050489693,
-0.0472978354,
0.0144802798,
0.064781405,
0.0181442089,
-0.0417843238,
-0.0427710004,
-0.0318308733,
-0.0002327377,
-0.0465441048,
-0.0295405369,
-0.0243850313,
0.032450866,
-0.0114297234,
0.0195267219,
-0.0286676884,
0.0102492552,
-0.0140974317,
-0.0514262803,
0.0834993497,
-0.0601444691,
-0.0244901981,
0.0519008711,
0.020165462,
0.0026207829,
0.1001393944,
-0.0033474932,
-0.0370456167,
0.0588711463,
0.0050836983,
0.0291738845,
0.0185865611,
0.0342083424,
-0.0327206776,
-0.0235878229,
0.0117730899,
-0.0113541475,
0.0093285264,
0.0403225645,
-0.0163896307,
-0.0266438853,
-0.0080871629,
0.0601141267,
-0.0431247465,
-0.014924746,
0.0312949605,
0.0028788457,
0.0078444825,
-0.0062364922,
0.0223983712,
-0.0604461133,
-0.000633207,
-0.0019232156,
-0.0224387404,
-0.0224428568,
-0.0038725273,
-0.0325212814,
-0.0431829095,
0.0059471806,
-0.010394088,
-0.0176170561,
0.0274578929,
0.0580589436,
0.0311989617,
0.0142025407,
0.0746023804,
0.0385080464,
0.0020612061,
0.026052421,
-0.0345244929,
0.0035262688,
0.0261525139,
-0.0023985994,
-0.0510467775,
-0.0209740996,
-0.0546890944,
-0.0048365709,
0.0101639004,
0.0569597408,
-0.0219382737,
0.0634214506,
-0.067343995,
-0.0605789796,
-0.0088644559,
0.0570621975,
0.0154556055,
-0.0041537867,
-0.0082442481,
0.028570151,
-0.0648804083,
-0.0227318928,
0.0362025462,
0.0478256159,
-0.0329929553,
0.0050785947,
0.0129027274,
0.0073775765,
0.0135509567,
-0.0382675007,
-0.0458407141,
0.0013528375,
-0.0129783135,
-0.0062270155,
0.0033783636,
-0.025301069,
-0.0647676736,
0.001054525,
-0.0559155904,
-0.0436087921,
0.0255808104,
-0.0925288424,
-0.0197618622,
0.0095442953,
-0.0060561197,
0.0215407182,
-0.0254095998,
-0.0444167703,
-0.0229320619,
0.0199201293,
-0.0379318893,
0.0695129484,
0.0144474693,
0.0189090855,
0.0019173005,
-0.0745497718,
0.0454470217,
-0.0255767461,
-0.0214103051,
-0.0011379085,
-0.0158250667,
-0.0070438706,
0.0302700568,
-0.0135195702,
-0.0742140338,
-0.0012197585,
-0.0626965985,
-0.0144353928,
-0.0379360728,
-0.0001797015,
0.0284649581,
0.000575616,
-0.0034649472,
-0.0586581863,
-0.0413442329,
-0.0695173889,
-0.0202435702,
-0.0018391286,
0.0358543023,
0.0015758513,
-0.0083142789,
-0.0146856019,
-0.0062012002,
-0.0263944361,
0.0407747179,
0.0217601079,
-0.0264164228,
-0.0311782639,
-0.0226639267,
-0.0108165462,
0.0074385284,
0.0095172981,
0.0037637295,
-0.0170267876,
0.0051491261,
-0.0422208048,
0.0540659539,
-0.0021218867,
-0.0003953337,
0.0422870927,
0.0191398636,
-0.0668985918,
0.001727358,
-0.0159337483,
0.0100489538,
-0.0308179948,
-0.0083158966,
-0.0460342392,
0.0675538257,
0.046715159,
-0.0195392128,
-0.0002210348,
0.0252070129,
-0.0012459244,
-0.0157439224,
-0.0341795534,
-0.0005093533,
0.0166205596,
0.0216249619,
-0.0678382888,
-0.0394757055,
0.082918182,
0.0213302262,
-0.0259460695,
-0.0500707068,
-0.0124724358,
-0.0174605791,
0.001654763,
-0.0065455525,
0.0241902657,
0.0220881291,
-0.0087153371,
-0.0564903431,
-0.0205091462,
0.0197217017,
-0.0054772673,
-0.0109202722,
-0.0310455281,
-0.0074241408,
-0.0189679302,
-0.0076003964,
-0.0431087129,
-0.0517140552,
-0.0293946974,
0.0138525078,
-0.0140114883,
0.0466608368,
-0.0586100072,
-0.0114735225,
-0.0218921825,
0.0395360328,
-0.0196860153,
-0.0035516378,
0.009339706,
0.0627590567,
0.007051826,
-0.0024994039,
-0.0024701892,
-0.0051770513,
0.003938498,
0.0167614389,
0.0254360363,
0.0245612916,
-0.046331089,
0.0153221078,
0.0099694412,
-0.0270969309,
-0.0107015278,
-0.0148380902,
0.0108539723,
-0.0492151305,
0.0060746749,
0.107802242,
0.0154953795,
-0.091229327,
0.0082622338,
0.0228751544,
0.0143634696,
0.0570541583,
-0.0113868332,
-0.0903874934,
-0.0528756827,
0.0004474757,
0.0028764752,
-0.0036649567,
-0.0330159068,
-0.0154284723,
-0.0794877037,
0.019395465,
-0.0171254389,
0.0039158342,
0.0091022272,
-0.0195495803,
0.0205605794,
-0.0713944361,
0.0275724418,
-0.0346584246,
0.0496386737,
0.0171031896,
0.0436101854,
-0.0137843648,
-0.0903019682,
-0.014575541,
-0.0168365575,
0.0559780151,
0.0128545258,
0.0141261565,
-0.0288616214,
0.0642184541,
0.0595686398,
-0.0390118547,
0.0135004194,
-0.0248988736,
0.1043317989,
-0.0415888466,
-0.0290643629,
0.0264072586,
0.027937768,
-0.0055334484,
0.0274344292,
-0.0077471561,
0.0423140414,
0.0073104152,
-0.012071996,
-0.0092562409,
-0.0394632667,
0.0487528667,
0.0647928193,
0.0227907225,
-0.0322813354,
-0.0157033931,
-0.0358165205,
0.0052748807,
0.007693545,
0.0054051341,
0.0392119624,
0.0070264358,
-0.042044539,
0.0017416114,
-0.0539385639,
0.0113511737,
0.0234969445,
0.0099422811,
-0.0091115218,
-0.0289318804,
0.0117331427,
-0.0168814212,
0.0248585138,
-0.0247134082,
0.0120215416,
0.0483099222,
-0.0304203685,
-0.0163994115,
-0.0350638144,
-0.0418541953,
0.0232812706,
-0.061902117,
-0.041774597,
0.0289375801,
0.0463872254,
0.0209334884,
0.0634196699,
-0.0186218247,
-0.0734626129,
0.0568111055,
0.0470930636,
-0.052822873,
-0.0564609542,
0.0547021329,
-0.0081014913,
0.0119653828,
0.0264790617,
-0.0300845634,
0.0451113246,
0.0051805112,
-0.0023148516,
-0.0585416704,
-0.0119454376,
0.0201530717,
-0.0155571029,
0.0692648813,
-0.0072184484,
0.0376593992,
-0.0375568867,
0.000155682,
0.0157812815,
-0.0640599504,
-0.0070993113,
0.0088922866,
0.0471922942,
-0.0157367215,
-0.0277571492,
-0.0147121456,
-0.0328358002,
0.001830128,
-0.0032940323,
0.0265559908,
0.0784867033,
0.0022051372,
-0.0239342712,
0.0011722443,
-0.0477686152,
0.045020014,
0.0179161467,
0.0146485511,
0.0156485047,
0.0166139379,
0.0381472223,
0.0280498751,
-0.0240148678,
-0.0440353192,
-0.0754177049,
0.0264930204,
-0.0228685159,
0.0329046771,
0.0498428941,
-0.0597611703,
0.0076239686,
0.0253486931,
-0.0136327036,
0.005115292,
0.0002265809,
0.0127225164,
-0.0409285091,
0.0524291918,
0.0083350614,
-0.0160505958,
0.0345063098,
0.0644293576,
0.0057075149,
0.074615933,
-0.0381966643,
-0.0138634378,
-0.0492191575,
-0.0066537866,
0.0408297628,
0.0249967482,
0.0129717626,
0.0280221812,
-0.0118441787,
-0.0629929453,
-0.0034364329,
-0.0247230045,
0.0598170944,
-0.0040448993,
0.023028411,
0.0452915505,
-0.024676159,
-0.0525625423,
-0.0136773828,
-0.0232484918,
-0.0120566478,
0.012805921,
-0.0525193587,
-6.218850007e-33,
-0.0184619222,
-0.0096804518,
-0.0573731288,
-0.0539527982,
0.0248605032,
0.002968126,
-0.0196410138,
-0.0096701356,
-0.074915275,
0.0390678607,
0.0255572163,
0.0303053074,
0.0213064961,
-0.0100648329,
0.0203257389,
-0.0434938297,
0.0656772777,
-0.020845335,
-0.005193626,
0.0042897309,
-0.0108606862,
0.0322926566,
0.1015807092,
-0.0862836391,
0.0723500475,
-0.0023315423,
-0.0425825901,
0.0377053358,
0.0032752273,
0.0196636841,
0.0102628302,
0.0871570334,
0.0602430478,
-0.0138795134,
-0.0027039337,
-0.0014786039,
-0.0583394058,
-0.0396116041,
0.0109936586,
0.0611017682,
0.0512277298,
-0.0089738648,
0.048638951,
-0.0053734737,
0.0252448097,
-0.0298050866,
0.0701059699,
-0.0290346164,
0.0056033977,
0.0104377195,
-0.0087065035,
0.0284975581,
-0.0353818312,
0.0267927274,
0.0074154842,
0.0603210293,
0.0061584557,
0.0178025533,
-0.0240352638,
-0.0065843812,
0.0186127927,
-0.0039292653,
0.0057928599,
0.0044823191,
-0.0484833159,
0.0463701785,
0.058342915,
-0.004710156,
-0.0077982019,
-0.0214101598,
0.0277405381,
0.0009931311,
0.0207841769,
0.0748673603,
0.0665107891,
0.0219039265,
-0.059227448,
-0.003313727,
0.0284703225,
0.013988086,
0.01742482,
-0.0083358791,
-0.0314527974,
-0.0195020568,
-0.0636088774,
-0.0844763815,
-0.0241017342,
-0.0043354933,
0.0160735436,
0.0263321064,
0.0083994903,
0.034749534,
0.0070473733,
-0.0608306713,
-0.003356274,
0.0418386906,
0.0062767947,
-0.005937539,
0.0258563682,
0.0017196285,
-0.0644652769,
-0.0342397094,
0.0198436156,
0.0451364815,
0.0200203788,
0.0074107731,
0.0861432031,
-0.0105981473,
-0.043644771,
-0.0093996869,
-0.0064104823,
-0.0089901034,
-0.0155165102,
0.0778920203,
0.0389877707,
0.0080498783,
-0.0277383104,
0.0351692028,
0.0206425171,
0.0149958944,
0.0023288468,
0.0340786614,
-0.0105027342,
0.0355186313,
-0.0398366898,
-0.0421025455,
0.0376199,
-0.0823846906,
0.0002557005,
-0.0453187488,
-0.0049715829,
-0.0232812297,
2.472e-7,
0.0312511846,
0.0409147441,
-0.0063430285,
-0.0138386264,
0.0257562473,
0.0386753865,
-0.0001710839,
0.0100346338,
-0.025193207,
-0.0307892822,
0.0454864725,
0.0384943299,
0.0169783756,
0.0236806553,
-0.062180616,
-0.0048034615,
-0.0179950036,
0.0553951338,
-0.0157549493,
0.0221636258,
0.0655472577,
0.0905048922,
0.0114201847,
-0.0202754084,
-0.0100308936,
-0.035477221,
0.0309705436,
-0.0058964677,
0.0562152416,
0.0172016043,
0.0342342891,
0.0538996533,
-0.0026615451,
0.0562474653,
-0.0023820465,
0.0205936357,
-0.0155735603,
0.0641449317,
-0.0426843427,
0.0074667376,
-0.013786708,
0.0366516821,
0.0021860697,
-0.0651237965,
0.0431581363,
-0.064206861,
-0.0262810029,
-0.0508992933,
-0.0303505845,
-0.0177750867,
0.0184280239,
0.0222270675,
0.0128784878,
0.0100364955,
0.0012884352,
-0.0158658549,
-0.0325113311,
-0.0837844387,
-0.0349204689,
0.0174300298,
-0.0324352831,
-0.0065136864,
0.0412464254,
-0.0061039925,
0.0592675954,
-0.0426623188,
0.028576361,
1.765830828e-34,
0.0535465255,
-0.0223031063,
0.0126703167,
0.0138692111,
0.0265632756,
-0.0075277342,
-0.0387630537,
-0.0375583023,
0.0255989768,
-0.031174399,
-0.0040368019
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03567v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03567v1 | XAIQA: Explainer-Based Data Augmentation for Extractive Question Answering | 2023-12-06T15:59:06 | 2023-12-06T15:59:06 | Joel Stremmel, Ardavan Saeedi, Hamid Hassanzadeh, Sanjit Batra, Jeffrey Hertzberg, Jaime Murillo, Eran Halperin | cs.CL | cs.CL, I.2.7 | Extractive question answering (QA) systems can enable physicians and
researchers to query medical records, a foundational capability for designing
clinical studies and understanding patient medical history. However, building
these systems typically requires expert-annotated QA pairs. Large language
models (LLMs), which can perform extractive QA, depend on high quality data in
their prompts, specialized for the application domain. We introduce a novel
approach, XAIQA, for generating synthetic QA pairs at scale from data naturally
available in electronic health records. Our method uses the idea of a
classification model explainer to generate questions and answers about medical
concepts corresponding to medical codes. In an expert evaluation with two
physicians, our method identifies $2.2\times$ more semantic matches and
$3.8\times$ more clinical abbreviations than two popular approaches that use
sentence transformers to create QA pairs. In an ML evaluation, adding our QA
pairs improves performance of GPT-4 as an extractive QA model, including on
difficult questions. In both the expert and ML evaluations, we examine
trade-offs between our method and sentence transformers for QA pair generation
depending on question difficulty. | [
0.0600866862,
0.0571573116,
-0.0092090126,
0.0181915648,
-0.0182502232,
0.0225588754,
0.0173727684,
0.0120263733,
0.0035316069,
-0.0077005047,
0.0184750147,
-0.0171932373,
-0.0339488536,
0.0393791869,
0.0274128914,
-0.0490170568,
0.0084507558,
0.0081194881,
0.0252929237,
0.0274155028,
0.0078558996,
0.0198880099,
-0.0056353994,
0.0369182378,
0.0236232374,
0.0047767293,
-0.0034010792,
-0.0263262875,
0.0170405786,
-0.0378660336,
-0.0089091156,
0.0139558641,
0.0010194429,
-0.0160928164,
0.0000017781,
-0.0447182171,
-0.0423176549,
0.035289105,
-0.0799900219,
-0.0382311046,
-0.0348430648,
-0.0382422134,
0.0472495072,
0.0315099917,
-0.0519950055,
-0.0247487985,
0.0289555229,
0.0338364951,
0.0641664788,
0.0559444316,
-0.0181175098,
-0.0037395128,
0.0502404496,
0.0048095235,
0.0539872088,
-0.0384801738,
0.0186210796,
0.0296248663,
0.0307260342,
0.01051699,
0.017262768,
0.0416575409,
0.015633123,
0.0131267654,
0.0362574607,
0.0371196643,
0.0084513314,
0.008304989,
-0.0229476821,
0.0919148773,
0.0338087715,
-0.0083450619,
0.0136155309,
0.0059596603,
0.0278484933,
0.0257637985,
-0.0356134512,
-0.0161388814,
-0.0177143533,
-0.0214592163,
0.0274072196,
0.0112423757,
0.0272308458,
0.0124244811,
-0.0418810882,
-0.0019511045,
0.0088838246,
-0.030085735,
-0.0039672027,
-0.0030818377,
-0.0255255699,
-0.0517253205,
0.0321088918,
0.0839729458,
-0.0399022214,
0.0251854323,
-0.0194366015,
-0.0372942686,
0.0399822667,
0.012770623,
-0.0002744824,
0.009561806,
-0.0142475525,
0.0528058745,
-0.0152118867,
0.0382473469,
-0.0213645734,
0.0345725827,
-0.0610887408,
-0.0385417491,
-0.0600776188,
-0.0454144739,
-0.0451205373,
0.0226644427,
-0.0427071787,
0.0134060727,
-0.0380209684,
0.0013887826,
0.0125336917,
-0.0051137218,
0.019709317,
0.0434462465,
-0.0256356671,
-0.0098847961,
-0.0395202041,
0.0065297442,
-0.0661574751,
0.0190699901,
0.0387279354,
-0.0720395967,
-0.0091466177,
0.0151103344,
0.0519920811,
-0.0120691517,
0.0174830928,
0.0310551524,
-0.0224827975,
-0.0133434916,
0.0206329059,
-0.0534376167,
-0.0151726268,
-0.0124087343,
-0.0245882031,
-0.0365636125,
0.0666489378,
0.0199986026,
-0.0278524309,
-0.057476908,
0.0317761898,
0.0115185231,
-0.0451493375,
0.0749727339,
-0.0684430972,
0.0337560996,
0.0348625593,
0.0158554353,
-0.0167577751,
0.0071353777,
0.0477577448,
-0.055227194,
0.0344630778,
-0.0322133228,
0.0637375191,
-0.0117623797,
0.0375059769,
-0.0431333818,
0.0180674754,
0.0578318909,
-0.0274224915,
0.0672196969,
-0.0277200826,
0.0876294672,
-0.0129183149,
0.0013697991,
-0.0039066304,
0.0423310548,
0.0153284417,
0.0170254298,
0.0358479954,
-0.0228403024,
-0.0018399144,
-0.0051229405,
-0.0085860603,
0.028364893,
0.028517751,
0.0065131942,
-0.0027114153,
-0.0178108588,
-0.0335083716,
-0.0611899905,
-0.0089950282,
0.0060305884,
-0.0205191616,
0.0310340151,
0.0171660837,
0.0213196855,
-0.0262709688,
0.0739453137,
0.0115999551,
-0.0294933692,
-0.0091606099,
-0.0762770548,
0.0094076432,
0.0631077886,
0.0479477271,
-0.0316516161,
-0.044640936,
-0.0313523039,
-0.0080359671,
0.0009117224,
0.022803342,
-0.0246196501,
0.0360074379,
-0.0467285924,
-0.0115740998,
-0.0054042521,
-0.0001817852,
-0.0359847099,
0.0374425948,
0.0010903183,
0.0245202351,
-0.0654121488,
-0.0360533707,
0.0482667983,
-0.0829731002,
-0.049201943,
0.0291019194,
-0.014582417,
0.0109422477,
0.0366235599,
0.009493785,
0.0555229746,
0.0266107097,
-0.0556211285,
-0.020649096,
0.01849062,
-0.0296701454,
-0.0525728054,
0.0244978163,
-0.0240761507,
0.0133363176,
0.0035490168,
-0.0402708016,
-0.0626752973,
-0.0579490401,
-0.06012436,
0.0392734483,
-0.0370596908,
-0.0111999512,
0.0625366792,
-0.0020314502,
-0.0532709695,
0.0286105964,
0.0012775889,
0.0082432749,
0.0164693538,
-0.0019561425,
-0.0096274782,
-0.013674059,
0.0272440407,
-0.0112980055,
-0.0125964405,
0.0116568394,
-0.0182389896,
-0.0081659565,
-0.0580328554,
-0.0443547927,
-0.0736988336,
0.0144383172,
-0.0120987799,
0.0109350979,
0.0502736568,
0.042921342,
-0.0060049472,
-0.0208421834,
-0.0974890217,
-0.01526633,
0.0440796949,
0.0132727278,
0.0630115047,
0.0663620234,
-0.0094096586,
-0.0464525335,
0.0008654929,
-0.022728201,
0.0258639064,
0.0361616835,
-0.0032500564,
-0.0411098525,
-0.0318704434,
-0.0369172581,
-0.0104540419,
0.0060333018,
-0.0244711637,
0.0045205792,
-0.0204552896,
0.0004584512,
0.0202506017,
0.0104972264,
0.0247951746,
0.0049997279,
0.0109752649,
-0.0346464925,
0.0433371626,
-0.0432399884,
-0.0213680584,
0.0117467083,
-0.0608623549,
0.0261879191,
0.0560167469,
0.0154986288,
-0.009771564,
-0.0302111451,
0.0192516129,
0.0233576857,
0.0220977329,
-0.045867186,
-0.0011988764,
-0.0325818397,
0.0708574057,
-0.0030923476,
-0.0134410691,
0.0958463177,
0.000358581,
-0.0008028357,
-0.0753126442,
-0.0159520116,
-0.0494802892,
0.0259762984,
-0.0214769561,
0.0185492896,
0.0026669304,
-0.0125614991,
-0.0166771151,
0.006327651,
-0.0124245174,
-0.0724407211,
0.0244599041,
-0.0242104176,
0.0235093832,
0.0154097732,
-0.0564222932,
-0.0609082878,
-0.0408316068,
-0.0303895548,
0.005877852,
0.0103397258,
0.0083596054,
0.0019391314,
0.0302660391,
0.0021749525,
0.0530597754,
-0.0089272624,
-0.0125150615,
-0.0142984567,
0.0831953064,
0.0818917379,
0.0483545288,
0.0025181116,
-0.0182394683,
0.0555813499,
0.0406051911,
0.0050806841,
0.0007730818,
0.0068192892,
-0.0129008573,
0.0004020721,
-0.0435259491,
0.0047244569,
0.0200347379,
0.0562130399,
-0.0667324066,
-0.0304540209,
0.0993624851,
0.0535906814,
-0.0263779089,
0.0087578669,
-0.0204716027,
-0.0001323276,
-0.0088811051,
0.0500519536,
-0.0725091249,
-0.041087728,
-0.0337462164,
0.0483005755,
-0.0116822608,
-0.011776654,
0.0253567547,
-0.0648751929,
0.0291919243,
-0.0293541253,
-0.072342813,
-0.0505435318,
-0.0233983379,
-0.0093026822,
0.0110317171,
-0.0113601387,
0.0227087494,
-0.0154598299,
0.0262283552,
0.0220452454,
-0.0363516212,
-0.0512323938,
0.0300603844,
-0.0088220211,
0.0394229032,
0.0737710819,
0.0152563369,
-0.0098187514,
-0.0352321677,
-0.0348410904,
-0.0493056104,
0.0101329954,
0.0193885192,
0.0944803357,
0.0235796887,
-0.0115191611,
-0.0432146005,
0.0679092035,
-0.0247626025,
-0.0062453025,
0.0282460041,
0.0583484285,
-0.0190348495,
-0.0071097217,
-0.0244329032,
0.0105896369,
0.0095957555,
0.0860800594,
0.0504619069,
-0.0022600561,
-0.043481715,
0.0108725689,
0.0404661261,
-0.0734354556,
-0.007479927,
0.0220948625,
0.0224224906,
-0.0005861252,
-0.0697284564,
-0.0471821018,
0.0628213733,
0.0060212091,
-0.0133592542,
0.0231957175,
-0.0244147778,
0.0153690455,
-0.0592290275,
0.0268819872,
0.0174007416,
-0.0185640343,
-0.0257627051,
-0.068875365,
0.0452518836,
-0.0176574048,
-0.0274522994,
-0.0115761003,
-0.0156074194,
-0.0035812627,
-0.0138013111,
0.0533675551,
0.0199408885,
0.0292525385,
-0.0057221497,
-0.0087079015,
0.0023558759,
0.0517405197,
-0.0536584854,
-0.0500671789,
0.0073824865,
-0.0048266375,
-0.0106901117,
0.0425027013,
-0.0230873004,
-0.0005227391,
-0.001207491,
0.0436689891,
-0.0686804876,
-0.0342301689,
0.0546300039,
0.0501659922,
0.0133050326,
-0.0102852341,
-0.0207650624,
-0.0169061366,
0.0328274965,
-0.037327975,
-0.0046508606,
-0.0500250533,
0.0222723261,
0.0007148645,
-0.041475974,
0.0159321371,
-0.0241117738,
-0.0477775373,
-0.0104151089,
-0.0581241027,
0.0227755345,
0.0099222325,
-0.0120198289,
0.0166817885,
-0.0329507813,
-0.0178042091,
-0.0025373264,
0.0352734998,
0.0571080409,
-0.0070560984,
0.0600797124,
0.0023856028,
0.0170060806,
0.0019965742,
0.0374212563,
-0.0795557797,
-0.050136365,
-0.0157913156,
0.0252163298,
0.0103155961,
0.0100932913,
0.0159107354,
0.0058669141,
-0.0211667977,
0.0064992411,
0.0288379397,
-0.0026997405,
0.0118972901,
0.0696668029,
0.0225878209,
-0.0199750755,
-0.0397025645,
0.0846622586,
-0.0089461207,
0.0367779545,
0.0042350804,
-0.0420167819,
-0.0508230478,
0.000519129,
0.0077945255,
-0.0016849573,
-0.0194954649,
0.0080025978,
-0.0386040881,
-0.0422252491,
-0.0061975224,
-0.019235881,
-0.0365019217,
-0.0094067054,
0.0557347201,
0.060289748,
0.0063000866,
-0.051364243,
-0.0540467687,
0.0680947527,
-0.0331278481,
-0.0084038228,
0.0143223153,
-6.175422838e-33,
0.0071925898,
-0.0254788268,
0.0330094472,
-0.0487613343,
0.0068863737,
0.0315028504,
-0.0569927171,
-0.0142484978,
-0.027463207,
0.0220357887,
-0.0293645598,
0.0137756029,
0.0066830381,
0.056887649,
-0.0213253759,
-0.0498132482,
0.0256398469,
0.0181445573,
-0.0166803207,
0.0577331781,
0.0070479396,
0.0432472453,
0.0142050423,
-0.0522988699,
0.0092669139,
-0.0297732297,
0.026623223,
0.0149431713,
0.0040423512,
0.0839187875,
-0.0272729974,
0.02616865,
0.0443680249,
-0.0346068889,
0.0183243025,
0.0135938348,
-0.0929260328,
-0.0249749385,
0.005939241,
-0.0465428755,
-0.0715017989,
-0.0470739454,
0.0630115941,
-0.0238044709,
0.0098074628,
-0.0198740959,
0.0145200677,
-0.0403788872,
0.009105606,
-0.0376559719,
-0.0081425672,
0.0282610636,
-0.0145090185,
-0.01117454,
-0.0158413108,
0.0292061642,
-0.0273949169,
0.0416170098,
0.0100479452,
-0.0249663349,
0.0764739364,
0.0280657392,
0.0168249905,
-0.0046756137,
-0.0328959525,
0.0133815175,
-0.0005677002,
-0.0500666834,
-0.0561739355,
0.0488938056,
-0.0835115165,
0.0514481738,
0.0708607435,
0.0473581553,
0.041760195,
0.0011982461,
-0.0697507486,
0.0616577342,
-0.0406049378,
0.0198054314,
0.0149429142,
-0.0317962989,
-0.0414391086,
-0.0009181713,
-0.0195341986,
0.0400137007,
-0.0226217639,
-0.031390138,
0.0506718308,
-0.0077866171,
-0.0369044431,
0.0139749087,
-0.0039194836,
-0.0232867803,
0.021589933,
-0.0101875644,
-0.0072504878,
-0.0055059502,
-0.0250889212,
0.002833365,
-0.0370945968,
0.0122448262,
0.0279271789,
-0.0065668137,
0.0323283225,
0.0498230793,
0.0122735044,
-0.0409776196,
-0.0564984642,
0.0005576113,
-0.015300177,
0.020187974,
-0.0717220753,
0.0037722776,
0.0056950366,
0.0683131441,
-0.0145617444,
0.0286566168,
0.0067345677,
0.0140314605,
-0.0443061292,
-0.0681671873,
0.002903885,
0.0153775923,
-0.0424778238,
0.0054301354,
-0.0267951861,
0.0363330208,
-0.005686678,
-0.0445364974,
-0.0058713686,
0.0076086083,
2.537e-7,
0.1058653146,
0.0337829255,
0.0320326388,
-0.0106868474,
0.010930636,
-0.0059625483,
0.045910079,
-0.0230078977,
0.0121411113,
-0.0322839953,
0.0369041078,
0.0345370993,
0.027136948,
0.0407363586,
-0.0514667258,
-0.0268611107,
-0.0837189704,
-0.0280211978,
-0.033647906,
-0.0260817092,
0.1085691079,
0.0698392838,
-0.0482247695,
-0.0150508126,
-0.0144526716,
-0.0198029969,
0.0213606246,
-0.0155468117,
0.0165800415,
0.0733295977,
0.0602250919,
0.0037190025,
0.0356747508,
0.0509978496,
-0.0196094625,
0.002938098,
-0.0012345694,
0.0841413811,
-0.0465984344,
-0.0204289015,
-0.0136669828,
-0.0065543866,
0.040840622,
-0.0661792308,
0.0890556872,
-0.0595516823,
-0.0398724526,
0.0154632451,
-0.0512139127,
-0.0189626738,
0.0164548475,
-0.0272880644,
-0.0393604785,
0.0511134788,
0.0169433095,
0.0067404341,
-0.0044662082,
-0.0627726614,
-0.0140805338,
0.0262301099,
-0.0131076025,
-0.0068508065,
-0.0015529559,
-0.03213403,
-0.0231680088,
-0.0587909147,
0.0009933716,
2.41214104e-34,
0.0099591408,
0.0370278917,
0.0182123706,
0.0652911216,
0.040668752,
-0.0054364139,
0.0190884676,
0.0145137291,
0.0309302937,
-0.0692532808,
-0.0016822779
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03549v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03549v4 | Holmes: Towards Distributed Training Across Clusters with Heterogeneous NIC Environment | 2023-12-06T15:27:26 | 2024-04-29T06:56:25 | Fei Yang, Shuang Peng, Ning Sun, Fangyu Wang, Yuanyuan Wang, Fu Wu, Jiezhong Qiu, Aimin Pan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.DC | Large language models (LLMs) such as GPT-3, OPT, and LLaMA have demonstrated
remarkable accuracy in a wide range of tasks. However, training these models
can incur significant expenses, often requiring tens of thousands of GPUs for
months of continuous operation. Typically, this training is carried out in
specialized GPU clusters equipped with homogeneous high-speed Remote Direct
Memory Access (RDMA) network interface cards (NICs). The acquisition and
maintenance of such dedicated clusters is challenging. Current LLM training
frameworks, like Megatron-LM and Megatron-DeepSpeed, focus primarily on
optimizing training within homogeneous cluster settings. In this paper, we
introduce Holmes, a training framework for LLMs that employs thoughtfully
crafted data and model parallelism strategies over the heterogeneous NIC
environment. Our primary technical contribution lies in a novel scheduling
method that intelligently allocates distinct computational tasklets in LLM
training to specific groups of GPU devices based on the characteristics of
their connected NICs. Furthermore, our proposed framework, utilizing pipeline
parallel techniques, demonstrates scalability to multiple GPU clusters, even in
scenarios without high-speed interconnects between nodes in distinct clusters.
We conducted comprehensive experiments that involved various scenarios in the
heterogeneous NIC environment. In most cases, our framework achieves
performance levels close to those achievable with homogeneous RDMA-capable
networks (InfiniBand or RoCE), significantly exceeding training efficiency
within the pure Ethernet environment. Additionally, we verified that our
framework outperforms other mainstream LLM frameworks under heterogeneous NIC
environment in terms of training efficiency and can be seamlessly integrated
with them. | [
0.0126323206,
0.0362616293,
-0.0302696191,
0.0497816503,
-0.0326411426,
0.0160100292,
0.0386183076,
-0.0121328849,
0.0045179236,
-0.0057899416,
-0.0068666772,
-0.030892903,
-0.005350044,
0.0082700839,
0.0117492266,
-0.0710407943,
0.0259702373,
-0.0400014184,
-0.0314512774,
-0.0104951365,
0.035443157,
0.0255443826,
0.001977544,
0.0119067244,
-0.022309104,
-0.0690854639,
-0.0146065857,
0.0292361733,
-0.0081847068,
0.0050328276,
0.041294679,
0.0049897865,
0.0516089387,
0.0323444977,
0.0000022058,
0.0102741383,
-0.034501072,
-0.0126705784,
0.0170557983,
0.0631603226,
0.0446227118,
-0.010014113,
-0.0313859731,
0.0227227341,
-0.0055214837,
-0.0234028921,
0.0444803536,
-0.0146055045,
0.0406533666,
0.0386720672,
-0.0071279858,
-0.0030443908,
0.0024966868,
-0.039689254,
-0.0497144274,
0.0120057371,
0.0086282548,
0.0366210379,
-0.0012115984,
-0.0541632548,
-0.0324339941,
0.0038483778,
0.0280786548,
0.0079887314,
-0.0052715447,
0.0207466632,
-0.0424667038,
0.007812215,
-0.0476486534,
0.0261932332,
-0.0894162804,
-0.0299009215,
-0.0019685554,
0.0000228658,
-0.065162085,
-0.026918361,
0.0000373082,
0.0142238112,
0.0124295447,
-0.0062155039,
0.0234134309,
-0.0016897317,
0.0111979265,
-0.0030260847,
0.0083065405,
0.0571960472,
0.0396307558,
0.0090907654,
-0.0350074209,
0.0230231881,
-0.0071819536,
-0.0174706448,
0.0350451767,
0.0155516118,
-0.039205879,
0.038400609,
-0.0633511543,
-0.0394201279,
0.0037959346,
-0.0044256565,
0.0305013563,
0.0297211707,
0.000512349,
0.0266994014,
-0.0713765249,
0.0204317607,
-0.028163977,
-0.0071040755,
-0.0418991596,
-0.0149792787,
-0.0254175831,
-0.0171353109,
-0.045785591,
0.0290931575,
-0.0529724024,
-0.0231523588,
-0.0283067916,
0.0404527858,
-0.0398434289,
-0.0254485067,
0.0204345528,
0.0209116116,
-0.0247341897,
-0.0167760849,
0.0043515507,
0.0440325737,
-0.0323501267,
0.024237724,
-0.0079316022,
-0.0783009902,
-0.0032774366,
0.0422750227,
-0.0406196713,
0.0244982075,
0.037322063,
0.0656783506,
-0.0455605611,
-0.0279076807,
-0.0326428562,
-0.0103643062,
0.0516592152,
-0.0593391545,
-0.0326613672,
-0.0555353649,
0.0185882896,
-0.0018834451,
0.0366910808,
0.0029245561,
-0.0013521834,
-0.0064471806,
0.0211705025,
0.0335002132,
-0.009677045,
0.0138235828,
0.0677500665,
0.0008730082,
0.0114003979,
0.0673121661,
0.0241621844,
0.0106870895,
0.00477518,
-0.0219496489,
-0.0285556987,
0.0601734482,
0.019714769,
0.0442886129,
-0.0433971807,
0.0417646617,
0.0625159517,
0.0437966771,
0.0498690121,
0.0724325776,
-0.0313457735,
-0.0062756301,
0.055628743,
0.0737066343,
-0.0330691263,
0.0073576844,
0.0320098288,
0.0285404362,
-0.0191744585,
-0.0358897373,
-0.0185160358,
0.004549237,
0.0785043463,
0.0129405931,
0.0663105026,
0.0756888688,
-0.0143677052,
0.0190009642,
0.0016777659,
-0.0128221484,
-0.0291501191,
0.0045724772,
0.0455625989,
-0.0210552178,
-0.0688991025,
0.0103264675,
0.0667801127,
-0.0267748944,
-0.0105419178,
-0.0192370936,
0.0164803471,
0.0499819368,
0.024789257,
-0.0101304539,
-0.0668923706,
-0.0137778278,
0.0073981932,
0.0458938144,
0.0218430459,
-0.0103852246,
-0.0084918346,
-0.0533088669,
0.0157257356,
0.0493903719,
-0.0079586701,
0.0404366329,
0.0533501841,
-0.0000905576,
-0.0235062279,
0.0100665614,
-0.0745806843,
0.0255039204,
-0.0038457706,
-0.0022687986,
0.0001580439,
-0.0022666389,
0.0475447066,
-0.0617288984,
-0.0216026418,
-0.0498579815,
0.0239099879,
-0.0285988878,
0.0183764938,
-0.0211826507,
-0.0429918095,
0.0266952459,
0.0236133058,
-0.0042738812,
0.024052307,
0.0426911972,
-0.0567135401,
-0.0563684553,
0.0367216058,
-0.0016944179,
0.0335187875,
-0.0281497631,
-0.0025361492,
0.0010105524,
0.0204410162,
-0.0212595016,
0.0267564375,
0.0150772445,
-0.0257493462,
0.0221384503,
-0.0152119296,
0.0248006452,
-0.0535187721,
0.016393818,
-0.0059393723,
0.0042118886,
0.0487140752,
-0.0278432984,
-0.0101957731,
0.0044737021,
0.0211043097,
-0.077145502,
0.0328700766,
-0.0447680689,
0.0446023196,
0.0511518121,
0.0148922922,
-0.0127518279,
-0.0611641593,
0.0121453749,
0.0408668406,
0.0217014477,
0.0200088602,
-0.0301619638,
0.0115705123,
-0.0486661233,
-0.0111395847,
-0.0451229103,
0.0073263342,
0.0669311807,
-0.0131673338,
-0.0302802697,
-0.017658392,
0.0060358932,
-0.0059954943,
0.0655763224,
-0.0170200374,
-0.0023023654,
0.0062261955,
0.0076518143,
0.0002466133,
0.0338703357,
-0.0072850599,
-0.0572427213,
0.0046721376,
0.0021641792,
-0.0653916001,
0.0381368548,
-0.0081364224,
-0.0305699129,
-0.0124660572,
-0.0064009959,
-0.0216311216,
0.0804977491,
-0.0318985544,
-0.00869992,
-0.0258302614,
-0.0537290014,
-0.0355644934,
-0.0198017452,
-0.0337080881,
-0.0226231683,
0.0089440476,
-0.0268696304,
-0.0094959978,
-0.0994930416,
0.0223493613,
-0.0450192019,
-0.0252239499,
-0.0579499304,
-0.0792053863,
-0.0375276394,
0.0415037386,
0.0110882325,
0.0315785967,
-0.0569901094,
-0.0175491702,
0.0041008852,
0.017346235,
-0.0317760929,
0.0081020026,
0.0424542949,
-0.0404343158,
0.0297513809,
-0.0631353483,
-0.0520147495,
-0.0005720389,
0.0324528515,
-0.0247360636,
0.0285466406,
0.0225530509,
-0.037527319,
0.0034139052,
0.0692413822,
-0.0178532563,
0.0837055072,
-0.0344919264,
-0.0122346189,
-0.0117628817,
0.008838322,
0.0462530218,
-0.0132832453,
-0.0331353508,
-0.0084656365,
-0.0208568797,
0.0321820639,
0.0500165783,
-0.0539841168,
-0.0912440643,
-0.0146380169,
0.0114167472,
-0.0487927012,
0.0053901384,
0.0336658694,
0.0224464163,
-0.1010262147,
-0.0288238768,
0.0252821241,
-0.013075388,
-0.0973157138,
-0.0128880525,
0.0486426167,
0.0787963644,
0.0195921846,
0.0743760541,
-0.07828217,
-0.0134911165,
-0.0139714377,
0.0245545357,
0.0197324343,
0.0012871964,
-0.0237285327,
-0.0947563276,
0.027645329,
0.0169971306,
-0.0746698529,
-0.0044177929,
-0.0574151613,
-0.0178244058,
0.0172870718,
0.0299003925,
0.0110282833,
0.0023776209,
-0.0030794097,
0.0416972674,
-0.0075983596,
-0.0091016367,
0.0188917443,
-0.0261170026,
0.0303156655,
0.0110041313,
-0.0678687915,
0.0175958667,
-0.0142514082,
0.0133976331,
0.0156172765,
0.0114680957,
-0.0139629021,
0.0172093324,
-0.040332336,
-0.0108982688,
-0.0083024269,
-0.0075115915,
-0.0355391279,
-0.0046111783,
0.0320666283,
0.1342124641,
-0.0104777478,
0.0017706961,
-0.013462346,
-0.0357553773,
0.0495634042,
0.0344363153,
-0.0224101171,
-0.017350398,
-0.02833125,
-0.0427972153,
-0.0106941042,
-0.0083965482,
0.0014165022,
-0.038034562,
-0.0052509815,
0.0081220381,
0.0083796857,
0.0154223647,
0.0252155624,
0.0265931766,
0.042758625,
-0.0371082202,
0.0438007824,
0.0120074209,
-0.1031463295,
0.0537591726,
-0.0639991686,
0.0071601369,
-0.0684116855,
-0.0213504955,
0.0499333702,
-0.0241275821,
-0.0079846065,
0.0166747663,
-0.0803557709,
-0.0554328188,
-0.0091951247,
0.0430636592,
0.0167122949,
0.0838025883,
0.0177865177,
-0.046739053,
0.0200827774,
0.0245204233,
-0.0766541511,
0.0275629368,
0.0041700187,
-0.0516956598,
-0.0089477459,
-0.0022628461,
-0.0353841782,
0.0533312857,
0.0356672816,
-0.0146076446,
-0.0066006426,
0.0113751506,
-0.0258274581,
-0.0165981762,
0.0054040994,
-0.004837946,
0.012739554,
-0.0301715024,
0.0409128852,
0.0487772971,
0.030376656,
-0.0196861792,
-0.0193236414,
0.0120352302,
0.0344540626,
-0.0016155413,
-0.0317283869,
0.0805513039,
-0.0057135429,
-0.0320100673,
-0.0228935797,
-0.0026338045,
-0.0050177602,
0.0294997506,
0.0126857338,
0.0244321506,
-0.0156360492,
-0.0275947656,
0.0528274998,
-0.0461626574,
0.0272930171,
0.0022151091,
-0.015929522,
-0.0114162015,
0.001367787,
0.0137574505,
-0.082464762,
-0.0384508409,
-0.0095476834,
0.0659121722,
0.0245688241,
0.0073132543,
-0.0424968824,
0.0210805666,
-0.0185716357,
-0.0065276264,
-0.0493229479,
-0.0075889933,
0.0346139967,
0.017421281,
0.0014448328,
0.0495619066,
0.0194850359,
-0.014692639,
0.0295933709,
0.0273411889,
0.0123979002,
-0.039909143,
-0.0297734216,
0.0137197524,
0.0225809738,
-0.038391646,
-0.0515760444,
0.0160904024,
-0.0021082438,
0.0043829172,
0.0153432749,
0.0060258126,
-0.0585057028,
0.0401588641,
0.0655446723,
0.0051791146,
-0.0110105127,
-0.0322057493,
0.0512307249,
-0.0136284688,
0.0352302529,
0.0111539401,
-6.251382548e-33,
0.0193477198,
-0.0009515296,
0.0677136257,
0.0171150509,
-0.0067685959,
0.061514575,
-0.024673041,
-0.0375408977,
0.0109547088,
0.0037628675,
-0.0041908794,
0.0153459245,
0.0329020135,
0.0233054329,
0.0184127372,
0.0043941014,
0.0393913649,
-0.0252863076,
-0.0312150437,
0.073380813,
0.0050040577,
0.0415946655,
0.0534489267,
-0.0365616791,
-0.0454283878,
-0.0292526744,
0.0502667725,
0.0020649426,
-0.018155396,
0.0239941087,
-0.0466735885,
0.0354034528,
0.0007216622,
-0.0901601017,
-0.0028680209,
0.0212654602,
-0.0622675642,
0.0143358391,
0.0046341191,
0.0283776131,
-0.0569627397,
-0.0179044437,
0.0081186565,
0.0537237674,
-0.0216809064,
-0.0071597709,
-0.0054520257,
0.0336545072,
-0.047807347,
0.0002829153,
-0.0260991305,
0.0168334357,
0.0152904196,
0.0483790562,
0.0478224158,
-0.0699664354,
-0.0150965285,
0.0183334928,
-0.0776718706,
0.0168061331,
-0.0153190065,
0.0472516045,
0.0890654325,
0.0238856785,
0.0155298784,
0.0560710803,
0.0726776496,
0.0267971754,
0.0290324297,
0.0510278381,
0.0450016297,
0.0185318105,
-0.0003869998,
-0.0144362804,
-0.0090860575,
-0.0020836052,
-0.0669148266,
-0.0581020489,
0.030649757,
-0.006845389,
0.0331300423,
0.025470132,
-0.0264928304,
-0.0318501815,
-0.009546754,
-0.0198339224,
0.0047525871,
-0.0058350838,
0.0338672586,
0.0550746694,
-0.0175592955,
0.0246939026,
0.0568444133,
-0.002576465,
0.0250262897,
0.016032666,
0.017797187,
0.0343476497,
0.021846462,
0.0462466963,
-0.0551915094,
-0.0685711652,
-0.046806924,
-0.0273172669,
0.0458634868,
-0.0241346918,
0.0275076739,
0.0457911231,
-0.0762551799,
0.0280706044,
-0.046267271,
0.0658862069,
0.0030196088,
0.0905741975,
0.0438556783,
0.018110171,
0.0225031059,
0.043704927,
-0.0306278616,
-0.0488959067,
-0.0018656321,
0.0121459989,
-0.0218164623,
0.0007885495,
-0.0395377651,
0.018822046,
-0.0646554753,
-0.0006688959,
0.0288220961,
-0.0657365918,
-0.0004130465,
0.0157428309,
2.892e-7,
-0.0282464046,
0.0495257676,
0.0200018715,
0.0157478079,
0.009174102,
-0.0029971439,
0.01445744,
-0.0001863162,
0.0687647611,
0.0246077441,
-0.0106188282,
0.0301176123,
0.0348327495,
0.0101098176,
-0.0654393062,
-0.0118540563,
-0.039858371,
0.0476704426,
-0.0399200544,
-0.0188361797,
-0.0636227727,
0.0734457672,
0.0043211398,
-0.0225103032,
0.0385657921,
-0.0214676745,
-0.0178302675,
-0.0096691027,
-0.0141246822,
0.0403499901,
0.0062664989,
0.0690119863,
-0.065751031,
0.0508022383,
0.0008779285,
0.0092842206,
-0.0575746335,
0.0843036696,
0.0067982255,
0.0416409373,
0.020069249,
-0.0219910052,
-0.0508367494,
-0.0444669724,
0.0118470369,
-0.0032696207,
0.0215767268,
-0.0486086011,
-0.0049950676,
-0.0341617391,
0.0001379933,
-0.0027884056,
0.0552000366,
0.0302285943,
0.0257702544,
-0.0366866067,
-0.0400158912,
-0.0275899339,
-0.0152193317,
-0.0039715078,
-0.0612315685,
-0.0425064452,
-0.0715719834,
0.0200503003,
0.0117765805,
-0.0169405937,
0.0025103602,
2.804303634e-34,
0.0139646735,
0.0194108356,
0.0053956048,
0.0668732375,
-0.0124186529,
-0.0450155698,
-0.0409700647,
-0.0099063311,
-0.0299733188,
-0.0879110619,
-0.021969419
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.14945v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.14945v1 | Empowering ChatGPT-Like Large-Scale Language Models with Local Knowledge Base for Industrial Prognostics and Health Management | 2023-12-06T15:24:01 | 2023-12-06T15:24:01 | Huan Wang, Yan-Fu Li, Min Xie | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL | Prognostics and health management (PHM) is essential for industrial operation
and maintenance, focusing on predicting, diagnosing, and managing the health
status of industrial systems. The emergence of the ChatGPT-Like large-scale
language model (LLM) has begun to lead a new round of innovation in the AI
field. It has extensively promoted the level of intelligence in various fields.
Therefore, it is also expected further to change the application paradigm in
industrial PHM and promote PHM to become intelligent. Although ChatGPT-Like
LLMs have rich knowledge reserves and powerful language understanding and
generation capabilities, they lack domain-specific expertise, significantly
limiting their practicability in PHM applications. To this end, this study
explores the ChatGPT-Like LLM empowered by the local knowledge base (LKB) in
industrial PHM to solve the above limitations. In addition, we introduce the
method and steps of combining the LKB with LLMs, including LKB preparation, LKB
vectorization, prompt engineering, etc. Experimental analysis of real cases
shows that combining the LKB with ChatGPT-Like LLM can significantly improve
its performance and make ChatGPT-Like LLMs more accurate, relevant, and able to
provide more insightful information. This can promote the development of
ChatGPT-Like LLMs in industrial PHM and promote their efficiency and quality. | [
0.0059818863,
0.0141651304,
-0.0284404792,
0.0318621919,
-0.0130149927,
-0.0123100029,
0.0006510594,
0.0548705757,
0.0537721738,
-0.0110523095,
0.0039518797,
-0.0013159883,
-0.0414422005,
0.067070514,
0.0050643776,
-0.0136323525,
0.0187409148,
0.0008269588,
0.0102422563,
0.0091611911,
-0.0114268186,
0.0151905138,
-0.00028473,
0.0511450544,
-0.0024192729,
0.0113280639,
-0.0038906019,
-0.0053167604,
0.0343332589,
-0.0293826591,
-0.001060683,
-0.0154021019,
0.0340420119,
-0.0089824004,
0.0000022912,
-0.0407520831,
-0.0482877009,
0.0111420592,
-0.0324933119,
-0.0246453714,
0.0167411231,
-0.0156941433,
-0.0062855361,
0.0401697904,
-0.0736617967,
0.0072243437,
0.023665471,
0.0591516048,
0.041600626,
0.0692969188,
-0.0058588409,
0.0119770486,
0.068357937,
-0.0076622753,
-0.0294530764,
-0.0615294725,
0.0258983932,
0.0372187011,
0.065792881,
-0.0106120631,
0.0139569184,
0.0566194654,
0.0259579029,
-0.0079337247,
-0.0319292471,
0.0397577286,
0.0085217068,
0.0417950414,
-0.0154837873,
0.0223448519,
-0.0236726217,
-0.0094126649,
0.0476325639,
-0.0181872249,
0.0109778279,
-0.0123468153,
-0.0319918729,
0.0034374101,
-0.0198091455,
0.0176243465,
0.0104441661,
0.0193714406,
0.0031240792,
-0.0199068319,
-0.0163572207,
0.0951180533,
-0.0206705909,
-0.0252957921,
-0.0367333554,
-0.0390724503,
-0.0179347619,
-0.0157722887,
0.0096050538,
0.0774827972,
-0.044428654,
0.019978622,
0.0128663722,
0.0372022055,
0.0255929958,
-0.0965725556,
-0.0440941192,
0.0362927578,
-0.0182427857,
0.0246398449,
0.0015272603,
0.0161338095,
0.0021116263,
-0.0058343965,
-0.0413595773,
-0.0080104871,
-0.0885772035,
-0.0506627262,
-0.0424650796,
0.0194049664,
0.0199352968,
0.0009718627,
-0.0327204801,
0.0250289869,
-0.0120576276,
0.0060072825,
0.0484243594,
-0.003350389,
0.007286598,
-0.0192567036,
-0.0686976165,
0.0194780063,
0.0097200368,
0.0029881643,
-0.0452609323,
-0.0680325776,
0.0329407752,
0.0303031988,
-0.0372737721,
0.017084172,
-0.0087459935,
0.0824386626,
0.0155451512,
0.0143242013,
-0.0577156954,
-0.0342600271,
-0.014415022,
-0.0513515696,
-0.0336467326,
-0.0260096584,
0.0462571383,
-0.0118311979,
0.0006109034,
-0.0350147374,
0.0067788842,
-0.0209294613,
0.0086582853,
0.0169742703,
-0.0776854455,
0.0222074091,
0.0142917512,
0.0163888354,
-0.0125135053,
0.0606287457,
0.0418593436,
0.0001036764,
-0.0023802107,
-0.0013608303,
-0.0054477407,
0.0188938081,
-0.0117249768,
-0.0189382844,
-0.0139166806,
-0.0010493732,
-0.0140219592,
-0.0027887397,
-0.0221115313,
-0.0066117099,
0.0220843349,
0.0231366679,
0.0392887965,
-0.0184716675,
0.0469285175,
0.0390762426,
0.0718807355,
0.056792818,
-0.0272013508,
-0.0454139039,
-0.000108398,
-0.0014852685,
-0.0604404472,
-0.0003296366,
-0.0135252643,
0.0235495642,
-0.0061245654,
-0.0583795384,
-0.0319716781,
-0.0068568187,
-0.0320278071,
-0.0234651044,
0.06773296,
-0.0268554781,
-0.0291825309,
0.0419288166,
0.044369176,
0.0134522105,
-0.0031851358,
-0.0804317743,
0.0048636142,
0.1141590849,
0.0521573499,
-0.0910640433,
-0.0528453775,
0.0179649945,
-0.029147882,
0.0137376282,
0.0302147921,
0.0228465088,
-0.037370611,
-0.0314328112,
-0.022694001,
0.0484177545,
0.0143986233,
-0.0191903356,
-0.0674267635,
0.0171558131,
-0.0173905548,
-0.0167565234,
-0.0436916649,
0.0007150382,
-0.0092399269,
0.02245491,
-0.0338726938,
0.0054819304,
0.0298047215,
0.0434843712,
0.0022536914,
0.0128410663,
0.0605850331,
-0.0436227173,
-0.1074899212,
0.0498857759,
-0.0349378958,
-0.0236403905,
0.0199030489,
0.0532401428,
0.0230689235,
-0.0579971187,
-0.0393109135,
-0.058336135,
-0.0144293252,
-0.0090005435,
0.0522504002,
-0.0139619512,
-0.0013161958,
-0.0065593109,
-0.0149386041,
-0.0289165024,
0.0632643774,
0.0130449412,
-0.0350805596,
-0.0043935571,
0.0080427965,
0.0113490922,
-0.0635828599,
-0.0241514333,
0.0470069349,
-0.008361889,
0.0277894456,
0.0201003198,
0.0505949892,
-0.0103807421,
0.0111182295,
-0.1358386129,
0.0055256709,
-0.0118424734,
0.0228280816,
0.0165432319,
-0.0193017498,
-0.0287095848,
0.0007481592,
-0.0375923775,
0.0460181236,
-0.0003237567,
-0.016944116,
0.0421899445,
0.0406138077,
-0.0270447098,
0.0104737235,
0.0221146494,
-0.0305690933,
0.0228927825,
0.0251139887,
-0.0149241053,
-0.1036337391,
0.0470897555,
-0.0364637524,
0.0063654389,
-0.0270314496,
-0.0340016261,
-0.0297575686,
-0.0642996505,
0.0295941271,
-0.0128982374,
-0.0486861505,
-0.00720233,
0.0271159336,
-0.0180146694,
-0.0542954728,
0.0213206112,
-0.0712371394,
-0.0063042976,
-0.0149975726,
-0.0033894421,
-0.0131725548,
0.0254396647,
0.0366178378,
0.0131651284,
-0.0577840805,
0.0236156974,
-0.0168895051,
0.0359471887,
-0.046847757,
0.0097829523,
0.0001238181,
0.0515761189,
0.0382736102,
-0.0399513468,
0.0508529097,
-0.0018347525,
0.0200451799,
-0.055936195,
-0.0729333162,
-0.0471202061,
0.0213856995,
-0.0510602593,
0.0215517469,
0.0013588832,
-0.0071891691,
-0.0260069128,
0.0262108762,
-0.041808974,
-0.0089093922,
-0.028865872,
-0.0554110222,
0.0521111153,
0.0296203271,
-0.0143600786,
-0.0224566925,
0.0263782181,
-0.0502356179,
0.0241680387,
-0.0094284229,
0.0101009859,
-0.0157253742,
0.0641918778,
0.0009518807,
0.0358192436,
0.0020079359,
-0.013811673,
-0.0053245369,
-0.0058928723,
0.0049803536,
0.0166406874,
0.0402126722,
0.0409626588,
0.0690305829,
0.0257544108,
0.0113486759,
-0.0386271141,
-0.0390273631,
0.0041092862,
-0.006543701,
-0.0092677595,
-0.032477472,
0.018594224,
-0.0286100954,
-0.0598941259,
0.0083279563,
0.0998332724,
0.0118743507,
-0.021491373,
0.0227571409,
-0.0221294984,
-0.0266174618,
-0.0197942071,
0.029060524,
-0.0486718304,
-0.0286561809,
-0.001670018,
0.0246589072,
0.0097649451,
-0.0158659332,
0.0017161978,
-0.0439919494,
0.0524148531,
-0.0165879484,
-0.0383473411,
-0.0873304605,
-0.0370568186,
-0.013394082,
-0.0290562753,
0.0147416955,
0.0340871774,
0.0109145744,
-0.0240288731,
0.0320931189,
-0.1159231514,
-0.0776447728,
0.0262263939,
0.0020734312,
0.062730968,
0.087648727,
0.0129688652,
0.0080591924,
0.0237736385,
0.0020976923,
0.0529518723,
0.0777845979,
-0.0636584759,
0.0229920615,
0.0276490096,
-0.017414568,
-0.0219928101,
0.0094227158,
-0.0594421141,
0.0054454547,
0.0473873802,
0.1044098586,
-0.0514444821,
-0.0445761532,
-0.0269024912,
0.0216237195,
0.0325123742,
0.04883378,
-0.0312569402,
-0.0399268344,
-0.0377848595,
0.0114175128,
-0.0138952611,
0.0172224063,
-0.0429855958,
0.0025056088,
-0.0687149093,
-0.0302586816,
-0.0651239529,
-0.0371616818,
0.0344850607,
0.0067711999,
-0.0017554492,
0.0116341943,
0.0325055942,
0.0067171045,
-0.024611719,
-0.0117038973,
-0.0281957928,
0.0226671081,
-0.0317752212,
-0.0090022851,
0.0643879026,
-0.0257748608,
-0.0335045718,
0.01275618,
-0.0382263288,
-0.0544293821,
0.0264700055,
0.0538982935,
0.0252946597,
-0.0095233852,
-0.0134797804,
-0.0172057077,
0.095593743,
0.0161504485,
-0.0553783178,
0.0093585243,
-0.0234662443,
0.038625259,
0.0088320868,
0.006989345,
-0.0571985394,
0.0284019522,
-0.000592667,
0.0623204783,
-0.0156469326,
-0.0063883411,
-0.0359479226,
0.0496230498,
-0.0069005489,
0.0113211572,
-0.0555764697,
-0.0146538904,
0.0392072387,
-0.0021938737,
-0.0098253386,
-0.040588174,
0.0701373741,
-0.0158627648,
-0.038968917,
0.0338592418,
-0.0091168722,
-0.0075229299,
-0.0464325659,
-0.0070503387,
0.014486149,
0.0126170022,
0.0201436952,
0.093721956,
0.0077577666,
0.0120503791,
0.0129293203,
0.0135681657,
-0.0111394292,
-0.0015960425,
0.0548837408,
0.0059429784,
-0.0341382511,
-0.037624374,
0.0382489711,
-0.0273954794,
-0.0915320143,
-0.0155959539,
0.0715383068,
0.0764732957,
0.058706712,
0.0338315554,
-0.0813241452,
0.0172587093,
-0.010174959,
0.001854904,
0.0301892813,
0.0297551285,
0.0356599651,
0.0003343305,
-0.0598650873,
-0.0182447303,
0.0886789784,
0.0228452552,
0.0391938537,
-0.0221943073,
-0.0269772559,
-0.0570366085,
-0.0174207613,
0.0655977055,
0.016122425,
-0.0288968608,
0.0024440354,
-0.0948178396,
-0.017859675,
0.0363089889,
0.0099389646,
-0.0332637578,
-0.0385469794,
0.0401545204,
0.0351435989,
0.0280805957,
0.0376778841,
-0.0066753905,
0.0037523271,
-0.036862243,
0.0034367025,
-0.0063731135,
-6.624259642e-33,
-0.0228794478,
-0.053851705,
0.0313011296,
0.023705136,
-0.0136778755,
0.0097810999,
0.0116458451,
-0.0139948912,
0.0465448983,
0.0217631776,
0.0023017379,
0.0090828585,
0.0046914546,
-0.0235128086,
0.0279118977,
-0.0385878012,
0.0025125917,
0.0067089112,
0.000386388,
0.0477022119,
0.0673664287,
0.0345207974,
0.0536471941,
-0.050311178,
0.03593098,
-0.0009294976,
-0.0122815911,
0.0336482786,
-0.0313678794,
0.0468863845,
-0.0235054847,
0.0842002481,
0.0284424294,
-0.0304043517,
-0.0324338898,
0.0027177818,
0.0165182091,
-0.0417530313,
0.0184820704,
-0.0135548497,
0.0314234942,
-0.01334312,
0.0183393303,
0.0074436227,
-0.0119189462,
0.0320540108,
0.0218572654,
-0.024096502,
0.018517632,
-0.0484803356,
-0.0046302611,
0.0421339199,
-0.0235220231,
0.0145092895,
0.0111860912,
-0.0065108989,
0.001637697,
0.0032922467,
-0.0624652952,
-0.0099373814,
0.0164687056,
0.017006157,
0.0668113679,
-0.0292238854,
-0.0103884488,
0.011434488,
-0.0175527632,
0.0127876103,
-0.0059443666,
0.0022183708,
-0.0046869884,
0.0808733702,
0.0310384445,
0.0027353324,
-0.0138162095,
-0.0238885693,
-0.0771760643,
0.046871528,
0.0269582942,
0.0327485614,
0.054525882,
0.0188291762,
-0.0291418582,
-0.0454340093,
0.0013275533,
0.0325556211,
-0.0258204155,
-0.0289331619,
0.005421157,
0.0055184229,
-0.0078917798,
0.0065411031,
0.0038481066,
-0.0330428556,
0.0266601052,
0.0395847708,
-0.0119973542,
-0.0228538271,
0.0051400308,
0.0180747248,
-0.0432666056,
-0.0097967377,
-0.0133354152,
-0.001525023,
0.005474925,
-0.0191151276,
-0.0098235905,
0.0410484336,
-0.0217074789,
0.0285577606,
-0.0005722651,
-0.0134984991,
-0.0031154284,
-0.0304701272,
0.0178955849,
0.0139368121,
0.0061280257,
0.0643263459,
0.0412505902,
-0.0101202251,
0.0069163237,
0.0250000432,
0.0010206524,
-0.0215255916,
-0.0413964465,
0.0166515186,
-0.0361477695,
0.0158541184,
0.01915369,
-0.0308421478,
-0.026390614,
0.0271527674,
3.041e-7,
0.0507914908,
0.0487579964,
0.0119857425,
0.0179149918,
0.0254961979,
0.0205684844,
0.0002962057,
-0.0161584113,
-0.0090175224,
0.0437643342,
0.050084658,
0.0078534614,
0.041046273,
0.0268781167,
-0.0799724162,
-0.0031846443,
-0.0640696585,
-0.0401699767,
-0.0774156675,
0.002259755,
0.1051160768,
0.0354250744,
0.0080645727,
-0.0147992363,
0.035084419,
-0.0149380211,
0.0148451971,
-0.0556649268,
0.0017978387,
0.0443822742,
0.0335994288,
0.0190038495,
-0.0199264809,
0.0143017378,
0.0042160684,
0.0081751253,
-0.0105295861,
0.0840044394,
-0.0010246519,
-0.0149043137,
0.0464002043,
-0.0241590217,
0.0235943999,
-0.0415536277,
0.0637710318,
-0.0601213798,
-0.0387968421,
0.0012059434,
-0.0020367687,
-0.0411638953,
-0.0274684522,
-0.047860954,
-0.0365764648,
0.0203637518,
-0.0349462815,
-0.0099169509,
0.0087248832,
-0.058759287,
-0.0022983751,
0.0254401639,
-0.0459787585,
-0.1116639003,
-0.0171874706,
-0.0315188393,
0.0250175614,
-0.0476332344,
0.0400685668,
3.060035874e-34,
0.026107274,
0.0209779423,
-0.0285550412,
0.0439578593,
0.0365095027,
0.0201096851,
-0.0014454572,
0.0352685787,
-0.0011438703,
-0.0912244394,
-0.0343039297
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03523v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03523v2 | Sig-Networks Toolkit: Signature Networks for Longitudinal Language Modelling | 2023-12-06T14:34:30 | 2024-02-06T12:14:19 | Talia Tseriotou, Ryan Sze-Yin Chan, Adam Tsakalidis, Iman Munire Bilal, Elena Kochkina, Terry Lyons, Maria Liakata | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present an open-source, pip installable toolkit, Sig-Networks, the first
of its kind for longitudinal language modelling. A central focus is the
incorporation of Signature-based Neural Network models, which have recently
shown success in temporal tasks. We apply and extend published research
providing a full suite of signature-based models. Their components can be used
as PyTorch building blocks in future architectures. Sig-Networks enables
task-agnostic dataset plug-in, seamless pre-processing for sequential data,
parameter flexibility, automated tuning across a range of models. We examine
signature networks under three different NLP tasks of varying temporal
granularity: counselling conversations, rumour stance switch and mood changes
in social media threads, showing SOTA performance in all three, and provide
guidance for future tasks. We release the Toolkit as a PyTorch package with an
introductory video, Git repositories for preprocessing and modelling including
sample notebooks on the modeled NLP tasks. | [
0.026234407,
0.0662505254,
-0.0023672765,
-0.0136677697,
-0.0268183313,
-0.0001023416,
0.0488929339,
-0.0062434827,
0.0574958436,
-0.0187194664,
0.003598883,
-0.0430533811,
-0.0296977591,
0.076009281,
0.0171705559,
-0.0641101599,
0.0619797185,
0.0109972851,
0.0480651669,
-0.006525822,
0.0223375671,
0.0237125326,
-0.0228320882,
0.0579686724,
-0.0393882282,
-0.0629002079,
-0.0053954693,
-0.0005367173,
0.0081655569,
-0.0438091643,
0.0446094237,
0.0887587219,
0.0214711428,
0.0311454516,
0.000002023,
0.0045579257,
0.0279385783,
-0.024936147,
-0.0114519102,
0.0047992393,
0.0505206846,
0.0054480727,
-0.011645929,
0.0193029344,
-0.0743902251,
-0.0246445443,
0.0133875981,
0.0544219613,
0.0638562739,
0.0805093795,
0.004193252,
0.0183907412,
0.048906371,
-0.0618803985,
-0.0251774304,
-0.0198747385,
0.0077995546,
-0.0382762849,
-0.0365515612,
-0.0020994265,
0.0044124289,
0.0545927621,
0.0416178368,
-0.0085336175,
0.0204177294,
0.0355944149,
0.0016910834,
-0.0072998791,
-0.033450406,
0.0287105963,
-0.0175391193,
-0.0334048569,
0.0190417897,
-0.0132284183,
0.0014037708,
-0.0096181743,
-0.042083662,
-0.0190659985,
0.0190997459,
0.0048308605,
0.0332161114,
0.0121431435,
0.0293156039,
0.0171254911,
0.0341796428,
0.049489636,
0.0037787564,
-0.0093075391,
0.0148308156,
-0.0068747443,
0.0272398964,
-0.1045559794,
0.0446035266,
0.0142114405,
-0.0224738941,
0.0223007072,
-0.025711529,
-0.0154962661,
0.0185378324,
-0.0761005357,
-0.0209920071,
-0.0049635889,
-0.0002108438,
0.0211923439,
0.0010452569,
-0.0099310055,
-0.0142237348,
0.0101246079,
0.0133624831,
0.0160050225,
-0.0777520984,
-0.0350156948,
-0.0292558689,
-0.0086443564,
-0.0112077761,
-0.0350748971,
-0.0214667153,
0.0167242605,
-0.0147361644,
-0.0466229469,
0.0277284719,
0.0336547494,
-0.0293739624,
-0.0030826761,
0.0052244873,
0.0701697841,
-0.0421434045,
0.0117558548,
0.019953642,
-0.0363566354,
-0.0163280871,
0.0129344696,
-0.0153816631,
-0.023840107,
0.0155544169,
0.0232185926,
-0.0072767716,
-0.0047367699,
-0.0310190432,
-0.0533789657,
-0.0201410912,
-0.0543097109,
0.0014186074,
-0.0655992031,
0.0233237129,
-0.012408996,
-0.0228764545,
-0.0565697774,
0.0112338951,
0.0277072284,
-0.0220386665,
0.0343629755,
0.0283377878,
0.0087278355,
-0.0038863153,
0.0280388854,
0.0318809673,
0.0559887029,
0.0299573801,
0.043752674,
0.0335713625,
-0.0417596921,
-0.027989177,
0.03067315,
0.0506691821,
-0.026478136,
-0.0115878843,
-0.0289985202,
-0.0055891625,
0.0389386266,
-0.0030548309,
0.0162503012,
-0.027623998,
-0.0548801273,
0.0805403218,
0.0551780276,
-0.0082511678,
0.0350631811,
0.0091611743,
-0.0030310985,
0.0218625031,
-0.0347922035,
-0.0332634188,
0.0461139344,
-0.0066775894,
-0.055935435,
-0.056168396,
0.0552097596,
-0.0473620035,
-0.0309054367,
0.0101487329,
0.0026383549,
0.0369328931,
0.0023056436,
0.0249738432,
0.0185805727,
-0.0413126387,
0.0567050241,
-0.0022961374,
-0.0207131412,
0.0016269556,
-0.0209690556,
0.0254379734,
0.0328901373,
0.0405679196,
0.0010719087,
-0.0466077551,
-0.0364577137,
0.0053135203,
0.0381095894,
0.0392900147,
-0.0164532028,
0.0314987972,
-0.0236344486,
0.0217586532,
0.0277338885,
0.0120686451,
0.0330563374,
0.0168709829,
0.0203810446,
-0.0304436777,
-0.0145569537,
-0.0001816598,
0.0272065066,
-0.064029038,
-0.0275511891,
0.0276840068,
-0.0160094444,
0.044121597,
0.0379561298,
-0.0028318474,
0.0043509449,
0.034079887,
-0.0411426052,
-0.0331656709,
0.0396497995,
-0.0728935525,
-0.0112719089,
0.0242913235,
0.0093609607,
-0.0005794904,
0.0492045321,
-0.0312258061,
-0.0411209501,
0.0883885399,
-0.0056523811,
0.0253084246,
-0.0292830747,
-0.0191256478,
-0.0110912379,
0.0267307535,
-0.0276277419,
0.0191369578,
-0.0234187692,
-0.0156509243,
-0.0342416167,
0.0090905698,
-0.0048290989,
-0.0173455849,
-0.0161054414,
-0.0075142323,
-0.0044725859,
0.0053967135,
0.0016380824,
0.0117889103,
-0.0466228612,
-0.0450971685,
-0.1386776567,
0.0157875381,
-0.0299844965,
0.0212832764,
0.0453278944,
-0.0166197438,
-0.0048065432,
-0.0242247917,
-0.0413216241,
-0.0089521343,
0.0080233794,
0.0303218588,
0.0102543551,
0.0145086655,
0.0071081202,
-0.0640410781,
-0.0674177483,
-0.036004357,
0.0276974589,
-0.0092867315,
-0.062406227,
-0.0096067581,
-0.0306719746,
-0.032732185,
0.0449704453,
-0.031108981,
-0.0214837845,
0.0149069205,
0.0038627286,
0.0600841083,
0.0694088712,
0.026920747,
0.0514332578,
-0.008005905,
-0.0470115244,
-0.0557336286,
0.0197072029,
-0.0657437518,
0.0553756393,
-0.0386352502,
-0.0101956278,
-0.0019615158,
0.0657483637,
0.0267352145,
-0.0028466461,
-0.0600035563,
0.0088220555,
-0.0064606732,
-0.0152635342,
0.0162879769,
-0.0060880473,
-0.0153200245,
-0.0253754444,
-0.0162132885,
-0.0423554815,
0.0651332438,
0.0164541975,
0.001082327,
-0.034411341,
-0.0487273484,
-0.0080178948,
0.1038656235,
-0.0040418459,
-0.0183487535,
0.0351245143,
-0.0507339463,
-0.0415534191,
-0.0302566085,
-0.0062821396,
-0.0481081009,
0.0110829659,
-0.0138353212,
0.0061201751,
0.0340114012,
-0.0201414116,
-0.0007025221,
-0.0744097382,
-0.0448695011,
-0.014136022,
-0.0174419787,
-0.0122830747,
-0.0161706451,
0.0009695563,
-0.0210374258,
0.0316447988,
-0.0351403318,
0.0290677696,
-0.0194294192,
0.0321993753,
0.0497819409,
-0.0214111526,
0.0468569286,
-0.0173199847,
0.0192864593,
0.0631432012,
0.0266077686,
-0.0006041407,
-0.0445189215,
-0.009533044,
-0.009839315,
-0.0364047326,
-0.0151762078,
-0.0057380232,
0.0650040358,
-0.0929112136,
-0.0174027495,
0.0800790787,
0.0133094173,
-0.065826118,
0.0066930186,
0.0146357035,
0.0512080602,
0.0266390741,
-0.0014042867,
-0.0365678333,
-0.0242496356,
-0.0057711308,
0.0149772782,
-0.0065896991,
-0.0274673905,
-0.009615506,
-0.0413870141,
0.0087890932,
-0.0023634634,
-0.042054899,
0.0298006721,
-0.0294489413,
-0.0163699556,
-0.0124854473,
0.0149548398,
-0.0079980688,
0.0059386273,
0.0062794317,
0.0305352081,
-0.0384436734,
-0.0156763364,
0.0687936991,
-0.0327499136,
0.1123065203,
0.0182324238,
0.0316633396,
0.0111870663,
-0.0476717465,
0.0461935401,
-0.0144108459,
-0.0145453839,
-0.0271477979,
0.0770793036,
-0.0059375721,
-0.0073207542,
-0.0605281405,
0.0325167924,
-0.0694067255,
-0.0103051495,
-0.0424129628,
0.0708105415,
-0.0083890483,
-0.0459161326,
-0.015623034,
0.0344459191,
0.0531193726,
0.0423717313,
0.0255300291,
-0.0456103906,
-0.0673724487,
0.0072198804,
0.0192821678,
-0.0423364304,
-0.0452740118,
-0.036179319,
-0.0068460926,
0.0058643166,
-0.0418629199,
-0.0316985846,
0.0052499664,
0.010894469,
-0.0175344348,
0.0076664896,
0.0328515917,
-0.0341156572,
-0.0755245388,
0.0529890172,
-0.0028715958,
0.0395105407,
-0.0622335114,
0.0031001747,
0.0503303371,
0.0312500857,
-0.0273663197,
0.0481403619,
-0.1387924254,
-0.0550460294,
0.0162436292,
0.0182484966,
0.026437182,
0.0231296085,
-0.0223479662,
-0.0813166723,
0.0247019697,
0.0185498409,
0.024267856,
-0.0007180823,
0.0068454896,
0.0000132818,
0.0011337287,
0.0600481592,
0.0047949697,
0.0323147736,
0.014985702,
0.0381609648,
-0.0437356345,
-0.0064086486,
-0.0252000093,
-0.0418498106,
-0.0018980202,
0.0417863578,
-0.036723461,
-0.0522533767,
-0.0047205039,
0.0094843181,
0.0197003018,
-0.0290683806,
0.009555649,
0.0042610872,
-0.012139285,
-0.0496176295,
-0.008330306,
-0.0030683361,
0.0592686534,
-0.0557950921,
-0.0069628162,
0.0077518746,
0.0107238526,
0.0141092725,
0.013428255,
-0.0145601509,
-0.0067018997,
-0.0076539144,
0.0231383592,
-0.014331216,
0.0234393328,
0.0168048833,
-0.0077243485,
0.0005391816,
0.020451555,
-0.0535663627,
-0.0390651673,
-0.0182213802,
-0.0399956107,
0.0381096788,
0.0144786872,
0.0702205449,
-0.0101122167,
-0.0028333238,
-0.0186382812,
0.014746136,
-0.0015712769,
-0.004467756,
0.0523155853,
0.0019490491,
-0.0067547113,
0.0352848507,
0.0520892777,
-0.028715197,
0.0589267127,
0.0685796514,
0.0018046194,
-0.0294719785,
-0.0223833807,
-0.0051915743,
0.0282673892,
-0.0336553603,
0.0141269276,
-0.0347720496,
-0.0593022332,
0.0595089495,
0.0011423455,
0.0079672877,
-0.0128438044,
-0.0096036512,
0.046186056,
0.0254676696,
0.020680625,
-0.0346619897,
0.0385645069,
-0.0165932849,
-0.0544546098,
-0.0603098311,
-6.77671979e-33,
-0.0021487852,
-0.0134889837,
-0.0031683927,
0.0124967154,
-0.0380189717,
0.0209199768,
-0.0518302321,
0.0290070977,
-0.0301271696,
0.0277947616,
-0.0066500898,
0.0556803085,
0.0189554282,
0.0106533682,
0.0385648422,
-0.0245863739,
0.0284641273,
-0.044965025,
0.0230177939,
0.065134041,
0.0530778207,
0.0321891084,
0.0674660578,
-0.1109272987,
0.0128796659,
0.015121581,
-0.0118739624,
0.004461742,
-0.023385657,
0.0471662767,
-0.0172447823,
0.0361449011,
0.0346280672,
-0.0240248088,
-0.0045312801,
0.0598785765,
-0.0787831321,
-0.0498327687,
0.0115979863,
-0.0067816577,
-0.0357863456,
-0.01675139,
0.0194957051,
-0.0015342007,
-0.0131559083,
-0.0061885454,
0.0195700135,
0.0072711101,
-0.0195876192,
-0.0602784604,
-0.0053142332,
0.0278304778,
-0.0133338263,
-0.0112157967,
-0.023131866,
0.0460249968,
-0.0242258217,
0.0157055538,
-0.1103753299,
-0.0327427648,
-0.0528305955,
0.0356725417,
0.0089768674,
0.0045006615,
0.0031542091,
0.0510557964,
0.0227424148,
0.0016389487,
-0.0133656505,
0.0426927693,
0.0495179482,
0.025861986,
0.0775099993,
-0.0294335093,
0.0276485346,
-0.0332754068,
-0.0573329106,
-0.0343711711,
0.1100367308,
0.0323383622,
0.0193161052,
0.0199312177,
0.0265604854,
-0.0150517458,
-0.0331323817,
-0.1007216275,
-0.0264568739,
-0.0293257367,
0.0158235673,
0.0185754318,
0.0072353319,
0.0222076476,
0.0274470132,
-0.0199105442,
-0.0020074125,
0.0421805456,
0.0150173213,
0.0399581417,
0.0481078178,
0.0489326864,
-0.0686191395,
0.00543779,
0.0192476306,
0.0080346288,
0.0411733128,
-0.0206161253,
0.0481408834,
0.0302951392,
-0.0719145834,
-0.0263079889,
-0.0088122524,
0.0739563033,
0.008607626,
0.0430813916,
0.023620218,
0.0037297185,
-0.0186559595,
0.0436586961,
0.0282200743,
0.0410973951,
-0.0211258139,
0.0239951666,
0.0180765539,
0.0053233677,
0.0017745692,
-0.019647859,
-0.0406021811,
-0.003446114,
0.0353484899,
-0.0356699191,
0.0044567422,
0.0228243954,
2.762e-7,
0.000826019,
0.0760488957,
0.048268497,
0.0134623526,
0.0722522065,
0.0117329471,
0.0169786029,
0.0380583629,
0.0155755226,
-0.0046230867,
-0.0173073579,
-0.013591513,
0.0552103892,
0.0415402241,
-0.0532903373,
-0.0086770961,
-0.0825159624,
0.0192565508,
-0.0590799525,
-0.001587202,
0.0511569567,
0.0842522681,
0.0524403192,
-0.0249190759,
-0.0013579357,
0.000781328,
0.0555211492,
-0.0200811848,
-0.0115552619,
0.0078987442,
0.0610985793,
-0.0285198949,
-0.0006434303,
0.027400298,
-0.0102716302,
0.0187415704,
-0.0247720722,
0.0594873801,
0.0063396855,
-0.0728031844,
0.0024567656,
-0.0091187684,
-0.0066512204,
-0.0227117687,
0.057880979,
-0.0469906852,
-0.0640100837,
-0.0610946454,
-0.0461390093,
0.0029385786,
0.0339842327,
-0.0150946341,
-0.030902816,
0.0347893648,
0.0059096226,
0.0093727959,
-0.0196547173,
-0.0991616398,
-0.0240627043,
-0.005690861,
-0.0546304062,
-0.002104877,
-0.0275219977,
-0.0130657544,
0.0065010935,
-0.0636489838,
0.0114937946,
2.609022798e-34,
0.0604955852,
0.0002613803,
0.0101047177,
0.0299757402,
0.005557728,
0.0260341428,
0.0071839914,
-0.0040676119,
0.0215027854,
-0.090747796,
-0.0302503854
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03483v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03483v1 | Exploring Answer Information Methods for Question Generation with Transformers | 2023-12-06T13:26:16 | 2023-12-06T13:26:16 | Talha Chafekar, Aafiya Hussain, Grishma Sharma, Deepak Sharma | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | There has been a lot of work in question generation where different methods
to provide target answers as input, have been employed. This experimentation
has been mostly carried out for RNN based models. We use three different
methods and their combinations for incorporating answer information and explore
their effect on several automatic evaluation metrics. The methods that are used
are answer prompting, using a custom product method using answer embeddings and
encoder outputs, choosing sentences from the input paragraph that have answer
related information, and using a separate cross-attention attention block in
the decoder which attends to the answer. We observe that answer prompting
without any additional modes obtains the best scores across rouge, meteor
scores. Additionally, we use a custom metric to calculate how many of the
generated questions have the same answer, as the answer which is used to
generate them. | [
0.0486887395,
0.0090075145,
0.0072964821,
0.0061963503,
-0.0285503995,
-0.0045334855,
0.0092039276,
-0.0053634332,
-0.0353449732,
-0.0341514051,
0.013679808,
-0.0412601903,
-0.0177496243,
0.0209441837,
0.0310503617,
-0.0338174999,
0.0016843451,
0.0195132531,
-0.0201427303,
0.0223920047,
-0.0123742474,
-0.0021067422,
0.0092988815,
0.041401118,
-0.000859568,
-0.0334618874,
-0.0357774384,
0.0191115942,
0.0262887776,
-0.036060188,
0.0111773042,
0.0565795079,
-0.0028465947,
0.0351619981,
0.0000018254,
-0.0446408838,
0.0058238478,
0.0080256015,
-0.0244387779,
-0.0480581336,
-0.007665345,
0.034401197,
0.0400394499,
0.0570183434,
-0.0560939126,
-0.0174821261,
0.0445044301,
0.0561711043,
0.0858481973,
0.0496663153,
0.0021981974,
-0.0306045953,
0.047535982,
-0.0153450463,
0.0613232963,
0.0284792613,
-0.0120492298,
0.0094850417,
0.0425728224,
0.0206951555,
-0.0266093686,
0.0221647173,
0.0802311674,
-0.0316931196,
0.0498907827,
0.0412124805,
-0.0009754118,
-0.0167579595,
-0.0310595501,
0.069676213,
-0.0098097865,
0.0002240657,
-0.0125731602,
0.0039501698,
0.0184742529,
0.0060628979,
-0.0519111492,
0.0212098267,
0.0055673174,
-0.0377741829,
-0.0003343076,
0.0452664867,
-0.0174477678,
-0.022794297,
0.0062358221,
0.0358476192,
0.0576654486,
-0.0421850532,
-0.0355582871,
0.0163217224,
0.0026552773,
-0.1154057682,
0.0066411346,
0.0539457649,
-0.0158598851,
-0.0056359177,
-0.0428247228,
-0.035121005,
-0.0040560677,
0.022687871,
0.0218152609,
0.0346115902,
-0.0056604706,
0.0039338875,
-0.0441500954,
0.0760329962,
-0.0132031906,
-0.0055343546,
-0.0831614211,
0.0220062435,
-0.0225997567,
-0.0361081436,
-0.0313317925,
0.0351404771,
-0.026559528,
-0.0318926349,
-0.0332175642,
0.0491068102,
0.0353574157,
-0.0067184311,
0.032904841,
0.0544979386,
-0.0275927112,
0.0231522545,
-0.0467104614,
0.0351899788,
-0.0671455562,
-0.0185290594,
0.0569257028,
-0.0638584569,
-0.0087350812,
0.0354711674,
0.027243983,
-0.0213904735,
-0.0035582201,
0.0522549935,
-0.0239795037,
-0.01817137,
0.030608898,
-0.0554318912,
-0.0086042006,
-0.0373716801,
0.0105449297,
-0.036894802,
0.02559462,
0.0184659231,
-0.0475824215,
-0.0032439083,
0.0147982044,
0.0475632921,
0.0204144083,
0.0054380964,
0.0172242224,
0.0135668525,
0.0275220182,
0.0078697912,
0.0454858243,
0.0143063115,
0.0286796149,
0.0448208451,
-0.0080116121,
-0.0140495729,
0.0381220803,
-0.0121644856,
0.0239637326,
-0.0154545354,
0.0250667445,
0.0545238741,
-0.0124812406,
0.0569060929,
-0.0096446015,
0.0327333212,
-0.0135935433,
-0.0115946513,
0.0696302652,
0.0042036525,
0.0123732425,
0.0302713327,
0.0462573916,
-0.0098022399,
0.000574335,
0.0472087897,
-0.0037616079,
0.0750318244,
-0.0107469372,
0.0203392413,
0.0394697376,
0.0314976871,
-0.0378530808,
-0.0310834851,
0.0167154241,
0.0263703018,
-0.036224734,
0.0544475466,
-0.004504622,
0.0321980752,
-0.0597999766,
0.0439242013,
-0.0373560525,
-0.0634361133,
0.0251215827,
-0.0396061353,
0.0497803092,
0.001836815,
0.0566144511,
0.0246677212,
-0.039133966,
-0.021580236,
-0.025925938,
0.0557808653,
0.035218548,
-0.0106258644,
-0.0219745338,
-0.0350141749,
-0.0034838838,
-0.0301102139,
-0.0259742253,
0.0112521155,
-0.00728853,
0.0171035416,
0.0275163297,
-0.0315816291,
0.0042216796,
0.0482651517,
-0.0174894594,
-0.0546968952,
0.0298433434,
0.0070873233,
-0.0138903335,
0.0320783406,
0.0070018419,
0.0428136922,
0.0170808043,
-0.0298021901,
-0.0194139797,
0.0173411146,
-0.0396471955,
-0.0661021769,
-0.0150961103,
-0.0621219724,
-0.0140171591,
0.0503426194,
-0.0057086553,
-0.0374769568,
-0.0124663282,
-0.0568151847,
0.0178935733,
-0.0516023003,
-0.025941262,
0.0209678952,
0.0181805063,
-0.0580181889,
0.0507423393,
-0.0016682517,
0.0290653352,
0.0223946311,
0.0022889182,
0.0216958076,
-0.0431855842,
-0.0172106922,
-0.0018606284,
-0.0443280376,
0.0109948041,
0.034604691,
0.0177501179,
-0.0469259843,
-0.0465304703,
-0.0381442867,
0.0173319131,
-0.03604047,
0.0126608936,
0.0356108099,
0.0401838571,
-0.0028907489,
-0.0021511891,
-0.1160275415,
-0.0078351358,
0.0157140195,
0.025061775,
0.0364497453,
0.0096745277,
0.0168785974,
0.0014241113,
-0.0151670258,
0.0056279646,
0.0639321879,
0.0273564328,
0.0691141263,
-0.0678432062,
-0.0003706825,
-0.0497231334,
-0.0338515714,
0.0262338333,
-0.036161568,
0.0108748693,
-0.0194745082,
0.0762947574,
0.0522266515,
0.016365625,
-0.0121526271,
0.0197543651,
0.0060641253,
-0.033718504,
0.0175371822,
-0.0697312281,
-0.0125852721,
0.0241299551,
-0.058628872,
0.0405780971,
0.0480976775,
0.0323259309,
-0.0397369117,
-0.0312061086,
0.0514782891,
-0.0086978218,
-0.024676457,
-0.0496275909,
-0.0019305022,
-0.007919021,
0.0345948301,
0.0040444848,
-0.0313606746,
0.0876585841,
-0.0310712829,
-0.0328377672,
-0.0629052147,
0.021140445,
-0.0342318267,
0.0286628157,
0.0180998445,
0.0137774032,
0.0105882566,
-0.0382579863,
-0.0670172125,
0.0258882623,
0.0173632056,
-0.0325043164,
0.0257273503,
0.027409818,
-0.022205947,
-0.0256689508,
-0.0285871476,
-0.0874933153,
-0.0516193472,
0.0401224829,
0.0073917652,
0.0126752667,
-0.0072284476,
-0.0104425438,
0.0358088054,
0.0209026746,
0.0105748437,
-0.0590386912,
-0.019276021,
-0.0298222862,
0.121134147,
0.0731675103,
0.0414252281,
0.0653174147,
-0.0064106146,
0.0355161317,
0.0527203493,
0.0301398747,
0.0489357039,
-0.0022842747,
0.0013725281,
0.0095488662,
-0.0306401476,
0.0399900787,
0.0485423245,
0.0531796329,
-0.059381552,
-0.0637394562,
0.074382633,
0.0471682325,
0.0067339647,
-0.0175146945,
-0.0092312554,
0.0339465365,
0.0192891695,
0.0640416816,
-0.0379747786,
-0.005012854,
-0.0178020168,
0.0232387856,
0.0074109277,
-0.0308718532,
-0.0024670863,
-0.095561564,
0.0253998823,
-0.0341483876,
-0.0333070606,
-0.0388967097,
-0.0082746791,
-0.0112289302,
0.0421957076,
-0.0130191566,
-0.0017594196,
-0.0155897522,
0.0102722337,
0.024919698,
0.0125916833,
-0.0150445905,
-0.0274594929,
-0.0303164143,
0.0085139852,
0.0889463723,
0.0042351354,
0.0060399906,
-0.0283308197,
-0.0374552757,
-0.0559562482,
-0.0110092871,
0.0179254394,
0.0157661531,
-0.0015336932,
0.0014622253,
-0.0388901234,
0.0294578187,
-0.0225990135,
0.0304807015,
0.0098894117,
0.0448949821,
-0.0186252892,
-0.0556327365,
-0.0322938338,
0.0362969525,
0.0267653503,
0.0808928907,
0.0685461834,
-0.0553385466,
-0.0353796855,
-0.0296769254,
0.0214323383,
-0.1023145393,
-0.036424242,
0.0163770355,
0.0480028875,
-0.0610593036,
-0.1015121341,
-0.0645772666,
0.0194303226,
0.0136490827,
0.0085287225,
-0.0493459925,
-0.0027722367,
0.0158440154,
-0.0294310525,
0.0035717555,
0.0132617541,
-0.0082731582,
-0.0490983315,
0.0053734551,
0.0207150187,
-0.0540942289,
-0.04032363,
-0.0155647574,
-0.0961936563,
-0.0167444348,
0.011756354,
0.0329126306,
0.0141866812,
-0.0202200972,
-0.0136792874,
-0.037476968,
0.0515183173,
0.0047836737,
0.0067755836,
0.0000945518,
-0.0334614925,
-0.0159542784,
-0.0101297526,
-0.0018059296,
-0.0372423008,
0.0279226061,
0.0092480825,
0.0611419082,
0.0011224705,
-0.0531395487,
0.0317168236,
0.0053217337,
0.0013148542,
0.0091328835,
0.0198260248,
-0.0168871153,
0.0300742798,
0.0057016024,
0.0002130658,
-0.0578323565,
-0.0187792443,
0.0013957368,
0.0042050909,
0.0182708595,
0.0302986261,
-0.013855949,
0.0343178175,
-0.0300791375,
0.0090872571,
0.0190759711,
0.0440056138,
-0.0021682286,
0.0026222588,
-0.046245411,
-0.0179863498,
0.0180466492,
0.0498091169,
0.019507898,
0.0681039914,
0.0069221421,
-0.0093287556,
0.0322792828,
0.0482281372,
-0.0757698342,
-0.0275714658,
-0.0285222903,
-0.0049551264,
-0.0018510851,
0.0369864367,
-0.005342694,
0.0007883716,
0.0057692514,
-0.0032271747,
0.0414580107,
0.0140489852,
-0.0406528935,
0.048218973,
-0.0074075037,
-0.0100538759,
-0.0446617007,
0.0417601094,
-0.0021645012,
0.0123637272,
0.0082921414,
0.0038595991,
-0.0433557443,
0.0073746112,
0.003155282,
-0.0063832621,
0.0024628418,
0.0248961784,
-0.0540624224,
-0.0360604152,
0.0062068575,
0.026018057,
-0.0183678605,
0.0052971984,
0.0400215313,
0.0275477003,
-0.0020576254,
-0.0246034991,
-0.0228062179,
0.0588589013,
-0.0961793959,
-0.0350794755,
-0.0165077336,
-6.146287843e-33,
-0.0116308145,
-0.0555752814,
0.0098213386,
-0.0467334874,
-0.0348235294,
-0.0036349597,
-0.0488273725,
-0.0127753438,
-0.0018860691,
-0.0144293495,
-0.0104352152,
-0.0259906128,
-0.0075320103,
0.0553115495,
0.0047408459,
-0.0873920619,
0.0489824377,
-0.004181054,
-0.0422471277,
0.0510427281,
0.0117716687,
0.014797695,
-0.0005923004,
0.0223053414,
0.0063386457,
-0.0477749407,
0.013080704,
0.0036280346,
-0.0153929573,
0.0579073764,
-0.028863769,
0.0244255029,
0.0307596158,
-0.0527469255,
-0.0149425808,
0.0889259875,
-0.0254418049,
-0.0499432273,
-0.0320718028,
-0.0141755845,
-0.1044975743,
-0.0275067873,
0.0184246041,
-0.0125912298,
0.0391746536,
-0.0098619796,
0.0343059339,
0.011537198,
-0.0005241536,
-0.0447727554,
-0.027520081,
-0.0137694729,
-0.0018577522,
-0.0588900819,
-0.0333112292,
0.1060916707,
0.0264084917,
0.012353424,
-0.0508592241,
0.0215436611,
0.015288298,
0.0542128123,
0.0407323167,
0.0310179088,
-0.0302162413,
0.0319480598,
0.0078265574,
-0.045658052,
-0.0160161257,
0.0089376681,
-0.0195355061,
0.0153121706,
0.0827155039,
0.0300418679,
0.0128475586,
0.0476708859,
-0.0488620102,
0.0781415775,
0.0163752846,
-0.0027938082,
0.0309106223,
-0.0514868274,
-0.0053144414,
0.0070227026,
-0.0249470454,
0.0241096597,
-0.0502203815,
-0.0380934738,
0.0579836629,
-0.0003615041,
-0.0488517694,
0.0090019489,
0.0566522963,
-0.0220795348,
0.0240350477,
0.0063439901,
-0.0107821682,
0.0366378166,
-0.0151450112,
0.0192674398,
-0.0258138143,
0.0730287805,
0.0478506461,
-0.0043788305,
-0.0139643513,
0.0185565557,
-0.0212121457,
0.0159338862,
-0.0459818169,
-0.0115103144,
-0.0342990048,
0.0364512727,
-0.0107822232,
-0.0041786199,
-0.015227682,
0.0282601323,
-0.0112894494,
0.0156410728,
-0.0140765328,
-0.0054898555,
-0.0639365017,
0.001657106,
0.0534087867,
0.0152943991,
-0.0224038288,
0.0368111208,
-0.0545095503,
0.0178252161,
-0.0170573853,
-0.0414805897,
-0.0123876343,
0.0370947048,
2.467e-7,
0.0255331397,
0.0110877287,
0.0385105386,
0.0300864894,
0.014049774,
0.0194677897,
0.0411121957,
0.0366633832,
0.069363229,
0.0033905359,
0.0007942012,
-0.0261278283,
0.0337174907,
0.0209659133,
-0.1111342832,
-0.0293886401,
-0.0667640567,
0.0058852779,
-0.0269297883,
-0.0235668849,
0.0993391275,
0.0586505271,
-0.024834495,
0.0059609823,
0.0026977565,
0.02098752,
0.0487343743,
0.0253640469,
-0.0170330033,
0.0405217782,
0.0232566316,
0.0182531737,
0.0025062477,
-0.0028086859,
-0.0175316669,
-0.0116854534,
0.0295793507,
0.0117881969,
0.0264557805,
-0.091908671,
-0.0467657745,
0.0191096347,
0.0276274905,
-0.0695254877,
0.0521901399,
-0.0557037666,
-0.0164009929,
-0.0188457388,
-0.0204315744,
-0.018061718,
0.0120827211,
-0.0300625637,
-0.0483385846,
0.0093120607,
0.0307631642,
-0.0092371637,
0.0184055157,
-0.0249462761,
-0.0301641822,
-0.0044683712,
-0.0480045602,
-0.04578216,
-0.0652571991,
-0.0417045876,
-0.0096225701,
-0.0289293546,
-0.0477615222,
2.164701086e-34,
-0.0222346988,
0.0237427633,
0.0191659201,
0.0143035073,
-0.0019747396,
-0.0076777823,
0.0328923836,
-0.0290071312,
0.0358253084,
-0.1089659557,
-0.0348085649
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03480v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03480v1 | AMR Parsing is Far from Solved: GrAPES, the Granular AMR Parsing Evaluation Suite | 2023-12-06T13:19:56 | 2023-12-06T13:19:56 | Jonas Groschwitz, Shay B. Cohen, Lucia Donatelli, Meaghan Fowlie | cs.CL | cs.CL, J.5 | We present the Granular AMR Parsing Evaluation Suite (GrAPES), a challenge
set for Abstract Meaning Representation (AMR) parsing with accompanying
evaluation metrics. AMR parsers now obtain high scores on the standard AMR
evaluation metric Smatch, close to or even above reported inter-annotator
agreement. But that does not mean that AMR parsing is solved; in fact, human
evaluation in previous work indicates that current parsers still quite
frequently make errors on node labels or graph structure that substantially
distort sentence meaning. Here, we provide an evaluation suite that tests AMR
parsers on a range of phenomena of practical, technical, and linguistic
interest. Our 36 categories range from seen and unseen labels, to structural
generalization, to coreference. GrAPES reveals in depth the abilities and
shortcomings of current AMR parsers. | [
0.0095722983,
0.0356069207,
-0.0272256713,
0.0379430577,
-0.0070046531,
0.0398939662,
-0.0500809103,
-0.0312719531,
-0.0109103797,
-0.0275011063,
0.0070272377,
0.0126314107,
-0.0137765473,
0.0373814516,
-0.0188217741,
-0.0533065647,
0.0509171523,
0.0346117355,
0.0531055257,
0.0507879965,
0.0358794555,
0.0339157097,
0.0011403903,
0.0381797142,
-0.028629791,
-0.0504762977,
-0.007845683,
-0.0048711556,
0.0469666906,
-0.0651080906,
-0.0182771925,
-0.0080471048,
-0.0059777643,
0.0331833176,
0.0000019793,
-0.0440699793,
-0.0566205457,
0.026647266,
-0.0195350256,
-0.0053597097,
0.0603181645,
-0.0298736896,
0.0122455601,
-0.0055818819,
-0.0362371244,
-0.0463068821,
0.005668785,
0.0561496355,
0.0385615304,
0.051928129,
-0.0326160043,
-0.0323163792,
0.0068487949,
-0.0007858906,
-0.0331038646,
-0.0318560302,
-0.0179599077,
0.0636414662,
-0.0046332399,
0.0027164537,
-0.0359887816,
0.0222332049,
0.0172597207,
0.0251632854,
0.0253339577,
0.0273888111,
-0.063864544,
-0.028016001,
0.0332078226,
0.051915843,
0.0356007293,
-0.0129035348,
0.016982181,
-0.0183263384,
-0.0344464555,
-0.0144912442,
-0.0114632444,
0.0273713991,
-0.0433838591,
0.0476203151,
0.034399569,
0.0097410874,
0.0008522942,
0.0166868214,
-0.007605256,
0.0550017245,
-0.0174268391,
-0.0376824662,
0.0609726198,
0.0501180477,
-0.0618956015,
-0.0212986413,
0.0577932894,
-0.0411614329,
-0.0159997139,
0.0008418569,
-0.037911348,
-0.026886208,
0.024981346,
-0.0317336507,
0.0317458548,
0.0247934647,
-0.0256611165,
0.019191809,
-0.0057914234,
0.037684314,
0.0051377099,
0.0226150937,
-0.0356679894,
-0.0008386074,
-0.0759631693,
0.0145464316,
-0.0605248585,
0.0646647811,
-0.0593023486,
-0.0341939703,
-0.0338402912,
0.0272182617,
-0.01501681,
0.0103440508,
0.0151167745,
-0.0208830778,
-0.011264543,
0.034061119,
-0.0078007914,
0.0078642508,
-0.0235554557,
0.012749522,
-0.0112785157,
-0.0340885594,
-0.0306172986,
0.023739174,
0.0273711681,
-0.0267086513,
-0.0255229697,
0.0384261981,
0.0104589527,
0.0009093916,
0.0218346734,
-0.0678294152,
-0.0063928901,
0.0018379455,
-0.0232802946,
-0.0296832193,
0.0382951237,
0.0278391968,
0.0384821557,
-0.0106192809,
-0.0000278022,
0.0127797788,
0.0397953913,
0.0192761347,
-0.0293422025,
-0.0337862037,
-0.0274906568,
0.0148171438,
0.0059441603,
0.0204035938,
0.007479535,
0.034601748,
0.0075055403,
0.0328723267,
-0.0199218653,
-0.0228361674,
-0.0125804869,
-0.0222401898,
0.0663231239,
0.0358971022,
-0.0392058827,
0.016351819,
0.0092599858,
0.0540829152,
-0.0170182306,
-0.0014513874,
0.0010035775,
0.0275051016,
-0.053447552,
-0.0058646481,
0.0571865104,
0.0204377715,
-0.0062234504,
-0.0205021463,
-0.0338816829,
-0.0217208546,
-0.0336185172,
0.0476503484,
-0.05361313,
-0.0045488048,
0.0370125212,
-0.0374993719,
-0.0434881598,
0.0117469616,
0.0027901882,
-0.0105915787,
0.0147598637,
0.0182693917,
-0.0125542888,
0.042494636,
-0.0016066252,
-0.019677816,
0.0060430164,
0.0208414197,
-0.0220262539,
0.0206383951,
0.0207138471,
-0.0389548689,
-0.0372869112,
-0.0456470996,
0.03199929,
0.0449001342,
0.0335447639,
-0.026037503,
0.0040013827,
-0.041571863,
-0.0184770189,
-0.0191297363,
0.0349351875,
-0.0167987943,
-0.0432851911,
0.002474651,
0.0132431891,
-0.0604072288,
-0.0524821021,
0.0328877419,
0.0276032928,
-0.0214655083,
-0.0525597744,
0.0216941964,
0.0470392257,
0.0456236415,
-0.0079202913,
0.0176112577,
0.0215361025,
-0.0391472504,
-0.0089222286,
0.0682638437,
-0.0620003194,
-0.0441816039,
0.0186893959,
-0.0686491877,
-0.0825120956,
0.0029792034,
-0.0572794713,
-0.0353451855,
-0.0072401203,
-0.055053141,
0.045917917,
0.0059651705,
0.0334494077,
0.0291155763,
-0.0305142403,
-0.0031321708,
0.0576369315,
-0.0235504862,
-0.010224428,
-0.0118681518,
-0.0255585555,
0.0465121083,
-0.0227854811,
-0.0142774926,
-0.0205860566,
-0.004854071,
-0.0284741893,
0.0185152702,
0.001743835,
-0.0700618848,
0.0216031242,
-0.015733704,
0.0043850406,
-0.0140198246,
0.0706759766,
0.0666678622,
-0.0095336791,
0.0387975723,
0.0242918488,
0.0099413926,
0.0092678545,
-0.031621743,
-0.0110150995,
0.036021471,
-0.0015487503,
-0.0177171919,
-0.0091465386,
0.0192174744,
-0.0702066869,
0.0222996902,
-0.0055359374,
-0.0483807437,
-0.0053509767,
0.0199646913,
-0.012282609,
0.0028678249,
0.0066318992,
-0.0014146805,
0.0140585527,
-0.0184953455,
-0.00196891,
0.0240201782,
-0.0471750088,
0.0585015416,
-0.0057488647,
-0.0195563342,
-0.0425695255,
-0.0142095443,
0.0344950594,
-0.0003851701,
-0.0512225516,
-0.0787355453,
0.0123928851,
0.0891145989,
0.0127163408,
0.0470227674,
-0.0247208755,
-0.0123533625,
-0.1006843224,
-0.0405903161,
-0.0245407876,
0.0048918179,
0.0110240262,
0.0123029705,
-0.0588514321,
0.0080086868,
0.1069333851,
-0.0014654452,
-0.043063309,
-0.0473791845,
-0.0390090346,
-0.0545673706,
0.0680078417,
-0.0203282498,
0.0177130327,
0.0453256853,
-0.0777991414,
0.0073415209,
-0.002705317,
0.0160836466,
-0.0062087127,
0.0296786912,
-0.0333545469,
0.0104519129,
-0.0081720026,
-0.0220697969,
0.0277551971,
-0.0101318127,
-0.0389804356,
0.0511120483,
0.0113084838,
0.052530311,
-0.0293229967,
0.01664632,
-0.0076527693,
-0.0190684926,
0.0145588573,
-0.0131055005,
-0.03954437,
0.0257923268,
0.0731600299,
-0.0185374301,
0.0205176789,
-0.005922731,
0.0306265894,
0.0458636582,
-0.0326352194,
-0.0335641094,
-0.0407701544,
0.038745176,
-0.0155921225,
-0.0309154447,
-0.028154593,
-0.0410234146,
0.0880888849,
-0.0646405518,
-0.0314920358,
0.0667383149,
0.0411835611,
0.0024726454,
0.0355260707,
-0.0143773323,
0.0126544358,
0.0236734971,
-0.0040385877,
-0.1352994144,
-0.0148803489,
0.0159857254,
-0.0189304724,
0.00679674,
-0.0571983047,
0.0368998572,
-0.1065947115,
0.0080463579,
0.0222733617,
-0.0539556891,
0.0056231678,
0.0016429021,
-0.0266352296,
-0.070672065,
0.0231256802,
-0.0035141273,
-0.0296810754,
0.0261585489,
0.0061022048,
-0.0032311101,
-0.0185464341,
0.0419399925,
-0.026813589,
0.0073142825,
0.0076927771,
0.0351673365,
-0.0157343224,
-0.0126850698,
0.0447120704,
-0.0520541556,
0.024258595,
-0.0227716696,
-0.0177344028,
-0.0067920573,
-0.0066085588,
-0.0284881815,
-0.008332164,
-0.0260957927,
-0.035170652,
-0.0109763397,
0.1023563817,
-0.0287695881,
0.0081951143,
-0.0152650997,
-0.0265670102,
0.0095913131,
0.0495204739,
0.0477768108,
0.0674188212,
-0.0757622868,
-0.0321358964,
0.0359632447,
-0.0553371683,
0.0212815516,
0.0427392907,
-0.0403145738,
-0.0042449129,
-0.0345700681,
-0.0934305042,
0.0529028922,
-0.0277269352,
-0.0194970667,
-0.0324506462,
0.0029150208,
-0.0240943115,
-0.0474002883,
0.0504490845,
-0.0051088221,
0.0379191115,
-0.0165220182,
-0.0151560288,
0.0201334395,
0.0236898977,
-0.0583807565,
0.0464691631,
0.013357209,
-0.0451394618,
0.0090757562,
0.0372659229,
0.0176499151,
0.0148404818,
-0.0340591222,
-0.0030332946,
-0.0031554089,
-0.0298950188,
-0.0135274269,
0.0063546952,
0.0569273867,
0.0495048501,
0.0083551267,
0.0112320269,
-0.0402027592,
0.0603735335,
-0.0251904503,
0.0670839027,
-0.0243332814,
0.0173907131,
0.0536477417,
0.0746866465,
0.0420682542,
0.0259656738,
-0.0192679372,
0.0003176259,
0.0117293485,
-0.0474770665,
-0.0311175734,
-0.0280712973,
0.0111905392,
0.0148980962,
-0.0083214361,
-0.0268121399,
0.0451559462,
-0.0074153459,
0.0446494371,
-0.0095881466,
0.0399313197,
0.0534396619,
-0.008813872,
-0.0162142999,
0.0266961828,
-0.0366401151,
-0.0372653417,
0.0086906329,
0.0493382998,
-0.0156616177,
-0.0136382151,
0.0163941905,
0.0192337278,
-0.0342918895,
0.0173557587,
-0.0278368108,
0.013728044,
0.0041803676,
-0.0035357352,
0.046932172,
-0.0195172131,
0.1273175329,
0.0093053104,
0.0108639784,
-0.0019949465,
0.0567969009,
0.0091790594,
-0.0464188382,
0.0145068495,
0.0257517397,
-0.0017871382,
-0.0591775142,
0.0275011528,
-0.0695981011,
0.0297929049,
-0.0092337318,
-0.0273605771,
-0.0550139248,
0.0074117067,
-0.0293140728,
0.0267295912,
-0.0072077331,
-0.0270042457,
-0.0415954255,
-0.0515965857,
0.0117507186,
0.0222684443,
0.0527366661,
0.0097531183,
-0.0167498123,
0.0128460471,
0.0436806045,
-0.0828585699,
-0.0036348847,
-0.0424101986,
-0.0396097936,
0.002172298,
-0.0647152886,
-6.25384227e-33,
-0.0485191233,
0.0235434286,
-0.0010868468,
-0.016137613,
-0.0658631101,
0.0342158452,
-0.0788863897,
-0.0152553068,
0.0039276131,
0.0534598082,
0.0230170954,
-0.0062718038,
0.0260619,
-0.0165994596,
0.0522035845,
0.0025029157,
0.0709909946,
0.0328882486,
0.0011736351,
-0.0232718829,
0.0485403799,
0.0336378254,
0.0695514977,
-0.0714594796,
0.0275841113,
0.0263514202,
-0.0303353239,
-0.0179085955,
0.0031387939,
0.0375313349,
0.0151180821,
0.027834136,
0.03655212,
0.0161532257,
-0.0435912423,
-0.0316714011,
-0.1223315299,
-0.0410117842,
0.0523699522,
0.0098993545,
-0.0517233238,
-0.0349539481,
0.0177762192,
-0.0288532544,
-0.008014272,
-0.0134694641,
0.0519050732,
-0.0205478929,
0.0105277002,
-0.0323043205,
-0.0443411469,
0.0191225577,
-0.0314118527,
0.0391369089,
0.0505777039,
0.0085146045,
0.0051045953,
0.0137405666,
-0.0281055812,
-0.0103761964,
-0.0297426339,
0.007529818,
0.0116882995,
-0.0162278861,
0.017830709,
0.0627730936,
0.0210246984,
-0.0431332141,
0.0194839481,
0.0545648821,
-0.0292140767,
0.071961388,
-0.0081899958,
0.0053118179,
0.0199468639,
0.027071448,
-0.0145220533,
-0.0093365582,
0.0095719509,
0.0861456618,
-0.0353839174,
0.0440218262,
-0.0701052696,
-0.0032221905,
-0.0141947791,
-0.0237249788,
-0.0156703983,
-0.0215985626,
0.041754771,
-0.0307563934,
0.0005032126,
0.1006519794,
0.0173804276,
-0.043106623,
0.015417994,
-0.045588579,
0.0363055319,
0.0165714342,
-0.0045430358,
0.0064455238,
-0.0306507852,
-0.0615565032,
-0.0034928918,
0.0116466777,
0.066736199,
-0.0060682683,
0.077303499,
-0.0144700976,
-0.0108463261,
0.0264522582,
-0.0259690136,
-0.0211139861,
-0.0297393315,
0.0073323096,
0.0414802171,
0.0234914534,
-0.0217030328,
0.0261452645,
0.0377002023,
0.0547755398,
-0.0189515557,
0.0500011444,
0.0076232641,
0.023081746,
-0.0122444332,
-0.0029004088,
0.0052700727,
-0.0084324814,
0.0529552102,
-0.0365611948,
-0.0317312367,
-0.0095579512,
2.744e-7,
0.0639402568,
0.0577215925,
0.0589285083,
0.022998333,
-0.0426888131,
-0.0284685344,
-0.0224694237,
0.0511509776,
-0.0162946936,
-0.0182182044,
-0.0103954887,
-0.0125030344,
0.0146366367,
0.0512612388,
-0.0744553283,
0.0497775823,
-0.0811185166,
-0.038146846,
-0.0341772661,
0.0751502588,
0.0911201835,
0.0422142111,
0.0093471371,
0.0366532654,
0.0017872243,
-0.0167543534,
0.0152542209,
-0.0146573177,
0.035778977,
-0.0092344349,
-0.0271532722,
-0.002476004,
0.0136353755,
0.0043517747,
-0.0053632278,
-0.0110102491,
0.0257597044,
0.0468863733,
-0.0437926687,
0.0192449931,
-0.0080723427,
-0.0430108085,
0.012905403,
-0.007720266,
0.0379454941,
-0.0438594185,
-0.0487286784,
-0.0365694053,
-0.0958338827,
-0.0012010759,
-0.0154821929,
0.0393438786,
0.0086077321,
-0.005557064,
0.004091504,
-0.0047012507,
-0.0485166423,
-0.0390089042,
-0.0254448876,
0.0399730504,
0.0341096409,
-0.0336686671,
0.015630791,
0.0345545933,
0.001761861,
-0.070611231,
-0.0455888733,
2.245766116e-34,
0.0682939664,
0.0054234792,
0.0457922965,
0.044496011,
0.0458646528,
-0.009965674,
-0.020543959,
0.0313889906,
-0.0253425371,
-0.0627934486,
-0.0104193632
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03463v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03463v2 | DBCopilot: Scaling Natural Language Querying to Massive Databases | 2023-12-06T12:37:28 | 2024-04-23T08:54:57 | Tianshu Wang, Hongyu Lin, Xianpei Han, Le Sun, Xiaoyang Chen, Hao Wang, Zhenyu Zeng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.DB, cs.IR | Text-to-SQL simplifies database interactions by enabling non-experts to
convert their natural language (NL) questions into Structured Query Language
(SQL) queries. While recent advances in large language models (LLMs) have
improved the zero-shot text-to-SQL paradigm, existing methods face scalability
challenges when dealing with massive, dynamically changing databases. This
paper introduces DBCopilot, a framework that addresses these challenges by
employing a compact and flexible copilot model for routing across massive
databases. Specifically, DBCopilot decouples the text-to-SQL process into
schema routing and SQL generation, leveraging a lightweight
sequence-to-sequence neural network-based router to formulate database
connections and navigate natural language questions through databases and
tables. The routed schemas and questions are then fed into LLMs for efficient
SQL generation. Furthermore, DBCopilot also introduced a reverse
schema-to-question generation paradigm, which can learn and adapt the router
over massive databases automatically without requiring manual intervention.
Experimental results demonstrate that DBCopilot is a scalable and effective
solution for real-world text-to-SQL tasks, providing a significant advancement
in handling large-scale schemas. | [
0.0142377,
0.0741913021,
-0.0091924444,
0.0027597868,
-0.0168850534,
0.004469018,
-0.0043072314,
0.0014580633,
0.0121434554,
-0.0417449102,
0.0191124566,
-0.0123571558,
-0.0337351412,
0.0773678869,
0.029146852,
-0.0289986841,
0.029886568,
-0.0405690782,
-0.0371960551,
0.0506916679,
-0.0270741787,
0.0209032577,
0.0212634914,
-0.0058414848,
-0.0145194288,
0.0062686554,
-0.0681144372,
0.0115044583,
-0.0365791395,
-0.0543385707,
-0.0035292956,
0.0421367399,
0.0568661951,
0.0222654473,
0.0000020676,
-0.0440092273,
-0.0493945405,
0.0149676101,
-0.0619870014,
-0.0007306673,
0.0183453988,
0.0031137578,
0.0337939449,
0.0677824914,
-0.044383958,
0.0171412658,
0.0311821196,
0.0507954136,
0.0602307953,
0.0689643472,
-0.0211789608,
-0.0906325579,
0.0088318186,
-0.0093184141,
0.0168551598,
-0.0465281904,
-0.0115359183,
0.0479086861,
0.050069131,
0.0150272958,
0.0039204285,
0.031675376,
0.025880808,
-0.0285556521,
0.0353302695,
0.0116543761,
-0.0424872078,
0.0005296916,
-0.025952233,
0.0704746917,
-0.0020227542,
-0.0144798793,
0.0197972301,
0.0158856679,
-0.0199976321,
-0.0434393957,
-0.0027575833,
-0.0118113579,
0.0066096359,
-0.0208598804,
0.0031467255,
-0.0564274006,
0.0047411798,
-0.0238328483,
-0.0554734804,
-0.0068399166,
-0.0052304617,
-0.0130922329,
0.0281412136,
-0.0409297347,
0.0412161723,
-0.0565493479,
0.0825411603,
0.0844797045,
-0.0688510239,
0.0341807306,
-0.0361503139,
-0.0025744103,
0.0011524772,
-0.0796470568,
0.0271420609,
0.0107238954,
-0.0252007842,
0.0499237105,
0.0026665244,
0.0226587132,
-0.0073791519,
0.000843883,
-0.0338379107,
-0.0170880258,
-0.0813630223,
-0.001100714,
-0.0637897849,
0.0464462191,
-0.0901395231,
-0.0404120833,
-0.0225218311,
0.0270863865,
0.0401300117,
0.0296977032,
0.0433030985,
0.047442168,
0.0062942207,
0.0275108311,
-0.0518955402,
0.0069989776,
0.0026145501,
-0.0160125103,
-0.0002374917,
-0.0204044301,
-0.006088133,
0.0114479261,
0.0222333632,
0.0083254687,
0.023799628,
0.0706190094,
-0.0217944514,
0.0024831262,
-0.134803012,
-0.0769020617,
0.0171511918,
-0.005351536,
-0.0256530493,
-0.0366466679,
0.0521141104,
0.0158849768,
-0.0704326108,
-0.0137703456,
-0.0057050958,
0.051589556,
-0.0217315629,
0.0465725288,
-0.0172528308,
0.005647046,
0.0357941575,
-0.015412393,
0.0354129784,
0.0408005305,
0.0186140463,
0.0038005551,
0.0109222084,
0.012637144,
-0.0150540983,
-0.0043398007,
0.0280034114,
-0.0174724162,
-0.0463632159,
0.1007060483,
0.0003356468,
0.0852336362,
-0.0287112985,
0.0654989406,
-0.0147556048,
0.0136217223,
0.0411244482,
0.0376627333,
0.0477541871,
0.0205009859,
0.047864303,
0.0512269102,
-0.017955903,
-0.0607883818,
-0.0505674928,
0.0401993096,
-0.0215310361,
-0.0197682921,
0.0344341025,
0.0100427112,
-0.0062662289,
-0.0507089943,
0.0186407864,
0.0120901484,
0.0107103512,
0.0125368256,
0.0085833156,
0.0064140479,
-0.0483243316,
0.0129829915,
-0.0149710774,
-0.0266132206,
-0.0055277818,
-0.0004624957,
-0.0452764928,
0.082025826,
0.0157444719,
-0.0425734669,
-0.028948199,
-0.0237869341,
0.0080738608,
0.052805271,
0.0125619695,
-0.0381003618,
-0.0173101295,
-0.0319028236,
-0.0013477375,
0.0569041409,
0.0308492705,
-0.0136236036,
0.0229044724,
0.0303954743,
0.0182125494,
-0.0202367064,
-0.0849864483,
0.0386285856,
-0.0503886566,
-0.041227527,
0.0205707084,
0.0126887076,
0.0058284071,
0.0577975437,
-0.0213724524,
0.0222894456,
0.0449239202,
0.0089719007,
-0.0528286062,
-0.0389979333,
-0.0110462951,
-0.0038840557,
0.0091899196,
0.0276360195,
-0.0067549194,
-0.0437054634,
-0.0452674925,
-0.0562816858,
0.0002569796,
-0.0215608068,
-0.0446736142,
-0.0207583588,
0.009307229,
0.031488426,
-0.0134651111,
-0.0581993535,
0.0362483412,
0.0296401288,
-0.021556396,
0.0328807533,
-0.0476212278,
0.0451222099,
-0.0685670003,
0.0454072729,
0.0319567956,
-0.0004590704,
0.0455538817,
-0.0121561866,
0.0196873657,
-0.0395384282,
0.008630204,
-0.0557444692,
0.0321372189,
-0.00206507,
0.0298291091,
0.0322785228,
0.0126874205,
0.0156172477,
-0.0238197595,
-0.0709340349,
0.0139770471,
-0.0157034602,
-0.0265057478,
0.0275377836,
0.0300756432,
-0.0333070531,
-0.0233392064,
-0.024228327,
-0.0253338031,
0.0153515153,
-0.0092990268,
-0.0271936618,
-0.0075635361,
-0.0162543561,
-0.0299385227,
0.0461678877,
0.0187190324,
0.0266921055,
-0.014026003,
-0.0360315852,
-0.0231585111,
0.0324848481,
-0.0022172411,
-0.0385800973,
0.0115135489,
-0.0386845246,
-0.0243945513,
0.0140772685,
-0.0071473313,
0.0424219407,
-0.0216566753,
-0.0158879012,
0.0420133434,
-0.0078051733,
-0.0099552907,
-0.0140298782,
-0.0370287448,
-0.0060373964,
0.0110070966,
0.027883552,
-0.04211035,
0.006095795,
0.0240424424,
0.0383177325,
0.0123565672,
0.0245784037,
0.0332694948,
-0.0156476777,
0.0175106656,
-0.069091484,
-0.0464466438,
-0.0455166847,
0.0972969159,
0.0197115131,
0.0320757963,
-0.012207889,
-0.0358900167,
-0.0414952859,
-0.0323603936,
-0.0189659577,
-0.0293733403,
0.0674924031,
-0.0410355292,
0.0425647795,
-0.0125898039,
-0.0293081403,
-0.0231826771,
0.0381905101,
-0.0420296267,
0.033581011,
0.0455984622,
-0.0517346933,
-0.0223399643,
-0.0002981858,
0.0076503824,
0.0771207362,
0.0035791961,
-0.0186397284,
0.0058726622,
0.0071367887,
0.0133197224,
0.0277233887,
0.0332941078,
0.0311498903,
0.028625926,
0.0363163501,
0.0007539302,
-0.0495730676,
0.0050019841,
0.0192605592,
-0.0209891181,
-0.0163906254,
-0.0018409274,
0.0497360304,
-0.0377815627,
-0.0876898021,
-0.0307859909,
0.0742980689,
0.0284409393,
0.0004325967,
0.0066430075,
0.0136802243,
0.0052004578,
0.0282262284,
0.0706108138,
-0.0948416665,
-0.0287665818,
-0.0242515318,
0.0179932248,
0.0230707452,
-0.0538707413,
-0.0241994429,
-0.1125736833,
0.0293491781,
-0.0449937657,
-0.0618280061,
-0.0101713594,
-0.066703178,
-0.0371917561,
-0.019013118,
0.032155659,
0.0646628737,
-0.0206770394,
-0.0199655425,
0.0019116353,
0.0093151089,
-0.0330857597,
0.0075133638,
-0.0572969504,
0.0350127406,
0.005833731,
0.0144685246,
0.02035705,
0.0175583269,
0.0187764615,
0.0192741137,
0.009765516,
-0.0334127285,
0.0786683559,
-0.0045026797,
0.0100188591,
0.0019958373,
0.0013516988,
-0.0672156364,
0.0411624424,
0.0248903669,
0.0955319256,
-0.0264971927,
0.0112607684,
-0.0366401747,
-0.0184254907,
0.0120571647,
0.0402647629,
-0.0117133856,
-0.0143112326,
-0.092794925,
-0.0030166751,
-0.0452878214,
-0.0399805084,
-0.0285709836,
0.0625841394,
-0.0350357145,
-0.0329479054,
-0.0562441424,
-0.0172833744,
0.0681998506,
0.0515263639,
0.0402723439,
0.0449886471,
0.0687466189,
-0.031092979,
-0.0615141988,
-0.0233100206,
-0.0414728373,
0.0109962085,
-0.0733850077,
0.0219810735,
0.0300007425,
-0.0293042716,
-0.0441642776,
0.0074394289,
-0.0641250983,
-0.0553309731,
0.0241992939,
-0.0249440577,
0.0202569645,
0.002327411,
0.0243971627,
-0.0461383462,
0.0115706781,
0.0536815338,
-0.056955304,
-0.0445975326,
-0.0252914932,
0.0000661947,
-0.0235789549,
0.036052037,
-0.0538036413,
0.0066018901,
-0.0268951021,
0.0331024118,
-0.0135224927,
0.0052649179,
0.0401246585,
0.0442518257,
-0.0207262076,
0.0632118434,
-0.0150461076,
-0.0192481317,
0.0394407436,
-0.0545092225,
-0.0155304298,
-0.0451090485,
0.0259688646,
-0.0002651988,
0.0089210439,
0.0273759216,
-0.0535308793,
0.0208629854,
-0.018786598,
0.0080675147,
-0.0253012087,
0.022636028,
-0.034303274,
0.0409736969,
-0.0228181537,
0.0116424933,
0.0181411821,
0.0224117115,
0.054893177,
-0.0223741941,
0.0111774867,
0.0426109992,
0.0094794137,
-0.0458941162,
-0.0038861413,
-0.0418992117,
-0.0736042336,
0.008034016,
0.0021933632,
0.0156256966,
0.0154753914,
0.0045940485,
-0.0277978387,
-0.0085326256,
-0.0024886571,
-0.0028912919,
0.000338186,
0.0061926041,
0.057907261,
0.0109493723,
-0.0171257704,
0.0057058465,
0.0451194569,
0.0299167279,
0.0166193116,
0.0018217455,
-0.0476568267,
-0.0455790386,
-0.0064196941,
0.0438379794,
-0.0143493852,
-0.0234032534,
0.0052354764,
-0.0172895826,
-0.0098764664,
0.0392366387,
0.0332695656,
-0.0311338287,
-0.0460355543,
0.0569004118,
0.0434841253,
0.0685045943,
-0.0192898251,
0.0194556545,
-0.000206587,
-0.0661523566,
-0.0827897489,
-0.0124608725,
-6.434161634e-33,
-0.009398371,
-0.0612571165,
0.0684327185,
-0.0011156764,
-0.0096286274,
-0.0274943691,
-0.0239912942,
-0.020483816,
-0.0510036647,
-0.0121990172,
-0.0341728963,
0.0443876274,
0.0176772848,
0.0467009284,
0.0298875961,
-0.0632800683,
0.0383924693,
-0.0027880161,
0.0293819457,
0.0394197702,
0.0441081189,
0.0389301851,
0.0078774868,
-0.0435392261,
-0.0121924868,
0.0327703208,
0.0183444992,
0.0711534992,
0.0005336446,
0.0187586937,
-0.0235935822,
0.0258888304,
0.0069664489,
-0.0093665961,
-0.0066452892,
-0.0052421805,
-0.0492015295,
-0.0213641673,
-0.0131989988,
-0.0030828756,
-0.0184898581,
-0.0069248076,
0.0609264113,
-0.0268338379,
0.0020562818,
0.0253258459,
0.0267823748,
-0.0122129796,
-0.011432345,
-0.0220446438,
-0.0410171859,
-0.0022860365,
0.0176081546,
0.004603866,
0.0000033319,
0.0411639586,
-0.0400488004,
-0.0051881257,
-0.0511408076,
0.0205779821,
0.0072677028,
0.0437690839,
-0.0173943453,
0.0475560799,
0.0219074897,
0.018417811,
0.0441039987,
-0.0019110978,
0.0003030288,
0.0511191227,
-0.0194907803,
0.0569928773,
0.0442456976,
-0.0181292258,
0.0049447394,
-0.0012625699,
-0.0685042068,
-0.0081139617,
-0.0467572622,
0.0026800691,
0.000645948,
0.0199475661,
-0.0203893539,
-0.0353976898,
-0.0316465273,
0.0254116263,
-0.0403739512,
-0.0053313421,
0.0387337208,
0.0187447816,
-0.0043994742,
0.001674854,
0.0362360887,
-0.0201591663,
-0.0484253094,
0.0360304713,
-0.0115963668,
-0.0410451405,
0.0147371264,
0.0353080444,
-0.0845096037,
-0.0040946342,
-0.0075331382,
0.002540516,
0.0039518857,
0.0243728459,
0.0035863246,
0.0357286744,
-0.0493375473,
0.0186476223,
-0.0062972172,
0.0391564928,
-0.0227446593,
0.0546235591,
0.0127065945,
0.0241522342,
0.01324513,
0.0543486513,
0.0182098597,
-0.0167552512,
-0.0073627988,
0.0163532626,
0.0219447259,
0.0222529713,
-0.0198772438,
0.0464121364,
-0.038325008,
-0.0000102511,
0.0290322956,
-0.0877356231,
0.013607569,
0.0524693392,
2.823e-7,
0.0422092266,
0.0430318564,
0.0303989425,
0.0512432605,
-0.0000136572,
0.0158250034,
0.0338951312,
-0.0068523348,
0.019226186,
-0.0085942764,
0.0215536729,
0.0083266674,
0.0120793721,
0.0326312296,
-0.074888885,
-0.024560729,
-0.0417612158,
-0.0218655989,
-0.0813728794,
0.0200678408,
0.0638140887,
0.0932588503,
-0.0388504528,
0.0146468114,
0.0078518987,
-0.0460178256,
-0.0332373194,
0.0161544569,
0.0099642463,
0.0139878541,
-0.0008090789,
0.0435934253,
-0.0330587365,
0.0435668714,
-0.0338823646,
0.0329409093,
-0.0345221385,
0.0498356298,
-0.0195256174,
0.0346917883,
0.0173092056,
-0.0751372874,
-0.0079507446,
-0.0236450341,
0.0442255922,
-0.0766113847,
0.0074661733,
0.0666503012,
-0.0000219259,
-0.0380802676,
0.01919985,
0.001200759,
0.0138733191,
-0.0313119926,
0.0225214791,
0.0096795121,
0.0379890464,
-0.0436132178,
0.0044214097,
0.0901312605,
-0.0109747481,
0.025563132,
-0.0270360336,
0.0287380554,
-0.0203879531,
0.0201015752,
-0.0319339707,
2.839457114e-34,
0.0424524546,
0.017109083,
0.0042899475,
-0.0282643065,
0.0463091508,
0.0059000622,
-0.0047907205,
-0.0136414524,
-0.0058814022,
-0.0963120833,
-0.0440558828
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03458v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03458v1 | Think from Words(TFW): Initiating Human-Like Cognition in Large Language Models Through Think from Words for Japanese Text-level Classification | 2023-12-06T12:34:46 | 2023-12-06T12:34:46 | Chengguang Gan, Qinghao Zhang, Tatsunori Mori | cs.CL | cs.CL | The proliferation of Large Language Models (LLMs) has spurred extensive
research into LLM-related Prompt investigations, such as Instruction Learning
(IL), In-context Learning (ICL), and Chain-of-Thought (CoT). These approaches
aim to improve LLMs' responses by enabling them to provide concise statements
or examples for deeper contemplation when addressing questions. However,
independent thinking by LLMs can introduce variability in their thought
processes, leading to potential inaccuracies. In response, our study seeks to
bridge the gap between LLM and human-like thinking processes, recognizing that
text comprehension begins with understanding individual words. To tackle this
challenge, we have expanded the CoT method to cater to a specific domain. Our
approach, known as "Think from Words" (TFW), initiates the comprehension
process at the word level and then extends it to encompass the entire text. We
also propose "TFW with Extra word-level information" (TFW Extra), augmenting
comprehension with additional word-level data. To assess our methods, we employ
text classification on six Japanese datasets comprising text-level and
word-level elements. Our findings not only validate the effectiveness of TFW
but also shed light on the impact of various word-level information types on
LLMs' text comprehension, offering insights into their potential to cause
misinterpretations and errors in the overall comprehension of the final text. | [
0.0506751984,
0.0199244265,
-0.0177534688,
0.0575985536,
-0.0493136197,
0.0619328246,
0.0408475921,
-0.0025357115,
0.0075447448,
-0.0498987325,
-0.0526560098,
-0.0574391745,
0.0431122407,
-0.0306571107,
0.0285114143,
-0.0640653446,
0.0342061147,
-0.0394098759,
-0.0074539254,
-0.0047810301,
0.0206055678,
-0.0120543055,
0.0012050041,
0.0055043106,
0.0077368524,
-0.0419380665,
-0.0003614356,
-0.0221397392,
0.0271639396,
-0.0404885821,
0.0108073754,
0.0418430716,
0.0133283203,
0.0291049276,
0.0000024546,
-0.0327056535,
-0.0190484729,
-0.0323593095,
0.0006707347,
0.0383260548,
0.0088954549,
0.0212791376,
0.0251812022,
-0.0002084646,
-0.016995579,
-0.0028532129,
-0.0021846443,
0.0477031395,
0.0770793483,
0.0379380062,
-0.0007909769,
-0.0634324402,
0.0078673083,
0.0040220884,
0.0503772087,
-0.0280222669,
0.0388585329,
-0.01961275,
-0.0003641789,
0.0365541466,
-0.0298685096,
0.0327083245,
0.0131624527,
0.0178964045,
0.0059316992,
0.0280422624,
0.0482058227,
-0.0305784494,
0.0170573853,
0.0609923191,
0.0406610221,
-0.035997197,
-0.0498056188,
-0.0031819129,
0.0105296439,
0.0580775589,
-0.0485793725,
0.0478918962,
-0.0479752049,
0.0132091464,
0.0349920467,
0.0239029285,
0.0085751154,
0.0271502379,
-0.0626459122,
0.0602133423,
-0.0081152236,
-0.0840105787,
0.0204798039,
0.0038287689,
-0.0236063208,
-0.0343627147,
0.0128767807,
0.055779729,
-0.0163583383,
0.0604076385,
0.0159142464,
-0.0531838313,
0.0123254126,
-0.0654188544,
0.032654345,
0.0330816135,
-0.0245471336,
0.0016256282,
0.0160242245,
0.0107452944,
0.0150961792,
0.0341891795,
-0.0598078072,
0.0416982919,
-0.0452925675,
-0.0496024117,
-0.0591944456,
0.0243397299,
-0.0047102915,
-0.0100550102,
-0.0043539992,
0.01300768,
-0.0125388801,
-0.019085234,
-0.0349358581,
-0.0336636044,
0.0235934425,
0.0245226715,
-0.0656936169,
0.0051916498,
-0.0345249288,
0.0247708075,
-0.0052726003,
-0.0008262493,
0.0203084964,
0.0039948686,
-0.0055399179,
-0.0081359083,
0.0106738908,
0.0047485204,
-0.0266449451,
-0.0495181531,
-0.0260360632,
-0.0065895841,
-0.0236452073,
-0.0271648876,
0.0033597618,
-0.0484675989,
-0.014739777,
0.0132441111,
0.0380044617,
-0.0123180253,
0.0227219537,
0.0335581861,
-0.0041353982,
0.0630161464,
-0.0007105453,
0.0290940031,
0.02761079,
0.0273733661,
0.0191036686,
0.0195862409,
0.0423870161,
-0.0197473206,
0.0332701243,
0.017890783,
0.0074681742,
0.0450185426,
-0.0071921218,
-0.0064166472,
-0.0364681706,
0.0065266825,
-0.0033816029,
0.0448948108,
0.0223032422,
0.0159153268,
0.0001125825,
0.0436668284,
0.0778067634,
0.0882616267,
-0.0475402251,
0.0299410168,
0.0660569295,
0.0304400492,
0.0292562824,
0.0433984548,
0.0071298322,
-0.0086692451,
-0.0380366221,
0.0382485166,
0.0197389312,
-0.013721833,
-0.0383625515,
-0.0829388499,
-0.0401026458,
0.019576462,
0.0021339217,
0.0414919853,
0.0221808087,
0.0235346928,
-0.0176541544,
0.0039756941,
0.0363112688,
-0.0200040396,
-0.0072711688,
-0.0530050024,
0.0469972976,
0.0432677232,
0.0267130975,
-0.02758554,
0.0022911672,
0.033216428,
0.0438874438,
0.068185322,
0.0199165549,
-0.0216287412,
-0.0707645118,
-0.0150896208,
-0.0078490889,
0.0000900191,
-0.0111210914,
0.0213864669,
-0.0310351755,
-0.0004200229,
-0.0140925488,
0.003216092,
-0.0480238274,
0.0501245223,
-0.0425258502,
-0.039715074,
-0.0455490798,
0.0498729609,
0.0039875102,
-0.0114601376,
-0.0037581413,
0.0153025715,
0.0078980802,
-0.0274418872,
-0.0223596692,
0.0122166099,
-0.0477528945,
-0.056258563,
-0.0200265553,
0.0014773675,
-0.0336632133,
-0.0064022611,
-0.0025335944,
-0.0143602705,
-0.0439144894,
-0.033362288,
-0.0071109645,
-0.0601441786,
0.0428698584,
-0.029674381,
0.0005743433,
-0.0578447096,
0.0890008062,
-0.0160159748,
0.0304290466,
0.0561311096,
-0.0036879361,
0.0253887288,
0.0112170754,
-0.03863528,
0.009779972,
0.0150784533,
-0.0053176321,
-0.0206205528,
0.0458732694,
-0.0569306761,
-0.0142852571,
-0.0909335166,
-0.0137662329,
-0.0050203791,
0.0128835114,
-0.0017767597,
-0.0254090056,
-0.0508106463,
0.0138246277,
-0.0131528396,
0.0034355076,
-0.0240904782,
0.0118297674,
0.0355702005,
-0.0228699595,
0.0320460796,
-0.0071042064,
0.001429703,
-0.0033418569,
0.0395925343,
0.0234242585,
-0.0698518157,
-0.0629217699,
0.0623342618,
-0.0438514501,
-0.0343521498,
-0.0035966753,
-0.0519484058,
0.0356546938,
-0.0357243344,
0.0552617051,
0.067244865,
0.0395984426,
0.0248137917,
0.0538132228,
-0.0144564081,
-0.0389355645,
0.0265693218,
0.0024448961,
-0.0234196745,
-0.0048953844,
-0.0266884454,
0.0017286484,
0.1071943045,
0.0427703895,
-0.0372284651,
-0.0323542207,
0.0038386751,
-0.0756534487,
-0.0272549093,
-0.0907323137,
-0.0195482839,
-0.0518502183,
0.0324811526,
-0.0047427225,
-0.0326143242,
0.0896345004,
-0.000501396,
0.0111379186,
-0.1007658467,
0.0272394828,
-0.0409821644,
0.05354793,
-0.005521582,
0.0107121058,
-0.0073972531,
-0.0206259452,
-0.0553240851,
0.044235494,
0.0011342388,
-0.0206879079,
0.0492799953,
-0.0471870899,
-0.0195226241,
-0.0025124636,
-0.0078669935,
-0.0512694232,
-0.0377772786,
-0.0322348848,
-0.0416654125,
0.008434887,
0.038655661,
0.0048607318,
0.0225118622,
0.0597544834,
0.0015480453,
-0.0325792283,
-0.0216539428,
-0.0280822869,
0.0276409965,
0.0160863735,
-0.0105511853,
0.0364955254,
-0.0609857962,
0.098245427,
0.0440871753,
0.0199166518,
0.0032577715,
0.0286385324,
0.0177309439,
0.0551316887,
-0.0137858577,
-0.023819156,
0.0091456082,
0.079553619,
-0.0548024513,
-0.0686901063,
0.1248858422,
0.0574181117,
-0.060093876,
-0.0018447482,
-0.0493931472,
0.02093268,
0.0046176361,
0.0040418366,
-0.0275618415,
-0.0342392363,
0.0145472912,
0.0071236123,
-0.0498638004,
-0.0071724257,
-0.0034821255,
-0.1224322841,
0.0071335873,
0.0066446136,
-0.0267047696,
0.0287597124,
-0.037053559,
0.027752297,
0.0949161276,
0.0326109678,
0.0131877828,
-0.0165538974,
0.0012613049,
0.0115893949,
-0.0368199311,
-0.0156953037,
0.0279071778,
0.0237667896,
-0.0033311828,
-0.009907607,
0.0316293612,
-0.0071857963,
-0.0272743814,
0.0595840849,
-0.0513946228,
0.0202534664,
-0.0394397415,
0.0157278031,
0.021381652,
0.0104557425,
-0.0418029837,
0.0238175578,
0.0144210728,
-0.0244770776,
0.0394328088,
0.0552460141,
0.0093653742,
-0.0249322969,
-0.0425170772,
0.0372706391,
-0.024999423,
0.0735909194,
0.0596246161,
-0.1101347581,
0.0234197788,
-0.0097643388,
-0.0208022334,
0.0015858139,
-0.0387075804,
0.0456992984,
-0.0159472581,
0.0652960986,
-0.088601701,
-0.0724072605,
0.0083006117,
0.0258409102,
0.0376625173,
0.0235372111,
-0.017308427,
-0.0087764133,
0.0042000916,
0.0132541591,
-0.0110639008,
0.0323657431,
-0.0313930847,
-0.0449254699,
0.0031271435,
-0.0413225442,
-0.0147885093,
0.0288143437,
-0.0449783355,
-0.0319313109,
-0.0207658485,
0.0223485008,
0.0121882278,
0.0018291576,
0.0464899875,
-0.0470041633,
0.0697405189,
0.0140411407,
-0.0060025845,
0.0292741098,
-0.0000555894,
0.0607498139,
0.0058146925,
0.0092923455,
-0.0011019171,
0.0061460058,
0.0166577399,
0.023738265,
-0.0286642369,
-0.013187224,
0.0201519784,
-0.0025969348,
0.0216902532,
-0.034149427,
-0.0005474483,
-0.0617882684,
0.0151884658,
-0.0069325333,
-0.0390971154,
-0.0276737623,
-0.0219477993,
0.0472742692,
-0.0161383413,
-0.039190229,
-0.0040694978,
0.0033894947,
0.0290611107,
-0.0127046593,
-0.017336281,
0.0138231106,
0.0562390499,
-0.0234420355,
0.0053389929,
-0.0240455903,
-0.048493728,
-0.0081144609,
0.0105990591,
0.0524794161,
0.1353155822,
0.0028188978,
-0.0317867175,
-0.0146167194,
0.0040584626,
-0.0568149202,
-0.0070987381,
0.0091565354,
0.0190964155,
0.0020726311,
-0.0030524356,
0.0013566143,
-0.0494468361,
-0.0199603643,
0.0167713035,
0.0121283922,
-0.0134864617,
-0.0572889559,
0.026082512,
0.0217173602,
0.0181046724,
-0.0422304571,
0.057770133,
0.0303220842,
0.0074791401,
0.0024127718,
0.0126468064,
-0.0367056318,
0.0234715734,
0.0321737789,
0.031313967,
-0.0013384501,
-0.0048238663,
-0.1111319587,
-0.0597466677,
-0.0048617548,
0.0140448483,
0.0215042513,
-0.0054611857,
0.0020962826,
0.0451348163,
-0.010598666,
-0.0186884403,
-0.0410240851,
0.0275250394,
-0.004023843,
-0.0081292614,
-0.0215520952,
-6.827529064e-33,
-0.0592454188,
-0.0542401299,
0.0294935349,
0.0433907546,
-0.0335057825,
0.0209241845,
-0.0386076756,
0.0085400473,
0.0254643504,
0.0169524532,
-0.0200309865,
0.0035709329,
-0.0045693405,
0.0392677486,
-0.0036337441,
-0.0028906509,
0.0047091558,
-0.0138289547,
-0.0055184076,
-0.0014214969,
0.0384301469,
0.0015850894,
0.0034610475,
-0.0096106445,
0.0731205493,
-0.0473126434,
0.0160987619,
0.0378938876,
-0.0056722658,
0.0350571759,
-0.0503700003,
0.0462740436,
0.0329246484,
-0.0090816431,
-0.019470809,
0.0768198222,
-0.0660316646,
-0.0351039618,
0.0371321142,
0.0013420793,
-0.0301251896,
-0.0345148183,
-0.0001819588,
0.004952156,
0.014495559,
-0.0147799095,
0.0553884804,
-0.0310655925,
-0.0112256883,
-0.0104910359,
-0.0845570117,
-0.0057024346,
-0.0152570959,
-0.0173829272,
0.0158585683,
0.0266623143,
-0.0242605191,
0.0093614794,
-0.0476417132,
0.0249475706,
0.0137149515,
-0.0183789004,
0.0238702837,
0.0278373249,
0.0070188064,
0.0336141661,
0.0135776103,
0.0102040926,
-0.0333743058,
-0.0209630616,
0.0381678008,
-0.0170562919,
0.008216518,
0.0622149296,
0.0335714258,
-0.0101045296,
-0.0482033975,
0.0143776257,
0.0149853555,
0.0061603631,
0.0548817851,
-0.0373754203,
-0.0695691705,
-0.0276759975,
-0.0543301366,
-0.0315933824,
-0.0387975052,
0.0137282759,
0.0241324324,
-0.0173182916,
-0.0278919693,
-0.0549674258,
0.0208458882,
-0.0274098683,
-0.0146451788,
0.040688429,
-0.0271682292,
0.0484304652,
-0.0084843747,
0.0277233347,
-0.0340051986,
-0.0306837372,
-0.0361525938,
0.0155281508,
0.0162619799,
0.0204668269,
0.0300120581,
-0.012223768,
-0.0293590631,
-0.0196750499,
-0.0410245359,
-0.0197201371,
0.0166095402,
-0.0166432485,
0.0248463154,
0.0315011069,
-0.0092348456,
0.0380570665,
0.0358823463,
-0.0397926867,
-0.0320987143,
-0.0158990212,
-0.0594921522,
-0.0038730649,
-0.0103075663,
0.000372776,
-0.0049228319,
0.0271266568,
0.0560885519,
-0.073929593,
0.011601598,
0.0491125844,
3.121e-7,
0.0133066904,
0.0638925135,
-0.0247136075,
0.014009553,
0.0305218603,
0.0402947217,
-0.0119347107,
-0.0197054036,
0.1005040109,
-0.0224681646,
0.0338845663,
0.0524906553,
0.0677389726,
-0.0096964436,
-0.1127594709,
-0.0057402425,
-0.011198611,
0.0252216719,
-0.0655235425,
-0.0041172584,
0.07561519,
0.0131897852,
-0.0153702488,
-0.0351671465,
-0.0121759707,
-0.0114349602,
0.0807796642,
-0.0121217985,
-0.0076910867,
0.030024739,
0.0386833549,
-0.005078306,
0.0213052854,
0.0152420048,
0.0090342192,
0.0068903239,
0.0367762372,
0.0327886827,
0.0479191206,
-0.0083575938,
-0.0128713949,
0.0065146703,
0.0113130147,
-0.0906189457,
0.0689439252,
-0.0862612426,
-0.0111743957,
0.0245600119,
0.0122494996,
-0.0412376411,
0.0093816267,
0.0002623181,
-0.0186395533,
0.0538248084,
-0.0000330072,
-0.0360221937,
-0.0034958043,
-0.0534489565,
-0.0260962714,
0.0100006303,
-0.0403480977,
-0.0316226594,
-0.0629040226,
0.012854171,
0.0186748989,
-0.0748397186,
0.0169964433,
2.517642347e-34,
-0.0158192962,
-0.041630134,
0.0116978986,
0.0106896479,
-0.0044698231,
-0.0210124478,
0.007381699,
0.0374909714,
0.0193869192,
-0.0818767175,
-0.0065026502
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03789v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03789v1 | Comparative Analysis of Multilingual Text Classification & Identification through Deep Learning and Embedding Visualization | 2023-12-06T12:03:27 | 2023-12-06T12:03:27 | Arinjay Wyawhare | cs.CL | cs.CL | This research conducts a comparative study on multilingual text
classification methods, utilizing deep learning and embedding visualization.
