id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16267v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16267v2 | Novel Preprocessing Technique for Data Embedding in Engineering Code Generation Using Large Language Model | 2023-11-27T19:17:39 | 2024-01-30T08:00:07 | Yu-Chen Lin, Akhilesh Kumar, Norman Chang, Wenliang Zhang, Muhammad Zakir, Rucha Apte, Haiyang He, Chao Wang, Jyh-Shing Roger Jang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SE | We present four main contributions to enhance the performance of Large
Language Models (LLMs) in generating domain-specific code: (i) utilizing
LLM-based data splitting and data renovation techniques to improve the semantic
representation of embeddings' space; (ii) introducing the Chain of Density for
Renovation Credibility (CoDRC), driven by LLMs, and the Adaptive Text
Renovation (ATR) algorithm for assessing data renovation reliability; (iii)
developing the Implicit Knowledge Expansion and Contemplation (IKEC) Prompt
technique; and (iv) effectively refactoring existing scripts to generate new
and high-quality scripts with LLMs. By using engineering simulation software
RedHawk-SC as a case study, we demonstrate the effectiveness of our data
pre-processing method for expanding and categorizing scripts. When combined
with IKEC, these techniques enhance the Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG)
method in retrieving more relevant information, ultimately achieving a 73.33%
"Percentage of Correct Lines" for code generation problems in MapReduce
applications. | [
-0.008335121,
0.0457571037,
-0.0326118022,
0.0196901187,
-0.0216901451,
-0.0304539353,
-0.0101381009,
-0.0080061629,
0.0291720256,
-0.0436165854,
0.0259149913,
0.0015133781,
-0.029731771,
0.0256077796,
0.0294468403,
0.0005775151,
0.0278569888,
-0.0111841755,
-0.0304741561,
0.0284234472,
-0.0337979719,
0.0063912184,
0.0485118851,
0.0333025493,
0.0165851936,
0.012827877,
-0.0290193856,
0.0137497401,
-0.0168077406,
-0.0253142752,
-0.0187088717,
0.0499223582,
0.0103359027,
0.0015974919,
0.0000024721,
-0.0415131301,
-0.050183434,
0.0369056277,
0.0135099199,
0.0321497694,
0.0328652821,
-0.0149171203,
-0.0052910144,
0.0420530364,
-0.0016709693,
-0.0251018517,
0.0361719318,
-0.0018136321,
0.0727299899,
0.0209814329,
0.0060564284,
-0.0568590425,
-0.0342952684,
0.0366845354,
0.0075958124,
0.0171735659,
0.0268034171,
0.0862325802,
0.0583061203,
0.0447090007,
0.004870153,
0.0225746837,
0.0235715732,
-0.0268653929,
0.0466340929,
0.0303213913,
-0.0148606235,
0.0331855118,
0.0068629663,
0.0220053792,
-0.0039759562,
-0.0171354264,
0.017299369,
-0.0113076894,
-0.0269540343,
0.0156678315,
-0.0344770104,
-0.0102641936,
0.0234240051,
-0.002692566,
-0.0241782051,
-0.0375249647,
-0.0033071386,
-0.0127229784,
-0.0575523525,
0.0268678181,
-0.0009464716,
-0.0371128581,
-0.0502524786,
-0.0238838531,
-0.009071202,
-0.0394626893,
-0.022970207,
0.0516856164,
0.0084851431,
0.0095093558,
-0.0118479608,
-0.0273649413,
0.0438333489,
-0.0451903194,
0.0607939214,
0.027281953,
0.0066512283,
-0.0049367263,
-0.0209939126,
0.0348757952,
-0.0003992904,
-0.0562669002,
-0.0380938537,
0.025082523,
-0.0525422581,
-0.041167073,
-0.0341077931,
0.0405218564,
0.0012698697,
0.0167814512,
-0.0088147642,
0.0765939727,
0.0052981838,
0.0441531874,
-0.00938778,
-0.0496511273,
0.0081595415,
-0.0004554164,
-0.0050346465,
-0.0416321792,
0.0329855159,
-0.0359063521,
-0.0263711084,
-0.0438036025,
-0.0075885281,
0.0214231648,
-0.001723765,
0.0192215089,
0.0058712321,
0.0429650098,
0.0164830498,
0.0119666969,
-0.0337377153,
-0.077095367,
0.015409017,
0.0183614474,
0.0048431666,
-0.0774847493,
-0.029133983,
-0.0004734157,
-0.0300703403,
-0.0270884316,
-0.0043835007,
-0.0026045821,
-0.026662929,
0.0287891645,
-0.06009835,
0.0682351515,
0.0315293968,
0.0158168767,
0.0222932473,
0.0213641413,
-0.0040422482,
0.0046834,
-0.0323435105,
-0.0419193134,
0.0386023633,
0.0100206304,
-0.0354366936,
-0.0095577957,
-0.0578496195,
0.0476871803,
0.0205114074,
-0.0026993658,
-0.0147292521,
0.002355925,
-0.0158443172,
0.0718829855,
0.0152748227,
0.0094748391,
0.045723401,
0.0488449186,
0.0771536008,
0.0797719359,
-0.0139460955,
-0.033730872,
0.0157734174,
-0.0088523291,
0.040909864,
0.0137478402,
0.0219455827,
0.0487836562,
0.0173129439,
-0.0206101164,
-0.0168403815,
0.0121658863,
-0.0429215841,
-0.0229910277,
0.0209623016,
0.0116287852,
-0.0463524051,
0.0047296635,
-0.0018482308,
-0.0506729446,
-0.0086284224,
-0.0131754214,
-0.0116828643,
0.0690076947,
0.0515266135,
-0.0629520491,
-0.0283047482,
0.0017477337,
0.0082301907,
-0.0362634324,
0.0558066331,
-0.0187488999,
-0.0329476185,
-0.0812210217,
-0.0421045646,
0.0046230019,
-0.005573479,
0.0055228816,
0.005552778,
-0.060039226,
0.0258357618,
-0.0205608979,
-0.0354661681,
0.0211749543,
-0.0026944831,
0.0177216437,
0.0137842409,
-0.009864267,
0.0096318284,
-0.005614649,
-0.0607211925,
0.0220928192,
0.0298929177,
-0.0045624902,
-0.0598596968,
-0.0348127149,
-0.0088224206,
-0.0032622889,
0.000491082,
0.0048254626,
0.0006877419,
-0.0467284396,
-0.0282334182,
-0.0105087096,
-0.0023455948,
-0.0284131225,
0.0314726308,
-0.0010382908,
0.0497218259,
-0.0535989068,
-0.0256292056,
-0.0820379853,
0.0337879136,
0.0078060855,
0.0060414444,
0.0331555642,
0.0308436565,
0.0183716845,
0.0066332067,
0.0098293712,
0.0297013745,
-0.0107173175,
0.0191612411,
0.0037938624,
0.0148948682,
-0.0025295538,
-0.0716812089,
-0.0596419685,
0.0123012597,
0.033713121,
0.0178478714,
0.0212844424,
0.0257733669,
-0.0059000147,
0.0156542175,
0.018952582,
0.0203368422,
-0.0116259977,
0.010637817,
0.0175049324,
-0.0389660224,
-0.0820889249,
0.0649448112,
-0.0177545901,
-0.0048353695,
0.0826486647,
0.0073157805,
0.0638591051,
-0.1284688264,
0.1153823882,
-0.013294396,
-0.0458619483,
-0.0029290144,
-0.0370336473,
-0.0236518253,
-0.0329424962,
0.1314495206,
-0.0346060619,
-0.0274172258,
-0.0094693117,
0.0419716872,
-0.0230046082,
-0.0480697975,
-0.0355826169,
-0.0031087829,
-0.0185474735,
0.0065905633,
-0.0221669842,
0.0463907383,
0.0177369416,
0.0072769541,
-0.0357854106,
-0.0172753986,
-0.0343729183,
0.0124025708,
0.0099817151,
-0.0221363287,
-0.0377006829,
0.0056489883,
0.0510830544,
0.0277378783,
-0.0668715015,
0.0724992454,
-0.0571039729,
0.0094772466,
-0.0589410178,
-0.0381910764,
-0.0387445241,
0.0000387193,
-0.018235242,
0.0220774785,
-0.0378458835,
-0.0080802329,
-0.0301253684,
0.038046848,
-0.0572680943,
-0.019952232,
0.0376780704,
0.0012285912,
-0.0107157491,
0.0073364913,
0.0037077568,
-0.050881587,
-0.0107909162,
0.0095899971,
-0.0045622038,
0.0586519241,
0.0336577035,
0.0318641104,
0.0287010614,
0.0303090308,
0.0167441163,
0.0547953174,
-0.0302812662,
0.0025801936,
-0.0173044689,
-0.0401119702,
-0.0294073597,
-0.0128355548,
0.0344578847,
0.0404961035,
-0.0002800385,
-0.0034808149,
0.0067409049,
-0.0935323462,
-0.0008577128,
0.0031918718,
0.0077057816,
0.0040553692,
0.0419378318,
-0.0360198356,
-0.0575842857,
0.0006219532,
0.0525239818,
0.018889999,
-0.0117561854,
0.0160885863,
-0.0165640879,
0.0662434846,
0.0552332848,
0.0587641485,
-0.0653676018,
0.0311459191,
0.0096264761,
0.0042528585,
-0.0182946138,
0.0007566912,
-0.0232664049,
-0.1422290355,
0.0842139348,
-0.0003438355,
-0.0119258091,
-0.0687558949,
-0.0713299438,
-0.0276799109,
0.0649934039,
-0.0774454921,
0.0605469234,
0.0016138722,
0.0097043142,
0.0028656563,
-0.0586387999,
-0.0801364779,
-0.0014885705,
0.0062224218,
0.0376518853,
0.0571247488,
0.0108596431,
0.0227322374,
0.028447412,
0.0518856421,
0.0330054574,
0.0401860215,
-0.0522980057,
0.0045236754,
0.0393955112,
-0.0208874624,
0.0038358523,
-0.0053951554,
-0.0274005607,
-0.0406760424,
0.0393050835,
0.1201933473,
-0.0631825849,
0.0142322648,
-0.0584948137,
-0.0184861738,
0.0512993596,
0.0153290406,
0.0505318381,
0.0047779712,
-0.0103292931,
-0.0344347432,
-0.0081135891,
0.0325388163,
-0.0062360582,
0.0139058186,
-0.0582317226,
-0.0026712872,
0.0021737285,
0.0153186992,
0.0517741442,
0.0552874655,
0.0462258682,
-0.0081483405,
0.0325148925,
-0.0316658206,
-0.0879481584,
-0.008077601,
-0.046827089,
0.0026313059,
0.0054056533,
0.0120656667,
0.0225499049,
-0.0467986166,
-0.0190786235,
-0.0073861126,
-0.0269981399,
-0.0735263079,
0.0331122242,
0.0255869776,
0.0140697006,
-0.0144053493,
0.0005895344,
-0.067976594,
0.0314524807,
-0.0068796342,
-0.0585592799,
0.0126929963,
-0.0366937481,
0.0202612523,
0.0292793252,
-0.031350024,
-0.0157220382,
0.0530569553,
-0.009023645,
-0.0222791154,
-0.0034584093,
-0.0018002139,
0.0018213616,
0.1012593955,
-0.0130650187,
0.009519659,
-0.0324871205,
-0.0084687714,
0.0085733952,
-0.0405857489,
-0.0485489517,
-0.0332389995,
0.0459411405,
-0.0130689181,
-0.0346303433,
0.0340704173,
0.0042382022,
0.0206228122,
0.0194078069,
0.0353705809,
0.0448193476,
-0.0094812326,
0.0372860022,
0.0836338326,
-0.0061734542,
-0.0139344046,
-0.0055117295,
-0.0108465543,
0.0049302611,
0.000178476,
0.0169959124,
0.0321862772,
-0.0029459966,
-0.0632228702,
-0.0137293637,
-0.0117904171,
-0.0626268312,
-0.0008294429,
-0.001119216,
0.0083557945,
0.066560097,
0.0199231301,
-0.0367356651,
0.0040058377,
-0.0077990228,
0.0481036492,
0.0138797555,
-0.0235562865,
0.027841052,
0.0127730547,
-0.051400438,
-0.0236336384,
0.055127956,
0.0291648619,
-0.027746005,
-0.0696787238,
-0.0382575579,
-0.0494244359,
0.0120883957,
0.0981444791,
0.003811765,
-0.0157766361,
-0.0256365146,
-0.0608958714,
-0.0330622308,
0.0047239293,
0.0190759022,
0.0008281557,
-0.0305989571,
0.0213235337,
0.0952366143,
0.0234026201,
0.0289929416,
-0.0230512209,
0.0418265127,
-0.025500644,
-0.0681998059,
0.0138152521,
-6.461013598e-33,
0.0040097246,
-0.0388628058,
0.0249782652,
-0.0004125624,
-0.0300342347,
0.0238415916,
-0.0126054185,
-0.0263611637,
0.0526681207,
-0.0309506282,
0.0325769186,
0.0253593698,
0.0051937867,
-0.0257203989,
0.0357369855,
0.0071906005,
0.0562441535,
0.0234864838,
-0.0332167521,
0.0106664225,
-0.0070093512,
0.030692013,
0.0116489241,
-0.0686072782,
-0.0325407237,
-0.0183564499,
0.0353880264,
-0.009076939,
0.0511273406,
-0.0005607689,
-0.0097771985,
0.0401226953,
-0.0188231748,
-0.0602242984,
-0.0325325355,
-0.0041670515,
0.0079462668,
-0.0115983803,
-0.0019069894,
-0.0340937674,
0.0201632343,
-0.0775747374,
0.0572167151,
-0.0077798786,
-0.0464059114,
0.0096384371,
0.0008011599,
-0.0047793272,
-0.0028483102,
0.0110934759,
-0.0544378571,
0.0304567628,
-0.011318963,
0.0289918091,
0.0228253789,
-0.0353349596,
0.0370449461,
0.068242833,
-0.0089686485,
0.0335961282,
0.0382790156,
0.0558732525,
0.0698214918,
-0.0141829252,
0.030116342,
0.0050759153,
0.018596435,
0.0444763452,
-0.010174674,
-0.0012564567,
0.0159842689,
0.0335669369,
-0.0400104448,
0.0617588386,
0.0246981438,
-0.0412278064,
-0.0460217297,
0.0314648896,
-0.052180618,
-0.0138109904,
0.0619421005,
0.0201833434,
-0.0335410237,
-0.0314261243,
-0.0346930735,
0.0446706004,
-0.0194821097,
-0.02968302,
0.022575479,
0.0073481789,
-0.0510743745,
0.0760541707,
0.0400918238,
-0.0224563163,
0.015149015,
0.0466468073,
-0.0649597272,
0.003163192,
-0.0170252752,
0.007760759,
-0.002100148,
-0.019689966,
0.0205290075,
-0.0235150121,
0.0370584428,
0.0329656601,
-0.0028831577,
0.0321883932,
-0.0869006738,
-0.0067179292,
-0.0267492719,
-0.0535103045,
-0.0307101794,
-0.0201214552,
0.002452353,
0.0047370475,
0.043740429,
0.0040831831,
0.0439568758,
-0.0444807187,
0.028717583,
0.0104087042,
0.0189725943,
0.0162116233,
0.0236270055,
0.0002729022,
-0.0489008352,
-0.0340503789,
0.0689968988,
-0.0226611905,
-0.0426178724,
0.0336980298,
3.418e-7,
0.0181245245,
0.0664808452,
-0.0109968446,
0.0088673495,
-0.0240894575,
0.0079776831,
0.0100404285,
-0.0520722643,
0.0385179259,
0.0336414054,
0.003593991,
0.0047344137,
0.0387689508,
0.012010322,
-0.0583550557,
-0.017626347,
-0.0192257427,
-0.0252931546,
-0.0833655074,
-0.0099586369,
0.0954171866,
0.0537603535,
-0.0047034314,
-0.005150686,
0.0034545693,
-0.0164021533,
-0.0159851238,
-0.0264106877,
0.0116868308,
0.0521198846,
-0.032798294,
-0.0040072771,
0.003030685,
0.0113589922,
-0.0070399558,
-0.0085871257,
0.018844258,
0.0588610098,
0.0178929605,
0.1043540314,
0.057066422,
-0.065733321,
-0.0345064327,
-0.0580205917,
0.0023336431,
-0.0431625247,
-0.0487941951,
-0.0105687845,
-0.0177384019,
-0.0519239232,
-0.0067697619,
-0.0225808807,
0.0390015729,
0.0100950943,
-0.0349325538,
0.0019781941,
-0.0080007352,
-0.0190078951,
-0.0399970226,
0.004695165,
-0.0556460507,
-0.0447680987,
0.0016061214,
0.005459195,
0.0448478647,
-0.0331801325,
0.0353853516,
4.06434886e-34,
0.0028805684,
-0.0150288297,
0.0199698173,
0.0423445031,
0.0480051339,
-0.0078365998,
-0.0021184231,
0.0382410176,
-0.0255024135,
-0.0573166609,
-0.012230821
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16258v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16258v1 | An Exploration of Left-Corner Transformations | 2023-11-27T19:04:37 | 2023-11-27T19:04:37 | Andreas Opedal, Eleftheria Tsipidi, Tiago Pimentel, Ryan Cotterell, Tim Vieira | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.DS, cs.FL | The left-corner transformation (Rosenkrantz and Lewis, 1970) is used to
remove left recursion from context-free grammars, which is an important step
towards making the grammar parsable top-down with simple techniques. This paper
generalizes prior left-corner transformations to support semiring-weighted
production rules and to provide finer-grained control over which left corners
may be moved. Our generalized left-corner transformation (GLCT) arose from
unifying the left-corner transformation and speculation transformation (Eisner
and Blatz, 2007), originally for logic programming. Our new transformation and
speculation define equivalent weighted languages. Yet, their derivation trees
are structurally different in an important way: GLCT replaces left recursion
with right recursion, and speculation does not. We also provide several
technical results regarding the formal relationships between the outputs of
GLCT, speculation, and the original grammar. Lastly, we empirically investigate
the efficiency of GLCT for left-recursion elimination from grammars of nine
languages. | [
-0.0068742712,
-0.0082885968,
-0.0276918542,
0.0640662834,
-0.0544934794,
0.0121146906,
-0.0230585504,
-0.0266904961,
-0.0653812289,
-0.0148472562,
-0.0389994606,
-0.0029856011,
-0.0083945896,
0.0175204054,
-0.0201917607,
-0.0268000644,
0.0334415548,
-0.0526316464,
-0.0427657999,
0.0435983874,
-0.0116514731,
0.0038976131,
-0.0055544116,
-0.0328136869,
-0.0310860164,
-0.038100075,
0.0098848073,
0.0158809274,
-0.0011201849,
0.0110368924,
-0.0339677371,
-0.0142026357,
-0.0882159397,
0.027680343,
0.0000022519,
-0.009488035,
-0.0506806187,
0.0372216888,
-0.0066146846,
0.0258134473,
0.041524969,
0.0062309462,
-0.0517643802,
0.0190603379,
-0.0417273492,
0.0174780693,
0.0271365289,
0.0018575711,
0.023474209,
0.0819530934,
-0.0085520484,
-0.0840024501,
-0.0392754562,
0.0049303053,
-0.0088240514,
-0.0307641979,
0.0187398326,
-0.0478164852,
-0.0277540851,
-0.0861090347,
-0.035057541,
-0.0402543619,
-0.0035844862,
-0.0476075076,
-0.0356073938,
-0.0113575682,
-0.0419972688,
-0.0140228206,
0.0078110993,
0.0034579651,
0.0192183666,
-0.0461882502,
0.0195941944,
0.0130105279,
-0.0015589914,
-0.0302578863,
-0.0571867153,
0.0720401928,
0.020070605,
0.0290406123,
0.0425153412,
-0.0558761433,
-0.0063318056,
-0.0594781525,
-0.0529514253,
0.1256340742,
0.043599911,
-0.0531087629,
-0.0639949292,
-0.0208292231,
0.015501014,
-0.0531257838,
-0.0092642885,
0.0065052672,
0.0141482679,
0.0130527001,
0.0040399632,
0.0025167749,
-0.0157352854,
-0.025405081,
-0.0246518143,
0.04105803,
0.0350115299,
0.0025648875,
-0.014979125,
-0.0163159575,
-0.0060964436,
-0.0128971627,
-0.0418719761,
0.0204592533,
-0.0004625905,
-0.0159196034,
-0.0424245857,
0.025407264,
-0.0431253724,
0.0352558494,
-0.0411665589,
0.0270320885,
-0.0406728201,
0.0079364507,
0.0187507067,
-0.038261082,
0.0097272135,
0.0068927133,
0.0343736485,
0.034743689,
0.0210289452,
-0.0434216261,
-0.0158685707,
-0.003509698,
-0.0177289471,
0.0694104135,
-0.0126485154,
-0.0177405737,
-0.0391391329,
0.0802194029,
0.0067386162,
0.0375568643,
-0.0144893061,
-0.0558466688,
0.0186818596,
0.0125779919,
0.0172380786,
-0.0462314039,
-0.0370597728,
-0.0164205674,
-0.0327757709,
-0.0012983629,
-0.0394209251,
0.0213005673,
0.0192044564,
-0.0011222821,
-0.0200449247,
0.0075731948,
-0.057270471,
-0.031832464,
-0.0223430246,
0.0288887005,
0.0068103997,
0.0169490501,
0.0048476718,
-0.0276291911,
-0.0171504579,
0.0378497317,
-0.029772047,
-0.0443947688,
-0.0072886315,
0.0074787154,
0.0271776095,
-0.0141311502,
0.0240799002,
0.0456829667,
-0.0257191733,
-0.018045146,
-0.0404435545,
-0.0057586525,
0.040172752,
0.0126988264,
0.0497645102,
0.0053576734,
-0.0484001897,
0.0200204998,
-0.0389119834,
-0.0264300443,
-0.0903911218,
0.0050929911,
-0.0880517215,
-0.0102845039,
0.0233570747,
-0.0581063628,
-0.0189910773,
0.0060038487,
0.0416407883,
-0.0661628842,
0.0501805171,
0.0551323481,
-0.0238380916,
0.0304983687,
-0.0132114952,
-0.0574033372,
-0.0297995042,
-0.0597091839,
0.0252391305,
-0.0225496572,
0.0221237931,
-0.0442354605,
-0.0320985317,
0.0487272404,
0.0138413701,
0.0238643531,
0.0165030658,
-0.0025838085,
-0.0133335479,
0.0048142741,
0.0011599098,
0.0479259379,
0.0010402291,
0.0555830188,
-0.025766151,
-0.0123922369,
0.0031597014,
-0.0003994307,
0.0247064233,
-0.0031079769,
0.0507167652,
-0.0125234704,
0.0337113962,
0.025163386,
0.030858621,
-0.0020870203,
-0.0183421597,
0.0572484918,
0.0507821478,
0.0046360828,
-0.0388515405,
0.0648803562,
-0.027126506,
-0.0726378039,
0.0451962873,
-0.0272343643,
-0.0209979918,
-0.0361390673,
-0.0239846874,
0.0024639701,
0.1318175495,
0.0105778147,
0.101669021,
-0.0067916373,
0.0627763197,
0.0472686999,
-0.0288381111,
-0.0298511703,
0.0767060667,
0.009929467,
0.0241329521,
-0.000982632,
-0.035554219,
0.0252369698,
-0.0129948156,
0.009349755,
0.0009693953,
-0.0259893294,
-0.0551193729,
0.0020949922,
0.0540682934,
-0.0067408574,
-0.0116790347,
0.0219096746,
0.0468589738,
-0.0310146194,
0.098002024,
0.0258211568,
0.0498742834,
0.001670884,
0.007364382,
-0.0026147154,
0.0058039771,
0.0091811828,
0.0283582695,
0.0264191758,
-0.0028784536,
-0.0473198891,
0.0276390705,
-0.0153971268,
-0.0487124361,
0.000622821,
-0.0590986051,
0.0001518237,
-0.007556444,
0.0111329742,
-0.0375164039,
0.0537485555,
0.0014757366,
0.0155176204,
0.0145801716,
-0.0284857769,
0.0115366047,
-0.0068451473,
-0.0283753667,
-0.0114322761,
-0.0150935818,
0.0020194862,
0.0178077631,
0.0116661079,
0.021603046,
-0.0363311805,
0.0150234643,
0.0238751043,
0.0079103941,
0.0941840932,
-0.0064410334,
-0.0174285024,
-0.033893466,
0.021923393,
0.0031006809,
0.0068786005,
0.0237316247,
-0.0383260809,
-0.0194915943,
0.049049031,
-0.0256096888,
-0.0227049273,
0.0345871598,
0.002789811,
-0.0300507341,
0.0080920747,
0.014553668,
-0.0809334591,
0.0106416913,
0.0161641594,
0.0194275174,
0.0288350713,
-0.0349432118,
0.0090239439,
0.0054430743,
0.0793743432,
-0.0074906466,
-0.0259109065,
-0.0412141234,
0.0116894869,
-0.0462809205,
-0.0468829907,
-0.000422181,
0.0554917119,
0.0399615839,
-0.0201927517,
0.0098916879,
0.0110684372,
0.0698385313,
0.0247940607,
-0.0217728913,
-0.0227127206,
0.0310452171,
-0.0029036726,
0.0149787925,
0.0142404865,
-0.0360604338,
-0.0491137169,
-0.0198000129,
0.0315305516,
0.0095420899,
0.059469372,
0.005950015,
0.0100979777,
0.0126417782,
-0.0079475893,
0.0282767396,
-0.022949947,
-0.0879416391,
0.0295328386,
-0.022887649,
-0.0244210456,
0.0021562728,
0.0686208829,
0.0389328226,
-0.0153760901,
0.0340609103,
-0.054291375,
0.0122637488,
0.0295409113,
0.0278887749,
-0.1209408417,
-0.0180041082,
0.0131911887,
0.0029253587,
0.0188234635,
-0.020496238,
0.0155263254,
-0.1163808405,
0.0669386163,
-0.0003950284,
0.0073394692,
-0.0119946441,
-0.0309831984,
-0.0037128835,
-0.0253077671,
-0.0839791819,
0.0520146787,
-0.0394310728,
0.0115315057,
0.0173785202,
-0.0653786808,
0.0369858779,
-0.0212925635,
0.0129427258,
-0.0282735564,
0.0489474982,
0.0039958865,
0.0064731757,
-0.0527364165,
0.0248312838,
0.0022945465,
0.0044623292,
-0.0709465891,
-0.065569073,
0.0131377224,
-0.0105166202,
0.0145797255,
0.0250294805,
-0.0336397626,
-0.025130501,
0.0163199082,
0.0727847144,
0.0363345556,
-0.0530991778,
-0.0105866892,
-0.0235350281,
0.0174635537,
0.0612886474,
0.0064073638,
0.0466521159,
-0.0445664749,
-0.059025757,
-0.0726588443,
0.0269729253,
-0.0269821063,
-0.0415833145,
0.0195629541,
-0.0362154059,
-0.0373350866,
0.0334592611,
0.0147973653,
0.008616236,
-0.0388271846,
-0.0032046007,
0.0218761563,
-0.0394411571,
-0.0547976159,
-0.033759959,
-0.056019403,
0.0454515181,
-0.0328968614,
0.0296428036,
0.0397465341,
0.0281709339,
-0.0229111146,
-0.0268169809,
0.0328966491,
-0.0685153902,
-0.0323000997,
0.0658304468,
0.0198186543,
0.0180346556,
-0.0263380464,
0.0419738851,
-0.0728798211,
0.0717151463,
0.0220482219,
0.025403725,
0.0348493382,
0.0014611349,
0.0372718088,
0.0206507333,
0.0109285694,
0.0386994667,
0.0244040359,
0.0112817409,
-0.0615067743,
0.0154352523,
0.011198625,
0.1122414097,
0.0350514352,
0.0313779451,
-0.0228995942,
0.0115432702,
0.0115364343,
-0.0990088433,
-0.0255879946,
-0.0186310615,
0.0380011089,
-0.0115138525,
-0.0005218601,
-0.016795665,
0.0190022439,
-0.0033458914,
-0.0296469983,
-0.0084316395,
0.0392590612,
0.0010160102,
0.0047181239,
0.0111259017,
0.0092462618,
0.0345025472,
-0.0052716383,
0.0142247332,
0.06437736,
-0.0147944093,
-0.0454236045,
0.0396259427,
0.0333779715,
-0.0182709657,
0.003742272,
-0.0011755093,
-0.0278711244,
-0.0018153279,
0.0099136205,
0.0117080342,
0.0145460563,
0.0635102317,
-0.004854376,
0.0089380248,
-0.0082042553,
0.0313569456,
0.0208174996,
-0.0644326732,
-0.0184062757,
0.0119124809,
-0.0076732114,
-0.0257122852,
0.0724197254,
-0.0158732887,
0.0159941837,
-0.0221759696,
-0.0103259105,
-0.062554352,
-0.063960053,
-0.0035481607,
-0.0216670036,
0.0325812325,
0.0043421644,
-0.0865438133,
-0.0619221479,
-0.0354727432,
0.0431901254,
0.0511102304,
-0.0102048609,
0.0739762038,
0.041110035,
0.0326200612,
-0.0647996441,
-0.0012529899,
0.02763368,
0.0137124266,
-0.0551510975,
0.0089805154,
-5.836300799e-33,
-0.0317987241,
0.0595811419,
0.0377697945,
0.0524127372,
-0.0242578052,
-0.0515400879,
0.0057617808,
0.0258744955,
0.0357602201,
-0.025147466,
-0.0024446477,
-0.0116948606,
0.0064893253,
-0.0378949679,
-0.0181491021,
0.0411502942,
-0.0009703446,
-0.0085419891,
-0.0362969376,
-0.0229665507,
0.0488589033,
0.0059533538,
0.0858086795,
0.0059652459,
-0.0370231681,
-0.0132520376,
-0.0149097648,
0.0705132037,
-0.0482922904,
0.0102784373,
-0.0006298313,
-0.0367063843,
0.006558443,
-0.0089583425,
-0.0322135612,
0.0036456774,
-0.0385733731,
-0.0438339822,
0.0255397148,
0.0161413662,
-0.0026693251,
-0.0322647505,
0.0565428473,
0.034076903,
-0.0422443748,
0.0458692126,
-0.0216163751,
0.0073869978,
-0.0043941014,
0.0350937545,
-0.101721637,
0.0339291878,
-0.015927162,
-0.0204098225,
0.0027694239,
0.0188216139,
-0.025857091,
-0.0197212379,
-0.0291257929,
0.017870849,
0.0235626698,
0.018403247,
0.0465871543,
-0.034778811,
0.0136571852,
-0.0125148278,
0.0333189592,
0.0011923811,
0.0130022336,
0.0373194553,
-0.0248995833,
0.0432515554,
-0.026130924,
0.0142716626,
0.1014889628,
-0.0258966424,
-0.0663959011,
0.0459027588,
0.001167406,
0.0721157864,
-0.0327230245,
0.0449456647,
-0.0234408174,
-0.0366487354,
0.0096211378,
0.0064557847,
-0.0098790675,
0.0061110924,
0.0178838428,
-0.0221353751,
-0.0688240677,
0.0315392725,
0.0048874342,
-0.0035819712,
0.0108118244,
0.0196745824,
-0.0124509288,
0.0002976029,
-0.0150703266,
-0.0081709037,
0.0511436351,
-0.0234992653,
-0.0242192149,
-0.002430792,
0.0495298319,
0.0039344504,
0.0264938325,
0.0397010669,
-0.0258907098,
-0.0150007717,
-0.033242166,
0.0029378738,
-0.0173923206,
0.0608952045,
-0.006551635,
0.0315400325,
0.0156323798,
-0.0163219944,
0.0133039067,
-0.0101148654,
-0.0224436652,
-0.0011829454,
0.0397073515,
0.0188487209,
-0.0209319051,
-0.0501464047,
0.0129322745,
0.0498010963,
0.0761259496,
-0.0221336782,
-0.0478124432,
0.036644049,
3.145e-7,
0.0733121336,
-0.0171641186,
0.085818395,
0.0926774889,
0.0469243824,
0.0096096024,
0.0459702462,
0.0406367593,
0.0494214818,
0.0409523435,
-0.0276928768,
0.0084829899,
-0.0317334905,
-0.0146277212,
-0.020432584,
-0.0099001126,
-0.0023776018,
-0.0433777608,
0.0152966706,
0.0039539421,
0.0306583885,
0.009546008,
-0.0040856032,
0.0018230521,
-0.0064428747,
0.0444022864,
0.0292108394,
0.0064901793,
0.0157351438,
-0.024892563,
0.0001446419,
-0.0183428768,
0.0095469281,
-0.0352767594,
0.012864125,
0.003253605,
-0.0461374857,
0.0123056285,
-0.0419602394,
0.0591218993,
0.0589246713,
-0.0564012192,
-0.023149861,
0.0697818846,
0.0476343185,
-0.0252121016,
-0.0166129917,
0.0102461474,
-0.0699296221,
0.0052900491,
-0.0254538283,
0.0093089258,
-0.0328123868,
0.0233695228,
0.0465896092,
-0.0131758843,
-0.0638689473,
-0.0051320931,
0.0015655598,
-0.006872904,
-0.0028882937,
-0.0225466527,
0.002057706,
0.0643862188,
-0.0393863581,
-0.0463124812,
-0.0384406187,
3.005342555e-34,
0.061476294,
0.0055744518,
0.0308362637,
0.0084747281,
0.0277720913,
-0.0191417299,
0.0049756295,
-0.004143103,
-0.0248593837,
-0.0667712167,
-0.0285852887
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16254v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16254v2 | Safe-CLIP: Removing NSFW Concepts from Vision-and-Language Models | 2023-11-27T19:02:17 | 2024-04-12T09:37:37 | Samuele Poppi, Tobia Poppi, Federico Cocchi, Marcella Cornia, Lorenzo Baraldi, Rita Cucchiara | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.MM | Large-scale vision-and-language models, such as CLIP, are typically trained
on web-scale data, which can introduce inappropriate content and lead to the
development of unsafe and biased behavior. This, in turn, hampers their
applicability in sensitive and trustworthy contexts and could raise significant
concerns in their adoption. Our research introduces a novel approach to
enhancing the safety of vision-and-language models by diminishing their
sensitivity to NSFW (not safe for work) inputs. In particular, our methodology
seeks to sever "toxic" linguistic and visual concepts, unlearning the linkage
between unsafe linguistic or visual items and unsafe regions of the embedding
space. We show how this can be done by fine-tuning a CLIP model on synthetic
data obtained from a large language model trained to convert between safe and
unsafe sentences, and a text-to-image generator. We conduct extensive
experiments on the resulting embedding space for cross-modal retrieval,
text-to-image, and image-to-text generation, where we show that our model can
be remarkably employed with pre-trained generative models. Our source code and
trained models are available at: https://github.com/aimagelab/safe-clip. | [
0.0417506248,
0.077486001,
0.0073128487,
0.0355490968,
-0.0103070652,
0.0076823602,
0.0199205596,
0.0280470569,
0.0153547758,
-0.0388120115,
-0.0659093335,
-0.030285703,
-0.0203167181,
0.0733577982,
0.0329482108,
-0.063743785,
0.0406111963,
0.000443107,
-0.0042982874,
0.0248334594,
0.0424307846,
0.0101503357,
0.0480587892,
0.0450939201,
-0.0211642794,
0.0008620626,
0.0419440679,
0.0310603846,
0.0289010387,
0.0042411308,
0.0395598114,
0.0423151627,
0.0234975908,
0.0005609847,
0.0000017187,
0.0084735043,
0.0141969956,
0.0294931661,
0.046266485,
-0.0131091233,
0.0609923825,
-0.0587244667,
-0.0262241699,
0.026905166,
-0.0300257206,
0.0128274495,
0.0624620095,
0.0592961721,
0.087426886,
0.0461274795,
-0.0339911431,
0.0390312038,
-0.0090196598,
-0.0254728179,
0.0316093341,
-0.0119433068,
0.0418091975,
-0.0177472159,
-0.0161412731,
0.0516158268,
-0.032092303,
0.0431959964,
-0.0042362898,
-0.0130102923,
0.0092803584,
0.0363620743,
-0.0201963875,
-0.0884934515,
0.0044537694,
0.067866832,
-0.0792289674,
-0.014058413,
0.0099573368,
0.0023649733,
0.0130221583,
0.016041236,
-0.0483793207,
0.0425151698,
0.0013369616,
0.0193922967,
-0.0565645657,
-0.007616214,
0.0252560824,
0.0302214548,
0.0554550514,
-0.0138280485,
0.0283577256,
-0.0066505107,
0.0120724784,
-0.0093983309,
-0.0180105157,
-0.0324958302,
0.0531645827,
-0.0147976996,
0.0240442213,
0.0192007143,
-0.0722250566,
-0.011788954,
0.0220447965,
-0.0534803085,
0.024471242,
0.0093756467,
-0.0516830385,
0.0501751117,
-0.036629159,
0.0076220524,
-0.0079564713,
0.0572790839,
-0.0202400461,
0.0111749386,
0.0158664975,
-0.0175107308,
-0.0087265493,
-0.0210822336,
-0.0664708242,
-0.0186839998,
-0.0382979587,
0.0079758894,
-0.0632029101,
-0.0352386534,
0.0175961908,
0.0593442135,
-0.0648728162,
0.0108522242,
-0.0044726147,
-0.0243581757,
-0.0068649338,
0.027809497,
0.0061525824,
-0.0554530211,
-0.0043160371,
0.008306236,
0.0195782818,
-0.0094080027,
-0.003126516,
0.077783972,
-0.0280311387,
-0.0140155917,
-0.0465939194,
-0.046520032,
-0.0464749299,
-0.0122778183,
0.0409282222,
-0.0447062515,
0.0193402413,
-0.0507924259,
-0.0201772992,
-0.0823073536,
0.0342740305,
0.0591329597,
-0.0746403411,
0.0821678489,
0.0097911833,
-0.038340047,
-0.0072082626,
0.0616994984,
-0.0206160117,
0.0607622638,
0.0131883211,
0.0728109255,
0.0346945301,
0.0089813583,
0.0088087823,
0.0358553715,
0.0349796899,
0.0110007273,
-0.0723984987,
-0.0048642186,
0.0181509703,
-0.0123508936,
0.0262113791,
0.0808914229,
-0.0512367897,
-0.0488948226,
0.0653727353,
0.0438440517,
-0.0047259005,
0.0628084168,
0.0520676933,
0.0086556366,
-0.0119610457,
-0.0153676476,
-0.0828841776,
0.0191309713,
-0.016406538,
-0.0222916324,
-0.0032053282,
0.0431985632,
-0.0337124877,
-0.0047700442,
0.0299383979,
-0.0123625677,
0.0358194299,
-0.0269732624,
0.0210189819,
0.0484631024,
-0.0649933666,
-0.0077588302,
0.0313567072,
-0.0683285519,
0.0266579464,
-0.0381203964,
-0.0092405844,
0.0416285433,
0.0326020122,
0.0073857778,
-0.0185696445,
-0.0353227295,
0.00156715,
0.0091307024,
-0.031874869,
0.0012032849,
0.0111119896,
-0.0375984572,
-0.0664423704,
-0.0034766151,
0.0047187246,
0.0018097655,
0.0270156246,
0.0101468163,
0.0458045863,
-0.0117046162,
-0.0270103496,
0.0369806774,
0.0003995003,
-0.0091832699,
-0.028784845,
0.0261965599,
0.0028513947,
-0.028982589,
-0.0228507482,
0.0144551918,
0.024262609,
-0.0184462164,
-0.0066574099,
0.0131647084,
-0.0412456132,
0.0066203717,
0.0172264148,
-0.1030199975,
0.0180569291,
0.0355832316,
-0.0291227419,
0.0076476084,
0.0035052677,
-0.0311318841,
0.0029965444,
-0.0686611608,
-0.0165836848,
-0.0015389354,
0.0054203724,
0.0003161472,
0.048495423,
-0.0204396602,
-0.0227052961,
0.0055384673,
-0.0192550309,
-0.0033866833,
0.0015459473,
-0.0364532024,
-0.0215990432,
-0.0493923686,
0.0483229794,
0.0330993682,
0.0062712561,
-0.0599223152,
-0.0330366269,
-0.0432713069,
-0.0156074408,
0.0033397607,
-0.0043963064,
0.0062000141,
-0.0058731507,
-0.0138671752,
-0.034314435,
-0.0305992905,
-0.0051751444,
0.0067665782,
0.0606381968,
-0.0101196701,
-0.0117097013,
0.0231892951,
-0.0201761276,
-0.0162279401,
0.0125455018,
0.0526132099,
-0.0000546073,
-0.0247386433,
-0.0032557584,
0.0804860592,
-0.0362888053,
0.0463965759,
-0.0041969577,
-0.0429259799,
-0.0013990953,
0.0048904801,
0.0057834531,
0.0669448376,
0.0293825138,
0.0232961047,
0.0249525532,
0.0004366789,
-0.0406058989,
-0.0127190202,
-0.005911659,
-0.0115284072,
0.0229023527,
-0.0264428388,
-0.0038903062,
0.0057271323,
0.0082974434,
-0.0103774723,
-0.0683821067,
0.0799870491,
-0.0189429857,
-0.0567168258,
-0.0613818467,
-0.0223443564,
-0.0261124074,
0.0189006627,
-0.0472172685,
-0.0465578623,
0.0196023136,
0.0092635239,
0.023712419,
0.0315680876,
-0.0101582799,
0.0186386518,
0.0396488123,
-0.0072352551,
0.0516781062,
0.043548733,
-0.0252099894,
-0.0861098096,
0.0129618039,
0.0320793875,
-0.0478996634,
0.0090889325,
-0.0032746734,
-0.0036576453,
-0.0187926311,
-0.0676097795,
-0.0706434846,
-0.0569675416,
0.0127113489,
-0.0154703697,
-0.0043186806,
-0.0040648468,
-0.0237616748,
0.0282432958,
-0.0056038839,
0.0075553665,
-0.0288773607,
-0.0018333987,
-0.0018595089,
0.0447504595,
0.0835811272,
-0.0507552847,
-0.0304940585,
-0.0038007786,
-0.0477648973,
0.1069927737,
-0.0090485141,
-0.0043697516,
-0.0235499144,
0.0353985727,
0.0114961006,
0.0378740653,
-0.0059646741,
0.0206905138,
0.0224093795,
-0.0287247673,
-0.0314159282,
0.0265671834,
0.0064126495,
-0.0298967902,
-0.0261859689,
0.0404299162,
0.011691412,
0.0081698475,
0.0121201091,
-0.0626164824,
-0.0117476517,
-0.0001438667,
-0.0002286013,
-0.0175892338,
-0.0133297462,
-0.0004460578,
-0.0794041231,
0.0497381762,
0.0129283927,
-0.0168452654,
-0.0625828281,
-0.0018133052,
0.0219931863,
0.0004062361,
-0.0057386733,
-0.0148102222,
-0.0367313549,
-0.0060295523,
-0.0042316429,
0.0466276146,
-0.0659064054,
0.00267453,
-0.0332983769,
0.0153184477,
0.0479673892,
0.0497614145,
-0.0064380853,
-0.061046537,
0.0293328017,
0.0089762537,
-0.0119880987,
0.0116817113,
0.0711054951,
-0.0339972861,
-0.0159481671,
-0.0176807977,
0.0515391827,
0.0311014187,
-0.03711183,
-0.03486754,
0.0495305099,
0.0096732574,
-0.023278594,
-0.0824658722,
0.0411574915,
0.0285989791,
0.0757612213,
0.0273880195,
-0.0577568002,
0.004594224,
-0.0379896164,
0.017412426,
-0.0159710795,
-0.0546096116,
0.0053196051,
-0.0032959471,
-0.013766598,
-0.0807665139,
-0.0055756727,
0.0092837643,
0.0254896842,
0.0163834002,
-0.0502799861,
-0.0321792848,
0.0044826069,
-0.0366978645,
0.0562693253,
-0.0276356693,
-0.0081090368,
-0.0213599112,
0.0540931933,
-0.0012445931,
-0.0384506993,
-0.0416359529,
0.0447907411,
-0.0732233226,
-0.0392442755,
-0.0190040618,
0.0951385275,
0.0195666924,
0.0111145191,
-0.0011902382,
-0.0106928498,
0.0892886445,
0.1034815833,
-0.0411570296,
-0.0316160396,
0.0456024557,
-0.0281462334,
0.0095795384,
0.0292340312,
-0.051278796,
-0.004883369,
0.0373364687,
0.0023384269,
0.0046006883,
-0.0252497792,
0.0140439859,
-0.0206074789,
0.0325320624,
-0.0268264133,
0.0315876193,
-0.048310291,
-0.0355647989,
-0.0038304881,
-0.0102089709,
-0.058477506,
0.0501373708,
0.0555326305,
-0.0046383538,
-0.011192725,
0.0160248652,
-0.0105479918,
0.0556361787,
-0.0531606898,
-0.0316374041,
0.0413980894,
0.0024169479,
0.0064876876,
0.0227989405,
-0.0175649077,
0.0312649161,
-0.0230259113,
-0.000667092,
-0.0327429138,
0.0408522561,
0.0123172142,
0.0000443506,
-0.0301642604,
0.046986267,
-0.0345742144,
-0.0090986155,
-0.0825076699,
0.0213169269,
-0.0057036816,
-0.0076867598,
0.0187537204,
-0.0255534239,
-0.0512967817,
-0.0208387561,
0.0165204331,
-0.0045704478,
-0.0386766978,
0.0507024974,
-0.0029794276,
0.0047778646,
-0.0276287775,
0.0763375387,
-0.011616773,
0.0412782393,
0.0221880749,
-0.0475826673,
-0.0393953621,
-0.0033623795,
0.0404399298,
-0.0094219893,
-0.0235970616,
0.0091404486,
-0.0338691622,
-0.0858049393,
-0.0048502996,
0.0072039207,
-0.004991286,
0.0341419578,
0.0442713499,
0.0375809371,
0.0137612177,
0.0144126276,
0.0053066113,
-0.0084703239,
0.0291168224,
-0.0231867824,
-0.0191774946,
-5.870483808e-33,
0.0080279401,
-0.0046331561,
-0.0044867867,
0.017715821,
-0.0194220841,
0.0214827955,
0.0050456673,
-0.0003527539,
0.0124553517,
0.0173321329,
-0.0077956403,
0.0096158003,
-0.005784458,
0.018505957,
-0.0295527056,
-0.0053086216,
0.0435748436,
-0.0077948533,
-0.0295052677,
0.037946675,
0.0286002588,
0.0419522896,
0.0185710955,
-0.0919665322,
0.0186924785,
0.0109445285,
-0.0602186993,
-0.0002402375,
0.0460668877,
0.0584916584,
-0.013483284,
0.0269061998,
-0.0019137755,
-0.0258610938,
-0.0182223208,
0.0900941044,
-0.069507964,
-0.0021447218,
0.0057603968,
-0.0227879304,
-0.0756276399,
-0.0385154262,
0.0602834262,
-0.0431555733,
0.0348323323,
-0.0525184385,
0.0238829721,
-0.0305863395,
-0.0151334992,
-0.0214908496,
-0.049060788,
-0.0017744066,
0.000553242,
-0.050384555,
0.0528306738,
0.0762282088,
0.029722387,
-0.0084602479,
-0.0281915087,
0.0216336232,
0.0128524136,
-0.0054204622,
0.0573421158,
0.005777393,
0.0059838551,
0.086646542,
-0.0263056681,
-0.0021130671,
-0.0010143073,
-0.0599210449,
0.0377366617,
0.0662062019,
0.0095065003,
0.0627989024,
0.0253891665,
-0.0270112008,
-0.0584259443,
0.031526342,
-0.0577532463,
0.0567411967,
0.0191749856,
0.0103183407,
0.0196334366,
0.0041202619,
-0.0396903083,
-0.0501262583,
-0.0481461436,
-0.0276371054,
0.0469012707,
0.029193949,
-0.0519993156,
0.0193195771,
0.0118858609,
-0.0446866937,
0.0242037699,
0.0411566161,
-0.0018297494,
-0.0117114792,
0.0004782498,
0.0380998217,
-0.0254645944,
-0.00648836,
0.0431439318,
-0.0358723179,
0.0033106578,
0.0112168482,
0.0622786842,
0.0221496467,
-0.0584173836,
-0.0017342226,
-0.0615148023,
0.0346028209,
0.015879279,
0.0496911146,
0.0373259783,
0.0086546894,
-0.0313679129,
-0.0035620043,
0.0358523689,
0.0540490784,
-0.0253516939,
-0.0149258431,
0.013839988,
0.0254407488,
-0.0117937997,
-0.0213389713,
-0.0259189717,
0.0113749355,
0.0759907365,
-0.0827831998,
-0.0073152222,
0.0249629542,
2.44e-7,
0.0241414737,
0.0114599401,
0.0201914217,
0.0120292623,
0.0085563129,
0.0562357306,
0.019818427,
0.0623290986,
0.0305960234,
-0.0108785499,
-0.0085386364,
0.0085936915,
0.0399196371,
0.0288820993,
-0.0213706661,
0.0090920553,
-0.0543659218,
-0.0113959331,
0.0082179625,
-0.0384658612,
0.0281043723,
0.0922086537,
0.0016805686,
-0.0450645909,
0.0236833803,
-0.0526111834,
0.0790024027,
-0.0414991714,
-0.005639723,
-0.0349057689,
0.0103934389,
0.0654704124,
0.005043556,
-0.0037881646,
-0.0339752361,
-0.0319294333,
0.0662401691,
0.0575625896,
-0.0062820036,
0.0167698357,
-0.0100876838,
-0.009530941,
-0.0083068386,
-0.0441268273,
0.0745951757,
-0.0804031417,
0.0040778047,
-0.0357243121,
-0.0381125957,
0.0085028689,
0.0459476598,
-0.0754343793,
-0.0277895685,
-0.0022775582,
0.0333508067,
0.0309921987,
-0.0203940272,
-0.0655550286,
-0.0234660767,
-0.0201374255,
-0.0185352098,
-0.0375793613,
-0.0431312807,
0.0153194778,
0.0053138868,
-0.0543580875,
-0.0114927413,
2.026441599e-34,
0.0163085852,
-0.032867305,
0.0152518256,
-0.0322999209,
0.0263442118,
0.0130829867,
0.0196011607,
0.0036991923,
-0.0203552656,
-0.0143776368,
-0.0274612792
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16101v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16101v1 | How Many Unicorns Are in This Image? A Safety Evaluation Benchmark for Vision LLMs | 2023-11-27T18:59:42 | 2023-11-27T18:59:42 | Haoqin Tu, Chenhang Cui, Zijun Wang, Yiyang Zhou, Bingchen Zhao, Junlin Han, Wangchunshu Zhou, Huaxiu Yao, Cihang Xie | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG | This work focuses on the potential of Vision LLMs (VLLMs) in visual
reasoning. Different from prior studies, we shift our focus from evaluating
standard performance to introducing a comprehensive safety evaluation suite,
covering both out-of-distribution (OOD) generalization and adversarial
robustness. For the OOD evaluation, we present two novel VQA datasets, each
with one variant, designed to test model performance under challenging
conditions. In exploring adversarial robustness, we propose a straightforward
attack strategy for misleading VLLMs to produce visual-unrelated responses.
Moreover, we assess the efficacy of two jailbreaking strategies, targeting
either the vision or language component of VLLMs. Our evaluation of 21 diverse
models, ranging from open-source VLLMs to GPT-4V, yields interesting
observations: 1) Current VLLMs struggle with OOD texts but not images, unless
the visual information is limited; and 2) These VLLMs can be easily misled by
deceiving vision encoders only, and their vision-language training often
compromise safety protocols. We release this safety evaluation suite at
https://github.com/UCSC-VLAA/vllm-safety-benchmark. | [
-0.013537121,
0.0655789375,
-0.019054627,
0.0779459178,
-0.0146103641,
0.0238490701,
-0.0037159643,
0.0096708583,
0.0275690686,
-0.0243493933,
-0.019057693,
-0.014012794,
0.0059003308,
0.0158950351,
0.0697775334,
-0.0382617414,
0.0433958881,
-0.0498929061,
-0.0620564185,
0.0028485195,
-0.0011741749,
-0.0309961215,
0.0082529141,
0.0195297655,
-0.0041088546,
-0.0347988829,
-0.0068547595,
0.0349064246,
0.0683364719,
-0.0233627595,
-0.0026642368,
0.00627338,
0.0217650644,
0.0357968174,
0.0000021225,
-0.012701978,
0.002739921,
0.0044526225,
0.0140206488,
-0.0128982812,
-0.0128626348,
-0.0724517256,
-0.0110854134,
0.032998126,
-0.0211852603,
-0.0133157065,
0.0587561838,
0.043730814,
0.0455847979,
0.0846613199,
-0.0024166373,
0.0108563351,
0.0521435104,
-0.0179452412,
0.0349780805,
-0.0437828004,
-0.003036815,
-0.0192436893,
-0.0422520153,
-0.0037870463,
-0.0297455657,
0.0242557973,
0.0454751886,
0.016909264,
-0.042907767,
0.0376701951,
-0.0318652019,
-0.0409702212,
-0.0261661038,
0.0765965804,
-0.0668574795,
0.0215928219,
-0.0104095154,
0.0177452303,
0.0094830887,
0.0001104654,
-0.0300641079,
0.0369954444,
-0.0011578802,
0.0052265124,
-0.0699374601,
-0.0069427723,
0.0508776456,
0.0129523855,
0.0014623094,
0.0087217148,
0.0222782753,
0.035650678,
0.0275855437,
-0.0072641112,
-0.0473075882,
-0.043551337,
-0.0157308485,
0.033814054,
0.0042499593,
-0.0062086401,
-0.0662548393,
-0.0052647241,
0.0006634871,
-0.0496072471,
0.0555899329,
-0.0047403602,
-0.0487829223,
0.029023286,
-0.0313861556,
0.0514815412,
-0.061166022,
0.0890229419,
-0.013191388,
-0.0019111835,
-0.0163835604,
-0.0126184607,
0.0406196639,
-0.0136333564,
-0.0185762495,
0.0064433711,
-0.0441198125,
0.0018831503,
-0.052643314,
0.0296804626,
-0.0307966433,
0.0482524522,
0.0047783111,
-0.0242208373,
-0.0317627527,
-0.026355546,
0.0095848069,
0.0095667243,
-0.0057856655,
-0.0830968842,
-0.0522273891,
0.0519116111,
-0.0484824441,
-0.0008998624,
0.001075667,
0.1443543285,
-0.001152283,
-0.0291248001,
-0.0539587773,
-0.0131664192,
-0.0050958879,
-0.0638896078,
0.0539225154,
-0.0602227598,
-0.020507589,
-0.0345458873,
-0.0063518467,
-0.0534227937,
0.0340987816,
0.0174561758,
-0.0316832997,
0.0592301078,
-0.0166625846,
-0.0403592847,
-0.0025182047,
0.0500483066,
-0.0157339387,
0.0844422653,
0.0319647454,
0.0496217944,
0.0181771349,
-0.0005530712,
0.0679710954,
0.0329448953,
0.0072881505,
0.0406303182,
-0.0488185249,
-0.0007364322,
0.026697563,
0.0103138126,
-0.0086321179,
0.0392666124,
-0.0312348083,
-0.0774435699,
0.0841891691,
0.0252613947,
-0.0129057691,
-0.0153509155,
-0.0094651151,
-0.0430752523,
0.0210422706,
-0.007680682,
-0.0848419145,
0.0629242882,
-0.0550524853,
-0.0207246784,
-0.0233975649,
0.029845709,
-0.0403737836,
-0.0337758139,
-0.0117218075,
-0.0276602842,
0.0053427285,
0.021697849,
0.0432390086,
0.0085057747,
-0.0235310085,
0.0059766266,
0.0094824936,
-0.0130939251,
-0.0333421901,
-0.0562507473,
-0.0065962635,
0.0215451661,
0.0446055047,
0.001124388,
-0.0031540287,
-0.0277712643,
-0.0037371181,
0.0097547444,
-0.0082276119,
0.0215893257,
0.0679612383,
-0.0472200476,
-0.0258111097,
-0.0486770235,
-0.0066404454,
0.016031608,
0.031502258,
0.0054011615,
0.0039255945,
-0.0724471062,
0.0080813691,
0.0352432504,
0.0066962363,
-0.0198126361,
0.005839014,
0.0224619024,
0.0058644209,
-0.0209838655,
-0.0043214699,
-0.0087192971,
0.0449966826,
-0.0226967018,
0.0345878974,
-0.0191683378,
-0.0160332453,
-0.0194107555,
0.019610472,
-0.0890727267,
-0.038881395,
0.065015398,
-0.0674178824,
0.0281243157,
0.0328521468,
-0.0105215916,
-0.0342054218,
-0.0193923768,
-0.0095631974,
0.0002203204,
0.0116701182,
-0.0056686359,
0.0689614043,
-0.0447972044,
-0.019156687,
-0.0177942254,
0.0184132587,
0.0316216871,
-0.0300882738,
0.0025574588,
0.0107664764,
-0.0270445831,
0.0116463993,
-0.0466389172,
-0.0003086536,
-0.0302915312,
-0.0021103697,
-0.0216128342,
-0.0108540971,
-0.0471229851,
-0.0009667982,
0.0093216626,
-0.0438896976,
-0.0084115751,
-0.025090253,
-0.0009393882,
0.0531414226,
-0.0169379693,
-0.0058722417,
0.0106218811,
-0.0316884369,
-0.014538683,
0.0200473536,
-0.004201767,
0.035273537,
0.0767122954,
-0.0081445221,
0.0092240041,
-0.0303304698,
-0.0011441315,
-0.0405370779,
0.0361088291,
-0.0418762229,
-0.0188782196,
0.0367100425,
0.0269686114,
-0.0059013008,
0.0790198818,
0.0149721196,
0.0254745185,
0.0659925789,
0.0534334481,
-0.0074191834,
-0.0173205808,
0.0290130712,
-0.0491712615,
-0.0134299416,
-0.0186376255,
-0.032510262,
-0.0004618207,
-0.0171878915,
0.0046814834,
-0.0332149602,
0.043172691,
0.0183074977,
-0.086425513,
-0.0335821323,
0.0212552976,
-0.0042525213,
0.0325538404,
-0.0186549071,
-0.0776802301,
0.0474483743,
-0.0139568355,
0.0206746738,
0.0341964513,
-0.0201910194,
0.0197864603,
0.0585524775,
0.0029203922,
0.012585137,
0.0220193658,
-0.0023968311,
-0.0680261478,
-0.0474479683,
-0.0129754823,
-0.0132742506,
0.0762721896,
-0.0593673289,
-0.0223400444,
-0.0292119719,
-0.0312136728,
-0.0677218065,
-0.0186297409,
-0.0097277705,
0.0129798129,
-0.0635682493,
-0.013033147,
-0.0457525887,
-0.0320799351,
0.0170386564,
-0.0095504373,
-0.0208772738,
0.0071983687,
-0.0095477784,
0.0329904966,
0.0432497002,
-0.0247888733,
0.0412246399,
-0.0580409579,
0.0181832984,
0.1029334888,
0.0091014896,
0.0049825637,
-0.0461671762,
0.0302225668,
-0.0105252648,
0.0617262237,
0.0166285094,
0.0446940735,
0.0499418899,
-0.034199968,
-0.0134511441,
0.0166070908,
-0.0085759107,
-0.001485565,
0.0268243942,
0.0272108763,
0.0266117435,
0.0210946873,
-0.004725304,
-0.0590216257,
-0.0297622811,
0.0101263579,
0.0386150852,
0.0205125157,
-0.0139477625,
0.0017210537,
-0.0607735217,
0.0504390746,
0.0196853001,
-0.0013596602,
-0.0638279021,
0.018694384,
-0.0135076214,
-0.0296245199,
0.0249445289,
-0.0075472086,
0.0019133949,
-0.0094690062,
-0.0092290081,
0.0350107588,
-0.0311125908,
0.0211520512,
-0.0219017081,
-0.0151676247,
0.0847378001,
-0.0256275516,
-0.0222157259,
-0.0658746883,
0.0240300801,
-0.0072376141,
0.0174650252,
0.0203515086,
0.0807669982,
-0.0108460905,
-0.0289657041,
0.0024964083,
0.042615924,
-0.0039943475,
-0.0452795029,
0.0204261132,
0.0118033597,
-0.018186029,
-0.0539736412,
-0.0318312906,
0.0018630621,
-0.0042651123,
0.0266244076,
0.0097617162,
0.0104731936,
-0.0527002104,
-0.0602248833,
-0.0172190387,
-0.0399024077,
-0.0322027318,
0.0313261747,
0.0838336721,
-0.04314496,
-0.0570659414,
-0.0037781908,
0.0077810315,
0.0530646071,
-0.0212617051,
-0.0532423332,
-0.023731634,
0.0319633447,
-0.0410881601,
0.0419810489,
0.010537127,
0.0249435119,
-0.0155163147,
0.034769021,
0.0098178154,
-0.0420223325,
-0.015454906,
0.0155060142,
-0.0800870061,
-0.0663738772,
-0.0200400464,
0.0787879676,
0.0203316044,
0.048623886,
-0.0067855944,
-0.0267385617,
0.0918104276,
0.0778104737,
0.038255468,
0.0203489922,
0.0570996329,
-0.0253177267,
0.006087733,
0.0376114845,
-0.024786612,
-0.0075692129,
0.0608360209,
-0.0132115735,
-0.0236879066,
0.0366834626,
0.0010199746,
-0.0223257598,
0.0606216229,
-0.0218705796,
0.0286386628,
0.0305668432,
0.0437084772,
0.0064146575,
0.0156308226,
-0.0384586193,
0.0151363453,
0.0586938858,
0.0029691125,
0.0178189296,
0.0135064833,
0.0247335918,
0.0189459026,
-0.006496185,
0.0035728368,
0.0112873213,
-0.0003435673,
0.0066426755,
0.0175117217,
-0.0248687826,
0.0384119041,
-0.0549089871,
0.0394692644,
0.0041061998,
0.0460987128,
0.0158986915,
0.021960564,
-0.0000140883,
0.0235934462,
-0.05632535,
-0.0658808351,
-0.0173038282,
0.0912455693,
0.0344594643,
0.0159693733,
-0.0366104431,
-0.0317617878,
-0.0134406677,
-0.0350470282,
0.0180305671,
-0.0020577291,
-0.02790723,
0.0677192658,
0.0188897178,
0.0087350262,
-0.0456459299,
0.0727404132,
0.0299405437,
0.0383846983,
-0.0025871736,
0.0289869457,
-0.0320647396,
-0.0217586029,
0.0469372682,
-0.0311704408,
0.0132332593,
0.0178906564,
-0.0310258195,
-0.09124621,
-0.0173918474,
0.0340124667,
0.0243864637,
0.0163603965,
0.0108169038,
0.0354530998,
0.0357531495,
0.0065681911,
0.0208102167,
-0.013203159,
0.0051021273,
-0.0080256145,
0.0110485675,
-6.483959983e-33,
0.0125761069,
-0.0367064625,
-0.0141362082,
-0.0484379083,
0.0325124338,
-0.0026552409,
-0.0177997332,
-0.0196874905,
-0.0400497355,
-0.0128188133,
0.0116398064,
0.0125274528,
-0.0124152387,
0.0232993606,
-0.0343902856,
-0.0665467978,
-0.0166697502,
-0.0226317178,
-0.0267009642,
-0.0154963071,
0.0072483276,
0.0060976646,
0.0440900326,
-0.0709765181,
0.0115362583,
0.0018204257,
-0.0692638606,
0.0097016487,
-0.0546265841,
0.0463038534,
0.0076978691,
0.0144777568,
0.0003634225,
0.0269700922,
-0.0170780495,
0.0102001801,
-0.0108029386,
-0.0205888636,
-0.0267218444,
-0.0146841612,
-0.097120814,
-0.0212593079,
0.0441164561,
-0.0090796202,
-0.0157765374,
-0.0699526221,
-0.0071216901,
-0.0278324988,
-0.0035884164,
0.0032507023,
0.0062449579,
0.000799674,
-0.0058399783,
-0.0333152898,
0.0347774141,
0.0307507496,
0.016653562,
0.0216971468,
-0.027672559,
-0.0065699457,
-0.0055706678,
-0.0344129093,
0.0894209072,
0.0315074585,
-0.0036143709,
0.089037776,
0.0003941891,
-0.0362845361,
-0.0511753559,
-0.043984659,
0.00566753,
0.0723372325,
0.1108630225,
0.0645008087,
0.0428730547,
0.0113348076,
-0.1120153293,
0.0234112069,
-0.0656139702,
0.0467219204,
0.0140880486,
0.0053447448,
-0.0089424411,
0.0034530163,
-0.0140780797,
-0.0041303704,
-0.0377698764,
-0.0154319638,
0.0515876897,
0.02625186,
-0.0141594075,
0.0079328073,
-0.009685236,
-0.0420026928,
0.0189379659,
0.0288080685,
0.0157026369,
0.0126198446,
0.009419811,
0.0290649831,
-0.0297912564,
0.0018385181,
0.0500609651,
-0.0099217016,
0.027808683,
-0.0033848498,
0.0638887584,
0.0258228928,
-0.0302221049,
-0.0081727132,
-0.0466104336,
0.0668291375,
0.0408711545,
0.0210825279,
0.035010241,
-0.0297010113,
-0.0207135212,
-0.0036591727,
-0.0278431084,
0.0024461567,
-0.0338596255,
0.0074679102,
-0.0381322429,
0.0524313264,
-0.0111317914,
-0.0168869291,
-0.0146127045,
-0.0369516164,
0.0399193168,
-0.066640459,
-0.0146871749,
0.0226057768,
2.886e-7,
-0.0073056594,
0.0034783143,
0.0034691757,
0.0300613362,
-0.0001027524,
0.0751190335,
-0.0591698922,
0.0647120327,
-0.0178392585,
-0.0867813379,
-0.0247687958,
0.0552694164,
0.0746460259,
0.0297624692,
-0.0033307616,
0.0355980881,
-0.0054973918,
-0.0091457721,
-0.0254368763,
-0.0048252875,
0.0482645892,
0.0793622509,
-0.0058366354,
-0.010851441,
0.06696444,
-0.0397598781,
0.0470895395,
-0.0367265977,
0.0267777368,
-0.0635739937,
0.0110263648,
0.0338991247,
0.0119369328,
0.0205643065,
-0.0134749636,
-0.0417301208,
-0.0031341792,
0.0332864299,
-0.0299097132,
-0.0448690988,
-0.0591608323,
0.0095115006,
0.0226540547,
-0.0685350075,
0.0839647427,
-0.0170851909,
-0.0358596779,
0.0001214066,
-0.0177787356,
-0.0135540646,
0.0382097773,
-0.0084772212,
-0.0050681015,
-0.0046583526,
0.002174207,
-0.0033745575,
-0.0097138006,
-0.0565570444,
-0.0204376969,
-0.0205341671,
-0.0156660564,
-0.054746937,
-0.0448070765,
0.0587761477,
0.0524262041,
-0.0022625397,
-0.0623071641,
2.327334403e-34,
0.0088980915,
-0.0311394092,
0.0153487651,
-0.0162564423,
0.0228366964,
-0.0155787533,
0.032220114,
-0.0287175402,
-0.0070314454,
-0.003494337,
-0.015370206
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03729v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03729v1 | Cognitive Dissonance: Why Do Language Model Outputs Disagree with Internal Representations of Truthfulness? | 2023-11-27T18:59:14 | 2023-11-27T18:59:14 | Kevin Liu, Stephen Casper, Dylan Hadfield-Menell, Jacob Andreas | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Neural language models (LMs) can be used to evaluate the truth of factual
statements in two ways: they can be either queried for statement probabilities,
or probed for internal representations of truthfulness. Past work has found
that these two procedures sometimes disagree, and that probes tend to be more
accurate than LM outputs. This has led some researchers to conclude that LMs
"lie" or otherwise encode non-cooperative communicative intents. Is this an
accurate description of today's LMs, or can query-probe disagreement arise in
other ways? We identify three different classes of disagreement, which we term
confabulation, deception, and heterogeneity. In many cases, the superiority of
probes is simply attributable to better calibration on uncertain answers rather
than a greater fraction of correct, high-confidence answers. In some cases,
queries and probes perform better on different subsets of inputs, and accuracy
can further be improved by ensembling the two. Code is available at
github.com/lingo-mit/lm-truthfulness. | [
0.0599189438,
0.0516208224,
-0.046206452,
0.0402681939,
-0.067171894,
-0.0002316282,
-0.0122489911,
-0.0028277403,
-0.0059825685,
-0.021593608,
-0.0456005298,
-0.0306025129,
0.047049921,
-0.0046693753,
0.0264601912,
0.0491987541,
0.0572189353,
-0.0136441784,
0.077009514,
-0.0462233946,
-0.02183415,
0.0138904843,
-0.0030033912,
0.0030510884,
-0.0122289481,
0.0015889597,
-0.0213432703,
0.0243852045,
-0.0221869163,
-0.0132006248,
-0.0136346063,
0.0352132618,
-0.000407301,
0.0683362409,
0.0000019943,
-0.0429440029,
0.0166871157,
-0.0326364711,
-0.0478994027,
0.0394538231,
0.0065699588,
0.0052456236,
0.0347172432,
0.0220736284,
-0.0165523086,
0.0256471988,
0.0144351805,
0.0246037822,
0.0063058529,
0.0489913821,
0.0199808627,
0.0317542553,
-0.0093481466,
-0.0312682725,
-0.0035893896,
0.0061444277,
0.027782049,
-0.0002945771,
-0.0784646496,
0.0089571187,
-0.0034824298,
-0.0080986386,
-0.0021295825,
-0.0018593683,
-0.0444412231,
0.0191295855,
-0.0213348791,
-0.0673570409,
-0.0027161674,
0.003761807,
0.0166490413,
-0.0353382379,
0.0051837591,
-0.0171156581,
-0.0083601233,
0.006590547,
-0.0103216274,
0.0354548767,
-0.0029729239,
0.0097648865,
0.0032469356,
-0.0073298351,
0.0083812894,
0.0141252661,
0.0047806231,
0.0586904436,
-0.0066374694,
-0.0419053771,
0.0238872375,
0.0045930785,
0.0194422677,
-0.0789497197,
-0.0350193866,
0.0007979939,
-0.0113139087,
0.0128116738,
-0.0019048308,
0.0071649742,
0.0845857188,
-0.0214532688,
0.0212566182,
0.0332859792,
-0.0334955677,
-0.0017707867,
0.025050303,
0.0760390386,
-0.0044843671,
0.0546952337,
-0.0191978887,
0.0044540227,
0.0159639176,
-0.0416598283,
0.0246873926,
0.0170457195,
-0.008374596,
0.0114867985,
-0.0444885008,
-0.007240315,
-0.0642993301,
-0.005210713,
-0.067560412,
0.019363815,
-0.0154069737,
0.040517047,
-0.0963777602,
0.0517795049,
0.0040059444,
0.0582971908,
0.0010330741,
-0.0970747769,
-0.0266953725,
0.0232369825,
-0.0456138775,
-0.0136390841,
0.0170455389,
-0.0168206114,
-0.0087875407,
-0.020567935,
0.0048867804,
-0.0044252751,
-0.0777876303,
-0.0929527581,
0.0405238941,
-0.0346053839,
0.0345568061,
0.0006906378,
-0.0284301322,
-0.0262739249,
0.0267307479,
0.003343269,
-0.0424978212,
0.0319397636,
0.038361311,
0.0270101801,
0.0337348282,
0.026348779,
-0.0000795158,
0.0355553031,
0.0050032316,
0.0111341244,
0.0327800438,
0.0315776281,
0.0064636134,
-0.039915435,
0.0360777713,
-0.0006111451,
-0.0321559161,
0.0264672898,
0.0179312639,
0.0199568234,
0.0633145198,
0.0816204622,
-0.0273489282,
-0.0565501414,
0.0981269851,
0.021437034,
-0.0203875266,
-0.0583628453,
-0.022479577,
-0.0003200488,
0.0537105128,
0.0107209738,
-0.0521704853,
0.0215245709,
-0.0481238216,
-0.001130678,
0.0469681248,
0.0171801131,
-0.0097668143,
-0.0237117354,
-0.023341421,
-0.0094351778,
0.036735855,
0.0336600058,
-0.0085980734,
-0.0512188412,
-0.028486358,
0.0079784719,
0.0060719838,
-0.0359624252,
-0.0160664283,
-0.0808421224,
0.0368889011,
-0.0326908231,
-0.0057535861,
0.0546879582,
-0.0224387087,
0.000559586,
-0.0478935651,
0.0738604516,
0.075923346,
0.0086141797,
0.0257176813,
-0.0146763874,
0.0168837998,
-0.0757635385,
0.0151260914,
-0.0423415452,
-0.025317803,
0.0110639352,
-0.0037771256,
-0.0285516363,
0.0094241342,
0.0434764959,
0.0055524115,
0.0124579351,
-0.0487949215,
-0.0048538051,
0.0281561874,
-0.00909812,
-0.00412224,
0.0277186371,
0.0506351851,
0.0313558355,
-0.0242383666,
-0.0128653813,
-0.0257723723,
-0.0405695289,
0.0299426746,
0.0009911945,
0.0068350676,
0.0097746709,
-0.0006313143,
-0.0071334443,
0.0025119798,
-0.0315411091,
-0.0200456046,
-0.0356876999,
0.0221613869,
-0.0526830666,
0.0155085102,
-0.037154872,
0.0286871269,
-0.032935556,
0.0304631591,
-0.0235486757,
-0.0188843403,
0.0240256488,
-0.0235262103,
-0.019551266,
0.0093634287,
0.0168828238,
-0.0273186937,
-0.008342728,
-0.0545943007,
-0.0574445911,
-0.0241249669,
-0.036059767,
-0.0249417741,
0.0406740308,
-0.0127681112,
0.0119927451,
-0.0683668777,
-0.0051970398,
0.0445387959,
0.0191736016,
0.01445409,
0.0453545973,
0.0461541601,
0.0462156683,
-0.024142215,
0.0139862513,
-0.0303874686,
0.020794332,
-0.018696215,
0.0130571825,
-0.0331569836,
-0.0135399783,
-0.0433769301,
0.0141192172,
-0.0843619704,
0.0123242773,
-0.031316448,
-0.0566795394,
0.0351511389,
0.0656569675,
0.0019160253,
0.0787014589,
0.0298941676,
0.0464266054,
0.0790630206,
0.0057610464,
-0.0500132218,
-0.0090983855,
-0.010271945,
-0.0150115537,
0.0075638858,
-0.0855678767,
0.0079569826,
0.0597576648,
0.0659438819,
-0.0026434304,
-0.0263838209,
0.0211442504,
0.0059944573,
-0.0497133546,
0.0416741706,
-0.0731352419,
-0.0395899154,
0.0882785991,
-0.0210879762,
-0.062988013,
0.0740873963,
-0.0451429114,
0.0227082055,
-0.0418737568,
0.0024511355,
0.0226065516,
0.043612875,
-0.0148210488,
-0.0117961867,
0.0774177387,
-0.0046221619,
-0.0724128559,
-0.0507389419,
0.0109554287,
-0.0655461848,
0.0488318801,
-0.0272696614,
-0.0183320772,
-0.0033316291,
0.0139624933,
-0.0570110083,
-0.0082171774,
-0.0135081541,
-0.013907671,
-0.0092402678,
0.0340234861,
-0.0228269827,
-0.0498494953,
0.0238368083,
-0.0349242166,
-0.0262896754,
-0.0030907567,
-0.0014451698,
-0.044844646,
0.0259381123,
0.0524033457,
0.0987332165,
-0.0296949055,
-0.0151026128,
0.0566469282,
-0.0549313985,
0.0527162887,
-0.004083429,
-0.0195936207,
0.0112489555,
0.0406130701,
-0.0119855702,
0.0262364987,
0.07326895,
0.0158561394,
-0.0227720104,
0.0771656856,
0.02010547,
-0.0004154667,
0.0044025737,
-0.0386086404,
0.010345214,
0.0318733789,
-0.0250986665,
-0.0665605366,
0.0099222772,
0.029462995,
0.0009417056,
-0.0609520636,
0.0215405002,
-0.0264793392,
-0.0908885971,
0.0254025944,
-0.0145465657,
0.0204870775,
-0.0541967638,
-0.0216306709,
0.0126556875,
0.0408928655,
0.0467402972,
0.0399662629,
0.0355856232,
0.0026713694,
-0.011498577,
-0.010052477,
-0.0313155614,
0.0089588184,
-0.0024881426,
0.0667088404,
0.0408590212,
0.0383939594,
0.0022381409,
-0.0677081943,
0.0285390876,
-0.0097271884,
-0.0203756317,
-0.0179219544,
0.0318728648,
0.0019744625,
0.0235820748,
-0.0271842349,
-0.0018517656,
0.0046158861,
-0.0163433459,
-0.0398943275,
0.0198705792,
-0.0298345722,
-0.0308803357,
-0.0097556999,
0.0660784617,
0.0147283394,
0.0807962269,
0.044310201,
0.0247702934,
-0.0247167218,
0.0176805314,
0.009649056,
0.0422612913,
0.0033851159,
0.0368389152,
0.067380026,
0.014624144,
-0.0393801704,
-0.0320649035,
-0.0288931746,
-0.0365148298,
-0.0394731425,
-0.0161569081,
0.0156595148,
-0.0318824127,
-0.0317906104,
0.0246151499,
0.0044158925,
0.0174458008,
0.0162265077,
0.0355815105,
-0.027307203,
-0.0395980664,
0.0039894157,
-0.0174456481,
-0.1006043926,
-0.0570247769,
0.0424704403,
-0.0045635751,
0.0289101452,
0.0044915066,
0.0070594382,
0.0141184805,
-0.0365037471,
0.0205039512,
-0.0351158753,
0.0813612863,
0.0187723152,
0.0596829951,
0.0008212801,
0.0418249741,
0.0011159389,
0.0079830363,
0.0517798066,
0.0020515106,
0.0277337953,
-0.087358214,
0.0448788814,
0.0309468117,
0.0722746328,
0.0382870063,
0.0454837009,
-0.0131952586,
-0.0086915232,
0.0036035399,
-0.0283596385,
0.0166413952,
-0.0714340061,
0.0288184583,
0.008154761,
-0.0215573031,
-0.0446289033,
-0.0352012403,
0.0601930097,
-0.0117037063,
-0.0167786367,
-0.0222176369,
0.0239877552,
-0.0083286464,
0.0130447689,
-0.0306541137,
0.0385873653,
-0.0491472781,
0.0256491769,
0.0200422686,
0.03982668,
0.0192708075,
-0.0255860891,
-0.027910525,
-0.0364454612,
-0.0472608767,
-0.043265041,
0.0536632389,
-0.0073514702,
-0.0033673779,
0.0334117077,
0.0161795411,
-0.012296197,
0.0111465082,
-0.0110354936,
0.010399688,
0.0143732317,
0.0108791264,
0.0866952613,
-0.0075292224,
-0.0257124994,
-0.0029303262,
0.0479928963,
-0.051967673,
0.0243669245,
-0.001130058,
-0.0086189369,
-0.0034661444,
-0.0252176858,
-0.0117126871,
0.0356426537,
-0.0455482081,
-0.0053717182,
-0.070606634,
-0.041414015,
0.0465520397,
0.0167936664,
0.0468522161,
-0.0632813945,
-0.0212708768,
0.0844916105,
0.0388716906,
-0.0165602677,
0.0108307833,
0.0451822467,
-0.0011376065,
0.0299844481,
-0.0399098508,
-6.688399022e-33,
-0.0197507367,
-0.0410421789,
-0.0304126684,
-0.0533801243,
-0.0486397147,
0.0195127148,
0.0015177436,
0.0075807311,
-0.0798717737,
0.0138846152,
-0.0041720858,
0.0347775668,
0.0143397022,
-0.0068131504,
0.0200779717,
-0.0281463061,
0.0144050317,
-0.0181734413,
-0.046115987,
-0.0583696328,
0.023707021,
-0.0265913196,
0.0333445296,
-0.0396054052,
0.0682547018,
0.0097792586,
-0.0109836617,
0.0165534951,
-0.0702611059,
-0.0002943065,
-0.0201158412,
0.0510280617,
0.0142595638,
0.0070520584,
0.0241953097,
-0.0033037968,
0.0127753448,
-0.0449766815,
0.0791226625,
-0.0242303926,
-0.0229846202,
0.006210478,
0.0093035707,
-0.0162771437,
-0.0465900488,
0.0054457765,
-0.0366534665,
0.0028174035,
0.0114308279,
-0.000342763,
-0.0421214402,
-0.0301701501,
0.025067037,
-0.0097326115,
-0.0589059554,
0.0269698855,
-0.0143690519,
0.0441701263,
-0.1310231686,
-0.0022020449,
-0.0139943128,
0.0074526947,
0.0448077545,
-0.005022089,
-0.0089889402,
0.0741855726,
0.0484556518,
0.054487437,
-0.0547967367,
0.0050887917,
0.0202901848,
0.0068318513,
0.0651640967,
0.0421626121,
0.0180649981,
-0.075763844,
-0.0539627522,
-0.0465883054,
0.0560956895,
-0.0110900477,
0.0656353682,
0.0132901501,
0.0114907129,
-0.0398060679,
-0.0706711486,
-0.0406543836,
-0.0520847254,
0.0155904954,
0.0103791067,
0.0202187877,
0.0023828405,
-0.036105305,
0.0174936932,
-0.0075187651,
0.0394356549,
-0.0078838011,
-0.0223262422,
-0.0074656075,
0.0276880544,
0.0233882479,
-0.0657126009,
0.0087238923,
-0.0034480148,
0.0379740745,
0.0045481431,
0.0247888211,
0.0013135399,
-0.0253990851,
-0.0075897197,
0.023990497,
-0.0217929855,
0.0295687672,
-0.0093258722,
-0.0812164992,
0.0175102428,
0.0128953801,
-0.0504343472,
-0.0345970243,
0.0101581272,
-0.0152116017,
-0.0491196103,
0.0403347798,
-0.0129014552,
0.0494192056,
-0.0176504254,
0.0006718548,
-0.0358434208,
0.0059003769,
-0.0067303516,
-0.0262729041,
-0.0291252788,
-0.0140919294,
2.805e-7,
0.0011888526,
0.041937694,
-0.0179564748,
0.0553055853,
0.0261766184,
0.0398018137,
-0.0192372296,
-0.0022277937,
0.0684436485,
-0.0573880896,
-0.0785745904,
0.0015633501,
0.039104823,
0.0380626768,
0.044913616,
0.0374976322,
-0.035543222,
-0.0260500982,
-0.0012690526,
0.0454638153,
0.0324146114,
0.0224829577,
0.025776932,
-0.0069657345,
-0.0166573152,
0.0235570986,
0.0457496792,
0.0054475944,
0.0043156054,
0.0054107523,
0.032450594,
-0.0366356932,
0.030817369,
0.0754896998,
0.0393977761,
0.0147265103,
-0.0429734029,
0.0217081755,
0.0090696737,
-0.0629136786,
-0.0531275012,
-0.004840205,
-0.0051731528,
-0.0831022263,
0.0410467647,
-0.0581370294,
-0.0423683561,
-0.0585316755,
0.0221494567,
-0.0070010959,
0.0778997093,
0.0001009642,
-0.0414959267,
-0.0049670106,
0.0196388029,
0.0461411513,
-0.0121724652,
-0.0416686907,
-0.0147278039,
-0.0049756547,
-0.0298045445,
-0.0563787669,
-0.0037130499,
0.016668506,
0.0372987539,
-0.0294461269,
0.0099228732,
2.58065688e-34,
0.0108479839,
0.0033728597,
0.017313242,
-0.0047789081,
0.0511994623,
0.0119264731,
-0.0172668118,
0.0192154795,
0.0282836482,
-0.0262488462,
-0.0102786254
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16087v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16087v1 | DUnE: Dataset for Unified Editing | 2023-11-27T18:56:14 | 2023-11-27T18:56:14 | Afra Feyza Akyürek, Eric Pan, Garry Kuwanto, Derry Wijaya | cs.CL | cs.CL | Even the most advanced language models remain susceptible to errors
necessitating to modify these models without initiating a comprehensive
retraining process. Model editing refers to the modification of a model's
knowledge or representations in a manner that produces the desired outcomes.
Prior research primarily centered around editing factual data e.g. "Messi plays
for Inter Miami" confining the definition of an edit to a knowledge triplet
i.e. (subject, object, relation). However, as the applications of language
models expand, so do the diverse ways in which we wish to edit and refine their
outputs. In this study, we broaden the scope of the editing problem to include
an array of editing cases such as debiasing and rectifying reasoning errors and
define an edit as any natural language expression that solicits a change in the
model's outputs. We are introducing DUnE-an editing benchmark where edits are
natural language sentences and propose that DUnE presents a challenging yet
relevant task. To substantiate this claim, we conduct an extensive series of
experiments testing various editing approaches to address DUnE, demonstrating
their respective strengths and weaknesses. We show that retrieval-augmented
language modeling can outperform specialized editing techniques and neither set
of approaches has fully solved the generalized editing problem covered by our
benchmark. | [
0.1020214781,
0.0446429886,
-0.0081490558,
0.026581293,
-0.0438277833,
-0.0118927835,
-0.024487,
-0.0208619963,
-0.0216409024,
-0.0982669145,
-0.0264078788,
0.0038158917,
0.011795165,
0.0155125856,
0.0229214728,
-0.0590015911,
0.0606626607,
0.0186269563,
0.0288983844,
0.0278803091,
0.0161001887,
0.018361263,
0.0151415979,
0.0443921238,
-0.0112083564,
-0.011304317,
-0.0152817499,
0.0433638729,
0.0115416646,
0.0414350927,
0.0205177851,
0.0810397491,
-0.0031595989,
0.0615137033,
0.0000018643,
-0.0438818596,
-0.0590553582,
0.0029872633,
-0.0110799531,
0.0062766448,
0.0656285584,
-0.0104717296,
-0.027828401,
0.0019648313,
-0.0191432852,
0.0124273514,
0.0695052147,
0.0327629931,
0.0821007639,
0.1031996608,
-0.002177442,
-0.0021728023,
0.0002971954,
-0.0390866101,
-0.011048492,
0.0017504917,
0.0410867259,
0.0136195151,
-0.0294037536,
0.0320421569,
-0.0032181223,
0.0489109792,
0.0053920848,
-0.0523604043,
0.0331120715,
-0.031684652,
-0.0717868507,
0.0010211847,
0.0116778947,
0.0240080617,
0.0065222471,
-0.0244731475,
-0.015443488,
0.0055144085,
0.0341392085,
0.0071296562,
-0.0249191206,
0.0015396121,
0.0093066515,
-0.0007808125,
-0.0162427332,
-0.0735022053,
0.0337608978,
0.0296275038,
0.0253017507,
0.0579924025,
0.051572375,
-0.019210672,
-0.0473712534,
0.0030922783,
0.0083637042,
-0.0786283538,
0.0015483551,
0.0065725781,
-0.0285793189,
0.0200220235,
-0.0675033107,
-0.0124321207,
0.0124778328,
-0.0261673518,
0.0458033048,
0.0080340346,
0.0033104371,
0.063958846,
0.011508882,
0.0207126979,
0.0146190971,
0.0043208869,
-0.0092385337,
0.0006437039,
-0.0420034453,
-0.0214484483,
-0.0631625801,
0.025267886,
-0.0520930327,
0.0361047164,
-0.0313012563,
0.0069166501,
-0.0192139409,
-0.0077531086,
-0.0016625016,
0.0171571057,
-0.0620854124,
-0.042659115,
-0.0249098819,
0.0209100284,
0.0170609746,
0.0359424166,
0.01901781,
-0.0574519075,
-0.0199814159,
-0.0236745421,
-0.0017519152,
-0.0444680192,
0.0099737272,
0.0348121822,
-0.0203862675,
-0.0381129012,
-0.0396057442,
-0.0622119978,
-0.033941716,
-0.0478071049,
-0.0275491644,
-0.0717922896,
0.0485743918,
-0.0294898488,
-0.0366037749,
-0.0948982984,
-0.0041670576,
0.000098666,
-0.0392531641,
0.086439997,
-0.0282481443,
0.0170726515,
0.0527536832,
0.0147305857,
-0.0049655973,
0.049288176,
0.0331178978,
0.0078800227,
0.0852027312,
0.0301237199,
0.0380644687,
0.0343990885,
-0.0029541173,
0.0057559703,
-0.0304519013,
0.0114015657,
-0.0260739382,
0.0451366901,
0.0223560408,
0.0514993146,
-0.0285969172,
-0.0105090747,
0.0863292664,
-0.0062985509,
0.0043286039,
0.0123093035,
0.0460848883,
-0.0094898846,
0.0242068246,
-0.0052382601,
-0.0409674272,
-0.0021890071,
-0.0205189567,
0.0111521622,
0.0100669032,
-0.0043698838,
-0.0041270279,
-0.0462152474,
-0.0022677199,
0.0182833634,
0.0147778671,
-0.0213024095,
0.0210583787,
0.058614511,
-0.0325394683,
0.0246570613,
0.0076776217,
-0.0535438582,
0.01393939,
-0.0529996492,
-0.0060736556,
0.0484063961,
0.1121819615,
-0.0465329774,
-0.0499062128,
-0.025828585,
-0.0201654229,
0.0286098756,
0.0834296197,
-0.0345173627,
0.0018924715,
-0.0101834154,
-0.0235098712,
-0.0518542752,
0.0603716448,
0.0030976513,
0.0539354198,
-0.0316138417,
0.0383196212,
-0.0501813889,
-0.0196196716,
0.0263260324,
-0.017595442,
-0.0094585493,
-0.0148536125,
-0.0085834377,
-0.0102954237,
0.0044574598,
-0.0481893718,
0.0081087118,
-0.0104291514,
0.0182932336,
-0.0371879227,
0.0086289458,
0.0253720451,
-0.0168398339,
0.049684383,
-0.0109960716,
-0.0399358794,
0.0523439087,
-0.0465159006,
-0.0294454526,
0.0018519588,
-0.0293010194,
0.0331009366,
-0.050409019,
0.0532960035,
-0.0126663325,
-0.0413352214,
-0.0387080684,
0.0325712748,
0.0200095773,
-0.0118419593,
-0.0096157789,
-0.019308487,
-0.0044182627,
-0.05112179,
-0.0322375707,
-0.0018923864,
0.010083952,
-0.0043530618,
0.0487144887,
-0.0043372796,
-0.0454233736,
-0.035204228,
-0.0780301839,
-0.0022346505,
-0.0381606519,
-0.0099102929,
0.0365196131,
0.0469044447,
-0.0225421935,
-0.0232091732,
0.0131520079,
-0.0444305874,
-0.0026554605,
0.0454591997,
0.0328353494,
-0.000166174,
0.0031842655,
-0.0913100392,
-0.0002076557,
-0.001872655,
0.0401793271,
0.014734528,
-0.0376304239,
-0.0293816943,
0.0222413465,
-0.0675387383,
0.0299178362,
0.0163863469,
-0.0085055539,
-0.0074250777,
0.007932853,
0.0825902373,
0.0571080707,
-0.0007284135,
0.023738252,
0.0545313098,
-0.0287971366,
-0.0182786211,
0.0088331094,
-0.0204175711,
-0.0186120626,
-0.0087695261,
-0.0359721519,
0.0329023376,
0.0484247468,
0.011539191,
-0.0372332036,
-0.0242060404,
0.0565639324,
0.0069929231,
-0.0312696472,
-0.0332676321,
-0.0301836934,
0.0007380103,
0.0274032969,
-0.0601128228,
-0.0428963266,
0.0794084221,
-0.0108222002,
0.0324121676,
-0.0450433269,
-0.0004490097,
-0.0198745672,
0.0606307425,
-0.0080408119,
0.0244967174,
-0.0306458026,
-0.005437904,
-0.0615374856,
-0.0143614141,
0.0480736904,
-0.0360427685,
0.0355139636,
-0.0940974653,
0.0054611065,
0.0173811112,
-0.0196925011,
-0.0303761642,
-0.0325661488,
-0.0302597955,
0.0149824517,
0.0070235794,
-0.0136597417,
-0.0510773547,
-0.0237250682,
0.0376060195,
0.0761841983,
-0.0170083046,
-0.02335619,
-0.0121842856,
0.0085474625,
0.0629484653,
-0.0108514074,
0.0010762092,
-0.0023885658,
0.0225844067,
0.0460805334,
-0.0057247905,
-0.0319661237,
-0.0389959365,
-0.0056442288,
-0.0106911752,
-0.0899203792,
-0.011173306,
-0.0129899858,
0.066989325,
-0.0514941998,
-0.0423619151,
0.1068624035,
0.0700364858,
-0.034025941,
-0.0085121784,
-0.0343151502,
0.0018787357,
0.0465057828,
0.0487993769,
-0.0528429002,
-0.0378610194,
0.0421805829,
0.029923737,
-0.0072256601,
-0.0334660821,
-0.0204231497,
-0.0955977812,
0.0365318023,
-0.0086022653,
-0.0053383335,
-0.0550557002,
-0.0331331566,
0.0271530561,
-0.030820122,
-0.0079732873,
0.0310403388,
0.002079146,
0.0236062538,
-0.0337582231,
0.0165476687,
-0.0344345048,
-0.0042059324,
-0.0320539661,
0.037424475,
0.0750990286,
0.0176312085,
0.0258146655,
0.011864542,
0.0247130822,
0.0529436953,
0.0076281801,
-0.0058236467,
0.0605729222,
-0.0125100743,
0.0228218455,
0.0001844389,
0.0099720629,
0.0417245403,
-0.037667118,
0.0061452435,
0.0491389781,
-0.0430951156,
0.0342566594,
-0.0123639414,
-0.022846641,
0.0076822783,
0.0755788982,
0.0503072888,
-0.0070386538,
0.0008455308,
-0.0634846613,
0.0016053846,
-0.0307309087,
-0.030024305,
-0.0297371726,
-0.0371626616,
0.0258323997,
-0.0719991177,
-0.0637084171,
0.0336075984,
-0.0141765494,
0.0583408698,
-0.023639394,
0.0070819366,
-0.0235928725,
-0.0435359292,
0.0101230219,
-0.0475116819,
0.0107273674,
-0.0188082885,
-0.0034983605,
0.0058201184,
-0.0387529321,
-0.0341543891,
-0.0055476623,
-0.0278582796,
-0.0624762662,
0.0351338349,
0.0437605307,
0.0277074147,
0.0571917146,
-0.0258046668,
-0.0700025707,
-0.0427962169,
0.0070609828,
-0.008750638,
0.0336824208,
0.0124815088,
-0.024321977,
-0.0143769719,
0.0502202995,
-0.0545737147,
0.0093725547,
0.0249883235,
0.062129993,
-0.0059799445,
-0.0568998083,
0.0426358767,
0.0008634857,
0.0569512732,
0.0177961159,
0.0028443446,
-0.0624997914,
0.0176426135,
-0.0646770373,
-0.0350982621,
-0.0294412933,
0.0318216085,
0.0125494897,
0.0050040162,
-0.0368848033,
0.0213860311,
-0.0610757731,
0.0555379614,
-0.0268970598,
-0.0330885723,
0.0210873969,
-0.0095349737,
0.0065753059,
0.0033360857,
-0.0115107354,
0.0471840054,
-0.0111657167,
0.0140355825,
-0.009764513,
0.0249928162,
0.0208955873,
-0.0189949013,
-0.0389634483,
0.0154928109,
-0.0667209625,
0.0034486619,
-0.0198918954,
0.0327265486,
0.0409902595,
-0.0208099224,
0.0497324988,
-0.0329609476,
-0.0529183485,
-0.021171378,
0.0425669439,
0.0501846522,
-0.047330495,
0.0161449611,
0.0035687508,
-0.0251450073,
0.0439260751,
0.0381459706,
-0.0399672762,
0.1040659249,
-0.0167060532,
-0.0555058308,
-0.0249128882,
-0.0434408337,
0.0025518418,
-0.0224205703,
-0.0272796396,
-0.0245464537,
-0.0561782867,
-0.0435072258,
-0.006195928,
0.0213297531,
-0.0165662654,
0.0309618656,
0.0011178984,
0.0786048099,
-0.0070852241,
-0.0167061593,
-0.0473317951,
0.0314247943,
-0.0244476143,
-0.0144047588,
-0.0375775658,
-5.330353337e-33,
-0.0356593058,
0.0015434375,
0.022956064,
-0.0165060051,
-0.0345153585,
-0.0049036369,
-0.0426122844,
0.0107605066,
-0.0012683981,
0.0159235615,
-0.027687192,
0.0500583127,
-0.0035546394,
0.0021908691,
0.0067906668,
0.0399814323,
0.0850242749,
0.0180898476,
-0.0464057289,
-0.018092664,
0.0062028649,
0.0236077644,
0.0672539473,
-0.0554606877,
0.0665229559,
0.0117184687,
-0.0431153998,
0.0562596656,
-0.0247014016,
0.0541456603,
0.0116526699,
0.0025034156,
0.0051918579,
-0.0441186018,
-0.0319610499,
-0.0275761411,
-0.0324658565,
-0.001528162,
0.0230238307,
0.0388279296,
-0.0206007324,
-0.0563357174,
0.0309901368,
-0.0186806545,
-0.0155036245,
-0.020401936,
0.0306019783,
-0.0408592895,
0.0106155844,
0.0116529092,
-0.0692438036,
0.0270073488,
0.0031051475,
-0.0322591439,
-0.0066844332,
0.0273861848,
0.0276785716,
-0.0040410236,
-0.0657159612,
0.0114544258,
0.024198506,
0.0550244376,
0.047171507,
-0.0328190587,
-0.006425505,
0.0556951575,
0.009105322,
0.0148300901,
-0.0115034971,
0.0055173161,
-0.0074131414,
0.0273698233,
0.0388685316,
0.087763615,
0.0008636137,
0.016479576,
-0.0290006716,
0.013610146,
-0.0783842206,
0.0345683247,
-0.0239825286,
0.0208771732,
-0.0116442684,
0.0189760029,
-0.0571293235,
0.0048694327,
-0.0382949971,
-0.0245149769,
0.034654811,
0.0261643995,
-0.012477315,
0.0171203241,
-0.0050757774,
-0.011809757,
0.00973613,
0.0286909845,
-0.0449375659,
0.0412040763,
-0.0062611615,
0.0027201406,
0.010940549,
0.033959236,
0.0410860926,
0.0157898162,
-0.0061166706,
-0.0227674171,
0.0616343953,
0.0398631133,
-0.0601915717,
0.0198079161,
-0.0011555341,
0.0275692698,
-0.0328113176,
-0.0011437485,
0.0085173519,
0.0246023815,
-0.0124078169,
0.0014260694,
0.0590089895,
0.0313615836,
-0.0384784676,
0.0159370676,
0.0111023737,
0.0139611065,
-0.0045153131,
0.0202823579,
-0.0084143635,
0.0151727218,
0.006009304,
-0.0022794574,
-0.0164165888,
-0.001002092,
2.473e-7,
0.0756041557,
0.0686129853,
0.0381214134,
0.0094638215,
0.0045482866,
0.0365830436,
-0.0044826958,
0.0245116856,
0.0421515331,
0.0395007171,
0.0175079741,
0.0170128252,
0.0427933857,
-0.0010533052,
-0.0527290367,
-0.0018707176,
-0.0401200019,
0.0066765761,
-0.0462798141,
-0.0586982295,
0.0195854288,
0.0577600375,
0.0457039401,
-0.0000252865,
-0.0525949262,
-0.0393285938,
0.0738116577,
-0.0242752656,
-0.0356237739,
0.0276923291,
0.0760381445,
0.0401621349,
0.016322203,
-0.0105895773,
-0.0439024158,
-0.0097092967,
0.0011810488,
0.0582341589,
-0.0326447226,
0.0245382022,
-0.0056068012,
0.0039982949,
-0.0040480951,
-0.0375267901,
0.04953935,
-0.0136724804,
0.0183512755,
-0.0396316163,
-0.0396170281,
0.0483699068,
0.0214369819,
-0.0397529975,
-0.026476549,
0.0088182054,
0.0156567767,
0.0720778629,
-0.0254646502,
-0.0368586257,
-0.0570096187,
-0.0048948773,
0.0013011749,
-0.0236191247,
-0.02026904,
-0.0225551259,
0.0066607278,
-0.1135926843,
0.0077265748,
2.256742294e-34,
0.0141072031,
0.0219505038,
0.0079451753,
0.0075073801,
0.0550965853,
-0.0063326303,
-0.0148267401,
-0.0034790093,
-0.0231948905,
-0.0655710399,
-0.0349699073
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16083v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16083v1 | BERT Goes Off-Topic: Investigating the Domain Transfer Challenge using Genre Classification | 2023-11-27T18:53:31 | 2023-11-27T18:53:31 | Dmitri Roussinov, Serge Sharoff | cs.CL | cs.CL | While performance of many text classification tasks has been recently
improved due to Pre-trained Language Models (PLMs), in this paper we show that
they still suffer from a performance gap when the underlying distribution of
topics changes. For example, a genre classifier trained on \textit{political}
topics often fails when tested on documents about \textit{sport} or
\textit{medicine}. In this work, we quantify this phenomenon empirically with a
large corpus and a large set of topics. Consequently, we verify that domain
transfer remains challenging both for classic PLMs, such as BERT, and for
modern large models, such as GPT-3. We also suggest and successfully test a
possible remedy: after augmenting the training dataset with
topically-controlled synthetic texts, the F1 score improves by up to 50\% for
some topics, nearing on-topic training results, while others show little to no
improvement. While our empirical results focus on genre classification, our
methodology is applicable to other classification tasks such as gender,
authorship, or sentiment classification. The code and data to replicate the
experiments are available at https://github.com/dminus1/genre | [
0.0069485526,
0.033669278,
-0.0019613185,
0.0181159787,
-0.0115421405,
-0.0023232347,
0.0179715678,
0.0022135226,
-0.0489850864,
-0.0765298158,
-0.0395565405,
-0.0161718298,
-0.0226487778,
0.0466840863,
-0.0094612017,
-0.0559102744,
0.0240381826,
-0.0196734294,
0.0297686905,
-0.0121352747,
-0.0076634954,
0.0231974144,
-0.0051028524,
0.005758543,
0.0386577547,
-0.030906776,
0.0140469,
0.0125734527,
0.0312263016,
0.0107638277,
0.0615975857,
0.0615799502,
0.0320024639,
0.0278592464,
0.0000015866,
-0.066631183,
-0.0416307002,
-0.0190717913,
0.0414898135,
0.025568448,
0.0538807921,
0.0240951423,
-0.007161865,
0.0507654361,
-0.0103589464,
-0.0257197376,
0.014414818,
0.059827067,
0.032670483,
0.0832397714,
-0.025461562,
0.0095150117,
0.0272393953,
-0.0231332239,
0.0028176925,
-0.0288380999,
0.0373824239,
-0.0457941443,
-0.0201387852,
0.0095806736,
-0.0165668186,
0.0009763525,
-0.0273192879,
0.0221093725,
0.0159234777,
0.0394616872,
-0.0845652819,
0.0197179653,
0.0287814606,
0.0533291288,
0.0000392441,
-0.0572725311,
0.011049943,
0.0160581116,
0.003089593,
0.0461622067,
-0.0278087165,
-0.0131589957,
-0.0234068744,
0.0118084094,
0.0320981778,
-0.0024856392,
0.0284745134,
0.0278322045,
-0.0136717688,
0.0390188992,
0.0392949879,
-0.0293656569,
0.0400209092,
0.0355769023,
0.002162101,
-0.0514864028,
0.0399852805,
-0.021885179,
0.0275187735,
-0.0059913401,
-0.0729538575,
-0.030380493,
-0.0109680137,
-0.0475076661,
-0.0141028287,
-0.0056205071,
-0.0201566163,
0.0445375517,
0.0074650417,
-0.0277322717,
-0.0274183434,
0.0090194782,
-0.0132974051,
-0.0208991859,
-0.0810749456,
-0.0028340172,
-0.05809246,
0.0006524827,
0.0416800901,
-0.0109321447,
0.0103584854,
0.0047413912,
0.0169012416,
-0.0441447645,
-0.0357894041,
-0.0306395032,
-0.0497873165,
-0.0086386492,
-0.0174076837,
0.0628445148,
-0.0228889864,
0.0641816109,
-0.0288853087,
0.0363047682,
0.0034895432,
0.015552571,
0.0139306057,
-0.0585008115,
0.0476703122,
0.0003189708,
-0.0081078056,
-0.0530765429,
-0.0544962138,
0.0615422763,
-0.0107496846,
-0.0502557382,
0.0510382913,
-0.0522311293,
-0.0100230277,
0.0275201611,
-0.0004905564,
-0.0052463342,
-0.0144458609,
0.0060413387,
-0.0370782875,
0.0561169796,
-0.0121228844,
-0.0024354137,
0.0840795413,
0.0106505007,
-0.030909013,
0.0602208152,
0.0250876397,
0.017342031,
0.0669776946,
-0.0419368446,
0.0230124276,
0.0237544421,
0.01407554,
0.0532948785,
0.0174399223,
-0.0046637333,
0.00628309,
0.0197324958,
0.0562851653,
0.0049585123,
0.0046725809,
-0.0088346694,
0.0648278072,
0.0481678024,
0.0305590015,
0.0690302774,
0.0026743186,
0.0133859264,
0.0245667603,
0.0288787019,
-0.007226828,
-0.0188224837,
-0.0178645793,
-0.0181867126,
0.0196337681,
-0.0063363072,
-0.0471109971,
0.0234791283,
-0.0047293887,
-0.0060576228,
-0.0162076559,
-0.0240715295,
0.0752347484,
0.0153603582,
-0.0066005061,
0.053981442,
0.028624,
-0.0516916215,
0.023668807,
-0.0271286368,
0.0197933316,
0.0458157845,
0.0209824536,
-0.0752840489,
-0.0389337428,
-0.0259804986,
0.025954552,
0.0394046195,
0.0407495573,
-0.0132074039,
0.0267342068,
-0.0087961638,
-0.0122014415,
-0.0217196438,
0.0264219157,
0.0241777655,
0.0062378058,
0.053100612,
-0.002563223,
-0.0865235925,
0.0212808233,
0.0370491482,
-0.0251135677,
-0.0277223643,
-0.0002103229,
-0.0154187977,
0.0353401229,
0.0146582276,
-0.0485449359,
-0.0313239358,
0.0132828616,
-0.0327604599,
-0.0352915451,
0.0041821362,
-0.0029280821,
-0.0078875078,
0.0205675717,
-0.0599475093,
-0.0009674118,
0.0502129719,
-0.0257277377,
-0.0064602569,
0.015045288,
-0.0042226636,
0.0403408706,
-0.0249797255,
0.0206226073,
-0.0350869112,
-0.0028922153,
-0.0138969049,
0.0225786716,
0.0477747023,
0.0127164563,
-0.0524239056,
-0.0160791669,
0.0329295881,
-0.0050269458,
0.0227066018,
0.0357201397,
-0.002013809,
0.0392376184,
0.0510532074,
-0.0123415804,
-0.0351295881,
-0.0291842278,
-0.0978568718,
0.0178208612,
-0.0355275534,
0.0448184349,
0.0176302716,
-0.0129791796,
-0.029271936,
0.0422029011,
-0.0470171273,
-0.0463537388,
-0.0602871403,
0.0099763665,
0.0376360081,
-0.0403451659,
0.0275042988,
-0.032346759,
-0.0035455327,
-0.015533438,
0.0719275028,
-0.0207379442,
0.0138983959,
-0.0285303872,
0.011871133,
-0.0122387046,
0.0106870057,
-0.0131914876,
-0.0021288015,
-0.0284663718,
-0.0246073809,
0.0493899398,
0.0068059391,
0.0330004506,
0.0155717032,
0.0533378422,
0.0203037057,
-0.0202626027,
0.0033077712,
-0.0027760314,
0.0135093676,
-0.0275449324,
-0.0086063696,
0.0453403071,
0.0540620983,
-0.027389681,
-0.021421181,
-0.0388902612,
-0.027137218,
-0.0192775019,
0.0452373326,
0.0002969446,
0.0124576483,
-0.0214911737,
0.0222396199,
0.0043034772,
-0.013317653,
0.0361523069,
-0.0318697169,
0.0336822905,
-0.1070980951,
-0.0280777793,
-0.0247138999,
0.049760215,
-0.0158274379,
-0.0099769402,
0.0471380204,
-0.0052289804,
-0.0267095026,
0.0139249107,
0.0184139032,
-0.0202747509,
0.0313820504,
-0.0165295228,
0.0308881793,
-0.0090433126,
-0.0340641998,
-0.0105909724,
-0.0627488121,
0.0150439842,
0.001731178,
-0.0221931171,
-0.027320886,
-0.0313381627,
-0.0188981965,
-0.0178435817,
0.0720815361,
-0.0175725743,
-0.0301721618,
0.0172970109,
0.0706743896,
0.0064286082,
-0.033166606,
-0.0459259264,
-0.0375301503,
-0.0286510661,
0.0065029347,
0.0068546063,
0.009009474,
-0.0338651091,
0.0013655233,
0.0406290181,
-0.0755687729,
-0.0487860553,
-0.0264744405,
0.0461394712,
-0.0290849227,
-0.015328777,
0.1135095507,
0.0368051119,
-0.0368685983,
-0.0272216052,
-0.0019074791,
0.0198600627,
-0.0074206921,
0.0217160452,
-0.0350865833,
-0.007228645,
0.0180506017,
0.0523337349,
0.0226098187,
-0.0141430385,
-0.0125720501,
-0.0908552557,
0.014399196,
-0.007001156,
-0.0521009639,
-0.0360856056,
-0.069589518,
0.0139298104,
-0.0049165399,
-0.002770368,
-0.0391512103,
-0.020931961,
0.0313320123,
0.0397554971,
-0.0140012801,
-0.0538289845,
0.045029182,
-0.0393703207,
0.0425409116,
0.035670884,
0.0512768887,
-0.0571872294,
-0.0139204357,
0.0280750692,
-0.0076387152,
-0.0531489216,
-0.0038382185,
0.087778531,
-0.0392567664,
0.0371394455,
0.0290647708,
0.0045244372,
-0.0396509767,
-0.0265385155,
0.0542614125,
0.0603032932,
0.0056790072,
-0.0752803758,
-0.0179952625,
0.0042527281,
-0.0106162811,
0.0798861161,
0.0096700173,
-0.0770864636,
0.0005345654,
-0.0422128402,
-0.0002853519,
-0.0167917497,
0.0117688328,
-0.0037087009,
-0.0711373538,
-0.0620133542,
-0.0474605225,
-0.0164641272,
0.0154412845,
0.0460329354,
-0.0031275772,
-0.0020609396,
0.012709735,
-0.006336302,
-0.0681042895,
0.0485203192,
0.0040157549,
0.0006759969,
-0.0514076985,
-0.0536564961,
0.0452191345,
-0.0379562527,
-0.0242430549,
-0.0300927628,
-0.0392640606,
-0.0309730936,
0.021599479,
-0.0296739433,
0.0188566297,
0.0083024772,
-0.0134392474,
-0.0423021354,
0.0323131196,
0.0651819855,
-0.0525901169,
0.007382412,
0.0600219183,
-0.0099575324,
-0.0098905638,
0.0019646119,
-0.0540212728,
0.0363447331,
0.0206697118,
0.0003322119,
0.0050326404,
-0.0104063451,
-0.0362002626,
-0.0108736753,
0.0878230184,
0.0104204603,
-0.0553311445,
-0.060965538,
-0.0050726836,
0.0242446009,
-0.0030995144,
-0.0275820158,
-0.0370454192,
0.0658563748,
0.0123617658,
-0.0530579649,
0.0392231233,
-0.0344438702,
0.0423729792,
-0.0405329801,
0.0200050604,
0.0206117239,
0.0939316228,
0.0331277512,
-0.0107720522,
-0.0323303305,
-0.0199813899,
0.0454131253,
0.0226730034,
-0.027961174,
0.0287866052,
0.030745402,
0.0267960876,
0.0269301608,
-0.006160392,
-0.0805583075,
0.0139770461,
-0.0285476241,
0.0510321073,
0.0198043138,
-0.0283857845,
0.0333104432,
-0.0181776155,
-0.0266506802,
-0.0369672552,
0.0273420103,
0.0097433347,
0.0315001644,
0.0302077495,
0.0000051603,
-0.0259874929,
0.0236704089,
0.0620946363,
0.0567562282,
0.0188710783,
0.0672500208,
-0.0290941782,
-0.0142962411,
-0.0064260378,
0.0347223319,
-0.0071881963,
-0.0029130585,
0.0332285054,
-0.0310165174,
-0.0338013805,
0.0510114059,
-0.0739667341,
0.0212044995,
-0.014409489,
0.0364023857,
0.1030343547,
-0.0410018675,
0.0117546804,
-0.0350942984,
0.0253523532,
0.0180550888,
-0.0053331712,
-0.0088962177,
-5.691047534e-33,
-0.0309881587,
-0.0014523263,
-0.0113298455,
0.0480274074,
-0.0169963185,
0.0044600265,
-0.0306025669,
0.0107965367,
0.0270167757,
0.0128240818,
-0.0171591118,
0.0501060709,
0.0080013443,
0.0382589921,
-0.0297546461,
-0.0487820096,
0.0517407916,
-0.0091857826,
-0.0559210144,
0.0249546077,
0.0167304594,
0.0639762953,
0.0428391881,
-0.0972307175,
-0.0051125898,
0.0000892015,
-0.0027656441,
-0.0294202976,
0.0419260114,
0.0116410004,
-0.0126389898,
0.0545044579,
0.0384331532,
-0.0349874273,
0.0262094587,
0.059931282,
-0.0590267219,
-0.0523984022,
0.0020730824,
-0.0037616461,
0.0376665443,
-0.0238758922,
0.0134682665,
0.0349379778,
0.0048113801,
-0.05234484,
0.0733633935,
-0.0108007956,
-0.0048212158,
-0.0871639326,
-0.0730425045,
0.0310454257,
0.0120389527,
-0.0164653119,
0.0119341882,
0.0102741169,
0.0193337183,
0.031685859,
-0.0244686175,
0.0107167168,
-0.002607296,
0.0230852887,
0.0024249435,
-0.0146783432,
-0.0374807045,
0.0348560736,
-0.0381706655,
0.0421867929,
-0.0060870186,
-0.015442295,
0.0495255888,
0.0290995911,
0.0006446656,
0.0233465843,
0.0226879194,
-0.0101521527,
-0.0569566116,
0.0391933657,
0.0010617001,
-0.0606915578,
-0.0057423995,
0.0016107154,
-0.0186348315,
-0.0370663404,
-0.0416673757,
-0.0227886494,
-0.0081359195,
0.0034366653,
-0.0101333009,
-0.0317005217,
-0.0020991289,
-0.0090858713,
-0.0079082735,
-0.0209292136,
-0.0522424243,
0.0144258169,
-0.0642657802,
0.0116077671,
-0.0124976067,
0.0442851894,
-0.0675416067,
-0.0436484665,
0.0252996869,
0.0170872863,
0.0274053216,
-0.014729796,
0.0402331874,
0.026532406,
-0.0764677599,
-0.0212399531,
-0.0167775229,
-0.0137083204,
0.0165183805,
0.1086205691,
-0.0160617027,
0.0335029252,
0.0196149312,
0.0596617274,
0.0363001525,
-0.0038612543,
-0.0385414772,
-0.0052641686,
-0.0092535838,
0.0211727377,
-0.0310967341,
-0.040610794,
-0.016709527,
-0.0082835071,
0.0259442348,
-0.0869705975,
-0.0426423512,
-0.0628247857,
2.404e-7,
0.0769975185,
0.0835800543,
-0.0293522719,
-0.0318287723,
0.0014833009,
0.0646249503,
-0.0389341488,
0.096238412,
0.0199009757,
0.0418686233,
-0.0065734461,
0.0208579209,
0.0456335507,
0.0542277433,
-0.0858291239,
-0.0332377143,
-0.0266542882,
0.0157640092,
-0.037562713,
0.0203961842,
0.0118599692,
0.0575554408,
0.0592382327,
-0.0200825613,
0.026779687,
-0.0542284064,
0.0782841146,
-0.0441434942,
-0.0056227231,
0.0440940633,
-0.0101304967,
0.0099132638,
-0.0362809338,
0.0157871731,
-0.0446740948,
0.0191253219,
0.0266704913,
0.064217262,
-0.0026513375,
-0.0040880083,
-0.0144064492,
-0.0156756043,
0.010431068,
-0.0377940796,
0.0560804307,
-0.0254357103,
-0.0316123851,
-0.0098379571,
-0.0357791744,
-0.0137100108,
0.0273176674,
-0.0311171338,
-0.0167177282,
-0.0111416811,
0.0124682626,
0.0005010238,
-0.0341180377,
-0.0743289813,
0.0161692873,
0.0405273438,
-0.0367706381,
-0.0597361401,
-0.004852565,
0.0178043172,
0.06222317,
-0.0845291317,
0.0599423833,
2.132403461e-34,
0.0397504121,
-0.0073926114,
-0.0306942128,
-0.0411911681,
0.0093116527,
-0.0053489706,
0.0448203422,
-0.0109084798,
0.0171869192,
-0.0142632537,
0.040378511
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16079v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16079v1 | MEDITRON-70B: Scaling Medical Pretraining for Large Language Models | 2023-11-27T18:49:43 | 2023-11-27T18:49:43 | Zeming Chen, Alejandro Hernández Cano, Angelika Romanou, Antoine Bonnet, Kyle Matoba, Francesco Salvi, Matteo Pagliardini, Simin Fan, Andreas Köpf, Amirkeivan Mohtashami, Alexandre Sallinen, Alireza Sakhaeirad, Vinitra Swamy, Igor Krawczuk, Deniz Bayazit, Axel Marmet, Syrielle Montariol, Mary-Anne Hartley, Martin Jaggi, Antoine Bosselut | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) can potentially democratize access to medical
knowledge. While many efforts have been made to harness and improve LLMs'
medical knowledge and reasoning capacities, the resulting models are either
closed-source (e.g., PaLM, GPT-4) or limited in scale (<= 13B parameters),
which restricts their abilities. In this work, we improve access to large-scale
medical LLMs by releasing MEDITRON: a suite of open-source LLMs with 7B and 70B
parameters adapted to the medical domain. MEDITRON builds on Llama-2 (through
our adaptation of Nvidia's Megatron-LM distributed trainer), and extends
pretraining on a comprehensively curated medical corpus, including selected
PubMed articles, abstracts, and internationally-recognized medical guidelines.
Evaluations using four major medical benchmarks show significant performance
gains over several state-of-the-art baselines before and after task-specific
finetuning. Overall, MEDITRON achieves a 6% absolute performance gain over the
best public baseline in its parameter class and 3% over the strongest baseline
we finetuned from Llama-2. Compared to closed-source LLMs, MEDITRON-70B
outperforms GPT-3.5 and Med-PaLM and is within 5% of GPT-4 and 10% of
Med-PaLM-2. We release our code for curating the medical pretraining corpus and
the MEDITRON model weights to drive open-source development of more capable
medical LLMs. | [
0.0276036635,
0.0444415845,
0.0133972391,
-0.0024359592,
0.0019962285,
0.030907372,
0.0121930456,
0.0362895764,
-0.0151769677,
-0.0084154336,
-0.0607938096,
-0.0560261756,
0.002660752,
0.0291773994,
0.0266346931,
-0.0477374531,
0.0495921783,
-0.0060248198,
0.016647594,
-0.0188307036,
-0.0133726103,
0.0046620355,
-0.0473424979,
0.0317477398,
0.0424159802,
-0.0161870737,
0.0412252434,
-0.0110556632,
0.0219644625,
-0.0796478093,
0.0078577138,
0.0487842076,
0.0177309513,
0.0204388425,
0.0000021306,
-0.0511939786,
0.0147922803,
0.0144425016,
-0.0177903697,
0.017454274,
0.0481679104,
-0.0464340597,
-0.0223985594,
0.0302297547,
-0.0433521271,
-0.0533151142,
0.0253024045,
0.0294410605,
0.0425814539,
0.0643324703,
-0.0043676533,
0.0103271492,
0.0491094328,
-0.0585164987,
-0.0098419432,
-0.0357592255,
0.0265631583,
0.0104506379,
0.0354085602,
-0.0061364598,
0.018036006,
0.0292016473,
0.0074919681,
0.038792152,
0.0068353228,
0.0689899102,
-0.0361991748,
-0.0105851777,
-0.0013561198,
0.0670221224,
-0.0113377962,
-0.0115070753,
0.014860522,
0.0046845507,
-0.0374446474,
-0.028115537,
-0.0426793247,
0.017088132,
-0.003782083,
0.0119544026,
0.012918557,
-0.0361671634,
0.0618677065,
0.0183075648,
-0.019698048,
0.0136800101,
0.0274580643,
-0.0165378489,
0.035481371,
0.0061686952,
-0.0220276434,
-0.044633016,
0.056320291,
0.035242416,
-0.0421712436,
-0.0059654391,
-0.0317523703,
-0.0507848822,
0.0938797146,
-0.0334476903,
0.0372511037,
0.0089775166,
-0.0145369414,
0.0449814722,
-0.016292816,
-0.0072998074,
-0.0570670366,
0.049127575,
-0.0390002578,
0.0276704226,
-0.0332315825,
0.0023384457,
-0.0189935938,
-0.0096990429,
-0.0305402987,
-0.0097999126,
-0.0824731439,
-0.0103799757,
0.0210313443,
-0.0175070632,
0.027431393,
0.0391247571,
-0.0219927374,
-0.0159508195,
-0.00152653,
0.0490988381,
-0.0129177719,
0.0253237244,
-0.0133972941,
-0.0646851361,
-0.0072999182,
0.0066418019,
-0.0321894549,
-0.0305121709,
0.0578802861,
0.057450965,
-0.0056879953,
-0.0331867747,
0.0016086922,
-0.013744452,
-0.004116077,
-0.068657659,
0.0114186322,
-0.0718419403,
0.0260016993,
-0.0012231867,
0.0291872434,
-0.0121874241,
0.0194807034,
0.0155808963,
-0.0363790132,
0.0720976368,
-0.0611412339,
0.004595513,
0.0456953794,
0.0377511382,
0.0030450728,
0.0382339433,
0.0372113995,
-0.029829938,
-0.00111344,
-0.0133568421,
-0.025261363,
0.0147524746,
0.0218121465,
-0.0303183887,
0.0060946872,
0.0284888875,
0.0069033988,
0.104794085,
-0.0068840659,
0.0716347471,
-0.0300805978,
-0.0160725415,
0.0506576113,
0.0733101517,
0.017647719,
0.0027175166,
0.030272482,
-0.0493332967,
0.0231950246,
-0.0601056665,
-0.0360410027,
0.0019312932,
0.0258560125,
-0.0007325687,
-0.0207450688,
0.0474188626,
-0.0326855928,
-0.027623279,
-0.0392861851,
-0.026123913,
-0.0305275172,
-0.0020400595,
0.058903683,
-0.0170271732,
-0.0263338257,
0.0870925039,
0.0585961826,
-0.051570531,
-0.0111016519,
-0.0504125841,
-0.008442034,
0.059442956,
0.0513853654,
-0.0505324043,
-0.0723339617,
-0.0092152068,
0.0268166214,
0.0280289389,
0.0465742424,
0.0036702855,
0.0240585264,
-0.0920312852,
0.017981546,
0.0337120406,
0.0114042573,
-0.0070419819,
0.0300457794,
0.0361232944,
-0.0313381515,
-0.0134820705,
-0.0155482115,
0.0530800112,
-0.0608970188,
-0.0280854534,
-0.0115901539,
-0.028167326,
0.0486691296,
-0.0078240186,
-0.0231063012,
0.0193477068,
0.0534361824,
-0.0460662544,
0.0000366944,
-0.0178342517,
-0.0639440417,
-0.0189361777,
0.0462929346,
-0.0163504016,
-0.0206254497,
0.0049598822,
-0.0304129682,
-0.0238654409,
-0.0162807889,
-0.0211512726,
0.0309746191,
-0.0236131977,
0.0172545351,
0.0178600289,
0.0069721378,
-0.0388146453,
0.0114484178,
-0.0233533103,
-0.0145460553,
0.0380153395,
-0.0421640985,
0.0131659638,
-0.0405676812,
-0.0288116187,
0.038394969,
0.0008131534,
0.0183431208,
-0.0408507213,
0.0324562378,
-0.0285911057,
-0.0440230221,
-0.1007061899,
0.022859931,
0.0048514879,
0.0244699903,
0.0321597792,
0.0212559141,
-0.0203216225,
-0.0173916016,
-0.0238215942,
-0.0096007036,
0.0150087178,
0.0254674051,
0.0216687471,
0.0303840134,
0.0219718218,
-0.0345794782,
-0.0158742107,
-0.0289620422,
0.006319047,
-0.0095989034,
0.0114312246,
-0.0015884491,
-0.005312195,
-0.0362101421,
0.0136659779,
-0.011945786,
-0.0289707649,
0.0538939796,
-0.0094000492,
0.0014463133,
0.0620012432,
-0.0007420963,
0.013834307,
0.0529143214,
0.0196957402,
-0.0171231069,
0.0185347702,
-0.0130194984,
-0.0494998358,
-0.0281889047,
-0.0200304259,
-0.0031149308,
0.1079395115,
-0.0174071044,
0.0109067643,
-0.0494331829,
-0.0297998767,
-0.0303174164,
0.0163753387,
-0.0202250015,
0.0297230203,
-0.0353297628,
0.0125272721,
-0.0030167827,
-0.0526566356,
0.086296089,
-0.0366583914,
0.0229750574,
-0.0798873678,
-0.0222498849,
-0.0280040521,
0.0020046202,
-0.0077139116,
0.0152155692,
0.009021516,
-0.0167299788,
-0.0044369493,
0.0346708968,
-0.0155487852,
-0.0613226928,
0.0540065691,
-0.0310209133,
0.0148001201,
-0.0067688269,
-0.0683459044,
-0.0087117739,
-0.0044227601,
-0.0655777305,
-0.0011013121,
0.0069812499,
-0.0063992627,
-0.0566503517,
0.0005068919,
-0.0134685431,
0.0792870969,
0.0115482826,
-0.0010025455,
-0.0078820139,
-0.0053493511,
0.0155620165,
0.0016292469,
0.0186468139,
-0.0466266163,
0.0063954736,
0.0826273933,
0.0319551006,
-0.016057238,
-0.0342431441,
-0.0023540263,
0.0291915126,
-0.0403569117,
-0.0111859804,
0.0159947593,
0.0534475967,
-0.0567775257,
0.0002347658,
0.1084314659,
0.0135063259,
-0.0840499178,
0.0147405034,
-0.0042206147,
0.035054829,
0.0011554289,
0.0163037255,
-0.085704878,
-0.051309485,
-0.0033616535,
0.0418614447,
0.0050824224,
-0.0160041451,
0.0175068919,
-0.0415550657,
0.009349769,
0.0099441828,
-0.0307654589,
-0.0047656195,
-0.0290527064,
-0.0148512209,
-0.0289240945,
0.0016012675,
0.0022151682,
-0.0254682545,
0.0097314799,
0.0130158206,
-0.0342947617,
-0.0848636255,
0.0500965565,
-0.024635544,
0.0573270172,
0.0477555655,
0.0103530986,
-0.0069890092,
-0.0438601375,
0.0198841542,
-0.0073252749,
0.0133311506,
-0.0289728623,
0.0740041733,
-0.0065382035,
-0.0081017185,
-0.0483134016,
0.0335417911,
-0.0495609045,
-0.0341259316,
-0.0185260624,
0.0823303163,
-0.0191617832,
-0.0181713924,
-0.0256116744,
0.0151040051,
0.0020566939,
0.0341899619,
-0.003578543,
-0.0096850079,
-0.0215700101,
0.0085364794,
0.0346056335,
0.0138121871,
-0.0046150996,
0.0084375041,
-0.018184891,
-0.0055661011,
-0.0393732898,
-0.0249691121,
0.0371120274,
0.0078721484,
0.0066689122,
0.0230512097,
0.0299651343,
0.0020842284,
-0.0619332306,
0.090470165,
0.0051020007,
0.026421668,
-0.0977822915,
-0.0505018719,
0.0602828003,
0.0147558833,
-0.020990992,
0.0310501046,
-0.0314203501,
-0.0372380577,
-0.018957004,
0.0650474876,
0.0271464642,
0.0115433056,
-0.0177064296,
-0.0464621298,
0.0345794298,
0.0369604528,
-0.0590043999,
0.0179635137,
0.0142073343,
-0.0488355719,
0.001038896,
0.0341810733,
-0.0042338404,
0.0216637235,
-0.0033199319,
0.0305767711,
-0.0097547229,
-0.0181606952,
0.0003018675,
0.0241899807,
0.0564988554,
-0.0336983874,
0.0040011634,
-0.0400824063,
0.0286420416,
-0.0046461751,
0.0449439846,
-0.0311425813,
0.0074444977,
0.0557582527,
-0.0164004732,
-0.0188433267,
-0.0169058964,
-0.0198166706,
-0.029807318,
-0.0525000282,
0.047560215,
-0.0019199314,
0.0049319975,
0.0659058839,
-0.0229022875,
-0.0093741855,
0.0121145053,
-0.0360379145,
0.0321775377,
-0.034586098,
0.0747449324,
-0.0057165036,
0.0142530147,
0.0003432764,
0.0669593662,
-0.0320305042,
-0.0474712737,
-0.0168843791,
0.037136402,
0.0598086044,
0.016674418,
0.0521928072,
-0.0052497224,
0.0004124522,
-0.0234127175,
0.0057269,
-0.053779155,
0.0228446852,
0.0612081401,
0.0115858689,
-0.0041821287,
0.0039298111,
0.0907591954,
-0.001550538,
0.0773528889,
0.0369335935,
-0.0145772528,
-0.0393226072,
-0.0329779349,
0.0031623922,
0.0162292644,
-0.0756311044,
0.0038847337,
-0.0384743996,
-0.05099044,
0.0301513989,
0.0316060968,
-0.0547114573,
-0.0363406874,
0.0467891507,
0.0324200466,
-0.004126884,
-0.0403534584,
-0.0049291309,
0.0478289835,
-0.033604078,
-0.0256050453,
0.0381591655,
-6.242237202e-33,
-0.0072030979,
0.021840658,
0.0609056428,
-0.0155634349,
-0.0234985799,
0.029478319,
-0.023757305,
-0.0064790426,
-0.0227183551,
0.0478869081,
-0.0256322082,
0.0061492571,
0.0173725318,
0.0194244497,
0.0004704001,
-0.0265741441,
0.0137222735,
-0.0003950509,
-0.0218822006,
0.0427366793,
-0.021419676,
0.0620552115,
0.0592619739,
-0.0656930581,
-0.0302635487,
0.0057276576,
0.029410623,
0.0029475396,
-0.0475105979,
0.0598490685,
-0.0589713342,
0.0332240127,
0.0293094665,
-0.0106159896,
-0.0145686846,
-0.0126947723,
-0.0789310858,
-0.0018926137,
0.0280029401,
-0.0077494918,
-0.0305245128,
-0.0346304849,
0.0424159802,
-0.0058337464,
-0.0430746675,
-0.0098144114,
-0.0060233031,
-0.0305187032,
-0.0299889371,
-0.0290794801,
-0.0236160737,
0.0499017723,
0.0250703357,
-0.0086663598,
-0.0115279388,
-0.0257731434,
-0.0375336371,
0.0383110903,
-0.0240304228,
-0.0054373038,
0.0554657392,
0.0360787064,
0.0285292305,
-0.014704016,
0.0104608294,
0.0643258318,
0.0138504272,
-0.0281580444,
-0.0162525903,
0.0230055563,
-0.0134405633,
0.036924053,
0.0529417172,
0.0227853693,
0.0228077788,
-0.032600604,
-0.1167908013,
0.0056803264,
-0.0250805672,
0.0530292094,
0.0103768855,
-0.0023098558,
-0.0271072499,
-0.0102234427,
-0.0069229435,
-0.003415867,
-0.0097261257,
-0.0295534972,
0.0416916125,
0.0152270272,
0.0138044618,
0.0304581877,
0.0062722536,
-0.0074846642,
0.0077082487,
-0.0103011681,
0.0423622839,
0.0101954313,
-0.0430369638,
0.0281939674,
-0.0766248852,
-0.0227675028,
0.0198791511,
-0.0296295602,
0.0615174323,
0.0046994388,
0.0253322441,
-0.0045538885,
-0.0556795895,
-0.0102182776,
-0.0150643205,
-0.0097300084,
0.0146247884,
0.0463906452,
0.0484421365,
0.0164070614,
0.0089713717,
0.0660152882,
-0.0198637862,
-0.0219865125,
-0.0530342348,
-0.0407354422,
0.0252673738,
0.0104684904,
-0.0375692584,
0.0029928731,
-0.0456988253,
0.0619533807,
0.0400367938,
-0.0725872815,
-0.0188391954,
0.0203653537,
2.825e-7,
0.0868921727,
0.0702664107,
-0.0073929946,
-0.0519221351,
0.0244654957,
0.0131334076,
-0.0298765488,
0.0076649729,
0.006260043,
-0.0096840085,
0.0101142628,
0.0374541245,
0.0404277258,
0.0321805626,
-0.0633332431,
-0.0310599338,
-0.0873929039,
0.0030758562,
-0.038297452,
-0.0646096244,
-0.0062560439,
0.0872389749,
-0.026167633,
-0.0453673862,
0.0499848835,
-0.0343834311,
0.05981002,
-0.047446806,
-0.0120110149,
0.0411614329,
0.031709075,
0.0163470656,
-0.0102256956,
0.011954423,
-0.0182857737,
-0.0218930338,
-0.0169353541,
0.1224355847,
-0.0508449674,
0.0204506516,
0.0419473536,
-0.0177458599,
-0.0075414008,
-0.0447720811,
0.0390169844,
-0.0445935987,
-0.0377005823,
-0.038640745,
-0.0107225189,
-0.0514332727,
0.0743025616,
-0.0442776643,
0.0035122072,
0.0296019968,
0.0234321672,
0.0052625984,
-0.0654297248,
-0.0871318504,
-0.0297011677,
0.0303822532,
-0.0403549038,
-0.0419970453,
-0.0278674997,
-0.0252619535,
-0.004042794,
-0.0795814097,
0.0124307768,
2.542057502e-34,
0.0262075961,
-0.0146373697,
0.0160019584,
0.030119095,
0.0284493174,
-0.0181306191,
0.0235133171,
0.0159208532,
-0.0076211998,
-0.085718371,
0.002033087
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16075v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16075v1 | BioLORD-2023: Semantic Textual Representations Fusing LLM and Clinical Knowledge Graph Insights | 2023-11-27T18:46:17 | 2023-11-27T18:46:17 | François Remy, Kris Demuynck, Thomas Demeester | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR | In this study, we investigate the potential of Large Language Models to
complement biomedical knowledge graphs in the training of semantic models for
the biomedical and clinical domains. Drawing on the wealth of the UMLS
knowledge graph and harnessing cutting-edge Large Language Models, we propose a
new state-of-the-art approach for obtaining high-fidelity representations of
biomedical concepts and sentences, consisting of three steps: an improved
contrastive learning phase, a novel self-distillation phase, and a weight
averaging phase. Through rigorous evaluations via the extensive BioLORD testing
suite and diverse downstream tasks, we demonstrate consistent and substantial
performance improvements over the previous state of the art (e.g. +2pts on
MedSTS, +2.5pts on MedNLI-S, +6.1pts on EHR-Rel-B). Besides our new
state-of-the-art biomedical model for English, we also distill and release a
multilingual model compatible with 50+ languages and finetuned on 7 European
languages. Many clinical pipelines can benefit from our latest models. Our new
multilingual model enables a range of languages to benefit from our
advancements in biomedical semantic representation learning, opening a new
avenue for bioinformatics researchers around the world. As a result, we hope to
see BioLORD-2023 becoming a precious tool for future biomedical applications. | [
0.0262075383,
0.0454913639,
0.0309536252,
0.0173194762,
-0.0436397865,
0.0381962024,
-0.0216967277,
0.0067877471,
0.0365770161,
-0.0103077926,
-0.0139019387,
-0.0434618853,
-0.0109768808,
0.0176953599,
0.0298199914,
-0.0223695524,
0.0412503555,
0.0302077029,
-0.0227222592,
-0.0328478515,
-0.0065134945,
0.0263055377,
-0.0143573992,
0.0095968023,
0.0207453184,
-0.0309643,
0.0421145298,
0.0071318415,
0.0324308276,
-0.0817077756,
-0.0152260875,
0.0220351443,
0.0366968513,
0.0204101447,
0.0000018949,
-0.0549105853,
-0.0116188386,
0.0376841575,
-0.0305374227,
-0.0135051766,
0.0537841134,
-0.0595397688,
0.0183288679,
-0.027514942,
-0.0285047628,
-0.0136295855,
0.0294542015,
0.0448966436,
0.0211341456,
0.0469602086,
-0.0044342838,
-0.0477572381,
0.0571309775,
-0.0380265489,
0.0109452493,
-0.018978795,
0.0422232933,
0.0164728798,
0.0235113949,
0.0073766732,
-0.0205197185,
0.0388509594,
0.0020408288,
0.0378608145,
0.0225600637,
0.0564287864,
-0.0018074465,
-0.0023984131,
0.0172659941,
0.0783334523,
-0.009169817,
0.0025978701,
0.0115041388,
0.009943923,
-0.0310344994,
-0.0001514765,
-0.0361401737,
0.0201317761,
-0.0146979317,
0.0338026844,
0.0250662491,
-0.0279373582,
0.0717154145,
0.0053097764,
-0.0179083254,
0.0177593194,
0.0331648961,
-0.0223376136,
0.0463582352,
-0.0117214862,
-0.0285108164,
0.0084999288,
0.0302520283,
0.0194510613,
-0.0178883746,
0.0142657775,
0.0206533968,
-0.013744507,
0.0905461535,
-0.0454681478,
0.0137344403,
-0.002643297,
-0.0281312633,
0.0481308028,
-0.0402260758,
0.0055860151,
-0.0207151007,
0.0533436276,
-0.0383079611,
-0.0081192711,
-0.0562721305,
0.005390428,
-0.0094944667,
0.0455456302,
-0.0341376849,
-0.0078417817,
-0.0885510072,
0.0045860675,
-0.0176730063,
0.0075623645,
0.0380798802,
0.0499670953,
-0.0065282816,
-0.0080103483,
-0.0121946465,
0.04509129,
0.0281180069,
-0.0106459772,
-0.0394718461,
-0.0276721511,
-0.0125942444,
0.0014686279,
-0.0135417199,
-0.0368655212,
0.023296807,
0.111005865,
0.0327976234,
-0.0293179583,
0.0088784574,
-0.0167946666,
-0.0629396662,
-0.0412591323,
-0.0001185216,
-0.0874345377,
0.0551399738,
0.0040641306,
0.0262461547,
-0.0622298457,
0.0267006252,
-0.0023176686,
-0.045398429,
0.0736455321,
-0.0544762798,
-0.0535678193,
-0.058313489,
0.0285104588,
-0.0089928722,
0.022562705,
0.0032440065,
-0.0488214716,
-0.0058587864,
0.0183462836,
-0.0650349036,
-0.0092703216,
0.0196379405,
-0.0208921786,
-0.0272376593,
0.0105211642,
0.0285476707,
0.0856397077,
0.0302594285,
0.0443427414,
-0.0163084492,
-0.0496291332,
0.0335853286,
0.0419161506,
0.0353009291,
0.0027634432,
0.0231158361,
-0.0149301952,
-0.0050203064,
-0.0175262168,
-0.0175050423,
-0.0066268961,
0.0237928517,
0.0221419018,
-0.0023080176,
0.0298442896,
-0.0167553555,
0.0061847805,
-0.0085525671,
-0.0345957614,
-0.0049086264,
-0.0106566167,
0.0359577239,
-0.0236963127,
-0.0102875223,
0.0849366933,
0.1013372988,
-0.0274756365,
0.0418339632,
-0.0157356896,
-0.014452613,
0.0670129508,
0.0256012809,
-0.0322212242,
-0.0234372839,
-0.0122552533,
-0.0263303574,
0.0322251692,
0.007936798,
-0.0190065932,
0.0379827879,
-0.0446198918,
-0.0133147482,
-0.0122340936,
-0.0019890305,
-0.0222596191,
-0.0280620884,
0.0393262543,
-0.0027420297,
-0.0797563195,
-0.0187119246,
0.022368921,
-0.0437663235,
-0.0033054294,
-0.012682775,
-0.0326652005,
0.0140618542,
0.0155911613,
-0.0234386101,
0.0375055484,
0.0478097647,
-0.0594611838,
-0.0425315239,
-0.0324554443,
-0.0562938377,
-0.1023048908,
0.0680251345,
-0.0295387488,
-0.022497382,
0.0059215208,
-0.0603419468,
-0.015122992,
-0.001530164,
-0.0179528724,
0.0283442121,
-0.0056190044,
0.0036153758,
0.0269816127,
0.0069310539,
-0.0545471162,
0.0332174525,
-0.0397003703,
0.0123951435,
-0.0166970883,
-0.0331857018,
0.01356389,
-0.0156882443,
-0.0351309963,
0.0113270171,
0.0210003853,
0.0213730671,
-0.0148500986,
-0.0011218301,
-0.0435582623,
-0.0087973708,
-0.0967940092,
0.026168786,
0.0149961123,
0.0112939049,
0.0220215861,
0.0192811769,
0.0259899478,
-0.0020386283,
-0.0628063381,
-0.0249533355,
0.0063315099,
0.0216544438,
0.0385637581,
-0.0025187051,
0.0294235963,
-0.0105399825,
-0.0175509099,
-0.0449263826,
0.0386181623,
-0.0415331237,
-0.0132658426,
0.0189000554,
0.0035791385,
-0.0743041039,
-0.0231479481,
-0.0030867623,
0.0148743847,
-0.0007674556,
0.0120362444,
0.0182769317,
0.0205362402,
-0.0064666113,
0.0339648277,
0.053801503,
0.0169205312,
-0.013127706,
-0.000887372,
-0.0391114429,
0.0013561317,
-0.037317615,
-0.0141860293,
-0.0251410995,
0.0605432279,
0.0355928726,
-0.0080360984,
-0.0244760737,
-0.0272754654,
-0.0035197088,
0.0243919715,
-0.0436464809,
0.0573013239,
-0.041504778,
-0.0182686821,
-0.034563791,
-0.0230626054,
0.098875761,
-0.0071332217,
0.0458570607,
-0.0459156558,
-0.0136762215,
-0.0495189875,
-0.0007983136,
0.0105691105,
0.0453486182,
-0.0277912766,
0.0205999315,
-0.011101258,
0.0029478602,
-0.0123186326,
-0.0519826561,
0.0608113967,
-0.015904665,
0.0142226573,
0.0133314412,
-0.0409214795,
-0.0137124304,
0.0034352657,
-0.0430620499,
0.0469457582,
0.0093162069,
0.0039966158,
-0.037333183,
-0.0030271974,
-0.0020391725,
0.026644621,
0.0132444147,
-0.0132715805,
-0.0177587699,
0.0273828357,
0.038450744,
-0.0117577938,
0.0387709811,
-0.018569909,
0.0371318907,
0.0958580151,
-0.0186011251,
-0.0119445892,
-0.0009484621,
0.0432376675,
0.0031468666,
-0.0402277373,
-0.0082829865,
-0.0091991825,
0.0347556621,
-0.0348180942,
0.0169251245,
0.0981687233,
0.0087481663,
-0.0696545392,
0.0393582769,
0.0065293428,
0.0065531014,
0.0002249975,
-0.0198614933,
-0.1142917201,
-0.0580517501,
-0.061294917,
0.0094098607,
0.0204428248,
-0.0596420839,
0.025811933,
-0.0312615149,
0.0235695466,
0.037518844,
-0.0419247299,
-0.0163780414,
-0.0585696325,
-0.0093186963,
-0.0362585858,
0.0207756273,
-0.0187760703,
-0.0180802234,
-0.0066148466,
0.0259537045,
-0.0114661194,
-0.0704421923,
0.0596994534,
-0.0461709797,
0.0326717384,
0.0307276752,
0.0484463535,
0.002342771,
-0.0254397821,
0.0028239158,
-0.0341057926,
-0.0145792989,
-0.0111722611,
0.0686980486,
0.0000163487,
-0.014446971,
-0.0601364039,
-0.0045932662,
-0.0513418838,
-0.0474149436,
-0.0444230251,
0.1147293225,
-0.0009985002,
-0.0276890565,
-0.0393787958,
-0.0072532515,
0.0080707911,
0.0623720624,
0.0028194974,
0.0011603235,
-0.0233680401,
0.0144863334,
0.0355818532,
0.0009514601,
-0.0338127837,
0.059575621,
-0.0352196731,
0.0051494637,
-0.0199654903,
-0.0275508948,
0.0280184653,
-0.0223965812,
-0.0193433221,
0.04357481,
0.0072622984,
-0.046586059,
-0.0827952847,
0.0549076013,
0.0025825903,
0.0140178464,
-0.0270457733,
-0.0532126203,
0.079128623,
-0.0050382982,
-0.0255986266,
0.0135641322,
-0.0331691206,
-0.044048477,
-0.0215613302,
0.0414368398,
0.0079323379,
0.0354719795,
0.0156996474,
-0.0060125035,
0.0940106511,
0.0389683284,
-0.0248410664,
-0.0168563072,
-0.0184116941,
0.025849564,
-0.0136397751,
0.0539730266,
-0.024222957,
0.0314625949,
-0.0141960112,
0.0821830481,
0.0092291683,
-0.0402100161,
0.0379138589,
0.0393828675,
0.0332512185,
-0.0201950464,
0.0039197565,
-0.0196375959,
0.0018519446,
-0.0275172964,
0.0102346092,
-0.0199108496,
0.0051414962,
0.0537418574,
0.003988571,
-0.0099654095,
0.0139060598,
-0.0265262015,
-0.039067518,
-0.0385479517,
0.0158284549,
0.0108641945,
-0.0340350047,
0.0424602814,
0.0204386357,
-0.0143680908,
0.0264925975,
-0.0422676876,
-0.0051418133,
-0.0246070456,
0.0265330374,
0.0105148144,
0.0368338861,
-0.0192487389,
0.0471863449,
-0.0499607287,
-0.0074891411,
0.0024455993,
-0.017456783,
0.0680161789,
-0.0149670448,
0.0565980785,
-0.0023455271,
-0.0096764266,
-0.0411726758,
0.0325510837,
-0.0687557608,
0.0173045993,
0.0581441559,
0.0244235694,
-0.0074938238,
-0.0140827773,
0.0683663785,
0.0190188568,
0.0787791833,
0.0252261795,
-0.0312905386,
-0.0241186172,
-0.0357731953,
0.0162006114,
0.0267315954,
-0.0466309898,
-0.0078275576,
-0.0694710463,
-0.0817643404,
0.0615001097,
0.0012901274,
-0.0403932743,
-0.0077036037,
0.0481368862,
0.0135622025,
0.0287186857,
-0.0393210389,
-0.0107776849,
0.0439153835,
-0.036089953,
-0.0438823216,
0.0065236366,
-5.9498609e-33,
0.0298405457,
-0.0142584015,
0.0163982902,
-0.0270250384,
-0.0253536422,
0.0169493686,
-0.0384198427,
-0.018071482,
-0.0152691584,
0.0900240093,
0.013235894,
-0.0087200664,
-0.0163957421,
0.0340864807,
-0.011524708,
-0.0316456929,
0.0306620691,
0.006969823,
0.029362971,
0.0395379364,
0.0121528748,
0.0660322383,
0.0715488344,
-0.0528761335,
0.0137867862,
0.0189978573,
0.044902008,
0.0140592847,
-0.0039387583,
0.0486823171,
-0.049728401,
0.0806526318,
0.0313059203,
0.0165617,
-0.0244731698,
-0.0611505993,
-0.0929129794,
-0.0168352295,
0.0189030394,
-0.0372436158,
-0.0626823083,
-0.0344310924,
0.0585385114,
-0.0029009508,
-0.0132118585,
-0.0317155346,
0.0185127817,
-0.0098923501,
-0.0581774637,
-0.0368091539,
-0.0395825468,
0.0411565453,
0.0064363005,
0.0086656753,
0.0078473482,
-0.0417017452,
0.0044059581,
0.0596163832,
-0.039922256,
-0.0145566417,
-0.0036563957,
-0.0001401288,
0.0221416801,
-0.0223914403,
0.0035214114,
0.0800864473,
-0.0094420649,
-0.0335378274,
-0.0124937501,
0.0231223851,
-0.0231463108,
0.0496207923,
0.0324778594,
0.0348097719,
0.0022006824,
0.0052368804,
-0.1183015108,
0.0142014008,
-0.04819097,
0.0602141507,
0.0065368395,
-0.0060986336,
-0.0070011271,
-0.0172912683,
-0.0373213291,
-0.0176125988,
-0.0059835524,
-0.0367977209,
-0.0020744067,
-0.0406339243,
0.0274382439,
0.0226508658,
-0.0105558783,
-0.0372130722,
-0.0424288698,
0.0197760966,
0.021999089,
-0.009866586,
-0.0104912762,
0.0344689228,
-0.050689321,
-0.0237387456,
0.0097433235,
-0.0239023324,
0.0494160876,
-0.0007815075,
0.0297282618,
-0.026207773,
-0.0277061276,
-0.0136731127,
-0.0404865369,
-0.0469813496,
0.0086268289,
0.0416884348,
0.0335611515,
0.0347889811,
0.0026044296,
0.0431390516,
0.0356751345,
-0.0165945888,
-0.0287812762,
-0.0057026832,
0.0256776419,
0.0311965793,
-0.0250022355,
0.0060350238,
-0.0456713736,
0.0542049929,
0.0385748297,
-0.0649820492,
-0.0245440733,
-0.0303080305,
2.7e-7,
0.1049378812,
0.0202533286,
0.0001971004,
-0.0282250885,
0.0095245931,
0.0097175483,
-0.0333633013,
0.0536378771,
-0.0373105481,
-0.029160561,
-0.0006036726,
0.0645137802,
0.0111804418,
0.0330905616,
-0.069358021,
0.0323862508,
-0.0686304271,
-0.0390520543,
-0.0117526753,
0.0006566078,
0.0643411726,
0.0891991705,
-0.0175000224,
-0.0364761986,
0.0351390317,
-0.0125097716,
0.0817834213,
-0.031921152,
-0.0066859303,
0.0303776711,
-0.0206987001,
0.0059955562,
0.0206386447,
0.035574086,
-0.005759845,
-0.0086312862,
0.0147132622,
0.0827947706,
-0.0582522266,
-0.017513955,
0.0358254649,
-0.0113856457,
0.0230307244,
-0.0371682569,
0.0271135084,
-0.0519935004,
-0.0484890826,
-0.0339627154,
-0.0183919203,
0.0134583162,
0.0850911811,
-0.0101697464,
-0.0171606485,
0.0317473747,
0.0200183336,
0.0141366692,
-0.0432065986,
-0.0783735067,
-0.0364046581,
0.0619884431,
-0.0218417924,
-0.0357299373,
0.0106415683,
0.0019710697,
0.0295663327,
-0.0781474113,
0.0121858027,
2.383346709e-34,
0.0285679922,
0.0019646699,
-0.0042669759,
0.0175106917,
0.0261200722,
-0.030734919,
-0.0145560978,
-0.0028336297,
-0.0011080407,
-0.0799086913,
0.0070754867
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16502v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16502v4 | MMMU: A Massive Multi-discipline Multimodal Understanding and Reasoning Benchmark for Expert AGI | 2023-11-27T17:33:21 | 2024-06-13T15:02:39 | Xiang Yue, Yuansheng Ni, Kai Zhang, Tianyu Zheng, Ruoqi Liu, Ge Zhang, Samuel Stevens, Dongfu Jiang, Weiming Ren, Yuxuan Sun, Cong Wei, Botao Yu, Ruibin Yuan, Renliang Sun, Ming Yin, Boyuan Zheng, Zhenzhu Yang, Yibo Liu, Wenhao Huang, Huan Sun, Yu Su, Wenhu Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV | We introduce MMMU: a new benchmark designed to evaluate multimodal models on
massive multi-discipline tasks demanding college-level subject knowledge and
deliberate reasoning. MMMU includes 11.5K meticulously collected multimodal
questions from college exams, quizzes, and textbooks, covering six core
disciplines: Art & Design, Business, Science, Health & Medicine, Humanities &
Social Science, and Tech & Engineering. These questions span 30 subjects and
183 subfields, comprising 30 highly heterogeneous image types, such as charts,
diagrams, maps, tables, music sheets, and chemical structures. Unlike existing
benchmarks, MMMU focuses on advanced perception and reasoning with
domain-specific knowledge, challenging models to perform tasks akin to those
faced by experts. The evaluation of 14 open-source LMMs as well as the
proprietary GPT-4V(ision) and Gemini highlights the substantial challenges
posed by MMMU. Even the advanced GPT-4V and Gemini Ultra only achieve
accuracies of 56% and 59% respectively, indicating significant room for
improvement. We believe MMMU will stimulate the community to build
next-generation multimodal foundation models towards expert artificial general
intelligence. | [
0.0015407391,
0.0602885671,
-0.015962841,
0.0476481318,
-0.0483846404,
0.0114354733,
0.0671314672,
0.003953597,
0.0142094931,
-0.0459757596,
-0.0211421717,
-0.0192548707,
-0.0292023141,
0.0556598753,
0.041385185,
-0.049809698,
0.0186117031,
-0.0415917337,
-0.0083777113,
0.0002672328,
0.0021164299,
-0.00885941,
-0.0916515738,
0.023245953,
-0.0347314402,
-0.0464110933,
-0.0382685475,
-0.0007435987,
0.0082717184,
-0.0266454387,
-0.0227118954,
0.0408925638,
0.0475038998,
0.0020651198,
0.0000023745,
-0.0607005805,
-0.0117792245,
-0.012363838,
0.0235143118,
-0.0200863667,
0.0230567437,
0.0174058639,
0.0281961393,
-0.0253117122,
-0.0402866453,
0.0297192018,
0.0253392439,
0.032456167,
0.0553753562,
0.0366835445,
-0.0171352904,
-0.0379394367,
0.0311124045,
-0.0100253401,
0.0110480925,
-0.0563804507,
-0.0129202595,
0.0440762267,
0.0135329384,
0.0021622721,
-0.0607716404,
0.0356221125,
0.0195048805,
0.0212445352,
0.0175076239,
0.0276868436,
0.0209162571,
-0.0191949997,
-0.0139994659,
0.0848186463,
0.0152893402,
0.0229520705,
-0.0191446915,
0.0109116891,
-0.0028115574,
0.076564081,
-0.0878493413,
0.0171352178,
-0.0489501506,
-0.0489735194,
-0.0594081432,
0.0022843981,
0.0090466589,
0.0233471449,
-0.0289270487,
0.0323206112,
0.0133962147,
0.0140078301,
0.0624550544,
0.0068919002,
-0.082632415,
-0.0093981046,
-0.0019411477,
0.0324388072,
-0.0386424251,
-0.0176967662,
0.0122382278,
-0.0221720897,
0.0028146524,
0.0286375526,
0.0480911769,
0.0508506671,
-0.0347862765,
0.0796529874,
0.0008016506,
0.0597019941,
-0.0496165007,
0.026723532,
-0.0226219147,
-0.0200276356,
-0.0738827735,
0.0091415737,
0.0030363181,
0.003877969,
-0.0329571292,
-0.0381367803,
0.0007872637,
0.0065406091,
-0.0357084088,
0.0462481864,
-0.0411496572,
0.0448676609,
-0.0037526826,
-0.0119112134,
-0.0673284456,
0.0533564873,
-0.0657426193,
0.0458547696,
0.0132508902,
0.0015622858,
0.0255864598,
0.0439747348,
0.0022617867,
-0.0255182274,
0.0196160339,
0.1036019027,
-0.0275001321,
-0.0029731633,
-0.0107501419,
-0.0678963438,
0.0138862804,
-0.0804954916,
0.0799385458,
-0.0308679529,
0.0491837338,
-0.002811274,
0.0057667606,
-0.0302730221,
-0.0100001451,
-0.0039930963,
-0.0004705525,
0.0886218324,
0.0242215041,
-0.0099370051,
0.0416215584,
0.0371147096,
-0.0873676017,
0.0216895007,
-0.0144797442,
0.0680385008,
0.0340787284,
-0.0052652317,
0.0359954648,
0.0259789024,
-0.0152730308,
-0.0182696506,
0.0011835174,
0.0071428572,
-0.0371959507,
0.0755057484,
0.0034439589,
0.0109740561,
-0.0105577763,
-0.0444786139,
0.057673011,
0.0585268177,
-0.0319504403,
0.0058974307,
0.0189850684,
-0.0345165543,
0.0187037941,
0.03021162,
-0.0284218118,
0.0766204819,
-0.0308404267,
-0.0103449086,
0.0247648582,
0.0251015741,
0.0045532756,
-0.0230818037,
-0.0101917572,
0.0334695429,
-0.0447252132,
0.0277616661,
0.0449018776,
-0.0326383784,
-0.0286763124,
-0.0318452828,
-0.009367181,
-0.0260129571,
-0.011631649,
-0.0085275136,
0.0236612633,
0.0350189656,
0.0766597763,
-0.0347682126,
-0.0553452857,
-0.0169609915,
0.0262812842,
0.0414524153,
0.0328349918,
-0.00274402,
0.0154336663,
-0.0521547198,
-0.0403387286,
-0.058718238,
-0.002328367,
0.0093356352,
-0.0061562643,
-0.018713804,
-0.0140145961,
-0.0815003738,
0.0417574607,
-0.0056053232,
0.0055749677,
-0.0073336908,
-0.0545996949,
0.0255583152,
0.0340569094,
0.0102053015,
0.0038258915,
0.009612157,
-0.0017901537,
-0.0280211177,
0.0161548071,
-0.0041203918,
-0.0366481058,
0.021304436,
0.0422867984,
-0.1283189505,
-0.0382166728,
0.0233133379,
-0.0555947572,
-0.0347997285,
0.0233571697,
0.0171375573,
-0.0296527687,
-0.0223617945,
-0.0342102535,
0.0161536299,
0.005200142,
-0.0084663881,
0.0505958125,
-0.0207926407,
-0.005375566,
0.0041273893,
0.0057315212,
0.0641317666,
-0.003168212,
0.0018507227,
0.0062997928,
0.0040491475,
0.0241484065,
-0.0000740552,
-0.018486971,
-0.0561037697,
0.0125413509,
-0.0770892873,
0.0035436274,
0.0112185152,
-0.0252156574,
0.01521827,
-0.053091649,
-0.0062433085,
-0.0053466335,
-0.024739366,
0.0447923057,
-0.0129672922,
-0.0153154163,
0.0302768629,
0.0056389095,
0.0495049879,
-0.0061455183,
0.0006946773,
-0.057856109,
0.0443087257,
0.0444372818,
0.0324936286,
0.0218806211,
-0.0167355128,
-0.0519360378,
0.0424764417,
-0.0222876258,
-0.0248265993,
0.0607569031,
-0.0584186949,
0.0405125208,
0.0709682852,
-0.0172850378,
0.0285154209,
0.034397576,
-0.044424545,
-0.0299588665,
0.0283556785,
0.0056923586,
0.0112949433,
-0.0089503266,
-0.0170512963,
-0.0141934166,
0.0215506162,
0.0052288468,
-0.0156497154,
-0.0127853556,
0.0420515463,
0.0181075465,
-0.0209053382,
-0.0516828857,
0.0254670139,
0.039667394,
0.0427121408,
-0.0327189714,
0.0089344578,
0.0470775329,
-0.0402978361,
0.0144817224,
-0.0024513688,
0.0270317029,
-0.0273356903,
0.0791723356,
0.0036155549,
0.0340750068,
-0.0230584852,
0.0200983752,
-0.0622417331,
0.0631113946,
0.0607469343,
0.0059667355,
0.0049463087,
-0.0864929184,
-0.0067373114,
-0.0024274669,
-0.032532692,
-0.008466077,
0.0217340514,
-0.0158156175,
0.0028760594,
-0.0079940362,
-0.0337402187,
-0.0447418205,
0.0052102725,
0.0056213927,
-0.0232155733,
-0.0153834671,
-0.0218114071,
-0.0356240161,
0.0693903491,
0.0358568989,
0.0479437038,
-0.0506464988,
-0.0522257574,
-0.0027710558,
0.058448825,
0.0151900444,
-0.0326325111,
-0.058732532,
0.0518779047,
0.0019795774,
0.0109057408,
0.0135833677,
0.0074670599,
0.0226097256,
-0.039049305,
0.0224088933,
0.0656724274,
0.0013286447,
-0.0467647351,
-0.0264807437,
0.0060014445,
0.0029778641,
0.0306857377,
0.0041419393,
-0.0844882131,
-0.057502199,
-0.0054819016,
-0.0080097746,
0.0275117811,
-0.059390422,
0.0339209698,
-0.0844425187,
0.0501624234,
-0.0157169383,
-0.0459573083,
-0.0270652324,
0.0055939546,
0.015621854,
0.0040193964,
-0.0294011179,
-0.0090066101,
0.0193386879,
-0.0077892989,
0.046061106,
0.0195438098,
-0.044626072,
0.0309686903,
-0.0326469094,
-0.0052381628,
0.0047400338,
0.0161786322,
-0.0193821769,
-0.0780574754,
0.0336124822,
0.0612831414,
0.0373516791,
-0.0089135999,
0.0746259391,
-0.0119061712,
-0.0093445377,
-0.0091303652,
0.0210267324,
-0.0077857617,
-0.0079866629,
0.0137134036,
0.0914505422,
-0.0388969965,
-0.0104579106,
-0.0726246089,
-0.0058455882,
-0.0381739773,
0.041473221,
0.0080779595,
-0.0105856238,
-0.0676581487,
-0.0327586606,
0.0397241563,
-0.047052037,
-0.0042196871,
0.0277605206,
0.0435635149,
-0.0258968398,
-0.0237887669,
-0.0314938761,
0.0382828191,
0.0534757227,
0.0076562823,
-0.0365076438,
-0.0199310333,
0.0203546286,
-0.0762777254,
0.0693122968,
0.0069499528,
0.0131380707,
-0.0276164412,
-0.0094313519,
-0.0110455379,
-0.0460908897,
-0.0405775793,
0.0415842012,
-0.0447747894,
-0.0121764177,
-0.0176253095,
0.0507775433,
0.0163399074,
0.0021291017,
0.0123867877,
-0.0354646295,
0.0013890457,
-0.0320079029,
-0.0197482761,
-0.0035418617,
0.0118039912,
-0.0138489613,
-0.01682318,
-0.0156394131,
-0.0122754471,
0.0152765261,
0.0027212752,
0.0270645581,
0.0068696868,
0.0004967796,
0.0018055389,
0.0205739923,
0.0425244942,
-0.005046586,
0.0150475968,
-0.0333703384,
-0.0043127788,
0.0303741787,
0.0064450954,
-0.0149845341,
0.0060611898,
0.045429077,
-0.0097802551,
0.0084217787,
0.0047872332,
0.0469412729,
0.0219103061,
-0.017863445,
-0.0108109703,
0.0517893881,
-0.0106226224,
-0.0289735999,
-0.0021940446,
-0.0152299907,
0.0113918744,
-0.0140379258,
0.0776845589,
-0.006621155,
0.1330415308,
0.0535735749,
-0.0183982812,
-0.0012023955,
0.0080509782,
-0.036194317,
-0.061391905,
-0.0040084939,
0.0759624615,
0.0670783818,
0.0396795943,
-0.0292823408,
-0.0305697396,
0.0103492178,
0.0128505956,
0.0286592767,
0.0203048103,
-0.0106280474,
0.0384673364,
0.0288605075,
0.0579526648,
0.0070507168,
0.036435049,
-0.0061701238,
0.0159371905,
-0.0046831137,
-0.0128147863,
-0.044546213,
-0.0201288927,
0.0161997713,
0.0465607271,
0.0345423967,
0.0489078201,
-0.0753824636,
-0.0465951376,
-0.0082544414,
0.0391761214,
-0.0252615083,
0.0222231094,
0.0303389635,
0.0694352016,
-0.008157338,
-0.0373883471,
0.005128907,
0.0128907561,
-0.050198108,
0.0151458122,
0.0024210212,
-6.934581334e-33,
-0.0018772196,
-0.0482594222,
0.0527713224,
-0.0785736144,
0.0092713786,
-0.0338248387,
-0.0424710289,
-0.0050507789,
-0.031136306,
0.0178090017,
-0.0035376057,
-0.0218697302,
-0.0128907105,
0.0125038223,
0.0419470184,
-0.0020632967,
0.0166556295,
0.0197424721,
-0.0371649228,
0.007996724,
0.0188195594,
0.0154384784,
0.0282446891,
-0.0680124238,
-0.0044628251,
0.0170763563,
-0.0106610144,
0.0080462443,
-0.0616187416,
0.0473787673,
-0.0653061494,
0.0154914837,
0.0267692823,
-0.0027694742,
0.006127608,
-0.0286230296,
-0.082113497,
-0.0533206016,
-0.0119546056,
0.0099720377,
-0.0840552822,
-0.0135239568,
0.0105090262,
0.0025608963,
-0.01526294,
-0.0582882538,
0.0672076866,
-0.0117765265,
0.0520599782,
-0.0058789589,
-0.0248112455,
-0.0016665,
-0.0501815379,
0.0013852561,
0.0017100956,
0.0351031832,
0.0190045834,
0.0365729891,
-0.0272679012,
0.0149934916,
-0.0208841208,
-0.0341494456,
0.0874923542,
-0.0128356079,
-0.0222021639,
0.048181504,
0.0028775684,
-0.01749493,
-0.0225834846,
-0.0261030775,
0.0158167463,
0.0937186405,
0.0200903825,
0.0576632433,
0.0468921959,
0.0092342915,
-0.033044342,
0.0467196405,
-0.0068180896,
0.0713900551,
-0.0127727455,
-0.0038635612,
-0.0248923488,
0.0164503139,
-0.0111469477,
-0.0003366396,
-0.0511420779,
-0.0104872109,
0.0520962253,
-0.0376180634,
0.0241984837,
0.0390866473,
0.0438166745,
-0.0243976731,
0.0075908783,
-0.0177911874,
0.0066729998,
0.0546675138,
-0.0002261651,
0.0190429017,
-0.0225128345,
-0.014313831,
0.0366577357,
-0.0216381177,
0.0412165783,
0.0067276671,
-0.0038704968,
0.024433393,
0.0322653316,
-0.0425033793,
-0.0694875121,
-0.0441486426,
0.0123229902,
-0.0200109314,
0.0225138273,
0.0355514288,
-0.0299461391,
0.0043628877,
-0.0265606269,
0.0420136154,
-0.0303755049,
-0.0523645915,
-0.0077598742,
0.0046187225,
-0.0193773415,
-0.0017249866,
-0.0249714851,
-0.0929106995,
-0.0223359317,
-0.0645821318,
0.0043825884,
0.0326750316,
3.039e-7,
0.0512665585,
0.0489973798,
-0.0086988891,
-0.0226549767,
0.0032218017,
0.0247287806,
-0.055053059,
-0.0093350485,
-0.0142579414,
-0.0166268516,
0.020617079,
0.0558094382,
0.0216170698,
0.0572838597,
-0.0111365262,
-0.0462330021,
0.0491421446,
-0.041019965,
-0.0848856643,
0.0393396132,
0.0759627223,
-0.0155775016,
-0.001808004,
-0.0375461318,
0.0402012877,
-0.048273012,
0.0503994189,
-0.0175110511,
0.0324020982,
-0.0047371024,
0.06772843,
0.0124027012,
-0.0156922936,
0.0422024392,
0.0296271369,
-0.0431053676,
0.0360229686,
0.0049019721,
-0.0243270993,
-0.0478311218,
-0.0195331927,
-0.0035707008,
0.0076339738,
-0.0391562544,
0.0473245978,
0.0019875811,
-0.0237024352,
0.00331157,
-0.0677661598,
-0.0178594999,
-0.0249478016,
0.0061324649,
-0.0266325325,
-0.0253966916,
-0.0147981141,
-0.0126274247,
-0.024066167,
-0.0460866168,
0.0345886499,
0.0325027667,
-0.0386976078,
-0.0253686439,
-0.0030350264,
-0.0480075963,
0.0629467145,
-0.0529893488,
-0.0830443427,
2.561812236e-34,
0.0360135324,
-0.0003298954,
0.0387812629,
0.0172691513,
0.0437706634,
-0.019271249,
-0.0602889061,
-0.0209778342,
-0.0033801333,
-0.0589439869,
-0.0196976159
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15983v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15983v2 | SPIN: Sparsifying and Integrating Internal Neurons in Large Language Models for Text Classification | 2023-11-27T16:28:20 | 2024-06-05T17:15:47 | Difan Jiao, Yilun Liu, Zhenwei Tang, Daniel Matter, Jürgen Pfeffer, Ashton Anderson | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Among the many tasks that Large Language Models (LLMs) have revolutionized is
text classification. Current text classification paradigms, however, rely
solely on the output of the final layer in the LLM, with the rich information
contained in internal neurons largely untapped. In this study, we present SPIN:
a model-agnostic framework that sparsifies and integrates internal neurons of
intermediate layers of LLMs for text classification. Specifically, SPIN
sparsifies internal neurons by linear probing-based salient neuron selection
layer by layer, avoiding noise from unrelated neurons and ensuring efficiency.
The cross-layer salient neurons are then integrated to serve as multi-layered
features for the classification head. Extensive experimental results show our
proposed SPIN significantly improves text classification accuracy, efficiency,
and interpretability. | [
0.0184843317,
0.0127465678,
0.0303357113,
0.0567008816,
0.005780777,
0.0293153692,
0.0352705419,
0.0105339307,
0.0207991619,
-0.0242388677,
-0.0712943003,
0.0052510183,
0.0194391683,
0.0070979451,
0.0250328816,
-0.0087482156,
0.0473106913,
-0.0080163227,
0.0186131038,
-0.0069096903,
-0.0090197166,
0.019972641,
0.0229171608,
0.0105380192,
0.0486557297,
-0.0345246345,
-0.0085298885,
0.0264575742,
0.0275734812,
-0.0188221466,
0.0281206984,
0.0528466552,
0.0361235626,
0.0961147398,
0.0000018084,
0.0019731501,
0.0194005035,
-0.0114657106,
-0.0303233359,
0.0663098767,
0.0547595322,
0.0062054866,
0.0079650525,
-0.0160911493,
0.0060264436,
-0.0287743621,
0.0534498729,
0.0943252668,
0.0295711718,
0.0628742129,
-0.0034587446,
-0.0336138867,
0.0438884161,
-0.0438677855,
0.0092478748,
-0.0255195405,
0.0392470732,
-0.053426493,
-0.0151418205,
0.056047447,
0.0038133818,
0.0520268381,
0.0371440053,
-0.0251420084,
0.043106541,
0.0562070534,
0.0241127051,
0.0041288654,
0.0106630819,
0.0290957373,
-0.053886313,
-0.0356442779,
-0.0166141633,
-0.0327156335,
-0.0033872339,
-0.0533555299,
-0.0457430966,
-0.0060221008,
0.0020584906,
0.0501995757,
0.0399978682,
0.0185712669,
0.0631671846,
0.0292313695,
-0.0222634953,
-0.0133677172,
0.0308842193,
-0.0245306063,
0.0155139705,
0.0380326621,
0.0362633057,
-0.0414744876,
0.0436890908,
0.0020791835,
0.0313025117,
-0.0070657441,
-0.0253886078,
-0.0111884596,
0.0003274537,
-0.0592937768,
0.0317284949,
0.0351607054,
-0.0235002767,
0.0346630476,
-0.0303709935,
-0.0212030038,
-0.0402432829,
0.0543850549,
-0.0152565911,
0.0153035345,
-0.0411115363,
-0.037424963,
0.0116631277,
0.0296467096,
-0.0229411628,
-0.0677374378,
-0.0374553576,
0.0104551185,
0.0118072247,
-0.0561341271,
-0.0061484356,
0.0254835226,
-0.0252991486,
-0.013740262,
-0.0077399747,
0.0576826371,
-0.0015325045,
0.0193274114,
0.0019063822,
0.0301969256,
-0.023079602,
0.0331990533,
0.0099052815,
-0.0534949079,
0.0234089419,
0.0155080147,
-0.0410674885,
-0.0701434836,
-0.0520018861,
0.0451726913,
-0.0026740693,
-0.0160592869,
0.0487814434,
-0.0404095612,
0.0074062557,
-0.0049212449,
-0.0091353077,
-0.0512157977,
0.006037313,
0.0302443784,
-0.0413090698,
0.0286189113,
-0.0149787059,
-0.0420251302,
0.0564371236,
0.0177457724,
0.0416384824,
0.0284061022,
-0.0119894594,
0.0900098979,
0.0043674917,
-0.0151997162,
-0.0031829572,
0.0224773791,
0.0441097654,
-0.0100423777,
-0.0677012801,
-0.0276325531,
-0.0241056159,
-0.0055694818,
0.0591428429,
0.0406498499,
-0.040116366,
-0.0292362571,
0.0990776271,
0.0739576221,
0.0425381623,
0.0268556215,
-0.0148071628,
-0.0119306399,
0.0114253853,
-0.0086013377,
-0.021542849,
0.0615272298,
-0.0163683351,
-0.0183561482,
0.0643363893,
0.0365924239,
-0.0547714978,
-0.0483896062,
-0.0098612616,
0.0038646059,
0.0176955033,
0.0366416648,
0.0673147291,
-0.0028451595,
-0.0102748871,
0.0390728973,
0.0377711169,
-0.0111486511,
-0.0122327888,
-0.0947463885,
0.059999682,
0.0327862985,
0.0222196225,
-0.0319713168,
-0.0237489212,
-0.0079190414,
0.0260718949,
0.086783126,
-0.0009281975,
-0.0032062151,
0.0614621788,
-0.0656647459,
-0.0039964668,
-0.0109705552,
0.028957529,
-0.0042623393,
-0.0046857721,
-0.0298845191,
0.021576032,
-0.0036227019,
-0.0424887352,
0.0496517681,
-0.0072876816,
-0.0318084545,
0.0181271248,
-0.0040549492,
0.0012328271,
0.0089444285,
-0.0186647084,
-0.0101771615,
0.0434861705,
-0.0638843328,
0.0009823948,
-0.0625812188,
-0.0129075684,
-0.0656682998,
0.0151643259,
0.0369707309,
-0.0045554596,
0.0198977813,
-0.0266422816,
-0.00385103,
0.0178654213,
-0.048792921,
0.0200298298,
-0.0789211914,
-0.0204823129,
-0.0167792644,
0.0396510027,
-0.0371209309,
0.0482356511,
0.0027308853,
0.007041092,
-0.0184502564,
-0.0018763719,
0.0014611242,
-0.0500903316,
-0.0430000685,
0.0298414137,
-0.0118142683,
0.0370858386,
-0.007015245,
0.0133121479,
0.0038783327,
-0.0331033245,
-0.0776194781,
-0.0023053451,
-0.0070800642,
0.0087414049,
0.0117466841,
0.0237599369,
0.0258004013,
-0.0214961059,
-0.0187726039,
-0.0277088899,
-0.0253609382,
0.0075812922,
0.0154279992,
-0.024614092,
-0.0246719662,
-0.0345827155,
-0.0503214449,
0.0070162346,
0.0848089606,
-0.0264738239,
0.0145367887,
-0.0502602272,
-0.0280575044,
-0.0011783437,
0.0066561825,
0.0059590661,
-0.0226030108,
-0.0061940942,
-0.0388271324,
-0.0480423793,
0.0891765505,
0.0066701537,
0.0578971356,
0.0255054887,
-0.010462353,
-0.020102324,
0.0034141382,
-0.0019255873,
0.094264552,
-0.0244903043,
0.0100273732,
0.0016125055,
0.1002202034,
0.0022236574,
-0.0116172675,
-0.0116886944,
0.0265592355,
-0.012128762,
-0.0030367018,
-0.0312028341,
0.026236305,
-0.0228518285,
0.0321051739,
-0.0396358781,
-0.0396175645,
0.0746026039,
-0.0223715771,
-0.028876638,
-0.0407697149,
-0.0385645926,
-0.0425213613,
0.0317123756,
-0.012579767,
0.0108002247,
-0.012802544,
-0.0295889229,
-0.0048201084,
-0.0172326621,
-0.0253178459,
0.0008296272,
0.0657985806,
0.022897426,
0.0354223289,
-0.0029172096,
0.0014352587,
-0.0073430459,
-0.0413099304,
-0.0242855866,
0.0270465277,
0.0293835551,
-0.0244069211,
-0.0020288939,
-0.0036111623,
0.0407060124,
0.0603522733,
-0.0432540812,
-0.007028854,
-0.0245206207,
0.0377641581,
-0.0023393352,
-0.0117781181,
-0.0043240036,
-0.0267993361,
0.0043038065,
0.028730873,
-0.0244849902,
-0.0011814974,
-0.0537073128,
-0.0063948613,
0.0640070289,
-0.016003456,
-0.0170596596,
-0.0384710357,
0.0434162617,
-0.0723988488,
-0.01058874,
0.0954524279,
0.0069819232,
-0.0986402705,
-0.0353409722,
-0.0135886688,
0.0032714719,
0.0104515012,
0.0567401387,
0.0113904821,
-0.0499799587,
-0.0123466216,
-0.0031528685,
0.0231353566,
0.037511155,
0.0250322297,
-0.0622220784,
0.0382141955,
0.0081430171,
-0.0501224585,
-0.0405226201,
-0.0429205932,
-0.0035000746,
0.0115831206,
0.0159820002,
0.0096075479,
-0.0089513715,
-0.0528598651,
-0.000121298,
0.0308129583,
-0.0217932388,
0.0179375168,
0.0025779828,
0.0092567969,
0.0774760395,
0.0402162448,
-0.0393511206,
-0.0379891209,
0.0279930085,
-0.0297727901,
-0.0267533977,
-0.0478166416,
0.0532250591,
0.0319268629,
0.0023196575,
-0.0441494808,
0.0011659439,
-0.026680056,
-0.0164803453,
-0.0422076508,
0.0433681011,
-0.0200451724,
-0.0128958598,
0.0090619829,
0.0061928923,
-0.011907883,
0.0309781078,
0.0504594296,
-0.0797200724,
-0.0255909935,
-0.0381149501,
-0.0417609289,
-0.0526692159,
-0.0173278749,
0.0205521081,
-0.0252565723,
-0.0693056509,
-0.020102432,
-0.0234501958,
-0.0102124531,
0.0353574865,
-0.0069203638,
0.030077735,
-0.0065736962,
-0.0369104259,
-0.021210555,
0.0036152143,
-0.0111159831,
0.0108792596,
-0.0369034633,
0.0153816044,
0.0274257511,
-0.0646210536,
-0.0094423536,
0.0075233458,
-0.0845195949,
-0.0663960874,
-0.0159711055,
-0.0135389958,
0.0168990958,
0.0112912888,
-0.0137714464,
-0.069612518,
0.0934454128,
0.0260094628,
-0.0255192146,
0.0320656635,
0.0274596158,
-0.0029629532,
-0.021225417,
0.0076929498,
-0.021724619,
0.0491089523,
0.0541659296,
-0.0130101927,
-0.0280065704,
-0.0069960752,
-0.026937915,
-0.0125035774,
0.0574380867,
0.0341463648,
-0.0362283923,
-0.0671108365,
0.0198722407,
0.0019995922,
-0.0028562213,
-0.0266411752,
-0.0251089651,
0.0775565654,
-0.0021133232,
-0.0324999765,
0.0445186682,
0.0477131791,
0.0192424543,
-0.0196636897,
-0.0149052441,
-0.0289026499,
0.0380225219,
0.0126215545,
0.0103587424,
-0.0576843657,
0.0416003354,
-0.0132796168,
0.0352985039,
-0.0236948393,
0.0311143026,
0.0308614038,
-0.0157458056,
-0.0731917918,
0.0375790559,
-0.0667980239,
-0.0293493904,
-0.0237756893,
0.0132867983,
0.0430419743,
0.0048930491,
0.0769481435,
0.025275562,
-0.0503589213,
-0.0107014431,
0.0103275962,
0.0071803196,
-0.0085745025,
0.0099254865,
0.0131892217,
0.0029417255,
-0.0541052781,
0.0307994839,
0.0401315764,
-0.018899912,
0.0295713507,
-0.0145718846,
-0.0254622083,
0.0168995094,
0.0468064323,
0.0373847559,
-0.0362772644,
0.0025475894,
-0.0076786419,
-0.0661588013,
0.0426629148,
-0.0158354901,
-0.0048171384,
-0.0155406697,
-0.0039621224,
0.0528494194,
0.055943083,
-0.0262996219,
-0.0226063021,
-0.0118320901,
0.0227299575,
-0.0356972553,
-0.0230270233,
-6.610584234e-33,
-0.0214584675,
-0.0088877073,
-0.003463205,
0.0111605832,
-0.0302442349,
0.0020496405,
-0.0436023548,
-0.0200235192,
0.0035466175,
0.0286698602,
-0.0296780914,
0.0229587946,
0.0088075669,
0.0554272085,
0.0052909483,
-0.0002693428,
0.0550894067,
-0.0032949727,
0.006095516,
0.0302460156,
0.0464178957,
0.0328919515,
0.0543954968,
-0.014009011,
0.005189999,
0.0272613429,
-0.0059604486,
0.0272504147,
-0.0176249798,
0.0358601995,
-0.0664706826,
0.0137879681,
0.034917485,
-0.0298981797,
0.0160308704,
0.0139853805,
-0.0462376587,
-0.027813796,
-0.0069184923,
-0.0062316153,
-0.0126629323,
-0.050373476,
0.0355476625,
0.0096516237,
0.0191118605,
-0.0683364645,
0.0423586555,
-0.0010881821,
-0.0588709265,
-0.0156960282,
-0.06730479,
0.0241985582,
0.0076486338,
-0.0526748039,
0.0275372863,
-0.04289525,
-0.0039702849,
0.0756234974,
-0.0900128037,
-0.0255616624,
-0.0344600491,
0.0488540046,
0.0031164528,
0.062298663,
-0.0155659318,
0.0572029725,
0.0446054116,
0.0088536805,
-0.0379740745,
0.0052150735,
0.0509593077,
0.029870674,
0.0364166833,
0.0102890963,
0.0739457309,
-0.018082954,
-0.0941446126,
-0.0157408714,
0.0316331945,
-0.0064396001,
0.0487095341,
0.0504423529,
-0.0076971096,
-0.0400589146,
-0.0063433736,
-0.0662702546,
-0.0562990457,
-0.0049491571,
-0.0047794352,
0.0169900414,
-0.0061561954,
0.0014753329,
0.0307324342,
-0.0211600326,
0.016585758,
0.0196948014,
0.0118561005,
0.0110455994,
0.0088620326,
-0.0444984995,
-0.0415410213,
-0.0398252532,
-0.0304445755,
-0.0295046773,
0.0032136615,
-0.0251973793,
0.0476153903,
0.0071635083,
-0.0362430289,
-0.0119312927,
-0.022391798,
-0.0354766175,
0.0622430295,
0.1124455705,
-0.0100956457,
-0.0128064249,
-0.0018640357,
0.0747538134,
0.0127888024,
0.0385963544,
-0.0219211169,
-0.0493081734,
0.022657739,
0.0331621505,
-0.0135628041,
-0.016331492,
-0.012942303,
0.0043070461,
0.010702638,
-0.075806655,
-0.0114267739,
0.022774199,
2.504e-7,
0.0436602421,
0.0555838048,
-0.0093480051,
-0.0049956008,
0.0135895507,
0.052368544,
0.0022901315,
0.0229159053,
-0.011205947,
-0.0105065499,
-0.0212017894,
0.0362060852,
0.0684591457,
0.0292815324,
-0.0933744013,
0.0304165427,
-0.05417227,
0.0277202241,
-0.0289189219,
-0.0188244022,
0.0195684358,
0.0959080607,
0.0370249227,
-0.0392403565,
0.0424882695,
-0.0425288379,
0.0728550181,
0.0152667882,
0.017909985,
0.0312392544,
0.0676742941,
-0.0264782626,
-0.0346327648,
-0.0209560432,
-0.0056575141,
0.0561677106,
-0.0094404435,
0.0601215139,
-0.0269652344,
-0.0284751337,
0.0041825627,
0.0077890181,
0.0226890966,
-0.0438262857,
0.0355211236,
-0.0593552701,
-0.0323173441,
-0.0212422889,
0.0381414928,
-0.0265002139,
0.0375521444,
-0.0511241555,
0.0092365164,
-0.0080801621,
-0.0192859005,
-0.0605052859,
-0.0195419565,
-0.1104482263,
-0.0428473167,
-0.0001506836,
-0.0599954948,
-0.0021171456,
-0.0734932721,
-0.0196566358,
0.0447155908,
-0.0122279162,
0.0168980435,
2.389250813e-34,
0.0214797463,
-0.0254825242,
-0.0385716781,
0.0361061022,
0.0098157376,
0.0067814589,
0.0195788704,
-0.0193265714,
-0.0062869778,
-0.0983621553,
0.0028790128
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15964v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15964v3 | Efficient Pre-training for Localized Instruction Generation of Videos | 2023-11-27T16:07:37 | 2024-05-23T13:24:33 | Anil Batra, Davide Moltisanti, Laura Sevilla-Lara, Marcus Rohrbach, Frank Keller | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Procedural videos, exemplified by recipe demonstrations, are instrumental in
conveying step-by-step instructions. However, understanding such videos is
challenging as it involves the precise localization of steps and the generation
of textual instructions. Manually annotating steps and writing instructions is
costly, which limits the size of current datasets and hinders effective
learning. Leveraging large but noisy video-transcript datasets for pre-training
can boost performance but demands significant computational resources.
