id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09694v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09694v2 | Whispers of Doubt Amidst Echoes of Triumph in NLP Robustness | 2023-11-16T09:09:32 | 2024-04-03T15:07:45 | Ashim Gupta, Rishanth Rajendhran, Nathan Stringham, Vivek Srikumar, Ana Marasović | cs.CL | cs.CL | Do larger and more performant models resolve NLP's longstanding robustness
issues? We investigate this question using over 20 models of different sizes
spanning different architectural choices and pretraining objectives. We conduct
evaluations using (a) out-of-domain and challenge test sets, (b) behavioral
testing with CheckLists, (c) contrast sets, and (d) adversarial inputs. Our
analysis reveals that not all out-of-domain tests provide insight into
robustness. Evaluating with CheckLists and contrast sets shows significant gaps
in model performance; merely scaling models does not make them adequately
robust. Finally, we point out that current approaches for adversarial
evaluations of models are themselves problematic: they can be easily thwarted,
and in their current forms, do not represent a sufficiently deep probe of model
robustness. We conclude that not only is the question of robustness in NLP as
yet unresolved, but even some of the approaches to measure robustness need to
be reassessed. | [
0.0331936143,
0.0496341251,
-0.0319113992,
0.0239443015,
-0.013249794,
0.004484606,
-0.0003516709,
0.0327890031,
0.0363268107,
-0.0776602998,
-0.0120302783,
-0.0261109341,
0.0066317865,
0.0236883685,
0.03363638,
-0.0588110574,
0.0411677361,
-0.0151814735,
-0.029026296,
0.0328746773,
0.0068260957,
-0.022275079,
0.0013857292,
0.0352210552,
0.0110189551,
-0.009944207,
0.0244125482,
0.0071080602,
-0.0098552695,
-0.0423686989,
0.0042642974,
0.0726276338,
-0.0332228243,
0.0577870496,
0.0000017172,
-0.0191158,
0.0075437836,
0.0290924199,
-0.0186214596,
0.0363348424,
0.0416984335,
-0.0526304469,
-0.0151512697,
0.0037957912,
-0.0238227118,
-0.0293904468,
0.0285356417,
0.094974488,
0.0320001543,
0.08766862,
-0.0027943226,
-0.0234084725,
0.0534000359,
-0.0396039076,
-0.0839006528,
-0.0558090433,
0.0140859867,
-0.0521784909,
0.0062600831,
0.0277964156,
-0.0073823822,
0.0187423937,
0.029913336,
0.0359758027,
-0.0413673259,
0.0066596176,
-0.0291175041,
-0.0175666846,
-0.0219383147,
0.0691020042,
-0.0365652815,
0.0047123334,
-0.017189879,
-0.0316813253,
0.0075840955,
0.0151655395,
-0.0314706676,
0.0194052961,
0.0308725256,
-0.0117733022,
-0.0249899067,
0.0199568141,
0.0599279031,
0.0150944218,
0.0166858528,
0.0209619701,
0.0202257913,
-0.0150937373,
0.0116341114,
0.0084249871,
-0.0639306381,
-0.0462592952,
-0.0058256867,
-0.0028583938,
-0.0173175875,
0.0143888174,
-0.0743512362,
-0.0121293627,
0.0348179117,
-0.046645388,
0.0829438046,
-0.0034514582,
-0.036964044,
0.022724377,
-0.017836798,
0.0525580831,
-0.0383163802,
0.0416586772,
0.0015502416,
0.0303469952,
-0.0521908514,
-0.0075606392,
0.0093897646,
0.0417324863,
-0.0336777344,
0.0011420458,
-0.0387782156,
0.0005722647,
-0.0353559777,
0.0232202131,
-0.0215677489,
0.0315990485,
0.0024693052,
0.0065161213,
-0.0289429631,
-0.0195647553,
-0.0458630137,
0.0078650108,
0.0175097603,
-0.1003673151,
-0.0086652124,
0.0131770493,
-0.0518701673,
-0.0720886812,
-0.0048905294,
0.1213944927,
0.0475781858,
-0.0621888936,
-0.0364892483,
-0.0194253065,
-0.0457078144,
-0.0583718941,
0.0284434371,
-0.019300472,
-0.0100362664,
-0.0023697515,
0.0073095202,
-0.0754334256,
0.0071386076,
0.0252528153,
-0.0429079011,
0.1033601686,
0.0310915057,
-0.0448595136,
-0.031563621,
0.0137015022,
-0.0052461373,
0.0712315068,
0.0051072887,
-0.0039150347,
0.0725128129,
0.0056695421,
0.0208630357,
0.0158765744,
0.0144975325,
0.0120994579,
-0.0106237959,
0.0185676366,
0.020705441,
-0.0076883533,
-0.0514406525,
0.0740769207,
-0.0103329727,
-0.0624964051,
0.0787291974,
0.0179006197,
-0.0192613695,
0.0110714678,
-0.0002599954,
-0.0576900654,
0.0077293641,
0.0403917469,
-0.0789463148,
-0.0135539081,
-0.0764750838,
-0.0358774476,
0.009726719,
0.014472072,
-0.0256407801,
-0.0514264144,
-0.1013343334,
0.0099189449,
0.0364422947,
-0.0261590797,
0.0398060903,
0.0596540719,
-0.0082345083,
-0.0051577105,
0.0161992144,
-0.0135512585,
-0.0174758192,
-0.0394897647,
-0.033955358,
-0.0065178699,
0.0760175735,
-0.0361097343,
0.0463264696,
-0.0170244314,
0.0211316459,
0.033004459,
0.0780259147,
0.0103369271,
0.0198331233,
-0.0224773213,
-0.0076619238,
-0.038060274,
0.0500620417,
0.0048945593,
0.0505636595,
-0.0144461375,
-0.0108293444,
-0.0133675197,
-0.0451528467,
0.0618291236,
-0.0150399776,
-0.047419291,
0.0061725304,
-0.0046805628,
0.0242329314,
0.0186511707,
-0.028344756,
0.0303317755,
0.0352169983,
-0.0072225872,
-0.0050949012,
-0.0109259365,
0.0043097041,
-0.0225308873,
0.0316512138,
-0.0092093749,
-0.0272864569,
0.0766439214,
-0.0251412075,
0.0093032056,
0.0319828764,
-0.0309013687,
-0.0049361847,
0.000320446,
0.0229646787,
-0.0034362292,
0.0612499826,
-0.0538092069,
0.0564974658,
-0.0153474044,
0.0340705812,
-0.0308509152,
0.0287795626,
0.022756651,
-0.030311415,
-0.0751906186,
0.0611419789,
-0.0330212153,
-0.005777108,
0.0045613181,
-0.0324286297,
-0.0359710269,
0.0072868294,
-0.0249792989,
0.0007212357,
-0.0247812029,
-0.0046192529,
0.034843307,
-0.0256997105,
0.0225829277,
0.0062832572,
0.0320211947,
0.0079979124,
0.0063759885,
0.0598060638,
0.032445211,
0.0027154447,
0.0060382201,
-0.0293169357,
-0.0550207347,
-0.015926322,
0.0924042612,
-0.007484864,
0.0120734256,
0.0066688522,
0.0182592422,
-0.0130787604,
0.0507671535,
-0.0225656424,
-0.0332293995,
0.0248955227,
0.0198207982,
-0.0102639673,
0.0622529648,
-0.0054688249,
0.0799296126,
0.0509483628,
0.0216809455,
0.0087890448,
0.0073636253,
-0.0150462463,
-0.018444825,
-0.0233194586,
-0.0049805255,
0.004497976,
0.0570896715,
-0.0031005738,
-0.0072508128,
-0.0400430821,
0.0216347836,
-0.052495122,
-0.0340534486,
-0.0156133957,
0.0099534001,
-0.0141989365,
0.0478316434,
-0.0265883449,
-0.0253252685,
0.064552635,
-0.0089568188,
0.0150348907,
-0.0084881512,
-0.020890912,
-0.0006236038,
0.0914457515,
0.0124736466,
-0.0171607304,
0.0597590394,
-0.0035357927,
-0.0565731712,
-0.0617584661,
0.0276488904,
-0.0253639277,
0.0489581823,
-0.0398862809,
0.00372998,
-0.0004598297,
-0.0642982572,
-0.0448030047,
-0.0175192896,
-0.024575673,
0.0508364812,
0.0172988437,
-0.004468238,
-0.048855301,
0.0217354316,
0.0003389227,
0.0132917715,
-0.0339416675,
-0.0185640957,
-0.007730314,
0.0513613895,
0.0351148322,
0.0001654289,
0.0703556687,
-0.0317002051,
0.0133857559,
0.0706996992,
0.0056054047,
0.0430309661,
-0.0435061939,
0.0210781433,
0.0180253237,
-0.0328816772,
-0.0178462751,
0.0226389058,
0.0562960207,
-0.0416501351,
-0.0375009067,
0.0569664016,
0.0196931623,
0.036506284,
0.0399220549,
0.040382009,
0.0080333566,
0.0246901885,
-0.0047427476,
-0.0232276712,
-0.0264065061,
0.0162744001,
0.0171881244,
-0.0043320959,
-0.0365396328,
0.0020142174,
-0.1292119473,
0.0093608554,
-0.0249410793,
-0.0094877081,
-0.0416885279,
-0.0541739427,
-0.0015453455,
-0.0507060699,
0.0649605617,
-0.0152368592,
0.0040052934,
-0.0083660968,
0.0005612139,
-0.0205220133,
-0.0578356571,
0.0187265389,
-0.048435472,
0.0311181135,
0.0875800103,
0.0177856293,
-0.0227208994,
-0.0089996429,
0.068057701,
-0.0186562631,
0.0096413232,
-0.0082927551,
0.0701356605,
0.006037809,
-0.0184443593,
0.0150807034,
0.0042173536,
-0.0292327721,
-0.0350518599,
-0.0209181681,
0.0184719134,
0.0197882615,
-0.0437694825,
-0.0374596678,
-0.0016681076,
-0.0153220082,
0.0682699755,
0.0155848935,
-0.0210639369,
-0.0587616786,
-0.0599156134,
-0.0180558972,
-0.0579108149,
-0.0647536442,
0.0283288397,
0.035242416,
0.0039500631,
-0.0703603402,
-0.0586581342,
-0.0227053557,
0.032022953,
-0.0043113423,
-0.0172001906,
-0.0225213617,
0.0172508676,
-0.0080418885,
0.0186553746,
-0.0051413393,
0.0341204032,
-0.0358381644,
0.0001796964,
0.0143670514,
0.0056317388,
-0.0226845294,
0.0179527048,
-0.0722530931,
-0.0779152587,
0.0058306414,
0.051059328,
0.0233485829,
-0.0071910159,
-0.0466200188,
-0.084228836,
0.0216821115,
0.0395035371,
-0.0136296228,
0.001923661,
0.0582189262,
-0.0316673182,
0.0205968451,
0.0435728841,
-0.0280848425,
-0.0046548541,
0.0506192259,
0.0257152636,
0.0101403631,
0.0112960665,
0.0063614687,
0.0265289862,
0.0465529151,
0.0006345546,
-0.0393973552,
0.019923877,
-0.0265977047,
-0.0245727096,
-0.0248136688,
-0.015471437,
0.0349815786,
0.030310791,
0.0464781411,
-0.0412832387,
0.0207394361,
-0.0059673963,
0.0518325903,
-0.028706722,
0.010513721,
0.0302500613,
-0.0120447623,
-0.0018393671,
0.029724285,
-0.0052030995,
0.04250836,
-0.0138998302,
0.0434444435,
-0.0008803948,
0.0053450707,
0.0265912767,
0.0148336105,
-0.0100945318,
0.0098614255,
-0.1000918075,
0.0080571789,
-0.0311253555,
0.0018730081,
0.0248730313,
-0.0412268415,
-0.0049889572,
-0.0279304162,
-0.0340142436,
-0.0378485657,
-0.0224797372,
0.0285617877,
-0.0082380772,
0.0408603102,
0.0323656425,
-0.0090514338,
-0.0017217204,
0.0544258505,
0.0141848214,
0.0451068729,
0.0434888341,
0.000182541,
-0.0502111465,
-0.0479923561,
-0.0016015703,
0.0075466279,
-0.0139738964,
0.0238237362,
-0.0478868932,
-0.0934038758,
0.0259830207,
0.0084748603,
0.0502751842,
0.0130272033,
-0.0029333851,
0.0594444126,
0.0390293077,
0.0340291783,
-0.0352798477,
-0.0219149254,
-0.0026485587,
-0.0019134835,
-0.0325852185,
-5.764820457e-33,
-0.0109347273,
-0.0239112806,
-0.0349615328,
-0.0874531195,
0.0339031965,
0.0018608588,
-0.0241352562,
0.0101430975,
-0.0626749843,
0.0094938762,
-0.0138872359,
0.0114623737,
-0.010985231,
0.0193981342,
-0.0054681664,
-0.0650953054,
0.0306438264,
-0.0146241104,
-0.0388521962,
-0.047310859,
0.0164456982,
0.006861276,
0.0166378655,
-0.0565068983,
0.0470679626,
0.0469200201,
-0.0279456861,
-0.0016702102,
-0.0313305557,
0.0723489225,
-0.0076086698,
0.0480372943,
0.0152941933,
-0.0101261865,
0.0004378541,
-0.0364463367,
-0.0671853945,
-0.0194515754,
-0.0077052107,
0.0225162469,
-0.0229982119,
0.0082247714,
0.0374087542,
-0.0204469506,
-0.0321097933,
-0.0419880487,
0.0089624133,
-0.010608023,
-0.0033516469,
-0.01142669,
-0.0155856004,
0.0249244459,
0.0178255755,
0.0030024825,
-0.005798067,
0.0032416724,
0.0047326689,
0.0371540077,
-0.0421362109,
-0.0447428897,
0.0360862389,
0.0382522307,
0.0180121642,
0.0042298888,
-0.0103633013,
0.0596163422,
0.0056949016,
0.0512470305,
-0.0197250303,
-0.0107069016,
0.0334454253,
0.0484274626,
0.1125979125,
0.0845794603,
0.0398329087,
-0.000938064,
-0.064704299,
-0.0127159953,
0.0126941055,
0.0149801793,
0.0304410011,
0.0222197138,
-0.0523687229,
0.0020692046,
-0.0423367992,
-0.068830058,
-0.0470234156,
-0.0286430996,
0.0305867363,
0.0184420682,
-0.0095136911,
0.0354305357,
-0.0136498995,
-0.0560170338,
-0.0243790951,
0.0311698001,
0.004348543,
-0.0028707013,
0.0191589836,
0.0198778361,
-0.0260639843,
-0.0181707051,
0.00475547,
0.0003237412,
0.0224349946,
-0.0343102254,
0.057121627,
0.0162562877,
-0.0549735762,
-0.0217028949,
-0.0230218098,
0.0566820689,
0.0434416085,
0.0282831751,
0.0485357605,
-0.0020631521,
-0.0107587557,
0.0228148922,
0.0177981257,
-0.0089222901,
-0.0419546068,
0.0322251506,
-0.003835829,
-0.0043974975,
0.0098162312,
-0.0489057377,
-0.0236614477,
0.0305785276,
0.0322284251,
-0.060594786,
-0.0215630475,
-0.0180501249,
2.348e-7,
0.0423192419,
0.0536146797,
0.0216078088,
0.0205910262,
0.026112305,
0.0312064532,
-0.0238517709,
0.0418317169,
-0.0436240472,
-0.0180832688,
-0.0519548617,
0.0161930863,
0.0769697651,
0.0369792953,
-0.0112688541,
-0.0174573772,
-0.0847878084,
0.0310979486,
-0.0132892504,
-0.0123650692,
0.0402605832,
0.119064644,
0.0336356536,
0.026868429,
-0.0209468864,
-0.0419377387,
0.0429134816,
-0.033180587,
0.0296006855,
-0.032672897,
-0.0074330168,
0.0232430566,
0.0203015134,
0.0258601196,
-0.0345708355,
0.0133015364,
0.0243526325,
0.0538074151,
0.0179681517,
-0.0542896502,
-0.0314819925,
-0.0296331793,
0.0015078795,
-0.0452620313,
0.0836217403,
-0.0354744382,
-0.0330039188,
-0.0093075084,
-0.0314726271,
-0.0197438449,
0.0430542789,
-0.0029291476,
-0.0299741905,
0.0254095942,
-0.0019966927,
0.0127573358,
0.0018006555,
-0.0863785967,
-0.0287023205,
-0.0010138056,
-0.0197857581,
-0.044323355,
-0.0112858573,
-0.005676413,
0.0305817928,
-0.0519121476,
-0.0426147208,
2.289235759e-34,
0.0584717058,
-0.0101512345,
0.013478877,
-0.0120347925,
0.0435697511,
-0.0033175214,
0.033929918,
-0.022285128,
0.0150916837,
-0.0472725332,
-0.0181028359
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09693v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09693v2 | BLT: Can Large Language Models Handle Basic Legal Text? | 2023-11-16T09:09:22 | 2024-02-28T14:46:25 | Andrew Blair-Stanek, Nils Holzenberger, Benjamin Van Durme | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.1; I.2.7; J.7 | We find that the best publicly available LLMs like GPT-4, Claude, and {PaLM
2} currently perform poorly at basic legal text handling. We introduce a
benchmark consisting of tasks that lawyers and paralegals would expect LLMs to
handle zero-shot, such as looking up the text at a line of a witness deposition
or at a subsection of a contract. LLMs' poor performance on this benchmark
casts into doubt their reliability as-is for legal practice. However,
fine-tuning for these tasks brings even a smaller model to near-perfect
performance on our test set and also raises performance on a related legal
task. These results suggest that many simple behaviors needed for a domain may
not be present in foundational LLMs, without additional engagement from subject
matter experts. | [
0.0235707182,
0.0235352609,
0.0008525072,
0.0109437732,
-0.0817820877,
0.0270039421,
0.0321986675,
0.0653374493,
-0.0115930559,
-0.0830135569,
-0.017408751,
-0.0222608093,
-0.0370922387,
-0.0131871467,
0.0039599412,
-0.0262280982,
0.040868368,
0.0136297438,
0.0523794368,
-0.0024304588,
0.0164268501,
-0.0069726324,
0.0072112759,
0.0055861636,
-0.032056842,
-0.012957382,
-0.0106034586,
0.0200120229,
-0.0085764714,
0.0029461994,
-0.0217100009,
0.0646315366,
-0.0023756551,
0.0311032124,
0.0000018228,
-0.0506147742,
0.0199960172,
-0.0059445933,
-0.0078401649,
0.0455095954,
0.0298756342,
-0.0388335772,
-0.0417211466,
0.0062586023,
-0.0272406843,
0.05135151,
-0.0163231678,
0.0396781452,
-0.0003635398,
0.1044625267,
-0.0065504862,
-0.0186903402,
0.0481774993,
-0.0399074517,
0.014561506,
-0.0504957251,
0.0115650296,
0.0058791251,
0.0595052056,
-0.0115073733,
0.0192084685,
0.0225329101,
0.0556963123,
-0.010327002,
-0.0454253964,
0.0145760588,
-0.0463905036,
0.0488236584,
-0.0124976132,
0.0224053562,
0.0365700871,
0.0050566341,
0.0008853385,
-0.0247172751,
0.0436385758,
-0.0015584965,
-0.0236699656,
0.0690903887,
-0.0012763964,
-0.003025671,
-0.0015225329,
-0.0041700797,
0.0299888216,
0.0045757364,
-0.0165995434,
0.0482472703,
0.0049913274,
-0.0346210711,
0.0225283206,
0.0263578873,
0.0258954987,
-0.0473862179,
0.014139914,
0.0401404276,
0.0094560655,
0.0201471988,
-0.0562200285,
0.0231567491,
0.0759850368,
-0.0296467841,
0.0359085761,
0.0203513261,
-0.0337996222,
0.0681394562,
-0.0544539392,
0.0165448673,
-0.0363017656,
0.0204573702,
0.0204319376,
-0.0215734802,
-0.026448993,
0.0105446205,
-0.0268027894,
0.0442265309,
-0.1103085801,
0.0065688975,
0.0001134128,
0.0147845363,
0.015135264,
0.0429595225,
0.0100237112,
-0.0324687287,
-0.0057400344,
-0.0405368097,
-0.0607576817,
-0.0500307642,
-0.0101186875,
0.0315593928,
0.0146008134,
-0.0557043478,
0.0066154459,
-0.0021979031,
-0.0109110633,
-0.0199262537,
0.0014560296,
0.1041848734,
-0.0045548864,
-0.0420551784,
-0.0345074981,
-0.0560249053,
-0.0301619936,
-0.0788837299,
-0.0250729993,
-0.0673510656,
-0.0170220546,
0.0069576441,
-0.0215082224,
-0.0678941235,
0.0052970476,
0.032523673,
-0.0254277028,
0.0572341904,
-0.0104407296,
-0.0170131158,
-0.0281598978,
0.0327114947,
0.0084165679,
0.0287644286,
-0.0014360952,
0.0192773286,
0.0051079765,
0.011444632,
0.0271178149,
0.0725442246,
-0.0175609589,
0.0446570292,
-0.0112546571,
0.0037692112,
0.0004878578,
0.0350073986,
0.0280433949,
0.0615410879,
-0.0144794332,
-0.0354129151,
0.0592733175,
0.0822135657,
0.0223800018,
0.0455473363,
-0.0009747391,
-0.0149203092,
0.0391866118,
-0.0035569281,
-0.0860867128,
0.0133570656,
-0.0348960906,
0.0072393026,
-0.0736985505,
-0.0075836326,
-0.0226565916,
-0.0439244285,
-0.0132116219,
0.0012729851,
-0.0461284071,
-0.0128905978,
0.0327513814,
-0.0245949198,
-0.0367638916,
0.0633516759,
0.0126554789,
-0.0386001877,
-0.0513628833,
-0.029576689,
-0.0171606708,
0.0345926397,
0.0482878536,
-0.0453504026,
-0.0242443942,
-0.0223834757,
0.0204654448,
0.094087027,
0.06756033,
0.0278422814,
-0.007019565,
-0.0412726514,
-0.0283667296,
-0.0149919568,
0.0337670334,
0.0101518547,
0.0138954949,
0.0138674341,
0.0285345484,
-0.056209486,
-0.0081428178,
0.0252836179,
-0.0481054075,
-0.0508781597,
-0.0178068001,
-0.0202361178,
0.0241706073,
0.0241720397,
-0.0034840959,
-0.0143713001,
0.0208951253,
0.0007063829,
0.0182821024,
-0.0111040846,
-0.0083549721,