The study employs LangDetect, LangId, FastText, and Sentence Transformer on a
dataset encompassing 17 languages. It explores dimensionality's impact on
clustering, revealing FastText's clearer clustering in 2D visualization due to
its extensive multilingual corpus training. Notably, the FastText multi-layer
perceptron model achieved remarkable accuracy, precision, recall, and F1 score,
outperforming the Sentence Transformer model. The study underscores the
effectiveness of these techniques in multilingual text classification,
emphasizing the importance of large multilingual corpora for training
embeddings. It lays the groundwork for future research and assists
practitioners in developing language detection and classification systems.
Additionally, it includes the comparison of multi-layer perceptron, LSTM, and
Convolution models for classification. | [
-0.026154222,
-0.0206993427,
-0.0218261965,
0.075351797,
-0.0241160132,
0.0310079921,
0.0610714853,
-0.022273425,
0.043793302,
-0.0198413637,
-0.0543259382,
-0.0731905028,
0.0154246343,
0.0118259536,
0.0146040935,
-0.0562810116,
0.0451734811,
-0.0393023528,
0.0226321332,
0.0194882695,
0.0137675349,
0.0169698372,
0.0194066502,
0.0185979735,
-0.0251811743,
-0.0047771716,
0.0259760637,
-0.0361423902,
0.0238668919,
-0.0298360381,
-0.0060891854,
0.0236957762,
0.0346416868,
0.1214622557,
0.0000020243,
-0.0252048597,
-0.0254122317,
-0.0207922664,
0.0112044243,
0.0114197712,
0.0531956702,
-0.0837341771,
-0.0000470789,
-0.0073901787,
-0.0031077648,
-0.0502359159,
0.0390603021,
0.059969373,
0.0095006851,
0.0401329175,
-0.0251412764,
-0.0717061535,
0.030045677,
-0.0047320337,
-0.0520317256,
-0.0008513472,
-0.0036158999,
-0.0398780815,
-0.036504332,
0.0091848262,
-0.0263966657,
0.0325125195,
0.0229288302,
0.0137382131,
-0.0249105133,
0.0153667321,
-0.0144811533,
-0.0174889751,
-0.0025847817,
0.0549178571,
-0.0828700438,
-0.0126748048,
-0.0322139598,
0.0041474863,
-0.0163546968,
-0.0318659432,
-0.0197093561,
0.0443239696,
0.0095899701,
0.0230739843,
0.0095080566,
0.0322036557,
0.0543701537,
0.0031644965,
-0.044702407,
0.0235920735,
0.008391262,
-0.0249856506,
0.0129575562,
0.0081919981,
0.0251444709,
0.0191174112,
0.0382738411,
-0.0081787007,
0.0257277023,
-0.0156100905,
0.0013591979,
-0.0683104545,
0.0217882134,
-0.0805235207,
-0.0135174152,
-0.0012578655,
-0.0590967871,
0.0379679985,
-0.0900695175,
0.0217610635,
-0.0229234546,
-0.0040038605,
-0.0120435972,
-0.0369901098,
-0.020272892,
-0.0330233499,
-0.0098119732,
0.0070942868,
0.0084567638,
0.005437816,
-0.0748444274,
0.0054244353,
0.0030751538,
0.0097464593,
-0.0644136667,
-0.022548411,
-0.0008954578,
0.0242462773,
-0.0195488725,
0.0533028506,
-0.0492009521,
0.0049592219,
-0.0598473623,
-0.024114836,
0.0164260771,
0.0840666816,
0.0356260799,
-0.0311401412,
0.0170283783,
0.0417924523,
-0.0508472919,
-0.0410306789,
-0.0802573413,
-0.0115609532,
-0.0268282425,
-0.0327091105,
0.0235815234,
-0.0890137404,
0.0280663259,
-0.0073895887,
0.020491885,
-0.0080384081,
-0.0301770046,
0.0014609986,
0.0036986852,
0.0516947992,
0.0043771537,
-0.0476565734,
0.0766695812,
-0.0210376661,
0.0277399737,
0.069463402,
0.0126980711,
0.0383275487,
0.0517391302,
-0.0374167152,
0.0104458099,
0.0460101888,
-0.0630232245,
0.0178599209,
-0.020014571,
-0.0384996831,
0.0098848911,
-0.0007086713,
0.0067811022,
0.0026286549,
-0.0255325921,
0.0147853773,
0.0088986577,
0.0802389681,
0.054415144,
0.0348358974,
0.0210788604,
0.0083450545,
-0.0258326586,
0.0019536365,
0.0438113585,
0.0045171115,
0.0132415108,
-0.0072078737,
0.0062904474,
0.0536277555,
-0.0292971563,
-0.0125538744,
0.0106070628,
-0.056810718,
0.0813159645,
-0.0526005402,
0.0800182298,
-0.0126462039,
-0.0031370474,
0.0276170205,
0.015015306,
-0.0327931456,
0.00042232,
-0.0108866533,
0.0001960404,
0.0268294346,
-0.0114372438,
-0.0374580398,
0.0137912985,
-0.0117578674,
0.0145853823,
0.0556549281,
0.0187347755,
0.0221881326,
0.0316626243,
-0.0795476437,
-0.0017278603,
-0.0300539788,
-0.014339217,
0.0677004009,
-0.0384974591,
0.083236292,
0.0246787611,
-0.0216070749,
-0.0386956595,
0.0238334648,
0.0124330847,
0.0044318512,
0.0411398411,
0.0649775863,
-0.0136213545,
0.030969996,
0.0160268601,
-0.0482512899,
0.0129259909,
-0.0533937663,
-0.0134463804,
0.005077628,
-0.0180664975,
-0.040298745,
-0.0139018949,
-0.0443726778,
-0.0244318452,
0.0003418559,
-0.0282081328,
-0.0410100333,
0.0426207781,
-0.0094703464,
0.0202507321,
-0.0217741709,
-0.0142637081,
-0.0650035441,
0.0503958277,
-0.020893909,
0.0524431765,
0.0272740982,
0.0470296144,
0.0075805662,
-0.0185078308,
0.0946332291,
0.0169253945,
-0.0556159131,
0.0259028077,
-0.0170366149,
0.0096972566,
0.0368268453,
0.0266225077,
-0.008952545,
-0.0251727365,
-0.0706845596,
-0.0052646389,
-0.0447259359,
-0.0095840888,
-0.0252751429,
0.0080781002,
0.0113510527,
-0.0476182587,
-0.0420892648,
0.0037759668,
0.013352151,
0.0145136314,
0.054838568,
-0.0083016641,
0.015644962,
0.0085950848,
-0.0101029994,
0.0021886001,
0.0649231896,
0.0132725853,
-0.0585187003,
-0.0415597968,
-0.0175234471,
-0.0197848901,
0.0077939942,
0.0025202981,
-0.0274871849,
0.0155229978,
0.0118517391,
0.0287611634,
0.0330945067,
-0.0087619033,
0.0401313715,
0.0419115536,
0.035738524,
-0.0044248751,
0.0137228556,
-0.0122833876,
0.0677017346,
-0.0256311502,
-0.0053383722,
0.014441276,
0.0240506809,
0.0216130614,
-0.0069689583,
-0.0288680177,
-0.0422085226,
-0.0192398839,
0.0313672833,
-0.0350735411,
-0.0129433954,
0.0365883596,
0.0291817412,
0.0185749307,
-0.044468578,
0.0460389405,
-0.0282960441,
0.0064786514,
-0.080680117,
-0.0518065803,
-0.0425143316,
0.0354595184,
0.0119460719,
0.0366367213,
-0.0676276684,
-0.0409242176,
-0.0073172655,
0.0335988887,
-0.0011670501,
0.0046458119,
0.0309022926,
-0.012763002,
-0.0441095196,
-0.0380408876,
0.003718199,
-0.0218488313,
-0.0115572354,
-0.0117733143,
-0.009550293,
0.0468032137,
-0.0157968067,
-0.0393066965,
0.0362352505,
0.0551663861,
0.0329502933,
-0.0056306217,
0.0043229847,
-0.004764434,
0.0631628484,
-0.0045474335,
-0.0200740565,
0.0022245659,
-0.0277519766,
0.0267846733,
0.0230895095,
-0.0295965169,
0.0012704741,
-0.0285584964,
-0.0128601631,
0.0132553689,
-0.0146487216,
-0.035816405,
-0.0359872058,
0.0061390102,
-0.037642587,
0.0163399782,
0.0941434503,
0.016605895,
-0.1027875394,
-0.0090838131,
-0.012706073,
0.0023779301,
-0.0000415186,
-0.0093260705,
-0.060103748,
-0.0188093539,
-0.0332300924,
-0.0548552722,
0.0154715888,
0.0138074653,
0.0193975512,
-0.0561936982,
-0.015290183,
-0.0038797955,
-0.0972535238,
-0.0471127033,
-0.0451604687,
-0.040163856,
0.0115550021,
0.0218407325,
-0.0593005531,
0.0330752693,
-0.0434616879,
0.010181739,
-0.0639246851,
-0.0178198759,
-0.0048478129,
-0.0437408201,
-0.0284729674,
0.0395369604,
0.0642192289,
-0.0785916224,
-0.0283094067,
-0.0019619439,
-0.0033848491,
-0.0029332198,
-0.0194943491,
0.0457763597,
0.0309251398,
-0.0085196393,
0.0141657889,
-0.0123596024,
-0.0137910265,
0.0107983733,
0.0266563576,
0.0651195124,
-0.0071593663,
-0.0354038142,
-0.0069250776,
-0.0276269317,
-0.0275688022,
0.0126216169,
-0.0061071436,
-0.0553962961,
-0.0174736269,
-0.0417692699,
0.0535068512,
-0.0421780944,
-0.003297359,
0.0220792759,
-0.0253695101,
-0.0147036035,
-0.0218462218,
-0.0560757145,
0.0094032586,
0.0304308645,
0.0271000285,
0.0319900289,
-0.0140841613,
-0.0188031234,
-0.0295767412,
0.0252240337,
0.003887702,
0.0161530953,
-0.0378300585,
0.019519439,
0.0270787496,
-0.0234480519,
0.0111895641,
-0.0024335312,
-0.0563286394,
-0.0101629738,
-0.0226154886,
-0.0343756229,
-0.0027680509,
0.0362416916,
-0.0058205295,
-0.0611472614,
0.0598483384,
0.0090373522,
-0.0057164156,
-0.0382653102,
0.0065738806,
-0.0011627725,
-0.0250068363,
-0.0032071834,
-0.0236186478,
0.005878373,
0.0028850664,
-0.0548376143,
-0.0417205617,
-0.0282075331,
-0.0435791425,
-0.0065651438,
0.0801453888,
-0.0182507467,
-0.0479350872,
-0.0498234108,
-0.0053979638,
0.0054246173,
-0.0083491858,
0.0332379192,
-0.0289994646,
0.0528607443,
-0.019900389,
-0.006826574,
0.0427664183,
0.0508128963,
-0.0343345702,
-0.0028975287,
0.0565286726,
0.0464914255,
0.0408865511,
-0.0100997398,
0.0592632256,
-0.0279858597,
0.0106260534,
0.001989983,
0.0178465284,
-0.0257116016,
0.0081188846,
-0.0091000414,
-0.0169992466,
-0.0330895372,
0.0533437096,
-0.0102164717,
0.0363463126,
0.0026448776,
-0.0152293406,
0.0482478328,
-0.0566927269,
0.0419952385,
-0.0246848073,
-0.0093178079,
-0.0164128486,
0.0215425193,
0.0195609778,
-0.0268681012,
0.0217519216,
-0.022236852,
-0.0464553609,
0.0242458489,
0.0690598339,
-0.0256421901,
-0.0224865396,
0.0590464212,
-0.0353651568,
-0.0404637158,
0.0243527591,
0.0561756566,
0.0440998822,
-0.0134651763,
-0.0264405552,
0.0020103271,
-0.0336271152,
0.0745912641,
-0.0441671088,
-0.0052764043,
0.0149566615,
0.0171333198,
0.0940283835,
0.0328459293,
0.0231080242,
-0.02702309,
0.0109176124,
0.0250252765,
-0.0297329891,
-0.0160753578,
-5.883876362e-33,
0.0183619037,
-0.0382644497,
-0.0172805618,
-0.0376820676,
0.0014676773,
0.0133523634,
0.0077885878,
0.0236357246,
-0.0178817715,
0.0188215151,
0.0154153025,
-0.0024516908,
0.0165280364,
0.0612009354,
0.018115107,
0.0062306565,
0.0135973524,
0.0002483157,
0.0167127177,
0.0267807078,
0.0635701492,
0.0275275037,
0.0875188187,
-0.0148079647,
0.0216500387,
0.0198004693,
0.0213362556,
-0.0135278255,
0.0456464067,
0.028273087,
-0.0442953669,
0.0715946853,
0.024493454,
-0.0118477438,
0.0042204568,
0.0382810719,
0.0005031301,
-0.0784185678,
-0.0372123048,
0.0596569143,
-0.0153744118,
-0.0391058996,
0.0339435786,
-0.0055335439,
0.0251126681,
0.0186089259,
0.0943301991,
0.0014720489,
-0.0298257973,
-0.0052610724,
-0.0730224177,
0.0470262244,
-0.0353603624,
0.0362214074,
0.0737098828,
0.0730422586,
0.0145452246,
0.0489639193,
-0.1331801564,
0.0239196327,
-0.0396223404,
0.0019833196,
0.0312778987,
0.0416853167,
-0.0238483772,
0.0377399549,
0.0310733467,
0.0247759167,
-0.0012037761,
0.0422930345,
0.0790451244,
0.0036263906,
0.0626277104,
0.0928996429,
0.0068220124,
-0.0597796366,
-0.0873386413,
0.0374391899,
0.0086160526,
-0.0210428052,
0.0357811451,
-0.0035654081,
-0.0547701977,
-0.0358702727,
-0.014034193,
-0.017688904,
-0.0300464779,
-0.0295007695,
0.0007631606,
-0.0356248133,
0.0033919162,
-0.018490307,
0.0214689057,
-0.0185320489,
-0.0242569577,
0.0114474082,
-0.0265498701,
0.0510689914,
0.0203027762,
0.0335651897,
-0.0047192825,
-0.0516985357,
-0.0181530099,
-0.0000597809,
0.0175586548,
0.0013425231,
0.0754448995,
-0.0006808155,
-0.0407679975,
0.0211323444,
0.0054813065,
-0.0447288118,
0.0155137982,
0.0480518416,
-0.0309639312,
-0.0251444709,
0.0027506812,
0.0666851848,
0.0368798301,
-0.0109626316,
0.0080178007,
-0.0434621647,
-0.0138223274,
0.0081249801,
-0.0416607931,
-0.0334680825,
-0.0371307172,
0.0152144078,
0.0415211283,
-0.0910520926,
0.0069293384,
-0.0154576488,
2.657e-7,
0.0453502759,
0.0373444818,
0.0315722413,
-0.0405728817,
0.0015073564,
0.0468380526,
-0.0068290508,
0.0415602066,
-0.0641608611,
0.0715897903,
0.0059572416,
0.0175617244,
0.0538415648,
0.042850282,
-0.0622746237,
0.0149155343,
-0.0319925137,
0.0346685089,
-0.0551659837,
0.0367509611,
0.0101551553,
0.1063393056,
-0.0124451304,
-0.0138155576,
-0.0007388639,
-0.0540525764,
0.046414867,
-0.0298982915,
0.0150317056,
0.0236390214,
0.0038553434,
0.0205826387,
0.000027915,
-0.0003499416,
-0.0229246132,
0.0192968547,
0.0283528697,
-0.0163695272,
-0.0118236057,
0.0024455299,
0.0541269444,
0.0110129248,
-0.0234174021,
-0.0654693544,
0.0710931942,
-0.0223976094,
-0.0441913605,
0.0220962558,
0.0486564077,
-0.0158308446,
0.091940023,
-0.0241765566,
-0.0589366145,
0.0446750894,
0.0273953546,
-0.0354645699,
-0.011893129,
-0.0473307855,
0.0011633334,
0.0118371202,
-0.0186789073,
0.0343976803,
-0.0295725483,
-0.0228019375,
0.0563914143,
0.0169127155,
0.0520330928,
2.061759235e-34,
0.0119756777,
-0.0095163137,
-0.0229939148,
-0.0167026278,
0.0148942359,
-0.0382753536,
-0.0035686607,
-0.0073886937,
-0.0136100249,
-0.0430537052,
0.0184309296
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03788v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03788v1 | SmoothQuant+: Accurate and Efficient 4-bit Post-Training WeightQuantization for LLM | 2023-12-06T11:10:55 | 2023-12-06T11:10:55 | Jiayi Pan, Chengcan Wang, Kaifu Zheng, Yangguang Li, Zhenyu Wang, Bin Feng | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have shown remarkable capabilities in various
tasks. However their huge model size and the consequent demand for
computational and memory resources also pose challenges to model deployment.
Currently, 4-bit post-training quantization (PTQ) has achieved some success in
LLMs, reducing the memory footprint by approximately 75% compared to FP16
models, albeit with some accuracy loss. In this paper, we propose SmoothQuant+,
an accurate and efficient 4-bit weight-only PTQ that requires no additional
training, which enables lossless in accuracy for LLMs for the first time. Based
on the fact that the loss of weight quantization is amplified by the activation
outliers, SmoothQuant+ smoothes the activation outliers by channel before
quantization, while adjusting the corresponding weights for mathematical
equivalence, and then performs group-wise 4-bit weight quantization for linear
layers. We have integrated SmoothQuant+ into the vLLM framework, an advanced
high-throughput inference engine specially developed for LLMs, and equipped it
with an efficient W4A16 CUDA kernels, so that vLLM can seamlessly support
SmoothQuant+ 4-bit weight quantization. Our results show that, with
SmoothQuant+, the Code Llama-34B model can be quantized and deployed on a A100
40GB GPU, achieving lossless accuracy and a throughput increase of 1.9 to 4.0
times compared to the FP16 model deployed on two A100 40GB GPUs. Moreover, the
latency per token is only 68% of the FP16 model deployed on two A100 40GB GPUs.
This is the state-of-the-art 4-bit weight quantization for LLMs as we know. | [
-0.0274832081,
0.0729016885,
0.004851894,
0.0781049803,
-0.0045578214,
0.0051542195,
0.0111400597,
-0.0014872523,
-0.0059632487,
-0.0074906144,
-0.0108040152,
-0.044462949,
0.0057874094,
0.0094786584,
0.0346964188,
0.0091056656,
0.0381118171,
-0.0367408544,
-0.0042096847,
-0.0299507417,
0.0000698868,
0.0075668562,
0.0058244765,
0.0025673204,
0.0068920814,
-0.0241228137,
-0.0198433902,
0.0238650795,
0.0171488114,
-0.0161540024,
0.0132297855,
0.043481119,
0.0308581833,
0.0510836877,
0.0000022946,
-0.033328969,
0.0008478642,
-0.0104895113,
-0.0368147828,
0.0669775233,
0.0086852089,
-0.0055995709,
-0.0247516967,
0.0011245636,
-0.005699567,
0.0094544273,
0.0618552193,
-0.0098653641,
0.0441555977,
0.0482706353,
-0.0056847427,
-0.0581339188,
0.0558574572,
-0.0312164444,
-0.0097605092,
-0.060511183,
0.0162554476,
0.0073192203,
-0.0292564221,
-0.03305595,
-0.025162302,
0.0280191898,
0.0430617519,
0.0116899693,
-0.0337482803,
0.027314024,
-0.0260436572,
-0.0250932574,
-0.0360773169,
0.0483622588,
-0.090928711,
-0.0445880033,
0.0036610104,
0.0015063956,
-0.0431216396,
-0.094208084,
-0.0147724673,
0.0374956019,
0.0145074073,
0.0424636081,
0.0046885479,
-0.0225406829,
0.0582456775,
0.0195140447,
-0.039122276,
0.0517402142,
0.0416968465,
0.0107765999,
-0.0161109492,
-0.0031573973,
-0.0726746246,
-0.0358248278,
0.0162199978,
0.0017105538,
0.0133598922,
0.0043722102,
-0.0714458376,
-0.0132612484,
-0.0022576281,
-0.0566402636,
0.00736721,
0.0850729719,
-0.0336370319,
0.0072870054,
-0.0544249341,
0.0379962809,
-0.0193339381,
0.0315643623,
-0.04260372,
0.0212408621,
0.0203661416,
0.0044569592,
-0.0276453197,
0.0481000915,
-0.0506294705,
-0.023856461,
-0.0587344579,
-0.0066297445,
-0.0366410352,
-0.0460549928,
0.0102220224,
0.0204801634,
-0.0205877181,
-0.0072588953,
0.0160451662,
0.0261954125,
0.0089308536,
0.0223473739,
-0.01305601,
-0.0858556628,
-0.0036943811,
0.0352759957,
-0.0003364465,
-0.0099182213,
0.0621468648,
0.0150001291,
-0.0119575467,
-0.0676024929,
-0.0275980942,
0.0221485198,
0.0167665053,
-0.0551521629,
-0.0103523368,
-0.0922299325,
0.0225761663,
0.0067732744,
0.0164406728,
-0.0137215964,
0.0206771754,
0.0281165298,
0.0129345926,
0.0529332943,
-0.0442129672,
-0.003719449,
0.0356651396,
-0.0001293398,
0.0302292909,
0.0843871236,
0.0353369713,
0.022400232,
-0.0003834981,
0.0157890711,
-0.0178054534,
0.0533210151,
0.0210332442,
-0.008144252,
-0.0585470125,
-0.0233545415,
-0.0412226245,
0.0504766516,
0.1124514416,
0.0824002102,
-0.0717373192,
-0.0495526642,
0.0391930118,
0.0463827737,
0.0006054632,
-0.0143249286,
-0.0049122483,
-0.0272169746,
0.0291688349,
-0.0123797609,
-0.0473160297,
0.0234873369,
0.0085588023,
0.0011848332,
0.0893801972,
0.0663222671,
-0.0204781163,
-0.0202558022,
-0.0079839248,
-0.0307215042,
0.024500832,
-0.0008305578,
0.0195815861,
-0.0179385357,
-0.0170817189,
0.0715060458,
0.0335397124,
-0.0435916632,
-0.0431624763,
-0.0833652392,
0.0366307423,
0.036057353,
0.0166726988,
0.0168512147,
-0.0227062963,
0.0335970111,
0.0264855344,
0.0331515409,
-0.0121195074,
0.026355641,
0.0273074824,
-0.0848435014,
0.0030313905,
0.0073155575,
-0.0032779423,
0.0017630071,
0.0444329605,
-0.0078837564,
-0.0127549414,
-0.0183477309,
-0.0348855704,
0.0231061205,
0.0271141678,
-0.0420861281,
0.0111030955,
-0.0219873879,
0.0247436371,
0.0021949082,
-0.003545169,
-0.0002149617,
0.0348626822,
-0.0539842471,
0.0312543921,
-0.0302529652,
-0.0237654969,
-0.0234944355,
0.0757197738,
0.0338504836,
0.0200721119,
0.0529932529,
-0.0533904098,
-0.0481747352,
0.040517047,
-0.0034306962,
0.0340315811,
-0.0728585571,
0.0167369414,
0.0233834051,
0.0501254275,
-0.0232029818,
0.0337484591,
-0.031206388,
0.0047518248,
0.0255429149,
0.0441020988,
-0.0052755047,
-0.0087961843,
-0.0331824012,
0.0038424751,
0.0018577849,
0.0489645638,
-0.046208974,
-0.0092621669,
0.0130771771,
0.024237901,
-0.0976849645,
0.0229819845,
-0.0444938615,
0.039904397,
0.0281552654,
0.0345235579,
0.0034787816,
-0.0231531281,
-0.0140536558,
0.0164677911,
-0.0166820679,
0.0024469127,
-0.0045531485,
-0.019876875,
-0.0140744159,
-0.0272858795,
-0.0370955244,
0.0146641796,
0.0352207646,
-0.0480434075,
-0.066842407,
-0.0488593914,
-0.0222268067,
-0.0221503731,
0.0698949769,
0.0017960345,
-0.0365394093,
0.0061135944,
0.0027544149,
0.0254416391,
0.0511419401,
0.001811002,
-0.0166090596,
0.044753518,
0.0208613109,
-0.0364462472,
0.0387127511,
-0.0014988717,
-0.0399712473,
-0.0157068521,
-0.001369621,
-0.0412620828,
0.0842221007,
-0.0165636931,
-0.0131487334,
-0.0177862588,
-0.0154606681,
0.0118238311,
-0.0093145175,
0.0005928551,
0.0101043098,
-0.0410068668,
0.020643672,
-0.0163140111,
-0.0842609927,
0.0191186611,
-0.0523428731,
-0.0209609326,
-0.0189383123,
-0.0094214547,
-0.0165328905,
0.0463528931,
0.0279451124,
0.0440334082,
-0.0796280727,
-0.0058836909,
-0.00642059,
-0.0006316673,
-0.0423949137,
-0.03815718,
0.040848799,
-0.052532237,
0.0462211743,
-0.0516726859,
-0.0109517407,
0.026846705,
0.0496322252,
-0.0368510634,
0.02004431,
-0.0032365108,
-0.054146003,
0.0614877678,
0.0465463884,
-0.0178606715,
0.0810344368,
-0.0234987922,
0.0185292028,
-0.0277711973,
0.005546961,
0.0304304808,
0.0278593358,
0.0356872156,
-0.0256622471,
-0.0110872639,
0.0317897387,
0.0164938904,
0.0381174274,
-0.0936665237,
-0.0094199423,
0.0384141542,
0.0078949472,
-0.0119001865,
0.029834602,
0.0547081493,
-0.0392802209,
0.019936204,
0.056798622,
0.0044400012,
-0.0641046092,
0.0060311835,
0.0181072541,
0.0028829009,
0.010868785,
0.0027048404,
-0.1117817461,
-0.041070722,
0.0264319982,
-0.0143350624,
0.0203890912,
0.0183357932,
-0.0048963204,
-0.0715100989,
0.0350339189,
0.005766781,
0.0197504889,
-0.0237027928,
-0.0139784804,
-0.0028022279,
-0.0119140157,
0.0437535979,
0.0353644416,
0.0102099283,
-0.0007989861,
0.0228007771,
-0.0267154779,
-0.0276876092,
0.0257703755,
-0.0246832352,
0.0251488592,
0.0417576768,
0.0074682711,
0.0025158406,
-0.0370828509,
0.0314366668,
-0.019266529,
-0.0227267891,
-0.009678009,
0.0167156197,
0.0187051967,
-0.0157791954,
-0.0020613964,
0.0047389129,
-0.0053122966,
-0.0167503804,
-0.0322957411,
0.0450714789,
-0.0116889048,
-0.0267779361,
0.0010322746,
-0.0256918613,
-0.0432571843,
0.0240610037,
0.0237003937,
-0.014157854,
-0.0672403872,
-0.0361860916,
-0.0148643712,
-0.0423563011,
-0.0219009761,
-0.0109412353,
0.0168199465,
-0.0578133911,
-0.0173758026,
0.0286876783,
0.0022417598,
0.0162626654,
-0.0287357159,
-0.0000564408,
-0.015739575,
-0.0217316784,
-0.0941075385,
0.01935797,
-0.0417771861,
0.0536008477,
-0.0563769154,
0.0016623286,
0.0253242049,
-0.0084453849,
-0.007840855,
0.0456481501,
-0.1225791499,
-0.0613757446,
-0.0104386732,
0.0131607391,
0.0210957862,
0.0309312046,
0.0040268218,
-0.0509624332,
0.0369362496,
0.0507111773,
-0.0267136246,
0.0770659521,
0.0226776786,
-0.0120186899,
-0.0087956348,
0.0429439507,
-0.0012386295,
0.0248874761,
-0.0018702294,
0.0424444489,
-0.0292757656,
-0.0404244401,
-0.0266910065,
-0.0122001944,
0.0531767942,
-0.0080364197,
-0.0128599852,
-0.0086002117,
0.0392181762,
0.0135726817,
0.0263975672,
-0.0424674712,
-0.0071114302,
0.0271596443,
0.0253803525,
-0.0094113341,
-0.0542294197,
0.0615197942,
-0.024932798,
0.020942755,
0.0042546242,
-0.0468875989,
0.0221587941,
0.0389591679,
-0.0239984114,
-0.0137068741,
-0.0104779536,
-0.0185894407,
0.03553994,
-0.0388244279,
-0.0033793007,
-0.006908447,
-0.0040659774,
-0.0343909487,
0.0334756412,
-0.0260139219,
-0.0608906709,
-0.0695954636,
-0.0075937225,
0.065945752,
0.0397307798,
0.0641496032,
0.0228224657,
-0.0221625231,
-0.0182990078,
0.0153335081,
-0.0182724949,
0.0073428238,
0.0682297796,
0.0179920308,
-0.017652018,
-0.0077591976,
0.0282886606,
0.0150691504,
0.0411186032,
0.017313214,
0.0287611168,
0.0088698147,
-0.055414319,
-0.0241728239,
0.0139964893,
-0.021156095,
-0.0272669159,
0.0133012598,
-0.0321764499,
0.0398839302,
0.019362621,
-0.021324737,
-0.0388215557,
0.0217135325,
0.0486133471,
0.0008338481,
-0.0541628748,
-0.0166115146,
-0.0254615415,
0.0201053116,
0.0116352132,
-0.0025879699,
-6.867099877e-33,
-0.0104977023,
0.0198716484,
0.0468189418,
-0.017808849,
0.0044781915,
0.0319512933,
-0.0240331627,
-0.0223343447,
-0.0184285119,
-0.0201507192,
0.002395866,
0.0196171831,
0.0311594885,
0.0089067193,
-0.0093814358,
0.0108909784,
0.0682764724,
-0.0142346481,
0.0109765455,
0.0252571087,
-0.0045919977,
0.037639603,
0.0712476671,
0.0324692614,
-0.0434396416,
0.018229166,
0.0065178471,
-0.0089679305,
-0.0187567621,
0.0237256326,
-0.0596703067,
0.0450336412,
0.006313669,
0.0099843908,
-0.017840106,
-0.0501100682,
-0.0541577674,
0.0000492726,
0.045950491,
0.0386979766,
-0.0106326723,
-0.0359805301,
0.0565305836,
0.0355281308,
-0.0552134067,
-0.0310505778,
-0.0392558873,
-0.0077953143,
-0.0291373171,
-0.0353535786,
-0.0121112252,
0.0437107421,
0.0495371185,
0.020395482,
0.0738875791,
-0.0433770157,
-0.047657907,
-0.0040368331,
-0.0960296765,
-0.029134281,
0.0018538747,
0.0648627579,
0.0596936978,
0.0496783592,
0.0192543007,
0.0435159542,
0.068767868,
-0.0505902506,
-0.0199779272,
0.0783641562,
0.0618373528,
0.0355727486,
0.0411533639,
0.0126871336,
0.0962500274,
-0.0093390001,
-0.0640931278,
-0.0258819703,
0.0062893094,
-0.0015660127,
0.0378044806,
0.0452457778,
-0.0134201683,
-0.0510880165,
-0.0005064037,
0.0039292476,
-0.0386732742,
-0.0261870548,
0.0211087298,
0.031802889,
-0.0265484322,
0.0239350311,
0.0183256194,
-0.0208260231,
-0.0002061379,
-0.0195819624,
0.0095787821,
0.0361210778,
0.0270347297,
0.0363244377,
-0.0369769484,
-0.0237182025,
-0.0092877205,
-0.0195682663,
0.0249874964,
-0.0176653191,
0.0111934366,
0.0683397204,
-0.0715577081,
-0.0123731308,
-0.0440719351,
-0.0074138092,
0.0265492462,
0.1000050902,
0.013620981,
0.0103265299,
0.0172807928,
0.0289801937,
-0.0420068912,
0.0231849123,
-0.0429352447,
-0.0134264156,
-0.0051806285,
0.0505239777,
-0.0539185628,
0.0050665322,
-0.0325693972,
0.0568053983,
0.0197749808,
-0.0817897096,
-0.0443370603,
0.0363103561,
3.021e-7,
0.0330667384,
0.0022606365,
0.0270940382,
-0.0080144946,
-0.0150471209,
-0.0300315116,
0.0056112162,
0.006260741,
0.0144946584,
-0.0334967524,
-0.0134364041,
0.0443973206,
0.033853583,
0.0122714015,
-0.0532833003,
0.0219214763,
-0.0329018086,
0.0068314974,
-0.0234708022,
-0.0386367291,
-0.0141108586,
0.1181885302,
-0.0213720109,
-0.0212895852,
0.0589325204,
-0.0004094644,
0.0151045322,
0.0135260653,
0.0123813422,
0.0089259809,
0.0413732864,
0.0090458244,
-0.0090399273,
-0.0142017156,
0.0196336918,
0.0075865062,
-0.037446741,
0.0819360465,
-0.0276451893,
-0.0088642044,
0.0029344079,
-0.0234334413,
-0.0124145206,
-0.0241269339,
0.0531859472,
0.0024258962,
-0.0000981734,
-0.1114803776,
-0.0075641121,
-0.0224054549,
0.0153170889,
-0.000030018,
0.0485223085,
0.0250556506,
0.0249164999,
-0.0421575792,
-0.0269203931,
-0.0777108893,
-0.0654551163,
-0.0010994852,
-0.0468714572,
-0.0432956144,
-0.0947222263,
0.0024654586,
-0.0092620505,
-0.0652355999,
0.0105636837,
2.872806945e-34,
0.0482688509,
-0.0241157115,
0.0234995671,
0.0505320318,
0.0099665392,
-0.0402268954,
0.0046589845,
0.0157416388,
-0.0497328006,
-0.0626304001,
-0.0289524868
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03414v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03414v2 | Compressed Context Memory For Online Language Model Interaction | 2023-12-06T10:50:43 | 2024-02-06T05:53:02 | Jang-Hyun Kim, Junyoung Yeom, Sangdoo Yun, Hyun Oh Song | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | This paper presents a context key/value compression method for Transformer
language models in online scenarios, where the context continually expands. As
the context lengthens, the attention process demands increasing memory and
computations, which in turn reduces the throughput of the language model. To
address this challenge, we propose a compressed context memory system that
continually compresses the accumulating attention key/value pairs into a
compact memory space, facilitating language model inference in a limited memory
space of computing environments. Our compression process involves integrating a
lightweight conditional LoRA into the language model's forward pass during
inference, without the need for fine-tuning the model's entire set of weights.
We achieve efficient training by modeling the recursive compression process as
a single parallelized forward computation. Through evaluations on conversation,
personalization, and multi-task learning, we demonstrate that our approach
achieves the performance level of a full context model with $5\times$ smaller
context memory size. We further demonstrate the applicability of our approach
in a streaming setting with an unlimited context length, outperforming the
sliding window approach. Codes are available at
https://github.com/snu-mllab/context-memory. | [
0.0144679081,
0.0524628721,
-0.0206823181,
0.0479556955,
-0.0210784525,
0.0150187733,
0.0069146059,
-0.0235175565,
-0.0494200811,
-0.0313412994,
-0.0256401226,
-0.0632079989,
0.0326907784,
0.0250012316,
0.0236890167,
-0.0432526059,
0.0323928893,
-0.0231204703,
-0.0224500261,
-0.0007371281,
-0.0051501649,
0.0155954519,
0.0154301953,
0.0465885252,
0.0091918316,
-0.0209167656,
-0.0380054601,
0.0075445534,
-0.0021318777,
0.007723806,
-0.0000082491,
0.047439158,
0.0474635623,
-0.0056544896,
0.0000021941,
-0.028893508,
-0.0064055314,
-0.0301638003,
-0.0375098623,
-0.008706199,
0.0616620854,
-0.0217244849,
-0.0222124569,
0.0304072425,
-0.0318640955,
-0.0257383771,
0.0660350919,
-0.0088230157,
0.0237262808,
0.0412192829,
-0.0133125894,
-0.0220459066,
0.0068995403,
-0.0426303446,
0.0102261947,
-0.0613540933,
-0.000661813,
-0.0101043051,
-0.0326997079,
0.0066763638,
-0.0308664348,
0.0474680662,
0.0465380959,
-0.0021400345,
-0.0040110559,
0.0297708288,
-0.0248684585,
-0.0341906995,
-0.0216286909,
0.0590390563,
-0.0225199629,
-0.0505435243,
0.0053397315,
0.0139645739,
-0.0142105622,
-0.036385756,
-0.0458765998,
0.0392998941,
-0.0087707369,
0.0308616161,
0.0238109566,
0.0002229268,
0.0187091883,
-0.0039247153,
-0.0409438387,
0.0476086289,
0.0159767754,
0.0006683054,
-0.0466364734,
-0.0092955232,
-0.027304057,
-0.0631127506,
0.0257752072,
0.0322637372,
-0.0047454466,
0.0349305794,
-0.0821028873,
-0.031838268,
0.0144377509,
-0.0633034185,
0.028907584,
0.0444791503,
0.0062290737,
0.0474858396,
-0.0088430215,
0.0190154519,
-0.0154862758,
-0.033066757,
-0.0378690064,
-0.035441041,
-0.0013671048,
0.0227935631,
-0.0516416095,
0.0254401546,
-0.0256333873,
-0.0280312113,
-0.0295761339,
0.0642902255,
0.0067721559,
0.0074732257,
-0.0202309024,
-0.0092828935,
-0.0476691425,
0.0146975769,
0.0110307895,
0.0582786947,
-0.0132338004,
-0.0088948328,
-0.0036065658,
-0.0705752745,
-0.0209313463,
0.0163582023,
0.0278647039,
-0.0426134579,
-0.0204441939,
0.0402050316,
-0.0030937085,
-0.0538049787,
-0.0016678232,
-0.0127257369,
0.0103373379,
-0.0503824539,
-0.0158379972,
-0.0601212084,
0.0356254056,
0.0022741489,
-0.0123933498,
-0.0012568277,
0.0002563431,
0.0492393635,
-0.0238057338,
0.0687138811,
0.0230594706,
-0.0151242344,
0.0417332761,
0.0174954478,
0.0199953392,
0.078747265,
0.0181398429,
0.0167231411,
0.0195950512,
-0.0145350732,
-0.0433010571,
0.0341467075,
0.0579366684,
0.003613939,
-0.0527331904,
0.0207255576,
0.0264924672,
0.0041768136,
0.0401820093,
0.0448176712,
-0.0556352697,
-0.0209605489,
0.0545984805,
0.050198894,
0.0198993944,
0.0387011431,
0.0358309485,
0.0235920567,
-0.0420227051,
-0.0003015333,
-0.0660559312,
0.0469831228,
-0.0374503285,
0.0203333423,
0.0598803572,
0.0305706151,
-0.0304383822,
-0.0215824284,
-0.0142044183,
-0.0219071545,
0.0491806082,
0.0259234756,
0.04181806,
0.0253618173,
-0.033016488,
0.0725721419,
0.0514910966,
-0.0452875197,
-0.0287348628,
-0.0431877188,
0.0088830767,
0.0552300736,
0.0274224244,
0.0162962824,
-0.0335815139,
-0.0146407085,
0.0247063413,
0.02218372,
0.0118867438,
-0.0082040653,
0.0273024756,
-0.0466191955,
0.0211449843,
0.0189311802,
-0.003903484,
0.0088287722,
0.0421129279,
0.0391184278,
0.0232557151,
0.0173942558,
0.0320667587,
0.0008139514,
-0.0197566263,
-0.0223478023,
-0.0081704566,
0.0110654524,
0.0286475811,
-0.0156726725,
0.0444447473,
-0.0060992311,
0.0454233587,
-0.0353299342,
0.0134929949,
0.0244444422,
-0.1018235609,
-0.0537505709,
0.0425965376,
0.0131733725,
0.0251192302,
0.0216150638,
-0.0294262338,
-0.0318598598,
0.0467230119,
-0.0348037481,
0.1047849953,
-0.0307524111,
0.0163006112,
0.0115415799,
0.0489938036,
-0.0139941201,
0.0391911864,
-0.0379487649,
0.0145132989,
0.0302060023,
0.0391676724,
-0.0255344976,
-0.0368184149,
-0.0261854287,
-0.0045290478,
-0.0323512591,
-0.006773938,
-0.0020766601,
-0.0084055131,
-0.029429784,
-0.0077804928,
-0.0916696638,
-0.0039071213,
-0.0330461264,
0.022500908,
0.0370944738,
0.0574945845,
0.0218165386,
-0.021062566,
-0.0218726508,
0.0329533182,
-0.0146309379,
0.0526733175,
0.0050226133,
0.0078809215,
-0.0184050146,
-0.034423694,
-0.0390947834,
0.0033267757,
0.0684807897,
-0.0144782215,
-0.0508267805,
-0.052652657,
0.0323186107,
-0.0171655118,
0.0481551625,
-0.0460369177,
-0.0206880886,
0.0080019496,
-0.0533636622,
0.0551412702,
0.077599816,
0.0076716454,
0.045308806,
0.0538742095,
-0.0161649846,
-0.0537851565,
0.023354277,
-0.0160564408,
-0.0334051736,
-0.0338280164,
-0.0020729539,
-0.0134005612,
0.1087601483,
-0.0350354575,
0.0072447159,
-0.0599645749,
-0.0345121734,
0.0117497249,
0.0014367194,
-0.0188590959,
0.0003140127,
-0.0311733969,
0.0354198813,
-0.0169597473,
-0.0565769225,
0.0716312081,
-0.0311790034,
-0.0224846415,
-0.0399836078,
-0.0269734953,
-0.00022348,
0.063820608,
0.0119436849,
0.0229966082,
-0.0154806273,
-0.0202725325,
-0.0165841505,
0.0263583176,
-0.0028083739,
-0.0362130217,
0.0533795506,
-0.0151784802,
0.0271787811,
-0.0266189389,
-0.0292887837,
-0.0269699022,
-0.004925102,
-0.0097831376,
-0.0088621192,
0.034275461,
-0.0155285047,
0.0001089544,
0.0312716477,
-0.0151523398,
0.0753821656,
0.0021047152,
-0.0006040185,
-0.0139091322,
0.0271891709,
0.0574199334,
0.0392145216,
0.0076496238,
-0.0250696689,
-0.0043119383,
0.0671530813,
0.0786700472,
-0.0300681125,
-0.0110738873,
-0.017769007,
0.0452182293,
-0.0048019774,
-0.0079478547,
0.0467729047,
0.0345238261,
-0.0739150941,
-0.0476166792,
0.1136288866,
0.025898315,
-0.0944946408,
-0.0200649761,
-0.0336606763,
0.0241242927,
0.0047651608,
0.0389658362,
-0.0940835103,
-0.0422719233,
0.0139341317,
-0.0050016446,
0.0332603268,
-0.0136139151,
-0.0335417427,
-0.0922028348,
-0.0122941639,
0.0068784729,
-0.0458863787,
-0.0099962084,
-0.0573353991,
-0.0006033814,
0.0053726914,
0.0147791533,
0.0162251182,
-0.0139092207,
-0.0157532692,
-0.0331639312,
0.0317506231,
-0.0453710742,
0.0371899344,
0.0007380443,
0.0637001842,
0.0192971695,
0.0065762536,
0.0220505614,
-0.037179023,
0.0399061628,
-0.0178754386,
-0.018922165,
-0.0386321656,
0.0156498663,
-0.041341804,
0.0020468272,
-0.007002892,
0.0056460551,
-0.0126378844,
-0.0246039946,
-0.0266570263,
0.06792932,
-0.0036469256,
-0.0038479837,
0.0161834639,
-0.0161782932,
0.0445437096,
0.0779832453,
0.0510313176,
-0.0415058695,
-0.0159348864,
-0.0091732908,
-0.0159946289,
0.0236183424,
-0.0153761916,
-0.0245195869,
0.0413902365,
-0.0275122877,
-0.0355223939,
-0.0143461749,
0.0350559577,
0.0252209567,
-0.0371657647,
-0.0077729239,
0.0233783238,
-0.0171641689,
-0.088344112,
0.0311004817,
-0.0538530573,
0.0112822568,
-0.0453458428,
0.0025094182,
0.0366596542,
-0.0169783682,
-0.0002234846,
0.0535523929,
-0.1427644789,
-0.0570207946,
0.0052502709,
0.0515788049,
0.0234466773,
0.0702269077,
-0.0305411536,
-0.0261224695,
-0.0048793871,
-0.006213319,
-0.0498548783,
0.0495055132,
0.0316087753,
0.0225352887,
0.03046933,
0.0575031415,
-0.0313556306,
0.0148264989,
-0.0085202148,
0.0277239382,
-0.0608117171,
-0.0544429645,
-0.0107260076,
-0.0258936752,
0.0245220345,
0.0179963876,
-0.0234160349,
0.0112292096,
0.0562387146,
-0.0056596706,
0.0228640418,
-0.0442392752,
-0.0144411931,
-0.023705028,
-0.0069580884,
0.0151493,
-0.0226618722,
0.0184783377,
-0.0197464637,
-0.0245991927,
0.0158524159,
0.021663608,
-0.0071587348,
0.0586217903,
0.0252554398,
-0.0264042486,
-0.0258117951,
0.0211962387,
0.0574226491,
-0.0631851852,
0.0393302962,
0.0046502184,
-0.0176304951,
-0.010928751,
0.0439844988,
-0.0426983684,
-0.0236304197,
-0.0202322248,
-0.0001627124,
0.0293899346,
-0.0160733387,
0.0639283508,
-0.0043082298,
0.0053046914,
-0.0210804734,
0.0244248454,
-0.0208348166,
-0.0718644261,
0.0328508876,
0.0262524299,
-0.0103046503,
0.0518191904,
0.0809767693,
-0.0044642817,
0.0146897975,
0.0116625754,
0.0247737262,
-0.0291997287,
-0.011351346,
-0.0474501029,
0.0648462176,
-0.002702777,
-0.0146015501,
-0.0097983051,
-0.0879982561,
0.0050351927,
-0.0299496111,
-0.0310752951,
-0.0085660145,
0.0419234224,
0.0450964272,
0.0162074231,
-0.0037062392,
-0.0218995214,
0.0291771702,
0.014050819,
-0.0139293438,
-0.0215318892,
-6.910826063e-33,
-0.0432396606,
-0.0249739215,
0.0184775759,
-0.0171561316,
-0.0255370345,
0.0166940149,
-0.056484323,
-0.0176490508,
-0.0337984562,
-0.0428243242,
-0.0247930586,
0.0407463312,
0.0108524552,
0.0391227193,
-0.0315061025,
-0.0248401761,
0.0397594534,
0.0177261364,
-0.0022996601,
0.0495457835,
0.0302555002,
0.0183564872,
0.0505664274,
-0.0367884599,
-0.0181299392,
-0.0186503772,
0.0247676298,
0.0138586788,
0.0169364512,
0.050572902,
-0.0365752801,
0.0292219389,
0.0161723029,
-0.0740478188,
-0.0147748161,
0.0549354851,
-0.0990700722,
-0.0318403505,
0.026253812,
-0.0009573967,
-0.0211410746,
-0.0418608077,
0.0500095412,
0.0183160175,
0.0422717854,
-0.0261569899,
0.0050176205,
0.0010055845,
-0.0668311268,
-0.0300304499,
-0.0566085577,
0.003773734,
0.0216115732,
0.009660705,
0.039325159,
0.0143642658,
-0.0133550437,
0.0189019013,
-0.0633799732,
0.0217303578,
-0.0189719107,
0.0618164279,
0.0791245624,
0.0140240695,
0.0360059477,
0.0252784733,
0.0030423757,
0.0147360386,
-0.0315852761,
-0.0044307057,
0.0402860753,
0.0109612057,
-0.0084317215,
0.0182914343,
0.0284549538,
-0.019441966,
-0.0567669757,
-0.0379272103,
0.0574842356,
0.0448619872,
0.035433773,
0.0078628566,
-0.0281854514,
-0.0389832594,
-0.0234780814,
-0.0249797124,
-0.05019987,
-0.0249788612,
0.0136781763,
0.0325331613,
-0.0171654876,
0.0053657042,
0.0483248644,
-0.0283910204,
-0.0172449667,
0.0240594335,
0.0282537322,
0.016468985,
0.0098369457,
0.0313642696,
-0.0415716991,
0.0003288295,
-0.0049633761,
-0.0219368935,
0.0049623717,
0.0286194477,
0.0208203308,
0.0430043228,
-0.0678603128,
-0.0203694645,
-0.0424218625,
0.0235165209,
-0.0234161075,
0.0518066101,
0.0736243054,
0.0225467477,
-0.0082935253,
0.0700565577,
0.0318697467,
0.0026500092,
-0.0241403338,
-0.0413696021,
0.0085112881,
0.0228306297,
-0.0556545965,
-0.0212252494,
-0.0511487871,
0.0464169607,
0.0573724397,
-0.0489247479,
-0.0248944685,
0.0321519598,
2.936e-7,
0.0050713331,
0.0505701825,
0.0001037875,
-0.0155680096,
0.0258437302,
-0.002375521,
0.0416099504,
0.0224509388,
0.0308871996,
-0.0057012639,
-0.0097846081,
0.0405341871,
0.0208398774,
0.0209343042,
-0.0955135301,
-0.0083923135,
-0.0654455274,
-0.0035382379,
-0.008165516,
-0.008510503,
0.0133361146,
0.132384032,
0.0065803952,
-0.0042933282,
0.0239208713,
0.0067198575,
0.0393579304,
-0.0322344899,
0.0046055862,
-0.0186054837,
-0.0353908502,
0.0213718712,
-0.0387561284,
-0.0231684707,
-0.014222729,
0.0069375164,
-0.0606592335,
0.0893704817,
-0.0142639009,
-0.0567553043,
0.022826761,
-0.0289756246,
-0.0279255286,
-0.0446998253,
0.0805181116,
-0.0542378947,
-0.0132907806,
-0.0443033427,
0.0310508981,
-0.012981954,
-0.0244399421,
0.0198137853,
-0.0120886629,
0.0226066466,
0.0064692395,
-0.0061256732,
-0.0190113392,
-0.1124631464,
-0.0432334282,
-0.0135217439,
-0.0373413563,
-0.029361615,
-0.0676737204,
-0.0554349385,
0.0319470987,
-0.0369948931,
0.0081912233,
2.976751869e-34,
0.0266148429,
0.0074847136,
0.0170331672,
0.0558984391,
-0.0128313052,
-0.0139719155,
-0.0104042441,
0.0250314847,
0.0462647341,
-0.1043983027,
-0.0241721757
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03379v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03379v1 | A Text-to-Text Model for Multilingual Offensive Language Identification | 2023-12-06T09:37:27 | 2023-12-06T09:37:27 | Tharindu Ranasinghe, Marcos Zampieri | cs.CL | cs.CL | The ubiquity of offensive content on social media is a growing cause for
concern among companies and government organizations. Recently,
transformer-based models such as BERT, XLNET, and XLM-R have achieved
state-of-the-art performance in detecting various forms of offensive content
(e.g. hate speech, cyberbullying, and cyberaggression). However, the majority
of these models are limited in their capabilities due to their encoder-only
architecture, which restricts the number and types of labels in downstream
tasks. Addressing these limitations, this study presents the first pre-trained
model with encoder-decoder architecture for offensive language identification
with text-to-text transformers (T5) trained on two large offensive language
identification datasets; SOLID and CCTK. We investigate the effectiveness of
combining two datasets and selecting an optimal threshold in semi-supervised
instances in SOLID in the T5 retraining step. Our pre-trained T5 model
outperforms other transformer-based models fine-tuned for offensive language
detection, such as fBERT and HateBERT, in multiple English benchmarks.
Following a similar approach, we also train the first multilingual pre-trained
model for offensive language identification using mT5 and evaluate its
performance on a set of six different languages (German, Hindi, Korean,
Marathi, Sinhala, and Spanish). The results demonstrate that this multilingual
model achieves a new state-of-the-art on all the above datasets, showing its
usefulness in multilingual scenarios. Our proposed T5-based models will be made
freely available to the community. | [
0.0578293763,
0.0397924855,
-0.0109509425,
0.055108916,
0.0022474569,
0.0463395491,
0.0329994932,
0.026239397,
0.0106726279,
-0.0531348661,
-0.0476737767,
-0.0260754768,
0.0019044313,
0.0062527247,
-0.0094078947,
-0.032604102,
0.0068119932,
0.0379526876,
0.0106899841,
-0.004760169,
0.0414791889,
0.0436619706,
0.0121811135,
0.0339143202,
-0.0606934316,
0.0139251743,
0.046373073,
0.016363522,
0.0536940396,
0.0126021262,
0.0710863695,
0.0293276627,
0.0043260152,
0.0565996282,
0.0000019412,
-0.0330493413,
-0.0217358842,
-0.0099801598,
0.0078244805,
-0.0615331009,
0.073277168,
-0.0620988645,
-0.029667167,
0.0339222103,
0.0108716246,
0.0401500799,
0.09478686,
0.0638323277,
0.0799064338,
0.064884305,
-0.0144295068,
-0.0694512054,
0.0125052594,
0.0281150769,
-0.0397219397,
0.0198463798,
0.0304777045,
-0.0508818291,
-0.0519998148,
0.013430587,
-0.0290794298,
0.0078981267,
0.0310776755,
0.0211778171,
-0.0232304838,
-0.0346075222,
-0.0092355497,
-0.0288917534,
0.0231106058,
0.0453678109,
-0.0873376429,
-0.0267030671,
-0.0034219841,
0.0004723731,
-0.0349320807,
-0.0385138541,
0.0246818196,
0.0138026513,
-0.0298505202,
0.038444262,
-0.0063048224,
0.0275654197,
0.0157701783,
0.0602806434,
0.0098531796,
-0.0254327748,
-0.0118566025,
-0.0272697881,
0.0002980097,
0.0044272831,
-0.0040527689,
0.0177494362,
0.0606262721,
0.0071076513,
-0.0230476018,
-0.0036559713,
-0.0633497536,
-0.1017907336,
-0.0089049209,
-0.1030040011,
0.028547097,
0.0550061427,
-0.0630663857,
-0.0164959375,
-0.0069820336,
0.0766322762,
-0.0157638527,
0.0584560484,
-0.0385163315,
-0.0349612609,
-0.0052015483,
0.0018375161,
-0.0156991854,
-0.0293877944,
0.0170259345,
0.0435911827,
-0.0571357831,
-0.0223662872,
-0.0387221202,
-0.0417726338,
0.0194026697,
-0.0068025202,
-0.0503413826,
0.0002051977,
0.0204837006,
0.0211556517,
-0.0179260708,
0.0088097397,
-0.0396887138,
-0.0718875751,
0.0037011984,
0.0314661302,
-0.0293650888,
-0.0384138562,
0.0416561849,
0.0359807462,
-0.0374549478,
-0.0403737649,
-0.038175758,
-0.0193278696,
-0.0353655778,
-0.039320901,
0.0252925307,
-0.0629491955,
0.0443346836,
-0.0058181025,
-0.0236019529,
-0.0756524652,
-0.0112615433,
0.0089808172,
-0.0643680468,
0.0703629106,
0.0255410764,
-0.02840106,
0.0508650653,
0.0201027133,
0.0049638227,
0.0579018705,
0.02398213,
0.0519726761,
0.0406893715,
-0.008968302,
0.0013674089,
0.0843803808,
0.0122064715,
0.0019395087,
-0.048961781,
0.0094939088,
-0.0461260714,
-0.0380294248,
0.0140322121,
0.0308463052,
0.0149844615,
-0.0463288985,
0.0402687266,
0.0294821355,
-0.0268065725,
0.0332680494,
0.0416766889,
0.0405820869,
-0.0226869471,
-0.0415541679,
-0.0269593224,
0.0022546772,
-0.0135821393,
-0.0633810386,
0.0028686237,
0.0900403783,
-0.0277052596,
-0.0280552022,
-0.0106703434,
-0.0313436165,
0.053185109,
-0.0368126854,
0.0543070063,
0.0401090607,
-0.0349136703,
0.0334194079,
0.0260945763,
-0.0255343765,
0.0158629883,
-0.0513823219,
0.0091016954,
0.0497878343,
0.0115867276,
-0.0049566068,
-0.0031854387,
-0.0747380182,
0.0076577417,
0.0566160195,
-0.010677902,
0.0082979342,
0.0087158456,
-0.0348146893,
-0.030276088,
0.043196816,
-0.013132358,
0.0183450803,
0.0499372594,
0.0522106402,
0.0158759989,
0.0232919231,
-0.0344416276,
0.0211914834,
0.0116534838,
-0.029219415,
0.022446705,
0.0244003627,
0.0530905016,
0.017652994,
-0.0256691314,
-0.0726836398,
0.0164173581,
-0.0156790596,
-0.0412781499,
0.0088280523,
-0.01913465,
-0.032673981,
0.010762115,
-0.0232586917,
-0.0101366555,
0.0881914422,
-0.033312466,
0.0168585721,
0.0362890512,
-0.0167107526,
-0.0213574916,
-0.026726786,
-0.0180894863,
-0.0651039705,
0.0339284539,
0.037753243,
0.0516355485,
-0.0201288704,
-0.0192602929,
0.0116382902,
-0.05016331,
0.0350147858,
0.024369536,
-0.0643365756,
-0.0001237947,
-0.0528389215,
0.0194948558,
0.016702652,
0.0461561196,
0.0059625935,
-0.0220844168,
-0.0266519878,
-0.0192485247,
-0.0415599756,
-0.0203051828,
0.0091591589,
0.0032360735,
0.0056427107,
0.0098265829,
-0.0008412933,
-0.0579095408,
0.0508542657,
0.0248617195,
-0.0079858499,
-0.0666362271,
-0.0169861242,
0.0117605012,
-0.0116162933,
-0.0049225697,
0.0332467556,
-0.0034350858,
-0.0637781769,
0.0186162032,
-0.0217958391,
-0.0232499447,
0.007334949,
-0.0154084982,
-0.0951873288,
0.012659424,
0.0399644934,
-0.0101704095,
0.053907562,
0.0655906051,
0.0800453424,
-0.0125582665,
0.0003998002,
-0.0139145069,
0.0025046889,
-0.0305420645,
-0.0198968984,
-0.0063021835,
-0.0549840964,
0.008332978,
0.0745122656,
0.0269049965,
0.0230103936,
-0.0547133014,
-0.0129036987,
-0.0401814729,
-0.0232736561,
-0.0266193449,
-0.0637286529,
-0.0233807135,
-0.0259035695,
-0.0202109236,
-0.0528113544,
0.0699230209,
-0.0045906208,
0.0116824331,
-0.0357541032,
-0.0077515352,
0.0159887895,
0.0232362673,
0.0133157717,
0.0675461218,
-0.0098223612,
-0.0261483379,
0.0223973207,
0.0034356348,
0.0191215798,
-0.0455718078,
-0.0041883108,
0.007604904,
0.0009127883,
0.0079836939,
-0.0432931073,
-0.0533624478,
-0.0356655382,
-0.0219046474,
-0.0273525864,
0.0151674235,
-0.0251229629,
-0.0204943977,
0.0315889791,
0.0261941701,
-0.0118922479,
0.0171319675,
0.0119450809,
0.0162942316,
0.0038301456,
-0.0043042055,
-0.0203491971,
-0.000389293,
-0.0030091645,
-0.0216522496,
0.0476203486,
-0.0332488976,
-0.0361066684,
0.0065680831,
-0.0051579252,
0.0239918046,
0.0192378331,
0.0148511361,
-0.0349910706,
0.0285888202,
-0.0021393676,
-0.0169335436,
0.0700755566,
0.0066719097,
-0.009452275,
-0.0142080346,
0.0098580299,
-0.017391501,
0.0017941333,
-0.0052897506,
-0.0623223782,
-0.0290938485,
-0.0079379724,
0.0208580792,
-0.0833394676,
-0.0253292676,
-0.0069523402,
-0.0696527809,
-0.0099079413,
-0.005127477,
-0.0367189161,
-0.0584746376,
0.0189074352,
-0.0184231084,
0.0011070115,
0.0310039222,
-0.0319974832,
0.0304361731,
-0.0443029143,
0.0121173896,
-0.0408912897,
-0.0453915112,
0.0312958173,
-0.0013438009,
0.0128808441,
0.02481368,
0.0397422649,
-0.0656578317,
-0.0171320252,
0.0370653905,
-0.0108283572,
-0.0253675021,
-0.0355139412,
0.0635069832,
-0.0130966101,
-0.0249946285,
-0.0095052831,
0.0199511927,
0.0072398493,
-0.012122808,
-0.0261231307,
0.0595316738,
0.0381778367,
-0.0088976938,
-0.0115421526,
0.0199167468,
0.0061042844,
0.0744925216,
-0.0053288825,
-0.0733795166,
0.0240635891,
-0.0594910868,
-0.0118620396,
-0.0452035218,
-0.06456469,
0.0003642908,
-0.0527201928,
-0.0734948814,
-0.0262368303,
-0.0097881276,
0.017048303,
-0.0080942418,
0.0149806514,
-0.0395443812,
-0.0037685868,
-0.0189475771,
-0.0348237082,
-0.0158146638,
0.0032550415,
0.0644672662,
-0.0491552912,
0.0087003056,
0.001535951,
-0.0209605005,
-0.0310307462,
0.0170590654,
-0.0518402159,
-0.0276306588,
0.0349048749,
0.0661445856,
0.0076707681,
0.0078301327,
-0.0264172815,
-0.0240304712,
0.066074647,
0.0674377978,
-0.0134817604,
-0.0303554926,
0.0588725433,
-0.0239301715,
-0.0134496139,
0.0020123969,
-0.0378677361,
0.0533864908,
0.0522389039,
-0.0388903767,
-0.0546495542,
-0.0498568863,
0.0017599277,
0.0004071745,
0.0302646458,
-0.0132558318,
-0.050473962,
-0.0225362722,
-0.0283497721,
0.0188955702,
-0.01049772,
-0.0195164811,
0.007988696,
0.0379216895,
-0.0021445963,
-0.0376525111,
0.0193545856,
-0.0144477775,
0.0048917304,
-0.0317628644,
0.0297597796,
0.0287224259,
0.0464329422,
0.0343323573,
0.0411913618,
-0.045425076,
0.0174945667,
0.0325549729,
-0.0106043173,
-0.018257048,
0.0595053583,
0.0137271937,
0.0190633778,
0.0259580798,
0.0131270979,
0.0418253317,
0.0211611781,
-0.0748047382,
-0.0365152769,
-0.0183970276,
-0.0050240508,
0.060270261,
-0.0038412362,
0.0009771882,
-0.0191325452,
0.0064000404,
-0.0287466198,
-0.0856758729,
0.0273476243,
-0.02313683,
-0.0212885104,
0.0094209174,
0.0475996956,
-0.0484234728,
0.0220490843,
0.0434503146,
-0.0529969521,
-0.0066555003,
0.0111258123,
0.03759294,
-0.0136490269,
0.0028521023,
0.0131226517,
0.0050544958,
-0.0365139507,
0.0316366665,
-0.0756081268,
0.0336028412,
0.0033218262,
0.0156752225,
0.0569991507,
0.0010303763,
0.0087632248,
0.0071245856,
0.0115315029,
0.000778723,
-0.0623271354,
0.0029759146,
-5.63576881e-33,
-0.0041717994,
-0.0083230799,
-0.0202109236,
0.0201694835,
0.0055272076,
-0.036896266,
0.0269746091,
-0.0070370482,
-0.0285341982,
0.0185516924,
0.0117444936,
-0.0017227547,
0.00423329,
0.0173730887,
-0.0137950126,
-0.0461308062,
0.0461204052,
0.0101327626,
-0.0207275245,
0.0199660826,
0.0777031183,
0.0010276358,
0.0888852477,
-0.062056262,
0.0158513151,
-0.0192270111,
-0.0364000797,
0.0226721801,
0.0377081111,
0.0595601685,
-0.0107922666,
0.0821175054,
0.0455117635,
-0.0313668251,
0.0020809239,
0.0544295274,
-0.0530434325,
0.0164547879,
-0.0185755491,
0.0679176748,
0.0304563008,
-0.0310075805,
0.0375849679,
-0.0063271592,
-0.0402411632,
-0.0388934202,
0.0309932698,
-0.0151279075,
0.0407279693,
-0.0701279715,
-0.0719821453,
0.0273422673,
-0.0227861013,
-0.0361169651,
0.0036811267,
0.1016606838,
0.0172658339,
0.034598656,
-0.1027498394,
0.0045214342,
-0.0077873426,
-0.0436818153,
0.0159372501,
0.0135819716,
-0.0258488636,
0.036284402,
-0.0270927288,
-0.0078743454,
-0.029109098,
0.0262779295,
0.0309797432,
0.0285433289,
0.0448332913,
0.0538958721,
0.0351510085,
-0.0959162116,
-0.0499025583,
0.0302517749,
0.0375802666,
0.0063802162,
0.0377029218,
-0.0266423561,
-0.0430958308,
-0.0380136333,
0.0180144049,
-0.0525546074,
-0.0170434695,
-0.0444494076,
0.0405758433,
-0.0201274864,
-0.0052679698,
0.0004330645,
0.0592681505,
-0.0385179855,
0.0217003636,
0.0407864824,
-0.0427337401,
0.0278760884,
0.0112499045,
0.0687548295,
-0.0495417304,
-0.0106262499,
0.03171812,
-0.0381787382,
0.0229291301,
0.0014848385,
0.0970099568,
0.035841614,
-0.0681754798,
0.0270080622,
0.0096788993,
0.0480761454,
0.000542529,
0.0817958638,
-0.0087598562,
0.057092499,
-0.0145806577,
-0.0024778745,
0.0370941311,
-0.008490623,
-0.0122451009,
-0.005350247,
-0.0192989353,
-0.0061578224,
-0.0071395324,
0.0060401866,
-0.0181373525,
0.0134616606,
0.0062424862,
-0.0821207613,
0.0166334808,
-0.0176421907,
2.633e-7,
0.0093602045,
0.0281838961,
0.0098113948,
-0.0178440362,
0.0057349433,
0.0469666384,
0.032008186,
0.0517836176,
0.01890173,
0.0250102095,
-0.0450530648,
0.01768158,
0.0397755392,
0.0693389177,
-0.0209097732,
-0.0020049345,
-0.0967321768,
0.0329028703,
-0.0484161749,
0.0083668036,
0.0057783327,
0.0829486921,
0.0486715436,
-0.0500023253,
-0.0332560912,
-0.0166293588,
0.0319721326,
-0.0407438315,
0.0049444386,
-0.0194922294,
0.0365268737,
-0.0011821528,
0.0205781739,
0.008466932,
-0.0145844873,
0.0160161629,
0.0155648291,
0.049832657,
0.0198751204,
0.0285312776,
0.0049128579,
-0.020813439,
-0.0217250958,
-0.0379389301,
0.0559131913,
-0.0169284306,
-0.0081994776,
0.0150945075,
-0.0041322201,
0.0044911555,
0.0350243039,
-0.0560074933,
-0.0143813826,
0.0031191627,
0.0729326233,
0.0026381239,
-0.0109608267,
-0.0620537139,
0.0027237581,
0.0076845014,
-0.022528924,
-0.0051241578,
-0.0097456947,
-0.0124908481,
0.0489223637,
0.0279123206,
0.0634480193,
1.998557128e-34,
0.0170346294,
-0.0334523357,
-0.0050041182,
-0.0318845175,
0.0304706786,
0.0209701248,
0.0157638062,
0.007788619,
0.011453893,
-0.032686796,
0.0012548376
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03367v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03367v1 | Lazy-k: Decoding for Constrained Token Classification | 2023-12-06T09:08:32 | 2023-12-06T09:08:32 | Arthur Hemmer, Mickaël Coustaty, Nicola Bartolo, Jérôme Brachat, Jean-Marc Ogier | cs.CL | cs.CL | We explore the possibility of improving probabilistic models in structured
prediction. Specifically, we combine the models with constrained decoding
approaches in the context of token classification for information extraction.
The decoding methods search for constraint-satisfying label-assignments while
maximizing the total probability. To do this, we evaluate several existing
approaches, as well as propose a novel decoding method called Lazy-$k$. Our
findings demonstrate that constrained decoding approaches can significantly
improve the models' performances, especially when using smaller models. The
Lazy-$k$ approach allows for more flexibility between decoding time and
accuracy. The code for using Lazy-$k$ decoding can be found here:
https://github.com/ArthurDevNL/lazyk. | [
0.0548332147,
0.0917828754,
0.02342101,
0.0188111048,
-0.0175136104,
0.0258325785,
-0.0099899219,
0.0405592397,
-0.0138987228,
-0.0687122941,
0.010012514,
0.0114545124,
-0.0061396789,
0.0432280339,
0.0034637516,
-0.0440491252,
0.0533978455,
-0.0475603081,
0.0578927957,
0.0171072669,
-0.014258801,
-0.0099307764,
-0.025958268,
0.0433206148,
-0.0648942888,
0.0042759636,
0.0239529125,
0.0037750807,
-0.0295901317,
-0.0215207879,
0.0266642272,
0.0673322752,
-0.0422306433,
-0.0076601575,
0.0000018274,
-0.0221280288,
-0.0465994552,
-0.0104894461,
-0.0145964064,
0.0033203431,
0.0121991001,
-0.0771676898,
-0.0035846897,
-0.0157890599,
0.0072990428,
-0.0786595494,
0.0647833496,
0.0454722233,
-0.0082962317,
0.063540481,
-0.0071071014,
-0.0377594158,
0.0323560797,
0.0233959872,
-0.0027188826,
-0.0392871983,
0.0584359765,
-0.0453214571,
-0.0356375203,
0.0086345877,
-0.0079383366,
-0.012880045,
-0.015205266,
0.0183564797,
0.0373742022,
0.0434002168,
-0.0985294655,
-0.0212863255,
-0.0236207806,
-0.0061441124,
-0.0029169996,
-0.0589850135,
0.0174577329,
-0.0269872993,
0.0000741148,
-0.03426148,
0.0022973695,
0.0079987478,
-0.0542961769,
0.0316319503,
0.0284588356,
0.0473946929,
0.0320723467,
0.005166275,
-0.034345679,
0.0849723592,
0.0005841024,
-0.0149795935,
-0.0010223701,
0.0087787453,
-0.0180423707,
-0.0419108793,
0.018281579,
-0.0007855254,
-0.0087082461,
0.0011085351,
-0.0517649427,
-0.0533278361,
-0.0118471943,
0.0027186063,
-0.0588830262,
0.0432560593,
-0.0013357572,
0.0496064685,
-0.0641879365,
0.071153827,
0.0109474454,
0.0478140078,
-0.0153265744,
-0.0001493721,
-0.0578949116,
-0.0409164876,
-0.0432620682,
0.0769419223,
-0.0097489944,
-0.0312548801,
-0.0298948735,
0.0258202907,
0.0065523004,
0.0144423693,
0.0081956852,
-0.012881889,
-0.0150948763,
0.0338348635,
-0.0038052623,
-0.0103862537,
-0.0388297811,
-0.0167924576,
-0.0228430722,
0.0008488484,
-0.0106206238,
0.0313444585,
0.0071459836,
-0.0143694757,
-0.0076614828,
0.0798562467,
-0.0136696668,
-0.0248575676,
-0.0103807067,
-0.0207046587,
-0.02016389,
0.0090464782,
-0.0110947229,
-0.0496805161,
0.0094481949,
0.0322627611,
0.0126034487,
-0.0370998308,
0.005717814,
-0.0226581693,
-0.0424133353,
0.0836304948,
-0.0091812816,
-0.0243356433,
0.0107935648,
-0.012440091,
-0.0285281073,
0.0767067075,
-0.0250751488,
0.0577539653,
0.0309296045,
-0.0206991583,
0.0186701808,
0.0436932817,
-0.0008683025,
-0.0635970682,
0.0075760973,
0.0139493989,
0.0507643335,
-0.0386836641,
0.0154010588,
0.0614528954,
-0.0211944785,
0.0136540309,
-0.0099393744,
0.0442869179,
-0.0055268179,
0.0052310368,
0.0034877653,
-0.0280314051,
0.0137260705,
0.01232283,
-0.0467672385,
-0.058476653,
0.0157712996,
0.0330970995,
0.0275142603,
-0.0260715391,
0.0051809205,
-0.0486741923,
-0.0258793011,
-0.0498235971,
-0.0073335324,
-0.0390712805,
0.0862324387,
0.0023702339,
-0.0592435785,
0.0902074128,
0.0275775604,
-0.0044661253,
-0.0069320388,
-0.0144190295,
0.0059277811,
0.0240910798,
0.049165234,
-0.0744021758,
-0.0054878122,
0.0110666258,
0.0040617841,
0.0003246535,
-0.0023244657,
-0.0360669829,
0.0236113407,
-0.0055909688,
-0.0154448152,
0.0515499748,
0.0476882122,
0.030703539,
0.0405204296,
0.0158051271,
0.0072805183,
-0.0452748686,
-0.0029123432,
0.0513789579,
0.0686640516,
-0.0458193272,
0.0476744026,
0.0389419273,
0.0314495601,
0.0262688771,
0.0013215184,
0.0371890962,
0.0461255424,
-0.0737612024,
0.0120433373,
-0.0202643443,
-0.0381703787,
-0.0476531722,
0.0212756861,
0.0012131083,
-0.0045219832,
-0.0053408793,
-0.0263295136,
-0.0103703728,
0.0162913892,
-0.0079366416,
0.0696258619,
-0.0232242644,
0.0010178778,
0.0132679613,
-0.0225702785,
-0.0262960531,
0.0781161934,
0.0038078153,
0.008707827,
0.0089178588,
-0.0509091392,
0.0025986547,
-0.005794697,
0.009017488,
0.0119282072,
-0.0549607463,
-0.0262326691,
0.0125970673,
0.0228756946,
-0.0251589566,
-0.0299233999,
-0.0464527309,
-0.0333481468,
-0.0202078801,
0.0513508581,
-0.0266812742,
0.0100545436,
-0.0019923395,
-0.0265331212,
-0.0183758903,
-0.0667631552,
-0.0339733995,
0.008439905,
0.0207639113,
0.0493188016,
-0.059282992,
0.0075153033,
0.0018397998,
-0.0180169791,
0.0264271628,
-0.0073053604,
-0.0644607246,
-0.0432286412,
0.0021652009,
0.0206205361,
0.007822874,
0.0179084092,
-0.0056374068,
-0.00162609,
-0.0340682045,
0.0059086541,
0.0169821288,
-0.0035959899,
0.0410096794,
-0.0274473019,
0.0029706999,
-0.0350597166,
0.0059267557,
-0.01860453,
0.0038740265,
-0.0348883197,
-0.0188667383,
0.0553408563,
0.0540172458,
0.013838823,
0.0393642373,
-0.1021247581,
-0.0077905501,
-0.0099327341,
-0.044330921,
-0.0384235494,
0.0052304761,
-0.0209680721,
0.0299764629,
-0.010462096,
-0.031152945,
0.0825374052,
-0.0324168839,
0.0223897323,
-0.0135025633,
-0.0001846358,
-0.0441037007,
0.0418513902,
0.0222150851,
0.0164034925,
0.0438040942,
-0.0935517251,
0.0297273919,
0.0225262046,
-0.0016859561,
-0.0193327274,
-0.0142294765,
0.0161845963,
0.0298891738,
-0.0085687954,
-0.0344987661,
-0.0321285166,
-0.0430954583,
-0.0420138054,
-0.0058234171,
0.0622302257,
0.0020867744,
-0.0126850568,
0.0681143478,
-0.0557459593,
0.0340679623,
-0.0178409163,
0.0256447773,
-0.0454760902,
0.0130763268,
0.029223714,
-0.0378225856,
-0.0476312004,
-0.007469119,
-0.0357685275,
0.0584150553,
0.0402488261,
0.022330733,
0.0229104813,
0.0088959932,
0.0574259274,
-0.0268932804,
0.009780352,
0.0016455298,
0.0170179456,
-0.0133261271,
-0.0302214343,
0.1231480464,
0.0477004573,
-0.0494079962,
-0.0026658457,
-0.0196745731,
0.0575580299,
-0.0069069336,
-0.0020347557,
-0.0675882846,
-0.0694112629,
0.0261377227,
0.0622666143,
-0.0048348783,
-0.0345815606,
0.0336203389,
-0.0870392025,
-0.0085927164,
0.0343062915,
-0.0662807524,
-0.0715831369,
-0.0375953503,
-0.0167640522,
-0.0235361774,
-0.0249879584,
0.0023124763,
0.0188891143,
0.0028203323,
0.0501764305,
-0.0582188256,
-0.0189463031,
-0.0063005621,
-0.032135278,
0.0209724717,
0.0395649895,
-0.0271143448,
-0.0106330048,
-0.0190308467,
0.0409612581,
0.0085297553,
-0.0337424874,
-0.0384306945,
-0.0095440643,
-0.0293038357,
-0.0012735556,
0.0244238507,
0.007080792,
-0.0511237904,
-0.0443439633,
0.0034438719,
0.0807753503,
0.0251561292,
0.0038514079,
-0.0239200685,
-0.0487002581,
0.0188593548,
0.0777080134,
0.0179522876,
-0.0156065496,
-0.0242470261,
-0.0617788471,
0.0450521,
-0.0703062937,
0.0479117744,
-0.005669646,
-0.0419565663,
-0.0512727797,
-0.083283402,
0.0063092038,
0.0657551214,
0.0274457,
-0.027466666,
0.0260047019,
0.0047370279,
-0.0110988654,
-0.0573526248,
-0.0086979978,
-0.0135610495,
-0.0059352969,
-0.1019040346,
-0.023294514,
-0.0196315497,
-0.0038051305,
-0.0411857776,
0.0126732206,
-0.0487302318,
-0.049377691,
0.0015818293,
0.0445114672,
0.0164658409,
0.0297840796,
-0.0213127136,
-0.0143903131,
0.0253494047,
0.0698020011,
-0.0504657999,
-0.0191476438,
0.0213480406,
-0.0187777448,
-0.013096882,
0.0085325306,
-0.0807026625,
-0.0224409662,
-0.0150336018,
0.0219457932,
-0.0355347879,
0.0121030221,
0.0392830409,
0.0227829311,
0.0566716343,
-0.0232623089,
-0.0503057316,
0.0197519995,
0.0308713261,
-0.0015654893,
-0.0274484269,
0.0082864678,
0.0270644687,
0.0154510168,
-0.0072669373,
0.0023146749,
-0.0158188734,
0.0216223039,
0.0625899658,
0.0334322341,
-0.0310431067,
0.0331395231,
0.0278857164,
0.0448472351,
-0.061294172,
-0.0285341684,
0.0072213328,
0.0257817525,
0.0184423067,
-0.046701774,
-0.0320135653,
0.0393202454,
0.0250246637,
-0.0339968428,
-0.0079024304,
-0.0068132556,
0.0338497274,
-0.0301394146,
-0.0063563483,
-0.0018437037,
-0.0116346758,
-0.0003905037,
-0.0232499111,
-0.0310103204,
-0.0337053686,
0.0183652993,
0.0279289391,
0.0113658924,
0.0377423503,
0.0331404954,
-0.0125714606,
-0.034805093,
0.0668693483,
0.0623632111,
0.023376381,
-0.0125479707,
-0.0421341993,
-0.0448440202,
0.0404141285,
-0.0149952183,
0.0559537038,
-0.0204532165,
0.0044006063,
-0.0238189138,
-0.0155730927,
0.0340051502,
-0.0015341111,
0.0095177842,
0.0108079128,
-0.0112297982,
0.0470005721,
0.0379079878,
-0.0494742095,
-0.0399028063,
0.0182391461,
0.0552489497,
-0.0265516378,
-0.0107173454,
-5.96849322e-33,
-0.0313040838,
-0.028111279,
-0.0366294943,
0.0272449758,
0.0055253543,
-0.0016918301,
-0.0071260422,
-0.0232414249,
0.0625075176,
-0.0051214392,
0.0052340254,
-0.0426015109,
0.037933778,
0.0374709442,
0.0098393951,
-0.0253701918,
-0.0150275053,
0.0104758628,
-0.0418833494,
-0.0049166461,
0.050885126,
0.0428429917,
0.0208618473,
-0.0409768298,
0.0381695069,
-0.0078635225,
0.0203703605,
0.0058480445,
0.0606876351,
0.0681285709,
-0.0076745553,
0.0145947747,
0.0435254425,
-0.0075126183,
0.0066671795,
0.0428673327,
-0.1558955759,
0.0030433049,
0.0291718319,
0.0576497614,
0.0111713391,
-0.0692638904,
0.0156890824,
0.0011456092,
-0.0000368579,
-0.0113021778,
0.0056351726,
-0.0490794294,
-0.0273329038,
-0.0774191394,
-0.0444313996,
0.0539647676,
0.0015776997,
0.0531334579,
0.0554693975,
0.0143801803,
0.0128079504,
0.0276558064,
-0.0054941941,
0.006066435,
-0.0192052443,
0.0737964362,
0.034620706,
0.0620182231,
-0.0173706152,
0.0389518179,
0.0074458551,
-0.0591542386,
-0.0483224355,
0.0231460128,
-0.0174108371,
0.0081031108,
-0.0041694706,
0.0060706576,
0.0595420524,
-0.0467163026,
-0.0527938567,
-0.0006025738,
0.0003358252,
0.0106482375,
0.0197216999,
0.0468912162,
-0.078344427,
-0.0261090565,
0.0048306277,
-0.0314036421,
-0.029719092,
-0.0094636846,
0.0380888097,
0.0175935533,
-0.0628225878,
0.0147815216,
0.0281888638,
-0.0176856685,
-0.0316829644,
0.0024015899,
0.0471993238,
0.0163040459,
-0.0595318824,
0.0109402854,
-0.0225551911,
-0.041958373,
0.0436415002,
-0.0346274041,
0.0363934934,
0.0146896448,
0.0364063568,
-0.0185979288,
-0.0592154115,
-0.0066455039,
0.0007201881,
0.0186516307,
-0.0051986775,
0.0463286974,
0.0648123845,
0.018348733,
0.0154123921,
-0.0085853543,
0.034930747,
0.0037517177,
-0.0147821391,
0.0360856503,
0.0043606535,
0.0365116373,
-0.004604206,
-0.014633446,
-0.0163564477,
-0.0040993039,
0.0118074249,
-0.0085419295,
0.0003536392,
0.0423597917,
2.459e-7,
0.064017348,
0.0564307421,
0.0584670827,
-0.0032853561,
0.001303449,
0.0358870476,
0.0156998839,
0.0078370869,
-0.0119735952,
-0.0295175593,
-0.0173733775,
-0.0437143967,
0.0050016362,
0.0106188422,
-0.1002660394,
0.0329674743,
-0.013093411,
0.0030075475,
-0.0364243388,
0.0293118861,
0.0665256381,
0.1036078259,
-0.0030837848,
-0.0004203923,
-0.01326364,
-0.0635249689,
-0.0211789683,
0.0029328633,
0.014114093,
0.0205082837,
-0.0030977821,
-0.0096589141,
0.0331413262,
0.0495892055,
0.0038007293,
0.0054236548,
0.064462699,
0.0656273514,
-0.0066583804,
-0.0092215287,
-0.0173810404,
-0.0083127208,
0.0111023067,
-0.0091704531,
0.0865063518,
0.0042879777,
0.0320782252,
0.018112611,
-0.0370620973,
0.0164279081,
-0.0544125177,
0.0166190714,
-0.0310352314,
0.048686523,
0.0474446677,
0.0262765456,
-0.01222625,
-0.0534000769,
-0.0143008605,
-0.0602389984,
-0.0442038476,
-0.0134703619,
-0.0145510193,
0.0388388522,
0.0076837828,
-0.0666764751,
-0.0250907391,
2.709916489e-34,
0.0245215464,
0.0014880793,
-0.0296637099,
0.0851417631,
0.0217005536,
-0.036914587,
-0.026610285,
0.0449979529,
0.0068058204,
-0.0560404435,
0.0118040629
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03361v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03361v1 | KhabarChin: Automatic Detection of Important News in the Persian Language | 2023-12-06T09:01:21 | 2023-12-06T09:01:21 | Hamed Hematian Hemati, Arash Lagzian, Moein Salimi Sartakhti, Hamid Beigy, Ehsaneddin Asgari | cs.CL | cs.CL | Being aware of important news is crucial for staying informed and making
well-informed decisions efficiently. Natural Language Processing (NLP)
approaches can significantly automate this process. This paper introduces the
detection of important news, in a previously unexplored area, and presents a
new benchmarking dataset (Khabarchin) for detecting important news in the
Persian language. We define important news articles as those deemed significant
for a considerable portion of society, capable of influencing their mindset or
decision-making. The news articles are obtained from seven different prominent
Persian news agencies, resulting in the annotation of 7,869 samples and the
creation of the dataset. Two challenges of high disagreement and imbalance
between classes were faced, and solutions were provided for them. We also
propose several learning-based models, ranging from conventional machine
learning to state-of-the-art transformer models, to tackle this task.