Furthermore, transcripts contain irrelevant content and differ in style from
human-written instructions. To mitigate these issues, we propose a novel
technique, Sieve-&-Swap, to automatically generate high quality training data
for the recipe domain: (i) Sieve filters irrelevant transcripts and (ii) Swap
acquires high quality text by replacing transcripts with human-written
instruction from a text-only recipe dataset. The resulting dataset is three
orders of magnitude smaller than current web-scale datasets but enables
efficient training of large-scale models. Alongside Sieve-&-Swap, we propose
Procedure Transformer (ProcX), a model for end-to-end step localization and
instruction generation for procedural videos. When pre-trained on our curated
dataset, this model achieves state-of-the-art performance on YouCook2 and Tasty
while using a fraction of the training data. Our code and dataset will be
publicly released. | [
0.0133504691,
0.0515581667,
0.0083588744,
0.0044596996,
0.0209304653,
0.002499768,
0.0028127509,
0.0141323255,
-0.0572650172,
-0.0372064337,
-0.0304372143,
-0.0082620773,
-0.0237821117,
0.0451972112,
-0.0147107467,
-0.0869171992,
-0.0022351511,
-0.0024551135,
-0.0179469045,
0.0208151974,
-0.0015391259,
-0.0070329788,
-0.0050797942,
0.0104550691,
-0.0248443186,
0.0218954831,
-0.0252215974,
0.030578807,
0.049013596,
-0.0620037615,
-0.0017692805,
0.0741562694,
0.0266239978,
-0.0174230728,
0.0000019857,
0.0186429601,
0.0213519502,
-0.0042608632,
-0.0255847033,
0.025306711,
-0.0026891907,
-0.0246119872,
-0.0460528731,
0.0173219815,
-0.0262675043,
0.0079488819,
0.0506010354,
0.0123292487,
0.0722149462,
0.0771484226,
-0.0213191006,
-0.0979934409,
-0.018749658,
0.0107573709,
0.0606937259,
0.040330451,
-0.0377989896,
-0.0017791035,
0.03240389,
0.0205035061,
-0.0177618954,
0.0507122055,
0.0535040684,
-0.0022845897,
0.0039546308,
0.0354830511,
0.0035682467,
-0.0308609828,
0.0079245688,
0.0570663363,
-0.0284875147,
0.0090098549,
0.0023655412,
0.0021046798,
0.0037475089,
-0.0103352247,
-0.0432071052,
0.0483435392,
-0.0073847752,
0.0124342851,
-0.0628526509,
0.011545253,
0.0031086002,
-0.0417126641,
0.0702981874,
-0.0016478751,
0.0098542646,
0.0035858916,
-0.0589582361,
0.0211583283,
0.0261169132,
-0.0552766174,
0.0422798321,
0.0402967744,
0.0154376142,
0.0077733574,
-0.0580715872,
0.0393795818,
-0.0190200061,
-0.0155906528,
0.0656644776,
0.0323068723,
-0.0222730003,
0.0021251554,
-0.0227376334,
0.018301988,
-0.010886387,
0.0453788713,
-0.0792497993,
0.0466253981,
-0.064488627,
0.0013281982,
-0.0401462689,
-0.0078581292,
-0.0499581248,
0.0006696998,
-0.0244080052,
-0.004528522,
-0.0440331548,
0.0266171303,
-0.0056979619,
0.0666050017,
-0.0291706063,
0.0188270193,
-0.0295836721,
0.0179412235,
-0.0684139132,
0.0293493103,
0.0053543248,
0.004274182,
-0.0414074212,
-0.0009486871,
0.0340242386,
0.0354754254,
0.0422222316,
0.0183118004,
-0.0548966825,
0.0111985477,
-0.0398840643,
-0.0167171936,
-0.0047302628,
-0.0500209294,
0.0401219539,
-0.0663049445,
0.0567076132,
-0.034365315,
0.0153080793,
-0.0156915393,
0.0336936973,
0.0413854271,
-0.0244392399,
0.0530532859,
0.0658024177,
0.0069408217,
-0.001340509,
0.039737694,
-0.008520687,
0.0001845385,
0.0460811146,
0.0273304172,
0.0147816734,
-0.0188875869,
0.0420196429,
0.012197095,
0.0005190557,
0.0511311255,
-0.0469368473,
0.0120524997,
0.0297457092,
0.0303851012,
0.0630301386,
0.0362106524,
-0.0257314444,
0.0169155728,
0.0615199134,
0.0200188253,
-0.0353505015,
-0.0050535733,
0.100262858,
0.0540846735,
0.0222161524,
0.010748853,
-0.0164117087,
0.0320445448,
-0.0370118394,
0.0026727982,
-0.0283335466,
-0.0187508967,
-0.079733111,
-0.0436778478,
0.0075525567,
-0.0165597629,
0.0418737642,
-0.0078738388,
0.0186221506,
0.0379715897,
-0.0713760406,
-0.0030203445,
-0.027907107,
-0.0599652268,
0.0256916527,
0.0174079761,
0.0216718055,
0.0854830444,
-0.0233842637,
-0.0013174646,
0.0119960392,
-0.0051551778,
0.0311248861,
-0.0196745899,
-0.0209927727,
-0.0492559187,
0.0238802172,
-0.0325087383,
-0.0499656089,
-0.0544493981,
0.0290956032,
-0.006775701,
0.0388441831,
0.0182016399,
0.0159912463,
-0.0015111319,
-0.0209252499,
0.0317591764,
-0.0227021072,
-0.0464580394,
0.0083757229,
-0.009216534,
-0.0076586218,
0.0046225106,
-0.0081794653,
-0.0157896262,
0.0231157821,
-0.0183770675,
0.0292488597,
0.0221538991,
-0.0180168152,
-0.0475449748,
-0.007188322,
-0.0715422481,
-0.0081964908,
-0.0239833742,
-0.0252627153,
-0.0357436948,
-0.0034359414,
-0.0080936672,
-0.0069674538,
0.0079615749,
0.0026187652,
0.0545491353,
-0.0154684698,
-0.0020828601,
0.0201589912,
-0.0327425674,
0.0054498855,
0.0170549247,
0.0213465523,
-0.0201332737,
-0.0178180933,
0.033605624,
-0.0231739189,
-0.0274729226,
0.0092207883,
-0.0126689719,
0.0477024876,
-0.0515039228,
-0.0416032635,
-0.0506926477,
0.0098340306,
-0.0245407876,
-0.0294286124,
0.0198545549,
-0.0112872357,
-0.0151463924,
-0.031029582,
-0.0205366798,
-0.0063980161,
-0.0281100199,
-0.0079884157,
-0.0191827007,
0.0333837308,
0.00511298,
-0.0291673895,
-0.0133385565,
0.0269939248,
0.0093967505,
0.0136778438,
0.0548518971,
-0.0663997829,
-0.0108253807,
0.0136328423,
0.0141363768,
0.0123500833,
-0.0405099168,
0.0042356225,
0.0097663673,
0.0040009087,
0.0436120518,
-0.0172880106,
0.0463645644,
0.0352593437,
-0.0271520074,
-0.0334214233,
0.0188815203,
-0.0069136349,
-0.0050269598,
-0.0320795551,
-0.0650204271,
-0.0210029036,
0.0360089764,
0.0093163019,
0.05482997,
-0.0615248531,
0.0067337919,
0.004669731,
-0.00929718,
0.0201392397,
0.0068536983,
-0.0127068367,
0.0034582017,
-0.0304833483,
-0.0409661978,
0.0238976628,
-0.0382862091,
0.0085630333,
-0.0088241473,
-0.0154380267,
0.0095309848,
0.0572123006,
0.0374662951,
0.0474867485,
-0.0048550405,
0.0028784075,
-0.0649912581,
0.0456175804,
0.0402342267,
-0.0401284099,
0.0201836694,
-0.0890054107,
-0.0351160467,
-0.011675071,
-0.0239252672,
-0.0600770116,
0.0140761277,
0.021349851,
-0.0179392695,
0.0339982472,
-0.0346544385,
-0.0413871892,
0.0072079687,
-0.0043873885,
0.0877863243,
0.0193033107,
-0.0068420218,
-0.0276805814,
-0.0009397822,
0.0214514043,
-0.0194228161,
-0.082804136,
-0.0510084033,
0.0414077528,
0.0469583459,
0.051495079,
-0.0632738844,
-0.0116718449,
0.0500626378,
0.038045451,
-0.0135661699,
0.0022387921,
0.0660155341,
0.1032290533,
-0.0508488528,
-0.0493820086,
0.0880801305,
0.0241585243,
-0.0374791808,
0.013129483,
0.0837730467,
-0.0133223077,
0.0411687717,
0.0318233632,
-0.0877747312,
-0.0205889344,
0.0021803989,
0.0456267595,
-0.0034106527,
0.0235434193,
-0.0233109798,
-0.0959790945,
0.0861922279,
0.034175165,
-0.0799772292,
-0.0808016062,
-0.0236618817,
-0.015087815,
-0.018029334,
-0.0041915011,
-0.0088532567,
-0.0483882055,
0.0265597031,
0.0285094883,
-0.0093879923,
-0.0735062063,
-0.007894339,
-0.0621020831,
0.0404345244,
0.0519369468,
-0.0057826624,
0.0212659407,
-0.0106133865,
0.0024608772,
0.0153025836,
0.0197683871,
-0.0033547401,
0.0756149143,
-0.0005480999,
0.0039727162,
0.0209415294,
0.0605539456,
-0.0193926319,
-0.0546200387,
0.0186691694,
0.0525961481,
-0.0029720978,
0.0040378105,
-0.033786308,
0.0042493278,
0.0416966006,
0.0350001045,
0.006532358,
-0.0131938495,
-0.014936517,
-0.0518000312,
-0.034840297,
-0.0480025001,
-0.0109897861,
0.0335325599,
-0.0302661378,
-0.0196454488,
-0.0667169243,
-0.0205955934,
0.0491279289,
0.0648650303,
0.00088386,
-0.038915962,
-0.009048976,
0.038673684,
-0.0651848614,
0.028174201,
-0.0263728742,
-0.0121574597,
-0.0845880806,
-0.0690384135,
0.0093218898,
-0.0140373744,
-0.0027588545,
0.0244132485,
-0.0742737949,
-0.0248356257,
-0.0121946633,
0.1113760322,
0.0153295528,
0.0930846781,
0.0219714064,
0.0323964506,
0.0275633316,
-0.016658267,
-0.0426494256,
-0.0228417385,
0.0256656222,
-0.0410451032,
0.0146909924,
-0.0152751198,
-0.0322795324,
0.0367672928,
-0.0176073704,
0.0464940295,
-0.0329906642,
-0.0367197059,
0.0343313441,
-0.0826873332,
0.0422094986,
-0.0016569595,
-0.0057697077,
-0.037861459,
0.0224727988,
-0.0073591727,
-0.007482918,
-0.0731244087,
0.0150500676,
0.0630829707,
-0.0040000943,
-0.0076637212,
-0.0231928919,
-0.0078454474,
0.0127447303,
-0.0534451641,
-0.017906554,
-0.0037777519,
0.0167774726,
0.0098596653,
0.0211785473,
0.0288194362,
0.0720141307,
-0.0000446762,
0.0250628982,
0.0275060683,
0.058817599,
-0.0021305473,
0.0597645342,
-0.014341414,
0.0394264013,
-0.0042864862,
-0.0219395179,
-0.0611846894,
-0.04354541,
0.0532753617,
-0.0593892746,
0.03030736,
0.0004829906,
-0.0031935563,
-0.0217825156,
0.0696709305,
-0.0414017811,
-0.0725363865,
0.0016381777,
0.003448463,
0.0170807019,
-0.0166302007,
0.0928784087,
-0.0092101032,
0.0513548218,
-0.0234670453,
0.0120198112,
-0.0196720622,
-0.024331592,
0.0076251607,
0.0039746291,
-0.0131669929,
-0.0081995707,
-0.0070269671,
-0.0421068557,
-0.0620399229,
-0.0213221963,
-0.0007373498,
-0.0198109373,
0.0750246197,
-0.0001298203,
-0.0447659455,
-0.012882717,
-0.0079109902,
-0.0106789973,
0.029229911,
-0.0380929969,
-0.0001195198,
-5.868701464e-33,
-0.0321038887,
-0.021537926,
0.0227667578,
0.0364398099,
0.0093088066,
-0.0328307189,
-0.0281452741,
0.0208854526,
0.0396219529,
0.0222108867,
0.0267244894,
-0.002427554,
0.0132866828,
0.0358523577,
0.0455852672,
-0.0450752154,
0.0863571689,
-0.0137493908,
-0.0255686324,
0.0257843751,
-0.0007354525,
0.0330228694,
0.0522489473,
-0.0602331385,
-0.042528633,
0.0071387859,
-0.036218822,
-0.0175008234,
0.0175891705,
0.0155916987,
-0.0074423347,
-0.0054341913,
-0.0407212451,
-0.0616201013,
-0.025693709,
-0.01703199,
-0.0437212251,
-0.0022530947,
-0.0758408159,
0.0349248759,
-0.0529307313,
-0.0603290983,
0.0397698656,
-0.02817229,
-0.0151854698,
0.0062482115,
0.0550934002,
-0.0016356595,
0.0379437618,
-0.0480650961,
-0.0643718392,
0.0146146445,
-0.0244719554,
-0.0733614042,
0.0303630009,
0.0314435363,
0.0496997349,
-0.1099819243,
-0.0514206216,
0.0318204388,
0.0317947157,
0.0230636802,
0.0498481914,
-0.0005161112,
-0.0101134684,
0.0413006619,
0.0289257336,
-0.0114281299,
0.0261414126,
0.0080449218,
-0.0105904099,
0.0758842602,
0.0245762095,
-0.0470596254,
0.079098165,
0.0105558354,
-0.0081258873,
0.0654183701,
-0.0556181185,
0.0139753837,
-0.0332697518,
0.0069748191,
0.0438276976,
-0.0166909564,
-0.027895404,
-0.0139282318,
0.0373362079,
-0.0299059395,
0.021974178,
0.0279774368,
-0.0126219243,
-0.0403427221,
0.0378589816,
0.0125373183,
0.0261750501,
-0.0067446963,
-0.0152486293,
0.0455312729,
0.000577854,
-0.0211080611,
-0.0741136074,
-0.066289559,
0.0444744155,
-0.0239433218,
0.0239519048,
0.0268208776,
0.0228397548,
0.0713588819,
-0.0309427902,
0.0268297326,
-0.0374007598,
0.0305579286,
0.0245125201,
0.0098224832,
0.0381479859,
0.0010876793,
-0.0361850746,
0.066638954,
-0.0287167188,
-0.0001145566,
-0.0303676836,
-0.000964161,
0.0301361941,
-0.0079179024,
-0.0187167972,
0.0304967277,
-0.0665853992,
-0.0145414146,
-0.004815158,
-0.0693600774,
-0.0156407822,
0.0095950868,
2.684e-7,
0.0071099331,
0.0139526185,
0.0172426775,
-0.0037276049,
-0.0127269467,
0.0174436197,
0.0110370191,
0.0055078212,
-0.0188357905,
-0.0168655235,
0.0585791506,
0.0263926685,
0.0166661479,
0.0493309945,
-0.0573160425,
-0.0300061721,
-0.0385240875,
0.029276548,
-0.0218680408,
-0.003727701,
-0.0114252688,
0.0498366207,
0.0228879675,
0.0049937204,
0.0337898768,
0.0209479686,
0.0680098683,
-0.0145209478,
0.059379831,
-0.009183445,
-0.0201726034,
0.0221485328,
-0.0291722286,
-0.0444732942,
-0.0633187667,
-0.0306164827,
0.0331327692,
0.0715237483,
-0.0165675227,
0.0152988378,
0.0062479973,
0.0120494477,
-0.0064474237,
-0.0233657062,
0.0318265446,
-0.0544100814,
0.0107944636,
0.0510970019,
-0.0063854321,
0.0166840795,
0.0053371717,
0.016943248,
0.038891688,
0.0073926765,
0.0272339918,
0.0130552091,
-0.0265787505,
-0.0553587675,
-0.0453037433,
-0.0026490847,
-0.0184292831,
0.0078034983,
-0.0197667163,
-0.0026155168,
-0.045155853,
0.0078479815,
-0.0426175334,
2.435889929e-34,
0.0039978912,
0.0110823717,
0.0306897014,
-0.0184133165,
0.0216883216,
0.0334275328,
-0.0248423573,
0.021084154,
0.0162319709,
-0.0245203003,
-0.0465673804
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15954v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15954v1 | A Quantitative Approach to Understand Self-Supervised Models as Cross-lingual Feature Extractors | 2023-11-27T15:58:28 | 2023-11-27T15:58:28 | Shuyue Stella Li, Beining Xu, Xiangyu Zhang, Hexin Liu, Wenhan Chao, Leibny Paola Garcia | cs.CL | cs.CL, eess.AS | In this work, we study the features extracted by English self-supervised
learning (SSL) models in cross-lingual contexts and propose a new metric to
predict the quality of feature representations. Using automatic speech
recognition (ASR) as a downstream task, we analyze the effect of model size,
training objectives, and model architecture on the models' performance as a
feature extractor for a set of topologically diverse corpora. We develop a
novel metric, the Phonetic-Syntax Ratio (PSR), to measure the phonetic and
synthetic information in the extracted representations using deep generalized
canonical correlation analysis. Results show the contrastive loss in the
wav2vec2.0 objective facilitates more effective cross-lingual feature
extraction. There is a positive correlation between PSR scores and ASR
performance, suggesting that phonetic information extracted by monolingual SSL
models can be used for downstream tasks in cross-lingual settings. The proposed
metric is an effective indicator of the quality of the representations and can
be useful for model selection. | [
-0.0229986962,
0.0346845537,
-0.0139855435,
0.0453001633,
-0.0387057364,
0.0259902328,
0.029776847,
-0.0402721576,
0.031555526,
0.0049458779,
-0.0775825232,
-0.0270630326,
0.0121483831,
-0.0058286791,
0.0104893958,
-0.0079513146,
0.0243131276,
-0.0573494621,
-0.008103882,
-0.0537761636,
-0.0274143871,
-0.0096434308,
-0.0125838937,
0.011866047,
-0.0266652051,
-0.0145356879,
0.0076770633,
-0.0107480893,
-0.0038065587,
0.0124454228,
-0.0205580927,
0.045011241,
-0.0057640313,
0.0007946425,
0.0000019505,
-0.0629110262,
-0.0063096527,
0.0106441872,
-0.0173947699,
0.0195206609,
0.0003845959,
0.0196622349,
-0.0384184346,
-0.0136736548,
-0.0107867895,
-0.0483749472,
0.0724921376,
0.0403936096,
0.0097666495,
0.0464993045,
-0.0183555577,
-0.0982982591,
0.0313014723,
-0.00701568,
-0.0176180508,
-0.0040877834,
0.0038994767,
0.0006051961,
-0.0269460119,
-0.0364950895,
-0.0188232195,
0.0566552319,
0.0019031123,
-0.0058346032,
-0.0105431806,
0.0070741787,
-0.0373100042,
-0.0349182189,
0.0129225552,
0.0402496867,
0.0030719757,
-0.0088916207,
0.0014818875,
0.0018474238,
-0.0150431674,
0.0018994148,
-0.0218939763,
-0.0070007909,
0.0094791129,
0.0353828482,
0.0289103631,
0.0369127542,
0.0261970386,
-0.0369743183,
-0.0187107436,
0.0375518426,
-0.0051570837,
-0.0107561368,
0.0194728132,
-0.0076263114,
0.0035754496,
0.0281319525,
0.0388472825,
-0.0286557935,
0.0393334068,
0.0042181723,
0.0295307375,
-0.0710426718,
0.0173652582,
-0.0773160681,
0.0257231109,
0.0245487988,
-0.0632326752,
0.0215584394,
-0.0309292823,
0.0804193914,
-0.0262837,
0.0215664934,
-0.0257376824,
-0.0109239127,
-0.0828224793,
-0.0102852732,
-0.0051457533,
0.0693278313,
0.0289735291,
0.0000815771,
-0.0208012611,
-0.0206555314,
-0.017048249,
0.0138084861,
0.0675066188,
0.0178082064,
-0.0490409583,
-0.0011732697,
-0.0113719134,
0.0223948732,
-0.0009440345,
-0.0138805099,
-0.0424170867,
-0.0609145798,
0.0217911433,
7.926e-7,
0.0220555253,
-0.0240501165,
0.0324441865,
0.0958577767,
0.0178048238,
-0.0290870704,
-0.014172609,
0.0288973115,
-0.0694907904,
-0.0648469105,
-0.0161800981,
-0.0889856741,
0.0242423434,
0.0038129934,
0.0098419953,
-0.0653279871,
-0.01615059,
-0.0457428843,
0.034427166,
0.019082509,
0.0316374861,
0.0177473389,
0.0638013333,
-0.0441376716,
0.04450294,
0.0814482868,
0.0425127633,
-0.0090691214,
0.0173822828,
-0.0558452308,
-0.0334097072,
0.0278282128,
-0.0320717469,
-0.043085292,
-0.0428232253,
0.0020912606,
0.032859996,
0.0121111926,
0.0728240982,
0.0494531542,
-0.0136489915,
-0.0622377545,
0.0493401587,
0.0648725629,
0.1028422564,
0.0568926185,
0.0505404547,
0.0023862773,
0.0322447009,
0.0612159893,
0.0003694857,
-0.006805432,
0.020663619,
0.0272780452,
-0.0022096408,
0.068428196,
-0.0553643554,
-0.0396909975,
0.0155633884,
-0.0320140906,
-0.0191311985,
0.0117282839,
0.0713448077,
-0.0094234301,
0.0071476693,
0.0492190421,
0.0226487461,
-0.0439575464,
0.0184528958,
-0.0159831233,
0.0108415969,
0.045384258,
-0.037367519,
-0.0191012621,
0.0152748646,
-0.0030347391,
-0.0515410155,
-0.0065999064,
0.0315922499,
-0.0099035008,
0.0899357423,
-0.0215702448,
-0.0077751051,
-0.029351186,
0.0053230361,
0.0784265995,
-0.0672941729,
0.0184279308,
0.0069050128,
-0.0674816146,
-0.0489893444,
-0.0060241777,
-0.0205156635,
-0.0525759831,
0.0582753718,
0.0326498225,
0.0417744145,
0.0540637448,
-0.0432707891,
0.0109453332,
0.0266804099,
-0.0576745048,
0.0253771599,
0.031633541,
-0.0706518143,
-0.0022446373,
0.0316099338,
-0.0469277129,
0.0121204834,
0.0409555845,
0.0228898283,
-0.0554081537,
0.0471257679,
-0.0307598505,
0.0132093327,
-0.0603662692,
0.0161646027,
-0.0211369321,
0.0481295623,
0.0141329942,
0.0369476415,
0.0449028984,
-0.0134241208,
-0.0275609363,
-0.006882662,
0.0340158418,
-0.0504373983,
-0.028869601,
0.0407944284,
-0.0267823804,
0.0268656407,
0.0496874154,
-0.0024975131,
-0.0215164628,
-0.0309464373,
-0.1080170646,
-0.0144343339,
-0.0431801639,
0.0449136943,
0.0012807979,
0.0119072534,
-0.0056928042,
-0.0307138395,
-0.029781118,
-0.0575325377,
-0.0319672786,
0.0060274671,
-0.0181831438,
0.0308340061,
0.008274626,
-0.0401359424,
-0.0240288675,
0.0079839155,
0.0240251608,
-0.0329761952,
-0.0125399577,
-0.0209785104,
0.0394826978,
0.0095582027,
0.0319486111,
0.0214945097,
-0.0357687213,
-0.0117689725,
-0.0171376057,
0.070366174,
0.0403062925,
-0.0049480475,
-0.0287380703,
0.0654603615,
-0.0226257145,
-0.031373661,
0.0150838662,
-0.0228775926,
0.0225702878,
-0.0372954458,
0.0185640976,
-0.0454322137,
0.0324915275,
0.0288781989,
0.0067092483,
-0.0601312555,
-0.0374915637,
-0.0002029822,
-0.0567714907,
-0.0224515684,
0.0241350252,
-0.0396916345,
0.0499630906,
0.0262320898,
-0.0437270775,
0.0385793932,
-0.0642652139,
-0.016981896,
-0.0347450674,
-0.0224314388,
-0.0372032635,
0.0601603575,
0.0015041729,
0.002612154,
0.0117148785,
-0.0695551038,
-0.0087488061,
0.0284162518,
0.061481297,
-0.0367049389,
0.0075792577,
-0.0228483211,
-0.0030415806,
0.0087814741,
-0.0428927988,
-0.0170861408,
-0.0190156195,
-0.0163862891,
0.0080127837,
-0.0072517265,
0.0071362616,
0.050065428,
0.0233475845,
0.0131365769,
0.0295710843,
-0.0160353966,
0.0197350793,
0.0122643197,
0.0304200538,
0.0182148945,
0.0406874716,
-0.0270174947,
0.0171211753,
0.0483555458,
-0.0295095854,
0.0069198357,
0.0175141878,
-0.0422316939,
0.0433453619,
0.0091703394,
-0.0068292622,
-0.0582229681,
0.0228102673,
0.0139158638,
-0.0199370924,
0.0089089908,
0.0886337161,
-0.0182709433,
-0.0253948867,
-0.0171911754,
-0.0443283431,
0.0118995886,
-0.0013195206,
-0.000041467,
0.0214934014,
0.0069422899,
-0.0037197836,
-0.017615553,
0.0211603697,
0.0084875571,
0.0189113263,
-0.0712460354,
0.018699497,
-0.0059189359,
-0.0734655485,
-0.0325248018,
-0.047353223,
-0.0050351936,
-0.0803468674,
0.0283647887,
-0.0457678363,
-0.0252766162,
-0.0165487416,
0.0387518853,
-0.0766061619,
-0.0665800944,
0.0428705886,
-0.0419093408,
0.0232481956,
0.0730385035,
0.0155858602,
-0.0515499264,
-0.0389338136,
-0.049174536,
-0.0450817235,
0.0159162395,
-0.0078131668,
0.0788955316,
0.0278234575,
-0.0320226029,
0.0280886535,
0.0058572134,
-0.0159476865,
0.0499300994,
-0.0097824968,
0.0582550839,
0.0108043253,
0.0097128535,
0.0328164175,
-0.012898095,
-0.0272401869,
0.0365455747,
0.0326434486,
-0.0341050774,
-0.0313661397,
0.0085297357,
0.0220725182,
-0.0282514673,
-0.0607049018,
0.0385011397,
0.0328038149,
-0.1375621855,
-0.0136304777,
-0.0550700538,
0.0017875032,
0.0292968526,
0.0140263829,
0.032092236,
-0.018841207,
0.0244872812,
-0.0275550149,
0.0374466479,
0.0212387647,
0.0091752214,
-0.0443373062,
0.0114072012,
0.0317364745,
-0.0401209332,
-0.012210235,
-0.0136666577,
-0.0513277426,
-0.0823446587,
0.0539976805,
0.041683726,
0.0063621332,
0.0514475368,
-0.0130080469,
-0.0533746816,
0.0430901907,
0.0353809893,
-0.0720056072,
-0.0273754187,
0.0854397714,
-0.0494466051,
-0.026616348,
0.0283886287,
-0.0362103023,
0.0089534884,
-0.0347152539,
0.0147075467,
-0.0058246478,
-0.0331248417,
0.0364603214,
0.0076960381,
0.0631287694,
-0.0208980106,
0.0253905114,
-0.0470277369,
0.0089822393,
-0.013385972,
0.0451229103,
-0.0043059089,
-0.0062913648,
0.0419564694,
0.0165950209,
0.0085136108,
0.0306609198,
-0.0080666272,
-0.0475202464,
0.0066023925,
0.0257416666,
0.0135144033,
0.0496447869,
-0.0044640019,
0.043245282,
-0.0128395315,
0.0155048603,
0.059963908,
0.0024480964,
0.0006335311,
-0.0423192196,
-0.021713376,
0.0354019068,
-0.0002389081,
0.0258395039,
-0.0334649049,
-0.0243820176,
-0.0033000621,
-0.0125931902,
0.0682132617,
-0.058715947,
0.075071618,
-0.0216383543,
0.017542569,
-0.0447076634,
-0.0174126439,
-0.0031070553,
0.0667408407,
-0.0015612309,
-0.0015617501,
-0.0235305224,
-0.0069407611,
0.0571618602,
-0.0196204912,
0.0053179902,
0.0164378975,
0.0257663447,
-0.0402632728,
-0.0209462326,
-0.0093939127,
-0.0077397279,
-0.0477981232,
-0.0224211793,
-0.0208687037,
-0.0792081133,
0.0501770601,
-0.000664797,
-0.005502156,
-0.013771533,
0.0505458079,
0.0837465823,
-0.0282067396,
0.0519827604,
-0.0119800428,
-0.0311437771,
0.0288241711,
0.0010498432,
0.0144282831,
-6.260067982e-33,
-0.0201057736,
-0.0029549624,
-0.0194838662,
0.0348569714,
0.0195952095,
-0.0174508784,
-0.0115306443,
0.0634165108,
-0.039861016,
0.0196819939,
0.010001,
-0.0193042345,
0.0336878859,
0.003488906,
0.0298261363,
0.0109386407,
0.0476359315,
0.0015081792,
0.0442658961,
-0.0042522387,
0.0471656844,
0.0628909394,
0.0720031112,
-0.0827600881,
-0.0275146309,
0.0118166134,
0.0422566757,
-0.0404396057,
0.0397424623,
0.0610588901,
-0.0409182459,
0.0962894857,
0.0012540621,
-0.0216173865,
-0.0288910568,
-0.0153801395,
-0.0971253663,
-0.063068673,
0.016497707,
0.0222647227,
0.0183646232,
-0.0487680957,
0.0168734677,
0.0168443136,
-0.0444166511,
-0.0248193983,
0.0559045151,
-0.018949097,
-0.0032546923,
-0.00568796,
-0.035076905,
0.0386492126,
-0.0313511789,
0.0113892006,
0.1281072497,
0.0575032197,
-0.0159908943,
0.0019113347,
-0.008023574,
0.0168974027,
-0.0062125581,
0.0663241968,
0.0586321354,
-0.0067472951,
0.0223665927,
0.0328118429,
0.0578054748,
-0.0594734028,
0.0099016419,
-0.0077944091,
0.0530963354,
0.0270101335,
0.0018579332,
0.0569454506,
0.0284341611,
0.003710113,
-0.0661491603,
-0.0071079237,
0.0191910509,
0.0350392498,
-0.0181342419,
0.0202899296,
-0.0348259807,
-0.0059851622,
-0.0360885486,
-0.0468214042,
-0.0113448771,
-0.0649741068,
0.0249508824,
-0.0461518951,
0.0171894971,
0.009279957,
0.0325902067,
-0.0106122978,
-0.0120080598,
0.0017921068,
-0.0375933312,
-0.0070405123,
0.0248179287,
0.0433761068,
-0.0336832404,
-0.0281620286,
-0.0125751756,
0.0373814926,
0.0493820459,
-0.0007325742,
-0.006799073,
0.045218192,
-0.0452315584,
-0.007059542,
-0.0150166806,
-0.0331337079,
-0.0156331733,
0.0169847067,
0.0095000304,
0.0022856533,
-0.0319931209,
0.0518403649,
0.0054829223,
0.0065265573,
-0.0316266045,
-0.0370840393,
0.0160487406,
0.0406678729,
0.0146799907,
-0.0215920862,
-0.0148501638,
0.022055503,
0.0493912995,
-0.0124419956,
-0.0112067219,
0.0238743611,
2.789e-7,
0.0112571949,
-0.004777269,
0.0385289304,
-0.0389143825,
0.0018336761,
0.0261507109,
-0.0439454503,
0.0073859058,
0.0048374981,
-0.0336289853,
0.0148405395,
0.0220245495,
0.043954961,
0.0409327522,
-0.0738600269,
0.0117867896,
-0.0638397783,
0.0355684012,
-0.0026979558,
0.0152627081,
0.0023049556,
0.0883768722,
-0.0190311018,
-0.0156860687,
-0.0082958974,
0.0087076835,
0.0214466453,
-0.040454831,
-0.0025319729,
-0.0230584852,
-0.0075820768,
-0.0217364449,
-0.0194212366,
0.0193156879,
-0.0244703498,
0.0715656951,
0.0303379111,
0.0162100513,
-0.020193316,
-0.0418442711,
0.0047764326,
0.0446594618,
-0.0480843075,
-0.0296763666,
0.0552048162,
-0.0120637789,
-0.0539295599,
-0.0101752635,
-0.0118168471,
0.0340921842,
0.0663116798,
-0.0016014808,
-0.0108663375,
0.0017382804,
0.0291331988,
-0.0540215485,
-0.0225235168,
-0.0186451655,
0.0114001846,
0.0309073702,
-0.0458756983,
-0.0005005705,
-0.0225083642,
0.0175377969,
0.0295123085,
0.0144702736,
0.0246041901,
1.77562692e-34,
0.0120213144,
-0.0092346482,
0.029301431,
-0.0020069845,
-0.0326524377,
-0.0440827869,
-0.0322311521,
0.0150901088,
-0.0163132772,
-0.037889909,
-0.0355907083
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15946v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15946v1 | Leveraging deep active learning to identify low-resource mobility functioning information in public clinical notes | 2023-11-27T15:53:11 | 2023-11-27T15:53:11 | Tuan-Dung Le, Zhuqi Miao, Samuel Alvarado, Brittany Smith, William Paiva, Thanh Thieu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Function is increasingly recognized as an important indicator of whole-person
health, although it receives little attention in clinical natural language
processing research. We introduce the first public annotated dataset
specifically on the Mobility domain of the International Classification of
Functioning, Disability and Health (ICF), aiming to facilitate automatic
extraction and analysis of functioning information from free-text clinical
notes. We utilize the National NLP Clinical Challenges (n2c2) research dataset
to construct a pool of candidate sentences using keyword expansion. Our active
learning approach, using query-by-committee sampling weighted by density
representativeness, selects informative sentences for human annotation. We
train BERT and CRF models, and use predictions from these models to guide the
selection of new sentences for subsequent annotation iterations. Our final
dataset consists of 4,265 sentences with a total of 11,784 entities, including
5,511 Action entities, 5,328 Mobility entities, 306 Assistance entities, and
639 Quantification entities. The inter-annotator agreement (IAA), averaged over
all entity types, is 0.72 for exact matching and 0.91 for partial matching. We
also train and evaluate common BERT models and state-of-the-art Nested NER
models. The best F1 scores are 0.84 for Action, 0.7 for Mobility, 0.62 for
Assistance, and 0.71 for Quantification. Empirical results demonstrate
promising potential of NER models to accurately extract mobility functioning
information from clinical text. The public availability of our annotated
dataset will facilitate further research to comprehensively capture functioning
information in electronic health records (EHRs). | [
0.0198090654,
0.0421088375,
-0.0094551966,
-0.0447476953,
0.0148782618,
0.0408135355,
-0.0043211207,
-0.0142803164,
0.0277538076,
-0.0423231721,
0.0214213617,
-0.0405786596,
-0.0158198569,
0.0168445855,
0.0308251921,
-0.0357882455,
0.0339397565,
0.0378521979,
0.0278325789,
0.0421151817,
-0.0070119188,
0.0281795412,
-0.0347977951,
0.0644135997,
-0.0198071208,
0.0097367549,
0.0278863758,
0.0042656013,
0.0481178798,
-0.0637454093,
0.0301133208,
0.0622955449,
0.0049676988,
-0.0372627489,
0.0000019279,
-0.0148068555,
-0.0216032229,
0.0277720597,
-0.0147705944,
-0.0673900768,
0.0060708416,
-0.0542111993,
0.0249344856,
-0.0025235943,
-0.0210859664,
-0.0445477106,
0.0309111606,
0.0252209418,
0.0268858913,
0.0587176159,
-0.0272954293,
0.0589392744,
0.0014133649,
-0.0100071663,
0.0349427462,
-0.0458736308,
0.0396424495,
0.0012923375,
-0.0020966227,
-0.0507534035,
0.0290623885,
0.0275216028,
-0.0082379235,
0.024295412,
0.0265421588,
0.0127681466,
-0.0517804474,
-0.002006622,
0.0310763177,
0.0901546702,
0.0266407728,
0.0478118323,
0.03552825,
-0.0357392728,
-0.0090008155,
0.026467029,
-0.0203069653,
-0.0366888754,
0.0054788147,
-0.0039344626,
-0.0024752312,
0.0004858712,
0.0372226909,
-0.0087108947,
-0.0097101666,
-0.021674525,
0.0049056103,
-0.0641392991,
0.0447650403,
0.0263048261,
-0.0470454209,
-0.0367776267,
0.0629326478,
0.0104180183,
-0.0233637914,
0.023593273,
-0.0206336714,
-0.0484381393,
0.0652404279,
-0.0529136173,
0.0097329775,
0.0087546147,
-0.0538902618,
0.0084201004,
0.0364493877,
-0.0127928685,
-0.0250287093,
0.0236762837,
-0.0001190577,
-0.0000407119,
-0.0530114584,
-0.0187293049,
-0.0140548833,
0.0247634463,
-0.0135317259,
-0.0175788533,
-0.0860030428,
-0.0006474091,
-0.0049084681,
-0.0091610197,
0.0235647187,
0.0446586311,
-0.0272074249,
0.0289126337,
-0.0141177727,
0.0248824097,
0.0089605832,
0.0128255868,
-0.0051850136,
-0.0218914542,
0.0470329002,
0.0044568037,
0.0400325172,
-0.0534963533,
0.0175646301,
0.020487342,
0.0349734426,
-0.0623913929,
-0.0155736879,
-0.0087629175,
-0.0160943158,
0.0096548321,
-0.0119933207,
-0.0450094827,
-0.0118247643,
-0.0248755571,
0.0124841118,
-0.0742685571,
0.0213788785,
0.0186043438,
-0.0355766304,
0.0409348831,
-0.062901549,
-0.0164570194,
0.0223742202,
-0.0183364134,
0.0741691962,
0.0123971915,
0.0304051004,
-0.0477353521,
0.041545067,
-0.007005557,
0.0009866554,
0.0130366478,
0.0114347637,
-0.0516451262,
0.0419359356,
0.0161271673,
-0.0602754913,
0.035734348,
-0.0504161157,
0.0407336764,
-0.0013115155,
0.0336537696,
0.0305622201,
0.0614775494,
0.0127477851,
-0.021270575,
0.0098024905,
0.0202577617,
0.0006232376,
-0.0364883095,
0.0067790817,
-0.0147692394,
0.0142938625,
-0.0218988247,
-0.0123747839,
0.031827651,
-0.0293790735,
-0.048260726,
-0.0492189713,
-0.024376452,
0.0184599906,
0.0018489597,
0.0347496383,
-0.0145437978,
-0.0101713911,
0.0713942349,
0.0265611205,
-0.021374777,
-0.0037274633,
-0.0409190916,
-0.0512609482,
0.0495677069,
0.019656308,
-0.043408595,
-0.076730758,
-0.0158773381,
0.0163820013,
0.0136092436,
-0.0248400234,
-0.0031230424,
0.0384795479,
-0.0678039193,
-0.0138049498,
0.0586627387,
0.0397091024,
-0.0635157675,
-0.0176518597,
-0.0041563734,
-0.0022266088,
-0.0537548698,
-0.0530652106,
0.0636840463,
-0.0101411343,
-0.0048710713,
0.0403812714,
0.0332747288,
0.028535042,
0.0290146824,
-0.0190305542,
0.0301142465,
-0.0055325627,
-0.0325887501,
-0.0312098488,
0.0488545708,
-0.0115997829,
-0.0064806351,
-0.0426611863,
-0.0084307715,
-0.044646807,
0.020713836,
-0.0138594909,
-0.0190497991,
-0.0745772347,
-0.0532125011,
-0.0365883596,
-0.0444714129,
0.022660343,
0.0532512441,
-0.0047070142,
-0.0492025763,
0.0621991456,
-0.0551098697,
0.0116382837,
0.010615617,
-0.0495902672,
0.0166011918,
-0.0563529059,
-0.0365709141,
-0.0207299851,
-0.0411735699,
0.0063112751,
0.0076887845,
0.0310752001,
-0.0129270786,
0.0154496152,
-0.1062403917,
0.0130825918,
-0.028290946,
0.0105486652,
0.0155180097,
0.0656331182,
-0.0027109764,
-0.0052724783,
-0.022138048,
-0.0210007038,
0.0187288132,
0.0172006544,
0.0454313233,
0.0209424607,
0.0141669288,
-0.0529206097,
-0.0084795617,
-0.0513506532,
0.021875266,
-0.0077135907,
-0.0564357191,
0.0227467529,
-0.0301622674,
-0.0146979205,
0.0090239476,
0.0123822344,
0.0105046183,
0.0100365952,
-0.0031646991,
-0.0258442797,
0.0014697087,
0.0107438872,
0.0553518422,
-0.0216307323,
0.0034705801,
-0.0307342112,
0.0480512157,
-0.0367403515,
0.0407799408,
-0.0417807139,
-0.0761948302,
0.0267279837,
0.0421278216,
0.0198415872,
-0.0032828823,
-0.0478461608,
-0.0616045073,
-0.03274123,
0.0021686936,
-0.0468458235,
0.0523909517,
-0.0394104384,
0.0163478013,
-0.0151635436,
-0.0141613027,
0.0501916967,
0.0122989221,
0.0127035668,
-0.0478884652,
-0.0041851536,
-0.0401339643,
0.0214993507,
0.0059765042,
-0.0001542625,
0.0042114048,
-0.0585990474,
0.0310923308,
-0.0468139201,
-0.0282870922,
-0.0377588384,
0.0409115143,
-0.0425291173,
0.0436763242,
0.0195861962,
-0.0615485646,
-0.0363148823,
-0.023061594,
0.000914252,
0.0349172689,
0.0035484587,
-0.0218068603,
-0.0385166518,
-0.0000809075,
-0.0252092686,
0.0846740156,
0.0376418866,
-0.0065208487,
-0.0278467182,
0.0322081149,
0.0619109944,
0.0326187909,
-0.0241446719,
-0.03224051,
-0.036639858,
0.0545256212,
-0.0470120087,
0.0590770617,
0.0307394713,
0.0102287764,
-0.0061122156,
-0.0543366112,
-0.001797854,
0.0191323385,
0.0555942133,
-0.0274234992,
-0.0282437764,
0.1008202881,
0.0316843651,
-0.0628242269,
0.0339854769,
0.0076518212,
-0.0477945656,
-0.0062727993,
0.0239743851,
-0.0570573322,
-0.0464534089,
-0.0271955561,
0.0574286468,
-0.0395462811,
-0.048866868,
0.0353126116,
-0.0479966365,
0.0367994979,
-0.0404980071,
-0.0044770846,
-0.0217632856,
-0.0286474414,
0.024301745,
-0.0229541156,
0.012213123,
-0.0623693913,
-0.0182912536,
0.0067648371,
0.041166693,
-0.1091288477,
-0.0965852588,
0.011637372,
-0.015216724,
0.053768903,
0.0456613526,
0.0516833626,
-0.0159627795,
-0.0128938332,
0.0336490534,
-0.0387994759,
-0.013481088,
-0.0050733797,
0.065970853,
-0.0273847561,
-0.0327766165,
-0.0681731552,
0.0318715759,
-0.0336398818,
-0.0325401835,
-0.010692725,
0.0360266194,
-0.0587030984,
0.0358585753,
-0.0386757143,
-0.0003634972,
0.0601356328,
0.0238961782,
-0.0100448169,
-0.012013182,
0.0045662215,
0.0413167141,
0.0328393467,
-0.0219655894,
-0.0321780182,
0.0206802748,
-0.0463857651,
-0.0004802623,
-0.0448951796,
-0.0531163923,
0.0748568773,
0.03274877,
0.0185440145,
0.043530941,
0.0365909003,
0.0211126748,
-0.0634705797,
0.0549026355,
0.0249894522,
0.0208689682,
-0.0101813124,
-0.0735499039,
-0.0007444948,
0.0407610275,
-0.0607977845,
-0.0206992868,
-0.0120560015,
0.0017430552,
0.0330111831,
0.0100581907,
0.0146182617,
-0.0084307864,
0.0035552958,
-0.0331092365,
0.0113077601,
0.0654420704,
-0.0049317186,
-0.0402255841,
0.011659258,
-0.0381736979,
-0.0214370936,
0.0211734362,
-0.0136930207,
0.0225477777,
0.0164462831,
0.0867574587,
-0.0568233952,
-0.01604563,
0.0050865784,
0.0145145208,
0.0607186221,
-0.0069565196,
-0.0474795885,
-0.0643390417,
0.0045792665,
0.0300929546,
0.0015529041,
-0.0139378943,
0.0202040412,
0.0201686118,
0.0190846343,
-0.039534077,
0.033853475,
-0.0318194143,
0.0120814797,
-0.0577072687,
0.0497094654,
0.0118448883,
0.0271378215,
-0.0183588918,
-0.029074233,
-0.0103981197,
0.0630876273,
0.0106882071,
0.0423059575,
0.0016004313,
0.0200053044,
-0.0086595835,
0.0485644788,
-0.0088496963,
0.0286665652,
-0.0299224555,
-0.0030198242,
-0.0624222644,
0.055351045,
0.0576607846,
-0.0109113529,
0.0466546454,
-0.0025812706,
-0.0124578401,
-0.0054126149,
0.0100250738,
0.0129614379,
0.0224846061,
0.032256946,
-0.0029401719,
-0.0137358131,
-0.0156968813,
0.0491996035,
0.0022826581,
0.0457136109,
-0.0164472312,
-0.0442274176,
-0.0456412248,
-0.0129929408,
0.0555362888,
-0.0043411823,
-0.0645334572,
0.0155638233,
-0.0256265644,
-0.0452185273,
0.0636736676,
-0.0327966698,
-0.0238140095,
0.0139162913,
0.0437674336,
0.0170332193,
0.0180555433,
-0.0289180148,
-0.0503725335,
-0.0078326901,
-0.0358151831,
-0.0027178449,
0.0145014636,
-5.727447818e-33,
-0.011847809,
-0.0231485311,
0.0074359337,
-0.0160718653,
-0.0137442378,
0.0616142862,
-0.0195855498,
-0.0266157072,
-0.0092038279,
0.0265007373,
0.0140342582,
0.0141028473,
0.0269050822,
0.0483645387,
0.0106220404,
-0.0179961659,
0.0219624639,
0.0470554456,
-0.01933093,
0.0150632868,
0.018133115,
0.0807604194,
0.0682815835,
-0.0691443086,
0.0683589056,
0.0076015657,
0.0050264476,
0.036017146,
0.0283893384,
0.0555333123,
-0.0615970604,
0.0422964357,
0.0370300338,
0.0000337717,
0.0089300107,
0.0216948818,
-0.0946961567,
-0.0060337363,
0.0023148188,
-0.0053932411,
-0.0503019243,
-0.0196244661,
0.0366741978,
0.0047211596,
-0.0033487827,
0.0225040652,
0.062645711,
-0.0117607135,
-0.0085700881,
-0.0404412933,
-0.0364749283,
0.0606149323,
-0.0362798907,
0.0314291902,
-0.0391459689,
-0.000486644,
-0.0496674925,
-0.0085656652,
-0.0422893278,
-0.0254368857,
-0.0248940866,
0.0338450894,
-0.040338587,
-0.0326735862,
-0.0182585418,
0.085045211,
0.0109142838,
-0.0172746815,
-0.0542059764,
0.007063339,
-0.0023902555,
0.0316966698,
0.0071520247,
0.0310817137,
0.0190891195,
-0.0122269914,
-0.0879631937,
0.0422626995,
0.0062462646,
0.0233643018,
0.0337283388,
-0.0346777551,
-0.0674284846,
0.0113069406,
-0.0115313912,
0.0335863456,
0.0005074944,
-0.0231109653,
0.0182187986,
0.0155551154,
-0.0388415195,
0.0722252503,
0.0105365245,
-0.0071481005,
-0.0027253085,
-0.0152854342,
0.0509491898,
-0.0011124223,
-0.0398474485,
-0.0049102572,
-0.0518570766,
-0.045158606,
0.0085278815,
0.0138273761,
0.0510742404,
0.0244200341,
0.0455410518,
-0.0223220252,
-0.0374475308,
-0.0118217031,
0.0292266048,
-0.0105766701,
-0.0584616177,
0.0996324047,
0.0227546487,
0.004126112,
-0.0077799698,
0.0701379627,
-0.0155693116,
0.0194909256,
-0.0409378111,
-0.0225123502,
0.0172531717,
0.0235157236,
-0.0202547479,
-0.0170044862,
-0.0264140442,
0.0398793854,
0.0027462435,
-0.052364286,
0.0330217443,
0.006699922,
2.645e-7,
0.0978801623,
0.0269634128,
0.0049223904,
-0.0232861191,
0.0036128424,
-0.0037725468,
0.0133559834,
0.0318162553,
0.0322181955,
0.0523738526,
0.0599187687,
0.0059429472,
0.0230064001,
0.028609354,
-0.0807197466,
-0.0278480835,
-0.0693506896,
-0.0171941482,
-0.0238845032,
0.027978681,
0.0521107763,
0.066214703,
-0.0496072844,
-0.0443348438,
-0.0029660377,
-0.0300308056,
0.0191571563,
-0.0093578892,
0.0127682397,
0.0274769329,
0.0257729627,
0.0283812564,
0.0263501219,
0.0305863116,
-0.0379831903,
0.0191972405,
0.0189293511,
0.1056538075,
-0.0626353025,
-0.0255612582,
-0.0168585368,
0.0169779118,
0.02428158,
0.0381997451,
0.0713310316,
-0.0620443001,
-0.0368017405,
0.0123785324,
-0.0465058573,
-0.0127688507,
0.0520920493,
0.0321217626,
-0.0067341453,
0.0145513285,
0.0311193895,
0.0039083106,
-0.0388292223,
-0.0954877213,
-0.0029085472,
0.0089521529,
-0.0249522608,
-0.0197883043,
0.023928849,
-0.0058272886,
-0.0256861895,
-0.0391263068,
0.0032676426,
2.374809452e-34,
0.0467240997,
0.0771948695,
0.0167756397,
0.0131214643,
0.00374335,
-0.0061108735,
0.0421409868,
0.0005106613,
-0.0437884554,
-0.0760771707,
-0.0120817963
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15941v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15941v1 | Tell2Design: A Dataset for Language-Guided Floor Plan Generation | 2023-11-27T15:49:29 | 2023-11-27T15:49:29 | Sicong Leng, Yang Zhou, Mohammed Haroon Dupty, Wee Sun Lee, Sam Conrad Joyce, Wei Lu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | We consider the task of generating designs directly from natural language
descriptions, and consider floor plan generation as the initial research area.
Language conditional generative models have recently been very successful in
generating high-quality artistic images. However, designs must satisfy
different constraints that are not present in generating artistic images,
particularly spatial and relational constraints. We make multiple contributions
to initiate research on this task. First, we introduce a novel dataset,
\textit{Tell2Design} (T2D), which contains more than $80k$ floor plan designs
associated with natural language instructions. Second, we propose a
Sequence-to-Sequence model that can serve as a strong baseline for future
research. Third, we benchmark this task with several text-conditional image
generation models. We conclude by conducting human evaluations on the generated
samples and providing an analysis of human performance. We hope our
contributions will propel the research on language-guided design generation
forward. | [
0.0364564471,
0.0933770686,
-0.0021730096,
0.0411959589,
-0.0399520621,
-0.0170467235,
0.0242529474,
-0.0129812062,
-0.0362405702,
0.0072480668,
-0.0302872453,
-0.0306491461,
0.0002574315,
0.023231972,
0.0114511447,
-0.0569217876,
-0.0704361647,
-0.0393335335,
-0.010720131,
-0.0208557844,
-0.0355237387,
0.0189027749,
-0.0369987786,
0.0076562939,
-0.0521137975,
-0.0316117778,
-0.0510551967,
0.0168876294,
0.0047657345,
-0.045335941,
-0.0263125524,
0.0822022408,
0.0234954711,
0.0174152832,
0.0000017931,
0.006225016,
0.023248544,
-0.0362278521,
0.0539354794,
-0.0295740645,
0.0554965101,
-0.0589117035,
-0.0285417158,
-0.0536650158,
-0.0354776345,
0.0080642281,
0.0576089881,
0.0722971559,
0.0708494037,
0.0268158931,
-0.0161656458,
-0.094026193,
-0.009561752,
-0.0488158613,
0.0602735877,
0.0195855573,
-0.0045708343,
0.0270520933,
0.0224595368,
0.0075942851,
-0.0219027791,
-0.0000759619,
0.0382856652,
-0.0004757082,
0.0137426928,
0.0177517813,
-0.0053080199,
-0.0063895658,
0.0012466484,
0.0780356899,
-0.0230800901,
0.0074047828,
0.0242249407,
-0.0230919924,
0.0015445194,
-0.001327547,
-0.0590322316,
0.0292329695,
-0.0100461291,
-0.0103560751,
-0.0688273236,
0.0157653503,
-0.0170165822,
-0.0186488684,
0.0431195535,
0.0050005992,
0.0231346954,
0.0200582799,
-0.0686728135,
0.0093516875,
-0.0283052269,
-0.0807559267,
0.0034360886,
-0.0192653723,
-0.0174454264,
0.0279614609,
-0.0460312366,
-0.0020173597,
-0.0062635601,
-0.0146549782,
0.0685235485,
0.023881536,
0.0073067192,
-0.0048964005,
-0.0148225399,
0.0622353256,
-0.0271939207,
0.018735107,
-0.1106811166,
0.0516796149,
0.0105112521,
0.0095230499,
-0.0631655082,
-0.0287149437,
-0.0881354362,
-0.0404685996,
-0.0414404422,
-0.0012523307,
-0.0109918863,
0.0118635232,
-0.0013197778,
0.0914934501,
-0.0467816181,
-0.0052262023,
-0.0276583154,
-0.0821187124,
-0.0119608175,
0.0176106673,
0.0042299121,
-0.0039737616,
0.016964484,
0.037213482,
0.0279274471,
-0.0006822695,
-0.0303810332,
0.0814281479,
-0.0214743968,
0.0329045616,
0.0078380974,
-0.0370704047,
-0.0063786372,
-0.0520286225,
0.071101591,
-0.0621151775,
0.0070293415,
-0.0276287813,
-0.0116240466,
-0.0499458686,
0.00211123,
0.0024100358,
-0.0026226735,
0.0463573039,
0.0050703422,
0.0234150235,
-0.0208337996,
0.0023781755,
0.0000634926,
0.0447296426,
0.0966152772,
0.1042572781,
0.0077661602,
0.0067320694,
0.0334515385,
0.0464290306,
0.035037227,
-0.0117768478,
0.0074125389,
-0.0212605037,
0.0219901036,
0.0466520414,
0.0287132636,
0.0308209192,
-0.0180738922,
0.013331797,
0.0446417406,
0.0226444956,
0.0180212036,
0.0581483468,
0.0683597773,
0.0375391655,
-0.0421765968,
0.0205924269,
0.0092065716,
0.0203492157,
0.0543773212,
0.0357415788,
0.0180000924,
0.0009614889,
-0.0215900168,
-0.0170626175,
0.0230429843,
0.016815396,
0.0388647541,
-0.0317142084,
0.0067604897,
0.0724710897,
-0.0640490353,
0.0481525995,
-0.0241954494,
-0.0643930584,
-0.0040315799,
0.0070058513,
-0.0001599754,
0.0951393694,
-0.0002561522,
0.0304849148,
0.0542613417,
0.032869596,
0.0395910963,
0.0453362167,
0.035282895,
-0.0246152859,
0.0279909987,
-0.0090552149,
-0.0334270634,
-0.0442316234,
0.008777013,
0.0157239288,
0.0010206943,
-0.0014764346,
0.0171407964,
-0.0418702029,
-0.0487348102,
0.0179860927,
0.0078056045,
-0.02049133,
0.0217000134,
0.0034511874,
-0.0246429518,
-0.0031457935,
-0.0476580374,
0.0078178793,
0.0273371935,
-0.0422170758,
-0.0016541624,
0.0128053045,
-0.0838834122,
-0.0467502624,
-0.0355382152,
-0.0577976629,
-0.0105056232,
0.0057584434,
-0.0567595437,
-0.0168392174,
0.0345760994,
-0.0252721161,
0.0289068334,
-0.0043731155,
-0.0503713973,
0.0422186777,
-0.0180643275,
-0.0217540339,
0.066847235,
-0.0424427725,
0.0263593998,
0.0095879287,
0.0217413157,
-0.0151299983,
-0.0409553088,
0.0065718768,
-0.0104550719,
-0.0082195019,
0.0337872356,
-0.0194565635,
0.0767540634,
-0.0569171757,
0.0122160586,
-0.0790554658,
-0.0357680507,
-0.0131377336,
0.0001670822,
0.0223128796,
-0.03291592,
-0.0222163387,
-0.0197190829,
-0.0505102947,
0.0254275352,
-0.0282135494,
-0.0101369163,
0.0287611708,
-0.0148801105,
-0.0188582391,
-0.0227522273,
-0.0041654133,
0.0302879773,
-0.0056910608,
0.0840322673,
-0.0293710735,
-0.0250329077,
0.0777510181,
-0.0130297141,
0.0216068756,
0.0197005048,
-0.0164504889,
0.0259125028,
-0.0200715568,
0.0464605168,
0.0517357364,
-0.0168373343,
0.0032716347,
0.011237151,
-0.048039265,
-0.0326672345,
0.0225763544,
-0.025021391,
0.0222214442,
0.0423057638,
-0.0328656025,
0.025492439,
0.0251199994,
0.0175035875,
0.0196578242,
-0.0509804636,
0.0428172983,
0.0210156627,
-0.021451477,
0.0042817593,
0.0144395549,
-0.0049947812,
0.105837822,
-0.0363492258,
-0.0763796195,
0.0056647835,
-0.0477608554,
-0.0156836938,
0.037978366,
0.0667928383,
0.0054454473,
0.0602578595,
0.0225087088,
0.0217038095,
0.0319065824,
0.002937811,
-0.0389551297,
0.0022559769,
0.0397595912,
-0.0031772156,
0.0335210338,
-0.0826324522,
-0.0176158771,
-0.0374125242,
-0.0696384236,
-0.0682460293,
0.015179636,
0.0006273107,
-0.0318442173,
0.0271337591,
-0.0281684529,
-0.0404596142,
0.0197139382,
-0.0452409945,
0.0549359247,
0.0027337477,
-0.004231289,
-0.0276400317,
0.06703756,
0.0662438199,
0.0587306544,
-0.0484681241,
-0.0295601487,
-0.0314543806,
0.0434522927,
-0.0329976082,
0.0436885841,
-0.0500929691,
0.0534776822,
0.0220854376,
0.0740109831,
0.0206098258,
0.0395520702,
0.0636899322,
-0.0006107602,
-0.0276631806,
0.045160111,
0.0015611193,
-0.0038276792,
-0.0164042395,
-0.0003847555,
0.0355582833,
0.0036612903,
-0.0001664814,
-0.0640713423,
-0.019121727,
-0.0171799771,
-0.0042093936,
0.0180095211,
-0.0262481589,
-0.0383453034,
-0.0854118541,
0.0596274398,
0.01079999,
-0.069920972,
-0.0250538941,
0.0197819956,
-0.008037705,
0.0083046667,
-0.0400198475,
-0.0265100151,
-0.0093593225,
0.0226810183,
-0.0147342645,
-0.0261875764,
-0.0142803723,
0.0085208807,
-0.02870721,
0.026639672,
0.063261874,
0.0293060523,
0.0510758832,
-0.0537567846,
0.0061980109,
0.0575558543,
0.0048728869,
-0.0179613866,
0.0303948075,
0.0597387031,
-0.0211811364,
-0.0057841106,
0.0361932777,
-0.0616911426,
-0.0258375723,
0.0321781226,
0.0031213651,
0.0020635666,
-0.0097215464,
-0.0508618392,
0.0426552929,
0.037434306,
0.0432345606,
0.0348132551,
-0.0202077925,
-0.0582465976,
-0.0650192946,
0.0285312589,
-0.1052718237,
-0.0302355569,
-0.0322047733,
-0.0295857564,
-0.0030604647,
-0.0897801518,
-0.0250725076,
0.0182959437,
0.0443469882,
0.0035918476,
-0.0608481169,
-0.0626957193,
-0.0121324435,
-0.0292613972,
-0.0111149559,
-0.0064481725,
0.0149474451,
-0.0017044988,
-0.0455779657,
-0.0258337539,
-0.0254129209,
0.0034388462,
0.0520960689,
-0.0810018182,
0.0031696584,
-0.0282023028,
0.0700924173,
0.0133701153,
0.0175189488,
0.0551773161,
-0.0070474376,
-0.0000260612,
0.0266943276,
0.0281798914,
-0.0398460701,
0.0177431423,
0.0382897146,
0.0364615805,
0.0058940402,
-0.014086959,
0.0460856818,
0.0222813599,
0.0611405298,
0.0094622085,
0.0130948499,
0.0193898939,
-0.017240867,
-0.0240469538,
-0.0579554327,
0.0210693143,
-0.0077006589,
0.0236353222,
-0.0576492995,
-0.028693134,
-0.0525921769,
-0.0019163693,
0.0291849449,
-0.0016264772,
0.0128931319,
0.0077801468,
-0.0157590397,
0.025470702,
-0.0305800661,
-0.0245790575,
0.0261057839,
0.0061947899,
0.0526480079,
0.0061588218,
0.0103687076,
0.0407679677,
-0.0392122939,
0.0526922047,
0.0358021595,
0.0024422817,
0.0219543632,
-0.0098823505,
-0.0368647836,
0.0402599946,
0.0276453234,
-0.068829,
-0.0291445535,
-0.0027875125,
0.0476172902,
0.0181541517,
0.0455290675,
0.0025221622,
0.0265714712,
-0.0100851143,
0.0574322715,
0.0378583334,
-0.0732542798,
-0.0177619327,
0.0110984733,
0.0199716166,
-0.0794998631,
0.0668406934,
0.0103636654,
-0.0103920195,
-0.0566683374,
-0.0221278165,
-0.0298504606,
0.0138870804,
-0.0132258553,
0.0048884372,
0.0160920694,
0.0054217894,
-0.0399316214,
-0.0518763885,
0.0110153249,
0.0356338546,
0.0326551758,
0.0223222524,
0.075074248,
0.0353803001,
-0.0128997387,
-0.0136070801,
0.0196479522,
0.003493937,
-0.0194744226,
-0.0113795223,
-0.0565843582,
-4.954975379e-33,
-0.0313901305,
-0.0703273267,
0.0473265983,
-0.0095895566,
0.0282512009,
-0.0472248457,
-0.0554995947,
0.0071427543,
0.0413115062,
-0.003705764,
0.0089410758,
-0.0477341749,
0.0298060384,
0.053649202,
0.0435676947,
0.0240210854,
0.0613333993,
0.0093946243,
-0.0699051991,
-0.0019910189,
-0.0167981181,
-0.0104817143,
0.0063152816,
-0.0319308415,
-0.0411335602,
-0.0505141877,
0.0017302991,
-0.0072528855,
0.0133677879,
0.0151917469,
-0.0187563431,
-0.0021323753,
0.0051743756,
-0.0054077669,
-0.042499125,
0.0260999724,
-0.0612458736,
-0.0349674374,
0.006769205,
0.0196750257,
-0.0502591729,
-0.0526954755,
0.010095316,
0.0007665125,
-0.0347166136,
-0.0146953128,
0.0507716909,
-0.0142270625,
0.0098298984,
0.010216292,
-0.0701205581,
-0.0325622894,
-0.0404122695,
-0.0579796769,
0.0367726982,
0.0241316706,
0.038992539,
-0.0141065083,
-0.0346793085,
0.0623617209,
0.0317628197,
0.0178566817,
0.0737053901,
0.0146313319,
0.0013973649,
0.0501380786,
0.0472946875,
0.0326849446,
0.0041009071,
0.0250276048,
-0.0351654738,
0.0833955407,
0.0012289587,
0.0049361233,
0.039158076,
0.0238887295,
-0.0207069311,
0.0505867712,
-0.0680669472,
0.0393220559,
0.0127812307,
0.0275546852,
0.0157173052,
-0.0071570515,
0.0000120755,
-0.054875318,
-0.0385358036,
-0.0097400425,
0.0227004681,
0.0377346799,
0.0286460984,
-0.0176046751,
0.0121767595,
-0.0169225112,
-0.0149982329,
-0.0156856999,
-0.0593847595,
0.0084310267,
-0.0487504862,
-0.0292172488,
-0.0152506866,
-0.0392284915,
0.0520351194,
0.0618672892,
-0.000519584,
0.0155601492,
0.0126142791,
0.0093859965,
-0.0132972067,
-0.0052001816,
-0.0445034131,
0.0118927453,
0.0108358162,
-0.0193317514,
0.0254260767,
-0.0108532552,
-0.050926093,
-0.0079591312,
-0.0194231104,
-0.0080080293,
-0.0066219554,
-0.0164052956,
-0.0246475991,
-0.0001740954,
-0.0174247306,
-0.004945735,
-0.0506521501,
-0.0442196615,
0.0304492824,
-0.0461870022,
-0.035138756,
-0.0072700409,
2.413e-7,
0.0019435533,
0.002766676,
0.0030904452,
0.0578534417,
0.0131360982,
0.0146939084,
-0.0311403275,
0.0149192987,
-0.028824389,
-0.0054379022,
0.0233416278,
0.0052242563,
0.0362116545,
-0.0091334004,
-0.0694822222,
0.0843972415,
-0.0346743204,
0.0202263556,
-0.0356300846,
-0.0272160191,
0.0982597172,
0.0243289638,
-0.0430318937,
-0.0231516305,
0.0133228479,
-0.00143231,
0.0158244893,
-0.0331488289,
0.0391395539,
-0.0136270067,
0.0224011429,
-0.0135774184,
-0.0358986408,
-0.0042216624,
-0.01431162,
-0.0199767146,
0.0443346798,
0.0235860366,
0.019385973,
0.0218577068,
0.0028235118,
-0.0205992926,
-0.0020363161,
-0.0022930757,
0.029709775,
-0.037979126,
-0.0017194294,
0.0177356713,
0.0256037675,
0.0312802084,
0.0094051855,
-0.0049909442,
-0.0246454477,
0.0128422156,
0.044252973,
0.0029161598,
0.0201055463,
-0.0301268287,
-0.0389607139,
0.006552516,
-0.0651473105,
0.0023980041,
-0.0364216007,
0.0007533186,
-0.0405775234,
0.02600451,
-0.0390657149,
1.462081825e-34,
0.0132925883,
0.0305121858,
0.0087071639,
0.0305880904,
0.0465681888,
0.0043744016,
0.0027230401,
0.012400751,
-0.004283451,
-0.0353093259,
-0.030928405
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03728v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03728v1 | Real Customization or Just Marketing: Are Customized Versions of Chat GPT Useful? | 2023-11-27T15:46:15 | 2023-11-27T15:46:15 | Eduardo C. Garrido-Merchán, Jose L. Arroyo-Barrigüete, Francisco Borrás-Pala, Leandro Escobar-Torres, Carlos Martínez de Ibarreta, Jose María Ortiz-Lozano, Antonio Rua-Vieites | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs), as the case of OpenAI ChatGPT-4 Turbo, are
revolutionizing several industries, including higher education. In this
context, LLMs can be personalized through a fine-tuning process to meet the
student demands on every particular subject, like statistics. Recently, OpenAI
has launched the possibility to fine-tune their model with a natural language
web interface, enabling the possibility to create customized GPT version
deliberately conditioned to meet the demands of a specific task. The objective
of this research is to assess the potential of the customized GPTs that have
recently been launched by OpenAI. After developing a Business Statistics
Virtual Professor (BSVP), tailored for students at the Universidad Pontificia
Comillas, its behavior was evaluated and compared with that of ChatGPT-4 Turbo.
The results lead to several conclusions. Firstly, a substantial modification in
the style of communication was observed. Following the instructions it was
trained with, BSVP provided responses in a more relatable and friendly tone,
even incorporating a few minor jokes. Secondly, and this is a matter of
relevance, when explicitly asked for something like, "I would like to practice
a programming exercise similar to those in R practice 4," BSVP was capable of
providing a far superior response: having access to contextual documentation,
it could fulfill the request, something beyond ChatGPT-4 Turbo's capabilities.
On the downside, the response times were generally higher. Lastly, regarding
overall performance, quality, depth, and alignment with the specific content of
the course, no statistically significant differences were observed in the
responses between BSVP and ChatGPT-4 Turbo. It appears that customized
assistants trained with prompts present advantages as virtual aids for
students, yet they do not constitute a substantial improvement over ChatGPT-4
Turbo. | [
0.0761391744,
-0.0198885687,
-0.0812653154,
0.025852114,
-0.0311928038,
-0.0154530518,
0.0307063721,
-0.0203573685,
0.0265211705,
-0.0418569371,
-0.0223478228,
0.001108186,
-0.0184354484,
0.0209839549,
0.0028350637,
-0.0860891864,
0.0283934269,
0.006025916,
0.0128245112,
0.009793655,
0.0328876488,
0.0265053175,
-0.0458956361,
0.077809535,
0.0260279123,
-0.0443883054,
-0.0396136269,
-0.0396232903,
0.0193237774,
-0.0004238678,
0.0279465374,
0.0337105505,
0.0283208489,
0.0414340161,
0.0000023865,
-0.0640718117,
-0.0201720633,
0.0132351201,
-0.0418356471,
0.0392042473,
0.0793676078,
0.0935751274,
-0.0273123216,
0.0325368978,
-0.0648502111,
0.0059076627,
0.055679433,
-0.0151249273,
0.0375795476,
0.0514647514,
0.0045440127,
-0.0257431306,
-0.0033998014,
0.0269192625,
0.0094289426,
-0.054838609,
-0.0177059006,
0.0179647319,
0.0380651988,
0.0199566539,
-0.0186496787,
0.0072971988,
0.0168759748,
-0.0186487213,
-0.0175387599,
0.0361774154,
-0.064663209,
-0.0159807187,
-0.0321314335,
0.0314698406,
0.0454298593,
0.0183912758,
-0.0194746722,
-0.0001008409,
0.0581044964,
0.0050397976,
-0.0517058186,
0.0304995812,
-0.0134589374,
0.0051391474,
-0.0068230517,
0.0117158154,
-0.0554763488,
0.0159501508,
0.0312956423,
-0.0070838556,
-0.0077775386,
-0.037713591,
0.012039124,
0.0095440298,
-0.0026450409,
-0.0019998034,
-0.0153821418,
0.0749607533,
-0.0180684067,
0.0228079297,
0.0074168285,
-0.0273343511,
0.0267937761,
-0.0357969925,
0.0352404639,
0.0566226095,
0.0003710508,
-0.0179242548,
0.0084711518,
0.0736113191,
0.0166995879,
0.0079385191,
-0.0198420268,
0.0356104374,
-0.1020472869,
-0.0160315279,
-0.0593869314,
0.0514751896,
-0.0134148439,
-0.0086252214,
-0.0536680371,
0.0607282147,
-0.0150289955,
-0.0005430065,
-0.0096606128,
-0.0164353065,
-0.0548360236,
0.0169450752,
-0.0703179836,
0.0341712423,
-0.0333923101,
-0.0130663803,
-0.0268630963,
-0.0913036838,
0.0598940738,
0.0188648086,
-0.007535012,
0.0030567148,
-0.0042072181,
0.0558896698,
-0.0252115671,
-0.0268548839,
-0.0335760713,
-0.0284588523,
0.0154756764,
-0.0727740899,
0.0043927613,
-0.0210204273,
-0.0245202091,
0.012536414,
-0.0276775118,
0.0422309041,
0.0131340791,
0.0285944231,
0.0247408673,
0.0243062954,
0.0035448733,
0.0267534722,
0.0639318526,
-0.0085334647,
-0.004674077,
0.0628783032,
0.0059024119,
-0.0052160812,
-0.0011896779,
-0.0562145673,
0.0306846816,
0.0347467475,
-0.0259682834,
-0.0066134646,
0.0203849263,
0.0288561005,
0.016699912,
0.0084703863,
-0.0247497335,
0.000385902,
-0.0269785412,
0.0697859749,
0.0479148068,
0.035355214,
0.0157217253,
0.0476577245,
0.0213419497,
0.0403230265,
0.0367675312,
0.0204413831,
-0.0035492331,
0.0214125328,
-0.014011424,
0.0361940749,
-0.0180665813,
0.0227350201,
-0.0086284243,
-0.0703776851,
0.0085975109,
-0.0066201175,
0.0038404202,
0.0070317569,
0.0225658659,
-0.0254229996,
-0.0508292951,
-0.0262142606,
0.0075851511,
-0.0402669311,
-0.039649602,
-0.0920929834,
0.0205992404,
0.083160691,
0.0363937467,
-0.012835755,
-0.0320979506,
-0.0195079017,
-0.0213696808,
0.07817626,
0.0799917728,
-0.0035357613,
-0.0597371571,
-0.0633867383,
-0.000896575,
-0.0601274446,
-0.0115929153,
0.0248489026,
0.0017060799,
0.0395761281,
-0.0037809261,
0.0323688723,
-0.0114534916,
-0.0017549987,
-0.0114116501,
-0.051730264,
-0.0571619645,
0.0176371802,
0.0287535172,
0.0285570323,
0.016586829,
-0.0077675772,
0.0033656999,
0.0410693586,
0.0231705923,
-0.0159948096,
-0.0008154357,
0.0281142183,
0.037511088,
-0.0195788238,
-0.0384230427,
0.0196220465,
-0.0099421432,
-0.0158389434,
0.0438420512,
-0.0225467887,
0.0745878741,
-0.0069389585,
-0.0034030697,
-0.0278780311,
-0.0095492462,
-0.0087663578,
0.0140579948,
0.0639590919,
-0.0083276592,
0.0535538532,
-0.0081102112,
0.0072850548,
-0.0671816021,
0.0005453821,
0.0300300494,
-0.0226852931,
0.0287712757,
0.0057681706,
0.0232531149,
-0.0472895615,
0.0007271644,
-0.095188491,
0.0037910179,
0.0135523574,
0.0201468207,
0.0464532375,
-0.0016766589,
-0.0443269275,
-0.0262709633,
-0.0571683273,
0.0090612844,
-0.0241980981,
-0.0063306889,
0.0176788624,
0.0032506068,
-0.0376980007,
-0.040007282,
0.0039577116,
-0.0187153406,
-0.0488637798,
0.0853699371,
-0.0172362775,
-0.0432819091,
0.048227109,
-0.0342800431,
-0.0076251514,
0.0128292209,
-0.0681996942,
0.0426837429,
-0.0055387346,
0.0696380883,
0.0670069382,
0.0005757347,
0.0400121137,
0.0335595235,
-0.0152737917,
-0.0540384836,
0.0414828025,
-0.0518324599,
-0.081301257,
-0.0114956535,
-0.0281440038,
-0.0173997544,
-0.0184163339,
0.0024199141,
0.0017116709,
-0.0252297651,
0.0362965912,
-0.013701465,
0.0316085108,
-0.005511025,
0.022577269,
-0.01698911,
0.018072851,
0.0379936248,
-0.0451509655,
0.0399822332,
0.0139358845,
-0.0215503946,
-0.0982643291,
-0.0380329415,
-0.0205196794,
0.0429319926,
-0.028145086,
0.0044561722,
-0.0046167593,
-0.0162439253,
-0.0443791635,
0.0042919298,
0.0329833366,
-0.05299972,
-0.0208681468,
-0.0286780428,
-0.012325462,
-0.0135192247,
0.0388026386,
-0.0170541964,
0.0086684246,
-0.0152312163,
-0.0219885055,
0.0413746797,
0.0100050261,
-0.015790673,
-0.0038926876,
0.0072723418,
0.0222216323,
-0.0277041886,
-0.0304827783,
-0.017181471,
-0.0446868688,
0.0301913284,
0.0139817446,
-0.0258455221,
-0.0059209475,
0.0264698192,
0.0384371392,
-0.0033166558,
-0.0443704911,
-0.0118073318,
-0.0436815768,
0.011087236,
-0.0400392562,
-0.005179211,
0.0554517061,
0.0244069919,
-0.0422971509,
-0.0135478172,
0.0818514675,
0.0229719821,
-0.0193675775,
-0.0311679617,
-0.0251697507,
0.0155180702,
-0.0036745179,
0.0484054051,
-0.0739809647,
0.0179152433,
-0.0316045471,
0.0505544879,
-0.0587638319,
0.006441006,
-0.0186736751,
-0.1015966833,
0.0478123166,
-0.0124050705,
-0.0743199214,
0.0467296913,
-0.0115673291,
-0.0023350317,
-0.0148121566,
0.0671155974,
-0.0100584524,
0.0089954911,
0.0278168246,
0.0398265906,
-0.0578239933,
-0.0420977287,
0.0002182789,
-0.0017398483,
0.0471825749,
0.0711631998,
0.020001974,
-0.0118843168,
-0.0482291095,
0.0051095113,
0.0241055042,
0.0240282081,
0.0048588798,
0.0579316393,
-0.0251168739,
0.0111464141,
-0.0611318238,
0.0136634298,
0.0016645945,
0.0452321768,
0.0842159912,
0.0752898604,
-0.0169437863,
-0.0027401121,
-0.0548666157,
0.0113286879,
-0.0021127905,
0.0420251042,
0.0151778301,
-0.0297014415,
0.0088553093,
-0.0298960544,
0.0235100966,
0.0307817571,
-0.0425750203,
-0.0152317388,
-0.0451812819,
-0.038806159,
-0.0285818893,
-0.0887322947,
0.0660486519,
0.0274647139,
0.0168300364,
-0.0059524314,
0.0250610933,
0.0448568612,
0.0061707092,
-0.0100888442,
-0.0024344176,
0.0049712574,
-0.0777948722,
-0.0554044396,
0.0139354123,
-0.0311041679,
0.0228545349,
-0.0078746295,
0.0072910846,
-0.0531057157,
-0.0126621993,
0.0704035312,
0.0388045274,
0.0016487058,
0.0231625643,
-0.002988334,
-0.048650112,
0.029012803,
-0.0348548554,
0.0151968421,
0.0288680643,
0.0441733748,
0.0283518005,
-0.0221438818,
-0.0071586147,
0.0052411649,
-0.0103381341,
0.0172747057,
0.0167662669,
-0.034809269,
0.0433410257,
0.0716811866,
0.0391224362,
0.0000415171,
0.0170925558,
-0.0081686731,
0.0255028829,
-0.0458827242,
0.0087507991,
-0.0218101349,
-0.0476482473,
0.0214181524,
0.0071201818,
0.0194760188,
-0.0480302237,
-0.0962194949,
-0.0288993344,
-0.0242486503,
0.0128054516,
0.0133733694,
0.0173500441,
0.0088783298,
-0.0006167375,
-0.0444941595,
-0.021572629,
0.0371152163,
0.0266327281,
0.0345194861,
0.1045625359,
0.0014076644,
-0.029150689,
0.0608224273,
0.0224669483,
-0.0076807416,
-0.0842805207,
-0.0018985403,
0.058687605,
-0.0206049867,
0.0414438136,
-0.0106297387,
-0.0502941869,
0.0262563117,
0.0004801264,
0.0256181285,
0.0138944825,
-0.038149748,
0.0141485063,
-0.0087931417,
-0.0150935752,
-0.0405635051,
0.0355519541,
-0.0387265384,
0.0219096076,
-0.0339797065,
-0.0019383548,
-0.0434609614,
-0.0168184452,
0.0307595655,
0.0301683806,
0.0096766157,
-0.0425103642,
-0.0597940534,
-0.0525800474,
-0.0640848652,
-0.015958745,
-0.0052407463,
-0.0635495186,
0.0475535318,
0.0237398893,
-0.0309787989,
-0.0385968983,
-0.0094962111,
0.0417587161,
-0.0218112897,
0.0168982074,
-0.0366667472,
-6.215978862e-33,
-0.0137377242,
-0.0116055924,
0.0432717539,
0.0476627536,
0.0231773145,
-0.0331941098,
-0.0064380351,
0.0434921049,
-0.0168592986,
-0.019544689,
0.001354157,
-0.0124245817,
0.0181763973,
-0.0086767767,
0.0199055783,
-0.0103035932,
0.0254749823,
-0.0164502747,
0.0072965929,
0.0127128316,
-0.0127527146,
-0.0151931904,
0.0747204795,
-0.0695161372,
0.0445170105,
-0.0738613755,
-0.0067825797,
-0.0274504833,
-0.0253395066,
0.0556025021,
-0.0041761654,
0.0660082176,
0.016309632,
-0.0402176231,
-0.0027898664,
0.0250682831,
0.027624419,
-0.0876136646,
0.0446579754,
0.0282747652,
-0.004836733,
-0.0285820048,
0.0208378751,
-0.0418945216,
-0.0504770987,
0.0125793656,
0.0581014901,
-0.0087362668,
-0.0038525988,
0.0326664597,
-0.0771413073,
-0.0125536565,
-0.0120189516,
0.0005813485,
0.0002631487,
0.0381267183,
-0.0384182297,
-0.0738649592,
-0.0057316446,
0.0464105196,
0.0658592284,
-0.0222751554,
0.0413339846,
-0.0207418427,
-0.0047917468,
-0.0180968866,
0.0575085059,
0.0238909945,
-0.0313551575,
-0.0338210352,
0.0330496915,
0.0277378224,
0.0408186801,
0.0378051214,
-0.0026004284,
-0.0011773112,
-0.0138845667,
0.0223494042,
0.0692841932,
-0.030650558,
-0.0054114484,
-0.0069028875,
-0.0648381412,
-0.0250025298,
0.026551662,
-0.0043595028,
-0.0101045938,
-0.0766729116,
0.0503257513,
-0.0491089001,
0.0013738506,
-0.0341936201,
-0.0015509856,
-0.0326319113,
-0.0228696931,
-0.055387672,
-0.0454369411,
0.0565325096,
-0.0151023027,
-0.0220770016,
-0.0525803864,
0.0013063987,
-0.0048115188,
0.0152118141,
0.0094220331,
0.0345469937,
-0.0137631763,
0.008609836,
-0.0126586854,
0.0067042205,
-0.0243256502,
0.0159084853,
0.0514714345,
-0.0377862714,
0.0171956532,
-0.0018901164,
-0.0095370561,
0.0620233268,
0.0134881437,
-0.0255445559,
-0.078699179,
-0.0375680551,
-0.0174001716,
-0.044905927,
-0.0395030379,
-0.0009069685,
-0.0119504565,
0.0400909148,
0.0174115188,
-0.0388612188,
-0.0189301539,
-0.0260809045,
3.122e-7,
0.010410673,
0.0433258638,
-0.008697344,
-0.0034871583,
-0.007278969,
0.0223774239,
0.0118029416,
0.0105431629,
0.0588763542,
0.0089821015,
0.0116684372,
0.000689775,
0.0135123953,
0.0175232831,
-0.0683699995,
-0.065926455,
-0.0137723135,
0.0019509846,
-0.0767447799,
0.0741304085,
0.084247835,
0.034540128,
0.0478457622,
0.0237373523,
-0.0341383815,
0.0163107365,
0.0216334201,
-0.0392523967,
0.0062441966,
0.0321072415,
0.0249316189,
0.0522220507,
-0.009568505,
0.0285554379,
0.0223390572,
-0.0214977525,
-0.0178770814,
0.0710301474,
-0.0002129789,
0.0206225514,
0.0774449632,
-0.0294276867,
-0.0021811905,
-0.055856742,
0.0346737541,
-0.0635632426,
-0.0227180775,
0.0237417351,
-0.0338967554,
-0.0416051336,
0.0168794915,
-0.0270022769,
0.0038239132,
0.0253728405,
-0.0311590768,
-0.0388134234,
-0.0109304525,
0.0007043532,
0.0412211381,
-0.0144853331,
-0.0236908328,
-0.061107859,
-0.0283536315,
0.0064195655,
0.0507876985,
-0.0194111783,
0.0340166688,
2.570097634e-34,
0.0027543178,
-0.0024185302,
0.0701481029,
0.0243669767,
0.0236763526,
0.0555128492,
0.0420323834,
0.0388144106,
0.0358882472,
-0.0088135861,
-0.0567411594
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15930v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15930v1 | WorldSense: A Synthetic Benchmark for Grounded Reasoning in Large Language Models | 2023-11-27T15:38:17 | 2023-11-27T15:38:17 | Youssef Benchekroun, Megi Dervishi, Mark Ibrahim, Jean-Baptiste Gaya, Xavier Martinet, Grégoire Mialon, Thomas Scialom, Emmanuel Dupoux, Dieuwke Hupkes, Pascal Vincent | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We propose WorldSense, a benchmark designed to assess the extent to which
LLMs are consistently able to sustain tacit world models, by testing how they
draw simple inferences from descriptions of simple arrangements of entities.
Worldsense is a synthetic benchmark with three problem types, each with their
own trivial control, which explicitly avoids bias by decorrelating the abstract
structure of problems from the vocabulary and expressions, and by decorrelating
all problem subparts with the correct response. We run our benchmark on three
state-of-the-art chat-LLMs (GPT3.5, GPT4 and Llama2-chat) and show that these
models make errors even with as few as three objects. Furthermore, they have
quite heavy response biases, preferring certain responses irrespective of the
question. Errors persist even with chain-of-thought prompting and in-context
learning. Lastly, we show that while finetuning on similar problems does result
in substantial improvements -- within- and out-of-distribution -- the finetuned
models do not generalise beyond a constraint problem space. | [
0.0511421859,
0.0221723728,
-0.017369749,
0.0824244097,
-0.0398240611,
0.0176860206,
-0.0147154527,
-0.023732122,
0.0201725643,
-0.0562777631,
-0.0261256397,
-0.0216398221,
-0.0074869087,
0.0213524606,
0.0338996015,
-0.0052075908,
0.0288936682,
-0.0328204334,
-0.0381638035,
-0.0304883067,
-0.0249825437,
0.0084511796,
-0.0331695229,
0.057776019,
0.0179061405,
-0.0015463907,
-0.0237666201,
0.0090979757,
-0.0010314249,
-0.0153042544,
0.0161698349,
0.0398949459,
0.0281353798,
0.0059495824,
0.0000021461,
-0.0610798933,
0.0093959179,
-0.0340306684,
-0.0230855662,
-0.0105475355,
-0.0307722744,
0.033278577,
-0.0002364343,
-0.0053708106,
-0.0499460846,
0.0031703375,
0.0406024642,
0.0600495599,
0.0513382927,
0.0500151403,
-0.0006219059,
-0.0022093554,
0.0210000202,
-0.0136469584,
0.0456203073,
-0.0670817494,
0.0275185741,
0.023840582,
0.0353341103,
0.0011989716,
-0.0210856814,
0.0091787335,
0.0489089116,
0.010765627,
-0.0214715991,
0.0606992468,
-0.0570489168,
-0.0189822614,
0.0083719268,
0.1060951054,
0.0285280365,
-0.0118099283,
-0.0030704066,
-0.0020871595,
-0.0111782197,
-0.0228895806,
-0.049056612,
0.0361711457,
-0.0073543051,
0.0214568488,
0.0119712166,
-0.0157314986,
0.0232482161,
0.031820748,
-0.0441152193,
0.0739689395,
0.0004398253,
-0.005002954,
0.0226091817,
0.045480825,
-0.0266004819,
-0.0585235022,
-0.0348100998,
0.0396516547,
-0.0353363268,
0.0161711797,
0.0164333489,
0.0840289816,
-0.0028204045,
-0.0323030725,
0.0190865118,
0.0686858296,
-0.0217268076,
0.0619428419,
-0.0155884232,
0.0247281045,
-0.0575403832,
0.0123391291,
-0.001296117,
-0.0058200075,
-0.0509293303,
0.0043249857,
-0.0011072666,
0.0630450249,
-0.0385705605,
-0.0174531471,
-0.0136063937,
0.0386447646,
-0.0187258795,
0.0196657721,
-0.006988666,
0.0181533266,
-0.0217830427,
-0.0052826074,
-0.0744968727,
0.0155845499,
-0.0519211181,
0.0402588472,
0.007023355,
-0.0996853858,
-0.019686956,
0.0018950847,
-0.0051684924,
-0.0455002151,
0.0023185511,
0.0570813715,
0.0101872692,
-0.0396702848,
-0.0431229323,
-0.0171428416,
-0.0185667146,
-0.0849169269,
0.0010130968,
-0.0651388317,
0.0355166085,
0.0284354966,
-0.0133107575,
-0.0298513845,
0.0312776007,
-0.0253140964,
-0.0290471148,
0.0811454952,
0.0129615841,
-0.004058321,
-0.0206543561,
0.0452806354,
-0.0369900353,
0.0965382755,
0.0344084613,
0.0201857816,
0.0030064052,
0.017349435,
0.0001767592,
0.0373113453,
0.023000909,
0.0179370102,
-0.0333931781,
0.0320848823,
-0.0265670773,
0.0176229067,
-0.0065153278,
0.0420219302,
-0.0261367653,
0.0072479476,
0.0650706887,
0.0606017858,
-0.0400963686,
0.008484113,
0.032954555,
-0.0268729534,
0.0171210542,
0.0373492055,
-0.0954743028,
0.0447366387,
-0.036001429,
-0.0036554311,
0.0097022383,
-0.0119873416,
-0.0396652706,
-0.027066581,
-0.0239200462,
0.0068506859,
-0.0181173831,
-0.0105287544,
0.0321148299,
-0.0004017848,
-0.0265557915,
0.0754352883,
0.0440333709,
-0.037614312,
-0.0222951602,
-0.0593504831,
0.0401546396,
0.0396421701,
0.0567682683,
-0.0346583873,
-0.0802890584,
-0.0023572906,
0.024138581,
0.0583341196,
0.035970863,
-0.0000732369,
0.0049235001,
-0.0363630913,
-0.0233917516,
-0.0339281224,
0.0046599391,
0.0075394856,
0.0389859565,
0.0176553577,
-0.0040935916,
-0.0483864844,
0.046063114,
0.0007635409,
-0.0406668186,
0.0043503712,
-0.0344010107,
0.0157827809,
0.0314415805,
-0.0213622767,
0.0006647437,
-0.0125703784,
0.0166612025,
-0.0254051071,
-0.0122609558,
0.0289156847,
-0.0655528754,
-0.0542423911,
0.0454012156,
-0.0179145262,
-0.0405729301,
0.0328353494,
-0.0484374799,
-0.0213934481,
0.0079176491,
0.0031344555,
0.0461516306,
-0.0411881693,
0.0003859473,
-0.0055905674,
-0.0003354156,
-0.0172930341,
0.0862153918,
-0.0198907722,
0.01215214,
-0.0039223973,
0.0271795522,
-0.01463445,
-0.0484236814,
-0.0028408961,
0.0288380273,
-0.0017169159,
-0.0200212635,
-0.0068327431,
0.0435963273,
-0.0661656111,
-0.0458292663,
-0.062376637,
0.0086410977,
-0.012800077,
0.0081311045,
0.0033942752,
0.0221451037,
-0.0122688506,
-0.0117303953,
-0.0345938727,
0.0263861939,
0.0076432652,
0.0523249172,
0.0719315931,
0.0022349334,
-0.0206713565,
-0.0529908426,
0.0182044748,
-0.02865915,
0.0283395126,
-0.0290914308,
-0.0121576078,
-0.0306320768,
0.0478355363,
-0.0793628842,
0.0448500142,
-0.0224034507,
-0.0184645057,
0.0346858315,
-0.0330500118,
0.0587228872,
0.0854889676,
-0.02848153,
0.0561034158,
0.0458094738,
-0.013003353,
-0.0686678812,
0.028108675,
-0.0047110808,
-0.0155093186,
-0.0202079508,
-0.0079495553,
-0.05561997,
0.0800730735,
-0.018039437,
-0.0156772081,
-0.0705447048,
0.0615420192,
0.0061365087,
-0.0105795776,
-0.0392023176,
0.0043541105,
0.0020393161,
0.052705124,
-0.0461659133,
-0.0311929155,
0.0689936876,
-0.0192871112,
-0.0107958885,
-0.008396904,
-0.0047808373,
-0.0479646735,
0.0614577904,
-0.0119466418,
-0.0121848425,
-0.0209632199,
-0.0195667837,
-0.0813976377,
-0.0240715165,
0.019309653,
-0.0190842263,
0.0423164517,
-0.0681759864,
0.0241253804,
-0.0439807884,
-0.0684923008,
-0.0615415014,
0.0058919261,
-0.0478134118,
-0.0132194674,
-0.0085898582,
0.0015296051,
-0.0029408408,
0.0170633607,
0.0104122842,
0.0108716926,
-0.0273627751,
-0.0108749904,
-0.0461288504,
0.0009956639,
0.0433675647,
0.0209406614,
0.0348572023,
-0.0364303254,
0.0475369543,
0.0563426763,
0.0114927022,
-0.0004270138,
-0.0358293056,
0.0398879908,
0.0220658425,
0.0169109832,
-0.026158398,
0.0060713282,
0.0885855108,
-0.0324885324,
-0.0365077071,
0.1161909923,
0.0290202592,
-0.0063431202,
0.0109805129,
-0.0348808356,
0.0379250646,
0.0281078946,
0.0087678945,
-0.0649144873,
-0.0324833989,
0.0347888619,
-0.021744445,
0.0311852824,
-0.0672023818,
0.0019512299,
-0.1150273979,
0.0337861255,
-0.0140838949,
-0.0509350188,
-0.0193311647,
-0.0093325879,
0.0300111659,
0.025630109,
0.0052376399,
0.0042328299,
0.0229701027,
-0.0022130436,
0.0105660874,
0.0075895507,
-0.0301511306,
0.0584866591,
-0.0334611014,
0.0550579205,
0.0184382927,
0.0292863213,
0.0284262653,
-0.0621335544,
0.0577205196,
0.0293266978,
0.0010317579,
-0.0200587604,
-0.0102400091,
0.0038185287,
-0.0207508672,
-0.0033942768,
0.0372204445,
-0.0473455153,
-0.0124470098,
-0.0054247351,
0.0764598921,
-0.0105608748,
-0.0045792195,
-0.0086744176,
0.0317443982,
-0.0003466282,
0.0641737804,
0.053741686,
-0.0042707655,
-0.0496168099,
-0.0388723463,
-0.0509948581,
0.0124364998,
-0.0351700224,
-0.0167374909,
0.0239633974,
0.0339143611,
-0.0479164012,
-0.0187821053,
0.0507476144,
0.0450906046,
-0.0001957691,
-0.0305773262,
-0.0214371365,
0.0095037371,
0.0094287824,
0.0506428517,
-0.0521930903,
0.0140381269,
-0.0191370863,
0.0202895124,
0.0543327928,
-0.0290552173,
-0.0160322506,
-0.0033298328,
-0.0646134242,
-0.0752076283,
-0.030063577,
0.054587476,
0.0348267183,
0.0272537246,
-0.0149541022,
-0.0163195115,
-0.0198913086,
0.030423034,
-0.0323029496,
0.0329528376,
0.0264630597,
0.0322322287,
0.0265002158,
0.0536968186,
-0.0652910024,
0.016606627,
0.0386365913,
0.0749716535,
-0.0004626324,
-0.0646461993,
0.0005068311,
-0.0138916858,
0.0193649512,
0.01460802,
-0.0261655357,
-0.0228026733,
0.0404765122,
-0.0086817481,
-0.0218080264,
-0.0305523835,
0.0080941701,
0.0088491049,
-0.0013153052,
0.0016811915,
-0.0226612706,
-0.0183738768,
0.0894895494,
0.0027768896,
-0.0174384285,
0.0321408138,
-0.0127944052,
0.0488980301,
0.0058997134,
-0.0463578813,
-0.0194544774,
0.0123579027,
0.0588109158,
-0.008681125,
0.0561730154,
0.0239548199,
-0.0044504167,
-0.0079052588,
0.0057529574,
-0.0681752861,
-0.0607581586,
0.0148236956,
0.0739643946,
0.0573450327,
0.0030155089,
0.0137169054,
-0.016555503,
-0.0046796543,
0.0185442977,
0.0254895147,
0.0066914479,
-0.0143141309,
0.0387202315,
0.0420881882,
-0.0073564849,
0.0320691913,
0.0305707473,
0.0170496535,
0.0615970604,
0.0304266419,
0.0396493301,
-0.033960674,
-0.0406152345,
0.0105139446,
0.0222176518,
0.0242451392,
0.0431749783,
-0.0962059498,
-0.0758238286,
-0.0085373623,
0.0336840115,
-0.0313728303,
-0.006486882,
0.0153477667,
0.0574747734,
0.0210261401,
-0.0184222497,
0.01124964,
0.0031477981,
-0.0094522256,
0.003424241,
-0.0256184731,
-6.796120589e-33,
-0.0469089486,
-0.025474973,
0.0383489728,
0.0028840813,
-0.0362559594,
-0.0165535789,
-0.0529639944,
-0.0027477008,
-0.0341325253,
0.0004482432,
-0.0166554507,
0.0300584603,
-0.002533104,
-0.00798639,
-0.0362890884,
-0.0470873155,
0.013163235,
0.0232120585,
-0.0397276133,
0.0163305197,
0.0276670028,
0.0112323314,
0.0469097421,
-0.0427520312,
0.0252187978,
-0.0105144856,
0.001691038,
0.0607984588,
-0.0363027267,
0.0362525098,
-0.033251863,
0.0092873583,
0.008820517,
-0.0164771564,
0.020920096,
-0.0088000856,
-0.0606405847,
-0.0528885461,
0.0385404378,
-0.0188673828,
-0.0405267105,
-0.0146024255,
0.021656476,
0.0254796967,
-0.0122104464,
0.0005696286,
0.0172479209,
-0.0293050241,
-0.0078041097,
0.0261217412,
-0.0530559942,
-0.002161891,
-0.0086223995,
-0.045036234,
-0.0425215103,
0.0113972956,
0.0068935142,
0.038189549,
-0.0441938639,
-0.0120715369,
0.0114974752,
-0.0269699749,
0.0710904151,
-0.026699204,
0.001337884,
0.0693512484,
0.0013390508,
0.0281178914,
-0.0661506429,
-0.0570225529,
0.01198419,
0.0741555914,
0.0269233882,
0.0266362745,
-0.0138761131,
0.0437036827,
-0.092608355,
0.0082921861,
0.0196617004,
0.0545523763,
0.0320120268,
0.0003529138,
-0.0532697216,
-0.0166507177,
-0.0426567011,
0.0299081001,
-0.0471244045,
-0.0225798115,
0.0386801325,
-0.0182785708,
-0.0342138372,
-0.0298297275,
0.0292507634,
-0.0661765188,
-0.0298681222,
0.0157153364,
-0.0120493295,
0.0018181279,
0.0058088168,
0.0429892167,
-0.0283358488,
-0.0467594899,
-0.0009962335,
0.0122644752,
0.0005450162,
0.0254058875,
0.0098899426,
0.0151798576,
-0.0543569736,
-0.0159958396,
-0.0755963922,
0.0113366414,
-0.019575797,
0.0122817028,
0.0310345851,
-0.0028911047,
-0.0047217882,
0.0625295341,
0.013402598,
-0.0241776817,
-0.0188864358,
0.0006289475,
-0.0324988626,
0.0292235557,
-0.0253657866,
-0.0023311542,
-0.0427618586,
0.0448217764,
0.0351157524,
-0.0516654402,
-0.0207784418,
0.0106572565,
2.878e-7,
0.0109306825,
0.0370818824,
0.0338905044,
0.0229010917,
0.0141222281,
0.0257370565,
-0.0496050455,
0.0123879462,
0.021107072,
-0.0486889035,
-0.0132055683,
0.0711468831,
0.0402108654,
0.0379263125,
-0.0793580413,
0.040102493,
-0.0714515075,
-0.0383462124,
-0.0350788236,
-0.026363831,
0.0324569009,
0.0629448071,
0.0317068696,
0.002033222,
0.0044717328,
-0.0305406582,
0.0617969036,
-0.050092876,
-0.0111157261,
-0.002052146,
0.0049176873,
0.0081039965,
0.0133874547,
0.0112947328,
0.0451121964,
0.0191099979,
-0.0131704947,
0.0503453687,
0.0004794393,
-0.0219389889,
-0.0325712152,
-0.0694119781,
0.0306849442,
-0.0597541779,
0.1007737815,
-0.0551272556,
-0.0278475173,
-0.0050560157,
0.0414815694,
-0.0437394604,
0.0137344766,
-0.0058343024,
-0.0162052922,
-0.002485893,
0.0000344395,
-0.0100036012,
-0.0015950646,
-0.0728816167,
-0.0124961352,
-0.0125899548,
0.0000364851,
-0.1017353386,
-0.0022035493,
-0.0074791783,
0.0244525075,
-0.0425862409,
-0.0068133045,
2.922312476e-34,
0.0103867501,
-0.0030105396,
0.0430809222,
0.061305888,
0.034538921,
0.0101111522,
-0.0044529261,
-0.0081454199,
0.0292134471,
-0.0399557836,
-0.0059207603
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03727v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03727v1 | Content-Localization based System for Analyzing Sentiment and Hate Behaviors in Low-Resource Dialectal Arabic: English to Levantine and Gulf | 2023-11-27T15:37:33 | 2023-11-27T15:37:33 | Fatimah Alzamzami, Abdulmotaleb El Saddik | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Even though online social movements can quickly become viral on social media,
languages can be a barrier to timely monitoring and analyzing the underlying
online social behaviors (OSB). This is especially true for under-resourced
languages on social media like dialectal Arabic; the primary language used by
Arabs on social media. Therefore, it is crucial to provide solutions to
efficiently exploit resources from high-resourced languages to solve
language-dependent OSB analysis in under-resourced languages. This paper
proposes to localize content of resources in high-resourced languages into
under-resourced Arabic dialects. Content localization goes beyond content
translation that converts text from one language to another; content
localization adapts culture, language nuances and regional preferences from one
language to a specific language/dialect. Automating understanding of the
natural and familiar day-to-day expressions in different regions, is the key to
achieve a wider analysis of OSB especially for smart cities. In this paper, we
utilize content-localization based neural machine translation to develop
sentiment and hate classifiers for two low-resourced Arabic dialects: Levantine
and Gulf. Not only this but we also leverage unsupervised learning to
facilitate the analysis of sentiment and hate predictions by inferring hidden
topics from the corresponding data and providing coherent interpretations of
those topics in their native language/dialects. The experimental evaluations
and proof-of-concept COVID-19 case study on real data have validated the
effectiveness of our proposed system in precisely distinguishing sentiments and
accurately identifying hate content in both Levantine and Gulf Arabic dialects.
Our findings shed light on the importance of considering the unique nature of
dialects within the same language and ignoring the dialectal aspect would lead
to misleading analysis. | [
0.0320558175,
0.0671166331,
-0.0225712154,
0.009967966,
-0.027108714,
0.0241014622,
0.0507096499,
-0.0203037448,
-0.0030397992,
-0.0360594019,
0.0062581543,
-0.0272670705,
0.0138261365,
-0.0028088214,
-0.0093473624,
-0.0264405161,
0.013585275,
0.0330387652,
0.0106581552,
-0.0363633037,
0.0667309314,
0.0292458534,
0.0314141698,
0.0248880666,
-0.0361843072,
0.0061575938,
-0.0043992326,
0.0027469313,
0.0471834019,
0.0163508654,
0.0184014924,
0.0198724121,
0.0105514172,
0.0549364127,
0.000001958,
-0.021370057,
-0.0316419452,
-0.027322676,
0.0424747095,
-0.032898888,
0.0969098657,
-0.0814834088,
-0.0145255923,
0.0323634893,
-0.0415639244,
-0.0069816792,
0.0421359129,
0.0180548672,
0.0710784569,
0.0737341419,
-0.0218476728,
-0.0245012008,
-0.0392748564,
0.0056158337,
0.0005943549,
0.0374070928,
-0.0170898549,
-0.0273854062,
-0.044192791,
0.00376654,
0.0036101842,
0.034439642,
-0.0139206909,
0.0074820872,
-0.0377351567,
-0.0404558368,
-0.0451935343,
-0.0241568703,
0.0216568224,
0.0448785424,
-0.0357133634,
-0.0242688209,
0.019738527,
-0.0000920144,
-0.0256805345,
-0.0059584044,
-0.0257278532,
0.0023325474,
0.009472928,
0.0484465174,
0.0104845082,
0.0223316588,
0.0227804333,
0.0113561191,
-0.0425458103,
0.0430166274,
-0.0382791534,
-0.0211777762,
-0.0214227177,
0.0281880144,
0.0093393791,
-0.0024077948,
0.094058454,
0.0248222854,
0.0258556921,
0.0110908067,
-0.0344822221,
-0.0365957655,
0.0024079236,
-0.1306331307,
-0.0034014427,
0.03880959,
-0.0173850097,
0.0233685412,
0.0109395124,
-0.0147190001,
0.0119135557,
0.0160851367,
-0.0444139242,
-0.0186755601,
-0.0562896729,
0.0311701652,
0.0252708755,
0.0080039566,
-0.0388619676,
0.0288858768,
-0.0407418236,
-0.0081578996,
-0.0412626714,
0.0078280251,
-0.0357087106,
0.0141467452,
0.0149134966,
0.001065835,
0.0049951533,
0.0384052955,
-0.033545386,
-0.0028157625,
-0.0764638633,
-0.0526459441,
0.0310848039,
0.0365003124,
0.0379078537,
0.0441316217,
0.0095248902,
0.0236937609,
0.0421893857,
-0.0121287471,
-0.0617334768,
-0.0014509883,
-0.0108424956,
-0.0199566502,
0.0002913997,
-0.0800957754,
0.0552409329,
0.0184742752,
-0.0303419586,
-0.0295245145,
-0.0101781925,
0.0214866679,
-0.0051693614,
0.0637175068,
0.0125709884,
0.0122498441,
0.0619865134,
0.0184640754,
0.0670817494,
0.0556305535,
-0.0051843417,
0.0407247543,
0.0554855689,
0.0017665069,
-0.0197540112,
0.0181085486,
0.0628318116,
0.0169902556,
-0.0968830585,
-0.0389283188,
-0.0216578469,
-0.0117416661,
0.0016576459,
0.0298168715,
0.018084323,
-0.0192231368,
0.0500605777,
0.0306191109,
-0.0706019476,
0.0340497568,
0.0041855522,
0.0935169011,
-0.0135827027,
-0.0374373496,
0.0062859338,
-0.0035142882,
-0.0120702442,
-0.0680984855,
0.0272880495,
0.0720791593,
-0.0408364236,
-0.0530965775,
-0.001726912,
-0.0289457869,
0.0511616506,
-0.0098127294,
0.05212887,
-0.0100806607,
0.0097707082,
-0.0089891041,
0.0405852385,
-0.0164899882,
0.023413999,
-0.0411900245,
-0.0126478886,
0.0505880155,
-0.0260954648,
0.001867017,
-0.0244122278,
-0.0357502252,
0.0210910533,
0.0306949019,
0.0314776972,
-0.0008202766,
-0.025745308,
-0.0340331085,
-0.0065140524,
0.0373264775,
0.0034834782,
-0.0159683377,
0.0315595157,
0.0870387554,
0.0032082053,
-0.0165778138,
-0.0252980925,
-0.0171399061,
0.0343439691,
0.0149347922,
0.0179252103,
0.0562859923,
0.0099555831,
0.0492192023,
0.0085935108,
-0.03402327,
0.0042668637,
-0.04822978,
-0.0476647876,
0.0338985063,
-0.0254353397,
-0.0131022567,
0.039851889,
-0.0314101726,
-0.0141755603,
0.0563171282,
-0.0174713507,
-0.0103998687,
0.09953776,
-0.0259474702,
0.0085233506,
0.0124430461,
-0.0004753669,
-0.0507634953,
0.0295889992,
-0.0074018189,
0.0612879954,
-0.0326614417,
-0.0200491529,
0.0159182809,
-0.0811826587,
0.050656043,
0.0427268334,
-0.0288910642,
-0.0256645642,
-0.0010810862,
0.0174374878,
0.0245828554,
-0.0025114799,
0.002715603,
-0.012962956,
-0.0862438455,
-0.0431606732,
-0.0362114161,
0.0310162585,
0.0141630443,
0.0308285374,
-0.0030053644,
0.0042661186,
-0.0406476334,
-0.0055108657,
0.0071938406,
0.0156540405,
0.0101394849,
-0.0472836532,
0.0196639244,
-0.0405616052,
-0.0010742996,
-0.003703444,
0.0239492748,
0.0077301124,
-0.0605877154,
0.0169515032,
-0.0438641384,
-0.0367477462,
0.0145558538,
0.0128739057,
-0.056366019,
0.0353878289,
0.0088165058,
0.0181064364,
0.0394026451,
-0.0033505454,
0.0635699257,
0.0044968198,
0.0039042155,
-0.0797313526,
0.0035577037,
-0.0446631759,
0.0125729609,
-0.0544811524,
-0.0592282303,
-0.0425705649,
0.0479213223,
0.0146827055,
0.0161470845,
-0.0448923297,
0.0458020978,
-0.066689454,
-0.0088625159,
-0.0093853697,
0.0386773534,
0.0287451595,
0.0423359983,
0.0063327719,
-0.0509398393,
0.02043535,
0.0234875288,
0.0547454804,
-0.0062374347,
-0.0472068563,
-0.0255937129,
0.0288572889,
-0.0099496339,
0.0400524959,
-0.0651577488,
-0.0052739163,
-0.0043776566,
-0.0479329228,
-0.017133737,
-0.0272822194,
-0.0362738818,
-0.012928661,
-0.0276004225,
0.0047329068,
-0.0138046341,
0.0015288841,
-0.0341804437,
-0.0496674702,
-0.0404905193,
0.0468821786,
-0.0392720439,
-0.0017322121,
0.0127458861,
0.0117837628,
-0.0071915039,
0.0134445205,
-0.0005600468,
0.0276070796,
-0.0295335837,
0.0338940434,
-0.0207124222,
0.0301093701,
0.0264806636,
-0.0274273343,
0.0415840819,
-0.0149076423,
-0.0069783344,
-0.0442649908,
-0.0221126601,
0.0398685783,
-0.0011050418,
-0.0423952788,
-0.0642720237,
0.0240883678,
-0.0184613317,
0.0246938672,
0.10112717,
0.0280220751,
-0.0578231998,
0.0125380903,
-0.0416363515,
-0.0182595588,
0.0152610084,
0.0194926169,
-0.0649564415,
0.0125583103,
0.0037105177,
0.0584139489,
-0.0161978286,
-0.0043667983,
0.0132062454,
-0.0588825606,
-0.0136387814,
0.0032815016,
-0.0281102452,
-0.0524874181,
-0.0141610848,
-0.0105255842,
-0.0193425007,
-0.0023388418,
-0.0997342095,
0.0513249896,
0.008188148,
0.0188805331,
-0.0688992813,
-0.0453302041,
0.0076118014,
-0.0209050775,
0.0488990098,
-0.0112360297,
0.0605978221,
-0.001758373,
-0.0430185646,
0.0096192043,
0.016610181,
-0.0078764567,
-0.0486884452,
0.0132472115,
-0.0063227094,
-0.0372451246,
-0.0325732902,
0.0079796808,
-0.0689868778,
0.0141363507,
-0.0106143532,
0.0546977744,
-0.010899649,
-0.0008209125,
-0.0450406931,
0.026973024,
0.0311222021,
0.0208140407,
0.0203076415,
-0.0724585652,
-0.0160168894,
-0.0131441131,
-0.0155751044,
-0.0489150323,
-0.0322913416,
-0.0164158978,
0.0355442092,
-0.0497615524,
-0.0313705206,
-0.0451128855,
0.0071929428,
0.0573334917,
-0.000564805,
-0.0347648486,
0.0531433076,
-0.0311441794,
-0.0505839176,
-0.0036128801,
-0.0003281457,
0.0108676963,
0.0236267112,
-0.0371284708,
0.020838527,
-0.029017048,
0.003998741,
-0.0249843728,
-0.071719788,
-0.0424017049,
0.0390273258,
0.0289297923,
0.015718719,
0.0307895523,
-0.0294519309,
-0.0525888428,
0.0638035312,
0.0132099101,
0.0026428655,
-0.0127897542,
0.0424989872,
0.0332279131,
0.0166803822,
0.0440676063,
0.0063045691,
0.0381498374,
0.0362616293,
-0.0516184121,
-0.0880386382,
-0.0137293749,
-0.0145169739,
-0.0423920564,
0.0372464098,
0.0232413746,
-0.0566412322,
-0.0425780341,
-0.0394355841,
-0.0155761205,
0.0068029901,
-0.0250558164,
-0.0232772436,
0.0300054308,
0.043228019,
-0.0386166535,
-0.0059149908,
0.0046452791,
-0.0540857799,
-0.0035642372,
0.0460816436,
0.0182493273,
0.0407652035,
0.0008933675,
0.0505444631,
0.0040010191,
0.0281869154,
-0.0173603259,
-0.0047651376,
-0.047802005,
-0.0195654351,
-0.0141328331,
0.0288106371,
0.0100156171,
0.0260257535,
0.0485275201,
-0.0222658496,
-0.0167832859,
0.0090932539,
0.015986152,
-0.0325918123,
0.0654949546,
0.0353490375,
-0.0079507744,
0.0082321921,
0.031441588,
-0.035267584,
-0.0908608586,
-0.0246917009,
-0.0349651091,
-0.0316756256,
0.0218693428,
0.0531604178,
-0.0423331894,
-0.0006452815,
0.0563322566,
-0.0568501391,
0.0057116025,
0.035051465,
0.0652641729,
-0.0023017942,
-0.0125422897,
0.0250953622,
-0.0396222696,
-0.0839423239,
0.0518975146,
-0.0383285992,
-0.0094643561,
-0.0000831019,
0.0278741475,
0.0796531439,
-0.0139884707,
0.0398788191,
-0.0514153428,
0.0228200015,
-0.0230160709,
-0.0626804829,
0.0261165127,
-6.329990059e-33,
0.0342715718,
-0.0417836457,
-0.0162444096,
-0.0129940072,
0.0254714098,
-0.0248059127,
-0.0190798417,
0.0297918133,
-0.0053033703,
0.0358211063,
-0.0083919568,
0.0387011468,
0.0147500243,
0.0103399521,
0.0152905975,
-0.0315133743,
0.0300021935,
-0.0155700948,
0.0027553993,
0.0430940278,
0.0821804851,
0.017479334,
0.1002901495,
-0.1075702012,
0.0280490369,
-0.0132706482,
-0.0185356922,
0.0082611591,
0.0561566316,
0.0308380071,
-0.0237920526,
0.0725726858,
0.0240214355,
-0.0183472261,
0.0090275528,
0.0068181185,
-0.0296158567,
-0.0322839506,
-0.0138154961,
0.0475069657,
-0.0232321266,
-0.0220141206,
0.035556931,
0.0141733065,
-0.0514870696,
0.0536730848,
0.0209455285,
0.0089398185,
0.0312389806,
-0.0426261909,
-0.092914775,
0.0446124598,
-0.0276824217,
0.0154448636,
0.023989819,
0.0429181084,
0.0301873516,
0.0061362027,
-0.0844589323,
0.0018619932,
-0.0278911423,
-0.0141936643,
0.0477013327,
-0.0111071421,
-0.0140163582,
0.0580795966,
0.009284243,
0.0302217528,
0.0096529825,
0.0507292524,
0.0319645703,
-0.0322340652,
0.014361931,
0.0640257746,
-0.0087419823,
-0.07118278,
-0.0648161173,
0.0234796144,
0.0438821092,
-0.0302260183,
0.0503029414,
-0.0279167835,
-0.0399733856,
-0.0225885231,
0.0135074966,
-0.0772137493,
-0.0187299047,
-0.0278263614,
-0.0254961513,
0.000263432,
-0.0529817902,
0.0173384976,
0.0106645403,
-0.0300842114,
0.0213979464,
0.0460445583,
-0.0030133629,
0.000259392,
0.0208706893,
0.0517961569,
-0.0491232574,
-0.0039246557,
-0.0466945767,
0.0081377467,
0.0258707274,
0.0172648914,
0.0436733924,
0.080049023,
-0.056658525,
0.0168279689,
0.0022977963,
0.0128319012,
-0.0443836264,
0.06864205,
0.0280470401,
0.0057464219,
-0.0267657954,
0.0089228172,
0.0413288735,
0.0351733565,
0.0210635122,
-0.0258751884,
-0.0195533838,
-0.0130956024,
-0.0192416981,
-0.0096718716,
-0.0507099479,
0.0214432497,
-0.0035256583,
-0.0701595768,
0.0031329466,
-0.0343242101,
2.79e-7,
0.024425419,
0.0508007929,
-0.0399500914,
-0.0257872306,
0.008785014,
0.0366866477,
0.048785571,
0.0063500204,
-0.0272998568,
0.0155330151,
0.0018817071,
0.0520391352,
0.0197412409,
0.0328337513,
-0.0930353627,
0.0496591479,
-0.032887172,
0.0409621485,
-0.0200515967,
0.0432529934,
-0.0047587971,
0.1298684031,
0.0210885517,
-0.0150746126,
-0.0180535149,
-0.0001954427,
0.0102018649,
-0.0377454795,
-0.0394785218,
-0.0108170519,
0.0295701399,
0.0014279514,
-0.0016691496,
-0.0771268234,
0.0049197865,
0.0009869518,
0.0191963185,
0.0327502228,
0.0200668741,
-0.0003960058,
-0.0042253952,
-0.0282907654,
-0.0085727135,
-0.0296838265,
0.0316669047,
-0.0321992859,
-0.0532806031,
-0.051849179,
0.0218798835,
-0.0027561169,
0.0490366705,
-0.0054254164,
0.0189021006,
-0.0114214579,
0.0294420552,
-0.0114836264,
-0.0050285384,
-0.0558084995,
0.0145125054,
-0.0053584683,
-0.0020068453,
-0.0043778555,
0.0100585027,
0.0403341614,
0.0394732878,
0.0585353523,
0.0611629039,
2.006157204e-34,
0.0294052493,
0.00103784,
-0.0365972891,
-0.0652974769,
0.015659783,
0.0107600354,
-0.0572495721,
-0.0188130476,
0.029709857,
0.0016573044,
-0.0111654494
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16483v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16483v1 | ChartLlama: A Multimodal LLM for Chart Understanding and Generation | 2023-11-27T15:20:23 | 2023-11-27T15:20:23 | Yucheng Han, Chi Zhang, Xin Chen, Xu Yang, Zhibin Wang, Gang Yu, Bin Fu, Hanwang Zhang | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Multi-modal large language models have demonstrated impressive performances
on most vision-language tasks. However, the model generally lacks the
understanding capabilities for specific domain data, particularly when it comes
to interpreting chart figures. This is mainly due to the lack of relevant
multi-modal instruction tuning datasets. In this article, we create a
high-quality instruction-tuning dataset leveraging GPT-4. We develop a
multi-step data generation process in which different steps are responsible for
generating tabular data, creating chart figures, and designing instruction
tuning data separately. Our method's flexibility enables us to generate
diverse, high-quality instruction-tuning data consistently and efficiently
while maintaining a low resource expenditure. Additionally, it allows us to
incorporate a wider variety of chart and task types not yet featured in
existing datasets. Next, we introduce ChartLlama, a multi-modal large language
model that we've trained using our created dataset. ChartLlama outperforms all
prior methods in ChartQA, Chart-to-text, and Chart-extraction evaluation
benchmarks. Additionally, ChartLlama significantly improves upon the baseline
in our specially compiled chart dataset, which includes new chart and task
types. The results of ChartLlama confirm the value and huge potential of our
proposed data generation method in enhancing chart comprehension. | [
-0.0273175202,
0.0746379346,
0.0029900968,
0.0523314849,
-0.0208272394,
0.0220315699,
0.0091269864,
-0.0254025795,
0.0175395198,
0.0057990733,
-0.0839512497,
-0.015741609,
0.0096635753,
0.015713796,
0.0413365252,
-0.0661162809,
0.0153827937,
-0.0392225906,
-0.012150337,
0.0316683166,
-0.0139540853,
0.0075259199,
-0.0266116504,
0.0320649371,
-0.0430427417,
-0.0531614274,
-0.0071092732,
0.0376043096,
0.0119095361,
-0.0770448744,
-0.0256353375,
0.0308053866,
0.0452957861,
0.0030971791,
0.0000019872,
-0.0100069419,
-0.0055785635,
-0.0098473467,
-0.0088640163,
-0.0178111568,
0.0648960322,
-0.0818095878,
0.0161797144,
-0.0199808087,
-0.0225329101,
-0.0155862318,
0.0376884751,
0.0011755115,
0.1020697728,
0.0460132584,
-0.0132585354,
-0.0155791873,
-0.0328338183,
-0.0511661619,
0.0353124104,
-0.0522338748,
0.0008543653,
0.0604405664,
0.0099269105,
0.041018147,
-0.0727993473,
0.0370934606,
0.0324358977,
0.012358224,
-0.033614181,
0.0258582197,
0.019481767,
-0.0489323139,
-0.0238115247,
0.1260261685,
-0.0023752144,
0.0193441361,
-0.004482206,
-0.0107096201,
0.0132769337,
0.0187591799,
-0.0878103301,
0.0158518068,
-0.0125054242,
-0.0110320589,
-0.0094006639,
-0.0174952187,
0.0207874253,
-0.0256553236,
-0.0019976108,
-0.030167643,
-0.0178572908,
-0.0039453786,
0.002806911,
0.0032908607,
-0.0523670428,
-0.0294256173,
-0.0064590927,
0.041915644,
-0.0094946558,
0.015787093,
-0.0694518089,
-0.0336076058,
-0.0029560884,
0.0109790135,
0.0862886086,
0.0202742033,
-0.0518749021,
0.0532386154,
-0.0292293541,
0.0288395267,
-0.0236032605,
0.010659771,
-0.0363228507,
-0.0071385433,
-0.0203567296,
0.0184953865,
-0.0189744569,
-0.0297486708,
-0.0412250049,
-0.0250345916,
-0.0272743255,
0.0335900709,
0.0031108651,
0.0457872115,
0.0605048165,
-0.0083571961,
-0.0768769607,
-0.0104353437,
-0.0085794739,
0.0529343784,
-0.0424166322,
0.0144030061,
-0.0173567049,
-0.0360593125,
-0.0185007341,
0.0557846874,
0.0230928268,
-0.0174913742,
0.0164138116,
0.1137953401,
-0.013616438,
-0.0001076156,
-0.0341127105,
-0.0382871032,
-0.015107709,
-0.0525808074,
0.0457222946,
-0.045357462,
0.0368164144,
-0.0066398312,
0.0179842729,
-0.0021169106,
0.0243392847,
0.006754641,
0.0008049699,
0.0635880902,
-0.0054605808,
-0.006634546,
-0.0118383309,
-0.0211198274,
-0.0310787018,
0.0808931962,
0.0808109865,
0.0175387282,
0.0259920042,
-0.0411132611,
-0.0228454005,
0.0750079229,
0.0076723942,
-0.012315684,
-0.0226527639,
-0.0012712476,
-0.0424816683,
0.0241780765,
0.0568026714,
0.010720076,
-0.0358774848,
-0.005597461,
0.0594383925,
0.0163600538,
0.074352093,
-0.0072774393,
0.0438589081,
0.0086573772,
0.0103863869,
-0.0208884776,
-0.0577455945,
0.0460244529,
0.068551369,
0.0425555892,
-0.0383956023,
-0.0006359359,
-0.0039760242,
-0.0429496281,
0.0118723903,
0.0093376003,
-0.0128898025,
-0.002951382,
0.04170724,
0.0137274051,
-0.0588870607,
0.0323720053,
-0.0122576077,
-0.0220704693,
0.0032190774,
0.0013227214,
0.0158057436,
0.0433223099,
0.0230313707,
-0.0106243761,
-0.0405240431,
-0.0021203826,
0.0394447334,
0.0510789752,
0.0049496158,
-0.0165780261,
0.0131479753,
-0.0823743194,
-0.0478029624,
-0.0152229695,
0.0067269378,
0.0144859152,
0.0024388351,
-0.0105098216,
-0.0104975756,
-0.0937787741,
-0.011282783,
0.0097642764,
0.0124552082,
-0.0489569604,
-0.0005406985,
0.0019808209,
-0.0054723485,
0.0076962104,
-0.012368273,
0.0103385188,
0.0187857561,
-0.0390553623,
0.0550989062,
0.0341503918,
-0.0632835478,
-0.0609215237,
0.0062035383,
-0.0328767933,
-0.0341962352,
-0.0128989164,
-0.0613002963,
-0.037707895,
0.0178854894,
-0.0513950251,
-0.022211846,
0.0131055983,
-0.0305213332,
0.013995559,
0.0050800736,
-0.0296187103,
0.0474473946,
-0.02886381,
-0.0031534331,
0.0068787383,
0.0827597976,
0.0116827209,
-0.0053204796,
0.0453430749,
0.0320595913,
0.0163166262,
0.026587015,
-0.036772605,
0.0360252559,
-0.055705715,
-0.0217710026,
-0.0807741955,
0.0326173455,
-0.0012127364,
0.0196867324,
0.0229111686,
-0.0401229449,
-0.0272216219,
-0.0364009552,
-0.0230515711,
0.0401638374,
-0.019439742,
-0.0184091404,
0.0388738178,
-0.014473903,
-0.0090132123,
-0.0154489065,
0.0021953837,
-0.0090300562,
0.0126604419,
0.0336025655,
0.0140957776,
-0.0244619288,
0.0237653758,
-0.0173752867,
-0.0021199672,
0.0042149108,
-0.0047947452,
0.0394525155,
-0.0069513861,
0.0855794623,
0.0613987446,
-0.0289088767,
0.0549836531,
0.0000161418,
-0.0555641539,
-0.0482045449,
0.030470334,
-0.0094945515,
-0.0194040034,
-0.0203791242,
-0.0255802702,
-0.0258947928,
0.0864301249,
0.0228851959,
0.0179122873,
-0.0374401994,
0.0020712607,
-0.0102980901,
0.0080793491,
-0.0486754477,
0.0564236343,
-0.0160028227,
0.0087627778,
-0.043782942,
-0.0683060139,
0.0304296371,
-0.0326101109,
-0.0297720265,
-0.0073978002,
-0.0048035756,
-0.0396612212,
0.0588094443,
0.0144261206,
-0.0053871907,
-0.0414736606,
-0.0270214472,
-0.0684233233,
0.0412123762,
0.0484049916,
-0.038898468,
0.0492167249,
-0.0852068141,
-0.0087823924,
-0.0501932502,
0.0153048337,
-0.0261397958,
0.0137586165,
0.0008215368,
-0.0001186046,
0.0204651784,
-0.034963131,
-0.0363892689,
-0.0311223362,
0.0333503932,
0.0160134509,
-0.0209247153,
0.0067843576,
-0.0365296975,
0.010037832,
0.0240575038,
0.0546446331,
-0.0342964195,
-0.0858527422,
0.0121473065,
0.0237343386,
0.0052961567,
-0.0092049865,
-0.0237121508,
0.0396636687,
-0.0177214723,
0.0336913727,
0.0045790896,
0.0379331782,
0.0856993496,
-0.0630778447,
0.025478119,
0.060740903,
-0.009926822,
-0.026780108,
-0.0347093716,
0.0437183417,
0.0405120067,
0.0166129619,
0.0016782506,
-0.111092478,
-0.0494774468,
-0.0053924806,
0.0471086688,
0.0436187312,
-0.0342700183,
-0.0468928479,
-0.0892646909,
0.0651836693,
0.0194029938,
-0.0402533971,
-0.0275716484,
-0.0217777565,
-0.0100635393,
-0.0089528933,
0.0016046708,
-0.0207331516,
-0.0275752246,
0.0251829345,
0.0423639193,
-0.0261755381,
-0.0471896268,
-0.0028419122,
-0.0148103591,
-0.0195166394,
0.0060373247,
0.0436575264,
-0.0013837011,
-0.0250140708,
0.0182176512,
0.0116411466,
-0.0131701874,
-0.0172361918,
0.0533961765,
0.0154187353,
-0.0609026738,
-0.0016109188,
0.0505888462,
-0.0456126072,
-0.0012253973,
0.0135626551,
0.049949605,
-0.0150659392,
-0.0048602801,
-0.0195826516,
0.017800197,
0.0009380254,
0.0410145111,
0.0620487817,
-0.01945813,
-0.0312965475,
-0.0415561609,
0.0053161439,
-0.1152556017,
-0.0014779555,
0.0162225049,
-0.0188417751,
0.0035378889,
-0.0339706354,
-0.0314658806,
0.0485076942,
0.0489257909,
0.0093295556,
-0.0041057975,
0.0016749752,
-0.0294611845,
-0.0648921356,
0.0782800019,
-0.0320613533,
0.0325118788,
-0.0481413752,
-0.0583204702,
0.0038269975,
0.0145837748,
-0.0124362847,
0.0516717322,
-0.1269268394,
-0.0005611969,
-0.0247143619,
0.0458129048,
0.012108366,
0.0385863818,
0.0265116971,
0.0050834254,
0.021725025,
0.0588237308,
0.0022202141,
-0.0186775345,
0.0074721612,
0.0367233269,
-0.0009526795,
-0.0026994923,
-0.0313185416,
0.0457653105,
0.014894248,
0.0410658866,
-0.0098744687,
0.0186053291,
0.0110334689,
0.023702478,
0.0011711044,
-0.0053396886,
-0.0005070968,
-0.0279954262,
-0.0419532917,
-0.0052337199,
-0.0200282335,
-0.0507495031,
-0.0028101455,
0.0415159911,
-0.0294832475,
-0.0039379215,
0.0037152404,
0.041310899,
0.0245271772,
-0.0661806539,
0.0802942589,
0.003994755,
-0.0190437194,
0.0187793355,
0.0311102681,
-0.0083507672,
0.0130357891,
-0.0160578173,
0.0448870882,
0.0424051397,
0.0685829222,
-0.0029957604,
0.0001998344,
-0.0078890109,
0.0484395884,
-0.009648622,
-0.0511983484,
-0.016192032,
0.0121322107,
0.0520611294,
0.0020925994,
0.0364526995,
-0.0147440499,
-0.001759749,
-0.0029062512,
0.0669533312,
0.0017691207,
0.0076441579,
0.0771909952,
0.0206384342,
0.003904718,
-0.0915896371,
0.0861520693,
0.0102044716,
0.0315986797,
-0.040725749,
0.0290118661,
-0.0718782544,
-0.0047341883,
0.0149540547,
-0.0309718475,
0.0201824866,
0.0277625248,
-0.0350942686,
-0.0837789774,
-0.01273451,
0.0234775618,
0.0011123572,
0.014039035,
0.045237042,
0.0360874198,
-0.0107197911,
-0.0164689329,
-0.0147208031,
0.0107446471,
0.0173461642,
-0.0255146958,
-0.0222887918,
-5.48692294e-33,
-0.0397516228,
-0.0509305969,
0.0579726659,
-0.0291325729,
-0.0129545294,
0.0123140272,
-0.0460304245,
-0.0049803695,
0.0016866931,
0.0074792621,
0.0460930057,
-0.0135386279,
0.009570146,
0.0144941993,
0.0062314621,
-0.0000177876,
0.0522258841,
-0.0242228694,
-0.023916807,
0.0176793616,
0.0328593105,
0.0204861071,
0.0453359336,
-0.0644174889,
0.0154719278,
0.0216240529,
-0.0116450647,
0.0078874072,
0.0331085064,
0.05350383,
0.0002263854,
0.0534553528,
0.0228897929,
-0.0267625228,
-0.0529792011,
0.0274049938,
-0.064961046,
-0.0582551844,
-0.0024431916,
0.0305131879,
-0.0525617003,
-0.0244186055,
0.051837489,
-0.0182226114,
-0.0249762256,
-0.0490695871,
0.0353727117,
-0.0191634223,
0.0017559009,
0.0303165149,
-0.018491568,
0.0247951485,
-0.001876791,
-0.0464012213,
0.0378746502,
0.0841029063,
0.0183009636,
0.026035849,
-0.0419859104,
0.0588476025,
0.0013830122,
-0.0149627896,
0.077215597,
0.0575702377,
0.0302468315,
0.0347827338,
0.0140709607,
-0.0014859862,
-0.0330336429,
0.0181759708,
0.0269149598,
0.0829946548,
0.027575111,
0.0107114986,
0.0091940165,
0.0056563593,
-0.0215694308,
0.0521267988,
-0.0205326881,
0.0312305335,
-0.0434616171,
0.0051222425,
-0.0092315525,
-0.0066477014,
-0.0242999699,
0.0005703101,
-0.0248613991,
0.0138981221,
0.0434835181,
-0.0011785944,
0.0067660352,
0.0257412922,
0.0369505957,
-0.0187870748,
-0.0096483836,
-0.0049560163,
-0.0039403462,
0.0490195751,
0.0052587148,
-0.0410172381,
-0.0459053703,
-0.0438315384,
0.0541380271,
-0.0166997667,
0.0363256112,
0.011927587,
0.0078902179,
0.0112920282,
-0.0495836474,
-0.0122420248,
-0.0372485146,
-0.0085260225,
-0.0068734335,
0.0161125008,
0.0458742194,
-0.0245405138,
-0.0657670721,
0.0342098959,
0.0062136794,
0.0202193446,
-0.0172848944,
-0.0261576995,
-0.0562662929,
0.0436930507,
-0.0041603036,
-0.0104914205,
-0.0213428587,
-0.0473707505,
0.0088704275,
-0.0630163774,
-0.0036496981,
-0.0193978976,
2.527e-7,
0.0617554747,
0.0375942327,
0.0188167933,
0.0531564392,
0.0228244066,
0.0242702104,
-0.0644614697,
-0.0233312361,
-0.0102263689,
-0.0307142753,
0.0006269949,
0.0274180546,
0.051927302,
0.0541699864,
-0.0261618309,
-0.0083601503,
0.0125702955,
0.0053947484,
-0.0525572151,
0.0389846265,
0.0724186972,
0.0605549328,
-0.0410151817,
-0.0228401888,
0.0364559032,
-0.0380650908,
0.0703406185,
-0.0355532058,
-0.0042385655,
-0.023112284,
-0.0109982667,
0.0384652168,
-0.0113059618,
0.0237132702,
-0.0216619819,
-0.0080472119,
0.025733443,
0.0597738139,
0.0204486847,
0.0170057211,
0.0148312887,
0.018501455,
-0.0064947191,
-0.0241267681,
0.0341815315,
-0.0723253861,
-0.0470630862,
0.004549752,
-0.0022385994,
0.025873078,
0.014325602,
-0.0252023712,
-0.0316499509,
-0.0064788084,
0.046797704,
-0.017804306,
-0.0082968585,
-0.0099204807,
-0.0347092971,
0.0340025946,
-0.0448354594,
-0.04797123,
-0.0507663824,
-0.0102093974,
-0.0087110978,
0.0127376467,
-0.0457091592,
2.327093565e-34,
0.0087001668,
-0.0410242938,
0.0428383052,
0.0032124897,
0.0438680984,
-0.0259832162,
0.0171898454,
0.047213804,
0.0126448255,
-0.0926791877,
-0.0224529169
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15896v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15896v1 | Data Generation for Post-OCR correction of Cyrillic handwriting | 2023-11-27T15:01:26 | 2023-11-27T15:01:26 | Evgenii Davydkin, Aleksandr Markelov, Egor Iuldashev, Anton Dudkin, Ivan Krivorotov | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | This paper introduces a novel approach to post-Optical Character Recognition
Correction (POC) for handwritten Cyrillic text, addressing a significant gap in
current research methodologies. This gap is due to the lack of large text
corporas that provide OCR errors for further training of language-based POC
models, which are demanding in terms of corpora size. Our study primarily
focuses on the development and application of a synthetic handwriting
generation engine based on B\'ezier curves. Such an engine generates highly
realistic handwritten text in any amounts, which we utilize to create a
substantial dataset by transforming Russian text corpora sourced from the
internet. We apply a Handwritten Text Recognition (HTR) model to this dataset
to identify OCR errors, forming the basis for our POC model training. The
correction model is trained on a 90-symbol input context, utilizing a
pre-trained T5 architecture with a seq2seq correction task. We evaluate our
approach on HWR200 and School_notebooks_RU datasets as they provide significant
challenges in the HTR domain. Furthermore, POC can be used to highlight errors
for teachers, evaluating student performance. This can be done simply by
comparing sentences before and after correction, displaying differences in
text. Our primary contribution lies in the innovative use of B\'ezier curves
for Cyrillic text generation and subsequent error correction using a
specialized POC model. We validate our approach by presenting Word Accuracy
Rate (WAR) and Character Accuracy Rate (CAR) results, both with and without
post-OCR correction, using real open corporas of handwritten Cyrillic text.
These results, coupled with our methodology, are designed to be reproducible,
paving the way for further advancements in the field of OCR and handwritten
text analysis. Paper contributions can be found in
https://github.com/dbrainio/CyrillicHandwritingPOC | [
0.0205579326,
0.0459863842,
0.0169626772,
0.0463336036,
-0.0342501551,
-0.0304420292,
0.0504631922,
0.0231923983,
-0.0107244253,
0.0005027337,
0.0429111086,
-0.038095288,
0.0664171427,
0.0067588403,
-0.0002452107,
-0.0722602606,
-0.0275394563,
-0.0624199435,
-0.0681576282,
0.005298391,
0.0117156412,
0.022327004,
-0.0225465149,
-0.0043972926,
-0.0514186248,
0.0202972721,
0.0094347177,
0.0441941023,
0.0169735961,
0.0089067556,
-0.0214410722,
0.0253837798,
-0.020231694,
0.0986095965,
0.000002018,
-0.0527110323,
-0.0488573201,
0.0220128112,
0.0103390105,
0.0041923793,
0.1192177981,
-0.0383128114,
-0.059167102,
-0.0172394104,
0.0374404304,
-0.0079899719,
0.0729891136,
0.0782378763,
-0.0201434717,
0.0783165172,
-0.0239194334,
-0.0109752277,
0.0113624129,
0.0137406355,
-0.0244202707,
0.0280114505,
0.0088984678,
0.0141780525,
-0.0275028441,
0.0106089236,
-0.0087952865,
0.0206322409,
0.0151751135,
-0.0832182691,
-0.0107910112,
0.0132092545,
0.0532420464,
0.0165431965,
-0.0183986165,
0.0379542634,
-0.0245343708,
-0.0181296691,
0.0302848145,
-0.0099764327,
0.0014230494,
0.0123630054,
-0.0030708732,
0.0130975852,
-0.0655472726,
-0.0241809748,
-0.0522493683,
-0.0157204755,
-0.041742757,
-0.0122249275,
0.0373987481,
0.0123914033,
-0.0024444042,
-0.0518584363,
-0.0153631642,
0.009114841,
0.024090549,
0.0014515906,
0.0760223567,
0.022908777,
0.0505253077,
-0.0024162419,
-0.0937917084,
-0.051210627,
0.0145968823,
-0.0236211605,
0.0900153443,
0.0259762108,
-0.0060047698,
-0.0107610328,
-0.0853988603,
0.0753415227,
-0.018077312,
0.041426409,
-0.0303759649,
0.0080343867,
-0.0478237271,
0.0132913804,
-0.0564402379,
-0.0836042985,
0.0461668037,
0.0284747854,
-0.0230141934,
0.0085737053,
0.0214110166,
0.0224966165,
0.0086576827,
-0.0209623538,
0.0010595246,
-0.0420949683,
-0.0149157457,
-0.0047997632,
0.0283856262,
0.0025298861,
-0.060963247,
-0.0088101821,
0.0282815732,
0.0282300897,
0.0449644774,
0.019265594,
0.0142547768,
0.0184656978,
-0.0370054841,
0.0044767726,
0.0157118961,
-0.0118204821,
-0.0193889812,
-0.0284076408,
-0.0085674301,
-0.0510084406,
-0.0187895969,
-0.0309542138,
-0.0238361191,
-0.0057415008,
-0.0015283232,
0.0112385107,
-0.0278657749,
0.0132697392,
-0.0405997932,
-0.0176511612,
0.0791246518,
-0.0410423279,
0.0408715047,
-0.0410046168,
0.0306116827,
0.0185341928,
0.0379927866,
-0.0354329012,
0.011910568,
0.0317983627,
-0.0151672447,
-0.0607253052,
0.0236634165,
-0.0414655209,
0.0231135376,
0.0403950103,
0.0907354802,
0.0611594953,
-0.0540712066,
0.0158144869,
0.0538350306,
0.0251892302,
0.0282268822,
0.0615132079,
-0.0069043841,
-0.0286380108,
0.045784682,
0.0146422386,
-0.0424922779,
0.0109408563,
0.0394483916,
0.0187238157,
-0.0287235081,
0.0113030812,
0.0100015784,
-0.0055590244,
-0.00839967,
-0.0112470873,
-0.0073224655,
-0.0693425089,
0.0997593775,
-0.0075754756,
-0.0893926546,
-0.0343154073,
-0.0078117303,
-0.0683985129,
-0.0135513563,
-0.0413373671,
0.0025919224,
0.0679181963,
0.1047381386,
-0.0467634909,
0.0458478108,
0.038712956,
-0.0634898394,
0.0424527079,
0.018891586,
0.0022945118,
-0.0296290275,
-0.0768064708,
0.0062850346,
0.0188638046,
-0.0262688063,
0.0454788171,
-0.0229463615,
0.0329836309,
0.0221606828,
-0.0036242113,
-0.086876817,
0.0303049143,
-0.0182077214,
-0.0125328582,
-0.0276464876,
0.0160525572,
-0.0171752535,
0.0057413308,
-0.029500708,
-0.0018360448,
0.0216810387,
-0.0174298249,
0.0105497958,
-0.0452513024,
-0.0159897264,
0.0004833044,
0.0691119507,
-0.0289405212,
-0.0086614266,
-0.0063690785,
0.0235717129,
-0.0264344886,
0.0022526241,
0.0051543587,
-0.030069245,
-0.0481856018,
0.0433922671,
-0.0374728926,
-0.0220492035,
-0.0087139634,
-0.0140775507,
0.0379782505,
-0.0046845912,
-0.006794442,
-0.0056414967,
-0.0149684381,
-0.0488477163,
-0.0262131337,
0.0011118875,
0.0070397137,
0.0241611023,
-0.0022873448,
0.0496081859,
-0.0186673887,
-0.0308151431,
-0.0534965396,
-0.0433332697,
0.0064681387,
0.0010564299,
0.0426265039,
-0.0281002056,
0.0151218222,
-0.0419787504,
0.0104453843,
0.0158194117,
-0.0041199103,
-0.0697709769,
0.0372019038,
-0.0575539507,
-0.03561005,
0.0136903087,
-0.0309111439,
-0.0142789045,
-0.0356353968,
0.0371434838,
-0.0359645896,
-0.0651977807,
0.0638235956,
-0.0055272062,
0.0390067175,
-0.0134989601,
-0.0270654745,
-0.0035917768,
-0.0146000898,
-0.0011782778,
0.0559779555,
-0.0117775043,
-0.0672361478,
0.0580092035,
-0.0275177639,
0.0494483709,
-0.0111818714,
0.0016474688,
0.0438214689,
0.0269943122,
-0.0477621891,
-0.0250632279,
-0.0055908458,
0.0113168629,
0.0413555019,
-0.0093121445,
-0.0889334083,
-0.0287882425,
0.0171588678,
-0.0400752425,
-0.0406864174,
0.0020896813,
-0.0240153801,
-0.0438167006,
-0.0031875751,
0.021241758,
-0.0538756996,
-0.0172869824,
0.015158006,
0.0329059064,
0.0090386774,
-0.0028510692,
0.0674233884,
0.0275723152,
-0.0020673503,
-0.0359536782,
-0.0163169038,
-0.0165028237,
0.0639447421,
-0.0654718354,
-0.0070913034,
-0.0313296095,
0.0609471016,
-0.0348771885,
-0.0054242718,
0.0302694496,
-0.0081510777,
0.0341897495,
-0.0156165194,
-0.0379260257,
-0.0454905927,
0.0251638219,
0.0237237364,
0.0061716037,
0.1140753031,
-0.017003458,
0.0160249453,
-0.0292195734,
0.0481484421,
-0.018046841,
-0.0379369184,
-0.0145778675,
-0.0681848079,
0.0015408455,
0.0107304342,
0.0405389518,
-0.031058725,
0.0051791989,
-0.0399759114,
-0.0014118988,
0.0249882918,
-0.0169604775,
-0.0198443737,
-0.0024880855,
-0.0492706411,
-0.0324866883,
0.0562471002,
-0.013748982,
0.0188803039,
-0.0582602844,
0.0015290953,
-0.021934798,
-0.0617567189,
0.0128532313,
-0.0475748181,
0.0182846356,
0.0117274104,
0.0610651448,
-0.0589173138,
-0.0033448664,
-0.0108161857,
-0.0841878355,
0.0121550392,
0.0353852957,
-0.0244917385,
-0.0233371053,
0.0040315758,
0.0093820551,
0.0058229817,
-0.0490478799,
0.0414155424,
-0.0131155439,
-0.0374313816,
0.0382031314,
-0.0365412347,
-0.0010405697,
-0.023280032,
0.0123560587,
-0.0340570919,
0.0246023498,
0.0053982511,
-0.0015492311,
0.0110018933,
-0.0108355405,
0.0166124161,
0.0155574959,
-0.0179518983,
0.0897366405,
0.0386283137,
-0.0017920927,
-0.017380029,
0.0420033708,
-0.0188326109,
0.0080916854,
-0.0122019891,
-0.0279715415,
0.0080135008,
0.0048727756,
0.0217617173,
-0.0209575929,
0.0012584128,
-0.0300893784,
-0.0446407683,
-0.0050302278,
-0.0464002639,
-0.0081550209,
0.0263103023,
-0.0741058365,
-0.0121586472,
0.0229759701,
-0.0453911498,
-0.0722751096,
0.0053778491,
-0.0071162777,
-0.0076261121,
0.0471063331,
-0.0185037386,
-0.0076676146,
0.0032798399,
0.0053658606,
-0.0239398573,
-0.0056189671,
-0.0221602134,
0.0017859036,
-0.1062781736,
0.0238635764,
-0.0377231948,
-0.0299376398,
-0.0098136272,
0.0227087047,
-0.0379940793,
-0.0252840091,
0.0980205759,
0.0650878325,
0.0102896765,
-0.0183363929,
0.0002590709,
-0.0630002692,
0.0884546489,
0.0254513025,
0.0724587739,
0.0048471484,
-0.0245906878,
-0.0526075326,
-0.0330251679,
0.0027458174,
0.0157126617,
-0.0007732547,
0.0355113931,
-0.0712049827,
-0.0129377684,
-0.0547112897,
-0.0074526654,
0.0152281402,
0.0486158542,
-0.0018780273,
0.0320153758,
-0.0765594989,
0.0063918247,
-0.0023569064,
0.0008913098,
-0.0101372059,
-0.0069797677,
0.0073034093,
0.0021106929,
-0.0023058977,
-0.0184633527,
-0.0148943486,
-0.0062846243,
-0.0258395411,
-0.0024089371,
0.0308551695,
0.0921973363,
0.0143173747,
-0.0189229324,
0.0206126366,
0.0336738117,
-0.007445761,
0.0178620256,
0.0207476374,
0.0108342031,
-0.025086211,
0.0162121765,
-0.0047369376,
0.0367544889,
-0.0832050443,
0.0492253825,
-0.0809879228,
0.0485384353,
0.0604657941,
0.0089135049,
0.0677694157,
-0.0590659715,
-0.0045827553,
-0.035620261,
-0.0103589296,
0.0327876285,
0.0109362686,
-0.0466962866,
-0.0217096992,
0.0250921715,
-0.006476108,
-0.0080942437,
-0.0180121623,
0.0170715991,
0.004678831,
-0.0015424307,
-0.0308442824,
0.0214144606,
0.02939214,
-0.0962520614,
-0.0272293426,
-0.039165765,
0.0049373284,
-0.0005779866,
0.0789534226,
0.0484363548,
-0.0082265567,
0.0019526468,
0.0317911096,
-0.0179559365,
-0.0532609858,
0.0354383998,
-0.002168155,
0.0241926517,
0.0169215146,
-0.0222170446,
-0.0265764482,
-4.997940065e-33,
-0.0124452608,
0.0009428948,
0.0015260159,
-0.0055941842,
-0.0256643947,
0.0137600061,
0.0160176605,
0.0044684079,
0.0001699468,
-0.0037720199,
-0.0182568599,
-0.0080328397,
0.0357252844,
0.0030061367,
-0.0089912293,
0.0516545884,
0.0690920353,
-0.0310849603,
-0.036471691,
-0.0027375484,
0.0967286453,
0.0290562771,
0.0681701303,
-0.0123548852,
0.0329642296,
-0.0420537852,
-0.0522973873,
-0.0408835858,
0.0177618694,
-0.0060445135,
0.0069200364,
0.0463751927,
0.0161872413,
0.0395921469,
-0.0045970459,
0.0350357592,
-0.0618256815,
0.0325361863,
-0.058474578,
0.0766064227,
-0.0488745049,
-0.0289921239,
0.0201247167,
-0.0262752809,
-0.0445870757,
-0.0109931007,
-0.0041167131,
-0.0078016976,
-0.0099752033,
0.0198869519,
-0.014538371,
0.0125950957,
-0.0060805688,
-0.0525128432,
0.0263537522,
0.0037776553,
0.0126290983,
-0.0461192988,
-0.0643758774,
0.0463052094,
0.042298764,
0.0263169184,
-0.0145729557,
0.0092347097,
-0.0038024294,
-0.0362089649,
0.0016355119,
0.0022757708,
0.0239626057,
-0.0200712606,
0.0229665078,
-0.0383997709,
0.036714334,
0.0745583251,
0.0820312127,
-0.0701910928,
-0.0124344798,
0.0302452054,
0.0023358227,
0.0504959412,
0.0115328077,
-0.0147694694,
0.012803019,
-0.0078720283,
0.0181793924,
-0.0705808923,
0.0002125213,
0.0194923263,
0.006730909,
0.0176703073,
0.0031163427,
-0.0300452802,
0.0035885349,
-0.0088752527,
-0.0111411782,
-0.0624559894,
-0.0163588598,
0.0651193857,
-0.0166395418,
0.0295043979,
-0.0132758254,
-0.076763168,
0.0185855888,
0.0355195291,
-0.01937888,
-0.0078571253,
0.0001548631,
0.0318631828,
-0.0341961905,
0.0418073647,
0.0291889813,
0.025579473,
0.0812650323,
0.0571398288,
0.0094403056,
-0.0301199667,
0.047500439,
0.0663789585,
0.0169333834,
-0.020276662,
0.0194201265,
-0.0146449944,
0.0173788387,
0.0030721985,
-0.0259927437,
0.026539769,
0.0143760154,
-0.0143007291,
-0.0127551854,
-0.0142595395,
0.0166785493,
0.0064501911,
2.609e-7,
0.0409244485,
0.0352703407,
0.0446647704,
-0.0007817385,
0.0281958841,
-0.0056984657,
-0.0315128081,
0.0174060632,
0.0191510729,
0.0258766934,
0.0649361089,
-0.0221689418,
0.0978004783,
-0.0000214884,
0.0032635564,
-0.0065563871,
0.0211717039,
0.0023132567,
-0.0195054282,
0.0919484645,
0.0180538669,
-0.0134508936,
-0.001721922,
-0.0461836383,
0.006948099,
-0.0172904339,
0.0452244803,
0.0209115446,
0.0220575836,
-0.006095415,
0.0092413248,
-0.0056475746,
-0.0104963155,
0.06432046,
0.0216686875,
0.010435815,
0.0319029801,
-0.0115028964,
-0.0139851328,
0.0706561804,
0.0395612046,
-0.0060618031,
-0.0187042858,
-0.040190585,
0.0507349111,
0.0449304581,
0.0357807688,
-0.0287138522,
0.0132194906,
-0.0061874641,
0.0677430332,
-0.0475227982,
-0.0628895983,
0.0128968405,
0.0417173915,
0.001331052,
0.005335052,
0.0077554593,
0.0284463223,
-0.0494795144,
0.0372004919,
-0.0265150312,
-0.0224691946,
0.0101517458,
0.0361499153,
-0.0125509873,
0.0158890411,
2.189599297e-34,
0.0023611316,
-0.0014269119,
0.0121228304,
-0.0512894765,
-0.0116850045,
-0.0063872305,
0.0570322089,
-0.0123655386,
-0.0187277663,
-0.0407257415,
-0.028929593
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15786v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15786v4 | YUAN 2.0: A Large Language Model with Localized Filtering-based Attention | 2023-11-27T13:01:59 | 2023-12-18T08:08:32 | Shaohua Wu, Xudong Zhao, Shenling Wang, Jiangang Luo, Lingjun Li, Xi Chen, Bing Zhao, Wei Wang, Tong Yu, Rongguo Zhang, Jiahua Zhang, Chao Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC | In this work, we develop and release Yuan 2.0, a series of large language
models with parameters ranging from 2.1 billion to 102.6 billion. The Localized
Filtering-based Attention (LFA) is introduced to incorporate prior knowledge of
local dependencies of natural language into Attention. A data filtering and
generating system is presented to build pre-training and fine-tuning dataset in
high quality. A distributed training method with non-uniform pipeline parallel,
data parallel, and optimizer parallel is proposed, which greatly reduces the
bandwidth requirements of intra-node communication, and achieves good
performance in large-scale distributed training. Yuan 2.0 models display
impressive ability in code generation, math problem-solving, and chatting
compared with existing models. The latest version of YUAN 2.0, including model
weights and source code, is accessible at Github. | [
0.0305681527,
0.0640007332,
-0.0060296431,
0.0384522602,
0.0274299346,
-0.0078368643,
0.0232409388,
-0.0153950974,
0.0205971487,
-0.0229913592,
-0.0431772918,
-0.0545951091,
-0.0188983027,
0.0521869659,
0.0325756781,
-0.0379344486,
0.0537832677,
-0.015168746,
-0.0079159243,
-0.0159485582,
0.0039479262,
0.0083794128,
0.028729884,
0.0584520884,
0.0170242228,
-0.0365379117,
0.0054026656,
-0.0144094238,
0.0049776235,
-0.0154836094,
0.0327903032,
0.0388138443,
0.0143767558,
0.0096843196,
0.0000021086,
0.0027056697,
0.0033517273,
-0.0348541476,
0.0117349671,
0.031064624,
0.0437555015,
0.0238779411,
-0.0193196815,
0.0284934845,
-0.046083115,
-0.016982099,
0.0598555468,
-0.0099509964,
0.0929013044,
0.0579978116,
-0.0063186912,
-0.0211879387,
0.004380655,
-0.0559813939,
-0.0143040074,
-0.0497672893,
0.0200623944,
0.0215773769,
0.0251246337,
-0.0127734281,
-0.0316955969,
0.0358054601,
0.0410892889,
-0.004998378,
0.0414348431,
0.0381182469,
-0.0351935588,
-0.0068702265,
-0.0059553268,
0.1132115275,
-0.0540472381,
-0.0390949957,
-0.0132021829,
-0.0085157584,
-0.0192657709,
-0.0387676954,
-0.0372561216,
0.0119994823,
0.007010554,
0.0356885493,
0.0177756175,
-0.0418019816,
0.0324764922,
0.0129795466,
-0.0284900609,
0.0345267653,
0.0039590141,
-0.0183938313,
-0.0448266976,
-0.0211239699,
-0.0345791169,
-0.072722666,
0.0579557233,
0.043479953,
-0.0031001884,
-0.0013953664,
-0.0631464347,
-0.0452456251,
-0.0199164003,
-0.0569906831,
0.0260194857,
0.047295358,
0.006942919,
0.0598672964,
-0.0259140916,
0.0336531438,
-0.0252910312,
0.0022695484,
-0.0338403396,
0.0080607105,
-0.0286634751,
0.0054733627,
-0.0576516278,
0.0477358699,
-0.0522684678,
-0.0414693467,
0.0012672327,
0.0428442769,
-0.001317162,
-0.0074624373,
0.0361572765,
0.0115539143,
-0.031689126,
-0.0172705445,
0.0185635798,
0.0434738621,
-0.0278776959,
-0.0235936083,
-0.012987732,
-0.0455234013,
-0.0229808856,
0.0221631173,
0.0045848265,
-0.0270252079,
-0.0056076213,
0.0660989881,
0.0031129434,
0.0001090126,
-0.017296629,
0.0133255608,
0.0142841991,
-0.0402011201,
-0.0027031542,
-0.0427220091,
-0.0066695157,
-0.0147827212,
0.0146103604,
-0.0483327582,
0.0189247597,
0.0305097252,
-0.0023628585,
0.0085083516,
-0.0345303491,
-0.0014441368,
-0.0029486169,
0.00213363,
0.0248595998,
0.0699263215,
0.0373556912,
-0.0028554022,
0.0076434421,
-0.038232252,
-0.0459230691,
0.0238947365,
0.0256165117,
0.0064387228,
-0.0237663388,
0.0165007878,
-0.00708145,
-0.0145843979,
0.0453239344,
0.0409507789,
-0.0345107466,
-0.0071132518,
0.0734751374,
0.0231114402,
0.0281017143,
0.0359523781,
0.0455690436,
0.0438248999,
-0.0140375635,
-0.0296275299,
-0.0485874303,
0.0674546361,
0.0158531237,
0.012998038,
0.0301079936,
0.0244682264,
-0.0735728145,
-0.0347020216,
0.0002026853,
0.0158543456,
0.0000021257,
0.0296631623,
0.0395373777,
-0.0068253754,
-0.0351140238,
0.066492945,
0.043139942,
-0.0448871665,
0.003949794,
-0.0282972585,
0.0534070432,
0.0843674913,
0.0405110456,
-0.0233537611,
-0.01705206,
-0.0238589682,
0.032164719,
0.0354782939,
0.0296507385,
0.0147679448,
0.0028812981,
-0.0616951995,
0.0018198917,
-0.013971502,
-0.0341705158,
0.01003394,
0.0252411198,
0.0070100715,
0.0135157304,
0.037035197,
-0.0628755987,
0.0209474899,
-0.0081997262,
-0.0153091606,
-0.0061361953,
0.0029641464,
0.0470843539,
-0.0241796598,
-0.0070562591,
0.0194703992,
0.0266942773,
-0.0139290839,
0.0057438714,
0.0132360272,
-0.0508969612,
-0.0353840664,
0.0403907523,
-0.0190729145,
-0.0028639517,
0.0378564037,
-0.0256092139,
-0.0376799926,
0.0636453629,
-0.0474897772,
0.021827301,
-0.0159632675,
0.0269142054,
0.0017234802,
0.0454504676,
-0.0039811246,
0.0486304574,
-0.0263631307,
0.0365609974,
-0.0007434622,
0.0654575899,
-0.0045592133,
-0.0493368208,
-0.0259322766,
0.0112512726,
-0.0207847971,
0.0088770129,
-0.0203306619,
0.048043333,
-0.0143139074,
-0.0091201076,
-0.0501057841,
0.0243012253,
-0.0348749943,
0.0003731606,
0.0255137328,
0.0096273981,
0.0012040518,
-0.0326521173,
-0.0332114957,
0.0297817104,
-0.0300974082,
0.0077504804,
-0.0109835006,
-0.0294192992,
-0.028432535,
-0.0516055785,
-0.045000311,
0.0027640986,
0.0386173055,
-0.0104565313,
-0.0470746867,
-0.0564333461,
0.0410438925,
-0.0281134136,
0.0592042916,
0.0005624099,
-0.056811668,
-0.0023177075,
-0.0191543084,
0.0451566242,
0.0735816583,
-0.0011583557,
-0.0133344829,
0.0503899939,
-0.0138109336,
-0.0303383004,
0.066409111,
-0.012842115,
0.0130631868,
-0.0212022234,
-0.0083653629,
-0.0086155375,
0.114508085,
-0.0230210535,
-0.0122219417,
-0.0754482225,
-0.0045725205,
-0.0081995167,
-0.0262230039,
-0.0144620696,
0.011033155,
-0.0404060297,
-0.0231397115,
-0.0670873597,
-0.0575593226,
0.0622603446,
-0.0161682814,
-0.0380118974,
-0.065858908,
-0.0144567322,
-0.0147173498,
0.0124562113,
0.0137832789,
0.0258694533,
-0.0653374791,
-0.0380334072,
-0.0239989422,
0.0319660753,
-0.031537801,
-0.0051110778,
0.0285454933,
-0.0078701526,
0.0204750933,
-0.0129077351,
-0.0464267172,
-0.0302858297,
-0.0187396687,
-0.0420550965,
0.0353646949,
0.0571338311,
-0.0248698201,
-0.0075727194,
0.0525159277,
0.0230294764,
0.0621899702,
-0.0257954709,
0.019979341,
-0.0362267345,
-0.0191863906,
0.0572690815,
-0.0281219687,
-0.0100032398,
-0.0465540104,
0.016498724,
0.056284897,
0.0580928326,
-0.0043161791,
-0.009098866,
0.0094782049,
0.0154083995,
-0.0095323985,
-0.0179540776,
0.0101516619,
0.0641590878,
-0.06490729,
-0.0323000066,
0.0782871097,
0.0162092764,
-0.0695300028,
0.005136793,
-0.0110360617,
0.0159570463,
0.0416513346,
0.0085086254,
-0.0580477864,
-0.0399102904,
-0.0065545146,
-0.0114012696,
0.0477946326,
-0.0086594149,
-0.0123877851,
-0.0939043909,
0.0095010484,
0.0303680636,
-0.0706878752,
-0.0593105778,
-0.0261110719,
-0.0096916957,
0.0183661934,
0.0012088836,
0.0218404513,
-0.0129883373,
0.0011154558,
0.0216946471,
0.0070610307,
-0.0224709976,
0.0343285426,
-0.0194164943,
0.026368361,
0.0571659058,
0.0045011151,
0.0187438875,
-0.0223678518,
0.0163681265,
0.0112572592,
-0.0076377718,
-0.0150983837,
0.0132738482,
-0.0222668163,
-0.0413351767,
-0.0158132389,
0.0139203379,
-0.0517275818,
0.0030630939,
0.0009545294,
0.0783415958,
-0.0141329654,
-0.0054055438,
-0.0010203227,
0.0300341807,
0.0175314583,
0.0606360659,
0.0576059483,
-0.0827966481,
-0.0284375846,
-0.0251995195,
-0.0403712988,
-0.0653457716,
-0.0074601667,
0.0164235644,
-0.0093257083,
-0.0299934596,
-0.0630416498,
-0.0457336493,
0.0231599323,
0.0148411198,
0.0063175494,
-0.0208565332,
0.0594542027,
-0.0091015734,
-0.0350829698,
0.0462944247,
-0.036630705,
0.0180672798,
-0.0558929518,
-0.0118385525,
0.0028761746,
-0.0277746078,
-0.0143635673,
0.0689388961,
-0.1300178617,
-0.0585532635,
-0.0086966604,
0.0558043979,
0.0106271533,
0.0168574397,
-0.0443599261,
-0.0504720993,
-0.0160942525,
-0.0157475956,
-0.0582196265,
0.0208025258,
0.0419917703,
-0.0290455967,
0.0310547519,
0.0525276847,
-0.0362753086,
0.0179430842,
0.0540116727,
0.0387729071,
-0.0393084511,
0.0006974455,
-0.0210525952,
0.0017753695,
-0.0063012289,
0.0286338534,
-0.0006357526,
-0.0393964313,
0.0528965518,
0.0095143141,
0.0007075483,
-0.0701882839,
0.0118946237,
0.0147502972,
-0.0292102974,
0.0280800555,
0.0109646702,
0.0258922279,
-0.0272024442,
0.0022441414,
0.0370524302,
-0.0238630902,
0.0244987626,
0.0673330203,
0.0130308932,
-0.0142147113,
-0.0156770293,
0.0023078332,
0.018400969,
-0.0188838989,
0.0480245464,
-0.0013825382,
-0.0158135463,
-0.0230625793,
0.0044266311,
-0.0846396983,
-0.0685417578,
-0.0322892182,
-0.0008344946,
0.0688416585,
0.0148663176,
0.03586426,
-0.0077819903,
0.0003929997,
-0.0269957818,
0.0345659852,
-0.0129970415,
-0.0422655195,
0.0180001035,
0.0133647956,
-0.0219191909,
-0.0195454173,
0.1006139293,
0.0018890471,
0.0140760252,
0.022867661,
0.0146413576,
-0.0351913683,
0.0078716548,
-0.002516004,
0.0669104606,
-0.042072732,
0.0288378391,
0.0029741703,
-0.062374007,
-0.0298313778,
-0.0170832556,
-0.0274238363,
-0.0122583117,
0.0582923628,
0.0334161855,
-0.0119197192,
-0.0188119262,
-0.0457175002,
0.0393015705,
0.0051671732,
-0.0091009857,
-0.0118287522,
-6.864012e-33,
-0.0197244417,
0.0009683834,
0.0242593382,
-0.0032266621,
-0.0202751011,
0.0049872752,
-0.057819128,
-0.0141402343,
-0.0456846841,
-0.0133613646,
-0.0041133724,
0.0771446005,
0.0110771973,
0.0350099839,
0.0047967029,
0.0113804257,
0.0514916219,
-0.0076445127,
0.0024312995,
0.0603359565,
0.0373297483,
0.0537504628,
0.0816410035,
-0.0276109055,
-0.0268584937,
0.0002828477,
0.0281374659,
0.0019085454,
-0.0217047129,
0.0383506306,
-0.026032988,
0.051187519,
-0.001377272,
-0.046304848,
-0.0671800226,
-0.0362915583,
-0.0297459047,
-0.0202332288,
0.0080330092,
0.0023446758,
-0.0195530634,
-0.0248515252,
0.037185099,
0.0161253568,
0.0349347703,
-0.0318457708,
0.0335718766,
-0.0022606214,
-0.0561751388,
0.0226141624,
-0.0179023836,
0.0282915328,
-0.0183148347,
0.0043744114,
0.0076284599,
0.0300697405,
-0.0085591078,
0.0213278681,
-0.0603462346,
0.0169799458,
0.02476261,
0.0828530937,
0.0436144061,
0.0081619155,
0.0646178424,
0.0429908596,
0.060619045,
0.0167585332,
-0.027649032,
-0.0007470072,
0.0309747439,
0.0560728386,
0.0403870717,
-0.0283992644,
-0.0059244265,
-0.0140405428,
-0.0879879966,
-0.0553111434,
0.0094264289,
0.0787979066,
0.0241675843,
0.0228501968,
-0.0372537896,
-0.0161258373,
0.0207414888,
-0.0410206243,
-0.0391198285,
-0.0302699581,
0.0361486636,
0.0248327479,
-0.0213476121,
0.0055699777,
0.0431850143,
-0.0382663608,
0.031194726,
0.0408184901,
-0.0103118038,
0.0096889809,
0.0044759442,
0.0405379832,
-0.1197655424,
-0.0288365465,
-0.0169308111,
-0.0024613161,
-0.0010765789,
0.0271835029,
0.0327198021,
0.0264150556,
-0.0570896864,
-0.0128673129,
-0.0441456847,
0.015825497,
0.0203146767,
0.0801806971,
0.0425218195,
-0.0003461869,
0.0055659083,
0.075346455,
-0.0044647078,
-0.0135075506,
-0.0239094645,
-0.0338313691,
0.0142008672,
0.0512901582,
-0.0266690031,
-0.0018415812,
-0.1022917777,
0.0647832975,
0.0507236123,
-0.0611534081,
-0.0308639463,
0.0116114132,
2.741e-7,
0.003037025,
-0.0032043804,
-0.0219735708,
0.0466367789,
0.0349135399,
0.0003244819,
-0.0115714679,
0.0412081592,
0.0284913387,
0.0443013571,
-0.0106406342,
0.0632622913,
0.0588309541,
0.0055989455,
-0.1190761328,
-0.0180943087,
-0.0826741382,
0.0100115705,
-0.0158087984,
-0.0507578067,
-0.0357764736,
0.1142719537,
0.0156468246,
0.0106384289,
0.0367476493,
-0.0636481047,
0.0298260823,
0.0066541568,
-0.0011686848,
0.0441192165,
-0.000359028,
0.011438258,
-0.0418024696,
-0.0106793568,
-0.0383380577,
0.0228362028,
0.00783592,
0.0816538408,
-0.0140726604,
0.0137906987,
0.0222783741,
-0.0117822895,
-0.0216360148,
-0.0539968349,
0.0601152331,
-0.0209338684,
-0.0093270801,
-0.0073800269,
0.032912761,
-0.0227842927,
-0.005120683,
-0.0371009782,
-0.0002359494,
-0.0074428315,
0.0082748719,
-0.0336836874,
-0.0126933055,
-0.075216867,
-0.0523835048,
-0.0226590876,
-0.0471300222,
-0.0509992018,
-0.0630807653,
0.0042105569,
0.0289795361,
0.0071953228,
0.0169142131,
2.428195951e-34,
0.0334663056,
0.0004837639,
0.0239238329,
0.0481942073,
0.027213607,
-0.0360722616,
-0.0403660238,
-0.0021176608,
0.0110093839,
-0.0789289996,
-0.0551591292
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15781v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15781v1 | Increasing Coverage and Precision of Textual Information in Multilingual Knowledge Graphs | 2023-11-27T12:54:47 | 2023-11-27T12:54:47 | Simone Conia, Min Li, Daniel Lee, Umar Farooq Minhas, Ihab Ilyas, Yunyao Li | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Recent work in Natural Language Processing and Computer Vision has been using
textual information -- e.g., entity names and descriptions -- available in
knowledge graphs to ground neural models to high-quality structured data.
However, when it comes to non-English languages, the quantity and quality of
textual information are comparatively scarce. To address this issue, we
introduce the novel task of automatic Knowledge Graph Enhancement (KGE) and
perform a thorough investigation on bridging the gap in both the quantity and
quality of textual information between English and non-English languages. More
specifically, we: i) bring to light the problem of increasing multilingual
coverage and precision of entity names and descriptions in Wikidata; ii)
demonstrate that state-of-the-art methods, namely, Machine Translation (MT),
Web Search (WS), and Large Language Models (LLMs), struggle with this task;
iii) present M-NTA, a novel unsupervised approach that combines MT, WS, and
LLMs to generate high-quality textual information; and, iv) study the impact of
increasing multilingual coverage and precision of non-English textual
information in Entity Linking, Knowledge Graph Completion, and Question
Answering. As part of our effort towards better multilingual knowledge graphs,
we also introduce WikiKGE-10, the first human-curated benchmark to evaluate KGE
approaches in 10 languages across 7 language families. | [
0.0573114976,
0.0516689457,
-0.0066642454,
0.0699447915,
-0.0179841761,
0.0210565589,
-0.0533668995,
0.0122260544,
0.0484527983,
-0.0274819825,
-0.0044455691,
-0.018558057,
0.0048411931,
-0.0132944146,
0.0560602583,
-0.0325647853,
0.0271753725,
-0.0260838065,
-0.0212915074,
-0.0373789333,
-0.0173930954,
0.0342485718,
0.0078469459,
-0.0239239559,
-0.0132583128,
-0.0078565618,
0.0150488736,
0.015707776,
0.0202945434,
-0.0118146027,
-0.0023123298,
0.0153639419,
-0.0351663381,
0.03732609,
0.0000016977,
-0.0422066264,
0.0264598131,
-0.0054839193,
0.0098440927,
0.0089031318,
-0.0191521086,
-0.0671387911,
0.0098607233,
-0.0285563245,
-0.0195840187,
0.0059827692,
0.027884122,
0.0107088173,
0.0261035021,
0.0577204339,
0.0153247193,
-0.0297651552,
0.0399382375,
-0.017739119,
0.009378423,
-0.0458515584,
0.0065501588,
0.0338928066,
-0.0005532922,
0.0192758255,
-0.0264070481,
0.0653176978,
-0.0005868752,
-0.0204873923,
0.0166393053,
0.0157018322,
-0.0329759531,
-0.0041352548,
0.0628575236,
0.0922307521,
0.0117374957,
-0.0211706311,
0.0002699391,
0.0182682127,
-0.0004164007,
0.0041765389,
-0.0311593991,
0.0111053688,
-0.0320339501,
0.0065563619,
-0.0042700386,
-0.0355182104,
0.058743611,
0.0271796305,
-0.0091288881,
0.0854281113,
0.0336462669,
-0.0025902046,
0.0230844971,
0.0471948497,
-0.0157250185,
-0.0427405089,
0.0354012437,
0.040617492,
-0.0380261019,
0.0507458597,
-0.0291252024,
-0.0368718579,
0.0178420991,
-0.0614927225,
-0.0622458272,
0.0149833066,
0.0080902101,
0.0498926751,
-0.0444284752,
0.0005490715,
-0.0372548103,
0.0074942289,
-0.0625164062,
-0.0675336272,
-0.0333363935,
0.0042600483,
-0.0190390442,
0.0149916243,
-0.0502833091,
-0.0032258765,
-0.0324114412,
0.0135610793,
0.0084378365,
0.0369832031,
0.0354656242,
0.0021127251,
-0.0260512009,
-0.0163819566,
-0.0517285578,
0.0623609237,
-0.0468035713,
-0.0195572451,
-0.0554337651,
0.0118551627,
0.0042600599,
-0.0129962619,
0.0263941139,
-0.0424442068,
0.0201818943,
0.06511987,
0.0263005514,
-0.0091349268,
-0.039505329,
-0.0271776654,
0.0062218281,
-0.0280790832,
0.0101380628,
-0.0822076201,
0.0772747472,
0.0041406825,
0.0011996377,
-0.0455382839,
0.0395357423,
0.0008569198,
-0.0911709666,
0.0691875145,
-0.0813061669,
0.0177703928,
0.0240464918,
-0.0126828887,
0.0193277765,
0.0472388156,
0.04648057,
-0.0139944023,
0.0824392214,
0.0318616852,
-0.0581165031,
0.0501830913,
0.0458520427,
0.0137631176,
0.0496841893,
0.0184718743,
-0.0262775198,
0.0381981619,
0.0448495001,
0.0502792262,
-0.0080576753,
-0.0035386321,
0.0504851677,
0.010569822,
-0.0044037192,
0.0194838773,
0.0358020552,
-0.0118096881,
0.0146163879,
0.0120916413,
-0.0237669572,
0.0139589189,
-0.0215342101,
0.0426497124,
0.0140568167,
0.0534444638,
-0.0212252941,
-0.0192548353,
0.0205433425,
-0.026072368,
0.0357341878,
0.0282689109,
0.0698354766,
0.0267276764,
-0.020914631,
0.0700659752,
0.0580711998,
-0.0128714032,
0.078910999,
-0.0074109412,
-0.0044479999,
0.0779261738,
0.0295668803,
0.0068997359,
-0.0466659926,
0.0239730105,
-0.0154321007,
0.0482706539,
0.0057680341,
-0.0509813689,
0.0150415488,
-0.0252545681,
-0.021948915,
-0.0159881245,
-0.0143344263,
0.0206218753,
0.0409441516,
0.0519721322,
0.0439866967,
-0.103165403,
-0.0486887731,
0.010114775,
-0.0283461455,
0.0099184178,
0.00119416,
0.0386541151,
-0.0417069159,
0.0538804047,
0.0094129574,
0.0008043957,
0.0058167889,
-0.0329003036,
-0.0247174818,
0.0045079719,
0.0302653983,
-0.0375999063,
0.0666074231,
-0.0472548753,
-0.0232379623,
0.0051928214,
-0.0337733924,
-0.0449468978,
-0.0112577714,
-0.0392130092,
0.0241509546,
0.0001349409,
0.0062668803,
0.0149500193,
-0.0165892523,
-0.0256154723,
0.0876926184,
0.0064140409,
0.0380801745,
0.0253781341,
-0.0357697234,
0.0157699864,
-0.0071050017,
-0.048233822,
0.0299652759,
0.0192791931,
0.030136764,
0.0542362928,
-0.0139091797,
-0.0700829551,
0.0249110702,
-0.0936274007,
0.0145407328,
-0.0069557563,
0.0505332388,
0.0030560626,
0.039265763,
0.010210773,
-0.0205882769,
-0.0262397006,
-0.0119455094,
0.0063390154,
0.0317306295,
0.0305193551,
0.015338134,
0.024833234,
-0.0274898857,
-0.0382522047,
-0.0008926599,
0.0313227773,
0.020288283,
-0.0462819375,
-0.0578111075,
0.0384297967,
-0.0777014941,
-0.0023060783,
-0.0110985283,
-0.0192926805,
-0.0229340401,
0.0313599482,
0.0310809519,
0.0230258871,
-0.044081673,
-0.033427868,
0.0487583131,
0.0004669485,
-0.0450536646,
0.0211160835,
0.0035426624,
0.0019154637,
-0.0348134153,
-0.0276021026,
0.026919255,
0.0123570245,
-0.0335843191,
-0.0479857288,
-0.0449813642,
-0.0006068808,
-0.0178445671,
0.0060384772,
-0.0233851448,
0.007252438,
0.0214911308,
0.0295253415,
-0.0299597941,
0.0064777373,
0.0725124478,
-0.0095199747,
0.0290003791,
-0.0275135897,
0.0238851961,
-0.0108974809,
0.0528249368,
0.0257864147,
0.0378268883,
-0.0481667966,
-0.0192443319,
-0.0252315607,
0.0364166796,
0.0350394882,
-0.0149674239,
0.0356304087,
-0.0139965266,
0.0082830675,
-0.0078870812,
0.0045405785,
-0.0125660961,
0.0216939226,
-0.0328973942,
0.0030639411,
0.0276699439,
-0.0148951188,
0.0059187748,
-0.0190036055,
0.0430980101,
-0.0056950706,
0.0068752575,
-0.0045850761,
-0.0095227063,
0.0602977462,
0.0749542415,
-0.0091364942,
0.0290214159,
-0.0040410743,
-0.0053707338,
0.0127426181,
0.0107469633,
-0.0278161094,
0.0208772495,
-0.0432840101,
0.0272192899,
-0.0705370754,
-0.0651762411,
-0.041558627,
0.0376389623,
-0.0333987437,
0.0066881799,
0.1008586287,
0.0272342525,
-0.0435407013,
0.0054838695,
-0.0162028745,
-0.0140281357,
0.03100878,
0.0314722322,
-0.106395945,
0.0201247279,
-0.0253250636,
-0.0023353214,
0.0279490724,
-0.0542709082,
0.0168217104,
-0.1237269267,
-0.0331783779,
0.0213128999,
-0.0334781297,
-0.0613741502,
-0.0595647804,
-0.016484078,
-0.02627494,
0.0122074578,
-0.0173304006,
0.0223010909,
0.0190238692,
-0.0214898158,
0.0101976171,
-0.076919198,
0.001472201,
-0.095728986,
0.0240000542,
0.01368054,
0.0818897784,
-0.0283768084,
-0.0219375286,
-0.014068163,
-0.0080176666,
-0.0094877509,
0.0165797174,
0.0443068482,
-0.0048051481,
-0.0228041057,
-0.0394001007,
-0.0266659763,
-0.017325582,
0.0090126917,
0.0035687899,
0.0760393888,
0.0307596922,
0.0034852643,
0.0101255989,
-0.0523112901,
-0.005142679,
0.0413094983,
-0.009406059,
-0.0077056806,
0.0185862929,
-0.0209905636,
0.0060505704,
-0.050470259,
-0.021690404,
0.0444838665,
-0.0508308336,
0.0210574884,
-0.1068632081,
-0.0946722478,
0.0412820801,
-0.0154750068,
0.0115932366,
0.0411658771,
0.0070170145,
-0.0190988798,
-0.0438567959,
0.0275039766,
-0.0699106902,
0.0059948131,
-0.0083222874,
-0.0015550207,
0.0046800766,
-0.0174379386,
0.0034459236,
-0.0266465731,
-0.0537666008,
-0.0829750523,
-0.054339163,
0.0603069551,
0.0079068495,
0.0639565885,
-0.0603963435,
-0.0435503758,
0.0086133508,
0.0254932567,
-0.0277191196,
-0.0089219529,
0.0074621402,
0.0075571053,
-0.0124481944,
0.0648372769,
-0.0764692575,
-0.0169484392,
-0.0173406191,
0.0801389143,
-0.0272990186,
-0.0563747883,
0.0113294395,
0.0695890635,
-0.0147280842,
-0.0343362689,
0.0220508445,
-0.0225962494,
0.0141982734,
-0.0266552847,
-0.0275279526,
0.0098615531,
0.0026831832,
0.0255070627,
-0.0131691732,
-0.0094076665,
0.0179509595,
0.000307731,
0.0075388025,
-0.0473726317,
-0.0330222547,
0.0377160013,
-0.019560026,
0.0237514768,
0.0100645032,
-0.0159111526,
0.0095529621,
0.0308075566,
0.0456748083,
-0.0621350892,
-0.0240090881,
0.0224811491,
-0.0399826132,
-0.0278717838,
0.0046543018,
-0.0333776176,
-0.0092945835,
0.0033384198,
0.0208856352,
0.114599593,
-0.0204403289,
0.0877105296,
0.0109593831,
-0.0499327481,
0.0115385111,
0.0113984402,
0.0132258506,
-0.0002346563,
0.0203118585,
0.0076613999,
0.0063012112,
0.0270813834,
0.0700306147,
-0.0173585787,
0.0726997554,
0.0059816567,
-0.0428077467,
-0.0081287902,
-0.0190170649,
-0.0347310193,
0.0023107717,
-0.0443503447,
-0.0094332146,
-0.0242439155,
-0.0920327827,
0.0172127988,
-0.004738681,
-0.0339237191,
-0.0096759973,
0.0247248579,
0.0185443219,
0.0512444787,
-0.0007736237,
-0.0238252115,
-0.0063784486,
-0.0257230066,
-0.0094374036,
0.0091058398,
-5.520093553e-33,
-0.0323364586,
-0.0464264899,
-0.0002909311,
-0.0050240732,
-0.0277029332,
-0.0052159065,
-0.0288014691,
-0.0178332478,
-0.0780397728,
0.0351255238,
-0.0176136568,
0.0131920176,
0.0081450846,
-0.0063171536,
-0.0050228443,
-0.0027368513,
0.0248507578,
0.0413557552,
-0.007494064,
0.0089671137,
0.0135322418,
0.0151330512,
0.1040349603,
-0.0503686517,
0.0711446777,
-0.0087291086,
0.0127338404,
0.0298243631,
0.03795968,
0.0602490753,
0.0020119818,
0.0644117966,
0.0222272277,
0.0041288715,
0.0115997149,
-0.0462282114,
-0.1201830581,
-0.0298550818,
0.0282708425,
0.0250442941,
-0.0247162338,
-0.0525887311,
0.0466791131,
-0.0106947189,
0.0572626665,
-0.0004581742,
0.0550353006,
-0.0241615344,
-0.0336483754,
-0.0425387733,
-0.0516482182,
0.0163796805,
0.0193302575,
0.0320599601,
0.0147085479,
-0.0009161705,
0.0068029505,
-0.0131389694,
-0.080781661,
0.0088548791,
-0.0078410357,
0.0176362246,
0.0518674664,
-0.0282236338,
-0.0071463678,
0.0075557013,
0.0027456537,
0.0277512111,
-0.0212943461,
0.0082384804,
0.0197535679,
-0.0055861771,
0.0358298309,
0.0778710246,
-0.0180743486,
-0.0367176607,
-0.0784480125,
0.0238854792,
-0.043551892,
0.0428857282,
-0.0609136,
-0.0251417719,
-0.0185098462,
-0.0185954086,
-0.0542026199,
-0.0114571843,
-0.028863281,
-0.0335802473,
-0.0233336668,
-0.0258718245,
-0.0522606336,
0.0175036211,
-0.0158029608,
-0.0500163399,
-0.01070615,
0.0711211488,
0.0092846742,
0.012250538,
-0.0082477098,
0.0179517549,
-0.0238986891,
-0.0135889053,
-0.0222463887,
-0.0204878934,
0.0079629691,
0.0236226618,
0.0297632422,
0.0067697726,
-0.0253240746,
0.0261567086,
-0.0386899114,
-0.0134557122,
-0.0341293029,
-0.0316268392,
0.0395643823,
0.0077764159,
-0.0075747692,
0.0242932998,
0.0973324701,
0.0074217268,
-0.0077781575,
0.0105095701,
0.0414370112,
0.0127372295,
-0.0214148927,
0.0118641621,
-0.0183371194,
0.028358927,
-0.0037884559,
-0.060260769,
-0.0344650745,
-0.0197306443,
2.527e-7,
0.0492824838,
0.0482934453,
0.017701434,
0.06536486,
-0.0144384988,
-0.0062399684,
0.0132316165,
0.025778031,
-0.0195024367,
-0.0324045457,
0.0019599458,
0.0016504881,
0.0059390757,
0.055638127,
-0.0868812352,
-0.0107534844,
-0.020107355,
-0.0292297006,
-0.0436207876,
-0.0120335706,
0.0118588284,
0.0284838304,
0.0245155375,
-0.0036249547,
-0.0400761552,
-0.0657417923,
0.0794504657,
-0.0068052248,
-0.036911346,
0.0187355895,
0.0378455557,
0.029451577,
-0.0060949605,
0.0404838361,
-0.0393533185,
0.0353385657,
0.0605992191,
0.032860402,
-0.0080627147,
0.0336554609,
-0.0226938091,
-0.0774628222,
0.0326232649,
-0.0407754146,
0.0750945881,
0.0019333969,
0.0117226578,
0.0504120253,
-0.0367477909,
0.0016456894,
0.0175078753,
-0.0591389239,
-0.0172022153,
0.0198634621,
0.0246275943,
0.0191269293,
0.0022765021,
-0.0333214588,
-0.0298405383,
0.0206049588,
0.028974928,
-0.0305239074,
0.0219289903,
-0.0376778804,
0.0043074414,
-0.0424683206,
0.0242120307,
1.740064084e-34,
0.034972351,
-0.0104171354,
0.0016488869,
0.0128315249,
0.0340418294,
-0.0447714962,
-0.0311997645,
-0.0132245701,
0.0124223512,
-0.045791544,
-0.0151125956
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15766v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15766v2 | Knowledge Unlearning for LLMs: Tasks, Methods, and Challenges | 2023-11-27T12:37:51 | 2023-12-08T01:23:56 | Nianwen Si, Hao Zhang, Heyu Chang, Wenlin Zhang, Dan Qu, Weiqiang Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | In recent years, large language models (LLMs) have spurred a new research
paradigm in natural language processing. Despite their excellent capability in
knowledge-based question answering and reasoning, their potential to retain
faulty or even harmful knowledge poses risks of malicious application. The
challenge of mitigating this issue and transforming these models into purer
assistants is crucial for their widespread applicability. Unfortunately,
Retraining LLMs repeatedly to eliminate undesirable knowledge is impractical
due to their immense parameters. Knowledge unlearning, derived from analogous
studies on machine unlearning, presents a promising avenue to address this
concern and is notably advantageous in the context of LLMs. It allows for the
removal of harmful knowledge in an efficient manner, without affecting
unrelated knowledge in the model. To this end, we provide a survey of knowledge
unlearning in the era of LLMs. Firstly, we formally define the knowledge
unlearning problem and distinguish it from related works. Subsequently, we
categorize existing knowledge unlearning methods into three classes: those
based on parameter optimization, parameter merging, and in-context learning,
and introduce details of these unlearning methods. We further present
evaluation datasets used in existing methods, and finally conclude this survey
by presenting the ongoing challenges and future directions. | [
0.0141477482,
0.0447218679,
-0.0068263705,
0.0670546368,
-0.0491658673,
0.0243527591,
-0.0385034643,
-0.0084564984,
0.0160533395,
-0.0579316393,
-0.0436994061,
0.0360729061,
0.0038400141,
-0.0179316178,
0.015355736,
0.0078600207,
0.0681317374,
-0.0271046404,
-0.0122815678,
-0.0014071466,
-0.0205118116,
0.0091863489,
0.0073569207,
-0.0038995922,
0.0113990521,
-0.0561514795,
-0.0074755829,
-0.0027427224,
0.0167554747,
0.0402069949,
0.0409631319,
0.0160605647,
0.0181676969,
0.0457197018,
0.0000020528,
-0.0478759557,
-0.0396746211,
-0.0108388504,
-0.0574578755,
0.0475588515,
0.0137359779,
-0.0052182833,
-0.0128852837,
0.0361739621,
-0.0573180206,
0.007523356,
0.0194305256,
0.0209368095,
0.0694587678,
0.0807596296,
0.0270743929,
-0.0108638015,
0.0282478854,
-0.0074801645,
-0.0011950029,
-0.0279557556,
0.0842885524,
-0.0299428646,
-0.0361584201,
-0.034870591,
0.0012456613,
0.0357025377,
0.0094026839,
0.021936046,
-0.0046158154,
0.0021865682,
-0.0352548249,
0.0046059974,
-0.0256060828,
0.0665335581,
-0.0392087065,
-0.0197966173,
0.0137973689,
0.0238431115,
0.0108246366,
0.0172204189,
-0.0345233604,
-0.0125477538,
-0.0097559653,
0.0218471959,
-0.0096304165,
-0.0548851304,
0.0679697096,
0.0387921929,
0.000808941,
0.088695392,
0.0244818423,
-0.0450072214,
0.0129801659,
-0.0422105044,
-0.0297091398,
-0.0516522378,
-0.027930595,
0.07492733,
0.0046507823,
0.047662884,
-0.0105113564,
-0.0004394107,
0.0494549386,
-0.038544666,
0.0311432518,
-0.0021696477,
0.0080034221,
0.0831498429,
-0.0340062678,
0.037828099,
0.0131229777,
0.0444136299,
-0.0542230383,
-0.0091491686,
-0.0421550199,
-0.0412056409,
0.0081252037,
0.0408160985,
0.0098728612,
0.0219736546,
-0.0126605108,
0.0386931375,
-0.038680803,
0.0283942949,
0.0029579464,
0.0119094597,
0.008153935,
-0.0169039946,
-0.0740710348,
0.043072015,
0.0102334237,
0.0460600518,
-0.014239978,
-0.058455009,
-0.0411387943,
-0.0076644928,
-0.0018651184,
-0.0151737342,
0.0359788202,
0.0659221783,
-0.0041217995,
-0.0221367218,
-0.0658061728,
-0.0395887904,
-0.0106661255,
-0.0634964854,
-0.0008471522,
-0.0573663339,
0.0424665287,
-0.0364913866,
-0.0267197695,
-0.0644354373,
0.0119069405,
0.0233812351,
-0.0607621558,
0.0820306242,
-0.0433243699,
0.0107772639,
0.0402173474,
0.0095356954,
-0.0590736121,
0.0499901511,
-0.0141386054,
0.0170704518,
0.0359515175,
-0.0175319668,
0.0327266306,
0.0204022434,
0.0449441373,
0.0150027769,
0.0006285339,
0.0056216698,
0.0235577635,
-0.0274227615,
0.0080772797,
0.0419897549,
-0.0122181512,
-0.022085771,
0.0587946586,
-0.0136895981,
-0.0075452602,
0.0233822931,
0.0309767462,
-0.011999567,
0.0305899307,
0.0385501459,
-0.0556435175,
-0.0317216218,
-0.0883329436,
0.0169319361,
-0.0033681423,
0.0489948317,
-0.0438907519,
-0.0714845583,
-0.0037849494,
-0.0485231131,
0.0087123383,
0.0363437571,
0.0569499359,
0.0484560765,
-0.048293177,
0.0448476039,
0.0392326005,
-0.0496976376,
0.0206532665,
-0.0323271789,
0.0340012759,
0.0528733693,
0.0577865504,
-0.0699085221,
-0.0375654697,
0.0099686077,
-0.0188643504,
-0.0426543392,
0.0054247309,
-0.0176549572,
0.0478851423,
-0.0438280739,
-0.0092197703,
-0.0259660967,
0.0314980783,
0.0026243986,
0.0363015383,
-0.0290357713,
0.0259737205,
-0.0760193989,
-0.0052315118,
0.0287425276,
-0.0355777927,
-0.0628267676,
0.0055692946,
0.0150452666,
0.0354812108,
-0.0007137129,
0.0134281134,
0.0152468868,
0.076271072,
0.0015998289,
-0.0453973413,
0.0019310033,
-0.0360389426,
-0.0577904023,
0.0408460796,
-0.0054900618,
-0.015707396,
0.0567884706,
-0.0630257428,
-0.0195259228,
-0.0129243052,
-0.0074227084,
0.082048133,
-0.0296067931,
0.0502796657,
0.0202821251,
-0.0233501717,
-0.0299951546,
0.1010809168,
-0.0232952479,
-0.0110776052,
0.0022939935,
-0.0293135028,
-0.0096170157,
-0.0085957944,
-0.0101036448,
-0.0251759216,
-0.0036148238,
0.0143280011,
-0.0062868567,
-0.0467543527,
-0.0560276322,
-0.0397261307,
-0.0900555551,
0.0165891759,
-0.0117501123,
0.0238051806,
0.0187015776,
0.000322383,
0.0033347111,
-0.0136767663,
-0.0160877407,
0.0039447304,
0.0063186283,
0.0232631862,
0.0294973925,
-0.0057970583,
-0.0108098621,
-0.0269307699,
0.0133714648,
-0.0224711224,
0.0429410823,
-0.0371152461,
-0.0058101336,
-0.0361466184,
0.0610007532,
-0.059737578,
0.034776777,
-0.0000730039,
-0.0227746908,
-0.0219422411,
-0.0153900767,
0.0095930751,
0.0644293651,
-0.0102512054,
0.0158781968,
0.0737309381,
-0.0191144403,
-0.0320266858,
0.0229567736,
-0.0271492898,
-0.0482516736,
0.0060182577,
-0.0110690994,
0.0181588754,
0.0491023846,
0.0090634329,
-0.0259978063,
-0.0151123935,
0.0249514543,
-0.0010385666,
-0.0418184623,
-0.0366041623,
-0.0206205416,
-0.0089116264,
0.0119352946,
-0.0371408761,
-0.0730555058,
0.0440398529,
-0.0239288118,
0.0300905891,
-0.0368641913,
-0.0163809266,
-0.0501795001,
0.0209635198,
-0.0007823638,
0.028119145,
0.0105635775,
-0.008337249,
-0.0308500249,
-0.0297550932,
0.0157129932,
-0.0243605059,
0.0472890139,
-0.0836466551,
0.0104561262,
0.0081844367,
-0.0284347348,
-0.0472394004,
-0.0313026123,
0.000750157,
-0.0028774915,
-0.0180236921,
0.0173569806,
-0.0214515273,
-0.0518440194,
0.0261417348,
-0.0066784271,
0.0236168467,
-0.0006772868,
-0.0303947441,
0.0545705333,
0.0572040528,
0.0229310617,
0.0137073295,
0.020709794,
0.0363401026,
0.0858226717,
0.0284255277,
-0.0223407783,
-0.0138619924,
-0.0006097119,
0.0006747426,
-0.0524841696,
0.0041951234,
0.0154646188,
0.0215501413,
-0.0523518175,
0.0228200946,
0.1215360463,
0.0333660617,
0.0096358582,
0.0039200163,
0.0238142796,
-0.0145911397,
0.0060317796,
-0.0002320507,
-0.076722987,
-0.0363314636,
0.0047052586,
0.0094566466,
-0.0097558387,
-0.0239320658,
-0.0185978729,
-0.1396339685,
-0.0041532465,
0.0371077247,
-0.0136133395,
-0.0446851291,
-0.0373406,
0.0003532826,
-0.0184631087,
0.0338473804,
0.0082080727,
-0.0263834037,
-0.0131843695,
-0.0133878477,
-0.0331457369,
-0.0478159934,
0.0108150663,
-0.034888044,
0.0469488576,
0.0316300504,
0.0386758447,
0.001396575,
-0.0298162028,
0.0077497377,
-0.0331439599,
0.0253858007,
-0.0217414871,
0.0369874984,
-0.0194666293,
-0.0035103334,
0.0166523289,
0.0453478172,
-0.0491124466,
-0.0342726447,
0.0247514118,
0.0862628594,
0.0003203423,
-0.0012322937,
0.0014758635,
-0.0277212076,
-0.0185148306,
0.1036336496,
0.0002777136,
-0.0023812826,
-0.0024995157,
-0.0090519236,
-0.0168374646,
0.0598036461,
0.0175074544,
0.0329073593,
-0.0181282889,
0.0205116048,
-0.0902933553,
-0.023144694,
0.0369742066,
-0.0138434861,
0.0221543536,
0.0465379469,
0.0208584256,
0.0169642027,
-0.0379429944,
0.0059676319,
-0.0454124585,
-0.0038051568,
-0.0317725651,
-0.0071384176,
0.0053796624,
-0.0043713776,
-0.0056461925,
0.0117830187,
-0.0784807503,
-0.0917698294,
-0.0092175575,
0.0429098681,
0.0233554225,
0.0558917522,
-0.0262498967,
-0.0035420933,
0.0522617958,
0.0210307259,
-0.0256034601,
0.0399077237,
0.0400687084,
0.021043526,
0.0065793646,
0.0466564372,
-0.0664076284,
-0.0331985988,
0.0174537078,
-0.008599665,
-0.0810369551,
-0.026438063,
0.0414605923,
0.025350444,
0.0290245209,
0.0215641931,
0.0025519233,
0.0027247467,
0.0412650146,
-0.0157170203,
-0.0434833281,
-0.0079299873,
-0.0027907433,
0.0266849492,
0.0111766709,
0.0040044999,
-0.0125278225,
0.0064832103,
0.0173444115,
0.0002582587,
-0.037033733,
0.0309960712,
-0.0230789278,
0.0153657971,
0.0101337768,
-0.0174064003,
0.0543434471,
-0.0232672188,
0.0245329123,
-0.0088411979,
0.0352729373,
0.0008537301,
0.0224744324,
-0.0561199374,
0.0203387681,
-0.0490598679,
-0.0768978223,
-0.018117087,
0.0291048754,
0.037698783,
-0.0227210671,
0.0184661243,
-0.0088229897,
-0.0330539867,
-0.027219601,
-0.0162615199,
0.0082290182,
0.0258938801,
0.0302326959,
0.0453729667,
-0.0179049633,
0.0338733681,
0.1035144478,
-0.0087947845,
0.1068340689,
-0.0100453235,
0.0016573303,
-0.0412422456,
-0.0135139404,
0.0208605397,
-0.0153685817,
-0.00680171,
-0.0026038489,
-0.0306594167,
-0.0818907842,
0.0373637602,
-0.0029421588,
-0.0199157353,
-0.0140054431,
0.0290926993,
0.0644040555,
0.005071437,
0.0035448235,
-0.0436024442,
-0.0089560254,
-0.0122771561,
-0.0271684714,
0.0116097657,
-6.173484007e-33,
0.0005925603,
-0.0140261389,
0.0017689881,
0.0187152177,
0.0097145736,
-0.0011353883,
0.0261686556,
-0.0391144454,
-0.047950577,
-0.0047511086,
-0.0160505418,
0.0177235231,
-0.0026526118,
0.0052981395,
-0.0445187651,
-0.038165208,
0.0367687307,
0.007269707,
-0.0112355798,
-0.0120654544,
0.0479385071,
0.0307392459,
0.0235414226,
-0.054498367,
-0.0027771946,
-0.0013505985,
-0.0374321751,
0.0767254159,
-0.0416851453,
0.0449055769,
-0.0230655521,
0.0384481512,
0.0118091684,
-0.0231391191,
-0.0137451021,
0.0407454446,
-0.0814183578,
-0.0190451406,
0.045567248,
-0.0194432922,
-0.0302921571,
-0.0824401528,
0.0655155629,
0.0074759973,
0.0279467627,
-0.024394419,
0.0139418058,
-0.0340464637,
-0.0147817619,
-0.0151243834,
-0.0432171896,
0.0109314183,
-0.0215142127,
-0.0566796325,
0.0094736759,
-0.0176438726,
0.0156432539,
0.0108019616,
-0.0823325291,
0.0011687443,
0.0391724221,
0.036466334,
0.0804629102,
-0.0167314,
-0.0035055082,
0.0550577715,
-0.0236739218,
-0.0004608918,
-0.0047195139,
-0.0109700141,
-0.0139740519,
0.0716732666,
0.0369770229,
0.0306939427,
0.022839101,
-0.0227920637,
-0.0595475845,
0.0437856093,
0.007518467,
0.0636551231,
-0.0412075818,
0.0336887501,
-0.0111078974,
-0.0086398236,
-0.0696095154,
0.022808155,
-0.0476351008,
-0.0000352594,
0.0283674989,
0.0211243834,
-0.0177680906,
-0.0226534959,
-0.0181887485,
-0.0451748706,
0.0279598981,
0.0364418104,
0.0135198589,
-0.000781904,
0.0019434135,
-0.0132790757,
-0.0767379701,
0.0104839075,
0.020240806,
0.0073923538,
0.0146437567,
0.0011354344,
0.0401431732,
0.0371592417,
-0.0296981595,
0.0197002385,
-0.0299099442,
0.0165178608,
0.0262712575,
-0.0079299994,
0.0401880108,
0.0320736766,
-0.001011555,
-0.0066193189,
0.0385275595,
0.0226498079,
-0.0437749587,
0.0149285579,
-0.0004064284,
-0.0002355361,
-0.0176384989,
-0.0244967844,
0.022867145,
-0.0037219552,
0.0257386919,
-0.0338591523,
0.0138688795,
-0.0005715428,
2.761e-7,
0.0345099233,
0.0155238174,
0.0274073165,
0.0100546833,
0.0363480449,
0.0413626097,
-0.0272477996,
0.0095096827,
0.0027588469,
-0.0475741439,
0.02140853,
0.0291048624,
0.0509954914,
0.0307438858,
-0.0972116217,
0.0113163665,
-0.0325167589,
-0.0436416268,
-0.0354178138,
-0.0242849533,
0.03646826,
0.0988464579,
0.0183846485,
-0.0443061367,
-0.0273332763,
-0.0540803522,
0.0570168905,
-0.0340674892,
-0.0368686542,
0.0084675234,
0.0604309663,
0.0024702132,
0.0003197026,
0.0285481531,
-0.0371845774,
0.0141133284,
-0.0106755188,
0.0762781575,
0.0034165182,
-0.0658146366,
-0.0173712075,
-0.0058480264,
0.0220277756,
-0.035368979,
0.1223110557,
-0.0232326966,
-0.0116792265,
-0.0186158922,
-0.0131010488,
-0.0193568151,
0.0290441103,
0.004679074,
-0.0171349589,
0.0301723275,
-0.0116060805,
0.0061478452,
-0.0220875442,
-0.0837937444,
-0.0151318759,
0.0031952069,
-0.0518378355,
-0.0624004789,
-0.0055733598,
-0.0029284605,
0.0268744156,
-0.1116960719,
0.0362807177,
2.393278718e-34,
-0.0229145829,
-0.0435850434,
0.0381482504,
0.0384706818,
0.0189098977,
-0.0076923743,
-0.0562056266,
0.016414661,
0.015384132,
-0.0813047886,
0.0313512199
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15759v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15759v1 | Towards Vision Enhancing LLMs: Empowering Multimodal Knowledge Storage and Sharing in LLMs | 2023-11-27T12:29:20 | 2023-11-27T12:29:20 | Yunxin Li, Baotian Hu, Wei Wang, Xiaochun Cao, Min Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV | Recent advancements in multimodal large language models (MLLMs) have achieved
significant multimodal generation capabilities, akin to GPT-4. These models
predominantly map visual information into language representation space,
leveraging the vast knowledge and powerful text generation abilities of LLMs to
produce multimodal instruction-following responses. We could term this method
as LLMs for Vision because of its employing LLMs for visual-language
understanding, yet observe that these MLLMs neglect the potential of harnessing
visual knowledge to enhance overall capabilities of LLMs, which could be
regraded as Vision Enhancing LLMs. In this paper, we propose an approach called
MKS2, aimed at enhancing LLMs through empowering Multimodal Knowledge Storage
and Sharing in LLMs. Specifically, we introduce the Modular Visual Memory, a
component integrated into the internal blocks of LLMs, designed to store
open-world visual information efficiently. Additionally, we present a soft
Mixtures-of-Multimodal Experts architecture in LLMs to invoke multimodal
knowledge collaboration during generation. Our comprehensive experiments
demonstrate that MKS2 substantially augments the reasoning capabilities of LLMs
in contexts necessitating physical or commonsense knowledge. It also delivers
competitive results on multimodal benchmarks. | [
0.0350507349,
0.0289655272,
-0.0182218496,
0.0651141033,
-0.0250566229,
-0.0054487251,
0.023546977,
-0.0191439223,
0.0246800594,
-0.0787627175,
-0.0380625241,
-0.0189888757,
-0.0193622243,
0.0074903714,
0.0543452986,
-0.0448362343,
0.0338672101,
-0.0392636359,
-0.0470333621,
-0.0022628028,
0.0269145239,
0.013455973,
-0.0303000025,
0.020473972,
-0.033584699,
-0.0114583373,
-0.0305287223,
0.013494079,
0.0178152174,
-0.019140806,
-0.0255590808,
-0.0032831272,
0.0695792213,
-0.0183353778,
0.0000020628,
-0.0275303945,
0.0238938294,
-0.0237380005,
0.0325396769,
-0.0275128167,
-0.0051918859,
-0.0120623605,
0.0261078365,
-0.0376154669,
-0.0458626896,
0.0059527629,
0.0690909699,
-0.0003813087,
0.0677401796,
0.0343187228,
-0.0165442377,
-0.0221892186,
0.0228342917,
0.0216582958,
0.0516121984,
-0.0129381623,
-0.0185777582,
0.0355917141,
0.0232806951,
0.0056249592,
-0.0434846133,
0.0473226532,
0.0208267439,
-0.0134921698,
0.0208550245,
0.0450025648,
0.0309721455,
-0.0215847977,
-0.0281890668,
0.0766025186,
0.0135036074,
0.0174564067,
0.001777344,
0.0108287828,
-0.0105885444,
0.0365901105,
-0.0511582755,
0.0624823272,
-0.041951254,
0.0063514994,
-0.0446056761,
-0.0270522851,
0.0173662659,
0.0423518531,
-0.0129179237,
0.0288714953,
0.0187089816,
0.0282861311,
-0.0148824239,
-0.0023147159,
-0.0439495482,
-0.0259424038,
-0.0067802789,
0.0718202144,
-0.0134394513,
0.0120855235,
-0.0239444487,
-0.0074062073,
-0.0101900231,
-0.0240435377,
0.0540626906,
0.0239663329,
-0.0534316748,
0.0540005229,
-0.0485766977,
0.0235625152,
-0.0329807624,
0.0474431776,
-0.0256446023,
-0.0266936384,
-0.0704364926,
-0.0297742952,
-0.0050827414,
0.0135951452,
-0.0453988314,
-0.0618557855,
-0.0123565113,
0.0629661456,
-0.0272377674,
0.011172846,
-0.0179748423,
0.016136134,
0.0141098835,
-0.0249147024,
-0.066790089,
0.0473043807,
-0.0008178182,
0.0049625584,
0.012093368,
-0.0434464887,
0.0237285998,
0.0520456992,
-0.0141636068,
-0.011661591,
-0.0136228092,
0.1085390002,
-0.0516203865,
-0.0241397303,
-0.0515253395,
-0.049627319,
-0.0142870788,
-0.0563782081,
0.0587535575,
-0.0461840369,
0.0397543907,
-0.0027218426,
-0.0175954681,
-0.0085036848,
0.0255361907,
0.0012655457,
0.0014389495,
0.0752072856,
-0.0368913449,
0.0143190799,
0.0332170539,
0.0390911959,
-0.0178558845,
0.0578448623,
0.0246632062,
0.0227980614,
0.0127822869,
0.007614607,
0.0157097168,
0.0340819731,
-0.000087047,
-0.0037002536,
-0.0363573357,
-0.0089370264,
-0.0037939087,
0.0308527425,
0.0390489846,
0.0304725096,
-0.0366529264,
0.0018464179,
0.0988362506,
0.0098549528,
0.0252345689,
0.0123713687,
0.0461726002,
-0.0284735318,
-0.003511396,
-0.0118189408,
-0.045811411,
0.0997024328,
-0.0319771692,
0.0041982932,
0.0048401803,
0.0452487059,
-0.0208292305,
-0.0165073648,
-0.009465781,
-0.0084850052,
-0.0076802918,
0.0160697456,
0.0315926373,
-0.0148338843,
-0.018634608,
0.0420798697,
-0.0080786329,
-0.0474901125,
0.0181714594,
-0.0440792926,
0.0467939638,
0.0783758536,
0.0215267036,
-0.0099766627,
-0.0332821757,
0.008094985,
0.0106451409,
0.0325006917,
0.0142317442,
-0.0121069048,
0.008294181,
-0.0766616836,
-0.0403987467,
-0.0491656139,
-0.0187724568,
0.02237821,
0.0071763326,
-0.0097055128,
0.0212607123,
-0.0107423682,
0.0546656176,
0.0055460366,
0.013759708,
0.0354335979,
-0.0518370569,
0.0096758101,
0.0079694539,
-0.0078966217,
0.0053141825,
0.008696802,
0.0003992859,
-0.0284255184,
0.0063633453,
0.04081228,
-0.0644674525,
-0.0222538244,
0.023634363,
-0.0429478101,
0.0241016019,
-0.0393504016,
-0.0339052118,
-0.0116485069,
0.0172375813,
-0.0151854297,
0.0102252569,
-0.0609808676,
-0.0232238807,
0.0528704189,
-0.0147171691,
-0.0275526606,
0.0673438981,
-0.0438500568,
-0.024993198,
0.0393744484,
0.0263198689,
0.0130114388,
-0.0072947172,
0.0049129692,
0.0174208097,
0.0284979176,
0.0407935977,
0.0009437307,
0.0009789034,
-0.0482658409,
-0.0436758809,
-0.1099018902,
-0.0172734987,
-0.007061962,
-0.0307934787,
-0.0055349725,
-0.014284797,
0.0217426047,
0.0061931512,
-0.0222189222,
0.0913944915,
0.0268462654,
0.0211697742,
0.0053642881,
0.0363894887,
0.0253249519,
0.0105539421,
0.0202870388,
0.0087130927,
0.0627145544,
0.0109402779,
-0.0019413693,
-0.0521299019,
-0.0051580463,
-0.0805267841,
0.0220524184,
-0.0265783966,
-0.0088278167,
0.0525625125,
-0.0566964447,
0.0617140867,
0.0243075155,
0.0035074165,
0.0245190226,
0.0408963189,
-0.0658788681,
-0.035850089,
0.021991659,
0.0108064692,
-0.0183026828,
-0.0167226195,
0.0158284698,
-0.034770675,
0.0188802425,
-0.0040890202,
-0.0234843101,
-0.0542072244,
0.0302331559,
0.0369825624,
-0.059880618,
-0.0370939672,
-0.0017474132,
0.003081328,
0.0153400898,
-0.0445731841,
-0.0788632035,
0.0330168419,
-0.040496055,
0.0072365692,
0.0414229147,
0.0037927129,
-0.0135551728,
0.0859660506,
0.0137067139,
0.0300037209,
-0.0542524904,
0.0317805335,
-0.0386975966,
-0.0033933448,
0.0141987856,
0.0030431487,
0.062937364,
-0.1073083207,
0.0007979076,
-0.0221652333,
0.0020750733,
-0.0011969717,
0.0405045226,
-0.0264233109,
0.0007483949,
-0.0276268721,
0.0051574414,
-0.0068969191,
0.0228072125,
0.0504537895,
-0.0017130382,
0.0130945686,
-0.0155251892,
-0.0487547033,
0.0198042747,
0.0243002903,
0.0628210902,
-0.0280245394,
-0.0677139983,
-0.0156719554,
0.0760666803,
0.0128363119,
-0.0378490388,
-0.0474887155,
0.0353042223,
0.0265901033,
0.0573475733,
-0.0261111408,
0.0285734236,
0.0648316443,
-0.0655548275,
0.0069917925,
0.0627166033,
0.0074580959,
-0.0364523977,
-0.0280584581,
-0.0064491886,
0.0296388324,
0.0385532081,
0.0159452427,
-0.0696308985,
-0.0474068932,
-0.0152493473,
-0.0494849831,
0.0218961202,
-0.0470307469,
-0.0366225466,
-0.0808384344,
0.0424883217,
0.0104002822,
-0.026647212,
-0.0214236006,
0.0396779552,
-0.028787436,
0.0605972819,
-0.01520593,
0.0058852076,
0.0074874619,
0.0072592283,
0.0061027985,
0.0157704838,
-0.0142001407,
-0.0170803964,
-0.0475751832,
0.0125459246,
0.0327353179,
-0.0128766913,
0.0204854682,
-0.0828110725,
0.0054341629,
0.0266076475,
0.0522783473,
-0.035955783,
0.0058529926,
-0.0307536032,
-0.0410508923,
-0.0162834488,
0.0066012605,
0.0001259445,
-0.0333052799,
-0.0082313465,
0.0860382989,
-0.0459865667,
0.0012191695,
-0.0314475372,
0.0343746506,
-0.015114719,
0.0386369005,
0.0167975109,
-0.021335315,
-0.0166999437,
-0.0090034967,
-0.0229940191,
-0.0298822895,
-0.0082128914,
0.001612767,
0.0217551794,
0.0293016769,
-0.0628123805,
0.0064118467,
0.0398642533,
0.0619457513,
-0.0096145077,
-0.0149787739,
-0.0270264018,
-0.0004512857,
-0.0435115322,
0.0312007889,
-0.0205196775,
-0.0030180949,
-0.0321534835,
-0.0101393163,
0.0325520784,
-0.0703329742,
0.0085345134,
0.044390697,
-0.0643300042,
-0.0716065764,
-0.0631068423,
0.0946476907,
0.0158083886,
0.0204706471,
0.0728365928,
-0.0534689687,
0.0440781713,
0.0504034199,
-0.0124409823,
0.0428761803,
-0.0139106428,
0.0121311517,
0.0081288917,
0.012758432,
-0.0413825102,
-0.0270541124,
0.0125200469,
0.038709186,
-0.0102882404,
-0.0120899342,
-0.0124848355,
-0.013784688,
-0.001079514,
-0.0352050811,
0.0262657329,
-0.0384058766,
-0.0106945243,
-0.0161146857,
0.0014644732,
-0.0870191157,
0.0186717901,
0.0001335102,
-0.0061046658,
0.0324140377,
-0.0004117504,
0.0606316589,
0.0464979857,
0.0026239324,
0.0081133824,
0.0185517315,
-0.0387369283,
0.0119547863,
0.0296658743,
-0.0004125152,
0.0187197123,
-0.051901374,
0.0162861012,
-0.0174695589,
0.1394029111,
0.0187858474,
-0.049170047,
-0.0088659227,
0.0449891426,
-0.0054115094,
-0.0852166787,
0.0146090984,
0.079578653,
0.059646111,
0.0360358767,
0.0102599515,
-0.0596307889,
-0.0060681617,
-0.0089576012,
0.0756053105,
0.0128143299,
-0.0404376574,
0.0557976179,
0.0250407606,
0.0112226885,
-0.03128618,
0.0485954694,
-0.0185648054,
0.0163049381,
-0.0183513574,
-0.0066023576,
-0.0286602993,
-0.0398625284,
0.0735024214,
0.0247050822,
0.0166650545,
0.0330496728,
-0.0417549647,
-0.0309798606,
-0.0053066253,
0.0444939844,
-0.0307636615,
-0.0115889153,
0.0580455512,
0.0673753992,
0.0077833962,
-0.0457893759,
-0.013233454,
0.0042728437,
-0.0064281998,
0.031416595,
0.0220303461,
-5.949303642e-33,
-0.0461323261,
-0.0521128289,
0.0966231972,
-0.013811266,
-0.0304046515,
-0.0070316293,
-0.016357718,
0.0123640355,
0.010116254,
-0.0179489646,
0.0494124107,
-0.0282150693,
-0.0238645952,
0.0404158011,
0.0091243396,
-0.0006165373,
0.0017277211,
0.0080695208,
-0.0013889687,
0.0165244471,
0.0322622806,
0.0148237636,
0.0387356803,
-0.0210799556,
-0.0186423566,
0.0253376979,
-0.0126729952,
0.0338640474,
-0.0207053144,
0.0483688973,
-0.0422038399,
0.0341833867,
0.0272203628,
0.0042671124,
-0.0354528055,
0.0062407376,
-0.0152150216,
-0.0125986179,
0.0491443574,
-0.0065907226,
-0.0970436707,
-0.0260251705,
0.0474944301,
-0.0146539519,
0.0090513863,
-0.0306266453,
0.0178833958,
-0.0238384642,
-0.0076749385,
-0.0040468262,
-0.0137292892,
-0.0071823481,
0.0078889783,
-0.0180727635,
0.0282232258,
-0.0116950283,
0.018951185,
0.0233506914,
-0.0407800786,
0.0316783935,
-0.0235351268,
0.0026743819,
0.0994163305,
0.0265104864,
0.0134834684,
0.0553805493,
0.0196258985,
-0.0217417087,
-0.0625467524,
0.0067535369,
0.0142265996,
0.0864080042,
0.017722901,
0.0610277392,
-0.0264524072,
0.0260440931,
-0.0102465013,
0.0085393293,
-0.0363016948,
0.0627597496,
0.0421415009,
0.0154066728,
0.0217908453,
0.0090912841,
-0.0186725799,
0.0335500948,
-0.0383178145,
-0.0093821399,
0.0431666933,
0.0153214019,
0.000265142,
0.010710909,
0.0771255568,
-0.0288771596,
0.0044374969,
0.0005292426,
-0.0126057426,
0.0501934402,
-0.009974381,
0.0085056843,
-0.0561305657,
-0.041079428,
0.029543858,
-0.0257928893,
-0.0111521073,
0.0363738053,
-0.0091780098,
0.0477478579,
-0.0188195594,
-0.002385108,
-0.0618527867,
0.0128566148,
-0.0028435008,
-0.0123378774,
0.0164086744,
-0.013003597,
-0.0544491373,
0.0114685064,
-0.0526980981,
-0.0415468998,
-0.0085340878,
-0.0572995171,
-0.0061762552,
0.0262202024,
-0.0060952613,
0.0344798304,
-0.0502644628,
-0.0789247081,
0.0196475759,
-0.037964996,
-0.0045970106,
0.0390152298,
2.751e-7,
0.005763608,
0.0166009907,
-0.021787487,
-0.0017947685,
0.0344296247,
0.0363834277,
-0.0167910401,
0.0301775504,
0.0042481222,
-0.0705652013,
-0.0021417849,
0.0824136063,
0.009375737,
0.003537819,
-0.0248990674,
0.0216769464,
0.0205839165,
-0.0343196392,
-0.0464332439,
0.0084074307,
0.0641359985,
0.0022919108,
-0.0199590027,
-0.0338588655,
0.0622979142,
-0.0576191135,
0.1116755456,
-0.0502032302,
-0.016721921,
-0.0229915474,
0.0628752857,
0.0150852045,
-0.0329811759,
0.0198428594,
0.0215319507,
-0.0556390248,
-0.0017350154,
0.0400347933,
-0.0042303768,
-0.0397195593,
0.0043233917,
-0.0140284169,
-0.0397039205,
-0.0356119387,
0.0600517727,
-0.0383020304,
0.0105117653,
-0.0029388294,
-0.0078637283,
-0.0536366701,
-0.0431333855,
-0.0312815905,
-0.0357758217,
0.0157259591,
-0.0007217232,
-0.0162069723,
-0.0299245734,
-0.0779157504,
-0.0054111741,
-0.0096240779,
-0.0674103275,
-0.0545183048,
-0.0582246743,
-0.0184454992,
0.0284521319,
-0.0422074199,
-0.0752154067,
2.127791023e-34,
-0.0049123876,
-0.0001503155,
0.0270810947,
0.0089979311,
0.0331229679,
-0.0102434894,
-0.0467839353,
-0.0041056001,
0.0034857751,
-0.0539068319,
-0.0378870629
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15723v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15723v1 | Italian Crossword Generator: Enhancing Education through Interactive Word Puzzles | 2023-11-27T11:17:29 | 2023-11-27T11:17:29 | Kamyar Zeinalipour, Tommaso laquinta, Asya Zanollo, Giovanni Angelini, Leonardo Rigutini, Marco Maggini, Marco Gori | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Educational crosswords offer numerous benefits for students, including
increased engagement, improved understanding, critical thinking, and memory
retention. Creating high-quality educational crosswords can be challenging, but
recent advances in natural language processing and machine learning have made
it possible to use language models to generate nice wordplays. The exploitation
of cutting-edge language models like GPT3-DaVinci, GPT3-Curie, GPT3-Babbage,
GPT3-Ada, and BERT-uncased has led to the development of a comprehensive system
for generating and verifying crossword clues. A large dataset of clue-answer
pairs was compiled to fine-tune the models in a supervised manner to generate
original and challenging clues from a given keyword. On the other hand, for
generating crossword clues from a given text, Zero/Few-shot learning techniques
were used to extract clues from the input text, adding variety and creativity
to the puzzles. We employed the fine-tuned model to generate data and labeled
the acceptability of clue-answer parts with human supervision. To ensure
quality, we developed a classifier by fine-tuning existing language models on
the labeled dataset. Conversely, to assess the quality of clues generated from
the given text using zero/few-shot learning, we employed a zero-shot learning
approach to check the quality of generated clues. The results of the evaluation
have been very promising, demonstrating the effectiveness of the approach in
creating high-standard educational crosswords that offer students engaging and
rewarding learning experiences. | [
0.0043025315,
0.007876819,
-0.0080255037,
0.0564822033,
-0.0580846034,
-0.0087919068,
0.022463873,
0.017071614,
0.0062712692,
-0.0161124039,
0.0060805916,
0.0283428356,
-0.0000722708,
0.0168944616,
0.0051298486,
-0.0548286997,
0.0507262759,
-0.0306792241,
0.0098407678,
0.0129036838,
-0.019974025,
0.0070474371,
-0.0187695567,
0.0351268388,
-0.0040252022,
0.005082245,
-0.0103972107,
-0.0197531115,
-0.0106815463,
-0.0363297202,
-0.0122438744,
0.0560182966,
0.0032004996,
0.066752322,
0.0000020506,
-0.0543490648,
-0.0279134363,
-0.0232520886,
-0.0124403154,
-0.008206889,
-0.0184750594,
0.0193016231,
-0.0311680976,
-0.0162667111,
-0.0320890807,
0.0057548378,
0.0915141851,
0.0120648919,
0.0389846116,
0.0610144846,
-0.0043253293,
-0.0242159702,
0.0437967069,
-0.0058406671,
0.111157313,
-0.0254446454,
-0.0082569765,
-0.0130495057,
0.0363541208,
0.0590958558,
-0.0254567284,
0.0099119619,
-0.0265808497,
-0.0113071864,
-0.0339130573,
0.031288337,
-0.0240412634,
-0.0095450636,
-0.0288562551,
0.0520336255,
-0.0273597855,
-0.0150047494,
-0.0145432455,
-0.0261885207,
0.0139456904,
0.0655368119,
-0.0797830448,
-0.0033439063,
-0.0301573854,
0.0185788814,
0.0591992252,
0.0244479347,
-0.0101001086,
0.0258914381,
0.0306684859,
0.0893760622,
0.0319841094,
-0.0534266233,
-0.0102845365,
-0.0199023355,
-0.0183397345,
-0.0497771278,
-0.0162506439,
0.0638548061,
0.0105345631,
0.0261939708,
-0.0583764687,
-0.0421270244,
0.0580963865,
-0.0158596411,
0.0565515421,
0.0093432898,
0.0180470347,
0.0490260683,
0.0088617112,
0.0375895947,
0.0214838795,
-0.015992118,
-0.0243462585,
0.0316714719,
-0.0468384698,
-0.0182638559,
-0.0620678179,
0.0402586423,
-0.0392945819,
-0.0185066201,
-0.0355228297,
-0.0154788624,
0.0254762284,
0.0232311469,
0.0289810691,
-0.014529096,
-0.0219278075,
0.0094274981,
-0.0204566941,
0.0353786759,
-0.065972805,
-0.0181466397,
-0.0018291845,
-0.0418538079,
-0.0162436441,
-0.0283358283,
0.0386032797,
-0.0321758874,
0.0638065711,
0.0370530374,
-0.0144431451,
-0.0444247648,
-0.0225549154,
-0.0445551313,
-0.0454927497,
-0.0792308971,
-0.0022074161,
-0.0821273029,
0.0246963296,
-0.0360250212,
-0.0053248396,
-0.0145376557,
0.034133058,
0.0568069071,
-0.0267608985,
0.075522542,
-0.0495516136,
-0.0105396658,
0.0353100523,
-0.0032239475,
0.0504121073,
0.0659128204,
0.0638056919,
0.049600035,
0.0623275489,
-0.035838224,
0.0279447902,
0.0192153584,
0.0499522537,
-0.0124673313,
-0.017308386,
-0.0156809334,
0.0212569106,
0.0443681255,
-0.049011346,
0.0473199375,
0.0057500168,
0.061903365,
0.0465290323,
0.0262427088,
0.0309123918,
0.0146934781,
0.0374680944,
-0.0061247987,
0.0225399714,
0.0219873786,
0.0185328741,
0.0262551848,
-0.000261964,
0.0059043844,
-0.0062003578,
0.0036803447,
-0.0098050982,
-0.0585638173,
-0.0194421746,
0.0086800409,
0.019541556,
-0.010225554,
0.1080950871,
0.0113993995,
-0.0824626163,
-0.0309717152,
0.0396381393,
-0.0702497661,
0.0280407183,
-0.0552275367,
0.0737461969,
0.1062601581,
0.0817446187,
-0.0230461136,
-0.0345611386,
0.0107918074,
0.0592403188,
0.0533781014,
0.0275458209,
0.0025094422,
-0.0107625723,
-0.0399505384,
-0.025653962,
-0.0256829727,
0.0006354467,
0.0159488078,
-0.0110475542,
0.042034056,
-0.0146555053,
-0.0161232501,
-0.0146738496,
0.0517241657,
-0.0272661485,
-0.0829338506,
-0.0047348468,
0.0118977446,
-0.0457377024,
0.0301741064,
-0.020724427,
0.025169339,
0.0383744016,
-0.0178514142,
0.0225417018,
-0.0468745157,
-0.0025131428,
0.0036751097,
0.0402958542,
-0.0885654539,
0.0580561832,
-0.016561145,
0.0067466474,
-0.0266957488,
0.0276835654,
-0.0498194881,
0.0238162782,
-0.034800753,
0.0117539205,
-0.0225794222,
0.023553092,
-0.0460136868,
0.0646546185,
0.0173016116,
0.0470087975,
-0.0342463031,
-0.013480355,
0.0366168022,
-0.0450611338,
-0.0179619864,
0.0285628326,
-0.0154281156,
-0.0073478436,
0.0197214205,
0.045013357,
-0.0317683928,
-0.0396305546,
-0.0559375808,
0.0036995097,
0.0121561931,
0.0072584776,
-0.026294997,
-0.0050696079,
-0.0295617096,
0.0168970264,
-0.0130092856,
-0.0066556097,
0.019687986,
-0.0306818821,
0.0385522358,
0.0016460931,
-0.0228543039,
-0.0103296293,
-0.0187883731,
-0.0021308586,
0.0567925461,
0.0765104294,
0.0008051589,
-0.0275609232,
0.0418137945,
-0.0041171438,
-0.0000801744,
0.0254753567,
-0.0325870849,
0.0278068427,
0.0111336438,
-0.0084475288,
0.0253537633,
-0.0069275685,
-0.015535146,
0.0321703143,
-0.0933755264,
-0.0194274262,
0.0091272481,
-0.0111047812,
-0.0226854403,
0.0162339415,
-0.0579419918,
0.0098133748,
0.0411852635,
0.02480576,
0.0159338526,
-0.0521313772,
0.0592970774,
-0.006709307,
-0.0272252578,
-0.0414647646,
-0.020003723,
0.0011375005,
0.0438732095,
-0.0185874589,
-0.0250560734,
0.0586172715,
-0.0419974998,
0.0236074254,
-0.0536029972,
0.0204928927,
-0.0214731377,
0.0331658944,
-0.0427474976,
0.0275501981,
0.0131335324,
0.011256936,
-0.0289803501,
-0.0387056209,
0.0674546883,
-0.0624362491,
-0.0263548866,
-0.0449348278,
-0.0078191217,
0.0063257925,
0.0048208106,
-0.0329632312,
0.0004371728,
-0.0183895063,
-0.0092486814,
0.0451163873,
-0.0092202593,
-0.0011668332,
0.03609249,
0.0017127341,
-0.0007998179,
-0.0303195938,
-0.0096340198,
-0.0007479912,
0.0391490646,
0.0575827807,
-0.0302897319,
-0.0342339426,
-0.0143365907,
0.0278883148,
-0.0052571939,
0.0268501118,
0.0233609378,
-0.0158936195,
0.0347369239,
0.0153060239,
-0.0443641208,
-0.0238963552,
-0.0045336839,
-0.0087313028,
-0.062422853,
-0.0615991279,
0.0717864186,
0.0502712652,
-0.0355083197,
-0.015435704,
0.0036498627,
-0.0078636706,
-0.0191504639,
0.0427381769,
-0.0676819757,
-0.0140558938,
0.0067120828,
0.0234180409,
-0.0262658019,
-0.0290004257,
-0.0183903612,
-0.1375790238,
0.0632522702,
0.0222608559,
-0.035099972,
-0.0289815404,
-0.0684188679,
-0.036227107,
0.0206091758,
-0.0334095918,
-0.0191985238,
-0.0185371377,
0.0145871555,
0.0168056358,
0.0323579721,
-0.0535998344,
-0.0109917363,
-0.0311090946,
0.04251495,
0.0652638674,
0.0399114713,
-0.0556321144,
-0.0748416334,
0.0111658704,
-0.0163673833,
-0.0065917252,
-0.0588553026,
0.0515623167,
-0.0201908816,
-0.0163385868,
-0.0043982286,
0.0060637803,
-0.0034182793,
-0.064416863,
0.0301050432,
0.0863817558,
-0.0096457144,
0.0336485542,
-0.0516275801,
0.0052735964,
0.0381723978,
0.0472191051,
0.0440713875,
-0.0519858338,
-0.000814735,
0.0066623287,
0.0319979899,
-0.0802133083,
-0.0111341821,
0.0123562282,
-0.0572127774,
-0.0090447757,
-0.0488419682,
-0.016133992,
0.0650715306,
0.0558864512,
0.0095461551,
0.0320252143,
-0.0670540854,
0.0450074114,
-0.0766290054,
-0.014165042,
0.0080667147,
0.0151124233,
-0.0618854053,
-0.0477203988,
-0.0180940982,
-0.054356046,
-0.021165153,
0.001026734,
-0.0531552471,
-0.0237009227,
-0.0008033299,
0.0785318911,
0.0264608711,
-0.0206275824,
0.0164060891,
-0.0392783619,
0.0502441525,
0.040958818,
0.04040033,
-0.023377981,
-0.0262349024,
0.0097502563,
0.0141699659,
-0.0269884616,
-0.0268300641,
-0.0074233757,
0.028531516,
0.0419740938,
-0.0240886938,
-0.0198687594,
0.0443697087,
0.0140805207,
0.0462320596,
-0.0813656673,
0.0040662573,
-0.0231756903,
-0.0079209674,
-0.0347717777,
-0.0258045346,
-0.0234696902,
-0.0050704619,
0.0170058087,
-0.0453020819,
0.0044818795,
-0.005683376,
-0.0508822091,
-0.0055338605,
-0.0855813399,
0.0216545947,
0.0300021358,
0.0381664373,
-0.0339060985,
0.0125569524,
0.0162971467,
0.0477298014,
-0.0205318071,
0.0561432913,
-0.0071506756,
0.0244432874,
0.0131944958,
0.0050062253,
-0.0303348936,
0.0490766019,
-0.0179214869,
0.0254437272,
-0.078427352,
0.0468278304,
0.0731124803,
0.0071898741,
0.0017308514,
-0.0086975181,
-0.0254660584,
0.0157461278,
0.0157748647,
-0.0079283593,
-0.0065484452,
0.0047456715,
0.0267344024,
0.0117444936,
-0.0467252024,
0.0637754276,
0.0186754689,
0.0275518857,
0.0331901908,
-0.0271937344,
-0.0431907624,
0.0298683159,
0.0347423032,
0.0179475062,
-0.003752033,
-0.0088788588,
-0.0752701089,
-0.0296093393,
0.0268691108,
0.0606115498,
0.0415019095,
0.0417169482,
0.0334518999,
0.0516337529,
-0.0036542709,
0.0102802599,
-0.0363696329,
0.0493756272,
-0.0127839018,
-0.050801035,
-0.0367710218,
-5.800105859e-33,
-0.0499825999,
-0.0528605469,
0.0346133262,
0.0680593997,
-0.0219154395,
-0.0033767773,
-0.0124110105,
0.0149977254,
-0.0058382503,
0.0082935076,
-0.0154192327,
-0.0457742736,
-0.0000101499,
0.0109445732,
0.0129467128,
-0.0290611517,
0.009480522,
-0.0128730377,
-0.0351074561,
-0.0127454633,
0.0245384537,
0.0097306008,
0.0644599125,
-0.0393654294,
0.0451329276,
-0.0263423696,
-0.0489424393,
-0.0158830546,
0.0208887309,
0.0709990263,
-0.0105728293,
0.0243897419,
0.0029193324,
-0.002271832,
0.0147433178,
0.0521658696,
-0.0366913453,
-0.0534172393,
0.0093952185,
0.0137063134,
0.0076057082,
-0.0520475246,
0.0129948473,
-0.0175894201,
-0.0374187753,
0.053268116,
0.0412404872,
-0.014633894,
-0.0318134241,
-0.030012466,
-0.0723673329,
0.008511534,
-0.0128661534,
-0.0778610483,
0.0543221608,
0.0104720406,
0.0174880568,
-0.0133473435,
-0.003934944,
0.0774800777,
0.0585961342,
0.0093628541,
0.0735838488,
0.0251627956,
-0.0191261824,
0.0577132739,
0.0581805669,
-0.0386797972,
0.0104780011,
0.0296861101,
0.0638346896,
0.0459001176,
0.0809255466,
0.0890085623,
0.0835346952,
-0.0198220685,
-0.0481695049,
0.0569433644,
0.0169933736,
0.009882573,
-0.015814485,
-0.0351727083,
-0.0466806777,
-0.0181298424,
-0.0200699233,
-0.0414219089,
-0.024850145,
-0.0237942338,
0.0078706173,
-0.0194607507,
-0.0525891222,
-0.0209088903,
0.0106994007,
-0.0092776846,
0.0006290819,
0.009789207,
0.0219126865,
0.0040597366,
-0.028157806,
-0.0168138333,
-0.0165976603,
-0.0373748951,
0.0041133938,
0.0084427092,
0.0043979795,
-0.0003225156,
0.0016473647,
0.0334891416,
-0.046253372,
0.00868396,
-0.025260061,
-0.0065251007,
0.0342698693,
-0.0207490418,
0.0159133058,
-0.035543967,
-0.0120943086,
-0.0242808163,
0.0697649568,
-0.0126622273,
0.0189541094,
0.0028411408,
-0.0063166809,
0.015627224,
0.0022395118,
0.0083538117,
-0.0173859261,
-0.0116402805,
-0.0116149867,
-0.0438526496,
-0.0004320639,
0.0172900781,
2.871e-7,
0.0539288372,
0.0740247741,
0.0198919605,
0.0445519686,
-0.0252429415,
0.0164676998,
-0.0113508059,
-0.0066086282,
-0.0148486709,
0.0306949578,
0.0233603679,
-0.0010001598,
0.0374134406,
0.0570673384,
-0.0546876192,
0.0006985436,
-0.0079825576,
0.0117249312,
-0.0663968697,
0.0102091711,
0.0516485311,
0.0191000272,
0.0479576811,
-0.0397824943,
-0.0348835588,
-0.0335920453,
0.0242017135,
0.0073532392,
-0.0421746597,
0.0136376005,
-0.0363544375,
0.0217374302,
-0.0072641466,
0.0053916797,
-0.0224627107,
0.0343873091,
0.0431923494,
-0.0123544084,
-0.0290700439,
0.0021390221,
0.0162368957,
-0.0416387431,
-0.0111252544,
-0.0296757426,
0.0654490516,
-0.0003111509,
0.0338779464,
-0.0455939136,
-0.0677711293,
-0.0045537809,
0.0616284795,
-0.080564931,
-0.0372237004,
0.0041492921,
0.0231082551,
0.0216544587,
-0.0263266303,
0.0136704342,
-0.0178034063,
-0.016210502,
-0.031340789,
-0.022451438,
-0.0218864214,
-0.0334323235,
-0.0276245363,
-0.0266426876,
-0.0079775397,
2.734784163e-34,
0.0079050725,
-0.0399769396,
-0.0030155382,
0.0016331082,
-0.0103116632,
0.0112339128,
-0.0183473267,
0.0254594162,
0.0219577793,
-0.0230496805,
-0.0062522073
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15716v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15716v1 | Justifiable Artificial Intelligence: Engineering Large Language Models for Legal Applications | 2023-11-27T10:59:16 | 2023-11-27T10:59:16 | Sabine Wehnert | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.IR, H.4.2; H.3.3; H.5.2 | In this work, I discuss how Large Language Models can be applied in the legal
domain, circumventing their current drawbacks. Despite their large success and
acceptance, their lack of explainability hinders legal experts to trust in
their output, and this happens rightfully so. However, in this paper, I argue
in favor of a new view, Justifiable Artificial Intelligence, instead of
focusing on Explainable Artificial Intelligence. I discuss in this paper how
gaining evidence for and against a Large Language Model's output may make their
generated texts more trustworthy - or hold them accountable for misinformation. | [
0.0431222543,
0.0802837238,
-0.0213322695,
0.0054320898,
-0.071493715,
0.0230542347,
0.0673695877,
0.032706067,
-0.0026928296,
-0.0512528121,
0.0379257426,
-0.0108357323,
-0.0273346305,
0.0240049008,
0.0286940578,
-0.0115379374,
0.0118074259,
-0.0208838191,
0.0783952773,
-0.0206889808,
0.0234106965,
0.0226801503,
0.0215452779,
0.0336529128,
-0.0264773816,
0.0087312367,
0.0126845306,
-0.0192878414,
-0.0496826395,
0.0308534727,
-0.05921904,
0.0508371629,
0.0122630764,
0.0567776412,
0.0000018009,
-0.0588199571,
0.0194684509,
0.0167974643,
-0.0462028384,
0.0340012126,
0.0220690984,
-0.0506883971,
-0.0204715561,
-0.0167558845,
-0.0267691333,
0.0593032688,
0.0284759328,
-0.0031914357,
0.0096939178,
0.0900821835,
-0.0034128572,
-0.0645645112,
0.0556011721,
-0.0201209169,
0.0002429424,
-0.0151317036,
0.031590078,
0.0166222882,
0.0293242205,
-0.0176290702,
0.0270052869,
0.0248344168,
0.0385867245,
-0.084170796,
-0.0313000679,
-0.0240087584,
-0.0300043132,
-0.0166213922,
0.0083951708,
0.0159352459,
0.0606607534,
-0.0454071164,
0.0191445071,
-0.0000628818,
0.0324092358,
0.0217975136,
-0.0186059978,
0.1012043655,
0.0000827285,
0.0197873544,
0.0536982231,
0.0053435094,
0.0530386455,
0.0386902392,
-0.0343951695,
0.0875514597,
-0.0122155165,
-0.0193065647,
0.0020880902,
0.0194873419,
0.010769831,
-0.0650923774,
0.035248816,
0.0405733511,
-0.003500269,
0.0495434925,
-0.0313749164,
-0.0123196514,
0.0340839401,
-0.0704597309,
0.0127657652,
-0.0192282163,
-0.014987139,
0.0478132218,
-0.0221747532,
0.0163710844,
-0.0286930483,
0.0392239019,
-0.001652998,
-0.0455015004,
-0.0138018616,
-0.0151470741,
-0.0207925756,
0.0373405106,
-0.0619765967,
0.0193473026,
-0.0120107904,
0.0044473642,
-0.0450769067,
0.0423617661,
-0.005674859,
-0.0095005231,
-0.0162740294,
-0.0587717332,
-0.0500801206,
-0.0459786654,
-0.0376937874,
0.0456922688,
-0.0099441586,
-0.025010664,
0.0373262279,
0.0253907964,
-0.0227403697,
0.0072779222,
0.002373361,
0.1100481898,
0.0211787391,
-0.0045062671,
-0.0168229211,
-0.0444996692,
-0.0541587546,
-0.0761892125,
-0.0458958857,
-0.040817894,
-0.007873442,
-0.0230119396,
-0.0225421954,
-0.092400752,
-0.0036005012,
0.0262446068,
-0.0296412129,
0.0611067377,
-0.0708137974,
0.0037862307,
-0.0226442162,
-0.0058728852,
0.0154533079,
-0.0058802036,
0.0301184002,
0.0157127827,
0.0335648023,
-0.0109580345,
0.0619837083,
0.0104514388,
0.0039561903,
0.0171954222,
-0.0151178502,
0.0058405749,
-0.036857795,
0.0224841833,
-0.0085698292,
0.0557421371,
0.0022474444,
0.0087250955,
0.0410329103,
0.0639057755,
-0.0096219555,
0.0701695234,
0.0560313053,
-0.0220305976,
0.0061617722,
0.0143068833,
-0.0579080172,
0.0081389928,
-0.0431868695,
-0.019765811,
-0.051820945,
0.0078330981,
-0.017040249,
-0.0749636814,
0.0151591133,
-0.0119496491,
0.0096041542,
0.0170675237,
0.0477443151,
-0.0133217489,
0.0120306844,
0.0097105615,
0.0247571133,
-0.0289065447,
-0.0168085191,
-0.0624686331,
0.0342748798,
0.0535907634,
0.0300140679,
-0.018409973,
0.0335151851,
-0.03662863,
-0.0021792147,
0.0650019869,
0.0239806846,
-0.005089235,
-0.023129113,
-0.0221933406,
-0.0032445076,
-0.0104894536,
0.0298323836,
0.012322709,
-0.0437734127,
-0.0127136186,
0.0194785856,
-0.04123649,
-0.0424002893,
0.0207625199,
-0.017557079,
-0.028523,
-0.0237207543,
-0.010659528,
0.0360092409,
0.0381800383,
-0.0092723928,
0.002375761,
0.0320662521,
0.0083600162,
-0.0107072247,
0.0157536548,
0.0101286704,
0.0737879798,
0.0380980298,
-0.0491494946,
0.01115462,
-0.0093208412,
-0.0129670147,
-0.0033744783,
-0.0165499412,
-0.0589553192,
0.0307381339,
-0.0275020991,
0.0358367153,
-0.0499757156,
-0.0308876168,
-0.0152867325,
0.0315389447,
0.0118833799,
-0.0116199981,
-0.0187597014,
-0.0097134961,
0.0500198007,
0.0122352447,
-0.021596428,
0.0089782141,
-0.0115971146,
0.0254620146,
0.0427784435,
-0.0109384414,
-0.0025256258,
-0.040427424,
-0.0329695828,
-0.0108645111,
-0.022789387,
-0.0204601251,
-0.0146426661,
-0.0395963341,
0.0017289062,
-0.0059018754,
-0.0069735702,
-0.0289344341,
-0.0008302915,
-0.0135987597,
0.0219153855,
-0.0176489539,
-0.0687524304,
-0.0058989106,
-0.0195464101,
-0.0334776454,
0.0428819582,
0.0495765544,
-0.0172698926,
-0.0683250576,
0.0450251848,
-0.0270311255,
-0.0106600476,
-0.014589035,
-0.0059406557,
0.0019538072,
0.0256052632,
-0.0642991215,
0.0398082137,
0.0310633071,
0.0434215516,
0.0313829742,
0.0461138263,
-0.0200154912,
-0.0328795537,
0.0154500557,
-0.0085215792,
-0.0460236408,
-0.0336582884,
0.0068323608,
0.0022933199,
-0.0095136836,
0.0000041196,
-0.0299917366,
0.0594856851,
-0.0197399221,
-0.036371991,
0.0099161575,
-0.0809587985,
-0.0228314754,
0.0723216906,
0.0116518009,
-0.075773336,
0.0518958196,
-0.026659729,
0.0606104173,
-0.0269394536,
-0.0215668473,
-0.0173659343,
0.0683458373,
0.011538988,
0.0238413066,
0.0016693599,
-0.0164602939,
0.0148459598,
-0.026921561,
0.0556158051,
-0.0214777049,
0.0821848363,
-0.0431256332,
0.0432845466,
0.0125063928,
-0.0480363369,
-0.0147736063,
-0.0573555939,
-0.0524709672,
0.0276375506,
0.0472690426,
-0.0086514456,
-0.0227470156,
-0.018783696,
0.0511717163,
-0.005186371,
0.0184062384,
0.0027920429,
-0.0264855437,
-0.0276173074,
-0.0175817031,
-0.0116205914,
0.0444610417,
-0.0366315469,
-0.0023499604,
-0.0061638439,
-0.0280271359,
0.0252851602,
0.0066981772,
-0.002763479,
-0.0187137425,
-0.0235698596,
-0.0296037421,
0.0471371301,
0.0263023302,
-0.0380008928,
0.0165363979,
0.0872216597,
-0.0006104967,
-0.0149639938,
0.0067795371,
-0.0015505877,
-0.0464409478,
0.0236523319,
0.0288971514,
-0.1071360931,
0.0269166287,
-0.0007525629,
-0.0050588031,
-0.064399913,
-0.0300722644,
-0.0118132588,
-0.0515223183,
0.0901262611,
0.0302218664,
-0.0210041907,
-0.029375609,
-0.0083534122,
-0.0355137102,
-0.011626387,
0.0169990901,
0.0017386052,
0.0095994715,
-0.0051888083,
0.0405294746,
-0.0291127823,
0.0085712709,
0.0145582259,
-0.0541927032,
0.0769750103,
0.0591487326,
0.0498791263,
-0.052621115,
-0.0326760933,
-0.0355130285,
0.0362258852,
-0.0033043926,
0.0298437476,
0.035549257,
0.0444451645,
0.006065526,
-0.0662898645,
0.0208542962,
0.0099057173,
-0.023692498,
0.0281498041,
0.0487302952,
-0.04408966,
-0.0450612456,
-0.0227910299,
-0.0387248658,
-0.0277046282,
0.0487959944,
0.0154162757,
-0.0042309389,
-0.0452401415,
-0.0616633594,
-0.0321506374,
-0.0338164046,
-0.0503891781,
0.0149703808,
0.0162987113,
-0.0422469042,
-0.0202848446,
-0.0445801765,
-0.0315185599,
0.0689064637,
0.0401900373,
0.0001091773,
0.0450662188,
-0.0313333869,
-0.0114495875,
0.01017005,
-0.0474808142,
-0.0030471231,
-0.0216630977,
0.0096218139,
-0.0327957496,
-0.0047527077,
0.0187975653,
-0.0067242514,
0.0321707353,
-0.0148000382,
0.0251691509,
0.0073447162,
0.0327298753,
-0.0060209665,
-0.0397053063,
-0.0728720129,
0.0535714328,
0.0256124288,
-0.045462396,
0.0047315205,
0.0511696264,
-0.0415274464,
-0.0067482092,
0.0141462823,
-0.0093139764,
0.0135026779,
0.0102806566,
-0.0228376314,
-0.0485396869,
-0.0023947451,
0.0517472737,
0.0699522942,
-0.0165814795,
0.0018180802,
-0.002631892,
-0.0050652381,
-0.0264996849,
-0.0314664915,
-0.0162278917,
-0.0078804363,
0.0005891922,
0.0166525394,
-0.0050276862,
-0.034487471,
0.0403969809,
-0.0397638418,
-0.002831873,
-0.0234201103,
0.0437944457,
0.0064418358,
0.0537782945,
0.0037542724,
-0.0134031819,
0.0010876533,
0.0567399859,
-0.0399000384,
0.0673691854,
-0.0080553684,
0.0417884178,
0.0075341887,
-0.0011821218,
-0.0125039844,
0.0159853511,
-0.0607289858,
-0.0623516701,
0.0067168241,
0.0546340793,
0.0572511293,
0.0139326518,
-0.002613195,
-0.0161704794,
0.0025469279,
0.0053454312,
0.0364865325,
0.0403643437,
-0.0477984473,
0.0009924275,
0.0090792133,
-0.0386042446,
0.0074952738,
0.0159152299,
-0.0266598184,
0.0200251061,
-0.0123693347,
-0.0164403021,
0.0073376941,
-0.0585562065,
-0.0240779165,
0.0066804257,
-0.0081889136,
-0.0622508153,
-0.0808309838,
-0.0501124859,
-0.0483174063,
0.0292309951,
0.0083482955,
-0.0197757985,
-0.0256749559,
0.0769876763,
0.0133519908,
-0.0302492455,
-0.0669747591,
0.0524814688,
-0.0108434549,
0.0129595716,
0.0138952108,
-5.203571128e-33,
-0.0180133227,
-0.0442952514,
0.0174425542,
-0.009507292,
-0.004187467,
-0.0115979854,
-0.0189559534,
-0.0114858737,
-0.0402203649,
0.0581578128,
-0.0235867389,
0.0462028384,
0.019945791,
-0.0288495421,
0.01308484,
-0.001260385,
0.0029434683,
0.0067418749,
0.0158954486,
0.0171290599,
0.0007237117,
-0.0285721309,
0.006371865,
-0.1092271805,
0.0797332078,
0.0325962752,
-0.0485990122,
-0.0259815417,
-0.070143044,
0.0491747782,
-0.0121115865,
0.0474928841,
0.0047509265,
-0.0567540787,
-0.0036823642,
0.0295424089,
-0.0078643849,
0.0455228239,
0.0419600308,
-0.0170284528,
0.0069166333,
-0.0507845767,
0.0585910752,
-0.0128666041,
-0.0542330258,
0.0239546578,
0.0375798121,
-0.0469684601,
-0.0229366124,
-0.0376647562,
-0.0843360499,
0.0325290374,
-0.0295679998,
0.03165894,
0.0059028529,
-0.0188218243,
-0.0180313513,
0.0233958811,
-0.0367177166,
0.0006755345,
0.0041884021,
-0.0417976044,
0.0564692914,
-0.0843857899,
-0.0012131528,
0.0596885644,
0.0350423828,
0.035809312,
-0.0545814075,
-0.0173189286,
0.0071500614,
0.0904879868,
0.0935169309,
0.0757178143,
-0.0074808896,
-0.031613186,
-0.0740079507,
-0.0279537905,
0.0066959104,
-0.0005908299,
0.040388763,
-0.0267497618,
-0.080599077,
-0.028555626,
-0.0274362732,
-0.067115128,
-0.0011932024,
-0.0090923607,
-0.0097327856,
-0.0182882827,
0.019296512,
-0.0004268014,
-0.0180700328,
-0.0668534413,
0.0247050691,
0.0238820799,
-0.0024154382,
0.0136194872,
-0.0098989224,
0.0170929264,
-0.0374514125,
-0.0369846039,
-0.0043645413,
0.0250750817,
0.0507619604,
0.0120409699,
0.0402851701,
-0.0074921953,
-0.0238282122,
-0.0013607829,
-0.02681081,
0.0258068182,
0.0539444871,
-0.0332292654,
0.020485254,
0.0463809408,
0.0217862464,
0.013595527,
0.0220808983,
-0.0373096354,
-0.0050903047,
0.0065006176,
-0.0163487233,
0.007808886,
-0.029418841,
-0.011508611,
0.0031847227,
0.0685254931,
0.0575812161,
-0.0234553479,
0.0118217384,
0.0274305064,
2.474e-7,
0.0646687448,
0.0330418237,
0.0017273492,
-0.0234040376,
-0.0147955231,
0.0592252538,
0.0225333609,
0.0238030385,
-0.0051351278,
-0.0251422059,
0.0019328293,
0.0007206059,
0.0572659969,
0.027470151,
-0.0164751522,
-0.015017123,
-0.0519764721,
-0.0517223291,
-0.0715295523,
0.0396343283,
0.0473344438,
0.0608964972,
0.0494578928,
-0.0226272531,
-0.0011650033,
-0.0470457226,
0.0168310571,
-0.0262322258,
0.0032873536,
-0.0081813373,
0.072637558,
-0.0245962869,
0.0052812155,
0.0457914397,
0.0100699328,
0.0405126438,
-0.0441999733,
0.0717493445,
-0.0101107135,
0.067816563,
-0.0235027801,
-0.0806832165,
0.0099594481,
-0.0445390195,
0.0446549468,
0.020922251,
-0.0412416495,
-0.0200512707,
-0.0221757684,
-0.046910882,
0.0026265453,
0.034738604,
0.0109286085,
-0.0169725027,
0.0133721624,
-0.014913328,
0.0441946983,
-0.0787449628,
0.0040588621,
0.0448180586,
-0.0026131247,
0.0284282938,
-0.0006348173,
0.0294058472,
0.0650015175,
-0.0719092414,
0.0427395292,
1.70522824e-34,
0.0153441662,
-0.0208989717,
0.0319837891,
0.0115079219,
0.0558243543,
0.061302457,
-0.0123516256,
-0.0056821294,
0.0287596118,
-0.0439961404,
0.0210656356
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15698v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15698v1 | Cerbero-7B: A Leap Forward in Language-Specific LLMs Through Enhanced Chat Corpus Generation and Evaluation | 2023-11-27T10:34:55 | 2023-11-27T10:34:55 | Federico A. Galatolo, Mario G. C. A. Cimino | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This study introduces a novel approach for generating high-quality,
language-specific chat corpora using a self-chat mechanism. We combine a
generator LLM for creating new samples and an embedder LLM to ensure diversity.