0.0045418907,
0.0559687838,
-0.012160359,
-0.0315045081,
-0.0122084459,
-0.0344571471,
-0.0238974225,
-0.0542566627,
-0.0243766326,
0.0167445391,
-0.0420022905,
0.0151749598,
0.0078421999,
-0.0362134464,
-0.0255172439,
0.043074999,
-0.0127655687,
-0.0098781744,
0.0019745994,
0.0072491448,
0.0259461496,
-0.0513979942,
-0.0305109899,
-0.0128973424,
0.0064195199,
0.0295796786,
-0.007120843,
0.0313923396,
-0.0380528159,
-0.0515201129,
-0.0781686604,
0.0040988247,
-0.0288193673,
0.021419324,
-0.0080528827,
-0.0290937107,
-0.0248191059,
-0.0125216292,
-0.0364520848,
-0.0166770313,
0.017273562,
0.00571161,
0.0057720938,
-0.020273339,
-0.0276721437,
-0.024047194,
-0.006696973,
0.0008734569,
-0.0105120605,
0.0251775347,
-0.0262248199,
-0.0216855872,
0.0706885457,
-0.0123014692,
-0.0114738038,
-0.0205176827,
0.000698513,
-0.0041515827,
0.0101271868,
-0.0288710501,
0.0317095779,
-0.0083393473,
0.0321968123,
0.0044322698,
-0.0050296648,
-0.079570584,
0.0045829411,
0.0370885879,
-0.0060298704,
-0.0782344788,
-0.0143717872,
0.0032551349,
0.0359857716,
-0.0249426048,
0.0415058993,
-0.003958751,
0.0071331402,
0.0103048198,
-0.0028571594,
0.0256251283,
0.0209179483,
-0.0406835265,
0.061705064,
-0.0035117264,
-0.0698201656,
0.0090190936,
-0.0025124722,
0.0414918885,
-0.0203102399,
-0.0095822494,
-0.045541063,
0.0730702728,
-0.0120939566,
-0.0117577277,
-0.0201064888,
-0.0598295517,
-0.0150624244,
-0.0139482198,
0.062730439,
-0.0464264713,
0.1161628515,
-0.021135265,
0.0599779263,
-0.0519845709,
-0.0515364222,
-0.0326013826,
-0.0180862118,
-0.0474849865,
0.0631949678,
-0.0030423524,
0.0050124456,
-0.0647531226,
-0.01886498,
-0.014326063,
0.0260327663,
0.0104820402,
-0.0037137638,
-0.0494456403,
0.0032092382,
-0.0084166331,
-0.011858209,
0.012187073,
-0.0571252815,
-0.0001420559,
0.0249242466,
-0.0062355702,
-0.0269651841,
0.0032051713,
-0.0133240586,
0.0032600784,
-0.0629829392,
-0.0421835817,
0.0380417928,
0.0091120722,
-0.0730642006,
0.0163910352,
0.120710209,
0.0097549111,
-0.0366072394,
-0.024717154,
-0.0131474007,
0.0016809439,
0.0425905399,
0.0257511027,
-0.105546698,
-0.0010022437,
0.0063889851,
0.0035270739,
-0.0070598,
-0.0380204245,
0.0033897664,
-0.1038250774,
0.1130477041,
0.0274615958,
0.0113870716,
0.0069316402,
0.027697036,
0.0080388011,
0.0091209235,
0.0420566499,
0.0049186503,
-0.035746213,
-0.0216958579,
0.0194089543,
-0.0155210579,
0.0175452977,
0.0195787381,
-0.0411074087,
0.0427843705,
0.0167499352,
0.0041099698,
-0.0343889706,
-0.0146442186,
0.0658365339,
0.006757739,
0.0272858609,
-0.0008061989,
0.0376372412,
0.0267744809,
0.0136490902,
-0.0308377258,
-0.0009184589,
-0.0184873994,
-0.0140169663,
0.0462518185,
0.0465323627,
-0.0490352735,
0.0015865888,
-0.0164860878,
-0.0198845286,
-0.0484785959,
0.0417837128,
0.0349861793,
0.0056522898,
-0.06938795,
-0.0293678958,
-0.0396682434,
-0.0029552046,
-0.0159597378,
-0.0119161364,
-0.0282491688,
0.0236718766,
-0.0386308804,
-0.0314742401,
0.0113800298,
0.0704054087,
0.0110972831,
0.0210504532,
0.0096610608,
-0.0086510479,
-0.0303207505,
0.012944689,
-0.0474460125,
0.007028162,
-0.0629070103,
0.0285716448,
0.0172845256,
0.006430211,
-0.0027540324,
-0.0244468339,
-0.0044113421,
-0.0287605096,
-0.0157255884,
0.0150235603,
0.0340385884,
-0.0006334642,
-0.0302707013,
-0.0502899662,
0.0166778341,
0.0288114734,
-0.0500072688,
0.0240276773,
0.0397334769,
-0.0128976358,
-0.0174020082,
0.0158501454,
-0.015078146,
0.0312399585,
0.0443458781,
-0.0064773154,
-0.0331293941,
-0.0376146175,
0.0080150105,
0.0604406819,
0.0135092586,
0.0228007045,
0.0014558004,
0.001966814,
0.0107368017,
-0.0398558825,
0.003800638,
-0.028552115,
-0.0121246669,
0.005544018,
-0.0142431082,
-0.0388973653,
0.071170792,
-0.0100692976,
0.0426853374,
-0.0539326593,
0.0308167487,
-0.0066970279,
-0.0242026728,
0.0294717327,
-0.0370504558,
0.0086632287,
0.0310736131,
-0.0140114147,
0.0672504008,
0.0100326883,
0.0564459451,
0.0026408317,
0.0178956203,
-0.0018210328,
0.0032742666,
-0.0344394334,
-0.0683529377,
0.0115255136,
0.0854448006,
0.0683274567,
-0.0101355426,
0.023311602,
-0.0543528832,
0.0018398669,
-0.0195280593,
0.0233748574,
0.016179163,
-0.0245597139,
0.0534395911,
0.0247361027,
-0.0118774818,
0.0076387487,
0.0429545119,
0.0334667265,
0.0377082266,
-0.0129414154,
0.0038337437,
-0.0356631018,
-0.0508325398,
0.0207021628,
0.0256332569,
-0.0083276462,
-0.0273687933,
-0.1099951565,
-0.0260249637,
0.0066274237,
-0.0072896448,
-0.0237579532,
-0.0315003656,
0.0093703512,
0.0468460768,
0.0428885818,
-0.0135740116,
-0.0148275066,
0.0314342119,
0.0080947541,
-0.0246070754,
0.0111233434,
-5.336958513e-33,
-0.0316497236,
-0.0500493757,
0.0442513674,
0.0478105843,
-0.0151563631,
-0.0018046062,
-0.0051291403,
0.0106227184,
0.0078748623,
0.0225741863,
-0.0429733209,
0.0444356874,
0.0296350922,
-0.0251010023,
0.0317892581,
-0.0376169048,
0.0224050283,
-0.0116664656,
-0.0095239328,
-0.0081916433,
-0.0307708438,
0.0085304044,
0.0321924798,
-0.0703464672,
0.0095256614,
0.0292035826,
-0.0089920936,
-0.0477398336,
-0.0783751383,
0.0554651022,
0.0018060979,
0.0177799314,
0.0182822999,
-0.0277191419,
-0.0119612254,
0.0007292347,
-0.0560045652,
0.0130814333,
0.0227268413,
0.0000723549,
0.0000153008,
-0.0376230329,
0.0381779447,
0.0038066672,
-0.0540381595,
-0.023942804,
0.014800787,
-0.0518759117,
-0.0596945733,
-0.0714706853,
-0.0784294456,
0.0713764727,
0.0267703254,
0.0312819034,
0.0468258895,
-0.0300885271,
-0.0054605585,
0.0307275895,
-0.0379058048,
-0.0276545212,
0.0023332876,
-0.0131971203,
0.0324396081,
-0.072985068,
-0.0450408719,
0.0651766807,
0.0043769185,
0.0423188806,
-0.0064697037,
-0.0265541319,
0.0289518926,
0.1178201735,
0.0237199944,
0.0557963289,
0.0003625254,
0.0129972696,
-0.0489556864,
0.0015081844,
0.0479210727,
0.0423149057,
0.0030754067,
-0.0093427589,
-0.0442879871,
-0.0003279699,
-0.0280479882,
-0.0022410771,
0.0013038757,
-0.0078134909,
0.0344878547,
-0.0019773203,
0.0759154335,
-0.0137633933,
-0.0072925119,
-0.0230130944,
-0.0049242596,
0.0018710059,
-0.0109298108,
0.0325554423,
-0.0286456011,
0.032065887,
-0.088906467,
-0.023645794,
-0.0300359279,
0.0103512853,
0.0087701743,
-0.0066725258,
0.046341829,
-0.0213133823,
-0.0911026895,
-0.0051905396,
-0.0077686342,
0.0607832931,
0.0384730026,
0.0295786671,
0.0265674647,
-0.0196194593,
0.0321873017,
0.0343586393,
-0.0129575059,
-0.0742244199,
-0.0187520925,
0.006981804,
0.0141293379,
-0.0058094054,
-0.0065562129,
0.0229048729,
0.014561425,
0.0620510839,
0.0448159575,
0.020000428,
0.0190921295,
0.0457297936,
2.488e-7,
0.0899696872,
0.039266672,
0.009369852,
0.0273158569,
0.0046821148,
0.0338839851,
-0.0189431291,
0.0282535311,
0.0019885555,
-0.0342306346,
0.0136752855,
-0.0039466075,
0.0888429508,
0.0291997083,
-0.0650275946,
-0.002136634,
-0.0270368569,
-0.034791261,
-0.0659777746,
0.0124698477,
0.0263957735,
0.0589712821,
-0.00515091,
-0.0340971611,
0.0035469867,
-0.0319837593,
0.082870461,
-0.052339565,
-0.0169747658,
-0.0167545732,
0.0901350453,
-0.0135874515,
-0.0146389911,
0.0497499853,
0.0103128897,
0.057148885,
-0.048330728,
0.1043835655,
0.0015505041,
0.0383518785,
0.0028232327,
-0.0802989602,
0.0023020825,
-0.0231737848,
0.0387959518,
0.0216688551,
0.0017082605,
0.0040489482,
-0.0452637747,
-0.0540872701,
0.0021502574,
0.0389887504,
0.0058100787,
-0.0233495459,
0.0218473691,
-0.065562889,
-0.012924931,
-0.0767846107,
-0.0022650571,
0.0416933149,
-0.0259190127,
-0.0122847809,
-0.02487389,
0.0220289622,
0.0515784584,
-0.0850585699,
-0.0151656996,
2.110960791e-34,
0.0498517901,
-0.0201665033,
0.0188938119,
0.0728352591,
0.0126848668,
0.0573257543,
-0.0106160278,
0.018110536,
-0.0048116399,
-0.0504737645,
0.0314025208
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09687v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09687v1 | Inducing Political Bias Allows Language Models Anticipate Partisan Reactions to Controversies | 2023-11-16T08:57:53 | 2023-11-16T08:57:53 | Zihao He, Siyi Guo, Ashwin Rao, Kristina Lerman | cs.CL | cs.CL | Social media platforms are rife with politically charged discussions.
Therefore, accurately deciphering and predicting partisan biases using Large
Language Models (LLMs) is increasingly critical. In this study, we address the
challenge of understanding political bias in digitized discourse using LLMs.
While traditional approaches often rely on finetuning separate models for each
political faction, our work innovates by employing a singular,
instruction-tuned LLM to reflect a spectrum of political ideologies. We present
a comprehensive analytical framework, consisting of Partisan Bias Divergence
Assessment and Partisan Class Tendency Prediction, to evaluate the model's
alignment with real-world political ideologies in terms of stances, emotions,
and moral foundations. Our findings reveal the model's effectiveness in
capturing emotional and moral nuances, albeit with some challenges in stance
detection, highlighting the intricacies and potential for refinement in NLP
tools for politically sensitive contexts. This research contributes
significantly to the field by demonstrating the feasibility and importance of
nuanced political understanding in LLMs, particularly for applications
requiring acute awareness of political bias. | [
0.0318168476,
0.1010914892,
0.0024612613,
0.0391437672,
-0.0174362641,
0.0130041791,
0.0156836957,
-0.0097803911,
0.0212662555,
-0.0864783823,
0.0176054891,
-0.0194187947,
-0.0230599213,
-0.0120069738,
-0.0298349485,
-0.0545129105,
0.0344099142,
0.0633566082,
0.083179228,
-0.0507714339,
0.0567156672,
0.0517659895,
0.0024470831,
0.03041921,
-0.0484502912,
-0.0260458495,
0.0073824478,
0.036394082,
0.052614335,
-0.0016708948,
0.0341071784,
0.0546373576,
0.0003275219,
0.0556116812,
0.0000017361,
-0.0273178164,
-0.0237159394,
-0.0270831231,
0.034536127,
-0.0153088626,
0.1195731461,
-0.022716837,
0.0000110852,
0.0130977239,
-0.0479086861,
0.0168649666,
0.0400748104,
0.0364165418,
0.0581555963,
0.0475455523,
-0.0081191622,
-0.0283720549,
-0.0283932909,
0.0196667481,
-0.0405023247,
-0.0204543751,
0.036123693,
-0.0051124082,
-0.0713847801,
-0.000671347,
-0.0162326414,
-0.0067400881,
0.0182654429,
0.042987179,
-0.0377262644,
-0.0053278478,
0.0096169915,
-0.0216525458,
-0.0127146244,
0.0333927013,
-0.0093051186,
-0.0219187681,
0.035406854,
-0.0222371817,
-0.0118520129,
0.0195318162,
-0.037013419,
0.0357294902,
-0.0255373027,
0.0397423394,
0.0622638352,
-0.004489061,
0.0167584866,
0.0853449181,
0.0066320598,
0.0339007638,
-0.0164805315,
-0.0137318037,
-0.0010350501,
0.0159059763,
0.0049191886,
0.020726813,
0.0266705528,
-0.0175293852,
0.0134858154,
0.0412385166,
-0.0448742136,
-0.010582448,
0.0258361399,
-0.0586958937,
0.0238042586,
-0.0094430605,
-0.0053052828,
0.0688361749,
0.0723036379,
-0.0278046392,
-0.0112546533,
0.0069435579,
0.0186210051,
-0.0152873658,
-0.0218916312,
0.0018009045,
0.0260686763,
0.0129084019,
-0.0211124234,
-0.0027262284,
-0.0050870329,
-0.0483981147,
-0.0366890244,
-0.0131943319,
0.0071439571,
0.0127233313,
-0.0065615838,
-0.0310639553,
-0.0466833673,
0.0670396388,
-0.0542854182,
0.0339407884,
-0.0464862175,
-0.0412352122,
0.0350648016,
0.0326274969,
-0.0199348982,
-0.0113245258,
-0.0033709654,
0.0507126711,
0.0117235258,
0.0010777477,
0.0108095063,
-0.035157904,
-0.0291524492,
-0.0386590511,
0.0363804027,
-0.0581435375,
0.0649358034,
-0.0008831015,
0.0053459941,
-0.0627495497,
0.0268389937,
0.0325773135,
-0.0263771936,
0.0625107959,
0.0100864209,
0.0240914766,
0.0292262416,
0.0276696142,
0.0097561078,
0.0994379297,
-0.0052341577,
0.0128049878,
0.0628549233,
-0.0200940445,
-0.0019741808,
0.027843982,
-0.0216031186,
-0.0040009529,
-0.0722539425,
0.0144787235,
-0.0395240039,
-0.0279129446,
0.0402235053,
0.0566142797,
0.0289708842,
-0.0435508527,
0.074072212,
0.0821047351,
-0.0258215293,
0.0370248035,
-0.0123414285,
0.0145766549,
0.0155934729,
-0.0045618941,
-0.029080037,
0.0133576076,
-0.0073816557,
-0.0748091266,
0.005927329,
0.060021475,
-0.0045682844,
-0.0252725203,
-0.0295438729,
0.0035716274,
0.0354178548,
-0.0095293289,
0.0069825845,
-0.046317216,
-0.0139539232,
0.0193145387,
0.0663893893,
-0.0573932678,
-0.0018986568,
-0.0319738425,
0.0626641437,
0.0739082173,
0.0141346361,
-0.019411318,
0.0084315259,
-0.0499692038,
0.0462258346,
0.0763686821,
0.0728635788,
-0.0257770699,
-0.0213739108,
-0.035581816,
-0.0155548397,
0.0077174082,
0.0248032399,
0.0540324114,
0.0290752184,
0.0074663484,
-0.0152303847,
-0.0038165252,
-0.0095129851,
0.0377096348,
0.0135213016,
-0.0029364871,
-0.0121221673,
0.0282294638,
0.017065635,
0.0430653095,
-0.0116843982,
-0.0493781008,
0.0343946964,
-0.0097261714,
-0.0194401406,
-0.0186028145,
-0.0359551273,
0.0327188559,
0.034781374,
-0.0370266177,
-0.0198006332,
0.0246883165,
-0.0283904895,
0.0337038338,
0.0611954741,
0.0083456412,
0.0043425751,
-0.0186675191,
-0.0344890617,
-0.0618195198,
0.0112240631,
-0.0511425026,
0.0711899847,
0.0009603738,
-0.0103497542,
0.0152890915,
-0.0554683618,
0.0084814737,
0.0269788466,
-0.027408788,
0.0041942815,
0.0044198213,
0.0452951975,
0.0268474966,
-0.0348788239,
-0.0491968021,
-0.0681761131,
-0.0393050425,
-0.0069774901,
-0.025517283,
0.0144095095,
0.0287803672,
-0.0272066966,
-0.0119666308,
0.0332399383,
-0.0046796971,
-0.0428342707,
-0.0141279669,
0.0120077804,
0.0138457632,
-0.0343549848,
-0.0001972109,
-0.0434754901,
-0.0014746313,
-0.0303010996,
0.021528095,
0.0110869594,
-0.0231622458,
0.0259792358,
0.0134992516,
-0.0365158841,
-0.0087287286,
-0.0171916429,
-0.0405782424,
0.0311036129,
0.0161379967,
0.0185771212,
0.0738899931,
0.0419080295,
0.0700704232,
0.0147525389,
-0.0157767553,
-0.0691870824,
-0.0272909161,
-0.0466971919,
0.0066487789,
-0.0390937179,
-0.0203420836,
-0.0231773518,
0.0983771086,
0.0090987915,
0.024497956,
-0.0404068865,
0.0671647415,
-0.0577893518,
-0.0544660389,
0.029986199,
0.0046987687,
-0.0204083137,
-0.0023532477,
-0.0166815147,
-0.0304284338,
0.0334406719,
0.0291123763,
0.0677140281,
-0.0142670898,
-0.019727692,
-0.0086533381,
0.0558637865,
-0.0246892367,
0.0052976729,
-0.0270012468,
-0.0042015468,
-0.0114218052,
-0.0314218141,
0.0380574763,
-0.0569856912,
0.0673647448,
-0.0494721457,
0.0033721442,
0.00450814,
-0.0088571673,
-0.0364089534,
-0.0594537705,
-0.0510901846,
-0.0035106132,
0.0135014998,
-0.027210325,
0.0176886823,
0.0166243482,
0.0109158671,
-0.0967137814,
-0.0047803456,
0.008110295,
0.0237815455,
0.0077866064,
0.0138423033,
-0.0124177141,
0.0255814232,
0.0245813392,
0.0097874869,
0.0280653331,
-0.0075190677,
0.0524001904,
-0.0296357702,
-0.0260747205,
0.0173393562,
-0.0089457035,
0.012878187,
-0.0334639885,
0.0720071271,
-0.0302476715,
0.0307799187,
0.1099461094,
0.0257601384,
-0.0548395105,
-0.0102290381,
-0.0057679703,
-0.0432561748,
0.0262166634,
-0.0107118534,
-0.0861043856,
-0.0016535593,
-0.0100843403,
0.0010609238,
-0.0417617448,
-0.0414294377,
0.0094150929,
-0.1236450523,
-0.0100368811,
0.0037728664,
0.0137734702,
-0.0258695818,
-0.0527686775,
0.0369358286,
-0.02992725,
0.0085118813,
-0.028420914,
0.0176120419,
-0.0023380176,
0.0027251919,
-0.061554376,
-0.0313805044,
0.0228725541,
-0.0168372579,
0.0363671444,
0.0253942925,
0.0729938149,
-0.007863922,
-0.0001774026,
0.05193251,
-0.0393571705,
-0.0285554528,
-0.038437821,
0.0227900296,
-0.0463264361,
-0.0089444295,
-0.0206745509,
0.053279005,
0.0303853154,
-0.0163206235,
-0.0226808749,
0.0325967632,
0.0090182144,
-0.0310400836,
-0.0436854735,
0.0222784262,
0.0447434895,
0.0534695201,
0.0418685488,
-0.05491101,
-0.0062131383,
-0.0693200007,
0.01521187,
-0.0332516953,
-0.0538568459,
-0.0266936235,
-0.0125495484,
-0.0022382564,
-0.009971818,
-0.0516594723,
-0.0050447537,
-0.0231622718,
0.0024297757,
-0.0100903939,
0.0171742067,
-0.0116118426,
-0.0165039152,
0.028043095,
-0.0247495566,
0.0511904322,
0.0146333743,
-0.0430138633,
-0.0207164027,
0.0023173124,
-0.0280529875,
0.0016986785,
-0.0357548669,
-0.0542047769,
0.0452113971,
0.0091564041,
0.0142491851,
0.0146383196,
-0.0206944942,
-0.0403899774,
0.0189454779,
0.0832946748,
-0.0259638038,
0.0015998282,
0.0202626958,
0.0617751405,
0.0153441206,
0.0192204546,
-0.0025645392,
0.0320386291,
0.0514395535,
-0.0256917216,
-0.0736485347,
-0.0518255234,
-0.0025609019,
-0.021416435,
0.0628340766,
0.0176147204,
-0.0583300069,
-0.0501788668,
-0.0599910542,
-0.0264165048,
-0.0552718788,
0.0204434209,
-0.0157658551,
0.0248762798,
-0.0141388662,
-0.0640377775,
0.0053968318,
-0.0479279459,
0.0478738658,
-0.0430916771,
0.0568094179,
0.002257931,
0.0287272315,
-0.0089908345,
0.0045868,
-0.0258131493,
0.0258966833,
-0.0114799188,
0.0044338922,
0.0013880889,
0.0371196233,
-0.0031922378,
-0.0040572756,
0.0349926576,
-0.0279048141,
0.0002717769,
-0.0141368732,
0.0042167003,
0.0363832861,
0.0268233176,
-0.0237347111,
0.0289233197,
0.0064536133,
-0.0187523067,
-0.0148414746,
0.0231133942,
0.0029954172,
-0.0452123024,
0.0528051779,
0.0310037211,
-0.0400013626,
-0.0038335042,
0.0313614383,
-0.0301228892,
0.0464646965,
0.0579255819,
-0.0263930596,
-0.0194226,
-0.0330489166,
0.0421992168,