Furthermore, we introduce the second task of important sentence detection in
news articles, as they often come with a significant contextual length that
makes it challenging for readers to identify important information. We identify
these sentences in a weakly supervised manner. | [
0.0492263883,
0.0414341278,
0.0034044553,
0.0057037901,
-0.0472769625,
0.0323332325,
-0.0245835725,
-0.010361651,
0.030023478,
-0.0459589809,
0.0013923018,
-0.0052082818,
-0.0163386464,
0.0172382221,
-0.0158260278,
-0.0275828354,
0.0571156219,
0.0048030512,
0.0551069677,
0.0423166752,
0.0496493876,
0.0261157863,
-0.0074072336,
0.0264766049,
-0.0262528714,
-0.0059012994,
0.0164037943,
-0.0189793445,
0.0574093834,
-0.0398390219,
0.0311918426,
0.0469015278,
0.0209771954,
0.0185167193,
0.0000019295,
-0.0318696983,
-0.0273981988,
-0.0567611828,
0.0038900189,
-0.0411016829,
0.0383025259,
-0.0924176574,
-0.0380593352,
0.0060120835,
-0.0334989056,
-0.0241246875,
0.0397512503,
0.077618733,
0.0672256872,
0.1043520421,
-0.022014061,
-0.0361265503,
-0.0117647676,
-0.0014787088,
-0.0115735969,
-0.0593401194,
0.054015886,
-0.0432006828,
-0.0993014276,
0.0124487383,
-0.0043330262,
0.0152240787,
-0.0223139301,
-0.0407295115,
-0.0218567345,
-0.0192354526,
-0.0915838629,
-0.0271170344,
-0.0014240813,
0.0463781543,
-0.0163240954,
-0.0377519168,
0.0291235745,
-0.0013250357,
0.0078078932,
0.0221727937,
-0.0367378965,
0.0325410478,
-0.0204392932,
0.0331366956,
0.0534091778,
0.0303628538,
-0.014746055,
0.0398592316,
-0.0055854251,
0.0272030849,
0.0038069945,
-0.0196809098,
0.0243862439,
0.0185023695,
-0.0614414886,
-0.0190677438,
0.0589584559,
0.0023793501,
-0.0199527033,
-0.0037409959,
0.00102483,
-0.0186118297,
0.031515196,
-0.1444416642,
-0.0561605915,
0.033904206,
0.0140783032,
0.0621721633,
-0.0226632953,
-0.0368372798,
0.0352707766,
-0.0129231596,
-0.0079563083,
-0.0014635796,
-0.0055747498,
0.0236883741,
-0.0239258148,
0.04336771,
-0.0372417197,
-0.0017613438,
-0.0691280365,
-0.0085904952,
0.0183940921,
0.0378266983,
-0.0184307117,
0.0018692868,
-0.0437974259,
0.0171909761,
0.0040410608,
0.0479362607,
-0.0185412932,
0.0184882004,
-0.0280767232,
-0.027513165,
0.0118836937,
0.0267755724,
0.019124249,
0.014529027,
-0.0165082123,
0.0257529579,
-0.0122105796,
-0.0523794889,
-0.0538833812,
0.0152211711,
-0.016927151,
-0.0105858063,
-0.0009460492,
-0.0449074507,
-0.007477113,
0.0012903342,
0.0113325566,
-0.0167228542,
0.0236487444,
0.0395494029,
0.0218522754,
0.0461785309,
0.0693177581,
-0.0088062827,
0.0438885726,
0.0168670416,
0.058818046,
0.0833163485,
0.0228893757,
0.06833487,
0.0585901141,
0.0000418021,
0.008918643,
-0.0010885907,
-0.0264524985,
0.0027664711,
0.0212427434,
-0.0203530528,
-0.0421215408,
0.0271364097,
-0.0200141929,
-0.0008487082,
0.0014026129,
0.0094826259,
0.0630618781,
-0.0106302276,
-0.0169382188,
0.0226588491,
-0.0244769715,
0.0463551804,
-0.0177686214,
0.0249669552,
0.0044796038,
0.0212757103,
0.0142681766,
0.0062963092,
-0.0471552871,
0.0469373092,
-0.0388805345,
-0.0304823685,
0.0042498172,
-0.0267318822,
0.0075214156,
-0.0150574073,
0.0736188665,
0.0158720557,
-0.0488431938,
0.0470400602,
0.03787034,
-0.0190839563,
-0.0041143112,
-0.0303284544,
0.0085465545,
0.0194330271,
0.0040848982,
-0.0563075058,
0.0283800717,
-0.0363445096,
0.0448464751,
0.0399367213,
0.0323290676,
-0.0263249949,
-0.012256749,
-0.0475872792,
-0.0136474483,
0.0187229905,
0.0340328552,
-0.0090213502,
0.0156210167,
0.0430112779,
0.0137224356,
0.0224292278,
-0.050411731,
0.0415484235,
0.0148490807,
-0.0212604813,
-0.0134241609,
0.0256236829,
-0.0197745692,
0.0173941553,
-0.0002906326,
-0.019148577,
0.0435244143,
-0.0313155651,
-0.0167100634,
-0.0071289544,
-0.0249760877,
-0.0223301966,
-0.0007181197,
-0.1103111282,
-0.029071847,
0.0765457228,
-0.0606104694,
-0.0274609402,
0.0320251733,
-0.0241763834,
-0.0314308219,
-0.0156819504,
0.0221595708,
-0.0157030784,
0.027749842,
-0.0488170572,
0.0792458877,
-0.0189947784,
-0.0199917629,
-0.0210441146,
-0.0667672008,
0.0032364859,
0.0186473168,
-0.0200392101,
0.014817372,
-0.000883551,
-0.0164172649,
0.0812330991,
-0.0225734934,
-0.0184996594,
-0.033234138,
-0.0293751694,
0.0022338659,
-0.0414728187,
0.0278010946,
0.0258029439,
0.0182661097,
0.0026213322,
0.0074639954,
-0.018574303,
-0.0273755807,
-0.00000682,
0.0064209322,
0.0510342158,
-0.0267393552,
0.0179042649,
-0.0398890153,
-0.0218894482,
-0.0366665497,
0.0541756935,
0.06342002,
-0.078338556,
-0.0086365808,
0.0036429565,
0.0315892734,
0.0058818962,
-0.0136053516,
-0.0248902142,
-0.0163763706,
0.0138024334,
0.0099252248,
0.0738643631,
0.0360572971,
0.0433068089,
0.0166074801,
0.0323620476,
0.0117224194,
0.0002941242,
-0.0706515908,
0.0107989572,
-0.0441275053,
-0.0440762565,
0.0462083369,
0.0229739752,
-0.0058233095,
-0.0212707408,
-0.0179764535,
0.003460377,
-0.0249986611,
0.0084688757,
0.007417215,
-0.0028052358,
0.0100383526,
0.0583654605,
-0.0126721859,
-0.0157349594,
0.0238685273,
0.027575871,
0.0659053773,
-0.0413074084,
-0.0211723037,
-0.090194732,
0.023669498,
-0.0151425293,
0.0124373762,
-0.0332823098,
-0.0605172515,
-0.0268458389,
-0.0570597947,
0.0041771946,
-0.0110115297,
0.0494290963,
0.0007252232,
0.0039632446,
-0.0218769833,
-0.0160170905,
-0.0286808945,
-0.0391537026,
-0.0186045282,
-0.0296342857,
0.0789210126,
-0.0198022369,
-0.0315720327,
-0.0050165616,
0.0086748051,
0.0451679975,
-0.0011895237,
0.0017408944,
0.0015070923,
0.0192155894,
0.0513502136,
-0.0113433888,
0.0472929999,
0.006758919,
0.0399087444,
0.0653642863,
-0.0086537628,
0.0082740802,
-0.0316277333,
-0.0264754444,
0.0305280369,
-0.0749688148,
0.01463567,
-0.056754481,
-0.0047473134,
-0.0595812201,
-0.0038896413,
0.113696143,
0.0213128384,
-0.02844375,
0.0127649326,
0.0181363393,
-0.056360174,
0.0393465459,
-0.0090085333,
-0.0913160294,
-0.0071000303,
0.0159137156,
-0.0218658708,
-0.0262512118,
-0.0234727096,
0.0135357473,
-0.0347859636,
-0.016710626,
-0.0174349099,
-0.0086007677,
-0.0458182096,
-0.0493951812,
0.002453102,
-0.0387000144,
-0.048391588,
-0.0429040305,
-0.0135457534,
0.0046484158,
0.0295936856,
-0.0710530579,
-0.0768036768,
0.0042900322,
0.0018148685,
-0.0481161959,
0.0420170575,
0.0743581951,
-0.0348753035,
-0.0148309786,
0.0253009908,
-0.0232723579,
-0.0275826547,
0.0062708789,
0.0652234405,
-0.0367768779,
-0.0299572181,
-0.0450504571,
0.0162113141,
-0.039492216,
0.014309804,
0.0136052864,
0.0240154006,
-0.0112750949,
-0.0069627729,
0.00949426,
0.0342191905,
0.0329944491,
0.0445605256,
-0.0255032778,
-0.0220974851,
0.0019869073,
0.0066629546,
0.0069757705,
-0.0574052818,
-0.0323217958,
0.0070785186,
0.0186928697,
-0.0599897318,
-0.0788891837,
-0.0129462304,
0.0441914052,
0.0110219745,
0.0181877613,
0.0220520645,
0.0332454257,
0.0228604544,
-0.0265781451,
-0.008697778,
0.0147022083,
-0.0266890042,
-0.0280845128,
-0.0096210642,
0.0297257081,
-0.020779686,
-0.0114570465,
0.053183239,
-0.0756513774,
-0.0189891979,
0.0385554954,
-0.0255966354,
0.019451296,
-0.0144969337,
0.0024883456,
-0.0222070776,
0.0267931428,
0.0505171195,
-0.0052522449,
-0.0091715707,
0.0247420445,
-0.0102698589,
-0.0124970498,
0.031138761,
-0.0036236695,
0.0239117462,
0.0192778446,
-0.0333704352,
-0.0437348485,
-0.023547072,
0.0152089233,
-0.0197686367,
0.030319564,
-0.0054896325,
-0.0023864668,
-0.0558294691,
-0.0027727881,
0.006464032,
0.0045602703,
-0.0070203831,
0.0061180666,
0.0486360416,
0.0239896961,
-0.0538841411,
0.0595286302,
-0.0069099516,
-0.0093321921,
-0.0659906343,
0.0488488078,
0.0184499696,
0.012687264,
-0.0420127362,
-0.0029827955,
-0.0233907346,
-0.0187084395,
-0.010729488,
0.0058244197,
0.0200157482,
-0.0031441844,
0.00948196,
0.0042290548,
0.0367330872,
0.0076950765,
-0.0564716794,
0.0013077047,
-0.0389430225,
0.0492729694,
0.0597725213,
-0.0753054395,
0.0334091932,
-0.0253361166,
-0.0131916925,
0.0026499236,
0.0579529628,
0.0123791285,
-0.0258544274,
-0.0319433659,
-0.004006552,
-0.0290217511,
0.0279907677,
0.0415735058,
-0.0205335785,
0.0134448623,
0.0603828914,
-0.0743824542,
-0.0337680466,
-0.0303283483,
0.0078664916,
0.0110589471,
-0.0265220068,
-0.004388798,
-0.0319713205,
-0.0129519403,
0.0235570129,
-0.0179379284,
0.0099795125,
-0.0098632034,
0.0164687708,
0.0378011689,
0.0256603882,
-0.0148150716,
-0.0795660987,
-0.0121411132,
-0.0402551964,
0.0033391458,
-0.0053933985,
-6.16721054e-33,
0.0016936809,
0.0156108448,
-0.0225486364,
0.033741001,
0.0142820152,
0.0238551032,
-0.0254659243,
-0.0267437305,
-0.0365554281,
0.0333260968,
-0.0014432783,
0.0447994806,
0.0186884273,
0.0170237534,
0.0208036341,
-0.0311892368,
0.0800205842,
0.0082347998,
-0.0127880247,
0.0379665606,
0.0660695136,
0.0383572169,
0.1286617219,
-0.0796438381,
0.003128025,
0.010664342,
-0.0278182942,
0.0116754863,
0.0239841621,
0.034766268,
0.0025538492,
0.0351484939,
0.0274714548,
-0.1000529751,
0.0027202016,
0.0483728163,
-0.0786809698,
-0.0092356196,
0.0036565708,
0.0524218604,
0.0153752966,
0.0009245498,
0.0214160923,
-0.0097200405,
-0.001105071,
0.0144625008,
0.0520519167,
-0.0435150452,
-0.0005239989,
-0.0748581961,
-0.0693689883,
0.0342153534,
-0.0370198525,
0.0172317978,
-0.004112707,
0.06487564,
0.0093531543,
0.0550490469,
-0.0533712991,
-0.0077202097,
0.0195474979,
0.0525492132,
0.0330906995,
-0.0200413372,
-0.0333510041,
0.0609199479,
-0.0074810213,
0.0078159375,
0.0281933509,
0.0088250544,
-0.0144639071,
0.0060866121,
0.0066276975,
0.0651937649,
0.0288499668,
-0.064421773,
-0.1279818863,
0.0359080285,
0.0426454358,
0.068069987,
0.0566509292,
-0.0186598003,
-0.06134592,
0.010175202,
0.0271559414,
0.0024685117,
-0.0143710133,
0.0148801161,
-0.0223405361,
0.0300301537,
-0.0454189032,
0.0850733668,
-0.005438393,
-0.0519111417,
0.0058405842,
0.0187119264,
-0.0409549549,
0.0127113201,
-0.0200617462,
-0.0039482438,
-0.0595816746,
-0.0380068645,
0.0168675985,
0.0303866435,
0.0381524339,
-0.0154208355,
0.0687520802,
0.0415597819,
-0.083279632,
0.0224230587,
-0.0084466776,
0.0289922152,
0.0079394924,
0.0673890486,
0.0003410917,
-0.0056900475,
-0.0441972725,
0.0191769227,
0.0251678992,
0.0166440215,
0.0354889482,
-0.029204065,
-0.0367976762,
0.0108835371,
-0.0249696858,
-0.0157514513,
-0.0164817795,
0.0330460258,
0.0241022501,
-0.0796481073,
-0.0098646507,
-0.0264385808,
2.733e-7,
0.0539300367,
0.0225511659,
0.0144232688,
-0.0013350619,
-0.0056732958,
0.0220982768,
0.0142486626,
0.0785047933,
-0.0271149054,
0.0012647983,
0.0308415983,
0.0006498612,
0.0150997052,
-0.0002443418,
-0.1234369501,
-0.0062630768,
-0.0705805793,
-0.005864602,
-0.0571282394,
0.0102137662,
0.0516459234,
0.1125227436,
-0.0070463587,
-0.0161882639,
-0.015846651,
-0.0224575903,
0.0236760974,
-0.0288081523,
-0.0266385861,
0.0386844724,
0.0642825216,
0.0228754468,
-0.0263445899,
0.0137741314,
-0.0448407829,
-0.0012748172,
0.040039029,
0.056982182,
0.0325475521,
0.0246527232,
0.0222400054,
0.0276603028,
0.0094522843,
0.0004438181,
0.07661286,
-0.0675290599,
-0.0467822216,
-0.0662781149,
-0.0193943195,
-0.0111709461,
0.0274301022,
0.0124786086,
0.0151496148,
0.0203924235,
0.0035755166,
-0.0168634225,
0.0073316246,
-0.0640248582,
0.0021571706,
-0.0072633955,
0.0119610699,
-0.0053627221,
0.0082775373,
-0.010884759,
-0.0281159095,
-0.0118849874,
0.0001385717,
2.311177096e-34,
0.0350279473,
0.0330104977,
-0.0434203334,
0.000636125,
0.0369999148,
-0.0022258081,
-0.0527093187,
-0.0036628919,
-0.0116017777,
-0.0320659243,
0.0036345772
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03360v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03360v2 | Teaching Specific Scientific Knowledge into Large Language Models through Additional Training | 2023-12-06T08:55:55 | 2023-12-18T01:43:56 | Kan Hatakeyama-Sato, Yasuhiko Igarashi, Shun Katakami, Yuta Nabae, Teruaki Hayakawa | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Through additional training, we explore embedding specialized scientific
knowledge into the Llama 2 Large Language Model (LLM). Key findings reveal that
effective knowledge integration requires reading texts from multiple
perspectives, especially in instructional formats. We utilize text augmentation
to tackle the scarcity of specialized texts, including style conversions and
translations. Hyperparameter optimization proves crucial, with different size
models (7b, 13b, and 70b) reasonably undergoing additional training. Validating
our methods, we construct a dataset of 65,000 scientific papers. Although we
have succeeded in partially embedding knowledge, the study highlights the
complexities and limitations of incorporating specialized information into
LLMs, suggesting areas for further improvement. | [
0.044026196,
0.0210670996,
0.0051737851,
0.0089368792,
0.0193143878,
0.0092220437,
0.018123785,
-0.0119348383,
0.0022573122,
-0.0624770857,
-0.0670935065,
0.0213731918,
-0.0236648079,
0.0042734565,
0.0647616759,
-0.0693579018,
0.034676455,
-0.0451241024,
0.0332472548,
-0.040881224,
0.0048670918,
-0.0009631809,
0.0075214342,
-0.0156969037,
0.0604938865,
-0.0360456146,
0.0248045772,
-0.0226899963,
0.0535139814,
-0.0243620109,
-0.0074112741,
0.0201314893,
0.074870117,
0.0592375919,
0.0000018369,
-0.0467643403,
-0.0016893983,
0.0143362228,
-0.0143526364,
0.062850073,
0.0680321157,
-0.0440356694,
0.0123204319,
-0.001795965,
0.0032915594,
0.0020409855,
0.0131809255,
0.0442392714,
0.0334156863,
0.0459260382,
0.022864351,
-0.0463952906,
0.1025736406,
-0.0271027982,
0.0457009822,
0.0062456913,
0.0490334891,
0.0393216759,
0.0485466681,
0.1073815227,
-0.0022579751,
0.0683618113,
0.0103762681,
-0.0324106663,
0.0607749932,
0.0334913433,
-0.0127743743,
0.0295567922,
0.0031724013,
0.0498680063,
0.0222413316,
-0.0363889076,
-0.0050605051,
-0.0005577923,
-0.0086925616,
0.0200447682,
-0.1211377829,
0.0089479312,
0.0327853225,
0.0077622742,
0.0370510668,
0.0004973191,
0.0492674373,
0.0256971847,
0.0107615581,
0.0604664683,
0.0385491662,
-0.028765792,
-0.0062254611,
-0.0090596415,
0.0021648833,
-0.0111163063,
0.0232014395,
0.0523276962,
0.0229942873,
0.0381921381,
-0.0215269085,
-0.0514021702,
0.0527049899,
-0.0442808196,
0.0257896706,
0.0151200434,
-0.0153421797,
0.0418285392,
-0.0276921708,
0.0121275075,
-0.0332352333,
0.0173310526,
-0.0355183259,
0.0052722064,
-0.0357322879,
-0.040684402,
0.0017413306,
-0.00236867,
-0.003440755,
-0.0067813154,
-0.0150547288,
-0.0028187244,
0.0147158951,
-0.0042561367,
0.0048363963,
-0.0256558284,
-0.0663369149,
-0.0194728654,
-0.0107513946,
0.0733779147,
-0.0071544629,
0.0376221612,
-0.0130503224,
-0.0139704514,
-0.0063295364,
0.0156916119,
-0.0231683776,
-0.0242238529,
0.0082831457,
0.0403863974,
-0.0203406103,
-0.0230784286,
-0.0232752115,
-0.010838462,
0.0181899872,
-0.0668486431,
0.0188018829,
-0.0777048916,
0.0367750041,
-0.0174069311,
0.021308016,
-0.0439067855,
0.0184416734,
0.0082040131,
-0.0394308604,
0.0486411564,
-0.0414951518,
-0.0142380921,
0.0866936743,
0.018894488,
0.0195154957,
0.0644088611,
0.0319755562,
-0.0358694494,
0.0036036889,
-0.0231746975,
-0.026772121,
0.0373540595,
0.0309664011,
0.0287260506,
-0.0230396576,
-0.0144515112,
0.021655485,
0.0737415478,
0.0527226739,
0.0203226153,
-0.045156464,
0.0079797888,
0.0266750064,
0.0258327294,
0.0257928874,
0.0036699465,
0.0412106514,
0.0063259713,
0.0555686653,
0.0031866056,
-0.0039539309,
0.0407649353,
-0.0045003514,
0.02820508,
0.0591776446,
0.0482825488,
-0.0311044976,
-0.0393766686,
0.0060294657,
0.0036981704,
-0.0428120643,
-0.0094357878,
0.064810805,
-0.0153628867,
-0.0005222739,
0.0279989429,
0.0506726876,
-0.0255337004,
0.0488155559,
0.0104083978,
0.0260854065,
0.0547693856,
0.0601513758,
-0.0447997488,
-0.0188274104,
-0.0090073291,
0.0293698832,
0.0587214716,
0.067083329,
-0.0248000622,
-0.0332194641,
-0.0646916553,
-0.0142920651,
-0.0337723307,
0.0282620769,
0.0287986938,
0.0067157983,
0.0229705144,
0.0130320396,
-0.036878176,
-0.0589823946,
0.0343217105,
-0.1081576496,
-0.0538558364,
-0.0687142164,
-0.0645950437,
0.0104472525,
0.0064797155,
0.0024346977,
0.0087403702,
0.0300400443,
-0.0695765838,
-0.0123288194,
0.000964244,
-0.0026533413,
-0.0464447215,
0.0571818762,
-0.0637476072,
0.005791537,
-0.0084579317,
-0.0269518513,
-0.0362758115,
-0.0040262365,
-0.0047986815,
0.0416093916,
0.0030178034,
-0.0146631217,
-0.016197823,
0.0161041543,
-0.0365088694,
0.0359272957,
0.0082278764,
0.0260817446,
0.0328540206,
-0.0418659858,
0.0042779339,
-0.0208983868,
-0.0309993438,
-0.0062210881,
0.0412059166,
0.0042568594,
-0.0194512866,
-0.0236953609,
-0.0702592582,
-0.0395720378,
-0.0405101702,
0.0108012706,
0.0183945727,
0.0241938438,
0.0303738602,
-0.0195378847,
-0.0134714385,
0.02826217,
-0.0282987971,
-0.0110460483,
-0.0439129621,
-0.0129680159,
0.0222875066,
0.0001361724,
-0.0099189943,
-0.067616038,
-0.0171279274,
-0.0353505313,
0.0187871419,
0.0401771702,
0.020525327,
-0.0537452698,
0.022675341,
-0.0033475976,
-0.0232106894,
-0.0353828408,
-0.0224199165,
0.0108255567,
-0.0397962742,
0.0124590164,
0.0770139098,
-0.0042230808,
-0.0100847324,
0.0695357695,
0.0115806581,
-0.0748540312,
0.0030575532,
0.0050411327,
-0.0153814498,
-0.0439796895,
-0.0264282282,
-0.0067129619,
0.0476619042,
-0.0532566272,
-0.0515852533,
-0.0047191209,
-0.0239127763,
-0.0261379369,
-0.0152816866,
0.0240078662,
-0.00665172,
-0.0073416927,
0.0108967163,
0.0338721722,
-0.0417115055,
0.0588414297,
-0.064145349,
-0.0077343136,
-0.0585796759,
0.0152920326,
-0.0530841164,
-0.0257295184,
-0.0001154882,
-0.0075573288,
-0.0337653756,
0.0152151296,
-0.0327998474,
0.0378882885,
-0.0098789511,
-0.0129116885,
0.0195389632,
-0.0335139856,
-0.0114555731,
-0.0151780061,
0.033274129,
-0.014514152,
0.0185226314,
-0.0369477011,
0.0222485755,
0.0236636773,
-0.0419099666,
-0.0781498775,
-0.0173373595,
0.0478706509,
0.049255956,
-0.0372661911,
-0.024334643,
-0.0276083071,
0.0030047004,
0.0545097962,
0.0104640052,
0.0048627378,
-0.0616259277,
0.019686088,
0.0200790446,
0.0022570956,
-0.0243321955,
0.0038574995,
-0.0178469252,
0.0383900441,
-0.05632006,
-0.0140408846,
-0.0047201505,
0.035435468,
-0.0465862378,
0.0114561096,
0.1097507998,
0.0225632004,
-0.0642007962,
-0.0208980385,
-0.0598717891,
0.0404535979,
0.0226072464,
0.0687477887,
-0.0622401871,
0.006516926,
-0.0260964371,
0.0084480988,
0.0277727973,
-0.0096828956,
-0.0146784727,
-0.0731721595,
0.0005726455,
0.0596706569,
-0.0144243157,
-0.0108806472,
-0.0319671594,
0.0028085285,
0.0104382662,
-0.0041721598,
0.0045358059,
-0.0496740341,
0.0081771351,
0.0259883758,
0.0073716347,
-0.0806101859,
-0.0029383693,
0.0068008737,
0.0673363507,
-0.0136207836,
0.0275937635,
-0.0351513252,
-0.0426904522,
-0.0147745311,
0.0222631339,
-0.0068359962,
0.0001373718,
0.0350349881,
-0.001519202,
0.027289534,
0.0041265087,
0.077761218,
-0.028819032,
0.0066002258,
0.0215456821,
0.0999501273,
0.0245260373,
-0.0103301303,
-0.064190805,
-0.017747853,
-0.0211670883,
0.0815017,
0.0343081132,
-0.0282445066,
0.0268099476,
-0.0371897183,
0.0027239248,
-0.0013875471,
-0.0418674946,
0.0218887646,
-0.0469142571,
-0.0062717949,
-0.0563229434,
-0.0230893437,
0.0306577776,
0.0294335019,
0.037940193,
0.0458985977,
-0.0037238339,
-0.0483300388,
-0.0146153178,
0.0357760079,
-0.063316308,
0.0045853164,
-0.0455420725,
-0.0341447219,
0.0487064086,
-0.0459376723,
-0.0201529227,
-0.012931399,
-0.045230452,
-0.089442119,
-0.0368253179,
0.0449499451,
0.0259332862,
0.0462243296,
0.0073405923,
-0.0768221244,
0.050432127,
0.0163502004,
-0.0145218428,
0.009493026,
0.0159629062,
-0.0080481153,
0.0083494252,
-0.0014776438,
-0.0350055024,
0.0024898383,
-0.0119181452,
0.0218000542,
-0.0326956846,
-0.0230526011,
0.0168693606,
0.0303275064,
0.002994658,
-0.0333367996,
0.0185126811,
-0.0366432033,
0.0372658819,
-0.030225236,
0.021446785,
-0.0289544892,
-0.0096773617,
0.0431001596,
0.0057611247,
0.0197199993,
0.0145955449,
0.0015187222,
0.0182933398,
-0.0415696241,
0.0297301542,
-0.0092404466,
0.0118495421,
0.0304141138,
-0.0061558913,
-0.0268986281,
-0.0305411853,
-0.0413082466,
0.0367738642,
-0.0059193727,
0.0177702494,
0.0315734781,
0.0143247675,
-0.0108229322,
0.0132931611,
-0.071026735,
-0.0542875677,
-0.005467061,
0.039338097,
0.0385407358,
-0.006704791,
0.0652550012,
-0.0498482287,
-0.0246106125,
-0.0164132901,
0.014859451,
0.002066063,
-0.0049584149,
0.0839378163,
0.0381146781,
0.0219110008,
-0.0160561241,
0.0797910169,
0.0221324768,
0.0423764624,
-0.0179328322,
0.0144390156,
-0.0044212705,
-0.0203789249,
0.0317252763,
0.0441033468,
-0.0156709831,
-0.0347931311,
-0.0224144626,
-0.0478221327,
0.0105606522,
-0.012481885,
-0.0587499589,
-0.0460456535,
0.0212085657,
0.0334808901,
-0.0514421575,
-0.0148218535,
-0.0141090937,
0.0365302637,
0.023668455,
-0.0386495925,
0.0148640918,
-5.912598097e-33,
-0.0304266028,
0.00319175,
0.028484432,
0.0229776204,
-0.0187307317,
0.0103714988,
-0.0219789706,
-0.0348029956,
-0.0181189235,
0.0433746353,
-0.0090322141,
-0.009676978,
-0.0084281545,
0.0035587519,
0.0359708518,
0.0387354568,
0.0449363366,
0.0094252508,
-0.0015667666,
0.0382940397,
0.0190598238,
0.0150024407,
0.060441155,
-0.0610506274,
0.0367132351,
-0.0146765504,
0.0316216387,
-0.0254980605,
-0.0131969759,
0.0540278628,
-0.0404854305,
0.0474849828,
-0.0086620403,
-0.0678109229,
-0.029520072,
-0.0090699764,
-0.0701955855,
-0.0379047096,
0.0541959852,
0.0081736157,
-0.0114713069,
-0.0854432806,
0.0773724392,
-0.0112794098,
0.0196684487,
-0.0494726002,
0.0619632117,
-0.0294776931,
-0.0458856486,
-0.0384828411,
-0.0824703276,
-0.0001671788,
-0.0132486895,
0.0340360291,
0.0296773855,
-0.0238864552,
0.0139028858,
0.0655315667,
-0.031193452,
0.0372063853,
0.050553225,
0.0345755108,
0.0510402806,
-0.0196966566,
0.0152113326,
0.0232821126,
-0.0371347852,
-0.0018648901,
0.0143427933,
0.0033776008,
0.0532571413,
-0.0100638811,
0.0233557653,
0.0483939908,
0.0128229009,
0.007411168,
-0.0548629351,
0.0444680527,
0.0105509637,
0.0316827036,
0.0016801368,
0.0316053852,
0.0088185444,
-0.0210443661,
-0.0507798083,
0.0202424489,
0.0097333873,
-0.0269475635,
-0.0202981289,
-0.0186754894,
-0.0349905342,
-0.0163323991,
0.0109178619,
-0.0297427233,
-0.0558588207,
0.0519681536,
-0.0096747661,
0.0435929149,
-0.0101548759,
0.015399077,
-0.0943845883,
-0.0272852033,
0.0271751527,
-0.0335414372,
0.0088262139,
0.0158176553,
0.0562266298,
-0.001173552,
-0.0345485657,
-0.019287426,
-0.0215778947,
-0.052639477,
0.0710934475,
0.0216101725,
0.0258499477,
0.0224246215,
0.0190953016,
0.0269645602,
0.0282355975,
-0.0210344438,
-0.0066924896,
0.0006550036,
-0.017292209,
0.0124172298,
-0.0381321311,
-0.0026130339,
-0.0282924082,
-0.020951312,
0.0105794808,
-0.0717851594,
-0.0141350478,
0.0002490132,
2.573e-7,
0.0513548106,
0.0762127265,
-0.0089823157,
-0.0324409306,
0.033854723,
0.0092983916,
-0.0246746596,
0.0269500669,
0.0281807259,
-0.0265834853,
0.0018758543,
0.0317341723,
0.0205980502,
0.0154364323,
-0.0911966786,
-0.059588477,
-0.0300005842,
0.0138067231,
-0.05658824,
-0.0604615882,
0.0248438288,
0.053561002,
0.0115071079,
-0.009968115,
0.0016026112,
-0.0486949235,
0.0724504665,
-0.027120173,
0.0193100218,
0.0791608617,
0.0361578949,
0.0270558931,
-0.03785583,
0.0195916202,
-0.0220012739,
0.0096752951,
-0.0203304905,
0.0653074011,
0.0232800115,
0.029642269,
0.0311383456,
-0.0067870757,
-0.0236281604,
-0.0658268183,
0.0367463753,
-0.0276813824,
-0.0150299985,
-0.0026958087,
-0.0366299525,
-0.0244726203,
0.0162281431,
-0.0325454436,
0.0171400104,
0.0231433045,
-0.0170632433,
-0.0284827575,
-0.0245936401,
-0.0575137623,
-0.0414828435,
0.0105037158,
-0.0476441719,
-0.0556086116,
-0.0524003506,
-0.0335790589,
-0.0106108934,
-0.0512160547,
0.031157149,
2.125923319e-34,
0.0552628115,
-0.0348958261,
0.0043821074,
0.0579031557,
0.0002363773,
-0.0162291415,
-0.0228927918,
0.036299549,
0.0360978134,
-0.1236869544,
0.0161883179
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03342v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03342v1 | Topic and genre in dialogue | 2023-12-06T08:33:51 | 2023-12-06T08:33:51 | Amandine Decker, Ellen Breitholtz, Christine Howes, Staffan Larsson | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this paper we argue that topic plays a fundamental role in conversations,
and that the concept is needed in addition to that of genre to define
interactions. In particular, the concepts of genre and topic need to be
separated and orthogonally defined. This would enable modular, reliable and
controllable flexible-domain dialogue systems. | [
0.0598097034,
-0.031189777,
-0.0310060102,
0.0278731119,
0.0112522803,
0.0014778362,
0.0125877671,
-0.0423725173,
-0.0634389669,
-0.0520211197,
-0.0460483581,
-0.0468340106,
-0.0085829226,
0.071596019,
-0.0120979836,
-0.1060965359,
0.0495869592,
-0.0462771654,
0.0452034548,
0.0175996441,
0.0218028743,
0.0058522178,
-0.0528785139,
0.0481140278,
-0.0243278183,
-0.0339784697,
-0.0642706305,
-0.0203815755,
-0.0153933167,
0.0373701565,
0.0432252102,
0.021481771,
0.0447062813,
0.0262639783,
0.0000014089,
-0.0374335833,
0.0213119425,
-0.0291529298,
0.024053691,
-0.0526542552,
0.0155350436,
0.0723592415,
-0.0048028678,
0.018692011,
-0.0437744111,
-0.043682076,
0.0460195243,
0.078430146,
0.0403664634,
0.0477069579,
-0.0081089819,
-0.0189253632,
-0.0254131649,
-0.0034368038,
-0.0367626324,
-0.0340300985,
-0.0031485464,
0.004776035,
0.0581215993,
0.0437187068,
0.0084689921,
-0.0164495893,
-0.0204886049,
-0.0344911516,
-0.0190942436,
-0.0107195629,
-0.0462326929,
0.0001314454,
-0.020084789,
0.0466289297,
0.0844015181,
0.0087917438,
0.0253810901,
0.0247371476,
0.0209971461,
-0.0104790619,
-0.0628601387,
-0.0035023023,
-0.0422650464,
-0.0189301576,
-0.0001494766,
0.0244428366,
-0.0457523949,
0.0148065807,
-0.0012674078,
0.1035070866,
-0.0097347116,
0.0020509597,
-0.0402412079,
-0.0390853323,
0.0248310007,
-0.0535932519,
0.0247419663,
0.0207582377,
-0.0497394688,
-0.0021615208,
-0.0383093506,
0.0243487116,
-0.0204641726,
-0.0367584601,
-0.0505999811,
-0.005924142,
0.0007775401,
0.0320352428,
0.1088692546,
0.0014558211,
-0.0256069247,
-0.0468467772,
0.0140413409,
-0.0128139108,
-0.0398469903,
-0.0176985804,
-0.0800542831,
0.0259214994,
-0.0342041999,
-0.0320620015,
0.0404206328,
0.0713555217,
-0.0084186392,
0.0168356039,
-0.0181979872,
-0.0089564165,
-0.0799494088,
0.0014201701,
-0.0373008139,
0.0425879955,
-0.0432891585,
0.0273617133,
0.0267954692,
-0.0037747025,
0.0419348925,
0.0217407551,
0.0001688818,
0.0039286092,
-0.0395110361,
0.0806992278,
-0.0277057476,
-0.0151242418,
0.0101878121,
-0.0228773002,
-0.0365870222,
-0.0535076261,
0.0098079517,
-0.0371294357,
-0.0054674032,
0.000021208,
-0.0162948351,
0.0063703316,
-0.0023449003,
-0.0064141662,
0.0130089568,
0.0344997123,
-0.0209657233,
0.0159621835,
0.0927480534,
0.0215972438,
-0.0333642066,
0.0434216857,
0.0176243782,
0.0050522173,
0.0712811351,
-0.0137783848,
0.036209356,
-0.0052304235,
-0.0722664967,
-0.017375987,
0.0253726877,
0.0107326675,
-0.0049868142,
-0.0086308904,
-0.020123722,
0.0567622669,
-0.0367270038,
-0.0215091426,
0.0714068264,
0.0352949426,
-0.0008585743,
0.0382228233,
0.0383567959,
0.012156114,
0.0261831675,
0.0757572651,
0.0258087702,
0.0129719954,
0.0394185632,
-0.0036218383,
-0.0176406819,
-0.029136505,
-0.0586022437,
-0.0523232631,
0.0061441264,
-0.0036358878,
0.0189422313,
-0.0319218412,
0.0385740027,
0.0124613252,
0.0021112221,
0.0409352407,
-0.0225282982,
-0.0380025283,
-0.0403187945,
-0.0005860846,
0.0161295496,
0.0422292948,
0.0073529342,
-0.0506032445,
-0.0630172044,
-0.0316533893,
0.0070257378,
0.0679341704,
0.0814279318,
-0.0751758441,
0.04149919,
-0.0279262103,
0.0197228007,
-0.033984717,
0.0063358364,
0.0361212455,
-0.0432739668,
-0.0072724917,
-0.0311045423,
0.0268626325,
0.0780940875,
-0.034609478,
0.0594133995,
0.009599735,
0.005895867,
0.0236850716,
0.0378237106,
0.0460006781,
-0.0180829931,
-0.0095384717,
0.0130778644,
0.0261069909,
-0.0152370287,
0.0530455001,
-0.0327718779,
0.0050314628,
0.0042735063,
-0.0340145901,
0.0096692247,
-0.031141229,
0.0166385993,
-0.0614377484,
0.0422698855,
-0.0438004024,
0.012199806,
-0.0422042385,
0.0250969734,
-0.0120828534,
-0.0144475037,
-0.0135393487,
-0.0118786022,
0.0446618311,
-0.0125645502,
-0.0118916873,
-0.0031629347,
0.0633751899,
-0.0955523774,
0.0003742179,
0.0760376453,
-0.0023919202,
0.0060674907,
0.0272028223,
-0.0627430454,
-0.0329643413,
-0.0224290267,
-0.108423464,
-0.0142356846,
-0.0308871958,
-0.0143233975,
-0.0086532179,
0.028029751,
0.0036954705,
-0.0308832228,
-0.0165186934,
0.0076163244,
0.0377225168,
0.0195361618,
0.0153237097,
0.0505251028,
-0.0402349569,
-0.0001866439,
0.0038958269,
-0.0012423599,
0.0224561337,
-0.0296877287,
-0.0150401965,
-0.0575369075,
-0.0550681651,
-0.0592616349,
0.0493765324,
-0.0330880098,
-0.0025892735,
0.0556797609,
0.0125063099,
0.0294449385,
0.0026354743,
0.0332987979,
0.029155802,
0.0058578239,
-0.0473214723,
0.0006050853,
0.0331735574,
-0.0278991368,
0.0102054095,
-0.0309033561,
0.0465574302,
0.0311284568,
0.0522457361,
0.0204406288,
0.0295352042,
-0.025265988,
0.0037021101,
0.0223241486,
0.007112633,
0.013527723,
-0.0320336483,
-0.0551435538,
0.036297366,
0.0052967723,
-0.0081784371,
0.0499585494,
-0.0209370181,
-0.0231286548,
-0.059394218,
-0.0613093823,
-0.0210890137,
0.0224461388,
-0.0577239953,
-0.0132708484,
0.0730578378,
-0.0758349076,
-0.0165721755,
-0.0200786944,
0.0556231663,
-0.0020706803,
0.0950328633,
-0.0641188398,
-0.0059922142,
0.028431898,
-0.0348719954,
-0.0215556081,
0.0214256626,
-0.0097949207,
0.0257386081,
-0.0052700783,
-0.0132809142,
-0.037752863,
0.0266847499,
-0.0063056452,
0.0417121239,
-0.0137169473,
0.0107670259,
-0.0205419287,
0.0652449131,
0.0139718773,
0.033446379,
-0.057432577,
0.036498405,
0.0682261959,
-0.0072089857,
-0.0238956604,
-0.0420831777,
-0.0305298883,
-0.0044126539,
0.0292116478,
-0.0224377494,
-0.0657394007,
0.011555871,
0.0499665774,
-0.0305086561,
-0.0088646123,
0.0934991241,
0.0212638527,
-0.0162381288,
-0.0066766394,
-0.0183934458,
0.0024276748,
0.0449601784,
0.0176373515,
-0.0354534686,
0.0115257995,
-0.017677689,
0.017260097,
-0.0170971509,
-0.0147245601,
-0.0303666778,
0.0087467283,
0.0252738073,
0.0122612175,
-0.0729318336,
0.0199461896,
0.0053477813,
0.0254450683,
0.0093995454,
0.0173524674,
-0.012418489,
0.0130593432,
-0.0256828256,
-0.0013408583,
0.0063905711,
0.0048240218,
-0.0170559026,
0.0043506385,
0.0629112199,
0.0193781164,
0.0390160792,
0.0248448495,
0.002194067,
-0.0009994148,
-0.0212965049,
0.0148349665,
0.0105109429,
-0.0049581546,
-0.0203882027,
0.0083565526,
-0.0430506766,
0.0144505724,
0.0224733166,
-0.0055622743,
0.012680565,
0.0672305897,
-0.0895911679,
0.0024766107,
-0.0305693764,
0.0119029153,
0.0542876422,
0.0507344306,
0.0427979268,
-0.0215867795,
-0.0241410956,
-0.0496120155,
-0.0655675232,
0.0400643572,
0.0185698438,
-0.0079247141,
-0.0288888253,
-0.0563894138,
-0.0600008182,
-0.039333187,
-0.0003655254,
0.0595999993,
-0.0376694687,
0.0189535134,
0.0041297879,
0.0627211779,
-0.0287700333,
-0.0008161544,
0.0103700012,
-0.0176383629,
-0.0827145278,
-0.0679371729,
0.0519430935,
-0.025331039,
-0.0121034011,
-0.0083199618,
0.0051998897,
-0.084090054,
-0.0119870631,
0.0038288194,
0.0276733581,
0.0132669779,
0.0129176648,
-0.0650362894,
-0.0281098075,
-0.0187067986,
-0.041005943,
0.0101520093,
0.0558487438,
0.0530787222,
-0.0223990493,
0.0328399874,
-0.0529443845,
0.0319833755,
-0.0443851836,
0.0189515129,
-0.0458896831,
-0.0473404676,
-0.0323276855,
-0.0402966999,
0.028530851,
0.0515640602,
-0.0358416922,
0.004816764,
0.0273257196,
-0.0152756749,
-0.0313657634,
-0.0351139493,
-0.0029294158,
-0.061385151,
0.0125668515,
0.0205019657,
-0.0154879019,
-0.0677275062,
0.0472231284,
0.0175106749,
-0.0168333407,
0.0349896662,
0.0146394391,
-0.0177149773,
0.0177112706,
-0.0000772588,
0.074549742,
0.0306565557,
0.013771615,
0.0032104228,
0.1166394874,
0.0195590984,
-0.0166599043,
0.0090680309,
0.0345641002,
-0.0897072554,
-0.0343811624,
0.0248393621,
0.0656099692,
0.0058539906,
0.0067632692,
0.0156942159,
-0.0244724229,
0.0057852007,
-0.01119735,
0.0797371566,
0.0252443906,
-0.0255313478,
0.0596379824,
0.0227683578,
-0.0108213546,
0.0114384042,
0.043070659,
-0.0170009676,
-0.0403335318,
0.0288764127,
-0.0161928367,
-0.0437427014,
-0.0237497222,
0.0329364575,
0.0194006879,
0.0016001235,
0.0180230364,
-0.0400193073,
-0.0085563129,
0.0203637574,
-0.0173406824,
0.0400428697,
-0.0337923467,
0.0596773252,
0.0576245263,
0.0185889155,
0.00814333,
-0.0260012522,
0.0070263701,
-0.0183050353,
0.0168534145,
-0.0499863289,
-5.020089685e-33,
-0.0372428633,
-0.0202168692,
0.0091155916,
0.0529493839,
-0.0279008262,
-0.0123722656,
-0.0138953403,
0.0333830193,
0.0002343248,
0.0123806223,
-0.007761498,
0.0435556807,
0.0051349634,
-0.0177883916,
-0.0087443003,
-0.0287451968,
0.0511627086,
0.001932065,
-0.0421852618,
0.0399633124,
0.0839939415,
-0.0001634088,
0.0298104864,
-0.1165446043,
0.0141784055,
0.0027236992,
-0.0041527711,
0.0346387811,
0.0508192554,
0.0404044874,
0.0293677691,
0.0589944012,
0.0075002015,
-0.0235188846,
-0.0174314845,
0.0677086264,
-0.019353861,
-0.0397039764,
0.0292809345,
0.0344593711,
0.0491812229,
-0.0051402734,
-0.0141165843,
-0.0152581036,
0.0053616455,
0.0119121978,
0.0107090976,
-0.0021910174,
0.0060861814,
-0.0369060002,
-0.0599076562,
0.0008555417,
-0.0241593458,
-0.0226842351,
0.0211069882,
-0.0033006356,
0.0211614687,
-0.0598281026,
0.0192400012,
0.0734596997,
-0.0340310186,
-0.0248548295,
0.0090397922,
-0.0006335125,
-0.0003702179,
0.0020389901,
-0.0028995329,
0.0596819669,
0.0185631383,
-0.0374294519,
-0.034734264,
0.0796651319,
-0.0014142718,
0.0459872149,
-0.030745713,
0.0248366352,
0.0145746302,
0.0295558032,
0.041298829,
0.0159872621,
-0.0588249452,
0.025685912,
-0.0501125678,
-0.0186239388,
-0.0178715792,
0.0405546986,
-0.017258361,
-0.0527951717,
0.0223178193,
-0.0319388844,
0.0276028644,
-0.0025641823,
0.0333414041,
-0.029418407,
0.0028058987,
0.0485458188,
-0.0212103669,
0.0287713259,
-0.0010442602,
-0.0314004384,
-0.0056052888,
-0.0367802009,
0.0601398572,
0.0026578866,
0.0098167257,
0.0186757855,
-0.0427037664,
0.0224735998,
-0.0136710471,
-0.0091427583,
0.0183354877,
0.0139113134,
-0.0224758592,
0.0812970251,
-0.0067610131,
0.0128786061,
-0.0137372594,
0.0841260254,
-0.0395321287,
-0.0318692513,
-0.0884040594,
-0.0248668231,
-0.0133101689,
0.0336125493,
-0.0404869877,
-0.0059477021,
-0.018011013,
-0.051484447,
0.0168824606,
-0.0221123248,
-0.0212151743,
-0.043175377,
2.225e-7,
-0.0311951693,
0.0074774553,
0.0130078234,
0.0078373803,
0.0548649244,
0.0539190099,
-0.008136712,
0.0274361968,
0.0110758478,
0.0105612632,
0.0133878384,
-0.0162545759,
0.0262065474,
0.0426133089,
-0.1042031124,
-0.0463535264,
-0.0035969417,
-0.0082784239,
-0.0377478302,
0.01345821,
0.0217106715,
0.0379598401,
0.028948281,
0.0487785377,
-0.0232694261,
0.0043124142,
0.0296770427,
-0.0019092187,
0.0136552444,
0.0438931249,
0.0145993661,
-0.0171431173,
-0.0471186526,
-0.0074250055,
0.0121809812,
0.0319202654,
0.0183963981,
0.0513070971,
-0.0088158604,
-0.0493914708,
-0.0214210693,
-0.0218309034,
-0.0149394041,
-0.0257053971,
-0.0146762403,
-0.0277826469,
-0.0307288803,
0.009415511,
0.0031508543,
-0.0123943025,
-0.0233646799,
-0.0197592396,
-0.0039010504,
-0.0150180245,
-0.0151129588,
-0.0053513921,
0.04682469,
-0.0673290268,
0.0504999906,
0.0233885162,
-0.0587339401,
-0.0818729475,
0.0086211907,
-0.0349723287,
0.0430341139,
-0.0197019074,
-0.0029029318,
1.253365801e-34,
0.0096085873,
0.0137817515,
-0.0198837537,
0.0344718769,
0.0116073722,
-0.0244924463,
0.0270080995,
0.0320660472,
0.0662548393,
-0.0220716372,
-0.014673559
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03330v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03330v1 | Measuring Misogyny in Natural Language Generation: Preliminary Results from a Case Study on two Reddit Communities | 2023-12-06T07:38:46 | 2023-12-06T07:38:46 | Aaron J. Snoswell, Lucinda Nelson, Hao Xue, Flora D. Salim, Nicolas Suzor, Jean Burgess | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG | Generic `toxicity' classifiers continue to be used for evaluating the
potential for harm in natural language generation, despite mounting evidence of
their shortcomings. We consider the challenge of measuring misogyny in natural
language generation, and argue that generic `toxicity' classifiers are
inadequate for this task. We use data from two well-characterised `Incel'
communities on Reddit that differ primarily in their degrees of misogyny to
construct a pair of training corpora which we use to fine-tune two language
models. We show that an open source `toxicity' classifier is unable to
distinguish meaningfully between generations from these models. We contrast
this with a misogyny-specific lexicon recently proposed by feminist
subject-matter experts, demonstrating that, despite the limitations of simple
lexicon-based approaches, this shows promise as a benchmark to evaluate
language models for misogyny, and that it is sensitive enough to reveal the
known differences in these Reddit communities. Our preliminary findings
highlight the limitations of a generic approach to evaluating harms, and
further emphasise the need for careful benchmark design and selection in
natural language evaluation. | [
0.074077189,
0.0868808851,
-0.0269221142,
-0.0026610163,
-0.0365502276,
0.029423248,
0.0241509043,
0.0147289596,
0.0255951751,
-0.085860543,
0.0051134988,
-0.0162626989,
0.0172591452,
-0.0153497839,
0.0132957185,
0.0144634228,
0.0165736005,
0.0644422099,
-0.0124730617,
-0.0270307008,
0.0494149923,
0.0327214673,
0.014516688,
0.047855597,
-0.0029923301,
-0.0282451473,
0.074856557,
0.0408607535,
0.0092424899,
-0.0013546771,
0.0636442453,
0.0425034165,
-0.022876421,
0.0380539931,
0.0000016324,
-0.0689867809,
0.0396451131,
0.0053599523,
0.0238616262,
-0.0221705791,
0.0729319379,
0.0014592655,
-0.0221256539,
0.0428204387,
-0.0012653352,
0.0089344522,
0.0442685448,
-0.0023186812,
0.0636785999,
0.0340869389,
-0.0037868656,
-0.0150431935,
-0.0367496237,
0.0132211326,
0.0096700378,
0.0670702681,
0.0473574661,
-0.018778339,
-0.0453564301,
-0.0051760897,
-0.011445581,
0.0129455701,
-0.0083086416,
-0.0131035848,
0.0093686273,
-0.0045175026,
-0.0084746871,
-0.0727254823,
0.0039240415,
0.0251063071,
0.0059362254,
0.0028599182,
0.0064889644,
0.0328752436,
-0.0110830646,
-0.0047880118,
-0.0281065535,
0.0168982986,
-0.0295591541,
-0.0169087984,
0.0031474526,
-0.0136492765,
0.0344806835,
0.0906424969,
0.0666369647,
0.0245643333,
0.0011840634,
-0.014709169,
0.01054167,
-0.0027612508,
-0.0086523294,
-0.0093654022,
0.0205438491,
-0.0368032232,
0.0116743892,
0.0280166976,
-0.0335875042,
-0.0291737933,
0.0706162453,
-0.0750119165,
-0.0035963391,
0.0247011818,
0.0285997856,
-0.0046237851,
-0.0054168473,
0.0123418681,
0.0215783957,
0.0159120411,
0.0058009531,
-0.0094626956,
-0.0235434473,
-0.0045637419,
0.0045062741,
-0.0274532009,
0.0379545614,
0.0447227061,
-0.0678550228,
0.0048189666,
-0.0602639467,
-0.0439228304,
0.0025320507,
0.0371186659,
-0.0033443873,
0.0328020565,
-0.0066436143,
-0.0314064734,
-0.0635566935,
0.0274799895,
0.0038144498,
-0.093094416,
0.0195128378,
0.0130438777,
-0.0286732968,
-0.0074166586,
0.0173160806,
0.0716321468,
0.0548043773,
-0.0396239683,
-0.0420306288,
-0.0274298433,
-0.0618680716,
-0.0368838012,
0.0082547814,
-0.0848132521,
0.0178465471,
0.0293110479,
-0.032503441,
-0.0555748269,
0.0164986849,
0.035232041,
-0.0536170714,
0.040062651,
-0.0073982435,
-0.0197183266,
0.0842196941,
0.048968859,
-0.0277913064,
0.0792856738,
0.0460240357,
-0.0052754465,
0.0384819582,
0.0140025485,
-0.0372970663,
0.0392261297,
0.0185539965,
0.0395498946,
-0.0370091982,
0.0214695968,
-0.0511870347,
0.0070670694,
0.0147797083,
0.0359433256,
0.0029880381,
-0.0373398848,
0.0606790483,
0.0438479595,
0.002034572,
0.0825383887,
0.0774956197,
-0.0021215209,
-0.0462249927,
-0.0042173527,
-0.0224698111,
-0.0413709283,
-0.0549229346,
-0.0588007495,
0.0353806615,
0.0213923808,
0.0109796636,
-0.074082084,
-0.0277953874,
0.006251235,
0.0114627704,
-0.054290846,
0.0067095095,
0.0438515469,
-0.0195354559,
0.0008970847,
0.0662007779,
-0.0577400476,
0.0281962343,
-0.0253762119,
0.0169493183,
0.0737125725,
0.0249098092,
-0.0136227896,
0.0013549908,
-0.0486384556,
-0.0076832469,
0.0182506461,
0.0238712952,
0.012297838,
-0.0241576303,
-0.0122343525,
-0.0012647044,
0.0271110479,
0.0130106919,
-0.0037786439,
0.0333669484,
0.0322837383,
0.0066883909,
0.0286176372,
-0.0718882307,
0.0379791185,
0.0164974872,
-0.000159551,
-0.0037614149,
0.0078249937,
0.0351368971,
-0.0156051554,
-0.0424837321,
-0.0240073595,
0.0021915501,
-0.0160208996,
-0.061282739,
0.0044787438,
-0.0207105502,
-0.0208843332,
0.0036789819,
-0.0526316725,
-0.0257122144,
0.0494050756,
0.0184315201,
0.0441650711,
0.0866343603,
-0.0760160834,
-0.0395864472,
-0.0329596363,
-0.0240176804,
-0.0437645167,
0.0211161356,
-0.0484582409,
0.0617096908,
-0.0693404153,
0.0236990359,
0.00098192,
-0.0642112195,
-0.0231125988,
-0.0173869729,
-0.040947184,
-0.0203259997,
-0.0168767497,
0.0230705533,
0.0424002334,
-0.0044437149,
-0.0413564369,
-0.0434710421,
-0.0272601806,
-0.0014858326,
-0.0238868278,
0.0062970864,
0.0278687775,
-0.009050753,
-0.0217591692,
0.0500491932,
-0.0068093757,
-0.0366872735,
0.0059237755,
0.0486123487,
0.0263625942,
-0.0428486615,
-0.0201753657,
-0.0309541225,
-0.0176641215,
-0.0216393545,
0.0530097336,
0.0443363898,
-0.017272003,
0.0212672353,
-0.0097572757,
-0.0569372103,
-0.0549065694,
-0.0083344709,
-0.0613107644,
0.0194108542,
0.0488911532,
0.0068556666,
0.0124366824,
0.0852957517,
0.094016321,
0.0164856501,
0.0295451526,
-0.0137229497,
-0.0372319631,
-0.0117480522,
0.01775188,
-0.0086143464,
-0.0801853836,
0.0029326964,
0.0331968255,
0.0060686553,
-0.0086352658,
-0.0388158821,
0.0981684849,
-0.0765248314,
-0.0308216456,
0.0091975406,
-0.0708886981,
0.0135994274,
0.0130312452,
-0.0217258558,
-0.0531366803,
0.0123737268,
0.001088794,
0.0013140434,
-0.0016883893,
-0.0535078757,
0.007307169,
0.0216193348,
-0.0188596416,
0.0633756146,
0.0297430772,
-0.0081863487,
-0.0250681955,
-0.0108688185,
0.0367503911,
-0.021789534,
0.0056651067,
-0.027463207,
0.0414966717,
0.0418848284,
-0.0470433272,
-0.0674412176,
-0.0609774105,
0.0140555985,
-0.0286085606,
0.0212892219,
0.0069550001,
-0.0015065074,
0.0250616781,
-0.033991266,
-0.0469126515,
-0.0057449141,
-0.0350134484,
0.0463298187,
0.0022889597,
0.0296054631,
-0.0233523306,
0.0448360071,
-0.0046959785,
-0.0266275872,
0.0625366271,
-0.0626206324,
0.0154652465,
-0.005738806,
0.0283461493,
0.0258037169,
-0.04228165,
-0.0060436814,
-0.0118119,
-0.0035445027,
-0.0401820131,
-0.0274044182,
0.0432743207,
0.0211415216,
0.0066125793,
0.0354613177,
0.0199466776,
0.0453322418,
0.0417018197,
-0.0196861364,
-0.0615650862,
0.0135746049,
-0.011871242,
0.0358336307,
-0.0971138105,
-0.0701300427,
-0.0166350026,
-0.0906001404,
0.0024356197,
0.0061755665,
-0.0498752519,
0.0022065216,
0.0164663531,
-0.000403214,
0.0082511362,
-0.002126782,
-0.006636207,
0.004846727,
0.0019716232,
-0.0005888991,
-0.0694852024,
-0.0311418548,
0.0107349614,
-0.0250475667,
0.0438978262,
0.0048919134,
0.060074944,
-0.0233623013,
-0.0096600894,
0.0237131249,
-0.0212946739,
-0.0126726208,
-0.0512170531,
0.0322305858,
0.0012455861,
-0.0281802285,
-0.0457028151,
0.023768682,
0.0243453532,
0.0294640493,
-0.0225867424,
-0.0037638955,
0.0355888978,
-0.0163570456,
-0.0676746741,
0.0277665313,
0.0482277237,
0.0533232763,
0.036967475,
-0.0486230403,
-0.0226084385,
-0.0648833886,
0.0009868063,
-0.014590851,
-0.0655766279,
-0.0330654569,
0.017898744,
-0.0309710093,
-0.0892412886,
-0.0371692106,
-0.0185651835,
-0.0153232124,
0.0080609461,
-0.06322705,
-0.0150335068,
0.011619579,
-0.0620531552,
-0.0007023895,
0.0185409021,
-0.0068114889,
0.0022431714,
-0.0317653082,
-0.0269934386,
0.0014496678,
-0.0241848212,
0.0613454059,
-0.017353395,
-0.07054995,
0.0567618012,
0.0544462241,
0.0151442001,
0.0201050192,
-0.0047948672,
-0.0277774241,
0.0701825768,
0.0637656003,
-0.0137217091,
0.0301533155,
0.0234618615,
0.0020642076,
0.0083011743,
0.0480863824,
-0.0378895141,
0.025050208,
-0.015443489,
-0.0202041268,
-0.0389836244,
0.0038661566,
0.0012114438,
-0.0033136252,
-0.0023706865,
-0.0498428084,
0.0127365198,
-0.0172597617,
-0.0455571599,
-0.0413068943,
-0.0413609035,
-0.0092180585,
-0.0458868816,
0.0223552193,
0.0067907199,
-0.0442935899,
0.0182480607,
-0.0546621345,
0.0443733744,
-0.0306547228,
0.011712051,
0.0315279774,
0.0339557715,
-0.0084558334,
0.0107934745,
-0.0175593831,
-0.0210018866,
-0.0179278199,
-0.0024382875,
-0.0053724968,
0.0136419004,
-0.0089133801,
0.020099869,
0.0036202762,
-0.0028430717,
0.0021288733,
-0.0053217318,
-0.005107183,
0.0066550337,
-0.0170040354,
-0.0268360469,
0.0702253357,
0.0100627318,
-0.0308490545,
-0.033613991,
0.0033329546,
-0.0049762344,
-0.0586690381,
0.0217512213,
0.0186025426,
-0.0178695265,
-0.0163057707,
0.0359048173,
0.0200220663,
0.0488970466,
0.0185162872,
-0.0630390644,
-0.0129729779,
-0.0345863178,
0.0006158212,
-0.0176927447,
0.0186550431,
-0.0021700012,
-0.1007004082,
-0.0353240669,
0.0065438896,
-0.0344932638,
0.0854052082,
0.0141053088,
0.0017570059,
0.0568849258,
-0.0113976914,
0.0045182658,
-0.0338302627,
-0.0060853981,
-0.0590787828,
-0.0093169492,
-0.0070531247,
-5.223692653e-33,
-0.0132699953,
-0.0826087371,
-0.0324053876,
-0.0021311233,
-0.0220490098,
-0.0016772525,
0.0112613374,
0.0074220416,
0.0203668941,
0.0206820033,
0.051899232,
-0.0028029024,
-0.0066908547,
0.0035730789,
0.013605441,
-0.0200683754,
0.0302781947,
-0.0006843108,
-0.0328344814,
-0.0188205354,
0.0389196016,
0.0338306911,
0.0025057129,
-0.045699764,
0.0612244718,
-0.0271359403,
-0.00964393,
-0.0031653452,
-0.013049393,
0.0347293839,
0.0141394297,
0.1082604975,
0.0093953134,
-0.0051609762,
0.0334266089,
0.0562185571,
-0.0218750797,
-0.0184299108,
0.0037013912,
0.0106847575,
0.0085025318,
0.0139212683,
0.0671818033,
0.0327035338,
-0.0436391905,
-0.0487100482,
0.058668863,
0.0056042275,
0.052146405,
-0.0308172051,
-0.0566693209,
0.0163502134,
-0.049237933,
-0.0152360452,
-0.024457559,
0.0494612008,
0.0125430292,
0.0097647328,
-0.0484408215,
0.0220506154,
-0.0192961544,
-0.0103184208,
0.01558848,
-0.0115699181,
0.0394448675,
0.0907454193,
0.0052294396,
0.0625123605,
-0.0026152683,
0.0332819149,
0.0203123894,
-0.0004796001,
0.0310835578,
0.0662987456,
0.0159783624,
-0.0483252928,
-0.0916298181,
-0.03988396,
0.0360992253,
0.0095153041,
-0.0022858346,
-0.0515865795,
-0.0630011782,
-0.0374746658,
-0.0209036823,
-0.0579720326,
-0.0059265755,
-0.0328705572,
0.0051123044,
-0.035275992,
-0.0740807354,
-0.0154608088,
-0.0383613333,
-0.0258124359,
-0.029214289,
0.0243094619,
-0.043730367,
-0.0506403111,
0.0350149795,
0.0232908223,
0.0040281159,
0.0457331538,
0.0101206787,
-0.0198272206,
0.0526184477,
-0.0032305322,
0.0509675667,
0.0389699787,
-0.0485508069,
-0.008262556,
-0.0249846019,
0.0517960191,
-0.0198449437,
0.0404430889,
0.0182986241,
0.0400882587,
-0.0336164273,
-0.0246991497,
0.0904132649,
0.0586207584,
-0.0133529138,
0.0164492056,
-0.0162335988,
0.0181667414,
-0.0308008622,
-0.0413557254,
0.0152646098,
0.0581505634,
0.0561176389,
-0.0542696752,
0.0039867857,
-0.0548027307,
2.324e-7,
0.044919908,
0.0754039735,
0.0065633366,
0.0194896348,
0.0427447632,
0.0193255581,
0.0313783959,
0.0495797396,
0.0161746312,
-0.0263694096,
-0.031819541,
0.0223362222,
0.0011399381,
0.0502047949,
-0.0203061104,
0.0218708832,
-0.0930480585,
0.036306221,
-0.0281848926,
-0.0039591887,
0.0097146407,
0.0262630563,
0.0381572992,
-0.0585202686,
-0.0183422752,
-0.019221874,
0.068152383,
-0.0222244747,
-0.0006839268,
0.0102465767,
0.0476119965,
0.0089857019,
0.0304802824,
-0.0073828315,
0.0093629295,
-0.0267563704,
0.0192559995,
0.0032215118,
0.0016493083,
0.0070239375,
0.039611388,
0.0021387965,
-0.0136715239,
-0.0312522724,
0.0519468337,
0.011421157,
-0.0009542682,
-0.0711243525,
-0.028744949,
-0.0103978077,
0.1018085182,
-0.0547009967,
-0.0275695287,
0.0044350224,
0.0144227026,
-0.001245898,
0.0191949569,
-0.0273733735,
-0.0047967122,
-0.0189252906,
-0.027890306,
-0.047545094,
0.0069171526,
0.0337071531,
0.0197200309,
0.0100789368,
0.0338973626,
1.64319451e-34,
-0.0172536317,
0.01284834,
-0.0011414048,
-0.0337797403,
0.0345497318,
0.0390282348,
0.0307616908,
0.0182740241,
0.0124171879,
0.0318767019,
0.0134048248
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03312v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03312v1 | Optimizing Two-Pass Cross-Lingual Transfer Learning: Phoneme Recognition and Phoneme to Grapheme Translation | 2023-12-06T06:37:24 | 2023-12-06T06:37:24 | Wonjun Lee, Gary Geunbae Lee, Yunsu Kim | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | This research optimizes two-pass cross-lingual transfer learning in
low-resource languages by enhancing phoneme recognition and phoneme-to-grapheme
translation models. Our approach optimizes these two stages to improve speech
recognition across languages. We optimize phoneme vocabulary coverage by
merging phonemes based on shared articulatory characteristics, thus improving
recognition accuracy. Additionally, we introduce a global phoneme noise
generator for realistic ASR noise during phoneme-to-grapheme training to reduce
error propagation. Experiments on the CommonVoice 12.0 dataset show significant
reductions in Word Error Rate (WER) for low-resource languages, highlighting
the effectiveness of our approach. This research contributes to the
advancements of two-pass ASR systems in low-resource languages, offering the
potential for improved cross-lingual transfer learning. | [
-0.0433913283,
0.0445828103,
0.0105105927,
0.0329470709,
0.0104509089,
0.0044318507,
0.0273463763,
-0.0076535735,
0.0245426521,
0.0016868631,
-0.0635921806,
-0.0580534972,
0.0726918131,
-0.0138966525,
0.058508642,
-0.0390720777,
0.0478943102,
-0.0481755137,
-0.0112247672,
-0.0297639389,
-0.012528195,
0.0079933982,
0.0017522167,
-0.0019983302,
-0.0045102565,
0.0417177267,
0.017063573,
0.0622831173,
0.0265239216,
-0.0322296508,
-0.0612032227,
-0.0194869302,
0.0028310686,
0.0766644701,
0.0000018998,
-0.0485901237,
-0.0358770825,
0.0181588829,
-0.0317029804,
-0.022818096,
0.0820606276,
-0.0266264156,
-0.0215356536,
0.0463443883,
0.0226154067,
-0.0505778417,
0.0856528357,
-0.0247935578,
0.0072431732,
0.056266509,
-0.02871673,
-0.0216269009,
0.0005118564,
-0.0307090804,
-0.0188698489,
-0.0463769883,
0.0045266943,
0.015018858,
-0.0198214557,
-0.0583786815,
-0.048690781,
0.0309372526,
-0.0365768038,
0.009010639,
0.0136263501,
-0.0139981909,
-0.0090090716,
-0.0606002733,
-0.0145425275,
0.0758528486,
-0.0532028191,
-0.0255615544,
0.0161933731,
0.0139843132,
-0.027481731,
-0.0185518023,
-0.0319654644,
-0.0027258161,
-0.0066768415,
0.011817798,
-0.0121785002,
0.0069509158,
0.0572857559,
-0.063205868,
-0.0319841169,
-0.0154185425,
0.0261956975,
-0.0314857624,
0.0544589907,
0.0216478501,
0.0125084165,
0.0210757293,
0.0395217389,
0.0127655622,
-0.0053633223,
0.0239145439,
-0.0071964217,
-0.0494322069,
0.000347532,
-0.0155591862,
0.0389837064,
0.033491835,
-0.0570921078,
0.0087088048,
-0.044533696,
0.0165677089,
0.0130419396,
0.0046257279,
-0.0314458162,
-0.0408220999,
0.0044161505,
0.0457858033,
-0.0574591048,
0.0173331071,
-0.0052366788,
-0.0335732289,
-0.0280371513,
-0.0317420885,
0.0031941249,
-0.007024881,
0.0538496487,
-0.0382679068,
-0.0554754175,
-0.0112158787,
0.0262220856,
0.0464658998,
0.0330796316,
0.0346506722,
-0.0371967554,
-0.0431922749,
-0.0032459861,
0.0166392568,
0.0528063215,
0.0058426498,
0.0390337743,
0.0739114508,
0.0003353664,
-0.0127216214,
-0.0498797782,
0.0282476395,
-0.0106474487,
-0.0278279129,
0.0015581071,
-0.039802786,
0.0556734763,
0.0069617648,
0.054818809,
-0.0222309418,
0.0119365305,
-0.0201516319,
-0.028972324,
0.077191636,
-0.0175091159,
0.0125555191,
0.0425355285,
-0.0264094211,
0.0004779699,
0.0629589558,
0.0652079582,
-0.0477667302,
0.0137647437,
-0.0430067629,
-0.0710007846,
0.0530146994,
0.050773941,
0.0126168057,
0.0079043433,
-0.0736032426,
0.0380931832,
-0.0016378638,
0.0401810817,
0.0822518319,
-0.0165635347,
-0.0139550427,
0.0188502371,
0.0318604559,
0.0418805405,
-0.0047138953,
0.0242913365,
0.0048324396,
-0.0287595391,
-0.0429666601,
0.006648845,
-0.0248042382,
0.0072963517,
0.0194183607,
0.0468805656,
0.0304132532,
-0.0207722373,
0.0200099237,
-0.0115334587,
-0.0481652208,
0.0247625858,
0.0132480524,
0.0465190485,
0.0104080243,
-0.0663709268,
0.0247389674,
0.0374848843,
-0.0308595262,
0.0389047191,
-0.0070600277,
-0.0241918601,
0.0248115901,
0.0123568168,
0.0338797905,
-0.0019187464,
-0.0145493597,
0.0098725865,
0.0359012,
0.0265181866,
0.0163501501,
0.0708782375,
-0.080657877,
-0.0156563427,
0.0681227818,
-0.0174079817,
0.0833636895,
-0.0247380268,
0.0455835983,
0.0113963298,
-0.058566127,
-0.0473140106,
-0.0302588381,
-0.0120809386,
-0.0059216563,
0.0465969853,
0.0211999174,
0.0264938027,
0.0234276075,
-0.0154448757,
-0.009020295,
-0.0043567708,
-0.0380649157,
0.0476157852,
0.0342945531,
-0.0599552952,
-0.0178868864,
0.0426181629,
-0.0152692469,
0.0291531365,
-0.0029540849,
0.0333135203,
-0.0901877955,
0.0241252016,
-0.0347848907,
0.0589597821,
-0.009927961,
0.0525540076,
0.0451549701,
0.0446291231,
0.0317757949,
-0.0172399543,
0.039465148,
0.0004972306,
-0.0261258855,
0.0430160426,
0.0189655013,
-0.0701246262,
-0.0226230025,
0.0499347448,
-0.0211003181,
0.0092997886,
-0.0030984727,
0.0081076426,
-0.0102350926,
0.0231284313,
-0.0724382699,
-0.0124116596,
0.0059838388,
0.0278926939,
-0.0389461815,
0.0362959206,
0.0208775215,
-0.0500960238,
-0.0329526104,
0.0591434166,
0.0088601522,
-0.0046780859,
-0.0304457769,
-0.0249542333,
-0.0220478419,
-0.0301926769,
0.0017000645,
0.035855867,
0.0207752734,
-0.0103570698,
-0.0487318709,
-0.0414917581,
0.0568211637,
0.014534926,
0.0251371227,
0.0111418283,
-0.0184357632,
-0.0115771908,
0.0070034736,
0.0449414141,
0.0065079648,
-0.0563260727,
-0.0381866023,
0.0161227956,
-0.0472648367,
-0.0530259535,
-0.0104472023,
0.0051052296,
-0.0088771107,
-0.0018683205,
-0.0076017007,
-0.0523995236,
0.047890529,
0.0019991586,
0.0210522283,
-0.039640151,
-0.066879034,
-0.0419599041,
-0.0193409938,
-0.0080425357,
0.0069773104,
-0.0155744655,
-0.0120963231,
-0.0558757968,
-0.0119287241,
0.0060886787,
-0.0743891671,
-0.0469905995,
-0.0459816009,
-0.0293841343,
-0.0060662422,
-0.0037642396,
-0.0070786788,
0.0252059307,
-0.023069771,
-0.0683617666,
-0.0112802163,
-0.0174265988,
0.0361789651,
-0.0552216768,
-0.0004151078,
-0.0235806573,
0.0128013352,
-0.0239360128,
-0.0153253684,
-0.0078698946,
0.0752051547,
-0.0014502496,
0.0281371772,
-0.0030144968,
-0.0481167138,
0.0015201678,
0.025399901,
0.0108151399,
0.0317602344,
0.0364163481,
0.0305501651,
-0.0082889395,
0.052701287,
0.0089981845,
0.0251219273,
-0.0303780083,
-0.03019109,
0.0306127146,
-0.0287681501,
0.075512819,
0.0058352244,
-0.0114200907,
0.0100196088,
0.0503084473,
0.040510904,
-0.0322976746,
-0.0114705302,
0.0440611541,
-0.0158325415,
-0.0034517851,
0.048979748,
-0.0417769179,
-0.0347773209,
-0.0265052784,
-0.0245328881,
0.0037696436,
0.001239587,
-0.0070146043,
-0.0426778644,
-0.0081524132,
0.0469781086,
0.0486853682,
0.0346894972,
0.0383185409,
-0.0393433161,
-0.1407923251,
-0.0028771765,
0.0697176307,
-0.0545709841,
-0.0472636074,
-0.0604935624,
-0.0224736519,
-0.0215185098,
0.0315824226,
-0.0298558678,
-0.0042593917,
-0.0657053664,
0.0529671311,
-0.0512144305,
-0.0448726378,
-0.0254367031,
-0.0177975036,
0.059891127,
0.0220973026,
0.0271441545,
-0.0256630816,
-0.0359484144,
0.0521438122,
0.0031277016,
-0.0059013413,
-0.0456386618,
0.0090714134,
0.0325783119,
-0.0197076835,
0.0678905845,
-0.0141577171,
-0.0126665449,
-0.016205702,
0.0140967043,
0.0664889142,
0.0305284634,
-0.0066867825,
0.0689653084,
0.0191325061,
0.0395047814,
0.0397173874,
0.0174851157,
0.0042205942,
-0.0154918218,
0.0137294345,
0.027833119,
-0.044430837,
-0.0075484384,
0.0357872061,
-0.0461672172,
-0.0822329447,
-0.039863199,
-0.0197602399,
-0.0049774568,
0.0499775037,
0.0462351032,
0.0353904329,
0.0056851055,
0.0249802489,
-0.0290895104,
-0.0402156264,
-0.0477873348,
0.0329009816,
-0.0786258653,
-0.0438895002,
-0.025931133,
-0.0354252681,
0.017026294,
-0.0093621034,
-0.0498891436,
-0.0520116985,
0.0075199301,
-0.0162037518,
0.0201262552,
0.0583675541,
-0.029462155,
-0.0194035396,
0.0729602501,
0.0181566551,
-0.0273362454,
-0.0025301781,
0.0813058242,
-0.0073666899,
0.0063650464,
0.0195672531,
-0.0337055512,
0.0068337996,
-0.0086516738,
0.0130185215,
-0.0456428267,
-0.0607097894,
-0.0291600581,
0.0448496453,
0.0263392031,
-0.0262523349,
-0.0229181685,
-0.0452111438,
0.0223165117,
0.0070121209,
0.0834128857,
-0.0187180769,
-0.0334678516,
0.0490643047,
0.0101979664,
-0.001993523,
-0.015381135,
0.0105786417,
-0.0356851295,
0.0386577472,
0.0521968193,
0.0117534446,
0.0510197654,
0.0132326381,
0.0235175062,
-0.0152764125,
0.0334459916,
0.0384498984,
0.010298036,
-0.0070484029,
-0.0373807959,
-0.0402673855,
-0.0072688316,
0.0240706466,
-0.0222525354,
0.0036681767,
-0.0457709469,
-0.0297728125,
-0.0063898256,
0.0227475297,
0.0028611643,
0.1301073134,
-0.004601276,
0.0277311318,
-0.0473906435,
0.0358872376,
-0.0442069322,
0.0009158787,
0.0081317062,
-0.0164128486,
0.0082519418,
0.0565440282,
0.0484769382,
0.0110848248,
0.0246382896,
-0.0588319898,
0.0204538908,
-0.0287067369,
-0.0388160869,
0.036428038,
-0.0202916637,
-0.0356611833,
-0.0193336997,
-0.0104682185,
-0.1092644483,
0.0267723668,
-0.0129555939,
0.0248448737,
0.0045273136,
-0.0111022256,
0.0112144295,
-0.0082230829,
0.0760563761,
-0.0108659603,
-0.0212764721,
0.0300817564,
0.0008065764,
0.0320119821,
-6.05718831e-33,
-0.0275207218,
0.018267164,
0.0033306519,
0.0227140915,
-0.0316273831,
0.0120205507,
-0.031159658,
0.0133229569,
-0.0145973451,
-0.0146703571,
0.014812435,
-0.0104448227,
0.0426958613,
-0.0006439125,
-0.0137133189,
0.0418532267,
0.0733315572,
0.0180551633,
0.0139692491,
0.0185924824,
0.041571822,
0.0798015073,
0.0406504981,
-0.0467064381,
0.000149874,
0.0543625653,
0.0183394365,
-0.0309844855,
0.0404614098,
0.0380949043,
-0.0078307465,
0.0663118735,
-0.0144377919,
0.0171903074,
-0.0271310471,
0.0177333038,
-0.1148077846,
-0.0275704935,
0.0022592284,
0.0835459381,
0.0282427743,
-0.0089637712,
0.0550870635,
-0.0189901926,
-0.0257410742,
-0.0042012185,
0.002048186,
-0.0475330576,
-0.0513127521,
-0.0228246208,
-0.0450092815,
0.0262555704,
0.0304143261,
0.0058879089,
0.0754748955,
0.0114733865,
-0.0417940356,
-0.0583241396,
-0.0789079443,
0.0395676978,
-0.0447542965,
0.0294698998,
0.0360395871,
0.0313906409,
-0.0452474244,
-0.0053673787,
0.0729456246,
-0.0900755748,
0.0890424028,
0.0033387649,
0.0612343289,
0.0234245323,
-0.0066149575,
0.0539660752,
0.0203694217,
-0.0729212314,
-0.0523397774,
-0.0020442049,
0.0003253922,
0.0047848541,
-0.0026660559,
0.0201403797,
-0.0192615204,
-0.0041387794,
-0.0255732704,
-0.0285353884,
-0.0357879885,
-0.0300427414,
0.0288344566,
-0.0015447651,
-0.0159118995,
0.0237273108,
0.0833914876,
-0.0097828517,
-0.0170540325,
-0.0044154646,
0.0219763387,
-0.0267173816,
-0.0313296728,
0.0059535396,
-0.0530268326,
-0.0843564272,
0.0024348164,
0.0450192876,
0.0104164248,
-0.0397212468,
0.0104916748,
0.0477433279,
-0.079674691,
-0.0059475978,
-0.0326321572,
-0.0022207727,
0.009310985,
0.0282353926,
0.0584648103,
-0.0322470739,
0.0040581319,
0.0218744501,
-0.0244645886,
0.0234787166,
0.0226895902,
0.0086454889,
-0.0114929741,
0.047822576,
-0.0568315014,
0.0189068709,
0.0050601582,
-0.0116721392,
0.0109919561,
0.0196658596,
-0.0230614636,
-0.0096903266,
2.787e-7,
0.0051293741,
-0.0184037425,
0.0168686304,
-0.0026755915,
-0.0097009195,
-0.0205881149,
-0.0535414815,
0.0235503484,
-0.0192268994,
0.0152239911,
0.0061271917,
0.0205776244,
0.0876309723,
0.0292870607,
-0.0472840779,
-0.0332272947,
0.0154167693,
0.0269650575,
-0.007602605,
0.0425213315,
0.0279133413,
0.0519801565,
-0.0098767038,
-0.0593748204,
-0.023401117,
-0.0296703074,
0.0570347011,
-0.050506644,
0.0036522551,
-0.0366829261,
-0.0065220981,
0.0111464923,
-0.0254207738,
0.0145155713,
-0.0466930047,
0.0172633398,
0.0377480127,
-0.0072519574,
-0.0063803196,
-0.02973965,
0.0245988462,
0.0379137471,
-0.0374359749,
-0.0140253166,
0.0252075084,
0.0288175195,
-0.0216772705,
-0.0184712857,
-0.0125264628,
0.0126945386,
0.01206988,
-0.0190459583,
-0.0345182605,
-0.0204151534,
0.0315468051,
-0.0026457857,
-0.0426094569,
0.0069411397,
0.0090660909,
0.0367840528,
-0.0133976182,
-0.0636562183,
-0.0201694947,
-0.0093439147,
-0.0046906201,
0.0162322484,
0.0108373063,
2.108885538e-34,
0.0172080081,
-0.0470512286,
0.0444038063,
-0.0023878927,
-0.0224453676,
-0.0519057848,
0.020889001,
0.0281784181,
-0.0235968661,
-0.0122785624,
-0.0457270183
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03303v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03303v1 | Dyport: Dynamic Importance-based Hypothesis Generation Benchmarking Technique | 2023-12-06T06:07:50 | 2023-12-06T06:07:50 | Ilya Tyagin, Ilya Safro | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | This paper presents a novel benchmarking framework Dyport for evaluating
biomedical hypothesis generation systems. Utilizing curated datasets, our
approach tests these systems under realistic conditions, enhancing the
relevance of our evaluations. We integrate knowledge from the curated databases
into a dynamic graph, accompanied by a method to quantify discovery importance.
This not only assesses hypothesis accuracy but also their potential impact in
biomedical research which significantly extends traditional link prediction
benchmarks. Applicability of our benchmarking process is demonstrated on
several link prediction systems applied on biomedical semantic knowledge
graphs. Being flexible, our benchmarking system is designed for broad
application in hypothesis generation quality verification, aiming to expand the
scope of scientific discovery within the biomedical research community.
Availability and implementation: Dyport framework is fully open-source. All
code and datasets are available at: https://github.com/IlyaTyagin/Dyport | [
-0.0148262139,
0.0064021419,
-0.0065343557,
-0.0433926433,
-0.0091196354,
0.001997523,
-0.0068890797,
0.0293594077,
0.0578182526,
0.0141948285,
0.020819813,
0.0062998845,
0.0206738692,
0.054719016,
0.0039709532,
-0.0076183258,
0.0455899425,
0.0612110309,
-0.0135423904,
-0.0351414345,
-0.042736344,
-0.0167486127,
-0.0185269266,
0.0048582582,
0.0155651644,
-0.000277473,
0.0229934808,
0.0215690378,
0.0498764366,
-0.1014112756,
-0.0386950076,
0.0321024209,
-0.0452701636,
0.035460975,
0.0000020427,
-0.0830956772,
-0.0332209542,
0.0336450152,
-0.0031060274,
-0.0249989685,
0.0289664548,
-0.0053433967,
0.0367303118,
-0.0186803881,
-0.0011981243,
-0.023099754,
0.0159092657,
-0.029116556,
-0.0281396024,
0.0057716365,
-0.0055107973,
0.0140748592,
0.0516601056,
-0.0338690095,
0.0667560548,
0.0045566456,
0.0513494126,
0.0617249049,
0.0163901169,
-0.0538141951,
0.035930533,
0.0251169279,
-0.0197666064,
0.0178213026,
0.0394329093,
0.0268788822,
-0.0219958629,
-0.019735761,
0.0323654674,
0.0792563334,
0.0233183727,
-0.040707618,
0.0438768156,
0.001858006,
-0.0106425276,
0.0889415741,
-0.0453871675,
-0.0213727634,
-0.0418573841,
-0.0292335544,
0.0309412014,
0.0302072465,
0.0705574378,
-0.0064869942,
0.0034972392,
0.0789799318,
-0.0074318745,
-0.0006796209,
0.0196491592,
-0.0067916834,
-0.0121875359,
-0.0503220148,
-0.0032591238,
-0.0327912681,
-0.0162296928,
-0.0080781737,
0.0699100271,
-0.0257528089,
0.0832845569,
-0.0260487292,
-0.0135924891,
-0.0363784283,
0.0447110087,
0.0119258007,
-0.0375666097,
-0.0358483158,
-0.0474625044,
0.0273202881,
-0.0021897969,
0.0078216763,
-0.1053257883,
0.0091247326,
0.0454565063,
0.0607090518,
0.0212069042,
0.0107846176,
-0.0612373836,
0.0357200317,
-0.0451922826,
0.0022188488,
-0.0343493968,
0.0288980771,
-0.0069591342,
0.0240968,
-0.0649312511,
-0.0282276124,
0.006159096,
0.0204647221,
-0.036236085,
-0.032619942,
0.016499497,
-0.021915812,
0.0301285088,
0.0252874196,
-0.0006041406,
0.0561974272,
0.0428227894,
-0.0241583288,
0.0124090007,
-0.0985227451,
0.0022982941,
-0.028342912,
0.0090799583,
-0.0665198565,
-0.0120489988,
0.0384960435,
0.0078885052,
0.0022135007,
-0.0101464968,
-0.0090206917,
-0.0351250842,
0.0261762366,
-0.0720127597,
-0.0214165151,
0.0051910356,
0.0096034175,
-0.0265694708,
0.0068067713,
-0.0106594795,
0.0211691838,
0.027591927,
0.045913998,
-0.0315261781,
-0.0544755235,
0.0262254681,
-0.0092353709,
-0.014926929,
0.0245529469,
0.0132356072,
0.0642695352,
-0.0586220808,
-0.0071267472,
-0.0519160889,
0.0191055089,
0.013879545,
0.029175017,
0.0563881882,
-0.0158311594,
0.0183135923,
-0.0376167484,
-0.0104922438,
-0.0231920592,
-0.0076750829,
0.0351469256,
-0.0171045177,
0.003872352,
0.0088501135,
-0.0104531692,
0.0265469309,
-0.0260519106,
-0.0124601629,
0.0291825011,
-0.0369003341,
-0.0128424261,
0.0267241113,
-0.0160497706,
0.0052253613,
0.043967396,
0.0414578617,
0.0061260257,
-0.0084915394,
-0.0085329637,
0.0142824333,
0.0505550131,
0.0586554036,
-0.068795599,
-0.0350220501,
0.0120828552,
0.0046607838,
-0.0183922686,
-0.0038561882,
-0.0272730216,
-0.0072070365,
0.022460429,
-0.019640673,
-0.029882567,
0.0185070243,
-0.0172995981,
0.0098020481,
0.0694662035,
-0.0226625539,
-0.0999636427,
0.0086136647,
-0.0021380486,
-0.0084572174,
0.0587908924,
0.0264276434,
-0.0569131151,
0.0539287515,
0.0302749816,
-0.0361237824,
0.0240185224,
0.0802830458,
-0.0144895036,
-0.0529882461,
0.0025456063,
0.0472967103,
-0.053072542,
0.0235204324,
-0.103069827,
-0.0007085856,
-0.004122538,
-0.0430673324,
-0.0328484476,
0.0543807596,
0.0090803122,
-0.0017157658,
-0.0202023629,
-0.0219622906,
-0.0558255874,
0.0256833993,
-0.0177754071,
0.0338401124,
-0.0171713084,
0.0325263999,
0.0284802318,
-0.0241044499,
0.0554062426,
-0.0335930213,
0.0113549503,
-0.0087426417,
-0.0097481459,
-0.0218647663,
0.0301313773,
-0.0406398512,
-0.0298906043,
0.0313647538,
-0.0149607696,
0.0156185152,
0.0274547674,
0.0264588203,
-0.0056929523,
-0.0179692805,
0.0033508688,
0.0002527075,
0.0070504448,
0.0067496225,
-0.0102056731,
-0.0000211418,
0.0543307289,
0.0169630237,
-0.0270802751,
-0.0171781089,
-0.018959336,
-0.0284547899,
0.0888683796,
0.0466170758,
-0.0206315666,
0.056686841,
0.0031239041,
-0.0569797568,
-0.0276282877,
-0.0146448463,
0.0369152501,
0.0193220153,
0.0355002135,
-0.0102752717,
-0.0149932113,
-0.0143576432,
-0.034126237,
0.066240266,
0.0204183552,
-0.0217184648,
-0.015951179,
-0.0847142413,
0.0584566742,
0.0082125347,
-0.0565719716,
0.0038266929,
-0.0218922794,
0.0361835212,
-0.0145599954,
-0.0410179533,
0.001252131,
-0.0069412352,
-0.0409655832,
-0.0349234082,
0.0156193674,
0.0040126038,
0.0392143503,
-0.0041519436,
-0.0589589998,
0.0782263875,
0.0080467016,
0.0662587583,
-0.0192322657,
0.0246956144,
-0.01617641,
0.0260424651,
0.0174508654,
0.0192897301,
0.0388920419,
0.0405560844,
-0.000371063,
0.0134133771,
0.0264680125,
-0.0403072312,
-0.0166882649,
-0.0281431414,
0.0155074364,
0.0743442997,
0.0091352602,
-0.0127263842,
0.0561860316,
-0.0332150459,
0.0121736098,
0.0077385576,
-0.0045985882,
0.0019630608,
-0.0188208669,
0.0281397812,
0.0049818009,
0.0135508757,
-0.0392312706,
0.0047003319,
-0.0268016979,
0.0090701459,
-0.0576154962,
0.0456790626,
-0.0041646035,
0.0405196771,
0.0335212871,
0.0063809813,
0.0008735341,
-0.0147605268,
-0.0123745427,
-0.0500363521,
-0.0103191948,
0.0027568403,
-0.0026781419,
-0.0366452858,
0.0079921847,
0.0081941281,
0.0563497767,
0.0356654413,
-0.0521652102,
0.0339171663,
0.0100569455,
0.0079209153,
0.0232902914,
0.0072432756,
-0.1074906364,
-0.0235847738,
-0.0242128931,
0.0172017477,
-0.0468404032,
-0.0776719227,
0.0091859587,
-0.0276867505,
0.033094015,
-0.0349708237,
-0.0205890331,
0.0235500168,
-0.1270573437,
0.0075993193,
-0.048431579,
-0.0880832449,
-0.0099193314,
0.0240215175,
0.0114217093,
-0.0318146944,
-0.0571653657,
-0.0624909289,
0.0306132287,
-0.0280243699,
0.0073772147,
-0.0035665487,
0.0248631537,
-0.0030776304,
0.0026653439,
0.0057808519,
0.0154325087,
0.0146307973,
-0.0345001929,
0.0927293599,
0.0346138217,
0.0274639465,
-0.0599226467,
0.0153438132,
-0.0254379734,
-0.0153875984,
-0.0168752633,
0.1045246124,
-0.0125206877,
-0.0335592479,
-0.0517564081,
0.0037765163,
-0.0067100716,
0.0653750896,
-0.0059344065,
0.0006117014,
0.0113608884,
0.0212248508,
0.0360535309,
-0.0115953889,
0.0078867264,
0.0233598817,
-0.0200768504,
0.0030196197,
-0.0670847967,
0.0048819343,
-0.0252274442,
-0.0114078168,
-0.0430789255,
0.0443903543,
-0.0217518825,
-0.0511070639,
-0.0995114595,
0.0407821983,
0.0505640693,
0.035106115,
-0.0214716997,
-0.0172951519,
0.0528650507,
-0.0167405829,
-0.0234073494,
0.0472212322,
-0.0196491163,
-0.0190197527,
-0.0435374863,
0.0063639851,
0.016184289,
0.022232309,
-0.0318125822,
-0.0389438942,
0.07873483,
0.0492966101,
0.0002059664,
-0.0275555365,
-0.0228307918,
-0.0401416346,
-0.0146880727,
-0.0029567124,
-0.0250629149,
0.0290842,
0.0092107365,
-0.0198811796,
-0.0005980518,
-0.0309377927,
-0.0111499885,
0.0575649142,
0.0539035164,
-0.0083977832,
-0.0638427511,
-0.016939003,
0.0004743446,
0.0160905775,
0.0082536722,
-0.0078228917,
0.0252972841,
0.0336875692,
0.0073254295,
-0.0064161513,
0.0156692117,
-0.0338580497,
-0.0226724595,
-0.0341982059,
0.003196775,
-0.0027597228,
0.035644874,
0.0595974028,
-0.0084842052,
-0.0051737181,
-0.0368193276,
-0.0464807861,
0.0443935916,
-0.009978476,
-0.0434910394,
0.0280494131,
0.0024057718,
-0.0066064983,
0.0177047867,
-0.0696671829,
0.019702347,
-0.0177378561,
0.0030151594,
0.0175400265,
0.0965808406,
0.054792162,
-0.0297629051,
-0.0128045641,
-0.0307013318,
0.0242820382,
-0.0375670753,
-0.0079165995,
-0.015557264,
0.0192823801,
-0.0339109115,
0.0296560265,
0.0732039288,
0.0151969716,
0.0385286175,
-0.0160135422,
-0.0555263422,
-0.0309201349,
0.0022076129,
-0.0354309008,
0.0490792729,
-0.0265418105,
0.0184838399,
-0.0884094685,
-0.0349936932,
0.0900298953,
0.0250016917,
0.023027068,
0.026247872,
0.0359719247,
0.0070617348,
0.0322922356,
-0.0495155342,
0.0148154795,
-0.0158151984,
-0.0611864179,
-0.0509281754,
0.0178539306,
-6.200390338e-33,
0.0658553988,
-0.0351532772,
-0.0294299517,
-0.0200177897,
0.0082082916,
0.0317466743,
-0.0643694028,
-0.0267884489,
0.0120261963,
0.0750237033,
0.0141590964,
0.0163041987,
-0.0183923002,
-0.0231579952,
-0.01994876,
0.0279404018,
0.01143461,
0.0307020769,
-0.0099342652,
0.0282391459,
0.0598188676,
0.0326353759,
0.0237915032,
-0.0257089958,
-0.0457742028,
0.0445467494,
0.0286593605,
0.01300296,
-0.0521816202,
0.0306168254,
-0.0045128777,
0.0354270935,
-0.0125676692,
-0.0406997167,
-0.0063195969,
-0.0784356296,
-0.0352632999,
-0.0192401353,
-0.0146076586,
-0.06724713,
-0.0009297302,
0.0054915547,
0.0028508503,
0.0288851652,
-0.029132409,
-0.043884024,
0.0352684893,
-0.0097433385,
-0.0641983598,
-0.0787792429,
-0.0046368176,
0.0657287166,
-0.0184000749,
0.0411347225,
-0.0064764563,
0.0081391213,
-0.0111601437,
-0.0111472066,
0.0003986963,
0.0494322218,
0.0088841151,
-0.0474957488,
0.0259752907,
-0.0146108894,
0.0290760417,
0.0871445686,
0.0401978604,
0.0245084036,
0.0548409857,
0.0548065193,
-0.0047414363,
0.0698726401,
0.0165127143,
0.0576314293,
0.0149955731,
0.0217379965,
-0.1432468742,
0.0492579825,
-0.0082028424,
-0.0086755175,
0.015471695,
0.0023497802,
-0.0061717499,
-0.0271696355,
-0.0278773457,
0.0232329164,
-0.0105004301,
-0.0179870091,
-0.0222558565,
-0.0224138256,
-0.0470096283,
0.0523890704,
0.0019946655,
-0.0426053405,
-0.0006361093,
0.0551510863,
-0.0079728356,
0.0123605598,
0.0160035212,
0.0022427866,
-0.0330169015,
-0.0142636066,
0.0364963152,
0.0166021138,
0.0527626909,
-0.027998507,
0.0056195189,
-0.0101470202,
0.0117571801,
0.0142188845,
-0.0061220615,
-0.0278433617,
-0.0064265379,
-0.0587642901,
0.0067152856,
0.0227793194,
-0.0164855588,
0.0102220019,
0.069475852,
0.0521618426,
-0.0090037966,
0.0629039779,
-0.0101264119,
0.0365056954,
-0.0056646112,
-0.0251774713,
-0.0387776382,
0.0022161864,
0.0070313662,
-0.0486312136,
-0.0359366722,
0.0251458734,
2.988e-7,
0.0670065582,
0.0368459448,
-0.0125896921,
0.0173518304,
0.032949239,
-0.0153207975,
-0.0056182537,
0.0034387698,
-0.0204829648,
-0.0367121063,
0.0094067529,
-0.0027588001,
0.0089043528,
0.0154130273,
-0.0427730232,
-0.0322644375,
-0.014264971,
-0.0576043576,
-0.020593103,
0.0025306398,
-0.0352845229,
-0.0223833751,
0.0141294431,
-0.0015908537,
0.0484026819,
-0.0000708373,
0.0153415231,
-0.0108250976,
0.0464642942,
0.0539197139,
0.008986569,
-0.0392981358,
0.0100984797,
0.0589492209,
-0.0194065999,
-0.009786875,
-0.0339965262,
-0.0539604872,
0.0002805458,
0.0065832813,
0.0552163608,
-0.0525706783,
0.0486389026,
-0.0387951843,
0.0362241417,
-0.0465636253,
-0.0567187481,
0.0761569291,
-0.032139875,
0.0037705472,
0.064502649,
0.0263653956,
0.0058579324,
0.0240486395,
-0.0358416475,
0.0444327369,
-0.0436017588,
-0.029383406,
-0.0166568421,
0.0583951771,
-0.0547757819,
-0.0490551814,
0.0327387415,
-0.0242897049,
0.0017129838,
-0.0481243767,
0.0174854584,
2.69310669e-34,
0.044725161,
0.0199917573,
-0.0349000767,
-0.0767952353,
0.0510913245,
-0.0398395509,
-0.0065575503,
-0.0479728021,
0.0116956504,
-0.0528347939,
0.0095357485
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03290v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03290v1 | Can language agents be alternatives to PPO? A Preliminary Empirical Study On OpenAI Gym | 2023-12-06T04:48:26 | 2023-12-06T04:48:26 | Junjie Sheng, Zixiao Huang, Chuyun Shen, Wenhao Li, Yun Hua, Bo Jin, Hongyuan Zha, Xiangfeng Wang | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | The formidable capacity for zero- or few-shot decision-making in language
agents encourages us to pose a compelling question: Can language agents be
alternatives to PPO agents in traditional sequential decision-making tasks? To
investigate this, we first take environments collected in OpenAI Gym as our
testbeds and ground them to textual environments that construct the TextGym
simulator. This allows for straightforward and efficient comparisons between
PPO agents and language agents, given the widespread adoption of OpenAI Gym. To
ensure a fair and effective benchmarking, we introduce $5$ levels of scenario
for accurate domain-knowledge controlling and a unified RL-inspired framework
for language agents. Additionally, we propose an innovative
explore-exploit-guided language (EXE) agent to solve tasks within TextGym.
Through numerical experiments and ablation studies, we extract valuable
insights into the decision-making capabilities of language agents and make a
preliminary evaluation of their potential to be alternatives to PPO in
classical sequential decision-making problems. This paper sheds light on the
performance of language agents and paves the way for future research in this
exciting domain. Our code is publicly available
at~\url{https://github.com/mail-ecnu/Text-Gym-Agents}. | [
0.0432131551,
0.0584032834,
-0.0139518017,
0.0209285058,
-0.0517882891,
-0.0020771043,
0.0134757254,
0.0285900347,
-0.0032956272,
-0.0063101146,
-0.0250302162,
-0.0122769065,
-0.0388670787,
0.043244198,
-0.0359008498,
-0.0799814984,
0.0274975672,
-0.0486957021,
0.0480986871,
-0.0016636509,
-0.0049914336,
-0.0475127362,
-0.0223000124,
0.0668907911,
0.0262529179,
-0.0178680625,
-0.072684668,
-0.0418199711,
0.0260756817,
-0.0154358791,
-0.0201102309,
0.0224791244,
0.0373361297,
0.0401722044,
0.0000021097,
-0.0388985835,
-0.0114275152,
0.0154487593,
-0.0126522565,
-0.0031932415,
0.0332527794,
0.02279534,
-0.0303986687,
-0.0184264407,
-0.0653847232,
-0.0086376574,
0.0606878996,
0.0519858114,
0.0641709268,
0.0960204825,
0.016036788,
0.0283656083,
-0.008611571,
-0.012468935,
0.0085316766,
-0.0897764266,
0.0033529405,
-0.0399206467,
0.0653425306,
-0.0120619722,
-0.0292155482,
0.0020114917,
0.0462655127,
-0.0062811454,
-0.0898720175,
0.0427333489,
-0.0114493715,
-0.019295413,
-0.0297652557,
0.0189315695,
0.0113204308,
0.014975192,
-0.0139622129,
-0.0137423296,
0.0186582524,
-0.0211024769,
0.0035397036,
0.0270181224,
0.0020560885,
0.034644369,
-0.0318103582,
0.0343218558,
0.0108995987,
-0.0013146825,
-0.0207413565,
0.1184997261,
-0.0140559925,
-0.0251241084,
0.0430992432,
0.0259485058,
-0.0116463779,
-0.076317139,
-0.016871471,
0.0471194498,
-0.0727031156,
0.026556449,
-0.0490000769,
-0.0203575902,
-0.0267540831,
-0.0559349954,
0.0247747395,
0.0548485816,
0.0354434401,
0.0035425955,
0.0414486527,
0.0810664892,
-0.0202718507,
0.0257601235,
-0.0095737772,
-0.0166142564,
-0.0474719107,
0.019280415,
-0.0513945892,
0.0367248505,
-0.0121276705,
-0.0381978191,
-0.0488326661,
0.0356557965,
-0.0482053347,
0.0311963018,
-0.016683232,
0.0028124987,
-0.030001536,
-0.0274879038,
-0.1074229553,
-0.0280483272,
-0.0473612025,
-0.0060120104,
0.0088180266,
0.0154607603,
-0.0116200689,
0.0242928956,
-0.023652399,
-0.0414912514,
-0.0306091066,
0.0763563067,
-0.0194095336,
-0.0195509512,
-0.025818307,
-0.0244043134,
-0.0016129372,
-0.0795004219,
-0.0212124437,
-0.0532315858,
0.0094297826,
-0.0102564739,
-0.0437440462,
-0.0732851401,
0.0177781153,
0.0093829827,
-0.0109950248,
0.0408285074,
0.0290836915,
-0.0180255342,
-0.0299434997,
0.0180964265,
-0.0512635373,
0.0931076705,
0.0388714746,
0.0244492721,
0.0079287784,
0.0246021897,
0.0371283367,
0.060343232,
0.0102878045,
0.0285660829,
0.0075534508,
-0.0088295965,
0.0143948002,
0.0368485935,
0.0085660657,
0.0240931697,
-0.0407028757,
0.0073271976,
0.0431286991,
0.003047595,
0.005526437,
0.0150891161,
0.0312458966,
0.0209996235,
-0.0103103416,
0.0253560692,
-0.0492778495,
0.0351587608,
-0.0041018128,
0.0270508323,
-0.0296017118,
0.0140068131,
-0.0120000485,
-0.0638415888,
0.0200181361,
-0.0150156012,
0.0295546893,
0.0090507558,
0.0526492223,
0.0149134099,
-0.0719273016,
0.0078278836,
0.0237509571,
-0.0320500173,
-0.0359103456,
-0.0622780621,
-0.0038037726,
0.0224985182,
0.0436962992,
-0.063827008,
-0.0142484251,
0.0293090008,
-0.0177525952,
0.112401478,
0.0259546395,
0.0032483276,
0.0073332065,
-0.0135580916,
-0.0482250936,
-0.0123593165,
0.0067325933,
0.038745068,
0.0276196133,
0.0449357964,
-0.0538387783,
0.0240525566,
0.0078049651,
0.0358209647,
-0.0233059861,
-0.0291851591,
-0.01365723,
-0.0029285504,
0.0364280827,
-0.0020282462,
-0.024684431,
0.0011890893,
0.014964981,
0.0290977024,
-0.0508886129,
-0.0068305959,
0.0009040421,
-0.0090932986,
0.0541292056,
0.000352442,
-0.0178011879,
0.0153261703,
-0.0419688895,
-0.0113996444,
0.0446911417,
0.039584849,
0.040625535,
-0.0207268,
0.0024954432,
-0.0492730401,
-0.0102244327,
0.0013578406,
0.0829504877,
0.013044782,
-0.0171027575,
0.0549027734,
0.0273492727,
0.0050943429,
-0.0306512509,
-0.0124533866,
0.0152106881,
0.0180301331,
0.0292938966,
0.0492635854,
0.018423114,
-0.0263118967,
-0.0279838834,
-0.0728810653,
0.0010700272,
-0.0191403814,
0.0014233486,
0.0147317238,
-0.0177852158,
-0.0146993147,
-0.0106103215,
-0.0133663351,
0.0326083004,
-0.0097823804,
0.0072057466,
0.0219462961,
0.0317199156,
-0.0265126228,
-0.0552489012,
0.0324663334,
0.0100890659,
-0.0027268117,
-0.0020288567,
-0.0052604116,
-0.0221076235,
0.0537759848,
-0.0313398018,
0.0505673848,
0.0013202658,
-0.033164531,
0.0427654609,
-0.0320551731,
0.0023861844,
0.0226352531,
-0.0207636319,
0.0853485018,
0.0933892876,
-0.0226872694,
-0.040899314,
0.0656167269,
-0.041067373,
-0.0115929879,
-0.0669369325,
0.0219958536,
0.028934963,
0.0706014782,
-0.0043101115,
0.0005352548,
-0.0474729352,
0.0064403932,
-0.0055522094,
-0.0573325828,
0.0092504807,
0.004633259,
-0.0364368744,
0.0390490666,
-0.0227730032,
0.012225192,
0.1077475026,
0.0312325153,
-0.0087931426,
-0.0574790388,
-0.027912179,
-0.0395626649,
0.0537824035,
0.0113623813,
-0.0023135671,
0.0020318592,
0.0179538429,
-0.0320398994,
-0.0385340042,
0.0018251177,
0.0293068253,
0.017676698,
-0.0476488434,
0.0224028975,
0.0067950818,
-0.061199937,
-0.0378168114,
0.0108117051,
-0.0386073105,
0.0109588243,
-0.0199171789,
-0.0390050448,
-0.0761704072,
-0.0077965562,
0.0332646519,
0.014339936,
-0.0347887613,
-0.0277218018,
-0.0203935932,
-0.0058332779,
0.0436048806,
0.0319902338,
-0.0111117102,
-0.0230807718,
0.0514791645,
0.0792409554,
0.0322591364,
-0.0582032204,
-0.0177976061,
-0.0034568345,
-0.0072908858,
-0.0613829643,
0.0089015178,
0.0567105636,
-0.0097972285,
-0.0645195767,
-0.0468168557,
0.0816115141,
0.0388089903,
-0.0278601181,
-0.004638013,
-0.0543044284,
0.0432371348,
-0.0073408769,
0.0615643635,
-0.0481359698,
-0.0286822226,
-0.0050387233,
0.0390787348,
-0.0149754239,
-0.035579145,
0.0052789086,
-0.083123073,
0.041356355,
0.0024018455,
-0.0373802967,
0.012876031,
-0.0033951821,
-0.0027512067,
0.003334614,
0.0092400294,
0.0266949777,
0.0595012493,
-0.0090584094,
-0.0191727784,
0.0252066255,
-0.0017868886,
0.0155949816,
-0.0305972192,
0.0025567936,
0.1024967581,
0.031120833,
-0.0215610396,
-0.004736057,
-0.0238494445,
0.0328764431,
0.0047289804,
0.0170138367,
0.0180827547,
0.0215019099,
-0.0090368576,
-0.0052496069,
0.02259285,
-0.0161469746,
-0.0309301838,
0.0371592641,
0.0951600298,
-0.0281599425,
-0.0616668873,
-0.0251259916,
-0.0176844876,
0.0417768322,
0.0285082217,
-0.0281666033,
-0.0673720986,
-0.0981750116,
-0.0602655411,
-0.0505808666,
-0.0581431054,
-0.0539859124,
-0.0001208313,
0.0016436592,
-0.0180380605,
-0.0592072867,
-0.074263975,
0.0448300242,
0.0329297893,
-0.0124099441,
-0.0094872788,
0.0066024908,
0.020239491,
0.0354102775,
-0.0730824172,
-0.0261431038,
0.0289978255,
-0.0507288165,
-0.0148458369,
0.0171930231,
-0.0089238165,
-0.0040405374,
0.0147328526,
-0.0260107107,
-0.0603546873,
0.0045923153,
0.0741408169,
0.0324169584,
0.0026632708,
0.0002539772,
-0.012858903,
0.0442743041,
0.0326341949,
0.0032195461,
0.0346524417,
0.036016915,
-0.0094731934,
0.0206278637,
0.0437656939,
-0.0585236847,
0.0062487437,
-0.0020269842,
0.0418991297,
-0.0340442955,
0.0135372933,
0.0315328054,
-0.0431394018,
-0.0117740268,
0.0018769398,
-0.0344688445,
-0.0115469219,
0.0201148503,
-0.0316963829,
-0.0330530107,
-0.047088109,
-0.0088631259,
-0.0031924348,
0.0066300104,
0.0702301562,
0.012969018,
0.0125794969,
-0.0098932208,
0.033808548,
-0.0106170895,
0.1029914171,
0.0248076506,
0.0344347171,
0.0376595929,
-0.0032408638,
0.0035182361,
0.0197231751,
0.0507562086,
0.0048981691,
0.0700021535,
0.0415499248,
-0.0125762466,
-0.016818542,
-0.0197746437,
-0.0718331039,
-0.0348983034,
0.0666421875,
0.0391441435,
0.0581522547,
0.0346226618,
0.014630137,
-0.0835817084,
0.0080991732,
-0.0026865783,
-0.0123552624,
-0.0108360434,
-0.0516059399,
0.0215852391,
0.0207876638,
0.0244644526,
0.0127712125,
0.0803801194,
0.0256629232,
0.0603002086,
-0.0098599773,
-0.0165050961,
-0.0377120078,
-0.0590648316,
0.0093362117,
0.0361350738,
-0.0162039734,
-0.0483116172,
-0.0836162046,
-0.0429714844,
-0.0253135003,
0.0418790355,
-0.0263672564,
-0.0525632799,
0.0404357128,
-0.0016698965,
0.0059723468,
-0.0005067994,
-0.0445936956,
-0.0090323845,
-0.0226730909,
0.0059521631,
-0.0305933841,
-5.58900691e-33,
-0.052263692,
-0.0457692593,
0.0621060841,
0.0154863345,
0.0193978976,
-0.040417552,
-0.0447503626,
0.0081562698,
-0.0008247949,
0.03930768,
-0.0089414287,
-0.0042395052,
0.0045113261,
-0.002418983,
0.0050104694,
0.0076705343,
0.0097443955,
-0.0316128135,
-0.0310325641,
-0.0155444052,
0.0229094643,
0.0049153906,
-0.0125202723,
-0.0278054271,
0.0496361926,
0.0111709023,
-0.0356646962,
0.0019979032,
-0.0285915062,
0.0831944197,
-0.002076911,
0.014107259,
-0.0232389346,
-0.0291255433,
-0.0285892319,
0.0005836997,
-0.0193004347,
-0.0549657233,
-0.0282529108,
0.0074597299,
-0.0322361439,
-0.0133687751,
-0.0162986927,
0.0274358392,
-0.0403805152,
-0.0010799374,
0.0072247121,
-0.0101275397,
-0.0083204564,
0.0081322426,
-0.0903892592,
-0.0065033501,
0.0142657794,
-0.0123995868,
0.0544059388,
-0.0187821239,
-0.0125859939,
-0.017207548,
-0.0598845556,
0.0072050639,
0.0256150421,
-0.0149255451,
0.0470184311,
0.0089717126,
-0.0101001402,
0.0473133884,
0.0245532952,
-0.0069521503,
-0.0009572253,
0.0382595211,
0.0114726163,
0.0588382483,
0.0378079414,
0.047455553,
-0.011826816,
0.0310985465,
-0.0216915179,
0.0193964262,
0.0467345566,
0.0260480009,
0.0143277133,
0.0331697203,
-0.031876035,
-0.0276551712,
-0.0194448624,
-0.0023735343,
-0.0200183,
-0.0709354654,
0.028744908,
-0.0061249188,
0.0026987859,
-0.0535278469,
0.028662093,
-0.0218441226,
-0.0266384576,
0.0417532548,
-0.0455203243,
0.0583653376,
0.0038305325,
0.01709719,
-0.061599873,
-0.0174636897,
-0.017942477,
-0.0232875478,
0.0012973965,
0.0107579352,
-0.0424511693,
0.0485625789,
-0.0321099386,
0.015833769,
-0.0376590304,
0.0193809047,
0.0714814812,
0.0193209592,
-0.0148927923,
-0.0375158116,
-0.0060624708,
0.0449591465,
0.0055030501,
-0.0556293391,
-0.0037480926,
0.0397799499,
-0.0052115549,
-0.0100174565,
-0.0063792812,
-0.022543611,
-0.050657779,
0.0452458523,
0.0084798308,
-0.0550851822,
-0.0055291308,
0.0378935784,
2.773e-7,
0.0183361396,
0.0238545667,
0.0359253287,
0.0524534732,
0.0190228149,
0.08370433,
-0.0546414703,
0.0131179309,
-0.0068880292,
0.0148949549,
0.0504460335,
0.0434065424,
-0.0003500411,
0.0190989505,
-0.084073998,
0.0009311648,
0.0179074686,
-0.0282668024,
-0.0732362121,
-0.0379544981,
0.0419565253,
0.0420225337,
0.052606158,
0.0096973395,
-0.009912068,
-0.0412851907,
0.0558753647,
0.0076853903,
0.0321232192,
0.0309039112,
-0.0433150046,
-0.0186779983,
-0.0421402603,
-0.0294395238,
0.0331487246,
0.0393416248,
-0.0230456311,
0.0679454282,
0.0158344954,
-0.0453118458,
0.0063766977,
-0.0005504143,
0.0235219132,
-0.027540708,
0.054283727,
-0.0572657585,
-0.0194331836,
0.0014410905,
0.0306902342,
-0.0222629234,
-0.0226257183,
-0.0153406011,
-0.0350323319,
0.0076176408,
-0.0218921714,
0.0129686706,
-0.0017685443,
-0.0283159781,
-0.0261494219,
-0.0057801418,
-0.016064506,
-0.0258477256,
-0.0477871671,
0.0541746691,
0.0079410346,
-0.0638075769,
0.0110554574,
2.498082534e-34,
0.007579939,
-0.0127643691,
-0.0134523921,
0.0570497848,
0.0205161218,
0.0210962575,
0.0096378336,
0.0304125212,
0.0542970598,
-0.0134987021,
-0.02749102
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.06668v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.06668v1 | Evaluating Self-supervised Speech Models on a Taiwanese Hokkien Corpus | 2023-12-06T01:32:20 | 2023-12-06T01:32:20 | Yi-Hui Chou, Kalvin Chang, Meng-Ju Wu, Winston Ou, Alice Wen-Hsin Bi, Carol Yang, Bryan Y. Chen, Rong-Wei Pai, Po-Yen Yeh, Jo-Peng Chiang, Iu-Tshian Phoann, Winnie Chang, Chenxuan Cui, Noel Chen, Jiatong Shi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Taiwanese Hokkien is declining in use and status due to a language shift
towards Mandarin in Taiwan. This is partly why it is a low resource language in
NLP and speech research today. To ensure that the state of the art in speech
processing does not leave Taiwanese Hokkien behind, we contribute a 1.5-hour
dataset of Taiwanese Hokkien to ML-SUPERB's hidden set. Evaluating ML-SUPERB's
suite of self-supervised learning (SSL) speech representations on our dataset,
we find that model size does not consistently determine performance. In fact,
certain smaller models outperform larger ones. Furthermore, linguistic
alignment between pretraining data and the target language plays a crucial
role. | [
-0.0127919316,
0.0236749798,
0.0070308773,
0.0176702142,
-0.0120738903,
-0.0063921008,
0.0457479171,
-0.0103019644,
0.0170886647,
-0.0085149268,
-0.1169318706,
-0.0061187721,
0.0202990491,
0.0178566054,
-0.0031831316,
-0.0413109809,
0.0378266424,
-0.0213301256,
0.0012822601,
-0.0392409526,
0.0266890079,
0.0021160913,
-0.0027416109,
0.0534760058,
-0.0029115307,
-0.0297040548,
-0.0234329551,
0.0299789533,
-0.0064136735,
-0.0171462148,
0.0041606491,
0.0333795324,
0.0171774011,
0.0451982915,
0.0000019704,
-0.0300283525,
0.0035071524,
-0.0260868631,
-0.0678875372,
0.0946162567,
0.0126982471,
-0.0045171552,
-0.0348945595,
0.0189643428,
-0.028592797,
-0.0515342243,
0.032070253,
0.0461419672,
0.0500329509,
0.0617765635,
-0.0123984292,
-0.020996755,
-0.0100955609,
-0.0250804424,
-0.0435099676,
-0.0137539292,
-0.0018842689,
-0.0273270383,
-0.0358861908,
-0.0519156344,
-0.0134409983,
0.0400377177,
-0.0355025455,
0.0055031157,
0.001618613,
-0.0073134312,
-0.0321164429,
-0.0107493708,
0.0110705197,
0.0426161923,
-0.0084327562,
-0.0354835764,
-0.0288577527,
0.0011724408,
-0.0192428678,
-0.0105783697,
-0.0190935582,
-0.0052701817,
0.0525053293,
0.0213327818,
0.0208416898,
0.0384606197,
0.0246018991,
-0.001007522,
-0.0343289189,
0.0047037131,
-0.0031099145,
-0.0318930224,
-0.0358977877,
-0.015716752,
0.013251272,
0.0155367972,
0.0097599244,
0.0004420694,
0.0172861405,
-0.0033192008,
-0.0014433772,
0.0188561231,
-0.0054797442,
-0.0658461377,
0.0072470955,
0.0465783514,
-0.0536918379,
0.0077293701,
-0.01304881,
0.0412860326,
0.006372239,
-0.0000604155,
-0.0628881678,
0.0092194406,
-0.0177349616,
-0.0022284654,
-0.0879897699,
0.041833438,
-0.0044224523,
-0.0194168501,
-0.0557996631,
-0.0065393518,
-0.0159606375,
0.0145488,
0.0265009701,
-0.0248366259,
-0.0700588003,
0.0126828179,
-0.0068480745,
0.0477961712,
-0.0057918094,
0.0428480767,
-0.0276849773,
-0.0578152649,
0.0040717809,
0.0146917962,
0.0191058014,
0.0006711975,
-0.0044014705,
0.0209894478,
0.0191709828,
-0.0219786894,
-0.0563520789,
0.0352868699,
-0.0484013967,
-0.036325708,
-0.0380289182,
-0.0592859723,
0.0048630922,
-0.0088105295,
0.0527314581,
-0.0372301936,
-0.0101290205,
-0.0519193783,
0.0369497836,
0.0162670147,
-0.0004135189,
0.0564200543,
0.0294651538,
-0.0281667355,
0.0231193583,
0.065604873,
0.0419087298,
-0.0219086781,
0.0574657321,
-0.0903621539,
-0.0063866707,
0.0268053208,
0.013811144,
0.0115573872,
-0.0363099948,
0.0132111246,
-0.0260043815,
0.0146051003,
0.0266885888,
-0.0089525925,
0.018169092,
-0.0230162852,
0.0644289106,
0.0775441974,
0.0261585899,
0.024464203,
0.0088060554,
0.0213133041,
0.0105708838,
0.0090005482,
0.0066542909,
-0.0103864921,
-0.031345848,
0.0215268265,
0.0138765266,
0.0138712348,
-0.0608189851,
-0.0563136227,
-0.0104608005,
-0.026658114,
-0.0376472622,
0.0166894551,
0.0526510701,
0.0200831797,
0.000340173,
0.0390475094,
0.0296899546,
-0.0449537039,
0.0143481409,
-0.0244598817,
-0.0084632691,
0.0582735874,
-0.0171268973,
-0.0027160295,
0.0021340623,
-0.0263956673,
-0.0538803115,
0.0169323459,
0.0391259603,
0.0119796805,
0.025837142,
-0.0183357242,
0.0048444094,
0.0330383591,
0.0152301397,
0.0299539957,
-0.0428354107,
0.0329911038,
0.0057617757,
-0.0476883873,
-0.0372787677,
-0.0012811406,
-0.0154399453,
-0.0297444649,
0.0412343293,
0.0430497341,
0.0618530363,
0.0437578,
-0.0511882789,
0.010205118,
0.0229163617,
-0.0006026665,
0.0111286687,
0.0471797213,
-0.0535548739,
-0.0262561906,
0.0426352657,
-0.0036965299,
0.0439477749,
0.0616574921,
-0.0138884708,
-0.0720751286,
0.0541134514,
0.0303798188,
0.0119052855,
-0.0848974288,
0.039676521,
-0.0216143169,
0.0531528294,
0.0247041695,
0.0172555614,
0.0584979765,
-0.0158840884,
-0.0001733258,
0.0026112362,
0.0503659174,
-0.0864282623,
-0.0465555638,
0.000783274,
-0.0422066487,
0.0321635567,
-0.0083631594,
-0.0448308066,
0.0183052476,
0.0153395068,
-0.0761104226,
-0.0236172993,
-0.0486569218,
-0.0364341475,
0.0065008518,
0.0193443801,
-0.0260133836,
-0.0396419503,
-0.0072897347,
-0.0341727771,
0.0022766627,
-0.007922966,
-0.032513503,
-0.021068735,
0.0312663652,
-0.0323584266,
-0.0135179851,
0.028963536,
-0.007083538,
-0.0481445901,
-0.0578668453,
-0.0165764149,
0.0053545018,
-0.0106626544,
0.0038575025,
0.0184975937,
-0.0764426738,
-0.0324316584,
-0.0228670873,
0.0208734125,
0.0440702364,
-0.0064022103,
-0.0031913482,
0.0580823012,
0.0088594053,
-0.0480917916,
-0.0048576132,
-0.0054159118,
-0.0054957154,
-0.0538686551,
0.0181405582,
-0.0482340865,
0.0748457536,
0.044905968,
0.0091243777,
-0.0443802401,
-0.0734431297,
-0.0481828339,
-0.0046396991,
-0.0023715163,
0.0178385377,
-0.0344502851,
0.0531601049,
0.0341691338,
-0.0319889076,
0.0384067148,
-0.03628885,
-0.0299790483,
-0.0544999875,
-0.0510950498,
-0.0167119503,
0.0305763464,
-0.0040585203,
0.0070347027,
0.0082244091,
-0.0227054209,
-0.007332827,
0.0276781246,
0.0279614143,
-0.0224860646,
0.0169630945,
0.0271103755,
0.0231797434,
-0.0253475867,
-0.0249027833,
-0.036552541,
-0.0631194338,
-0.0386905484,
-0.022965882,
0.0073112003,
0.01409698,
0.020582106,
0.0738303289,
-0.0412882753,
0.0263821669,
-0.0087848771,
0.0436569601,
-0.0083648758,
0.0200937912,
-0.0018365948,
0.042360846,
0.0055917427,
0.0435660705,
0.0944060609,
-0.0049355673,
0.0659098327,
0.0320186131,
-0.0384884737,
0.0051623662,
0.0349247605,
-0.0242233258,
0.0159614291,
0.0151223624,
0.0901790038,
-0.0373090692,
0.0169144999,
0.1142653599,
0.0044459845,
0.0193009768,
0.0200245325,
-0.0008093494,
0.0152781419,
0.0119166626,
0.0087961722,
-0.0379979685,
0.0178813692,
0.0312648527,
0.0341243036,
0.0001578023,
0.0270631146,
0.0233596172,
-0.1276873946,
0.0697661936,
0.0517173707,
-0.0098846573,
0.0070075258,
-0.0489702709,
-0.0378592834,
-0.0618221126,
0.0563147962,
0.0006394512,
-0.043399144,
-0.0400095545,
0.0410936773,
-0.0991617665,
-0.0581781678,
0.0458113477,
-0.0235435124,
0.0717756525,
0.0084723393,
0.0016511488,
-0.0242739804,
0.022382848,
0.0004216931,
-0.0065404428,
0.0006649254,
-0.002612063,
0.0439880006,
0.0244081505,
-0.0371000357,
0.0243959762,
0.0318899974,
-0.0087227896,
0.0286142025,
0.0263083056,
0.0496684648,
-0.0257725921,
0.0086062355,
0.0064841397,
0.0417581648,
-0.040654771,
0.0619013943,
0.0546736382,
-0.0329216272,
-0.000131065,
0.0045026033,
0.0094225826,
0.0102272267,
-0.0301388428,
0.0788297951,
0.0037485596,
-0.0552061014,
-0.0412478819,
-0.0413123034,
-0.0142170638,
0.0257100966,
0.0241714064,
0.0156413876,
-0.0188334379,
0.030214088,
-0.0123488707,
0.0237465296,
0.0230058804,
0.0075347242,
-0.0552932844,
-0.0399840549,
0.0583817363,
-0.0292022713,
0.0171298031,
-0.0572542399,
-0.0038252659,
-0.0412981622,
0.0185809098,
0.0205590725,
0.0130942836,
0.0333600119,
-0.0281311441,
0.0004165741,
0.0573276691,
0.0384753831,
-0.0951270089,
-0.0359756947,
0.0860574171,
-0.0362354778,
-0.0205417722,
0.0278706048,
-0.0260716695,
0.0633725896,
-0.0241403449,
0.0147427563,
-0.0298706163,
-0.0209675711,
0.0253142416,
0.035528101,
0.058100976,
-0.0285917241,
0.0759423748,
-0.0425843298,
0.0101385936,
-0.0314680114,
0.0076726931,
-0.0282065291,
-0.0296332426,
0.0776899755,
0.012710304,
-0.0205042847,
0.0391050763,
-0.0530936569,
-0.0316487029,
-0.0241314806,
0.0248112567,
0.0119416406,
0.0307361688,
-0.037205182,
0.036741782,
-0.0219169036,
0.0157219395,
0.0420088135,
-0.0094923554,
0.0175968967,
0.0220055468,
-0.017639786,
0.0714939162,
-0.0093629286,
-0.0094691264,
-0.0496669598,
-0.0642546862,
-0.0250899773,
-0.0264212769,
0.0567438789,
-0.0688231215,
0.0304363854,
-0.0274078324,
0.0126346806,
-0.055807896,
0.029776942,
-0.0185470972,
0.0254412629,
0.0121677881,
-0.010932669,
-0.06574554,
0.0087002823,
0.0545943119,
0.0178046972,
0.0270357057,
0.073941201,
0.0515602529,
-0.0408133641,
-0.0228072125,
0.0133907776,
0.0256386325,
-0.0439532623,
-0.0324378796,
-0.023570966,
-0.0685727596,
0.0085843103,
-0.0288721453,
-0.0004139364,
0.0005483604,
-0.0137231592,
0.0065229759,
-0.0096732369,
0.0436924472,
-0.015367928,
-0.0392288491,
0.0230915919,
0.0236539412,
0.0558997802,
-6.561348653e-33,
-0.0148981735,
0.0519249626,
-0.0086153969,
0.0102797514,
0.0243482385,
-0.011309254,
-0.0140700191,
0.0560671203,
-0.0394134447,
-0.0192009229,
-0.042565193,
-0.0087918835,
0.0324812643,
0.0444874391,
0.0166559815,
0.0045101247,
0.0624480695,
-0.0319017358,
0.0100085018,
-0.0022728601,
0.0170075689,
0.0329418592,
0.0396259539,
-0.0749376491,
-0.0306419488,
-0.0057966467,
-0.0019668455,
-0.0255250484,
0.0097328387,
0.0550572649,
-0.0260573961,
0.0978344306,
-0.0011015245,
0.0074294619,
-0.069355391,
-0.036234308,
-0.1103108749,
-0.0237426627,
-0.015379414,
0.0719073936,
0.0128810043,
0.0246810988,
0.0219885167,
0.0250333231,
-0.0598606504,
-0.0328659564,
0.0304988679,
-0.0454348437,
-0.020924205,
0.013417176,
-0.006471274,
0.0272693038,
-0.0062759044,
-0.0168567188,
0.1014429331,
0.0470164977,
-0.0400842577,
-0.0087787937,
-0.0628203526,
0.0154500408,
0.0228995159,
0.0374086127,
0.0469009131,
-0.0189204924,
0.0244242866,
-0.0127338851,
0.0926488265,
-0.0472641177,
0.0122233247,
-0.0209241286,
0.0598531477,
0.0364140309,
-0.0019543038,
0.0059043663,
0.0371436588,
-0.0513505451,
-0.0392436273,
-0.0113468058,
0.038232632,
-0.0118068177,
0.0101685198,
0.0327194482,
-0.053427022,
-0.0232649893,
-0.0277830753,
-0.0557965115,
-0.0138582252,
-0.041847527,
0.0313467458,
-0.0077192751,
0.0028383594,
0.009587571,
0.0611161441,
-0.0683432892,
-0.0458147898,
-0.0141903581,
-0.0190437566,
-0.0473809913,
-0.0061257235,
0.0331963636,
-0.0539363138,
-0.0400411002,
-0.0261945464,
-0.0004135772,
-0.019687295,
-0.0295866355,
0.0046542715,
0.0360077135,
-0.0522491075,
0.0043937224,
0.0246948265,
-0.0471782796,
0.0011628477,
0.0105157541,
0.0223675724,
0.0042993743,
0.0157714859,
0.0640155971,
-0.0115993358,
-0.0101148076,
-0.027985869,
-0.0078130635,
-0.0003349884,
0.0190934334,
-0.022013437,
-0.00153185,
-0.0348185822,
0.0163381696,
0.0693104118,
-0.0076655154,
-0.0067775873,
0.0042803385,
2.685e-7,
0.0045770439,
-0.0097558117,
0.0559019409,
-0.023347659,
0.0095375003,
0.0195201952,
-0.0604253151,
0.0085480828,
-0.0194187425,
0.03363543,
0.0611294694,
0.0323241279,
0.0945690796,
0.0004903834,
-0.0548772998,
0.0034418325,
-0.0815013349,
0.0170021504,
-0.0424977094,
0.0162005033,
-0.0281220749,
0.1153218001,
-0.0025988421,
0.0023714318,
0.0186972413,
-0.0089057162,
0.0494287536,
-0.0214943849,
-0.0090161487,
0.0437649675,
-0.0155559788,
0.0205381475,
-0.0329492949,
-0.0371300504,
-0.0369389765,
0.0662967116,
0.0219515674,
0.0682261959,
-0.0167920664,
-0.0536377579,
-0.0147256441,
0.0519266501,
-0.0190232769,
-0.0232851077,
0.035577964,
-0.0201188978,
-0.0420440882,
0.0210099723,
-0.018667791,
0.026435174,
0.0329452045,
-0.0026752125,
0.0085587353,
0.0551321134,
0.0370545126,
-0.0206216462,
-0.0385540016,
-0.0037359991,
-0.0232710652,
0.004559848,
-0.0262895077,
-0.0040107383,
-0.0058337594,
0.0101503376,
0.0325441211,
0.0195542015,
0.0034340404,
1.627093337e-34,
0.0188171081,
-0.033982534,
-0.005594844,
0.0289257821,
-0.0451013409,
-0.0780232474,
0.0052650534,
0.0221868362,
0.0062995418,
-0.011783666,
-0.0347172096
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03217v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03217v1 | Rethinking E-Commerce Search | 2023-12-06T01:15:40 | 2023-12-06T01:15:40 | Haixun Wang, Taesik Na | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | E-commerce search and recommendation usually operate on structured data such
as product catalogs and taxonomies. However, creating better search and
recommendation systems often requires a large variety of unstructured data
including customer reviews and articles on the web. Traditionally, the solution
has always been converting unstructured data into structured data through
information extraction, and conducting search over the structured data.
However, this is a costly approach that often has low quality. In this paper,
we envision a solution that does entirely the opposite. Instead of converting
unstructured data (web pages, customer reviews, etc) to structured data, we
instead convert structured data (product inventory, catalogs, taxonomies, etc)
into textual data, which can be easily integrated into the text corpus that
trains LLMs. Then, search and recommendation can be performed through a Q/A
mechanism through an LLM instead of using traditional information retrieval
methods over structured data. | [
0.0558839366,
-0.0039347298,
-0.0269124098,
0.0249181539,
-0.019993268,
-0.008832708,
-0.01856157,
0.0595802851,
0.0010604188,
-0.0945196524,
-0.0688110217,
0.0066235373,
-0.0489371866,
0.0575731508,
-0.0319804214,
0.008066114,
0.0018405215,
0.009522398,
0.0016644727,
0.0311908685,
0.0502617247,
0.0220081266,
0.0256568789,
-0.0404420234,
0.0642100051,
0.0156361293,
-0.0368196033,
0.0276629217,
-0.0271139573,
-0.0313246064,
0.042558223,
0.0019471954,
0.002584052,
-0.0227140374,
0.0000015877,
-0.0405147858,
-0.0672490522,
-0.0177395064,
-0.0369800664,
-0.0088739609,
0.0449728593,
0.0459391773,
0.0362936556,
0.0355397053,
-0.0498618409,
0.0233998653,
0.0062992815,
0.0702341273,
0.0230528098,
0.0862923265,
-0.0120275868,
-0.0500133075,
-0.0186502207,
0.0240056813,
0.033546444,
0.0215267353,
0.0225506108,
-0.0048477105,
0.0592992231,
0.0860804245,
0.0489289351,
-0.0092758955,
-0.0766879618,
0.0005438059,
0.0301707294,
0.0049244966,
-0.0337853953,
0.018035166,
-0.0276575573,
0.051608678,
0.042120032,
-0.0134958886,
0.0380815752,
-0.001821756,
-0.0231717229,
0.0102129402,
-0.0123890871,
0.0024142482,
-0.0236928277,
0.0320826657,
-0.014497513,
-0.0178055875,
0.0056224144,
0.0011999389,
0.007335701,
0.0957009718,
-0.0113647012,
-0.0395573862,
0.007209307,
0.00361637,
0.0441409945,
-0.030841589,
0.0195800941,
0.0134006478,
-0.0207878686,
0.0233974494,
0.0019631172,
0.0144657511,
0.0125949839,
-0.0600557588,
-0.0084755495,
-0.0238251127,
0.0078854272,
0.057141427,
-0.0239308197,
-0.0139318136,
0.0167796891,
0.0003238573,
-0.0573075637,
0.0113050826,
-0.0704232305,
-0.0220427252,
0.0067765331,
0.0526330732,
-0.0253839046,
0.0023934236,
-0.0140462955,
0.0371234268,
-0.0053036241,
0.0008263158,
0.0324658267,
-0.0070843324,
0.0075404849,
0.0127980513,
-0.0818772316,
-0.0453346558,
-0.0119133573,
0.0088165179,
-0.046908576,
-0.0137051865,
0.0524450056,
0.0446006879,
0.0578957275,
-0.0090853907,
0.0356326737,
0.010106015,
0.034963537,
-0.0357242674,
-0.1330836713,
-0.0572645441,
-0.0014198297,
0.0155975223,
0.0041206474,
-0.0536139309,
0.0041935211,
-0.0134336539,
-0.0288850963,
0.0121899815,
0.0047066296,
0.0159898233,
0.0020045405,
0.0812543407,
-0.0269066375,
-0.0109801143,
0.0106443753,
-0.0258036759,
0.0638130903,
0.0134093584,
-0.0258389525,
0.0304291137,
0.0663884729,
0.0118370643,
0.0243841168,
0.0006640547,
-0.0567126051,
-0.0186896995,
-0.0205666479,
0.0686725378,
-0.0819120333,
-0.0092532961,
0.0183240026,
0.0245741084,
-0.0330420807,
0.0357697159,
0.0405472443,
0.0182432588,
0.0482486822,
0.0308192372,
-0.0081710955,
0.0340655409,
-0.006983188,
-0.0334342979,
0.0469530113,
-0.0003589272,
-0.0351606309,
-0.0120305801,
-0.0125749698,
-0.040321365,
-0.0320644341,
-0.0489245765,
-0.0094825169,
-0.0108285397,
0.0307459086,
0.0234248992,
0.014019724,
-0.0138272783,
-0.0098511837,
0.0251836553,
-0.003326623,
-0.0396161824,
0.00533931,
-0.0239986256,
0.0305067226,
0.1204095483,
0.050275024,
-0.0289821401,
-0.0191632528,
0.0072347401,
-0.0294267815,
0.0209703818,
0.0016376571,
-0.0388364084,
-0.0303284265,
-0.0389638655,
-0.0470886268,
0.0223158393,
-0.0149129471,
-0.0100156013,
-0.0031607067,
0.0172815882,
0.0174557827,
-0.0548476242,
0.0387244783,
0.0036627355,
0.0411402211,
-0.0205059648,
0.0184474159,
0.0155953113,
0.0326252766,
0.0216458216,
0.0045250333,
0.0016916014,
0.0482198745,
0.0089508528,
-0.0980101451,
-0.037065614,
0.0542203821,
0.035597913,
0.0277587213,
-0.0531505682,
0.0417823941,
0.0014328277,
0.0170919914,
-0.0297388863,
-0.0580612794,
-0.0278167892,
0.06344264,
-0.0089482199,
0.0144669125,
-0.0108422469,
-0.0159406923,
-0.0794997066,
0.0404554494,
0.0410041995,
0.0162925478,
-0.0279551633,
-0.0643660575,
-0.0110140303,
-0.0268409308,
0.0061930032,
0.0168072898,
0.0433230214,
0.0440224372,
0.0312565789,
0.0100797163,
-0.0589058883,
0.0216534473,
-0.0465698615,
0.0274415407,
0.0445706174,
0.0698208436,
0.0187795572,
0.0031025934,
-0.0104392506,
-0.0019999903,
-0.0775870755,
0.0037612603,
-0.0175587628,
-0.0215258263,
0.0608333573,
0.025499152,
-0.0266305078,
-0.0358604491,
-0.0042525996,
0.0042900145,
-0.02232958,
0.0005861833,
-0.0569468886,
-0.0507376976,
0.055400759,
-0.0502365902,
-0.0037002226,
0.026138531,
0.0103945797,
-0.0348563455,
-0.0425020903,
-0.0070791566,
0.0195054673,
-0.0065627336,
-0.0663814768,
0.0184949618,
-0.0412815399,
-0.0702570602,
-0.0179205518,
-0.0119046383,
0.0282838345,
-0.0083689662,
-0.0053918138,
0.0898220539,
-0.0220451951,
-0.0212477259,
0.0021342258,
0.0181532614,
-0.0407495126,
0.0335748531,
0.0072869756,
-0.0269418098,
0.005344159,
0.0065334444,
0.08959838,
0.0008005728,
-0.003890224,
0.0226436369,
0.0030682583,
0.0301923919,
-0.0536030568,
-0.0225965362,
-0.0671784282,
-0.0115154348,
-0.0093910033,
0.00615673,
-0.0483385995,
-0.0420623384,
0.0057961349,
0.0183823928,
0.0625738278,
-0.0408794023,
0.0286223143,
0.0043601347,
0.0356293507,
-0.0137012759,
-0.0403057188,
-0.0093429685,
-0.0059591765,
0.0139672887,
-0.028059274,
0.0514413156,
0.0068044337,
-0.0501397662,
0.0196059886,
-0.0264614224,
0.0423181802,
0.0170019902,
-0.0520168692,
0.0193764009,
0.0499732979,
0.011635351,
-0.0498806722,
-0.0034975624,
0.0193409659,
-0.0044498676,
0.06250754,
-0.0306462515,
-0.0423868857,
-0.0008911803,
-0.0203449391,
0.0488008857,
-0.0901235044,
-0.0023043193,
0.0275718309,
-0.0811501145,
-0.0078613553,
0.0231559221,
0.080369994,
0.0483924933,
-0.0535785258,
-0.0451603644,
0.0199997406,
-0.0102470806,
0.0298203267,
0.0355874598,
-0.0645057335,
0.0177421458,
0.0019171974,
0.0477126352,
0.0099390438,
-0.0244070608,
0.0160725638,
-0.1115608811,
0.0076386798,
-0.021756513,
0.0203056056,
-0.0466385819,
-0.0524079576,
-0.0108767385,
-0.0138678607,
0.018048672,
0.0202953853,
-0.0455550589,
0.0143494541,
0.0125080748,
-0.016383674,
-0.012726943,
0.0194692202,
-0.0125819072,
-0.0057480182,
0.0290631726,
0.0427025855,
-0.0044620577,
0.0033636512,
0.0182834007,
0.0010455028,
-0.030108301,
-0.0148174679,
0.0330916084,
-0.0271949992,
0.0172853265,
0.0086245025,
-0.017353978,
-0.0244332906,
0.0544459261,
0.0261479616,
0.0102635622,
-0.0160580967,
0.0150975827,
-0.0376237743,
-0.0584339797,
-0.0225809142,
0.0481219105,
-0.0321031623,
-0.0317771249,
-0.029140044,
-0.0326849334,
-0.0326594859,
0.0366610251,
-0.0407516137,
0.0428232066,
-0.0526500903,
0.0063439854,
-0.1267316341,
-0.0153772496,
0.0145824449,
0.0188831687,
0.027326772,
0.0006079061,
-0.008343624,
0.0197515786,
-0.0549481697,
-0.0112245381,
-0.0405621231,
0.0139058726,
-0.0486334749,
0.0392488465,
0.0434565246,
-0.0618315637,
-0.0035751511,
-0.0789889023,
-0.0413515456,
-0.0288318843,
-0.0303321872,
-0.0023664176,
0.0195817258,
0.0192543156,
-0.0194547959,
-0.0489067771,
0.0062705348,
0.0432298966,
-0.0484152138,
-0.049736172,
0.0143880267,
0.0812784731,
0.0138962492,
0.0139741786,
-0.0606474616,
0.0076212697,
-0.0100361304,
0.0055983057,
-0.0200399198,
-0.0532268323,
0.0724663436,
0.0661927387,
0.029086927,
0.0517664142,
0.0648331344,
0.0032750827,
0.0643852949,
-0.0090537565,
-0.0429161713,
-0.0211924128,
0.0204105955,
-0.001573932,
0.0128784785,
-0.0157514568,
0.0673191547,
-0.0378395878,
0.0366072841,
-0.0258355774,
0.0460754931,
0.0284202509,
-0.0140572693,
-0.0013355503,
-0.0293662772,
0.0039017745,
0.0064919931,
0.0337252878,
0.0398170464,
-0.040386986,
-0.0046131746,
0.0104067614,
-0.0204573777,
-0.0285416637,
0.0416911431,
-0.0264883917,
-0.0208542664,
-0.0313045494,
-0.0054762345,
-0.0163465906,
-0.001789298,
0.0213640407,
-0.0372871347,
-0.0173914898,
0.0014857402,
0.0107024089,
-0.0239413679,
0.0402434096,
0.0248213578,
0.0259849746,
-0.0106813349,
0.0033828379,
0.0478776097,
-0.0095800571,
-0.004061983,
-0.0353655554,
-0.0818780884,
-0.0575648546,
-0.0001587095,
0.02131542,
-0.0031154214,
-0.0279264785,
-0.0500757433,
0.0337492488,
-0.0092786578,
0.0085416576,
0.0131216589,
0.0361017771,
-0.003367024,
0.0792590156,
0.0723887756,
0.0424173847,
0.0557518676,
-0.0496472493,
-0.0194359776,
0.0000254401,
0.0082479902,
-0.0239929911,
-5.487472483e-33,
0.0256955326,
-0.0512010083,
-0.0031142673,
0.0480315685,
0.0319906771,
-0.0185116697,
0.0327428542,
0.0070940065,
0.0240992997,
-0.0209527854,
-0.0052507096,
0.0247478709,
0.0258398894,
-0.0145388842,
0.0337126628,
-0.0287912562,
0.017166378,
0.0037353397,
-0.0085758939,
-0.0071874964,
0.0064661019,
0.0301402491,
0.0461324938,
-0.0420044363,
0.0269038677,
-0.0208400171,
-0.0481012501,
0.0423726961,
0.0237605516,
0.0694731772,
0.018063914,
0.0202465281,
0.0290670507,
0.0090054255,
0.0221802276,
-0.0026383183,
-0.0623324253,
0.0103272349,
-0.002504261,
0.0168064851,
0.0084901731,
0.027003713,
0.0662177801,
-0.0373752862,
0.0148614068,
0.0834876969,
0.045676887,
-0.0332968719,
-0.0309320148,
-0.1276551634,
0.0013463385,
0.015449333,
-0.0102496296,
0.0503627807,
0.0695165619,
0.0559581369,
-0.0131092547,
0.0572105385,
-0.0232340749,
0.0509481393,
-0.0504893549,
0.0336989909,
0.0068947896,
0.0118628666,
-0.016586503,
0.0303218309,
0.0141694443,
0.0116658174,
0.0423673131,
0.0130963856,
-0.030376289,
0.0303410422,
-0.005349963,
0.0446750335,
0.0239823721,
0.0289324895,
-0.0061428156,
0.0544793569,
0.0092404215,
-0.01997949,
-0.0402769186,
0.0485153571,
-0.0446700528,
-0.0388524085,
0.0395094641,
0.0010625158,
-0.0529756732,
-0.0055625215,
0.0148544554,
0.0024637692,
-0.0306575596,
-0.0369942486,
-0.031507127,
-0.0140140792,
-0.0892897025,
-0.0401875935,
0.0017485736,
-0.0093653072,
-0.014194889,
-0.0454983115,
-0.0297566764,
-0.0296106394,
-0.0293681994,
-0.0299550053,
-0.0420207791,
-0.0304549448,
0.0252965558,
0.0093798591,
-0.085871987,
0.0099309394,
0.0472469367,
-0.0300738569,
-0.0191509742,
0.0408123061,
0.0252856463,
0.0111350808,
0.0059494809,
0.0536774695,
0.037296202,
0.0040910514,
-0.0324183442,
-0.0404102243,
0.0147242136,
-0.0208539497,
0.0026070538,
0.0100003248,
-0.0201254468,
0.0160419736,
0.0257101376,
-0.0728789866,
-0.0025231829,
0.0331934653,
2.472e-7,
0.0646346956,
0.0600906983,
-0.0458504856,
0.031755887,
0.030267125,
0.0066680554,
0.0213780403,
0.0043784208,
0.022275934,
-0.0225472748,
0.0659087971,
-0.0308516081,
0.0254851058,
0.0242884029,
-0.1102734655,
-0.0364780426,
0.0001789892,
-0.0493295416,
-0.0441739038,
-0.0052806893,
0.0555809624,
0.0435670465,
0.0005117494,
0.005039664,
-0.0442929938,
-0.0302539319,
0.0098936884,
-0.0336151645,
0.0126726013,
-0.0053518144,
0.0607413016,
0.0375552885,
-0.05260114,
-0.0244934075,
-0.0125240721,
0.0603790134,
0.0110917743,
0.0271804705,
0.0180960316,
-0.0125256386,
0.0028518771,
-0.0751219988,
-0.0023871046,
0.0245994665,
0.0570480861,
0.0068573053,
0.0117504681,
0.0014948123,
-0.035864111,
-0.0344978198,
-0.0181730483,
-0.0450745896,
-0.0461692512,
0.0314861014,
0.0184003357,
-0.0268845037,
-0.0160800684,
-0.0468890816,
0.0208049789,
0.0123128444,
-0.0280418806,
-0.0114698913,
0.0107711265,
0.0623669736,
0.0077545801,
-0.0114146508,
0.0127739627,
1.98578901e-34,
0.0324625187,
0.0239031017,
0.0041027404,
0.041884739,
0.0098366588,
0.0151916826,
-0.0234577432,
-0.0359190777,
0.0152973598,
-0.0663081855,
-0.0120138917
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03195v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03195v1 | Detecting Rumor Veracity with Only Textual Information by Double-Channel Structure | 2023-12-06T00:08:44 | 2023-12-06T00:08:44 | Alex Kim, Sangwon Yoon | cs.CL | cs.CL | Kyle (1985) proposes two types of rumors: informed rumors which are based on
some private information and uninformed rumors which are not based on any
information (i.e. bluffing). Also, prior studies find that when people have
credible source of information, they are likely to use a more confident textual
tone in their spreading of rumors. Motivated by these theoretical findings, we
propose a double-channel structure to determine the ex-ante veracity of rumors
on social media. Our ultimate goal is to classify each rumor into true, false,
or unverifiable category. We first assign each text into either certain
(informed rumor) or uncertain (uninformed rumor) category. Then, we apply lie
detection algorithm to informed rumors and thread-reply agreement detection
algorithm to uninformed rumors. Using the dataset of SemEval 2019 Task 7, which
requires ex-ante threefold classification (true, false, or unverifiable) of
social media rumors, our model yields a macro-F1 score of 0.4027, outperforming
all the baseline models and the second-place winner (Gorrell et al., 2019).
Furthermore, we empirically validate that the double-channel structure
outperforms single-channel structures which use either lie detection or
agreement detection algorithm to all posts. | [
0.0531863123,
0.0128818853,
0.0014832962,
0.0467129834,
-0.0462147035,
-0.0146856904,
0.0263192188,
0.0007905905,
0.0014920174,
-0.0500635728,
-0.0182989575,
-0.0138977608,
0.0411731042,
0.0422619544,
0.0054651867,
0.0425555483,
0.0393449217,
0.0232711919,
0.0676031485,
-0.0400872417,
0.0411882028,
0.0266169161,
-0.0330235623,
0.0132504227,
-0.0595205054,
-0.0016076389,
0.0239759926,
0.0132050794,
-0.0002144241,
-0.0239853393,
0.0019172594,
0.0562445186,
0.0212396178,
0.0465900972,
0.0000018706,
-0.0368474908,
-0.0287436638,
-0.0035571677,
-0.040412575,
-0.0294222869,
0.0317998268,
-0.0215764362,
0.0117090372,
0.0397607312,
-0.0065662968,
-0.0366304629,
0.0213140193,
0.0646395087,
0.0574924164,
0.1069423035,
-0.0254938845,
-0.0353847332,
0.022075953,
-0.0214828495,
0.0210002158,
-0.0657978058,
0.0601966567,
-0.0330106206,
-0.0755038634,
0.0409007967,
0.0473998114,
-0.0148683283,
-0.0016964168,
-0.0226481073,
0.0030799948,
0.0338735916,
-0.0269485749,
-0.0575373583,
0.0020243542,
-0.0109043121,
0.017810883,
-0.069885321,
-0.0171193872,
0.0180989541,
-0.0014335754,
0.0476781316,
-0.0187626537,
0.0330858752,
-0.0397178307,
0.0185236968,
0.0223585553,
0.0258408189,
0.0240294039,
-0.000594534,
0.0646478012,
0.0575099289,
-0.0202089399,
-0.0348570906,
0.0078293495,
0.0069824927,
0.0258996487,
-0.0631045178,
0.0153365098,
0.0041883471,
-0.0069716899,
0.0229507051,
-0.0334674306,
-0.0093661891,
0.0449780002,
-0.1168556288,
-0.0672383234,
0.0023690816,
0.0003175469,
0.0328152366,
-0.034049511,
-0.0480553769,
-0.0064234477,
-0.0024069902,
0.0183892641,
-0.0156381577,
0.0159278158,
0.0340917185,
-0.0232098717,
-0.0001659539,
-0.00929558,
0.0069079632,
-0.0442334786,
-0.04099847,
-0.0269355867,
0.0033950554,
-0.0204241704,
-0.0002369569,
-0.008701128,
-0.0051268628,
-0.0027003919,
0.0251337085,
0.0113289636,
0.0509903692,
-0.0264845788,
-0.0307722297,
-0.0038708413,
0.0247206334,
-0.011272545,
0.034250427,
-0.0102795847,
-0.0249644723,
0.0093596261,
0.0020164747,
-0.0322599746,
-0.0455473587,
-0.0146486461,
-0.0500482917,
-0.0102908919,
-0.0556139089,
0.0177941807,
-0.0218503755,
-0.0060601467,
0.0275373217,
0.0135269938,
0.0183624309,
-0.0449105091,
0.0264483374,
-0.027068451,
0.0124764582,
0.0493635163,
0.0433329456,
-0.0231809858,
0.071582973,
0.013974349,
0.0979317427,
0.0826052874,
0.0396977291,
0.0118478565,
0.0003845391,
0.0602739267,
-0.0019198515,
0.0875472501,
-0.0213399492,
-0.0269466527,
-0.0499964207,
-0.0434128232,
0.0045960662,
-0.0060250657,
-0.0579270236,
0.0566709228,
-0.0602319986,
-0.0305468775,
-0.00401471,
0.0387922116,
0.0105333664,
0.0088910004,
-0.0072943228,
-0.0295923986,
-0.0037351563,
-0.0809502676,
-0.0165185146,
0.0582255535,
0.0186851099,
-0.0268503651,
-0.0217941441,
-0.0226167608,
-0.0231369883,
0.0027069752,
-0.0401022062,
-0.0106620798,
-0.0008068674,
-0.053229209,
0.026357051,
0.0369267873,
0.0163685679,
-0.0180938412,
-0.047264684,
0.0232871473,
-0.0194896385,
-0.0236786138,
0.0575828739,
0.0251833964,
-0.0340212137,
0.0192192029,
0.021471316,
0.024836801,
-0.0059640594,
-0.0133752758,
-0.0113335941,
0.0140860109,
-0.0077992971,
0.0194285866,
-0.0345037952,
0.0365935266,
0.0447833464,
-0.034839008,
-0.000962943,
-0.022622304,
-0.0099113435,
0.0219805073,
0.0114834253,
0.0205057673,
0.0221365839,
0.0223212745,
-0.0001330667,
0.0134939542,
-0.0228846408,
0.033305008,
0.0333584771,
-0.0441596098,
0.0044281692,
-0.0306316148,
-0.0201326013,
0.004340224,
-0.0089955013,
-0.041287519,
0.0116516314,
0.004202751,
0.020177016,
0.0284301266,
-0.0277674738,
0.0099494448,
-0.036576692,
-0.0196026601,
-0.0414946862,
0.0205680709,
0.0357186459,
0.0480907932,
-0.0320602804,
-0.0182752628,
-0.0343575999,
-0.0223808978,
0.0326209217,
0.0223210193,
0.0001220963,
-0.0189441387,
0.0135064879,
0.016265912,
0.0458880104,
-0.0278120209,
0.0095868642,
-0.0192823894,
-0.0860158131,
0.0062088971,
-0.0319100991,
-0.0132628549,
0.0497045927,
-0.0066171815,
0.0173498895,
0.0258905459,
-0.0356178097,
0.0479659289,
0.010811503,
0.0150934784,
-0.004361575,
-0.0393742621,
0.0009581613,
-0.0057216599,
0.0314902924,
-0.0202589072,
0.0318098925,
0.0420442075,
-0.0570834205,
-0.035371989,
0.0183751285,
-0.070572257,
0.0366082676,
-0.0236523263,
0.0026050638,
-0.009040894,
0.0164568406,
-0.0210889447,
-0.010372078,
0.0462002307,
0.0431087352,
-0.0059319884,
0.0441302881,
0.0229097921,
0.0001635151,
-0.04961285,
0.0186005943,
-0.0445114784,
-0.0637644678,
0.0079586618,
0.0348996222,
0.0511345454,
-0.0105556278,
-0.0011192611,
0.0257665403,
0.038760189,
-0.0030947933,
0.0382872447,
-0.0490325391,
0.0251890887,
0.0229977649,
-0.0336304456,
-0.0763263106,
0.085760735,
-0.0367333218,
0.0336655453,
-0.0296975207,
-0.0496286899,
-0.0132301645,
-0.0060365945,
-0.0234110337,
0.0191140343,
0.0578149259,
0.0121371215,
0.0195017625,
-0.0377084315,
0.062327899,
-0.0201332141,
-0.0287993997,
-0.0082324045,
0.0304750204,
0.0548381433,
-0.0177563597,
-0.0315485224,
-0.1157569215,
-0.0275332443,
-0.0395796001,
-0.017279081,
-0.011752123,
-0.1030593663,
-0.0157563128,
0.0168507639,
0.0003307066,
-0.0195136182,
-0.0097889714,
0.0301736258,
0.0250616912,
0.0093343379,
-0.0046933619,
0.0554077253,
-0.0247697365,
-0.0088540278,
0.0957063138,
-0.0520008281,
0.0350358523,
0.028016258,
-0.0555529669,
0.0025861559,
0.0148420017,
-0.0080960533,
-0.0271108821,
0.0352504551,
-0.0377571136,
-0.0041152393,
0.0765344203,
0.0205567051,
-0.0146653317,
-0.0071376152,
0.047722552,
0.0049508456,
0.0172265414,
-0.0250052214,
-0.0589095503,
-0.0061346232,
-0.0315095074,
-0.0367558673,
-0.0373417698,
-0.0017794955,
-0.0529731847,
-0.0630745068,
0.008538547,
-0.0258187465,
-0.0104757743,
-0.0327765383,
-0.0549034551,
0.0110044451,
0.0295776818,
0.0102208592,
-0.0275169257,
0.0489503816,
-0.0251280218,
-0.0281259716,
-0.0593690947,
0.0066250972,
0.0376206227,
0.0030993598,
0.0423500314,
-0.007790952,
0.0241736136,
-0.0163267162,
-0.0644558743,
-0.018615013,
0.0015237269,
-0.0511652939,
-0.0279668905,
0.0585760176,
-0.059805695,
0.0164299887,
-0.0236248765,
0.0136552136,
-0.0038530088,
0.0106821442,
-0.0046883663,
0.0121392282,
0.0371443443,
-0.0923432633,
-0.0041742311,
0.0525003746,
0.0431371555,
0.0566874817,
-0.0070558549,
0.0077477298,
0.021116307,
-0.0281257443,
-0.0182959884,
0.0151707856,
-0.0244198181,
0.0410639942,
0.0172235798,
-0.0492896922,
-0.0497168936,
-0.0053156898,
-0.0186158866,
0.0077820993,
-0.0487112738,
0.0169908907,
0.0618730374,
-0.0152891567,
-0.0360917524,
-0.0559727363,
0.0030992806,
0.0393020548,
0.0536825582,
0.0197401419,
0.0238560457,
-0.010813172,
0.0090810163,
0.0437691994,
-0.0992486253,
-0.0366893969,
-0.038377732,
0.0007067648,
0.0162575115,
0.0396369062,
-0.0240661744,
-0.0272045061,
0.022009261,
-0.0132665895,
-0.031657327,
0.0403742269,
0.0172769446,
-0.0081380978,
0.0615665913,
0.0084632933,
0.0173041075,
0.034152519,
0.026494503,
-0.0410351716,
-0.0578043759,
-0.0086501502,
0.0108785899,
0.0362815484,
0.0111755328,
0.0136918062,
0.002125059,
-0.0177366044,
-0.0058663888,
-0.0437901393,
-0.021079354,
0.0147337988,
0.0361940153,
-0.0104153873,
0.009349199,
-0.0089398865,
-0.0211204998,
-0.0100375684,
0.0093673011,
0.0022248658,
-0.0328936055,
0.015510859,
0.0143821584,
-0.01245338,
-0.0069359331,
-0.0193875376,
0.001114973,
0.0308568031,
0.0095119113,
0.0181795396,
-0.0069440817,
0.0067498065,
-0.0757186115,
0.0356660075,
-0.0216506124,
-0.0493659526,
-0.0056672678,
-0.0323838256,
0.0153156947,
-0.0084826751,
0.0204874165,
0.0316535458,
-0.0093740616,
0.0077901003,
0.0172825139,
-0.003801008,
-0.03252808,
-0.0276197921,
0.0218795501,
-0.002774888,
-0.0470296927,
0.0935868025,
0.0189620219,
0.0022319544,
-0.0097164456,
0.0117441369,
-0.0798534974,
-0.0345040113,
0.0189851187,
-0.0307511576,
0.0851933062,
0.0364753343,
0.0086645503,
-0.0580728725,
-0.0188661367,
0.0606941879,
0.0022398555,
0.0546711348,
0.0291165523,
-0.0377637856,
0.0876064673,
0.0475379117,
0.0143291065,
-0.0520043485,
-0.0374108404,
0.0157584567,
-0.0227141995,
0.0066505866,
-6.398154038e-33,
0.0369127169,
-0.054755941,
-0.0285730511,
-0.003327908,
-0.0057449485,
0.0689008534,
0.0000653664,
-0.0080610905,
-0.0495339297,
0.0648293644,
0.0442041717,
0.0502800196,
0.0084124822,
-0.0194486529,
-0.0486914031,
0.0198615938,
0.0488590561,
-0.0126175554,
-0.0156993531,
0.0209690724,
0.0607897267,
-0.0276651438,
0.036432799,
-0.0742476732,
0.0829327032,
-0.0465470254,
-0.0576233715,
0.0445966274,
-0.0089519462,
0.0178035963,
-0.0244141314,
0.0411952734,
0.0234073643,
-0.0139172003,
0.0025007543,
0.015432639,
-0.0346954018,
-0.0207510684,
0.0434031971,
-0.0195871443,
-0.0013481254,
0.0434816368,
0.0107326359,
0.0209086612,
-0.00432475,
-0.0295939632,
0.0279829446,
0.0093191108,
0.0341768265,
-0.0030790281,
-0.0261205714,
-0.0094197243,
0.0275313873,
-0.0357564613,
-0.0272056963,
0.0471309088,
0.0151401618,
-0.0028111243,
-0.1188238263,
0.0362901092,
-0.1092068255,
-0.0128049003,
-0.0185159277,
-0.0877121836,
-0.0378078669,
0.0431480855,
0.0407860689,
0.0631800741,
-0.0434630588,
0.0328802951,
-0.0180537552,
0.0529306084,
0.0426993668,
0.0886003748,
0.0595161803,
-0.0656033307,
-0.1262084246,
0.0151836639,
0.0760051087,
-0.0386420935,
0.0157500021,
-0.007381421,
-0.0547957681,
-0.0245081168,
0.008193505,
-0.0012359811,
-0.0420265868,
-0.0085323108,
-0.0536718816,
0.0418916084,
0.0039102645,
0.0917067379,
0.0088730389,
-0.0501185805,
0.0006325653,
0.0227580257,
-0.0109461732,
0.0160551537,
0.0098401094,
0.0519715473,
-0.0425434895,
0.0417172499,
0.023284737,
0.0715730265,
-0.0083741108,
0.0150398044,
0.0567316674,
-0.0163580235,
-0.0636311918,
0.0186609793,
-0.0273959618,
0.025387913,
-0.0002222295,
-0.0221300349,
0.0028122524,
0.0149782049,
-0.0136954077,
0.032204248,
-0.0228031818,
0.0161727257,
-0.0132498536,
0.0228404365,
-0.0250092465,
0.0331177227,
0.0185267441,
0.0032621333,
-0.0076611782,
-0.0239540227,
-0.017846765,
-0.0703034699,
0.0213998053,
-0.0310256761,
2.768e-7,
-0.0155801671,
0.0335160568,
-0.0063345954,
0.0091800233,
0.0606224015,
0.064600341,
0.0471777245,
-0.002074454,
0.0113778962,
-0.0940731913,
-0.0598475151,
0.0350168422,
0.0123854298,
0.0778514296,
-0.0482472144,
-0.0054814438,
-0.0617728122,
-0.0363864675,
-0.0185153708,
-0.0102044521,
0.0465193093,
0.027615495,
0.054501947,
-0.015194864,
-0.0140248286,
-0.0025197852,
0.047662206,
0.0471302569,
-0.0824354589,
0.0342022888,
0.018543547,
-0.0301763322,
-0.0127730416,
0.0306830723,
-0.0194903184,
0.017754171,
-0.0448124222,
0.0100972904,
0.0089526623,
-0.0110343238,
0.0057204878,
-0.0104057174,
0.0132184317,
-0.0239886623,
0.0254606511,
0.0009212082,
-0.0690417141,
-0.0635461956,
-0.0078444052,
0.0425942913,
0.0324471891,
0.0040970389,
-0.0171748176,
0.0312668644,
0.001685388,
-0.0052031553,
-0.0032543563,
-0.0396975353,
0.001426416,
0.0083645191,
-0.0466900691,
-0.0511500835,
0.0506775789,
-0.0491403341,
0.0539792515,
-0.0375743359,
0.0609091334,
2.056876801e-34,
0.0383698195,
-0.0291911419,
-0.0099819954,
0.0031409743,
0.02551548,
-0.0056150765,
0.002399808,
-0.0516844466,
0.0313733704,
0.0020341501,
-0.0045877579
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03194v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03194v1 | Corporate Bankruptcy Prediction with Domain-Adapted BERT | 2023-12-06T00:05:25 | 2023-12-06T00:05:25 | Alex Kim, Sangwon Yoon | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, econ.GN, q-fin.EC | This study performs BERT-based analysis, which is a representative
contextualized language model, on corporate disclosure data to predict
impending bankruptcies. Prior literature on bankruptcy prediction mainly
focuses on developing more sophisticated prediction methodologies with
financial variables. However, in our study, we focus on improving the quality
of input dataset. Specifically, we employ BERT model to perform sentiment
analysis on MD&A disclosures. We show that BERT outperforms dictionary-based
predictions and Word2Vec-based predictions in terms of adjusted R-square in
logistic regression, k-nearest neighbor (kNN-5), and linear kernel support
vector machine (SVM). Further, instead of pre-training the BERT model from
scratch, we apply self-learning with confidence-based filtering to corporate
disclosure data (10-K). We achieve the accuracy rate of 91.56% and demonstrate
that the domain adaptation procedure brings a significant improvement in
prediction accuracy. | [
0.0255893245,
0.0759979412,
-0.020452857,
0.0120203272,
0.0083221085,
-0.0162779465,
0.0005566798,
0.0698441491,
0.0164377559,
-0.0854958296,
-0.0351611823,
-0.0079225311,
-0.0453156494,
0.023650106,
-0.0057180729,
0.0159155689,
0.0350897424,
0.0249947105,
0.0371528678,
-0.0368843675,
0.0063476907,
0.0236563366,
0.0140232593,
0.0154760033,
-0.0135129504,
-0.0010735043,
0.0354953893,
0.0061542946,
0.0056121107,
-0.0418873616,
0.0457840413,
0.0576090328,
0.037552692,
-0.0010868851,
0.0000019143,
-0.076656647,
-0.0582973287,
0.0058159861,
0.0433455408,
0.0274460297,
-0.004655425,
-0.0414411984,
0.0393914543,
0.0200402364,
-0.0938610733,
-0.0091652852,
0.0152790528,
0.0537746288,
0.0740126818,
0.0451781675,
-0.009940804,
-0.0720534846,
-0.0068241078,
-0.0438334681,
-0.0126150958,
-0.0581954271,
0.0435455143,
-0.0002342462,
-0.0118760336,
-0.082013391,
-0.0202786773,
0.0407201722,
-0.0170511454,
-0.0113982344,
0.0111253802,
0.0186576322,
-0.0427195393,
0.0078022671,
-0.0110716065,
0.0106418617,
0.0649712607,
0.0016511797,
0.0040498422,
-0.0036799293,
0.0307859667,
0.0322946906,
0.0264285114,
-0.0117164245,
-0.0416396931,
0.0384020805,
0.0074561089,
0.0297474638,
-0.0151204607,
-0.0222982354,
0.0078398427,
0.031966269,
-0.0177705381,
-0.0513127297,
0.0408041961,
0.0368243344,
-0.0337317102,
-0.0312997773,
0.0218443982,
-0.0176409241,
0.0257121846,
0.0256837942,
-0.0386327878,
-0.051365681,
-0.0056016291,
-0.1360066533,
0.0044158171,
0.0079112528,
0.0063733035,
0.0014692629,
-0.0413945541,
0.0135512017,
0.030566385,
-0.0120537207,
-0.0181386359,
0.0320147276,
-0.0691216215,
0.0336042717,
-0.033920534,
0.0903179869,
-0.0137827629,
0.0043523349,
-0.0792425871,
0.0101741813,
-0.0038128952,
-0.001105909,
0.0052974038,
0.0014109892,
0.0304036532,
0.0157476682,
-0.0517973751,
-0.028414052,
-0.0233108792,
0.001657113,
-0.0653264523,
0.0042191204,
0.0484160483,
-0.0193671193,
-0.0046939831,
-0.015026534,
0.009208357,
0.0606882013,
0.0259829666,
-0.0405330434,
-0.0602163598,
0.0219660345,
-0.024567442,
-0.0095084766,
-0.0268637277,
-0.0052851671,
-0.0256401952,
0.011829894,
-0.0225231964,
-0.0137961386,
0.0223812815,
-0.0315415114,
-0.0236220229,
0.0692819059,
-0.0440631658,
-0.0203230102,
0.0341223925,
-0.0333549716,
0.0247859433,
0.0306033511,
-0.0012598712,
-0.0432033092,
0.0228980351,
-0.0262781158,
-0.0164070241,
0.0280614737,
0.0071375123,
-0.0447973274,
-0.0282869432,
0.0597758442,
-0.0435754731,
-0.0065882057,
0.0161778647,
-0.0077351774,
0.0121824108,
-0.0196618233,
0.0402870253,
0.01577623,
0.0535461791,
0.0603579842,
-0.0412050672,
0.0287098065,
0.0099945692,
-0.0278977174,
-0.0016812314,
-0.0206828807,
-0.0442014262,
0.0117102833,
0.010254656,
-0.0299460571,
-0.0193013214,
-0.0619692802,
-0.0382523909,
0.0147699704,
-0.0266173985,
-0.0209675413,
0.0396119803,
-0.0097072031,
-0.0488961115,
0.0780136362,
0.04797123,
-0.008089127,
-0.0215881336,
-0.0248811003,
0.0734662861,
0.0782766938,
0.0404850543,
-0.0667724088,
0.0114825312,
-0.0302245095,
-0.0300236773,
0.0153079033,
0.0261998177,
0.0327288248,
-0.0348969586,
-0.0366953425,
-0.0254678652,
0.0324019603,
0.0373604931,
0.0090276925,
-0.0306070894,
0.0529434755,
-0.0045103244,
-0.0776409805,
-0.0139772296,
0.0496784896,
0.0295622256,
-0.0445143394,
0.0489385277,
0.0017155526,
-0.0022515056,
0.0195855796,
-0.0389275588,
-0.0167836864,
0.0038996402,
0.0176013969,
-0.0539565831,
0.0017962026,
-0.014081426,
-0.0368575491,
-0.0115770306,
0.0080466624,
0.0223712213,
0.013438344,
0.0026465144,
0.0063013113,
-0.007507463,
-0.0309236776,
0.0457725562,
-0.0562287383,
-0.0119162519,
-0.0211922918,
0.0321681686,
0.0054723928,
0.0789704844,
-0.0194917228,
0.0404843651,
-0.0839703307,
0.0231972542,
0.0214721318,
0.0069417767,
-0.0257718116,
-0.0433532298,
-0.0396075621,
0.0574823841,
0.0532933958,
0.0212768298,
0.0077061807,
0.012668835,
-0.1010637134,
-0.0421703868,
-0.011809268,
0.0142132947,
-0.019868847,
-0.0150299715,
-0.022713447,
-0.0103944764,
-0.0178178977,
-0.0047304123,
-0.0312062111,
-0.0172789693,
0.0559010766,
0.0092766425,
-0.0191785842,
-0.0429433361,
-0.0139830438,
-0.0107242782,
0.0230594389,
0.031951353,
-0.048398722,
-0.0373093486,
0.0411309302,
-0.0036161128,
0.0154601801,
0.0288167149,
0.0028018034,
-0.0046555325,
-0.004631904,
-0.0082788868,
-0.0149130803,
0.0244518965,
0.0729004443,
-0.0135316774,
0.0233142581,
-0.0339800045,
0.036870528,
-0.0108314399,
0.0301239137,
-0.0100552617,
-0.0191971287,
0.0393111072,
0.0122969188,
0.0028757786,
-0.0114200544,
-0.0827831104,
-0.0425161086,
-0.003750107,
0.0124332085,
-0.0154164359,
0.0093498677,
-0.0001799277,
0.0382234603,
0.0429622568,
-0.0338702053,
0.0776969418,
0.0087501779,
0.0326228552,
-0.043758478,
-0.026178021,
-0.0375403501,
0.0254813731,
-0.0437307134,
-0.0189613122,
0.0373717993,
-0.007349479,
0.0294747092,
-0.0321103707,
0.0326347798,
-0.0120121622,
0.0379857197,
-0.0114768958,
0.0376771577,
0.0491132811,
-0.0276671853,
-0.0332362428,
-0.0817685872,
0.0094145453,
-0.0042510051,
0.0184035953,
-0.0026815131,
-0.073372744,
0.0189135484,
-0.0663183853,
-0.0131885083,
0.0006866156,
-0.0425564572,
0.0199529864,
0.0562407747,
0.0342429504,
-0.0513514616,
0.037124306,
-0.0353653021,
0.0369212702,
-0.0159049593,
0.0340927579,
0.0315191299,
-0.0039862096,
-0.0006284691,
-0.0077084852,
-0.0172180142,
-0.0198698547,
-0.0111367088,
-0.0248682536,
-0.0163007975,
-0.0065884297,
0.1177074984,
0.0157007538,
0.0487476066,
0.0112188803,
-0.0083488217,
-0.0233909767,
0.0175792538,
0.0615793243,
-0.0229373761,
-0.0153159918,
-0.0525099821,
0.0515622497,
0.0488937274,
-0.0618834384,
0.0136780431,
-0.1014816165,
0.0401179567,
-0.0405512564,
-0.0370060876,
-0.063021414,
-0.0335813463,
-0.008101345,
-0.0511231273,
-0.0193157811,
-0.0382306576,
-0.0066483077,
0.0196974333,
0.0362233147,
-0.0880424678,
0.001293617,
0.0145203061,
-0.0325464755,
-0.0132919867,
0.0711621866,
0.0331436582,
-0.0566932037,
-0.0004527279,
-0.0251260363,
-0.0431477427,
-0.0185240507,
-0.0135303438,
0.078871958,
-0.0258397125,
-0.027603209,
0.0218637642,
0.0299115572,
-0.0339851081,
0.0423375778,
-0.0005711373,
-0.0094983829,
-0.0152710471,
-0.0660259649,
-0.005320196,
0.0393578783,
-0.0022335339,
0.0636620522,
-0.0207893867,
-0.0730781257,
0.0239031799,
-0.0184991676,
-0.0052708648,
-0.0153601281,
0.0730632171,
-0.0189466607,
-0.0693703294,
-0.0440059565,
-0.0981565416,
-0.0509452783,
0.006847084,
0.0337210335,
0.0046558459,
0.0309187304,
0.0094933333,
0.014871289,
-0.0620081052,
-0.0006594666,
0.0261632241,
0.0229900777,
-0.0460987724,
0.014649461,
0.0490493886,
0.0399875008,
-0.0672821254,
-0.0005375965,
-0.0250737444,
-0.0385177284,
-0.0124268793,
0.0187800657,
0.0070270435,
-0.0091330977,
-0.0174330156,
-0.0047546201,
0.1001380682,
0.0734131113,
-0.0487496145,
-0.0144384569,
0.0391218252,
0.0113086142,
0.0100811776,
0.0454294197,
-0.0355106182,
0.0274334103,
0.0048862156,
0.0022721083,
-0.015655743,
-0.0275311638,
-0.0250451807,
-0.0050339615,
0.0453161597,
0.0202023163,
-0.070748508,
-0.0396850891,
-0.0199068636,
0.0194663573,
0.01028967,
-0.0446137674,
-0.0107229678,
0.0331061333,
0.0038801332,
-0.0509168431,
0.0660477877,
-0.0388073549,
-0.0175897498,
-0.0595696457,
0.0710957199,
0.0413474366,
0.0651050732,
0.0255143661,
-0.0192537289,
0.0149877379,
-0.0287811756,
0.0616674535,
-0.0113693764,
-0.0020037284,
0.0145777008,
0.0103077833,
0.0452814437,
0.0377819836,
-0.020326959,
-0.0269922689,
0.0315911174,
-0.0395270437,
0.0362716839,
-0.0234622546,
-0.0253589544,
0.0056856694,
-0.0584997274,
0.0434448123,
-0.0183597598,
0.035583403,
0.0165343173,
-0.0079267854,
0.0716952905,
-0.005244371,
-0.0423957817,
0.026104575,
0.0601639561,
0.026692111,
0.0212216042,
-0.0350819193,
-0.0279428232,
-0.0634908825,
0.0028983245,
0.0762175769,
0.0374105759,
0.0021855328,
0.0010217836,
-0.0424138643,
-0.0479016602,
0.0930616781,
-0.0293541458,
-0.0020227907,
-0.0152843026,
0.0204884615,
0.0608954467,
0.0280572157,
0.0489285253,
-0.0374606252,
0.0085890489,
-0.0151592642,
-0.009707354,
-0.0658195987,
-5.618542307e-33,
-0.011121816,
-0.0269219466,
-0.0216482691,
0.0042235856,
0.0549433567,
0.0026308571,
-0.0046329917,
-0.0047354125,
0.0055732732,
0.029023068,
0.0124088125,
0.0539241359,
0.0044148089,
-0.0002309259,
0.0046901163,
-0.0096129058,
0.0001669938,
-0.0549331009,
0.0012541566,
-0.0308252554,
-0.0109742722,
0.0892474428,
0.0483618081,
-0.0792297646,
0.0225367341,
0.0204992667,
-0.0185660981,
-0.0279244408,
0.0450172387,
0.0104928389,
-0.0176741425,
0.0496023297,
0.0096814251,
-0.0618946142,
0.0196197517,
-0.0163762011,
-0.0101307044,
-0.0342767015,
0.0048344978,
0.0183480307,
0.0417052917,
0.0647744089,
0.0316842571,
0.0059727957,
-0.0284843128,
0.017977478,
0.0511923954,
-0.0107608614,
-0.0135492235,
-0.0640838817,
-0.0199480727,
0.0436124094,
-0.0067428071,
0.0121724904,
0.0297239237,
0.0659008175,
0.0024954546,
-0.0173517708,
-0.0028468496,
-0.0300551504,
-0.0152724041,
0.0036827477,
0.0118260197,
-0.0304542352,
-0.0000388642,
0.0598833151,
0.0051401607,
0.0037789773,
0.0214119721,
0.0023532477,
0.0348906331,
0.0555537641,
0.0037921085,
0.0318037719,
-0.0000741142,
-0.0623828545,
-0.0353686139,
0.0532938838,
0.0067811231,
-0.0515526421,
0.0600214154,
-0.0081801703,
-0.0480814241,
-0.0221817289,
0.0152576063,
-0.0422187075,
-0.0076025403,
0.0316671431,
-0.0144408289,
-0.0285156183,
-0.0184758771,
0.0168844815,
-0.0144218812,
-0.047709845,
-0.063384071,
0.0141545273,
-0.0236877445,
-0.0050675897,
0.0176630951,
-0.0127891274,
-0.0073959199,
-0.0173988473,
0.0018515941,
0.0108000292,
-0.0119234622,
-0.0247060489,
0.0377116725,
-0.0207473077,
-0.0532262847,
-0.0109935049,
0.0137973549,
0.0096533829,
0.0319384448,
0.0486018844,
-0.0068504633,
0.030745564,
0.0190110058,
0.0036307699,
0.0235636905,
0.0204888899,
-0.0088617625,
-0.0140376119,
0.0250389948,
0.0136233941,
0.0016986368,
-0.0281418841,
0.0241479259,
0.0572890937,
-0.0035643794,
-0.0373423286,
-0.0227501579,
0.0295208935,
2.6e-7,
0.068889305,
0.0672069564,
-0.0295363478,
-0.0405116789,
0.0044364501,
0.058365643,
0.0158585832,
0.058823742,
-0.0055977604,
-0.0140092056,
0.0137528507,
-0.0225512814,
0.0575581752,
0.032748159,
-0.0601364188,
-0.0517704375,
-0.0306911524,
0.038630724,
-0.0625268221,
0.0607343838,
0.0574017093,
0.0629930645,
0.0426669829,
-0.0547173619,
0.0027056974,
-0.0493230075,
0.036643438,
-0.0506728515,
-0.0021066011,
0.0263532251,
-0.0073126457,
0.0171671938,
-0.0316577777,
0.0099116918,
-0.0390911624,
0.0613296479,
0.0124517018,
0.0077937776,
0.0103172641,
-0.0095693097,
0.0503617153,
0.0184743851,
-0.0071645468,
-0.0009500103,
0.0413093157,
-0.0221406817,
-0.0287906267,
0.0138111953,
-0.0071050581,
0.0026275113,
0.0405872762,
-0.0027596764,
-0.0473490283,
0.030773364,
0.0222355705,
-0.0417086668,
-0.003884786,
-0.0529780239,
-0.0079156077,
0.0032068559,
-0.0478788689,
0.0348636992,
-0.0257057473,
0.0141666019,
0.0538345203,
-0.0322381072,
0.0666356012,
2.080604338e-34,
0.0492909141,
-0.0375913642,
-0.0494044051,
0.0095197475,
0.0521873869,
0.0069131781,
0.0259014703,
0.0479020104,
0.0026118853,
-0.072207436,
0.0086118951
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03173v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03173v1 | A Comparative Study of AI-Generated (GPT-4) and Human-crafted MCQs in Programming Education | 2023-12-05T22:29:43 | 2023-12-05T22:29:43 | Jacob Doughty, Zipiao Wan, Anishka Bompelli, Jubahed Qayum, Taozhi Wang, Juran Zhang, Yujia Zheng, Aidan Doyle, Pragnya Sridhar, Arav Agarwal, Christopher Bogart, Eric Keylor, Can Kultur, Jaromir Savelka, Majd Sakr | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL | There is a constant need for educators to develop and maintain effective
up-to-date assessments. While there is a growing body of research in computing
education on utilizing large language models (LLMs) in generation and
engagement with coding exercises, the use of LLMs for generating programming
MCQs has not been extensively explored. We analyzed the capability of GPT-4 to
produce multiple-choice questions (MCQs) aligned with specific learning
objectives (LOs) from Python programming classes in higher education.