A new Masked Language Modelling (MLM) model-based quality assessment metric is
proposed for evaluating and filtering the corpora. Utilizing the llama2-70b as
the generator and a multilingual sentence transformer as embedder, we generate
an Italian chat corpus and refine the Fauno corpus, which is based on
translated English ChatGPT self-chat data. The refinement uses structural
assertions and Natural Language Processing techniques. Both corpora undergo a
comprehensive quality evaluation using the proposed MLM model-based quality
metric. The Italian LLM fine-tuned with these corpora demonstrates
significantly enhanced language comprehension and question-answering skills.
The resultant model, cerbero-7b, establishes a new state-of-the-art for Italian
LLMs. This approach marks a substantial advancement in the development of
language-specific LLMs, with a special emphasis on augmenting corpora for
underrepresented languages like Italian. | [
0.0453704968,
0.003234501,
-0.0230772346,
0.0652139634,
-0.0323681757,
-0.0173894428,
0.0111827375,
0.0151295252,
0.0762280151,
-0.0248489045,
-0.0852955356,
-0.0284331646,
-0.0193261672,
0.0245596562,
0.0292211287,
-0.0126407202,
0.0537548922,
0.0027480521,
-0.0221578237,
-0.0180641711,
0.0251980983,
0.0012371014,
0.0213409271,
0.0150261,
-0.0028377841,
0.0100415265,
0.0073753749,
-0.0038894063,
-0.0163931064,
-0.0117389299,
0.0151570048,
0.0206258316,
-0.0124303177,
0.0126811285,
0.0000018983,
-0.0606060922,
-0.0271862503,
-0.0223600026,
-0.010393328,
-0.0190990884,
0.0540529825,
0.0315849893,
-0.0391283296,
0.0665519536,
-0.0420119651,
0.0577934049,
0.0307953712,
-0.0126236919,
0.0946647674,
0.1041863114,
-0.0122557413,
-0.0244059637,
0.0177457146,
-0.0090444591,
-0.0063464879,
0.0020414924,
-0.0278933886,
0.0151469773,
0.0275737569,
0.0341907181,
0.0147567755,
0.0563488416,
0.0025776259,
-0.0466607586,
-0.0070121489,
-0.0127985254,
-0.019752115,
-0.0408847034,
-0.0296199694,
0.0331872068,
0.0167266894,
-0.014754774,
0.0034905076,
0.0269867405,
0.0298292134,
0.0150493812,
-0.0631298572,
0.0159125179,
0.0131947482,
0.0336054675,
0.0512243882,
0.0172924362,
-0.0060593341,
-0.0047825216,
-0.018337626,
0.0416534841,
0.0300186221,
-0.0357593559,
-0.0310920682,
-0.0097857928,
0.0023127957,
-0.0429252535,
0.0203155354,
0.0525872484,
-0.0016963572,
0.0194130782,
-0.0461705737,
-0.0311002042,
0.053585235,
-0.0696257651,
-0.015313887,
0.037794929,
-0.0273716971,
0.03500662,
-0.0189004838,
0.0461913981,
0.0033319956,
0.0219556633,
-0.0648887679,
-0.0560838953,
-0.0291477367,
-0.0093152933,
-0.0549977385,
0.061074283,
-0.0593023188,
0.0109062782,
-0.0614564605,
0.0521407314,
0.0264292005,
0.0037708185,
0.0304984655,
-0.0505520329,
-0.0130371796,
0.0200090017,
-0.0495207123,
-0.0137566328,
-0.0032077415,
-0.028063437,
-0.0080500701,
-0.0962607935,
-0.0038640578,
0.0516677462,
-0.0283579826,
-0.0237803869,
0.017487511,
0.0703522041,
-0.0132481949,
-0.0504205525,
-0.0131090051,
-0.0068019154,
-0.0248468053,
-0.0575755946,
0.0295180995,
-0.0736273974,
0.0242719296,
-0.0302627161,
0.004886962,
-0.0170506742,
0.0160469338,
0.0295843501,
0.013234199,
0.0384397507,
-0.0462535359,
-0.0014222532,
0.0378203169,
0.0025272837,
0.0043435772,
0.067091465,
0.0708216429,
-0.0223524049,
0.077464506,
-0.0002421082,
0.0027373272,
0.0737596527,
0.0157154314,
0.0002567777,
0.0052990424,
0.0187155027,
-0.0400811248,
0.0197921917,
0.0057406821,
0.0628687292,
-0.0022503801,
0.0171523392,
0.0465448685,
0.0352149345,
0.0536947548,
0.0350313783,
0.0148017267,
0.0249040984,
0.0233611949,
0.0272622909,
0.0054691611,
0.0415979289,
-0.0144251147,
-0.0055410974,
0.0228484441,
0.0484960638,
-0.0370899774,
-0.0746165812,
-0.0117902756,
-0.0341535322,
0.0223959927,
-0.0146345682,
0.03575629,
0.0091455327,
-0.0312070381,
0.0472501107,
0.0254070777,
-0.0720967725,
-0.0009045917,
-0.0885942206,
0.0318749249,
0.0827273726,
0.0525440909,
-0.008704978,
-0.0412877835,
0.0083590494,
-0.0327096619,
0.1016809419,
0.0049308809,
0.0101536876,
0.0010779769,
-0.0664412528,
-0.0174163058,
-0.0007273386,
-0.0176439397,
-0.0069942377,
-0.0098853242,
0.0264144763,
0.0099456906,
-0.0390442945,
0.0261407513,
0.0227494072,
-0.0304415356,
0.0061127311,
0.0065536215,
-0.0109396381,
0.0131518915,
0.0424792767,
0.004625082,
0.012492327,
0.0314733647,
-0.0653534979,
-0.0314639993,
0.0324075259,
-0.0508507229,
-0.0935428441,
0.0312581696,
-0.0544557162,
-0.0063502709,
0.0328460634,
-0.0348059721,
-0.062545076,
-0.0060554282,
-0.0470803678,
0.0270253457,
-0.0676203817,
0.0008884186,
0.0100211268,
0.0412741639,
-0.0370224863,
0.039666228,
-0.0017111354,
0.0009906617,
0.0144855557,
0.0127361808,
0.045037847,
-0.0426637493,
-0.0184521526,
0.025743112,
-0.0109553887,
0.0137554258,
0.0421467423,
0.0595136546,
-0.046768453,
-0.0625974983,
-0.0860132501,
0.0395927727,
-0.0142962467,
0.0343046635,
0.0445695892,
0.0110555654,
-0.0245267991,
-0.0043792338,
-0.0620992072,
-0.0283420905,
0.0420555808,
-0.0288834274,
0.0671810433,
-0.0238726791,
-0.0504179671,
-0.0478825644,
0.0044219973,
0.0437604561,
0.0213746708,
0.0049632103,
-0.0434763022,
-0.0558784641,
0.0365217179,
-0.0371107161,
0.019339269,
0.010047555,
-0.0675658286,
0.0117249023,
0.0137734637,
0.015694119,
0.0048980289,
0.0249769185,
-0.0078513511,
0.029443305,
-0.00840367,
-0.0510764495,
0.0013943487,
-0.0169835519,
-0.039866358,
-0.0386434756,
-0.0518909283,
0.0582660399,
0.0300662052,
0.0025016556,
0.0003323455,
-0.0392240621,
-0.0254261345,
-0.0132853836,
-0.0142502459,
0.0161986332,
0.0012057449,
-0.0329120681,
0.0318549834,
0.0007545946,
-0.0339316912,
0.0444712229,
-0.0530489683,
0.0013879851,
-0.0818313137,
-0.0215073153,
-0.0506336503,
0.0038817516,
-0.0259319972,
0.0290238187,
0.0031761294,
-0.0272819549,
-0.0362737775,
-0.0174773484,
0.0405969322,
-0.0591859482,
-0.0198175851,
-0.0376037844,
0.0209098328,
0.0315372534,
-0.0234720707,
-0.0407524444,
-0.0075532286,
0.0088531487,
0.0009580808,
0.0338250697,
0.0257486869,
-0.0115941735,
0.0036414682,
-0.0261148885,
0.015485567,
-0.0007645341,
0.0046913833,
0.0032648658,
0.0520435274,
0.0068892576,
0.0294682886,
0.0068732938,
-0.0070952973,
0.0529132374,
0.039318759,
-0.0008107233,
-0.0176148843,
-0.0092527214,
-0.0095496345,
0.0356675088,
-0.0253345221,
-0.0531371273,
-0.0173131078,
0.0535683148,
-0.0123091033,
-0.0206158999,
0.1261346489,
0.0383492485,
-0.0021845824,
-0.0118884165,
-0.0513163954,
0.0471243486,
0.0095635485,
0.0414366685,
-0.0997511968,
-0.0123388954,
0.0038279269,
0.0278008711,
-0.0516154692,
0.008554874,
-0.0235519763,
-0.1078261361,
0.078824237,
0.0092179393,
-0.0068916045,
-0.0041096737,
-0.0294780452,
-0.0285013225,
0.0194134191,
0.0350985192,
-0.0172462594,
0.00034138,
-0.0134837776,
0.0253470298,
-0.0564496554,
-0.0569716059,
-0.0074887769,
-0.002667401,
0.078436479,
0.0120776733,
0.0452342108,
-0.0152861411,
-0.0092737637,
0.0553956777,
0.0054980186,
0.0073469342,
-0.0291583277,
0.0464762561,
-0.011799342,
-0.0183205381,
-0.0479402468,
-0.0091435993,
0.0145733599,
-0.0062028235,
0.0049665244,
0.0401340686,
-0.0275288485,
0.0482111983,
-0.0199529454,
0.0161630847,
-0.0005781748,
0.0757112876,
0.0439786501,
-0.019611543,
0.0066093476,
-0.0021130601,
-0.0063808621,
-0.0212518387,
-0.0229472332,
0.0381138362,
-0.0562620834,
0.0097367708,
-0.1027933583,
-0.0468682237,
0.0003296357,
-0.0021549005,
-0.0205207597,
0.0235013794,
-0.0243340135,
-0.0267435145,
-0.0006677445,
0.0013312169,
-0.0362531766,
0.0057569379,
-0.0741333291,
-0.0014367738,
0.0216299146,
-0.0315303281,
-0.0001148988,
0.005302377,
-0.0755581707,
-0.0526556857,
-0.0217021164,
0.0519768856,
0.0232700109,
0.0267274473,
-0.0081050135,
-0.0447529592,
0.0762574151,
0.0140069714,
-0.0332971811,
0.025076624,
0.0488164052,
0.0151637485,
0.0115328636,
0.0264397115,
-0.0354295485,
0.0205169078,
-0.0241309702,
0.0404670574,
-0.0095009999,
-0.0519127548,
0.0262663551,
0.0535367317,
-0.0088839196,
-0.0488552973,
0.0479940921,
-0.0151432808,
0.0465601571,
-0.0520025119,
0.0067961067,
-0.0389622562,
0.0104091903,
0.017456362,
-0.0508949682,
0.0173333418,
0.0114407027,
-0.09960071,
0.0425349735,
-0.0205869414,
0.0494402684,
-0.008923064,
-0.0314009711,
-0.037189763,
0.0298002791,
-0.0093891174,
0.0273390952,
0.0215219781,
0.0377649628,
-0.0180921759,
0.034765508,
-0.0133535853,
-0.0161854587,
0.0079822941,
0.0841929018,
-0.0349555425,
-0.0122716427,
-0.0218800753,
0.0572294071,
0.0678527951,
0.0490659252,
0.1062049717,
-0.0046377433,
0.001966672,
0.0020704959,
0.0517405532,
-0.009967939,
-0.0108676245,
0.0402355529,
-0.023232786,
-0.0256112311,
-0.0130952615,
0.0688092485,
-0.0137486719,
0.007409154,
-0.0002166044,
0.0014307912,
-0.0584823936,
-0.007132899,
0.0260003638,
-0.0116058588,
-0.0127654849,
-0.0423566177,
-0.0390678197,
-0.073593922,
0.0145699671,
0.0142474705,
-0.0027408353,
-0.0253987499,
0.0435829833,
0.0521946177,
0.0182072017,
0.0178918354,
-0.042235963,
-0.0006925309,
0.015288271,
-0.003825637,
0.0019517498,
-6.388033032e-33,
-0.0581656136,
-0.0377662554,
0.0240834914,
0.0349487104,
-0.0145635139,
-0.0278003346,
-0.0163438097,
-0.0209132284,
-0.0128350276,
-0.009352359,
-0.0199079979,
-0.0056929872,
0.022556182,
0.0125043821,
-0.03684121,
-0.0012926678,
0.0266429633,
-0.0208494104,
-0.0189803038,
-0.0208642893,
0.0105868503,
0.0237325802,
0.0723253191,
-0.0559080988,
0.0438912921,
-0.0227004495,
-0.0266845673,
0.0186581053,
0.0302189998,
0.0790602267,
-0.007916946,
0.0590983965,
0.0139817465,
-0.0244652666,
-0.0184378941,
0.0167166684,
-0.0460347421,
-0.0635230467,
0.0491273515,
0.0217436533,
0.0159326028,
-0.0352936983,
0.0269120391,
-0.0279215798,
-0.0210772697,
0.0245380662,
0.0193242636,
-0.0218897425,
0.0144663416,
-0.0121100554,
-0.0249996223,
0.0366760902,
-0.005950511,
-0.037929628,
0.0147943022,
0.0465689227,
-0.0094108852,
-0.0098823216,
-0.0423904546,
0.0349664837,
-0.0077146613,
0.0093383724,
0.0695841238,
0.0092698792,
-0.003256924,
0.0388187803,
0.0040260353,
0.0114701809,
0.0122745559,
-0.0046031298,
0.0347261466,
0.0427663475,
0.0595821887,
0.075366132,
-0.0081265578,
-0.0145255318,
-0.1017676741,
0.0579374954,
0.028346302,
0.0109073054,
-0.0182514172,
0.0083339009,
-0.0216582473,
-0.0226179603,
-0.0319315828,
0.0077601811,
-0.0060717403,
-0.0444853604,
0.0227583591,
-0.0256156214,
-0.0222593881,
-0.0760599598,
0.0200280324,
-0.0348403752,
0.0011887664,
-0.030320026,
-0.0364772789,
0.0148949521,
-0.0004366864,
0.0384240001,
-0.0267108772,
-0.0114683397,
0.0255462173,
-0.0075905551,
-0.0135376304,
0.0048546353,
0.0082828337,
0.0362792797,
-0.0650039688,
0.0277851652,
-0.0306852497,
0.0160981119,
-0.0163139924,
-0.0150335934,
-0.0241040159,
0.003030176,
-0.0323669501,
0.0563179553,
0.0137065332,
0.0343885049,
-0.027297847,
0.0120958053,
0.0078065107,
0.0436074771,
-0.0444637425,
0.0395298451,
-0.0190506205,
0.0358531214,
0.0416634232,
-0.0444906652,
-0.0040492597,
-0.0424134582,
2.769e-7,
0.0581845269,
0.0368636474,
0.00111703,
0.0319304876,
-0.003555127,
0.0325219296,
-0.0090133315,
0.0340709053,
0.0108935116,
0.0107272593,
-0.0031587149,
0.0150027052,
0.0433778912,
0.0277836211,
-0.0770326406,
-0.0096720038,
-0.0253595542,
-0.0373279601,
-0.0211809296,
0.0129414322,
0.0688595623,
0.0748919547,
0.0119427778,
-0.0345915742,
-0.0730918869,
-0.043134287,
0.0746386573,
-0.0340176225,
-0.0968335271,
0.0374216065,
0.0795860589,
0.0397678055,
0.0039400086,
-0.0004676913,
-0.0224250481,
0.0341600329,
0.0097098676,
0.0469588563,
0.0166644324,
-0.0356379561,
0.0364727825,
-0.025348844,
-0.0458260365,
-0.0195602365,
0.0586680621,
-0.0278151669,
-0.0188892279,
-0.040982075,
-0.0369368643,
-0.020909721,
0.034834221,
-0.0577256978,
-0.0559530705,
0.0331207775,
0.0250788853,
-0.0184577666,
0.0071601188,
-0.0208463147,
-0.031429965,
-0.0543548763,
-0.0406671166,
-0.0582468025,
-0.0132568292,
-0.010043636,
-0.0219877921,
-0.0162299275,
0.0244317874,
2.547794925e-34,
0.0254784822,
-0.0078766467,
0.0056336843,
0.0677778721,
0.0285690874,
-0.0132657867,
0.0002090766,
0.0305018425,
0.0038364469,
-0.0559804961,
0.017796291
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15653v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15653v1 | MoDS: Model-oriented Data Selection for Instruction Tuning | 2023-11-27T09:33:13 | 2023-11-27T09:33:13 | Qianlong Du, Chengqing Zong, Jiajun Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Instruction tuning has become the de facto method to equip large language
models (LLMs) with the ability of following user instructions. Usually,
hundreds of thousands or millions of instruction-following pairs are employed
to fine-tune the foundation LLMs. Recently, some studies show that a small
number of high-quality instruction data is enough. However, how to select
appropriate instruction data for a given LLM is still an open problem. To
address this problem, in this paper we present a model-oriented data selection
(MoDS) approach, which selects instruction data based on a new criteria
considering three aspects: quality, coverage and necessity. First, our approach
utilizes a quality evaluation model to filter out the high-quality subset from
the original instruction dataset, and then designs an algorithm to further
select from the high-quality subset a seed instruction dataset with good
coverage. The seed dataset is applied to fine-tune the foundation LLM to obtain
an initial instruction-following LLM. Finally, we develop a necessity
evaluation model to find out the instruction data which are performed badly in
the initial instruction-following LLM and consider them necessary instructions
to further improve the LLMs. In this way, we can get a small high-quality,
broad-coverage and high-necessity subset from the original instruction
datasets. Experimental results show that, the model fine-tuned with 4,000
instruction pairs selected by our approach could perform better than the model
fine-tuned with the full original dataset which includes 214k instruction data. | [
0.0212073661,
0.0780838579,
-0.0282418467,
0.0048134658,
-0.0226385687,
0.0321020111,
-0.0229614582,
0.0195030365,
-0.0006887242,
-0.0427495055,
-0.0263587944,
-0.0114149405,
-0.0020506403,
-0.0218148213,
0.0034550298,
-0.0364290029,
0.0820508674,
-0.0593208708,
-0.0789705515,
0.0261051189,
-0.0441669449,
0.0195361804,
0.0197366904,
0.0110755805,
0.0213222001,
0.0123411212,
-0.0039950334,
0.0426709391,
-0.0107426485,
-0.0129477261,
0.0150519982,
0.0304605961,
0.0193114188,
-0.0496265516,
0.0000022912,
-0.0339627564,
-0.0263526607,
0.0025224541,
-0.0305569377,
0.0554194897,
0.0372851305,
0.0302636921,
-0.0398402512,
0.019553395,
0.0014228451,
0.0389728695,
0.028791368,
-0.0160163958,
0.0692666918,
0.0734478161,
0.0187160093,
-0.0090777948,
-0.0089294771,
0.0411604121,
-0.0071415934,
-0.0092240181,
0.0263698455,
0.0586102791,
0.0528402403,
0.036144767,
-0.0146347778,
0.0021876241,
0.0048160958,
-0.0203813221,
-0.0170543455,
-0.0077541391,
-0.0225247797,
-0.0028521891,
-0.0199075826,
0.0433093086,
-0.0398687199,
-0.0169522166,
0.0169693381,
-0.0158609208,
-0.0245955903,
-0.0040863524,
-0.0151186492,
0.0036941832,
-0.0171125196,
0.01746751,
0.0500875041,
-0.0551479831,
-0.0082347831,
0.0080675036,
-0.0410664864,
0.0380388759,
0.0146682411,
-0.0462153926,
-0.0020631724,
-0.0283784028,
-0.0451464802,
-0.0394018628,
-0.0103455968,
0.0432267897,
-0.0560958721,
0.0278013907,
-0.0819623023,
0.028051177,
0.0267919675,
-0.0215674769,
0.0869384557,
0.0523230359,
-0.0106048444,
0.0245889854,
-0.0229526535,
0.0399861522,
0.0148632498,
0.0177624468,
-0.0259646047,
0.0432460457,
-0.0570543818,
0.0443720892,
-0.0405374914,
0.0593802556,
-0.0338841453,
0.0298462696,
-0.0380326807,
0.0474239439,
0.0227564573,
0.0147488201,
0.0249381512,
-0.0797068849,
-0.0367167927,
0.0303927604,
-0.010418037,
-0.0243714638,
-0.0247748122,
-0.010987672,
-0.0484065711,
-0.0692469329,
0.028793212,
0.0076573854,
-0.0249259658,
-0.0125988284,
0.0433011688,
0.0737179667,
0.0178360306,
-0.0077614523,
-0.0849764794,
-0.0131471865,
0.0307333227,
-0.0315951221,
-0.0132683329,
-0.0409690849,
-0.0215565581,
0.0074814451,
0.0096774874,
0.0136731556,
-0.0086653074,
0.0394669995,
-0.0032141088,
0.0047832197,
-0.0052353512,
0.0428760312,
-0.0074415924,
0.0013696314,
0.0137979984,
0.0585156567,
0.0269645993,
0.0045425938,
0.0321423262,
-0.0424851216,
-0.0082717398,
0.0264813323,
-0.0117003694,
0.0355098248,
-0.004928716,
0.0414638259,
0.0038583551,
-0.0254258662,
-0.0021917976,
0.0376059115,
-0.0122847641,
0.0187441148,
0.0132690687,
0.0097811399,
0.0259651393,
0.0179477092,
0.0644833595,
0.0426095799,
-0.0047093998,
0.0086571788,
-0.0275290329,
0.0098007079,
-0.0272434894,
-0.0062244963,
-0.0265698489,
0.0473503843,
-0.0264162291,
-0.0431507751,
-0.0054179998,
-0.0089732213,
-0.008402463,
0.0241159257,
0.0485371388,
-0.0328781381,
-0.0821750835,
0.033628054,
0.0558465049,
-0.0185024887,
-0.0354936533,
-0.0762531534,
-0.0030357458,
0.0705022737,
0.0471134335,
-0.0337324031,
-0.0358453505,
0.018256776,
0.05058847,
-0.0454668365,
0.0329657309,
-0.0234886389,
0.0102085033,
-0.064513877,
-0.0509089381,
0.0207173396,
-0.0027127119,
0.011560021,
-0.0043575652,
-0.0327114016,
-0.0000707141,
0.0016720903,
-0.1038354933,
0.0508264042,
-0.0120048765,
-0.0187037773,
-0.0109125944,
0.0204928406,
0.0308098961,
-0.0181371272,
-0.0172755942,
-0.0138541358,
0.0324850306,
0.0209199451,
0.043575637,
-0.0515334979,
-0.0517539121,
-0.0043823835,
-0.0052795256,
-0.0205656178,
-0.0022630831,
0.0120949037,
-0.0424154326,
-0.0515019335,
-0.0124344938,
-0.055115588,
0.0061231274,
0.0113644283,
0.0710814074,
-0.0321508311,
-0.0396561138,
-0.0527714193,
0.0408163331,
-0.0180138852,
-0.0058293962,
0.0686968118,
0.0246944577,
0.0235852227,
-0.0319546387,
-0.0142574804,
0.0071497224,
-0.0171214975,
0.0390308127,
0.0281095728,
0.0562140234,
-0.0224146843,
-0.0382308289,
-0.0599749796,
0.0298354737,
-0.016316019,
0.0235248227,
0.0478230529,
0.0106265685,
-0.004193197,
-0.0189944915,
0.0189596675,
-0.0237531513,
-0.0017654481,
-0.0042593051,
-0.0025612442,
-0.0046571959,
-0.0618999787,
-0.0337649584,
-0.0295164175,
-0.0044766935,
-0.0220744871,
-0.0113242241,
0.0143108005,
-0.086834915,
0.0597948469,
0.0116261346,
0.0217707213,
-0.0137553504,
-0.0596895777,
0.0023898929,
0.0167452451,
-0.0359666049,
0.0680127889,
-0.0448258929,
0.0042915414,
0.0483324565,
-0.0063484092,
-0.0600371622,
0.0113091953,
0.0116286315,
-0.0267906357,
-0.0346579291,
-0.0454240255,
0.0376551263,
0.0425860882,
0.0041002156,
-0.0019794679,
-0.0310277473,
-0.0280148461,
-0.0419437476,
0.0363420732,
0.0066328067,
0.0042406088,
-0.0189135224,
0.0105932932,
-0.0352467224,
-0.0773942024,
0.0540735237,
-0.0061339396,
0.0134868408,
-0.0756751895,
-0.0044896281,
-0.0166654699,
-0.0210524909,
-0.0003559137,
0.0208145231,
-0.0200954471,
-0.0303980261,
-0.0353407599,
-0.0106506776,
0.0280390382,
-0.0221658889,
0.0474885926,
-0.0741257071,
0.0180783551,
0.0089980727,
0.0102389408,
-0.0441270731,
-0.0128732054,
0.0324620195,
0.0104830451,
0.0618393645,
-0.0151660368,
-0.0139592104,
-0.0042046737,
0.0024094547,
0.0279717799,
0.0112336222,
0.0056672967,
-0.0163927265,
-0.0651650429,
0.016465148,
-0.044064749,
-0.0315243527,
-0.0440305881,
0.0420376919,
-0.0074607073,
0.0445668772,
-0.0221396461,
-0.0228849743,
0.038514901,
0.0547614172,
-0.0426799208,
-0.0629064217,
0.0836657658,
0.0953608155,
-0.0547478832,
-0.0085592847,
0.080841139,
0.039612785,
0.0059075137,
0.0109394398,
0.0201135166,
-0.0023744125,
0.0394195914,
0.0692085549,
-0.0688540041,
-0.0073891208,
-0.0004778184,
0.0537060089,
-0.0185954366,
0.0071805753,
0.0012700349,
-0.0843926072,
0.0573668592,
0.0203061309,
-0.0312603153,
-0.0371544398,
-0.0656553209,
0.0305742864,
-0.0027812182,
0.0161939897,
0.0239058081,
-0.0417303964,
-0.0299226977,
0.0290231518,
-0.0171038527,
-0.0879226625,
0.0512694903,
-0.0031031759,
0.0466149896,
0.0705119669,
0.0235788003,
0.0351412781,
-0.021900367,
0.0374035984,
-0.0275050215,
0.0293251518,
-0.0612656511,
0.0474393852,
0.0126100183,
-0.0115976566,
0.0192708485,
0.0129457517,
0.0027149371,
0.0328237675,
0.0136745144,
0.0613559224,
-0.0625711456,
0.0389519036,
-0.0065155546,
-0.0280175377,
0.0384113267,
0.0159175303,
0.0227082707,
-0.0373682342,
-0.0110928491,
-0.0271347184,
-0.0733494237,
-0.091597937,
0.0127115361,
0.0484391823,
-0.1092580259,
-0.017394444,
-0.0310073104,
0.0098718805,
0.0509804524,
0.0238005947,
0.032065291,
0.0003696435,
0.0470959917,
-0.0058738515,
-0.0015892686,
0.0056098481,
-0.0510306954,
0.0242442992,
-0.1251480579,
-0.0822793618,
-0.0018947907,
-0.000591788,
-0.0039229421,
-0.0264639929,
-0.030395953,
-0.0539535582,
0.0224127453,
0.0928940549,
0.012856896,
0.0218910333,
-0.0306401756,
-0.0415891781,
0.0160450079,
-0.0157124568,
-0.0317332633,
-0.006358237,
0.0337835997,
-0.0502584465,
-0.0248444509,
-0.0115514044,
-0.0339451879,
0.078331545,
0.0566696823,
-0.0047109858,
-0.032199271,
-0.0006227337,
0.0237604938,
0.0676915646,
-0.0133656962,
-0.0055644922,
-0.0268689673,
0.0004155274,
0.0423688702,
0.001997849,
-0.0024310001,
-0.042969685,
0.0472571664,
-0.0059229769,
-0.0312819928,
0.0150925051,
-0.0674332082,
-0.0522401556,
0.0092201903,
-0.0359906256,
0.0829137862,
-0.0195606351,
0.054318171,
0.0535472147,
0.0138389766,
-0.0007205636,
0.0087915426,
0.0419689417,
0.0351348892,
0.002111322,
0.0658874735,
-0.0085218418,
0.0538326688,
-0.0261202883,
0.0311897099,
0.0040239794,
-0.0230980311,
-0.0433929823,
-0.0005115814,
0.0436025821,
-0.0262048412,
0.0410374664,
-0.0004118934,
0.0170267839,
-0.0391329788,
0.0505733378,
0.0301873591,
-0.0261292215,
-0.0211312436,
0.0468850285,
-0.0163613334,
-0.0305276867,
0.0547186323,
0.0082485098,
0.0416604169,
-0.0111581003,
-0.0158364922,
-0.0588335991,
0.0302075539,
0.037536025,
-0.0171509385,
-0.0410175584,
0.0003387124,
-0.0185625795,
-0.0266792495,
-0.0551546514,
0.0259211008,
0.0109414076,
-0.0295284614,
0.0564678721,
0.0253586397,
0.0100895995,
0.0147641879,
-0.054904066,
-0.0522432141,
-0.0099744787,
-0.0071205213,
-0.0101620918,
-5.9922889e-33,
-0.0484749041,
0.0264208633,
0.0253888816,
-0.0192239601,
0.0068745292,
-0.0009245918,
-0.0242546741,
-0.0353117064,
-0.0154310092,
-0.0352489427,
-0.0027079431,
-0.0093358997,
0.0075191176,
-0.0097288713,
0.0160907079,
0.0203469489,
0.0527483448,
0.0015939852,
-0.0627618656,
0.0303135477,
0.0312268082,
0.0070966091,
0.0457089953,
-0.0439467244,
-0.0401401706,
-0.0103676869,
0.0303249974,
0.0025331897,
-0.0230317172,
0.0925496668,
0.0461922884,
0.0225035846,
-0.0002134239,
-0.0541369654,
-0.0500809439,
-0.0345184542,
-0.0046961112,
-0.0558721162,
0.0194818433,
0.0239210576,
0.0169318803,
-0.0335560925,
0.0070249364,
-0.0016310393,
-0.0396145731,
0.0069382177,
0.020005364,
-0.0165930633,
-0.0231492929,
0.0397359245,
-0.0533036254,
0.0407880247,
-0.0015549349,
-0.0554126017,
0.0165616944,
0.009644717,
-0.0102783144,
-0.0344976708,
0.0338532627,
0.0477720872,
0.0750190914,
0.0686200932,
0.0714829564,
0.0242587402,
0.0140364114,
0.0077386666,
-0.0300063416,
0.0366650634,
0.0655468404,
0.0129503831,
0.021034969,
0.081011273,
-0.0348846577,
-0.0379687101,
0.0294749942,
-0.0377347581,
-0.0431867763,
0.013446046,
0.007670274,
0.0514927134,
0.008159061,
0.0121980105,
-0.0749635324,
-0.0152206747,
-0.0276587736,
0.028725177,
-0.0119996918,
-0.0210418627,
0.0491903275,
-0.0092044044,
-0.0863533169,
-0.0000888483,
0.0431485102,
-0.009757218,
-0.0274279211,
-0.0139805051,
-0.0420204662,
0.0026181976,
-0.0137736583,
0.0117251324,
-0.0377547182,
-0.1127988324,
0.041173853,
-0.0435722768,
0.0599080324,
-0.0095187137,
-0.0086970432,
0.0455438048,
-0.0529460944,
0.0095410347,
-0.0312001128,
-0.0112622753,
-0.0040053441,
0.0173836537,
0.0156873036,
0.0132433893,
0.0031531057,
0.0751453713,
-0.0071814335,
-0.073079139,
-0.0465065613,
-0.031336844,
0.0164544526,
0.0320329256,
-0.0234948453,
0.0033369297,
-0.0487612039,
0.0115883052,
-0.009243425,
-0.0263229497,
-0.02962167,
0.0288061909,
3.043e-7,
0.0075909495,
0.0594535396,
-0.0043859221,
0.0404120572,
-0.0245863069,
-0.0022657334,
-0.0145734763,
-0.0264495499,
0.0206533335,
0.0130462516,
0.0249547176,
-0.0022514639,
0.0439700745,
0.016474871,
-0.0158742964,
0.0340793543,
0.0043509156,
0.0219509806,
-0.0683058128,
0.0046182214,
0.0319860764,
0.055582568,
-0.0179219563,
0.0113016833,
0.0004274266,
0.0234343987,
-0.036802914,
-0.0069479793,
-0.015436097,
0.0546189733,
0.0286484379,
0.0372520834,
-0.0173320193,
0.0535537526,
-0.0459296778,
-0.0058444347,
-0.0321447849,
0.0886410028,
-0.0307442117,
0.0274886079,
0.0519597642,
-0.0213025529,
-0.0136706466,
-0.0065100701,
0.0547625609,
-0.0229506865,
0.0131707462,
-0.019961074,
-0.015895078,
-0.0132887289,
-0.0248364005,
-0.0174139384,
0.0094974358,
0.0287524927,
0.0251340065,
-0.0377148688,
-0.0161913317,
-0.0094688823,
0.0226267334,
0.0326828621,
-0.0150062116,
-0.0792309716,
-0.0456577986,
-0.0023285171,
0.006047497,
-0.0331280418,
0.001715736,
3.147311278e-34,
0.0205053482,
-0.0501833744,
0.0502181388,
0.0174733549,
0.0126053588,
0.012223376,
-0.0323892049,
0.0377355777,
0.0093386285,
-0.0340237841,
-0.0147931417
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15648v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15648v1 | Reinforcement Learning from Diffusion Feedback: Q* for Image Search | 2023-11-27T09:20:12 | 2023-11-27T09:20:12 | Aboli Marathe | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.RO | Large vision-language models are steadily gaining personalization
capabilities at the cost of fine-tuning or data augmentation. We present two
models for image generation using model-agnostic learning that align semantic
priors with generative capabilities. RLDF, or Reinforcement Learning from
Diffusion Feedback, is a singular approach for visual imitation through
prior-preserving reward function guidance. This employs Q-learning (with
standard Q*) for generation and follows a semantic-rewarded trajectory for
image search through finite encoding-tailored actions. The second proposed
method, noisy diffusion gradient, is optimization driven. At the root of both
methods is a special CFG encoding that we propose for continual semantic
guidance. Using only a single input image and no text input, RLDF generates
high-quality images over varied domains including retail, sports and
agriculture showcasing class-consistency and strong visual diversity. Project
website is available at https://infernolia.github.io/RLDF. | [
0.0151639478,
0.0680147558,
0.0287854392,
0.0163384397,
0.0029746818,
-0.0007363946,
-0.0242294297,
0.0331426188,
-0.0321512483,
-0.0289125089,
-0.0108232386,
-0.0290025752,
-0.0545828193,
-0.0094717154,
0.0197264012,
-0.0570512265,
-0.0177117921,
-0.0165781453,
-0.0482369885,
-0.0434927233,
-0.0019514991,
-0.0392931961,
0.022813959,
0.0170108527,
-0.0577696301,
0.0251494404,
-0.0409466438,
0.0308476929,
0.027178565,
-0.0653603896,
-0.0119817397,
0.008784784,
0.0482218042,
0.0164789204,
0.0000023498,
-0.0052386988,
0.0220686682,
-0.014304922,
0.0267652106,
-0.050499294,
0.0504639149,
0.0413846076,
-0.0072593065,
-0.0118338224,
-0.0160336997,
0.0274159797,
0.100649491,
0.0460802354,
0.062848866,
0.0562007986,
-0.0064600734,
-0.0759790242,
-0.0351806208,
-0.0242227428,
0.0630963147,
-0.0183995515,
0.0141271828,
0.0496594496,
0.0312245172,
-0.0009603617,
-0.0704145879,
0.0242377613,
0.0089079989,
-0.0060309931,
0.0482614413,
0.0525069721,
0.0661644116,
-0.0471024513,
0.0043787989,
0.0458513983,
-0.0515113957,
-0.0265709665,
-0.0201171841,
-0.0009754302,
-0.0066864737,
0.0052762032,
-0.0072486587,
0.0641563311,
0.0036586558,
0.0295264367,
-0.0216790587,
-0.0144175598,
0.0135219023,
-0.0257669948,
-0.0154669182,
-0.0169226471,
0.0323724076,
-0.0146960178,
-0.0312636904,
0.0296686608,
-0.0685170591,
-0.0456664003,
-0.0058801216,
0.0041677728,
-0.0572381429,
0.0190413054,
-0.0505865924,
-0.0135898404,
-0.0127367787,
0.0007818666,
0.070502907,
0.0182391461,
0.0004015305,
0.0175099801,
-0.0402517095,
0.0014655464,
-0.0313009731,
0.058954224,
-0.0747876465,
0.023351714,
-0.0417633988,
-0.0002835047,
-0.0474936217,
0.0068407599,
-0.046135556,
-0.0257091951,
-0.0486656353,
0.0285135359,
-0.01552126,
0.0227688365,
0.0355845578,
0.030746853,
-0.0363179706,
-0.000125312,
-0.0558799952,
-0.0139527796,
-0.0170143582,
0.0032901668,
0.0314574949,
0.0461604185,
-0.0148450285,
0.0123487078,
0.0340598486,
0.0035698023,
0.0129733821,
0.0816965401,
-0.0509977639,
-0.0009648411,
-0.0433870144,
0.0028863726,
0.0301838107,
0.0061208401,
0.056285806,
-0.0444356278,
0.0043221614,
-0.05033895,
0.004182748,
-0.0258982256,
0.0261587817,
0.0187643673,
-0.0180967506,
0.0386165045,
-0.0003467886,
0.002107322,
0.0448971055,
-0.013061177,
0.0174214635,
0.0509026498,
0.0263033882,
0.0310508143,
-0.0114931464,
0.007053622,
0.0143405311,
0.0037583434,
-0.0090515725,
0.048177816,
-0.0341135189,
-0.0525917336,
0.0046694209,
0.0506238975,
0.053561084,
0.0345960259,
-0.0651121438,
-0.0164326895,
0.0447379202,
0.0475536995,
0.0320440605,
-0.0255051907,
0.0562538505,
0.0157176107,
-0.0439155921,
-0.0357716531,
-0.0049107349,
0.0604600869,
0.0166781042,
0.0063725319,
-0.0385660753,
0.0012177933,
-0.0602140203,
-0.0404025875,
0.0295814257,
-0.0156925507,
0.0530614145,
0.0231900979,
0.0533194318,
0.0480552763,
-0.0620696954,
-0.0412569232,
0.0001124398,
-0.0146701038,
-0.0071464726,
-0.0398304835,
0.0785396695,
0.0690540746,
0.013322006,
0.0140804211,
0.0345989577,
-0.0038254249,
-0.0111195669,
0.0605805777,
0.0063376278,
0.0062606717,
0.0153637324,
-0.0315585062,
-0.0483912826,
-0.0099181561,
0.0216997508,
0.053356424,
-0.0388245024,
0.0190760624,
-0.0352602489,
0.0762927458,
-0.0631241873,
0.0470948219,
-0.01076499,
-0.027139442,
0.0458482131,
-0.0110350093,
-0.0308773741,
-0.0293697696,
-0.0234552249,
0.016208576,
0.0122024696,
0.003287131,
-0.0043676072,
0.0062963823,
-0.0020687536,
-0.0267645568,
0.0056351433,
-0.0571700372,
-0.0153697105,
-0.0208596736,
-0.0186733883,
-0.0345941819,
0.0231009386,
-0.0059130667,
0.0523386113,
-0.0121323792,
-0.004445659,
0.0184472427,
-0.0017275122,
-0.0078507559,
0.0535567403,
-0.0017261712,
-0.015389001,
-0.0062237009,
0.0579487011,
-0.0164919384,
-0.0666212514,
-0.010170619,
-0.047300268,
0.0194116496,
0.0321587846,
0.0482995845,
0.0627230331,
-0.0558671728,
0.0095226485,
-0.0241323207,
-0.0190153029,
-0.0217240211,
-0.0507037938,
0.0152569227,
0.0240176059,
0.0160065945,
-0.0087694181,
-0.0307872966,
0.0456669144,
-0.0040615066,
-0.0096215941,
0.0126676997,
0.0413292497,
-0.0056202589,
-0.0297436323,
-0.0031197686,
0.0494382419,
0.0224309787,
0.0142442742,
0.0618725903,
-0.0605450571,
0.0262424871,
-0.0152926203,
0.0478528552,
-0.0107099181,
-0.0056388061,
0.0115423147,
-0.0417797193,
-0.0054934323,
0.0805295855,
0.0322647877,
0.0273805521,
-0.0027846477,
0.0217546448,
-0.0558092259,
0.0131527502,
-0.0489957854,
-0.032985691,
-0.0057178708,
-0.0073934752,
0.0107488623,
0.0304118861,
-0.022864351,
0.0265476238,
-0.0816269964,
0.0321773402,
-0.0086560054,
-0.090234369,
-0.0712350085,
0.0517058633,
-0.0065314812,
-0.0030917197,
-0.056297116,
-0.0448848382,
0.0205759108,
0.0499748774,
-0.0067185503,
0.0243223514,
-0.0147135146,
0.0536554344,
0.0192825366,
0.0244509801,
0.063328594,
-0.0059588356,
0.0209289771,
-0.0231504496,
-0.0117825,
0.0217252318,
-0.0005531866,
0.0256387461,
-0.0178191476,
-0.0136455009,
-0.0127808405,
-0.0194746982,
-0.0618212707,
-0.0288399924,
0.0173846371,
-0.0215295721,
-0.0471226349,
-0.027087057,
-0.0141084855,
0.003439988,
0.01139051,
0.0000996712,
0.0024658772,
-0.0472212061,
0.00754529,
0.031182969,
0.0439085811,
0.0141531369,
-0.0211553276,
-0.0454555154,
0.0017303147,
0.0446080118,
0.0223469548,
-0.0300130993,
-0.0263328608,
0.0253374744,
-0.0104853529,
0.0367824882,
0.0076324698,
0.0189865958,
0.0727736801,
0.0013927649,
-0.048020687,
0.0491100885,
0.0005083854,
-0.013781596,
-0.0001640764,
-0.0079578431,
0.072929576,
0.0099313045,
0.0441412516,
-0.0520872138,
-0.0140323471,
-0.029398486,
0.023949353,
-0.0017476702,
0.0039662798,
-0.016877871,
-0.0612595789,
0.0903533921,
0.0331957862,
0.0045317677,
-0.0036572283,
-0.0015225364,
-0.0099428836,
-0.0099531654,
-0.0226433221,
0.0282539595,
0.0055569825,
0.0202669259,
0.0428667292,
0.094043985,
-0.036684107,
-0.0398005582,
-0.006265332,
-0.0212624837,
0.0683226883,
-0.0350676663,
-0.0183538739,
-0.0906734467,
-0.0384837948,
0.0147875026,
-0.0000733156,
-0.0189808309,
-0.0022859434,
-0.0173773449,
-0.0111169973,
0.0322304629,
0.026153896,
0.0056068148,
-0.0154785868,
0.0102323266,
0.0236732773,
-0.0174311772,
-0.0154035203,
-0.0160157196,
-0.0550083034,
0.0347006507,
0.0213823412,
-0.0199831501,
-0.057930924,
-0.0286362711,
-0.0577788502,
-0.0338174142,
-0.0782487243,
-0.0849722326,
0.0050931796,
-0.0109452484,
-0.0634971112,
-0.0595256202,
-0.0110990936,
0.0228693336,
0.068267785,
-0.0418331474,
-0.0432995744,
-0.0419793129,
-0.0091198897,
-0.0458785556,
-0.0086930823,
-0.0488594174,
-0.0122036766,
-0.0454101115,
-0.0219628494,
0.0160970017,
-0.0630218461,
-0.016277872,
0.0054700654,
-0.0862098932,
-0.0274243169,
-0.0111119207,
0.0873880759,
-0.0022021311,
0.0323379636,
-0.0043184152,
0.0042546322,
0.084187001,
0.0409970805,
0.0479204282,
0.0519825071,
0.0119381119,
-0.0078786844,
0.002103603,
0.0011231852,
-0.0475251265,
0.0340510756,
-0.0118927667,
0.0590489544,
-0.0118769426,
0.0869404748,
0.0531254075,
-0.0582185239,
0.0106063411,
-0.0478780083,
0.034502916,
-0.0228618011,
-0.0299013574,
-0.0045601828,
-0.0162585806,
-0.0866648555,
-0.0018769809,
0.0253753494,
0.0130753303,
0.0148413917,
-0.0332350135,
0.0019590866,
0.0418945774,
-0.0322399065,
-0.0013776065,
0.021116307,
0.002788353,
-0.0066419542,
0.0281606447,
0.05343863,
-0.0296913423,
-0.0170635004,
0.041260805,
0.0253082085,
0.0301114302,
0.0579449832,
-0.0270196758,
-0.0357766375,
-0.000333167,
-0.0001549121,
-0.0423932783,
-0.0357559659,
0.0758234859,
0.0953696668,
-0.0088886442,
-0.0022834116,
-0.0539195016,
0.0017131198,
-0.0067903721,
0.0075834198,
0.0064658201,
-0.0497172065,
0.0910701528,
0.0093032103,
0.0236128829,
-0.0286329389,
0.0402957536,
-0.0005354677,
0.0249540061,
-0.0450141691,
0.0188345667,
-0.0210579969,
-0.0079193339,
0.0424833968,
0.0005004189,
0.0325020179,
0.0302276779,
0.0027891712,
-0.0382288396,
-0.0665409192,
0.0475697182,
-0.0283653345,
0.0097030289,
0.082807079,
0.0052348273,
-0.0128456103,
0.0005912426,
-0.0351812765,
-0.0335319936,
-0.0206478778,
-0.024846727,
-0.0075085931,
-6.88071651e-33,
0.0049957614,
-0.0378416255,
0.0564969443,
-0.0647404343,
-0.0345096663,
-0.0391567387,
-0.0161542017,
-0.019036673,
-0.001446586,
0.0382683277,
-0.0053124232,
-0.0039228247,
-0.019527182,
0.0447633862,
0.0315831788,
0.0011736234,
0.0414945818,
-0.0120621184,
-0.0137866205,
0.0190266818,
0.0143682742,
-0.0012579989,
0.0186963975,
-0.0282146614,
-0.0435715429,
-0.0026351376,
-0.045647569,
0.0078470428,
0.0553718358,
0.0663205683,
-0.0146207605,
-0.0113641126,
-0.0233167745,
-0.0161246546,
-0.0190193411,
-0.0297812521,
-0.0345611945,
-0.0144151766,
-0.046492625,
-0.014615573,
-0.1155050471,
-0.005597237,
0.0383701846,
0.0017895186,
-0.0368776694,
0.033842098,
0.0098067643,
-0.0234365165,
0.0039166696,
0.0178811401,
-0.0092901746,
0.0028832534,
0.0054092794,
-0.0122554693,
0.058317598,
0.0209749583,
0.0168574899,
0.0234629884,
-0.0165528115,
0.0444332659,
-0.0293159615,
0.0135526415,
0.0414819829,
0.1182391569,
0.0745438635,
-0.0038387335,
0.0293089524,
-0.0193122476,
0.0415951647,
-0.006805954,
-0.0139722582,
0.035985563,
-0.0037135379,
0.0172779784,
0.0485624038,
-0.0024352828,
-0.0030316419,
0.0269775167,
-0.0728039145,
0.034981899,
-0.0046738824,
0.0503658354,
0.0340441689,
0.002099155,
-0.0237049628,
-0.0261836965,
-0.0111358557,
-0.0146379145,
0.0310060848,
0.0502855964,
0.0042975452,
-0.0262980796,
0.0447053313,
0.0029072943,
0.0054424643,
-0.0606942475,
-0.0434782505,
0.0377341397,
0.0236587655,
-0.0588457212,
-0.0309152361,
-0.0481252708,
0.0292324331,
0.0114990994,
-0.0750873759,
0.0502778403,
-0.0171629675,
0.0301415529,
-0.0056956913,
0.0339794382,
-0.0260508265,
0.0124292048,
0.0279670041,
-0.0359446034,
0.0265815947,
-0.0131746298,
-0.0365702435,
0.0546307527,
0.0083448133,
-0.0100106746,
-0.0107263951,
0.0043719988,
-0.0234833583,
0.0279235691,
-0.0402355716,
0.0389120132,
-0.0586528592,
0.0695248619,
0.0511913784,
-0.1081964076,
-0.027549604,
0.0416594297,
3.126e-7,
-0.0238987412,
0.0137934471,
-0.0467383079,
0.0227722246,
-0.0058784704,
0.0464917831,
-0.0037546209,
0.0246136803,
-0.0160599072,
-0.0376291536,
0.0408265367,
0.0636991784,
-0.0237811375,
-0.0746274814,
-0.0507139601,
-0.0179236736,
-0.016497083,
0.0125723192,
0.013791509,
-0.0157110076,
-0.0085504856,
0.0948153585,
0.0108962292,
0.0191508327,
0.0657400787,
0.0167829618,
0.0961966813,
-0.0056295637,
0.0281301308,
-0.0423695371,
-0.0284066219,
-0.0251974557,
0.0105301235,
-0.0663638413,
-0.0231865235,
0.0109385066,
0.0022779577,
0.0268585458,
-0.0334694088,
-0.019719705,
-0.0257130936,
0.0615735501,
0.0116430381,
-0.030216394,
-0.011145466,
-0.0340851918,
0.0214074776,
-0.0030306173,
-0.0326361358,
0.0229887143,
0.0044405363,
-0.0381524302,
-0.053948395,
-0.0394106098,
0.0376935825,
0.0463431552,
-0.0247836411,
-0.0237576328,
0.0074992925,
-0.0425341837,
-0.0380090214,
-0.0015127709,
-0.0245856214,
0.0303619616,
0.0064257584,
0.0190909114,
-0.0711509883,
2.348977275e-34,
0.0618930683,
-0.0188367236,
-0.0012746172,
-0.0289929137,
-0.0152693428,
0.0240757689,
-0.011772655,
0.0070134802,
0.0539909266,
-0.0143712368,
-0.0425668098
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15642v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15642v1 | InfoPattern: Unveiling Information Propagation Patterns in Social Media | 2023-11-27T09:12:35 | 2023-11-27T09:12:35 | Chi Han, Jialiang Xu, Manling Li, Hanning Zhang, Tarek Abdelzaher, Heng Ji | cs.SI | cs.SI, cs.CL | Social media play a significant role in shaping public opinion and
influencing ideological communities through information propagation. Our demo
InfoPattern centers on the interplay between language and human ideology. The
demo (Code: https://github.com/blender-nlp/InfoPattern ) is capable of: (1) red
teaming to simulate adversary responses from opposite ideology communities; (2)
stance detection to identify the underlying political sentiments in each
message; (3) information propagation graph discovery to reveal the evolution of
claims across various communities over time. (Live Demo:
https://incas.csl.illinois.edu/blender/About ) | [
0.0053935591,
0.0721115619,
0.0090213623,
0.0308008026,
-0.046921581,
-0.0391100459,
-0.0334748924,
-0.0037550067,
-0.0193806347,
-0.0084515298,
0.0192700252,
0.0258086082,
0.0011736357,
0.0033407272,
-0.0008478883,
-0.0417007506,
0.0273074079,
0.0436449759,
0.0208835565,
-0.0274405852,
0.0459796041,
0.0597639717,
-0.044371739,
0.0348775722,
-0.0218311865,
-0.0311115328,
-0.0099281063,
0.004130749,
0.0738546625,
-0.0332745574,
-0.0114603341,
0.0227376819,
0.002893033,
0.07070297,
0.0000021648,
-0.0053828359,
-0.0119658047,
-0.02128613,
0.0332607143,
0.0114663513,
0.0679452792,
0.0138683235,
-0.0037929201,
0.028358629,
-0.0437851138,
0.0388042629,
0.0333167426,
0.0436883569,
0.0744766593,
0.0318209492,
-0.0095334193,
-0.0208571162,
-0.0304056853,
-0.0043209223,
0.0405307487,
0.0130908163,
0.0421443656,
-0.0437530428,
-0.0433532968,
0.01453475,
0.0008956384,
0.0103513654,
0.0060272617,
-0.0065004909,
-0.0287141688,
-0.0105708325,
0.0089100469,
-0.0400112346,
-0.0256517027,
0.0677217245,
0.0022194972,
-0.0226047467,
0.025931377,
-0.0191041529,
-0.012736029,
0.061520271,
-0.0191708207,
-0.0109235542,
-0.041948285,
0.030974336,
0.0257476792,
0.0122619281,
0.0208220333,
0.0133846113,
0.0042570769,
0.0788657889,
-0.0226753503,
-0.0011982828,
0.0162542071,
-0.0042831674,
0.0275594816,
-0.0135470759,
0.0217302144,
-0.0207920931,
0.030877389,
-0.0004838581,
-0.0011725017,
-0.0045206575,
0.0371523201,
-0.0778455958,
-0.0082760183,
-0.0197592229,
0.0144843506,
0.0752562508,
0.0295355301,
-0.0340242796,
-0.0286678094,
-0.0162632558,
0.0208683386,
0.0024185039,
-0.0512764379,
0.0154816369,
0.0054153991,
-0.0053895828,
-0.0115865078,
-0.0177981462,
-0.0108546522,
-0.0091957748,
-0.0600177534,
-0.0121934116,
-0.01438912,
0.0145256268,
0.0336061977,
0.0199273881,
-0.0258362032,
0.0412163846,
-0.0453654304,
-0.0014433251,
-0.0208121818,
0.002774498,
-0.0016815485,
0.023944864,
0.0169358477,
-0.0098137017,
0.0145568969,
0.005263966,
0.0208031945,
0.0126459226,
0.0120528936,
-0.0407685116,
-0.0013834569,
-0.0390807055,
0.0284375567,
-0.0896451101,
0.0438322425,
-0.0071002762,
-0.0230524,
-0.0399311967,
0.0124659464,
0.0316301808,
-0.041549623,
0.0601461381,
-0.0309183728,
-0.0074769482,
0.0015109871,
0.0397849567,
0.039989803,
0.0871810839,
-0.0268781409,
0.0604944155,
0.0283183791,
0.0202454142,
-0.0088281063,
0.0300912261,
0.0415305048,
0.0341551006,
0.0152038597,
-0.0416069701,
-0.047137659,
-0.0245270897,
-0.0078137256,
0.0561210737,
-0.0185521618,
-0.0601001009,
0.0174250491,
0.0192906838,
-0.0098889265,
-0.0080859987,
0.0251237359,
0.0751935318,
-0.0104849134,
0.0000246901,
0.0066403705,
0.0066676838,
-0.0390110277,
-0.0506876484,
0.0451449901,
0.072838977,
-0.006823089,
0.0217851792,
0.0193844847,
-0.0011467634,
0.058262568,
-0.0324954614,
-0.0074608936,
0.0083561875,
-0.0260660555,
-0.0061332574,
0.0560326986,
-0.0138767147,
-0.0327801779,
-0.022414472,
-0.0063344045,
0.035812743,
0.0142239146,
-0.0423310511,
0.0008014255,
-0.0254998207,
0.016928032,
0.0408918113,
0.0463290066,
-0.0152569739,
-0.0400391035,
-0.0104131056,
0.0173028409,
0.0376011468,
0.0105321025,
0.063491717,
0.0516436137,
0.0359535776,
-0.0382475816,
0.0057754745,
-0.0019391079,
0.0057377648,
0.0481765978,
0.0421771258,
-0.00571346,
-0.0099263294,
0.0587778911,
0.0712190419,
-0.0056506628,
-0.0383863747,
0.0489595644,
-0.0055975681,
-0.0430499054,
0.0164438598,
0.0232053362,
-0.0139285428,
0.0459584855,
-0.0660706684,
-0.0419081897,
0.0298312865,
0.0005162699,
0.0106912805,
0.0666067749,
-0.037272431,
0.0266301855,
0.0101257041,
-0.0734179169,
-0.0264926553,
0.0434357524,
-0.0283205472,
0.0188041907,
-0.0227726176,
-0.0151649034,
0.0008630008,
-0.0649301261,
0.0010143212,
0.0186145436,
0.0257330928,
-0.0132443467,
0.0167049225,
-0.0057040011,
0.0445962064,
-0.0585175641,
-0.0124770086,
-0.0151880123,
-0.0017676064,
-0.0333583243,
-0.0111072268,
0.012812105,
0.0390658863,
-0.0032562995,
0.0139030144,
0.0295888167,
-0.0170183331,
0.0426641963,
0.0031094823,
0.0164631382,
0.0232481621,
-0.0248927679,
-0.0346790403,
-0.0350681506,
0.0118293725,
-0.0328753591,
0.0262989458,
0.0537647717,
-0.1136997789,
0.0313289911,
-0.0169158094,
-0.0609103404,
-0.0148354312,
-0.0537557304,
-0.0517596304,
0.0218431726,
-0.0112831509,
0.0085266819,
-0.0021298318,
0.0221548099,
0.0735570341,
0.0096606556,
0.0218886212,
-0.0539051369,
-0.0309879817,
-0.0850887299,
0.0756856203,
-0.0123090316,
-0.0503707565,
0.0158464406,
0.0561863109,
0.0304598063,
0.0083721224,
-0.0130321337,
0.0143421255,
-0.0203747693,
-0.0078607081,
0.0264865998,
-0.0429678224,
0.0240389593,
-0.0095047476,
0.0041069323,
0.004327639,
0.0447140709,
0.003237993,
0.0409982428,
-0.0045588929,
-0.0538292304,
-0.0189657845,
0.0405059122,
0.0334977694,
0.0205498748,
-0.0056724101,
0.0233291686,
0.0329708904,
-0.0442110114,
0.047988914,
-0.0184034593,
-0.0195228849,
-0.013908539,
0.0138303181,
0.0232761353,
0.0011542281,
0.0161457714,
-0.0679376125,
-0.0173678715,
-0.0241811369,
0.0594972074,
-0.0462092236,
0.0108400946,
-0.0166495666,
0.054004062,
-0.0342716463,
0.0349052772,
-0.0110026943,
0.0122578861,
-0.00213799,
0.0042274506,
-0.0363784321,
0.0350491218,
-0.0059313662,
-0.0412233323,
0.0771751702,
0.0116664683,
0.0110867452,
-0.0588103049,
-0.0389176309,
-0.0123800188,
0.0038238608,
0.0261933841,
-0.0491525009,
0.0563030951,
-0.0136974724,
0.0632153153,
0.0395110324,
0.0504282005,
-0.0475444868,
0.0105706118,
0.045731578,
0.0376597494,
0.0253052488,
-0.0034894794,
-0.117784895,
0.0001934688,
-0.0120543605,
-0.0062665115,
-0.0347205214,
-0.0576354116,
-0.0145771811,
-0.0785783008,
-0.0025496054,
0.0034518386,
0.0105922278,
-0.0203632452,
-0.08596953,
0.0088403672,
-0.0109540634,
-0.0707454532,
-0.0495119169,
0.0345863625,
0.0161376875,
-0.0166935492,
-0.111751169,
-0.0326911137,
0.0131206866,
-0.0111739906,
0.0324048698,
0.0028550474,
0.0564293638,
-0.0286713298,
-0.0261364896,
0.0518013984,
0.0117365224,
-0.0268591587,
-0.0359780975,
0.0835133195,
-0.0161152352,
0.0106051862,
-0.0316612385,
0.0167078525,
-0.0123897251,
-0.0273612048,
0.0148628568,
0.0327854455,
-0.0112721529,
-0.0588647425,
-0.0335444659,
0.0606428236,
0.069805786,
0.0336090997,
0.0158607606,
-0.0330946147,
-0.0086241001,
-0.0620677359,
0.0272831134,
-0.0670154318,
-0.0947945639,
-0.0605644844,
0.0219905786,
-0.0197884962,
-0.0603659712,
0.003567175,
-0.0016336899,
0.0267322082,
-0.027461078,
-0.0360758081,
0.0015800102,
-0.0198471826,
-0.0540875494,
-0.0116339969,
0.0146140158,
0.033501938,
0.0044352612,
-0.0623648427,
-0.0033437836,
0.0068449932,
-0.0343224071,
0.0381618068,
-0.0440697446,
-0.0727195814,
0.0378489494,
-0.0027762731,
0.026272295,
0.0525975153,
-0.0464074463,
0.0095273051,
0.0740507618,
0.103153944,
-0.002920005,
-0.0086091179,
0.0231275745,
0.0159221273,
0.0426026247,
0.0041218172,
0.009663892,
0.0405715778,
0.0364724547,
-0.0526829697,
-0.0812619105,
-0.0347313471,
-0.0045760632,
0.0316351764,
0.0320828967,
0.0197728202,
-0.0566552691,
-0.0528717488,
-0.0479402281,
-0.0044173477,
-0.0106873279,
0.0006219513,
-0.0107546858,
0.020104995,
-0.0754771382,
-0.0060247849,
0.0285783671,
0.0287443027,
-0.00704634,
-0.024588922,
0.0434736498,
0.0270549878,
0.0528000407,
0.034053158,
-0.0152752362,
0.0183833856,
0.0094276788,
-0.016236579,
0.0330157951,
0.0087664984,
-0.000785058,
0.0085321628,
-0.0352519155,
0.0423064455,
0.0148042589,
-0.0457546748,
-0.0270353239,
-0.0094720814,
0.0343927592,
0.014434645,
0.0554120764,
0.0618766099,
-0.0111007364,
-0.0173809826,
0.0038451201,
0.0085706459,
-0.0451041907,
-0.0381427109,
0.0116774281,
0.0289909281,
-0.0399371721,
0.0432092622,
0.0276411511,
-0.0271032248,
0.0302408002,
0.0600295663,
-0.0381102599,
-0.0366396718,
0.0029305271,
-0.0462542884,
0.0409365185,
0.0095175393,
0.0167117193,
-0.0476452932,
-0.0271975454,
0.0443091914,
0.0292343181,
0.0214483514,
0.051831115,
0.0214295909,
0.0410073474,
0.0029294072,
0.054079745,
-0.0532510467,
0.007145701,
-0.073606953,
-0.0430452079,
0.0249454845,
-6.982368853e-33,
-0.0135373557,
-0.0539377257,
-0.0253236238,
0.0450912267,
-0.0450419262,
0.0028089439,
-0.0222455226,
0.0263550952,
-0.0202511866,
0.0530818328,
0.0199260674,
0.0265482999,
0.0054757595,
-0.0006489266,
-0.0454605184,
-0.0081562605,
-0.0035242501,
0.0221574809,
-0.0112153133,
0.039699506,
0.039273195,
-0.0139145525,
0.0173903685,
-0.1140958369,
0.0005834277,
0.0466187857,
-0.0103202527,
-0.0165432319,
0.0010202916,
0.0072885701,
-0.0336706564,
0.0269156136,
0.0210650247,
-0.0218280181,
0.0064460384,
0.0388102047,
-0.0104546631,
-0.0462570861,
-0.0169450473,
-0.0250287652,
-0.0402364843,
0.0098458417,
0.0248338915,
-0.0077947262,
-0.0274396073,
0.008031778,
0.0318307206,
0.0219111778,
0.0394991748,
0.0070286961,
-0.0467057712,
0.0405401848,
-0.0425077565,
0.0166791603,
-0.0362496525,
-0.0057747681,
0.0397074297,
0.0272016339,
-0.1052736118,
0.0500429496,
-0.0878861323,
-0.0150712328,
0.0001455252,
-0.0397048965,
0.0240115449,
0.0875232592,
0.0158223659,
0.0258856528,
-0.0438985415,
0.0237110332,
-0.0181487594,
0.0184359644,
0.078151077,
0.0679108799,
-0.0130809378,
-0.0610213801,
-0.0673823655,
0.005235218,
0.0855859667,
-0.0410523415,
0.0083791753,
-0.0093665998,
0.0053195967,
-0.0190578103,
0.0100519452,
-0.0577384569,
-0.0209610481,
-0.0205303561,
-0.0474287421,
0.0097793452,
-0.0344180167,
0.0575238355,
-0.0009738507,
-0.0205232352,
-0.0379995555,
0.057155434,
-0.0311831515,
0.0344778635,
0.0025086554,
-0.0071807364,
-0.05675992,
0.0448600613,
-0.0483533368,
0.026594542,
0.0404304713,
-0.0170720946,
0.0206104927,
0.0152967228,
-0.0671052709,
-0.0206019655,
-0.0290892776,
0.0274920613,
-0.0194264166,
-0.0142341489,
0.0520951487,
0.012297147,
-0.0195046943,
-0.0148431063,
0.0302014053,
0.0470143892,
0.0327762701,
-0.0101054311,
-0.0578357726,
0.0261960868,
-0.0422983691,
-0.0183463208,
-0.0483371131,
0.0087711103,
-0.0073654167,
-0.0959683284,
-0.0082603386,
-0.0360646918,
2.831e-7,
0.0283045061,
0.0810567513,
0.0326736085,
0.0119253816,
0.0190212801,
-0.0039983178,
0.0375498012,
-0.0000754876,
-0.0377680995,
-0.0895949677,
-0.0389994532,
0.0575512163,
0.00298114,
0.058381889,
-0.0670767874,
0.0009315517,
-0.0134504735,
-0.0087305317,
-0.0554508418,
0.0320835337,
-0.0324724354,
0.0357164629,
0.0825410485,
0.0193125401,
-0.0002342942,
0.0159246922,
0.027133042,
-0.003782209,
-0.034165673,
0.0101821963,
-0.006538053,
-0.0802193955,
-0.0126308789,
-0.0062096734,
-0.0070908866,
-0.0304191764,
-0.0383599922,
-0.0324601382,
0.0233671442,
-0.0068081226,
0.0036068643,
-0.021949945,
-0.0001279843,
-0.0091358507,
0.0617153905,
-0.0071489173,
-0.0470413752,
-0.0580738597,
-0.0371046439,
-0.0093782097,
0.0367654823,
0.0208510309,
-0.0244995132,
-0.0029051707,
-0.0121763023,
-0.0006565248,
-0.0137904892,
-0.0642995089,
0.0288689211,
-0.0323043354,
-0.0601359494,
-0.0197767392,
0.0254089534,
-0.0040409723,
0.0084591992,
0.008332287,
0.0111481361,
2.845787564e-34,
0.037319351,
-0.0074613919,
-0.0161807705,
-0.0723783448,
0.0718428344,
0.0081107197,
-0.0579187348,
0.0039187684,
0.0335506536,
-0.0376712717,
0.0044689863
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16203v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16203v3 | ChatTraffic: Text-to-Traffic Generation via Diffusion Model | 2023-11-27T08:52:10 | 2024-02-05T02:46:11 | Chengyang Zhang, Yong Zhang, Qitan Shao, Bo Li, Yisheng Lv, Xinglin Piao, Baocai Yin | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Traffic prediction is one of the most significant foundations in Intelligent
Transportation Systems (ITS). Traditional traffic prediction methods rely only
on historical traffic data to predict traffic trends and face two main
challenges. 1) insensitivity to unusual events. 2) limited performance in
long-term prediction. In this work, we explore how generative models combined
with text describing the traffic system can be applied for traffic generation,
and name the task Text-to-Traffic Generation (TTG). The key challenge of the
TTG task is how to associate text with the spatial structure of the road
network and traffic data for generating traffic situations. To this end, we
propose ChatTraffic, the first diffusion model for text-to-traffic generation.
To guarantee the consistency between synthetic and real data, we augment a
diffusion model with the Graph Convolutional Network (GCN) to extract spatial
correlations of traffic data. In addition, we construct a large dataset
containing text-traffic pairs for the TTG task. We benchmarked our model
qualitatively and quantitatively on the released dataset. The experimental
results indicate that ChatTraffic can generate realistic traffic situations
from the text. Our code and dataset are available at
https://github.com/ChyaZhang/ChatTraffic. | [
0.030488994,
0.051068835,
-0.0216263067,
0.0461319387,
-0.0297202859,
-0.016390102,
0.0232297424,
-0.021861,
0.0008110171,
-0.0078665055,
0.0454617776,
-0.0274526067,
-0.0118006477,
0.0778827071,
0.0590168685,
-0.0596743934,
-0.0494004302,
-0.0367363133,
-0.0751450211,
0.0128324172,
0.0218702089,
0.0439602919,
0.0187550448,
0.0218303483,
-0.0638082027,
0.022399541,
-0.0296277963,
0.0324899219,
0.03099145,
-0.0531736836,
0.0159842651,
0.0315120742,
0.086114116,
-0.0118969148,
0.0000019429,
0.0326849595,
0.0005525622,
0.002235665,
0.0449332036,
-0.0358447395,
0.0397417136,
-0.0084953643,
0.0064994642,
0.0182348322,
-0.0523699708,
0.0403060578,
0.0214134492,
0.0378914326,
0.0453133173,
0.0735910162,
-0.0402956344,
-0.0323384404,
0.0232593082,
-0.0067322291,
0.0540533066,
-0.0144401006,
0.0319183245,
0.0231916048,
0.0018239049,
-0.0074682105,
-0.0497363955,
-0.0063763717,
0.0538004935,
-0.0278278738,
0.0785720199,
0.0612607673,
0.0052989349,
0.0107085044,
-0.0127414046,
0.1064608768,
-0.0474727526,
-0.0802136213,
0.0503390506,
0.0033633625,
-0.0452743992,
0.0102539081,
-0.0492381379,
-0.0984004736,
0.0382679887,
0.0638713017,
-0.0578675531,
0.0252328124,
0.0118022971,
0.0071782568,
0.0035505593,
-0.0223437119,
0.0018306181,
0.0013402173,
-0.0746258721,
0.0236197561,
0.0158606861,
-0.0520151593,
0.0082712509,
0.0266837981,
-0.0143805267,
-0.0331677459,
0.0023543483,
-0.0416976735,
-0.0356175043,
-0.0883357972,
0.0302930884,
-0.0215053596,
-0.0060273306,
0.029788645,
-0.0120116537,
-0.015816668,
-0.0420900621,
0.0225371681,
-0.0270921011,
-0.0027972544,
-0.0320187695,
0.0216462724,
-0.0490990169,
0.0004021178,
-0.0107404841,
-0.0137487883,
-0.0087669287,
0.016083315,
-0.0006899734,
-0.0248701423,
-0.0257341657,
0.0806074515,
-0.0224495828,
-0.0504590496,
0.0150883421,
-0.042795103,
0.0031140542,
0.0134998392,
0.0159932394,
0.0067486153,
0.0037218819,
0.0231997557,
0.0372716524,
-0.0025189719,
-0.019071199,
0.03807237,
-0.0235239286,
0.030086739,
-0.0467663482,
-0.0334249213,
-0.009419865,
-0.0616026334,
0.0077035651,
-0.0804142132,
0.0143086547,
-0.0139573449,
-0.050668858,
0.0014429993,
0.0173628535,
-0.0378473587,
-0.0217449423,
0.0338260084,
-0.0043941624,
0.006907376,
0.0504201651,
-0.0215799175,
0.0488544554,
0.0452416912,
0.0483431071,
0.0905095637,
0.0016163363,
0.0315809958,
0.0126242712,
-0.0042307279,
0.063872695,
0.0221358798,
-0.0133612491,
-0.0017403557,
-0.0658521727,
0.0135642821,
0.0122444807,
0.0503091887,
-0.0394897833,
-0.0074975202,
0.0402976945,
-0.0013649904,
0.0033991234,
0.0209789127,
0.0724296346,
0.051715672,
-0.0667262003,
-0.0120005785,
-0.0093218079,
0.0362855271,
-0.0341048986,
0.0138515094,
0.0253857821,
0.036267098,
-0.0510155559,
-0.0230795778,
0.0468042567,
-0.037264023,
0.0560574792,
-0.0372789316,
0.0730329454,
-0.021676952,
-0.0488809347,
-0.0195141137,
-0.0088493004,
0.0194747392,
0.034615133,
-0.0256570149,
-0.0023832528,
0.0800216496,
0.0243544262,
0.0327246152,
-0.0019516965,
-0.0150085213,
0.0017532788,
0.0127990209,
0.0253140349,
0.011856907,
-0.0300317928,
-0.0440577976,
-0.0367837995,
0.045262482,
0.0018889307,
-0.0514019765,
0.0104630748,
0.0644476637,
0.0616948232,
-0.0343895592,
-0.0393997617,
0.0020826154,
0.0202057548,
-0.0092053451,
0.0049677244,
-0.0098827789,
0.0132843126,
-0.041277945,
-0.0270507503,
0.0077988454,
0.0293243267,
0.014023196,
-0.0492338687,
0.0415190309,
-0.038573809,
-0.0104205087,
0.0079415841,
-0.060757786,
0.0005527447,
0.0381343178,
-0.0634439513,
-0.0249159392,
0.0480171777,
-0.0665008873,
0.0040496676,
0.0223090556,
-0.0262116566,
0.0643467009,
0.0242120028,
0.0322537869,
0.0230714455,
0.0324176587,
0.000230546,
-0.0081920782,
0.0701523647,
0.0059546526,
0.0074701016,
0.0078953803,
-0.0534250215,
-0.0071665701,
0.0093851117,
0.0013336246,
0.0036426943,
-0.0274270941,
-0.0236152001,
-0.0473756567,
-0.0167736001,
-0.0120485667,
-0.010440412,
-0.0048505361,
-0.0346772224,
-0.0020053415,
-0.032052651,
-0.0566717908,
0.0587193556,
0.0225007031,
-0.0525359325,
0.0281301457,
-0.0195542015,
-0.006811141,
-0.0469235331,
-0.006547011,
-0.0227728933,
0.0532437935,
0.0427081734,
-0.0815765262,
0.0060309577,
0.0086241206,
-0.0192641336,
0.0396487415,
-0.01653786,
-0.0207983293,
-0.0328292698,
0.0019069273,
0.0901881382,
-0.0116520617,
0.0826120079,
-0.0379021615,
-0.0465489179,
-0.0405799262,
-0.040530324,
-0.0002224433,
-0.1112496629,
0.0207247417,
-0.0351705439,
-0.0907972455,
-0.0245477855,
0.0322535969,
0.008397582,
-0.0118006216,
-0.0398544967,
-0.0259131417,
0.0060592783,
-0.0144513883,
-0.036063578,
0.0222620275,
0.0099600684,
-0.0162120014,
-0.0268831775,
-0.0460785031,
0.0443707816,
0.0079697836,
0.0224311184,
-0.0035911368,
-0.0161701888,
-0.0047962097,
0.0577977002,
0.0457001217,
0.0322260223,
0.010644435,
0.0506450497,
0.0122245336,
0.0190304164,
-0.0443031676,
-0.007309638,
-0.0013957142,
-0.0120880967,
0.0401718244,
0.0159594156,
-0.0503968261,
-0.0217290986,
-0.0772751048,
0.0193777364,
-0.0202400889,
0.0201847125,
-0.0351454616,
0.0251280703,
0.0145762479,
-0.0249654595,
0.0442313924,
-0.0338156857,
-0.019940475,
-0.0091806902,
0.035411831,
0.0985976905,
0.0293685161,
-0.028858941,
-0.018592542,
-0.0136467349,
0.0481560938,
0.0064293491,
0.0100295115,
-0.0410272032,
0.0129086087,
-0.0159170497,
0.0328766443,
0.0030983544,
0.0336264595,
0.0304993484,
-0.0192036368,
-0.033239156,
0.0270545222,
0.0120063461,
-0.0059450343,
0.0117973993,
0.025179131,
0.0480572544,
0.0007415903,
0.0173581131,
-0.0518833846,
-0.0010602655,
-0.0332215913,
-0.0229136236,
0.0026180297,
-0.0295360629,
-0.0056588552,
-0.039721258,
0.0631886497,
0.0205129422,
-0.0471983552,
0.0059617744,
-0.0672350749,
-0.0286803488,
0.0217194334,
0.0067109806,
-0.0215721894,
0.0307750218,
0.0137134809,
0.0630432367,
-0.0292061642,
-0.0454124399,
-0.0212586876,
0.0022028962,
0.0912935436,
0.0222493056,
0.0450687818,
-0.0036305315,
-0.0085111996,
0.0072970907,
0.034289442,
-0.0280879773,
0.012401971,
0.0736621097,
0.0128863882,
0.0047055334,
-0.0184836332,
0.0562795885,
-0.0417577028,
-0.0089577986,
-0.0145951668,
0.0392972007,
-0.008540648,
-0.047120735,
-0.0522087626,
0.0623225346,
0.042040851,
0.0188053958,
0.0032057853,
-0.0391283035,
-0.043347694,
-0.0305086114,
0.0068194158,
-0.07238812,
-0.06007066,
-0.0509667471,
-0.0122870579,
-0.0339243561,
-0.0483152494,
-0.0225971583,
-0.0340394415,
0.0023705044,
-0.021154752,
0.0206909627,
0.0330562592,
-0.0913935602,
-0.0292951595,
-0.0164947193,
0.0062473812,
0.0250714831,
-0.0085507901,
-0.0096272575,
0.0243334696,
-0.0674927533,
-0.0360253118,
0.0463787653,
-0.1247199625,
-0.053380914,
-0.0075374818,
0.0367719345,
0.010150943,
0.0190084539,
-0.0348137133,
0.0345832929,
0.0667375103,
0.0359350331,
-0.0151984459,
-0.0075890091,
-0.0288638584,
-0.0228796694,
0.0282582436,
0.0213023368,
-0.0488925129,
0.0709617361,
0.0162324384,
-0.0193523988,
-0.0631866157,
0.0275815912,
0.0026861553,
-0.0026659861,
0.0432040952,
-0.0105267838,
0.0234523378,
-0.0493537225,
-0.004665317,
-0.0091017978,
0.0302934218,
-0.0476467423,
-0.0086411666,
0.0272438489,
0.0349610001,
-0.0244630594,
-0.0097391577,
0.0408204347,
-0.0328286774,
0.0175659601,
-0.0525952764,
0.0270889159,
0.009469822,
0.0470976345,
0.0158547871,
0.0094115352,
-0.0353136882,
0.0026316671,
0.0123605812,
0.0037612447,
0.004034583,
0.0488050655,
0.0057343459,
-0.038401857,
-0.0018609002,
-0.0663428679,
0.0047455933,
-0.0919043124,
0.0526993535,
0.0372635946,
0.0330270119,
0.0168416444,
-0.0438950285,
0.0298219398,
-0.0314297155,
0.0591507442,
0.0016067969,
-0.0116529875,
0.024566276,
-0.04421141,
-0.0376312882,
0.0081242453,
0.0636144876,
0.0122406278,
0.0171250906,
0.0443225279,
-0.0372456945,
-0.0313018747,
0.0191758182,
-0.0078197643,
-0.01910506,
0.0398681499,
0.0205274485,
-0.0131217865,
-0.0590069629,
0.0113153365,
0.0225845836,
0.0093926284,
-0.0039011892,
0.0363158807,
-0.014064406,
-0.0235430337,
0.0227732845,
-0.0289481133,
0.00952149,
-0.0059697162,
-0.0498509705,
-0.0165133011,
-6.227611114e-33,
0.0105659561,
-0.0351920649,
0.0247828737,
0.0269630868,
-0.0567310564,
0.0155608244,
-0.0673591793,
-0.0239920262,
-0.0056791576,
0.0063728946,
-0.0054789614,
0.0485558026,
-0.0045088786,
0.0482899807,
-0.021933347,
-0.007798912,
0.0289319269,
-0.0183796082,
0.0386594869,
0.0719259232,
0.0570728704,
-0.0021365681,
0.0096380515,
-0.0747933239,
0.0155157261,
-0.067458272,
-0.0285421871,
-0.0062432396,
0.0088634109,
-0.0002972407,
-0.0165793523,
0.0326895043,
0.0270419642,
-0.0043018656,
-0.0454588495,
0.0470516235,
0.0118131042,
-0.0064429203,
-0.0234430134,
-0.0192088317,
-0.1001530364,
0.0114857359,
0.0460336804,
-0.0048794961,
-0.0174931437,
0.018880764,
0.073346585,
0.0181494802,
-0.0177981127,
-0.0023708886,
-0.0664915442,
0.0205853302,
-0.0473572277,
-0.03559855,
0.0251176972,
0.0162459612,
0.0442700535,
-0.0339741372,
-0.0405815654,
0.0213411078,
0.0041674334,
0.0257082414,
0.0305994079,
-0.0010124727,
0.0254315492,
0.0740098357,
-0.0057479711,
-0.0338333994,
-0.0619590133,
0.016738113,
0.0050007068,
0.0799923614,
0.0036573899,
0.0408699736,
0.0089549953,
-0.0535917841,
-0.0772175789,
0.0174784996,
-0.0063553615,
-0.0406603031,
0.0378221832,
-0.0225673094,
-0.0411462821,
0.006699611,
-0.002007548,
-0.0075339852,
0.0146852313,
-0.063252382,
-0.0067935013,
0.0260424484,
-0.0153205693,
-0.0051271701,
0.0246338919,
-0.061072167,
-0.041878622,
0.0172901247,
-0.0432496928,
0.0138876643,
0.0265504066,
0.0368448198,
-0.1034079939,
-0.018949952,
0.0074921115,
0.0231099743,
-0.017640125,
0.0469393879,
0.033117108,
0.0249761585,
-0.0178780854,
0.0045590196,
-0.0387291349,
0.0421287008,
0.0125343679,
-0.0160923395,
0.025532037,
0.0015298473,
-0.0319410302,
0.0140609946,
0.0212702397,
0.0187106356,
0.0254597999,
-0.0005244447,
0.002216059,
0.0369452611,
-0.0156154968,
0.0072001936,
-0.0496049896,
0.0188442748,
0.0588971041,
-0.0497448146,
-0.026105281,
0.0376215614,
2.657e-7,
0.008617172,
0.0269589629,
0.0152314994,
0.0209279396,
0.019690929,
0.0371114388,
0.0104920994,
0.0386977531,
0.0028758107,
0.0146631589,
0.007075428,
0.0488196798,
0.0245416965,
0.0400869772,
-0.0671129376,
0.0440366715,
-0.0932745412,
0.0132018533,
-0.0036595091,
-0.0057457616,
0.062270727,
0.0940270126,
0.0542137884,
-0.0046249465,
0.058413174,
0.0221353304,
0.0470602214,
-0.0231971629,
-0.0195057467,
0.0471599996,
0.0146994665,
-0.0013277162,
-0.0333110094,
0.0189190768,
-0.0446051508,
-0.011197879,
-0.0034990415,
-0.0012020515,
-0.0250293612,
-0.0221005138,
0.0277904384,
-0.0443749018,
0.0274111126,
-0.054135602,
0.0107102254,
-0.0088772988,
0.001879781,
0.0042155222,
-0.0271100067,
0.0189046208,
0.0165154133,
0.0111133419,
-0.0188779719,
-0.0132731674,
0.0499157533,
-0.00166892,
0.0032139996,
-0.0404073521,
0.0199681669,
-0.00173029,
-0.0289489292,
-0.036916595,
-0.0395302661,
0.0603942834,
0.057341408,
0.0198377911,
-0.013631952,
1.689068292e-34,
0.0462363884,
0.0235614814,
-0.0227187183,
-0.0409208834,
-0.0001567293,
-0.0203803591,
-0.0347191915,
0.0207067262,
-0.011361382,
-0.0158920158,
-0.0518846773
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15626v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15626v2 | The WebCrow French Crossword Solver | 2023-11-27T08:45:31 | 2023-12-10T02:11:02 | Giovanni Angelini, Marco Ernandes, Tommaso laquinta, Caroline Stehlé, Fanny Simões, Kamyar Zeinalipour, Andrea Zugarini, Marco Gori | cs.CL | cs.CL | Crossword puzzles are one of the most popular word games, played in different
languages all across the world, where riddle style can vary significantly from
one country to another. Automated crossword resolution is challenging, and
typical solvers rely on large databases of previously solved crosswords. In
this work, we extend WebCrow 2.0, an automatic crossword solver, to French,
making it the first program for crossword solving in the French language. To
cope with the lack of a large repository of clue-answer crossword data, WebCrow
2.0 exploits multiple modules, called experts, that retrieve candidate answers
from heterogeneous resources, such as the web, knowledge graphs, and linguistic
rules. We compared WebCrow's performance against humans in two different
challenges. Despite the limited amount of past crosswords, French WebCrow was
competitive, actually outperforming humans in terms of speed and accuracy, thus
proving its capabilities to generalize to new languages. | [
0.0295255277,
0.045432847,
-0.0130185988,
0.0407438278,
-0.0540816002,
-0.0319402143,
0.0182732511,
0.0070501142,
0.0338818021,
-0.0015856791,
-0.0323762968,
0.0123924231,
-0.0168610103,
0.0202296264,
0.0375190563,
-0.0234069303,
0.0182147808,
-0.054553058,
0.0146136573,
-0.0412364043,
0.0197087042,
0.0304397102,
-0.0428526737,
0.0174319185,
0.0089630689,
0.0298544317,
-0.0077269063,
-0.0157415848,
0.0055962885,
-0.0317594334,
0.01155903,
0.0450036526,
-0.0202456675,
0.0530305803,
0.0000020421,
-0.0364491083,
-0.0528968163,
-0.0155549115,
-0.0202674381,
-0.0359502696,
-0.0404013097,
-0.0227917582,
-0.0108404905,
0.0148529718,
-0.0186030492,
-0.0334067158,
0.0508985333,
0.0027263074,
0.0260450784,
0.047019206,
-0.0080197407,
0.0306338537,
0.0203882549,
0.00371706,
0.0528295562,
-0.073512882,
-0.0267329626,
0.018012384,
0.0645172596,
-0.0107360194,
-0.0730469078,
0.0230024625,
-0.0210703313,
0.0124659138,
-0.0445926823,
0.0047523626,
0.0238508638,
-0.0169192739,
-0.0522395559,
0.0398161635,
0.0052661076,
-0.0008785782,
0.0020412456,
0.0238571819,
-0.008406288,
0.0718787163,
-0.0466913097,
0.0049561616,
-0.0197520591,
-0.0507453792,
0.0147000169,
0.0115980692,
-0.002854693,
0.007276393,
-0.0300368704,
0.1127608716,
0.0151953055,
-0.0260970965,
0.0272224639,
-0.0313880667,
0.0180550944,
-0.0635455325,
0.0472121388,
0.0349010713,
-0.064902015,
-0.0039165812,
-0.020641176,
-0.0174679607,
0.0605937801,
0.0070972592,
-0.0019701191,
0.019239394,
0.0082410583,
0.0699717924,
0.0578816906,
0.0395972505,
-0.0022885674,
-0.0267866235,
-0.0382248648,
-0.0386710167,
-0.0372055247,
0.0141870314,
-0.0266370568,
0.0020588988,
-0.0188174043,
-0.0205496009,
-0.0129501484,
-0.0276907124,
0.0075712199,
0.0215138327,
0.0790300667,
0.0174927767,
-0.006751352,
-0.0145245474,
-0.0411598943,
0.0277689714,
-0.068114616,
-0.0068290741,
-0.0307532381,
-0.0444503613,
0.0121232839,
-0.0560494959,
0.0494686961,
-0.0490927473,
0.0819082633,
0.0813608468,
-0.0250047445,
0.0027463657,
0.0461258814,
-0.0456648432,
-0.0079719033,
-0.0945004374,
-0.0358507819,
-0.1265271604,
0.0746762007,
0.0152302403,
0.019945221,
0.0019702378,
0.0268459972,
0.0156514123,
-0.0595506392,
0.0870273113,
-0.0472785123,
-0.002280754,
0.0546986051,
-0.0073542735,
-0.0440412462,
0.0484073162,
-0.0072805653,
0.0231585018,
0.0421574041,
-0.0147642046,
0.0170266032,
0.0376257375,
0.0214335993,
-0.0290826559,
0.0428127684,
-0.0140121877,
0.0412892699,
0.0358017124,
-0.0120758712,
0.056315735,
-0.0000704822,
0.0061342358,
0.043550428,
0.0512327775,
0.0396193303,
0.0443588719,
-0.0192116331,
-0.0282093231,
0.0477037393,
-0.0212780107,
-0.00839533,
0.0390067026,
-0.0413758308,
-0.0140893795,
0.006470819,
0.0324373506,
0.0076491158,
-0.0217311215,
0.0036591468,
0.0553970672,
0.0440370925,
0.0456514545,
0.0837627724,
-0.0108722374,
-0.0213457253,
0.0022808476,
0.0178466644,
-0.0234099571,
-0.0044940216,
0.0000278288,
0.0199219007,
0.1047999784,
0.0616189949,
-0.0087908637,
-0.0354961976,
0.0284775216,
0.0343225412,
0.0045020804,
0.0158966649,
-0.0087488247,
-0.0153731992,
-0.036762666,
-0.0492801145,
0.0074182637,
-0.0157541949,
0.001999832,
0.0423056521,
0.0632937774,
-0.0501897335,
-0.0563353188,
0.0190131608,
0.0012973147,
-0.0332553238,
-0.0108502042,
-0.0493324734,
0.0040494367,
-0.0439382158,
0.0231366064,
-0.0304314941,
0.0114011187,
0.0264083594,
-0.03256879,
-0.0087606534,
-0.0185818281,
0.024084514,
0.0228003748,
0.0739779845,
-0.1197772175,
0.0129355509,
0.0199093577,
0.0449063182,
-0.0034756621,
0.0234898925,
-0.0443748385,
0.0689148456,
-0.0082013402,
0.030228788,
0.0291073788,
-0.0259636547,
-0.0094336765,
0.0854024068,
0.0254578199,
0.0617234558,
-0.0373158939,
-0.0211697705,
0.0075736046,
-0.0270538256,
0.0166223254,
0.0307639223,
-0.0235106461,
0.0115716811,
0.028696375,
0.024668891,
-0.0496475287,
-0.0329108573,
-0.0858796462,
0.0149773005,
0.0028053224,
0.0123878578,
-0.0220975224,
0.0185860805,
-0.0126755405,
-0.0308757909,
-0.0452162437,
0.018991109,
0.0319099575,
0.0085959826,
0.0133982347,
0.0058618151,
-0.0169106834,
-0.0282638893,
-0.0316544399,
0.0016648078,
0.0131763052,
0.0004579457,
0.0086543569,
0.012162393,
0.0377429277,
-0.066198267,
0.0210371967,
0.0060585104,
-0.0579537489,
0.0111424942,
-0.0415408611,
-0.0177743416,
-0.0042957971,
0.0085362727,
-0.0007625875,
0.0205036607,
-0.0801662281,
-0.0423201993,
0.0019648178,
0.0064583095,
-0.0437815823,
-0.0158286355,
-0.0580750257,
-0.0160815921,
0.0271126814,
0.013519749,
0.012922965,
-0.0061529204,
0.0436614491,
0.0084006032,
-0.0252484921,
-0.0901347846,
0.043748036,
0.0153556177,
0.0369675979,
-0.0347713754,
0.019334903,
0.0556017831,
-0.0112050259,
0.0144636836,
-0.0128337061,
-0.0115365079,
-0.0029566563,
0.0600199923,
-0.0250348877,
0.0460050479,
-0.0288292058,
-0.0253679454,
-0.0174041018,
-0.0136502683,
0.103397429,
-0.0544852205,
-0.0204622466,
-0.0212788489,
-0.008510937,
-0.0085056741,
-0.060466934,
0.0034858235,
0.0149010066,
-0.0703270659,
-0.0230384618,
0.0776430964,
-0.0348596312,
-0.02406976,
-0.004000173,
0.0407693982,
0.0079615675,
0.0073488965,
-0.0213785246,
0.0176286269,
0.0353337042,
0.0480007306,
0.0353299417,
0.0005136536,
-0.0392856859,
-0.0178141184,
0.0516752303,
0.0367559604,
-0.0570083857,
0.0424517766,
0.0268152114,
0.0377630256,
-0.0426643528,
-0.0404053032,
-0.008368331,
-0.0194285829,
-0.0278637577,
-0.0074025169,
0.0525414087,
0.0483194143,
-0.0055162744,
-0.016677117,
0.007112104,
-0.0298383906,
0.0173397865,
0.0246824939,
-0.0651459694,
-0.0033317737,
0.0202739835,
-0.0108711617,
0.030457316,
-0.0299280416,
0.0111711845,
-0.0880392492,
0.028246697,
0.0002591449,
-0.0241341814,
0.0056535574,
-0.0122468956,
-0.0254045855,
-0.0322427452,
-0.0523593985,
0.0023960043,
-0.0166014154,
-0.0066706282,
-0.0184939392,
-0.0043295966,
0.0192493349,
0.0115347533,
-0.082085155,
0.0222496949,
0.0056994278,
0.0328076929,
-0.0214591976,
-0.1010524109,
-0.0177570935,
-0.0013201167,
-0.0137969619,
-0.0356315374,
0.0280963723,
0.0158850476,
-0.0256749801,
-0.0107305879,
-0.0066547915,
-0.0160817187,
-0.004331653,
0.0709923431,
0.0716217458,
-0.0223754495,
0.0450374745,
-0.0115013653,
-0.0214565676,
0.0047569061,
0.0426173843,
-0.022720959,
-0.0251375921,
-0.0523190387,
-0.0295307431,
-0.0157638639,
-0.0490748137,
-0.0630894303,
0.024288062,
-0.0271726307,
-0.0413998477,
-0.0326543748,
-0.0125830881,
0.0639324039,
0.0704084039,
0.0118599357,
0.025778655,
-0.0413731709,
0.0659554973,
-0.0911542475,
-0.0279285759,
0.0117104938,
0.0049150023,
-0.0507669374,
-0.0600601844,
0.0002004883,
-0.0736202821,
-0.0179945249,
0.0268946066,
-0.023271732,
-0.0153696612,
0.0157728605,
0.0236266237,
0.0188994315,
-0.0017362509,
0.0004589101,
-0.0160554852,
0.0613061748,
-0.0084282542,
-0.0532808974,
-0.0357788391,
0.0071039731,
-0.0176938269,
-0.0022130886,
0.0140645467,
-0.0447372869,
0.0069888788,
0.0179584287,
0.0858247206,
-0.0128886737,
-0.02969772,
0.0476573557,
0.0278575458,
0.0142139532,
-0.0388298333,
-0.0272636618,
-0.0124309277,
0.0000885473,
-0.0271000043,
-0.0375810862,
0.0219984073,
0.0054887496,
-0.0041203108,
-0.0236658491,
0.029749101,
0.0308725089,
0.0551970936,
-0.0468739942,
-0.053852912,
0.0154243046,
0.0542006902,
-0.0067501273,
0.0217680689,
0.0302390624,
0.039357163,
0.0627182573,
0.0289034564,
0.0528709516,
-0.045027554,
-0.0096307425,
0.0247092154,
-0.0287376717,
-0.0774587989,
0.0185473301,
-0.0420876071,
-0.0470048338,
-0.0133131426,
0.0411368459,
0.1035336554,
-0.0043213363,
0.0002586594,
-0.0153215425,
-0.0314817615,
-0.0029624724,
-0.0298243444,
0.0059891422,
0.0041854498,
-0.0119227301,
0.0365524665,
0.0076311799,
-0.0321112424,
0.0572328083,
-0.0097515732,
0.0299839005,
0.044545684,
-0.0544290096,
-0.0394225083,
-0.0055503463,
0.0158609189,
0.0095185293,
-0.0164302699,
-0.0408057272,
-0.0270129591,
-0.0374110863,
0.0221374799,
0.0626111552,
0.0049750269,
0.0511872396,
0.0333378501,
0.064686209,
0.0403939486,
-0.0025217375,
-0.0472372063,
0.0956098959,
-0.0365115181,
-0.0399245955,
0.0290806442,
-6.290802016e-33,
0.0010900854,
-0.0682644919,
0.022004135,
0.0220205095,
0.0187355354,
-0.0152530046,
-0.0171182491,
0.0338524468,
-0.0097794682,
0.0367676169,
-0.0272295605,
-0.0227222629,
0.0173903164,
-0.0110875657,
0.0647193342,
-0.0114951152,
0.0231867768,
0.0200811997,
-0.0191776957,
-0.0418429673,
0.0322899334,
0.0643870905,
0.0352673605,
-0.0472334065,
0.0043653389,
-0.0139125967,
-0.0230558533,
0.0048467545,
0.0182697512,
0.0751727074,
-0.0225566253,
0.0428526625,
-0.0081604002,
-0.0188163705,
0.0331899971,
-0.0063655125,
-0.1099691465,
-0.0389345475,
-0.0100170067,
0.0327548087,
-0.0219618846,
-0.0187814403,
0.008331595,
-0.0210180804,
-0.0401281752,
0.0540964454,
0.0313488767,
-0.0228621848,
0.0045324089,
-0.0369281285,
-0.0266745202,
-0.0170447379,
0.0005410702,
-0.0406373404,
0.0610067323,
0.0129685961,
0.0367842801,
-0.0880801156,
-0.029776277,
0.0717771202,
-0.0049542869,
0.0191399418,
0.061804574,
0.0010873696,
-0.0239912421,
0.0507919565,
0.0206823722,
-0.0791432783,
0.0228503216,
0.0343963206,
0.0518067554,
0.0216640104,
0.0686961189,
0.0840321705,
0.0462808385,
-0.0079942364,
-0.0148294521,
0.0366780125,
0.0105800712,
-0.0001680982,
-0.0232263152,
0.0067943297,
-0.0351829007,
-0.0034252079,
-0.0114997216,
0.0450734049,
-0.0366370305,
-0.0305183604,
0.0017406382,
0.0212093703,
-0.0010513467,
-0.0482917167,
0.0173761547,
0.0098835174,
-0.0278647467,
0.0165143833,
0.0643270239,
-0.0174428206,
-0.0243687816,
0.0050520599,
-0.0171994381,
-0.0001995852,
-0.0259481072,
0.0530934557,
0.0142422663,
0.0006310379,
-0.0341844596,
0.0302169099,
-0.0484640673,
0.001297964,
-0.0291054137,
0.0216869116,
0.0163037293,
-0.0270588715,
0.0422950983,
-0.0704140365,
-0.0036673197,
-0.0535476245,
0.0424121842,
-0.0177239403,
-0.012487486,
0.0056175916,
0.0066878549,
-0.0012404263,
-0.0145096071,
0.0114311799,
-0.0704453588,
-0.0228370316,
-0.024311807,
-0.0093149887,
-0.0116791641,
-0.0063345092,
2.832e-7,
0.0401520506,
0.0475449115,
0.0333923995,
0.0567559153,
-0.0151506476,
-0.0274728425,
-0.014489091,
0.0212978348,
-0.0293025188,
-0.0181577262,
0.008452368,
0.0372119658,
0.053103637,
0.0927053541,
-0.0574383736,
-0.0240757968,
0.0109966733,
0.0187521707,
-0.0470984988,
0.0228767768,
0.0064971824,
0.0379038379,
0.0111596715,
-0.005967143,
-0.0210083444,
-0.0064267605,
-0.017580647,
-0.0081687476,
-0.0123215197,
-0.0150924921,
-0.018488856,
0.0355452374,
-0.029325923,
0.0120556643,
-0.0082748532,
-0.0008854051,
0.0591304153,
-0.0357432254,
-0.0073370505,
0.0057909698,
-0.017879989,
-0.0449384488,
0.0210083649,
-0.047860764,
0.0445705727,
0.0705942959,
0.0184983816,
-0.0198584311,
-0.0285086334,
-0.0455667824,
0.0441447981,
-0.0626235008,
-0.0166048314,
-0.0078102443,
0.0220199041,
0.0329840407,
-0.0172726903,
-0.0345410183,
-0.006382884,
0.0017474404,
-0.0076621552,
-0.02301565,
0.0114589045,
-0.0282814391,
-0.0522427149,
-0.0277924798,
-0.0009594052,
2.05617403e-34,
0.0056288936,
0.0059887115,
-0.015881367,
-0.0262407232,
0.0556408353,
-0.0154368598,
-0.0173811447,
-0.0058897776,
-0.0065936218,
-0.043811895,
-0.030685544
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15623v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15623v3 | Injecting linguistic knowledge into BERT for Dialogue State Tracking | 2023-11-27T08:38:42 | 2024-07-03T02:59:32 | Xiaohan Feng, Xixin Wu, Helen Meng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Dialogue State Tracking (DST) models often employ intricate neural network
architectures, necessitating substantial training data, and their inference
process lacks transparency. This paper proposes a method that extracts
linguistic knowledge via an unsupervised framework and subsequently utilizes
this knowledge to augment BERT's performance and interpretability in DST tasks.
The knowledge extraction procedure is computationally economical and does not
require annotations or additional training data. The injection of the extracted
knowledge can be achieved by the addition of simple neural modules. We employ
the Convex Polytopic Model (CPM) as a feature extraction tool for DST tasks and
illustrate that the acquired features correlate with syntactic and semantic
patterns in the dialogues. This correlation facilitates a comprehensive
understanding of the linguistic features influencing the DST model's
decision-making process. We benchmark this framework on various DST tasks and
observe a notable improvement in accuracy. | [
0.0278138295,
0.0560795516,
-0.0190912168,
0.0672556907,
-0.0033176108,
0.0022172462,
-0.0234839004,
-0.0177545417,
0.0036416284,
-0.0426311418,
-0.0032098743,
-0.0330067202,
0.0035894932,
0.0767261013,
0.0096882256,
-0.0824505612,
0.0556458011,
-0.0287501141,
-0.0017092261,
0.0098092835,
0.035480421,
-0.0123930993,
-0.0619049966,
0.0398266651,
-0.0530192368,
-0.0047185961,
-0.0591522679,
0.0120588383,
0.0046430216,
0.0288434736,
-0.0141412001,
0.0167650189,
0.0390790328,
0.0123584606,
0.0000015972,
-0.0269657187,
-0.03233869,
-0.0228354074,
-0.0289061759,
-0.0331343524,
-0.0766567513,
0.0263177473,
-0.0235908721,
0.0042873258,
-0.0220008008,
0.0258482546,
0.0259379093,
0.0527000129,
0.0861241072,
0.0825139508,
-0.0154959057,
0.0188440215,
0.0549922921,
0.0292392913,
-0.0276074558,
-0.0649506003,
0.0073266071,
-0.0154588204,
-0.017958479,
-0.0162448771,
-0.0083848378,
0.0204322133,
0.0063094427,
-0.0219521709,
-0.0375191867,
0.003823417,
-0.0462749265,
-0.0096605523,
-0.0538047403,
0.0712626874,
0.0461351909,
0.0415431261,
0.0259494614,
0.0072826175,
0.0096832775,
-0.0169578977,
-0.0359342881,
-0.0427240208,
-0.0208687373,
0.0103092371,
-0.0272577126,
-0.0093549257,
-0.0131548289,
-0.0072103967,
-0.0138236294,
0.0603166483,
0.0045876643,
-0.0349249542,
-0.0092277238,
-0.0076410524,
0.0402390882,
-0.0270014163,
0.0779149905,
0.0317165367,
0.0134441322,
0.052128803,
-0.0338175148,
0.0126846153,
-0.0486148521,
-0.0799658895,
-0.0102528222,
0.0506757908,
-0.0405270569,
0.0564693995,
0.0047597829,
0.0744838864,
-0.0281367004,
-0.0008643763,
-0.0191002674,
-0.0110884784,
-0.0833825618,
-0.0197214391,
-0.0622254983,
0.0464548059,
0.0204233546,
-0.040142227,
-0.0081453929,
0.0352807082,
-0.0012216223,
0.0341251418,
-0.0030187804,
0.0075476137,
-0.0038461613,
-0.015027835,
-0.015802864,
0.063763395,
-0.0121121937,
-0.0347567387,
-0.0146978041,
-0.0397112444,
-0.0028035119,
0.0146722244,
0.0217046756,
-0.0154652717,
-0.0250411406,
0.0414189622,
-0.0038932231,
-0.0564574264,
-0.0270165596,
0.0178012904,
-0.0306721833,
-0.0105121983,
-0.0056783408,
-0.039363157,
0.047623422,
-0.0225187391,
-0.0204153676,
0.0050441218,
0.0132046789,
-0.0188920293,
-0.0028626558,
0.0333256572,
-0.0381064452,
0.0046698176,
0.0306185894,
-0.0182633139,
-0.0112294881,
0.0542891212,
0.0754038841,
0.0081060277,
0.0372024663,
0.0076298793,
0.0100175757,
0.0629382581,
-0.0004063791,
-0.0139199458,
-0.0690089837,
0.0234205611,
-0.0322916582,
-0.0303735472,
-0.0062601911,
0.0416856892,
-0.0212846212,
-0.002080146,
0.0694698766,
0.0533492751,
-0.0246677492,
0.0243689511,
0.0073757777,
0.0200429577,
0.0386673994,
0.0311693139,
0.0249676555,
0.0087020779,
-0.0240087043,
-0.0314953513,
0.0095570302,
0.0109803192,
-0.0270737354,
-0.0292319153,
-0.0020960195,
-0.0075705582,
0.0265432317,
-0.0041171811,
0.0545316823,
-0.0345378369,
-0.0352959633,
0.0649306253,
-0.0200521313,
-0.0309349764,
-0.0123450141,
-0.0264742002,
0.0017971529,
0.0768572241,
0.0106859654,
-0.0456018075,
-0.0971291289,
-0.0352971256,
-0.0428122059,
0.052105777,
0.0167307816,
-0.0327974223,
0.0498785637,
-0.040589422,
-0.0120815551,
0.0209415201,
0.0226498041,
0.0254598539,
-0.0023502354,
-0.0343991518,
0.0003634372,
0.0372680239,
0.0459174328,
0.012408738,
0.0171028394,
-0.0191324297,
-0.0347889662,
0.0177290309,
0.0624682754,
0.053614039,
-0.0018523409,
-0.0079573737,
0.0128422938,
-0.0115895728,
-0.0101062832,
0.0471509844,
-0.0259190574,
-0.0812792107,
0.0402797535,
0.0080988435,
-0.0464019664,
0.03276667,
-0.0150665799,
-0.0789746121,
-0.0237599928,
-0.1056659296,
0.041408889,
-0.0631747767,
0.0124568697,
0.0183436945,
-0.0275187604,
-0.0172884986,
0.0326453149,
-0.0102413734,
-0.0165934004,
0.0300243292,
0.0029463666,
0.047035493,
-0.0716018528,
-0.0144162308,
0.023678612,
-0.0146636516,
-0.0150647834,
0.0283150822,
-0.0153771024,
-0.0421221331,
-0.0300206393,
-0.111524038,
0.0232484527,
-0.0216185991,
0.0215389803,
0.0253822859,
-0.0040967353,
-0.0207764823,
-0.015692465,
-0.0571543276,
-0.0585688539,
0.0063512921,
-0.0025729176,
0.0172482282,
0.0310273916,
-0.0462374203,
-0.0570389219,
0.0112643177,
-0.0369988009,
0.0174710695,
-0.0259254575,
-0.0777954906,
-0.0309301428,
-0.0291075818,
-0.0513678715,
0.0615244284,
-0.0028702703,
-0.0554377511,
0.0279889088,
0.0041028401,
0.0119843418,
0.0256788302,
0.017116297,
0.0388594195,
-0.012555507,
-0.0621688142,
-0.0476544946,
0.0670695454,
-0.0476860628,
0.0480378568,
-0.0312003996,
-0.0041542887,
0.0228695329,
0.0535205342,
0.0104813948,
0.0132115232,
-0.0954556242,
-0.0144383181,
0.0179135576,
-0.0313159823,
-0.019536186,
-0.0169259533,
-0.0628648177,
0.0446216837,
-0.0055963807,
-0.0367361642,
0.0854115337,
-0.0631090179,
-0.0222868994,
-0.0258999001,
0.0009869622,
-0.0284779314,
0.0393260457,
0.0076126587,
0.0210559182,
-0.035149578,
-0.0430666916,
-0.0053149671,
-0.0017710037,
-0.0094385073,
-0.0470146574,
0.0417366438,
-0.0455600433,
0.0418074206,
0.0214103479,
-0.0068331659,
-0.0575456619,
-0.0051190928,
-0.0023600534,
0.0341991968,
0.0165313203,
-0.0374682136,
0.0370384268,
0.0297945868,
0.0417802334,
0.0353596956,
-0.0052972152,
0.0247589126,
-0.0345093273,
0.0532035641,
0.0396907143,
0.0078802677,
-0.0202233884,
-0.0487420782,
0.0296433344,
0.0138851153,
0.0328603871,
-0.0003630622,
-0.0255741943,
-0.0005134274,
0.0055362699,
-0.024233304,
-0.0263657831,
-0.0043598777,
0.0385851972,
-0.0452967286,
-0.0009659097,
0.1103740856,
0.0388685539,
0.0086525874,
-0.0353057161,
-0.0161504596,
-0.0059296889,
-0.0010962832,
0.0159423407,
-0.0471758246,
-0.0071472926,
-0.0030426842,
0.0132159544,
-0.0158681832,
-0.0372330025,
-0.0206757169,
-0.0634797215,
-0.0021950726,
-0.0185703672,
-0.0574967898,
-0.0362118743,
-0.0107628694,
0.0347875804,
0.0090232622,
-0.0052762581,
-0.0040045069,
0.0512880348,
-0.0234757569,
0.0328349248,
-0.0525342077,
0.0014287741,
0.0182431526,
-0.0060109366,
0.0544793345,
0.072152786,
0.0343762636,
-0.0229771156,
0.0052192807,
-0.010818827,
0.0133147454,
-0.0193799306,
0.0146086728,
0.0234885365,
-0.0374173746,
-0.0269464627,
-0.0250400621,
0.0136033082,
-0.0052899001,
0.0089232745,
-0.0031159257,
0.0566236787,
-0.0447685383,
0.0485010892,
-0.0001264526,
0.0169104096,
-0.0246440414,
0.068909049,
0.038176395,
-0.0381055921,
0.0015264176,
-0.0139814503,
-0.0308830254,
-0.0354487002,
0.0139528411,
-0.0019203493,
0.0014887309,
-0.0274594128,
-0.1032866165,
-0.0246822983,
0.0513796657,
0.0393417478,
-0.0028873794,
-0.0128928851,
0.0519452207,
0.0268892497,
0.0234080497,
0.0473888367,
0.0052508041,
-0.0187385138,
-0.0415395163,
-0.0393275805,
0.0532451682,
0.0094813155,
-0.0149495341,
0.0444963165,
-0.0129025336,
-0.0641202107,
-0.0052920002,
0.0500594154,
0.0183623154,
0.0308191627,
-0.0142200477,
-0.0018651198,
-0.0342155658,
-0.0006943914,
0.0177937001,
-0.0314623341,
0.054828044,
0.0689776316,
-0.0357029028,
0.0391177684,
-0.0148360739,
0.0051531876,
-0.0390308015,
0.0536427982,
-0.0871539563,
-0.1118059084,
0.0192305725,
-0.0220603719,
0.0657335892,
0.0312803648,
-0.0116034374,
-0.0437759645,
0.0276480578,
0.000724298,
0.0068654343,
-0.1002058759,
0.0129747568,
-0.0266225561,
-0.0088774152,
-0.0134235974,
-0.0114690028,
-0.0221534446,
0.0266184546,
-0.0158311315,
-0.01860133,
-0.000788775,
-0.0326563343,
-0.0185354613,
-0.0134123312,
-0.0050956141,
0.0389867835,
0.0134721966,
-0.0053914846,
0.0114581026,
0.1116500124,
0.0191399902,
-0.0543028638,
0.041253753,
0.0115451133,
-0.0555775575,
-0.0438315086,
-0.0176139399,
0.0690547898,
0.0619194321,
-0.013526937,
0.027291622,
-0.0255160015,
0.0022950866,
0.0008575716,
0.0441187024,
0.0273853075,
0.0021189642,
0.0552202351,
0.0426832475,
-0.0055435528,
-0.0305808168,
0.055634737,
0.0239436682,
0.0298888665,
0.0051039793,
-0.0027503304,
-0.0493359491,
-0.047267057,
0.0609799512,
0.0569055602,
-0.0264880229,
0.0360520631,
-0.0323762707,
-0.0328287259,
0.0149526261,
0.0072300727,
0.0170233138,
-0.0156493392,
0.0661638305,
0.0109154806,
-0.043704953,
-0.0105135515,
-0.0366463959,
-0.0048629357,
0.0322008431,
0.0278335027,
0.0012930827,
-5.331441404e-33,
-0.0627507716,
-0.0088427719,
-0.0010938866,
0.0532030538,
-0.0421324894,
-0.0274796542,
-0.027215397,
0.0132704051,
-0.0014460481,
-0.0069138375,
0.0095503321,
0.0320505053,
0.0138845267,
0.0140491603,
-0.0402425863,
-0.0420622639,
0.0336291902,
0.0191752519,
-0.0044063907,
-0.0005311165,
0.0657467842,
0.0539989471,
0.0717463195,
-0.0817420706,
0.0165870953,
-0.0087003922,
0.0118532777,
0.0581259653,
0.0188130736,
0.0374364108,
-0.0043003475,
-0.0024517842,
0.0170938633,
-0.0435895622,
-0.0024594052,
0.0351338461,
0.0112567255,
-0.0183448624,
0.0482342206,
0.0380470045,
-0.0075225569,
0.0263032131,
0.0062304121,
-0.0021455598,
0.0258025713,
0.0425727069,
0.0255998112,
-0.0372492187,
-0.0190450456,
-0.0025639448,
-0.0248848647,
0.0480997898,
-0.0314120017,
-0.0577203184,
0.0418155715,
0.0631021559,
0.0374087133,
-0.0498192981,
-0.0092054168,
0.0036046945,
0.0097565949,
-0.0006521955,
0.041142337,
0.0342812575,
0.0120376032,
0.0795091093,
0.0281389449,
-0.003876566,
-0.0167133063,
-0.0511152707,
0.0133975064,
0.0421199985,
0.0619434267,
-0.0365665071,
-0.0393363088,
0.0350110978,
-0.0471194349,
0.0136351772,
0.0599365011,
0.0044823415,
-0.0051049273,
0.0123225329,
-0.0413603596,
0.0122293271,
-0.0093268994,
0.0286106225,
0.0045884992,
-0.0089157652,
0.0078438483,
-0.0043299762,
-0.0228443239,
0.0230290834,
0.0629965365,
-0.0182141289,
0.0302456226,
0.0156477746,
-0.0185536183,
0.0225574728,
-0.0016076964,
0.0409425236,
-0.0428456701,
-0.0297864899,
0.0005678497,
-0.0041568782,
0.01683685,
0.009425818,
-0.0085725682,
0.0064552347,
-0.0146193402,
-0.0018489506,
-0.0476571172,
0.006330607,
-0.0813864172,
0.0686101764,
0.0221505519,
-0.0039088442,
-0.0365451947,
0.0924045444,
0.002298563,
0.0054370323,
-0.0230822135,
-0.0348817483,
-0.0035631969,
0.0062032468,
-0.0152501892,
-0.025165936,
0.0032589885,
0.0204157569,
-0.0269655176,
-0.0240193922,
0.0193562191,
0.016570922,
2.403e-7,
0.0102486629,
0.0340090841,
0.0605627522,
-0.007704901,
0.0331525877,
0.0357517973,
-0.068821758,
0.0130431717,
0.0102343746,
-0.0582888201,
0.0176887363,
0.0187865496,
0.042542845,
0.0299310535,
-0.1079759076,
-0.0707706735,
-0.0465824418,
-0.0314288773,
-0.0458504856,
0.0403938405,
0.087365441,
0.0371380486,
0.0215837751,
0.0296184495,
0.0199662484,
0.0187795516,
0.0701394528,
-0.0135794217,
-0.0348024406,
0.0264683738,
0.0541974269,
0.005796995,
-0.0518361926,
0.0137150493,
0.0148782041,
0.0736023635,
0.0243100803,
0.1061850935,
0.0096471626,
-0.0426814631,
-0.0053672548,
0.0010553621,
-0.0158139467,
-0.0203449018,
0.0304137487,
-0.0295537617,
-0.0151759712,
-0.0136136729,
0.0061754179,
-0.0099931108,
0.0015501543,
0.001961001,
-0.0278545599,
0.009770277,
-0.0177357495,
-0.0490988046,
0.0056948443,
-0.0604826286,
-0.0024456033,
-0.0389670879,
-0.0862483904,
-0.0370855592,
-0.0293285381,
-0.0054189852,
-0.009370028,
-0.0228652582,
0.0023614117,
2.067424337e-34,
0.0295254141,
-0.0083426191,
-0.0062236236,
0.0398607701,
0.0166061278,
-0.0103310551,
0.0470824875,
-0.0091101015,
0.0295400117,
-0.0440071113,
-0.0093381545
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15614v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15614v1 | FreeAL: Towards Human-Free Active Learning in the Era of Large Language Models | 2023-11-27T08:23:08 | 2023-11-27T08:23:08 | Ruixuan Xiao, Yiwen Dong, Junbo Zhao, Runze Wu, Minmin Lin, Gang Chen, Haobo Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Collecting high-quality labeled data for model training is notoriously
time-consuming and labor-intensive for various NLP tasks. While copious
solutions, such as active learning for small language models (SLMs) and
prevalent in-context learning in the era of large language models (LLMs), have
been proposed and alleviate the labeling burden to some extent, their
performances are still subject to human intervention. It is still underexplored
how to reduce the annotation cost in the LLMs era. To bridge this, we
revolutionize traditional active learning and propose an innovative
collaborative learning framework FreeAL to interactively distill and filter the
task-specific knowledge from LLMs. During collaborative training, an LLM serves
as an active annotator inculcating its coarse-grained knowledge, while a
downstream SLM is incurred as a student to filter out high-quality in-context
samples to feedback LLM for the subsequent label refinery. Extensive
experiments on eight benchmark datasets demonstrate that FreeAL largely
enhances the zero-shot performances for both SLM and LLM without any human
supervision. The code is available at https://github.com/Justherozen/FreeAL . | [
0.0262391288,
0.044202432,
-0.0044006142,
0.0268582981,
-0.0160223823,
0.0435629375,
0.0072417906,
-0.0029053073,
0.0134894187,
-0.0759548992,
-0.0461146273,
0.0005155428,
-0.0514045283,
0.0206758976,
0.0227791276,
-0.0372133441,
0.0285333209,
-0.0176091623,
0.0412962995,
0.0001014455,
0.0101667671,
0.0108088925,
-0.0290905088,
0.0330820158,
-0.0152520873,
-0.0071393657,
0.0066615394,
-0.0053926539,
-0.0243566204,
-0.0216148887,
0.0342211016,
0.0696703345,
0.0035503786,
0.0497909263,
0.0000021382,
-0.0495645031,
-0.0223955158,
0.0031991005,
-0.0328219384,
0.0297847837,
0.012008518,
0.0239613913,
0.0089039681,
-0.0052396273,
-0.0660810322,
-0.037481118,
0.0444003567,
0.022748176,
0.0651828945,
0.0382234044,
-0.003510684,
0.0280043725,
-0.0083210263,
-0.0482021831,
0.0090375245,
-0.0680088028,
0.0228103586,
-0.0091235973,
-0.0101059694,
0.0261129756,
0.0117568616,
0.0630864576,
0.0175167285,
-0.0413231812,
0.0231273379,
0.032496687,
-0.0369174331,
-0.0720197558,
0.0045895553,
0.0744832903,
0.0132559603,
-0.0232440792,
0.0096023642,
-0.0531137288,
0.0067017754,
0.0278925691,
-0.0470046178,
0.0302312803,
-0.0181762967,
0.0338262208,
-0.0130656082,
-0.0388329402,
0.0380103178,
0.0116543686,
0.0460723229,
0.0235871635,
-0.0212093592,
-0.0280803088,
0.0595902093,
0.0525060445,
-0.0695175231,
-0.0253869761,
-0.0050443574,
0.0306274965,
-0.0393972285,
0.0023013428,
-0.0049943994,
-0.0349002331,
0.030241996,
-0.0621002354,
0.0367186628,
-0.0079536866,
-0.0021538623,
0.0487033203,
0.0071380385,
-0.0406212658,
0.0477235429,
0.0583470315,
-0.022284463,
-0.0156224724,
-0.071981281,
0.0065245819,
-0.0516028143,
0.0319943614,
-0.0208665356,
0.0100094751,
-0.0332432985,
0.0212231092,
-0.0397187136,
0.0183773842,
0.045839943,
0.0249059424,
-0.0420809686,
0.0370177664,
-0.0077515682,
0.0196911618,
-0.0188170169,
0.0048051733,
-0.012707415,
-0.0461220182,
0.0009873013,
0.0201530289,
0.006203148,
-0.0419072062,
0.0092282994,
0.0391464308,
-0.0032659052,
-0.0578932166,
-0.020684056,
0.0064971424,
0.0294403322,
-0.0513100922,
-0.0094648637,
-0.0492608137,
0.0013553149,
-0.0145784942,
0.0330634117,
-0.0763561279,
0.0045168786,
0.0322961211,
-0.0191115402,
0.0830944777,
-0.0524193048,
-0.0140465926,
0.0139997164,
0.0101725366,
-0.0232550111,
0.0900677741,
0.0134151271,
0.0105332285,
0.0698822141,
-0.0097100101,
-0.0085360296,
0.015537045,
0.0330146477,
0.0115313875,
-0.0215041488,
-0.0040493687,
0.0076319911,
-0.0158174131,
-0.0213265065,
0.019072203,
-0.0052389493,
0.0333733112,
0.0708643347,
-0.0013985115,
0.001249503,
-0.0277814809,
0.0576661266,
0.0360587537,
0.0341800824,
-0.0287004616,
-0.0446074605,
0.0087582432,
-0.0031029521,
-0.0157597978,
-0.0129277259,
0.0118142962,
-0.0277187433,
-0.0539700314,
-0.0397724472,
-0.0356825031,
-0.0140212737,
0.0536671765,
0.0492103957,
0.0485120341,
0.0165109262,
0.0698413104,
0.0746585503,
-0.0245557874,
-0.0039669219,
-0.0321013108,
0.0439886004,
0.0017395014,
0.030877484,
-0.0496412404,
-0.0493567362,
-0.0246634986,
0.0396759808,
0.0182209983,
0.0414905958,
-0.0625484362,
0.0203087367,
-0.0437922701,
-0.0356852114,
0.0117084309,
0.0355064981,
-0.0422697477,
0.0461308844,
-0.0328863822,
-0.005248996,
-0.0340764821,
-0.0398168005,
0.0506688617,
-0.0363404267,
-0.0686169267,
-0.0113530112,
0.002498854,
0.0253540073,
0.0147491219,
0.0031056155,
-0.0125848101,
0.0629943013,
-0.0159031674,
-0.0034643908,
-0.0035980591,
0.0027375098,
-0.0094479658,
0.0202390142,
0.0070865485,
-0.055152908,
0.0197695643,
-0.0559694953,
-0.009141244,
-0.0432028323,
-0.0138822794,
-0.0031796733,
-0.0655678064,
-0.0090927798,
0.0068546063,
0.0123386905,
-0.071377039,
0.0672687739,
-0.0017700837,
0.0072872178,
0.0190004054,
-0.0034646543,
-0.021303378,
-0.0117562814,
-0.0281372964,
0.0102896327,
0.0013591785,
0.0062211147,
0.0034911386,
0.0631121024,
-0.059453439,
0.0217250586,
-0.0653038844,
0.0096694455,
-0.0247651879,
-0.009555622,
0.0294452906,
0.0343287811,
-0.0025904654,
-0.0221932083,
0.0012744394,
0.0118900146,
-0.0112107797,
0.0302347764,
0.0123467622,
0.0231355764,
0.0204656664,
-0.0500704683,
-0.003661572,
0.0089345183,
0.0254165474,
0.0266652666,
-0.0261853412,
-0.0258109495,
0.0058358787,
-0.01354877,
0.0213451926,
0.0330455452,
0.0131789297,
0.001029072,
-0.0388366468,
-0.0333919562,
0.0494771972,
-0.0222333055,
0.0730067044,
0.0495370217,
0.0045633344,
-0.0619123057,
0.0309310835,
-0.042924881,
-0.0153838852,
-0.0174967218,
-0.0048585092,
-0.0152775804,
0.1016935408,
-0.0433537886,
-0.0072669694,
-0.0410661213,
0.0266849678,
-0.0485017225,
-0.0441566929,
-0.0498780347,
0.0519926436,
-0.0298275892,
0.0088072745,
-0.0296163093,
-0.0517218225,
0.0571067221,
-0.0022441058,
-0.0355393142,
-0.0455622599,
-0.0136396103,
-0.02868733,
0.0451476872,
0.0136005376,
-0.0040212306,
0.0180621259,
-0.006598202,
-0.0239079762,
-0.0123133399,
0.0291706733,
-0.0063351188,
0.0169271901,
-0.0514361598,
0.0306294877,
-0.0026493191,
-0.023736449,
-0.0382960998,
-0.029207835,
-0.0371484868,
0.0457338169,
-0.0090434365,
0.0003911623,
0.0117018018,
0.0011031212,
-0.0027923314,
0.0391891859,
0.0153868785,
-0.0263184421,
-0.0307977423,
0.0311652496,
0.0445483439,
-0.0154407267,
-0.0304373596,
-0.0373325273,
-0.0046187462,
0.074864462,
0.0514017306,
-0.0099529037,
0.0100715002,
-0.0040363586,
0.0526090376,
-0.036738988,
-0.0022374082,
0.0061113136,
0.0409717597,
-0.0268450808,
-0.0442472994,
0.1202073693,
0.0367385,
-0.0874761119,
0.0140071725,
0.0030601064,
0.0400812961,
0.0442210175,
0.0259695258,
-0.0432481542,
-0.0529946983,
0.0038628092,
0.0675474629,
0.028582627,
-0.0547001995,
-0.0091977734,
-0.0996097848,
0.0347209387,
-0.0158260781,
-0.0386665687,
0.0382371247,
-0.0677820146,
0.0108965859,
-0.0504052639,
0.0132407006,
-0.0245357938,
-0.0119352154,
0.026049789,
0.068501763,
0.0056125573,
-0.0608845651,
0.0108220074,
-0.0473430306,
0.0674936026,
0.0221522395,
0.0341458097,
0.0216799527,
-0.0149902496,
0.0622338243,
-0.0227447767,
-0.0140501494,
-0.0504354574,
0.0594261214,
-0.0172239691,
-0.0089516891,
0.0187019221,
0.018734768,
-0.0409236364,
-0.0245911684,
0.009617541,
0.0720701218,
-0.0039012209,
0.0246732198,
0.0064527099,
-0.0057401783,
0.0334069878,
0.0566418543,
0.0401999876,
-0.0421094224,
-0.0095824245,
0.0059421784,
-0.0077584386,
-0.0222633593,
-0.0466622934,
0.0294417124,
-0.0542498343,
-0.040889632,
-0.0503901653,
-0.0776125342,
0.095975183,
0.0757035241,
0.0167764854,
0.0378997289,
-0.0109182401,
0.0142495865,
-0.0436644219,
0.0455361977,
-0.0679279789,
0.025382828,
-0.0322201997,
-0.0961291417,
0.0042859865,
0.0051984545,
-0.0142315002,
0.0273133628,
-0.092576623,
-0.0565445162,
0.0382966399,
0.0643641353,
0.0313705802,
0.0643927455,
-0.0281766374,
-0.0656767115,
0.004517925,
0.0406748056,
-0.026292149,
0.0030221466,
0.0351680182,
-0.0376267247,
0.022722749,
0.0433134288,
-0.048050601,
0.005149377,
0.0464068092,
0.0563878976,
-0.0305511188,
-0.0427695774,
0.0224783737,
0.0118732061,
0.0967691913,
-0.0221244022,
-0.031916555,
-0.0401883498,
-0.0024011747,
0.0131701408,
-0.0294961184,
-0.059136413,
0.0213145576,
0.0017782246,
0.0232954305,
-0.01620345,
0.0575120114,
0.0261680949,
0.0783374831,
-0.0250380952,
0.024010621,
0.0361705534,
-0.0189097878,
0.0154518848,
0.0203604922,
0.002657224,
0.0165399686,
0.0173057448,
0.0482781604,
-0.0138025405,
0.0507890582,
0.0180129576,
0.0379883759,
-0.0148769841,
0.0356529728,
-0.058000192,
-0.039111834,
-0.0365236178,
0.0440905988,
0.0734500587,
-0.0491184071,
0.0674715564,
-0.0269184373,
-0.0163113941,
0.0016430642,
0.0162343793,
-0.0038806114,
-0.0454896241,
0.0058058812,
0.0234000385,
-0.0126133012,
0.0210166927,
0.1010868698,
0.0200855378,
0.0564954989,
-0.0215718113,
0.011675234,
-0.052472841,
0.0020412121,
0.0404740833,
0.00373516,
-0.0302326661,
0.0058216639,
-0.029294081,
-0.0868906304,
-0.0161375869,
-0.0411377102,
-0.025799064,
0.0066110422,
0.0589458682,
0.0487646088,
0.0086917318,
0.0024466615,
-0.063038297,
0.0010168817,
0.0600913763,
-0.0119887358,
0.0025574674,
-6.858656154e-33,
-0.039812576,
-0.0281076171,
-0.000788988,
0.0157646053,
0.0175756663,
0.0243103374,
-0.0285289343,
-0.0084106643,
0.0126409652,
0.0161329005,
-0.0047797477,
-0.0129717141,
0.0211978331,
0.0182823762,
0.0144581795,
-0.0275754128,
0.0465156958,
-0.0088041108,
-0.0065561319,
0.0258960072,
0.0109044369,
0.0616949424,
0.0374996662,
-0.0855665207,
0.0598211102,
0.007150339,
-0.0167791527,
0.0373887494,
-0.0136497607,
0.0416257903,
-0.0062850127,
0.0376609527,
0.0039600004,
-0.0304188263,
-0.0092037488,
-0.0288899094,
-0.1114133373,
-0.0124366349,
-0.0005161185,
0.0254119374,
-0.0441563949,
0.0135374619,
0.014865458,
-0.0079697287,
0.0079251025,
0.0246301312,
0.0451395735,
-0.009183567,
-0.0618435442,
-0.0239519645,
-0.048411645,
0.0085904421,
-0.0136627583,
-0.0050213314,
0.0366939679,
-0.0048518912,
-0.0094093932,
0.0011779333,
-0.0475028045,
-0.0137440935,
-0.0310843587,
0.0326690935,
0.0265853796,
0.0277377833,
0.0026649269,
0.0434279181,
0.0346356854,
-0.0000518698,
-0.0088974386,
0.0104178218,
0.0190181155,
0.0326003097,
0.019231895,
0.0305723324,
0.0197534338,
0.0112676704,
-0.0294873305,
0.0219271835,
0.042975381,
0.0062283361,
-0.0042585679,
0.0365840755,
-0.0187799223,
-0.0312363412,
-0.0209835228,
-0.0050095995,
-0.0262999218,
-0.0145308208,
0.0248271134,
0.0224721096,
-0.0729993358,
0.0044708368,
-0.0024520766,
-0.0301236901,
-0.0167528726,
-0.0226701256,
0.0243161023,
0.0083039301,
-0.0160866734,
-0.0309608951,
-0.0793394744,
-0.0454512164,
-0.0043159002,
-0.0116839269,
0.0238263607,
0.0138578014,
0.0782715827,
0.0281945989,
-0.0268330798,
-0.0045359312,
-0.0540175475,
0.0428610742,
0.003514271,
0.0585401654,
0.0299149919,
0.0024164782,
-0.0305432007,
0.0663600415,
0.0551933423,
-0.0164818279,
-0.0227077212,
-0.0172486678,
-0.0126572205,
-0.0240558963,
-0.0225330871,
-0.0269860886,
-0.0223545954,
0.0025907175,
0.0216146614,
-0.0724588707,
0.0030336368,
-0.0419561155,
2.771e-7,
0.0440517962,
0.0739199817,
-0.0245938301,
-0.0156504195,
0.0204492863,
0.049882181,
-0.0364955589,
0.003905101,
0.0215934329,
-0.0113065084,
-0.0027621223,
0.0242743865,
0.0435631461,
0.0481350757,
-0.1033119485,
-0.0426091552,
-0.0725506395,
0.0214349236,
-0.0223333817,
0.0062804865,
-0.0064972071,
0.0708418116,
0.0559551828,
-0.0349149592,
-0.0154681467,
-0.0670924857,
0.0356769264,
-0.026367154,
0.0048365425,
0.0080894874,
0.0340869986,
-0.0107117537,
0.0176010877,
0.0123603167,
-0.0472180508,
-0.0367149264,
0.0204801355,
0.0716551766,
-0.0083899982,
-0.023479566,
-0.0001694739,
-0.0082464973,
0.038511768,
-0.0101149082,
0.0827212259,
-0.0478457808,
-0.0523245819,
0.0038303779,
-0.010150075,
-0.0155740427,
-0.0175642967,
0.0021979413,
-0.0068352805,
0.0169200096,
-0.0048706285,
0.0006514299,
-0.0809845552,
-0.0722070485,
-0.0421321094,
-0.065049924,
-0.023249099,
-0.0449569635,
-0.0295635872,
0.0191887952,
-0.0358392633,
-0.0300830081,
0.0147584667,
2.585536559e-34,
0.0207662191,
0.0333678089,
0.0167412143,
0.0497017652,
-0.0023534121,
-0.0070326533,
-0.0046405918,
0.0113144983,
-0.0115892394,
-0.0225922782,
0.002324048
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03726v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03726v1 | Interpretation modeling: Social grounding of sentences by reasoning over their implicit moral judgments | 2023-11-27T07:50:55 | 2023-11-27T07:50:55 | Liesbeth Allein, Maria Mihaela Truşcǎ, Marie-Francine Moens | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The social and implicit nature of human communication ramifies readers'
understandings of written sentences. Single gold-standard interpretations
rarely exist, challenging conventional assumptions in natural language
processing. This work introduces the interpretation modeling (IM) task which
involves modeling several interpretations of a sentence's underlying semantics
to unearth layers of implicit meaning. To obtain these, IM is guided by
multiple annotations of social relation and common ground - in this work
approximated by reader attitudes towards the author and their understanding of
moral judgments subtly embedded in the sentence. We propose a number of
modeling strategies that rely on one-to-one and one-to-many generation methods
that take inspiration from the philosophical study of interpretation. A
first-of-its-kind IM dataset is curated to support experiments and analyses.
The modeling results, coupled with scrutiny of the dataset, underline the
challenges of IM as conflicting and complex interpretations are socially
plausible. This interplay of diverse readings is affirmed by automated and
human evaluations on the generated interpretations. Finally, toxicity analyses
in the generated interpretations demonstrate the importance of IM for refining
filters of content and assisting content moderators in safeguarding the safety
in online discourse. | [
0.0739000365,
0.0484365076,
-0.0286360532,
0.0394772701,
-0.0327349678,
0.0112248771,
0.0202401746,
-0.0208873618,
0.0291037224,
-0.046186544,
-0.0572061911,
0.0108355153,
-0.0039833849,
-0.0018596726,
-0.0028200219,
-0.0269108322,
0.0194991603,
0.0390214249,
0.0268266108,
0.0027098814,
0.043051146,
0.0687782764,
0.053210821,
0.022994522,
0.0124063892,
-0.0363387205,
0.0165370051,
0.0212738886,
0.0399337448,
-0.0330938473,
-0.0055749891,
0.0424386002,
0.0323243216,
0.0369341671,
0.0000019044,
-0.0270570777,
-0.0133005343,
0.0028654931,
-0.0045852675,
0.0208880007,
0.0406308547,
-0.0177780762,
0.0257534944,
-0.0080378465,
-0.0524329357,
0.0420923196,
0.0031878285,
0.0346988402,
0.0621444546,
0.0455926657,
-0.0152197881,
-0.0188630968,
-0.0306022018,
0.0064993082,
-0.0142595861,
-0.0261613429,
0.0440973006,
0.0570981689,
-0.066808112,
0.0354657881,
0.0008219676,
0.0292939134,
0.0131035354,
-0.0171848424,
0.0004904747,
-0.0340951644,
0.0225106347,
-0.0436218418,
-0.0181585792,
0.0503713228,
0.0527589768,
-0.0268213153,
0.0130045796,
-0.0056481245,
-0.012396195,
0.0545480624,
0.0150346318,
0.0467793904,
-0.0448754989,
0.0124584436,
0.0161776766,
0.0420851372,
0.007611203,
0.0560122691,
0.0380618498,
0.0248216558,
-0.0448306352,
-0.005694523,
0.0023687314,
0.0185425989,
-0.0606846064,
-0.001767622,
0.0549588278,
-0.0032537421,
0.0083314208,
0.0480303206,
-0.033471562,
-0.0264324844,
0.0541021079,
-0.0996840894,
0.0537165403,
0.0159565825,
-0.0098015927,
0.0404470637,
0.0272274353,
-0.0325940363,
-0.0103948032,
0.005211893,
-0.022133939,
0.0201187078,
0.0142674912,
-0.0017910728,
-0.015098379,
0.0486342572,
-0.0193104148,
0.0359964073,
-0.0525386222,
-0.0082051605,
-0.0529366434,
-0.0413668118,
-0.0058580856,
0.0131308241,
-0.050078027,
0.0221030451,
-0.0269122235,
-0.0014716387,
-0.0668046921,
0.042108167,
-0.0696210936,
-0.0249782614,
0.026320653,
-0.0166654363,
-0.0069985073,
-0.0055920519,
-0.0072362893,
0.0957630053,
0.018576432,
-0.0010868845,
-0.0423176289,
-0.0988935605,
-0.0367142409,
-0.021314811,
-0.0413074046,
-0.0117081711,
0.0471840799,
0.014801098,
-0.0122843729,
-0.0745479763,
0.015167553,
0.0291096643,
-0.0303378012,
0.034642145,
0.0407248996,
0.0047898488,
0.0162553284,
0.0476375856,
-0.0371393412,
0.0412982628,
0.0143027175,
0.0342912003,
0.034201473,
0.0412178561,
-0.020032702,
0.00014491,
0.0327674672,
-0.0174525622,
0.0010587847,
0.0203402098,
-0.0422813594,
-0.0018109876,
-0.0113423057,
0.0451904535,
-0.0355211832,
-0.0471079201,
0.0331437066,
0.0738457218,
-0.0390078612,
0.0449853726,
0.0569744147,
0.0266549345,
0.0216316879,
0.0240854025,
-0.0322975703,
-0.003280316,
0.007533168,
-0.0809382647,
-0.0469349138,
0.0349135622,
0.0146185057,
-0.0332852602,
0.0031825299,
0.0175442528,
0.0509794392,
-0.0110972747,
0.0224767365,
0.0010707165,
-0.0229020268,
-0.0271157268,
0.0461004414,
-0.0596222654,
0.0187568236,
-0.0026070003,
0.0325579084,
0.0699525848,
0.0438246578,
0.0013957698,
0.0016181513,
-0.0477896817,
0.0175625589,
0.0310619082,
0.0099900784,
-0.023956744,
-0.0153893009,
-0.0255712867,
-0.0357164703,
0.0023996399,
-0.0035224482,
0.0304444637,
-0.0149400821,
-0.012222087,
0.0277834553,
0.0223547798,
-0.0290853232,
0.0323619135,
0.0020328416,
0.022690719,
-0.0448942631,
0.0344108865,
0.0159807932,
0.0318640843,
-0.00991478,
-0.0428180471,
0.0185724795,
-0.0187160913,
-0.0100511229,
0.0319956876,
-0.0539523549,
0.013125632,
-0.0034431713,
-0.1187194139,
-0.0561665185,
-0.0017165206,
-0.0174291097,
0.0343733244,
-0.0077471146,
-0.0475786515,
-0.0080657573,
-0.0550778359,
-0.0446370952,
-0.0510085337,
-0.029581042,
-0.0219717324,
0.066080071,
-0.0196698811,
-0.0184441786,
-0.0055611841,
-0.0578175597,
0.0359719619,
0.0035888345,
-0.0141408509,
-0.0795456246,
-0.0120232925,
0.0024479043,
0.0369628109,
0.0074868002,
-0.0446064845,
-0.0201859679,
-0.0601307899,
-0.0277075358,
0.0079458002,
0.0075915307,
0.0448136516,
-0.0194468796,
0.0200750176,
0.0266252309,
-0.0073099933,
-0.0076851635,
-0.0335594788,
-0.0135176778,
0.0370262191,
-0.0339261442,
-0.0045437412,
0.0022314906,
0.008398761,
-0.0761388093,
0.064038597,
0.0430392213,
-0.0382362716,
-0.0123094702,
0.0088501871,
-0.0767707154,
-0.0201422404,
0.0012545686,
-0.0486113057,
0.00379319,
0.045394171,
0.0046907053,
0.052223891,
0.0426105298,
0.081056267,
0.0129925944,
0.0318851247,
-0.0465985574,
-0.0356914699,
-0.0055971574,
0.024341749,
-0.0052057221,
-0.0863715038,
-0.0341852531,
0.0545133725,
0.0443529449,
-0.0109020136,
-0.0498766378,
0.07193546,
-0.0712221414,
-0.074486725,
-0.0376349203,
-0.0745623112,
0.0190383866,
0.0322227478,
-0.0384383798,
-0.0324873701,
0.0735500827,
0.0474367514,
0.0418091305,
-0.0187445935,
0.0178287849,
-0.010193849,
0.0698418319,
-0.021091437,
0.0475276858,
0.0157615896,
-0.0146679506,
-0.0050114035,
-0.029637197,
0.0816244781,
-0.0329122581,
0.0386009477,
-0.0259610936,
0.0091569545,
0.0414959304,
-0.0243800934,
-0.0279921759,
-0.0722866729,
-0.0281896219,
-0.0524898916,
0.0027339677,
0.0303922128,
0.0339252502,
0.0107814875,
0.0023831644,
-0.0658824071,
0.0006195949,
-0.0134995207,
-0.0044408292,
-0.0168907456,
0.0182147212,
-0.0494174175,
0.0446989015,
-0.0240081977,
0.0168510489,
0.0775976703,
-0.0534874722,
-0.02110916,
-0.0042926525,
0.0340807028,
-0.0253392775,
0.0058873789,
0.0100705335,
-0.0189526677,
0.0363652036,
-0.0434215479,
0.0195928309,
0.0646147132,
0.0234597549,
-0.0369278677,
0.0359508954,
-0.0218383409,
-0.0342792608,
0.0098818485,
-0.0091572972,
-0.0968807265,
-0.0023994837,
-0.0409155414,
0.0045969924,
-0.0770804137,
-0.0841394812,
0.0086925356,
-0.0270256586,
0.0211540814,
0.0212689899,
-0.0097770328,
0.0021642835,
-0.0348322727,
-0.0005904149,
-0.0056372751,
0.0035356379,
0.0177435447,
0.0137849487,
-0.005757167,
-0.02665581,
0.053008832,
0.0165115241,
0.0572628155,
-0.0161058474,
0.0235950947,
0.0157892555,
0.0579476953,
-0.0032478089,
0.0106531512,
0.0061469022,
0.024899913,
-0.0104502384,
-0.0035407424,
0.0031517548,
-0.0311221778,
0.0154263256,
-0.0755412281,
0.0583604202,
-0.0023954753,
-0.0406853482,
-0.0111298589,
0.0472079106,
0.0052796295,
-0.0519702509,
-0.0369591415,
0.0464730449,
0.0194210168,
0.0828260332,
0.0262740999,
-0.0151166068,
0.0006878575,
-0.0281586293,
0.0039514164,
-0.0229363628,
-0.0507303327,
0.0021000826,
-0.0342937745,
-0.035911601,
-0.0340073481,
-0.0485581644,
-0.0123007083,
-0.0106135495,
0.0470098592,
-0.0385023728,
0.0719229728,
-0.0018227815,
-0.0227854736,
0.024271505,
-0.0156257674,
-0.0052908161,
0.0676677525,
0.0134610133,
0.0107038105,
-0.0157948509,
-0.0218264218,
0.03605216,
-0.0054091634,
-0.0272479784,
0.0318376385,
0.0271357596,
0.0160023253,
0.041106306,
-0.0012982511,
0.0028507796,
0.0285906047,
0.0276097078,
-0.0621969476,
0.0545064136,
0.0241055768,
0.0654746145,
-0.0016278346,
0.0356837846,
-0.012685189,
0.0304839797,
0.0123596117,
-0.015855331,
-0.0319601223,
0.014237727,
0.0287232101,
0.0088664023,
-0.0274801161,
0.0074908449,
-0.0182264894,
-0.0280191861,
-0.0333962105,
-0.0501871258,
-0.0439474583,
-0.0317615569,
0.0065630921,
0.0062165181,
-0.0401428752,
-0.0676283315,
-0.0076391851,
-0.0531670265,
0.0596469939,
-0.0265791267,
0.0242289379,
0.0574959442,
0.0179554038,
-0.0277308486,
-0.031034654,
-0.044912722,
0.0297081247,
-0.040024139,
0.0154949594,
0.0053476016,
0.0335473008,
0.0351623744,
0.0248945728,
-0.0168693084,
-0.003244159,
-0.0476791784,
0.0147448089,
-0.0322453566,
0.0026366259,
-0.0018399762,
0.0300394893,
0.064069137,
0.00016743,
-0.0001994562,
0.0105794054,
0.071749121,
-0.0224370603,
-0.0558288135,
0.003359485,
0.0241078939,
-0.0135810561,
0.0088018347,
0.0444775969,
-0.085350275,
0.054108385,
0.0328242406,
-0.0730683506,
-0.0327490233,
-0.0286261961,
0.0389304087,
0.0064832559,
0.0058918465,
0.0068951929,
-0.0886936635,
-0.0390012152,
0.0119586149,
0.0257650353,
0.0489851721,
-0.0194688234,
-0.0079464158,
0.0885986984,
0.009824736,
-0.0120109357,
-0.0182746612,
0.0519674271,
-0.0509687103,
-0.019944137,
-0.0618761368,
-5.542376886e-33,
-0.0373590291,
-0.0480216481,
-0.0398504511,
0.025953019,
-0.0351798609,
0.0151333027,
-0.0133134983,
-0.001808721,
-0.0087493071,
0.0610330142,
0.013821329,
0.0413895845,
0.0063053728,
-0.0134719182,
0.0072942493,
-0.0384393185,
0.0322806165,
-0.0185588617,
-0.0115040364,
0.0306101926,
0.0190739594,
-0.0064794216,
0.0329550765,
-0.1002313495,
0.0636384711,
-0.000890129,
-0.0353833325,
-0.0046205604,
-0.0218306333,
0.0370555036,
0.0000254946,
0.0504609272,
0.0352940932,
0.0246777218,
0.0176762324,
0.0325305536,
-0.0675661117,
-0.0107325688,
0.0621924438,
0.0116774905,
-0.057474982,
-0.0301193018,
0.0524128117,
-0.0189468246,
-0.0165212434,
-0.0286648143,
0.061510805,
-0.0138328383,
0.0272365771,
-0.0741140246,
-0.0475248285,
0.0031607228,
-0.0448493622,
-0.0126104457,
-0.0280548185,
0.0428812243,
-0.0084427493,
0.0217293687,
-0.0218240619,
0.0098054931,
-0.0262819789,
-0.0353435166,
-0.0149266021,
-0.0515902862,
0.0334724113,
0.0769805014,
-0.0220906194,
0.0156859029,
-0.0656062737,
-0.0094842343,
0.010870208,
-0.0002343233,
-0.0234752335,
0.0697188303,
-0.0132805202,
-0.0220345203,
-0.1014213711,
0.0006068118,
0.0646377206,
0.002402517,
0.0476168506,
-0.0416324437,
-0.0314256661,
-0.0040965164,
-0.0465241894,
-0.0847615153,
-0.0231500808,
-0.0306784231,
0.003753827,
-0.0346516818,
-0.0797185823,
-0.0267702546,
0.0027555875,
-0.0785840079,
0.0113746757,
0.0085241068,
0.0199062079,
-0.0128079578,
0.0114998175,
0.0335386209,
0.0022695754,
-0.0198816396,
-0.01848533,
-0.0219362956,
0.0542170107,
-0.003142406,
0.059062507,
-0.0119381137,
0.0261716433,
-0.017147718,
-0.0087435953,
-0.0021147639,
-0.0056426297,
0.0057950476,
0.0364000723,
0.0634354502,
-0.0092925383,
-0.0107504008,
0.0544452704,
0.0516671948,
0.0013685222,
0.0039020206,
-0.0118742734,
0.0275734328,
-0.0483437218,
-0.020669749,
0.0013903278,
-0.0138470661,
0.0416464396,
-0.0470081158,
-0.0261247773,
-0.0079953037,
2.641e-7,
0.0709998012,
0.0364694931,
0.0208890419,
0.0387602933,
-0.0112529136,
0.0327243097,
0.0744830519,
0.0731137097,
0.0039244955,
-0.072571367,
0.017071344,
0.0181010365,
0.022886809,
0.0283835623,
-0.0006014374,
0.0153771713,
-0.0333106779,
0.0047986573,
-0.0117500117,
0.0443484783,
0.0735941306,
0.045358371,
0.0204807147,
-0.0010559858,
-0.002726889,
0.0307190251,
0.0425394662,
-0.033152312,
-0.0164481122,
0.0060888701,
0.0123608802,
-0.0452214926,
0.0109412745,
0.0330106504,
0.0337431766,
-0.0095425555,
0.0371958725,
0.063242957,
-0.024230795,
-0.01901168,
-0.0050052395,
-0.0377557799,
-0.0024442191,
-0.0237182286,
0.033777386,
-0.0561625473,
-0.044096455,
-0.0073622866,
-0.0191177577,
-0.0328883901,
0.0116704172,
0.0072226725,
-0.0295926165,
0.0138642853,
0.024036482,
-0.0249292366,
0.0137242367,
-0.0319025218,
-0.0019145308,
-0.0420633927,
0.0014494645,
-0.070644632,
0.0140565298,
0.0260647275,
0.0158632006,
-0.0639199167,
0.0069307107,
2.085017722e-34,
0.028261818,
-0.0352265947,
0.0240705423,
-0.0071758563,
0.0476924889,
0.0175195169,
-0.0208333898,
-0.0014749129,
0.0308230277,
-0.0377845466,
-0.0269848574
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15596v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15596v2 | EgoThink: Evaluating First-Person Perspective Thinking Capability of Vision-Language Models | 2023-11-27T07:44:25 | 2024-03-28T11:35:55 | Sijie Cheng, Zhicheng Guo, Jingwen Wu, Kechen Fang, Peng Li, Huaping Liu, Yang Liu | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Vision-language models (VLMs) have recently shown promising results in
traditional downstream tasks. Evaluation studies have emerged to assess their
abilities, with the majority focusing on the third-person perspective, and only
a few addressing specific tasks from the first-person perspective. However, the
capability of VLMs to "think" from a first-person perspective, a crucial
attribute for advancing autonomous agents and robotics, remains largely
unexplored. To bridge this research gap, we introduce EgoThink, a novel visual
question-answering benchmark that encompasses six core capabilities with twelve
detailed dimensions. The benchmark is constructed using selected clips from
egocentric videos, with manually annotated question-answer pairs containing
first-person information. To comprehensively assess VLMs, we evaluate eighteen
popular VLMs on EgoThink. Moreover, given the open-ended format of the answers,
we use GPT-4 as the automatic judge to compute single-answer grading.
Experimental results indicate that although GPT-4V leads in numerous
dimensions, all evaluated VLMs still possess considerable potential for
improvement in first-person perspective tasks. Meanwhile, enlarging the number
of trainable parameters has the most significant impact on model performance on
EgoThink. In conclusion, EgoThink serves as a valuable addition to existing
evaluation benchmarks for VLMs, providing an indispensable resource for future
research in the realm of embodied artificial intelligence and robotics. | [
0.0404583365,
0.0389274023,
-0.0124889715,
0.0440454893,
-0.0217691548,
0.0107978592,
0.0017737387,
-0.0167917814,
0.013625945,
-0.0675332099,
-0.0429167524,
-0.0520870052,
0.0072695054,
0.0301131494,
0.0363523886,
-0.0623896159,
0.0189252216,
-0.0511415005,
-0.0034542794,
0.0181492846,
0.0086007137,
-0.017138157,
-0.0215397682,
0.0414584726,
-0.0172351431,
0.0030359251,
0.0026967486,
0.0034445527,
0.041908145,
-0.0462019853,
-0.0187507346,
0.0329029746,
0.0306839347,
-0.0446055084,
0.0000021261,
-0.0252970066,
0.0271361247,
-0.03338404,
0.0340402946,
-0.0222049709,
0.0020196403,
0.0064910548,
0.0380302593,
0.0200122613,
-0.0823833942,
-0.0328081287,
0.0094744153,
0.0427927263,
0.0785645992,
0.0243335478,
-0.0128889512,
-0.0109657757,
-0.0068655037,
-0.0087618222,
0.0247413013,
-0.0270640124,
0.0212106537,
0.0103935692,
-0.0032601974,
-0.0096657369,
-0.0669817999,
0.0421805196,
0.0568535104,
-0.0049800561,
0.0028770685,
0.0497904159,
-0.0309166145,
-0.0307920221,
-0.0188004039,
0.0856848583,
0.0354219563,
-0.0162119139,
-0.0204915497,
-0.0047740093,
0.0338010788,
-0.0261798892,
-0.0369559936,
0.0476696715,
-0.0010256406,
-0.0106879212,
-0.0779968351,
0.0566061623,
-0.0236463938,
0.0053735478,
0.0115279388,
0.025466444,
0.007336827,
0.0138922958,
0.0320799313,
0.0197343212,
-0.0034319651,
-0.0521499291,
-0.0432734229,
0.0361567326,
0.0255181435,
-0.0079040816,
-0.0460668765,
0.0386925563,
-0.030803008,
-0.0277450383,
0.0615357235,
0.0277690254,
-0.0089345565,
0.0332073122,
0.0011226587,
0.0739740729,
0.010807544,
0.0446254387,
-0.0326095112,
-0.0007304961,
-0.0422748215,
-0.0142254876,
-0.0513395369,
-0.015139427,
-0.021889478,
-0.0440028682,
-0.0250124764,
0.0124670854,
-0.0285882298,
-0.0337555185,
-0.023559548,
0.0621792376,
0.0250662379,
-0.0194860697,
-0.0557615459,
0.0147201726,
-0.0301670656,
0.0133682415,
-0.0110433912,
-0.0915717259,
-0.0058284001,
0.0351484865,
-0.014310468,
-0.0069928891,
-0.0155474208,
0.0642760694,
0.0042779166,
-0.045834545,
0.0346984752,
-0.0001002339,
-0.0114040412,
-0.0400417037,
0.0228790436,
-0.0596677177,
0.0238716938,
-0.0281253122,
0.0051275222,
-0.029681975,
0.0318577886,
0.0122462604,
0.0146228774,
0.0651603416,
0.0022019939,
0.0302718934,
0.0136843864,
0.0181404203,
0.0279864985,
0.0454368554,
0.0333810188,
0.0069942744,
0.0118486946,
-0.0033447049,
0.0612894371,
0.0200847853,
-0.0213565622,
0.0101210661,
-0.0406418182,
0.0471324474,
-0.0202485938,
0.047427915,
-0.0013109567,
0.0384199917,
-0.0074851979,
-0.0422407985,
0.0655049533,
0.0517266467,
-0.0485681109,
-0.0514882356,
0.0356950387,
0.0077541121,
0.038369894,
-0.0306092538,
-0.0335911736,
0.0841639116,
0.0282539912,
-0.0195827056,
-0.0122825224,
0.0118268644,
-0.0476705432,
-0.0573677719,
-0.0108232684,
0.0122776218,
-0.0112212682,
0.0317240916,
0.016249828,
0.0239084531,
-0.0122394999,
-0.0001598919,
-0.0217644945,
-0.0511430055,
0.0026740409,
-0.0308044869,
-0.0039361231,
0.0296228752,
0.0295160487,
-0.0029743321,
-0.0280322526,
-0.0054743565,
0.0496639088,
0.0437162369,
0.0472125039,
0.006937704,
0.0327856503,
-0.0143914651,
-0.0408721231,
0.0027137632,
0.0103662023,
0.0071913558,
0.0043058004,
0.0063679162,
0.0046029366,
0.0044506122,
-0.0283601545,
0.0351932719,
-0.0059643555,
0.0076125287,
-0.0104621993,
0.0113615058,
-0.0313071832,
0.0068717431,
-0.0159387663,
0.0202781484,
0.0277154017,
-0.0192651805,
0.0068257921,
0.0481602885,
-0.0439708158,
-0.0080363452,
0.02827942,
-0.110810414,
-0.0036327688,
0.0612463504,
-0.0000903637,
-0.0316960439,
-0.0103249354,
-0.059115842,
-0.026055865,
-0.0330238156,
-0.0010964054,
0.0169570055,
0.0030858549,
-0.0322735235,
0.0096518239,
-0.0500248186,
0.003701885,
0.0126010804,
-0.0020730314,
0.0282265991,
-0.0483715497,
-0.016853191,
-0.0058805998,
0.0025176622,
0.0081958836,
0.0301378742,
0.0037400639,
-0.064126581,
0.0038450689,
-0.1012480557,
-0.0463944748,
-0.0213949289,
-0.0355414078,
0.0145509839,
-0.0313971229,
-0.025711365,
-0.0526208691,
-0.0558788367,
0.0350957699,
0.0180161037,
0.0087362593,
0.0362695158,
0.0060365051,
0.0272322074,
-0.0545866713,
0.0207143128,
-0.0166512933,
0.02080933,
0.0554767102,
-0.0117765749,
0.0141365249,
-0.0282743275,
-0.0579439253,
0.0502669178,
-0.0323655605,
-0.0232424103,
0.0558053292,
-0.044064045,
-0.0021349119,
0.0684498549,
0.0226369761,
0.0206662305,
0.029841803,
-0.0186417364,
-0.0299486332,
0.0082420278,
0.0108629428,
-0.0212602951,
-0.0243717525,
-0.0272463989,
-0.00527373,
0.035307847,
-0.0101338737,
0.0131524568,
-0.0995973498,
0.1035199985,
-0.009509095,
-0.1016711593,
-0.0414845385,
0.0381188393,
-0.0107952664,
0.0460704453,
-0.023779761,
-0.049532257,
0.0440768301,
-0.0481836908,
-0.0182094127,
0.0575296022,
0.0443719253,
-0.0368830785,
0.0880842581,
0.0487114452,
0.0163518991,
-0.0173063669,
0.0290006902,
-0.0555947609,
0.0058095641,
0.0115405573,
-0.0094086416,
0.0198943652,
-0.0764999092,
-0.0036805745,
-0.0183334742,
-0.0410595015,
-0.0386557169,
-0.0174594913,
-0.0335751884,
0.0087622646,
-0.0631044433,
0.0044738147,
-0.020560123,
0.0322368555,
0.0271524098,
-0.0056301849,
-0.0122356983,
-0.0099995555,
-0.0033763852,
0.0099181244,
0.0847648978,
0.0303681139,
0.0071145277,
-0.0405712314,
0.0584106557,
0.0669867694,
0.0573467277,
0.0272125769,
-0.0187543947,
0.0267909095,
0.0104040308,
0.0330615416,
0.013490404,
0.0112031735,
0.0622548573,
-0.0344236717,
-0.0131134763,
0.1082310379,
0.0253895372,
-0.0333111957,
0.0001672756,
0.0184969436,
-0.0166548882,
0.0497492254,
0.0142467478,
-0.0484759882,
-0.0294567626,
-0.0267675892,
0.0164352171,
0.0092620291,
-0.0594297573,
-0.022431422,
-0.1083332151,
0.0399727337,
-0.0248448737,
-0.0290356819,
-0.0240602884,
0.0320745967,
0.0029891168,
-0.0090963859,
-0.0630809963,
0.0016547885,
-0.0027634453,
0.0336584188,
-0.0120063024,
-0.0126301972,
0.0162359271,
0.0702248588,
-0.0360941663,
0.0188185424,
0.0133459913,
0.012006226,
-0.0121574663,
-0.068552427,
-0.0037391828,
-0.0302081015,
0.0106767872,
0.0045483471,
0.0564641245,
-0.0696589723,
-0.0308694821,
0.0161229372,
0.0410009213,
-0.0173524562,
0.003745951,
0.0070131407,
0.0040820953,
-0.0312953554,
0.0067115603,
-0.0558034368,
0.0103188371,
-0.0263685565,
0.0541750081,
0.0248875767,
-0.0621640198,
-0.0371534675,
0.0061696139,
-0.0179309361,
-0.0225996468,
-0.0918011665,
-0.0104162982,
0.0711389557,
0.0024493751,
-0.0898296013,
-0.0612070933,
0.0654038414,
0.0580196083,
-0.0206813253,
-0.037613146,
-0.0340396687,
0.0336007811,
-0.0600428544,
0.04835039,
-0.0078372816,
0.0354080386,
-0.0361549482,
0.0111174984,
0.0520348214,
-0.0244034417,
-0.010187678,
0.034685161,
-0.0313471481,
-0.025285203,
-0.0166124031,
0.1001201421,
0.0201682262,
0.0376531705,
-0.0121131409,
-0.0300213061,
0.0086221611,
0.009409273,
0.0299662091,
0.0556724779,
0.0001715269,
0.0208382327,
0.0045191026,
0.0359934345,
-0.0326809026,
0.0116106262,
0.0080759907,
0.0063399072,
-0.003355681,
-0.0641108751,
0.0174481887,
0.0068540606,
0.0573442392,
0.0034230242,
0.034163259,
0.0015943057,
-0.0137441326,
-0.026304882,
0.0021091846,
-0.0873895511,
0.0137650743,
0.0515944362,
0.0181906763,
0.011658526,
0.0123427287,
-0.0234067496,
-0.019454984,
-0.0244387463,
-0.0432353988,
0.0315575041,
-0.0101649603,
-0.0312905721,
0.0122413486,
-0.0243610516,
0.0144577567,
-0.0232518166,
0.0382571407,
0.0460371077,
0.0760673434,
0.0149953272,
-0.0268347953,
-0.0037898668,
0.0685907006,
-0.075875029,
-0.0816744268,
-0.0345661975,
0.0517654642,
0.0265099425,
0.0027579265,
0.0183476433,
-0.0042459415,
0.0139360521,
-0.0151716601,
0.0132255526,
0.018561665,
-0.0497138239,
0.063793689,
0.0168847814,
0.0088372184,
-0.0039696493,
0.063278839,
0.0464979149,
0.0220009293,
-0.0075212265,
0.0117878737,
-0.0259931497,
-0.0328172036,
0.005853429,
-0.0077001057,
0.0137117002,
0.0629063547,
-0.0588785112,
-0.0572141446,
-0.0420313515,
0.0701168329,
-0.0121680908,
0.011364718,
0.0619833805,
0.0119916061,
0.0157486703,
-0.0231169853,
-0.0318444967,
-0.0351310372,
-0.0411798321,
0.0071383836,
0.0108041009,
-5.762250165e-33,
-0.0361110196,
-0.0075142924,
0.0328748189,
0.0284517035,
-0.0502465479,
-0.0043550613,
-0.0397281274,
0.0389322266,
-0.0167497899,
0.0051395386,
0.0275823884,
0.0173156504,
-0.0104004191,
0.0219446104,
-0.0090589244,
-0.0033730315,
-0.015689604,
-0.0246858746,
-0.03774314,
-0.0042683207,
-0.015684545,
-0.0000728229,
0.018935496,
-0.0629941076,
-0.0002180617,
-0.0064138919,
-0.0257153567,
0.034171544,
-0.0137107996,
0.0616208203,
-0.036324773,
-0.0126370778,
0.0248364992,
-0.0192824304,
-0.0351333655,
0.0184238125,
-0.0105503397,
-0.0286393333,
-0.0070636356,
0.0265992582,
-0.1135471687,
0.0281801,
0.0249433648,
-0.0085484078,
-0.0241490286,
-0.0284104645,
0.0367712006,
-0.0168874599,
0.0251814593,
0.0262990892,
-0.0025399786,
-0.0028337962,
-0.0014290588,
-0.0401006676,
0.0330308042,
0.0678704083,
-0.006321446,
-0.009444965,
0.005076387,
0.0181253478,
0.0022702732,
-0.0130759198,
0.1009946316,
0.0213058069,
0.0352754928,
0.0653490052,
0.0491402782,
-0.0060253809,
-0.0346810147,
-0.0580958985,
0.0172473397,
0.0767435208,
0.0556543432,
0.0785858631,
-0.0343756676,
0.0402816162,
-0.0194476359,
0.0337180458,
-0.0561392158,
0.0517656952,
0.00553976,
-0.0220043752,
-0.0306935571,
0.0235350877,
-0.0730067566,
-0.0412704386,
-0.0298693385,
0.0040545138,
0.0696378425,
0.0004502411,
-0.0170816332,
-0.0351019613,
0.0453869998,
-0.064451851,
0.0280045103,
0.0030713764,
-0.0444940291,
0.0601530038,
0.0201389473,
0.0331400894,
-0.0358003974,
0.0489033461,
0.0508874916,
0.0450254865,
-0.0029988687,
-0.0122569241,
-0.0255082361,
0.0017754853,
-0.0138288448,
-0.0401517078,
-0.0379731432,
0.0046781199,
-0.0073454329,
0.0278414078,
0.0358700231,
0.023644628,
-0.079625763,
0.0139977261,
-0.0422043093,
-0.030174803,
-0.0269163344,
-0.0190230664,
0.0123818507,
0.0175082274,
-0.0082049444,
-0.0085113244,
-0.0355227701,
-0.0325879008,
0.008975937,
-0.0465572961,
-0.0023621484,
0.0545585565,
2.686e-7,
0.0161930565,
0.0052596349,
0.0351682939,
-0.0234494098,
0.0353687666,
0.0656722635,
-0.0148777245,
0.0724292547,
-0.0088771759,
-0.0228258669,
-0.0000760476,
0.0771929026,
0.0557338856,
-0.0286421608,
-0.0218850076,
0.0226396471,
-0.0260511953,
-0.006751305,
-0.0251461044,
-0.0104150269,
0.0553064719,
0.0326574706,
-0.0126724606,
-0.0123363025,
0.0208489858,
-0.0360458903,
0.0906755179,
-0.0456779078,
0.0216710232,
-0.0181015246,
0.0274301246,
0.027538972,
0.002928813,
0.0100113824,
-0.0002363783,
-0.0139445746,
0.0316468999,
0.0431418344,
-0.0297489464,
-0.0509973392,
-0.0096245669,
0.0524344742,
-0.0045832526,
-0.0780171677,
0.0798869431,
-0.0694145635,
0.0142692681,
-0.0016337123,
-0.016932141,
0.0010805562,
0.0399707779,
0.0155984676,
-0.0300075635,
0.0111669693,
0.0192561969,
-0.0152973626,
-0.0277998857,
-0.0833060741,
-0.0071586957,
-0.0771625265,
-0.0332944766,
0.0019848926,
-0.0443101786,
0.0088819927,
-0.0107033821,
-0.0055518616,
-0.0539262667,
1.636024683e-34,
0.0011631032,
0.0154203149,
0.0168310162,
-0.0198689047,
0.0112089105,
0.0043184976,
-0.018376302,
-0.0043499074,
-0.0074808691,
-0.0737468377,
-0.0110077448
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16201v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16201v1 | Pre-trained Language Models Do Not Help Auto-regressive Text-to-Image Generation | 2023-11-27T07:19:26 | 2023-11-27T07:19:26 | Yuhui Zhang, Brandon McKinzie, Zhe Gan, Vaishaal Shankar, Alexander Toshev | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Recent advances in image tokenizers, such as VQ-VAE, have enabled
text-to-image generation using auto-regressive methods, similar to language
modeling. However, these methods have yet to leverage pre-trained language
models, despite their adaptability to various downstream tasks. In this work,
we explore this gap by adapting a pre-trained language model for
auto-regressive text-to-image generation, and find that pre-trained language
models offer limited help. We provide a two-fold explanation by analyzing
tokens from each modality. First, we demonstrate that image tokens possess
significantly different semantics compared to text tokens, rendering
pre-trained language models no more effective in modeling them than randomly
initialized ones. Second, the text tokens in the image-text datasets are too
simple compared to normal language model pre-training data, which causes the
catastrophic degradation of language models' capability. | [
0.0040366291,
0.0894453004,
0.0112311943,
0.0196616519,
-0.0102381818,
-0.0037787682,
0.0373430736,
0.0271401051,
-0.0434947796,
-0.0575648099,
-0.025362378,
-0.0260121971,
0.0155721596,
0.0802413672,
0.0535245351,
-0.084469907,
-0.0056430148,
-0.0419928841,
-0.0123577341,
-0.0067329258,
0.0242102649,
0.0209455714,
0.0193815548,
0.0505713969,
-0.0953249112,
-0.0084024426,
-0.0019135752,
0.045135498,
-0.0169641133,
-0.0022539529,
-0.0251040254,
0.0650192052,
0.0370121263,
0.0140970834,
0.0000017238,
-0.0152547061,
0.0037978871,
-0.0002356776,
0.0354778096,
-0.0097251339,
0.0692952722,
-0.0498635471,
-0.0253817383,
-0.0112321582,
-0.0048628813,
-0.0200103093,
0.088120684,
0.0549717508,
0.0833845884,
0.0584296919,
-0.0282636527,
-0.0183706563,
0.0073267007,
-0.0470801964,
0.0453292169,
-0.0103831785,
0.0054072808,
0.0002847545,
-0.0275550503,
0.0131313084,
-0.0219544861,
0.0343873203,
0.0232711472,
-0.0271001756,
0.0091222618,
0.0595076047,
-0.0095117353,
-0.0400446095,
-0.0316054225,
0.0540861376,
-0.0484992042,
-0.0380299166,
-0.0168472212,
-0.0184429549,
-0.0072423574,
0.0031085706,
-0.0238997322,
0.0437639616,
0.038812872,
0.0313723795,
-0.0410357974,
0.0133958645,
0.0058872378,
-0.0093382699,
-0.0142252864,
-0.0214042254,
0.0407713465,
0.0255066883,
-0.0568133295,
0.0482551157,
-0.0259916186,
-0.0880246609,
0.0326427296,
0.026838297,
0.0155516705,
0.002704229,
-0.0904573947,
-0.0705097467,
-0.0135037275,
0.0314725973,
0.0439997464,
0.0269643553,
-0.070622161,
0.019930698,
-0.0624497458,
0.0526225455,
-0.0021592793,
0.0349296294,
-0.0424066894,
-0.0089151869,
0.008569614,
-0.0472843349,
-0.0690135062,
-0.0001127285,
-0.0535304137,
-0.0492963977,
-0.0299108159,
0.0092289913,
0.0012723277,
-0.0259155389,
-0.0069271531,
0.0395754203,
-0.084258087,
-0.0124556338,
-0.0116971713,
-0.0143576944,
0.0099129314,
0.0227157753,
0.0151834693,
-0.0256093089,
-0.0012024068,
0.0357815586,
0.0346502252,
-0.0100388732,
-0.0180942845,
0.0720653981,
-0.0539201461,
-0.0151714934,
0.0006104076,
-0.0246389601,
-0.0318596698,
-0.0449299179,
0.0215120427,
-0.0653783754,
0.0268890876,
0.0048474614,
0.0028052093,
-0.0341508053,
-0.0005879117,
0.0040009124,
-0.0123989517,
0.0884991214,
-0.0087477295,
-0.004220753,
0.0372044034,
-0.0051361131,
0.0259691719,
0.0566499121,
0.0152384629,
0.0790577829,
0.0060449508,
0.0021878979,
0.0158358384,
0.0750309899,
0.0325832479,
-0.0095786685,
-0.0623801574,
-0.0352860987,
-0.0057150288,
0.008558902,
0.0641266853,
0.0798893124,
-0.036472477,
0.0153905163,
0.0609120615,
0.0557534285,
0.0076680426,
0.0379322916,
0.0658056363,
-0.0201485623,
-0.0043398854,
0.0073785177,
-0.0560278334,
0.0468315408,
0.0378583707,
0.0392839685,
0.0253667608,
0.0517951995,
-0.0451730564,
-0.0455709882,
0.0235326923,
-0.0400454365,
-0.0082754316,
-0.054156892,
0.0489997007,
0.0741791502,
-0.058603622,
0.0192839373,
-0.0112601146,
-0.0471867695,
0.0402236432,
-0.0580026172,
0.0186360218,
0.047200866,
0.0361750051,
0.016022278,
0.0352923088,
0.0105684269,
0.0275404789,
0.0855883956,
-0.0085173091,
0.0311276391,
0.013503504,
-0.0356467851,
-0.0350593999,
-0.0183363445,
0.0037954471,
0.0216841009,
-0.012373263,
0.0297134034,
0.0355118997,
-0.023313066,
-0.0143247023,
0.0559209399,
0.0203203484,
-0.0083638048,
0.0127004841,
0.0167091954,
-0.0237322506,
-0.0188135169,
-0.0275792759,
0.0370979384,
-0.003913566,
-0.0405372158,
0.003107839,
0.0386722423,
-0.0579681359,
-0.0525554903,
-0.0033992359,
-0.0401572324,
-0.008287237,
-0.0005079078,
-0.0183269512,
-0.0462606065,
0.0269887745,
-0.0058281608,
0.0417388789,
-0.0551532283,
-0.0039519332,
0.0423305482,
0.0068455953,
0.0215802062,
0.0319986641,
-0.0126536917,
-0.0187611394,
-0.0045951079,
0.0259090364,
-0.0194015782,
-0.0107984599,
-0.0104463696,
-0.0335670076,
-0.0071587265,
0.0022821433,
0.0228861347,
0.0345537774,
-0.0204599276,
-0.0038136786,
-0.065742135,
-0.0421590582,
-0.0248913039,
-0.033375714,
0.0111888563,
0.0276188161,
0.0167697985,
-0.0305203963,
-0.0427103341,
0.0277764574,
0.0301724765,
0.0081287427,
0.0464065187,
-0.0093544684,
0.0331059434,
-0.0460863709,
-0.0285051987,
0.0295004342,
0.0548537299,
0.0145123275,
-0.0102234455,
-0.0297145154,
0.0096445065,
-0.0239451546,
0.0128214294,
0.0088030398,
-0.0563573539,
0.0266932901,
-0.0168805756,
0.0784781203,
0.0486494303,
0.0306299515,
0.0083323596,
-0.0201804973,
-0.0049602743,
-0.043758247,
-0.0169203598,
-0.0307194851,
-0.0190463439,
0.0281158853,
-0.0389917456,
0.023017263,
0.0637963042,
-0.0106391199,
0.0255288184,
-0.0729099736,
0.0388601869,
-0.0141727561,
-0.0500968583,
-0.0442356728,
0.0034786216,
-0.0060031018,
0.0182222445,
-0.0452778935,
-0.0906664357,
0.0232116785,
-0.0588590018,
-0.0158154741,
0.0353056937,
0.041132085,
0.0011659762,
0.0458306521,
0.0571416952,
0.0520637408,
0.0090171993,
-0.0127510056,
-0.0477753729,
0.0057446677,
-0.0109733073,
0.0038046786,
0.0521609299,
-0.011131986,
0.0191940088,
-0.0206926335,
-0.0237954687,
-0.0377853103,
-0.0241884459,
0.0103918565,
0.0020889584,
0.0047273217,
-0.0154029652,
-0.0066901501,
0.0409270115,
-0.011447289,
0.0277669616,
-0.0212867111,
-0.0198065899,
-0.0311873611,
0.0580440648,
0.055937212,
-0.0289001744,
-0.0254268441,
-0.031587027,
-0.0057428917,
0.0278857388,
0.0284563694,
-0.0115536042,
-0.0466659591,
0.0274566356,
0.0024138987,
0.0632008016,
0.0057384698,
0.0206733905,
0.0731102824,
-0.0204679649,
-0.0282108169,
0.0709279403,
-0.0022662007,
-0.0169166531,
-0.0208032727,
0.0290887747,
0.0626754016,
-0.0025402047,
-0.0110215284,
-0.091214776,
-0.027869571,
-0.0101877395,
-0.0011547133,
0.0185134001,
0.0204358008,
-0.0386798754,
-0.0705088004,
0.0419658907,
0.0254212711,
-0.0355827436,
-0.0117789786,
0.0310685392,
-0.0019007219,
-0.0060350313,
-0.0017270369,
-0.0208810978,
-0.0134374956,
0.020020593,
0.0096526584,
0.0169175398,
-0.0066534118,
-0.0365513004,
-0.0211311299,
0.0223396514,
0.0752806365,
0.0102527793,
-0.0030222568,
-0.0139285438,
0.0524913929,
0.0353298448,
0.0229691528,
-0.0135354735,
0.0402901918,
0.0012694035,
-0.0286341831,
0.0169936009,
0.050083138,
0.0017738772,
-0.0264642052,
-0.0292744562,
-0.0061715646,
0.0186117012,
-0.0289563127,
-0.0430089273,
-0.0004171145,
0.014562468,
0.0419788659,
0.0290826652,
-0.0493940525,
-0.0731270835,
-0.0419408083,
0.0431259163,
-0.0899374932,
-0.0465243123,
-0.0195526071,
0.0005866903,
-0.0593889952,
-0.0784060434,
-0.0121118817,
0.0254089739,
0.0498508848,
-0.0252886452,
-0.0139430799,
-0.021450147,
-0.0045043621,
-0.039971754,
0.0465991795,
-0.0218186695,
0.0045580128,
-0.0689564869,
-0.0257674213,
-0.0070829191,
-0.065259926,
-0.0185158569,
0.0036138173,
-0.0873716548,
-0.0219989847,
-0.0010836229,
0.1030497476,
0.0154245477,
0.0276018549,
-0.0036971327,
-0.0401332006,
0.0771935061,
0.0713813826,
-0.0220540836,
-0.0012588465,
-0.0011104208,
0.0022032263,
-0.0199500285,
0.0239944775,
-0.0331210569,
0.0519354455,
0.0313665196,
0.0088400058,
0.024210168,
-0.0272556972,
0.0309753772,
-0.0241965745,
0.0137405647,
-0.0587152839,
0.0372254401,
-0.0338975266,
-0.0438426472,
-0.0360331647,
-0.0100233098,
-0.0939908475,
0.0184396673,
0.0103047499,
0.0332433805,
0.001322198,
-0.0460732169,
-0.0168146808,
0.0724930465,
-0.0208737906,
-0.0084599229,
0.0084032007,
0.0343937017,
0.0379772857,
-0.0103628198,
0.0112514691,
0.0186084695,
-0.0444793515,
0.0188035071,
-0.0403530821,
0.0199172013,
0.0157727972,
-0.004892501,
-0.0225213878,
0.0483663343,
-0.004760243,
-0.0238320641,
-0.0777087361,
0.030164035,
0.0275531951,
0.0004774569,
0.0464277864,
-0.0389477946,
-0.0105964402,
-0.0082153706,
0.0325349197,
0.0304830503,
-0.0264185518,
0.0334268957,
-0.0294741187,
-0.0104862601,
-0.0431002639,
0.0747196451,
0.0397615097,
0.0052630058,
-0.0040708478,
0.0161751434,
-0.0251528528,
-0.0023975531,
0.0174199715,
-0.0345788933,
0.0025715467,
0.0224081874,
0.0037919362,
-0.0727266371,
0.0037774523,
0.0194980521,
-0.0248246752,
0.0386480354,
0.0373657197,
0.0260613579,
0.0120355627,
0.0078796297,
-0.0035486084,
0.0402563512,
0.0097474558,
-0.0170897245,
0.0056111431,
-5.742041213e-33,
-0.054160919,
-0.0429790504,
0.0105300611,
-0.0479124151,
-0.004126031,
0.0296216272,
-0.0392889604,
0.0052548344,
0.0428158939,
0.0000070737,
0.0092530716,
-0.0177856293,
0.0210531391,
0.0688855946,
-0.0054859426,
0.0485044979,
0.0618634894,
-0.0314941108,
-0.0341365002,
0.0349461213,
0.010192344,
0.0049871663,
0.0208165906,
-0.0304522663,
-0.0252854638,
-0.0038232442,
-0.0317432471,
-0.0127477013,
0.057288032,
0.0473953187,
-0.0210803971,
-0.0088201864,
0.0037770388,
-0.0005977875,
-0.0474061295,
0.0600389615,
-0.0718664899,
-0.0050008665,
-0.0047815638,
0.0230333675,
-0.0642704591,
-0.0084814802,
0.0418257266,
-0.0584954508,
-0.012790625,
-0.0151471021,
0.0428729169,
-0.0064011244,
0.010167297,
-0.0327343009,
-0.0700877011,
0.003477901,
-0.013468192,
-0.0353653654,
0.040695928,
0.0346453674,
0.0137542337,
0.0152354278,
-0.0679296553,
0.0394484811,
0.0069939657,
0.0335535333,
0.0737951696,
0.0588348247,
0.0026668534,
0.0230786856,
0.011118345,
-0.0151750883,
-0.0389532223,
0.0358077027,
0.0261044372,
0.0682516694,
0.0392418988,
0.0294118673,
0.0316980109,
-0.021673901,
-0.0253016092,
0.0384478346,
-0.061333362,
-0.0015430547,
0.0328256339,
0.005942503,
0.0339208208,
0.0142948935,
-0.032341633,
-0.0482163206,
-0.0316597447,
-0.0350996889,
0.0379334278,
0.0546891764,
-0.0175757837,
-0.0124731455,
0.054807663,
-0.0059345379,
-0.0516147502,
-0.0098955696,
-0.0410488062,
0.0364197083,
-0.0255383961,
0.0251426082,
-0.0344131477,
-0.0540958047,
0.0873745009,
0.0294562131,
-0.0065080947,
0.0258676931,
0.032798335,
0.0103514604,
-0.0652994886,
-0.0009696405,
-0.0322386548,
0.0288644079,
0.0242261048,
0.018635327,
0.0392854661,
-0.0268543698,
-0.0522838794,
-0.0020274748,
-0.0074227434,
-0.0281672254,
-0.0127193667,
-0.0149653591,
0.0019918894,
0.0276639611,
-0.0509661436,
0.0104209566,
-0.0562446117,
-0.0024963566,
0.0430370979,
-0.0376391262,
-0.0218931455,
0.0106925769,
2.21e-7,
0.0366361141,
-0.002885551,
0.0375214443,
0.0021643147,
0.0164227542,
0.0358995497,
-0.0260043964,
0.0220793411,
0.0175067075,
0.0067274175,
-0.0068648849,
0.0196711104,
0.044551,
0.0000587706,
0.0081520425,
0.0575347804,
-0.0563606359,
0.036021702,
-0.0353683047,
-0.0170514118,
0.0439271256,
0.0766480491,
-0.0508893207,
-0.0250391476,
0.0321237817,
-0.0468888879,
0.0834573358,
-0.0189812351,
0.0010181346,
0.0021338961,
0.0071824333,
0.0184740052,
-0.0075943233,
-0.0133933229,
-0.0111759258,
-0.0159240607,
0.055367332,
0.0112174712,
-0.0343873352,
-0.0264157895,
-0.0152023034,
0.0132077476,
0.0066635339,
-0.0582148321,
0.0610043593,
-0.056093581,
0.0175722167,
-0.0568534397,
-0.0076097804,
0.0416127853,
0.0235850736,
-0.0463896915,
-0.0628129095,
0.0395439565,
0.0837002695,
0.0161560606,
-0.0336847082,
-0.0460375398,
-0.0623078234,
-0.0188158751,
-0.0373525061,
-0.001960801,
-0.1078635901,
0.0273447037,
0.0154172406,
0.006336791,
-0.0381303951,
1.776032833e-34,
-0.002437975,
-0.020170534,
0.0060214377,
0.0112471506,
0.0094500026,
-0.0169771556,
0.0226102602,
0.0219195671,
-0.0232025832,
-0.0444904976,
-0.0369892903
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15566v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15566v1 | SpotServe: Serving Generative Large Language Models on Preemptible Instances | 2023-11-27T06:31:17 | 2023-11-27T06:31:17 | Xupeng Miao, Chunan Shi, Jiangfei Duan, Xiaoli Xi, Dahua Lin, Bin Cui, Zhihao Jia | cs.DC | cs.DC, cs.CL, cs.LG | The high computational and memory requirements of generative large language
models (LLMs) make it challenging to serve them cheaply. This paper aims to
reduce the monetary cost for serving LLMs by leveraging preemptible GPU
instances on modern clouds, which offer accesses to spare GPUs at a much
cheaper price than regular instances but may be preempted by the cloud at any
time. Serving LLMs on preemptible instances requires addressing challenges
induced by frequent instance preemptions and the necessity of migrating
instances to handle these preemptions.
This paper presents SpotServe, the first distributed LLM serving system on
preemptible instances. Several key techniques in SpotServe realize fast and
reliable serving of generative LLMs on cheap preemptible instances. First,
SpotServe dynamically adapts the LLM parallelization configuration for dynamic
instance availability and fluctuating workload, while balancing the trade-off
among the overall throughput, inference latency and monetary costs. Second, to
minimize the cost of migrating instances for dynamic reparallelization, the
task of migrating instances is formulated as a bipartite graph matching
problem, which uses the Kuhn-Munkres algorithm to identify an optimal migration
plan that minimizes communications. Finally, to take advantage of the grace
period offered by modern clouds, we introduce stateful inference recovery, a
new inference mechanism that commits inference progress at a much finer
granularity and allows SpotServe to cheaply resume inference upon preemption.