-0.0219137613,
-0.0099028675,
0.0002118235,
-0.0759391785,
-0.038661547,
0.0394312963,
-0.0294687301,
0.0224556662,
0.0000434475,
-0.0193516631,
0.0822022036,
-0.0306553021,
0.0516047813,
-0.0456897207,
0.0238908622,
-0.0770549625,
-0.0376212187,
-0.036053136,
-5.662655672e-33,
0.0038740763,
-0.0353284217,
-0.0237465706,
-0.0232488438,
-0.0063536703,
0.027675923,
-0.0065796962,
0.0478623472,
-0.0352913588,
0.0326114371,
0.0162146688,
0.0314848386,
0.0202784501,
0.0038435787,
-0.0076588527,
-0.0447668321,
0.0030569867,
-0.0193738192,
-0.0084147397,
0.0048188046,
-0.0016249898,
0.0011930835,
0.0187707599,
-0.0732615739,
0.0271544252,
0.0021531584,
-0.0151379472,
-0.0279618278,
0.0187804494,
0.0351422466,
-0.029330235,
0.0550618097,
0.0414215773,
0.0011551961,
0.0171086155,
0.1077055335,
-0.0053280634,
-0.0026583029,
0.0224692561,
0.0014228572,
0.0246460401,
-0.019591039,
-0.0094933473,
0.0211678818,
-0.0681063384,
-0.0232819971,
0.0514327101,
-0.0178915132,
0.0308207124,
-0.059091188,
-0.0465150364,
0.0307370108,
-0.0233338885,
-0.01471915,
-0.0165845938,
0.0133771216,
0.0543249734,
0.0586127639,
-0.0537088886,
0.0301552229,
-0.0552451946,
-0.0087577272,
0.0140648801,
-0.0304673444,
0.0162360333,
0.0970193446,
0.0224524178,
0.0413709991,
-0.0661582202,
0.0012716936,
0.0195314176,
0.0005719411,
0.0566030778,
0.0683971569,
0.0268435515,
-0.0507256463,
-0.0480617844,
-0.0414074473,
0.0820703059,
0.0187447257,
0.0407813303,
-0.0272325799,
0.0054121171,
-0.0043989858,
-0.0416403413,
-0.0937379971,
-0.0211990681,
-0.0142148081,
-0.0005285782,
0.0100198155,
-0.0334906541,
0.02355735,
0.0305792373,
-0.0509686694,
-0.0221764501,
0.0556083024,
-0.0066197775,
-0.0021148694,
-0.0075016208,
0.0433491319,
-0.0455298312,
-0.0139728729,
-0.0094815791,
-0.0234044548,
0.0275815744,
-0.0333365873,
0.0391065739,
0.0022745912,
-0.0586693697,
-0.0032997434,
-0.0168431289,
0.0027591768,
-0.0272597354,
0.0568991415,
0.0416889489,
0.0344597958,
0.0063861953,
0.000182389,
0.0274393708,
0.0109625813,
0.0207725894,
-0.0207590815,
-0.0628973842,
0.009721892,
-0.0473565236,
-0.0323353708,
-0.0414591692,
-0.0080069359,
-0.0099730119,
-0.0350469835,
-0.0214573424,
-0.0247483142,
2.321e-7,
0.0287886597,
0.0684877187,
-0.0223355405,
0.0100217396,
-0.002093825,
0.0271418877,
0.0552878901,
0.0281435866,
-0.0404508337,
-0.0836652815,
-0.0490057841,
0.0441486016,
0.0496707633,
0.0219544154,
-0.05935755,
0.0005147828,
-0.0141428309,
0.048802875,
-0.0551103614,
0.0417511873,
-0.0030621472,
0.0365784541,
0.0487268902,
-0.0033701975,
-0.0375971571,
0.0181873795,
0.0386453122,
-0.0514972433,
-0.0402517542,
0.0084322011,
0.0133688375,
-0.0397807211,
0.0152912214,
0.0223012995,
0.0153239956,
-0.0003713859,
0.0103915753,
0.0875688419,
0.0050338926,
-0.0130588496,
-0.0180566758,
-0.0179414414,
-0.0123367589,
-0.0147644486,
0.0548828542,
-0.0404070653,
-0.0142320087,
-0.0923742577,
-0.0444914177,
-0.0146101005,
0.0505418628,
-0.0162227768,
-0.0330232047,
-0.0088466685,
0.0033378915,
-0.0009619537,
-0.0244525317,
-0.0547506846,
-0.0224600267,
-0.0272647813,
-0.055789575,
-0.05813675,
0.0280152354,
0.0124248192,
0.0518905632,
-0.0015461238,
0.0321074538,
1.759086659e-34,
0.0367798135,
-0.0159019567,
-0.0197739229,
-0.0192131065,
0.053446427,
0.0287599582,
-0.0070262733,
-0.004942874,
0.0128120296,
-0.0527139716,
0.0212897323
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09684v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09684v2 | Do Physicians Know How to Prompt? The Need for Automatic Prompt Optimization Help in Clinical Note Generation | 2023-11-16T08:54:52 | 2024-03-19T16:27:37 | Zonghai Yao, Ahmed Jaafar, Beining Wang, Zhichao Yang, Hong Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This study examines the effect of prompt engineering on the performance of
Large Language Models (LLMs) in clinical note generation. We introduce an
Automatic Prompt Optimization (APO) framework to refine initial prompts and
compare the outputs of medical experts, non-medical experts, and APO-enhanced
GPT3.5 and GPT4. Results highlight GPT4 APO's superior performance in
standardizing prompt quality across clinical note sections. A human-in-the-loop
approach shows that experts maintain content quality post-APO, with a
preference for their own modifications, suggesting the value of expert
customization. We recommend a two-phase optimization process, leveraging
APO-GPT4 for consistency and expert input for personalization. | [
0.07440871,
0.0074124727,
-0.0050356062,
-0.0396955349,
-0.0238633007,
-0.0132332817,
0.0255225096,
0.0194631107,
0.0041886545,
-0.0142018879,
0.0013130785,
-0.0667479113,
0.0178109631,
0.0370080024,
0.0259506181,
-0.0753955469,
0.0210422743,
0.0165096633,
0.0645719394,
0.0173275359,
0.009154194,
0.0073913233,
-0.035356503,
0.0352375731,
0.0000476619,
-0.0129080284,
0.0156013956,
0.0121385232,
0.0056844186,
-0.0851236507,
-0.0029968855,
0.0813495144,
-0.032388635,
-0.0328258164,
0.0000021274,
-0.0654936656,
-0.0018665409,
0.0125285331,
-0.0405604467,
-0.0033951083,
0.0323364548,
-0.0468129255,
-0.0181502979,
0.0176489856,
-0.0186582264,
-0.0163184702,
0.0283442382,
0.0194365457,
0.061788138,
0.084994033,
-0.0164879803,
0.04694717,
0.0129093099,
-0.0253752582,
0.0170143265,
-0.0170705654,
-0.0042899717,
0.0013662211,
0.0531011038,
0.0163624585,
0.0323384255,
0.0376856476,
-0.0156956948,
-0.0264741275,
0.0248241555,
0.0292056967,
0.0129214786,
-0.0275465138,
-0.0318934098,
0.0414121337,
0.0482046865,
0.0151586914,
0.0214787722,
-0.0360497683,
0.0209406745,
-0.0032929422,
-0.0349013023,
0.0331553929,
-0.026314972,
-0.0360486954,
0.0145142404,
-0.0024030628,
0.0017878521,
0.001893049,
0.0067718741,
0.0129045555,
0.035123039,
-0.0278496593,
0.0048749461,
-0.0082504982,
-0.0191382319,
-0.0671184808,
0.0451941118,
0.0366393626,
-0.0952530578,
-0.0042236941,
-0.0273522865,
-0.0373356678,
0.0645847172,
0.0008495387,
0.0237971582,
0.0270523783,
0.0196176935,
-0.0103770914,
0.0012476481,
0.0102681015,
-0.019908227,
0.0069360733,
-0.0387241542,
0.0638613552,
-0.0237049069,
-0.0294924621,
-0.0424359627,
-0.0029323862,
-0.0026800262,
-0.0053775655,
-0.0744701549,
0.0202016067,
-0.0147512509,
0.043763157,
0.0401181839,
0.0268714465,
-0.0465153456,
-0.0186264571,
0.0022145752,
-0.0005639544,
-0.0177868418,
-0.0052440003,
0.0174442604,
-0.0308853649,
0.034898892,
0.0306831002,
0.0293869395,
0.016121136,
-0.0228579454,
0.0229102504,
-0.0228197221,
0.0221607909,
0.0323624872,
-0.0745952725,
-0.0342366286,
-0.0071376492,
-0.0394367948,
-0.0487932563,
0.0190780852,
0.0154404733,
0.0094790356,
-0.0433228016,
0.0036993215,
0.0421651304,
-0.0255429931,
0.0144408764,
-0.0880525187,
0.0356258564,
0.0461684242,
0.0129683297,
-0.0018613761,
-0.0315226987,
0.018043017,
-0.0106233014,
-0.0173391998,
-0.0260866918,
0.0228719208,
0.0178559795,
-0.0084978445,
-0.0175649971,
0.0130577534,
0.0202774405,
0.0546306409,
0.0731145591,
-0.03835392,
0.0880298093,
0.0025298623,
0.0402869098,
0.0521442108,
0.0321780443,
-0.0031665042,
0.0134015707,
0.0580623001,
-0.0196844693,
0.0133997388,
0.0167796947,
-0.0295177754,
-0.0050906115,
0.0059064548,
0.0261004604,
0.0034641661,
-0.0094801858,
-0.0251947306,
-0.0227212422,
-0.0549639426,
0.0058680931,
-0.0659038946,
-0.0232093744,
-0.0052115661,
-0.0166311655,
-0.0613763519,
0.036797598,
0.0076955887,
-0.0323148891,
-0.0117707271,
-0.0351122469,
0.0270659439,
0.1152585968,
0.0619918518,
-0.0343331844,
-0.0135359131,
-0.0330953002,
0.0177327711,
0.0288498458,
0.0620562322,
-0.0184548032,
-0.021987224,
-0.0599108376,
-0.0274199303,
0.0342049226,
0.0114519605,
0.0076057352,
-0.0089682611,
0.0108866328,
0.0287006889,
0.0386852399,
-0.0634357259,
0.027701458,
-0.0707586855,
-0.0246935245,
0.0097825397,
-0.0017929432,
0.0073986594,
0.0380028263,
-0.011929947,
0.0532072224,
-0.0007946746,
-0.002421075,
0.005984203,
-0.0097676767,
-0.0658496767,
-0.003423166,
0.0262492094,
-0.0237272792,
-0.0018478086,
-0.0627645925,
-0.0114018936,
-0.0357906893,
-0.0615173504,
-0.0562081821,
0.0141522009,
-0.012387854,
0.0506704748,
0.0608691312,
-0.0307310671,
-0.0479927957,
-0.0023411834,
0.006588643,
-0.0126623809,
0.0924547687,
0.0111937998,
0.0154155688,
-0.052069094,
-0.0102991238,
0.0106419921,
0.0082582422,
0.0089737335,
0.0368847549,
0.0591922775,
-0.0282615032,
-0.0623661466,
-0.1172941476,
-0.0216559488,
-0.0084312856,
-0.0149104595,
0.0502083339,
0.0153532894,
-0.0315695331,
0.0069315536,
-0.0530816764,
-0.0502278171,
0.0117302099,
0.0230135228,
0.0467416197,
0.0461372882,
0.0085897194,
-0.0266979598,
-0.0158640966,
-0.0306548793,
-0.0237436537,
0.0504883453,
-0.0427082703,
-0.0541655272,
0.0176327303,
-0.0261673499,
-0.0283305105,
0.0365482271,
-0.0132410051,
0.0279523227,
-0.014590947,
0.07832551,
0.0263415519,
0.0079658711,
-0.0071425983,
0.0477002673,
0.0091845412,
-0.0232487619,
-0.0086109685,
-0.0272125918,
-0.0376612693,
0.0385994427,
-0.0800896063,
0.0399722233,
0.0629766807,
0.0350333825,
0.0072393459,
-0.0587108918,
-0.0110523943,
-0.0125669464,
0.0244574342,
-0.0226501916,
-0.0207286794,
-0.0562313385,
0.0747191608,
0.0093487976,
-0.050522428,
0.0777934268,
-0.0242130738,
0.0280242115,
-0.0479383171,
0.012513862,
-0.0223095641,
-0.0248233695,
-0.0135515453,
0.0241479408,
0.0360510312,
-0.026868809,
-0.0231545009,
0.0186164863,
0.0304486845,
-0.0230566524,
0.0363665335,
-0.037630707,
0.0005091119,
-0.0000978429,
-0.044327125,
-0.0145073896,
-0.0342383608,
-0.0270804111,
-0.0063601863,
0.0436819084,
0.006856096,
-0.0014390959,
0.028822016,
-0.0013659605,
0.0882534161,
-0.0121616395,
-0.0140417367,
-0.0081005525,
-0.0148144644,
0.034102004,
-0.0155542176,
-0.0011594046,
-0.0480227955,
0.0379708149,
0.0193719119,
-0.0131664276,
0.0110679111,
0.0000997727,
-0.006659253,
0.0127638346,
-0.0641267002,
-0.0478013121,
0.0758233964,
0.0314094275,
-0.0528173707,
0.0167508777,
0.1349403709,
0.0301377904,
-0.0602666028,
0.0033976745,
-0.0105768042,
-0.000703146,
-0.0017726586,
0.0250421278,
-0.0576306581,
-0.0058033699,
-0.004039228,
0.0608651377,
-0.0385290682,
-0.0110647129,
-0.0269103833,
-0.0486176759,
0.0459078737,
0.0178582817,
-0.0184169691,
-0.0064556617,
-0.0120292157,
-0.0139410961,
0.0183972102,
-0.0018647696,
0.0167817455,
-0.0245765597,
0.0087202797,
0.0078130988,
-0.1018560901,
-0.0662875175,
-0.0222242586,
-0.0016359523,
0.0603034273,
0.0813899189,
-0.0036584316,
0.0041561825,
-0.0394357555,
0.0273073111,
0.0246948805,
0.0184353031,
-0.028907774,
0.043384511,
0.008537963,
0.0142035214,
-0.0459790006,
0.0264757015,
0.0012619988,
-0.0061165285,
0.0305247009,
0.0671911463,
-0.0384043753,
-0.0279885326,
-0.0304948241,
0.054323364,
0.0350147411,
0.0335289985,
0.0382955149,
-0.019782681,
-0.0230515022,
-0.0121461656,
0.050563693,
-0.0280426238,
0.0150704151,
-0.0051130457,
-0.0434506983,
-0.0206165966,
-0.061289832,
-0.0389939137,
0.052134648,
0.0113694137,
0.035522569,
0.0125093581,
-0.0102592399,
-0.0026604724,
-0.0211849399,
0.0330115221,
0.0178071912,
0.0072146999,
-0.1011188552,
-0.0573108234,
0.0358448178,
-0.0303806271,
0.0078464132,
0.0091212895,
0.0174264256,
-0.0266433712,
0.0082415119,
0.0908153802,
0.0242281985,
-0.0113565791,
0.0098147066,
-0.0380058698,
0.0257903393,
0.0258555785,
-0.0181037746,
-0.0246756002,
-0.0197306313,
0.0221684966,
-0.0127560394,
0.0019596205,
-0.0138140433,
0.0002477906,
0.0138811199,
0.0397865511,
0.0388312191,
-0.0741841197,
0.0229631681,
0.0813913718,
0.0260529164,
-0.0446622036,
0.009271211,
-0.0355513655,
0.0003563743,
-0.0361115448,
0.0089036319,
-0.0226679817,
0.0336305015,
0.0038742854,
-0.0239678752,
-0.0028067478,
-0.0132719157,
-0.099563919,
-0.0264312923,
-0.0316380225,
0.0409547202,
-0.0363079794,
0.0247680061,
0.0577293187,
-0.0210306235,
-0.0342548639,
0.0339783654,
0.0011553655,
0.0153849609,
0.0180754028,
0.0735696629,
-0.0102331275,
0.020265352,
-0.0001180846,
0.0669709146,
-0.0213719774,
-0.0674100518,
-0.0321174301,
0.0375470705,
0.0235430319,
0.0017102268,
0.006391522,
-0.0507922098,
0.0070411619,
-0.0391467884,
0.0416491739,
0.0384530723,
0.001720853,
0.0259085391,
-0.0088141048,
0.0018460973,
-0.0569696538,
0.0727597997,
-0.0378214531,
0.0206993744,
-0.0220424552,
-0.0485347658,
-0.0646084547,
-0.0059643742,
0.0164018404,
-0.0117933983,
-0.0747954398,
-0.0123420106,
-0.0743729472,
0.0027570091,
-0.0029417828,
0.001841606,
-0.0235517435,
-0.0112852091,
0.0520201772,
0.0245045573,
-0.038118355,
-0.0092551811,
-0.009978991,
0.0398648269,
-0.0176594742,
-0.0221963227,
0.0077180448,
-5.765695098e-33,
-0.00794686,
-0.0403959453,
0.0111477114,
-0.0174424928,
0.0017530157,
0.01102849,
-0.057454288,
0.0363638252,
0.0314137042,
0.0249395296,
-0.0534719117,
-0.0494570434,
0.0179201309,
0.0232554004,
0.0294064973,
-0.0129557177,
0.0511561111,
0.0027421638,
-0.0563553311,
0.0271584112,
-0.0514095053,
0.0239891373,
0.0255966242,
-0.0411335751,
0.0506762601,
-0.0204112176,
-0.0081741717,
-0.009278412,
-0.0058063841,
0.0329403393,
0.0038832615,
0.006509447,
0.0464466251,
-0.0320282839,
-0.0441026948,
0.0249809027,
-0.0090073794,
-0.033298783,
0.0350349136,
-0.0375396274,
-0.0549709611,
-0.0744241402,
0.0039618639,
-0.0359567143,
-0.0468825698,
0.0163333397,
0.0189102814,
-0.0207702126,
0.0008301729,
-0.0368912295,
-0.0304525141,
0.0369219407,
0.0060309405,
0.0009986802,
-0.0110783689,
0.0190899894,
-0.0352403782,
0.0064758081,
0.0150582856,
0.0234348625,
0.0611974932,
0.0326676592,
0.0088761142,
-0.0097764404,
-0.0392218418,
0.0209867433,
0.0376862884,
0.0285988655,
-0.0170112476,
0.0184704065,
-0.0631518513,
0.0156533644,
0.0607602559,
0.0435377583,
-0.0039351033,
-0.0354516059,
-0.0413926318,
0.066261664,
-0.0450617671,
0.0010085253,
0.0321643315,
-0.0574915968,
-0.034738265,
-0.0396733843,
-0.020690769,
-0.0046452372,
-0.0020778175,
-0.0377442949,
0.028042024,
-0.0051676319,
-0.0026835168,
-0.0158024225,
0.0026495531,
0.0153015191,
0.0328134187,
-0.036123883,
-0.00717584,
0.0288282651,
-0.0364566408,
-0.0096439319,
-0.0544480421,
-0.0084077474,
0.0230691805,
0.0038652041,
0.0523534454,
0.0568829626,
-0.0030923267,
-0.0094730472,
-0.068032749,
0.0267345682,
0.0328136124,
0.0268223025,
-0.0007205149,
-0.0039870595,
0.0243413262,
0.0048231613,
0.0030120243,
0.0646573603,
-0.0046985061,
-0.0359599181,
-0.0448481999,
-0.0330292247,
0.0340851918,
0.0101232156,
-0.0374273919,
0.0213055313,
-0.0089765387,
0.0656821504,
0.0316522941,
0.011515012,
-0.0172037967,
-0.0249200892,
2.807e-7,
0.0675933436,
0.057706967,
0.0298841484,
-0.0085425889,
0.0279124603,
-0.0049502575,
0.0039810566,
0.0142951328,
0.0054521998,
-0.0241400655,
0.0722278208,
-0.027464034,
0.0317794085,
0.009704534,
-0.074477002,
-0.0257902425,
-0.0863675028,
0.0102339238,
-0.0613708384,
-0.0037955432,
0.0840858072,
-0.0009370568,
-0.0650651231,
-0.0211457107,
0.0050170473,
0.0199931972,
0.0328563638,
-0.0512194075,
0.0171388835,
0.0772886425,
0.0575932041,
-0.0442624725,
0.0155889811,
0.0541623831,
-0.0261140727,
-0.035331253,
0.0091674458,
0.1240718812,
-0.0212234575,
0.0475680903,
0.0488080271,
0.0027255081,
0.0253320485,
-0.0713165104,
0.0171774626,
-0.0283163153,
-0.0125552788,
-0.0136606907,
-0.0370128565,
-0.0536244325,
0.0730572119,
-0.0576572083,
-0.0187872369,
0.044791013,
0.0043677469,
0.0454347208,
-0.0224763621,
-0.0119568566,
-0.0185978264,
0.0120192673,
-0.0284975786,
-0.0460100397,
0.0086294329,
-0.0167349,
-0.0070626382,
-0.081660822,
0.0181031451,
2.605661849e-34,
0.0447773784,
-0.0062741297,
0.0444604568,
-0.008797233,
0.0399165712,
0.0012627484,
0.0097469138,
0.0400719605,
0.0526124723,
-0.0525284111,
-0.0477626882
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09682v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09682v3 | MacGyver: Are Large Language Models Creative Problem Solvers? | 2023-11-16T08:52:27 | 2024-03-27T23:43:54 | Yufei Tian, Abhilasha Ravichander, Lianhui Qin, Ronan Le Bras, Raja Marjieh, Nanyun Peng, Yejin Choi, Thomas L. Griffiths, Faeze Brahman | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We explore the creative problem-solving capabilities of modern LLMs in a
novel constrained setting. To this end, we create MACGYVER, an automatically
generated dataset consisting of over 1,600 real-world problems deliberately
designed to trigger innovative usage of objects and necessitate out-of-the-box
thinking. We then present our collection to both LLMs and humans to compare and
contrast their problem-solving abilities. MACGYVER is challenging for both
groups, but in unique and complementary ways. For instance, humans excel in
tasks they are familiar with but struggle with domain-specific knowledge,
leading to a higher variance. In contrast, LLMs, exposed to a variety of
specialized knowledge, attempt broader problems but fail by proposing
physically-infeasible actions. Finally, we provide a detailed error analysis of
LLMs, and demonstrate the potential of enhancing their problem-solving ability
with novel prompting techniques such as iterative step-wise reflection and
divergent-convergent thinking.