Specifically, we developed an LLM-powered (GPT-4) system for generation of MCQs
from high-level course context and module-level LOs. We evaluated 651
LLM-generated and 449 human-crafted MCQs aligned to 246 LOs from 6 Python
courses. We found that GPT-4 was capable of producing MCQs with clear language,
a single correct choice, and high-quality distractors. We also observed that
the generated MCQs appeared to be well-aligned with the LOs. Our findings can
be leveraged by educators wishing to take advantage of the state-of-the-art
generative models to support MCQ authoring efforts. | [
0.0104531273,
-0.0189924426,
-0.0350041315,
-0.0031404484,
-0.0254186299,
0.0132884858,
0.0091929268,
-0.0466445684,
0.0276241731,
-0.0288175642,
0.021425955,
0.0297697447,
-0.0476998426,
0.0047848411,
0.0209152866,
-0.0373018309,
0.0202756692,
-0.0545297004,
-0.0197169445,
0.0325654224,
-0.0108834412,
0.0341449156,
-0.0500818752,
0.0480782613,
0.001904021,
-0.0447630286,
-0.038661547,
-0.0063425992,
-0.0177410804,
-0.0652665198,
0.0021990503,
0.0264822245,
0.0287562367,
-0.0013490251,
0.0000022378,
-0.0812041536,
-0.0069940365,
0.0154069681,
-0.0411398523,
0.0407474637,
0.0044564395,
0.0779880807,
0.0171586759,
0.0210278295,
-0.0368731357,
0.0120620746,
0.0226792209,
-0.0215404574,
0.088468872,
0.0510118231,
0.0302705504,
-0.0032285496,
0.0409271568,
0.0359200872,
0.0308829546,
-0.0153414849,
0.0013892931,
0.0717903599,
0.0434302837,
0.0167800188,
-0.0116510978,
-0.0229298491,
0.043455597,
-0.0200418271,
0.0279678721,
0.0193387009,
-0.0543060862,
-0.0088569121,
-0.0030313807,
0.0353208445,
0.0224693734,
-0.0315825343,
-0.0046670684,
-0.024356531,
0.0400040932,
0.0028038246,
-0.0869178846,
0.0545952842,
-0.0119385403,
-0.0263843834,
0.0142115299,
-0.0488566495,
-0.0283370204,
0.0281499755,
-0.0158045348,
0.0162413474,
0.0292357039,
-0.0302683786,
-0.017789565,
0.0282626338,
0.0068299607,
-0.0104616471,
0.0251630079,
0.1001418531,
-0.0354303643,
0.0036602374,
-0.0204083901,
-0.0101546701,
0.0206269789,
-0.0209257752,
0.0276915859,
0.0305673592,
0.0136253489,
-0.0086910957,
-0.0005797184,
0.0944209397,
-0.0059532812,
0.0152051467,
-0.041522719,
0.026485445,
-0.0549992844,
-0.0264395326,
-0.0150050176,
0.081769444,
0.026588995,
0.0377615578,
-0.0264094174,
0.0532204434,
-0.0360559113,
0.0537991375,
-0.0347656831,
0.0019293072,
0.0005205945,
0.0265050884,
-0.0156535264,
0.0129212551,
-0.0141930142,
-0.0269134063,
0.009515305,
-0.0350611284,
0.0027158803,
0.0613328591,
-0.0047300886,
-0.0381147787,
0.0296277162,
0.0888440907,
-0.0217570588,
0.0114893066,
-0.0103790062,
-0.0339959152,
0.0234345999,
-0.0164775811,
0.0183562171,
-0.0931383446,
-0.0506961793,
0.0417422727,
-0.0195582975,
-0.0234418549,
0.0257961135,
0.0509633943,
0.0417708494,
-0.0065630605,
-0.0070056729,
0.0080596572,
0.0910776779,
-0.006962568,
0.0071091275,
0.0063348245,
0.0478581414,
0.0102590248,
0.0154123884,
-0.0860395879,
0.0609093681,
-0.0058385599,
-0.0389822461,
-0.002614015,
0.0188509468,
0.0433583632,
0.034325365,
0.0303905867,
-0.0333735161,
0.0733625144,
0.0293945652,
0.057825584,
0.0191869624,
0.0221867207,
-0.0039091143,
0.0227697827,
0.0631023422,
0.027516745,
0.0319961235,
0.0350081958,
-0.0363190062,
0.0687753111,
-0.0166182779,
0.011744651,
0.0137780514,
0.0475025736,
0.0134903025,
-0.0830991194,
-0.0077335234,
0.0264667515,
-0.0046505453,
0.0430130735,
0.047724463,
-0.0288593136,
-0.0379802361,
0.0029098906,
-0.0127597274,
-0.0670009032,
0.0127906837,
-0.06244516,
0.0516330414,
0.0539703928,
0.0726460069,
-0.0429023802,
-0.0694543421,
-0.0250601787,
-0.0011648438,
0.0321359262,
0.0582747757,
-0.0275064204,
-0.0595446341,
-0.044695437,
0.0033968575,
-0.0609735027,
-0.013270421,
-0.0318875089,
0.031300541,
-0.0305966232,
0.0283181053,
-0.0022564793,
-0.0779863894,
0.0454487354,
-0.0282962564,
-0.0744214281,
-0.0266246237,
-0.0102633657,
0.0012993988,
0.027367413,
-0.0030358769,
0.0303397402,
0.0369530432,
0.0098542832,
0.0164253209,
-0.0503961556,
-0.0659453273,
0.0095864348,
0.0676451921,
-0.0388514809,
-0.0457899906,
0.0128073748,
-0.0119032143,
-0.0070992294,
0.0420649946,
-0.0328474976,
-0.0039412715,
-0.0239354875,
0.0102369124,
-0.0076627033,
-0.0149114123,
-0.0169976912,
0.0428884253,
0.068100974,
0.0299913045,
0.0517299064,
0.050605949,
0.033086028,
-0.0049810498,
-0.0073695644,
0.0409520678,
-0.0178937074,
0.0341177881,
0.0172299445,
0.0436190255,
-0.0868481994,
-0.0094092255,
-0.0425767563,
0.0059745316,
-0.0032214704,
-0.0007556643,
0.0207767002,
-0.0378191732,
-0.0180790126,
0.0247542877,
-0.0291187577,
-0.0623278879,
-0.0296146628,
-0.0070598735,
0.0234094523,
0.0016962616,
-0.012784237,
-0.0346851498,
0.0072678612,
-0.0645371825,
0.020229429,
0.0534683876,
0.0433752947,
-0.0291977394,
0.0454310551,
-0.0039542415,
-0.0368564837,
0.0264165197,
-0.0004373554,
0.0288423672,
-0.0413284935,
0.0939435139,
0.0409156345,
0.0104945442,
0.0396532342,
0.0376170203,
-0.0178173315,
-0.0361962654,
0.0395985916,
0.0210302994,
-0.0425712466,
0.0131546911,
-0.0571091548,
0.0056280666,
0.0228848532,
0.0265714712,
-0.0242988002,
-0.0093454299,
0.0479230434,
-0.0298900735,
0.0159741454,
-0.0402991064,
-0.0197031423,
-0.0287941974,
0.0157859828,
0.0143586574,
-0.0669010356,
0.095938459,
-0.0098207202,
-0.0093522863,
-0.0413482301,
-0.0207640827,
-0.0518327951,
0.0428275205,
0.0126676206,
0.0067076478,
-0.0374398194,
-0.0183380079,
-0.0667576194,
0.0233568605,
-0.0029843489,
-0.0507176518,
0.0435349531,
-0.084789969,
-0.0403326862,
0.0115485694,
0.0253295917,
-0.0375259221,
0.0588081479,
0.0095287971,
-0.0094538219,
0.0043885545,
0.0038385037,
0.0629727468,
-0.034205351,
0.0569854155,
-0.0085283956,
-0.0149117466,
-0.0166928228,
-0.0022868819,
0.0350371599,
0.0109604048,
-0.001777085,
-0.0132699041,
-0.0520819165,
0.0281857569,
0.0154584637,
0.0574684516,
0.0295227673,
-0.0131817088,
0.0159820151,
0.0218671951,
-0.062290553,
0.0221384354,
0.0411873423,
0.0368796214,
-0.0627762675,
-0.029716067,
0.0753057823,
0.0403346233,
-0.0160825234,
-0.0138290934,
-0.0498626903,
-0.0121891033,
0.0622187927,
0.048059348,
-0.0506255291,
-0.0092809321,
-0.0249751378,
0.0406789854,
-0.0484696701,
-0.0107594132,
-0.0037895611,
-0.1175884455,
0.028026931,
0.0085819922,
-0.0088725071,
-0.0193712506,
-0.0237311497,
-0.0143105006,
-0.0033907171,
-0.0069031967,
0.0371201746,
0.0021269289,
0.0423317924,
0.0558913387,
-0.0042962409,
0.0127712134,
0.0307179131,
0.0226140097,
0.0119121419,
0.0559730083,
0.0045361323,
-0.059488304,
-0.0210719425,
0.027440045,
-0.0416032672,
-0.0000708258,
-0.008087771,
-0.0009130791,
-0.0082691172,
0.0003266575,
-0.0315872654,
0.0316621922,
-0.0182107519,
-0.0273405332,
0.0927889347,
0.0655428022,
-0.0303965677,
-0.0394962728,
-0.0533170365,
-0.0044649877,
-0.031555213,
0.0422598235,
0.0426460505,
-0.0343143344,
0.0113639953,
-0.0821831301,
0.0087805782,
-0.0500034466,
-0.0162952077,
-0.0134702558,
0.0083002029,
0.0463215113,
-0.002606065,
-0.0316845141,
0.1056778505,
-0.0210194699,
0.0117041962,
-0.0094070472,
0.0036312388,
0.0231093559,
-0.0534468777,
-0.0167877395,
-0.0043057515,
-0.0020662786,
-0.0408685543,
-0.055550091,
0.0005193661,
-0.0548897646,
-0.0331857577,
0.048601009,
-0.0669258684,
-0.0445179082,
-0.0052194498,
0.0418159664,
0.0140841082,
-0.0472725444,
0.0241894834,
0.0146997636,
-0.0289067868,
0.0243491009,
0.0050177635,
0.0150742372,
-0.0533408672,
0.0268481374,
0.0000807751,
-0.0501060113,
-0.0408683643,
-0.001631949,
-0.0063666115,
0.0421682969,
-0.0008571435,
-0.0241156667,
0.0459889136,
0.0685409158,
-0.0361746959,
-0.0130325733,
-0.0316284969,
-0.0225040503,
0.0098226015,
0.0018608962,
-0.0451686345,
0.0115145687,
-0.0241933689,
0.0047645369,
-0.0193735529,
0.0376381576,
0.0021323562,
-0.0425675921,
0.0546402,
-0.0145603586,
0.052611094,
-0.0102401385,
0.0262975227,
0.0287434198,
-0.0346245915,
-0.0344567373,
-0.0086197508,
-0.0072315657,
0.0611410886,
0.0166762117,
0.0794336647,
-0.0181207266,
0.0268453248,
0.0435906984,
0.0111271776,
-0.0326722786,
-0.0497395806,
-0.0170812756,
0.0266917255,
-0.0055218549,
0.0403624848,
-0.0347131118,
-0.0316892043,
0.0141452942,
-0.0072097387,
0.0482121408,
0.0120738298,
-0.0398904644,
0.0085026128,
0.0399232581,
0.0127725285,
-0.0299811624,
0.0405778848,
-0.0145041123,
0.003287358,
0.0047181523,
-0.0096266763,
-0.0465972535,
-0.0127755245,
0.0086339982,
0.0145245986,
0.0271345098,
0.003786708,
-0.0544586852,
-0.0734604225,
-0.0233630966,
0.01999823,
0.0556705445,
-0.0511122495,
0.036352057,
0.0591469556,
-0.0586082339,
-0.0130899837,
0.0016158527,
0.0540268309,
-0.0358210988,
-0.049218379,
-0.010700345,
-5.627815488e-33,
-0.0291854925,
-0.0714545771,
0.0600455217,
0.0376241542,
-0.0012361795,
-0.0378074087,
-0.0319289975,
0.0424858145,
-0.0248395074,
-0.0385100655,
0.0257728845,
-0.002581981,
-0.0245588068,
0.016314311,
0.022863213,
-0.0063224663,
0.0077109453,
0.0148133356,
-0.0191607848,
0.0557140149,
-0.0183192119,
-0.0181993991,
0.0321545117,
-0.0105254371,
0.0042294161,
-0.0563725494,
0.0278785601,
-0.0427672341,
-0.0680600852,
0.0262887329,
0.0020195723,
0.0361190252,
0.0110444818,
-0.0238579083,
0.0087818112,
0.0001861845,
0.0137859117,
-0.0640983731,
-0.0059091961,
-0.0488990396,
-0.0190946516,
-0.0836068466,
0.0458996706,
-0.0029258905,
-0.0251719002,
0.0006819478,
0.0632819012,
0.0038136181,
0.024346536,
-0.0034694769,
-0.0554895364,
0.0029518243,
-0.0801209882,
0.0000312505,
-0.0454383753,
0.0336522833,
-0.0070703183,
0.0530151688,
0.0112363631,
0.0511964671,
0.0289034173,
0.0325609744,
0.0765581802,
-0.0127024418,
-0.0089631947,
-0.0078498023,
0.0212228615,
0.0015582467,
-0.0031991636,
0.0174150057,
-0.0138237923,
0.0215498041,
0.0633782744,
0.0432348102,
-0.0021602204,
-0.0001593546,
-0.053896904,
0.0302640665,
-0.0186498575,
-0.0038803951,
0.0092225969,
-0.0407539457,
-0.0392062925,
-0.0108285565,
-0.0445336699,
-0.003501649,
-0.0163692832,
-0.0273128673,
0.0427912436,
-0.0638187602,
-0.0312413238,
0.0090728579,
0.0001963552,
0.0098481346,
0.0066605518,
-0.016551327,
-0.0553442538,
0.0677472726,
-0.0137661742,
0.0147923781,
-0.0223779175,
0.0221536532,
0.0166192949,
-0.01647087,
0.0758316964,
0.0161641669,
-0.016115088,
0.0026545918,
-0.0365454145,
-0.0151567664,
-0.0726901963,
0.0000209018,
0.0118573122,
-0.0044778935,
-0.0071591977,
0.0310610812,
-0.0135160126,
0.0068647442,
0.0062720948,
-0.0487063974,
-0.06031885,
-0.0637277588,
-0.0216361582,
-0.027841337,
-0.0255373251,
-0.0026550267,
-0.0416851453,
0.0338494293,
0.0040575517,
-0.0346468687,
-0.0304944925,
0.0184956491,
2.827e-7,
0.0220370609,
0.0444363467,
0.0131050674,
0.0593966544,
-0.0139066372,
0.0135172326,
-0.0223103222,
-0.0222289041,
0.0472239144,
-0.0022203699,
-0.0223999433,
0.0486521162,
0.0154343965,
0.0340390056,
-0.0373349898,
0.0164045673,
0.0095013846,
-0.0111109866,
-0.0749555454,
0.0586185753,
0.1101837158,
-0.0256364308,
0.0014579765,
0.00304842,
-0.0052680536,
-0.0362904705,
-0.0071250703,
-0.011447927,
0.0162807498,
0.0603239201,
-0.0720792636,
0.0140976282,
0.0077458126,
0.0227142442,
0.0046376707,
-0.0813132226,
0.0276163369,
0.0284592584,
0.0321885236,
-0.0064759096,
0.0339242965,
0.0159820858,
0.0210875813,
-0.0807576552,
0.0227266904,
-0.0018187065,
0.0006324987,
0.0139887054,
-0.0416646786,
-0.024468489,
-0.0378539115,
-0.0324599706,
0.0278547499,
-0.0106550511,
-0.0446514189,
-0.0118396999,
0.0021330076,
0.0156563185,
-0.0103076398,
-0.0174956266,
-0.0213654451,
-0.0547994301,
-0.0671413839,
-0.0481170528,
0.0022404608,
-0.0022284582,
0.0098237628,
2.53118946e-34,
0.0019303442,
-0.0354885906,
0.0551676191,
0.0429654419,
0.0205234215,
0.0255897306,
-0.0025113865,
0.0123927165,
-0.0062557817,
-0.014540174,
-0.0296711586
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03171v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03171v1 | Combining Counting Processes and Classification Improves a Stopping Rule for Technology Assisted Review | 2023-12-05T22:28:42 | 2023-12-05T22:28:42 | Reem Bin-Hezam, Mark Stevenson | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | Technology Assisted Review (TAR) stopping rules aim to reduce the cost of
manually assessing documents for relevance by minimising the number of
documents that need to be examined to ensure a desired level of recall. This
paper extends an effective stopping rule using information derived from a text
classifier that can be trained without the need for any additional annotation.
Experiments on multiple data sets (CLEF e-Health, TREC Total Recall, TREC Legal
and RCV1) showed that the proposed approach consistently improves performance
and outperforms several alternative methods. | [
0.0401147865,
-0.0105519276,
-0.0019607842,
-0.0547830388,
-0.0402336642,
0.0043352763,
-0.00209353,
0.030038707,
-0.029768629,
-0.0821184888,
0.0132508241,
-0.0335792229,
-0.0141467443,
0.0505158827,
-0.0271434542,
0.0017484379,
0.0249726251,
0.0164260808,
0.0575988032,
0.0181931071,
0.0016115201,
0.005681986,
0.0047097709,
0.0238067377,
0.0233821534,
0.025833331,
0.0344709419,
-0.0304578319,
-0.0056563406,
-0.0523193702,
-0.0152132669,
0.041579701,
0.0048480546,
0.0561928861,
0.0000019795,
-0.0497110263,
-0.0443315133,
0.0128766755,
-0.0063046324,
-0.0228235573,
0.0690442324,
-0.0067857262,
0.0307145286,
0.0236518923,
0.0167966802,
-0.0115097631,
-0.004914334,
0.0778107494,
0.0107483873,
0.0288988873,
-0.0208326019,
0.0230686348,
0.0148256421,
0.0105782049,
0.0149607975,
-0.0140950382,
0.0086844172,
0.0140466765,
0.0568482317,
-0.045564916,
0.0252056289,
0.0265882388,
-0.0082766758,
-0.0161189437,
0.0056313663,
0.034076333,
-0.0264947768,
0.0228926707,
-0.0094063301,
0.0163595825,
0.0607930459,
-0.0359401256,
0.0193512272,
0.0166971125,
-0.0027959626,
0.0364248455,
-0.0271893181,
-0.0199459828,
-0.0042983806,
-0.005752374,
0.0041997,
0.0544010513,
-0.0263597909,
0.0023241057,
0.0324484333,
0.0130929584,
-0.0000925131,
-0.0343377255,
0.0836777762,
0.0730482116,
0.0622880086,
-0.0147343306,
0.0176076796,
-0.0043011522,
-0.0238405,
-0.0424985103,
0.0269044694,
-0.0022020815,
0.052123908,
-0.035705898,
0.0535219386,
-0.0042860177,
0.0021702226,
0.0712176487,
-0.0067241807,
-0.0486736,
0.0124173425,
-0.0352792628,
0.0006767722,
0.0264974292,
-0.0617386475,
-0.0006673145,
-0.000411611,
0.0372795202,
0.0536150821,
-0.0038630867,
-0.0866038054,
0.0066101658,
0.0005313634,
-0.0125712948,
0.0112318136,
-0.013878339,
0.0049529276,
0.0270750392,
-0.0118822521,
-0.0206040312,
-0.0247722436,
0.0354227014,
-0.0709600672,
-0.0136465775,
0.0356032923,
-0.0000107777,
0.0513603017,
0.0027212093,
0.0131796068,
-0.0318047889,
0.0056360969,
-0.0650533587,
-0.0492683128,
-0.0515817888,
-0.0027908613,
-0.0409631915,
-0.0327796154,
-0.0258935466,
-0.0576061383,
-0.0277452655,
0.0258333981,
0.0117042018,
-0.0273136944,
0.0024742153,
-0.0192071293,
0.0035924681,
-0.0060985484,
-0.0186066106,
0.0417162031,
-0.0077046831,
-0.0331183411,
0.0477903448,
-0.0100324582,
-0.0024796322,
0.0212103017,
0.0015212226,
0.0344845057,
-0.0129774166,
-0.0121372882,
-0.010201484,
-0.0161893032,
0.0145890182,
-0.0452348627,
-0.0423588082,
-0.0292777047,
-0.0083366344,
-0.0165008381,
0.0313216262,
0.0210211072,
0.0035249142,
0.0389699638,
-0.0148491422,
-0.0241952669,
0.0093892282,
-0.0092143621,
0.0126759298,
0.0235617682,
0.0481760874,
-0.0580359995,
-0.0194587186,
-0.0124356784,
-0.0592079423,
-0.0584099554,
-0.0236243941,
-0.0043899128,
0.044882834,
-0.0202110726,
-0.0172913913,
0.0643499419,
-0.0162035245,
-0.0040865964,
-0.019189328,
-0.0143159088,
0.0008343576,
-0.0069635562,
-0.0281889308,
0.0225339849,
0.0593757555,
0.0672569573,
-0.0413818471,
-0.0197085012,
-0.0269010998,
0.005589216,
-0.0303556677,
0.0506359637,
-0.0012018074,
-0.0269826148,
-0.0378561392,
-0.0548429377,
0.0180768333,
0.0071192426,
-0.0262584724,
0.0004975583,
0.0749819651,
0.0009131499,
-0.035374172,
-0.0233761631,
0.0439328626,
0.0758396164,
-0.0104984306,
0.0178412385,
-0.0006422236,
0.0476992913,
0.0249656066,
-0.0061162943,
-0.0121201277,
0.04165278,
-0.0026881793,
-0.0209437162,
-0.0099819731,
0.048113741,
0.0198736545,
0.0099142417,
-0.0130457934,
-0.016096158,
0.0397927538,
0.0266979244,
-0.0419143103,
-0.0282269455,
-0.0461541675,
0.034025874,
-0.0526409149,
0.0233484991,
-0.0357567184,
-0.0400168076,
-0.0076246257,
0.0502924807,
0.0244150683,
0.0254388154,
-0.020542223,
-0.0950500146,
-0.0082846163,
-0.0234104097,
-0.0159021914,
-0.0396437161,
-0.008131572,
0.0000522606,
0.0567424409,
0.0370982997,
-0.0255970098,
-0.0221267026,
-0.0753561854,
-0.0150487423,
-0.0090619894,
0.0214766171,
-0.0476005822,
-0.0473916866,
0.0033061805,
-0.0143470718,
-0.0231061559,
-0.0493710004,
0.015633652,
0.0192930121,
-0.0014407183,
0.0058419774,
-0.0243441332,
-0.002960061,
-0.0019688688,
-0.0003339156,
0.0448716134,
0.0640964732,
-0.0809181929,
-0.0294319913,
0.0309796296,
0.0103990696,
-0.0157773681,
0.0199820679,
0.0324785747,
-0.0033889031,
0.0065522734,
-0.042932339,
-0.0045929938,
-0.0108961416,
0.0102303382,
0.0516392104,
0.0060006557,
-0.0677694604,
-0.0251309182,
-0.0143754408,
0.0412869863,
0.0723167956,
-0.0506059006,
0.0429567657,
-0.0072119324,
-0.0177514106,
0.0234517455,
-0.022163365,
0.0007867109,
-0.0315269642,
-0.0223403387,
-0.0545317307,
-0.0237300787,
0.0087057007,
0.0086528314,
0.0326884985,
-0.0026442718,
0.055027511,
0.0254675951,
0.0239731297,
-0.1072464883,
0.0347764418,
0.0021260392,
0.0310984738,
0.0031262739,
0.0187302772,
-0.0064594061,
0.0032821645,
0.0269570258,
-0.017901808,
0.0303066969,
-0.0150495255,
0.0251622237,
-0.0565533452,
0.0499343984,
-0.0095272139,
-0.0054489942,
-0.0212372057,
-0.0209412854,
0.0059616556,
0.0114370082,
-0.0287647806,
0.0132327443,
-0.092631124,
0.0623890236,
0.0449372977,
0.1075221971,
-0.0074973274,
-0.0521959849,
0.054010801,
0.0529955588,
0.0388927795,
-0.0806103349,
-0.0008178358,
0.0146408435,
0.0370931588,
0.0613796525,
0.012476746,
0.050698027,
0.0113716703,
-0.0037645961,
0.007387497,
-0.0856753662,
-0.0152726704,
0.0094872434,
-0.0185662862,
-0.0509630181,
-0.0164556485,
0.0851893276,
0.0470411479,
-0.090330787,
-0.0420958437,
0.0318472497,
-0.0643797219,
-0.0165811572,
0.0080971355,
-0.0398128405,
-0.0106614726,
0.0025645487,
0.0317039788,
-0.0616925657,
-0.0061042574,
-0.0011319791,
-0.0441686176,
0.0408885963,
-0.0150841409,
-0.0906976238,
-0.0311387144,
-0.0146446042,
0.0412947424,
-0.0035554115,
-0.0672312006,
0.0143039431,
-0.0317051075,
0.0006135061,
0.0252874605,
-0.0554951318,
-0.0240325872,
0.055657845,
0.0157421585,
-0.0072751278,
0.0351889059,
0.0084001403,
-0.032849025,
-0.0103747826,
0.0373316631,
-0.0575977564,
-0.0000896514,
-0.0341158584,
0.0737172291,
0.0235401448,
0.0358243249,
-0.0118158469,
0.0387649536,
0.0005157061,
0.0457058735,
0.0423574708,
0.073519282,
-0.0379130989,
-0.0304989126,
-0.0165863838,
0.0254843049,
-0.0300907176,
0.0257799774,
-0.017668942,
-0.0329071805,
-0.0053885458,
0.0301549826,
0.0407711081,
-0.0334283113,
0.0060165045,
-0.0198451672,
-0.0688195303,
-0.0640034601,
-0.0759695694,
-0.0191601422,
0.0099392114,
0.0661326721,
0.0069588227,
0.0283958279,
-0.0067560454,
0.0447059982,
-0.0239589959,
0.0033150837,
-0.0071742805,
0.0128581356,
-0.0495935827,
-0.0043648705,
0.0256922785,
0.0376906507,
-0.0027712209,
-0.0224933643,
0.0298737101,
-0.0010127174,
0.0035038579,
0.0082252705,
0.0244336929,
-0.030771276,
-0.0020622925,
-0.0260439329,
0.0237878617,
-0.0089052692,
-0.0151580879,
-0.020704126,
0.0005973371,
-0.0500252731,
-0.038392473,
-0.011540099,
-0.0483693331,
0.0399055593,
0.0132018765,
-0.0003821233,
-0.0653861091,
0.0166605804,
0.0022171317,
-0.0155475605,
0.0209116023,
-0.0116854766,
0.0333725363,
-0.0258369558,
0.0356764048,
0.0084712831,
0.010321727,
-0.0147813475,
0.0288768932,
-0.0043971827,
-0.0093673142,
-0.0768432841,
0.0543998815,
-0.045245517,
0.048591923,
-0.0718316957,
0.049693007,
0.0503774323,
0.0836427957,
-0.0442639031,
-0.0436510853,
-0.0510161072,
-0.018215362,
0.0203805827,
0.0175372437,
0.0121470839,
0.0383405611,
0.0041509401,
0.0120766098,
-0.0378872678,
0.0082945684,
-0.0367668569,
0.0561392456,
-0.0286859572,
0.0218044203,
0.0102168657,
-0.0120851649,
0.0100981332,
-0.0266160816,
-0.0133380387,
-0.011691872,
0.0144569594,
0.0350177288,
0.0542982146,
-0.030896863,
0.0202381499,
-0.0092444662,
0.0162755139,
0.0572662801,
-0.0183813181,
-0.033721026,
-0.0163027365,
-0.09598618,
-0.0225709993,
-0.0160225853,
0.0070611672,
0.0134000862,
0.0129310191,
-0.0165720787,
-0.0726896226,
0.0288249664,
0.0373102017,
-0.0344632305,
0.0644808188,
0.0005048249,
0.0197876021,
0.0434820615,
0.0154230604,
-0.013319158,
-0.0552334897,
-0.0139032314,
0.0155648114,
0.0367723219,
-0.0370464399,
-5.838744358e-33,
0.0125897918,
-0.0485155657,
-0.0254305117,
0.0456584767,
0.0167476684,
0.0324277654,
0.0057316748,
-0.0511175953,
0.0421054438,
0.0205089506,
-0.0126997354,
0.0043735988,
0.0218201559,
-0.0299373027,
0.0328246392,
0.0404763408,
0.0399491973,
0.0091941981,
-0.0204896349,
0.0360783972,
0.0296836589,
0.0037608165,
0.0305824894,
-0.0215668064,
0.0652427673,
0.0732846111,
-0.0254542138,
-0.0520887375,
0.034156289,
0.0242532026,
-0.0200184397,
0.0037866812,
0.0467565469,
-0.0688273311,
0.0161239263,
0.0590188019,
-0.0486664809,
-0.0395691767,
-0.0250911638,
-0.0073568313,
0.0581154637,
0.0154097574,
0.0169110801,
-0.0317754112,
-0.0658231378,
0.0645926148,
0.0458550788,
-0.0234779641,
-0.0728004947,
-0.1368542463,
-0.0306920242,
0.0659286827,
0.016310066,
0.0084491083,
-0.021385299,
0.0707807317,
-0.0091132745,
0.0145493206,
-0.1001314968,
0.0107050072,
0.0181398559,
-0.0047451425,
-0.0343239531,
-0.0451858491,
-0.0243233684,
0.0271168314,
-0.06148839,
-0.0024178412,
0.0157509819,
-0.0312134158,
0.0110168662,
-0.052227892,
0.0378324986,
-0.0021192438,
0.0768996179,
-0.0264772065,
-0.0568994731,
0.0642808452,
0.033227656,
0.0635073707,
0.0796683058,
-0.0253727119,
-0.0969548747,
-0.000984494,
0.0213613976,
0.0135726379,
-0.0141622089,
0.0050831432,
0.0246156286,
0.0305332839,
-0.0255319588,
-0.021243928,
-0.0084873745,
0.0130654862,
-0.0017710933,
-0.0298267175,
0.0207706895,
0.0487739258,
-0.0056763161,
-0.0466899946,
-0.02199018,
-0.0018236357,
0.0148552209,
0.0217435323,
-0.0015290695,
-0.0536253266,
0.0655027479,
0.0152041437,
-0.08887095,
-0.0000253711,
0.0416804887,
0.0192197897,
0.0030289053,
0.0072697327,
-0.0139807565,
-0.0063050301,
0.051922895,
0.0549287759,
-0.0274686702,
0.0287234187,
-0.0202225372,
-0.0051456317,
-0.0090312529,
-0.0107269399,
-0.0019120539,
-0.0028447325,
0.0173020586,
0.0184920747,
-0.0128629673,
-0.0046304842,
0.0278036185,
0.0263689421,
2.696e-7,
0.0511458404,
0.0254284237,
-0.0357235409,
-0.0783483312,
0.0109885344,
-0.0032225982,
0.0327075385,
-0.0093446728,
0.0220553372,
0.0605822951,
0.0733994097,
-0.0259102061,
0.0113579687,
0.0693854019,
-0.0541756414,
-0.0754291266,
-0.029334899,
0.0020884492,
-0.0096785435,
-0.024693558,
-0.0052072909,
0.0321349166,
-0.0025630984,
-0.0229808632,
-0.0214574337,
-0.0652914122,
0.0349247493,
-0.0357467495,
-0.0353724808,
0.0069572926,
0.1262403429,
-0.03201662,
-0.0009289107,
0.0080086002,
-0.0362564288,
0.0264531597,
-0.0279534962,
0.0413044617,
-0.0192944184,
0.0166495703,
0.0382764712,
-0.0046981699,
0.0293574408,
0.0298919808,
0.054102622,
-0.0097159613,
0.0069306628,
-0.015360212,
-0.0148532838,
-0.0296923332,
0.0624746792,
0.0113356179,
-0.0537799858,
0.0586339682,
0.0021094445,
-0.0386325829,
-0.0089887911,
-0.042086117,
0.0284975152,
0.0357519165,
0.0342918783,
-0.0382106155,
0.0060486789,
-0.0651083067,
-0.0379172228,
-0.0582083687,
0.0222079903,
2.443616509e-34,
0.0648589209,
-0.0310647972,
-0.0228475742,
-0.0244808123,
-0.006890845,
0.0388027914,
0.0079812333,
-0.0160208754,
0.0316874869,
-0.068160899,
0.0245958511
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03769v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03769v1 | GPT vs Human for Scientific Reviews: A Dual Source Review on Applications of ChatGPT in Science | 2023-12-05T21:41:52 | 2023-12-05T21:41:52 | Chenxi Wu, Alan John Varghese, Vivek Oommen, George Em Karniadakis | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The new polymath Large Language Models (LLMs) can speed-up greatly scientific
reviews, possibly using more unbiased quantitative metrics, facilitating
cross-disciplinary connections, and identifying emerging trends and research
gaps by analyzing large volumes of data. However, at the present time, they
lack the required deep understanding of complex methodologies, they have
difficulty in evaluating innovative claims, and they are unable to assess
ethical issues and conflicts of interest. Herein, we consider 13 GPT-related
papers across different scientific domains, reviewed by a human reviewer and
SciSpace, a large language model, with the reviews evaluated by three distinct
types of evaluators, namely GPT-3.5, a crowd panel, and GPT-4. We found that
50% of SciSpace's responses to objective questions align with those of a human
reviewer, with GPT-4 (informed evaluator) often rating the human reviewer
higher in accuracy, and SciSpace higher in structure, clarity, and
completeness. In subjective questions, the uninformed evaluators (GPT-3.5 and
crowd panel) showed varying preferences between SciSpace and human responses,
with the crowd panel showing a preference for the human responses. However,
GPT-4 rated them equally in accuracy and structure but favored SciSpace for
completeness. | [
0.0579198003,
0.0298494175,
0.0065414831,
-0.0030836307,
-0.0530128628,
-0.015263061,
0.0474518612,
-0.0121628717,
0.0114177773,
-0.0347826891,
-0.0708289817,
-0.04735649,
0.0101719163,
0.0298899673,
0.0247039758,
-0.0127342241,
0.0132829184,
-0.0058176741,
0.070061706,
-0.0065677073,
0.0066605643,
-0.0282179415,
0.0227119271,
0.0314880796,
0.0559738576,
-0.0163352191,
0.0380598381,
-0.0469767563,
-0.0019994886,
-0.0511156991,
-0.0039317813,
0.0928967893,
0.0104658855,
0.1112395376,
0.0000021163,
-0.0417886563,
0.0048798895,
0.0758578554,
0.0152368052,
0.0663744435,
0.0581216179,
0.0145879667,
0.0038093794,
-0.0119596347,
-0.0196068883,
-0.0348829068,
0.0335879475,
0.0224578306,
-0.0062612225,
-0.0023520421,
-0.0041925153,
-0.006143393,
0.0296665039,
-0.023690477,
0.0144015858,
-0.0260548517,
0.0263143014,
0.0169933978,
0.0560262576,
0.0584712178,
0.0222163163,
0.0258236639,
0.0061054425,
-0.0503363721,
0.0207395572,
0.012715213,
-0.0595250577,
-0.0298034213,
0.0213597603,
0.0367221311,
0.0734793544,
-0.0188056845,
-0.0278653614,
0.0005239424,
-0.0074873348,
0.0620052628,
-0.056635201,
-0.0022066415,
0.0022249694,
-0.0274581537,
-0.0312291067,
0.0036871952,
0.0143404985,
0.0305936672,
0.0331640691,
0.0783401877,
0.0201581363,
-0.0489829853,
0.0283697993,
0.0507818945,
0.0125824241,
-0.030710144,
-0.0250121653,
-0.0349109545,
0.0017310693,
-0.0162218809,
0.0748017654,
0.01069781,
0.0614509284,
-0.049050007,
0.0168860275,
0.0035234015,
0.0263683181,
0.0313352123,
0.0292233881,
0.0014126525,
-0.0265573468,
0.0184345674,
0.0093621984,
0.0378032178,
-0.0455682687,
-0.0275984164,
0.0153494598,
-0.0143126361,
0.0022306868,
0.0223210398,
-0.0807957873,
-0.0302540623,
-0.036888957,
-0.0342965014,
0.0066007986,
0.0135675846,
0.0035171914,
-0.0009696675,
-0.0237758178,
0.0540947169,
-0.0094833961,
0.0360822752,
-0.0321197845,
-0.0295093842,
-0.0154902702,
0.0235963333,
-0.0156549625,
-0.0153388828,
0.0037797927,
0.0484876335,
0.0331644602,
-0.0192028452,
0.0840406194,
-0.0134625062,
-0.0271027368,
-0.0651106313,
-0.0322360583,
-0.0527872443,
0.0181596614,
-0.0004488399,
0.0016030212,
-0.0056927949,
-0.0171943773,
-0.0148418248,
-0.0092201736,
0.0456249937,
-0.0648543015,
0.0062072421,
0.0048043719,
0.0182573292,
-0.0324822217,
-0.0014859268,
-0.0143752452,
-0.0116211185,
0.017295111,
-0.0305898599,
0.0501350239,
-0.0258710999,
-0.0108970236,
0.0184427854,
0.0482579321,
0.0449512862,
-0.0158502813,
0.0281450022,
-0.0137398615,
0.078794688,
-0.0741239339,
-0.0010371362,
0.0685423836,
0.0551481657,
-0.0402727909,
0.045692198,
-0.0036946284,
0.0029813272,
0.0478874594,
0.0022165293,
-0.0313711762,
0.0336154141,
-0.0406369492,
-0.007762508,
0.0396830775,
0.0198556352,
0.0161719397,
-0.0203992762,
-0.0138131995,
0.0406310707,
0.0432004854,
-0.0246135592,
0.0280519947,
-0.0447012521,
-0.0113254152,
-0.032548897,
0.0183511954,
-0.016572509,
-0.0210053399,
-0.0344429314,
0.0214665066,
0.0193984825,
0.0355714411,
0.0078093871,
-0.0229427274,
-0.0214234684,
-0.0357930176,
0.0328786634,
0.04977227,
-0.0079676099,
-0.0707172155,
0.0092872512,
-0.0299402382,
-0.0352832377,
-0.0029072054,
0.0049223518,
0.0206275973,
0.0467879549,
-0.0212037936,
-0.013665759,
-0.0502815694,
-0.0091169169,
0.008937113,
-0.0089456718,
-0.0131834,
-0.0467301719,
0.0706303269,
0.0202132389,
-0.0203939937,
0.0570084155,
0.013932256,
0.0052987039,
-0.0582713895,
0.0056529189,
0.0361130573,
0.0452202857,
0.0112546757,
-0.0383422263,
0.0049247239,
0.0049399193,
0.0098032653,
0.006953394,
0.018190667,
0.0132273417,
0.0019261482,
-0.028638877,
-0.0255408771,
-0.0480151176,
-0.0268850699,
-0.0187491681,
0.0070620836,
0.041305244,
0.0605271719,
-0.0067350194,
-0.0394707993,
0.024334928,
0.0027364243,
-0.0525383241,
0.0441202559,
0.0407081321,
0.0143602462,
0.0606514513,
0.0055146106,
-0.0203568917,
-0.0259138197,
-0.084108606,
-0.027455572,
0.0231814533,
0.0303103607,
0.0040429514,
-0.0719866082,
0.0110594286,
0.0397501029,
-0.0251295511,
-0.0423686393,
-0.000374482,
0.0299683884,
0.0421704613,
-0.0036892479,
0.003729332,
-0.057590466,
-0.0363918543,
-0.0239334088,
0.0240424592,
0.0878533348,
-0.0160004143,
-0.0329430364,
0.0049010217,
-0.0418014005,
-0.0140423551,
0.0054797507,
-0.008075037,
0.0517773554,
0.0119831264,
-0.0131379804,
-0.0003675391,
-0.0134142125,
0.0022359572,
0.0373427384,
0.0282856058,
-0.0131303528,
-0.0336369313,
-0.0095883198,
-0.015395334,
0.0238121711,
-0.0189837441,
0.0485934243,
0.0257905964,
-0.0120030884,
-0.0237476714,
-0.0379900299,
0.0300711542,
-0.0552191846,
-0.0126436958,
-0.0008625367,
-0.0665915981,
-0.0094549982,
0.0384025425,
0.0191956107,
-0.0356755182,
0.0624848194,
-0.0255048666,
-0.0110197105,
-0.0951352194,
0.0350376368,
-0.0397224799,
0.0130930971,
-0.0039408314,
0.0112043601,
-0.0179480519,
0.0404065251,
-0.0133069679,
-0.0110116256,
0.0334283374,
-0.0035047154,
-0.0083318008,
-0.0426614098,
0.0456753634,
-0.0033103905,
-0.019727705,
0.0466544591,
-0.0336300693,
-0.0207683537,
0.017460987,
0.0614400245,
-0.0338940844,
-0.0157716144,
0.0438638814,
0.068567425,
0.0230145883,
-0.0472988561,
-0.0032674405,
0.0132036256,
-0.0292013977,
0.0246738531,
-0.0055688135,
0.064603433,
-0.0367596932,
0.0135604134,
0.085049361,
-0.0073291804,
0.0017322683,
-0.0020975024,
-0.038979847,
0.0295302235,
-0.0130449776,
-0.0469474867,
-0.0101512671,
0.0599237755,
-0.0358342305,
0.0563475825,
0.0675116256,
-0.0110049667,
-0.0983543247,
-0.0286818203,
-0.0281215068,
-0.02451084,
-0.0001046176,
0.0154203223,
-0.0703040436,
0.0137913637,
-0.0135063119,
0.0089978259,
-0.0277114492,
-0.0260482971,
-0.0099024065,
-0.0449700542,
0.0451137647,
0.0070084054,
-0.0723717958,
-0.0068635959,
-0.0549016409,
0.0280483253,
-0.0207283534,
0.0139898164,
0.0293516275,
0.007032108,
0.0240509398,
-0.0264418088,
-0.0348584168,
-0.0198133495,
0.07990852,
-0.0409575365,
0.0648114011,
0.0151837962,
0.014816233,
-0.044576373,
-0.0295393597,
0.0454918183,
0.0180245228,
-0.0454293713,
0.0110057825,
0.0118348878,
0.0100048864,
0.0258269198,
-0.0606388859,
0.0177050643,
-0.0307187922,
0.0153470756,
-0.0138140507,
0.0839304402,
-0.0045470134,
-0.0341073126,
-0.0337933302,
0.0207235049,
-0.027505789,
0.0599471629,
-0.0146867707,
-0.0486624613,
-0.0544086248,
-0.0092162928,
0.0079114418,
0.0293317921,
-0.082848981,
-0.0277821291,
0.0197241027,
-0.0445552357,
-0.0444414094,
-0.0309867356,
0.0131855272,
0.0049638744,
0.0076454552,
0.016033873,
0.0372808725,
0.0040116855,
0.0445606112,
0.0648869798,
0.0191211719,
0.0101047577,
-0.0348498747,
-0.001531938,
0.067512691,
0.008346892,
-0.0208761618,
0.0282788761,
0.0055563082,
-0.0324332714,
-0.0433962122,
0.0234299675,
0.0284260716,
-0.0165238641,
-0.0145163611,
-0.0215131082,
-0.0252611153,
0.0216235109,
-0.0239365287,
-0.0165913459,
-0.0225536078,
0.0047751772,
-0.0015950055,
-0.0278270785,
0.0049138353,
0.0099183265,
0.0085290233,
-0.0127831157,
-0.0263794549,
-0.0528149754,
0.0391431227,
0.0458669104,
0.0278125983,
-0.0322631299,
0.0433035642,
-0.0011006042,
-0.0560469739,
-0.0493166,
0.0073175454,
-0.045701351,
-0.0364452153,
0.0157219656,
0.015462121,
-0.0237860531,
0.0058640223,
-0.027767675,
0.0550306253,
-0.0650900602,
0.0786015168,
-0.0271333139,
0.0159933195,
0.0210543703,
-0.0037580044,
-0.0270186514,
-0.021989366,
-0.0662259683,
0.0263755638,
-0.0034760118,
0.0264908094,
-0.0041040196,
-0.0050310493,
0.0315572247,
0.0276276786,
-0.1089706942,
-0.0685802326,
-0.0277231447,
0.0537885688,
-0.039924629,
0.0668308139,
0.0563054681,
-0.0303418431,
-0.0316388272,
-0.0312568992,
-0.0011642639,
0.0086634494,
0.0489953086,
0.0258808173,
0.0247381683,
-0.0416199453,
-0.0408606455,
0.0609402582,
0.0232837163,
-0.0241769273,
-0.0460956879,
-0.0639667585,
-0.0017401034,
-0.055200357,
-0.0612973496,
-0.0068671172,
-0.0091744009,
-0.0162072238,
-0.098285459,
-0.0113912392,
-0.035475336,
0.0327849016,
-0.0026043968,
-0.0405638255,
-0.020964127,
0.0567942485,
-0.0138453636,
-0.0506176613,
-0.0187231023,
0.0304087419,
0.0070441072,
-0.0264880117,
-0.016207004,
-6.597758122e-33,
0.0265092757,
-0.0369475111,
-0.0075676586,
0.0198874976,
-0.0465418063,
-0.0000502763,
-0.0363460779,
0.0253445059,
-0.0038345058,
0.0511661246,
-0.0205340683,
0.0090172039,
-0.0103097726,
-0.0417138599,
0.0570140667,
0.0105211018,
0.0302671771,
-0.025801396,
0.0034759175,
0.0372137874,
-0.0298377629,
-0.0372330137,
0.0377896875,
-0.0648677275,
0.1135961786,
0.0169892851,
-0.0080416612,
-0.0130858673,
-0.0445158258,
0.0187485702,
-0.0295732133,
0.0242229477,
0.0112719554,
-0.0727917328,
0.0218449682,
-0.023063371,
-0.0165608618,
0.0342708305,
0.051412195,
-0.0261412095,
-0.0279386435,
0.006387583,
0.0526743382,
-0.0125540635,
-0.0858618021,
0.0128033282,
0.0270763598,
-0.0269714631,
-0.0238583274,
-0.0374280624,
-0.0424434915,
0.0219245534,
0.0017043279,
0.0571851768,
-0.0146104926,
0.0337678716,
-0.0388083123,
0.0828671232,
-0.0461153835,
0.0210191775,
0.0023156283,
-0.0257260241,
-0.0156219462,
-0.0559746586,
0.0428397171,
0.05959424,
0.0118754311,
0.051256787,
-0.0438793786,
-0.0433971919,
-0.0028367233,
-0.0059894882,
0.0791431516,
0.0764917731,
0.0464163944,
-0.0274937041,
-0.053893283,
0.0034441343,
0.0168502983,
0.0105066085,
0.0646919981,
-0.0161639061,
-0.0227142237,
-0.0366329029,
0.0213735048,
-0.0265058298,
-0.022842126,
-0.0279926099,
-0.0201163683,
-0.038985949,
-0.0043007261,
-0.0130185569,
0.0352922305,
-0.0333731212,
-0.0142762922,
0.0111636687,
-0.0299958866,
0.0737009943,
0.0191502813,
-0.006433663,
-0.0708025172,
0.0427086353,
-0.0391827673,
0.060765475,
0.0344973952,
-0.015171919,
0.0107395826,
0.0090298783,
-0.0566170365,
0.0052665561,
-0.0061589717,
0.0037509487,
0.0563528463,
-0.0011069673,
0.0099297212,
0.0092513869,
0.0278671179,
0.0178906936,
0.0271232165,
0.0706243515,
-0.0267898906,
0.0285634734,
-0.0509749874,
-0.0001229109,
0.0140347639,
-0.003673505,
0.0041668676,
-0.0027251428,
0.0063779186,
-0.0498777479,
-0.0027532922,
-0.0279734787,
2.926e-7,
0.0631775633,
0.0539100058,
-0.0391918309,
-0.0548324659,
0.0653841123,
0.0301442184,
-0.0188589096,
0.0157273859,
0.0438370779,
-0.0160723366,
0.0311092511,
-0.0122295357,
-0.0021825598,
0.0365847647,
-0.05983565,
0.0113980062,
-0.0870439485,
-0.0498807989,
-0.0160989165,
0.0100435754,
0.016121408,
0.0036625979,
-0.0105564473,
0.0119530819,
-0.0327198096,
-0.0237261634,
0.0776360482,
-0.0166496951,
-0.0178736597,
0.0539702475,
0.041583918,
-0.0370885059,
0.0092104981,
0.033604458,
0.0146638984,
-0.0079636984,
0.0525508448,
0.0302264113,
0.0084816087,
0.0265905596,
0.0366705954,
-0.0218527764,
0.0456291102,
-0.0630215928,
0.0374405198,
-0.0282982122,
-0.0681952313,
-0.0600380227,
-0.0204976033,
-0.0424070619,
0.0829270706,
-0.0097090518,
-0.0274768267,
0.0362335034,
-0.033481393,
0.0056715719,
0.0061974097,
-0.0003713499,
-0.0054073427,
0.0122387307,
-0.0508943461,
-0.0670384318,
0.0001281114,
-0.039341867,
0.0058620586,
-0.0011340037,
0.017333515,
2.769239923e-34,
0.1100226045,
-0.0322004333,
0.0244650487,
-0.0263944995,
0.0350469314,
0.062213812,
-0.0019883418,
-0.0258540325,
0.0265980102,
-0.0443721563,
-0.0084887333
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03140v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03140v1 | FlexModel: A Framework for Interpretability of Distributed Large Language Models | 2023-12-05T21:19:33 | 2023-12-05T21:19:33 | Matthew Choi, Muhammad Adil Asif, John Willes, David Emerson | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.DC | With the growth of large language models, now incorporating billions of
parameters, the hardware prerequisites for their training and deployment have
seen a corresponding increase. Although existing tools facilitate model
parallelization and distributed training, deeper model interactions, crucial
for interpretability and responsible AI techniques, still demand thorough
knowledge of distributed computing. This often hinders contributions from
researchers with machine learning expertise but limited distributed computing
background. Addressing this challenge, we present FlexModel, a software package
providing a streamlined interface for engaging with models distributed across
multi-GPU and multi-node configurations. The library is compatible with
existing model distribution libraries and encapsulates PyTorch models. It
exposes user-registerable HookFunctions to facilitate straightforward
interaction with distributed model internals, bridging the gap between
distributed and single-device model paradigms. Primarily, FlexModel enhances
accessibility by democratizing model interactions and promotes more inclusive
research in the domain of large-scale neural networks. The package is found at
https://github.com/VectorInstitute/flex_model. | [
-0.0058326642,
0.066959776,
-0.0204034578,
0.0491958037,
-0.0180808119,
0.0184127446,
0.0694290772,
-0.0181699898,
-0.0077117691,
-0.0109233195,
-0.0311637148,
-0.0308744833,
0.0072152289,
0.0462378897,
0.0184436087,
-0.0610412695,
0.0422245637,
-0.0229022801,
-0.009752675,
-0.0023335151,
-0.0086376863,
0.0235912427,
0.0074217734,
0.0674666315,
0.0047011343,
-0.0494033918,
-0.03213403,
0.0164844282,
-0.0166188702,
0.0325239524,
-0.0043068388,
0.0576942153,
0.0469216965,
0.0953174233,
0.0000023027,
-0.0030912363,
-0.0029713174,
0.0165284984,
-0.046133671,
0.054967586,
0.0617544539,
-0.0294395573,
-0.0226811077,
-0.0100582344,
-0.0168164261,
-0.0226475764,
0.0668891594,
-0.021689551,
0.0372630507,
0.0209191255,
0.008064989,
-0.0087351678,
-0.0022292167,
-0.0259765163,
-0.070662044,
-0.0138554275,
0.002695747,
0.0058796336,
0.0113982428,
0.0051306523,
-0.037721023,
0.0452287681,
0.0739690214,
0.0068842587,
0.019177638,
0.0156053388,
-0.0295396633,
-0.0581164956,
-0.0102700191,
0.0431269631,
-0.0367084853,
-0.0414831266,
-0.0053633503,
-0.0252319723,
-0.013787617,
0.0180752873,
-0.04018021,
-0.0051560248,
0.0262251589,
0.0131321019,
0.0060767015,
-0.0350040272,
0.074369967,
0.0145347705,
-0.0233755969,
0.0674756318,
0.0218155198,
0.025699703,
-0.0535730235,
0.0028286192,
-0.0181509256,
-0.0335515514,
0.0624652579,
0.017548481,
-0.0284853764,
0.0093189068,
-0.0470996462,
-0.080078803,
0.0179078504,
-0.0506615378,
0.0893417895,
-0.001891735,
-0.0065801963,
0.0432904959,
-0.0066802958,
0.0275436938,
-0.0481179766,
0.0166362599,
-0.0099851899,
0.0088630058,
-0.0343518592,
-0.0308400728,
0.0080154575,
-0.0483392887,
-0.0605885945,
-0.0419081002,
0.0106149027,
0.0304324441,
-0.0195525624,
-0.0219097678,
0.0131706176,
0.0119068399,
-0.0271029361,
-0.0053154989,
0.0215704646,
0.0652318895,
-0.0344781987,
0.0006021718,
0.0067422506,
-0.0610217564,
-0.0287068505,
0.0000116594,
-0.0177463088,
-0.0240785107,
0.0219118502,
0.0492549352,
0.0185517352,
-0.0186098963,
-0.0098504042,
-0.0096119251,
0.0088888239,
-0.0535846613,
0.0008853552,
-0.0608544648,
0.0252392106,
0.0165267456,
0.0082633412,
-0.0380078293,
-0.0105887111,
-0.0104776938,
-0.0056086658,
0.0303589515,
-0.0439385511,
0.0068261628,
0.0304600373,
0.0207327213,
0.0108471289,
0.0573148392,
0.0261197686,
0.03120647,
0.0287684258,
-0.0432875752,
0.0049544973,
0.0280140638,
0.0300760046,
-0.0006360002,
-0.0466493256,
-0.0084450711,
-0.0185179207,
0.0331697576,
0.0142355245,
0.0218019783,
-0.0319443867,
-0.0388406776,
0.0720031634,
0.050845664,
-0.0036533317,
0.0277419817,
0.0386171974,
0.0059053889,
0.01147616,
-0.0339853317,
-0.0643512681,
0.0267053135,
0.0528757311,
0.0063120783,
-0.0322726183,
0.0789498091,
-0.0110423155,
-0.033798296,
-0.0152308708,
-0.0285573676,
0.0123967351,
0.014993933,
0.0661868751,
0.0014198512,
-0.0037630079,
0.0504330993,
0.0349484347,
-0.0397384427,
-0.0084135607,
-0.0563572794,
0.0344083309,
0.0762731805,
0.0385321267,
-0.0083806301,
-0.0234961938,
-0.0151653076,
-0.0059665446,
0.0254021864,
0.0076624658,
-0.0027437217,
0.0479667597,
-0.0639675111,
-0.0032742007,
-0.0110757593,
0.033513464,
0.0364492238,
0.0088644484,
-0.0273077358,
-0.0196556076,
-0.012471498,
-0.0406153761,
0.0252775941,
-0.0180297159,
-0.0170045868,
-0.0223923847,
-0.00858898,
0.0278515089,
0.0210296474,
-0.0166933443,
-0.0201217104,
0.0368263647,
-0.0238413122,
0.0102050779,
0.0063490891,
-0.0367366932,
0.027196005,
0.0060961782,
0.0122704329,
-0.0107574677,
0.0585265793,
-0.0495777242,
-0.0185478162,
0.0601866022,
-0.0273172148,
0.0407475643,
-0.0178881232,
-0.0104402816,
-0.0422498398,
0.0440298803,
-0.004083022,
0.0318179652,
-0.0185933635,
-0.0249297097,
0.0109136365,
0.012486238,
0.0074119288,
-0.0302460138,
-0.0044586351,
0.0172837805,
-0.0095591014,
0.007424878,
-0.0285157394,
0.0005088167,
-0.0098646628,
0.0242965147,
-0.0653135031,
-0.0048228242,
-0.048873879,
0.0342269056,
0.0326138884,
0.0209622346,
-0.0075204307,
-0.0138593987,
0.0324176997,
0.0180890653,
-0.0091442531,
0.0340147354,
0.0088270167,
0.0008052216,
-0.0470960587,
-0.0041096429,
-0.0733596906,
0.0054336484,
0.0910634995,
0.0079408921,
-0.0221070368,
-0.0560650267,
-0.0382395834,
-0.0147632584,
0.0125941318,
0.0019975286,
-0.0284324065,
0.0288524367,
-0.0016860485,
0.0081489775,
0.0829759911,
-0.0355060585,
0.0601601228,
0.0448264629,
0.0068031643,
-0.0493119806,
-0.0052113244,
-0.0174793992,
0.0061451979,
-0.0476242006,
-0.0240199026,
-0.0422167741,
0.1065545157,
-0.0158368852,
-0.0278774891,
-0.0221936572,
-0.0066640568,
-0.0352162607,
-0.0523156784,
-0.0096423263,
-0.0170062315,
0.0171847306,
0.0176750831,
-0.0049858871,
-0.0945003852,
0.062602438,
-0.0392240025,
-0.0165708587,
-0.0152110066,
-0.0852918252,
-0.0243632905,
0.0991285071,
0.0047994303,
0.0252844747,
-0.0285268687,
-0.0238552839,
0.0062356903,
0.0033952894,
-0.0088035092,
-0.0080941515,
0.014484182,
-0.0500635505,
-0.027517911,
-0.0187326558,
-0.0228223726,
0.0274593178,
-0.0035519577,
-0.0549009033,
0.012521524,
0.0337000377,
-0.0526770987,
-0.014852454,
0.0214611273,
0.0112195425,
0.0330964215,
-0.0203060023,
0.0175449979,
-0.0320744254,
-0.0140130743,
0.0282019805,
-0.0014233835,
0.0569307618,
-0.0537263192,
-0.0300070979,
0.0661748052,
0.0411398821,
-0.025031358,
-0.0890832692,
0.01087486,
0.0063305157,
-0.0196309872,
-0.0219900832,
-0.0147391306,
0.0395191349,
-0.1265571117,
-0.0050782519,
0.0660298467,
0.0066422937,
-0.0684242174,
0.0262176674,
-0.0188332293,
0.068402566,
0.0125102466,
0.0231167395,
-0.0561532266,
-0.0296471957,
0.0250218026,
0.0176582653,
0.0279602744,
-0.0038285491,
0.0155368773,
-0.0385172181,
0.0477800258,
0.0085388832,
-0.031879548,
-0.0239596646,
-0.0480359495,
-0.0200132821,
-0.0233854353,
0.0179140884,
0.0146358125,
0.0100932,
0.0351794772,
-0.0085370252,
0.0316329002,
-0.0194814019,
0.0252500232,
-0.0270661693,
0.0638347045,
0.0388905965,
-0.0155935884,
-0.0052003693,
-0.0275360197,
0.0078628454,
0.0203804485,
-0.0008233114,
-0.027333511,
0.0072262511,
0.0059349192,
-0.0215928555,
-0.0461142175,
0.0170440525,
-0.0424094312,
-0.0224364232,
-0.0449695624,
0.103106305,
-0.004634378,
-0.0299545694,
-0.0187839977,
-0.052322939,
0.0349384397,
0.0564287789,
0.0593477376,
-0.0272433963,
-0.0727557093,
-0.0270747934,
-0.0266764909,
-0.0076297997,
-0.0180806946,
-0.0095025813,
0.0158324204,
-0.0277140215,
0.0023622813,
-0.0127890762,
0.0119403983,
0.0205506682,
0.0005001282,
-0.0168481953,
0.0149301533,
-0.0062391083,
-0.0526121482,
0.0819536,
-0.0114549501,
0.0526997149,
-0.0398950726,
-0.0247778408,
0.0253999121,
-0.0266881716,
-0.0441251397,
0.0684157982,
-0.0880149454,
-0.0583512262,
0.0358262882,
0.0493400544,
0.0350076295,
0.0207070597,
-0.0143306302,
-0.0624497421,
0.0123792393,
0.0304181911,
-0.0571407974,
0.0383818187,
0.0554152653,
-0.0482584611,
0.0099264607,
0.0376457833,
-0.0172370356,
0.0260907318,
-0.0101183662,
0.0154564502,
-0.0415112302,
-0.0424393527,
-0.0301224124,
-0.011528925,
0.0141846929,
0.0145732444,
-0.0199548248,
-0.0329925939,
0.0175376255,
0.0300016105,
0.0284161866,
-0.0740691945,
-0.0134760942,
0.0058726463,
-0.018644331,
0.0084637646,
-0.0329312012,
0.0574325658,
-0.007308817,
-0.0126100713,
0.0294382852,
0.0113552948,
0.0071387719,
0.0249032248,
0.0115094623,
-0.006313046,
0.0333299339,
-0.0459671281,
0.0445654392,
-0.0227482691,
0.0437362753,
0.0051388759,
-0.0220045019,
-0.0306048635,
0.0299977697,
-0.0646379441,
-0.0909243003,
-0.0069501321,
0.013550641,
0.0235044807,
0.0259419177,
0.0660330877,
-0.0130874244,
-0.0155986184,
-0.0226111282,
0.0510113053,
0.0077857221,
-0.0236315243,
0.020737404,
0.0124708517,
-0.0247246437,
-0.0018006405,
0.0496181287,
0.0172198284,
0.0344641209,
0.0142185725,
-0.0082694329,
-0.0156977959,
-0.0709822476,
-0.0153045794,
0.0142423119,
-0.0595834851,
-0.0161597412,
-0.0229199994,
-0.0790572166,
0.0050445693,
0.0511267483,
-0.0135186883,
-0.0441642068,
-0.0047549396,
0.0497413538,
-0.0147478068,
-0.0211432409,
-0.0266837552,
0.053911455,
-0.0130941616,
-0.0101229837,
0.0078584757,
-6.742496741e-33,
-0.0023090004,
-0.0120118642,
0.0148612689,
-0.029069256,
-0.0080307135,
0.0200823788,
-0.0603408404,
-0.0068827355,
-0.0322182775,
0.025883982,
0.0109040001,
0.0344206989,
0.0269701108,
0.0464214087,
0.0080092978,
-0.0155466897,
0.0314630531,
0.0103988061,
0.0272596087,
0.0549683385,
0.0494929217,
0.0606356896,
0.0559231378,
-0.0785169825,
0.015399579,
-0.0415465944,
0.0104319192,
-0.0091531305,
-0.0749471262,
0.0477324016,
-0.0421382524,
0.0107221464,
0.014019791,
-0.0443759114,
-0.0300175752,
-0.0014082902,
-0.0580014102,
0.0151882498,
0.0194939338,
0.0340951383,
-0.080780983,
-0.028780397,
0.0457316153,
0.0174891278,
-0.0044893147,
-0.0173845049,
0.004609663,
-0.017405916,
-0.033546675,
0.0162073262,
-0.0271027219,
0.0218788385,
-0.0075272797,
0.0218467433,
0.0535451211,
0.0119101284,
-0.0133062014,
0.0336742625,
-0.0519637652,
-0.0243135802,
0.0073750787,
0.0249952134,
0.0991692171,
0.0286924131,
0.0228130314,
0.0451417305,
0.0553120263,
-0.058558628,
-0.0360672995,
0.0303131901,
0.0243718624,
0.0690165833,
0.0508835427,
0.0340341702,
-0.0089869248,
-0.012258362,
-0.0578639172,
-0.0538559295,
0.033692155,
0.0111431563,
0.0377060473,
0.0451263413,
-0.0140821645,
-0.0121137165,
-0.0048857373,
-0.0749197602,
-0.0234550834,
-0.0202506837,
0.0088568125,
-0.0078774625,
-0.0514620505,
0.0476859473,
0.0395068154,
-0.0439911261,
0.0067948392,
0.0369253196,
0.0434024483,
0.0381343365,
0.0303536877,
0.0309289899,
-0.0319338478,
-0.019098876,
-0.0413081124,
-0.0036466697,
0.0391633548,
0.0115640964,
0.0298253112,
0.0345206112,
-0.0138167022,
-0.0020821975,
-0.0371550843,
0.0146473534,
0.0057472112,
0.0725758523,
0.0516399592,
-0.0100776069,
-0.0092939287,
0.0475793518,
0.0103953602,
0.0450916551,
-0.000936807,
0.0142833637,
-0.0214728341,
0.0056945439,
-0.0171261448,
-0.0325430408,
-0.0851022974,
0.0398790762,
0.0578359962,
-0.0714774951,
-0.0073517207,
0.0073159314,
2.929e-7,
0.0440326482,
0.0407993421,
0.001821283,
-0.0120012555,
0.0497284457,
0.0341581441,
-0.0128802862,
0.0142827835,
0.0102868658,
0.0050151278,
-0.0121469609,
0.0394805595,
0.0707873181,
0.0121251559,
-0.0325398482,
-0.0110124359,
-0.084614858,
0.0296180379,
-0.0593209714,
0.0132511249,
-0.019667957,
0.117266342,
0.0380256735,
-0.0170175936,
0.0587336831,
-0.0150898919,
0.0133285001,
-0.047122404,
0.0317343846,
0.0001901271,
-0.0037952818,
0.0018081005,
-0.0091831349,
-0.0009159453,
-0.0033085668,
0.0007516828,
-0.0235903934,
0.1008475423,
-0.0146103101,
0.0416445397,
0.0023563453,
-0.0502091609,
-0.012887381,
-0.0967157707,
0.0341054574,
-0.0173253436,
-0.032488618,
-0.0497586988,
0.0169402659,
-0.0558452941,
0.034824159,
-0.0230482891,
0.0458594114,
-0.0026411391,
0.0028543896,
-0.054241091,
-0.0407232307,
-0.0702078938,
-0.033334624,
-0.0461588055,
-0.0541991033,
-0.0165557135,
-0.0862845704,
-0.011164451,
0.0543916523,
-0.0360724889,
-0.0050099925,
3.001626202e-34,
0.0489447899,
0.0092850504,
0.0102961604,
0.0560055152,
0.0341087431,
-0.0179862883,
0.0185390692,
-0.0111979991,
-0.0159067381,
-0.0822607726,
-0.0360297374
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03122v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03122v3 | Assertion Enhanced Few-Shot Learning: Instructive Technique for Large Language Models to Generate Educational Explanations | 2023-12-05T20:41:34 | 2024-01-20T15:02:20 | Tasmia Shahriar, Kelly Ramos, Noboru Matsuda | cs.CL | cs.CL | Human educators possess an intrinsic ability to anticipate and seek
educational explanations from students, which drives them to pose
thought-provoking questions when students cannot articulate these explanations
independently. We aim to imbue Intelligent Tutoring Systems with this ability
using few-shot learning capability of Large Language Models. Our work proposes
a novel prompting technique, Assertion Enhanced Few-Shot Learning, to
facilitate the generation of accurate, detailed oriented educational
explanations. Our central hypothesis is that, in educational domain, few-shot
demonstrations are necessary but not a sufficient condition for quality
explanation generation. We conducted a study involving 12 in-service teachers,
comparing our approach to Traditional Few-Shot Learning. The results show that
Assertion Enhanced Few-Shot Learning improves explanation accuracy by 15% and
yields higher-quality explanations, as evaluated by teachers. We also conduct a
qualitative ablation study to factor the impact of assertions to provide
educator-friendly prompting guidelines for generating explanations in their
domain of interest. | [
0.0290668961,
-0.0377470255,
-0.0225586556,
0.0203488637,
-0.0242805295,
0.0020066039,
0.0607664399,
-0.0396356657,
-0.0178223606,
-0.0356936455,
0.0404186249,
-0.0010357853,
0.0010001448,
-0.0352150463,
0.0349903889,
-0.0980625749,
0.0268183704,
-0.015243886,
0.0433547124,
0.0170055926,
0.0296233371,
0.0059185843,
-0.0623520352,
0.0423158593,
0.0025097972,
-0.0312122125,
-0.0584560931,
-0.0047523719,
-0.0145637989,
-0.0214960724,
-0.0176294278,
0.0340634137,
0.0336445309,
-0.0061822925,
0.0000022219,
-0.0698451474,
-0.0041417778,
-0.0048831236,
-0.063065134,
0.0352906398,
-0.0067489771,
0.0483306423,
0.014868171,
0.0088285701,
-0.0018078015,
0.0045593716,
0.028387228,
0.0357986353,
0.0561606996,
0.0353293382,
0.023760831,
-0.0477585979,
-0.0162478462,
0.0312548056,
0.0427610949,
-0.0238138475,
-0.0110087171,
0.0194929484,
0.0606865548,
0.0162740741,
-0.0495351329,
0.0066160611,
0.0518459231,
-0.0566496067,
-0.0168680623,
0.0221318062,
-0.0134702781,
-0.0177972112,
0.006205386,
0.0495481677,
0.0528486744,
-0.0270816404,
-0.0257921033,
0.0055243033,
0.0504410006,
0.0668456778,
-0.0890823454,
0.0305127744,
-0.0074091423,
0.007258201,
0.0032148161,
-0.0029512146,
-0.0009782175,
0.0344139636,
0.0033508206,
-0.0057496084,
-0.0236945432,
-0.0317884013,
-0.0567474589,
0.0009549435,
-0.0278679784,
-0.0447830968,
-0.04417523,
0.1051781103,
-0.0315017328,
0.0229635239,
0.0002179205,
-0.0327099115,
0.0038991857,
0.0457150303,
0.0439038575,
0.0557939038,
-0.0238205194,
0.0420008376,
-0.0113114472,
0.0839641094,
0.0429590642,
0.0069285994,
-0.0230360217,
0.0394861139,
-0.0831522048,
-0.0159144066,
-0.0465632752,
0.0410051793,
0.0054738065,
0.0006558507,
-0.0249738861,
-0.0002606196,
-0.0077137803,
0.0536664166,
-0.0750859603,
-0.0066097267,
-0.0081398292,
-0.0399323739,
-0.0348104574,
0.0439860635,
-0.0589668602,
-0.0137972869,
0.0307480451,
-0.0512271114,
-0.036471352,
0.0220096372,
0.0221241172,
0.0264310259,
-0.0184519831,
0.0198611431,
-0.0282519758,
-0.0309886746,
-0.0275223199,
-0.0555570796,
0.0139928823,
-0.0452427752,
-0.0268412326,
-0.0570047908,
-0.0058540301,
0.0113494042,
-0.0360842757,
-0.0004239307,
0.019984711,
0.0040582786,
0.0103310663,
0.0310226381,
-0.0333800428,
0.0292155929,
0.0325510651,
0.0184361227,
-0.0403025597,
0.0552508757,
0.0148538332,
-0.0275806598,
-0.0042646648,
-0.0351398848,
0.0774301663,
-0.0352358073,
0.0254909508,
0.0016772037,
-0.0334619693,
-0.0035297056,
0.0008161055,
0.0551467054,
-0.0360182524,
0.0249108057,
-0.0397934727,
0.0625568703,
0.0115024224,
0.0481196642,
-0.0231252443,
-0.0007740126,
0.050923869,
0.0274905302,
0.0366921201,
0.0434548184,
-0.0486949123,
0.0300826747,
-0.0272232555,
0.0175928194,
0.0207923166,
-0.0119493986,
-0.0114721516,
-0.0840860158,
-0.0129720895,
0.0375937112,
-0.013985062,
0.040662013,
0.0600450858,
0.0180187989,
-0.0166791789,
0.0240642261,
0.0295339767,
-0.0322838128,
0.0175314117,
-0.0964966789,
0.0802736133,
0.0843823329,
0.0405777059,
-0.0297330357,
-0.0368632823,
-0.0365862623,
0.0994559526,
0.0352071449,
0.0367634185,
-0.0128172413,
-0.0119115291,
-0.0197181497,
-0.0140915615,
-0.0609422959,
0.0280620549,
-0.0062697344,
0.0093000606,
0.0114627713,
0.0027094886,
-0.0416685157,
-0.0525043458,
0.0230269805,
-0.0355204605,
-0.0824388489,
-0.0479936153,
0.0229175705,
-0.0593214184,
0.0394402109,
0.0044664987,
0.0134944273,
0.005878747,
0.0031676572,
0.0026650273,
-0.0146131143,
-0.0236896705,
-0.046621643,
0.023981452,
-0.0156171536,
-0.0107895602,
-0.0712056831,
-0.0186114423,
-0.0328049175,
0.0301324576,
-0.0299738999,
0.036710348,
-0.0052248035,
0.0214917213,
-0.0418430343,
-0.0233086701,
-0.0165634882,
0.0125244902,
0.0514413826,
0.0240053628,
0.0601892024,
0.0127743827,
0.0055225748,
-0.0106693795,
0.0011492469,
-0.0172850396,
-0.032233756,
-0.0020814254,
-0.0090018502,
-0.0065338705,
-0.0653441697,
0.0316246673,
-0.0515638255,
-0.0112200622,
-0.0115776733,
0.0053143543,
0.0020183085,
-0.0055056107,
-0.0041680071,
-0.011984529,
-0.0272369105,
-0.0314847417,
-0.0229549371,
0.0028018299,
0.0232424643,
0.0333898067,
-0.0551126897,
-0.0204344057,
0.0136038745,
-0.0447628982,
0.0484852344,
0.0672902986,
0.0380225964,
-0.0646852329,
-0.0021556483,
-0.0121742655,
-0.0201797578,
-0.0037187047,
-0.0533823259,
0.0539306626,
-0.0309627671,
-0.0066724233,
0.0988405645,
0.0036312097,
0.0740127042,
0.0324705616,
-0.0212904923,
-0.0768178329,
0.0191688631,
-0.0149511499,
-0.0164128821,
0.0014776731,
-0.0072777253,
-0.0379015803,
0.038362287,
0.0213977229,
0.0053790449,
-0.0473030843,
0.0607174672,
-0.0187730324,
-0.0066691572,
-0.0320745222,
-0.0435476117,
0.0054238304,
0.0224007852,
-0.0063177808,
-0.0236967225,
0.1042389497,
0.0083296495,
-0.0266024303,
0.0032103963,
0.0457749553,
0.0053198352,
0.0537466519,
-0.0488934144,
0.0094827255,
0.0207513478,
0.0026230856,
-0.0243364386,
-0.0328126848,
0.0641387105,
-0.027861217,
-0.0020792927,
-0.0605643876,
-0.0423945114,
0.0067740711,
0.0114886295,
-0.0584274642,
-0.0340232663,
-0.0082643656,
-0.0028906087,
-0.0572240837,
0.0012810366,
-0.0061586509,
-0.0117392037,
0.0653214455,
-0.0141901625,
-0.0307168625,
-0.0261679739,
-0.0165607519,
-0.0105409585,
0.0042170146,
-0.0014595009,
-0.0001936134,
-0.0430023298,
0.1266345531,
0.0249826889,
0.0140430303,
0.0071691964,
-0.0162339769,
-0.0056478912,
0.0005864371,
-0.0244318359,
-0.0127692064,
0.0459687077,
0.0989188701,
-0.0960087478,
0.017307099,
0.1159176677,
0.0330119841,
-0.0010279603,
-0.0033590377,
-0.0383607112,
0.0090585668,
0.0212116838,
0.0494610891,
-0.0978574008,
-0.0323395915,
-0.0200921874,
0.021135252,
-0.0080025708,
-0.0048910161,
-0.0231776759,
-0.1207911372,
0.0463253222,
0.0042236764,
-0.0074420166,
0.005119944,
-0.0457576849,
-0.001678498,
0.0393164381,
0.0188443121,
0.0335409418,
0.0140387565,
0.0303288903,
0.0752729326,
0.0142773744,
-0.061778035,
0.0084609399,
-0.0235863887,
0.0171725526,
0.0105741825,
0.0147889685,
-0.0219664387,
-0.0352107435,
-0.0455390252,
0.0390940793,
0.0183468182,
0.0036702016,
0.044849351,
0.0101610627,
-0.0025548253,
-0.0175609794,
0.0675576478,
0.0126532875,
-0.0219643414,
0.0369809531,
0.0847025216,
-0.0096887806,
0.0037481082,
-0.0315912366,
0.0054485938,
0.0119957868,
0.0634081364,
0.0708495528,
-0.0278462265,
0.0186299384,
-0.042605862,
-0.045859471,
-0.0517846011,
-0.0128762815,
0.0244698804,
0.0018527803,
0.0261217505,
-0.0375742055,
-0.02363359,
0.0859557986,
0.0495017879,
0.0005822561,
0.0073846607,
-0.0360559598,
0.0086947903,
-0.0074145747,
0.0011353381,
0.0205701329,
0.0043211714,
-0.0290382057,
-0.0083380388,
-0.0117613319,
-0.0421235561,
0.0099654282,
-0.0180454496,
-0.0101602068,
-0.0684889033,
-0.0299846008,
0.0451035164,
0.0186576322,
0.0495901816,
0.0230465233,
-0.0408572331,
0.0185995493,
0.0278615654,
0.0197191201,
-0.0243855417,
0.0064844848,
-0.0029947748,
0.0278518908,
0.0155225359,
-0.0189522617,
0.0016071481,
-0.001042381,
-0.004201707,
-0.0171709955,
-0.0018861401,
0.0481297523,
0.0244739186,
0.0476369075,
-0.0376725458,
-0.0255840067,
-0.0088446653,
0.0113718649,
-0.0679800361,
-0.0421587117,
-0.0202528127,
0.0279563777,
-0.0140883448,
-0.041212827,
0.02596654,
-0.0359791107,
-0.0196423791,
0.0341624282,
-0.0204661489,
0.0478555411,
-0.0447515771,
-0.0508990921,
0.0083365534,
0.0181681719,
-0.0148914093,
-0.0103030866,
0.0103770811,
0.0598244071,
0.014762166,
0.1129632145,
0.0259699915,
0.0250222366,
0.0091533605,
-0.0272095874,
-0.0071262163,
-0.0589763597,
0.0087121492,
0.0366624109,
-0.0029115924,
-0.0141707854,
0.0001567969,
-0.0005108365,
0.0241595712,
0.031730216,
0.0625789687,
-0.0006557388,
-0.0424618423,
0.0331224874,
0.0464981571,
0.0291661806,
-0.0058565568,
0.0198282432,
-0.0433877558,
0.0353061967,
-0.0072034681,
0.020716209,
-0.0147379143,
0.0006285975,
0.0571792684,
0.0325845443,
0.0351001844,
0.0322416499,
-0.069099322,
-0.0195361413,
-0.0552753657,
0.0346370004,
-0.0095776301,
-0.0391586274,
0.0170477014,
0.0402396545,
-0.0171910618,
-0.0380000509,
-0.0316666774,
0.0088981744,
-0.0392630734,
-0.0172765832,
-0.0086805737,
-6.337197309e-33,
-0.0302081238,
-0.0539098009,
0.0392418578,
-0.0114621976,
0.0068432284,
-0.0245122761,
-0.0539137162,
0.0249380004,
-0.0091297207,
0.0515444055,
0.0051815943,
-0.0005419598,
-0.0161510855,
0.0127683999,
0.0309978649,
0.0034326639,
0.0157955214,
0.0225120168,
-0.0236872733,
0.0444542766,
0.013334197,
-0.0025278549,
0.048655834,
-0.0031135452,
0.0518642925,
-0.0048477603,
-0.0038103606,
0.0076779681,
-0.0468851402,
0.0454914719,
-0.009852523,
0.0277318619,
-0.0016590558,
-0.0425619408,
0.0073256935,
0.0265510585,
-0.0139222965,
-0.0609270819,
0.0340095311,
0.0142849842,
-0.064127177,
-0.0292549003,
0.0032471081,
-0.0232952107,
-0.0151903778,
-0.0015692135,
0.0511568263,
-0.0073443707,
0.0165683869,
0.0130714709,
-0.0520054288,
0.0006809424,
-0.0726183355,
-0.0866337717,
0.0139735416,
0.052558884,
-0.0099305296,
-0.0335152857,
0.0026928682,
0.0098428056,
0.0583274737,
0.0176695995,
0.0471661799,
0.0144105013,
-0.0188329108,
0.0387743786,
0.0142720658,
0.0197231099,
-0.0201481339,
0.0447314456,
0.0092346855,
0.0336346813,
0.0751833245,
0.0501299202,
0.0169295073,
0.0346432999,
-0.0383610651,
0.0230881199,
0.0226617921,
0.0141514493,
0.0212308578,
-0.0267636981,
-0.073685579,
-0.0443053283,
-0.0553837232,
0.0014595955,
-0.0139215933,
-0.0461190827,
0.0225019883,
-0.023425322,
-0.0549980886,
-0.0300253276,
-0.003046765,
-0.0265809894,
-0.0024073387,
-0.0179019552,
-0.0333032012,
0.0190988705,
-0.0173447113,
-0.0265031978,
-0.0144006219,
-0.0078274384,
0.0075377533,
0.0046958919,
0.0320497043,
0.0409742706,
0.046917785,
0.031873174,
-0.008090849,
-0.0039031038,
-0.0519208461,
-0.0162868854,
0.0223275665,
-0.0754842907,
0.0058863806,
0.0445729345,
-0.0367705785,
0.0504610464,
0.022361679,
-0.0657963753,
-0.0100825913,
0.0036939355,
-0.0329217725,
-0.0149108693,
-0.0502807423,
-0.030704489,
-0.0366104767,
-0.0083677648,
-0.02207564,
-0.0712740943,
-0.016670255,
0.0274883211,
2.916e-7,
-0.0083134873,
0.0488812216,
0.0347007997,
-0.0050616823,
-0.0096494658,
0.0354098305,
-0.001916608,
-0.047778368,
0.0408923887,
-0.0338711888,
0.0148432627,
0.0381705165,
0.0163749214,
0.0061213891,
-0.0887016058,
-0.0164281968,
-0.0135637335,
-0.0161611363,
-0.0468487255,
0.0433175415,
0.131498158,
-0.0283756834,
0.0272806436,
0.0143245691,
0.0007249697,
-0.0256863646,
0.0227580126,
0.0106803942,
-0.0051691709,
0.0216403119,
0.0063228421,
0.009300055,
0.0435135849,
0.0131263621,
-0.0003274324,
0.0040969159,
-0.0655520335,
0.0303289369,
0.0008155517,
0.0236431472,
-0.0108609516,
-0.0189997032,
0.0065221814,
-0.0547176637,
0.0631532967,
-0.0615827516,
0.0080369571,
0.0389047787,
-0.0367602147,
-0.0496231429,
-0.0320420973,
-0.0223197341,
-0.0077609303,
0.007547752,
-0.0123849316,
-0.0286772102,
0.0136720128,
-0.0040054806,
-0.0263226535,
0.0091280807,
-0.0068258406,
0.0034550724,
0.003550393,
-0.0406119749,
-0.0119383093,
-0.0379957408,
-0.0178160705,
2.230554484e-34,
0.0127799222,
-0.0039724945,
0.0683090836,
0.039162498,
0.0232305881,
0.0305021964,
-0.0532101095,
0.0146180904,
0.0949885622,
-0.0229097977,
-0.0382121876
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03766v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03766v1 | Mismatch Quest: Visual and Textual Feedback for Image-Text Misalignment | 2023-12-05T20:07:34 | 2023-12-05T20:07:34 | Brian Gordon, Yonatan Bitton, Yonatan Shafir, Roopal Garg, Xi Chen, Dani Lischinski, Daniel Cohen-Or, Idan Szpektor | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | While existing image-text alignment models reach high quality binary
assessments, they fall short of pinpointing the exact source of misalignment.
In this paper, we present a method to provide detailed textual and visual
explanation of detected misalignments between text-image pairs. We leverage
large language models and visual grounding models to automatically construct a
training set that holds plausible misaligned captions for a given image and
corresponding textual explanations and visual indicators. We also publish a new
human curated test set comprising ground-truth textual and visual misalignment
annotations. Empirical results show that fine-tuning vision language models on
our training set enables them to articulate misalignments and visually indicate
them within images, outperforming strong baselines both on the binary alignment
classification and the explanation generation tasks. Our method code and human
curated test set are available at: https://mismatch-quest.github.io/ | [
0.0392889865,
0.064181529,
0.0013636068,
0.0504650474,
-0.0229473785,
0.0392037481,
0.0020935992,
0.0196302477,
0.0084604491,
-0.0431719646,
-0.0058698892,
-0.0062296493,
0.0689654723,
0.0049284115,
0.0424120873,
-0.0748107284,
0.0296531692,
-0.0339391753,
-0.0192925222,
0.0276458897,
0.054476928,
0.0345208012,
-0.0144063793,
0.0300457478,
-0.0392866954,
-0.0595836043,
-0.0308093969,
0.0559408627,
0.0429045521,
-0.0107091321,
-0.0049650911,
0.057771083,
0.0325642489,
0.0549197681,
0.0000018099,
0.0102877421,
0.001020844,
0.0107834116,
-0.0038591113,
0.0083539104,
-0.0065854611,
-0.0458169058,
0.0018383585,
-0.0135149378,
-0.0009860344,
0.0086181313,
0.0976371914,
0.0506515764,
0.0677030385,
0.0502280034,
-0.0070051374,
-0.0040387996,
-0.0355467349,
-0.0186331179,
0.0226900764,
-0.0196213741,
0.0128606781,
0.053043358,
-0.0315460674,
0.0080179302,
-0.0356415398,
-0.0054772962,
-0.0013911539,
-0.0524890721,
-0.0055838628,
0.0167848077,
-0.0598854125,
-0.0498067215,
-0.0319983326,
0.0849213675,
-0.0174071416,
-0.0361755714,
-0.0387449451,
-0.0179361477,
0.0033753319,
0.0194358267,
-0.0243149474,
0.0345385969,
-0.0272234213,
0.0431631729,
-0.0316250399,
-0.0008528245,
0.0167398397,
-0.0144293429,
0.0020589505,
-0.0149978651,
0.0027706681,
0.019218225,
-0.0670083761,
0.0333366096,
-0.048057165,
-0.0581100695,
0.0075946744,
0.0137153659,
-0.0075588431,
-0.0183768999,
-0.0604457557,
-0.0595472716,
0.0127815949,
-0.0418195315,
0.0131401047,
-0.0026269392,
-0.0814607292,
0.0747806132,
-0.0139073748,
0.1245917752,
0.0112371743,
0.0448238626,
-0.0497816689,
0.002143662,
0.00844301,
0.0029607972,
0.0082424441,
-0.0702459961,
-0.0578650795,
-0.0194929242,
-0.0114582935,
-0.0106718512,
-0.0163395125,
0.0497773997,
-0.0063860617,
0.0386325456,
-0.0640754923,
-0.0390894786,
-0.034205243,
0.0096718622,
0.0180159938,
0.0022123533,
-0.0234467871,
-0.0585254431,
-0.0171705615,
0.0533262305,
-0.0143236294,
-0.028072862,
-0.0262602232,
0.0463129953,
-0.0501316935,
-0.0037363742,
-0.0021877899,
0.0076673711,
-0.0427292176,
-0.0568738841,
-0.0231618397,
-0.0303118154,
-0.0013582745,
0.0024183805,
-0.0076465714,
-0.0212427732,
0.0405336879,
0.0176112466,
-0.031788297,
0.1163772047,
-0.02976151,
0.0063622552,
0.0167240202,
-0.025409773,
0.0078340014,
0.0469822846,
0.0379308946,
0.0091327745,
0.0336366482,
-0.0105347708,
0.0252185892,
0.0272871424,
-0.0270333737,
-0.0074551301,
-0.0314196274,
0.0097023388,
0.0372250378,
0.0473467633,
0.0286298897,
0.0372504294,
0.0040059979,
0.00307825,
0.0859343857,
0.02882508,
-0.0017530272,
-0.001304934,
-0.0144793484,
0.0027664059,
-0.0204160959,
0.0261946563,
-0.0729767308,
0.0483128279,
0.011230058,
0.0254931282,
0.0178229716,
0.0390878692,
-0.0100249927,
-0.0286125354,
-0.0254607927,
-0.0044610412,
0.0029390051,
-0.043778602,
0.0530160703,
0.0086642345,
-0.0744738951,
0.023007134,
-0.0149752414,
-0.0282616671,
-0.0171749741,
0.0125039751,
-0.0002555995,
0.0889386386,
0.0305758826,
-0.0214272887,
-0.0369362831,
-0.0078772847,
0.0296697225,
0.0603569299,
0.0024963389,
0.0116316089,
-0.0181300845,
-0.0534131415,
-0.0317973234,
0.0039969119,
-0.0110833505,
-0.0126506779,
-0.0040885834,
-0.0125158681,
0.0199193489,
-0.0317665637,
-0.0816167146,
0.0555200875,
0.0424218141,
-0.0118220551,
-0.0539138429,
0.052607324,
-0.0144438632,
-0.0082898438,
-0.0180334784,
0.0001621793,
-0.0008133116,
-0.0076982104,
0.0235363375,
0.0410974883,
-0.0023648508,
-0.0344449691,
0.0563020557,
-0.0619973652,
-0.0312436782,
-0.0064386833,
-0.0322935879,
-0.0336614996,
-0.0327853896,
-0.0004845709,
-0.0275974944,
-0.0725754797,
0.0328956433,
-0.0003239656,
0.0110436967,
-0.0390536785,
0.0372590013,
0.0151547538,
-0.0116357803,
-0.0389515907,
-0.0147019578,
0.0030075999,
-0.0438785814,
0.0088903727,
0.0039376584,
0.0104489233,
0.0161221232,
-0.010801143,
0.0202504564,
-0.0344622098,
-0.0091113569,
-0.080343917,
-0.0014248964,
-0.0399540775,
0.001984583,
0.0323238112,
-0.0329619572,
0.0220739469,
-0.0500738025,
-0.0231648274,
0.0067963549,
0.0126242079,
-0.0249960236,
0.0839514509,
0.0067083933,
-0.0182084236,
-0.07744167,
0.0234736744,
0.0031834836,
0.0561572798,
0.0728786141,
-0.0148953544,
-0.0735593885,
0.0105020702,
0.0255620591,
0.0112801082,
-0.0031237402,
-0.0332672782,
0.0111622009,
0.019496616,
0.0040451325,
0.0565443784,
0.0172126554,
0.040916007,
-0.0404554196,
0.0108681265,
-0.0293747336,
-0.0188416187,
0.0157004837,
-0.0410031639,
-0.0075892741,
-0.0286733042,
-0.05192573,
0.0119472658,
-0.0504505634,
0.0321985893,
-0.0719239116,
0.0156210875,
-0.0119296173,
0.0175902341,
-0.0571337081,
-0.0192090794,
0.0163508095,
0.0557609312,
-0.0898850486,
-0.0670687407,
0.0564984865,
-0.0751342624,
-0.0235713013,
-0.0009785667,
-0.0106793381,
-0.0309396684,
0.0526650362,
0.0176357478,
0.0450856052,
0.0256570373,
-0.0045715095,
-0.0606137961,
-0.0442640483,
0.0390727632,
0.0007253563,
0.0605090596,
-0.0547181815,
0.0313569158,
-0.0240800697,
-0.0334144793,
-0.0284964256,
-0.0410519801,
-0.0150212608,
-0.0501435138,
-0.0383091569,
-0.0221287906,
-0.0591440164,
0.0416184552,
-0.0130182486,
-0.0099209743,
0.0074932645,
0.0153496275,
-0.0228428636,
0.0167461541,
0.0323311463,
0.025407752,
-0.0012166065,
-0.0626473278,
-0.0213444047,
0.0077288225,
-0.0001785918,
0.0228563007,
-0.0353499576,
-0.0143044144,
-0.0001469161,
0.0225364696,
0.0130537804,
0.016128242,
0.0744417906,
-0.0416331738,
-0.0061914618,
0.0856466293,
0.0345618501,
-0.0038042981,
-0.0243277401,
0.0006695336,
0.0326485559,
0.0270233713,
0.0204026923,
-0.0721143484,
-0.0416415893,
0.0152254151,
-0.0228205118,
0.038630046,
0.0275183264,
-0.0069246958,
-0.0667307749,
0.0357420594,
0.052293621,
0.0044382964,
-0.0822483823,
0.034612,
-0.0014511627,
-0.008506001,
0.0181685016,
0.0042379107,
0.0062343748,
0.0140875559,
0.0182400551,
0.0211891402,
-0.0214307532,
-0.0347960852,
-0.0564981475,
0.0378371775,
0.069812417,
0.0245506894,
0.0005290237,
-0.0589928254,
0.0217969399,
0.0085223177,
0.0270311292,
0.0272289496,
0.0908901468,
-0.0057232659,
-0.0680979416,
0.004710346,
0.0282245651,
-0.0325793698,
-0.0183646642,
-0.0519527532,
0.0027195839,
-0.0093958685,
0.0292012971,
-0.0040852502,
0.0111987889,
0.0436267443,
0.0298003294,
0.0393152907,
-0.0113305375,
-0.0637071282,
-0.0333225206,
0.0434665494,
-0.0325751267,
0.0256842375,
0.0346392952,
0.0065128272,
-0.0220961869,
-0.0566563979,
-0.0207399391,
0.0309661478,
0.0106747793,
0.0278986227,
-0.0221729502,
-0.0341580138,
0.0040390496,
-0.0357837006,
0.0744349286,
0.0154868523,
0.0703364834,
-0.0314337425,
0.0206127688,
-0.0311185829,
-0.0119372001,
-0.0293017328,
0.014110717,
-0.0873010457,
-0.0320131779,
-0.0398630388,
0.02620643,
0.0114442194,
0.0687304214,
0.0023084406,
-0.0226391032,
-0.0576254651,
0.0504215918,
0.0259737931,
0.0082729794,
-0.0028669706,
-0.0256709382,
0.0003237994,
0.0364721641,
-0.0231570303,
-0.0174544621,
-0.0206929985,
0.0116383629,
-0.0058270823,
-0.0408350229,
0.0106975567,
-0.0252988953,
0.0499382988,
-0.0375130735,
-0.006162649,
-0.0182895828,
0.0152390152,
-0.0030195522,
-0.0356752947,
-0.0465941839,
0.0038673272,
-0.0009280984,
0.002741741,
0.0074527799,
-0.0380833596,
-0.0210548751,
0.0426380038,
-0.0058361921,
-0.0018185453,
0.0225701835,
-0.0043152119,
0.0192287024,
0.0389529206,
0.0215987898,
0.0353003517,
-0.0039717094,
0.0571196526,
0.0110420538,
0.0525580682,
0.0397080667,
0.0014896562,
-0.0108685298,
0.015939163,
0.0333760828,
-0.0029798734,
-0.0372316688,
0.0456270389,
0.0722148865,
-0.0325125605,
0.0332072154,
0.0199532881,
-0.0130183762,
0.0056430502,
0.0512241162,
-0.0072580813,
-0.0202012304,
0.0132770902,
0.0215758495,
-0.0137212593,
-0.0040377723,
0.0551409274,
0.0084414408,
0.0225400161,
-0.0157810114,
-0.0331371613,
-0.0111210095,
0.0157558247,
-0.0021559219,
-0.0234415717,
0.0019186442,
0.0336012729,
-0.0318924077,
-0.0524227843,
0.0338223986,
0.0660838261,
-0.0113179898,
0.0557115413,
0.0056817313,
0.0388984159,
-0.0105021307,
0.0124871172,
0.0007502254,
-0.026823191,
-0.0275706854,
-0.00441611,
-0.0424245782,
-5.783676856e-33,
-0.0557670332,
-0.0921653733,
-0.0022129973,
-0.0431159213,
-0.0109932618,
0.0082335249,
-0.0294712503,
0.0061455704,
0.0011675,
0.0577930138,
0.0425655022,
0.005858561,
0.0203264561,
0.0284076594,
-0.0214833207,
0.0030203308,
0.0589069054,
-0.0049685985,
0.0018807877,
-0.009977675,
0.0223640054,
0.0152844191,
0.0326478295,
-0.0691027641,
0.0168774091,
-0.0118020624,
-0.0423534028,
0.0263679288,
0.0244275238,
0.0535302423,
0.0049849339,
-0.0089690788,
-0.011467116,
0.0258277394,
-0.0079267956,
0.0456333458,
-0.062345162,
0.0002651045,
0.0369065776,
0.0803954378,
-0.0102957273,
-0.0088777058,
0.021717865,
-0.0610867515,
0.0082489289,
-0.0243350156,
0.0795644969,
-0.0262339413,
0.0358895883,
0.0565599054,
-0.0401859246,
-0.0045283767,
-0.0625756755,
-0.029195141,
0.0413707457,
0.0093724681,
0.031742759,
0.042904444,
-0.0495043695,
-0.0247948151,
0.0119627453,
0.0386585817,
0.0715358108,
0.0467054509,
-0.0203665961,
0.0718959048,
-0.0157062635,
-0.052442424,
-0.0230022483,
0.0096925879,
-0.0083502941,
0.0457682647,
0.0758293271,
0.043889448,
0.0313226171,
0.014281068,
-0.0430386923,
0.0253893994,
-0.0852185115,
0.0173552968,
0.0076767863,
0.0333260149,
-0.0389215015,
0.0199374482,
-0.0198019966,
-0.0546641983,
-0.0505257286,
0.0117791509,
0.0534403361,
0.0074565639,
-0.0177867953,
0.0437744819,
0.042638611,
-0.0317406133,
-0.011396572,
-0.0482258871,
-0.0275600757,
0.0389065146,
-0.0262209792,
0.0011920013,
0.0045624939,
-0.0521281883,
0.0930267572,
0.0525161363,
0.0301291533,
-0.0024759828,
0.0796469301,
-0.0220678151,
-0.0288265981,
0.0116685154,
-0.0277485829,
-0.0099584674,
-0.0330095328,
0.0125466054,
0.0159050021,
0.0377664827,
-0.0640553683,
0.0137929684,
-0.0081768427,
-0.0140158497,
-0.0181204695,
-0.0327940658,
-0.0390264578,
-0.0004111668,
-0.0179068726,
0.0136109786,
0.0014985626,
-0.0458233021,
0.0267078783,
-0.0459214374,
-0.0111349905,
0.0366045721,
2.286e-7,
0.0446255915,
0.0521021225,
0.0667065009,
-0.0308136716,
0.0298215002,
0.0479223803,
-0.0361283831,
-0.0166932233,
-0.0094196713,
-0.0390965641,
0.0191157851,
0.0334116779,
0.0716295764,
-0.0265696011,
0.0173757114,
0.0310010146,
-0.0444987118,
-0.0471393839,
-0.046019882,
-0.0060769194,
0.0624882355,
0.0481217057,
-0.0142354276,
-0.0148730893,
0.0372325592,
-0.0645759925,
0.0393112414,
-0.0321500339,
0.0194536522,
-0.010227127,
0.0098201605,
0.0109623671,
-0.030086847,
0.0284284987,
0.0220741779,
-0.0337415747,
0.0609504618,
0.0210970528,
-0.0687995031,
0.0205236971,
-0.1033334583,
0.0337527245,
-0.0168098882,
-0.0758779272,
0.0531262606,
-0.0236632321,
0.0062738294,
-0.0515100025,
-0.0551050492,
-0.0002826779,
0.0246237889,
-0.0115894303,
-0.0058545484,
0.062827155,
0.0542711951,
-0.0113069611,
-0.0454440266,
-0.0520251542,
-0.0562652536,
0.0067466442,
-0.0037917939,
0.0448178463,
-0.0559656322,
-0.0134769306,
0.0297682174,
-0.0088421581,
-0.0224997923,
1.938323374e-34,
0.0378326401,
-0.011544073,
0.0135626188,
0.0144847305,
0.0261899494,
-0.0072467388,
-0.0397240706,
-0.0079681464,
-0.0123236664,
-0.0315827727,
-0.0015192321
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03095v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03095v1 | Understanding Environmental Posts: Sentiment and Emotion Analysis of Social Media Data | 2023-12-05T19:26:28 | 2023-12-05T19:26:28 | Daniyar Amangeldi, Aida Usmanova, Pakizar Shamoi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Social media is now the predominant source of information due to the
availability of immediate public response. As a result, social media data has
become a valuable resource for comprehending public sentiments. Studies have
shown that it can amplify ideas and influence public sentiments. This study
analyzes the public perception of climate change and the environment over a
decade from 2014 to 2023. Using the Pointwise Mutual Information (PMI)
algorithm, we identify sentiment and explore prevailing emotions expressed
within environmental tweets across various social media platforms, namely
Twitter, Reddit, and YouTube. Accuracy on a human-annotated dataset was 0.65,
higher than Vader score but lower than that of an expert rater (0.90). Our
findings suggest that negative environmental tweets are far more common than
positive or neutral ones. Climate change, air quality, emissions, plastic, and
recycling are the most discussed topics on all social media platforms,
highlighting its huge global concern. The most common emotions in environmental
tweets are fear, trust, and anticipation, demonstrating public reactions wide
and complex nature. By identifying patterns and trends in opinions related to
the environment, we hope to provide insights that can help raise awareness
regarding environmental issues, inform the development of interventions, and
adapt further actions to meet environmental challenges. | [
0.0348020531,
0.073690325,
0.0076997499,
0.007304715,
-0.0253858566,
0.0220466424,
-0.0196059998,
0.0309584867,
0.0142218415,
-0.0491478965,
0.0246249083,
0.0281318054,
-0.0304163136,
0.0342590883,
0.0001465966,
-0.0393347591,
0.0175593086,
0.0672794208,
0.0537193231,
-0.0241046529,
0.0542266965,
0.0029119954,
0.0053124777,
0.0032872972,
-0.0136422627,
-0.0288524851,
0.0290901456,
0.0261640325,
0.0758861825,
-0.0637616366,
0.0504581332,
0.0417252705,
0.0182657745,
0.0291210152,
0.0000022121,
-0.0083565973,
-0.0205141474,
-0.019461602,
0.0644413382,
0.0045556868,
0.0780993551,
-0.0298770852,
0.0076619703,
0.0179612413,
-0.0446675494,
-0.0167088117,
0.0851960033,
0.0365788005,
0.0678126588,
0.0214256067,
-0.0209709015,
0.0137527017,
-0.0236284658,
0.0125121316,
0.009856917,
0.0824013874,
0.0427929014,
-0.0424822345,
-0.0512102209,
-0.0285684075,
0.0142414235,
0.0416982435,
-0.0329158381,
0.0062147309,
0.018622594,
0.031008916,
0.0080887899,
-0.0731316805,
-0.0067907129,
0.0403063558,
0.0376610234,
-0.012368287,
-0.0206514448,
-0.010882712,
0.0029405651,
0.0302688181,
-0.0469533019,
0.0084732985,
0.0203207508,
0.0159579851,
-0.0229438338,
0.0490478538,
-0.0224408153,
0.0771257356,
0.0054479772,
0.0580307394,
-0.0385127589,
-0.0499283671,
0.0203717686,
0.0285827853,
-0.0180587638,
-0.0027425759,
-0.0069189146,
-0.036178384,
0.0199791174,
0.0166164022,
0.0003962198,
-0.0052461261,
0.0222450923,
-0.1082850546,
-0.0522340238,
0.0069313706,
0.0217322726,
0.0269082617,
0.0917218998,
-0.0363017544,
0.0316685773,
-0.0183107182,
0.0288187843,
0.0206852295,
-0.0565185435,
0.02801474,
0.0237106346,
-0.0017210309,
0.0145588098,
0.010050023,
-0.0219224766,
-0.0211510826,
-0.0584269874,
-0.0129465163,
-0.0127079273,
-0.0025179961,
0.0354760364,
-0.0004718354,
-0.0023362276,
0.0837138742,
-0.0372228995,
0.0567073375,
-0.0241405666,
-0.0044867205,
0.0269565843,
-0.0221092384,
0.0531477146,
0.0077575245,
-0.0145399449,
0.0397367552,
0.0421805009,
-0.0232789516,
-0.0087673683,
-0.0267301947,
0.01921493,
0.0165588539,
-0.0085782167,
-0.026666645,
0.0392505489,
0.0269056819,
0.011565757,
-0.0134183392,
0.0031891873,
-0.0011112584,
-0.0567354225,
0.0242774487,
-0.0845014676,
-0.0112570832,
0.0241294596,
0.0372725017,
0.0261569135,
0.0191464443,
0.0479251891,
0.0425115637,
0.0557747893,
-0.0067697349,
-0.01967212,
-0.0209508464,
0.0300414059,
0.0094228163,
0.0201122202,
-0.0162826311,
-0.0896397308,
-0.0240975507,
-0.0177584067,
0.007483393,
0.0174887441,
0.0237295479,
0.0414485745,
-0.0022608605,
-0.0506097265,
0.0015565661,
-0.0431341678,
0.0724555477,
-0.0109310877,
-0.0474049412,
-0.0077604493,
0.0462575331,
-0.0394392572,
-0.0397582874,
0.0423596986,
0.0352414027,
-0.0079618124,
-0.0295923762,
-0.0195365101,
0.0139074419,
0.0366372876,
-0.0594652407,
-0.0315873288,
-0.0511597395,
-0.0454037488,
0.0011530055,
0.0195327941,
-0.0667859837,
-0.0053079636,
0.0143086519,
0.0279030111,
0.0349020623,
-0.0590193421,
0.010271322,
0.0267640855,
-0.0346663743,
0.0006387217,
-0.0206861477,
0.0087861037,
0.0297313258,
-0.0582063794,
-0.0088352421,
-0.0290487427,
0.0282149296,
0.012932823,
-0.011386646,
-0.0128448457,
0.0712030381,
-0.0257465243,
-0.0018387991,
0.0141654937,
-0.0047976151,
0.0482718349,
0.0313865878,
-0.0428055264,
0.0420179702,
0.0296355151,
0.0395634174,
-0.0039281673,
-0.0000033128,
0.0396218412,
0.0050908504,
-0.0895939246,
0.0594741032,
0.0163944084,
0.0535881817,
0.0412185006,
-0.0854988843,
-0.0188997369,
0.0494279154,
-0.0324677527,
0.0136932926,
0.042886626,
0.0022270228,
0.0163127184,
0.0046182903,
-0.0372657366,
-0.0207017642,
0.0229689963,
0.0131503958,
0.0241318829,
-0.0398644805,
-0.0535914153,
-0.0571470857,
-0.0527352877,
0.0272667129,
0.0232191645,
-0.0280830115,
-0.015697632,
-0.0158496276,
-0.0108370949,
0.0367113054,
-0.0225318149,
-0.0843445808,
-0.0015599213,
-0.0811079964,
-0.0297287088,
-0.0064485609,
-0.0127244908,
0.0218520574,
-0.0090550818,
-0.0120247155,
0.0453410186,
0.0099598393,
0.0363676846,
-0.0341089703,
0.0453874506,
0.0306698028,
0.0020005445,
0.0287856255,
-0.0490485616,
-0.0137659051,
-0.0612635389,
0.0372978747,
0.0549598597,
-0.1218769103,
0.00534085,
0.0584733859,
-0.0446784906,
-0.0154661043,
0.0004910976,
-0.0347583331,
-0.0173086543,
-0.0132724801,
-0.0124598593,
-0.0341009796,
0.0663214847,
0.044409126,
0.0051893326,
0.0224298276,
-0.0422591157,
0.0017309602,
-0.006548109,
-0.0127098104,
0.0319996886,
-0.0423282348,
0.0061025107,
0.0268481374,
-0.0190080144,
-0.0021477749,
0.0036271499,
0.0770914927,
-0.0409081057,
-0.0252369177,
-0.0316886753,
-0.0145542333,
0.0425049476,
0.0226240419,
-0.0138625335,
-0.063676998,
0.0160437822,
0.0360104032,
0.0384313725,
-0.0364679694,
-0.0187755357,
0.0300577749,
0.0401806571,
0.0234346464,
0.0082943765,
0.0355167724,
0.0364581533,
0.0322635658,
-0.0493909977,
-0.0295865778,
0.0022129326,
-0.0307007525,
-0.0311449189,
0.0103304703,
0.0161861908,
-0.0431864187,
0.0453765467,
-0.0472585261,
-0.0505356677,
-0.0273849312,
0.0123613505,
-0.0492226481,
-0.0043429099,
-0.0209183339,
0.0458633564,
-0.0957300514,
0.0300225783,
-0.0534448661,
0.0426224917,
0.0188002381,
0.0361764096,
0.0134908184,
0.0159184691,
0.0124544837,
-0.0145565197,
0.0449117795,
0.0118381083,
0.0005552922,
-0.0291664023,
0.0078827767,
-0.0002129708,
0.0243834313,
0.0096961632,
-0.0439491384,
0.0461993515,
0.006267806,
0.0453393757,
0.059340775,
0.0222694594,
-0.0241498388,
0.0087208794,
0.0000229147,
-0.0047105509,
0.0084888488,
0.0002534965,
-0.060102351,
-0.0108796172,
-0.0368948393,
-0.029129874,
-0.0194042139,
-0.0373152345,
-0.010226124,
-0.0486429743,
0.0372804776,
0.008545042,
-0.0141450716,
-0.0484742559,
-0.0749285296,
-0.0083995834,
-0.0137911327,
-0.029062368,
-0.0580650456,
0.0085626626,
0.0086088656,
0.0164158978,
-0.0680479705,
-0.0091760289,
0.0145370653,
-0.0232057087,
0.025583202,
0.032325644,
0.0922277272,
-0.0316136144,
-0.0337184519,
0.0140529713,
0.0119402362,
-0.0041715042,
-0.0460588932,
0.0298280828,
-0.0141948927,
-0.003170789,
-0.0212078206,
0.03563115,
-0.0424939431,
-0.0141126998,
-0.0132193016,
0.0679559037,
-0.0115792351,
-0.0358566456,
-0.0359947458,
0.0559705794,
0.0495516174,
0.0332920961,
-0.0011667456,
0.0004773897,
-0.0195155572,
-0.0489742085,
0.0296770595,
-0.0361148715,
-0.0203031413,
-0.0363292918,
-0.0041782702,
-0.047911752,
-0.0200887322,
-0.0287708193,
0.0239627901,
-0.0137824668,
-0.0369497426,
-0.03286843,
0.067267403,
0.000684747,
-0.0626076609,
0.0351237357,
0.0147655793,
0.0401850529,
0.0153690334,
-0.0547427386,
0.0356203392,
0.0820975825,
-0.0225679465,
0.0132799521,
-0.034483511,
-0.0457910784,
0.0143374717,
0.0427398905,
0.0208228678,
-0.0362692811,
0.0561193526,
-0.0084454995,
0.0280258432,
0.0773280561,
-0.0194739867,
-0.0055498378,
0.0294162128,
0.0664982423,
0.0338499285,
0.0194454417,
0.0147685418,
0.0030008256,
-0.0021009138,
-0.02348282,
-0.0656017885,
0.0019848289,
-0.0112809241,
0.0171969701,
0.0717366785,
0.005928251,
-0.0524749458,
-0.0529862307,
-0.0230390131,
0.0304306448,
-0.0043025846,
-0.0416255258,
0.0080171041,
0.012328513,
0.0250441656,
-0.0838370696,
0.0368356034,
0.0064733024,
-0.0181598514,
-0.030848084,
0.0498686954,
0.015237052,
0.013841942,
-0.0105708009,
-0.0222950894,
0.0095180925,
-0.0518478565,
0.0189884733,
-0.0472172759,
0.0245319176,
0.0276483912,
-0.0212648083,
-0.0001392426,
0.0099641597,
0.0371280611,
0.0072357939,
-0.0456806421,
-0.0103040114,
0.0414715745,
-0.0019352561,
0.0034202808,
0.0288392808,
-0.030588109,
-0.0018006236,
0.0021327385,
0.0232654568,
-0.0349239856,
-0.0224401411,
0.0467075184,
-0.0336508006,
-0.0447436348,
-0.0055459309,
0.0102756731,
-0.0704444125,
0.0422823578,
0.0004930803,
-0.0415493213,
-0.0184613504,
0.0136356754,
-0.0000861864,
0.001693962,
0.0335299671,
0.0530980453,
-0.049557738,
0.0064295279,
0.0749326274,
-0.0191301089,
0.0140881147,
0.0143081844,
-0.0127995666,
0.0307059474,
-0.0380747318,
0.0316292234,
-0.004351804,
-0.0314652137,
-0.066131942,
-0.0374979004,
-0.0160525981,
-6.994040042e-33,
-0.0113440715,
-0.0400743335,
-0.0591640137,
0.0272530653,
-0.0342126377,
0.0115096951,
0.0096035479,
0.0500725321,
-0.0005435244,
0.0766421035,
0.0044599059,
0.0045586936,
0.0061803116,
-0.0231342502,
0.0449466333,
-0.0037839781,
0.0051062102,
-0.0306853559,
0.0023189157,
-0.0025145204,
0.0499447249,
0.0336808041,
0.0179693624,
-0.1362420619,
0.0297970045,
0.0073082973,
-0.0391060412,
-0.0295500644,
0.0009766858,
-0.0094680926,
0.0011353237,
0.0542525165,
0.0528537482,
-0.0096926223,
-0.0225922931,
0.105068773,
-0.0298727751,
-0.0429011621,
-0.0048932019,
-0.0450591221,
-0.0285021774,
0.0159125831,
-0.0044696033,
0.0371480547,
-0.0518419705,
0.0090934066,
0.0369069315,
0.0159131475,
0.0554618388,
-0.0504942723,
-0.0281691439,
0.0095769605,
-0.0300281662,
0.0368340276,
-0.0107340813,
0.0502432771,
0.0299979746,
0.085778296,
-0.0948868394,
0.0581264496,
-0.0304208286,
-0.0020221616,
-0.0075610164,
-0.0606460683,
0.0065595787,
0.0824353248,
0.0170741435,
0.0201364607,
-0.0080247121,
0.02215215,
-0.0095812473,
-0.0055780048,
0.0178072397,
0.0845752805,
0.0347018391,
-0.0435894914,
-0.0545954853,
0.0404732265,
0.0444518514,
0.0234438609,
0.01258842,
-0.0030483778,
0.0176268872,
-0.00403562,
-0.0103698326,
-0.0262436848,
-0.0484251566,
0.0115152532,
-0.035863623,
-0.0107244998,
-0.0340761691,
0.001599783,
0.0000883332,
-0.0197535288,
-0.0682996064,
0.0396775641,
-0.0137781529,
0.0411062054,
0.0230104234,
0.0180561077,
-0.042064622,
0.0136262011,
-0.0471127406,
0.0262609422,
0.0468300395,
-0.014927268,
0.0281174928,
0.0092820274,
-0.0470691361,
-0.0356263965,
-0.0199307036,
-0.0102377003,
-0.0041673086,
-0.0621255264,
-0.038952779,
0.0203226283,
0.0163434315,
-0.0189069305,
0.0222734194,
0.0556456037,
0.0302454699,
-0.0330182128,
-0.077500917,
0.0113094654,
0.013604017,
-0.0357076973,
-0.0327344462,
-0.0425584652,
-0.0196619686,
-0.0495084524,
0.0098493984,
-0.0420551449,
2.938e-7,
0.0386902504,
0.0634485334,
-0.0157017279,
-0.0267468244,
0.028030796,
0.0586114191,
-0.0030443866,
0.0071551278,
-0.011212579,
-0.0347018167,
-0.0107993744,
-0.0055199079,
-0.0049387314,
-0.0020873456,
-0.0417097732,
-0.0249981973,
-0.0256997291,
-0.0233149249,
-0.0676317513,
0.0364558771,
0.0432465672,
0.0542973168,
0.0349734873,
0.0247020796,
-0.0179455318,
0.0363300443,
0.0627738386,
-0.102396436,
-0.009622762,
0.0013301149,
0.0324044228,
-0.0812171996,
-0.0218069572,
0.0085865306,
-0.0238728914,
-0.0582093298,
0.0038033808,
0.0046430668,
0.0658829063,
-0.0244080815,
0.0260259528,
0.0224303752,
0.0014351683,
0.0027437333,
-0.00164437,
-0.0571533926,
-0.0635331348,
-0.0518856533,
-0.0081957001,
0.0328890644,
0.0372806601,
-0.0167856254,
-0.0524818338,
-0.0006003255,
-0.0114500504,
-0.0036457269,
-0.0138798207,
-0.0425067544,
0.0363880135,
-0.041744601,
-0.0098828021,
-0.0307848305,
-0.0191761553,
-0.0017975767,
0.0366641767,
0.0443420075,
0.0110316249,
1.729005712e-34,
0.0075421734,
-0.0373430215,
-0.0306960698,
-0.0697520003,
0.0462054387,
-0.0001453413,
-0.0036452529,
0.0047656912,
-0.0094002858,
-0.0204523895,
0.0323782749
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03093v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03093v1 | RESIN-EDITOR: A Schema-guided Hierarchical Event Graph Visualizer and Editor | 2023-12-05T19:25:38 | 2023-12-05T19:25:38 | Khanh Duy Nguyen, Zixuan Zhang, Reece Suchocki, Sha Li, Martha Palmer, Susan Brown, Jiawei Han, Heng Ji | cs.HC | cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL | In this paper, we present RESIN-EDITOR, an interactive event graph visualizer
and editor designed for analyzing complex events. Our RESIN-EDITOR system
allows users to render and freely edit hierarchical event graphs extracted from
multimedia and multi-document news clusters with guidance from human-curated
event schemas. RESIN-EDITOR's unique features include hierarchical graph
visualization, comprehensive source tracing, and interactive user editing,
which is more powerful and versatile than existing Information Extraction (IE)
visualization tools. In our evaluation of RESIN-EDITOR, we demonstrate ways in
which our tool is effective in understanding complex events and enhancing
system performance. The source code, a video demonstration, and a live website
for RESIN-EDITOR have been made publicly available. | [
0.0005810349,
0.0032138687,
-0.0255470332,
0.022426907,
-0.0133733312,
0.0027011435,
-0.0459131449,
0.0421538614,
0.0009184044,
-0.0027150933,
0.0141006764,
0.0795459226,
-0.0399652682,
0.0781905353,
-0.0354260318,
-0.11667265,
0.0503991358,
0.0188147984,
0.0069891131,
0.068623215,
0.0149503881,
0.0117452778,
-0.0079749115,
-0.0076754703,
-0.0220303051,
-0.0136936512,
-0.0498130731,
0.0036425821,
0.0362879708,
-0.0606423467,
-0.0737236962,
0.0216554552,
0.0423689224,
0.0279540811,
0.0000021491,
-0.0163347535,
-0.0249705072,
-0.0206097327,
-0.0166878086,
0.0644198954,
-0.0171665084,
-0.0424041785,
-0.001031601,
-0.0472277179,
-0.0150877442,
-0.0403549038,
0.0158137679,
0.0148373386,
0.0471100397,
-0.0020666597,
-0.029150337,
0.0139764631,
-0.0131558459,
-0.0000120575,
-0.0162503347,
0.0013025138,
-0.0168474633,
0.0228638202,
0.0446122438,
0.0071486523,
0.0178560205,
0.0034383347,
-0.0158346538,
-0.0242030155,
0.0505755246,
0.0264391452,
0.0276973099,
-0.0552261546,
-0.0115695717,
0.0094749006,
0.0140795447,
0.0243223552,
0.0623103641,
-0.0112274764,
-0.0177398026,
0.04591465,
-0.0712993219,
0.0149913393,
-0.0139401145,
-0.0003951323,
0.0127338478,
-0.0294627529,
-0.0319326706,
-0.03738961,
0.012289037,
0.0033999057,
0.017212823,
0.00292327,
-0.0485125929,
0.0021576483,
0.0373464152,
-0.0645544454,
0.019514326,
0.0149367293,
-0.0226880908,
0.0139042297,
0.0100989304,
0.0236414596,
-0.0015623617,
-0.0412438326,
-0.0056213229,
0.0055428399,
0.0397685766,
0.0370666981,
0.0724213719,
-0.0233744942,
-0.0165459868,
-0.0193468407,
0.0498016365,
0.0178217199,
-0.0067861527,
0.0303160865,
-0.0033245992,
-0.0319206789,
-0.0894729495,
-0.0047775977,
0.0046626059,
0.0373585485,
0.005750278,
0.0297125373,
-0.0231253486,
-0.0225614551,
0.0038915398,
-0.0094736507,
-0.0225204267,
-0.0108606154,
-0.0582546815,
-0.0167869199,
-0.0252078287,
0.0039667236,
-0.0319826193,
0.0205797348,
0.0659846514,
-0.0059220679,
-0.0413515568,
0.0258641858,
-0.0258880388,
0.0206792038,
-0.0766264275,
-0.0615480281,
0.0118151568,
0.0316715427,
-0.0297391415,
-0.0268500205,
0.0350047164,
-0.0128649715,
-0.0141158635,
-0.0091721984,
-0.0120270075,
-0.0161444787,
-0.0508353561,
-0.0074878396,
-0.1135605574,
0.0123195089,
0.0180052929,
-0.0040653693,
-0.0427866392,
-0.0147572216,
-0.003907233,
0.0543112755,
0.0589283928,
-0.0139786489,
0.0086673955,
0.0303664561,
-0.0010518857,
-0.0019456093,
-0.0087113995,
-0.0128266867,
-0.028922243,
-0.0287093837,
0.0229524113,
-0.0798422098,
-0.0435530022,
0.006452166,
0.0271241385,
0.0017395464,
0.0015781437,
-0.0220469907,
0.0165165309,
0.0112456819,
0.0061439318,
-0.0119062215,
0.0022841576,
0.0281718243,
0.0366792753,
0.0082419375,
-0.0761564746,
-0.0046703327,
0.0274244864,
0.0082086027,
0.0128837535,
0.036226511,
0.0176712796,
-0.0433168598,
0.0349140763,
0.0029675753,
0.0092483051,
0.0343453325,
0.0399255492,
-0.0272254292,
0.0399818644,
0.0254224688,
0.0092019672,
0.0945513248,
0.0463374853,
-0.0435582399,
-0.013792377,
0.0282832049,
-0.0165110156,
0.0207475312,
0.0257035457,
-0.0236670114,
-0.0175713934,
-0.0031302636,
-0.0251486357,
-0.0352388285,
0.0202813931,
0.0348875672,
-0.0086506903,
0.0032311992,
-0.0073074191,
0.0364978872,
-0.0074299481,
0.0012676838,
0.0280179642,
0.016330516,
-0.0525014661,
0.0217257775,
-0.0196474139,
0.0400070101,
-0.0184238795,
-0.0062764697,
0.0455759987,
0.0068123816,
-0.0174339395,
0.0399630852,
0.0713412836,
0.0046645449,
0.0013042267,
-0.0376048721,
-0.0211685225,
-0.0286421739,
-0.0332184955,
-0.043152526,
0.0358089022,
-0.0211340711,
0.0139573459,
0.0226712637,
0.0025051502,
-0.0128764519,
-0.0266944468,
-0.0262960549,
0.0542819463,
0.0298610516,
-0.0400147848,
0.0115416069,
-0.0212675836,
-0.014357781,
-0.0163522698,
0.0563145801,
0.0101277288,
0.0049748491,
-0.0562700033,
0.0190399215,
-0.0774590895,
-0.0560925044,
0.0329496264,
-0.0278558377,
-0.013940732,
0.0015328689,
0.0503476895,
0.041068837,
0.0370035395,
-0.0594546013,
-0.0104319025,
0.0283203088,
-0.0368275233,
-0.0387246311,
-0.0217012782,
0.0335838534,
0.0125337066,
0.0100814607,
-0.0462464206,
-0.0047662063,
-0.0413804017,
0.0338175148,
0.0806730911,
-0.1005152538,
0.0082189711,
-0.0007726871,
0.0096022524,
-0.0369710922,
0.0057669468,
0.0374733955,
0.0072128726,
-0.0081752138,
0.0307758078,
0.0153582105,
-0.0191662163,
0.1104800701,
0.0291046724,
-0.0718911439,
0.0101004187,
0.0176728703,
-0.04464164,
0.1006408855,
0.0109404335,
-0.0291154962,
0.0642067716,
-0.0063221934,
0.0465115421,
0.0455491431,
0.0043599578,
-0.0428402498,
-0.0257435162,
0.064168185,
-0.0029533207,
-0.0907738581,
-0.009039537,
0.0272966363,
-0.0120134596,
-0.0032978768,
0.0138403513,
0.0071936892,
0.0301613118,
0.0145723941,
-0.043163009,
-0.0616842993,
0.0639872551,
-0.0167176519,
-0.0080592912,
-0.0448118187,
-0.0502616912,
0.0226302184,
-0.0018449946,
0.0445831679,
-0.0228241216,
-0.0367167331,
-0.0258623902,
-0.0478081703,
-0.016350437,
0.0274325274,
0.0106143672,
0.0130634857,
-0.003899158,
-0.0354061797,
0.0906817839,
-0.0261705071,
-0.0353156701,
0.0186251663,
0.0231485702,
0.0424562953,
0.0277164225,
-0.0144388396,
0.0149801914,
0.0640449002,
-0.0065734102,
-0.038152311,
-0.0368122011,
-0.0287837293,
-0.0132331261,
0.0603153184,
0.0117866853,
-0.0283905677,
-0.0285709575,
0.0233545788,
-0.0443932004,
-0.018200526,
-0.0023993601,
-0.0332895666,
0.0015206676,
-0.0202910267,
0.0639620647,
0.0611047894,
0.0602164418,
-0.054531984,
0.0237475839,
0.0026789114,
-0.0163211692,
0.0169789195,
0.0276026167,
-0.0925401524,
0.0196095239,
-0.0129359802,
0.0158044565,
0.0235612653,
-0.0601256825,
0.0011646372,
0.0133838793,
0.0599184111,
0.0023662273,
-0.0101335952,
-0.0093571385,
-0.1006760597,
0.0249978323,
-0.0194125827,
-0.0725951865,
0.0223324075,
-0.0012731482,
-0.0055668512,
-0.0242337827,
-0.1034711599,
-0.0129899522,
-0.0347662605,
-0.0022513701,
-0.0055086841,
-0.0690374449,
0.0263058506,
0.0031487774,
0.0846605748,
-0.0044031148,
0.0145789403,
0.0350500755,
-0.0321930423,
0.0843955278,
0.021382004,
0.0045296596,
-0.039652437,
0.0238437913,
0.0831999257,
-0.0608839989,
0.0314806812,
0.0834315792,
-0.0171673838,
0.0013167649,
-0.0069150538,
-0.0292094722,
0.0268357545,
-0.0125504918,
0.0646872073,
0.0098432275,
-0.0087924777,
-0.0243709926,
0.0383680426,
-0.0256500915,
-0.0229057204,
0.0189126674,
-0.0632914603,
-0.0576303303,
-0.0407059342,
-0.0187384505,
0.0211862884,
0.000572196,
-0.0272374582,
-0.0384063385,
0.0160626676,
-0.03062368,
-0.0538384803,
0.0103450865,
0.0114311008,
-0.0233376641,
0.0385087579,
-0.0001297371,
-0.027258765,
0.0671840832,
-0.033473704,
0.0804950967,
-0.0085053453,
-0.0006250149,
-0.0086694984,
-0.0638613477,
0.0108239185,
0.0161117017,
0.0153098544,
-0.0046026977,
0.0154153053,
0.0079073012,
-0.0468321592,
-0.0634737238,
-0.0609312542,
-0.0219985154,
-0.013819945,
-0.0297770649,
-0.0165725183,
0.0217422117,
-0.0436022282,
0.0094104698,
-0.0395379998,
0.0215758961,
0.0058564949,
0.0236003362,
0.0221394282,
0.0218529366,
-0.0154878907,
-0.0378220119,
0.0159908291,
-0.0425377712,
-0.0082693081,
0.0426363833,
0.0173779726,
-0.0517518334,
-0.0480062291,
-0.0032632451,
0.0580572598,
0.0048677167,
-0.0318466835,
-0.0847104415,
0.006675994,
0.0418950059,
-0.03592816,
0.0187675245,
0.00266539,
0.0041257995,
0.0042553456,
-0.0189228151,
0.0345388278,
-0.0073343059,
-0.0065533919,
-0.0003609938,
-0.0191426203,
0.0035701373,
-0.0249967743,
-0.0553086363,
0.040760424,
0.0420992374,
0.0013656003,
0.0702224672,
0.0233026259,
0.0404188931,
-0.0186522994,
-0.0097889984,
0.033480566,
0.0075519672,
0.0062910714,
0.0321857706,
-0.0476905592,
-0.011436454,
-0.0298920404,
0.0131539712,
0.0427480303,
-0.0090404637,
0.0273874793,
-0.0082391584,
-0.0442289338,
-0.0280975047,
0.0031160701,
0.0239049681,
0.0264255516,
-0.0272647999,
-0.0418233499,
-0.0476640277,
0.0226871576,
0.0299543906,
0.0021700365,
-0.0381731316,
0.0112558817,
0.0059105977,
0.0387990996,
0.035100475,
-0.0253624357,
0.0069363913,
0.065015547,
-0.0209842902,
-0.0244058426,
-0.0097190496,
-6.577593985e-33,
-0.0057777492,
-0.065583244,
0.0014431896,
0.0411769599,
-0.0105126984,
-0.0067816125,
-0.0685969815,
-0.0199472103,
0.0232989527,
0.0055015488,
0.0147772068,
-0.0042075398,
0.0015384316,
-0.0447082222,
0.0182715766,
0.0408768766,
0.0543986224,
0.0276309382,
-0.011354872,
0.0266583376,
0.0574016236,
0.0401672274,
0.0041883104,
-0.0784415752,
0.0013475179,
0.028309742,
0.0291580018,
-0.0280521326,
0.1036100462,
0.0243275892,
-0.017468363,
-0.0359073654,
0.0082281958,
-0.0359271169,
-0.0159139838,
-0.00530037,
-0.0435786135,
-0.0190682244,
0.0156481955,
-0.0086288406,
0.0137454858,
-0.0240852032,
0.0112751061,
0.0249693654,
0.0089518474,
-0.0145549709,
0.038434796,
0.0295716878,
-0.019334767,
-0.0229626726,
-0.0283742566,
0.0649744645,
-0.0516813137,
0.0588804223,
-0.0053411932,
-0.0100121126,
0.0379035436,
0.0257779416,
-0.0324408859,
0.036780633,
-0.0473064035,
-0.0340330414,
0.0098061292,
-0.0176888909,
-0.0053487835,
0.0183391813,
-0.0366360471,
0.0305840448,
0.0010673817,
0.0910743102,
-0.004727039,
0.1370587498,
0.0015233231,
-0.0125724506,
-0.0272998326,
-0.0057940455,
-0.0798055008,
0.0474929847,
-0.0251649376,
-0.0221799053,
-0.0446686707,
0.061259836,
0.0147893373,
0.0203765463,
0.0478867404,
0.0221727174,
-0.0356215239,
-0.0190702099,
-0.0072939605,
-0.0201921519,
-0.0389326885,
0.0330849141,
-0.0168988835,
0.0342575312,
-0.0127913812,
0.0228575487,
-0.0227200985,
0.0467875637,
-0.0281710569,
-0.0554513447,
0.0080851344,
-0.0149342539,
-0.0098303501,
-0.0040357914,
0.0211167,
0.0064600161,
0.0199224222,
0.0169603284,
-0.021366762,
0.0150730051,
0.0442748889,
-0.0020742696,
-0.0274950825,
-0.0696496144,
0.0334176458,
-0.0066776462,
-0.0148069263,
0.0010284997,
0.0613537766,
0.1068318114,
0.0530244,
-0.0240814853,
-0.0459181145,
0.0349807665,
0.0309828836,
-0.0045717107,
-0.0348113887,
0.005263024,
0.0219982211,
-0.0274043381,
-0.01889541,
-0.0190278031,
2.834e-7,
0.055088345,
0.0833862722,
0.0502238572,
0.056593664,
0.0489653125,
-0.0420018733,
-0.0009008525,
0.0234697238,
-0.0135735003,
-0.0181057993,
0.0234760065,
0.0144354282,
0.0227272287,
0.1079466566,
-0.0098485854,
-0.0276319776,
-0.0575431921,
-0.0442029834,
-0.1132074594,
0.0206243917,
0.084642306,
-0.0141326031,
0.0559941754,
0.0335309841,
0.0191647373,
-0.0044861478,
-0.0111984052,
0.0087934965,
-0.0586709604,
-0.0125696333,
-0.0348986723,
0.0132047944,
-0.0457689874,
0.0295433085,
-0.0456693918,
-0.0130169559,
-0.0560637899,
-0.0023177576,
-0.0330658741,
0.0726456493,
0.0565488189,
-0.044973202,
0.0086756907,
-0.0269874148,
0.0273084361,
-0.010698677,
0.0070554661,
0.0173397753,
-0.0565607734,
0.0264402498,
-0.0419301987,
0.0080889268,
-0.0054579908,
0.0321434103,
-0.044442907,
0.0150327235,
-0.0182482228,
-0.006695834,
0.0149154421,
0.0288243145,
-0.0019081844,
-0.0352190398,
-0.0382671766,
-0.0332514755,
-0.0225538891,
0.0452714823,
0.0035487413,
2.625299722e-34,
0.0325568579,
0.0659472197,
-0.0201606024,
-0.0120336888,
0.0833139196,
-0.0097729582,
-0.0436494946,
0.013890258,
0.0158278849,
-0.0546638928,
-0.0099911131
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03088v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03088v1 | LLMs for Multi-Modal Knowledge Extraction and Analysis in Intelligence/Safety-Critical Applications | 2023-12-05T19:04:50 | 2023-12-05T19:04:50 | Brett Israelsen, Soumalya Sarkar | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models have seen rapid progress in capability in recent years;
this progress has been accelerating and their capabilities, measured by various
benchmarks, are beginning to approach those of humans. There is a strong demand
to use such models in a wide variety of applications but, due to unresolved
vulnerabilities and limitations, great care needs to be used before applying
them to intelligence and safety-critical applications. This paper reviews
recent literature related to LLM assessment and vulnerabilities to synthesize
the current research landscape and to help understand what advances are most
critical to enable use of of these technologies in intelligence and
safety-critical applications. The vulnerabilities are broken down into ten
high-level categories and overlaid onto a high-level life cycle of an LLM. Some
general categories of mitigations are reviewed. | [
0.0021687071,
0.0420923606,
-0.0089668371,
0.0672174916,
-0.0612001307,
0.0210219473,
0.003689406,
0.005239381,
0.0241374448,
-0.0860738009,
-0.0237070676,
-0.01237847,
-0.0227401741,
0.0211137924,
0.0336210355,
0.0252175909,
0.0778140798,
-0.0974229127,
0.007256954,
0.0258821659,
-0.0058864299,
-0.0054778322,
-0.0353365988,
0.0026288757,
-0.042516157,
0.0003756873,
-0.0191249792,
-0.0198198073,
0.0359168686,
-0.0291295033,
-0.0177529957,
0.0079029016,
0.0204490554,
0.0214554314,
0.0000017869,
-0.025491368,
-0.0342691466,
0.0126624387,
-0.0201976858,
-0.0618751012,
0.0423528105,
0.0009140075,
-0.0205248371,
-0.0192623939,
-0.0529686138,
0.0247517005,
-0.007355764,
0.0270058624,
0.0440174863,
0.08076033,
-0.0129710166,
0.0147363273,
0.0720039904,
0.0268281493,
-0.0024156496,
-0.034941908,
0.0435606726,
0.0000683805,
0.0426795334,
-0.0166030377,
0.0156254787,
0.0382240452,
-0.0082876701,
-0.0031566492,
-0.0696387365,
0.0202443618,
0.0289950836,
-0.0212174244,
-0.0579439886,
0.0576031022,
0.0232197531,
0.0318348184,
-0.0000829774,
0.0208967309,
-0.0089041656,
0.0302856732,
-0.0159865506,
0.0375858098,
-0.0409900658,
0.0061569894,
0.0230081901,
-0.0180876665,
0.0320599638,
-0.0011311907,
-0.0146501213,
0.0844189301,
0.0266329274,
-0.042191986,
0.0559403747,
-0.0152426008,
0.0253587626,
-0.0096003143,
-0.0308222994,
0.035180524,
0.0112905316,
0.042829819,
-0.0148998266,
-0.0078814104,
0.0454729088,
-0.0450070314,
0.024079198,
-0.0200339351,
-0.029985236,
0.0316087641,
-0.0039658728,
-0.0059602098,
-0.0179580804,
0.0412309431,
-0.0173891839,
-0.0101753781,
-0.041994486,
-0.0186732076,
0.0288222022,
0.0730332881,
-0.0188883189,
-0.0080319839,
-0.0147414301,
0.0578125417,
0.0034413552,
0.0249600783,
-0.0243056882,
-0.0355275534,
0.0198855679,
0.018431671,
-0.0159423631,
-0.028435437,
0.0294880122,
0.0537265129,
-0.0064027305,
-0.0773896426,
0.0122425947,
0.055999849,
-0.0252507068,
-0.0278254841,
-0.0051899385,
0.1307931393,
-0.0008665206,
-0.053019736,
-0.0745255426,
-0.0519576073,
-0.0403167456,
-0.0626165047,
0.0430875085,
-0.0465878546,
0.0327108353,
-0.0081311911,
-0.0328680873,
-0.0378642678,
0.0156329423,
-0.0159391705,
-0.0472827107,
0.0600257628,
-0.0397308953,
-0.0164344963,
-0.0032834876,
0.0389207117,
0.0068619093,
0.0835689232,
0.0431221053,
0.0042576189,
0.0630428791,
0.0150121218,
0.0222019963,
0.0733557045,
-0.0211476292,
0.0105669172,
-0.0314685851,
0.0034402667,
0.0016407645,
-0.038221553,
-0.0259361044,
0.059753634,
0.0186793134,
-0.0264765024,
0.0666171089,
0.0536667742,
0.0264451392,
-0.0015955712,
0.0337760523,
-0.0246848892,
0.0446657203,
-0.006431106,
-0.0298408642,
-0.0276693664,
-0.1083663926,
-0.0099033611,
-0.0240603797,
0.0606224388,
-0.0070524015,
-0.0340592824,
-0.0250184443,
-0.0329034254,
0.0285861585,
-0.0006172262,
0.0580776148,
-0.0607117079,
0.0077263508,
0.0615738817,
0.020175755,
-0.0306507368,
-0.0251362808,
-0.0851330236,
-0.0260140616,
0.0493092127,
0.0329549052,
-0.0629146621,
-0.0622455962,
-0.0057412875,
-0.0240637194,
-0.0079230601,
-0.0237257313,
-0.0065769469,
0.0385337882,
-0.0206246302,
-0.0485407561,
0.0284142625,
-0.0062189079,
-0.0109610315,
-0.0042721732,
0.0211723577,
-0.0078625558,
-0.0350402407,
0.0215890221,
0.0383394845,
-0.0103030829,
0.0138701992,
-0.0579555258,
0.0248484649,
0.0401904359,
0.0264942497,
-0.019808976,
0.0199551918,
0.0802680552,
-0.0294255763,
-0.0202138275,
0.0186820459,
-0.0125497887,
0.0247865953,
0.0569733419,
-0.0069015459,
0.0179313924,
0.0172532629,
-0.0191578753,
-0.0346902274,
-0.0051042852,
-0.0435305946,
0.0223027337,
-0.0218555443,
0.0067058923,
0.0214396212,
0.0088635059,
-0.0399435461,
0.0709420666,
-0.0403333455,
-0.0299958885,
-0.0047058687,
-0.0233031772,
0.01262068,
-0.0408320725,
-0.0289209336,
0.0407712311,
0.0003519466,
0.0166830942,
-0.0237698015,
-0.0016365781,
-0.0385826901,
-0.053055726,
-0.0807539299,
-0.017373614,
-0.0048788264,
0.0511741824,
-0.0177502688,
-0.020318279,
-0.0457147658,
0.0187433437,
0.0186533928,
0.0326312371,
-0.008675118,
-0.0015694271,
0.0246855039,
0.0456999801,
-0.0289124493,
-0.0103760073,
-0.0089180479,
-0.0324858986,
0.0507357419,
-0.0104190633,
-0.0553990118,
-0.0378581323,
0.0478843674,
-0.0428419039,
0.0453385785,
-0.022479333,
0.0045853574,
0.0168860462,
-0.0245142579,
0.0222029705,
0.0178033933,
0.0205776021,
0.0180021953,
0.0496897697,
-0.0604797751,
-0.0319577977,
0.0103167044,
-0.0064362711,
-0.0151745966,
-0.0519466959,
0.0192627944,
-0.0003734936,
0.0070564598,
0.0014197244,
0.0286837034,
0.0249005035,
-0.007511294,
-0.0048715449,
-0.0525763221,
0.0078324908,
-0.0017487901,
-0.0231462102,
0.0444132276,
0.0196450707,
-0.0291225817,
0.064333491,
-0.0506542102,
0.0250672363,
-0.0125475349,
-0.0496407598,
-0.0361265317,
0.0433087498,
-0.0411196575,
0.0065173381,
0.0063485573,
-0.0033058915,
-0.0163848251,
-0.0257629715,
-0.0179331955,
-0.0290710367,
0.0721609369,
-0.0845589265,
0.0511573628,
-0.0160113163,
-0.0325874649,
-0.0329780392,
-0.0252789576,
-0.0149108078,
0.0206086412,
-0.014100004,
-0.0018234563,
-0.0021832178,
0.0071073668,
0.0535469241,
-0.0325531848,
0.008878801,
0.0003691746,
-0.0432827622,
0.0523519069,
0.02692472,
-0.0137345837,
0.0352157615,
-0.0194639117,
0.0371226296,
0.091661714,
0.0082040951,
-0.0134707205,
-0.0403628983,
0.0074232323,
0.0485552289,
-0.0051890723,
-0.024270812,
0.0441213436,
0.0254402775,
-0.0488978513,
0.0185745154,
0.0579702519,
0.0055625774,
-0.037061654,
0.0155413086,
-0.0007397325,
-0.0359493382,
-0.0084958905,
-0.0122418869,
-0.0632940307,
-0.0239461605,
0.003102124,
0.0366997719,
-0.011591428,
-0.0471230038,
0.0193621032,
-0.0697378591,
0.0513490438,
-0.0086407466,
-0.028387133,
-0.0463401824,
-0.012975404,
0.0112017104,
0.0086729238,
0.0312177837,
-0.0004913783,
-0.0380074754,
-0.0546985976,
0.035623271,
-0.0548703745,
-0.0566260554,
0.0013391237,
-0.0236698184,
0.0499727353,
0.0114379665,
-0.0157048218,
-0.0546498522,
-0.0306251217,
0.0490432642,
-0.0054785232,
0.036619138,
-0.0390188061,
-0.0000491143,
-0.02962026,
0.0152135845,
-0.0225432348,
0.0064931945,
-0.004740349,
-0.0164144579,
0.0236593597,
0.0987408012,
-0.067189917,
0.0124688139,
-0.0494036078,
0.006586506,
-0.0143029233,
0.0558454506,
-0.0211108197,
-0.0299522225,
-0.0304458607,
0.0034398625,
-0.0279981215,
-0.016895486,
-0.0460805893,
0.0264957789,
-0.0043627187,
0.0078827078,
-0.0239568204,
-0.035065081,
-0.0060543353,
0.0217824727,
0.011298595,
0.0293836072,
0.0105235493,
0.0248950161,
-0.0469078012,
-0.0061824094,
0.0004643724,
0.0094847083,
-0.0415909663,
0.0486118756,
0.0439357571,
-0.018522324,
-0.0117715439,
0.0176509041,
-0.055354666,
-0.0739058629,
0.0106773376,
0.05651775,
0.0240496341,
0.0161394887,
-0.0170437954,
-0.0181217454,
0.0748946443,
0.0034244896,
-0.0415366441,
0.0125474557,
0.0277000386,
0.0152417766,
0.0141555034,
0.0160687696,
-0.0477401949,
-0.0091233524,
0.0296028126,
0.0122884847,
-0.0591760203,
-0.0706764236,
-0.0210089218,
0.062195532,
0.0228507966,
0.0045776898,
0.0262392666,
-0.0153407799,
0.0304741729,
-0.0211327244,
0.017580539,
-0.0234344099,
0.052405864,
-0.0397019163,
-0.0098531749,
0.0103554195,
-0.0040390375,
0.0189716406,
0.0247567631,
-0.00797047,
0.0748843402,
0.0207313038,
-0.0031623123,
-0.0027126551,
-0.0050621605,
-0.0036502853,
0.0386148617,
-0.011910975,
0.0160324518,
-0.0110522164,
0.0827127025,
-0.0058643725,
-0.0332785472,
-0.0436209291,
0.0700193346,
-0.0351980627,
-0.0100038592,
0.0084703388,
0.0720489323,
0.0542775914,
0.0639964268,
0.011090911,
-0.0366457328,
0.0151869347,
-0.0339190513,
0.0102047035,
0.0128110666,
0.0203615632,
0.0540804118,
0.0344701931,
-0.038382709,
0.0102134636,
0.0676912889,
-0.0033644165,
0.0443660505,
0.0065890062,
-0.0362760238,
-0.0620366521,
-0.0374549739,
0.051137004,
-0.0069309566,
-0.040016491,
-0.030026421,
-0.1036854386,
-0.0626549199,
0.0561321005,
0.0215897243,
-0.0089804046,
0.0035644579,
0.0143951289,
0.0531553216,
0.0596526638,
-0.0237949099,
-0.0296817403,
-0.038658049,
-0.019776728,
-0.000276877,
0.0337542184,
-5.830454919e-33,
-0.0201486796,
-0.012743854,
0.0399994217,
0.0342526883,
-0.0328055397,
0.0277939402,
0.0250508413,
0.0294584017,
-0.0210339855,
-0.0352458283,
0.0096867476,
-0.0274841078,
0.0184219554,
-0.0199389979,
0.0043138186,
-0.0266265422,
-0.0453455411,
-0.0202549491,
0.0105261132,
-0.0200005844,
0.0682450458,
0.0262348615,
0.0595933087,
-0.0993828475,
0.0494587421,
0.0022144623,
-0.0144903557,
0.0379853398,
-0.0311100669,
0.0640117377,
-0.0439664647,
0.0320246816,
0.0289314352,
-0.0235998165,
-0.0160514973,
0.0205826648,
-0.0249560513,
-0.010779947,
0.033599548,
-0.0173486266,
-0.0069309468,
-0.0570744947,
0.0551978946,
-0.0020485884,
-0.0165220872,
0.019220341,
0.0190108716,
-0.0431890972,
-0.0040566307,
-0.0379877649,
-0.0382143706,
0.0418539606,
0.0182694718,
0.0153638292,
0.0473652668,
0.0095897699,
0.0144160446,
-0.0190145504,
-0.0355526991,
0.0091207093,
0.0164401121,
-0.0053617633,
0.0893459991,
0.0072609824,
-0.0251812302,
0.0817962587,
-0.0198777765,
-0.0573381297,
-0.0037480399,
-0.027612038,
0.0110567007,
0.1168555692,
-0.0106660146,
0.038646739,
-0.0631621704,
0.0166618191,
-0.1066661105,
0.0193828065,
0.0374226235,
0.0530670322,
0.0310396533,
-0.018205734,
-0.0681755021,
0.0098707071,
0.0022871357,
0.0413165689,
-0.0060816938,
-0.0137280719,
0.014892865,
-0.0023030934,
-0.0226132274,
0.0242901128,
0.0214999933,
-0.0270093419,
0.0189798884,
-0.0047682431,
0.0264067166,
0.0005239471,
-0.0084846197,
0.0168699455,
-0.0453635864,
-0.0475204848,
0.0003331153,
-0.0345306322,
0.0377518944,
-0.0342146307,
-0.026574742,
0.0561286695,
-0.0286186766,
-0.032180436,
-0.0182735771,
0.0171077289,
0.0422147959,
0.0210266318,
0.0502824113,
-0.0184368342,
-0.000986425,
-0.001064876,
0.0345087089,
0.0113941701,
-0.0152286133,
0.0205705874,
0.003571698,
0.0139589449,
-0.0069795181,
0.0084604044,
0.0058028577,
-0.0187259745,
-0.0075465939,
-0.0132341785,
0.0178697892,
0.0364288464,
2.613e-7,
0.044166293,
0.0342170484,
0.0373556018,
-0.0181725454,
0.0382931754,
0.0453441255,
-0.0425909497,
0.021325456,
-0.0135706458,
0.0019321752,
0.0003359876,
0.0268243756,
0.0490015857,
0.0526207648,
-0.0190749783,
-0.0247717556,
0.015735209,
-0.046928037,
-0.0589892305,
0.011370901,
0.0877847299,
0.0460963286,
-0.022795368,
-0.0289327856,
-0.0507830083,
-0.0851959884,
0.029505726,
-0.0496737584,
-0.0413192399,
0.0044244342,
0.074154824,
0.0501168072,
0.0078022312,
0.0554281883,
0.0227144696,
0.0253685582,
-0.0180726591,
0.0546808876,
-0.0029956286,
-0.0796683803,
0.0071008261,
-0.0397242233,
-0.0026466125,
0.0085485121,
0.0717495382,
0.0105963461,
-0.0202208683,
-0.0331346616,
-0.0181436595,
-0.0104399379,
-0.0399773121,
-0.0273035895,
0.0062333997,
0.0179204457,
-0.0182120707,
-0.0294263754,
-0.0196287353,
-0.0678830966,
0.0167280398,
0.0244750548,
-0.034305051,
-0.0878469497,
0.0232017729,
0.0354320481,
0.0272006746,
-0.0841968879,
-0.0192431547,
2.454118816e-34,
-0.01373218,
-0.0335219726,
-0.022256393,
0.0199049078,
0.0077236798,
0.0045241956,
-0.0736446902,
0.0022282996,
-0.0494025536,
-0.0761614516,
-0.0022479554
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03077v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03077v1 | Clinical Notes Reveal Physician Fatigue | 2023-12-05T19:00:18 | 2023-12-05T19:00:18 | Chao-Chun Hsu, Ziad Obermeyer, Chenhao Tan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY | Physicians write notes about patients. In doing so, they reveal much about
themselves. Using data from 129,228 emergency room visits, we train a model to
identify notes written by fatigued physicians -- those who worked 5 or more of
the prior 7 days. In a hold-out set, the model accurately identifies notes
written by these high-workload physicians, and also flags notes written in
other high-fatigue settings: on overnight shifts, and after high patient
volumes. Model predictions also correlate with worse decision-making on at
least one important metric: yield of testing for heart attack is 18% lower with
each standard deviation increase in model-predicted fatigue. Finally, the model
indicates that notes written about Black and Hispanic patients have 12% and 21%
higher predicted fatigue than Whites -- larger than overnight vs. daytime
differences. These results have an important implication for large language
models (LLMs). Our model indicates that fatigued doctors write more predictable
notes. Perhaps unsurprisingly, because word prediction is the core of how LLMs
work, we find that LLM-written notes have 17% higher predicted fatigue than
real physicians' notes. This indicates that LLMs may introduce distortions in
generated text that are not yet fully understood. | [
0.03053331,
0.0714262947,
-0.013548146,
-0.022934081,
-0.0240597576,
0.0372438468,
0.0428069234,
0.0679798052,
-0.0176725462,
-0.0383054577,
0.0308288075,
-0.0490992367,
0.0099500027,
-0.0306549035,
0.0421843603,
-0.0164540038,
0.0122519359,
0.0148307821,
0.0807327926,
0.0150622772,
-0.0040846905,
0.028669538,
0.0293305423,
0.033941824,
-0.0154294027,
-0.0255855918,
0.0389444679,
-0.0114482222,
0.0228857361,
0.0047265608,
0.004102041,
0.0657764897,
-0.0042549497,
-0.0165633168,
0.0000018723,
-0.0166707691,
-0.0045333174,
-0.0082565965,
-0.0203557927,
-0.0161345415,
0.0457032323,
-0.0694729537,
0.0174239762,
0.0221582856,
-0.0415929183,
-0.0563838147,
-0.0106607415,
0.0207427945,
-0.033816155,
0.051354453,
-0.0179579705,
0.0620899871,
-0.0502833612,
-0.0375476964,
0.0301147364,
-0.0107863676,
0.0491723679,
0.0062145954,
-0.021582827,
-0.1135736331,
0.0212332495,
0.0067318105,
-0.0442972332,
0.0071348147,
0.0112365233,
0.0328360908,
-0.0008774715,
0.0166585259,
-0.0030551099,
0.0071705882,
-0.0209476743,
0.017818233,
0.0476017259,
-0.0119856121,
0.0235252548,
0.0096655618,
-0.0330388993,
0.0225735363,
-0.0311121978,
-0.0049477494,
0.0447717756,
0.042448651,
0.0500504784,
0.0136869131,
0.0137370816,
-0.0386310108,
-0.0013443939,
-0.0695348904,
0.0148907453,
0.0408134945,
0.0422103778,
-0.0477157161,
0.0691116229,
-0.0160108153,
-0.0472102612,
0.0141260149,
-0.0015546824,
-0.0216382034,
0.0418062434,
-0.057209909,
-0.0263917893,
0.0231914148,
0.0028594784,
0.0108492905,
0.0244422145,
0.0005064388,
-0.0032114109,
-0.017782947,
-0.0488238148,
0.0208632071,
-0.0420165285,
-0.003592927,
0.0133862579,
-0.0336261019,
0.0566406958,
0.0289564282,
-0.0738949999,
-0.0308392998,
-0.0285193957,
-0.0049413573,
0.0114925588,
0.0205947012,
-0.0161185227,
0.0121884905,
-0.0048759724,
0.0195743702,
-0.0029810222,
0.0020038527,
-0.0064624753,
-0.0319004916,
0.0292191934,
0.0139834266,
0.0159663036,
0.0171928275,
-0.0130090574,
0.0262995344,
0.0108307321,
-0.0099727754,
-0.0224017948,
-0.0429840758,
-0.0403652154,
-0.0404327996,
0.0117937652,
-0.0381549001,
-0.0020060649,
0.0178545862,
0.0154032325,
-0.0326881669,
-0.0022827736,
0.0078446129,
-0.0385308042,
0.0076084929,
-0.0222814865,
0.0409496576,
0.0343563519,
0.0213965904,
0.0139063392,
0.0033680317,
0.0287088789,
-0.0235829949,
0.0069762398,
-0.0738330111,
0.0506701358,
0.044760704,
-0.0193687174,
-0.003104338,
0.0259072874,
0.0117782867,
0.0161584448,
0.0371483937,
0.0223113541,
0.0636512414,
-0.0207065642,
0.0275328495,
0.038247861,
0.0693352446,
-0.0074571692,
0.0223658402,
0.0194760785,
-0.0148689887,
-0.019297678,
0.0129591385,
-0.0332862698,
-0.031650316,
-0.000030877,
-0.0297279265,
0.0295493398,
-0.0132529885,
-0.0428381599,
-0.0439590812,
-0.0539866611,
-0.008068772,
0.0059732697,
-0.006012402,
0.0353342518,
-0.0594045967,
-0.0216416195,
0.0702126771,
0.0439601727,
-0.0005304933,
-0.0351540074,
-0.0559205189,
0.0115258442,
0.1181926206,
0.0160792973,
0.0053926473,
0.0443947464,
-0.0471873432,
0.0523742326,
0.0343936868,
0.068416439,
-0.0074580451,
0.001957417,
-0.0487304702,
0.0092355581,
0.0504034944,
0.0508357696,
-0.0261754468,
-0.0002079965,
0.0365274884,
0.0069556013,
-0.0415618569,
-0.0961384699,
0.0164336357,
-0.0605931245,
-0.0494754687,
0.0100656645,
-0.0092096953,
0.0024912888,
-0.0041744453,
-0.0232892428,
0.0162689146,
-0.0252697542,
-0.0228612944,
0.0023764314,
0.0182273444,
-0.0740075037,
0.0461881757,
-0.0146865984,
0.0150149353,
-0.0037145859,
-0.0280415788,
-0.005490371,
0.0085838474,
-0.0178838782,
-0.0273406934,
0.0459429026,
0.011559411,
0.0486710817,
0.0187676828,
0.0042375084,
-0.01734435,
0.0169629641,
-0.0294294152,
0.0254782028,
-0.0343437232,
-0.0204520877,
-0.021661479,
-0.0425412543,
0.0299921334,
0.0103382524,
-0.004598164,
0.0090231737,
-0.0122708762,
0.0035948546,
-0.0137639241,
-0.0421835035,
-0.0985261053,
-0.016399879,
-0.0031895014,
-0.0269322768,
-0.0021661448,
-0.0176275894,
-0.0227541253,
0.0211978406,
-0.012784536,
-0.0071449424,
0.0305643454,
0.0340965651,
-0.0129272658,
0.0102307098,
0.0040085819,
-0.0340779386,
-0.0246047359,
-0.0731662512,
0.0181577615,
0.035230808,
-0.0459666513,
-0.0539254807,
-0.0160009526,
-0.0217035376,
-0.0323069096,
-0.0071078348,
-0.0463589504,
0.0117069548,
-0.0138847986,
0.0505409501,
0.0555124395,
0.0025191056,
0.0281920489,
0.0460658297,
-0.0404367633,
-0.0016280623,
0.0064817704,
-0.0018162393,
0.0039525321,
0.002136369,
-0.1194002032,
-0.033285886,
0.0993304551,
0.0448636934,
0.0329176933,
-0.0260193124,
0.0093279984,
-0.0627933517,
-0.0109150726,
0.0035054737,
0.0217731521,
-0.0266722143,
0.0286415406,
0.0218571946,
-0.0622629188,
0.042175293,
0.0349379592,
0.0539976023,
-0.0409319475,
-0.0260786675,
-0.0214741603,
0.0051663145,
-0.0079514952,
-0.0193171185,
0.0587134808,
0.0028899279,
0.0034128346,
-0.0109247742,
-0.0234901812,
-0.064649865,
0.0497173406,
-0.0220191032,
-0.0175254457,
0.0077615306,
-0.0935990363,
-0.013044307,
-0.0581697337,
-0.1074685454,
-0.0190675538,
0.0135289226,
-0.0265336223,
-0.0746304467,
-0.0237979982,
-0.006522642,
0.030641716,
-0.0114608491,
-0.0198407266,
0.037112277,
-0.024251448,
0.0524638109,
0.0148891974,
-0.011121436,
-0.0897464231,
0.0250573978,
0.0243993439,
-0.0093594603,
0.0236279406,
0.0146711441,
-0.0260844417,
0.0077921818,
-0.0021615671,
-0.0510855652,
0.035934519,
-0.0088417875,
-0.052803617,
0.0266457722,
0.1244918928,
0.0036895883,
-0.0528497286,
0.0213450324,
-0.071306847,
-0.0134676863,
0.0000871368,
0.0183708239,
-0.0315049142,
-0.0364143886,
-0.0113784317,
0.0564047433,
-0.0249052402,
-0.0157075394,
0.0181660354,
-0.0191839356,
0.0296647232,
0.0141857471,
0.0207808744,
0.0468544587,
-0.0226375405,
-0.0101036597,
-0.0262649506,
-0.0267790407,
-0.0148666445,
-0.0198823679,
0.0021957322,
0.0079613114,
-0.1021386236,
-0.035371393,
0.0625943169,
0.0054173884,
0.0012463651,
0.0600835457,
0.0615138337,
-0.0175613593,
-0.0593214333,
-0.0073937681,
0.0093094902,
0.0262222886,
-0.0163752362,
0.0916107297,
-0.0048742634,
0.0151674747,
-0.0743137896,
0.0314552784,
-0.0412533507,
0.0286699142,
0.0274983924,
0.0433465466,
0.0089944676,
-0.0924824923,
-0.0092229247,
0.0537870191,
0.0447928533,
0.057336051,
-0.0002049245,
-0.0563203357,
-0.0129239233,
0.0111379735,
0.0373703912,
-0.0356686115,
-0.0308204126,
-0.0129959593,
-0.0240072608,
-0.0115338638,
-0.0319726057,
-0.0527790338,
0.0244993269,
-0.0012003431,
0.0214178544,
0.0173947345,
0.0196230933,
-0.0282484721,
-0.0521213524,
0.0332755819,
0.0100772269,
0.0091346866,
-0.0279435106,
-0.0634695962,
0.0148247015,
0.0213726964,
0.0103167817,
-0.0279102549,
-0.057784494,
-0.0051058047,
0.0520433672,
0.0382078066,
0.0251830537,
0.0075317724,
0.0273992997,
-0.0318211429,
0.0132531021,
0.0165123343,
-0.0376293547,
0.0109710572,
-0.0283294842,
-0.0140881827,
-0.0096873604,
0.0131831951,
-0.0271033235,
0.0374625362,
0.0330389403,
-0.0386231206,
-0.0598248504,
-0.0198518597,
-0.0352049284,
0.0045536892,
0.0166822281,
-0.0080936756,
-0.0460682288,
-0.0302681793,
-0.0042557274,
-0.0115127666,
-0.0037054501,
-0.0006720567,
-0.0297402125,
-0.0120519996,
0.0043832753,
-0.0313277096,
0.0126709649,
-0.0393193923,
-0.0385908559,
-0.0574214347,
0.0392446145,
-0.0141368723,
-0.0053803395,
0.0405464657,
-0.0218862705,
-0.0175203662,
0.0389260575,
-0.0167354979,
0.0534050129,
0.0356473029,
0.0866656154,
-0.0217893161,
0.0113278143,
0.0076554785,
0.0008564592,
-0.0431733318,
-0.0558977574,
-0.0090906564,
-0.0427926369,
-0.0000488551,
-0.0638922229,
0.049919717,
-0.0212177932,
0.0133124189,
-0.036878746,
0.0302830487,
-0.0135976281,
0.0594277307,
0.0524672754,
0.011000853,
-0.0281381235,
-0.0094150556,
0.0870199576,
0.0208533704,
0.047849521,
0.0156992562,
-0.0536674485,
-0.0391480252,
0.0172025319,
0.0461061336,
-0.0142374784,
-0.0161060281,
-0.0004452002,
-0.0931955054,
0.005424343,
0.0616037212,
-0.0257642698,
0.0017466721,
-0.0332591906,
-0.0043944689,
0.0533287823,
-0.0180202704,
-0.010529682,
-0.0287297592,
0.0872998834,
-0.0346369632,
-0.00511578,
0.0166068375,
-5.60840073e-33,
0.0175109617,
-0.0316900238,
0.0021765896,
-0.0368590057,
0.0205534995,
0.0935028717,
-0.0243142787,
0.0042684688,
-0.0025878933,
0.0290077142,
-0.0164693054,
0.0254413784,
0.0181691386,
0.0082854303,
0.0275517665,
-0.0199347995,
0.0369179733,
0.0008766425,
-0.0019657495,
0.0091932816,
-0.0151656447,
0.0314792283,
0.0482956357,
-0.0532918274,
0.0003721375,
-0.0092254151,
0.0136390384,
-0.0180996861,
-0.0011124008,
0.0411119945,
-0.0305080395,
0.0660055056,
0.0387202799,
0.0122025106,
-0.0116874082,
0.0466615483,
-0.0174802933,
0.0027897565,
0.0094392877,
-0.0073269689,
-0.0060992357,
-0.0531990007,
0.0211095363,
0.0297742914,
-0.0469173938,
-0.0076786941,
0.0294532739,
-0.0217225216,
-0.0154812159,
0.0050192857,
-0.0173478704,
0.0659127906,
0.006056264,
0.0186653398,
-0.0328802541,
0.0320859067,
-0.0318927541,
0.03387044,
-0.071611762,
-0.018031979,
0.028468851,
0.0419740565,
-0.020305559,
0.022687044,
-0.0062905904,
0.0678695738,
0.0460889079,
0.043094784,
-0.0310351606,
0.0012897914,
-0.0178607982,
0.0165367797,
0.0269761309,
0.0586106516,
0.0729879588,
-0.0789482594,
-0.0331750438,
0.0028765379,
-0.0246885512,
-0.0079898108,
0.0874253511,
-0.0215325523,
-0.0666042641,
-0.0734859854,
0.0252838768,
0.0161582008,
0.0074951747,
-0.0061177188,
0.0062223501,
0.0401239917,
0.0365180485,
0.0087711336,
0.0254811272,
-0.00314958,
0.0356690921,
-0.0053257137,
-0.0384054892,
0.0060383044,
-0.0477797091,
-0.0367476828,
-0.0941171348,
-0.0035294597,
-0.0209274646,
0.0543132573,
0.0706889257,
0.0572961718,
0.0290408768,
-0.0218529459,
-0.0389177091,
-0.0107009839,
0.0469116159,
0.0001743294,
0.0248305127,
0.0017033499,
0.0771591365,
0.0007074836,
0.0172972437,
0.0362399817,
0.0135161513,
-0.0533795357,
-0.0144000072,
-0.0439031348,
0.027678825,
0.0004365356,
-0.0619982481,
0.0036469358,
0.0043342635,
0.0287598278,
0.0401241519,
-0.0385958701,
0.0086814873,
-0.0501939468,
2.479e-7,
0.0410989188,
0.0895902365,
-0.0531748533,
-0.0548788123,
0.0267346893,
0.0353892036,
0.0027383945,
0.0116822319,
0.0410021022,
-0.0072266553,
0.0343637802,
-0.010485461,
0.0771569684,
0.0535326377,
-0.0659789443,
-0.0359920599,
-0.0845277384,
0.0022097279,
-0.0387908816,
-0.0163426995,
0.025220992,
0.0613622069,
-0.0100300144,
-0.0265427828,
-0.0134051098,
-0.037608847,
0.0407476537,
-0.0362498425,
0.0065651573,
0.0044737086,
0.0453668423,
0.0012071035,
-0.0089288643,
0.0696157739,
-0.0479626991,
-0.0000262088,
0.0110403411,
0.1034849286,
-0.0414380953,
0.071614407,
0.0263255853,
-0.0157807022,
-0.0174703188,
-0.0117800906,
0.0572673976,
-0.0158286784,
-0.0475558266,
-0.0229269955,
-0.0067236531,
-0.0158530399,
0.0501149632,
-0.0006385092,
-0.0131696127,
0.0398156643,
0.0035271677,
0.0061198724,
-0.0256291386,
-0.0229552984,
-0.0362572819,
0.0250734724,
-0.0238351431,
-0.0603675619,
-0.0006114233,
-0.014863316,
-0.0018101559,
-0.0739689916,
0.0118559329,
2.030439657e-34,
0.052482456,
0.0627916455,
-0.0118789999,
0.0086995028,
0.0252113268,
-0.0021793894,
0.0119011132,
0.0249734819,
0.0293967184,
-0.0597869009,
-0.0098225661
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.02974v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.02974v2 | Describing Differences in Image Sets with Natural Language | 2023-12-05T18:59:16 | 2024-04-26T19:29:58 | Lisa Dunlap, Yuhui Zhang, Xiaohan Wang, Ruiqi Zhong, Trevor Darrell, Jacob Steinhardt, Joseph E. Gonzalez, Serena Yeung-Levy | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG | How do two sets of images differ? Discerning set-level differences is crucial
for understanding model behaviors and analyzing datasets, yet manually sifting
through thousands of images is impractical. To aid in this discovery process,
we explore the task of automatically describing the differences between two
$\textbf{sets}$ of images, which we term Set Difference Captioning. This task
takes in image sets $D_A$ and $D_B$, and outputs a description that is more
often true on $D_A$ than $D_B$. We outline a two-stage approach that first
proposes candidate difference descriptions from image sets and then re-ranks
the candidates by checking how well they can differentiate the two sets. We
introduce VisDiff, which first captions the images and prompts a language model
to propose candidate descriptions, then re-ranks these descriptions using CLIP.