We evaluate on real spot instance preemption traces and various popular LLMs
and show that SpotServe can reduce the P99 tail latency by 2.4 - 9.1x compared
with the best existing LLM serving systems. We also show that SpotServe can
leverage the price advantage of preemptive instances, saving 54% monetary cost
compared with only using on-demand instances. | [
-0.0205051452,
0.088246718,
-0.0293769203,
0.0297978707,
-0.0488059781,
0.0098425979,
0.0271341484,
-0.0105613051,
0.0021290882,
0.0161769334,
0.0359217413,
-0.0423990823,
-0.0175555386,
0.0160281472,
-0.0199189261,
0.0031362139,
0.0473393686,
-0.0254381448,
-0.0409668423,
-0.0689806193,
-0.0045871679,
0.0131748682,
-0.0070920507,
-0.0195045639,
0.0122432662,
-0.0544943959,
-0.0232537594,
-0.0148346657,
0.0122004896,
-0.0038581062,
-0.0449049883,
0.0137894563,
0.0106237084,
0.0556199215,
0.000002245,
-0.032067392,
-0.0489645377,
0.0243515112,
-0.0461129136,
0.051621601,
0.0196617078,
0.0116710048,
-0.0496272407,
0.0169057697,
-0.0178221632,
-0.0123570757,
0.0654530153,
-0.0478472523,
0.054713659,
0.0164753087,
-0.0200094115,
0.0153538398,
-0.0144747747,
-0.0259113628,
-0.0166410413,
-0.0602371208,
0.0267626382,
-0.0106301373,
0.003057682,
-0.0633263662,
-0.0104809646,
0.0267110914,
0.0016699883,
-0.0202701464,
-0.0317258164,
0.0399760641,
-0.0298670419,
-0.0090073887,
-0.0238808934,
0.0159709677,
0.0198947247,
-0.037131086,
0.0219127126,
-0.0046760053,
-0.0502195358,
0.0458488315,
-0.019016793,
0.0360222682,
0.0162146781,
0.003613268,
0.0600718074,
-0.041565083,
0.0311783813,
0.0037318578,
-0.0227829795,
0.0722521991,
0.0650755465,
0.0139029119,
-0.084713012,
0.0245677903,
-0.0614826977,
-0.0708580986,
0.0592178702,
0.0214780513,
-0.0367781743,
-0.0089077996,
-0.0740000084,
-0.0544077978,
-0.0144418254,
-0.0059948713,
0.0653888658,
0.0319528878,
-0.0089898175,
0.0561544336,
-0.0202514417,
0.0138949044,
-0.045322448,
-0.0316043533,
-0.027911881,
-0.0056604366,
0.0539149493,
-0.0046972735,
-0.0579201169,
0.0274995118,
-0.0155002028,
-0.0225133821,
-0.0062270169,
0.0479442775,
-0.0308429766,
-0.0144066922,
-0.0192701966,
-0.0005114248,
-0.0141554102,
-0.0095358472,
0.0041742777,
0.0070378082,
-0.017284723,
0.0158690196,
-0.01481234,
-0.0859726518,
-0.0115000103,
0.0307270456,
0.0215550251,
-0.007090122,
0.0251031946,
0.0342268012,
0.0234442279,
-0.0044441186,
0.0128874239,
0.0228005685,
0.046985887,
-0.0742665008,
-0.0477926284,
-0.0492281541,
0.0271391273,
0.0364024863,
0.0117937131,
-0.0128423087,
-0.006786345,
-0.0218008868,
-0.0003968047,
0.0202705786,
-0.0105365654,
0.0394997448,
-0.0281149801,
-0.0114708655,
0.0176200718,
0.0177797582,
-0.0015219955,
-0.0023874198,
0.0267147943,
-0.0135923084,
0.0329778828,
0.0494916663,
0.0342591256,
0.061915569,
-0.0492953435,
0.021205131,
-0.0055072382,
0.0356279984,
0.0246058218,
0.0409309156,
-0.0118271755,
-0.034097258,
0.0428569466,
0.0667270198,
-0.0606989339,
0.0317839906,
0.0191918518,
0.0138363717,
-0.048109103,
-0.0219394695,
-0.0316372477,
0.0041961684,
-0.0401799195,
-0.0096569574,
0.0549584851,
0.0688645467,
-0.0187161602,
0.0147477565,
-0.012492544,
0.016405018,
-0.0696821958,
0.0370144211,
0.050441552,
-0.0144636659,
-0.0306513496,
0.0577187091,
0.0433095992,
-0.0347153246,
-0.0199579187,
-0.047425434,
0.0433241241,
0.0696020648,
0.0642273054,
0.0108878324,
-0.0645289049,
0.0305047706,
-0.0197393298,
0.0115608126,
0.0003267825,
0.0095125567,
0.0292587299,
-0.0265988242,
-0.0057266192,
0.04925384,
0.0140329646,
0.0087717986,
0.0475043319,
0.0021712142,
-0.0073852772,
-0.0385933183,
-0.0086654192,
0.0113727022,
-0.0241406448,
0.0185695924,
-0.0203333497,
-0.0098851817,
0.0515837707,
-0.0566747971,
-0.0206894819,
-0.0144313835,
0.0420821756,
-0.0040566619,
0.0141924256,
0.0419940427,
-0.0121535016,
0.0046923524,
0.0146528743,
0.011427056,
0.0307017099,
0.0148899779,
-0.0518759377,
-0.0368509963,
0.0259910226,
-0.0171872936,
0.0115039311,
-0.0272342302,
0.0522957966,
-0.0109307934,
0.0270562544,
0.0167840552,
0.0125873284,
-0.0152356233,
0.0091800364,
0.0242268387,
0.0077357264,
0.0021982556,
-0.0273116529,
-0.0181596223,
0.0110483244,
-0.0085583106,
0.008107692,
-0.0163165592,
-0.0557844266,
0.0004219573,
0.0420175791,
-0.0617495179,
0.0535986759,
-0.0051053786,
0.037305221,
0.0548859946,
0.0385861509,
-0.0119572841,
-0.0149057759,
0.0136737647,
0.0792736337,
0.0459739603,
0.0544586927,
-0.0209997557,
-0.0239786375,
-0.0320576429,
0.0087124566,
-0.0402435251,
0.0219597723,
0.0740560368,
-0.0135794757,
-0.0600009859,
-0.0657615066,
0.0841775984,
-0.0199250598,
0.0446224734,
-0.0086413631,
-0.0037197804,
-0.0090066381,
-0.05950341,
0.0590455085,
0.0436696112,
-0.010427163,
-0.0424748585,
0.0071565351,
-0.0358473808,
-0.0532155707,
0.0010095504,
-0.0459453538,
-0.0437742062,
-0.0185257792,
0.0243974496,
-0.05592563,
0.0503022112,
-0.0553354695,
-0.0600673109,
-0.01423393,
-0.0138026243,
-0.0195456371,
0.0215856228,
-0.0287756566,
0.0288651343,
-0.004454942,
0.0087759262,
-0.0098754875,
-0.0892413855,
0.0393394604,
-0.0367202237,
0.0245458856,
0.0207877364,
-0.0402841158,
-0.0119909244,
0.0505680181,
0.0401227102,
0.0324977674,
-0.1039149761,
0.0133655732,
-0.0008503961,
0.0718409568,
0.0026826418,
-0.0219905246,
-0.0299386121,
-0.0144887706,
0.0356600285,
-0.0098044444,
-0.0598143302,
-0.0099565247,
0.0160543062,
-0.035162501,
-0.0418072678,
0.0118092569,
-0.0185958594,
-0.0190085899,
0.0536209159,
-0.0053504426,
0.0778034851,
-0.0170478337,
0.0244451165,
-0.0139056426,
-0.0167226698,
0.0211132634,
0.016552899,
0.0142149804,
-0.0365162045,
-0.0198867377,
0.0521746427,
0.0363313742,
-0.0209841188,
-0.0139066139,
-0.0106545091,
0.0863026232,
-0.0216161888,
-0.0302860327,
0.0323536396,
0.0208649728,
-0.0513759516,
-0.0533176623,
0.03412126,
-0.0225789696,
-0.0428507514,
-0.0017720003,
0.0121795153,
0.0314045697,
0.0044971672,
0.0521525405,
-0.1179986522,
0.0059840092,
0.040340431,
-0.0029284088,
0.0005179941,
-0.014777177,
-0.0210015774,
-0.130348593,
0.0582784079,
0.0142438728,
-0.0015953453,
0.0190768838,
-0.0485804901,
0.0099095814,
-0.0023563984,
-0.0280428138,
0.0219867453,
0.0133788018,
0.0262630582,
-0.0054020644,
0.0134963105,
-0.000948426,
0.0176995527,
-0.0338402241,
0.024898259,
0.0073482567,
-0.0001649732,
0.0174443927,
-0.0310979132,
0.0349748172,
0.0238460805,
-0.035058368,
-0.005078665,
-0.0284215827,
0.0280617438,
0.0071683414,
-0.0168205202,
0.0114668747,
0.0113054551,
-0.0312240142,
-0.0245416872,
0.0985535756,
-0.0280770119,
-0.0060177133,
-0.0126784183,
-0.005415278,
-0.0014633962,
0.0627786294,
-0.0012365545,
-0.0340656601,
-0.0596681871,
-0.0040928898,
0.0138284964,
-0.0514067896,
-0.0054555265,
0.0020854499,
0.0111848898,
-0.0179189648,
0.0100643728,
0.0600493997,
0.0139321703,
0.0553359985,
0.0176640712,
0.0314416625,
0.0280704983,
-0.0214739759,
-0.0870286599,
-0.0050947592,
-0.0741974562,
0.016900124,
-0.062880218,
-0.0144577464,
0.0206425693,
-0.0131319333,
-0.0411135368,
0.0087448088,
-0.0939674228,
-0.0713570938,
0.0590154342,
0.0216459315,
0.026152648,
0.0515553802,
-0.0170836002,
-0.0508454889,
0.0730092824,
0.0807622448,
-0.0595318228,
0.0484029241,
-0.0226775128,
-0.0351306796,
-0.0074268035,
0.0313079879,
-0.0199193433,
0.0385498218,
-0.0013142744,
0.0152788106,
0.0222553629,
-0.0349153094,
-0.0321143195,
0.0838813782,
0.004235201,
-0.0169710033,
0.0025920514,
-0.014663795,
0.0382244997,
0.0136472788,
-0.0115153352,
-0.0441930294,
0.0159291141,
0.0145513536,
-0.0082358783,
-0.0114640677,
-0.02066838,
0.0874637589,
-0.0156806335,
-0.0301649179,
-0.0283696335,
0.0073901634,
-0.0494390614,
0.1021888852,
0.0006727315,
0.0478245467,
0.021254817,
0.0095204152,
0.0613272153,
-0.0494934209,
0.000380742,
0.0281374659,
0.020435309,
-0.0100689502,
-0.0001496795,
-0.0103257475,
-0.093721211,
-0.0501063578,
0.0193722732,
0.074084051,
0.0395141616,
0.0520753488,
-0.0104085812,
-0.0213808473,
-0.0275801513,
0.0314394981,
0.0020000371,
-0.0536128618,
0.0043067541,
0.0313739739,
-0.0027300778,
0.0703590736,
0.0331840515,
0.029322058,
0.0483085513,
0.0206521712,
-0.0235786717,
-0.0131909698,
-0.0528933592,
-0.0794214606,
-0.0116363196,
-0.0079467082,
0.0051871538,
-0.0050279386,
-0.0215050839,
-0.0420491993,
0.0245958082,
-0.0174324326,
-0.0515517034,
-0.0184616018,
0.0444301255,
0.0121587114,
-0.0244180541,
-0.0492257029,
0.0797829032,
-0.0206869561,
0.0049920175,
0.0306838658,
-7.012705423e-33,
-0.0110956589,
-0.0362741686,
0.0526244827,
-0.0230232608,
-0.0211171079,
0.0169033911,
-0.0357151367,
-0.0253791679,
0.046800293,
-0.00885568,
0.0030384217,
0.0539210401,
0.0288414769,
0.0337959267,
-0.0174272954,
0.0277044177,
0.0302736405,
0.0188332684,
-0.0413493663,
0.0614132918,
0.0328450799,
0.0253296699,
0.0085907327,
-0.0120352339,
-0.0534615815,
-0.0875602737,
0.0301064365,
-0.0053705424,
-0.0449837893,
-0.0010796357,
-0.0423520841,
0.0089646317,
-0.0331005752,
-0.0295388512,
0.0055873501,
-0.0386479162,
-0.0459124185,
0.0186173953,
0.0138977533,
-0.0031838408,
-0.0507828146,
-0.0067924811,
-0.0308978967,
0.0468918011,
-0.0105610369,
0.0082648741,
-0.0162440445,
0.013497808,
-0.0339493975,
-0.0429251641,
-0.0068385303,
0.0138949249,
0.0176797137,
0.052472353,
0.0722523779,
-0.0332309045,
-0.0029354938,
0.0339580625,
-0.0561781153,
0.0276446678,
0.0046839206,
0.0467311144,
0.0345683135,
-0.018363798,
0.0453663766,
0.0349112786,
0.0053028278,
-0.0243385006,
-0.0147872409,
0.0480583161,
-0.0117333522,
0.0316914469,
-0.0034113794,
-0.006986646,
0.0592833944,
-0.0095699718,
-0.0467701294,
-0.0121438839,
0.0246447213,
-0.0372313634,
0.0618533082,
0.0169498641,
0.0169971287,
-0.0462440252,
-0.0249512177,
-0.0299695693,
-0.0272116363,
0.0249121282,
0.0258124918,
0.0279204976,
-0.0387089364,
0.0171550252,
0.0592427254,
-0.0218904559,
-0.0390835777,
0.0165017899,
-0.0143412957,
-0.0247195438,
0.0036832113,
0.0682311729,
-0.0353995934,
-0.0568243638,
-0.0494430922,
-0.0358140506,
0.0292566661,
0.0099916719,
0.0210257731,
0.0277771875,
-0.0657830238,
0.0155883972,
-0.0423510522,
0.0231402889,
-0.0073856893,
-0.0071845078,
0.0484304726,
0.0253458899,
0.051471848,
0.0338804908,
0.0539459027,
0.0334635451,
0.0165815186,
-0.011742074,
0.0007161798,
-0.0143056111,
-0.0246950872,
0.0225577671,
-0.0649208501,
0.0430090241,
0.0208025537,
-0.0899564028,
-0.0312471036,
0.026679825,
3.203e-7,
0.0118891504,
0.0273448732,
0.0375055745,
-0.0012357114,
0.0094625019,
-0.0040975548,
0.018111201,
-0.0195653867,
0.034003187,
0.0560380295,
0.00869238,
0.0249199718,
0.05628483,
0.018525986,
-0.0428031832,
0.025007749,
-0.0988834724,
0.0345545784,
-0.0421329327,
-0.0397863053,
-0.0146464417,
0.046495989,
0.0126893055,
-0.0075552361,
0.0514596365,
-0.011687411,
0.0186245423,
-0.0258936044,
-0.0003704275,
0.0184058174,
0.0146363648,
0.0601606667,
-0.0163343679,
-0.0015397363,
-0.0189536344,
0.0156406406,
-0.0373377167,
0.0413103886,
0.0107948463,
0.0331098847,
-0.0036336463,
-0.0568395145,
-0.0250443276,
-0.0175290909,
0.0670013055,
-0.025951989,
-0.0126383184,
-0.0397681631,
-0.0219797716,
-0.0594225377,
-0.0300020929,
0.0127970604,
0.0392793715,
0.0204151366,
0.0086035812,
-0.0555000752,
-0.038441442,
-0.0591185093,
-0.0328817479,
0.0049451161,
-0.0448784083,
-0.0382355936,
-0.0401860997,
0.0190823842,
0.0101943687,
-0.015522561,
0.0256824885,
3.160657272e-34,
0.0317808464,
0.0393883027,
-0.0059407256,
0.0439178795,
0.0251865648,
-0.0503327176,
0.0215032715,
-0.0003366327,
-0.0410957038,
-0.0725844353,
-0.0438140891
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15565v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15565v3 | Evaluating the Efficacy of Hybrid Deep Learning Models in Distinguishing AI-Generated Text | 2023-11-27T06:26:53 | 2024-01-13T15:09:41 | Abiodun Finbarrs Oketunji | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, I.2.7, I.2.7 | My research investigates the use of cutting-edge hybrid deep learning models
to accurately differentiate between AI-generated text and human writing. I
applied a robust methodology, utilising a carefully selected dataset comprising
AI and human texts from various sources, each tagged with instructions.
Advanced natural language processing techniques facilitated the analysis of
textual features. Combining sophisticated neural networks, the custom model
enabled it to detect nuanced differences between AI and human content. | [
0.0406217761,
0.0347199403,
-0.0156812984,
0.0441667512,
-0.0483987331,
0.01581336,
0.0378047042,
0.0019049068,
0.0306628328,
-0.0576702394,
-0.0219663698,
-0.0262641218,
-0.0118285036,
0.0644073114,
0.0000391043,
-0.0001917646,
0.0267249923,
0.0085885189,
0.034193065,
0.0489255972,
0.0292997099,
0.0280650686,
0.0153374234,
0.0641781017,
-0.0409092419,
-0.0473263413,
-0.0121633774,
0.0139215523,
0.020185383,
0.0233762134,
0.0336459763,
0.0485415868,
0.0079873754,
0.1046783328,
0.0000017012,
-0.0289815478,
0.0164971817,
-0.0090626776,
-0.0394121148,
-0.0172242727,
0.0784554631,
0.0007626068,
-0.0331907794,
0.0037229762,
-0.0429226011,
0.0098306909,
0.0308896303,
0.0588726327,
0.025840247,
0.0867023915,
-0.0286779571,
0.0062493468,
0.0569937341,
0.0230887886,
-0.0033342417,
0.0072056227,
0.0095168352,
-0.0145188067,
0.0099797575,
-0.0208969116,
0.0353307053,
0.025477251,
0.044158563,
-0.0252955705,
-0.0061350148,
0.0059966487,
-0.0056770463,
0.000581885,
-0.032943923,
0.0641212985,
-0.051845558,
-0.0371755697,
0.0163285024,
-0.0545064583,
-0.0070024324,
-0.0329855941,
0.030094713,
0.0294074919,
-0.0324451067,
0.0119370949,
0.0178676061,
0.0175888967,
0.0307501312,
0.0375477634,
0.0021635988,
0.0401307084,
-0.0139771886,
-0.0363122635,
-0.0109976931,
0.0198767465,
0.044638209,
-0.0576318242,
0.050346788,
0.0548839457,
0.0069434191,
-0.0246686097,
-0.1056336537,
-0.094341442,
0.0102957645,
-0.0552829914,
0.0504917912,
-0.0068085631,
-0.0557414778,
0.0318521224,
-0.0285389908,
0.0631475151,
-0.0213657599,
0.0554864928,
0.0084111802,
0.0364976116,
-0.0489022434,
-0.0348062068,
0.0038619707,
0.0125651108,
-0.0057614427,
-0.0559916534,
-0.0284662619,
-0.0000843076,
-0.0307320226,
0.0370642655,
-0.0087111844,
0.0050329356,
-0.0410745479,
0.0085450923,
0.0053619505,
-0.0495869257,
-0.0148093486,
0.0410349406,
0.0040915166,
-0.0681227669,
0.0246567093,
0.071644336,
0.0290991738,
0.0009992833,
-0.014447513,
0.0627455115,
-0.0517003722,
-0.0164856445,
-0.0492431857,
-0.0442993119,
-0.0098825591,
-0.0480620265,
0.0246438719,
-0.0539147295,
0.020886071,
-0.0396037959,
-0.0331733376,
-0.0729667991,
-0.0252194256,
0.0343551338,
0.0113540906,
0.0431341678,
-0.036204502,
-0.005861213,
0.0383682922,
-0.0113925682,
-0.0055013453,
0.0065812604,
0.0582053065,
0.068998985,
0.0351118892,
0.0294879582,
0.0385718346,
0.0282151755,
-0.0372491628,
-0.0306374934,
-0.0290687755,
-0.037573278,
-0.0458357036,
0.0328540616,
-0.0045542498,
0.0641041547,
0.0115223918,
0.0002076646,
0.061749164,
0.0612157881,
0.0138642956,
0.0260829367,
0.0795271769,
0.0622743107,
0.0401812419,
0.0357200392,
-0.0008460242,
-0.005136061,
-0.0044781789,
-0.0108362213,
-0.0292853229,
0.0022040247,
-0.0120514212,
-0.0399980359,
-0.0164503492,
-0.0397019908,
0.042551633,
-0.0476218909,
0.0499263406,
-0.0035992169,
-0.0421163999,
-0.0949353501,
-0.0214689374,
-0.0378414467,
0.0015252299,
-0.0681011304,
0.0368440449,
0.0899391472,
0.0255294032,
-0.0629947186,
0.0397622213,
-0.0199529752,
-0.0162662398,
0.0692454129,
0.0159212984,
0.0074248919,
-0.0142969582,
-0.0568080768,
-0.0227960087,
-0.0501785241,
0.0130109517,
-0.0121518662,
-0.00356509,
0.0345681012,
0.0302009769,
0.0058119195,
-0.0665479973,
0.0770195425,
-0.0164950658,
0.002570302,
0.0097565986,
0.0277744625,
-0.026267644,
0.0283481516,
-0.0403905958,
0.0196551345,
0.0030988918,
-0.0466673933,
-0.0645848885,
-0.0097644068,
-0.0128824832,
0.0012641983,
0.0023635819,
-0.0424318612,
-0.0087932497,
0.0357201099,
-0.0225766841,
-0.0110474778,
-0.016904356,
-0.0468536727,
-0.0233608577,
-0.0530203097,
-0.002813142,
-0.004364016,
0.0117265955,
-0.0266944207,
0.0394769572,
0.003793288,
-0.0416117422,
0.0022347395,
-0.0364963338,
0.0175112057,
-0.0023034422,
0.0013305484,
-0.0049479175,
-0.0262217131,
0.025243856,
0.0021652956,
0.0578454323,
-0.0307274833,
-0.0151148979,
-0.0740579739,
-0.0061172321,
-0.0453519486,
-0.0105149047,
0.0253636185,
-0.0344624855,
0.0187920723,
0.014196869,
-0.0437704399,
-0.0406254902,
0.0097529506,
-0.0038225891,
0.0644156858,
-0.0100743053,
0.03614581,
-0.05370152,
-0.014911647,
-0.0314528048,
0.0415836237,
0.0504449904,
-0.05622283,
-0.0338026397,
0.0077776019,
0.002665241,
0.0062034898,
0.0105486056,
-0.0395401902,
0.0077303741,
-0.0087351678,
0.0095830411,
0.0916846022,
-0.0004826326,
0.0274326559,
0.0288371202,
0.0553756692,
-0.0255738087,
0.0064197388,
0.0264996402,
0.0616092309,
0.0035902103,
-0.040554259,
0.0051388433,
0.0219318606,
0.015256078,
0.0123037249,
-0.027401736,
0.04702143,
-0.0133015262,
-0.0660165995,
0.0028278048,
-0.0461943932,
-0.0069605429,
0.0462685674,
-0.0383304171,
-0.0392692462,
0.0504757725,
-0.0213379636,
0.0124663617,
-0.0233314615,
-0.0454147011,
-0.0253819302,
0.0155404638,
0.0068352832,
0.0355644524,
-0.0247314945,
-0.0097486908,
-0.0295094568,
0.0415666066,
0.0072717736,
-0.0018183717,
0.0381618813,
-0.0208503101,
0.0109181637,
0.000195013,
-0.020482894,
-0.0517278239,
-0.0347618945,
-0.0155203827,
0.0144813899,
0.0382522754,
-0.0499163307,
0.0125958743,
-0.033782918,
0.0087756375,
0.0905952528,
-0.0133969355,
0.0096282009,
-0.0573800169,
0.0455968641,
0.021506818,
-0.0338488147,
-0.0021985103,
-0.0342754684,
0.0135260262,
0.0120909875,
-0.0125533147,
0.0202271435,
-0.055174876,
-0.0084880544,
-0.0220227987,
-0.0022700997,
-0.0213546064,
0.0271473192,
0.0368476547,
-0.0817160755,
-0.0030199611,
0.0866176933,
0.017514728,
-0.0546373464,
-0.0115875183,
-0.0073016994,
-0.029760208,
-0.0331307128,
0.0152282361,
-0.0548300967,
-0.0400584452,
0.0247676522,
-0.0008038046,
-0.0360962935,
0.0057548424,
0.0106573701,
-0.0356894061,
0.0121162236,
-0.0159374978,
-0.0542427078,
-0.0216225311,
0.0011515656,
-0.0136832502,
0.0293431096,
-0.0297843814,
-0.0535027161,
-0.0095157335,
-0.0372641906,
-0.0051996862,
-0.0638828799,
-0.0258667488,
-0.0220842101,
-0.0263055284,
0.0094205011,
0.1115472913,
0.0493402258,
-0.0352693275,
-0.040014822,
0.0267925449,
0.032710202,
0.0323529243,
0.0070655826,
0.066890873,
-0.0299767051,
-0.0011679039,
-0.021832969,
0.0556014068,
-0.0157559998,
-0.0014620371,
-0.0224849191,
0.0461223423,
-0.0290305298,
-0.0492169075,
-0.0396106802,
0.0001671788,
0.0529951975,
0.0558655038,
0.0367221124,
-0.0545375906,
-0.0995449647,
-0.0208109915,
0.0191926472,
-0.0840584934,
-0.0438419022,
0.0315871276,
-0.0058789095,
-0.0501208603,
-0.0894832537,
-0.0882187411,
-0.0148412725,
-0.0180376805,
0.0431143008,
-0.0102213779,
0.0307246987,
-0.0026155815,
-0.0626910776,
-0.0142910052,
-0.0054442557,
0.0422156341,
-0.0417413674,
-0.0205710996,
-0.0077854935,
-0.0154474648,
-0.0140704159,
0.0215197057,
-0.0617413223,
-0.0348533429,
0.0232149903,
0.0269822143,
0.0062643108,
0.0079662027,
-0.0150786759,
-0.0631741062,
0.0299182869,
0.0331759639,
-0.0007424432,
-0.0108099021,
0.0481736623,
-0.0244098008,
-0.0324632116,
0.0050467337,
-0.0069962558,
0.0212567709,
0.042076394,
-0.0303633101,
-0.027730681,
-0.0083170906,
-0.0137778753,
-0.001817217,
0.0110123856,
-0.0020492843,
-0.007457084,
-0.047410015,
-0.0180927217,
-0.0017877406,
-0.0127311414,
-0.0466764122,
-0.0122198751,
0.0132391322,
0.0277184714,
-0.0021594157,
0.0347267278,
0.0066159396,
0.0395139456,
-0.0228361916,
0.0103303622,
0.0104566235,
0.1144652143,
-0.0315184407,
0.0155489603,
-0.0272838194,
0.0966545865,
-0.0232750326,
0.0234409366,
0.0228599776,
0.0270058624,
0.0039270292,
0.0029938596,
-0.0078839287,
0.0557027832,
-0.0481510162,
-0.0456021316,
-0.0435505845,
0.0254890621,
0.0452285968,
-0.0108681889,
0.038793847,
-0.0296109337,
-0.004911752,
-0.0424190424,
0.0486091748,
0.0214104783,
-0.0080487467,
-0.0431768708,
-0.013922058,
-0.0230467375,
-0.0214412846,
0.0625294298,
0.0123951677,
0.0399932936,
-0.001473579,
-0.0210118815,
-0.0414951555,
-0.0059138257,
0.061121121,
0.0203669444,
0.0062463051,
-0.009161856,
-0.0164868962,
-0.0434625633,
0.0490510128,
0.0129715372,
0.0455661342,
0.0257702339,
0.0180778541,
0.0435887612,
-0.0249816924,
-0.0036635192,
-0.0400480554,
0.0128002148,
0.0341198333,
-0.0337371565,
-0.0510371476,
-5.226759591e-33,
0.0152703552,
-0.0562926456,
-0.0220010336,
-0.0037233341,
-0.0051773838,
0.0310681909,
-0.0182204247,
-0.0117644444,
-0.0004123714,
0.043632295,
-0.0099073667,
0.0194247887,
0.023676578,
0.0185726341,
-0.0134439375,
-0.0268860925,
0.0555493645,
-0.037734285,
0.007673345,
0.031503927,
0.0471249633,
0.02743911,
0.0264716037,
-0.0924541205,
0.0426493473,
-0.031655997,
-0.013542329,
-0.0312736593,
-0.027791176,
0.0439948514,
-0.0260478109,
0.0235481039,
0.0490100347,
0.0220831372,
-0.0249601752,
0.0748889074,
0.0005219732,
-0.0227637049,
-0.0456610844,
0.0166192967,
-0.0683007017,
-0.0865620449,
0.0419513136,
-0.0139283491,
-0.0067405589,
0.0149598848,
0.0972853303,
0.0107971644,
0.046288643,
-0.0711193532,
-0.1024429053,
0.0167262945,
-0.0319946036,
0.0123598697,
0.043238204,
0.0497826859,
-0.0194800887,
0.0131290741,
-0.097634472,
0.0043443162,
0.0054381113,
-0.0166479684,
0.0376961641,
0.0220115539,
-0.0352226496,
0.0498703085,
0.0264417473,
0.0145232072,
-0.054284405,
0.0106234895,
0.0467281789,
0.0394309722,
0.0800279006,
0.0676890686,
0.0102225887,
-0.0065820604,
-0.0496557429,
0.0278412104,
0.0296258777,
-0.009691353,
0.0138163539,
-0.0232159197,
-0.0609223023,
0.0202251095,
0.0003431048,
-0.0404590927,
-0.0173759721,
-0.0243564378,
0.049411606,
-0.001287127,
-0.0103189414,
0.0016880834,
0.0125066098,
-0.0540142916,
0.037554089,
-0.0041566454,
-0.0385240316,
0.0480701216,
0.0143412016,
-0.0002396854,
-0.0236351229,
-0.0383435935,
0.041921746,
0.0297178775,
0.061649777,
0.0023095931,
0.058957465,
0.0281761177,
-0.0129151437,
0.0249574147,
0.0138380649,
0.0161597505,
0.0254183766,
0.0370656811,
-0.0074824938,
-0.0278011095,
-0.0107659874,
0.0463543981,
0.0082605695,
0.0220653247,
-0.0178650375,
-0.0287324376,
-0.0117000071,
0.0064635323,
-0.0385642685,
-0.0039556604,
-0.0495209061,
0.0103254169,
0.014137649,
-0.056306947,
0.0197161008,
-0.0126990303,
2.206e-7,
0.0113408184,
0.0232431032,
0.048182983,
0.0058491989,
0.0187476892,
0.0502813123,
0.0178100262,
0.0294869225,
-0.0213007703,
0.0026994147,
0.0353400223,
0.0366043486,
0.0685529336,
-0.0071952776,
-0.0311708394,
-0.0102872895,
-0.0750776902,
0.0212711561,
-0.0649563149,
0.0114214122,
0.0715144426,
0.0449721292,
0.0136018666,
-0.0357370898,
0.0199202504,
-0.0408410802,
0.0260713622,
-0.0029219077,
0.0455225594,
0.0294789411,
0.041570764,
0.0112193255,
-0.0128021874,
0.014597537,
-0.0226364806,
-0.0310440008,
0.0381517559,
0.069936417,
-0.0246880352,
0.0249030553,
-0.0009615971,
0.0102848047,
0.0090421345,
-0.0345994905,
0.0621463917,
0.0005095249,
0.003680256,
-0.033928141,
0.0205796603,
-0.0309148803,
0.0460267365,
-0.0336880498,
0.0099459132,
0.0229430981,
0.0216940325,
-0.0072032134,
-0.0040587168,
-0.0308187492,
-0.0234856978,
-0.0238011442,
-0.0397440232,
0.0332914181,
-0.0753434747,
0.0022266801,
0.0373852029,
-0.0492209159,
0.0153650353,
1.92153619e-34,
-0.0006378947,
0.0079713147,
-0.0026311362,
0.0123080974,
0.0156449843,
0.0461423621,
-0.0152178686,
-0.0102896728,
-0.0149613367,
-0.0384897515,
0.0121655343
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15564v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15564v1 | Boot and Switch: Alternating Distillation for Zero-Shot Dense Retrieval | 2023-11-27T06:22:57 | 2023-11-27T06:22:57 | Fan Jiang, Qiongkai Xu, Tom Drummond, Trevor Cohn | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Neural 'dense' retrieval models are state of the art for many datasets,
however these models often exhibit limited domain transfer ability. Existing
approaches to adaptation are unwieldy, such as requiring explicit supervision,
complex model architectures, or massive external models. We present
$\texttt{ABEL}$, a simple but effective unsupervised method to enhance passage
retrieval in zero-shot settings. Our technique follows a straightforward loop:
a dense retriever learns from supervision signals provided by a reranker, and
subsequently, the reranker is updated based on feedback from the improved
retriever. By iterating this loop, the two components mutually enhance one
another's performance. Experimental results demonstrate that our unsupervised
$\texttt{ABEL}$ model outperforms both leading supervised and unsupervised
retrievers on the BEIR benchmark. Meanwhile, it exhibits strong adaptation
abilities to tasks and domains that were unseen during training. By either
fine-tuning $\texttt{ABEL}$ on labelled data or integrating it with existing
supervised dense retrievers, we achieve state-of-the-art
results.\footnote{Source code is available at
\url{https://github.com/Fantabulous-J/BootSwitch}.} | [
-0.0059020207,
0.0466971248,
0.0113648009,
0.0296959411,
0.0040369169,
0.0146419369,
0.0311989002,
0.0092558032,
-0.0045641414,
-0.0241542291,
-0.041263815,
-0.0244392175,
-0.047713533,
0.0722042993,
0.0030681454,
-0.0379556827,
0.0236043967,
-0.0109742749,
0.0076873284,
-0.0024398877,
-0.0349071398,
-0.0128037948,
-0.0242108572,
-0.0051571969,
0.0480643772,
0.0307935383,
-0.0249023531,
0.0409441777,
0.0262916684,
-0.0552754849,
0.0292249173,
0.0307612512,
0.0760339126,
0.0265437681,
0.0000022273,
-0.0291008297,
-0.0509329811,
-0.0182910971,
-0.0552077256,
-0.0304630063,
0.0094180088,
0.0258269403,
0.0460220799,
-0.0243167318,
-0.0190407354,
-0.03762253,
0.0323302224,
0.0296735018,
0.0405679829,
0.0657566562,
-0.0315307528,
-0.0563660562,
-0.01295033,
-0.0536149628,
0.0152567178,
-0.0652087852,
0.0331574902,
-0.027148664,
0.0039132023,
0.0526218675,
-0.0629061386,
0.0441731326,
0.025554629,
-0.0103851296,
0.0607827865,
0.0155621162,
-0.0500634164,
0.0287245233,
0.0215442088,
0.0759112686,
-0.0217478536,
-0.0147346631,
-0.0040967991,
0.0007976626,
-0.0139435185,
-0.0212749969,
-0.0677443668,
-0.0123770423,
0.0176872835,
0.0086184237,
-0.1082409546,
0.0410772823,
0.0128238751,
0.0002673405,
-0.0389978364,
-0.0083274301,
-0.0008529946,
-0.0108087473,
0.0066376338,
0.0436883457,
-0.0173524544,
-0.0137072764,
0.0250457283,
0.0255793463,
0.0254916195,
0.0081400676,
0.0032490529,
-0.0155064147,
-0.0418626182,
0.0323315151,
0.0673275962,
0.0245352294,
-0.0540430807,
0.0429493822,
-0.0413286164,
0.0402528346,
-0.0209278651,
0.0452125967,
-0.0207835045,
0.0144029176,
-0.0979004279,
0.0092609776,
-0.0380218923,
0.0656833202,
-0.0311516766,
0.0049004285,
-0.0117983557,
-0.0250799581,
0.0299870707,
-0.0403145254,
-0.0016476818,
0.025055008,
-0.0555872284,
-0.0307322759,
0.0031122013,
0.0783071294,
-0.0172537547,
-0.0049530934,
0.0401526503,
0.0026619476,
-0.0522630364,
0.0012630111,
0.025569601,
-0.0109798415,
0.0140101649,
0.0356472097,
-0.0677803233,
-0.0841613337,
-0.0570225753,
-0.0050398107,
-0.0352458768,
-0.040814057,
0.0066180201,
-0.0552440621,
0.0507170334,
-0.0111498004,
0.0081129726,
-0.0609230325,
0.0099857626,
0.0209456142,
-0.0318952911,
0.0375830159,
0.0059366152,
-0.0271025784,
0.0070813177,
0.04510675,
0.0155599602,
0.0425732173,
-0.0270745531,
0.0593338646,
0.0130679561,
0.0613933168,
0.0407058112,
-0.0021968882,
0.008226322,
0.014314563,
-0.0322285444,
-0.025365226,
-0.036557354,
-0.0100138569,
0.0650467053,
0.0027409075,
-0.0677912608,
-0.0297594685,
0.028534269,
0.0469150767,
0.0491434857,
-0.0411669202,
0.0444045179,
-0.0093863085,
-0.0387613289,
0.0369545892,
-0.0231353417,
0.0607471541,
0.0124517307,
-0.0007518912,
0.0256547034,
0.0093966592,
-0.042297937,
-0.0327452235,
0.0353832357,
0.0282833353,
-0.0295651406,
0.0151090203,
0.064780429,
0.0331173129,
-0.0192486513,
0.0107190162,
0.0337643139,
-0.0215404108,
0.0241271015,
-0.0194262937,
-0.0171445385,
0.0676506087,
0.0559110902,
-0.0314988606,
-0.0068632383,
-0.0219137184,
0.0454168208,
0.0153023759,
-0.033685185,
-0.0226830468,
0.0539923571,
-0.0820361078,
-0.0529952943,
-0.0161822736,
0.0143061681,
0.0409089625,
0.0011210325,
0.022091819,
0.0254446696,
-0.0531216115,
-0.0095330803,
0.0229109004,
-0.0519989543,
-0.058194492,
0.0196452364,
0.0010321365,
-0.0336922668,
0.007361847,
-0.0280661099,
-0.0226189774,
0.0437837206,
-0.031921275,
-0.0187581033,
-0.0200730413,
-0.0806913599,
-0.0157131143,
0.0029511375,
0.0207677092,
0.0158239473,
0.0153456265,
-0.0153060704,
-0.0315871723,
-0.0065494804,
0.0290085599,
-0.0250707921,
-0.0004519471,
0.0231042691,
0.0291481316,
-0.0179557689,
-0.0754967332,
0.038129542,
0.0044393358,
0.0071130889,
-0.0099527901,
0.0024975401,
0.0052340101,
-0.0292302538,
-0.0087328842,
0.0291001219,
-0.0216012839,
-0.0031483166,
0.0535875522,
-0.0379315615,
-0.0185840279,
0.0256818514,
-0.013202467,
0.0154597256,
-0.0238301195,
-0.005570868,
0.0066535678,
0.0180244986,
0.0002868888,
-0.0470360667,
-0.0011236691,
0.0083453301,
-0.0004997751,
0.011876828,
0.0177590735,
0.0262574572,
0.0181333479,
-0.0349467099,
-0.0271295588,
0.0112591693,
0.0206718743,
-0.0591309629,
-0.0532131456,
-0.0212338436,
0.0252917856,
0.0103392173,
0.0329364389,
-0.0187213551,
-0.0113477102,
-0.0050801868,
-0.0577836521,
-0.0043810583,
0.0533086509,
-0.0251210127,
0.0046440326,
0.0299908854,
-0.0242670774,
-0.0442627892,
0.0140184788,
-0.0292657334,
-0.0277824476,
-0.0177330282,
0.0245091207,
-0.0165589955,
0.0385508053,
-0.010707112,
0.0185004808,
-0.0319798626,
-0.0316190235,
-0.0081121502,
0.0059100199,
-0.0554247797,
0.0235440042,
-0.0133542959,
0.0370043255,
-0.0455964245,
-0.0101657435,
0.0409172699,
0.0062965099,
-0.0354383588,
-0.0465787835,
-0.0004349761,
-0.0349423699,
0.0739887431,
0.0078330608,
0.0011837106,
0.0210716259,
-0.0284954943,
-0.0360819623,
-0.0187890846,
0.003624791,
-0.0095847119,
0.0409296639,
-0.0244961474,
0.015181955,
-0.0143194674,
-0.0365936235,
-0.0396520123,
-0.0162819121,
0.0145644527,
0.0119169997,
-0.0379417054,
-0.0228941757,
-0.0770662725,
-0.0211921781,
0.024961656,
0.1012931094,
-0.0263431817,
-0.0077625979,
-0.033281967,
0.0650354922,
0.0287724249,
-0.0052935146,
-0.0298829786,
-0.0343396179,
0.0417387933,
0.0579904318,
-0.0041709403,
-0.0206157193,
-0.0039526839,
0.0248413626,
0.0374271385,
-0.0215205457,
0.0006422179,
-0.0001212993,
0.0621946231,
-0.0566005185,
-0.045152504,
0.0435797684,
0.0291656405,
-0.0502056815,
-0.0461267494,
0.0041394285,
0.0365133137,
0.0297559481,
0.0197126344,
-0.0668985173,
-0.029187873,
-0.0098034041,
0.0745444819,
0.0587164797,
-0.0219865032,
0.0143976565,
-0.1055554524,
0.0632271096,
0.0432620496,
-0.0136153968,
-0.0348649584,
-0.027745273,
0.0010262692,
-0.0172482543,
-0.0136257531,
0.044487562,
-0.0231010504,
-0.0192992967,
0.018065745,
0.0830850452,
-0.0467795245,
-0.0128544997,
-0.0279701855,
0.0130009372,
0.0449390039,
0.000410818,
0.0169924442,
0.0273292046,
0.0141708096,
-0.0646902025,
0.0057122041,
0.0185652226,
0.1084351465,
-0.0169150028,
-0.0050274539,
-0.0067584435,
0.0148358028,
-0.0124169495,
-0.0397463776,
-0.0308180172,
-0.0016920083,
-0.0018375086,
0.0008685251,
-0.0343039781,
-0.0245411266,
-0.0213626996,
0.0301201232,
-0.0183250532,
0.0218647048,
-0.0321832746,
0.0099621657,
0.0010004196,
-0.0627831966,
-0.0406690538,
-0.0043585575,
-0.0629903525,
-0.0119070271,
-0.0689495429,
-0.0207670815,
-0.004020466,
0.0717634037,
-0.0130898422,
0.0026533888,
-0.0330810472,
-0.0112554124,
-0.0592025071,
0.011577352,
-0.0553023331,
-0.0133572472,
-0.0712990761,
-0.0086077768,
0.0330003165,
-0.0115810735,
-0.0108639132,
-0.0116016781,
-0.0420415625,
-0.045520138,
0.0193404108,
0.046076715,
0.0183431022,
0.0498486497,
-0.0106396554,
-0.0351106487,
0.0773482025,
0.0356255099,
-0.0212768707,
0.0306865033,
0.0213125627,
-0.0255595036,
-0.0455557406,
0.0169817004,
-0.0544516668,
0.0712936595,
0.0149702523,
0.0110596437,
-0.0299629569,
-0.0121814664,
0.0147029916,
-0.0329635739,
0.0762950629,
0.0566995889,
0.0168128219,
-0.0284148622,
0.0132366633,
-0.0045164111,
-0.0085966857,
-0.0281719901,
0.0063076867,
0.0483850837,
-0.0032285384,
-0.0097318981,
0.0328321569,
0.0037161424,
0.0471969545,
-0.0740289837,
-0.0270475503,
0.0159370434,
-0.0073223654,
-0.0285387207,
0.0311760213,
0.0029381097,
0.0643898919,
0.011358087,
0.091256611,
-0.0292744692,
0.0523912087,
0.0250082724,
0.0042346111,
-0.0568923093,
0.0234272089,
-0.1044016629,
0.0261890553,
-0.0410450995,
0.0348034613,
0.0454719737,
-0.0252710357,
0.0307001844,
0.0341079086,
-0.0205208417,
-0.0405699611,
-0.0559979863,
0.0024105797,
0.0266686417,
-0.0239126738,
0.0561114438,
0.0086723538,
0.0562218726,
0.0740357488,
0.0319873281,
0.0318726115,
0.0197134949,
0.0166367423,
-0.0104591018,
0.011859823,
0.0432678126,
0.054085847,
0.030835161,
-0.0028184245,
-0.0004076721,
-0.0249519125,
0.0361143425,
-0.0410456471,
0.0205798484,
-0.0026727563,
0.0359816551,
0.0120221181,
0.015610151,
-0.0129468348,
-0.0293948669,
-0.0273260828,
0.0367316492,
-0.0110459151,
-0.0186665636,
-6.639507273e-33,
-0.0320331641,
0.0065836608,
0.0113402214,
-0.0312494989,
-0.0368279591,
-0.0061426223,
-0.0392477065,
0.0089233946,
-0.0280541684,
0.0214826595,
0.0021611049,
0.0122016855,
0.0260419548,
0.0160588045,
0.0022718897,
-0.0253056604,
0.0850700811,
-0.0043054591,
-0.0440563336,
0.0204046834,
0.0633188635,
0.0747065619,
0.010709242,
-0.0610169806,
-0.0324787349,
-0.0437245443,
-0.0002608217,
0.0207869802,
0.0702288598,
0.0195484608,
0.0119650532,
0.003943922,
0.0170809478,
-0.0360220112,
-0.0292878635,
-0.0182896834,
-0.1189540997,
-0.0208763648,
-0.05489235,
-0.020005038,
0.0044893478,
-0.0160146002,
0.0405035131,
-0.0479920991,
0.0213153083,
-0.0352683999,
0.0231953599,
-0.0191901624,
-0.0143609764,
-0.0211083964,
-0.0336337276,
0.0231311787,
0.000081191,
-0.0724984109,
0.0578452311,
0.0473439433,
0.0296908449,
0.0110146366,
-0.0603894256,
0.0030034408,
-0.0363076665,
0.090640977,
-0.0048115887,
0.0147346715,
-0.0421526097,
0.0700554699,
0.0270862859,
-0.024356693,
-0.0082520293,
-0.0557823293,
0.0379522555,
0.0239886958,
0.0062329154,
0.0156381261,
0.0659057721,
-0.0141604058,
-0.0516417176,
0.0362310149,
-0.0144431824,
0.0283514578,
0.003861014,
0.0683643967,
-0.0148858884,
-0.0224686842,
0.0079593407,
-0.0497623943,
-0.0174139831,
-0.0375267044,
0.0435833372,
0.0441901088,
-0.035858158,
-0.008190129,
0.0823981017,
-0.0213651359,
0.0225363951,
0.01398254,
-0.0171654075,
0.0438588299,
0.0225777179,
0.0042004013,
-0.0291342903,
-0.0110531235,
0.0766512603,
0.017297281,
-0.0259541646,
-0.0017049597,
0.0413176864,
0.0225426741,
-0.0400271453,
-0.0108514586,
-0.0093169361,
-0.0013369822,
0.0109403692,
0.0679073408,
-0.0083246669,
0.0318243094,
-0.0016576846,
0.0977606773,
0.0173660051,
0.0031839816,
-0.0062895222,
0.0267571565,
0.0235068053,
0.0099862199,
-0.0072740181,
0.0299207456,
-0.004047737,
0.0377380177,
-0.017037997,
-0.0616953261,
0.0043802103,
0.035437718,
2.914e-7,
0.0373914577,
0.0022175347,
0.0438704379,
-0.053454455,
-0.0127318902,
-0.0014230345,
-0.0435105301,
0.0150200026,
0.0210327003,
-0.0437341183,
-0.0015453495,
0.0647719279,
0.0121965408,
0.0007189552,
-0.0798566863,
-0.0128607424,
0.0035868217,
-0.0407222956,
-0.0376016945,
-0.0725158229,
0.0509743318,
0.0542514659,
-0.0061251605,
0.0040448587,
0.0234652292,
-0.0319404639,
0.0385182761,
0.063493371,
0.0202638842,
-0.0044776793,
0.0018408868,
0.0383389294,
-0.0359774232,
-0.0094333123,
0.0019116463,
0.0630384758,
0.0389516354,
0.0465963893,
-0.0359990038,
-0.0551825874,
0.0236015804,
0.0485094488,
0.0321251526,
0.0050551407,
0.05666041,
-0.0596117824,
-0.0027380635,
0.0183455143,
-0.0979010239,
0.0125859883,
-0.0040453081,
0.042098023,
-0.0277746748,
0.0285806041,
0.0151542109,
0.0508828796,
-0.0417119451,
-0.1081983149,
0.0107966093,
0.0065433523,
-0.0140810786,
0.0147441858,
-0.0193423778,
-0.0208232459,
-0.0243989415,
-0.0508472286,
-0.0267697554,
2.661551324e-34,
0.0302740894,
0.0068433541,
0.0170828737,
0.0140467463,
0.0068797683,
-0.0160514507,
-0.0801364854,
0.0162048675,
0.0014083883,
-0.0604904629,
-0.0088100769
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15563v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15563v1 | Noisy Self-Training with Synthetic Queries for Dense Retrieval | 2023-11-27T06:19:50 | 2023-11-27T06:19:50 | Fan Jiang, Tom Drummond, Trevor Cohn | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.IR | Although existing neural retrieval models reveal promising results when
training data is abundant and the performance keeps improving as training data
increases, collecting high-quality annotated data is prohibitively costly. To
this end, we introduce a novel noisy self-training framework combined with
synthetic queries, showing that neural retrievers can be improved in a
self-evolution manner with no reliance on any external models. Experimental
results show that our method improves consistently over existing methods on
both general-domain (e.g., MS-MARCO) and out-of-domain (i.e., BEIR) retrieval
benchmarks. Extra analysis on low-resource settings reveals that our method is
data efficient and outperforms competitive baselines, with as little as 30% of
labelled training data. Further extending the framework for reranker training
demonstrates that the proposed method is general and yields additional gains on
tasks of diverse domains.\footnote{Source code is available at
\url{https://github.com/Fantabulous-J/Self-Training-DPR}} | [
0.0103501445,
0.0425116308,
0.0118258055,
0.0385656506,
0.0363331921,
-0.0256409794,
-0.0090900473,
-0.0113045312,
0.0488925129,
-0.0229406394,
-0.0674282536,
-0.006897856,
-0.0787852928,
0.042706579,
0.019252399,
0.0027437045,
0.0269523486,
0.0132045168,
0.0085699642,
-0.0284264907,
-0.0422407314,
0.0003794006,
0.0170550086,
-0.0068866592,
-0.0006956302,
0.010322215,
-0.0273200758,
0.050894741,
-0.0367831737,
-0.0527884625,
0.0411915369,
0.0342163332,
0.0617092848,
0.0217039119,
0.0000018689,
-0.0528016277,
-0.0596855208,
-0.0072882604,
-0.0430429466,
0.0037119335,
-0.0038205325,
0.0347058177,
0.0385085382,
-0.0065049967,
-0.058525335,
-0.0168116558,
0.0003918958,
0.0372401178,
0.053698387,
0.0632367581,
-0.002671646,
-0.029055154,
0.0153212799,
-0.0590195507,
0.0073216753,
-0.0569706485,
0.0121901957,
-0.0269317403,
-0.0187667478,
0.0510456301,
0.0249547027,
0.0393966287,
0.0264343414,
0.0045660576,
0.0739503801,
0.0045222514,
-0.051310733,
0.0212906059,
0.0110514853,
0.0549104661,
-0.0298653282,
-0.0196263995,
0.0049140449,
0.0255173314,
0.0345613174,
-0.0291385222,
-0.0023060297,
-0.0236126482,
-0.0118438033,
0.0292592011,
-0.0508299731,
0.0716226324,
0.0276136696,
0.0161131863,
-0.0379945189,
0.0300170165,
-0.0068940846,
-0.0441592,
0.0160619095,
0.0153787369,
-0.004832,
0.0224738885,
0.020375954,
0.0050853249,
0.0187958684,
-0.0002627872,
-0.0022102508,
-0.0098540941,
0.0035560201,
-0.040252503,
0.0187900737,
0.0094800917,
-0.0534822345,
0.0739088431,
-0.0081294589,
0.0131922374,
-0.0123483641,
0.0159514174,
-0.0381428972,
0.0056646583,
-0.0264688041,
-0.0384975709,
-0.0696011484,
0.089279823,
-0.0437767543,
0.0040005506,
-0.0249358956,
-0.0094894515,
0.0084300563,
-0.0388180092,
0.0287255179,
0.0292212088,
-0.0890707597,
0.0112931216,
-0.0621351711,
-0.0117096491,
0.0074833124,
-0.0206186194,
0.01043336,
-0.0221994612,
-0.0168540366,
-0.018982986,
0.0026217219,
-0.0307772681,
0.0112268906,
0.0576466583,
-0.0466136001,
-0.0509735011,
-0.0109131755,
-0.0101974802,
-0.0059409714,
-0.0059351968,
0.0208487678,
-0.0191171877,
0.0190045182,
-0.0438867919,
-0.0141519476,
-0.0730341524,
0.0108792661,
0.019392252,
0.017831469,
0.0492095239,
-0.0506040156,
0.004960597,
0.0499393642,
0.0177290086,
0.0343238413,
0.053928148,
-0.021144066,
0.0387938879,
0.0451970398,
0.0331034772,
0.0406627022,
-0.0064341603,
0.0401433446,
-0.0318983085,
-0.0036310656,
0.0426858813,
-0.0307874829,
0.0176102594,
0.0170505289,
0.0114979828,
-0.0511873364,
-0.0703447014,
-0.0083344448,
0.0115031973,
0.0827429667,
0.0187947731,
0.0018718641,
0.0013398923,
-0.0187931601,
0.0117422566,
-0.0297867879,
0.0411683135,
-0.0040969346,
-0.0019137103,
0.0486697033,
0.004199056,
-0.061686527,
-0.0764523223,
0.0337568969,
0.0494070873,
-0.0813301057,
0.0438332856,
0.0513845533,
0.0527882837,
0.0160792284,
0.0201432426,
0.0121842064,
-0.0150024742,
0.0200125463,
-0.0406607203,
-0.0159758553,
0.0586628467,
0.0487874299,
-0.0778117254,
0.0031413874,
0.0056996886,
-0.0097466642,
-0.0029754068,
0.0130002657,
-0.0229475684,
0.0473559797,
-0.0401589312,
-0.0384056754,
-0.0357097387,
0.0027621244,
0.0330345295,
0.0109674009,
-0.0113426205,
0.0611983463,
-0.0618859753,
-0.0205616914,
0.0164420586,
-0.0143809449,
-0.0689186379,
0.0602291524,
0.0114903133,
0.0055819429,
0.0148434062,
-0.0409398042,
0.0051533738,
0.0616868697,
-0.0174475908,
-0.0265093222,
-0.0068218363,
-0.0632809699,
-0.0076325187,
0.0494450033,
0.0173738804,
-0.0060727959,
0.030790804,
-0.0012721149,
-0.0146682747,
0.0157508943,
-0.0197453555,
-0.0227792542,
-0.0885622948,
0.0037474022,
0.0273435358,
-0.0055564367,
-0.0447297804,
0.0443913415,
0.0249067247,
-0.0146980872,
-0.0327122211,
0.0020488335,
0.0378644243,
-0.0873590261,
-0.0356352068,
-0.0260360185,
-0.036533732,
0.0255039148,
0.0158780199,
-0.0209030639,
-0.0200400259,
-0.0043716943,
-0.0319542736,
0.0057630064,
-0.0184892416,
-0.0384625904,
-0.0052441917,
0.0120507237,
0.0139065217,
-0.0433015749,
-0.0258130673,
-0.0406953469,
-0.0146888262,
0.001229168,
0.0317164361,
0.0147510571,
0.0401095748,
-0.0346822962,
-0.0635022819,
0.0024401844,
0.0114725297,
-0.0179479737,
-0.0222137328,
-0.0100226877,
0.0125141693,
-0.0394509621,
0.0561500303,
-0.036263071,
0.0065987888,
0.0072519421,
-0.0866574124,
0.003995568,
0.0724356472,
0.0360600241,
-0.0044603585,
0.028095739,
-0.0155086489,
-0.100757055,
0.0526260138,
-0.0488481633,
0.0100930668,
0.0229121838,
0.0121490192,
0.0325924978,
0.0039427136,
-0.0309193935,
-0.0183772594,
-0.0160073247,
0.0114454934,
0.0241639037,
-0.0704536214,
-0.0923693925,
0.0448474698,
0.0092267953,
0.0322214402,
-0.0260912254,
-0.0099327732,
0.0710635111,
0.0101716295,
-0.0090401685,
-0.0355906934,
-0.0202506315,
-0.0528129376,
0.0403910279,
-0.0296087619,
0.0185780115,
0.010697173,
-0.0178457443,
-0.0039657145,
-0.0148544768,
0.0225198995,
-0.0507774204,
0.0211549401,
0.0072245803,
0.0426334962,
0.0196912885,
-0.0923298299,
-0.0313672796,
-0.0317364857,
0.047086373,
-0.016014101,
-0.0417312831,
0.0077954638,
-0.0063510491,
0.0108416229,
-0.0157033931,
0.0723148808,
-0.0383208208,
-0.0229016617,
-0.0014654435,
0.0212201569,
0.0260449518,
0.0195702687,
-0.0212296136,
0.0035521043,
0.0070535201,
0.0466090702,
0.020380361,
-0.0591837205,
-0.0470275544,
0.0216359869,
0.0375423841,
-0.0064048897,
-0.0036639303,
-0.0087723546,
0.0129177552,
-0.0131727271,
-0.0478728078,
0.0502989441,
-0.0136351762,
-0.0273962803,
-0.0495006368,
-0.0166180395,
0.0161010902,
0.0619025193,
0.0679760724,
-0.0428939946,
0.0069643469,
-0.0072561814,
0.0775407404,
0.0200679693,
-0.0269762818,
0.0171169098,
-0.1319631487,
0.0645962283,
-0.0122700641,
0.0008063008,
-0.0052440097,
-0.0089361137,
-0.0147662675,
-0.0194723755,
-0.0304206815,
0.036012467,
-0.0150226159,
-0.0197854005,
0.0338386893,
0.0135022067,
-0.0327656716,
-0.0329146348,
-0.0488635078,
0.0189925265,
0.022217093,
-0.0022543876,
0.0197879244,
-0.0236580335,
0.0392909311,
-0.0222179294,
0.0103775673,
-0.0078907479,
0.0885416493,
-0.0175898448,
-0.0331307799,
0.0043534106,
-0.0291180406,
0.016668966,
0.0213070679,
-0.0079910439,
0.017072618,
-0.0112909209,
0.0349490084,
-0.0552688353,
-0.0262326691,
-0.0184813421,
0.0214131065,
-0.0185170937,
0.0444370843,
-0.0332188383,
-0.0001551791,
0.0361182429,
-0.0222438388,
-0.0432010107,
0.0182039049,
-0.026509596,
-0.0224030521,
-0.0517459661,
-0.045452442,
-0.0123864561,
0.0876901224,
-0.0192031376,
0.0026388131,
-0.0331801698,
-0.0099774795,
-0.0754218176,
0.0208068658,
-0.0354083888,
-0.0466509536,
-0.028799437,
0.0208994821,
0.0603521317,
-0.0417327546,
-0.0143597964,
-0.0568749048,
0.0145843327,
-0.028493531,
0.0037746595,
0.1043116152,
0.0148892915,
0.0579028763,
-0.0318736173,
-0.054930225,
0.0492738448,
0.0953561068,
-0.0566730835,
-0.0326048955,
0.0346846133,
-0.0178957079,
-0.0204671808,
0.0094993571,
-0.0488740504,
0.0648328438,
0.0008056627,
0.0198265295,
-0.0303508602,
0.0008166686,
0.0556780398,
0.0344458632,
0.0999538079,
0.0390559696,
0.039906051,
-0.037248157,
0.0135124754,
-0.029006809,
-0.0371218733,
-0.0470416211,
0.0471670106,
0.0296176244,
0.0094446195,
-0.0118054897,
0.0014395518,
0.0135786152,
0.0352406539,
-0.0347837992,
-0.0830509365,
-0.0040720794,
0.0033220463,
-0.0245864429,
0.0063146697,
-0.0127162477,
0.0671805665,
0.0618485324,
0.0680499375,
0.0075397715,
-0.0452398919,
0.0343665928,
0.0197295006,
-0.0289326124,
0.0284154434,
-0.0717365816,
-0.0568558685,
-0.0637023151,
-0.0104111396,
0.0554272495,
-0.00709265,
-0.0223030578,
0.0574959815,
-0.0125468662,
-0.0179332122,
-0.0421558656,
0.0064764027,
0.0054074991,
-0.0175859146,
0.0364413485,
-0.0093618473,
0.0189457759,
0.0694490969,
0.0217237305,
0.025160227,
-0.0114179524,
-0.0019656084,
-0.0354890935,
0.0007383377,
0.0422032811,
0.0155522535,
-0.0132160373,
-0.0335974246,
0.0263443701,
-0.0306001548,
0.0448621176,
0.0194471944,
-0.0137394005,
0.0144699449,
0.0554633476,
0.0734585673,
0.014419741,
-0.0199908968,
-0.0377755351,
-0.0284245685,
-0.0006163113,
-0.0054050838,
0.0230700262,
-6.248584137e-33,
-0.0032955436,
0.0049236892,
0.0401578695,
-0.0293801166,
-0.0125474278,
-0.0133646457,
-0.0161722805,
-0.0222982075,
-0.0182029046,
-0.0012289825,
-0.0526711456,
0.0274399407,
0.0110573983,
0.0032515109,
0.0297752116,
-0.0289655551,
0.0839315578,
-0.009069751,
-0.0089618042,
-0.0100504961,
0.0159736034,
0.0708532035,
0.002941326,
-0.089711614,
-0.0561652295,
0.0075720414,
-0.011756002,
0.0774487257,
0.0215127673,
0.0462521948,
0.0119357258,
0.0235791989,
0.0207933281,
-0.0295286309,
0.0154127348,
-0.0397092961,
-0.1137894765,
-0.036218904,
-0.0794332251,
-0.0309320185,
-0.0086053992,
0.0184201896,
0.0543100126,
-0.0166743435,
-0.0184350908,
0.0017952139,
0.0288977772,
0.003864968,
-0.0279472768,
-0.0631742552,
0.0354710072,
0.0293494854,
0.0053176517,
-0.004097892,
0.0352314934,
0.0344193988,
0.0285483859,
0.0038180863,
-0.0664190203,
0.0269202404,
-0.0678568557,
0.0513974242,
-0.0328282937,
0.0069892891,
0.0056108693,
0.0416310616,
0.0760686547,
0.021177901,
0.0025421358,
-0.028988529,
0.016140366,
0.0649455562,
0.0294728912,
0.0333035029,
0.0435215272,
-0.0303793475,
-0.0390189104,
0.0693400875,
-0.0269756652,
0.0075287661,
-0.0349321961,
0.0252816621,
-0.0529344641,
-0.0053633652,
0.0134142246,
-0.0120143667,
-0.0343693979,
-0.002643062,
0.0242369268,
0.0735789761,
-0.0320902839,
0.0246879552,
0.0066458695,
-0.0248709656,
0.0087447762,
-0.017454451,
0.0206033606,
-0.0359451547,
0.0130917775,
0.0266475715,
-0.0109117106,
-0.0360509157,
0.0109011019,
0.0452739932,
-0.0193119645,
0.020103626,
-0.007641091,
0.0140542798,
-0.0477390364,
0.0046277661,
0.0226405878,
0.0060278242,
0.0043446827,
0.026033774,
-0.0121829668,
-0.0029200874,
0.0111902189,
0.03476597,
0.046429906,
0.0250762906,
-0.0573224016,
0.0241077505,
0.0458925478,
-0.0105579998,
0.0301521383,
0.0224977937,
-0.0198047068,
0.0210717451,
0.0128074531,
-0.0650533661,
-0.0033152418,
0.0411161855,
2.556e-7,
0.0246377233,
0.0102436524,
0.0106379623,
-0.0058620772,
-0.0209249612,
0.0174532477,
-0.0214351434,
0.0403097905,
0.0451023132,
0.0014664544,
0.0226066615,
0.0226637255,
0.0140021807,
0.0165103395,
-0.110860303,
-0.0150110153,
-0.0577322133,
-0.0103213741,
-0.025251342,
-0.0617342144,
-0.0148981595,
0.0538704656,
-0.012574424,
-0.01502416,
0.0194533579,
-0.0633011907,
0.044771675,
0.0463162772,
0.0266800541,
0.0080220317,
0.0462482981,
0.0674523786,
-0.0232828148,
-0.0381830186,
-0.0086252447,
0.0882534534,
0.0343228318,
0.0303606577,
-0.0041390681,
-0.0640354902,
0.0313795507,
0.0306448545,
0.015978191,
0.0037993614,
0.0467991233,
-0.0660449341,
0.0113907233,
0.0253806692,
-0.0447268374,
-0.0241789855,
0.016777141,
0.0066811047,
-0.0139533021,
0.0129599897,
0.0113991955,
0.0117232827,
0.0046318783,
-0.0940292776,
0.0138525432,
-0.0259106886,
-0.0289753415,
0.044345431,
-0.025770314,
0.0373053886,
-0.0194409769,
0.0035409722,
0.017594276,
1.648922405e-34,
0.0393293835,
0.0290006753,
0.0178433713,
0.0108193168,
-0.0033905702,
-0.0084240576,
-0.0415677987,
0.0049521974,
0.0115252892,
-0.0383456014,
-0.0241239201
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15548v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15548v1 | Deficiency of Large Language Models in Finance: An Empirical Examination of Hallucination | 2023-11-27T05:27:13 | 2023-11-27T05:27:13 | Haoqiang Kang, Xiao-Yang Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, q-fin.ST | The hallucination issue is recognized as a fundamental deficiency of large
language models (LLMs), especially when applied to fields such as finance,
education, and law. Despite the growing concerns, there has been a lack of
empirical investigation. In this paper, we provide an empirical examination of
LLMs' hallucination behaviors in financial tasks. First, we empirically
investigate LLM model's ability of explaining financial concepts and
terminologies. Second, we assess LLM models' capacity of querying historical
stock prices. Third, to alleviate the hallucination issue, we evaluate the
efficacy of four practical methods, including few-shot learning, Decoding by
Contrasting Layers (DoLa), the Retrieval Augmentation Generation (RAG) method
and the prompt-based tool learning method for a function to generate a query
command. Finally, our major finding is that off-the-shelf LLMs experience
serious hallucination behaviors in financial tasks. Therefore, there is an
urgent need to call for research efforts in mitigating LLMs' hallucination. | [
-0.014533137,
0.087849088,
-0.0302602891,
0.0119189266,
0.0028775726,
0.035442289,
0.0288441051,
0.0385128669,
-0.0024891642,
-0.0083502624,
-0.0273403451,
-0.0531925261,
-0.0107345693,
-0.0115243969,
0.0384139642,
-0.0413077921,
0.0408673733,
-0.0441571586,
0.0002270262,
-0.0366373993,
-0.0149409855,
-0.0240845215,
0.0208756514,
0.026287742,
0.0479487665,
-0.0195390712,
-0.0206789915,
-0.0180957634,
-0.0320996456,
0.0042264978,
-0.0182950702,
0.0152951907,
0.0305422973,
0.085848555,
0.0000022702,
-0.0575920604,
-0.0264128316,
0.0029861107,
-0.0485375859,
0.0027593467,
0.0287771374,
-0.0149701526,
0.0360468142,
-0.005401406,
-0.0364631005,
0.0058362652,
0.0606159121,
0.0704668462,
0.0403332338,
0.0709300786,
0.0168301594,
-0.0858825743,
0.0103426799,
-0.0286175851,
0.0577089749,
-0.0657102987,
0.0311660543,
0.0497332551,
0.0158682149,
-0.0126484884,
-0.0461262614,
0.0376440696,
0.0126738157,
0.0215773564,
0.0261850599,
0.0117527284,
-0.041385185,
-0.0084161665,
-0.0093971686,
0.0367700346,
0.009049247,
0.0120515451,
0.0152786663,
-0.0002699445,
0.0189805105,
0.0501275472,
-0.082506001,
0.0561391041,
-0.0098688556,
0.0019588787,
0.0145224845,
-0.0273762345,
0.0451577008,
0.0099368002,
-0.0804213285,
0.0306386929,
-0.0374377742,
-0.0480940305,
0.0460581928,
0.0093058376,
0.0040508886,
0.0000020832,
0.008830104,
0.0290556643,
-0.0129921455,
0.0094794324,
0.0242121946,
-0.0253930204,
0.0153659843,
-0.0955403149,
0.0478554554,
0.0348231494,
-0.0360000655,
0.0437687077,
-0.0700937137,
0.0368076339,
-0.011905415,
0.01306393,
-0.0196886584,
0.0373020023,
-0.0791652873,
-0.0285518896,
-0.0577850044,
0.1016465798,
-0.0378864817,
-0.0412932113,
-0.0506567173,
0.0090265544,
-0.0201130118,
0.027065279,
-0.0399053358,
-0.0263031852,
0.0108941644,
-0.0371440798,
-0.0262281541,
-0.004031335,
-0.027912898,
0.0008373136,
0.0002743127,
-0.045573283,
-0.0017874861,
0.0110610062,
-0.0470551848,
-0.0257420987,
-0.0048930789,
0.0662812069,
0.0255021024,
-0.0136295576,
-0.0666898116,
-0.0676104724,
0.0068306504,
-0.0326835923,
0.0124263773,
-0.0402033329,
-0.02426848,
-0.0151997972,
-0.0143141486,
-0.0240954105,
0.0122065088,
-0.0129556078,
-0.0361698903,
0.0697759315,
-0.0011016871,
-0.0247968156,
0.0240715891,
-0.0065893079,
-0.0068014548,
0.0864895806,
-0.0333869494,
0.031357836,
0.0159977283,
-0.0126539338,
0.0267883558,
0.032375697,
0.0107045481,
-0.044228185,
-0.0678148642,
0.0074607497,
0.0086757103,
-0.0014233433,
0.036676906,
0.0063834107,
-0.0518561229,
-0.0021729402,
0.0474693142,
0.0229244716,
0.0784302652,
0.0087936195,
-0.0104033183,
0.0148220109,
0.0173527244,
0.0239340868,
-0.0153784845,
0.0122008333,
-0.0377891995,
0.0344479121,
-0.0002406167,
-0.0159657877,
-0.039901454,
-0.0535748452,
0.0080594961,
-0.0004907358,
-0.0375529416,
0.0426980145,
0.0553332567,
-0.0243741963,
-0.0347580276,
0.0661882609,
0.0269400328,
0.0040097381,
-0.0095520969,
-0.0508729853,
0.0187190026,
0.1011297703,
0.0285083782,
-0.024213817,
0.0263209306,
-0.0196470134,
0.0245673954,
0.0593134053,
0.0293496437,
0.0091897771,
-0.0304932874,
-0.0563320667,
-0.0079651233,
-0.0035383906,
0.0377920941,
0.0232044552,
-0.0310388599,
-0.0229585227,
0.0101819085,
-0.040720053,
-0.0340171047,
0.0205918513,
-0.0195830651,
-0.0572854914,
-0.0062593855,
-0.016697742,
-0.023075128,
0.019907549,
-0.0016156676,
0.0234626587,
-0.0083591007,
-0.0196142811,
-0.0490613282,
-0.0061664674,
-0.0518395007,
0.0123694902,
-0.0106723187,
0.0202768166,
0.0007911082,
-0.0205225553,
-0.0193761606,
-0.013753905,
0.0095388452,
-0.0299582724,
0.0692297593,
-0.0590520166,
0.0132349227,
-0.024987014,
0.0295996051,
-0.0274192709,
0.0769063085,
-0.0119840503,
0.005189742,
-0.0044210902,
0.0162678268,
-0.0115133952,
-0.0311436728,
0.0160460398,
0.0406715795,
-0.0151572768,
0.0503673926,
0.0164864995,
-0.0460841246,
0.0020125888,
-0.022518415,
-0.0333250351,
-0.0348044224,
-0.0182279013,
0.0141155208,
-0.0193510745,
-0.0164629351,
-0.0003649666,
-0.0280194487,
0.0015345095,
0.0220424011,
-0.0290384684,
0.0361036621,
0.0231341496,
0.015598461,
-0.0481252559,
-0.0189966597,
-0.0231878739,
0.0039969631,
0.0475627184,
0.0164480619,
-0.0441185161,
-0.0426769815,
0.0374400839,
0.009343884,
-0.0239627995,
-0.0168557875,
0.0372634903,
0.0170305558,
-0.0410182551,
-0.0064284354,
0.0757247657,
0.0070175789,
0.0748681203,
0.0053435569,
-0.0094273519,
-0.063674733,
-0.0073103514,
-0.0196489412,
-0.0313983113,
-0.0293996502,
-0.0112546831,
0.0062150978,
0.0558822304,
-0.023900874,
0.0312559567,
-0.0630137399,
0.0741838738,
-0.01670569,
-0.0291048829,
-0.0606391281,
0.0165303629,
-0.0162092149,
0.0505812839,
0.0156597067,
-0.0477098264,
0.0491567962,
0.0073253559,
-0.018421784,
0.0213845614,
-0.0108031947,
-0.0447949842,
0.039762862,
-0.0360762998,
0.0162855089,
-0.0099171018,
-0.0877260938,
-0.04314873,
-0.0105131725,
0.0224934891,
-0.0501136221,
0.0331774168,
-0.0048668766,
0.0039154552,
0.0090531111,
0.0166002568,
-0.0225954689,
-0.0505592749,
-0.0161459167,
0.0012191504,
0.0062120026,
-0.0123385424,
-0.0536527969,
0.0140280994,
-0.0000842028,
-0.0330597125,
-0.014471516,
-0.042473916,
0.01360464,
-0.0170513652,
0.0478291176,
-0.0099143479,
0.0428124815,
-0.0723251179,
0.0957934484,
0.0047003799,
0.0382542945,
0.0046007209,
-0.0013260468,
-0.0114773214,
0.0133097311,
-0.0467389487,
-0.0216533765,
0.0383975804,
-0.0453689806,
-0.0686985925,
-0.0089564156,
0.0987783149,
0.0090837106,
-0.0159684885,
0.0004847349,
-0.0479453057,
0.0178186204,
-0.0143714789,
0.0244369749,
-0.0942180455,
0.0058406573,
-0.0034520535,
0.0465641171,
0.0124803493,
-0.0315532386,
0.005756069,
-0.1486776024,
0.0561837777,
0.0134938341,
-0.0137998136,
0.0080679534,
-0.0330230743,
-0.051526051,
-0.0140317837,
0.0554624312,
0.0496034808,
-0.0231932234,
0.002220449,
0.0411371887,
-0.0342366695,
-0.0096374592,
-0.0033628093,
0.0011861153,
-0.0096463291,
0.0680656508,
-0.000490026,
-0.0350286216,
-0.0328222103,
-0.0293055065,
0.0176897366,
0.0125398627,
0.0011226223,
0.046586249,
0.0131690884,
-0.0174487904,
0.0308878161,
0.0191585328,
-0.0081937863,
0.0297546871,
0.0057692425,
0.0317499489,
-0.0403554067,
-0.0496062376,
0.0013929992,
0.0151563287,
-0.0405291282,
0.078554444,
0.0133849829,
-0.0318581648,
-0.0308283474,
-0.0326151177,
0.0013260313,
-0.0561521947,
-0.0067065493,
0.0472216606,
0.0457221121,
-0.0085919769,
-0.0474799499,
-0.0531387664,
0.0116421254,
0.0568880625,
-0.0028338779,
0.083977893,
0.013360478,
-0.0071069649,
-0.0143644903,
0.0069588171,
-0.0472085811,
0.00514594,
-0.0401743874,
0.0087525314,
0.0022415614,
-0.0367010534,
-0.0194381289,
-0.0210522059,
-0.0453435108,
-0.0446010716,
0.0360551849,
0.0092637651,
0.0360118747,
-0.0050044935,
0.0047800075,
-0.0134748537,
0.0423621982,
0.0874627903,
-0.0136514371,
-0.0054446608,
0.0504531637,
-0.0054387753,
0.0001722601,
0.031981077,
-0.0618340969,
0.0094923582,
-0.0048862048,
0.0275857709,
-0.0328971632,
0.0541699827,
0.0364897847,
0.0119365547,
0.0102991695,
-0.000815418,
-0.0269672088,
-0.0006561324,
-0.0007012784,
-0.0104590543,
0.0120053971,
-0.0096440688,
-0.0380745418,
0.0714872926,
-0.0127938967,
0.0313308425,
0.0078018731,
0.003514603,
-0.0116138598,
-0.0318438746,
0.0162430201,
-0.0199333467,
-0.0077384645,
0.0532698594,
-0.0147582805,
-0.0123021454,
0.0130102467,
0.0378678441,
0.0200579781,
0.0174913686,
0.0531958155,
0.0164130796,
-0.0006813869,
-0.0110752666,
-0.0321496315,
-0.0454945937,
-0.1085765213,
0.0180039667,
0.0306142718,
0.0388867296,
-0.0340161063,
-0.0041396981,
-0.0344172902,
0.0282564107,
0.0016660969,
-0.0099911634,
0.0414908305,
-0.0477384478,
0.0170298349,
0.0225742776,
-0.0445953533,
-0.050626982,
0.1014050022,
0.0263414774,
0.016485896,
-0.0364057459,
0.0054426226,
-0.0194732882,
-0.0654736757,
0.0588459969,
0.0174406189,
-0.0259172339,
-0.0136668608,
-0.1010530517,
-0.034540616,
-0.0184766427,
-0.0338306502,
-0.0208141301,
-0.0275251362,
0.010640542,
0.0934938714,
0.0098013962,
0.0388352908,
-0.013873429,
0.0219864249,
-0.0085846838,
0.0041810921,
-0.0234322324,
-6.531895173e-33,
-0.023074368,
-0.0331422612,
0.0592054166,
-0.0212947726,
0.0139899198,
-0.0176149532,
-0.0216786861,
0.0208534915,
-0.0092341136,
-0.0068866792,
0.0141949877,
0.0103927394,
0.0256366283,
0.0140678138,
0.057811603,
0.0009853158,
0.037384022,
0.0012897908,
0.0106142862,
-0.0174918361,
0.0218154304,
0.0751841217,
0.0360723622,
-0.0200552661,
0.0413750596,
-0.0055387844,
-0.0179699287,
-0.0176854432,
0.0466135703,
0.041531574,
0.0017427811,
0.0678977817,
-0.0040713679,
-0.0991353765,
-0.0394217074,
-0.0153103424,
-0.0207584575,
-0.0186013263,
0.0272458661,
0.0612073876,
0.0377527364,
-0.0100069605,
0.0371090695,
-0.0327289179,
-0.0090543488,
-0.0073528853,
0.0248480365,
-0.0424171612,
-0.0409171395,
0.0015757988,
-0.093437396,
0.019596396,
0.0156270135,
0.0388157256,
0.0622981749,
0.076684542,
-0.0154650044,
0.0319814086,
-0.051182922,
0.0289979205,
0.0238095168,
0.0087826904,
0.0341970213,
0.0524158403,
0.0060391705,
0.0540508106,
0.0486088321,
0.0342199244,
-0.0215948187,
0.0087041305,
0.0496805497,
0.0734629035,
0.0197994485,
0.0126222223,
0.0601798445,
-0.0284514949,
-0.020881854,
-0.0154763414,
-0.0169899557,
0.0310614444,
0.0575337261,
0.0314416662,
-0.0480326973,
-0.0593861602,
-0.0126589267,
0.0237628967,
-0.0233241115,
-0.0261398107,
0.0365049988,
0.0142392721,
0.0012165878,
-0.0064255726,
0.0240438301,
-0.0642432794,
-0.0630765408,
-0.0107150311,
-0.0008178278,
0.0121414587,
-0.0129343309,
-0.0051703891,
-0.0367446728,
-0.051881399,
-0.0335476175,
-0.0036478473,
0.0149763487,
0.0103555238,
0.0210485943,
-0.0189450271,
-0.0442522876,
-0.0330956317,
-0.0320696421,
-0.0224137418,
0.0486966185,
-0.0046565644,
0.0358479246,
0.0213353075,
-0.0064692423,
-0.0188080706,
0.01300075,
-0.007568242,
-0.002788682,
-0.0018689795,
-0.0258737914,
0.0196106248,
0.0252933055,
-0.0008715468,
-0.0032629312,
0.0474280454,
0.0604861081,
-0.0621097274,
-0.029382119,
0.0538995713,
3.031e-7,
0.0179925114,
0.0716736466,
-0.0145060271,
0.0330061279,
-0.003017077,
0.0353851281,
-0.0265044644,
-0.0277883466,
-0.0027499502,
-0.0226266272,
0.0122676129,
0.0301232021,
0.0743679106,
0.0217944011,
-0.0863799006,
-0.0785540491,
-0.0351579897,
0.0230676439,
-0.0758013874,
0.0266013071,
0.0294305813,
0.0535612926,
-0.0140592093,
-0.0266481675,
0.0028220215,
-0.1066769436,
0.0710995644,
-0.033586964,
-0.0106278611,
0.0166007727,
-0.0006405422,
0.0551359802,
0.0091456212,
0.0180355385,
0.0031863558,
0.0076627475,
0.0226878598,
0.0151474914,
0.0043546893,
0.000438435,
-0.0124750594,
-0.0163859334,
0.0040550302,
-0.0680986568,
0.0373630337,
-0.0621964447,
-0.0395582393,
-0.0137935868,
-0.0558061302,
-0.003791153,
0.0319405049,
-0.0082029607,
0.0249805339,
-0.0130363023,
0.0027587188,
-0.004179718,
0.0437075272,
-0.0262315441,
-0.0067670913,
0.043005351,
-0.0298751369,
-0.0107591609,
-0.0320532322,
0.0169247743,
0.0014698742,
-0.0345220193,
0.0099031823,
2.739666598e-34,
0.0832518265,
-0.0212755129,
0.0145079074,
0.0759655163,
0.0334094688,
0.0106849791,
0.0089741331,
0.0620061159,
0.011212213,
-0.0757583827,
0.003112383
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15544v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15544v2 | The effect of source disclosure on evaluation of AI-generated messages: A two-part study | 2023-11-27T05:20:47 | 2023-11-28T02:04:58 | Sue Lim, Ralf Schmälzle | cs.CL | cs.CL | Advancements in artificial intelligence (AI) over the last decade demonstrate
that machines can exhibit communicative behavior and influence how humans
think, feel, and behave. In fact, the recent development of ChatGPT has shown
that large language models (LLMs) can be leveraged to generate high-quality
communication content at scale and across domains, suggesting that they will be
increasingly used in practice. However, many questions remain about how knowing
the source of the messages influences recipients' evaluation of and preference
for AI-generated messages compared to human-generated messages. This paper
investigated this topic in the context of vaping prevention messaging. In Study
1, which was pre-registered, we examined the influence of source disclosure on
people's evaluation of AI-generated health prevention messages compared to
human-generated messages. We found that source disclosure (i.e., labeling the
source of a message as AI vs. human) significantly impacted the evaluation of
the messages but did not significantly alter message rankings. In a follow-up
study (Study 2), we examined how the influence of source disclosure may vary by
the participants' negative attitudes towards AI. We found a significant
moderating effect of negative attitudes towards AI on message evaluation, but
not for message selection. However, for those with moderate levels of negative
attitudes towards AI, source disclosure decreased the preference for
AI-generated messages. Overall, the results of this series of studies showed a
slight bias against AI-generated messages once the source was disclosed, adding
to the emerging area of study that lies at the intersection of AI and
communication. | [
0.0780289993,
0.0390687585,
-0.041127,
-0.0432099327,
-0.0434855334,
0.0027359081,
0.040085461,
0.0072988467,
0.0605865046,
-0.0405933671,
-0.0011507066,
0.0298569892,
-0.0115300501,
0.048949942,
0.0089456225,
0.0004979608,
-0.0123541746,
0.0560866259,
0.0941919759,
0.0239620954,
0.026264051,
0.0330131017,
0.0173487961,
0.0544123985,
-0.0157767646,
-0.0399547033,
0.0490172803,
0.0008897271,
0.0208420027,
-0.0732251853,
0.0190429706,
0.0265473071,
0.0250727944,
-0.0037427098,
0.0000019298,
-0.0436228923,
0.0151883746,
0.0233744252,
-0.0689298883,
0.0082826316,
0.0832762644,
0.0112075303,
-0.0147671336,
0.0286799017,
-0.0542465188,
0.0290670656,
0.0748572424,
0.0172344986,
0.0568727255,
0.0590822548,
-0.0435762405,
0.0302132219,
0.0007194888,
-0.0184515975,
0.0243543591,
-0.0201633926,
0.0266305935,
-0.0344248004,
-0.0137593001,
0.0156153487,
0.0216384903,
0.0437901616,
-0.0371758975,
-0.0091783386,
0.0178029295,
0.0290037952,
-0.0262812842,
-0.0802277923,
-0.0129121663,
0.0303160958,
0.0666132122,
0.0068699238,
-0.0095367543,
-0.0102219442,
0.0406130143,
0.0069782338,
-0.0505164042,
0.0116755124,
0.0071242182,
0.0108162826,
-0.0188977476,
0.0120930821,
0.022415502,
0.0196466558,
0.0620029457,
0.0327343196,
-0.0330881961,
-0.0407659523,
0.0091453353,
-0.0316156633,
0.0440293103,
-0.0604099743,
0.0083040753,
-0.0169339925,
0.0116385669,
0.0147204576,
0.0450627655,
-0.030029472,
0.0497328863,
-0.0911584124,
0.0093302941,
0.007249549,
-0.0134323733,
-0.0067561758,
0.039866358,
0.0294063464,
-0.0078335749,
0.0674595535,
-0.0206587035,
0.0606828928,
-0.027224347,
-0.039982602,
-0.0264501031,
0.0168454088,
0.0308419447,
0.00904145,
-0.0886911973,
0.0071583455,
-0.0721956939,
-0.0246322602,
-0.0423295647,
0.0188140217,
-0.0013165408,
0.0090876454,
-0.0031770384,
0.0457235873,
-0.0420274884,
0.0398420282,
0.0129221054,
-0.0474872887,
0.0205875412,
0.0202903133,
-0.0162656158,
0.0027276715,
0.0105454549,
0.0789399967,
0.0252024997,
-0.0463805236,
0.0103802085,
0.0131701538,
-0.0440770276,
-0.0392124429,
0.0030956031,
0.0039879954,
0.0144947954,
0.0237585623,
-0.0071205567,
-0.056487713,
0.0086433804,
0.0147635154,
-0.0636722967,
0.0159212407,
-0.0172576979,
0.0509638414,
0.0283893086,
0.0506926179,
-0.0043598465,
0.0127706286,
0.0397137441,
0.0515364893,
0.0122460322,
-0.0081133442,
0.0207200442,
-0.017389331,
0.0030866808,
-0.0014912204,
0.0248600356,
0.0124536995,
-0.0549108312,
0.0030499105,
-0.0523435399,
0.0821608156,
-0.0234307982,
0.0537761562,
0.0674981028,
0.0343338512,
-0.0044888514,
0.0267228298,
-0.0080216639,
0.0561719723,
-0.0173113905,
0.0070793629,
-0.0256584417,
0.0041510472,
-0.0138554033,
-0.0335006155,
0.0350610353,
-0.006052231,
-0.0299783982,
-0.0438238904,
-0.0261047445,
-0.0327242129,
0.0493689254,
0.001776824,
-0.0006978849,
0.0082177687,
-0.0266034789,
-0.0144208567,
-0.0076668584,
-0.0216637626,
-0.0412345752,
-0.0672023296,
0.0483703762,
0.0941643789,
0.007504038,
0.0300010834,
0.0303534307,
-0.0668254942,
-0.0371339396,
0.0007654628,
-0.0018381767,
-0.0164049249,
-0.0288442597,
0.0048203282,
-0.0069120182,
-0.0297659542,
-0.0045034424,
-0.0060874992,
-0.0126904333,
0.0351794362,
0.0014350793,
0.0643334612,
-0.017598927,
0.0116179697,
0.0267547201,
-0.0232764743,
-0.0486893356,
0.0187165067,
0.0675161481,
0.0371111669,
-0.0019913607,
0.0420987345,
0.0365531482,
-0.024022609,
-0.0605891682,
0.0289065912,
0.0079629393,
0.0812717453,
-0.0134329237,
-0.0487285256,
-0.0079443427,
0.0312627703,
-0.0080193989,
0.0372841582,
0.0131408386,
-0.0553272218,
0.0139145264,
-0.0211209133,
-0.0024209467,
-0.0181163792,
-0.0030047789,
0.0107901357,
-0.009984416,
-0.0357187763,
-0.0396852158,
0.01292165,
-0.0453391895,
-0.0249687973,
0.0021838022,
0.0170799233,
0.0078989612,
-0.0172375739,
0.0212446284,
0.0399019197,
0.0137017192,
-0.0108003551,
-0.0150630763,
-0.1186707467,
-0.0347395353,
0.0118408632,
-0.0174586531,
0.0072968034,
0.0058755251,
0.0044031171,
-0.0044387504,
-0.0534106791,
-0.0310539361,
0.0201059673,
0.0625746325,
0.0185619183,
0.015960101,
-0.0253882445,
-0.0106203873,
-0.0194968525,
-0.0396998599,
0.0184830688,
0.0760126561,
-0.0594050102,
-0.0243591778,
0.0165032595,
-0.0649880692,
-0.0194861982,
-0.0077694585,
-0.0401223749,
0.0224075317,
0.0231311265,
0.0285611786,
0.0309408922,
0.0606082268,
0.0290566906,
0.0764705762,
0.0602115281,
-0.040590845,
-0.0072558718,
-0.0248260871,
-0.0236985907,
-0.0002475219,
-0.0959861353,
0.0275138281,
-0.0129432268,
0.027021803,
0.0155386114,
-0.0036904875,
0.0816941708,
-0.018905187,
-0.0546904951,
-0.02191942,
-0.0920406803,
-0.0280381385,
0.0499675013,
0.0235562529,
-0.1114878058,
0.0550414883,
0.0071178172,
-0.0128073087,
-0.0092280144,
-0.0038668828,
0.0051965108,
0.0054231547,
-0.0325734653,
0.0444965772,
0.0350138843,
-0.0010548773,
0.0169256069,
-0.031438008,
0.0046248385,
-0.0349752828,
-0.0417973883,
-0.0065434673,
-0.0114947958,
0.0493218452,
-0.0703553408,
-0.0299246907,
-0.0778352842,
-0.0358262025,
-0.00721183,
0.045391757,
0.013044267,
-0.0242210981,
-0.0020606313,
0.0450080633,
-0.0158675984,
0.0372835584,
-0.004034854,
0.0209550615,
-0.0529661588,
0.0255406126,
-0.042472139,
0.0284563471,
0.0246959832,
-0.0007240777,
0.0195943415,
-0.0154417269,
0.0065812785,
0.0124153588,
-0.0182938464,
0.0009361599,
0.042933628,
-0.0187163912,
0.0153260864,
0.0118319653,
0.0231378302,
0.0378899015,
0.0539957993,
0.0046860809,
-0.039315328,
0.0193540417,
-0.0276180822,
-0.0322701335,
-0.0291861407,
-0.002328723,
-0.0896733403,
0.0265859757,
-0.0087459888,
0.0078154197,
-0.0920154378,
0.0228730906,
-0.0095147127,
-0.0363578238,
0.0411055312,
0.0166122653,
-0.0095543498,
-0.0286763776,
-0.026702797,
-0.0426191315,
-0.0147868972,
0.0010105431,
-0.044213362,
0.0066663246,
-0.016568156,
-0.0119475732,
-0.0474191867,
-0.0479835942,
0.0164817981,
-0.0000636709,
0.0586989149,
0.1106974259,
0.0562808588,
-0.0178122204,
-0.041111771,
-0.0002489506,
0.0477313735,
0.0034946192,
-0.0021558066,
0.0734431967,
-0.0453163683,
0.0377698392,
-0.0706778914,
0.0029339658,
0.017526431,
-0.0045028026,
-0.0062079318,
0.0326606408,
0.0131992698,
-0.0603849888,
-0.0260055419,
0.0448508635,
0.0486735962,
0.0708587244,
0.0026629586,
-0.0405468866,
0.0256003682,
-0.024181921,
0.0312281251,
0.0772493333,
-0.0227546729,
-0.0249934718,
-0.0123770833,
-0.0630814433,
-0.0601982921,
-0.0344533175,
-0.0393498875,
-0.0377730653,
0.0220373087,
-0.0117577184,
-0.0029513352,
0.0320536681,
0.0076717096,
-0.0104007889,
0.0329953097,
-0.0011130209,
-0.0154338265,
-0.0037617499,
-0.0019609323,
-0.0156645868,
0.0204225555,
0.0550596677,
-0.0080877598,
-0.0331333615,
0.0278736465,
0.0704278424,
0.0291329455,
0.0175168924,
0.0111771356,
-0.0337875076,
0.0200635549,
0.0546879135,
-0.0321364962,
0.0177624132,
0.0439915583,
0.0290767383,
0.0156154661,
0.0110800071,
-0.0096303551,
0.0313722193,
0.0167064331,
-0.0162680298,
-0.0175002497,
-0.0071893716,
0.0413879156,
0.063146621,
-0.0115896966,
-0.0275543071,
0.0291144773,
-0.0201317668,
-0.0215638429,
-0.0276808757,
-0.0163967684,
-0.0245951097,
-0.0002196127,
-0.0061427751,
-0.0050979634,
0.0035732305,
0.006604943,
-0.0665107146,
-0.0034073775,
-0.0197150428,
0.0389404073,
0.0068062684,
0.0784307271,
0.0144960145,
0.0019514094,
-0.020757379,
0.0468985848,
-0.0153162442,
-0.0127644716,
0.0064540394,
0.0492847897,
-0.0156227248,
-0.0262840353,
0.0325681455,
0.0602713823,
-0.0558112226,
-0.068246074,
-0.0136609143,
0.0437098779,
-0.0035879503,
0.0326087587,
0.0454652384,
-0.0349136591,
-0.0102719767,
-0.0317740478,
0.03760897,
-0.0168462489,
-0.0272466242,
-0.0077992529,
-0.018532332,
-0.0539691672,
-0.0144392289,
0.0305284914,
-0.0245435107,
0.0215129871,
-0.051841177,
-0.0529984608,
-0.0260001384,
-0.0146853058,
-0.0040191649,
0.0185800754,
-0.0091388598,
0.0111517385,
-0.0829622597,
-0.0423960499,
0.0196073614,
-0.0361576639,
0.0581093244,
-0.0423262455,
0.008683092,
0.057065323,
-0.0039315782,
-0.0709719434,
-0.018861128,
-0.0010020705,
-0.0432756245,
0.0129751237,
-0.0530841909,
-5.804300904e-33,
0.0107564582,
-0.0254520401,
-0.0271902978,
0.0124557344,
-0.0087342504,
0.0139933201,
-0.0171930008,
0.034186013,
-0.0115980515,
0.0465884618,
-0.0067984867,
0.0071427687,
-0.0008230601,
-0.0606690608,
0.0264283344,
-0.0289548412,
0.0497748107,
-0.0400264934,
-0.0240997076,
0.0456565842,
0.0205802303,
0.0343670733,
0.0026133962,
-0.1237832531,
0.0700757056,
-0.035118673,
-0.0396310277,
-0.0362249389,
0.0052777384,
0.0128865195,
-0.0065408112,
0.0310578439,
0.0487812422,
0.0122019416,
0.0058843154,
0.0874970034,
0.0027016476,
-0.0093480619,
0.0496934615,
-0.0681817085,
-0.006300881,
-0.0614429638,
0.0042359219,
-0.0153259058,
-0.0505504794,
0.0253680032,
0.0265411474,
-0.0393570103,
0.0199919231,
-0.0252210665,
-0.0274802372,
-0.0398475118,
-0.0214548409,
0.0061372081,
-0.0051046102,
0.1072300002,
-0.037496198,
0.0216359217,
-0.0096542323,
0.045421131,
0.0163710788,
-0.0405611768,
0.0264348071,
-0.0488972217,
0.0243902449,
0.0320165493,
0.014701236,
0.0041565713,
-0.0603253506,
-0.050384935,
-0.0247423258,
0.0230737962,
0.0382415578,
0.0081943106,
-0.0406841189,
-0.0578781366,
-0.0317113958,
-0.0085896412,
-0.0254492983,
-0.0157698039,
0.05313484,
-0.0078162393,
-0.0896766856,
-0.0407613963,
0.0122981872,
-0.0412048735,
-0.0345521495,
-0.0694029108,
0.0180730615,
-0.0009455221,
0.0089351637,
-0.0142039321,
-0.0279100277,
-0.0565323979,
0.0104492577,
0.0065444238,
-0.0076403185,
-0.0054383138,
0.0026418334,
-0.0246927291,
-0.0675702915,
0.0417401567,
0.002485886,
0.0775785297,
0.038882561,
0.0157858599,
0.0651034936,
-0.0172471888,
-0.0300280526,
-0.0212235935,
0.0260161106,
0.0288118944,
0.0464926399,
-0.0820789933,
0.0036894444,
0.0291353203,
-0.0129956407,
0.0379121713,
0.0211343747,
0.0299369935,
-0.0384062678,
-0.0203227736,
-0.0186970979,
0.0271440633,
-0.0586973093,
-0.0010415243,
-0.0083462587,
0.0351055823,
0.0465821885,
-0.0446931049,
-0.0215424318,
-0.0623232573,
2.78e-7,
0.0227286238,
0.0269737709,
0.0107983509,
0.0178386793,
0.010981393,
0.0351325534,
0.0055604465,
0.0217936933,
0.0233716853,
0.0410480276,
0.0313261785,
0.0050277156,
0.0153208543,
0.0098793199,
-0.0387038179,
0.0108699314,
-0.0970525444,
-0.0393048972,
-0.0081151994,
0.0448803678,
0.0739389434,
0.0287954099,
0.0060617458,
-0.0187200103,
-0.0251187421,
0.0095806587,
0.0383756869,
-0.0724403337,
0.0167664215,
-0.0001833629,
0.0151412627,
-0.0032159069,
0.0011702239,
0.0048164628,
-0.0022016759,
-0.058089599,
0.0033436755,
0.075365454,
0.0010615116,
0.0185457505,
0.0259328354,
0.0295290835,
-0.0070436867,
-0.0236464106,
0.0211484656,
-0.0706415325,
-0.0516434461,
-0.0240688659,
-0.0027023808,
-0.0290336739,
0.0483330116,
-0.0409294553,
-0.0166569836,
0.0196186639,
-0.02459489,
0.0001053463,
0.0316066891,
-0.0231789052,
0.023759516,
-0.035092108,
0.0054455199,
-0.0867518187,
-0.0106134564,
0.0090556405,
-0.0023126001,
-0.0304146074,
0.0330391005,
1.78396168e-34,
0.043210309,
-0.0189517327,
-0.007664165,
0.0070005548,
0.0621150881,
0.0359687321,
0.0240845867,
-0.0117729437,
-0.0057878969,
-0.0241033453,
-0.0104132891
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16480v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16480v4 | WsiCaption: Multiple Instance Generation of Pathology Reports for Gigapixel Whole-Slide Images | 2023-11-27T05:05:41 | 2024-06-27T12:38:12 | Pingyi Chen, Honglin Li, Chenglu Zhu, Sunyi Zheng, Zhongyi Shui, Lin Yang | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | Whole slide images are the foundation of digital pathology for the diagnosis
and treatment of carcinomas. Writing pathology reports is laborious and
error-prone for inexperienced pathologists. To reduce the workload and improve
clinical automation, we investigate how to generate pathology reports given
whole slide images. On the data end, we curated the largest WSI-text dataset
(PathText). In specific, we collected nearly 10000 high-quality WSI-text pairs
for visual-language models by recognizing and cleaning pathology reports which
narrate diagnostic slides in TCGA. On the model end, we propose the multiple
instance generative model (MI-Gen) which can produce pathology reports for
gigapixel WSIs. We benchmark our model on the largest subset of TCGA-PathoText.
Experimental results show our model can generate pathology reports which
contain multiple clinical clues and achieve competitive performance on certain
slide-level tasks. We observe that simple semantic extraction from the
pathology reports can achieve the best performance (0.838 of F1 score) on BRCA
subtyping surpassing previous state-of-the-art approaches. Our collected
dataset and related code are available. | [
0.025302222,
0.0550263487,
0.0234099869,
0.0085775992,
-0.0249662958,
0.0234493595,
0.0074429046,
0.0415982492,
-0.044129163,
0.0013680913,
0.0033481736,
-0.0335629582,
-0.0244270135,
0.0728661194,
0.0032204119,
-0.0782629102,
0.0119451219,
0.016010059,
-0.0503667444,
0.0000582857,
-0.0131159844,
0.0091986703,
-0.0141135063,
0.0473770425,
-0.0838463902,
-0.0039893775,
0.0263051018,
-0.0021882115,
0.0307614729,
-0.0558132939,
-0.0175118539,
0.0079797208,
0.0111260684,
0.0375744924,
0.0000019986,
-0.0493633971,
0.0010711617,
0.0331629328,
0.0016503853,
0.0155690322,
0.0446757488,
-0.0189403165,
-0.0194315668,
-0.0113783842,
-0.0054961825,
-0.0410872139,
0.0149832861,
0.0521469489,
0.0735102445,
0.0759690925,
-0.035914842,
-0.0069395793,
0.0368515514,
-0.0021917108,
0.039820198,
-0.0334695205,
0.0226637144,
0.0285915136,
-0.0006855538,
-0.0238454305,
0.0294686817,
0.0631182492,
0.0335143059,
-0.0432718284,
-0.0035602199,
0.0756481066,
0.0075576864,
-0.0267780796,
0.0049667857,
0.04750368,
-0.0446962193,
0.0048491759,
0.000821607,
-0.0113420133,
-0.0150584849,
-0.024390813,
-0.0426369496,
0.0114307012,
-0.0353289545,
-0.0065373918,
-0.0193783604,
0.0321382321,
-0.0183064975,
-0.0293070395,
-0.0093740216,
-0.0295197293,
-0.0057834391,
0.032973405,
-0.0151833249,
0.0347915478,
0.0198076237,
-0.037731193,
0.0718425736,
0.0458838232,
-0.0453144386,
0.003514301,
-0.0500471666,
-0.0460506789,
0.0588854775,
-0.0608737469,
0.0399389751,
-0.0308096092,
-0.0762985349,
0.0691651255,
-0.0242058411,
-0.0053725103,
-0.0360291153,
0.0319881998,
-0.0378394239,
-0.0139365392,
-0.0020296955,
-0.0071015498,
-0.0377569087,
0.017433906,
-0.0107781515,
-0.0231350251,
-0.0503544994,
-0.0057133306,
-0.0032219833,
0.0400890671,
0.0342363231,
0.034692958,
-0.0848076195,
0.0301206037,
0.0208688471,
0.0388940647,
-0.0002499939,
-0.0374296494,
-0.003905298,
-0.0220796354,
0.0104345297,
0.0427354686,
0.0416715704,
0.0195580591,
-0.0052896277,
0.0658645406,
-0.0324062519,
-0.007593811,
-0.0097176824,
-0.0642864034,
-0.0376513898,
-0.0262138769,
0.012692255,
-0.0425665788,
0.0280887205,
0.0067794584,
0.0005151102,
-0.0153962262,
0.0251259375,
-0.0011543497,
-0.0075751874,
0.0550246537,
-0.0396921672,
-0.0109663056,
0.0425113328,
0.0146220867,
0.0027554464,
0.0033003264,
0.0119853383,
0.0298858117,
0.0053110197,
0.0077242381,
0.0307274163,
0.0413277447,
0.0249411631,
-0.0492190309,
-0.0206060242,
0.0002999836,
0.0076095397,
0.0644275248,
0.0641339943,
0.0479583517,
-0.027323395,
-0.0235590003,
0.0251139477,
0.0330726244,
0.0244326573,
0.0391355753,
0.0693945363,
-0.0241699032,
-0.0053765783,
-0.0162017662,
-0.0022193301,
0.0046310448,
0.0184088927,
0.0305971988,
-0.0002720042,
0.0200565811,
-0.028191559,
-0.0440141596,
0.0046618502,
0.0075779832,
-0.043640431,
-0.0302306544,
0.0486809462,
0.0149845192,
-0.0517778546,
-0.0125218574,
0.0700727552,
-0.0290548727,
-0.044822976,
-0.0699483827,
0.0095766652,
0.0899964049,
0.0771022886,
-0.0097078271,
-0.0647807345,
0.0298285391,
-0.0069323457,
0.0466397554,
-0.0139089515,
-0.0332753286,
0.0175588522,
-0.0401101932,
-0.0191986859,
0.0194352884,
-0.0231127515,
0.0122770853,
0.0393999033,
0.012719756,
-0.0146085694,
-0.0450725518,
-0.0299414396,
0.0499760248,
0.006098229,
-0.0189954787,
-0.013249184,
0.0008318205,
0.0145405196,
-0.0339448825,
-0.0666803345,
-0.0071066143,
0.0059466171,
-0.0219204091,
-0.0078460099,
0.028364718,
-0.0541757867,
-0.0513041578,
-0.0027372998,
-0.0515075736,
-0.0302045438,
-0.0547283292,
-0.036045704,
0.0078234831,
-0.0680293292,
-0.0310910977,
-0.0560572334,
-0.0066142399,
0.0150542138,
0.0823356509,
0.0181553792,
-0.005871837,
0.0588759966,
-0.0301929675,
-0.032888867,
-0.0021042821,
-0.0344307199,
0.022408383,
-0.0417240858,
-0.0141929993,
0.0083806161,
-0.0006662494,
-0.0051067537,
-0.0181385651,
0.0337795094,
-0.0211549625,
-0.0078570517,
-0.0651304498,
-0.0092237229,
0.0165097397,
-0.0226887688,
0.0400766693,
0.0533884726,
0.0153248794,
-0.0528033823,
-0.0602107868,
0.0103292987,
0.0404657535,
0.0091581596,
0.0680047572,
0.0109627377,
0.0420430303,
-0.0338776559,
-0.0111467568,
-0.0067617763,
0.0399519987,
0.0488891192,
-0.0469254293,
-0.0171707198,
0.0713864341,
-0.0096819606,
0.0408367738,
0.0301242396,
-0.0287359841,
0.013102171,
-0.0208854992,
-0.0104970392,
0.0895847753,
-0.0050170766,
0.0560481176,
-0.0280927066,
0.0009612123,
-0.027998412,
0.0118282549,
-0.0328329541,
0.0065593142,
0.0242301244,
-0.0562418699,
0.0173936766,
0.0504978299,
0.0017067739,
0.0318536535,
-0.0330627114,
-0.0219059605,
-0.0070749642,
0.0081932647,
-0.0070155784,
0.0144779915,
0.0079955747,
-0.0060584294,
-0.0435486436,
-0.0254954472,
0.0713598803,
0.0180234946,
0.0185631234,
-0.0202803817,
0.0096369684,
-0.0078748576,
0.0799317732,
0.0253824219,
0.0398906209,
-0.0146484096,
0.0008861206,
-0.0269915778,
0.014230419,
0.0290205013,
-0.0500287265,
0.0152594224,
-0.0097722281,
0.0391142964,
-0.0026138655,
-0.0324445106,
-0.0354646631,
0.0402502753,
0.0495495684,
-0.0124530243,
-0.0015143408,
-0.0088466778,
-0.106184192,
0.0429509208,
0.0039604842,
0.0679910332,
0.0252761543,
-0.0213483498,
-0.0062577548,
0.0721586719,
0.0204535667,
-0.0143425604,
-0.0577230267,
-0.0049261698,
0.0366278514,
0.061538808,
-0.0124145253,
0.0403256603,
-0.023760071,
0.0070043029,
-0.0292017665,
0.0061229598,
-0.036514774,
0.0067434395,
0.0377563424,
-0.053693153,
-0.0377795547,
0.0532951131,
0.0209259391,
-0.0212775599,
-0.0124972658,
0.0089092152,
-0.034879148,
-0.0307084899,
0.0430087261,
-0.0701342374,
-0.0069838618,
-0.0139032146,
-0.0111177946,
0.0081168199,
0.0024860972,
0.0082292091,
-0.0334795266,
0.0931073949,
0.0063463016,
-0.0212955847,
0.0012276073,
-0.0227344129,
-0.0153659908,
-0.0287632104,
-0.0250473954,
-0.0001057015,
-0.0003182227,
-0.0065717045,
0.0082187457,
-0.0289422311,
-0.0725224912,
-0.0141196232,
-0.0320115723,
-0.0571865886,
0.0623785295,
0.0206207819,
-0.0034580522,
-0.0370318852,
-0.0193395857,
0.0313245095,
0.0069077238,
-0.0303052757,
0.1455231905,
-0.0017093862,
-0.0392119847,
-0.0295108669,
0.0366677344,
0.0341831595,
-0.0110794837,
-0.0255915094,
0.027296884,
-0.0046592322,
-0.0362762809,
-0.0605968907,
-0.0143380128,
0.0138776293,
0.0286893509,
0.011102939,
-0.0177715756,
-0.0278360453,
-0.0317326225,
0.06608022,
-0.0436314754,
-0.0154327769,
0.0538130887,
-0.0383205041,
-0.0697709471,
-0.0676012263,
-0.0304308943,
0.0641966835,
0.0443865024,
-0.0084889801,
-0.0217809658,
-0.0601176508,
-0.0085752672,
-0.1050878391,
0.0474048071,
0.0122411903,
0.0096984468,
-0.0343179032,
-0.0392006822,
0.0607533269,
-0.0097957384,
-0.0346901044,
0.0687961951,
-0.0146331526,
-0.0082254335,
-0.0452483557,
0.0614738949,
0.0224252809,
0.0008028203,
-0.0050567989,
-0.0282249078,
0.1086702198,
0.059737429,
-0.0132931983,
-0.0059064268,
-0.0091405371,
-0.0269727241,
-0.0330340415,
-0.0119579127,
-0.0197652429,
0.0147177232,
0.0002582949,
0.0329897404,
-0.0226968918,
0.0221946687,
0.0409565829,
0.0339209661,
0.0046158624,
-0.0184430834,
0.012284359,
-0.0226041898,
-0.0109393001,
-0.0170819275,
-0.0204645339,
-0.0450948812,
0.0354823321,
-0.0038187481,
-0.0002303942,
0.0028789749,
0.0029576235,
-0.0230667442,
-0.0303188004,
-0.0593375787,
-0.0344722122,
0.0350436345,
-0.0366282426,
0.052281823,
-0.0071830396,
0.0133097824,
-0.0503100082,
0.0069005401,
-0.0093657244,
-0.0192171689,
0.0075532747,
0.043611858,
0.0541981906,
-0.0201991554,
0.027726382,
-0.0064458172,
0.0236799642,
-0.0618538521,
0.0519649163,
0.0548833422,
0.0239698254,
0.0482349135,
-0.0202202629,
-0.0109732728,
0.0036213438,
0.0550979264,
0.0000618717,
-0.0039723893,
0.0428659506,
-0.010992365,
0.0259193126,
-0.0558817796,
0.0886485577,
-0.0119042806,
0.066752322,
-0.0147211617,
-0.0237974562,
-0.0956665277,
-0.0090976479,
0.0592397675,
-0.0128541002,
0.0053083994,
0.015024934,
-0.0409695581,
-0.0223966688,
0.0425658375,
0.0351187736,
-0.0449571386,
-0.0196711104,
0.0659991801,
0.020105049,
0.0377131812,
-0.0455446467,
0.0064122337,
-0.0033068603,
-0.0086125713,
-0.0555746891,
0.027631294,
-5.995820158e-33,
-0.0272057783,
-0.0388376936,
0.0585448518,
-0.0035527055,
-0.0021275461,
0.0387529433,
-0.0309597813,
-0.004578962,
0.02864342,
0.0410594083,
-0.0260390844,
-0.0512294695,
0.0260036476,
0.0479144976,
-0.0335884243,
0.0308305807,
0.0463546254,
-0.0247619431,
-0.0203046408,
0.0463887043,
-0.0068141045,
0.0319528095,
0.0447050706,
-0.0661968291,
-0.0618279465,
0.0277544335,
-0.0290332064,
-0.0480660982,
0.0177190658,
0.0350301936,
-0.0603884384,
0.0159879122,
0.0151064172,
0.010050213,
-0.002403859,
-0.0302092824,
-0.0872746408,
-0.0363139436,
-0.0068369196,
0.0323236473,
-0.110593617,
-0.0329288617,
0.0503245965,
-0.0452411585,
0.0331460461,
-0.0209515896,
0.048755642,
-0.0101776822,
-0.0378709696,
-0.0523708425,
-0.0347233526,
0.0503397025,
0.0092368554,
-0.0462899171,
0.0110448552,
-0.0624900758,
-0.0080166124,
-0.0046157958,
-0.0160099547,
0.0233452935,
0.0634915233,
0.0327871479,
0.0429200567,
-0.0247740187,
0.0163811538,
0.0554320626,
0.054600805,
-0.0662916899,
0.0142774377,
0.0108190868,
-0.0372223593,
0.063125737,
0.0124625424,
0.0037169033,
0.0191089287,
-0.0022481994,
-0.0693201721,
0.0563822798,
-0.0572113842,
0.0409551635,
0.0067215683,
-0.0277320184,
-0.0334416516,
0.0248073749,
0.0161106754,
-0.0555142425,
-0.0072421678,
-0.0361328572,
0.0632882789,
0.02228944,
-0.0276655294,
0.0433805846,
0.0116910869,
0.0308969766,
-0.0402218737,
-0.0173604097,
0.0264774822,
0.0486855842,
-0.0540954769,
-0.0324325003,
-0.006360807,
-0.0404601209,
0.0251755361,
0.0359427147,
0.0175673962,
0.0427992605,
0.0604731478,
-0.0012232913,
-0.0736893043,
0.0245875083,
-0.0069804098,
0.0231671687,
-0.0126429684,
0.0130149331,
0.0337032266,
-0.0064546587,
-0.0284432247,
0.0146570541,
0.0084973937,
-0.0062936209,
-0.0164375454,
-0.0611297227,
-0.0011028707,
0.0484370664,
-0.0616540127,
0.0122196376,
-0.0621536411,
-0.0194791313,
0.0380720757,
-0.0218954366,
-0.0271538123,
0.0337531045,
2.712e-7,
0.0485536307,
0.0259645376,
0.0366162546,
0.049394384,
0.0162776653,
-0.0042325361,
-0.0046485825,
-0.0280913357,
-0.0460653156,
0.0030356369,
0.0151827447,
0.0154881664,
0.0141373621,
0.0072504412,
-0.0290737823,
0.044904422,
-0.0433426015,
0.0045837699,
-0.0162636675,
-0.0136113865,
0.0653703883,
0.0593928099,
-0.0398866273,
-0.0482234024,
0.0557153001,
-0.040894758,
0.0483996943,
-0.0311961751,
0.0282725934,
0.0175464991,
-0.0328424647,
0.0349708125,
0.0073430925,
0.0377783999,
0.0251216292,
-0.0212584641,
0.0130968001,
0.0401404426,
-0.0448823906,
0.0506849252,
0.0417283438,
0.0015647527,
0.0144485747,
-0.0304540265,
0.0378807075,
-0.0480793007,
-0.0127064707,
-0.0237823632,
0.0039800322,
0.0144301197,
0.0117258113,
-0.0651747808,
-0.0494489372,
0.0527101792,
0.0183291361,
-0.0018136507,
-0.0517650768,
-0.0423163548,
-0.0200761985,
-0.0222847331,
0.0110900262,
-0.018635232,
-0.005535055,
0.0082082432,
0.013087648,
-0.0381971486,
-0.0440641381,
2.66950359e-34,
0.0295267981,
0.0009307171,
-0.0115142968,
0.0503722988,
0.0058247251,
-0.0266131479,
0.0012863858,
0.0033492823,
-0.0211356673,
-0.0041792654,
-0.0155462623
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03725v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03725v1 | SCStory: Self-supervised and Continual Online Story Discovery | 2023-11-27T04:50:01 | 2023-11-27T04:50:01 | Susik Yoon, Yu Meng, Dongha Lee, Jiawei Han | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, cs.LG | We present a framework SCStory for online story discovery, that helps people
digest rapidly published news article streams in real-time without human
annotations. To organize news article streams into stories, existing approaches
directly encode the articles and cluster them based on representation
similarity. However, these methods yield noisy and inaccurate story discovery
results because the generic article embeddings do not effectively reflect the
story-indicative semantics in an article and cannot adapt to the rapidly
evolving news article streams. SCStory employs self-supervised and continual
learning with a novel idea of story-indicative adaptive modeling of news
article streams. With a lightweight hierarchical embedding module that first
learns sentence representations and then article representations, SCStory
identifies story-relevant information of news articles and uses them to
discover stories. The embedding module is continuously updated to adapt to
evolving news streams with a contrastive learning objective, backed up by two
unique techniques, confidence-aware memory replay and prioritized-augmentation,
employed for label absence and data scarcity problems. Thorough experiments on
real and the latest news data sets demonstrate that SCStory outperforms
existing state-of-the-art algorithms for unsupervised online story discovery. | [
0.0239000656,
0.0353319272,
-0.0199342761,
0.0168457925,
-0.0195958186,
0.011856216,
-0.025370419,
-0.0596288517,
0.0416177735,
-0.0168772452,
0.021891674,
0.0189357158,
-0.0402780175,
0.1013512462,
-0.0450063944,
-0.0138836699,
0.0596576817,
0.0216182712,
0.0419924967,
0.0374033041,
0.02697853,
0.0258251727,
-0.0037773075,
-0.0060094208,
-0.0018657786,
0.0085441554,
-0.0184543468,
-0.0099561512,
0.0114477761,
-0.0581442155,
-0.0095585883,
0.0084968349,
0.1074659228,
-0.0029746636,
0.0000016652,
-0.007461024,
-0.0201692414,
-0.0546237007,
-0.0098141544,
-0.0375402533,
0.0646174029,
-0.0481832288,
0.0264951717,
-0.0159876235,
-0.0253011938,
0.0009901642,
0.0058779884,
0.0382207967,
0.0407968275,
0.0508860946,
-0.0396391526,
-0.0117012784,
0.0237477385,
-0.0150846839,
0.0323397145,
-0.0466617756,
0.0129472502,
-0.0346498191,
0.0011892216,
0.0246240143,
-0.0070486455,
0.035221789,
0.0396447927,
-0.0097694537,
0.0305753797,
0.0389373936,
0.0014307704,
0.0074712839,
-0.0211599655,
0.053395696,
0.0040355721,
-0.0218713321,
0.014161082,
0.0022992857,
-0.0170931462,
-0.0238728337,
-0.0680072904,
0.0238046125,
-0.0092445286,
0.0316131599,
-0.0005807744,
0.0168612693,
-0.0154871959,
0.0091600567,
0.0428823456,
0.0414263718,
0.0110712582,
0.0148796709,
-0.0453151129,
0.0258173067,
0.0032770077,
-0.0032891897,
0.0728446171,
0.0343687721,
-0.0214500837,
0.0151866721,
-0.0410400368,
0.0033042533,
-0.0213224478,
-0.1132535413,
-0.0395870879,
0.0091011738,
0.026161978,
0.0719848424,
0.0017798864,
-0.0304569434,
-0.0113820462,
-0.0503243878,
-0.0299053099,
0.0096040573,
-0.0399036147,
0.0180598646,
-0.0186322983,
0.0743802339,
-0.0113684349,
-0.0569027066,
0.0058313259,
0.073043175,
0.0454056822,
0.0052207061,
-0.0844843909,
0.0276514515,
-0.0706926063,
0.0027170354,
0.0133925499,
0.041526556,
-0.0525539257,
-0.0022453326,
0.0129104089,
0.0198306814,
-0.013793312,
0.0077265222,
0.017719185,
0.0059280959,
-0.0463976376,
-0.0169316232,
-0.0490470603,
-0.0625401437,
-0.0596469603,
-0.0130358674,
0.0003932694,
-0.0135118952,
-0.0224329848,
-0.0404994488,
0.0288317073,
-0.0059780888,
-0.0047943378,
-0.0253319275,
-0.014245118,
0.0170142893,
-0.0339894816,
0.0127941035,
0.0250457674,
-0.0309007708,
0.0361962058,
0.0429907814,
0.0473651253,
0.0923780352,
0.0181352422,
0.060624931,
0.0690256804,
0.004395152,
-0.0004162792,
-0.0396016501,
-0.0160197653,
-0.0041157105,
-0.029564701,
0.0172112472,
-0.050928697,
0.0583101511,
0.0379756689,
-0.012148194,
-0.0206679199,
-0.028924197,
0.0664359331,
0.0387555212,
-0.0039697015,
0.0306555852,
0.0348612219,
0.0447658487,
-0.0120792128,
0.0560557544,
0.0196667127,
0.0766435117,
-0.0116830803,
0.0007319741,
0.0328212231,
0.0160567686,
-0.0724644586,
-0.0230520144,
0.0419228859,
-0.0103288526,
0.0074533313,
-0.0122021483,
0.0227716435,
-0.0175580289,
-0.0080425842,
0.0143978894,
0.038631063,
-0.0281413794,
0.048003681,
-0.0015532868,
0.0536631718,
0.0603337027,
0.0726620182,
-0.0296626333,
-0.0174347386,
-0.021360442,
0.0314836204,
0.0311303344,
0.0110851498,
-0.0289697517,
0.0140331648,
-0.0167179815,
-0.0309433676,
-0.0252602063,
0.0157554168,
-0.0104775932,
0.0075863674,
0.0632721931,
-0.0027526584,
-0.0136507526,
-0.0147595285,
0.0150038917,
-0.0457795039,
-0.0152031463,
0.0367359743,
-0.0112755466,
-0.0444132499,
0.0290268809,
0.0272269249,
-0.0131981997,
0.0303715561,
-0.016351508,
-0.0621986836,
0.0198637731,
-0.0665814951,
-0.0578999855,
0.008788337,
-0.0595620461,
0.0025925646,
0.023128666,
-0.0055461782,
-0.0327986926,
0.0518130921,
-0.0412463248,
0.008109794,
-0.0396219529,
-0.0253650136,
-0.0067056445,
0.0048453799,
0.0083930679,
0.074206464,
-0.0153591335,
0.020402208,
-0.0595651232,
-0.0261039101,
-0.0196739621,
-0.0258561112,
-0.0021396242,
-0.0007254275,
-0.0020574227,
0.0042294012,
0.0428623036,
-0.0758081079,
-0.0314150415,
0.0072205933,
-0.0245187506,
0.0497589,
0.0008205251,
-0.0234369095,
0.0184614491,
0.0200137645,
0.0018765607,
-0.0610115379,
-0.0221291613,
-0.0115892543,
-0.0269830953,
0.0440365374,
-0.0013340829,
0.0359004959,
0.0267539546,
-0.0236391649,
-0.0085073402,
-0.0174738057,
0.0471965484,
0.0128955562,
-0.0247028191,
-0.0515658259,
-0.0100911334,
0.0082351333,
-0.0305573903,
-0.0138472319,
0.0213495269,
-0.0148757575,
-0.0086888485,
0.0178069063,
0.0800415576,
0.0459117927,
0.0755597651,
0.0179810822,
-0.0045297947,
-0.0203089081,
0.0246412531,
-0.0480179861,
0.0571192168,
-0.025220396,
0.0029309394,
0.0515852086,
0.0455054455,
-0.011134983,
0.0257667173,
-0.0129312938,
-0.0125454953,
-0.0016601753,
0.0200436674,
-0.0029665299,
-0.0365158468,
0.0187514015,
-0.0230468884,
-0.0012233176,
-0.0131217577,
0.0878273696,
0.031246895,
0.0136871338,
-0.0801199824,
-0.0481279194,
-0.0445231088,
0.0254441425,
-0.0433555208,
0.0265555438,
-0.0060634399,
-0.0517132059,
0.0110555431,
0.0028462166,
0.0414411686,
-0.0109584844,
0.0100523112,
0.02553696,
0.0123469103,
0.0428265668,
-0.0331613086,
-0.028354045,
-0.0941906497,
0.0014341448,
-0.0378702022,
0.0179356895,
-0.0299489126,
-0.1028485298,
-0.0006971325,
0.028563248,
0.0578356683,
-0.0324521512,
-0.0312339608,
0.0193111282,
0.079300046,
0.0660315529,
-0.0039390195,
0.0082267383,
0.0000126047,
0.0647365376,
0.0625190735,
0.026567487,
-0.0069933082,
0.029845681,
0.0032053699,
0.0178426523,
-0.060076274,
0.004167424,
-0.0166565794,
-0.0013422625,
-0.0180840511,
-0.0438200794,
0.0955478251,
0.0626607016,
-0.0985282212,
0.0049485774,
0.0249437746,
-0.0143070342,
0.0308646336,
0.0213887263,
-0.0434717946,
0.0108501129,
-0.0126884067,
0.0183177944,
0.0328811593,
-0.0480706245,
-0.0533639342,
-0.0246404391,
0.0148005094,
0.0306649338,
-0.0237814765,
-0.0111386487,
-0.0786622465,
0.0060874121,
-0.0156305507,
-0.0336560793,
0.0158007685,
-0.0459189974,
-0.0119701773,
-0.0160131361,
-0.0527457856,
-0.0459835343,
-0.0026257983,
-0.0260949694,
-0.0061081992,
0.0108705582,
0.0135449851,
0.0232399981,
0.0254671723,
-0.0279479455,
-0.010320032,
-0.0234285537,
-0.0238895249,
0.0536115915,
-0.0697104931,
0.0347444788,
-0.0702528954,
0.0495611504,
0.0175318718,
-0.0466585495,
0.0030780246,
0.0567644387,
-0.009408487,
-0.0361647233,
-0.0463818721,
-0.0120206699,
0.0389741473,
0.0640670583,
0.0202666596,
-0.0385028571,
0.0122388359,
0.0013441439,
0.0218520667,
-0.0072623924,
-0.0183075424,
-0.0058056246,
-0.0064403187,
-0.0183795989,
-0.0646935776,
-0.044151403,
-0.0188557357,
0.0191343632,
-0.0278765298,
0.0080132196,
0.0016246084,
-0.031651441,
-0.0716986507,
-0.0124295121,
-0.0052536852,
-0.0270343162,
0.0111254444,
0.0471902788,
0.0627227947,
-0.0174667705,
0.005767297,
0.0081363944,
-0.084313713,
-0.0172716379,
-0.006554333,
-0.0402870253,
0.0084338486,
0.0739480108,
-0.0327683128,
-0.0695981681,
0.0424999148,
0.0420163646,
-0.0436548293,
-0.0036860537,
-0.0264147036,
0.0079615824,
0.0077217026,
0.0122142015,
-0.0036007699,
0.0304027442,
-0.0505398624,
0.0317630433,
-0.0043690763,
0.022605611,
0.0111597516,
-0.0588313267,
0.0044350643,
0.0057813167,
-0.0077217664,
-0.0547207408,
-0.0096732527,
-0.0001544482,
0.0058279047,
-0.0191263109,
0.0211597085,
0.0472524166,
-0.0251114648,
-0.056511458,
0.0732183605,
-0.0171531253,
0.0217653271,
-0.0796079934,
-0.0094011091,
0.0426113717,
-0.0329754986,
-0.0533389933,
0.0344066136,
-0.01947565,
0.0187218394,
-0.0005048563,
0.0361477844,
-0.0313611813,
0.016125286,
0.0009565543,
0.0035328197,
0.0103879832,
0.0028995441,
-0.0939682499,
0.022105189,
-0.0746980384,
0.0157857109,
0.0394374169,
-0.0484648719,
-0.0011746489,
-0.0191722456,
0.0028032479,
-0.0193023551,
-0.0081595406,
-0.028595861,
-0.0367958322,
-0.0248699691,
0.0319096707,
-0.0329185463,
0.0704973936,
0.071937792,
0.0040341779,
0.0428833626,
0.0155016677,
-0.0510044582,
-0.0243960824,
0.0152430497,
0.0319038033,
0.0796355233,
-0.0326226316,
-0.0124641629,
0.0009453921,
-0.0071636084,
0.0300833564,
-0.0455332324,
0.0034815792,
-0.0169573873,
-0.007249462,
0.0659125969,
0.0283206701,
-0.006409158,
-0.0395927317,
0.0337439626,
-0.020117633,
-0.0391382352,
0.0185068287,
-6.124580136e-33,
0.0148532549,
-0.0205464717,
-0.036671076,
-0.0221988019,
-0.011594261,
0.0293227937,
-0.0395873077,
-0.0093126306,
0.0088165998,
0.0037079705,
0.0347482748,
0.0455683097,
-0.009311812,
0.0157982428,
0.024145091,
0.0110972878,
0.0399792083,
0.0033240509,
-0.0210157186,
0.0641335323,
0.0363955982,
0.0527302139,
0.0353678577,
-0.0269088894,
0.0027656136,
-0.0277377553,
0.0124796173,
0.0247758795,
0.1103167161,
0.0584149845,
-0.0251134038,
0.0131103024,
0.0140682319,
-0.0331938267,
-0.032121893,
0.0228707474,
-0.1135664284,
-0.0432079583,
-0.0165456682,
0.0035150424,
-0.0261633713,
0.0076261307,
0.0320088193,
-0.0067577362,
0.025497403,
-0.0037918068,
0.0239000674,
-0.0212756749,
-0.0304174144,
-0.0144061968,
-0.0471790582,
0.0139962984,
-0.035439115,
-0.0214207824,
-0.0031854911,
0.0058861687,
0.0450344533,
0.0308791064,
-0.0448554605,
0.0272662938,
-0.0529948473,
0.0394979268,
-0.0056188139,
-0.0648865402,
-0.0324868113,
0.0601103194,
0.0072960099,
-0.0014877283,
-0.0188209098,
0.0450262055,
0.0416446924,
0.0249565803,
0.0132584414,
0.0012994189,
0.0139138205,
-0.0201185383,
-0.0614367053,
0.0723898411,
0.0968493,
0.0102591794,
0.0432372205,
0.0709385797,
-0.0523053631,
-0.0113968374,
0.0255361255,
-0.0118607674,
-0.0337162837,
-0.0543580614,
-0.0071963458,
0.0502993949,
-0.0100320671,
0.0364310369,
0.0384262651,
-0.0297079943,
-0.0309264697,
0.0289010126,
-0.0082327425,
0.0172076952,
0.0354623869,
0.0489320457,
-0.0226090495,
0.0283329617,
0.0229312852,
-0.0176630542,
-0.0417815149,
-0.0376665294,
0.0394126214,
0.0316638201,
-0.037476331,
0.0033671567,
0.0297772028,
-0.0173408259,
-0.0158252008,
-0.0174748879,
0.0201791376,
0.0075556971,
-0.0364540443,
0.0536474623,
0.0219564326,
0.0230923332,
-0.0250562429,
-0.0181888249,
-0.0057158824,
0.0125623168,
0.0282730479,
0.0013718763,
-0.0107294405,
0.0038762568,
-0.0300660171,
-0.1042392552,
-0.0043063401,
0.0127263824,
2.522e-7,
-0.0201773047,
0.0454892367,
0.0139602115,
-0.0315887667,
0.0378794782,
0.0194931887,
-0.0118093034,
0.0377293229,
-0.0185108464,
-0.0255726986,
0.0144234318,
0.0593795925,
0.0251211487,
0.0325821675,
-0.0781960413,
0.0379749052,
-0.066318959,
0.0153976101,
-0.0778829455,
-0.0474970415,
0.0328156836,
0.0475004986,
0.0360421352,
0.0065389834,
0.0246721823,
-0.0372609086,
0.0663735494,
0.055026032,
-0.0363523327,
-0.0056893076,
-0.038601432,
0.0443339199,
-0.052710481,
-0.0758260712,
-0.0372764058,
0.0080319224,
0.0248658862,
0.0286417305,
0.0149201537,
-0.0353404805,
0.0342969373,
0.0060958453,
0.0219747219,
-0.005335609,
0.084964782,
-0.0777280629,
-0.0175660215,
-0.0272748657,
-0.0141389798,
0.0252108984,
-0.0035288872,
0.0269644018,
-0.0477089435,
0.0301712342,
0.000541748,
0.0157182384,
0.019231312,
-0.080473192,
0.0214158241,
0.0147077097,
-0.0413967893,
0.0274093952,
-0.0481609665,
0.0160812158,
-0.0032654831,
-0.0397848859,
0.0455170162,
1.977743072e-34,
0.0114321504,
0.0395634398,
-0.0335992239,
0.021148717,
-0.0121346312,
0.0208485145,
-0.0272544492,
-0.0366636887,
0.0408451259,
-0.0495401993,
-0.0153425466
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15525v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15525v1 | Overview of the VLSP 2022 -- Abmusu Shared Task: A Data Challenge for Vietnamese Abstractive Multi-document Summarization | 2023-11-27T04:01:13 | 2023-11-27T04:01:13 | Mai-Vu Tran, Hoang-Quynh Le, Duy-Cat Can, Quoc-An Nguyen | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper reports the overview of the VLSP 2022 - Vietnamese abstractive
multi-document summarization (Abmusu) shared task for Vietnamese News. This
task is hosted at the 9$^{th}$ annual workshop on Vietnamese Language and
Speech Processing (VLSP 2022). The goal of Abmusu shared task is to develop
summarization systems that could create abstractive summaries automatically for
a set of documents on a topic. The model input is multiple news documents on
the same topic, and the corresponding output is a related abstractive summary.
In the scope of Abmusu shared task, we only focus on Vietnamese news
summarization and build a human-annotated dataset of 1,839 documents in 600
clusters, collected from Vietnamese news in 8 categories. Participated models
are evaluated and ranked in terms of \texttt{ROUGE2-F1} score, the most typical
evaluation metric for document summarization problem. | [
0.0271781702,
0.039466437,
0.021554416,
-0.0044166408,
-0.0225016847,
0.0087660579,
-0.0420017578,
-0.0200512744,
-0.0437400565,
-0.0269399658,
-0.0048294342,
-0.0589251071,
0.0297937263,
0.0116497818,
-0.0069478918,
-0.1154808849,
0.0362749845,
-0.0201872345,
0.0028032372,
0.0048245904,
0.0280834809,
-0.0013748893,
0.033950761,
0.0061535258,
0.0418147668,
-0.0195188913,
0.0044978345,
-0.0080530215,
0.0380515829,
-0.040646214,
0.0029405572,
0.0238472614,
-0.0035101038,
-0.0064572324,
0.0000018395,
-0.0419763587,
-0.0321850516,
-0.0107691027,
0.0449523181,
0.0206851866,
0.079424724,
-0.0770098343,
0.0219446309,
0.0283948462,
-0.0029523598,
-0.061542064,
-0.012171383,
0.066963546,
0.0902429149,
0.0582924448,
-0.031606108,
-0.0257460941,
0.0415490381,
-0.0264689233,
-0.0153788263,
-0.0241644774,
-0.0077476879,
0.0330738164,
0.0140885087,
-0.0416810252,
0.0080757439,
0.0242132265,
0.0125372093,
-0.0034586806,
-0.0119979139,
0.0258247294,
-0.0566231571,
-0.0199233126,
0.019911563,
0.0486025028,
0.0061565731,
0.0027220829,
0.0263374913,
0.0262704324,
-0.0068580979,
-0.0207497869,
-0.0978711993,
0.0390697941,
-0.0121099502,
0.0231905188,
0.0645005181,
0.045350939,
-0.0114735169,
0.0615526512,
0.0019004636,
-0.0243185461,
-0.0053667556,
-0.0136638191,
-0.0202414487,
-0.0029686203,
-0.0510837957,
-0.0376183465,
0.0232958626,
0.0471770801,
-0.0367621258,
-0.025866488,
-0.0211341549,
-0.0632045269,
0.0280855577,
-0.0668872967,
0.0089917565,
0.0038997368,
0.0188159551,
0.0394631252,
-0.0099304719,
0.0088389153,
0.0142448647,
-0.000583483,
-0.0671835169,
-0.0262096077,
-0.0110173468,
0.0312130637,
-0.045633167,
0.0701026395,
-0.0369462632,
-0.0418929011,
-0.0224037059,
0.0230888631,
-0.0120558962,
-0.0091718566,
0.0101722414,
0.0149230454,
-0.0346686989,
-0.0010372696,
0.0354534462,
0.0037429838,
-0.0249132328,
-0.0156615656,
0.0522209704,
0.0143940197,
-0.0015082438,
0.0284540169,
0.0337698013,
0.0144519052,
0.0059646815,
0.0037412897,
-0.0436554439,
0.0108567057,
-0.0081992988,
0.0027641791,
0.0244598929,
-0.0509790331,
-0.0148241706,
-0.0891858563,
0.0061842403,
-0.0067949118,
0.0196689945,
0.0392990038,
0.0130329551,
0.0063199205,
-0.0202039834,
0.0241354257,
0.0095629301,
0.0116767315,
0.0735545009,
0.0234588832,
0.0114687989,
0.0556203462,
0.0137518821,
0.0536884777,
0.0521855354,
0.0215025507,
0.0096583292,
0.0094191432,
-0.013130174,
0.0211214647,
0.0545972809,
-0.0045457734,
-0.054236237,
-0.0098378807,
0.0188358556,
0.0576099679,
-0.0437162369,
0.0481846817,
0.0391177163,
0.051546853,
-0.008493728,
0.017208565,
0.0123838773,
-0.0077132271,
0.0466872752,
0.0379258916,
0.0176993739,
0.0209666248,
-0.0321493708,
0.0933955386,
0.095122695,
0.0145188188,
-0.0387184396,
-0.0734128803,
0.014523779,
-0.0244062692,
0.0209182333,
-0.0165272225,
0.0324049518,
0.0274831336,
-0.0200189948,
0.0132196071,
-0.0079340907,
-0.0435720161,
0.0425381996,
-0.0081967972,
0.0068387119,
-0.001760182,
0.0390284061,
-0.0340733118,
-0.0182193946,
-0.0105971545,
-0.0013709699,
0.0408407375,
0.0446552336,
-0.0446425676,
0.0055577736,
-0.0368316621,
-0.0015738236,
0.0204535779,
-0.0018360324,
-0.0014789246,
0.0079922229,
-0.0126881208,
0.0308675338,
0.0032908032,
-0.0703429654,
0.0059327157,
-0.0120799858,
0.0034408276,
-0.0090234801,
-0.0103058713,
0.0580439344,
0.0479221381,
0.0044092406,
0.0252969917,
0.0332977846,
-0.0300797075,
-0.0025722927,
0.0183190312,
0.0036744913,
-0.0198008344,
0.0229328182,
-0.0838149637,
0.0038331957,
0.0675859824,
-0.029693136,
-0.0705642924,
0.0374899991,
-0.0268274061,
-0.016547719,
-0.0648501366,
0.0299278814,
0.0205987282,
-0.0091127446,
-0.0051208027,
0.0489119105,
-0.021135252,
0.0056382949,
0.0597588345,
-0.0443723537,
-0.0180771016,
-0.0515622832,
0.0089714499,
0.0154778212,
0.0193788894,
0.0136751644,
0.0424325578,
0.0123322429,
-0.0200801715,
-0.0113983983,
-0.0988672599,
0.0258414857,
-0.0308933482,
0.0097950147,
0.0644993186,
0.0153541872,
-0.0270700995,
-0.0214557275,
-0.0168117378,
-0.0250697546,
0.0519444272,
0.0015612837,
0.00120957,
0.0194684528,
0.0407906733,
-0.0550197586,
-0.0257471967,
0.0270325541,
0.0209308621,
-0.0176226199,
-0.0557961389,
-0.006971742,
0.0075220913,
-0.0167808533,
-0.0396713614,
0.0190739222,
0.009626749,
-0.0318547897,
-0.0117060132,
0.0182035901,
0.0241560601,
0.0545818508,
0.0265637748,
0.0183725636,
-0.0039066081,
-0.0050072405,
-0.0234647952,
-0.0364416316,
0.0514794104,
0.013242566,
-0.0316261426,
0.0039567407,
0.06016187,
0.0256243311,
0.0041683004,
0.0097099543,
-0.0235960763,
-0.0372827873,
0.0062181652,
-0.0142798992,
-0.0258464329,
-0.0014775401,
0.0059338198,
-0.0358866863,
-0.0237774029,
0.0657971799,
-0.0137888603,
0.0114386156,
-0.0899481252,
-0.0054779812,
-0.0657114908,
0.0537855849,
-0.0027812489,
0.0223659147,
-0.028475726,
-0.0363267213,
-0.0200373083,
0.0046283035,
0.0216902215,
-0.0142306732,
0.0841739699,
-0.0220211074,
0.0032318025,
-0.0252103973,
-0.0035067503,
0.00776299,
-0.0128329918,
-0.0122113219,
0.0343813859,
0.0307564344,
0.040325176,
-0.0388383418,
0.0483613238,
0.0202508587,
0.0385823548,
-0.0124626309,
-0.0091251833,
-0.0201590508,
0.0959869921,
0.077750288,
-0.0154957958,
0.0038225646,
-0.0516334251,
0.051446069,
0.0400648266,
0.0657138452,
0.006428258,
-0.0047634365,
-0.0128477411,
0.0067855762,
-0.0762607455,
0.0206830278,
-0.0524173826,
0.0281110555,
-0.0217634607,
0.018643776,
0.1100593433,
0.0193904806,
-0.033275526,
-0.0106074112,
0.0056099137,
0.0410575904,
0.0060090711,
-0.0100988057,
-0.0556968115,
0.0437557139,
0.018759679,
0.0046787369,
0.0283005033,
0.0036596234,
0.0168608371,
-0.0710659325,
0.0175057817,
0.0361847319,
-0.0722302347,
-0.032981284,
-0.0210870914,
-0.0001365087,
-0.0512725487,
0.0160188042,
0.0088855298,
-0.0273437649,
-0.0028331806,
0.0045376546,
-0.0669602603,
0.0259195846,
0.005155562,
-0.016584862,
-0.0289230775,
0.0451375954,
0.0291068666,
-0.0006163886,
0.0458191037,
0.0568972118,
-0.0663466826,
-0.0254665781,
0.013018176,
0.0176729895,
-0.012957437,
0.0192025583,
-0.0216753911,
0.0680221021,
-0.0025785421,
-0.0195166692,
0.0249093808,
0.0374595895,
0.0026471203,
-0.0254143514,
-0.037141256,
0.022260217,
-0.0420011096,
0.0445028096,
0.0438336991,
-0.0132828718,
-0.0105727399,
-0.0161102619,
-0.0132420706,
-0.0509313531,
0.0061977808,
-0.0162328836,
-0.0848883539,
-0.0450266115,
-0.0805185437,
-0.0922210366,
0.0171849858,
-0.0026235636,
-0.020780975,
-0.0230322517,
0.0121119274,
0.009199609,
-0.0293699708,
0.0142511269,
0.0118792243,
-0.0104624042,
-0.0139763476,
-0.0331526548,
0.03911414,
-0.0246393587,
-0.0254052542,
0.0378018916,
-0.0397689976,
-0.0369741134,
-0.0111002205,
0.011861315,
0.0244646426,
0.0614884086,
0.0157461707,
0.0107155126,
0.0542451926,
-0.0181175135,
-0.0040010242,
-0.0090536624,
0.0126259541,
0.0301600825,
-0.0220809169,
0.0383087918,
-0.0381881222,
0.0602183826,
-0.0376463011,
0.049840387,
-0.0266065113,
0.0006220238,
0.0072161504,
0.043431405,
0.0102066519,
-0.0583263449,
-0.0142015079,
-0.06002976,
-0.0207868982,
-0.0233811457,
-0.0326436684,
-0.0103940293,
0.0363670811,
0.0057072542,
0.0035725422,
-0.0217363071,
0.0407712683,
0.0384596176,
-0.0213098004,
0.0083195996,
0.0030231804,
0.004968117,
0.0249087922,
-0.0655957162,
-0.0046363333,
-0.0465891771,
-0.0291464645,
-0.0599915534,
0.0015137533,
-0.0236036275,
0.0255124066,
0.0103284577,
0.0311826598,
-0.0152316047,
0.0276178792,
-0.064277783,
0.0302813984,
-0.0826990083,
0.0250469446,
0.0497217067,
-0.0548177361,
0.0810592994,
-0.0059153917,
-0.0137495706,
-0.0467901528,
0.0241397079,
0.011251634,
-0.0079558948,
-0.061151091,
0.0349759683,
0.0236457549,
0.03761838,
0.1153175756,
-0.0754257068,
0.0113862343,
0.0351288393,
-0.008864291,
-0.0368548855,
-0.0007983486,
0.0282350704,
0.0501369238,
-0.0355421863,
-0.0448008999,
-0.0328560136,
0.0059577608,
0.0408831984,
0.0217835642,
0.0152316755,
0.022167461,
-0.0008923056,
0.0496394783,
0.0136971027,
0.0176345445,
-0.0627348498,
-0.0300302804,
-0.0510870442,
0.0170838647,
0.0291705821,
-6.1744413e-33,
-0.0625897944,
0.0331068933,
-0.0358711295,
0.0072702295,
-0.0464720242,
0.0133663099,
-0.0797726139,
-0.0102585554,
0.0133679528,
-0.0281206556,
-0.0236853734,
-0.0061321664,
0.0297298208,
0.0440530963,
0.0434055664,
0.0191038232,
-0.0114974435,
0.0283022113,
-0.0200130548,
0.0391054377,
-0.0009722895,
0.0005206342,
0.030523194,
-0.0348754786,
0.0453282818,
-0.007238281,
-0.023989968,
-0.023449637,
0.037632715,
0.0460727066,
-0.0264696982,
0.0034492253,
0.0500716567,
-0.016892517,
-0.0690757185,
-0.0242538285,
-0.0794373676,
-0.0420460254,
0.0195686426,
-0.0069938204,
-0.073259823,
-0.0472944826,
0.015833972,
-0.0368022621,
0.0238320716,
-0.0509231985,
0.0476601943,
-0.0834423378,
-0.0157236718,
-0.0328060724,
-0.0308619514,
0.0161581822,
-0.0359794647,
0.0007480463,
0.0260465983,
0.0296157207,
-0.0275841039,
-0.007214949,
-0.0449488983,
0.0489673764,
0.023456553,
0.0516411811,
0.0470694527,
-0.0028382381,
0.0033985826,
0.0148606002,
0.0192902219,
-0.0469987392,
-0.011852473,
0.034947563,
-0.0240542777,
0.023862116,
0.0033681153,
0.0061482196,
0.0528567918,
0.0257032067,
-0.0199191757,
0.0869328901,
0.0063924906,
0.0095732342,
-0.0043549896,
0.0252270009,
0.002234427,
-0.002690434,
-0.0227281079,
-0.0371430628,
-0.0151958494,
-0.0423275717,
-0.0237264857,
0.0383823402,
-0.0447875857,
0.0275209956,
0.0368118174,
-0.0634001419,
0.0401803963,
-0.0375053212,
-0.0038916566,
0.0463252477,
-0.0226442888,
-0.0158084333,
-0.0344473422,
-0.0192432143,
0.0224447399,
0.0089299921,
-0.0285245664,
0.0087548094,
0.0568735451,
0.0108498521,
-0.0446586721,
0.0120039508,
0.0038344238,
-0.0028780915,
-0.061212644,
0.0541624278,
-0.0188583639,
-0.0052009476,
0.0252167489,
0.0151581103,
-0.0130154612,
0.0315102227,
-0.0199862663,
0.0189323947,
-0.0070306733,
0.0332094617,
0.0082066488,
0.0556313768,
-0.031794142,
-0.022842627,
0.0429363586,
0.0129471757,
-0.0084067406,
-0.0170652736,
2.513e-7,
0.0372945853,
-0.0053002089,
0.0978296995,
0.0042479313,
-0.0211755577,
-0.0211813152,
-0.0442764908,
0.025088083,
0.0214753486,
0.0086984346,
0.0666204542,
0.0261153001,
0.0516552627,
0.0305384714,
-0.0888933465,
-0.0046267719,
-0.0708202869,
-0.0689056888,
-0.0347433724,
-0.0523867384,
0.0079836939,
0.082227625,
-0.0437310077,
0.0134467175,
-0.0275872499,
-0.0017284084,
0.0169556979,
0.0062573901,
-0.0677548647,
0.0294417217,
0.0500648022,
-0.0127009787,
-0.0229402017,
-0.0644427165,
-0.0047984896,
-0.0150457546,
0.1041563153,
0.0478256494,
0.0060569746,
0.0042773592,
0.0181692429,
-0.0025381171,
0.0105754621,
-0.0069694687,
0.0400922708,
-0.01479661,
-0.0031700188,
-0.0366419479,
-0.041967757,
0.0456365235,
-0.0096957805,
-0.0051984061,
-0.0511127114,
0.0849729255,
0.008472749,
0.0016954282,
-0.0084933238,
-0.0191900637,
-0.064121604,
0.0057451897,
0.0094918991,
-0.018799331,
0.0184953082,
0.022839861,
0.0049934201,
-0.0786144957,
-0.0277852193,
2.157930055e-34,
0.1090636104,
0.0049515166,
-0.0689298138,
-0.0030488609,
0.0353046097,
-0.0806301758,
-0.0794072151,
0.0085906424,
-0.0201672316,
-0.0553285889,
-0.0149446726
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15513v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15513v1 | A Comparative and Experimental Study on Automatic Question Answering Systems and its Robustness against Word Jumbling | 2023-11-27T03:17:09 | 2023-11-27T03:17:09 | Shashidhar Reddy Javaji, Haoran Hu, Sai Sameer Vennam, Vijaya Gajanan Buddhavarapu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Question answer generation using Natural Language Processing models is
ubiquitous in the world around us. It is used in many use cases such as the
building of chat bots, suggestive prompts in google search and also as a way of
navigating information in banking mobile applications etc. It is highly
relevant because a frequently asked questions (FAQ) list can only have a finite
amount of questions but a model which can perform question answer generation
could be able to answer completely new questions that are within the scope of
the data. This helps us to be able to answer new questions accurately as long
as it is a relevant question. In commercial applications, it can be used to
increase customer satisfaction and ease of usage. However a lot of data is
generated by humans so it is susceptible to human error and this can adversely
affect the model's performance and we are investigating this through our work | [
0.1094780788,
-0.0305484608,
-0.0434427522,
0.0093774963,
-0.0319667831,
-0.0110333441,
-0.02654442,
-0.0125300083,
0.0330265574,
-0.0795696974,
0.0277051833,
-0.0383810736,
0.0154717993,
0.0516375341,
0.0226279404,
-0.0569319315,
0.0694230497,
-0.0300767794,
-0.0022032741,
0.000354307,
0.0034105007,
0.0064500044,
0.0158218946,
0.034683194,
0.0054772319,
0.0018725712,
-0.0152929444,
-0.0057199285,
-0.0149606196,
0.0044849264,
0.0239463616,
0.024602145,
-0.0571358688,
0.025423605,
0.000002029,
-0.0788175166,
-0.0319674723,
-0.003510528,
-0.0295435302,
0.0002304493,
0.0386102349,
0.0492343716,
-0.0049959784,
0.0647511929,
-0.0670842007,
0.0580157451,
0.011524694,
0.0115691377,
0.078914836,
0.0544266962,
-0.0040999674,
-0.0445331559,
0.0165072083,
0.04789057,
0.0183164235,
-0.0531689636,
0.0142381527,
-0.0022358729,
0.0268102717,
-0.0015351588,
-0.0174165294,
0.0027583162,
0.0004120245,
0.006748538,
-0.0212747008,
-0.0053840294,
-0.0518950373,
-0.04035528,
-0.0420237221,
0.0573053621,
-0.0068976069,
-0.0184230022,
0.0086939242,
-0.0047882255,
0.0360374451,
0.0401789397,
0.0012215115,
0.0181119721,
-0.0611257441,
-0.0354839787,
0.0051914956,
-0.0242274757,
-0.0278502181,
0.0168916583,
-0.0011641791,
0.0405432545,
0.0363830999,
-0.0395192578,
-0.0275943857,
-0.0228886157,
-0.002317437,
-0.0729818866,
0.0315334089,
0.0695611387,
-0.0418900996,
0.020314822,
-0.0597161874,
-0.0307019837,
0.0466576405,
-0.0693694204,
-0.0112974169,
0.0104882577,
-0.0129534733,
0.0275967307,
-0.0006451566,
0.0342728384,
0.0148588503,
-0.0203475337,
-0.0665407628,
-0.0115115754,
-0.0465327613,
-0.0390711315,
-0.050949648,
0.0661482438,
-0.0496868305,
-0.0250432305,
-0.0235780813,
0.0140848644,
0.0301748365,
-0.0175708625,
-0.0087413164,
0.0579842478,
-0.0156608801,
0.0015482958,
-0.0665809661,
-0.0176543053,
-0.0671926066,
0.0381092988,
-0.0160913002,
-0.076448448,
0.0206523836,
0.0007395124,
0.0057732696,
-0.0249535087,
0.0319033116,
0.0512464941,
0.0103662238,
-0.040942926,
-0.0490552969,
-0.055432871,
-0.0454202816,
-0.0302260518,
-0.0445145294,
-0.0792184621,
0.0262376349,
0.0267610811,
-0.0390716679,
0.0090210373,
0.0208661538,
0.0698058084,
-0.0630571395,
0.0540358089,
-0.0599254891,
0.0326461978,
0.0709195808,
-0.0023764418,
0.0164296813,
0.0053690304,
0.0335426368,
0.0088520003,
0.0749252364,
-0.0087514259,
0.0659611672,
-0.0202528927,
0.0022894449,
-0.0490078516,
0.0377356037,
0.0681567267,
-0.0314839259,
-0.0204252731,
-0.0234291144,
0.0831625089,
0.0041617122,
-0.0228614826,
0.0434172861,
0.05483656,
-0.0215922259,
0.0276569147,
-0.0035138689,
-0.0090547707,
0.063734062,
0.0328439362,
-0.0050377925,
0.0061538606,
-0.0699313581,
0.0141285518,
0.0290593598,
0.0485147573,
-0.0258941203,
-0.0552926436,
-0.0264118165,
-0.0045554866,
0.0248666909,
0.0128357559,
0.0274119861,
0.039081838,
-0.0431290716,
0.0060815737,
-0.0017206925,
0.0171914808,
-0.0077187163,
-0.0610064976,
0.0272358637,
0.0660884976,
0.0611101799,
0.0063113924,
-0.0175897218,
-0.0149045298,
-0.0173566379,
0.0152965989,
0.0540733673,
0.0018663571,
-0.0103640193,
0.0051552388,
0.0094751362,
0.0059439801,
-0.0156737734,
-0.0156921539,
0.0176480114,
0.0367027819,
0.0155003397,
-0.0095188944,
-0.0158001855,
0.0191700086,
0.0029302265,
-0.028538296,
-0.0005747954,
-0.016508678,
-0.0087516028,
0.0436211191,
-0.0219349544,
0.0542360097,
0.0239029862,
0.0213207938,
-0.0231288318,
-0.0165510345,
0.0241064876,
-0.0105981817,
0.0450717472,
-0.0408252738,
-0.010321416,
0.0459480323,
-0.0092643574,
-0.0573723689,
0.0021275165,
-0.072871834,
0.0025403213,
-0.0571209267,
0.0268792082,
0.0198637433,
0.0298449378,
-0.0561109409,
0.0484665222,
0.035126321,
0.0391210765,
-0.0391444005,
-0.0019961747,
0.0132462019,
-0.0459118299,
-0.0161045548,
0.0038671016,
-0.0225151572,
0.0417189263,
0.0410543941,
-0.0211625714,
-0.0604842007,
-0.003930585,
-0.0692973584,
0.0016145663,
0.0047479817,
0.0406539254,
0.0066677043,
0.0393994898,
-0.0436903946,
-0.0495781749,
-0.0274525005,
0.0145656858,
0.0435748361,
0.0207959954,
0.0562235564,
-0.0045402115,
-0.0270592906,
-0.0520886779,
0.0049385,
-0.0242535658,
0.0068236818,
0.0473417714,
-0.0402358696,
-0.0660925582,
-0.0054219263,
-0.0346887186,
0.0116257668,
0.0336582698,
-0.0453461483,
-0.0126679651,
0.0276636016,
0.0154136373,
0.0474150777,
0.070969902,
-0.0073106387,
-0.0156278461,
0.0003623963,
0.0036971937,
0.020729769,
-0.0229689945,
-0.0317460373,
0.0002474259,
-0.0341819376,
0.0428962559,
0.0055116354,
0.0533018,
0.0065016863,
-0.0019075463,
0.0775846615,
-0.0256982204,
-0.0106342407,
-0.033750169,
-0.0001719421,
-0.0341806933,
0.0583748929,
0.0090950029,
-0.0422997735,
0.0737201869,
0.0205599349,
0.0191347711,
-0.0954323933,
-0.0172336325,
-0.0253280737,
0.0522403046,
-0.0229840558,
0.0469191521,
0.0183429997,
-0.0286112595,
-0.0498663001,
-0.0662877783,
0.0186262708,
-0.0399716571,
0.0019675419,
-0.0329681747,
0.0034157811,
-0.0250606705,
-0.0344119333,
-0.0438607,
-0.0926642343,
-0.0281534959,
-0.0029754664,
0.0503149964,
-0.0036711851,
0.0083030425,
0.0173246376,
0.0075221937,
-0.002551981,
-0.0342505015,
-0.0377640277,
-0.0063532428,
0.0597060099,
0.1069977134,
0.0203734729,
0.0632089749,
0.0300360918,
0.0209869221,
0.0554726869,
0.0229825191,
0.0068564247,
0.0155897569,
-0.0120593691,
-0.0025777339,
-0.0687253997,
-0.0416360311,
0.0363040864,
0.0319061838,
-0.0362051204,
-0.0063373144,
0.0774904713,
0.0835066363,
0.0165771265,
0.0021092363,
-0.0404845327,
-0.0149003454,
0.008543374,
0.0749809146,
-0.0498849414,
-0.0392225608,
-0.003911112,
0.0444156043,
-0.0070160497,
-0.0136321923,
0.0012512008,
-0.130756706,
0.0269555114,
-0.0186275467,
-0.020854976,
-0.054409381,
-0.0269162487,
-0.0298437253,
0.0432990491,
0.0257429276,
0.033980865,
-0.0462594442,
0.0373892374,
0.0237231385,
-0.0484389663,
-0.0305116363,
0.0137164826,
-0.0383736566,
0.0597236902,
0.0554130413,
0.0126857208,
-0.0100254426,
-0.0157937817,
-0.0034637551,
0.0034333281,
0.0129483128,
-0.0123838503,
0.0345010497,
0.0196627919,
0.0090755029,
-0.0463001914,
-0.0193776805,
-0.0220007487,
0.0048314957,
0.039334707,
0.0188113451,
-0.0437155962,
-0.014978393,
-0.0424554311,
-0.0145420525,
0.0043458752,
0.0781977847,
-0.0008763924,
-0.0307100788,
-0.08906129,
-0.0267420989,
0.0011782399,
-0.0167740788,
-0.0108275507,
0.0332745053,
-0.0022522174,
0.0029780276,
-0.1034675241,
-0.0520709604,
0.0191698503,
0.0344358608,
-0.0003420608,
0.0434075668,
0.0029347814,
0.0372795947,
-0.0207131822,
-0.0353445336,
0.0103563415,
0.0470345318,
-0.0638682246,
0.0207242724,
0.0175271425,
-0.0598203987,
-0.0207150038,
-0.0110808322,
-0.0281329844,
-0.0331911035,
0.0111358203,
0.0678191185,
0.0288565829,
-0.0027586466,
-0.0261234958,
-0.0318822712,
-0.0122312093,
0.0462375097,
-0.0544124469,
0.0125760883,
-0.0058461628,
0.0302758235,
-0.0178674478,
0.0092410017,
-0.0505303033,
-0.0150835598,
-0.0355221294,
0.0555588678,
-0.001003296,
-0.0592422485,
0.0407854542,
0.0471977778,
-0.0080253165,
-0.0125450548,
0.009618571,
0.0223879758,
0.0121500026,
-0.0112007204,
-0.0304323398,
-0.0070496439,
0.0214737505,
-0.0083267884,
-0.0066201719,
0.018138472,
-0.03722433,
-0.0837746039,
0.0313817337,
0.0437294729,
-0.0133739794,
0.0466761142,
0.0343805589,
-0.0178437736,
-0.0361030363,
-0.0061150072,
0.0246803984,
0.0206872057,
0.0630865246,
0.0109188976,
0.0194428265,
-0.0150206499,
-0.0457329229,
-0.0729234442,
0.0203982666,
-0.0731051266,
-0.0738697723,
-0.0265279822,
0.0221125633,
0.0169440899,
-0.0038641742,
0.0060629123,
-0.005592403,
-0.0134337451,
-0.011815533,
0.0005160823,
0.0178122837,
0.0239956137,
0.0360620655,
0.0002173477,
-0.0441524535,
-0.0297377538,
0.0814296827,
0.0355560966,
-0.0232800804,
0.0047422154,
-0.0636286736,
-0.0249320157,
0.0023851611,
0.0050575603,
0.0249217004,
-0.0062839771,
0.0318127424,
-0.0724473596,
-0.0426192284,
-0.0181429703,
0.0151683223,
0.053081736,
-0.0083179548,
0.0467302203,
0.0759221688,
0.0747446865,
-0.0123480894,
-0.0827765465,
0.0416874811,
-0.0199402682,
0.0031114297,
-0.01329144,
-6.391945959e-33,
-0.0111673931,
-0.0557728074,
0.0036903846,
-0.0135758491,
0.0180454515,
-0.0278930869,
0.0033777922,
-0.0025921129,
-0.03319446,
-0.0023607346,
-0.0411004014,
0.0162068382,
0.0127344942,
0.0026370853,
0.0124848215,
-0.0509658121,
0.0045904112,
-0.0070301108,
0.0072285542,
-0.0258240849,
0.0193092097,
0.0230650418,
0.007416504,
-0.0043168962,
0.0268791653,
-0.0306076389,
0.010342245,
0.0056362636,
0.0114218965,
0.0679831356,
0.0048456667,
0.0387783051,
0.0310797673,
-0.0140822576,
-0.0075476994,
0.062499553,
-0.0745045394,
-0.0689814016,
0.0403911918,
0.0030466884,
-0.0055854553,
0.0169766974,
0.0350174904,
-0.0139674498,
-0.0008782898,
0.0400088094,
0.0491067469,
-0.0116856061,
-0.0096749235,
-0.0199052207,
-0.0416581221,
0.0225857161,
0.0032916756,
-0.0324186943,
-0.0550941043,
0.0546442308,
-0.0252028406,
-0.0359027572,
-0.043480739,
-0.027195977,
0.0285749119,
0.0195249412,
0.0447251461,
0.0218076594,
-0.0254849326,
0.0346220918,
0.0155804008,
-0.0144797899,
-0.0344679989,
0.0113401338,
-0.0364856124,
0.016263321,
0.0478167757,
0.0629734397,
0.0641132295,
-0.0261147693,
-0.0375568792,
0.0453537293,
0.017101068,
0.0236554258,
0.0071762763,
-0.0324671268,
-0.0582125597,
-0.0140656456,
-0.0095386645,
0.0454832688,
-0.0404830687,
-0.0352563113,
0.0411077812,
0.0062047872,
-0.0265554115,
-0.0506810546,
-0.0099164629,
-0.048637908,
-0.0250730459,
-0.0104060033,
-0.0097784,
-0.0209137537,
0.0260789283,
0.0540824309,
0.0088527109,
0.0126143293,
0.0111259501,
0.03107474,
-0.0003480814,
0.007553319,
-0.044027023,
-0.0017782549,
-0.0557213314,
0.0167307798,
0.0127992416,
0.0211126488,
-0.0093937721,
-0.0378915444,
0.0424441285,
0.0255024619,
-0.0201739706,
0.0243227463,
0.0152768027,
0.0177561585,
-0.0531327575,
-0.0305260569,
0.014332002,
0.0444089547,
0.0025146164,
0.0267630219,
-0.020936612,
0.0543856621,
-0.0226092916,
-0.0504097492,
0.0006114332,
0.0224822536,
2.723e-7,
0.0715826601,
0.0332711376,
0.0075092227,
0.0307898596,
-0.0009150478,
0.0298308246,
0.0270294305,
0.0305891149,
0.028114656,
0.0237129182,
-0.0186069515,
0.0044631627,
0.0230517611,
0.0464489125,
-0.0523203202,
-0.0139678372,
-0.0694387853,
0.0183450542,
-0.0576076992,
0.0186038781,
0.0892765298,
0.059706565,
0.0018125841,
-0.0276727322,
-0.05541379,
-0.0653482154,
0.0083496794,
0.0412123203,
-0.0021417998,
0.0134272622,
0.0643555894,
0.0052353344,
0.0455283709,
0.0341543481,
-0.0104538612,
0.0245097615,
0.0272861738,
-0.0068370379,
-0.0311789233,
-0.0154868839,
-0.0138353752,
-0.0654596537,
0.0309415236,
-0.0781835169,
0.085412994,
-0.0259220432,
-0.0038689503,
-0.0237228367,
-0.0281297993,
-0.0193775631,
0.0423888229,
-0.0392514542,
-0.0184573438,
0.0179051217,
0.0089597767,
0.0127730668,
0.0153254215,
-0.0443858057,
-0.0052108881,
0.0296946261,
0.009527632,
-0.0294095986,
-0.0220309589,
-0.004210575,
0.0148285972,
-0.017484175,
0.0090526631,
2.368819711e-34,
0.0411973521,
-0.0133620556,
-0.0003209745,
0.0387928374,
0.0430581421,
0.0056852065,
-0.0027813721,
0.0081624119,
0.0260836594,
-0.0459083021,
-0.0231740642
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15509v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15509v1 | A Corpus for Named Entity Recognition in Chinese Novels with Multi-genres | 2023-11-27T03:08:41 | 2023-11-27T03:08:41 | Hanjie Zhao, Jinge Xie, Yuchen Yan, Yuxiang Jia, Yawen Ye, Hongying Zan | cs.CL | cs.CL | Entities like person, location, organization are important for literary text
analysis. The lack of annotated data hinders the progress of named entity
recognition (NER) in literary domain. To promote the research of literary NER,
we build the largest multi-genre literary NER corpus containing 263,135
entities in 105,851 sentences from 260 online Chinese novels spanning 13
different genres. Based on the corpus, we investigate characteristics of
entities from different genres. We propose several baseline NER models and
conduct cross-genre and cross-domain experiments. Experimental results show
that genre difference significantly impact NER performance though not as much
as domain difference like literary domain and news domain. Compared with NER in
news domain, literary NER still needs much improvement and the
Out-of-Vocabulary (OOV) problem is more challenging due to the high variety of
entities in literary works. | [
0.0456794575,
0.0240102336,
0.0042241174,
0.0326183476,
0.0097706616,
0.0416627675,
0.0188106056,
0.010888285,
0.0059655635,
-0.0355898552,
-0.0019395531,
-0.0377161615,
0.0401990302,
0.0189863201,
0.0096709486,
-0.0230802912,
0.0006895885,
-0.0137678981,
0.0472008586,
0.0417260788,
0.0199224371,
0.0309779104,
0.0174696967,
0.0211511739,
0.0654445887,
-0.039771609,
-0.0040404946,
0.0375904925,
0.0746222064,
-0.0593303069,
0.0464613512,
0.0139880227,
-0.0093252352,
0.0353081711,
0.0000018086,
-0.0770983323,
-0.0698661283,
-0.0011001314,
0.0185907837,
-0.0102865333,
0.0493062772,
-0.0002153468,
-0.0320381857,
-0.0241137352,
0.0270422138,
-0.0275330152,
0.0126045635,
0.1230133027,
-0.0144321807,
0.1042004526,
-0.0135787157,
-0.016671896,
0.0282331593,
0.0137273716,
-0.0428544171,
-0.0087769022,
0.026256647,
-0.0488075688,
-0.0032389683,
0.0230492279,
-0.00829494,
-0.0085843448,
-0.0362059884,
0.0519982725,
0.0084755439,
0.0545246266,
-0.04318754,
0.0482740924,
0.0167667829,
0.0531361848,
-0.0102937082,
-0.0170502122,
0.0431032181,
-0.0134587465,
-0.0476552583,
0.0152434399,
-0.0054830448,
0.0061343145,
-0.07430204,
-0.002191647,
0.0396436863,
0.000024708,
0.0188671798,
0.0155281676,
-0.0077348161,
-0.0135596544,
0.0328643247,
-0.0368410312,
0.0078509189,
-0.007920268,
-0.0414433666,
-0.0262183584,
0.0210446175,
0.0086289998,
0.0167764295,
0.0116402116,
0.0083486075,
0.0044337995,
-0.0334748663,
-0.0497520864,
-0.0225074086,
0.002795517,
0.0146952625,
0.010402008,
-0.0153657552,
-0.006046426,
0.0188653432,
-0.0148971565,
0.0094597107,
-0.0333813056,
-0.0448376946,
-0.0120392311,
-0.0473859757,
0.0501592346,
-0.0029654144,
-0.0548529327,
0.000021227,
-0.030795332,
0.0227510706,
0.0066700918,
-0.0056789382,
0.0085962955,
-0.0018438619,
-0.0135753751,
-0.0512554012,
0.0117286965,
-0.0080445949,
0.0002246047,
-0.0475709662,
0.0005277835,
0.0062022163,
-0.0297948718,
0.0460578874,
-0.049245961,
0.0311953742,
0.0253346395,
0.0105665987,
-0.0854529887,
-0.0790967271,
0.0084846383,
0.01564743,
-0.0484405272,
-0.0185690913,
-0.0307563506,
0.008530926,
-0.0091581447,
0.0500790626,
-0.0211995486,
0.0332295522,
0.0015070104,
-0.0494851135,
0.041314356,
-0.0140235499,
-0.0248022899,
0.0070660016,
0.0201820135,
0.0415260047,
0.0343157947,
0.0601326525,
-0.0220781118,
0.0817667022,
0.0169577189,
0.0123450318,
0.0105777709,
-0.053603489,
-0.0129327457,
0.0160356537,
-0.0221225284,
-0.0283219684,
0.0028394661,
0.0017111634,
0.0261853449,
-0.0172363799,
-0.0159130134,
0.0419536754,
0.0419791266,
0.0242994782,
0.0169735327,
0.0089277504,
0.0038834775,
0.0301342756,
0.0092900312,
-0.011662852,
-0.0035622474,
0.009924531,
0.0182479117,
-0.015055526,
0.0389397815,
-0.0134291388,
0.0085363267,
-0.0216440205,
0.01257121,
0.0146121616,
-0.0036889457,
0.0504951887,
0.0012537087,
-0.0598083586,
0.0032262341,
0.0275761187,
-0.0352580473,
0.0339630023,
0.0172253847,
0.007064105,
0.1061204374,
0.0795444846,
-0.0330607593,
-0.0186098013,
-0.0161431152,
-0.0613128915,
0.0729758516,
-0.0367760025,
-0.0373168513,
0.0381984115,
-0.0477508195,
0.0107301725,
0.0036956712,
0.0144456681,
0.0187843647,
0.0078537324,
0.0689990148,
0.0061163134,
-0.0446679778,
-0.0491035469,
0.0321491174,
-0.055597268,
-0.0353413783,
-0.0197899938,
0.0343711264,
-0.0131456759,
0.0480779856,
-0.052869495,
-0.0319466516,
-0.0041538114,
-0.0415935703,
-0.0423420556,
0.0027499963,
0.01996479,
-0.0424643755,
0.0150224511,
-0.0578507185,
-0.0025572602,
0.0082370322,
0.0039989376,
-0.0605840273,
-0.0394410864,
0.0581329204,
0.0435828678,
-0.0501366928,
0.0488966741,
-0.003880695,
0.028069742,
-0.0184475183,
0.0668939278,
0.0090722898,
0.0457583182,
-0.0431304015,
-0.0121566243,
0.009437046,
-0.0304312035,
-0.0631685778,
0.0014717518,
0.0470067672,
-0.0114722252,
0.0395198576,
-0.0130272713,
-0.0099033639,
-0.0402104929,
-0.0768334717,
0.0297236349,
-0.0200317018,
0.04536964,
0.011888776,
0.0116509944,
-0.0531712994,
0.0165907983,
0.0026602256,
-0.0232517403,
-0.0765643269,
-0.020861486,
0.0249515381,
-0.0224298164,
-0.0139391385,
0.0227424465,
0.032741528,
-0.0401329584,
0.0138947265,
-0.0075052581,
-0.059788309,
-0.043206349,
0.0316489339,
-0.0141860219,
-0.0117302528,
-0.0158035923,
0.0135506978,
-0.0331360288,
0.022703005,
0.0199824255,
0.0357463434,
-0.0048126425,
0.005753885,
0.017599497,
-0.0491227917,
-0.0022951823,
0.0205963664,
0.0218505953,
0.0418433212,
0.0071991305,
-0.0654551908,
0.0216007363,
0.043696098,
-0.0043892628,
-0.0134440502,
-0.0144374091,
-0.0370495468,
-0.004189691,
0.0145131676,
-0.0023257416,
0.0311432835,
-0.0304329805,
-0.0054952893,
-0.0335177146,
0.0555411838,
0.0402607508,
-0.05402264,
-0.0050069308,
-0.0483025387,
0.0097924098,
-0.0665553361,
0.0285780039,
0.0054431274,
0.0034559234,
0.0634584501,
-0.1050840393,
0.0036381558,
0.0721272826,
0.0114732012,
-0.0159227885,
0.0380027071,
0.0262550917,
-0.0086595127,
-0.0066113463,
0.0289253406,
-0.0022771049,
0.000271547,
-0.0349330753,
0.002597786,
-0.0075380723,
-0.0166965835,
0.0458227061,
0.0453508496,
-0.0291888677,
0.0143272607,
-0.0239204746,
-0.0177944042,
-0.0188486334,
0.0427157022,
0.0509125702,
0.0145986835,
-0.0150781656,
-0.0403704643,
0.0338120125,
0.018219607,
-0.0715396851,
-0.0133714192,
0.0150134172,
0.0023071761,
0.0190444607,
-0.0772319734,
-0.0099929553,
-0.0228811782,
0.0453183167,
-0.0584916137,
0.0106276013,
0.1085307226,
0.0187970288,
-0.0121617531,
-0.0264923349,
0.0130345421,
-0.0078739775,
0.0354098342,
-0.0308301449,
-0.0710234195,
-0.0141004175,
0.0256250557,
0.0033837168,
0.0064907344,
-0.0825698152,
0.0002139706,
-0.1062030569,
0.0124023687,
-0.0211286098,
-0.0479746051,
0.016935477,
-0.0348698236,
0.0251959953,
-0.0275263656,
-0.0068384516,
-0.0328653418,
-0.0195994489,
-0.0066306074,
-0.0328444913,
0.0281914193,
-0.0130154826,
0.0277354717,
-0.0684492886,
0.0204879213,
-0.0087802885,
0.0657952204,
-0.0284390841,
0.0397561379,
-0.0328349061,
-0.0585050136,
-0.0214284994,
0.0130352322,
0.0645730495,
-0.0394970514,
0.0222805236,
-0.0287250075,
0.0221735183,
-0.0192310903,
-0.0319755934,
0.0582354516,
0.0082208766,
0.0210565459,
-0.0110333208,
-0.0157645233,
0.0025057206,
0.0051332857,
0.0639858246,
-0.0202527493,
-0.029553486,
-0.032096263,
0.0071284147,
-0.0335458405,
-0.0121236797,
0.0068884161,
0.0305296145,
-0.0493473224,
-0.0574472435,
-0.0620194301,
-0.0550838709,
-0.0225064177,
0.0195887294,
0.0438105315,
0.0588807948,
0.0482291058,
0.0552228279,
-0.0389043912,
0.0047048125,
-0.0062609222,
-0.0048236721,
-0.0166388955,
-0.004921902,
0.0083425064,
-0.0275193062,
0.0118830958,
-0.0268586129,
-0.0437236726,
-0.0360776111,
-0.0155698387,
-0.074903205,
-0.0061341939,
0.023330031,
-0.0232833102,
-0.0104697179,
0.068850413,
0.0044613322,
-0.0375920571,
-0.0014886573,
0.0006597135,
0.0546790697,
-0.0413679369,
0.0112432986,
-0.0116781881,
0.0321468301,
-0.0018291671,
0.0355803408,
-0.0045334483,
-0.0090269083,
-0.0055023981,
0.007602632,
0.0289831888,
-0.0334480479,
-0.0030521392,
-0.0925550237,
0.0091533065,
-0.0042224256,
-0.0028974498,
0.0028949531,
-0.0080784494,
0.0626540408,
-0.0116013512,
-0.0558139011,
0.0841832757,
0.0259725265,
0.0082954383,
-0.035442695,
0.0056164502,
0.0303763971,
0.0551730692,
-0.0284322258,
-0.0010260843,
0.0313058011,
0.029898826,
0.0109292539,
0.043484021,
0.0004972903,
0.0457212701,
0.0020214322,
0.0140879918,
-0.0002042263,
-0.0016775682,
-0.0491318032,
0.0565649495,
-0.0061018527,
0.0344766155,
0.0440148078,
-0.0103799654,
0.0505692549,
-0.0251358207,
-0.0181124359,
0.001720346,
0.0329512954,
-0.0002880387,
0.0233329553,
-0.0246248301,
0.0272453018,
-0.0226272605,
0.0015072543,
0.0639352277,
0.0205260031,
-0.0003399537,
0.0784459934,
-0.0361372903,
-0.0217136312,
0.0123034706,
0.0334808789,
0.0194723643,
0.0084338952,
0.024926763,
-0.0340592712,
-0.0359371305,
0.0507354699,
-0.0361646749,
0.0045903958,
0.007284598,
-0.0105419867,
0.0072189877,
0.0071045258,
0.0038829721,
-0.0635615885,
-0.0268058181,
0.0058275866,
-0.0176029932,
0.0123953503,
-6.04258867e-33,
-0.0311422404,
-0.0091737872,
-0.0108916182,
0.025817534,
-0.0103299422,
0.0206806064,
-0.0335553512,
-0.0242907312,
0.0339786001,
-0.0149221011,
-0.0062264325,
0.0203431789,
0.0220907275,
-0.0149424654,
0.0021121609,
-0.0217836834,
0.035804145,
0.0484971777,
-0.0370916724,
-0.0049255532,
0.1032272801,
0.0814919174,
0.0881933868,
-0.0615235567,
0.0390091017,
-0.0227172412,
-0.0225381143,
-0.0317126736,
0.0783972293,
0.0404469408,
-0.0309053119,
0.0174061544,
0.0305162352,
-0.0187170058,
0.0110059427,
-0.0208776761,
-0.1617987305,
-0.0079665715,
-0.0255340543,
0.0481748059,
0.0514877997,
-0.0357004628,
-0.0114412112,
0.0162494406,
0.0470068082,
-0.0056042336,
0.084125258,
-0.0192713179,
0.0196913891,
-0.0452379249,
-0.0842384994,
0.0412982143,
0.0037057353,
0.0442053862,
0.0374063812,
-0.010828319,
0.0143240476,
0.0030973137,
-0.0717446133,
-0.0348633491,
0.0331979245,
-0.0084302779,
-0.04483895,
0.0432007574,
-0.0100965388,
0.0328318216,
-0.0013319901,
0.0022582097,
-0.0487309694,
0.0406377167,
0.069301255,
-0.0183414221,
-0.0555878058,
0.0753137246,
0.0550068319,
-0.0168427192,
-0.0419695601,
0.04793562,
0.0085043227,
-0.0250198673,
0.0014369335,
-0.0260801725,
-0.0769773796,
-0.0336323604,
0.0099048773,
-0.0266208276,
-0.0381666757,
0.0004590153,
0.0074427519,
0.0276186988,
-0.0564830154,
-0.0011661407,
0.0138773145,
-0.051370468,
-0.0512019917,
0.0326227583,
-0.0007008672,
0.0228197519,
-0.0155186839,
0.0172284413,
-0.0643876493,
-0.050262522,
0.0083117411,
-0.0174007695,
0.0167987961,
-0.0570718423,
0.0531699322,
0.0128831463,
-0.0705367476,
-0.0105558792,
0.018384004,
-0.0149346208,
0.0018230168,
0.0856201649,
-0.0256811883,
-0.0270809233,
0.0094837733,
0.0155496504,
0.0628492534,
0.024165431,
-0.0495364666,
0.0188604854,
0.0131417261,
-0.0163463149,
-0.0030336636,
0.0226923861,
0.0150131462,
-0.0375028364,
0.0288880989,
-0.0639096946,
-0.0075322171,
-0.0143877761,
2.57e-7,
0.0148123931,
-0.0212645661,
0.0283761639,
0.0354336239,
-0.0205149483,
0.0125191426,
0.0004171435,
0.0829205438,
-0.0356351994,
0.0012597877,
0.0341255069,
-0.0036464799,
0.0485051535,
0.0376473144,
-0.1186627075,
-0.0122376392,
0.0217158459,
-0.015218881,
-0.0566389523,
0.028613301,
-0.0166388135,
0.0465648323,
0.0173609573,
0.0009661293,
-0.0053381436,
-0.0347475894,
0.0314883292,
0.0073407213,
0.0008425635,
0.0741956234,
0.023983648,
0.0786443874,
-0.0392502993,
0.0010552933,
0.004529438,
0.0671492666,
0.0495392904,
0.0318285264,
-0.0066384193,
-0.0379389897,
-0.0136578111,
-0.0257643294,
0.0094580045,
-0.0204468258,
0.0691490471,
0.0581792183,
-0.0183977466,
-0.0014996798,
0.0019875958,
-0.0059768171,
0.0095859384,
-0.0010770585,
-0.023973126,
0.0200038273,
0.0288329292,
-0.0350444987,
0.014948749,
-0.072496444,
0.0094512198,
0.0540551469,
0.0198623724,
-0.0309585612,
0.0213361308,
-0.0506934673,
0.0002709799,
-0.1069617644,
0.0203159358,
2.217528996e-34,
-0.0074693481,
-0.0084126256,
-0.0764279664,
0.0345638655,
0.0348459072,
-0.0386116691,
-0.0117241368,
-0.0270579383,
-0.0414995737,
-0.0356027521,
-0.0218080524
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15507v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15507v1 | Improving Word Sense Disambiguation in Neural Machine Translation with Salient Document Context | 2023-11-27T03:05:48 | 2023-11-27T03:05:48 | Elijah Rippeth, Marine Carpuat, Kevin Duh, Matt Post | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Lexical ambiguity is a challenging and pervasive problem in machine
translation (\mt). We introduce a simple and scalable approach to resolve
translation ambiguity by incorporating a small amount of extra-sentential
context in neural \mt. Our approach requires no sense annotation and no change
to standard model architectures. Since actual document context is not available
for the vast majority of \mt training data, we collect related sentences for
each input to construct pseudo-documents. Salient words from pseudo-documents
are then encoded as a prefix to each source sentence to condition the
generation of the translation. To evaluate, we release \docmucow, a challenge
set for translation disambiguation based on the English-German \mucow
\cite{raganato-etal-2020-evaluation} augmented with document IDs. Extensive
experiments show that our method translates ambiguous source words better than
strong sentence-level baselines and comparable document-level baselines while
reducing training costs. | [
0.0405984148,
0.0230087861,
0.0182201769,
0.0535586104,
-0.0088029196,
0.0248597618,
-0.0095822774,
-0.017126115,
-0.0358320214,
-0.0128579363,
-0.0127344728,
-0.0064453441,
0.0142293572,
-0.0161116514,
0.0375105739,
-0.0325833634,
0.0593830496,
-0.0102300942,
-0.043496795,
-0.0027763483,
-0.0149638597,
0.026361309,
0.0223751049,
-0.0167688634,
-0.0220923219,
-0.0376155861,
0.000897342,
0.0694582984,
0.0371171571,
-0.0071368273,
0.0253639743,
-0.0033990885,
0.0114669381,
0.0977073759,
0.0000019342,
-0.0450029224,
-0.0574899055,
-0.0069751581,
-0.0077162767,
-0.0072236024,
0.0427731983,
-0.0588185154,
0.0035646588,
-0.0050069601,
-0.00956167,
0.01547396,
0.0229301658,
0.0091353646,
0.0609815605,
0.0732948259,
-0.0138156312,
-0.0266024582,
-0.0291143712,
-0.0662528351,
0.0197856557,
-0.0556215346,
-0.0422813669,
-0.0126652066,
-0.0304863416,
0.0392955467,
0.0040179105,
0.0679432377,
0.0281721931,
0.0075409897,
0.0046160347,
-0.0065869302,
-0.0183242355,
-0.0226276144,
-0.0200811587,
0.0697568581,
-0.0147209028,
-0.006365438,
-0.0077714636,
-0.0166022293,
-0.001794126,
-0.0490550697,
0.0045535737,
0.0049282839,
-0.0221334286,
0.0041983598,
0.0556427166,
0.0630901903,
0.0418787189,
0.0503895469,
-0.0232360419,
0.0078829639,
0.0108637204,
-0.0081051057,
0.0120531535,
0.0070113246,
-0.0415054858,
-0.0118880859,
0.0768415853,
-0.0081909401,
-0.0273532812,
0.028799016,
-0.047504276,
-0.0718789995,
0.0170314368,
-0.1159873903,
0.0052505513,
0.044755619,
-0.0182340853,
0.0864934325,
0.0017634145,
0.0405734964,
-0.0274432302,
0.0036922719,
-0.0910006315,
-0.0558335744,
-0.0287677255,
0.0354857482,
-0.0534169339,
0.0035000641,
-0.0885750428,
-0.0123849409,
-0.0233813208,
0.0180183947,
0.0004603464,
-0.0082670702,
0.0023193173,
-0.0137300398,
-0.1093029678,
0.0103790928,
0.0088711735,
0.0370295905,
-0.0517488085,
-0.0239807516,
-0.0126925483,
-0.0316964984,
-0.0366676636,
0.0196996816,
-0.0314698778,
-0.058469329,
0.0108224545,
0.0236807913,
-0.0218853168,
-0.0230713207,
-0.0232003331,
-0.0397742614,
-0.0069125523,
-0.0294670314,
0.0192367956,
-0.0564941168,
0.0622522011,
-0.0022268929,
0.0113069853,
-0.0650174543,
0.0034940767,
-0.0061277621,
-0.0205237996,
0.1109800637,
-0.0358558968,
-0.0544658899,
0.0117792729,
0.0187133364,
0.0038908247,
0.0609785952,
0.0374932736,
0.0498676151,
0.0621056408,
0.0655926168,
-0.0640423372,
0.0076486538,
0.0189561397,
0.009254572,
0.0006248514,
0.0007412624,
-0.048756171,
0.0485146679,
0.0236722287,
0.0659452602,
-0.0311021153,
-0.0014451791,
0.0178248808,
0.0076869517,
0.0024364057,
-0.006713727,
0.0200020857,
0.0296311844,
-0.0206800159,
0.0009062334,
-0.0214057174,
0.0141701289,
-0.0005860909,
0.0177371353,
0.0240805559,
0.019092137,
-0.027512027,
-0.0388322398,
-0.00968228,
-0.0199928228,
0.0336211734,
0.0131608704,
0.0277624913,
0.0486719348,
-0.0387471505,
0.0637146011,
-0.001200107,
-0.0529390909,
0.0271763336,
-0.001819596,
-0.0298053306,
0.0563847907,
0.0472006463,
-0.0283327382,
-0.076077044,
-0.0195559859,
0.0208318494,
0.0771686211,
0.0644872561,
-0.0173008442,
0.0774880722,
-0.0553931482,
-0.0200247504,
-0.033942163,
0.0084665818,
0.0000248343,
-0.0022057877,
-0.002666773,
0.0514066778,
-0.0660917014,
-0.0274581499,
0.0354360156,
-0.0358353034,
-0.0406219102,
0.0055347141,
0.0134757087,
0.0314146839,
0.0179311149,
-0.0029928128,
-0.0042322096,
0.0167504735,
-0.0544086881,
0.0100631863,
0.0232850369,
-0.0459144786,
-0.0423801541,
0.0270306189,
-0.0329577811,
-0.0450436175,
0.017987987,
-0.0923548341,
-0.0349323191,
-0.0201806221,
-0.0145272044,
0.0039233691,
-0.0305243619,
0.0271637086,
-0.0066100429,
0.0022792239,
-0.0450678989,
0.0386460461,
-0.011350329,
-0.0112607656,
-0.0054313038,
0.023954574,
0.0236756243,
-0.0001490553,
-0.0296558123,
0.0348379612,
0.0132574104,
0.025041867,
0.0323026031,
0.0540874861,
-0.0446609855,
-0.044213675,
-0.0509597994,
0.0419172011,
-0.0355414636,
0.0275184065,
0.0630978644,
0.0610752478,
0.0164432339,
-0.0219446924,
0.0155576468,
0.0018124557,
-0.024227567,
-0.0033660007,
0.0363418907,
-0.0094722323,
0.0526379831,
-0.027433211,
-0.0245319027,
-0.0063007483,
0.0207447764,
0.0309838746,
-0.0504288413,
-0.0531745479,
0.055931028,
-0.042437803,
0.0158644505,
-0.0164893586,
-0.02392455,
-0.0147238597,
-0.0135526676,
0.0118540917,
0.039776817,
0.0026814514,
0.0178683344,
0.0201981571,
-0.0067893448,
-0.0530600809,
0.0251869932,
0.013948286,
0.0262521431,
-0.014690741,
-0.0503572896,
0.0322374813,
0.0287193432,
-0.0202813186,
-0.0249696393,
-0.0041228486,
0.0151953995,
-0.0263016205,
-0.0220493525,
0.0042103813,
0.0225534961,
0.0125072561,
0.0112182023,
-0.0338363759,
-0.033918675,
0.0782478601,
-0.0094904546,
0.0130732767,
-0.1245587692,
0.0100246826,
-0.0340865627,
0.0445470735,
-0.0435245484,
0.0296881869,
-0.0311975647,
-0.0124508478,
-0.0479485914,
-0.0311502796,
0.0086574014,
-0.0138290497,
0.031020103,
-0.0627803877,
0.0128359059,
-0.0162309837,
-0.0137128374,
-0.0339516588,
-0.0176567361,
-0.0152413473,
0.0303304847,
0.0449534394,
0.0138503993,
-0.007854349,
-0.0252726991,
-0.0042618369,
0.0892611369,
-0.0047291424,
-0.0338632278,
-0.0444236696,
0.0184281878,
0.0335937142,
-0.0082172621,
0.065503262,
-0.0503100827,
0.0083878096,
0.0249061286,
0.0162977315,
-0.0583933741,
-0.0378845558,
-0.0103646191,
0.0458516032,
-0.0221102834,
-0.03050787,
-0.0278614368,
0.0470136255,
-0.0381293893,
-0.0327038914,
0.0953948572,
0.0476011187,
-0.0753375068,
-0.0269670226,
0.000313124,
0.0265078489,
-0.0043894849,
0.0245376546,
-0.064743109,
-0.0423054546,
-0.0011404644,
0.0277267117,
0.0416815355,
0.0260237586,
-0.0261320118,
-0.050054837,
-0.0092872037,
0.0360582955,
-0.0375178754,
-0.0145407915,
0.0273313094,
-0.0220459905,
-0.0219573937,
0.040010184,
-0.0083485376,
0.0128103346,
-0.0063824994,
-0.0269290768,
0.0715122372,
-0.0569854267,
0.0053572739,
-0.0577246845,
0.0167891048,
0.0715653747,
0.0349843614,
0.0301592778,
-0.0002549146,
0.0439276733,
-0.0425157994,
-0.0056280657,
-0.051085256,
0.045735918,
-0.0014873893,
0.0010713695,
0.0134230098,
0.0064406609,
-0.0374891534,
0.0139355008,
-0.0089863939,
-0.0016893977,
-0.021062037,
0.0191909596,
-0.0090167504,
-0.0265871417,
0.0117502818,
0.0643534139,
-0.0181910899,
-0.0370437428,
-0.0172643941,
-0.0176966861,
0.0405334421,
-0.0576468483,
0.0628536642,
-0.0320603438,
-0.0787911862,
0.0062351786,
-0.0693623796,
-0.0682215616,
-0.0238339324,
0.0382508337,
0.0082621211,
0.0115294661,
0.0095786126,
-0.0147174932,
-0.0435243435,
0.0519143417,
-0.0151577098,
0.0139241479,
-0.0188426543,
0.0191428401,
0.0445155539,
-0.0143483309,
-0.008512239,
0.0910532698,
-0.0841532871,
-0.0501621403,
0.0023413002,
0.0299429707,
0.0233580396,
0.0859247297,
-0.0785349607,
-0.0310471617,
0.0069651599,
-0.0135446526,
-0.0084867058,
0.0165704917,
0.0489608608,
0.0388058051,
-0.0212847907,
0.0660437644,
-0.0567592829,
0.0120447995,
0.0146467267,
0.0560717471,
-0.0004347831,
-0.0089498106,
0.0090028737,
0.0003023958,
0.0193345156,
-0.0161875449,
0.0119458456,
-0.0393556058,
0.0087252259,
-0.0025020787,
-0.0239952039,
-0.0375945047,
0.0103115654,
0.0220959354,
-0.0264945012,
-0.0127408374,
0.0614461377,
-0.0231549982,
0.0166782215,
-0.0091383858,
-0.0346586965,
0.0165149551,
0.0062681278,
-0.0300275125,
0.0035826501,
0.013399398,
0.0323206894,
0.0048755324,
0.0253029317,
-0.0329748131,
0.0467796512,
0.0202940237,
-0.0060789133,
-0.0412781797,
0.03530569,
-0.0510618463,
0.0213514045,
-0.0252842531,
0.0228156373,
0.0654020011,
0.0008837911,
0.1210962459,
-0.0026451237,
-0.0202859417,
0.0036033485,
0.0302710608,
0.0329970457,
-0.000937878,
-0.0246962123,
0.012873007,
0.0307122655,
0.0312640071,
0.0569128878,
-0.0362257622,
-0.0012443897,
0.0172879994,
-0.018247284,
-0.0427985415,
0.0011655944,
-0.012525823,
0.0263152327,
-0.0113868667,
0.0003766598,
-0.0248269085,
-0.0548781715,
0.057122428,
-0.000927721,
-0.0099395839,
0.019428594,
0.0491733253,
0.0764851868,
-0.0205032304,
-0.0071600988,
-0.0187160559,
0.0046436195,
0.0032140214,
-0.0769751668,
-0.0527221002,
-6.415777637e-33,
-0.0180744939,
0.0180151872,
-0.0258167684,
-0.0491223261,
-0.0274639111,
0.0222170912,
-0.0442148037,
-0.0631825924,
-0.0304479469,
0.0079082064,
0.0002523458,
0.0585794114,
0.032807108,
0.0302517898,
-0.0406665504,
0.008365293,
0.0805602521,
0.019681165,
-0.0123378411,
0.0232859887,
0.0565285794,
-0.0012167098,
0.0750968605,
-0.064932473,
0.0719996691,
-0.0001469353,
-0.0154629583,
0.0305159912,
0.0422169045,
0.0230543315,
0.009279632,
0.0250483155,
0.0143699395,
0.0046460591,
-0.0402964093,
-0.0405388586,
-0.1185261309,
-0.0400112644,
0.0150955971,
0.0205153339,
-0.0430317186,
-0.0801957697,
0.0494703576,
-0.047270909,
0.0136592444,
0.0084141605,
-0.0004702479,
-0.0133369844,
-0.0451845154,
-0.0554913357,
-0.0409606509,
0.0156251155,
-0.0054117166,
-0.0227431152,
0.0225012098,
0.0259251911,
0.0052766935,
0.0169620197,
-0.0791525468,
-0.0020817341,
-0.0334185436,
0.0188838355,
0.047813002,
0.0076313363,
-0.0155724688,
0.0046327808,
0.0276701115,
-0.020745378,
0.0526191071,
-0.0133165289,
0.006416176,
-0.001470154,
0.054383181,
0.0591681115,
0.0728077218,
-0.012286284,
-0.0460415781,
0.0154015003,
0.0081549827,
0.0137384562,
0.008231286,
0.0092426538,
-0.0318489932,
-0.0123082828,
-0.0501580723,
-0.0540580153,
-0.0445266366,
-0.0130810346,
0.0014864957,
0.0157105196,
-0.0214915983,
0.0071895598,
0.0587035455,
-0.0235026032,
0.0400520936,
0.0301410183,
0.0196541883,
0.0251598191,
0.0262322463,
0.0354158245,
0.022916114,
-0.0377441831,
0.0066232882,
0.0321171097,
0.016226748,
-0.0096383234,
0.0434195101,
-0.0126483524,
0.0138010867,
0.0050167278,
-0.0231510922,
-0.0020945012,
-0.0426250584,
-0.0063366815,
0.0120053478,
0.0138795301,
0.0084646801,
0.0379871503,
0.0771019608,
0.0084050009,
0.0031984795,
0.0009321198,
-0.000842489,
0.0593179651,
-0.0451192483,
0.0224795397,
0.0023709161,
0.0210251436,
0.0255182013,
-0.0649066642,
0.0003263826,
0.0107164318,
2.704e-7,
0.0535737686,
0.0406567305,
-0.0071048783,
0.0117755076,
0.0050329091,
-0.0043077744,
0.0044854842,
0.0241372027,
-0.0210626144,
0.0062155016,
-0.0071728923,
0.0130314073,
0.0678456128,
0.0499953255,
-0.0479963571,
-0.0187109206,
-0.0057753539,
0.0527421311,
-0.0409138799,
0.0085097691,
0.0390761979,
0.1165339872,
0.0120368246,
-0.0144421589,
-0.03724733,
-0.0427379049,
0.0491436869,
-0.0207751654,
-0.0184603594,
0.0179722663,
0.0439030007,
-0.0002585242,
-0.0289056338,
-0.0204279516,
-0.0261616223,
0.005951806,
0.0388911925,
0.0680020526,
0.0157043505,
-0.0188848618,
-0.0132235968,
-0.0405396372,
0.0325218476,
-0.0107245408,
0.0475591719,
-0.0682671964,
0.000563223,
-0.0099884011,
-0.0121938232,
0.0136513021,
0.0546960644,
-0.0160000212,
-0.0642395243,
0.0103248619,
0.0256686118,
-0.0125087006,
-0.0475545488,
-0.052435711,
-0.0374439508,
-0.0116921552,
0.0035392412,
-0.0092116278,
0.0196845755,
0.0008358906,
0.0293179434,
-0.0333490185,
0.0082906876,
2.453843309e-34,
0.0714221075,
-0.0322637483,
-0.0128937978,
-0.0253681913,
0.026536582,
-0.017382225,
-0.0475727618,
0.0068217046,
0.0122618135,
-0.0337346606,
-0.005341351
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15500v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15500v2 | Function-constrained Program Synthesis | 2023-11-27T02:55:34 | 2023-12-04T06:24:02 | Patrick Hajali, Ignas Budvytis | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.PL | This work introduces (1) a technique that allows large language models (LLMs)
to leverage user-provided code when solving programming tasks and (2) a method
to iteratively generate modular sub-functions that can aid future code
generation attempts when the initial code generated by the LLM is inadequate.