This work (1) introduces a fresh arena for intelligent agents focusing on
intricate aspects of physical reasoning, planning, and unconventional thinking,
which supplements the existing spectrum of machine intelligence; and (2)
provides insight into the constrained problem-solving capabilities of both
humans and AI. | [
0.0449400246,
0.0050873673,
-0.0212652665,
0.0139530851,
-0.0488372371,
0.0011370779,
-0.0230490752,
-0.0059362338,
-0.0121138003,
0.0008795203,
0.0053196833,
0.0104182241,
-0.0351983719,
0.032151375,
0.0084317299,
-0.0119073251,
-0.0016915613,
-0.0665198937,
0.0054459912,
-0.0191881545,
-0.0624886788,
-0.0116857467,
-0.0479697548,
0.0519159511,
-0.002776654,
-0.0193314981,
-0.0308199432,
-0.0029610265,
0.0161992293,
-0.0375047885,
-0.021917874,
0.02328665,
0.0328813232,
0.0171070006,
0.0000022102,
-0.0569161586,
0.0339919738,
-0.0435356759,
-0.038578067,
-0.0447172485,
0.0127756074,
0.0205846038,
-0.0163506065,
0.0231051054,
-0.0560884774,
0.0474556349,
-0.0053565735,
0.0323247612,
0.0084721074,
0.0444017909,
0.0213684272,
0.0063241725,
0.013099771,
0.0091456268,
0.0517682359,
-0.0286519658,
-0.002130602,
0.0228263568,
0.0732883438,
-0.0116115753,
-0.0279386472,
0.0247098543,
0.0517296605,
0.0033452269,
-0.0134453522,
0.0416633636,
-0.0066375346,
-0.0041387305,
-0.0151468236,
0.0405205786,
0.0049442942,
-0.0131404959,
-0.0057595568,
-0.0026633628,
0.0076568346,
0.0396276377,
-0.0656389073,
0.0448812209,
-0.0112217991,
0.0085931681,
-0.025185585,
-0.0172596257,
0.027897764,
-0.0030707058,
-0.0015702199,
0.0888898522,
-0.026035456,
-0.0141931362,
0.0370304249,
0.0032945594,
0.0185528789,
-0.0614262037,
0.0080376556,
0.0340037122,
-0.0471958406,
0.0003945791,
-0.0147581976,
-0.0018671136,
-0.0220116042,
0.0076966952,
0.1169893891,
0.0314957872,
0.0413559601,
0.0326175876,
0.0047782715,
0.0232115667,
-0.0456759781,
0.0338590331,
-0.0571064726,
0.0313420184,
-0.0735016838,
-0.023880139,
-0.0129840448,
0.0083867544,
-0.0323028266,
-0.0064394381,
0.0070687882,
0.0603710636,
-0.0231821351,
0.0235802773,
-0.0232379455,
0.0518221222,
0.0318504162,
-0.0455267467,
-0.0892892554,
-0.0226860866,
-0.0354649834,
0.0400033221,
0.0340837203,
-0.0232166182,
-0.0103099123,
0.0010871736,
-0.0271542147,
-0.021930607,
0.0393788666,
0.0935151652,
-0.0149153545,
-0.0248120371,
-0.0383651741,
-0.0378771275,
0.028266659,
-0.0670754611,
0.0832132474,
-0.0772349238,
0.0103031537,
0.0063319998,
-0.0330301747,
-0.0459087044,
0.0114550674,
-0.0049868538,
-0.0010679328,
0.0581964999,
-0.0082103834,
0.0441392846,
0.0461373404,
0.0298350193,
-0.023929242,
0.0560921282,
0.0635791942,
0.0203329977,
-0.002941448,
0.041944664,
0.0554677323,
0.0201170463,
-0.0139363687,
0.0042189443,
-0.0411768109,
-0.0191673879,
-0.0333186686,
0.0520806238,
-0.0086677009,
0.0150194056,
-0.0119692152,
0.0685268119,
0.0604389571,
0.0844487324,
-0.0079714917,
0.0425245278,
0.0320382342,
-0.0295679942,
-0.0061644064,
-0.0309283994,
-0.0059432313,
0.0564786494,
-0.0312985368,
-0.013932039,
-0.045211114,
0.0252227802,
-0.030447837,
-0.0469885021,
-0.0110695269,
0.0170923546,
0.0284264125,
0.0171967354,
0.0284152683,
0.0040293857,
-0.0150190266,
0.0241959002,
-0.0496644638,
-0.0280803461,
-0.029075494,
-0.0517240241,
0.0211303383,
0.0811719224,
0.0523663573,
-0.0562291555,
-0.0473439097,
0.0058314102,
0.0450983271,
0.0296894517,
0.0252475478,
0.0117931059,
-0.0401410609,
0.0046179253,
-0.0185873285,
-0.0413312912,
-0.0038097335,
0.0016345425,
-0.0078801354,
0.0085221296,
-0.0257489569,
0.0131342849,
-0.0047002118,
0.0241879877,
-0.0851833299,
-0.0062693395,
-0.0208323896,
-0.0044037919,
0.0001309693,
0.028531516,
-0.0100810025,
0.0275438111,
0.0508162491,
-0.0497696511,
-0.0689340159,
0.0329866633,
-0.0195204131,
0.0369411781,
0.0389679447,
-0.1277903616,
-0.0127418172,
0.0059895227,
-0.0013771574,
-0.0275450032,
0.0411455631,
-0.0366567522,
0.0246820524,
-0.0023810756,
0.0109174056,
-0.0194313806,
-0.0168413669,
0.0021074687,
0.0616523139,
-0.0276863184,
0.0011922084,
0.0362779759,
-0.0018616241,
0.002712003,
-0.0318659097,
-0.008672893,
-0.0027030339,
0.0212181751,
0.0196121316,
0.006665187,
0.0276998561,
-0.0548980348,
-0.0260588042,
-0.0577088483,
-0.0204363316,
0.0192505494,
-0.0074370657,
-0.0044627162,
-0.039875254,
-0.034826871,
0.000280855,
-0.0041097426,
0.0229663141,
0.0177095626,
-0.0002463475,
0.0346197002,
0.0083613461,
-0.0287363715,
0.0078063053,
0.0149355419,
-0.0255020857,
0.0047712834,
0.0235975944,
0.0036708999,
-0.0369027928,
0.0440485403,
-0.039200224,
0.0130177792,
-0.0249653254,
-0.0179569144,
0.0487127192,
-0.0274501797,
0.022880042,
0.0488019064,
-0.0197120588,
0.0441277809,
0.0791363865,
-0.0562042519,
-0.0371172354,
0.0311046746,
0.0045925691,
-0.0066914693,
-0.0268255435,
-0.010437889,
-0.0086743804,
0.0328486115,
-0.0197006054,
0.0385687239,
-0.0014577783,
0.0897791758,
0.0297674891,
-0.0686265305,
-0.0103393327,
-0.0195592064,
-0.0342379212,
0.1188829094,
0.0115309479,
-0.0018390993,
0.0623850599,
0.036487598,
-0.0042824568,
0.0086786952,
0.0024338379,
-0.0221784879,
0.1004591435,
-0.0440921932,
-0.0064661358,
0.0019682101,
0.0280706082,
-0.05862353,
0.0253516641,
0.0046422179,
-0.0318392329,
0.0579509102,
-0.0660141855,
-0.0239906888,
-0.0012470443,
-0.0605007187,
-0.0630665272,
0.0138972215,
-0.0285259038,
-0.0023647023,
-0.016946923,
-0.0305238571,
-0.0537438877,
-0.0541573167,
0.0472051539,
-0.0056466218,
0.016777778,
-0.0271658096,
-0.0188227091,
-0.027251903,
0.0265133176,
0.070553951,
0.028160248,
-0.016888069,
0.0386474319,
0.0434038639,
0.0108757019,
-0.0364064127,
-0.0182633251,
0.0629652143,
0.0165928677,
0.0300821681,
0.003345374,
0.0374360234,
0.0644405559,
-0.031431742,
-0.0344086625,
0.0632554367,
0.0519535989,
-0.0002025406,
0.0422589891,
-0.0707439184,
0.003614624,
0.0409089401,
0.0456196293,
-0.0655737892,
-0.026918767,
0.0180663355,
0.0226832442,
-0.0433115959,
-0.0652277321,
-0.0122024193,
-0.1194829196,
0.0529094227,
0.0026000771,
0.0029416985,
-0.0187909082,
0.0226580333,
-0.0450254604,
0.022832064,
-0.0045541977,
0.0196740814,
0.0066576935,
0.0041252947,
-0.0026758206,
0.0088187763,
-0.0417493209,
0.0345267765,
-0.0110849515,
0.0315141417,
0.0600269362,
0.0000825467,
-0.0128956437,
-0.0472221039,
0.0273520891,
0.0467427261,
0.0543278493,
0.000019653,
-0.0269220844,
0.0415253118,
-0.0084107472,
-0.0290417075,
0.0398284569,
-0.0739961416,
-0.0794704407,
0.028008623,
0.1214906201,
-0.0526914373,
0.0017379136,
-0.0479584113,
-0.0029683767,
-0.012455238,
0.0517703295,
0.0065831929,
-0.0606578365,
-0.0518389158,
-0.0514801964,
-0.0391348675,
-0.0327748246,
-0.047657039,
0.0084796771,
0.0451304056,
0.0058947569,
-0.070423238,
-0.0387642272,
0.0355808735,
0.049247317,
0.0112846624,
-0.0419954248,
-0.0195135754,
0.0296150669,
-0.0313085988,
0.0067741685,
0.0092310477,
0.0133512318,
-0.0284819044,
0.0000420866,
-0.0144783882,
-0.0709037781,
-0.0161983278,
0.0166123118,
-0.082056053,
-0.0751266181,
0.0008827727,
0.0350840092,
0.0381035097,
-0.0111984331,
0.0132891638,
-0.0604714267,
0.0461956933,
0.0552950762,
-0.0028460419,
0.0463819169,
0.0066072126,
0.0567030311,
0.0271502342,
0.0160088819,
-0.0407462418,
0.0037878514,
0.0200057272,
0.0279041417,
-0.0554891191,
-0.0343293808,
0.0262175873,
0.0181296766,
-0.0088718561,
-0.0097515583,
0.0031844932,
-0.0284985919,
0.0260506049,
0.0073503964,
-0.0304694418,
-0.0627861023,
-0.0241292771,
-0.0087544639,
-0.0310959425,
0.0477473289,
0.0184058268,
0.003222191,
0.0271281246,
-0.025481822,
0.0607402213,
-0.0026962145,
0.0313215591,
0.0124369795,
0.0103312461,
0.0073254686,
0.0380605087,
-0.0239917021,
0.0418925136,
0.0243229028,
0.0762313455,
0.0176865626,
0.0174600855,
-0.0373719297,
0.0117920274,
-0.0678206459,
-0.139714241,
0.0358033702,
0.0746413022,
0.0694492534,
0.0234232787,
-0.0271700919,
-0.0746304616,
0.0155301886,
0.0009000564,
-0.0001830684,
0.0000036786,
-0.0176544748,
0.0325865671,
0.0420393161,
0.0147482092,
-0.0432897955,
0.0496295691,
-0.0734360516,
0.0591658689,
-0.0142237023,
0.0003252895,
-0.043311242,
-0.0337426104,
0.0085467482,
-0.0151032303,
0.0227910727,
0.0136341322,
-0.0809782818,
-0.0602289476,
0.0248395149,
0.0405803286,
0.0022869499,
-0.0243775323,
0.036425665,
0.0127330245,
-0.0061734221,
-0.0346679017,
0.0095601259,
-0.0205628257,
-0.014539008,
-0.0117355054,
-0.0465221144,
-6.010238698e-33,
-0.0002331489,
-0.0545611642,
0.0549418591,
-0.0106087951,
0.0068219411,
-0.0542142615,
-0.0403611399,
0.050096374,
-0.0107647832,
0.0193703938,
-0.0436953194,
-0.0005756593,
-0.0058328388,
-0.0137794912,
0.047085613,
-0.0261937156,
-0.0094761793,
-0.0072777369,
-0.0162357502,
-0.0272461679,
0.0256290715,
0.0123938555,
0.0029072927,
-0.0492637306,
-0.0070486208,
-0.0193620678,
-0.0176587943,
0.0141611593,
-0.0042507434,
0.0167707782,
-0.0058598053,
0.0023510715,
0.0325498357,
-0.0300515424,
-0.024606755,
-0.0027824964,
-0.0003875557,
-0.0575647391,
-0.0125359846,
-0.0150520997,
-0.0000725554,
-0.0416087024,
0.0231319349,
0.031686198,
-0.0777545497,
-0.0010090841,
0.0191772506,
-0.0244101845,
0.0477005988,
0.0154658994,
-0.0334119126,
-0.0104051251,
-0.0378386304,
-0.0365799181,
-0.0024076873,
-0.0060743485,
-0.0230338462,
-0.0157473478,
-0.0519783422,
0.0604119264,
0.0089766691,
-0.0170913301,
0.0759773478,
-0.0294010825,
-0.0039786398,
0.0396311618,
0.0321781561,
0.0167892687,
-0.0452365987,
-0.0165271237,
-0.0263418145,
0.1139786318,
0.0244901124,
0.0378503278,
0.0278103836,
0.0295627937,
-0.0246064626,
0.0060264585,
-0.0015571351,
0.0374086946,
0.0399066508,
0.024461735,
-0.0107208574,
-0.0085977335,
-0.0064393957,
0.0417221934,
-0.0260929018,
-0.004584298,
0.020519577,
-0.0031382246,
0.0283445027,
-0.0204137154,
0.0074878358,
-0.033273086,
0.0230663382,
-0.0216243193,
-0.0237649307,
0.0390646979,
0.0031198768,
-0.0168362781,
-0.0504404716,
-0.0307302307,
-0.0117256138,
0.0217120871,
0.0344156362,
0.0447522625,
-0.0119651714,
0.0302091185,
-0.0251050871,
-0.0263520926,
-0.0528101511,
0.0252026524,
0.0598872676,
-0.0116209323,
0.0388316363,
-0.0061777383,
-0.0295032673,
-0.0282521155,
-0.0139950765,
-0.0568805449,
-0.0082464218,
0.010637749,
-0.0299983975,
0.0100708809,
-0.0254989509,
-0.0199878551,
-0.0357877389,
0.0190189313,
0.0397603773,
-0.0554195121,
-0.0197097808,
0.0212529041,
3.057e-7,
-0.0084230704,
0.055371739,
-0.0057420046,
0.0429908969,
0.0263969228,
0.040870484,
-0.0616422705,
-0.0024808096,
-0.0134923169,
-0.0117028859,
0.0303510576,
0.0400852822,
0.0292549469,
0.0146716041,
-0.0889232904,
0.0108903451,
-0.0183152948,
0.0040922468,
-0.0481080785,
0.0042397319,
0.0778558999,
0.0137634063,
0.025016265,
-0.0361345075,
0.0004118386,
-0.0533197932,
0.0403353609,
-0.0620095134,
0.0599941015,
-0.0181633811,
0.0165064801,
0.0149660315,
-0.024113657,
0.0335425586,
-0.0147476783,
-0.0243863109,
-0.0354455039,
0.0340095647,
0.0153610595,
-0.0398540944,
-0.004196458,
0.004252783,
-0.0039932742,
-0.0161397327,
0.0443166047,
-0.0409536548,
-0.012639774,
0.0192743149,
0.0357683301,
-0.021776529,
-0.0119884601,
-0.0095789805,
0.0395884663,
-0.0264070947,
-0.001954267,
0.0074602631,
-0.008847951,
-0.0603847392,
0.012177486,
0.0293690823,
-0.0647911206,
-0.036863137,
-0.0461859442,
0.0346738622,
0.0356985889,
-0.0423467085,
-0.0154073415,
2.58711567e-34,
0.0017211413,
0.0293420833,
0.0055002025,
0.0476397239,
0.0171017852,
0.0298397858,
0.0233838484,
0.0297222622,
0.0230224747,
-0.0322579555,
-0.0414421707
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09677v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09677v3 | R-Tuning: Instructing Large Language Models to Say `I Don't Know' | 2023-11-16T08:45:44 | 2024-06-07T02:46:36 | Hanning Zhang, Shizhe Diao, Yong Lin, Yi R. Fung, Qing Lian, Xingyao Wang, Yangyi Chen, Heng Ji, Tong Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have revolutionized numerous domains with their
impressive performance but still face their challenges. A predominant issue is
the propensity for these models to generate non-existent facts, a concern
termed hallucination. Our research is motivated by the observation that
previous instruction tuning methods force the model to complete a sentence no
matter whether the model knows the knowledge or not. When the question is out
of the parametric knowledge, it will try to make up something and fail to
indicate when it lacks knowledge. In this paper, we present a new approach
called Refusal-Aware Instruction Tuning (R-Tuning). This approach is formalized
by first identifying the disparity in knowledge encompassed by pre-trained
parameters compared to that of instruction tuning data. Then, we construct the
refusal-aware data based on the knowledge intersection, to tune LLMs to refrain
from responding to questions beyond its parametric knowledge. Experimental
results demonstrate R-Tuning effectively improves a model's ability to answer
known questions and refrain from answering unknown questions. Furthermore, when
tested on out-of-domain datasets, the refusal ability was found to be a
meta-skill that could be generalized to other tasks. Further analysis
surprisingly finds that learning the uncertainty results in better calibration
and an improved ability to estimate the uncertainty than uncertainty-based
testing. Our code is available at https://github.com/shizhediao/R-Tuning. | [
0.0422144383,
0.0684611872,
-0.0313857682,
0.0331177004,
-0.0318470821,
0.0520999208,
-0.031423144,
-0.0034091575,
-0.0088988133,
-0.0553384759,
-0.0267951693,
-0.0360607021,
-0.0044886055,
0.0127303442,
0.0171445198,
-0.0081268344,
0.0542465523,
-0.0527191684,
0.008372087,
-0.0009473648,
-0.0294616576,
0.0143811377,
-0.0301166661,
0.0183359813,
-0.0132671157,
-0.025358025,
-0.0164991394,
0.0063915006,
-0.0026378057,
0.0075191245,
0.0404013544,
0.0621864162,
0.0047095437,
0.0614916272,
0.0000021822,
-0.0566168502,
-0.0174659789,
-0.0120107597,
-0.0637166873,
-0.0258244574,
0.0198320206,
-0.0030444521,
0.0235142969,
0.0391712971,
-0.0373137519,
-0.0034037898,
0.0249207504,
0.0556887724,
0.0122626387,
0.0822680444,
0.0319071338,
0.0167198721,
0.0079584587,
-0.0180497877,
0.0371644385,
-0.0370463543,
0.0142267589,
0.0191878397,
-0.003463615,
-0.0117407413,
-0.0607356131,
0.0481593944,
0.0202774853,
0.0311648604,
-0.0362377055,
0.0127748651,
-0.0408093706,
-0.0347324349,
-0.0004790883,
0.0272837188,
-0.0283290595,
-0.0361747704,
0.0181756578,
-0.0070505464,
0.020759441,
0.0235752109,
-0.0126829138,
0.0248619951,
-0.0166269951,
-0.0100620519,
-0.0306535698,
-0.0373450816,
0.0305102263,
-0.009901776,
0.014198347,
0.0929063037,
0.0004270688,
-0.0434132814,
0.0263838507,
-0.0040225545,
-0.0217199493,
-0.0535258837,
-0.0096960608,
0.0404469967,
-0.0823319033,
0.035271477,
-0.0451953672,
0.0231141709,
0.0457325876,
-0.0270195808,
0.0144206751,
0.0289938208,
0.0018210275,
0.0400370248,
-0.0240500756,
0.0305047091,
0.0000073474,
0.0385697559,
-0.0183996595,
0.0076202825,
-0.0535223372,
-0.0193174928,
-0.0384974293,
0.0083115716,
-0.0451020971,
0.0178334787,
-0.0012835147,
0.0454041213,
-0.003092373,
0.0370973051,
-0.0256785378,
-0.0053601214,
-0.036204271,
-0.0221271794,
-0.0585869551,
0.0131192738,
-0.0155014107,
0.0158278402,
-0.0026731256,
-0.0468583032,
-0.0103506902,
-0.003290266,
-0.0092627779,
-0.0013191829,
0.033687897,
0.0535146706,
0.0033843059,
-0.0091102421,
-0.0135502899,
-0.0379464589,
-0.0015917887,
-0.1078040153,
0.0085973507,
-0.0307370909,
-0.0181599092,
0.030635668,
-0.018638948,
-0.0618452393,
-0.0017244489,
0.0383570679,
-0.0208119173,
0.0830942094,
0.008240182,
0.0207439419,
0.0336481072,
0.0263287928,
-0.0097917151,
0.1123794094,
0.002857765,
-0.009247832,
0.0207866784,
-0.0049178069,
0.0503014214,
-0.006308706,
0.028073078,
0.0143983141,
-0.0259657446,
0.0150488885,
0.0430031903,
0.0077814921,
0.0293019451,
0.0201748535,
0.016236525,
-0.0415952615,
0.0475386083,
-0.0317633487,
-0.0249984935,
-0.0089757126,
0.0557926483,
0.0216861553,
0.0054497439,
0.025576625,
-0.070541434,
0.0199342053,
-0.0650940463,
0.0285907239,
0.001176856,
0.0184725821,
-0.0282492768,
-0.061779283,
-0.0032162024,
0.0218904875,
0.0140723642,
0.0660329461,
0.0402941555,
0.0195239391,
-0.0504898503,
0.0284717251,
0.0113198124,
0.007026609,
-0.0026866067,
-0.086220026,
0.0282155741,
0.0057563866,
0.0357440226,
-0.0686832219,
-0.0356554575,
-0.0237115696,
0.047923822,
0.0673817098,
0.0850056112,
-0.0016008114,
0.0273908246,
-0.0416123457,
-0.0503922552,
-0.0316676758,
0.0368613116,
0.0201640241,
0.0067775687,
0.0117305601,
0.011222031,
-0.0483470932,
-0.0323544256,
0.0457092859,
-0.0262768418,
-0.0275717769,
-0.0270396881,
-0.0024745008,
0.0092150923,
-0.0372008197,
0.0040978906,
0.0166258272,
0.030940244,
0.0079576597,
-0.0187447816,
-0.039506536,
-0.0112995831,
-0.0308394842,
0.0150436917,
-0.0305927806,
-0.0409889631,
0.0054268609,
-0.0438880138,
-0.040857777,
0.026057696,
-0.035679359,
0.0608000755,
-0.0187158044,
0.0486376509,
-0.0166914109,
0.0119093526,
-0.037306197,
0.0566814281,
-0.0120833106,
0.041033268,
0.0069530192,
-0.0014254729,
0.000621204,
-0.0458780788,
-0.0486314334,
-0.0395695679,
-0.0230142009,
0.0284733232,
0.0297291782,
0.01454431,
-0.0636459664,
-0.0267830659,
-0.0470280349,
0.014923661,
-0.0127991568,
-0.012409037,
-0.0047029234,
-0.0275723748,
-0.0357869081,
-0.0528719053,
-0.0153379841,
-0.0178865213,
-0.0140830064,
0.0219675619,
0.0264915079,
0.032241717,
-0.0374337062,
-0.0118298493,
0.0140385469,
-0.0197062008,
-0.0147230299,
-0.0045977994,
0.0338662304,
-0.0937101096,
0.0694416985,
-0.0333526395,
0.0296187419,
-0.0159753449,
-0.0214140825,
-0.0000483564,
0.0031364849,
0.0088734245,
0.0792579204,
-0.0201051682,
-0.0094624273,
0.0882940143,
0.0003465932,
-0.0225706697,
0.0561124533,
-0.0291242134,
-0.0240042023,
-0.0275890324,
-0.0285272058,
-0.0040328512,
0.06659282,
0.0217812955,
-0.0092586465,
-0.0629002228,
0.0391227603,
-0.0471815839,
-0.0433026664,
-0.0412257574,
0.0296331793,
-0.0106526706,
0.0548116192,
-0.0224678144,
-0.043478746,
0.1003880277,
-0.0124091953,
-0.023829082,
-0.0610578917,
0.002389608,
-0.0101028876,
0.0393412076,
0.0134483399,
-0.001893436,
0.0323149674,
0.0030314189,
-0.0740447491,
-0.0103889266,
0.0134481872,
-0.0431610271,
0.0097464528,
-0.0436826721,
-0.0335406363,
0.0090051321,
-0.022473136,
-0.0792454556,
-0.0195203274,
-0.0167152137,
-0.0374172851,
-0.0151673676,
-0.0336081125,
-0.0463909432,
-0.0223996229,
0.00117501,
0.0397247747,
-0.0225097444,
-0.0180344917,
-0.0269218739,
-0.0244081281,
0.0788984895,
0.0356625617,
0.0296155401,
-0.0474598147,
0.0294249766,
0.0037888587,
0.0094799995,
-0.0077835727,
0.0199427288,
0.0118435351,
0.0160654951,
-0.0034066266,
0.0056913001,
0.0470970571,
0.063118808,
-0.0385303013,
-0.0542104878,
0.100687556,
0.0476933159,
0.0031915735,
-0.0107913557,
-0.0613153055,
0.0704917759,
0.057459414,
0.0538848564,
-0.0629121959,
-0.0313391909,
0.0061308369,
0.0082934201,
-0.0350618139,
-0.0136217531,
-0.0328378193,
-0.1110095233,
0.0392381698,
-0.0177132897,
-0.0431841575,
-0.0499200299,
-0.0174102094,
-0.0118097905,