To evaluate VisDiff, we collect VisDiffBench, a dataset with 187 paired image
sets with ground truth difference descriptions. We apply VisDiff to various
domains, such as comparing datasets (e.g., ImageNet vs. ImageNetV2), comparing
classification models (e.g., zero-shot CLIP vs. supervised ResNet), summarizing
model failure modes (supervised ResNet), characterizing differences between
generative models (e.g., StableDiffusionV1 and V2), and discovering what makes
images memorable. Using VisDiff, we are able to find interesting and previously
unknown differences in datasets and models, demonstrating its utility in
revealing nuanced insights. | [
-0.0109252939,
0.0778116956,
-0.0167661887,
0.0522045381,
-0.0431574546,
0.0196988825,
0.0078812204,
0.0035521146,
-0.05858187,
-0.0619608797,
-0.0063265623,
0.0085617015,
0.0061390102,
0.0512454882,
-0.0069413674,
-0.1093436256,
0.034390863,
-0.0109910956,
-0.009776257,
0.0151375411,
0.0188195389,
-0.0171398707,
-0.0236878414,
0.0226932131,
0.0280256309,
-0.0177373886,
-0.0397311039,
0.0380400419,
0.055031199,
-0.0277499966,
-0.0087152272,
0.0710941851,
0.0409139059,
0.0357500166,
0.0000020642,
-0.0246609226,
0.0257463176,
0.0046168156,
-0.0050565945,
0.0049101277,
0.0143546304,
-0.0068297582,
0.0250540655,
-0.0558132119,
-0.0244087111,
-0.0338659771,
0.1027789265,
0.0011385352,
0.0464965068,
0.0305337813,
-0.0022220002,
-0.0395952128,
-0.0297711994,
-0.0046888827,
0.0243437234,
0.0158097222,
-0.0215470567,
0.0306417979,
0.0118325558,
-0.0216929819,
-0.0243142787,
0.02467715,
0.0101184873,
-0.025141431,
0.0144143673,
0.049338229,
-0.0400094837,
-0.0190363806,
0.0012570206,
0.0750788972,
-0.0149778845,
-0.0121518057,
0.0071407673,
-0.0551667251,
-0.002319487,
0.015407254,
-0.0278216619,
0.0311444998,
-0.0098402472,
-0.0025130003,
-0.0675630495,
0.0777134374,
-0.0025421286,
-0.0204563979,
-0.0156904962,
-0.0621701963,
0.0107006887,
0.0369189233,
-0.0797991753,
-0.0059539233,
-0.021716876,
-0.0778159648,
-0.0048471885,
0.0015457064,
-0.0142177911,
-0.0306454692,
-0.0380225852,
-0.0458901078,
0.0056743715,
0.0007399584,
0.0447170734,
-0.0276337378,
-0.1009965464,
0.0508391298,
-0.0076351846,
0.0797975287,
0.0363274105,
0.034551736,
-0.0230202936,
0.0211935062,
-0.0943489671,
-0.0167861041,
-0.014127505,
-0.0145495702,
-0.0146328388,
-0.0221289378,
0.0081277192,
-0.0554292761,
-0.0793832615,
0.0212784577,
-0.0139414249,
-0.0006852588,
-0.0537479036,
0.0121810026,
-0.064978011,
-0.0358905829,
-0.0693124831,
-0.018358862,
0.0294914618,
-0.0623326562,
-0.0056062946,
0.000453856,
-0.0068944776,
0.0074215899,
-0.018562451,
0.0648686811,
-0.0158991795,
0.0134176966,
0.0003391176,
-0.022995919,
0.0302576236,
-0.0644375086,
0.0325623453,
-0.0809253454,
0.0373047478,
-0.0224090628,
-0.0033820758,
-0.0663945228,
-0.0154445451,
-0.0137032382,
0.0235123392,
0.1349066049,
-0.0249145981,
-0.0019137891,
0.008728697,
-0.0032363979,
-0.0065769604,
0.0576287284,
-0.009729336,
-0.0079370681,
0.07155516,
0.0009019813,
0.0109620756,
-0.0265738573,
-0.0156494547,
-0.0008196159,
-0.0951445922,
0.0080241403,
0.0102880746,
0.0218680352,
0.0115865413,
-0.0135245584,
-0.0318134464,
-0.0286005232,
0.0252448749,
0.0601597317,
-0.0101735489,
0.0119052902,
0.0454591438,
0.0135648241,
0.0092537161,
0.0446721129,
-0.018534191,
0.0507215671,
0.0213169698,
0.0059554749,
-0.0225300826,
0.0229990166,
-0.0277334973,
-0.0563250929,
0.002218151,
-0.0094834231,
0.0346434228,
-0.0333211832,
0.015602611,
0.0207123104,
0.0065687052,
0.0177079085,
0.026032256,
-0.0436602235,
-0.0450670198,
-0.0775578544,
0.0236629751,
0.051371444,
-0.0143925818,
-0.0360893123,
-0.0028776317,
0.0366107188,
0.015266723,
0.0529412515,
0.0180254113,
0.0116468491,
-0.007282089,
-0.0387575701,
-0.0407060012,
-0.0685925931,
0.0331306085,
0.0303047076,
0.0200376306,
-0.0172595289,
0.0364264064,
-0.0313414894,
-0.0392708555,
0.0109705608,
0.0443062633,
-0.0004009886,
0.0218224172,
-0.0069130803,
-0.0109114526,
-0.0099948365,
-0.0044601522,
0.007814642,
-0.0369031951,
0.0104919318,
-0.0229134038,
0.0612132549,
0.0079081682,
-0.0117841978,
0.0077696987,
-0.094231084,
-0.0336078331,
0.0199468657,
-0.073175095,
-0.0152298249,
0.002350834,
-0.0308499839,
-0.0325991549,
-0.0123669188,
0.0188441928,
-0.0074805832,
-0.0007006731,
-0.0186624676,
0.0914487764,
0.0227518845,
-0.0218162239,
0.0143520283,
0.0135529051,
-0.0027770451,
-0.0226343162,
0.0178546719,
0.0362429209,
0.0004869237,
0.0009364109,
0.0060695009,
0.0202908311,
-0.02798412,
0.0502703823,
0.001617393,
-0.0033821585,
-0.0103094913,
0.0002384456,
0.0298860501,
-0.0198922437,
0.010492783,
-0.0372105278,
-0.0001761175,
0.0223630071,
-0.0278953947,
-0.0155325299,
0.051815901,
0.0207364336,
-0.012368015,
-0.0475249328,
-0.026464561,
0.0346233621,
0.053430181,
0.0448497273,
-0.0300399475,
-0.0536266603,
0.0265820641,
-0.0335062407,
0.0290904567,
-0.0085552773,
-0.0309262183,
0.0290740523,
0.0089381244,
-0.018080933,
0.056341473,
0.0061356588,
0.0450195298,
0.0463386513,
-0.004350286,
-0.0339539982,
-0.0313589275,
0.017725125,
-0.0186614543,
0.0493755937,
-0.0487609729,
-0.0257173423,
0.000437273,
-0.0015218141,
0.0023287514,
-0.0475277677,
0.0568467937,
-0.0088582002,
-0.0216244869,
-0.053283684,
-0.0057482915,
0.0274270438,
0.0440258533,
-0.0336024575,
-0.0652348846,
0.0638122037,
0.0049241926,
0.0408470221,
-0.0229862481,
-0.0137771098,
-0.0181737822,
0.067624405,
0.0391058847,
0.0259232037,
0.0491196439,
0.0060801739,
-0.0056581353,
-0.0304258447,
0.0782752782,
0.0237555578,
0.0580708683,
-0.1058438867,
-0.0036432301,
-0.0298938658,
-0.0153860133,
0.001252735,
0.0130640687,
-0.0225755721,
0.0139128193,
-0.0155482432,
-0.0586209968,
-0.0142155495,
0.0168423243,
-0.0158127677,
0.0370418467,
-0.0005318624,
0.0089637637,
-0.0105837397,
0.0132005,
0.0189065561,
0.0250282995,
0.0017123104,
-0.0219555609,
0.0153405238,
0.0051943925,
0.0008065121,
0.0189057849,
-0.0738237873,
0.0123363072,
-0.0522821434,
-0.0172406938,
0.0106208706,
0.0131106656,
0.058878433,
-0.0413018726,
-0.0058795935,
0.0587961227,
0.0212751348,
-0.0187357161,
-0.0021175051,
0.0027611374,
-0.0030563984,
0.0382853597,
-0.0008095686,
-0.0506702438,
-0.0337633565,
-0.021284733,
-0.0137833804,
-0.0016891184,
0.0190310944,
-0.0239642225,
-0.0909520313,
0.0489948951,
0.0200995486,
-0.0564784557,
-0.0405459218,
0.0161023252,
0.0081003271,
0.0007007485,
-0.0690100566,
-0.0220115911,
-0.008954349,
0.0055034789,
-0.0016607294,
0.013855719,
-0.0558100268,
-0.0041981996,
-0.0502824448,
-0.0034248303,
0.0433567427,
0.0012716723,
-0.0098753013,
-0.0272306316,
0.0058891331,
-0.0070929397,
0.0282586087,
0.0049680895,
0.0962722972,
0.0405613109,
-0.0298306588,
-0.0109167537,
0.0200733263,
0.0458742715,
-0.0408159345,
-0.0223064497,
-0.027484566,
-0.0236583613,
-0.0072296453,
-0.04680622,
0.0161667429,
0.0312094167,
0.0415652208,
0.0670662671,
0.0209851786,
-0.0477791503,
-0.0051785572,
0.0358507968,
-0.0399940833,
-0.0159239732,
-0.0027216203,
-0.0184394494,
-0.0399168581,
-0.0576926842,
0.0032894388,
-0.0177160464,
-0.0128056081,
0.0183167495,
-0.0531092361,
-0.017118277,
0.0198289473,
-0.0550973602,
0.0652754456,
0.0023895313,
0.0213653911,
-0.0187307671,
-0.0597109869,
0.0445678122,
0.0303025022,
-0.0407738313,
0.0190077648,
-0.0630079135,
-0.0127710691,
-0.0298074726,
0.0261542443,
0.0132777207,
0.0229379777,
0.0201431643,
-0.0632312,
0.0113251014,
0.0631425083,
0.0473026298,
-0.0271863751,
0.0483889841,
-0.0438250452,
-0.0300426278,
0.0089555327,
-0.0176657494,
0.0477350801,
-0.0017599612,
-0.0051055355,
-0.0189358387,
-0.021287946,
-0.0052776183,
-0.0217791665,
0.0639211312,
-0.0002508295,
-0.0064952453,
-0.0258316919,
-0.0145865194,
-0.0214446634,
-0.0192628875,
-0.0214821119,
-0.0116947647,
-0.0230737422,
0.0075088944,
-0.0033309066,
0.0423602164,
-0.0268581342,
0.0252922773,
-0.0433131121,
0.0153062372,
0.065592207,
0.0265493691,
-0.0284393691,
0.0132221878,
-0.0195095539,
0.0084856935,
0.0137423649,
0.0380050354,
-0.0234173704,
0.0334428549,
0.0459161215,
0.009628661,
-0.0283373669,
0.0397904366,
0.0045052404,
-0.033262115,
-0.0341956876,
0.0362985656,
0.0390013866,
-0.0117519265,
-0.0007555853,
0.0074095917,
-0.0234398991,
-0.0052500055,
0.0369394533,
0.0397756249,
-0.0176423769,
0.0530678667,
0.0173144657,
0.0224403609,
-0.0300035104,
0.0584663376,
0.001711422,
0.0315887593,
-0.0020329573,
-0.0036782234,
-0.0238454174,
-0.0109830778,
-0.0246969741,
-0.0337895378,
0.0216103476,
0.00565837,
-0.0347482488,
-0.0488003232,
-0.0079153292,
0.0373026021,
0.056503132,
0.0834109411,
0.0660184771,
0.0211438034,
0.0030122262,
-0.0333442166,
0.0087884795,
-0.0035385657,
-0.0304764975,
0.0118707623,
-0.0499143898,
-5.856944684e-33,
-0.0503295623,
-0.0318927355,
-0.006992212,
-0.03904856,
0.0065331147,
0.0001468033,
-0.0407431126,
0.0018205807,
0.0013457723,
0.064148277,
0.0438745767,
0.0021432512,
0.0263042916,
-0.0075601242,
0.0216533858,
-0.0311259795,
0.0809284672,
0.0039187702,
-0.0271366686,
0.0265532434,
0.0293311551,
-0.0344605669,
0.0607670918,
-0.0582533032,
0.0064250203,
-0.0197276324,
-0.0064690611,
-0.0032727353,
0.0066025625,
0.0368742123,
0.0154099287,
-0.0008002031,
0.0040971022,
-0.0082054967,
-0.0759229809,
-0.0218517762,
-0.024511965,
-0.0562296323,
0.0331938863,
0.0222894624,
-0.0271925405,
-0.0436071008,
-0.0113148335,
-0.0153611228,
0.004384202,
-0.0614807531,
0.0945851356,
-0.0368586108,
0.041241724,
-0.0022097931,
-0.0303169843,
0.021731047,
-0.055421792,
-0.0373290814,
0.041925393,
0.0129790856,
-0.0033625085,
0.0410824716,
-0.0429424234,
0.05420072,
0.088431187,
0.0164823234,
0.0806694403,
0.0167317912,
0.012324051,
0.0687021315,
0.0356046818,
-0.0438754261,
0.0501105785,
-0.0075029312,
-0.0276509207,
0.0943472385,
0.0558718294,
0.0684091896,
0.0825199038,
0.03048262,
-0.0336900391,
-0.0024180671,
-0.1060530469,
0.0543125644,
-0.0128953895,
0.0327115022,
0.0022002012,
0.0356548838,
-0.0190970562,
-0.0636686385,
-0.0411086753,
-0.0098345438,
0.0370617472,
-0.0254688915,
-0.0401268601,
0.0256056413,
0.0189589467,
-0.0353994817,
-0.0032590355,
-0.0034427042,
0.0092152748,
0.0407726131,
0.0172207616,
-0.0532160699,
0.0119901355,
-0.0164927226,
0.0603726581,
0.0831298977,
0.066528745,
0.0030467212,
0.0317550376,
0.0187201407,
-0.0076746182,
0.025915198,
-0.0225744713,
-0.0211280007,
-0.0702932104,
-0.0104518682,
-0.0168216079,
0.0265336502,
-0.0663350448,
0.0342175551,
-0.0111118443,
-0.0438639037,
-0.0138987582,
-0.0135801416,
-0.0135320751,
0.0538575128,
-0.0064475657,
0.0353979133,
-0.044880636,
-0.0277305562,
0.0753089339,
-0.0025466389,
-0.0160293933,
0.0619875938,
2.656e-7,
-0.0149436165,
0.0165159758,
0.0717597902,
0.0224529188,
0.0308757238,
0.0428221412,
-0.0361363627,
-0.0161821302,
-0.0005361883,
-0.026780609,
-0.0009740855,
0.036656145,
0.0460517742,
0.0020580674,
0.0264370628,
0.0282981377,
-0.0544761829,
-0.0375610478,
-0.0644979849,
-0.0520027764,
0.0828102306,
0.0317274705,
-0.0066514984,
0.0085523855,
0.0216088202,
-0.0232143775,
0.0412330367,
-0.0648677349,
0.0139661655,
-0.0172782391,
0.0252502337,
0.0339558609,
-0.0171979498,
0.0483996235,
-0.0418034606,
-0.0527379103,
0.0475509763,
0.0114267208,
-0.0010651572,
0.0241665971,
-0.0629867539,
0.056807626,
0.0160604678,
-0.0364298783,
0.0589230545,
-0.0571718477,
-0.0128012821,
-0.0474112183,
-0.0456383303,
-0.0175744202,
0.0481078923,
-0.0281275045,
-0.0538873486,
0.0366089679,
0.0054053124,
0.0232596342,
-0.0472627319,
-0.0692801699,
-0.0164619423,
0.0243253652,
-0.0189821552,
-0.0015869993,
-0.0188390464,
-0.0410846546,
0.0134793986,
0.0139571587,
-0.0249114037,
1.937645399e-34,
0.0447635874,
0.045229584,
0.0030371512,
-0.0207607336,
0.0386113301,
0.0198641736,
-0.0429732762,
0.0128144184,
-0.0247829426,
-0.0066912589,
0.0135001065
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03052v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03052v2 | Visual Program Distillation: Distilling Tools and Programmatic Reasoning into Vision-Language Models | 2023-12-05T18:58:37 | 2024-04-05T04:33:23 | Yushi Hu, Otilia Stretcu, Chun-Ta Lu, Krishnamurthy Viswanathan, Kenji Hata, Enming Luo, Ranjay Krishna, Ariel Fuxman | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Solving complex visual tasks such as "Who invented the musical instrument on
the right?" involves a composition of skills: understanding space, recognizing
instruments, and also retrieving prior knowledge. Recent work shows promise by
decomposing such tasks using a large language model (LLM) into an executable
program that invokes specialized vision models. However, generated programs are
error-prone: they omit necessary steps, include spurious ones, and are unable
to recover when the specialized models give incorrect outputs. Moreover, they
require loading multiple models, incurring high latency and computation costs.
We propose Visual Program Distillation (VPD), an instruction tuning framework
that produces a vision-language model (VLM) capable of solving complex visual
tasks with a single forward pass. VPD distills the reasoning ability of LLMs by
using them to sample multiple candidate programs, which are then executed and
verified to identify a correct one. It translates each correct program into a
language description of the reasoning steps, which are then distilled into a
VLM. Extensive experiments show that VPD improves the VLM's ability to count,
understand spatial relations, and reason compositionally. Our VPD-trained
PaLI-X outperforms all prior VLMs, achieving state-of-the-art performance
across complex vision tasks, including MMBench, OK-VQA, A-OKVQA, TallyQA, POPE,
and Hateful Memes. An evaluation with human annotators also confirms that VPD
improves model response factuality and consistency. Finally, experiments on
content moderation demonstrate that VPD is also helpful for adaptation to
real-world applications with limited data. | [
0.015077631,
0.0671045482,
-0.0236220229,
0.0489259437,
-0.0057121892,
0.0279112458,
-0.0212677587,
-0.0136546446,
-0.0171227995,
-0.0421281457,
-0.0052628345,
0.0295442883,
0.009801087,
0.0408765711,
0.0136896567,
-0.1068471968,
0.0262562223,
-0.0544351786,
0.0299349762,
0.0124256667,
-0.0021238402,
-0.0003690964,
-0.0113190962,
0.0388319716,
-0.0208755191,
-0.0259630792,
-0.0325176641,
0.0230493657,
0.0122610098,
0.002791604,
-0.060682524,
0.0113683194,
0.0489907563,
-0.0004967967,
0.0000022752,
-0.0243190993,
0.0224750675,
-0.0080898814,
-0.0018910203,
-0.0071534147,
0.0017441548,
-0.0315960273,
-0.0045087649,
0.0101529434,
-0.0121991448,
-0.0368409716,
0.0541341417,
-0.0153430225,
0.0882419199,
0.0654234663,
0.0077901217,
-0.0344089493,
0.0224090721,
0.000135854,
-0.0005832113,
-0.0156437308,
0.0064394292,
0.038088657,
0.007132824,
-0.0012343135,
-0.0452090092,
0.0530402139,
0.0551343635,
-0.0082839485,
-0.001868807,
0.0177964065,
-0.0309991036,
-0.0334037691,
-0.0199995078,
0.0335926041,
-0.0361585133,
-0.0225305017,
0.0375469923,
0.0009344644,
0.0132104475,
-0.0141120097,
-0.0615107343,
0.0706533417,
-0.0173559934,
-0.0009682534,
-0.034787789,
-0.0237198807,
0.0144053111,
-0.0231362563,
0.0059467303,
0.0037903357,
0.0056800176,
0.0187994502,
-0.0185136255,
-0.0172869451,
-0.0281198155,
-0.0917638913,
-0.0081384713,
0.0643228143,
-0.0326864645,
0.0189860631,
-0.0408734977,
-0.0037594964,
-0.0437235571,
-0.0293530375,
0.0730485991,
0.0494990647,
-0.0471296534,
0.0760022253,
-0.0352209248,
0.1010903716,
-0.017814273,
0.0609243438,
-0.027519742,
-0.0381564535,
-0.0430984125,
-0.0148100303,
-0.0352617987,
0.001715758,
-0.0343339406,
-0.029206004,
-0.0071461862,
0.0315289907,
-0.0449322797,
0.0173500963,
-0.0030265746,
0.0066395593,
-0.014402559,
-0.0249691345,
-0.0422691703,
0.0520207286,
-0.029831741,
-0.0116365366,
-0.0117660435,
-0.0372494683,
0.0002299226,
0.0359561741,
-0.0100613432,
-0.0083527388,
0.0181466695,
0.0753511265,
-0.0289752167,
-0.0013353783,
-0.0368535183,
-0.0269635171,
-0.0021922232,
-0.0689085945,
0.0278603192,
-0.0924398899,
0.0226485394,
-0.0153904185,
-0.0070938552,
-0.0601538271,
0.0000382936,
0.0284516774,
-0.0273460224,
0.0899840295,
-0.0036733868,
0.026625352,
0.003123926,
0.0422416516,
-0.0035031778,
0.0710835978,
0.0315819308,
0.0559309199,
0.0135961687,
0.0045210104,
0.0324243419,
0.020241512,
0.0029008377,
-0.0145584587,
-0.0764963999,
0.0146746682,
-0.0344196409,
-0.008080381,
0.0116771366,
0.0574046187,
-0.031765148,
-0.0217996035,
0.0349932685,
0.0419701599,
-0.0002076183,
-0.0248722136,
0.0687781796,
-0.0172982067,
0.02432115,
0.0005584985,
-0.0677691624,
0.0869882181,
-0.0045361901,
-0.0137659265,
-0.0100366585,
0.0159021616,
-0.0429404266,
-0.078474164,
-0.0031478086,
-0.0108135985,
-0.0103427405,
0.0257168766,
0.0477206036,
0.0146869626,
-0.0077115432,
0.0223399904,
0.0041371877,
-0.0310857892,
-0.0109075923,
-0.061841011,
0.0314087197,
0.0857204795,
0.0433723591,
-0.0256692152,
0.023007337,
0.0210719239,
0.0345468,
-0.0004833459,
0.0210590139,
-0.0274144541,
0.0166660734,
-0.0118098399,
-0.0305666756,
-0.0277765524,
0.0107327234,
0.0299618263,
0.0498697273,
-0.0147934621,
-0.0040642326,
-0.00143739,
0.0101730144,
0.0399933308,
0.010173047,
-0.0341997594,
-0.0351066031,
0.0272451174,
0.012359201,
-0.0233028401,
-0.0179333463,
-0.0049685752,
0.026558226,
-0.0081903739,
0.0042807311,
-0.0104608312,
-0.0323350616,
-0.0084532565,
0.0441180542,
-0.0757518783,
-0.0121238362,
0.0307498369,
-0.0375788212,
-0.0210619923,
0.0544936992,
-0.0335785486,
-0.0320462137,
-0.0200375468,
0.0065857936,
0.0039881407,
-0.0472451076,
-0.0122618945,
0.0580092035,
-0.0178726539,
-0.035341382,
0.0186141785,
-0.0050583854,
0.0178494621,
-0.0078605814,
-0.0138559807,
-0.0064741401,
-0.0077498695,
0.0090411529,
-0.0109317331,
-0.0072229053,
-0.018429568,
0.0034813336,
-0.0907355994,
0.0210463796,
-0.0332761407,
-0.0399289131,
0.0163593981,
-0.0257962402,
0.0209343862,
-0.0444072038,
-0.0119471615,
0.0268603712,
0.013200257,
0.0183866546,
0.0151129579,
0.0059774732,
-0.014720249,
-0.0220008064,
-0.0285250023,
0.0000166837,
0.0177071579,
0.0059173424,
-0.0044809831,
-0.0281172544,
0.0167569313,
-0.0328743346,
0.0483744144,
-0.0166881084,
-0.0106665809,
0.0554182045,
-0.0325382575,
-0.0166823715,
0.1011311486,
-0.0331620984,
0.0398535393,
0.0502246358,
-0.0006190442,
-0.0311032534,
0.0237436909,
0.0208627395,
-0.0221705921,
-0.0036195796,
-0.033435341,
-0.0358960815,
0.0409661047,
-0.0279743671,
0.0334967449,
-0.0731779188,
0.0430936888,
0.0152664976,
-0.0572132468,
-0.0295830723,
-0.0529039167,
0.024947051,
0.0381121524,
-0.0614190139,
-0.0803793371,
0.061992012,
-0.0141083598,
-0.0133701321,
0.0408962518,
0.0121846246,
0.0042897877,
0.1135741621,
0.0409870371,
0.0194137581,
-0.0260739047,
0.0293145515,
-0.0563250259,
-0.0378381014,
0.0238866974,
-0.0285313725,
0.0752444789,
-0.1122255251,
0.0039255824,
-0.0221654996,
-0.0172644351,
-0.0502116531,
0.0170866325,
-0.0251404587,
0.0129725514,
-0.0409074835,
-0.0235478431,
-0.0118265999,
0.0161052179,
0.0413357355,
0.0277967975,
0.0261365995,
-0.0093162376,
-0.0385870002,
-0.0002374019,
0.0421941876,
0.0334193744,
-0.005054371,
-0.0282189287,
-0.004914002,
0.0636685118,
0.0215818435,
-0.0316710845,
-0.0622941852,
0.0277769119,
0.0131377829,
0.029779207,
-0.0009015304,
0.0461214148,
0.0707988068,
-0.0915309712,
-0.0221254621,
0.0653443784,
0.0421016254,
-0.0008839081,
-0.0106544998,
0.0473353602,
0.0018709253,
0.0604329482,
0.0384186171,
-0.0822362602,
-0.0443961509,
-0.0034208382,
0.00039349,
0.0333674215,
-0.0070209512,
-0.0217440836,
-0.1148799062,
0.0656371117,
0.0157337226,
-0.0154537084,
-0.0339090712,
-0.0096680867,
-0.0019744609,
-0.0167837404,
-0.040844474,
0.0121860439,
-0.0028984477,
0.0243077204,
-0.0050043622,
0.0150448298,
0.0046203639,
0.0379583612,
-0.021034183,
0.0113931727,
0.0639770702,
-0.0078584533,
0.0144041991,
-0.0714608729,
0.0256724358,
0.009241635,
0.0038948138,
0.0080339368,
0.0693669841,
0.0121792164,
-0.0436534509,
0.0246260166,
0.0044753593,
-0.0226608217,
-0.0411155447,
-0.0181352012,
0.043081522,
0.006447339,
0.0015807176,
-0.0107914694,
-0.0240710434,
-0.0417150818,
0.0490938574,
0.0293822102,
0.0009705748,
-0.0532057881,
-0.0405457094,
-0.0297608897,
-0.0811031833,
-0.0546638183,
-0.0054004388,
0.0159799941,
-0.0387727804,
-0.0527978875,
0.0107102124,
0.0431743488,
0.0747591257,
-0.0254580323,
-0.0654499531,
0.0398898087,
0.0160260089,
-0.088674508,
0.0533567108,
-0.0413119346,
0.037068557,
-0.0261049177,
-0.0161960386,
-0.0321831293,
-0.0189874712,
-0.0217868742,
0.0085144574,
-0.0792285874,
-0.0432038121,
-0.0189486984,
0.125952512,
0.0237002801,
0.0407163538,
-0.0051037776,
-0.0283229165,
-0.0280714203,
0.02497462,
0.0360199288,
0.0265893191,
0.0088066813,
-0.0545369163,
0.0063305441,
0.018699808,
-0.0241740569,
0.0184200257,
0.0557588898,
-0.0043909959,
-0.0259305015,
0.0018644378,
0.0250627138,
0.0169742294,
0.0357165709,
0.0007475145,
0.0099540083,
0.0032363341,
-0.0094322795,
0.0029135111,
-0.0100808525,
-0.0720193386,
0.0118355714,
0.0002702661,
0.0183165669,
0.0214737747,
-0.0216361154,
0.0200585537,
-0.0068688854,
-0.0501676537,
0.0041179736,
0.0410568863,
0.0051993649,
0.002461442,
0.0080219936,
0.0230574142,
0.0533470884,
0.0024252415,
0.0504359081,
-0.0077473782,
0.0362351499,
0.0298664179,
0.0200999565,
-0.0359637402,
0.0136721237,
-0.0394978896,
-0.0923674926,
-0.006939908,
0.0638038889,
0.0723809674,
0.012110142,
-0.0072086812,
-0.0078362403,
-0.0233746655,
-0.025153948,
0.0060742591,
0.0278206971,
-0.0208179988,
0.0191147439,
0.0657524541,
0.0043407585,
-0.0635808632,
0.0652040318,
-0.0268871766,
0.0211514644,
-0.0133708296,
-0.0126493918,
-0.0241252556,
-0.0407300107,
-0.0067508658,
0.0011098391,
-0.0011263667,
0.0209416896,
-0.0289451685,
-0.0968831927,
-0.0475046486,
0.0615102649,
0.0241232533,
0.0100540062,
0.0446269847,
0.0434539057,
0.0249597803,
-0.0074588466,
-0.0076930621,
-0.0187178254,
-0.0016416193,
-0.0061216448,
0.0351696312,
-6.301247018e-33,
-0.0478882343,
-0.0269730669,
0.0488449559,
-0.0315218158,
0.0145095484,
-0.007179623,
-0.0447867624,
-0.0039437138,
-0.0253100116,
0.0137160942,
0.034458667,
0.0194452051,
-0.0042702239,
0.0092107812,
0.0266523361,
0.0049213166,
0.0381183997,
0.0170589965,
-0.0490847901,
0.0010099506,
0.0439447351,
-0.025630692,
-0.025124928,
-0.0686073005,
-0.0547541231,
0.0242531579,
-0.0048641344,
0.0340518393,
-0.0174931716,
0.0700120181,
0.0051799095,
0.0013794806,
0.0079621319,
-0.0146372812,
-0.0228801053,
0.0196658671,
-0.0814763531,
-0.027842395,
0.0441264622,
0.0319593027,
-0.071606867,
0.0068610166,
0.0488367304,
0.0001146422,
-0.0013764317,
-0.0235330462,
0.035067603,
-0.0358079039,
0.0126072643,
0.0220065545,
-0.0358488597,
-0.0121745076,
-0.0042653023,
-0.0833919197,
0.0531002395,
-0.0155666368,
0.008001118,
0.0592878684,
-0.0405322425,
0.0133851841,
0.0315215886,
0.0222392753,
0.0960683152,
0.0524115004,
0.0026492691,
0.0386558883,
0.036497701,
-0.029248219,
-0.0268907603,
-0.0059755086,
0.0037635225,
0.0821010768,
0.0564668551,
0.0026030403,
0.0352960192,
0.0104442276,
-0.0452625528,
-0.0161617901,
-0.0670660064,
0.0620397329,
-0.0192853846,
0.0399399064,
-0.0157876611,
-0.0004824068,
-0.0144145172,
-0.0179188717,
-0.0471694916,
0.0109657925,
0.0572694503,
0.0360064469,
-0.0237955153,
0.0119363721,
0.0172060188,
-0.0652438402,
0.010829105,
-0.0007132503,
-0.0189821757,
0.0474871695,
0.0159447826,
0.036108695,
-0.0384818055,
0.0098232562,
0.0643902719,
0.0035449744,
0.0168209467,
0.0280747581,
0.042473875,
0.0272135958,
-0.0446015,
0.0109194675,
-0.0664438158,
0.0195987299,
0.0161366388,
0.0600520484,
0.0097779557,
0.0282647535,
-0.0417006128,
-0.011337026,
-0.0209103543,
-0.0682140067,
-0.0356756635,
-0.0145253064,
-0.0264044218,
0.0048418725,
-0.0130661707,
-0.0098740058,
-0.0314275436,
0.0148996664,
-0.0218040887,
-0.0422713421,
-0.0140074389,
0.0341994986,
2.96e-7,
0.0097361933,
0.0162592195,
0.0285680983,
0.0267455168,
0.027227141,
0.0367769524,
-0.0444286801,
-0.0023660506,
0.0123314019,
-0.0700955763,
0.0053092628,
0.1009879783,
0.0448740087,
0.0197215267,
0.0000624284,
0.0454242676,
-0.0145551031,
-0.0288631767,
-0.0517961346,
0.0000410593,
0.047857482,
0.0582361333,
0.0219205972,
-0.0198802818,
0.0524425767,
-0.0420192331,
0.040137019,
0.0119561721,
0.0133517357,
-0.0254390631,
-0.0412658602,
0.0251347702,
-0.0271505695,
0.0234314781,
-0.0197439305,
-0.026675459,
0.0152961221,
0.0841972083,
-0.0341884382,
0.0038241989,
-0.0268070493,
-0.0005139371,
0.0022094473,
-0.029715443,
0.0798483863,
-0.0391764194,
0.0321426652,
-0.0237431377,
-0.0353855938,
0.0097461343,
0.0099706808,
0.0156722758,
-0.0139642339,
-0.0030105149,
0.0212373957,
-0.0139264883,
-0.0184379853,
-0.0647119433,
-0.0205735359,
-0.0063801999,
-0.0156730227,
-0.0332849771,
-0.0636539981,
-0.014508957,
0.022610018,
0.001513126,
-0.0566487163,
2.583350644e-34,
0.034536887,
-0.0072077811,
0.0020139609,
-0.0422065184,
0.0188807435,
0.0022407193,
-0.0734703913,
-0.0126883853,
0.0100162756,
-0.0165681541,
-0.0296593588
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.02969v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.02969v1 | Rank-without-GPT: Building GPT-Independent Listwise Rerankers on Open-Source Large Language Models | 2023-12-05T18:57:40 | 2023-12-05T18:57:40 | Xinyu Zhang, Sebastian Hofstätter, Patrick Lewis, Raphael Tang, Jimmy Lin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Listwise rerankers based on large language models (LLM) are the zero-shot
state-of-the-art. However, current works in this direction all depend on the
GPT models, making it a single point of failure in scientific reproducibility.
Moreover, it raises the concern that the current research findings only hold
for GPT models but not LLM in general. In this work, we lift this pre-condition
and build for the first time effective listwise rerankers without any form of
dependency on GPT. Our passage retrieval experiments show that our best list se
reranker surpasses the listwise rerankers based on GPT-3.5 by 13% and achieves
97% effectiveness of the ones built on GPT-4. Our results also show that the
existing training datasets, which were expressly constructed for pointwise
ranking, are insufficient for building such listwise rerankers. Instead,
high-quality listwise ranking data is required and crucial, calling for further
work on building human-annotated listwise data resources. | [
0.0277348179,
0.044729948,
0.0003610222,
0.0679146871,
-0.0021306691,
0.0096785277,
-0.0014217665,
0.011362236,
0.08031708,
-0.0684272498,
-0.0236094594,
-0.0204970334,
-0.0173821729,
-0.0031032106,
0.0201163776,
-0.0363805927,
0.0124162342,
-0.013408415,
0.0233131927,
-0.0092150029,
0.0025475661,
-0.0022959944,
0.0280229934,
-0.0025031597,
0.1072321311,
-0.0024916609,
0.0205566213,
-0.0148687931,
0.044525858,
-0.0244330019,
0.0099777868,
0.0317602865,
0.0345016792,
0.0572431423,
0.0000018308,
-0.0263147857,
-0.0674279556,
0.0101559414,
0.0136579927,
0.0470110364,
0.000722907,
0.0054027038,
-0.0051887915,
0.015706785,
-0.0279408284,
-0.0047514518,
0.0035398677,
0.0154770063,
0.0505864136,
0.0594787374,
-0.0007176616,
-0.0598166026,
0.0292856991,
-0.0544891208,
0.021906089,
-0.0589294732,
0.0378194079,
-0.0257501025,
0.0087321047,
0.0510143191,
-0.0122869499,
0.0112561565,
-0.0112645701,
0.0024672952,
0.04047947,
0.0349040218,
-0.1020610109,
0.0500511378,
0.0093508903,
0.0868766382,
-0.055487942,
-0.0286920834,
0.0206450615,
0.0048384727,
-0.009503372,
0.0265607387,
-0.052900508,
0.0142997531,
-0.018054558,
0.0225969236,
0.0186631605,
0.0058225808,
0.0454526655,
0.0186623745,
-0.0608543046,
0.0785336643,
0.059089344,
-0.0456418954,
0.0120397443,
0.0002894519,
-0.0659422427,
-0.012111865,
-0.0009583342,
-0.0243377388,
-0.0105585977,
0.0255054478,
0.0144238705,
-0.0021656323,
0.0053811641,
-0.02975237,
0.0006354057,
0.0022669982,
0.0202095062,
0.0148796272,
-0.033205986,
0.0748394951,
-0.0005028193,
0.0310833063,
-0.0394891202,
-0.0057363692,
-0.0088025564,
-0.0394249111,
-0.0038030022,
0.0394335501,
-0.0109334104,
0.0100387838,
-0.053356275,
-0.0187974684,
-0.0084018279,
0.0023152896,
-0.0170100313,
-0.0449560434,
-0.0185922123,
-0.0094735697,
-0.0079764081,
0.0162932035,
0.0297957938,
-0.0139172897,
-0.0270959772,
0.0062900013,
0.0049367175,
-0.0120502943,
-0.0166621376,
-0.0329769887,
0.0149377119,
0.0236979965,
-0.0144182472,
-0.0498235784,
0.0122113554,
0.0008406909,
-0.0169794597,
-0.0314548053,
-0.0312487315,
-0.0739511624,
0.0118217776,
0.0315517969,
0.0314399488,
-0.0101819662,
0.0245419648,
0.0533502363,
-0.0606088638,
0.0436347835,
0.0311001129,
-0.0140041513,
0.0038371729,
0.0309305936,
0.037980713,
-0.0020657473,
0.0130292978,
0.0341062844,
0.0651287511,
-0.0138008846,
0.0029184239,
0.0389063209,
-0.0055141998,
0.0117065795,
-0.0064040609,
0.0154876476,
0.0165469367,
0.0048364932,
0.0013299109,
0.0486863106,
-0.0562900268,
-0.0283288565,
0.0510503724,
0.0440891758,
0.0513065271,
0.0318372436,
-0.0044252286,
0.0042359801,
0.0021793311,
0.0342041068,
-0.0160681661,
-0.0073283114,
-0.0128708938,
0.0230263136,
0.0705878586,
0.0387733951,
-0.0007141445,
-0.0234527364,
-0.0133497342,
0.0227688029,
-0.0369025543,
0.0041588158,
0.0626730919,
-0.0169706643,
-0.0414376743,
0.0217019636,
0.0350548215,
-0.0804049298,
-0.0050572306,
-0.0161008276,
-0.0070114592,
0.0768061504,
0.0773450211,
-0.0539838262,
-0.0044074301,
0.009705714,
0.0000331186,
0.011617424,
-0.000526878,
-0.0251986105,
-0.0019131216,
-0.0503927544,
-0.0047211186,
0.0209001247,
0.0171135496,
0.0633912235,
0.012931752,
-0.0004777407,
0.0278354008,
-0.0544141605,
-0.0315064788,
0.0181257185,
0.0050457357,
0.0086525688,
0.0243137721,
-0.0401346236,
0.0244088601,
0.0242049843,
-0.0178827252,
0.0080913827,
0.0311973076,
-0.0456288904,
-0.0122810258,
-0.0388368368,
-0.0156440455,
-0.0215999112,
0.042209208,
-0.0308827143,
0.0214794744,
0.1015993804,
-0.0402693413,
-0.0279710181,
-0.0317906588,
-0.011397738,
0.0156796407,
-0.0189704467,
0.0299865268,
0.0062724855,
-0.0171918608,
-0.0628393814,
0.0765801296,
0.019060187,
0.07884489,
0.0505316891,
0.0023045191,
0.0052136886,
-0.0490295365,
-0.0744244009,
0.0786507502,
0.0027431687,
-0.0072911973,
0.0501846373,
0.0116385706,
-0.0414047278,
-0.037713103,
-0.1190140396,
0.0287952516,
-0.016948469,
0.0082704891,
0.0181644727,
0.0083772661,
0.001234396,
0.0037733633,
-0.0346311145,
-0.036674004,
0.0144465677,
0.0047935024,
0.0244083647,
-0.0263202004,
-0.0101359822,
-0.03867184,
-0.0498499237,
-0.0065432852,
0.0493657365,
-0.030119393,
-0.0051149218,
-0.0367222019,
0.037858218,
-0.0534986667,
0.0154975029,
-0.0328488238,
-0.017820647,
-0.0024808547,
-0.0038546606,
0.0511690676,
0.0236862898,
0.0385338627,
-0.0075423676,
0.0512349494,
-0.0357470028,
-0.0409933627,
0.0027403454,
0.0020561665,
-0.0264876261,
-0.0173054654,
0.0017466053,
0.002456414,
0.0051417332,
-0.0107509308,
-0.0269586071,
-0.0352416858,
0.0171897169,
-0.0443397798,
0.0141228549,
-0.0764582083,
0.0176069234,
-0.0279512256,
-0.0144415367,
0.0036781323,
-0.0557447001,
0.017973898,
-0.0383864194,
-0.0049360618,
-0.0732563138,
0.0003776083,
-0.0668929964,
0.0433350429,
0.0340882987,
0.0131970989,
-0.0406897292,
-0.0086211851,
-0.0299157705,
0.0338563547,
0.0279817563,
-0.0690067783,
0.0595925711,
-0.0463810526,
0.0352065414,
-0.0317635871,
-0.043261528,
-0.0208774358,
-0.0526316054,
0.018162908,
-0.010668084,
0.0065374374,
-0.0393548943,
0.0149673158,
0.0147968475,
0.0352645405,
0.0688170716,
-0.0224948209,
-0.0116690695,
0.0036893014,
0.0655288026,
0.0638984665,
-0.0471546315,
0.0014002216,
0.0001511034,
0.037199337,
0.0502566397,
0.0609991662,
-0.0345799886,
0.028248312,
0.0017749525,
0.0501369163,
-0.0744881332,
-0.0318958052,
0.0065256678,
0.0136213219,
-0.0223059077,
-0.010362477,
0.1079013124,
0.0380975567,
-0.0799323097,
-0.0357293263,
0.0180130582,
0.0373074822,
-0.0032254562,
0.0126569569,
-0.072028093,
0.0135488585,
0.008557912,
0.0244220644,
-0.0307416376,
-0.0374571048,
-0.0109144831,
-0.1268218756,
0.0629046634,
0.0222372562,
-0.0268330052,
-0.0094462875,
-0.0375009514,
-0.0110127833,
-0.0247320198,
-0.0303711481,
0.0485323519,
-0.0327544808,
0.0330994874,
-0.0113660768,
-0.0331632607,
-0.0228641629,
0.0320720039,
-0.036918465,
0.0180068873,
0.0288243573,
0.0561545752,
-0.0486419946,
-0.0198867843,
0.0021062926,
-0.0774784833,
-0.0530768186,
0.0029506742,
0.0164190754,
-0.0119372932,
0.0093845781,
-0.0305794887,
0.0429982655,
-0.0084715039,
0.0073471395,
0.0203596819,
0.0508278981,
0.0080167139,
-0.0013529339,
-0.0032901727,
-0.0252069309,
-0.031287726,
0.0510258786,
-0.039871797,
0.0014173447,
-0.0209323894,
-0.052576337,
0.0318891965,
0.0021400552,
-0.0685426965,
-0.0005033721,
-0.0160949714,
0.0213092156,
-0.0650641099,
-0.0294441003,
0.0002427778,
0.0079383794,
-0.0232648123,
0.090927735,
-0.0556853786,
-0.0139037455,
-0.0346866176,
-0.0295964368,
-0.0297809746,
0.0191376656,
-0.0279056318,
0.0010338695,
0.0395753048,
0.00424862,
-0.0296994988,
0.0119929435,
-0.0271164458,
-0.0589789227,
-0.0184297934,
0.0424463898,
0.0269465558,
-0.0145347519,
-0.0042217076,
-0.0306156129,
0.0679495111,
0.0152792362,
-0.0054810159,
0.020346446,
0.0135761499,
0.022818679,
-0.0192283783,
0.0304232016,
-0.0514317155,
-0.0098417234,
-0.0185635015,
0.0367505215,
0.0129089095,
-0.0320499763,
0.0281578675,
0.0608110204,
0.0470821969,
-0.0019523713,
-0.0063304114,
-0.0540026948,
0.0398538783,
-0.0772379413,
-0.0109430524,
-0.012891951,
0.0438534394,
0.0679445043,
0.0104218572,
-0.0471136309,
0.0003534803,
0.0116035715,
0.0198233929,
-0.0943615362,
0.0029800537,
-0.008109252,
-0.0496773385,
0.0194697324,
-0.0119041521,
-0.0349733122,
-0.0302198641,
0.0246720016,
0.0617451854,
-0.0228830539,
0.0326699428,
0.0224610679,
-0.0580737554,
0.0017188715,
0.0768362656,
-0.1039871052,
-0.0211591776,
-0.0562929399,
0.0095193265,
0.054919593,
0.0185281225,
0.101646021,
-0.0067957337,
-0.0208896436,
-0.0297392029,
-0.0114197871,
0.0393842123,
0.0019520409,
-0.0124836285,
0.0428585634,
-0.0197087824,
0.050263714,
0.1041670963,
0.0636794716,
-0.0186294522,
0.0335642397,
-0.0582855083,
-0.0202607848,
-0.0321775377,
-0.0124561265,
0.0414995737,
-0.0042166021,
-0.0366560519,
-0.0462391563,
-0.0124294842,
0.0376376249,
-0.0159427412,
0.0182035957,
-0.0477692336,
-0.0159327053,
0.0607991628,
-0.0274185278,
0.0119819222,
-0.070882678,
-0.0071773711,
-0.0261548888,
-0.0582410842,
-0.0210083965,
-5.629992724e-33,
-0.0214627255,
-0.0193992052,
-0.0196080748,
-0.0144446734,
-0.045518361,
0.0142706074,
0.0142299104,
-0.0125910686,
0.0132935056,
-0.0026376122,
-0.0201381166,
0.0241759624,
0.0173475724,
0.0091737565,
0.0093949204,
0.0134659195,
0.0051034167,
0.0247924924,
-0.0343985409,
0.0200831983,
0.0371092968,
0.0384838656,
0.0322327577,
-0.0186720435,
0.0169387273,
-0.0586013459,
0.0139248818,
-0.0137361418,
-0.0063952361,
0.0324337222,
0.005051916,
0.0286446661,
0.0446830653,
-0.0707402304,
0.0265028197,
-0.0010358684,
-0.0230121836,
-0.0099936668,
0.0058080642,
-0.054764431,
0.0093580261,
0.0125225512,
0.0177152008,
-0.0018185849,
0.0097451378,
-0.0388237163,
0.0457193144,
-0.0151097607,
-0.0317269489,
-0.0285769664,
-0.0085013937,
0.0506436378,
-0.0114582768,
0.0257558282,
0.0207475573,
0.0437711291,
-0.0002840779,
0.0584148876,
-0.0228974167,
0.0208605081,
0.0128609473,
0.0732551143,
0.0152907232,
-0.0256974269,
-0.0124151241,
0.0517076999,
0.0015812528,
-0.0091309696,
0.0274331942,
-0.0205552354,
-0.0206030868,
0.0025611515,
0.0401057974,
0.0574038886,
0.0183156785,
0.020254327,
-0.0939948484,
0.0610327423,
0.0187303815,
0.001777755,
0.0164142027,
0.0450263172,
-0.0208362658,
-0.0321246162,
-0.0091245901,
-0.024478104,
-0.0153005999,
-0.0287679173,
0.0427930504,
-0.0074300724,
-0.0462470278,
-0.005320977,
0.0263316594,
-0.0183632504,
-0.0438552089,
0.0423745625,
-0.0130009511,
0.0236090068,
-0.0149126556,
0.0349216908,
-0.0326267928,
0.0091199065,
-0.0066962447,
-0.0137864286,
-0.0213538222,
-0.03016009,
0.0046330537,
0.0030141294,
-0.0551555194,
0.0037435291,
-0.0037707821,
-0.0273666345,
-0.0370529629,
0.0846680477,
-0.0178716071,
-0.0121347457,
0.0186866634,
0.0786953941,
0.0467405766,
0.0212263707,
-0.0385602526,
0.0113440258,
0.0246851314,
-0.0477224067,
0.0155605618,
0.0329134837,
0.0205358043,
0.0720315203,
0.0158165321,
-0.0227186363,
-0.0042781169,
-0.0224533901,
2.584e-7,
0.0246316195,
0.0175982695,
0.0133320214,
0.0030377242,
0.0185862016,
0.0125034088,
-0.0086851241,
0.0697941184,
0.0183251742,
0.0143896891,
0.0286882836,
-0.0288682785,
0.0220664274,
0.0220009498,
-0.0857416242,
-0.0134003172,
-0.0600329824,
-0.07385353,
-0.0443167202,
-0.0663918182,
0.0398859382,
0.0741874501,
-0.0126028033,
0.0189105012,
-0.0316143148,
-0.0298604276,
0.0615073256,
-0.0475289933,
-0.0415982939,
0.0115869688,
0.0876085609,
0.0126745803,
-0.0201487616,
-0.001286446,
-0.0177673399,
0.0415287763,
0.0784201249,
0.0469100438,
-0.0024377969,
-0.0115617756,
0.0057794903,
-0.0049461075,
0.0061347326,
-0.0877636969,
0.0611483604,
-0.0308961403,
-0.0177530628,
0.0155542837,
-0.0645375028,
-0.0352446847,
0.0189539436,
-0.004366809,
-0.0163777731,
0.04496729,
-0.0100601623,
0.0080889137,
0.0066562239,
-0.0821208358,
-0.0227153972,
-0.0072530685,
-0.0406044759,
-0.0408937037,
-0.0238668863,
-0.0224855766,
-0.0189613234,
-0.0485311486,
0.0183719397,
2.338778713e-34,
0.0353832059,
-0.0095962416,
0.0034975535,
0.0009354594,
0.0423437878,
-0.0123916669,
-0.0017720484,
0.0274530184,
-0.016231373,
-0.1077960581,
-0.0114909681
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.14943v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.14943v1 | Flood Event Extraction from News Media to Support Satellite-Based Flood Insurance | 2023-12-05T18:39:42 | 2023-12-05T18:39:42 | Tejit Pabari, Beth Tellman, Giannis Karamanolakis, Mitchell Thomas, Max Mauerman, Eugene Wu, Upmanu Lall, Marco Tedesco, Michael S Steckler, Paolo Colosio, Daniel E Osgood, Melody Braun, Jens de Bruijn, Shammun Islam | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL, cs.LG | Floods cause large losses to property, life, and livelihoods across the world
every year, hindering sustainable development. Safety nets to help absorb
financial shocks in disasters, such as insurance, are often unavailable in
regions of the world most vulnerable to floods, like Bangladesh. Index-based
insurance has emerged as an affordable solution, which considers weather data
or information from satellites to create a "flood index" that should correlate
with the damage insured. However, existing flood event databases are often
incomplete, and satellite sensors are not reliable under extreme weather
conditions (e.g., because of clouds), which limits the spatial and temporal
resolution of current approaches for index-based insurance.
In this work, we explore a novel approach for supporting satellite-based
flood index insurance by extracting high-resolution spatio-temporal information
from news media. First, we publish a dataset consisting of 40,000 news articles
covering flood events in Bangladesh by 10 prominent news sources, and inundated
area estimates for each division in Bangladesh collected from a satellite radar
sensor. Second, we show that keyword-based models are not adequate for this
novel application, while context-based classifiers cover complex and implicit
flood related patterns. Third, we show that time series extracted from news
media have substantial correlation Spearman's rho$=0.70 with satellite
estimates of inundated area. Our work demonstrates that news media is a
promising source for improving the temporal resolution and expanding the
spatial coverage of the available flood damage data. | [
-0.0109336944,
0.0813684389,
-0.0313410014,
-0.0185149852,
-0.0316013135,
0.032630045,
0.0310983993,
-0.0330362432,
0.0421536714,
0.0012159388,
0.0587853566,
-0.0290382598,
-0.007257238,
0.0716337934,
-0.0027426595,
-0.0816489309,
0.058627326,
-0.0178351011,
0.0641373843,
0.0003781445,
0.0085404012,
-0.0350220799,
-0.0190771539,
-0.0174198914,
-0.0016256233,
0.0431132875,
-0.0381457172,
-0.0372354724,
0.0323069841,
-0.0658129305,
0.0220888983,
0.0076792343,
0.0329975076,
-0.0226831604,
0.0000015921,
-0.000258571,
-0.0326323621,
-0.0304169506,
0.0574206673,
0.0243081711,
0.0005103979,
-0.0457784794,
-0.0115589816,
-0.0147220986,
-0.0385221876,
-0.0015641969,
0.0363827161,
0.0384963527,
0.0332847014,
0.0666586682,
-0.0213905219,
-0.0378748477,
0.0511751287,
0.024379883,
0.0543183461,
-0.007034482,
0.0055873813,
0.0215325505,
0.0085808095,
-0.0153141823,
0.0016338254,
0.0726120174,
0.0118032638,
0.0595051982,
-0.0151340552,
0.0409266129,
-0.0112785315,
0.000842814,
-0.0452245101,
-0.0167677216,
0.0076796031,
0.0178065225,
0.0585008897,
-0.0077812742,
-0.0008066188,
0.057601396,
-0.0456565842,
-0.0169620253,
0.0137922633,
0.0271745864,
0.0065732943,
0.0235086512,
-0.0293859132,
0.0734898746,
-0.015745258,
0.0468176603,
-0.0050047189,
-0.0313123427,
-0.0748485401,
-0.0364014544,
0.0094880397,
-0.0088416757,
0.025103068,
-0.0066740932,
-0.006823109,
0.009758072,
-0.0288695209,
0.015106759,
0.0134303579,
-0.1123378426,
-0.0339012593,
-0.0095494529,
0.000973014,
0.0629724413,
0.0413543321,
0.0184017643,
0.0020373794,
0.0099117504,
0.0398358963,
-0.0235043801,
-0.0641694069,
-0.0311002526,
0.070725508,
0.0604515374,
0.0251470022,
0.0223053489,
-0.0406972244,
0.0390485749,
0.0001714234,
-0.0507218838,
-0.052734971,
0.0202112626,
-0.0022811738,
-0.016831791,
-0.0219042953,
-0.0464619994,
-0.0183553975,
0.035341423,
0.0043145232,
-0.0386091545,
0.032628376,
-0.0095799314,
0.058076106,
0.0019585567,
-0.0150116505,
-0.0438378714,
0.0345022753,
-0.0396080613,
-0.0441363119,
0.0217112843,
0.0000908102,
0.042041339,
-0.0353819951,
-0.0412476845,
-0.0325126834,
-0.0050686798,
-0.0514876656,
0.0268734228,
0.0204540566,
-0.0075359796,
-0.0467358716,
0.0268437695,
-0.0067089731,
0.0132001229,
0.0355598554,
-0.0133520495,
0.0475893319,
0.0623894557,
0.0387112089,
0.0508536287,
0.0476250276,
-0.0056743021,
0.0301644392,
-0.0140952226,
-0.0157908276,
0.0447641686,
-0.0409298949,
-0.0085368631,
-0.0278833993,
-0.0266933963,
0.0150263133,
-0.0780802444,
0.0218763854,
0.0214555655,
0.0808872879,
0.00569356,
-0.0224448089,
0.0151453698,
-0.0146317137,
0.0675448105,
-0.0332671776,
-0.0308395363,
0.0133761913,
0.0011530187,
-0.0697022304,
0.0162825007,
0.0168266073,
-0.0111443261,
-0.0318385884,
-0.0006188884,
0.0048027751,
0.0251701195,
-0.0114868842,
-0.0264280979,
0.0366815142,
-0.0501662791,
0.0453558005,
0.0237969924,
0.0240143482,
0.0513563342,
0.0190236531,
-0.0253453497,
-0.0112740956,
0.0201265141,
0.0022816444,
-0.0340585597,
0.0179811697,
0.0286261756,
0.0251139607,
-0.0289963353,
0.0006061881,
0.0397766642,
-0.0201933496,
0.0009142492,
-0.0307395831,
0.0600536503,
0.0376804657,
-0.0071113706,
0.0326450989,
0.086869508,
-0.0150602944,
-0.0043318169,
-0.0435133129,
0.0190307871,
0.04269154,
-0.0182764102,
-0.0027933549,
0.0286497641,
0.0114417179,
-0.0476376712,
0.0200531688,
-0.0028444133,
0.043836534,
-0.0085556069,
-0.0800180361,
0.0393176302,
0.0112500852,
0.024220312,
-0.0283112153,
0.0065533794,
0.0303502046,
0.0434309579,
-0.0277136397,
-0.0346221216,
0.0502947494,
0.0379479639,
-0.0067909742,
-0.0694929138,
-0.0039986372,
0.0114519335,
0.0177795384,
-0.0340896249,
0.0878797397,
-0.0262007527,
0.0137133319,
-0.0963579416,
-0.0330560617,
-0.000550212,
-0.0112629738,
0.0444376506,
-0.0270020422,
-0.040621832,
0.0001673729,
-0.0012313158,
-0.0155984778,
-0.0270976909,
-0.0041822558,
-0.0071018729,
0.0116269179,
-0.0053438237,
0.0113600753,
-0.010016432,
-0.0050873915,
-0.0292768627,
0.0092477147,
-0.0032268502,
-0.0199089795,
-0.003323426,
0.0140630882,
0.0415144227,
-0.0377292298,
-0.0058508115,
-0.0108761853,
-0.0159635842,
-0.0177166611,
0.056832619,
0.0630219877,
-0.1322924346,
0.0208023265,
-0.0381328166,
-0.0168195311,
-0.024084365,
-0.0110953255,
-0.0200215783,
-0.0273777656,
-0.0364087969,
-0.0826600417,
-0.0199519824,
0.05981455,
0.038991373,
-0.0393777266,
-0.0385805592,
-0.0308022704,
0.0421708897,
-0.0780665874,
-0.021517396,
0.017937934,
-0.0143679231,
-0.0110135507,
-0.0050333203,
-0.0044516008,
0.0298726764,
0.0305683147,
-0.0188080166,
0.0006773411,
-0.0043435907,
-0.0607032999,
0.0203631297,
-0.0094621656,
0.0575393215,
-0.0057499483,
-0.0551863648,
0.0006301107,
0.0583670922,
0.0595484264,
-0.0154559892,
-0.0374084637,
-0.0645768866,
0.0129976366,
-0.0424607098,
-0.0044822521,
-0.0121068172,
-0.0014195117,
0.0091984319,
-0.0303346179,
0.0213165581,
-0.0003175064,
-0.060678035,
-0.0616101846,
0.0298799742,
0.0254494399,
0.003885028,
-0.0331547484,
-0.0847957134,
0.0216458384,
-0.0104904417,
-0.0168518089,
-0.014048879,
-0.0415230766,
0.0649522915,
0.020225374,
0.0121356836,
-0.0099592041,
-0.0166122746,
0.0246544834,
0.0567082055,
0.0232723914,
-0.0163974538,
0.010084914,
0.013626093,
-0.0186909493,
-0.0331410468,
0.0450653546,
0.040965382,
-0.0161328129,
0.0467240997,
-0.0043039825,
-0.0395285003,
0.0142788924,
-0.0093860552,
-0.0131468475,
-0.0328800827,
0.0215958524,
0.0468424857,
0.0286278948,
0.0095991623,
0.0093672965,
-0.0223375224,
-0.0020973454,
-0.0043629655,
-0.0381561443,
-0.0193400718,
0.0199630857,
-0.0140347285,
-0.0668542758,
-0.0012865161,
-0.0585971549,
-0.0050058044,
-0.0150545305,
0.0667614713,
0.0145120062,
-0.021773139,
-0.0281423368,
-0.0771343186,
0.022122385,
-0.0136716468,
-0.0689462721,
-0.0380803198,
0.0022514805,
0.0047801286,
0.0325847901,
-0.0523607396,
-0.0471422635,
-0.00731157,
-0.0319147855,
-0.0314867869,
-0.0025453814,
0.0198234264,
-0.0528041087,
0.0115046389,
-0.0097518666,
0.0074668867,
0.0231758915,
0.019851137,
0.0324008577,
0.0128852874,
-0.02518785,
-0.0150297713,
0.0226355437,
-0.0230442341,
-0.0010998418,
0.0512778647,
0.0511394553,
-0.0456572138,
0.026958704,
-0.0019971249,
-0.0020407578,
0.0751945376,
-0.0166524854,
-0.0236836057,
0.0030010801,
-0.0330356136,
0.0062349178,
-0.0333015397,
0.0098181227,
-0.0415471345,
0.0152693307,
-0.0314719304,
-0.0946970955,
-0.0324718915,
-0.0276752822,
-0.018387055,
0.0292543042,
-0.0486517102,
-0.0063350806,
0.0838562474,
-0.0699964389,
-0.0618183054,
-0.0001061715,
-0.0148746297,
0.0092014838,
0.0141623737,
0.0159412492,
-0.0048470325,
-0.013437042,
-0.0680062324,
0.0348724164,
-0.0453878082,
-0.0244296845,
0.0648729354,
-0.0215962213,
0.0143648963,
-0.0343530849,
-0.0331362411,
0.0321634673,
0.0906694829,
0.0694807246,
-0.0032644717,
-0.0516138338,
0.0146816671,
-0.0167727266,
0.0047299098,
-0.0024812839,
-0.0024633056,
0.0514661521,
-0.0201802272,
-0.0118815973,
-0.0472738184,
0.0231322311,
-0.0141974883,
-0.0067118602,
0.0998771042,
0.0269302931,
-0.0783100501,
-0.0102454945,
0.0041506719,
-0.002831297,
-0.0085648997,
0.0197464302,
0.048194699,
-0.0049730241,
0.020038221,
-0.0516710281,
0.0484493151,
0.0195455831,
-0.0803790912,
-0.0349316411,
-0.0093943235,
-0.0057970555,
0.0085397391,
-0.0476955585,
0.025964465,
0.0340974629,
-0.0223253518,
0.0365980603,
-0.0049133026,
0.0100064678,
-0.0160305798,
0.0131036304,
0.0363795459,
-0.0151970591,
-0.0026550693,
-0.0606471039,
-0.010678255,
-0.0141502563,
0.0397108346,
0.0454323664,
0.0309844539,
-0.0272198468,
-0.0471213609,
-0.0029085192,
-0.0094268704,
0.0203299876,
0.0209453665,
-0.0549707487,
0.0019110364,
-0.0113353617,
-0.0646877587,
0.0988433212,
0.036804188,
0.0479271524,
-0.0020153085,
0.0154678468,
-0.0581612177,
0.0021302213,
-0.0035748926,
0.0093026515,
0.0190006625,
0.0050028181,
0.005083621,
-0.0651554018,
0.015479696,
0.0468914658,
-0.0501287021,
-0.0367727652,
-0.0060736574,
-0.0250275731,
0.027557198,
-0.02347547,
0.0728300512,
-0.024121955,
0.0317279808,
-0.114078708,
-0.0128540527,
-0.003082796,
-5.417421469e-33,
-0.0201677661,
-0.0283342358,
-0.0208445322,
-0.0296901874,
0.0054885703,
0.0902772024,
0.0012582309,
-0.0249584317,
0.0374987721,
-0.021280054,
-0.0111520337,
0.0076305657,
0.0401700586,
-0.0363232084,
0.106262818,
-0.0016900668,
-0.0333579928,
-0.0072568795,
0.0130692879,
-0.0201395564,
0.0276541002,
-0.0047940742,
0.0435594469,
-0.0624006949,
-0.0224020928,
0.0207823925,
-0.0306003857,
-0.056196671,
0.0324536636,
0.0314163491,
-0.0232385155,
0.021374194,
0.0152124772,
-0.0448437072,
-0.0128757805,
-0.0012777657,
-0.0572686195,
-0.026275659,
-0.0047216197,
-0.0168288369,
-0.0307650603,
0.0016653762,
-0.003754067,
0.0402032882,
0.0108500076,
-0.0066385176,
0.0263545532,
0.0079828622,
-0.0511330329,
-0.0420717411,
-0.0079984162,
0.0711239725,
-0.0575824343,
0.0383689478,
-0.0224114042,
-0.01659045,
0.0012642808,
0.0468259715,
-0.0063467077,
0.0039857556,
0.0161043033,
0.0408750847,
0.0126134446,
-0.0133787515,
0.0251713973,
0.0765474588,
0.0133071635,
-0.0618009865,
0.0156614967,
-0.0152548682,
0.0423519127,
0.006824214,
-0.0147040868,
0.1002021357,
0.0910503864,
-0.0543930344,
-0.0535854399,
0.0562028401,
-0.0107138474,
0.046032235,
-0.004980674,
-0.0043066959,
-0.0484895892,
0.0101653691,
0.0066884491,
-0.0356329121,
-0.0326719806,
0.0376025774,
0.0150309773,
0.0394414738,
0.0186223667,
0.1286304891,
-0.0307714473,
0.0512797683,
-0.0318025574,
0.0022624615,
0.0011295712,
0.030087525,
-0.0047496543,
0.0403718874,
-0.0030007144,
-0.0045079058,
-0.0068974849,
0.0307321809,
0.0109605165,
0.0083826175,
0.0284346696,
0.0455973707,
-0.0077213002,
0.0008571094,
0.0104001882,
-0.025274206,
-0.0465443842,
-0.0362037979,
0.0071349167,
-0.0278330836,
0.0000807795,
-0.029918503,
0.0157577749,
0.0108691165,
0.0525180027,
-0.0198308807,
-0.0597154014,
0.0160659757,
0.0361741036,
0.0116403457,
-0.0156091508,
-0.060766466,
-0.022955751,
-0.0088112578,
0.001586661,
0.0119802644,
2.482e-7,
-0.0040329248,
0.0822773129,
0.0205692705,
0.0312038455,
-0.0128598399,
0.0341077372,
0.0148179103,
0.0170284789,
-0.0110899555,
0.0298983324,
0.070148848,
0.0113142245,
0.0213906262,
0.0202994309,
-0.042369172,
0.017063139,
-0.0506323949,
0.0080317361,
-0.1031743586,
-0.0074309027,
0.0962552801,
0.0344110951,
0.0490394011,
-0.0089967977,
0.0365325473,
-0.0249526352,
0.007845154,
-0.0259896051,
-0.0529571548,
-0.0109294914,
-0.0084213726,
0.0424591675,
0.0177241061,
0.0332239754,
-0.0341981389,
-0.0170990061,
0.0383543037,
0.0209172331,
-0.025284756,
-0.0198994707,
-0.0240919981,
-0.0340862498,
-0.0220188014,
-0.0397785753,
0.0417406,
0.0153466491,
-0.0083470652,
-0.027173711,
-0.058347445,
0.0691882893,
0.0347871892,
0.0182068553,
-0.0343875401,
0.0011323384,
-0.0218566004,
-0.0205272809,
-0.0081834411,
-0.0002735425,
0.0625239983,
0.017232703,
-0.0052114003,
0.0426187925,
-0.027554201,
0.0686118081,
0.0476425961,
-0.0198257826,
0.0290570427,
1.78153883e-34,
-0.0056739454,
0.0310956556,
-0.0454556495,
-0.041763898,
0.0033053963,
0.0572417974,
-0.0477735735,
0.017559601,
0.0004865912,
-0.0386120453,
0.0327187479
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.02931v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.02931v2 | WhisBERT: Multimodal Text-Audio Language Modeling on 100M Words | 2023-12-05T18:03:13 | 2023-12-07T00:37:29 | Lukas Wolf, Greta Tuckute, Klemen Kotar, Eghbal Hosseini, Tamar Regev, Ethan Wilcox, Alex Warstadt | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Training on multiple modalities of input can augment the capabilities of a
language model. Here, we ask whether such a training regime can improve the
quality and efficiency of these systems as well. We focus on text--audio and
introduce Whisbert, which is inspired by the text--image approach of FLAVA
(Singh et al., 2022). In accordance with Babylm guidelines (Warstadt et al.,
2023), we pretrain Whisbert on a dataset comprising only 100 million words plus
their corresponding speech from the word-aligned version of the People's Speech
dataset (Galvez et al., 2021). To assess the impact of multimodality, we
compare versions of the model that are trained on text only and on both audio
and text simultaneously. We find that while Whisbert is able to perform well on
multimodal masked modeling and surpasses the Babylm baselines in most benchmark
tasks, it struggles to optimize its complex objective and outperform its
text-only Whisbert baseline. | [
-0.0164065473,
0.0903420001,
0.0062636863,
0.0493097864,
-0.0342592858,
-0.0219770726,
0.0462554619,
-0.0100973807,
-0.0333572812,
-0.0697142556,
-0.0753817558,
-0.0629744157,
0.0204314943,
0.0073593161,
0.0467736758,
-0.0756588429,
0.0238267761,
-0.0630035773,
-0.0221319385,
-0.0019607553,
0.029150391,
0.0230720583,
-0.0508553125,
0.0311541092,
-0.0647267327,
-0.0103328349,
0.0014964789,
0.0182126034,
0.0020944518,
-0.0210026447,
-0.0085471878,
0.0374317579,
0.0416776314,
0.0400171764,
0.0000018543,
-0.0200908631,
0.0219297465,
0.0043911324,
0.0493374616,
0.0122597869,
0.0702622235,
-0.0473241098,
-0.0078520654,
0.0341878608,
-0.0028423327,
-0.0151443835,
0.0335318223,
0.017383717,
0.0603037924,
0.0673025921,
-0.0346880257,
-0.0543832928,
-0.0034476912,
-0.0118774939,
-0.0015237234,
-0.0183929279,
-0.0115078716,
-0.0134751964,
0.0022381165,
-0.0168524012,
-0.0511107221,
0.0634521917,
-0.0023384828,
0.0150873633,
0.0008962867,
0.0272191521,
-0.0084209293,
-0.0452396721,
-0.0051684594,
0.104880549,
-0.0023522582,
0.0026187133,
0.0131595694,
0.0046694316,
-0.0373947471,
-0.0014880267,
-0.0021771111,
0.0431196205,
0.0316008218,
0.0069421898,
-0.0624803714,
0.0126767876,
0.0359318294,
-0.0130096637,
0.0204211418,
-0.009363208,
0.0200173706,
-0.0095276292,
0.0036472995,
-0.0094831623,
-0.0295574404,
-0.0140511869,
-0.0044580391,
0.0165609829,
0.0001189669,
-0.008635995,
-0.0605791248,
-0.0505327918,
-0.0211237259,
-0.010993965,
0.0265883431,
0.0063059921,
-0.0794423893,
0.0576629415,
0.0093924403,
0.0094987843,
-0.0002029328,
0.0026395181,
-0.0135785686,
-0.0140782082,
-0.0135018146,
0.0042200121,
-0.0299386475,
-0.0272770803,
-0.0473882668,
-0.0596668571,
0.0003495703,
-0.0288843308,
-0.0014669648,
-0.0100018866,
0.0117309587,
0.0017686179,
-0.0096913129,
-0.029855866,
0.0208650865,
0.0412683375,
0.0318042748,
0.0640879273,
-0.0398980677,
-0.0281235687,
0.0049235784,
0.0565328076,
0.0212864056,
-0.0145994918,
0.0013579206,
0.0902763084,
-0.0439751297,
-0.0453629196,
0.0059617995,
-0.0103534982,
-0.0330025367,
-0.0634401664,
-0.0036284118,
-0.0578858927,
0.0419869535,
-0.0218600649,
0.0157882217,
-0.02476996,
-0.0071854042,
0.010047365,
0.0068748905,
0.1156329587,
0.0119256927,
0.0167044979,
0.034445893,
0.0158425011,
0.0130810644,
0.080875814,
0.0530243814,
-0.0328498818,
0.0244466383,
-0.0169394128,
-0.0024691126,
0.0931836963,
-0.0049707377,
0.0080228867,
0.00561166,
-0.0314422436,
0.0015446277,
0.0347065739,
0.0596289411,
0.0644885004,
-0.0323034935,
-0.0364194065,
0.0920601487,
0.0200676918,
-0.0018479067,
-0.0046970858,
0.0296588987,
0.0078512914,
0.032201875,
-0.0068381703,
-0.0080371611,
0.0002553341,
-0.0074654911,
0.0168695636,
0.042186413,
0.0172463767,
-0.0360004269,
0.0185786486,
-0.0173262786,
-0.0440528095,
0.0201911405,
-0.0047865622,
0.0370100811,
0.0165077876,
-0.0616500638,
0.0234232489,
0.0189655181,
-0.0559293069,
0.0095388088,
0.0013754416,
-0.0228623915,
0.0237032026,
0.0231633782,
-0.031063946,
0.0373206884,
-0.0213715695,
0.0153450826,
0.0685465485,
0.0052209487,
0.0075540072,
0.0822024643,
-0.0750077516,
-0.0233780574,
-0.0001227933,
-0.0036723074,
0.0041213883,
-0.0155400727,
0.0005591876,
-0.0057861838,
-0.0081442203,
0.0481959134,
0.0350456648,
-0.0277023949,
-0.0108887702,
-0.0258701649,
0.0129590435,
0.0220068097,
-0.0022475044,
-0.0410875082,
0.0018673547,
0.0090705976,
-0.0435170271,
0.0292826165,
0.0211699959,
-0.0578665994,
-0.0371923447,
0.0427518412,
-0.0614276566,
0.026214825,
0.0823373199,
-0.0052815154,
-0.0457603224,
0.0120276632,
-0.0222469233,
0.0166233163,
-0.0662093684,
0.0012663502,
0.0201600026,
0.0469552316,
-0.0004310732,
-0.0138132023,
-0.0010542846,
-0.0174667146,
0.0018814392,
-0.0082999244,
0.0149947889,
-0.0338935219,
-0.0614911988,
0.0031459406,
0.0154298572,
0.0712174326,
-0.0149385659,
-0.0037187084,
0.0007831153,
-0.0114570921,
-0.126174137,
-0.014872496,
-0.0253556725,
-0.0397929251,
0.0137156723,
0.0042003137,
0.0044260556,
-0.0338915363,
-0.0268051606,
0.0086515732,
0.0150744403,
0.0051298272,
0.0003882985,
-0.001802723,
-0.0038555013,
-0.0231145732,
-0.009849811,
0.0194702931,
0.036849536,
-0.0407650247,
-0.0136870453,
0.0127316639,
-0.0140343206,
-0.0152315451,
0.0434002057,
-0.0204804912,
-0.0236975532,
-0.0205838196,
-0.0121343099,
0.0712583885,
0.001421738,
0.0072697797,
-0.0004348245,
0.0158142243,
0.0115988264,
-0.0109097473,
-0.0076986463,
0.0217976384,
0.0041054632,
-0.0271313451,
-0.0071271602,
-0.0395202376,
0.0673869178,
0.0266393907,
0.0306598004,
-0.0485171415,
-0.0132724894,
-0.0008615175,
-0.0318299942,
-0.0611455217,
0.000652769,
-0.0412612408,
0.0000526714,
-0.0180923305,
-0.0440809987,
0.0232286155,
-0.0781837925,
-0.0414639227,
-0.0375222079,
-0.0264582783,
-0.0157420728,
0.0458499156,
0.0259780921,
0.009807379,
-0.0054075508,
0.0130745545,
-0.0810308605,
0.0061994577,
0.0336763002,
-0.0324838795,
0.0192551222,
-0.0264641941,
0.0155803161,
-0.0225617904,
-0.0423512533,
-0.0028976449,
-0.0762022361,
-0.0354982689,
-0.0191265158,
-0.0286685061,
-0.0093149906,
-0.0378406644,
0.0208070334,
0.0347627066,
0.0470258556,
0.0182677172,
0.0192109067,
-0.0250440296,
0.0706299543,
0.0548754111,
0.0244413707,
-0.0266084485,
-0.0697629899,
0.0065993541,
0.0006257857,
0.0488266163,
0.0253163762,
-0.0513113029,
0.0230888911,
0.0216919556,
0.0728375688,
-0.0403216667,
0.0301896892,
0.068577528,
-0.025870841,
0.0128727397,
0.0750955045,
-0.0143437907,
-0.0120157124,
-0.0182441864,
0.0563412458,
0.0456790701,
-0.001640495,
-0.0263513457,
-0.0601472035,
-0.0619024262,
0.0167839509,
0.0143093495,
0.0475912429,
0.0265245494,
-0.0177246872,
-0.0751586109,
0.0110645806,
0.0009083744,
-0.033644326,
0.01780577,
-0.0140163386,
-0.0160393566,
-0.0242991894,
0.0276215691,
-0.0015424201,
-0.0053654336,
-0.0191985685,
0.0284732953,
-0.0415510945,
-0.0588062666,
0.0232262332,
-0.0447334871,
0.0332123898,
0.0392838009,
0.0163527895,
-0.0268987399,
-0.0658446029,
0.0639908314,
0.0231503006,
-0.0109203244,
0.0160545353,
0.045710627,
-0.0215054229,
-0.034472771,
0.0188753493,
0.0514965169,
0.0009142739,
-0.0307427216,
-0.0149534661,
0.0267381296,
0.0294349119,
0.0096189221,
-0.0274064932,
0.0497728735,
0.0056115012,
0.0629397631,
0.0029141074,
-0.0723192617,
-0.0109123187,
0.0253924206,
0.0187893007,
-0.0322813652,
-0.0478871912,
0.0207900312,
-0.0040889764,
0.0221997816,
-0.0487444885,
-0.0056751277,
-0.0253324509,
0.0528459437,
0.010902605,
-0.0127522638,
-0.013309923,
0.0129738254,
-0.0592996664,
0.0700544268,
-0.005250948,
0.0643830076,
-0.0531758592,
-0.0219459217,
0.0372198261,
-0.0385468826,
-0.0127238063,
0.0403552875,
-0.0950301513,
-0.0371099077,
-0.0308511443,
0.0136218304,
0.0175097734,
0.0510143973,
0.0059523988,
-0.0726949349,
0.0399241298,
0.0221973024,
-0.0409113728,
0.0487917624,
0.0389326252,
-0.0156546682,
-0.0188020878,
0.0181692094,
-0.0159576945,
0.0182199273,
0.0066333348,
0.0285592191,
0.0250566136,
0.0014471167,
-0.0364217237,
-0.0153249996,
0.0632745251,
-0.0371997356,
0.0187989157,
-0.0455812067,
-0.0194296483,
-0.012057364,
0.008252563,
-0.0624862239,
0.0089805098,
0.0348617695,
0.0268948823,
-0.0351403877,
0.0331283621,
0.0053063747,
0.0159795452,
-0.0190674309,
0.0517903119,
0.0334512703,
-0.018639721,
-0.0161744542,
0.0125895124,
0.0310108922,
0.0411975309,
-0.0131565388,
-0.0050644833,
-0.003025492,
0.0591540411,
-0.0076440512,
-0.0110711614,
-0.0230552778,
0.0272064712,
-0.0324196555,
0.0199239273,
-0.0468369499,
0.0201351903,
0.0551859885,
-0.0131605156,
0.0527244173,
0.0019856596,
-0.0067696068,
-0.0344681628,
0.0617686883,
-0.0213881228,
0.000643476,
0.0489818491,
0.0011869555,
-0.0329470299,
0.0356234349,
0.0757069513,
0.0143598318,
0.0108877001,
-0.0088052042,
0.0350987129,
-0.0378631055,
-0.016298892,
0.0520326942,
0.0531501174,
-0.0226949826,
0.0165677778,
-0.0247810613,
-0.067069985,
-0.0019809911,
0.0036125595,
0.0071369209,
0.0106871743,
0.0397911407,
0.0175445173,
-0.0050988696,
0.0290052053,
-0.0152502386,
-0.0419032723,
0.0340007283,
-0.0112559488,
0.0291277263,
-5.820857007e-33,
-0.0073649469,
0.0226971302,
0.0199677609,
-0.0222616289,
-0.0264477096,
0.0219264049,
0.0043404503,
0.0247884542,
0.0031703003,
-0.00985731,
0.032433603,
-0.0107744318,
0.0110961664,
0.0573871247,
-0.0391797461,
0.0353256203,
0.0411570333,
-0.0476531796,
-0.0211014282,
-0.0359186754,
0.0097647328,
0.0355992392,
0.0141344499,
-0.0582871996,
-0.0280595329,
-0.0203496665,
-0.0431870669,
-0.0142738251,
0.0358673185,
0.0653082207,
-0.0711488277,
0.02914216,
-0.0180432573,
-0.0006301845,
-0.0554650873,
0.0478422977,
-0.0733694136,
0.0437121056,
0.0153622618,
0.0558915362,
-0.0734219179,
0.0270865504,
0.0499704853,
-0.0220634565,
-0.021269381,
-0.0234395061,
0.0462079011,
-0.021511307,
-0.0199584626,
-0.0052745948,
-0.0514456518,
0.0265479069,
-0.0229133312,
-0.0446217135,
0.0483970307,
0.0357919931,
0.0022446518,
-0.0027687689,
-0.0667671636,
0.0229956247,
-0.0231903885,
0.0173456315,
0.0593452491,
0.0378427096,
0.0023533003,
0.058124397,
0.056882903,
-0.0623044148,
-0.0073282705,
0.014282736,
0.0707407221,
0.0363585912,
0.0246527977,
0.0637234598,
-0.0037196635,
-0.0185102746,
-0.0489734374,
0.0094336811,
-0.0391428322,
-0.0326576792,
0.041108638,
0.0300884303,
0.0014635643,
0.0042784293,
-0.0689986348,
-0.0227684826,
-0.0349191986,
0.0099223638,
0.0404626876,
0.0356482267,
0.0128812287,
0.0126181943,
0.0830006376,
-0.0319453292,
-0.0199595429,
-0.0232904218,
-0.0372480005,
0.0421132073,
0.0018659245,
0.0413338207,
-0.0229859669,
-0.0237873644,
0.0723517686,
0.0420164764,
0.050088007,
-0.0262591615,
0.0206271689,
0.049763646,
-0.0864547268,
-0.01305997,
-0.0066547939,
-0.0065235877,
0.0086602941,
0.0426422171,
0.0435770489,
-0.0006350466,
-0.042733565,
0.0560341366,
-0.0115686962,
-0.0231527537,
-0.0136138136,
-0.0376569331,
-0.0274697915,
0.0229140185,
-0.0028365988,
0.0358208939,
-0.0080192126,
-0.059925817,
0.0509217381,
-0.0382112153,
-0.0172350146,
0.0325277373,
2.497e-7,
0.0212968588,
0.0025037567,
-0.0130782453,
-0.0183932558,
0.0529101379,
0.0404883251,
-0.0643877685,
0.0408436768,
-0.0463171341,
-0.0228735711,
-0.004601357,
0.0034359926,
0.0933644846,
0.0115601458,
-0.0379628763,
-0.021065725,
-0.0604539998,
0.0136300186,
-0.0451178998,
0.0019687098,
0.0338851027,
0.1080029309,
-0.0173979159,
-0.0330210179,
0.0195300207,
-0.0296655167,
0.0886490792,
-0.0243891943,
-0.0340855196,
-0.058752466,
-0.0001172759,
0.0126655987,
-0.0074633085,
-0.0229651667,
-0.0209314357,
0.0201859903,
0.0673566982,
0.0703576431,
-0.0082366886,
-0.060744606,
0.0058001219,
0.0437933952,
-0.0754685327,
-0.0130202686,
0.0702315271,
0.0208859742,
-0.0232547522,
-0.0439233258,
-0.0342920087,
0.0135149229,
0.041257944,
-0.0264773276,
-0.0510621406,
0.0380071774,
0.0460580327,
-0.0273867846,
-0.0561302863,
-0.0732784793,
-0.0427444726,
0.0049782302,
-0.0593725741,
-0.0113664614,
-0.0250312015,
-0.030914627,
0.0405480079,
-0.0835011229,
-0.0216181464,
1.907987814e-34,
0.0405860841,
-0.0648293495,
0.0018368098,
-0.0152568854,
-0.0018798554,
-0.0280637424,
0.0039556897,
-0.0033470665,
-0.0040829121,
-0.0570878498,
-0.0133938519
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.02913v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.02913v1 | Let the LLMs Talk: Simulating Human-to-Human Conversational QA via Zero-Shot LLM-to-LLM Interactions | 2023-12-05T17:38:02 | 2023-12-05T17:38:02 | Zahra Abbasiantaeb, Yifei Yuan, Evangelos Kanoulas, Mohammad Aliannejadi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR | Conversational question-answering (CQA) systems aim to create interactive
search systems that effectively retrieve information by interacting with users.
To replicate human-to-human conversations, existing work uses human annotators
to play the roles of the questioner (student) and the answerer (teacher).
Despite its effectiveness, challenges exist as human annotation is
time-consuming, inconsistent, and not scalable. To address this issue and
investigate the applicability of large language models (LLMs) in CQA
simulation, we propose a simulation framework that employs zero-shot learner
LLMs for simulating teacher-student interactions. Our framework involves two
LLMs interacting on a specific topic, with the first LLM acting as a student,
generating questions to explore a given search topic. The second LLM plays the
role of a teacher by answering questions and is equipped with additional
information, including a text on the given topic. We implement both the student
and teacher by zero-shot prompting the GPT-4 model. To assess the effectiveness
of LLMs in simulating CQA interactions and understand the disparities between
LLM- and human-generated conversations, we evaluate the simulated data from
various perspectives. We begin by evaluating the teacher's performance through
both automatic and human assessment. Next, we evaluate the performance of the
student, analyzing and comparing the disparities between questions generated by
the LLM and those generated by humans. Furthermore, we conduct extensive
analyses to thoroughly examine the LLM performance by benchmarking
state-of-the-art reading comprehension models on both datasets. Our results
reveal that the teacher LLM generates lengthier answers that tend to be more
accurate and complete. The student LLM generates more diverse questions,
covering more aspects of a given topic. | [
0.0515850745,
-0.022630401,
-0.0319098495,
0.0560932569,
-0.008722486,
-0.0050097667,
0.0134374388,
-0.0218364708,
0.0079986108,
-0.0384310894,
-0.0087466156,
-0.0280802939,
-0.0394313782,
-0.0136372494,
0.0291565899,
-0.0655236989,
0.0157650262,
-0.0401597694,
-0.0232008938,
0.0173780806,
0.0280425325,
-0.0017817129,
-0.0161196627,
0.0442429371,
0.0196660943,
-0.0186425205,
-0.0633689538,
0.0012692973,
-0.0036790888,
-0.0205485076,
0.0126187801,
0.0583851859,
0.034913525,
0.0483112447,
0.0000021405,
-0.0240371954,
0.0082128001,
0.007409513,
-0.0424949601,
0.016984351,
0.0103431214,
0.0358320847,
0.0099535501,
0.0236714818,
-0.0596801974,
0.0132554499,
0.0098435972,
-0.0086850012,
0.0833642483,
0.0392470956,
0.0032854511,
-0.0107041346,
0.0282395519,
0.0063723195,
0.0866475701,
-0.0830338895,
-0.0026276996,
0.0552568585,
0.080947198,
0.0373839512,
-0.0163109377,
0.0503287762,
0.0260243788,
-0.0383845083,
0.0215680059,
0.0286290366,
-0.001588691,
-0.0185394678,
-0.0042167576,
0.1013300195,
0.0353126042,
-0.0232899655,
-0.0012847135,
0.0008633933,
0.0133771282,
0.0441650823,
-0.069862403,
0.014985837,
-0.0109748943,
-0.0095871734,
-0.0439167991,
0.0098249754,
0.0004452518,
0.0233478658,
0.0146665834,
0.0135671953,
-0.0030456856,
-0.0439400449,
-0.0317403898,
0.0201622974,
-0.0019244191,
-0.0524658188,
0.0101175122,
0.0851610526,
-0.0331081487,
0.0405666418,
-0.0451756939,
-0.040702682,
0.0290999673,
-0.0106098857,
0.0191637482,
0.0477690287,
-0.0001897142,
0.0697331056,
0.0091227395,
0.0418932699,
0.0003923068,
0.0206925906,
-0.0459833667,
-0.0239701755,
-0.056547381,
-0.0252795387,
-0.0400692485,
0.0256319679,
-0.0302457493,
-0.0338723324,
-0.0072346781,
0.042644456,
0.0335400738,
0.0014577345,
-0.0219328329,
0.0011563558,
-0.0323791094,
0.0169401243,
-0.0508708283,
0.0413746014,
-0.0576892123,
0.0006921166,
0.0314435251,
-0.0828042477,
-0.0212424677,
0.0211000852,
0.0053699506,
-0.0189307816,
-0.0288187023,
0.0228314009,
-0.038643606,
-0.0437125228,
-0.0016577769,
-0.0364803858,
0.022900844,
-0.03068964,
-0.0105784656,
-0.0468417332,
0.0494362339,
0.014863871,
-0.0234324802,
-0.0054969671,
0.0173791237,
0.0757599249,
0.0028182329,
0.0766011626,
-0.0227185264,
0.0280463882,
0.0808331892,
0.0303853042,
-0.0164349098,
0.0681188926,
0.0589630343,
-0.0067811892,
0.0377216898,
0.0034047165,
0.0362444073,
0.0354730822,
0.0118735507,
0.0187231582,
0.0189789254,
0.0298599657,
0.0290673897,
0.0596709475,
0.023696484,
0.0442868359,
-0.0530198999,
-0.0089527238,
0.0375948362,
0.0941295996,
-0.0227837805,
0.0057375603,
0.0458903871,
0.0586000271,
0.0338754579,
0.0127659123,
-0.0123204133,
0.037313085,
-0.0333396606,
-0.0075914571,
0.0386292636,
-0.0227935165,
-0.0209330264,
-0.0429971255,
0.0110827163,
0.0297628921,
-0.0071133384,
0.0265124552,
0.0244815815,
0.0056664925,
-0.051818233,
0.0260057468,
-0.0116875498,
-0.0514188074,
0.015821429,
-0.0587863959,
0.0632985458,
0.0771076605,
0.0684339926,
-0.0208415315,
-0.0372288115,
0.0013212893,
0.0275225863,
0.0651431233,
0.0248642322,
-0.012911303,
-0.0196633339,
-0.0418527015,
-0.0172063876,
-0.0053017456,
-0.0074982797,
0.0175275095,
0.0375845321,
-0.0040906253,
0.0177074838,
-0.0362617373,
-0.0125556225,
0.0288927648,
-0.0708692968,
-0.0227818433,
-0.0363710262,
-0.0163657255,
-0.0428309068,
0.0197007786,
0.0067592044,
0.0103406115,
0.0190679133,
0.0114189917,
-0.0085301679,
-0.0144043872,
-0.0297429748,
-0.0301254112,
0.0312342215,
-0.024700677,
0.0016661277,
0.0025541123,
-0.0125590051,
-0.0503296778,
-0.012937854,
-0.0387182869,
0.017056277,
-0.0505912006,
-0.0248058122,
0.0110887475,
-0.0241035428,
-0.0515380651,
0.0331670046,
0.0338249579,
-0.0016578902,
0.0166722033,
0.0223506577,
0.0045274948,
-0.0841342807,
-0.0130552137,
-0.0191486347,
0.0037146064,
0.0097001651,
-0.0047541745,
-0.0091621233,
-0.0865825489,
-0.0018677803,
-0.1089053899,
0.0250422396,
-0.0030013805,
0.0176343154,
0.0193771683,
0.0218374729,
-0.0178097337,
-0.0236509684,
-0.0575561486,
-0.0026121521,
0.0028500203,
0.0025958405,
0.0442474373,
0.0287919007,
0.0189846233,
-0.0738658011,
-0.0026126434,
-0.0212188195,
0.0218170136,
0.0605309196,
0.0210013408,
-0.0450619496,
0.0125879301,
-0.0259605125,
0.0116230287,
0.0022563576,
-0.0137370927,
0.0369627252,
-0.0372574516,
0.0080165286,
0.0601003952,
0.0043083942,
0.0401995443,
0.0145128714,
-0.0087720295,
-0.0867098123,
0.0462138318,
0.0175739285,
-0.036140725,
-0.0192130916,
-0.0430665575,
-0.0205728952,
0.0655258223,
-0.0126779778,
-0.000943367,
-0.0550691821,
0.0473488756,
-0.0116786007,
-0.0304265637,
-0.0706454217,
-0.0028548872,
-0.0276457071,
0.0374986529,
-0.0210585613,
-0.001868085,
0.0635497123,
-0.0213157069,
-0.0118303411,
-0.0282746926,
0.0308025815,
-0.0277808364,
0.0431099087,
-0.0216810014,
-0.0113961408,
-0.0110832285,
-0.0012496676,
-0.0316075608,
0.0152835101,
0.0394377001,
-0.059796799,
0.0137456488,
-0.0654706284,
0.0191036537,
-0.0123542259,
-0.0000973992,
-0.0396418348,
-0.0119235599,
-0.043661993,
-0.0016424386,
-0.0109944036,
-0.0133226523,
-0.0149648134,
-0.0057821157,
0.0375221781,
0.0245735142,
-0.038289912,
-0.0228325576,
-0.0382423885,
0.0755999312,
0.0613184981,
0.0194796789,
-0.0299442858,
-0.0368918478,
0.0775329098,
0.0492793508,
0.0331143439,
-0.0066003981,
0.0261806529,
-0.0567921437,
0.0170738902,
-0.0225526802,
-0.0009284939,
0.0342389196,
0.0510812178,
-0.0786895975,
-0.0273222309,
0.1028527319,
0.0562927686,
-0.0450279601,
-0.0220639426,
-0.062855646,
0.0372218974,
0.0057446407,
0.0487527139,
-0.1190853044,
-0.0415033288,
-0.0105570778,
0.0393594578,
-0.0014365902,
-0.040546678,
-0.0073865196,
-0.1212042272,
0.0186445452,
-0.0164347086,
-0.048631113,
0.0239297263,
-0.0374691896,
0.0098075587,
0.0166220535,
0.0116031151,
0.0168311894,
0.00356726,
0.0285020135,
0.0105920527,
0.0152770858,
-0.0158895906,
0.0270992983,
-0.0087203095,
0.0413871855,
0.0632250905,
0.0310651567,
0.0166496094,
-0.0183917824,
-0.0047084698,
-0.0275981724,
0.0016737765,
-0.0005384364,
0.0386555754,
-0.0294893552,
0.0061774724,
-0.0486741215,
0.0326587446,
0.0004829879,
0.0048865741,
0.0420928523,
0.0644902289,
-0.0047397185,
0.0193153787,
-0.0490710586,
0.0247513521,
0.0210244879,
0.0834222287,
0.0567648262,
-0.0574513413,
-0.0363032967,
-0.0183340888,
0.0076292921,
-0.0580982044,
-0.0552495271,
0.0002989479,
0.0193967447,
0.0256581157,
-0.0502600931,
-0.0834107324,
0.0610505678,
-0.0066829026,
-0.0157250706,
0.0233427715,
0.0097930348,
0.0075845686,
0.0013481636,
0.0080918875,
-0.0515077598,
0.0291967597,
-0.0368577726,
-0.0142752109,
0.0073988372,
-0.0416673906,
-0.0071314005,
0.0029988545,
-0.1020707339,
-0.0373357423,
-0.0356687382,
0.0495749563,
0.025772566,
0.0133423684,
-0.0007989871,
-0.0614664853,
-0.0075096027,
0.0120831169,
-0.0204273313,
-0.0081012668,
-0.0209637173,
0.0471630506,
0.0007966417,
0.0166414734,
-0.0167403612,
-0.0103199854,
-0.0363407657,
0.06095488,
-0.0669059753,
-0.08346086,
0.0249517355,
0.0018988386,
0.009056028,
0.0270031672,
-0.0162301697,
0.0090449313,
0.0201465935,
-0.0611907914,
0.0000841274,
-0.0458335802,
-0.0221706331,
0.0102006737,
-0.0405540057,
0.0131708486,
-0.0192080848,
-0.041635748,
0.0609132946,
-0.0234210901,
0.022717176,
0.0146957207,
-0.0279394742,
-0.0004792839,
-0.0111008268,
-0.0081798155,
-0.0013380871,
0.0192029998,
0.0817320123,
0.0315597914,
0.0999131799,
0.0063197948,
-0.0268424042,
0.0583281629,
0.0106024593,
-0.0729477033,
-0.0473629907,
-0.0090608019,
0.0526068211,
-0.001074835,
0.036220897,
0.0084984004,
-0.0112113925,
0.0046041738,
0.0114169214,
0.004141592,
-0.0160237011,
-0.0311377849,
0.0562632456,
0.0376013927,
0.0237827208,
0.0050122375,
0.0855012015,
0.016465405,
0.0108794486,
-0.0136777097,
0.003673753,
-0.0232454631,
0.0082957791,
0.0332133286,
0.0337538272,
0.0084602982,
0.0166724902,
-0.061073821,
-0.0429359637,
-0.0079969782,
0.0255628694,
-0.0202977434,
-0.0378654525,
0.0297817811,
0.045964662,
-0.0174638908,
-0.0199427456,
-0.0490589291,
0.0670710579,
-0.0363890715,
-0.045079466,
-0.0245612152,
-6.105749451e-33,
-0.0499827228,
-0.0636268705,
0.0449867137,
0.0108520333,
-0.0354390517,
-0.0206187051,
-0.0446814857,
0.0045913793,
-0.0240507349,
-0.0056690029,
-0.03443693,
0.0342811048,
0.0031760049,
0.0321561471,
-0.003436235,
-0.0490172841,
0.0305819102,
-0.016245164,
-0.0068664113,
0.040233925,
-0.0001058449,
0.0140736429,
-0.0189368017,
-0.0160037205,
0.0616501793,
-0.070738934,
0.0126360347,
0.0305852257,
0.0038325507,
0.0427980833,
-0.0467009582,
0.0404971279,
0.0277462509,
-0.0232601892,
0.0175511371,
0.0512811691,
-0.0535519123,
-0.0170696415,
0.0200271402,
-0.0035328399,
-0.0644939318,
-0.0184813645,
0.0177330635,
-0.0296286512,
0.0121826511,
-0.0162293985,
0.0500775017,
-0.0010965475,
-0.0170922372,
-0.0013226881,
-0.0687299967,
0.0188991129,
-0.0279118121,
-0.0688262209,
0.0022660966,
0.0812166333,
0.003569131,
0.015386642,
-0.0401980169,
0.0188100897,
0.0458599441,
0.0099979583,
0.0480692349,
0.0311137363,
-0.010117813,
0.0409785286,
0.0266690049,
0.0047290418,
-0.0507403463,
-0.0512156524,
0.0132197114,
0.0008306889,
0.0431075171,
0.0663807094,
0.0174878929,
0.0464611426,
-0.0388941914,
0.0634845495,
0.0243498478,
0.0187225211,
-0.014895129,
0.0028400081,
-0.0494321808,
0.0046999496,
-0.0510387197,
0.0042159082,
-0.0354008749,
-0.042926427,
0.0381863974,
-0.0245234463,
-0.0286440495,
-0.0197503362,
0.0204141755,
-0.0320568308,
0.0097004175,
-0.0104992753,
0.0018380783,
0.0347438976,
-0.0292627905,
0.0313742384,
-0.0408501402,
0.0106920796,
0.0262725987,
0.0046186429,
0.0025779752,
0.0460283943,
-0.0106146568,
-0.0186450351,
-0.0241705477,
-0.0363798179,
-0.0382921956,
0.0123730162,
-0.0276284665,
-0.0168440733,
0.0085602785,
0.0342353545,
-0.0287840031,
0.0289535224,
0.0142664211,
-0.0057210135,
-0.0064104358,
-0.061311204,
-0.0219626725,
-0.0421169177,
-0.0173356328,
0.0164626557,
-0.0246965289,
0.0394899584,
-0.0190563947,
-0.0729162768,
0.0133550689,
0.0101239998,
2.764e-7,
0.0323283747,
0.0331936255,
0.0223513991,
0.0128664644,
0.0248147845,
0.0269908644,
0.0087493546,
0.0092877625,
0.0605949983,
-0.04239548,
0.0078777596,
0.0490593463,
0.0295466501,
0.0164956786,
-0.1101216599,
-0.023621425,
-0.038902387,
0.0010816558,
-0.0402993597,
-0.0181089602,
0.0862668902,
0.0249148738,
-0.0028391583,
0.0018352724,
-0.0139435772,
-0.0246136189,
0.0509157367,
-0.0053287367,
-0.0256043784,
0.0216493737,
0.0435817502,
-0.0012690878,
0.0278294329,
0.0388957895,
0.0032750205,
0.002953826,
0.0383961648,
0.0327801518,
0.0005537796,
-0.0321585499,
-0.0254919082,
-0.0210558735,
0.0173232481,
-0.0749535933,
0.0586820431,
-0.058218468,
-0.0064325426,
0.0287420936,
-0.0420985371,
-0.0203494523,
-0.023600772,
-0.0125577506,
-0.0282049384,
0.0019717892,
-0.00754706,
-0.004868492,
0.0203595664,
-0.0254425853,
-0.0245106053,
-0.0375152566,
-0.0437040441,
-0.047354348,
-0.0834229514,
-0.0403932966,
-0.0103258118,
-0.0435618199,
0.0025689523,
1.990646189e-34,
0.0306989774,
0.0191974454,
0.0368218198,
0.0456413962,
0.0253657755,
0.0187784638,
0.0048580384,
0.0196346361,
0.0608538911,
-0.0898873806,
-0.0170000102
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.02901v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.02901v1 | Concept Drift Adaptation in Text Stream Mining Settings: A Comprehensive Review | 2023-12-05T17:15:16 | 2023-12-05T17:15:16 | Cristiano Mesquita Garcia, Ramon Simoes Abilio, Alessandro Lameiras Koerich, Alceu de Souza Britto Jr., Jean Paul Barddal | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.IR | Due to the advent and increase in the popularity of the Internet, people have
been producing and disseminating textual data in several ways, such as reviews,
social media posts, and news articles. As a result, numerous researchers have
been working on discovering patterns in textual data, especially because social
media posts function as social sensors, indicating peoples' opinions,
interests, etc. However, most tasks regarding natural language processing are
addressed using traditional machine learning methods and static datasets. This
setting can lead to several problems, such as an outdated dataset, which may
not correspond to reality, and an outdated model, which has its performance
degrading over time. Concept drift is another aspect that emphasizes these
issues, which corresponds to data distribution and pattern changes. In a text
stream scenario, it is even more challenging due to its characteristics, such
as the high speed and data arriving sequentially. In addition, models for this
type of scenario must adhere to the constraints mentioned above while learning
from the stream by storing texts for a limited time and consuming low memory.