Generating computer programs in general-purpose programming languages like
Python poses a challenge for LLMs when instructed to use code provided in the
prompt. Code-specific LLMs (e.g., GitHub Copilot, CodeLlama2) can generate code
completions in real-time by drawing on all code available in a development
environment. However, restricting code-specific LLMs to use only in-context
code is not straightforward, as the model is not explicitly instructed to use
the user-provided code and users cannot highlight precisely which snippets of
code the model should incorporate into its context. Moreover, current systems
lack effective recovery methods, forcing users to iteratively re-prompt the
model with modified prompts until a sufficient solution is reached. Our method
differs from traditional LLM-powered code-generation by constraining
code-generation to an explicit function set and enabling recovery from failed
attempts through automatically generated sub-functions. When the LLM cannot
produce working code, we generate modular sub-functions to aid subsequent
attempts at generating functional code. A by-product of our method is a library
of reusable sub-functions that can solve related tasks, imitating a software
team where efficiency scales with experience. We also introduce a new
"half-shot" evaluation paradigm that provides tighter estimates of LLMs' coding
abilities compared to traditional zero-shot evaluation. Our proposed evaluation
method encourages models to output solutions in a structured format, decreasing
syntax errors that can be mistaken for poor coding ability. | [
0.002993563,
0.0608474985,
-0.0342169292,
-0.0210259408,
-0.0022211391,
0.0036546981,
-0.0150763877,
0.0079937996,
0.0168732405,
0.004524841,
-0.004685564,
0.0252454318,
-0.0119372252,
0.0527465083,
0.0255806092,
-0.0650322735,
0.0058584693,
-0.0360858999,
-0.0317455344,
0.0054347934,
-0.0191847067,
0.0192849822,
0.0051430762,
0.0626448691,
0.0146733923,
-0.0126547962,
0.0048886919,
0.0189811364,
-0.041161228,
0.0013946064,
-0.005356336,
0.0276745111,
-0.0251527466,
-0.018491311,
0.0000027458,
-0.0336470976,
0.0013613678,
-0.0190908331,
-0.0523260832,
0.0163872316,
0.0201408528,
0.0237038154,
0.0105991066,
0.0102866273,
-0.0403998382,
-0.0087445257,
0.0402086638,
-0.094470717,
0.0699203163,
0.0125162303,
0.0270436686,
0.0259580165,
-0.0093254782,
0.0237470139,
0.0173910614,
-0.009735113,
-0.0303481724,
0.0535236634,
0.0780331194,
-0.0399410129,
0.0438602939,
0.0476838574,
0.0464625023,
-0.0161401369,
0.0363076553,
0.039789103,
-0.0310777836,
-0.065667592,
0.0115629332,
0.0009638103,
-0.0765338093,
-0.0755189434,
0.0141308187,
-0.0260106288,
-0.0241620559,
0.0153897395,
-0.0759271383,
0.029394757,
-0.00126858,
-0.0291521829,
-0.0104489001,
-0.0100788195,
0.014648865,
-0.0151806632,
0.0031560366,
0.027006574,
0.0154964775,
-0.0042738928,
-0.0630934238,
0.0075406344,
-0.0237827711,
-0.0551516898,
0.009692003,
0.0704307258,
-0.0465759858,
-0.0041845911,
-0.0407154113,
-0.016260501,
0.0185659267,
-0.0174919311,
0.004208121,
0.0486488454,
0.0002611139,
0.0215734523,
-0.0162114855,
0.0420017317,
-0.0379844867,
-0.0436219387,
-0.0270790495,
0.0136088468,
-0.039743375,
-0.0161030423,
-0.0546254963,
0.0381253436,
-0.0098546343,
0.0609979443,
-0.0239688791,
0.0730141401,
-0.0174526628,
0.0738796741,
-0.0064587244,
-0.007939117,
-0.0063843806,
-0.0364594311,
0.0341767743,
-0.0263695922,
0.0004864052,
-0.063221477,
-0.0050205793,
-0.0353071466,
0.0004354485,
0.0061012777,
-0.0340941884,
-0.0075583649,
0.0385749005,
0.0836427063,
-0.0044421237,
0.0239558108,
-0.0085905679,
-0.0695080757,
0.0209440459,
-0.0487656817,
-0.0312345512,
-0.1203963086,
-0.0457352959,
0.0652361959,
-0.0030545627,
-0.0582532883,
-0.0068973638,
-0.0117348628,
0.0214675646,
0.0223967917,
-0.0668542758,
0.0390801504,
0.0354659297,
0.0415779278,
-0.0157219116,
0.0158467107,
0.0237290859,
0.0149722565,
0.0009279201,
-0.0470769517,
0.0665453076,
0.033114031,
-0.0056341705,
0.0026712078,
0.0073004998,
0.00996021,
0.039828755,
-0.0210252106,
-0.0427879728,
0.0053378637,
-0.006768703,
0.0679136738,
0.0051678601,
0.0110439155,
0.0115493666,
0.033329919,
0.0680327341,
0.0147016076,
0.0255953632,
0.0005336386,
-0.0449416973,
0.0835347772,
-0.0153737189,
0.0106121833,
-0.025049068,
0.0436303727,
-0.0020771306,
-0.0500252508,
-0.0010189762,
-0.0076378244,
-0.0380065814,
0.0304068495,
0.0400981754,
-0.0045110136,
-0.0108762914,
0.0290839542,
-0.0043440098,
-0.0777780861,
-0.0130111948,
-0.0404902287,
0.058913108,
0.09141092,
0.0848863497,
-0.0503903143,
0.0150621515,
0.0070243604,
0.0204605013,
-0.0347181112,
0.0093690464,
-0.0158439521,
-0.0048167855,
-0.0140121505,
-0.0134269381,
-0.019899698,
-0.0213139486,
0.0237851348,
0.0210713632,
-0.0646745712,
0.0181112625,
-0.001797167,
-0.0225138254,
0.009295743,
-0.0356592014,
-0.0179215074,
0.0297212657,
-0.0026905285,
-0.0094709583,
-0.0222511888,
-0.0184614491,
0.0209010746,
0.0543151274,
-0.0406306982,
-0.0259929653,
-0.0321246199,
-0.0285953507,
0.0241481066,
0.0012590719,
-0.0066100848,
-0.0555406101,
-0.0146243973,
-0.0093147149,
-0.0179488715,
0.0582256578,
0.0073299562,
0.0324450098,
0.0026491215,
0.0454873964,
-0.0217883736,
-0.0478717573,
-0.0030936024,
0.0387835614,
0.0342800654,
0.0231527854,
0.0497641861,
0.0499934778,
0.0300816204,
-0.0019801336,
-0.0114098042,
0.016900355,
-0.0233693514,
0.0378744788,
-0.0018157212,
0.0418746546,
0.0155869108,
-0.0178571623,
-0.0938649476,
0.0302204788,
-0.0118947076,
-0.0076881922,
0.0213159453,
0.0462446734,
0.0085912952,
0.0076263989,
0.0077238367,
-0.0093744453,
0.0142253125,
0.0110281054,
-0.007385178,
-0.0023389703,
-0.0758088455,
-0.0193015728,
-0.0321411267,
-0.0086561963,
0.0335548297,
-0.0121746864,
-0.0148057016,
-0.0620965362,
0.0730842203,
0.0434632935,
0.0225979108,
-0.0108980909,
-0.0136730038,
0.0217130706,
-0.0390287079,
0.0798239037,
0.0184067525,
-0.0506105796,
-0.0105670262,
0.0850546584,
-0.0075468114,
-0.0383406766,
0.0245516058,
0.0399213433,
-0.0563735478,
0.0457508452,
-0.0194591228,
0.017540887,
0.0382779539,
0.009374734,
0.0038381447,
-0.0431762189,
0.0401542783,
0.0164584536,
0.0014548319,
0.0115089454,
-0.0388938598,
0.005789984,
0.0506699234,
-0.0053589321,
-0.0970956981,
0.0319560617,
-0.0308857113,
-0.0367314555,
0.0622808672,
-0.063217409,
-0.0348840542,
0.0872243196,
0.0207099915,
-0.0139411427,
-0.0039398833,
-0.0023725883,
-0.0111266188,
0.0315870494,
-0.0182195716,
-0.032546971,
0.0560721084,
-0.043295823,
-0.0001435325,
-0.0120692719,
-0.0245235637,
-0.0340406224,
-0.0011726803,
-0.0472018644,
-0.0028397378,
0.0095147835,
-0.002089411,
0.0465728939,
-0.0005916753,
0.0530174524,
0.0201749746,
0.0316481628,
-0.0300096571,
-0.00870586,
-0.0594618246,
-0.0491859652,
-0.0629819557,
-0.0640863255,
-0.0296287779,
0.0205999296,
0.0124054365,
0.0657493025,
0.0858096927,
-0.0255008563,
-0.0280041266,
0.0420478359,
0.0016813087,
-0.0520006791,
0.0585393161,
0.0541327409,
-0.0594867282,
-0.0326901264,
0.0495215692,
0.0124893766,
-0.0387553014,
0.0216462556,
-0.0329413153,
0.0470551066,
0.0806516185,
0.0519542173,
-0.0609538071,
-0.0203433484,
0.0032949334,
0.0417486727,
-0.0356617458,
0.01468598,
-0.0211519636,
-0.1005726904,
0.0356490687,
0.0224043094,
0.0183576439,
-0.0123079875,
-0.0128027974,
-0.0049204514,
0.0296776202,
-0.0926023424,
0.0630566552,
-0.0102829123,
0.0283395499,
-0.0101955868,
-0.0504582636,
0.0135045657,
0.0533870533,
0.0097865779,
0.0020559104,
0.0545774512,
-0.0054743807,
0.0391121022,
-0.0000939042,
0.0289040785,
-0.0238892902,
0.0063921721,
-0.0295357164,
0.0074411193,
0.0195022319,
-0.030961534,
0.0401190706,
0.009584574,
-0.029915696,
-0.0523482561,
0.0293951072,
0.0480601527,
-0.0260453019,
0.0230708551,
-0.020180501,
-0.0131169157,
-0.0016588196,
0.0285488628,
0.0540297069,
-0.0288376585,
-0.0254147723,
-0.0544693805,
-0.0362302102,
-0.077417478,
-0.0197377205,
-0.0094593288,
0.0067324261,
0.0459502302,
-0.0049466738,
0.043653395,
0.0575207211,
0.0415745936,
0.0075531271,
-0.036812406,
-0.02211616,
0.0102031734,
-0.0736654252,
-0.0397600234,
-0.0105383545,
0.0167699233,
-0.0505710989,
-0.022772871,
-0.022886591,
-0.0544049405,
0.0060153478,
0.0593089275,
-0.0547656566,
-0.037744686,
-0.0204556063,
0.0894965678,
0.0272705592,
-0.0459857918,
-0.0213349704,
-0.0728975907,
-0.0133856703,
0.0711538717,
-0.0089125941,
0.0187836234,
-0.0096807946,
0.0100225629,
0.0123557579,
-0.0187113341,
-0.0745162964,
-0.0273426492,
0.0378946699,
0.0027753753,
-0.0229072459,
0.0053673461,
0.0430809781,
0.0376489162,
-0.019397052,
0.0120915193,
-0.0312600657,
0.0063416194,
-0.0136839608,
-0.0022585304,
-0.0263695084,
-0.0729619116,
0.0063536167,
-0.0035990267,
-0.0380258523,
0.0765133947,
-0.0070400168,
-0.0594508834,
0.0535109863,
-0.0111509794,
0.0474440344,
-0.0560316555,
0.0345467292,
0.105587557,
0.0006810364,
-0.0168183763,
0.0245768391,
0.0013465246,
0.0087959794,
0.0026206735,
0.0280877892,
-0.0100774588,
0.0569562912,
0.0081606181,
0.0083746025,
-0.0338646993,
-0.1148891747,
-0.0077182315,
0.0456762128,
0.0286771748,
0.0422091819,
0.0077704657,
-0.0401631333,
-0.002194358,
-0.0528246649,
0.0342610814,
0.0116351275,
-0.0601156279,
-0.0346168876,
0.0336176045,
-0.0124530392,
-0.0780838057,
0.0923236758,
-0.0081782443,
0.002406636,
-0.0274677221,
-0.0155303199,
-0.0229003169,
-0.0058518187,
0.0289169699,
-0.0434489511,
-0.0238113422,
-0.0269290376,
-0.0573849306,
-0.0534181632,
-0.012586535,
0.0501597077,
-0.0013817661,
-0.0233093463,
0.0365637876,
0.05884967,
0.0103513328,
-0.0013682017,
0.0115448004,
0.058287967,
0.0232174192,
-0.0264112502,
-0.0134178605,
-6.611479079e-33,
-0.030562751,
-0.0521087982,
0.0256711859,
0.029548116,
0.0525983833,
0.0050665024,
-0.0589480288,
0.0332031399,
0.0441130884,
-0.0510817058,
0.0275933594,
-0.0246213451,
-0.0142006632,
-0.0424457602,
0.052267272,
0.0579777323,
0.041875042,
0.0523732118,
-0.0735860988,
0.0320599005,
0.0096891886,
0.021995591,
-0.0120137753,
-0.0337024629,
-0.0408558883,
-0.0251471195,
0.0140602943,
0.0036688934,
0.0197107941,
0.0401270762,
-0.0003961652,
0.0081702294,
0.0029123076,
-0.037515074,
-0.041564431,
0.0090368809,
-0.0048632193,
-0.0282806419,
0.0329626203,
-0.0379624292,
-0.0197784696,
-0.0408791602,
0.0720823482,
0.0045882552,
-0.0319459401,
0.0072512329,
-0.0033192281,
0.0065214457,
-0.0061864383,
-0.0222986266,
-0.0495875329,
0.030554574,
-0.0061994987,
-0.0483233184,
-0.0195395425,
0.0533200875,
-0.0217952076,
0.015902387,
0.0669170469,
-0.0025307615,
0.0080548413,
0.0587006509,
0.0470072739,
-0.0239868741,
-0.0082747377,
0.0046053217,
0.0263006687,
0.0130973132,
-0.0620841868,
0.0074237273,
-0.0036035378,
0.0364884585,
0.0383317024,
0.0441283882,
0.0166867394,
-0.0193733722,
-0.0163603667,
0.0046544163,
-0.0275851488,
0.0171508696,
0.0090391226,
0.0445832089,
-0.004675569,
-0.0035986786,
-0.023507541,
-0.0098932469,
-0.0286393743,
-0.0492661707,
0.0087453537,
-0.0011472685,
-0.0558727719,
-0.0012591819,
-0.0013656864,
0.0125412699,
0.0179486722,
0.0045931139,
-0.0362487659,
0.0477500334,
-0.0107226018,
0.0040200604,
0.0097512417,
-0.0137112429,
0.0021241775,
-0.004990594,
0.0851326957,
0.0366275124,
-0.0013431889,
0.0435161963,
-0.0402696393,
0.0016119654,
-0.0719109625,
0.0068559656,
-0.0029429749,
-0.0012583941,
0.0271059852,
0.0079216808,
0.0036042966,
-0.0043790122,
-0.031535387,
-0.0961398184,
-0.0699775219,
0.0006499985,
0.0179278664,
0.0022379102,
-0.0329578742,
-0.0340234414,
-0.062699981,
0.0241180584,
0.0324891359,
0.0064920746,
-0.0547261238,
0.0184394009,
3.496e-7,
-0.0069904602,
-0.0007807448,
-0.0073137968,
0.0591984503,
0.0016233783,
0.0223188028,
-0.0098149655,
-0.0034692076,
0.0299265552,
-0.0183920171,
-0.0247604288,
0.0060880366,
0.0571897328,
0.0275454335,
-0.035381157,
0.0327232815,
0.0017921214,
0.0128286742,
-0.0443646237,
0.0016644829,
0.0397057608,
-0.0077531063,
0.0502284467,
-0.0030222856,
0.0430995896,
-0.0541104861,
0.008261445,
-0.0189083666,
0.0002555963,
0.0084922025,
-0.0950550064,
0.0534848273,
-0.0023246692,
-0.0060304939,
-0.0038533558,
-0.0579019897,
0.0291890651,
0.0698639378,
0.0064932476,
0.0648392141,
0.0359970927,
-0.0362254642,
-0.0041787745,
-0.0580692217,
0.0252318587,
-0.0158280469,
0.0288000032,
0.0061030216,
0.0042937505,
-0.008363463,
-0.0128129898,
-0.0150108794,
0.0106913541,
0.0082972096,
-0.0224122684,
0.0096467696,
-0.0500713997,
0.0058053168,
-0.0359282531,
-0.0002149912,
-0.0368367322,
-0.0255640559,
-0.0596325956,
0.012746348,
0.0162231456,
-0.0351471156,
0.0106021045,
3.381495926e-34,
0.0254487526,
-0.0006495272,
0.0474803112,
0.0129198553,
0.0305018537,
0.0078978864,
-0.0286063161,
0.0145154232,
0.0263199061,
0.0047287755,
-0.0489337333
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15490v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15490v1 | Optimizing and Fine-tuning Large Language Model for Urban Renewal | 2023-11-27T02:17:11 | 2023-11-27T02:17:11 | Xi Wang, Xianyao Ling, Tom Zhang, Xuecao Li, Shaolan Wang, Zhixing Li, Liang Zhang, Peng Gong | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This study aims to innovatively explore adaptive applications of large
language models (LLM) in urban renewal. It also aims to improve its performance
and text generation quality for knowledge question-answering (QA) tasks. Based
on the ChatGLM, we automatically generate QA datasets using urban renewal
scientific literature corpora in a self-instruct manner and then conduct joint
fine-tuning training on the model using the Prefix and LoRA fine-tuning methods
to create an LLM for urban renewal. By guiding the LLM to automatically
generate QA data based on prompt words and given text, it is possible to
quickly obtain datasets in the urban renewal field and provide data support for
the fine-tuning training of LLMs. The experimental results show that the joint
fine-tuning training method proposed in this study can significantly improve
the performance of LLM on the QA tasks. Compared with LoRA fine-tuning, the
method improves the Bleu and Rouge metrics on the test by about 5%; compared
with the model before fine-tuning, the method improves the Bleu and Rouge
metrics by about 15%-20%. This study demonstrates the effectiveness and
superiority of the joint fine-tuning method using Prefix and LoRA for ChatGLM
in the urban renewal knowledge QA tasks. It provides a new approach for
fine-tuning LLMs on urban renewal-related tasks. | [
0.0776513219,
0.0587200001,
-0.0054021389,
0.0279723722,
-0.0153772533,
-0.0194035377,
-0.0067485003,
-0.0122642973,
-0.0379049107,
-0.0658776537,
-0.0033798264,
-0.0113765923,
-0.0053221532,
0.0170559417,
-0.0073916153,
-0.0468795374,
0.0150566725,
-0.0130179795,
0.0159284994,
-0.0269230399,
0.0266574919,
0.0301524028,
0.0187714063,
0.0191771463,
0.0137796653,
0.0003438655,
-0.0018576812,
-0.0000250937,
0.0127678113,
-0.0256219562,
0.0359258279,
0.0305557493,
0.019578157,
0.0082544321,
0.000002168,
-0.0635991693,
-0.0456442423,
0.0012173011,
0.0203649718,
0.0033199773,
0.0541042387,
0.0149999876,
0.0185637232,
0.043517191,
-0.0284299981,
0.0153272422,
0.0116417874,
0.0482983738,
0.0487239622,
0.0580509678,
0.0291124098,
-0.0687175468,
0.0218675248,
0.0006758207,
-0.0182802267,
-0.0210966915,
0.0257276818,
0.0226035286,
0.0090400539,
0.0380493328,
-0.0115667991,
0.0213342644,
-0.0059901066,
-0.0158191845,
0.0301824957,
-0.0001896952,
-0.0382243246,
0.017277671,
-0.0148742869,
0.0806343257,
-0.0061194836,
-0.0114507675,
0.0557384118,
0.0053634988,
0.004047744,
0.0404608585,
-0.0854439214,
-0.0050380984,
-0.005312365,
0.0149820996,
-0.0342629217,
-0.0694617182,
0.0093015479,
0.0391457975,
-0.038881816,
0.0842857063,
0.0103822583,
-0.0295139998,
-0.0326904766,
-0.0122775435,
0.0052719209,
-0.0333947018,
-0.0035697655,
0.0938570276,
-0.04019491,
0.0241381694,
-0.0240764674,
0.012304144,
0.0376158319,
-0.0101835486,
0.0121891126,
0.0096193561,
-0.0025386994,
0.0145046366,
-0.0221215617,
0.0398942754,
0.0409346819,
-0.0033639995,
-0.0490741506,
-0.0158169046,
-0.063532114,
-0.0481656529,
-0.0704405829,
0.0641867667,
-0.0425310098,
0.0075999587,
-0.0194309857,
0.0284574609,
0.041976545,
-0.0115253292,
-0.0300104581,
0.0265772119,
-0.0171739757,
-0.0274583809,
-0.0406766422,
0.0170009676,
-0.041448921,
0.0023425906,
-0.0138534326,
-0.0196358673,
0.0200264174,
0.0125156641,
0.0308958944,
-0.0118485717,
-0.0035984395,
0.0188585557,
-0.007582014,
-0.010166659,
-0.0604573004,
-0.0343290977,
-0.0078325914,
-0.0662314966,
0.0043544164,
-0.0755350366,
-0.0274046585,
0.0037762127,
-0.032621108,
-0.0051236791,
0.0039551607,
0.0309979022,
-0.046300251,
0.0176599436,
-0.0879881456,
0.0538056754,
0.0881741792,
-0.0169972703,
0.0792033225,
0.0750120357,
0.0402886607,
0.0249682646,
0.0257111024,
-0.0028785728,
-0.0055046268,
-0.0116865439,
0.0356795564,
0.0345693789,
0.0008252808,
0.0418936051,
-0.0133971702,
0.039604269,
0.0207579248,
0.0499753505,
0.0024349077,
0.0549986511,
0.050106369,
0.0083600422,
0.0375789776,
0.0056856181,
0.0330602191,
0.0619835034,
-0.0009584014,
0.0150596686,
-0.0028341485,
0.0032921408,
-0.0669827238,
0.0399446487,
-0.0028534716,
0.0645781457,
-0.029863948,
-0.0251620114,
-0.0058052563,
0.0217837561,
0.0062860278,
-0.0180812795,
0.0568612777,
0.0135568939,
-0.0270523373,
0.0102782082,
0.017452538,
0.0222882051,
0.0388399437,
-0.0829972476,
0.0150087886,
0.0732725784,
0.0221345723,
-0.013637092,
-0.0108108688,
-0.0106987506,
0.0184583161,
0.0312656127,
0.0460387468,
-0.0041149748,
-0.0730393827,
-0.0802553296,
-0.0346039198,
-0.0356366634,
0.0047248057,
-0.0187592041,
0.0205096174,
0.0461607799,
0.061840307,
-0.0524269119,
-0.049697604,
0.0322959758,
0.013744385,
-0.0018890576,
-0.0134982169,
-0.003355328,
-0.03554295,
0.0079271495,
-0.0387387536,
0.0235185716,
0.0152457515,
0.0016680832,
-0.0574843027,
-0.0129628917,
-0.0065175947,
-0.0317360163,
0.029549703,
0.0099233268,
-0.0046816943,
0.0131533444,
-0.0428832434,
-0.0346880741,
-0.0263796039,
-0.0311504286,
0.0161269344,
-0.029391991,
0.0455414094,
-0.0037863089,
-0.0345910825,
-0.0817572996,
0.0678822175,
0.0165856145,
0.0207945295,
0.0308505185,
0.0378549583,
0.0267633852,
-0.0482900962,
-0.0286294427,
-0.0369483531,
-0.0074583874,
0.016246723,
0.0294053983,
0.0699252486,
-0.0455095433,
-0.0311989598,
-0.0719069317,
0.0050628665,
-0.0362357385,
0.0201185383,
0.0100575956,
-0.0183030088,
-0.0234513599,
-0.0041335202,
-0.0340351202,
0.0543855429,
0.0097449031,
0.0180571396,
0.0407257155,
-0.0388190448,
-0.0201916154,
-0.021021368,
0.0096303411,
0.0025900949,
0.0358964875,
0.0502614155,
-0.0053667203,
-0.0372395366,
0.0214795154,
-0.0273941774,
-0.0248443689,
0.0308689456,
-0.0610794649,
-0.0022638582,
0.0320945866,
0.0711696967,
-0.0021923278,
0.0409430489,
-0.0272698645,
0.0100813936,
-0.0208235364,
-0.0521131158,
0.0001765368,
-0.0305550992,
-0.0451822542,
0.0036063481,
-0.0379368886,
0.0299147274,
0.0108076762,
0.0036939126,
-0.0140383802,
-0.0192392096,
0.0385871902,
-0.0290766377,
-0.0160223171,
-0.0520721897,
0.0347121395,
0.01109803,
0.0321597904,
-0.0286898017,
-0.051042892,
0.037468262,
-0.0093040569,
0.0204789918,
-0.0614353754,
0.0231093727,
-0.0659109727,
0.0298397094,
-0.0207957625,
0.0445313156,
0.0266065244,
-0.0151291015,
-0.0446222983,
-0.0377646163,
-0.0469649695,
-0.0223134886,
0.0161451977,
-0.0779553205,
0.0275932681,
-0.0030854885,
-0.0330010802,
-0.0270905141,
-0.0548151061,
-0.0003048277,
0.0134233385,
0.0412290581,
0.0130493604,
0.0172324684,
0.0640472695,
0.0074356012,
0.0241520051,
-0.0416127071,
-0.0018994705,
-0.0079187332,
0.0504263751,
0.103131853,
0.0672644526,
-0.0123392055,
0.021604063,
0.0021549582,
0.0024984994,
0.0076533542,
0.0195819028,
-0.0060556829,
0.0053232969,
0.0060283989,
-0.0569783784,
-0.0265039578,
0.017163083,
0.018206913,
-0.0596825331,
-0.0228888858,
0.0811240003,
0.0381999798,
0.0327192284,
-0.0079373624,
-0.0407591909,
0.01190315,
0.0192487519,
0.0437077992,
-0.0744403452,
-0.0016849148,
-0.0106458599,
0.0202905517,
0.0025359017,
-0.0024959797,
-0.0067467215,
-0.1342740953,
0.0524259321,
-0.016051067,
-0.0687406808,
-0.0367377661,
-0.0470854752,
-0.0301660877,
0.0369025469,
-0.0163612887,
0.0201860536,
-0.037287984,
0.0156578608,
0.0320895389,
-0.0452153794,
-0.0665327981,
-0.0266077165,
-0.0089287441,
0.0893688872,
0.0670561865,
0.0642339215,
-0.0072642895,
0.0193418805,
0.0081486115,
-0.0211542808,
0.0423083641,
-0.0294086132,
-0.0022507191,
0.0285943244,
-0.0185743943,
0.0067972997,
0.0102024823,
-0.0341118537,
0.0018981257,
0.0813769698,
0.0385856219,
-0.0244219583,
0.010491427,
-0.0218987726,
0.037036255,
0.012586385,
0.0541764423,
0.027342096,
-0.0114085823,
-0.0219320729,
-0.0256182868,
-0.0520770811,
-0.0686997622,
-0.0305836424,
0.0254138242,
-0.0700176209,
0.0428495668,
-0.0765894651,
-0.0393202603,
0.0480778702,
0.0412948281,
0.0092028687,
0.031710308,
0.0124456026,
-0.0084439246,
-0.0431871191,
0.0176057331,
-0.0461750738,
-0.0069966866,
-0.0369837396,
-0.0395852923,
0.0365460142,
-0.0312060639,
-0.0225023665,
-0.0089492481,
-0.0592318736,
-0.0403621085,
0.0022654955,
0.0395445079,
0.0207759906,
-0.016984798,
0.0005549762,
-0.0525988936,
0.0684576035,
-0.0025833072,
-0.017601585,
0.005607673,
-0.0283873137,
0.0268914066,
-0.0035078702,
0.0138576059,
-0.0598364919,
0.0343413614,
0.012664156,
0.0751446486,
-0.0198722221,
0.0202920698,
0.0124823665,
0.0905581489,
0.0012497236,
-0.0025403802,
-0.0140931271,
-0.0246009324,
0.0191473477,
0.0084692501,
-0.0225028098,
-0.010700997,
0.0360066295,
-0.0058297263,
0.0124263149,
-0.0153776752,
0.015383265,
0.002110108,
0.0091168778,
-0.0343279839,
-0.0333840661,
-0.0137400227,
0.0060822405,
0.0348073505,
0.0163992364,
-0.0288461987,
0.0017573317,
0.0192646142,
0.0084086657,
0.0266388059,
0.0197065286,
0.0175494049,
0.0016415291,
-0.0425468087,
0.0311485641,
0.0003578498,
-0.0789054707,
-0.0544133224,
0.056991145,
0.046441935,
0.0595445782,
0.0231162943,
-0.0019877753,
-0.0085886158,
-0.0223266464,
-0.0053620934,
0.043809589,
-0.0231438577,
0.0277090948,
-0.0140979523,
-0.0691396818,
0.000141382,
0.0738573596,
0.027260229,
0.027874697,
-0.0116513427,
-0.0033204528,
-0.0108586363,
-0.007426165,
0.0072423955,
0.0322084576,
0.02615414,
-0.0182904471,
-0.0464559272,
-0.0075929672,
0.0240437556,
-0.0136213098,
-0.0067659332,
-0.0133261979,
0.0444046557,
0.0550669208,
0.0016293559,
-0.0011435933,
-0.0735098943,
0.0124998819,
-0.0360365883,
-0.0032640419,
-0.0047056279,
-6.8359074e-33,
-0.0341964141,
-0.0667471513,
0.0670947731,
-0.026458215,
-0.0453415886,
0.0079651624,
-0.0262920409,
-0.0390468352,
-0.0087323198,
-0.0108633805,
-0.0023620373,
-0.027977176,
0.0074823885,
0.0150158955,
0.0295596886,
0.0139010381,
0.0410195477,
-0.0126533872,
-0.0301601086,
-0.0007354456,
0.0156538226,
0.0343641937,
0.0158388875,
-0.0268923044,
-0.0364545323,
0.0021317287,
-0.0202057064,
0.0205157902,
-0.0134399626,
0.0406353474,
-0.0042547467,
0.0835603923,
0.0491748713,
-0.0572423376,
-0.05250993,
0.0385776833,
-0.077386722,
-0.0330347866,
0.0351875871,
-0.0099378116,
-0.0211168285,
-0.0550009795,
0.0420642719,
0.0038620802,
0.012751461,
0.0238369498,
0.047859095,
-0.0273667742,
-0.0294073559,
-0.0525974333,
-0.0949663222,
0.0231157131,
-0.0222606733,
-0.0226636492,
-0.0362499207,
-0.0080035115,
-0.0118066035,
0.0482405312,
-0.0343981646,
-0.0111891422,
0.088107653,
0.0423537977,
0.0301110502,
0.035657037,
0.0049140784,
0.0226171724,
-0.0257695317,
0.0167834032,
0.0221053325,
-0.0147485817,
0.0562949255,
0.015565821,
-0.0052459105,
0.0718140453,
0.0218868498,
-0.0158660747,
-0.05889979,
0.0257008467,
0.0012331058,
0.0278239865,
0.0347557478,
-0.0199198462,
-0.0052972022,
-0.0314983875,
-0.0641615763,
0.0213828459,
-0.0441115759,
-0.0165437534,
0.0547012836,
0.0188178495,
-0.0496111326,
0.0206839256,
-0.0083720926,
-0.0433899052,
-0.0028321878,
0.0173324253,
-0.064426735,
0.0234708488,
-0.0335125662,
0.0781378672,
-0.0881989747,
-0.0258034132,
0.0096865483,
0.0254791919,
-0.0150568793,
0.0400306769,
-0.0096378578,
0.0221376214,
-0.0672439039,
0.0140677718,
-0.0211522356,
-0.009466337,
-0.0029375628,
-0.0351634622,
-0.026242733,
-0.0158115458,
0.0073560658,
0.0274367109,
0.0327203237,
-0.0212570447,
0.0127118016,
-0.0283594728,
0.0163334198,
0.0288113039,
0.0109409634,
0.051849179,
0.0017303473,
-0.0098983021,
-0.0242141951,
-0.0359581448,
-0.0133267241,
0.0137599502,
2.981e-7,
0.0237420257,
0.0697824955,
0.0034261155,
0.0107914452,
0.0051968792,
-0.0161398873,
0.0331660919,
-0.0039650234,
0.0020836829,
0.0491725691,
0.0297329538,
0.0020229325,
0.0324154012,
0.0155379456,
-0.1004462913,
0.0565474406,
-0.1116753966,
-0.0251527168,
-0.0804106146,
-0.0124659976,
0.0508817546,
0.0478131063,
0.0056317779,
-0.0074898526,
-0.0146165425,
-0.0255326685,
0.0312384553,
-0.0091493558,
-0.0549855642,
0.0950748622,
0.0448866487,
-0.0006293627,
0.0072165211,
0.0081739044,
-0.0021252951,
0.0243248586,
0.0135563528,
0.0485785455,
0.0045826794,
-0.0096415151,
0.0381658226,
-0.0735647306,
0.0052482872,
-0.0534676015,
0.0805352926,
-0.0464515984,
-0.0104877055,
0.0020300546,
-0.0169561375,
-0.0374904163,
0.0020040027,
-0.0594121367,
-0.0113471327,
0.010260189,
-0.0003163517,
0.0174160209,
-0.0202673562,
-0.0687400326,
0.048173327,
0.0423602872,
-0.0158392377,
-0.0756743327,
-0.0510511436,
-0.0388355292,
-0.0067735282,
-0.047223907,
0.0469500273,
2.538615508e-34,
0.0247175805,
-0.0113247046,
-0.0338732228,
0.0190050267,
0.0372392349,
0.0173027236,
-0.034087047,
0.0037497061,
-0.0200524982,
-0.0857776627,
0.0129124559
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03724v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03724v2 | DP-OPT: Make Large Language Model Your Privacy-Preserving Prompt Engineer | 2023-11-27T02:01:10 | 2024-03-17T23:16:41 | Junyuan Hong, Jiachen T. Wang, Chenhui Zhang, Zhangheng Li, Bo Li, Zhangyang Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs) have emerged as dominant tools for various
tasks, particularly when tailored for a specific target by prompt tuning.
Nevertheless, concerns surrounding data privacy present obstacles due to the
tuned prompts' dependency on sensitive private information. A practical
solution is to host a local LLM and optimize a soft prompt privately using
data. Yet, hosting a local model becomes problematic when model ownership is
protected. Alternative methods, like sending data to the model's provider for
training, intensify these privacy issues facing an untrusted provider. In this
paper, we present a novel solution called Differentially-Private Offsite Prompt
Tuning (DP-OPT) to address this challenge. Our approach involves tuning a
discrete prompt on the client side and then applying it to the desired cloud
models. We demonstrate that prompts suggested by LLMs themselves can be
transferred without compromising performance significantly. To ensure that the
prompts do not leak private information, we introduce the first private prompt
generation mechanism, by a differentially-private (DP) ensemble of in-context
learning with private demonstrations. With DP-OPT, generating
privacy-preserving prompts by Vicuna-7b can yield competitive performance
compared to non-private in-context learning on GPT3.5 or local private prompt
tuning. Codes are available at https://github.com/VITA-Group/DP-OPT . | [
0.0135225346,
0.1000896543,
-0.0188077968,
0.0644975007,
-0.0370123424,
-0.0218555797,
0.1031035259,
-0.0170106664,
0.0184259657,
0.0139639108,
-0.0425724834,
-0.0235652961,
0.0021451002,
0.0408828259,
0.0220293887,
-0.0073288926,
0.0269152466,
-0.0508165397,
-0.0179843232,
-0.0408674218,
-0.0501434766,
-0.0022155794,
0.0119783226,
0.0051007411,
0.0250702258,
-0.0424324833,
-0.0280883778,
0.0163588449,
0.0223155636,
0.0123794777,
0.0180479549,
0.0659310743,
0.0409412757,
0.0814348906,
0.0000021287,
-0.0267757233,
-0.0544924214,
0.0383481234,
-0.0808573738,
0.0173007194,
-0.0040407474,
-0.008547836,
-0.0106384335,
0.0168736968,
-0.016604552,
0.0241793916,
0.0447048508,
0.0040875105,
0.0781971812,
0.0695375353,
0.0114808222,
0.0099403737,
-0.0262851771,
-0.0422945358,
-0.0431420058,
-0.0503029525,
-0.0011629512,
-0.0905918032,
-0.0234211851,
0.0293873735,
-0.005795138,
0.0053453627,
0.030972695,
0.0239626579,
-0.0099700419,
0.0395516716,
-0.0222762339,
-0.0361787044,
-0.0528304912,
0.032248266,
0.0156053863,
-0.0095236097,
0.0280074477,
-0.0069569089,
0.0331613645,
-0.0006310282,
0.0147696678,
0.045536492,
-0.0136600798,
-0.0059872181,
-0.016729854,
-0.0128346737,
0.0003592337,
0.0028087664,
0.0334571004,
0.066350162,
0.0249461401,
0.0046588876,
-0.0288224705,
-0.0207543876,
-0.0105622895,
-0.0736775324,
0.0622574762,
0.012279436,
0.0000449282,
-0.0056537767,
-0.0558094159,
-0.0433850586,
0.0069951648,
0.0257297419,
0.047214184,
0.0082342075,
0.0222080778,
0.0157036856,
-0.0163656864,
0.0601423308,
-0.0079244617,
0.033042796,
0.033339195,
0.0410426818,
-0.0159703121,
0.0230959766,
-0.0464952253,
0.0267762262,
-0.077010341,
0.0080261715,
-0.0200961325,
0.0442417413,
-0.0034915858,
0.0528964996,
0.0085942242,
-0.0132499253,
-0.0578283034,
-0.0221306551,
0.0146905407,
-0.0665964484,
-0.0115059093,
-0.0168782063,
0.037203379,
-0.0861152783,
-0.029985385,
-0.0409189872,
-0.0194759127,
-0.0061786529,
-0.0237757713,
0.0621638969,
0.0126329158,
-0.0041833925,
0.0360954963,
-0.0772103667,
0.0229748506,
-0.0516115092,
-0.0338070765,
-0.0329414979,
-0.005939486,
-0.0213090573,
-0.0032304688,
-0.077808708,
-0.0078547969,
0.0173095614,
0.0303458627,
0.0382129587,
-0.0015235355,
-0.0149572464,
-0.0044500721,
0.048034735,
-0.0365430415,
0.0419531018,
0.0105853658,
0.0303436052,
0.0486230813,
-0.0183356293,
0.041918736,
0.0139788315,
0.0681917891,
0.0445183553,
-0.0381950252,
0.026884798,
0.0777696744,
-0.0176635757,
-0.0119052855,
0.0247198474,
-0.0018714535,
-0.0507907979,
0.0817980319,
0.0327033512,
-0.0032863235,
0.0030357253,
-0.0400725752,
0.049424462,
-0.0349716991,
-0.013182627,
-0.0695223212,
-0.0020225809,
-0.0541716143,
-0.0321709812,
-0.0042070556,
0.0717400461,
-0.0089883665,
0.0212763473,
0.0324687324,
-0.0460310765,
-0.0198500231,
0.0567239076,
-0.0105327992,
-0.0024210834,
-0.0111111365,
0.0481305644,
-0.0027183811,
-0.03912846,
-0.0500687286,
-0.0491621085,
0.0149630606,
0.0616156086,
0.0136076948,
0.0178983547,
-0.0134069715,
-0.054917071,
-0.0217429828,
0.040800117,
0.0089066532,
0.006606149,
0.0793889016,
-0.0226382948,
-0.061514277,
-0.0108815646,
0.0180725697,
0.01242973,
0.0089677162,
-0.0015366393,
0.0136199454,
0.00803925,
0.0181572177,
0.030389782,
-0.0263523385,
-0.0339537747,
0.0310705714,
0.0343793556,
0.048341088,
0.0069375369,
-0.001634513,
-0.0195491873,
0.001211011,
0.0465060361,
0.013663725,
-0.040348772,
-0.0353985354,
-0.0140982009,
-0.026650412,
0.0029041197,
0.0237559658,
0.0217981003,
-0.0334720165,
-0.0253375322,
-0.0132015171,
0.0011701847,
0.0123106483,
-0.0043075047,
0.0092718005,
-0.0176765174,
0.0358514786,
-0.0294000264,
-0.0025922453,
-0.0133144921,
-0.0194100682,
-0.0342277437,
0.0308292005,
0.0072979461,
-0.0628108904,
-0.0076808534,
0.0114105642,
0.0147906477,
0.0076327268,
-0.003273725,
0.0137958666,
-0.0270746127,
-0.0249256119,
-0.0470223688,
0.0165718701,
-0.0378853083,
0.0192477237,
0.0211200137,
0.0303783473,
-0.0500432663,
-0.0505500771,
-0.0380060039,
0.0021222944,
-0.0442077816,
0.0345862433,
-0.0131424973,
0.0286942795,
-0.0374658108,
0.0276539382,
-0.0115124639,
0.0234428402,
0.0211518463,
-0.0560063757,
-0.0002405469,
-0.0328204483,
0.0391022041,
-0.0231100023,
0.0360570066,
0.0007649806,
-0.0058496688,
-0.0063466788,
0.0164312497,
0.017395867,
0.0842674971,
0.0084654903,
-0.0387300141,
0.0510582812,
0.0036677378,
-0.0574255325,
0.0036652787,
-0.0162457731,
-0.0444284976,
-0.0342263505,
0.033227168,
0.0013768402,
0.0223497227,
-0.0070038117,
-0.0513147824,
-0.0388488434,
0.0620736554,
0.004338067,
-0.0319206044,
-0.034590397,
-0.0055367947,
0.0036428508,
0.065135166,
0.0068965275,
-0.0804936066,
0.0833915025,
-0.0146549167,
0.005241801,
-0.0185107235,
-0.0378886126,
-0.0128074167,
0.0453398488,
-0.015765829,
0.0340463333,
0.0425252169,
-0.0520135239,
-0.0409608781,
0.0112554803,
0.0502572879,
-0.03025176,
-0.0173654351,
-0.0156652369,
-0.0374527313,
-0.0126410685,
-0.0857376233,
-0.0290521905,
-0.0699676722,
-0.0167390388,
-0.004564919,
-0.0388376787,
-0.0260272436,
0.0239421669,
-0.0023186058,
0.0162746776,
0.0583876707,
-0.0344177298,
0.0291585121,
-0.0304697137,
-0.053959474,
0.0092053209,
-0.0087253461,
-0.0196357761,
-0.0465090424,
0.0045072734,
0.0489089228,
0.0768968314,
-0.0245205685,
0.018928621,
-0.0280026458,
0.0353315584,
-0.0178187061,
-0.0338039957,
0.0332294442,
0.0583825037,
-0.057339184,
-0.0187766254,
0.0475978404,
-0.0115925716,
-0.0838080198,
-0.0186984558,
0.0397692136,
0.0373768732,
0.0084279543,
0.0133244516,
-0.0856887847,
0.0077570966,
0.0372684374,
0.048681125,
-0.0231542196,
-0.0209613368,
-0.0499840975,
-0.1004576534,
0.0053984015,
0.0082352282,
0.0165110193,
0.0065737194,
-0.0341199003,
0.0106477411,
0.0023891716,
0.0095322998,
-0.028592309,
0.0103720622,
-0.005989972,
-0.0013844569,
0.0512288548,
-0.0418755338,
-0.0075807227,
-0.0341075547,
0.0502253845,
0.0534640513,
-0.0300699845,
-0.0025016794,
-0.0399824828,
0.0244406424,
0.0272905286,
-0.0163203608,
0.0088116247,
-0.0021817486,
-0.0035831593,
-0.0074660997,
0.0186849348,
0.0500880852,
0.0052891755,
0.0051677437,
0.0372511521,
0.0469190851,
-0.008043102,
0.0108088711,
0.0202410482,
-0.0324908718,
0.0450611971,
0.0381137542,
-0.0056146882,
-0.0431011245,
-0.0184118915,
-0.0311724599,
0.028585637,
0.0136733698,
0.0345753543,
0.0117073813,
0.0207964294,
-0.0470812395,
-0.0030305705,
0.026251724,
-0.0058398363,
0.0574055947,
0.0477869883,
0.0008429654,
0.0055306489,
0.031334158,
-0.0275192242,
0.0306583494,
-0.092051439,
0.0280464888,
-0.0410228036,
-0.006706798,
0.0170352515,
-0.0153723136,
-0.0304794498,
-0.0051255524,
-0.0534341298,
-0.0677828118,
0.0283702835,
0.0350893848,
0.0198053271,
0.0531648323,
-0.0378985293,
-0.072688885,
0.1090462878,
0.0383327082,
-0.0824319273,
0.0185673349,
0.0464401543,
-0.0286565758,
0.0046672034,
0.0290912166,
-0.0395934768,
-0.030598551,
0.0811146572,
-0.0477698036,
-0.0139397848,
-0.0546209328,
-0.0084837833,
0.0317090377,
0.0322204046,
-0.0083739487,
0.015813496,
-0.0585263558,
0.0647395775,
0.0077365162,
0.0090166414,
-0.0219624639,
0.017384313,
0.0217818152,
-0.0390315764,
0.0572283491,
-0.0181172676,
0.0510169417,
0.0083897039,
-0.0685709044,
0.0338755697,
0.0461347811,
0.0153460624,
0.058591526,
-0.0000156616,
-0.0200544447,
0.053876318,
0.0408733971,
0.0341370441,
-0.0196127295,
0.0476298854,
0.0283646826,
0.0039669056,
-0.0073870309,
0.0545200445,
-0.0555310771,
-0.0549849272,
-0.0209351499,
0.0338814929,
0.0054466524,
0.0649012774,
-0.0262420122,
-0.0278219562,
-0.0130090788,
-0.0203858931,
0.0030599702,
-0.0016824878,
-0.0678313896,
0.0098031806,
-0.01411907,
0.0096391942,
0.0493155941,
0.0679587722,
0.0008773257,
0.0355476364,
-0.0020294711,
0.0183576625,
-0.0744825527,
-0.0066250926,
0.0049086688,
0.0387887359,
-0.0102916816,
0.0194729492,
-0.0037591076,
-0.0626031384,
-0.0255441293,
-0.0241584424,
-0.0042467979,
-0.0147509938,
0.0175891053,
0.012093219,
-0.0241125226,
-0.0423462689,
-0.0758125409,
-0.0074541159,
0.0517577715,
-0.0065982505,
-0.0054101837,
-5.806033289e-33,
-0.0171998404,
-0.0077721379,
-0.0197423287,
0.0344983824,
0.0201696604,
0.0167450868,
-0.0150029818,
-0.0137628196,
0.0071800984,
-0.0314713158,
-0.0648511723,
0.0186483059,
0.0347347409,
0.0326904915,
-0.0123674525,
-0.0137275923,
0.0492593274,
-0.0528450757,
-0.038683895,
0.0804534331,
0.0232005492,
0.0384068191,
0.0290142018,
-0.0548496246,
0.0351669639,
-0.0200886708,
-0.0585708283,
0.0150169106,
-0.0777525604,
0.0326647274,
-0.0195937045,
-0.0317855924,
-0.0227670502,
-0.0378059149,
-0.0149671575,
0.0228738561,
-0.0120943645,
-0.0017607969,
-0.0362267159,
0.0023055724,
-0.0030098958,
-0.0766252726,
0.0138878291,
-0.0433242582,
-0.0181435999,
0.0057827141,
-0.0166760124,
0.0006297554,
-0.013297963,
-0.045910202,
0.0336887799,
-0.0041875872,
0.0017448204,
0.0042081634,
0.071116358,
-0.0073607415,
-0.0006721695,
-0.0066255303,
-0.0222068243,
0.0279823355,
0.0467578508,
0.000230805,
0.0467823707,
0.0177146662,
0.0085531548,
0.0106133465,
0.0752688572,
0.0288629718,
0.0210525431,
-0.0207017008,
-0.0071913591,
0.0209145918,
-0.0024606416,
0.0206445381,
0.001213755,
-0.024066953,
-0.0106772473,
-0.0148700336,
0.0164493546,
-0.0307352524,
0.0686267689,
-0.0031903966,
-0.0473251194,
0.0095092896,
-0.0653954744,
-0.0531318076,
-0.0338211879,
0.0161545165,
0.0077659618,
0.031072557,
-0.0372666344,
-0.0274368133,
0.0291798208,
-0.0361330211,
-0.0129502397,
0.0180073734,
0.0650195032,
-0.0271140076,
0.0295519792,
0.0207352359,
-0.0326394811,
-0.0207209811,
-0.0107172858,
-0.032002911,
0.0232880116,
-0.0048368783,
0.0207194369,
0.0198547002,
-0.0891543925,
0.0054420703,
-0.0532085933,
0.0614402927,
0.0431647152,
0.0234508719,
0.0383333527,
-0.0488713719,
0.0112751434,
0.0398178808,
0.0240618382,
0.0065054446,
-0.0244977325,
0.0274005141,
-0.0007301274,
0.0112761818,
0.0178620499,
-0.00928507,
0.0223979093,
0.0159060117,
0.0803350732,
0.0380629674,
0.0141679356,
-0.0193364043,
2.776e-7,
-0.0599000528,
0.0076603657,
-0.0147973113,
-0.0215245057,
0.0389191359,
0.0580146946,
-0.0049707741,
0.0570431873,
0.0084055169,
0.0003670419,
-0.0314565934,
0.0046252692,
0.0661601201,
0.032265842,
-0.0756529719,
-0.0028872958,
-0.024530055,
0.0372312255,
-0.0652775615,
0.0083798422,
-0.0141809573,
0.0952412486,
0.0241348073,
-0.0201638062,
0.0227209125,
-0.0027984302,
0.024009075,
-0.05575772,
-0.0164249409,
0.0010847652,
0.0251978952,
0.0674531683,
0.0009714202,
0.0253971349,
-0.0211585052,
0.0386341698,
-0.0832310095,
0.1090533584,
0.048530791,
-0.00186201,
0.0152654108,
-0.0347022377,
-0.032225702,
-0.0390541703,
0.0305510983,
0.013108965,
-0.022308372,
-0.0203247219,
0.0308256317,
-0.1265119314,
0.0440895073,
-0.0182551835,
0.0226875879,
0.024799386,
-0.0065664006,
-0.0124629438,
-0.0059671546,
-0.0572734885,
-0.0144626601,
-0.054096926,
-0.0383209623,
-0.0410319045,
-0.0034502891,
0.021754723,
-0.0221821312,
-0.0023372634,
0.0520066768,
2.704416461e-34,
-0.0140366219,
-0.0330807641,
0.0071135419,
0.0227042977,
0.012726143,
-0.019193057,
0.0433913469,
-0.0019911034,
0.043029733,
-0.0528787151,
-0.0297905207
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15480v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15480v2 | Automatic Time Signature Determination for New Scores Using Lyrics for Latent Rhythmic Structure | 2023-11-27T01:44:02 | 2024-01-28T19:53:22 | Callie C. Liao, Duoduo Liao, Jesse Guessford | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.MM, cs.SD | There has recently been a sharp increase in interest in Artificial
Intelligence-Generated Content (AIGC). Despite this, musical components such as
time signatures have not been studied sufficiently to form an algorithmic
determination approach for new compositions, especially lyrical songs. This is
likely because of the neglect of musical details, which is critical for
constructing a robust framework. Specifically, time signatures establish the
fundamental rhythmic structure for almost all aspects of a song, including the
phrases and notes. In this paper, we propose a novel approach that only uses
lyrics as input to automatically generate a fitting time signature for lyrical
songs and uncover the latent rhythmic structure utilizing explainable machine
learning models. In particular, we devise multiple methods that are associated
with discovering lyrical patterns and creating new features that simultaneously
contain lyrical, rhythmic, and statistical information. In this approach, the
best of our experimental results reveal a 97.6% F1 score and a 0.996 Area Under
the Curve (AUC) of the Receiver Operating Characteristic (ROC) score. In
conclusion, our research directly generates time signatures from lyrics
automatically for new scores utilizing machine learning, which is an innovative
idea that approaches an understudied component of musicology and therefore
contributes significantly to the future of Artificial Intelligence (AI) music
generation. | [
0.0169873293,
0.0479755029,
-0.0183135811,
0.006195893,
-0.0543287322,
0.0002526861,
0.0306261908,
0.0011205964,
-0.028288532,
0.0491871312,
0.0039646807,
0.0037239736,
-0.0049808468,
0.0379353166,
-0.0016056298,
0.002640503,
-0.0318086483,
0.0064981533,
0.0761275738,
0.0479458347,
-0.0490210727,
0.0154845985,
-0.0143985087,
0.0505301878,
-0.0325542428,
-0.0194712617,
-0.0487909429,
0.0108787501,
-0.0114791738,
-0.0332357734,
-0.0564395972,
0.0289313253,
-0.0177942533,
0.0374452099,
0.0000016762,
-0.0183944181,
-0.0230693407,
0.0144144492,
-0.0012969989,
-0.0230717435,
-0.0144718541,
0.002894307,
-0.0133334389,
0.0082307048,
-0.0504120588,
0.0522381179,
0.0178131852,
0.0168698393,
0.0397889093,
0.087233685,
0.0121954195,
-0.004082649,
0.0315266401,
-0.0181122739,
0.0103589827,
-0.0138444752,
-0.0218016971,
0.0232786946,
0.0131034227,
-0.0417466052,
-0.0238785762,
0.048875574,
0.0140512567,
-0.0124326348,
0.0457493737,
0.0442719199,
-0.0708573014,
-0.0434000641,
-0.0058079092,
0.0024433124,
-0.0023033989,
-0.0439998358,
0.0260260534,
0.0094557935,
0.0015679795,
-0.0048699579,
-0.0602399521,
-0.0240145586,
0.0263584219,
0.0208264273,
0.0030870847,
0.0020976176,
0.0475755632,
-0.0054717688,
0.0168567132,
0.0429863147,
0.0164713617,
-0.0546963066,
0.0170099102,
-0.0127745857,
0.0435186699,
-0.0576968603,
0.0160842612,
0.0143730072,
-0.0155780241,
-0.0205699354,
-0.0338386185,
-0.0323870182,
-0.0453177132,
0.0086413519,
0.0885525197,
-0.0219811127,
0.0164031889,
0.051409021,
-0.0171410125,
0.0197305791,
-0.0338498913,
-0.0197653491,
-0.0127280522,
-0.0051946538,
-0.0216705985,
-0.0126872193,
0.003347124,
-0.034538012,
0.0361844152,
-0.0113810189,
-0.0150697026,
0.005311626,
-0.0072045606,
0.0221395269,
0.0243075676,
-0.0050884727,
-0.0074313786,
-0.0061703944,
0.0473828726,
-0.0379790477,
-0.0081108706,
0.01463567,
-0.0260371808,
0.0035781069,
0.0054012658,
0.017991934,
0.0512005202,
0.0245453231,
0.0893967971,
0.0522059873,
0.0555439666,
-0.0597246885,
-0.023044318,
-0.05016312,
-0.0549305081,
-0.0220258068,
-0.0090982402,
-0.0685377717,
0.0288964715,
-0.0276178699,
-0.0377702527,
-0.0131810606,
-0.0008923023,
0.0152794337,
-0.0309792534,
0.0132424394,
0.0008210801,
0.0708966702,
-0.0186332427,
-0.0351046212,
-0.0071244119,
-0.0584128313,
0.1025360301,
0.0282642301,
0.0491627902,
-0.0407446809,
0.0383117758,
0.0177301113,
0.0308876168,
-0.0264360514,
-0.0002225894,
-0.0411773846,
-0.0492432415,
0.0472431369,
0.0064821905,
0.004787432,
0.0719869509,
-0.0148254419,
0.0392444953,
0.0319939554,
0.0336598605,
0.0900672972,
0.0688650459,
-0.0038483005,
0.0391402505,
0.0092246728,
0.0204415284,
0.0782808438,
0.0172227267,
0.0100017516,
0.0454597883,
-0.0032800429,
0.0080011385,
-0.0181199107,
-0.0178669896,
-0.0199978258,
-0.0389737897,
-0.0017173061,
0.0292810854,
0.0318556465,
0.0001985927,
-0.001859654,
0.0014737722,
-0.0245878138,
-0.0099646365,
0.0063836989,
0.0506720208,
0.0345738903,
0.0670604333,
-0.0331305563,
0.0581852421,
-0.0264653172,
-0.0074530141,
0.0431952849,
-0.0479641929,
-0.0224663075,
-0.0146825677,
0.013963378,
0.017758783,
-0.0277561489,
-0.0119759561,
-0.0073276651,
-0.0541453101,
0.0093237665,
0.0006797775,
-0.0333504677,
-0.0187891033,
0.0169160999,
-0.0157928634,
-0.0462756716,
0.0559179671,
0.0197461359,
0.051740367,
0.0677491128,
-0.0196700972,
0.0368035957,
0.0260330159,
-0.0195896067,
-0.0046507637,
0.0252141468,
-0.017305484,
-0.00532497,
0.0468621738,
0.0010581166,
0.0061920546,
0.0492381044,
0.0264529809,
-0.0337177478,
0.0919527262,
-0.0106469048,
0.0246402603,
0.0170750078,
0.0256045777,
-0.0169378612,
-0.0057769376,
0.0308194552,
-0.0046666116,
0.0386685841,
0.0259910766,
-0.0452594161,
-0.0291733816,
0.0635248423,
0.000269562,
0.002021939,
0.0490762666,
0.0106822047,
-0.0484054275,
-0.0304631237,
-0.0147881508,
-0.0068963217,
-0.03940662,
-0.0886607468,
-0.0072678141,
-0.0370976441,
-0.0333550833,
0.0070908833,
-0.0459848903,
-0.0083420323,
-0.0281868,
-0.0346160755,
-0.0304654278,
0.020307865,
-0.0055853333,
-0.0152899055,
-0.0141074639,
-0.088190347,
-0.0030164768,
-0.0167517904,
-0.0482620187,
0.0318323784,
0.0147470422,
0.0063008321,
0.0146209346,
-0.0100400094,
-0.0283204839,
-0.0467053652,
0.0202182978,
-0.0062935478,
0.014097007,
-0.0303403269,
0.0119769787,
0.0552198105,
0.0048972946,
0.0334881432,
0.0565903597,
0.0007099199,
0.0485202447,
0.0020622816,
-0.0086425282,
0.0353837758,
0.0229983199,
-0.0555493794,
0.0280592907,
0.0419959798,
0.0764724538,
-0.0088497987,
0.0140203126,
0.0467289053,
-0.0309660248,
0.0415023901,
0.0037869667,
0.0283411238,
-0.0392712094,
0.0569758564,
-0.0236031972,
-0.0341064706,
0.0399540067,
-0.0037862565,
-0.012085584,
0.0120072654,
-0.0755046904,
-0.0627570972,
0.0392938852,
-0.0215109903,
0.0212845672,
-0.0145432949,
-0.0286449064,
-0.0271191895,
0.0091411052,
0.0274805762,
-0.0431468636,
-0.0119377701,
-0.0447008051,
-0.0194940791,
0.036484316,
-0.0331573561,
0.0068999836,
-0.0619326271,
0.0217294395,
0.0052073151,
-0.0376382545,
-0.0385385826,
0.0247978009,
-0.0327130519,
0.0301825013,
0.0257640667,
-0.0121255573,
-0.006120102,
0.0035369596,
0.0749980956,
0.0256263092,
-0.0615946688,
-0.0031400206,
-0.0281285774,
0.0265958849,
-0.0235355999,
0.0241569318,
0.038272392,
-0.0480259061,
0.0283774976,
-0.0447279066,
-0.0045851371,
0.0108566256,
0.0460700653,
-0.0204361752,
-0.019570021,
0.0264476668,
0.0814239904,
0.0344335288,
-0.0093731498,
0.0138336122,
0.0368992314,
-0.038182728,
0.0149923041,
-0.0079102619,
0.0411417633,
0.0246122666,
0.0035600632,
0.0669042841,
0.0088582309,
0.0057899342,
-0.0248838067,
-0.0279489793,
0.0191752538,
0.0057407613,
-0.0499100387,
-0.0038599218,
-0.0125197712,
-0.0464803539,
-0.0096847927,
-0.0408933833,
-0.0333548784,
-0.0033446033,
0.0587106012,
-0.0091470806,
-0.0643661618,
-0.0260455944,
-0.0041562314,
-0.0853110105,
0.0525073446,
0.0601352192,
0.1222929657,
-0.0213875826,
0.0104374262,
-0.0639103949,
0.0061184783,
0.0236243922,
0.0328403115,
0.0341846161,
0.0563651286,
-0.0103373565,
-0.0061951517,
0.0481077693,
-0.0378938317,
-0.0229252949,
0.0204494465,
0.0781813711,
-0.0264733173,
-0.0173778646,
-0.0054586432,
0.0163146388,
0.0129772611,
0.067481257,
0.0661800429,
-0.0433481932,
0.0197745934,
0.0023286243,
-0.0016929462,
-0.0458942764,
-0.0333306007,
-0.0289063435,
-0.0137744155,
-0.0097965645,
-0.0481563397,
-0.0152221993,
-0.0149504393,
0.0252191387,
0.0346803628,
0.004519532,
-0.0429392457,
-0.0430604182,
-0.0980382264,
-0.0080534089,
0.0131616853,
0.0236900058,
-0.027835397,
-0.0827246457,
-0.0458096452,
-0.0087954206,
-0.0205250029,
-0.0183920134,
-0.0673675984,
-0.0088327024,
0.0215250161,
0.0072374563,
0.0169944502,
0.0394238308,
0.0117964055,
-0.0055711931,
-0.0123236198,
-0.0059737642,
0.0154736759,
0.023417253,
-0.002811031,
-0.0028539358,
0.0213076491,
0.0079711583,
-0.0725184977,
0.0372638069,
0.0498804189,
0.0006354287,
0.0136096524,
-0.0218209345,
0.0574338101,
0.0176701583,
0.0321352407,
0.0119136674,
-0.0321436077,
-0.0174745172,
-0.0515701734,
-0.0399272554,
-0.009746219,
-0.033521194,
0.0030000748,
0.0605371669,
0.0377703123,
-0.0464277416,
0.0157055221,
0.0051768646,
-0.0280823205,
-0.0475052893,
-0.0100764958,
-0.0020928548,
-0.0053243879,
-0.0027677489,
-0.0111077344,
0.0394002274,
-0.0081572765,
0.0289707985,
0.0112452563,
0.0710466653,
-0.003989168,
0.0059471475,
0.0039969156,
-0.0209091678,
0.0160613731,
-0.0748180375,
-0.0120325545,
-0.0261898898,
-0.0015763094,
0.0647753924,
-0.041780673,
0.0223303456,
0.0134277493,
-0.0164843556,
0.0172978137,
0.0757149309,
0.0206553657,
-0.0471040197,
-0.0406519547,
0.0019512884,
-0.0338108949,
-0.0233282372,
0.0635241568,
-0.0002907127,
-0.0138556752,
-0.0166746322,
-0.0255240053,
0.0186504908,
0.0410794318,
-0.0216696914,
-0.0599170253,
0.0263673738,
0.0330595113,
-0.0452522486,
-0.0319612399,
0.0621533804,
-0.0075557595,
0.0476326197,
0.0027579458,
-0.0277339146,
0.038611941,
-0.0166474357,
0.0018104953,
-0.0483033881,
-0.0362412445,
-0.0353984907,
-0.023766676,
-0.0468405671,
-5.316812377e-33,
-0.0406480767,
-0.0519938357,
-0.0613378026,
0.0508955643,
-0.0047172136,
-0.0119645838,
-0.0863806307,
-0.021298904,
0.0208814256,
0.0099289864,
0.0006990042,
0.0512100495,
-0.0225571711,
-0.0333882645,
0.0765790716,
0.0052386494,
0.0632793531,
-0.0386493504,
-0.0437500216,
0.034956526,
0.0426170826,
0.0428493135,
-0.0299699288,
-0.0831191838,
0.0127077093,
-0.0131257549,
0.0177361574,
0.007957371,
0.0110292826,
0.0310352538,
0.0159224793,
-0.0288179144,
0.0415089615,
0.0142409028,
0.0013023171,
0.0044340324,
-0.0140657965,
-0.0455843061,
-0.0384602025,
0.023024153,
0.014343515,
-0.0446953252,
0.0089380601,
-0.0360678397,
-0.0411403961,
0.0042639524,
0.0532881431,
-0.0397086479,
-0.0131081548,
-0.133334741,
-0.004237588,
-0.0081631122,
-0.0609113388,
-0.0267013554,
0.0235206354,
0.0482996292,
0.0082183192,
0.0024252713,
0.0144543983,
0.0271993317,
-0.0596138388,
-0.0159954205,
0.049361337,
0.0075100777,
-0.0202368777,
0.0327995494,
0.0035851097,
-0.0476619899,
-0.0506820567,
0.0614881068,
-0.0129665658,
0.0531009324,
0.0817250758,
-0.0082632601,
0.0531795882,
0.0028745283,
-0.0060048834,
0.0389514491,
0.0039759572,
-0.0458919778,
-0.0033903208,
0.0447302572,
-0.0638150647,
0.0113329859,
0.0230613742,
-0.0530206412,
-0.0377955623,
-0.0423768014,
0.0170678273,
-0.0442549735,
-0.0216153637,
0.0044717412,
-0.0365300924,
-0.058368776,
0.0389048979,
-0.0012346149,
-0.0589489229,
0.036162097,
0.0132514182,
-0.0303005595,
-0.0088120643,
-0.008612589,
0.08142896,
-0.0323311463,
0.0688798204,
-0.0243998058,
0.0403490365,
0.1012114212,
-0.0367976129,
-0.0230921302,
-0.0193879195,
-0.035924457,
0.0386171453,
-0.0479269475,
0.0507535897,
-0.005752394,
-0.0123192351,
0.0047237966,
0.0248439889,
0.0680862516,
-0.005616466,
-0.0058160797,
-0.0194900408,
0.0039913533,
0.0226436127,
-0.0042435578,
0.0059302803,
-0.0416557454,
-0.0050952118,
-0.010677156,
-0.0413472578,
-0.0111008612,
2.556e-7,
0.021477811,
0.0087868217,
-0.0051270463,
0.0058299894,
0.0269689988,
0.0074614049,
-0.1126710698,
-0.0227874797,
-0.0256836358,
0.0091366693,
0.0722446069,
-0.0305231102,
0.1070439517,
0.0420060568,
-0.0750791207,
-0.0070440713,
-0.0600758307,
-0.039600987,
-0.1161895469,
-0.0326598249,
0.0208160579,
0.0387628898,
0.0676235706,
-0.0120280655,
0.0063777925,
-0.0263371952,
0.0147054596,
-0.0089721577,
0.0267811064,
-0.0765514746,
0.0303204563,
-0.0208489448,
-0.0286126155,
-0.0089630401,
-0.0695571974,
0.058848232,
0.0344831571,
-0.0013656444,
0.0278893914,
0.0012444798,
0.0116152754,
0.0070324466,
0.0235330164,
0.0001357956,
0.0374985561,
0.0317065492,
-0.0843068585,
-0.0409396663,
-0.0136409514,
-0.0033683705,
-0.0236720201,
0.0181831755,
0.0130110113,
-0.0226923767,
0.0050696777,
-0.0107583385,
0.0866165832,
-0.0240005236,
-0.0093094641,
0.0483011976,
-0.0240084305,
0.0267419405,
-0.0097687095,
0.0055243718,
0.0448768102,
-0.0569185577,
-0.0294115581,
2.229190038e-34,
0.0431731865,
-0.0418858565,
0.0066415155,
0.0056558968,
0.0424048454,
0.00634389,
-0.006590364,
0.0016999703,
-0.0114453891,
-0.0161448587,
-0.0026995488
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03723v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03723v1 | ChatGPT Application In Summarizing An Evolution Of Deep Learning Techniques In Imaging: A Qualitative Study | 2023-11-26T23:22:37 | 2023-11-26T23:22:37 | Arman Sarraf, Amirabbas Abbaspour | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | The pursuit of article or text summarization has captured the attention of
natural language processing (NLP) practitioners, presenting itself as a
formidable challenge. ChatGPT 3.5 exhibits the capacity to condense the content
of up to 3000 tokens into a single page, aiming to retain pivotal information
from a given text across diverse themes. In a conducted qualitative research
endeavor, we selected seven scientific articles and employed the publicly
available ChatGPT service to generate summaries of these articles.
Subsequently, we engaged six co-authors of the articles in a survey, presenting
five questions to evaluate the quality of the summaries compared to the
original content. The findings revealed that the summaries produced by ChatGPT
effectively encapsulated the crucial information present in the articles,
preserving the principal message of each manuscript. Nonetheless, there was a
slight diminishment in the technical depth of the summaries as opposed to the
original articles. As a result, our conclusion underscores ChatGPT's text
summarization capability as a potent tool for extracting essential insights in
a manner more aligned with reporting than purely scientific discourse. | [
0.0177685395,
0.0450421944,
0.0181011744,
-0.0266620927,
-0.0280037802,
0.0258510541,
0.0027275288,
0.0259625372,
-0.0043670074,
-0.0127897467,
0.021844767,
-0.0231331345,
0.0298596695,
0.0520375371,
0.003972156,
-0.0566582568,
0.008287061,
0.0331519283,
0.0133107314,
-0.0098719327,
0.0018772325,
-0.0060880864,
0.0070992294,
0.0367305465,
0.013057488,
-0.0393329822,
0.0182017833,
-0.0070102555,
0.0259144232,
-0.032078214,
-0.0076331603,
0.0156540815,
0.0347668752,
0.0609588586,
0.0000022865,
-0.0340936147,
-0.0365429707,
0.0426495112,
-0.0150971245,
0.039446827,
0.0681617707,
-0.0076867989,
-0.0032500892,
-0.0146068921,
-0.00713749,
0.0068792668,
0.0501536205,
0.0654455498,
0.0099924346,
0.0294218231,
-0.01365148,
-0.0450829342,
0.0729107857,
-0.0035183949,
-0.0021165004,
0.0095282672,
-0.0120303631,
0.0202777721,
0.0034144619,
0.0301311724,
0.0211450588,
0.0925720632,
0.0232482459,
-0.0349895209,
0.0066180681,
0.0794158578,
-0.0366692618,
-0.0296117701,
0.0001437123,
-0.0049807164,
0.0285564624,
-0.0004338347,
0.0088878842,
-0.0131290378,
-0.0323052332,
-0.0072700069,
-0.0941178501,
0.0528377369,
0.0060458826,
-0.0110709174,
-0.0488146916,
0.0010212845,
-0.0138305184,
0.0161663182,
-0.0289797597,
-0.0496892743,
-0.0164787713,
0.0035128368,
0.0003182641,
0.0211915672,
0.0008680254,
-0.0494223498,
0.0138511192,
0.0245800279,
0.0275856685,
-0.010397926,
0.0276526473,
-0.0493595228,
0.068032451,
-0.0344968513,
-0.0493054539,
-0.0150861479,
-0.0519708507,
0.0453360341,
0.0004993337,
-0.0029301143,
-0.0192245133,
0.0409426354,
-0.0241382699,
0.0104491543,
-0.0557996668,
-0.0496407636,
-0.0058381828,
0.0440739617,
-0.028418472,
-0.0452494733,
-0.0412383378,
-0.0074522514,
0.0507712997,
-0.0286817625,
-0.0096270069,
0.1015348285,
-0.0605689995,
0.0284141414,
-0.0148735,
0.0598720163,
0.0095756734,
-0.0187204722,
0.0292408615,
-0.015736172,
-0.0014330075,
0.0398874097,
0.0098221526,
0.0073770424,
-0.0042105215,
0.0486197472,
-0.0393427052,
-0.0291724168,
0.0548136681,
-0.0415752232,
-0.0145258233,
-0.0563489348,
0.0561194047,
-0.0724924579,
0.0364130251,
0.0029130182,
-0.009038901,
0.0005486455,
-0.0253648497,
0.0074572871,
-0.0447229333,
0.0362765528,
-0.0703461617,
-0.054800123,
0.08465036,
0.0296792705,
0.0359978825,
0.0238753334,
0.0415086262,
0.0214858297,
0.0219322629,
-0.0280449092,
-0.0207625367,
-0.0437598899,
0.0072218864,
-0.0254902728,
0.0252738986,
-0.0189089552,
-0.0492476933,
0.0337110311,
-0.0054816343,
0.0570558012,
-0.0406544693,
0.013576475,
0.0510427952,
0.1371325999,
0.0194308013,
0.0478173383,
-0.0244317632,
0.0273960587,
0.0423884839,
0.0315222181,
-0.0083471714,
0.0716968551,
0.0314212516,
0.0362206809,
0.043701034,
0.0502202436,
0.0017574091,
-0.0320548378,
-0.0108733624,
0.0219647978,
0.015503197,
-0.007943064,
0.0017054586,
-0.0245557241,
0.0114588449,
-0.0078875981,
0.026791878,
-0.0294414256,
0.0001381536,
-0.0404981337,
-0.0192590859,
0.0263354015,
0.0414644741,
-0.0278419927,
-0.0283679795,
-0.01443577,
0.0194260199,
0.062386293,
0.0148350028,
0.0483198464,
0.0145230833,
-0.0156513955,
-0.0467982851,
-0.0570658073,
-0.0213005915,
-0.0311000459,
-0.0318936221,
0.0012074553,
-0.0085475128,
0.0171785578,
-0.0303077828,
0.0252022073,
-0.0284448601,
-0.0132417614,
0.0000645719,
-0.0378771611,
0.0175871607,
0.0237344466,
-0.0226826854,
0.0209286958,
0.045453839,
0.0178867877,
-0.0497288406,
0.0244795457,
0.0103760147,
-0.019324448,
0.0044993623,
-0.1150013283,
-0.0231277552,
-0.0230756048,
-0.0455379337,
-0.0194414053,
-0.0064033954,
-0.0445799232,
-0.0008049123,
-0.0225390326,
-0.0373078696,
0.0119482744,
0.0160495825,
-0.019494053,
0.0390114598,
0.0054720375,
-0.0407241359,
0.0354097225,
-0.0796460509,
0.0170987882,
-0.0108684013,
-0.0135084502,
0.0144988727,
0.0191734191,
0.0048924214,
0.0399165973,
0.034952499,
-0.017569134,
0.0140143167,
-0.0974147767,
0.0168048572,
0.0188529864,
-0.0152199818,
0.0372059681,
-0.0258303843,
0.0203842185,
0.0189205371,
-0.0213302262,
-0.0272070412,
0.0404745862,
0.0194467697,
0.0831184685,
0.0108355721,
0.0513496511,
-0.0671839416,
-0.0370496698,
-0.0243824907,
0.0428553559,
0.0429512635,
-0.0522939041,
0.0036168846,
-0.0144987525,
-0.0511178672,
-0.0132037038,
-0.0020662323,
-0.0347988755,
0.0390908271,
0.0078594722,
-0.029308755,
0.0922399163,
0.0186399072,
0.0534816198,
0.0422843508,
0.039359808,
-0.0109496061,
-0.0374573842,
-0.0601147264,
0.0009532339,
0.0469926968,
-0.0241431762,
0.0421640798,
0.011511134,
0.0137718301,
0.0197893884,
-0.0326476954,
0.0484017134,
-0.0316308886,
-0.0082011595,
-0.0362385735,
0.0079307035,
-0.0071174833,
0.0383248627,
-0.0071646967,
0.0008685333,
0.0773641095,
0.022168586,
0.0116338497,
-0.0858643427,
-0.0075191897,
-0.0228646342,
0.0430046767,
0.0015617124,
0.0415575914,
0.0341283195,
0.0066531999,
-0.0255195647,
-0.0224468727,
0.0338466577,
-0.0091023138,
-0.0036871869,
-0.0262730084,
0.0043719802,
-0.0125201801,
-0.0060183043,
0.0183738116,
-0.0028271179,
-0.0060437769,
0.0360980667,
0.0527278036,
-0.0351687334,
-0.0583100952,
-0.0018500892,
0.07323993,
0.0395983271,
-0.0415965244,
-0.0223530084,
-0.0116775837,
0.0517765097,
0.0327130593,
0.0015552499,
0.0609774366,
-0.01102506,
0.0282201674,
0.0827297792,
-0.0335302763,
0.0615069941,
-0.0196074378,
-0.0318532996,
-0.0470367335,
-0.0077650947,
-0.0191100612,
-0.0305930749,
0.0619896576,
-0.0443243645,
0.0094603794,
0.0349947251,
0.0111484006,
-0.0407029837,
-0.0194553938,
0.0235849135,
0.0013165046,
-0.036232233,
-0.0022919811,
-0.0825451314,
0.006239011,
-0.0423297957,
0.0026823906,
-0.0069638994,
-0.0105694104,
-0.0083943671,
-0.0214800388,
0.0553465299,
-0.0231074374,
-0.0853514224,
0.0093298154,
-0.035434559,
-0.0309005156,
0.0027347659,
0.0334160291,
0.0029599683,
-0.0070383572,
-0.0179419052,
0.0348638929,
-0.0604882725,
-0.0024534333,
-0.0270402133,
-0.0496405922,
-0.0183966085,
0.0577706732,
0.0640550181,
-0.0288025066,
0.0218039062,
0.0102065876,
0.0295021962,
0.009662766,
0.0369697697,
0.112143524,
0.0018472022,
0.0112396441,
-0.0504665487,
0.0551510081,
0.0207496881,
0.0008403655,
-0.0166604128,
0.0449487232,
-0.01760328,
-0.012963363,
-0.0894520357,
0.0518960953,
-0.0408205576,
0.0421232842,
0.0299485568,
-0.0077578505,
-0.042149663,
-0.0068446165,
0.0741434991,
-0.0457330532,
-0.0384590328,
0.0078958785,
-0.0272520762,
-0.0123341177,
-0.0614952818,
-0.0420078076,
0.0221563615,
-0.0629682392,
-0.0095296083,
-0.0017261588,
0.004199516,
-0.0183751509,
-0.0633384734,
0.0398183353,
0.0241739992,
-0.0302326288,
0.0041913567,
-0.0189555362,
0.0473588072,
0.0151912104,
-0.0250936523,
0.0419606827,
-0.0536639318,
-0.0255940333,
-0.017603213,
0.0292048603,
0.0155098699,
-0.0016316409,
0.0348429754,
-0.0654044598,
0.0758537054,
0.0787777975,
0.0146077266,
0.0198309906,
-0.0023038769,
0.0228848718,
-0.0408229791,
-0.0405616425,
-0.0271900427,
-0.008714403,
-0.0465541109,
-0.0378457867,
-0.001820341,
-0.0232780278,
0.0298974216,
-0.002307062,
0.034168724,
-0.0495688431,
0.0292958543,
0.011679261,
-0.0429561585,
-0.0224767495,
0.0241524223,
-0.0356217399,
0.0046376204,
-0.011400342,
0.0125210434,
0.0063310349,
0.0514763221,
-0.0274182763,
0.0153114107,
-0.0576692559,
0.0410581864,
0.0013720304,
-0.047953248,
-0.0234873611,
0.0104864566,
-0.0573169142,
-0.0173945315,
-0.0667277053,
-0.0073094987,
0.0084806504,
-0.0118457191,
0.0527442284,
0.0338782668,
0.0136939995,
0.0343612619,
-0.10451442,
-0.0761534944,
-0.0276605431,
0.0492323898,
0.0391863994,
-0.0071878666,
0.0474694036,
-0.0288530588,
-0.0303182527,
-0.0122896582,
0.0250008516,
0.0166826583,
0.026115777,
-0.0044632349,
-0.0011110677,
0.0063352687,
-0.0530517139,
0.0710629225,
-0.0362357572,
-0.0040508085,
0.0216551684,
-0.0383111238,
-0.0147783048,
-0.0493468717,
-0.0086812908,
0.0071539208,
0.0102352705,
-0.0331694074,
-0.0344182812,
-0.0102654221,
-0.010316113,
0.0276897103,
-0.0159822889,
-0.0377652459,
0.0409205295,
0.0241382085,
0.032772135,
-0.0571731552,
0.0150102889,
0.0356661268,
-0.0407230593,
-0.0167791899,
0.0392149389,
-6.826986132e-33,
0.0108022308,
-0.0230691694,
-0.0015309502,
0.0220878664,
-0.0289286114,
0.0418961607,
-0.0634304881,
-0.0176760294,
0.0379344597,
0.0238316227,
-0.0408847705,
-0.0077090417,
0.0061594793,
0.034401644,
0.002899745,
0.0341814309,
0.0208619107,
-0.0399934687,
-0.006146342,
0.0498710163,
0.01225923,
0.0096620964,
0.0726803839,
-0.0618227869,
0.0159781128,
0.0249726288,
0.0085471552,
-0.0498007126,
0.0106048444,
0.0250112172,
-0.0457114056,
-0.0137314769,
0.0135086775,
-0.0507816784,
-0.0098422207,
0.0006042123,
-0.0463357866,
-0.0105656479,
0.0193123277,
-0.0400039442,
-0.0866048932,
0.0072814156,
0.0597824976,
-0.0555137061,
0.035352312,
-0.0399457887,
0.0675639585,
0.0079909656,
-0.0395608507,
-0.0801615044,
-0.0439453758,
0.0223597102,
-0.0336332247,
0.0027808815,
0.001635895,
0.0172337499,
-0.027880514,
0.0392834432,
-0.0471968502,
0.0026508807,
0.0647441968,
0.0177301057,
0.0148502011,
-0.0310947429,
0.0402930118,
0.07029742,
0.0238278098,
-0.010846803,
-0.043988727,
0.0193875134,
0.0162473191,
0.0086799171,
0.0655687675,
0.0203397498,
0.0576865077,
0.0078974394,
-0.069629319,
0.0394524522,
-0.0173803065,
0.018308863,
0.0057848645,
0.0117962379,
0.0225481316,
-0.0143756345,
0.0141994962,
-0.0227627009,
0.008316908,
-0.0504641533,
-0.0337349698,
-0.0243785363,
-0.0699100494,
0.0188490208,
0.0183559265,
-0.0287002772,
0.0140191158,
-0.0321434885,
-0.0126034645,
0.0362501815,
0.0035026872,
-0.0239880979,
-0.0500492379,
0.0107409935,
0.0180963855,
0.0408947095,
0.0457359329,
-0.0170613509,
0.0480813757,
-0.0074493126,
0.0138530331,
0.016581187,
0.0074286745,
-0.0112248342,
-0.0161656272,
0.0033540612,
-0.023859337,
0.0193231534,
0.0019100484,
0.0132559156,
0.0284107774,
0.0268465672,
-0.0478664897,
0.0124827754,
-0.0081957541,
0.0006753959,
-0.0227716845,
0.0175594315,
-0.0227786154,
0.0187793113,
0.0747315735,
-0.0654656515,
-0.0363534614,
0.0001106547,
2.996e-7,
0.0757770389,
0.0533852577,
0.0733515993,
-0.0204934441,
0.0241565295,
0.0100049013,
0.0127448207,
0.0145843029,
-0.0100899963,
-0.0209007319,
0.043277517,
0.0449837931,
-0.0207379665,
0.0419385768,
-0.0562619045,
-0.0470889509,
-0.1056774482,
-0.0572867356,
-0.0398396291,
0.0032630397,
0.059369076,
0.0184127148,
-0.038802579,
-0.0460805595,
0.0008330937,
0.0229559969,
0.0399403982,
-0.0155981844,
0.0239569675,
0.0159256607,
0.0120780868,
0.0015952836,
0.0032720708,
-0.0083524818,
0.0206539053,
-0.0680155978,
0.0245496426,
0.0014563627,
-0.0071456623,
-0.0465226434,
0.035820622,
0.0172772426,
0.031671755,
-0.0467365533,
0.0475523733,
-0.1106672734,
-0.0438028425,
-0.0715861097,
-0.0048940498,
-0.0154493703,
0.0740898326,
-0.0307173189,
-0.0377042666,
0.0553664677,
-0.0368194133,
-0.0041689449,
-0.0057953009,
-0.0780455992,
-0.0115996962,
0.027905928,
-0.0244636573,
0.0073821587,
-0.0086084371,
-0.0434409454,
0.0147066209,
-0.0363619775,
-0.0149791772,
2.389355965e-34,
0.0595990606,
-0.0028367713,
-0.0141382189,
0.0026050846,
0.0110954391,
0.0029703602,
0.0458517037,
-0.0175054539,
-0.0068218932,
-0.0229306985,
-0.0193902757
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03722v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03722v1 | Leveraging AI-derived Data for Carbon Accounting: Information Extraction from Alternative Sources | 2023-11-26T22:49:41 | 2023-11-26T22:49:41 | Olamide Oladeji, Seyed Shahabeddin Mousavi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Carbon accounting is a fundamental building block in our global path to
emissions reduction and decarbonization, yet many challenges exist in achieving
reliable and trusted carbon accounting measures. We motivate that carbon
accounting not only needs to be more data-driven, but also more
methodologically sound. We discuss the need for alternative, more diverse data
sources that can play a significant role on our path to trusted carbon
accounting procedures and elaborate on not only why, but how Artificial
Intelligence (AI) in general and Natural Language Processing (NLP) in
particular can unlock reasonable access to a treasure trove of alternative data
sets in light of the recent advances in the field that better enable the
utilization of unstructured data in this process. We present a case study of
the recent developments on real-world data via an NLP-powered analysis using
OpenAI's GPT API on financial and shipping data. We conclude the paper with a
discussion on how these methods and approaches can be integrated into a broader
framework for AI-enabled integrative carbon accounting. | [
-0.0098176496,
0.1611372828,
-0.0120582478,
0.0538761988,
-0.0343450382,
-0.0028862748,
-0.0055003297,
0.0071875658,
0.0090514841,
-0.0138038052,
0.0260387436,
0.0240722317,
0.0061952872,
0.1017559394,
0.0138809141,
-0.0265648123,
0.055883877,
-0.0262252707,
0.0322826877,
0.0316521525,
-0.0018138253,
0.0067026191,
0.0025930938,
0.0175145529,
-0.0466110595,
0.0019558433,
-0.0237803124,
-0.0571009517,
0.0128557188,
-0.0317099728,
0.0383734182,
0.016354464,
0.00290678,
0.0604994558,
0.0000020057,
-0.0563512892,
-0.0607693791,
0.0219791941,
-0.039339833,
0.0068614404,
0.0564694963,
-0.0071411869,
0.0224383362,
-0.0014432304,
-0.0715080649,
-0.0064625056,
0.0672922507,
-0.0253915712,
0.0740864798,
0.0122805173,
-0.0280469675,
-0.0359286219,
0.0119288024,
-0.0104436073,
-0.0204629656,
-0.0056450116,
0.0142212771,
0.0118416138,
-0.0038922664,
-0.0613609962,
-0.0159582123,
0.0470723212,
0.0302653071,
-0.0334784612,
0.0043889019,
0.021986343,
-0.024515776,
0.0219935384,
-0.0711411387,
0.042588599,
0.0548661537,
0.0067793275,
0.0155917685,
-0.0422295257,
-0.0011007854,
-0.0316221341,
-0.0259674285,
0.0284962542,
-0.0012949067,
0.0161524732,
0.0235964768,
0.0184677858,
-0.0093183368,
0.0748842582,
-0.0478373952,
0.0424509384,
-0.0614315495,
-0.0595115609,
0.0576202162,
0.0366277695,
-0.0329269022,
-0.026087055,
-0.018681895,
0.0243990906,
0.0083788149,
0.0269609466,
0.0217164382,
-0.0192614459,
-0.0076609524,
-0.0361005999,
0.0331438705,
0.0158741623,
-0.0235636253,
0.0399322435,
0.0228585489,
0.0742595047,
-0.0170494765,
0.0148006724,
0.0340879373,
-0.0266052168,
-0.0491033792,
-0.0662703961,
-0.0360731557,
0.0346397497,
-0.0296776481,
0.0116125559,
-0.0204014182,
-0.00774894,
-0.0867006108,
0.0092182523,
0.0581042282,
0.0272408649,
0.0349620357,
-0.0086547639,
-0.0655281544,
0.0020359815,
-0.023302231,
0.0540191494,
0.0336569138,
-0.0185729638,
0.0174060483,
0.0131873097,
0.016523283,
-0.0144424075,
0.0195036288,
0.075218454,
0.0261403639,
0.0198209658,
-0.0178376213,
-0.0369185843,
0.0154476222,
-0.0366809852,
0.0094138617,
-0.023437785,
0.0460293852,
-0.0325635262,
-0.0169883538,
-0.077457726,
-0.0236935355,
-0.026616266,
-0.0532717891,
0.0264245402,
-0.0873256326,
-0.0291550532,
-0.0078288149,
-0.027249448,
-0.0093959086,
0.0414043777,
0.0811358839,
-0.0277391002,
0.0274634175,
0.0060678115,
0.03253261,
-0.0095206108,
0.0323269106,
-0.0583916306,
-0.0438453704,
0.0266288333,
-0.0752973408,
-0.0275862888,
0.0498294905,
0.0079238284,
-0.0107729807,
0.0286475047,
0.0348312892,
-0.0049065035,
-0.0100524966,
0.0294409208,
0.0016643725,
-0.0010667918,
0.0151034566,
-0.0134904655,
-0.0040845922,
0.0036584206,
0.0032460031,
0.004632046,
-0.0005565757,
0.0100552924,
0.0264173746,
-0.0994746089,
-0.0042344742,
0.0211674199,
0.0235129893,
-0.0115453228,
0.0159239117,
-0.0078512589,
0.0046383007,
0.0045123915,
0.0106771151,
-0.059776295,
-0.0280094463,
-0.0378296189,
0.0235415623,
0.0001879363,
0.0173137672,
-0.0375510082,
0.0296603236,
-0.0176327992,
-0.0673892573,
0.0206185319,
0.0146160219,
-0.0239461586,
0.0011780185,
-0.0214740131,
-0.0131917037,
0.0243050326,
0.009945726,
-0.0244871769,
0.0031169667,
-0.0068209809,
-0.0070414199,
0.0047324398,
-0.0069131982,
0.0570409782,
0.0303015038,
-0.0554870218,
-0.0079208203,
0.0342193246,
0.0367662609,
0.0296979491,
-0.0018097576,
0.0269557647,
0.0154347792,
0.0212768707,
-0.0554507822,
0.0219740849,
0.0437788442,
0.0960547328,
0.0260076616,
-0.0069951969,
-0.0252489746,
0.0274246298,
-0.0392249525,
-0.0218771547,
-0.0359971039,
0.0179276615,
0.0141703421,
-0.0544663742,
-0.0294851232,
-0.0056765913,
0.0613903441,
0.0094920183,
0.0785946548,
-0.0004471007,
0.0015575776,
-0.0285939164,
-0.0277580395,
0.000135197,
-0.0158613641,
0.0374704413,
-0.0028839756,
-0.0351033434,
0.028398633,
0.0305614565,
-0.0105359079,
-0.0235058088,
0.0385034196,
-0.0421430767,
0.0259872079,
0.0207988005,
0.0183313489,
-0.0016791713,
-0.0155182965,
-0.046439942,
0.0130720735,
0.0127243446,
-0.026208397,
-0.0162830409,
-0.0151415449,
0.068712227,
0.0029867727,
0.0069935438,
-0.0300996006,
-0.0113882003,
-0.0694869906,
0.058405526,
0.0536958873,
-0.078618288,
-0.0301156715,
-0.0055450401,
-0.0244337805,
0.016780816,
0.0084360233,
-0.0083557097,
-0.0049326224,
-0.0200696513,
-0.0395213403,
0.0292388331,
-0.0083546927,
0.0246613156,
-0.0235447213,
-0.0393045992,
-0.0587666519,
0.0417651273,
0.0103713749,
0.04038978,
0.0563694686,
0.0234926827,
0.0394821391,
0.0383902453,
-0.0200631153,
0.0032677797,
0.0358641595,
0.0820386782,
-0.0131473318,
-0.0376581922,
-0.0180573575,
-0.0073696114,
-0.0012086979,
0.0497047193,
0.0178936068,
-0.0348328948,
0.0348432995,
-0.0018952644,
0.0046540978,
-0.0482413061,
0.0024559742,
-0.0046286392,
0.0494237989,
-0.0008601292,
-0.0041601127,
0.0311744809,
0.0161430016,
0.025328489,
-0.034915328,
0.0018723599,
0.0406651087,
0.0244880859,
-0.076669842,
0.0567885339,
0.0103331739,
-0.0411385521,
-0.0247375444,
-0.0281310342,
-0.0335761681,
0.0384089574,
0.0099865682,
-0.0656611398,
-0.0115566859,
0.0164550506,
0.0573354624,
0.0328731053,
-0.0026548728,
-0.034376923,
-0.0214253291,
0.0158482604,
0.0132015478,
0.0317666531,
0.0532688573,
0.0369457453,
0.0032323985,
0.0121296681,
0.0410738066,
0.0175564829,
-0.0049972259,
0.0416909382,
-0.0366666876,
-0.0186786521,
0.0602572635,
0.0168704987,
-0.0533988513,
-0.0830739662,
-0.0311528035,
0.051670637,
0.0251911301,
-0.0229403786,
0.0019582266,
0.0327818841,
-0.0560036972,
-0.0292030741,
0.0199979711,
-0.1035639122,
-0.0006298369,
-0.0044306014,
-0.0069620293,
-0.057021752,
-0.0756644756,
-0.0166910682,
-0.0915848613,
0.0875240341,
0.0025462003,
-0.0380099192,
-0.0484568067,
-0.078694582,
-0.0109740822,
-0.0768852234,
-0.0379103646,
-0.042166058,
0.0190249253,
-0.0324029364,
0.0510661416,
-0.0701716393,
0.0052529131,
-0.0291028973,
-0.0012773447,
-0.0048384559,
0.0626132414,
0.0778082833,
-0.0660451725,
0.01170325,
0.0167878792,
0.0126169799,
0.0020556801,
-0.0024033829,
0.0094313081,
0.0469066091,
-0.0168896839,
-0.0161606595,
0.0456389822,
-0.0371398404,
-0.0186318625,
0.0066372086,
0.1079327092,
-0.023788048,
0.003262992,
0.0226609521,
-0.0268747341,
0.0258513857,
0.0438255668,
-0.0119193653,
0.0041584936,
-0.072336331,
-0.0742471367,
-0.0268542673,
-0.0624555051,
0.0243179817,
0.0489029698,
-0.0038243684,
-0.0511903465,
-0.0339245424,
-0.0722560436,
0.0206315164,
0.0084682619,
-0.0076446822,
-0.0075132474,
0.0879835263,
-0.0087694032,
-0.0471643209,
-0.0060812375,
-0.0687602833,
0.0542357154,
-0.0053746575,
-0.0199306663,
-0.012582276,
0.0589554235,
-0.0444431938,
0.0742161423,
-0.0585367456,
-0.0639173836,
0.0482088476,
0.0127670001,
0.0350140966,
-0.0274082702,
0.0120512182,
0.0170129742,
0.0055258307,
0.077576369,
-0.0534723811,
-0.0208154414,
0.011688577,
0.0345719233,
0.0012967163,
-0.0171553567,
0.01024854,
-0.0103024682,
-0.0046832822,
0.0323461778,
-0.0321868397,
0.009002991,
0.0225335173,
0.0312792733,
0.0334349051,
0.0155271506,
0.0055597709,
-0.0443822555,
-0.0180287417,
-0.0006499303,
-0.0136702489,
-0.0326637402,
-0.0126805184,
0.0008340976,
0.0465328656,
-0.0531084724,
0.0511991493,
-0.0108910659,
-0.027496418,
-0.0630369782,
0.0317285359,
0.0425081849,
0.0663325638,
-0.014972249,
-0.0095063001,
0.0030629982,
-0.0789508522,
0.0252098702,
0.0400760509,
0.013174572,
0.0317556225,
0.0195208825,
0.0031819334,
-0.0358382389,
0.0292406064,
-0.050814122,
-0.0002695703,
-0.0160694513,
0.0274453592,
0.0199830942,
0.0022605583,
-0.0555460379,
-0.0558002256,
0.0057670986,
0.0493073203,
0.024939945,
0.0196786746,
0.0100878812,
0.0074396674,
-0.0066232048,
-0.0670128539,
-0.022873003,
0.041477643,
0.0222705062,
0.0486343876,
-0.0559063777,
-0.0192108583,
-0.0223342571,
-0.0422384404,
-0.0139508434,
-0.0429351963,
0.0042224419,
0.0020307498,
-0.0426267534,
-0.032736741,
0.049546171,
0.057148926,
0.0376424342,
-0.0102799935,
-0.0256694462,
0.0065697492,
-0.013381632,
-0.0133530423,
0.0041145044,
0.01565619,
-0.0956835076,
0.0067218663,
-0.0204757806,
-5.808702029e-33,
-0.0312409047,
-0.0627771094,
-0.0049916846,
0.0467634536,
0.0084807314,
0.0280006044,
-0.0477930009,
-0.0521123782,
-0.0155529538,
0.0189263262,
-0.0308584422,
0.0187027548,
0.0389718339,
-0.0203300472,
0.0511118732,
-0.0057055545,
0.0005195519,
-0.0137736499,
-0.001245021,
-0.0574109592,
0.057065282,
0.0259114671,
0.0805478096,
-0.0761087537,
0.1036141962,
0.0363270901,
-0.0496030003,
0.0002473753,
-0.0008845414,
0.0485998876,
-0.0129311746,
0.0454757661,
0.0292769689,
-0.013687429,
-0.0441711433,
0.0353843905,
-0.0712542161,
-0.0521263555,
0.0054505034,
-0.003497404,
0.0200719852,
-0.0179183297,
0.0269279573,
0.0334607847,
-0.0259671025,
0.0308327302,
0.0304245427,
-0.0401970819,
0.0137646217,
-0.0285488591,
-0.0522244498,
0.000251505,
-0.0204383917,
0.0700233355,
0.0151585685,
0.054129798,
-0.0327515751,
-0.0067624054,
-0.0707438514,
0.0185419638,
0.0197802447,
-0.0074981553,
0.011276165,
0.0168175958,
0.0396996289,
0.0525201932,
0.0100768954,
-0.0161752049,
-0.0469578765,
-0.0048389737,
0.0167592391,
0.0225485768,
0.0179784298,
0.036503613,
0.047092814,
-0.0366876423,
-0.0800675899,
0.0317907967,
0.0378638618,
0.001131518,
-0.0114986962,
-0.0111703863,
-0.0092665507,
0.0093749007,
-0.0335781947,
-0.0174820665,
-0.0296222679,
0.0488966145,
-0.001209392,
0.0074835652,
-0.0155405058,
0.0447595529,
0.0200676341,
-0.0519231372,
-0.0266207177,
-0.0042908303,
0.0445440337,
0.0459882021,
0.0240514204,
-0.0254808143,
-0.0284280237,
-0.0116685601,
-0.0156378392,
0.0475501679,
0.064742811,
-0.0092176609,
0.0272916853,
0.045983389,
-0.0131232431,
0.0057550366,
-0.0460738651,
-0.0030804987,
0.0366184041,
-0.0281300638,
-0.0042787464,
0.0368115157,
0.0170645975,
-0.0086475201,
-0.006609865,
0.0006885916,
-0.0163377468,
-0.0041717389,
-0.0296153594,
-0.0063116392,
-0.0249694996,
-0.0299080033,
0.0012004515,
-0.0627087355,
0.0006421656,
-0.0305990968,
0.0108476542,
0.0368710868,
2.641e-7,
0.0438659005,
0.0083916923,
0.0522013158,
0.0075258007,
0.0088405302,
0.0036508904,
0.0048984117,
0.0022517003,
-0.0527265035,
-0.0029402142,
0.0225158855,
-0.0114187095,
0.0378731117,
0.0199813098,
-0.0317841582,
-0.041136276,
-0.0309592038,
-0.0652106181,
-0.0819151774,
0.0111421105,
0.0181561355,
0.0450566448,
0.0187974591,
-0.024086671,
-0.0315874144,
-0.0206244588,
0.0230150949,
-0.0501050614,
0.0114415735,
-0.0157124288,
0.0334718116,
0.0096407905,
0.0026649339,
0.0118791442,
-0.0215100832,
0.0401566178,
0.0234223194,
0.0625018775,
0.0062906384,
-0.0048330175,
-0.0012306401,
-0.0610688254,
0.0179550145,
-0.0149850352,
0.0207940824,
-0.0084150136,
-0.0076529346,
-0.054543376,
0.0197812114,
0.0263182838,
0.0075057279,
-0.0209386535,
0.0148136076,
0.0331059173,
-0.0091494173,
-0.0042751832,
0.0181256812,
-0.0116633307,
-0.0022316019,
-0.0059999754,
-0.0052191238,
0.0293763969,
-0.0221997909,
0.0038257656,
0.0807346702,
-0.0086227646,
0.0326959565,
2.018610557e-34,
-0.0154686775,
-0.0204632152,
-0.0204262845,
-0.0103261871,
0.0928345919,
0.0305826869,
0.0173327979,
0.0504057929,
-0.0304677226,
-0.0672853291,
-0.0272765979
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15451v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15451v1 | Uncertainty-aware Language Modeling for Selective Question Answering | 2023-11-26T22:47:54 | 2023-11-26T22:47:54 | Qi Yang, Shreya Ravikumar, Fynn Schmitt-Ulms, Satvik Lolla, Ege Demir, Iaroslav Elistratov, Alex Lavaee, Sadhana Lolla, Elaheh Ahmadi, Daniela Rus, Alexander Amini, Alejandro Perez | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | We present an automatic large language model (LLM) conversion approach that
produces uncertainty-aware LLMs capable of estimating uncertainty with every
prediction. Our approach is model- and data-agnostic, is
computationally-efficient, and does not rely on external models or systems. We
evaluate converted models on the selective question answering setting -- to
answer as many questions as possible while maintaining a given accuracy,
forgoing providing predictions when necessary. As part of our results, we test
BERT and Llama 2 model variants on the SQuAD extractive QA task and the
TruthfulQA generative QA task. We show that using the uncertainty estimates
provided by our approach to selectively answer questions leads to significantly
higher accuracy over directly using model probabilities. | [
0.0471026748,
0.0871695802,
-0.0078697046,
0.0409888811,
-0.0143761747,
-0.0003369885,
-0.0188111123,
-0.0253376849,
-0.0217277389,
-0.0755650103,
-0.0073964777,
-0.0754965618,
-0.0474326164,
-0.0042683096,
0.0180799607,
-0.0345126949,
0.0496219844,
-0.0939565822,
0.0544039272,
-0.0392189026,
-0.0210901015,
-0.020461414,
0.0162014496,
0.0013766873,
-0.007238816,
-0.0149172693,
0.0100537082,
-0.0136386501,
-0.0165443756,
0.0078313434,
0.0167396702,
0.0703681484,
0.0046509588,
-0.0044299024,
0.0000019548,
-0.045342844,
-0.0063548945,
-0.0129708946,
-0.0599885769,
0.0345030427,
-0.0165496152,
0.0593821257,
-0.0031453918,
0.0272759199,
-0.0351743624,
0.0283021424,
0.0411072597,
-0.0298946556,
0.0452411324,
0.0303916428,
0.0230354704,
0.0013950765,
0.045720052,
-0.0034563707,
0.0563789979,
-0.0557214394,
0.0408896916,
0.029161077,
0.0080618421,
0.032660529,
-0.015788218,
0.0486887246,
-0.0039330223,
0.0062494376,
-0.0106171193,
0.0091261137,
-0.0021900367,
-0.0376156121,
-0.0131388279,
0.0360056423,
0.0193091165,
-0.0199198872,
-0.025262624,
0.0023142286,
0.0016244411,
0.0435478389,
-0.0613826141,
0.042255722,
0.0164011624,
-0.0027415566,
0.0027725263,
0.0012070899,
-0.00078295,
0.0148333004,
-0.0327112935,
0.0701085851,
0.0231682602,
-0.0141011439,
0.0013458768,
-0.0082024196,
-0.0819984451,
-0.0527705252,
0.0109695466,
0.0709346533,
-0.0241538379,
0.0485974289,
-0.0307621658,
-0.0355149321,
0.0403773449,
-0.035676185,
-0.0023706236,
0.0156496447,
0.0286380425,
0.0410261378,
0.0033199773,
0.0489065647,
-0.0038624876,
-0.008856101,
-0.0475693271,
-0.0451729968,
0.0020060739,
-0.0338213593,
-0.0624640733,
0.0395254381,
-0.03973151,
-0.0199517403,
-0.0351246372,
0.033661861,
-0.019562168,
0.0019834598,
0.0143118603,
0.0515958145,
-0.0508850329,
-0.0227687787,
-0.0469575785,
0.0025039997,
-0.0364294276,
0.0367797539,
0.0164896231,
-0.063737154,
-0.0025428419,
0.0037939367,
-0.0085345926,
-0.0227978546,
0.0041512591,
0.0591156185,
-0.0347591043,
-0.0155723076,
-0.007922248,
-0.0001867832,
-0.0376974009,
-0.0353410468,
0.0000844,
-0.0904317871,
0.0083126388,
0.0097359866,
-0.0034236806,
-0.0532923043,
0.0267314743,
0.0377861746,
-0.024752954,
0.0708086267,
-0.0121066011,
0.0433808491,
0.0541176945,
-0.0144516947,
-0.0215969663,
0.0725624338,
0.0553517751,
0.0123632709,
0.0516612343,
-0.0038069696,
0.0298362263,
0.0561778061,
0.0128000546,
0.0030662827,
-0.0339052156,
0.0439695269,
0.0040103947,
-0.001760416,
0.024935564,
0.0673609078,
5.144e-7,
-0.0275643356,
0.0680183917,
0.0561314747,
-0.0485525951,
-0.0079598418,
0.008521839,
0.0071198712,
0.0588946864,
0.0033995917,
-0.0531756878,
0.0243190527,
-0.0449214168,
0.0280330684,
0.0086003244,
0.0258288253,
-0.0155708157,
-0.0320300832,
-0.0255557802,
-0.0102586867,
-0.0013491056,
0.0708249509,
0.0271432009,
-0.0217886455,
-0.0114536639,
0.0747408867,
0.0009840074,
-0.0272123124,
0.0065049119,
-0.0649301186,
0.0756300315,
0.0016512191,
0.025237387,
-0.0511360876,
-0.0598063096,
-0.0088842381,
-0.0072085843,
0.0368479975,
0.0222546849,
-0.015757462,
-0.0017166311,
-0.0345439762,
0.0138414111,
0.0168716516,
0.019581411,
-0.0250659734,
0.0500831418,
0.0014785097,
0.0164679792,
-0.0621512756,
-0.0000194209,
0.0191529598,
-0.0269434303,
-0.0552699193,
0.0024170282,
-0.0316800848,
0.0365353227,
-0.0264324229,
-0.0069088507,
0.0306041297,
0.0388615914,
-0.0008458403,
-0.0379400142,
-0.0325509943,
-0.0188177731,
-0.0035266886,
0.0438411124,
0.0436660014,
-0.0203649513,
0.025823161,
-0.0247486234,
-0.0296420567,
-0.0345654897,
-0.069726266,
-0.0047479812,
-0.0440006591,
0.0099584851,
0.017519787,
-0.0010565347,
-0.0728133544,
0.0715791136,
-0.0037135719,
0.022447791,
0.0437916815,
0.0054401997,
-0.0044332598,
-0.053165175,
-0.0258476753,
-0.0138264485,
-0.0066514863,
0.0280480925,
0.0465807915,
0.0018314037,
-0.0325207673,
-0.039620012,
-0.0624044016,
0.0406518467,
-0.0060494286,
0.047584869,
0.021522874,
0.0136909587,
-0.0197893083,
0.0110819712,
-0.0485382825,
-0.0128482748,
0.006242366,
0.0437239558,
0.0094278278,
0.0189381521,
0.0198970381,
-0.0678567514,
-0.0087230308,
-0.010999117,
0.0339974053,
-0.0104355579,
0.0018295569,
-0.0504883714,
0.0350543633,
-0.0535714962,
0.0483130105,
0.0153438011,
-0.0516480803,
-0.0064821383,
-0.036862798,
0.0204988215,
0.0542342626,
0.0479024425,
-0.0179811064,
0.0456544943,
-0.0289476477,
-0.0562246665,
0.0562523417,
-0.0291605368,
-0.0515289269,
-0.0015587732,
-0.0685575455,
0.0091004698,
0.041376669,
0.0303732455,
-0.0262248777,
-0.0377800278,
0.0272253361,
-0.0218598116,
-0.0423805639,
-0.0233848952,
-0.0019093197,
-0.0338971727,
0.0479971953,
-0.0013698044,
-0.0146656958,
0.0646602511,
-0.0212458335,
0.0078366399,
-0.0446993299,
0.0038833162,
-0.0070538782,
0.0313802101,
-0.0065662302,
0.0092866803,
0.0025219268,
0.0079552336,
-0.0673489496,
-0.0216039233,
-0.005774885,
-0.0606790483,
0.0361798406,
-0.0780956894,
0.0099482369,
0.0055756578,
-0.0115673039,
-0.0605521835,
-0.0398165621,
-0.0314714015,
0.0343364514,
0.0293155089,
-0.0130075533,
-0.0056360229,
0.0055136816,
0.0146922208,
0.0017164086,
-0.0596118793,
0.0026396068,
-0.034006197,
0.0647625625,
0.088200815,
0.0486087017,
0.0501980558,
-0.0116113732,
0.0089349393,
0.0518838316,
0.0296045933,
0.0255460907,
0.001683516,
-0.0306557566,
0.0556631126,
-0.0416356362,
-0.0276604798,
0.0588310324,
0.094893001,
-0.0379831307,
-0.0357640199,
0.128906101,
0.0456124395,
0.0049989331,
-0.0294531658,
-0.0480016656,
0.0183779411,
0.0016389714,
0.054212261,
-0.0459699109,
-0.0557220913,
0.0019083458,
0.0251591355,
0.0000118384,
-0.0199345555,
0.0165824741,
-0.1045125648,
0.0327627212,
-0.0233135968,
-0.0436845683,
-0.0170343332,
-0.0242320858,
0.0466524735,
0.0227413867,
0.0227115769,
0.0125516113,
-0.0190340076,
0.0233778525,
0.0321140178,
-0.0237557478,
-0.0020263358,
0.0278011188,
-0.0043974691,
0.074225232,
0.0624849275,
0.0165766664,
-0.0376804397,
-0.0032866776,
0.0135462694,
-0.073082529,
-0.035466101,
0.0080562327,
0.0202509034,
0.0299133621,
-0.007406794,
-0.0109436456,
0.0208491907,
-0.01273691,
-0.0028563035,
0.0308402907,
0.0699992031,
-0.0073446436,
-0.0078436341,
-0.0344274044,
-0.0063621989,
0.0155458814,
0.081306003,
0.0109787509,
-0.0612412766,
-0.0229605753,
-0.0424792841,
0.0151725635,
-0.019134542,
0.0139201162,
0.0073887836,
-0.003778273,
0.0174666066,
-0.0752213895,
-0.0196435247,
0.0262690056,
-0.0058747055,
-0.0071552419,
0.0195851699,
0.0626382381,
0.030614635,
-0.0149793914,
0.0125129856,
-0.0260301623,
0.0304303467,
-0.0499495305,
0.016601216,
0.0503734127,
-0.0100306077,
-0.0112368548,
0.0279287882,
-0.0983350947,
-0.0582443252,
0.0107164625,
0.0614333004,
0.0260672551,
-0.0290091429,
-0.0076778936,
-0.0704750866,
0.0274318065,
0.0284453258,
-0.0160215516,
0.0366484746,
0.0192661844,
0.0485336222,
-0.0268033165,
0.0398083441,
-0.0510177948,
-0.0109303836,
-0.0117470091,
0.0425476506,
-0.0582706444,
-0.0913852826,
0.0059486059,
0.0412915908,
0.003838331,
0.000215191,
-0.0165101849,
0.0094873784,
0.0078981826,
-0.0246372968,
-0.0090824543,
-0.0297236554,
0.0023298038,
0.0231728703,
-0.0350379162,
-0.0025082249,
-0.0012235262,
0.0064430749,
0.0397365615,
-0.0492234193,
-0.0222611856,
0.0326315425,
-0.0219545774,
0.0195965376,
-0.0135110971,
-0.0309219044,
-0.0086982884,
0.009515875,
0.0412974581,
0.0078181485,
0.0271521118,
0.0018949008,
-0.0298875291,
-0.0201249979,
-0.014414127,
-0.068392545,
-0.1075118557,
-0.0250908844,
0.074784793,
0.0116154151,
0.0361605734,
0.032523945,
-0.025931403,
-0.0261851307,
-0.0312023368,
-0.0058976333,
0.0513265543,
0.0408819243,
0.1052616388,
0.0255482551,
0.0070668021,
-0.0037153803,
0.0780012459,
0.0210183002,
0.0558844768,
-0.0298516005,
-0.0464656688,
-0.0027049244,
-0.0249920655,
-0.008564705,
0.0011333454,
-0.0017315574,
0.0282369331,
-0.0273673069,
-0.0682909116,
0.0228052642,
0.0143945552,
-0.0054228543,
-0.0565945804,
0.0321946591,
0.0682053789,
0.0158431977,
-0.0414229371,
-0.0325169824,
0.0663680732,
-0.0154579151,
0.0116208987,
-0.0287730545,
-6.525563667e-33,
-0.032742653,
-0.0405251309,
0.00257241,
-0.0484582223,
-0.0054808152,
-0.0090399729,
0.0003286575,
0.0061231172,
-0.0404087864,
0.0057367412,
-0.0309677273,
-0.0068076844,
0.0104590151,
0.047538273,
0.0110041145,
-0.0214573797,
0.0078041209,
-0.0232713763,
-0.0040210499,
-0.016671773,
0.0360756554,
-0.0021446876,
0.0115521476,
-0.022097325,
0.0252547469,
-0.0250493903,
-0.0100518186,
0.0558181778,
-0.0130764674,
0.0528416857,
-0.0343531035,
0.0554223321,
-0.0018627176,
-0.0274125393,
-0.0110363616,
0.0276567861,
-0.0558518879,
-0.0478334799,
0.0530672744,
-0.0139066512,
-0.0153044658,
-0.0208488014,
0.0200143382,
0.0101216957,
-0.0067945216,
0.0060699671,
0.0165913906,
-0.0409908667,
-0.02986129,
-0.0571276434,
-0.0364145078,
0.0020607025,
0.0209915768,
-0.0511260256,
-0.0182156917,
0.0574944578,
-0.0271844529,
0.0034389023,
0.0180725008,
-0.0279689543,
0.0361706205,
0.0548550151,
0.0456547402,
0.0395429991,
-0.0120146051,
0.0225996599,
-0.029175166,
-0.0368853547,
-0.0107314074,
-0.0192358494,
-0.0151032098,
0.0337377116,
0.0309181996,
0.0458491296,
-0.0177915823,
0.0251693036,
-0.0758567974,
0.0364277028,
0.0213819537,
0.0417847857,
0.0404896364,
-0.0064218566,
-0.0247760974,
-0.0183667894,
-0.0760973394,
0.0293100458,
-0.0188613534,
0.0096275089,
0.0238077492,
-0.0318473354,
-0.0459598899,
-0.0096438089,
0.0314570032,
-0.0298862066,
-0.0020682712,
0.0218774825,
-0.0277557783,
0.034736637,
0.0115462737,
0.053518042,
-0.0171157941,
0.0177303664,
0.0017900903,
-0.0290964264,
-0.0282368958,
0.0422151722,
-0.0276114102,
0.0149278268,
-0.0644247159,
0.0172999315,
-0.0358320177,
0.0319977514,
-0.0016139015,
-0.0135794785,
0.0208385736,
-0.0082329446,
0.0074873231,
0.0404382832,
-0.0089400653,
0.0080808811,
-0.0052213101,
-0.0146583198,
0.0015170439,
0.0222609099,
-0.0522565506,
0.0099886423,
-0.0132016568,
0.0149842314,
-0.0602107123,
-0.0395789593,
-0.0117283762,
0.0313001536,
2.572e-7,
0.0726402253,
0.0474147238,
-0.0000037642,
0.0709253326,
0.0307419971,
0.0485402606,
0.0064226142,
-0.0006391408,
0.0827386528,
-0.0047523971,
-0.0215928201,
0.0445435941,
0.00600392,
0.049050767,
-0.043651022,
-0.055802878,
-0.0394793227,
0.012238916,
-0.0131224534,
-0.0184448566,
0.0616974607,
0.0854040161,
-0.0076011634,
0.0006363498,
-0.037045069,
-0.0448833853,
0.064445667,
-0.0236032046,
-0.0532880723,
0.0625167713,
0.0426624864,
-0.0034943062,
0.0090919882,
0.020863669,
-0.0058487169,
0.0025526455,
0.0254677404,
0.0756778568,
0.0053074406,
-0.0238543712,
-0.017661741,
-0.0497850105,
0.0361497067,
-0.0668799579,
0.082985498,
-0.0541674718,
-0.0041267499,
-0.0292635132,
-0.0201024823,
-0.0173156131,
0.0104826037,
-0.0501779467,
-0.0013394782,
-0.0111206602,
0.01103603,
0.0203339607,
-0.0295617636,
-0.0413605012,
-0.0337448269,
-0.0104256533,
-0.0482316948,
-0.0619919486,
-0.0034239576,
-0.0160572808,
-0.0111487033,
-0.0874764174,
0.0328549631,
2.16486111e-34,
0.0403632075,
0.0392884091,
-0.0107723679,
0.0440032482,
0.0213327929,
-0.0076172636,
-0.0059939669,
0.0083355401,
0.0239150468,
-0.0963436589,
-0.0217766613
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15436v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15436v1 | Learning to Skip for Language Modeling | 2023-11-26T21:45:53 | 2023-11-26T21:45:53 | Dewen Zeng, Nan Du, Tao Wang, Yuanzhong Xu, Tao Lei, Zhifeng Chen, Claire Cui | cs.CL | cs.CL | Overparameterized large-scale language models have impressive generalization
performance of in-context few-shot learning. However, most language models
allocate the same amount of parameters or computation to each token,
disregarding the complexity or importance of the input data. We argue that in
language model pretraining, a variable amount of computation should be assigned
to different tokens, and this can be efficiently achieved via a simple routing
mechanism. Different from conventional early stopping techniques where tokens
can early exit at only early layers, we propose a more general method that
dynamically skips the execution of a layer (or module) for any input token with
a binary router. In our extensive evaluation across 24 NLP tasks, we
demonstrate that the proposed method can significantly improve the 1-shot
performance compared to other competitive baselines only at mild extra cost for
inference. | [
0.006822153,
0.0693463609,
0.0122904321,
-0.0091734845,
-0.0179631785,
0.0442448854,
0.0562174954,
-0.0127099892,
-0.0292162169,
-0.0526572019,
-0.0060123485,
-0.0074124369,
-0.0392471515,
0.0101374285,
0.043193724,
-0.0310415756,
0.0528435223,
-0.0069021354,
0.0279616341,
0.0012633547,
-0.0305477921,
0.0134554477,
0.0039008476,
0.0594291613,
0.0162864868,
-0.0129138986,
-0.0065787882,
0.0057020029,
0.0143662645,
-0.0399403274,
0.0124128954,
0.0253508016,
0.012687562,
0.0286973026,
0.0000019851,
-0.00405868,
-0.0214592796,
0.0122851804,
-0.0490547083,
0.0092603918,
0.0294710714,
0.0053579006,
0.014602392,
0.0136038372,
-0.007881307,
-0.064321205,
0.054315608,
0.0444017462,
0.0383748114,
0.0729428455,
-0.0094148125,
-0.0315201022,
0.0098617161,
-0.0328940228,
0.0029407842,
-0.0572777241,
0.0133967707,
-0.0550678447,
-0.0278251488,
-0.0056502069,
-0.0335954092,
0.0272310358,
0.0319560394,
0.0426781699,
0.0130446088,
0.0521806106,
-0.0630515143,
-0.0421102904,
-0.0176791362,
0.073660858,
-0.0842420682,
-0.0473235399,
0.0026155524,
-0.025414113,
-0.0277639795,
-0.0528110377,
-0.0540158153,
-0.0077126254,
0.0323094353,
0.0209847353,
0.0069134687,
-0.0236806385,
0.0484124981,
0.022344619,
-0.0283552781,
0.019418098,
0.0394124649,
0.0056135291,
0.0120946597,
0.0375550836,
-0.0211822577,
-0.0558641292,
-0.0070592347,
0.0275038239,
-0.040188197,
0.0036207263,
-0.0417144224,
0.0022615958,
0.0023531329,
-0.0485566333,
0.0733496249,
0.0509156249,
-0.0212705024,
0.0687184185,
-0.0581340343,
-0.0186113231,
-0.0261296835,
0.0454693474,
-0.0224873312,
-0.0018416878,
-0.0192301348,
-0.0037907052,
-0.0768247694,
0.0435049981,
-0.0356068276,
-0.0329375565,
-0.0216565412,
0.0280941315,
-0.005114621,
0.0031268187,
-0.0039373268,
0.0086613968,
-0.0195148997,
-0.0143855382,
0.0427175984,
0.0248632543,
-0.0659721717,
0.0208281577,
0.0045654825,
-0.0415604673,
-0.0560298525,
0.0040359059,
0.0264092889,
-0.0338904522,
0.0300755277,
0.0758853555,
-0.001662617,
-0.0572302565,
-0.0232025012,
-0.0132819563,
0.020254869,
-0.0742523819,
-0.0064742463,
-0.0673699304,
0.022903556,
0.0041952534,
0.0255396571,
0.0083830683,
-0.0146556105,
0.0541531146,
-0.0317109935,
0.0490765274,
0.0246733334,
-0.0257514305,
-0.0002882699,
0.0000718423,
-0.0060506766,
0.0787474886,
-0.0165709835,
0.01795475,
0.0367282741,
0.0190365929,
0.0101663703,
0.0232734028,
0.050315287,
0.0063759955,
-0.0362780765,
-0.0048257741,
0.0387238227,
0.0095387166,
0.0486127436,
-0.0155889513,
-0.0829287693,
-0.0056703496,
0.0119609032,
0.042130921,
0.0193021558,
0.0032040733,
0.0842493102,
-0.0140985232,
-0.0047991239,
-0.0083357506,
-0.0580021441,
0.036228437,
-0.0127177387,
-0.0166170485,
0.0461010188,
0.0316607393,
-0.0531152599,
-0.0028992924,
0.0008621388,
0.0148380222,
-0.0081109693,
0.0308136716,
0.0441040099,
0.0297527909,
-0.0283677969,
0.0475307032,
0.0532876328,
-0.0103983302,
-0.002256325,
-0.0236930232,
-0.0168443173,
0.0486067384,
0.0406849794,
-0.015695259,
-0.0165304448,
0.0040471349,
0.0737657771,
0.0117191663,
0.0373216756,
-0.0242510587,
0.0778350756,
-0.0527450517,
-0.0081245359,
-0.023905145,
0.0361712202,
-0.0153963994,
0.0172431022,
0.0212685987,
0.0054815281,
-0.0447117798,
0.0076971347,
0.0346826948,
-0.0416885465,
-0.0631975457,
0.0227743257,
0.0345411114,
0.0090780593,
-0.0134967361,
-0.0054715192,
0.00069545,
0.0054196189,
-0.0225524921,
-0.0091763977,
0.0116572138,
-0.0473933816,
-0.0795980915,
0.0093334848,
-0.0241736658,
-0.0146074649,
-0.0081098778,
-0.0654677078,
-0.0111260647,
0.0440250635,
-0.0033876682,
0.0770591199,
0.0019269155,
0.0219203029,
0.0090362094,
0.0171445012,
-0.0274328478,
0.0241536722,
0.0159124248,
0.0291970465,
0.0058373716,
0.0082879458,
0.0084136119,
-0.0098064989,
-0.0443429425,
0.0179872755,
-0.0100992769,
0.0025912318,
0.0013402337,
0.009151428,
-0.0330616087,
0.0007390986,
-0.1074559167,
0.0003331384,
-0.0211143922,
0.0066163908,
0.0193150342,
0.0112746367,
0.0123142712,
-0.0331048034,
0.004938338,
0.0112383859,
-0.0271966103,
0.0295547899,
-0.0032670095,
0.0030240447,
-0.0176471677,
-0.0144768162,
-0.0510965735,
-0.0157184973,
0.0778929442,
-0.0489404388,
-0.0014535679,
-0.0141911274,
-0.0452909246,
-0.012853818,
0.0328801349,
-0.002444111,
-0.0279022567,
0.0054255342,
-0.0361824743,
0.0073870285,
0.0578520186,
-0.0362502076,
0.0248042233,
0.0431340411,
0.0020348593,
-0.0712467209,
0.0270769075,
-0.0268956199,
0.0082850587,
-0.039111767,
0.0222634021,
-0.0193721652,
0.0943481773,
-0.0324845538,
-0.0074388087,
-0.0610958748,
0.0185532123,
-0.0147170611,
-0.0159846265,
-0.0182780195,
0.0088385148,
-0.0099188443,
0.0227591265,
-0.0194517262,
-0.0003907065,
0.0625821277,
0.0016270076,
-0.0129360752,
-0.0384405404,
-0.0066424087,
-0.0078289593,
0.0528466925,
0.0290569253,
0.0156234782,
-0.0246603154,
-0.0341954194,
-0.0461433046,
0.0219277069,
0.0094157057,
0.0186290517,
0.0254886709,
-0.0131434985,
0.0031949037,
-0.017752476,
-0.032505814,
-0.0213463679,
-0.0330451764,
-0.0425931588,
0.0174624361,
-0.0420599803,
0.004213748,
-0.05330614,
-0.0328893103,
-0.0133505873,
0.0784080327,
-0.0047995923,
-0.0033109807,
-0.0376264974,
0.0138878012,
0.0390111543,
-0.0512435324,
0.0153169017,
-0.0175580736,
0.059518747,
0.0394390859,
0.0457118563,
0.0141134178,
-0.0170530863,
0.011820998,
0.049134437,
-0.0411908813,
-0.0247752219,
0.0068763732,
0.0600807518,
-0.0623233505,
-0.0551025942,
0.0840770453,
0.0182072688,
-0.061490722,
0.0077211717,
0.0203962289,
0.0285360646,
0.0387003012,
0.0241955966,
-0.0876952261,
-0.0385698788,
0.0301255286,
-0.0063782865,
-0.0078538461,
-0.0320367925,
-0.019340165,
-0.1159404516,
0.0018527553,
-0.0060833958,
-0.057511244,
-0.0035387287,
-0.0569556914,
-0.0125914393,
-0.0124153597,
0.031557776,
0.0034256219,
-0.0079906583,
0.0000669262,
0.0077467402,
0.0418049768,
-0.0301319491,
0.0556794219,
-0.0432920232,
0.049045641,
0.0103756543,
0.0039823093,
0.0243736617,
0.0353376456,
0.0696451887,
-0.0181262549,
-0.0060555977,
-0.0199245587,
0.0530215614,
-0.0176814459,
-0.0215596054,
0.0139079681,
-0.0032122524,
0.0011792459,
-0.0350237302,
-0.0315435007,
0.0777769163,
-0.0121567389,
-0.0537246279,
-0.0107705016,
0.0047818073,
-0.0213120822,
0.0687303469,
0.0304095149,
-0.0521138571,
-0.0609844737,
-0.0166900549,
-0.0332719982,
-0.0700645745,
-0.0023684185,
-0.0008361824,
-0.01011898,
-0.0528401472,
-0.0451130308,
-0.0189431123,
0.0649677962,
0.0727096573,
-0.0213514231,
-0.0009055127,
-0.0067454176,
0.0004300605,
-0.0404351614,
0.023784548,
-0.0332807302,
0.0032063986,
-0.0562697053,
0.0056674997,
0.0285522733,
0.005439519,
-0.0344553962,
0.0100042103,
-0.106846191,
-0.079479225,
0.0015364377,
0.0361469872,
0.0097592007,
0.0654467046,
-0.0320896693,
-0.0791189298,
0.1003831327,
0.0396283381,
-0.0157892257,
0.013779426,
0.0518752635,
-0.0108069107,
0.0061540673,
0.0437326021,
-0.048664432,
0.0172421448,
0.0594909266,
0.0570031516,
-0.0289002042,
0.0544461533,
0.004439225,
-0.0212770086,
0.0584634133,
-0.0118815182,
0.0037514709,
-0.0200267136,
0.0314463116,
-0.0175835676,
-0.0025703888,
-0.0402826406,
0.0154266041,
0.0102602188,
0.0083092777,
-0.0262618046,
-0.0066874879,
0.0095080733,
0.0448032506,
-0.0001820246,
0.0054221801,
0.0228401292,
-0.0093318317,
0.0399053916,
0.0120119341,
-0.0345402285,
0.0039497665,
-0.001813883,
-0.0031754677,
-0.077298604,
0.0089319116,
0.0512683317,
0.0352722667,
-0.0618443005,
0.0113655264,
-0.067277208,
-0.0361574851,
-0.0416945331,
0.0457631834,
0.0409627929,
-0.0050606839,
0.0074034785,
-0.0017904353,
-0.0433308333,
0.0164432861,
-0.0032135374,
-0.0188745577,
-0.0529399514,
0.0281309579,
0.0487290472,
0.0020812463,
-0.0182709396,
0.0675488338,
0.0286356919,
0.0697719231,
0.0119141452,
0.0213944688,
-0.0165166873,
-0.0069549144,
0.0228515267,
0.0437859893,
-0.0132322861,
0.0293425843,
-0.0144836679,
-0.0679877102,
-0.0335366987,
-0.0321182869,
-0.0093328543,
0.0079066958,
0.0253773667,
0.0522834547,
0.023724461,
-0.0263341721,
-0.0262309052,
-0.0045797196,
0.0672900975,
-0.0409377404,
-0.0056607076,
-6.908545604e-33,
-0.0023225795,
0.0190382041,
0.0379056185,
-0.0404689051,
-0.00253068,
-0.0052704117,
-0.0299119242,
-0.0013975947,
-0.0410038345,
0.0174406059,
-0.0211129375,
0.0185066704,
0.0214673541,
0.0394610353,
0.0253173821,
-0.0028161502,
0.0712899417,
0.008083038,
-0.0124095064,
0.0129766101,
-0.0024696328,
0.0327516869,
0.0761368498,
0.0379942842,
-0.0228609592,
0.0244203731,
-0.0178929009,
0.0115663046,
0.0056402395,
0.0218496323,
-0.0158750676,
0.0284509007,
0.0192381311,
-0.0288192127,
-0.0204599835,
0.0131058497,
-0.0905655399,
-0.0581574515,
0.0192188751,
0.0352947041,
-0.0077193598,
-0.0318369009,
0.034421891,
-0.0132172965,
-0.0054139439,
-0.0152438655,
0.0082983207,
0.013308187,
-0.0430451035,
-0.0229475815,
-0.0807134286,
0.0116661852,
0.0023324566,
0.0007307889,
0.0296073109,
0.0261348486,
-0.0152691174,
0.0519018658,
-0.060372401,
-0.0134487711,
-0.0161085464,
0.0107844258,
0.0130871739,
0.0184514057,
0.0192874167,
0.0506211221,
0.0340789296,
-0.0172686689,
-0.0099029532,
0.0186317768,
0.0686441287,
0.0123043768,
0.0007027961,
-0.0015781615,
0.0888801441,
-0.001777032,
-0.0603931621,
-0.0422370508,
0.0254390407,
0.0508248322,
0.0224230103,
0.0247505531,
0.0113071399,
-0.0156330019,
-0.0502524674,
-0.0647420958,
-0.045000881,
-0.0292374082,
0.0242787693,
0.052958969,
-0.0124568585,
0.0014752295,
0.0600916408,
-0.034426637,
-0.0218158681,
0.0405277982,
-0.018218847,
0.016229691,
0.0123508852,
0.0359988585,
-0.0743287578,
-0.0339158997,
0.0108412728,
-0.0116408309,
0.019566793,
-0.0179850049,
0.0629612282,
0.0078655789,
-0.0812443495,
-0.0159028452,
-0.0500186607,
0.0116791362,
0.0293126311,
0.0669455528,
0.0698099062,
0.0263120402,
-0.0007330269,
0.0488556065,
0.0170548037,
-0.0211112816,
-0.0001208094,
0.0384385772,
0.0058918102,
0.0192469805,
-0.0429920256,
-0.0089115342,
-0.0367426351,
-0.0132152773,
0.0318240784,
-0.0912720263,
-0.0327851698,
0.0364600532,
2.758e-7,
0.0024110451,
0.0453899615,
-0.0077352347,
0.0302500539,
-0.0101411734,
0.0064195883,
0.0234035142,
0.0126252212,
-0.0027116712,
0.0353433043,
0.0105426945,
0.0207005516,
0.0238802303,
0.0110142482,
-0.1127149984,
0.0347361006,
-0.0747828558,
0.0226653386,
-0.0327341557,
-0.0688965619,
-0.0031111431,
0.1372505724,
0.0227490868,
0.0045221997,
0.0229212474,
-0.0236166976,
0.0415243693,
0.0274624825,
0.0062216017,
0.0084617352,
-0.0297145955,
0.0313626789,
0.0126296869,
-0.0042417073,
-0.0394046307,
0.0288864616,
-0.0025559119,
0.0771914124,
-0.026551459,
-0.0538572408,
-0.0189080052,
-0.0365166254,
-0.0026473843,
-0.056577757,
0.088810809,
-0.0841001421,
-0.0242277589,
-0.0466581844,
-0.0052225548,
0.0013181502,
0.0266616549,
-0.0281814374,
-0.0202880744,
0.042262096,
0.0383180864,
-0.0162471514,
-0.0035378551,
-0.1122092679,
-0.0188713688,
0.0269043092,
-0.0148115857,
-0.0273938645,
-0.0139275715,
-0.0053137685,
0.0205728896,
-0.0444381386,
-0.0147805298,
2.531447059e-34,
0.0669833794,
-0.0249801725,
0.0313454568,
0.0281705186,
-0.0027074483,
-0.0133234737,
-0.0402469449,
-0.0057320776,
0.0388928875,
-0.0514467433,
-0.030354334
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15425v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15425v1 | Machine-Generated Text Detection using Deep Learning | 2023-11-26T21:16:01 | 2023-11-26T21:16:01 | Raghav Gaggar, Ashish Bhagchandani, Harsh Oza | cs.CL | cs.CL, I.2.7; I.5.4; I.2.6 | Our research focuses on the crucial challenge of discerning text produced by
Large Language Models (LLMs) from human-generated text, which holds
significance for various applications. With ongoing discussions about attaining
a model with such functionality, we present supporting evidence regarding the
feasibility of such models. We evaluated our models on multiple datasets,
including Twitter Sentiment, Football Commentary, Project Gutenberg, PubMedQA,
and SQuAD, confirming the efficacy of the enhanced detection approaches. These
datasets were sampled with intricate constraints encompassing every
possibility, laying the foundation for future research. We evaluate
GPT-3.5-Turbo against various detectors such as SVM, RoBERTa-base, and
RoBERTa-large. Based on the research findings, the results predominantly relied
on the sequence length of the sentence. | [
0.0367632806,
0.0711367354,
0.0023163049,
0.0891330615,
-0.0326558501,
0.0286811385,
-0.0373303592,
0.0510240011,
-0.0232519619,
-0.0304051619,
0.0234226696,
-0.0435335897,
-0.0069221803,
0.0334700607,
0.0032982912,
-0.006534881,
0.0020559381,
-0.0031105317,
0.0179041345,
0.030026095,
0.0529281981,
0.0232811719,
0.0140342051,
0.0214634761,
-0.0350105427,
-0.0032752175,
0.0158691332,
0.0196474809,
0.0290685724,
-0.0255103875,
0.014789368,
0.0500703268,
0.0122819953,
0.1084622592,
0.0000019017,
-0.0084601426,
-0.0123494407,
-0.0380627699,
-0.0003713575,
0.010120362,
0.0941127241,
-0.0397530794,
-0.0242469627,
0.0121308658,
-0.0178095866,
-0.0069413171,
0.0089445747,
0.0569086112,
-0.0117504485,
0.0882197991,
-0.040060021,
-0.0093894415,
0.0643722564,
-0.0188140031,
0.016612947,
-0.0365122333,
0.0299923755,
-0.0252397452,
-0.0338341594,
0.0122859878,
0.0340744443,
0.0145252254,
0.0270861927,
-0.0010396135,
-0.0387919359,
0.0124953957,
-0.0266487375,
-0.0145886606,
-0.0277474392,
0.050273139,
-0.0569986366,
-0.0445416383,
0.0342559665,
-0.0283168424,
-0.0013907896,
-0.0397670269,
0.0127504077,
0.0317017697,
-0.0317398757,
0.0386347584,
-0.0188838746,
0.002778976,
0.0352601409,
0.0403323993,
-0.0129115861,
0.0362803861,
0.0165503807,
-0.0329550467,
-0.0072076027,
0.0417789929,
-0.0496227257,
-0.0121173728,
0.0738592744,
-0.0045088702,
-0.010721135,
-0.0039645899,
-0.0677986443,
-0.0716865212,
0.0282165818,
-0.0568112843,
0.0269477088,
-0.0077751805,
-0.0224743858,
0.0408434235,
-0.0613867454,
0.0330697112,
-0.0911993682,
-0.0190872308,
0.0107652191,
0.0142989345,
-0.0033667122,
-0.025658356,
0.0091585554,
-0.0099043446,
-0.0546837598,
-0.0409677774,
-0.0398962647,
0.0080920216,
0.0437648967,
-0.018613955,
-0.012936851,
-0.0198756903,
-0.0268246215,
-0.0129947672,
0.0110206436,
0.0140544502,
-0.0035671599,
0.0205371939,
-0.0115131531,
-0.066203922,
0.0042882082,
0.0627086163,
0.0396446958,
0.0155426711,
0.0227390714,
0.0081809685,
-0.0186000075,
-0.0618761256,
-0.0377228484,
-0.0294905286,
-0.0477358773,
-0.0709664896,
0.0314185433,
-0.0739120692,
-0.0230803564,
-0.0304372869,
-0.0039880415,
-0.0041588359,
0.0197196323,
0.0591854937,
0.0003464565,
0.0398288108,
-0.0416164026,
0.0053555928,
0.0229112878,
0.0012509552,
0.0296172909,
0.0674991086,
0.0317793377,
0.0816675946,
0.0327583253,
0.0067824889,
0.0212560538,
0.0701125786,
-0.0181594156,
-0.008687932,
-0.015683027,
-0.0335393772,
-0.0362141728,
0.0254144222,
0.0187945701,
0.0557231605,
0.0119735999,
-0.0181617532,
0.0711595193,
0.0478327163,
0.0122452723,
0.0192783587,
0.0396910757,
0.0527580455,
-0.0206762441,
0.0221851338,
0.0128602246,
-0.0452433005,
-0.013920946,
0.0030133177,
-0.0034119224,
0.0386834368,
-0.0043734731,
-0.0244572368,
-0.01162834,
-0.0272123702,
0.0043464489,
-0.0294662192,
0.0652827024,
-0.0167790335,
-0.0734762028,
-0.0258946288,
-0.0014570217,
-0.0311780609,
0.0126864361,
-0.0660166368,
0.0473662019,
0.0515492633,
0.0184955094,
-0.0073060635,
0.040629223,
-0.0162900779,
0.0057230266,
0.1056193933,
0.0071561672,
0.0506754108,
0.0055905012,
-0.0470767133,
-0.0063597369,
0.0014448046,
0.0335881077,
0.0356543027,
0.0369929373,
0.038239982,
0.0295819845,
-0.0067753773,
-0.0417431369,
0.0575024635,
-0.0051095225,
-0.017412575,
-0.0159354638,
-0.0035849044,
0.0037362108,
0.0375569128,
-0.0285185631,
-0.0118962098,
0.0332065076,
-0.0523369424,
-0.0294599738,
-0.0276906192,
-0.0139274625,
-0.0238885209,
0.001691105,
-0.0369573496,
-0.0378682725,
0.0696260631,
-0.0236912556,
-0.0040241154,
-0.0138178552,
-0.0355330892,
-0.0068270066,
-0.0599847175,
0.012680186,
-0.0270568579,
0.0550154671,
0.0096586561,
0.0641253889,
-0.0042930846,
-0.0283646956,
0.0200908873,
-0.0417539515,
0.0419507623,
-0.0352900587,
-0.0172357801,
0.0201597158,
-0.0028473265,
0.0170323923,
0.0442450196,
0.0486571118,
-0.0402803905,
-0.0281687323,
-0.0892514884,
0.0350144729,
-0.0510144867,
0.0127950925,
0.0203925651,
-0.0016274893,
-0.0303098634,
-0.0094290115,
-0.0255881604,
-0.0206304267,
0.0546046868,
0.0035617631,
0.0425754152,
-0.0181974974,
0.0137284445,
-0.0349886455,
-0.0099031916,
-0.0168262459,
0.026743846,
0.0519433878,
-0.0523692705,
-0.0286899339,
0.0010383793,
0.0246188138,
0.0149932355,
0.0104050385,
-0.0464392416,
-0.0080623832,
-0.0229558665,
0.0338932276,
0.0887315422,
0.0347255655,
0.0162349697,
-0.0089802062,
0.0515223704,
0.0029720562,
0.0042271167,
-0.0369553193,
0.0145345805,
-0.0322880968,
-0.0431894921,
0.0485890061,
0.0577049106,
-0.0311194845,
0.0407129005,
-0.0346802175,
0.0059296484,
-0.0081772758,
-0.0179646648,
0.0020924206,
-0.0111906687,
-0.0305341613,
0.0225228351,
-0.0381914303,
-0.0501849391,
0.0385095887,
-0.0400592051,
0.0025011562,
-0.0661137402,
-0.0510998778,
-0.0366498902,
0.016012162,
0.0402341448,
0.0192767903,
-0.0472918488,
-0.0043844385,
0.0081417905,
0.0094108572,
-0.0081239566,
-0.0325183384,
-0.0017399539,
0.0109558851,
0.0028555181,
-0.0155784711,
-0.0171995293,
-0.0406563431,
-0.0524989031,
-0.0568003841,
-0.0279854983,
0.0591009334,
-0.0472331606,
-0.0079769129,
0.0119690234,
-0.0111123137,
0.0655934587,
-0.0216344707,
0.0010656673,
-0.037257202,
0.0586947426,
0.0568061881,
-0.0442717969,
0.0222569089,
-0.0452086851,
0.0038254245,
0.0478937626,
0.0075468752,
0.0433491133,
-0.0313356444,
-0.0160790477,
-0.0006935934,
0.0135226808,
0.0028127485,
-0.0020862957,
0.0207176283,
-0.0784734562,
0.0071225101,
0.0981496572,
0.0046915896,
-0.0684159324,
-0.0211692415,
0.0300052818,
0.020734055,
-0.0174290501,
-0.0111103905,
-0.0682646856,
-0.0545058064,
0.0076341215,
-0.0266783386,
-0.0270204153,
0.0150284246,
-0.0021473202,
-0.0687279701,
0.0154990926,
0.0006423104,
-0.031254679,
-0.0334364511,
-0.0107876286,
0.0056309584,
0.0206270777,
-0.0014526537,
-0.0288848747,
-0.0189475976,
-0.0104223713,
0.0044131903,
-0.0312636457,
-0.0474790782,
-0.0249465071,
-0.0555026978,
-0.0276525263,
0.089648433,
0.0549198426,
-0.0206805635,
-0.0328832828,
0.0478807166,
-0.0174512733,
-0.0215324704,
0.0079086665,
0.0726857558,
-0.0445432365,
-0.0056197355,
-0.0291940533,
0.0364935473,
-0.0542656444,
0.0220503043,
0.0307059158,
0.0396628007,
0.0338797122,
-0.0758407637,
-0.0574607365,
0.0234080665,
0.0130097782,
0.0632408708,
0.018489683,
-0.04457739,
-0.0619293824,
0.0042166375,
0.0443640798,
-0.0752699524,
-0.0576359294,
-0.0104015209,
0.016898632,
-0.0319648236,
-0.040474385,
-0.0165215265,
-0.0122693609,
0.0048707421,
-0.0047645941,
0.022514984,
-0.015992919,
0.0044929525,
-0.05925918,
0.0006930298,
-0.0219088644,
-0.0033585052,
-0.0625328794,
0.0310729388,
0.0354269296,
-0.016040599,
-0.0139554096,
0.017111836,
-0.1016121358,
-0.0210064072,
-0.0067257849,
-0.0225240365,
0.0178444143,
0.0105165597,
0.0089112949,
-0.0432663523,
0.0726355836,
0.0314844288,
-0.0305030588,
0.0048694229,
-0.019589562,
-0.0170224346,
-0.0338629931,
0.0052477545,
-0.0156750251,
0.0410197787,
-0.002417163,
-0.0386162028,
-0.0232939441,
0.0063409461,
0.0063847098,
-0.0189885814,
0.0590596944,
0.001062771,
-0.0288085435,
-0.0303382147,
-0.0223204456,
0.011689554,
0.0311677083,
-0.0613306537,
0.0090757152,
0.039688427,
0.0175762381,
-0.0291314144,
0.0215302259,
-0.0014557695,
0.0379234329,
-0.0314031765,
0.0457591452,
0.0370123461,
0.0425699651,
0.0213949233,
-0.0287963841,
-0.0111056184,
0.0420833156,
-0.0139474841,
0.0035378004,
0.0179532096,
0.0203351937,
0.0251351893,
-0.0508211814,
0.027735319,
0.0139318053,
-0.0380486287,
0.0006214658,
-0.0599041395,
0.0535147414,
0.0676476434,
-0.0246905405,
0.0533836186,
-0.0620992482,
-0.0263281558,
-0.0277706049,
-0.0013636366,
-0.0042276122,
0.0034747594,
-0.0118399095,
0.0027744207,
-0.0429121107,
-0.0022175056,
0.0415108241,
0.0607574768,
0.0276039671,
0.0494966805,
-0.0706092566,
-0.043952994,
-0.0186853781,
0.0140491361,
0.006093007,
-0.0126967095,
0.0554294176,
-0.0071425689,
-0.0266754031,
-0.0002849528,
-0.0209595505,
0.0159738548,
-0.0178273935,
-0.0014262248,
0.069640778,
-0.0186126921,
-0.0058519393,
-0.0115441335,
0.0305808373,
-0.0357588753,
-0.0248678438,
-0.0046020346,
-6.122367635e-33,
0.0265961979,
-0.0598545447,
-0.0348402485,
0.0097071342,
-0.0314163528,
0.0325765498,
-0.0117952544,
-0.0279408358,
0.0116878115,
0.0430995598,
0.0054934369,
0.0614955798,
0.0262300018,
0.0378884897,
-0.0317103602,
-0.0227384605,
0.0645458624,
-0.0487946235,
-0.0144403894,
0.0263038725,
0.000550707,
0.0419751592,
0.0311812032,
-0.0563843325,
-0.0062288637,
-0.0562354065,
-0.0209995192,
0.0102101117,
0.0071629449,
0.0717651397,
-0.0471495688,
0.0361995362,
0.0398894027,
-0.0133923665,
0.0020522443,
0.1082471088,
-0.0110473428,
0.0263983719,
-0.0365155376,
0.0179299247,
-0.03741147,
-0.0356709622,
0.0518459044,
-0.0180226751,
-0.0235067103,
0.0198423509,
0.0488972478,
-0.0318299569,
0.0334916115,
-0.0704520419,
-0.0685141012,
0.0650858581,
0.0237727314,
0.007815605,
0.0704381242,
0.0335415937,
0.0012954946,
0.0699932501,
-0.0486092307,
0.0043688761,
0.014867519,
0.0357596166,
0.0096873539,
0.0245114118,
-0.0161746759,
0.0400660448,
0.0339289233,
0.0132483151,
-0.0325600542,
-0.0212160349,
0.0253571142,
-0.0064312564,
0.0708798617,
0.0733590499,
0.0717045963,
-0.0030217301,
-0.0800683796,
-0.0116512133,
0.0400579721,
-0.0132644884,
0.060178522,
-0.0139199058,
-0.0615025647,
0.0133649958,
0.0057404805,
-0.0652651787,
-0.02579589,
-0.0196324401,
0.0404486097,
0.0371115282,
-0.0122807622,
0.0010657957,
0.0164758395,
-0.0256035831,
-0.0016759655,
0.0303844102,
-0.0444764756,
0.0229313932,
-0.0029295781,
0.0455812998,
-0.0343914255,
-0.0247162841,
-0.0006086242,
0.0291471537,
-0.0076093874,
-0.0122172628,
0.0218763854,
-0.0010327009,
-0.0557926558,
0.0169719812,
0.0025741861,
0.0215234589,
0.0036271827,
0.0333862714,
0.0179541893,
-0.0548199043,
0.0008646732,
0.0559184328,
0.0249318536,
0.0245509986,
-0.0033165242,
-0.0242586434,
-0.0204428472,
0.0408565514,
-0.0364925005,
-0.0096955085,
-0.017842466,
0.0211116504,
0.0237155333,
-0.0785961449,
0.0211170893,
-0.0289818067,
2.464e-7,
0.0164031088,
0.0387613811,
0.0350719094,
-0.0517455079,
0.0209693722,
0.0491443761,
0.0181155521,
0.0323374756,
-0.0205757804,
0.0073587955,
0.0111081451,
0.023191778,
0.0720042661,
-0.0291828699,
-0.0738109276,
-0.0135566415,
-0.0510290712,
0.0172052328,
-0.0723513067,
-0.005493612,
0.0480855741,
0.0966574028,
0.0205902085,
-0.0287716817,
0.01265876,
-0.0562244505,
0.0418154895,
-0.0584176034,
0.0122704925,
0.0209977962,
0.0455574058,
0.0196040832,
-0.0256727487,
-0.0073792213,
0.0117168743,
0.0233359076,
0.0450438894,
0.0708450302,
0.0358843319,
0.0384992734,
0.0142039517,
0.0063388194,
-0.0038578508,
-0.037827123,
0.0507594161,
-0.057913173,
-0.0353352316,
-0.0255168751,
-0.0091667147,
-0.0864531696,
0.0408363529,
-0.0247890987,
-0.0155651784,
0.0041621197,
0.0167513806,
-0.0130356746,
-0.0220616944,
-0.0573646985,
0.0104576005,
0.0040692948,
-0.0717048049,
0.0193827562,
-0.0911016762,
0.0105036842,
0.0224981401,
-0.0448536612,
0.0358568132,
2.433516211e-34,
0.0330855288,
-0.0085380413,
-0.0322876871,
-0.0112711461,
0.0218310487,
0.0178980231,
-0.0105095571,
-0.0119459368,
0.0051955022,
-0.0506567098,
0.0353241339
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15402v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15402v1 | Learning Section Weights for Multi-Label Document Classification | 2023-11-26T19:56:19 | 2023-11-26T19:56:19 | Maziar Moradi Fard, Paula Sorrolla Bayod, Kiomars Motarjem, Mohammad Alian Nejadi, Saber Akhondi, Camilo Thorne | cs.CL | cs.CL | Multi-label document classification is a traditional task in NLP. Compared to
single-label classification, each document can be assigned multiple classes.
This problem is crucially important in various domains, such as tagging
scientific articles. Documents are often structured into several sections such
as abstract and title. Current approaches treat different sections equally for
multi-label classification. We argue that this is not a realistic assumption,
leading to sub-optimal results. Instead, we propose a new method called
Learning Section Weights (LSW), leveraging the contribution of each distinct
section for multi-label classification. Via multiple feed-forward layers, LSW
learns to assign weights to each section of, and incorporate the weights in the
prediction. We demonstrate our approach on scientific articles. Experimental
results on public (arXiv) and private (Elsevier) datasets confirm the
superiority of LSW, compared to state-of-the-art multi-label document
classification methods. In particular, LSW achieves a 1.3% improvement in terms
of macro averaged F1-score while it achieves 1.3% in terms of macro averaged
recall on the publicly available arXiv dataset. | [
0.0232497677,
0.0299172699,
0.0089780102,
-0.0292291362,
-0.0128775248,
0.0049587446,
0.0620826669,
0.0238892473,
0.0415580794,
-0.0432412364,
-0.0681730062,
-0.000292355,
-0.0187062584,
-0.021648841,
0.0020305463,
-0.0154648246,
0.0260693803,
0.0239835288,
0.0415990613,
0.0027283237,
0.0192623399,
-0.0097042145,
0.0127811832,
0.0096944887,
0.0101227816,
-0.0317107476,
0.03279965,
-0.0019908291,
0.02166133,
-0.0369456336,
0.0679039732,
0.0402639322,
0.0015958892,
0.0292506292,
0.0000016235,
-0.025342226,
-0.063884221,
0.0214332566,
0.0293276533,
0.0201512873,
0.0452960692,
-0.0366139337,
0.0439035334,
-0.0087736798,
-0.0060839653,
-0.0240797773,
0.0115794446,
0.1021740586,
0.0355714597,
0.0423259586,
-0.0209064614,
-0.0600741915,
0.0396146998,
-0.0080379099,
0.0288359746,
-0.0698201731,
0.0328275003,
0.0118351448,
-0.0200397838,
0.0505448654,
0.0027614241,
0.0196046066,
0.0192850996,
-0.003938661,
0.0209923852,
0.0228644107,
-0.076124683,
-0.0129320361,
0.0039856499,
0.0522194467,
-0.0317536332,
-0.0366687775,
0.0291060992,
-0.0166792721,
-0.0083452817,
0.0055673704,
-0.0334178731,
-0.0165432449,
-0.028426107,
-0.0187165346,
0.0473592356,
0.0160335433,
0.0116896415,
0.014256727,
0.0160237681,
0.0409742333,
-0.0047733821,
-0.0293178558,
0.0595196337,
0.0286084209,
-0.0279225167,
0.0131021831,
0.0636905059,
0.0343347788,
-0.0047856611,
0.0334954821,
-0.0292791408,
-0.0686297268,
0.0539552905,
-0.0769221559,
-0.0374476612,
-0.0187232159,
-0.010368078,
0.0538209565,
-0.0298753623,
-0.0315164775,
-0.0059649437,
0.0220184363,
0.0050176661,
-0.0064387606,
-0.0670107827,
-0.037878897,
-0.0392469056,
0.0750756115,
0.0461735204,
-0.0247432794,
-0.0377419181,
-0.0173347723,
-0.0304317567,
-0.0170775503,
0.0092109432,
-0.0209955201,
-0.0176704358,
0.0125707034,
0.0567431785,
0.0405684635,
-0.0192275792,
0.0175437145,
-0.0197093133,
0.0214293934,
0.0005764241,
0.0209829509,
-0.0232317019,
-0.0007284966,
0.0420193933,
-0.0290318951,
-0.0104041649,
-0.0287760254,
-0.0385840274,
-0.0615789853,
-0.0237739589,
-0.0493541062,
0.0392055847,
-0.0303454101,
0.0093057565,
-0.012312484,
0.0261243638,
-0.0022620722,
-0.0013424967,
0.0292449985,
-0.0362707712,
0.0440236777,
0.0211204607,
-0.0326346569,
0.0713241398,
0.0316176862,
-0.0026268545,
0.056677781,
-0.0122671667,
-0.004196676,
0.0289709046,
0.0064010704,
0.0274831839,
-0.0091643771,
0.04986763,
0.0230360329,
0.041574195,
-0.0309467074,
0.0137260677,
0.0112918057,
-0.0070534907,
-0.0042466004,
-0.0206368621,
-0.026378924,
0.0009435444,
0.0039313692,
0.0242911391,
-0.0220287647,
-0.0273905881,
-0.0061535314,
0.0180306453,
0.0122887939,
0.0353206471,
0.0385563485,
-0.0201363657,
-0.0039883018,
0.0559698567,
-0.0188132375,
-0.0369084664,
-0.0204485487,
-0.0043118424,
-0.0260373,
0.0048545436,
-0.0159724355,
0.0991506055,
0.0216025263,
0.0255700629,
0.0102297133,
0.059055686,
0.0010815607,
0.0194983445,
-0.025715204,
0.0006694244,
-0.046838358,
0.0316253379,
-0.0806173831,
-0.035505116,
0.0179338343,
0.0566140749,
-0.0212871693,
0.0641738176,
-0.0190459136,
-0.0029634996,
-0.0202179439,
0.0061073266,
-0.0051199328,
0.0121859638,
0.0365545116,
-0.0251730587,
0.0121437982,
0.0005605054,
-0.003884146,
-0.0372376144,
0.0393079408,
-0.0342015736,
-0.0034719347,
0.0356275849,
-0.0157260299,
0.0198089797,
0.028200645,
-0.0031904499,
0.0017952874,
0.0444762893,
-0.0054485169,
-0.0431061536,
-0.0663534552,
0.0253992379,
-0.0239181425,
0.044206962,
-0.0320673473,
-0.0024131059,
0.0189001244,
-0.0348879322,
-0.0346816741,
0.0265062023,
0.0074173617,
-0.0060034785,
0.0086161541,
-0.0206045955,
-0.0026593907,
0.0189950019,
-0.0418695807,
0.0143668279,
0.0170743037,
0.0911230668,
-0.0159008969,
-0.0352306962,
0.0420363843,
0.0148735689,
-0.0210401379,
-0.0213585775,
-0.0409722254,
0.0000354339,
0.0442761742,
0.010884786,
-0.0465626121,
-0.0119955894,
-0.0303313453,
0.0194759462,
-0.0137634464,
0.0035814673,
-0.0229639951,
-0.0342124961,
0.0346118659,
-0.0360702351,
-0.0459964834,
-0.0200699307,
-0.047083959,
0.0013642001,
0.0275631137,
-0.0220634993,
0.0109077655,
0.0106330933,
-0.043935474,
-0.0593327284,
0.0527602099,
0.0184175,
0.0026246179,
-0.0429939069,
-0.0573087595,
-0.0342905484,
-0.0154434377,
-0.0052056694,
0.014283306,
-0.0034439843,
-0.0239338223,
-0.0391619243,
0.0443510935,
0.01571781,
0.0228605904,
0.048358921,
0.0566909313,
-0.0327495746,
0.0096046999,
-0.05846579,
0.0504432805,
-0.0303121563,
0.0048560514,
0.0299834535,
0.0686843097,
-0.0083161481,
-0.0096171126,
-0.0127256671,
-0.0092426185,
-0.0292986464,
-0.0107522355,
-0.0012090448,
0.0006397256,
0.0223910939,
0.0132125933,
0.0436012037,
-0.0146323554,
0.069024235,
0.0030040706,
-0.0216164459,
-0.0721422434,
-0.0213243719,
-0.0821651146,
0.0346635543,
-0.0016711659,
0.0277991518,
0.0702994093,
-0.0093395663,
0.0078482199,
0.0383859761,
-0.0070475144,
-0.0270575006,
-0.0217438098,
-0.0048488039,
0.0124250874,
-0.0169595201,
-0.0121309897,
0.0488139428,
0.0012740175,
0.0131003745,
0.0425872505,
-0.0106729874,
-0.0023712281,
-0.0706908852,
0.0155544244,
0.0445447154,
0.0502368025,
-0.051537212,
-0.0247759409,
0.0141451415,
0.0434777103,
0.0515523702,
-0.0570370592,
-0.0140793957,
-0.0467082076,
-0.0377686247,
0.0203860831,
0.0111900885,
0.0495895818,
-0.0067874873,
-0.0100461245,
0.038685713,
-0.0805761069,
0.0076166303,
-0.0278521087,
0.0174195077,
-0.0269594491,
0.0101115303,
0.0654702485,
0.0575773828,
-0.0877189711,
-0.033237122,
-0.0079425387,
-0.0016662695,
0.0337715112,
0.0121711995,
-0.0270981602,
-0.0265577715,
-0.0091314036,
0.000534476,
0.0078770341,
-0.0091838073,
0.0120889256,
-0.0225292146,
0.0085677495,
-0.0051774764,
-0.1052601859,
-0.0068582925,
-0.109708868,
-0.0213011019,
-0.026465198,
-0.0353506655,
-0.0230827108,
0.013563755,
-0.0056913425,
0.0250214711,
-0.0812170282,
0.0150279934,
0.0265360232,
0.0076995436,
0.0089640412,
0.0013220981,
0.0304241162,
-0.0535027906,
-0.0341929272,
0.0505230427,
-0.0241813846,
-0.0653616264,
-0.0470150225,
0.0694526136,
-0.0235175099,
0.0220741201,
-0.0050539598,
0.0353813767,
-0.0576328672,
-0.0153756496,
0.0137578389,
0.0358967595,
-0.0097856428,
-0.0636683181,
-0.0887290016,
-0.0212385077,
-0.010467126,
0.0368097797,
-0.0368600786,
-0.0798069611,
-0.0217630956,
-0.0104629183,
0.0232143011,
-0.0090760682,
0.0176383015,
0.0238888953,
-0.0534027889,
-0.0339474566,
-0.0515074655,
-0.0185877699,
-0.0016538675,
0.0300805792,
-0.0297546647,
-0.0230427142,
0.0238546953,
-0.0249770135,
-0.0270442627,
-0.0288594738,
0.0054310546,
0.0055486215,
0.0166323297,
0.005109272,
0.1137411296,
-0.0129101463,
-0.0555979386,
0.0002679982,
-0.0165932458,
-0.0288847089,
-0.0233246181,
0.0075735305,
0.0080892891,
-0.0086672297,
-0.0098656537,
-0.0532133877,
0.0561963618,
0.0308052823,
-0.0069422531,
-0.0190937128,
0.0282075014,
-0.048032105,
-0.0195883904,
-0.0006116219,
-0.0320681296,
0.0507920124,
-0.0057618753,
0.0234824363,
-0.0082726842,
0.0141964545,
-0.0107001876,
0.0246270671,
0.065025121,
-0.0059714168,
0.0078237113,
-0.0099252984,
0.0208428875,
0.035391286,
-0.0325576514,
0.0044338331,
0.0183942746,
0.038734071,
-0.0217374396,
-0.017986048,
0.031581182,
0.0299187936,
0.0650040656,
0.00041994,
-0.019856235,
0.0160861555,
0.0153009528,
-0.0271859132,
-0.0078975083,
-0.034568876,
-0.0318311863,
0.0099987052,
0.0017198768,
0.0020610597,
0.0132619292,
0.0646634549,
0.0381874852,
-0.0242587384,
-0.0338241011,
-0.141546011,
0.0599277243,
-0.0283294469,
-0.0215048082,
0.0238502808,
0.0168834459,
0.0492763445,
-0.0257355161,
-0.0455244407,
-0.0283049103,
0.0095106009,
-0.0003097889,
0.0171317682,
0.0407714695,
0.0166338924,
-0.0104231946,
0.0024874513,
0.067307286,
0.0189010054,
-0.0113635892,
0.0116226776,
-0.0396278575,
-0.0223544072,
-0.0123216333,
0.0225544386,
0.0490480997,
-0.0099481689,
-0.0214173757,
-0.0081178527,
0.0394351371,
0.0493565761,
-0.0159314349,
0.0183367878,
0.0121643534,
0.0162285957,
0.0486332662,
0.0256882552,
-0.0327346548,
-0.058296755,
-0.0595736615,
-0.0249621738,
-0.0399288274,
0.0108064022,
-5.871495467e-33,
-0.0012758514,
-0.0189058464,
-0.0254547019,
0.0906251147,
0.0013299888,
0.0153328478,
-0.0356068462,
-0.0130456639,
-0.0156947505,
0.027187746,
-0.0176827237,
0.0206070784,
-0.011789985,
0.0410534516,
0.0681789517,
0.0081430553,
0.0144062899,
-0.0008151482,
-0.0022472318,
0.0741848424,
0.0132023487,
0.0213316549,
0.0665923953,
-0.0252114441,
0.0689534098,
0.0178925898,
-0.0349550322,
-0.0440823585,
0.0079737511,
0.0601221845,
-0.0128458617,
0.0149937952,
0.0588483028,
-0.0722480416,
0.022468945,
0.0144500798,
-0.0446766727,
-0.0361240469,
-0.0450463369,
0.0044853948,
-0.004254384,
0.0056240568,
0.0402532481,
0.0060332902,
0.0446416549,
-0.0716285184,
0.1085947976,
0.0059657036,
-0.053551361,
-0.1314022243,
-0.0230574347,
0.0185952242,
-0.0206901319,
0.0347439684,
0.0212724991,
0.0373380221,
-0.0121435979,
0.0941827148,
-0.0587273426,
0.0079443883,
-0.042156253,
0.019745715,
-0.0300019644,
-0.0041511389,
-0.000661795,
0.0025473766,
0.0299209245,
0.0280791167,
0.0314685106,
-0.008931784,
0.0447469205,
-0.0074624373,
0.0392487459,
-0.0071394453,
0.0939164534,
-0.0136868758,
-0.0949393585,
0.0219076928,
0.0204133336,
0.0015278165,
0.0356304906,
0.0198713895,
0.0331443101,
0.0166855045,
-0.0377424099,
-0.0299310591,
-0.0286434833,
-0.0024969652,
-0.0374051221,
0.0241093859,
0.0014313002,
0.0466700085,
-0.0058694459,
-0.0693143532,
-0.0794142932,
0.0122110611,
0.0023813769,
0.0568478964,
0.0068726516,
-0.0032705718,
-0.0467452407,
-0.0357623622,
0.0158225708,
-0.0393813811,
0.0264392402,
-0.0273309946,
0.1243251041,
-0.0043187812,
-0.0601020902,
-0.0255081821,
0.0309284497,
-0.0535827503,
0.0087163597,
0.1018929631,
-0.0035014909,
0.0099779479,
0.0065723076,
0.0500105508,
0.048605673,
0.0418234766,
-0.0218875837,
0.0026034841,
-0.0053951191,
0.0195449963,
-0.0248608552,
-0.0343540236,
-0.0009347203,
-0.0020293496,
0.0299928468,
-0.0523909628,
0.0021397551,
0.0084767416,
2.435e-7,
0.0450708717,
0.0552676842,
-0.0324155316,
-0.0056605078,
0.0164141636,
0.0276553798,
-0.0343916938,
0.0689733922,
-0.0297593977,
0.0072305161,
-0.0048461542,
-0.0350671671,
0.0325749628,
0.0286154728,
-0.0744131655,
-0.0381116271,
-0.0406120233,
-0.0403352454,
-0.0273883231,
0.0206298251,
0.0101090884,
0.0417864956,
0.0314568132,
-0.0236988124,
0.0092262821,
0.001519234,
0.057365559,
0.023297919,
0.0252409484,
0.0627947673,
0.0225188062,
0.0393644795,
-0.0237037968,
0.001054295,
-0.0538591854,
-0.0024915859,
0.0130842952,
0.064562276,
-0.0180223119,
-0.0257948376,
0.0567888916,
0.0193274971,
0.0309614316,
0.0045567774,
0.026848197,
-0.0630384237,
-0.0227743611,
-0.0354694054,
-0.0131780673,
-0.0194866806,
0.0562480949,
-0.0098097986,
0.0220354963,
0.0424142554,
-0.041194804,
-0.0078786183,
0.0141406804,
-0.0934973434,
-0.0211585294,
0.1018535271,
0.0145502584,
0.0079575451,
0.0231608413,
-0.0216430146,
0.01467227,
-0.0903383493,
-0.0222975723,
1.952949784e-34,
0.0719413906,
-0.0464409627,
-0.0354338177,
0.0203301236,
-0.0261406843,
-0.0278318785,
-0.0860665068,
0.0014789352,
-0.0168515425,
-0.0302682407,
0.0165708568
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03721v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03721v2 | Exploring the Robustness of Model-Graded Evaluations and Automated Interpretability | 2023-11-26T17:11:55 | 2023-12-08T11:16:39 | Simon Lermen, Ondřej Kvapil | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | There has been increasing interest in evaluations of language models for a
variety of risks and characteristics. Evaluations relying on natural language
understanding for grading can often be performed at scale by using other
language models. We test the robustness of these model-graded evaluations to
injections on different datasets including a new Deception Eval. These
injections resemble direct communication between the testee and the evaluator
to change their grading. We extrapolate that future, more intelligent models
might manipulate or cooperate with their evaluation model. We find significant
susceptibility to these injections in state-of-the-art commercial models on all
examined evaluations. Furthermore, similar injections can be used on automated
interpretability frameworks to produce misleading model-written explanations.
The results inspire future work and should caution against unqualified trust in
evaluations and automated interpretability. | [
0.0271904934,
0.074802883,
-0.0421007127,
0.0503023528,
-0.0238090288,
0.0164311901,
0.0305908211,
-0.0116873877,
-0.0117300954,
-0.0442189053,
-0.0312957391,
0.0049522649,
0.0266117826,
0.0833268389,
0.0462373346,
-0.0134373074,
0.0475854576,
-0.032903973,
0.0400761813,
0.0025487766,
-0.0096539455,
-0.0191792212,
0.0231196824,
0.0548407063,
0.0248998199,
-0.0130144088,
0.0131727662,
-0.0202041566,
0.0011463566,
-0.0137139726,
-0.028389819,
0.0687166601,
-0.0005562425,
0.0613942668,
0.0000018943,
-0.0402815528,
-0.0165415723,
0.0309057664,
-0.0951395854,
0.0373222381,
0.0504957624,
0.001145532,
0.0086034201,
0.0009658292,
-0.0389600657,
-0.0000317745,
0.0427041873,
-0.0002992626,
0.0698320121,
0.0499228947,
0.002121049,
0.0024616134,
0.0152035095,
-0.0114024207,
-0.0175063461,
-0.0398254357,
0.0249993894,
0.0231399108,
-0.0463173762,
0.0197862536,
-0.0306578279,
0.0193973556,
0.0181797855,
-0.0180187281,
-0.0038166591,
-0.0063670278,
-0.0020742407,
-0.0297630411,
-0.0165927336,
0.0314470194,
0.0015971282,
-0.0011927538,
-0.0344222561,
-0.0254868791,
0.0160401706,
0.0174743664,
-0.0012277786,
0.0251404494,
0.0253925584,
-0.0086638145,
0.0107542928,
0.033035934,
0.0487589613,
0.0102309994,
0.0255891979,
0.0647652224,
-0.0117089422,
-0.042282518,
0.0060641067,
-0.0059533822,
-0.000799777,
-0.0479883142,
-0.0174279436,
-0.0040281042,
-0.0265829246,
0.0382481031,
-0.0176955871,
0.0089912703,
0.0542205274,
-0.0535584427,
0.0672704279,
0.0103811333,
0.0127806272,
0.0241283476,
0.0060761841,
0.0931135118,
0.0196204241,
0.0527275242,
-0.0291040689,
0.0377991386,
-0.0321427099,
-0.0474567227,
0.0363947563,
-0.0106616663,
0.0012881735,
0.0327445641,
-0.0706290826,
-0.0250397231,
-0.0953041315,
0.0241098925,
-0.0103772292,
0.0010583862,
-0.0358806625,
0.0035251221,
-0.0524493344,
0.0017406696,
-0.007276678,
0.0472495258,
0.0034016545,
-0.0587628111,
-0.00015998,
-0.0036213652,
-0.0340049863,
0.012318423,
-0.0206606612,
0.0711366609,
0.028865261,
-0.011806801,
0.0134191569,
-0.0504056104,
-0.0627238527,
-0.0567608215,
-0.02889934,
-0.0374099016,
-0.0118379481,
-0.0043502771,
-0.0254671555,
-0.0704302639,
-0.0041663498,
0.0018392334,
-0.0554813519,
0.0671109632,
0.001694655,
0.0031410686,
-0.0291496739,
0.0319332331,
-0.0555110462,
0.061303921,
0.0237828456,
0.0406056792,
0.0290985238,
-0.045473963,
0.0736641288,
0.021468902,
0.0207586791,
0.025217358,
0.0033081851,
0.0006683639,
0.001046047,
-0.0131391259,
-0.0032093085,
0.0411061794,
-0.0069166361,
-0.010104863,
0.0665865615,
0.007085809,
0.0092148958,
0.0048631751,
0.0512380712,
0.0112365428,
0.0082116826,
0.0278572049,
-0.0795586556,
-0.0303485654,
-0.078549847,
-0.0066279555,
-0.0174538791,
-0.0032679455,
0.0256103631,
-0.0817142949,
-0.0051426929,
-0.0002119734,
0.0606030077,
0.0395981409,
0.0294732451,
0.0130212093,
-0.0250632707,
0.005197159,
0.0291791167,
-0.032167729,
-0.0000258494,
-0.0878063738,
-0.0056307018,
0.0866726115,
0.0373081304,
0.0151502648,
0.0355976336,
-0.0319813155,
-0.0465585701,
0.0027959752,
0.0373155512,
-0.0110658994,
0.0126872938,
0.0015361982,
-0.0384281985,
-0.0267652273,
0.0329668261,
0.015562118,
-0.0248494782,
-0.0123710223,
-0.0007356869,
-0.0448280647,
-0.0706699267,
0.0308022611,
-0.0006399851,
-0.0449461974,
-0.0392805785,
0.0059352452,
0.0220942311,
0.0001113762,
-0.0107817464,
0.0368673503,
0.0299448576,
0.0195768289,
-0.0106238434,
-0.0241117682,
-0.0063239257,
0.0104060136,
-0.007013964,
-0.0262951385,
-0.0178249106,
0.0220856499,
-0.0089873802,
0.0022896456,
0.0252635237,
-0.0353489704,
0.013984249,
-0.0119463122,
0.0314431787,
-0.0450413898,
0.0010805908,
-0.0299987067,
0.0335107073,
-0.020909559,
0.0466591939,
-0.0443737842,
-0.025186263,
-0.0015326805,
-0.0393893272,
-0.0336969756,
0.0113090929,
-0.0230465923,
0.0131838033,
0.0157162063,
-0.0008410902,
-0.0218165554,
-0.0280497372,
-0.0662090853,
-0.0455094762,
-0.0044221454,
0.011672304,
0.0160873681,
-0.0487229042,
0.0049027158,
0.0248507187,
-0.012080159,
-0.0448885411,
0.0250359178,
0.0170754418,
-0.0001650264,
0.0049598748,
-0.0363256857,
-0.009620985,
-0.0316852704,
-0.0552753471,
0.0925160572,
0.0424412899,
0.033260107,
-0.0598208718,
0.0086128749,
-0.0309195463,
-0.0100246668,
-0.0018817983,
-0.0544734895,
0.0182916988,
0.0448698029,
-0.0415820889,
0.0442579538,
0.004814642,
0.0769315511,
0.0495607816,
-0.0006666854,
-0.0533015653,
-0.0267368983,
0.0090697091,
-0.0207889881,
-0.0293255225,
-0.0981303677,
-0.0174486712,
0.0670511425,
0.0398465507,
-0.0060574054,
-0.0245610233,
0.0652406961,
-0.07784044,
-0.0798430592,
-0.0084107639,
-0.0562115535,
-0.0242149476,
0.059605211,
0.0077932668,
-0.071743302,
0.0976105034,
-0.0376636051,
0.0027707878,
-0.0367568992,
-0.0044568018,
0.0092154108,
0.0679278523,
-0.0120320693,
0.0052923607,
0.0461912751,
0.0029639036,
-0.0145869171,
-0.0497308001,
0.041701518,
-0.0392123647,
0.0325617418,
-0.0604801662,
-0.010833961,
0.0307071246,
-0.0255128071,
-0.0437338501,
-0.0497976504,
-0.0118906638,
0.0125346454,
0.0365828536,
-0.0021061311,
-0.0169941373,
-0.0125156073,
0.0137240896,
-0.0218897704,
-0.0382792801,
0.0003158028,
-0.0084374221,
-0.0213634111,
0.0349132307,
-0.0115773212,
0.0554056577,
-0.0282297935,
0.025321858,
0.0342980847,
-0.0156268924,
0.0215035994,
-0.0073008877,
0.0324143246,
0.0088197552,
0.0083592394,
0.0015359999,
0.0503334925,
0.0112938825,
-0.0731113106,
-0.0090262042,
0.0665043667,
0.0119245052,
0.0204595141,
0.0317508839,
-0.0110154515,
0.0081675835,
0.003144227,
-0.0001363234,
-0.0868947878,
-0.0049052387,
0.0136239557,
0.0560325421,
-0.0469346382,
-0.0233679079,
-0.0025259987,
-0.0730175674,
0.0563082173,
0.0050516329,
-0.0407437049,
-0.0216240957,
-0.0422576666,
-0.0371782482,
-0.0351334587,
0.04068565,
0.0178033412,
0.0212768484,
0.006185547,
0.0033054245,
-0.0412908457,
-0.0501766875,
0.0701498464,
0.0117142349,
0.0751241446,
0.0535268895,
0.0032962793,
-0.0354017243,
-0.0497323498,
0.0009176852,
0.000791055,
-0.0252345297,
0.0065949447,
0.0536141954,
0.0087509053,
-0.0143917836,
-0.0192332715,
-0.0097663682,
0.0164321028,
-0.0028306218,
-0.0089944601,
0.0540823787,
-0.0031987943,
-0.0577453673,
-0.0035850196,
0.0120087983,
0.0347820371,
0.0921016783,
0.0407792889,
-0.0287864096,
-0.0337303579,
-0.0841814205,
0.0054631489,
-0.0122874426,
-0.0778402388,
0.0568940789,
0.0217787847,
-0.0597727373,
-0.0378124453,
-0.0652510449,
0.0006356807,
0.0063725105,
0.0257644653,
-0.0107657583,
0.00744431,
0.0110712359,
-0.0153897312,
0.0381861739,
-0.0070857108,
0.033540871,
-0.0371698588,
0.0021273962,
-0.0105311926,
-0.0155969234,
-0.0374986082,
0.0295445044,
-0.0141361849,
-0.0318322256,
0.0625583008,
0.0645982623,
0.0391367525,
0.0246693064,
-0.0112211751,
-0.0292135775,
0.0337752029,
-0.0423621498,
-0.0483693853,
0.0148026021,
0.0615977086,
-0.0057160393,
0.0068278355,
0.0251215752,
-0.028290702,
0.0126546621,
0.0212542005,
0.0170255043,
-0.0421535708,
-0.0077225007,
0.0335716084,
0.0325365514,
0.0408173949,
-0.0080588534,
0.0157958567,
-0.0016963619,
-0.0076486967,
-0.0434961617,
-0.0373917297,
-0.037847694,
-0.0122341691,
0.0171901584,
0.0105099753,
-0.0037357134,
-0.0337077864,
-0.0651366562,
0.0213142522,
-0.0039223642,
0.0359838344,
0.0385470577,
0.0325285196,
0.0039292369,
0.0063226395,
-0.0223876648,
0.0153650483,
-0.0241985153,
0.043738611,
0.0336168781,
0.0456561036,
0.0013308853,
-0.002682647,
-0.0091500813,
0.0315822139,
-0.0497200117,
-0.0223778486,
-0.0049193115,
0.0024407627,
-0.0326885842,
0.0352802947,
0.0259597208,
-0.008273948,
0.0083681177,
-0.034337081,
-0.0051554395,
0.0024310444,
-0.0594136901,
0.0666291043,
0.014394599,
-0.0264842957,
-0.0104703922,
0.0627807379,
0.0276081823,
0.0306172799,
-0.0578434169,
-0.028320821,
-0.0332638696,
-0.0406148434,
0.0321892649,
0.0061172601,
-0.0092553943,
-0.0403394885,
-0.1065720543,
-0.0890385807,
-0.0114839114,
0.041303169,
0.0447519757,
-0.0370363407,
-0.0213124231,
0.0749048218,
-0.0061242399,
-0.009117282,
-0.0612642542,
0.0216501802,
0.0361782089,
0.0136218164,
-0.0153435161,
-5.913009887e-33,
-0.0007694027,
-0.0508464761,
-0.0201472454,
-0.0155057255,
0.0276693143,
0.0294253156,
-0.0258934759,
0.0288730506,
-0.0269351006,
0.0443228669,
0.0172070097,
-0.0056123426,
0.0126797631,
-0.0045940736,
0.0142995697,
-0.0379143916,
0.018975893,
0.0031364709,
-0.0263390504,
-0.0089659961,
0.0057820925,
-0.009637353,
0.0590470023,
-0.0872564837,
0.1437052041,
0.0121288523,
-0.0571363084,
-0.0156222889,
-0.0663392842,
0.0647164434,
-0.0028872511,
0.0406438559,
0.0164228044,
-0.0600768887,
-0.005749038,
-0.0007283111,
-0.0221793689,
-0.0082025109,
0.0594278909,
0.0003882944,
-0.0292428229,
-0.0308756214,
0.0713824928,
-0.0286649074,
-0.0670672059,
-0.0025498057,
0.0117127663,
-0.0437185504,
0.0026123475,
-0.0096841902,
-0.0442561433,
0.0149707338,
-0.0263917465,
-0.0054340051,
-0.0007676093,
0.0444322303,
0.0004130947,
0.014593197,
-0.0367209539,
0.0240592901,
0.0474686325,
-0.0022227017,
0.0724440888,
-0.0115701184,
-0.0238241423,
0.0714183673,
0.0049803131,
0.0184781458,
-0.0150647946,
-0.0330275334,
0.0512759462,
0.028177686,
0.0898351297,
0.0516585037,
-0.0012755955,
-0.0092089726,
-0.0571695827,
0.0082897795,
-0.0097184423,
0.0172411017,
0.0193079598,
-0.015048706,
-0.1065950096,
-0.0554036461,
-0.0686490908,
-0.0217951424,
-0.0382386185,
-0.0208470952,
0.0450447835,
-0.0264190454,
-0.0326580517,
0.0022762122,
0.0084527768,
-0.068565473,
-0.0085729491,
0.0000890086,
0.0100356201,
0.0067385882,
0.0096539268,
0.0189091172,
-0.0017030577,
0.0250765476,
0.008360778,
0.0184654687,
0.0559860133,
-0.0063282247,
0.0239127129,
-0.0008283371,
-0.0293535367,
0.0089569967,
-0.0140370866,
-0.0137710935,
0.0279252436,
-0.0092134215,
0.0491619669,
-0.0022352044,
-0.0223422591,
0.0023174461,
0.0165533982,
0.0436535068,
-0.0382896923,
0.0383327827,
-0.0244698096,
0.0398414247,
-0.0365028828,
-0.0245393459,
-0.0035224983,
0.0019238177,
0.0344547406,
-0.0236466117,
-0.0021847337,
-0.0087954849,
2.603e-7,
0.0687285215,
0.062038403,
-0.0344736278,
0.0137964394,
0.005602363,
0.0788825601,
-0.02680411,
0.0141617944,
0.0690888688,
-0.0094795767,
0.0067237052,
-0.009987914,
0.0421196371,
0.0196237788,
-0.0035798829,
0.0009009974,
-0.035603147,
-0.0097929556,
-0.0256130081,
0.022300411,
0.0844104886,
0.0841897875,
0.0254198536,
0.0106867757,
-0.0172566716,
-0.0313704126,
0.0021766848,
-0.0380846001,
-0.0098817879,
-0.0014055726,
0.0486551486,
-0.0086980108,
0.0266500711,
0.0629749969,
-0.0070346729,
0.0008590882,
0.0046650628,
0.0622128434,
-0.0151056256,
-0.0124632837,
-0.0452827737,
-0.0731545389,
0.0067029204,
-0.0833993554,
0.049430389,
-0.0346388109,
-0.0388934724,
-0.0273692384,
-0.0338732414,
-0.0139161944,
0.0563282222,
0.0068981373,
-0.0264326632,
0.0155880069,
0.0032227598,
0.0103789698,
0.0271935947,
0.0057830825,
-0.0198586527,
-0.0065094912,
-0.0031516613,
-0.0580048487,
-0.0039214627,
0.0135454359,
0.0042701741,
-0.1018746495,
0.0120116835,
2.52717005e-34,
0.0508600883,
-0.0093805837,
0.0400412939,
-0.0298855137,
0.073750779,
0.0354519412,
0.0246277004,
0.0216801595,
0.0150236133,
-0.0475150347,
-0.0247184504
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15316v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15316v2 | Sibyl: Sensible Empathetic Dialogue Generation with Visionary Commonsense Knowledge | 2023-11-26T14:35:23 | 2024-05-30T06:18:20 | Lanrui Wang, Jiangnan Li, Chenxu Yang, Zheng Lin, Hongyin Tang, Huan Liu, Xiaolei Huang, Yanan Cao, Jingang Wang, Weiping Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recently, there has been a heightened interest in building chatbots based on
Large Language Models (LLMs) to emulate human-like qualities in dialogues,
including expressing empathy and offering emotional support. Despite having
access to commonsense knowledge to better understand the psychological aspects
and causality of dialogue context, even these powerful LLMs struggle to achieve
the goals of empathy and emotional support. As current approaches do not
adequately anticipate dialogue future, they may mislead language models to
ignore complex dialogue goals of empathy and emotional support, resulting in
unsupportive responses lacking empathy. To address this issue, we present an
innovative framework named Sensible Empathetic Dialogue Generation with
Visionary Commonsense Knowledge (Sibyl). Designed to concentrate on the
imminent dialogue future, this paradigm directs LLMs toward the implicit
requirements of the conversation, aiming to provide more sensible responses.
Experimental results demonstrate that incorporating our paradigm for acquiring
commonsense knowledge into LLMs comprehensively enhances the quality of their
responses. | [
0.079138048,
0.0509711727,
-0.0405357517,
-0.0009130568,
-0.0177627131,
0.0132359108,
-0.0167113729,
-0.0205991995,
0.048199933,
-0.023571372,
-0.0020779388,
0.0229637288,
-0.0080558052,
0.0193589889,
-0.0038673365,
-0.0761015192,
0.0208286699,
0.0296590589,
0.0366661288,
-0.0277364086,
0.0199016817,
0.0466474332,
-0.0071185022,
0.0608785711,
-0.0520342924,
-0.0107313627,
-0.0348117389,
0.0344667807,
0.0137019502,
-0.0041357884,
0.0224834811,
0.0132544553,
0.0145955617,
0.0051909285,
0.0000019979,
-0.0203187559,
0.0468824059,
-0.0296662413,
0.0261482075,
-0.0442794673,
0.061386358,
-0.0424195454,
0.0058035553,
0.0228654668,
-0.0425478965,
0.0169390105,
0.0176053047,
0.0608811677,
0.0658957735,
0.0578610785,
-0.0160034895,
0.0042461897,
0.010061265,
-0.0057493942,
-0.0028270006,
-0.0241181608,
-0.0085140653,
0.0363575481,
0.0290030353,
-0.0122472206,
-0.0065444442,
0.0393410511,
0.0240578875,
-0.038229458,
0.003151309,
0.0268577654,
-0.0239816122,
-0.0506524779,
-0.0352173336,
0.0990392193,
0.0297230259,
0.0048737288,
0.0159505252,
-0.0098012155,
0.0326144248,
-0.0095527712,
-0.050015837,
0.0361005515,
0.0093411636,
0.0037499194,
0.0170849264,
0.0029867366,
-0.0128198005,
0.0567345433,
0.0124601759,
0.0088139595,
-0.0217988901,
0.0071486617,
-0.0092182914,
0.0015706243,
-0.0317414403,
-0.0494941436,
0.0011190805,
0.0639910176,
-0.0517917722,
0.0345590189,
-0.042844411,
0.0428343341,
0.0076072821,
-0.0377695151,
-0.0145104108,
0.0459418297,
0.0132507626,
0.010562323,
0.0028884835,
0.0238994397,
0.0208899695,
0.0156869423,
-0.0159425754,
-0.0041841641,
-0.0296097286,
-0.0236268211,
-0.0424480438,
0.0278864801,
-0.0611893237,
-0.0318943039,
-0.0127478056,
0.0503486358,
-0.011403528,
0.0137922289,
-0.017882945,
0.0095446147,
-0.0453563258,
-0.0240364466,
-0.0275791697,
0.025010163,
-0.0650964081,
0.016057875,
0.0575915538,
-0.0639390275,
-0.0094256513,
0.0413237102,
-0.0098079918,
-0.0140458187,
-0.0031429573,
0.0317630768,
-0.0181130264,
-0.004817639,
-0.0235970933,
-0.0222393014,
-0.0047401558,
-0.0421933271,
-0.0221511461,
-0.0128243398,
0.0327148847,
-0.0047598723,
-0.0117184222,
-0.0000593669,
0.0389629379,
0.004524034,
-0.048233781,
0.0409933701,
-0.0251679718,
0.0284276679,
0.0222924724,
0.0315589979,
-0.0011758892,
0.0387162827,
0.0098865507,
0.0074446937,
0.0230813362,
0.0137894927,
0.0020436991,
0.0008921438,
-0.0250283312,
-0.013788552,
-0.0155574074,
-0.0136215705,
-0.0454624668,
0.060563039,
0.0526641198,
0.0408937521,
-0.0293961708,
-0.0015578795,
0.083327584,
0.0658860281,
-0.044573281,
0.0903207436,
0.0213467125,
0.0256970432,
0.0078001651,
0.0122352745,
-0.0290815644,
0.0516791604,
-0.0150633203,
-0.0251054019,
-0.0208966974,
-0.0170726534,
-0.0312429946,
-0.0218353532,
0.0183845758,
-0.0186554156,
0.0480758809,
0.0012553211,
-0.0062525454,
0.0017545298,
-0.0172877163,
0.026438104,
0.013781786,
-0.0698058456,
-0.020255981,
-0.038626045,
0.0063137971,
0.0682424828,
0.0690176114,
-0.0182783343,
-0.0647418872,
0.0086375754,
-0.0341964737,
0.0882092044,
0.0605977476,
-0.0289864521,
0.0159003753,
-0.0495323502,
0.0181445424,
0.0076520429,
-0.0119576473,
-0.0055916496,
-0.0115736425,
0.0276429821,
0.0003834856,
0.0038412015,
0.0195719041,
0.0300936494,
-0.053501647,
0.0218122527,
-0.0222067144,
-0.0151885767,
0.0251178108,
0.0053761289,
0.0026824127,
-0.0085283918,
0.0143808182,
-0.0223337412,
-0.0477891415,
0.0987899303,
-0.0708614513,
-0.047767818,
0.042384889,
-0.0142129445,
-0.0044468227,
0.0450890064,
0.0096944673,
-0.0129860844,
0.0189394765,
-0.0477230549,
0.0389288366,
-0.0659810752,
0.0178703535,
-0.0257059392,
-0.0042052423,
0.0081341332,
0.0263906028,
-0.0134194568,
-0.0394039266,
0.0251810923,
-0.0035196824,
-0.0249366239,
-0.0280091204,
-0.0001051438,
0.027421413,
0.0221624766,
0.0063371062,
0.0279437173,
0.0327188931,
-0.0513893925,
-0.0450250208,
-0.118818529,
-0.0191050712,
-0.0003886885,
-0.0351857096,
0.0019025491,
0.0065444657,
-0.0113288667,
0.0094744656,
-0.0632871091,
0.0596190505,
0.0384286046,
-0.006760858,
0.0351911709,
0.0083344607,
-0.0019461047,
-0.029515963,
0.0365586281,
-0.0011212388,
-0.0138151255,
0.0058815442,
0.025249036,
-0.0434701592,
0.0243994836,
-0.0626559779,
0.0195935536,
-0.0189418811,
-0.0982521772,
0.0216806661,
0.0001483791,
-0.0031671084,
0.0754198879,
0.0612415001,
0.0568207502,
-0.0151321441,
-0.0053547188,
-0.0744940713,
0.0434507057,
-0.0188681036,
0.0226626545,
-0.0440497361,
-0.0168379061,
-0.006738463,
0.0270786695,
-0.006651239,
0.0321286917,
-0.0950690582,
0.0160466861,
0.0234034527,
-0.0797436461,
-0.0143521745,
0.0073452601,
-0.0146219721,
-0.0095963543,
-0.014031007,
-0.0326167718,
0.0829434767,
0.0167541504,
-0.0150372917,
-0.0370521173,
-0.0023708113,
-0.0105805555,
0.0543439202,
-0.056400694,
0.0292518903,
-0.0130071249,
-0.0130267739,
-0.0563613959,
-0.0195863862,
-0.0108189685,
-0.0463083647,
0.0159889814,
-0.0401502997,
-0.0123679265,
0.0341874808,
-0.0446113907,
-0.0540465415,
-0.0581644848,
-0.0089563364,
0.0238653049,
0.0300586838,
-0.0224665496,
-0.0470370874,
-0.0145029323,
0.041547019,
0.0356084704,
-0.0168156531,
-0.0373619422,
-0.020226514,
0.0004036588,
0.0558969527,
0.034067031,
0.0560373552,
-0.0024630316,
0.086099796,
0.0595197417,
0.0300332382,
0.0021606623,
0.0255217217,
0.0056524277,
0.0202059019,
0.0188525468,
0.0120413508,
-0.0079104574,
0.0778193772,
-0.0146409757,
-0.0340510979,
0.120530948,
0.030350633,
-0.0282956921,
0.0318637788,
-0.0609854572,
0.0271913763,
-0.002565773,
0.0114892907,
-0.0345903076,
-0.0256603751,
0.000991425,
0.027218163,
-0.0484161861,
-0.0733511075,
0.0140288528,
-0.0821633264,
0.021324167,
0.0094522862,
-0.0101534138,
-0.0346118212,
0.0089206472,
-0.0006533764,
0.0408732146,
0.0345207527,
0.0017912423,
0.0206241906,
-0.0256392267,
-0.0060342583,
0.0004177997,
-0.0163686145,
0.0249835178,
-0.0210926849,
0.1036713794,
0.0379974544,
0.1051959619,
0.0171389151,
0.0008862244,
-0.0263424162,
-0.0016275563,
0.0221776199,
-0.0196872894,
-0.006762377,
-0.0210973341,
-0.0152850412,
-0.0366474576,
0.0751561522,
-0.0356351212,
-0.0212772507,
0.0187320877,
0.0357173607,
-0.0483200215,
-0.0195892323,
-0.0143795917,
0.0473258533,
0.0335056707,
0.0788147449,
0.0415315963,
-0.0527524948,
-0.0178490262,
-0.0000228646,
-0.0006552943,
0.018353546,
-0.0273833554,
0.0094917258,
0.020598188,
-0.0054896018,
-0.0840836838,
-0.0769524351,
0.0095030526,
0.0097915772,
-0.0107823741,
-0.0393133163,
0.0135418028,
0.010933538,
-0.0212116763,
0.021198744,
-0.024786694,
-0.006837076,
-0.0101971636,
0.0124104088,
0.0165872518,
-0.0512752198,
0.0079729473,
0.0287058689,
0.0117828902,
-0.055726137,
-0.0213812348,
0.0547061339,
0.0183882583,
0.0126608228,
0.00419578,
-0.057218492,
0.0219052732,
0.0503789783,
-0.0286969282,
0.016279472,
0.018746445,
0.0683021843,
0.0064710821,
0.0696300864,
-0.0117151681,
0.0190637633,
-0.0040521305,
0.0645765886,
0.0040749786,
-0.054558523,
0.013133998,
0.0364136957,
-0.0334151685,
0.0015860903,
0.0120218638,
-0.0105281863,
-0.0262650792,
-0.0528721549,
-0.0123427771,
-0.0631464943,
0.0079623377,
-0.0114384834,
0.0247440375,
-0.0165773854,
-0.0393369868,
-0.0514698215,
0.0098178154,
-0.0169932134,
-0.0105058979,
-0.0222624298,
0.0059643392,
0.0021880162,
-0.0181619711,
-0.0218825247,
-0.0049990015,
-0.0441153124,
0.0221119504,
-0.0024310586,
0.1261270195,
0.0165087096,
-0.0551846176,
0.0132271871,
0.032352034,
-0.0305796675,
-0.059155494,
0.0201620813,
0.0856317356,
0.0178877413,
0.0384787172,
0.047984343,
-0.0863192976,
0.0067234058,
0.002159622,
0.0567699783,
0.0152761061,
-0.0496565141,
-0.0060793296,
0.0140105132,
-0.0354072936,
-0.0097810375,
0.0194746219,
-0.0849898607,
0.0380663387,
-0.0124663617,
-0.002882858,
-0.0307416134,
-0.0275291055,
0.0549226105,
-0.0047808113,
-0.0001823667,
0.0461591445,
-0.081763871,
-0.0364724137,
0.0110634668,
0.0060459697,
-0.008235503,
-0.0461292565,
-0.0014634382,
0.0347619839,
-0.0288949758,
0.0003688031,
-0.0382973775,
0.0574591011,
-0.1125810817,
0.0076194946,
-0.0318596698,
-6.038417869e-33,
-0.0212818664,
-0.0256413277,
-0.0171921514,
-0.0243505575,
-0.072341986,
0.0000307485,
-0.0566723906,
0.0102009028,
-0.0093728341,
0.0424833149,
-0.0257778745,
0.051525794,
-0.0115924058,
0.0004761564,
-0.0081066396,
-0.007261028,
0.0228912197,
0.0071257656,
-0.0352230556,
0.0549004376,
0.0244930089,
0.0231914688,
0.0034189594,
-0.0390000492,
-0.0039284392,
-0.0052054729,
-0.0165927038,
0.03385555,
0.0295010041,
0.0298105851,
-0.0042463718,
0.0547993518,
0.0187656805,
0.0046131462,
-0.0039055855,
0.0535335764,
-0.0171606876,
-0.0069073606,
0.0240441132,
0.0019286675,
-0.0458549932,
-0.0257669631,
0.0075486414,
-0.0130564133,
-0.0106299696,
-0.0063686492,
-0.0138325384,
-0.0273269843,
0.0135424519,
-0.0155365383,
-0.0507251769,
-0.0135551728,
-0.032566227,
-0.0593749397,
-0.037993595,
0.0314476453,
-0.0102634476,
0.0054113101,
-0.0019528826,
0.0097607514,
-0.0391872078,
-0.038649004,
0.0236974992,
-0.0224571116,
0.0420134328,
0.0872336254,
-0.0215527918,
0.0308806691,
-0.0312588811,
0.0241621863,
0.0309811588,
0.0200841073,
0.0155165466,
0.087676093,
-0.0578627735,
-0.0402564965,
-0.0182857197,
0.0283217691,
0.0615942813,
0.0478174351,
0.0379085205,
-0.0052917325,
-0.0402513891,
0.0188975595,
-0.0333635621,
-0.0289249178,
-0.0071061659,
-0.0073830127,
0.0102578113,
-0.0030467722,
-0.0319470353,
-0.0580050685,
-0.0044978675,
-0.0382419862,
0.0405924879,
0.0337251052,
-0.0603233352,
0.0153058087,
-0.0163459759,
0.0283207484,
0.0007105751,
-0.0366077051,
0.0494364202,
-0.0116806068,
0.0243386719,
0.0410571843,
-0.0224180948,
0.0089830784,
-0.001134994,
-0.0240528062,
-0.0324968994,
0.0742208064,
-0.0313346311,
-0.0350901745,
-0.0009641912,
0.0127462046,
-0.0246886313,
-0.0039785975,
0.006488353,
-0.0035621217,
-0.0193381384,
0.0090170056,
0.0216941666,
0.0104825357,
-0.068183966,
0.0047995844,
-0.0279540736,
-0.0564102866,
0.0204989873,
-0.0432978049,
-0.0344248749,
0.0009318722,
2.68e-7,
-0.0531513877,
0.0363061652,
0.0097712697,
0.0065553589,
0.024346495,
0.0717809498,
0.0107416138,
0.0600078851,
0.0115166623,
-0.0455984287,
0.0416939333,
0.0363478921,
0.0907509252,
-0.0072857616,
-0.0910289735,
-0.0055768746,
-0.047485128,
-0.030429855,
-0.0312453005,
0.0075528645,
0.0759734586,
0.0314213485,
0.0159847122,
-0.0194483958,
0.0317312069,
0.0021938405,
0.054300908,
-0.0600955412,
-0.0191054791,
0.0164218396,
-0.0092928465,
-0.0079692854,
0.0173116736,
0.002224986,
0.0341411866,
0.0285935644,
0.0047740545,
0.1031054705,
-0.0110493321,
-0.0773172006,
0.0312488358,
0.0043045059,
-0.0009456879,
-0.0514645316,
0.0205401555,
-0.1009095162,
-0.0396744721,
-0.0381364785,
0.0049244533,
-0.0127634304,
-0.0161732417,
-0.0405017585,
-0.0446078628,
0.0555763058,
0.0177520718,
-0.0003100132,
0.021428274,
-0.0431106165,
0.0220182166,
-0.0254970305,
-0.0650566444,
-0.0825547725,
-0.0350063443,
-0.0072691916,
-0.0110657485,
-0.0427337363,
0.020598039,
2.105433442e-34,
-0.0134940231,
0.0188744087,
-0.00793056,
0.0415080711,
0.0546020158,
0.0205028057,
0.0205712449,
0.0284139626,
0.0405177809,
-0.0495756045,
-0.004228292
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15296v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15296v3 | UHGEval: Benchmarking the Hallucination of Chinese Large Language Models via Unconstrained Generation | 2023-11-26T13:42:56 | 2024-05-24T03:29:14 | Xun Liang, Shichao Song, Simin Niu, Zhiyu Li, Feiyu Xiong, Bo Tang, Yezhaohui Wang, Dawei He, Peng Cheng, Zhonghao Wang, Haiying Deng | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have emerged as pivotal contributors in
contemporary natural language processing and are increasingly being applied
across a diverse range of industries. However, these large-scale probabilistic
statistical models cannot currently ensure the requisite quality in
professional content generation. These models often produce hallucinated text,
compromising their practical utility in professional contexts. To assess the
authentic reliability of LLMs in text generation, numerous initiatives have
developed benchmark evaluations for hallucination phenomena. Nevertheless,
these benchmarks frequently utilize constrained generation techniques due to
cost and temporal constraints. These techniques encompass the use of directed
hallucination induction and strategies that deliberately alter authentic text
to produce hallucinations. These approaches are not congruent with the
unrestricted text generation demanded by real-world applications. Furthermore,
a well-established Chinese-language dataset dedicated to the evaluation of
hallucinations in text generation is presently lacking. Consequently, we have
developed an Unconstrained Hallucination Generation Evaluation (UHGEval)
benchmark, designed to compile outputs produced with minimal restrictions by
LLMs. Concurrently, we have established a comprehensive benchmark evaluation
framework to aid subsequent researchers in undertaking scalable and
reproducible experiments. We have also executed extensive experiments,
evaluating prominent Chinese language models and the GPT series models to
derive professional performance insights regarding hallucination challenges. | [
0.005674534,
0.0463383272,
-0.0047100838,
0.0241836309,
-0.0527095832,
-0.0004373519,
0.0084258094,
0.0186178721,
-0.0014911717,
-0.0356057249,
0.0156496,
-0.0916030705,
0.0149921738,
0.0021269126,
0.0307148136,
-0.0666694492,
0.0287075303,
-0.0313380919,
-0.0351887569,
-0.0014327917,
0.016443355,
0.0005829505,
-0.0077419635,
0.0514638759,
-0.0142125776,
-0.0337721445,
0.0074362247,
0.0270311031,
0.0166073758,
0.0053141126,
-0.0304087307,
0.0849721432,
-0.0237418357,
0.0812956691,
0.0000021195,
-0.0587119311,
-0.0244412925,
-0.0031932085,
0.0249101017,
0.0568911918,
0.0560120679,
-0.0005672368,
-0.0459097289,
0.0144475447,
-0.020213237,
0.0259004906,
0.0386702083,
0.0742115453,
0.0509920642,
0.0581924915,
-0.0171454903,
-0.050052695,
0.0384893119,
-0.013650924,
0.0187680312,
0.0255809929,
0.0260757003,
0.0359585024,
-0.01393924,
-0.0385812409,
-0.0107061472,
0.0017443865,
0.026289722,
-0.0026399503,
-0.0081591187,
0.033740364,
-0.0860539973,
0.0003237129,
0.0073233172,
0.0523465872,
-0.0277078878,
-0.0399879813,
0.0257765912,
-0.0088708373,
-0.0188049134,
-0.010718571,
-0.0321481787,
0.0501707606,
-0.0240295641,
0.0254003033,
0.0460519046,
0.0093733957,
0.0261964034,
0.0202671848,
-0.0299406089,
0.0250871684,
0.037976753,
-0.0402587913,
0.0272707865,
-0.0089258524,
-0.0240716301,
-0.0463107564,
0.0158409793,
0.0047298344,
-0.0330442563,
-0.0009113728,
-0.0491176471,
-0.0155163892,
0.0410801247,
-0.0730837286,
0.0326091498,
0.0082006883,
-0.0145267621,
0.0242241565,
-0.027325945,
0.0369094536,
-0.0389709324,
0.0187970176,
-0.0262993537,
0.0421313457,
-0.0377201214,
-0.0216206536,
-0.054313194,
0.0058808569,
-0.0274496563,
-0.0460517481,
-0.0665043965,
-0.0233842153,
-0.0295012817,
0.0057191094,
-0.0251075868,
0.0099901352,
-0.0205987357,
-0.0195555966,
0.0158497989,
-0.0090367142,
-0.0353441797,
-0.0245302115,
0.030285703,
-0.0592412688,
-0.007228666,
0.0465314649,
-0.0112424092,
0.0091334675,
-0.0204022489,
0.0357109159,
0.0132157812,
0.0149181895,
-0.0175750367,
-0.0481206104,
-0.0231390502,
-0.0746222138,
0.0209870171,
-0.0650385618,
-0.0050616711,
-0.0101921204,
-0.0037190344,
-0.017534446,
0.0441932231,
0.0154783186,
-0.009565712,
0.0346233249,
-0.0388206616,
-0.000256654,
0.0261990987,
0.0419465937,
-0.0095225498,
0.0630638525,
0.0265728347,
0.0505857989,
0.0130859744,
-0.0275778193,
0.0659781769,
0.0343590714,
-0.0171505939,
0.0118410354,
-0.0680243596,
-0.0386225358,
0.0347022004,
0.0335392728,
0.0108511196,
0.0842958689,
-0.0460087433,
0.0326123498,
0.0571313351,
-0.0013008049,
-0.0091773476,
0.0203924589,
0.0362339318,
0.0029294069,
0.0137575809,
0.0547468401,
-0.0121394265,
0.0019327175,
-0.0285098329,
0.0518649705,
0.0744536743,
0.0044745607,
-0.0057641007,
-0.0430067293,
-0.0095963888,
0.0182754509,
-0.0040387842,
-0.0419428013,
0.0304768961,
0.0239540469,
-0.083868362,
0.033743605,
0.0359249264,
-0.0701407567,
0.0171774663,
-0.0253055599,
-0.0150163267,
0.1308536828,
0.0723528191,
-0.0080642216,
0.0586462244,
-0.0156471133,
0.0210050941,
0.097604759,
0.0244998187,
0.0239572264,
-0.0207823329,
-0.0640348196,
0.0197078213,
0.0045865825,
0.039479401,
0.0087107075,
-0.0119544454,
0.0226443168,
0.0419580825,
-0.0087717511,
-0.0779304579,
0.0345662013,
-0.0573397912,
-0.0073881554,
-0.0409069099,
-0.0346173979,
0.0037375616,
0.0108594671,
-0.0705918893,
0.048426073,
-0.0096509941,
-0.0683103576,
-0.0350128449,
0.021986736,
-0.0476262942,
-0.0085195117,
0.020348141,
-0.0569988787,
0.0260187387,
-0.0060994495,
0.0058172718,
-0.0508380085,
-0.0066216914,
-0.0416743197,
0.0347269624,
-0.0728654787,
0.0475433096,
0.0022523832,
0.0498991981,
-0.0142837064,
0.0817414224,
-0.0213148966,
0.0416026711,
0.0454338938,
0.0126488796,
-0.0200659297,
-0.0417822413,
-0.0273229703,
0.0146091143,
-0.0044832504,
0.0176202524,
-0.0181919821,
-0.0268938784,
-0.0538088679,
-0.0449911021,
-0.0717416704,
0.0077931737,
-0.0440952852,
-0.0142128281,
0.0486364029,
-0.0414175503,
-0.0126502011,
0.0383422039,
-0.0181882717,
-0.0096050501,
0.0089410078,
0.0182682909,
-0.0035289933,
-0.0348815992,
-0.0313221253,
-0.0054883906,
0.0113502834,
0.0028920816,
0.047563903,
0.0151013201,
-0.0233923513,
-0.0838611424,
0.0581951514,
-0.0233406872,
-0.0324934013,
0.00149362,
-0.0414252989,
0.0144281862,
-0.0005186607,
0.0962011591,
0.0229261536,
0.0411585085,
0.018945951,
0.0402371958,
-0.0385328792,
0.0123467641,
-0.030330183,
0.0005807286,
0.0313583128,
-0.00436388,
-0.0783078596,
0.0081268772,
0.0361556113,
0.0334043242,
0.0207931828,
-0.0658491924,
0.0207812805,
-0.0617417321,
-0.0422228761,
0.0148639865,
-0.0157016497,
-0.0429229587,
0.024965642,
-0.0221296716,
-0.0424349345,
0.0175411571,
-0.0546989776,
0.0148332333,
-0.0050171465,
0.0363522843,
-0.0050586998,
0.029797215,
0.0339916386,
0.0420389399,
-0.015595275,
0.0007001237,
-0.0149772791,
0.0465937033,
-0.0079062767,
-0.0626608431,
-0.0225764234,
-0.0146199558,
-0.0066604447,
-0.0088920826,
0.0250775553,
-0.0246479809,
-0.0181365646,
0.0098313289,
-0.0020815185,
0.0326811895,
0.0116360877,
0.002143984,
0.0436934382,
-0.0210688021,
0.0304311123,
-0.0323687457,
-0.0060815946,
-0.004386385,
-0.0016778201,
0.0658174604,
-0.0204070359,
0.0320914984,
-0.0569444038,
0.0347807556,
0.0519119166,
0.0283761639,
0.0651762784,
-0.0010025759,
-0.0260565002,
-0.008589997,
-0.0454383343,
-0.0243588537,
0.0232113656,
0.0391539223,
-0.0445673317,
-0.0219288208,
0.0820516646,
0.0242622029,
-0.0243147016,
0.0213157423,
-0.0008224564,
0.0745998025,
-0.0082269702,
-0.0185656473,
-0.0931679681,
0.008889731,
0.0108476076,
0.0119223921,
-0.0344940461,
-0.0205762256,
0.0022678471,
-0.1153078824,
0.0602850802,
0.0566918552,
-0.0207665171,
-0.0034333484,
-0.0121114105,
-0.0190588459,
0.0275590904,
0.0297552496,
0.0086628217,
0.0090547195,
-0.0157681853,
0.0245730076,
-0.0394511633,
-0.0545260496,
-0.005462117,
-0.0235486273,
0.0390935317,
0.0676913559,
0.0152115449,
-0.0133570889,
-0.0541785546,
0.0124515956,
-0.0079070693,
-0.0017180011,
0.026589524,
0.0496286266,
0.0528199337,
0.0090356804,
-0.0144740324,
0.0358556472,
-0.0301006418,
-0.0328117087,
0.0034412283,
0.0367141888,
-0.0227685552,
-0.0557792485,
-0.0146294776,
0.0658706501,
0.0191838518,
0.0921284184,
0.0450460352,
-0.0467926003,
-0.0643012449,
-0.0335242338,
0.0522583798,
-0.0707380474,
-0.0278286375,
0.0496933721,
0.0350404643,
-0.0362382568,
-0.0975800157,
-0.0257603507,
-0.0151095632,
0.0418743007,
0.003049894,
0.0462859049,
-0.0279798489,
-0.0241620746,
-0.02561027,
-0.0063126436,
-0.0322943255,
0.0204877462,
-0.042725917,
-0.024320988,
0.0118934354,
-0.0245757997,
0.0097605847,
0.046429798,
-0.0887111425,
-0.081014432,
0.0319206975,
0.0215641819,
0.027087735,
0.0183488056,
-0.0019839145,
-0.025767019,
0.0331496261,
0.0231222194,
0.0307229031,
0.0253412649,
-0.0112012569,
0.0025210932,
-0.0088509247,
-0.0103649516,
0.0186581742,
0.01135414,
0.0034569365,
0.0525962748,
0.0161351804,
0.0075852717,
0.0300766695,
0.0162975751,
-0.0327614732,
-0.054023657,
0.0143497074,
-0.0123347845,
0.011314529,
-0.0550906509,
-0.0257340278,
-0.0379487388,
-0.0167904347,
0.0699845105,
-0.0194691289,
0.0042948779,
0.0065921536,
-0.0156611819,
-0.0322213434,
-0.0352664255,
-0.0431278646,
-0.0212016515,
0.012361994,
0.0431980453,
-0.0358686559,
-0.0304409489,
0.0056369794,
-0.028456267,
0.0419996083,
0.004528848,
0.0832736418,
0.0044556079,
-0.0097916173,
0.0102528362,
0.0184422955,
-0.0240457673,
-0.0553390682,
-0.0544926934,
0.0139903771,
0.0683628842,
0.0146793099,
0.0817510188,
-0.0672109127,
0.022070298,
-0.0205152221,
0.0358964652,
0.0549342111,
-0.0506068543,
-0.0368958898,
0.0053371619,
-0.0335214362,
-0.0190179516,
0.1053466126,
0.0218795873,
0.0144794611,
0.0287598874,
-0.0089170868,
-0.0246721935,
-0.0635028183,
-0.0431442671,
-0.0137054268,
-0.006284331,
-0.0255624745,
-0.0612061918,
-0.0285590142,
0.0044395886,
0.0018528871,
0.0173006579,
-0.0078964243,
0.0149922194,
0.048867669,
-0.0528269596,
0.01271905,
-0.0237648264,
0.0051679374,
0.0334793814,
0.0055625113,
-0.0004628987,
-6.400623311e-33,
0.0045145652,
-0.0288377218,
0.0003114874,
-0.053496033,
-0.0286561418,
-0.0433376096,
-0.0276709162,
0.0039437362,
0.053816013,
-0.0050969063,
0.0015468979,
0.0043342263,
0.0259730779,
0.0417640246,
-0.0173943341,
0.0134522123,
0.0586255714,
0.0057837493,
-0.0291882977,
0.0423148833,
0.0358816124,
0.0125706373,
0.0426588543,
-0.0384901725,
0.0168500785,
-0.0393613726,
-0.0400125608,
-0.0251548365,
0.0007779166,
0.0147631885,
-0.0403823443,
0.0321134068,
0.0262412913,
-0.0506951883,
-0.0227306709,
-0.019171847,
0.0034678727,
0.010389532,
-0.0139311831,
0.0214122869,
-0.0406378135,
-0.0371315181,
0.0305249281,
-0.018084662,
0.0121809021,
0.0126987267,
0.011527882,
-0.0464571826,
-0.0379988886,
-0.0023212896,
-0.0887244269,
0.0283333454,
-0.0020971149,
0.0224841926,
-0.0147456033,
0.0083025526,
-0.0271588191,
-0.0137806721,
-0.0611408986,
0.0098612113,
0.0533921272,
0.0252990909,
0.0415399149,
0.0043956749,
0.0133796725,
0.0739872381,
0.0692053884,
0.0375611447,
-0.0224006828,
-0.0049060434,
0.0223507695,
0.0421198495,
0.0419015959,
0.0263953637,
0.0699179843,
-0.0205394626,
-0.0345685668,
0.0093930205,
-0.0411881283,
-0.034660127,
0.0803799182,
-0.0083075222,
-0.0343681574,
-0.0358107984,
-0.0165831689,
0.0026817657,
-0.0158105232,
-0.0232826862,
0.038156461,
0.0086686341,
-0.0420377403,
-0.0223943014,
0.0267817043,
-0.0303082503,
-0.0006366502,
0.0209047105,
-0.0427587852,
0.0297131278,
-0.0329718776,
0.0061776997,
-0.0144159589,
-0.032003805,
0.0285360031,
0.0073030302,
0.0119029926,
0.0073348391,
0.0071301339,
-0.0116804726,
-0.0598244295,
0.0253204275,
-0.0236641895,
0.0173698142,
0.0468294062,
-0.0055362834,
0.0456354804,
-0.0314974599,
-0.0116008036,
-0.0254065581,
0.0481971242,
0.0307107512,
-0.0027209974,
0.0290640704,
-0.0240546316,
0.019955907,
-0.0213375315,
0.0225472338,
-0.0265009943,
-0.0000984824,
0.0569524914,
-0.0626785681,
-0.0269807633,
-0.0070973434,
2.748e-7,
0.0063491734,
0.0379256457,
0.0121155204,
0.0367335118,
0.0197721571,
-0.0155730043,
0.0001170957,
0.0182815604,
0.0035609694,
-0.0255640782,
-0.0072851591,
0.0210699812,
0.0965442732,
0.0351296701,
-0.0732323229,
-0.0126939258,
-0.0536577925,
0.0320941731,
-0.0851206258,
-0.0198652316,
0.0397792757,
0.0530686453,
-0.0376655348,
-0.0135001829,
0.0340640359,
-0.061599981,
0.0807101205,
-0.004851433,
0.0087437257,
0.0617006868,
0.0420434847,
0.0119478051,
-0.0099029019,
0.026179133,
-0.0140924798,
-0.0394071899,
0.0454563871,
0.0360666662,
0.0058333864,
-0.0042517842,
0.014790386,
-0.0080383886,
0.0122064929,
-0.0596981049,
0.0514542051,
-0.004844781,
-0.0115612494,
-0.0051670484,
-0.0540479459,
-0.0276459046,
0.0634170845,
-0.022341093,
-0.013924446,
0.046956677,
-0.0015708818,
0.044872921,
-0.0111964829,
-0.0043886942,
-0.0320152976,
-0.010266209,
-0.0380512103,
-0.0435610488,
-0.0321492329,
0.0014060055,
-0.0227591749,
-0.0690509155,
-0.0091264611,
2.858311171e-34,
0.0370891243,
-0.0107057951,
0.0268571991,
0.0201484337,
0.0352676883,
-0.0065907771,
0.0449176021,
0.0261435155,
-0.04456871,
-0.0507946238,
-0.0218087193
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03720v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03720v1 | Negotiating with LLMS: Prompt Hacks, Skill Gaps, and Reasoning Deficits | 2023-11-26T08:44:58 | 2023-11-26T08:44:58 | Johannes Schneider, Steffi Haag, Leona Chandra Kruse | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models LLMs like ChatGPT have reached the 100 Mio user barrier
in record time and might increasingly enter all areas of our life leading to a
diverse set of interactions between those Artificial Intelligence models and
humans. While many studies have discussed governance and regulations
deductively from first-order principles, few studies provide an inductive,
data-driven lens based on observing dialogues between humans and LLMs
especially when it comes to non-collaborative, competitive situations that have
the potential to pose a serious threat to people. In this work, we conduct a
user study engaging over 40 individuals across all age groups in price
negotiations with an LLM. We explore how people interact with an LLM,
investigating differences in negotiation outcomes and strategies. Furthermore,
we highlight shortcomings of LLMs with respect to their reasoning capabilities
and, in turn, susceptiveness to prompt hacking, which intends to manipulate the
LLM to make agreements that are against its instructions or beyond any
rationality. We also show that the negotiated prices humans manage to achieve
span a broad range, which points to a literacy gap in effectively interacting
with LLMs. | [
0.0498000495,
0.0554213561,
-0.0269091725,
0.0222654827,
-0.0276234597,
-0.0087658139,
0.0315592289,
0.0280684568,
0.0300229266,
-0.0075617437,
-0.0264845919,
0.0272447821,
0.0263164826,
0.0138277765,
0.0057051219,
-0.0233871061,
-0.0007626825,
-0.0010413734,
0.0628027245,
-0.0144666228,
0.0216773413,
0.0040970892,
-0.0095744552,
0.0398753583,
-0.0341784731,
-0.0131884031,
-0.0154744592,
-0.0074720606,
0.0176668651,
-0.0412880927,
0.0294484142,
0.0433486104,
0.008848235,
0.0298810024,
0.0000021087,
-0.0688946396,
-0.0061142398,
-0.0088899406,
-0.0836132839,
-0.0010338571,
0.0438067019,
-0.0083099287,
-0.0061736517,
0.0204482693,
-0.0920065567,
0.0487011485,
0.0237905513,
0.0428629555,
0.034694314,
0.0499980412,
-0.0050350116,
0.0297129508,
0.0231284127,
-0.0113685811,
-0.0025386279,
-0.0985688865,
0.0114899408,
-0.0040531834,
0.0034676637,
0.0057871533,
-0.0120309787,
0.0051085288,
0.0035893875,
-0.0293843411,
-0.0795934647,
0.0281232391,
-0.0328027643,
-0.0374455899,
-0.0026257292,
0.0687820986,
0.0543465875,
0.0178430546,
0.0175162833,
0.0135068418,
0.0354599655,
0.0170930885,
-0.0402373821,
0.0551552847,
-0.0324115232,
0.0023092446,
-0.0179629866,
0.0000775811,
0.0374018066,
0.0271025039,
0.0098463157,
0.0464264452,
-0.0615485795,
-0.0335946865,
0.0155662289,
0.0026712611,
0.0204097461,
-0.0548568107,
-0.016159581,
0.0330414921,
-0.0729798079,
0.0107202409,
-0.0090197008,
0.0409753248,
0.0216607731,
-0.043974489,
0.0009168786,
0.0304640252,
0.0173399448,
0.0429286212,
0.0550135002,
-0.0210655034,
-0.0160797779,
0.0719572008,
-0.0013388935,
0.0507144481,
-0.0072444887,
-0.0248236097,
-0.0117124049,
-0.0087647941,
-0.0431098863,
0.0130531359,
-0.0045270785,
0.0102864066,
-0.0641316324,
0.0510700867,
-0.0294796191,
0.0266690087,
0.0270997304,
-0.0219846312,
-0.0791520327,
-0.0535539314,
-0.0371344015,
0.031938199,
0.0248522684,
-0.0619142093,
0.0017857295,
0.0165516622,
-0.0238167848,
0.0036731311,
0.0017297885,
0.0978961885,
-0.0032913552,
0.0216136351,
-0.0413276702,
-0.0654774234,
0.0140543198,
-0.0349379554,
0.0011917441,
-0.0286437292,
0.0339446776,
-0.0105044656,
-0.0492024496,
-0.077712968,
0.0047885487,
0.0250880066,
-0.0433318056,
0.0884001479,
-0.0100259082,
0.0051023327,
0.0475475192,
0.0466632247,
-0.0518100336,
-0.0034590387,
0.0455325469,
0.0139609277,
0.056790784,
0.0246598013,
0.0621750876,
0.0458343141,
-0.0288541801,
0.008569614,
0.0330360122,
0.0089053689,
-0.0208542347,
0.0234794151,
0.020540202,
0.0041433601,
-0.0588627644,
-0.0279133618,
0.1016478911,
0.0926851183,
-0.0197345726,
0.0174212363,
-0.0365184583,
0.0233937241,
0.0013759001,
-0.0497368202,
-0.0155707598,
0.0009057742,
-0.0440064408,
-0.037452504,
-0.0090348236,
0.0096117118,
-0.0244349018,
-0.0292512029,
0.016697159,
-0.0050020479,
0.0325402096,
0.0615608767,
-0.0212165639,
-0.0374180898,
-0.0171099734,
-0.005534213,
-0.0112462081,
-0.0026775941,
-0.041656889,
-0.0518296063,
-0.0124256359,
0.0543582067,
0.0227211211,
0.0185140725,
0.0307426825,
-0.0399824157,
0.0008668035,
0.0764789283,
0.0613537021,
0.0002504535,
-0.0394512378,
-0.0322132669,
-0.0254947748,
-0.0109599382,
-0.0257241335,
0.0369745344,
-0.0152376769,
0.0003801608,
0.0002980091,
-0.0020716973,
0.0338739417,
0.0182740409,
-0.0311965793,
-0.0404875688,
-0.060985107,
0.0298124589,
0.0128836893,
0.0005419596,
0.0232894998,
0.0055655991,
0.016181035,
0.0032613329,
0.0146153206,
0.0442871973,
-0.0181976352,
0.0480388924,
0.0203126855,
-0.0330094583,
-0.0421086736,
-0.0311948992,
-0.0048949136,
-0.0029884607,
0.0200866908,
-0.017135039,
0.0150877219,
-0.0299509596,
-0.0333199017,
-0.0021664894,
-0.0090327775,
-0.0255097207,
0.0230327509,
-0.0027247472,
-0.0417348184,
0.0096870288,
-0.0452968292,
0.0131519753,
-0.0334707014,
0.0102284206,
0.0386060886,
0.0121652102,
0.0236930456,
0.0065695499,
0.0323615335,
-0.0212405752,
0.0178776719,
-0.0574320965,
-0.0395198166,
0.0042504971,
0.0179641414,
-0.0070195799,
-0.0603700317,
-0.0149602247,
0.0041327416,
-0.0241512153,
-0.011522199,
0.0190671775,
0.0221410003,
0.054423254,
0.0113255084,
-0.0284468606,
0.0087347878,
0.0063243574,
-0.0125698028,
0.0300868377,
0.0451977812,
-0.0146425292,
-0.0208117664,
-0.0212452523,
-0.0176725984,
-0.0117343338,
-0.0308433361,
-0.0259666778,
0.0468613952,
0.0307563487,
-0.027190024,
0.0377860367,
0.0035940798,
0.0846420899,
0.0237082615,
-0.0176549274,
-0.0563696362,
-0.008062751,
0.0095163304,
0.0109600825,
-0.0394748449,
-0.0250100866,
0.0074290661,
0.0562527478,
-0.0027939908,
0.0368218906,
-0.0047117504,
0.1027406678,
0.0225003082,
-0.0448499024,
-0.0292340294,
-0.0189970788,
-0.0573669337,
0.1041769683,
0.0119983042,
-0.052252382,
0.0357387923,
0.0134185329,
0.0124116205,
0.0333838873,
-0.0196404047,
-0.0254668798,
0.0779621676,
-0.0438035615,
0.0072008492,
0.0061954651,
-0.0410286188,
-0.0524625778,
-0.0187666472,
0.0740164295,
-0.0385132469,
0.0579403453,
-0.0535371378,
-0.0088643506,
-0.0047039599,
-0.0335639231,
-0.0343331248,
-0.0559375323,
-0.0384738073,
0.0142105389,
0.0466193259,
-0.0373589732,
-0.0569407716,
-0.0566631295,
0.0239192452,
0.0058024884,
0.0517168716,
-0.0202890448,
0.0052337651,
-0.0428041406,
-0.0308891293,
0.052323848,
0.0232643727,
-0.0319155827,
0.0186014902,
0.0603501238,
-0.0301894192,
-0.0346919373,
0.016355386,
0.0056657139,
0.022444047,
0.020235857,
0.0265107118,
0.0220253225,
-0.0183447059,
-0.02352437,
0.0175976306,
0.0388367288,
0.016686555,
-0.022650104,
0.0232514869,
-0.0644595921,
0.023979431,
0.0006440559,
0.0099550067,
-0.1153285056,
0.0206860602,
0.021084249,
0.0667806342,
-0.0682699457,
-0.0544938296,
-0.0260466877,
-0.086843513,
0.0356670879,
0.0072179167,
0.0220868085,
0.0583426654,
0.0259910356,
-0.0249945857,
-0.0081410706,
0.0841519833,
-0.002083607,
0.0415528677,
0.0082986467,
0.0147502013,
-0.063768968,
0.0471508056,
0.0280636605,
0.003320083,
0.0425166041,
0.0455705002,
0.0375147313,
-0.011082706,
-0.0089726085,
0.0648183972,
0.0664417148,
-0.0189362168,
0.0163077079,
0.0103160907,
-0.0165151637,
0.0364250392,
-0.0118334899,
0.0464159101,
-0.0204234123,
-0.0346715599,
0.0356334969,
0.0307015125,
-0.0328806192,
-0.0223145131,
0.0289578307,
-0.0073966039,
0.004666626,
0.0291978978,
-0.0203043297,
-0.0138081247,
-0.0361703001,
-0.0406528749,
-0.057190422,
0.014752564,
-0.0505429506,
0.0348495133,
0.0307460744,
0.0271700285,
-0.0035096242,
-0.0817892104,
0.005196433,
0.0006671114,
0.0167905428,
-0.0395341031,
0.0261258781,
0.0316438451,
0.0313565917,
0.0164553244,
-0.0374759659,
0.0193868689,
-0.0279299952,
0.0420519002,
-0.0477419384,
-0.0460377559,
0.0151260504,
-0.0110738771,
-0.0083822235,
-0.0368031524,
-0.0268745609,
0.0447288305,
0.0390176959,
0.0164680742,
0.0234702285,
-0.0202122275,
-0.0179432444,
0.0556064472,
-0.0162183717,
0.0132168764,
0.031029705,
0.0596420094,
-0.0205280129,
-0.0001692101,
-0.0143845724,
-0.0182514563,
0.0142858429,
0.0149617093,
-0.0651406273,
-0.048194211,
0.0566333272,
-0.013231854,
-0.0329000242,
-0.0166326165,
0.0033161694,
0.0004598931,
0.0031728004,
-0.0064124372,
0.0065946849,
-0.018044604,
-0.0801545307,
0.0226481948,
-0.028346708,
0.0231477171,
0.0072868788,
-0.022230735,
0.0275514964,
0.0010644265,
0.0693104193,
-0.023713965,
0.0148795871,
-0.002840478,
-0.0121705048,
0.0521214493,
0.0633374676,
-0.0304533914,
0.0316270031,
0.0494052507,
0.0585682131,
0.0160318613,
-0.0248775706,
0.0102582006,
0.018723866,
-0.0060896589,
-0.1559976935,
0.0647517666,
0.0438637845,
0.0065050647,
-0.0055070645,
-0.0150923682,
-0.0274226442,
0.0029790557,
0.0187356751,
-0.0081353877,
-0.0107976692,
-0.0152029637,
0.0321026407,
-0.0005232985,
-0.0495401025,
0.0100389589,
0.0605193041,
-0.050371103,
0.0316512957,
-0.0291155186,
-0.0128027424,
-0.0158740655,
-0.0552893728,
0.0227403082,
-0.0349949487,
-0.0119055454,
-0.0535522811,
-0.0714914054,
0.0049583237,
-0.0573643856,
-0.0026571243,
-0.0178885665,
-0.0166734681,
-0.0093658231,
0.0360875949,
0.0024769884,
-0.0082848966,
-0.0017124458,
0.0026471054,
-0.0630346835,
-0.0269696545,
-0.0173361097,
-5.691323407e-33,
0.0423875898,
-0.1198369935,
0.0451252423,
0.031338241,
-0.001684942,
-0.046598848,
-0.0208468363,
0.0409023054,
-0.0176982284,
0.0149523336,
-0.0445033759,
-0.0132155837,
0.0225697607,
-0.0259196721,
0.0286392458,
-0.0472210795,
0.0050917761,
-0.0103210714,
-0.0028880748,
-0.0344682075,
-0.0317162462,
0.0149853136,
0.0147273168,
-0.0605587736,
0.1108533964,
-0.0048388639,
-0.0251707807,
0.0200477149,
-0.0134087568,
0.0273812246,
0.0205518641,
0.013860493,
0.0145320445,
-0.0095603494,
-0.0112456633,
0.0650827363,
-0.0227788594,
0.0031280725,
0.0268833991,
-0.0060875681,
-0.0090293195,
-0.0407885797,
0.0178280547,
-0.0055735749,
-0.0421546325,
0.0082185892,
0.0064031929,
-0.0225022808,
0.0075775995,
0.0132656256,
-0.0365918055,
0.0134311188,
-0.0782008395,
0.0030728152,
0.0199159365,
0.0487533808,
-0.0223347135,
-0.0397002362,
-0.0855475366,
0.0518702045,
-0.0126984427,
-0.0417687222,
0.0604073405,
-0.0324888267,
0.0117433807,
0.0453506075,
-0.0147344293,
0.0347501189,
-0.046697665,
-0.0517245382,
-0.0137525247,
0.0869622231,
-0.0181248188,
0.0582181215,
-0.0274574328,
-0.0393487737,
-0.0291255061,
0.0077889408,
0.0430617258,
0.0405724868,
0.0020037594,
0.0237756222,
-0.0073523112,
-0.0299628209,
-0.0128080091,
-0.0250617769,
-0.0214457493,
-0.0608979128,
0.0123899831,
-0.0074188439,
0.0427527763,
-0.0367958732,
-0.0048062019,
-0.0503729582,
-0.0321800224,
-0.0724442303,
0.031082131,
-0.006760532,
-0.0012970936,
-0.0032209118,
-0.0433792956,
-0.004538795,
-0.0312955864,
-0.0111649949,
0.0638035312,
0.0327552743,
0.0023864491,
-0.0312690325,
-0.0077918633,
-0.017341435,
0.0001267504,
0.0403005518,
0.0070095807,
0.0097091505,
0.032747563,
-0.019046722,
0.0026611267,
-0.0327217579,
0.0027798966,
0.0085753547,
-0.0493353345,
0.0348928608,
-0.0619168058,
-0.0086478852,
-0.0227617472,
0.0052759238,
-0.0284657087,
0.0386648402,
0.0600242764,
-0.0188533664,
0.0032578856,
-0.057190638,
2.716e-7,
0.003726372,
0.0622657314,
-0.0234701298,
0.0130546419,
-0.018454114,
0.0730879605,
-0.001586901,
0.0418770164,
-0.0116408374,
-0.0700794235,
0.0537124537,
-0.0112131657,
0.0512904264,
0.0326673351,
-0.049619019,
-0.008373525,
-0.0329130962,
-0.0452806801,
-0.0549127422,
0.0104439072,
0.0734984949,
-0.0303451326,
-0.0168318525,
-0.0301047992,
-0.0258135609,
-0.0114348242,
0.016620772,
-0.094411701,
-0.0196564328,
-0.02592103,
0.0584471524,
-0.0432940125,
0.0190238375,
0.0349817201,
-0.0052591134,
-0.031425152,
-0.0420677885,
0.0689511225,
0.0172370952,
-0.0408193544,
-0.0153327417,
-0.0392476134,
0.0066524521,
-0.0282697435,
0.0106251147,
-0.002211622,
-0.0684099197,
-0.0052091861,
0.0335329734,
-0.0724985003,
0.017249573,
-0.0178889018,
0.0311325639,
-0.0039442349,
0.0151845524,
0.0039012749,
0.0500065051,
-0.0124875298,
-0.0005892551,
0.0113772545,
-0.0341164283,
-0.0601930954,
0.0111743398,
0.0631558821,
0.0144775547,
0.0081905965,
-0.0072363191,
1.941601442e-34,
-0.0093860952,
0.0144634023,
0.031563282,
0.0575181022,
0.0445719212,
0.0591731668,
0.0642569587,
0.0274181031,
0.016608825,
-0.0214856584,
-0.0069776452
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15218v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15218v4 | Real-Time Online Stock Forecasting Utilizing Integrated Quantitative and Qualitative Analysis | 2023-11-26T07:19:10 | 2024-01-02T15:13:44 | Sai Akash Bathini, Dagli Cihan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CE, cs.LG | The application of Machine learning to finance has become a familiar
approach, even more so in stock market forecasting. The stock market is highly
volatile, and huge amounts of data are generated every minute globally. The
extraction of effective intelligence from this data is of critical importance.