0.0021120631,
0.0432780571,
-0.0023940254,
-0.0287401713,
-0.0080751637,
0.0354292132,
-0.0066778567,
-0.0568078011,
0.037797723,
-0.0052971151,
0.0731395707,
0.0170185398,
0.0098410463,
0.0092192348,
-0.0313391201,
0.016588863,
-0.028705705,
-0.0107018529,
-0.0144402115,
0.0593065582,
0.0114366887,
-0.0107936347,
-0.0016883942,
0.0190725997,
-0.0377216637,
-0.0113417786,
0.0121539813,
0.0961697847,
-0.0363381766,
-0.0330900811,
0.0001297253,
0.0112024341,
0.0140838614,
0.103820011,
0.0503771789,
-0.0421930887,
-0.0231007431,
-0.0434844792,
-0.0090184044,
-0.0474908948,
-0.0109440321,
0.0658907592,
0.010262466,
0.001945121,
-0.0341858193,
-0.0185423102,
0.0642852113,
0.0040446068,
0.0268212929,
0.0132006537,
0.0229779072,
0.004815917,
-0.0609262362,
0.0129282987,
-0.0496637337,
0.003732217,
-0.0786247104,
-0.0257352646,
0.027166523,
-0.0347796418,
-0.0285148211,
0.0211566798,
-0.0732846484,
-0.0709081739,
0.0223910119,
0.0598296188,
0.038031999,
0.0526133254,
-0.0431757122,
-0.0508406498,
0.045271907,
0.0423155539,
-0.0162635222,
0.0129319225,
0.0496726111,
-0.0243895389,
-0.0367841125,
0.047864344,
-0.03848885,
0.0091383709,
0.0497758389,
0.007886786,
-0.0539557822,
-0.0013730596,
0.0533570871,
-0.0045269267,
0.014459596,
-0.0050868397,
-0.011941771,
-0.032980714,
0.0093147764,
-0.0100060469,
-0.0008637664,
-0.0249939859,
-0.0120112058,
0.0106497882,
-0.0251449868,
0.0107862065,
-0.0128068468,
-0.0347458348,
0.0188546162,
-0.0048936075,
-0.0061174999,
0.0317290165,
0.0415705331,
0.0489417315,
0.0003193001,
-0.0151128601,
0.0211212877,
0.0307443421,
0.0446163267,
0.0361106992,
0.0880498216,
0.0172845982,
-0.0036781849,
-0.0316736437,
-0.018012967,
-0.0690153763,
-0.0496871993,
-0.0109505402,
0.0408528335,
0.0267838277,
-0.0132275037,
0.0109545756,
-0.0253473409,
-0.0155749721,
-0.0058559608,
0.0215612501,
0.0404371619,
-0.0094257556,
0.0632957667,
0.0395916812,
-0.0218120683,
0.0015027669,
0.0554002598,
0.0238586813,
0.0936116576,
0.0018568878,
-0.0187520515,
-0.0549463071,
-0.0279190075,
-0.0065596984,
-0.0101527916,
-0.0246249083,
0.0536121614,
-0.0723193884,
-0.1033921316,
-0.0508711785,
0.0363368019,
0.0053273845,
-0.0428016558,
0.0018970417,
0.0227071308,
-0.0048485002,
-0.0458408557,
-0.0387267396,
0.0172287822,
0.0267661307,
0.0188195445,
-0.0087191314,
-6.731055508e-33,
-0.0399791524,
-0.0400757678,
0.0116786016,
-0.019896863,
0.0251280963,
-0.0066909888,
-0.0160833895,
0.0027502682,
-0.0302265268,
0.0234599262,
-0.0176706947,
0.0175294634,
0.0120611778,
0.0108748749,
0.0211811084,
-0.0245822873,
0.0456360877,
0.0078051509,
-0.0398180597,
0.0104945619,
0.0449041128,
0.0155700436,
0.0364235342,
-0.0259794779,
0.021352049,
-0.0256989785,
-0.0350615345,
0.054506924,
-0.0668020695,
0.0763048381,
-0.0243735965,
0.0421252698,
0.0076607475,
-0.0422252193,
-0.0237094462,
-0.012538298,
-0.0534666963,
-0.0474914424,
0.0397242568,
0.0435085222,
-0.0007373233,
-0.0232574511,
0.0282311589,
-0.0087737627,
-0.0193432067,
0.0079988409,
0.0249142684,
-0.0371301658,
-0.0037448502,
0.0207432844,
-0.0646499395,
0.009055973,
0.0095703034,
-0.0749871284,
0.0084261727,
0.0376252532,
0.0190133639,
-0.0476560742,
-0.0389843062,
-0.0065855291,
0.0349837169,
0.0485360734,
0.0506493226,
0.0372318141,
-0.0340237096,
0.0398566388,
-0.0147631913,
0.0144533953,
0.0567931049,
-0.0042935414,
0.0342230089,
0.0347171128,
0.012661336,
0.0186910108,
0.0405253023,
-0.0260370951,
-0.0549777038,
-0.0026729596,
-0.0073830881,
0.0455194078,
0.0431297012,
-0.0255202763,
-0.0551164448,
-0.0231886506,
-0.0431965142,
-0.0295718554,
-0.0475387014,
0.0120318811,
0.0618492886,
0.039268706,
-0.0177988727,
-0.0142959375,
0.0016274224,
-0.047427088,
0.0083098933,
0.0149592441,
-0.0192846432,
0.0007356025,
0.0019579688,
0.0323171206,
-0.014438035,
-0.0471743234,
0.0242510904,
-0.0037078764,
0.0312721543,
-0.0112784486,
0.0395639613,
0.0228064954,
-0.0747003108,
0.0191070326,
-0.0232410785,
0.0787093714,
0.0117450692,
0.0062486967,
0.0306088533,
0.0199832469,
-0.0229498688,
0.0221022032,
-0.0122307381,
-0.0396384001,
-0.0399029478,
0.028113598,
0.0105446698,
0.0441622548,
-0.0238573384,
-0.0484651923,
-0.014781788,
-0.0320587158,
0.0196314398,
-0.0502751842,
-0.0115646003,
0.0185120329,
2.895e-7,
0.0045772917,
0.0388130508,
-0.0067817969,
0.0433098972,
-0.0148150865,
0.0474044569,
-0.0474515781,
0.0025861547,
0.042103298,
-0.0128934514,
-0.0204668604,
0.0104607791,
0.0610180981,
0.0180672202,
-0.1098171622,
-0.0195208434,
-0.0005484335,
0.0084306849,
-0.03424979,
0.0092751822,
0.0251345802,
0.121698305,
0.0219441075,
0.0064606601,
-0.0254289024,
-0.0279062409,
0.0379331782,
-0.038523186,
-0.0088153696,
0.0346033499,
0.0421019942,
0.0147275226,
0.0178279448,
0.0840088651,
-0.0210020579,
0.0055497382,
-0.0360146686,
0.0740831643,
0.0267940275,
-0.0197327398,
-0.0146674886,
0.0161387492,
0.0033554849,
-0.0517810583,
0.0635516271,
-0.0463688187,
-0.0272101313,
0.0099015599,
0.0287958439,
-0.0381769724,
0.0411448516,
-0.0205237921,
-0.0272712428,
-0.0150059601,
0.0251243357,
0.0025581613,
0.0007508368,
-0.0523946024,
-0.0065956539,
0.0454003774,
-0.0325036943,
-0.0524088852,
-0.0060329805,
-0.0090895128,
0.0594395101,
-0.0858213678,
0.0195285212,
2.959159403e-34,
0.0767181292,
0.0050233663,
0.0280135386,
0.0003658487,
0.049586188,
0.0054656998,
0.0055879303,
0.025350336,
0.0371302925,
-0.0646822155,
-0.0032208646
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09675v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09675v2 | Where Do People Tell Stories Online? Story Detection Across Online Communities | 2023-11-16T08:42:26 | 2024-02-27T03:37:03 | Maria Antoniak, Joel Mire, Maarten Sap, Elliott Ash, Andrew Piper | cs.CL | cs.CL | Story detection in online communities is a challenging task as stories are
scattered across communities and interwoven with non-storytelling spans within
a single text. We address this challenge by building and releasing the
StorySeeker toolkit, including a richly annotated dataset of 502 Reddit posts
and comments, a detailed codebook adapted to the social media context, and
models to predict storytelling at the document and span level. Our dataset is
sampled from hundreds of popular English-language Reddit communities ranging
across 33 topic categories, and it contains fine-grained expert annotations,
including binary story labels, story spans, and event spans. We evaluate a
range of detection methods using our data, and we identify the distinctive
textual features of online storytelling, focusing on storytelling span
detection, which we introduce as a new task. We illuminate distributional
characteristics of storytelling on a large community-centric social media
platform, and we also conduct a case study on r/ChangeMyView, where
storytelling is used as one of many persuasive strategies, illustrating that
our data and models can be used for both inter- and intra-community research.
Finally, we discuss implications of our tools and analyses for narratology and
the study of online communities. | [
0.045317173,
0.0579359978,
-0.038806621,
0.0079377629,
-0.0291289929,
0.0000108673,
0.0110896816,
-0.0000159444,
0.023847254,
-0.0194775239,
0.0328684039,
0.0125860414,
0.0293781217,
0.075652048,
0.0117101092,
-0.0053992579,
-0.0368813276,
0.0491801836,
0.0740111247,
0.0408831388,
0.0444093011,
0.0722419843,
-0.0438516513,
0.0522303693,
-0.0241097398,
-0.0185970683,
0.0638382211,
0.0201082397,
0.0246687178,
-0.0490618497,
0.0269095991,
0.0391819254,
0.0157470163,
0.0287132319,
0.0000019652,
0.009927148,
0.0330918357,
-0.0413205102,
0.0149643086,
-0.0305145774,
0.0554694831,
0.0148744108,
0.0253289994,
0.0087273857,
-0.0161148608,
0.0180534702,
0.04941554,
0.0637929067,
0.0006353288,
0.0578649938,
-0.0335517861,
-0.0438290723,
-0.0367716141,
0.008663238,
0.0232165195,
0.0342044234,
-0.0012225815,
-0.0073518027,
-0.0006334236,
-0.0292674229,
-0.0005801705,
0.0261977166,
-0.0010058876,
-0.0453763902,
-0.013451552,
0.0530213788,
0.0021509717,
-0.0389544666,
-0.0025897187,
0.0429557562,
0.0286940224,
-0.0365246013,
0.0452722684,
0.0182729252,
-0.0068048867,
0.0253586564,
-0.0776939988,
0.0473719761,
-0.014647129,
0.0007766358,
-0.0397482328,
0.0117248567,
0.0252761934,
-0.0197387543,
0.0879732892,
0.0120608974,
0.0045661712,
0.0328163095,
-0.046548564,
0.0142597714,
0.0206291843,
-0.0667278692,
0.0427675247,
-0.0168549474,
0.0224311426,
0.0342938825,
-0.016039636,
0.0555658713,
0.0187903158,
-0.0649634078,
0.0090359515,
-0.0137553578,
0.0083540585,
0.0322448723,
-0.0130706662,
-0.0497853383,
0.0032499339,
-0.0400037207,
0.0103171133,
0.0406863205,
-0.0445167646,
0.0314406008,
-0.0093403952,
-0.0295586996,
-0.0048899092,
-0.0282822493,
0.0143161565,
-0.0048628589,
0.0114430729,
-0.0319849811,
-0.0430879891,
0.011849219,
0.008827175,
0.008855179,
0.0201384611,
0.067595005,
-0.0712359101,
0.0124884555,
0.0196223445,
-0.0030484817,
0.0093734693,
0.0083823083,
0.0566032641,
-0.0156011898,
-0.0237528551,
-0.0508382283,
0.0163968988,
-0.018651776,
-0.0492172688,
-0.0635901242,
-0.006971105,
0.0057611074,
-0.0183524583,
-0.0729200616,
0.0694344416,
0.0305862986,
0.0411413498,
-0.0149614336,
0.0074996161,
0.0353496373,
-0.0267943256,
0.0017702014,
0.0004035509,
-0.0014659463,
0.0680665523,
0.0442493893,
0.031860847,
0.0245034657,
0.039592728,
0.0364831053,
0.0992560908,
0.0235892422,
0.030884644,
-0.0092401346,
-0.0176899023,
-0.0201707073,
0.0285679493,
-0.0127920927,
-0.0038097084,
0.0190902334,
-0.013088515,
-0.0116483448,
-0.0384384133,
-0.0053309062,
0.0716789514,
0.1082637161,
-0.0031843346,
0.0048175389,
0.0358160883,
0.0370518938,
-0.0048459307,
-0.0105440244,
0.0349475592,
-0.0238470901,
-0.0044978941,
-0.0590593442,
0.0388959982,
0.0189226549,
-0.0122268759,
-0.0062655732,
-0.0318071879,
0.0000083882,
-0.0248734858,
-0.0510840528,
-0.0322644524,
-0.0179158747,
-0.0008346615,
-0.0062585375,
0.0541105308,
-0.0698753223,
0.0365129597,
-0.003210987,
0.0593912266,
0.0411894061,
0.0245935488,
-0.0116561158,
0.0137227802,
-0.042827405,
0.0706201196,
0.0009106912,
0.0075041554,
0.011894241,
-0.0349995308,
0.0006123187,
-0.017548278,
-0.0190525409,
0.0253875367,
-0.0007431183,
0.0063140281,
0.019624969,
-0.0422095358,
-0.0277738683,
-0.0548078939,
0.0200126301,
-0.0151202679,
0.0469957553,
-0.0370958447,
0.0103203943,
-0.0072359755,
0.0149771711,
0.0009460528,
-0.0374653935,
0.0084906146,
0.014931486,
-0.057485424,
0.0631192401,
-0.0239054356,
-0.0537614487,
0.017172534,
-0.1125790551,
-0.0048963926,
-0.0061216373,
0.0260396916,
0.0051813754,
0.0685518011,
-0.0697772056,
0.0128163258,
0.0329506882,
-0.0404840671,
-0.013907725,
-0.0298756175,
-0.0001797851,
0.0483161658,
-0.0041410821,
0.0272971373,
-0.0679325163,
-0.0537544601,
0.0100691309,
0.0301560946,
0.0194865521,
-0.0036203424,
-0.0115564559,
-0.0106489891,
0.0735169202,
-0.07304582,
-0.040203169,
-0.0451844223,
-0.0790458694,
-0.01544738,
-0.0262365472,
-0.0079293428,
0.0533573814,
-0.0211371649,
-0.0112797953,
-0.0037092455,
-0.0554017052,
-0.0300471801,
-0.0399839394,
0.0002138273,
0.0034155415,
0.0378829464,
0.0040271664,
-0.0249167606,
-0.0087011717,
-0.0249376055,
0.0754460469,
0.0736818016,
-0.0862324759,
-0.0170857292,
0.0001969401,
-0.0397657417,
-0.0378229544,
-0.0453304313,
0.0023529772,
0.0134402411,
-0.0008409335,
0.0480289459,
0.0106197968,
0.0340097882,
0.0453650244,
-0.0066877948,
0.0199863948,
-0.0039934642,
-0.0253638532,
-0.0342388377,
0.0395317003,
-0.0632716268,
-0.0970003456,
0.0395325013,
0.0384585075,
0.0352132805,
0.0258924458,
-0.0444905795,
-0.0110264774,
-0.0226020031,
0.0115100183,
0.0083593763,
-0.0178580172,
0.0052762893,
0.0499196872,
-0.0172151756,
-0.0072836936,
0.0382593721,
-0.0075826123,
0.030293636,
0.0194614232,
-0.036006216,
-0.0542130508,
0.0634739324,
0.0139250569,
0.0351753198,
0.0037615153,
-0.0415445827,
0.0608527847,
0.0041782358,
0.0488261394,
-0.0107020941,
-0.0391650088,
0.0087708412,
-0.010534836,
0.0598776117,
-0.0116648152,
-0.0117960731,
-0.0926819146,
-0.0185542163,
-0.0537503846,
0.0403924808,
-0.0439430177,
-0.0564725623,
-0.0106766354,
-0.0046046549,
0.0593448766,
-0.0067394888,
-0.0340321101,
0.0124880951,
0.0642752275,
0.0471382737,
-0.0094225146,
0.0013177339,
-0.0165793914,
-0.0050123981,
0.0640750453,
-0.0159085747,
-0.0060659149,
0.0475011021,
-0.0565436073,
0.0134896673,
-0.0351475663,
-0.0183743555,
-0.005083588,
0.0357109345,
-0.0495700091,
-0.0179855451,
0.0770877302,
0.0197906271,
-0.0317315981,
0.0163921602,
-0.017227374,
0.0331217945,
0.0548624508,
-0.0172457416,
-0.1062076464,
-0.0046525053,
-0.0251906421,
0.0036022076,
-0.0098107317,
-0.052284807,
-0.0237428006,
-0.0510270074,
0.0218162555,
-0.0085972426,
-0.0005665852,
-0.0146037498,
-0.0375488549,
0.0038536096,
0.0111038359,
-0.0585136786,
-0.0096168341,
-0.0297383796,
0.0012879341,
-0.0034309819,
-0.0879217982,
0.0053610411,
-0.0244033188,
-0.0572837591,
0.0264173988,
0.0332085453,
0.0680715963,
0.0227284841,
0.001708382,
-0.0275301822,
0.0231701601,
0.0044053448,
0.0071988245,
0.0963923335,
-0.0313563645,
0.0209963191,
-0.0473139398,
0.071555607,
-0.0059724413,
-0.036377091,
0.0301002767,
0.0571961626,
0.0309824031,
-0.0935585871,
0.0075907991,
0.0475000478,
0.0267191995,
0.0473884568,
0.0607949793,
-0.0254769865,
-0.0103971725,
-0.0286755152,
0.0498714335,
-0.0281355716,
-0.0600591563,
-0.0518480688,
0.0309621189,
0.007707533,
-0.0427298509,
-0.0151362326,
-0.0127195893,
0.0084501905,
0.0240216404,
-0.0296208765,
0.0101722907,
-0.010775812,
-0.0435842648,
0.0328578241,
-0.0557198301,
0.0017474015,
-0.0168757271,
-0.0027205253,
-0.0065410472,
-0.0255859755,
0.0077503254,
0.04035585,
-0.0687461048,
-0.0153232589,
-0.0170048345,
-0.0646393672,
0.0030554617,
0.0444646776,
-0.0139476452,
-0.0479071587,
0.0724275261,
0.00287675,
-0.0799693614,
0.0139102032,
-0.0184582192,
0.0195127018,
0.0078299306,
-0.002820018,
0.0114716254,
-0.0114601534,
-0.035857223,
-0.000175698,
-0.0337726921,
-0.0028017617,
0.0074294717,
-0.0257951897,
0.001347661,
-0.0172909927,
-0.0041446458,
-0.0811413899,
-0.0511054844,
0.0057124794,
0.0158588123,
-0.0024637876,
0.0121325795,
0.039348606,
-0.0210548323,
-0.0426504835,
0.0404361039,
-0.0307487641,
0.0355117656,
-0.1041189507,
-0.0098373787,
0.0476811677,
-0.0054122806,
-0.0049268831,
0.0079280855,
-0.000204445,
0.0076280949,
0.0003878997,
0.04517873,
-0.0095475558,
0.0322773792,
0.0116281733,
-0.0512563922,
0.0367875025,
0.0142996451,
-0.0610487014,
-0.0056780558,
-0.0033740862,
-0.0068626516,
0.0266798381,
-0.0202474911,
0.0513574854,
-0.019426005,
-0.0090479068,
0.014064827,
0.0257016122,
-0.0005596689,
-0.0376765803,
-0.0531753115,
0.0071650911,
-0.0380205698,
0.0252605453,
0.0354500376,
-0.0582424961,
0.0562516116,
0.0095287263,
-0.0670901164,
-0.021045588,
-0.0208071917,
-0.0026067898,
0.0544283129,
0.01807601,
-0.0002059615,
-0.0290257782,
0.0011229946,
0.0043035741,
-0.0270424038,
0.0160126202,
-0.0102404989,
-0.0309132822,
0.0249977279,
0.0162010491,
0.0238988269,
-0.0512706116,
0.0151296845,
0.0067317979,
0.0076544615,
-0.010940765,
-6.452173881e-33,
0.0293523055,
-0.0724387094,
-0.0391980596,
0.055165302,
-0.0331578031,
0.0292289481,
-0.0178276785,
0.0371245369,
0.0274631344,
0.0677051097,
0.0349628665,
0.0435542166,
-0.004109771,
-0.0006413017,
0.004467085,
0.0086972183,
0.0213445947,
0.0192746352,
-0.0461653508,
0.0518793724,
0.0276342947,
0.0032231198,
0.0166060198,
-0.0588638261,
0.0249013789,
-0.0175124686,
0.0011403421,
0.0190229435,
0.0795937404,
0.0108613027,
-0.0128461896,
0.0428106189,
0.0203328244,
-0.0100304419,
-0.0060157827,
0.0339582413,
-0.0654122531,
-0.0045865402,
0.0259704273,
0.0003106866,
-0.0400646441,
-0.0277692154,
0.0306961071,
-0.0123282839,
-0.0056257602,
-0.0230405238,
0.0676142797,
0.0000741814,
0.0604466274,
-0.0109009584,
-0.0555768497,
0.0295964666,
-0.0250339583,
-0.0355511494,
-0.0602342598,
0.0887899473,
0.0477926806,
0.0390309095,
-0.0311669223,
0.0418824703,
-0.0459633097,
0.0577033423,
-0.0096517438,
-0.022136528,
-0.0331652947,
0.0850228295,
-0.0107444068,
0.0369919278,
-0.0409590714,
0.0230081864,
-0.0356146023,
0.023544196,
0.0474095233,
0.0417668745,
-0.0235985145,
-0.0396512151,
-0.0598196015,
0.024147464,
0.0870360956,
-0.0540144891,
0.0696300492,
-0.0120337317,
-0.0289499089,
-0.0138531784,
-0.0177410096,
-0.0761608183,
-0.020131398,
-0.0109704761,
-0.0400774032,
0.005643961,
-0.0118415756,
0.0597634986,
-0.0177603755,
-0.0234239735,
-0.0319489725,
0.0449777618,
-0.032323841,
0.0298212096,
0.0117793288,
0.0167796109,
-0.0163080245,
0.034930069,
-0.0003197872,
0.0115096224,
0.0376295708,
-0.0411603749,
0.0658765733,
-0.0061987625,
-0.0449123941,
-0.0168811791,
-0.0333770551,
-0.0015261993,
-0.0438013747,
-0.0179272685,
0.0273265895,
0.022683477,
-0.0158691704,
0.0229325444,
0.020567026,
0.0333560929,
-0.0017622659,
-0.0376644023,
-0.031544257,
-0.0037642496,
-0.0234795399,
-0.0229208134,
-0.0095090549,
0.0176262427,
0.0390768796,
-0.0275640767,
-0.006938485,
-0.0635496154,
2.736e-7,
0.0100594675,
0.0500402413,
0.0322995782,
-0.0352780409,
0.0352430418,
0.0042671086,
0.0452108085,
-0.0012821648,
-0.0202627126,
-0.0616475791,
-0.0066078119,
0.0299362745,
0.0396794975,
0.0125596896,
-0.0631713346,
-0.0083903801,
-0.0796079338,
0.0062241973,
-0.0714879707,
-0.0352826007,
0.0277354866,
0.0220960882,
0.050868798,
0.0000516552,
0.0085549215,
-0.0334399156,
0.0237020012,
-0.0444314852,
-0.0267037917,
0.0353703611,
-0.0545977354,
-0.0412974656,
-0.0171168912,
-0.0888289586,
-0.0204686746,
-0.0214287303,
0.0228684172,
0.0554131754,
0.0356984176,
-0.017736461,
0.0333632305,
0.010467913,
-0.0047650188,
-0.0183249824,
0.0265520308,
-0.013801937,
-0.0187767781,
-0.0333015732,
0.0279129855,
-0.0199237131,
0.0298844669,
-0.0124978498,
-0.0001692852,
0.01048679,
0.0004280058,
0.002195986,
0.004315021,
-0.0634494051,
-0.0077980161,
0.0197382774,
-0.0535924509,
-0.0158395246,
0.0071646124,
0.0058338144,
-0.0384557992,
-0.0125341844,
0.0629052743,
2.038432101e-34,
-0.0114755658,
0.0263070017,
-0.0396113768,
-0.0026234405,
0.0679813772,
0.0175699666,
-0.0380279459,
-0.0273458958,
0.0395706594,
-0.0340643562,
-0.0230146535
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09668v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09668v1 | Improving the Generation Quality of Watermarked Large Language Models via Word Importance Scoring | 2023-11-16T08:36:00 | 2023-11-16T08:36:00 | Yuhang Li, Yihan Wang, Zhouxing Shi, Cho-Jui Hsieh | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.LG | The strong general capabilities of Large Language Models (LLMs) bring
potential ethical risks if they are unrestrictedly accessible to malicious
users. Token-level watermarking inserts watermarks in the generated texts by
altering the token probability distributions with a private random number
generator seeded by its prefix tokens. However, this watermarking algorithm
alters the logits during generation, which can lead to a downgraded text
quality if it chooses to promote tokens that are less relevant given the input.