In this study, we performed a systematic literature review regarding concept
drift adaptation in text stream scenarios. Considering well-defined criteria,
we selected 40 papers to unravel aspects such as text drift categories, types
of text drift detection, model update mechanism, the addressed stream mining
tasks, types of text representations, and text representation update mechanism.
In addition, we discussed drift visualization and simulation and listed
real-world datasets used in the selected papers. Therefore, this paper
comprehensively reviews the concept drift adaptation in text stream mining
scenarios. | [
0.0398889333,
0.0425771102,
-0.0458428226,
0.000214559,
-0.0541734584,
-0.0102430405,
-0.0460372232,
0.0026427004,
-0.0275878105,
-0.0475347005,
0.0659070611,
-0.0351813845,
0.0047630761,
0.0776166171,
-0.0562844537,
-0.0467780866,
0.0520986691,
-0.0268234387,
0.0375789367,
0.037884403,
0.0564438812,
-0.0170787461,
0.0110095404,
-0.0423084795,
0.033655528,
-0.0194218289,
-0.014035278,
-0.0579673611,
0.0070964494,
-0.0306214765,
0.0241420139,
0.0541638955,
0.0353250057,
0.0315792039,
0.0000020727,
-0.0373579413,
-0.0483201407,
-0.0266480148,
0.0148101505,
-0.0343838856,
0.0921264291,
0.014142192,
-0.0115017947,
0.0402407199,
-0.0494910628,
0.0264053214,
0.0409428701,
0.0162423272,
0.0360298865,
0.0656315163,
-0.0241390355,
-0.0085984617,
0.0012262623,
0.0282600243,
0.0365332849,
-0.0283101294,
0.0535118543,
-0.0162815023,
-0.0261772033,
-0.0004982355,
0.0005893439,
-0.0105480002,
-0.044572942,
-0.0181832202,
0.0583487861,
-0.0171845239,
-0.0290459394,
0.0310517736,
-0.0139217824,
0.0253457017,
0.0057572955,
-0.0266285855,
0.0259946566,
-0.0297519788,
-0.014276702,
-0.0031996856,
-0.0143763684,
-0.0323431939,
-0.0187845342,
0.0048905094,
-0.0233249478,
-0.0035704796,
-0.0255847927,
0.0412771776,
-0.0276831836,
0.0013627512,
-0.0276883021,
-0.0379396044,
-0.003263091,
0.0265269522,
0.030834889,
-0.0213057362,
0.046227742,
0.0331353955,
0.0099355532,
0.0585176274,
-0.0207250807,
-0.0517257079,
0.0111455685,
-0.1273168027,
0.0281406995,
-0.0206155963,
0.0010700766,
0.0475723185,
0.0302109197,
-0.0082183639,
0.0352754556,
-0.0565783754,
-0.0090836342,
0.0395707078,
-0.1009798199,
0.0011316775,
0.0023766751,
0.0431995615,
0.0264880098,
0.0073292516,
-0.0080651613,
0.0765507817,
0.0231638812,
-0.0265293755,
-0.0668041855,
-0.0062821722,
-0.011684984,
0.0218849704,
-0.0443589911,
0.0478863753,
-0.0095941834,
0.0266410653,
-0.0124778133,
-0.0100431861,
0.0142821781,
-0.0391590446,
0.0668027699,
0.0129684452,
-0.0215727463,
-0.0735845715,
-0.0023268345,
-0.0407959148,
-0.0991710275,
-0.0006153507,
-0.012671371,
0.0150852753,
-0.0320063122,
-0.059244249,
0.0044794469,
0.0108314492,
-0.0276163127,
-0.007693545,
-0.0263109356,
0.0281521361,
-0.0244226307,
0.0321533009,
-0.0381892659,
-0.0043221987,
0.0367296934,
-0.0071532978,
-0.0196636058,
0.0947829038,
0.0161666591,
0.0238425117,
0.0527759008,
-0.0366107225,
-0.0122405449,
-0.0009086746,
-0.0123933936,
0.0003580196,
0.0072626928,
0.0180431493,
-0.0550734736,
-0.0126481419,
0.0002373384,
-0.0032991513,
0.0281799287,
0.0075691966,
0.042247463,
0.029406216,
-0.0196187161,
0.0375490859,
-0.062303707,
0.0471319966,
-0.0058215694,
0.0085946256,
0.0394454524,
-0.0063179019,
-0.0215387754,
-0.0452688299,
-0.0057397415,
0.0037542589,
-0.0403339304,
-0.0358276069,
0.0060777054,
0.0067717019,
0.0421199985,
-0.0327184461,
0.044185441,
-0.0026823464,
0.0369967446,
0.0044956119,
0.0321704037,
0.0054445351,
0.0125246653,
-0.0244655441,
0.0264221635,
0.0753629953,
0.0177996289,
-0.0517723337,
-0.0367599092,
-0.0362180658,
0.0629561394,
-0.0240217,
0.0356110185,
-0.0143350149,
-0.047412388,
-0.0117123853,
-0.0264395624,
0.0500908494,
-0.0165239498,
-0.0074146991,
-0.0141808856,
0.089969784,
-0.0008188778,
-0.0171259772,
-0.051042825,
0.0171068236,
0.0320549235,
0.0502609424,
0.0554251373,
-0.0328500383,
0.045340091,
0.0151428496,
0.0231875405,
-0.0282880794,
0.0333851911,
0.0220918693,
-0.0487111695,
0.0220330022,
-0.0063727857,
0.0342404097,
0.0267719012,
0.0059369602,
0.0270412788,
0.0215251185,
-0.0529579669,
-0.028583264,
0.0377096348,
-0.0194069631,
0.0419467352,
-0.0145075321,
0.0302303769,
-0.0543059185,
0.0265022945,
-0.0089762686,
0.0567818098,
0.0092691686,
-0.0123759666,
-0.0640142858,
0.0018154825,
-0.0018490097,
0.0275203492,
0.0000282038,
0.0077748732,
-0.0183685385,
0.0356441438,
0.045570001,
-0.0649739057,
-0.0578176156,
0.0242217686,
-0.01301206,
0.0243856311,
-0.0136718145,
0.0435359441,
0.0148346992,
-0.0036024731,
-0.0067121615,
-0.0220262446,
-0.0142376954,
0.0355125889,
-0.0064133066,
0.037214458,
0.0264057871,
0.0040247003,
0.040123865,
-0.0137492046,
0.0146220587,
-0.0006560918,
0.030033173,
0.0357892923,
-0.0783915669,
-0.068564184,
0.022986684,
-0.04432071,
-0.0155153256,
-0.0042449664,
0.0393123701,
-0.0531620346,
-0.0023780847,
0.0266394727,
-0.0154131148,
0.0875941664,
0.0542077832,
0.0150588593,
-0.0118150581,
-0.037679784,
-0.0039647911,
-0.004795772,
0.0458702035,
0.0040340107,
0.0141116465,
0.0757525936,
-0.0241324231,
-0.0025056258,
-0.0185606778,
-0.0159137156,
0.0089767519,
-0.0219115522,
0.021888474,
-0.015079149,
-0.0119523285,
-0.0008679345,
-0.0397446193,
-0.0167124253,
-0.0244128276,
0.0305980947,
0.0701944605,
0.0644335672,
-0.1120830551,
-0.0373984016,
-0.0239758771,
0.0211869814,
0.0062461938,
-0.0030481981,
0.0282438267,
0.0158131141,
0.0397962444,
-0.0284626167,
0.0150600988,
-0.0181639362,
0.0035402826,
-0.0145021481,
0.0257068481,
0.0101773897,
0.0183793493,
-0.0133065516,
-0.0423461162,
0.0138468565,
-0.0465294868,
0.0488302708,
-0.0145110693,
-0.0210511107,
0.047184851,
0.0084426459,
0.0190479849,
0.0158001743,
-0.0375437476,
0.0267160498,
0.0313493721,
0.0424331576,
-0.0354449302,
-0.0023221229,
0.0098142019,
0.0148747452,
0.089514263,
0.0099371877,
-0.0466024838,
-0.0711875334,
-0.0188173112,
0.0166058037,
-0.0672469586,
0.0076836175,
-0.0207701381,
-0.019926101,
-0.0332694054,
0.0023299188,
0.0712118074,
0.0627763644,
-0.075213477,
-0.0087511363,
-0.0109148026,
0.0057581789,
-0.0288676787,
0.0186200719,
-0.0366042517,
0.0005154823,
-0.0330839567,
0.0048265965,
-0.0226836316,
-0.055347804,
-0.0278158449,
-0.0424410328,
0.0079124058,
0.0074640876,
-0.035451591,
0.0074810963,
-0.1204439998,
0.0397644639,
-0.0077964282,
-0.0459438786,
-0.0170518253,
0.0187375713,
0.0195305552,
0.0459243059,
-0.1326496452,
-0.0656728148,
-0.0013285727,
-0.0133411502,
0.0238041505,
0.0519508645,
0.03784943,
-0.0541000441,
-0.0284308512,
0.0126362061,
-0.0717055872,
0.0019256785,
-0.0296159945,
0.0689045787,
0.001433898,
0.0241176877,
0.0070482781,
0.000490198,
-0.0166681278,
-0.0058171647,
0.0543223768,
0.0613812618,
-0.0321094394,
-0.0677318424,
-0.043522425,
-0.058717642,
0.0173478797,
0.0241710953,
-0.0352048986,
-0.0485399961,
0.0206882562,
0.010051297,
0.0190870911,
0.0279922895,
0.0380858444,
-0.0690618977,
-0.017467767,
-0.03201456,
-0.0959331617,
0.0407987051,
0.000850647,
0.0014718705,
0.0077943727,
0.0599086881,
0.066749081,
-0.0332086273,
-0.057614442,
-0.0168186799,
0.0193896145,
0.00424605,
0.0062245843,
-0.0521853045,
0.0586219765,
-0.0056237401,
-0.0140445055,
-0.0097727934,
-0.0998979136,
-0.0367962532,
0.0168211721,
-0.0142732393,
0.0072049578,
0.0348343216,
-0.0326890424,
-0.0280216467,
0.0448656641,
0.0379352719,
0.0136249466,
-0.0396107808,
-0.0259386469,
0.0110279117,
-0.0283214319,
-0.0142179653,
-0.0029336687,
0.0178457312,
-0.0161592569,
-0.0576134771,
-0.0411781147,
0.0406223647,
-0.0103741921,
0.0049863504,
0.0004821236,
0.0865414366,
-0.076309301,
-0.0119361505,
-0.0133623723,
0.0452793501,
-0.0370547734,
-0.0221779346,
-0.0103870844,
0.0241757855,
-0.019494595,
-0.0475356691,
0.0174441822,
0.0255812798,
-0.0569079891,
-0.0311374571,
-0.0032020332,
0.0497750752,
0.0750749409,
-0.0019591779,
0.0177215356,
0.0228207167,
-0.0486862771,
-0.0011996462,
0.0245103613,
-0.0221656617,
0.0089544822,
0.014197913,
-0.0162999183,
0.0227400996,
0.037200924,
-0.0706958473,
0.0328035466,
-0.0246959757,
0.0155039169,
0.0337389782,
-0.0166521315,
0.0305048618,
-0.0093228417,
0.0085808076,
-0.019408986,
-0.0094231348,
0.0050120163,
-0.0108771129,
-0.0116905067,
0.019064961,
-0.0405921265,
0.0610884465,
0.0208945777,
-0.0320936814,
0.0277179256,
0.0234228317,
-0.0811416805,
-0.0046100332,
0.0662619472,
0.0024494778,
0.033336442,
0.0308610853,
0.0036129092,
0.0067879474,
-0.0108637065,
0.1027696058,
-0.0914299116,
0.0519016869,
-0.0088546798,
0.0272770133,
0.0863985121,
0.0147853568,
0.0525608286,
-0.0258546472,
-0.0196246859,
-0.0303246509,
0.0064151706,
-0.0157316681,
-6.004678977e-33,
0.0180554073,
-0.0317769684,
-0.0219160002,
0.0413616933,
-0.0281116813,
-0.0119995521,
-0.0005264659,
-0.0395255201,
0.0173673071,
-0.0329874828,
0.0112023074,
0.0347482301,
0.009753719,
-0.0130235702,
0.0077711307,
-0.0163475312,
0.0135820014,
-0.0186928678,
-0.0027563698,
0.0498164073,
0.0599867031,
0.0317244679,
0.0297818445,
-0.0341431946,
0.0356739871,
0.0127856871,
0.0104411608,
-0.0022977318,
0.0585235804,
0.0273959264,
-0.0146764033,
0.0524215549,
0.0270951167,
0.0120254345,
-0.0720072687,
0.009943584,
-0.0363105014,
-0.0441435389,
-0.047210753,
0.0394061469,
0.0431904681,
0.009689915,
0.0276192967,
0.0149186561,
-0.0034350988,
0.0564428382,
0.0519175082,
-0.0556577779,
-0.0316402726,
-0.0398114622,
0.0021986035,
0.0514613092,
-0.0396985263,
0.0296983905,
-0.0212238263,
0.0255334545,
0.0236285422,
-0.0142977424,
-0.0908168852,
0.0395512432,
0.0328875892,
0.029101951,
0.0019883583,
-0.039554745,
-0.0042667468,
0.0543144085,
-0.0155857932,
0.0352693908,
0.0175036844,
0.0067552836,
0.0199956037,
-0.009699001,
0.0076419152,
0.0066565434,
0.0828722417,
-0.0716092065,
-0.0159198809,
0.0324029103,
0.0387342647,
0.0163443647,
0.0555722266,
0.0075654532,
-0.052759897,
-0.0351343639,
0.0314773209,
-0.014066454,
-0.0247491673,
-0.0356379934,
0.0063477051,
0.0070476732,
-0.010366003,
0.0004158496,
-0.0057451627,
-0.0360215716,
-0.0537312515,
-0.0024949312,
-0.0207080245,
0.043067351,
0.04064475,
0.0097977361,
-0.043178197,
-0.0296068005,
-0.011830911,
0.0168212894,
-0.0375219993,
-0.030240871,
0.0309452415,
0.0144225098,
-0.0385020971,
0.0077603045,
0.0273832791,
-0.0126586817,
-0.034974467,
0.0060548265,
-0.0284037385,
-0.0058098934,
-0.0217289664,
0.0624689162,
0.0553895384,
-0.0077794553,
-0.0016062196,
0.0125772553,
-0.0314413421,
-0.0195542593,
0.0147634968,
-0.0299528725,
0.0246735793,
0.0147502702,
0.0089191487,
-0.0415884703,
-0.0144610321,
-0.04027915,
2.867e-7,
0.0386923999,
0.0809024945,
-0.0146675454,
-0.0386003591,
0.0355492271,
-0.0071876277,
-0.0414592996,
0.0117562544,
0.0175882671,
0.0414779149,
0.0195833482,
0.0119995689,
-0.0125412559,
0.0544130132,
-0.0590759851,
-0.0089675132,
-0.0272319559,
0.0216453541,
-0.0510138161,
0.0143477693,
0.042940449,
0.0127906371,
0.0078267083,
0.0052471915,
-0.0102152163,
-0.0433064327,
0.0104208691,
0.0103765205,
0.0065975343,
0.0157244466,
0.0295015275,
-0.0088293022,
-0.0468461551,
0.0187514946,
-0.0402865633,
0.0107465349,
-0.0139823155,
-0.0147727812,
0.0059661763,
0.0400743261,
0.0133078657,
0.0420774445,
0.0512551963,
-0.0083977496,
0.0828639716,
-0.0134995775,
-0.0188462827,
-0.0790380239,
-0.0283812936,
-0.0097722914,
0.0144936927,
0.0567305014,
-0.0445271842,
0.0022444236,
-0.0315708406,
0.0099176131,
-0.0690313727,
-0.0553384833,
0.0487715565,
-0.0405075364,
0.0149452277,
-0.0157836564,
-0.0608901419,
0.0233778302,
0.034058731,
-0.0279899482,
0.0833693221,
2.369470595e-34,
0.0383049659,
-0.0285085645,
-0.0497166328,
-0.0119211962,
0.0056464099,
0.0259400699,
0.0283823684,
-0.0107346028,
0.0322544314,
-0.0549162105,
0.0301111862
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.02869v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.02869v1 | Can a Tabula Recta provide security in the XXI century? | 2023-12-05T16:36:27 | 2023-12-05T16:36:27 | Francisco Ruiz | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.CL, cs.CY | In the not so unlikely scenario of total compromise of computers accessible
to a group of users, they might be tempted to resort to human-computable
paper-and-pencil cryptographic methods aided by a classic Tabula Recta, which
helps to perform addition and subtraction directly with letters. But do these
classic algorithms, or some new ones using the same simple tools, have any
chance against computer-aided cryptanalysis? In this paper I discuss how some
human-computable algorithms can indeed afford sufficient security in this
situation, drawing conclusions from computer-based statistical analysis. Three
kinds of algorithms are discussed: those that concentrate entropy from shared
text sources, stream ciphers based on arithmetic of non-binary spaces, and
hash-like algorithms that may be used to generate a password from a challenge
text. | [
0.0051311236,
0.0597121008,
-0.0141335446,
0.0094641084,
-0.054422915,
-0.0104607251,
0.0118129821,
-0.0097486768,
-0.0069318288,
-0.0108821681,
0.0473496839,
-0.0322379731,
0.0566845983,
-0.0076002674,
0.0441001095,
0.0012348905,
-0.0404738262,
0.0020400009,
-0.0399384238,
0.0031252769,
-0.023190707,
-0.0457002968,
-0.0102632353,
-0.0399001837,
0.0573116988,
-0.0165976789,
-0.0324610248,
-0.0500425994,
-0.0143966665,
0.0109304758,
-0.0460170321,
0.0509614423,
-0.0401601456,
0.0747905448,
0.0000023318,
-0.006286846,
-0.036831785,
0.0394742824,
-0.037521001,
0.0477888063,
0.0154032484,
0.0367536359,
-0.0337543003,
0.0161072779,
-0.0468873642,
0.0277870223,
0.0400379002,
0.0189689305,
0.0349510089,
0.0601921342,
0.0079959035,
-0.0233843178,
0.0421475917,
-0.0679669902,
0.0502756387,
-0.0463012904,
-0.0180998147,
-0.0667598248,
0.012762486,
-0.0040018992,
0.0178431775,
0.0107038794,
0.0094797695,
-0.001078338,
0.0102942754,
0.0276305825,
-0.0320593081,
0.0083681727,
-0.0423980094,
0.0237390045,
-0.0401214622,
-0.0189257916,
0.0089823026,
0.0296822935,
-0.0076508108,
-0.0021238141,
0.0029895965,
0.0075060842,
-0.0499043837,
-0.041426979,
0.0092852181,
-0.0119811911,
0.017562231,
-0.0181428082,
0.0527654812,
0.0138696777,
0.0196604468,
-0.0559769012,
0.0100678308,
-0.0128718857,
0.0147651527,
-0.0310429893,
-0.0074891653,
0.013322941,
0.0501707122,
0.0170152541,
-0.0494797155,
-0.0598347485,
0.0277813002,
-0.0300791599,
0.0600049421,
-0.0119322948,
0.069772765,
-0.018035518,
-0.0070276987,
0.0119080544,
-0.0506095774,
0.026137745,
0.006490936,
0.0646243021,
-0.0317986794,
-0.0383225121,
0.0135534517,
0.0440964513,
0.024544036,
0.0448223427,
-0.0379347503,
0.0351234153,
-0.003272614,
0.0250638351,
-0.0394942909,
-0.0271763131,
0.0709093288,
0.0039967811,
-0.007698202,
-0.0443966202,
-0.0068850829,
0.0025231966,
-0.0572017543,
-0.0331113525,
0.0016862267,
0.0130510554,
-0.0439439714,
-0.0030206887,
0.0117951222,
-0.006821245,
-0.0172332004,
-0.0129307564,
-0.0183060821,
-0.0283393934,
-0.0240148157,
-0.0472098216,
0.0246221926,
-0.0230076462,
0.0284394994,
-0.0231279396,
0.0083343806,
0.0109004462,
0.0272133928,
0.0329081826,
0.0013803965,
0.0801207274,
-0.0146111222,
-0.007956028,
0.0397962816,
0.0096896105,
-0.0125723984,
-0.0165451597,
0.0310814716,
0.0534644946,
0.006853994,
0.0075099007,
0.0915552825,
0.0104910256,
-0.0066020396,
-0.0200534705,
-0.022920588,
-0.0115889516,
0.0150194867,
-0.0564411171,
-0.0283642001,
0.0216486994,
-0.0121537475,
-0.0203307401,
0.0310214553,
0.0743109137,
0.0328074545,
0.0906700715,
-0.0239486136,
-0.0255607069,
0.0693112835,
0.0190084167,
-0.012650786,
0.0213988964,
-0.0470299311,
-0.0081276596,
0.0654015616,
-0.0245408174,
-0.0175986327,
-0.003123479,
0.0391349494,
-0.0291925464,
0.0192220267,
-0.0480739623,
0.0184139144,
-0.0198998619,
0.0208489485,
-0.0740487725,
0.0289089605,
-0.0628308728,
-0.0555777177,
-0.045496732,
0.0582425408,
0.0459377281,
0.0641388372,
0.0074511538,
0.1081469804,
-0.0021492692,
0.0131669324,
-0.0492604896,
0.0129569145,
0.0285936017,
-0.0237826724,
-0.0226382297,
-0.005295503,
0.063396506,
0.029593559,
0.01864109,
-0.032216493,
0.021292273,
-0.0077212797,
0.0470787883,
-0.0134250252,
-0.0277001522,
0.0365937352,
-0.0172291398,
0.0145265069,
0.0178864431,
0.0188293476,
0.0318799391,
-0.0223315042,
0.0637716576,
-0.0110543016,
-0.0324288942,
-0.0399299264,
-0.0528868698,
0.0433136486,
0.068725571,
-0.0007805214,
-0.0779295266,
0.0256826561,
0.0157216247,
0.0160506144,
0.003882796,
0.0912809148,
-0.0506621301,
-0.0312364455,
-0.0574620552,
-0.0031868827,
-0.0173568148,
-0.008089995,
-0.0200308654,
0.0296950936,
0.0229664706,
0.0520701446,
-0.0454056934,
-0.0746914446,
0.0259509664,
-0.0111917323,
-0.0409184881,
0.0013385903,
0.0068013547,
0.0293620266,
-0.0086224033,
-0.0138266152,
0.0047729816,
-0.0728294179,
0.0182398837,
-0.0124816066,
-0.0036421462,
0.0707107112,
0.0081677381,
-0.0165911317,
-0.0153157292,
-0.0372011289,
-0.0148467226,
-0.0192310642,
-0.0815014169,
-0.0399287678,
0.0281291399,
0.0024682991,
0.0009188032,
0.0103670247,
-0.0362626985,
-0.0167381465,
0.0095035052,
0.0248219613,
-0.0109074572,
-0.0147005273,
0.0014530289,
0.0223835725,
-0.0005110274,
0.0080115786,
0.0059234961,
0.01428199,
-0.0356204435,
0.0060859458,
0.0478024036,
0.015978884,
0.0280528497,
-0.0230057612,
0.0470313244,
0.0428811945,
-0.0070034005,
0.0182678103,
-0.0336294957,
0.0365523584,
-0.0492075905,
0.0233751629,
-0.0334324166,
-0.0156195164,
-0.0190788768,
-0.019806359,
0.0227116179,
0.0089720702,
0.0198568348,
-0.0843006968,
-0.0382509194,
-0.0018342608,
-0.0257165395,
0.0083316639,
-0.012129711,
-0.0124048106,
-0.0512229279,
-0.0013665595,
-0.0403043218,
-0.0148512265,
0.0179093685,
0.04752158,
-0.0033426706,
-0.0116574438,
0.0293524321,
-0.0072434167,
0.0074254,
-0.0324031934,
0.0419356599,
-0.0697302967,
-0.0347307622,
0.0019382086,
-0.0072887568,
-0.0281284321,
0.0225056149,
0.0257828981,
-0.0745459199,
0.0035861828,
-0.0367804281,
-0.0091574388,
-0.0390377678,
-0.0198828671,
-0.0129640037,
0.0983203128,
0.0019592198,
-0.0049394788,
-0.0249548052,
0.0044466374,
0.0341341533,
-0.045384787,
-0.0466070324,
-0.0109384879,
-0.0286469739,
-0.0119011141,
0.0651402324,
0.0641401857,
0.0599287003,
0.0198438112,
-0.0068863807,
-0.0336609557,
-0.0033363784,
-0.0409286954,
0.0351986922,
-0.0366778411,
0.0480550565,
0.0463281609,
-0.0149602825,
0.0153982677,
-0.0228174087,
-0.0040359357,
0.042079173,
-0.0382442027,
-0.002987074,
0.0020984174,
-0.0737572163,
0.021922797,
0.0064511877,
0.0647970662,
-0.0727984309,
-0.0500341281,
-0.0129890405,
-0.0590962358,
0.0162073467,
-0.010868907,
-0.0272267666,
-0.0704738349,
-0.0468866266,
-0.0125817982,
-0.0184057392,
-0.0527073331,
-0.006547872,
0.0153465029,
0.0528593771,
0.0169899706,
-0.0744342133,
0.0688344315,
-0.0353707746,
0.0264878962,
-0.0345811658,
0.0356436707,
0.0280870479,
-0.0314078629,
-0.0433927365,
-0.0371384658,
-0.0221281406,
-0.024777174,
0.0381247923,
0.0268735196,
0.0463561416,
-0.046957586,
-0.0034249295,
0.0237815268,
0.0195970014,
0.020419037,
0.0510024838,
-0.0013008675,
-0.0105040921,
-0.0137651926,
0.0102197845,
-0.0369384587,
0.0347409584,
0.0205356292,
-0.0042614345,
0.0133117773,
-0.0363343284,
-0.001213847,
0.0532469451,
-0.0262321308,
-0.0395432897,
-0.0183138847,
0.0467301011,
-0.0816756636,
-0.027844632,
-0.0221338496,
-0.0244211182,
0.0720443577,
-0.0212506354,
-0.0207192115,
0.0684575662,
0.0030236277,
-0.0698001459,
-0.0819346607,
-0.0506588034,
0.0371729992,
-0.0039458461,
0.0177798122,
-0.047671888,
-0.0172079578,
-0.0344059914,
0.0340554304,
-0.0594711676,
0.0049085212,
0.0342240296,
0.038796749,
0.0398483276,
-0.0993234962,
-0.058181528,
0.0160015095,
0.0242655165,
0.0153839244,
0.0065758033,
0.0218530335,
-0.0177456699,
-0.047481712,
0.0031196307,
-0.0148974033,
0.0159212593,
-0.0494965389,
0.0410490632,
-0.0227154177,
-0.0302373059,
-0.0344528779,
-0.0294832904,
0.03876739,
-0.0415005647,
0.0227618944,
0.0388168804,
0.0496116951,
0.0482978374,
-0.0095525002,
0.0230313502,
0.0068076793,
-0.0274927486,
-0.0001887512,
-0.0248258729,
-0.0007881432,
-0.0623553917,
0.0139418757,
0.0058925743,
0.0047701458,
0.0090676965,
0.0371912383,
0.0955775231,
0.0119646713,
-0.0197547954,
-0.0013800643,
0.0343961827,
0.0100715421,
0.0560677983,
0.0233461149,
-0.0134408614,
-0.0068638772,
-0.0048208358,
-0.0000952876,
0.0657740235,
-0.1032215282,
-0.0697086751,
0.0193840545,
0.0495557114,
0.0108230915,
0.0582004637,
-0.0619402528,
-0.0297704302,
0.0084465779,
-0.0186494347,
-0.038608633,
-0.0178907663,
0.0462779365,
-0.0471357331,
0.0324681886,
-0.0273744706,
0.0120467152,
0.0324032344,
-0.0441969596,
0.0121357758,
0.0050308984,
-0.0280188657,
-0.0043758648,
-0.0346709937,
-0.005860168,
0.0369127914,
-0.0145035591,
0.002266749,
-0.0384388529,
0.0298356675,
0.0477534868,
-0.0043533635,
0.0328112654,
0.0387863703,
-0.0035620877,
-0.0048701931,
-0.0377323627,
0.0998310149,
-0.0548375733,
0.0511674136,
-0.0190491993,
-0.0060666357,
-0.0238933451,
-6.370880365e-33,
0.0362216011,
-0.0164349806,
-0.0418060273,
0.0369269326,
0.0208094958,
-0.0144909639,
-0.006676422,
0.0252947193,
-0.0011046561,
-0.0041150376,
-0.0164092239,
-0.0081362994,
0.0293413177,
-0.0193974432,
-0.0359824672,
-0.0457465425,
-0.0346721411,
0.0009906406,
-0.0159220714,
-0.0253144149,
0.0405738764,
-0.0056862207,
0.0276846066,
-0.0134432223,
0.0580819398,
-0.0186329167,
-0.0623563752,
-0.0427179262,
-0.0033571282,
-0.004227153,
0.0133811906,
-0.0040405546,
0.0119345179,
-0.0537809357,
0.0296617094,
0.0874676928,
0.0209886935,
-0.0314983502,
0.0123321759,
-0.0014801942,
0.0165124796,
-0.0510905758,
0.003048524,
-0.028208809,
-0.0103397919,
0.0290093757,
-0.0104351733,
0.0053902515,
0.0033840982,
-0.0208875351,
0.0759980828,
0.0116896695,
-0.0290005505,
-0.0034017139,
-0.0225722734,
-0.0402139984,
-0.0204730295,
-0.0911588147,
-0.0425196923,
0.0837253854,
0.0668705776,
-0.0156263337,
-0.0607545972,
-0.0597572811,
-0.0016130736,
-0.0137151061,
0.0909833908,
-0.0116855316,
-0.0134485513,
-0.0021224562,
-0.0257922281,
-0.0555699393,
0.0498429351,
0.060854461,
0.111805059,
0.0003275351,
-0.0653494522,
0.0623317286,
0.0201955792,
-0.0020743075,
0.0401798189,
-0.0410278849,
-0.0647227317,
-0.0097314883,
0.0349017344,
-0.0043562823,
-0.0382442921,
0.0179154929,
-0.0487946831,
0.0053557213,
0.035349492,
0.017619567,
-0.0348051153,
-0.0049085827,
0.0352831818,
0.0018896217,
0.0585944615,
0.0140079707,
-0.018818615,
-0.0456706882,
0.0144565627,
0.037972156,
0.0103215128,
0.0187697038,
0.0252203047,
-0.023837572,
0.0043739625,
0.0376514867,
-0.053860724,
-0.039912615,
0.0306096934,
0.0356059186,
0.0418841429,
0.0026264349,
0.0045392779,
-0.0106127737,
-0.009495181,
-0.0184036456,
-0.0177631266,
-0.0008181506,
0.025295075,
0.0451914556,
0.0004651113,
0.0043515614,
0.0854713172,
0.0060786153,
0.0207598116,
0.0029792078,
0.0187148955,
0.026428476,
0.0135754645,
-0.0887893438,
3.169e-7,
0.0419066213,
-0.0449720286,
0.0740252584,
-0.0272969641,
0.0410689376,
0.0259109642,
-0.0387606919,
0.0558060296,
-0.0436161272,
-0.0162131861,
0.0133559434,
-0.0052625351,
0.0685945004,
-0.0368641056,
0.0076742936,
-0.0083389925,
-0.033756718,
-0.0096428432,
0.0022418571,
0.0328520164,
0.0751712173,
0.0012175617,
0.0351016857,
-0.0056663943,
0.0010038373,
-0.0332557261,
-0.0249427482,
0.0105864191,
0.0296101328,
-0.0319514684,
0.0341631435,
0.0353304558,
-0.0312172603,
0.0509613194,
-0.0342254825,
-0.0265467241,
0.0389868617,
0.0482404716,
0.0442796089,
0.0314702727,
-0.0183288623,
-0.0691343173,
0.0093613723,
0.0151185934,
0.029047206,
0.0294251777,
-0.0428895988,
0.0470069833,
-0.005217771,
0.0444541648,
0.070626311,
0.0041385302,
0.021993652,
-0.0213019345,
-0.0279167313,
0.012902353,
0.0551717952,
-0.0099320477,
-0.0209857021,
0.0240768827,
-0.0133923357,
-0.019848872,
-0.0242891014,
0.0485830642,
0.0761398897,
-0.0389823355,
0.033014629,
2.69181158e-34,
-0.0153719084,
-0.0587320141,
-0.0136628188,
0.0117617948,
0.0041448446,
0.0470757857,
-0.0153873581,
-0.0521052219,
0.0461090393,
-0.0137221823,
-0.0139123313
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03042v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03042v1 | Inherent limitations of LLMs regarding spatial information | 2023-12-05T16:02:20 | 2023-12-05T16:02:20 | He Yan, Xinyao Hu, Xiangpeng Wan, Chengyu Huang, Kai Zou, Shiqi Xu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Despite the significant advancements in natural language processing
capabilities demonstrated by large language models such as ChatGPT, their
proficiency in comprehending and processing spatial information, especially
within the domains of 2D and 3D route planning, remains notably underdeveloped.
This paper investigates the inherent limitations of ChatGPT and similar models
in spatial reasoning and navigation-related tasks, an area critical for
applications ranging from autonomous vehicle guidance to assistive technologies
for the visually impaired. In this paper, we introduce a novel evaluation
framework complemented by a baseline dataset, meticulously crafted for this
study. This dataset is structured around three key tasks: plotting spatial
points, planning routes in two-dimensional (2D) spaces, and devising pathways
in three-dimensional (3D) environments. We specifically developed this dataset
to assess the spatial reasoning abilities of ChatGPT. Our evaluation reveals
key insights into the model's capabilities and limitations in spatial
understanding. | [
0.0362690091,
0.0182257891,
-0.0029608582,
0.0417092331,
-0.0544395708,
0.0398784876,
0.0128592839,
-0.0248359498,
0.0291359648,
-0.034869276,
-0.0301455222,
0.0024883992,
0.0269678142,
0.0292059463,
0.0190131254,
-0.0654981807,
0.0248173419,
-0.0680632815,
-0.0217345413,
0.0021851838,
-0.0507019907,
-0.0015273481,
-0.0487849936,
0.037893571,
-0.0181502588,
0.0027761112,
-0.010211166,
-0.0133793568,
0.0028435776,
-0.0880919024,
-0.0194280706,
-0.0013160857,
0.0835558027,
-0.0022531436,
0.0000017133,
-0.0198374204,
0.0062457188,
-0.0073710452,
0.0140941413,
-0.0244229138,
0.0113412375,
-0.0114497375,
0.0212006718,
0.0014513339,
-0.0340305232,
-0.0007927465,
0.0211703405,
0.0341676362,
0.0397646017,
0.049483262,
-0.0082810391,
-0.0387047306,
0.0135955112,
0.0039121178,
0.0534927398,
-0.0160513185,
-0.0130424928,
0.0297814384,
0.0211368073,
0.0518404022,
-0.0298238732,
0.0173860639,
0.0339020602,
0.0428922772,
-0.0016133914,
0.0563961901,
-0.0130935544,
0.0202629846,
-0.0278797094,
0.0559903868,
0.0058849133,
-0.0179005582,
0.0258421861,
0.0210522749,
-0.0019186835,
0.0058472375,
-0.0724288225,
-0.0106023774,
-0.0060546398,
0.0139435846,
-0.0301490165,
-0.0206856281,
0.0055187242,
-0.0073880251,
-0.0150026698,
0.0991016477,
-0.0090376688,
-0.010788261,
-0.0207220707,
-0.0066075907,
-0.022049984,
-0.0443313047,
-0.0002799261,
0.0448065698,
-0.0234806035,
0.0193017349,
0.0090519488,
0.0983516052,
-0.0102777164,
-0.0709433109,
0.0552539825,
0.0375385471,
-0.0211000871,
0.0701522902,
-0.0573443808,
0.074708119,
-0.0136850663,
0.0773456842,
0.0078354096,
0.0059034722,
-0.0360305756,
0.0132328467,
-0.0299268477,
0.0139669674,
-0.0405052453,
-0.0110408347,
0.0113204392,
0.0391771086,
0.0007739548,
0.030667441,
-0.0116268778,
0.0549976639,
0.0244101882,
-0.0150573701,
-0.0398231782,
-0.0142516838,
-0.0161585789,
0.0197641682,
-0.0345963649,
-0.0260808878,
0.0141986683,
0.0133419307,
-0.0104990592,
-0.0213906784,
-0.0063068126,
0.1321397424,
0.0283361338,
-0.0479956977,
-0.0545345731,
-0.0133283595,
-0.0229876842,
-0.0607298166,
0.0524212606,
-0.0880243257,
0.0117007568,
0.020028051,
-0.0423597507,
-0.016765926,
0.0029975181,
0.0072595393,
-0.0207108147,
0.0642112866,
0.0070947828,
0.0131219439,
0.0450295471,
0.0055783088,
0.0180767868,
0.058763396,
0.0736059099,
0.0531059317,
0.0078507597,
0.0371942781,
-0.0071825315,
0.0285868943,
-0.0359112658,
0.0017466749,
-0.0429824367,
0.0278067365,
-0.0375956967,
0.0673708245,
-0.0050258823,
0.0441356935,
-0.0297331922,
-0.0225906223,
0.0213043783,
0.0929825604,
0.0326421373,
-0.0103111891,
0.0426975042,
0.0102180755,
-0.0268096477,
-0.0301112644,
-0.0604090318,
0.0345016904,
-0.0204361193,
-0.0124503486,
-0.007849223,
0.0212417226,
0.004287174,
-0.0687855184,
-0.0422685668,
0.023715416,
0.0260458328,
-0.0316281877,
0.0390128233,
-0.0405120552,
-0.0234639831,
0.0279197209,
-0.0039901817,
-0.0175940525,
-0.0144341039,
-0.0034725545,
-0.0179103278,
0.036766462,
0.0262120888,
0.0056353463,
-0.0566488057,
0.0047347876,
0.0385491326,
-0.0068605174,
0.05341639,
0.0080910996,
-0.0006472958,
-0.0336833484,
-0.0807499886,
0.0186285973,
0.0175307002,
0.0217630602,
0.0599131621,
0.0137836412,
0.0158566162,
-0.0831080377,
0.014515412,
0.0173497982,
0.0108536948,
-0.0284004752,
-0.0576308146,
0.0118298903,
-0.0020368244,
-0.0170755684,
-0.0018812513,
0.0104182735,
0.0183462147,
0.0164568499,
0.0063189459,
0.0358948819,
-0.0372312963,
-0.0427724458,
0.0155892922,
-0.0462125763,
-0.0296295639,
0.0386726744,
-0.050920397,
-0.0132687874,
-0.0127412491,
-0.047180254,
-0.0063676992,
0.017423939,
-0.0008392515,
0.0517542958,
-0.0326305628,
-0.0604441874,
0.0513049178,
-0.0244403034,
0.0293116216,
-0.0053697866,
0.026909152,
0.0499738827,
-0.0207317322,
0.0237911586,
-0.0186259169,
0.0112120146,
-0.0136427265,
-0.0204404574,
0.0470825396,
-0.0236838255,
-0.0455179028,
-0.0581167825,
-0.0143410908,
-0.000411487,
0.0321889371,
-0.0023407976,
-0.0718443617,
-0.0346426442,
-0.0102196131,
-0.0074707814,
0.0090515288,
0.0135755427,
-0.0013258769,
0.0215916559,
-0.0341108851,
-0.0240499433,
-0.0303052347,
-0.0090532564,
-0.0565617643,
-0.0032800694,
0.0415565558,
-0.0486838035,
-0.0178106539,
0.0159748718,
-0.0413458422,
0.0298658479,
-0.0186952278,
-0.0066918861,
0.0522073247,
-0.03156152,
0.0031747313,
0.016617028,
-0.0232875347,
0.0187344849,
0.0422690101,
-0.0509882048,
-0.0494797193,
0.0345677286,
-0.033536084,
0.0051253075,
-0.0456787758,
-0.0381295346,
-0.0366783738,
0.0412453525,
-0.0050990903,
0.0120196566,
-0.0183313508,
-0.0090262517,
-0.0347878672,
-0.0070635448,
-0.0370482579,
0.0561508425,
0.0085389242,
0.0551918074,
-0.0394693986,
-0.0414242186,
0.010439584,
-0.0569517761,
0.0046444619,
-0.0214917511,
0.0270655528,
-0.0533363111,
0.1018024385,
0.0312530473,
-0.0129879229,
-0.0310590584,
-0.0259029344,
-0.0110258497,
-0.0209011752,
-0.0207300521,
0.007545576,
0.0506164841,
-0.0988374203,
0.0246470552,
-0.0038486526,
-0.0307264309,
-0.026036609,
0.0091148932,
-0.030048646,
0.0002984525,
-0.0177909434,
-0.0460496247,
0.0057134684,
0.0306434687,
0.0323915705,
0.0474434756,
-0.028935587,
-0.0360409468,
-0.03213761,
0.0025248309,
0.0437058657,
0.0926789045,
-0.0056463112,
-0.0128924418,
-0.0171216298,
0.0471728109,
-0.0398449562,
0.0087867342,
-0.0367447473,
0.0745294541,
0.0397291966,
0.0111748856,
-0.0159075186,
0.0466868803,
0.0841929466,
-0.0760315806,
-0.0686280057,
0.0869698301,
0.0590209141,
0.0253577866,
-0.0004326877,
-0.0390438996,
0.0120348027,
0.0329027735,
-0.005760883,
-0.0369929783,
-0.028511731,
0.0016025581,
-0.0251028668,
0.0204267185,
-0.0287141688,
0.0204088911,
-0.0804980993,
0.0784791186,
0.0036353075,
-0.0698040798,
-0.031413395,
-0.0238651335,
-0.0359051898,
0.00284381,
-0.0145766344,
-0.0350729227,
-0.0205889102,
0.0114613418,
0.0320672244,
-0.0602355376,
0.0051613348,
0.0169178359,
-0.0082417196,
0.0478147902,
0.0092793461,
0.0435068943,
0.0017686525,
-0.0495902896,
0.0419383869,
0.0831596553,
0.0552407987,
-0.0471941829,
0.0275883619,
0.0172127914,
0.0010288247,
-0.0109146079,
-0.0102961967,
-0.0315407999,
-0.0393727869,
0.0016078833,
0.0654406622,
-0.0625525638,
0.0354047418,
-0.0363585018,
0.037698783,
-0.0351077616,
0.0354128107,
0.0187638998,
0.0479964092,
-0.0861574113,
-0.0640932918,
-0.0377057791,
-0.0375293121,
-0.0515270308,
0.0198321007,
0.0402306058,
-0.0031417562,
-0.0476664491,
-0.0392291993,
0.0418642871,
0.0386410393,
-0.0180067252,
-0.0231544189,
-0.0048653409,
-0.0094543332,
-0.0451511219,
0.0659799054,
-0.0232674871,
0.0146095203,
-0.0134229409,
0.0469616093,
-0.0095386617,
-0.0439835005,
-0.0288457014,
0.0158118997,
-0.0669172183,
-0.0410987213,
0.0048287846,
0.0528768599,
0.0231088903,
-0.0012135031,
-0.0141462581,
-0.0085043907,
0.0308618248,
0.0235945564,
-0.0007062291,
0.0292713437,
0.025343895,
0.0856501013,
0.0154181654,
-0.0136577683,
-0.0152712353,
0.0035251144,
0.0217762031,
0.000118288,
-0.0349698514,
0.0219875518,
-0.0058373981,
-0.0041324385,
0.1073911041,
0.0368138961,
0.027018832,
-0.0228451323,
0.0102561079,
-0.0436298028,
0.025715895,
-0.0528521053,
0.0245793965,
0.0202601627,
0.0358960032,
-0.0041900328,
-0.0256159138,
0.0060847136,
-0.0141480025,
-0.0249684211,
0.0159285683,
0.0349078998,
-0.0375907049,
-0.0005414368,
-0.0030750362,
-0.0224752743,
0.0213200506,
-0.0453475825,
0.0197834689,
0.0250065755,
0.0463108793,
0.0284349807,
0.0056181974,
-0.0265114903,
0.0251934081,
-0.0642796904,
-0.1077140868,
0.0083400123,
0.0776624531,
0.0756112188,
-0.0027153478,
-0.003823783,
-0.0407075882,
0.0242425203,
0.0139706153,
-0.0169608518,
0.0396658368,
-0.0161121879,
0.0755503923,
0.0205137134,
-0.020233281,
-0.0571163036,
0.0352122523,
0.0238196421,
0.0538965575,
0.0060994281,
-0.0168334879,
-0.0307579059,
-0.0331152752,
0.0067362497,
0.0043214234,
-0.0002181404,
0.0283525568,
-0.0315087438,
-0.0492635407,
-0.0094330963,
0.0655325949,
0.0053951475,
-0.0084287981,
0.0357469618,
-0.0002595506,
-0.0145791015,
-0.0588570759,
-0.0158670805,
-0.038864594,
0.0040304558,
-0.0352195427,
-0.0055986126,
-5.531795967e-33,
-0.0189156756,
-0.0637420118,
0.1043747813,
-0.0085789757,
-0.0011747857,
-0.0177940764,
-0.0334401615,
0.0231147408,
-0.0335985497,
-0.0114100585,
-0.0114124864,
-0.0123692742,
0.0228228141,
0.0237434879,
0.0061326264,
-0.0211734436,
0.0080413194,
0.024804851,
-0.0227257647,
-0.0264696702,
0.0275560282,
-0.0106945559,
0.0508444831,
-0.0394474976,
0.0044814846,
0.0215154402,
-0.0121902525,
0.0270248316,
-0.04324333,
0.0559563674,
-0.0099301161,
-0.0094838087,
0.0393391177,
-0.0130437408,
-0.0436181687,
0.0069818273,
-0.0488774106,
-0.0506409854,
-0.0007349556,
0.0394094996,
-0.0553944483,
-0.0151111269,
0.0472368598,
0.0092158318,
-0.0268473066,
-0.0180728957,
0.0384049974,
-0.0148676476,
-0.0267389324,
0.0622037761,
-0.0003051429,
0.0418973304,
-0.0124614071,
-0.0355233699,
0.0285495725,
0.0205438416,
0.0216817055,
-0.0043330858,
-0.0280855019,
0.0135990847,
0.0085506355,
0.0312440731,
0.0425591357,
0.0055827834,
0.0248665735,
0.0791552886,
0.0321942642,
-0.0325832404,
-0.0404110476,
-0.0334294736,
0.0211315081,
0.0759665892,
0.0088433158,
0.011185471,
-0.0013675692,
0.0396067426,
-0.0490582474,
0.026416,
-0.0706597641,
0.0670531094,
-0.0000240131,
-0.0130667035,
-0.0581956692,
-0.0014874786,
-0.034006957,
0.0069028214,
0.0012324183,
0.0012273761,
0.0330054425,
-0.0102201896,
0.0607705116,
0.0065194331,
0.0309107024,
-0.0298179239,
-0.0305737481,
-0.0043146405,
0.0146623198,
0.0282867681,
-0.0006594418,
0.0492164828,
-0.0784086883,
-0.0245653894,
-0.0145460274,
0.0025095532,
0.0045668194,
-0.0094473185,
-0.0224438012,
0.0113160675,
-0.037209399,
-0.0177886579,
-0.0666153729,
-0.0180498678,
0.0068842401,
0.0055017825,
0.0698100552,
-0.0230876822,
-0.0203214325,
0.0646738559,
-0.046887517,
-0.0481491536,
-0.0006847024,
-0.0241898336,
-0.0582424104,
0.0264143925,
-0.017369261,
0.009784217,
-0.0254310202,
-0.0105597209,
0.0089242673,
-0.0544205084,
-0.0037687772,
0.0268167593,
2.566e-7,
0.0375237092,
0.0667344853,
0.0104213953,
0.0271374155,
0.0028812683,
0.0214462541,
-0.0214646682,
0.0011162199,
-0.0271624625,
0.0229740217,
0.0260406565,
0.0775161013,
0.0200043917,
0.0144397607,
-0.0630455613,
0.0439405218,
-0.0106414286,
-0.0179085117,
-0.0488633998,
0.0423747376,
0.1073068976,
0.0229364056,
-0.0232029334,
0.0028521654,
-0.0299962033,
-0.0288868099,
0.0042938539,
-0.0687418431,
0.0200359505,
0.0022048862,
0.0762266293,
0.026594121,
-0.0055316864,
-0.0209826678,
0.0017362532,
-0.0277318936,
-0.0152781857,
0.0685020536,
-0.0068043596,
-0.0301054977,
0.0289678238,
-0.0508801267,
-0.0403345786,
-0.0689207315,
0.071407713,
-0.0700208247,
-0.012752315,
0.0146813747,
0.0458966009,
0.0063991076,
0.0097358972,
0.0276090391,
0.0029379483,
-0.0625939071,
0.0276014041,
-0.0175535921,
-0.0000349154,
-0.0737329796,
-0.0115710692,
0.0430186354,
-0.013253672,
-0.0271353479,
-0.0289294887,
0.0285186898,
0.0241319295,
0.0026205401,
-0.0837671086,
1.697825151e-34,
0.0035451816,
-0.0030754944,
-0.0029757922,
-0.0364449359,
0.0170793794,
-0.0012353685,
0.0201050323,
0.013679387,
-0.0151952514,
-0.0319536887,
0.0078574913
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.02820v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.02820v1 | Clustering Pseudo Language Family in Multilingual Translation Models with Fisher Information Matrix | 2023-12-05T15:03:27 | 2023-12-05T15:03:27 | Xinyu Ma, Xuebo Liu, Min Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In multilingual translation research, the comprehension and utilization of
language families are of paramount importance. Nevertheless, clustering
languages based solely on their ancestral families can yield suboptimal results
due to variations in the datasets employed during the model's training phase.
To mitigate this challenge, we introduce an innovative method that leverages
the fisher information matrix (FIM) to cluster language families, anchored on
the multilingual translation model's characteristics. We hypothesize that
language pairs with similar effects on model parameters exhibit a considerable
degree of linguistic congruence and should thus be grouped cohesively. This
concept has led us to define pseudo language families. We provide an in-depth
discussion regarding the inception and application of these pseudo language
families. Empirical evaluations reveal that employing these pseudo language
families enhances performance over conventional language families in adapting a
multilingual translation model to unfamiliar language pairs. The proposed
methodology may also be extended to scenarios requiring language similarity
measurements. The source code and associated scripts can be accessed at
https://github.com/ecoli-hit/PseudoFamily. | [
0.0340703689,
0.027095722,
-0.0426631235,
0.0546574853,
-0.051025264,
0.0251062997,
0.058751706,
0.0370717831,
-0.0476049706,
-0.0108832167,
-0.074249655,
-0.071339801,
0.0523716211,
-0.0407597013,
0.0444649979,
-0.0430917069,
0.0272325817,
-0.0031062397,
0.0041903774,
0.0027391224,
-0.0202831794,
0.0090943864,
0.0384173393,
0.0392595418,
0.0241567679,
-0.0091779567,
0.0322930701,
0.0447822586,
0.0653914362,
0.011359008,
-0.0110806348,
0.0347263925,
0.0303996447,
0.1152528077,
0.0000018981,
-0.036420051,
-0.043814484,
0.0080738747,
0.0223750323,
0.0144780539,
0.0860351399,
-0.0457407497,
0.0348478518,
0.0016721546,
-0.005575994,
-0.0580448955,
0.0460450687,
-0.0123550622,
-0.0163524728,
0.0464955159,
-0.0138095059,
-0.0448900163,
-0.0231526289,
-0.0257572625,
-0.0069467877,
-0.0212382134,
0.0062300591,
0.0557765327,
-0.0457542092,
-0.0068255849,
0.0052741021,
0.0374563895,
-0.0061359797,
0.0315243192,
-0.021218814,
-0.0019765957,
-0.0067946543,
-0.0339284167,
0.0149965389,
0.0299483445,
-0.0442323349,
-0.0223816205,
-0.0005944711,
0.0009153046,
-0.0078746229,
0.0062536993,
-0.0305643324,
-0.0013809698,
-0.0228405949,
-0.0113278944,
0.0815610588,
0.0468122661,
0.0118341101,
-0.0310325194,
-0.043200098,
0.0556095056,
0.0516772233,
0.0261897128,
-0.0313087814,
-0.0194464363,
-0.0080103725,
0.0172684994,
0.0229600947,
-0.0290508885,
0.0140291164,
0.0118409498,
-0.0118109826,
-0.047917787,
0.0451280959,
-0.0637154207,
0.0359246358,
0.0616954826,
0.0012524426,
0.0245426726,
0.0077374387,
0.0372267812,
-0.0038761226,
0.0144439349,
-0.0895004123,
-0.0159071777,
-0.0575930402,
0.0378562734,
-0.0196687076,
-0.0322807766,
-0.0662308559,
0.0041237096,
0.0033647823,
0.0226052199,
0.0107487375,
-0.0197440442,
-0.0062366189,
-0.0566897057,
-0.0301297884,
-0.0076552629,
0.0279268976,
0.038255848,
0.0079888385,
-0.0208587833,
-0.0441070497,
-0.0399359502,
0.0226593222,
0.0179644078,
-0.0325082541,
-0.0356480144,
-0.0254816283,
0.0180702265,
-0.015762195,
-0.0283969939,
-0.0403199643,
-0.0085377106,
-0.0268684495,
-0.0666132197,
-0.0057667028,
-0.0538460836,
0.08343862,
0.0021652039,
0.0177207813,
-0.0577135347,
-0.0376980007,
-0.0404716097,
-0.0313102901,
0.0410396196,
-0.0026479256,
0.0194102526,
0.0643313304,
-0.0258171558,
0.0148485899,
0.0652969703,
0.0176611785,
-0.0497566201,
0.0763622448,
0.005691031,
-0.0463684909,
0.0564993992,
-0.0213309824,
0.0667668805,
-0.0406901874,
-0.0080852732,
0.041827783,
-0.0115296794,
0.0208444726,
0.0373782925,
-0.007418518,
0.0067379628,
0.0113995112,
0.0168075729,
-0.0090194307,
0.063040711,
0.036011599,
0.0286634769,
-0.0136076631,
0.0008704134,
0.0260225423,
-0.0026058478,
-0.0319859087,
0.007499137,
0.0591160618,
0.0612511709,
0.005875072,
-0.018067034,
-0.0088720638,
0.007352232,
0.0285490509,
-0.0128101455,
0.0485187545,
-0.0082717966,
-0.0017659424,
-0.0151676172,
0.037379045,
-0.0328433327,
0.0237550009,
-0.0098585412,
-0.0114625469,
0.0723591,
0.0212343745,
-0.0157258399,
-0.0450405665,
0.0083026011,
-0.0164626651,
0.0195680074,
0.0290687699,
-0.0090656588,
0.0242148265,
-0.044531282,
-0.0182582587,
0.0483901538,
0.0248772465,
0.0403302722,
-0.0477039889,
0.0209356677,
0.0191281363,
-0.0613120086,
-0.0647393167,
0.039431002,
-0.0422244109,
0.0359363854,
0.0247674659,
-0.0038565332,
0.0330620855,
0.0016246894,
-0.0111015057,
-0.0210686475,
0.0180343054,
-0.0261430349,
0.0390477441,
0.0262046084,
0.0228548925,
-0.0331904069,
0.0217115581,
0.0033096701,
0.0269927736,
-0.0235756785,
-0.0196158439,
-0.0476742461,
0.0016078136,
-0.0014586183,
0.0660036057,
-0.0061689466,
0.0561307706,
-0.0497993194,
-0.0017061302,
-0.0532439351,
0.0370556004,
-0.0053646178,
0.0260418393,
-0.0289274082,
-0.0394160748,
0.0179138724,
-0.0761179775,
-0.0093046119,
0.0260432102,
-0.0067840442,
0.0016329543,
0.0337437466,
0.0106221447,
-0.0078779412,
-0.0027623447,
-0.0885296315,
0.0135688893,
-0.0390371494,
0.0293938518,
0.0536839329,
0.0077680745,
-0.0154181216,
0.0209130868,
-0.0146134747,
0.0258736052,
0.0105681466,
0.02202392,
-0.0338648744,
-0.021453172,
-0.0284142531,
-0.0393192619,
-0.0146772908,
0.0204908811,
0.0853064358,
0.0011763108,
-0.0210511629,
-0.0765270367,
0.0258141067,
-0.0804661065,
-0.0424222797,
-0.0114161512,
0.0012258491,
-0.0143914958,
0.0043038456,
0.0432330854,
-0.0092191361,
0.0076610036,
-0.0485280268,
0.0432383418,
-0.0250079855,
-0.0353776217,
-0.0059695081,
-0.0158072803,
0.0023851846,
-0.0041489555,
-0.1117527708,
0.0097257281,
-0.0070954645,
0.0361989103,
-0.0392547026,
-0.0457916223,
-0.0216738451,
-0.0288910847,
0.0171060786,
-0.0200938173,
0.0114905853,
0.0421415195,
0.0546076596,
-0.0472495593,
-0.0744587258,
0.0268429555,
-0.0322156996,
-0.0151742306,
-0.0606372952,
-0.0182637163,
-0.0287511908,
0.0512160696,
0.0096890135,
0.0082835173,
0.0053880047,
0.0169887878,
-0.0048813443,
0.0289242137,
0.0161912125,
-0.0133039532,
0.0562860891,
-0.0537434742,
-0.004339234,
0.0295478161,
0.0620937869,
-0.0032378675,
0.0112881213,
0.0080331229,
-0.0239157192,
0.0216943827,
-0.032242652,
-0.0105123492,
0.043461524,
0.0197403952,
0.0405038595,
-0.0012834565,
0.0120745013,
-0.003776486,
0.0363365822,
-0.0236126557,
-0.0466220602,
-0.0034045277,
-0.0502764285,
0.0252696518,
-0.0268949475,
0.0370280631,
-0.0241847783,
-0.0164460205,
-0.0425487757,
0.0251400974,
0.029296672,
-0.0548449866,
0.001803787,
0.0193059705,
0.0147233959,
-0.0112968516,
0.1005971581,
0.0567978881,
-0.0553954802,
0.0071799918,
-0.0288623106,
0.0820799246,
0.020184638,
-0.0019008857,
-0.0061317226,
0.0145802135,
0.0170334242,
0.0154146431,
0.0430185199,
-0.0046577156,
-0.027862791,
-0.0328569114,
0.0246087071,
0.0506464429,
-0.1108820513,
-0.0724293143,
-0.0255051889,
-0.0132637257,
-0.0527950712,
0.0375885032,
0.0089201247,
0.0261456762,
-0.0015521649,
-0.0054596509,
0.0156480148,
-0.0454652086,
-0.0041093072,
-0.0673251972,
0.0297754668,
0.0128751267,
0.0312568359,
0.0089080269,
-0.0310800783,
-0.0094546126,
-0.0640614629,
-0.0450761467,
-0.0256247818,
0.0085406303,
0.0408450998,
0.0125624267,
0.0307995006,
0.012336323,
-0.0522451289,
-0.0156543013,
0.0119768186,
0.0231785607,
-0.0313118212,
-0.0119501501,
0.0402744114,
-0.0094091678,
0.0010555354,
0.0444881096,
0.0066613704,
-0.0223381706,
0.0717858523,
-0.0082384609,
0.0087259859,
0.0176472105,
0.0229833368,
-0.0006938187,
-0.0584804527,
-0.0347659215,
-0.0811534226,
-0.0165197253,
0.014279902,
0.0301388521,
0.0296738707,
0.0191350058,
-0.0362517349,
-0.0301095229,
-0.013176729,
0.0214524008,
-0.0407377556,
-0.0141756702,
-0.0076794247,
-0.0231955089,
0.0248735007,
-0.0205446035,
-0.0174185932,
0.0203191675,
-0.0506540686,
-0.0884047151,
-0.0190154277,
0.0464296155,
0.0234930776,
0.0074062897,
0.0167909265,
0.0062254025,
0.0063842637,
-0.0082610957,
-0.0147569263,
0.0074466038,
0.0016254854,
-0.0287001282,
0.0016265437,
0.0387292244,
-0.0144909769,
-0.028028205,
-0.0166587494,
0.0506296046,
-0.0703182742,
-0.0723851025,
0.0036386102,
0.0071406798,
0.0337046832,
-0.0579108857,
-0.0963323563,
-0.0580315106,
-0.015637096,
-0.0199226085,
0.0017020709,
-0.0175421555,
-0.0241236463,
0.0419698842,
0.015136919,
-0.0063838037,
0.0271715019,
-0.0406353064,
-0.0164468642,
0.0361742862,
-0.0028642197,
-0.0432946049,
0.0496497862,
-0.0181128159,
0.0282824468,
-0.0034572342,
0.0127058187,
-0.0426911674,
0.0259076692,
-0.0242284779,
0.0552280992,
-0.0201099031,
-0.0001538712,
-0.0420432873,
0.036513187,
-0.0120080039,
-0.0180253722,
-0.01224552,
-0.0101840692,
0.0590855777,
-0.0100348908,
0.0997099802,
-0.0066755251,
-0.000038561,
-0.0244766511,
0.0455652028,
0.0130998138,
-0.0574123673,
0.0025167738,
-0.0058298311,
-0.0078951344,
0.0472558588,
0.0681716949,
-0.0024837451,
-0.0063385586,
-0.0047274348,
-0.0207705051,
-0.0141188949,
-0.0065434999,
0.0261087529,
0.0168892313,
-0.0293190796,
-0.0318937451,
-0.0507058986,
-0.0341810808,
0.0269348025,
0.031594716,
-0.0092719411,
0.0065515628,
0.0174358245,
0.077827163,
-0.0670348033,
0.0004419707,
-0.0459572598,
-0.0304506421,
0.0143723823,
-0.0160807725,
-0.0423458219,
-5.718720507e-33,
-0.0146894129,
-0.0185816586,
-0.0297589842,
-0.038866248,
0.0087848622,
-0.032075949,
-0.0067411014,
0.0120789651,
0.0098347859,
-0.0177607723,
0.0324699916,
-0.0218952149,
0.0098304516,
-0.0132281799,
-0.0144873522,
0.0281732064,
0.022196833,
0.0015692168,
0.0019122276,
0.0354330391,
0.0573399514,
0.0074263955,
0.1000436395,
-0.0247234982,
0.0654211193,
-0.0421758294,
0.0025897818,
0.0103491312,
0.0047612833,
0.0274612736,
-0.0115624992,
0.0182809141,
0.0384474136,
0.0143488226,
-0.0249815546,
-0.0661869198,
-0.0466665365,
-0.0014026696,
0.054381907,
0.0264626183,
0.0145373773,
-0.0644871294,
0.0801157877,
-0.046076145,
-0.0115898242,
0.0109514138,
0.0328679159,
-0.0492365956,
-0.0479649901,
0.0437089354,
-0.0725815892,
0.0170726813,
-0.010092943,
0.0240057521,
0.0320273526,
0.0875137523,
-0.0217685942,
-0.0089311711,
-0.0729247406,
0.0132300006,
-0.0256197564,
0.0233330205,
0.0685726404,
0.0477701947,
0.0085184155,
0.013606282,
0.0533302948,
0.0134614566,
0.0355163179,
0.0151655851,
0.0678961352,
-0.0134603307,
0.0511558056,
0.0656335801,
0.0068235258,
-0.024599364,
-0.0423191078,
0.0611587949,
-0.0235473923,
-0.0431326739,
0.0321408547,
0.0490098521,
-0.0157077126,
-0.0078595011,
-0.0772518665,
-0.0907462686,
-0.0235477742,
-0.0120690102,
-0.0210770667,
-0.018301582,
-0.0575927608,
-0.0391105302,
0.1193296835,
0.0058057969,
-0.0078046625,
0.0120558506,
-0.0036862488,
0.0316102728,
-0.0091576679,
0.0636190623,
0.0139839603,
-0.090057537,
0.0074578403,
-0.0078748884,
-0.0108153298,
-0.0474804901,
0.029031137,
0.0034426912,
-0.0488934964,
0.0335022509,
-0.005301916,
-0.0232572332,
-0.0026804386,
-0.0063216374,
0.0182928722,
0.013999192,
-0.0084730024,
0.0104829557,
0.0907577574,
-0.0193567425,
-0.0330080613,
0.0107923467,
-0.0382692032,
0.0490164012,
-0.0173455831,
0.0183654632,
-0.0185138118,
-0.0161285046,
0.0640548095,
-0.0107733514,
-0.0132960798,
0.0064805644,
2.602e-7,
0.0573435053,
0.0404037572,
-0.0209522508,
-0.0231850762,
0.0171454512,
0.004675163,
-0.0054423604,
0.0008184659,
0.0307142157,
-0.0039439797,
0.0428143404,
0.0417406,
0.0675274655,
0.0184653234,
-0.0102513339,
-0.0274772961,
-0.0010599375,
0.0063400916,
-0.0378997549,
-0.0032481705,
-0.0205236375,
0.1301820427,
0.0018394124,
-0.002654861,
-0.0065856948,
-0.0341393426,
0.0680362359,
-0.0817547441,
-0.0277743787,
0.0364952832,
-0.0110918526,
0.0106879752,
-0.0158681646,
0.0198553931,
0.0062150746,
0.0112704337,
0.0140102003,
0.0264424775,
-0.0093794605,
0.0216107517,
0.0230946168,
0.0179735888,
-0.034006007,
-0.0821764097,
0.0042781606,
0.0014782362,
0.0012904417,
0.0265763886,
-0.0012888913,
0.0766292736,
0.0628415048,
-0.0541411974,
-0.0445721596,
0.0632456616,
0.0411350615,
-0.01117149,
-0.0113679748,
0.0324350037,
-0.0232531112,
0.036914032,
-0.0531541705,
-0.009616618,
0.0056020762,
-0.0303091165,
-0.0018989736,
-0.0070177331,
0.0319816843,
2.341095952e-34,
0.0253718048,
-0.0113561293,
-0.0235813819,
-0.0321949907,
0.0343557596,
-0.0536740273,
-0.0601812825,
0.0217697788,
-0.0231137276,
-0.0662178323,
-0.0053499108
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.02803v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.02803v1 | Leveraging Domain Adaptation and Data Augmentation to Improve Qur'anic IR in English and Arabic | 2023-12-05T14:44:08 | 2023-12-05T14:44:08 | Vera Pavlova | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In this work, we approach the problem of Qur'anic information retrieval (IR)
in Arabic and English. Using the latest state-of-the-art methods in neural IR,
we research what helps to tackle this task more efficiently. Training retrieval
models requires a lot of data, which is difficult to obtain for training
in-domain. Therefore, we commence with training on a large amount of general
domain data and then continue training on in-domain data. To handle the lack of
in-domain data, we employed a data augmentation technique, which considerably
improved results in MRR@10 and NDCG@5 metrics, setting the state-of-the-art in
Qur'anic IR for both English and Arabic. The absence of an Islamic corpus and
domain-specific model for IR task in English motivated us to address this lack
of resources and take preliminary steps of the Islamic corpus compilation and
domain-specific language model (LM) pre-training, which helped to improve the
performance of the retrieval models that use the domain-specific LM as the
shared backbone. We examined several language models (LMs) in Arabic to select
one that efficiently deals with the Qur'anic IR task. Besides transferring
successful experiments from English to Arabic, we conducted additional
experiments with retrieval task in Arabic to amortize the scarcity of general
domain datasets used to train the retrieval models. Handling Qur'anic IR task
combining English and Arabic allowed us to enhance the comparison and share
valuable insights across models and languages. | [
0.0596437156,
0.0610882714,
-0.0131332511,
0.0222038049,
-0.0450342037,
0.0464876443,
0.0310394708,
0.0229088701,
-0.033945784,
-0.0259978157,
-0.0450635403,
-0.0374138877,
0.0250372179,
-0.0508556217,
0.0236184727,
-0.0023033291,
0.0484683998,
-0.0447417535,
-0.0211331379,
0.0199592076,
0.0175532568,
0.0257855281,
-0.0059091076,
0.0078832116,
0.0020244324,
-0.0305508487,
-0.0369854122,
-0.0089997519,
0.005947839,
-0.0156262256,
0.0111189904,
0.0304106176,
0.0274818782,
0.0482753143,
0.0000019215,
-0.058823172,
-0.0366922207,
-0.0017078267,
-0.0067782728,
-0.024632182,
0.0539121628,
-0.0476910621,
0.0020942434,
-0.044730287,
-0.0196541101,
-0.0280403737,
0.0167211518,
0.080135338,
0.0217084866,
0.0670489371,
0.0198627077,
-0.0908118114,
0.0390028767,
-0.0414066836,
0.0102789309,
-0.0153988246,
-0.0022650319,
0.0232113432,
0.0036836988,
0.0563264042,
-0.0582057349,
0.0065280874,
0.0161716677,
-0.0308125522,
-0.0126699563,
-0.0380657315,
-0.0348056518,
-0.000305724,
0.053238973,
-0.016798526,
0.002394567,
-0.0326169878,
-0.000449801,
0.0480636731,
0.0168588702,
0.0285848975,
-0.0415710621,
0.0001776119,
-0.0593879521,
-0.0225351267,
-0.0063461936,
0.0092337821,
0.0351910777,
0.0006846194,
-0.0561408363,
0.0452985242,
0.0053373659,
-0.0429751761,
0.0367908552,
0.0006476406,
-0.0295216087,
0.0229486153,
0.0137621565,
-0.0256126337,
0.0297014769,
-0.0329843722,
-0.0124532506,
-0.0586460307,
0.0096783144,
-0.0532205142,
0.0178576726,
0.0788573399,
-0.0159252286,
0.0099636465,
-0.0457187593,
0.0301007237,
0.0353327468,
0.0135072488,
-0.0741170049,
0.0100907488,
-0.0422786437,
0.0234199278,
-0.0497513562,
0.0537259579,
-0.0620641746,
0.0226354357,
-0.0686704814,
0.0123410998,
0.020298494,
-0.0370617881,
0.0011500762,
-0.0462172441,
-0.0450603999,
-0.020193046,
-0.0076134945,
-0.0047075227,
-0.0221382231,
0.0007126922,
-0.0409014262,
-0.0802255571,
0.0079162512,
0.0105482507,
-0.0157184377,
-0.0371170193,
0.001614101,
0.0970753506,
-0.0147236241,
-0.051025752,
-0.0455568433,
0.0252300724,
0.0210003089,
-0.0216954835,
0.0271786284,
-0.0485897921,
0.0408331752,
0.0081181061,
-0.0088428846,
-0.0037835427,
-0.0151346931,
0.0374236666,
0.0244134273,
0.0736533701,
0.0353777707,
-0.0234165564,
0.1022526324,
0.0045640697,
0.0171527527,
0.036837671,
-0.0045477943,
-0.0185225569,
0.0212553423,
0.0117494566,
-0.0480648167,
-0.0070000659,
0.0530579388,
-0.0002067493,
-0.0226230975,
-0.0052841417,
-0.0133570563,
0.0408244804,
0.0046290234,
-0.0011412357,
-0.0560660809,
-0.0407785811,
0.0044312468,
0.0223362092,
0.047791563,
0.0351472907,
-0.0090788072,
0.0271753762,
0.053344097,
0.009765747,
-0.039249856,
0.0212927125,
0.0114827845,
0.030894164,
0.0362256914,
0.0500411019,
0.0022210209,
-0.0577286594,
0.0068246517,
-0.0081662647,
0.0080019655,
0.0104830926,
0.0739113763,
0.012498918,
-0.0015282359,
0.0002044935,
0.043615777,
-0.0414403789,
0.0376146622,
-0.0204792656,
0.0132998554,
-0.0238032043,
0.0404738337,
-0.055260431,
-0.0160305072,
0.0047178851,
0.021231981,
0.0379279703,
-0.0046304478,
0.0186929088,
0.0099775922,
-0.0370761119,
-0.0167023428,
0.0182695892,
0.0167858284,
-0.0341589153,
0.0154809067,
0.0121265035,
0.0392437726,
-0.0963187143,
-0.0066717267,
0.0457374156,
-0.0185060501,
-0.0022322242,
-0.041810818,
0.0214760862,
0.0086628264,
-0.0081058163,
-0.0274103805,
-0.0131674977,
0.0088334829,
-0.0434518196,
-0.0213695038,
-0.0044261608,
-0.0060187974,
0.0052036056,
0.0630290657,
-0.0359408893,
0.0244527813,
0.0425739847,
-0.0291691944,
-0.0059225541,
0.0452375002,
0.0040759016,
0.0297190771,
-0.035642501,
0.0223331079,
0.0165298898,
0.0108456565,
-0.0581486523,
0.056206841,
0.001853544,
0.0305781793,
-0.0218377914,
-0.053012386,
0.0660432652,
0.0054758037,
-0.0001987314,
-0.0317094065,
-0.0085283406,
0.0190473571,
0.0497961789,
-0.0268548373,
-0.0079699038,
-0.0173806101,
-0.0315994136,
-0.0197538771,
0.005429924,
0.0281896181,
-0.0442020111,
0.0322673023,
-0.0109745031,
-0.0311971866,
0.0028016833,
-0.0487250574,
-0.0140068298,
0.0471501909,
0.0287459735,
-0.0101622008,
0.0576998144,
-0.0566804186,
-0.0654654875,
0.0476833023,
0.0562184416,
0.026613066,
-0.028723333,
0.0252189934,
-0.016457025,
-0.0366230533,
0.008424338,
-0.0386191308,
-0.020265786,
-0.0165201072,
-0.0341107771,
-0.0578299128,
0.0155104017,
0.0286705028,
-0.059720885,
-0.0050944141,
0.0138484892,
-0.0843215361,
0.0365287326,
0.0249874759,
-0.0424659252,
-0.0108248927,
-0.0068883812,
-0.0008442076,
-0.0419483706,
-0.0185738597,
-0.0000569956,
-0.0228863899,
0.028349556,
-0.0261423513,
-0.013213356,
-0.0075849625,
-0.011083073,
-0.0061741304,
0.0743535534,
-0.0301513802,
-0.067256026,
0.0073283999,
0.0074745063,
0.0008836733,
-0.0475631729,
0.0483606458,
-0.0338818394,
-0.0467726141,
-0.0323273167,
0.0148044555,
-0.0073472792,
-0.0332028195,
-0.0269884896,
0.0100504896,
0.0201935153,
-0.0294097755,
0.0571375228,
0.0490957014,
0.0430240668,
-0.0483744144,
-0.0079225274,
-0.0424035192,
0.0432953835,
0.0124634495,
-0.0466098748,
-0.0067429598,
0.0057689436,
-0.029297078,
0.0163608678,
0.0434928276,
0.0107737305,
-0.0324049667,
-0.0358734727,
0.0088585792,
-0.0252626911,
0.0320184231,
0.0189859886,
0.0087598022,
-0.0083083697,
-0.0040441644,
0.0065116216,
-0.0410053991,
-0.0464021452,
-0.051503174,
-0.0105419215,
0.0410034806,
-0.027419297,
-0.0496858433,
-0.0509584509,
-0.044077795,
-0.0398342945,
0.0081082406,
0.09500999,
-0.0089069381,
-0.0675660297,
-0.0232001003,
-0.0753702074,
-0.0163575988,
-0.0024350779,
0.0338130891,
-0.1283647418,
0.000438342,
0.0288120992,
0.0439716689,
0.0483665764,
-0.0063781557,
0.0433281958,
-0.092686303,
-0.016982425,
-0.0124866385,
-0.0364686772,
-0.0620601363,
-0.0058921366,
0.018027965,
0.0089534037,
0.0207506716,
-0.0239637513,
-0.0382684506,
0.0407847017,
0.0218364019,
0.053559117,
-0.0366779789,
-0.0370559283,
-0.0505871512,
-0.0459285825,
0.0548808165,
0.0061879782,
-0.0450515039,
-0.0275336187,
0.0187100545,
-0.0080630295,
0.0010517793,
-0.0208412427,
0.0545447171,
0.0285958927,
-0.0045501254,
-0.0422659591,
-0.0674980357,
-0.0128261242,
0.0094006145,
-0.0121060908,
0.0010809733,
-0.0274063349,
0.0716972053,
-0.018811373,
0.0098299012,
-0.0442461334,
0.0471524782,
-0.0222697575,
-0.0299297012,
0.0194149315,
0.0151744261,
0.0106110787,
-0.0606249683,
-0.0352686346,
-0.0238088779,
0.0262331553,
0.0122506898,
-0.0936948285,
-0.0343515612,
-0.0806633756,
0.0261284318,
0.0403587446,
0.0076296749,
0.0033159514,
-0.003977573,
-0.0569634773,
0.0069925706,
-0.0134672243,
-0.0353704654,
-0.063290827,
0.0490579046,
0.000910571,
-0.0925331041,
0.0187886506,
-0.0090731205,
-0.023458723,
-0.0307838246,
0.0468079448,
0.0145196551,
0.0099155568,
0.0184646193,
-0.0364756659,
-0.050957568,
0.0437028147,
0.0224044342,
-0.0484008975,
0.0593913831,
0.0577364452,
-0.0139109604,
-0.0687709674,
0.0447146744,
-0.0356318876,
0.0455318466,
0.0069118263,
-0.0299925525,
0.0293910243,
-0.0490839891,
0.0209558085,
-0.0230562184,
-0.0061318679,
-0.0096349502,
-0.0021345485,
-0.0412107296,
0.0245963745,
-0.0275019258,
0.0083141346,
-0.0097916061,
0.0026134828,
0.0114222439,
0.0491070114,
0.0310216229,
0.0040170308,
0.0574972928,
0.0301718079,
-0.0442607887,
0.0065622306,
-0.0020487322,
0.0504132099,
-0.0327374525,
0.0560181364,
0.0273048338,
-0.0293271635,
-0.0403741486,
0.0464550517,
-0.0565611869,
0.0321657844,
0.0183207169,
0.0398292653,
0.0055381092,
0.0400777832,
-0.0217438098,
-0.0253177229,
0.0136861373,
0.0266604498,
0.0574967265,
-0.0359031744,
0.018440336,
0.0439884514,
-0.0086570652,
-0.0200882517,
-0.0218950268,
0.0410909019,
0.0132659199,
-0.0020012488,
0.028969761,
0.0172862951,
0.0038347077,
0.0416093059,
-0.0301865246,
0.014416134,
0.0084803961,
-0.0229097866,
0.0021416044,
-0.010987252,
-0.0024360863,
0.0283795688,
-0.0430823378,
0.0210795123,
-0.0373071954,
-0.0415432826,
0.0429646373,
0.0106780864,
-0.0531276055,
-0.0145014413,
0.0281814989,
0.0706740096,
0.0309342984,
-0.0516687259,
-0.0577998124,
0.0419977307,
-0.0150020653,
-0.044663243,
-0.0178395975,
-5.155853772e-33,
-0.0374497436,
0.0295879655,
-0.0029361343,
-0.006304902,
-0.0136286905,
-0.0212585144,
-0.0079496745,
-0.013102835,
-0.0424561501,
0.0153487008,
-0.0447564833,
0.0337967053,
0.0184412096,
0.0070222029,
0.0178630445,
-0.0090554832,
0.0510298498,
0.0132533526,
-0.0291026011,
-0.0013687613,
0.0570898615,
0.061135605,
0.0803426132,
-0.087071836,
0.0203621928,
-0.0224233624,
0.017959442,
0.0185150132,
0.0240156874,
0.0734770671,
0.0001342064,
0.0547004379,
0.0206847508,
-0.0656705499,
0.0254990906,
-0.0148719894,
-0.1097151116,
-0.0184865128,
0.0318486802,
0.0662418604,
0.0063174516,
-0.0212836713,
-0.0025038894,
-0.0146771353,
-0.0301232785,
0.0053772251,
0.0496742539,
-0.018876411,
-0.0314353816,
-0.0167532861,
-0.0888662413,
0.0270904917,
0.0455041155,
0.0213182308,
0.0326054022,
0.0488209799,
0.0238047615,
0.055821158,
-0.0881869122,
-0.0371557623,
-0.0399873443,
0.0724133253,
-0.0203116871,
0.0378949307,
-0.0583945811,
-0.0111800339,
-0.0212628972,
-0.0003925379,
0.0752870888,
0.02620757,
0.038928207,
-0.057745114,
0.0510724299,
0.0975675359,
0.0614053942,
-0.0024723238,
-0.0624362975,
0.0437511504,
-0.0405250639,
0.041351039,
-0.0113472687,
0.0028340786,
-0.0556243993,
0.0298140272,
0.0108227395,
-0.0008068573,
-0.0032536213,
-0.0038944238,
0.0295330919,
0.0264510922,
0.0246620942,
0.0164839942,
0.0215632953,
-0.0156997517,
0.0394438095,
0.0362707935,
-0.0036666843,
-0.0388849042,
-0.0195882898,
-0.0026441843,
-0.0042876163,
-0.0025795184,
0.0258787107,
0.0057908311,
-0.0081852423,
-0.030386677,
0.0384805389,
-0.0151860574,
-0.0571045056,
0.0253298879,
-0.0000212288,
0.0338249505,
0.0273670889,
0.0757346302,
0.009124144,
0.0162373967,
0.0227268245,
0.0311162192,
0.0674167722,
-0.0475398153,
-0.0331923701,
-0.0214232244,
0.0196710005,
-0.042267397,
0.0296221655,
0.0290903654,
-0.0063686357,
0.0396011993,
-0.0053694504,
-0.0593087152,
-0.0048625385,
0.0320090912,
2.666e-7,
0.061046835,
-0.0567014217,
0.0554112978,
0.0204383396,
-0.0468562059,
0.0081143891,
0.0098968726,
0.0228576045,
0.0318041444,
0.0310840849,
-0.0227637477,
0.0083763031,
0.0672239736,
-0.0161097478,
-0.0573415197,
-0.0551328287,
0.0015716781,
0.0211032238,
-0.020187499,
-0.0105189951,
-0.0006140419,
0.1215305105,
-0.0386631005,
-0.0190276951,
-0.0427154414,
-0.0633656457,
0.0469291918,
0.006096852,
-0.0309854187,
0.0245254505,
0.0884089023,
0.0066210465,
0.0077015529,
-0.0046346053,
-0.02782459,
0.0227854885,
0.0659283325,
0.009023238,
0.0399587639,
0.0241977386,
-0.0137478542,
0.0260112304,
0.0102064591,
-0.0318403356,
0.042301286,
0.0050026416,
0.0355863944,
0.0359147377,
-0.0447633266,
0.0313700363,
0.0097642317,
0.0030691316,
0.0029314512,
0.0145510808,
0.0707515329,
0.0247439798,
0.0123804081,
-0.0490950346,
0.0226199981,
-0.0082614794,
0.0020683589,
0.0401005,
-0.007703389,
-0.0348208547,
-0.0076357727,
-0.0177279748,
-0.0148566822,
1.975297034e-34,
0.0419340618,
-0.0054134903,
0.0027952569,
-0.0113654817,
0.0220110379,
-0.0057017561,
-0.0112799658,
0.0156150749,
-0.0235822424,
-0.0326182395,
0.0146468878
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.02798v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.02798v1 | Weakly Supervised Detection of Hallucinations in LLM Activations | 2023-12-05T14:35:11 | 2023-12-05T14:35:11 | Miriam Rateike, Celia Cintas, John Wamburu, Tanya Akumu, Skyler Speakman | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | We propose an auditing method to identify whether a large language model
(LLM) encodes patterns such as hallucinations in its internal states, which may
propagate to downstream tasks. We introduce a weakly supervised auditing
technique using a subset scanning approach to detect anomalous patterns in LLM
activations from pre-trained models. Importantly, our method does not need
knowledge of the type of patterns a-priori. Instead, it relies on a reference
dataset devoid of anomalies during testing. Further, our approach enables the
identification of pivotal nodes responsible for encoding these patterns, which
may offer crucial insights for fine-tuning specific sub-networks for bias
mitigation. We introduce two new scanning methods to handle LLM activations for
anomalous sentences that may deviate from the expected distribution in either
direction. Our results confirm prior findings of BERT's limited internal
capacity for encoding hallucinations, while OPT appears capable of encoding
hallucination information internally. Importantly, our scanning approach,
without prior exposure to false statements, performs comparably to a fully
supervised out-of-distribution classifier. | [
-0.0113878436,
0.0589297637,
-0.025905855,
0.0629083961,
-0.0250844061,
0.0308465026,
-0.0251530465,
0.0318095237,
0.0224784855,
-0.0266886111,
-0.0667711571,
-0.0062609185,
-0.004972179,
0.0095931608,
0.0668736696,
0.0201053582,
0.0724213198,
-0.0438616648,
-0.0101048695,
-0.0007781078,
-0.0292307213,
0.0110780969,
-0.0037266929,
0.0347035676,
0.0027317023,
-0.0299504083,
-0.0107563706,
0.0137012033,
-0.0085640587,
-0.0071346113,
0.0129942428,
0.0533170216,
-0.013787616,
0.0820859298,
0.000001932,
-0.0305744018,
-0.0008608902,
-0.0247595757,
0.0023850421,
0.023799805,
-0.0177052468,
0.0040695965,
-0.0095798178,
-0.0225646514,
0.0038829658,
-0.0118259434,
0.0403158963,
0.085618265,
0.0178909898,
0.0899823233,
-0.007179094,
0.0161249992,
0.0314101391,
0.0043673944,
0.0343620852,
0.0177822411,
0.0612382218,
-0.0280715823,
-0.0250839684,
-0.0589030609,
-0.0200749505,
-0.0215430185,
0.0150580173,
0.0079593249,
-0.0209014863,
0.0235955808,
-0.064138785,
-0.0116968527,
-0.0007531511,
0.0394640863,
-0.0531013459,
-0.0489132255,
0.0463689528,
-0.0106833568,
0.020668488,
-0.0028322823,
0.0021014845,
0.0107321804,
-0.0042406316,
0.0285360273,
0.0282210764,
-0.0183095448,
0.0528592058,
0.0009269793,
-0.0408438966,
0.0346936844,
0.0175113995,
-0.0678162351,
0.0388143696,
0.0460546352,
0.0021397285,
-0.0710024089,
0.0249897204,
-0.0215945374,
-0.0492628329,
0.0014137382,
-0.0336303152,
0.018209504,
0.0205079298,
-0.0630163252,
0.0120364558,
-0.0143535351,
-0.0845052302,
0.0237263553,
-0.0505986214,
0.0421614349,
-0.0342192389,
0.1080751345,
-0.0069913142,
0.0344017632,
-0.0329757333,
-0.0218705963,
-0.0316469818,
0.027775215,
0.0253280383,
-0.0332000703,
-0.0430836417,
0.0010689429,
-0.0275910068,
-0.005967143,
-0.0301100388,
0.0167129878,
0.0239950176,
0.0163946617,
0.0064821783,
0.00590481,
-0.0145513387,
-0.0078580631,
0.0095813433,
-0.0507346094,
-0.0410331637,
0.0460906066,
-0.0402338803,
-0.0184146166,
-0.0066142096,
0.0455324575,
0.0167987086,
-0.030839663,
-0.0499157906,
-0.0300634634,
-0.0577572994,
-0.0255371872,
0.0430546962,
-0.0252254289,
-0.036912851,
-0.0277167726,
0.0106690116,
0.003865836,
0.0281559564,
-0.0066989711,
-0.0304775834,
0.0422938168,
-0.018151002,
-0.0215580929,
-0.0301430766,
0.0180692263,
0.0202315748,
0.0770274699,
-0.0085873557,
0.0196379442,
0.0122431675,
0.000565016,
0.0455092862,
0.0582992882,
0.0159838498,
-0.0164977014,
-0.0655644909,
-0.039361652,
0.0080833202,
0.0135617163,
0.0354541838,
0.0428605713,
-0.0300716273,
-0.033236295,
0.0484684855,
0.032220494,
-0.0372781418,
-0.0100698378,
0.0033524872,
-0.0259305649,
-0.0098061115,
0.0669260472,
-0.063159354,
0.0051871552,
-0.0384049714,
-0.0382478312,
0.0141339032,
-0.0256071556,
-0.0200167801,
-0.0229612701,
-0.0327932462,
0.0239075292,
-0.006037239,
0.0068500163,
0.0324098393,
0.0538885407,
-0.0410447195,
0.0567220673,
0.0119378604,
-0.0042998856,
0.0171052683,
-0.093011573,
0.0106563959,
0.0775675923,
0.0525789149,
-0.0440780409,
0.0121703167,
-0.0210451186,
0.000065362,
0.0697526857,
0.01716258,
-0.0005866425,
0.029059669,
-0.0490844585,
0.0107653718,
-0.0141226929,
0.0652960166,
-0.0195888393,
-0.0292308051,
-0.0257516578,
-0.0455472283,
-0.0811071917,
-0.05221067,
0.0582314432,
0.004204791,
-0.0501093343,
-0.0138528505,
0.0102340709,
0.0112779178,
-0.0173101369,
-0.019886734,
0.019949235,
0.0093177753,
-0.0205813125,
-0.0267786477,
0.0085432716,
-0.0227833707,
-0.0339821912,
0.0097042043,
-0.0072424538,
-0.031497851,
0.0230215564,
-0.0030656671,
-0.0405493155,
-0.0112023186,
-0.067198731,
0.0791533366,
-0.0579468235,
0.0349135995,
-0.0144566121,
0.0504385754,
-0.0095968312,
0.0933302417,
-0.0441465601,
0.0330710001,
0.0184337776,
-0.0247617587,
0.0046724519,
-0.0058767237,
-0.0443118513,
0.0163887441,
-0.0222892687,
0.0037503005,
-0.0297047496,
-0.0306896847,
-0.0717580318,
-0.0366505384,
-0.0714774951,
-0.0153301638,
-0.0142684458,
-0.0043091113,
0.0307135936,
-0.0221417435,
-0.020632945,
-0.0145787783,
0.0069612921,
0.0065873899,
0.0103182327,
0.0544831902,
0.0008690263,
-0.0309805796,
-0.044131007,
-0.0302519519,
-0.0007768731,
-0.0464184098,
0.0767205283,
-0.0268013887,
-0.0358481891,
-0.0827398598,
0.0295074694,
0.0036975292,
0.0276351813,
0.002497657,
-0.0384581946,
0.035906639,
-0.0048906947,
-0.0053488347,
0.0841262192,
0.0015070249,
0.0335327201,
0.051679574,
-0.0421643294,
-0.0259946324,
-0.0204506088,
0.013839934,
0.0074124285,
-0.0498549044,
-0.0167398639,
0.0196770784,
0.0840916559,
0.0397195294,
0.0092487633,
-0.035182789,
-0.0049362346,
-0.025711054,
-0.0754299611,
0.0083886199,
-0.0338334665,
-0.029169837,
0.0464992076,
-0.0218583513,
-0.0522749275,
0.08329878,
-0.0171320122,
0.0048527243,
0.0013723618,
0.0015738859,
0.0193141531,
0.0239874367,
0.0316404179,
0.0052740374,
0.0242513679,
-0.0723870099,
-0.0425653979,
-0.0367797427,
-0.0668580532,
-0.0106563829,
0.0284560025,
-0.0078583341,
-0.0062876497,
0.0467593707,
-0.0098728854,
-0.0772156715,
-0.0218315609,
-0.0017781032,
-0.0081573175,
-0.0315614194,
-0.0131195011,
-0.0322652757,
-0.0080858767,
-0.0351402611,
0.0417048596,
-0.0326339714,
-0.020932937,
-0.0174051337,
0.0333792455,
0.0298979152,
-0.0343775563,
0.0385210887,
-0.0667138174,
-0.0210685357,
0.0497182049,
-0.0032202161,
0.0879291221,
-0.0454562157,
0.0113790175,
-0.0002843011,
-0.0164564922,
0.0063788048,
0.0024640013,
0.0433360748,
-0.0550672933,
-0.0582785569,
0.0898597986,
0.0282198787,
-0.067865558,
0.019239638,
-0.0348416045,
0.0495994985,
0.0271665175,
-0.0000343485,
-0.0565730371,
-0.0078349328,
0.0061639086,
-0.0056672692,
-0.0315727368,
-0.0180501193,
0.043248713,
-0.0892603174,
0.0423348136,
0.010763933,
-0.0141265085,
-0.0111064464,
0.0264477078,
0.0220759343,
0.0212146062,
0.0424519815,
-0.0220755674,
0.0209442955,
-0.0375698023,
0.0158157256,
-0.0122612827,
-0.0281092282,
0.0551665239,
-0.0063869576,
0.0577017255,
0.0906067714,
0.0290762093,
-0.0185100418,
-0.0442764573,
0.0834185258,
-0.0358098149,
0.0248570479,
0.0244917627,
0.0633742586,
0.0136752473,
-0.0149337146,
-0.0202244651,
0.0412067696,
-0.0471583307,
-0.0204064045,
-0.0075264829,
0.0823901668,
-0.04804736,
-0.0694997832,
0.0073541962,
0.0171109978,
0.0213224161,
0.0634361953,
0.0521691516,
-0.0338376649,
-0.0394277088,
0.0179515667,
0.0228875764,
-0.0438562147,
-0.0226770733,
0.0549700484,
0.0876838416,
-0.0301427115,
-0.075960651,
-0.027167337,
0.0084024649,
0.0134818284,
0.0090018986,
0.0016881122,
-0.0237877648,
-0.0424627513,
-0.0169230849,
0.0272811409,
-0.0224299151,
0.0029055194,
-0.006499608,
-0.021926323,
0.0262145232,
0.0066295872,
-0.0153732244,
0.0359221324,
-0.076927416,
-0.0617031343,
0.0588478334,
0.033127591,
0.0224142876,
0.0587862618,
-0.0440727621,
-0.0304202344,
0.0873467177,
0.0375710689,
-0.0070108958,
0.0485635847,
0.025589237,
-0.0511514582,
-0.0083751483,
0.0327651761,
-0.0086758342,
0.0032090005,
0.0482290573,
0.0038332969,
-0.0092336284,
0.0082926741,
0.0280230902,
-0.0256397165,
0.0546754785,
-0.0118311523,
0.0039368719,
-0.0480322838,
-0.0013638063,
0.0256699212,
-0.0091952449,
-0.011285224,
-0.0172301009,
0.0552648716,
-0.014787145,
-0.0028828704,
-0.0198186804,
-0.0520567335,
-0.0007398329,
-0.0209944695,
-0.0161819849,
0.0245835446,
0.009005595,
0.0014767633,
0.0152350161,
-0.016420329,
0.0358133651,
-0.014715259,
0.0493625104,
0.0101916734,
0.0542201325,
0.0200238489,
0.0065559228,
-0.0044310656,
0.003094669,
-0.0404216982,
-0.0361684337,
-0.0252312478,
0.0092691863,
0.0257828347,
-0.0181083865,
0.0408916287,
-0.0145908128,
0.0212929025,
-0.00409021,
0.0084735006,
0.0188225806,
-0.0264904834,
-0.0103887133,
0.0300254002,
-0.0221484918,
-0.0292203948,
0.0302009657,
-0.0069555761,
0.0618043989,
0.0058143944,
-0.0101855705,
-0.0326256119,
-0.0544435494,
0.006714622,
0.0069997446,
-0.049492646,
-0.0183006264,
-0.0092659118,
-0.0785390586,
-0.0049337558,
0.0141551346,
0.0361131653,
-0.0008486959,
0.0045547467,
0.0716235042,
-0.0131693371,
-0.0148747265,
0.0181420818,
-0.0253342409,
0.0533767901,
-0.0046829632,
-0.0169101097,
-6.327881516e-33,
-0.0146337142,
-0.027415067,
-0.0033700878,
-0.0420443527,
0.0058618728,
0.0119056692,
-0.0461062901,
0.0044329404,
0.0175995883,
0.0290913917,
0.004342265,
0.062762849,
0.021829946,
0.016128948,
0.0244028457,
-0.0508542433,
0.0546655245,
-0.014970745,
-0.0225421041,
0.0172841661,
0.0401036516,
0.0215984359,
0.1144982949,
-0.0468224548,
0.033069551,
0.0216384605,
-0.0511141457,
0.0240594633,
-0.0361766778,
0.0406323224,
-0.0294854362,
0.0193196665,
0.0139288716,
0.0236913543,
-0.0157504082,
-0.0077251797,
0.0041313102,
-0.0204244461,
0.0184430201,
0.0424177907,
-0.0215345249,
-0.0173958838,
0.0721513107,
-0.0283376295,
0.0127919223,
0.0112125119,
0.0326780863,
-0.0343331359,
-0.0016579146,
0.0289534386,
-0.065593183,
-0.0160546992,
-0.0008493065,
-0.0031778386,
-0.0189607423,
0.0156671684,
-0.0204166751,
-0.0292416345,
-0.034372244,
0.0076820734,
0.015115493,
0.0152638303,
0.0222427752,
0.0314240716,
0.0012301442,
0.1099931374,
0.1080732048,
0.0256160926,
-0.0111990031,
-0.0338224396,
0.0711921602,
0.0569848977,
0.0251343623,
-0.0261387918,
0.0505006313,
0.0294189397,
-0.0337320864,
-0.035459049,
-0.0051442184,
-0.0055063665,
0.08989086,
-0.0201779399,
-0.0316601433,
-0.0245233905,
0.0006676002,
-0.0406468064,
-0.042719014,
-0.006430258,
0.0498526692,
0.0030022226,
0.0026968806,
0.0046904138,
0.0289959703,
-0.0369962975,
0.0227102712,
0.0226660557,
-0.029539289,
0.0169762298,
-0.0009461879,
-0.0039716633,
-0.0011711683,
-0.0396452583,
0.0324474424,
0.0098866438,
0.0581360683,
0.0235211998,
0.052670598,
0.0088956337,
-0.0545144565,
0.012788997,
-0.0374116749,
0.0053688185,
-0.0228760689,
0.0396222472,
0.0534430891,
-0.0179905556,
-0.0271519721,
-0.0110000679,
0.0047630928,
0.0323872864,
-0.0275171772,
0.0647392198,
-0.0223957188,
0.030376127,
-0.0183705073,
-0.0514421277,
-0.028465068,
-0.0073847258,
0.0258236472,
-0.0818087682,
0.0117663024,
0.0012964349,
2.775e-7,
0.0118527589,
0.0459603556,
0.0184104275,
0.0279758461,
0.0382183455,
0.0018315389,
-0.018763531,
0.0345687568,
0.0137290685,
-0.0738978386,
-0.0098134624,
0.0062518558,
0.0607759915,
0.0462570302,
-0.0768156871,
0.0131323542,
-0.0565430187,
0.0334496908,
-0.0724227801,
-0.0389142446,
0.0115750972,
0.0635699481,
0.025134474,
-0.0433064364,
0.0395157076,
-0.0877926499,
0.0486449227,
-0.0070375656,
0.0089075854,
0.0134885684,
0.0029813971,
0.0233153217,
0.0228015967,
0.0708206743,
-0.0101012196,
-0.005439661,
-0.0244237389,
0.014431159,
-0.0259445496,
-0.0551826358,
-0.0413387492,
0.0065699322,
0.0205040798,
-0.0395334959,
0.0351226814,
-0.0242572799,
-0.0128767081,
-0.0048172865,
0.0104622021,
-0.0657039434,
0.0499033481,
-0.0181278996,
0.0003442193,
0.0399949923,
0.0162521396,
0.0384600237,
-0.0125219142,
-0.0751096904,
-0.0253712628,
-0.009461036,
-0.0493047051,
-0.0222602207,
-0.0183508378,
0.0196781699,
-0.0170471966,
-0.0834461749,
0.0092430236,
2.956072352e-34,
0.0283918697,
0.0003702397,
0.0253417753,
0.0222121663,
0.0116718467,
-0.0030555823,
0.0369292498,
-0.0059774187,
-0.0177745409,
-0.0623769015,
-0.0123340301
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.02783v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.02783v2 | Large Language Models on Graphs: A Comprehensive Survey | 2023-12-05T14:14:27 | 2024-02-01T22:51:24 | Bowen Jin, Gang Liu, Chi Han, Meng Jiang, Heng Ji, Jiawei Han | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs), such as GPT4 and LLaMA, are creating
significant advancements in natural language processing, due to their strong
text encoding/decoding ability and newly found emergent capability (e.g.,
reasoning). While LLMs are mainly designed to process pure texts, there are
many real-world scenarios where text data is associated with rich structure
information in the form of graphs (e.g., academic networks, and e-commerce
networks) or scenarios where graph data is paired with rich textual information
(e.g., molecules with descriptions). Besides, although LLMs have shown their
pure text-based reasoning ability, it is underexplored whether such ability can
be generalized to graphs (i.e., graph-based reasoning). In this paper, we
provide a systematic review of scenarios and techniques related to large
language models on graphs. We first summarize potential scenarios of adopting
LLMs on graphs into three categories, namely pure graphs, text-attributed
graphs, and text-paired graphs. We then discuss detailed techniques for
utilizing LLMs on graphs, including LLM as Predictor, LLM as Encoder, and LLM
as Aligner, and compare the advantages and disadvantages of different schools
of models. Furthermore, we discuss the real-world applications of such methods
and summarize open-source codes and benchmark datasets. Finally, we conclude
with potential future research directions in this fast-growing field. The
related source can be found at
https://github.com/PeterGriffinJin/Awesome-Language-Model-on-Graphs. | [
0.0416864902,
0.0465147719,
0.0021240644,
0.0449028425,
-0.0437592939,
-0.0056365221,
-0.0194192324,
0.0022903259,
0.0702974647,
-0.0311832558,
0.0112330616,
-0.0263732225,
-0.0051820483,
0.062549457,
0.0267092902,
-0.0028775139,
0.0088190343,
-0.0230582133,
0.0486904681,
-0.0246902909,
0.0212744493,
0.0269635171,
0.045740284,
0.0044769146,
0.0169554092,
-0.003082088,
-0.0004738236,
0.0077166161,
0.0005842047,
-0.0273918957,
-0.0378324538,
0.0085446984,
0.0274021365,
0.0375281461,
0.0000016752,
-0.0341886096,
-0.0497866347,
0.0175472461,
-0.0245887414,
-0.0060951719,
0.0353427306,
-0.0562438704,
0.0220462009,
0.0027002774,
-0.0347386226,
-0.0418329388,
0.0609137304,
0.004537438,
0.0259592179,
0.074213095,
-0.0277083814,
-0.0791432858,
0.0426627286,
-0.0198594052,
-0.0057548857,
-0.0361866206,
0.0650589764,
0.0337128006,
0.024418395,
0.0060249106,
-0.0594478659,
0.009480074,
-0.0202784389,
-0.0208801385,
0.0479727201,
0.0387546234,
0.003491482,
0.0102613335,
-0.0050534438,
0.1086782143,
0.006371045,
-0.0295247138,
0.0214240197,
-0.0038001193,
-0.0318833813,
0.03582149,
-0.0503044277,
-0.003246397,
-0.0146113224,
0.0489403047,
0.0144191077,
-0.0297980253,
0.0775705725,
0.0122394683,
-0.0341618173,
0.0945329443,
-0.0118587073,
-0.0166373421,
0.0192488395,
-0.0037564882,
-0.0548733063,
-0.0326205455,
0.0227851029,
0.0464419462,
-0.007816107,
0.0345465057,
-0.0109052155,
0.022118086,
-0.002950429,
-0.0070692245,
-0.0027805138,
-0.0112196365,
0.0387712382,
0.0585992709,
-0.0028127034,
0.0692086071,
-0.0581183359,
0.04552228,
-0.0467084423,
-0.0400118381,
-0.0590036511,
-0.0121352402,
-0.0231900103,
0.0407386757,
-0.0209157802,
-0.0553653091,
-0.0430857614,
0.0397317521,
0.0199679565,
0.0047189556,
0.0374328196,
-0.0004245887,
0.0302680321,
-0.036620222,
-0.0104406485,
0.0527127609,
0.0403628722,
0.0110718114,
-0.0314021222,
-0.008491586,
0.0137300445,
0.0210930761,
0.0554141328,
-0.0420234725,
0.0182593912,
0.0917096734,
0.0421336666,
-0.0244366396,
0.0148694227,
-0.0305017531,
-0.0181606282,
-0.0753790587,
0.0411669463,
-0.0695863366,
0.0594773479,
0.0534035079,
0.0058164117,
-0.0559479482,
0.027168395,
-0.0192055292,
-0.0701085776,
0.0630223006,
-0.0246401522,
0.0224121269,
-0.0010852179,
-0.0419096202,
0.0216203239,
0.0159488991,
0.0522074848,
0.0058418857,
0.0386765786,
-0.0209278632,
-0.0259276945,
0.0237369165,
0.0205090605,
-0.0206495225,
0.0201709177,
-0.0011322044,
-0.0140928859,
0.0110301292,
-0.0213989224,
0.0851232931,
-0.0197536163,
-0.0301629454,
0.042498026,
0.0491531678,
-0.0087159276,
-0.0156951454,
0.0019062061,
0.0122647155,
-0.0069538145,
-0.0014932278,
-0.0284345187,
0.0056917029,
-0.0084677916,
0.026023509,
0.0199577734,
0.0076883072,
0.0009409084,
-0.0087753013,
-0.0319782794,
-0.0198208969,
0.0714261979,
-0.0076768491,
0.0810687989,
-0.0271619372,
-0.0637044534,
0.0049354169,
0.0170372799,
-0.0270444956,
-0.0001421184,
0.0032851335,
-0.0012315726,
0.0799273476,
0.0540813468,
0.0130689293,
-0.030759111,
0.0061393809,
-0.0260907058,
-0.0025843959,
0.0107171247,
-0.0235703811,
-0.0461174212,
-0.0678196773,
-0.032373514,
-0.0058795335,
-0.0178372376,
0.0055229818,
0.0062303878,
0.0093408162,
-0.0169878174,
-0.0755314007,
-0.0424743444,
-0.0097062439,
0.0105174305,
0.0203630868,
-0.0277434178,
-0.0208338723,
0.0270579793,
0.0353827104,
0.0076364176,
0.0344631113,
0.0384370498,
-0.0243729446,
-0.0216690935,
-0.0218121801,
-0.0065843822,
-0.0420556776,
0.0523433164,
-0.0264943093,
-0.0208668485,
0.0300521646,
-0.0467789322,
-0.0505339094,
0.0328577645,
-0.0592049435,
0.0318151638,
0.0047233286,
0.0050248764,
-0.0237134602,
0.0169082694,
0.0009625428,
0.0768314078,
0.0085990885,
0.0147577254,
-0.0068994905,
0.0087450529,
0.0163092092,
-0.0520582758,
-0.0041608689,
0.0457888469,
0.033351019,
0.0179292839,
0.0371909477,
-0.0325794443,
-0.0192204695,
0.0168783031,
-0.0641371757,
0.022728635,
-0.0074912524,
0.0304283444,
-0.003906297,
0.0104993107,
0.0272768419,
0.0145752141,
-0.0563194938,
0.0462983884,
0.0322860181,
0.0098096952,
0.0215979721,
-0.0232346859,
-0.0355392694,
-0.0133000622,
-0.0605980009,
-0.0457932428,
0.0804645047,
0.036955256,
-0.0850261003,
-0.0007996962,
0.0315692388,
-0.047574807,
0.0291939937,
-0.0250273366,
0.0084296102,
-0.0164319295,
-0.0088565489,
0.0413341746,
0.0446416624,
-0.0448965505,
0.027569985,
0.0420231596,
0.0019729845,
-0.0097070821,
-0.0231117476,
-0.0718905106,
-0.0043582479,
-0.0500425585,
-0.0434895009,
-0.0333816186,
0.0301110838,
0.023166554,
-0.0120908329,
-0.041548118,
-0.0285530854,
-0.0152808018,
0.0493911095,
0.0017632868,
-0.0427483805,
0.0150385862,
0.0064668059,
-0.0410979092,
-0.0323410816,
0.0843539611,
-0.0274139624,
0.0114704678,
0.0132419746,
-0.0141203022,
-0.0743618608,
0.0649924949,
0.0577349253,
0.0022400843,
-0.0035714658,
-0.026635848,
-0.0126351267,
-0.003120373,
0.0329977125,
-0.0550268888,
0.01139984,
-0.016253287,
0.0618126579,
0.0032486173,
-0.018415805,
0.0119398842,
-0.003860835,
-0.0529631898,
0.0468227826,
0.0298203994,
-0.0439591669,
-0.0073507815,
0.035798125,
-0.0118869673,
-0.023069283,
-0.013982065,
0.0350131616,
-0.0470987484,
0.0492569953,
0.0640516877,
-0.0560253263,
0.0100355465,
-0.0487040356,
0.0082759615,
0.0405759215,
-0.0093613081,
-0.0280190986,
-0.0274734851,
0.0059413994,
-0.0049417815,
0.0165401231,
-0.0194772501,
-0.0301632546,
0.0246704519,
-0.0398397259,
0.0238726586,
0.0777375475,
0.0228381697,
-0.0283937827,
0.0000370218,
0.0390791558,
-0.0008048066,
0.0204832498,
0.0038133017,
-0.0846881792,
-0.029805135,
-0.0151723977,
0.01309097,
0.0190021414,
-0.0541690737,
-0.0193637051,
-0.1010996327,
0.0129527608,
0.0498435609,
0.0192641802,
-0.0616158172,
-0.0624185875,
-0.0208115969,
-0.0212133862,
-0.0204300676,
-0.0066875266,
-0.0045792698,
-0.0030988494,
0.0283417329,
-0.0242930502,
-0.0353058428,
0.005572496,
-0.0011827642,
0.0212138537,
0.0172098018,
0.0374956653,
0.006019576,
-0.0000443687,
0.0317669362,
0.0066830022,
-0.0298479851,
-0.0050082686,
0.0276279841,
0.0049118055,
0.0043391124,
-0.0484622866,
0.0207149033,
-0.0475003682,
-0.0170577653,
-0.0366359726,
0.1295254529,
0.0018473311,
-0.0417873748,
-0.0020878166,
-0.0260126572,
-0.0386188477,
0.0365043655,
0.0111804949,
0.0341846831,
-0.0788545534,
-0.033959344,
0.0065468093,
-0.0262107495,
-0.0434863567,
0.0103909196,
-0.0159111097,
0.0255632624,
-0.0201705452,
-0.0174197108,
0.0383916125,
-0.0258513894,
-0.0125013115,
0.0455103777,
0.0677867308,
-0.0582056306,
-0.0760832801,
-0.0009039051,
-0.0383369885,
0.0348078497,
-0.0063036485,
-0.0093023414,
0.0336221159,
-0.0123454509,
-0.0030955304,
0.037864957,
-0.0607049838,
-0.1057830304,
-0.0414053351,
-0.0268143788,
0.0229927637,
0.0622564442,
-0.0177039523,
-0.0244076587,
0.0315417238,
0.0248679761,
-0.0078799576,
-0.0026409572,
-0.0077570868,
-0.010011836,
-0.0011630779,
0.0215082616,
-0.0532710552,
0.0031601305,
0.008303741,
0.0400586314,
-0.0373658873,
-0.0359269232,
0.0385575667,
0.0754437447,
0.0192903876,
0.0378735848,
-0.0201018415,
-0.0374676995,
-0.0088500883,
-0.0328652821,
-0.0375826843,
-0.0239680875,
-0.023911424,
0.044552166,
-0.0083727604,
-0.0143485824,
-0.0476988554,
0.0065731383,
0.032823462,
-0.0296914652,
0.0136096412,
-0.028184576,
-0.0382221714,
0.0538650118,
-0.0177241508,
0.0062626824,
0.019114431,
0.0131925996,
0.0156329349,
-0.0132589089,
0.0159694497,
0.0321920142,
-0.020205969,
-0.0430218838,
0.000419772,
-0.0664544925,
-0.0161918569,
0.0028872187,
0.022674175,
0.0429426916,
0.0275964886,
0.0579761788,
-0.0144096464,
-0.0091981702,
-0.0307760574,
0.0641540438,
0.01362703,
-0.0541304946,
0.070997104,
0.022945039,
-0.02069984,
0.0199313294,
0.0566938072,
0.0739390999,
0.0082878442,
0.0127845025,
-0.0724617466,
-0.012419981,
-0.0303876437,
-0.0312116053,
0.0033542628,
-0.0104154665,
0.018237045,
-0.0447912589,
-0.0846684426,
0.0322403871,
-0.006993691,
-0.0001369937,
-0.0017327878,
-0.0008681163,
0.0265974998,
0.0155509198,
-0.0218117256,
-0.0514016859,
0.0587842986,
-0.0428877287,
-0.0124389036,
0.006370551,
-5.839110965e-33,
-0.0060800398,
-0.088253431,
0.0278493315,
0.0421214774,
-0.0600444451,
0.024987286,
-0.0546915419,
-0.0347755551,
-0.0219236612,
0.0346348211,
0.0060308143,
0.0147361159,
-0.0004433605,
0.0170972086,
-0.0328740217,
-0.0253895484,
0.0085780015,
0.0120259495,
0.0079171108,
0.0319379196,
0.0521998443,
0.0258509982,
0.0500194654,
-0.0610159896,
0.0246048328,
-0.043634288,
0.0134558883,
0.0170598701,
-0.0112485131,
0.0454496294,
-0.0202645585,
0.0463700145,
0.0295348447,
0.0052022184,
-0.0004747931,
0.0308949593,
-0.0631281063,
-0.000029969,
0.0285093226,
0.0085977446,
-0.0318257697,
-0.0412990898,
0.0418930501,
-0.0023312464,
0.0031631514,
-0.0331552289,
0.0412357524,
-0.0111677544,
-0.0381840765,
0.0076030963,
-0.0250760317,
0.0398320109,
-0.0172797423,
0.0346985124,
0.0358627774,
-0.0083836867,
0.0001237966,
0.0462535881,
-0.0302435141,
0.0398923121,
-0.0243449975,
-0.0092440704,
0.0229039676,
0.005526843,
0.0205446184,
0.0334879309,
-0.0145738414,
-0.0205466356,
-0.0236062109,
0.0364168547,
-0.0385890193,
0.0623851568,
0.0163955893,
0.0155890565,
-0.0392711647,
0.0170272272,
-0.1058036909,
-0.0162121169,
-0.0160948802,
0.0145802582,
0.0121541061,
0.0411922708,
-0.0189122315,
-0.063977167,
0.0050118105,
-0.0109481392,
-0.0180281643,
-0.0072831274,
-0.0165617056,
-0.0200771391,
-0.0204752982,
0.0555140749,
0.0150681557,
-0.0863966942,
-0.050804507,
0.0941020697,
-0.0028181581,
0.0529706255,
-0.0110743074,
0.0468492322,
-0.0732967481,
-0.0376987532,
-0.0010069214,
-0.0288311392,
0.0145937353,
0.0077422662,
0.029847838,
0.0272446834,
-0.0157446265,
-0.0033919404,
-0.0569662265,
-0.0370992087,
-0.0422335826,
-0.0279815029,
0.0449234173,
0.0614862815,
0.0057092751,
0.0466386713,
0.0558949821,
0.0348215774,
-0.0038035314,
0.0114610773,
-0.0086357696,
0.0191822015,
-0.037112873,
0.0001298214,
-0.0140011068,
0.0141628552,
0.0247980803,
-0.043710608,
-0.0209100302,
0.0032357147,
2.549e-7,
0.0827111155,
0.0492795222,
0.062110927,
0.0290183574,
0.0195126291,
0.0114965411,
-0.028635487,
0.0336662568,
-0.0126448162,
-0.0079520661,
0.0460998043,
0.0374853387,
-0.0284058936,
0.0021930984,
-0.0396892242,
0.085632883,
-0.0614945628,
-0.0633799657,
-0.0549586713,
0.0215331428,
0.0393803604,
0.067043215,
0.0298306793,
-0.0048353947,
-0.0341881402,
-0.0475188605,
0.0626201034,
-0.0003618893,
-0.0250831284,
0.0214590356,
-0.0198704209,
-0.0282209367,
-0.038948603,
0.0319517888,
0.0148571432,
0.0352710411,
0.0207051542,
0.044127509,
-0.0306006521,
0.0261656418,
0.004999999,
-0.0589370131,
-0.0073704342,
-0.0230935775,
0.0737788528,
-0.0238234904,
-0.0844139308,
0.0141252056,
-0.0450537838,
-0.0238351431,
-0.0276775472,
0.0291144643,
0.0060660304,
0.0167796519,
0.0046465611,
-0.0096444217,
0.0131479064,
-0.053430941,
0.0299376752,
-0.0017933203,
-0.0230022818,
-0.0264738351,
0.0011162799,
0.0415058546,
0.041739855,
-0.0368549936,
0.0022655795,
2.415562142e-34,
0.0545194149,
-0.0009201575,
-0.0050563151,
-0.0060910559,
0.0329196565,
-0.043150086,
-0.0216714256,
0.0383063368,
0.0106431311,
-0.1352486759,
-0.0278671086
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.02780v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.02780v1 | Scaling Laws for Adversarial Attacks on Language Model Activations | 2023-12-05T14:12:15 | 2023-12-05T14:12:15 | Stanislav Fort | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CR | We explore a class of adversarial attacks targeting the activations of
language models. By manipulating a relatively small subset of model
activations, $a$, we demonstrate the ability to control the exact prediction of
a significant number (in some cases up to 1000) of subsequent tokens $t$. We
empirically verify a scaling law where the maximum number of target tokens
$t_\mathrm{max}$ predicted depends linearly on the number of tokens $a$ whose
activations the attacker controls as $t_\mathrm{max} = \kappa a$. We find that
the number of bits of control in the input space needed to control a single bit
in the output space (what we call attack resistance $\chi$) is remarkably
constant between $\approx 16$ and $\approx 25$ over 2 orders of magnitude of
model sizes for different language models. Compared to attacks on tokens,
attacks on activations are predictably much stronger, however, we identify a
surprising regularity where one bit of input steered either via activations or
via tokens is able to exert control over a similar amount of output bits. This
gives support for the hypothesis that adversarial attacks are a consequence of
dimensionality mismatch between the input and output spaces. A practical
implication of the ease of attacking language model activations instead of
tokens is for multi-modal and selected retrieval models, where additional data
sources are added as activations directly, sidestepping the tokenized input.
This opens up a new, broad attack surface. By using language models as a
controllable test-bed to study adversarial attacks, we were able to experiment
with input-output dimensions that are inaccessible in computer vision,
especially where the output dimension dominates. | [
0.0244037881,
0.0586616807,
-0.0371120311,
0.0556746796,
-0.0356885567,
0.0011789774,
0.0463041998,
0.0316563696,
-0.0230558198,
-0.0547307357,
-0.0161751341,
-0.0280101616,
0.0191657189,
0.0743900016,
0.0789587572,
-0.0154575063,
0.0339679569,
-0.0236257184,
-0.0409518853,
-0.0297718346,
-0.0203078929,
-0.0400873646,
0.0291598234,
0.0504405312,
-0.006962928,
0.0186626948,
0.0238019787,
-0.0136134075,
-0.0266023725,
0.008465128,
-0.0028290635,
0.0250005927,
0.0101434356,
0.0829425454,
0.0000018364,
-0.0308643542,
-0.0207455773,
0.006689799,
0.0016073963,
0.0256102532,
0.0179029275,
-0.0625920519,
0.0031685382,
-0.004957445,
-0.001393037,
-0.0412390642,
0.0434376821,
0.07842841,
0.014438902,
0.1133106574,
-0.002983842,
-0.0410990939,
0.0557278022,
-0.0320265107,
-0.0149404593,
-0.0201300457,
0.050003428,
-0.0329388045,
-0.0292993076,
0.0450324938,
-0.0189144146,
-0.0011291712,
0.0120572336,
-0.0040017655,
-0.0326216519,
0.031616807,
-0.016010331,
-0.0035900197,
0.048110798,
0.034049876,
-0.0397906154,
-0.0060301046,
0.006023142,
0.0033873529,
0.0194780473,
0.0119023127,
-0.0364845023,
-0.0073562758,
0.0310722515,
0.0117362803,
-0.0379766263,
-0.0176465847,
0.061970707,
0.0191282462,
-0.0081437435,
0.0147832045,
0.0278333668,
-0.0070044897,
-0.0286472812,
-0.0395756438,
-0.0087787593,
-0.0041606217,
-0.0208947882,
-0.0065698433,
0.0156436898,
0.0062095867,
-0.0545229837,
-0.0414694734,
0.035293512,
-0.0530183613,
0.0400357321,
0.011579643,
-0.0328234807,
0.0351906717,
-0.0125689218,
0.0902803913,
-0.0719140619,
0.0820147842,
-0.0230476707,
0.0116244983,
-0.0113497879,
-0.0215364974,
0.0044069593,
0.0004499824,
-0.0206032172,
-0.0031772444,
-0.0304664318,
0.0129228011,
-0.0172271393,
0.0123593872,
-0.0776750296,
0.0187722724,
-0.033918567,
-0.01413,
0.0389747657,
0.0054545086,
-0.0136755174,
0.0026273129,
-0.0150715103,
-0.0947428197,
-0.0515160374,
0.0174038801,
-0.0229697432,
-0.0400007851,
-0.0064599072,
0.1103959233,
0.0160851963,
-0.0586835146,
-0.0022217417,
-0.0572191179,
-0.0422175787,
-0.0203151759,
0.0044001099,
-0.0597392358,
-0.0223541148,
0.000998956,
-0.0223231651,
-0.0715379193,
-0.0039512455,
-0.000861905,
-0.054425925,
0.093129769,
0.0543582849,
-0.0346974023,
0.0370700881,
0.0211212132,
-0.0168477613,
0.0689689741,
-0.0201364942,
0.0567780323,
0.0646856651,
0.0067795669,
0.0306600388,
0.0357523896,
0.039369382,
0.0524081923,
-0.0549909323,
-0.005300967,
0.0469355024,
-0.0081950724,
-0.0178279579,
0.0680353791,
-0.0457402095,
-0.0840898752,
0.0654402301,
0.0505111888,
-0.0319829583,
0.068058759,
-0.0164847933,
-0.0427099913,
0.0027677158,
0.0147193652,
-0.0837483704,
-0.0156035135,
-0.0318558291,
-0.0407863781,
0.054409042,
0.0239970423,
-0.0268055703,
-0.0172272027,
-0.0197909772,
-0.0013775344,
0.0040169773,
-0.045634497,
0.0581032149,
0.0246920958,
0.0166240577,
0.0477878973,
0.02270036,
-0.0212555695,
0.0128821963,
-0.0524926446,
-0.0313899703,
-0.031555742,
0.0690650195,
-0.0412281305,
0.0533496477,
-0.0110781332,
0.0050591705,
-0.0000059466,
0.0276807956,
0.0001603285,
-0.0016888925,
-0.0117349401,
0.0027260885,
-0.0491750687,
0.0336952433,
-0.0007224323,
-0.0043403609,
0.0124157174,
-0.0172194336,
-0.045775447,
-0.0032538408,
0.0210819039,
0.0499342568,
-0.0793375596,
-0.0016537788,
0.0205229055,
0.0369188786,
-0.0076471353,
-0.0442863964,
0.0386890918,
0.0350426249,
-0.0257063396,
-0.0223533381,
-0.0111626294,
0.01500923,
0.0094926171,
0.0239440165,
0.0010751871,
0.02394595,
0.0422248058,
-0.0211254973,
-0.0082170563,
0.0829808563,
-0.0482957214,
0.0240916368,
0.0032435965,
-0.0127548035,
-0.0431343354,
0.05744192,
-0.0285861064,
0.0450716726,
-0.0322017446,
0.0334070362,
-0.015802335,
0.0114383949,
0.0190525558,
0.0071728653,
-0.0273864362,
0.0263374783,
-0.0250952691,
0.0253011733,
0.0322528891,
-0.06966272,
0.0090516703,
-0.0244233441,
-0.0190954451,
-0.0534851253,
-0.0188325997,
0.0036071667,
0.0047867829,
0.0040134075,
-0.0023372397,
-0.032727845,
0.0156990625,
-0.0047964226,
-0.0177571476,
0.0707586855,
0.0054179188,
0.0094188685,
-0.0220961217,
-0.0148567827,
-0.0451760739,
-0.0023088248,
0.0943252146,
-0.0021734741,
-0.0031218505,
-0.0305630919,
-0.0064181322,
-0.0059075574,
0.082494244,
-0.0495714322,
-0.0586265437,
0.0250872783,
-0.0203885287,
-0.0206233393,
0.0820687786,
0.018055601,
0.0758373588,
0.0628991798,
0.048715353,
-0.0273223296,
-0.0308141578,
-0.0140295485,
-0.0228862707,
-0.0655557737,
-0.001472273,
0.0247910935,
0.0486117005,
0.029315751,
-0.0095575321,
-0.0213583112,
0.0498480275,
-0.009459842,
-0.0432346687,
-0.0231308155,
-0.0169691984,
-0.0432412289,
0.0251228586,
-0.0191560965,
-0.0791531652,
0.045328036,
-0.0254232977,
0.0136420112,
0.0141966287,
-0.0172818694,
0.0134114698,
0.0869397074,
0.0392379649,
0.0250420813,
0.022241747,
-0.0195786301,
-0.0537211597,
-0.0394459628,
0.0299694277,
-0.0154058831,
0.056348633,
-0.0057846075,
0.0147013701,
-0.010508785,
-0.0415587761,
-0.042045638,
-0.0533706136,
0.0171722621,
0.0113350525,
0.0082211047,
-0.052599445,
-0.0619693324,
-0.0476642661,
0.0506987832,
0.0088774851,
-0.0412091278,
0.0021746452,
-0.0049714837,
0.0721909106,
0.0388085321,
-0.0175971091,
0.0168540571,
-0.0247935392,
-0.0218894053,
0.0803170428,
0.0002640146,
0.0476323776,
-0.0300001595,
-0.0031988586,
0.0350045227,
0.0199294351,
-0.0212951116,
0.0034082588,
0.0541410483,
-0.0257936083,
-0.0511604324,
0.034244556,
-0.0191649776,
-0.0186308939,
0.0165010542,
0.0141280014,
0.0159086678,
0.0249050204,
0.0009579486,
-0.0397141799,
0.0023364902,
0.0016299933,
0.0211273544,
-0.019101996,
-0.0060258424,
-0.0061599333,
-0.0800067857,
-0.0032022828,
0.0064247572,
-0.0418689884,
-0.0802455619,
-0.0396964774,
0.0018116297,
-0.0166226178,
0.0381732248,
-0.0002764499,
0.0034076083,
-0.0036903676,
0.0011422426,
0.0618126169,
-0.0339601785,
0.0237648636,
-0.0264223311,
0.0294278394,
0.0553360917,
0.016170539,
-0.0449506603,
-0.0199210215,
0.0475803129,
0.0195108913,
-0.0069882418,
0.0361376218,
0.0521801002,
0.0078627383,
-0.0203319807,
0.0374418311,
0.0401121899,
0.034251295,
-0.0096346624,
-0.0219294149,
0.0176690556,
-0.0012143139,
-0.019718416,
-0.0202756468,
-0.0343828015,
-0.0123130493,
0.043072477,
0.0342629813,
-0.0274347086,
-0.0272386521,
-0.0646657795,
0.0130127398,
-0.0125531936,
-0.0647298247,
0.0169174932,
0.044354517,
-0.0424478352,
-0.0435792208,
0.025138583,
-0.0418184251,
0.033803083,
-0.0081462367,
-0.0120666353,
-0.042525813,
0.0050769746,
0.0084062554,
0.006561466,
-0.0153685836,
0.0177302696,
-0.0226159077,
0.0379936174,
0.0030561304,
-0.0426723808,
-0.0318868645,
-0.0219831429,
-0.0915581882,
-0.0917018652,
0.0123077212,
0.0180140343,
0.0158885103,
0.02494031,
-0.0051225368,
-0.0981244743,
0.0705179051,
0.0408759415,
-0.0035992221,
0.0333155319,
0.0710853264,
-0.0419471487,
0.0069874129,
0.0855546072,
-0.0610531941,
0.0009771236,
0.077227667,
-0.0148069989,
-0.0358657539,
0.0145234475,
-0.000298506,
-0.001093772,
0.0919886231,
0.0024699273,
0.0119677689,
0.0243815556,
-0.0049733124,
-0.0038775282,
-0.0102006365,
0.0012302789,
0.0093383072,
0.0139839286,
0.0071789091,
0.0056472099,
-0.0423315689,
0.0277572833,
0.0098948777,
-0.0189943109,
0.0193668287,
0.0158185065,
0.0281742495,
0.0589987896,
0.0291123334,
-0.0403887443,
0.0427099504,
-0.0352269635,
0.0063723763,
-0.0210983418,
0.0022249818,
0.0329064168,
-0.006962928,
-0.0433851369,
0.0001078628,
-0.0914407223,
-0.0350086503,
0.0061262543,
0.0018482334,
0.0150980959,
-0.0002872881,
-0.0211842246,
-0.0273666251,
-0.0387806855,
-0.0338523649,
-0.0354421958,
0.0276269168,
-0.022247158,
0.037686605,
0.0138054807,
-0.0050358893,
0.0476178154,
0.0675501302,
0.0032414552,
0.0517374165,
0.0068859216,
0.0128102377,
-0.0045570075,
-0.0179438815,
-0.0015519026,
0.0235201716,
-0.0097533586,
-0.006293383,
-0.0431707241,
-0.0803554058,
-0.0093412176,
0.0180932973,
0.0261273943,
0.0173143577,
-0.0184961092,
0.0576894097,
0.0262714978,
0.0284241792,
-0.0510752425,
0.0300764646,
0.0313353464,
-0.0475918651,
0.0275579467,
-6.100965924e-33,
0.0325205326,
-0.0104078148,
-0.0536570437,
-0.0203130729,
0.0460641421,
0.0273945145,
-0.0045801471,
-0.008304121,
-0.0512251407,
0.010914579,
-0.0020829565,
-0.0012458881,
-0.0283158924,
0.0457704999,
-0.0109482566,
-0.0312825069,
0.0212176163,
-0.0208842754,
-0.0357254483,
0.0236684456,
0.0866747275,
-0.007860437,
0.0266676676,
-0.0371876545,
0.0407265313,
0.0067701992,
-0.0442792848,
0.029160412,
-0.0041193515,
0.0588281862,
-0.0066555417,
0.0480707102,
0.0111087924,
-0.0611928999,
-0.0026944543,
0.016644679,
-0.014624537,
-0.0338677615,
-0.0028014227,
0.0070441836,
0.0031939761,
-0.0192472115,
0.0465504974,
-0.036170233,
-0.0341427624,
-0.0206374694,
0.0136988899,
-0.0097695207,
-0.0295035373,
0.0173012298,
-0.0357351974,
0.0096701169,
-0.0104609774,
0.0189420432,
0.0026131207,
0.0034114909,
0.0493699573,
0.003556686,
-0.0545367748,
0.0201145969,
0.0019170113,
0.0446459837,
0.01880317,
0.0280001797,
0.0099360114,
0.0726235211,
0.0656489432,
0.0044190628,
-0.0298690535,
-0.0333188027,
0.0247815736,
0.0318309963,
0.0608096458,
0.0660792664,
0.0470051207,
-0.0440598018,
-0.0530543402,
-0.0191088431,
0.0115039693,
0.0299785454,
0.0369014591,
0.0173037667,
-0.0756864324,
0.0033850891,
-0.0280002449,
-0.0739243776,
-0.0631144792,
-0.0187393595,
-0.0010189249,
0.0221026801,
-0.0091874506,
0.003144064,
0.0131863328,
-0.0451617017,
-0.0349532664,
0.0487302504,
-0.0024729641,
-0.0011957972,
-0.0094802929,
0.0003420363,
-0.0021358088,
-0.0027811567,
0.0041221492,
-0.0412050448,
0.022439206,
0.0101911565,
0.038724184,
0.0306309443,
-0.0490014479,
-0.0364910439,
-0.0275680833,
-0.0188271347,
0.0579069555,
0.0179984625,
0.0462302603,
0.0018941794,
-0.0062531293,
-0.0121255619,
0.025420621,
0.0060890578,
-0.0056919269,
-0.000816319,
-0.0162255354,
0.0092736464,
-0.0439705588,
-0.037145257,
-0.0361849703,
0.0437979437,
0.0748143941,
-0.0678738952,
0.0059966352,
-0.0081432974,
2.779e-7,
0.0066839703,
0.0257333238,
0.001994353,
-0.008228098,
0.0435210951,
0.078435421,
0.0148507264,
0.0951559022,
-0.0139705772,
-0.0176304132,
-0.0507037304,
-0.0063218703,
0.0190167557,
0.0121243717,
-0.0326193683,
0.0298111513,
-0.0651608333,
0.0088252984,
-0.0222917348,
-0.0072210296,
-0.0033414077,
0.1213552579,
0.0502928682,
-0.013470483,
-0.019608032,
-0.0912797153,
0.0289115552,
-0.0199789349,
0.0375364199,
-0.0273245517,
0.0055452022,
0.0455089398,
0.0268737581,
0.0070434459,
-0.0351730734,
0.0179765038,
-0.0137705831,
0.0179358087,
0.0020776112,
-0.0173167586,
-0.0496634468,
-0.0461112335,
-0.0318597704,
-0.0639148951,
0.0716475248,
-0.0083424747,
-0.0116342036,
-0.0324963555,
0.0168160573,
0.0036439924,
0.0276259314,
-0.0145335887,
-0.0330829062,
0.0350743234,
0.0051762401,
0.0178556535,
0.0426831134,
-0.086863175,
-0.0153664956,
-0.0172305442,
-0.0536043234,
-0.0198153332,
-0.0045554065,
-0.0071326802,
0.0170291346,
-0.0000651828,
-0.0283430293,
2.567156373e-34,
0.0093138721,
-0.0434034914,
0.0212242045,
-0.0142377028,
0.0038612993,
-0.033117149,
0.0143922726,
0.0001025623,
0.0108896373,
-0.0646487847,
-0.0458399132
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.02748v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.02748v1 | Compositional Generalization for Data-to-Text Generation | 2023-12-05T13:23:15 | 2023-12-05T13:23:15 | Xinnuo Xu, Ivan Titov, Mirella Lapata | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Data-to-text generation involves transforming structured data, often
represented as predicate-argument tuples, into coherent textual descriptions.