However, a collaboration of numerical stock data with qualitative text data can
be a challenging task. In this work, we accomplish this by providing an
unprecedented, publicly available dataset with technical and fundamental data
and sentiment that we gathered from news archives, TV news captions, radio
transcripts, tweets, daily financial newspapers, etc. The text data entries
used for sentiment extraction total more than 1.4 Million. The dataset consists
of daily entries from January 2018 to December 2022 for eight companies
representing diverse industrial sectors and the Dow Jones Industrial Average
(DJIA) as a whole. Holistic Fundamental and Technical data is provided training
ready for Model learning and deployment. Most importantly, the data generated
could be used for incremental online learning with real-time data points
retrieved daily since no stagnant data was utilized. All the data was retired
from APIs or self-designed robust information retrieval technologies with
extremely low latency and zero monetary cost. These adaptable technologies
facilitate data extraction for any stock. Moreover, the utilization of
Spearman's rank correlation over real-time data, linking stock returns with
sentiment analysis has produced noteworthy results for the DJIA and the eight
other stocks, achieving accuracy levels surpassing 60%. The dataset is made
available at https://github.com/batking24/Huge-Stock-Dataset. | [
0.0094890855,
0.1074657142,
-0.0294097532,
-0.0317474082,
0.0133779915,
0.0129171181,
-0.0098186145,
0.0118165873,
0.0058436557,
-0.0196700357,
0.0280226115,
0.0071135606,
-0.0466193594,
0.0826299712,
0.0042711669,
-0.0121276099,
-0.0047483239,
0.0238016248,
0.064785257,
-0.009966936,
0.0171008911,
0.0257960707,
0.0370470881,
-0.030445043,
-0.0363357402,
-0.0102863107,
-0.0136590833,
-0.0020553304,
0.020394234,
-0.0375831611,
0.017681513,
-0.0284514837,
0.0111120995,
0.0329942219,
0.0000021487,
-0.0152114909,
-0.0134275882,
-0.0306114778,
0.034083277,
-0.040641129,
0.0417016298,
-0.0558631271,
0.0264328606,
0.0097181285,
-0.1079982668,
0.0455401056,
0.0414534621,
0.0669797808,
0.0565339327,
0.056330476,
-0.0129448455,
-0.0166089069,
0.0305235926,
-0.0324907042,
-0.0371577591,
-0.0331198946,
0.0073702312,
0.0106481994,
-0.034667287,
-0.0051537608,
0.0204328373,
0.0565274358,
-0.0006203403,
0.0387734398,
0.0226254091,
-0.0204273332,
-0.0240960121,
-0.0039221346,
-0.0325769782,
0.054825183,
0.020320531,
0.0078654438,
0.0402415767,
-0.0157784764,
-0.0276786145,
0.0005619508,
-0.0184063669,
0.0110625261,
-0.0222728774,
0.0644722283,
-0.014236982,
0.0082740439,
-0.0030156223,
0.0069727935,
-0.0019157818,
0.0523961671,
-0.0625949949,
-0.0327759087,
0.0448095649,
0.0138694467,
0.0153423883,
-0.0097001037,
-0.0073594474,
-0.0150027759,
-0.0020047494,
0.0061760996,
0.0177094657,
-0.0390436389,
-0.0221742112,
-0.1140637323,
-0.0436677597,
0.0055698259,
0.0373990014,
0.0370221846,
-0.0139372973,
-0.017769957,
0.0471754558,
-0.0340146944,
0.0114089968,
0.0159065556,
-0.0862194449,
0.0024440037,
0.0172012318,
0.0891863182,
0.0096726557,
-0.0105766132,
-0.0759532601,
0.0028796501,
-0.0345936045,
0.0386618897,
0.0209438037,
0.0113077443,
-0.0325567685,
-0.0112490579,
-0.0147088086,
-0.0172090922,
-0.0403217748,
0.0749305561,
-0.0411019959,
-0.0571247824,
0.0326352566,
-0.0070600663,
0.0284269396,
0.020061478,
0.0183919743,
0.0584604219,
0.027232565,
-0.0220454764,
-0.0131603498,
-0.0574395917,
0.0142104607,
0.0022051241,
-0.0366874337,
-0.0012692863,
-0.0007473197,
-0.0513177998,
0.0001569858,
0.0249522664,
0.0357386582,
-0.0140562141,
-0.0217766538,
0.0526804775,
-0.0140536027,
-0.0103757363,
0.0030487285,
-0.0345103815,
0.0440522507,
0.0780251697,
0.0033834903,
0.0283622798,
0.0787220672,
-0.0078033209,
-0.0248327348,
0.0186666772,
0.0395733565,
-0.0494739935,
-0.0624925084,
0.0346813127,
-0.0531447455,
-0.0145779289,
0.0056334692,
-0.0048598959,
0.028149223,
0.0159228258,
0.0525201596,
0.010614288,
0.0308282729,
0.0499428548,
-0.0264579318,
0.0339557528,
0.0180454534,
-0.0996839851,
0.0176752023,
0.0127453897,
-0.0189173277,
0.0422511324,
0.0019641533,
0.0408122838,
-0.0264385249,
-0.0420812257,
0.0162439402,
-0.033909861,
-0.026241919,
-0.0075473897,
0.0375225917,
-0.0629951954,
-0.0125802448,
0.0226445645,
0.0497260541,
-0.0111587448,
0.0004185802,
-0.0153204184,
0.0378311127,
0.0618645623,
-0.003146563,
-0.0326740928,
0.0264057182,
-0.0173695125,
-0.0239318348,
-0.0025863985,
-0.0243241377,
0.0011260143,
-0.0397530198,
-0.0262281839,
-0.0168135148,
0.0302103907,
0.0194722321,
-0.0121742999,
-0.0377133675,
0.0709706843,
-0.0115241501,
0.0045963856,
-0.0140283788,
0.0079938509,
0.0087823411,
-0.0482793413,
0.0271267574,
-0.0225360394,
0.0253535118,
0.0583818778,
-0.0082740784,
-0.0204687957,
0.0136777749,
-0.0040472075,
-0.0640794784,
0.0349488631,
-0.0303773582,
0.0420024507,
-0.0257074051,
-0.0121651255,
0.0187293217,
0.0373549983,
-0.0430342928,
-0.0119365612,
0.0138887176,
0.0101092439,
0.0087585123,
-0.039164111,
-0.0781264678,
0.0150901563,
0.0560044087,
0.028479103,
0.027019985,
-0.0079239374,
0.0112576056,
-0.0365908891,
-0.0434459224,
-0.0038800908,
-0.017138917,
0.0362122133,
0.0011853715,
-0.0045454814,
0.0521936789,
0.013544796,
-0.0239483658,
-0.0089668892,
-0.0024441315,
-0.0732189044,
-0.0467835665,
-0.006597009,
0.0077982666,
0.0169054922,
0.0055743316,
-0.0090063224,
-0.0119977659,
0.0140188932,
0.000805605,
-0.0346133672,
-0.0181311704,
0.041807238,
0.0157875586,
0.0431791879,
-0.0216623303,
-0.022841014,
-0.0241274182,
0.0051984121,
0.0716900453,
-0.0442232452,
0.0240557138,
-0.0366987921,
-0.0315190405,
0.0091298185,
0.0091290884,
-0.0049237846,
-0.034671437,
-0.0369359925,
-0.0408356413,
0.0699031204,
0.0590220317,
0.0195473079,
-0.0167243574,
-0.0196337905,
-0.017831089,
0.0286563169,
-0.026867209,
0.0387769975,
-0.0077838111,
-0.0015427402,
0.0254001487,
0.0146272155,
-0.0101019982,
-0.0015462552,
-0.0678064972,
0.0501563512,
-0.0039276616,
0.0045468747,
-0.0587342903,
0.0337128453,
-0.0272957068,
0.0424877144,
0.0514104515,
-0.0521116927,
0.018213205,
0.035016302,
0.0002165422,
-0.0277203992,
-0.0503528677,
-0.0486784764,
0.0195788126,
-0.0394637249,
-0.0117725022,
-0.0659739375,
0.0055621699,
0.0181456562,
-0.0026174854,
0.0023786647,
-0.0417058878,
-0.0202935468,
0.0014213378,
0.0065480312,
0.0090049542,
-0.0144455098,
0.0075720316,
-0.0517565794,
-0.0827217698,
-0.0051593292,
0.0050423928,
-0.0491551049,
-0.0011344586,
-0.0038491676,
-0.0171984117,
-0.0194342304,
-0.007258771,
-0.0556450151,
0.0440554135,
0.0040200665,
0.0625558347,
-0.0238911361,
-0.0019164378,
0.0073961942,
0.0651965216,
0.0338679031,
0.0895687714,
-0.0003295407,
-0.0067055584,
-0.0057805665,
0.0050319554,
0.0124930376,
0.0120227486,
0.0156095056,
-0.0197703391,
-0.0109246541,
0.0021927205,
0.072229214,
-0.004225024,
-0.0103803771,
0.0057874313,
0.030625632,
-0.0401685797,
-0.0384998471,
0.011063992,
-0.0659144744,
-0.0014284725,
-0.0099356957,
0.054773327,
-0.0101634683,
-0.0500884727,
-0.0232196283,
-0.1227685809,
0.0555139333,
-0.0195452403,
0.000992636,
-0.0435823202,
-0.0561182424,
-0.0048631974,
-0.0635009035,
-0.0120871346,
-0.0021572607,
-0.0131476643,
0.0411521271,
0.0298388749,
-0.1032901257,
-0.0127302092,
0.0346824192,
0.0030713589,
-0.0625583827,
0.0044602016,
0.0510000512,
-0.0544120222,
-0.029930016,
-0.054580085,
-0.0360733978,
0.0112958653,
-0.0032298553,
0.0608822666,
-0.0520447493,
-0.0333583727,
-0.0217748377,
0.0768168271,
0.0049904524,
0.0561535284,
0.0298589095,
0.0141393542,
-0.0107804816,
-0.0373725444,
-0.0168435387,
0.0377316065,
0.0184800494,
-0.0013121074,
-0.03217379,
-0.0730351061,
-0.0385297649,
-0.0105397422,
0.0322210118,
-0.0594021492,
-0.0215767566,
-0.0371196494,
-0.0090293968,
-0.0180711374,
-0.0915240347,
-0.0308294985,
-0.0575476997,
0.0547605082,
0.0036865545,
0.0045490596,
0.0397826582,
0.0082644699,
-0.0618994758,
-0.0139455209,
0.0451358929,
0.0007627729,
0.0034490628,
0.0319669209,
0.0469509996,
0.0064050118,
-0.0354643278,
-0.0136351809,
-0.0433764271,
-0.0262547452,
0.0189387053,
0.0135920346,
0.0175158884,
0.0039498922,
0.0144071998,
0.0398191735,
0.0573931895,
0.124151893,
-0.0479259975,
-0.0406180955,
0.0556110069,
0.0741774738,
-0.00068791,
0.0442343093,
-0.0171772223,
0.0055639884,
-0.0365556404,
-0.0410826243,
-0.0518830083,
0.016831765,
-0.0470701382,
-0.0001827748,
0.073220104,
0.0746874288,
-0.0409960113,
-0.0231355149,
-0.0032132147,
0.0258715097,
0.0189419128,
-0.0341552049,
0.0164306127,
0.0006446264,
-0.0005460957,
-0.0525031947,
0.0433823988,
0.0545150079,
-0.0634891167,
-0.0523557737,
-0.0059830584,
-0.0199445132,
0.032535933,
0.0023670357,
-0.0210798066,
0.003033665,
-0.0196081009,
0.0186025128,
0.0111446716,
-0.002412359,
-0.0246340148,
0.0142605314,
0.0322960615,
0.0125223594,
-0.0246816687,
-0.0453203805,
-0.043844305,
-0.028394524,
0.0431281812,
-0.0284381025,
-0.0231648833,
0.029410582,
-0.0482452065,
0.0259676799,
0.0284418836,
0.0349579453,
-0.0336866342,
-0.0102817211,
0.0104975412,
-0.0184048712,
-0.073910147,
0.0169872269,
0.0570283085,
-0.0518828332,
0.0291655101,
-0.0048345951,
-0.031454403,
-0.033149641,
0.025861375,
0.0805278197,
0.005084591,
0.0218044966,
-0.0085818777,
-0.0116832219,
-0.017887691,
0.0651572123,
-0.0385629348,
0.0045386492,
-0.0352516919,
0.0072667473,
0.0518612303,
0.0100038145,
0.0714144632,
-0.0280327592,
0.005744901,
-0.0489438549,
-0.0158686209,
-0.0367050655,
-6.60466562e-33,
0.0168816112,
0.0027327598,
-0.031658005,
-0.0053456249,
-0.0064545725,
0.0466510765,
0.0036037932,
-0.0078241229,
0.0298837069,
0.0042613032,
0.0107667958,
0.0472719409,
0.0078837564,
0.0284759272,
0.0788358748,
0.0113393841,
-0.0024954116,
-0.0395374373,
0.0250357278,
0.0139619065,
0.0571573786,
0.0670547262,
0.0210731737,
-0.0294629633,
0.0161385685,
-0.0093321586,
-0.0603531785,
-0.0295268707,
0.0557764471,
0.015735412,
0.0048031164,
0.0408839956,
0.0210675411,
-0.0527770221,
-0.0069168056,
0.0226781275,
0.0185211077,
-0.0467024781,
-0.0361337066,
0.0178823136,
0.0025278346,
0.0416791476,
0.050209552,
0.0093810437,
0.0091159632,
0.0031083135,
0.0374552794,
0.0121586332,
0.006922706,
-0.0985695273,
-0.0158879552,
0.0234279577,
-0.0276866239,
0.0801997557,
0.0322520137,
0.1004698351,
0.0281219669,
0.0113576185,
-0.0776008368,
0.0216971375,
-0.028993899,
0.0213323832,
-0.0191660877,
-0.0227043498,
0.0169585794,
0.0471043363,
-0.0057561672,
-0.0299920253,
0.0068185725,
0.0828438699,
0.0293146558,
0.056548126,
0.0055762175,
0.0367471427,
0.0408575386,
-0.0840058401,
-0.0448296182,
0.0002146037,
0.0240392331,
0.0030194737,
0.0361834988,
-0.0095555605,
-0.0300138909,
-0.0073314519,
0.0611406527,
0.0163882915,
0.007053148,
-0.0108117983,
-0.0117251528,
0.0137041435,
-0.0255854446,
0.0222286619,
-0.0287616495,
-0.0445213169,
-0.0523044057,
0.0017644621,
-0.0338188931,
0.0239864495,
0.0100073358,
-0.0589222051,
-0.0378109179,
-0.0410667546,
-0.0479412116,
0.0251455531,
0.0029825389,
-0.0525602028,
0.0215327702,
0.0326187983,
-0.0410159789,
-0.0396256149,
0.0253746174,
0.0400740169,
0.0177997146,
-0.007829506,
0.033162538,
-0.0003324813,
-0.0104298331,
0.0361231156,
-0.0022229552,
0.0531687774,
0.0039138468,
-0.0006271921,
0.0003416077,
-0.0133361761,
0.0040591848,
-0.0152385989,
0.0052809571,
0.0057011293,
-0.0354852751,
-0.042580463,
-0.0200408213,
0.0215443186,
2.966e-7,
0.0078138672,
0.083535105,
-0.0144259818,
-0.0122480756,
0.0241042506,
0.040976759,
0.0138387373,
0.0282327514,
-0.0115450257,
0.0043915031,
0.0731032118,
-0.004177073,
0.0366226994,
0.0532291606,
-0.0924947336,
-0.0923316479,
-0.0729748607,
0.0289730877,
-0.0775758177,
0.034041483,
0.0346630663,
0.0446019582,
0.0291309785,
-0.0146688772,
0.0317417979,
-0.0146604758,
0.0153929535,
-0.0213033035,
0.0164397787,
-0.0076040747,
0.017692795,
0.0263376981,
-0.0391861945,
-0.0241927598,
-0.025113171,
0.0236256402,
0.0186587218,
0.018227024,
0.0294556916,
0.0307098888,
0.0227996204,
0.0161261,
0.0013936288,
-0.0366744585,
0.0736282766,
-0.0823499039,
-0.0687482357,
-0.0837763697,
-0.0500988141,
0.0324682482,
0.0340685211,
0.0140420469,
-0.0069921147,
0.0395167209,
-0.0205549691,
-0.0214597955,
0.0128420461,
-0.050841637,
0.0144892465,
0.0388380364,
-0.0318068378,
0.012388574,
-0.0057657813,
0.0307647642,
0.0308576766,
-0.0216841474,
0.0696059316,
2.319811699e-34,
0.0506226607,
-0.0065015447,
-0.0308697522,
0.0153290033,
0.0151225636,
-0.0044820192,
-0.030578861,
0.0062014139,
0.0135875344,
-0.0402842946,
-0.015770521
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15211v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15211v1 | Probabilistic Transformer: A Probabilistic Dependency Model for Contextual Word Representation | 2023-11-26T06:56:02 | 2023-11-26T06:56:02 | Haoyi Wu, Kewei Tu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Syntactic structures used to play a vital role in natural language processing
(NLP), but since the deep learning revolution, NLP has been gradually dominated
by neural models that do not consider syntactic structures in their design. One
vastly successful class of neural models is transformers. When used as an
encoder, a transformer produces contextual representation of words in the input
sentence. In this work, we propose a new model of contextual word
representation, not from a neural perspective, but from a purely syntactic and
probabilistic perspective. Specifically, we design a conditional random field
that models discrete latent representations of all words in a sentence as well
as dependency arcs between them; and we use mean field variational inference
for approximate inference. Strikingly, we find that the computation graph of
our model resembles transformers, with correspondences between dependencies and
self-attention and between distributions over latent representations and
contextual embeddings of words. Experiments show that our model performs
competitively to transformers on small to medium sized datasets. We hope that
our work could help bridge the gap between traditional syntactic and
probabilistic approaches and cutting-edge neural approaches to NLP, and inspire
more linguistically-principled neural approaches in the future. | [
0.0328504629,
0.1027637646,
0.0009497253,
0.0608481206,
-0.0314936936,
-0.0195639469,
-0.0028224394,
-0.0122721167,
-0.0184030961,
-0.0478564501,
0.0092005888,
-0.046554748,
-0.0167512409,
0.0415957123,
0.0179055873,
-0.0992322341,
0.0062955194,
-0.0095778592,
-0.0213351715,
0.00415128,
0.0226747524,
0.0007812959,
-0.0316138528,
0.0258400925,
-0.0732508749,
-0.029676009,
0.0250006691,
-0.014979084,
0.0427204929,
-0.0020357058,
0.0219214745,
0.0507535078,
0.0111547066,
-0.0063945632,
0.0000019344,
-0.0249615125,
-0.0239033774,
-0.0164561179,
0.0082441093,
-0.0305189062,
0.0249057561,
-0.0304319113,
-0.0275971089,
-0.0205514338,
-0.0101616457,
-0.0364372656,
0.0527562536,
0.0911983401,
0.0082771564,
0.0407849103,
-0.025717862,
-0.0830124617,
0.0224118568,
-0.0420414992,
0.0498651601,
-0.0299724787,
-0.0060402551,
-0.0155044599,
-0.0462243408,
0.0219893847,
-0.0717255846,
0.0265232362,
0.0487257726,
0.0105045876,
0.0310697332,
0.0698503926,
-0.0131300325,
0.0010361649,
0.0004656916,
0.0747154653,
-0.0536860861,
-0.0362761542,
-0.0201605782,
-0.0409589633,
-0.0329839587,
0.0590952113,
-0.0340540968,
0.0659882575,
-0.0153917363,
0.0348921716,
0.0122146811,
0.0420827679,
0.0412272029,
-0.004330324,
-0.0309490096,
0.0412423834,
0.0350471698,
-0.0107074454,
-0.0196161307,
-0.0051897676,
-0.0584427603,
-0.0187260676,
0.0141374096,
-0.0157933217,
0.0054226853,
0.0265039578,
-0.0259619672,
-0.0509931631,
-0.0042744507,
-0.0243558809,
-0.0287247468,
0.0255864263,
-0.0160797723,
0.0386058688,
-0.0018510587,
0.0198157374,
-0.0740825385,
-0.0203138329,
-0.0393137485,
-0.0075646369,
-0.0179690961,
-0.0146092288,
-0.0216222778,
0.0118924025,
-0.0226088353,
-0.0340553895,
-0.0369741656,
0.0227738582,
-0.0139588276,
-0.0175475646,
0.0299593639,
0.070857048,
-0.0325669348,
-0.0065538608,
-0.036511872,
0.0034974969,
-0.0503265187,
-0.0041886405,
-0.0088380883,
-0.0264419615,
-0.0190939195,
0.0468899943,
0.0380024314,
-0.0326775201,
-0.0196498688,
0.0590653233,
0.0255336743,
-0.0577463172,
-0.0383205414,
-0.0047164387,
-0.0385229699,
-0.0381696932,
0.0400181562,
-0.0609300397,
-0.0099788895,
0.0224117376,
0.0340947732,
-0.0194175355,
0.0047930321,
0.0353494436,
-0.0047164909,
0.1067454666,
0.0429403074,
-0.0447386242,
0.000500587,
-0.0077373092,
0.0245639663,
0.0463002361,
0.0282366462,
0.0203840882,
0.0137360962,
0.0219394341,
0.003544878,
0.0229078103,
-0.0171394665,
-0.0254852697,
-0.0198767632,
-0.0300127156,
-0.0148254149,
0.0155020338,
0.0537241586,
0.0599771664,
-0.0162153486,
-0.0437272862,
0.038640216,
0.0400889516,
0.0348830745,
0.0257987026,
0.065914914,
0.0219791643,
-0.0307968799,
0.0124239419,
-0.0486060604,
0.0578643344,
0.0166773312,
0.0107234502,
-0.018606849,
0.010057494,
-0.0221519843,
-0.0009226795,
0.004788097,
-0.0590808131,
0.0053992476,
-0.0350281745,
0.0673107058,
0.0404689014,
-0.0340950266,
0.0708556697,
0.035499379,
-0.0188489053,
-0.0371867977,
0.0089197913,
-0.0083529158,
0.0320559293,
0.0263837334,
-0.0284137707,
0.0217821412,
-0.01852105,
-0.0199346859,
0.0756215602,
0.0160206649,
0.0140160089,
-0.0114359902,
-0.0287029352,
-0.0215890687,
-0.0008234333,
0.0158591829,
0.0052050422,
-0.0057394477,
-0.0124907084,
0.0306506474,
-0.041485481,
0.0244897064,
0.0390820578,
0.004918023,
-0.0372228138,
0.0175168831,
0.0208225138,
0.0441000909,
0.010203043,
-0.0133057283,
0.05861523,
0.0430400595,
-0.0562230013,
-0.0138258077,
0.0556254126,
-0.066177927,
-0.0676221997,
-0.0080899876,
-0.0688580051,
-0.0197451096,
0.0251192003,
-0.0392097495,
-0.0403886102,
0.0242197067,
-0.0550279915,
0.0701931864,
-0.0277018826,
-0.0176980495,
0.0336959623,
0.04554905,
-0.0059707905,
0.0750428885,
-0.0424706824,
0.0309510678,
-0.0240192227,
0.0665517449,
0.0253488645,
-0.0215880163,
-0.0157100447,
-0.0193413626,
-0.0187439546,
0.0051487964,
0.043046169,
-0.0113260057,
-0.0359145887,
-0.021782361,
-0.0690517351,
-0.0087171374,
-0.0226152893,
-0.0040091262,
0.0173072536,
0.0381254256,
0.0314397253,
0.0006977804,
0.0095186252,
0.0181371458,
-0.0107963104,
0.0103356522,
0.0390275493,
-0.074842371,
-0.0082868962,
-0.0259275194,
-0.0355061889,
-0.027110884,
0.0722101852,
0.0110595059,
-0.0140101891,
-0.0126193892,
0.02581135,
0.01361732,
0.0581914522,
-0.0250232816,
-0.0122773107,
0.0300261863,
-0.0605237931,
0.0685079172,
0.0686862692,
0.0024753634,
0.0645849183,
0.0233523995,
0.0001167817,
-0.0133948661,
0.0069868946,
-0.0423194282,
0.0235329662,
-0.0289705135,
-0.0244011935,
-0.0131162079,
0.0891350433,
0.0102820694,
-0.0086995466,
-0.0496365614,
-0.0215456113,
-0.0160831176,
-0.0408596247,
0.0062149828,
0.0293526482,
-0.0516999513,
0.0223169439,
-0.0263659637,
-0.0260258708,
0.0598585717,
-0.0018649679,
0.0234453045,
-0.0233416948,
0.0269269291,
0.0054749739,
0.0650380105,
0.0723441094,
-0.0072193919,
0.0175640043,
-0.0255091116,
-0.0341863371,
0.0315471329,
-0.0011107589,
-0.0185485072,
0.0148613239,
-0.0369103961,
0.032433331,
0.022200983,
-0.0065018213,
-0.0518565625,
-0.0613073856,
-0.0184924919,
0.0181655828,
0.0437305793,
-0.0269653853,
-0.0169932861,
0.0154947815,
-0.0010972718,
0.0391966887,
-0.0027218172,
-0.0171185266,
-0.0256116763,
0.0980787575,
0.0408352055,
0.0011841611,
0.0212132968,
-0.0322422683,
-0.024304118,
0.0560164042,
0.0458719581,
0.0252388138,
-0.0535583794,
0.0133174211,
-0.0218293834,
-0.0205377247,
-0.0174850319,
-0.0055319974,
0.0047510313,
-0.0168820266,
-0.0474684015,
0.1094237864,
0.03031395,
-0.0607261434,
0.0135732191,
0.006738524,
0.0026476712,
0.0175797734,
0.0084570376,
-0.0797607899,
-0.0567563362,
-0.0048463345,
-0.0217544585,
0.0120696267,
-0.0453430638,
0.0421255454,
-0.0888321102,
0.0086632287,
-0.0360051207,
-0.0263101067,
-0.0604288206,
-0.0293249153,
-0.0070437314,
-0.0064599407,
0.0177890826,
-0.0331952013,
-0.0118626431,
0.015660869,
0.0161452815,
0.0183721781,
-0.0261762571,
0.0088842623,
-0.0408949964,
0.0378554426,
0.0622659698,
0.0043985904,
-0.0235406999,
-0.0068045193,
0.0132773714,
-0.0537568182,
-0.008269256,
-0.0162650701,
0.0610782839,
-0.0184491444,
-0.0257204827,
-0.0193819925,
-0.0139219062,
-0.0581608005,
-0.0643060356,
-0.0528057702,
0.0645532683,
-0.0291229505,
0.0014955235,
-0.0370050706,
0.0028421602,
0.0122930855,
0.0456383489,
0.0247751717,
-0.0444981977,
-0.0034681421,
-0.0351712294,
0.0622103214,
-0.0247931015,
-0.0313141309,
-0.0080750193,
0.0418173149,
-0.0298591182,
-0.0370688327,
-0.0427433737,
0.0018269987,
0.0189956371,
-0.0325236432,
-0.005472926,
0.0461819321,
-0.0360330306,
-0.0538781844,
0.0368646607,
-0.0085684601,
0.0141157554,
0.0035214613,
-0.0066636978,
0.0560352169,
-0.0288766194,
-0.0512353107,
0.0125187822,
-0.0973097906,
-0.0249963421,
0.0136134094,
0.0553859472,
0.0155298105,
0.0262054,
-0.0433577485,
-0.0328944288,
-0.0009354972,
0.0121196723,
-0.0146168284,
0.0362821594,
0.0146800196,
0.0164626129,
0.0257886443,
0.024536252,
-0.0210844576,
0.0174404718,
0.0026886885,
0.0778709948,
-0.0353732705,
-0.046255745,
0.0358807258,
-0.0438033678,
0.0610693879,
-0.0139624868,
-0.0049201818,
-0.043248307,
0.006445887,
-0.0190335046,
-0.0183512885,
-0.0233457461,
0.0268325098,
0.036819797,
0.0374745056,
-0.0167963449,
0.0224364493,
0.0007692766,
0.036096476,
0.0093892561,
0.0090193264,
0.0380943194,
-0.0443243645,
-0.0050355773,
0.0170253552,
0.0068217651,
-0.0072213006,
0.002948036,
0.0237417165,
0.0067015309,
0.0626671836,
0.009866639,
-0.0220028069,
-0.0566434748,
-0.0396501943,
-0.0724151954,
0.0253333971,
-0.0102478955,
0.0516015626,
0.0277101099,
-0.0628745556,
0.0555544682,
-0.0551583841,
0.0115927355,
-0.0145829869,
-0.0032446543,
0.0288970023,
-0.0013533316,
0.0732629597,
0.0306946933,
0.0132890185,
0.0025101979,
0.0493863598,
-0.0010135262,
0.0251082946,
-0.0252661649,
0.0027245127,
-0.0631531179,
-0.0025391784,
-0.0057134251,
0.0379315838,
-0.0151426969,
0.0222944207,
-0.0440939628,
-0.0572865494,
0.0335508361,
-0.0127195558,
-0.0023925807,
-0.0425958112,
0.0329982527,
0.0472208038,
0.0094947545,
-0.0137887262,
-0.0394174606,
0.045341786,
0.0113632409,
-0.0295623951,
-0.0595112555,
-6.551444379e-33,
-0.013640766,
-0.0532886423,
-0.0390824936,
-0.0026527343,
-0.0180998333,
0.0206560511,
-0.0550678074,
-0.0151311783,
-0.0229306016,
0.0554657429,
-0.0215540733,
0.0418189541,
0.0233294442,
0.0744920298,
0.009543594,
-0.0411264747,
0.0124377338,
-0.0369003862,
0.0467237979,
-0.0001085812,
0.0488996692,
0.0378128439,
0.0534041077,
-0.0540113226,
0.024000328,
-0.0411341563,
-0.0035787439,
0.0557755642,
-0.0239062812,
0.0532824285,
-0.0485365838,
0.0316662975,
0.0351455994,
-0.0165263303,
0.0013377364,
0.0194605254,
-0.1008024141,
-0.0274169911,
-0.0125862453,
0.0184865724,
-0.0610412806,
-0.009738028,
0.0750838965,
-0.0090076197,
0.0109154284,
-0.0072133527,
0.0616094247,
0.0013545942,
-0.0327734128,
-0.0333250538,
-0.0766125992,
0.022929877,
0.0127974069,
0.0179910306,
0.0163325444,
-0.0174012836,
0.0138100982,
0.051142469,
-0.0208346397,
-0.0221623313,
-0.0271707475,
0.0509743802,
0.014822185,
0.036007043,
-0.0044061118,
0.0364015326,
0.0321963839,
-0.0651531518,
-0.0367210098,
-0.025358703,
0.0059013134,
0.0146426922,
0.0034084003,
0.022451194,
0.0260306317,
0.0257889461,
-0.041060742,
-0.0231976341,
0.0182916597,
0.0721459538,
0.0120054847,
0.0142909884,
-0.0310372841,
0.0001756025,
-0.0266011693,
-0.0490327738,
-0.0125756618,
0.0151074827,
-0.004988526,
-0.0047880597,
-0.0111695481,
0.0111821685,
0.0241661556,
-0.0535887517,
-0.0053026197,
0.0280180797,
0.0287734494,
0.0492297746,
-0.008648444,
0.0410038754,
-0.0488239601,
-0.0109487595,
-0.0146065243,
-0.0139247905,
-0.0063650049,
0.0056330292,
-0.0042432058,
0.0147030223,
-0.0456474423,
-0.0199463069,
-0.0637305975,
-0.0516361296,
-0.0276648998,
0.068542622,
0.0394026525,
0.0196396578,
-0.0338879153,
0.0310019869,
0.0283965189,
0.0308740623,
0.0167355295,
-0.0008610365,
-0.0063569131,
0.0404515266,
-0.034702342,
-0.046501819,
-0.0398141034,
0.0389074832,
0.0615537949,
-0.0672598407,
-0.0012464103,
0.0318075009,
2.663e-7,
0.1082837805,
0.0319475606,
0.0366415866,
0.0301530156,
0.0218302552,
0.0354880951,
0.012458832,
0.0165760051,
-0.0201689117,
-0.0280620679,
0.0216586199,
0.043915391,
0.0116565051,
-0.0135589642,
-0.080265224,
0.0380982086,
-0.052326899,
-0.0204265956,
0.024747882,
-0.0028839374,
0.0444541648,
0.1275074482,
0.0176267251,
-0.0188072864,
0.0082880305,
-0.006592181,
0.0671175197,
-0.0119903991,
0.0168743953,
-0.0205872133,
-0.0054574641,
-0.028444035,
-0.0243042652,
0.038504418,
-0.0133483745,
0.0019926615,
0.0396783054,
0.0504593849,
0.0062499382,
-0.0284601748,
-0.0000191853,
-0.0199921113,
0.027747361,
-0.0272056069,
0.0635510385,
-0.0644888729,
-0.0100637302,
-0.0059434716,
-0.0488766953,
0.0478541777,
0.0152350888,
0.020251492,
-0.0544557907,
-0.0124485567,
0.0117560001,
0.0187411737,
-0.0444112271,
-0.0857356042,
-0.0365090296,
0.0216653012,
-0.0657763779,
-0.0160542857,
-0.0359278321,
-0.0440715365,
0.0730177984,
-0.008832546,
-0.0395515859,
2.544257651e-34,
0.0423379466,
0.0474179052,
-0.0095801,
-0.0028568835,
-0.0213818792,
-0.0039512273,
0.0020928255,
0.0251593012,
0.0155964317,
-0.0764601529,
-0.025867112
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15208v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15208v1 | LongStory: Coherent, Complete and Length Controlled Long story Generation | 2023-11-26T06:24:25 | 2023-11-26T06:24:25 | Kyeongman Park, Nakyeong Yang, Kyomin Jung | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | A human author can write any length of story without losing coherence. Also,
they always bring the story to a proper ending, an ability that current
language models lack. In this work, we present the LongStory for coherent,
complete, and length-controlled long story generation. LongStory introduces two
novel methodologies: (1) the long and short-term contexts weight calibrator
(CWC) and (2) long story structural positions (LSP). The CWC adjusts weights
for long-term context Memory and short-term context Cheating, acknowledging
their distinct roles. The LSP employs discourse tokens to convey the structural
positions of a long story. Trained on three datasets with varied average story
lengths, LongStory outperforms other baselines, including the strong story
generator Plotmachine, in coherence, completeness, relevance, and
repetitiveness. We also perform zero-shot tests on each dataset to assess the
model's ability to predict outcomes beyond its training data and validate our
methodology by comparing its performance with variants of our model. | [
0.014902425,
0.0383956023,
-0.0217315089,
0.0135764768,
-0.0582258739,
-0.0280320924,
0.0042960481,
-0.0187354553,
-0.0255148355,
-0.0204318371,
0.0208616313,
-0.0399015732,
0.0566863641,
0.0920852944,
-0.0042625391,
-0.040801324,
0.0055476362,
0.0026670708,
0.0331248529,
0.0221519098,
-0.0098696649,
0.0103830518,
0.0142543009,
0.0353049487,
-0.0479310006,
-0.0325322635,
-0.0287963171,
0.0245909095,
0.03607722,
-0.056928914,
0.0094634527,
0.0136443581,
0.0146487588,
0.013821586,
0.0000019943,
-0.061576996,
-0.0140052792,
-0.0218170378,
0.025196204,
-0.009275631,
-0.0009532169,
-0.0078310659,
0.0253486391,
0.0088757826,
-0.0248952806,
0.0487188287,
0.004100801,
0.0744993314,
0.0374015309,
0.0810225755,
-0.0155300424,
-0.0604276806,
-0.0103340102,
-0.0243489016,
0.0195069294,
-0.0172930229,
-0.015564722,
0.0024594811,
0.0402460322,
0.0021642454,
-0.039556291,
0.0048494986,
0.0472212546,
-0.0101847416,
0.0068146987,
0.0712506622,
0.0035237458,
0.03549698,
0.0097877961,
0.0501618683,
0.0303425323,
-0.0449188165,
0.0170762595,
-0.0027124786,
0.0168072246,
-0.0514358766,
-0.0387662686,
0.0545118637,
-0.0071291924,
0.018503705,
0.0442973971,
0.0154798785,
-0.0123376986,
-0.0015217189,
0.0233753752,
-0.0008465211,
0.0221855212,
-0.0057330155,
-0.0744407102,
-0.012236448,
-0.0215998515,
-0.0925998613,
0.025713848,
0.0611497015,
-0.0349172689,
0.0038441403,
-0.0652360991,
0.0132960193,
0.0209314805,
-0.0581305735,
-0.000819011,
0.0308200605,
-0.0198567398,
0.0134197557,
-0.0294387974,
0.0463448353,
0.0239200946,
-0.0688319579,
-0.0371866301,
0.0118663758,
-0.032417506,
0.0022996627,
-0.0517999046,
0.0129852816,
-0.0449688919,
-0.0493703932,
-0.0688274801,
0.01467642,
0.0388042703,
-0.0121493535,
-0.0194382407,
0.0461047664,
-0.028040031,
0.0243597738,
-0.0183096454,
0.0244280715,
-0.0661211163,
-0.0034089845,
0.0456524864,
0.0285088252,
-0.0236796457,
0.0302362293,
0.0200953875,
-0.0180117507,
0.0012838468,
0.0108571583,
-0.0142005486,
0.0062083188,
-0.0426072069,
-0.0943443552,
-0.0568949468,
-0.0723525509,
-0.0532711409,
-0.0543460734,
0.0170682091,
0.0136651956,
0.0260512084,
-0.0458907038,
-0.0011564364,
0.0252180472,
-0.0159173533,
0.0138317263,
-0.0015624316,
-0.0070348331,
0.0314671099,
0.0160168521,
0.0072486429,
0.0328769684,
0.0762389675,
0.0639121607,
0.0300554037,
0.0258458275,
0.0148936389,
-0.0185221154,
-0.0026273618,
-0.0211723894,
-0.0207014196,
0.0012807847,
-0.0057211416,
0.0738027468,
0.0173546877,
0.0547144935,
-0.0175022017,
-0.0053604292,
0.0544085465,
0.0454233028,
0.0458648875,
0.0048870416,
0.1043939814,
-0.0104941484,
-0.0209268015,
0.0670827255,
-0.028698327,
0.0271439292,
0.0108069535,
0.0378446542,
0.0093110697,
-0.0034506393,
-0.007376207,
-0.0165079385,
-0.0005302719,
-0.0135498736,
0.0077797272,
-0.0371111631,
-0.0125132622,
0.0114160469,
-0.0530262142,
0.0128748408,
0.002710857,
-0.081375286,
0.0286658015,
0.021042753,
0.0550791584,
0.0952948779,
0.0493670404,
0.0108302748,
-0.0229523834,
-0.026868064,
0.0239579678,
0.0349470936,
-0.0096334321,
0.0014441498,
0.0201628301,
-0.0371564217,
-0.0039956286,
-0.0342728943,
0.0076276697,
0.0038794281,
0.0078952266,
0.0326036289,
0.0200623646,
-0.0284829438,
-0.0294280723,
0.0409869738,
-0.0606086515,
-0.0229021292,
-0.0039092326,
-0.0142219448,
-0.0116140684,
-0.0017671211,
-0.0155867403,
0.0108592995,
0.0286723375,
-0.0138348062,
-0.0313991457,
0.0548489988,
-0.090909183,
-0.0443016477,
0.0187335014,
-0.0556453764,
0.0165670644,
-0.0419543497,
0.0356747471,
-0.0794700384,
0.0248489864,
-0.0480353683,
0.0115203774,
-0.027960822,
0.026594324,
0.0023025302,
0.0025594356,
-0.0181739349,
0.0628690124,
0.0156943239,
-0.002486916,
0.0170755703,
0.0011524564,
0.016230803,
-0.026631806,
0.0185245313,
0.0086535402,
0.0145577351,
-0.0052759303,
0.0511725731,
-0.0143912667,
-0.0246834159,
-0.0727166757,
-0.1351816207,
0.0261583999,
0.0033717921,
-0.0271275155,
0.0338679738,
-0.0097432546,
-0.021612443,
0.0159338675,
-0.0645170733,
-0.0264574699,
0.0106938137,
-0.0076027513,
0.0285904538,
0.0148123996,
-0.0023200088,
-0.0323103406,
0.0257142745,
-0.005413861,
0.0638096854,
0.0453964584,
0.0080663962,
-0.0553475469,
0.0498441346,
-0.0074414606,
-0.0264172871,
-0.0199377146,
-0.0231720656,
0.0332023129,
0.0385202132,
0.0979128927,
0.0405030921,
0.0471221097,
0.0177879464,
0.0479233153,
-0.0353210978,
-0.0041472269,
0.0045436462,
-0.0218932554,
0.0434716232,
-0.0251663569,
-0.0367917195,
0.0020719136,
0.0621013641,
0.032407064,
0.0140853804,
-0.0227615945,
-0.0163526777,
0.0019030976,
-0.0134778293,
0.0437909029,
-0.0357193314,
-0.0235110559,
0.0167086013,
-0.0094527397,
-0.0345350131,
0.0789347664,
-0.0598443002,
0.0200346597,
-0.0074672601,
-0.0065488014,
-0.0698736086,
0.0894050449,
0.0005156132,
0.0272853225,
-0.0002373985,
0.0016157172,
-0.0318167247,
-0.0151313981,
0.0259222668,
-0.0062253615,
0.0090678865,
-0.0293384157,
-0.0112529332,
0.0078779636,
-0.0161016602,
-0.0548665337,
-0.0620062761,
-0.002979751,
0.0039178738,
0.0352978408,
-0.0256682299,
-0.0220159795,
0.0008953291,
0.0258950815,
0.0490678474,
-0.032138411,
-0.0097153978,
-0.0106865242,
0.0399365053,
0.0681635141,
0.0003231641,
-0.0051737921,
-0.0582051389,
0.0384068899,
0.03672475,
-0.0403584875,
0.0453103669,
-0.0083738053,
0.0038225141,
-0.0132202143,
-0.0303259455,
-0.044483725,
0.0275791213,
0.0843723491,
-0.0619830228,
-0.0253594592,
0.1338165849,
0.0175496377,
-0.0137761822,
0.0237792619,
0.0125985118,
0.0608509965,
0.0258068182,
-0.006596311,
-0.074774906,
-0.0150293829,
0.0277426261,
0.0036161481,
-0.0085113663,
-0.0547775552,
-0.0228995495,
-0.071508646,
0.0286853295,
0.0254901517,
-0.0339804143,
0.0107496874,
-0.0193531066,
-0.0469656922,
0.0463361479,
0.0063010375,
0.0266083796,
-0.0156856533,
0.0114472192,
-0.0329339392,
-0.038243942,
-0.0022578109,
-0.0162777361,
-0.0560015105,
0.0484579764,
0.0404235087,
0.0743623972,
0.0243617091,
0.0288707986,
0.012210222,
0.0000922774,
0.0250296611,
0.000842239,
0.0519183166,
-0.0317962095,
0.0095152548,
-0.0316465423,
0.0777123496,
-0.0021602658,
-0.0553223006,
0.0402831472,
0.0348645076,
-0.0194535088,
-0.0387605801,
-0.0102788145,
0.0326495692,
0.0141550591,
0.0754083693,
0.063169919,
-0.0557369255,
-0.062596634,
-0.0207874961,
0.0250647459,
-0.0570277274,
0.0306836125,
-0.0184023473,
-0.0140875531,
0.0622168407,
-0.0888130888,
-0.0839693174,
0.0112635493,
0.0462864637,
0.0188612584,
0.028779326,
-0.0299051665,
-0.0389868505,
-0.0637942255,
-0.0090860827,
-0.027337458,
0.0327592678,
-0.0387813076,
0.0346967354,
0.0220457967,
-0.0614986829,
0.0248807538,
0.0446740054,
-0.0610295795,
-0.0561323017,
-0.0050356118,
-0.0214225221,
0.0141452672,
0.0608078018,
0.0137669202,
-0.0275386274,
0.0588953868,
0.0046463506,
-0.0595056824,
0.071121484,
-0.0287922621,
0.0293556284,
0.0011031618,
-0.0041642403,
-0.0156098669,
-0.003314004,
0.006946167,
0.0694256723,
0.0137007488,
0.0004827415,
0.0113408314,
-0.0088333217,
-0.0160007533,
-0.0664003044,
0.001606839,
-0.0479950532,
-0.0148867192,
-0.0697526857,
-0.0183221791,
-0.0164912269,
0.0319906473,
0.0336141698,
0.0054275678,
-0.0006857876,
-0.0007049938,
-0.0478983261,
0.0158350561,
-0.0386586376,
0.000905515,
-0.010223194,
-0.0349628441,
0.0054464601,
0.0067450386,
-0.0089599639,
0.0083248317,
-0.0567944534,
0.0595602728,
-0.0246972255,
0.0357794426,
0.0249794461,
0.0103127137,
-0.0072795735,
0.0047759279,
-0.0745159388,
0.0714555904,
-0.013401594,
0.0110140899,
0.0738697201,
-0.0064092171,
0.0736746639,
-0.0091593433,
0.0221997034,
-0.0086528827,
0.0580872484,
0.0025025851,
-0.0201968793,
-0.071549952,
0.0197346192,
-0.0424848348,
0.0393311493,
0.0659679398,
0.0034720846,
0.0267439783,
0.0264349878,
-0.0086247353,
-0.0174559075,
-0.0300465282,
-0.0080859279,
0.0388722345,
0.0174569115,
-0.0303065274,
-0.0470745899,
-0.0277338382,
0.0806986019,
0.0010903225,
0.0172538217,
-0.0307520684,
0.008272022,
0.0135112572,
-0.0141644096,
-0.0032336011,
-0.0386996232,
0.0071537877,
0.0415430777,
-0.0230505839,
-0.0479869395,
-5.77572831e-33,
-0.025330035,
-0.0662485138,
0.028412018,
0.0065358696,
-0.0658514425,
0.031086579,
-0.0509820804,
-0.0039540515,
0.0481068119,
0.0349350125,
-0.0003343498,
-0.0104564363,
-0.0008165521,
0.0364154875,
-0.0161503516,
0.0275711976,
0.043982774,
0.0211876724,
-0.0638080016,
0.0380752943,
0.0661402345,
0.0419116989,
-0.0123327868,
-0.0109467814,
0.0118863117,
-0.0318497457,
-0.0198660679,
-0.0068143737,
0.0255117323,
0.0321526416,
-0.0205294583,
0.0154105788,
0.0322391279,
0.0026881918,
-0.0293093231,
0.0033467573,
-0.0705312118,
-0.021324819,
0.0248458181,
-0.0181885362,
-0.0351717323,
-0.0469762199,
0.0352376141,
-0.0339243449,
-0.0094698733,
-0.0335531309,
0.0445752926,
-0.0216275584,
-0.017898513,
-0.0325412825,
-0.0814943761,
-0.0013520668,
-0.0032510881,
-0.0428771116,
-0.0514869206,
0.0102984691,
0.0208989531,
-0.0198727213,
-0.0485449918,
0.0179366972,
-0.0419464819,
0.0329302251,
-0.0210534241,
0.0176459495,
-0.0161436871,
0.0917942598,
0.0427636318,
0.0327515379,
-0.0681983009,
0.0257193949,
-0.006361797,
0.004970524,
0.045731511,
0.0379603617,
0.0293994285,
-0.0367220826,
-0.040578302,
0.0393388346,
-0.0206399821,
0.0067802989,
0.0327357613,
-0.0033493072,
-0.0154780103,
-0.0516905598,
-0.0496664196,
-0.0176823139,
0.0004116933,
-0.0213438775,
0.0269615799,
0.0203698333,
0.0146532282,
-0.0050671385,
0.0224287994,
-0.0254554115,
0.009374884,
0.0306512769,
-0.0495588556,
0.0354582705,
0.0186976623,
0.0335765481,
0.0164710451,
0.0002839887,
0.048448272,
0.0234053433,
0.0421653092,
-0.0135619445,
0.0536975861,
0.0416735858,
-0.0379445665,
0.011473611,
-0.0305837952,
0.009222649,
-0.0167314466,
-0.0337020606,
0.0049400078,
0.010547746,
-0.0144378301,
0.0291745216,
-0.0137778586,
0.0271451846,
-0.0400576703,
-0.044435598,
-0.0020561116,
0.0368836708,
-0.033254616,
0.0405231714,
0.0022045271,
0.0540185235,
0.0277222581,
-0.0524010248,
0.0094587021,
0.0043477947,
2.619e-7,
-0.017598033,
0.0002617769,
0.0663830042,
-0.0091477185,
0.0010924394,
0.0063204458,
-0.0051483028,
0.0268502533,
-0.0199723393,
-0.0243260469,
-0.0106543927,
0.0195792336,
0.0460370593,
0.0267924722,
-0.0798140243,
0.0314966142,
-0.0798960328,
-0.0310173463,
-0.0744595826,
-0.0187461078,
0.0704053789,
0.0108163478,
0.0256163012,
-0.0023216368,
0.0222830065,
-0.0561254583,
0.067757234,
-0.0230843145,
-0.0370889567,
0.0289758425,
-0.0343133993,
-0.0104385354,
-0.0018622461,
-0.0528305285,
-0.0114561971,
0.0239233151,
-0.013254283,
0.0417125858,
-0.0053050523,
-0.0236047115,
0.0258811787,
0.0009918211,
-0.0367027856,
-0.023125397,
0.038959261,
-0.0306799579,
-0.0170071572,
-0.0239096154,
-0.0014320924,
0.0084206434,
-0.0064610913,
-0.0069125751,
-0.0045531853,
0.0261662826,
0.0110227186,
0.0223944671,
0.0089054592,
-0.0578107089,
-0.0593727678,
0.0204883572,
-0.0481422059,
0.0125213107,
-0.0300791226,
-0.0262576025,
0.0011955193,
-0.0789097399,
0.01539612,
2.611466311e-34,
0.0632671937,
-0.0297705941,
-0.0058869375,
0.0144910347,
0.0473817475,
-0.0142891156,
0.0202494636,
0.0126510151,
0.0460357182,
-0.0243669935,
-0.0575261526
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15198v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15198v1 | ChatGPT and Beyond: The Generative AI Revolution in Education | 2023-11-26T05:34:22 | 2023-11-26T05:34:22 | Mohammad AL-Smadi | cs.CY | cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL | The wide adoption and usage of generative artificial intelligence (AI)
models, particularly ChatGPT, has sparked a surge in research exploring their
potential applications in the educational landscape. This survey examines
academic literature published between November, 2022, and July, 2023,
specifically targeting high-impact research from Scopus-indexed Q1 and Q2
journals. This survey delves into the practical applications and implications
of generative AI models across a diverse range of educational contexts. Through
a comprehensive and rigorous evaluation of recent academic literature, this
survey seeks to illuminate the evolving role of generative AI models,
particularly ChatGPT, in education. By shedding light on the potential
benefits, challenges, and emerging trends in this dynamic field, the survey
endeavors to contribute to the understanding of the nexus between artificial
intelligence and education. The findings of this review will empower educators,
researchers, and policymakers to make informed decisions about the integration
of AI technologies into learning environments. | [
0.0364557169,
0.0277888346,
-0.0598991923,
-0.0319793522,
-0.0544469021,
0.0066526448,
0.051279366,
-0.0515706055,
0.047651533,
-0.0266107917,
0.0084780036,
0.0113659808,
-0.0527277365,
0.0327076241,
0.0187745038,
-0.0829785839,
0.0093807736,
-0.0011684292,
0.0028791572,
0.0146626923,
-0.0396040976,
0.020198131,
-0.0389969423,
0.0873421803,
-0.0470925681,
-0.0551038906,
-0.0041838977,
-0.0153875332,
-0.0039645266,
-0.0232214071,
0.0066302335,
0.0190745182,
0.0432363488,
0.0432596132,
0.0000024668,
-0.042060528,
-0.0130659658,
0.0172155425,
-0.0187940653,
0.0068572583,
0.0366203114,
0.1015064716,
-0.0309131667,
-0.0029108955,
-0.0819840059,
0.0309169311,
0.0536922477,
-0.0152029209,
0.0050222976,
0.017092837,
0.0001745406,
-0.0088383239,
0.0617979951,
0.0106415078,
0.0558371134,
0.0226563923,
0.0014309902,
0.0451186784,
0.0486545004,
0.0003969637,
-0.0216019619,
0.0268417019,
0.0269796252,
-0.0355997123,
0.0215853769,
0.0413984433,
-0.0235568304,
-0.0437819026,
-0.0030512717,
0.0094531151,
0.0238551758,
-0.0063259983,
0.0235541631,
-0.005398802,
0.058219213,
0.0467924438,
-0.0769107565,
0.0467336476,
-0.0052625784,
0.0143791614,
0.0246976428,
0.0132695921,
-0.0096055539,
0.0113409124,
0.0288941693,
-0.0391444787,
0.026644012,
-0.0097011523,
-0.0207512137,
0.0393779725,
-0.0029113849,
-0.0090393526,
-0.0159557629,
0.0610118695,
0.0148122394,
0.0209947824,
-0.0082665207,
-0.0232995078,
0.0135958185,
-0.0078197448,
0.0080378447,
0.0671695918,
0.0125472145,
-0.0081750983,
0.0005717817,
0.0570217632,
0.007786755,
0.0288251676,
-0.0152258268,
0.042494256,
-0.1020623147,
-0.029110698,
-0.0489475131,
0.0488294773,
0.0077021699,
-0.0127974898,
-0.0176251382,
0.0441929139,
-0.0525527783,
0.0018807412,
0.0074669877,
0.0362608917,
-0.022490235,
0.0356493481,
-0.0256581176,
-0.0063716462,
-0.0167781729,
-0.0006676915,
0.0019219589,
-0.0456720814,
0.0116673149,
-0.0069118896,
-0.0158895161,
0.0174778234,
0.0003363399,
0.0736559704,
-0.0222861897,
-0.0285901204,
-0.007731508,
-0.0204771776,
0.0217342619,
-0.0518547297,
0.0608963259,
-0.0611252598,
0.0080831805,
-0.0262040477,
0.0197877754,
-0.01123913,
0.0080356076,
0.008187688,
0.0304158684,
0.0048991726,
0.0095751379,
0.0272165667,
0.0298732128,
0.0108497487,
-0.0230158735,
0.0402332656,
0.0592615791,
-0.0020752486,
-0.0135958139,
-0.0490536876,
0.0424393192,
-0.0095381849,
-0.029737629,
-0.0179733839,
0.0428027548,
-0.0599780828,
-0.0100113833,
0.0156782698,
-0.052447658,
0.0187254306,
-0.0384898037,
0.054121878,
0.0263795163,
0.0616446286,
-0.005144286,
0.0955807269,
0.0933335721,
-0.0050276816,
0.0587060861,
0.0078581506,
-0.0206681639,
0.048347909,
-0.0175304599,
0.0069279652,
-0.0428066254,
0.0710118935,
0.0010655643,
-0.0941442102,
0.031534601,
0.0104945209,
0.0187865198,
0.0162544455,
0.0462789163,
-0.0149699496,
-0.0061750999,
-0.0670283809,
-0.0012083797,
-0.0606892258,
0.0128301634,
-0.1242856607,
0.0427616425,
0.1114175543,
0.0990477949,
-0.0342936181,
-0.0573310293,
-0.0027423869,
-0.0396901332,
0.0455970429,
0.0080005815,
-0.0162776448,
-0.0536192507,
-0.0015949897,
-0.0069775693,
-0.0311702192,
0.0234029293,
0.0461689718,
0.005430215,
0.0069979625,
-0.0153848426,
0.0155319711,
-0.0423332453,
0.0093220575,
-0.0752070844,
-0.0308848359,
-0.029705517,
-0.0114529738,
0.0183170401,
0.0408944674,
-0.0262766685,
0.0150091527,
0.0262396168,
0.0133336801,
-0.0268809628,
0.0035175623,
-0.0581446961,
0.0352714173,
0.0179397985,
-0.0861167461,
0.0035045692,
-0.0235125925,
0.0026519091,
-0.0226562601,
0.0408366434,
-0.0050898744,
0.0546097048,
-0.0257688258,
0.0163302142,
-0.0193496346,
-0.0009428221,
-0.0139798364,
0.0246106144,
0.0382218696,
-0.0362204872,
0.0105098644,
0.041284699,
0.0309525337,
0.0164448544,
0.0126998695,
0.0259348284,
-0.0274991412,
0.0213688128,
0.0135527942,
0.0224990249,
-0.0340985022,
-0.0071328636,
-0.0792412683,
-0.023153672,
0.0333827846,
-0.0167458262,
0.0024508061,
-0.0435092524,
-0.0374987721,
0.0452263653,
-0.0293054506,
0.0165547468,
0.023867283,
-0.0454036556,
-0.0211542714,
-0.0204380825,
-0.0194943938,
-0.0456183106,
0.0075107682,
-0.0381825417,
0.0184298642,
0.1074973792,
-0.0144081432,
-0.0059054466,
0.0395580716,
-0.0160858575,
0.0224075522,
0.0049681747,
-0.0284430068,
0.0473830737,
-0.0331456922,
0.0712487474,
0.0328463353,
0.0020894841,
0.0498090461,
0.0366756618,
-0.0490668677,
-0.0377911627,
0.0375988744,
-0.022995716,
0.0126729924,
0.0211424977,
-0.0695232973,
-0.0271021184,
0.0067896536,
0.0180182122,
-0.0305653512,
-0.046617087,
0.0843457729,
-0.0105951428,
-0.005932604,
-0.0112704989,
-0.0433687009,
-0.0078289267,
0.0173915029,
-0.0027369375,
-0.0129753388,
0.0577277914,
0.0066574817,
0.0173604432,
-0.0404081978,
0.0168003514,
-0.0161907896,
0.0523973443,
0.0215354189,
-0.0060975021,
0.0168558639,
0.0375595056,
-0.0688583478,
0.0492000394,
0.0370403677,
-0.0411037765,
-0.010972593,
-0.0385380499,
-0.0389986001,
-0.0087582646,
0.004963737,
-0.0806694999,
0.0352176204,
0.0289489925,
-0.0128438771,
0.0541589744,
-0.0301753078,
-0.0216490664,
-0.0365636088,
0.0236566365,
0.0109699285,
-0.0355337523,
-0.0294853337,
-0.0137178935,
-0.0070095835,
0.0235480834,
-0.0415571071,
-0.0262971129,
0.0077141048,
0.0498252623,
0.0419385917,
0.0025007543,
-0.0229580235,
-0.0111693526,
0.0155521547,
0.0171884838,
0.0040844954,
0.0164263416,
0.0288063046,
0.0084541272,
-0.0372442566,
0.0021146359,
0.0458543114,
0.0129722422,
-0.0159552805,
0.0037847967,
-0.0230693184,
-0.0107795792,
-0.0152927525,
0.043930117,
-0.0804014429,
0.0334149972,
-0.0292243473,
0.0205033924,
-0.0737701729,
-0.0304161571,
0.0110034961,
-0.0753287077,
0.0816886872,
0.015718285,
-0.0279424321,
0.0140663991,
0.0034822696,
-0.0169063825,
0.0107210902,
-0.0352711752,
-0.0444050692,
-0.0086895255,
0.0461498611,
0.0465843491,
-0.0253942385,
-0.0194751192,
0.0102519281,
0.0430566594,
0.0383278057,
0.0711008236,
0.0372847356,
-0.0135279549,
-0.0267865825,
-0.0405117758,
0.0747548789,
0.0131813595,
0.0243167784,
0.0306492615,
-0.0028932211,
0.0138292592,
-0.0507211536,
0.0155034019,
0.0276734196,
-0.0198243633,
0.0625407994,
0.0833076462,
-0.0337607674,
-0.010524855,
-0.0871426985,
0.0045188642,
0.0068370826,
0.0429247282,
0.0240189657,
-0.0530520007,
0.0056003034,
-0.0562625676,
0.036817465,
-0.0469846055,
-0.041762203,
-0.0256933644,
0.0152659798,
-0.0346327834,
-0.0272116978,
-0.0462379046,
0.0219505895,
-0.0199652817,
0.0035917568,
-0.0224159714,
0.0233905967,
0.0152828051,
-0.0230152998,
-0.0222244505,
-0.01352158,
-0.0541518666,
-0.0201191269,
-0.1040640622,
-0.0097221266,
-0.0834286511,
-0.0034937218,
0.0385234915,
-0.0355975442,
-0.0295835324,
0.0175563451,
0.0655518845,
0.0192496665,
-0.0308831409,
0.0307096224,
0.0405288488,
0.0255808905,
0.0604435615,
0.0191354677,
-0.0141709698,
-0.0216184277,
0.0176411513,
0.0201207753,
-0.0562006086,
-0.0015142474,
0.0406215414,
0.0038568191,
0.0183963962,
-0.0100754872,
0.0037334538,
0.0335016362,
0.0176534057,
0.0289897639,
-0.0290568694,
-0.0005680598,
-0.0403092019,
-0.0369046032,
-0.0661060512,
0.0069173872,
-0.0474138334,
-0.0392525345,
0.0335444808,
0.0386702158,
0.0169043187,
-0.00548191,
-0.0178755522,
0.0262250938,
-0.0322895758,
0.020028783,
0.0024647259,
0.0434062965,
-0.0050732829,
-0.0188106485,
-0.0136569366,
0.0217773989,
-0.0342707634,
0.0291621778,
0.0130971204,
0.0709525719,
-0.004388825,
0.0070680571,
0.0426835567,
0.0211518817,
-0.0659294501,
-0.0584645979,
-0.0414983369,
0.0911847502,
0.0513738506,
0.0537645742,
-0.009475627,
-0.0672837198,
0.0181761626,
0.0123716686,
-0.0009431282,
0.0123751843,
-0.035684336,
-0.0518732667,
0.0068214661,
0.025249606,
-0.0633675084,
0.0334729142,
-0.0471936986,
0.0480061918,
-0.030530069,
-0.0018483865,
-0.0201093163,
-0.0420301519,
0.0041846661,
-0.0114283618,
0.0585336573,
0.0092551885,
-0.0553688779,
-0.0365555286,
-0.0476319492,
0.0329126306,
0.0102775395,
-0.0441027954,
0.0401272811,
0.0355270505,
-0.0655169785,
-0.0404135138,
0.0093151284,
0.0304782279,
-0.0502169617,
-0.0255275127,
-0.0075835213,
-6.474373826e-33,
-0.0393872149,
-0.0489840098,
0.0714369267,
0.0427859388,
-0.0222480409,
-0.0360859632,
-0.0316684432,
0.0264260955,
-0.0104076071,
-0.0007297402,
0.0007200711,
-0.0274693388,
-0.0233338624,
0.0222507752,
0.0282522831,
0.0195226986,
0.044877097,
-0.0171220731,
0.0063624666,
0.045811791,
-0.0106048929,
-0.0278460328,
0.0275209341,
-0.0449262671,
0.0098249698,
-0.0428844541,
-0.0125282388,
-0.0687177852,
-0.0506997481,
0.0158005711,
-0.0391590297,
0.0150539279,
0.0119444821,
-0.0084580742,
-0.0145583805,
0.0003141641,
-0.0404333994,
-0.0557889417,
-0.0104073714,
-0.0273538046,
-0.0091624735,
-0.0842661783,
0.018595241,
-0.0136471801,
-0.0529521331,
-0.0063537536,
0.0614229813,
-0.0133358054,
0.0254149754,
-0.0228442214,
-0.0941169038,
-0.0046163676,
-0.0472945161,
-0.0204723515,
0.0002074225,
0.0314763449,
0.0119843669,
-0.0328459069,
0.0068775993,
0.0788691565,
0.0466132499,
-0.0362231769,
0.0567886978,
-0.0009580058,
0.0441104807,
0.0236912444,
0.0582170114,
0.0212563742,
-0.0658351555,
-0.0214199182,
0.0190523528,
0.0101714488,
0.0513818562,
0.0570319444,
-0.0152844843,
-0.022511797,
-0.0455181263,
0.0460215174,
0.0259633977,
-0.0265986845,
0.016617693,
-0.0213843398,
-0.0448029302,
-0.0164607931,
0.027243549,
-0.0312151071,
0.01908697,
-0.0372324437,
0.0127096716,
-0.0709883273,
-0.0022429922,
-0.0030495229,
0.0029968903,
-0.0354833417,
0.0356067531,
0.039184045,
-0.0259657837,
0.0348151959,
-0.0037474148,
-0.0250497796,
-0.0199316684,
-0.0388902277,
0.0498621091,
0.0268186666,
0.0267408825,
0.0331013463,
-0.0020138684,
0.0310989656,
0.0170587059,
-0.0067422213,
-0.0363876522,
0.029223593,
0.0643108562,
-0.0993498117,
0.0144366128,
0.0163271166,
-0.0103917792,
-0.0378708728,
0.0312109347,
0.0397242829,
-0.0356411487,
-0.0023383964,
-0.0557207353,
-0.0278815143,
-0.0190058015,
0.0160933342,
-0.0564267412,
-0.0188198686,
0.0111571038,
-0.0663401857,
-0.0166581199,
-0.0150653226,
3.078e-7,
-0.0076274974,
0.0321037918,
0.0271822643,
-0.0138848145,
0.0112400623,
-0.0038742439,
0.0148503194,
-0.0315160044,
0.062124148,
0.0617445,
0.0430091731,
0.0429052785,
0.0091771251,
0.0185775254,
-0.0277702194,
-0.0266226083,
0.0058407248,
-0.0147520397,
-0.037941169,
0.0625440106,
0.1109670401,
-0.0176544022,
0.0520171672,
0.0049051405,
0.0069540464,
0.0126711568,
0.0147962552,
-0.0145539138,
0.0037574326,
0.0086140493,
-0.030446263,
0.0412213318,
0.0144711947,
-0.0032053185,
0.0012404416,
-0.0075907605,
0.0013712022,
0.0200360492,
0.0104009993,
0.018493861,
0.0465321019,
0.0116647538,
0.0003683133,
-0.0538107343,
0.0588644817,
-0.0597699955,
0.0149181318,
-0.0068565342,
-0.0378419422,
0.0089001441,
-0.0219473504,
-0.0281147938,
-0.0086096544,
-0.0105236527,
-0.0226061605,
-0.013676486,
0.0248707831,
0.0054727318,
0.026725335,
-0.0360226966,
-0.0332345441,
-0.058760535,
-0.0161491968,
-0.0111096296,
0.0127981585,
-0.0039111353,
0.0108921118,
2.600385211e-34,
0.0025890805,
-0.0287411045,
0.040540304,
-0.0183434933,
0.0091346847,
0.0225114617,
0.0114562139,
-0.0052436991,
0.0267075431,
-0.0046692798,
-0.0714339763
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03719v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03719v4 | Comparative Analysis of ChatGPT, GPT-4, and Microsoft Bing Chatbots for GRE Test | 2023-11-26T05:27:35 | 2024-04-06T18:37:05 | Mohammad Abu-Haifa, Bara'a Etawi, Huthaifa Alkhatatbeh, Ayman Ababneh | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This research paper presents an analysis of how well three artificial
intelligence chatbots: Bing, ChatGPT, and GPT-4, perform when answering
questions from standardized tests. The Graduate Record Examination is used in
this paper as a case study. A total of 137 questions with different forms of
quantitative reasoning and 157 questions with verbal categories were used to
assess their capabilities. This paper presents the performance of each chatbot
across various skills and styles tested in the exam. The proficiency of these
chatbots in addressing image-based questions is also explored, and the
uncertainty level of each chatbot is illustrated. The results show varying
degrees of success across the chatbots, where GPT-4 served as the most
proficient, especially in complex language understanding tasks and image-based
questions. Results highlight the ability of these chatbots to pass the GRE with
a high score, which encourages the use of these chatbots in test preparation.
The results also show how important it is to ensure that, if the test is
administered online, as it was during COVID, the test taker is segregated from
these resources for a fair competition on higher education opportunities. | [
0.0429797508,
-0.0152028585,
-0.040654052,
-0.0100732278,
-0.0509551056,
0.007170829,
0.0144948335,
-0.0000676009,
0.109317787,
-0.0474819168,
0.0350248553,
0.0110545922,
-0.0302186999,
0.0495133288,
0.0241136681,
-0.0611153692,
0.0092124948,
-0.0019179935,
0.0156231606,
-0.0169847813,
-0.0030123007,
-0.0001708751,
-0.0658797473,
0.0416442603,
-0.0630910769,
-0.0397431403,
-0.0337570012,
-0.0190282594,
-0.0099484036,
-0.0079291072,
-0.0029869739,
0.0299867261,
0.0102433534,
0.0306075532,
0.0000021153,
-0.0586321652,
-0.0290387794,
-0.0033103658,
-0.0287734084,
-0.0466376059,
0.0168564152,
0.0545450673,
-0.0180373732,
0.0391962118,
-0.0787706524,
0.0180146098,
0.0679447725,
-0.0118614305,
0.0391484275,
0.067289032,
-0.0073181782,
-0.0098146079,
0.0191597827,
0.026051132,
0.0050082118,
-0.0430626683,
-0.0096207326,
0.066824913,
0.0515878685,
-0.0161103886,
-0.0567875691,
0.0178157315,
0.0163594149,
-0.018727107,
-0.0236795321,
0.0359767228,
-0.0711969584,
-0.0358619168,
-0.020073561,
0.0154563114,
0.0288873687,
0.0118022803,
-0.0199224409,
0.015944941,
0.0362112336,
0.0483698137,
-0.0351562016,
0.0258852635,
-0.0175605565,
-0.0253406707,
-0.0459968559,
-0.0393748917,
-0.0369644687,
-0.006798455,
-0.0035685876,
0.025305476,
0.0212506298,
-0.0133261653,
0.0211900026,
0.0335221477,
-0.0432522558,
-0.0208846796,
-0.0136873033,
0.0612087473,
-0.0430039801,
0.0193776935,
0.0143765574,
0.0038290028,
-0.0146520203,
-0.0107800653,
-0.0240891557,
0.0563149229,
0.0173101295,
0.0385447815,
0.0067587537,
0.1292525977,
0.0404483899,
0.0362585187,
-0.0389989391,
-0.0258995276,
-0.0829347819,
-0.0258399546,
-0.0440737009,
0.040256869,
0.0019672881,
-0.0096917087,
-0.0366225876,
0.0089742374,
-0.0284653492,
0.0131219588,
-0.0189113133,
0.041724693,
-0.0086052585,
0.0302069057,
-0.0879059583,
-0.0058032228,
-0.048954647,
-0.008142978,
0.021367576,
-0.0511061847,
0.0160268806,
0.0419126116,
0.0049507017,
-0.0131475572,
0.0139557477,
0.0558907837,
-0.0191650856,
-0.0123588163,
0.0146856178,
-0.0302446391,
0.0147294756,
-0.0643925145,
0.0546015948,
-0.0193000026,
0.0230193119,
0.0027530866,
-0.0168386754,
0.0323186293,
0.0015131199,
0.0225699749,
0.020156011,
0.0371338017,
0.0200742036,
-0.0034983011,
0.0518577322,
0.0078221541,
-0.0456730649,
0.0306285452,
0.0016678197,
0.0241293646,
0.0227438286,
-0.088548772,
0.0339473039,
0.0018210944,
-0.0247913003,
-0.0470820107,
0.0293476582,
0.0094224745,
0.0191054624,
0.044461906,
-0.0098193921,
0.0279631242,
-0.0144601893,
0.0038586408,
0.0378121436,
0.0871864185,
-0.0249434765,
0.0209334232,
0.0060078818,
0.0197860841,
0.0376528949,
0.0587105267,
-0.018786028,
0.027014792,
-0.0137682762,
-0.0010405745,
-0.0058386652,
0.0162570253,
-0.0087205535,
-0.0399115607,
-0.0109524149,
0.0000888884,
0.0469286181,
0.0511537418,
0.0260288604,
-0.0697337911,
-0.0391482674,
-0.0391255617,
-0.0195027757,
-0.0124722337,
-0.0391790867,
-0.0827002004,
0.0276587587,
0.0577224195,
0.0608427972,
-0.0041851467,
-0.0706848502,
0.0017417341,
-0.0281282868,
0.0319434851,
0.0598883927,
-0.0102512911,
-0.0399992429,
-0.0177765954,
-0.0246854164,
-0.022612717,
-0.024942467,
0.0094690612,
0.0130595053,
0.032682199,
-0.0182250086,
0.0203514379,
-0.0041544209,
0.009319243,
0.0143747926,
-0.0325879417,
-0.0550533719,
0.0048216465,
0.0132839046,
0.0308354385,
-0.0071430104,
0.006153537,
0.0016637815,
0.0297354423,
-0.0359662659,
-0.0065417215,
-0.0041169068,
0.0164967366,
0.0467417762,
-0.1097886786,
-0.0628840476,
0.061921183,
-0.0320952758,
-0.0362050943,
0.0084215719,
-0.0597207956,
0.0340770483,
-0.0266157296,
0.0018005803,
-0.0564364195,
-0.0042571379,
-0.0235604178,
0.0190411862,
0.0789244771,
0.0134775024,
-0.013254636,
0.0099948263,
0.0403441824,
-0.0479191989,
0.0007873067,
0.006394309,
0.0358622037,
0.0170725714,
0.0340027213,
0.0359791405,
-0.0864868909,
0.0008298642,
-0.1115901843,
0.0036808229,
0.0251731575,
0.0135626197,
0.0320543237,
-0.0620865002,
-0.0122384224,
-0.0166251771,
-0.0623127744,
0.0421340391,
0.0193839986,
0.0011476222,
0.035198953,
-0.0078895623,
0.023626199,
-0.032646101,
-0.0047996403,
-0.048848249,
-0.03291611,
0.1074433997,
-0.0167841911,
-0.0016401052,
-0.0008268362,
-0.0279181059,
0.0129093202,
0.0285365265,
-0.0640271753,
0.0308056958,
-0.0322851315,
0.0179088917,
0.1056622937,
0.023006713,
0.0259921607,
0.0333538093,
-0.0116757089,
-0.0368165895,
0.0287906155,
-0.0118106008,
-0.0287864022,
0.0006089151,
-0.0271352567,
-0.0229740813,
-0.0385903046,
0.0039201197,
-0.0051654442,
-0.0200566091,
0.0788718611,
-0.011283854,
-0.0143349059,
-0.0370034091,
0.0314702131,
0.0028436575,
0.0158782806,
0.0020505807,
-0.0299345814,
0.0739602894,
-0.0051592309,
0.000610184,
-0.0606916174,
-0.0198097341,
0.0023744684,
0.0417999588,
-0.0203254465,
0.0264624413,
-0.0030495892,
-0.0341031961,
-0.0908613652,
-0.0208357777,
0.0360542983,
-0.0273761898,
-0.021870086,
-0.0309160128,
-0.0184582155,
-0.017657252,
0.0055671744,
-0.0377619304,
-0.000689589,
0.0205867868,
0.0138125401,
0.0299850795,
-0.0319030546,
-0.0376397744,
-0.0005805278,
-0.0059649055,
-0.0172199514,
-0.0305508431,
-0.0221001208,
0.0056057675,
0.0080315052,
0.0399899334,
0.075887613,
0.0065954141,
0.0168777928,
0.0257976111,
0.0403211042,
-0.0052728774,
0.0120466817,
-0.0104547665,
-0.0092017986,
-0.0109186806,
-0.0316449702,
0.0149037773,
-0.0009885068,
0.0268731937,
-0.0715908185,
0.010364688,
0.0958448201,
0.017806204,
0.0111192251,
-0.0368750878,
-0.0433401167,
-0.0454871804,
0.0099696247,
0.0644491911,
-0.071113728,
0.0070085255,
-0.0221477859,
0.0078117107,
-0.0699501559,
-0.0336545147,
0.0041668601,
-0.0982151404,
0.05420468,
-0.0205863565,
-0.0451619886,
-0.0268428158,
-0.0126629425,
-0.0109509639,
0.0207683742,
0.021099139,
-0.0229151379,
0.0337770395,
0.0209697969,
0.0143534839,
-0.0445924103,
0.0275806747,
0.0721107423,
-0.017332403,
0.0393645801,
0.0529144555,
0.0469658971,
-0.0331896693,
-0.0185581669,
0.0159595869,
0.0145390909,
0.0363247804,
0.0249322429,
0.0273683611,
0.0093006492,
0.0058569256,
-0.0329258107,
-0.0133670624,
0.0109018143,
0.0563036688,
0.0777428076,
0.0825871825,
-0.0261834953,
-0.0303710476,
-0.0500795431,
-0.0027400074,
-0.0240774993,
0.0272843223,
-0.0036172087,
-0.0005592569,
-0.0594768673,
-0.0366143286,
0.0219473653,
0.009912489,
-0.0394367054,
0.0297204182,
0.0159488656,
-0.0273953732,
-0.044395946,
-0.0829237029,
0.0887753516,
0.0527358502,
0.0030837613,
-0.0209136587,
0.015375142,
0.049943544,
-0.0253785551,
0.0358342491,
0.0138837071,
-0.0021513717,
-0.0482104495,
-0.0211795401,
-0.0159544349,
-0.0239167716,
-0.0276402198,
0.012048603,
0.0239138026,
-0.0225889869,
-0.0134624047,
0.0566584282,
0.0223081075,
-0.0100012599,
-0.0073585799,
-0.0104603684,
0.0029550286,
-0.0103747742,
0.0073324754,
0.0103278141,
0.0009809892,
0.0059206961,
-0.0317119658,
-0.0137090553,
-0.0224758405,
-0.0033730066,
-0.0253374614,
-0.0062808194,
0.0194168389,
-0.0201119687,
0.0610816181,
0.0708075538,
0.0102804657,
0.0154188899,
0.0122932596,
0.0034824363,
0.0397412702,
-0.0313532725,
0.0044832034,
-0.002041298,
-0.0527571701,
0.0208761413,
-0.0099585317,
0.0316194296,
-0.0231965184,
-0.0743011162,
0.0121943327,
-0.0189551599,
0.0335720703,
0.0295425095,
0.0330217071,
-0.0193789434,
-0.021553928,
-0.0161923002,
-0.0213973019,
0.0146244634,
0.065295659,
0.0197539125,
0.0865327269,
-0.0116765825,
-0.0263192691,
0.0646893606,
0.0128026465,
-0.0618643202,
-0.1179923341,
0.0134363305,
0.053717643,
0.0300072525,
0.0527389757,
-0.0441821851,
-0.0346295647,
0.0138087906,
-0.0007116973,
-0.0120441178,
0.0319173597,
-0.0134745808,
0.0355803557,
0.0101597719,
0.015409614,
-0.0132403485,
0.0162142105,
-0.0250735208,
0.008483097,
-0.0193117447,
-0.025288349,
-0.013258704,
-0.0580452792,
0.0256057456,
-0.0029630719,
0.0441555232,
0.0196897425,
-0.0107115647,
-0.0638912991,
-0.0397453271,
0.0294099133,
-0.0128964251,
-0.0278851967,
0.0549326986,
0.0398612991,
-0.0194496326,
-0.0216059778,
-0.0215945225,
0.043352969,
-0.048890993,
0.0256468318,
-0.0083389981,
-6.263997072e-33,
-0.0124656996,
-0.0784131065,
0.0609674789,
0.0040480201,
0.0008735951,
-0.0183325615,
-0.0077682193,
-0.0031537083,
-0.0356606804,
-0.004630113,
-0.021182457,
0.0269933511,
0.0131561775,
-0.0031572811,
0.0289522447,
-0.0229277425,
0.0196574181,
-0.0083904536,
-0.0093968939,
0.0417149886,
-0.0038064364,
0.0049961992,
0.0415564775,
-0.0407773256,
0.0399670973,
0.0077013681,
0.0106586553,
-0.0424192883,
-0.0090768663,
0.0159957334,
0.0105527388,
0.0408894457,
0.0239494573,
-0.022372758,
0.0107889697,
0.0303444862,
-0.0249037836,
-0.0814685747,
-0.0025342193,
0.0427731164,
-0.0239747148,
-0.021170035,
0.0261296872,
-0.0601071976,
-0.0285134148,
-0.0439202823,
0.0555367023,
0.0033859746,
0.0250858087,
0.0113061834,
-0.053425394,
-0.0039771581,
-0.0567707941,
0.0001937745,
-0.0253038574,
0.0676382333,
0.0025066563,
0.0062429341,
0.0049561234,
0.0367946178,
-0.0204369295,
-0.0214324687,
0.0596272238,
-0.0358578749,
0.0170703083,
0.0289019439,
0.0424165763,
-0.0175861008,
0.0113713276,
-0.0417899899,
0.0116255563,
0.0243118461,
0.0920611694,
0.0476410203,
0.0327634029,
-0.0161156692,
-0.0692835376,
0.0621396936,
0.0674657747,
0.00723365,
-0.0395791642,
-0.0269288719,
-0.0640848204,
0.0182405617,
0.0029210548,
0.0015050406,
-0.0241434537,
-0.0799120441,
0.0319027752,
-0.0703843608,
0.0218993705,
-0.0287664104,
0.0099810204,
-0.0496249609,
0.0275768228,
-0.0557628982,
0.0032303426,
0.0502838492,
-0.0218254589,
0.0299445782,
0.002411955,
0.0048341691,
0.0613167584,
0.0329795964,
0.0488541797,
0.0158695839,
-0.0358073786,
0.0342682824,
-0.0008521447,
-0.0317014791,
-0.0338558331,
0.0066034053,
-0.0073351641,
-0.0470711365,
-0.0037427037,
0.0524760522,
0.0164739862,
0.0110245151,
-0.0042082109,
0.0214146711,
-0.0166666023,
-0.0309767369,
-0.0187802576,
-0.0396377631,
-0.0250625983,
-0.0162352398,
-0.0408912934,
0.0252617914,
-0.0401200913,
-0.0637988076,
-0.0075522778,
0.0107217487,
2.864e-7,
0.0494897105,
0.0442465693,
0.0148229161,
0.0455694199,
-0.0106177423,
-0.0018786916,
-0.0022797382,
-0.0034737538,
0.0571012758,
0.0145867979,
0.02487294,
0.0050375825,
-0.0170041155,
0.0358601995,
-0.0577889346,
-0.022342924,
0.012354468,
-0.0693924353,
-0.0596144833,
0.0830728412,
0.1178935692,
0.0162941124,
0.0050381422,
-0.0145730376,
-0.0078079319,
-0.0440527834,
-0.0134661617,
-0.0124926604,
-0.0191586874,
-0.0001663919,
0.0080017112,
0.0457918346,
0.0322288722,
0.0847745016,
0.0180122238,
-0.0182002857,
0.0035103324,
0.0175140202,
-0.012771355,
-0.0297629014,
0.0220346469,
-0.0013108242,
0.0187739041,
-0.0633040294,
0.0760993138,
-0.0577656403,
-0.0593671538,
-0.0004839139,
-0.0265755095,
-0.0603868999,
0.0165707488,
-0.0267279763,
-0.0219469611,
0.004345736,
-0.0048223068,
-0.0253510121,
0.0323928893,
-0.0320224911,
0.0533179529,
-0.0029820057,
-0.0130651984,
-0.0922251195,
-0.004111046,
-0.0255692545,
0.0410022363,
0.0035504496,
-0.0255155079,
2.195983012e-34,
0.0141581791,
0.0178593043,
0.0447454937,
0.0417089611,
0.0458571613,
0.0324006043,
0.0026960967,
-0.0114575922,
0.0204627998,
-0.0129864886,
-0.0351331942
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15180v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15180v1 | Benchmarking Large Language Model Volatility | 2023-11-26T03:54:03 | 2023-11-26T03:54:03 | Boyang Yu | q-fin.TR | q-fin.TR, cs.CL | The impact of non-deterministic outputs from Large Language Models (LLMs) is
not well examined for financial text understanding tasks. Through a compelling
case study on investing in the US equity market via news sentiment analysis, we
uncover substantial variability in sentence-level sentiment classification
results, underscoring the innate volatility of LLM outputs. These uncertainties
cascade downstream, leading to more significant variations in portfolio
construction and return. While tweaking the temperature parameter in the
language model decoder presents a potential remedy, it comes at the expense of
stifled creativity. Similarly, while ensembling multiple outputs mitigates the
effect of volatile outputs, it demands a notable computational investment. This
work furnishes practitioners with invaluable insights for adeptly navigating
uncertainty in the integration of LLMs into financial decision-making,
particularly in scenarios dictated by non-deterministic information. | [
0.0148283932,
0.0872556269,
-0.0081060324,
0.0253767502,
-0.0000326222,
0.0293155462,
-0.0035972113,
0.0087776361,
-0.0237426031,
-0.0281669088,
0.00975361,
-0.0597969927,
-0.0195482094,
0.0585830845,
0.007603338,
-0.0313329734,
0.0104887094,
-0.064051643,
0.0427290723,
-0.0316115059,
-0.0060972739,
-0.0231641345,
0.0536337458,
-0.0006682868,
-0.0027189779,
-0.0208125263,
-0.0113824066,
0.0181752611,
-0.0030963633,
0.0308615938,
-0.0257199705,
0.0269321408,
-0.0088170106,
0.0584189482,
0.0000017483,
-0.0272419732,
-0.0104629016,
-0.0024546231,
-0.0053986753,
-0.0060275667,
0.0679886937,
-0.0411209203,
0.0045995009,
0.0018918673,
-0.0359799787,
0.0009642381,
0.0545624793,
0.0346102007,
0.0429471172,
0.0519660041,
-0.0012637487,
-0.0094096782,
0.0072245491,
-0.0545858704,
0.0045141247,
-0.0620932616,
0.0110028256,
0.003023196,
-0.0432906225,
0.0233648829,
-0.0216094814,
0.045609992,
0.0045558419,
0.0164008159,
0.0079097208,
0.0107244374,
-0.0095181987,
0.0060498528,
-0.027852986,
0.0111080408,
0.0258190203,
0.0449042767,
-0.0145816188,
-0.0120762233,
0.0139806876,
0.0295652933,
-0.0231641531,
0.0529059619,
0.0097603183,
0.022274876,
0.0286957864,
0.0177447814,
0.0323536471,
0.0084416633,
-0.0231610164,
0.0602878816,
-0.0339831933,
-0.012694031,
0.016557321,
0.0559623986,
0.011124406,
-0.0246544015,
-0.0068020974,
-0.0068053529,
0.024598876,
0.003774551,
-0.0117471851,
-0.0582182407,
-0.0342365801,
-0.1256033033,
0.0212435108,
0.0185960568,
-0.0012554937,
0.0436952822,
-0.0248909295,
0.0114189861,
0.0003836745,
-0.0468475446,
-0.0122786891,
-0.0028266488,
-0.0370655693,
-0.0166826397,
-0.0049044071,
0.048549775,
-0.0247889478,
-0.0276186578,
-0.0695775822,
0.0010472857,
-0.0222393889,
0.0141748339,
-0.0199977849,
-0.0143761169,
-0.025279643,
-0.0413622782,
-0.0051232013,
0.0212745424,
-0.0048675304,
0.0164045654,
-0.0346006714,
-0.0204879288,
0.0003822406,
0.0178119205,
-0.0437733382,
-0.01222103,
0.0063551646,
0.0857481733,
0.0062237349,
-0.0176591072,
-0.047721833,
-0.0688701048,
-0.0239053927,
-0.0516043976,
-0.016970966,
-0.0162268709,
-0.0268474128,
0.0298303273,
0.0007046796,
-0.0160452146,
0.0031067869,
-0.0430663601,
-0.0460807532,
0.0838102549,
0.0469084121,
-0.0304572694,
0.0069644554,
-0.0359797552,
0.0467973389,
0.10850586,
-0.0022593532,
0.06153192,
0.0442107134,
0.0024647238,
-0.0011864803,
0.029586101,
-0.0013617071,
-0.0206500459,
-0.0764814466,
0.0112619083,
0.0129026761,
-0.0229517221,
0.0689082146,
0.0450806282,
-0.0183019172,
0.0052030976,
0.0768961236,
0.0068354025,
0.0176691394,
0.0347611159,
-0.0262893699,
-0.0211820453,
-0.0007618871,
-0.00105691,
0.0082126167,
0.014396362,
-0.0423191562,
0.0249915831,
-0.0085505098,
0.0300482232,
-0.031771075,
-0.0493835919,
-0.0162300076,
-0.0432786345,
0.0302731898,
-0.001392013,
0.0493574105,
-0.0818674639,
-0.0113560306,
0.0498619899,
0.0204399154,
-0.0188087523,
0.0257843379,
-0.0102568287,
0.0121855363,
0.1072396562,
-0.0139243091,
0.0266911238,
0.0335620381,
-0.0382110812,
-0.0201917049,
0.0536248647,
0.0315745026,
0.0070639369,
-0.0093365824,
-0.0258137025,
-0.0253605675,
0.0334275663,
0.0422190502,
0.0417010412,
-0.0399210155,
0.0139410431,
0.0058530462,
-0.0134938732,
-0.0095893731,
-0.0239943396,
-0.0172760934,
-0.05953357,
0.0256816112,
-0.0460952334,
0.0322489552,
0.0123198014,
-0.0341981389,
0.0004687149,
-0.0112061072,
-0.0421236195,
-0.0716170073,
0.0284111779,
-0.0183550566,
0.0207370613,
-0.0049483604,
0.0165906101,
-0.0113347359,
-0.0168204196,
-0.0172822867,
-0.0174904391,
0.0403657816,
-0.0187686048,
0.0088307625,
-0.0472442396,
-0.0371200703,
-0.0195029993,
0.046846021,
-0.0116142826,
0.0356475376,
-0.060601864,
0.0033686638,
-0.0432809554,
-0.0091459602,
-0.0194895118,
0.0125018116,
0.017380679,
0.0312645733,
0.0235487465,
0.0581368208,
0.0248015597,
-0.021508351,
0.059400484,
-0.0983968005,
-0.0346297957,
-0.0425619893,
-0.0212548207,
0.0394452736,
-0.0018873782,
-0.0014727213,
-0.0116513195,
0.0009464368,
-0.00576209,
-0.0074305977,
-0.0155650703,
0.0316012837,
0.0481194742,
-0.0179716069,
0.0001315101,
-0.0208736975,
-0.0290658884,
0.0000943641,
0.0660895556,
0.0170791484,
-0.0200545825,
-0.0656037703,
0.002767066,
-0.0137195857,
-0.0179406311,
-0.0094013186,
-0.0074156323,
-0.0073324428,
-0.0197239239,
0.041448269,
0.084431082,
0.0244113188,
0.0380144455,
-0.0073192352,
-0.0257225651,
-0.0291477721,
0.0065766778,
-0.0204828661,
-0.0050164643,
-0.0538777784,
-0.0253274478,
0.0057068765,
0.0546270162,
-0.0193710588,
-0.0030430616,
-0.0815417692,
0.0477970205,
-0.0397608206,
0.0174833965,
-0.0468019247,
-0.0018447441,
-0.0201974139,
0.071512334,
0.0279899985,
-0.062384259,
0.0542582236,
0.0088930428,
0.0057373261,
-0.0322945416,
-0.0205836743,
-0.0612460487,
0.038237147,
-0.0323027298,
0.0021868106,
-0.0322836488,
-0.0193673931,
-0.0100607667,
-0.0390888453,
0.0281236749,
-0.0297194179,
0.0581805855,
-0.0122332843,
0.0129433265,
-0.00005227,
0.0003856441,
0.0191762019,
-0.0474388078,
-0.071265921,
0.0228965711,
0.1085931808,
-0.0678794757,
-0.0270068366,
0.0274467804,
0.0046044746,
-0.0409302749,
-0.0434327461,
-0.0217172746,
0.0181608144,
0.0172136519,
0.0735122859,
-0.0029903222,
0.0691571012,
-0.0617646053,
0.0014061792,
0.0009330219,
0.0201767851,
0.0018912985,
-0.0233752169,
0.0009781859,
0.025521338,
-0.0033015218,
-0.008653325,
0.0277982,
0.0013321602,
-0.0419727601,
-0.0023527467,
0.0971880034,
0.0025321557,
-0.020207243,
-0.0053182235,
-0.0228924118,
0.0648541227,
-0.0295518246,
0.0217437595,
-0.058505401,
-0.0203915909,
-0.00453935,
0.0329305083,
0.0261234902,
-0.0282109119,
-0.0060909134,
-0.0882700831,
0.0639569685,
0.0266396087,
0.0039590704,
-0.0144923814,
-0.0349909738,
-0.0330961347,
-0.0527014099,
0.0383522622,
0.0070368545,
-0.0314707309,
0.0361411087,
0.0237191133,
-0.0590638109,
-0.0228102971,
-0.0064646434,
0.0142646944,
-0.0094322376,
0.0420325063,
-0.0221302435,
-0.0393016115,
0.0241358839,
0.0010768393,
-0.000382757,
0.0045383945,
0.0095670344,
0.0446378849,
0.004223695,
-0.0166399777,
-0.0182789098,
0.0141408835,
-0.0338241495,
0.061377991,
-0.0387497358,
0.0015872144,
-0.0195766073,
-0.0663248301,
-0.0000082816,
0.0158307031,
0.0135522429,
0.0675462261,
0.022323681,
-0.0649152771,
-0.0587493405,
-0.076274626,
0.0193065181,
-0.0618231222,
-0.030209722,
-0.0025945979,
0.0361843295,
-0.0461458638,
-0.0552416556,
-0.0563381761,
-0.0297276266,
0.03761122,
-0.0052952575,
0.0620213002,
0.0620938726,
-0.0039037843,
-0.0296346974,
0.014731206,
0.0112255355,
-0.0015678381,
-0.0168730021,
0.0351832584,
0.0246597175,
-0.0280161649,
-0.0368870981,
0.0385711603,
-0.1054163128,
-0.0747453719,
0.0534599833,
0.0294921007,
0.0296956003,
0.0027308026,
0.0143702282,
-0.0077318088,
0.0371642746,
0.0677870587,
0.000375222,
0.0174887665,
0.0495509841,
0.0694916993,
0.0002365359,
0.0350624658,
-0.0160002913,
0.0128927119,
-0.0104927365,
0.0093089994,
-0.0322693698,
-0.057122387,
-0.0503228977,
-0.0013939933,
0.0117647089,
-0.0020876862,
-0.0200172439,
0.0028511675,
-0.0033003807,
0.0242642909,
0.0097125052,
-0.0274824314,
-0.0479804985,
0.0543934926,
-0.0287192557,
-0.0498830266,
0.0653252304,
0.0220753774,
0.014768688,
-0.0107264677,
0.0122511983,
-0.0203739908,
0.0157120097,
0.052164644,
-0.0239292625,
0.0059267208,
0.023130618,
0.0147919003,
-0.0019383588,
0.0008969324,
-0.0140344808,
0.017772764,
0.0114347134,
-0.0441702865,
-0.0315975435,
-0.0534256548,
-0.0456663631,
0.0088697318,
0.0009638254,
-0.0005582335,
-0.0144630978,
0.0476538241,
-0.0704726204,
0.0193788931,
0.0059257611,
0.0060998634,
0.0062234271,
0.0027135063,
0.0400693789,
-0.005891066,
-0.080240041,
-0.0365584381,
0.0832363442,
0.0114576351,
0.0228382628,
-0.0082233548,
-0.0160559639,
-0.036853984,
-0.0303455684,
0.0275659412,
-0.0023938576,
-0.0232142545,
0.0193747524,
-0.0758140683,
-0.0438243411,
0.0428274311,
-0.0075732237,
0.0308743045,
-0.0367557183,
-0.0059205699,
0.0708748922,
0.0048558363,
0.0565225519,
-0.007248044,
0.0221563373,
-0.0148082897,
0.0000272289,
-0.0589452013,
-6.516006163e-33,
-0.0071971836,
-0.0016152423,
-0.0192557089,
-0.0287215784,
0.0104832798,
0.0149070946,
-0.0212311931,
0.0503227785,
0.0143196639,
0.0205092914,
0.0315952897,
0.0309819076,
0.0201777387,
0.0326766446,
0.0664402619,
-0.0121489335,
0.0449987501,
-0.0162252299,
0.0175968129,
-0.0250599254,
0.0650237724,
0.0550409853,
0.0360396802,
-0.0656291321,
0.0307079684,
0.0123959007,
-0.03612867,
-0.025833739,
0.0729093179,
0.0283690076,
-0.0072222641,
0.0708293244,
0.007225323,
-0.069964841,
-0.0292126834,
-0.017296575,
0.004675936,
-0.0386020467,
-0.0018238509,
0.0442390405,
0.0313343145,
-0.0300312713,
0.0405633301,
0.0327481031,
-0.0249251984,
-0.0093451701,
0.0163142774,
-0.0072061131,
-0.0349374823,
-0.0723778382,
-0.0608195737,
0.039970573,
0.0150859207,
0.0464722514,
0.0577422939,
0.0211793538,
-0.0125952717,
0.0460968725,
-0.0513884537,
0.0179671124,
0.0141324848,
0.0513443239,
0.0226204675,
0.0258881673,
-0.0178778972,
0.054310821,
-0.0052520931,
0.0158835221,
-0.0496817157,
0.010678024,
0.0407041609,
0.0367070995,
0.0139600355,
0.0626025274,
0.0347997174,
-0.0349745229,
-0.039250765,
-0.0057998435,
0.0179774594,
0.0077723018,
0.0520874299,
0.0114605147,
-0.033649724,
-0.0695337653,
-0.0084478175,
-0.010793183,
-0.0130014997,
-0.0087775569,
0.0000400643,
0.015553697,
-0.0014192678,
-0.0271841306,
0.0473385938,
-0.032592766,
-0.0876119286,
0.0285068359,
-0.0259726178,
0.0177404024,
0.0060897898,
0.009440165,
-0.0082742991,
-0.0523982681,
-0.0306615643,
0.0194655601,
-0.0401692465,
-0.0152066685,
0.0261585023,
0.024689449,
-0.0544195361,
-0.0335404351,
-0.0045228694,
0.0321916714,
0.033339642,
0.0374842286,
0.0369122662,
-0.0256945901,
-0.0014166469,
0.0314187445,
0.0030814882,
0.0574740581,
0.0238387398,
0.0167127345,
-0.0084933322,
0.0288155247,
0.0287582539,
0.0208451431,
0.0163139626,
0.018332148,
0.0327270478,
-0.0519096404,
-0.0069865496,
0.0423794985,
2.586e-7,
0.0561372302,
0.1312679648,
-0.0161341447,
0.0110406987,
0.0394830704,
0.0828979313,
-0.0397707559,
-0.0190462004,
-0.0110609354,
0.0057252892,
-0.0068246108,
0.0280215722,
0.0466916673,
0.0523296818,
-0.0356118344,
-0.0493604131,
-0.0469287261,
0.0842092484,
-0.0479509458,
0.0133321434,
0.0424275808,
0.0707833394,
-0.0240780544,
-0.0103757726,
-0.0062053599,
-0.0383041576,
0.0608966202,
-0.0576910339,
-0.0287341196,
0.0246268604,
0.01239134,
-0.0270886924,
0.0128981052,
0.004403952,
-0.0182064362,
0.0009992078,
-0.0096264137,
0.0442033596,
0.0185558442,
0.0076433988,
0.015720211,
-0.0049285428,
-0.0231297947,
-0.0497733988,
0.0413216203,
-0.0892299041,
-0.0535897911,
-0.0785029903,
-0.0533370897,
0.0118916268,
0.0575823076,
0.0123472577,
0.0026983421,
0.0319877192,
-0.005827928,
-0.019849455,
0.0132908942,
-0.0328027867,
-0.0470097773,
-0.0054216539,
-0.0760631338,
0.0009349248,
-0.047310967,
0.0453699306,
0.0525879487,
-0.0155432355,
0.0407925174,
2.457709354e-34,
0.1005767062,
-0.0057408726,
-0.0447284803,
0.0363687687,
0.0360904559,
0.0073433109,
-0.0432082154,
0.0501820445,
-0.0080551244,
-0.0774356499,
-0.0073541873
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03718v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03718v1 | Large Language Models in Law: A Survey | 2023-11-26T00:48:12 | 2023-11-26T00:48:12 | Jinqi Lai, Wensheng Gan, Jiayang Wu, Zhenlian Qi, Philip S. Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The advent of artificial intelligence (AI) has significantly impacted the
traditional judicial industry. Moreover, recently, with the development of
AI-generated content (AIGC), AI and law have found applications in various
domains, including image recognition, automatic text generation, and
interactive chat. With the rapid emergence and growing popularity of large
models, it is evident that AI will drive transformation in the traditional
judicial industry. However, the application of legal large language models
(LLMs) is still in its nascent stage. Several challenges need to be addressed.
In this paper, we aim to provide a comprehensive survey of legal LLMs. We not
only conduct an extensive survey of LLMs, but also expose their applications in
the judicial system. We first provide an overview of AI technologies in the
legal field and showcase the recent research in LLMs. Then, we discuss the
practical implementation presented by legal LLMs, such as providing legal
advice to users and assisting judges during trials. In addition, we explore the
limitations of legal LLMs, including data, algorithms, and judicial practice.
Finally, we summarize practical recommendations and propose future development
directions to address these challenges. | [
0.0742883906,
0.0381088443,
-0.035663493,
0.0258495007,
-0.0903728232,
0.0312929228,
0.0436836928,
0.0567637831,
0.0406203978,
-0.0786741301,
0.0125470096,
-0.0367781632,
-0.0262765512,
0.0237954706,
0.0046214247,
-0.0325712152,
-0.0088538611,
-0.0314814076,
0.0623168908,
0.0043137544,
0.0362959355,
0.0189679302,
0.0186581686,
0.0146917747,
-0.0579754598,
0.0040640002,
-0.0147396214,
-0.001990275,
-0.0459645279,
0.0122736311,
-0.0361410864,
0.0736358464,
0.0201593656,
0.0418223031,
0.0000019493,
-0.0740897432,
0.0186390467,
-0.0120482827,
-0.0186804701,
0.0265189651,
0.0454535708,
-0.0480379313,
-0.0476033762,
0.0062465086,
-0.0380382836,
0.0461268015,
0.0332132615,
0.001788744,
0.0330947079,
0.084107928,
-0.0221144352,
-0.0463632159,
0.0694951713,
-0.0303999167,
-0.013179509,
-0.0113138761,
0.0431125723,
0.0387364738,
0.0531939976,
-0.0324192345,
0.0335729271,
0.0184121467,
0.034855783,
-0.0558488779,
-0.0330055133,
-0.0096733999,
-0.0232299417,
-0.0192554481,
-0.0111751147,
0.0391762108,
0.0545404479,
-0.0292526297,
0.0164291952,
-0.0008288205,
0.0581601635,
0.0146539845,
-0.033196073,
0.1165207103,
-0.0025149628,
0.0159523375,
0.0187992696,
-0.0031919125,
-0.0062508485,
0.0431261696,
-0.0284081828,
0.03947201,
0.0153218508,
-0.0431446731,
-0.0227749683,
0.0062982347,
0.014854636,
-0.0718895644,
0.0600219108,
0.0452313907,
-0.0053907451,
0.0296496507,
-0.0600952432,
-0.0521390811,
0.051440496,
-0.084918566,
0.0490356945,
-0.0122013018,
-0.0122143524,
0.0725570917,
-0.0216572527,
0.027271565,
-0.0080668991,
0.0072654402,
0.0195696913,
-0.0363111123,
-0.0043881647,
-0.0201994013,
-0.0353943333,
0.0416687354,
-0.0988682434,
-0.0217255931,
-0.0201810002,
0.0394613147,
-0.0214725658,
0.0321215726,
0.0108896196,
-0.0147884972,
0.0045842039,
-0.0264451336,
-0.0413138717,
-0.0491908081,
-0.0215505399,
0.0367635526,
0.0083307819,
-0.0204660445,
0.0419245549,
0.0350577235,
0.0105837006,
0.0010554522,
0.0078497836,
0.1041507274,
-0.0146970702,
-0.0326786414,
-0.0246502571,
-0.064118363,
-0.0436442383,
-0.079557091,
-0.0251789894,
-0.0844676867,
-0.0012317067,
-0.0153771285,
-0.0276056007,
-0.0536068156,
0.0111529026,
0.0453062207,
-0.0219330341,
0.0577422045,
-0.0395317562,
0.0207204297,
0.0023388108,
0.0015485464,
0.0291604921,
0.0031887151,
0.0071347454,
0.0454410873,
0.0348178409,
-0.0161139444,
0.033317849,
0.0657912567,
-0.0082223788,
0.0198821984,
-0.0404748954,
-0.0161290653,
-0.0126709398,
0.0274895541,
-0.0000679717,
0.0844602957,
-0.0134903025,
-0.0040409602,
0.0657094195,
0.0877017081,
0.0097421221,
0.0616961755,
0.026771212,
-0.0037660513,
0.0371983387,
-0.0080163116,
-0.0624552295,
0.0137986531,
-0.0527690724,
-0.0076336823,
-0.0306623559,
0.040509738,
-0.0225557648,
-0.0496588461,
0.0013466533,
-0.0231214706,
0.0140528278,
0.0062112282,
0.0702523068,
-0.0078757461,
0.0027662369,
-0.0180518124,
0.0346987359,
-0.0263668392,
-0.029160738,
-0.052866675,
0.011762443,
0.0625228062,
0.0587254018,
-0.007105188,
0.0217669178,
0.0020143474,
0.0116326641,
0.0466750488,
0.0356473252,
-0.0013563368,
-0.0681635737,
-0.0304633863,
-0.0040309234,
0.0362865366,
0.0057563223,
-0.0006348907,
0.0085909795,
0.0148293367,
0.0286350325,
-0.0233187992,
-0.018675765,
0.0123952888,
-0.0268358868,
-0.0094372006,
0.0155659374,
-0.0060801543,
0.0363033749,
0.0509012304,
-0.0103249671,
-0.0121027231,
0.0373578593,
0.0020416342,
-0.0159078855,
0.0015015473,
0.014436515,
0.0224092025,
0.0498325787,
-0.025538519,
-0.005754387,
-0.0169200487,
-0.0217625815,
-0.0055303369,
-0.0067109694,
-0.0521956272,
0.0195973348,
-0.0671677813,
0.0311953481,
0.0125887236,
-0.0265068859,
-0.0280975327,
0.0488799848,
0.0100434599,
-0.0429378785,
0.0224172436,
-0.0076712584,
0.0282186996,
-0.0234302767,
-0.0156945325,
-0.0143044498,
-0.0185943916,
0.0334872752,
0.0322387069,
0.0148852477,
-0.0232510827,
-0.0537198856,
-0.0744168758,
-0.0232109036,
-0.0209696572,
-0.0143530248,
-0.0152565427,
-0.0124053508,
-0.0108323107,
-0.0132441269,
-0.0294299908,
-0.0025274956,
0.0325484797,
-0.0017677562,
0.0132488944,
-0.0146691017,
-0.0472966544,
-0.0098715657,
-0.0271732491,
-0.0173654277,
0.0327780955,
0.0344597846,
-0.0466518551,
-0.0491489097,
0.0567270964,
-0.0234846678,
0.017352758,
-0.0156144938,
-0.0041115079,
-0.0224247165,
-0.0117283762,
-0.0056827869,
0.0360641479,
0.0567963608,
0.0307383817,
0.0117374957,
0.0035955168,
-0.0417389832,
-0.0193857867,
0.004103316,
0.0193800572,
-0.0370426662,
-0.0285561662,
0.0094143171,
-0.0049506901,
-0.0075797569,
0.0347516797,
-0.0135212215,
0.0307259839,
-0.0070880856,
-0.0139684314,
-0.0138934925,
-0.0068811183,
-0.0222354028,
0.0461666249,
0.0024134377,
-0.0825595483,
0.0534738675,
-0.0059739654,
0.0755525604,
-0.0099744834,
-0.0218632966,
-0.0303566847,
0.0943275094,
0.0213440228,
0.0424034223,
-0.0249273535,
-0.0252055451,
0.0288547184,
-0.010593676,
0.0331223868,
-0.0505029708,
0.0681680515,
-0.0369960926,
0.0483305901,
-0.0175518226,
-0.0653235689,
-0.0204597339,
-0.0482019708,
-0.0159277748,
0.0125117414,
0.0424687453,
-0.0042149937,
-0.0267277323,
0.0151460385,
-0.0063421568,
-0.0045164805,
0.0183693394,
0.0057525826,
-0.0449371748,
0.0370668806,
0.011380557,
-0.0215727594,
-0.0076087429,
-0.0169953052,
-0.0173326284,
0.0243680459,
-0.0198989827,
0.0003673287,
0.0058527864,
0.0072135832,
0.0170504395,
-0.0255778339,
-0.0052073104,
0.0473781303,
0.0143136224,
-0.028701853,
0.0460653566,
0.0957650319,
0.0308087561,
-0.0487738885,
-0.0087052826,
-0.0101196468,
-0.0123476051,
0.0237665791,
0.0333073251,
-0.1262668371,
0.013921882,
-0.007187577,
-0.0337646753,
-0.0523566157,
-0.0222023223,
-0.0096228803,
-0.105303511,
0.1187653616,
0.0346743837,
0.0212520771,
-0.0471487232,
-0.0005965976,
-0.0035835516,
0.0264439024,
-0.0016471042,
-0.0251793545,
-0.0179287791,
-0.0406040438,
0.0127060283,
-0.0439773761,
0.0058163572,
-0.0128444051,
-0.0645083785,
0.0828983262,
0.0279867109,
0.0368456319,
-0.0316594318,
-0.0122880125,
-0.0035448226,
0.043274194,
0.0265400819,
-0.0073412992,
0.011028178,
0.0308386032,
0.0102848122,
-0.0686770082,
0.0417117923,
0.0096878503,
-0.0213399641,
0.0436347127,
0.0630199239,
-0.0532518141,
-0.021381963,
-0.0321287513,
-0.030817885,
-0.0009961154,
0.0453208424,
0.020604955,
-0.0284289308,
-0.0635668263,
-0.0365639701,
-0.0282038879,
-0.0155637935,
-0.0292611364,
-0.0235091485,
0.0032778131,
-0.004343865,
-0.0373265557,
0.0050191921,
0.0095008854,
0.0232562236,
0.027257178,
0.0057627312,
0.0479802154,
-0.0224662013,
-0.0208816808,
-0.0169302709,
-0.0585105605,
0.0204388816,
-0.0400743186,
0.0142662982,
-0.0036710508,
-0.0441088006,
0.0053405329,
0.0077596707,
-0.0126213096,
-0.0272865389,
-0.0059881755,
0.0127356797,
0.0147287259,
-0.0024319359,
-0.0433245897,
-0.0833751485,
0.0585824028,
0.0157765653,
-0.0026610096,
-0.0005611155,
0.0044360757,
-0.0193998273,
-0.0193010736,
-0.0023501194,
-0.001982769,
0.0394150056,
0.0158498809,
-0.0205969606,
-0.0284509715,
-0.0345424674,
0.031929981,
0.0669854805,
-0.0293786936,
0.0083214613,
-0.0230091717,
-0.0064746514,
-0.0053378064,
-0.0542495809,
-0.0072008721,
-0.0223577172,
-0.0255156569,
0.0007786949,
0.0005686035,
-0.0148010924,
0.0537857227,
-0.0133909369,
-0.003071476,
-0.0483891182,
0.0347964279,
0.0073613389,
-0.0085658208,
0.0244177468,
-0.0295739919,
0.016631078,
0.0466156863,
-0.0237769969,
0.0414925516,
-0.0335168242,
0.0543210357,
-0.0020028774,
-0.0203043707,
-0.0143265491,
0.0373256654,
-0.0075149434,
-0.0384199508,
-0.0032908893,
0.0843861848,
0.0990554765,
0.0284556225,
0.0136292912,
-0.0584340803,
-0.0136100017,
-0.01971264,
0.0231824908,
0.0168336537,
-0.0498061813,
0.0020055333,
0.0175428931,
-0.0277656317,
0.0296392459,
0.0189650618,
0.0063660075,
0.0130737927,
-0.0154855214,
-0.0268954001,
-0.021449104,
-0.0354775824,
0.004706732,
0.0006611526,
-0.0290020406,
-0.0424464494,
-0.0648842454,
-0.0384201035,
-0.0327301137,
0.0085373847,
-0.0085214386,
-0.0065313224,
0.0072318818,
0.0581003167,
0.0158901121,
-0.0021230131,
-0.0434505232,
0.017646281,
-0.0173396431,
-0.0310372878,
0.0022863632,
-5.94741477e-33,
-0.0115369651,
-0.0651120991,
0.0284326449,
0.02463804,
-0.0109801255,
-0.023328146,
-0.0041869138,
-0.0082415389,
0.0143647948,
0.0079385871,
-0.03358116,
0.0140298093,
0.0193969533,
-0.0017456358,
0.0068336013,
0.011651638,
0.0077217217,
-0.0162363276,
-0.0002177162,
0.0219414942,
-0.0100246537,
-0.0221688058,
-0.0260889661,
-0.0906927213,
0.0184866618,
0.0472966284,
-0.0321731605,
-0.0138146644,
-0.0735543147,
0.0672512278,
-0.0240863394,
0.0413179547,
0.0249244403,
-0.0295892488,
-0.0135729499,
0.0717282221,
-0.0493063852,
0.0370137393,
-0.0059550703,
-0.017765535,
0.0056813918,
-0.0510084182,
0.0363661759,
-0.0130463401,
-0.0516144186,
0.0362413451,
0.0339456908,
-0.0448513702,
-0.0365355909,
-0.0596447028,
-0.0831583217,
0.0483759232,
-0.0274509136,
0.0135023892,
0.0402020849,
-0.0117755709,
-0.002050905,
0.0273276158,
-0.051531408,
0.0458656102,
-0.0114576975,
-0.0341689065,
0.0491469465,
-0.0493666641,
-0.0228050649,
0.0546247512,
0.0029461337,
0.0140040517,
-0.0551479571,
-0.0207702238,
0.0075654909,
0.1100326329,
0.0621156506,
0.052349925,
-0.0089301188,
-0.0410772972,
-0.0560807027,
-0.0168589707,
0.0260239001,
0.0164336991,
0.061263565,
-0.0417142436,
-0.0617549866,
-0.0144916056,
-0.0282702129,
-0.0318375304,
-0.0148599036,
-0.0048147161,
0.0127201909,
0.0157259591,
0.0291785356,
-0.0114151984,
0.0150336269,
-0.0612738431,
0.0033933544,
0.0210324731,
0.0049010501,
0.0540082827,
-0.0165647753,
0.0181648582,
-0.0617462471,
-0.0536349379,
0.0068304907,
-0.0128002567,
-0.003251208,
0.0001295692,
0.038100224,
-0.0136881787,
-0.034723632,
0.0100706341,
0.022879757,
0.0302631091,
0.0693708584,
-0.0038090944,
0.0165558644,
0.0206364952,
0.0302584954,
0.0235458277,
0.0270322189,
-0.0097737629,
-0.0211735796,
-0.0347499214,
-0.0016696986,
-0.0149799185,
-0.0081656389,
0.0216248855,
-0.0374075845,
0.0453573354,
0.0443653315,
0.0012502284,
0.0080825146,
0.0218609534,
2.615e-7,
0.0549911484,
0.0629982278,
0.0038495671,
0.0331090316,
0.0144830579,
0.0279849898,
0.0317646042,
0.0253809765,
0.0208000783,
-0.0007045891,
0.0310395937,
0.024230361,
0.0680810288,
0.0196274724,
-0.0457546897,
0.0031154016,
-0.0618085414,
-0.0522372983,
-0.0909960493,
0.0520036705,
0.0549681224,
0.089263849,
0.015544516,
-0.029893769,
-0.0070106043,
-0.0394540466,
0.0456449091,
-0.0278757419,
-0.0351162106,
-0.0184646323,
0.0568051152,
-0.0446034707,
-0.0136059904,
0.0514596887,
0.0120958835,
0.0410996974,
-0.0333845653,
0.0532856025,
-0.0025009741,
0.0772897154,
-0.0079308823,
-0.0316298939,
0.0022511727,
-0.0252790414,
0.0536621474,
-0.0156727787,
-0.0223864727,
-0.0529697984,
0.0028736521,
-0.0578127652,
-0.003528184,
-0.0054197456,
-0.0050620176,
-0.0205862094,
0.0343307629,
-0.0213547964,
0.0220388528,
-0.0852624029,
0.0234997924,
0.0064504617,
-0.023181282,
0.0079661189,
-0.031411767,
0.0106808404,
0.0734398291,
-0.0811177641,
0.0409092493,
2.181401831e-34,
0.0289628077,
-0.0010833929,
0.0070104683,
0.0288002901,
0.0381470099,
0.0451516993,
-0.008237944,
0.0097591802,
-0.0259593353,
-0.1001571044,
0.0278820451
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15131v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15131v1 | Localizing Lying in Llama: Understanding Instructed Dishonesty on True-False Questions Through Prompting, Probing, and Patching | 2023-11-25T22:41:23 | 2023-11-25T22:41:23 | James Campbell, Richard Ren, Phillip Guo | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) demonstrate significant knowledge through their
outputs, though it is often unclear whether false outputs are due to a lack of
knowledge or dishonesty. In this paper, we investigate instructed dishonesty,
wherein we explicitly prompt LLaMA-2-70b-chat to lie. We perform prompt
engineering to find which prompts best induce lying behavior, and then use
mechanistic interpretability approaches to localize where in the network this
behavior occurs. Using linear probing and activation patching, we localize five
layers that appear especially important for lying. We then find just 46
attention heads within these layers that enable us to causally intervene such
that the lying model instead answers honestly. We show that these interventions
work robustly across many prompts and dataset splits. Overall, our work
contributes a greater understanding of dishonesty in LLMs so that we may hope
to prevent it. | [
0.0488271676,
0.0531505905,
-0.0683497116,
0.0587810501,
-0.0480957292,
-0.0158308614,
0.0341961198,
0.0157381035,
0.059760768,
-0.0012936643,
-0.0583686233,
0.0023297931,
0.0339639224,
0.0448352061,
0.0535447188,
0.0289254729,
0.049151551,
-0.0026411493,
0.038980253,
-0.0231989119,
0.0119221034,
-0.0009444414,
0.0283809956,
0.0191173255,
-0.0069781682,
-0.0100340182,
-0.0301939957,
-0.011790405,
0.0057782587,
0.0236289706,
0.0280671883,
0.0412317403,
-0.0207292996,
0.0699781179,
0.0000020333,
-0.026271645,
-0.0285300128,
-0.0186236184,
-0.0710092261,
0.0492992997,
-0.0081020631,
-0.0261212885,
-0.0028942905,
0.0190799534,
-0.0444080457,
0.0353920832,
0.0447319709,
0.0244174916,
0.0605610684,
0.0664342865,
0.0032145171,
0.0439784452,
0.0193728898,
-0.0356734321,
0.0573210791,
-0.0392411388,
0.0041786181,
-0.0254166313,
-0.0251395442,
0.0170613509,
-0.0331274793,
0.0151109323,
0.0333904326,
-0.0417336002,
-0.0225991756,
0.0219648797,
0.0001850434,
-0.0169979651,
0.0046346965,
0.0437899716,
-0.0000626033,
-0.0113968328,
0.0084920293,
-0.0019141497,
0.0045606564,
-0.016057726,
-0.0193877611,
0.0202883445,
0.0092450371,
-0.0090737278,
-0.0020257332,
-0.0124132866,
0.0317276418,
-0.0003740648,
0.0171319079,
0.0451247692,
-0.0405476987,
-0.0010986006,
0.0004504871,
-0.0172692221,
0.0341199897,
-0.0675627887,
-0.0039203176,
0.019168755,
-0.0370741598,
0.015559487,
-0.0259096269,
0.044350706,
0.054773856,
-0.0222014338,
0.0286515485,
0.0298487432,
-0.0415525809,
0.0227729995,
-0.0088519147,
0.0566415489,
-0.0314494632,
0.0732604712,
-0.0538878329,
-0.0001002657,
0.0453888886,
-0.0481037199,
-0.0006970208,
-0.0126773352,
-0.0176812913,
0.0145217869,
-0.0396385342,
-0.0123261344,
-0.0587795526,
-0.0131117478,
-0.037714757,
0.0322312377,
-0.0344554,
0.0211175662,
-0.0191475693,
0.034548942,
-0.0372139551,
0.043772459,
0.0376643576,
-0.0790595636,
-0.056149032,
-0.0022722015,
-0.0299083032,
0.0091652051,
0.0071661398,
0.034429267,
0.00035554,
-0.0148480833,
-0.018862823,
-0.0379268639,
-0.0494672395,
-0.0631797984,
0.0046155974,
-0.0308516473,
0.0424607694,
-0.0354271643,
-0.0279844608,
-0.0184487533,
0.0185224656,
0.0101261111,
-0.0366931409,
0.0748509839,
0.0164021831,
0.0104099428,
0.004399138,
0.0281633604,
-0.0470686592,
0.0464473069,
0.0034393093,
0.070665136,
0.0518753603,
-0.0143919624,
0.0103123896,
0.0046541798,
0.0780357048,
-0.0049648429,
0.0202237852,
0.0018337677,
0.0289907008,
0.0214091241,
0.0207830463,
-0.0049097347,
-0.0150465826,
-0.0591127351,
0.0935076028,
0.0135517884,
-0.0344755389,
-0.0325462632,
-0.0035756929,
-0.0004674993,
-0.0087147392,
0.0263949838,
-0.0912396163,
0.0631871,
-0.047748059,
-0.0132927652,
0.0091238143,
0.0296292938,
-0.0016544723,
-0.0328489915,
0.0208199397,
-0.0121454494,
0.0127667813,
0.0583283305,
-0.0289017037,
0.0063386518,
-0.0269211587,
0.0414991193,
0.0267861225,
-0.015210202,
-0.0141794654,
-0.1056850851,
0.0550774597,
0.0405971222,
0.0216512494,
0.0031414262,
-0.0217675827,
-0.0261524599,
0.0301759858,
0.0278001707,
0.019964572,
-0.0089549264,
0.0180371944,
0.0042973855,
0.0029564751,
-0.0628026202,
0.0094636334,
0.0091225468,
-0.017852148,
-0.0129994657,
-0.0113714924,
-0.0538839959,
0.0188042298,
0.0297467895,
-0.0202873293,
-0.0155864712,
0.0006932736,
0.038286224,
0.0185591783,
-0.0370098725,
0.0112691,
-0.0030555883,
0.0410782434,
-0.0133841755,
0.0208126083,
-0.0280224029,
-0.0293554179,
-0.0262826774,
0.0021797894,
-0.0419535935,
-0.0057786023,
0.0393912196,
-0.0226217154,
-0.0017223647,
0.0070543629,
-0.0171803385,
-0.0007060315,
-0.022036789,
0.00106774,
-0.025044065,
0.0446260646,
-0.0192836896,
0.059082184,
-0.0517551042,
0.0208264478,
-0.000067599,
-0.0247798264,
-0.0011993187,
-0.0236864407,
0.0207606815,
-0.0037153896,
0.0061216978,
-0.0083724437,
-0.0021611208,
0.0395638011,
-0.0254818853,
-0.0487505533,
-0.061861556,
-0.009816776,
-0.0029973085,
-0.0157749336,
0.0443826839,
-0.0159994774,
0.0084150573,
0.0107369758,
-0.0426430069,
0.0369993672,
0.0262159165,
0.0113808829,
0.0202481747,
-0.0210736152,
-0.0179229006,
-0.0260298084,
0.0197898131,
-0.0113795223,
0.0226904936,
-0.0192516241,
-0.04489775,
-0.0493555665,
-0.0244696792,
-0.0389907733,
0.0306082144,
-0.0285827201,
-0.0666573718,
0.0015535741,
0.0388512313,
-0.0326727517,
0.1168828234,
0.0120088318,
0.0518976562,
0.0353842303,
0.0293890946,
-0.0440916568,
0.002865891,
-0.0001229878,
0.004415846,
-0.0313877687,
-0.0899027139,
-0.0031556678,
0.0752369687,
0.0420017056,
-0.0051039024,
-0.0145292729,
0.0213433076,
-0.0057471008,
-0.0683429465,
0.0154459225,
-0.025696246,
-0.0220194887,
0.0637737587,
-0.0218872577,
-0.0935184807,
0.1018820778,
-0.0153926071,
-0.0056436583,
0.0263195299,
-0.0076121255,
-0.0057099783,
0.0555623546,
0.0102720903,
0.0200544782,
0.0715212524,
-0.0161200427,
-0.0578460917,
-0.0533447377,
0.0266154688,
-0.0229424611,
0.0014697402,
-0.0327703208,
-0.0056060357,
0.0185287055,
-0.0293254815,
-0.0705998987,
-0.0709381178,
0.0009298432,
-0.0365684703,
-0.0107149221,
0.0004003988,
-0.0403737314,
-0.0453793071,
0.0277490653,
0.0150562301,
-0.0479600541,
0.0245250855,
-0.0344053246,
0.0087690167,
0.0512374118,
0.0436973758,
0.0668541268,
-0.0288580991,
0.0146519244,
0.0526694022,
-0.051323045,
0.0449678153,
0.0278695971,
-0.006588703,
0.0254072696,
0.0255638305,
0.0075489744,
0.0119687654,
0.0528609902,
-0.017912345,
-0.0476570874,
0.0605196878,
0.0246698726,
-0.0201646574,
0.0356884301,
-0.0153767336,
0.0141861979,
0.026778819,
0.0268740952,
-0.088683106,
-0.0136828693,
-0.0017041519,
-0.0124527896,
-0.0592350885,
-0.0003657728,
-0.0260873009,
-0.1065436751,
0.030858269,
0.0004612877,
-0.0290827285,
-0.0382860303,
-0.0143349599,
-0.0225021821,
0.0273096301,
0.0789948925,
-0.0075654602,
0.0484715328,
-0.0271962881,
-0.0251491833,
0.0320327692,
0.000999275,
0.0517913774,
0.017402906,
0.1050635576,
0.0441771597,
0.0454792269,
-0.0036871459,
-0.0808698907,
0.0002144504,
0.0455265492,
-0.001532994,
0.0122918831,
0.0597396567,
0.0152921425,
-0.0083804475,
-0.0047093458,
0.0394844227,
0.0041650101,
0.0090875765,
-0.003787287,
0.0711646602,
-0.0084690163,
-0.0500291064,
0.0205956846,
0.0279880501,
0.0480946153,
0.0325597711,
0.0532300025,
-0.0248781741,
-0.0137091354,
-0.0426704213,
-0.01320366,
-0.0027871858,
-0.0402320139,
0.046836663,
0.0406937674,
0.0201210901,
-0.0461596698,
-0.0240382291,
0.0177875608,
-0.0226678476,
0.0160745643,
-0.0427376963,
0.0060903761,
-0.015034127,
-0.0002418888,
0.0259422585,
-0.056478899,
0.0520623289,
-0.0117395418,
-0.010219858,
0.0115038594,
-0.0741540641,
0.0051516485,
-0.0048595774,
-0.0486868694,
-0.0223342497,
0.0321346745,
0.0552746579,
0.0189422239,
0.0426246524,
-0.027162822,
-0.0234840456,
0.0033760055,
-0.0064622797,
-0.090272136,
0.0501122847,
0.0473281257,
0.0024567095,
0.0104850335,
0.050184194,
-0.0220829211,
0.0223775264,
0.0263324976,
-0.0098676421,
-0.0121612586,
-0.0433803014,
0.0436491743,
0.0112897577,
0.0516439416,
0.0274913888,
0.0318964198,
-0.0429389067,
0.0151318414,
0.006765564,
-0.0008006028,
-0.0259615909,
-0.0315580219,
0.0251486246,
-0.0029062622,
0.0272743106,
-0.0410305411,
-0.0227827821,
-0.0086638406,
-0.0137262186,
-0.0118397726,
0.0000516069,
-0.0011550335,
-0.0316266082,
0.0390775874,
-0.0275275018,
0.0573973581,
-0.0034410092,
0.0817321613,
0.0234717503,
0.0363898687,
0.0130020874,
-0.0457859412,
-0.0463981815,
0.0280745793,
-0.0581673235,
-0.0181977265,
0.0490898229,
0.0446614511,
0.0160745718,
0.0144342948,
0.007951769,
0.024875192,
-0.0103864511,
0.0203328356,
0.014656025,
0.0171014685,
-0.0711692795,
0.0253776442,
-0.0060293372,
-0.0128367227,
-0.0069888001,
0.0417436659,
-0.0014450267,
0.0328324996,
-0.012115919,
-0.0031840876,
-0.0165857542,
-0.025005674,
0.03836051,
0.0156547092,
-0.0334624611,
-0.0111188637,
-0.0647685602,
-0.0667579696,
-0.0118808029,
0.0078595066,
-0.0192721374,
-0.0458934009,
-0.0090511013,
0.0515051745,
0.0345173068,
0.0053521749,
-0.0412765704,
0.0287969932,
0.0275039915,
-0.0117536802,
0.0272293333,
-6.761386935e-33,
-0.0036008791,
-0.0920255035,
-0.0206321459,
-0.0217362475,
-0.0069901864,
0.0617748946,
-0.024895506,
-0.0102910995,
-0.0800518841,
0.0187367499,
-0.0283817258,
0.0302239414,
0.0073506101,
-0.0138890659,
-0.0258149207,
-0.0200119615,
0.0116766458,
-0.0044088783,
-0.0384921059,
0.0151106836,
0.0166642722,
-0.0086439392,
0.082794182,
-0.0308513474,
0.0692862347,
0.0058747269,
-0.0439405404,
0.0498298854,
-0.1058101133,
0.0261465721,
-0.0053737126,
0.0356141031,
-0.0119665246,
-0.0170062836,
0.0028401071,
0.0149570713,
-0.0303965621,
-0.0346771032,
0.0715026334,
0.0089677582,
-0.0641422793,
-0.0507704765,
0.0299644768,
-0.0437020957,
0.0020283833,
-0.0193526242,
0.0105921114,
0.0144987088,
-0.0156516656,
0.0360447615,
-0.0584174395,
-0.0469119512,
-0.0090420367,
-0.0549550205,
-0.0532746166,
0.0466185212,
-0.0110874604,
0.0133749414,
-0.095027566,
0.0066524497,
0.0052444027,
-0.0060023945,
0.0465872176,
0.0041534482,
0.0080651212,
0.0731505826,
0.0460131094,
0.0552119687,
-0.0117745278,
-0.013178031,
0.0169971436,
0.0069962461,
0.0740376189,
0.035588257,
0.0028646053,
-0.0649279729,
-0.0782303438,
-0.0361755602,
0.0718292817,
-0.0090536047,
0.0385942571,
-0.0256353281,
-0.0100351218,
-0.018932499,
-0.056160979,
-0.0108177876,
-0.0347632244,
-0.0193357076,
0.0172074698,
0.0053906799,
-0.0380162597,
-0.0352396667,
0.0245454814,
-0.0810176805,
0.0375097618,
-0.0011079926,
0.0251239482,
0.0017622387,
0.0240294393,
0.0236638188,
-0.055310227,
0.014373539,
-0.0120173721,
-0.0176702384,
0.0332980864,
0.0104136905,
0.0609010309,
0.019754814,
-0.0181851927,
0.0333981924,
-0.047787644,
0.0358083397,
-0.0070163277,
0.0098998602,
0.0309792832,
-0.0074995928,
-0.0472048894,
-0.010495333,
0.0169987939,
0.0173516106,
-0.0577572957,
0.0486708954,
-0.0381972007,
0.0465966091,
-0.0555744544,
-0.0072016316,
-0.0540773273,
0.0528362319,
-0.0007895944,
-0.0489991046,
-0.0260060001,
-0.0342697129,
2.792e-7,
-0.0249916818,
0.0094578629,
-0.0223724432,
0.0696224421,
0.0235250983,
0.0504600182,
0.0191341974,
0.0419692881,
0.0399251245,
-0.0864633396,
-0.0276871063,
0.000512106,
0.0457917266,
0.0320900492,
-0.0614328049,
0.0374341421,
-0.0429815874,
-0.0313501768,
-0.00132513,
-0.0350713469,
0.0109936707,
0.1114225835,
0.0311560221,
-0.0212729294,
0.0210188515,
-0.0210307501,
0.0078010517,
-0.0124327717,
-0.0104616871,
-0.0027119932,
-0.0062194257,
-0.0397445299,
-0.0136955902,
0.0152499601,
0.0123201655,
0.0054164445,
-0.058587268,
0.0271286238,
-0.024820134,
-0.0580519885,
-0.0393317379,
-0.0331143998,
0.003983614,
-0.0852909535,
0.0665453672,
-0.0237967893,
-0.0531694405,
-0.0710487291,
0.0534251966,
-0.031599436,
0.037258774,
-0.0232180506,
0.006241044,
0.0244846735,
-0.0042083836,
0.0224518757,
0.0133488411,
-0.016570121,
-0.0504547432,
-0.0360078327,
0.0028327231,
-0.0460659862,
-0.0160379503,
-0.0006860121,
0.0187379103,
-0.0514149852,
0.054094471,
2.335914135e-34,
-0.0053337882,
-0.029757889,
0.0487908162,
0.0297915749,
0.0468401611,
0.0015145316,
0.0025102475,
0.0029638035,
0.0517901108,
-0.0198820755,
-0.0255216695
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15110v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15110v1 | Relevance feedback strategies for recall-oriented neural information retrieval | 2023-11-25T19:50:41 | 2023-11-25T19:50:41 | Timo Kats, Peter van der Putten, Jan Scholtes | cs.CL | cs.CL | In a number of information retrieval applications (e.g., patent search,
literature review, due diligence, etc.), preventing false negatives is more
important than preventing false positives. However, approaches designed to
reduce review effort (like "technology assisted review") can create false
negatives, since they are often based on active learning systems that exclude
documents automatically based on user feedback. Therefore, this research
proposes a more recall-oriented approach to reducing review effort. More
specifically, through iteratively re-ranking the relevance rankings based on
user feedback, which is also referred to as relevance feedback. In our proposed
method, the relevance rankings are produced by a BERT-based dense-vector search
and the relevance feedback is based on cumulatively summing the queried and
selected embeddings. Our results show that this method can reduce review effort
between 17.85% and 59.04%, compared to a baseline approach (of no feedback),
given a fixed recall target | [
0.0745178759,
-0.0264665503,
0.0063240225,
-0.0305465031,
-0.0022675698,
-0.0119977789,
-0.0317268483,
0.0353180394,
-0.00760466,
-0.0607617535,
-0.0620660484,
-0.0304658171,
-0.0301881377,
0.0205552839,
-0.0057250606,
0.0114288544,
0.0678774938,
0.0336592868,
0.0690247342,
-0.0131040867,
-0.0086409831,
-0.0100747598,
0.010270996,
0.0292032715,
0.0242932308,
0.0375345275,
0.0043866658,
-0.0017200508,
0.0166935101,
-0.015879916,
0.0137329279,
0.0499352589,
0.0175836179,
0.0549652204,
0.0000015078,
-0.0528382324,
-0.0250866022,
-0.0092638079,
-0.0111942952,
0.0514985584,
0.0171210989,
0.0266542751,
0.0429392159,
0.0051603219,
-0.0003667309,
-0.0243120566,
0.0088905329,
0.073942095,
0.042450726,
0.0267003234,
-0.0032831288,
0.024328623,
0.0146575896,
-0.0455569439,
0.0315527655,
-0.0300672967,
0.0140050976,
-0.0294665806,
0.0224983376,
0.0273257252,
0.0345117226,
0.0402823016,
-0.0055480562,
-0.0551825799,
0.0601510704,
0.0147505198,
-0.049641531,
0.0391105711,
0.015749095,
0.0581902079,
0.0187601708,
-0.0185690951,
-0.0261434652,
0.0031293079,
0.010688168,
0.0245141797,
-0.0263325498,
-0.0209211428,
-0.0156373493,
-0.0135041103,
-0.0418889746,
-0.018825043,
0.0266640987,
0.0129718231,
0.0232173204,
0.007275152,
0.0182416569,
-0.0634833351,
0.0453017801,
0.0384863764,
0.0095629813,
-0.008259357,
0.0456646606,
0.0105012367,
-0.0263634473,
-0.0245494805,
0.0295571145,
-0.0288924593,
0.0445704013,
-0.1065504551,
0.0377246067,
0.0080516888,
-0.0122618238,
0.079396069,
-0.0553202927,
0.0376516581,
0.0020710214,
0.0128249107,
-0.0323548354,
-0.0049457634,
-0.0507032014,
-0.0323680006,
-0.0099329557,
0.0922496393,
0.0405439362,
0.0079536298,
-0.0328410193,
0.0357192308,
-0.0297704544,
0.009239072,
-0.0142680546,
0.0563279577,
-0.028464213,
0.0307302736,
-0.0683335289,
-0.0043022824,
-0.0189265199,
-0.0175570417,
-0.0619664788,
0.0215377379,
0.0008022995,
0.0138031421,
-0.0015931281,
-0.0191173758,
0.0140110981,
-0.022721773,
0.006716643,
-0.0565068573,
-0.0211603437,
-0.015627889,
0.0417037755,
0.0074703684,
0.0239452086,
0.0029659057,
-0.012207129,
-0.0349561721,
-0.025908947,
-0.0042615263,
-0.0417101197,
0.0385099538,
-0.0244581066,
0.0388974287,
0.030482173,
-0.0344773605,
0.0489463769,
0.0074816169,
0.0173431691,
0.0329689123,
-0.0240306016,
0.0463764109,
0.0286205877,
0.0215206202,
0.0226192512,
-0.0333426669,
0.0564074107,
0.0134288082,
-0.0145229977,
0.0300407074,
-0.0572635382,
0.0100714015,
-0.0084378999,
0.0072935261,
-0.0518216416,
0.0047190636,
0.0170159601,
0.0138352644,
0.0559266098,
0.0014188336,
-0.0152344108,
0.0003165458,
-0.0034677009,
-0.0161752664,
-0.0366267487,
0.0654886663,
-0.0598091669,
-0.0195942484,
0.0286785625,
-0.0411012284,
-0.0578528829,
-0.0238862652,
0.0126099205,
0.0395156555,
-0.0187708884,
0.0123921027,
0.029388614,
-0.005587853,
-0.0236088093,
0.0333491117,
-0.0167809445,
-0.0140919425,
0.0118901497,
-0.0447059646,
0.0189363007,
0.0484353304,
0.0877701566,
-0.0586824343,
-0.0183273908,
-0.003646441,
-0.045751173,
-0.0083082188,
0.0735710487,
-0.0248371027,
-0.0152085237,
-0.0485743359,
-0.0738368407,
-0.0379731618,
0.0015833065,
0.0262590405,
-0.0032505409,
0.0297417771,
0.0340890028,
-0.038969826,
-0.0210717972,
0.0209669825,
0.0374229401,
-0.0304498114,
0.0400684848,
0.0140605578,
0.0034492889,
0.0436645336,
-0.014414438,
0.0271864906,
0.0334154367,
0.0020566205,
-0.0565478057,
-0.0174806323,
-0.0058593019,
0.0098038157,
-0.0015616483,
0.0070831785,
0.0307170842,
0.0316655189,
0.013507965,
-0.016980892,
-0.0153259151,
-0.0363448039,
0.0550009161,
-0.0368872769,
-0.0126627721,
-0.045539584,
-0.02280063,
-0.048303999,
0.0541128777,
-0.02030682,
0.0508000813,
0.0401897207,
-0.0216255989,
0.0367916599,
-0.0414260998,
-0.0604306459,
-0.0027165492,
0.003190021,
0.0183439869,
0.0438867919,
0.0100255916,
-0.0209647715,
0.0223332252,
-0.0881872475,
-0.010728403,
-0.021901438,
0.0111592179,
-0.0148068909,
-0.0063774982,
0.029519856,
-0.0412594154,
-0.0367683992,
-0.03763083,
-0.0118626738,
0.0231917184,
0.0145696308,
0.0263551306,
0.0367912203,
-0.0309666805,
-0.0630364567,
-0.0074535627,
0.0449165925,
0.0175044201,
-0.001564109,
-0.0295684896,
0.0255673174,
-0.0682513118,
0.0173886381,
0.0202508215,
0.0277221557,
0.0061587631,
-0.0159010794,
-0.0042233416,
0.0455307737,
-0.0012223625,
0.0050420505,
0.0384652466,
0.0125866774,
-0.1008023918,
0.0254760999,
-0.0316426642,
0.0220771674,
0.0378648788,
-0.006471674,
0.0386020467,
-0.0508985594,
-0.0087461863,
-0.0252311919,
-0.0725322068,
-0.0069188182,
-0.0092979092,
-0.020366326,
-0.0610822476,
-0.0152049828,
0.0400120392,
0.0124222264,
-0.00621753,
-0.0347366519,
0.1014113277,
0.0335064232,
0.0097783906,
-0.0482793339,
0.0378379375,
-0.0307767801,
0.0462720878,
-0.0287707523,
-0.0038100313,
-0.0540857911,
-0.0098423287,
0.0189728383,
-0.0247809049,
0.029335795,
-0.0732925385,
0.0274967086,
0.0043616248,
0.031899102,
-0.0127614373,
-0.049028594,
-0.0421779267,
-0.0194760952,
0.03531795,
0.036524307,
-0.0183666311,
-0.0310456268,
-0.0830450431,
0.0323429927,
0.029761631,
0.0687846914,
-0.0126419719,
-0.0443453863,
0.0411134325,
0.0280488748,
0.0118262433,
-0.0316823795,
-0.0032452303,
0.0063653742,
0.0176619478,
0.0344092175,
0.0402572751,
-0.0262011122,
-0.0186286084,
-0.0195348281,
0.0354550034,
-0.0586321577,
0.003012487,
-0.0193945486,
-0.0294154529,
0.001118188,
-0.0210972223,
0.0690194592,
0.0385519043,
-0.0778554603,
-0.0292731132,
-0.0349831693,
0.0006221161,
0.0361321978,
0.0668431148,
0.0001810352,
0.0258606225,
0.0045524645,
0.0678762421,
0.0131374337,
-0.0022753067,
-0.0046850783,
-0.1094447002,
0.0287524145,
-0.0357147194,
0.0300141238,
-0.0714683756,
-0.0538494959,
0.0041950913,
-0.0008396993,
-0.0185379349,
0.0276475139,
0.0115693584,
-0.0041537196,
0.015817944,
0.0084857177,
-0.021932818,
0.0265949983,
-0.0143256523,
-0.0187631063,
0.0503512658,
0.0043734303,
0.0096302861,
-0.0163227431,
-0.0083253011,
-0.0546522662,
-0.0021556767,
-0.0256158765,
0.0541454554,
-0.0038400625,
0.0113186343,
-0.0345996544,
-0.027068276,
0.0067998627,
0.0352264009,
-0.0205179919,
0.0453272164,
-0.0821527541,
0.0107381614,
-0.0792219713,
-0.0176652502,
-0.0323682912,
0.0455365591,
-0.0079610702,
-0.0386632755,
0.0122151868,
0.004236469,
0.0300076138,
-0.0324601792,
-0.016265111,
-0.0194332432,
-0.0438806266,
0.0182253718,
-0.0936299264,
-0.0331193022,
-0.008508943,
0.0469615273,
0.0049896529,
0.0106165577,
-0.0238691401,
-0.0191869121,
-0.0318219922,
0.0349594802,
0.0341657549,
0.0187573582,
-0.0228730608,
0.0101357503,
0.0716891885,
-0.0127061466,
-0.03298999,
-0.0454712585,
0.0134497928,
-0.0127053848,
-0.049495548,
0.0461141542,
0.0148721859,
0.0432043485,
-0.0559195131,
-0.0642421767,
0.0921469703,
0.0178080909,
0.0053215441,
-0.0047300025,
0.0426843017,
-0.0178637486,
-0.0451622568,
-0.004759023,
-0.1069804877,
0.0022391092,
0.0275896993,
0.0389483906,
0.0333427191,
-0.0213338751,
0.0117151365,
0.028989166,
0.0590957254,
0.0336913243,
0.0481767915,
-0.0333500057,
0.0436967202,
0.0220807195,
-0.0147594353,
-0.0173766688,
0.0445139408,
-0.0080327969,
-0.0131469583,
-0.0397737809,
0.0577438213,
0.003161238,
0.0638154745,
-0.0886363313,
-0.0109755136,
0.0015622525,
0.0113901682,
-0.0365503877,
0.0116591314,
-0.0639905185,
0.0337146111,
0.0074910983,
0.0239455029,
-0.0538154095,
0.0037546081,
0.0249847472,
0.017485695,
-0.0104242526,
0.0318758562,
-0.0809254274,
-0.0167231485,
-0.051964052,
0.0137306293,
0.0379338823,
0.0075199287,
-0.0037488879,
-0.0160408914,
-0.0084324712,
-0.0211632941,
-0.0518527329,
0.0325858369,
0.023959253,
0.0071333381,
0.0414388143,
0.048398532,
0.0401657932,
0.0428720377,
-0.0384183936,
0.0384240113,
-0.0745174214,
-0.0611220226,
-0.0395145752,
-0.0334698074,
0.0539937802,
0.0652038679,
-0.0528378859,
-0.0170248039,
-0.0127082402,
-0.0137271313,
0.0626343712,
0.0037787901,
0.0102373427,
-0.0018860464,
0.0675696135,
0.0786333755,
0.0185357593,
-0.0325053446,
-0.0361427069,
-0.0035688272,
-0.0149202282,
-0.0012600488,
-0.0387447625,
-5.625097892e-33,
0.0176871717,
-0.0070859296,
-0.0153628765,
-0.0180281401,
-0.0192015637,
0.0102968877,
-0.0082773501,
-0.0475121811,
-0.0255987942,
0.0122177424,
-0.0473573096,
0.0257128458,
-0.0098770522,
-0.0207643379,
0.0134629915,
0.0035101653,
0.0775403157,
-0.0084301867,
-0.0157889146,
0.0516981967,
0.0305382274,
0.0563868284,
0.023823062,
-0.0307112578,
0.050647337,
0.0350853987,
-0.0016701373,
0.039692916,
-0.0289705154,
0.0639611259,
-0.0192671474,
0.0504111648,
0.0519779734,
-0.0264179353,
0.0236924123,
-0.0163874719,
-0.0827073827,
-0.0399034508,
-0.0184485968,
-0.0278734155,
-0.0033527894,
0.0430232063,
0.0362402201,
-0.0184963252,
-0.0404471941,
0.052927129,
0.0384602211,
0.0041346024,
-0.0867260247,
-0.0894816592,
-0.0095956381,
-0.0030210486,
-0.0071247141,
0.006440666,
-0.0119295334,
0.0785887614,
0.0115678227,
0.0332892984,
-0.0760662258,
0.0110157784,
-0.0554558374,
0.0304615386,
-0.0095847258,
-0.0092148054,
-0.0270991046,
0.053068921,
-0.0275435336,
0.007348645,
-0.0056641204,
-0.0623417422,
0.0312207043,
-0.012064252,
0.0448450111,
0.0004532873,
0.0248595085,
-0.0098938104,
-0.0510955304,
0.038476035,
0.020138422,
0.0785687193,
0.0625483841,
0.0169374067,
-0.0554505549,
-0.0007140758,
-0.0186298322,
0.0133271106,
-0.0620648935,
0.0022578365,
0.0243573207,
0.0646866933,
-0.0251235552,
-0.0325963721,
0.0048490227,
-0.0147768138,
0.0179392695,
0.0354992412,
0.0019592249,
-0.0012481838,
0.0001083789,
-0.031039007,
-0.0069915755,
0.0028069997,
0.0110398717,
-0.0292658359,
-0.0395613872,
-0.0141202668,
0.0221588947,
0.0174657293,
-0.0302295517,
0.016420031,
0.0191987175,
-0.0124868816,
-0.002938512,
0.0253896415,
-0.0192098059,
0.0030576661,
0.0260818638,
0.0618719943,
0.0343461335,
0.0567502603,
-0.0367632732,
-0.0091141723,
0.0360522084,
-0.0061298492,
0.0102196671,
-0.004464197,
0.0084260888,
0.0649075434,
-0.0235420875,
-0.0751548335,
-0.0064841439,
0.0373205021,
2.448e-7,
0.0098595601,
0.0385365635,
-0.0255073793,
-0.0302504785,
0.0175228883,
0.0139245177,
0.0073263124,
0.0175648555,
0.0321435295,
0.0547712259,
0.0271113962,
-0.0186824892,
-0.0055377027,
0.0027902732,
-0.0602895208,
-0.0491305664,
-0.0930505544,
-0.010860187,
-0.0189414695,
-0.0255985595,
0.0094266869,
0.0673411638,
0.0164784249,
-0.0128426235,
0.0032908639,
-0.0934133828,
0.050172478,
0.0118819391,
0.0019387597,
-0.0156148756,
0.1395674348,
0.0203251746,
-0.0055453149,
-0.012712379,
-0.0240704902,
0.0265668035,
0.0212400202,
-0.0006181846,
-0.0140878111,
-0.0678375587,
0.0013650018,
0.000981466,
0.041646909,
0.0021061152,
0.0582549945,
-0.0112828985,
0.0071209488,
0.0182973798,
0.0006930693,
-0.007791501,
0.0568398945,
-0.011006006,
-0.0355206914,
0.0065092007,
-0.0077148662,
0.0260181371,
-0.0087954355,
-0.1253572106,
0.0241632182,
-0.0174170416,
-0.0202493947,
-0.0230744071,
-0.0168659966,
-0.0030048466,
0.0063496707,
-0.014966785,
0.0195519291,
1.897911279e-34,
0.0907713473,
-0.0240004268,
0.0116464617,
-0.0215947609,
0.0043928446,
0.0303587653,
0.0043515689,
-0.0218499471,
0.0355043598,
-0.0782343522,
-0.038040176
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15106v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15106v1 | Solving the Right Problem is Key for Translational NLP: A Case Study in UMLS Vocabulary Insertion | 2023-11-25T19:35:53 | 2023-11-25T19:35:53 | Bernal Jimenez Gutierrez, Yuqing Mao, Vinh Nguyen, Kin Wah Fung, Yu Su, Olivier Bodenreider | cs.CL | cs.CL | As the immense opportunities enabled by large language models become more
apparent, NLP systems will be increasingly expected to excel in real-world
settings. However, in many instances, powerful models alone will not yield
translational NLP solutions, especially if the formulated problem is not well
aligned with the real-world task. In this work, we study the case of UMLS
vocabulary insertion, an important real-world task in which hundreds of
thousands of new terms, referred to as atoms, are added to the UMLS, one of the
most comprehensive open-source biomedical knowledge bases. Previous work aimed
to develop an automated NLP system to make this time-consuming, costly, and
error-prone task more efficient. Nevertheless, practical progress in this
direction has been difficult to achieve due to a problem formulation and
evaluation gap between research output and the real-world task. In order to
address this gap, we introduce a new formulation for UMLS vocabulary insertion
which mirrors the real-world task, datasets which faithfully represent it and
several strong baselines we developed through re-purposing existing solutions.
Additionally, we propose an effective rule-enhanced biomedical language model
which enables important new model behavior, outperforms all strong baselines
and provides measurable qualitative improvements to editors who carry out the
UVI task. We hope this case study provides insight into the considerable
importance of problem formulation for the success of translational NLP
solutions. | [
0.0530576222,
0.0726097375,
0.025130976,
-0.0374601036,
-0.0302658994,
0.0211360287,
-0.0144473454,
-0.0093491711,
-0.024039764,
-0.0385612175,
0.0554255769,
-0.0353595428,
-0.0029031229,
0.0527902059,
0.0230865907,
0.0048314743,
0.0463451035,
0.0197247453,
-0.0238101631,
-0.0006412291,
-0.0154621564,
-0.0033430303,
0.0288920067,
-0.00297951,
0.0257625394,
0.0174433757,
0.0021958379,
0.0073762932,
0.0131762354,
-0.0184487533,
-0.0340497047,
0.0525929779,
0.0262092855,
0.0350165293,
0.0000019318,
-0.07944417,
-0.083653219,
0.0461172722,
-0.0151816076,
-0.0387548171,
0.0684180334,
-0.0731671005,
-0.0429937504,
-0.0040972852,
-0.0182810444,
-0.0093874531,
0.0778844506,
-0.0069557051,
0.0338619985,
0.0576488115,
-0.0229222029,
-0.0114776883,
0.0404250212,
-0.0012597827,
0.0380471162,
-0.0367435701,
0.0488408692,
0.0186316893,
0.0232465863,
-0.0036067646,
0.012966983,
0.0716802999,
-0.0411096253,
-0.0224269833,
0.0374129154,
-0.0121894171,
-0.0412742719,
-0.0309568122,
-0.0152144618,
0.0515411384,
-0.0166036896,
-0.0408169366,
0.0059510581,
0.0309241191,
-0.0263176877,
0.0335677043,
-0.049165938,
0.0150457639,
-0.0132846208,
-0.0227294154,
0.0573110171,
-0.0315821767,
0.032768555,
0.0247243308,
-0.043349877,
0.0309066158,
0.0464307331,
-0.0514817201,
0.0176539309,
-0.0339863896,
-0.0199132338,
-0.0353647657,
0.052123908,
0.0171057489,
-0.0128341932,
0.0480106734,
0.0040373001,
-0.0346358828,
0.0690394118,
-0.0848043561,
0.0465898663,
-0.0115118371,
0.0159929879,
0.0500162058,
0.0027954103,
-0.0330802426,
0.0032007818,
0.0055137719,
-0.0585243292,
0.0193348806,
-0.0723381639,
0.0005911457,
-0.0367698185,
-0.000020095,
-0.0241336487,
-0.0236626491,
-0.0657581612,
0.0096561257,
0.0034764032,
0.0043198541,
0.0301759318,
-0.0043379711,
-0.0132410945,
0.0172506142,
0.0185040664,
0.002472867,
0.0233639572,
-0.004405566,
-0.0162188951,
-0.035141591,
-0.0176026523,
-0.0098318337,
0.0105926273,
-0.0023813399,
-0.0014945682,
0.0800643414,
0.0455062278,
-0.01040053,
0.0296366289,
-0.0517409481,
-0.0401263721,
-0.0046495995,
0.0069864076,
-0.0735515729,
0.0607603602,
0.0116477394,
-0.0036155907,
-0.0623835437,
0.0266780127,
0.0179893933,
-0.0633447319,
0.1137444451,
-0.0846104622,
-0.012540115,
0.0060875039,
0.0104740737,
0.029701544,
0.0028978165,
-0.0083171027,
-0.0445962325,
0.0451066345,
-0.0131593235,
-0.0012749586,
0.0087404819,
0.0026735046,
0.0050866646,
-0.0270809624,
-0.0074833981,
0.0337469578,
0.101860553,
-0.0121370181,
0.0256047808,
0.0021164375,
0.012740911,
0.033774808,
0.018020561,
0.0276834667,
0.0276014637,
0.0179981794,
-0.0204199571,
-0.0211148933,
-0.0474332608,
0.0135634504,
-0.0195961744,
-0.0202276967,
0.0438779481,
-0.0012511964,
0.0170658603,
0.0251035783,
-0.0100181922,
-0.0480712652,
-0.0126746576,
-0.0073994123,
-0.0301284026,
0.0411940441,
0.0208340846,
-0.0205128659,
0.0765818432,
0.058303047,
-0.0571982339,
0.0144363074,
-0.0064723426,
-0.0223303176,
0.0643670633,
0.0962302238,
-0.0371312425,
-0.0567740835,
-0.0031759371,
-0.0089983111,
0.0430029482,
0.0197227914,
-0.0157964006,
-0.0239234753,
-0.0374298729,
-0.0305021908,
0.0239679031,
-0.0074724993,
0.0071983188,
0.0108719384,
-0.0112625631,
-0.0010408058,
-0.0384956412,
-0.085288249,
0.0389037803,
-0.0665510446,
-0.0194989741,
-0.0144401146,
-0.0171420816,
-0.0023732113,
0.0370703004,
-0.0093839625,
0.0358223543,
0.057664115,
-0.0374283046,
-0.0654734895,
-0.0138131911,
0.0110380426,
-0.0277919564,
0.0699380562,
-0.0149942925,
0.0007836387,
-0.0388546176,
-0.0198920537,
-0.0196425002,
-0.0304773152,
0.0008246833,
0.0084648691,
-0.0165480264,
0.0359244496,
0.0472953022,
0.004587655,
-0.0623838976,
0.0213580355,
-0.0107219396,
0.0269652363,
0.0081912726,
-0.0746174827,
0.0131606488,
-0.0158076528,
0.0006755505,
0.0344982147,
-0.0158164147,
0.0115256542,
0.0085347397,
0.0287703313,
-0.0368238688,
-0.024792945,
-0.0535713546,
-0.0049633728,
0.043868646,
0.023420332,
0.0242946725,
0.0357516147,
0.0104136635,
0.0137239899,
-0.0221547484,
-0.0151495282,
-0.0071886322,
0.0071440418,
0.0172332097,
0.0157023501,
-0.0128183197,
-0.0422830693,
-0.0043359161,
-0.0286929924,
0.0326180719,
-0.0098159015,
-0.0470859446,
-0.0365235284,
0.0211094636,
-0.040397346,
0.0269876979,
0.0311100427,
-0.0333444588,
-0.0030335844,
-0.0021514706,
0.0248175673,
0.0276098996,
-0.0174409002,
0.0178948194,
0.0926079825,
-0.0205123257,
0.0046500107,
-0.016213987,
-0.0331146456,
-0.02814514,
0.0144494716,
-0.0119307553,
0.037022844,
0.0318526253,
-0.0100171939,
-0.0247384533,
-0.0101906508,
0.051214058,
-0.0456698239,
-0.0233521499,
-0.0395638011,
0.0185693838,
-0.0391386487,
0.0458022207,
0.0197612848,
-0.0375427268,
0.0789506808,
-0.0220257491,
0.0427413397,
-0.0872861743,
-0.0042022229,
-0.0394345783,
-0.0135239456,
0.0040386897,
0.0501721092,
-0.0157434642,
0.036139708,
-0.0058444105,
0.045309484,
-0.0206466131,
-0.0304960571,
0.0479697622,
-0.0458073951,
0.0055732848,
-0.0097077582,
0.0006463207,
-0.02466809,
0.0307858549,
-0.0053326264,
0.0307406243,
0.0508001968,
-0.0395185724,
-0.0426147766,
0.0318797007,
0.0221798364,
0.0299737938,
0.0126752704,
-0.0316060558,
-0.0151532479,
-0.0084865363,
0.0404084362,
-0.0340547934,
0.0218614191,
0.022961203,
0.0442849472,
0.0544734448,
-0.0043622251,
0.0244544856,
-0.0021960267,
0.0261752941,
0.0339029431,
-0.0608672127,
0.0075663459,
-0.0168938991,
-0.001812004,
-0.0199800581,
-0.0310356151,
0.1118560135,
0.081252493,
-0.035758514,
0.0132453814,
-0.0259197317,
-0.0247167833,
0.0142599801,
0.0392091125,
-0.08311297,
-0.012519706,
-0.0039160512,
0.0082468083,
-0.0129363528,
-0.0263196416,
-0.0195637792,
-0.03863585,
0.0341088995,
0.0506293476,
-0.0500253737,
0.0052487114,
-0.040965341,
-0.0175959244,
-0.0467951894,
0.010625856,
-0.0035428042,
-0.0183090586,
-0.0049444092,
0.0061602262,
-0.0136633413,
-0.0920146033,
0.0060132281,
-0.0548729599,
0.0404728055,
0.0533364713,
0.0362648107,
-0.0226290226,
-0.0033351714,
0.0400410965,
0.0243290719,
-0.0174443927,
-0.0155319152,
0.0452629253,
0.0141492197,
0.0062274267,
-0.0253296625,
-0.0086727599,
-0.0725078806,
-0.0398684517,
-0.0111804456,
0.1232679635,
0.0162355322,
0.0236836746,
-0.0466098115,
-0.0060595227,
0.0143601913,
0.055080317,
-0.0019232085,
-0.0158743579,
0.0104495352,
-0.0186814032,
0.004712909,
-0.0137045039,
-0.0155868409,
0.0255799051,
-0.1026437283,
-0.0425032303,
-0.0988814086,
-0.0356930234,
0.0585384592,
0.0144580426,
0.0683709532,
0.0494977832,
-0.0041502598,
-0.0318250172,
-0.0420310348,
0.0092778979,
0.0276760999,
0.0344271176,
-0.0372074805,
-0.0486117713,
0.0332502723,
0.0234698895,
-0.01925385,
0.0370857343,
0.0338618681,
-0.0710769296,
0.0257061291,
0.0364856906,
0.0246620458,
-0.0173274279,
-0.0166353639,
-0.0340670198,
0.0334149562,
0.0341284759,
0.0034709945,
-0.0356486514,
0.0227375273,
-0.0041337297,
-0.0185121484,
-0.0049760561,
0.0063627507,
0.0110950451,
-0.0644090697,
0.0655823797,
-0.0068099112,
-0.0628832653,
0.0829361379,
0.026693929,
0.0388810858,
-0.0393952057,
-0.0194213018,
-0.0043441057,
0.013919509,
-0.0334645398,
-0.0135665881,
-0.034762457,
0.0014856977,
0.0421890095,
-0.0020228771,
-0.0056737135,
0.0280136988,
-0.0756463483,
-0.0112978984,
-0.0058061797,
0.0109326923,
0.0279854909,
0.0101368437,
0.0416418537,
0.008552664,
-0.0048779505,
0.0158365872,
-0.0691919401,
0.0099193761,
-0.072733894,
0.0066019464,
-0.0003540224,
0.0186524596,
-0.010396596,
0.0539727807,
-0.0191617589,
-0.0202445202,
-0.0208013412,
0.0094339233,
0.0306436289,
-0.0021895866,
0.0725117102,
-0.0311504379,
-0.0429650173,
-0.0310296603,
0.0242390838,
-0.0274380688,
0.0071321256,
0.0499644615,
0.0419769138,
-0.0095346989,
-0.0470462851,
0.0436943099,
0.0202185512,
0.0369131193,
-0.0199298672,
-0.0718163997,
-0.0006739561,
-0.001131856,
0.0208708979,
0.0025793104,
-0.0559908748,
-0.0144342808,
-0.0736142248,
-0.0397422351,
-0.0111631323,
0.0483676828,
0.0024449856,
0.0373052843,
0.0225868989,
0.0442874432,
0.0219730791,
-0.0309924912,
-0.0297522489,
0.0059149615,
-0.0523447655,
-0.0425321348,
0.0539326556,
-5.72309004e-33,
0.0058538793,
-0.0480219685,
0.0320785642,
-0.0149464235,
-0.006078261,
-0.0179594066,
-0.0358337276,
-0.018973669,
0.0248373523,
0.0291839819,
-0.0086799124,
-0.0241142735,
0.0150623545,
-0.0174352117,
0.0183527153,
0.0481041335,
0.0103755295,
0.0595442206,
0.0285786092,
-0.0307654478,
0.0337430388,
0.0541687571,
0.0856578723,
-0.0332912579,
0.0361217931,
0.0307283849,
0.0123723643,
0.0136192413,
-0.0155772455,
0.0559360608,
-0.0277547296,
0.034403421,
-0.0027912287,
-0.0163518582,
-0.0205619577,
-0.0329545848,
-0.0437801592,
-0.0060790656,
0.025698971,
-0.017100893,
-0.0313092358,
-0.0121095721,
0.0084308786,
-0.0263497569,
-0.019767601,
-0.0104811713,
0.0058175819,
-0.0512633584,
-0.0684574395,
-0.0272236355,
-0.094159849,
0.043957971,
0.0641062707,
0.0177116264,
0.0208353177,
-0.0153860897,
-0.01741332,
-0.0278278086,
-0.022010535,
0.0194050297,
0.0663704276,
0.061340563,
0.0465098172,
-0.0520458184,
-0.0298044346,
0.0073740236,
-0.0253288411,
-0.0202479605,
0.0415968522,
0.0052342894,
-0.0268589519,
0.05872887,
0.0380445942,
0.0320854448,
0.0571507215,
0.021140717,
-0.0456670783,
0.0520241112,
-0.0892872587,
0.0694357157,
-0.0270257294,
0.0443327837,
-0.0387742296,
-0.0191874634,
-0.0383172818,
0.0349849537,
-0.0403597057,
-0.0775634125,
0.0280211512,
-0.0327700302,
-0.040032696,
0.0070366603,
-0.0081734583,
-0.028209947,
-0.0107567022,
-0.0152427787,
0.0154059613,
-0.0033960156,
-0.0561751127,
0.0085461959,
-0.0463487841,
-0.0242464785,
0.0197301935,
-0.0351978093,
0.0382110626,
0.0022291883,
0.0401461646,
0.0450089909,
-0.0469924137,
0.009088723,
-0.0337937437,
-0.0385597013,
-0.0091026165,
0.009273272,
0.0045031095,
0.0247665998,
0.0132677676,
0.0278835036,
0.0794657916,
-0.0009804281,
-0.0256463178,
0.0151507463,
0.0155416327,
0.0197894927,
-0.0603237972,
0.0214758851,
-0.0302229058,
0.0455128178,
0.0509013534,
-0.0341326296,
-0.0234062541,
-0.0237138178,
2.794e-7,
0.0798214674,
0.0710685626,
0.0253668409,
0.0141683156,
-0.0082628066,
-0.0129555054,
-0.0516803749,
0.0271512941,
-0.0317208767,
0.0061349096,
0.0362791121,
-0.0139408028,
-0.0000529113,
0.0054750019,
-0.063397184,
-0.0260436069,
-0.0291435681,
-0.0031993159,
-0.0538189374,
-0.0176279452,
0.0641243681,
0.0589495227,
-0.0027336285,
-0.0187986493,
-0.0183151253,
-0.0242376179,
0.0395941138,
-0.0417926833,
-0.0399625599,
0.0290474296,
0.0432323627,
-0.0017425155,
0.0055843764,
0.0099048968,
-0.0559099652,
-0.0221722852,
0.0082548,
0.0509853773,
-0.0692405403,
0.0488365702,
0.0633527189,
-0.0474208929,
0.0211649947,
-0.0518181622,
0.0038511346,
-0.0438081957,
-0.0321464129,
-0.0312356856,
0.0024010635,
0.0294501297,
0.027488362,
-0.0230761301,
-0.0031225535,
0.0194186717,
0.0159141868,
0.0407518074,
-0.0573828854,
-0.0574094579,
-0.0222224761,
0.0637654588,
0.0260703396,
-0.027643906,
0.0090991966,
-0.0108827045,
0.0052812081,
-0.050978031,
-0.0042519034,
3.055445706e-34,
0.0241081696,
0.0123698656,
0.0150569063,
0.0305508338,
0.0453069136,
-0.0362243913,
-0.0017143373,
0.0423430577,
-0.0250430852,
-0.0670613348,
-0.0111913821
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.16185v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.16185v1 | Enhancing Sentiment Analysis Results through Outlier Detection Optimization | 2023-11-25T18:20:43 | 2023-11-25T18:20:43 | Yuetian Chen, Mei Si | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | When dealing with text data containing subjective labels like speaker
emotions, inaccuracies or discrepancies among labelers are not uncommon. Such
discrepancies can significantly affect the performance of machine learning
algorithms. This study investigates the potential of identifying and addressing
outliers in text data with subjective labels, aiming to enhance classification
outcomes. We utilized the Deep SVDD algorithm, a one-class classification
method, to detect outliers in nine text-based emotion and sentiment analysis
datasets. By employing both a small-sized language model (DistilBERT base model
with 66 million parameters) and non-deep learning machine learning algorithms
(decision tree, KNN, Logistic Regression, and LDA) as the classifier, our
findings suggest that the removal of outliers can lead to enhanced results in
most cases. Additionally, as outliers in such datasets are not necessarily
unlearnable, we experienced utilizing a large language model -- DeBERTa v3
large with 131 million parameters, which can capture very complex patterns in
data. We continued to observe performance enhancements across multiple
datasets. | [
0.026309697,
0.0474620797,
-0.0279346555,
0.0306642782,
-0.0455171615,
0.0277575646,
-0.0178617705,
-0.028852161,
-0.0014665616,
-0.0238852575,
0.039022401,
-0.0259574596,
-0.0384653173,
0.0030782649,
-0.0653233007,
-0.0267837569,
0.0314704105,
0.0260716584,
0.0974536017,
-0.0285663847,
0.0271283351,
-0.0076801647,
0.0072573754,
-0.0081060501,
-0.03811628,
-0.031550698,
0.0120101003,
0.0066317283,
0.0387418084,
0.0163411871,
0.0611605309,
0.0469917841,
-0.0152810067,
0.0435813032,
0.0000019928,
-0.0261912961,
0.0125241354,
-0.0240479019,
0.0028081348,
0.0348670073,
0.0399114676,
-0.0130117489,
0.0012148242,
0.0280590262,
-0.0240185801,
0.0019296168,
0.0263369307,
0.0615898855,
0.0567462444,
0.0577843152,
-0.0201685596,
-0.0205029249,
-0.0268954225,
0.0255492385,
-0.0146935079,
0.0186343528,
0.0293969419,
-0.0346897766,
-0.0469381139,
-0.0311052687,
-0.0153319826,
0.0025137281,
-0.0141142886,
0.0089799864,
0.0327404998,
-0.0099489214,
0.0025589762,
-0.0367985591,
0.015733147,
0.0822520703,
-0.021115046,
-0.0271550883,
0.00203825,
-0.0101517607,
-0.0078758458,
-0.0252077803,
-0.0159820933,
0.0011392505,
0.0123427063,
0.0260862913,
0.0112088453,
0.001096252,
0.0242802184,
0.0128079299,
0.0010117327,
0.0085587064,
-0.0452347659,
-0.0505135879,
0.0272185579,
0.0004546518,
-0.031714581,
-0.0096782036,
0.0145373326,
-0.0027332336,
0.022589732,
0.010431271,
-0.0269498061,
-0.0404556766,
0.0149277467,
-0.0755576044,
-0.0017008127,
-0.0040297746,
-0.0486529134,
0.0231732372,
0.0226763003,
0.0177920721,
0.0471199751,
0.0094435485,
0.0168396533,
-0.0261032786,
-0.0336945765,
0.0262990929,
0.0086966697,
0.0484458655,
-0.0225685015,
0.0222900193,
-0.0663400665,
-0.0086390516,
-0.0152258091,
-0.0083911344,
-0.0242158994,
0.0057848492,
0.0210447349,
0.0329806954,
-0.0245976653,
0.0428493358,
-0.0421310812,
0.0130242622,
-0.0435346775,
-0.0379932486,
0.0287740529,
0.0412565693,
0.0240393449,
0.0251518674,
0.039649535,
-0.0009035951,
0.0276381727,
-0.0100058829,
-0.0107608158,
-0.027502276,
-0.0178214125,
-0.0346565917,
-0.0251928251,
-0.0932574719,
0.008296011,
0.0065663587,
-0.01221886,
-0.0184129681,
0.0411819704,
0.0153997876,
-0.0239012986,
0.0389091969,
-0.0438028798,
0.0379745029,
0.0360255614,
-0.0180623569,
0.0247823875,
-0.0045480658,
-0.0092397863,
0.00408886,
0.0503361225,
-0.01615954,
0.0693865493,
0.0111934189,
-0.031292513,
-0.0605101362,
-0.025906397,
0.0126014296,
-0.0422302932,
-0.0201130211,
0.0129308961,
-0.0115193855,
0.0113273934,
-0.0130798146,
0.0447750613,
-0.0099103963,
-0.0341337062,
0.0144493999,
-0.0623950846,
0.0219280366,
0.0305869766,
-0.0614587516,
-0.024262799,
0.017492136,
0.0280665737,
-0.056384217,
-0.0243997183,
-0.0196740236,
-0.021767322,
-0.0628239289,
-0.0264075231,
-0.0277899597,
0.0119571649,
-0.0101450402,
0.0332742743,
-0.0385984033,
-0.0344947577,
-0.025330808,
0.0360017456,
-0.0275948104,
-0.0246103555,
-0.0032739039,
0.0151247708,
0.0881473273,
-0.0226450376,
-0.0135230981,
0.0358978882,
-0.0719369799,
0.027529791,
0.0158949289,
0.0313766934,
0.0029596931,
-0.0020639228,
-0.0486372635,
0.0281542297,
0.0198477805,
0.0215390343,
0.0312910937,
-0.0221209899,
0.0332576334,
-0.0052507087,
-0.0452349633,
-0.0228004586,
0.0096363313,
0.0173255987,
-0.0362075008,
0.0297523886,
0.0264155734,
0.0059253727,
0.0149859702,
-0.0252328627,
-0.0402568951,
0.0022806374,
0.0079442859,
-0.0526059754,
-0.0042204582,
0.0011267377,
-0.0430652089,
0.0138150956,
-0.0297382306,
-0.0402804613,
0.0673284829,
0.0004797231,
-0.0073144254,
0.0178415626,
-0.0345435999,
0.000333351,
-0.0396022089,
-0.0029352475,
-0.0445518456,
0.0314260833,
-0.0110713188,
0.0639359653,
-0.0191541892,
0.0411725156,
-0.0523432381,
-0.0263788123,
0.0554563142,
-0.0089199916,
-0.03880753,
-0.0152280396,
-0.0294697843,
0.059640307,
0.0086891223,
-0.0151913483,
-0.0179067589,
-0.0091676163,
-0.0504390821,
-0.0061802599,
-0.0331303217,
0.0062349639,
0.0055023446,
-0.0000931474,
-0.0094841802,
0.0146638118,
-0.0220589768,
0.0047432641,
0.0138828214,
0.0094303014,
0.0618010089,
0.0019476151,
-0.0005946294,
-0.0324798636,
-0.0003679244,
-0.0321553051,
-0.0022961318,
0.0148532838,
-0.0108188344,
0.0006462874,
0.0134553649,
-0.0588130392,
0.0379679911,
-0.0106074316,
-0.0562407225,
-0.0115832193,
0.0087917484,
0.0478483923,
0.0155304559,
0.0237760264,
0.036879532,
0.0118944002,
0.0036480799,
-0.0249380041,
-0.0011949461,
-0.0530182011,
0.0270497333,
-0.0361081883,
0.0213184878,
-0.0191353094,
0.0056330292,
0.0267358683,
-0.0222066063,
-0.0029118983,
0.0247816667,
0.0251703579,
-0.0059618969,
-0.0180647708,
0.0280050747,
0.0096690515,
0.0420870781,
-0.0073469817,
-0.0342397094,
0.0375269838,
0.0506896116,
-0.0090455972,
-0.0532160737,
-0.0474575013,
-0.0132264895,
-0.0208258294,
-0.0077761211,
0.0196087398,
-0.0911539719,
-0.0139837982,
0.0186543912,
-0.0096977698,
0.0033386583,
-0.0220291987,
0.0198901724,
0.0042198198,
-0.0259270687,
0.0449519046,
-0.0377517976,
-0.0606904663,
-0.0303934123,
-0.0160101857,
-0.035191223,
0.00434501,
-0.0506545156,
-0.0306004658,
-0.0597809255,
-0.0292148218,
0.0086928532,
-0.0018454226,
-0.0116686346,
0.0045686089,
0.0160973594,
0.0257636923,
-0.0489840992,
0.0457225032,
-0.0281795766,
0.0251846611,
0.0279674381,
-0.0240691379,
0.0075909188,
-0.0051210551,
-0.0227710474,
0.0021413858,
-0.0068639526,
-0.0108832642,
0.0034902061,
0.0177296717,
-0.0029350282,
-0.0002873951,
0.1266128868,
0.0478199571,
0.0125045124,
0.0293262452,
-0.0333589353,
0.0167840179,
0.0443367623,
-0.014125431,
-0.0267005656,
-0.0134881856,
-0.0053385864,
0.0549563579,
-0.0438080542,
-0.0423554778,
0.0300023183,
-0.1158856228,
0.0424232259,
-0.0355918817,
-0.0409503281,
-0.066761747,
-0.0645526946,
-0.0119924098,
0.0056614918,
0.0062878793,
-0.0323519707,
0.0610611401,
-0.0029707553,
0.0081694592,
-0.092166692,
-0.0503295772,
0.0635550991,
-0.0003429717,
0.0035345224,
0.0113968626,
0.0775777325,
-0.0270134751,
0.0156085817,
0.0263684876,
-0.0215931665,
0.0064680614,
-0.0139925061,
0.0930363908,
0.0124632753,
-0.0546785071,
-0.0586314909,
0.0214078538,
-0.0796780288,
0.0725141466,
-0.0274582822,
0.0704924017,
0.0033246877,
-0.0378247797,
-0.0379479788,
0.0102096722,
0.0456079207,
0.0386336371,
-0.0286532752,
-0.0830161944,
-0.0462074652,
-0.0336262882,
0.0026386667,
0.0214128345,
0.0046901116,
0.018853059,
0.0429999717,
-0.0806159973,
-0.0663064569,
-0.0875976831,
-0.0078386469,
-0.0090372581,
-0.0282231718,
0.0280525517,
-0.0354399681,
0.0116857486,
-0.0564304888,
-0.0032334845,
0.0384964235,
-0.0033059877,
0.0188982189,
0.0062774285,
0.0578102693,
0.0137456432,
-0.0419109762,
-0.0222164728,
-0.0060834885,
-0.0326933824,
0.0134639665,
-0.0137932431,
0.0078311134,
0.0450550392,
-0.0014829767,
-0.0543312803,
0.0078547811,
0.0985306203,
-0.0082840826,
-0.0139717748,
0.0336412638,
0.0046429122,
0.0193089098,
0.0235961843,
0.015054876,
0.0571906567,
0.0225877836,
-0.0723905489,
-0.0427239165,
-0.0255643167,
0.0126366122,
0.035080418,
0.0622752495,
0.0814256966,
-0.0538532585,
-0.0259573553,
-0.0152019877,
-0.0041167764,
-0.0133430222,
-0.0127993338,
-0.0188492276,
0.0146259069,
0.0400101058,
-0.0683077872,
0.0484597981,
0.0142108425,
-0.024788687,
0.0213050935,
0.0634957775,
0.0487852097,
0.047606729,
0.0078530442,
0.011562149,
0.0107110217,
-0.0264296345,
0.023130009,
-0.0004888136,
-0.0008514929,
-0.0476065315,
0.0290554669,
0.0339919254,
-0.0016393529,
-0.0480506569,
-0.0413444303,
-0.0088710235,
-0.0451938994,
-0.0064160805,
0.0068657929,
-0.0212382451,
0.0051113707,
-0.0301484764,
0.0036568057,
-0.0195686501,
0.0202930849,
-0.0219022278,
0.0229547825,
0.0121355643,
0.0014949377,
-0.0145591618,
0.0048878854,
0.0134810349,
-0.0069663441,
0.0427569859,
0.0175637975,
-0.0051620128,
-0.0487414114,
0.0404190645,
0.0361475796,
0.0078422893,
0.0411266536,
0.0273157135,
0.0136103602,
-0.0336707383,
0.0501731001,
-0.0249975435,
0.0150690479,
0.0043272716,
0.0221278537,
0.0853119567,
-0.0293329041,
0.0161213409,
-0.0393596403,
-0.024858037,
-0.0290515143,
-0.0520057864,
-0.004095614,
-6.13537999e-33,
0.037076436,
-0.0365286954,
-0.0427947864,
0.0172507968,
0.0337299593,
-0.0563813411,
0.0021588565,
0.0403377414,
-0.0188721307,
0.0526994914,
-0.0068521076,
0.0463626534,
-0.0021107167,
0.0199818127,
0.0211155191,
-0.0155565701,
0.0747096613,
-0.0217738487,
0.0130427545,
0.018138323,
0.0311962012,
0.0529229157,
0.0847160965,
-0.15594998,
0.0217380673,
-0.0057730996,
-0.0231903996,
0.027439693,
0.0218445957,
0.0058817086,
0.0068298369,
0.1272052675,
0.0000071653,
-0.0145016033,
-0.0069159404,
0.0154339569,
-0.0069970824,
-0.0250026081,
-0.0431407019,
0.030204393,
0.0687192604,
-0.0211048257,
0.0412074924,
0.0025876639,
-0.0321502611,
0.0036914523,
0.0739660263,
-0.0107567795,
0.046441365,
-0.0344233401,
-0.0114348447,
0.0153089305,
-0.0308921523,
0.0163299069,
-0.0061832489,
0.0440196991,
-0.0068483222,
0.0460247435,
-0.0973706916,
0.0430578031,
0.0208110455,
-0.0269034933,
-0.0299952347,
-0.025335703,
-0.0194601454,
0.0442552157,
0.0614909306,
0.0128360093,
0.0010125458,
0.0448320881,
0.0704091117,
0.05193967,
0.049898278,
0.0809311718,
0.0578178428,
-0.0680020526,
-0.0820936039,
-0.0082779089,
0.0251525268,
-0.0952310041,
0.0308572706,
-0.045122765,
-0.0787053481,
-0.0270149466,
0.0109889088,
-0.026709022,
0.0005971936,
-0.0044998541,
0.0342315808,
-0.0114197023,
0.0100208307,
-0.0369986929,
-0.0231093969,
-0.0684204176,
-0.0397046693,
0.0349900462,
-0.0434781946,
0.0425572172,
0.0238786172,
-0.0291577484,
-0.0391426086,
-0.0117456196,
-0.0285700206,
0.0127862943,
0.0292952638,
0.0024710076,
0.0615949184,
0.0021064619,
-0.1016972661,
0.0115852999,
0.0436280817,
0.045419801,
-0.0213778894,
0.0853375122,
-0.0407211632,
-0.0417514294,
-0.0054018884,
0.0604855604,
0.0104366029,
0.0846160427,
-0.0273821242,
-0.0311012715,
-0.0230557304,
-0.0358093455,
-0.0209255703,
-0.0487548634,
0.0125026964,
-0.0418035686,
0.0025349795,
-0.0289603751,
0.0268825926,
-0.0688136965,
2.652e-7,
0.0081363218,
0.0844868422,
-0.0195306148,
-0.0283419956,
0.049309738,
0.053670153,
0.0358044952,
0.0013828981,
-0.012761604,
-0.0573869608,
0.032918144,
-0.0147010749,
0.0187624618,
0.0367915817,
-0.0683531687,
-0.0120579191,
-0.0147752836,
-0.0065576541,
-0.0222269837,
0.0022929839,
0.079153575,
0.1129435897,
0.0269641783,
-0.0447012596,
-0.0105529279,
0.0188372005,
0.0423391759,
-0.0434479192,
-0.0135133257,
0.0250586104,
0.0562579483,
0.010204982,
0.0203354135,
0.016078081,
-0.0011226417,
0.0528844185,
0.0103370696,
0.0561879389,
-0.0380703807,
-0.0180022027,
0.015176625,
0.0568729676,
-0.0296765864,
0.004167391,
0.0273601767,
-0.0401010513,
-0.0418901779,
-0.0445651747,
-0.0217686072,
-0.0177787393,
0.0667909235,
-0.0070899981,
0.0163016021,
0.007417785,
0.0012691717,
-0.0470821299,
-0.0016408166,
-0.0254536327,
-0.0001022453,
0.0311233178,
-0.0337392241,
-0.036082048,
0.0276447851,
0.0851342678,
0.0487681553,
0.0197450984,
0.0493248925,
2.192995144e-34,
0.0711728409,
0.0071047861,
-0.0103754262,
-0.0088729179,
0.0172547232,
0.0227264613,
-0.0100851497,
-0.0201603509,
0.0168479364,
-0.0147202918,
0.0077743791
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15077v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15077v1 | Multilingual self-supervised speech representations improve the speech recognition of low-resource African languages with codeswitching | 2023-11-25T17:05:21 | 2023-11-25T17:05:21 | Tolúlopé Ògúnrèmí, Christopher D. Manning, Dan Jurafsky | cs.CL | cs.CL | While many speakers of low-resource languages regularly code-switch between
their languages and other regional languages or English, datasets of
codeswitched speech are too small to train bespoke acoustic models from scratch
or do language model rescoring. Here we propose finetuning self-supervised
speech representations such as wav2vec 2.0 XLSR to recognize code-switched
data. We find that finetuning self-supervised multilingual representations and
augmenting them with n-gram language models trained from transcripts reduces
absolute word error rates by up to 20% compared to baselines of hybrid models
trained from scratch on code-switched data. Our findings suggest that in
circumstances with limited training data finetuning self-supervised
representations is a better performing and viable solution. | [
-0.0104873637,
0.0438755564,
0.0084812259,
0.0574705675,
0.0096970079,
0.0191934761,
0.0307080038,
-0.0251170751,
0.0050260741,
-0.0360734537,
-0.064753145,
-0.0193661433,
0.0442345627,
0.0062547945,
0.0386273228,
-0.0037130064,
0.0458000526,
-0.0715288743,
0.0033377414,
-0.0209680684,
-0.0071474728,
0.0377088301,
-0.0222853888,
0.0187179949,
-0.0325319506,
-0.005215886,
0.0108957263,
0.0446232595,
-0.0100129321,
-0.0061641675,
0.0080757178,
0.011203845,
0.0046958728,
0.0406176001,
0.0000019959,
-0.025650762,
-0.0399364196,
-0.0144109698,
-0.0598836243,
0.0617800541,
0.0250637215,
-0.0022446848,
-0.0360222757,
0.0269287247,
-0.0348173603,
-0.0051498911,
0.0680639744,
-0.0256925263,
0.0257555246,
0.0369770527,
-0.0044736923,
-0.0430685468,
0.0108038783,
-0.0453313142,
-0.0283297803,
-0.0268704183,
-0.016832184,
0.0221809931,
-0.015405871,
-0.0338211171,
-0.0448803231,
0.0407659039,
-0.0123472866,
-0.0050157313,
-0.0413355604,
-0.0197948776,
-0.0918690711,
-0.0021757493,
-0.025677627,
0.0337921679,
-0.0533676408,
-0.0361125395,
-0.0148324352,
-0.0005151483,
-0.0180375911,
-0.0391155034,
-0.0053871018,
-0.0178538319,
0.0262362976,
0.0104660084,
0.0058062896,
0.0474583469,
0.0647865459,
-0.0336408429,
-0.0628665388,
0.0086006485,
-0.0120877717,
-0.0001347011,
-0.0078488933,
-0.008143275,
0.0438432656,
0.030960083,
0.0114858421,
-0.0456348099,
0.0138758812,
-0.0301326141,
0.0059091006,
-0.0327820778,
-0.0044323872,
-0.0186622869,
0.0401890799,
0.0416692793,
-0.0797582865,
0.025529569,
-0.0596437864,
0.0256350692,
-0.0114626046,
0.0093061188,
0.000214174,
-0.0090427678,
-0.0352524929,
-0.0135719292,
-0.0535800233,
-0.0256303288,
-0.0238503385,
0.0268397871,
-0.014490189,
-0.0063956962,
-0.030202575,
0.0019579562,
-0.0003497952,
-0.039101202,
-0.0104016932,
-0.0284706801,
0.0524019711,
0.0320460349,
0.0196756441,
0.0316743255,
-0.0270207338,
-0.112567395,
0.0167353954,
-0.010160896,
0.0179653186,
0.0199884251,
0.0210594833,
0.0689085424,
-0.0007112341,
-0.0589972436,
-0.0592562743,
0.0259008948,
-0.0625742525,
-0.0364652798,
-0.0632269382,
-0.0722938851,
0.0195117537,
0.0436528884,
0.0704868957,
-0.0457053967,
-0.0176020171,
-0.0716933981,
0.0458818264,
0.0897504389,
-0.0016518963,
-0.0074839657,
0.0548551045,
-0.0214556158,
0.0434534475,
0.0848439336,
0.0573053472,
-0.0426408872,
0.0199740455,
-0.02164937,
-0.0285153165,
0.0703622848,
0.0103762457,
0.0018415449,
-0.020699203,
0.0005098879,
0.0813490376,
-0.0150230331,
0.0737314969,
0.0216042623,
-0.0234132353,
-0.0240951926,
0.0203716196,
0.0418856628,
0.0431759953,
0.0084933685,
0.0406829081,
-0.0110809421,
0.0158040393,
-0.0076529542,
0.0088795293,
0.0188802704,
0.0199845321,
-0.033295393,
0.0696281865,
0.0346032567,
-0.0237809271,
-0.0002570512,
0.0033491421,
-0.0386077538,
0.0517110974,
-0.0022614889,
0.0183943212,
-0.0058454489,
0.0006527475,
0.0224647913,
0.0305370931,
-0.0561096892,
0.003163666,
-0.0721715316,
-0.0127672646,
0.0275877118,
-0.0175498091,
0.0148188965,
0.0376438797,
-0.0592697188,
-0.0278459024,
0.0084398733,
0.0814468414,
-0.0017907484,
0.0680003166,
-0.052296672,
0.0234697163,
-0.0175721962,
-0.0122082541,
0.0532728732,
-0.0227168202,
0.0630949438,
-0.0018465602,
-0.0372763388,
-0.0425165519,
-0.0169020686,
-0.0401049405,
-0.0146516729,
0.0309369974,
0.0254584905,
0.0652430952,
0.0122829499,
-0.0214021802,
0.0254689753,
-0.0214796364,
-0.0335088819,
0.0305902325,
0.0096557625,
-0.0406778827,
-0.0480850823,
0.0357507393,
-0.0301905479,
0.0240835696,
0.0524709299,
0.0375543237,
-0.0850850269,
0.0684527755,
-0.0154107632,
0.0545878969,
-0.034378536,
0.0245567057,
0.0105376076,
0.0379835814,
0.0371871665,
-0.0249397513,
0.057431221,
-0.0158564001,
-0.0023657032,
0.0287586395,
0.0483347587,
-0.0047758883,
-0.033530917,
0.03124048,
-0.0169037189,
0.0103824381,
-0.0116419364,
-0.0242239609,
-0.0088388827,
-0.0169108342,
-0.090332821,
-0.0173261426,
-0.0413115807,
-0.0109434724,
-0.0363636538,
0.0294895582,
0.0082967374,
-0.0357129313,
-0.0200686678,
-0.0223791916,
-0.0300212204,
-0.0046613677,
-0.0674886778,
-0.0167329889,
0.0022269771,
-0.0443138964,
0.0061542913,
0.0392188057,
0.0062240935,
-0.0356538035,
-0.0178594422,
-0.0655600205,
-0.0360439904,
0.0119291721,
0.0185276233,
0.0025318884,
-0.0468996279,
0.007366125,
-0.016477149,
0.0328833833,
0.0180312414,
-0.0185434837,
-0.0245146379,
0.0595669039,
-0.0046059298,
-0.0438226871,
-0.0256518032,
0.0258490779,
-0.0272789244,
-0.0437126569,
0.0365958251,
-0.0377360284,
0.0498410463,
0.0533395447,
0.0285827909,
-0.0548246615,
-0.056995973,
-0.0183013938,
-0.0303601772,
0.0325858183,
-0.0123695433,
-0.0247374959,
0.0389810316,
-0.0152171599,
-0.059477184,
0.0383689962,
-0.0488467403,
-0.053746853,
-0.035582874,
-0.0159771387,
-0.0139335468,
0.0142880334,
-0.0219002012,
0.0253233444,
-0.0184204169,
-0.0269989725,
-0.0303296987,
-0.014514707,
0.0414471924,
-0.0415992737,
-0.0034620883,
-0.0100546544,
0.0355790369,
-0.0003046427,
-0.0624273196,
0.0147142308,
-0.0464033782,
-0.047810141,
-0.0047595603,
0.0505052432,
-0.0328055248,
0.0217528604,
0.0573477186,
0.0290436,
0.0665988848,
0.0102979355,
0.0041323327,
0.002114245,
0.0334369838,
-0.0104785636,
0.0195729472,
0.0210292712,
-0.0152728362,
0.03589857,
-0.0392287709,
-0.0079768291,
0.0420819484,
-0.0220780987,
0.0189540144,
0.0522046611,
0.0289310962,
-0.0263680033,
0.0158125367,
0.0505074412,
-0.0377629511,
0.0068439487,
0.0765591115,
0.0014973645,
-0.0427459851,
-0.0171221849,
-0.0680275038,
0.0099645732,
0.0214216821,
0.0055936482,
-0.0415703058,
-0.026538074,
0.0089120278,
0.0476555154,
0.0006980468,
0.0367217287,
-0.0088490099,
-0.0872167274,
0.0429617167,
0.056385763,
-0.039775271,
-0.0425412171,
0.0023730826,
-0.0419252664,
-0.046930518,
-0.0103704352,
-0.0041044462,
-0.0133642573,
-0.0371314511,
0.0419237614,
-0.0475656725,
-0.008941018,
0.0194419827,
-0.0016888663,
0.0839874819,
0.0858884305,
-0.0164899193,
-0.0017402818,
-0.0261813365,
-0.0109687001,
-0.0357480571,
-0.006939752,
-0.027932357,
0.0203310661,
0.0079845684,
-0.0351992361,
0.0657217354,
0.038889192,
0.0226080138,
0.0011110193,
-0.0323319919,
0.0376010984,
-0.0202273745,
-0.0059244586,
0.016068548,
-0.0122518521,
0.0059518493,
0.0167359151,
0.0503510274,
-0.0426657014,
-0.0065229973,
0.0087520853,
0.0524848402,
-0.0077143176,
-0.0228029713,
0.0350379646,
0.0564043596,
-0.0446081869,
-0.0131010162,
0.0050759576,
0.0162545945,
0.0195947513,
0.0137660755,
0.0410371833,
0.0015849867,
0.0175813381,
-0.0398446321,
-0.022475332,
-0.0287824571,
0.0387399308,
-0.039708212,
-0.0394123718,
0.0655945465,
-0.0378146619,
0.0276895203,
-0.0319447219,
-0.0690670386,
-0.039894931,
0.0430906266,
0.0165270064,
0.0122892987,
0.0517308451,
-0.0030568589,
-0.0390553772,
-0.0215265341,
0.0195806008,
-0.0724165663,
0.0194098391,
0.0595066436,
0.046087496,
-0.0228579752,
0.0305306707,
-0.0213766117,
0.0166069362,
-0.0083340537,
-0.0078342184,
-0.0625013039,
-0.0489752218,
-0.0233411677,
-0.0627431124,
0.0269499943,
-0.0493031777,
-0.0042568692,
-0.0242404528,
0.0039981101,
0.036228478,
0.0458765514,
-0.0223945528,
0.0001009752,
0.0211439896,
-0.0237402543,
-0.0223427974,
0.0023666339,
-0.0263384562,
-0.0370380133,
0.0023835863,
0.0838265046,
0.0400803052,
0.0148419896,
0.0105336802,
0.0398148,
-0.0138697308,
0.052550029,
0.0305289757,
0.0017020381,
-0.0157552417,
0.0016196105,
0.0015719607,
0.0086804228,
-0.0033095148,
0.0261140112,
-0.0267734993,
-0.0424248278,
-0.0040052943,
-0.0233643241,
0.0536729954,
-0.0036591962,
0.0861904696,
0.0195485577,
0.007103283,
-0.006441297,
0.0293903854,
-0.0297929235,
0.0328648165,
0.0252810065,
-0.0135228075,
-0.0446492359,
0.0521917678,
0.0185808185,
0.0246434547,
0.0090399683,
-0.0174859092,
0.0691324845,
-0.0231069662,
-0.0135138007,
0.0401685871,
-0.00318594,
-0.0270532351,
0.0202349778,
-0.0164177138,
-0.0800720751,
0.037032824,
-0.0000779296,
-0.018427372,
-0.0016284644,
0.0016886822,
0.0234127939,
-0.0189364776,
0.0515746027,
-0.0184489898,
-0.0368710086,
0.0976285562,
-0.0202405993,
0.042186223,
-6.15730296e-33,
0.0185636226,
0.0316278078,
-0.0365930088,
-0.0280736387,
-0.0010038217,
-0.0140523491,
-0.02449595,
0.0241512209,
-0.0314835198,
-0.034541849,
-0.0150766037,
0.0317733958,
0.0351970606,
0.001937609,
0.0404596142,
0.0221875813,
0.0781215653,
-0.0045923637,
-0.0110084387,
0.0165163931,
0.0534687936,
0.0452749319,
0.0622484535,
-0.0701553449,
0.0032309275,
-0.0032389851,
-0.0156698097,
-0.0644532964,
0.0161448196,
0.0372771136,
0.000491292,
0.0128912488,
-0.0176885612,
-0.0013883383,
-0.0285317339,
0.0010097072,
-0.0899576023,
0.0083666984,
-0.0122365793,
0.0462297834,
0.0017727596,
-0.0249153152,
0.0408734493,
0.0257913582,
-0.0338140875,
0.0235242229,
-0.0006014869,
-0.0580978245,
-0.030743327,
-0.0058942768,
-0.0468320511,
0.0427794755,
-0.0357864387,
-0.0043708691,
0.0653815344,
0.0306810103,
-0.044048775,
-0.0197246168,
-0.0898525789,
0.0044153859,
0.0032382533,
0.0540614687,
0.0186097007,
0.0237302687,
-0.0444811918,
0.0275939777,
0.0742902458,
-0.0770490691,
0.0766468197,
-0.0225945003,
0.0759085417,
-0.0283976905,
-0.0011708671,
0.0458218046,
0.0466990396,
-0.0942289084,
-0.0266645774,
-0.0412640721,
-0.0049935854,
0.0046294588,
0.0260009952,
0.0294633862,
-0.031629134,
-0.0174922515,
-0.0446275324,
-0.0620368049,
-0.0287092142,
-0.0291341413,
0.0553886294,
-0.0266452022,
0.0121130468,
0.0178431701,
0.0663250983,
-0.0225765575,
-0.0291488077,
-0.0207686387,
0.0058684014,
0.0158999935,
0.0246240422,
0.0481798835,
-0.023145074,
-0.014544853,
0.0077424347,
0.0265441388,
0.0312130488,
-0.0153704081,
0.0384395532,
0.0413800664,
-0.0856043324,
0.0177021828,
0.0171941873,
-0.0057799066,
-0.0170426201,
0.0236592051,
0.0223555882,
-0.0116668129,
0.0147072589,
0.0152825676,
-0.0349778421,
-0.0475062653,
0.0104366271,
-0.0354450122,
-0.0107270088,
0.0473414287,
-0.0457170159,
-0.0075096092,
-0.0252817273,
0.0585947521,
0.0152666373,
-0.0126995947,
0.0172358304,
0.0335547179,
2.655e-7,
0.0037235713,
0.0054871561,
-0.0012196336,
-0.0616832227,
0.0182894897,
0.0040313303,
-0.0300123077,
-0.0428889133,
0.0031228401,
0.0325462706,
-0.0133836241,
0.0124512129,
0.1335766912,
0.0412059054,
-0.0544128902,
0.0190402884,
-0.0226072762,
0.0454379506,
-0.0236707423,
-0.0176898707,
0.0320313536,
0.1456386447,
-0.0079534156,
-0.0141185839,
-0.0340652727,
0.0027619649,
0.0380164981,
-0.0081779808,
0.0364581794,
-0.0477638878,
-0.0483931899,
0.0319014713,
-0.0165671594,
-0.011245423,
-0.0405156054,
0.048165556,
0.009584629,
0.0290777907,
-0.0122714592,
-0.0205928795,
-0.0079726782,
0.0178234782,
-0.0766247958,
-0.0421043821,
0.0595527962,
0.0058611529,
-0.0041344287,
-0.0089624487,
-0.0079792701,
0.0359919369,
0.0283908248,
-0.0467868075,
-0.0178781282,
0.0352199264,
0.0057799253,
-0.0234678853,
-0.0338910669,
-0.042560637,
0.0034512517,
0.0157114845,
0.0034432532,
-0.0069893412,
-0.014349903,
0.0190939642,
0.058090318,
0.0072526117,
0.0546500087,
1.802513254e-34,
0.034807276,
-0.0246211626,
0.0433245972,
0.0181866363,
-0.0473458506,
-0.0271004662,
0.020523414,
0.0308916103,
0.0009358196,
-0.009018464,
-0.0282241367
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15055v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15055v1 | Automatically Finding and Categorizing Replication Studies | 2023-11-25T15:27:10 | 2023-11-25T15:27:10 | Bob de Ruiter | cs.DL | cs.DL, cs.CL | In many fields of experimental science, papers that failed to replicate
continue to be cited as a result of the poor discoverability of replication
studies. As a first step to creating a system that automatically finds
replication studies for a given paper, 334 replication studies and 344
replicated studies were collected. Replication studies could be identified in
the dataset based on text content at a higher rate than chance (AUROC = 0.886).