In this work, we propose to improve the quality of texts generated by a
watermarked language model by Watermarking with Importance Scoring (WIS). At
each generation step, we estimate the importance of the token to generate, and
prevent it from being impacted by watermarking if it is important for the
semantic correctness of the output. We further propose three methods to predict
importance scoring, including a perturbation-based method and two model-based
methods. Empirical experiments show that our method can generate texts with
better quality with comparable level of detection rate. | [
0.0387078039,
0.0652841851,
-0.0063905576,
0.0329500735,
-0.040449556,
-0.0079033738,
0.0257107988,
0.0467535444,
-0.0041553038,
-0.0512434766,
0.0097769015,
-0.0344938636,
0.0075211064,
0.0453498699,
0.0346947722,
-0.0366707072,
0.0465975516,
-0.0244956687,
0.0146415019,
-0.0277341399,
0.0035177369,
-0.0071611595,
0.0851044953,
0.0277857408,
-0.0240293629,
0.0081446143,
0.0438816734,
0.0164305214,
0.0091262814,
-0.0179848298,
-0.0467028432,
0.0600234009,
-0.0156503096,
0.0681381822,
0.0000020838,
-0.0535106622,
-0.041396901,
0.0402581058,
0.01526934,
0.050947208,
0.0479046591,
0.0293993391,
-0.0428801179,
0.0113012511,
-0.0155195808,
0.0594465174,
0.0536011048,
0.0523983687,
0.0851641893,
0.0343347341,
-0.0118316105,
0.0166993737,
0.0261860285,
0.0096027758,
0.0311839208,
-0.0296129435,
0.0248604678,
0.0595733114,
-0.0511687212,
0.0417480059,
0.0181988366,
0.0429508351,
-0.0022160592,
-0.0810195059,
0.0198706277,
0.0038256783,
-0.021171581,
0.0004361391,
0.0329976119,
0.0173041113,
-0.0518574268,
-0.0413719341,
0.0218574964,
-0.0091721565,
0.0109221088,
0.0045152861,
-0.0431087464,
0.0438836552,
0.0366556123,
0.0269860812,
0.0499540418,
-0.0006794272,
0.0405815355,
0.0393357463,
0.0092116324,
0.0603729449,
0.026750993,
-0.0044425209,
-0.0730060637,
-0.0372352824,
-0.0623221695,
-0.085319832,
0.052418001,
-0.0050458917,
0.0283612683,
0.0082377419,
-0.0893342048,
-0.049897112,
0.0080150971,
-0.0526299775,
0.0118625043,
0.0073897187,
0.0221502818,
0.0440626778,
-0.0458949693,
0.0471792817,
0.0100945989,
0.0261411797,
0.0029131926,
-0.0137517871,
0.0219565742,
-0.0259483736,
-0.0056923204,
0.0528668687,
-0.0343540795,
-0.0105205569,
-0.0330254212,
0.0320928171,
0.0093764123,
0.0002196593,
0.0190647021,
-0.0116331168,
-0.0252858978,
-0.035416536,
0.0185831841,
-0.0543523431,
0.0252883304,
-0.0095620891,
-0.0324982405,
-0.0102920402,
0.0123019749,
0.0175000709,
0.0154768415,
0.021177914,
-0.0223956071,
0.0956028104,
0.0395766981,
-0.0118008107,
0.0015681845,
-0.0619952455,
0.0055968938,
0.0027265237,
-0.033326976,
-0.0597402938,
-0.058456298,
-0.0094405618,
0.0094905496,
-0.0625287667,
0.0270427819,
0.0075018085,
-0.033575505,
0.0116279805,
-0.0480868742,
-0.0050247866,
0.0185158718,
-0.0031954742,
-0.0015564355,
0.0440204479,
0.0435597934,
0.0688177496,
0.0705655292,
-0.0177554693,
0.0083712069,
0.0496824086,
0.0019846992,
0.0454739109,
-0.0266183801,
-0.05131853,
0.0396047756,
-0.032395862,
0.0237460937,
0.0507643558,
-0.0119813997,
-0.0059986627,
0.0926253051,
0.0372034833,
-0.0497446693,
-0.0021388056,
0.0073462934,
0.0242344178,
-0.0024865807,
-0.0034886883,
-0.0347287096,
-0.0007541238,
0.0053032255,
-0.03550056,
0.0533290021,
0.0017454121,
0.0220504403,
-0.0222406182,
0.0061374623,
-0.02817831,
0.0142754009,
-0.0108934734,
0.0245885849,
0.0182956234,
-0.0437931865,
0.0278838184,
0.0095598632,
-0.0293923542,
0.0543877482,
-0.0854713917,
0.0286441762,
0.0817755759,
0.0758243054,
0.0019270638,
0.0816305801,
-0.0050502266,
-0.0257403348,
0.0393123329,
-0.025504956,
-0.020332532,
-0.0147047481,
-0.0369819887,
-0.039324712,
-0.0049004513,
0.0196569394,
0.039192114,
-0.0131226778,
0.0204409324,
0.0437621623,
-0.0501771346,
-0.0568854697,
-0.0023569704,
0.0221388787,
-0.0089611476,
0.0133604072,
-0.029420061,
0.0276919845,
0.016733652,
-0.0298171807,
0.0392559879,
0.0034689121,
-0.0152439158,
-0.0326125026,
-0.016181767,
-0.0007611764,
0.034732081,
0.0469404384,
-0.0308647919,
0.0086928215,
0.0476747006,
-0.0147140455,
-0.0335540362,
0.0408734083,
-0.0659291744,
0.0399199761,
-0.0496636704,
0.0399908386,
-0.0281671397,
0.0160273239,
-0.0377828926,
0.0285360385,
-0.0206104852,
0.0269661378,
0.0097960643,
0.0294445194,
0.0034663645,
-0.0111932997,
-0.010852959,
-0.0116349747,
-0.0475106798,
0.0210866239,
0.0570960008,
0.0215164628,
0.0107299052,
-0.0304195844,
-0.0375291333,
-0.032050807,
-0.0087367576,
0.0268984139,
0.0249141324,
0.0051388736,
0.0056654429,
-0.0114176646,
-0.0306653399,
-0.065294899,
0.0153189255,
0.0024420554,
0.0222113803,
-0.0337374732,
-0.0059150672,
-0.002683012,
-0.0125795193,
0.0361178964,
0.0591691807,
0.0335450135,
-0.0238145236,
-0.0780656412,
0.0224948283,
-0.0441154502,
-0.0103760008,
0.0084304567,
-0.0388002619,
-0.0235968232,
0.0129791526,
0.0109000625,
0.0349380225,
0.0270190183,
-0.0017565215,
0.0312141012,
0.0269447789,
-0.0517371781,
-0.0586661994,
-0.0198552553,
0.0423201248,
0.0045569916,
-0.0695029944,
0.0349985883,
0.0164628401,
0.0121203223,
-0.0194688942,
-0.0342577137,
0.0824968219,
-0.0450970493,
-0.0231122002,
0.0086095762,
-0.030884767,
-0.0434618481,
0.0190842897,
-0.0065986221,
-0.0814139843,
0.0104167005,
-0.0368691124,
0.0465169586,
-0.0315215401,
0.0265742764,
0.0063926633,
0.0096610226,
-0.004511605,
0.0568982251,
0.0000804195,
-0.0366300456,
-0.0097258817,
0.0056903069,
0.063394092,
-0.0569082126,
-0.0260036848,
-0.0085448492,
-0.0115450742,
-0.0016375064,
-0.0009858392,
-0.0122190705,
-0.0475529172,
-0.0098011708,
0.0091563081,
0.0659138411,
-0.0000577717,
0.0187056921,
0.0123904776,
0.0496437959,
0.0062985276,
-0.0393541493,
0.0176938698,
-0.0268221628,
0.0493869819,
0.0076311277,
-0.093987599,
0.0284022447,
-0.0133986874,
-0.0054041632,
0.0596989244,
0.0368989743,
-0.0035101983,
0.0466709659,
-0.0155736497,
0.0393342413,
-0.0006598471,
-0.0494324006,
0.0253989864,
0.0274110232,
-0.0365221687,
0.0204318166,
0.0897886083,
0.0312962532,
-0.007470679,
0.021336304,
-0.011814937,
0.0047932635,
0.0180868786,
-0.0013721359,
-0.0479927324,
0.0020719462,
0.0478602313,
0.0220248476,
-0.0546983257,
-0.0223299749,
-0.0286253039,
-0.0667703748,
0.0311143361,
0.0328569412,
-0.0243630502,
-0.0088427523,
-0.0795957893,
-0.0292592533,
0.041768726,
-0.0143836485,
-0.0318561457,
0.036531277,
-0.0042715739,
0.0232532807,
-0.0288637206,
-0.0627119169,
-0.0024532904,
-0.006255785,
0.024865821,
0.0939680338,
0.032827422,
-0.0359597914,
-0.0389686637,
0.0515105352,
0.0373061672,
-0.0323297642,
-0.0187821742,
0.0201745257,
-0.0028791092,
-0.0289383326,
-0.0324657038,
-0.0039962949,
0.0586714596,
-0.0300907623,
-0.0378907137,
0.0333521552,
0.020061655,
-0.0349908359,
0.0003181373,
-0.0380571336,
0.0457736142,
0.0331965163,
0.0149009703,
-0.0450930409,
-0.0092415502,
-0.0720932782,
0.0156203527,
-0.0374682359,
-0.0291159507,
-0.0266798697,
-0.0309098288,
-0.0672205165,
-0.0864267796,
0.0106069762,
-0.0664522052,
0.0054591172,
0.0449247994,
0.0316878594,
0.0150806084,
-0.0380201563,
-0.0017916805,
-0.0086829662,
-0.0839192346,
0.0245908629,
-0.0716566294,
0.0101877702,
0.0174613781,
-0.0394911319,
-0.0343514197,
0.016222056,
-0.052143272,
-0.0651010796,
0.0079082614,
0.0644050911,
0.0216600783,
-0.0090282094,
-0.0252241176,
-0.0909224227,
0.0466954671,
0.0103153363,
-0.013928039,
0.0018516491,
0.0434794426,
-0.0260126293,
-0.0030172083,
0.0396008156,
-0.0713969246,
0.0285597946,
0.0552878752,
-0.0105570462,
-0.0176187064,
0.0179902371,
-0.0041170386,
0.0768449903,
0.0066226497,
-0.0389140435,
0.009527714,
-0.0160708465,
0.0114184953,
-0.0599703826,
-0.0385212488,
-0.0296742655,
0.0567786135,
0.0175787807,
-0.0191855617,
-0.0024841039,
-0.0008288006,
-0.0241262205,
-0.0323649682,
0.0165876355,
0.002826029,
-0.0337326564,
0.0389266722,
0.0431561321,
-0.0199675709,
-0.0236035716,
-0.004394168,
0.0170139689,
0.0058452329,
-0.0137663754,
-0.0414401181,
0.0061557814,
-0.0136607708,
0.0067053926,
0.047412917,
-0.0450739972,
-0.0161134023,
-0.058954373,
0.0248608217,
0.0554796197,
0.0296514332,
0.0512546599,
-0.0305886995,
-0.0039368328,
-0.0204939712,
0.0034734323,
0.0532367416,
-0.075206697,
-0.0295218639,
-0.0191777535,
-0.0391143039,
0.0466081798,
0.0540509671,
0.033878807,
0.0064436393,
0.0046161199,
-0.0447534434,
-0.0188019928,
0.0164792575,
0.0377395004,
0.0307920724,
-0.0539889522,
-0.0038040341,
-0.0530714542,
-0.0680695325,
-0.0074430015,
0.0114983348,
0.0226609241,
0.0134023009,
-0.0120065557,
0.030395275,
-0.0216687322,
0.0240132548,
-0.0718978345,
-0.0004287312,
0.0042803399,
-0.0288160946,
0.0292935353,
-5.918817931e-33,
-0.0003725056,
-0.0524991527,
-0.0781839564,
-0.0068345978,
0.0356948636,
0.02155382,
-0.0354560763,
-0.0243402682,
0.0190208144,
-0.0011572582,
-0.0028904772,
-0.019233413,
0.0201641601,
0.0129142748,
-0.0494592488,
0.0316401646,
0.0454760417,
0.0205355231,
-0.0390911102,
0.0359313414,
0.0458295494,
-0.0212569702,
0.0329489075,
-0.048089195,
0.0425177924,
-0.0111232111,
-0.0513737239,
-0.0221188664,
0.0061729234,
0.0412200578,
0.0039406214,
0.0189928655,
-0.0173347238,
-0.0446088389,
-0.0561263151,
-0.0026978974,
0.015671229,
-0.0073762946,
0.0096892314,
0.0083502894,
0.0229699053,
-0.0819422975,
0.0202857442,
-0.0076975315,
-0.0248506311,
0.0297152326,
0.0205287915,
-0.0100332741,
-0.0505856313,
-0.0416782722,
-0.0300248694,
0.0404630639,
-0.0183509812,
0.0242614299,
0.0170050506,
-0.0251706485,
0.0397837199,
0.0009663507,
-0.0305853877,
0.0564625785,
0.0178561471,
0.0111184791,
0.0512660965,
0.0048241704,
0.0011380801,
0.0362884291,
-0.0120338732,
0.0134616746,
0.0400775187,
-0.0187769458,
0.0165397841,
-0.0031084786,
0.0643037558,
0.0543992072,
0.0644517243,
-0.0392073952,
-0.0384220034,
0.0453774631,
-0.0469515398,
0.001918058,
0.063626796,
-0.0092097158,
-0.0222888421,
-0.0014533766,
-0.0647189543,
-0.0588267297,
-0.0161597524,
-0.024333993,
0.0060339286,
-0.0066141887,
-0.0755149275,
-0.0364835784,
0.0155972317,
-0.0810861066,
-0.0600052178,
0.0241833795,
-0.0099153295,
0.0206689071,
-0.0208562482,
0.0363878496,
0.011422961,
-0.0021336486,
0.0284343604,
-0.0504279919,
0.0168553088,
-0.009122083,
0.0174310524,
-0.0028064337,
-0.0815003142,
0.0273451172,
0.000932061,
0.0180386063,
0.0345418192,
0.0111219659,
0.0089961989,
-0.0422641151,
-0.0070999227,
-0.031018097,
0.0251183379,
0.0012450638,
0.01047171,
-0.0056566936,
-0.0225171614,
0.0397684462,
-0.0213698409,
0.0202496871,
-0.046408888,
0.06882938,
0.0422795452,
0.0051301178,
-0.0433357358,
-0.00083654,
2.792e-7,
0.0220132694,
0.0530085489,
-0.0094947852,
-0.0029661099,
0.0277338326,
0.0468502082,
0.0230743755,
0.0287916511,
0.0004547024,
0.0132959485,
-0.0386649296,
-0.031129146,
0.0413116552,
0.0019474025,
-0.0815414116,
0.0286986791,
-0.0515570678,
0.0077974242,
-0.0235419516,
0.0051042079,
0.0037037225,
0.1062781587,
0.0205415003,
-0.0266150236,
-0.0121582979,
-0.0511920005,
0.0384590216,
-0.0176052861,
-0.0093683004,
0.0158983301,
0.0341632776,
0.0071046008,
0.0341981947,
-0.0102435257,
-0.0507074185,
-0.0244390368,
0.0372572653,
0.052029755,
-0.0186833292,
0.0319037214,
-0.0297986753,
-0.0426951759,
0.0167680867,
-0.070406206,
0.0548354611,
0.079782337,
-0.0272516087,
-0.0677608326,
-0.0356206782,
-0.0518359654,
0.0333444402,
-0.0398453958,
-0.0574058667,
0.0189195443,
-0.0028412391,
0.0396849327,
-0.0011841033,
-0.0333824381,
-0.0403619297,
-0.0923638344,
-0.0107810935,
-0.0528545603,
-0.0211448856,
0.013864438,
0.057436347,
-0.0222309306,
0.0369271711,
2.714647624e-34,
0.0390005298,
-0.0554849319,
0.0083534578,
0.0171689428,
0.0447435491,
0.0226856712,
0.0220971312,
0.0333027504,
0.0204318855,
-0.0221007485,
-0.0048546218
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09665v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09665v2 | The Wisdom of Partisan Crowds: Comparing Collective Intelligence in Humans and LLM-based Agents | 2023-11-16T08:30:15 | 2024-02-16T16:43:53 | Yun-Shiuan Chuang, Siddharth Suresh, Nikunj Harlalka, Agam Goyal, Robert Hawkins, Sijia Yang, Dhavan Shah, Junjie Hu, Timothy T. Rogers | cs.CL | cs.CL | Human groups are able to converge on more accurate beliefs through
deliberation, even in the presence of polarization and partisan bias -- a
phenomenon known as the "wisdom of partisan crowds." Generated agents powered
by Large Language Models (LLMs) are increasingly used to simulate human
collective behavior, yet few benchmarks exist for evaluating their dynamics
against the behavior of human groups. In this paper, we examine the extent to
which the wisdom of partisan crowds emerges in groups of LLM-based agents that
are prompted to role-play as partisan personas (e.g., Democrat or Republican).