Despite recent advances, systems still struggle when confronted with unseen
combinations of predicates, producing unfaithful descriptions (e.g.
hallucinations or omissions). We refer to this issue as compositional
generalisation, and it encouraged us to create a benchmark for assessing the
performance of different approaches on this specific problem. Furthermore, we
propose a novel model that addresses compositional generalization by clustering
predicates into groups. Our model generates text in a sentence-by-sentence
manner, relying on one cluster of predicates at a time. This approach
significantly outperforms T5~baselines across all evaluation metrics.Notably,
it achieved a 31% improvement over T5 in terms of a metric focused on
maintaining faithfulness to the input. | [
0.0144450599,
0.0850401223,
0.0251314789,
-0.0036007711,
-0.0021888572,
0.0097561963,
-0.0051538935,
-0.0137333479,
-0.0353704207,
-0.0596634187,
0.0028403169,
-0.0420065895,
0.0208611954,
0.0299964361,
0.0614824779,
-0.0881160498,
0.0334608331,
0.001614333,
-0.0337490328,
0.0319287702,
0.0131401587,
0.0364203192,
0.005160158,
0.0157888606,
-0.0390360467,
-0.0110412193,
-0.0287948847,
0.0168012846,
0.0240493212,
-0.016955208,
-0.0096394606,
0.0323315635,
0.0018882258,
-0.0077342149,
0.000001763,
-0.0183694381,
-0.026781695,
0.005388008,
0.0463333912,
-0.0237044673,
0.0333023444,
-0.0392715372,
0.0265186969,
0.0121620866,
-0.0264415592,
-0.0234695524,
0.0448203869,
0.0333971791,
0.0960399136,
0.1158310696,
-0.0267494805,
-0.0306035671,
-0.0038410623,
-0.0012304035,
0.0440718494,
0.0165007021,
0.0031462912,
0.0100317998,
0.0199192259,
-0.0144425966,
0.0080241477,
0.0172335003,
0.0362759493,
0.002991647,
0.0252270587,
0.0328825712,
-0.0359225459,
-0.013363569,
0.012757428,
0.0669741035,
-0.0123248398,
-0.0330665857,
0.0181879569,
0.0010358638,
-0.0022639479,
-0.0424059853,
-0.0187516026,
0.0589763522,
-0.0382606313,
0.0139570972,
0.0158007331,
0.0324292369,
0.0144304894,
-0.0151509214,
-0.0433528945,
0.0266752504,
0.0192422904,
-0.0339159854,
-0.0064763692,
0.0320222639,
-0.0046184994,
-0.0655762628,
0.0135085667,
0.0427571237,
-0.06131972,
-0.0055193854,
-0.1041420624,
-0.0533376411,
-0.0095556183,
-0.0359634496,
0.0844039246,
0.0404169932,
0.0218430236,
0.0104664844,
-0.0471953675,
0.0275459792,
-0.0154530378,
-0.0046399888,
-0.0748950988,
-0.0019746346,
-0.0598755293,
0.0100040305,
-0.0562123656,
0.0427165739,
-0.0264092889,
-0.0393398106,
-0.0259239301,
0.0295606311,
0.0050354046,
0.0214611609,
0.0091425879,
0.0264828354,
-0.0532557555,
-0.0078475438,
0.0129730115,
-0.0448774882,
-0.0424534902,
-0.0166975986,
0.0541147403,
-0.0098212622,
-0.0122224959,
0.0273685791,
0.020468723,
-0.0146946441,
-0.015616497,
0.0418067314,
-0.0287254155,
0.0150060961,
-0.042246066,
-0.0655385256,
-0.0168266464,
-0.0702145398,
0.000191882,
-0.0655358732,
0.0591280535,
-0.0072903712,
-0.0378366858,
-0.0528916866,
0.0144106699,
0.0370857157,
-0.0108277872,
0.0289134309,
-0.0344747342,
-0.0098197367,
-0.0229273327,
0.0008154695,
-0.0129893469,
0.0370053947,
0.0438269749,
0.0558800064,
-0.0225586891,
0.0263658036,
0.0167841054,
-0.0105273556,
0.043562118,
-0.0199342836,
-0.0043319189,
0.0151964221,
-0.0131088812,
0.0490564182,
0.0371360928,
0.0918334275,
-0.0323072262,
0.0359775126,
0.0610419363,
-0.0234388672,
0.0385761447,
0.0462021604,
0.1121073663,
0.0098152915,
-0.0120595191,
0.0427720658,
-0.0396172628,
0.0198074542,
-0.0071483981,
0.0607427061,
0.0488786176,
0.0274178833,
-0.0240669921,
-0.0361953676,
-0.0033320067,
-0.009024268,
0.0094387121,
-0.0373196453,
-0.0119187618,
0.0798366964,
-0.0757066533,
0.0306092631,
0.0191958528,
-0.0760758817,
0.045863349,
0.0133640608,
0.0213019904,
0.0590843037,
0.0281833261,
0.0089934785,
-0.0183607209,
-0.0068463306,
0.0271202475,
0.0576443598,
0.0173773095,
-0.0089755198,
0.0225781798,
-0.0320150629,
-0.0131169697,
-0.0464185588,
0.0000036383,
-0.0037236421,
0.0183453579,
-0.0057852506,
0.0677072182,
-0.0465021133,
-0.0229318365,
0.0588583909,
0.0272510592,
-0.0212479923,
0.0255254898,
0.0035363543,
0.0011087777,
-0.0104259038,
-0.0034393317,
0.0409186631,
-0.0170870274,
-0.0242041331,
-0.0153761739,
0.021046361,
-0.0704386383,
-0.0636144727,
-0.0172268003,
-0.0592177399,
0.0031089557,
-0.0052838102,
-0.0331758969,
-0.0647854507,
-0.0052301018,
-0.0479024798,
0.009360835,
-0.0253111329,
-0.0056981044,
0.0797904357,
-0.0050606439,
-0.0011685187,
0.0614202134,
-0.000139279,
-0.0122508332,
0.0138912657,
0.0186319891,
0.0107674459,
-0.0375787541,
0.020537829,
-0.0284685809,
0.0130974483,
0.0054785013,
0.0072036004,
0.015891552,
-0.0441785753,
-0.0313024856,
-0.0712002069,
0.0046672234,
-0.0033542584,
0.0142484112,
0.0522078611,
0.0129828276,
0.0237615556,
0.0130277826,
-0.0898640826,
-0.0080507025,
0.0553565472,
-0.0100688012,
0.0552856065,
-0.0001079515,
0.0034026997,
-0.0245018974,
0.0038704956,
-0.006540338,
0.0510355681,
0.0024157956,
-0.0025835689,
-0.0588039868,
0.0403108075,
-0.0524005108,
-0.0009760698,
0.0183785688,
-0.0002097117,
0.0107255941,
-0.0262419041,
0.0570089519,
0.0305948835,
0.0173207428,
-0.0143930288,
0.0185891464,
-0.0229818188,
-0.0148643209,
0.017070299,
-0.0313733369,
0.0354840197,
0.009011874,
-0.046008274,
0.0452565439,
0.0494251549,
0.026530588,
-0.0074819545,
-0.0636846274,
0.0365846269,
-0.0162209868,
-0.0242409948,
-0.0308613703,
-0.0075323274,
-0.0032313764,
0.0206751507,
-0.0362890437,
-0.030392874,
0.0602419712,
-0.0408443697,
0.0141500765,
-0.0110987956,
0.0125423241,
-0.0293829944,
0.0402902104,
0.015538563,
0.0562971346,
-0.0010716917,
-0.0055818311,
-0.0637586638,
0.0028884229,
0.0024284276,
-0.0082092769,
0.036241997,
-0.0419475958,
0.0080411807,
-0.0252216533,
-0.0220006965,
-0.047761593,
0.0231704582,
0.0381426588,
0.0177654363,
0.0504824035,
-0.0212147813,
-0.037675444,
-0.0142666753,
-0.006718256,
0.0372003987,
-0.0177671928,
-0.0429334603,
-0.0309158806,
0.0231741164,
0.0060105408,
-0.0314128809,
-0.0096157035,
-0.0521236658,
-0.0164111517,
0.0628821552,
-0.0150802014,
0.027270386,
-0.0293724108,
0.004902015,
-0.031936612,
-0.0092414562,
-0.0222248062,
0.0251520127,
0.0372289531,
-0.0592990629,
-0.0386040621,
0.0878824815,
0.0305057671,
0.0095919641,
0.0046401597,
0.0469302274,
0.07072559,
-0.0123234438,
0.0297666676,
-0.086182937,
-0.0007856853,
0.0072801788,
0.027365813,
-0.0086020986,
-0.0357984714,
-0.0411297195,
-0.0813511536,
0.0421194918,
0.0435516462,
-0.0475889556,
-0.0230914056,
-0.0010160762,
-0.0375702418,
0.0149091966,
-0.0034727696,
0.0313382819,
-0.0255529098,
0.0355445072,
-0.0018510674,
-0.0278940499,
-0.0246622432,
-0.0217050239,
-0.0231385417,
0.0024106568,
0.0560153536,
0.0273425952,
0.0436586328,
0.0108963335,
-0.0099705877,
0.0113439215,
-0.0043160981,
0.0202316716,
0.0299428999,
-0.0244282503,
0.0033755638,
0.0235716272,
0.0556531362,
-0.0594496392,
0.005028408,
0.0093284054,
0.0287129935,
-0.0106366836,
-0.0332576446,
-0.0332617387,
0.0333450623,
0.0378242098,
0.0769318342,
0.0422823317,
-0.0100720534,
-0.0464797281,
-0.0512164757,
-0.0084739923,
-0.1080171987,
0.0006058494,
0.019947594,
0.0023815678,
0.0076589184,
-0.1214479059,
-0.0508602746,
0.0420112312,
0.0530851819,
-0.0088778278,
-0.0360377952,
-0.012717396,
-0.0596299656,
-0.0485712998,
0.0030932631,
-0.0187744815,
0.0191957857,
-0.0301267747,
-0.0342653543,
-0.0101838913,
-0.0345798172,
-0.0072555426,
0.0317919925,
-0.0955155566,
-0.0272647776,
-0.0033258344,
0.047348693,
0.0152976681,
0.0411707871,
0.007690026,
0.0025114932,
0.0633378178,
0.0487189144,
-0.0029409253,
0.0109608304,
0.0180457048,
0.0016365835,
0.0112381252,
0.0290327799,
-0.0450222865,
0.0320060775,
0.0178447478,
0.0291767996,
0.0215305258,
0.0179509427,
0.0772794634,
0.0137316296,
-0.030928649,
-0.0327894017,
0.0419105887,
-0.016128486,
-0.0376419686,
-0.0541058294,
-0.0626152605,
-0.0821210891,
0.045154389,
0.037756592,
0.034549579,
0.0137158632,
0.0073923632,
-0.0140800988,
0.0277018193,
-0.0236067921,
-0.0508089289,
0.0324049108,
-0.0126312161,
0.0631775036,
-0.0105646281,
-0.0461236574,
0.0283497665,
-0.0527637191,
0.0190031249,
-0.0242896229,
0.0153987966,
0.0396761671,
0.018561339,
-0.0453236401,
0.0177996755,
-0.0563564412,
0.0051031923,
-0.0867705494,
-0.0226563457,
0.0102283088,
0.0319958813,
0.0582697242,
-0.0341060609,
-0.0020279759,
0.0057235314,
0.0789465532,
0.0172883738,
-0.0160638206,
-0.0148869595,
-0.0103353253,
0.0001081239,
-0.0299990717,
0.0932993591,
-0.0174368862,
0.0141859865,
-0.003056726,
0.017525956,
-0.070620127,
-0.0356972627,
-0.0129974512,
0.0226237066,
0.0180782098,
-0.0437207781,
-0.0085944012,
-0.0380083136,
0.0231850464,
0.0472832844,
0.029436456,
0.0084834788,
0.0660891756,
0.0419772156,
0.0012733655,
-0.0218435265,
-0.022309443,
-0.021372566,
0.0343252942,
-0.0278961249,
-0.0426178761,
-5.982406298e-33,
-0.0561180748,
-0.0254871119,
0.0072107399,
-0.0270246696,
-0.0378641635,
-0.0187951513,
-0.028428724,
0.0094949296,
0.034214288,
0.0133251939,
0.0172571037,
-0.0029201144,
0.0110804336,
0.0560499579,
-0.0090691065,
0.0261947159,
0.064890705,
-0.0082474602,
-0.0454327092,
0.0633483008,
0.0394973829,
0.0157402828,
0.0231041927,
-0.0413283594,
0.0220983513,
-0.0142462756,
-0.0441395156,
0.0026463026,
-0.0019131575,
0.009669357,
-0.0082898028,
0.0166093037,
0.0213239603,
0.0249993689,
-0.0624684505,
0.0136570288,
-0.039886374,
0.0053975265,
-0.0062399679,
-0.0407948308,
-0.0872266218,
-0.0442992561,
0.0345279165,
-0.033472918,
0.0304427892,
-0.0531078838,
0.028001124,
-0.0354399011,
-0.0181492101,
-0.0582516938,
-0.0762480423,
0.0033612533,
-0.0125354659,
-0.0174966287,
-0.0507659167,
0.0683868229,
-0.0176933967,
0.0135494061,
-0.0484213941,
0.0284134988,
0.0030880489,
0.0223010946,
0.0287306104,
0.0152454143,
-0.0161564182,
0.0443333387,
0.0226863865,
0.007248017,
-0.063811034,
0.0797570869,
-0.0295922924,
0.059961006,
0.0148966946,
0.0573167242,
0.0348889045,
0.0040540118,
-0.0384798013,
0.0330188386,
-0.0643152297,
-0.0242348183,
0.0203457568,
-0.0151361218,
-0.0086734444,
-0.0266850106,
-0.0222623385,
-0.027933348,
-0.0116636632,
-0.0407832302,
0.043014124,
0.0378931053,
-0.0473770425,
-0.0145499753,
0.0117635839,
-0.0098861754,
0.0274130274,
-0.0105062993,
-0.0633643419,
0.0131273353,
-0.0108074946,
0.0054292311,
-0.0527604856,
-0.0554345399,
0.0642516613,
0.063360557,
0.0119203115,
0.0209014565,
0.0366857797,
0.0434284545,
-0.0513602123,
0.0281723514,
-0.0416954942,
0.0383991562,
-0.0132249389,
0.0024197779,
0.0320497081,
-0.021149084,
-0.0111932978,
0.0505650155,
-0.0253003836,
-0.0066143451,
-0.0033818942,
-0.0062362393,
0.0243864562,
0.0315790661,
0.0023623558,
0.0157350637,
-0.0596525036,
-0.0477808863,
0.0749409348,
-0.0332687013,
0.0076586665,
0.0201314483,
2.467e-7,
0.0411219187,
-0.0019392278,
0.03542348,
0.0521569997,
-0.0034761014,
-0.0149913812,
0.0081655392,
0.0504599698,
0.0113372458,
-0.0023682842,
0.0221620519,
0.0057959557,
0.0450505652,
0.0535595641,
-0.0641351938,
0.0013349443,
-0.0839755386,
-0.0131217521,
-0.0668412969,
-0.0205063168,
0.0746011212,
0.0520048887,
-0.0299615934,
-0.0046710386,
0.0481166355,
-0.0357033424,
0.087053448,
0.0153953042,
-0.0359146781,
0.0327114426,
0.0322825797,
-0.0007017151,
-0.0220710319,
-0.0068144826,
-0.0122937495,
-0.0206894334,
0.0236761812,
0.046822615,
0.0343393721,
-0.0128222527,
0.030734865,
-0.0290773381,
0.0159038212,
-0.0368429311,
0.0551314205,
-0.0791336969,
-0.0082575791,
0.0202661995,
-0.0302098542,
0.0298770126,
-0.0118227722,
-0.021686906,
-0.0148121892,
0.0120115839,
0.0441232659,
0.0093046483,
0.0026942813,
-0.0384286754,
-0.0580440909,
-0.0175915398,
-0.016374737,
-0.0206555966,
-0.0193237029,
-0.0026277155,
0.010556831,
-0.0355162248,
-0.0335001461,
2.315506221e-34,
0.0338306613,
-0.0142065696,
0.0256978106,
-0.0460285693,
0.0473550893,
-0.0198728573,
0.0062519205,
0.0025022146,
-0.0092780376,
-0.0571192577,
-0.047401052
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.02730v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.02730v1 | Towards Measuring Representational Similarity of Large Language Models | 2023-12-05T12:48:04 | 2023-12-05T12:48:04 | Max Klabunde, Mehdi Ben Amor, Michael Granitzer, Florian Lemmerich | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Understanding the similarity of the numerous released large language models
(LLMs) has many uses, e.g., simplifying model selection, detecting illegal
model reuse, and advancing our understanding of what makes LLMs perform well.
In this work, we measure the similarity of representations of a set of LLMs
with 7B parameters. Our results suggest that some LLMs are substantially
different from others. We identify challenges of using representational
similarity measures that suggest the need of careful study of similarity scores
to avoid false conclusions. | [
-0.0007399495,
0.0591730587,
-0.0182360839,
0.0526350476,
-0.0504359044,
0.0178444684,
0.0414442122,
0.0200546011,
0.0006920773,
-0.066824764,
-0.042733375,
-0.0526655838,
0.0184826478,
0.0026427826,
0.0227148645,
-0.0225271881,
0.0315039903,
-0.0409679115,
-0.0217123348,
-0.0114243068,
-0.0033886286,
0.0056157438,
0.0394929238,
0.059634082,
0.0388361476,
-0.0234970786,
0.0228832308,
-0.0360545665,
-0.005787767,
-0.0050216988,
-0.0219398253,
0.0364114903,
0.0315722823,
0.0860987231,
0.0000016241,
-0.0421022177,
-0.0141282734,
-0.0100623313,
0.0032783335,
0.0864379629,
0.0853772089,
-0.0021550832,
-0.0012008889,
0.0262721162,
0.0024469646,
-0.0372184478,
0.0532921404,
0.0113431299,
0.0267359111,
0.0495523363,
-0.0110285226,
-0.0456136875,
-0.0062590381,
-0.0081681656,
-0.0309793819,
-0.0049441056,
0.0318050943,
0.0603738576,
0.0164050795,
-0.0021514199,
-0.0082680713,
0.0467619672,
-0.0315996446,
0.0060826666,
-0.0516935326,
0.0251662675,
-0.011563017,
0.0042351508,
0.0285103954,
0.0539810434,
-0.0343729779,
-0.0734826401,
0.0008729444,
-0.0002869879,
-0.0278333556,
0.0348312184,
-0.0524960235,
0.0499400571,
0.0299400873,
0.064261362,
0.0289775822,
0.0163713507,
0.0513747931,
-0.0285833385,
-0.044811938,
0.0295374691,
0.0538557768,
-0.006414644,
-0.0554326847,
-0.0367419012,
-0.026884634,
-0.0395992771,
-0.0286634993,
-0.0157694202,
-0.0160481595,
0.0172982402,
-0.0478623174,
-0.0043135616,
0.0392558724,
-0.0739986151,
0.0833730325,
0.0452750623,
-0.012168969,
0.0490903147,
-0.0480854325,
0.0864492655,
-0.0378650464,
0.006845647,
-0.0412501693,
-0.011585162,
-0.0578056574,
0.0013941805,
0.0053775026,
0.0209756978,
0.014814036,
-0.0331971906,
-0.0255976971,
0.029301405,
-0.0188502315,
0.0024045554,
-0.0010548318,
-0.0271894243,
0.0431605093,
0.0002776457,
-0.0106935995,
0.0206603035,
0.0112351431,
-0.0023964236,
-0.0458562896,
-0.0593944639,
0.0141109545,
0.0283638574,
-0.0078590978,
-0.0119378334,
-0.0195077695,
0.0652826056,
0.0224648006,
-0.0095136622,
-0.0265933778,
0.0158921927,
-0.0067582554,
-0.059216246,
-0.0130585274,
-0.0778285936,
0.0345854275,
0.020367872,
0.0050604693,
-0.0552197061,
-0.0123350359,
-0.0057797786,
-0.0231939852,
0.0586205572,
-0.0078103957,
0.0295729656,
-0.0129928691,
-0.0122368475,
0.0096294973,
0.065355368,
0.0040386389,
-0.0123554403,
0.0486525856,
-0.024212366,
-0.0110095078,
0.0525174104,
-0.0173198022,
0.0365188345,
-0.0526775122,
0.0028044381,
0.0512707271,
0.0319599882,
0.0304435212,
0.0693116933,
-0.0264861677,
-0.035549853,
0.0559438318,
0.0692687556,
0.0314416178,
0.0222945791,
0.0313998684,
0.0112760561,
0.0236785915,
-0.0008473803,
-0.0394878499,
-0.006776033,
-0.0193019118,
0.0231672153,
0.0359583981,
0.0381721593,
-0.0232221708,
0.0318133645,
-0.0466154553,
-0.0430574082,
0.0066936309,
-0.0224710274,
0.0311809815,
-0.0519021191,
-0.0392773226,
0.0749771148,
0.0272534229,
-0.0599941351,
-0.0499457605,
-0.04882228,
0.0401779562,
0.0357245989,
0.0156961195,
-0.0028709541,
0.0100841392,
0.0118052,
0.0052228686,
0.0097699892,
0.064340055,
-0.0042875311,
0.0082520936,
-0.0465363897,
-0.0122687528,
-0.0018502707,
0.0425450318,
0.0377507173,
-0.0197814386,
-0.004454941,
0.0387033075,
-0.036226213,
-0.044205673,
0.021326676,
-0.0377834737,
0.015290265,
-0.0150439274,
-0.0205445588,
0.0473660491,
-0.0142809292,
-0.0172460116,
0.0370860063,
-0.005017607,
-0.0431718715,
-0.0100337202,
0.0062550046,
-0.0357458852,
0.0096338931,
0.0542908944,
-0.005255932,
0.0328071788,
0.0467771813,
-0.0060361731,
-0.0249510333,
0.0534694158,
-0.0220807549,
0.0836397409,
-0.0384315215,
0.069752343,
-0.06992542,
0.0122044599,
-0.0238362048,
0.0569353327,
0.0166515168,
0.0567216836,
0.0260190759,
0.0048010466,
0.0605604835,
-0.0253827926,
-0.0480614565,
0.0288486425,
0.0104242964,
0.0271594767,
0.0171643198,
-0.0202217586,
-0.006836229,
-0.0260259509,
-0.067059204,
-0.0065597668,
-0.0107721938,
0.0063552987,
0.0466168523,
0.0053842431,
-0.0026186116,
0.0196816903,
-0.0237127244,
-0.0266244356,
0.0098965913,
0.0199692436,
-0.0023629535,
-0.0466779396,
-0.0758025423,
-0.0617436096,
-0.0264127497,
-0.0135571389,
0.1017966792,
-0.0313249752,
-0.0088693546,
-0.0734654069,
0.0516131893,
-0.0331760868,
0.0229288917,
-0.0069827875,
-0.0330736563,
0.0080051571,
-0.0208472908,
0.0202357396,
0.0246223677,
0.0019518355,
-0.0096779307,
0.0937573537,
0.0087912232,
-0.0670320988,
-0.0585262403,
-0.0017762489,
-0.0239274055,
-0.0289429259,
-0.0548352078,
-0.0195277613,
0.0541606434,
0.0212319847,
-0.0141189918,
-0.0260402448,
0.0105677657,
-0.0375092328,
0.0224440694,
-0.0425757058,
-0.008796433,
-0.0090631209,
0.0278132167,
-0.0003662286,
-0.0854126438,
0.0152398096,
-0.0740978569,
0.0352242999,
-0.013508481,
-0.0186428856,
-0.0650232732,
0.065994136,
0.0000606048,
0.0296480078,
0.0037557755,
-0.0095149912,
-0.010862072,
0.0280841812,
0.0303770266,
-0.0179534163,
0.0779341236,
-0.0186448544,
0.0469476543,
0.0104662562,
-0.0057943105,
-0.0279195309,
-0.0317083038,
-0.04699241,
0.03207637,
0.025925342,
-0.0368379205,
-0.0605358295,
0.0670228004,
-0.0143696945,
0.0019890817,
0.0114729544,
0.0169300288,
-0.009046386,
0.0064265742,
0.0275658648,
-0.0067553753,
0.042104926,
-0.0309070181,
0.0364026502,
-0.01210248,
0.0364768878,
0.0486526228,
-0.073825255,
0.0048770118,
0.031583108,
-0.0252771806,
-0.0146351987,
0.0153685939,
0.0217002053,
-0.0090033012,
0.005780411,
0.1497849375,
0.0325599536,
-0.0224222727,
0.0338087715,
-0.0180284791,
0.0387955271,
0.0261395518,
0.0021301324,
-0.0392351784,
-0.0114156324,
-0.0062131183,
-0.0129585089,
0.0145821627,
0.0003184811,
0.0020687049,
-0.0963876396,
0.003382829,
0.0374321826,
-0.0359369367,
-0.0345259123,
-0.0428476185,
0.0031950676,
-0.0183348302,
0.0346718729,
0.0192671828,
-0.0461661965,
-0.0350039862,
-0.0142241986,
-0.0355067365,
-0.0662668571,
0.0416648611,
-0.052381441,
0.0567566939,
0.0361025073,
0.0242683999,
0.0013526983,
-0.0211470909,
0.0047873794,
0.0010429571,
-0.0281991232,
0.018521864,
0.0096438145,
0.040075697,
-0.0338958502,
-0.0074804323,
-0.0051189014,
-0.0439430587,
-0.0074499319,
-0.037097726,
0.0459058098,
-0.0218292773,
-0.0495219082,
-0.0007252161,
-0.0035525658,
-0.0107842265,
0.0938810185,
0.044063583,
0.0097568464,
-0.012174027,
-0.0014511412,
-0.0242867339,
0.0147657273,
-0.0514997691,
0.0166280009,
-0.0048118788,
0.0036912907,
-0.0424621552,
0.0208048411,
0.0027143592,
-0.007803136,
0.0041663027,
0.0421678498,
0.0256457701,
-0.0457446724,
-0.0184141602,
-0.0094351489,
-0.0409555361,
0.0141338455,
-0.0483775921,
0.0007490957,
0.0520098172,
0.0420625992,
-0.026565535,
-0.0191236828,
-0.1210350171,
-0.0724894777,
-0.0174188688,
-0.006012002,
0.0202584714,
-0.0025550197,
-0.0012387236,
-0.0561143905,
0.0142053161,
-0.0188132059,
-0.0122959865,
0.0321558975,
-0.0090577705,
-0.0253647193,
0.0025242153,
0.0643248484,
-0.0340128094,
0.0017369252,
0.0113575757,
0.0240852311,
-0.0107655963,
-0.0439411439,
0.0069135106,
0.0470328592,
-0.0163015369,
0.0015584305,
-0.0112005472,
-0.0214611702,
-0.0162154902,
-0.0422025211,
0.0052255844,
-0.021889206,
0.0259022005,
0.0321545638,
0.0059086932,
-0.0011855686,
-0.0026039726,
0.0012912092,
0.0424240306,
-0.0274778232,
0.0360959135,
-0.0231987759,
-0.0053774375,
0.014548921,
-0.0132484632,
-0.035897214,
0.0230881907,
-0.0161473174,
0.0059294649,
-0.0327931494,
0.0184299722,
-0.0058164792,
0.0276165791,
-0.0424923636,
0.0463510491,
-0.0309515167,
-0.0948683843,
-0.0152781121,
0.030456176,
0.0632917956,
-0.0266078506,
0.0789209977,
-0.0261721686,
0.0029570651,
-0.0527116545,
0.0273737833,
-0.0051016351,
-0.0022808644,
0.0317562707,
0.0155015327,
-0.0494667366,
0.0124889174,
0.0851899832,
0.0291223451,
0.0255748332,
0.0087527549,
-0.0273475721,
-0.0091766855,
-0.0373377912,
0.0015400648,
0.0155739328,
-0.0499639735,
-0.0144732539,
-0.0491547324,
-0.0598239973,
0.0000373344,
-0.0007981624,
-0.0261199009,
0.0095385313,
-0.005590898,
0.0601074249,
-0.0037273176,
0.0346999057,
-0.0412253775,
-0.0324857011,
-0.0242785402,
-0.0262118764,
-0.0248573367,
-5.766182928e-33,
-0.0050381757,
0.0258473884,
-0.0135513619,
-0.0798794553,
-0.008924081,
-0.0135077601,
-0.0196542963,
0.0172506683,
-0.0408452861,
-0.014441723,
0.0266607758,
-0.0088461554,
0.0012973719,
0.0092894332,
0.0207764637,
0.0041174442,
0.0298257172,
0.0279231109,
-0.0303673726,
0.0138206333,
0.0544366203,
-0.0019166589,
0.0482214689,
-0.0487995967,
0.0030544153,
-0.0247727204,
0.0112115601,
-0.0111801624,
0.0022112757,
0.0938546881,
-0.0409789011,
0.0512921996,
0.0152678983,
-0.022005748,
-0.0570955686,
-0.0156339537,
0.0033263853,
-0.0172065087,
0.0638917461,
-0.0149490424,
0.0247515533,
-0.0278525781,
0.0387283675,
-0.0117340032,
-0.0275963768,
-0.0123245474,
0.0111795533,
-0.0145589402,
-0.0301107559,
0.0325765721,
-0.0540669747,
0.0250505637,
-0.0137357488,
0.0269551072,
0.0234544668,
0.0230434891,
-0.0247673709,
0.0583861917,
-0.0337290727,
0.0224023126,
0.0138326623,
0.0624531619,
0.086429432,
0.0136001734,
0.037756294,
0.0762239546,
0.0157449171,
-0.0387393683,
-0.0164118614,
-0.0009407381,
0.0593357719,
0.0441107973,
0.0507820323,
0.030729387,
-0.0011494306,
-0.0127653265,
-0.049884446,
0.006042812,
0.0158252027,
0.0132309906,
0.0536306873,
0.0198802631,
-0.0255080033,
-0.04594687,
-0.0574297905,
-0.0014433045,
-0.0345915332,
-0.0289842393,
0.0492239259,
-0.0504109077,
-0.0146059776,
-0.0189880598,
0.0575276837,
-0.0766542479,
-0.0562696755,
0.0171412472,
-0.008165855,
0.0052085677,
0.0019874307,
0.0395901278,
-0.0321715176,
-0.0536837094,
-0.0084352326,
-0.0156221539,
0.0188833121,
-0.0058645075,
-0.007107255,
-0.0072344854,
-0.0843476355,
0.0013822881,
-0.0202808306,
-0.0817161202,
-0.0066291587,
0.0013416723,
0.0186476335,
-0.01479189,
0.0144563057,
0.0123257004,
0.0212994125,
-0.0228837878,
0.0073773926,
-0.0026899353,
-0.0034616354,
0.0316286385,
-0.0084437793,
0.0052784299,
-0.0790424496,
0.0403264947,
0.0833284631,
-0.0056329928,
-0.0271200091,
0.0100380164,
2.213e-7,
0.0590382852,
0.0290482976,
-0.0038841276,
0.0203646012,
0.0191645101,
0.0382844061,
-0.0382426344,
0.010051298,
0.01730299,
0.0027913516,
0.0007265537,
0.0006396542,
0.0420662835,
0.0095822383,
-0.0480361506,
0.0414347276,
-0.1136217117,
-0.0214418601,
-0.0551360957,
-0.0199026559,
0.0266270451,
0.1257427633,
0.0206465777,
0.0013374906,
-0.014420148,
-0.0604806133,
0.061123319,
-0.0619217008,
-0.0049569299,
0.0385273173,
0.0123810219,
-0.0079740947,
-0.0020414658,
-0.001062802,
0.0214703195,
0.0269545782,
0.037376374,
0.0281853806,
0.0035680372,
0.0169831105,
0.0006545929,
-0.0437488183,
-0.0232738201,
-0.0773503259,
0.0679412037,
-0.0295542795,
-0.0274552591,
-0.0531981662,
0.0012617292,
0.0168516226,
0.0249980614,
-0.002228589,
-0.0208540279,
0.0565547198,
0.0129188048,
-0.0305438824,
-0.0046260185,
-0.0454468913,
-0.0241953544,
-0.0020793353,
-0.0456131212,
-0.0469696969,
-0.027835561,
-0.0062295054,
0.046591863,
-0.0216684714,
0.0420201011,
1.945227796e-34,
0.0369550288,
0.0243972782,
0.0139174927,
0.0272854287,
0.0441472977,
-0.0247642733,
0.0039483318,
0.0356292091,
-0.0355065875,
-0.10292463,
0.0063329958
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.02706v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.02706v2 | Large Knowledge Model: Perspectives and Challenges | 2023-12-05T12:07:30 | 2024-06-26T16:11:55 | Huajun Chen | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Humankind's understanding of the world is fundamentally linked to our
perception and cognition, with \emph{human languages} serving as one of the
major carriers of \emph{world knowledge}. In this vein, \emph{Large Language
Models} (LLMs) like ChatGPT epitomize the pre-training of extensive,
sequence-based world knowledge into neural networks, facilitating the
processing and manipulation of this knowledge in a parametric space. This
article explores large models through the lens of "knowledge". We initially
investigate the role of symbolic knowledge such as Knowledge Graphs (KGs) in
enhancing LLMs, covering aspects like knowledge-augmented language model,
structure-inducing pre-training, knowledgeable prompts, structured CoT,
knowledge editing, semantic tools for LLM and knowledgeable AI agents.
Subsequently, we examine how LLMs can boost traditional symbolic knowledge
bases, encompassing aspects like using LLM as KG builder and controller,
structured knowledge pretraining, and LLM-enhanced symbolic reasoning.
Considering the intricate nature of human knowledge, we advocate for the
creation of \emph{Large Knowledge Models} (LKM), specifically engineered to
manage diversified spectrum of knowledge structures. This promising undertaking
would entail several key challenges, such as disentangling knowledge base from
language models, cognitive alignment with human knowledge, integration of
perception and cognition, and building large commonsense models for interacting
with physical world, among others. We finally propose a five-"A" principle to
distinguish the concept of LKM. | [
0.0595818646,
0.0073629539,
-0.0364581607,
0.0482265763,
-0.0386335179,
0.0059186486,
-0.036607217,
0.0399133302,
0.0520034581,
-0.040497914,
-0.0148877474,
0.0221557971,
-0.0211511273,
0.0226413589,
0.0250621978,
-0.0528623052,
0.0445544422,
-0.0349043123,
0.0249191578,
-0.0002881571,
-0.0370555334,
-0.0063015702,
-0.0041562216,
0.0101995263,
-0.0340674259,
-0.0221563447,
-0.0427862778,
-0.0194211956,
0.0128392298,
-0.0433612615,
-0.0447010472,
0.0151393209,
0.0468338095,
0.0386325642,
0.0000022404,
-0.0385718979,
0.0297387838,
0.0047134641,
-0.043397136,
-0.0222502369,
-0.02211928,
0.0140877329,
0.0226654038,
-0.0391523875,
-0.04734914,
0.0100343674,
0.0359156355,
0.0441459417,
0.0273386594,
0.063725017,
0.0012583712,
-0.0249799639,
0.0511860922,
-0.0081117684,
0.0325856768,
-0.014237754,
0.0654752105,
0.0557875745,
0.039660152,
0.0177299343,
-0.0266330466,
0.0362508334,
0.0317805856,
0.005708382,
0.0392920226,
0.0332749449,
-0.0041628908,
-0.0123211173,
-0.0068366742,
0.07787247,
0.0094652483,
-0.0203004293,
0.0255359095,
0.0144124003,
0.0327530466,
0.0258007757,
-0.0411224626,
0.0434650928,
-0.0080748154,
-0.0041084797,
-0.0090557411,
-0.0284648109,
0.0289673936,
0.0104174782,
-0.0366692096,
0.0741178691,
0.0022646554,
-0.0047913622,
0.0017402254,
-0.0205994956,
-0.035923373,
-0.0735413283,
0.0063870973,
0.0766946077,
-0.004885918,
0.04337525,
-0.0134909842,
0.028039813,
0.0041337716,
-0.0821566433,
0.0265053157,
0.0350522473,
0.0213408936,
0.0595797785,
-0.0428013131,
0.0776905641,
-0.0081871459,
0.0423652753,
-0.0395554863,
0.0075491546,
-0.0925339013,
-0.0361266471,
-0.0339320153,
0.0609484315,
-0.0227089915,
-0.0168896522,
-0.0119682429,
0.0568037555,
-0.0070139999,
0.0691065937,
0.0245757531,
0.0048130695,
0.0274651367,
-0.0231508706,
-0.055259984,
0.0030907474,
-0.0265197828,
0.0095798625,
0.0010456843,
-0.0173602346,
0.0411989652,
-0.010480362,
0.0028833158,
0.0005040038,
-0.0148127861,
0.1054218933,
0.0404727906,
-0.0082583157,
-0.0340049118,
-0.0589054227,
0.0128801474,
-0.0517674983,
0.0197745953,
-0.035528414,
0.0382559858,
-0.0002227543,
-0.0154873775,
-0.0240821633,
0.0199472401,
-0.0172137246,
-0.0350186937,
0.0551650114,
-0.0300887078,
0.008980698,
0.0056197727,
0.0309105162,
-0.0232296884,
0.0144565692,
0.0417923965,
0.0188992489,
0.0442000553,
0.001036102,
-0.0416031741,
0.0099426406,
0.0206407793,
-0.0361448973,
-0.014795945,
0.0173841193,
-0.0062333168,
0.0371151939,
-0.0194798782,
0.031646695,
-0.0243114568,
-0.0201561879,
0.0870958865,
0.0530430079,
0.0181635488,
0.0172634553,
0.0688429996,
-0.009693143,
0.0342888944,
-0.0236595832,
-0.0581399165,
0.0229431652,
-0.0609945767,
0.0164429415,
-0.0682632253,
0.016031079,
-0.0158448294,
-0.0442146808,
-0.0097896764,
0.0109784687,
0.0165037625,
0.0191998836,
0.0560270101,
-0.0264353622,
0.0037651241,
0.0323515646,
0.032210201,
-0.0197995398,
0.0233978126,
-0.0402690321,
0.0386366025,
0.0683306828,
0.0305159688,
-0.038037356,
-0.0421093032,
0.0298219025,
-0.0526273884,
0.0261693317,
0.0105278986,
-0.025670588,
-0.0547822341,
-0.0208300482,
-0.0224884003,
-0.0066621029,
-0.0168449767,
0.0374702476,
0.0005765633,
0.0116130933,
0.0021816625,
-0.0341065302,
-0.0106339743,
0.0036419437,
-0.0385119505,
-0.0083215591,
-0.0625918359,
0.0040766718,
0.0477095991,
0.0248793233,
0.0098013123,
0.0090970024,
0.0525803044,
-0.018226156,
-0.0578949451,
0.0246025696,
-0.058206819,
-0.0234665368,
0.0674124211,
-0.0073094703,
0.0158934034,
-0.0102606611,
-0.0125882477,
-0.0387217812,
0.0265330393,
-0.0075481455,
0.089133963,
-0.0369307324,
0.01846922,
0.002423526,
-0.0539317168,
-0.0105288308,
0.101633817,
-0.0024362709,
-0.0339574143,
0.0013064393,
-0.0070852889,
0.0190108996,
-0.0085217059,
0.0013621146,
0.0431640483,
0.0245550144,
0.0050984621,
0.024956746,
-0.0182215683,
-0.0459374152,
-0.0044210874,
-0.1124436036,
-0.0132672191,
0.0212135073,
-0.0148137631,
-0.0094506256,
-0.0172319598,
0.0094558913,
-0.0018264032,
-0.0464972183,
0.0753918961,
-0.0016047412,
0.0113679832,
0.0349176899,
0.0257625207,
-0.046460636,
0.0073497314,
0.0098942686,
-0.0161371138,
0.037719883,
0.0429426245,
-0.0242428351,
-0.0270220339,
0.0628862455,
-0.0670032576,
0.0217608549,
-0.0341880508,
-0.0384431668,
0.0012352357,
-0.0161079671,
-0.0006698997,
0.0526317358,
-0.0153710302,
0.0295140743,
0.0289859902,
-0.0328960419,
-0.0252202656,
0.0053396439,
-0.0195715334,
0.0042958553,
-0.0348291509,
0.0233806279,
-0.0058834837,
0.062092863,
-0.0032984775,
-0.0136902556,
-0.0711146593,
0.0283994135,
-0.0095944554,
-0.0236755833,
-0.0567419864,
-0.0501788035,
0.0080884611,
0.0134567134,
-0.0435667038,
-0.0072272909,
0.0672129393,
-0.0068271453,
0.0349610001,
0.0185104441,
-0.014119043,
-0.0313379727,
0.0873672813,
0.0263728611,
0.0424918272,
0.0008802529,
0.0031890101,
-0.073988907,
-0.0297672097,
0.0070485142,
-0.0153941289,
-0.028824199,
-0.0737233013,
0.0251033027,
0.006681412,
-0.0250353198,
-0.0384697728,
0.0465427898,
-0.0366238058,
0.0279507134,
0.0050415196,
-0.0345938765,
0.0187677853,
0.0030857136,
0.0287351478,
-0.0031005652,
0.008084489,
-0.0073351697,
-0.0479442328,
0.0103819827,
0.0305656083,
0.0064296951,
0.0105677471,
-0.0156212673,
0.0159553383,
0.061395213,
-0.0236266516,
-0.0331227928,
-0.0079228273,
0.0171906278,
-0.0009872015,
-0.0522007085,
-0.066739656,
0.0013506445,
0.0166122541,
-0.0582303777,
0.01448981,
0.1110943556,
0.0224785674,
-0.0128860092,
0.0287037622,
0.004915948,
-0.034690503,
0.0217768084,
0.0154335881,
-0.0921852812,
-0.005127402,
-0.018178178,
-0.0617812723,
-0.0124071483,
-0.0874485672,
-0.0074200286,
-0.0731330737,
-0.0036054808,
0.0200400092,
-0.0524580851,
-0.0458503328,
0.0200699102,
-0.0152971661,
0.0428016633,
-0.0445794463,
0.0131506696,
-0.0001042171,
-0.0145543572,
0.0066421451,
0.0130772917,
-0.0214804839,
0.0104812048,
-0.0394204147,
0.0321335122,
0.0231500976,
0.0566788502,
0.0097326627,
-0.0345750451,
-0.0144956633,
0.0310253054,
0.0566561036,
-0.0007551791,
-0.0294879172,
-0.0068798657,
-0.0165717509,
-0.0455662161,
0.0125560919,
-0.056302499,
-0.0256491955,
0.0186628755,
0.1301692575,
-0.0258737653,
-0.0141673917,
-0.0025048817,
-0.0121008595,
-0.0139686381,
0.0816940963,
-0.0156744272,
-0.0032069732,
-0.006190327,
-0.0171313006,
-0.0102525642,
0.0336022712,
-0.0238219146,
0.0207504258,
-0.0119708804,
0.0079534892,
-0.0906605273,
-0.0137613416,
0.0238090083,
0.0307815336,
0.0299380776,
-0.0195642132,
0.0591464043,
-0.0125089865,
-0.0506624803,
0.0162948389,
-0.0555923209,
-0.0283506699,
-0.02168989,
-0.0149586052,
0.0089971097,
-0.0639775842,
-0.0197414085,
-0.0223199688,
-0.0379945561,
-0.0744109154,
-0.0222891588,
0.0535370633,
0.0282811504,
0.035840515,
0.0159382708,
0.0027500058,
0.0896004438,
0.0385248587,
-0.0711864159,
0.0277742762,
-0.0087256385,
0.006982062,
0.0108512118,
0.0367657803,
-0.0688482821,
-0.0026735174,
0.010613584,
0.0188274495,
-0.0352156311,
-0.0253784582,
0.032192111,
0.038475588,
-0.038867373,
0.013740059,
-0.0136978747,
-0.0343290716,
0.0035942891,
-0.0560775399,
-0.0275270808,
-0.0417286903,
0.014645665,
-0.0050180336,
0.0205531251,
-0.0043206988,
-0.0339300036,
0.0317658149,
0.0159920547,
0.0090576494,
-0.0313424952,
0.0119109396,
0.0146357408,
0.0401813686,
-0.0007775623,
-0.0066514458,
0.0303084478,
-0.060131561,
0.009199582,
-0.0229628216,
0.0672949925,
0.0296954978,
-0.0320298374,
-0.0579655394,
0.0183056556,
-0.0499662235,
-0.101572901,
0.0359696336,
0.0676832944,
0.0885794014,
0.0100123612,
-0.0299368855,
-0.1029734984,
-0.013394393,
0.0296889748,
0.008363449,
0.0310688354,
-0.0315422826,
0.020319581,
0.0402145833,
-0.0020496221,
-0.0083931917,
0.0427636094,
-0.0208561607,
0.0639475286,
-0.000606857,
-0.0522519536,
-0.0446424484,
-0.019630162,
0.0582290292,
0.0147656193,
-0.0063794213,
0.0524869114,
-0.0735376626,
-0.0565071069,
0.0070286887,
0.0541692488,
-0.0099557675,
0.0046316949,
0.0509078726,
0.0186657701,
0.0064341212,
-0.0687982067,
-0.0208763331,
0.0233500488,
-0.0496298224,
0.009956887,
0.0329470783,
-6.108645575e-33,
-0.0391743891,
-0.0045698979,
0.042260699,
0.011415028,
-0.0431511179,
-0.0166442394,
-0.01624294,
-0.0201187022,
-0.0093128532,
0.0409861244,
-0.0075173215,
0.0042095794,
-0.0130387358,
-0.0220760088,
0.0062716892,
-0.0079616504,
0.0256910212,
0.0012210719,
0.0173535943,
0.0350628421,
0.0742794052,
0.0088592451,
0.0485129729,
-0.0393265858,
0.019788757,
-0.0003314374,
0.0281799212,
0.0303616822,
-0.0303105507,
0.0449229404,
-0.0240110978,
0.0274374839,
0.0145215858,
0.0175157599,
0.0142139886,
-0.0044989903,
-0.075833492,
-0.0598150417,
0.0492188297,
0.0375816375,
-0.0258431602,
-0.0585855916,
0.0307539534,
-0.0401160419,
0.0220065136,
0.0081982994,
0.0295437854,
-0.035715919,
-0.0188202411,
-0.0470219739,
-0.0320376307,
0.0078333495,
-0.0066426336,
-0.0043226611,
-0.0277206451,
-0.0262706913,
-0.0059339721,
-0.0063103531,
-0.0498512834,
0.0225594286,
0.0092285946,
-0.0103332484,
0.0448868312,
0.0221936367,
0.0564643741,
0.0336724706,
-0.0105061587,
0.0115382671,
-0.0225600358,
0.0293291733,
-0.0087437229,
0.076310046,
0.0131209567,
0.0229555406,
0.0053873817,
-0.0024160445,
-0.0671926811,
-0.025255939,
0.0112711675,
0.0647129044,
0.0132764224,
0.0111437188,
-0.0306226257,
-0.0078055575,
-0.0334396809,
-0.0251117703,
-0.0246120729,
-0.0325082503,
0.0127188182,
-0.0199993048,
0.0241238605,
-0.0019837616,
0.0045212116,
-0.0651140064,
0.0073949886,
0.0568183959,
0.0288788453,
0.0201924592,
0.0027389883,
0.0247718934,
-0.0490175337,
-0.0346700549,
0.0099717565,
-0.031774547,
0.0015952839,
0.0419041365,
0.0021109944,
0.0286590625,
0.0172862262,
-0.015341213,
-0.0289140772,
-0.0275980327,
0.0282955244,
-0.0656333938,
0.0459399745,
0.0232700966,
0.0042404719,
0.0297504403,
0.0110390764,
-0.0188909266,
0.0036986016,
0.0344549343,
0.0005366732,
0.017507093,
0.002418081,
-0.0168581773,
-0.0552245304,
0.0071946806,
0.0325859636,
-0.0582508892,
0.0139477728,
0.0272607077,
3.114e-7,
-0.0219019074,
0.023256762,
0.0157632791,
0.0285673104,
0.0332636721,
0.0206567552,
-0.0200394429,
0.0142567381,
-0.0405127667,
-0.0459360369,
0.0530702956,
0.0609908067,
-0.0102335829,
0.0102921585,
-0.0789117515,
-0.0322530083,
-0.0144263105,
-0.0580455735,
-0.0737163946,
0.0259782039,
0.0788492933,
0.0503169484,
0.0430970043,
0.0037927697,
0.0042918287,
-0.062490724,
0.0491344146,
-0.0388357975,
0.0145685617,
-0.0042082733,
0.0290313251,
-0.0031469348,
-0.021058578,
0.0817070454,
0.0324701145,
0.025067145,
-0.0073407381,
0.0392734222,
-0.0077347471,
0.0531399325,
-0.0153610017,
-0.0527154021,
-0.0009292623,
-0.0676551163,
0.0682871416,
-0.0707838088,
-0.0329866819,
0.0346946642,
-0.0296037868,
-0.038803719,
-0.0528493337,
-0.0124983788,
0.0197948962,
0.0002491395,
-0.0040642647,
-0.0097762262,
0.025810549,
-0.0638380945,
0.0232968125,
0.0246549547,
-0.0225859992,
-0.0628750697,
-0.0358840451,
-0.034240704,
0.0312310494,
-0.0667455718,
-0.0062290099,
2.737262574e-34,
-0.00087079,
-0.0197619386,
-0.004587221,
-0.0159794204,
0.0336873978,
-0.0113513255,
-0.0294226762,
0.0178063754,
0.0517061651,
-0.1039569452,
-0.01431695
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03759v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03759v1 | How should the advent of large language models affect the practice of science? | 2023-12-05T10:45:12 | 2023-12-05T10:45:12 | Marcel Binz, Stephan Alaniz, Adina Roskies, Balazs Aczel, Carl T. Bergstrom, Colin Allen, Daniel Schad, Dirk Wulff, Jevin D. West, Qiong Zhang, Richard M. Shiffrin, Samuel J. Gershman, Ven Popov, Emily M. Bender, Marco Marelli, Matthew M. Botvinick, Zeynep Akata, Eric Schulz | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.DL | Large language models (LLMs) are being increasingly incorporated into
scientific workflows. However, we have yet to fully grasp the implications of
this integration. How should the advent of large language models affect the
practice of science? For this opinion piece, we have invited four diverse
groups of scientists to reflect on this query, sharing their perspectives and
engaging in debate. Schulz et al. make the argument that working with LLMs is
not fundamentally different from working with human collaborators, while Bender
et al. argue that LLMs are often misused and over-hyped, and that their
limitations warrant a focus on more specialized, easily interpretable tools.
Marelli et al. emphasize the importance of transparent attribution and
responsible use of LLMs. Finally, Botvinick and Gershman advocate that humans
should retain responsibility for determining the scientific roadmap. To
facilitate the discussion, the four perspectives are complemented with a
response from each group. By putting these different perspectives in
conversation, we aim to bring attention to important considerations within the
academic community regarding the adoption of LLMs and their impact on both
current and future scientific practices. | [
0.0475193672,
0.0868012458,
-0.0125614898,
-0.0011554206,
-0.061468944,
0.0003917126,
0.0479999483,
0.0189151336,
-0.0014089895,
-0.0156607442,
-0.0084405933,
-0.0305432528,
-0.0021430473,
0.0125191826,
0.0118593229,
-0.0337379016,
0.0232859254,
-0.0476791449,
0.0129055651,
-0.0179382134,
-0.0104306024,
-0.0061443564,
0.0398330651,
0.033220984,
0.0418014564,
-0.0262601636,
0.02590473,
-0.0258311871,
0.0094476491,
0.0020740442,
-0.0281419214,
0.0676277354,
0.0223422814,
0.1011216715,
0.0000021379,
-0.0532033108,
0.0214696024,
0.0689579919,
-0.0343398564,
0.0479206406,
0.0381997824,
-0.0128643289,
-0.024978701,
-0.0283135623,
-0.0099602686,
0.0204096045,
0.0679912791,
-0.0891095102,
-0.0198097751,
-0.0094194086,
0.0204597376,
-0.0198386479,
0.0220919419,
-0.0032220073,
-0.0000432695,
0.0265101381,
0.0535196587,
0.0462946109,
0.0729913414,
0.0558998846,
-0.0045746826,
0.0839033574,
0.0087911272,
-0.0671032742,
0.0005848471,
-0.0016852968,
0.0058895685,
-0.0468890145,
0.0179193802,
0.0246723667,
0.062664628,
-0.0400630981,
0.0038855586,
-0.0113047352,
-0.0309660248,
0.0538818277,
-0.0799287185,
0.0499904193,
0.006901742,
-0.0143690128,
0.0113909831,
-0.0366798826,
0.0214838758,
0.0353177376,
-0.0122851999,
0.0713864714,
0.0011085792,
-0.0170698334,
-0.0179291125,
0.0198108479,
0.012621819,
-0.0676665753,
0.0151852835,
0.0166254882,
0.0092499703,
0.0102824494,
0.0429488383,
-0.0249841232,
0.0748851299,
-0.0258971453,
0.0533272922,
0.0033976478,
0.0114348587,
0.0141136218,
0.0271229614,
0.0185138341,
-0.0533498265,
0.0163431726,
0.02211928,
0.0128280558,
-0.0461444296,
-0.0356330499,
0.0071244352,
-0.0468256883,
-0.027456956,
0.0381946899,
-0.0053458568,
0.000231409,
-0.0042387014,
-0.0069968351,
-0.01654833,
-0.0306728389,
-0.0379207097,
0.004511443,
0.0015158524,
0.0645346567,
0.0238917712,
0.0330144875,
-0.0022642522,
-0.0397039317,
-0.0213301815,
0.0225791465,
-0.0295903981,
-0.0091204755,
0.0099726701,
0.0643918216,
0.056219317,
0.0103798704,
0.0606515631,
-0.0422898419,
-0.0304264743,
-0.0464828163,
-0.0019984071,
-0.0626863837,
0.0247942861,
0.0612015426,
-0.0079424242,
-0.0630230457,
-0.0210683066,
-0.0199361201,
-0.0388535075,
0.025026178,
-0.078292191,
0.0195197202,
0.0237844586,
0.0380541757,
0.0165089369,
0.0113082351,
0.0188236367,
-0.0202059895,
0.0047705797,
-0.0354111716,
0.0267938692,
0.0069992784,
-0.0282916296,
0.049901329,
-0.0299211964,
0.0169902593,
0.0164831392,
0.0259065535,
0.0051352549,
0.0466490574,
-0.0146796126,
0.0002767674,
0.0429848582,
0.0552214198,
-0.0144042103,
0.0416080281,
0.0184344985,
-0.0149503201,
0.0349351466,
-0.0307407435,
0.0007433444,
0.0415653884,
-0.0095820725,
-0.0102553805,
-0.0052738599,
0.0417166874,
-0.0002482206,
-0.0192741212,
-0.0292185843,
0.0092105465,
0.006612842,
0.0037125074,
0.0470313765,
-0.0382719375,
0.0351197384,
0.0349489711,
0.0166438948,
-0.0546915568,
0.013636603,
-0.0314608179,
0.0389730856,
0.0280230492,
0.0490879826,
-0.0165736619,
-0.0049218698,
-0.0406669378,
0.0214368813,
0.0659647807,
0.0242774058,
0.0092326365,
-0.0468502007,
0.0006525454,
-0.0103655308,
-0.030574508,
-0.0108235916,
-0.0038921656,
-0.0200914033,
0.0150075331,
-0.0089161284,
-0.0074447868,
-0.085776791,
0.0123996679,
-0.078536801,
0.0051372861,
-0.0404448435,
-0.0356938243,
0.0259447675,
0.0239146072,
-0.0331762768,
0.0313341469,
0.0320328623,
-0.0215793289,
-0.0212089848,
0.0094598383,
0.0451524146,
0.0743374825,
0.030906653,
-0.0161792561,
0.0244745594,
-0.0308083147,
0.0011944595,
-0.0093820198,
0.0523629896,
0.0065448778,
0.0172544643,
0.0085788723,
0.0084769363,
-0.0800849795,
0.0073348447,
-0.0452326387,
-0.0262714531,
0.0133706275,
0.057006225,
0.0071296985,
-0.027797088,
0.0348170064,
-0.0135308905,
-0.0285005234,
0.0628203079,
0.0498339199,
0.0059678671,
0.0372086242,
-0.0308550913,
-0.0092614684,
-0.0281867348,
-0.0317577682,
-0.0453075543,
0.0214452595,
0.0265609194,
-0.0001454969,
-0.0407338515,
-0.018562559,
0.0401057079,
0.0133168446,
-0.0126850633,
0.0095263645,
0.0160623416,
0.0366446599,
-0.0012942076,
-0.0468196496,
-0.048516307,
-0.0283234324,
-0.0108779436,
0.0557036996,
0.0539037436,
-0.0305387489,
-0.0977572501,
0.0322735645,
-0.0433236696,
-0.0297417566,
0.0067964657,
-0.0144831603,
0.0494389124,
0.0060698288,
0.0020499784,
0.0061673978,
-0.0499085411,
0.0181479491,
0.0719805807,
-0.0126681849,
-0.0378550924,
-0.0347252339,
0.0007879534,
-0.0365458205,
0.0116819488,
-0.0350140929,
-0.0015138391,
0.0301426835,
-0.0369861983,
-0.0388928577,
0.0208463036,
0.0417673588,
-0.0507944226,
-0.0175936036,
0.0307028871,
-0.0583517924,
-0.0272135753,
0.0279699694,
0.0016822442,
-0.0683804899,
0.0460993685,
-0.0303594917,
-0.0200971998,
-0.0692641586,
-0.0350938961,
-0.0389532857,
0.0461183712,
-0.0368804,
-0.0001204715,
0.0168901272,
0.0246759467,
-0.0115451654,
0.0024422822,
-0.0269471072,
-0.005702476,
0.0238117371,
-0.0640809834,
0.0300607197,
-0.0134159783,
0.0048631909,
0.019269051,
0.021389924,
-0.0606669188,
0.0544824339,
0.0394666269,
-0.0480400659,
-0.0398735069,
0.0223436691,
0.1095721424,
0.0004535531,
-0.0200970266,
0.0000028282,
-0.007817409,
-0.0467346013,
-0.0293812603,
-0.0093399696,
0.0458625965,
-0.0469694026,
0.0139964567,
0.0473966375,
-0.0007105172,
0.0246723667,
-0.0149564967,
-0.0364514701,
0.0529667661,
-0.0037044955,
-0.0424390733,
0.0086411107,
0.0549683459,
-0.0620469823,
-0.012374253,
0.064525865,
-0.004740769,
-0.0479009412,
0.0189039335,
-0.0664488301,
-0.0116007421,
0.0120855719,
0.039078068,
-0.0748072043,
0.0262924153,
-0.0029022128,
-0.0150715029,
-0.0257969834,
-0.046838861,
-0.0063607781,
-0.0199252479,
0.0829650685,
0.0453043021,
-0.040153902,
0.0282568354,
-0.0865155384,
0.00442422,
0.025284756,
0.0331841558,
0.0302988496,
0.0077360189,
-0.0082396148,
0.0300974175,
-0.0266553313,
-0.0584085025,
0.0166135877,
-0.0382542461,
0.0404062606,
0.0212096069,
0.0253068954,
-0.0399375632,
-0.0198906735,
0.0112888906,
0.0329889245,
0.000274293,
-0.003950343,
-0.0347071141,
0.077409558,
-0.0085069938,
-0.0436112322,
-0.001195534,
-0.0495802984,
-0.0282731839,
-0.0004102696,
0.1169126332,
-0.0446301363,
-0.0435263105,
-0.0394792594,
-0.0047189198,
-0.0076420563,
0.0719834641,
0.03327135,
-0.0593840703,
-0.0321017914,
-0.0366591588,
-0.006135582,
0.0286004432,
-0.0521411151,
-0.0006976123,
0.0060042036,
-0.010211478,
0.0079517541,
-0.0063764718,
0.04459887,
0.0004236544,
0.0403341465,
0.0270357262,
0.0088410275,
-0.045393277,
-0.0025744417,
0.0283010416,
-0.0170626994,
0.0505356789,
-0.0566150211,
-0.0221232511,
0.035250172,
0.0303002428,
-0.0013958684,
0.0214210749,
-0.0401295088,
-0.0743987486,
-0.0163058322,
0.0463290587,
0.0352574587,
-0.0603822693,
0.0517756343,
-0.0910214856,
-0.0079056388,
0.0477250926,
-0.0004434391,
0.0202860981,
-0.0488642901,
0.0105950199,
-0.002559199,
-0.0163197741,
0.0116368132,
-0.009112657,
0.0200057887,
0.0189302992,
-0.0426273867,
-0.0718439445,
-0.0022747503,
0.0513015613,
0.031961564,
-0.0472138822,
-0.0219201706,
-0.0004599882,
-0.0353442878,
-0.0341542102,
0.0019167183,
-0.0338538438,
-0.0082237804,
0.0010318862,
0.0173667148,
0.0189705603,
0.0274809729,
-0.0574540161,
0.0297751669,
-0.0302071068,
0.1084813625,
-0.0231264103,
0.0229592789,
0.0626847595,
0.0132010952,
-0.01613882,
0.0000522902,
-0.0637702942,
0.0413270816,
0.019068107,
0.0287243109,
-0.0022732723,
-0.0005940787,
-0.0060793315,
0.0166501999,
-0.0650399029,
-0.0969195813,
-0.0069709979,
0.0244859643,
0.0150064509,
0.052381251,
0.0454203524,
-0.0492336042,
-0.0123745715,
-0.0623302236,
0.027328046,
-0.0064225872,
0.0012282623,
0.0326930843,
0.0054177758,
-0.0524977259,
-0.0619756021,
0.029237045,
0.0182718355,
0.0282485299,
-0.0469877906,
-0.0339553878,
0.0256287064,
-0.0723470226,
-0.0067025642,
-0.0448355712,
-0.0286152214,
-0.0392146409,
-0.1028698757,
-0.0326392613,
0.014874408,
0.0003317092,
-0.0342241228,
-0.0629254803,
-0.0220050476,
0.0403882153,
0.0019192018,
-0.0435418338,
-0.00492184,
0.0521975346,
-0.0103778746,
-0.0607158467,
0.0112738963,
-6.025903997e-33,
0.0216711797,
-0.0317869522,
0.0145630203,
0.0078209126,
-0.0290883929,
0.0018021006,
-0.05674804,
0.0034456158,
-0.0035929559,
0.0390333347,
-0.0022993498,
-0.0396869294,
-0.0068851183,
-0.0362165868,
0.0747370273,
0.0444424115,
0.0285698529,
0.0030101812,
0.0158219133,
-0.0111287404,
0.054491736,
-0.0061793174,
0.0485502966,
-0.0860560089,
0.0569497868,
0.0063805641,
0.0136995576,
0.0082246261,
-0.0203202963,
0.0309686363,
-0.0027868503,
0.031123735,
-0.0067220521,
-0.0529762171,
-0.0330676474,
-0.0102073438,
0.0064148228,
0.0392728299,
0.0418924689,
-0.0099314433,
0.0157526638,
-0.0350877307,
0.049256403,
0.0001539649,
-0.0591270477,
0.0062794336,
0.0006007937,
-0.0482696816,
-0.0570065677,
-0.0025144462,
-0.0543726943,
0.0072025009,
0.0059186532,
0.0660839304,
0.0234411564,
-0.0085568372,
-0.0230240636,
0.0178918988,
-0.0382173024,
0.0393200517,
0.0459714606,
-0.0193719361,
0.0668659434,
0.0123489359,
0.0254992954,
0.0563187189,
0.034594886,
0.0209640283,
-0.0070281173,
-0.0142437331,
0.0295094643,
0.0217220392,
0.0522638783,
0.0448094308,
-0.0272264034,
-0.0013146547,
-0.0719296634,
0.0144336587,
0.0005520607,
0.0165656861,
0.0199964941,
0.0384446196,
-0.0150047122,
-0.0618026145,
-0.0203856118,
-0.0142964711,
0.0009352871,
-0.0218550302,
-0.0196987316,
-0.0717643946,
-0.0291930214,
0.0229451563,
0.057073947,
-0.0378142595,
-0.0520001203,
0.0037786989,
-0.0232653189,
0.0598264001,
0.0056967246,
0.0151504735,
-0.094585754,
-0.0137232617,
-0.0324558951,
0.0210574605,
0.0404362455,
0.012931739,
-0.0202390868,
0.0292194765,
-0.0229003858,
0.0157860722,
-0.0295866635,
-0.0215380825,
0.0566190034,
-0.0099268835,
0.0145046562,
0.0050684446,
0.0350675918,
0.0210679118,
0.0279728547,
-0.0052212775,
0.0085993577,
0.0661375746,
-0.0357409045,
0.0145436274,
-0.0302466005,
-0.016845176,
-0.0149502764,
0.0366335325,
0.0664680898,
-0.0311469622,
-0.0064311228,
-0.0357091352,
2.891e-7,
0.0760102645,
0.0651752502,
0.0056478474,
-0.0017922116,
0.0552371368,
0.0030040171,
-0.032851059,
0.0102023082,
-0.0004165185,
0.0095630763,
-0.0034300585,
-0.0091173891,
0.0440866686,
0.0208978299,
-0.0367325768,
-0.0355165228,
-0.0570060983,
-0.034332782,
-0.0682896078,
-0.0321163982,
-0.0295561831,
-0.0077166501,
0.0218977965,
-0.0119763976,
-0.0318153575,
-0.0214974992,
0.0547880866,
-0.0484399423,
0.0530859269,
0.0659535676,
-0.0036392675,
-0.0135667594,
0.0304826461,
0.0228356048,
0.0046872757,
-0.0329658128,
-0.0006747154,
0.0726129189,
-0.0066442271,
0.0364876986,
0.0323050246,
-0.0351284295,
0.0280785114,
-0.0675151274,
-0.0150820222,
-0.045765873,
-0.0403300487,
-0.005335439,
0.0014644869,
-0.0349488929,
0.040894106,
-0.0263895858,
0.0283262432,
0.0534241758,
-0.0192001015,
0.0019647407,
-0.0018131781,
-0.0169564132,
-0.0372311994,
0.0072481516,
-0.0635981932,
-0.0609811544,
-0.0272080656,
-0.0178125668,
0.0047506117,
-0.018222319,
0.0327867046,
2.856822977e-34,
0.0437603891,
-0.0016813065,
0.0141323796,
0.0187669937,
-0.0057482598,
0.02279846,
0.0120526999,
0.0330577828,
0.0242090039,
-0.0408946462,
-0.0138922408
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.02614v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.02614v3 | Prompt Optimization via Adversarial In-Context Learning | 2023-12-05T09:44:45 | 2024-06-22T15:19:11 | Xuan Long Do, Yiran Zhao, Hannah Brown, Yuxi Xie, James Xu Zhao, Nancy F. Chen, Kenji Kawaguchi, Michael Shieh, Junxian He | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | We propose a new method, Adversarial In-Context Learning (adv-ICL), to
optimize prompt for in-context learning (ICL) by employing one LLM as a
generator, another as a discriminator, and a third as a prompt modifier. As in
traditional adversarial learning, adv-ICL is implemented as a two-player game
between the generator and discriminator, where the generator tries to generate
realistic enough output to fool the discriminator. In each round, given an
input prefixed by task instructions and several exemplars, the generator
produces an output. The discriminator is then tasked with classifying the
generator input-output pair as model-generated or real data. Based on the
discriminator loss, the prompt modifier proposes possible edits to the
generator and discriminator prompts, and the edits that most improve the
adversarial loss are selected. We show that adv-ICL results in significant
improvements over state-of-the-art prompt optimization techniques for both open
and closed-source models on 11 generation and classification tasks including
summarization, arithmetic reasoning, machine translation, data-to-text
generation, and the MMLU and big-bench hard benchmarks. In addition, because
our method uses pre-trained models and updates only prompts rather than model
parameters, it is computationally efficient, easy to extend to any LLM and
task, and effective in low-resource settings. | [
0.0042173001,
0.0745046809,
0.0175301135,
0.0482549779,
-0.0080836648,
0.0121671567,
0.0275455769,
-0.0228328817,
-0.0021987783,
-0.0266308356,
-0.0305982772,
-0.0062913992,
-0.0040617096,
-0.0116632283,
0.0375288874,
-0.0220018663,
0.0439104103,
-0.0248926356,
-0.018122904,
0.0017900771,
-0.0358978026,
-0.0161439963,
0.0010736217,
0.0016287945,
0.0024549169,
-0.0263904519,
-0.0325039849,
0.0269588307,
0.0372058414,
-0.0223346781,
0.0457198732,
0.044625517,
0.0140799945,
0.0484595485,
0.0000023367,
-0.0444232002,
-0.0349569619,
-0.0184629299,
-0.0685270801,
-0.0095633566,
0.0087913843,
-0.0078006592,
0.0005094032,
0.0120049855,
-0.0428350605,
0.0146929482,
0.0262169875,
0.0412406437,
0.0850214809,
0.112200059,
0.0136220073,
-0.0034503874,
0.0160204303,
-0.0619566999,
0.0237464234,
-0.0415933728,
-0.0094031934,
-0.0379146375,
-0.0249391831,
0.0001379054,
0.0042906641,
0.0298354495,
0.0495670587,
-0.0017361263,
-0.0216026325,
0.0428415649,
0.0231086295,
0.0104418267,
-0.0137891406,
0.0875097141,
-0.0442644954,
-0.011142672,
0.0170687232,
-0.0190658085,
0.0424242839,
-0.0383241922,
-0.0283995382,
0.0302631594,
-0.0243892428,
0.0080292495,
-0.0234608818,
0.0291119553,
0.0249112435,
0.0111806719,
-0.0002731132,
0.0190581493,
0.0067103948,
-0.0099224122,
-0.0086919982,
-0.0163551271,
-0.0604769625,
-0.0765685141,
0.0031493059,
0.0466473922,
-0.1053774804,
0.0015056992,
-0.0806766823,
-0.0488535315,
0.0056105051,
0.0162906181,
0.0707975104,
0.0157957152,
-0.0044642449,
0.0308495741,
-0.0349024273,
0.0578481518,
-0.0125866039,
0.0533935316,
-0.0327020623,
0.0298450124,
-0.0013638221,
-0.0075501846,
-0.0364023745,
0.0263134316,
-0.0665965378,
0.0186226033,
-0.0353193134,
0.0536422804,
-0.0390431583,
0.0456862375,
-0.0024891994,
0.0288983714,
-0.0549169816,
0.0046065021,
-0.0087290658,
-0.0405670479,
-0.0393313877,
-0.0026894067,
0.034773089,
-0.0612604991,
-0.034867093,
0.0186464284,
-0.0183914937,
-0.0119811296,
0.0214928556,
0.0897074491,
-0.0531437285,
-0.0058597401,
-0.0270862933,
-0.0556125976,
-0.008789815,
-0.0750310123,
0.0168188252,
-0.0470638759,
0.0093847401,
-0.0283775926,
-0.0332402326,
-0.0473179705,
0.0029691295,
0.0217034258,
0.0541724376,
0.0862773135,
0.0275967997,
-0.0638011247,
0.0468977243,
0.027616499,
-0.0330843292,
0.0648711845,
-0.0039750729,
0.0612404719,
0.0072260071,
0.0253521409,
-0.0048898193,
0.0370151997,
0.0640696585,
0.0258263331,
-0.0098326569,
0.0094294334,
0.0324198678,
0.026135169,
0.0202879757,
0.033097893,
-0.0290677883,
-0.0124197863,
0.0532171577,
-0.0093068713,
-0.0036348144,
0.0012097352,
0.023320742,
0.0285199881,
-0.0164275747,
0.0354126506,
-0.0359304808,
0.0316161811,
-0.0634208992,
-0.0079564434,
0.0328812115,
-0.012820947,
-0.0208510086,
-0.067407459,
0.0392025858,
-0.0198148899,
-0.020095082,
0.0374354422,
0.0096079269,
0.0248480346,
-0.0845863968,
0.0064625549,
-0.0104727456,
-0.026802212,
-0.0124863256,
-0.0535500459,
0.0291491076,
0.0093033323,
0.0431163684,
-0.0500776879,
-0.011532478,
-0.0442043729,
0.0298193581,
0.0395510904,
0.0289690271,
-0.0264087506,
0.0007034244,
-0.0492666624,
-0.0251147076,
-0.0551999323,
0.002819882,
0.0368322022,
0.0132494895,
-0.0095112938,
0.0404935926,
0.0165035818,
0.0070065763,
0.0385266319,
-0.0305724144,
-0.0911741629,
0.0478715412,
0.0286017656,
0.0390207581,
0.0061199893,
0.0264668856,
0.0391214155,
0.0209705885,
-0.0441815257,
-0.0204005335,
-0.0295613557,
-0.0784336776,
-0.0756213292,
0.0376887955,
-0.0161444861,
-0.0252275355,
0.0065568597,
-0.0775580481,
-0.0204576924,
-0.018238971,
-0.0505982451,
-0.0182530303,
-0.0348047763,
0.0043408219,
0.0167172533,
-0.0062819156,
-0.0589414872,
0.0934034958,
-0.0061656274,
-0.0028973708,
0.0790885538,
0.0427437238,
0.0104365442,
-0.0572848432,
0.0160951838,
-0.0046170028,
-0.0303636845,
0.0058413446,
0.0327717625,
0.02140701,
-0.0395352542,
-0.0336225368,
-0.0438612737,
0.0300002731,
-0.0303091984,
0.0176637452,
0.0296370536,
-0.0068549337,
0.0061242939,
-0.0207554139,
-0.0591854937,
-0.0172822885,
0.0119861476,
-0.0102758212,
0.0425445214,
0.0178501178,
0.0183188729,
-0.0046109594,
0.0091043198,
0.0155803561,
0.0452863164,
-0.0054728133,
-0.0027187695,
-0.0537390858,
0.0299520474,
0.0068365713,
0.0306993276,
-0.0208412688,
0.037221957,
0.010705879,
0.0004940829,
0.0491115078,
0.0833864808,
0.0238735005,
0.0344558321,
0.0155934496,
0.0116272513,
-0.0695221424,
0.0228352658,
0.0143725611,
-0.011206843,
-0.0006240734,
-0.01794862,
0.0504092164,
0.0390737839,
0.024535425,
-0.013533785,
-0.0133969923,
0.070223324,
0.0415416919,
-0.050577879,
-0.0786356404,
-0.0065213693,
-0.0225471798,
0.0232204907,
-0.0321862847,
-0.0409242138,
0.06532529,
-0.0140021583,
0.0077357334,
-0.0329597481,
-0.0154053029,
-0.0119441589,
0.0220491979,
-0.0146511411,
0.0150136435,
0.0237596948,
-0.0143671567,
-0.0928495377,
-0.0051459782,
0.0556193329,
-0.0176240131,
0.0493740402,
-0.0289599299,
-0.0084045967,
-0.040558815,
-0.0479065552,
-0.0967029035,
-0.0447700396,
0.0263908822,
0.0386197865,
-0.0048056315,
0.0138541851,
-0.0214603189,
-0.0523779467,
-0.0002216664,
0.055567801,
-0.0415395834,
-0.0204079263,
-0.0419000536,
0.0555993058,
0.0432370342,
-0.0022902759,
-0.0031056218,
-0.0575800538,
0.0331115536,
0.0544066206,
0.0086256405,
-0.0107739707,
-0.022590803,
-0.0080594709,
0.0238252766,
-0.0388104655,
0.0001061487,
0.0500028022,
0.0443364307,
-0.0354816206,
-0.0136682019,
0.0804479271,
0.0225972012,
-0.0263568144,
-0.0007765478,
0.0207519606,
0.0168593284,
0.017424522,
0.0197421294,
-0.0747546628,
-0.0574136414,
0.0161370821,
0.0412705131,
0.003563286,
-0.0211217608,
-0.0347123295,
-0.1107988954,
0.026199555,
0.0052932636,
-0.0362821259,
-0.0278039929,
-0.0045110127,
-0.0425396524,
0.002126605,
0.0184333734,
0.0156402644,
0.0139029715,
0.0137283159,
0.0192899778,
0.0503021851,
-0.0214698259,
-0.0061670123,
-0.0152575653,
-0.0011064881,
0.0898974612,
0.0270387828,
0.0167926028,
-0.042327404,
0.0698166266,
-0.0041580014,
0.0030419223,
-0.002418163,
0.0397094414,
0.0013983006,
0.0024663603,
0.0026825024,
0.0561217554,
-0.0022225685,
-0.0090509122,
0.0319226719,
0.0321756899,
-0.0185432211,
0.0045442143,
0.0020824643,
-0.0047504529,
0.0614974312,
0.0483052582,
0.0234399159,
-0.0237831958,
-0.0464243479,
-0.0509320945,
0.0197808538,
-0.0668014586,
0.018122945,
-0.0195933674,
0.0058082743,
-0.0097862473,
-0.070241563,
-0.0319311805,
-0.007169412,
0.0379340239,
-0.0167427938,
-0.0389912724,
-0.0625308529,
0.0005876248,
-0.0601458214,
-0.0021029599,
-0.0442084558,
0.0312472228,
-0.0445773862,
-0.0084732929,
0.0281671192,
-0.0583372042,
-0.0267110821,
0.0661256537,
-0.0966737568,
-0.0576988906,
-0.0437771454,
0.0611350909,
0.009095164,
0.0674564317,
-0.0081936615,
0.0012660034,
0.101398237,
0.0649192408,
-0.0033924351,
0.0067006145,
0.0670906156,
0.0398412608,
-0.0236300286,
0.022684915,
-0.0446371101,
0.0089055207,
0.0767994598,
-0.0124579566,
-0.0284197163,
-0.0227057058,
0.0321656056,
0.0174651854,
0.0217570849,
-0.0380085632,
-0.0262431018,
-0.0037392841,
0.023748653,
0.0181539953,
-0.0228601955,
-0.0280935783,
-0.0035038956,
0.0063431077,
-0.0217974279,
0.0391483009,
0.0259571429,
0.0262225326,
0.0325809419,
-0.0322529003,
-0.0066920328,
-0.001191674,
0.0460387208,
0.0209672339,
0.0058531119,
-0.016966667,
0.0351003818,
0.026246449,
0.0422707833,
-0.0110253589,
0.0512306392,
0.0424891151,
0.0237802602,
-0.0231757686,
0.0404440351,
-0.0488271154,
-0.0192105938,
-0.0515280701,
0.0527060851,
0.0358784758,
0.0358361639,
-0.0397016183,
-0.013415697,
-0.0120257,
-0.0313528292,
0.0136823226,
0.029494008,
-0.061999172,
0.0280246288,
0.01082794,
0.0187376924,
-0.0276685711,
0.0781893432,
-0.020815609,
0.0478405952,
-0.0041507757,
0.0297871269,
-0.0982675925,
-0.0388825946,
0.0366059318,
-0.0053578196,
0.0105332155,
0.0098693436,
-0.0018064011,
-0.0233380161,
0.0103656836,
0.0198923368,
0.0015327856,
0.0135484692,
0.0553027764,
0.0194716044,
-0.0290797409,
0.0000612552,
-0.0222597085,
0.0309741348,
0.0062542888,
-0.0329468735,
-0.0231365655,
-6.215387442e-33,
-0.0437690355,
-0.0496721342,
0.0184305012,
-0.0300701987,
0.0089588519,
0.0003295077,
-0.0502560325,
-0.0202215556,
0.0125227682,
-0.0287198927,
-0.0167378113,
-0.0144973136,
0.0013782677,
0.0448034927,
-0.0240514129,
-0.0579080582,
0.0724494234,
-0.0044289548,
-0.0562515408,
0.0397085249,
0.0381913483,
0.0144922435,
0.0167735908,
-0.027057711,
0.0437799245,
-0.0244673993,
-0.063284643,
0.0294514596,
-0.0356472917,
-0.0025401933,
-0.0121499607,
0.0226276405,
0.0029797077,
-0.0612456724,
-0.0390554965,
0.0335607231,
-0.0575480349,
-0.0420180559,
-0.0208469518,
0.0011416423,
-0.0621655509,
-0.0919678062,
0.0108941812,
-0.0181437228,
-0.0088181291,
-0.0249629505,
0.0147543242,
-0.0169466287,
-0.0148935588,
-0.0449862741,
-0.0362388603,
-0.0115085645,
-0.0241921227,
-0.0408284962,
-0.0053946627,
0.0789988115,
0.0127542941,
-0.0103634056,
-0.0731816143,
0.0262002014,
0.0412952825,
0.0151176527,
0.0835357681,
0.0392259918,
-0.0000236649,
0.0367825702,
0.0311677791,
-0.0119374404,
-0.0194645245,
-0.0059459587,
-0.0134334508,
0.0279760305,
0.0659844279,
0.0673630238,
0.0538497642,
-0.0113724805,
-0.0626672581,
0.0622489303,
0.0283656325,
-0.0156367756,
0.0068484563,
-0.0045041787,
0.0047653415,
-0.0237571243,
-0.0427588746,
-0.0313055515,
-0.0110499952,
-0.001465595,
0.0368814878,
0.0396798588,
-0.016470002,
-0.0320636295,
0.0218243655,
-0.0162385348,
0.0320549794,
0.032808207,
0.0126699647,
-0.0315019414,
0.0174325611,
-0.0124658924,
-0.0118897716,
-0.0220063496,
0.0537617207,
-0.0138620622,
0.0163001325,
0.0159865264,
0.0516282208,
0.0252999645,
-0.0511669107,
0.0142190875,
-0.0426684693,
0.0800577998,
0.0225894954,
0.0111426068,
0.0042691729,
-0.0278572198,
-0.0183254853,
0.0259811208,
-0.0032639704,
-0.0365585648,
-0.0033047223,
0.0314091258,
-0.0198420752,
0.0204117205,
-0.0169265904,
0.0157062802,
0.000089088,
0.0317207985,
0.0218188111,
-0.0594119951,
0.0002637963,
-0.0410851426,
2.904e-7,
0.0037915071,
0.0076065026,
0.0375695713,
0.0250413343,
0.0089845126,
0.0577730387,
-0.0145790083,
0.036658816,
-0.0119762309,
-0.0348967463,
0.0226215571,
0.0119745117,
0.0432333685,
0.0287780333,
-0.0762433335,
0.0212810263,
-0.0602491237,
0.0411626734,
-0.0287831333,
0.0117080733,
0.0240290053,
0.070668757,
-0.0275945421,
-0.0236877929,
0.0263548717,
-0.0172249284,
0.0473749004,
-0.0371877998,
0.014313682,
0.0135802319,
0.0411564261,
-0.0447225124,
0.0121737532,
0.0133277057,
-0.0374482796,
-0.0099362219,
0.0182806607,
0.0554104857,
0.039061293,
-0.0562524498,
-0.0312471967,
-0.0077373423,
0.0184203945,
-0.0219131839,
0.0757330805,
-0.0498443805,
-0.0182021614,
-0.0285401959,
-0.007967907,
-0.0341834426,
0.015519564,
-0.020171117,
-0.0035965946,
-0.0077334661,
0.0027250764,
0.0107979355,
0.0039145164,
-0.0280132666,
-0.0450941548,
-0.0150626656,
-0.0499756895,
-0.0450102985,
-0.0406015813,
0.0466943085,
0.0380688384,
-0.0494161583,
-0.0084872302,
2.89992987e-34,
0.0189432278,
-0.0008700665,
0.009476536,
-0.0047127712,
0.0055694166,
-0.0128370877,
-0.0233085975,
0.0249062572,
0.0689288899,
-0.0184989106,
-0.0431337841
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.02598v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.02598v1 | Impact of Tokenization on LLaMa Russian Adaptation | 2023-12-05T09:16:03 | 2023-12-05T09:16:03 | Mikhail Tikhomirov, Daniil Chernyshev | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Latest instruction-tuned large language models (LLM) show great results on
various tasks, however, they often face performance degradation for non-English
input. There is evidence that the reason lies in inefficient tokenization
caused by low language representation in pre-training data which hinders the
comprehension of non-English instructions, limiting the potential of target
language instruction-tuning. In this work we investigate the possibility of
addressing the issue with vocabulary substitution in the context of LLaMa
Russian language adaptation. We explore three variants of vocabulary adaptation
and test their performance on Saiga instruction-tuning and fine-tuning on
Russian Super Glue benchmark. The results of automatic evaluation show that
vocabulary substitution not only improves the model's quality in Russian but
also accelerates fine-tuning (35%) and inference (up to 60%) while reducing
memory consumption. Additional human evaluation of the instruction-tuned models
demonstrates that models with Russian-adapted vocabulary generate answers with
higher user preference than the original Saiga-LLaMa model. | [
0.0510909036,
0.0436839797,
-0.0061209011,
0.0181952529,
0.0184838679,
0.0189463384,
0.0156041477,
-0.0174772535,
-0.0245411564,
-0.0446553528,
-0.0834010914,
-0.0560604036,
-0.02335958,
-0.0172950421,
0.0425797999,
-0.0437820926,
0.0567049645,
-0.0701308846,
-0.0178261418,
-0.027523363,
0.0080144117,
0.0026561131,
-0.0004702827,
-0.0003909869,
0.0124727963,
0.0033512714,
0.0312010553,
0.0032139884,
-0.016065985,
-0.0005902324,
-0.0071193064,
0.0370925479,
-0.0092403153,
0.0160686821,
0.0000019926,
-0.0543319471,
-0.0003894774,
-0.0325013101,
0.0026097684,
0.0764549151,
0.0690333694,
-0.0157660935,
-0.0371476002,
0.027088847,
-0.0331758223,
-0.0047984128,
0.0452441797,
0.0044120401,
0.0468103364,
0.0943446383,
0.0085987365,
-0.0416992493,
0.0165042467,
-0.022904288,
0.0029121693,
-0.0569748543,
0.0301435478,
0.0250079799,
0.0065209488,
-0.0049717636,
-0.0471265912,
0.0275890771,
0.0123578701,
-0.0214675851,
-0.0152940974,
0.0040506166,
-0.0204907153,
0.0204286315,
-0.023225626,
0.0499402992,
-0.033140026,
-0.0290237423,
-0.0131247714,
0.0139172161,
0.0058729593,
-0.0180772971,
-0.0538826659,
-0.005778132,
0.0122401025,
0.0106622307,
0.0677900016,
-0.0619934648,
0.0251479391,
0.0266927294,
-0.0507169887,
0.074674271,
0.0254022721,
-0.0081993118,
0.000023294,
-0.0159825888,
-0.0568976775,
-0.0442019664,
0.046733968,
0.0331243463,
-0.0757597387,
0.0262883306,
-0.0666235834,
-0.0548170917,
0.0132235773,
-0.0595227703,
0.039471563,
0.0650695115,
0.0102816569,
0.0378452986,
-0.0672269613,
0.0755975097,
-0.009529057,
0.0570272505,
-0.1017929241,
-0.0206388664,
-0.0352115557,
-0.0042643989,
-0.0433615893,
0.0241087936,
-0.0550938807,
0.0160913542,
-0.0416236222,
0.0289978739,
0.0186780989,
-0.0131924916,
-0.0219757389,
-0.042641364,
-0.0462509133,
-0.0005014965,
-0.0201740991,
0.0456413813,
-0.0502845012,
0.0321263932,
-0.0085517606,
-0.0458968654,
0.0306460951,
0.0130763622,
-0.0341633931,
-0.0258002914,
0.0420209467,
0.0608038604,
-0.0352497101,
-0.0194919761,
-0.0237477645,
0.0463807508,
0.0062423502,
-0.0421586558,
0.0210859459,
-0.0365566537,
0.0214824341,
-0.0022847641,
0.0155454315,
-0.047758434,
-0.0189097226,
0.0107741728,
-0.0282962732,
0.0439169481,
0.0040274886,
0.0087859407,
0.0171594322,
-0.0192218497,
0.0382413827,
0.0951705202,
0.0111422138,
0.019220639,
0.049982328,
-0.043580018,
-0.03106598,
0.0547962524,
-0.0016887238,
0.0215085596,
-0.0250957776,
0.0447133444,
0.0462341495,
0.032802742,
0.0901728272,
0.0521262027,
-0.001935205,
-0.0187159814,
0.0440920442,
0.0374487676,
0.0011840074,
0.0451204665,
0.0324104205,
-0.0196132362,
0.0181221105,
0.0297613628,
-0.0695455074,
0.0101623582,
-0.0128136855,
0.0067229979,
0.0017799311,
0.0432619229,
-0.0375101566,
-0.0428997464,
-0.0186946876,
0.001640666,
0.027034035,
-0.0167292468,
0.0427962318,
-0.0053077731,
-0.026845444,
0.045659367,
0.0536684468,
0.0031641074,
0.0247903503,
-0.0858056247,
0.0334033556,
0.0629846379,
0.030788796,
-0.0115225622,
-0.0197505951,
0.0303068124,
0.0563304722,
0.0311649628,
0.0409804173,
-0.0154861435,
-0.0320617482,
-0.0526434407,
0.0247766841,
-0.0274737757,
-0.0074472846,
0.0628562719,
0.0071121072,
0.014789463,
0.0074757733,
-0.0402468331,
-0.0433751494,
0.0348700657,
-0.0179301314,
-0.0362388603,
0.0238083731,
-0.019000385,
0.0194593873,
0.0053148037,
-0.0029473859,
0.0159911159,
0.0081616379,
-0.0439815298,
0.0157121103,
-0.0121888779,
-0.054838337,
0.0014429059,
0.0422381572,
0.0082018347,
0.0121359657,
-0.0130606042,
-0.0375492722,
-0.0251268055,
0.0421415567,
-0.0152536267,
0.0373042673,
-0.0217422005,
0.0458117016,
-0.0057559805,
0.0493154936,
-0.0401832312,
0.0232195482,
-0.0049344101,
-0.0088686226,
-0.0001657846,
0.0336938277,
-0.0004697496,
-0.0484911986,
-0.0267075319,
0.0745275095,
0.0057986998,
0.0092475507,
-0.0317952782,
0.0049315011,
-0.0508733541,
-0.0218774863,
-0.0691250786,
0.0171767808,
-0.0326967463,
0.0592827722,
0.0379001088,
0.0004518342,
-0.024453124,
-0.025306616,
-0.0268522762,
0.0027130123,
-0.0128411381,
0.0354358479,
-0.0152241429,
0.0147137623,
0.0095603066,
-0.042427212,
-0.047173962,
0.02289211,
-0.0103222346,
-0.0224131066,
0.0071774018,
-0.0755954683,
0.0175056253,
-0.0338258743,
0.0365376808,
-0.0059803212,
-0.0978113264,
-0.0167593751,
0.0016557982,
0.0518677384,
0.0848043784,
-0.019053936,
-0.0165014695,
0.077400744,
0.0019380297,
0.0050074323,
-0.0012285245,
0.0069183409,
-0.0503397845,
-0.0379503183,
-0.0086809145,
-0.0015932996,
0.0661663786,
-0.043997705,
-0.0147114741,
-0.0549679883,
-0.0105194757,
-0.0623587929,
-0.0335041098,
-0.008723449,
0.0172846951,
-0.0072881617,
0.0046445844,
-0.0184039641,
-0.0196772236,
0.0745281279,
-0.0274449214,
0.0108713433,
-0.0800999552,
-0.0154542746,
-0.0375255719,
-0.0093872556,
0.0092567429,
0.0070247031,
-0.0552281179,
-0.0051064626,
-0.0486721992,
-0.0485316999,
0.0026603905,
-0.0128922621,
0.0228738189,
-0.064730987,
-0.0317019336,
-0.0167941526,
-0.0219486263,
0.0104638292,
-0.0484469198,
-0.0227037929,
0.0204984043,
0.042352289,
-0.0031149259,
-0.0428353436,
0.0039886162,
0.0122086741,
0.0326414667,
-0.0292231813,
0.0385216847,
-0.0252606459,
-0.0156882741,
0.071118094,
0.0490517132,
0.0007147843,
-0.0209992025,
0.0426730849,
0.0031399063,
0.0504325181,
-0.0670403019,
0.0123497536,
0.0080747902,
0.0466902405,
-0.0344385542,
-0.0238886569,
0.0141344387,
0.0452420078,
-0.0232625715,
-0.0068402025,
0.0699217469,
0.0088120196,
0.0080357352,
0.025292052,
-0.0526442006,
0.0277671684,
0.03370969,
0.0582262836,
-0.0535980724,
-0.0185582247,
0.0140450224,
0.0166590679,
0.0067981738,
0.0042108544,
0.0040930635,
-0.1086418256,
-0.0187671464,
0.0029167831,
-0.0887060165,
-0.0101817688,
-0.0419305675,
0.0038841232,
-0.0044265268,
0.0669500083,
0.014042112,
-0.0315167829,
0.003899903,
0.0459201075,
0.0047066188,
-0.0350893438,
0.0006115384,
-0.004130207,
0.0527750701,
0.0428822413,
-0.0136960531,
-0.0280862898,
-0.0279437006,
0.060172461,
-0.015880933,
0.0062793689,
-0.0427762605,
-0.0069712168,
0.0116368663,
-0.0166872889,
0.0347886942,
0.0099630905,
0.0203158483,
0.005734595,
0.0401177965,
0.0353308506,
0.0191067457,
-0.0106628789,
-0.0064460989,
-0.027528679,
-0.0171825476,
0.0364223234,
0.027303081,
-0.0444608331,
-0.0090203648,
-0.0048908521,
-0.0664171204,
-0.0555242971,
-0.0013476161,
0.0474484563,
-0.0717072636,
-0.0138412779,
-0.0609787665,
-0.0189183671,
0.0278151277,
0.0204751231,
0.0258939452,
0.0484068431,
-0.05506818,
-0.0194068588,
0.0146005731,
0.0366639383,
-0.0347677097,
0.015159877,
-0.1036163867,
-0.005708022,
0.0332995914,
-0.0356899425,
-0.0007193954,
-0.0059614182,
-0.0050159926,
-0.050366573,
0.0191577058,
0.0489431396,
0.0120807579,
0.0223627351,
-0.0004726785,
-0.090167135,
0.0476403348,
0.0082032438,
0.0018359667,
0.0693220496,
0.0145540684,
-0.0008533634,
0.0082529821,
0.0402621888,
-0.0299192797,
0.0140616177,
0.0501065515,
0.0252522565,
0.0036725514,
0.0079509085,
-0.0089549897,
0.0453481562,
0.0227235835,
0.0004980695,
-0.0118896533,
-0.0105341347,
0.0604429208,
-0.0196796246,
0.0184021555,
0.0117908074,
-0.0332607701,
0.0253062733,
-0.0338982195,
-0.0041214959,
-0.0198917575,
-0.0155853536,
0.0208392274,
-0.0160395056,
0.0424715243,
0.002788861,
0.0092070494,
0.0391602069,
0.0326027311,
-0.0256392155,
-0.0260296315,
0.0348278545,
0.0469564125,
-0.0268188827,
0.0054406701,
-0.0055080862,
-0.0260254238,
-0.0315091386,
0.0601541065,
-0.0288263112,
-0.0046005133,
-0.014666345,
0.0378184728,
0.0352959372,
-0.026672801,
0.0558042377,
-0.0013772839,
-0.0234573428,
-0.0324264914,
-0.0088624824,
0.013591486,
-0.0039892425,
0.0564285628,
-0.0111209881,
-0.0056945584,
-0.0000463612,
0.0408617593,
0.026744308,
0.0544773862,
0.0082083531,
0.0242245086,
-0.0189198796,
-0.0056222356,
-0.0212331563,
0.0014861894,
-0.028520897,
-0.0239045713,
-0.0128173223,
-0.0748087168,
-0.0434704795,
0.0202811193,
-0.0196203142,
-0.0135198841,
0.0288503226,
0.052294381,
0.0052137231,
-0.0079853181,
-0.0411757678,
0.0012041365,
-0.0022986212,
-0.007125746,
0.0462261587,
-6.357323242e-33,
-0.0478735343,
0.0174219459,
0.0358064584,
-0.010348795,
0.000763885,
-0.0056725102,
-0.0218942892,
-0.0051143882,
-0.0323507823,
-0.0220804736,
-0.0404908732,
-0.0047583515,
0.0278672539,
-0.0208522771,
-0.0014235015,
0.0073491009,
0.0477711335,
-0.0040235915,
-0.0135576632,
0.0048791161,
0.0431923233,
0.0065659173,
0.0653638914,
-0.0158010945,
0.0026429147,
0.0030118797,
0.014477917,
0.0063108546,
-0.0172725581,
0.0766362324,
-0.0054620118,
0.0719984323,
0.0140147777,
-0.0234677736,
-0.0285077821,
-0.0016721548,
-0.0808523521,
-0.03648578,
0.0793140084,
0.0278984606,
0.0128146103,
-0.0918132365,
0.0575081185,
0.0078902235,
-0.0327627957,
0.014389405,
-0.0049900906,
-0.0511573814,
-0.0486112759,
0.0235703401,
-0.0894009247,
0.0142323589,
0.0043831309,
0.0133674964,
0.0105083939,
0.0264150463,
0.0047757053,
-0.0367438607,
-0.0152300373,
0.0262249913,
0.0355135724,
0.0746440887,
0.0864352807,
0.0353746563,
-0.0184308533,
-0.0017202829,
0.0055496786,
-0.0174890868,
0.0477157086,
-0.0056200544,
0.0416343845,
-0.0345846228,
0.0409836434,
0.033644449,
0.0355569832,
-0.0674635917,
-0.0925713405,
0.0147370864,
0.0301686767,
0.0688313097,
0.0216613784,
0.0307033584,
-0.0240041576,
-0.0086507248,
-0.0314590409,
0.0317920409,
-0.0403335989,
-0.0577616468,
0.0513113141,
-0.0315119997,
-0.0229784716,
-0.0250702035,
0.0217469353,
-0.0127683347,
-0.0168161504,
-0.0035433003,
-0.0238202605,
0.0043925513,
-0.0223129336,
0.0230212975,
-0.0354129821,
-0.0800840482,
0.0097412374,
-0.0213835873,
0.0109289261,
0.0025041117,
0.0260660704,
0.0036829095,
-0.0585799702,
0.0121272802,
-0.0026119209,
0.0074821701,
0.0452226065,
0.0165827628,
0.0146846622,
-0.0063901446,
-0.0005610266,
0.0383738279,
0.0267123543,
-0.0463106818,
0.0014577259,
-0.019792797,
0.023291776,
0.0352219753,
-0.0667245984,
0.0290656369,
-0.0143432375,
0.0155869778,
-0.0091464221,
-0.0534376316,
-0.0329139046,
0.0139061678,
2.727e-7,
0.0427570455,
0.0811688229,
-0.0311232358,
-0.0384989306,
0.0114765046,
0.0043863854,
-0.0501021408,
0.0060406718,
0.0439442471,
0.0356167294,
0.0133414222,
0.0228813812,
0.0414569341,
0.0223900527,
-0.0849262848,
0.0192268938,
-0.0305405259,
0.0670277998,
-0.0664702058,
0.022847604,
0.0304132793,
0.1226892024,
-0.0153470021,
-0.0248045679,
-0.0251819212,
-0.0730876699,
0.0289892182,
-0.0237553511,
-0.023425756,
0.0263904631,
0.0250372961,
0.0395735092,
-0.0186808612,
0.0244030226,
-0.030943796,
0.029172305,
0.0196533855,
0.0556260943,
-0.0102554401,
-0.0195004474,
0.034427952,
-0.0247563645,
-0.0044414597,
-0.0768856779,
0.1000624821,
-0.0393827632,
-0.0389996395,
-0.016877247,
-0.0039334721,
-0.0101358257,
0.0349905752,
-0.0334932655,
-0.0275500789,
0.0098580085,
0.044246655,
-0.0022002638,
-0.0551862791,
-0.0311687551,
0.0050529344,
0.0059517194,
-0.0209250674,
-0.0725867748,
-0.0608402006,
0.037076734,
-0.0048286533,
-0.0194820259,
0.035040468,
2.206835671e-34,
0.0307538379,
-0.0052214782,
0.0302825067,
0.0197174624,
0.0277818535,
0.0026279897,
-0.0014466117,
0.0369045883,
0.0089202514,
-0.1327407509,
-0.0133153023
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.02590v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.02590v1 | Text Intimacy Analysis using Ensembles of Multilingual Transformers | 2023-12-05T09:04:22 | 2023-12-05T09:04:22 | Tanmay Chavan, Ved Patwardhan | cs.CL | cs.CL | Intimacy estimation of a given text has recently gained importance due to the
increase in direct interaction of NLP systems with humans. Intimacy is an
important aspect of natural language and has a substantial impact on our
everyday communication. Thus the level of intimacy can provide us with deeper
insights and richer semantics of conversations. In this paper, we present our
work on the SemEval shared task 9 on predicting the level of intimacy for the
given text. The dataset consists of tweets in ten languages, out of which only
six are available in the training dataset. We conduct several experiments and
show that an ensemble of multilingual models along with a language-specific
monolingual model has the best performance. We also evaluate other data
augmentation methods such as translation and present the results. Lastly, we
study the results thoroughly and present some noteworthy insights into this
problem. | [
0.0543038398,
0.0492186658,
-0.02849002,
0.0433087759,
-0.0579411536,
0.0032990065,
0.0150930779,
-0.0268198159,
0.0225702189,
-0.0042526489,
-0.060731221,
-0.0779287294,
0.0255321451,
0.0366089679,
0.0146156298,
-0.019646626,
-0.001801202,
0.0322179496,
-0.0330514833,
-0.0138153639,
0.0406596959,
0.0170689654,
0.0354013927,
0.0007097949,
-0.0074633113,
0.0221024454,
-0.0288495086,
-0.00341132,
0.0182413366,
0.0391566046,
0.035684485,
0.0735383332,
-0.0116170263,
0.0029389362,
0.00000205,
-0.0137493582,
-0.0493394844,
-0.0268463343,
0.0737059265,
-0.0643378496,
0.0852699131,
-0.0471584797,
0.016985897,
0.0253240559,
-0.0556888506,
0.0388957448,
0.0579886623,
0.0328874849,
0.0495169535,
0.0618438646,
-0.0370242596,
0.0184153467,
-0.0149825653,
-0.0296538901,
-0.0038516142,
0.0124555752,
0.0179530401,
-0.0412502475,
-0.0347705111,
0.0222411398,
-0.0104581537,
0.0408479236,
0.025879059,
-0.0297965631,
0.0706083328,
0.0217093956,
0.0021656009,
-0.0552328825,
-0.0004543567,
0.0494116507,
0.0237940345,
0.0099008204,
0.0054165986,
0.024135448,
-0.0061115487,
-0.0139637534,
-0.0108170286,
-0.0418992117,
0.007242294,
0.0073314826,
-0.0486047044,
0.0829456672,
0.0022223981,
0.0375867821,
0.0191057473,
0.0414100252,
-0.0222370978,
-0.0433428362,
0.0367479436,
0.0291189253,
-0.0038079233,
-0.0137117673,
0.0714637786,
-0.0080567589,
0.0262694415,
0.0104974927,
-0.0310051683,
-0.0539952666,
0.0124353804,
-0.0460613966,
-0.0406744964,
-0.0096337209,
-0.0067760078,
0.0048463163,
0.0156388395,
0.0121774171,
0.0100816675,
-0.0270536393,
-0.0439957194,
-0.0260460675,
-0.0200612359,
0.0068479539,
-0.0129336091,
0.0171726253,
-0.0272980165,
-0.0200779308,
-0.0306424908,
0.0182618275,
-0.0107505061,
0.0061449776,
-0.0046149213,
0.0332158133,
-0.0267737396,
-0.0069203358,
0.0203840211,
0.0405449718,
-0.0676137954,
0.0034039752,
-0.0300569851,
-0.0505787618,
0.0160863865,
0.0246090963,
0.0500030555,
-0.0308878161,
-0.0117311394,
0.0190098416,
-0.0229548458,
-0.0758606419,
0.0283830538,
-0.0410301201,
-0.0547480062,
-0.0585973375,
-0.0241748337,
-0.0661146268,
0.0736207515,
0.0184687991,
0.0012902117,
-0.0395225659,
0.011029155,
0.0098107783,
-0.0467831828,
0.0740059167,
-0.0095471004,
0.0130033949,
-0.0266519487,
0.0393057801,
0.0069550895,
0.041067943,
-0.006892506,
0.0846069306,
0.0840774849,
0.0126894144,
0.0164296851,
0.0279777087,
-0.014037936,
0.0411989689,
0.0280038379,
-0.0005356069,
-0.0021371357,
0.0104372501,
-0.0011891858,
0.0432151817,
0.0087336134,
-0.0467480719,
0.0743145198,
0.0774990916,
-0.0242325757,
0.0921783,
-0.0217771437,
0.0489586405,
0.0034328075,
0.051120311,
-0.0340376496,
0.0313690938,
-0.0005647116,
-0.0429639891,
0.0682538822,
0.0250901114,
-0.0167993344,
-0.0627630875,
0.0049161864,
-0.0396586992,
0.0447156727,
-0.0202006996,
0.0519434102,
-0.0030922466,
0.0009512222,
0.0167901814,
0.046433717,
-0.0782213584,
0.0076451716,
0.009349958,
-0.0104785366,
0.0650606081,
0.0118006216,
-0.0154731609,
-0.0063826405,
-0.051185105,
0.0318338051,
0.0227951761,
0.0007364683,
0.0252265483,
0.0617086515,
-0.0365822315,
-0.0142797315,
-0.0029646284,
0.0091074891,
0.0275068358,
-0.0083289873,
0.0242511444,
0.0026983253,
-0.0066435668,
-0.0122122737,
0.0160604697,
-0.0586438552,
0.0160016455,
0.0273320582,
0.03180575,
0.0067650238,
0.0581498779,
-0.0055810786,
-0.0275003165,
0.0345405266,
-0.0157065019,
-0.0442490578,
0.045404762,
-0.0364597365,
0.0224938169,
0.0204512421,
-0.0396890529,
-0.0272906031,
0.0203486253,
-0.0234216247,
-0.018875448,
0.0461422279,
-0.040443223,
0.0223739743,
-0.0224948023,
-0.0162344016,
-0.0573653132,
0.0354003832,
0.0081955148,
0.0147460699,
-0.0215880424,
0.0187933296,
-0.0301381778,
-0.0333091244,
0.0154016372,
0.0135498708,
-0.0535313562,
-0.0152759049,
0.0025537205,
0.0139845917,
0.058125753,
0.012310748,
-0.0552495047,
-0.0744759366,
-0.1177817062,
-0.004928262,
-0.0358417146,
-0.0066057667,
0.0087863598,
0.0235799197,
0.0189479142,
-0.0021661799,
-0.0692035183,
-0.0100463266,
-0.0220962912,
0.0180327706,
0.0179694667,
0.0026715095,
0.0195057001,
-0.0444934331,
0.0040866858,
-0.0099928575,
0.0487350523,
0.0292880889,
-0.01915038,
-0.0132543929,
0.0227565262,
-0.0384830423,
0.0006948363,
-0.0087577729,
-0.0663069785,
-0.0435872898,
-0.0090495264,
-0.0151864076,
0.0388203077,
0.0126616349,
0.0641176701,
0.0178146921,
-0.0101439422,
-0.0366434902,
0.0108401878,
-0.0332354978,
0.0233164299,
-0.0244455971,
-0.0462898239,
0.0168960001,
0.0288167633,
-0.0542157479,
-0.0246762838,
-0.0634142831,
0.0146300755,
0.0097553441,
-0.0174746606,
0.025325641,
0.0006906368,
0.0021294823,
-0.0044945944,
-0.008202292,
-0.0603210069,
0.051781863,
-0.0084493598,
-0.0328702107,
-0.065287523,
-0.0350819938,
-0.0138046779,
0.0838205889,
-0.0080864727,
0.0141777704,
0.0066758785,
-0.0219208188,
-0.022610914,
0.0121556977,
0.0035278013,
-0.0217165481,
0.0295626912,
0.0178670585,
-0.0273301713,
0.0308150034,
-0.0425360426,
-0.0128952404,
0.0058666617,
-0.0403576978,
-0.0457999334,
0.0308186654,
-0.0453768931,
-0.029242428,
-0.0046005887,
-0.0004113229,
-0.0345850587,
-0.049886059,
-0.0225642864,
-0.0130182095,
0.0309331808,
0.055755686,
-0.0277842581,
-0.0126148788,
-0.0281789992,
0.0235607456,
0.0657609254,
-0.003151953,
0.0017007432,
-0.0093207043,
-0.0342015922,
0.0209060069,
0.024685353,
-0.0238224696,
-0.0709068924,
0.0284867156,
-0.0068204189,
-0.0003574128,
0.1201964319,
0.0094309272,
-0.0855367705,
-0.0180192553,
-0.0436917506,
0.003572294,
-0.000404481,
0.0296768695,
-0.0606210381,
-0.0150403753,
-0.0081759719,
0.0060795108,
0.0008882427,
-0.0745683387,
-0.0196026489,
-0.0638884306,
-0.0413110889,
0.0066090967,
-0.0297368038,
-0.0288675521,
-0.0790475979,
0.0205201693,
-0.0564440973,
0.026388593,
-0.0533556342,
0.0113329003,
-0.0031892946,
0.0004576395,
0.0101314411,
-0.041532699,
0.0102620674,
-0.0577437058,
-0.0112520847,
0.0270008221,
0.1021864116,
-0.0415633395,
-0.0035049249,
-0.0211308133,
0.0556298569,
-0.0289159939,
-0.0052774195,
0.0763739944,
-0.0143093895,
0.0144510781,
-0.0103073101,
0.024589695,
0.0123911127,
0.0313407071,
0.0029903823,
0.0278632715,
-0.0213594586,
-0.0423552282,
0.0148143629,
0.0121655036,
0.0189194009,
0.0476791821,
0.0087636001,
-0.0803032368,
0.011598561,
0.005202339,
0.0520766787,
-0.0206990819,
-0.0287876986,
-0.0278391894,
0.0037306058,
-0.0580101795,
-0.0710121393,
-0.0590906702,
0.0215709917,
0.0191748887,
0.0180675406,
-0.0050208527,
0.0162771475,
-0.0074136686,
-0.0260294564,
0.0268213004,
0.0108096693,
0.0278764367,
-0.0017559867,
0.0110373497,
0.0158463847,
-0.0197061356,
0.0247240942,
-0.0500356592,
-0.0509470552,
-0.064979881,
0.0050015375,
0.0473230407,
0.0180391818,
0.0548477173,
-0.0385603644,
-0.0738668144,
0.0000776579,
0.0658652186,
-0.0396827161,
-0.0233467612,
0.0414463468,
-0.0024408151,
-0.010538524,
0.0584186725,
0.0081441365,
0.0326278284,
-0.0003194629,
-0.0358037651,
0.0119699202,
-0.0842976719,
-0.038273789,
-0.0115943961,
0.0527211279,
0.0046745096,
-0.0098515395,
-0.0350304767,
-0.0267013758,
-0.0226571728,
-0.001773896,
-0.0517388955,
0.024386242,
0.0201800447,
0.0276994314,
-0.0395524353,
-0.0290922113,
-0.0292245541,
-0.0011558929,
-0.0448291302,
0.0130354799,
0.0299543515,
-0.0269869082,
0.0104700513,
0.031238934,
-0.0209292788,
-0.0038968616,
0.0208658427,
0.0081077814,
0.0100857718,
-0.013381552,
0.0251976717,
-0.047022678,
0.0145112891,
0.0717501566,
-0.0229465477,
0.0157289524,
-0.0638561547,
-0.0243867487,
0.0286357645,
-0.0212381035,
0.0579422414,
-0.0110987285,
0.0008707648,
-0.0072910525,
0.0529993065,
-0.0094188685,
-0.0410479419,
-0.0118826097,
-0.0074660559,
-0.0185923278,
0.0695290118,
0.0547976121,
-0.0918238238,
0.0036963795,
0.0746330917,
-0.0441359021,
0.0010691722,
0.0393555649,
0.0328201242,
0.0229995772,
-0.0091172149,
0.0109864539,
-0.0156671274,
-0.0576797798,
0.0698291436,
-0.0820615813,
-0.0081943609,
0.0060386374,
0.0346881747,
0.0398147106,
-0.0018046158,
0.0448462851,
-0.039533034,
-0.0158697776,
-0.0155488141,
-0.0263545401,
0.0072318437,
-6.089446446e-33,
0.0474387966,
-0.0507611074,
-0.0594311245,
0.046849966,
-0.0352927223,
0.0201599877,
-0.0056638848,
0.0243551414,
-0.0081322631,
0.0284987837,
-0.0226533748,
0.0313033462,
0.0141580943,
0.0171502382,
0.0117095839,
0.015756188,
0.0093146823,
0.0039157011,
0.0001749665,
0.0556202494,
0.0279396996,
0.051050391,
0.052564647,
-0.1024545804,
0.0541307069,
-0.008477103,
-0.0556288809,
0.0149272252,
0.0522606857,
0.0290840697,
-0.0229230598,
0.0655310377,
0.0051403111,
-0.0074013653,
0.0140889846,
0.0835534707,
-0.0178882796,
-0.0443229452,
-0.0288335476,
0.0376537628,
-0.0262596607,
-0.0323531516,
0.0182839744,
-0.0039418028,
0.0172209702,
-0.0293809418,
0.0485635772,
-0.0209079664,
0.0192882977,
-0.037109226,
-0.0207759701,
0.0194495656,
0.0090615703,
-0.0261084214,
0.0720737204,
0.0789675415,
0.0257089231,
-0.0117799034,
-0.0184465256,
0.000274754,
-0.0185826458,
0.0261229593,
-0.0166259911,
-0.0549092293,
0.0121486625,
0.0461278297,
-0.0058829398,
0.005754583,
0.008402843,
-0.0047598183,
0.0300107095,
0.0489783213,
0.0158690661,
0.0675012916,
-0.0276937261,
0.004134479,
-0.0149774458,
0.0322699435,
0.0409784168,
0.025778709,
0.0118505061,
-0.0088215778,
-0.0126173394,
-0.0095958961,
-0.0113615319,
-0.0397231691,
-0.0246183332,
-0.0692222044,
-0.0295165107,
0.0029455132,
-0.0522284918,
0.015697049,
-0.000628025,
-0.0727893859,
-0.0417358838,
0.0239636134,
-0.0433922298,
0.0499660894,
0.0239604618,
0.013852451,
0.0014853516,
-0.0382514223,
-0.0170031674,
0.0100808712,
0.0323861353,
-0.0137551781,
0.0540428199,
0.0056882263,
-0.0463356003,
-0.0105212135,
-0.0323566832,
0.0223057121,
-0.0197608434,
0.057075467,
-0.0279525779,
0.0195053276,
-0.02639376,
0.056080658,
0.0479274839,
0.0751058906,
-0.0542378388,
-0.0185216125,
0.018336622,
0.0021310537,
-0.0299216285,
-0.0210018698,
-0.0053464165,
-0.0600892901,
0.0189565457,
0.009398385,
-0.021958841,
-0.0581288114,
2.755e-7,
-0.007911006,
0.0552328601,
0.0280536544,
-0.0494789816,
-0.0013715422,
0.0599604994,
0.0019225359,
0.0826105475,
-0.0128154131,
0.0043775514,
0.02814468,
-0.0161192976,
0.0874900594,
0.0309404507,
-0.104925409,
-0.0019459487,
-0.084401831,
-0.0192407109,
-0.0255247038,
-0.0195734091,
0.0220856722,
0.077202633,
0.0561540313,
0.0225310382,
-0.0236846432,
-0.0054297727,
0.0498415157,
-0.0756184757,
0.0088765761,
0.0341082066,
0.0362557508,
-0.0005002357,
-0.0259762332,
0.0063389433,
-0.0389503911,
-0.000630597,
0.0222944096,
0.071688585,
-0.003769832,
-0.0103294384,
0.0430342965,
0.0051003266,
0.0057508168,
-0.0566812456,
0.0534198992,
-0.0501794405,
-0.0432201326,
0.0088565433,
0.0110421628,
-0.0036642395,
0.0681743845,
-0.0020383238,
-0.0393134914,
0.0627222359,
0.020808775,
-0.0204222333,
-0.0046587829,
-0.05719335,
0.0057146503,
-0.0247630998,
0.0006616224,
0.0055716834,
-0.0081341602,
-0.000592198,
-0.001364534,
-0.0467060693,
0.0523729287,
1.952932335e-34,
0.0217868127,
-0.0159298014,
-0.0034564068,
0.0257870313,
0.0270898845,
-0.0036195882,
0.01024165,
-0.0024429089,
0.0364056006,
-0.0356096253,
0.0032606435
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.02578v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.02578v1 | Empathy and Distress Detection using Ensembles of Transformer Models | 2023-12-05T08:50:34 | 2023-12-05T08:50:34 | Tanmay Chavan, Kshitij Deshpande, Sheetal Sonawane | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper presents our approach for the WASSA 2023 Empathy, Emotion and
Personality Shared Task. Empathy and distress are human feelings that are
implicitly expressed in natural discourses. Empathy and distress detection are
crucial challenges in Natural Language Processing that can aid our
understanding of conversations. The provided dataset consists of several
long-text examples in the English language, with each example associated with a
numeric score for empathy and distress. We experiment with several BERT-based
models as a part of our approach. We also try various ensemble methods. Our
final submission has a Pearson's r score of 0.346, placing us third in the
empathy and distress detection subtask. | [
0.0287242476,
0.0287989154,
-0.0292491019,
0.0160204414,
-0.032916747,
0.0421802141,
0.0135503625,
-0.0117849307,
0.015916599,
-0.0465190001,
-0.052209042,
-0.0120366523,
0.0074914182,
-0.0433946103,
-0.0240467452,
-0.0878834799,
0.0119580468,
0.0647160783,
0.0104806721,
-0.0127717666,
-0.0065384167,
0.0332205892,
-0.0257908721,
0.0633583888,
-0.0221348517,
-0.0115803014,
0.0038619831,
0.0021105499,
0.0624705367,
0.010040435,
0.0239477102,
0.0668855458,
0.001925649,
-0.0191001855,
0.0000017614,
-0.0282022916,
0.0040560612,
-0.0032223247,
0.012190369,
-0.0561104529,
0.0172192641,
-0.0272172447,
0.0246703941,
0.042728167,
-0.03660395,
-0.0330628604,
0.0248525422,
0.1007595733,
0.0768289417,
0.0535379387,
-0.0387278423,
0.0041487566,
-0.0012496305,
-0.001630352,
-0.0239901021,
0.0458862633,
0.0187287852,
-0.013964246,
-0.0096234232,
-0.0437190533,
-0.018790707,
-0.0030465478,
-0.0090157604,
-0.0044767288,
-0.0047819456,
0.0263736099,
-0.0493835732,
-0.0436350517,
-0.0289329384,
0.0596109815,
0.0092668105,
0.0325817876,
-0.0078691887,
-0.0059999321,
0.0182472933,
0.0095894532,
-0.0024236646,
-0.0204519872,
-0.0115296887,
0.0141373193,
-0.0013516909,
0.0428770334,
-0.030220842,
0.0055229459,
0.0017765359,
0.0427068658,
-0.0034918564,
-0.0288751833,
0.0261684749,
0.0321007371,
-0.0494820811,
-0.0093540028,
0.0340655148,
0.0018009434,
-0.0079575637,
0.0135195693,
-0.0373872779,
-0.0380303264,
-0.0175622888,
-0.0218479112,
0.0425198339,
0.0551028252,
-0.0294011384,
-0.007586218,
0.0061526312,
0.0434269421,
0.0133842751,
0.0101568773,
-0.0359768867,
-0.0094396183,
-0.0446949042,
0.0263714977,
-0.0194885656,
0.0412036255,
-0.0292571038,
-0.0015943461,
-0.0547981299,
0.0064813579,
-0.0063179759,
-0.018882893,
0.0290679187,
-0.0103126615,
-0.0084666787,
0.0200099163,
0.0067068981,
0.0646579266,
-0.0228779949,
0.0069675534,
-0.0101951426,
-0.0677772239,
0.0302019026,
0.019618975,
0.0213759653,
-0.0403180383,
0.0089485226,
0.0156146716,
0.0045142933,
-0.0657613799,
-0.0100227054,
0.0210060347,
-0.0355134457,
-0.0372256078,
-0.0111026242,
-0.0054985206,
0.0423905179,
0.011874117,
0.0221224725,
0.0128857223,
0.038826663,
-0.0087115541,
-0.0187741853,
0.0586555153,
0.0233972818,
0.0311769415,
-0.0022482274,
-0.0024808904,
0.0011963936,
0.0317668878,
0.0143207908,
0.0056076893,
0.039651759,
-0.0428817682,
0.0214104243,
0.0288227126,
-0.0393861644,
-0.0154970307,
0.0070937066,
-0.0318454839,
-0.0192110147,
0.0336496606,
0.0023149136,
0.0450589396,
-0.0061804196,
-0.0204234831,
0.0431567132,
0.1222806573,
0.0264308006,
0.0749375075,
-0.0060604601,
0.0157900527,
0.0189083423,
0.0094140135,
-0.0271042343,
0.0422949567,
-0.0344646201,
-0.0487440601,
-0.008256603,
0.0416126959,
-0.018720137,
-0.035599377,
-0.0423145182,
-0.0187834688,
-0.0132877147,
-0.0078177145,
0.0142217865,
-0.0241323225,
-0.0256975908,
0.012005873,
0.026095368,
-0.0845452324,
-0.008593604,
-0.0373945273,
0.01177218,
0.0718812719,
0.023950804,
-0.0284803472,
-0.0414618552,
-0.0436219051,
-0.0250348449,
0.0213078409,
0.0248153694,
0.0046735536,
0.0338478424,
-0.0273674019,
-0.0039826403,
0.0467635691,
0.0088904612,
-0.0075147678,
-0.0363358259,
-0.0000171587,
-0.024234619,
-0.0084905168,
-0.0117422482,
0.0560228303,
-0.0593230426,
0.0270471722,
0.0146168396,
0.0303286444,
0.0291428622,
0.0127584096,
-0.02105611,
-0.0223058537,
0.0255199913,
-0.0172305182,
-0.0609055534,
0.0833117887,
-0.0347843356,
-0.0595318303,
0.0014882718,
-0.0862924308,
-0.0116196694,
0.0694243088,
0.0018089233,
-0.02005977,
-0.0058652363,
-0.0670199916,
0.0148088299,
-0.0270249974,
0.0313709192,
-0.0330320597,
0.0518726781,
0.0003759433,
0.0207855087,
-0.0332115032,
0.0392507613,
-0.0616463311,
-0.0368212946,
-0.0016306803,
-0.0509139225,
-0.0423403196,
-0.0093495278,
0.0096592978,
-0.0085720383,
-0.0031226675,
-0.0315231159,
-0.0380732082,
-0.0536307879,
-0.1227304488,
-0.0142662628,
-0.0079007456,
-0.0035961836,
0.0079306969,
0.0157594346,
-0.0370349474,
0.0346803553,
-0.0334012173,
0.0221667644,
0.0310364403,
-0.0160567611,
0.0084503768,
-0.0298998449,
-0.0006136768,
-0.0729523525,
0.0070947791,
-0.0691230297,
0.0345249362,
0.0144176427,
-0.0439860001,
-0.0337305889,
0.0068473262,
-0.022891894,
0.0183893424,
0.0007735794,
-0.0801245794,
0.0029512865,
0.0004953998,
0.0688985139,
0.0521002598,
0.0455496274,
0.0851080269,
-0.009879983,
0.0117508415,
-0.046971228,
0.0345666111,
-0.0423386693,
0.037114542,
-0.0344549976,
-0.0664605349,
0.0223581102,
0.0630524606,
0.0185627881,
-0.0016417709,
-0.0666773468,
-0.0398211554,
0.0203733295,
-0.0520500913,
0.0304304026,
-0.0088426257,
0.0067916345,
-0.0230822228,
0.0129107395,
-0.0274432786,
0.053608425,
0.011965448,
-0.0442553721,
-0.0598996468,
-0.0084630447,
-0.0175553169,
0.0588368736,
-0.0432775952,
0.0181936231,
0.0403767787,
-0.0134696178,
-0.0223807078,
-0.0077945739,
-0.018739203,
-0.0334114507,
0.0161134899,
0.0182532854,
-0.0226079803,
0.0398816951,
-0.0255081654,
-0.0407321528,
-0.0745261014,
-0.0154284472,
0.0017576355,
0.0257642828,
-0.0480434857,
-0.0754030198,
-0.0037645458,
0.0172397587,
0.0019793808,
-0.0170620829,
-0.0223581716,
0.0044190222,
0.0291206334,
0.0215258598,
0.0168669671,
0.0448088124,
-0.0434801728,
0.0626306236,
0.0436252765,
0.0332686715,
0.036092855,
-0.013533379,
0.0073979702,
0.0160645936,
0.0001413627,
-0.0083187753,
-0.0489541441,
0.0195440874,
0.0182022117,
-0.0025161428,
0.1462183595,
0.0239609331,
-0.0582089126,
0.0217079688,
-0.0632693022,
-0.0374830514,
0.030290097,
-0.0040261163,
-0.0130558079,
-0.0046030232,
-0.0203852039,
0.0102811642,
-0.023815589,
-0.0634725019,
0.0339000598,
-0.0762830153,
0.0622125268,
-0.021214975,
0.0378406495,
-0.0204567164,
-0.0138448151,
0.0502728969,
0.0025631529,
0.0030520863,
-0.0602163412,
0.0072055906,
-0.0177475251,
0.026704479,
0.0107509643,
-0.0219388492,
0.0466167703,
-0.0436826348,
0.0390136689,
0.0139386673,
0.1047742739,
-0.0264608487,
-0.0366974883,
-0.04748578,
0.0058080037,
-0.0070387055,
0.0083131799,
0.0600286201,
-0.0273886323,
-0.0176149718,
-0.0452461913,
0.0507723168,
-0.036285907,
0.023597911,
-0.0350478701,
0.0740692466,
-0.0515389629,
-0.0523728803,
-0.002692675,
0.0199204367,
0.0206457265,
0.0901790261,
0.0193179902,
-0.0502423942,
0.0279715396,
0.0515813343,
0.0285532288,
0.0162670109,
-0.0196433142,
0.0243859719,
0.0229346454,
-0.0326910801,
-0.0656364262,
-0.0562694222,
0.0340850949,
0.0241713971,
-0.0080069499,
-0.083110556,
0.0087827565,
0.0446351022,
-0.0821214914,
0.0402384661,
0.0415047668,
0.0347591378,
-0.0324581154,
0.0012569085,
0.0433842912,
0.0299103875,
-0.038048625,
-0.0317904577,
-0.0109702442,
-0.0471294746,
0.0359533392,
0.0204861164,
0.0130735142,
-0.0074494518,
-0.0027062732,
-0.0326639749,
0.0246809144,
0.0624332093,
-0.031471841,
0.0168854333,
0.0149354935,
0.0273107085,
-0.0116206734,
0.0377075784,
0.0010657212,
0.0521730632,
0.0140589513,
0.0142918564,
0.0244596973,
-0.0525511578,
0.0040579755,
0.0016838559,
0.0336346105,
0.0256544966,
-0.0091548637,
-0.0344066918,
-0.0357716493,
-0.0121759819,
-0.0040028556,
-0.0473561734,
-0.0318209194,
0.034090206,
0.0330192484,
-0.0348267183,
-0.0301627647,
-0.0593019575,
-0.0309154764,
-0.0497970432,
0.0441950411,
0.0266762543,
0.0149200168,
-0.0293714125,
0.0230467413,
-0.0093965074,
-0.0380956717,
0.00712934,
-0.0037068427,
0.0116618806,
0.0613274351,
0.0167091452,
-0.009165612,
0.0037762064,
0.0264866687,
-0.0198065098,
-0.0218185224,
-0.0503982157,
0.0183352586,
0.0071174162,
-0.0003110375,
0.036173325,
-0.0296168532,
0.0279018041,
-0.0011992059,
0.0157829989,
-0.0417509675,
-0.0181926712,
0.0226066262,
-0.0003058657,
-0.0155870812,
-0.0254283417,
0.020337617,
-0.0848029479,
0.0397292115,
0.030130446,
-0.0173103176,
-0.0636825264,
0.0117074391,
0.0706335455,
-0.0419258922,
-0.0157882161,
0.0441927984,
-0.0561090074,
-0.0234384984,
0.0816215128,
-0.0463225767,
-0.0047629322,
-0.0169952065,
-0.0034555309,
0.0345944092,
-0.0223150477,
0.0131452978,
-0.03718156,
0.0368871801,
-0.0643774346,
-0.0193666443,
-0.036553394,
-5.507898902e-33,
-0.0191500485,
-0.0018871658,
-0.0798023641,
0.0080575487,
-0.0343289152,
0.0098676318,
-0.0270004291,
0.0144544933,
0.0029981574,
0.0698253959,
-0.0093131829,
0.0608813092,
0.0125032952,
-0.0035639312,
0.0034860086,
-0.0168391448,
0.0152792521,
-0.0237407945,
-0.0341360644,
0.0108363898,
0.0187794007,
0.0523740016,
0.1118844971,
-0.0498480909,
-0.0171051323,
0.0234949738,
-0.0328702256,
0.0178296417,
0.048421368,
0.0539284721,
-0.0195443351,
0.0572110787,
0.0273222532,
0.0036159006,
0.0284372289,
0.0618553646,
-0.0279201791,
-0.0034022182,
0.0077884533,
0.0189609844,
-0.0290923417,
-0.0099610342,
0.0288103055,
0.0001359102,
-0.0200294629,
-0.0357810184,
0.045856934,
-0.0155945327,
0.0632901639,
-0.0286022741,
-0.0453645848,
-0.0209253412,
-0.0363314748,
-0.0367264785,
0.0039343303,
0.0755103305,
-0.0085291769,
0.0392904729,
0.0017687421,
0.005182507,
-0.027713418,
-0.0089581702,
-0.0058261617,
-0.0548491329,
0.0078565171,
0.0862007365,
0.0124988034,
-0.012666313,
-0.0238957107,
0.0043806611,
0.0338370167,
0.04578273,
0.0560838468,
0.0366503596,
-0.0616891123,
0.0008091657,
0.0031300655,
0.044535242,
0.0671251267,
0.0291298013,
0.0369560085,
-0.0142909,
-0.0301042069,
0.0228706114,
-0.0066703949,
-0.0843931288,
-0.0118277278,
0.0003184077,
0.0152385365,
-0.030736275,
-0.0191140361,
-0.0066640619,
0.0123120164,
-0.0483760796,
0.0207406338,
-0.0007916769,
-0.0034559388,
0.0649911836,
-0.0036367006,
0.0236025006,
-0.0068680206,
-0.0438015983,
0.0365826376,
0.0577171557,
0.0598680153,
-0.0107374787,
0.0054203025,
0.019412294,
-0.0578711629,
-0.023783043,
-0.016659284,
0.0161636584,
-0.0325059779,
0.0581566766,
-0.0154059976,
0.024961995,
-0.0245644506,
-0.0228398256,
-0.0094508529,
0.0356744751,
-0.0590491146,
-0.0127163678,
0.0190895312,
0.0153169343,
-0.0152702918,
-0.0208188184,
-0.0173335969,
-0.0680411533,
0.0401157364,
0.0070360736,
0.0023698844,
-0.0413964801,
2.442e-7,
-0.0058868858,
0.0519560836,
0.0212065019,
-0.0710188448,
-0.0074138236,
0.0255829096,
0.00652172,
0.0696895346,
0.0405511856,
-0.0054366658,
0.0396653935,
-0.0352149792,
0.0631440207,
0.0126838181,
-0.0649453476,
0.0023011272,
-0.0258383229,
-0.027217038,
-0.0206533279,
0.0018386353,
0.0851931125,
0.0910154134,
0.0380857624,
0.006163382,
0.0041350219,
0.038784299,
0.0468286313,
-0.0692394823,
0.0048951865,
0.0438202098,
0.0190421678,
-0.0068398197,
0.0190732609,
0.0106969737,
0.0243909527,
0.042405609,
0.0347714126,
0.0481561758,
-0.0251993071,
-0.0417368673,
-0.0009607775,
0.0339121893,
-0.0189687703,
-0.0267241057,
0.0023677454,
-0.1227024645,
-0.0429657809,
-0.0077733449,
-0.0390144065,
0.0021164319,
0.0274316557,
-0.0010534158,
-0.0225295816,
0.0670847967,
0.0380835347,
-0.0217720941,
0.0057511558,
-0.0655691698,
0.0250772834,
-0.0031595537,
-0.0566405095,
-0.0327075347,
0.0148829091,
0.007333186,
0.0131488051,
-0.0590564199,
0.006449536,
1.949140907e-34,
0.0019501123,
0.0349790119,
-0.0001600589,
0.0575309359,
0.0302207265,
-0.0088777589,
-0.0067672678,
-0.014497214,
0.0107532218,
-0.0896250904,
-0.00024164
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03025v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03025v1 | Training on Synthetic Data Beats Real Data in Multimodal Relation Extraction | 2023-12-05T08:11:34 | 2023-12-05T08:11:34 | Zilin Du, Haoxin Li, Xu Guo, Boyang Li | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG | The task of multimodal relation extraction has attracted significant research
attention, but progress is constrained by the scarcity of available training
data. One natural thought is to extend existing datasets with cross-modal
generative models. In this paper, we consider a novel problem setting, where
only unimodal data, either text or image, are available during training. We aim
to train a multimodal classifier from synthetic data that perform well on real
multimodal test data. However, training with synthetic data suffers from two
obstacles: lack of data diversity and label information loss. To alleviate the
issues, we propose Mutual Information-aware Multimodal Iterated Relational dAta
GEneration (MI2RAGE), which applies Chained Cross-modal Generation (CCG) to
promote diversity in the generated data and exploits a teacher network to
select valuable training samples with high mutual information with the
ground-truth labels. Comparing our method to direct training on synthetic data,
we observed a significant improvement of 24.06% F1 with synthetic text and
26.42% F1 with synthetic images. Notably, our best model trained on completely
synthetic images outperforms prior state-of-the-art models trained on real
multimodal data by a margin of 3.76% in F1. Our codebase will be made available
upon acceptance. | [
0.0404689871,
0.1040586382,
0.0218306091,
0.0853023082,
-0.0089284955,
0.0096276235,
0.0330410562,
0.0143978251,
-0.0220632516,
-0.0766739026,
-0.051071275,
-0.0467337593,
-0.0252562501,
0.0074707004,
0.0385059007,
-0.0651444122,
0.0179862063,
0.0182171687,
-0.0509635694,
-0.0036298907,
-0.0018515873,
0.0370505005,
-0.0470767282,
-0.0165016074,
-0.1166751981,
-0.0129458485,
-0.0017019823,
0.0087688165,
0.0133010037,
-0.0608329847,
0.0009077406,
0.0278237835,
0.0299025737,
-0.0273068324,
0.0000020868,
-0.0112089133,
-0.0011829172,
0.0030265118,
0.0168494917,
-0.0439135022,
0.0363785475,
-0.0210883729,
0.0336574614,
-0.0203686859,
-0.0545199104,
-0.0541964248,
0.040809121,
0.0714346096,
0.0239641778,
0.0388014428,
-0.0605725124,
-0.039409291,
0.0050401818,
-0.0176089071,
0.0537172779,
0.0200537033,
-0.0070126317,
0.0369367264,
-0.0057553048,
-0.0032174662,
-0.058321856,
0.0320500955,
0.0362505764,
-0.0029498823,
0.0261061639,
0.0686468408,
0.0275778957,
-0.0357584916,
-0.0115786092,
0.1343375444,
0.0163802598,
0.0363533571,
0.0119519606,
-0.0017430827,
-0.0082782479,
0.0209993552,
0.0092623169,
0.0238757916,
-0.0578032769,
0.0157107338,
-0.0516543612,
0.0020984856,
0.0222201142,
-0.0161374826,
0.0122989574,
-0.0137240272,
0.0061265249,
0.0195745211,
0.0129527152,
0.0105240671,
-0.0114285871,
-0.0124875624,
-0.03865356,
-0.0044270591,
0.0074015781,
-0.0000350937,
-0.050669495,
-0.051594995,
-0.0204234943,
-0.0300370175,
0.011305104,
-0.0168513991,
-0.0468701608,
0.032625448,
-0.0152800987,
-0.0405485295,
-0.037788406,
0.0320615619,
-0.0131969387,
-0.0020478819,
-0.0350853316,
0.0042639389,
0.0016894882,
0.01666913,
-0.0692469329,
-0.0390930921,
-0.0237268787,
0.0079309335,
0.0028671811,
-0.0087294783,
-0.0058009122,
0.0335522965,
-0.0336107835,
0.0050078272,
-0.0140874228,
0.0020497432,
-0.0173516925,
0.0276322551,
-0.0165390857,
-0.0515632816,
0.0233205017,
0.0210463591,
0.0282869916,
-0.031952545,
0.0217715278,
0.1170238256,
-0.0662976578,
-0.0394273289,
-0.051095333,
-0.0708082244,
-0.0074450332,
-0.0639900267,
0.0640585721,
-0.0310874246,
0.0778376982,
-0.0015132368,
-0.0065536224,
-0.0098484056,
0.0244014785,
-0.0246729702,
-0.0179444905,
0.0920666456,
-0.0370000117,
-0.0073022959,
0.005207411,
0.010627036,
0.0250009634,
0.0735436603,
0.064494811,
0.0194216762,
0.0388118625,
0.0078276591,
-0.0150555316,
0.0207316373,
0.0146906739,
-0.0117794406,
-0.0003266444,
-0.0263805091,
0.042700354,
0.0170044433,
0.0444897972,
0.0351734906,
-0.0430500507,
-0.0180777628,
0.0445174836,
-0.0529181994,
0.0228538923,
0.0463548712,
0.0659044981,
-0.0224424619,
0.0024299512,
0.0169194825,
-0.0502139479,
0.0573149137,
0.0087945396,
0.0030777049,
0.0245335717,
0.0429019518,
-0.0111068692,
-0.0348319896,
0.0476759821,
-0.0205954462,
0.005339358,
-0.0064783762,
0.0681031197,
0.0368887298,
-0.052147992,
0.0229394045,
0.0665480494,
-0.0346643329,
0.0159446672,
0.0577384345,
-0.0005197836,
0.0362568535,
0.0335681289,
-0.0151245268,
-0.0017520095,
-0.0094032343,
0.0172257386,
0.0313230455,
0.0041502747,
-0.0278258659,
0.0719215348,
-0.0547873043,
-0.075547412,
-0.0041266438,
-0.0033073646,
0.0262248535,
0.0168386307,
0.0136719588,
0.0156348851,
-0.0216010325,
0.0224139858,
0.0480946079,
-0.0124956826,
-0.0063974624,
0.001276341,
0.025169652,
0.0335072652,
0.0122027416,
-0.0321226567,
-0.036746487,
0.0291716773,
-0.0672151074,
-0.0036974379,
0.042824924,
-0.0663992912,
-0.0635321438,
0.0139114261,
-0.0696683526,
-0.0148268165,
-0.0240316726,
-0.0465064645,
-0.0119194807,
0.0157631617,
-0.0039659166,
0.0210359041,
-0.0246467981,
-0.0451937132,
0.0859107748,
0.032936614,
0.0019531497,
0.0565986224,
-0.0186004732,
-0.0172916967,
-0.008920664,
-0.0044832421,
0.021642264,
0.0125564476,
0.0113369562,
0.0321399942,
0.0013149475,
-0.0046024723,
-0.0034099168,
0.0185015053,
-0.0283510666,
-0.009955232,
-0.0777485743,
-0.0330253765,
0.0302090868,
-0.004054904,
-0.0162854865,
0.011099373,
0.0037371584,
-0.043710947,
-0.0075238547,
0.0505275205,
-0.0026962857,
-0.0037884465,
0.0284540951,
0.0458153971,
0.0193042997,
-0.0156744439,
0.0062454701,
0.0028164259,
0.0921290815,
0.0213155914,
0.0021392577,
0.0066438229,
0.0074225031,
-0.0521676242,
0.0765766203,
-0.0259745456,
-0.0067987251,
0.0008928382,
-0.0284291953,
0.0204984285,
-0.0167687256,
0.0225063581,
0.0305515788,
0.0103353551,
-0.0275686309,
-0.0266154073,
0.0372768566,
-0.012221681,
0.0116654532,
-0.0130127128,
-0.0295503139,
-0.0492986664,
0.0249827132,
0.01211718,
0.036201667,
-0.0322401598,
0.0056236433,
0.0576386638,
-0.0584014468,
-0.0303955264,
0.0457095094,
0.0311729182,
-0.0100989426,
-0.0579560101,
-0.0080502955,
0.0219875127,
-0.0222624969,
-0.0112324031,
-0.0015601721,
0.0221092664,
-0.0062467908,
0.09896788,
0.0143414019,
0.0554156601,
0.0232498366,
0.0243850909,
-0.0463766083,
-0.0053681596,
0.0434451513,
0.0172467791,
-0.0064824768,
-0.0462692045,
0.0202271398,
-0.0103851529,
-0.0322686732,
-0.04908856,
-0.0419845991,
0.0088674203,
-0.0466902107,
-0.0172167197,
0.0038237053,
0.0239988007,
-0.013082793,
0.0186177175,
0.0182332937,
0.0066557075,
-0.0317556486,
-0.0157542415,
0.0626621023,
0.0425133333,
-0.007518738,
-0.0498867705,
-0.0380399562,
-0.0300144665,
0.0519658327,
0.0211684853,
0.0105240224,
-0.0373588577,
0.0184361022,
-0.0262016077,
0.0584203973,
0.0030838682,
-0.0130051272,
0.0130132381,
-0.0214296915,
0.009484658,
0.0202435683,
-0.010776707,
-0.0549392328,
0.0118552968,
0.0724711642,
0.0039791199,
0.0170245823,
-0.0005258527,
-0.0941124782,
-0.0522990711,
-0.0321696438,
-0.0210155435,
0.0222638585,
-0.0344130956,
-0.0142679354,
-0.1069323793,
0.0136701278,
-0.0138936993,
-0.0555455461,
-0.0493253469,
-0.0221735667,
-0.016888056,
0.0103283273,
-0.0227245782,
-0.0044634356,
-0.0195149835,
0.0161674805,
0.0218995158,
0.0564604551,
-0.0707648173,
-0.0349463671,
-0.0398438461,
-0.0152597902,
-0.0031727226,
0.0171540789,
-0.0005031252,
-0.0191480983,
0.0284937155,
0.0265419297,
-0.0060511841,
-0.0384294987,
0.0938240513,
-0.0527404137,
-0.0445018746,
0.0123426896,
0.0279520862,
-0.0085616633,
0.0146515677,
-0.0252462681,
0.0280804913,
-0.0017330853,
0.0047070705,
-0.0171470754,
0.0093213767,
0.0374850705,
0.0209173206,
-0.0108701102,
-0.0427362025,
-0.00941025,
0.0048314058,
0.0469352454,
-0.0594322346,
0.0262364503,
0.0161825065,
-0.0490650944,
-0.0076795369,
-0.060550563,
-0.0468386561,
0.0073492173,
0.0749546736,
-0.0033685653,
-0.0277070161,
-0.0219719205,
0.0133202095,
-0.0791852772,
0.0369954929,
0.0124454238,
0.0000559277,
-0.0066512949,
-0.0236576665,
0.0179194584,
-0.0869525447,
-0.0080511356,
0.0097501967,
-0.0318843685,
-0.0189852789,
-0.0483504348,
0.0604912564,
0.000200603,
0.0628632605,
0.0626587644,
-0.0042339875,
0.006499466,
0.1027542427,
-0.0412834026,
0.000344387,
0.0336017422,
-0.0118372981,
0.0143111348,
0.0014630489,
-0.0570446439,
0.0309447255,
0.0306510031,
0.0270339213,
0.001914674,
-0.0125243152,
0.0081221936,
-0.0075477604,
0.0381887667,
-0.0605817437,
0.0224570595,
-0.068192035,
-0.0081319483,
-0.0236807577,
0.0054428987,
-0.0842576101,
0.0543442406,
-0.0074141715,
0.0233531073,
-0.0122994222,
-0.010931639,
0.0397896506,
0.0620899945,
-0.0091269845,
-0.0021000907,
0.012582873,
-0.0105418051,
0.0072303126,
-0.0040256828,
0.0087327259,
0.0277627278,
0.0133794649,
-0.006731709,
-0.0178262275,
0.0756889433,
0.0412343852,
-0.0494777933,
-0.0330535695,
0.0233043302,
0.0134000927,
0.0671542734,
-0.0660846308,
0.064261198,
0.0620345138,
0.0184229724,
0.0072702658,
-0.0378164724,
-0.0012738258,
0.0184012391,
0.0764620081,
-0.0078375274,
-0.0218789838,
0.0481933653,
-0.0211361162,
-0.0008070598,
0.0099566607,
0.0923200995,
-0.0191882607,
0.0541625805,
-0.012324715,
-0.0017270632,
-0.074420318,
-0.0043162252,
0.03057044,
0.0095514031,
-0.0005441793,
0.0313456096,
-0.0086372541,
-0.0551195629,
-0.007495177,
0.0185316578,
-0.0242581293,
0.044077266,
0.0476757362,
0.0498103648,
0.0342510752,
-0.0316155814,
-0.0235582925,
0.0021028449,
0.0079643223,
-0.004856823,
0.0007324936,
-6.138654109e-33,
-0.0327229127,
-0.0172790196,
0.0238158237,
-0.0130260913,
-0.0557231903,
0.0151626794,
-0.0327136852,
-0.0015095893,
-0.0020687471,
0.0340699293,
0.0219784509,
-0.0407129601,
0.0024500231,
0.0288150609,
0.0067615602,
0.0042934516,
0.0224567298,
-0.0139310844,
0.0076478343,
0.0261934809,
0.0456918664,
0.0402907394,
0.0734140351,
-0.1102001742,
-0.0137328999,
0.0158162303,
-0.027799936,
0.0099041769,
0.0168840662,
0.035774067,
-0.0668628812,
0.0252595022,
0.0282856412,
-0.0205067378,
0.0058626262,
0.0017914957,
-0.1295027137,
0.0100307707,
-0.0117494678,
0.0185812861,
-0.0781768113,
-0.0110610053,
0.0367362499,
-0.0301878657,
0.0295832753,
-0.0478245616,
0.0472402126,
-0.042202238,
0.0233128164,
-0.0696146116,
-0.0461881198,
0.0127257342,
0.0293319765,
-0.0320568755,
0.034767475,
0.0564941317,
0.0392520688,
-0.0280322805,
-0.0137212882,
0.0072140009,
-0.0487775207,
-0.0084300805,
0.0416864231,
0.0367091782,
0.0165313128,
0.0621676967,
0.0366764627,
-0.0315870903,
-0.0248009097,
0.0115256738,
0.0049242456,
0.0647020862,
-0.0260805096,
0.1156946197,
0.0165256243,
0.0063067931,
-0.082124576,
0.0159169193,
-0.0128828306,
-0.0088155558,
-0.0247150604,
-0.0077593066,
0.0050170468,
0.0046969038,
0.0035530631,
-0.0385232121,
0.0001630855,
-0.0288679209,
0.0172938164,
0.0359576046,
-0.0343746692,
0.0381643586,
0.0534912236,
-0.025138868,
-0.0591938645,
-0.0044921907,
-0.0088697784,
0.0405315869,
0.0010721142,
-0.0438178591,
-0.0317734778,
-0.0446028486,
0.0571459234,
-0.013759858,
0.0261195246,
0.0160422064,
0.0438277796,
0.0108563574,
-0.0312517621,
-0.0147715695,
-0.0321168043,
0.0288972985,
0.0188521873,
0.0157608613,
0.0229737461,
0.0153986625,
-0.0578481779,
0.0214063469,
0.0149556203,
0.0487100184,
-0.0321896337,
-0.0265002735,
0.0011976379,
0.0685910136,
0.0065413942,
0.0198895242,
-0.0401580259,
-0.0839062333,
0.024385903,
-0.0743710175,
-0.0077310815,
0.0262675583,
2.735e-7,
0.0135444961,
-0.0165604744,
0.0186998025,
-0.012703428,
0.0175942928,
0.0585158542,
0.0176516715,
0.0510860868,
-0.0367857553,
-0.0492191277,
0.0083174221,
0.0134683624,
0.0260748863,
0.0249588117,
0.0015099121,
-0.0192850363,
-0.0345728993,
-0.0638304725,
-0.0566632077,
0.0012002109,
0.0535847694,
0.0396202318,
0.0078349207,
-0.0269113593,
-0.0028846781,
-0.0112296613,
0.0583401173,
-0.0278302636,
-0.018864451,
-0.0017131206,
0.0326972492,
-0.0119758816,
-0.0163001642,
0.045480676,
-0.0233723372,
-0.0307015274,
0.0327781104,
-0.0107074277,
-0.0117728431,
-0.0214532241,
0.0134592978,
0.0341151208,
-0.0326983295,
0.0038503192,
0.0503751151,
-0.0289609749,
0.0060991459,
-0.0122671267,
-0.0488490388,
0.0371516049,
-0.0208986383,
0.0070747384,
-0.039985545,
0.0335833132,
0.0387605131,
-0.0185014196,
-0.0426916629,
-0.064801164,
0.0091097299,
0.0218795575,
-0.042641636,
0.013625985,
0.0094765807,
-0.0364580862,
0.0070122108,
-0.0229830164,
-0.0437937677,
1.904920049e-34,
-0.0253282376,
-0.0005775825,
-0.0019098383,
-0.0333548747,
0.0249494836,
-0.0288792849,
-0.0468154326,
-0.0230008941,
-0.02792117,
-0.0134862512,
-0.0054137115
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.02554v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.02554v2 | ULMA: Unified Language Model Alignment with Human Demonstration and Point-wise Preference | 2023-12-05T07:52:12 | 2024-02-26T08:51:03 | Tianchi Cai, Xierui Song, Jiyan Jiang, Fei Teng, Jinjie Gu, Guannan Zhang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Aligning language models to human expectations, e.g., being helpful and
harmless, has become a pressing challenge for large language models. A typical
alignment procedure consists of supervised fine-tuning and preference learning.