Additionally, successful replication studies could be distinguished from
failed replication studies at a higher rate than chance (AUROC = 0.664). | [
0.0427243598,
0.0116642043,
-0.0200579166,
-0.0126073305,
-0.0785456449,
0.0055299802,
0.0798042044,
0.0294205118,
-0.0293103047,
-0.0231687929,
0.0357553847,
0.0406849235,
0.0014520944,
0.0319916308,
0.008045841,
0.0491567776,
0.0389891453,
0.0452179089,
0.0246085078,
-0.0094739273,
-0.058354497,
-0.0363602266,
-0.0020851369,
0.0044030943,
0.0318340287,
-0.0036179028,
-0.0368517376,
-0.0073591415,
0.0173891876,
-0.0506620556,
-0.0122059826,
0.0361488238,
0.0170120969,
0.0842138752,
0.0000017753,
-0.0439214706,
-0.0379148051,
0.0362239629,
-0.0206874385,
0.0398568027,
0.0389483199,
0.0329980403,
0.0240107309,
0.0126387142,
0.0277110636,
-0.0313718282,
0.0464076139,
0.0020577379,
-0.0217278544,
-0.0364278294,
-0.0054826303,
0.0320191123,
0.0498406179,
-0.00833291,
0.0453131981,
0.0346465856,
0.0355881639,
0.0514864586,
0.0449894629,
0.0467271321,
0.033300627,
0.0742765516,
-0.0111317961,
0.0127404137,
-0.0457624495,
0.0146348933,
-0.0327961445,
-0.0451145321,
0.0165294111,
-0.0027733701,
0.0230161287,
-0.0641736761,
0.0370454825,
0.0146504464,
-0.0104976129,
0.0911737457,
-0.0615386963,
-0.0114969434,
0.015260268,
-0.0352850966,
-0.0308471825,
0.0084548574,
0.0159968976,
-0.0248249415,
0.0262180977,
0.0103298351,
0.0052367984,
-0.0422316641,
-0.0242976639,
0.0162790641,
0.0457300395,
-0.0082635218,
-0.0104319239,
-0.0166349914,
0.0596669428,
-0.0276321508,
0.0434347019,
-0.0311067551,
0.0882468,
0.0359706655,
0.0573348925,
-0.0136946943,
-0.0195695553,
0.0307740644,
-0.0392311327,
-0.0166217126,
-0.0514377281,
0.0886848792,
0.0247557107,
0.0329405293,
-0.0801915452,
-0.020030411,
0.0068352269,
-0.006198782,
0.0537428595,
-0.003965057,
-0.0143315122,
-0.0214821044,
0.0012906579,
0.018078221,
-0.0676135495,
-0.0010848191,
-0.0381526537,
0.0439446568,
0.0102726258,
-0.0065777157,
-0.0090483949,
0.0227246489,
-0.0417228751,
-0.0060859001,
-0.0369783565,
0.0146374386,
0.0608271323,
0.030440541,
0.0018041923,
-0.0080866683,
0.0317282304,
-0.054560896,
-0.0044291746,
-0.0299614072,
-0.004271856,
-0.0214606784,
0.0059815017,
-0.0451131798,
0.0592552237,
0.0222863927,
0.013961086,
0.0287548508,
-0.0009787302,
-0.0420715846,
0.0068000574,
0.0198911503,
-0.0513982065,
0.0201501604,
0.0227668528,
-0.0007449855,
0.018255638,
-0.0295702256,
-0.025109319,
-0.0040623951,
0.0199496895,
0.0048951884,
0.0561774224,
-0.039052736,
0.0168919507,
0.023677595,
0.0447644591,
0.0102840802,
-0.042101752,
0.0290012509,
-0.0401551388,
-0.0201164335,
-0.0500469878,
0.0495120473,
0.0161264092,
0.0267074965,
-0.0101727108,
0.044595357,
0.0003551186,
0.0037099635,
-0.0003636535,
-0.007509775,
-0.0131720295,
0.0329231359,
-0.0015623081,
0.0329120271,
-0.0042272154,
0.0015483596,
-0.0278619472,
-0.0285167117,
-0.0243656989,
-0.0007920081,
-0.033326935,
-0.0434923284,
0.0318628326,
0.0397623703,
0.0497870743,
-0.0060033188,
-0.0150170745,
0.005248493,
0.0062007499,
-0.0215938091,
0.0544581376,
-0.0045866943,
0.0695215091,
-0.0503731556,
0.0417141952,
-0.0050989138,
-0.0210658945,
0.0338669904,
-0.0294341668,
-0.0027850035,
-0.0107960934,
0.0088146832,
-0.0201091841,
-0.0252766423,
0.0083578229,
0.0147286039,
0.0229492746,
0.0600879453,
-0.0096987952,
0.0063168756,
-0.0209425613,
0.0069948141,
-0.0270658359,
-0.0149556743,
0.0029925124,
-0.0651189536,
0.0300417002,
-0.0125999935,
-0.0200672876,
0.0099464348,
0.0494278856,
-0.0090092989,
-0.0777607784,
0.0469214246,
0.1075780317,
-0.0165539794,
-0.0168575197,
-0.0645102188,
0.0041225073,
0.030935498,
-0.0323529914,
0.0020574876,
0.0172900446,
-0.0270118434,
0.0112543153,
-0.0248622727,
0.0378205813,
-0.0493627973,
-0.0203319527,
-0.0160352178,
0.0661162511,
0.0140568884,
0.0491932072,
0.0189346652,
-0.0786955357,
0.0322422087,
-0.0196777359,
0.0074470979,
-0.0632303134,
-0.0363054574,
0.0118854055,
0.018924566,
-0.0332596488,
-0.004124952,
-0.0342840292,
0.0564853288,
0.0001489337,
0.0167305246,
0.0058253105,
-0.0055963178,
-0.0413444526,
0.001166752,
-0.0097557558,
0.0370791629,
-0.0069720703,
0.0378882438,
0.0017977563,
0.0734159946,
0.0121810008,
-0.0389524437,
-0.0457234867,
-0.0183432698,
-0.0061324239,
0.0592187047,
0.0461974777,
0.0230742488,
-0.1253827363,
0.0177445821,
-0.0094618676,
-0.0161405448,
0.0351022296,
0.0058878837,
0.0195930805,
0.048476126,
-0.0271140393,
0.0462648273,
0.0002670416,
0.0144114606,
0.0479796082,
0.0540959276,
-0.0349308774,
-0.0222341511,
-0.0843977034,
-0.0000087802,
0.051647719,
-0.0563506447,
0.0590980053,
-0.0458047129,
0.0024316432,
0.0057748943,
-0.0060506184,
0.0238441136,
0.0078222239,
-0.0360353291,
0.0241059717,
-0.0587872192,
-0.0083766021,
0.0153239518,
0.0144572882,
0.0012890619,
0.0382272638,
-0.0030845532,
0.0132662421,
-0.0781651139,
0.0132961944,
0.0253002811,
0.0049819648,
0.0103160087,
0.0066719502,
-0.0029868444,
0.0028185069,
0.0367019959,
0.0315284617,
0.0382365584,
0.0051108398,
-0.0286642592,
-0.0178265069,
-0.0123520996,
0.0453183018,
-0.0079045855,
-0.018114496,
-0.022285793,
0.0379508361,
-0.01154052,
-0.0197282415,
0.0170881879,
-0.1173211038,
0.031396199,
0.1319771558,
0.0352187008,
-0.0466715619,
-0.0207784716,
-0.0443492234,
0.015822608,
0.0417970456,
-0.0612466894,
0.0293763485,
-0.0165202599,
0.0094148181,
0.0161832049,
-0.0119345319,
0.1049702317,
-0.021065101,
-0.0228580721,
-0.0373867676,
-0.0607555807,
-0.0293978732,
-0.0203466918,
-0.0060976087,
0.0283135176,
-0.0153750414,
0.0284171198,
0.0467649214,
-0.0684129447,
-0.0225735065,
-0.070964925,
-0.0366400369,
0.0009645353,
-0.027447572,
-0.0499326363,
0.0688031465,
-0.0286130197,
-0.0142462775,
-0.0423524007,
-0.0195783917,
0.024491718,
-0.0093432358,
0.038377244,
-0.0139874602,
-0.0277316887,
-0.0581397153,
-0.113337025,
0.0131480945,
-0.0183096845,
-0.0064219199,
0.0224707015,
-0.0153433941,
0.0014858912,
-0.0124667734,
-0.0310330838,
-0.0865488797,
-0.0061479574,
-0.0505380109,
-0.0290934928,
-0.0104604047,
0.0293986481,
-0.0361599401,
-0.000731705,
-0.0481322072,
-0.0261271577,
-0.0055860849,
0.0014354958,
0.0683166608,
0.0651709363,
0.0063831913,
-0.0664395094,
0.0114585338,
-0.0088280877,
-0.0218462329,
0.0102914823,
0.0461345389,
-0.0148737375,
-0.023644438,
-0.0443756841,
-0.0270780306,
0.0026457761,
0.0396017805,
0.0752202347,
-0.0161044728,
0.0029266095,
0.0512950011,
0.0754090622,
-0.0378531925,
0.0092808828,
0.0256417785,
-0.0448909588,
0.0256712548,
-0.0524926893,
0.0155777037,
-0.0210199598,
0.0153249707,
0.0192542989,
-0.0064648897,
0.0147452997,
-0.0672053024,
-0.0429562703,
-0.0186374169,
0.023966508,
-0.0267719813,
-0.0228973683,
0.0296002198,
0.0303593185,
0.0568483397,
-0.0207799226,
0.0224708039,
-0.0463428348,
-0.0465050526,
0.0070541096,
0.0041511636,
0.0349470377,
-0.0026367705,
-0.023602806,
-0.0214999393,
-0.0223677196,
-0.0060222205,
0.0093904976,
-0.0217322093,
-0.0817469284,
-0.0696094707,
-0.0279184952,
-0.0515051857,
-0.0185941551,
0.0161718465,
-0.0114701604,
-0.0323463157,
-0.0173456501,
-0.0069381436,
0.0321009345,
0.0164451879,
0.0302048028,
-0.0467108674,
0.0273722187,
0.0215864331,
-0.0024248178,
0.0157961622,
0.0050586145,
0.0216245949,
-0.0007191849,
0.0185128227,
0.0307744071,
-0.0205907784,
0.011327045,
-0.0359193087,
0.0413419865,
-0.0308165587,
0.0228318237,
-0.0481587872,
0.0994363427,
0.0057096654,
0.0114376945,
-0.0324467532,
0.0332962982,
-0.0210283268,
0.057509698,
-0.000331136,
-0.030334359,
0.00254914,
-0.0187753849,
-0.0456091836,
0.0206802152,
-0.0785270035,
-0.0010618896,
-0.004369678,
-0.0573318787,
0.0220568012,
0.0309760068,
0.0559823774,
-0.0223202594,
-0.0257918295,
-0.0134931952,
0.0440344587,
-0.0066635972,
0.0462204628,
-0.0382390842,
0.0352518223,
-0.0374070443,
-0.0329737104,
0.0210077129,
0.0677495673,
-0.0533175282,
-0.0641634613,
-0.0180932786,
0.0077847587,
0.0018888501,
-0.0185626447,
-0.0329949893,
0.0009353707,
-0.0849708542,
-0.0314847268,
-0.0090761259,
0.0644371212,
0.0625902191,
0.0241615996,
0.0088684447,
-0.0322354883,
0.0172783174,
0.0338659324,
-0.0648166314,
0.0363680869,
0.0502406359,
0.0562879853,
-0.0597098246,
0.0043503363,
-5.695537922e-33,
0.0585759729,
-0.030029634,
-0.0288398154,
-0.0030504125,
-0.0110359211,
0.0127371736,
-0.0703002065,
-0.0426911823,
0.028213501,
0.0197897758,
-0.0052045388,
0.0188486502,
0.014918847,
-0.0683420971,
0.0707371756,
0.0263962671,
0.0190733895,
0.0103933644,
-0.0337309912,
0.024304159,
0.0193736013,
0.0088861836,
0.0083574131,
-0.0322508477,
0.0262981709,
0.0031307703,
0.0418932103,
-0.012707538,
-0.0193744358,
0.0677234158,
0.0070760883,
-0.0243751705,
0.0052166907,
-0.0150761176,
-0.0160762202,
-0.0504366606,
-0.0669946522,
-0.0006619576,
0.0062185694,
-0.0246780496,
-0.0099249724,
0.0542282723,
0.0151165854,
-0.0096022254,
-0.0408015922,
0.0262984429,
0.0504244603,
-0.0178523678,
-0.0564963296,
0.0125990678,
-0.0308052413,
-0.0165652297,
-0.0067457506,
0.0463854074,
0.047135327,
0.0495175682,
0.0033417013,
0.0312823951,
-0.0197210107,
0.0659370273,
-0.007473201,
0.0084075583,
0.0092460327,
-0.0360846333,
0.0113595007,
0.0303094983,
-0.0323229097,
0.0137906363,
0.0086395871,
-0.0287900083,
0.0043107616,
0.0094488123,
0.0797316357,
0.0807400271,
0.0064189215,
-0.0078826025,
-0.0616365224,
0.0231565926,
0.006069907,
-0.0368685909,
0.0448139012,
-0.0368197784,
0.0060431734,
-0.0159858987,
0.0079795197,
0.0177178737,
-0.0121185444,
-0.0555332713,
0.0123451287,
-0.0073209684,
-0.0215207133,
0.0134877702,
0.0325090922,
0.0120411208,
-0.0706184655,
0.0043808278,
0.0359334461,
0.0437567867,
-0.0137018664,
0.0051061078,
-0.0484964587,
-0.0175735503,
-0.0103261508,
0.0822631568,
0.0172853563,
-0.0522780903,
0.0218567289,
0.0134413363,
-0.0571143441,
0.05150811,
0.0342363641,
-0.0310931187,
-0.0164608527,
-0.0865219533,
-0.0395693891,
0.0479920618,
0.032139644,
-0.006823529,
0.0705546066,
0.0081509976,
-0.01289644,
0.0709526092,
-0.0278330911,
0.0620316528,
0.0338743664,
-0.0055626659,
-0.0498037525,
0.0543331839,
-0.032491345,
-0.0585792623,
-0.0046159173,
-0.022135783,
2.655e-7,
0.0402371697,
0.0112237586,
0.0030570279,
-0.0376846902,
0.059995763,
-0.0457402393,
-0.0408714712,
0.0047677648,
-0.0098134205,
-0.0104978876,
0.0474582538,
-0.0154057471,
0.0003822292,
0.0179278534,
-0.0319432653,
-0.0139991269,
-0.1075437441,
0.0020616231,
-0.0388701633,
-0.0166371707,
-0.023489574,
-0.028606385,
0.0076087723,
0.0488814823,
-0.0229790509,
-0.0356782265,
-0.0237693507,
0.0307996981,
0.027225703,
0.0581655279,
-0.0320762508,
0.0085252877,
0.0256806184,
0.0070242006,
-0.0287692919,
-0.034470439,
-0.0392835028,
-0.0553693734,
-0.0085768346,
0.0187041461,
0.0365090929,
-0.0067202495,
0.0420682393,
-0.0594626926,
-0.0240445435,
-0.0557480082,
0.0073201186,
0.0397275873,
-0.0391566642,
-0.0116476994,
0.0534899347,
-0.0154997976,
0.0041416115,
0.0410627536,
-0.0588072911,
0.0560390428,
0.0082534393,
-0.0070141861,
0.0348408148,
-0.0036388137,
-0.0326885544,
-0.0146272862,
-0.0171497539,
-0.0615338832,
-0.0194186326,
-0.0352816582,
-0.0082602547,
2.201517937e-34,
0.061740879,
0.0109089492,
0.0092129633,
0.0220303386,
0.0072586318,
-0.0122459382,
-0.0328971557,
0.0119238021,
0.0077823889,
0.0058552655,
0.0106261866
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15054v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15054v2 | Detection of developmental language disorder in Cypriot Greek children using a neural network algorithm | 2023-11-25T15:23:46 | 2024-02-10T11:05:40 | Georgios P. Georgiou, Elena Theodorou | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Children with developmental language disorder (DLD) encounter difficulties in
acquiring various language structures. Early identification and intervention
are crucial to prevent negative long-term outcomes impacting the academic,
social, and emotional development of children. The study aims to develop an
automated method for the identification of DLD using artificial intelligence,
specifically a neural network machine learning algorithm. This protocol is
applied for the first time in a Cypriot Greek child population with DLD. The
neural network model was trained using perceptual and production data elicited
from 15 children with DLD and 15 healthy controls in the age range of 7;10
until 10;4. The k-fold technique was used to crossvalidate the algorithm. The
performance of the model was evaluated using metrics such as accuracy,
precision, recall, F1 score, and ROC/AUC curve to assess its ability to make
accurate predictions on a set of unseen data. The results demonstrated high
classification values for all metrics, indicating the high accuracy of the
neural model in classifying children with DLD. Additionally, the variable
importance analysis revealed that the language production skills of children
had a more significant impact on the performance of the model compared to
perception skills. Machine learning paradigms provide effective discrimination
between children with DLD and those with TD, with the potential to enhance
clinical assessment and facilitate earlier and more efficient detection of the
disorder. | [
-0.0416790023,
0.0186615717,
-0.0523545966,
0.0001930914,
-0.0222550165,
0.0387515947,
0.0467760526,
-0.0189808384,
0.0299281981,
-0.0105766077,
0.0668366551,
-0.0081180222,
0.0221737716,
0.0257407855,
-0.0290603489,
-0.0283230655,
0.0347680263,
-0.0065235086,
0.0437406935,
-0.0124674002,
-0.0379097536,
0.0183963254,
-0.046554774,
0.0089510372,
-0.0266370848,
-0.0005157284,
0.036918778,
-0.0797686279,
-0.0223230738,
0.0007531179,
-0.0432381369,
0.0498141311,
-0.0471126102,
0.043980442,
0.0000023011,
-0.0515136607,
0.0604493096,
-0.0381867848,
0.008731869,
-0.0308781732,
0.0086897882,
-0.0063512241,
-0.0155301979,
-0.0218626577,
-0.0300630741,
-0.0338341855,
0.0574314483,
0.0337660015,
0.0163832884,
0.0095501691,
-0.0041555106,
-0.0237762723,
0.0745748654,
0.0448881425,
-0.0199825633,
0.0234546084,
0.0340582021,
0.0106568094,
-0.0151820956,
-0.0841417834,
0.0215729009,
0.066167064,
-0.0121343108,
-0.0009378226,
-0.0635881945,
-0.0103948899,
3.309e-7,
-0.0666029155,
0.0219629798,
0.0038247516,
0.0010516782,
0.0212767329,
0.0173794534,
0.0154064912,
0.003548743,
0.0138369119,
-0.0307315718,
-0.0173975956,
-0.0152495112,
-0.006328953,
0.0380865522,
-0.0401122868,
0.0140235415,
-0.0132758152,
0.026814105,
0.0768242478,
-0.0244863704,
-0.0081273261,
-0.0046720519,
0.0374325961,
0.029742647,
-0.0081535699,
-0.0293414146,
0.0126428623,
-0.0074491207,
0.0055126566,
0.008134868,
-0.0651826784,
0.0187333468,
-0.047630161,
0.0286155548,
-0.0076086703,
-0.0387213826,
-0.0489094295,
-0.0769240558,
0.0725773945,
0.0695130527,
0.0478115343,
0.0175033547,
0.0656450316,
-0.0397571847,
0.0147446888,
0.0197692532,
0.0405391119,
0.0303785391,
0.0236421674,
-0.0689131096,
-0.0051543643,
0.0141618829,
-0.0238786321,
0.0371574573,
0.0005283518,
0.0408284962,
0.0567177683,
-0.0138541255,
-0.0118469223,
0.0024464095,
-0.0095815994,
-0.0629804581,
-0.0310876463,
0.073268041,
-0.0471523181,
0.00207105,
0.0298952665,
0.0125763677,
0.0611518659,
0.0262387954,
-0.0310014728,
-0.0616622716,
0.0190696195,
-0.010263755,
-0.0553132407,
-0.021629991,
-0.0212627053,
-0.020760471,
0.0357494429,
-0.0036138163,
-0.0561576635,
-0.0243980214,
-0.0073899329,
0.0363481306,
-0.0141887087,
0.0030441212,
0.0266395137,
0.0605987124,
-0.047017917,
0.0628787205,
0.0405906513,
0.0271382052,
-0.0858913511,
-0.0189482234,
-0.0534298085,
-0.026770018,
0.0075696004,
-0.0140714943,
-0.0142839095,
-0.0415644757,
-0.0644117072,
-0.0555014387,
0.0173260849,
0.015914686,
-0.010351968,
0.0218547042,
0.0201578736,
0.0501768738,
0.0304563567,
0.0315498374,
0.0361310318,
0.0135708945,
0.0094019342,
0.0365654416,
-0.0141512202,
0.0266270246,
0.0027087859,
0.0022941967,
-0.034162946,
-0.056875471,
0.0174959991,
-0.003939827,
-0.0429525897,
0.0057699364,
-0.0128093911,
0.0582075827,
0.0410575978,
0.0326485038,
-0.0163447857,
-0.0153077282,
0.0022914268,
0.0213949028,
0.0446598046,
-0.0025200201,
-0.0705239102,
0.0307614189,
0.0063292929,
-0.0509230196,
-0.0455469191,
-0.0024116049,
-0.026316138,
-0.049322661,
0.0174463037,
-0.0716745481,
0.0270623099,
-0.0158035755,
-0.0013987253,
0.03398256,
0.0476209633,
0.0414399914,
0.0121924598,
-0.0359445512,
0.0819037706,
-0.0090468619,
0.03164481,
-0.0489143245,
0.0246757362,
-0.0058604022,
-0.0179517921,
0.0297385175,
-0.0055893962,
-0.0019175204,
0.0123280194,
0.0174263492,
-0.0082923723,
-0.0205291491,
0.0286678988,
0.0136792613,
-0.01230116,
-0.0667269081,
-0.0255963653,
0.0246120878,
0.0267992876,
-0.0089180134,
0.0644760951,
0.0351779275,
-0.0027598334,
0.1050480679,
-0.0800167248,
0.0371959209,
0.0121721933,
0.0519489199,
-0.077768147,
0.0310098082,
-0.020286886,
0.0469384901,
-0.0238684714,
0.0114963166,
-0.0335060768,
-0.046964325,
0.0408001766,
-0.0269218981,
-0.0646567419,
-0.0275041591,
-0.0586765483,
0.0468153916,
-0.0278259367,
0.0266542882,
0.0311282519,
0.0087776864,
-0.0316662677,
-0.0220942814,
0.0137121435,
0.0143236332,
-0.0727345049,
-0.0480261408,
-0.0069098365,
-0.0033514579,
0.0153303277,
0.0671030283,
0.0772695318,
-0.0123345116,
0.0060691931,
0.0127053559,
-0.0481148064,
-0.0044137468,
-0.0276185684,
-0.0214140378,
0.0399659351,
0.0702702105,
-0.0235573314,
-0.0189661011,
0.0044508297,
-0.053082779,
0.0158356652,
0.0228975154,
-0.0180710219,
0.0346013084,
0.0686862543,
-0.0064161564,
0.0220844615,
-0.0496640615,
-0.0151812909,
0.043129988,
-0.0146325277,
-0.0234239679,
-0.0366688222,
0.0071913814,
0.0245378166,
-0.0485728011,
-0.0142585877,
-0.0379780531,
0.0764053464,
0.0549039431,
-0.0041145459,
-0.0105988774,
0.0207356233,
-0.0258982442,
0.0213655829,
-0.0115622496,
-0.0589497052,
-0.0243506841,
0.0698413849,
0.0264697485,
-0.0397350565,
0.0109438933,
0.0100425938,
0.0353540145,
-0.0426166393,
-0.0483944491,
-0.0097871507,
-0.0066742701,
0.000002936,
-0.0119680995,
-0.0247277189,
-0.0560960434,
-0.0188338384,
0.0023969666,
0.0221351478,
-0.0252910517,
0.0474335924,
-0.0678640008,
-0.0096812183,
0.0305399206,
0.0221506245,
-0.0353030637,
0.0521035455,
0.0434811711,
0.0173432827,
-0.0336276926,
-0.00793593,
-0.0697005019,
0.0032826182,
0.0267529693,
0.0661477521,
-0.0023432111,
0.0232348982,
0.0115487985,
-0.0191664845,
0.0067729894,
-0.0712568164,
0.0101758419,
0.0120647587,
0.0194962807,
-0.0180375353,
-0.0962622538,
0.0723809451,
-0.0561010353,
0.005809926,
-0.0007785624,
0.0036908309,
-0.0352950431,
0.0223524943,
-0.0586176999,
-0.0159216877,
0.0089206416,
0.017211739,
0.0109269302,
-0.0729008988,
-0.0129584884,
-0.0003927737,
-0.0726067796,
0.0182389803,
0.0061046924,
0.0348929502,
0.0436630994,
0.0028683334,
0.0087711699,
-0.0564877689,
-0.0505964383,
0.0141437491,
0.017529238,
0.0023423927,
-0.0191715267,
-0.0657922775,
-0.04751385,
-0.0291466471,
0.0000371652,
0.0391366072,
0.0199798811,
-0.0445131324,
0.0006308325,
-0.0262898598,
0.0092414524,
-0.0972193629,
-0.0884651989,
0.0578114577,
0.0076508177,
0.0375200175,
0.0216215942,
0.0241555963,
-0.0507368408,
-0.0179281663,
0.0153415883,
0.0183497798,
-0.0292046983,
-0.0118577816,
0.0133958505,
0.0485949256,
-0.0171767417,
-0.0595703982,
-0.0254833195,
-0.0552677549,
0.0481570736,
0.0179758184,
0.1051405296,
-0.0183015671,
-0.0276165698,
0.03724318,
0.0230360124,
0.0206458606,
-0.0103858029,
0.0117232641,
-0.0503803045,
-0.011279867,
-0.014149026,
-0.0174778588,
-0.0017762873,
-0.0036884455,
0.0537876785,
0.022694787,
-0.0548727475,
-0.0511341281,
0.0334272087,
0.0277619511,
-0.0127406502,
0.0360460617,
-0.0070757712,
-0.0187638719,
-0.0058921929,
-0.0169029608,
0.0358063206,
0.0844353586,
-0.011584416,
-0.0698226318,
0.008667062,
0.0101909023,
-0.0450905487,
-0.0256096572,
-0.0201891009,
0.000373495,
-0.0101098027,
0.0372133702,
0.0096113421,
0.0110719018,
-0.0376630537,
0.0408795066,
-0.0926564634,
-0.0019896473,
-0.0091749132,
-0.0038540552,
-0.0365660749,
-0.0148887578,
-0.0547395684,
0.0172299761,
0.0037236086,
0.0212823059,
0.0331534259,
-0.0074345209,
-0.0779255852,
-0.0753756016,
-0.012661892,
-0.0467599928,
0.0371738374,
0.0380777195,
-0.0118192658,
-0.0318967551,
-0.0966915116,
-0.0622769296,
0.0167003926,
0.0420861468,
-0.0019456128,
-0.0032452799,
0.0232388694,
0.0393230319,
-0.0347647145,
-0.0920595974,
-0.0240531787,
-0.0703889877,
-0.0111358864,
0.1103775501,
0.0026113037,
0.0459742323,
0.0060438099,
0.0525569171,
-0.0188026056,
-0.0033032279,
-0.0151858516,
0.0207301136,
-0.0148709323,
0.0311832726,
-0.017098343,
-0.003617537,
0.0122818816,
-0.0196241792,
0.0874876529,
-0.0247263871,
-0.0179250427,
-0.0417325757,
0.0289206747,
0.0155947488,
0.0023012562,
-0.0172976255,
0.0205996614,
-0.0402658954,
-0.0096967472,
-0.0163754914,
0.0020001126,
0.0036199463,
-0.0227393638,
0.0032390116,
-0.0168174095,
-0.0109492643,
-0.0005153244,
-0.047359623,
-0.0447470099,
-0.0108404448,
-0.0128395082,
0.0130690401,
0.0203895774,
0.0371625833,
-0.051756151,
0.0142142763,
-0.004684695,
-0.0577909462,
0.0092896856,
0.0253460836,
0.0151576428,
-0.0030521599,
-0.0215194356,
-0.0127908504,
-0.0045234258,
-0.0040050615,
-0.0493227057,
-0.0383438207,
-0.0179329701,
0.0042402507,
-0.0073897284,
-5.422337974e-33,
-0.0023264743,
-0.0376751013,
0.0436853394,
0.0509658419,
0.0169300493,
0.0166457519,
0.0054357466,
0.038008444,
-0.0300278813,
0.0020887977,
0.0379617289,
0.0043140929,
-0.0059249639,
-0.0057110381,
0.0267665535,
-0.0122387754,
-0.0436353385,
-0.0186737739,
0.0192240179,
-0.0166904051,
0.0052579176,
-0.0027170917,
0.10793861,
-0.0271073747,
0.0302444808,
0.0181705896,
0.0527946502,
-0.0109423632,
-0.0158714633,
0.0001530537,
-0.0089521157,
0.045890443,
0.0343388058,
-0.0055984841,
0.0368167795,
-0.0016264187,
-0.0030602855,
-0.0306774173,
0.0019420176,
0.0384200215,
-0.0622667484,
0.030220991,
0.030428892,
0.0297097303,
-0.0517022498,
0.007673976,
0.059995085,
-0.0564983152,
-0.0065564173,
0.0106440205,
-0.0314784274,
0.0202452745,
-0.0140299872,
0.0284602158,
0.0602314174,
0.0579183809,
-0.0339311063,
-0.053638041,
-0.0322928466,
0.0182297695,
0.0010418595,
-0.0197339263,
0.03324911,
-0.0019021904,
0.0320164338,
0.0312104356,
0.0756035149,
-0.0273274612,
0.0265114922,
0.017603375,
0.0588539168,
-0.0199384019,
0.0631858706,
-0.0232821163,
-0.0136178862,
-0.0770168304,
-0.0585296489,
-0.0097962338,
0.0382089689,
0.031989105,
0.0072531453,
-0.070625186,
-0.0389594361,
-0.007370898,
-0.0164205488,
-0.0115042832,
-0.0036290693,
-0.0263231024,
0.0364583023,
-0.0666953474,
-0.0032489775,
-0.009859439,
0.003861584,
-0.0130044557,
0.0371352769,
-0.0325387642,
0.0421807729,
0.0382117406,
0.0104982005,
0.0006706239,
-0.0003225479,
-0.0564147793,
-0.0220272075,
-0.0412419699,
0.0707149357,
-0.0021054386,
0.0062297117,
0.0087183388,
-0.0087435003,
0.0327963904,
0.0179591179,
0.0499779768,
0.0457690731,
0.06853313,
-0.0302805007,
-0.0306841843,
0.0004377412,
-0.0202813223,
0.028868515,
-0.0441882573,
-0.0000849331,
0.0292400327,
-0.0032889533,
-0.0039473725,
-0.0241832584,
-0.0297563225,
-0.0367026292,
0.0669200197,
-0.001511272,
-0.0166043621,
0.038636364,
0.0181124602,
3.006e-7,
0.0079393815,
0.088365376,
-0.0186488964,
0.0221954957,
0.0412285589,
-0.0414532609,
0.0137476129,
-0.0291620605,
0.0313343517,
0.0711270124,
0.0132869184,
-0.0050009089,
0.0468064547,
0.0429784358,
-0.0574035272,
-0.0032309564,
-0.030820379,
0.0346260555,
-0.0328340456,
0.0323867835,
-0.015670104,
-0.0018474392,
-0.0016967528,
-0.057810761,
-0.023763936,
-0.0117245084,
-0.0209564045,
0.005894877,
0.0384721272,
0.0111031821,
0.0321138911,
0.0146433553,
0.0786065683,
0.0680120662,
-0.0283383131,
0.0603012815,
0.0006658195,
0.0018885495,
-0.0368489698,
0.0196425989,
0.0560135581,
0.0107112881,
-0.0370026678,
-0.0452625044,
0.0303441565,
-0.0050597023,
0.0000479466,
0.0194579177,
0.0099258311,
-0.0338949598,
0.0808797777,
-0.0211390294,
0.0160052124,
0.0271364227,
0.0081535,
-0.0819226801,
0.0382337347,
0.0332870036,
0.0235666744,
0.0387836546,
-0.0371573642,
0.0276580844,
0.00912748,
-0.0053126663,
0.0119392825,
0.0143324081,
0.0642585605,
2.125024708e-34,
-0.0397184417,
0.0132224476,
0.0168172382,
-0.0445344783,
0.0056748181,
0.0157193467,
0.0073484015,
0.031881731,
-0.0130809052,
-0.0078123328,
0.0273376107
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15032v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15032v1 | nlpBDpatriots at BLP-2023 Task 2: A Transfer Learning Approach to Bangla Sentiment Analysis | 2023-11-25T13:58:58 | 2023-11-25T13:58:58 | Dhiman Goswami, Md Nishat Raihan, Sadiya Sayara Chowdhury Puspo, Marcos Zampieri | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this paper, we discuss the nlpBDpatriots entry to the shared task on
Sentiment Analysis of Bangla Social Media Posts organized at the first workshop
on Bangla Language Processing (BLP) co-located with EMNLP. The main objective
of this task is to identify the polarity of social media content using a Bangla
dataset annotated with positive, neutral, and negative labels provided by the
shared task organizers. Our best system for this task is a transfer learning
approach with data augmentation which achieved a micro F1 score of 0.71. Our
best system ranked 12th among 30 teams that participated in the competition. | [
0.006245635,
0.0490273423,
-0.0164788514,
0.0335268863,
-0.0487754121,
0.0108560845,
-0.0264003109,
-0.0336766429,
-0.0171708781,
-0.0042187702,
-0.0074476255,
-0.0122236665,
-0.0219351165,
0.0614658035,
-0.0201629195,
-0.0756035671,
0.0498694628,
0.0757604912,
0.0463449098,
0.0091996109,
0.0106147379,
0.023450641,
-0.0184912421,
-0.0384086594,
-0.0345211811,
0.0281312224,
0.0203831848,
-0.0012536448,
0.0226144474,
-0.0624846742,
0.0118816616,
0.0335451476,
-0.0188535582,
-0.0115582841,
0.0000020791,
-0.0421588719,
-0.0508072786,
-0.0011258904,
-0.0019324488,
-0.0433901474,
0.0853634179,
-0.0327952728,
0.0050752601,
0.0381012,
-0.0493341573,
-0.0105845891,
0.0882178694,
0.0839967653,
0.0572762452,
0.0911064893,
-0.0210689083,
-0.0121022761,
-0.0150734549,
0.0061148908,
0.0285542235,
-0.0189226549,
0.0267079677,
-0.0103152515,
0.009046617,
0.0135682859,
-0.0163537189,
0.010811694,
-0.0052008242,
-0.0171596445,
0.0334094316,
-0.0294521265,
-0.0103271371,
0.0001217187,
0.0153562231,
0.0406104922,
0.0123123471,
-0.0261956211,
-0.0113918781,
-0.0068491804,
-0.0051848027,
-0.0292534884,
-0.045094341,
-0.0192551035,
0.0181836039,
0.0667473748,
-0.0172537398,
0.0450840406,
0.0253864042,
0.017967619,
0.0020291188,
0.0704127625,
-0.0154267484,
-0.0368378572,
0.0244832896,
0.0943940058,
0.0390851796,
0.0374917537,
0.0242913496,
-0.0291745868,
0.0405298136,
0.0156629886,
-0.0015724736,
-0.0289959703,
-0.018893227,
-0.0188180339,
-0.0010009392,
0.0074820011,
-0.0340389647,
0.0460512005,
-0.0278180093,
-0.0412412435,
0.0249535777,
0.0023121978,
0.0038624872,
-0.0156988502,
-0.0635358393,
0.0141645242,
0.0114470078,
0.0399004519,
0.0004931623,
0.0264881905,
-0.0642692894,
-0.0266295522,
-0.0726540685,
-0.0539534464,
0.0059613837,
0.0062842863,
0.0323411338,
-0.0012678541,
5.403e-7,
0.0783663988,
-0.0002333232,
0.0313064009,
-0.0284990333,
-0.0437180661,
-0.0138970418,
0.024475798,
0.0192902666,
-0.0529226363,
0.0001986441,
0.0322690085,
0.0122445505,
-0.015063622,
-0.0881694779,
0.0550741367,
-0.008439254,
-0.0430433489,
0.0121069653,
-0.04655293,
0.0669587627,
-0.0296449251,
-0.0123440158,
-0.0293827765,
0.0010998026,
0.0267486405,
-0.0131307254,
0.0894853994,
-0.0320838913,
-0.0210159775,
0.0245856326,
0.0188793875,
0.0053732242,
0.0549903587,
-0.0185634755,
0.0492865443,
0.0162710119,
-0.0287928414,
-0.0138486121,
-0.0011618347,
0.0498978235,
-0.0072123241,
-0.0105143422,
-0.0172128286,
-0.0205938052,
-0.0406790487,
0.0090331389,
0.0069555561,
0.0153349731,
-0.0056476491,
0.0469760485,
0.0036846362,
-0.0397012085,
0.0104504125,
-0.0193521269,
0.0078094583,
-0.0266031697,
-0.0308962781,
-0.0199928284,
0.0528137423,
-0.0373800732,
-0.0617622547,
0.0331295915,
0.0131858382,
-0.0014903513,
0.000283577,
0.0181619935,
-0.0274903905,
0.0375758111,
-0.0221831761,
0.0622623339,
0.0098815225,
-0.0185254477,
0.0365658142,
0.066028662,
-0.0593473651,
-0.0179908853,
-0.0361525454,
0.0465011746,
-0.0254798289,
-0.0364955962,
-0.0174823832,
-0.0323451534,
-0.046858754,
0.0039366493,
0.0301576369,
0.0300394204,
0.0053142691,
-0.0102909785,
-0.0216863174,
0.0217289999,
0.0191947818,
0.0020306041,
0.0048186127,
-0.0260169804,
0.0762844905,
0.0063906834,
0.0380687565,
-0.0197700262,
0.0114605892,
0.0338625237,
-0.0069493768,
0.0461389646,
0.018806234,
0.0606644005,
0.018431982,
-0.0023298492,
-0.030929558,
0.0113674561,
-0.0353271961,
-0.0488581881,
0.0029191291,
-0.0135678295,
-0.0545294397,
0.0438045785,
-0.0679125562,
0.0245317034,
0.0478280634,
-0.0451929681,
-0.0397656076,
0.1062442064,
-0.0009571583,
-0.0239088368,
0.0049024224,
0.0201282315,
-0.0383834243,
0.0540455244,
-0.0165445786,
0.0251571387,
0.0263380054,
-0.0350759178,
-0.0358743332,
-0.0268817991,
0.0518171787,
-0.011662378,
-0.0204710755,
0.0386918746,
-0.0034553395,
-0.0133005464,
-0.006532935,
0.024160644,
-0.0349367075,
-0.0008040661,
-0.0485059172,
0.0050717723,
0.0007397246,
0.0302907042,
0.0341600366,
0.0193174798,
-0.0133464467,
0.0007287535,
-0.0298600383,
0.0166705791,
0.0200203918,
0.0081333816,
0.0482178964,
-0.0221217535,
0.0494187474,
-0.0279271137,
-0.0229282174,
0.0058232122,
-0.0186333358,
-0.0044721682,
-0.0642893091,
0.0124510704,
0.0105455639,
0.0017833238,
-0.0130346091,
0.0116275698,
-0.0176370926,
-0.0091755381,
-0.0416170247,
-0.0223839376,
0.0386653617,
0.0167685263,
-0.0012109807,
-0.0177596863,
-0.0043159062,
-0.0167747326,
0.0236049145,
-0.03010129,
0.049746979,
0.016791895,
-0.0399287157,
0.0020522953,
0.0266572498,
-0.0151941301,
-0.0035978325,
-0.0434438325,
-0.0089141866,
-0.0317170322,
-0.0371470377,
-0.0252953228,
0.0364620611,
-0.0102575421,
0.0093862452,
0.008258922,
-0.0165951531,
0.0321200602,
0.0007410839,
0.0208456889,
-0.0764954761,
-0.0151506169,
-0.025549477,
0.0361016095,
-0.0059426213,
-0.0076847924,
-0.0414038599,
-0.0018554792,
-0.0060311817,
-0.0256384015,
0.0065250369,
-0.0110650426,
-0.0085299574,
-0.0184501167,
0.0249047969,
-0.0391536132,
-0.0551909097,
-0.0014831027,
-0.0386089198,
-0.0061899335,
-0.0067910794,
0.0049503339,
-0.0083141169,
-0.0304979347,
0.0127753858,
-0.0161458384,
-0.0671018288,
0.0083411643,
0.0036447146,
0.0399505571,
0.0023251092,
0.037798509,
0.0129469186,
0.0582594648,
0.0264943726,
-0.0849955305,
0.0072018886,
-0.0107558463,
0.0087599391,
-0.0200065318,
-0.0309730507,
0.0414252803,
-0.0328519903,
-0.0051509324,
-0.0639770776,
0.0432406813,
-0.0138817895,
-0.0095705669,
0.0842204988,
-0.0002500688,
-0.0426308587,
-0.0107290456,
-0.0205677673,
-0.0336809978,
-0.0182893295,
0.0398732796,
-0.051093284,
-0.0212462731,
-0.0240825173,
0.0232698061,
-0.0077882493,
-0.0358826518,
-0.0405331738,
-0.1390969604,
-0.0037051218,
-0.0161812939,
-0.0227510389,
-0.0659399107,
-0.0612114146,
0.0124941533,
-0.0588216595,
0.0363966376,
-0.0486185662,
-0.0023305444,
0.0263575204,
0.0379189178,
-0.0423404165,
-0.0208244696,
0.0235797223,
-0.0182243064,
0.0539738759,
0.0162643623,
0.0475211777,
-0.0522520021,
0.0006792464,
-0.0103684515,
-0.0373017304,
-0.035183385,
-0.0198241752,
0.0731965378,
-0.0152410902,
-0.0333127789,
0.0087334095,
-0.0003510067,
-0.0663817227,
0.010816847,
0.0215420108,
0.0697692335,
0.0155464867,
-0.0534674823,
-0.038864892,
0.0347585976,
0.0477544814,
0.0502626523,
0.0191094372,
-0.0356751494,
-0.0215179734,
0.018449679,
-0.0347173996,
-0.0580674671,
0.0011177037,
-0.0016061682,
-0.0575395152,
-0.0417880975,
-0.0701485351,
-0.0586643741,
0.0340446346,
0.0649723932,
-0.025213439,
0.0104482016,
0.0103618614,
-0.0232937057,
-0.0159099959,
0.0152360499,
-0.0066444362,
0.0419251844,
-0.0229221005,
-0.0337865129,
0.0265328567,
0.0095090372,
-0.0024333217,
-0.0349675938,
-0.0366245471,
-0.0252980515,
0.0248465948,
0.0274488609,
0.0130953966,
-0.0077018822,
-0.0581281185,
-0.0255186837,
0.0024077361,
0.1035441086,
-0.0318371281,
-0.0145168155,
0.0408399887,
0.039146293,
0.017124841,
0.0531430282,
0.0166519918,
0.0496437289,
0.0444335155,
-0.038399782,
0.0099308379,
-0.0017986165,
-0.0112446435,
0.0472546108,
0.0587413572,
0.0435816832,
-0.0832603127,
-0.0353839993,
-0.0301057287,
0.0183531437,
-0.0158758294,
-0.040120177,
-0.0257871691,
0.0396339856,
0.0207227711,
-0.0414446741,
-0.0095954193,
-0.0032830825,
0.0007594898,
-0.0133427763,
0.0578327142,
0.0782918185,
0.0362440087,
-0.0165847782,
0.0332125202,
0.0178647637,
-0.0319542103,
0.0358890295,
0.0198203176,
-0.0359581262,
0.0195584614,
-0.0088857273,
0.0454736166,
0.0073028598,
0.0440873504,
0.0033580475,
0.0645252019,
-0.0193290487,
0.0037355239,
0.0274737608,
-0.0413890406,
0.1014514565,
0.0050448785,
-0.0184664782,
-0.0246192645,
0.0258296225,
-0.0552375689,
0.0185000543,
0.0289279092,
-0.0203352105,
-0.0203971397,
0.008778587,
0.026033204,
-0.0759479702,
0.0121511891,
0.0493446514,
-0.0005542602,
-0.0213959292,
-0.0164784342,
0.0478667356,
0.0059801838,
0.0485505462,
0.0754766837,
-0.0386483893,
-0.0550606959,
0.0189893991,
-0.0989978686,
0.0214938261,
0.0193301346,
0.0206582639,
0.0377692319,
0.0113949757,
0.0710529611,
-0.0469547324,
0.0110615222,
-0.0166116282,
-0.0082494365,
-0.0062229154,
-6.848327232e-33,
-0.0248690657,
0.0140675614,
-0.0300591867,
-0.0140890721,
-0.0362811349,
-0.0284640417,
-0.0044935537,
-0.0038175052,
-0.022381708,
0.0252509546,
-0.0313459374,
0.0014711113,
0.0172145516,
0.063265793,
0.0404435173,
-0.028485164,
0.0243300479,
0.0507790893,
-0.0027347088,
0.0340483189,
0.0512586683,
0.0591231622,
0.0818587616,
-0.1047596931,
0.0021447339,
0.0351115055,
-0.02766403,
-0.0150657687,
0.0485610813,
0.006169775,
-0.0065142214,
0.0543568097,
0.0502528511,
-0.0434241593,
-0.0194531567,
0.0041003609,
-0.0172366481,
-0.0433119275,
0.0010398503,
0.0463134982,
-0.0271313637,
-0.0042356574,
0.022132881,
-0.0144540891,
-0.0162344016,
0.008949602,
0.0035244161,
-0.0199662056,
-0.0049164016,
0.0183228441,
-0.0755295381,
0.0363163613,
-0.0014806821,
0.0336126462,
0.0350155644,
0.0051905802,
-0.0166082811,
-0.0108583895,
-0.0534834825,
-0.0058387825,
-0.0130905788,
0.012127961,
0.0333723947,
-0.0274909791,
-0.0104881097,
0.0187306609,
0.0293087661,
-0.0186880939,
0.0321151316,
0.0193459336,
-0.0031335019,
0.0559980907,
0.0274165273,
0.0830519497,
0.031568177,
-0.0707241297,
-0.0300816372,
0.0265487507,
0.0999103263,
0.007052395,
-0.0058519142,
0.0229858402,
-0.0229891427,
-0.0248341244,
0.0483813658,
-0.0217615403,
0.0019863746,
-0.0601151139,
0.0191245824,
-0.0397325829,
-0.0355433598,
0.0252912305,
0.0176557451,
-0.0720049888,
-0.0043172375,
0.0010885919,
-0.0493186712,
-0.0012157439,
0.029011108,
-0.0035544576,
-0.0889613256,
-0.0229692608,
-0.0318754464,
0.0552734919,
0.004665486,
-0.0077275992,
0.0704991445,
0.0129317017,
-0.0806175023,
-0.0129432566,
-0.0511819683,
0.0555106327,
-0.0102969799,
0.1015261188,
-0.0371904634,
0.0017180709,
-0.003265742,
0.033112254,
0.0359384604,
0.0414553769,
0.0578844957,
-0.0049368525,
-0.0077941837,
-0.0644228384,
-0.0474267527,
-0.0303818211,
0.0001128795,
-0.009935692,
-0.019289827,
-0.0554267392,
-0.008958404,
-0.0288956799,
2.987e-7,
0.043453794,
0.055021923,
-0.0219397228,
-0.0592972077,
0.0097820684,
0.0263782814,
-0.0430698059,
0.0407634452,
-0.0260688495,
0.0390129387,
0.0100606866,
0.0087912716,
0.0218112133,
0.0468923561,
-0.0850117505,
-0.0246601142,
-0.0419898294,
-0.0422049575,
-0.0184689835,
-0.0018763526,
0.0610264838,
0.0749014169,
0.0519729741,
-0.0386075824,
-0.0006574679,
0.0013194182,
0.0107119549,
-0.0373733081,
0.0016216087,
-0.0058284937,
0.0092751579,
-0.0062045204,
-0.0209826436,
0.0022454895,
-0.0240537263,
0.0217965543,
0.0347164348,
0.0522672981,
0.0020970458,
-0.0188379008,
0.0204140469,
0.027772285,
0.0259238482,
-0.0208777245,
0.0974977612,
-0.0392108038,
-0.0867376029,
-0.0610888861,
-0.0605200119,
0.011789673,
0.0541177206,
0.0210030265,
-0.0206357669,
0.0015006901,
0.0149139622,
-0.0236753393,
-0.0998545662,
-0.0643681139,
0.0472586788,
0.0176618826,
-0.0126567157,
-0.0101695126,
0.0048971381,
0.0676648319,
0.0172294434,
-0.0061689904,
0.0448178537,
1.988946543e-34,
0.0148537615,
-0.0150876837,
0.0270011239,
-0.051441744,
0.0020751122,
0.0251139402,
-0.0506953932,
-0.0009098618,
0.0198380891,
-0.0252502169,
0.0339850821
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15029v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15029v1 | nlpBDpatriots at BLP-2023 Task 1: A Two-Step Classification for Violence Inciting Text Detection in Bangla | 2023-11-25T13:47:34 | 2023-11-25T13:47:34 | Md Nishat Raihan, Dhiman Goswami, Sadiya Sayara Chowdhury Puspo, Marcos Zampieri | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this paper, we discuss the nlpBDpatriots entry to the shared task on
Violence Inciting Text Detection (VITD) organized as part of the first workshop
on Bangla Language Processing (BLP) co-located with EMNLP. The aim of this task
is to identify and classify the violent threats, that provoke further unlawful
violent acts. Our best-performing approach for the task is two-step
classification using back translation and multilinguality which ranked 6th out
of 27 teams with a macro F1 score of 0.74. | [
0.0567633323,
-0.0139498832,
-0.0297080576,
0.0595497862,
-0.0464927331,
0.0332192406,
0.0320175961,
0.0349408351,
0.0091231083,
-0.0263097323,
0.0276343673,
-0.0306838509,
0.0066544954,
0.0354964621,
0.0028856371,
-0.0635387748,
0.0303618964,
0.0140479971,
0.0565486141,
0.03072639,
0.0263543166,
0.0510884039,
-0.0445641056,
0.0118341874,
-0.0838267505,
0.0038768831,
0.0123011954,
-0.0362338237,
0.0509062521,
-0.0398178883,
-0.0012761357,
0.0772980154,
0.0066922545,
0.0448538847,
0.0000019968,
-0.0753463283,
-0.0111922324,
-0.0264344625,
-0.0067770854,
-0.061149817,
0.0325719193,
-0.0457262881,
-0.0120356269,
0.0071479296,
-0.0139025534,
0.0008423305,
0.0535010323,
0.1062999219,
0.0544759892,
0.0764963925,
0.0084279552,
-0.0959384665,
0.0291077625,
0.0282352548,
0.0184266735,
0.0363704413,
-0.0004403447,
-0.0187627338,
0.0109435245,
0.0365787819,
0.0073896041,
0.0148309655,
0.0129996762,
-0.0115184737,
-0.0282482263,
-0.0016705658,
-0.0373396762,
-0.027488824,
0.0254753996,
0.0309769362,
-0.0604212023,
-0.0210134964,
-0.0019575665,
-0.0094539775,
-0.0316541493,
-0.0463817455,
0.0111953411,
0.0104073649,
-0.0365806073,
0.0013924723,
0.0154426973,
0.0785415396,
0.01117534,
0.0352720767,
0.0282025784,
-0.0013712862,
-0.0389583968,
-0.0229771994,
0.0030781967,
-0.003491885,
-0.0023461725,
0.0141160479,
0.0219623838,
-0.0258578192,
0.0077273566,
-0.0177858658,
-0.0228689536,
-0.1045165062,
0.0246225148,
-0.1107385606,
0.0134484423,
0.0368854143,
-0.0531934313,
0.0049195266,
-0.0221812855,
0.0389245711,
0.0150832748,
0.0073970021,
-0.008648932,
0.0555569157,
-0.0445660762,
-0.0086856419,
-0.017399177,
-0.0171851888,
-0.0046501514,
0.0308388732,
-0.0767549872,
-0.0157997459,
-0.0442972705,
-0.0806606933,
-0.0083553195,
-0.0133208316,
0.0114259524,
0.0117439423,
0.0367968306,
-0.0177463777,
-0.0295511615,
-0.0269624367,
-0.0532522909,
-0.0659240931,
0.0071643721,
0.0024704242,
-0.0405795835,
-0.0310547817,
-0.0014413359,
0.0616962798,
-0.0317870639,
-0.0202284884,
-0.0991260856,
0.0115381405,
-0.0286219586,
-0.0555594116,
-0.0069301534,
-0.056232594,
0.0575247519,
-0.0305583682,
-0.0190464221,
-0.0022409854,
0.0118300607,
0.0222666375,
-0.0000725269,
0.1086630374,
0.0052167331,
-0.0201237258,
0.075360857,
0.0457829386,
0.032461822,
0.0689827427,
0.0036989946,
0.0227620155,
0.017937446,
0.02316905,
-0.0005225231,
0.0436816961,
-0.003043934,
-0.0146221481,
-0.0263691563,
-0.0110310167,
0.0227837265,
-0.0222830754,
-0.0055070603,
-0.0257654488,
-0.0307622701,
-0.0093183583,
0.0170656946,
0.0796106532,
-0.0264261086,
0.0235367604,
0.0431059487,
0.0062943157,
-0.0563307367,
-0.0188596491,
0.0036041157,
-0.0226869974,
-0.0557194091,
-0.0430975184,
0.0201883838,
0.0501359031,
0.0012484379,
-0.006686022,
-0.0265073515,
-0.0092312051,
0.0067117047,
-0.045190949,
0.0301617347,
0.028938178,
-0.0049466756,
0.0082524354,
0.0418490097,
-0.0248860847,
-0.0180411525,
-0.0409964509,
-0.0016628741,
0.0190260038,
0.0004146705,
0.002437718,
-0.011220675,
-0.0734600052,
0.0530897453,
0.0551742949,
-0.0435347185,
0.020012198,
-0.0038512126,
-0.0412198156,
-0.0048564691,
0.0343594626,
-0.0173456408,
0.010004282,
0.0085726464,
0.0238301139,
0.0240146611,
0.0594761893,
-0.0755258277,
0.0282432586,
0.0346696787,
-0.0193371959,
0.0024519563,
0.028757561,
0.0581416897,
0.0170375202,
-0.0180334933,
-0.0681580752,
0.0130357267,
-0.0534675643,
-0.0282936096,
0.0086954525,
0.0037496304,
-0.0455055125,
0.0201890264,
-0.0411129147,
0.0132790441,
-0.0066019278,
0.0086619928,
-0.0023338797,
0.0237361547,
-0.0169059224,
-0.0681553334,
-0.0203445219,
0.0210359674,
-0.0253686383,
0.0069983206,
-0.0320908763,
0.0727660879,
0.0067265867,
0.0094934348,
0.0033843198,
-0.019985849,
0.0978821516,
0.0008872678,
-0.0347822383,
0.0567928664,
-0.0008991303,
0.0131771034,
0.0187944546,
0.0623866692,
-0.0193014015,
-0.0179633535,
-0.0163468793,
0.0059249089,
-0.0211899672,
-0.0059912545,
0.0373485871,
0.0201588441,
-0.0376122594,
-0.0102371303,
0.006736204,
-0.0217903927,
0.0757663772,
0.0178679228,
0.0071816132,
-0.0623157956,
0.0273704827,
0.0228904337,
0.007807571,
-0.0228475221,
0.0339038931,
0.0094189206,
-0.1154297069,
-0.0103827044,
-0.0187362749,
0.0011065066,
-0.0000444729,
-0.0177274346,
-0.0560303405,
0.0525831543,
-0.0064197984,
0.0115091344,
0.0599539205,
0.0346764103,
0.0423652902,
0.0352629162,
0.0095966253,
-0.033769127,
0.0052646222,
-0.0186467487,
0.0115635628,
0.006068713,
-0.0248065908,
-0.0205214266,
0.0390699953,
0.0290418323,
0.0104185874,
-0.051195614,
-0.0231625009,
-0.0320295654,
-0.0447752103,
-0.0970267802,
-0.0699621588,
-0.0463093109,
0.0315906778,
0.0125099383,
-0.0515241958,
0.0387799777,
0.0037516765,
0.0523729064,
-0.0684371665,
0.0097264387,
-0.0013853493,
0.0769569203,
-0.0056320853,
0.0513056181,
-0.0277715474,
-0.0484782122,
0.0428763628,
0.0014879062,
0.0144201955,
-0.0104588894,
-0.0246669333,
-0.0520563684,
0.0080309473,
-0.018484652,
-0.0312009621,
-0.0397822298,
-0.0456358567,
0.0133558465,
-0.0206686929,
-0.0322517827,
0.0133259771,
-0.0161061361,
0.0600370467,
0.0177229177,
-0.0073885056,
-0.0281864293,
0.0093714027,
0.0107909078,
-0.0209896043,
-0.0055188048,
-0.041492451,
-0.0084230788,
0.0071434965,
-0.0396186188,
0.038807217,
-0.0281123091,
-0.0432312228,
-0.0155778099,
0.0295584928,
0.0439970754,
-0.0354235694,
-0.0341247693,
-0.0385054313,
-0.0118732266,
-0.0015309292,
-0.0023766672,
0.0873838216,
0.0403248817,
-0.0273313895,
-0.0017446376,
-0.0350609124,
-0.0025561131,
-0.0059358822,
-0.0037260209,
-0.0479415171,
0.008157976,
-0.0039090882,
-0.0082116127,
-0.0472945049,
-0.0299811084,
-0.0347015299,
-0.0251843929,
0.0197773725,
0.0112498095,
-0.0224644765,
-0.0503907055,
-0.0069443001,
0.0008343954,
0.0029971602,
0.0314763263,
-0.0151982997,
0.0134543097,
-0.023815589,
0.0296590626,
-0.0159008931,
0.0149809085,
0.0213677287,
-0.0260136705,
-0.0119536109,
0.0522257648,
0.041033715,
-0.0507315211,
0.0369358473,
0.031014109,
-0.0004228877,
-0.0238708109,
-0.0385496505,
0.0486071929,
-0.0019119882,
-0.0191786382,
0.0003211735,
0.0349045657,
0.005579832,
-0.0285058562,
0.0333082937,
0.0557890274,
0.0070672315,
0.0035256722,
-0.0192651972,
0.0360982753,
0.0011357543,
0.0045227986,
0.0248786472,
-0.0181005038,
-0.0066853124,
-0.0365077853,
-0.0533673428,
-0.0377919339,
-0.0820100531,
-0.0161415599,
-0.0633479059,
-0.0975205302,
-0.0024814603,
-0.0719107389,
0.0537154712,
0.0481041223,
-0.0003997381,
-0.0055379733,
-0.0116010988,
-0.0182407815,
-0.0285120159,
-0.007044212,
0.0207492132,
0.0512441248,
-0.0192339793,
0.0506971665,
0.0011055146,
0.007805794,
-0.0260164775,
0.0297275577,
-0.0555425622,
-0.0492021441,
0.0492274389,
0.0182857309,
0.020416243,
-0.0128639173,
-0.0533788316,
-0.0399511792,
0.0556683242,
0.0391595699,
0.0193833802,
-0.0295563415,
0.017148884,
0.0085027516,
0.0085887406,
0.0021016812,
0.0510982871,
0.0354208648,
0.0282331612,
-0.0315914154,
-0.0530733913,
-0.0271910075,
-0.0056440695,
0.0264446922,
0.0419058464,
-0.0372788124,
-0.1081798747,
-0.0374803171,
-0.0287390891,
0.0265973415,
-0.0314671434,
0.0083516249,
0.026154533,
0.0386628509,
0.0106357681,
-0.0096821235,
-0.0340890884,
-0.0280043371,
-0.032690268,
-0.0099767838,
0.0467986986,
0.0602711253,
0.0619879775,
0.0383788012,
0.0163671672,
-0.0137328878,
0.028955441,
-0.0206726007,
-0.0015479135,
-0.0299964007,
0.0535024181,
-0.0081476672,
0.023574451,
0.017044168,
0.0671331808,
0.0047523226,
0.0367275774,
-0.0222393293,
-0.0262043793,
0.0348531604,
-0.0340435915,
0.0742451549,
-0.0134029128,
-0.0072319228,
-0.0138362376,
0.0375735536,
-0.0505849756,
-0.0346893743,
0.0002929642,
-0.0016130743,
-0.0272681266,
-0.0017313841,
0.0548154376,
-0.0603920817,
0.0023054213,
0.1083718985,
-0.0409974419,
-0.0223449972,
-0.0420811549,
0.0131551968,
0.0368025824,
0.0107818637,
0.0306738131,
-0.0408163406,
-0.0055868719,
0.0171325859,
-0.0398600362,
0.0078667933,
0.0242578238,
0.0152017092,
0.0580503382,
0.0113467267,
0.020834012,
-0.04319527,
0.0167675782,
0.0190275554,
-0.0182171296,
-0.0080916956,
-5.524956427e-33,
-0.0264001824,
-0.0528297499,
0.0031762151,
-0.0123196328,
-0.0147846555,
-0.021265354,
0.0366798565,
0.0046887635,
0.015229919,
0.0279655159,
-0.011019825,
0.0046461984,
0.0227992944,
-0.0272642579,
0.03029087,
-0.0467903204,
0.00065062,
0.0251749046,
-0.002524307,
-0.0110197179,
0.0747922435,
0.0221168082,
0.1042060778,
-0.0723912567,
0.0587917492,
0.0101864738,
-0.0381303728,
0.0141176963,
0.0040511661,
0.0589080378,
-0.0350084491,
0.0406397022,
0.0504878908,
-0.0325387083,
-0.0105113499,
0.0149573479,
-0.0132523887,
-0.0204351973,
0.0297179483,
0.0489722081,
-0.0132113425,
-0.0222040322,
0.0155594833,
-0.016359603,
-0.0302366912,
-0.0112048499,
-0.0064902869,
-0.0333569758,
-0.0037191573,
-0.0162716992,
-0.075249128,
0.0295492969,
-0.0244182181,
0.0177342743,
0.0254928563,
-0.0145368436,
-0.0077208667,
-0.021613745,
-0.0971401557,
0.0093196593,
0.0550466664,
0.0048045344,
0.0188138913,
-0.0157194789,
-0.0340083838,
0.0185545161,
-0.0112408083,
-0.040747568,
0.0234888233,
0.0424975082,
0.0237542596,
0.0442562513,
0.0389385559,
0.0624466464,
0.0451452695,
-0.0537820943,
-0.0560916625,
0.0216929875,
0.0877642259,
0.0233912896,
0.0280511715,
-0.006037401,
-0.0840752348,
-0.0385411195,
0.0210374519,
-0.0171757657,
-0.0095700268,
-0.0507009923,
0.0326161981,
-0.0189450551,
0.0247546379,
-0.010480036,
0.0204611085,
-0.0063211094,
0.0477442481,
0.0236883294,
-0.0412076637,
0.0433847867,
0.0331581607,
0.065037623,
-0.0349794142,
-0.0069889249,
-0.0050356919,
0.0174505021,
0.0361787267,
0.0025243333,
0.0820391551,
-0.0140662445,
-0.0762057006,
0.0033479393,
-0.0123101687,
0.0280419979,
-0.001531181,
0.1007936075,
0.0006617267,
-0.0222968385,
-0.0017700446,
-0.0161032826,
0.0707934275,
-0.019809857,
0.0503258519,
0.0185418222,
-0.0312741436,
-0.013479189,
0.0024386989,
0.0172479283,
-0.0172678325,
0.0191780496,
0.0084358538,
-0.0675919279,
0.0230667815,
-0.0210624672,
2.626e-7,
0.0173404086,
0.0521464609,
-0.0095283976,
0.0026087309,
-0.0266169254,
0.0206755102,
0.0180758163,
0.0398848802,
-0.0012912273,
0.0358102396,
0.0145859988,
0.0067383009,
0.0319259614,
0.0638855174,
-0.0873791575,
-0.0048595965,
-0.0690864027,
-0.017399095,
-0.0795440823,
-0.0020186321,
0.0450768918,
0.0178189445,
0.020498503,
-0.0123636136,
-0.0195020828,
0.006632755,
-0.0201148372,
-0.0206458662,
-0.0342715085,
-0.0049392944,
0.0755152777,
-0.0084396349,
0.0041829492,
0.0341677703,
-0.0083280168,
-0.0054688095,
0.033279039,
0.0378436781,
-0.0224990379,
0.0501129776,
0.0240990836,
-0.0317471027,
-0.0039423327,
-0.0378034674,
0.0718543306,
0.0556786172,
-0.0510292798,
0.0168937929,
0.0009914439,
0.0020902841,
0.0597826391,
-0.0374874696,
-0.0243670959,
-0.0112890303,
0.0513530709,
-0.0584211498,
-0.026525747,
-0.0488685146,
0.0173176881,
0.0208017211,
0.0069895932,
0.0023617854,
-0.0207397193,
0.0680028796,
0.036004208,
-0.0070176749,
0.0243911613,
2.399807303e-34,
0.0106583126,
0.0079536811,
0.0314908139,
-0.0457442068,
0.0190442447,
0.0376464278,
-0.015595004,
-0.0169777628,
0.011359822,
-0.0558063202,
0.0073377737
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15023v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15023v1 | Offensive Language Identification in Transliterated and Code-Mixed Bangla | 2023-11-25T13:27:22 | 2023-11-25T13:27:22 | Md Nishat Raihan, Umma Hani Tanmoy, Anika Binte Islam, Kai North, Tharindu Ranasinghe, Antonios Anastasopoulos, Marcos Zampieri | cs.CL | cs.CL | Identifying offensive content in social media is vital for creating safe
online communities. Several recent studies have addressed this problem by
creating datasets for various languages. In this paper, we explore offensive
language identification in texts with transliterations and code-mixing,
linguistic phenomena common in multilingual societies, and a known challenge
for NLP systems. We introduce TB-OLID, a transliterated Bangla offensive
language dataset containing 5,000 manually annotated comments. We train and
fine-tune machine learning models on TB-OLID, and we evaluate their results on
this dataset. Our results show that English pre-trained transformer-based
models, such as fBERT and HateBERT achieve the best performance on this
dataset. | [
0.0762169659,
0.0504952408,
-0.0214714017,
0.0445077717,
0.0113579016,
0.0592782311,
0.0305463411,
0.01066106,
0.0204913802,
-0.0339695178,
-0.0260540508,
-0.0237065088,
0.0095704636,
0.0048136702,
-0.0011370343,
-0.0236863028,
-0.0090043964,
0.0206736904,
-0.0069922078,
-0.0027003891,
0.0485557616,
0.0371960439,
0.0059023392,
0.0457842872,
-0.055399105,
0.0079951379,
0.0495058298,
0.0206920076,
0.0250660982,
0.023970332,
0.0456602499,
0.070458822,
-0.0455819964,
0.0681276321,
0.000001527,
-0.0330216698,
0.0026939013,
-0.0197388437,
0.003267688,
-0.0313731655,
0.0867088586,
-0.0487080999,
-0.0362501368,
0.038100753,
-0.0140872709,
-0.0155219166,
0.1089219153,
0.0412444696,
0.081806004,
0.0789301097,
-0.0044415365,
-0.0793788433,
-0.0160858277,
0.0214768387,
-0.0375652984,
0.0111862496,
0.0404721238,
-0.0214763712,
-0.070816569,
-0.0030557821,
-0.0284435842,
-0.0115510635,
0.0168657564,
-0.0176907592,
-0.0184864178,
-0.0559829473,
-0.0358854979,
-0.0512536988,
0.0385548398,
0.0649610534,
-0.0622688271,
-0.0459929332,
-0.0162564721,
0.0002644788,
-0.0316049196,
-0.0291424207,
0.004221506,
0.0185472388,
-0.0272482242,
0.0537414402,
0.0239452608,
0.0237434227,
0.0264950879,
0.0600248836,
0.006096717,
-0.0405468121,
-0.0177929085,
-0.0172036644,
-0.0267202612,
0.0125321504,
-0.0112992767,
0.0056764777,
0.0436536931,
0.0031110595,
-0.0023104153,
0.0099773472,
-0.0250384193,
-0.0918997824,
0.0222237017,
-0.0699092597,
0.0246426985,
0.0360583477,
-0.0690321848,
0.0163614955,
-0.0240280982,
0.0539034456,
-0.0000116228,
0.022892151,
0.0102373231,
-0.0367083065,
-0.0124801844,
0.0114366654,
0.0001026684,
-0.0234240908,
0.0124924975,
0.0661458969,
-0.0709613413,
0.0064715026,
-0.0424060784,
-0.0139967883,
0.022681972,
-0.0081320303,
-0.0191494171,
-0.0042654527,
0.018873753,
-0.0063066175,
-0.028234642,
0.0047822823,
-0.0597561225,
-0.0886678621,
0.0273778625,
0.009687297,
-0.01716117,
-0.0016898516,
0.0353260003,
0.0384731442,
0.0121354032,
-0.0443457738,
-0.0422551297,
0.0000240144,
-0.01389369,
-0.0242268443,
-0.0156030515,
-0.0772985518,
0.0433914885,
-0.0055203512,
-0.0229618251,
-0.0885393173,
0.0039985804,
0.0290876888,
-0.0508515798,
0.080868803,
-0.0057461066,
-0.0148178972,
0.0406649522,
0.0045210933,
-0.0050689853,
0.0703788772,
-0.0077877515,
0.0178251117,
0.0484800637,
-0.0107536521,
0.0155195054,
0.0745914206,
-0.0041959239,
0.0005348861,
-0.0322463252,
0.0087513085,
-0.0379620679,
-0.0379390456,
-0.0019356965,
0.0252648667,
0.0060548787,
-0.0500556417,
0.0277408976,
0.0306502432,
-0.0300680771,
0.0798758119,
0.0172791313,
0.0219530277,
-0.0108735738,
-0.0220993534,
-0.0202822182,
-0.0192691702,
-0.0165572148,
-0.0560091883,
0.040782921,
0.0849478766,
-0.0300519504,
-0.0402347371,
-0.0258030929,
-0.0299607646,
0.0714619905,
-0.0417322628,
0.0589441545,
0.0352128819,
-0.0045332662,
0.006788651,
0.0613300391,
-0.0228582472,
-0.001342303,
-0.0257613957,
0.0068249367,
0.0378840864,
0.0239653271,
-0.0107613271,
-0.0093703838,
-0.0680005401,
0.0164840296,
0.0469636247,
-0.0072894953,
-0.0135330874,
0.0191191211,
-0.0309329107,
0.0117156599,
0.0818617791,
-0.0115256021,
0.0010824566,
0.050618995,
0.0133569948,
0.0128178606,
0.0389443189,
-0.0746403262,
0.0238190927,
-0.0144362459,
-0.0087337047,
0.0214647837,
0.0148052471,
0.0426972993,
0.0146009643,
-0.0265030097,
-0.0586006567,
0.0087831058,
-0.0047953534,
-0.0166376829,
0.0300790276,
0.0102474056,
-0.0294638611,
0.0367737189,
-0.03765155,
-0.0270961076,
0.0688380003,
-0.0242051203,
0.0234875903,
0.0398854837,
-0.0108464304,
-0.0096996799,
-0.0281661078,
0.0177033227,
-0.065058209,
0.0218081325,
0.0068036998,
0.0399364382,
-0.0073152403,
0.0264034607,
0.0125326337,
-0.0425524339,
0.051026877,
0.0324269868,
-0.0628319904,
0.0183816087,
-0.030845616,
0.0138949146,
0.0140086161,
0.0471021868,
0.0032099662,
-0.008249891,
-0.0764194354,
-0.0316911899,
-0.0306602567,
-0.022784004,
0.0270342529,
0.0219405908,
-0.0125105605,
-0.004141612,
-0.0033068331,
-0.0473060869,
0.0467139445,
0.0391463116,
0.0165990721,
-0.0661878213,
0.0053450838,
0.0048714355,
-0.0198671538,
-0.0062711299,
0.044474829,
0.0102195693,
-0.0388004854,
0.0034112846,
-0.0116575044,
-0.0287278257,
0.0260031577,
0.0129096666,
-0.0959263965,
0.0159496963,
0.0167753045,
-0.0135761471,
0.0450209863,
0.0414903015,
0.0557211041,
-0.0007443925,
0.0023018229,
-0.0084179528,
-0.0180817079,
-0.0356120914,
-0.0091029871,
0.0018643561,
-0.043417275,
-0.0087123886,
0.0410357974,
-0.008339542,
0.0049025835,
-0.0628096312,
0.0161803532,
-0.0441208109,
-0.0251745339,
-0.0225841776,
-0.0271260813,
-0.0206596702,
0.0251066182,
-0.0183714349,
-0.0492927991,
0.0739956722,
0.0102481833,
0.0189634077,
-0.0370981731,
0.022012122,
-0.0065578739,
0.0227790512,
-0.0037451687,
0.0555242673,
-0.0270098299,
-0.0308720507,
0.0304734763,
0.0364757366,
0.025168879,
-0.0339374542,
0.0036257294,
0.0021663629,
-0.0115119414,
0.0032452249,
-0.063676849,
-0.0529325716,
-0.069349736,
-0.0186700895,
-0.04489851,
0.033383891,
-0.0343408138,
0.0152063332,
0.0387948602,
-0.0102813505,
-0.0258302484,
0.0090930024,
0.00904442,
0.0230669323,
-0.0324414745,
-0.012971038,
-0.0183898378,
0.0253598299,
0.0375419259,
-0.0276409648,
0.0395452715,
-0.0002847349,
-0.0348294936,
-0.0140689956,
0.0022575457,
0.0405481309,
-0.004985969,
0.0184919424,
-0.0209309272,
0.0117447376,
0.0245622378,
-0.0277956575,
0.0786870122,
0.024189936,
-0.0223081652,
-0.0031393701,
-0.0316744745,
-0.0064827669,
0.0047906847,
0.0104687884,
-0.0886714011,
-0.0219470114,
-0.015271836,
-0.0043405918,
-0.0614384525,
-0.0404206738,
0.0062059159,
-0.0888845101,
-0.0122997789,
-0.0064875516,
-0.0156323276,
-0.0623502769,
0.0034670718,
-0.0055616726,
-0.0357610248,
0.0106055373,
-0.031090105,
0.0017472425,
-0.0217538327,
0.0296341963,
-0.0449242815,
-0.0380094349,
0.0072557088,
-0.0296004787,
0.0319455788,
0.0289991684,
0.0314278156,
-0.0637663528,
0.0123200566,
0.0191321522,
-0.0058358908,
-0.0372425281,
-0.0400183648,
0.0437341593,
0.0071068308,
-0.059580341,
-0.0038970867,
0.0013232708,
-0.0203965791,
-0.0091347117,
-0.0227856617,
0.036468409,
0.0381381474,
0.0184891522,
-0.0086471979,
0.0364120975,
0.0016557716,
0.045769088,
0.0126272654,
-0.0665235966,
0.011967822,
-0.0628607795,
-0.02350506,
-0.0333279409,
-0.0714614987,
0.0029934137,
-0.0226107594,
-0.0867489725,
-0.0552348383,
-0.0382703431,
0.0375681669,
-0.0013342497,
0.0232114606,
-0.0366112255,
-0.0020971897,
-0.0141853308,
0.0028565645,
-0.0193074308,
-0.0064046551,
0.0061649722,
-0.0659021959,
0.0156187294,
-0.0046330462,
-0.0205038022,
-0.0224110652,
0.0247325823,
-0.0600993931,
-0.0567523986,
0.0696972609,
0.0592472181,
0.0138465641,
0.0121285338,
-0.0464723408,
-0.0632036179,
0.0230299141,
0.0472115986,
-0.0144584794,
-0.0356292576,
0.0557971001,
-0.0131617542,
0.00467742,
0.029714521,
-0.0033550304,
0.0271926913,
0.0382245593,
-0.0651276633,
-0.0666889772,
-0.0335323215,
-0.0083605237,
-0.0050636171,
0.0449787229,
0.0012750934,
-0.0831121057,
-0.0384143069,
-0.0269615687,
0.0211538952,
-0.0117754908,
-0.0054865838,
0.007845168,
0.0353300236,
-0.0012251807,
-0.0497183278,
-0.0051313154,
-0.0383652933,
0.0190065447,
-0.0268917345,
0.0377404429,
0.060513176,
0.0304682255,
0.0297051016,
0.0248388983,
-0.0324719846,
0.0329835303,
0.0233939998,
0.0000015729,
-0.0088677816,
0.0212608129,
0.0047401916,
0.0518698022,
0.0337110385,
0.0210085493,
0.0448381454,
-0.0065599484,
-0.045006305,
-0.0370646343,
0.0340053439,
-0.04231821,
0.0619498752,
-0.010993897,
0.0074851424,
-0.0299437139,
-0.0005237922,
-0.0340761058,
-0.055891037,
0.0146607962,
-0.0098531069,
-0.0298757367,
0.0242710933,
0.065417707,
-0.0363840014,
0.018468339,
0.0654909983,
-0.053185273,
-0.0184903238,
0.0072569824,
0.0196014475,
0.0026943011,
0.0031240843,
0.0342073999,
-0.0153866746,
-0.0460664891,
0.0143847158,
-0.0724339485,
0.0312221795,
0.0178662948,
0.012783194,
0.0712118894,
0.0354125723,
0.0644019544,
-0.0351709947,
-0.0024356057,
-0.0069847363,
-0.0543490835,
-0.007114979,
-5.344223068e-33,
0.0232662037,
-0.0134713016,
-0.033664491,
0.015102949,
0.0511739142,
-0.0390020981,
0.0266648456,
0.013500479,
-0.0448308475,
0.0116420994,
-0.0223264899,
0.0039111213,
0.0146727934,
-0.0001601405,
0.0194160156,
-0.0565079004,
0.0318118818,
0.0319407135,
-0.0144509813,
0.001608888,
0.0735605359,
0.0034374679,
0.0573021993,
-0.0472869575,
0.0339614116,
-0.0378425047,
-0.0177658498,
0.0262520444,
0.0453975014,
0.0770006552,
-0.0202047098,
0.0800144374,
0.0484417565,
-0.0217535105,
-0.0084344931,
0.0232512057,
-0.0349606723,
0.0257334113,
0.0075334343,
0.0637357906,
0.0158147458,
-0.0334717184,
0.0622424074,
-0.0268763695,
-0.0501983576,
-0.0167026129,
0.0252999663,
-0.0257729478,
0.030947132,
-0.0452456772,
-0.0901837796,
0.0326241776,
-0.021372309,
-0.0085205678,
0.0154375155,
0.0620914698,
0.0102654528,
0.0205861554,
-0.0895661861,
0.0075343368,
0.013943851,
0.0032083879,
0.0035287116,
-0.0058372673,
-0.0086634038,
0.0135401292,
-0.0088578379,
-0.0037901162,
-0.0072161686,
0.0421492495,
0.0270828176,
0.0158569813,
0.0270374138,
0.0602451414,
0.0475587286,
-0.0941947103,
-0.0433336645,
0.0266808998,
0.0521366782,
0.0275118034,
0.0372363068,
-0.042897407,
-0.0609440915,
-0.0277637281,
0.0355376005,
-0.0398373976,
-0.0231212117,
-0.0454859175,
0.0183081049,
-0.0435074978,
-0.0219602715,
0.0186151378,
0.0380138233,
-0.0375386514,
0.0169611946,
0.0408085287,
-0.0371836238,
0.0306114759,
0.0250962581,
0.0673602894,
-0.0418675654,
-0.0193597563,
0.0006648353,
-0.041303914,
0.034149725,
0.0228544008,
0.1000890136,
0.0403613336,
-0.0767354518,
0.0141875315,
-0.0003629369,
0.0645169914,
-0.0150876958,
0.0972205177,
0.0119509269,
0.0260009784,
-0.0173502546,
-0.0200064778,
0.0532465391,
0.0197428092,
-0.013448773,
-0.0213420596,
-0.0192771461,
-0.0291533973,
-0.0156028019,
-0.0192606933,
-0.0113728307,
0.0093757259,
-0.0107359188,
-0.0725571439,
0.0110375788,
-0.0257754382,
2.272e-7,
0.0392730497,
0.0549124703,
0.0215562489,
0.0022537862,
0.0047081956,
0.0285560638,
0.022255931,
0.0226451624,
0.0225089863,
0.0451671556,
-0.0156843197,
-0.0010294212,
0.0299189445,
0.0518434681,
-0.0570370965,
-0.0371314101,
-0.0847518966,
0.0279929545,
-0.0271961633,
-0.0182088036,
-0.0066929059,
0.1011003777,
0.0453136824,
-0.0489431173,
-0.0342219323,
-0.0122081637,
0.0206702966,
-0.0400711186,
0.0018273619,
-0.0336398408,
0.0730779991,
0.031779632,
0.0297449566,
-0.013554371,
-0.0096638482,
-0.0115649235,
0.0285607148,
0.0130428225,
0.0057691811,
0.0401819199,
0.027221594,
-0.0406306908,
-0.0098552853,
-0.0532888845,
0.066209361,
0.0216393974,
-0.0265941527,
0.0028255384,
-0.0067122835,
-0.0049563739,
0.0507583208,
-0.0531298481,
-0.0267689619,
0.0172005352,
0.0665094778,
-0.0338499099,
-0.0140355714,
-0.0487702116,
-0.0091231884,
-0.0110298106,
-0.0122300247,
0.0145741859,
0.016620392,
-0.0027612632,
0.0342919976,
0.0135661131,
0.0629374981,
1.793658017e-34,
0.0307624862,
-0.0141549502,
0.0083087794,
-0.0085805785,
0.0209838226,
0.0297849998,
-0.0031457469,
0.0119251525,
0.018653091,
-0.0157028437,
-0.0009192154
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.15016v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.15016v1 | E-CORE: Emotion Correlation Enhanced Empathetic Dialogue Generation | 2023-11-25T12:47:39 | 2023-11-25T12:47:39 | Fengyi Fu, Lei Zhang, Quan Wang, Zhendong Mao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7 | Achieving empathy is a crucial step toward humanized dialogue systems.
Current approaches for empathetic dialogue generation mainly perceive an
emotional label to generate an empathetic response conditioned on it, which
simply treat emotions independently, but ignore the intrinsic emotion
correlation in dialogues, resulting in inaccurate emotion perception and
unsuitable response generation. In this paper, we propose a novel emotion
correlation enhanced empathetic dialogue generation framework, which
comprehensively realizes emotion correlation learning, utilization, and
supervising. Specifically, a multi-resolution emotion graph is devised to
capture context-based emotion interactions from different resolutions, further
modeling emotion correlation. Then we propose an emotion correlation enhanced
decoder, with a novel correlation-aware aggregation and soft/hard strategy,
respectively improving the emotion perception and response generation.
Experimental results on the benchmark dataset demonstrate the superiority of
our model in both empathetic perception and expression. | [
0.0369094089,
0.0057193991,
-0.0077684806,
0.0271591917,
0.007887708,
0.0257682595,
0.0027672348,
-0.0194022581,
0.0332907997,
0.0044323346,
-0.035820581,
0.0204856079,
-0.0180791058,
0.0063561243,
-0.0186336506,
-0.0946729034,
0.0143207787,
0.0550168715,
0.0801168531,
-0.0158198774,
0.021113649,
0.0549751483,
-0.0428941958,
0.0221753456,
-0.0959847346,
-0.0161739476,
-0.0435868874,
0.0707491711,
0.0316668935,
-0.022262482,
0.0423099436,
0.0342492312,
0.0151713807,
-0.0217064787,
0.0000019741,
-0.0191347264,
-0.0118689239,
-0.0218932573,
0.0055584712,
-0.0480718426,
0.0484292656,
-0.0366955921,
-0.003913946,
0.0277051404,
-0.0420541987,
0.0015336991,
0.0571573973,
0.0550710261,
0.1092798114,
0.0602062829,
-0.0393273309,
-0.0105840778,
0.0047585722,
-0.0094435727,
-0.017560197,
-0.0127205839,
-0.0256720651,
0.0500868745,
0.0120780002,
-0.0690158829,
-0.0555801131,
-0.0111962277,
0.027259307,
0.0054769553,
0.0200924538,
0.0111191869,
0.008193966,
-0.0556577817,
-0.0368959159,
0.0977895558,
0.0022965653,
0.0421103612,
0.0122692659,
-0.0138404481,
0.0158374403,
-0.04718557,
-0.027839331,
-0.0158508476,
-0.0320393257,
0.0170666948,
-0.011458219,
0.0523816943,
-0.0317213424,
0.0099758524,
0.0103526125,
0.0114709139,
-0.0178692006,
0.0093814218,
-0.030910017,
0.0097863814,
0.001606414,
-0.0011669943,
0.0037524998,
0.0167546459,
-0.0534685776,
0.0074957181,
-0.077105619,
-0.0213757996,
-0.0137465009,
-0.0152754188,
-0.0033676012,
0.0258003008,
0.0199011229,
0.0277486872,
0.0164492764,
0.0399269089,
0.0116972672,
-0.0040493635,
-0.0369663388,
-0.0080695245,
-0.013185977,
0.0002473539,
-0.0273678619,
0.0443340763,
-0.0387611911,
-0.0574197918,
-0.0828963369,
0.0127197923,
-0.0183725711,
-0.0009590799,
0.0282349307,
0.0345769003,
-0.0229141843,
-0.0059312494,
0.0047463891,
0.0436517224,
-0.0486674234,
0.0304110721,
0.0327447131,
-0.0365325361,
-0.011660642,
0.0192262456,
0.0471977852,
-0.0192469973,
0.0216748528,
0.0169168208,
-0.0329954922,
-0.0196477715,
-0.0098144934,
-0.0423806533,
-0.0426936336,
-0.0313956328,
-0.0203611013,
-0.0293010399,
0.0641517192,
-0.006744524,
0.0041976613,
-0.0332585201,
0.0137952091,
-0.0238246694,
-0.0430383198,
0.0186176896,
-0.0125384312,
0.0044709034,
0.0174752474,
-0.0067488933,
0.018225817,
0.0488528758,
0.0334163047,
0.0498062931,
0.0260725301,
0.0103398617,
0.025390178,
-0.0027615088,
0.0220060162,
-0.0363445505,
-0.0215203539,
-0.05546562,
-0.0511138625,
0.0195402205,
0.0691124871,
0.0645121038,
-0.0529117323,
-0.0390063301,
0.0479298197,
0.0504867174,
-0.0025246593,
0.0355853476,
-0.0003312629,
0.0431500897,
0.0050524967,
0.0156813562,
-0.0258668587,
0.0897937194,
0.0029688862,
0.0051337956,
0.0225707907,
0.0109683815,
-0.0426855795,
-0.0271061398,
0.0116905011,
-0.0235512573,
0.0184649006,
-0.014495681,
0.0022068459,
0.0155670438,
-0.0694568902,
-0.0172203071,
0.0152586875,
-0.0783544853,
-0.0192422569,
-0.0073858025,
-0.0218782611,
0.0936392918,
0.0448533036,
0.0132043073,
-0.0472097583,
0.0077669448,
-0.0527651384,
0.0125829037,
0.0340357088,
-0.0181998946,
0.057994917,
-0.07206361,
-0.0016852752,
-0.0094377827,
-0.0140301762,
0.0210467502,
-0.0335195139,
0.006109233,
0.0084560942,
0.0026857967,
0.0401812419,
-0.0090548377,
-0.0291995257,
0.0261063669,
0.0183575954,
0.022280395,
0.0165965818,
0.0293379072,
0.0022212558,
-0.0108352592,
0.021699952,
-0.0095838793,
-0.0109662767,
0.0480824113,
-0.0552692488,
-0.0837742388,
0.0218386948,
-0.0176880173,
-0.0082404455,
-0.0068612616,
-0.0347085223,
-0.0428676903,
0.0626619831,
-0.0349943675,
0.0478905551,
-0.036139749,
0.0270073526,
0.0097463354,
0.0359255485,
0.0250162296,
0.012786299,
-0.0166468862,
-0.0246141516,
0.0252446849,
0.030539386,
-0.0271532927,
-0.0337624513,
-0.0116828522,
0.0059433519,
-0.0046727764,
0.000157436,
0.005586443,
0.0090962993,
-0.0932753533,
-0.0618696027,
-0.1020088419,
-0.0106095858,
0.0252189133,
-0.026225742,
0.0111661768,
0.0114233233,
-0.0132418759,
-0.0090963319,
-0.0360564291,
0.0539660864,
0.0568134151,
-0.0182059314,
-0.0047026221,
-0.0081240702,
-0.0249375161,
-0.0490786284,
0.0070230635,
-0.0109177129,
0.0368481651,
-0.0278646741,
-0.0331138745,
0.0296891183,
0.0457397588,
-0.036184065,
0.0264126472,
-0.0054604881,
-0.07713826,
-0.0004100844,
-0.003286727,
0.0096271513,
0.0753185004,
0.023383094,
0.0804199353,
-0.0228754692,
-0.0569863506,
-0.0639610514,
0.0592114739,
-0.0369879007,
0.0301808696,
-0.0135789262,
-0.0305911731,
-0.0258258395,
0.0495514907,
0.0290058088,
0.042159427,
-0.0722525418,
-0.0176486447,
0.0401782915,
-0.077527687,
-0.0022636433,
-0.0341878198,
-0.022914391,
-0.0154090505,
-0.0430397913,
-0.0390984155,
0.0461883135,
0.0390422493,
-0.0280768722,
-0.0448273234,
0.019247653,
-0.0025901743,
0.0509602167,
-0.0364691615,
0.0376501568,
-0.0074936161,
-0.0355684012,
-0.0378846899,
-0.0154234888,
0.0130675891,
-0.0693156943,
-0.0197155438,
-0.0229595806,
-0.0365985781,
0.024447687,
-0.0096713696,
-0.0312791169,
0.0120941652,
-0.0274010245,
-0.0137932869,
0.0323922485,
-0.0193775911,
0.008922264,
-0.017727606,
0.0339251533,
-0.015420706,
-0.0165871959,
-0.0033953823,
-0.0082025919,
0.030134799,
0.0533618778,
0.0192372892,
0.0055797477,
-0.0423832014,
0.0750390515,
0.0570168346,
0.0502080247,
-0.0243879501,
0.0133631611,
0.0332772434,
0.009255047,
0.046443589,
0.0094598271,
0.0120293992,
0.0185779575,
0.0053130267,
0.0138608739,
0.1059867889,
0.0301936436,
-0.0415068828,
-0.0022311579,
-0.038098719,
0.0378101058,
0.0099685546,
-0.0115592899,
-0.0197926145,
-0.0397099443,
0.0065365811,
0.0267411694,
0.0080330279,
-0.0333973616,
-0.0097196111,
-0.0726732537,
0.0229712687,
0.0215383377,
0.0444309227,
-0.0399607457,
-0.000734227,
-0.0045309179,
0.0122781908,
0.021429766,
-0.0124519281,
0.0273443479,
-0.0034497248,
0.0341596901,
0.0046820058,
0.0071427301,
-0.0186154153,
-0.0084414165,
0.042591732,
0.022218829,
0.0871790349,
0.0272896755,
0.0346081033,
-0.0158964433,
0.0121457977,
0.0080061154,
-0.0036095367,
0.048074808,
-0.0118789515,
-0.0009417853,
-0.0240469221,
0.0403431505,
-0.0271331277,
-0.0152339293,
-0.0092518851,
0.0414492227,
-0.0267198328,
-0.0062677176,
-0.0117718959,
0.0207604002,
0.0110727064,
0.0427809209,
0.0164133944,
-0.0530883372,
-0.0240546633,
0.0137917725,
0.0619278029,
-0.0334776491,
-0.0166154355,
0.0188720021,
0.0099564949,
-0.0289031826,
-0.0687911734,
-0.0594574772,
0.0125017995,
0.0427115113,
-0.0343266055,
-0.0483234487,
0.0194380879,
-0.0025104687,
-0.0540127046,
-0.0246254615,
0.0316292755,
0.0260922313,
-0.0340326503,
0.0322709084,
0.0312987305,
-0.02848983,
0.0153628616,
0.0465241708,
-0.0057387757,
-0.0556422845,
-0.0130438879,
0.0479651429,
0.0126100993,
0.0516297631,
0.0121103637,
-0.0097521758,
-0.0071732951,
0.0560793318,
-0.0479969084,
0.0344190821,
0.0269823801,
0.0328206867,
-0.0170411337,
0.0166846979,
-0.0623541176,
0.0527912043,
-0.0089053567,
0.059980087,
-0.0235711988,
-0.1122678891,
0.0159370806,
0.0257810429,
-0.0029072331,
-0.0050596469,
-0.013481712,
-0.0112614483,
0.0083768042,
-0.0650773942,
0.0164190251,
-0.0531551763,
0.0113177272,
-0.0208633486,
0.020467028,
-0.0179424156,
-0.030312771,
-0.0004826774,
-0.0108478488,
0.0131269814,
-0.0110387858,
-0.0391519405,
-0.0094066169,
0.0141836591,
0.0065472145,
-0.0115804616,
-0.00037604,
-0.0006305322,
-0.0007062041,
0.0105582252,
0.0870130062,
-0.0124837887,
-0.0408829488,
-0.0041675293,
0.0286504626,
-0.0120445909,
0.0471520163,
-0.0518204756,
-0.0128441704,
0.0310572889,
0.0248408839,
0.0867417231,
-0.039245557,
0.0284721088,
-0.0111271637,
0.0393295884,
-0.0031579465,
-0.0668516979,
0.0062566572,
0.0018288884,
-0.0087238569,
-0.0118788285,
0.0319153965,
-0.1150851548,
0.0369248614,
-0.0302155484,
0.0129118906,
-0.0531626828,
-0.0141866775,
0.0634333119,
-0.031694416,
0.0067588445,
0.0146020884,
-0.0681727976,
-0.0396109521,
0.0310527515,
-0.0028280921,
0.0168622043,
-0.0389486291,
0.0416828133,
0.0039300593,
-0.0352700353,
0.0176456496,
-0.0142692626,
0.0221108198,
-0.0946431533,
-0.013086345,
-0.0104784183,
-5.750693219e-33,
-0.0123369237,
-0.00228304,
-0.0350564681,
-0.0108802542,
-0.0405434258,
0.0302194394,
-0.0353224054,
0.0315037295,
-0.0173098613,
0.0303961318,
-0.0127636334,
0.0393854007,
-0.0016734092,
0.0262309648,
-0.0386685245,
0.0249774475,
0.0289862622,
-0.0068267887,
0.0009443302,
0.0740688294,
0.0541796759,
0.0286391824,
0.0106830075,
-0.0837673619,
-0.0480188914,
0.0192664005,
-0.0448676795,
0.0172491558,
0.0994815156,
0.0462976284,
0.0042531798,
0.0299573317,
0.0049911104,
0.0051416159,
-0.0058814641,
0.0054456592,
-0.0425291173,
-0.010642224,
-0.0298973266,
-0.0021423022,
-0.075793989,
-0.0182401761,
-0.0189090911,
0.0232139416,
0.0133130439,
-0.0242556334,
0.0072421073,
-0.0040849694,
0.0023721198,
-0.0752739757,
-0.0220573489,
0.001572035,
-0.0417034477,
-0.0459547415,
-0.0048234258,
0.0538769737,
0.0093911653,
-0.0230477173,
-0.0013554791,
0.0223699454,
-0.0684946924,
-0.0325946622,
0.0185119025,
0.0166477207,
-0.01239416,
0.0954880193,
-0.0206459798,
-0.003510128,
-0.0110579291,
0.0565530322,
-0.0003517886,
0.0757236034,
-0.0007228238,
0.0977049544,
-0.0292613395,
-0.0349886045,
0.0063648322,
0.0712417439,
0.0528886653,
0.0371673182,
0.0245794039,
0.0094616534,
-0.006790204,
-0.0009313448,
-0.0053428211,
0.0117779607,
-0.0241470411,
-0.0430896431,
0.027300762,
0.0020355727,
-0.0101500535,
-0.0739458129,
0.006862056,
-0.0320470333,
0.0209155977,
0.0775080845,
-0.0628005266,
0.0523298085,
-0.0240414683,
0.0015049366,
0.0000863138,
-0.05609525,
0.0785385445,
0.0272985604,
0.0329562686,
0.0102753127,
-0.005040322,
-0.0047378852,
-0.0263910294,
-0.0019006368,
-0.0152779473,
0.0718564466,
-0.0140784681,
-0.0440846346,
-0.0190650243,
-0.0032934754,
-0.028066827,
-0.0039856448,
0.0016580035,
0.0639288574,
-0.0245036781,
-0.0424217097,
0.0316547491,
0.0545975529,
-0.0353042297,
0.007351357,
-0.0136847999,
-0.0656628534,
0.0215967465,
-0.0363382511,
-0.034547545,
0.0209375322,
2.764e-7,
-0.0590577088,
0.0191400368,
0.0514840148,
-0.039497409,
0.0181816481,
0.0672400519,
0.0269665346,
0.0631683543,
0.052974768,
-0.0640930608,
0.062392503,
0.0268791169,
0.0551125295,
0.0049678958,
-0.0711999908,
0.0125876116,
-0.0063584521,
-0.0370176807,
0.0065807882,
0.019432852,
0.1004579291,
0.0168721229,
0.014594065,
0.0038238333,
0.0344338492,
0.0636644587,
0.0242193826,
-0.0269595049,
0.010499767,
0.0043213661,
-0.0364195257,
-0.0677242205,
0.0199257806,
0.013594741,
-0.0119450586,
0.0219562482,
0.0336501561,
0.0353942513,
-0.0120710153,
-0.0808851868,
0.0350611359,
0.0287585575,
-0.0115877436,
-0.0096635036,
0.0282363724,
-0.0812923238,
-0.0341083333,
-0.0095344717,
-0.0357082598,
0.0247595776,
-0.0338708311,
-0.0274348781,
-0.064862527,
0.0318241827,
0.0192818604,
-0.0067411228,
0.0053624283,
-0.0572762974,
-0.0049391561,
0.0105024567,
-0.0466396511,
-0.0651732162,
-0.0034318734,
0.0242423564,
0.0246656835,
0.0013830933,
-0.0075022173,
1.939155633e-34,
-0.0092881164,
-0.0098333675,
0.0225070268,
0.0200586524,
0.0326763354,
-0.0137777654,
-0.0729276091,
0.0213951841,
0.0557211787,
-0.0529826954,
-0.0210194048
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14966v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14966v1 | Walking a Tightrope -- Evaluating Large Language Models in High-Risk Domains | 2023-11-25T08:58:07 | 2023-11-25T08:58:07 | Chia-Chien Hung, Wiem Ben Rim, Lindsay Frost, Lars Bruckner, Carolin Lawrence | cs.CL | cs.CL | High-risk domains pose unique challenges that require language models to
provide accurate and safe responses. Despite the great success of large
language models (LLMs), such as ChatGPT and its variants, their performance in
high-risk domains remains unclear. Our study delves into an in-depth analysis
of the performance of instruction-tuned LLMs, focusing on factual accuracy and
safety adherence. To comprehensively assess the capabilities of LLMs, we
conduct experiments on six NLP datasets including question answering and
summarization tasks within two high-risk domains: legal and medical. Further
qualitative analysis highlights the existing limitations inherent in current
LLMs when evaluating in high-risk domains. This underscores the essential
nature of not only improving LLM capabilities but also prioritizing the
refinement of domain-specific metrics, and embracing a more human-centric
approach to enhance safety and factual reliability. Our findings advance the
field toward the concerns of properly evaluating LLMs in high-risk domains,
aiming to steer the adaptability of LLMs in fulfilling societal obligations and
aligning with forthcoming regulations, such as the EU AI Act. | [
0.0410535932,
0.0456880182,
0.0161454864,
0.005506332,
-0.0506530106,
0.0181388129,
-0.0028353087,
-0.0119800223,
0.0285994299,
-0.0572209843,
-0.0169886928,
-0.0472500324,
-0.0111730602,
0.0014758556,
0.0179827902,
-0.0420944765,
0.0573268905,
-0.0325570293,
0.000627217,
-0.0029378221,
0.0301944651,
0.0193172581,
-0.0110198203,
0.0618767515,
-0.0024516799,
-0.0134230377,
0.0328196697,
-0.0148082236,
0.0214995872,
-0.0225580316,
0.0317164771,
0.0541666895,
0.0144269438,
0.0487438366,
0.0000019444,
-0.0437352508,
0.0336894207,
0.0181526039,
-0.0422893353,
0.0116265677,
0.0317312479,
-0.0162433647,
-0.0074012266,
0.0415945314,
-0.0299774278,
0.0012658729,
0.024847962,
0.02813912,
0.0921057463,
0.0729813874,
0.0082181357,
0.0016871435,
0.0597610436,
-0.0239688549,
-0.0159557667,
-0.0656605735,
0.0358257219,
0.0445392653,
0.0253751948,
0.0012312651,
0.0007868605,
0.0569885746,
0.0300714821,
0.0060266056,
-0.0459106751,
0.0237687156,
-0.0818385184,
-0.0236611348,
-0.009598285,
0.0583961904,
0.0013176529,
-0.0083374241,
-0.0197731573,
0.0130028455,
-0.0078863511,
0.0025858912,
-0.0580441952,
0.0624546856,
-0.012887557,
-0.0004238969,
0.0011525378,
0.0212332401,
0.0200864263,
0.046802979,
0.0200937744,
0.0547827259,
0.00801038,
-0.0312744379,
0.0277601741,
0.0267067682,
-0.0448308699,
-0.0467002243,
0.0158083364,
0.0430203713,
-0.0427955762,
0.0355855711,
-0.0520654321,
-0.0065026535,
0.0886694863,
-0.0797117651,
0.0228249524,
0.012360787,
-0.0052147233,
0.0593430102,
-0.0038988153,
0.0551123172,
0.0160638448,
0.0364319943,
-0.0389849506,
-0.0219903532,
-0.0302460883,
-0.0241408013,
-0.0181095861,
0.0064285821,
-0.0322478488,
-0.0024085848,
-0.0376164243,
0.01077432,
-0.0158133097,
-0.0088475598,
0.0065340269,
0.0143970996,
-0.0204814672,
-0.0118725076,
-0.042715814,
-0.0057039233,
-0.0273502693,
0.01895147,
0.0289904363,
-0.0702663958,
-0.0122538479,
0.0180553664,
-0.0356931165,
-0.0227054078,
0.0144373011,
0.1004872322,
-0.0118796127,
-0.0342170298,
-0.0028790645,
-0.0258239303,
-0.0500653461,
-0.0735356733,
0.000622971,
-0.0652481914,
0.0328293182,
0.0024610683,
-0.0309316833,
-0.0468310714,
0.0240638964,
0.0528158695,
-0.0441344641,
0.0455785319,
-0.0095167868,
0.0145378876,
-0.0017861191,
0.0389459096,
-0.0292341709,
0.0585452132,
0.0423641987,
0.0058895587,
0.0294321962,
0.0098499721,
0.0320293307,
0.0388415158,
0.0108074658,
0.0412298106,
0.0162955318,
0.0331732929,
-0.0042586932,
0.0187032092,
0.0185845811,
0.0911352187,
-0.0128344353,
-0.0241784547,
0.0662712306,
0.0624031983,
-0.0166882221,
0.0025311622,
0.0231426582,
0.001502779,
0.0428915694,
-0.000932642,
-0.0546541102,
0.0042943256,
-0.0390960649,
0.0171553493,
0.0275542997,
0.0332053602,
-0.0272786487,
-0.0386790335,
-0.0353073142,
0.0141573977,
0.0431840867,
0.035049811,
0.0007237915,
-0.0113962526,
-0.0156408977,
0.0342148319,
0.0351883844,
-0.0288152453,
0.0055367127,
-0.06689924,
-0.0253849719,
0.0512700304,
0.0666777715,
-0.0130342152,
-0.0612068512,
-0.0290627368,
0.0340904221,
0.0443775319,
0.0393251106,
0.0008667536,
0.0132969115,
-0.0204004049,
-0.021711709,
0.0172725171,
0.0022104408,
-0.0144694168,
0.0536029339,
-0.003204233,
0.01377487,
-0.0436635092,
-0.0594758615,
0.041352611,
-0.0508480147,
-0.0299353004,
-0.0343313329,
-0.0316386558,
0.0132115055,
-0.006003221,
-0.0105118463,
0.0257785693,
0.0207431838,
-0.010590422,
-0.022436792,
-0.0251535811,
-0.049524717,
-0.0129802423,
0.0430288315,
-0.0419648923,
-0.0330486707,
0.0240907576,
-0.043646168,
-0.0211753044,
-0.0389724188,
-0.0722390562,
-0.023061797,
-0.0383611321,
-0.0155851245,
0.0120627042,
-0.0121102585,
-0.0574293733,
0.06597583,
-0.0099559687,
0.001954847,
0.0045054965,
-0.0170170143,
-0.0011073742,
-0.0217823293,
-0.0313354954,
-0.0041547297,
-0.0130759431,
0.0788310543,
0.0356527492,
0.0391456373,
-0.0492444076,
-0.0209946856,
-0.0846442804,
0.0123499911,
-0.0325013809,
0.0271370225,
0.0324921422,
-0.02041547,
-0.0255426466,
0.0007418824,
-0.0451653413,
-0.0443862602,
0.025595326,
0.0465363301,
0.0169146415,
0.0095142899,
0.0180244222,
-0.0357018076,
-0.016297156,
-0.0252834521,
0.0324264131,
0.0096352138,
-0.0054584946,
-0.0303919837,
0.0565354638,
-0.0281377044,
-0.0023250056,
-0.0006691742,
-0.0232024509,
0.0191153847,
0.0439090803,
0.0331243463,
0.0506415255,
0.0245603528,
0.0094455443,
0.0411215574,
0.0136547023,
-0.044969108,
0.002022411,
-0.0286735222,
-0.0417082794,
-0.0011110234,
-0.0322691724,
0.003868409,
0.0380805917,
0.0071721422,
0.0000720926,
-0.0484729931,
0.013975122,
-0.068480134,
-0.0288070776,
-0.0418967158,
-0.0138291763,
-0.0393790007,
0.0399879366,
-0.0269946735,
-0.0217658505,
0.0774937943,
-0.0073866351,
0.0359622762,
-0.0819644928,
-0.0377387665,
-0.0452097766,
0.0435458012,
0.0018156358,
0.0265447292,
-0.0053654336,
-0.0098505793,
-0.0310206413,
-0.0129357474,
0.0127348201,
-0.0433697142,
0.0834181085,
-0.0615639724,
0.0230796002,
-0.0081120301,
-0.0573693514,
-0.0528524369,
-0.0699097514,
-0.0163911618,
0.0346059129,
-0.0106590027,
0.0149340127,
-0.0578682646,
0.0078344597,
0.0514556244,
0.0167608839,
-0.0294081047,
-0.0159536786,
-0.0147298854,
0.0271292906,
0.0836585388,
0.0037220439,
0.0511870533,
-0.0402844325,
0.0255267136,
0.0894604251,
0.037852861,
0.0117525831,
-0.0139258485,
-0.0091190236,
-0.0001534556,
-0.0393529125,
-0.0033351118,
0.0275210645,
0.0716841072,
-0.0606286116,
-0.0158798043,
0.0881095976,
0.0113149732,
-0.0085720886,
0.0132479388,
0.0089742597,
0.0329456329,
0.0043153237,
0.0061922381,
-0.0471129194,
-0.0342107154,
0.0005254189,
0.0469168648,
-0.020290615,
-0.032103505,
0.006054271,
-0.0805484429,
0.0345569737,
-0.006724352,
-0.0391083695,
-0.0355222486,
-0.038763985,
0.0352060534,
-0.0225944426,
0.0835127458,
0.0101740435,
-0.0392491892,
-0.020334756,
0.0372175761,
-0.0605014637,
-0.026778115,
0.0649993494,
-0.0439491309,
0.0604579523,
0.0770080313,
0.0036514397,
-0.0339134149,
0.0121000996,
0.0427161828,
0.0003069906,
-0.0058477889,
0.0313590467,
0.0655067414,
0.0072955596,
0.011999066,
-0.0592721067,
0.015329292,
-0.0196632855,
-0.0338352211,
0.0075599127,
0.0635227263,
-0.0242111739,
-0.0199136492,
-0.0547693186,
0.0387152061,
-0.020790657,
0.0939303562,
0.0277588945,
-0.0379289836,
-0.0305052884,
-0.0252012853,
-0.0055429433,
-0.0371515676,
-0.0625340864,
0.0299778152,
-0.0046954476,
0.0010419278,
-0.0547338501,
-0.0592462569,
0.0312664993,
-0.0227164142,
-0.0063218768,
0.0001449913,
0.0120716523,
0.0105203176,
-0.0031097664,
0.0606686026,
-0.0449032038,
0.0130735459,
-0.0414636843,
0.025111692,
0.0184001345,
0.0060589272,
-0.0278874673,
0.0275142938,
-0.07672894,
-0.0482334681,
0.0158384908,
0.0444224663,
0.0278585665,
0.0018857537,
-0.0181194264,
-0.0485938974,
0.0518112183,
0.0321455933,
-0.0346798487,
0.0023201799,
0.021430783,
0.0040996647,
-0.0020655848,
0.0249900389,
-0.0440232344,
0.0068686265,
0.0073425416,
0.0539660379,
-0.0207106043,
-0.0559340343,
0.0370098352,
0.0366495363,
0.0016448844,
-0.0032494403,
0.0024031249,
-0.0045493105,
-0.0322766863,
-0.0046257856,
-0.0103947213,
-0.0194198638,
0.0143413777,
0.011922895,
-0.0263742898,
-0.0148557341,
0.0065744305,
-0.0324249119,
0.0225838386,
-0.0657436997,
0.0207208674,
-0.0027683876,
-0.0090264007,
0.0145209394,
-0.0103650689,
-0.0493636876,
0.0074482672,
-0.0326053351,
0.0355074853,
0.0047040856,
0.0360182561,
0.0120027699,
-0.0104056029,
0.0183303878,
0.0406802855,
-0.0837721005,
-0.0500174984,
-0.0426942781,
0.0488817319,
0.0312712863,
0.0128760701,
0.0291101392,
-0.0238411054,
-0.0086532841,
-0.0443264097,
-0.0157261956,
0.0162717421,
-0.0137890717,
0.039591521,
0.0303868931,
-0.0117913634,
0.0008414449,
0.1045780107,
0.0056493487,
0.0431805514,
0.0200385544,
-0.0171957184,
-0.018144181,
-0.0610764958,
-0.0241619162,
-0.0199915916,
-0.0328384489,
-0.0091979802,
-0.0958937928,
-0.0696142316,
-0.0122596249,
0.0048503359,
-0.004404733,
-0.0109581491,
0.029700391,
0.0379275233,
0.0114712836,
-0.01192246,
-0.0314245559,
0.0128049729,
-0.0089825829,
0.0077254781,
-0.0352175608,
-6.316280122e-33,
-0.0029101097,
-0.0141507955,
0.0189588908,
-0.007866702,
-0.0202784687,
0.0167503227,
-0.0187959932,
0.0201143865,
-0.0262052044,
0.0146475155,
-0.0102829784,
0.0159622319,
0.0056419289,
0.0256411601,
-0.0112393303,
-0.0748878345,
-0.0140249971,
-0.0073795277,
-0.0229698829,
0.0186338853,
-0.0062178089,
-0.0067987805,
0.0295890141,
-0.0783068091,
0.0510988124,
0.0075839413,
-0.0035537095,
0.0021295315,
-0.0310473684,
0.083494857,
-0.0087426333,
0.0778051764,
0.0326800309,
-0.0655382574,
-0.0137370871,
0.0354797468,
-0.0475330167,
-0.014937616,
0.0258044191,
-0.0293534491,
-0.0491486266,
-0.0386742651,
0.0451397859,
-0.0176628828,
-0.0230732206,
-0.0341942608,
0.0106727649,
-0.0273280051,
-0.0163256787,
-0.0452553257,
-0.0467912741,
0.0350779109,
0.0099189784,
-0.0422427319,
-0.0119759245,
0.0521596707,
-0.0185012762,
-0.0004654787,
-0.0424957462,
-0.0133777726,
0.0138813257,
0.0034461096,
0.0608162098,
-0.0338476263,
-0.027928371,
0.0831673965,
-0.0159932747,
0.0046750885,
-0.0345365219,
-0.0453168117,
0.0026061877,
0.0363214239,
0.0527511537,
0.0408727862,
-0.0049538771,
0.0277439654,
-0.0827717856,
0.0449676923,
-0.0033333844,
0.0579056479,
0.0302354544,
-0.0180536937,
-0.0786699653,
-0.0229941215,
-0.0423618928,
0.0663492158,
-0.0224964991,
-0.0126425037,
0.0375520512,
-0.0196095295,
-0.0036583859,
-0.0161138829,
0.0028814543,
-0.0472881719,
0.0341410898,
-0.0023917388,
0.0011015023,
0.0068406556,
-0.0008616773,
0.0770111904,
-0.0399968028,
0.0297134295,
0.011994265,
-0.0079578767,
0.0127561968,
-0.0007547585,
0.0456272066,
-0.0054895412,
-0.0462543257,
-0.0011924396,
-0.0204760842,
0.0426584966,
0.0118942065,
0.017301647,
0.0389803648,
0.0233117975,
0.0067741517,
0.031148579,
0.0326777771,
-0.0112640867,
-0.0179562941,
-0.0025962314,
-0.0186895672,
0.004699578,
-0.0240705796,
0.0320587941,
-0.0235603545,
0.0130580543,
-0.0046315975,
-0.0522460453,
-0.0081571443,
0.0283972044,
2.575e-7,
0.0946606249,
0.0708243549,
0.0186205339,
0.0397368148,
-0.0053692795,
0.0372714102,
-0.0036356982,
0.0285914671,
0.0281553827,
-0.0004944666,
0.0011349054,
0.0387224965,
0.0790722668,
0.0600404963,
-0.0520576872,
-0.0250119157,
-0.0871528089,
-0.0095966021,
-0.0419865251,
-0.0031719429,
0.0760403574,
0.0918018818,
-0.0284139644,
-0.0203521494,
-0.0269374214,
-0.0518421866,
0.055172231,
-0.0249829441,
-0.0376159735,
0.0030971619,
0.0518615544,
0.0343165509,
0.0432052501,
0.0529865883,
0.0004337909,
-0.028025968,
0.0281025339,
0.0828784108,
-0.0026313963,
-0.0441476442,
-0.006401123,
-0.0606772192,
0.0356512889,
-0.0574124008,
0.084889859,
-0.0801168084,
-0.0198951364,
-0.0275813006,
-0.0365691744,
-0.0044916002,
0.0410182364,
-0.0193566903,
-0.0429127924,
0.0098460857,
0.022515567,
-0.0026124828,
-0.0155336177,
-0.0484611057,
-0.0210668314,
0.0134098502,
-0.0206478834,
-0.0649407879,
-0.0159726124,
0.0241030045,
0.0026841997,
-0.0905236527,
-0.0074865436,
2.583600437e-34,
0.0385376588,
-0.0280121453,
-0.0008022111,
0.005311796,
0.0349543728,
0.0270535927,
0.0063174106,
0.0095964232,
-0.0077505722,
-0.0626247078,
-0.0112590669
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14949v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14949v1 | Vector-Quantized Prompt Learning for Paraphrase Generation | 2023-11-25T07:13:06 | 2023-11-25T07:13:06 | Haotian Luo, Yixin Liu, Peidong Liu, Xianggen Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Deep generative modeling of natural languages has achieved many successes,
such as producing fluent sentences and translating from one language into
another. However, the development of generative modeling techniques for
paraphrase generation still lags behind largely due to the challenges in
addressing the complex conflicts between expression diversity and semantic
preservation. This paper proposes to generate diverse and high-quality
paraphrases by exploiting the pre-trained models with instance-dependent
prompts. To learn generalizable prompts, we assume that the number of abstract
transforming patterns of paraphrase generation (governed by prompts) is finite
and usually not large. Therefore, we present vector-quantized prompts as the
cues to control the generation of pre-trained models. Extensive experiments
demonstrate that the proposed method achieves new state-of-art results on three
benchmark datasets, including Quora, Wikianswers, and MSCOCO. We will release
all the code upon acceptance. | [
0.0503358841,
0.0709477365,
-0.0070116748,
0.0009082326,
-0.031641271,
-0.018990539,
0.0297903847,
0.0245124567,
-0.0331550911,
-0.0157795418,
0.0210180487,
-0.024351107,
-0.0464366898,
-0.0039411592,
0.0270971023,
-0.0699518695,
0.049139414,
-0.0307047032,
-0.0039416426,
-0.0240429826,
-0.0029170276,
0.0270378087,
-0.0107574882,
0.0543641225,
-0.0197389852,
-0.0365440398,
0.0113763092,
0.0192134399,
0.0252261497,
0.0029346591,
0.0328959078,
0.0336606465,
0.0315016098,
0.0328186788,
0.0000017462,
-0.0380728059,
-0.0512202606,
-0.0259739645,
-0.0099160513,
0.0081180325,
0.0342303403,
-0.0088086985,
0.0142750852,
0.0011209099,
-0.0269230027,
-0.0388919525,
0.0223313309,
0.0123965219,
0.1126897708,
0.0415699594,
-0.0038502214,
-0.028781943,
0.0263005402,
-0.0150334118,
0.018762527,
-0.0348796956,
-0.0106523223,
-0.0378429405,
-0.005346206,
0.023007581,
-0.0345273241,
0.0454938337,
0.0241507422,
-0.0014870361,
0.0176939741,
0.0074780211,
0.0251663141,
-0.0141537059,
-0.0253951326,
0.0899496228,
-0.0314687006,
-0.0070347339,
0.0099934684,
-0.0228636116,
0.026134653,
0.0250234287,
-0.0599972643,
0.0359725468,
0.0068833339,
0.0044732676,
-0.0063123605,
0.031741593,
-0.0178913213,
0.0206570867,
-0.0293742698,
-0.0170762595,
0.0541900694,
-0.0184527598,
-0.0299746264,
-0.0117463563,
-0.0642193034,
-0.0210556407,
0.0012882978,
-0.0005154089,
-0.0689697415,
0.0174540654,
-0.0656509995,
-0.0568855815,
0.0384192131,
0.0249334555,
0.0516990349,
0.018268168,
0.0031675922,
0.0291250292,
-0.0209210161,
0.0661474019,
-0.0495268479,
0.0564825721,
-0.0459653661,
-0.0020849556,
-0.0653657392,
-0.0032228453,
-0.0762643889,
0.0477461591,
-0.0158299822,
-0.0230416395,
-0.0476401113,
0.0252727158,
0.046514187,
-0.004869719,
0.0185358785,
0.0663183406,
-0.0520472601,
-0.0050300485,
-0.001321095,
0.0088752853,
-0.0567372963,
0.0100228703,
0.0337097384,
-0.0579179451,
-0.0301556662,
0.0093672816,
0.0613359809,
-0.053400699,
-0.010187516,
0.0196783338,
-0.0182824545,
-0.0244728532,
0.0340352431,
-0.0307539012,
-0.035395734,
-0.0552682169,
0.0094057648,
-0.0498545058,
0.0599002987,
-0.0117982095,
0.0061145886,
-0.0388774686,
0.0130420011,
0.0363617763,
-0.0214958321,
0.0443538427,
-0.006787315,
-0.0299790762,
-0.004822847,
0.001642142,
0.0204849616,
0.0107205305,
0.0185672194,
0.0140342787,
0.0398422703,
0.0228197444,
0.0326443464,
-0.008060189,
0.040144939,
-0.006216858,
0.0068589612,
0.0358893536,
0.0015059169,
0.0493943095,
0.0247853883,
0.0701439977,
-0.0505027696,
-0.0144729903,
0.0546956174,
0.0405128114,
-0.0184687078,
0.034593232,
0.1015868783,
0.0515279584,
-0.0217701085,
0.0099683767,
-0.0010052779,
0.0210392699,
0.013765417,
0.0425870605,
0.0038004422,
0.0281542111,
-0.0253527071,
-0.0368280299,
0.0182410013,
0.0006413481,
-0.0536634363,
-0.0007831932,
-0.0405069292,
0.0620967187,
-0.0689241216,
0.0851630569,
-0.0246411506,
-0.075740464,
-0.013602077,
-0.0425080135,
0.0479151383,
0.0548180081,
0.0471137054,
0.0096438685,
-0.0010160325,
-0.0445928052,
0.0153731694,
0.0462068357,
0.0382905677,
-0.0076674311,
0.0304874573,
-0.0639101714,
-0.0044858558,
-0.0412726626,
-0.005711501,
-0.0095477141,
0.0155345574,
-0.0125222849,
0.0282470994,
-0.0228806995,
-0.0405716673,
0.0379176252,
0.0010783979,
-0.0554207861,
0.0523768477,
0.0001220303,
-0.0072783055,
0.03241859,
0.0024281654,
0.0299991909,
0.0092531238,
-0.0450140461,
-0.0323168524,
0.0407720245,
-0.0605945811,
-0.0920116752,
-0.0120717399,
-0.0500757359,
-0.0027629116,
-0.0086532496,
-0.0535069779,
-0.0536161661,
-0.0072590532,
-0.0639324561,
0.0123999305,
-0.0638764203,
0.0158848912,
0.012262417,
0.0493347608,
-0.0358331688,
0.0699964091,
0.004854227,
0.0171857607,
0.0654688105,
0.0231729001,
0.0097331395,
-0.0527434461,
-0.0009114564,
-0.0207105391,
0.0083172424,
0.02575697,
0.0226964541,
0.0215642098,
-0.0511176586,
-0.0235540941,
-0.062852785,
0.0226935819,
-0.0159465931,
-0.0348907188,
0.038913019,
0.0227942597,
-0.0013188075,
-0.0269964505,
-0.0342065655,
-0.0099892663,
0.0222807061,
0.0217487197,
0.0581389554,
0.023729207,
0.0045631579,
-0.0526577309,
0.0055403882,
-0.0124008972,
0.0585062206,
0.0140927956,
0.0340660885,
-0.020384945,
0.0004621327,
-0.0209958311,
-0.0041344659,
0.0316566303,
-0.0010444407,
0.0047832443,
-0.0364493355,
0.0668811202,
0.0338360518,
0.0464861467,
-0.0063368152,
0.01058935,
0.0161682088,
-0.0592183731,
0.0231449381,
-0.0329251029,
-0.046739433,
-0.0119711077,
-0.0155165689,
0.0456419513,
0.0231394116,
0.054992307,
-0.0096794218,
-0.0772573277,
0.0706245527,
0.0257408191,
-0.0232653711,
-0.0355567001,
0.0207347143,
-0.0259557441,
0.0327264518,
-0.0158667061,
-0.0045060306,
0.0733414292,
-0.005803036,
-0.0085067712,
-0.0439062603,
0.0212547872,
-0.0283241179,
0.0214347616,
-0.0077484823,
0.0380395129,
0.0082183927,
-0.0036800769,
-0.0633712932,
-0.0246768184,
0.0016412466,
-0.0097591402,
0.0270370077,
-0.0438923053,
0.0026565157,
0.0018474337,
-0.0514244922,
-0.0498800129,
-0.0798900723,
0.0097000645,
-0.0025110187,
0.0041220067,
0.0042494317,
0.0290313754,
-0.0369323865,
-0.0023514989,
0.0270441733,
-0.0354575142,
-0.0188849643,
-0.0571645014,
0.0780847147,
0.0935809687,
0.0467553623,
0.0032027573,
-0.0356875397,
0.0219492745,
-0.0005938158,
0.0158381071,
0.0240346342,
-0.0065647732,
-0.0115418136,
0.0074308319,
-0.0400948972,
-0.0101366639,
0.004599947,
0.0541106686,
-0.0121982135,
-0.0341214873,
0.0834234804,
0.0253999829,
-0.0224384088,
-0.0015924671,
-0.0047064004,
0.0393471494,
-0.0063961423,
0.0285522491,
-0.0836940929,
-0.0265891757,
-0.0422480442,
0.0021437071,
0.0095138149,
-0.0253780782,
-0.0214132126,
-0.08992441,
0.0298838168,
-0.0161638204,
-0.038040407,
0.0008930074,
0.0345150568,
-0.0202190988,
-0.0152369728,
0.0334026515,
0.015439881,
-0.0493048355,
0.0405628569,
-0.0054368293,
0.0086574005,
-0.0274793096,
0.001833787,
-0.0616935082,
0.0161984544,
0.0571245812,
0.0491711199,
0.0250618123,
-0.0282571521,
-0.0377356,
-0.0510138646,
-0.0102832615,
0.0249929689,
0.0440031551,
0.0035777807,
-0.0097272163,
0.0055248397,
0.0246518254,
-0.0128283873,
-0.0205380488,
0.0526553281,
0.0168219209,
-0.0046210815,
-0.0232465602,
-0.0131310727,
0.016176898,
0.0055355453,
0.0921690911,
0.050036598,
-0.0383492261,
-0.047789,
-0.0203654021,
0.0441581607,
-0.1212758049,
-0.0501456112,
-0.0199997462,
0.0077854944,
0.0211731214,
-0.1001462191,
-0.0365636274,
-0.00384926,
0.0451888368,
-0.0076393457,
0.0245768316,
-0.03360717,
0.0225244407,
-0.0150658991,
0.0025824457,
-0.0413665138,
0.0038861681,
-0.0107376967,
-0.0193190407,
0.0452715196,
-0.0495881625,
-0.0268462673,
0.0119531052,
-0.0596913807,
-0.0386656225,
-0.0036243792,
0.0741646364,
0.0148067903,
0.0358128436,
-0.0019490614,
-0.0028397371,
0.1028534546,
0.0380677469,
-0.0199487898,
0.0130096506,
0.0285847746,
0.0284697581,
-0.0361398719,
0.0511006713,
-0.027479196,
-0.000365595,
0.0143189244,
0.068852365,
-0.0367398076,
-0.0576708056,
0.0562259518,
-0.020814091,
0.0087515982,
-0.0360143483,
0.0028764205,
-0.0147182494,
0.0072452016,
0.0115186777,
-0.0087511633,
-0.0320739299,
0.0441593714,
0.035962984,
-0.0101126516,
0.0029597126,
0.0066709882,
-0.0436974652,
0.0488176905,
-0.0218314752,
-0.0405225456,
-0.0027343875,
0.0004072231,
-0.0041081542,
-0.0145135913,
-0.0319592729,
0.0093772588,
-0.0474644788,
0.0148244798,
-0.001775743,
0.0524057932,
0.014848101,
-0.0360028669,
-0.0193796437,
0.0427857041,
-0.0806547925,
-0.0530718304,
-0.0173636805,
0.0486676916,
0.0446125753,
0.0193871874,
0.0516722836,
0.0079420488,
-0.0180864464,
0.0097043822,
0.0537746809,
0.0226047933,
-0.0108470628,
0.0418334231,
0.0136941951,
0.0120174037,
-0.0380535536,
0.0416122749,
0.0053813886,
0.0291025732,
-0.0048330203,
0.0235950779,
-0.0705817714,
-0.028324334,
-0.0148263806,
0.0094224401,
0.0075689028,
0.0065696584,
-0.0260393266,
-0.0269154273,
0.0199935101,
0.0171024408,
-0.0036027587,
-0.014871493,
0.0666737631,
0.0427809805,
-0.0132663939,
-0.0428104736,
-0.0711789951,
0.0415686704,
0.0046165138,
-0.0214448459,
-0.0465886407,
-5.888870743e-33,
-0.0197629984,
0.0278401189,
0.0000219314,
-0.0342307985,
-0.0047624586,
-0.0333868936,
-0.023372991,
-0.0340427421,
-0.0061392705,
-0.0142234163,
-0.0421129987,
-0.0076127998,
0.0161712915,
0.0491141565,
0.0034524605,
-0.0003062769,
0.085435003,
0.0138260247,
-0.0081394613,
0.0304166973,
0.013003028,
0.0424994007,
0.0395398177,
-0.0153689375,
0.0135982754,
-0.0487396382,
-0.0109303622,
0.0031626034,
0.0081676729,
0.0542645268,
-0.0309493896,
0.0454376154,
-0.0022259674,
-0.0295434333,
-0.0187016875,
0.0174154807,
-0.0690037534,
-0.0130187785,
0.0341103598,
-0.0165535118,
-0.0825627968,
-0.0894563422,
-0.0243731383,
-0.0571450517,
0.0334521234,
0.0002399248,
0.0419904366,
-0.0233701486,
0.0052138548,
-0.0403242037,
-0.0399946906,
-0.0250980742,
0.0152210928,
0.0030480418,
-0.0300678033,
0.059842553,
0.0022129018,
0.0310021695,
-0.0195619557,
0.0349426158,
0.0197257232,
0.0380489975,
0.0104370434,
0.0125255892,
0.0019229109,
0.0167603698,
0.0019438571,
-0.056206625,
0.0055937935,
0.0389158875,
-0.0234628431,
0.035118252,
0.0202425662,
0.1143627539,
0.0440652966,
0.0146824596,
-0.0274744574,
0.0133835832,
0.0190193579,
0.0058926581,
0.0354844071,
-0.0271007121,
0.0256782547,
0.0067751026,
-0.0455186963,
-0.0207037833,
-0.0154989241,
-0.0405736305,
0.040149305,
0.040529374,
-0.0735915452,
-0.0065221237,
0.0375579223,
-0.0305136908,
-0.0445271954,
0.0178365763,
-0.0352583304,
-0.0164374132,
0.0115764244,
0.0293407626,
0.0060364003,
-0.0247740392,
0.0494800285,
0.0091531221,
0.0258187149,
0.0255530272,
0.0413006507,
0.0156288799,
-0.0662568584,
0.0221687816,
-0.0347784534,
0.0162432492,
-0.0661433414,
-0.0319583379,
-0.0166827999,
0.0424911156,
-0.0169243142,
0.0178581383,
0.0079925386,
-0.0127661163,
-0.0112086944,
-0.001758157,
0.0075311144,
0.0512992144,
-0.0383939557,
-0.0140786832,
-0.0133037549,
0.048982311,
0.0229891147,
-0.0623878688,
-0.0133651486,
-0.0070457826,
2.451e-7,
0.0107880859,
0.0054144501,
0.0317740552,
-0.002159684,
-0.0196617022,
0.0026660047,
0.0324402973,
0.0596780963,
-0.0259195268,
-0.0151287457,
0.021453144,
0.0335051119,
0.0063554612,
-0.0213367436,
-0.1367179006,
0.0112471478,
-0.0755416304,
0.0381018817,
-0.0621789731,
-0.0181956161,
0.1005311385,
0.1120398343,
-0.018714888,
-0.0234823599,
0.0116471341,
0.0021972863,
0.0717655942,
-0.0023706062,
-0.0207538269,
0.0332124196,
0.031847585,
-0.0176872816,
-0.0024973026,
0.0032669296,
0.0360079855,
0.0153712574,
0.0297039207,
0.0575154386,
0.0407103635,
-0.032811556,
-0.0266329851,
-0.0386502929,
0.0202455334,
-0.0414392091,
0.0592963248,
-0.0776748881,
0.0135199986,
-0.035214752,
-0.0441380367,
0.0420404598,
0.0427823924,
-0.0618803538,
-0.038817104,
0.0065430487,
0.0220334865,
0.020640824,
0.0097124409,
-0.0381321609,
-0.0103234267,
-0.0203636102,
-0.0283012278,
-0.0272342302,
-0.0387091823,
0.0066026556,
0.0241161175,
-0.0601764545,
0.0201667566,
1.983472689e-34,
0.0371363834,
0.0161075629,
0.0174061321,
-0.000501046,
-0.0036698747,
-0.028535556,
0.0004278067,
0.0102937622,
0.0322585814,
-0.040536698,
-0.0423994102
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14919v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14919v1 | Faster Minimum Bayes Risk Decoding with Confidence-based Pruning | 2023-11-25T03:38:14 | 2023-11-25T03:38:14 | Julius Cheng, Andreas Vlachos | cs.CL | cs.CL | Minimum Bayes risk (MBR) decoding outputs the hypothesis with the highest
expected utility over the model distribution for some utility function. It has
been shown to improve accuracy over beam search in conditional language
generation problems and especially neural machine translation, in both human
and automatic evaluations. However, the standard sampling-based algorithm for
MBR is substantially more computationally expensive than beam search, requiring
a large number of samples as well as a quadratic number of calls to the utility
function, limiting its applicability. We describe an algorithm for MBR which
gradually grows the number of samples used to estimate the utility while
pruning hypotheses that are unlikely to have the highest utility according to
confidence estimates obtained with bootstrap sampling. Our method requires
fewer samples and drastically reduces the number of calls to the utility
function compared to standard MBR while being statistically indistinguishable
in terms of accuracy. We demonstrate the effectiveness of our approach in
experiments on three language pairs, using chrF++ and COMET as
utility/evaluation metrics. | [
-0.0351184346,
0.1029817611,
0.0228469558,
-0.0287237801,
-0.0462777019,
0.024836516,
-0.0120140752,
0.0399012342,
-0.0421777293,
0.0165682826,
-0.0102796396,
-0.060856346,
0.0273562633,
0.0142149758,
0.006178569,
-0.0345465951,
0.0133483,
-0.0312524885,
0.0497497842,
-0.0333778225,
-0.0445931703,
-0.0003212322,
-0.0323212892,
0.062375769,
0.0233211275,
0.0196856819,
0.0072636358,
0.0112683317,
0.0399204455,
-0.0307831131,
-0.0266315639,
0.0373527184,
0.0017166144,
0.0483675562,
0.0000021629,
-0.0113013387,
-0.0333986729,
0.0089485859,
-0.0352184884,
-0.0315399282,
0.0707840696,
-0.0230378788,
-0.0119710881,
0.021643091,
-0.0013855367,
-0.0460706577,
0.0820505768,
-0.0008082386,
-0.0122487228,
0.062893942,
0.0120674409,
-0.0077256244,
-0.0034951759,
-0.0384414494,
0.0222883672,
-0.0934023857,
-0.0044584549,
0.0173998997,
0.0002512745,
-0.0157531668,
-0.0180431549,
0.0764279738,
0.0282600783,
0.0316765532,
-0.0288118422,
0.0356291123,
0.0096449917,
-0.0287550185,
-0.005019838,
0.0127304215,
-0.0371700302,
-0.0367316827,
-0.013218536,
-0.0213379562,
-0.0271015875,
0.0082427552,
-0.002224962,
0.0711515099,
-0.047239501,
0.0377685018,
0.0576364323,
0.0227056686,
0.0319241397,
0.0022642906,
-0.0322713479,
0.0927247703,
0.0407492407,
-0.0078254677,
0.0081834011,
0.0420674458,
-0.007537846,
-0.0255521704,
0.0418653563,
-0.0121996189,
-0.0329864323,
0.0265349783,
-0.0649775863,
-0.0216582511,
-0.0113479318,
-0.0122853285,
0.0188192129,
0.0485069118,
0.0500313267,
0.0071597784,
0.0047983951,
-0.0114105931,
-0.0081872493,
-0.0418378264,
-0.015705321,
0.0244075563,
0.0051701819,
0.0056082075,
-0.0240338612,
-0.0013664253,
-0.0705845207,
-0.0152044408,
-0.0369748361,
-0.0217563361,
0.0375824198,
-0.0211842619,
0.0071546603,
-0.0140122576,
-0.1094070449,
0.0190571807,
0.0198347215,
0.0275557209,
-0.0119293025,
-0.0165355615,
0.0249974113,
-0.0791201964,
-0.0181495994,
0.0273581073,
-0.0201517921,
-0.0329359993,
-0.0169157609,
0.0885635838,
-0.0247339346,
-0.0332959779,
-0.0068329559,
-0.0337203443,
-0.0315104909,
-0.0232251063,
0.0172417965,
-0.0768375471,
0.0177970976,
0.0026943001,
-0.0080660228,
-0.0492320955,
0.0055615306,
-0.0128251277,
-0.0140184052,
0.0240958519,
0.0051693581,
-0.0223751012,
0.0393092483,
0.0053493185,
-0.0086222067,
0.1127952784,
0.0268567242,
0.0473170392,
-0.0005680545,
0.0221964661,
-0.0094072772,
0.0402086414,
0.0209922846,
0.0365983509,
-0.0095592951,
-0.0457988307,
-0.0129350061,
0.0452488884,
0.0503877737,
0.021111019,
-0.0897814184,
0.0027992735,
0.0411559232,
-0.0059859096,
0.0371698514,
-0.0370446928,
0.0246759597,
0.0345506743,
-0.0187430121,
0.0142831905,
-0.0014926249,
0.0260745976,
-0.0711335689,
0.0058969883,
0.0335551724,
0.0299782362,
-0.0035420021,
-0.0194253996,
0.0124556608,
-0.0142712705,
-0.018779818,
0.0241624787,
0.0612134822,
0.0111571671,
-0.0343335271,
0.0384793952,
0.0410330296,
-0.0332014747,
0.0193541087,
-0.0320981219,
-0.0063343127,
0.0058474741,
0.0494268835,
0.0072818813,
-0.0106112016,
0.0159515105,
-0.0660080016,
0.0190211888,
0.0248017497,
0.0238653868,
0.0668351501,
-0.0554379299,
-0.0264789201,
0.0125001278,
0.0390524901,
0.0503658168,
0.0118697463,
0.0196787436,
0.0173557047,
-0.0260077119,
-0.0309396423,
0.0261982083,
0.013084163,
-0.026025435,
0.0531906076,
-0.0029952619,
0.0392141119,
-0.0316466391,
-0.0324715041,
0.031189926,
-0.0020918541,
-0.0359121524,
-0.0422980748,
0.0171280913,
-0.0261510573,
-0.1211616248,
0.0102267973,
-0.069089815,
-0.0184564888,
0.0163612813,
-0.0074518472,
-0.0393297412,
0.031945657,
-0.0659377053,
-0.0180322062,
-0.0354976878,
0.0295347665,
0.0011000887,
0.0087976679,
-0.0619757287,
0.0543942228,
-0.0293509681,
-0.0060317623,
-0.0217369385,
-0.0025396443,
0.0239986908,
-0.097176224,
-0.0195366256,
0.0118417302,
-0.0099752359,
-0.0033195943,
0.0565044507,
0.0480104759,
0.0092743542,
-0.0009468388,
-0.0175435413,
0.00786475,
-0.0288473647,
0.0425557718,
0.0292062815,
0.0373419225,
0.0080965133,
-0.0149411345,
-0.0208153427,
-0.018938208,
-0.0118864384,
0.0406252891,
-0.0048128017,
0.0178062674,
0.0242583994,
-0.0003569455,
-0.0508465655,
0.0200967547,
0.0744986236,
0.0265018232,
-0.0169620104,
-0.0702432171,
0.1033563614,
0.0013520526,
-0.012844733,
0.0115423808,
-0.0167306624,
0.0189552791,
-0.0469109006,
0.0397825912,
0.0203378908,
-0.0053523453,
-0.0069338786,
0.0547591746,
0.0211852454,
-0.0548957549,
-0.0220456589,
-0.0504084751,
-0.0085357884,
-0.0054626265,
-0.0956884995,
0.0543193631,
0.0315570608,
0.0275125001,
0.006139731,
-0.089151673,
0.0068949349,
-0.0017767129,
-0.0712328702,
-0.0145678576,
0.0221605971,
-0.0072270646,
0.0704160929,
-0.0051385546,
-0.0271318741,
0.0832475498,
-0.0468349718,
0.0209590737,
-0.0748258084,
0.0228571203,
-0.0162579156,
-0.0163458902,
-0.0149229094,
0.0419808663,
-0.0472621992,
-0.0455682725,
-0.0142439958,
0.0189914256,
0.0344855078,
-0.0163094383,
-0.0149142118,
-0.0612472296,
-0.0011198728,
-0.0080115274,
-0.030357454,
-0.027117392,
-0.0090301326,
0.0014872025,
-0.0208025966,
0.0355238728,
-0.0107696075,
0.0027040986,
0.0147104263,
0.0043666824,
0.0185313486,
-0.0161576048,
-0.0092951022,
-0.0099036293,
0.0470139794,
0.0458274037,
-0.0333297774,
0.0675030723,
-0.0414649174,
-0.0314759873,
0.0427920409,
0.0622488484,
0.0661993921,
-0.0385419913,
-0.0000475865,
0.053417515,
0.0233354084,
-0.0278069694,
0.0334908776,
0.0505212508,
-0.0263157301,
-0.0074578184,
0.0763927847,
-0.0065795281,
-0.0640102848,
0.0089262249,
-0.0033543373,
0.0467266552,
-0.0215358213,
0.0354888625,
-0.0645014718,
-0.0284434333,
0.0243189838,
0.060990531,
-0.0152555453,
-0.0321900621,
-0.0096390583,
-0.0922171697,
0.0159957353,
0.0165755805,
-0.0074080341,
-0.0208515134,
-0.0098857153,
-0.0248996764,
-0.052740369,
0.015291403,
0.0376415886,
0.025533352,
0.0242123082,
0.0187561773,
0.0050734337,
-0.1023064479,
-0.0387725644,
-0.0435938165,
0.0454706028,
0.0832369253,
0.0171724521,
0.0036252332,
-0.0094705112,
-0.0160935111,
-0.0309305266,
0.0087071024,
-0.0212367158,
0.0286413506,
0.0301820841,
-0.0000715553,
0.0191841293,
0.0078662522,
-0.0062974277,
0.0218021441,
0.0157032367,
0.0276730601,
-0.0664046779,
-0.0003554971,
0.022897372,
0.0267790724,
0.0568557531,
0.0464223251,
0.037601769,
-0.0166717451,
-0.0148891974,
-0.0457040519,
0.0253102779,
-0.0834257528,
0.0112777296,
0.0406449772,
0.0123859122,
-0.109758012,
-0.065163523,
-0.0032347147,
0.0194741953,
0.0608306825,
-0.0310048908,
-0.018348502,
-0.0136594633,
0.0073797852,
-0.0346449874,
0.0181916244,
-0.0240843948,
-0.015433142,
-0.0362411179,
0.0286150891,
-0.0197577272,
-0.0714967698,
-0.0115170376,
0.0546172559,
-0.0713550374,
-0.0745684728,
-0.0244570617,
0.0469890311,
0.0275934562,
-0.0001556279,
-0.0193433091,
-0.0673017725,
0.0145965945,
0.0281880554,
-0.0358519778,
0.0103337588,
0.0277130231,
-0.0338422023,
-0.0199098494,
0.027608376,
-0.0118349707,
-0.0084323157,
-0.0104397517,
0.0719505623,
-0.0168337561,
-0.0142684095,
0.0417572968,
0.0293899123,
0.0196457561,
-0.0989353135,
-0.0198072176,
-0.0283762552,
-0.0117113134,
0.0141392322,
0.0314574242,
-0.0187873691,
0.0293109622,
0.0303660538,
0.0092711216,
0.0129258139,
0.0043016607,
0.0098734032,
0.0022393938,
-0.0048838188,
0.0410139859,
0.0272687133,
0.0256847031,
0.0708073452,
-0.0163817424,
0.003861086,
0.0122978585,
0.010769221,
0.0076042092,
-0.0169215146,
0.0183325391,
0.047253184,
0.005527705,
0.0115257269,
0.004871083,
-0.043144539,
-0.0632633418,
-0.0042138523,
0.0013410707,
0.041530747,
0.049409572,
0.0911426842,
-0.0522442684,
-0.0124770645,
-0.041415751,
0.034610752,
0.0188233983,
-0.0418629348,
0.0240392741,
0.00316075,
-0.0019290288,
-0.0020956616,
0.0863571241,
-0.0147467656,
0.0321874358,
-0.0504813604,
-0.010847793,
-0.0383957177,
-0.0498870462,
-0.0440627746,
0.0194884948,
-0.0263995286,
-0.0256487373,
-0.0560099259,
-0.0290821996,
-0.017678868,
0.0254029538,
0.0243141912,
-0.0009856663,
0.0412661657,
0.0414111055,
-0.0384011865,
0.0365096368,
-0.0322228596,
0.0053261248,
-0.0375404507,
-0.0077413023,
-0.0475684144,
-6.936681796e-33,
-0.0029576248,
-0.0275139604,
0.0025288817,
-0.0454297774,
0.0182381794,
0.0020080809,
-0.0522501953,
-0.0098410379,
0.0269781332,
-0.0036059541,
0.0182351116,
-0.0169580095,
0.0280307066,
0.0107687972,
-0.0059335707,
0.0305243693,
0.0616197363,
0.0072354479,
-0.0518241338,
0.0217916276,
0.0315910466,
0.0376007855,
0.0412263647,
-0.0272666365,
-0.0345465653,
0.0469967872,
-0.0367423408,
-0.0108201876,
-0.0278770365,
0.0292832628,
-0.001360178,
0.0317427367,
-0.0174745824,
-0.0765176713,
-0.0129854977,
-0.0557748228,
-0.0483414717,
0.0014462634,
-0.0252126325,
0.0201301221,
-0.0286013652,
-0.0314689837,
-0.0189036094,
-0.0085011749,
-0.0444340035,
0.002768097,
-0.02412083,
-0.0430043004,
-0.0412557721,
-0.0781331137,
-0.0036924656,
0.0555874296,
0.0184400603,
0.006539383,
0.0482651703,
0.0475947112,
-0.0517712012,
-0.0167933572,
0.0033854586,
0.0449396893,
0.0505603328,
0.0536312386,
0.0719955117,
0.011669076,
-0.0210258439,
0.0280392654,
0.0445297845,
-0.0595004633,
0.0379388742,
0.0060865451,
0.0509456992,
-0.0147070233,
0.0115084127,
0.0623783246,
0.0688756853,
0.0010367498,
-0.0505260825,
0.0369094498,
0.0651683584,
-0.0085017104,
0.0328894556,
0.0340035446,
-0.0526337549,
-0.0351946242,
-0.0670096278,
-0.0576685779,
-0.0371171124,
-0.0200593006,
0.0063433843,
0.0271158963,
-0.0466775112,
-0.0060417345,
0.0795212314,
-0.0104472823,
0.0380028076,
0.0233850721,
-0.0215548892,
-0.0034989221,
-0.0179223549,
0.0421178713,
-0.0011920249,
0.0037967269,
0.0475120507,
-0.028915599,
0.0012709938,
-0.0124485986,
0.0000173696,
0.0103706662,
-0.0189223737,
0.0161425304,
-0.0542850159,
0.0368794613,
0.0539171137,
0.0422581583,
0.0558818504,
-0.0423899926,
-0.000877101,
0.0156870577,
0.0141692935,
0.0145004494,
-0.0276507344,
0.0204062834,
0.0074591204,
0.0501827337,
-0.0273055341,
0.0198000204,
-0.0149457734,
0.0090391599,
0.0385683216,
-0.0428837799,
-0.0548630282,
0.0446701124,
2.894e-7,
0.056122385,
0.0267265365,
0.0339523815,
0.0203609262,
0.0076776994,
0.027164083,
0.0011237519,
-0.0167106185,
-0.0104968986,
0.0386698991,
-0.0103117907,
-0.0025846132,
0.0796311125,
0.0397189036,
-0.0644599646,
-0.0349874236,
-0.0278727673,
0.0040701726,
-0.0222087596,
-0.0459503159,
0.0287837777,
0.0592048727,
-0.045641046,
-0.0400121249,
0.0346469432,
0.024702888,
0.0233414341,
0.0019942541,
-0.0251795724,
-0.0001774484,
-0.0279469993,
0.0152132465,
0.0006111813,
0.00346254,
-0.0151032731,
-0.046281226,
-0.0037093007,
0.035787981,
0.0450778119,
-0.066037178,
0.0431067273,
0.0430012047,
-0.025150016,
0.0043517505,
0.0210244711,
-0.0418429747,
-0.0120180948,
0.0118847778,
-0.0106830448,
0.0089889402,
-0.0193326641,
-0.0352009311,
0.0069160927,
-0.0028554713,
-0.0151623543,
0.0164850689,
-0.0048891068,
-0.007655459,
0.005632665,
0.017674474,
-0.0383687392,
-0.0390984267,
-0.020037517,
0.008525731,
0.0332730934,
-0.1018755883,
-0.0230796188,
3.059772306e-34,
0.0320835486,
0.0145706441,
-0.0051288367,
-0.0158664733,
0.0303847212,
-0.0168914758,
-0.0009808617,
0.0266823079,
0.0175750311,
-0.0450666733,
-0.0448162109
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14901v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14901v2 | Code Search Debiasing:Improve Search Results beyond Overall Ranking Performance | 2023-11-25T02:31:22 | 2024-02-17T01:22:24 | Sheng Zhang, Hui Li, Yanlin Wang, Zhao Wei, Yong Xiu, Juhong Wang, Rongong Ji | cs.CL | cs.CL | Code search engine is an essential tool in software development. Many code
search methods have sprung up, focusing on the overall ranking performance of
code search. In this paper, we study code search from another perspective by
analyzing the bias of code search models. Biased code search engines provide
poor user experience, even though they show promising overall performance. Due
to different development conventions (e.g., prefer long queries or
abbreviations), some programmers will find the engine useful, while others may
find it hard to get desirable search results. To mitigate biases, we develop a
general debiasing framework that employs reranking to calibrate search results.
It can be easily plugged into existing engines and handle new code search
biases discovered in the future. Experiments show that our framework can
effectively reduce biases. Meanwhile, the overall ranking performance of code
search gets improved after debiasing. | [
0.0313303098,
0.0485234782,
-0.0341927856,
-0.001217456,
0.0234828219,
-0.0390673652,
-0.0013085093,
-0.0034087608,
0.0303931944,
-0.0279815979,
-0.0202922933,
0.0688594431,
0.0059112175,
0.0070884512,
-0.0141468309,
-0.0404061005,
0.0053127483,
0.0224337298,
0.0227620881,
-0.0028842355,
0.0293008462,
-0.0100497771,
-0.0080525465,
0.0500383638,
0.0559486933,
0.0063232766,
0.0348080359,
0.0428878255,
-0.0292783752,
-0.035164237,
0.0252194926,
0.0279758871,
-0.0478942282,
0.0289233848,
0.0000018656,
-0.0294372961,
-0.029018186,
-0.031981647,
0.0033937562,
0.0362104885,
0.0196568556,
0.0616953671,
0.0573781058,
0.03267847,
-0.039388746,
0.0084114438,
0.0358433761,
-0.0468471125,
0.0044225804,
0.0072784531,
0.0390158519,
0.0326487161,
-0.0583643652,
-0.0147943012,
0.0470977575,
-0.0432451144,
-0.0055200998,
-0.0012727358,
0.0140124569,
0.0478750691,
-0.006403164,
0.0173770133,
-0.0350996293,
-0.0019781063,
0.0885106847,
0.0286837071,
-0.0683687851,
-0.0229351949,
0.0390583873,
0.0277135763,
-0.0389502458,
-0.0402948335,
0.0107340487,
-0.0187511966,
0.006606983,
0.0138083957,
-0.0294956472,
-0.0195917245,
-0.0012952723,
-0.0292513147,
-0.0227190182,
0.0314616002,
0.0207263678,
0.0089740735,
-0.0123005696,
0.0343522504,
0.0061591342,
-0.0157212671,
0.0039308434,
-0.003193086,
0.0533446446,
-0.0272835437,
-0.004152555,
0.0022881203,
-0.0332330801,
0.0089915367,
0.0381815247,
0.0127538452,
0.0401006788,
-0.0142803183,
-0.0723108724,
0.0100851525,
-0.0027680804,
-0.0209401939,
-0.0233900193,
0.0214738268,
0.003054939,
-0.0255092531,
-0.0020034364,
0.0096866004,
-0.0201611407,
-0.0157918055,
-0.0141235292,
0.0148676252,
0.0140338782,
0.0351796187,
-0.0381019115,
0.0263482817,
-0.0063449428,
-0.0191201437,
0.0086063948,
0.0380913131,
-0.0262167584,
0.0411433801,
-0.0087592434,
-0.0226097796,
-0.0498326868,
-0.0032634784,
-0.0230525974,
-0.0535833389,
-0.0006954962,
-0.0187145956,
-0.0301730018,
-0.0308742039,
0.011286445,
-0.0041573723,
0.0767472386,
0.004754304,
0.0067887479,
-0.0256560352,
0.0400129668,
0.0686123371,
-0.0569636077,
-0.0531426035,
-0.0435912944,
0.0166971069,
0.0224256516,
-0.0418587737,
-0.0403840728,
-0.0115666604,
-0.0224431343,
0.0301681422,
-0.0265620574,
0.0311357565,
0.0584917255,
0.0440535918,
0.0025687276,
0.0382722579,
-0.0358588509,
0.0306721274,
0.0742243081,
-0.0140618449,
0.0653153211,
-0.0034290925,
-0.0110750897,
-0.019730892,
0.0451526754,
0.0612293184,
-0.023971729,
-0.0052523613,
0.0136088971,
-0.0077952179,
-0.0342356376,
-0.0117935939,
-0.0033482339,
0.0048219562,
0.0429118983,
-0.0047772299,
0.0077716988,
0.0239269622,
-0.0424599275,
-0.0280306358,
-0.037537612,
0.0363399461,
0.0045813955,
0.013853576,
0.0219753943,
0.0055912044,
-0.0187081024,
-0.0271108542,
0.0020072996,
0.046371799,
-0.0305236336,
0.0265586488,
-0.0002517451,
0.0013119134,
-0.0100879641,
0.0206739977,
0.013747667,
-0.0333804525,
-0.0215441156,
-0.0396002419,
-0.0080176694,
0.0568003282,
0.0515030809,
-0.0813689083,
0.0080725141,
0.0199161619,
-0.0310017802,
-0.0478277095,
0.0495379902,
-0.0159909446,
0.0302069616,
-0.0334721059,
-0.0665182695,
0.0004959056,
0.0127272867,
0.045017045,
0.0325331911,
0.0100385528,
0.0213407893,
-0.0654546693,
-0.0384671912,
0.0105785625,
0.0563333556,
-0.0164379179,
0.015204804,
-0.0020070102,
-0.0347301438,
-0.0148621723,
-0.0058539216,
0.0093527623,
0.014692056,
0.0370053053,
-0.0154205812,
-0.0605906397,
0.0311936531,
0.0204494372,
-0.0218947623,
-0.1042147726,
0.0129629942,
0.0376857594,
-0.0184483808,
0.0390266553,
0.0418505892,
-0.0005565226,
0.0299223661,
0.0650222078,
0.0131617347,
-0.0720505491,
-0.0470405668,
-0.0489801429,
0.056262631,
0.0347676985,
0.0418654494,
0.0170121379,
0.0268830862,
-0.009847098,
-0.0371953361,
-0.0278244857,
-0.0101982625,
-0.0197168235,
0.0080432361,
0.0519126579,
0.0009514866,
-0.0195489954,
-0.00311421,
-0.1054721624,
0.0038037901,
0.0079881744,
0.0249723885,
-0.0146748004,
0.0627054349,
0.0075752912,
-0.0235715695,
-0.0213934779,
-0.1075015813,
-0.0517259575,
0.0169551689,
0.0020842131,
-0.0068030003,
-0.025077777,
-0.0658121929,
-0.0566002987,
-0.0252534077,
0.0403296798,
0.0234917738,
0.0145521779,
-0.0549021736,
0.0862003118,
-0.0207575727,
-0.0197852887,
-0.0309202392,
-0.0013913169,
-0.0078149606,
0.0170331746,
0.0009250455,
0.0626316369,
0.0092221573,
0.0008576941,
0.0385935865,
0.026988145,
-0.0842625871,
-0.0314664096,
0.020508457,
0.0010738624,
0.022590464,
-0.0850609764,
0.061800845,
0.0202812944,
-0.0064231139,
-0.0158414897,
-0.0116762826,
0.0160764102,
-0.0122467699,
0.0058342731,
-0.0198030621,
-0.0085477121,
0.0183901023,
0.0436437316,
0.0055986135,
-0.0884557664,
0.0446700342,
-0.0016837794,
0.024494743,
-0.0567140244,
0.0201304629,
-0.0234325286,
-0.0024403634,
-0.0292144958,
0.0143539533,
-0.0154316276,
-0.0156777781,
-0.0454604775,
0.0153166633,
0.0533882789,
-0.0672248006,
0.0297740623,
0.0264807492,
-0.0134021044,
0.0243929289,
-0.0323785953,
-0.0097963065,
-0.0546859801,
0.0042619118,
-0.0298993103,
0.0848639458,
0.0136877988,
0.014313845,
0.0278720949,
0.0185709186,
0.0407094136,
0.0134167187,
-0.0530479774,
0.0089574456,
-0.0218044482,
-0.0272837281,
-0.0826097578,
0.0297491979,
0.0058236434,
-0.0269571692,
-0.0071849991,
0.1017413959,
-0.0014393281,
-0.0177366268,
-0.0451524854,
0.0090067852,
-0.0568202138,
-0.0195324942,
0.030032916,
-0.0267877039,
0.0090396684,
0.0190990251,
0.036740534,
0.0437453426,
-0.0868156999,
0.0127906315,
-0.0075689168,
0.0594288446,
0.1059022471,
0.0163792707,
-0.0595205911,
0.0004545328,
0.0172158647,
0.0777487084,
-0.0573561378,
-0.022473963,
0.0165478941,
-0.066931501,
-0.0232764762,
-0.0279483441,
0.0489340909,
-0.0056276657,
-0.0569214039,
0.0083158361,
-0.0368633233,
-0.0670759603,
0.0564744771,
-0.0243122987,
0.0575673394,
0.0141089214,
-0.030699417,
-0.0175406206,
0.0197385401,
-0.0628010556,
-0.015834691,
0.0713231638,
0.0136243813,
-0.0062274658,
0.0455115698,
-0.0088148629,
-0.0442016199,
-0.0234391484,
-0.0184608363,
0.0544766374,
-0.0511132218,
0.0089820921,
0.0018858319,
-0.0398594774,
0.0071008541,
0.0674604848,
0.049761869,
-0.02896774,
0.0064444146,
0.0089200232,
-0.0565068461,
-0.0272310916,
-0.034713719,
0.0335032158,
0.0490835793,
0.0226930138,
0.0117408708,
-0.0802611783,
0.0196322687,
0.0368838646,
-0.0234207213,
-0.0294063669,
-0.0370854773,
0.0315034203,
-0.0386928208,
0.0286563449,
-0.0160484277,
0.0463590398,
0.0149297751,
0.0140087381,
-0.0505230315,
-0.0022419177,
-0.0419809744,
0.0084681632,
-0.0054785837,
0.0303013995,
0.0124791628,
0.0004384158,
-0.0008950502,
-0.036446996,
-0.0421589054,
-0.003385477,
-0.0055752485,
-0.0092126345,
-0.0458974801,
0.0483247377,
0.0308458507,
0.0130796256,
-0.0644302666,
-0.0692376569,
-0.0283727665,
0.0277901012,
-0.0206168219,
-0.0011398587,
-0.0212380718,
-0.0402176864,
0.027011903,
-0.033027444,
-0.1026554331,
-0.0026920261,
-0.0084162792,
-0.022626929,
-0.0087145576,
-0.0158848502,
-0.0033419582,
0.007234273,
0.0541242138,
0.0453960747,
0.0210803356,
0.0062962901,
0.019241415,
-0.0092386343,
-0.0261296555,
0.0230670869,
0.0683903024,
0.0211977605,
0.040875081,
-0.0120478524,
0.0550237373,
-0.0158955101,
0.0224212725,
-0.0506775901,
0.0688962117,
0.0031690646,
0.0003837565,
0.0357193872,
-0.0028779819,
-0.0081022019,
0.0033191557,
0.0197498295,
0.0564136021,
0.0037778863,
-0.0546431355,
0.0141159613,
0.0200289506,
0.0132238325,
-0.004868445,
-0.1016999856,
-0.0494150035,
0.0012331416,
-0.0534092337,
-0.0147501891,
0.0347431302,
-0.0018134972,
0.0544576272,
0.0355333239,
0.0084090764,
-0.0199371912,
0.0052187075,
0.0037795918,
0.0042515406,
0.0250343233,
-0.0121472133,
-0.0151149891,
0.0881313384,
0.0093228035,
-0.0170744136,
-0.0944381803,
-0.0656773672,
0.0058147712,
0.0196082648,
0.0748499557,
0.0470816046,
-0.0342365503,
-0.0734823719,
-0.0330740809,
-0.03494763,
-0.0275819618,
0.0101357242,
0.0892026275,
-0.0158107225,
0.0571144819,
0.108814925,
-0.0105210599,
-0.0270121526,
-0.0023756125,
-0.0371639468,
-0.0438472927,
-0.0078773387,
-0.0078128222,
-5.388164884e-33,
0.0208619796,
-0.0096788546,
-0.0423914157,
-0.0233050119,
0.0198466722,
-0.0002937451,
0.0234974157,
0.0065553375,
-0.0283225961,
-0.049185589,
0.0076341205,
0.0626980662,
-0.0017103936,
-0.0678271875,
0.0594122857,
0.0265408698,
0.0468834117,
0.0314332992,
-0.0751523748,
0.0365037881,
-0.0648415461,
0.02171419,
-0.0212983917,
-0.0113920672,
-0.0093629742,
-0.027135862,
0.0292032715,
-0.001100325,
0.0634669587,
0.0546593219,
0.0414441638,
0.0063558128,
-0.0009646374,
-0.0218536612,
-0.0146070188,
-0.0558773428,
0.0084547438,
-0.0093158642,
0.0450594723,
-0.0203778464,
0.0386780947,
-0.005519615,
0.0724807754,
0.0314735733,
-0.0383181162,
0.0298011582,
0.0513399802,
0.014965279,
-0.0053642495,
-0.0409865342,
0.0086907251,
0.0348488353,
-0.0594089143,
0.0350901,
0.002234187,
0.0418377109,
0.0032547996,
0.0898117945,
0.0730637982,
-0.0050809444,
-0.0205644015,
0.0626558959,
0.0535611659,
0.0180547647,
-0.0322864167,
0.0142633021,
0.0534322932,
0.0158410743,
0.0191432852,
-0.0716688633,
0.0230768975,
-0.0031567491,
0.0185849145,
0.0415372811,
0.0334004946,
-0.0104467748,
0.0099441446,
0.0309989285,
-0.0035329191,
-0.0092801563,
0.0391066521,
0.0358016267,
-0.0922443867,
-0.0192308798,
-0.0058614835,
-0.030419115,
-0.0483389348,
-0.026384607,
0.039723292,
0.0206963476,
0.0037898431,
0.000717276,
-0.0269217379,
-0.0363945477,
-0.0082369624,
0.0475416891,
-0.0251020659,
0.0022553867,
-0.0148619218,
-0.0135279233,
-0.0076523619,
0.0308777075,
-0.0112113403,
0.0228724293,
0.0244273562,
-0.0219629519,
-0.0462020822,
-0.055761274,
-0.0685967207,
-0.0359519571,
0.0095726289,
-0.0359808952,
-0.0358089097,
0.0163003635,
0.0037461296,
0.024668321,
0.0330489092,
-0.0281814672,
0.0515200533,
0.0248977859,
-0.0731858611,
-0.0142391454,
0.0001614609,
-0.0052532903,
-0.0025444441,
-0.0509379208,
-0.0017934198,
0.0269587878,
-0.0144406725,
-0.040713679,
-0.0848217234,
-0.018632153,
2.555e-7,
0.0128532108,
0.050581567,
-0.0340780355,
0.0540096685,
0.0171842184,
0.0035894518,
0.0219211355,
0.0427090302,
0.032602001,
-0.0242119301,
-0.0312578455,
0.0001331434,
-0.0010754307,
0.0066324617,
-0.0348118655,
-0.0255385991,
-0.0075882026,
0.0073362952,
-0.0297791697,
-0.0142065417,
0.0031418919,
0.0408933535,
0.0043853535,
0.0441000722,
0.005868366,
-0.0250166841,
-0.0267852042,
0.0018945556,
0.0822155178,
0.0746820047,
0.0244165547,
0.0212483983,
0.0052595451,
-0.0219077319,
0.0137712723,
0.0038152754,
0.0536250509,
-0.0034216382,
-0.0138554359,
0.0387598202,
0.0230317265,
-0.0253569707,
-0.0032996223,
-0.116307348,
0.0179231167,
0.0471989401,
0.0293747205,
-0.0147202769,
-0.0203445423,
-0.0362063721,
0.0205750186,
-0.0062174005,
-0.0167764854,
-0.0047035832,
-0.024334291,
-0.0183602702,
-0.0409701131,
-0.0469454899,
-0.0448551252,
-0.0162634943,
-0.0257540271,
-0.0802786425,
-0.0309201125,
0.0299349762,
0.0071805003,
0.0265597664,
0.0451045148,
2.096848201e-34,
0.0462653004,
-0.0018854677,
-0.0002247472,
-0.0056415731,
0.0567431524,
-0.0116511798,
-0.0527271405,
-0.0300345495,
0.0023309463,
0.0058795772,
-0.0259734467
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14871v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14871v1 | Tracing Influence at Scale: A Contrastive Learning Approach to Linking Public Comments and Regulator Responses | 2023-11-24T23:32:13 | 2023-11-24T23:32:13 | Linzi Xing, Brad Hackinen, Giuseppe Carenini | cs.CL | cs.CL | U.S. Federal Regulators receive over one million comment letters each year
from businesses, interest groups, and members of the public, all advocating for
changes to proposed regulations. These comments are believed to have
wide-ranging impacts on public policy. However, measuring the impact of
specific comments is challenging because regulators are required to respond to
comments but they do not have to specify which comments they are addressing. In
this paper, we propose a simple yet effective solution to this problem by using
an iterative contrastive method to train a neural model aiming for matching
text from public comments to responses written by regulators. We demonstrate
that our proposal substantially outperforms a set of selected text-matching
baselines on a human-annotated test set. Furthermore, it delivers performance
comparable to the most advanced gigantic language model (i.e., GPT-4), and is
more cost-effective when handling comments and regulator responses matching in
larger scale. | [
0.0510162078,
0.116202563,
0.0030037761,
0.0187372323,
-0.0386357382,
0.010065482,
-0.0131077934,
0.0434652306,
-0.0054310728,
-0.0599416718,
0.0249127001,
-0.0703658611,
-0.0215576515,
0.0081521822,
0.007017287,
-0.0726042688,
0.0048276167,
0.0357533582,
0.0131353298,
0.0357367992,
0.0397639126,
0.0194037482,
0.012736991,
0.0552505143,
-0.0084383851,
-0.0152194118,
0.0149708958,
-0.0037192518,
0.0498753935,
-0.0381894633,
0.0651879534,
0.0259473082,
0.0144075332,
0.0795849338,
0.0000015818,
-0.0259236097,
-0.0322464071,
0.0122867152,
0.0400293171,
0.0320978835,
0.0694756806,
-0.0545098297,
-0.0154543044,
0.0716624707,
-0.0394918472,
-0.0267721191,
0.0384928957,
0.0372046046,
0.0572456084,
0.0873093829,
-0.0248424467,
-0.0803728104,
0.0066017099,
-0.046707958,
-0.0174316578,
-0.0179408249,
0.0540048331,
-0.0219557509,
-0.0729099512,
0.0053120274,
0.0196859594,
0.0092949728,
-0.0022511475,
-0.0109914467,
-0.0029963171,
0.020669261,
0.035768196,
0.0432020947,
-0.0133374631,
0.0976279303,
0.032994628,
-0.0101357801,
0.0367021076,
-0.0380673744,
-0.000206048,
0.042339433,
-0.0291729458,
-0.0003959658,
-0.0132971816,
0.0301635731,
0.0258044042,
0.0087192459,
0.0219224244,
0.0131947966,
0.0035662262,
-0.0358843952,
0.0052392939,
-0.0540854782,
-0.0028789686,
0.0124721061,
0.0293128472,
-0.0537227206,
0.0250954106,
-0.0148600917,
-0.0286521222,
0.0218283553,
-0.0082859062,
-0.0402587689,
0.040736828,
-0.0533285923,
0.030959744,
0.0134612015,
-0.0190770198,
0.063424997,
-0.009226365,
-0.0043005846,
-0.035723649,
-0.0119845802,
-0.0226408131,
-0.0204507858,
-0.0652286932,
0.00731477,
0.0071088448,
0.0218185168,
-0.0959326401,
-0.0077427886,
-0.0116880778,
-0.0111274365,
-0.044021491,
0.0048693977,
0.0021072996,
0.0140251787,
0.0242937133,
-0.0149233621,
-0.0454111286,
0.054392837,
-0.0381677449,
0.0358463265,
-0.0291800629,
0.0373364426,
0.0011580822,
0.0339422859,
0.0108540673,
-0.0043966905,
-0.0084113656,
0.0806861818,
0.0235838294,
-0.0185045656,
-0.0131614637,
0.0088710049,
-0.0000943782,
-0.0269296058,
0.0034755738,
-0.0339245349,
-0.0085069481,
-0.0542234667,
-0.0117335832,
-0.0346776284,
-0.0147509016,
-0.0022466665,
-0.027072778,
0.0677484572,
0.0125184488,
-0.0415474921,
-0.0015385961,
0.0007659094,
0.0126883136,
0.0094161294,
0.0063988101,
-0.0023149545,
-0.0007743125,
-0.0105601242,
-0.0012127388,
0.0062537109,
0.0597999804,
0.0083482284,
-0.0072099315,
0.0240500998,
-0.0118353013,
0.007015028,
0.023276208,
0.0644440502,
-0.0142325619,
-0.0316264369,
0.069667235,
0.0627771169,
-0.0013486906,
0.0453967564,
-0.0072888918,
0.0623891465,
-0.0374442488,
-0.011375119,
0.0112486435,
0.0109222746,
-0.043176014,
-0.0184930079,
0.0516019724,
0.004349587,
-0.0702388585,
-0.02392672,
0.0030263166,
0.0272198394,
0.0350437872,
-0.0009500962,
0.0548156537,
-0.0157671701,
-0.0777542442,
0.0178338196,
0.0414868966,
-0.0017428633,
-0.0281096194,
-0.0516224466,
0.0157282259,
0.0598836951,
0.0109643852,
-0.0035470689,
0.0236392878,
-0.0596616827,
0.0610051565,
0.0756158605,
0.0417941734,
-0.0291292351,
-0.0154649634,
-0.028236961,
-0.0178504176,
-0.0153396111,
0.0250658765,
0.0729432479,
0.0060801664,
-0.0151123796,
0.0100198593,
0.0514743775,
-0.0063197734,
0.0514315218,
0.0089674192,
-0.042176716,
0.0312867723,
0.0078749377,
0.0363569148,
0.0303823017,
-0.0252975319,
-0.0064562368,
0.0334524028,
-0.0312737562,
-0.0151281422,
-0.045850981,
0.0191827863,
0.0013509239,
0.0494355746,
-0.0555398539,
-0.0379309095,
0.0610175543,
-0.0640703365,
-0.0325005352,
0.04611478,
-0.0370964631,
0.0459666848,
-0.0311350916,
-0.0101037724,
-0.0075328331,
-0.025075471,
-0.0339543596,
0.0670655221,
0.0074352659,
-0.0232723989,
-0.0262215491,
0.0226613153,
0.0038176957,
-0.0015413973,
-0.0047679688,
-0.0467495658,
-0.0293002743,
0.0320457742,
0.0343311541,
-0.0213634316,
-0.03095676,
-0.0369583108,
-0.0350219831,
0.0181297194,
-0.0065106479,
0.0342334621,
0.0198388752,
-0.0117113125,
0.0196869429,
-0.0065650223,
-0.029059954,
-0.0538413636,
-0.0322557203,
-0.004978138,
0.0465067625,
0.0103295874,
-0.0318621323,
-0.0648129061,
-0.0297299344,
-0.0484016016,
0.0156422649,
0.0246002395,
-0.0714112893,
-0.0516932718,
0.0262806844,
-0.0190890189,
0.0108298939,
-0.0113469623,
-0.01623776,
0.0344280824,
0.0321513005,
-0.0042481725,
0.0346203633,
0.0444048271,
0.0144178504,
0.0019382702,
0.0402019471,
-0.0554063283,
0.0136861755,
-0.0347191095,
0.0335480757,
-0.012640168,
-0.013453369,
0.0344944596,
0.0635272115,
-0.0093652196,
-0.0144116078,
-0.0541617535,
0.0521905497,
0.0393651687,
0.0349706709,
-0.007315672,
-0.0188847799,
-0.012496409,
0.0047055287,
-0.0233243499,
-0.0256363135,
0.0305051692,
0.0006236283,
0.0397287719,
-0.0400147252,
-0.0087840566,
-0.0427115038,
0.0837768167,
-0.0167912673,
0.0013418046,
-0.0210964587,
-0.0109268986,
0.0279008076,
-0.0488737263,
0.0379400365,
-0.0163105559,
0.0852119774,
-0.0432060212,
0.0718123615,
-0.0130772004,
-0.084927313,
-0.0214923993,
-0.0795761421,
-0.0248029847,
0.0165435839,
0.0639267936,
-0.0323334448,
-0.0327933095,
0.0412938818,
-0.0070160902,
0.0589352958,
0.0253508724,
-0.0211002007,
-0.0000507714,
0.0128758894,
0.0250658728,
-0.0091019282,
0.0337594524,
-0.0389443338,
0.0019739373,
0.0181019176,
0.0423901454,
0.0220712721,
-0.0537245423,
-0.0502600148,
-0.0316461362,
-0.0486334041,
0.0371391512,
-0.0052005076,
-0.0026901236,
-0.0301971491,
0.0213137716,
0.0543289334,
0.0139312465,
-0.0286565796,
-0.0090564573,
0.0149113871,
0.0212513208,
0.0090795616,
0.0286823567,
-0.0863783658,
-0.0256640557,
-0.0047828141,
-0.0055965553,
-0.0058452026,
-0.0281358343,
-0.0022806418,
-0.0932974741,
0.0251546111,
0.0009170056,
-0.0096871387,
-0.0228828173,
-0.0490046069,
0.0247860532,
-0.0364952162,
-0.0093821362,
-0.0435339734,
-0.0158450548,
-0.0277638324,
0.0113750156,
-0.0161699299,
-0.0334462337,
-0.0005260651,
-0.049554456,
0.0564918444,
0.0765009373,
0.0539241098,
0.0256817359,
-0.0130977742,
0.0695725679,
-0.0003417361,
-0.0365944803,
-0.0139060244,
0.0709091723,
-0.0090821423,
-0.0029773617,
-0.0264933128,
0.0089738453,
-0.0303934366,
0.0423113853,
0.0122538479,
0.003273661,
-0.0022086911,
-0.0020553574,
-0.0029257569,
0.0390819013,
0.0309749804,
0.0629925728,
0.0045321342,
-0.0298083704,
-0.044694256,
-0.0263989083,
0.0155875711,
-0.0583079048,
-0.0073180767,
-0.0395818241,
-0.0013619571,
0.0230202414,
-0.0374750905,
0.0052573401,
-0.0283907857,
0.0213280134,
0.0131017724,
0.0294699837,
0.0537808426,
-0.03045417,
0.0130785946,
0.055384092,
-0.036165908,
0.011804793,
-0.0356698968,
-0.0832909718,
0.0171868149,
0.0503239855,
-0.0536433049,
0.0303128157,
-0.0819258764,
-0.0786818638,
-0.0372090824,
0.0197561961,
0.0204231776,
0.048664771,
-0.0052126762,
-0.0031880785,
0.0116667654,
0.037598934,
-0.0308474023,
-0.0633227006,
0.0207847543,
-0.0188293476,
-0.0047247061,
0.0159330051,
-0.0027977359,
0.0293297004,
0.0544160195,
0.0340034515,
-0.0566911586,
0.0089238491,
0.0252227578,
-0.0287113115,
0.0489370935,
0.0380688906,
-0.00117756,
-0.0508279912,
-0.0204692464,
-0.0291251875,
0.0121021373,
-0.0423013568,
-0.0205922127,
0.0273184851,
0.0097906124,
-0.0579663515,
0.0133123612,
-0.0154891266,
0.0493211336,
-0.0564050637,
0.0310283583,
-0.0207602046,
0.0533273928,
0.0192568246,
-0.0261758361,
-0.0061027263,
0.0492581204,
0.0398005657,
0.0424460582,
0.0231443141,
0.0114116464,
0.0387697928,
0.0465329848,
-0.0191562213,
-0.011005478,
-0.0488880947,
-0.0372273289,
-0.0602916367,
-0.0227746721,
0.0356450453,
-0.0030147566,
0.0230294615,
0.0036294616,
-0.0118090566,
0.0140839331,
0.0189872831,
-0.0227174945,
-0.0107502267,
0.0235344414,
-0.0019038988,
-0.0264995024,
0.0192846339,
0.0394709185,
-0.0014953226,
0.0338965468,
-0.0046858513,
-0.0292092562,
-0.0265616719,
-0.0294329319,
0.016846776,
0.0254422724,
-0.0109243188,
-0.0357873514,
-0.0292718764,
-0.031453345,
0.0201262385,
0.0018082121,
-0.0060694618,
0.0353725776,
0.030822264,
-0.0128365057,
0.0045074495,
-0.0222194884,
-0.0195802841,
-0.0250841044,
-0.052462332,
-0.0397733115,
-0.0299710277,
-5.827345002e-33,
-0.0270302687,
-0.0264468621,
0.0044973469,
0.0185750555,
0.0032440517,
0.0256084017,
-0.0338863023,
-0.0271431152,
-0.0055871373,
-0.0070723472,
-0.0016052939,
0.0588457137,
0.0182572994,
0.0205304641,
0.0096882163,
-0.0144650824,
0.0651577935,
-0.0151583077,
0.0108338259,
0.0228963308,
-0.0078659151,
0.0198179763,
-0.0203210637,
-0.1311465949,
0.0474728979,
0.0245160833,
-0.0246601198,
0.0138148069,
-0.0111654438,
0.0566789918,
-0.0230201818,
0.011951752,
0.0216409732,
-0.0564831384,
-0.0033171261,
0.0752627775,
-0.0747818351,
-0.0268364493,
-0.0169152226,
-0.0788002014,
-0.006090235,
-0.0198784899,
0.0455281734,
0.0250063203,
0.0017755199,
0.0082220351,
0.0315197706,
-0.0018132246,
0.0161817074,
0.01320522,
-0.0778857097,
0.0330038927,
-0.0207866691,
0.0501555204,
-0.010883701,
0.0503317378,
0.0067349751,
0.0594262853,
-0.0851001889,
-0.0087811491,
0.0056605153,
-0.0067134863,
0.0097557409,
0.0121563617,
0.0120808622,
0.0682138577,
0.0234843586,
0.0231190976,
-0.0261098519,
-0.048466906,
-0.0045482651,
-0.0290888548,
0.0332642347,
0.0736250281,
0.0472529978,
-0.0517222211,
-0.1420937032,
0.0291808005,
0.0287533738,
-0.0017169184,
0.0337080769,
-0.0119485641,
0.0015758038,
0.0134964539,
-0.0000431637,
-0.0466688387,
-0.0125864539,
-0.017095685,
-0.0005553736,
0.047335051,
0.0097462777,
0.0238669962,
0.0055245063,
-0.0464590974,
-0.0029014039,
0.0078872945,
-0.0306090433,
-0.0176437162,
0.0280817114,
0.0042610201,
-0.1095384061,
-0.0328339338,
-0.01205651,
-0.0128427437,
0.0335581936,
-0.0102638341,
0.0462434702,
-0.0561526269,
-0.0933362767,
0.004444005,
-0.0017245336,
0.0029899238,
-0.019591542,
0.0337060429,
0.0361766741,
0.0111772204,
0.0555149987,
0.0276132431,
0.0037925313,
0.0092757009,
0.0142744472,
-0.0166381616,
-0.0432381481,
-0.0069041499,
-0.0184385162,
-0.0227276459,
-0.0189862885,
0.0406489745,
0.0309405588,
-0.0493339635,
-0.0308380648,
-0.0000725429,
2.342e-7,
0.0533177108,
0.0482982956,
0.0061434237,
-0.0170788188,
0.0116827767,
0.0238211881,
-0.0068632257,
0.0487691946,
-0.0094603002,
-0.003199148,
0.0223515164,
-0.0390939005,
0.051660765,
0.0188126862,
-0.1074191034,
-0.0183912832,
-0.0928240344,
0.0003039414,
-0.0378760993,
0.0095269596,
0.026839342,
0.0720025823,
0.0394590423,
-0.0251880754,
0.0045449743,
-0.0124271279,
0.0788881853,
-0.0501956269,
-0.0104830461,
-0.0234958325,
-0.0018536841,
-0.0128755132,
-0.0476012602,
0.0817770585,
-0.0070879031,
0.0563214682,
-0.0414217114,
0.0520584807,
0.0035111737,
-0.0298920367,
-0.0050124191,
0.010100998,
0.0140876798,
0.0048165661,
0.0214640368,
-0.0544041209,
-0.015755754,
-0.045041237,
-0.0414279103,
-0.0203258134,
0.0238217041,
0.0127183255,
-0.0210384112,
-0.0168739967,
0.0075586229,
0.0037025297,
-0.0019612219,
-0.0663155392,
0.0465988927,
0.0084429402,
-0.0232909676,
-0.0007667573,
-0.0215647686,
0.0382662565,
0.0460627265,
-0.022323247,
0.036367137,
1.698757052e-34,
0.0350404382,
-0.0433416292,
-0.0017759262,
-0.0218303204,
0.0664570555,
0.0386539139,
-0.0443324484,
0.0014690389,
0.0139319925,
-0.1090970784,
-0.0053721452
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14865v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14865v2 | Improving Cross-Domain Hate Speech Generalizability with Emotion Knowledge | 2023-11-24T23:00:36 | 2023-12-17T23:14:37 | Shi Yin Hong, Susan Gauch | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Reliable automatic hate speech (HS) detection systems must adapt to the
in-flow of diverse new data to curtail hate speech. However, hate speech
detection systems commonly lack generalizability in identifying hate speech
dissimilar to data used in training, impeding their robustness in real-world
deployments. In this work, we propose a hate speech generalization framework
that leverages emotion knowledge in a multitask architecture to improve the
generalizability of hate speech detection in a cross-domain setting. We
investigate emotion corpora with varying emotion categorical scopes to
determine the best corpus scope for supplying emotion knowledge to foster
generalized hate speech detection. We further assess the relationship between
using pretrained Transformers models adapted for hate speech and its effect on
our emotion-enriched hate speech generalization model. We perform extensive
experiments on six publicly available datasets sourced from different online
domains and show that our emotion-enriched HS detection generalization method
demonstrates consistent generalization improvement in cross-domain evaluation,
increasing generalization performance up to 18.1% and average cross-domain
performance up to 8.5%, according to the F1 measure. | [
0.056969218,
0.0657157749,
-0.0244656503,
0.0126331449,
0.032059554,
0.0630303919,
0.0237909146,
0.0096404003,
0.0013646423,
-0.0779759511,
-0.0509416163,
-0.0417789184,
-0.0480727889,
0.0071701552,
-0.0207759961,
-0.0585007854,
0.0132315299,
0.0547080524,
0.0307744648,
-0.0077877482,
0.0667563379,
0.0075422768,
0.0023190577,
0.0229705926,
-0.0961781815,
0.0280980207,
0.0215812791,
0.0074569006,
0.0494608171,
0.0077386075,
0.0726127103,
0.0200315323,
0.0314118974,
0.0396369249,
0.0000018517,
-0.0363782905,
0.0009097752,
-0.0022461589,
0.0208125114,
-0.0768214539,
0.1013651118,
-0.0623072051,
-0.0186885633,
0.0216078199,
-0.0160181187,
-0.0081543308,
0.0744874626,
0.089950487,
0.072619766,
0.0733579248,
-0.0222470574,
-0.0255240165,
0.0077072033,
0.0201772228,
-0.012603581,
0.014636063,
0.0337778367,
-0.0423924364,
-0.0413315184,
-0.0513350479,
-0.0202309694,
-0.0148271192,
0.0141855655,
0.0462268628,
0.0012687534,
-0.0410946868,
-0.0235233922,
-0.0288640074,
-0.0080505013,
0.0412472486,
-0.0555620864,
0.0191611331,
0.0020188065,
0.0124240108,
-0.0115023535,
-0.0289134663,
-0.0137266545,
0.0027827204,
-0.0364348926,
-0.0053286487,
-0.0144338952,
0.0194513295,
0.0344845913,
0.0576124266,
-0.0183740295,
0.0503286049,
-0.0226284899,
-0.0367845446,
0.048857864,
0.0101748137,
-0.0122883087,
0.0201061908,
0.0314100347,
-0.0041006063,
-0.0153513355,
0.0181056596,
-0.0680992305,
-0.060271319,
-0.0375061221,
-0.0607875511,
0.0238004383,
0.0207809731,
-0.0439662635,
-0.0144899189,
0.023617832,
0.0352008007,
-0.0271422863,
0.0323096924,
-0.0185416006,
-0.0364636108,
-0.0530121513,
0.0271352548,
0.0056294906,
0.0080029648,
0.0086410325,
0.0307130609,
-0.0605980791,
-0.0001266785,
-0.0586931929,
-0.0263875648,
-0.0055234674,
0.0048280824,
-0.0225086734,
-0.0232728254,
-0.0172022954,
0.0122786397,
-0.0384624787,
0.0337342359,
-0.0296535958,
-0.0805001333,
0.0089062219,
0.0285603479,
-0.0186606888,
-0.0207521357,
0.0384236649,
0.084581688,
0.0369460136,
-0.0351641513,
-0.044509463,
-0.0113244206,
-0.0364903174,
-0.0618024543,
0.0214411318,
-0.0381612703,
0.0232556127,
-0.0189923048,
-0.0201721992,
-0.0442278869,
-0.014914589,
-0.0043409755,
-0.0446015336,
0.076090388,
-0.0009939381,
-0.0407678783,
0.0223766994,
0.0271183513,
0.006274973,
0.0651794374,
0.0058102906,
0.0241836738,
0.0579938851,
-0.0025109579,
0.0173395518,
0.0647784248,
0.0227003619,
-0.0070363521,
-0.0015321675,
0.0100888833,
-0.0579463504,
-0.0419451036,
0.0239564963,
0.0196801331,
-0.0174559094,
-0.0474554263,
0.018662557,
0.0538805537,
-0.0362924263,
0.0363020413,
0.0465618111,
0.0283102486,
-0.0137205897,
-0.0201561674,
-0.0594476536,
-0.0222337916,
-0.0268929414,
-0.0369956158,
-0.0154534914,
0.0700722784,
-0.0375968441,
-0.0439899266,
-0.0289007071,
-0.0465807542,
0.0183197167,
-0.0452413484,
0.048803933,
0.0316633545,
-0.0023014173,
0.0363120735,
0.0516736917,
-0.0503435358,
0.0211651195,
-0.0070465072,
0.0012878876,
0.066638574,
-0.0017788636,
-0.0412973277,
-0.0065142554,
-0.0758176744,
-0.0175601877,
0.0292023178,
-0.0163906235,
-0.0087887309,
0.0430343375,
-0.0429677516,
-0.0297225174,
0.0431018881,
0.0256042648,
0.0338964611,
0.0586723499,
0.0178891569,
0.0138882017,
0.0096095996,
0.0054828767,
0.0147835482,
0.0126842419,
-0.0258772206,
-0.006869629,
0.0224140231,
0.0586781986,
0.0318547003,
-0.0360669531,
-0.070865117,
0.0023428993,
-0.0124881929,
-0.0653255954,
0.0352408737,
-0.0405595712,
0.0273684878,
0.0190058667,
-0.0608317479,
-0.0282836091,
0.0989308879,
-0.0028989343,
0.0426477604,
0.0627997518,
-0.0124076158,
0.0127974749,
-0.025586009,
-0.036831595,
-0.0527431481,
0.0332244188,
-0.0066890703,
0.0509973764,
0.0079420079,
-0.0442500524,
0.0184910093,
-0.0546278134,
0.0363590568,
0.0397184268,
-0.0873352289,
-0.0360825956,
-0.031240005,
0.0336517654,
0.0125677455,
-0.0243004654,
-0.0230079852,
0.0040911878,
-0.0862895474,
-0.0033100899,
-0.0312281474,
-0.0188143868,
0.0131470859,
0.0116762808,
-0.0117541514,
0.0188644342,
-0.0090068737,
-0.0445900746,
0.0504548438,
0.030667102,
-0.0077145593,
-0.0549763367,
-0.0107715614,
-0.0139879854,
-0.0050013661,
0.0029272814,
-0.0057691163,
-0.0034234682,
-0.0403375551,
0.0120523851,
-0.0049669957,
-0.0160647314,
0.0357690863,
-0.0057576587,
-0.0499191359,
0.002595054,
0.0255274121,
-0.017282512,
0.0324793756,
0.0456360504,
0.0712836012,
0.0001968782,
-0.0009138189,
-0.0133349439,
0.0214708149,
-0.0192484744,
0.0206361096,
-0.0451783016,
0.0113792084,
0.0007915461,
0.1070412174,
0.0181670226,
-0.0216336381,
-0.0434509665,
-0.0001910299,
-0.0527099445,
-0.0530288629,
-0.0287067033,
-0.071109198,
-0.0021767621,
-0.0448225774,
-0.0291615333,
-0.0627192333,
0.0507342555,
0.0239510443,
-0.0066113276,
-0.050927829,
-0.0062143984,
-0.0026947218,
0.0486699343,
-0.0123777678,
0.0268572848,
-0.0065151928,
-0.0080252215,
-0.0025817887,
-0.0206932668,
-0.0149841746,
-0.0212818682,
0.0180496071,
-0.0155095477,
-0.0071304291,
0.0246421229,
-0.0420065708,
-0.0781196281,
-0.0161200166,
-0.0535678528,
-0.0562090166,
0.0378534906,
-0.014641474,
-0.0286853854,
-0.0012594069,
0.0421183668,
-0.0160051808,
0.0122162392,
-0.0112792691,
0.0459448099,
-0.0075991866,
-0.0004321035,
0.0039769262,
0.0152754933,
0.0191606209,
-0.0506639183,
0.0626045167,
0.024653811,
-0.0110440608,
-0.0165759865,
0.0195341427,
0.0137119433,
0.0177122783,
0.0133136949,
-0.0370840319,
0.0093509806,
0.0045907446,
0.0158533342,
0.0935735777,
0.0092858626,
-0.0189845469,
-0.0013112307,
0.0095936321,
-0.0064925794,
0.0206988044,
0.0044626757,
-0.0753662512,
-0.0156410579,
-0.0275682807,
0.006474568,
-0.049764581,
-0.0316301621,
-0.0023288259,
-0.0526700467,
-0.0046696756,
-0.0098613882,
-0.0106541598,
-0.0369065404,
0.0316593014,
0.042992726,
-0.0306785032,
0.045446001,
-0.0687990934,
0.0403097756,
-0.0139806056,
0.0267764758,
-0.0662901402,
-0.0365543664,
0.004228747,
-0.0235981531,
0.0347213261,
0.0335257389,
0.0451229662,
-0.0306678582,
-0.0054328074,
0.0246606786,
0.0134814186,
-0.0060750716,
-0.0467422381,
0.0714365318,
-0.0280217417,
-0.0419746637,
-0.0075917412,
0.0250562169,
-0.0051260185,
0.0144543918,
0.0129865333,
0.0475573316,
0.043397557,
0.0031473953,
-0.0814781189,
0.0053045927,
0.0047859992,
0.0649140552,
-0.0051427404,
-0.0604044795,
0.0413617417,
-0.0573808923,
-0.0036801272,
-0.0502931736,
-0.0932021141,
-0.0027427536,
-0.0437974408,
-0.0344285555,
-0.0141939986,
-0.0273112077,
0.0097185019,
0.013588558,
0.0263321381,
-0.0472938269,
0.0147237424,
-0.0070674755,
-0.0679268464,
0.0166062582,
0.001521614,
0.0495167933,
-0.0072262473,
-0.0165197421,
-0.0144172944,
-0.0238204654,
-0.0565054826,
0.0334735885,
-0.0272427406,
-0.0352289677,
0.0909969285,
0.0435732156,
0.0159582403,
0.0287065692,
-0.0213009045,
-0.0329536833,
0.0948787034,
0.0359003656,
-0.0260035638,
-0.0160089787,
0.0872718841,
-0.0150113096,
0.0150720701,
0.0096545359,
-0.0243057795,
0.0886197761,
0.0380411372,
-0.0607500114,
-0.0243631825,
0.0191505421,
-0.026385244,
-0.0125531191,
0.0551889986,
0.0186908916,
-0.0323895626,
-0.014603639,
-0.0215934366,
0.0019518734,
-0.0408149883,
-0.0302757192,
0.0015227778,
0.0150540536,
-0.0019661249,
-0.0491338074,
-0.0037235154,
-0.0290441569,
0.0137706166,
-0.0078008869,
0.0180151872,
0.0423689522,
0.054279495,
0.021068655,
0.0241621453,
-0.0099822953,
0.0251072403,
0.0264617186,
-0.0388431884,
0.0047205375,
0.0047014742,
-0.0055146436,
-0.0001394457,
0.0412703119,
0.0014695318,
0.0182351898,
0.0116886236,
-0.0532458015,
-0.0349396802,
-0.0187169015,
-0.0460989587,
0.0310387947,
-0.002682318,
0.0027677021,
-0.000811755,
-0.0183078442,
-0.019241605,
-0.0420660749,
0.0043934039,
0.0111429757,
-0.0295436978,
-0.0034737589,
0.0381674133,
-0.0286931824,
0.0681673735,
0.003996917,
-0.0340628996,
-0.0487631857,
0.0148118436,
0.0466818362,
0.0090027014,
0.0151024088,
0.0283112843,
-0.051215712,
-0.0371202417,
0.0223112423,
-0.0862651467,
0.0302640852,
-0.0119875697,
0.029456703,
0.0808407143,
-0.0239066891,
0.0536597893,
0.0334540382,
-0.0159004889,
0.0006019867,
-0.037026003,
0.0325906202,
-5.475987903e-33,
-0.010496079,
0.0142165897,
-0.0315260403,
-0.0479598865,
-0.002832385,
-0.0000382437,
0.0566169657,
0.0120362043,
0.0032964365,
0.0234000366,
0.0069317529,
0.0323346853,
0.0072279777,
0.0014094457,
-0.0113700163,
-0.0279660672,
0.0330158286,
-0.0107080964,
0.0048958622,
-0.0079624709,
0.0579693243,
0.0342436433,
0.0659710318,
-0.0724278912,
0.0424717516,
0.0118496073,
-0.0400615036,
-0.0003900051,
0.0520263873,
0.082032308,
-0.0020843225,
0.0814259201,
0.0459210873,
-0.0342012309,
-0.0132570341,
0.070101656,
-0.0388943367,
0.0038029742,
0.0162502173,
0.0320920423,
0.0258423686,
-0.0048319362,
0.0276704226,
0.0245042704,
-0.0357120298,
-0.0507374518,
0.0362799652,
-0.045799993,
0.0600617528,
-0.0545457602,
-0.070353128,
0.0123471925,
-0.0180605166,
-0.0016451511,
0.0071957819,
0.0461226404,
0.0374579541,
0.007258249,
-0.037852101,
0.0270034224,
-0.023578437,
-0.0153689766,
-0.0089713065,
-0.0210700333,
-0.0089433715,
0.0883321613,
-0.0125334375,
0.0027449157,
-0.0389729179,
0.0287840422,
0.0295873992,
0.032526806,
0.0224401336,
0.0738575235,
0.0144062266,
-0.0767976493,
-0.0353733078,
0.0078209899,
0.04016947,
-0.0034404276,
0.0361335203,
-0.0275260657,
-0.049585674,
-0.0090658488,
-0.0002793087,
-0.0239815358,
-0.0187647268,
-0.0380510017,
0.0295755211,
-0.026426116,
-0.0185190793,
-0.0016565074,
-0.0094861286,
-0.039596241,
0.0147636738,
0.0711607113,
-0.0270541739,
-0.00071415,
0.0307943169,
0.0147227468,
-0.0403305218,
-0.0264403112,
0.0260432325,
0.0036286169,
0.0267626233,
-0.0090729706,
0.0668947697,
0.0564209931,
-0.0720516741,
-0.0067135589,
-0.0025412929,
0.0694587752,
-0.0025517771,
0.0576426201,
-0.0042647929,
0.0688906759,
-0.0324446298,
-0.0180742983,
0.0044063702,
-0.019215418,
-0.0147978486,
0.0395498015,
-0.015087815,
0.0331096947,
0.0023747787,
-0.036179807,
-0.0059970757,
-0.0648801029,
0.0166940335,
-0.0791050196,
0.0105137983,
-0.0566493198,
2.546e-7,
-0.018225383,
0.0208327547,
0.0247286297,
-0.0085799461,
0.0253429115,
0.0496898331,
0.031029148,
0.0390240289,
-0.0146706635,
-0.0097129904,
-0.0126105333,
0.0397843979,
0.0167120788,
0.0512915924,
-0.0358738713,
-0.0560632907,
0.0033874069,
0.0246891566,
-0.0281788483,
0.0369910672,
-0.0019480736,
0.0996211916,
0.0815612748,
-0.0452792831,
-0.0104405982,
0.0062728962,
0.0117396908,
-0.0348461084,
0.0047929059,
-0.0141700367,
0.0087982658,
0.0310190376,
0.0161368959,
0.0035879428,
0.0002315462,
0.011917782,
0.0278582554,
0.0399704017,
0.0363326333,
-0.0017031288,
0.0134620983,
0.0056567374,
-0.0203290526,
-0.0092560584,
0.0268640406,
-0.0366392322,
-0.0005061806,
-0.0542946272,
-0.0233827718,
-0.0221911483,
0.0168044921,
0.005536119,
-0.0109830657,
-0.0043518329,
0.0449366644,
0.0008450258,
0.0025921559,
-0.0946549997,
0.0192562621,
-0.007207362,
-0.0314546674,
-0.0403455831,
-0.0126470933,
-0.0269893333,
0.0695913881,
0.0052597383,
0.044089973,
1.677453168e-34,
0.0135796778,
-0.0062471554,
-0.007644075,
-0.023893334,
0.0248525366,
-0.0023332967,
-0.0226213709,
-0.030496696,
0.060460858,
-0.0074746814,
0.0056812307
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.00805v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.00805v1 | Gender inference: can chatGPT outperform common commercial tools? | 2023-11-24T22:09:14 | 2023-11-24T22:09:14 | Michelle Alexopoulos, Kelly Lyons, Kaushar Mahetaji, Marcus Emmanuel Barnes, Rogan Gutwillinger | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | An increasing number of studies use gender information to understand
phenomena such as gender bias, inequity in access and participation, or the
impact of the Covid pandemic response. Unfortunately, most datasets do not
include self-reported gender information, making it necessary for researchers
to infer gender from other information, such as names or names and country
information. An important limitation of these tools is that they fail to
appropriately capture the fact that gender exists on a non-binary scale,
however, it remains important to evaluate and compare how well these tools
perform in a variety of contexts. In this paper, we compare the performance of
a generative Artificial Intelligence (AI) tool ChatGPT with three commercially
available list-based and machine learning-based gender inference tools (Namsor,
Gender-API, and genderize.io) on a unique dataset. Specifically, we use a large
Olympic athlete dataset and report how variations in the input (e.g., first
name and first and last name, with and without country information) impact the
accuracy of their predictions. We report results for the full set, as well as
for the subsets: medal versus non-medal winners, athletes from the largest
English-speaking countries, and athletes from East Asia. On these sets, we find
that Namsor is the best traditional commercially available tool. However,
ChatGPT performs at least as well as Namsor and often outperforms it,
especially for the female sample when country and/or last name information is
available. All tools perform better on medalists versus non-medalists and on
names from English-speaking countries. Although not designed for this purpose,
ChatGPT may be a cost-effective tool for gender prediction. In the future, it
might even be possible for ChatGPT or other large scale language models to
better identify self-reported gender rather than report gender on a binary
scale. | [
-0.0177194327,
0.1158159077,
-0.057872504,
0.0008226054,
0.013199823,
0.0204063598,
0.0797153562,
-0.0218771882,
0.0353341997,
0.0136985322,
0.0700166598,
-0.0239493195,
0.018969411,
0.0155462408,
0.0177599881,
-0.0605610013,
-0.0222875588,
0.00724976,
0.0253133364,
-0.0285568554,
-0.0320885479,
0.0058182739,
0.0164470654,
0.0837191865,
0.0367448628,
-0.003299728,
0.0280808657,
0.0146556767,
0.0028045168,
-0.0287052151,
0.0262205023,
0.0093843788,
-0.0254792329,
-0.0106295031,
0.0000020171,
-0.0724699572,
0.018890582,
0.0278532188,
-0.0068051759,
-0.032331232,
0.0081016561,
0.019794507,
0.0127405087,
0.0203024391,
-0.0335941799,
-0.0067530051,
0.0482515283,
-0.0160953384,
-0.0002155022,
-0.0068918569,
-0.0082869632,
0.0393960848,
-0.0531208105,
-0.0353923105,
0.0125288665,
-0.0059130187,
0.0207563415,
-0.0309254099,
-0.0328213312,
-0.0237662457,
-0.0134599619,
0.0100691067,
-0.0411381237,
0.0411725529,
-0.0148255108,
0.0677879006,
-0.0690312237,
-0.0637881234,
0.0490280539,
0.0073673553,
0.0331225619,
0.0242938884,
0.0384977125,
0.0060198796,
0.0280487314,
0.0216436628,
-0.001332458,
0.0223720521,
-0.043894358,
-0.0135831991,
-0.017014673,
-0.0017373293,
0.0092571769,
0.0342269689,
-0.0347675085,
0.0703129321,
-0.0124841062,
0.0061782473,
-0.0169833731,
0.0033021027,
0.0159381963,
-0.0710294619,
0.0005082281,
-0.0429391898,
-0.0012214278,
-0.0220685173,
0.0143661704,
-0.0372228213,
0.0207253899,
-0.0434264541,
0.0055187666,
0.0462691225,
0.0283537544,
-0.0350879878,
0.0008554849,
-0.0000713462,
0.0305100512,
0.0052217748,
-0.0084125884,
-0.0417557694,
-0.0491475724,
0.0147379898,
0.0270733405,
-0.0195558891,
-0.0427138209,
0.068686299,
-0.0866394863,
-0.0185087696,
-0.0336734913,
0.0136351641,
0.0007699253,
0.019648416,
0.0173568558,
0.0311055202,
-0.0631784126,
-0.0246451516,
-0.0565011688,
0.0315176249,
-0.0096038347,
-0.0423259102,
0.0216959547,
-0.0349453799,
0.0415163673,
-0.0035199767,
0.0229514055,
0.0219906177,
0.0479081348,
0.0108973281,
0.0016296013,
0.003476863,
0.0119273691,
-0.0699979514,
0.0207635593,
-0.0625129342,
0.0457039513,
0.0464763083,
0.0106039159,
-0.0431245305,
0.0052349837,
0.0182461496,
-0.0442064889,
0.0598410591,
0.0490416251,
0.0173350144,
0.0643618479,
0.0053788591,
-0.0100474069,
0.0410809629,
0.0226030611,
0.0090360828,
0.0087340726,
-0.0139541421,
-0.0056867995,
0.0155422688,
0.0256873332,
0.0005650072,
-0.0094909659,
-0.0091452161,
-0.0156310108,
0.0128479172,
0.0331692658,
-0.0261401553,
0.0072323675,
-0.0042017973,
0.0466258712,
0.0837957188,
0.0528730825,
0.0543199219,
0.0472457074,
-0.0260528736,
-0.0080670184,
-0.0246570688,
-0.058833044,
0.0141614843,
0.0203793366,
-0.0071568857,
-0.0276184343,
0.0632825717,
-0.0257205982,
-0.0558114536,
0.0059958417,
-0.0033741512,
0.0168991145,
0.0364923738,
0.0472857691,
-0.013357115,
0.0325333774,
0.0164887421,
0.0343309157,
-0.0375881493,
-0.0248953253,
-0.0584314466,
-0.0039999145,
0.0395824276,
-0.0519867167,
-0.0440042764,
0.000163526,
-0.0251727868,
-0.0270698294,
-0.0195362438,
0.0047020451,
0.0302456114,
0.0432119109,
-0.0249087643,
-0.0055067553,
0.0715603456,
0.0397320464,
0.0536502711,
0.0618011877,
0.056753397,
0.0242819637,
-0.0027245099,
-0.053717427,
0.0045963763,
-0.0546051338,
0.0044615986,
0.0823695734,
-0.033904165,
0.0244989935,
0.0418803431,
-0.0120334132,
-0.0258334745,
-0.0225297045,
-0.0075744004,
-0.0114936363,
0.0144408271,
0.0489782505,
0.010181996,
-0.0057215733,
-0.0630455017,
-0.0454871915,
0.0252588242,
-0.0379865505,
0.0146852406,
0.075439319,
0.0524060056,
0.0029983777,
-0.0198583975,
-0.0176283997,
0.0399520993,
0.0433252826,
0.0063877096,
0.0218845531,
-0.0126837753,
-0.0612497702,
-0.015952494,
-0.0440540835,
-0.0298804045,
-0.0877466649,
-0.0612251312,
0.0066906698,
0.015368104,
-0.0010719191,
0.0249055326,
-0.0213142019,
-0.0086575933,
-0.0053380383,
-0.101327695,
0.03785019,
0.0058398079,
0.0121725025,
-0.0557625666,
0.0390057452,
-0.0512806997,
-0.0094437515,
0.0115246987,
-0.0204873141,
-0.0233717784,
0.0171133019,
0.0213453285,
-0.0135684414,
0.0380587243,
-0.0137448367,
-0.0344459936,
-0.0400366001,
0.0505571328,
0.0687112138,
-0.0228697676,
0.0084240139,
-0.0304531325,
-0.0804128796,
0.0155702122,
-0.030820692,
0.0042527351,
-0.0030768821,
0.0343215242,
0.0606158562,
0.0484429821,
0.0246957634,
-0.0167048033,
0.0402693674,
-0.0077674515,
-0.0075420658,
0.0347615741,
-0.0071028247,
0.0109490119,
0.0017601179,
-0.1011379138,
-0.0154644549,
-0.0264366474,
-0.0076611429,
-0.0182134714,
-0.0004693515,
0.0325233266,
-0.021377258,
-0.0135450531,
-0.0624590293,
0.025528146,
0.0028536934,
0.0301440321,
-0.0126201622,
-0.0206216592,
0.0107102497,
0.0105007961,
0.023469504,
0.0112794358,
-0.0308016706,
-0.0402630791,
0.0379795469,
0.035439197,
0.0196308978,
0.0235695355,
0.0228021517,
-0.0159967057,
-0.0290159583,
0.0515486449,
-0.0687703267,
-0.0049949479,
-0.0032701695,
0.001112857,
-0.0089489101,
-0.0488659926,
-0.0274460781,
0.0001786466,
-0.0029421102,
-0.0236948468,
-0.0012655485,
-0.0085302265,
0.0031555213,
0.0010917898,
0.0116388015,
0.0211988986,
0.0011017976,
-0.0215788912,
0.0382081941,
-0.0022935667,
-0.014490474,
0.0104631875,
0.0118966419,
-0.0525908917,
-0.0206450522,
0.0163956732,
-0.0127681559,
0.0108599085,
-0.0033941073,
0.0172228962,
0.0021519614,
-0.0223482605,
-0.0209769476,
0.0112046842,
0.024128465,
-0.0541548729,
0.0715743527,
0.0845056027,
0.0100752087,
-0.0587925203,
-0.00566873,
0.0313410684,
0.0105333347,
0.010305021,
0.0113115208,
-0.0580950491,
0.023820512,
0.0499879271,
0.0367790461,
-0.0856725946,
-0.0711523741,
-0.0379611813,
-0.0921403691,
0.0393485911,
-0.0284030568,
-0.0242936555,
-0.0172852501,
-0.0359466523,
0.0140742017,
-0.053460855,
-0.0176842585,
-0.0314110853,
0.0004014284,
0.0292588212,
-0.0161157809,
-0.1188140959,
-0.0447346196,
0.0280795004,
-0.0968067497,
0.0821612403,
0.0292695276,
0.0630516633,
-0.0398779884,
0.0275803078,
0.0110455072,
0.017008014,
-0.0144019276,
-0.0324892364,
0.0752008781,
-0.003808019,
-0.0106120063,
-0.0642873719,
0.0503103286,
0.0478695482,
-0.0027031845,
0.0879378989,
-0.0003902019,
0.0331427716,
-0.0099528981,
-0.0092681991,
-0.0286819693,
0.0012881986,
0.0334778316,
-0.0018565039,
-0.0161737688,
-0.0340996534,
-0.0381468236,
0.0333487317,
0.0021813009,
-0.0622389764,
-0.0139915952,
0.0036341196,
-0.0813795328,
0.0324494056,
-0.0416441597,
0.0483706445,
0.0077039609,
-0.0424058773,
-0.0111757424,
-0.0019963249,
0.0212973766,
-0.064365916,
0.0433373451,
0.0201693997,
-0.0095078722,
0.0538540632,
-0.0617623404,
0.0169896502,
-0.0205389988,
-0.0206902698,
0.0511428639,
-0.0429613553,
-0.0032548986,
0.0396526083,
0.037497066,
0.0214256328,
0.0440945029,
-0.0067057726,
-0.0016622972,
0.0121068731,
0.0697467327,
-0.00970174,
-0.0001381835,
-0.01255921,
0.0358353294,
-0.008149826,
-0.0138099166,
0.0255742464,
0.051850874,
-0.0050471276,
-0.0316806808,
-0.0557603911,
0.0198135953,
-0.013530748,
0.0365153216,
0.0580842383,
-0.034135811,
-0.0341014415,
-0.0272152945,
-0.0102067636,
-0.02629086,
-0.0072544687,
-0.0202420913,
-0.0620073266,
0.0007875485,
0.0580385476,
-0.0356150679,
-0.0140269902,
-0.0479612425,
0.0065488974,
-0.0912312865,
0.0666327924,
0.016669983,
0.0854249522,
0.0167755149,
-0.0057004704,
0.0367545858,
-0.0179743897,
0.0170289334,
0.0396242514,
0.0043580462,
-0.0420374386,
-0.018659303,
0.0195455234,
0.0020382502,
-0.0134983361,
-0.0276222341,
0.0128496019,
-0.0218173955,
0.0674773455,
0.0178863145,
-0.0031529125,
0.0074863904,
-0.0040244241,
-0.0192130581,
0.0117353862,
0.0200862978,
-0.0140243405,
0.0190400388,
-0.0098862872,
-0.0368426926,
-0.0221384093,
-0.0130886212,
0.0290896427,
0.0660846606,
0.0084596658,
-0.0352910049,
-0.0854633301,
-0.0196879059,
-0.0380036421,
0.0079410281,
-0.050714612,
-0.0329724103,
-0.0073788213,
-0.0983354673,
-0.0460354388,
-0.0231653191,
-0.0379200988,
0.0221311059,
0.0372241549,
-0.0471055731,
0.0320177861,
-0.03358588,
-0.0438923351,
-0.0281803105,
-0.0075470903,
-0.0435195081,
-0.0592520088,
-0.0105828829,
-5.786016457e-33,
-0.0072124572,
-0.0441409796,
0.0273518134,
-0.0190040115,
-0.0363744125,
0.0372137688,
-0.0218385048,
-0.0297028217,
0.0167745985,
0.00499338,
-0.0190725513,
0.0083028218,
0.017031813,
-0.002000052,
0.0151760383,
-0.0311990026,
0.0494906828,
0.0299307443,
-0.0134816691,
-0.0268597752,
-0.0422875471,
0.0413830392,
0.0025611795,
-0.0628734007,
0.0688196495,
-0.0027799744,
-0.0157467723,
-0.0245159883,
0.0091256192,
-0.0175590813,
0.0198196638,
0.0190936495,
0.0102193598,
-0.0369864292,
0.0195073634,
0.0223343987,
-0.090792127,
-0.0280908775,
-0.0615249798,
0.0130537683,
0.0474580601,
0.0008532105,
0.0385541134,
0.0403717794,
-0.0458585061,
-0.0562525876,
0.0755599216,
0.007327395,
0.063016437,
-0.010209024,
0.0363885053,
0.0484732985,
-0.0318623669,
0.0611447059,
0.0284268241,
0.0582750626,
-0.0185128879,
-0.0003481543,
-0.0461561345,
0.0253779721,
0.0263330359,
-0.0159991663,
-0.0036292335,
0.039606221,
0.0434215665,
-0.0241296552,
0.107163392,
-0.0295990519,
-0.0624932945,
-0.0555117764,
0.0142403794,
-0.0161275119,
0.0093357246,
0.0627630204,
0.0286570955,
-0.016778795,
-0.0932007506,
-0.0005882031,
0.0303409658,
-0.0061701238,
-0.0235807002,
-0.000749057,
-0.056292221,
-0.013905867,
-0.0148564614,
-0.0895146802,
0.0004666921,
-0.0298640635,
0.0071108304,
-0.0119200461,
-0.0522108376,
0.0210002363,
-0.0019832475,
-0.0164890438,
-0.0367790945,
-0.0276335534,
0.0222163126,
-0.0097469259,
0.0429363251,
-0.0134985764,
-0.0336088911,
0.0163899604,
-0.0190969575,
0.0444926061,
0.0407303385,
0.0084280279,
-0.0224231388,
0.0159391295,
-0.0540912114,
-0.0203983374,
-0.0119392052,
0.0215729065,
-0.0116762146,
-0.0126599697,
0.0045015127,
0.0198989492,
0.0109169008,
-0.018454114,
0.0584433265,
0.0484639443,
-0.0355438143,
-0.0069632214,
-0.0190710314,
-0.0076949229,
0.0212161578,
-0.0068031522,
-0.0028869226,
0.043900419,
0.0444888659,
-0.0114700766,
-0.0038139718,
-0.0336698182,
2.657e-7,
0.020979315,
0.057474561,
-0.0231538564,
0.0028353068,
-0.0210517086,
0.0198368989,
-0.0110368663,
0.045914162,
0.0890748352,
0.0506088249,
0.025938116,
0.0662287995,
0.0141359894,
0.0737130195,
-0.0612825342,
-0.0088483775,
-0.0273400061,
-0.0088933567,
-0.0238587949,
0.0355664417,
-0.0081604319,
0.0454174541,
0.0810640827,
0.0092555368,
0.0234647039,
-0.0001496468,
0.0225422364,
-0.0339823104,
-0.0397808701,
0.0061029065,
0.0045201541,
-0.0080265105,
0.0160259046,
0.0545251034,
-0.0290363673,
0.0061493795,
0.0109972535,
-0.0072089583,
-0.0116397962,
0.0756297931,
-0.0152273197,
0.0067906384,
0.0044410136,
-0.0339753032,
0.0719459131,
0.0101422947,
-0.041071225,
-0.0503582247,
-0.0476803258,
0.0360401236,
0.0883537531,
0.0164686423,
-0.0285844952,
0.0237281378,
0.0114370622,
-0.0042112041,
0.0104057705,
-0.0216978732,
0.0005813629,
-0.0203589797,
-0.0267952569,
-0.0692871958,
0.0090263765,
0.0498826057,
0.0205390174,
-0.0588676631,
0.032911513,
2.27136549e-34,
-0.0254949629,
0.0544556119,
-0.044115603,
-0.0380744562,
0.0116058057,
-0.0100550782,
0.0282638762,
-0.0148679456,
0.0380081423,
0.0326295123,
0.0161313545
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14838v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14838v1 | OpusCleaner and OpusTrainer, open source toolkits for training Machine Translation and Large language models | 2023-11-24T20:24:00 | 2023-11-24T20:24:00 | Nikolay Bogoychev, Jelmer van der Linde, Graeme Nail, Barry Haddow, Jaume Zaragoza-Bernabeu, Gema Ramírez-Sánchez, Lukas Weymann, Tudor Nicolae Mateiu, Jindřich Helcl, Mikko Aulamo | cs.CL | cs.CL | Developing high quality machine translation systems is a labour intensive,
challenging and confusing process for newcomers to the field. We present a pair
of tools OpusCleaner and OpusTrainer that aim to simplify the process, reduce
the amount of work and lower the entry barrier for newcomers.