We find that they not only display human-like partisan biases, but also
converge to more accurate beliefs through deliberation as humans do. We then
identify several factors that interfere with convergence, including the use of
chain-of-thought prompt and lack of details in personas. Conversely,
fine-tuning on human data appears to enhance convergence. These findings show
the potential and limitations of LLM-based agents as a model of human
collective intelligence. | [
0.0525422245,
0.0592156611,
-0.0371482372,
0.0028182375,
-0.0291448403,
-0.017967457,
0.013106267,
-0.0139863687,
0.0245565698,
-0.0175728146,
-0.0113931959,
-0.0218434799,
0.0069374144,
-0.0234852284,
0.0362119935,
-0.0512050763,
0.0187209006,
-0.022093419,
0.0870536193,
-0.0665602386,
-0.006832914,
0.0077530448,
-0.0082782283,
0.0390006192,
0.0004758996,
0.0067542419,
-0.0185492896,
-0.0082765659,
0.0520900302,
0.0009017407,
-0.0064033396,
0.0485961214,
0.0091667604,
0.0223155431,
0.0000017366,
-0.0385309383,
0.0290218592,
-0.028515989,
0.0011005693,
-0.0274517611,
0.0670488179,
0.0786873549,
0.0029295657,
0.0146026202,
-0.0601813719,
0.0206112172,
0.0012814258,
0.0097558461,
0.0442268848,
0.039447505,
0.0300413128,
0.0056819147,
0.0003398418,
-0.0159761198,
-0.018151056,
-0.0360718034,
0.0260384604,
-0.032937143,
-0.0305828415,
-0.0028792797,
0.0193050802,
-0.0201845076,
-0.0237284508,
-0.0120263537,
-0.049375914,
0.0331890732,
-0.029066762,
-0.0219063107,
0.0045104339,
0.0447573625,
0.0481389649,
-0.0180232991,
-0.0006814796,
0.0178673398,
0.0420617498,
0.0639474615,
-0.0184183288,
0.0478953645,
-0.0139622455,
0.0105722919,
0.012829937,
0.0329611786,
0.0002358438,
0.0144743081,
-0.017630484,
0.0701793954,
-0.0190690625,
0.0045846766,
-0.0172913708,
0.0089133624,
-0.0082710395,
-0.062716417,
-0.0177288745,
0.0176200364,
-0.0256852582,
0.0220623054,
-0.0164776612,
0.0282405969,
0.0439858735,
-0.050822597,
0.0094620492,
0.0013655934,
0.03942357,
0.0751050934,
0.0287904013,
0.0132590933,
-0.015311135,
0.0564625822,
0.0158231426,
-0.0358344652,
-0.0331608094,
-0.0116146086,
0.006258708,
0.0260987915,
0.0198390428,
-0.0183244739,
0.000915423,
-0.0184262358,
-0.0744132921,
0.0131364372,
-0.034189783,
0.03268601,
0.0259552188,
-0.0469047762,
-0.0903899446,
0.0355712101,
-0.0622224994,
0.0279020313,
-0.0065400437,
-0.0348856226,
0.0298070759,
0.016379077,
-0.0125218472,
0.0122683858,
0.0123171406,
0.0532366447,
0.0059046438,
0.0078573572,
0.0010636469,
-0.0076868478,
0.0229141787,
-0.0793991759,
0.0014460809,
-0.0541317649,
0.0591107346,
0.0099720741,
-0.0022168877,
-0.0550852828,
0.012188118,
0.0184455086,
-0.0390552506,
0.0685626715,
-0.0135036549,
0.0495855622,
0.0542554595,
0.0242667086,
-0.0112221735,
0.0628800616,
0.0106585408,
0.0175546892,
0.0247236434,
-0.0000701782,
0.0404594429,
0.014754991,
-0.0094670309,
0.0198933408,
-0.0202351157,
0.0080818189,
-0.0312725306,
-0.0005026227,
0.0350319594,
0.0890057385,
-0.023732841,
-0.0429291539,
0.0942760706,
0.0935860872,
-0.0354486369,
0.019614704,
-0.0029685285,
0.0502683707,
0.0262449849,
0.0033878491,
-0.0314665213,
0.0403201506,
-0.0258006342,
-0.0412146002,
0.0305885244,
0.0465340577,
-0.0354163535,
0.0049438439,
-0.004387618,
0.0075785676,
0.0428427719,
0.0093295323,
-0.0186243523,
-0.0311050937,
-0.0170284789,
0.010884339,
0.0454432964,
-0.0208912604,
-0.0292232595,
-0.0778521895,
0.0460872278,
0.0384187736,
0.0132798376,
0.0064495085,
-0.0230990518,
-0.0208400413,
0.0226437282,
0.0725914687,
0.081142053,
-0.0392218865,
-0.069747366,
-0.0290595405,
-0.0024591726,
0.0220699888,
-0.0005798725,
0.0804918706,
0.0046891165,
-0.0020474149,
-0.0259383433,
0.0259016063,
-0.0021211049,
0.0199943557,
-0.0263626855,
0.0335186087,
-0.0562424362,
0.0091304881,
0.0657577813,
0.004643912,
-0.0145617519,
-0.0191493761,
0.0281680655,
0.0053913477,
-0.058025796,
0.0290724747,
-0.0124801332,
0.0667104721,
0.0288155172,
-0.0363452993,
-0.0385229141,
0.0013980848,
0.0368726775,
0.01675204,
0.0409660861,
-0.0208311137,
-0.0055855727,
0.0058508269,
-0.0005011956,
-0.0633863881,
0.0071729491,
-0.0252967477,
0.0688888654,
-0.0052587404,
-0.0131708859,
0.0149949901,
-0.0205792505,
0.0062378771,
-0.0041164523,
0.0313829407,
0.0142516354,
0.0513153188,
0.0345112942,
0.0469183028,
-0.0550727099,
-0.028483538,
-0.0640269518,
-0.05118775,
-0.0233769082,
-0.0052828914,
0.0085942838,
0.012832894,
-0.0648402274,
0.0000125317,
0.0545588769,
-0.0447513163,
0.0125679718,
-0.007284143,
0.0089679454,
0.011290133,
0.0012828041,
-0.0388252065,
-0.0203713104,
0.0389431156,
-0.0198503714,
-0.0002380023,
0.03427127,
-0.0022424567,
-0.0359085947,
-0.0008213267,
-0.0695218071,
0.009604753,
-0.0502260663,
-0.043059852,
0.066118218,
0.0036842583,
0.0377138034,
0.0666854084,
0.0629222095,
0.0359050818,
0.046350684,
0.0387434512,
-0.0694961622,
-0.0156401284,
-0.0409410186,
0.0101875141,
-0.069997102,
-0.059520416,
0.0107625499,
0.0701580569,
0.0009084253,
0.0288544912,
-0.036830008,
0.0885650441,
0.0048284912,
-0.0530164056,
0.0200248584,
-0.0535908565,
-0.0227690861,
0.031680122,
-0.013199023,
-0.0048517426,
0.0685554892,
-0.002175557,
0.0397981219,
0.0095762452,
-0.0102402885,
-0.0177393164,
0.0453702025,
0.0188512616,
-0.0049040015,
-0.0317852423,
0.0123144351,
-0.0646964163,
-0.0263373442,
0.0334075466,
-0.0503318682,
0.0530135334,
-0.0446222685,
-0.0118215745,
-0.0114560341,
0.0149043594,
-0.0185807031,
-0.0357227623,
-0.0591424145,
-0.0029270456,
0.0688364729,
-0.0528597459,
-0.0496884286,
0.0067838631,
0.0508907661,
-0.0645969436,
0.0235661212,
-0.0051898812,
0.0104028257,
-0.0485748649,
0.00418879,
0.0566147454,
0.0487746187,
-0.0502772629,
0.0179474168,
0.0510267541,
0.005046309,
-0.0049335044,
-0.0290770754,
-0.0695575252,
0.0375499167,
-0.0016301273,
-0.0021652735,
0.0163019318,
0.0211341437,
-0.0177212823,
0.0525439493,
0.0656835511,
0.0304683223,
-0.0661943331,
-0.0154630281,
-0.0159656722,
-0.0002674632,
0.0475120097,
-0.0191791132,
-0.0313420929,
0.0044375369,
0.0113158757,
0.0008115742,
-0.0422390699,
-0.0677298307,
-0.0078815324,
-0.1241137162,
0.0182345957,
-0.0024714717,
0.007611257,
0.0095804632,
-0.0331079327,
0.0368434414,
-0.0109026125,
-0.0107517112,
-0.0069032367,
0.0401776843,
-0.0025676715,
-0.0141003244,
-0.05021099,
0.0026366909,
0.0216556694,
-0.0400884077,
0.0958478972,
0.0379307903,
0.0753179342,
-0.017154349,
-0.0650283992,
0.0126191713,
-0.0113221621,
-0.0144493561,
0.0284822155,
0.0424301215,
-0.0259916876,
0.0234744698,
-0.0255349316,
0.0137628634,
0.0290635414,
0.0182540752,
0.0210555196,
0.0285314638,
-0.0047215852,
-0.070310168,
-0.0065227002,
0.0082244463,
0.0151594225,
0.0665900558,
0.0040936572,
-0.0498993285,
0.0051362654,
-0.0355039574,
0.0022410504,
-0.0307698604,
-0.1076780632,
0.005128385,
0.0077013462,
0.0134629356,
-0.0358868577,
-0.067390725,
0.0081480034,
-0.0090133138,
0.0048809135,
0.0238898322,
0.02329956,
0.0065843556,
0.0254515521,
-0.0075296583,
-0.0316235833,
0.0153307514,
-0.0434407294,
-0.077678971,
-0.0209943801,
-0.01358834,
-0.0032047885,
0.0056697191,
-0.0149290068,
-0.0651496053,
0.0606381558,
0.0118711591,
0.0311828237,
0.009023523,
0.0118175931,
-0.0247016028,
0.0191909298,
0.027296992,
-0.0303244796,
0.0374508537,
-0.017706342,
0.0611263625,
0.0066547343,
0.0279115885,
-0.0110076638,
0.0448469184,
0.0348607153,
-0.0206101872,
-0.0975489169,
-0.0695712268,
0.0281003136,
-0.0010727117,
0.006906155,
-0.0037495762,
-0.0081270635,
-0.0061862613,
-0.0283811297,
-0.0279350691,
-0.0236454289,
0.0188642107,
-0.0690814033,
0.010917061,
-0.0244995728,
0.0190364867,
0.0297233127,
-0.0089636398,
0.0206714366,
0.0067563979,
0.0453131907,
-0.0036410464,
0.0430171974,
0.0339586511,
-0.0042893956,
0.0182341542,
0.0302110408,
-0.0301721469,
0.0394355506,
0.0420535915,
0.0164058246,
0.0119873853,
-0.0396738388,
0.0103376387,
-0.0056138551,
-0.0425518788,
-0.112059027,
0.0563043281,
0.0674635097,
-0.0244190563,
0.0396581516,
0.015591355,
-0.0214418899,
0.0101864552,
-0.0000126368,
-0.0150182089,
-0.0040388131,
-0.0144676398,
0.0087423725,
0.025458917,
-0.0467184596,
0.0273808539,
0.0654896647,
-0.0232091732,
0.0133057404,
-0.0205502082,
-0.0315286554,
-0.0155401751,
-0.0275219232,
-0.0120263007,
-0.0075883227,
-0.0213498548,
0.0062436145,
-0.082261622,
-0.0208244324,
-0.0023172044,
0.0396674611,
0.0356258787,
-0.0335542746,
-0.0171228126,
0.029060591,
-0.0170004796,
0.0618942678,
-0.0491847247,
0.0538243167,
-0.0954746753,
0.024655655,
-0.0167590473,
-6.014614476e-33,
-0.0230359789,
-0.0445996262,
0.0247863065,
0.0078871585,
0.0007427933,
-0.0267407671,
-0.0295842029,
0.0589237995,
-0.0263152309,
0.0361169614,
0.0049138744,
0.0079148933,
0.0103385178,
-0.0520917214,
-0.0035710856,
-0.0065486464,
0.015963845,
-0.0375552624,
-0.031668067,
-0.0147364195,
0.0311298352,
-0.0300168712,
-0.0317191407,
-0.0787016377,
0.0169168543,
-0.0083356909,
-0.0010666657,
-0.0096554169,
-0.0070980196,
-0.000851948,
0.0024095483,
-0.0038891304,
0.0179061797,
-0.0316245444,
-0.0130481869,
0.0592845716,
0.018798409,
-0.0076330914,
0.0104662301,
-0.0311179347,
-0.0153870871,
-0.0212146845,
-0.0079514273,
-0.0031145969,
-0.0564584211,
0.0210468248,
0.0367299691,
-0.0141409468,
0.0324413441,
0.0003725753,
-0.0557033308,
-0.0020886746,
-0.003579766,
-0.0033336584,
-0.0548486561,
-0.0101227164,
-0.0061888499,
0.0246754531,
-0.086382933,
0.0571562089,
-0.0398044027,
-0.0294240471,
0.021870885,
-0.006672902,
0.0335494503,
0.0902879462,
0.0805299431,
0.0879234895,
-0.0785341039,
-0.0198006853,
0.0055089495,
0.052299507,
0.0881455764,
0.0773498267,
-0.0087899975,
-0.0548621118,
-0.0144553408,
-0.0041447212,
0.0386178792,
-0.0026876731,
0.0566440299,
-0.002636211,
-0.0198898111,
-0.006102141,
-0.0072638234,
-0.0374589935,
-0.0072106868,
-0.0189856198,
-0.0158287417,
0.0276884455,
-0.0362465158,
-0.0427264832,
0.0454831682,
-0.0420770347,
0.0062655048,
0.0215997361,
-0.0132263843,
0.0166817904,
0.0027097287,
-0.0218841806,
-0.0624536723,
-0.0094860494,
-0.048206374,
0.0013887865,
0.039798677,
-0.001076268,
-0.0073973555,
-0.0015250528,
-0.0300362185,
-0.014183552,
-0.0051623629,
0.0284737963,
0.0121612996,
-0.0333314389,
0.0548710227,
-0.0003361578,
0.0048975195,
-0.0835687593,
0.008748305,
-0.0308037661,
0.0114674633,
0.056494806,
-0.0693657771,
-0.0131539647,
-0.0323180966,
-0.0119628469,
-0.0743584633,
0.0088549098,
0.0092656547,
-0.0243530385,
-0.0332050361,
-0.0377279595,
2.468e-7,
0.002537119,
0.0783641115,
-0.0234962814,
0.0078390362,
0.017410744,
0.0539402589,
-0.0064378143,
0.0040296926,
0.0249807928,
-0.0922498703,
-0.0226014405,
0.0436559394,
0.0193657428,
0.0484467596,
-0.0762263685,
-0.0125874709,
0.0014358063,
0.0205337703,
-0.0072931577,
-0.0006334604,
-0.0050030295,
-0.0153825395,
0.04036057,
0.0027562932,
-0.0300950631,
-0.0520262867,
0.0504599325,
-0.0288410243,
-0.0156224035,
0.0417270586,
0.0106297527,
-0.053015437,
-0.008250664,
0.0665807128,
0.0456813499,
0.0050411755,
-0.0391608067,
0.0088488348,
0.0065660961,
-0.01278752,
-0.0214402806,
-0.0230884273,
0.0074720853,
0.0081058145,
0.0370093733,
-0.0606040508,
-0.0412398204,
-0.0501357503,
-0.0343719199,
-0.0124303671,
-0.0004507508,
0.0140994228,
-0.0106444517,
-0.0000800503,
0.0071475036,
0.0035429883,
0.0291690864,
-0.0545080006,
-0.0200376138,
-0.0344231352,
-0.0759132802,
-0.1064455733,
0.0012160862,
0.0194585342,
0.0209348835,
0.0106859654,
0.0158966649,
1.72998376e-34,
0.0184838958,
0.016925836,
-0.0180767067,
-0.0104954131,
0.0715232044,
0.0144196535,
-0.0116705913,
-0.0076560145,
0.0477223285,
-0.0347293541,
-0.0087708067
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09661v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09661v1 | Evolving Domain Adaptation of Pretrained Language Models for Text Classification | 2023-11-16T08:28:00 | 2023-11-16T08:28:00 | Yun-Shiuan Chuang, Yi Wu, Dhruv Gupta, Rheeya Uppaal, Ananya Kumar, Luhang Sun, Makesh Narsimhan Sreedhar, Sijia Yang, Timothy T. Rogers, Junjie Hu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Adapting pre-trained language models (PLMs) for time-series text
classification amidst evolving domain shifts (EDS) is critical for maintaining
accuracy in applications like stance detection. This study benchmarks the
effectiveness of evolving domain adaptation (EDA) strategies, notably
self-training, domain-adversarial training, and domain-adaptive pretraining,
with a focus on an incremental self-training method. Our analysis across
various datasets reveals that this incremental method excels at adapting PLMs
to EDS, outperforming traditional domain adaptation techniques. These findings
highlight the importance of continually updating PLMs to ensure their
effectiveness in real-world applications, paving the way for future research
into PLM robustness against the natural temporal evolution of language. | [
0.0151455728,
0.0667031482,
-0.0144215524,
0.0195007939,
-0.0207770951,
0.0143691543,
0.0060687303,
-0.0138731096,
-0.0262151696,
-0.0848948434,
-0.0132777235,
-0.0246827547,
-0.0398873426,
0.0126455892,
-0.015240158,
-0.0075725829,
0.088184461,
0.0051889024,
-0.0080394112,
0.00244182,
0.0040210322,
0.0135017121,
-0.0362133272,
-0.0260490011,
0.0426738299,
-0.0419982523,
-0.0192143228,
-0.0397542268,
0.0539482385,
-0.0298165027,
0.0252095424,
0.0558476113,
0.0591321588,
0.0461774357,
0.0000019261,
-0.0664724037,
-0.0549725518,
-0.0432421044,
-0.0241342299,
0.0319778696,
0.0151193365,
-0.0250758771,
-0.0118931346,
0.0176920686,
-0.082414262,
-0.0319302529,
-0.0017895955,
0.0070492062,
0.0872175694,
0.1110537127,
0.0009695376,
-0.0074030701,
-0.0223836415,
-0.0648698434,
-0.0967548564,
-0.0902459919,
0.0542284772,
-0.0293356795,
-0.0718191788,
0.0361903943,
-0.0142805027,
-0.0000236591,
-0.0060041011,
-0.0166438576,
-0.0572314113,
0.0161444079,
0.0244648419,
0.0375210531,
-0.014383655,
0.0453637727,
0.0187905747,
-0.0484085828,
-0.0105671082,
-0.0362562947,
0.0244413856,
0.019837765,
0.0029499808,
-0.0408848301,
0.006756647,
0.0374225564,
0.0083807977,
-0.0083346218,
0.0211769864,
0.0538712814,
-0.0202032309,
0.0493519045,
-0.0350918844,
-0.0082002254,
0.0001045228,
0.0065916134,
0.0123275286,
-0.0549803562,
0.0357291736,
0.0246142428,
0.0054033641,
0.0273280274,
-0.0917764679,
-0.0078297826,
-0.0067721689,
-0.0355363376,
0.0255687069,
0.0057279919,
-0.0145252207,
0.0535420217,
-0.0052058753,
0.0165359136,
-0.0194080807,
-0.0425934233,
-0.0389431529,
0.0581649914,
-0.0546390191,
-0.0275814943,
-0.0072705704,
0.0202323236,
-0.0410166197,
0.0115682594,
-0.028017642,
0.038558796,
0.0281154159,
-0.0518826731,
-0.0259310119,
-0.0123720206,
-0.0307354275,
-0.0135528138,
-0.0182967149,
0.0435465388,
0.0248672701,
0.0559156351,
-0.0198691301,
-0.0185951535,
-0.0340692736,
0.0123713929,
-0.0064570922,
-0.0002793289,
-0.0069517633,
0.0340972133,
-0.007547094,
-0.0388584696,
-0.0316095911,
0.0469176471,
-0.0493765473,
-0.0389379375,
0.026978828,
-0.0147598004,
0.0193473157,
-0.0123182107,
-0.0151510695,
-0.0952567607,
-0.0207874645,
-0.0179415215,
0.015728781,
0.0740725771,
0.002731635,
-0.0021945813,
0.044437442,
-0.0001589983,
0.0356644653,
0.108267501,
-0.0035329715,
-0.028288193,
0.0201574098,
-0.0127147958,
-0.0303835329,
0.0346960165,
0.0250554495,
0.0421155691,
0.0258682817,
0.0502461977,
-0.0182350948,
0.0020952816,
0.0000227148,
-0.0459631123,
0.0304243024,
-0.0470294468,
0.0696974695,
0.0139259687,
0.0215292051,
0.0096883578,
0.0077249384,
-0.0096480176,
0.0150216771,
-0.0087861223,
-0.0180865806,
-0.0201891623,
-0.0345961675,
-0.0363075621,
-0.0533989035,
0.0195255317,
-0.0322062112,
-0.0546010099,
0.0054933829,
0.0137906531,
0.0161346346,
-0.0287648365,
0.0426236764,
0.0377069861,
-0.0250845887,
0.038089551,
0.0349249952,
-0.0170799531,
0.0049483082,
-0.0578742772,
0.0035244343,
0.0019458247,
0.0033060457,
-0.0688701645,
-0.0375480466,
-0.0383973271,
0.0828113109,
0.0565676466,
0.0539891757,
0.0021070756,
-0.0092460858,
-0.0074002622,
-0.0159848947,
-0.0302965585,
0.0239456668,
0.0690036714,
-0.0134366648,
0.0570380948,
0.019398151,
-0.0045557292,
0.0189095419,
0.0591123216,
-0.0422541983,
-0.0218899399,
0.0465923436,
0.010692779,
0.0417199209,
0.0210186373,
-0.0161829796,
-0.0315414704,
0.0189354979,
-0.0084619233,
-0.0365135148,
0.0330459699,
-0.030102849,
-0.0411998443,
0.0695263371,
0.0258242264,
-0.0325976163,
-0.0065650446,
-0.0453945473,
-0.0080064768,
0.0515693277,
-0.0058103465,
-0.0048552677,
-0.0454579815,
0.0135465348,
-0.0528668351,
0.0333755352,
-0.0332359672,
0.0453516021,
0.018632289,
-0.0659088418,
-0.0271230545,
0.0205555055,
0.0558948964,
-0.0135608083,
0.0149060832,
-0.015841322,
-0.0256186221,
0.0047193449,
0.0120326746,
0.0119898692,
-0.0161218811,
0.0286304094,
-0.0395052359,
-0.0028062633,
-0.0395004377,
0.0587828495,
0.0369728766,
-0.0329742767,
-0.0322348289,
-0.0033762439,
-0.0073366403,
-0.0280799624,
-0.0242517497,
0.0069972486,
0.0427779779,
-0.0258749388,
0.0270284973,
-0.0405291803,
0.0274419859,
0.0003753701,
0.0563289039,
-0.0178052988,
-0.0455807373,
-0.0641777441,
0.0341022685,
-0.0127125038,
0.0364533365,
-0.0223558638,
-0.025853727,
-0.0082099969,
0.0219495688,
0.0169377178,
0.038590271,
0.0502093583,
0.0562321134,
0.0396051221,
0.0439032465,
-0.0268299542,
0.0069361483,
-0.0257205833,
0.0329633951,
-0.0460613556,
0.0415942147,
0.0607557222,
0.05270328,
-0.0168438908,
-0.0351274461,
-0.0171533488,
0.0396768339,
-0.0369583778,
-0.0384125002,
0.0198864155,
-0.0092812683,
-0.0408086143,
-0.0038000292,
-0.012760303,
-0.0482983403,
0.0572906621,
-0.0000459962,
0.0394152738,
-0.0807157084,
-0.0525883026,
-0.0252750441,
0.0569946319,
0.0223273411,
-0.0238207094,
0.0747446269,
0.0129516311,
-0.0217989869,
-0.018219607,
0.0386060067,
-0.0081876172,
0.041919034,
-0.0303873625,
0.0666768476,
0.0019293288,
-0.0324526504,
-0.0310615581,
-0.0715354383,
-0.0249193627,
-0.0341610685,
-0.0679748803,
0.0138908084,
0.0053865802,
0.0264103021,
-0.0323175527,
0.0513438173,
-0.0203828383,
0.0104299346,
0.0198478084,
0.0085202968,
0.0162351578,
0.0304462276,
-0.0207937118,
-0.0069962894,
0.0194296371,
0.0273271706,
-0.0098934062,
0.0109125292,
-0.0321249999,
-0.0140152322,
0.0076031885,
-0.0354435556,
0.0116128251,
-0.0529170372,
0.0418946296,
-0.0273252912,
0.000705934,
0.0759423524,
0.008612358,
-0.0087129734,