Most preference learning methods, such as RLHF and DPO, depend on pairwise
preference data, which inadequately address scenarios where human feedback is
point-wise, leading to potential information loss and suboptimal performance.
Addressing this gap, we introduce Point-wise Direct Preference Optimization, a
novel preference learning method designed to harness point-wise feedback
effectively. Our work also uncovers a novel connection between supervised
fine-tuning and point-wise preference learning, culminating in Unified Language
Model Alignment, a single-step method that unifies the alignment with human
demonstrations and point-wise preferences. Extensive experiments on point-wise
preference datasets with binary or continuous labels validate the effectiveness
of our methods. Our code and a new dataset with high-quality demonstration
samples on harmlessness are released. | [
0.0270404816,
0.0761456639,
-0.0026986441,
0.0349226743,
-0.0226624776,
0.022412518,
-0.0313151702,
-0.0154596148,
0.0001165447,
-0.0174364671,
-0.0392206535,
-0.0325494781,
0.0169779547,
-0.0120906783,
0.0289265029,
-0.0541430935,
0.0622946806,
-0.0081698727,
0.0100392904,
-0.0294767004,
0.0426331349,
0.0228777602,
-0.0255523771,
0.0524818785,
-0.0119383438,
-0.0030701563,
0.0112426756,
0.0185354147,
0.0295458455,
-0.024777405,
0.0655909032,
0.0699782521,
0.0298943128,
0.0191268194,
0.0000020446,
-0.0563813411,
-0.0103075281,
-0.0126639279,
-0.0072021903,
-0.0109852105,
0.0652244091,
-0.0079934001,
-0.0228145048,
0.025702145,
-0.0099990144,
0.0132381562,
0.0745412111,
0.0176762287,
0.0245304238,
0.0513213538,
0.0078608841,
-0.0237193014,
-0.0096274884,
-0.0375025235,
0.0123010781,
-0.025003653,
0.0333991498,
-0.0438599959,
0.0160587952,
-0.0222965218,
-0.0190421902,
0.0105771655,
-0.0307855308,
0.0030949821,
-0.0112389587,
0.0198947992,
-0.0335008278,
-0.0381394625,
-0.0062646605,
0.1003309488,
-0.0358315781,
-0.0330187455,
-0.003265959,
-0.020522207,
-0.0025189053,
-0.0019737438,
0.0132375462,
-0.0254817046,
0.0062559778,
0.0379250459,
0.0190743674,
-0.0076359562,
0.0262644906,
0.0346497893,
-0.0036716771,
0.0934029147,
0.0173533373,
-0.0352008864,
0.0310167745,
-0.0179549698,
-0.079560414,
-0.0381241515,
0.0066951141,
-0.0089809289,
-0.0585580394,
0.0105654076,
-0.0556130335,
0.0103507424,
0.0535862297,
-0.0667372048,
0.0831785947,
0.0432516821,
-0.0279685073,
0.0399702974,
0.0392669551,
0.052593749,
-0.0116405785,
0.0505927354,
-0.0209365226,
0.0353247896,
0.0149694243,
0.018676579,
-0.0130661065,
0.0116811953,
-0.0063794567,
0.0079020066,
-0.0290879197,
0.0107840365,
-0.0314525627,
0.0262215249,
0.0145700537,
0.0051464983,
-0.0685303509,
-0.0214724354,
-0.025796365,
0.036073979,
-0.0309806727,
0.0210444499,
-0.0276221465,
0.0109401876,
-0.0032744501,
0.0191800538,
0.0024693513,
-0.0179057531,
0.0226487014,
0.067474544,
0.0063554547,
-0.0178809576,
0.0123888161,
0.010920574,
-0.044630859,
-0.0593076572,
-0.0584109798,
-0.0720753819,
0.0293127317,
-0.0096426299,
-0.0178363472,
-0.1029622406,
0.0097545628,
0.0031273023,
-0.0524063036,
0.0744289532,
-0.0078013018,
0.0219150186,
-0.0116723757,
-0.0275148544,
-0.0249413345,
0.0505981706,
0.0499930717,
0.0403628498,
0.0353364907,
-0.006181194,
0.0074209305,
0.0693495274,
0.0312354788,
0.0334803984,
-0.0687002242,
0.0077450271,
0.0277996622,
0.0538129769,
0.0328554399,
0.0447435156,
-0.013966714,
-0.0189211052,
0.0631533414,
0.0028084354,
0.0013565554,
-0.0264561772,
0.0059524179,
0.042300377,
-0.0312804617,
0.0069434014,
-0.076305747,
-0.0020029589,
-0.0563560314,
0.0116763748,
0.0166026484,
0.0197151359,
-0.0181596391,
-0.0257473178,
-0.0221109986,
-0.0182451513,
0.0194200892,
0.0007180733,
0.0247524846,
0.0150719946,
-0.0585283674,
0.0199641455,
0.0623847432,
-0.0443902425,
-0.0044317273,
-0.016700875,
0.0592118949,
0.083658345,
0.0242712293,
-0.0389194004,
-0.0335161723,
-0.0191121493,
0.0070078969,
0.037408106,
0.0466605052,
-0.0235010013,
0.0133340238,
-0.0412703566,
-0.0416325592,
0.0362292416,
0.0070822346,
0.0059218197,
0.0193014741,
-0.0283934642,
-0.0212864541,
-0.0470102765,
-0.0357346982,
0.0414198339,
0.0158083551,
-0.0008508289,
0.0152441282,
0.0344727859,
0.0060714828,
-0.0110383686,
0.0023243201,
-0.0155551787,
0.028674569,
0.0113069452,
0.041093085,
-0.0092946375,
-0.0309848189,
-0.0456130393,
0.0674497932,
0.0073844297,
-0.0681025386,
0.0886754766,
-0.0447713546,
0.0032372384,
-0.0348169655,
-0.0122036505,
0.0118959649,
-0.0241166838,
0.0407435261,
-0.0084999548,
-0.0113213435,
-0.0717705116,
0.0561241135,
-0.023281306,
0.0108559104,
-0.0320710205,
-0.0120505765,
-0.0031756707,
-0.0530120023,
-0.0488461554,
0.0030614284,
-0.018511245,
0.0486933962,
0.0357400253,
0.054484006,
-0.0260239132,
-0.0404922999,
-0.0730257258,
0.0065745851,
-0.0185930338,
-0.0061950227,
-0.0022110946,
-0.0026999111,
-0.0219763797,
-0.0344898291,
-0.0233586058,
-0.0142640984,
-0.0177529752,
-0.0057908511,
0.0375046358,
0.0057322662,
-0.0451521836,
-0.0797264427,
-0.0019252505,
-0.0236557648,
-0.0049244785,
-0.0398993418,
0.0021499111,
-0.0326364525,
0.0310254768,
-0.0148835937,
0.0405184291,
0.0129213538,
-0.0382275134,
0.0205678288,
0.0040229904,
0.0085070701,
0.0867508128,
0.039582178,
0.0130021898,
0.0623743869,
0.035255421,
-0.094943881,
0.016571369,
-0.0649002269,
-0.0215827581,
-0.0386002734,
0.0060541579,
-0.0119763436,
0.0715562403,
0.0098588234,
0.0055647618,
-0.0805839598,
0.0118442457,
-0.0049885605,
-0.0286452975,
-0.0255025811,
-0.003770875,
-0.0486052893,
0.0033961185,
-0.0455569401,
-0.0807725489,
0.0998786315,
-0.025019085,
0.0192837529,
-0.0222868491,
0.0104040727,
0.0050636977,
0.0059449254,
0.0056555062,
0.0352304988,
-0.0103527661,
-0.0192168579,
-0.0496347956,
-0.0208101682,
0.0381864086,
-0.0335941724,
0.0487218127,
-0.0648144931,
0.0071529136,
-0.0099384142,
-0.0818966031,
-0.0484056771,
-0.0672602579,
0.0097571099,
-0.0239274018,
-0.0148580372,
-0.0354677923,
-0.0003426042,
-0.0232368,
-0.0077455854,
0.0102092456,
-0.0126404734,
0.0152620375,
-0.0235761479,
-0.0330770165,
0.0908734649,
0.025486419,
-0.0169505421,
-0.0145138772,
-0.0391508788,
0.0202922691,
0.0392076336,
0.041262392,
-0.0044941348,
0.0208012536,
0.0595639236,
-0.0045852992,
0.0078555718,
0.0474542156,
0.0482733995,
0.0113247959,
-0.0069374265,
0.0906101242,
0.0383267552,
-0.0586856119,
0.0303898603,
-0.0045559783,
0.084843643,
0.0178518295,
0.0206806045,
-0.0511608049,
-0.0359416045,
0.0086482121,
0.0620266944,
0.0168784466,
-0.0171008948,
0.012753454,
-0.1146830544,
0.005968302,
0.040451657,
-0.0609807372,
-0.0321000293,
-0.0061196242,
0.0303978436,
-0.0210142601,
0.062094748,
0.0148951476,
0.003339241,
-0.016398076,
0.0330490954,
-0.0039570862,
-0.0561830252,
0.0324900001,
-0.0548311844,
0.0540244505,
0.0845047683,
0.0346686281,
-0.0016342365,
-0.0413140208,
0.0233682748,
0.0429217629,
-0.0372612663,
-0.012535248,
0.0035239579,
-0.0289360136,
-0.0058593489,
0.0148134697,
0.0767227486,
-0.0299110133,
-0.0052727992,
-0.0185569394,
0.0539038181,
0.0006070538,
0.0274785589,
-0.0133303944,
-0.0025577333,
0.055744566,
0.0555573255,
0.0019475408,
-0.0882023945,
0.0095358798,
-0.0202497784,
-0.0325402915,
-0.0272411555,
-0.0390505604,
-0.0040870686,
0.0090377778,
-0.0184986647,
-0.0627740324,
-0.011095142,
0.0266976729,
0.0157356393,
0.0235008057,
-0.0156416968,
-0.0336049572,
0.0029400035,
-0.0312153865,
0.0328603238,
-0.0250456166,
0.0501845181,
-0.0823214799,
-0.0227712374,
0.0137178935,
-0.0093312813,
-0.0091451481,
0.0076937499,
-0.0303885881,
-0.1067210883,
0.0258383937,
0.0730761215,
0.0180158727,
0.0709603503,
-0.0341008306,
-0.0710770637,
-0.001139502,
0.0583942048,
-0.0229783542,
0.0106451688,
0.0464142673,
-0.0214017369,
-0.0025686326,
0.0510301441,
-0.0430811457,
0.0033487361,
0.0258866586,
0.0368157998,
-0.0260196757,
-0.0725571886,
0.0367489383,
0.0011637119,
0.0576994382,
-0.0461084321,
-0.0219838582,
-0.0391304567,
0.0089006517,
0.0165911075,
-0.049382437,
-0.0295538474,
-0.0147791114,
0.0356630534,
-0.0064580189,
-0.0181511678,
-0.036452692,
-0.0144744786,
0.0339812078,
-0.019371612,
0.0125927962,
0.0346990563,
0.0312462524,
0.0516126044,
0.0317047685,
-0.0181504395,
0.0306243226,
-0.0090549206,
0.0457311235,
-0.0041230922,
0.0466586798,
0.0300950184,
0.0210214779,
-0.0136025352,
0.0311507881,
0.0428517796,
-0.0593383573,
-0.07088691,
-0.031894844,
0.0201459825,
-0.0083106672,
0.0477368534,
-0.0216390043,
-0.0083920071,
-0.03770997,
0.041583173,
-0.0394929163,
-0.0407273062,
0.043269977,
0.0151116764,
-0.0242928658,
0.0059615569,
0.0541826561,
-0.0072585084,
0.021575639,
-0.0266045872,
0.0172602162,
-0.0308165848,
-0.0209242795,
0.0421425961,
0.0044361013,
-0.0454652756,
-0.0158989821,
-0.0497408658,
-0.0506098047,
-0.017823793,
0.0504959337,
-0.0061789518,
0.0036099893,
0.0361352824,
0.0322190374,
-0.0430693924,
0.0100981696,
-0.0472439937,
-0.0425963551,
0.0227493476,
-0.013913298,
-0.0399776325,
-6.415498457e-33,
-0.0353101566,
-0.006475348,
-0.0211915076,
-0.0020651165,
-0.0163900331,
-0.0734529346,
0.0151585294,
0.0462777019,
-0.0228588618,
0.0034838864,
-0.011368433,
-0.0216599777,
0.0057619666,
-0.0159367993,
0.002269363,
0.0059542581,
0.0243982859,
-0.0037748644,
-0.0663476065,
-0.0004667487,
0.0254288614,
-0.0041523674,
0.044058606,
-0.0961851701,
0.0273476746,
0.0137854312,
-0.0590225458,
0.044077456,
-0.048478432,
0.0727146417,
0.0004197753,
0.0422858223,
-0.0161780231,
0.0130690895,
-0.0070179165,
0.0083331326,
-0.0390752964,
-0.0181978084,
0.0060604229,
0.0007227195,
-0.0261203833,
-0.0285626519,
0.0455554835,
-0.0095051667,
-0.0447162986,
0.0100494968,
0.0255046152,
-0.0201163273,
-0.0302770082,
0.0231352057,
-0.0705550611,
0.0163099393,
0.0085723307,
-0.0509937815,
0.0041174353,
0.0185468085,
0.0165370312,
0.0038948492,
-0.0402402058,
0.0258544032,
0.0213396903,
0.018588461,
0.0563597679,
-0.0049129967,
-0.0049576387,
0.06176994,
0.001856291,
-0.0000422895,
0.0772207305,
-0.0084689874,
0.0412020423,
0.0592262968,
0.023408426,
0.0664938241,
0.0316059105,
-0.0512552969,
-0.0167667661,
0.0449187122,
-0.0080484804,
-0.0108627575,
0.016667936,
0.036803294,
-0.0650947094,
-0.0222789105,
-0.0357481204,
-0.0177490953,
-0.039966166,
-0.0391134843,
0.0212322101,
0.0232496932,
-0.0616910234,
-0.0145594981,
0.0110642463,
-0.041212745,
-0.0442416444,
-0.0068075969,
-0.0417927951,
0.0090006161,
0.003533236,
0.0075642965,
-0.0744700655,
-0.0522246473,
-0.0174451694,
-0.0318809636,
0.0224492699,
0.0218594782,
0.0519228168,
0.0459767766,
-0.0612427481,
0.0388201624,
-0.0042257132,
0.0009872743,
0.0062893159,
0.0047520106,
0.0560939759,
-0.0205167793,
0.0044912486,
0.0540142469,
0.0144031579,
-0.0386257246,
-0.0632544681,
0.0041148304,
-0.0221989993,
0.0263868235,
-0.0101288613,
-0.0162065495,
0.0020456347,
0.0146382796,
0.0240994319,
-0.0257064607,
0.0006186579,
-0.0073375311,
2.708e-7,
0.0363201499,
0.0397652872,
0.0210507866,
0.0163610168,
-0.0213016216,
0.0646996722,
-0.0172957759,
0.0388008319,
0.0223864354,
0.0107189389,
0.0264136884,
0.0035098768,
0.046715416,
-0.0081424825,
-0.0819966197,
0.0032996039,
-0.004847643,
0.0479286313,
-0.0351085588,
-0.0336804539,
0.0346310362,
0.097803995,
0.0368434079,
0.0079038423,
-0.0021147768,
0.0227072798,
0.0586452,
-0.0668643191,
0.0048743645,
0.0157504231,
-0.0077598863,
-0.0267415084,
-0.0210078526,
-0.0142319622,
0.0043079257,
0.0236103442,
-0.0082449894,
0.062975958,
-0.0348887779,
-0.0391637683,
-0.0120010534,
0.0070634247,
0.0017131447,
-0.0652280301,
0.0372652747,
-0.0572515614,
-0.0025894858,
0.0027086765,
0.042582918,
-0.0054290094,
0.0114781307,
-0.0384196527,
-0.0203243271,
0.0035780992,
0.0460526869,
0.0056912554,
-0.0347935036,
-0.0627350435,
-0.0434809215,
0.0244311728,
-0.0147694042,
-0.0350956842,
0.0179636572,
0.0478039123,
-0.0329746082,
-0.0572294705,
0.0216685776,
2.249626191e-34,
0.0191095546,
-0.0150695657,
0.0214330796,
-0.0097283125,
0.0409507453,
-0.0046095895,
0.0359392092,
0.0286684539,
0.0413420759,
-0.0200605728,
-0.011715278
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.02549v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.02549v1 | DemaFormer: Damped Exponential Moving Average Transformer with Energy-Based Modeling for Temporal Language Grounding | 2023-12-05T07:37:21 | 2023-12-05T07:37:21 | Thong Nguyen, Xiaobao Wu, Xinshuai Dong, Cong-Duy Nguyen, See-Kiong Ng, Luu Anh Tuan | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Temporal Language Grounding seeks to localize video moments that semantically
correspond to a natural language query. Recent advances employ the attention
mechanism to learn the relations between video moments and the text query.
However, naive attention might not be able to appropriately capture such
relations, resulting in ineffective distributions where target video moments
are difficult to separate from the remaining ones. To resolve the issue, we
propose an energy-based model framework to explicitly learn moment-query
distributions. Moreover, we propose DemaFormer, a novel Transformer-based
architecture that utilizes exponential moving average with a learnable damping
factor to effectively encode moment-query inputs. Comprehensive experiments on
four public temporal language grounding datasets showcase the superiority of
our methods over the state-of-the-art baselines. | [
-0.0090101864,
0.054728929,
0.0050235093,
0.0226990059,
0.0315358005,
-0.0237231907,
-0.0165364444,
-0.0000091316,
-0.0838964134,
-0.008665273,
-0.0077651399,
-0.0535042994,
-0.0034535641,
0.0254726615,
0.0186108444,
-0.0682630539,
0.0262261387,
-0.0021096498,
-0.0297320858,
0.0116379177,
0.0289812889,
-0.0293755569,
0.0051410617,
0.0450118147,
-0.06881392,
0.0105048232,
-0.0428343602,
0.0061156745,
0.0650340617,
-0.0220162347,
-0.0239873789,
0.052422829,
0.0524107106,
0.0596165285,
0.0000018637,
0.0241718926,
-0.0156954415,
-0.0269897394,
-0.0304737315,
-0.014997934,
0.003925507,
-0.0377418175,
-0.0216163471,
0.0094483597,
-0.0255143642,
-0.0296937693,
0.0772100687,
0.0171910822,
0.0590441078,
0.052287437,
-0.0305410493,
-0.0222983919,
0.0348761752,
-0.029251134,
0.0756478757,
0.006831645,
-0.0153533537,
0.0069002346,
0.0210410412,
0.0142064821,
-0.0764505714,
0.0539817438,
0.0329741091,
-0.0425872058,
0.0412849151,
0.0571170077,
-0.0520718843,
0.0018790542,
-0.0459191911,
0.0750219449,
0.0161783583,
-0.0098414458,
-0.0222402532,
0.0142552778,
-0.0232570879,
0.0102244392,
-0.0421967357,
0.0216294378,
0.0538184717,
0.0314983204,
-0.0342266932,
0.0665089116,
-0.0057133101,
0.0181716662,
-0.0166356377,
0.0582939386,
0.0295481924,
-0.0144964922,
-0.033559408,
0.0002042009,
0.021697199,
-0.015404827,
0.0462163873,
0.0210039653,
0.0700297281,
-0.0021014339,
-0.0414609164,
-0.0381969698,
-0.0425601453,
-0.024556566,
-0.0232720468,
0.054546196,
-0.0128363818,
0.0471689627,
-0.020100262,
0.0769613162,
-0.0391258001,
0.0029108552,
-0.0334746391,
0.0066183852,
-0.0019829404,
0.008999194,
-0.0484657884,
0.0077716568,
-0.0691286698,
-0.0190230105,
-0.0151655544,
0.0171014089,
-0.0054889568,
-0.0272459146,
-0.0351123847,
0.0451423638,
-0.0561544672,
-0.0402943715,
0.0109959329,
0.0372003242,
-0.0066958787,
0.0074188835,
0.0241384488,
-0.0856453702,
-0.060169287,
0.0367966443,
0.0157057978,
-0.0264186095,
0.0082164835,
0.0127129592,
-0.011744136,
-0.0301243309,
-0.0361633301,
0.0069689639,
-0.0070016049,
0.0352033302,
0.0172001943,
-0.0497931913,
0.0248048306,
0.0072318981,
-0.0006787635,
-0.032746926,
0.0333909281,
0.0071105538,
-0.0101998998,
0.095607847,
0.0356043726,
0.0027054281,
0.0349362306,
0.0012217805,
0.0142909354,
0.0642396063,
0.0587111712,
-0.0150334341,
0.0242153145,
0.0427504592,
0.0460053235,
0.0353445224,
0.0195198189,
0.0253634565,
-0.0953003764,
-0.0421493165,
-0.0101104975,
0.0155093605,
0.0436548442,
0.04500008,
-0.007980397,
-0.0216891933,
0.0705408454,
0.0187035929,
-0.0906355307,
-0.0167851467,
0.0032530122,
-0.0176680703,
-0.0303974487,
-0.0023139478,
-0.0275086034,
0.0982471779,
-0.0091789616,
-0.0205706116,
-0.0218791086,
0.0095798634,
-0.092701681,
-0.0148213077,
0.0271917358,
-0.0105283502,
0.024649946,
0.0184550788,
0.0344544016,
0.0118700154,
-0.0450354926,
0.1445598453,
-0.0101033133,
-0.0326972678,
0.0306257308,
-0.0223292839,
-0.0224422235,
0.0166055337,
0.0069568604,
-0.0182112139,
-0.0337985978,
-0.0443293154,
0.0568483323,
0.0512824915,
-0.0293427762,
0.0122502502,
0.005810542,
-0.0525283292,
-0.0297293812,
-0.0046643913,
0.0050268532,
-0.0014575609,
-0.0045423745,
0.0649830028,
0.036553137,
-0.0361086726,
0.0245650969,
0.0252326988,
0.0560995862,
-0.0167461261,
-0.0064148093,
0.0027830715,
0.0105125709,
-0.0085100252,
-0.0305920485,
0.0194239989,
0.0186971221,
-0.0554720908,
-0.0092526227,
0.0698734745,
-0.0658578277,
0.0015313029,
0.0366061479,
-0.0494600944,
0.0019671083,
0.031206375,
-0.0088168038,
-0.0515557751,
0.0415425189,
-0.0196057968,
0.0501856357,
-0.0434547402,
0.0257757306,
0.0158938952,
0.0599988587,
-0.0249007903,
0.0241365526,
-0.0411733091,
-0.0248345975,
-0.0052430411,
0.0288029835,
-0.0190862231,
-0.0395538323,
-0.0549809448,
0.0070519121,
0.0007419082,
-0.0125160273,
0.0282735061,
-0.0263934936,
-0.0377307162,
-0.0086973924,
-0.0570125133,
-0.0273537692,
-0.0509439223,
0.0062096328,
0.0208006669,
0.0465311073,
-0.0105692139,
0.0005664474,
-0.01495279,
-0.0274071302,
-0.0120101273,
-0.0013313992,
0.0229694732,
-0.000523663,
-0.0361717232,
-0.0067252377,
-0.0221149102,
0.0096559413,
0.0579438098,
-0.0067553907,
-0.0846890733,
0.002886944,
0.0173557922,
0.0093822554,
0.0113534015,
-0.008197288,
-0.0420637056,
-0.0169124417,
-0.0283326358,
0.0642141476,
0.0695365444,
0.0404778309,
0.024702644,
0.0067282668,
-0.0363231525,
-0.0359474123,
0.0356562026,
-0.023817597,
0.0192409493,
0.0115286307,
0.0279524364,
-0.0024165793,
0.0290885344,
-0.0151765198,
0.0283876359,
-0.0527756475,
-0.0162142217,
-0.0280613936,
-0.0063659265,
-0.0134296147,
0.0294169523,
-0.0553366877,
0.0089546805,
-0.0367982313,
-0.0669321716,
0.0559141859,
-0.0068828077,
-0.0475983247,
0.0295356587,
0.0059889685,
-0.0040244199,
0.0178704821,
-0.0055106673,
0.0165090114,
-0.0430906378,
-0.0535436757,
-0.0415778458,
-0.0305498894,
-0.006489811,
-0.0019920128,
0.0898405686,
-0.0069861775,
0.0236057304,
-0.004474137,
0.0155010689,
-0.0460514389,
-0.013733875,
-0.0395862162,
-0.0089765657,
-0.0310488995,
-0.0149084395,
-0.0771553889,
0.030013686,
0.037105605,
0.0425097384,
-0.0184767339,
-0.0096371472,
-0.0022794141,
0.031764105,
0.050502371,
0.0386027507,
0.0140677737,
-0.0354071856,
0.0466485284,
0.0618974902,
0.0984448269,
-0.0326972827,
-0.0632710084,
0.0303725246,
0.0364886075,
-0.0096365036,
0.0150395827,
0.0048798956,
0.0348344892,
-0.0480552688,
-0.0003748483,
0.0796782821,
0.0149598615,
-0.0463784784,
0.0128115639,
-0.002066415,
0.0034185173,
0.0157079864,
-0.0037608391,
-0.0811227188,
-0.0402747616,
0.0014413353,
0.0149831278,
0.03992109,
-0.012115689,
-0.0088941166,
-0.0625515431,
0.0231153313,
0.0127731096,
0.013851284,
-0.0521585308,
0.0003541416,
0.0179639328,
-0.0072876355,
0.0197904501,
-0.0009792314,
0.0236115567,
-0.0098728742,
0.0354178138,
0.0181531757,
-0.0677894503,
-0.0064677652,
-0.0421082079,
0.0364581011,
0.0311395172,
0.0209551174,
-0.0389961377,
-0.0905282199,
-0.008227285,
-0.0404141657,
-0.0144692147,
-0.0014059835,
-0.0047414019,
-0.0143434675,
-0.0323950909,
0.0074574491,
0.0506151132,
-0.0029629075,
-0.0343638696,
-0.0442510284,
0.1181315109,
-0.0720433071,
0.0411317162,
-0.0206751339,
0.0146428607,
0.0249599125,
0.0480369292,
-0.0040218532,
-0.0207461249,
-0.0098794159,
-0.0170740392,
0.0282230861,
-0.0615085177,
-0.0456413217,
-0.0242047329,
0.0453898981,
-0.0123174386,
-0.0184925664,
-0.0015705891,
0.0092136962,
0.0479528718,
-0.0009521003,
-0.0619042404,
0.0223608427,
0.0270210654,
-0.0453707986,
0.0467789322,
-0.0106551833,
0.0218270738,
-0.0768902525,
-0.0024494505,
0.0693144873,
0.0148659516,
0.0043006451,
-0.0011440152,
-0.0591308437,
-0.076787129,
-0.0179372393,
0.0277558379,
0.0225290302,
0.0581840836,
0.0086708991,
0.0311553683,
0.0305357073,
0.038516961,
-0.0445981622,
0.0061090188,
0.033849258,
-0.0427603573,
-0.009603519,
0.034281306,
-0.0468648449,
0.0305306688,
-0.0015136014,
0.0630691946,
-0.0499794967,
-0.0084348582,
0.0256571434,
-0.0227748323,
0.0589243695,
-0.0079483557,
0.0235713236,
-0.0301867351,
0.0140248835,
0.0031474871,
0.0387622267,
-0.0798910707,
-0.0000629755,
0.0267751869,
0.0029524385,
-0.0139308684,
0.0266689807,
-0.0113252653,
-0.0574447252,
-0.0103472341,
0.0544592403,
-0.0533489138,
-0.0239374302,
-0.0087946588,
0.0174676552,
0.0322077386,
0.0051885853,
0.031938009,
0.0125138024,
0.0002720969,
0.042243965,
0.0281478968,
0.0144085549,
-0.0452489741,
0.0042086281,
-0.0387334004,
0.0270970538,
0.0060030837,
-0.0200256035,
0.0213694721,
-0.0545945205,
0.0203574095,
0.0193805136,
-0.0115822302,
-0.0018315165,
0.0245215334,
0.0004941075,
-0.0171631537,
0.0477720909,
0.0148788532,
0.010956808,
0.0368468277,
0.0542527698,
-0.0773484185,
0.0397733934,
0.0367390215,
0.0018234033,
-0.0084657976,
0.0009568254,
-0.0392011367,
-0.0878763795,
-0.019716274,
0.0094973613,
-0.0440832451,
-0.0334472656,
0.0137551473,
-0.0458795801,
-0.0244682748,
-0.0045103375,
0.0652576014,
0.0167501383,
0.0152902724,
0.0006301561,
0.0071647582,
-0.010319218,
0.0064129191,
-0.0154434722,
-0.0529697053,
-6.05342783e-33,
-0.0256337058,
0.0071557914,
-0.0125059746,
0.040255893,
-0.0344730616,
0.0663787723,
-0.0317515545,
-0.0016145796,
-0.0224107392,
0.0109800752,
-0.0190435555,
0.037355002,
0.0295807272,
0.0206294116,
0.0188788921,
-0.0386992581,
0.0345670916,
-0.0432106294,
-0.0119625432,
0.0282605048,
0.0302693415,
0.0421241075,
0.0757167116,
-0.0431641378,
-0.0457033217,
0.0560339279,
-0.017041713,
0.0159301013,
0.0462622643,
0.050841745,
0.004180715,
0.0310142562,
-0.0241795909,
-0.0742962658,
-0.0345866568,
0.0014999469,
-0.0890716687,
-0.0094443141,
-0.0346786529,
0.0481773317,
0.0271026548,
-0.0115572419,
0.0385631919,
-0.0017269562,
-0.0316181928,
-0.0030695586,
0.0139663145,
-0.041068621,
-0.014876687,
-0.0647893026,
0.0069397842,
0.031311091,
-0.0209312234,
-0.0138830869,
0.0423741154,
0.0064074104,
0.0288072228,
0.0150440345,
-0.0674032569,
0.014588845,
-0.0154264355,
0.0374273695,
0.0802556723,
0.0093798125,
0.0277392156,
0.0517959036,
-0.021458542,
-0.0345167592,
-0.0166158043,
0.02228464,
0.0627233312,
0.003309184,
0.0280953236,
-0.0557546355,
0.0084570702,
-0.0335717872,
-0.0041340161,
0.0164535847,
-0.0063957665,
0.0976621881,
0.0042370409,
0.0208568368,
0.0129337264,
-0.0092816437,
0.0052660806,
0.0169573277,
-0.0209751539,
-0.0098769767,
0.0090135261,
0.0316072255,
-0.0139841363,
0.0026814076,
0.082873702,
-0.0170259122,
0.0413779579,
0.0519227087,
0.0101990197,
0.030754555,
0.0297003631,
-0.0151994126,
-0.030410856,
-0.0088707488,
0.0267092157,
-0.0177640636,
-0.0198749416,
-0.0185723417,
-0.0370430537,
0.0992401391,
-0.0356907845,
-0.0367315039,
-0.0163363013,
0.0193663761,
0.0286908094,
0.0146983294,
0.0323694311,
-0.0088140666,
-0.010972918,
0.0034670096,
-0.0204824973,
0.0293305349,
-0.0040587503,
-0.0140841044,
-0.0117872339,
0.0656768531,
-0.0509628057,
0.0037703754,
-0.0321111754,
-0.0011859565,
0.0266535711,
-0.0919225886,
-0.0437036306,
0.0082790153,
2.748e-7,
0.0023295705,
0.0177920628,
0.0540662259,
-0.0068460782,
-0.0056266142,
0.0122105712,
-0.0229937173,
-0.0012274176,
0.0141243814,
-0.0572356842,
0.0242729206,
0.0169082247,
0.0324815847,
-0.0022955439,
-0.0660891831,
-0.020423701,
-0.041440066,
0.0128344866,
0.0063017071,
-0.0567347147,
-0.0016991502,
0.1206195578,
0.0128281666,
0.0279015061,
0.0000209531,
-0.0697972029,
0.0610521957,
-0.0079231039,
0.0076452699,
0.0108825415,
0.0493513756,
-0.0149496719,
-0.0370290093,
-0.0071739526,
-0.0379173346,
0.0135312956,
0.0138604967,
0.0107409144,
-0.0174549427,
-0.0633604676,
-0.0167495199,
0.0266475193,
-0.0402560607,
-0.0090387044,
0.0501289181,
-0.0403531864,
-0.0003508118,
-0.0008060726,
-0.0510037951,
0.035630554,
0.0102587342,
0.0049902629,
-0.0272038784,
-0.0015566435,
0.0291318055,
-0.0181165468,
-0.0258105416,
-0.0771357492,
-0.0088102883,
0.0013352941,
-0.0460276455,
0.0115223173,
-0.0459991507,
-0.062009614,
-0.0072856904,
0.0540160611,
-0.0706229582,
2.437908014e-34,
0.028021967,
-0.0143664554,
-0.0173637066,
0.0198364593,
-0.0274228454,
0.0059194164,
0.018462006,
-0.0100638745,
0.0017051531,
-0.0497768931,
-0.0451109596
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03022v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03022v2 | Beyond Isolation: Multi-Agent Synergy for Improving Knowledge Graph Construction | 2023-12-05T07:27:08 | 2023-12-29T07:34:30 | Hongbin Ye, Honghao Gui, Aijia Zhang, Tong Liu, Wei Hua, Weiqiang Jia | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Knowledge graph construction (KGC) is a multifaceted undertaking involving
the extraction of entities, relations, and events. Traditionally, large
language models (LLMs) have been viewed as solitary task-solving agents in this
complex landscape. However, this paper challenges this paradigm by introducing
a novel framework, CooperKGC. Departing from the conventional approach,
CooperKGC establishes a collaborative processing network, assembling a KGC
collaboration team capable of concurrently addressing entity, relation, and
event extraction tasks. Our experiments unequivocally demonstrate that
fostering collaboration and information interaction among diverse agents within
CooperKGC yields superior results compared to individual cognitive processes
operating in isolation. Importantly, our findings reveal that the collaboration
facilitated by CooperKGC enhances knowledge selection, correction, and
aggregation capabilities across multiple rounds of interactions. | [
0.0632622987,
-0.0134336846,
-0.0405038446,
0.0529216826,
-0.0519674346,
0.0045066774,
0.0248419959,
-0.0056995489,
0.056095697,
-0.0045583304,
0.0023621318,
-0.0046257484,
-0.0125834858,
0.0064124409,
-0.0022102755,
-0.0223385096,
0.0395900533,
0.0111433249,
0.0446133427,
-0.0109473476,
-0.0117825065,
0.0235679392,
-0.0376624316,
0.0063160849,
-0.0226106085,
0.0020498715,
-0.0000094034,
-0.0432507992,
0.0317669474,
-0.019441925,
-0.0379444212,
0.0169505142,
-0.0005235727,
0.0075106989,
0.0000019134,
-0.0637451112,
0.0006921691,
-0.0300092082,
-0.0394932516,
-0.0176738054,
-0.0207049996,
-0.0003841065,
0.0349153653,
-0.0368495435,
-0.0731033832,
-0.022853205,
0.0041217916,
0.0281426515,
-0.0028487188,
0.0363473892,
-0.0162169766,
0.0026184879,
-0.0123614883,
-0.0151820658,
-0.0419798568,
-0.0418003611,
0.037618801,
0.0209958348,
0.0217323005,
-0.0204960704,
-0.0050422908,
0.0411636643,
0.0136633851,
-0.0353791565,
0.0657129511,
0.0658905059,
-0.0229342338,
-0.0261547174,
0.0167967658,
0.096676752,
0.0432777926,
0.0291490071,
-0.004847466,
0.0164409131,
0.0214415863,
0.0608137697,
-0.0472779945,
-0.0189224593,
-0.0377936214,
0.0070291613,
-0.0104279621,
-0.0432631597,
0.0336769037,
0.0017493645,
-0.0102292253,
0.0917438343,
-0.0189572256,
-0.0125888204,
-0.007873985,
0.0300168581,
-0.0314067416,
-0.0600900501,
0.0173403416,
0.0387528203,
-0.0230281241,
0.028651325,
0.022297075,
-0.0037675945,
-0.0020296643,
-0.0310300216,
-0.016194215,
-0.0090173939,
0.0447095484,
0.079063572,
-0.0460711196,
-0.0136585487,
-0.0053962176,
0.0212719981,
0.0003404022,
-0.0285153538,
-0.1159471646,
0.000346621,
-0.0072873137,
0.0771487057,
-0.0288403723,
-0.0565332174,
0.0142840128,
0.0473735221,
-0.0023355326,
0.0157573167,
0.0170198865,
0.0430683605,
0.0211142525,
-0.0319048315,
-0.0449133553,
0.0269119404,
-0.0245412774,
0.0212151799,
-0.0030314475,
-0.029536305,
-0.0220213793,
-0.0122604687,
0.0349866413,
-0.0323005095,
-0.0260891281,
0.0632265285,
-0.0223744605,
-0.0193639528,
-0.0219892152,
-0.0431936458,
0.002887253,
-0.0521536656,
-0.002459632,
-0.0357951187,
0.0672127604,
0.0470242649,
-0.0245753601,
-0.0496364385,
0.041063901,
-0.0604476556,
-0.0641505718,
0.0365305841,
-0.0482238755,
0.0386079326,
0.0335189886,
0.0184720121,
-0.0277856681,
0.0553654172,
0.0414677486,
0.0326385088,
0.063858375,
0.034749452,
-0.0379744619,
0.0253674686,
0.0124742119,
-0.0078363419,
0.0443385467,
-0.0048251753,
-0.0115079554,
0.0367030688,
0.0156018361,
0.0361699723,
-0.0503979623,
0.0085297944,
0.0849208012,
0.0411844254,
0.012444823,
0.0146325333,
0.0027068481,
0.0132891797,
-0.0045207553,
0.0015455254,
-0.0222608279,
0.0388985276,
0.0083774542,
0.0176708382,
-0.0251212344,
0.0438646451,
-0.0244635716,
0.0022230861,
-0.0026940287,
0.0081163216,
0.0487731211,
0.0093438346,
0.0645840019,
0.0145526538,
-0.0155279813,
0.0356829353,
0.0378168933,
-0.0342822373,
0.0069229282,
-0.0169798899,
0.0225468874,
0.0698269978,
0.0683478713,
0.0100009693,
-0.0310831033,
0.0253541786,
-0.0229721107,
0.0193398893,
0.0578949042,
-0.0412685685,
-0.0015197929,
-0.0535546653,
-0.0519318469,
0.0202061478,
-0.0256091785,
0.0143965995,
0.0685974509,
0.0011011898,
-0.0021960475,
0.0128138373,
0.0130342394,
0.0044649038,
-0.0304628927,
0.0087177139,
-0.0447990224,
0.0196183287,
0.0233339146,
0.0321911015,
-0.0148006482,
-0.0044121025,
0.0280433912,
-0.0415796191,
-0.0587562472,
0.0561145693,
-0.0102890553,
-0.0695130527,
0.0158181787,
0.0062987013,
-0.0013188928,
-0.0271062441,
0.0193537045,
-0.0360907316,
0.05131834,
0.0201817807,
0.0850065947,
-0.0008748649,
-0.00703562,
-0.0148534896,
-0.0107165035,
-0.0095601212,
0.0913837552,
0.021728728,
-0.0432844386,
-0.002695367,
0.0151696056,
-0.0434276722,
-0.0077513899,
0.0274485704,
0.0386053436,
0.0609531142,
-0.0118760495,
0.0199021902,
-0.0613362491,
-0.0655479059,
-0.0185604971,
-0.1138417497,
0.0086787846,
0.0075846873,
0.0183568187,
0.0046817143,
-0.0011392873,
-0.0083241882,
0.0089971079,
0.0044208062,
0.0758229196,
-0.0060095824,
0.0357471332,
-0.0049071452,
0.0440189317,
-0.027863238,
-0.0416444056,
-0.0158050545,
-0.0154756019,
0.0553920157,
0.0554013252,
-0.0775429234,
-0.0135390004,
0.0523174778,
-0.062735647,
0.0022384736,
-0.0217668433,
0.0114264777,
0.0175113305,
-0.0365150124,
0.0012618772,
0.0099267233,
-0.0353082009,
0.0262327231,
-0.0016370565,
-0.0499717332,
-0.0603484735,
0.0211767405,
-0.042814143,
0.0438088067,
-0.0472045131,
0.0223028809,
-0.0075445417,
0.0230458677,
0.0175606031,
-0.0091112219,
-0.0106587186,
-0.0164669491,
0.0111042373,
-0.0277273487,
-0.0181641188,
-0.0697119907,
0.0058582434,
-0.0019580645,
-0.0658795163,
0.0185369141,
0.0787351951,
0.0251294319,
-0.0135439346,
-0.0135785416,
0.0035855777,
-0.0357446782,
0.1136180833,
0.0063001374,
0.0070328685,
-0.03010647,
-0.0156187173,
-0.0427868329,
-0.0041618114,
0.0169310085,
-0.0075931638,
0.0477061681,
-0.0754446387,
0.0295296293,
0.019926494,
0.0008941298,
-0.0303791445,
0.0110775288,
-0.0316816755,
0.0199006908,
0.0583663397,
0.0068035321,
-0.0168778487,
0.0159898847,
0.0321604423,
-0.0095287701,
0.0019838691,
-0.0013590067,
-0.0277352519,
0.0375441983,
0.0102857323,
0.0114190849,
0.0333208665,
-0.0386948287,
0.0540266149,
0.0784557164,
0.0625479147,
-0.0391430035,
0.0313059576,
-0.04119277,
-0.0094817514,
-0.0529982969,
-0.0145110972,
-0.0431559756,
0.0454487577,
-0.039399188,
0.0080534043,
0.0739122257,
0.0252741538,
-0.075821273,
-0.0205643345,
0.005981741,
-0.0059292926,
0.0224720109,
-0.0165109262,
-0.0351522043,
0.0103619499,
-0.0009243487,
-0.028957352,
0.0209528375,
-0.0938787758,
-0.0098906085,
-0.0895587578,
0.0175694115,
0.0233430862,
-0.0018637249,
0.0105267297,
-0.0430476181,
0.0534448773,
0.0002673691,
-0.0170134809,
0.0245240964,
0.0010143954,
-0.0131337643,
0.0071029924,
-0.0020661622,
-0.029288616,
0.0057096621,
-0.0440511554,
0.068382524,
0.0122086639,
-0.0022342086,
0.0040722862,
0.0238831937,
-0.0083847633,
-0.0014833355,
0.0380459391,
-0.0178478975,
0.0468525812,
-0.0014481784,
0.0107979607,
-0.0169411376,
-0.0192294326,
-0.0567158386,
-0.0010243878,
0.0137262922,
0.0693785697,
0.0023372266,
-0.0402137674,
0.0448641032,
0.0004315118,
0.0078529855,
0.0634201989,
0.0137892496,
-0.0067016399,
-0.0165550578,
0.0180985462,
-0.0091357119,
-0.0622387715,
-0.0146483872,
0.0191134624,
-0.0166362934,
0.0186131857,
-0.0389314033,
-0.074213855,
0.089213796,
-0.0104676457,
0.0192894246,
0.0433027372,
0.0346396938,
-0.0099679837,
-0.0148563469,
-0.0036941525,
-0.0197245888,
-0.0154408813,
0.0299284048,
-0.035228081,
-0.0312750563,
-0.0172958709,
0.0148303816,
0.0110956058,
-0.0586462989,
-0.0781800821,
0.015774684,
-0.0106328735,
0.0169129726,
0.0280828793,
0.0150068616,
-0.0244954079,
-0.0089167915,
0.0166939031,
-0.0898036659,
0.0152661372,
-0.0628387406,
-0.0505054407,
0.0055021844,
0.0403215066,
-0.0237758774,
0.0181187578,
0.0088920724,
0.0671242252,
-0.1135498881,
-0.0695030689,
-0.0083111348,
0.0042869775,
-0.0111074829,
-0.0001041401,
0.0199823622,
-0.0736273229,
-0.0090059247,
0.0015586334,
0.0186282806,
-0.002453143,
-0.0264456458,
-0.0143824518,
-0.0090393256,
0.0545346141,
0.0098672817,
0.021673603,
0.0207509212,
-0.0087969918,
-0.0254925843,
-0.0188828688,
-0.0183800906,
0.045645766,
0.0133387549,
-0.0044045448,
0.0392028429,
0.0016454377,
-0.0128453858,
-0.01603771,
0.0376480967,
0.0053397026,
-0.0670988709,
-0.0190696549,
-0.017189404,
-0.0651697144,
-0.0218613464,
0.0270256717,
0.0658662543,
0.0746483579,
0.0245690029,
0.0698541999,
-0.0428354628,
-0.0027135059,
-0.0045700832,
-0.0019381836,
-0.0190962609,
-0.0037100883,
-0.016516583,
0.0248278398,
-0.0219357423,
-0.0060627908,
0.0488926843,
-0.0319256373,
0.0348364525,
-0.0015970138,
-0.0282158293,
-0.034856461,
-0.0410200134,
-0.0092905955,
0.0370179377,
-0.02204239,
0.0359155573,
-0.0468073115,
-0.0227560662,
0.0094022388,
0.0013015716,
-0.0152472341,
-0.0248229746,
0.0073666694,
0.0515913107,
0.0328061841,
-0.0707233101,
-0.050587438,
0.0365057848,
-0.0261733476,
0.0260851458,
0.0000131433,
-6.220233417e-33,
-0.0355968773,
-0.0401627235,
0.0440461785,
0.0519872829,
-0.0219696239,
0.0033936149,
-0.0478025563,
0.0108270589,
-0.0268787351,
0.0325119831,
-0.0091545759,
0.0278273802,
0.0107261129,
-0.0164418966,
0.0242999084,
0.0190915316,
0.0330963023,
-0.001599604,
0.0365945846,
0.0198529083,
0.0536889881,
0.0332864113,
0.0296254344,
-0.0929429308,
0.0159738585,
-0.0072518685,
0.038070973,
0.0061807572,
0.0339848921,
0.0490100719,
-0.0002809603,
0.0406133085,
0.0441096164,
-0.0331249945,
-0.009406562,
-0.0084118629,
-0.0890453979,
-0.0307430997,
0.0407075174,
-0.0058554397,
-0.0190115571,
-0.0388212092,
0.013671848,
0.0033319937,
0.026631169,
-0.0332047418,
0.0355534703,
-0.0106774382,
-0.051700633,
0.0008684691,
-0.0399091728,
0.017796671,
0.0180147327,
0.0253951289,
0.0304492842,
-0.0608958192,
0.0018304113,
-0.0465910099,
-0.098197937,
0.0143257705,
-0.0354021676,
-0.0111620827,
0.0235289745,
0.0375026725,
0.0228709094,
0.0597082712,
0.0301557388,
0.0423064195,
-0.0555424131,
-0.005045916,
-0.021491548,
0.07907819,
-0.031604223,
0.0463055819,
-0.0735621005,
-0.0585855097,
-0.0568071716,
-0.0134119019,
0.0395642072,
0.0047936365,
0.0075158235,
0.0182442032,
-0.0219503362,
-0.0186260026,
-0.0029543776,
0.044102028,
-0.0117004169,
-0.0466551743,
-0.0110423686,
0.0026068948,
-0.0066524642,
0.0359778777,
0.00458478,
-0.0346387327,
0.0060187122,
0.0491538234,
0.003224191,
0.0231513847,
-0.0046865973,
-0.0215338077,
-0.1167219803,
-0.0252438597,
-0.026636932,
0.009873203,
-0.0009566564,
0.039644219,
0.0054951473,
-0.0102675911,
0.0003829347,
-0.0073407292,
-0.0389171019,
0.0224733073,
0.0150101129,
-0.0501055717,
0.0178654958,
0.0222417079,
-0.0096085761,
-0.0295135174,
0.0647401586,
0.0276443195,
-0.0175524335,
0.0302368198,
-0.0088809757,
-0.0044425614,
0.0081815552,
-0.0149886785,
-0.0448672771,
-0.0022918959,
0.0261302348,
-0.0203701463,
-0.0227046888,
0.0004729764,
2.817e-7,
0.0187028404,
0.0451109596,
0.0093076527,
0.0173077211,
0.0404333696,
0.0101450682,
-0.0084143132,
0.010582665,
0.0221043713,
-0.0399760418,
0.0362820774,
0.0764780119,
-0.0196419246,
0.0744732544,
-0.0707428232,
-0.0516071059,
-0.0178151149,
-0.0380900353,
-0.0449932329,
-0.0176290702,
0.0104973055,
-0.0149340024,
0.0768394396,
0.0115471492,
-0.0470927358,
-0.0958968922,
0.0576994494,
-0.0105427867,
-0.0254762135,
0.064851962,
0.0075674248,
-0.029713789,
-0.0395382233,
0.0924010351,
0.0336991884,
0.0344994068,
-0.0192177072,
0.0284841545,
-0.0313411206,
-0.0006814917,
0.0098352786,
-0.0350068621,
0.0166368764,
-0.0288963839,
0.0534370989,
-0.0620875023,
0.007704217,
0.0421864353,
-0.0040923776,
-0.0071614445,
-0.0304809958,
0.0146978991,
0.0139199793,
0.027189929,
-0.0084903762,
0.0033147552,
-0.0323898382,
-0.0684512407,
0.0138249435,
0.0353495814,
-0.0637537315,
-0.0749415904,
0.0190213211,
-0.0542620569,
-0.0063643535,
-0.0204619691,
0.0331147648,
1.992620652e-34,
-0.013900822,
0.0428492017,
-0.02306889,
0.033594396,
0.0477673784,
-0.0589936599,
-0.0666322559,
-0.0120277926,
-0.0020073236,
-0.0933411047,
-0.0104307197
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.02532v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.02532v1 | DRAFT: Dense Retrieval Augmented Few-shot Topic classifier Framework | 2023-12-05T06:28:45 | 2023-12-05T06:28:45 | Keonwoo Kim, Younggun Lee | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | With the growing volume of diverse information, the demand for classifying
arbitrary topics has become increasingly critical. To address this challenge,
we introduce DRAFT, a simple framework designed to train a classifier for
few-shot topic classification. DRAFT uses a few examples of a specific topic as
queries to construct Customized dataset with a dense retriever model.
Multi-query retrieval (MQR) algorithm, which effectively handles multiple
queries related to a specific topic, is applied to construct the Customized
dataset. Subsequently, we fine-tune a classifier using the Customized dataset
to identify the topic. To demonstrate the efficacy of our proposed approach, we
conduct evaluations on both widely used classification benchmark datasets and
manually constructed datasets with 291 diverse topics, which simulate diverse
contents encountered in real-world applications. DRAFT shows competitive or
superior performance compared to baselines that use in-context learning, such
as GPT-3 175B and InstructGPT 175B, on few-shot topic classification tasks
despite having 177 times fewer parameters, demonstrating its effectiveness. | [
-0.0046364879,
0.0301400553,
-0.0066301669,
-0.013817803,
-0.0024464978,
0.0201830361,
0.0257619899,
0.0419842489,
-0.0401745476,
-0.0533722751,
-0.0072944476,
-0.0128240902,
-0.0468455888,
0.0063576452,
-0.009964101,
-0.0464129969,
0.0482579507,
0.0316095799,
0.0235021003,
0.0416009426,
-0.005861077,
0.0443583131,
0.0100964587,
0.0219798945,
0.0402483605,
0.0006643485,
-0.0300164856,
0.0324281566,
-0.0190856867,
-0.0302612148,
0.0501082614,
0.0556720272,
0.0653406307,
0.029231688,
0.0000018996,
-0.0361462533,
-0.0408997349,
-0.0108599924,
-0.0317281671,
-0.001072531,
0.0541590117,
-0.034374658,
0.0654334798,
-0.0109810419,
-0.0125657553,
-0.0055876207,
0.0096162455,
0.0848168805,
0.0075146169,
0.0440441146,
-0.0347114466,
-0.0252052881,
0.0244128183,
-0.015425642,
0.0787978396,
-0.0770261064,
0.0202731993,
-0.029779708,
0.0158483889,
0.0472503193,
0.0033393174,
-0.0140797468,
-0.0102346539,
0.0430365764,
0.0532240458,
0.0297631472,
-0.0658249706,
-0.0108735096,
0.0069706067,
0.0599843115,
0.0002648973,
-0.0397416167,
0.0304309353,
-0.0193985719,
-0.0181292649,
-0.0237459764,
-0.0578441098,
-0.0308585502,
0.0022697079,
0.0087074088,
-0.0272471812,
0.0018873193,
-0.0079973023,
0.0284250118,
0.0101809315,
-0.0407861918,
0.0028650872,
-0.027043527,
-0.0166324507,
0.0218870733,
-0.0037728441,
-0.01593039,
-0.024941178,
0.0199288502,
-0.023954846,
-0.0090120928,
0.0003810737,
-0.0422364511,
0.0635871813,
-0.0197179783,
0.020510802,
0.0139002465,
-0.0257526524,
0.0659555122,
0.0534573309,
-0.0197597202,
0.005077946,
-0.0058685066,
-0.0104159089,
0.0137827052,
-0.0867143273,
-0.0168790743,
-0.0436049402,
0.0751493946,
0.0115382727,
0.00331893,
-0.0157376584,
0.0300330855,
0.011029046,
-0.0305117443,
-0.0265824888,
0.0296847597,
-0.051280126,
-0.0159335211,
-0.0041161054,
0.0315030552,
-0.028506631,
0.0600501858,
-0.0004655716,
-0.0118217831,
-0.0100473091,
-0.0004674464,
0.0141077135,
-0.035338372,
0.0217599608,
0.0107568875,
-0.0363709889,
-0.0886855796,
-0.0375105888,
-0.0237736665,
0.0265103206,
-0.0081963353,
-0.0008653282,
-0.0396743715,
0.0208508372,
-0.0174560603,
-0.0148082534,
0.0158292055,
-0.0126912864,
0.0506555289,
-0.0092971781,
0.0370423645,
-0.0205586683,
-0.0206604935,
0.0916803405,
0.0297772642,
0.04139442,
0.1049095243,
-0.0529467314,
0.0511591062,
0.0433791019,
0.0160835553,
0.0206594355,
-0.0510114878,
0.0046725492,
0.0019152893,
-0.0112994211,
0.0453607403,
-0.0481001846,
-0.0165531673,
-0.0195228066,
-0.0249577574,
-0.0486217849,
-0.0024157809,
-0.031383764,
0.0576268919,
0.0556487963,
-0.0164191239,
-0.0185977053,
0.077553384,
-0.0187261757,
-0.060391739,
0.012675073,
0.0521388948,
-0.0135370195,
-0.0317369252,
0.0245533586,
0.0034069652,
-0.0627296865,
-0.009028906,
0.0124460747,
0.0116870636,
-0.0673236325,
0.0171708986,
0.0848012641,
-0.0002536857,
-0.0117230238,
0.0281310678,
0.0220497865,
0.0117713688,
-0.015270316,
-0.0128437374,
0.0333794057,
0.0123695154,
0.0272467565,
-0.0564592667,
-0.0303614214,
-0.0252112318,
0.0604940206,
-0.0143261384,
0.0525758862,
-0.0089275567,
0.0326069631,
-0.0378216244,
-0.0288543347,
-0.0436438322,
0.0472670086,
0.0037054464,
0.0073035746,
0.0302898604,
0.0230321269,
-0.0449764505,
0.0670789853,
0.0232852455,
0.0176929403,
-0.0447300561,
0.0632720217,
-0.0216051377,
0.0392569415,
0.0227555372,
-0.0164038446,
-0.0173727106,
0.0242926255,
-0.0073930696,
-0.0298803393,
-0.0419863723,
0.0014568529,
-0.0251288172,
-0.0077329846,
0.0251750052,
0.0204929709,
-0.0443408266,
-0.0490638129,
-0.0208936874,
0.0037009483,
0.0062981402,
-0.0392374173,
-0.051060643,
-0.0390553176,
-0.0154362665,
0.0019131004,
-0.0578966327,
0.0451792702,
0.0510734357,
0.0288057998,
0.0131476372,
-0.0289807208,
0.0446713865,
-0.0208162591,
0.0018019777,
-0.0067916112,
-0.071008563,
0.041767545,
0.0384388193,
0.0170627106,
-0.0211966597,
0.005419272,
-0.0664636716,
0.0236101821,
-0.0123208584,
-0.0223489571,
0.0030373877,
0.0034845793,
-0.0158230066,
-0.0199251752,
-0.0012732121,
-0.0137624824,
-0.0208365247,
0.0281479917,
0.0224249307,
0.0169825926,
0.0479158424,
-0.0031526415,
-0.0180674754,
-0.0109920902,
0.0443992168,
-0.0233365018,
0.0016510923,
0.0159974303,
0.0067828177,
-0.0115625057,
-0.0400915258,
-0.0190448333,
0.0106426273,
0.0149556892,
-0.0694281459,
-0.012147963,
0.0289756097,
0.0144511536,
0.0400038846,
0.0170514975,
-0.0112418588,
-0.0656441823,
0.0314075202,
-0.0290481541,
0.0295127276,
0.0276915058,
0.0066924347,
0.012507787,
0.0063339006,
-0.0019508385,
0.0378580578,
-0.0595400892,
0.0377073362,
0.023638254,
-0.0027421538,
-0.0993045792,
0.0700951219,
0.0318259485,
0.0206454843,
-0.0257085338,
-0.0147894938,
0.0726372004,
0.0497174188,
0.002112543,
-0.0115629192,
-0.0205859523,
-0.0516733564,
0.0483728573,
-0.0553460233,
-0.0159656499,
0.0084849922,
0.0077118627,
-0.0333273746,
-0.0117146326,
0.0028369657,
-0.0359274149,
0.0270359498,
-0.015642222,
0.0207133237,
-0.033065524,
-0.0518754348,
-0.0010948619,
-0.0394535847,
0.0047186762,
0.0254154932,
-0.0543854423,
0.0135979075,
-0.0329450779,
-0.0038024904,
0.0205523632,
0.0222057477,
-0.0216581803,
-0.0471712239,
0.0222867243,
0.028589908,
0.0510823131,
-0.0409554988,
-0.0883068368,
0.0122787589,
0.0521959513,
0.0453351848,
0.0328652896,
-0.0056623477,
-0.0127464738,
0.0494019017,
0.0383642316,
-0.0282597374,
0.002948812,
0.003022365,
0.0414170399,
-0.0361264125,
-0.0259810761,
0.0590323433,
0.032209605,
-0.0608109385,
-0.0519847348,
-0.0120443897,
0.0080996696,
0.0324561931,
0.033286266,
-0.0808420256,
-0.0257047303,
-0.009490354,
0.0557989664,
-0.0007751918,
-0.0157418884,
-0.0036917578,
-0.0791718289,
0.0430093482,
-0.0137957335,
0.0045081344,
0.0028913058,
-0.0911558196,
-0.0127725611,
-0.0210965592,
-0.0421638303,
0.0060235201,
-0.0152328173,
-0.0212360378,
0.0002292025,
0.0162442438,
-0.0518104322,
0.0407428741,
0.022415759,
-0.0236577857,
-0.0212958846,
0.001932136,
-0.0036308519,
0.0491638966,
-0.0199621748,
-0.0468712598,
-0.0049886205,
-0.0091026304,
0.0671133846,
-0.0213430654,
0.0022708825,
0.0011568535,
-0.0177949592,
-0.0367967375,
-0.0556621104,
0.0077301888,
0.0672481507,
-0.0779657662,
0.0063083633,
-0.0634571686,
-0.0451246239,
-0.0158831272,
0.0314523466,
-0.009223639,
-0.0156656411,
-0.0209402032,
0.0189528912,
0.0103507554,
-0.0558398478,
-0.0045764325,
-0.0366084762,
-0.0372089408,
-0.0338674821,
0.0018116271,
-0.0165183246,
0.0265448373,
0.0245635733,
-0.0519729555,
0.0102167232,
-0.0201805308,
0.002523185,
-0.0504200235,
0.0201517958,
-0.0127065964,
-0.0202024113,
-0.0306502748,
-0.0407591872,
0.0808261409,
-0.025476709,
-0.0187233463,
-0.0361180976,
-0.0645046681,
-0.0130142514,
-0.0262963474,
0.0170523468,
0.0055755819,
0.0004739355,
-0.0188955162,
-0.0494124219,
0.0520728603,
0.1118640378,
-0.0557532869,
-0.0338923298,
0.0049333838,
-0.0307149775,
-0.0381610431,
-0.0080885841,
-0.0749324486,
0.0601247959,
0.0029269184,
-0.002700336,
-0.0834782124,
0.0089666285,
0.0147984717,
-0.0243159756,
0.1053632423,
0.008656173,
-0.0312405974,
-0.0324261822,
-0.009860443,
0.0005351661,
-0.0032830678,
-0.0275551397,
-0.0044009197,
0.0080941878,
-0.0442810804,
-0.0516849533,
0.0175703801,
-0.01251351,
0.0791340992,
-0.0499572977,
-0.0292059314,
-0.0025882779,
0.0084663546,
-0.0070060212,
0.0237720441,
-0.0114634586,
0.0275347196,
-0.0199953262,
0.0116177415,
-0.0397021174,
0.0258474089,
-0.0053653326,
0.0057253675,
-0.0106228618,
-0.0079146447,
-0.05390843,
0.0015003468,
-0.014749906,
0.0221829843,
0.0538165867,
-0.0285525937,
-0.0659676939,
0.0102255074,
-0.0276130512,
-0.044705268,
0.0256110132,
-0.0191259235,
-0.0063010696,
0.0102363406,
0.0579872355,
-0.0289923064,
0.0607048869,
0.0411347523,
0.0137590347,
0.0047223377,
0.0325245596,
-0.0032406109,
-0.0237514712,
0.0409949571,
0.0905112028,
0.0517461821,
0.0077887871,
0.0025694461,
-0.0106696133,
0.025929343,
0.0813462585,
-0.0999716893,
0.0010383154,
0.0433031879,
0.055294618,
0.1035863087,
-0.0245999005,
-0.0274535567,
-0.0331970565,
-0.0090381242,
-0.0424580127,
-0.0062033529,
0.0114396075,
-6.683138684e-33,
0.0243353285,
0.0096127447,
0.0204190332,
-0.0195891708,
0.0477742851,
-0.0153621826,
-0.006115979,
-0.0185892228,
-0.0077221333,
-0.016185062,
-0.0136057753,
0.0242850278,
-0.0003911059,
0.0160853639,
0.0420470983,
-0.0190921463,
0.0646786094,
-0.0134385806,
0.0053484975,
0.0444027372,
0.021284055,
0.0614925474,
0.0354706645,
-0.0403453447,
-0.0308079496,
-0.0040126201,
-0.0071449028,
-0.0160158221,
0.0422353819,
0.0613537803,
-0.0163136665,
0.0565571487,
0.0527332351,
-0.0142083867,
0.0167085622,
0.011115347,
-0.0433376096,
-0.0766186193,
-0.0720983073,
-0.0147323115,
0.0390494056,
-0.0300192088,
0.0040106336,
-0.027717771,
0.0111836642,
-0.0434725322,
0.0596064143,
0.0167319942,
-0.0318382382,
-0.087025404,
-0.0149705969,
0.0251778904,
-0.0252387002,
-0.0032752315,
0.0202415679,
0.0250421278,
0.0300848652,
0.0716589615,
-0.0466866829,
0.0146526033,
-0.0528051928,
0.0298925713,
-0.037646547,
-0.0256991964,
-0.015355343,
0.0252652373,
0.0148143414,
0.0104583669,
0.0017287317,
0.0177024752,
0.0211588833,
0.0547193326,
-0.001683485,
0.0786688849,
0.0824946463,
-0.028578585,
-0.053859558,
0.0227192324,
-0.0090352334,
0.04293897,
0.0279804785,
0.0331023037,
-0.0296566188,
-0.0124711888,
0.0034133771,
0.0004907592,
-0.0526315719,
-0.0032936812,
0.02098988,
0.0628636628,
0.0053924862,
0.0502767041,
0.0619454347,
-0.012849411,
-0.0083982581,
0.0379453748,
-0.0345920064,
0.0180501193,
0.0249190982,
-0.0035289561,
-0.0581836812,
-0.0641356632,
0.0547009632,
0.0030091631,
-0.0200986266,
0.0035753006,
0.0249730963,
0.0068009137,
-0.0571007393,
-0.0214922298,
0.0336454734,
-0.0332263298,
-0.0193728041,
0.0383875109,
-0.0380884856,
0.0579600669,
0.0213685017,
0.0789115429,
0.0298644602,
0.0143689159,
0.0012528521,
-0.0484811217,
-0.0588801727,
0.0063504875,
0.0376160741,
0.0086379992,
-0.0052534523,
-0.0145732705,
0.0407147631,
-0.0353518017,
0.0006958488,
0.0007683655,
2.841e-7,
0.0130466809,
0.0666267201,
-0.0483065769,
-0.0125263073,
-0.0239816364,
0.0392799489,
-0.023084471,
0.0518005081,
0.0048908433,
-0.0240705833,
0.0487013683,
0.0306311063,
0.014660906,
0.0582774989,
-0.0986383781,
0.0258145481,
-0.0516846888,
-0.0009169315,
-0.0790912807,
-0.0199060235,
0.0586107858,
0.0834487826,
0.0297253579,
-0.000222183,
0.0020502587,
-0.0213346761,
0.0653779209,
-0.0028738973,
-0.0210403986,
0.0168149546,
0.03355854,
0.0622048415,
0.0077123707,
-0.0054055988,
-0.0481125787,
0.0159400385,
-0.0066119684,
0.0518738851,
-0.0393801294,
-0.0573409498,
-0.0016222844,
-0.0147611117,
-0.0038688988,
0.0030488814,
0.0709522441,
-0.0729589313,
0.0000999302,
-0.0081323404,
-0.0485559329,
0.0207740366,
0.0705822632,
-0.0105957352,
-0.0170622375,
-0.0095926402,
-0.0096324096,
0.0041671521,
-0.019329017,
-0.0826507509,
0.0629780442,
0.0503286086,
-0.0098088132,
0.0363435261,
-0.0252380017,
-0.0111780241,
0.0087033613,
-0.0248766486,
0.0093182549,
2.195359908e-34,
0.0248593129,
0.0065623326,
-0.0127586033,
0.0094212936,
-0.0172467791,
-0.0048804078,
-0.0423024297,
0.0058557545,
0.0218816809,
-0.0322490185,
0.032079339
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.06798v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.06798v1 | Building Trustworthy NeuroSymbolic AI Systems: Consistency, Reliability, Explainability, and Safety | 2023-12-05T06:13:55 | 2023-12-05T06:13:55 | Manas Gaur, Amit Sheth | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, I.2; I.2.7; J.3; H.3.3 | Explainability and Safety engender Trust. These require a model to exhibit
consistency and reliability. To achieve these, it is necessary to use and
analyze data and knowledge with statistical and symbolic AI methods relevant to
the AI application - neither alone will do. Consequently, we argue and seek to
demonstrate that the NeuroSymbolic AI approach is better suited for making AI a
trusted AI system. We present the CREST framework that shows how Consistency,
Reliability, user-level Explainability, and Safety are built on NeuroSymbolic
methods that use data and knowledge to support requirements for critical
applications such as health and well-being. This article focuses on Large
Language Models (LLMs) as the chosen AI system within the CREST framework. LLMs
have garnered substantial attention from researchers due to their versatility
in handling a broad array of natural language processing (NLP) scenarios. For
example, ChatGPT and Google's MedPaLM have emerged as highly promising
platforms for providing information in general and health-related queries,
respectively. Nevertheless, these models remain black boxes despite
incorporating human feedback and instruction-guided tuning. For instance,
ChatGPT can generate unsafe responses despite instituting safety guardrails.
CREST presents a plausible approach harnessing procedural and graph-based
knowledge within a NeuroSymbolic framework to shed light on the challenges
associated with LLMs. | [
0.0581325106,
0.0824673325,
-0.0208580717,
0.0198242143,
-0.0135025904,
0.0028807449,
-0.0157151874,
-0.0006534346,
0.0402893201,
0.027651893,
0.0077030212,
-0.0200739112,
0.0084209554,
0.0660260469,
0.0374143757,
-0.0442333259,
0.0398964547,
-0.0126954438,
0.0614747293,
0.0208712071,
-0.0076655424,
0.0253596064,
-0.0324757211,
0.0613729581,
-0.0200274326,
-0.0069251391,
-0.0189319681,
-0.0010247196,
0.0010081445,
-0.0693062469,
-0.0299216565,
0.0224004667,
0.0030718532,
-0.0020265982,
0.0000021974,
-0.034442272,
0.0177051611,
0.0395402834,
-0.0413742922,
-0.0458481051,
0.0425885282,
-0.0152596151,
0.0187688768,
0.0193803571,
-0.0216291696,
0.0412575826,
0.0577771142,
0.057715755,
0.0765365362,
0.049327407,
-0.0204733815,
0.0312648639,
0.0400793999,
0.0085126609,
0.0193379782,
-0.0266839452,
0.0274004918,
-0.0371756703,
0.034673661,
-0.003159086,
-0.0093307914,
0.0241847057,
0.0194973331,
-0.0246557351,
0.0153646357,
0.0287656169,
0.0090702726,
-0.0349633545,
-0.0201342069,
0.0646348819,
-0.0015788346,
0.0234134011,
0.0384999029,
0.0266607068,
-0.0070169587,
0.0027375591,
-0.0578168109,
0.0147127779,
-0.0325512476,
-0.0094801802,
-0.0038170675,
-0.0170936901,
0.0822210386,
0.0200577546,
0.0016826296,
0.0695441887,
-0.0153219281,
-0.0174820237,
0.0133509552,
-0.0343096405,
0.0149388192,
-0.0445573442,
0.0268821213,
0.0695626885,
-0.075606823,
0.0325723924,
-0.0195521768,
0.0224751141,
0.0425650999,
-0.0250179451,
0.0070646945,
0.0137124509,
0.011632693,
0.016076358,
0.0344293341,
0.0135226902,
-0.0218466744,
0.0587046891,
-0.0115383845,
-0.0023408378,
-0.0693952665,
-0.0187604558,
0.0004724,
0.0229910109,
0.0061448426,
-0.0153653705,
-0.0521405078,
0.0467747375,
-0.0502666496,
0.0206000637,
0.0139040044,
0.0564953759,
0.0024910348,
-0.0008820526,
-0.0610812046,
-0.0301314462,
-0.041370675,
0.0264862776,
0.0182369817,
-0.0448887423,
0.0023363403,
0.0100863017,
-0.0404145569,
0.0072063841,
0.0022133887,
0.0995423794,
0.0452035218,
-0.0179050155,
-0.0875423178,
-0.0662238896,
-0.0293895658,
-0.0464368798,
0.0046297186,
-0.0383881815,
0.0273145251,
0.0078472281,
-0.0019777932,
-0.0775680616,
0.0205739383,
-0.0015731247,
-0.0676570535,
0.092485562,
-0.0415997729,
0.0065987301,
-0.008550615,
0.0447765589,
-0.0278359596,
0.0150014106,
0.0743059888,
0.0061220257,
0.0507947989,
0.0099412715,
0.0379911698,
-0.0409508459,
0.0097166188,
-0.0103028631,
0.0013845263,
0.0044097411,
-0.0574174263,
0.0138320671,
-0.0260195322,
0.095232673,
-0.0050720661,
-0.0277941246,
0.0916451067,
0.0599707663,
-0.0124799283,
0.015863331,
0.028127946,
-0.0381236523,
-0.0063745677,
-0.0242784619,
-0.0910521299,
0.0405734554,
-0.0193897448,
-0.0162697081,
-0.0233493429,
0.0114400387,
-0.0186441205,
-0.0562108234,
-0.003347707,
-0.0428521372,
0.035968706,
0.0094708754,
0.0121558327,
-0.0516996533,
-0.0146393375,
0.0059370031,
0.0066038049,
-0.0227089953,
0.0048475279,
-0.071138382,
0.0329401381,
0.1219349205,
0.0366450436,
-0.008708911,
-0.0300051458,
-0.0275960192,
-0.0600081012,
0.0184665993,
-0.0287784897,
-0.013286096,
0.0447435565,
-0.0502145104,
-0.0125587098,
0.0126728276,
0.0111194123,
-0.0151208863,
0.0101242568,
0.0242811255,
-0.0265316926,
-0.0077293701,
-0.0640604571,
0.0520678982,
-0.0332688354,
-0.0237988885,
-0.0264658723,
-0.0101224557,
0.0485147834,
0.0259877704,
0.0181455594,
0.0475330986,
0.0330892093,
-0.0030823539,
-0.0443350971,
0.0027576289,
-0.0234522596,
0.0348055921,
0.0219890885,
-0.0207714755,
0.0165682714,
0.0227775816,
-0.0364431515,
-0.0561902262,
-0.0064605973,
-0.0622561239,
-0.0039789919,
-0.0233210679,
0.0011034786,
0.0150419287,
-0.0240699071,
-0.0226796623,
0.0192941204,
-0.025791632,
-0.043394804,
-0.0215898491,
0.000065504,
-0.0022679365,
-0.0473510921,
-0.0268204212,
0.0307461899,
-0.0165126249,
0.0323681608,
0.0019312309,
-0.018064132,
-0.0328797512,
-0.0000254807,
-0.0951271206,
-0.0116399731,
0.0073399772,
0.0217144117,
-0.0033145694,
-0.0249454062,
0.0009467809,
-0.014667958,
-0.006175613,
0.06181008,
0.0160972867,
0.0305619873,
0.0388804264,
0.0205452461,
-0.0346195027,
-0.0128841475,
-0.0094818184,
-0.0455852747,
0.0474551022,
0.017533863,
-0.0010745492,
-0.0635900423,
0.0209999457,
-0.0524914823,
0.0139252488,
0.0004080614,
-0.0175512303,
0.0460218526,
0.0450784005,
-0.0188790355,
0.0528613143,
0.0018376115,
0.020228276,
0.0302600712,
0.0110936295,
-0.0056123012,
0.0000398295,
-0.0266326144,
0.0135029042,
-0.0259832069,
-0.0475605018,
0.0172012839,
0.0521689057,
0.0194789115,
-0.0043953033,
-0.0356951058,
0.0472712591,
-0.0143321855,
-0.0203031786,
-0.0277572945,
-0.0561682396,
-0.008854433,
0.0478143841,
-0.0141166477,
-0.0857921988,
0.1166313291,
-0.0040237023,
0.0388172008,
-0.0039597959,
-0.0592921451,
-0.0169746596,
0.0611523204,
-0.0157519486,
0.0303662159,
0.0613854229,
-0.0203042906,
-0.0222596917,
-0.0620663203,
-0.0003717561,
-0.038515307,
0.0368798636,
-0.0469595231,
-0.0075807725,
0.0576639883,
-0.0489355326,
-0.051613491,
-0.0284505952,
-0.0475973859,
0.0102354577,
0.0478220768,
-0.0390483662,
-0.0344012864,
-0.0127752339,
0.0473129749,
-0.0019669326,
-0.0135881342,
-0.0399965756,
-0.0045506191,
-0.0168506205,
0.0373896211,
-0.0086493501,
0.0795770213,
-0.0079441685,
0.0161909834,
0.064092353,
0.0213770699,
0.0070264596,
-0.0377995446,
-0.00565028,
-0.0388826169,
-0.0257017799,
0.0020312024,
0.0561710894,
0.0134039046,
-0.0200873557,
-0.0071629854,
0.0891074091,
-0.0005009756,
-0.0339268856,
0.0407189019,
-0.0133821601,
-0.0328388549,
-0.0010416651,
0.0128257936,
-0.0351089574,
-0.0048259255,
-0.0033629271,
0.0684674978,
-0.0168088991,
-0.0456394963,
-0.0038065566,
-0.0321249105,
0.0348368622,
-0.009002951,
-0.0372852869,
-0.0056805369,
-0.060563609,
-0.029242862,
-0.0396295078,
0.0224312562,
0.0248681214,
-0.0063391062,
-0.0113832131,
-0.0005361488,
-0.0324587151,
-0.048807282,
0.0304798391,
-0.0577296615,
0.0871239379,
0.0313714221,
0.0332284868,
-0.0197900999,
-0.0390278548,
-0.0048628245,
0.0276488401,
0.0197554901,
-0.0085732769,
0.0713144317,
0.009250435,
0.0024171702,
-0.0648723319,
0.0250253584,
-0.0504527651,
-0.0314226784,
-0.0161125585,
0.0738524646,
-0.0417476557,
-0.0092415102,
-0.0589683093,
0.0124161569,
0.0386279263,
0.0763388425,
0.0191517957,
-0.0170787424,
-0.0243484713,
0.005811878,
-0.0070576807,
0.0066719423,
-0.0263570864,
0.015692642,
0.0076570357,
-0.0168425273,
-0.072521016,
-0.038833797,
0.0019790158,
0.0232406892,
0.0198911726,
-0.0206026044,
0.0764212832,
-0.0031994598,
-0.0401303545,
0.0427053981,
-0.007619536,
0.0149738546,
-0.0336987376,
0.0331073292,
-0.0045835464,
-0.0140773486,
0.0009425179,
0.0073496914,
0.0151854334,
-0.0322301164,
-0.006017819,
0.0848285928,
0.0419135578,
0.0002487983,
-0.0327586532,
-0.039000392,
0.0149856135,
0.0448651388,
-0.0491886735,
-0.0409252606,
0.0117264353,
0.0217374712,
0.0252973493,
0.0079130996,
-0.0387058333,
0.0033335926,
-0.0091241375,
0.0399256349,
-0.0120422188,
-0.0047434708,
0.0279180501,
0.0439124927,
0.0227816887,
-0.0012492157,
0.0317372866,
-0.0132418387,
-0.0311355721,
-0.0063613369,
0.0060052807,
-0.0263731144,
0.0243370812,
0.0243681427,
-0.0099729756,
-0.0148489783,
-0.0795217901,
-0.0318781361,
0.0101767918,
0.0006266073,
-0.0182230119,
-0.0283071063,
0.0233136248,
-0.0127123501,
0.0087664798,
0.0069227871,
0.0316754729,
-0.0335125178,
0.046498321,
0.0232290793,
0.0694172531,
-0.0011830744,
-0.0269652419,
-0.0471539162,
0.0282308701,
-0.0523806028,
-0.0667510182,
0.0192728397,
-0.0220785737,
0.0059981481,
0.0366358459,
0.0247214641,
-0.0408506878,
0.0184652321,
-0.0194281656,
0.0062244483,
0.0217850357,
0.0125551214,
0.0200414285,
0.0281771012,
-0.0209263042,
-0.0414710902,
0.0718254969,
-0.014224017,
0.0171317738,
-0.0153494244,
-0.0701860487,
-0.0187612288,
-0.0225815326,
0.0035716242,
0.0352710597,
-0.0656728521,
-0.035897024,
-0.067884028,
-0.0557818152,
0.0353515185,
0.0294103324,
0.010806961,
-0.031472344,
0.021281248,
0.0392048359,
0.0299115703,
-0.0289801694,
-0.0124251982,
0.0031456482,
-0.0383972526,
0.0018896218,
-0.0355202481,
-6.370809835e-33,
0.0219488498,
-0.0774072558,
0.0284614805,
0.0066281608,
0.0006854418,
0.0022613781,
-0.0433382541,
0.0021111513,
-0.012639489,
0.041833207,
0.000425351,
0.0447744168,
0.0075535821,
-0.0015913139,
0.0321252979,
-0.0350347348,
0.0110926488,
0.030579865,
-0.0227058697,
0.0304061547,
0.0426767208,
0.0269369315,
0.0234350674,
-0.1304302812,
0.0688486919,
0.0104401056,
-0.0077481079,
0.0422792025,
-0.0253196396,
0.0489914753,
-0.0215037316,
0.0524143688,
0.0396470577,
-0.0278469063,
0.0172229074,
0.0172784999,
-0.0374470763,
-0.0486131385,
0.0256556273,
-0.0505435802,
-0.0696179718,
-0.0437147468,
0.0584973842,
-0.036085505,
0.0022332459,
0.0225862246,
0.0131364847,
-0.039987009,
-0.0017012365,
-0.0288171787,
-0.0227917358,
0.0055610803,
0.0141922627,
-0.0227946471,
-0.0433545671,
0.0122895045,
-0.0447724052,
0.0159057584,
-0.0405389927,
0.0018317087,
-0.0196271837,
-0.024610186,
0.0349087343,
-0.0303930249,
-0.0144542605,
0.0443272106,
0.030788783,
0.0012032421,
-0.0746999085,
-0.0217613857,
-0.0100449193,
0.095799692,
0.0834329128,
0.0076535447,
-0.0116687333,
-0.0190726519,
-0.088406302,
0.0429763086,
-0.0237146243,
0.0867709517,
0.0382348634,
0.0120290089,
-0.0633051172,
-0.020405639,
-0.0203199014,
-0.0193450674,
-0.0526706204,
-0.0295098666,
0.0092904428,
0.0013140602,
-0.0279363599,
0.0157929771,
-0.0286670774,
-0.0446983166,
0.0278860573,
0.0231060758,
0.0628076792,
-0.0320443138,
-0.0009770838,
-0.0109648369,
0.0087399483,
-0.000477766,
-0.0216849055,
-0.0047065555,
0.0532123446,
0.013082278,
0.0359841958,
0.0348200165,
-0.0055620382,
-0.0227798261,
-0.029693041,
0.004549691,
0.0237870365,
-0.031823948,
0.0171946418,
0.0129759936,
-0.017546976,
0.0295600574,
0.0415493138,
0.0364678614,
-0.018242795,
0.033050485,
-0.0144192735,
0.0136848427,
0.0018461683,
-0.0226862747,
-0.0387381949,
0.0179159716,
0.0111039178,
-0.0667265579,
0.0001411863,
-0.0222441126,
2.994e-7,
0.0231026262,
0.05841925,
0.0034419505,
0.0038017181,
0.057449352,
0.0358166657,
-0.0006200516,
0.008485659,
-0.0411319099,
-0.0679804236,
0.0150641678,
0.0466556847,
0.025252793,
0.0661586523,
0.0095720356,
-0.0221798327,
-0.0649151877,
-0.0374751873,
-0.0622263663,
0.0384409055,
0.090100728,
0.0285315868,
0.0255143493,
-0.0364371166,
0.012059954,
-0.0418546461,
0.013449857,
-0.0313109607,
0.0381763242,
-0.0083072828,
0.0673770308,
0.0159633495,
0.0370714739,
0.0331901908,
0.0085682152,
-0.0177664906,
-0.0468143001,
0.0792222694,
-0.0382058024,
-0.0004420077,
0.0146940984,
-0.0588506535,
0.0192068517,
-0.0790000856,
0.0383840241,
-0.0586972013,
-0.0684834197,
-0.0148894349,
-0.0177627895,
-0.033797808,
0.0488442928,
-0.0153056057,
-0.0002426157,
0.0027485294,
-0.0196838845,
0.0115060918,
0.010507415,
-0.050567057,
-0.0153763304,
0.0229497459,
-0.0053112037,
-0.024400169,
-0.0066710105,
-0.0023126001,
0.0187847819,
-0.0979134887,
0.0163330194,
2.507672685e-34,
-0.0075024283,
-0.0006177225,
-0.0077474336,
-0.0061514778,
0.058857847,
0.0333539359,
-0.0431357995,
0.0060811946,
0.0293065701,
-0.0472024456,
-0.0333492979
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.02496v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.02496v1 | MKA: A Scalable Medical Knowledge Assisted Mechanism for Generative Models on Medical Conversation Tasks | 2023-12-05T04:55:54 | 2023-12-05T04:55:54 | Ke Liang, Sifan Wu, Jiayi Gu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Using natural language processing (NLP) technologies to develop medical
chatbots makes the diagnosis of the patient more convenient and efficient,
which is a typical application in healthcare AI. Because of its importance,
lots of research have been come out. Recently, the neural generative models
have shown their impressive ability as the core of chatbot, while it cannot
scale well when directly applied to medical conversation due to the lack of
medical-specific knowledge. To address the limitation, a scalable Medical
Knowledge Assisted mechanism, MKA, is proposed in this paper. The mechanism
aims to assist general neural generative models to achieve better performance
on the medical conversation task. The medical-specific knowledge graph is
designed within the mechanism, which contains 6 types of medical-related
information, including department, drug, check, symptom, disease, food.
Besides, the specific token concatenation policy is defined to effectively
inject medical information into the input data. Evaluation of our method is
carried out on two typical medical datasets, MedDG and MedDialog-CN. The
evaluation results demonstrate that models combined with our mechanism
outperform original methods in multiple automatic evaluation metrics. Besides,
MKA-Bert-GPT achieves state-of-the-art performance. The open-sourced codes are
public:
https://github.com/LIANGKE23/Knowledge_Assisted_Medical_Dialogue_Generation_Mechanism | [
0.0918116644,
0.0316061042,
0.0109148137,
-0.0222612787,
-0.0303852241,
0.012547452,
0.0146268709,
0.0290049817,
0.0499822982,
-0.0160046387,
-0.0129518574,
-0.0266537368,
0.0108219087,
0.0746418312,
0.0354557373,
-0.0795757025,
0.0229163785,
0.0435439013,
0.0466280207,
0.0116915135,
-0.0104591995,
-0.0018193464,
-0.0685806498,
0.0844605491,
-0.0483863279,
-0.0093721161,
-0.0039197863,
-0.0037495461,
0.0243299641,
-0.0577038415,
-0.0056021591,
0.031181762,
-0.0280010253,
-0.007774868,
0.0000018565,
-0.01931048,
0.0122226216,
0.0243409462,
-0.0153866699,
-0.0740254819,
0.0326879472,
-0.0367045514,
-0.0121435607,
0.0380224586,
-0.0392383337,
-0.0276711341,
0.0271037538,
0.0725085363,
0.0563304983,
0.0881579593,
-0.0192828495,
0.000245963,
0.0331235789,
-0.0179715268,
0.0236881506,
-0.0511316098,
0.0206113327,
0.0120434202,
0.0431367084,
-0.0092233866,
-0.0033266121,
0.0207483247,
0.0049382807,
-0.023381412,
0.0482047573,
0.0680067465,
-0.0402775854,
-0.0255214591,
-0.0138917482,
0.0966543183,
-0.0029184532,
-0.0029142671,
0.029014146,
0.0009791898,
0.0114752725,
-0.0214670897,
-0.0389185138,
-0.0289719738,
-0.0310326256,
0.0048317946,
-0.0046788654,
-0.0165429227,
0.0166511592,
-0.0162344556,
0.0266782623,
-0.0090122148,
0.0312513299,
-0.0190061741,
-0.0307807103,
-0.0129311401,
-0.0167590193,
-0.0652244464,
0.0420460142,
0.0609567128,
-0.0591197573,
0.0124894138,
-0.0354542509,
-0.0238242354,
0.0557719655,
-0.0653610826,
-0.0269335378,
0.0371796191,
0.0119748022,
0.0195036456,
-0.0215894822,
0.0465355739,
-0.0168959107,
0.0225586742,
-0.0344521739,
-0.0250568222,
-0.0610417277,
-0.028669728,
-0.0430117063,
0.036737565,
-0.0166558139,
-0.0365254916,
-0.0836660415,
0.0216520615,
0.0175551325,
0.0208653044,
0.0469080657,
0.0654457957,
-0.0328464322,
0.0204935446,
-0.0215873923,
-0.0006760773,
-0.045233205,
-0.0109921545,
0.0204009265,
-0.0495262071,
-0.0051198895,
0.0144608663,
0.01636637,
0.0116951074,
0.0039864019,
0.0726102293,
0.0064573474,
-0.0053157741,
0.0171323344,
-0.0387379602,
-0.0306048598,
-0.0236812606,
0.0210396554,
-0.0331096165,
0.0646342933,
-0.0178193152,
-0.0048050825,
-0.0245999247,
0.0139108663,
0.0190847889,
-0.0345759988,
0.0484882817,
-0.0566906482,
0.0153436959,
0.0372633934,
0.0310531855,
-0.0136635732,
0.0187455676,
0.0251832176,
-0.0301095117,
-0.0125740906,
-0.0058473703,
0.032115072,
-0.0103290565,
0.0367358364,
-0.0719902739,
0.0178565923,
-0.0133400988,
-0.0425235033,
0.0971761271,
-0.0296007302,
0.0916394666,
-0.0340126492,
-0.0095843757,
0.0006136902,
0.0591390431,
0.0174595639,
0.026895998,
0.0413876958,
-0.0160802845,
0.0087270504,
-0.0152279334,
0.0037711358,
0.0174613614,
0.0310183372,
-0.0086062197,
0.0045105168,
0.0024998779,
-0.0502664782,
-0.0318332613,
-0.0152466549,
-0.0203498658,
-0.0147786606,
-0.033076752,
0.0153800072,
0.0168630257,
-0.0459123552,
0.045150768,
0.0424828231,
-0.0370755754,
-0.0272788517,
-0.0689316839,
-0.0002484727,
0.0940036178,
0.0843817517,
-0.0030363568,
-0.1029455438,
-0.0234981347,
-0.0580820665,
0.0584376417,
0.0321443602,
-0.0251546092,
0.0122186905,
-0.0638387874,
-0.0075465711,
0.0250132866,
0.0013287062,
-0.0116769504,
0.0112884529,
0.0185220856,
0.0195303392,
-0.0173416175,
0.0362769477,
0.029436741,
-0.0197975449,
0.0048517673,
0.031483721,
-0.011484378,
0.0525292046,
0.0433193408,
-0.0005560541,
0.0273637827,
0.0233373325,
-0.0228499044,
-0.0385364778,
0.0472310781,
-0.0653128847,
-0.0958131179,
0.011777089,
-0.01525837,
0.0037551185,
-0.0348125137,
-0.0314477496,
-0.0599044077,
-0.0195843633,
-0.0563000701,
0.0484159663,
-0.0224200804,
0.0161538851,
0.0525863692,
-0.0037935835,
-0.0110522034,
0.0375950336,
-0.0216748193,
0.0093994979,
0.0181696247,
0.0327053219,
0.0014651844,
-0.0313659534,
-0.0195768848,
0.0188972447,
0.0006416315,
-0.0007254882,
-0.0044406499,
0.0267903712,
-0.0255558975,
-0.0511859022,
-0.1617587656,
0.001666324,
0.0223061778,
-0.0215757936,
0.0294513088,
0.0375497676,
-0.0010413849,
-0.0266511086,
-0.0754270703,
0.0296465736,
0.0450637639,
-0.0004991207,
0.0442552678,
0.0413181745,
-0.0118770273,
-0.0164248962,
0.0251805354,
-0.020734245,
0.0137142856,
0.0256048311,
0.0103609497,
-0.0069998419,
-0.0175876655,
-0.0643584505,
0.0276532024,
-0.0116829704,
-0.0427555703,
0.0374609903,
-0.002282277,
0.0466856025,
0.0359826535,
0.0226712693,
0.0119746011,
-0.0067146472,
0.0028184983,
-0.0433308333,
0.0461870134,
-0.0244335607,
0.0143769085,
0.0118998438,
-0.0267368555,
0.0153578687,
0.0716164336,
0.0271090083,
0.009064029,
-0.0690391511,
0.0055098501,
0.0202002954,
0.0097845113,
-0.033104863,
0.0091196448,
-0.0467350595,
0.0048518311,
0.0048217941,
-0.0346942097,
0.0913933665,
-0.0218546987,
0.0096299388,
-0.0874476731,
-0.0169423409,
-0.0347866677,
0.0200625286,
-0.0085154399,
0.0243981313,
0.0153596736,
-0.0250221491,
0.0117232706,
0.0432180166,
-0.0237240698,
-0.0543843322,
-0.0014416121,
0.0016347591,
0.0098882793,
0.0309352949,
-0.0463131629,
-0.0655318871,
-0.0088283075,
-0.0044422136,
0.0123598864,
0.0334387869,
-0.0247400496,
-0.0416117907,
0.0262933504,
-0.0363433212,
0.0645823553,
0.0164045822,
-0.0115054287,
-0.0004073183,
0.0331780463,
0.0198585019,
0.0098317312,
-0.0302380119,
0.0253814217,
0.0335508436,
0.0348390825,
-0.0031127746,
0.0238453262,
-0.0115507888,
-0.0270416606,
-0.0223330595,
-0.0041232784,
-0.0146073513,
0.0085519273,
0.0162307769,
-0.0461048037,
-0.0156703778,
0.1365659535,
0.0386263058,
-0.0258177426,
0.0293375719,
-0.0017415999,
0.0074812146,
-0.0402610004,
0.0279892422,
-0.0504205786,
-0.0077417069,
0.0044324594,
0.027798472,
-0.0442633703,
-0.0249321051,
0.0095179174,
-0.0488982871,
0.0154925957,
-0.0237758905,
-0.0378973596,
-0.0675564185,
-0.0263818037,
-0.0144139705,
-0.004750073,
0.0128886085,
-0.0153923323,
0.0231738426,
-0.0026040457,
0.003627043,
-0.0368119292,
-0.0753664374,
-0.0020040863,
-0.0179012064,
0.0952377766,
0.0662778988,
0.0797414333,
0.0354068838,
0.0073963879,
0.0084575387,
0.0678998753,
0.0031271956,
-0.0150562003,
0.0651651919,
0.0029278276,
-0.0201854501,
-0.0585881174,
0.029228678,
-0.0127214417,
-0.0204531215,
-0.0114463205,
0.0343062319,
-0.0364300907,
-0.0202946849,
-0.0514169447,
0.0344004817,
0.0308296271,
0.0685295835,
0.0080877366,
0.0151491771,
-0.0443268009,
0.0006138544,
0.044379361,
-0.0299535599,
0.0109070931,
0.0095077595,
-0.0006487957,
-0.0262118597,
-0.1138140708,
-0.0360964611,
0.032072138,
0.0032082729,
0.0046484326,
-0.0075428509,
0.0175445843,
0.0078104087,
-0.0202185512,
0.0014036618,
0.0314956717,
-0.0284670908,
-0.0553957336,
-0.0582657643,
0.0655642897,
-0.0143762408,
-0.0160797536,
0.0294569917,
-0.0268493798,
-0.0142720323,
-0.031734854,
0.04929756,
0.0093720295,
0.0190723725,
-0.0405934006,
-0.0082211616,
0.0482260473,
0.033394631,
-0.0404984578,
-0.0381377116,
0.0034388432,
0.0382061489,
0.0037736627,
0.0297453627,
-0.0170581751,
0.0218664836,
-0.0268139318,
0.0504482649,
0.0005502816,
-0.0199700221,
0.0094136382,
0.0284407586,
-0.002674066,
-0.0265491921,
0.0033463421,
-0.021915378,
0.0238959175,
-0.0497377515,
0.0258003641,
-0.0619422868,
0.0158301741,
0.0092868414,
-0.018307915,
-0.0049710157,
-0.0126635851,
-0.0644390061,
-0.0033539266,
-0.0126106944,
0.0029250744,
0.0065436587,
-0.0258906167,
0.0403052084,
-0.0144441631,
0.0023127515,
0.021280054,
-0.0073947348,
-0.0112664783,
-0.0212884452,
0.0518247485,
-0.0063407957,
0.0015244304,
0.027714964,
0.0557285361,
-0.0480216034,
-0.0533226915,
-0.0227178857,
0.0801487491,
0.0329854637,
0.044334285,
0.0224380773,
-0.0424801707,
0.0156489871,
0.000446269,
0.0361441746,
-0.0291169733,
-0.0130698457,
0.0299181249,
-0.0170772839,
0.0122399945,
-0.0412282571,
0.0932962447,
-0.0039503165,
0.0538645722,
-0.0076957652,
-0.0316000693,
-0.070354417,
-0.0074332408,
0.0139551004,
0.0244354177,
-0.0360504277,
0.0429108515,
-0.0201639887,
-0.0329164267,
-0.0065419595,
-0.0229530223,
-0.0233928766,
-0.0020606355,
0.0975560769,
0.0342792906,
-0.0120330062,
-0.012917731,
-0.0267837923,
0.0447958633,
-0.0270820092,
-0.0240677744,
0.0094200149,
-5.780777426e-33,
-0.0264247712,
-0.0226832069,
0.0347221792,
-0.0060676532,
-0.0285753272,
0.0061690612,
-0.0495600514,
-0.0177098792,
0.0046804557,
0.0137201697,
-0.0285359323,
0.010104781,
-0.0007884992,
0.0706369206,
-0.0238921512,
-0.0416438468,
0.0602059923,
0.0019230131,
-0.0211665537,
0.0632904619,
-0.0049468507,
0.0616857931,
0.0194372516,
-0.0542540774,
-0.0117426561,
-0.0135823442,
0.0205946956,
0.0049235229,
0.0009942417,
0.0464435667,
-0.0481756404,
0.0186411552,
0.0573311374,
0.0032407835,
-0.0196988024,
0.0215539169,
-0.063916482,
-0.0312609784,
0.0028178294,
-0.0111896014,
-0.0552979186,
-0.0428567901,
0.0481838696,
-0.0350894369,
0.007613617,
0.0194656868,
0.0054150042,
-0.0124544939,
-0.0013516385,
-0.0337415934,
-0.0319024436,
0.042097792,
0.0001338006,
-0.0534438677,
-0.0498477481,
0.0239640828,
-0.0150428033,
0.010146128,
-0.0112441713,
-0.0003270503,
0.011962276,
0.0011323956,
-0.0118554952,
-0.0358086601,
0.0064632222,
0.0484975278,
0.0301459543,
-0.0038477683,
-0.0677014068,
0.0130759627,
-0.063655749,
0.056104701,
0.0481132083,
0.0024677604,
0.0031416535,
-0.0297278743,
-0.0748675838,
0.0382272191,
-0.0156972092,
0.0480740964,
0.0066720322,
-0.0167383701,
-0.068252407,
0.0094294855,
-0.0001439731,
-0.0141738961,
-0.0108604208,
-0.0516102649,
0.0390282869,
0.0247778948,
0.0224763975,
-0.0380189084,
-0.0173937324,
-0.0226316191,
0.0624817125,
0.0178490411,
0.0310968161,
0.0064136041,
-0.0306908078,
-0.014559947,
-0.0527863055,
-0.0407347083,
0.0771532208,
0.007884142,
0.0222461931,
0.0332617201,
-0.005185727,
-0.0345410109,
-0.0357157066,
0.0098378872,
0.0001598411,
0.0231794659,
-0.031916637,
0.0337565355,
0.0123809604,
0.0229474157,
-0.0228485856,
0.0379981659,
-0.0052763755,
0.0373324752,
-0.0482710339,
-0.0142652113,
0.0276597068,
-0.0217354484,
-0.0520066582,
0.0173872132,
-0.0309698284,
0.033305496,
0.0116116833,
-0.0482487269,
-0.0147549249,
-0.0210780427,
2.699e-7,
0.0509346686,
0.0304389633,
0.0227836054,
-0.0134999119,
0.055971086,
-0.0005900908,
0.0185837019,
0.0280039888,
-0.0226097163,
-0.0031274313,
0.0182568897,
-0.0072753644,
0.0128620947,
0.0158027019,
-0.0895846337,
-0.0189557243,
-0.0938279256,
-0.0610899366,
0.0060636583,
-0.0543748774,
0.0619259439,
0.0669633076,
-0.0312548615,
-0.0257837363,
0.0253347307,
-0.0261816606,
0.043517217,
0.0046329843,
-0.0331077799,
0.0553403459,
0.0482588634,
0.0491862819,
0.029420102,
0.0381994359,
-0.0082911449,
0.0055074645,
0.0173991919,
0.0733981282,
-0.0345738195,
-0.0221954267,
0.0446527489,
-0.0069670281,
0.0227329228,
-0.0488182902,
0.0565484837,
-0.0515454262,
-0.0408653207,
-0.0051063769,
0.013682724,
0.0125984699,
0.0707891732,
-0.0577705875,
-0.0468717217,
0.0381742865,
0.0327453837,
0.0062567941,
0.0068151182,
-0.0831387267,
-0.0339338481,
0.0023758507,
-0.0670351684,
-0.0500124171,
0.0147752119,
-0.0583356582,
-0.0018686937,
-0.0329249986,
0.0144859394,
2.106098331e-34,
0.0189206265,
0.0165564865,
-0.0037349234,
0.0464979447,
0.0086038299,
-0.0116443746,
0.0128296679,
0.0013318104,
0.0330121033,
-0.0501207411,
-0.0284739472
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.02441v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.02441v1 | MedDM:LLM-executable clinical guidance tree for clinical decision-making | 2023-12-05T02:44:07 | 2023-12-05T02:44:07 | Binbin Li, Tianxin Meng, Xiaoming Shi, Jie Zhai, Tong Ruan | cs.CL | cs.CL | It is becoming increasingly emphasis on the importance of LLM participating
in clinical diagnosis decision-making. However, the low specialization refers
to that current medical LLMs can not provide specific medical advice, which are
more like a medical Q\&A. And there is no suitable clinical guidance tree data
set that can be used directly with LLM. To address this issue, we first propose
LLM-executavle clinical guidance tree(CGT), which can be directly used by large
language models, and construct medical diagnostic decision-making dataset
(MedDM), from flowcharts in clinical practice guidelines. We propose an
approach to screen flowcharts from medical literature, followed by their
identification and conversion into standardized diagnostic decision trees.
Constructed a knowledge base with 1202 decision trees, which came from 5000
medical literature and covered 12 hospital departments, including internal
medicine, surgery, psychiatry, and over 500 diseases.Moreover, we propose a
method for reasoning on LLM-executable CGT and a Patient-LLM multi-turn
dialogue framework. | [
0.0474063419,
-0.0106925005,
-0.0064553516,
-0.0123858256,
-0.021515958,
0.0195056628,
-0.0285432432,
0.0652838871,
0.0128502734,
0.0256502125,
0.0123560745,
-0.0216949657,
-0.0043073348,
0.040936958,
-0.0424172282,
-0.0583890975,
-0.0071992418,
-0.0084304353,
0.0493156686,
0.0061829514,
0.0063607716,
0.0229289364,
-0.0351415575,
0.0460714884,
-0.0060912636,
-0.0494402759,
0.00382335,
-0.0012099697,
0.0447939038,
-0.0937373713,
-0.038396243,
-0.0136429658,
-0.0172187295,
-0.0308127012,
0.0000021799,
-0.0513862483,
-0.0196437221,
-0.0044616931,
-0.061506737,
-0.086218141,
-0.008046113,
-0.0291666053,
0.0175488163,
0.0028892118,
-0.0161173083,
-0.0168917384,
0.0412292592,
0.0547253676,
0.0891654715,
0.0760497451,
-0.0053196745,
-0.0238170158,
0.0150007801,
-0.0016960783,
0.0151680643,
-0.047207851,
0.0419159085,
0.0425716005,
0.0562677309,
-0.0156793948,
-0.0029271725,
-0.0074013388,
0.0034274689,
-0.0101855537,
-0.0134589532,
0.0313088149,
0.0200619716,
-0.035918016,
0.0098550478,
0.0962136537,
0.0196152404,
0.0079867896,
0.0305841062,
-0.0292895716,
0.0030205266,
0.0129973209,
-0.0307584908,
-0.014443622,
-0.0543155596,
-0.017322503,
0.0302173682,
-0.0233903732,
0.0274740681,
-0.0382686481,
-0.0282043479,
0.0435919128,
-0.0317198075,
-0.0125348838,
0.0352669582,
-0.0168792289,
-0.0101363799,
-0.0585631467,
0.0204009861,
0.0374478698,
-0.0944622979,
0.0121331653,
0.0238155667,
0.051212661,
0.0674712136,
-0.0550417192,
0.0177506097,
-0.0043827174,
0.0334066376,
0.0251633674,
0.0022437146,
-0.0194020942,
-0.0484016612,
0.0502489135,
-0.0362413414,
0.014068109,
-0.0466814227,
-0.0166199319,
-0.011865736,
-0.0015852943,
-0.0074573695,
0.0215550065,
-0.06596037,
0.0145974541,
-0.0279086139,
0.041503638,
0.0728406906,
0.0256217867,
0.0301426798,
0.0078080883,
-0.0504919849,
0.0021760315,
0.0003564244,
0.0044140937,
-0.0095699076,
0.0329932608,
0.0505853072,
0.0251868498,
0.0050338134,
0.0258839615,
0.0184223093,
0.0927047879,
0.0400805175,
0.0038693598,
-0.0073124571,
-0.0684716031,
-0.0262400769,
-0.0217655785,
0.0090171443,
-0.054411374,
0.0213851575,
0.0178915933,
0.0271245092,
-0.0019394644,
0.0124254664,
0.0321922936,
-0.0139509356,
0.0201078933,
-0.0768634453,
0.0194688085,
-0.0006926527,
0.0263808537,
-0.0052876896,
-0.0088783214,
0.0184051245,
0.0029037993,
-0.0002178893,
-0.0367292576,
0.0212673303,
-0.002214096,
-0.0234174859,
-0.0253861807,
0.0135108242,
0.0398883894,
-0.0689738318,
0.0455397703,
-0.053404171,
0.0273417681,
-0.0174408797,
-0.0265150797,
0.0243581031,
0.0397662185,
0.0610717535,
-0.0197913405,
0.0125161763,
-0.0342320986,
-0.013320501,
-0.0347127058,
0.0322660692,
0.0180810727,
-0.0047872411,
-0.0230543055,
-0.0815728605,
-0.0162925292,
-0.0099459114,
-0.0522770248,
-0.0524848849,
0.0015480006,
-0.0462460183,
-0.0071671885,
0.0065485658,
-0.0233404003,
-0.0161387473,
0.0563843362,
0.0246579628,
-0.0054440866,
-0.0987317041,
-0.0368534215,
-0.0064714556,
0.0775607526,
0.0405494049,
-0.0347221866,
-0.0247393474,
-0.0278102867,
0.0069285822,
-0.0240464676,
0.0171822011,
-0.0345802344,
-0.003276594,
-0.0244524442,
-0.0213859193,
0.0566304363,
0.0239604469,
-0.001996744,
-0.0296194889,
0.0186942536,
-0.0574023202,
-0.0159973409,
-0.0232355632,
0.0285373535,
-0.0260845907,
0.0010382414,
0.042125266,
-0.0031844571,
0.0497847758,
0.0377996974,
-0.0037991116,
0.0197638012,
0.036722485,
-0.0003603923,
-0.0497382917,
0.0325906165,
-0.0551090017,
-0.0404455513,
0.0180036891,
-0.0098389788,
-0.0312270205,
-0.0741993934,
-0.0545513853,
-0.0302696377,
-0.0545312874,
-0.0650606304,
0.0241845399,
0.0205876511,
0.0457565635,
0.0502453558,
-0.0370610319,
-0.0181642547,
0.0503032878,
-0.0184177309,
0.0187212266,
0.0186825823,
-0.0261552408,
0.0317946374,
-0.0207825173,
0.0179637242,
0.0247466881,
-0.0029266488,
0.0103421938,
-0.020891441,
0.0430933014,
-0.0180837475,
0.0263090897,
-0.0723806918,
-0.0113008395,
0.0299108848,
0.0074167312,
0.0221407954,
0.0016436265,
-0.0109754559,
-0.0313592404,
-0.025602866,
0.0447296649,
0.0495998338,
-0.0009326276,
0.0477112606,
0.037291687,
-0.0219511222,
0.0182675682,
0.00097387,
-0.0407105088,
0.0077225715,
0.0101858331,
-0.0147502348,
0.0149246333,
0.0329990536,
-0.0419090986,
0.0014052049,
0.0001060925,
0.0081581008,
0.0236758441,
-0.0283146091,
-0.032702066,
0.0313572809,
-0.0424670912,
0.0190734956,
0.0266757514,
-0.0157214198,
-0.0466902144,
0.0103474259,
-0.0155782485,
0.0163378604,
-0.018703714,
-0.0404471904,
0.01622287,
0.0615388341,
0.0267525222,
0.0317913815,
-0.0111368401,
-0.0252492167,
0.0191570949,
0.0464549661,
-0.0422050133,
-0.0150828566,
-0.0207411386,
0.054886736,
-0.0081179123,
-0.0275505148,
0.0921885669,
-0.0197623502,
0.0246121995,
-0.0505310297,
-0.0591988713,
-0.0815507025,
0.022750102,
0.0032211547,
0.0206004642,
-0.0032225198,
-0.0245885532,
0.0149179641,
-0.0088722762,
0.0277565885,
-0.0541594252,
0.0646015182,
-0.0448919833,
0.0275162831,
0.0076775136,
-0.02317168,
-0.0482942127,
0.0222445671,
-0.0032369795,
-0.0230453592,
0.0274882503,
0.0022243676,
-0.0597952865,
0.0428327471,
-0.0227496941,
0.0471832938,
0.0281115342,
-0.0240170229,
0.0066708745,
0.0010107283,
-0.0178029798,
0.0025408934,
-0.0024937103,
-0.0309664793,
0.0903483033,
0.0805392042,
-0.0620055534,
-0.0083403755,
-0.0168619473,
0.011574964,
-0.0334730409,
-0.033372853,
-0.0026593767,
0.0182356387,
0.0116229914,
-0.0535164773,
0.0179816168,
0.0749751702,
0.0193020701,
-0.0613626912,
0.0034732828,
-0.0335693508,
-0.0413694419,
-0.002155283,
0.0017736362,
-0.0758730397,
-0.0398393981,
-0.0171438996,
0.0271733422,
-0.0242189933,
-0.0371629074,
0.0308143981,
-0.0157797895,
0.040146891,
0.0105133345,
-0.0054070572,
-0.0387758277,
-0.0339212641,
-0.014145283,
-0.0179842338,
-0.0577319264,
-0.0266503897,
-0.000461464,
-0.0164330322,
-0.0153078604,
-0.1025649235,
-0.0489407182,
0.0379584916,
0.024357304,
0.0079210158,
0.0267371628,
0.0498061255,
0.0134137087,
0.0022382603,
-0.000850414,
-0.0123610189,
0.0191054251,
-0.0409444422,
0.0546481833,
0.0373016484,
0.0006498422,
-0.0549257137,
0.0008564943,
-0.0431409441,
-0.0154801877,
0.0440285392,
0.1059254482,
-0.0813410655,
-0.0505715795,
-0.0375328399,
0.0361857004,
0.0181397982,
0.0275382157,
-0.0100323968,
0.0251340307,
-0.0174094178,
-0.016243862,
0.0354733653,
0.0185965225,
-0.0240580011,
0.0328367688,
-0.0267833453,
-0.0131509118,
-0.0348700248,
0.0278642122,
0.0285613593,
0.0124559188,
0.0111298468,
0.0183311291,
-0.0146330548,
0.021493908,
-0.0156303048,
0.0250349622,
0.0418934561,
0.0443195328,
-0.051084742,
-0.0167305116,
0.0601295978,
0.0215871688,
-0.005338687,
0.0292497016,
0.03900069,
0.0028261591,
-0.0357843637,
0.0376358405,
0.0286932718,
-0.0111564081,
-0.0022250656,
0.0324161947,
0.0298550092,
0.0468350798,
-0.0165587608,
-0.0560285226,
-0.0055930885,
0.0233846996,
-0.0151976738,
-0.0222996902,
-0.011890905,
0.0428711772,
-0.0272436291,
0.0380818471,
-0.1013432369,
-0.0529662371,
0.0292565711,
0.0367362946,
0.001575417,
0.0356100015,
-0.0211709887,
-0.0134799695,
0.0480137989,
-0.0034658762,
-0.0013295586,
-0.0142933307,
0.0130948117,
0.00938763,
-0.057830926,
0.0150805293,
-0.0221527256,
-0.0391819291,
-0.0838307068,
-0.0274729636,
0.0799376518,
0.0732833147,
0.0087791281,
0.0399456285,
-0.0172369815,
0.0268410463,
-0.0201279279,
0.0036709397,
0.0247271787,
0.0248180833,
0.0915922448,
-0.0102894241,
0.0106085129,
0.0154172136,
0.0339479297,
-0.0376561545,
-0.0825718865,
0.0090064527,
0.0145532731,
0.0471029282,
0.0352292843,
0.0041533671,
-0.0490567386,
0.0256273467,
-0.0140482178,
0.0118633304,
-0.0020971764,
0.0014168327,
0.0526572429,
0.004421534,
-0.0097958362,
-0.0649128705,
0.0701234639,
-0.0082718246,
0.0014719187,
-0.0169880353,
-0.0728968382,
-0.0754216537,
-0.0557553992,
0.0307673588,
0.0288745109,
-0.0303028282,
-0.0063822367,
-0.0881295875,
-0.0496031046,
-0.0035775385,
-0.017201107,
0.0040232763,
-0.0257891156,
0.0342468657,
0.0072544618,
0.048102878,
-0.0141364001,
-0.0316201709,
0.0477990061,
-0.0466871038,
0.0159178302,
-0.0247560386,
-5.266514075e-33,
-0.003066248,
-0.0619159602,
0.0385310352,
-0.0024473125,
0.0198155325,
-0.0076362984,
-0.023746321,
-0.0024506531,
0.0122640571,
0.0379708782,
-0.0038917854,
-0.0062696105,
-0.0059367772,
0.0205299687,
0.0118685933,
-0.0298011545,
0.0147198429,
0.0286166873,
-0.0159162171,
0.0265895091,
0.0246003363,
0.0124391438,
0.0221065059,
-0.0734919682,
-0.0164484717,
0.0093845678,
0.0263714083,
0.0223538727,
-0.0712778941,
0.0631037205,
0.015532935,
0.0305633638,
0.0642604604,
0.0028190962,
-0.0235200841,
-0.010095316,
-0.0445193462,
-0.0441942662,
0.0002748074,
-0.0203026049,
-0.0453002639,
-0.0036985877,
0.0442078784,
-0.0038499509,
0.0316730104,
-0.0085297227,
0.0014899874,
-0.0544710681,
-0.0365707316,
-0.0177896917,
0.0308713578,
0.0793618038,
-0.0155800637,
0.0020383103,
-0.033630427,
0.0345483497,
-0.0197681561,
0.0000900561,
-0.017727498,
0.0230682809,
0.0134846438,
-0.033471141,
-0.0146019254,
-0.0360976569,
-0.0244709346,
0.0522117764,
-0.0105046583,
-0.0403297879,
-0.0180507004,
0.0384171829,
-0.106515035,
0.0987414718,
0.0504838265,
0.0012172281,
0.0027108719,
-0.0213767886,
-0.0679673329,
0.04263651,
-0.0618696101,
0.1008611992,
0.0055918102,
-0.0190101545,
-0.0456558652,
-0.029857086,
0.0130620645,
-0.0079509979,
-0.0104787629,
-0.0158673711,
0.0366257615,
-0.0107633444,
0.0199293084,
0.0028063739,
0.0031737047,
0.0078595262,
-0.010383809,
-0.0027792219,
0.0589133538,
0.0161920097,
-0.021131495,
-0.0099672219,
-0.0343472213,
-0.0323229097,
0.0149416188,
-0.0634307638,
0.0519744903,
0.0424524061,
0.0110070808,
-0.052956894,
-0.039655216,
0.003768058,
0.0233031008,
0.0075178361,
-0.058897689,
0.0632240772,
0.025279671,
0.0094653349,
-0.0156623628,
0.0785496905,
-0.0046122964,
-0.0029292891,
-0.0489777476,
-0.0571911223,
-0.0296061523,
-0.0180772897,
-0.0251050498,
-0.0205359422,
-0.014385445,
0.0547744446,
0.0419731252,
-0.0293610748,
0.0209023505,
0.0037203014,
2.923e-7,
0.0839977339,
0.0224689096,
-0.0001672935,
0.0392882898,
0.0646146908,
0.0117849037,
-0.0367113836,
-0.0203925669,
0.0047940821,
-0.0602440797,
0.0575797111,
-0.0144359553,
0.0206172876,
0.0716113076,
-0.056982182,
-0.0360419005,
-0.0587645508,
-0.0218749307,
-0.0322852246,
-0.0165946782,
0.0767664388,
0.036347799,
-0.0379338786,
-0.0294279512,
0.020259358,
0.0029243259,
0.0086059403,
-0.0561927408,
0.0330439918,
0.0092914887,
0.0679137781,
-0.020686334,
0.0188374929,
0.0805456191,
-0.0054406123,
-0.0062476378,
-0.0472169779,
0.076304771,
-0.0264579467,
0.0398850739,
0.0273560565,
-0.0270120446,
0.0527186394,
-0.001948568,
0.0573274419,
-0.0473896749,
-0.0479068384,
0.0133051928,
0.0160983615,
-0.0440910347,
0.0645553321,
0.0003698727,
-0.0186596904,
0.0319244452,
0.0056232861,
0.0286428109,
0.0039833034,
-0.0588475093,
-0.0161105078,
0.0165090263,
-0.0247475263,
-0.0412770212,
0.0412504487,
0.0067806272,
-0.0086489832,
-0.0395167246,
-0.0102915959,
2.897391996e-34,
0.0301362593,
0.0068633067,
-0.0096112499,
0.0230518505,
0.0528663844,
-0.0090314299,
0.0518083498,
0.0163324866,
0.0179010145,
-0.0575664453,
-0.0184957087
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.