OpusCleaner is a data downloading, cleaning, and proprocessing toolkit. It is
designed to allow researchers to quickly download, visualise and preprocess
bilingual (or monolingual) data that comes from many different sources, each of
them with different quality, issues, and unique filtering/preprocessing
requirements.
OpusTrainer is a data scheduling and data augmenting tool aimed at building
large scale, robust machine translation systems and large language models. It
features deterministic data mixing from many different sources, on-the-fly data
augmentation and more.
Using these tools, we showcase how we can use it to create high quality
machine translation model robust to noisy user input; multilingual models and
terminology aware models. | [
0.0304809455,
0.0681128204,
-0.0195669401,
0.062600337,
-0.0234779716,
0.0236498639,
-0.0032076461,
-0.0082223229,
-0.0291708801,
-0.0020978842,
-0.0376340002,
-0.0225411244,
0.0129693588,
0.0056184581,
0.0039976379,
-0.1050974056,
0.0475740768,
-0.0089288047,
-0.0731161982,
0.0043548159,
-0.0008447501,
0.0443457663,
0.0177842584,
0.035076879,
0.0118668294,
-0.0076310616,
-0.0005237369,
0.0393783934,
0.0220538098,
0.0075315149,
-0.0044616656,
0.0497625917,
0.0072169895,
0.1331413239,
0.0000022268,
-0.0327949375,
-0.0531313047,
0.004472672,
0.0061538504,
0.0051169316,
0.0987785086,
-0.0589059927,
-0.0313425139,
0.0073797018,
-0.0359588377,
0.0091936933,
0.0507436655,
-0.0111796921,
0.0778524727,
0.0520083755,
-0.0151614724,
-0.0200745743,
-0.0073261536,
-0.0413026474,
-0.0259118825,
-0.0239649769,
-0.0116641233,
-0.0092292512,
-0.011621533,
0.0361203589,
0.0061500208,
0.0396959037,
0.0037996592,
-0.0050440566,
0.0124199074,
-0.0007081071,
-0.0139210941,
-0.0788174123,
-0.0115314443,
0.0602185838,
-0.0178713184,
-0.0170503575,
0.0079129161,
0.0115330387,
-0.0132299606,
-0.0134838326,
-0.0501969866,
-0.0009874229,
0.0039479411,
0.0069366745,
0.0407102257,
0.0013185432,
0.0183348954,
0.0062233452,
-0.0270233937,
-0.017309444,
0.0356949531,
-0.0247634389,
0.0015537605,
0.0132356677,
0.0029800402,
-0.0457140692,
0.0452053063,
0.0036386654,
0.0114170648,
0.0134495124,
-0.0303959362,
-0.0623562708,
0.0268671624,
-0.0769139901,
-0.0069015492,
0.033697024,
-0.0258437414,
0.0470906198,
0.0098465709,
0.0081711309,
-0.0056392299,
-0.0193261672,
-0.0638145506,
-0.0344031863,
-0.0240531974,
0.0206744689,
-0.0526462123,
-0.0476497598,
-0.0616891608,
0.0221715476,
-0.0503200963,
0.0050707902,
0.0096512334,
0.0022660734,
0.0530815572,
-0.0207967591,
-0.0464607067,
-0.0358731449,
-0.0082027214,
0.0649459288,
-0.0343461111,
-0.0042642653,
-0.028247444,
-0.0607969873,
-0.0174069349,
0.0014783082,
-0.0329429395,
-0.0388719067,
0.0075631402,
0.0640930533,
-0.0167117845,
-0.0140827326,
-0.0047875443,
-0.0228174161,
-0.0241948795,
-0.069750376,
-0.0341711529,
-0.080543153,
0.0677348301,
0.0030304894,
0.0205934104,
-0.0354200192,
0.0018697346,
0.0098660486,
-0.0281975418,
0.0594262332,
-0.0433567576,
0.0133982506,
0.0266985092,
0.0112556992,
0.0334778689,
0.0714297071,
0.0476827025,
0.0152568175,
0.0412284061,
-0.0120574813,
-0.0359742828,
0.069135271,
-0.0110368505,
0.0199069474,
-0.0063651241,
0.0065809977,
0.0192739274,
0.0306694321,
0.0490917452,
0.0479822606,
-0.0205168799,
0.0235136114,
0.0594022572,
0.01992107,
0.0240247659,
0.0372189954,
0.0411572531,
0.005505024,
-0.0039985687,
-0.0303629059,
-0.0144344606,
0.0218079537,
0.0609594248,
0.0000739725,
-0.0124613754,
0.0938348919,
0.0128405979,
-0.0437019244,
-0.0035133555,
-0.0108315786,
-0.0061210953,
-0.0303601176,
0.0789798796,
0.0239924397,
-0.0493270569,
0.0504639558,
0.0046126707,
-0.0650812536,
0.0336399153,
-0.0126632405,
-0.0225676242,
0.0969933867,
0.0459543988,
-0.0246184338,
-0.0165227894,
-0.0104509396,
0.0112413131,
0.0309182592,
0.0464276783,
-0.0058242129,
0.0157997962,
-0.0820441023,
-0.0345894732,
0.0306660179,
0.012467294,
0.0311918128,
0.0342039838,
0.0376296826,
0.0467491634,
-0.0451459065,
-0.0682759136,
0.040086858,
-0.0236540027,
-0.0303890277,
0.0185848903,
0.0040113949,
0.0032643592,
0.0524494275,
-0.0262619611,
-0.0121727753,
0.050233312,
-0.0137224291,
0.0141647346,
0.0438286364,
-0.009729173,
0.0409051105,
0.0308572259,
-0.0284221321,
-0.0103408759,
-0.0228013154,
-0.036489252,
-0.0606144331,
-0.0199009813,
-0.0131933307,
-0.0137502262,
-0.0465789326,
0.0511845611,
-0.0110733239,
0.0293441843,
-0.0372075997,
0.0294564571,
0.0041387207,
-0.0190371908,
0.0230839103,
-0.0392515808,
0.0261821579,
-0.0276125465,
-0.0203776434,
0.0293259714,
-0.0038307302,
0.0192186553,
0.008659048,
0.0240703151,
-0.0322047696,
-0.0429926887,
-0.0981877521,
0.0293093305,
-0.009657912,
0.031643521,
0.0121002495,
0.057380762,
-0.0152830575,
-0.0164411683,
0.045131918,
0.005407989,
0.0199719518,
-0.0036624942,
-0.0049308343,
-0.0249257758,
0.0277311821,
-0.0117378077,
0.0027858783,
0.0173290521,
0.0065401276,
0.0288772956,
-0.0410575829,
-0.0461044461,
-0.0095009413,
-0.0254724361,
0.0074718669,
0.0197131895,
-0.04205532,
-0.0007123452,
-0.003919445,
0.0457347706,
0.0405378155,
-0.0111493543,
0.0064621326,
0.0534260795,
-0.0301677641,
-0.0472711362,
-0.0008118512,
-0.0062482748,
-0.0352026038,
-0.0318076536,
-0.0535932481,
0.0093830992,
0.0519696064,
-0.0018807616,
0.0188599229,
-0.0232498106,
-0.0100764669,
-0.0491308048,
-0.0124220224,
0.0052768057,
0.0187335722,
-0.0104450118,
0.0321405679,
-0.0175019689,
-0.0396196544,
0.0633814633,
-0.0212416537,
-0.0102563621,
-0.0575127415,
-0.0286981165,
-0.0394372083,
0.0362654701,
-0.0151297096,
0.018104,
-0.0210322607,
0.0073888907,
-0.0231658947,
0.0450429469,
0.0417771228,
-0.0436056294,
0.0071009244,
-0.0607801341,
-0.0299592204,
-0.0080526378,
-0.0277583655,
-0.0396260396,
0.0366793126,
-0.0288026296,
-0.034257561,
0.0133676566,
-0.0271041207,
-0.0313414447,
0.0086246748,
0.0098928763,
0.0665491298,
0.0068383082,
0.0020604476,
-0.0086197453,
0.0406837389,
-0.0049358681,
-0.0101184547,
-0.0100741517,
-0.0587512627,
0.0156096788,
0.0203307364,
0.0003001587,
-0.0423348919,
-0.020623507,
-0.0170867089,
0.0464812554,
-0.0095812539,
-0.012026879,
-0.0246060118,
0.029139746,
-0.0518756807,
-0.0222189892,
0.092637293,
0.0343218036,
-0.0604972281,
-0.0225365385,
-0.0393687151,
0.0331294052,
0.0144142555,
0.0453790799,
-0.0995979384,
-0.0157470275,
0.0014707793,
0.056417387,
0.0304387063,
0.0177827869,
-0.0060416698,
-0.0664961785,
0.029169457,
0.0481831618,
-0.0715865344,
-0.0289745908,
-0.0537449382,
-0.0469625816,
-0.0917728245,
0.0302727986,
-0.0198075864,
0.0064869821,
0.0039924062,
0.0173554737,
0.0289683305,
-0.0556023382,
-0.0211305227,
-0.0725217685,
0.0410854667,
0.0820461065,
0.0452593155,
-0.0169496648,
0.0198557489,
0.0360299349,
0.005058594,
-0.0182707887,
-0.0116591202,
0.029026784,
0.0096143605,
-0.006356529,
-0.0154423257,
0.014705779,
-0.0066159051,
-0.0115318233,
0.052134946,
0.0726967901,
0.007911792,
0.0109537495,
-0.0139774317,
-0.0094375806,
0.0296813678,
0.051990062,
-0.0038077903,
-0.0377690233,
0.0118076764,
-0.0256376602,
-0.0052229096,
-0.0732894316,
-0.0106852781,
0.0352476016,
-0.1068704352,
-0.0906375125,
-0.0666192323,
-0.0213556513,
-0.000401128,
0.014605307,
0.0457039066,
0.01450893,
0.0174752176,
-0.0097419256,
-0.0598223731,
0.0558704399,
-0.0101014124,
0.0256907549,
-0.0621886477,
-0.0240712296,
-0.010702082,
-0.0086477203,
-0.0106177153,
0.074553214,
-0.0726417303,
-0.0469659567,
0.0177345593,
0.0639889985,
0.0255067367,
0.0371748693,
-0.0118656736,
-0.035587877,
0.0044580474,
0.0332828909,
-0.0317281,
-0.0309557226,
0.0122204879,
-0.0365359783,
-0.0104175536,
0.0322860964,
-0.0153402584,
0.0150792999,
-0.0209436752,
0.024339499,
-0.0410261415,
-0.0368565693,
0.0048174676,
-0.0078899758,
0.0237740036,
-0.0368343666,
-0.0559884012,
-0.0626281649,
0.0206730049,
-0.0004311549,
-0.032332655,
-0.0335350074,
0.0344602689,
0.0654300898,
-0.0070660203,
0.0131833628,
0.0230797306,
-0.0222710501,
-0.0470150784,
-0.0278360136,
0.0070651053,
-0.000425273,
0.0344445929,
0.0197317712,
0.0276809651,
0.0110179121,
0.0558715686,
-0.0192925669,
0.0290538929,
-0.0317917839,
0.0256515276,
-0.0149385324,
0.0160622261,
0.0234530717,
0.02826548,
-0.0100635402,
0.0125942873,
-0.0459212735,
0.0067226714,
0.0760197043,
0.0006951554,
0.1151599064,
-0.026544923,
-0.025509337,
-0.0070474343,
0.0467808768,
0.0077040363,
0.0102585852,
-0.0289952159,
-0.0203094687,
-0.0025782855,
-0.0003984373,
0.0511810519,
-0.0309803393,
0.0137191219,
0.0234649703,
-0.0289031807,
-0.0050988486,
-0.0325737037,
-0.0165661778,
-0.0004206508,
-0.0509752557,
-0.0354470052,
-0.020528838,
-0.0424784385,
-0.0258170292,
0.0307018049,
-0.0206907578,
-0.0164895058,
0.0188217126,
0.0705488399,
-0.0373370051,
0.0229974538,
-0.0417004079,
0.0428261831,
0.0051679737,
-0.0487280451,
-0.0158526767,
-6.206901842e-33,
-0.0209744666,
-0.0207533743,
0.0183788855,
-0.0511789955,
-0.0327429064,
-0.0163725633,
-0.0195416473,
-0.0298459474,
0.0135506587,
0.0124393376,
0.0172736049,
0.0082107885,
0.036016725,
-0.0227146801,
0.0514709726,
0.0554853268,
0.0667075291,
0.0309592951,
-0.0222321898,
0.01048024,
0.0470136628,
0.0343904048,
0.0751349404,
-0.0538179278,
0.0484902263,
-0.0124374842,
-0.0106260134,
0.0237732418,
0.0130414171,
0.0445597284,
0.002487523,
0.0259890184,
-0.0083898362,
-0.0120997597,
-0.0102242306,
0.011230316,
-0.1108825877,
0.0123622641,
0.0358567312,
0.0730501041,
0.0148198269,
-0.0532395281,
0.0470330939,
-0.025335161,
-0.0095844772,
0.0082122507,
0.0250152778,
-0.0416431986,
-0.0291351061,
0.0110913236,
-0.0632798895,
0.025170967,
-0.0185119621,
-0.0247163475,
0.0560247973,
0.0567636155,
0.0079513872,
-0.0303956307,
-0.0564808995,
0.0361624248,
0.0045049535,
0.0259635206,
0.1089469865,
0.0124946423,
-0.0244954638,
-0.0000855005,
0.0176546387,
-0.0329625607,
0.018063603,
0.0414399244,
0.020006232,
0.0344548114,
0.0624322146,
0.0311687514,
0.0235824455,
-0.0133048529,
-0.0168734081,
0.0554024167,
0.0307607055,
-0.0074838041,
-0.0049138917,
0.0223699473,
-0.0033211461,
-0.0046809651,
-0.0348800272,
-0.0654352158,
-0.0336626843,
-0.0269400813,
0.0022525385,
0.0183987413,
-0.018829219,
-0.0010595479,
0.0403322205,
-0.0264331326,
-0.0036986747,
-0.008419347,
-0.016635064,
-0.0201837961,
-0.0299383309,
0.067517899,
-0.0090624075,
-0.0377545841,
0.0259962752,
-0.0125381676,
0.0047202948,
-0.0116710505,
0.0311352462,
-0.0256986227,
-0.0293158274,
0.0284657255,
-0.0326709896,
-0.0004428651,
-0.0009867396,
0.0526943356,
0.0094898585,
0.0209760778,
-0.0061626406,
0.0388089456,
0.0598671325,
0.0154130952,
-0.0310818776,
-0.0344306603,
0.0329370946,
0.0281945914,
-0.0400056802,
0.0207224544,
-0.0394159481,
0.0039964202,
0.036324311,
-0.0507855192,
-0.0309652332,
-0.0101543283,
2.877e-7,
0.0665143207,
0.0742533877,
0.0005467594,
0.0174607839,
-0.0051070992,
-0.0009064507,
-0.0421417393,
0.0423968956,
-0.0243753437,
0.0603509098,
0.0020235039,
0.0246272292,
0.0885643587,
0.0633180588,
-0.0717525333,
-0.0899267867,
-0.0418691337,
0.0082706437,
-0.0960902199,
0.0211230088,
0.0029714997,
0.1058236584,
0.0183896031,
-0.0106030181,
-0.0103637595,
0.0090493383,
0.0441824198,
-0.0229432918,
-0.0244710818,
0.0287608877,
0.0487803444,
0.0300800111,
-0.0206953287,
-0.0140401628,
-0.0491308495,
-0.0086836042,
0.0369448438,
0.0770325884,
-0.0158435218,
0.0052686413,
0.0294741727,
-0.0427644476,
-0.0281910412,
-0.0600266941,
0.0419725627,
-0.0144914128,
0.0034818733,
0.0019585013,
-0.0292316675,
0.0120493378,
0.0355546884,
-0.0435256585,
-0.0504468903,
0.0288161784,
0.0677022561,
-0.0058398549,
-0.0539848655,
-0.0255134683,
-0.02123948,
-0.0045935339,
-0.0042053135,
-0.046712216,
-0.0283323098,
-0.0098741762,
-0.0059806909,
-0.016418675,
0.0134196999,
2.869614973e-34,
0.033546865,
-0.0035051918,
-0.0162370745,
-0.0088106003,
0.049987182,
-0.0477211215,
-0.0131364847,
0.0182736404,
-0.0295205843,
-0.025556067,
-0.0254908986
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14836v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14836v3 | Custom Data Augmentation for low resource ASR using Bark and Retrieval-Based Voice Conversion | 2023-11-24T20:16:29 | 2024-01-09T21:37:45 | Anand Kamble, Aniket Tathe, Suyash Kumbharkar, Atharva Bhandare, Anirban C. Mitra | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS | This paper proposes two innovative methodologies to construct customized
Common Voice datasets for low-resource languages like Hindi. The first
methodology leverages Bark, a transformer-based text-to-audio model developed
by Suno, and incorporates Meta's enCodec and a pre-trained HuBert model to
enhance Bark's performance. The second methodology employs Retrieval-Based
Voice Conversion (RVC) and uses the Ozen toolkit for data preparation. Both
methodologies contribute to the advancement of ASR technology and offer
valuable insights into addressing the challenges of constructing customized
Common Voice datasets for under-resourced languages. Furthermore, they provide
a pathway to achieving high-quality, personalized voice generation for a range
of applications. | [
0.0008967342,
0.039740704,
0.0115230372,
-0.0164289884,
0.0135120619,
-0.0339768939,
0.0208978001,
-0.01143183,
-0.0566533096,
0.013615571,
-0.0742469877,
-0.0058645029,
0.0253558308,
0.0242217481,
-0.0032319673,
-0.0602451302,
0.0067053353,
-0.0328104421,
0.0128220422,
-0.0208497196,
0.0079688178,
0.0352485664,
-0.0304845013,
0.0312630273,
-0.0184405167,
0.021821769,
-0.0059080692,
0.0220500249,
0.011140286,
-0.0336308144,
-0.0242700111,
-0.02720562,
0.0478197336,
0.0307436213,
0.0000017073,
-0.0413082205,
-0.0275888275,
0.0247961115,
-0.0618089847,
-0.0145450849,
0.0613126941,
0.0065103685,
-0.0260682721,
0.0354996882,
-0.0042822491,
0.0044071618,
0.0773479864,
0.0053407769,
0.0210662596,
0.0775475502,
-0.0103035849,
-0.0614171997,
0.0129429828,
0.0006989891,
-0.0029166099,
0.0344918668,
-0.0230375677,
0.0145224528,
0.0197101776,
0.0192472469,
-0.0017956038,
0.0394819677,
0.0269664489,
-0.0319843031,
0.0307684429,
-0.0232849158,
-0.0374578126,
-0.0455847681,
-0.0001059974,
0.0168850664,
0.0377213024,
-0.0453731008,
0.0018800906,
0.0289200451,
-0.019479854,
-0.0243525412,
-0.0212505758,
0.0252165012,
0.0025061988,
0.0148783503,
-0.0328725874,
0.0695582032,
0.002903613,
-0.0529350452,
-0.0070457398,
-0.0193652399,
0.008921193,
-0.0262139514,
-0.001098692,
-0.0175794158,
0.0144227156,
0.038935218,
0.0551969074,
0.0069391252,
-0.0152133601,
-0.0044623343,
-0.0311420001,
-0.0560724474,
-0.0296774078,
-0.0058078007,
0.0295702498,
0.0415966548,
-0.0714249313,
-0.0547719188,
0.0246815011,
0.0170648322,
0.0004113444,
-0.0194816794,
-0.0155986641,
-0.0264253449,
0.0292444844,
-0.0184717458,
-0.0513177179,
0.0160829313,
-0.0704968497,
0.0013232467,
-0.0550025739,
0.0247268137,
-0.0158367809,
-0.0254456829,
0.0719719753,
-0.0119635882,
-0.0823379382,
-0.027170876,
0.0238277018,
0.0097575272,
0.0184773523,
0.0689993277,
0.016027445,
-0.0908807591,
0.0148302894,
0.0225861259,
0.0241385996,
-0.0057771867,
-0.0013949281,
0.0231125187,
-0.0135637196,
0.0108896084,
-0.0432302542,
0.0007242223,
-0.0376527868,
-0.0133775426,
-0.0317111351,
-0.055402603,
0.0168007575,
-0.002989904,
-0.0201708842,
-0.0021322172,
-0.0172803402,
0.0041959942,
0.0614577346,
0.0574405491,
-0.0310281459,
0.0424522012,
0.0678875148,
-0.0146736344,
0.0328054652,
0.0361565612,
0.0444389507,
-0.0081175147,
0.0102475751,
-0.0623283908,
-0.0182540007,
0.0527120233,
-0.0067864684,
-0.0219910182,
-0.030799564,
0.0044272323,
-0.0247478578,
0.0130285798,
0.0319746099,
0.0376234278,
-0.0165229142,
0.0171137769,
0.0367067493,
0.0442960709,
0.057442449,
0.0195547715,
0.0103344824,
0.034309078,
-0.0082332427,
-0.0356512778,
0.020807799,
0.0238857288,
-0.0037920789,
-0.0038263807,
0.0235495493,
0.0607243143,
-0.0124192685,
0.0041353977,
0.0041063004,
-0.0377703011,
-0.0226774458,
0.0291600917,
0.0379536748,
0.0591786243,
0.0007914162,
0.0135690616,
-0.0026779512,
-0.1033370197,
0.0059366119,
-0.0355559625,
-0.0358927175,
-0.020480847,
0.0225171875,
-0.0049058129,
0.046738904,
-0.0305943768,
-0.0503369085,
0.0309220422,
-0.0288416781,
-0.0030245411,
0.0338761173,
-0.0815689042,
-0.0031071811,
0.041042313,
-0.0207473412,
0.0430372953,
-0.0212622676,
0.0368456542,
0.0173003599,
-0.0170318242,
0.0431179851,
-0.0234015286,
-0.0323976725,
-0.0036692964,
0.0628207773,
0.0112358304,
0.0648683384,
0.0689958036,
-0.011653713,
-0.0031665138,
0.0381500944,
-0.0317560285,
0.0062085968,
0.0511556268,
-0.0444655232,
-0.0063835802,
0.0149546592,
-0.0281958673,
0.0614509508,
0.0511972681,
0.0411967337,
-0.1174216941,
0.0140095651,
-0.0417004935,
0.0763155892,
-0.0338286571,
0.0613567829,
0.0337466523,
0.0117964251,
0.0318075307,
-0.0099463919,
0.0326842852,
-0.0140412878,
0.0105300061,
0.0408590287,
0.025202224,
-0.108076483,
-0.0072670053,
0.0283976085,
-0.0273857154,
0.0094844447,
0.0369310267,
-0.0491570123,
-0.0067040976,
-0.0120161464,
-0.0428902693,
-0.0209156983,
-0.0031668229,
-0.0076873689,
-0.0257413425,
0.0533515885,
0.0236120168,
-0.0314174443,
-0.0379122309,
-0.0500088781,
0.015693292,
-0.0128079886,
-0.0512190461,
-0.0221700761,
-0.0040922845,
0.0057856948,
-0.0095062079,
0.0403895155,
-0.0107402597,
-0.027056044,
-0.0453006737,
-0.0325363018,
-0.0141649293,
0.0209614057,
0.0268190447,
-0.0181705263,
-0.0388893895,
0.0003896026,
0.0044428115,
0.0312070828,
0.000776601,
-0.0118753938,
-0.0315647125,
0.0024796547,
0.0117943278,
-0.0643666089,
-0.0090633798,
0.0443017296,
0.0154453842,
-0.0023570945,
0.0116739394,
0.0034154174,
-0.0268537793,
0.0344787613,
0.0216925498,
-0.0240095928,
-0.0352203622,
0.0037221781,
-0.0499950051,
0.0012751102,
-0.0139078526,
-0.0491124615,
0.0078357346,
-0.0253417119,
-0.0405811407,
-0.0117118321,
-0.0536271445,
-0.0604520105,
-0.0530503988,
-0.0457802787,
-0.0160300694,
0.0003872736,
-0.0280757491,
0.010230897,
-0.0304705594,
-0.0087205758,
-0.0021666628,
0.0579524525,
-0.0155952033,
-0.0741473734,
0.0225580093,
-0.00070531,
0.0232982691,
-0.0383567996,
-0.0165767632,
-0.0258566383,
0.0386566855,
0.0178924501,
0.0342298038,
0.0356100872,
-0.032473579,
0.0158238914,
0.0664520636,
0.0163503829,
0.0486277379,
0.0037857962,
0.0171537716,
-0.0085359989,
0.0321369395,
0.0349952318,
0.0336522572,
-0.0256017689,
0.0215770174,
0.0415172912,
-0.0520416908,
0.0462699234,
-0.0275807325,
-0.0250494555,
-0.0067444555,
0.046741806,
0.0398781858,
0.013502623,
0.020448437,
0.0500073992,
-0.0028175048,
0.0138366167,
0.0456982069,
0.0010380675,
-0.0544625968,
-0.0253600646,
-0.052159179,
0.0195500422,
0.0058356621,
-0.0049884892,
-0.0705537945,
0.0128639927,
0.0636058077,
0.0580651537,
0.0093312124,
0.0525873974,
-0.0296363439,
-0.1009488851,
0.0279079285,
0.0162010435,
-0.0191940907,
-0.0459163226,
-0.0099957231,
-0.045887351,
-0.0117078023,
0.0529032014,
0.0374298096,
-0.0266079735,
-0.0339594632,
0.0560446903,
-0.0581811778,
-0.0456343628,
-0.0486819223,
0.0116448933,
0.1066663042,
0.0752150193,
0.0061001144,
-0.011328782,
-0.0369873084,
-0.0508670993,
-0.0122239869,
-0.0095448941,
0.0083934236,
0.018289296,
0.0492034145,
-0.0002356755,
0.0128239011,
0.0609345883,
0.0065776943,
0.0123589355,
-0.0123945903,
0.0073531503,
-0.0447833985,
0.025405826,
0.0163473822,
-0.0093938848,
0.015215951,
0.045266144,
-0.0099445768,
-0.0290880296,
0.0196421109,
0.0189239159,
0.0807693377,
-0.0451456569,
-0.0505135208,
0.0589043833,
-0.026097253,
-0.1059002653,
-0.0021349574,
-0.0099553913,
0.0098980907,
0.0538963415,
0.0275007337,
0.0365236774,
-0.0343259685,
0.0111728767,
-0.0369165465,
-0.0243494194,
-0.046287898,
0.0305796489,
-0.0602433905,
-0.0568412058,
0.0195159633,
-0.0687301382,
0.0176092219,
-0.0343774632,
-0.0003111173,
-0.0344602354,
0.0567016974,
-0.006662393,
0.0243412126,
0.0180404428,
0.0137016522,
-0.0424623042,
0.0695556626,
0.0103186825,
-0.0401143879,
0.0549709648,
0.051814463,
0.0286486149,
-0.0070926836,
0.010294158,
-0.0313733593,
0.0513210408,
-0.0581239238,
0.0171159394,
0.0085158981,
-0.0612712689,
0.0465214923,
0.0392424949,
0.0091551878,
-0.0379180759,
0.0277580507,
-0.0082098106,
0.0412825756,
-0.037352439,
0.0666189715,
-0.0532666743,
-0.0466427281,
0.047936745,
0.0430080257,
0.0302037951,
0.0202198662,
-0.024526719,
0.0045361868,
-0.0396412946,
0.0763671175,
0.0591071099,
0.0372172892,
0.0233048107,
0.0259174071,
-0.0164352823,
0.0225046799,
0.0378121622,
0.0194532964,
-0.0072657452,
0.0379250608,
-0.0132921375,
0.0092549939,
0.0368312448,
0.0471164212,
0.0131065426,
0.0049865064,
-0.0122560849,
0.0071242424,
-0.0054794103,
0.0114056282,
0.0672314763,
0.0183724426,
0.0381526947,
-0.0482837856,
0.0231205095,
-0.0429444723,
0.003430879,
-0.0045652944,
-0.0344578251,
-0.0342827924,
0.019385647,
0.0135521619,
-0.0363838635,
0.0102390982,
-0.0628829002,
0.0347010382,
-0.004547501,
-0.0736863986,
0.0100823725,
-0.0182200093,
-0.0097425021,
-0.0519243293,
-0.0024734552,
-0.0734484196,
0.00093954,
-0.0346424542,
0.0030930189,
-0.0434927754,
0.0131929629,
-0.0428933464,
-0.0385963768,
0.0159926359,
0.015496227,
-0.0344187953,
-0.0515571274,
-0.0309010558,
0.0436580814,
-5.65903772e-33,
-0.0268440694,
0.0695468858,
0.0182516593,
-0.017125275,
-0.0262710787,
0.0149453748,
-0.0302857105,
-0.0025974223,
-0.0071447161,
-0.0272035953,
-0.028115252,
-0.0194409117,
0.0190969221,
0.0509552248,
0.002863694,
0.0674853101,
0.102464892,
0.0046222932,
0.0088318205,
0.0026616917,
0.0538081191,
0.0183749199,
0.0110388035,
-0.039401602,
-0.043237783,
-0.0190878771,
-0.0198005568,
-0.0183908921,
0.0278367288,
0.0309951883,
0.0213550217,
0.0573578775,
-0.0308935363,
-0.0130122919,
-0.0074425824,
0.0362791494,
-0.0963690579,
0.015507753,
-0.0408145525,
0.0676101446,
0.0055637998,
-0.0107000228,
0.0258650724,
-0.0241745282,
-0.0578172877,
0.0477023087,
-0.0180118047,
-0.0213922095,
-0.0359904543,
-0.0497484989,
0.0050007799,
0.0213489421,
0.0050868806,
-0.0008980075,
0.0705912635,
0.0722559616,
-0.0308053233,
-0.0548248477,
-0.0517390631,
0.0208992586,
0.0308225788,
0.0413973145,
0.0150024323,
0.0553428121,
0.0042916951,
-0.0219022483,
0.0545347407,
-0.1180339679,
0.0405962579,
0.0015791551,
0.0271462891,
0.0481187291,
-0.0058964873,
0.0404822528,
0.0277178045,
-0.0529198274,
0.022373097,
0.023969451,
0.0240369644,
0.0069163106,
0.0143417278,
0.062230885,
-0.012262933,
-0.0080058295,
-0.0159224439,
0.0088902311,
-0.0145305162,
-0.0455438495,
0.0801509917,
-0.0095831128,
-0.0057276124,
0.0214842986,
0.0665793195,
-0.0322364271,
0.0412395149,
0.008784242,
-0.0331795961,
0.0072786822,
-0.0117288893,
-0.0087226368,
-0.036378935,
-0.0273533929,
0.1023880765,
0.0115078883,
-0.0171007887,
-0.0281245485,
-0.0107779037,
0.06607797,
-0.0717352405,
-0.0017400002,
0.0263314322,
0.0410873778,
0.0150867486,
0.0403281562,
0.0122544831,
-0.0116819786,
0.0013108478,
0.0230475292,
-0.0168841016,
0.0195568129,
-0.0113296751,
-0.0047629755,
0.0276235938,
-0.0079950094,
-0.0491656363,
0.0493191183,
-0.0115418425,
-0.0321646929,
0.0179463252,
0.0015353842,
0.0004839829,
0.005034274,
2.6e-7,
-0.0346058309,
-0.0162092391,
0.0495943464,
-0.0548176058,
-0.0052231397,
-0.0098684886,
0.0022518914,
-0.0058585629,
0.0052296421,
0.0031689962,
0.0013262003,
-0.0154426359,
0.0877112001,
0.0090847192,
-0.0827277079,
-0.0264736228,
-0.0778178275,
0.0145299993,
0.0011390717,
0.0151143298,
0.0096480474,
0.0566722229,
-0.0353415161,
-0.0777660981,
0.000017801,
0.0008096058,
0.0337499417,
-0.0186151564,
0.0151773114,
0.0006187062,
0.0046326034,
-0.0238415729,
-0.0385948047,
-0.0216680374,
-0.0530736819,
0.0482501648,
-0.0007299384,
0.0388566218,
-0.0490324646,
-0.0652290061,
0.0137923062,
0.1035550237,
-0.0531218313,
0.0175126251,
0.0304177999,
0.0345865227,
-0.0201959945,
-0.0300392676,
-0.047844097,
0.0196983218,
-0.0481698401,
-0.0094505791,
0.0170332417,
-0.0250373576,
0.0222733449,
0.0033911937,
-0.0149693191,
-0.0086249914,
-0.0117144398,
-0.0208253004,
-0.0682116672,
-0.0238830112,
-0.0344281644,
0.0043950533,
-0.0220917929,
0.0140821934,
0.0028153032,
2.024386091e-34,
0.0224779882,
-0.0098957168,
0.027226733,
0.0010453535,
-0.0100604519,
-0.036867898,
0.054562442,
0.055237405,
-0.0197739489,
-0.062407475,
-0.0647981018
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14835v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14835v2 | Weak Alignment Supervision from Hybrid Model Improves End-to-end ASR | 2023-11-24T20:14:28 | 2023-11-30T20:18:56 | Jintao Jiang, Yingbo Gao, Zoltan Tuske | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS | In this paper, we aim to create weak alignment supervision from an existing
hybrid system to aid the end-to-end modeling of automatic speech recognition.
Towards this end, we use the existing hybrid ASR system to produce triphone
alignments of the training audios. We then create a cross-entropy loss at a
certain layer of the encoder using the derived alignments. In contrast to the
general one-hot cross-entropy losses, here we use a cross-entropy loss with a
label smoothing parameter to regularize the supervision. As a comparison, we
also conduct the experiments with one-hot cross-entropy losses and CTC losses
with loss weighting. The results show that placing the weak alignment
supervision with the label smoothing parameter of 0.5 at the third encoder
layer outperforms the other two approaches and leads to about 5\% relative WER
reduction on the TED-LIUM 2 dataset over the baseline. We see similar
improvements when applying the method out-of-the-box on a Tagalog end-to-end
ASR system. | [
-0.0255224463,
-0.0118695926,
0.0410471633,
0.0273642037,
0.0210652836,
0.0079497937,
0.0150576299,
-0.023276953,
-0.0074257143,
0.0443435945,
-0.0713766888,
-0.0474968515,
0.0281686969,
-0.0055545247,
0.0377902351,
-0.0388952196,
0.0034419301,
-0.0408367626,
-0.0083209453,
-0.0093812672,
0.0492049865,
-0.0233983118,
-0.0188483987,
0.0307642613,
-0.0271113589,
0.0055819131,
-0.0296422299,
0.0455375351,
0.0632045791,
-0.0070600314,
0.0123752588,
-0.0061748894,
0.0337066911,
0.0173356812,
0.0000018999,
-0.0146861384,
-0.0247756168,
0.0182079785,
-0.0463205911,
0.0014953928,
-0.0313767679,
-0.0219392311,
-0.0411754027,
0.0395331793,
0.0092264647,
-0.0040602647,
0.0998521075,
0.0537225977,
0.0210710615,
0.0680635795,
-0.001072167,
-0.0707696974,
-0.0018479024,
-0.0380229764,
-0.0143626146,
-0.0321744643,
-0.003395329,
-0.0176804494,
-0.0637655035,
-0.063466683,
-0.0282793529,
0.0581634603,
0.0152176525,
-0.0212841351,
0.0338766351,
-0.0094219549,
-0.0253550224,
-0.0267964583,
-0.005654335,
0.0389989242,
-0.0133831147,
-0.0283982363,
0.0231775623,
0.0128599172,
-0.0315258503,
-0.0653701723,
-0.02352993,
-0.0033164951,
0.0147391753,
0.0176475067,
-0.0006672402,
0.0332270302,
0.0384851806,
-0.0455492735,
-0.018177893,
0.003570033,
0.0025518232,
-0.0733402595,
0.0150345853,
0.0052566328,
0.008005782,
0.0155797191,
0.0510838628,
-0.0138495276,
0.0056096553,
0.0000478673,
-0.0486277267,
-0.0261519607,
-0.0139716929,
-0.0678272992,
-0.0054951753,
0.0702842399,
-0.0516000502,
0.0165846348,
-0.0139290905,
0.0699507371,
-0.022104511,
0.0565705523,
-0.015696384,
-0.0214165002,
0.0031260038,
-0.0106193544,
-0.0259567872,
0.0068377554,
0.0268944073,
-0.0146024292,
-0.0786476135,
0.0290490743,
-0.0136850746,
0.0382741801,
0.0600542873,
-0.0035478713,
-0.0824615806,
-0.0179329198,
0.0517617315,
0.0568781868,
0.0255238749,
0.0142777078,
0.0106234113,
-0.0312225055,
-0.0087559139,
0.0353579149,
0.0272692256,
-0.0052648508,
0.0109703531,
0.0768684745,
-0.0234350003,
-0.0075251744,
-0.0641067252,
0.0003375704,
-0.041651573,
-0.0385784768,
-0.0317184627,
-0.0168313216,
0.0632708147,
-0.0079778666,
-0.0089708949,
-0.0225599501,
-0.0104611451,
-0.0377648361,
0.0258226786,
0.0292669293,
-0.0080359792,
0.0015403915,
0.0350017659,
-0.0129537899,
0.0012921037,
0.074538298,
0.0499605015,
-0.0205771141,
-0.0188604761,
-0.0460742339,
-0.0423166938,
0.0763362125,
0.0187085029,
-0.0051374962,
-0.0260035489,
-0.0293047894,
0.0468849018,
0.0257661659,
0.0544959828,
0.056322027,
0.0017036153,
0.0029611147,
0.048188936,
-0.0111105964,
0.0574641265,
0.0264232066,
0.0170190297,
-0.0379673392,
-0.0162108224,
0.0306122284,
0.0159473252,
0.0164097901,
-0.0252223257,
0.0274726581,
0.0550502762,
0.0382680967,
-0.0393599533,
-0.0180140641,
-0.0019343606,
-0.0180734489,
-0.0303603727,
0.0104549956,
0.050749924,
-0.0189136714,
-0.0418817401,
0.0460427515,
0.0030768991,
-0.0680376589,
0.0149323111,
0.0017877989,
-0.0437485948,
0.0121110911,
0.0051519917,
0.0023634231,
-0.0459940955,
-0.0246309377,
-0.0106884725,
0.0414120033,
0.0185239427,
0.0308494959,
0.0513207316,
-0.109186016,
-0.0287619811,
0.055818785,
-0.0266409777,
0.0193979405,
-0.0358718671,
0.0127024585,
0.0229030401,
-0.0203238856,
0.0302053541,
0.0017452177,
0.0038903083,
0.0025831824,
-0.0202519484,
0.0685281679,
0.0616009682,
0.0576437302,
-0.0289195552,
-0.0179771911,
0.0429058373,
-0.0539752431,
0.0083996803,
0.0247158948,
-0.0756475627,
-0.0303028654,
0.0608278662,
-0.0330557972,
-0.0023878992,
0.0384704247,
0.0162610393,
-0.1031733975,
0.0123420879,
0.0002029043,
0.0460903458,
-0.0405125283,
0.0721301734,
0.0423916653,
-0.000103799,
-0.0075503332,
0.0042859651,
0.0267148837,
0.0220349617,
0.0174846482,
-0.0402057134,
-0.0148602389,
-0.0634231269,
0.0041640303,
0.0390464701,
-0.0247820225,
0.0127937142,
0.0161930323,
-0.0183928329,
0.0192461293,
-0.0274225697,
-0.0574456006,
0.0178523883,
-0.0241263025,
0.0493086129,
-0.0017694893,
0.0541327074,
0.0168125518,
-0.0299095567,
-0.045309782,
-0.0191018432,
-0.0358143598,
-0.0275157671,
-0.0320569202,
0.0126653118,
-0.0469572023,
0.0020522913,
0.0070838644,
0.0116712125,
-0.0033042668,
-0.0355226658,
-0.0746015683,
-0.0596112832,
0.0213497393,
0.0121224271,
0.0327553712,
0.0134303253,
-0.0353766568,
-0.0582393073,
0.0424365103,
0.0085083712,
0.0185854398,
-0.032274086,
-0.0144662289,
-0.023783965,
0.016312167,
-0.0531576648,
0.0101774959,
0.0196566042,
0.0037552931,
-0.0155623853,
0.0183702968,
-0.0667963028,
0.0550730228,
0.0198367536,
0.058661174,
-0.0871784464,
-0.0753699765,
0.0090025207,
-0.0312144142,
0.008412567,
-0.0257510766,
-0.0238259714,
-0.0184126049,
-0.0596399605,
-0.0055589639,
0.0328724422,
-0.0712703541,
-0.0612466298,
-0.0126902983,
-0.0707485676,
-0.0328294784,
-0.0242266692,
-0.0060154744,
0.0389527529,
-0.0145100001,
-0.0394874699,
-0.0567234457,
0.0066833212,
-0.0081071919,
-0.0238555223,
0.0246384423,
0.0180403721,
0.0071064052,
-0.0246947259,
-0.0282694753,
0.0257256608,
0.0429153442,
-0.0053768791,
0.0291774031,
0.0193018634,
-0.0139719341,
-0.0194154922,
0.0664643124,
0.0254681408,
0.0524760112,
0.0075040022,
0.0316525735,
-0.0329886451,
0.0549983047,
0.0391895585,
-0.0337405242,
-0.0681848377,
-0.0440032855,
0.0267470218,
-0.0133102927,
0.0718234777,
0.0109557696,
-0.0544631034,
-0.0408536382,
0.0353248417,
0.0112257265,
0.0129254134,
-0.0029952072,
0.0566365831,
-0.034284573,
0.0369219482,
0.060937915,
-0.0193263702,
-0.0496292524,
-0.0185225271,
0.0006710058,
0.0706603453,
-0.0171901546,
-0.0452019386,
-0.0276092552,
-0.0426317602,
0.0339408256,
0.0157851409,
0.0378140099,
0.0381535031,
0.026144363,
-0.0659687445,
-0.0264134109,
0.0536125824,
-0.0481553227,
-0.0387984402,
-0.0298679043,
-0.0077733933,
-0.0345892608,
0.0725377351,
0.0034281462,
0.0077592214,
-0.0461125188,
0.0871595591,
-0.0455342904,
-0.0495080687,
-0.066564098,
-0.0677897856,
0.073785387,
0.0766110942,
-0.0189120397,
0.0070787622,
-0.0605293326,
0.0664543286,
-0.0027066381,
-0.0008252297,
0.0168327074,
-0.0029686959,
-0.0114021096,
-0.0179411881,
0.0553279333,
0.0134373186,
-0.0262830816,
0.0631901994,
0.0118742809,
0.0793584511,
-0.010068682,
0.0319366902,
0.0229561385,
0.0007829233,
-0.0164802354,
0.0530104041,
-0.0144894999,
-0.0229326896,
-0.0080143046,
0.0120983226,
0.0666398257,
-0.0156938806,
0.0127333859,
0.0385713652,
-0.0521783754,
-0.1150417402,
0.0103870481,
-0.0025842111,
0.0030461969,
0.052862335,
0.0342290066,
0.0002170968,
-0.0259577502,
0.0100307986,
-0.0191611238,
-0.0180993322,
-0.0315176286,
0.0216198061,
-0.0464859344,
-0.0053383317,
-0.0021438019,
-0.0113232629,
0.0301315635,
0.0274305549,
-0.0382060967,
-0.1004531309,
-0.0092059355,
-0.031810008,
0.0139480885,
0.0751752034,
0.0043762308,
-0.0185866803,
0.035828732,
0.0116490675,
-0.0021428391,
0.0575910322,
0.0206953157,
-0.0400559381,
-0.01351956,
0.0251170266,
-0.0806035176,
-0.0263657309,
-0.0224291515,
0.0538181327,
-0.0009941504,
-0.0585750304,
0.0245324299,
0.0052088262,
0.0634932891,
-0.0126281967,
0.0077630072,
-0.0043508424,
0.0634721518,
0.0099251373,
0.0347268656,
-0.0178011209,
-0.029686803,
0.0301673301,
0.0297834612,
0.0275972616,
0.0341835432,
0.0007090586,
-0.0117606921,
0.0023052653,
0.0469186306,
-0.0293821488,
0.0010127585,
-0.0126097426,
0.0166276731,
-0.0142100221,
0.0426465087,
0.0540583767,
0.0085630063,
-0.0050382074,
0.0234952588,
0.0233507231,
0.0576383434,
0.0246045403,
0.0254989434,
-0.0131463706,
-0.0077374233,
-0.0335013643,
-0.0189013314,
0.0278445072,
0.0184758473,
0.054705888,
0.024935862,
0.004762427,
-0.0202498529,
0.0283092931,
-0.0277297087,
-0.0133499783,
0.05095746,
-0.0201892499,
-0.0127894199,
0.0405377261,
0.0213804245,
0.0010391101,
0.0499699563,
-0.0532975234,
0.0251260065,
-0.0035884746,
-0.0083276751,
0.0316701941,
-0.011749519,
-0.0296057463,
-0.0497682914,
0.0155286826,
-0.0644931644,
0.0122367609,
-0.0282166433,
0.0452532992,
0.0041023348,
0.0298353396,
-0.0004309749,
-0.0479323566,
0.0003018306,
0.049688641,
-0.0700498149,
0.0363810919,
-0.0043031606,
0.009545505,
-6.478486587e-33,
-0.0327973329,
0.0636915863,
-0.0052859941,
-0.0089719212,
-0.0522644557,
0.0107642133,
-0.0102607319,
-0.0037895432,
-0.0010942504,
-0.0293287374,
0.0178926382,
-0.009763604,
0.0419801399,
0.0069047902,
-0.0025464774,
-0.0182034727,
0.1007896513,
-0.0225478131,
0.0025162925,
-0.0223765541,
0.0244908165,
0.030235339,
0.0339061767,
-0.0579746589,
-0.0330480374,
0.0192457158,
-0.0175503679,
-0.0125843845,
0.033879824,
0.0215939898,
0.0061025661,
0.0171691235,
-0.025587013,
-0.041839242,
0.0155134387,
0.0320520177,
-0.0678492263,
0.0281635486,
-0.0162157472,
0.0752751753,
-0.0064513185,
-0.0627859309,
0.0381399542,
0.0055837496,
-0.0304274578,
-0.0272195227,
0.0322007574,
-0.0097378697,
-0.0348540395,
-0.0864006504,
0.0053639421,
0.0374243371,
-0.0353477709,
-0.0244084485,
0.0609763078,
0.0416488163,
-0.0126357721,
-0.02557173,
-0.0504320003,
-0.0117444647,
0.0149571309,
0.0488378368,
0.0607009344,
0.0398415588,
-0.0107566155,
-0.0005999508,
0.0363253988,
-0.046588365,
0.0216395725,
-0.0657052398,
0.0059059518,
-0.0156999715,
0.0122077046,
-0.0175083838,
0.0326553173,
0.0164858494,
-0.0330357105,
-0.0106126545,
0.0160303228,
0.020547403,
0.0010270525,
0.0951671079,
-0.0607809797,
-0.0012937663,
-0.006688958,
-0.0444779396,
-0.0301541593,
-0.0521762222,
0.0473864712,
0.0141632156,
0.0126620801,
0.0258647688,
0.0612419546,
-0.0196695384,
0.0648467392,
0.0056158872,
-0.0108626336,
0.0007459224,
-0.0282854885,
0.0011097455,
-0.0615952536,
-0.0564562641,
0.0303451866,
0.0401084498,
0.0130308261,
-0.0239524674,
0.0559248105,
0.0607899018,
-0.0507426262,
-0.0184688456,
-0.0163019095,
-0.0201186612,
0.0043295557,
-0.0182580128,
0.0383970849,
-0.0357075557,
0.0039808047,
0.0664743185,
0.0010602415,
0.0265662409,
-0.007740851,
0.0124380831,
0.0352977514,
0.0042931437,
-0.012903193,
0.0291273277,
0.0327247754,
-0.0398601443,
0.0229628067,
-0.0307493918,
-0.0195565708,
-0.0054236236,
2.785e-7,
-0.0354263932,
-0.0248321407,
0.0587705784,
-0.0279308967,
-0.0248725489,
0.0258171745,
-0.0131790396,
0.0159004703,
-0.0269575696,
-0.0226748325,
0.0205378607,
-0.0302744899,
0.0760439187,
-0.0162941292,
-0.1018617824,
-0.0368080772,
-0.0557899736,
0.0293245558,
-0.0002248739,
0.0426055789,
0.0075610611,
0.1044213548,
-0.0292725451,
-0.0286104176,
-0.0018862989,
-0.0089964401,
0.0153229451,
0.0094980951,
0.0058932127,
-0.0097435741,
0.0404552557,
-0.043225877,
-0.0368863493,
0.0201229881,
-0.0288651697,
0.028884327,
0.0328931212,
0.0035722051,
-0.0485301279,
-0.0383686908,
0.0322832949,
0.064711757,
-0.0267954599,
-0.0019225273,
0.0374400988,
0.0175698474,
-0.0257289186,
-0.0178480893,
-0.0707456991,
0.0152288657,
-0.0162146259,
0.0089895567,
0.0329937972,
0.0053235465,
0.0147181507,
0.0042712162,
-0.0438839495,
-0.0214871261,
-0.0095359907,
0.0208050404,
-0.0259452704,
0.0063384501,
0.0028056595,
0.0378152691,
0.0106846299,
-0.0203460585,
-0.0156922881,
2.393807231e-34,
0.0098928269,
-0.051105693,
0.0350025743,
0.0255733114,
-0.0031707066,
-0.0786319971,
0.0086789178,
0.0209158063,
-0.0375844203,
-0.0268235039,
-0.0350272991
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14808v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14808v1 | Data-to-Text Bilingual Generation | 2023-11-24T19:05:57 | 2023-11-24T19:05:57 | Guy Lapalme | cs.CL | cs.CL, I.2.7 | This document illustrates the use of pyrealb for generating two parallel
texts (English and French) from a single source of data. The data selection and
text organisation processes are shared between the two languages. only language
dependent word and phrasing choices are distinct processes. The realized texts
thus convey identical information in both languages without the risk of being
lost in translation. This is especially important in cases where strict and
simultaneous bilingualism is required. We first present the types of
applications targeted by this approach and how the pyrealb English and French
realizer can be used for achieving this goal in a natural way. We describe an
object-oriented organization to ensure a convenient realization in both
languages. To illustrate the process, different types of applications are then
briefly sketched with links to the source code. A brief comparison of the text
generation is given with the output of an instance of a GPT. | [
-0.0023139683,
0.0345526412,
-0.0069910912,
0.0581019372,
-0.0399785526,
-0.0023971652,
0.0039305026,
-0.0171678644,
-0.0069661979,
-0.0178533755,
-0.0582123213,
-0.0093852598,
0.0167077556,
-0.0157903545,
0.0040348661,
-0.093859151,
0.0346798599,
0.0056441389,
-0.0548018441,
0.0047011669,
0.0383346938,
0.0720755756,
0.025131166,
-0.0060691074,
0.0184636842,
-0.0084225126,
-0.0224153064,
0.0102582397,
0.037875779,
0.0182322711,
-0.0427050442,
0.0240540169,
0.0058596665,
0.0248420518,
0.0000021749,
-0.0333336182,
-0.0472874008,
0.0400707908,
0.0313270912,
-0.0131764729,
0.0875492394,
-0.0391282514,
-0.021766521,
0.008370392,
0.0005094783,
-0.0085453745,
0.0607279204,
-0.0145631758,
0.0549419709,
0.0251891669,
-0.0183868837,
-0.0516859628,
-0.048903469,
0.0376473442,
0.0012276584,
0.0313518569,
-0.0261387825,
0.011219535,
0.0523886904,
0.007653771,
0.0296743885,
0.0277863573,
-0.0084381634,
-0.0109328926,
-0.0447241068,
0.0091388496,
-0.0341060236,
-0.0411781222,
-0.0150613254,
0.0200776719,
-0.0158224832,
-0.0729558095,
0.0123074669,
-0.0010700071,
-0.0219417997,
-0.0209960807,
-0.0282979477,
0.0224222615,
-0.0262317769,
0.0107398797,
0.0637995377,
-0.0043737539,
-0.011327656,
-0.0342931822,
-0.087105982,
0.0174136944,
0.0400077961,
-0.0177719891,
-0.0226446204,
0.0426293574,
0.0356595255,
-0.0628691092,
0.044636745,
0.0368025415,
0.0025846774,
0.0174969193,
-0.0825182498,
-0.0769599155,
0.0131708896,
-0.1122853458,
0.0063246316,
0.0329902098,
0.0049897479,
0.03159073,
0.0025053935,
0.0416389108,
-0.0192126818,
0.0037903043,
-0.0528148189,
-0.0207732841,
-0.028597869,
0.0092991013,
-0.0696017072,
-0.0084344652,
-0.0523590855,
0.0029454487,
-0.0207782667,
0.0414413735,
-0.0020329989,
0.0230378844,
0.0299580693,
-0.0333260782,
-0.026693387,
0.024292957,
-0.016026631,
-0.0097848224,
-0.0013810386,
-0.0507510714,
-0.032925535,
-0.051472988,
0.0113848997,
0.0398921818,
-0.003884068,
-0.0152662331,
-0.0479012467,
0.0922916234,
-0.0588332526,
0.0274504013,
-0.0276156981,
-0.034182746,
0.025872387,
-0.0725462884,
-0.0255865045,
-0.0930628031,
0.035239283,
0.0299941376,
0.007325442,
-0.0020490438,
0.0429525077,
0.0370733142,
0.0178925972,
0.0505435541,
-0.0353874303,
-0.0029040989,
0.0153981112,
-0.0041774325,
0.0486720614,
0.0800699517,
0.0273888689,
-0.0179830194,
0.0054105772,
-0.020520661,
-0.0079333624,
0.0243197642,
-0.0046670036,
-0.0107462602,
-0.035952393,
-0.0032867636,
0.0350939855,
-0.0123123033,
-0.0160466842,
0.0736277252,
-0.0147749828,
0.0520820729,
0.021294741,
-0.0241423231,
0.0393642597,
0.0750585943,
0.0864189565,
0.0611774027,
-0.0042103403,
0.0120059419,
0.0198498107,
0.0543865934,
0.0084336102,
0.0111895753,
-0.0231078733,
0.053959053,
-0.009332438,
-0.0247262102,
0.0010348919,
-0.0027019132,
0.05057206,
-0.019640686,
0.0526681095,
0.0407242328,
-0.039692834,
0.0276974887,
0.0066972454,
-0.0729940534,
0.0167222079,
0.0184955634,
-0.0066196597,
0.1017313227,
0.0053819888,
-0.0035259293,
0.0447047353,
0.0046421653,
-0.0122598391,
0.0568406209,
0.0479413867,
-0.0311553217,
0.0262936503,
-0.0678091794,
-0.0085794926,
0.0036138252,
-0.0274153017,
0.064090088,
-0.0034447254,
0.0664251447,
0.0313453227,
0.0253349319,
0.0040065083,
0.0139853684,
-0.0244673938,
0.0005182821,
-0.0194249153,
0.0074255136,
-0.0101395715,
0.0370482765,
-0.0386598632,
0.0142692933,
0.0321239568,
0.0061545782,
0.0158795416,
0.0385411046,
-0.0039278297,
0.0125945797,
0.0042352662,
-0.058652319,
0.0344971418,
-0.0475047417,
-0.0071718162,
-0.0466916673,
-0.0120856883,
-0.0216685161,
0.0374239646,
0.0025732326,
0.0457314812,
-0.012476122,
0.0027038995,
0.0006051558,
0.0294375401,
0.029187113,
0.0036949194,
0.0330149233,
0.0026500258,
0.0499970466,
-0.0351555236,
-0.0028965713,
0.0645397529,
0.0307536535,
0.0149012767,
0.0253296494,
0.0372684821,
-0.0053707776,
-0.0360582508,
-0.0623379759,
-0.0205549728,
-0.0135708563,
0.0322877541,
0.0691238418,
0.0073891338,
0.0275233313,
-0.0130140912,
-0.0437891483,
0.0194872487,
0.0082501033,
-0.0076672002,
0.0311012603,
-0.0003732033,
-0.0136146452,
0.0261140615,
0.0068473276,
0.0344645754,
0.0198708475,
0.0474829972,
-0.0543508306,
-0.1074106768,
0.0093558179,
-0.0553655028,
-0.0052017621,
0.0358536951,
-0.0285875816,
0.0232975055,
0.0002541827,
0.0762669146,
0.016052505,
-0.012517198,
0.006922265,
0.069068782,
-0.0187823288,
-0.0266577583,
-0.0088296086,
-0.0142086893,
-0.0065867077,
0.0253539141,
-0.0730359778,
-0.0000732415,
0.0171880685,
0.0156482588,
0.0226038061,
-0.0364605263,
-0.0099233622,
-0.0238930043,
-0.0285015423,
-0.011843103,
-0.01219007,
0.0016687416,
0.0045550331,
-0.0275763758,
-0.0039300942,
0.0490387753,
-0.0460322499,
0.0088308211,
-0.0619601272,
-0.0404281914,
-0.0251523182,
0.050459154,
-0.0275953747,
0.0267041139,
-0.0220934357,
-0.0170094948,
-0.0291294772,
0.0252488125,
0.008119612,
-0.0154573936,
0.029157605,
-0.0792984739,
-0.0114408405,
-0.0230490398,
-0.0357146561,
-0.0234985314,
0.0515839756,
0.0014036876,
-0.0200395454,
0.0616666377,
-0.0150979823,
-0.0041559245,
0.0037832214,
0.0557388738,
0.0524903163,
0.0034055635,
-0.0007345364,
-0.0047730887,
-0.0339192376,
-0.041358389,
-0.0428784229,
-0.0549004562,
-0.0556387305,
-0.0217652488,
0.0113942474,
-0.0221448671,
-0.067481339,
0.0112821031,
-0.0223514959,
0.0240645688,
0.0103913518,
-0.0734179467,
-0.0337852165,
0.0135171246,
-0.0358261205,
-0.0395706855,
0.0596863478,
0.0371644907,
-0.0221989006,
-0.0170963146,
-0.0308659431,
0.0111310408,
0.023770133,
0.0470648929,
-0.0876944214,
0.0328254364,
-0.0317243449,
0.0317156054,
-0.018351797,
0.0433966815,
-0.0477703959,
-0.0529637933,
0.0348155424,
0.0307120625,
-0.0321171097,
-0.0057857484,
0.0252506454,
-0.0426702499,
0.0040400797,
-0.0358222499,
0.0023336015,
0.0150729083,
-0.0024202513,
-0.0176306777,
-0.0151613541,
0.0169422105,
-0.0629870519,
0.0066933585,
-0.0132058291,
0.0676785856,
0.0546835884,
-0.0082743708,
-0.0104571637,
-0.0150243128,
-0.0265535656,
-0.0160922203,
-0.020491736,
0.0097390208,
0.0559765324,
-0.052017279,
-0.0303331595,
-0.0151014207,
0.0321701951,
-0.0131532336,
-0.0092758453,
0.0062619303,
-0.0282356553,
0.0085091079,
-0.0004517281,
0.0267367642,
0.0399029963,
0.0009397357,
0.0034612264,
-0.0032606721,
-0.0812914446,
-0.0411494412,
-0.0343810171,
-0.0760125741,
-0.0124928877,
0.0077169803,
-0.0735693201,
-0.0874192789,
-0.0693732947,
0.002699021,
0.0208789334,
0.028128542,
0.0355337486,
0.0313051715,
0.0128672337,
-0.0383028686,
-0.0554860346,
-0.0527021624,
-0.0156071354,
0.0190372523,
-0.0690705627,
-0.0902331024,
0.0038684544,
-0.0569512174,
-0.0131343426,
0.0461851135,
-0.0482415818,
-0.0489650369,
0.0349934585,
0.0436047614,
0.0271758474,
0.0314756855,
-0.0093083745,
-0.0046042507,
0.0224013925,
0.056617327,
0.0152564729,
0.0017154339,
-0.0226522889,
0.0491824187,
-0.0046629384,
-0.0012222312,
-0.0212214999,
0.0077841403,
-0.0043510343,
-0.0078909481,
0.0247161333,
-0.0109783532,
0.0325144604,
0.0630739927,
-0.0506996363,
-0.0187981687,
-0.0089155044,
-0.0116387252,
-0.0018574442,
-0.0779323131,
-0.0426299907,
-0.0421979353,
0.0111867161,
0.0381200761,
-0.0466331579,
0.0362097025,
-0.0248003677,
-0.0061057024,
-0.0187100712,
0.0189133435,
0.051136598,
0.0030483583,
0.0567419119,
0.0486388132,
0.0353959315,
-0.0334694386,
0.0164466836,
-0.0008948018,
0.0538938269,
-0.063939184,
0.0420140997,
0.0085370345,
-0.0091381865,
-0.003763055,
0.0405689403,
0.0068143536,
0.0055771591,
-0.0358623751,
0.015182347,
0.0465989597,
0.0236570183,
0.0817778558,
-0.033536192,
-0.0126376124,
-0.0171907414,
0.0802486166,
0.0011269934,
-0.0369347781,
-0.0464264229,
-0.0277362559,
0.0004876814,
-0.0828957111,
0.0531430058,
-0.0331497528,
-0.0522447415,
0.0054592751,
-0.0370289832,
-0.0501483567,
-0.0225367416,
0.0081235021,
-0.0265249442,
-0.0428335704,
-0.0288239047,
-0.0275898315,
-0.0411472246,
-0.0137850316,
0.07313063,
0.0112402719,
-0.0398359299,
0.0334529243,
0.0369716659,
0.0008289332,
0.0157105252,
-0.0101186559,
0.0762545168,
0.0151859885,
-0.0410435759,
0.0231204648,
-5.808486766e-33,
-0.0615898669,
-0.0046250243,
0.0019841676,
-0.0061794664,
-0.0013483573,
-0.0327026993,
-0.0259443298,
-0.0118388506,
0.0106489118,
0.0135900266,
0.032058496,
-0.0213719029,
0.0430353843,
-0.0142210079,
0.0022724103,
0.0136337318,
0.0379239134,
0.0204040948,
-0.041368328,
0.0413937122,
0.1038097888,
-0.0068985294,
0.0822092146,
-0.0553858355,
0.0167657714,
-0.0691473633,
0.0093963929,
-0.0235052016,
-0.0277070794,
0.0209732894,
0.0239001457,
0.0344641581,
-0.0086061088,
0.0288379416,
-0.0497221909,
0.0342010371,
-0.0502106212,
-0.0525374413,
0.0044286,
0.0408437625,
-0.0469133891,
-0.0123247933,
0.0147492783,
-0.0478661135,
0.0007162044,
0.0368858352,
-0.0097422944,
-0.0005960398,
-0.0057113767,
0.0225301534,
-0.1057921499,
0.0061937198,
0.015929848,
0.0285553951,
0.0746657252,
0.0435327925,
-0.0300123952,
-0.0807647556,
-0.0305989981,
0.0216708109,
0.0045406255,
0.0024116719,
0.0778874531,
0.0227833055,
0.0013477342,
-0.0155699933,
0.0515259728,
0.0307361893,
0.0067377589,
0.0635519624,
-0.0201265048,
0.0157991778,
0.0329024941,
0.0528303012,
-0.0379863419,
-0.0363746956,
-0.0393692479,
0.0382279716,
0.0128113329,
-0.0594760031,
-0.0051169102,
0.0148798553,
0.0114795743,
-0.0300997235,
-0.0253572781,
0.0338121168,
-0.0152070606,
-0.0295266397,
-0.0001533684,
-0.0007992508,
-0.0167015828,
0.0137452558,
0.017812172,
0.0034226147,
-0.0300937369,
-0.0009590545,
-0.0122776739,
0.0140407719,
-0.0035210191,
0.0545394458,
-0.0303345006,
-0.0372759253,
0.0159451701,
0.0184133761,
0.0356342196,
0.0433029048,
-0.0278694611,
0.0180392712,
-0.0424983017,
0.0489810854,
-0.0509458594,
0.0214693602,
-0.0062823221,
0.00211599,
0.0147543205,
-0.0148511222,
0.0121780075,
-0.0025498194,
0.0453844257,
-0.0836623237,
0.0052505187,
-0.0047675115,
0.016502101,
0.0331359431,
-0.0298159458,
0.0646907538,
-0.0476227887,
-0.0226961747,
0.0661595017,
-0.0165719707,
-0.0260836706,
0.0290680807,
2.892e-7,
0.0634128749,
0.0059057381,
0.0374857709,
0.0787102282,
-0.0157322921,
-0.0171336494,
-0.0144980252,
0.0700043216,
0.0027290913,
0.0414090119,
-0.0262682941,
-0.0239370037,
0.044186417,
0.0420089588,
-0.0721052215,
0.046226006,
0.0171838291,
-0.0003029839,
-0.0635563731,
0.0134864934,
0.0939741284,
0.0303738043,
0.0018285689,
0.0047588279,
-0.011679722,
0.0241500698,
0.0251301881,
-0.0064451881,
0.0415506363,
-0.0140352258,
-0.0422096327,
0.0114640351,
-0.0285474434,
0.0425603241,
-0.0339945517,
-0.0348913223,
0.0245901681,
0.0272131488,
-0.0360983089,
0.0639871284,
0.0660188347,
-0.0524320118,
-0.0268441159,
-0.0658405274,
0.0212325156,
-0.0018784353,
0.0152024738,
0.0391726978,
-0.0431340635,
0.0124083105,
-0.0317881554,
-0.0026904563,
-0.0566051304,
0.0278008264,
0.0362928025,
0.0350423157,
-0.0248659775,
-0.0082024708,
-0.0055172369,
-0.0167416148,
-0.001077845,
-0.0293122996,
-0.0244672131,
0.0290952865,
-0.0160679165,
-0.0242782198,
0.007818047,
2.72592089e-34,
-0.0209097043,
-0.0181863792,
-0.0233799592,
-0.0223532841,
0.0361443423,
-0.0165619645,
0.0356479362,
0.0283026807,
-0.0100138793,
-0.0040966403,
-0.0382289067
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14788v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14788v1 | Evaluating Large Language Models through Gender and Racial Stereotypes | 2023-11-24T18:41:16 | 2023-11-24T18:41:16 | Ananya Malik | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY | Language Models have ushered a new age of AI gaining traction within the NLP
community as well as amongst the general population. AI's ability to make
predictions, generations and its applications in sensitive decision-making
scenarios, makes it even more important to study these models for possible
biases that may exist and that can be exaggerated. We conduct a quality
comparative study and establish a framework to evaluate language models under
the premise of two kinds of biases: gender and race, in a professional setting.
We find out that while gender bias has reduced immensely in newer models, as
compared to older ones, racial bias still exists. | [
0.0613747239,
0.1147663966,
-0.0333562903,
0.0099219261,
-0.0257655624,
0.0126234433,
0.0615841039,
-0.0204468016,
0.0196789503,
-0.0927136019,
0.0015783969,
-0.0572943203,
0.0255810302,
0.0442470573,
-0.0037577632,
-0.0313234106,
0.0256982725,
0.0272656754,
0.0458649509,
-0.0347797833,
-0.0061179576,
0.0336147472,
0.0164437518,
0.0779162347,
-0.0200796984,
-0.0259625744,
0.0651803166,
-0.0256405361,
-0.0399538241,
0.0148340203,
0.0342372656,
0.0739820898,
-0.0095036691,
0.0341406204,
0.0000018995,
-0.0744332075,
0.019948395,
0.0094613563,
-0.0329383537,
0.0071902475,
0.0752319768,
0.0085759889,
-0.0319254696,
0.0213153213,
-0.0635649934,
0.0147203645,
0.0343590975,
0.0119210063,
0.0116560068,
0.0174803119,
-0.012481356,
0.012292874,
-0.02702149,
-0.0101509485,
-0.042711135,
-0.0238299593,
0.0476126224,
-0.0232062917,
-0.0277378317,
-0.0542572625,
-0.012339578,
0.0096700173,
-0.0026769226,
-0.0018774864,
0.0115830489,
0.0225281417,
-0.0270263385,
-0.0324291065,
-0.0186581649,
0.0098802298,
-0.0001967521,
0.0037797238,
-0.0119519765,
0.0055651409,
0.0171492323,
0.0161694735,
-0.0173833091,
0.0319991559,
0.0020285023,
-0.0199699458,
0.0008422327,
-0.0119058378,
0.0196904726,
0.0535578206,
-0.0076942509,
0.0984103233,
0.0070071663,
-0.0413748398,
0.0283571351,
0.0101036159,
0.0323213749,
-0.0517009534,
0.0047476697,
-0.0152942361,
-0.0261018462,
0.0237037726,
-0.0041572666,
0.0086304024,
0.0152708702,
-0.0740852207,
0.0288102888,
0.0331867449,
0.0340586416,
-0.0002923972,
-0.0036063034,
0.0469031669,
0.0225504022,
-0.0228491798,
-0.0103450539,
-0.0197687466,
-0.0346365571,
-0.0224261638,
-0.0070278579,
-0.0186799467,
0.0088624358,
0.0224650037,
-0.0473016463,
-0.0330932662,
-0.0728780776,
0.0184693616,
0.0071924939,
0.0268396903,
-0.016971983,
-0.0220747422,
-0.0586463138,
-0.0158036798,
-0.0438310392,
0.0176403169,
-0.0420913212,
-0.1030627936,
0.0345419832,
0.0019415221,
-0.0371673778,
-0.0251405351,
-0.013157282,
0.0538897328,
0.0030684369,
-0.0133876782,
-0.0191986803,
-0.00203551,
-0.0363274962,
-0.0648972839,
-0.0087424386,
-0.0468099341,
0.004407512,
0.0262576956,
0.0120760798,
-0.0781924948,
-0.0062726373,
0.0270862747,
-0.0609700903,
0.0454962179,
0.0387542322,
0.0188955572,
0.0541764013,
0.0081940424,
-0.0329669639,
0.0850241333,
0.0342223905,
0.007777771,
0.0410057306,
-0.0248194225,
0.0006480461,
0.0350138322,
-0.000314851,
0.0220500324,
-0.0516992882,
0.0294087995,
-0.0163550917,
0.0073629608,
0.041861169,
0.0495162681,
0.0271280594,
-0.024919793,
0.0381000005,
0.074071981,
-0.0035661715,
0.054991968,
0.0565939657,
-0.0108997058,
0.0078133689,
0.0042401929,
-0.0705860183,
-0.0276568681,
-0.012866199,
-0.0559189804,
-0.0151075041,
0.0589108281,
0.009721362,
-0.0511946119,
-0.0208376125,
0.0118343085,
0.0364001133,
-0.0002465569,
0.0121603794,
-0.0016617696,
-0.0013465431,
0.0215358268,
0.0348855518,
-0.0079144193,
-0.0479000472,
-0.063252762,
-0.0010759856,
0.07117448,
-0.0073452615,
-0.0004569471,
-0.0007000436,
-0.0130223827,
-0.0593421422,
0.0500717983,
0.0794312358,
0.0084240101,
-0.0052516335,
-0.0337535813,
0.0163233709,
0.0392401367,
0.0521558374,
0.0206334088,
0.0636188164,
0.0711291134,
0.008769461,
-0.0151602142,
-0.0792784467,
0.0312494189,
-0.0495331697,
-0.0320439339,
-0.000174169,
-0.0078038545,
0.0346701182,
0.0187207684,
-0.0267572422,
0.0236881934,
-0.0312595293,
0.0027946678,
-0.0077865785,
0.0194878411,
-0.0605144836,
0.0418516956,
0.0272810198,
-0.0355673805,
-0.0446059108,
0.0248625986,
0.0112951975,
0.0120225195,
0.0647456795,
-0.004751429,
0.0184378289,
-0.00691653,
0.0243718456,
-0.0432735942,
0.0263869427,
-0.0212377124,
0.0360464603,
-0.0274798218,
-0.0317860991,
0.025400728,
-0.0237796083,
0.0103814378,
-0.0364487693,
-0.0527640991,
0.0364583731,
0.0152142039,
0.0093277153,
0.0201284271,
-0.0198280811,
-0.0321516618,
-0.0011028508,
-0.0881725177,
-0.0072879,
-0.0073976009,
-0.0193570927,
-0.0354895107,
-0.0246866196,
-0.0434390977,
-0.0018781252,
-0.0082087098,
-0.0400567763,
0.0106072221,
0.0438852087,
0.0061446005,
-0.0211961083,
-0.0048511955,
-0.049566634,
-0.0450385734,
-0.043047566,
0.0756599829,
0.0352020375,
0.0057574981,
-0.0238391366,
0.0139861153,
-0.0333857015,
0.0191122126,
-0.0025387343,
-0.0108937686,
0.0218841154,
0.0217856169,
0.0380762517,
0.0761565045,
0.0157649852,
0.048843015,
0.05379235,
-0.0094488086,
-0.0364054181,
-0.0196922105,
0.0217765179,
0.0231143814,
0.0174424741,
-0.0836616829,
-0.0042986874,
0.0515406802,
0.0263294559,
-0.0307262056,
-0.0551725999,
0.081118539,
-0.0858187675,
-0.0486641303,
-0.0161546711,
-0.0348841771,
-0.0003092806,
0.0495277569,
-0.0283315815,
-0.0709391236,
0.0483285896,
0.0119780181,
0.0287258942,
-0.0182225518,
-0.0268427022,
-0.0508500561,
0.0441492423,
-0.0208023693,
0.0168431625,
0.0329658203,
0.0129299555,
-0.0584022738,
-0.0299439188,
-0.003237329,
-0.0348026231,
0.0470669866,
-0.0405029319,
0.0097820051,
0.0231692307,
-0.0245467033,
-0.0411045775,
-0.0290842801,
-0.0520177074,
0.027800709,
0.0391793475,
-0.0297058392,
-0.0293223821,
0.0125392396,
-0.0044927681,
0.0048540034,
-0.0153229944,
-0.0132447109,
0.0264817812,
-0.0306818336,
0.0364269465,
-0.0065995487,
0.0509968251,
0.0031154924,
0.0243552253,
0.0051906984,
-0.0139618786,
0.0402192064,
-0.0411536396,
0.00360997,
0.0320511125,
-0.0513289571,
-0.0275660828,
0.0088059148,
0.0021958835,
-0.0613791011,
0.0431074165,
0.0950926468,
0.0182930119,
-0.0600454323,
0.0189496484,
-0.0242867749,
0.0122884959,
0.0241675004,
0.0078204116,
-0.0734210089,
0.0172645282,
0.0155528914,
0.0057135439,
-0.0378916152,
-0.0466094464,
-0.0214571878,
-0.1271187365,
0.0133496886,
-0.000053109,
-0.0197387803,
-0.017096607,
-0.0228781365,
-0.0028850012,
-0.0189305935,
0.0583054237,
-0.0024578914,
-0.0061647152,
0.0059815818,
0.0105649102,
-0.08429984,
-0.0546856895,
0.0684669614,
-0.041734606,
0.0593484193,
0.0421124212,
0.0449427329,
-0.0299157836,
-0.0001433557,
0.0213872734,
0.0033605711,
0.0098415818,
-0.0240662508,
0.025425056,
-0.0365904607,
0.0073702224,
-0.0382759422,
0.0007233919,
0.0009858945,
0.0282530021,
0.0212093182,
0.0149159711,
0.0223487634,
-0.0654878169,
-0.0645476729,
-0.0011967195,
-0.0144401342,
0.1007766426,
-0.0011515748,
-0.0541256629,
-0.0484200902,
-0.0670617893,
0.0160738435,
0.0224932022,
-0.0702301115,
0.0324965082,
0.0164099801,
-0.0266405139,
-0.0191007517,
-0.0629276633,
0.0329709724,
-0.0262973551,
0.0184303131,
-0.0412233733,
0.0190957934,
-0.0140412822,
-0.0467643961,
0.0292316321,
-0.0130137606,
0.0515411645,
-0.0062306253,
-0.0090931989,
-0.0029576633,
-0.0034336816,
-0.0093475198,
0.0069748312,
-0.0216364954,
-0.0390824601,
0.0673945025,
0.0438400209,
0.0296425503,
0.0134760952,
-0.0000435179,
-0.0584869534,
0.0231098887,
0.0265047066,
0.0023236864,
0.0209800657,
0.0168298744,
0.0335928276,
0.014870448,
0.0315956473,
-0.0282050688,
0.0514041409,
-0.0030660098,
-0.0006397053,
-0.0287875421,
-0.0281023346,
0.0088000949,
0.0071038865,
-0.0162535943,
-0.047175955,
-0.0041550775,
-0.0146457516,
-0.0266723651,
-0.0221849885,
-0.0546598509,
-0.0123691382,
-0.0372525379,
0.0209819172,
0.0458337069,
-0.0194187555,
-0.0227055643,
-0.0401863195,
0.0155999865,
-0.0154465027,
0.0529851429,
0.0331312045,
0.0455714278,
0.0209641177,
0.0029715979,
-0.012808118,
0.0157905556,
-0.0428569317,
0.0311503448,
0.0405813754,
0.0393829904,
0.008573167,
-0.0031165674,
-0.0128599023,
0.0111467605,
-0.0305625368,
-0.0453150421,
0.0155848395,
0.0046053031,
0.0228639282,
-0.0412754491,
0.0343552679,
-0.0149119599,
0.0129573531,
0.000674811,
-0.0254424047,
0.0463839583,
-0.0066923317,
0.039322488,
0.0001834,
-0.0075854668,
0.015329767,
0.0672284588,
0.054864388,
0.0573565587,
-0.0174833033,
-0.0461313948,
-0.0188768338,
-0.034529753,
0.0324563533,
-0.0263081752,
-0.0099782795,
-0.0105566205,
-0.1198896989,
-0.0565508604,
-0.0037319693,
-0.0109825609,
0.033400517,
-0.021680953,
-0.0000526131,
0.0729741827,
0.0002915805,
-0.0237895641,
-0.0320795327,
-0.0068603638,
-0.0204514768,
0.0039795553,
-0.0448936634,
-6.01287805e-33,
-0.0115949046,
-0.0590420999,
-0.0181248281,
-0.0338387191,
-0.0056661624,
-0.0014059151,
0.0137769859,
0.0133800535,
-0.044416707,
0.0172979608,
-0.0062898924,
0.0267345291,
0.0027781434,
-0.016135145,
0.0290737506,
0.0137408916,
0.044080127,
-0.0055725817,
-0.0088985432,
-0.0402502716,
-0.026475545,
0.0117209461,
0.0201227684,
-0.0485698953,
0.1012106165,
0.001031911,
-0.0159724522,
-0.0037755226,
-0.0325137526,
0.0379037336,
-0.0418498479,
0.075795114,
0.0374123491,
-0.0474241525,
0.0176233724,
0.0419463105,
-0.0218500476,
-0.0137915649,
0.0219712369,
0.0201310273,
0.0339402258,
-0.0208940189,
0.0267471988,
0.0375015475,
-0.08926557,
0.003009127,
0.0562117919,
-0.0199158117,
0.0423833281,
0.0220955815,
-0.0511697717,
0.041258812,
-0.0311502982,
0.0385847092,
-0.008746136,
0.004633958,
-0.007090007,
0.0080292504,
-0.0432466418,
0.0115411002,
0.0184447039,
-0.0106401816,
0.0453874245,
0.0029187137,
0.0091580376,
0.0369329713,
0.0659003034,
0.0582467839,
-0.0501033925,
-0.0914615393,
0.0418077521,
-0.0090713836,
0.0006973222,
0.046679534,
0.0381507501,
-0.0129165566,
-0.0121673439,
-0.0319849811,
0.0528070442,
0.0425163656,
0.0248546135,
-0.013700515,
-0.103643164,
-0.0558430776,
-0.0301948879,
-0.053421542,
-0.0145785222,
-0.0327214561,
0.0289793219,
-0.002306361,
-0.011725137,
0.0186102968,
-0.0043617813,
-0.0650377348,
-0.0154313501,
-0.0096875699,
-0.0314504877,
-0.0411908962,
0.0385266244,
0.0301103517,
-0.0858981758,
0.0408498682,
-0.0172491726,
0.0481061377,
0.028353367,
0.0205056928,
-0.0204726923,
0.0060446016,
-0.0778634176,
0.0131967263,
-0.0121652009,
-0.0019554913,
0.0196989141,
0.0126178255,
0.0132401073,
0.0312995203,
0.0016067034,
0.0177964512,
0.0360387266,
0.020861743,
-0.0167028457,
0.0040525654,
-0.0020914436,
0.0171120297,
-0.0337549485,
-0.0214436743,
-0.0175339635,
0.0345667526,
0.0441338569,
-0.0300698038,
-0.0124395574,
-0.0465042517,
2.383e-7,
0.026322566,
0.0915905312,
-0.0109130703,
0.0469231792,
0.0327596478,
0.0234737601,
0.0197836887,
0.0032419914,
0.04247915,
0.0431106463,
-0.0313269272,
0.0428896509,
0.0190952085,
0.0468963869,
-0.0517636091,
-0.0088526672,
-0.1044377759,
0.005452096,
-0.0360978246,
0.0220750235,
0.0062885717,
0.0744551644,
0.031459976,
-0.0028744505,
-0.0691994429,
-0.0338913053,
0.0279124733,
-0.0360025689,
0.0156469848,
0.0405085422,
0.0326441638,
0.0192843769,
-0.0019816372,
0.0601700656,
0.021087056,
0.0287775341,
0.0149930241,
0.0354458019,
-0.0215723738,
0.0430039167,
0.009983751,
-0.0078129731,
-0.0271594916,
-0.0844251588,
0.0599520132,
0.027710069,
-0.0622821413,
-0.0731276944,
-0.032353539,
0.0113321645,
0.065032877,
-0.0181686655,
-0.0275151897,
0.0048978054,
0.007012648,
-0.004855508,
-0.0097131059,
-0.034476947,
-0.0245303996,
-0.0227231756,
-0.0021107486,
-0.0568711683,
-0.0049281614,
0.008876537,
0.0211630091,
-0.0464242809,
0.0548563525,
1.931303469e-34,
0.0271426663,
0.0416036695,
0.0188868362,
-0.0079286965,
0.0463013463,
0.02193789,
0.0263584405,
0.0001989535,
0.054559581,
-0.0112873856,
0.0051083998
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14652v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14652v2 | One Pass Streaming Algorithm for Super Long Token Attention Approximation in Sublinear Space | 2023-11-24T18:35:00 | 2024-02-05T18:30:30 | Raghav Addanki, Chenyang Li, Zhao Song, Chiwun Yang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, stat.ML | Attention computation takes both the time complexity of $O(n^2)$ and the
space complexity of $O(n^2)$ simultaneously, which makes deploying Large
Language Models (LLMs) in streaming applications that involve long contexts
requiring substantial computational resources. In recent OpenAI DevDay (Nov 6,
2023), OpenAI released a new model that is able to support a 128K-long
document, in our paper, we focus on the memory-efficient issue when context
length $n$ is much greater than 128K ($n \gg 2^d$). Considering a single-layer
self-attention with Query, Key, and Value matrices $Q, K, V \in \mathbb{R}^{n
\times d}$, the polynomial method approximates the attention output $T \in
\mathbb{R}^{n \times d}$. It accomplishes this by constructing $U_1, U_2 \in
\mathbb{R}^{n \times t}$ to expedite attention ${\sf Attn}(Q, K, V)$
computation within $n^{1+o(1)}$ time executions. Despite this, computing the
approximated attention matrix $U_1U_2^\top \in \mathbb{R}^{n \times n}$ still
necessitates $O(n^2)$ space, leading to significant memory usage. In response
to these challenges, we introduce a new algorithm that only reads one pass of
the data in a streaming fashion. This method employs sublinear space $o(n)$ to
store three sketch matrices, alleviating the need for exact $K, V$ storage.
Notably, our algorithm exhibits exceptional memory-efficient performance with
super-long tokens. As the token length $n$ increases, our error guarantee
diminishes while the memory usage remains nearly constant. This unique
attribute underscores the potential of our technique in efficiently handling
LLMs in streaming applications. | [
0.0016631855,
0.0349272899,
0.0061589428,
0.060092479,
-0.0436963812,
0.0081918603,
0.0031941882,
-0.0045986623,
0.0012228809,
-0.0316711999,
-0.0148557657,
-0.0900204778,
-0.0212934855,
0.0735347793,
-0.0053992546,
-0.0507212654,
0.0377420709,
-0.0483436473,
0.0052863797,
-0.0173832532,
-0.0094545661,
-0.0188763849,
-0.0059929579,
0.0208665598,
-0.0219060201,
-0.0619949996,
-0.0348626301,
-0.0433886684,
-0.0106849531,
0.0124366432,
-0.0281646308,
0.0320157669,
0.0196484942,
0.023680564,
0.0000022698,
0.0130899884,
0.0067098234,
-0.0092662806,
0.0064788614,
0.0698549822,
0.066519551,
-0.0185819287,
-0.0150206927,
-0.0194485746,
0.0099412873,
-0.032121174,
0.0454027392,
0.0384318605,
0.0552616268,
0.0346631333,
-0.0114962049,
-0.0254544262,
0.05760663,
-0.031695649,
-0.0032083762,
-0.0992243588,
0.0315139033,
-0.0621533357,
0.0051093032,
0.0084017888,
-0.0275160614,
0.0620804988,
0.0106007839,
-0.0344485343,
0.0510189421,
0.0427417867,
-0.0274801645,
0.0219287053,
-0.0325725414,
0.090355821,
-0.0553639457,
0.0078345044,
-0.0237510521,
0.0062458804,
-0.0149718933,
-0.0615669638,
-0.0343240127,
0.0116071347,
0.0023684034,
-0.0135539593,
-0.0228919983,
-0.0174357686,
0.0040540295,
0.0233913921,
-0.0401985347,
0.0297864731,
0.0134766418,
-0.0118878093,
-0.0437167324,
-0.0251976661,
-0.0112697044,
-0.0542602167,
0.0188495312,
0.0454796888,
-0.0017509336,
-0.0086461529,
-0.045381438,
-0.0493110605,
-0.047346551,
-0.0397515744,
0.1067711785,
0.0522615537,
-0.002573794,
0.0686817318,
-0.0170390662,
0.0574138351,
-0.0609688796,
0.008609511,
-0.0392016396,
-0.0005780819,
0.0167511981,
0.02331453,
-0.0753726885,
0.0402106643,
-0.0629291907,
-0.0457689054,
0.017610427,
0.0419806838,
0.0350656398,
-0.0183099471,
-0.0524905622,
0.0032817854,
-0.0174054913,
-0.0227572117,
0.0039357743,
0.0544124953,
-0.0431512073,
-0.0309569705,
-0.0150842983,
-0.0185618531,
-0.0497550033,
0.0349387415,
0.0208277628,
-0.0264700036,
-0.037433099,
0.0221111737,
-0.0096146353,
-0.0422168225,
-0.0168927852,
0.027597975,
-0.0150160436,
-0.0479422174,
-0.0116405729,
-0.0536818691,
0.0351692103,
-0.0021448249,
-0.0077935061,
-0.0156405717,
-0.0135700628,
0.0321029238,
-0.0267934296,
0.0520277582,
0.0307906866,
0.0202456918,
0.0120086474,
-0.0132344058,
0.0178071242,
0.0334278941,
0.0533874482,
0.0292954706,
0.0105310688,
0.0038783441,
-0.0110515961,
0.0236548875,
0.0199596528,
0.0025620267,
-0.0237871427,
0.0353061296,
0.0295084808,
0.0444547348,
0.0613226332,
0.0646706671,
-0.0266719181,
-0.009577699,
0.0288934335,
0.0717985407,
0.0299541932,
0.059098497,
0.0484658442,
0.0306396838,
-0.0272772685,
0.0053431857,
-0.0046017757,
0.0893295705,
0.0782403275,
0.0107047567,
0.0687089935,
0.0055557387,
-0.0621142164,
-0.0110736173,
-0.00121716,
-0.0063965134,
-0.0267912932,
-0.0197824109,
0.0450550877,
-0.0190209225,
-0.0657709017,
0.0374722071,
0.010803693,
-0.0512355417,
-0.0198848508,
-0.0285990722,
0.0405990109,
0.0821462721,
0.018504044,
-0.0296316016,
0.0383223295,
-0.0056395186,
0.0816234201,
0.0176068693,
0.0328754075,
0.0084429858,
0.0074091535,
-0.0266396906,
0.0279181525,
-0.0266929734,
-0.0238991976,
0.0355437919,
0.0007736963,
0.0128319161,
-0.0369192138,
-0.013634054,
-0.0024037512,
0.0070291916,
-0.0020510796,
-0.0251230858,
0.0136290826,
0.0152436476,
0.0375576951,
0.0312997177,
0.0014997552,
0.035123881,
0.0460526161,
-0.0339295864,
0.0185806826,
-0.0507245064,
-0.0481267981,
-0.0243523885,
0.0140183819,
0.0046307025,
-0.0043333382,
0.0537484288,
-0.0176257119,
-0.0347998142,
0.0645162761,
-0.020341685,
0.0241310913,
-0.0210678093,
-0.0224244483,
0.0302680451,
0.0179469567,
-0.0042174016,
0.0369273163,
-0.041718442,
0.0119716674,
0.0217764508,
0.0284192394,
-0.0239201989,
-0.0174098108,
-0.0379259661,
0.0382126048,
-0.0185858347,
0.0237540081,
-0.0340058655,
-0.0368400179,
-0.0170274042,
0.0050957301,
-0.0322405361,
0.0361830667,
-0.033656653,
0.0210983288,
0.0060526142,
0.0169462506,
0.0147924125,
-0.0069859726,
-0.0067348452,
0.0037545196,
-0.0396063812,
0.0188661013,
0.0029715458,
-0.0117667373,
0.012727295,
-0.0144177387,
-0.0594346821,
0.0146707343,
0.0547335632,
-0.0234489683,
-0.0829475522,
-0.0290241968,
0.0073372037,
0.0032494995,
0.043981757,
-0.0280085783,
-0.0171998888,
0.0054726591,
-0.032501407,
0.053805735,
0.082270436,
0.014416378,
0.0228306483,
0.025437871,
0.0166468155,
-0.0016147745,
0.0590180457,
-0.0067060068,
0.0074387332,
0.0600979291,
0.0449610651,
0.0153172463,
0.0465458967,
-0.0447955467,
-0.0111343097,
-0.0320026837,
-0.0315125845,
0.0262620021,
-0.0036132177,
-0.0097121978,
-0.029400995,
-0.0506253615,
-0.0154418731,
-0.0353966057,
-0.0222048238,
0.0304336566,
-0.0056599416,
-0.0141486693,
-0.003877952,
0.0183607116,
-0.0319320709,
0.0631861612,
-0.0069162459,
0.0149184912,
-0.0725531727,
-0.0197723415,
0.0098270187,
0.0216863137,
-0.0630644187,
-0.0125243319,
0.0646872744,
0.021648014,
0.0608073212,
-0.022768328,
-0.0323216766,
-0.0153607232,
-0.0144650498,
0.0010286965,
0.0013622806,
-0.0048087253,
-0.0280188024,
-0.0037571811,
0.060335204,
0.0147656044,
0.0751951709,
-0.0258389581,
0.0114301881,
-0.0172267854,
0.0500959903,
0.0014276605,
0.0273796488,
-0.0172345527,
0.0016300068,
0.0598306991,
0.087584652,
0.0703492686,
-0.0030432432,
0.0066899196,
-0.0168028139,
0.0247614048,
0.0219802056,
0.0066282097,
0.0250846222,
0.0420953371,
-0.0498807393,
-0.0440283231,
0.0503277406,
0.0322935507,
-0.0797713026,
-0.0134282485,
-0.0094738249,
0.0088861203,
0.0165342167,
0.0109049939,
-0.0633886978,
-0.0359112546,
-0.0032146603,
0.0361080989,
0.0548537187,
-0.0562556423,
-0.0182606447,
-0.0976094082,
0.0096823638,
0.0196357537,
-0.0595978722,
-0.0481566526,
-0.0188795496,
0.0024466794,
0.0351126082,
-0.0162583571,
0.0582783967,
-0.0000598523,
-0.0041336035,
0.013562792,
0.0319453292,
-0.0087769227,
0.0404524617,
-0.041695103,
0.0014977165,
0.0377707854,
0.0260112509,
0.0255880691,
-0.0472690761,
0.029627353,
-0.0091328695,
-0.0006917815,
-0.0061662695,
0.0168646853,
-0.0475428067,
-0.0061305142,
-0.0077977506,
0.0271102283,
-0.0590953082,
0.0163046643,
-0.0162243899,
0.1145204753,
0.0177365784,
-0.0327768177,
-0.0317262486,
-0.0304516088,
-0.0164190158,
0.0803219974,
0.0384090282,
-0.0198349189,
-0.0460207164,
-0.0100515587,
0.0225166511,
-0.0502342023,
-0.0179266054,
0.0059035621,
0.0160112511,
-0.0522180907,
-0.0218359772,
-0.000720648,
0.0410832353,
0.0343204029,
-0.0552520789,
-0.0067014871,
0.023840962,
-0.0236901734,
-0.0504365824,
0.0073480834,
-0.0514704101,
0.0214255061,
-0.0427424498,
0.0010839973,
0.0054807602,
0.004621475,
0.0026773775,
0.020280797,
-0.1356153935,
-0.0326293483,
0.010974654,
0.0130987503,
0.0124087697,
0.0223314893,
0.0008553648,
-0.0246001203,
0.0027090067,
0.022803152,
-0.0615662038,
0.0151339741,
0.0093142372,
-0.0079690022,
0.0173991974,
0.0517898127,
-0.016667312,
-0.0131682437,
0.0169504993,
0.0177211296,
0.0031508689,
0.0057553127,
-0.0155280512,
-0.015540313,
0.0252263173,
0.0666022599,
-0.0355205573,
-0.0148998545,
0.033597555,
0.00858308,
0.0012812838,
-0.0694738105,
0.0047108894,
-0.0095739514,
-0.0272499751,
-0.0104065044,
-0.0022050606,
0.0265969932,
-0.0422759056,
-0.0022493342,
0.0064382954,
0.0213463325,
-0.0073508867,
0.0380844697,
0.0005116368,
-0.0439183116,
-0.0195319746,
-0.0046145767,
0.0154275484,
-0.0149677573,
0.0148757929,
0.0129185654,
0.0028704887,
-0.0123361731,
0.0099064577,
-0.0842012987,
-0.0589845814,
-0.0208496209,
0.0215179361,
0.0222318154,
-0.0097311912,
-0.0180168971,
-0.0005578225,
-0.0202622935,
-0.0431383625,
0.0282324944,
0.0015443118,
-0.0586815141,
0.0396078564,
0.0381712317,
0.0141278552,
0.0037140199,
0.0582079403,
-0.0002945789,
0.0121001694,
0.0301768668,
-0.0268737115,
-0.0330715254,
-0.0104967831,
-0.0608620532,
0.0750768185,
-0.0179367289,
0.0033733363,
-0.0207904726,
-0.0605955236,
0.0168125872,
-0.0136225512,
-0.0048265681,
-0.0392098278,
0.0245808139,
0.0620364174,
0.0505073108,
-0.0054081162,
-0.0301495399,
0.0324804895,
0.0132450638,
-0.0350264125,
0.010396664,
-6.502315327e-33,
-0.0049252254,
-0.0319073759,
-0.0083718365,
-0.0300219022,
-0.0533432849,
0.0268907193,
-0.0336766876,
-0.0121160485,
-0.0262232162,
-0.0195136182,
-0.0292884801,
0.0243353862,
0.0006279752,
0.0163680911,
-0.0107684257,
-0.0132799437,
0.0263544805,
-0.0298859421,
-0.0144310575,
0.0588780157,
0.0305033084,
0.0241280794,
0.0283643119,
0.0362970792,
0.0067189159,
-0.036119055,
0.0305714887,
0.0131566022,
-0.0071913013,
0.0199130643,
-0.0621844195,
0.0257426575,
0.021919826,
-0.0418346152,
-0.0372955911,
0.0406312235,
-0.0755097792,
-0.00273336,
-0.0092528742,
-0.0170981996,
-0.0462863855,
-0.0074895248,
0.0463370718,
0.0619264245,
-0.0282761864,
-0.0523426495,
-0.0152184796,
0.0024773062,
-0.0806530416,
-0.0056196223,
-0.0379496031,
0.0324851051,
0.0102128303,
-0.0302752312,
0.0527230985,
-0.0342671871,
-0.000066985,
0.0023966173,
-0.0792797059,
-0.0038325128,
-0.0035660723,
0.0626750514,
0.0308259036,
-0.0273921639,
0.0081931148,
0.0100982869,
0.0494542383,
-0.0033246083,
-0.0677693412,
-0.0509277843,
-0.0023854333,
-0.0140162148,
0.0268421397,
-0.0090978853,
0.0371268615,
-0.0088146748,
-0.0469634384,
-0.0383800194,
0.0142141413,
0.0681090057,
0.0576078184,
0.0082595777,
-0.0254630856,
-0.0241782349,
0.0059394222,
-0.0304882359,
-0.0543631539,
0.0089913346,
0.0278911646,
0.010177806,
0.0288655125,
-0.0110396398,
0.0409701206,
-0.0025166972,
-0.0004901526,
0.0031427999,
-0.0128348321,
0.0526855551,
0.0247143712,
0.0463257283,
-0.0595981069,
0.0220706463,
-0.0355925933,
-0.001014853,
-0.0162893943,
0.007598001,
0.0420452133,
0.0306010302,
-0.0816652551,
-0.0275769215,
-0.049658753,
0.0042105354,
0.0163044706,
0.0601006001,
0.0521958247,
-0.0042403415,
0.0297774374,
0.1311387569,
-0.0374743119,
0.0018852901,
0.0000656046,
-0.0508244336,
-0.0051706303,
0.0085375765,
-0.0483418778,
-0.0032084503,
-0.0816516951,
0.0219967868,
0.0271778107,
-0.0575730056,
-0.0314246193,
0.0412570275,
2.911e-7,
0.0214796849,
0.0362235084,
0.0449400581,
0.0155969327,
0.0336748175,
0.0086144898,
0.0066597485,
0.0728877485,
-0.009513855,
0.0204665065,
0.0266009606,
0.0212006718,
0.0132703371,
-0.02066404,
-0.1289285272,
0.0070942305,
-0.0816070214,
0.0414058901,
-0.049429778,
-0.029794341,
0.0088342689,
0.1074374393,
-0.0113149257,
0.01935759,
-0.0014825556,
-0.0228289012,
0.0533645749,
0.0151620442,
0.0187815428,
-0.0175291039,
0.0192876495,
-0.0021488236,
-0.0522637852,
-0.0273393597,
0.0002374115,
0.0201272685,
0.0341332555,
0.0821984336,
-0.0089874109,
0.0047191777,
0.0354778841,
-0.0056444686,
-0.0091105131,
-0.0460256748,
0.0757076591,
-0.013674479,
-0.016592361,
-0.0638488159,
0.0490076914,
0.016217446,
-0.0151235443,
0.0283970237,
0.0215754714,
0.0302049462,
0.0064302776,
-0.0184614398,
0.0356810428,
-0.0881184489,
0.0050996472,
-0.0177532751,
-0.0427251421,
0.0137823904,
-0.0897544026,
0.0109879943,
0.0520573109,
-0.044438865,
-0.0466611311,
2.649053432e-34,
0.0569625348,
-0.0087202983,
0.0020645999,
0.021626154,
-0.0107610421,
-0.054650899,
0.017737342,
-0.011192644,
0.0159927588,
-0.0900844261,
-0.0614417233
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14648v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14648v3 | Calibrated Language Models Must Hallucinate | 2023-11-24T18:29:50 | 2024-03-20T02:21:20 | Adam Tauman Kalai, Santosh S. Vempala | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recent language models generate false but plausible-sounding text with
surprising frequency. Such "hallucinations" are an obstacle to the usability of
language-based AI systems and can harm people who rely upon their outputs. This
work shows that there is an inherent statistical lower-bound on the rate that
pretrained language models hallucinate certain types of facts, having nothing
to do with the transformer LM architecture or data quality. For "arbitrary"
facts whose veracity cannot be determined from the training data, we show that
hallucinations must occur at a certain rate for language models that satisfy a
statistical calibration condition appropriate for generative language models.
Specifically, if the maximum probability of any fact is bounded, we show that
the probability of generating a hallucination is close to the fraction of facts
that occur exactly once in the training data (a "Good-Turing" estimate), even
assuming ideal training data without errors.
One conclusion is that models pretrained to be sufficiently good predictors
(i.e., calibrated) may require post-training to mitigate hallucinations on the
type of arbitrary facts that tend to appear once in the training set. However,
our analysis also suggests that there is no statistical reason that pretraining
will lead to hallucination on facts that tend to appear more than once in the
training data (like references to publications such as articles and books,
whose hallucinations have been particularly notable and problematic) or on
systematic facts (like arithmetic calculations). Therefore, different
architectures and learning algorithms may mitigate these latter types of
hallucinations. | [
0.0116179083,
0.0678385571,
-0.028067125,
0.0324243307,
-0.021105947,
0.0296001937,
-0.0058099339,
0.0126977339,
-0.0271625556,
-0.0334326699,
-0.0182978846,
-0.0288578216,
0.0453572571,
-0.0139554692,
0.0228434335,
-0.0232180934,
0.0419957526,
-0.0240927581,
0.0045057586,
-0.0273947585,
-0.008685438,
-0.0089149829,
-0.0064400942,
0.0160085,
-0.027817538,
-0.0387339257,
0.0107739028,
-0.0347959623,
-0.0017938188,
0.0144751044,
-0.0098319864,
0.0584069602,
-0.0246290248,
0.0459199622,
0.0000021463,
-0.0395818129,
-0.0020587579,
-0.0121661937,
-0.0462998301,
-0.0069557116,
0.0394019932,
-0.0249500088,
-0.0030949619,
0.0292623192,
-0.0448762216,
-0.0222403817,
0.0336663462,
0.0680703595,
0.0231212135,
0.0743209869,
-0.0073085227,
-0.0407926403,
0.0616999157,
0.0229900535,
0.0497860759,
-0.0117231663,
0.0102786412,
0.0198838636,
-0.0491028912,
-0.0069191745,
-0.0207331218,
0.0209552459,
0.0185969099,
0.0332023911,
-0.0035751227,
0.0545913912,
-0.0653973073,
-0.0296603292,
0.0025239815,
0.0270219576,
-0.0585259199,
-0.0757320598,
-0.004741889,
-0.0164177865,
0.0310342424,
0.0169102587,
0.010491496,
0.0341774672,
-0.0217813496,
0.0140816728,
0.0395967886,
-0.0207584575,
0.0587536842,
-0.0004583445,
-0.0256912988,
0.0812228173,
-0.0054041883,
-0.0467326306,
0.0249267519,
0.0449623987,
0.0117197381,
-0.037694037,
-0.0138305668,
0.0315865241,
-0.0218926352,
0.0241489522,
-0.0669953078,
0.0093489196,
0.0078892177,
-0.0781566724,
0.0197535492,
0.0089673558,
-0.052155491,
0.0343564004,
-0.028229516,
0.0398354679,
-0.0172209181,
0.0543144606,
-0.0185611676,
0.0192820691,
-0.0090666786,
-0.0112678148,
-0.0426859185,
0.0245168526,
0.0198739599,
-0.0051866425,
-0.0375314355,
0.0054287026,
-0.0182301141,
0.0482332148,
-0.0310550313,
-0.0070217955,
-0.029161375,
-0.0392363518,
-0.0397760198,
0.0000401544,
0.0014344018,
0.034137778,
-0.0098926956,
-0.0974885076,
-0.0091613708,
0.0160716921,
-0.0213423427,
0.0046995291,
0.0242901929,
0.0308149997,
0.0280377977,
-0.003151708,
-0.0525482222,
-0.027527282,
-0.0253156219,
-0.0679427534,
0.016033344,
-0.0560430959,
-0.0038167923,
0.0307424776,
-0.0029433847,
-0.0523753949,
-0.0069320654,
0.0128660332,
-0.0571212396,
0.0827826336,
-0.0106576551,
0.0049880245,
0.0385740697,
0.0074570756,
-0.0069476669,
0.0788911656,
0.0457183756,
0.0139863202,
0.0220727492,
-0.0207639299,
0.0908091292,
0.0339365751,
0.01176224,
-0.0051386487,
0.0003830076,
-0.0301777646,
0.0136610689,
0.0035345959,
0.0082938187,
0.0833460093,
-0.0118426001,
-0.0220079832,
0.0590225793,
-0.0086818058,
0.0097727375,
0.044725813,
0.0131692076,
-0.0393498465,
0.0249748752,
0.0568923056,
-0.0690007359,
-0.0012753302,
-0.043008551,
0.0035548508,
0.0124747902,
-0.0008641983,
-0.0249599852,
-0.082957983,
-0.0133924391,
-0.0223399475,
-0.0014926533,
-0.0193179063,
0.0460344329,
0.0241478626,
-0.0463630669,
0.0690184236,
0.0202878993,
-0.0326224193,
0.0293394271,
-0.0605043955,
0.0121074812,
0.0539203398,
0.0526295304,
-0.0166941844,
0.0341893882,
-0.0277654976,
0.028045347,
0.0402808599,
0.065687336,
0.0043344484,
0.0014738567,
-0.0311052017,
0.007861536,
0.0080021918,
0.0499234349,
-0.0077338926,
-0.0273054391,
0.0147517184,
-0.0114471884,
-0.0294870175,
-0.0629466549,
0.0605161414,
-0.0233842153,
-0.036311511,
-0.0390963554,
-0.0212549344,
0.0105618779,
-0.0127265602,
-0.0372285917,
0.0300982483,
0.0087895682,
-0.0221132915,
-0.0196713656,
0.0234254804,
-0.0243872795,
0.006782644,
0.0366334617,
-0.0356063955,
0.0123497918,
0.0044120005,
-0.0209215842,
-0.0118259992,
-0.0030568868,
-0.0673943534,
0.0556192771,
-0.0171839669,
0.0658829883,
-0.0425696895,
0.0305680186,
0.0043542529,
0.0736232549,
-0.0455867387,
0.0378540643,
-0.017844785,
-0.0099391835,
0.0156006142,
-0.0104287155,
-0.04656386,
-0.0085875671,
0.0120291784,
0.0377000198,
0.0184032582,
-0.0586769246,
-0.0249040239,
-0.0285153743,
-0.0559958257,
-0.0164839886,
-0.0239367671,
0.0075167846,
0.0074033272,
-0.047102835,
-0.008633784,
0.0039214632,
-0.0293515455,
0.0041807136,
0.0116654215,
0.0305546615,
0.0429839343,
-0.0218910966,
-0.0109546883,
-0.0247116871,
0.0137690837,
-0.0236726422,
0.0452097915,
0.0192261524,
0.0045055654,
-0.127570793,
0.0672846511,
-0.0201067701,
0.0239939671,
-0.013034421,
-0.0167109538,
0.0299232937,
0.0059038368,
0.0255990382,
0.106191732,
0.0308979657,
0.0273567196,
0.0706253424,
0.023507921,
-0.0385717861,
-0.0149548771,
-0.0096708601,
-0.0355123654,
-0.0292118415,
-0.0456694029,
0.0100187724,
0.0671493039,
0.0035630791,
0.0022766204,
-0.0396797098,
0.0588936508,
-0.0277232006,
-0.0535942353,
0.0521184132,
-0.0130105279,
-0.0222142171,
0.0414739847,
-0.0169082582,
-0.0551791079,
0.060326267,
-0.037516132,
0.0187676754,
-0.0173871294,
0.0181522667,
0.0183950495,
-0.0039206701,
0.0302632153,
0.003355334,
0.0212581102,
0.0100485031,
-0.0589328371,
-0.0024312974,
0.0211598985,
-0.0651374906,
0.0342796929,
-0.0265340824,
0.0060474887,
0.0038257372,
-0.0440496132,
-0.0642994493,
-0.0279624816,
-0.0070979074,
-0.0540703721,
0.0046270862,
-0.0145875579,
-0.0655415803,
-0.0249644183,
0.0059692347,
0.0338379107,
-0.0004017402,
-0.0336692818,
0.0152357053,
-0.0104290256,
0.0616174638,
-0.0212259069,
0.0472585782,
-0.0511830859,
-0.0016964306,
0.0439365357,
0.0099454997,
0.0514662005,
-0.0389906019,
-0.024844721,
0.0201232228,
-0.0109762559,
-0.0493967645,
0.0351413302,
0.0148258833,
-0.0270814095,
-0.0325514227,
0.128507942,
0.0178612284,
-0.0389317237,
-0.0001640119,
-0.0069064084,
0.0144822998,
-0.0017399013,
-0.0116267735,
-0.0993527174,
0.0063952925,
-0.0061876676,
-0.0010796309,
-0.0213075373,
-0.0231183674,
-0.0064096055,
-0.1031443104,
0.0051255766,
0.0229472313,
-0.0012767473,
-0.0499495864,
-0.0309667997,
-0.0265262388,
-0.0385978036,
0.0406710245,
-0.0112992795,
0.0163062047,
0.005625424,
0.0246241931,
-0.0379842222,
-0.0216243062,
-0.0029083276,
-0.0145362401,
0.0753302723,
0.0621520989,
0.0440469757,
-0.0418763459,
-0.0709739029,
0.0075353216,
0.0304176733,
-0.0057463693,
0.039687071,
0.0741601735,
0.0071937758,
-0.0037613227,
0.0077467998,
0.0050580734,
-0.0316737778,
-0.0037172581,
-0.0061682519,
0.0597492307,
-0.0243020896,
-0.0707985088,
0.0017409999,
0.0062570004,
-0.0061004041,
0.0833626762,
-0.0011534508,
-0.0413454324,
-0.0450055599,
-0.0455262549,
0.0650145188,
-0.0211035572,
-0.0505925976,
0.0727145448,
0.0343206935,
-0.0545345433,
-0.0720056146,
-0.0477282852,
-0.0257948563,
0.0379475951,
0.025771115,
0.0135866338,
0.0251829643,
-0.0037273702,
-0.0177883487,
-0.0033977469,
-0.0526149645,
0.0004364453,
-0.0490864739,
0.0136873648,
0.0237008743,
-0.0170548987,
0.0034029563,
-0.0020463979,
-0.0725358501,
-0.0735701323,
0.0572206229,
0.0460245088,
0.0393975899,
0.0469247699,
-0.0103511196,
-0.0480232053,
0.0515066162,
0.0566576831,
-0.0232010949,
0.0255696736,
0.030597534,
-0.01253107,
0.0224885009,
0.0157219227,
-0.0146498103,
0.0130919702,
0.0279052779,
-0.0252966434,
-0.0638815388,
-0.0147458958,
0.0507121719,
-0.004732748,
0.044288408,
-0.0275226813,
0.0213176552,
-0.0005009382,
0.0017746908,
-0.0036706529,
-0.0241704844,
-0.0110505689,
-0.0072609303,
0.0584778674,
0.020505039,
-0.0137847988,
-0.0171214361,
-0.0262874719,
0.0248012468,
-0.0277629867,
-0.0262244493,
0.0210266728,
0.051208701,
0.0505726859,
-0.0228299405,
-0.0243950393,
0.0137638822,
-0.0016058158,
0.0703478903,
0.0396470204,
0.0491695292,
0.0069441465,
0.010524014,
-0.0210207328,
-0.0063219666,
-0.0615735166,
-0.0541794784,
-0.037782602,
0.0337868296,
0.0288116485,
-0.0038742772,
0.0335588865,
-0.0314762853,
0.020723898,
-0.0256176051,
0.0077919955,
0.0431052521,
-0.0235546716,
-0.0105186431,
0.0039851535,
-0.0381230265,
-0.021785913,
0.0707001239,
-0.0170287602,
0.0673311427,
-0.0273249168,
-0.0323276371,
-0.0332615897,
-0.0485985838,
-0.0757092461,
-0.0391818695,
-0.003653575,
-0.010763946,
-0.0693429857,
-0.0769410059,
-0.0004862284,
0.0363360457,
0.0604477264,
-0.0201811176,
-0.0148096625,
0.0691077337,
-0.0442366302,
0.0052979374,
-0.0314395539,
0.0267753974,
0.0342221633,
-0.0012255493,
-0.0330630429,
-6.351633849e-33,
-0.003610333,
-0.0062346892,
0.0070093209,
0.0064682239,
0.0342463925,
-0.0124773728,
0.0030809604,
0.0270594396,
-0.0513993241,
0.0300641786,
-0.0139422277,
0.0355444029,
0.0178397186,
-0.0023293945,
-0.0066615418,
-0.0382354856,
0.0491751507,
-0.0273134448,
-0.0642486736,
-0.006337177,
0.0305747297,
0.0025986221,
0.0592812076,
-0.0755653009,
0.0533277057,
-0.0335439146,
-0.0385889485,
0.0178296398,
-0.0023787569,
0.0433760509,
-0.015911812,
0.0440457128,
0.0151632251,
-0.0376173221,
-0.0100332228,
0.0050854953,
-0.0439098105,
-0.0268753003,
0.0099773873,
0.0842346624,
0.013494377,
-0.0161854122,
0.05873546,
-0.0233888328,
-0.0705724657,
0.0015600154,
0.0359236822,
-0.0523732826,
-0.0152676748,
-0.0073683588,
-0.0489569902,
-0.001575998,
0.0244746432,
0.0009527468,
0.0036443591,
0.0321452431,
-0.0030207806,
-0.018867908,
-0.0989856869,
0.0223919768,
0.027731454,
0.021011848,
0.0530363545,
-0.0159668569,
-0.008112858,
0.0642839894,
0.0868615285,
0.033686474,
-0.0387097932,
-0.0037788707,
0.0325896889,
0.0092457961,
0.0475917086,
0.0327956676,
0.0864309371,
-0.0334219523,
-0.0282024685,
0.0074814274,
-0.0206812583,
0.0017512585,
0.0555996262,
-0.00769943,
-0.0908409432,
-0.0417266339,
-0.0328844599,
-0.0042658322,
-0.0276652128,
-0.0085142823,
0.0016406144,
0.0164138749,
0.0154495733,
-0.0328088067,
0.0079566333,
-0.0593747124,
-0.0251389928,
0.0276799109,
-0.0178668983,
0.001494056,
-0.0264173485,
0.0119212354,
-0.0189322587,
-0.0305291787,
-0.0001751603,
0.0268843248,
0.0419636033,
0.0275309812,
0.0483373627,
0.0159983002,
-0.0709122643,
-0.00277545,
-0.0276532229,
-0.0087242834,
0.0672056898,
-0.0012029923,
0.0617444776,
-0.0169760045,
-0.0211348981,
-0.0246506762,
0.0151228197,
0.0132460725,
-0.0321846455,
0.025147628,
-0.0239861738,
0.0155201117,
-0.0307699293,
-0.0489502624,
-0.0274826754,
-0.0032866818,
0.0443485714,
-0.0884659141,
-0.0106804604,
0.0030053577,
2.878e-7,
0.0234884601,
0.0512813292,
0.005491266,
0.0011822873,
0.0170928631,
0.0422488637,
0.0076159304,
0.0287914444,
0.0183876026,
-0.0307576582,
-0.0197420493,
0.019431252,
0.0419892259,
0.032374043,
-0.0668326765,
-0.0566787384,
-0.0325725451,
0.0332878157,
-0.0302827824,
-0.0073045255,
0.0149867777,
0.0792204365,
0.0335042141,
-0.0188408457,
-0.0144587029,
-0.0700406358,
0.0517887436,
-0.0272258408,
0.0172962211,
0.0429062732,
0.0782646611,
0.0488996841,
0.0000656322,
0.0376824103,
-0.0188935827,
0.0126111293,
-0.0170335174,
0.018704975,
-0.0054860055,
-0.0094259055,
-0.0228585321,
-0.0269934926,
-0.0002114066,
-0.0434081294,
0.0614735819,
-0.0049188556,
-0.0048251548,
-0.0348100998,
-0.0239630193,
0.0011348617,
0.0505351461,
0.0109917512,
-0.0066977344,
0.0070561632,
0.0161965359,
0.029288996,
-0.0035822834,
-0.0480052121,
-0.0273431912,
0.0254910849,
-0.0105512459,
-0.0605024174,
0.0042996379,
0.0036091357,
0.0248159841,
-0.0682191253,
0.0320724174,
2.567584326e-34,
0.0370501541,
-0.0295084156,
0.0447658822,
0.0308919493,
0.0361370891,
0.0045779399,
0.0532352068,
0.0154356621,
0.030739801,
-0.0403451808,
-0.0013855827
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14583v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14583v1 | GPT Struct Me: Probing GPT Models on Narrative Entity Extraction | 2023-11-24T16:19:04 | 2023-11-24T16:19:04 | Hugo Sousa, Nuno Guimarães, Alípio Jorge, Ricardo Campos | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR | The importance of systems that can extract structured information from
textual data becomes increasingly pronounced given the ever-increasing volume
of text produced on a daily basis. Having a system that can effectively extract
such information in an interoperable manner would be an asset for several
domains, be it finance, health, or legal. Recent developments in natural
language processing led to the production of powerful language models that can,
to some degree, mimic human intelligence. Such effectiveness raises a pertinent
question: Can these models be leveraged for the extraction of structured
information? In this work, we address this question by evaluating the
capabilities of two state-of-the-art language models -- GPT-3 and GPT-3.5,
commonly known as ChatGPT -- in the extraction of narrative entities, namely
events, participants, and temporal expressions. This study is conducted on the
Text2Story Lusa dataset, a collection of 119 Portuguese news articles whose
annotation framework includes a set of entity structures along with several
tags and attribute values. We first select the best prompt template through an
ablation study over prompt components that provide varying degrees of
information on a subset of documents of the dataset. Subsequently, we use the
best templates to evaluate the effectiveness of the models on the remaining
documents. The results obtained indicate that GPT models are competitive with
out-of-the-box baseline systems, presenting an all-in-one alternative for
practitioners with limited resources. By studying the strengths and limitations
of these models in the context of information extraction, we offer insights
that can guide future improvements and avenues to explore in this field. | [
0.0546651557,
0.0363030359,
-0.0094852494,
0.0516729765,
-0.0580901615,
0.0317845605,
-0.0177564621,
0.0097113559,
0.025540242,
-0.0539275184,
0.0150878523,
-0.0200014953,
-0.0297003072,
0.056784045,
-0.0146161485,
-0.0617334731,
0.0246830452,
0.0073532071,
0.0494593233,
0.0406252034,
0.0214213133,
0.0555278175,
-0.0116860205,
0.0265352055,
-0.0027799024,
0.0122990254,
0.0015789298,
-0.0170121845,
0.0265669581,
-0.0206565689,
-0.0004848643,
0.0220789704,
-0.0063603087,
0.0057299733,
0.0000020663,
-0.0393325835,
-0.0532946698,
-0.0017441412,
-0.0174174644,
-0.0195031054,
0.0312651172,
0.0084908558,
-0.034161441,
-0.0309361145,
-0.0554780439,
-0.0509290919,
0.0038242878,
0.0481937453,
0.0300846994,
0.0922912732,
-0.0507821515,
-0.043676842,
0.0463730134,
-0.0110399164,
0.0123017058,
-0.0442172699,
0.0140004661,
-0.0061201579,
0.0434739068,
0.0293876994,
0.0400270186,
0.018032698,
0.0053051044,
0.0259770639,
-0.0379425958,
0.0518687293,
-0.0391717926,
0.0073232679,
-0.0299362298,
0.0201254971,
0.0593800284,
0.0102394894,
0.0549717359,
0.0108435703,
0.0101924762,
-0.0088627199,
-0.0480838157,
0.0241282601,
-0.052450493,
0.021284489,
0.0784932747,
0.0066575585,
-0.0081389956,
-0.0069831959,
0.0141082993,
0.0471633077,
0.026187012,
-0.0184906833,
0.003889295,
0.0221635755,
-0.015765721,
-0.043200396,
0.0179875195,
0.0091227321,
0.0468797795,
0.0385204218,
-0.0203490984,
0.0134456186,
-0.0154014574,
-0.0544348396,
-0.0420860983,
0.0069623869,
0.0023853043,
0.079073444,
-0.003230778,
0.0296174474,
-0.0238380209,
-0.01793354,
-0.000446528,
-0.0262126606,
-0.0780049115,
-0.0121700633,
-0.0336198397,
0.0566610359,
-0.0401940383,
-0.0114709232,
0.0026437892,
0.0049450276,
0.0247220639,
-0.0071811965,
-0.0191075057,
-0.0218858998,
-0.0220167395,
-0.0249189921,
-0.02947185,
-0.0076937899,
-0.0392083526,
-0.0129229454,
0.0048017199,
-0.0462123714,
-0.0044259424,
0.0051535517,
0.0126573863,
-0.0472423285,
0.0055388729,
0.0354904123,
-0.0144447191,
-0.0341535322,
-0.0735934675,
-0.0505847447,
-0.0050663934,
-0.0673139915,
-0.021301955,
-0.0463776812,
0.0537091568,
0.0067792665,
0.0010271834,
-0.0346530788,
0.0078961784,
-0.0038936352,
-0.0620338544,
0.0446312241,
-0.0128094386,
0.0000288611,
0.0217401199,
0.0080009317,
0.0154385921,
0.0273461342,
0.0548910312,
0.0160517022,
0.0664091259,
0.0098488731,
0.0055864872,
0.0552327074,
-0.0337575749,
-0.0239700805,
0.0393189453,
0.0170173403,
0.0104784928,
-0.0138345174,
0.0328547582,
0.0403365865,
-0.031166574,
-0.0000422073,
0.0499980748,
0.0400973223,
-0.0220338516,
0.0175664406,
0.0804352462,
-0.0286533348,
0.0532149598,
0.0300564896,
-0.0144347074,
-0.0533052087,
-0.0016718009,
0.0315494686,
-0.0530058593,
0.0411491431,
-0.0033256987,
-0.0168753359,
-0.0090485513,
-0.0018666905,
0.0122477366,
-0.0108675174,
0.0521994978,
-0.013491014,
-0.0521341003,
0.0177820474,
0.0053842845,
-0.057025332,
0.0124833528,
-0.0256202538,
0.022680128,
0.0419471562,
0.0694827586,
-0.0320857614,
-0.0414507985,
-0.0185731873,
0.0008436121,
0.0106041189,
0.0211284943,
-0.0259441957,
0.0048041004,
-0.0134737585,
-0.0090616541,
0.0075092432,
0.0271214955,
0.0180262662,
0.0278449021,
0.0115089631,
0.0028754175,
-0.0033013425,
-0.0075462996,
0.0496740676,
-0.0432818681,
-0.0418285355,
-0.0452291258,
-0.0108857779,
0.0146276541,
0.0392169543,
0.0057044877,
-0.0246301629,
0.0506123863,
-0.0139823547,
0.0150149427,
0.0273136739,
-0.0110527072,
-0.0315247513,
-0.0105460668,
-0.0082775662,
-0.0241845958,
-0.0154312812,
-0.01632558,
-0.0467560627,
-0.0374326929,
0.0042311428,
0.0287310202,
-0.0415893532,
0.00527687,
0.026335679,
-0.0122817662,
-0.031581074,
0.0753486529,
0.013414572,
-0.0097591514,
-0.0138529036,
-0.0418450758,
0.0037986748,
-0.0540055446,
0.0004756975,
0.0454019159,
0.0246424563,
-0.0247686617,
0.0501825884,
0.0039858408,
-0.0411555357,
-0.0385870449,
-0.126461044,
0.0437524542,
-0.0319863632,
0.0713877827,
0.0280560758,
0.026248822,
-0.057548333,
0.0059068454,
-0.0354561396,
-0.0693474934,
-0.0078136642,
-0.0030875856,
0.0392473452,
0.0497136489,
-0.011599673,
-0.0432642549,
0.028919179,
-0.0464126989,
0.0298550259,
0.0492157526,
-0.0746132359,
-0.0222838465,
0.0121714715,
0.0040733116,
0.0279174298,
-0.0125113754,
0.0038513162,
0.0056511424,
-0.0106367534,
0.0696479008,
0.0766508356,
-0.0143670319,
0.0775208101,
-0.0520732738,
-0.0376363657,
-0.0123855304,
0.0247891732,
-0.0535678528,
0.0318385065,
-0.0541482195,
-0.0364141986,
0.0657387748,
0.0774042159,
0.016572278,
0.0395875312,
-0.0567867197,
0.0081394017,
0.0040338994,
0.0147540774,
0.0437337756,
0.0027175518,
-0.0183466598,
0.0272448044,
-0.017884789,
0.0190455914,
0.0703422055,
-0.0337826796,
-0.0109880567,
-0.0140467519,
-0.0146856662,
-0.0570467785,
0.0832567289,
0.0154237282,
-0.0043945438,
0.0303970408,
-0.0506756082,
0.0127421934,
0.0139421551,
0.0435523279,
-0.0204879846,
-0.0015618531,
-0.0490336418,
0.0159831531,
0.0022617015,
-0.0320076644,
-0.0127039151,
-0.04070713,
-0.006289429,
0.0187607259,
0.010995998,
0.0148804225,
-0.0349609256,
0.0353746153,
-0.0192010999,
0.061852254,
-0.0243412461,
-0.016297834,
-0.0148327202,
0.0763582289,
0.0344059877,
-0.0442923233,
-0.0168763176,
-0.0106621087,
0.0169408843,
0.0403670892,
0.0121412454,
-0.0018563714,
0.0162945017,
0.0132885072,
-0.0024162657,
-0.090292193,
-0.056490045,
-0.0263665766,
0.0245384313,
-0.0888824463,
-0.0080649117,
0.1220987588,
0.0357173197,
0.0019066782,
-0.0262191091,
0.0382157229,
0.0250201244,
0.0048470674,
0.0162857715,
-0.0734734088,
-0.0056800991,
0.0013647141,
0.0024027792,
-0.0229483657,
-0.0561470725,
-0.0075124642,
-0.0795840472,
0.0589025356,
-0.020994341,
-0.0182632469,
-0.0141113605,
-0.0374438241,
-0.0011219282,
-0.054533869,
-0.0412214398,
0.0134924911,
-0.0232102666,
0.0302056223,
0.0043328223,
-0.0620267242,
-0.0329743922,
0.0298523773,
-0.012739473,
0.0113486806,
0.0667450652,
0.0265550856,
0.0018224989,
0.0194512606,
-0.0012772459,
-0.0180820078,
-0.0156013081,
-0.0092279101,
0.052016899,
-0.0584229045,
0.0015339655,
-0.0225761682,
0.0657474399,
0.0116861928,
-0.0094133615,
0.0324448384,
0.0757580623,
-0.0008598018,
0.0026364147,
-0.0108282426,
-0.0469742529,
0.000188942,
0.0896888524,
0.007115942,
-0.0145317139,
-0.0502940603,
-0.0128738414,
0.0062528672,
-0.0318038166,
-0.0272989739,
0.0045974315,
-0.0336509943,
-0.0030689642,
-0.0636544675,
-0.1014088243,
0.0416824184,
0.0217046496,
-0.0034007472,
0.0117236767,
0.0057790033,
0.0102985082,
-0.031280797,
0.0299231745,
-0.0367901064,
-0.0186077859,
-0.0302609187,
0.0013327801,
0.003234599,
0.0213079788,
-0.0346273892,
0.0260195434,
-0.0521792658,
-0.037938185,
0.0052507804,
-0.0107519859,
0.02604031,
0.0491922945,
-0.020823868,
-0.0003205791,
-0.0198088363,
-0.0137650156,
-0.0705947727,
-0.0233087577,
-0.0050854473,
0.0340216085,
-0.0145355193,
0.0072878171,
0.0091159046,
0.0401777923,
-0.0302928369,
0.0630400404,
-0.0424490348,
0.0021339385,
0.0217606872,
0.0237128809,
0.0583355986,
-0.0135513768,
-0.0144353174,
-0.0707596168,
-0.0279398058,
-0.0548451617,
0.013121672,
-0.0357520804,
0.0310099516,
0.0113053061,
-0.0041034725,
-0.0465535261,
-0.0021667283,
-0.0496274829,
0.0366289467,
-0.0783209801,
0.0035148989,
0.0236934237,
-0.0006281521,
-0.0271120872,
-0.0460660346,
0.0018606471,
0.0303879008,
-0.0064590485,
0.030558724,
-0.0486304462,
0.0442126058,
0.0107860956,
-0.0220590625,
0.0533012375,
0.0178406499,
-0.0495595001,
0.0393884815,
-0.0408172011,
0.0599036105,
0.0310226064,
-0.0243576169,
0.0521563552,
-0.040943224,
-0.0083304094,
0.0058620898,
0.018632248,
0.0606814735,
0.0159623288,
0.0044305953,
0.0276519731,
-0.065923363,
0.0102468347,
0.0497967936,
0.0407820977,
0.059516523,
0.0227659848,
-0.0541595928,
-0.052146282,
-0.0216832086,
0.0213165302,
-0.0068166004,
-0.0145688578,
-0.0165003333,
-0.0970965922,
0.0158421937,
0.022619186,
0.0002823523,
-0.0078475596,
-0.024208406,
-0.0003056574,
0.0585712977,
0.004820745,
-0.0208771769,
-0.0638254359,
0.0196177904,
-0.0257354379,
-0.0195552297,
-0.0124440854,
-6.330809232e-33,
-0.04824543,
-0.0063250479,
0.0271453485,
0.0734744072,
-0.0399556682,
0.0177755803,
-0.0303540826,
-0.0214948356,
0.0083179008,
0.0188753717,
-0.0097866291,
-0.0168863572,
0.0323995203,
-0.0207533557,
-0.0118886493,
0.0150347035,
0.0119395507,
0.0035083857,
-0.042261865,
0.0195243023,
0.0417172983,
0.0513139069,
0.0829322934,
-0.078050375,
0.0744415373,
-0.0220936183,
-0.0114365341,
-0.0004345827,
0.077454403,
0.0599490143,
-0.0222644955,
-0.0134827793,
0.0310116485,
-0.0792402253,
0.0194103364,
0.021810811,
-0.1252705008,
-0.0170507934,
0.0422674939,
0.0026917532,
0.0096281013,
-0.0450146347,
-0.014448788,
-0.0296145212,
0.0080199838,
0.0005061885,
0.0457131416,
-0.0406803489,
0.0238025207,
-0.0444811508,
-0.0860101432,
0.0687550753,
0.0080287298,
0.030654002,
0.059966635,
0.0361989476,
0.0037405079,
0.0244285949,
-0.0044502052,
-0.0228214562,
-0.0067697284,
0.0257401094,
-0.0007977905,
-0.017941067,
0.0016541345,
0.0530820936,
-0.0040241191,
-0.0263583362,
-0.0626104251,
0.046055153,
0.0093277926,
0.061793603,
0.0118142935,
0.0413349159,
-0.0100698657,
0.014370325,
-0.0677006617,
0.0456734449,
0.033433672,
0.0009845828,
-0.0194110312,
-0.0261509698,
-0.0747888759,
0.0053379582,
-0.013759546,
-0.0449688323,
0.0153288962,
-0.0180132929,
0.0238469001,
-0.0122640524,
-0.0060757832,
0.0643579289,
0.0238469318,
0.0097799711,
-0.0104138581,
-0.0043453421,
-0.0436802916,
0.038875673,
-0.0180875305,
0.0479985811,
-0.0556723401,
-0.0159954149,
0.0131525081,
0.0314362608,
0.0275136624,
-0.0193001647,
0.0193271935,
-0.0092392582,
-0.0418179706,
-0.0169636719,
-0.0115241045,
0.0330314673,
-0.0690808967,
0.0144251958,
0.0292850565,
0.0140996017,
0.0045217914,
0.0136886565,
0.0469324365,
0.0203137603,
-0.0310570393,
-0.0177004281,
0.0125932824,
0.0114274928,
0.0079103345,
0.0206235107,
0.0173744727,
0.0022213114,
-0.0055173286,
0.0159530435,
0.0072543691,
0.0306785461,
2.615e-7,
0.041363094,
0.0343979709,
0.0593121462,
0.0000964089,
-0.0069591966,
0.0230839513,
0.0235248525,
0.0130425915,
-0.0093046678,
-0.0368860029,
0.0232208204,
0.0026188579,
0.0567526631,
0.0369778983,
-0.0887975022,
0.0044206441,
-0.0306949746,
-0.0495826453,
-0.1042839438,
-0.0032454203,
0.0618802868,
0.0383755602,
0.035972923,
0.0012455754,
-0.0605517067,
-0.0395833477,
0.0517924987,
-0.0145784905,
-0.0627773702,
0.0480091497,
0.0353550799,
0.0327310376,
-0.0461038686,
0.0007894687,
0.0107081216,
0.040801242,
0.0139750531,
0.0910055116,
-0.0035417613,
0.0290365089,
0.0142667955,
-0.0698668063,
0.0008289733,
-0.0549763516,
0.0741856322,
-0.0170926638,
-0.0174170788,
-0.0191529635,
-0.0386019647,
0.0097847767,
-0.0201397464,
0.002461357,
-0.0548347384,
0.0477716252,
0.0123886885,
-0.0222089719,
-0.012407979,
-0.0543385744,
0.0186587535,
0.0338383876,
-0.0108267032,
-0.0063162181,
-0.0046700849,
0.0233813319,
-0.0191073064,
-0.0792227834,
0.0073289098,
2.738956939e-34,
0.0017294897,
0.0296753552,
-0.0318495594,
0.0572841726,
0.0658849627,
0.0229733139,
-0.0156678315,
0.0060214209,
-0.0233877543,
-0.0419590697,
0.0030867737
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14543v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14543v1 | Data-Efficient Alignment of Large Language Models with Human Feedback Through Natural Language | 2023-11-24T15:20:36 | 2023-11-24T15:20:36 | Di Jin, Shikib Mehri, Devamanyu Hazarika, Aishwarya Padmakumar, Sungjin Lee, Yang Liu, Mahdi Namazifar | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Learning from human feedback is a prominent technique to align the output of
large language models (LLMs) with human expectations. Reinforcement learning
from human feedback (RLHF) leverages human preference signals that are in the
form of ranking of response pairs to perform this alignment. However, human
preference on LLM outputs can come in much richer forms including natural
language, which may provide detailed feedback on strengths and weaknesses of a
given response. In this work we investigate data efficiency of modeling human
feedback that is in natural language. Specifically, we fine-tune an open-source
LLM, e.g., Falcon-40B-Instruct, on a relatively small amount (1000 records or
even less) of human feedback in natural language in the form of critiques and
revisions of responses. We show that this model is able to improve the quality
of responses from even some of the strongest LLMs such as ChatGPT, BARD, and
Vicuna, through critique and revision of those responses. For instance, through
one iteration of revision of ChatGPT responses, the revised responses have
56.6% win rate over the original ones, and this win rate can be further
improved to 65.9% after applying the revision for five iterations. | [
0.0680032149,
0.0524979159,
-0.0078821015,
0.0402831472,
-0.049996458,
0.0032175709,
-0.0750431567,
-0.0132029746,
0.0111376802,
-0.0667282641,
-0.0687909201,
-0.0417230502,
0.0210964736,
0.0126832174,
0.0180647708,
-0.0598634109,
0.0321353786,
-0.0455527529,
0.0079876641,
-0.0019287388,
0.0157529879,
0.0023174633,
-0.025582375,
0.0489887372,
0.0551493317,
0.008791035,
-0.0431361198,
0.0110059176,
0.0256280638,
-0.0421776623,
0.0240155514,
0.0680350065,
0.015239588,
0.0532389991,
0.0000018793,
-0.0416506268,
0.016196847,
-0.0172463916,
-0.0130406143,
0.0056323637,
0.0630204529,
0.0155501161,
-0.0245315954,
0.0235952269,
-0.0504862815,
-0.0064789071,
0.0450692587,
0.0384912603,
0.086315833,
0.0914693847,
0.0274689812,
-0.011722967,
-0.0017239578,
-0.014290615,
-0.004101452,
-0.0296947863,
0.0074070385,
-0.0141999358,
0.0281996969,
0.0439158119,
-0.021341281,
0.0013230136,
0.007738356,
-0.009764039,
-0.002815044,
0.0290672109,
-0.0262116641,
-0.0009974564,
-0.0209924933,
0.0896591693,
0.0163464304,
-0.0133636137,
-0.0184442494,
-0.0175642334,
0.0207629595,
-0.0030822053,
-0.0229083318,
-0.001327396,
0.0104474621,
0.028201215,
-0.0069003091,
-0.0139307054,
0.0169064011,
0.0209189877,
0.023182774,
0.0309101678,
-0.0022737994,
-0.0472852141,
0.0143501936,
0.011298948,
-0.0190904252,
-0.0627840608,
-0.0248202812,
0.0159113761,
-0.0815564916,
0.0150082149,
-0.0468789302,
0.0113327596,
0.0135929557,
-0.0424608961,
0.0505620204,
0.0543168113,
0.0068235346,
0.0389694683,
0.0192791279,
0.0615568273,
-0.0128063075,
0.0173391867,
-0.043039754,
0.0161114763,
-0.0476220027,
-0.0177315976,
0.003778338,
0.0213693436,
-0.0175642129,
-0.0147119416,
-0.0594433509,
0.0143467644,
-0.0357722268,
0.0406396538,
0.0274788067,
0.0403749421,
-0.0263511557,
-0.0122348424,
-0.0998444185,
0.0368339941,
-0.0238395054,
0.0143477116,
0.0153579218,
-0.0335125253,
0.0207220409,
-0.0058740727,
-0.0198261179,
-0.0272179078,
0.0047438294,
0.0764177144,
-0.0080397548,
-0.0132539552,
-0.0026780856,
-0.0100551974,
-0.0151010677,
-0.0611183345,
-0.032222975,
-0.063802883,
0.0398795381,
-0.0086404718,
-0.0305654164,
-0.0067158197,
0.0195503198,
0.0304046795,
-0.0469753593,
0.0819648653,
-0.0078233583,
0.0176272299,
-0.0030296128,
-0.0189478546,
-0.025442807,
0.0532344468,
0.0453920737,
0.0212876555,
0.018286569,
-0.0064957272,
0.0032160825,
0.0484817401,
-0.0103490269,
0.0076393369,
-0.0132721411,
0.0255807377,
-0.0023345954,
0.0767988861,
0.0535207801,
0.0497405566,
-0.0247948114,
-0.0174857806,
0.0920233727,
0.0608148016,
-0.0011911776,
-0.0024460088,
0.0109214298,
0.0644312799,
0.0125830816,
-0.0045808144,
-0.0676761493,
0.0390179716,
-0.0172126796,
-0.0001386147,
0.0352442451,
-0.0042094607,
0.001555117,
-0.0551902875,
-0.0123406779,
-0.0059282426,
0.0234098248,
0.0269627832,
0.0344717279,
-0.0034228873,
-0.0517341904,
-0.010184817,
0.0532692149,
-0.0226915814,
0.0012073985,
-0.044558946,
0.0436823778,
0.1032298878,
0.0402732715,
-0.0239349771,
-0.0216953922,
-0.0148957977,
-0.0493413545,
0.0574822463,
0.0581656694,
-0.0278635863,
-0.0211208723,
-0.0142221684,
-0.0380679965,
0.0186917037,
-0.0196205098,
0.0433776565,
0.0207882877,
-0.0229314193,
-0.0245133769,
0.0149983503,
-0.0457796007,
0.0314559229,
0.0377020501,
-0.0333166271,
0.0069907764,
0.0014722357,
0.0605410263,
0.014054236,
-0.0064268694,
0.0152336108,
0.0283049587,
0.0075902562,
-0.0373428278,
-0.006826045,
-0.0301707126,
-0.0363610797,
0.0463339463,
0.0054344106,
-0.0401710756,
0.0519361831,
-0.0490086488,
-0.0179743953,
0.0015598502,
-0.0397308134,
0.0315564573,
-0.0004376875,
0.0291622709,
0.0184268393,
-0.0524788834,
-0.0619509667,
0.0424573012,
-0.0001821076,
0.0166640468,
-0.0024351499,
-0.0069383322,
-0.00285195,
-0.0494948737,
-0.015391265,
0.0388327129,
-0.0016981931,
0.0276412815,
0.0601608716,
0.0302765574,
-0.0483035333,
-0.0255080424,
-0.0985874832,
-0.0067022634,
-0.0061555956,
0.0071479059,
0.0179497749,
-0.008873485,
-0.0036677476,
-0.0125720361,
-0.0593181178,
-0.0270927828,
0.0349156335,
0.0229017101,
0.0482871532,
-0.0008442407,
-0.0149547821,
-0.078606613,
-0.0108668283,
-0.0114313597,
0.0049898881,
0.0047733807,
0.0248461775,
-0.0662353933,
0.0017069087,
-0.0374248177,
0.0413713492,
-0.0084644426,
-0.0724232718,
0.0350198969,
-0.0060614212,
0.0205013175,
0.0645887032,
0.0297228545,
0.0125730187,
0.056811288,
0.0251647718,
-0.0841672122,
0.019379789,
-0.042132359,
-0.0608369932,
-0.0491018929,
-0.0086463671,
0.0203798246,
0.0598844662,
0.0211365148,
0.0165370181,
-0.0785362944,
0.0240748785,
-0.0033906854,
-0.0299744513,
-0.0427558906,
-0.0098797902,
-0.0394861437,
0.0161495637,
-0.0275088158,
-0.0389034674,
0.0895006359,
-0.0073529645,
0.0086794347,
-0.0352274142,
0.0079892278,
-0.0319461785,
0.0541189983,
0.0051155034,
0.029460758,
-0.0072224108,
-0.0049410709,
-0.0712107867,
-0.0306100361,
0.0400740281,
-0.057391569,
0.0289570466,
-0.0589200333,
0.0077491431,
0.000893238,
-0.0753109157,
-0.0607884675,
-0.0252255443,
-0.0389604196,
-0.0071035703,
0.0199948475,
-0.0382164679,
0.0009316697,
-0.0265417919,
0.036030978,
-0.001753238,
-0.0136447316,
-0.0169348046,
-0.0166521743,
0.0161055792,
0.0817809701,
0.0331183001,
-0.0056090145,
-0.0284288712,
-0.0119172987,
0.0623426922,
0.0347900987,
0.010361461,
-0.0184620433,
0.001499036,
0.0450418442,
-0.0316503569,
0.0045160349,
0.0378941149,
0.0389635377,
-0.0422098525,
0.0094398763,
0.1098014712,
0.0353793912,
-0.0315462723,
0.0209665988,
-0.0234308615,
0.0437378958,
0.026292285,
0.0520910285,
-0.0681916699,
-0.0428337082,
0.0019858438,
0.0545775518,
0.007260446,
-0.0094332062,
0.0063922293,
-0.1745763719,
-0.0054824259,
0.0078070299,
-0.0405192748,
-0.0227512754,
-0.0326058231,
-0.0083029512,
-0.0389793292,
-0.0057935826,
0.0340681188,
0.0085337758,
0.0027938178,
0.0121974302,
-0.0292584915,
-0.0346008614,
0.0299000069,
-0.057432916,
0.080969505,
0.0796608552,
0.035600353,
0.0041546491,
-0.0206486769,
0.0053599547,
0.0274146572,
-0.0020832361,
-0.0030975335,
0.0342781171,
-0.0208768696,
0.0035354074,
-0.0426332057,
0.0350876525,
-0.0047437013,
-0.001085379,
0.0095085511,
0.0476358496,
0.001725956,
0.0251228418,
-0.0221405234,
0.0060986276,
0.0303951688,
0.0704394579,
-0.0075354343,
-0.0825510547,
-0.0215255693,
-0.0364358276,
-0.0331589878,
-0.0369449891,
-0.0708008856,
-0.0066199102,
0.0048757722,
0.0228473786,
-0.0949668363,
-0.0448619127,
-0.0024593512,
0.0107798195,
0.0124700526,
-0.0009992481,
0.0281223096,
0.0107576232,
0.0082180388,
0.0329628363,
-0.0131847085,
0.0310462937,
-0.0868510976,
-0.0310606547,
0.0127843209,
-0.0300472043,
-0.0178542603,
0.0039912262,
-0.0495737717,
-0.0808962211,
-0.0147022009,
0.0877953023,
0.0173323844,
0.0454640053,
0.0094959354,
-0.0500575975,
-0.0132000623,
0.0216344967,
-0.0500468984,
0.0102328938,
0.0079931831,
0.0644415691,
-0.0144357141,
0.0320156291,
-0.0332540683,
-0.0134362802,
0.0217471551,
0.0551901385,
-0.0048195375,
-0.0524293073,
0.038919609,
-0.0080764778,
0.0552300066,
-0.0333154798,
-0.0286164526,
-0.0019469934,
0.0065661818,
-0.026397597,
-0.0423177145,
-0.0372559465,
-0.0100606931,
0.025326319,
-0.030449098,
-0.0174931213,
-0.0326546282,
-0.0171987452,
0.030051725,
-0.0300957691,
-0.006225267,
0.0387201048,
0.002322458,
0.0318695158,
0.020336818,
-0.0145699186,
0.0227151234,
0.0103319623,
0.0455990694,
0.0145039931,
0.0719508529,
0.0229159966,
-0.0239557661,
0.001422808,
0.0229272638,
-0.0387895703,
-0.0549702644,
-0.0158484094,
-0.0005511536,
0.0328133777,
0.0267343335,
0.0420664921,
-0.0230808295,
-0.0005335482,
-0.0189446472,
0.0301069114,
-0.0368583053,
-0.0124960206,
0.0512964986,
0.0397371612,
-0.0194780156,
0.0087514604,
0.0559314564,
0.0256242957,
0.0209934153,
-0.0208755452,
0.0009247902,
-0.0332933441,
-0.0207188986,
0.0233961456,
0.0178545322,
-0.0313854329,
0.0242082514,
-0.0516795292,
-0.0366169177,
-0.0223647952,
0.0584181882,
-0.0102914181,
-0.0316117853,
0.0619305968,
0.021657601,
-0.0284130499,
-0.0165634938,
-0.0581753999,
-0.0043562236,
-0.0194020476,
-0.0416426472,
-0.0445665233,
-6.016659836e-33,
-0.0293845609,
-0.0382880904,
0.0218426771,
-0.0030805662,
-0.0358117633,
-0.0478189997,
-0.0122346403,
0.0429801345,
0.0176570173,
-0.0013496546,
-0.0067839166,
-0.0097546186,
-0.0003404793,
0.0153749138,
0.0381128751,
-0.0262588542,
0.0470078066,
-0.0192191638,
-0.0461225621,
0.0008583769,
0.0246370565,
-0.002546004,
0.0309049673,
-0.0696238652,
0.0558438376,
0.0028119476,
-0.0294082966,
0.0311863348,
-0.0319125131,
0.0695122331,
-0.020694254,
0.023914203,
-0.0115454812,
-0.0411053859,
-0.0020372346,
0.0205314551,
-0.0339711644,
-0.0173287541,
0.0229308996,
0.0080052624,
-0.0346984491,
-0.000255458,
0.0370379128,
0.0006201557,
-0.0671493039,
0.0176129676,
0.0209048986,
-0.0116072772,
-0.0273357313,
0.0210559666,
-0.0647122264,
0.0102369841,
-0.0286871567,
-0.043729037,
-0.0221749675,
0.0667089373,
-0.0213194098,
0.0051648165,
-0.0401281342,
0.0286976751,
0.0337430574,
0.0319544822,
0.0428571925,
0.0264313612,
0.0215504393,
0.0727326199,
0.0339709371,
0.0014866201,
-0.0045836475,
-0.0248441864,
0.0161816105,
0.0354491547,
0.0513094887,
0.0836067796,
0.022330787,
0.0202277061,
-0.0359410681,
0.0299063642,
-0.0071996865,
0.0542791262,
0.0228331257,
0.0292319637,
-0.0618254766,
-0.0220190603,
-0.0423379391,
-0.0086888596,
-0.0316003338,
-0.0285673048,
0.0394761674,
0.0227561183,
-0.0102365445,
-0.0467506945,
0.0254985224,
-0.0320078395,
-0.032406155,
0.0044487426,
-0.0334743075,
0.023726441,
-0.0120759094,
-0.0154695557,
-0.051079195,
-0.0087486682,
0.0006415996,
-0.0218782686,
0.0083201006,
0.0091901161,
0.0113095799,
0.032864891,
-0.0755207986,
0.0201266278,
-0.0117707215,
0.0043247072,
-0.0129295122,
-0.007727453,
0.0535129979,
-0.0171139799,
-0.0185982753,
0.0745695233,
-0.0078491755,
-0.0227606334,
-0.0455187112,
-0.0307855364,
-0.0031234985,
-0.0109863151,
-0.0204213765,
0.021885423,
-0.016474355,
0.0225576106,
-0.0164025202,
-0.0292211659,
-0.0184716266,
0.011395013,
2.577e-7,
0.0102535747,
0.0633973628,
0.0169101339,
0.0184481069,
0.0029903061,
0.0784262344,
-0.0268011447,
0.0356949158,
0.0375143029,
0.0112523362,
0.027302023,
0.0217436925,
0.0560580231,
0.0061387671,
-0.0842206702,
0.0044288286,
-0.1054369882,
-0.0027642404,
-0.0387639627,
-0.0151772304,
0.0663827211,
0.0841329023,
0.0247420426,
0.0009906481,
0.0067854044,
0.0066556279,
0.0682311133,
-0.0598746836,
-0.0310472343,
-0.0139181046,
0.0119991777,
-0.0113556292,
-0.0169511903,
-0.025959881,
0.0033796283,
0.0013046777,
-0.0062511577,
0.0694690347,
-0.0213528182,
-0.0299624968,
-0.0155798951,
0.0062609874,
0.0116881989,
-0.0445073172,
0.0411038958,
-0.065902248,
-0.0210590903,
-0.0256788507,
0.0265129209,
-0.0436616763,
0.0169859696,
-0.040491648,
-0.031359572,
0.0028578769,
0.0302270651,
0.0179614406,
-0.0078997212,
-0.0589080229,
-0.017061023,
0.019803986,
-0.0256304983,
-0.0379919223,
-0.0366492942,
0.0369888507,
0.0055309469,
-0.050974831,
-0.0073189861,
2.032577588e-34,
0.0280881375,
-0.0088708829,
0.0321377479,
0.0124777397,
0.0549043939,
0.0397196859,
0.01875869,
0.0135756508,
0.0738385692,
-0.0838824064,
-0.0309431516
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14539v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14539v1 | CMed-GPT: Prompt Tuning for Entity-Aware Chinese Medical Dialogue Generation | 2023-11-24T15:10:56 | 2023-11-24T15:10:56 | Zhijie Qu, Juan Li, Zerui Ma, Jianqiang Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Medical dialogue generation relies on natural language generation techniques
to enable online medical consultations. Recently, the widespread adoption of
large-scale models in the field of natural language processing has facilitated
rapid advancements in this technology. Existing medical dialogue models are
mostly based on BERT and pre-trained on English corpora, but there is a lack of
high-performing models on the task of Chinese medical dialogue generation. To
solve the above problem, this paper proposes CMed-GPT, which is the GPT
pre-training language model based on Chinese medical domain text. The model is
available in two versions, namely, base and large, with corresponding
perplexity values of 8.64 and 8.01. Additionally, we incorporate lexical and
entity embeddings into the dialogue text in a uniform manner to meet the
requirements of downstream dialogue generation tasks. By applying both
fine-tuning and p-tuning to CMed-GPT, we lowered the PPL from 8.44 to 7.35.
This study not only confirms the exceptional performance of the CMed-GPT model
in generating Chinese biomedical text but also highlights the advantages of
p-tuning over traditional fine-tuning with prefix prompts. Furthermore, we
validate the significance of incorporating external information in medical
dialogue generation, which enhances the quality of dialogue generation. | [
0.0564628951,
0.0333865248,
0.0220227968,
-0.0173708294,
-0.0096325632,
0.002492721,
-0.0021417919,
0.0336723067,
0.0306553897,
-0.0283047035,
-0.0264571533,
-0.0726618916,
0.0045341239,
0.0534238294,
0.0265395306,
-0.0769366696,
0.0327339061,
0.0626596436,
0.0399300642,
0.0065066963,
0.0166909005,
0.0038108416,
-0.0577625409,
0.0480799861,
0.018179249,
-0.0074612643,
-0.0014284718,
0.0261680745,
0.0447970033,
-0.0853347257,
-0.0021665797,
0.0576219074,
-0.0112143289,
-0.0104865395,
0.0000018924,
-0.0447396152,
-0.0208126474,
0.0092470292,
-0.0163705517,
0.0150683802,
0.0046664244,
-0.0261699092,
-0.0152874263,
0.0318200216,
-0.0279206559,
-0.0297788251,
0.0488391258,
0.0988125354,
0.0680649504,
0.0978304371,
-0.0162816811,
0.0147093683,
0.0149274422,
-0.0195446629,
-0.0029620058,
-0.033754386,
0.0082393037,
0.0037577983,
0.0355530791,
0.0074023274,
-0.0035737241,
-0.0062142569,
-0.0229050238,
0.0092941448,
0.0018884586,
0.0561152436,
-0.0093439957,
0.0013481155,
-0.0259725899,
0.0804158673,
0.0300665721,
0.0034550694,
0.0108019458,
-0.0089994576,
-0.0064178295,
-0.0327938907,
-0.0392827429,
0.0095260916,
-0.0277502928,
-0.0010391329,
0.0300429631,
0.0043385653,
0.0074108499,
0.016938597,
-0.0096287793,
-0.023491744,
0.0374604426,
-0.0311143976,
-0.0349426828,
-0.0074773096,
-0.0393777341,
-0.0446393304,
0.055150222,
0.0258149095,
-0.0706754103,
0.0183707159,
-0.0471970402,
-0.0033777617,
0.0400309786,
-0.0157269202,
-0.0116683468,
0.0420432091,
0.0137280822,
-0.005326,
0.0023036317,
0.0317535028,
-0.0318746604,
0.0087818289,
-0.0264152773,
0.0360411368,
-0.031178521,
-0.0256163292,
-0.0714530572,
0.0243087634,
-0.0222005062,
-0.0453660376,
-0.0708934367,
0.0064329193,
0.0415897965,
-0.0032855158,
0.0286308918,
0.0282564964,
-0.0442558229,
-0.0032529603,
-0.0051067527,
0.0035021559,
-0.0457879342,
-0.0212213881,
0.0237520672,
-0.0496862344,
-0.0181300621,
0.0234697573,
0.0171292648,
-0.0078832237,
-0.0092546279,
0.0497350805,
-0.012392072,
-0.0035011549,
0.0134587139,
-0.0365108475,
-0.0380047075,
-0.0199909285,
-0.0315303728,
-0.0147652216,
0.0197247248,
-0.0126309218,
0.02060459,
-0.0129132364,
0.0331333801,
0.0278267972,
-0.0381380841,
0.0341496505,
-0.0523154028,
0.0175808854,
0.0360481143,
0.0274812207,
0.0259035062,
0.0128307082,
0.0369729772,
-0.0645787865,
0.0131876254,
-0.0042522373,
-0.0154514266,
-0.0171573572,
0.0264222603,
-0.0419157408,
0.0104944576,
0.0082386574,
-0.0099704359,
0.06903442,
-0.0346536972,
0.0818014517,
-0.0473524965,
0.0179628022,
0.0256362241,
0.0341659524,
-0.0037721691,
0.0260376241,
0.0336012691,
-0.0017288466,
-0.014999602,
0.0364010483,
0.0058828294,
0.0036216502,
0.0128431432,
0.0298194699,
0.0523485467,
0.0143471686,
-0.0295940489,
-0.0214860812,
-0.0122476015,
-0.0014702878,
-0.027005231,
-0.0306614693,
0.0017396393,
0.0185232554,
-0.0771574005,
0.052561067,
0.0270580333,
-0.0653631464,
-0.0135436803,
-0.0308986492,
-0.0103318477,
0.0888095126,
0.0916056111,
-0.0093263686,
-0.0739523545,
-0.0207025167,
-0.0040336563,
0.0670332015,
0.0469141379,
-0.0075020562,
-0.0004147774,
-0.0763227046,
-0.0084239542,
0.0189607069,
0.0099968975,
0.0076120822,
0.0129436972,
0.0122086648,
0.0431074686,
0.025539441,
0.0018323119,
0.0334979668,
-0.0697395653,
-0.0143268937,
0.0105384784,
-0.0067932317,
0.0362621658,
0.0478533693,
-0.0398872755,
0.0504797325,
0.0124398312,
-0.0196077731,
-0.0122156292,
0.0337513424,
-0.0634917319,
-0.0768885314,
0.0137450006,
-0.0302565526,
0.0233199149,
-0.0472437441,
-0.0177508052,
-0.0612299554,
-0.0568244904,
-0.060071528,
0.0276642758,
-0.0420801453,
0.0399507433,
0.0549666435,
0.0125104608,
-0.040035475,
0.0210579988,
0.0058867075,
0.0266093798,
0.0771928579,
0.0461668484,
0.0293243807,
-0.0641742945,
-0.0401207805,
0.0269117802,
0.0233303867,
-0.0027659985,
0.024816595,
0.0515744984,
-0.0186756216,
-0.0492366217,
-0.1414560378,
0.0287729446,
-0.0109901018,
-0.0019005061,
0.0455526747,
0.0261912774,
-0.0227487106,
-0.0027165341,
-0.0637471825,
-0.0190129429,
0.0452181101,
0.0063155564,
0.0460215099,
0.0169945974,
-0.0007672611,
0.0005847773,
0.0149837313,
-0.0258756746,
-0.0029877522,
0.0346901007,
-0.0322482996,
-0.0237960722,
0.0160712078,
-0.0301188938,
-0.0127665708,
0.0175900329,
-0.0425126255,
0.020094851,
0.0206090976,
0.0634336695,
0.021327557,
0.0480512306,
0.0171630234,
-0.0058634421,
-0.0071706055,
-0.0102101201,
0.0208194684,
-0.0350147597,
-0.011421565,
0.0275754165,
-0.0403241813,
0.0267341472,
0.0609469041,
0.0360318385,
0.0063110976,
-0.0732496828,
-0.0143308351,
0.0083066486,
0.0092832157,
-0.0023358678,
0.0177786369,
-0.0408417135,
0.0250263363,
0.0130947493,
-0.017374821,
0.0946342647,
-0.0278366022,
0.0032163162,
-0.0833513662,
0.0280989632,
-0.0482262522,
-0.0126743717,
-0.0078076972,
0.0432167165,
0.0350762196,
-0.0430830307,
-0.0070866188,
0.0520948619,
-0.0073697944,
-0.0543710142,
0.0068628849,
-0.0127067082,
-0.0104820542,
-0.0059133624,
-0.0359312221,
-0.0565146171,
-0.0258229598,
0.0025833594,
-0.000133211,
0.0448076837,
-0.0137699638,
0.0133402068,
0.0580875464,
-0.0272522811,
0.0589087754,
-0.0145597942,
0.0074252407,
-0.0271982998,
0.0429178514,
0.0209937822,
0.03490334,
-0.0008982482,
-0.0294104312,
0.0602980591,
0.0330035351,
0.0043519959,
-0.0064850277,
0.0238765758,
0.0107203834,
-0.0074458276,
-0.0561086163,
-0.0271411017,
0.038360361,
0.0361866653,
-0.0431335159,
-0.0357572846,
0.1403813958,
0.0399623662,
-0.017026633,
0.0106555894,
0.0226752423,
0.0124317659,
-0.0143249398,
0.0111040119,
-0.0737576634,
-0.014055701,
-0.023181688,
0.0212232713,
-0.0167520214,
-0.0197534952,
-0.0013881866,
-0.0857528225,
0.0267308354,
0.0260028429,
0.0027338555,
-0.0384984016,
-0.0079373112,
-0.0328396931,
0.0263472535,
0.0222030804,
-0.0024513244,
-0.005138136,
0.0094375769,
0.0021215666,
-0.0323129781,
-0.074381955,
-0.010002926,
-0.0257823747,
0.0617177747,
0.0865111426,
0.0461707376,
0.0164561924,
0.0032416156,
0.013320175,
-0.022254087,
-0.0099619925,
-0.0114739733,
0.0655787215,
-0.0177606866,
-0.0136521971,
-0.0307781454,
0.0368750095,
-0.0042034918,
-0.0229405724,
0.0203272775,
0.0022459512,
-0.0393325686,
-0.0046109059,
-0.020898236,
0.082778506,
0.0222798586,
0.079379715,
0.0170152541,
-0.0205497481,
-0.0322381184,
-0.001880916,
0.0390656069,
-0.0580347031,
0.0239249188,
0.0345991291,
-0.0167434644,
-0.0162854362,
-0.1131879836,
-0.0190886036,
0.0297450833,
0.0012999119,
0.0127100451,
0.0158427395,
0.0009629118,
0.0276313946,
-0.0284869857,
0.0080915466,
0.0343173556,
0.0002531847,
-0.0923419148,
-0.0511892997,
0.0621311553,
-0.0108640967,
-0.0046810443,
0.0255949572,
-0.0110954158,
-0.0416588224,
-0.0499765016,
0.031154342,
0.0104222009,
0.0327387527,
-0.0027846626,
0.0181566123,
-0.001332081,
0.0302664675,
-0.0246413741,
-0.0187541042,
-0.0044994717,
0.0317636579,
-0.0237772185,
0.0131042488,
0.0243635401,
0.0048761577,
-0.0181108955,
0.0797464997,
-0.0018712023,
-0.0676743537,
0.0393447764,
0.0507566072,
0.0165356714,
-0.0353242755,
0.0080027785,
-0.0479961447,
0.0376708806,
-0.0418204367,
-0.0027389433,
-0.0534732491,
0.0025601964,
0.0210388303,
-0.0357475542,
-0.0142974146,
-0.0060066441,
-0.0763731748,
-0.0101512959,
-0.0207688361,
0.0163711254,
-0.0519838147,
-0.0005239648,
0.0279459748,
-0.0334447734,
-0.0213310346,
0.0140114184,
-0.0041308659,
0.0141638424,
-0.0147463586,
0.1084665731,
0.0008302596,
0.0127745932,
0.0380749851,
0.0607637055,
-0.0415954627,
-0.0054910704,
-0.0430541746,
0.0424650013,
0.0347510315,
0.0053806799,
0.0370268226,
-0.0516519397,
0.0180516895,
-0.0250576865,
0.0549938418,
0.0012591534,
-0.0055736755,
0.0527056158,
-0.011169781,
-0.0000224432,
-0.030029973,
0.0988285244,
0.0180328004,
0.0273136012,
0.0418770239,
-0.0281412788,
-0.0763763711,
-0.0379325338,
0.0193398967,
0.0285518691,
-0.0400239937,
0.0294970125,
-0.0400581397,
-0.0167183895,
0.0075222328,
-0.0164483543,
-0.0255084224,
-0.0103401486,
0.052891165,
0.01865438,
-0.0307409018,
0.0020750414,
-0.023811698,
0.0533110984,
-0.0161732584,
-0.0094444323,
0.0033426343,
-5.862727749e-33,
-0.0502639003,
-0.0350517556,
0.0252123512,
-0.0116595216,
-0.0277388208,
0.0008793286,
-0.0692795739,
-0.0055095386,
0.0153749771,
0.004799298,
-0.0327725746,
-0.022195464,
0.0102924081,
0.0625810549,
-0.0477153249,
-0.0294808671,
0.0474886745,
0.0065274029,
-0.0169454776,
0.0581363924,
-0.0161407366,
0.0625258386,
0.0383574814,
-0.0387784131,
-0.0119386632,
-0.0106188552,
0.0001156136,
-0.0126808379,
0.0177626722,
0.0443739817,
-0.0382914841,
-0.0076313107,
0.0341389924,
-0.0181532856,
-0.0309304502,
0.0287413392,
-0.0651812702,
-0.0062963669,
0.0034900564,
-0.0087193996,
-0.0320221372,
-0.038120348,
-0.0219562687,
-0.0412103795,
0.0206802376,
0.01761478,
-0.0069794222,
-0.0496261008,
-0.0084332302,
-0.0347001068,
-0.0402146615,
0.0600418486,
-0.0029790634,
-0.0181846563,
-0.0405048244,
0.0250976048,
-0.0325072259,
0.0184155479,
0.0234586876,
0.0082060518,
0.0705730617,
0.0102060027,
-0.0166308023,
-0.0243311692,
-0.0093412772,
0.0383863822,
-0.0067389761,
-0.0071284184,
-0.0343671143,
0.0176085085,
-0.0459225103,
0.0312598981,
0.0223030131,
0.0446522534,
0.0019289266,
-0.0153495306,
-0.0908128396,
0.0501701869,
-0.0198010337,
0.0076003144,
0.0276251603,
-0.0227320436,
-0.0404812135,
-0.0198404975,
0.0003145151,
-0.017946329,
-0.0036840166,
-0.0472406298,
0.0402171984,
0.01713714,
-0.0319508463,
-0.0133638671,
0.016541807,
-0.0272085518,
0.0288443044,
-0.0025721509,
-0.0056360094,
-0.008604954,
-0.0626363829,
0.0101761231,
-0.0608763583,
-0.0527612455,
0.0505218692,
-0.0175609533,
0.0007485996,
0.0267189238,
-0.0057799714,
-0.0284895692,
-0.0661022738,
0.027100658,
0.0065628742,
0.0149927139,
-0.0179384612,
0.0603495166,
-0.0006345336,
-0.0015240883,
-0.004033525,
0.0631750599,
0.0143226292,
-0.0130115254,
-0.0478143916,
-0.0482141003,
0.0408573858,
0.019675564,
-0.036496155,
0.0325365886,
0.0057507143,
0.0336396284,
0.0075944955,
-0.0396752767,
-0.0209832713,
-0.0309739728,
2.621e-7,
0.0539453961,
0.0372943021,
0.0669147372,
0.0042532715,
0.0180287194,
-0.0012391999,
0.0117582576,
0.0607917905,
-0.0110122841,
-0.0221190695,
0.0483692065,
-0.009048488,
0.0423874408,
-0.0091002695,
-0.0874184817,
-0.0206221677,
-0.086242564,
-0.0221354645,
-0.0307026152,
-0.0212278869,
0.0593417734,
0.051061321,
-0.0874293,
0.0055821226,
0.0132736973,
-0.0135634728,
0.0636679456,
-0.0259155221,
-0.0225621518,
0.0788149908,
0.0256064385,
0.0178938862,
-0.0025074387,
0.0249711946,
-0.0400566794,
0.0187030938,
0.0232930407,
0.0949117914,
-0.0046136044,
-0.030333519,
0.0418888554,
0.0056670774,
0.0170498174,
-0.0460118726,
0.0380330868,
-0.0423004515,
-0.0286372472,
0.005286118,
-0.0135457078,
-0.0440338254,
0.0710182711,
-0.0685525611,
-0.0606465042,
0.056853164,
0.0209328439,
0.0125309685,
-0.0066567063,
-0.0698458031,
-0.039848756,
-0.0106195435,
-0.0674825236,
-0.0370722599,
0.0176242106,
-0.0542511754,
-0.0041118921,
-0.0337724388,
-0.0146190217,
2.703369995e-34,
0.0359556116,
-0.0207682364,
0.0086303726,
0.0265329052,
0.0350219235,
-0.0215456095,
0.0348608978,
0.0034265637,
0.034402553,
-0.0610932223,
-0.0452701077
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14530v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14530v3 | Machine Translation for Ge'ez Language | 2023-11-24T14:55:23 | 2024-04-15T15:08:43 | Aman Kassahun Wassie | cs.CL | cs.CL | Machine translation (MT) for low-resource languages such as Ge'ez, an ancient
language that is no longer the native language of any community, faces
challenges such as out-of-vocabulary words, domain mismatches, and lack of
sufficient labeled training data. In this work, we explore various methods to
improve Ge'ez MT, including transfer-learning from related languages,
optimizing shared vocabulary and token segmentation approaches, finetuning
large pre-trained models, and using large language models (LLMs) for few-shot
translation with fuzzy matches. We develop a multilingual neural machine
translation (MNMT) model based on languages relatedness, which brings an
average performance improvement of about 4 BLEU compared to standard bilingual
models. We also attempt to finetune the NLLB-200 model, one of the most
advanced translation models available today, but find that it performs poorly
with only 4k training samples for Ge'ez. Furthermore, we experiment with using
GPT-3.5, a state-of-the-art LLM, for few-shot translation with fuzzy matches,
which leverages embedding similarity-based retrieval to find context examples
from a parallel corpus. We observe that GPT-3.5 achieves a remarkable BLEU
score of 9.2 with no initial knowledge of Ge'ez, but still lower than the MNMT
baseline of 15.2. Our work provides insights into the potential and limitations
of different approaches for low-resource and ancient language MT. | [
0.0138216894,
0.0401278362,
-0.0111430436,
0.0473828688,
-0.0397842154,
0.0231089015,
0.0356918573,
0.0462361611,
-0.0360806398,
-0.0541576818,
-0.0323282033,
-0.0578877777,
0.0445650965,
-0.0277800411,
0.0534698032,
-0.0525628217,
0.0178417675,
-0.0002867061,
0.0213929769,
-0.0064350646,
0.0143238148,
0.0431689546,
0.0259153284,
0.0238358583,
-0.0249005128,
0.0262118038,
0.0326184928,
0.0561724231,
0.0291270819,
-0.0103705693,
-0.0579050519,
-0.0177922323,
0.0227350537,
0.0520407446,
0.0000022821,
-0.056133382,
-0.0402791724,
-0.0075441129,
-0.0017129887,
0.008090416,
0.0707138926,
-0.055238843,
-0.017681336,
0.003735852,
0.0054952498,
-0.0200797096,
0.0719081461,
0.0133906789,
0.0124161737,
0.073308453,
-0.0170383379,
-0.0539745875,
0.0123767518,
-0.0226680581,
0.0119010434,
-0.0572672822,
-0.0065018758,
-0.0058408743,
-0.0366929621,
0.0335415192,
-0.040473558,
0.0547715761,
-0.0099199051,
0.0145661775,
-0.0399210379,
0.0088366754,
-0.0352920592,
-0.0193525087,
0.0200162809,
0.0353911333,
-0.0689747781,
-0.0344362631,
-0.0173054133,
0.0092876041,
-0.0217189435,
-0.02569017,
-0.0403583981,
0.0047193002,
-0.0118748387,
0.0214367248,
0.0458952449,
0.0077399961,
0.0621449724,
-0.0292562954,
-0.0654601231,
-0.0143446987,
0.0744899586,
-0.0103923855,
-0.0090244897,
0.0187480468,
-0.0486130193,
0.0226822924,
0.0343222246,
0.0054665268,
-0.0223451592,
0.0062483116,
-0.0240468755,
-0.0266766101,
-0.0035442167,
0.0072553698,
0.0030537632,
0.1077649966,
-0.0193648562,
0.0709554926,
-0.0546827912,
0.0129720299,
0.0147958146,
-0.0188340992,
-0.0494960956,
-0.0449744835,
-0.0225748867,
0.0332674421,
-0.0608086027,
-0.0226138532,
-0.0325040743,
0.0159684103,
-0.0058153966,
-0.0167036746,
0.0250015892,
-0.0063778963,
-0.0196221508,
-0.0431890115,
-0.0528434031,
-0.0414475426,
0.0113738347,
0.0135664772,
-0.0226242319,
-0.0081286235,
-0.0132338759,
-0.0846106857,
-0.0226644464,
0.0088396883,
-0.0074729668,
-0.0500387885,
0.0170244519,
0.0492469221,
-0.0286007505,
-0.0623937882,
-0.033893954,
0.0317116454,
-0.0332441181,
-0.0344692841,
-0.0227804463,
-0.0628828555,
0.0816812068,
0.0035626355,
0.019881824,
-0.0254133381,
-0.0177651774,
0.0202290099,
-0.0324768201,
0.0554710403,
0.0201000962,
-0.0132191395,
0.0714927465,
0.0030910824,
0.0141833201,
0.0376440138,
0.0326752998,
-0.0260478742,
0.0346656442,
0.0142238876,
-0.0324213617,
0.0530335456,
0.0416144803,
0.0384116173,
-0.006551024,
-0.0062711365,
0.0300452523,
0.0628571287,
0.0180335715,
0.076010868,
-0.0150756314,
-0.0170734171,
0.0494235419,
0.0752675384,
-0.0184396934,
0.0540578477,
0.0219457354,
0.0026734855,
-0.0204338729,
-0.0241171475,
-0.0029089802,
0.0293822959,
0.0052351491,
-0.0153172715,
0.0589824021,
0.0776251629,
-0.0121653266,
0.0115080457,
0.0103682876,
-0.0255165026,
0.0185577534,
-0.0380903408,
0.0541819036,
0.0129705891,
-0.0438219011,
0.0573178604,
0.038412407,
-0.0335424989,
0.0313435607,
-0.0281693246,
-0.0131248953,
0.0407868549,
0.0502480716,
0.0055355239,
-0.0009487959,
-0.0223043375,
0.0048180553,
0.0345114619,
0.0639770702,
0.0276921093,
0.0730962604,
-0.0647233352,
0.0228519421,
-0.0077303685,
0.0038061105,
0.0152514782,
0.0006638258,
0.0857999772,
0.0590136237,
-0.0454897024,
-0.0060557406,
0.0477385707,
-0.0534466319,
-0.0266260244,
0.0109452726,
0.0199525263,
0.0015562678,
0.0032434557,
-0.0202173125,
0.0050252113,
-0.0049840678,
-0.0566661544,
0.0081333537,
0.0051385551,
-0.0671089962,
-0.0577510558,
0.037156079,
-0.0123104285,
-0.0011071666,
-0.0194331668,
-0.0319815166,
-0.0321917087,
0.0280852597,
-0.0397503637,
0.0321763158,
-0.0170425456,
0.0474817418,
0.0134861618,
-0.0054851063,
-0.0650989488,
0.053647805,
0.0268805474,
-0.0029621336,
0.0015325996,
-0.0331513695,
0.057362657,
-0.0564376563,
-0.0301508866,
0.0125009371,
0.008172974,
-0.0070082638,
0.0493404865,
0.0203364454,
-0.0131257074,
0.0129115526,
-0.0840745866,
-0.0053383559,
-0.020644553,
0.0219938383,
0.0029998855,
0.0656332672,
0.0066553401,
-0.0051410501,
-0.0170779061,
0.0374065526,
-0.0034380467,
-0.0033160192,
-0.0035710097,
-0.0254802648,
0.0198481344,
-0.0335830003,
-0.0031131175,
0.0244995486,
0.0487584099,
0.0220398679,
-0.0272717439,
-0.0310946181,
0.0146619352,
-0.0566149801,
-0.0009343935,
0.0102048451,
-0.022386156,
0.0027938453,
-0.0275344346,
0.0229615383,
-0.0073243845,
-0.0181110054,
-0.0201321952,
-0.0062514683,
-0.0256038066,
-0.0782551393,
-0.0228301063,
-0.0448834784,
-0.0464090295,
-0.0280750357,
-0.0174157228,
0.0021504201,
0.0087312609,
0.0107820341,
0.0019791396,
-0.0634148046,
0.0105889589,
-0.0277280379,
0.0155157233,
-0.0097563472,
0.0270433128,
0.0110542318,
0.018137211,
-0.0305715762,
-0.032731697,
0.0736490488,
-0.019270556,
-0.0046731238,
-0.0349534936,
0.0054519037,
-0.0402391106,
0.0357395969,
-0.0198282413,
0.0404639319,
-0.0577023104,
-0.0064756824,
-0.0379549786,
0.0347716548,
0.0027589656,
-0.0065222578,
0.0231079981,
-0.0486009903,
0.0045317425,
-0.0192656592,
-0.0314851552,
0.0058630225,
0.0140062021,
-0.0109116146,
-0.0106962835,
0.0477726832,
0.0249218605,
-0.0531128347,
0.0241318494,
-0.0081977453,
0.0500233695,
0.0139770117,
0.0044539808,
-0.0141619211,
0.0419502594,
-0.012434951,
-0.0263536442,
0.0300710071,
-0.0440131836,
0.0262398385,
0.0023695969,
0.0195072554,
-0.057792753,
-0.0167736169,
-0.0261088144,
0.0663396344,
-0.0040815808,
-0.0241952799,
-0.0460766815,
0.0428473428,
-0.0437620357,
0.0029164518,
0.1005872935,
0.0094255004,
-0.0466420837,
0.0020144151,
-0.0438250974,
0.002876611,
0.0052785832,
0.036836274,
-0.091239363,
-0.0424635671,
0.0011782757,
0.0217345543,
0.0449285582,
0.0142679131,
-0.0096643027,
-0.1295527816,
-0.0208250619,
0.0734329596,
-0.0732111409,
-0.0501303412,
0.0027179522,
-0.0193130095,
-0.0123727107,
-0.001801925,
-0.0174193978,
0.0350087397,
-0.0058416948,
-0.0117318677,
0.0641343445,
-0.0439329557,
0.0272868332,
-0.0964206085,
0.0449192636,
0.0293168407,
0.0638241917,
-0.0250182152,
-0.0009052963,
0.0546577834,
-0.0569227301,
-0.0248728432,
-0.0062689395,
-0.0036290141,
-0.004649986,
-0.0039877077,
0.0492380969,
0.0046945456,
-0.0069469083,
-0.0191954132,
0.0122923283,
0.0336879194,
-0.0199748054,
-0.0111213876,
0.0492165312,
-0.023303492,
0.0063109817,
0.0546913594,
-0.0007921817,
-0.0412292629,
0.0081022959,
-0.0137722474,
0.0108503485,
-0.0270544495,
-0.0173983071,
-0.0258411616,
-0.0301517937,
-0.0024067054,
-0.1029139087,
-0.0287161861,
0.0085102851,
0.0378557444,
0.0490893163,
0.0114249103,
0.0052101859,
-0.0031201283,
-0.0281060562,
0.0445940979,
-0.037797004,
0.0282093994,
-0.0753062591,
0.0171459168,
-0.0025645369,
-0.0669897571,
0.0172975659,
0.0359710418,
-0.05555683,
-0.064740032,
-0.0145639386,
0.0628319383,
0.012428903,
0.0182438269,
-0.0235665813,
-0.0421289951,
0.0154604539,
0.0364178456,
-0.0308027118,
0.0045107687,
-0.0276499018,
0.0022915651,
-0.0049190721,
0.0532804206,
-0.0106584141,
0.0024580283,
0.0118930675,
0.0372184105,
-0.0098315198,
-0.0567413941,
0.0042749573,
0.0051553561,
0.0368178897,
-0.0547668859,
0.0065906169,
-0.0350404009,
-0.0119931353,
0.0031119143,
0.0345155448,
-0.0343925543,
-0.036261525,
0.0453304201,
0.0204640683,
0.0176812317,
-0.0345696248,
0.0393273048,
0.0028544385,
-0.0089511452,
-0.0392236225,
-0.061975956,
0.0112948716,
-0.0066597466,
0.0367737524,
-0.0061667091,
0.0328669362,
-0.0458881445,
0.0251286738,
-0.0744284391,
0.0314976126,
0.0199056417,
-0.0000578188,
0.0219046697,
0.0274873935,
0.010943423,
-0.0418589339,
-0.0341402739,
-0.0040312181,
0.0762307197,
-0.0107308384,
0.1174332649,
0.0149053158,
-0.0347608887,
-0.022180371,
0.0216822661,
-0.0012367395,
-0.0300539751,
-0.0240695365,
0.0041832915,
0.0034586913,
0.0363440439,
0.0379728936,
-0.0179284364,
-0.0049859961,
0.016647758,
-0.0183324944,
0.012014173,
0.015005297,
0.0056268852,
-0.0027455569,
-0.0258729961,
-0.0014626224,
-0.0426964536,
-0.046852652,
-0.0321559273,
-0.0017546384,
-0.0434211865,
0.0136098852,
0.0285566412,
0.061914973,
-0.038619481,
0.0248110704,
-0.0360054299,
0.0168453101,
-0.0140210651,
-0.0284911692,
0.015651498,
-6.537292896e-33,
-0.0345531292,
0.0148724448,
0.0392829441,
-0.0428124554,
-0.0125126308,
-0.0449857861,
-0.0576114692,
-0.0236771703,
-0.0286946744,
0.0031277773,
0.0177921019,
-0.0237307735,
0.0110323327,
0.0194795243,
0.0083954735,
0.0196576919,
0.0435544625,
0.0388457142,
-0.0337756574,
0.0299281608,
0.072868295,
0.0520313382,
0.0982518867,
-0.0645170435,
-0.0019385931,
0.0044670026,
0.0024135923,
0.0332143717,
-0.0031586983,
0.0107457349,
-0.0186738782,
-0.011589596,
0.0052360431,
-0.000503361,
-0.0067350883,
-0.0537412204,
-0.0876561254,
0.0004368144,
0.0136140771,
0.054769557,
0.0220521539,
-0.0155657353,
0.02927332,
-0.0374126211,
-0.0223287698,
0.0034124032,
0.0162110943,
-0.0400489829,
-0.0373223536,
0.0036599864,
-0.104404144,
0.0296992417,
-0.0008972309,
-0.0109934611,
0.0193336233,
0.0465397574,
-0.0221938286,
0.0568436459,
-0.1096316203,
-0.0129248369,
-0.0712405369,
0.0217517037,
0.0681235418,
0.0060970774,
-0.017197581,
0.0326654762,
0.0106266234,
-0.0328392647,
0.0330120623,
0.007449809,
0.040956296,
-0.0232673604,
0.0320929885,
0.0326773636,
0.0553457625,
-0.0695316643,
-0.0432571657,
0.0249550417,
-0.0068432563,
0.0181769934,
0.0429739691,
0.0362211987,
-0.0025897089,
-0.0229482874,
-0.015898494,
-0.0402296484,
-0.0272503626,
0.00216301,
0.0114141544,
0.0040729134,
-0.0332634076,
0.0142788114,
0.0809994936,
-0.0079069296,
0.0164595526,
-0.0065783798,
-0.0449826717,
-0.0473777764,
-0.0239766669,
0.0444211438,
-0.0440169461,
-0.0697062537,
0.0091402307,
-0.0107711079,
0.01037311,
-0.0185396913,
0.0285160355,
0.0196788851,
-0.0482342727,
0.0284147896,
-0.0547708981,
-0.0542825684,
-0.006107803,
0.0213162154,
0.008077438,
0.0087044202,
0.0231995396,
0.035255827,
0.0976517797,
-0.0546628907,
0.032018207,
0.0092644254,
0.0062362687,
-0.0017647177,
-0.0327864699,
0.0195422824,
0.001206873,
-0.0035142016,
0.0375888757,
-0.0437413156,
-0.0315146893,
0.0128191402,
3.226e-7,
0.0700962618,
0.0356427729,
-0.0103586717,
-0.0168667622,
-0.0053808,
0.0418585055,
-0.0417036712,
0.0295713414,
0.0310507398,
0.0782697424,
0.0211550295,
0.0229699016,
0.0963922739,
0.0200174656,
-0.0717676505,
-0.0153264822,
-0.02711148,
-0.0155596286,
-0.0552939624,
-0.0017947442,
0.0220149308,
0.1177860796,
0.0084673669,
-0.0158230122,
0.0098248115,
-0.0620745532,
0.0882094726,
-0.0328622274,
-0.038532652,
-0.0065527,
0.0196994748,
0.0408309773,
-0.0469888747,
-0.0139767323,
-0.0261784643,
0.0402880833,
0.0752807483,
0.0626985729,
0.0149488868,
0.0178227592,
0.0184964519,
-0.0162408352,
-0.0168013368,
-0.0690166652,
0.0351425149,
-0.014266422,
-0.0072271135,
0.0432515852,
-0.0079268431,
0.0046878182,
0.0499871522,
-0.0249778163,
-0.0352504514,
0.0111486213,
0.0695557296,
0.0219471436,
-0.0568807013,
-0.0365700871,
-0.0090313395,
0.0026515108,
-0.0063770888,
-0.0275647417,
0.0012359746,
0.0150170512,
0.0035149837,
-0.0021122699,
-0.0165186413,
2.79531776e-34,
0.0228365213,
-0.0244945921,
0.0078949761,
-0.0151770357,
0.0299419053,
-0.0311549958,
-0.0123969214,
0.0160629973,
-0.0296017397,
-0.0128267799,
0.0010715466
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.14517v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.14517v2 | tinyCLAP: Distilling Constrastive Language-Audio Pretrained Models | 2023-11-24T14:45:53 | 2024-06-12T11:41:31 | Francesco Paissan, Elisabetta Farella | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, cs.LG, eess.AS | Contrastive Language-Audio Pretraining (CLAP) became of crucial importance in
the field of audio and speech processing. Its employment ranges from sound
event detection to text-to-audio generation. However, one of the main
limitations is the considerable amount of data required in the training process
and the overall computational complexity during inference. This paper
investigates how we can reduce the complexity of contrastive language-audio
pre-trained models, yielding an efficient model that we call tinyCLAP. We
derive an unimodal distillation loss from first principles and explore how the
dimensionality of the shared, multimodal latent space can be reduced via
pruning. TinyCLAP uses only 6% of the original Microsoft CLAP parameters with a
minimal reduction (less than 5%) in zero-shot classification performance across
the three sound event detection datasets on which it was tested | [
-0.0543487109,
0.0542574301,
-0.0032188944,
0.0450561345,
0.005147967,
-0.0023701291,
0.0477137491,
-0.0153634427,
-0.0976482928,
0.0050853286,
-0.0736253709,
-0.0305998977,
-0.0009228732,
0.0328229629,
0.0326558165,
-0.0800155103,
-0.0015534974,
-0.0306338631,
-0.0068979566,
-0.0233589951,
0.0193071291,
-0.0039186701,
-0.061809577,
0.0262203887,
0.0066818236,
-0.0109592499,
-0.0317584835,
0.0377617106,
-0.0051770485,
-0.038635388,
-0.0056389626,
0.0385613665,
0.0560598299,
0.0015359322,
0.0000019797,
-0.0198437255,
0.0243469477,
-0.0038392288,
-0.0071349326,
-0.0012145679,
0.0216490608,
0.0052433885,
-0.0182064064,
0.0449082144,
0.0069498578,
-0.0898522884,
0.0553556122,
0.0225603171,
0.0292159747,
0.0665149912,
-0.0225412231,
-0.0774747804,
-0.019235393,
-0.0262076519,
0.0178761259,
0.0008355359,
-0.0147293424,
-0.0436025038,
-0.017409442,
-0.0035242175,
-0.0364442281,
0.0351457298,
0.0036174033,
0.0499856696,
-0.0031533611,
0.0352741592,
-0.0622997582,
-0.023230115,
-0.0022112189,
0.0777100325,
0.005736324,
-0.0242792089,
0.0069765882,
0.0036119425,
-0.0232114736,
-0.0418690294,
-0.0381937958,
0.0124895005,
0.033955723,
0.0230497047,
-0.0479584187,
0.0686808303,
0.0266709756,
-0.0232486706,
0.016247604,
-0.045801159,
0.0016507048,
0.0097002797,
0.0162264779,
-0.0102442214,
-0.0101371426,
-0.0238501672,
-0.0021046391,
0.0044108788,
0.0032720936,
-0.0676286072,
-0.0558992997,
-0.0295751952,
-0.0199260078,
-0.0023269372,
0.0492660068,
0.0295476075,
-0.0569214597,
0.0538588166,
0.0120335333,
-0.0015063259,
-0.0124539575,
-0.0096859625,
-0.0165174175,
0.008754869,
0.0067685661,
-0.0027636853,
-0.0375298671,
0.01246153,
-0.0295278095,
-0.0278888997,
-0.0049221986,
-0.0369711034,
-0.0530798808,
-0.0254386552,
-0.0083030406,
0.0276393909,
-0.0337237678,
-0.016409561,
0.0275040027,
0.0705275908,
-0.0139136473,
0.0727010891,
-0.0341317058,
-0.0356343649,
-0.0319903195,
0.0381133854,
0.0424895585,
-0.0147439493,
0.0403721556,
0.069400683,
0.0053567537,
-0.0631451905,
-0.0371011645,
0.0009410044,
-0.0290652961,
-0.0529753715,
-0.0049202275,
-0.0937070474,
0.0587489046,
-0.0410180725,
-0.0056637027,
-0.0300772265,
-0.0366139673,
-0.023609858,
0.0126899295,
0.0715846047,
-0.0237980168,
0.039343968,
0.0284438636,
0.0047253203,
0.0125109274,
0.0692670867,
0.0608885698,
0.0089022107,
0.0117556518,
-0.0218530633,
-0.0218984429,
0.0371524841,
0.0492287986,
0.0019009663,
-0.055836644,
-0.0404756255,
-0.056451939,
0.0040823198,
0.1045985222,
0.036608845,
-0.0571218543,
-0.051018402,
0.0569299795,
0.0383198522,
0.0448811203,
-0.0179179572,
0.0390617251,
0.0009577308,
-0.0249324273,
0.0073153982,
0.001428925,
0.0529495776,
0.0141201923,
-0.0106860129,
0.0752769038,
0.0428462662,
-0.0704941377,
0.0016325609,
0.0217626542,
-0.0332662165,
-0.0301798172,
0.0069039622,
0.0363459215,
0.0169371329,
-0.0065476424,
0.0726113096,
0.013749171,
-0.0416987166,
0.0119483499,
-0.0188751016,
-0.012170095,
0.0164649673,
-0.0044417907,
-0.0387543067,
0.0091971513,
-0.0207136124,
0.0247972179,
0.0046345475,
-0.0008772297,
-0.0229523592,
0.0939706862,
-0.0223872848,
-0.0408556573,
-0.0196092557,
0.0082043288,
0.0215384737,
0.0074777585,
0.0269293096,
0.0111881485,
-0.0290294625,
0.0512454547,
-0.0203651916,
0.0001790969,
-0.0726036653,
0.0227983911,
0.0356852561,
0.0693048388,
0.0138398595,
-0.0385448709,
0.0076019666,
0.0285351463,
-0.0560079888,
0.0334840827,
0.0187651813,
-0.0511771515,
-0.0821369067,
0.0384986661,
-0.0290379897,
0.0660583153,
0.0647665262,
-0.0470832214,
-0.0409067795,
0.0534843951,
0.0069640502,
0.0404988192,
-0.0186245181,
0.0074015129,
0.0092403153,
0.0047138175,
0.0196752027,
-0.0128026716,
0.0015196791,
-0.0120269833,
-0.026898928,
0.0342054963,
0.0387644917,
-0.0170220714,
-0.0557081848,
0.0421112403,
-0.0157610383,
0.0163369812,
0.0187288299,
-0.0272225942,
-0.0048596766,
0.0253505707,
-0.0356837101,
0.0184522737,
-0.0269946903,
0.036614947,
0.0049703512,
0.0132203223,
0.0129020065,
-0.0243254192,
-0.0099661136,
-0.0126964757,
-0.0188225228,
0.0160051789,
-0.0381832756,
0.0113094635,
-0.0076127006,
-0.0013783191,
-0.0218898598,
0.0565914586,
0.0333763249,
-0.0751583278,
-0.0044056666,
0.0131617188,
0.0513280705,
0.0040210658,
0.0404814519,
0.0075347056,
-0.0354898907,
-0.0040173749,
-0.0056326035,
0.0358435065,
0.0241024885,
-0.0197839942,
0.0225490723,
0.0588520467,
0.0194954388,
-0.0210088007,
0.0044431719,
-0.0046868441,
0.0126905274,
-0.017297931,
0.0094121546,
-0.0542719252,
0.0865476653,
0.0207286738,
0.0115155317,
-0.0434742607,
-0.0251372959,
-0.0014607252,
-0.0293844435,
-0.0222091563,
-0.0114345532,
-0.0437055677,
0.024455579,
-0.0303468145,
-0.0513464883,
0.0171858761,
-0.0345303044,
-0.0187361669,
-0.0417069122,
-0.0575645827,
-0.0175269339,
0.0649477318,
-0.0168825369,
0.0207051449,
-0.0141562512,
-0.0221763309,
-0.0710305423,
-0.0090784132,
0.0423601903,
-0.0309074149,
0.0045750267,
-0.0092337243,
-0.0030995533,
-0.0357667245,
-0.0546527952,
0.0016454455,
-0.0325407125,
-0.0040497971,
0.0126540754,
-0.0269568786,
-0.0002834416,
-0.0362953916,
0.022362845,
0.0304319561,
0.0756203458,
0.0097392239,
0.0182198938,
-0.014902465,
0.085068278,
0.0071940231,
-0.0165871251,
-0.0226566829,
-0.0329483859,
0.0341084525,
0.0418547541,
0.0765320435,
0.0126173478,
-0.0722641125,
0.0236220267,
0.0291317981,
0.0493797772,
-0.0477615558,
0.0551349446,
0.0483933128,
-0.042402219,
-0.005634327,
0.0773836076,
-0.009783186,
-0.0285801273,
0.0155660454,
0.0828972533,
0.052523274,
0.0087020136,
-0.0541061349,
-0.051330924,
-0.0526676625,
0.0239169206,
0.0335531533,
0.049146276,
0.010929619,
-0.0120855104,
-0.0444950722,
0.0282528382,
0.0340554826,
-0.0659659132,
-0.0305493511,
-0.0173641834,
-0.004913067,
-0.0250952337,
0.0025500776,
0.0003675203,
-0.0159888305,
0.0146733504,
0.0325630493,
-0.0120404819,
-0.0697657689,
-0.0052934699,
-0.0448481068,
0.0425424315,
0.0301680509,
0.0312968269,
-0.0144055169,
-0.0179471727,
0.0109386873,
-0.0427045412,
-0.0142647242,
0.0090903221,
0.0892771408,
0.0051877252,
0.0047964253,
0.0567855649,
0.0424499437,
-0.0242825188,
-0.0205709208,
-0.0104914326,
0.0189307351,
0.0066632982,
0.0054848501,
-0.0155715104,
0.0412223898,
-0.0041723638,
0.0707624629,
0.0384410694,
0.0026778604,
-0.0031146179,
0.0395417213,
0.0106589645,
-0.0538977422,
0.0044575129,
-0.0233216379,
-0.0043885391,
-0.0514653698,
-0.0152495783,
0.0151313739,
-0.0014312313,
0.0562558025,
-0.0431738533,
-0.004744485,
-0.0325265899,
0.0034815164,
-0.0751144215,
0.0527716912,
0.0143470485,
0.0387563519,
-0.0333295763,
-0.0156350955,
0.0133713251,
-0.0240939427,
-0.0276595969,
0.0343265086,
-0.0988959447,
-0.0461588539,
-0.0347244479,
0.0119690811,
0.0174908079,
0.0404894911,
0.0397580527,
-0.0409298427,
0.0503513776,
0.0211856645,
-0.0284834914,
0.0767885149,
0.0698504001,
-0.0239919461,
0.0107150311,
0.0215252191,
-0.044229608,
0.0614757687,
0.0026078706,
0.0175281893,
0.0088899117,
-0.0195314027,
-0.0205297396,
-0.0451959819,
0.0715241656,
-0.0225672573,
0.0445756167,
-0.0525758639,
0.0197356045,
-0.0000503277,
0.0335711464,
-0.0739976689,
0.0167861786,
0.0188580938,
0.0407313555,
-0.0516364127,
0.0098263072,
0.0113581568,
0.0118668899,
-0.0095393099,
0.0425029248,
0.0644183457,
-0.0303575918,
0.0411400497,
0.0182229206,
0.0262398887,
0.0144621311,
-0.0017495025,
-0.0074599707,
0.0046145082,
0.0171306208,
0.0128025878,
0.0309167597,
-0.0118484413,
0.0216538105,
-0.0282603018,
-0.0039884998,
-0.0144924847,
-0.0103491126,
0.012777633,
-0.0345660001,
0.0298253745,
0.0102529684,
-0.0103177736,
-0.0211155489,
0.0431186408,
-0.0445368513,
0.0038241444,
0.0203970149,
0.0147568835,
0.0033388727,
-0.0010584091,
0.0926798657,
-0.0299079157,
0.041664917,
-0.0350054987,
0.0380755588,
0.000854732,
-0.024554342,
0.0155534456,
0.0825999528,
0.0126449838,
0.0028496736,
-0.0340211205,
-0.0707535073,
-0.0230350792,
-0.0316581912,
0.0234712586,
0.0092580402,
0.0614011399,
0.0022685397,
-0.0064554699,
0.0051880144,
0.0430220179,
-0.0721482038,
-0.0020305989,
-0.0125306603,
0.0374434441,
-5.943919878e-33,
-0.0154457297,
0.0029438515,
0.0095332731,
0.0037493457,
-0.0184525922,
0.0380779505,
-0.0242585409,
-0.0171917025,
0.0117440363,
0.0014395614,
0.034599416,
0.0216036644,
0.0097666085,
0.0352309309,
-0.0044618989,
0.0204837434,
0.0959923193,
-0.0431010276,
-0.0032222648,
0.0344373919,
0.0339452773,
0.0297162589,
0.0143834893,
-0.0508656725,
-0.0894859806,
0.0200298727,
-0.0419795848,
-0.0055005606,
0.0607859455,
0.0216059908,
-0.0208975933,
0.0274448656,
-0.0222842619,
-0.0281404946,
-0.0212255958,
0.0079269437,
-0.0831734985,
-0.0338069275,
-0.0090745315,
0.0110094901,
-0.0312172957,
-0.0020988481,
0.0237333961,
0.006206431,
-0.0025438154,
-0.0648976266,
0.0104826121,
-0.0100596836,
-0.0146295745,
-0.0893909708,
-0.0462454818,
0.0326487236,
-0.0129405884,
-0.0468702912,
0.0653370395,
0.0416001938,
-0.0108160703,
-0.0081534227,
-0.0534373224,
0.0390843004,
0.0287253894,
0.0181160588,
0.0235103238,
0.0199248344,
-0.0162965935,
0.0503258258,
0.0539373495,
-0.0720020309,
0.0267317984,
0.0164363477,
0.0417979471,
0.0383780301,
-0.0116459085,
0.0416898243,
0.0841088444,
-0.010856444,
-0.0503926314,
0.0267856345,
-0.0440276191,
0.0012335842,
-0.0030458823,
0.0571989045,
-0.03310927,
-0.0266040675,
-0.0427397043,
-0.0341537409,
-0.023418013,
-0.0359620228,
0.0221097078,
0.0135288555,
0.0052301269,
-0.0055664699,
0.054939907,
-0.0318369754,
0.0110314647,
0.0138648134,
-0.036873322,
0.0037316927,
-0.0027556075,
-0.0144354841,
-0.0582612827,
-0.0203591511,
0.0861539021,
-0.0062943478,
0.0284097195,
-0.0039102817,
0.0232731588,
0.0909700021,
-0.0649473667,
-0.0146152638,
-0.0023504845,
-0.0232108906,
0.0520370491,
0.0710431263,
0.0320012271,
-0.0020712961,
-0.0246740393,
0.0491428822,
-0.0097870277,
-0.0211488362,
-0.0295988843,
-0.0249797758,
-0.0105860792,
0.0536665879,
-0.0170522351,
0.0319651142,
-0.0211865138,
-0.0300119687,
0.053640943,
-0.0420493558,
-0.0419868566,
-0.0070582232,
2.811e-7,
-0.0109540308,
-0.0374994501,
-0.0217556302,
-0.0269367173,
0.0385238081,
0.0314591564,
-0.0187497307,
0.0174000245,
-0.0376130454,
-0.0050014718,
0.0412017331,
0.0274615102,
0.061734803,
0.0487074144,
-0.07796783,
0.0282399766,
-0.0612944104,
-0.0063105635,
-0.0064028311,
-0.0496343188,
0.0416561514,
0.0787085518,
0.0297731422,
-0.0610661693,
0.0384579301,
-0.0063831755,
0.0265380535,
-0.0055158692,
0.050348483,
-0.0617829636,
0.0017504647,
-0.0188768953,
-0.0259948205,
-0.0220951326,
-0.0424460582,
0.0154770454,
0.0110905329,
0.0449778996,
-0.0058112103,
-0.0764867514,
0.0063476623,
0.0406041592,
-0.0421682,
-0.0181353204,
0.0552199446,
-0.0233107358,
-0.0443178825,
-0.0238629617,
-0.0625682995,
-0.0090546599,
0.0028883948,
-0.0139860343,
0.024378987,
-0.0135686072,
0.0025380785,
-0.0142406607,
-0.0417959578,
-0.0717283785,
0.0194517206,
0.0405867398,
-0.0279225167,
-0.0394634493,
-0.0256506652,
-0.0329473168,
0.006131913,
-0.0343627483,
-0.0238954332,
2.187232925e-34,
0.0072199181,
-0.0427688099,
0.0169084482,
-0.0352638997,
-0.0386224091,
-0.0277289543,
-0.0033468525,
-0.01633339,
0.0083232122,
-0.0114195161,
-0.0351712964
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.