0.0034518153,
0.03956379,
-0.0280574355,
0.0116804782,
0.0055262288,
-0.0507834665,
-0.0334220305,
-0.0212357193,
0.0220418628,
0.0040620249,
-0.0262240227,
-0.02098828,
-0.0905974358,
-0.0367072001,
-0.0117861191,
-0.0771746188,
0.0107435184,
-0.047655303,
0.0301081892,
-0.0190015752,
0.0149442637,
-0.0152121391,
-0.0060311556,
-0.0091891037,
0.0642380044,
-0.0682203248,
-0.0628266335,
-0.0334554724,
-0.0139918439,
0.0098132677,
0.0748002529,
0.0371295884,
-0.0303988643,
-0.0189558584,
0.0803221613,
-0.0097790845,
0.0191288199,
-0.0220318474,
0.0293396004,
-0.0145189669,
-0.0066694813,
0.036496494,
0.0293930396,
-0.0210912358,
0.001608673,
0.0429266281,
0.0243529938,
0.0059671164,
-0.0185731892,
-0.0266172867,
-0.0012008476,
0.0132138459,
0.0222518165,
-0.0055351201,
-0.082119517,
0.0216308013,
-0.0334823243,
0.0021161973,
-0.0712620616,
-0.0407856181,
-0.0247380845,
-0.0464061126,
0.0179325156,
-0.0467513129,
0.0065238778,
-0.0329113528,
0.0206635688,
0.0137906764,
-0.0078534847,
0.0072097844,
0.0153977089,
-0.0697167292,
-0.0046831202,
0.0000057224,
0.0153787313,
-0.0222071689,
-0.0234263092,
0.0929479972,
-0.0045518572,
-0.0227366816,
-0.0416573696,
-0.0653053448,
-0.0692526996,
0.0259640552,
0.0079773339,
0.0051340461,
0.045459006,
-0.0089332182,
-0.0099926768,
0.0933600813,
0.0973059088,
-0.0019604685,
0.0484744981,
0.052825287,
-0.0131485341,
-0.0276299436,
0.0164871253,
-0.0098824417,
0.0405784696,
0.0801672116,
-0.0199367255,
0.0175458919,
-0.0289432183,
-0.0235695038,
-0.0257430319,
0.0483477823,
0.0132819284,
-0.0706187487,
-0.0124337533,
0.0082730167,
0.0083568804,
-0.0286444053,
-0.0061254753,
-0.0092010479,
0.0155011574,
-0.0324286632,
-0.0376284756,
0.0611367114,
-0.0305840354,
0.0599751286,
-0.0437787026,
0.0354574583,
0.0474190675,
0.0911889076,
-0.0098111155,
0.0000899371,
0.0031647633,
-0.0165673625,
0.0363271572,
-0.0050597843,
0.0094233369,
0.0354508571,
0.0250977352,
0.0268226434,
0.0021856171,
0.0358565561,
-0.0329861939,
0.0235864744,
-0.0434763134,
0.0020770149,
0.0322091505,
-0.0182166714,
0.0471210778,
0.0055131144,
-0.0281025581,
-0.0257385354,
-0.0020655,
-0.0160554033,
0.0255887154,
0.0306118168,
-0.0052274992,
-0.0349070355,
0.0596225895,
0.0217112191,
0.0307025034,
0.0534955412,
0.0423840247,
-0.0239517968,
-0.023388233,
-0.0201317612,
-0.0392649807,
-0.0109103387,
0.0015131363,
0.0145896096,
-0.0457406826,
-0.0454378389,
-0.003354256,
0.0057245358,
0.0069809826,
0.0446404293,
0.0013083522,
0.0629581586,
-0.0034964597,
0.0375840813,
-0.0285656527,
0.0303204786,
0.0068423715,
-0.012562505,
0.0044660536,
-5.899679781e-33,
-0.0282164905,
-0.0118545704,
-0.004931407,
-0.0076117604,
-0.0277418494,
-0.0136346351,
0.0040754625,
0.0072205504,
-0.0075069712,
0.0143135712,
0.0115548745,
0.033787854,
-0.0032545559,
0.015718786,
-0.0164238866,
-0.0150058372,
0.0515950732,
-0.0354032367,
-0.0485887937,
-0.0225374028,
0.0200144909,
0.0280654952,
0.0540136546,
-0.1009427011,
0.0210458599,
0.0372652523,
-0.011185416,
0.0095653776,
0.0155598437,
0.0643761605,
0.0217216648,
0.034274932,
0.0331590325,
-0.0567906573,
-0.0160363168,
0.0083458275,
-0.0811768398,
-0.0272374637,
-0.0025971527,
0.0222736169,
0.022804426,
0.0005435224,
-0.0088065537,
0.0263484549,
-0.0280652288,
-0.0198512319,
0.0084355753,
-0.0378100872,
0.0282698795,
-0.0263436418,
-0.0288986508,
0.0459769182,
-0.0062594153,
-0.0169824176,
-0.0423168354,
0.0150071084,
0.0350079387,
0.0042363987,
-0.0649572983,
0.0196504407,
-0.0131887449,
0.0013491953,
0.0293353423,
0.001403856,
0.0040110038,
0.0353527702,
-0.0116794091,
0.0245045871,
-0.0003123892,
0.015214311,
0.0442621745,
-0.0332260281,
0.0231705364,
0.0353259631,
0.027687123,
-0.0637952164,
-0.080853574,
0.0236236751,
0.0468521491,
-0.0401540697,
-0.00334655,
0.0376654044,
0.0250119548,
-0.0167160779,
-0.0096903108,
-0.0201115254,
0.0126585914,
-0.0221851189,
0.0190420635,
-0.0014307324,
-0.0504073724,
0.0323675312,
-0.000371483,
-0.0625772625,
-0.0526002683,
0.012927765,
-0.0457355119,
-0.0346277095,
0.0181123316,
0.0146289449,
-0.014923987,
-0.0422982164,
0.0170019139,
0.0203505736,
0.0367151573,
-0.0580150634,
0.0572150312,
0.0052132895,
-0.0744380206,
-0.0105193555,
0.0265288372,
0.0268579461,
0.0120514119,
0.0892214403,
-0.0083643571,
-0.0124617647,
0.0068453946,
0.055575233,
0.0515112467,
-0.0839721709,
-0.0422892198,
0.0408273228,
-0.0148188537,
0.038406916,
-0.0221735593,
-0.0325980708,
0.0379540659,
0.0628120601,
-0.0252866279,
-0.1096006408,
-0.0151375728,
-0.0208327789,
2.64e-7,
0.0568853877,
0.0683824718,
0.0123371743,
-0.051159855,
0.0577403083,
0.0542081185,
-0.046810776,
0.052544523,
0.0127425101,
0.0152113121,
0.0002050864,
0.0274816025,
0.0265089311,
0.0229902714,
-0.0492596179,
-0.028695805,
-0.0215330068,
0.0263530258,
-0.0519379936,
0.0058605876,
-0.0078670187,
0.0623333231,
0.0550411269,
-0.0083736209,
0.0034709875,
-0.0398063399,
0.0532424301,
0.0193078537,
0.038261909,
0.0292368978,
-0.0306184385,
-0.0081897881,
-0.0466891192,
-0.0021045746,
-0.0466368571,
0.0910438597,
-0.0119471531,
0.0397441201,
0.0150407832,
-0.012988898,
-0.0126683544,
0.0321038105,
0.0266381595,
0.0109565016,
0.099097684,
-0.0809937268,
-0.0135133713,
-0.0535166226,
-0.0395305529,
-0.0091512082,
0.0266296752,
0.0258941483,
-0.0122135505,
0.0359168239,
0.0012170399,
0.0148602165,
-0.0251348093,
-0.0922420621,
0.0052322354,
-0.0216997676,
-0.042264618,
-0.0037061381,
0.0041210945,
0.0209885631,
0.0324493758,
-0.0266936235,
0.0363805071,
1.843988001e-34,
-0.0026576961,
-0.0249470472,
-0.0122069772,
-0.0188080594,
-0.0027354823,
0.0267767422,
0.0401133224,
0.0009147798,
0.0327160992,
-0.0173035506,
0.0086943191
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09656v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09656v2 | Structured Chemistry Reasoning with Large Language Models | 2023-11-16T08:20:36 | 2024-02-09T16:35:28 | Siru Ouyang, Zhuosheng Zhang, Bing Yan, Xuan Liu, Yejin Choi, Jiawei Han, Lianhui Qin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs) excel in diverse areas, yet struggle with
complex scientific reasoning, especially in the field of chemistry. Different
from the simple chemistry tasks (e.g., molecule classification) addressed in
previous studies, complex chemistry problems require not only vast knowledge
and precise calculation, but also compositional reasoning about rich dynamic
interactions of different concepts (e.g., temperature changes). Our study shows
that even advanced LLMs, like GPT-4, can fail easily in different ways.
Interestingly, the errors often stem not from a lack of domain knowledge within
the LLMs, but rather from the absence of an effective reasoning structure that
guides the LLMs to elicit the right knowledge, incorporate the knowledge in
step-by-step reasoning, and iteratively refine results for further improved
quality. On this basis, we introduce StructChem, a simple yet effective
prompting strategy that offers the desired guidance and substantially boosts
the LLMs' chemical reasoning capability. Testing across four chemistry areas --
quantum chemistry, mechanics, physical chemistry, and kinetics -- StructChem
substantially enhances GPT-4's performance, with up to 30\% peak improvement.
Our analysis also underscores the unique difficulties of precise grounded
reasoning in science with LLMs, highlighting a need for more research in this
area. Code is available at \url{https://github.com/ozyyshr/StructChem}. | [
-0.0116085093,
0.0520473011,
0.0067482251,
0.0341678746,
-0.0294282455,
0.0162383839,
0.0278770886,
0.0079307081,
0.0540663339,
-0.0109976484,
-0.0081093861,
-0.0508044772,
-0.0265511051,
0.0352670737,
0.0110715562,
-0.0264512226,
0.0408867672,
-0.0764371976,
0.0091266809,
-0.0402091146,
0.0013855872,
-0.0087656155,
-0.0368380696,
-0.0286752097,
0.0435358733,
-0.041759152,
-0.0045017991,
-0.0158964992,
0.0244842991,
-0.0503401794,
-0.0144908801,
0.0678295717,
0.019896213,
0.0434909761,
0.0000021695,
-0.0571343601,
-0.0048398902,
0.0448585562,
-0.0351669788,
0.0017817378,
-0.0239916835,
-0.0225353781,
-0.0119652711,
0.0153171988,
-0.0306519736,
0.0231269635,
0.047696542,
0.0285283476,
0.0311203487,
0.022962369,
0.0125273056,
-0.0298115239,
0.0294165965,
0.0177176632,
0.0683587268,
-0.021134492,
0.0346446708,
0.0664833486,
0.0674201995,
0.0201804787,
0.008544608,
0.0378190801,
0.0222251732,
-0.0382895917,
0.0018216178,
0.0521644913,
-0.0412254706,
0.0163457599,
0.0150699178,
0.0503403023,
0.0288386624,
-0.0102791293,
-0.0322448984,
-0.0012331131,
-0.0433552749,
0.0185267404,
-0.0736277029,
0.0270067155,
-0.009375195,
-0.0038282941,
0.0124702211,
-0.013788959,
0.0386124887,
0.0180235468,
-0.0234060343,
0.1218176186,
0.0075205001,
-0.0235749613,
0.0086050713,
0.0235113259,
-0.0380673259,
-0.0177955367,
0.0032727104,
0.0303165913,
-0.0260892734,
0.0221445318,
0.0518650338,
0.0290277433,
0.0260725617,
-0.0313348733,
0.0012870097,
0.0423679538,
0.0222857483,
0.0547254272,
-0.0328047425,
0.0377748199,
-0.0386887044,
0.0142301908,
-0.021170916,
-0.0115074869,
-0.0965541005,
-0.0476438403,
-0.0152213788,
0.0282017458,
0.0072909859,
-0.0054134913,
-0.0427432135,
0.0092489636,
-0.0201823022,
0.0096491212,
-0.0091554224,
0.0098879281,
-0.0024780012,
-0.0159840807,
-0.0532741919,
0.0433425382,
-0.0181279574,
0.0134505099,
-0.0006992332,
-0.0209165346,
-0.0378036276,
-0.011998171,
-0.0477289855,
-0.0298156962,
0.01202372,
0.0748221055,
-0.0023247753,
0.0179997981,
-0.0122014843,
-0.0659047514,
0.0034155168,
-0.0984040648,
0.0622553043,
-0.0583196953,
0.0257922579,
0.0496740974,
0.0063147601,
-0.0472933501,
0.0087884497,
-0.0321542025,
-0.0189362131,
0.1013673097,
0.0108244317,
-0.0401898734,
0.0063858973,
0.0471628457,
-0.0156561565,
0.0313225612,
0.0078034457,
-0.0233436078,
-0.0316531323,
-0.023122469,
0.0201394334,
-0.0336447209,
-0.0076646185,
-0.0202958491,
-0.0192480739,
0.005344301,
-0.031921301,
0.0607604645,
-0.0242248066,
0.0080744047,
-0.0124889202,
0.0126130208,
0.0113597875,
0.0102083562,
0.0143314647,
0.0427323431,
-0.0190994088,
-0.0383745655,
0.0307365861,
-0.0062502376,
-0.0478168726,
0.0966476128,
-0.0623158403,
-0.0043131821,
0.0120390877,
0.013220896,
-0.0162152871,
-0.0341150984,
-0.0397559814,
0.0433027931,
-0.0059661274,
-0.00728493,
0.0681793541,
-0.0547544882,
-0.0257342085,
0.0421774872,
0.0050249328,
-0.0352289714,
-0.0089567564,
-0.0016070739,
0.0540509969,
0.0757879466,
0.0396801643,
-0.0729834363,
-0.0775530562,
0.0320028253,
0.0091917384,
0.0029393011,
0.0221843477,
0.0028119606,
-0.0253653228,
-0.0287916549,
-0.0110424189,
-0.0563561842,
0.0084098177,
-0.0160206649,
0.0019422225,
-0.0075613717,
-0.0037052229,
-0.0288192444,
0.006887231,
-0.002306652,
-0.0082384702,
-0.0325345807,
-0.0231195372,
-0.0215035733,
0.0319922492,
0.0068000266,
0.0134659447,
0.036416024,
0.0433056131,
-0.0540536679,
-0.0281116087,
-0.037101768,
-0.0172238145,
-0.0353194773,
0.0359790698,
-0.005470457,
-0.0231441669,
-0.0432679504,
-0.0613078997,
-0.0232613944,
0.0844178274,
0.0234906003,
-0.0196752679,
-0.0187352803,
-0.0053919409,
-0.0149567751,
0.0252886545,
-0.0282617398,
0.0657575577,
0.0165138822,
0.0041314014,
0.0225711614,
0.019980656,
0.0197325461,
-0.0183625836,
0.0129805133,
0.0278654154,
0.0448036753,
0.0073807985,
0.006589957,
-0.0297811441,
-0.0404544547,
-0.0029081549,
-0.0000175475,
-0.007446663,
-0.0052476958,
0.0292407274,
0.0059540519,
-0.0109435525,
0.0028871421,
0.0187435672,
-0.0121361976,
-0.0076365136,
0.0007713552,
-0.0038357982,
0.0400147736,
-0.008112791,
-0.0452002287,
-0.0176601578,
-0.0205227062,
-0.069283098,
0.0467195958,
0.0071980632,
0.0116348444,
-0.0322012641,
0.0068859812,
-0.0354120471,
0.0134430854,
-0.0116301104,
-0.0078066899,
0.033447139,
-0.0263667777,
0.0180291962,
0.0527129024,
-0.0249069706,
0.0223708823,
0.0856184065,
-0.0242281258,
-0.0262529645,
0.0226706266,
-0.0083421189,
0.0164848827,
0.0317423828,
0.0088322964,
-0.0351009518,
0.0583152436,
-0.0351193435,
0.0127942069,
-0.0204561688,
0.0536789484,
-0.0191769786,
0.0068610804,
-0.0256022271,
-0.0163651258,
0.025819879,
0.0212930627,
0.023459252,
-0.034579549,
0.1152909547,
-0.0194829423,
-0.009262763,
-0.0770127773,
0.0138067314,
-0.006475497,
0.0657884628,
-0.0317278616,
-0.0038429494,
0.0090282466,
0.0146173937,
-0.0293542109,
-0.0495474376,
0.0367932953,
0.0082223788,
0.0392837301,
-0.0902668312,
0.0209395047,
0.0056800703,
-0.0318886302,
-0.0060355449,
0.0476251617,
-0.0407596678,
0.0521197468,
-0.0217373446,
-0.0547745377,
-0.0171161797,
0.0203454774,
0.067540586,
-0.0328286588,
-0.0341131724,
-0.0127807669,
-0.0181131084,
0.0043048528,
0.007955417,
-0.0197055209,
0.0558892377,
-0.0733090043,
0.0754310563,
0.0564071834,
0.0239582397,
-0.0102759153,
-0.0341754332,
0.0150692025,
0.0205324162,
0.0374813303,
-0.0045062993,
-0.0042540655,
0.0076233866,
-0.0807536095,
-0.0391189307,
0.0944004208,
0.023568511,
-0.0056944108,
0.0094124535,
-0.0295019057,
-0.0011179863,
0.0082269954,
0.0666027293,
-0.0864334553,
-0.0255454108,
-0.0025641269,
-0.0021795779,
0.0082314555,
-0.0197798349,
-0.017671831,
-0.0550218783,
0.0561681055,
0.0450618193,
-0.0470089205,
-0.047164347,
-0.0536416136,
-0.0181170236,
0.010909332,
0.000885696,
0.0440268517,
0.0118853739,
-0.0320598409,
0.0285663586,
-0.0061514457,
-0.0341283232,
0.0801680535,
0.0044983402,
-0.0046155537,
0.049350284,
0.0093348147,
-0.0190193262,
-0.0500915386,
0.0591964014,
0.0093165329,
0.0157394968,
-0.0458074026,
-0.0326881558,
0.0652746484,
0.0014485869,
-0.0251415186,
0.0383339562,
-0.0425824225,
-0.0566739924,
-0.0162270982,
0.1591067016,
-0.0479644984,
-0.0505874269,
-0.0327442363,
0.0007715441,
-0.02711403,
0.0729083195,
-0.023769306,
0.0290740728,
-0.1015666574,
-0.0462679304,
-0.0273689888,
-0.0025707018,
0.0074246549,
0.0137200318,
0.0080077704,
0.0327968895,
0.0131780021,
0.0164248981,
0.078370586,
0.0056282375,
-0.0275397878,
0.0044072531,
0.0060754013,
-0.0139974719,
-0.0249988846,
0.0566637851,
-0.0306280851,
0.0380090736,
-0.0448430516,
-0.0336289182,
0.0099151889,
-0.0294508729,
-0.013689586,
0.0148617355,
-0.0323721655,
-0.0578030944,
-0.0150993448,
0.0143620055,
0.0303438175,
0.0287611876,
-0.0113679422,
-0.0497066788,
0.0134201655,
0.0170730669,
-0.0055250735,
-0.0120365843,
-0.0083758216,
-0.0125646275,
0.0106726075,
-0.0091989199,
-0.0184135381,
0.01750906,
-0.0168522727,
0.0428725258,
-0.013581939,
-0.0019413149,
0.0283951052,
0.0530600734,
0.0539624579,
0.0332900397,
-0.0057725809,
-0.0192079488,
0.0146881128,
-0.0002971523,
-0.0090454193,
-0.0232212953,
0.0066413856,
0.0369934849,
-0.0277646556,
-0.0084072072,
-0.0147254439,
-0.008887467,
0.027955655,
0.0176020861,
0.0329907015,
0.0251777805,
0.0001533021,
0.0973694697,
-0.0288433749,
-0.0128611885,
-9.234e-7,
-0.0200820882,
0.071180366,
-0.0367488265,
0.0431951843,
0.0438991785,
0.0310923755,
-0.0652603582,
-0.0113910874,
-0.0709352195,
-0.0993112847,
0.0000132721,
0.0082729245,
0.0169217158,
0.0057629002,
0.0086724889,
-0.0851468071,
-0.0118865613,
0.0049723298,
0.0299379341,
0.0428549685,
-0.0109652663,
0.0870116577,
0.0587536022,
0.000394819,
-0.0424972773,
0.049545873,
-0.0027426721,
0.043368984,
-0.0091868481,
-0.0345997065,
-0.0080447635,
-0.0361764804,
-0.0519912168,
0.0063690525,
-0.0109953731,
0.003038364,
-0.0897922069,
-0.0222701821,
-0.0040915059,
0.0372896679,
-0.0330812782,
-0.0249529202,
0.0355360471,
0.0764028057,
-0.0073806127,
-0.0598289408,
0.015705904,
-0.0018026887,
-0.0046128207,
-0.0422180071,
0.0200014114,
-6.095284613e-33,
-0.0171181709,
-0.0343574956,
0.0307300054,
0.0104858931,
-0.0107103586,
-0.04308635,
-0.0905240849,
-0.0022369437,
-0.0018299519,
0.0606637858,
0.0028080964,
0.0297301076,
0.0033810486,
-0.037509378,
0.0508968197,
-0.0142753543,
0.0161874704,
0.0605120175,
-0.0251347963,
0.0342037641,
0.0650908127,
0.0088140462,
0.0505541675,
-0.030036509,
0.0090778563,
0.036709141,
0.0160262436,
0.0213966537,
-0.1085538417,
0.0372090526,
-0.0313118249,
0.0324254446,
-0.004455321,
-0.0242728982,
-0.0134612964,
-0.0230773762,
-0.0381411426,
-0.0253163632,
0.0288520213,
-0.0373061448,
-0.0296289846,
-0.0198752619,
-0.004946236,
0.0454079919,
-0.0081515647,
-0.0564720482,
0.0124710435,
-0.0406048894,
0.0166585092,
-0.0200705361,
-0.0707697868,
0.0167650804,
-0.0137863802,
0.0274791438,
0.0006928279,
-0.0002298031,
-0.0052535124,
0.0097870976,
-0.0279452279,
0.0415004864,
0.026856672,
0.009047606,
0.0543516725,
0.0220464189,
0.0049130479,
0.0366028734,
0.000116459,
0.0223293658,
-0.0238262303,
0.0136533733,
0.0002557025,
0.0519590303,
0.0549345948,
0.0169112682,
0.0461223572,
0.041820012,
-0.1107689142,
-0.0176184066,
-0.0134521835,
0.0492808186,
0.0221691281,
0.0338872336,
-0.0173206162,
-0.0629667565,
-0.0222178642,
0.0691010207,
-0.0294495821,
-0.0330512822,
-0.0231695082,
-0.0643531308,
-0.0607050844,
-0.0120592229,
0.0181471538,
-0.0293613598,
-0.0272945967,
0.0251763444,
-0.0057833944,
0.0173176676,
0.0061235316,
0.0368381105,
-0.0584785938,
-0.0352501273,
-0.024731895,
-0.0359747,
0.0203639027,
0.0279293787,
0.0063409987,
0.0450090356,
-0.003421858,
-0.0226344969,
-0.0933296457,
-0.0040464099,
0.0301811211,
-0.0000559477,
-0.00706974,
0.0328264907,
0.0142177194,
0.0397102833,
-0.0132283811,
-0.0203502886,
0.0158935916,
0.0632152483,
0.0014777973,
0.0247480441,
-0.0164923221,
-0.0324116461,
-0.0557295159,
-0.0284576695,
0.0365794264,
-0.0698970035,
-0.016614981,
0.0236736741,
2.97e-7,
0.0678425059,
0.0483372249,
0.0148315243,
0.0036980971,
-0.0142654562,
0.0200311095,
-0.0481164232,
-0.0330203995,
-0.0120754065,
-0.0240701996,
0.0097204158,
0.0354683027,
0.0437220596,
0.0566954352,
-0.0358966924,
-0.00251393,
-0.0153871942,
-0.0524232164,
-0.0696601644,
-0.0260672029,
0.0142399026,
0.0289689116,
0.0265943296,
-0.020471096,
0.0357867926,
-0.0246966742,
0.0621285774,
0.0018868792,
0.0404158719,
0.057777755,
-0.0182335377,
-0.0379598998,
0.0145269288,
0.0677935556,
-0.0079452014,
-0.0309250634,
-0.037712004,
0.0388291813,
0.00780378,
-0.0004430602,
-0.0045103738,
-0.0556470528,
0.0264401846,
-0.0532285422,
0.0358181298,
-0.0347895138,
-0.0298145525,
0.0301591698,
-0.0132882632,
-0.0420590602,
0.0131205805,
-0.0014014273,
0.0085380822,
0.0234592836,
-0.03588368,
-0.0122402953,
0.0044902433,
-0.0493363738,
-0.0439788811,
0.0297071561,
-0.0458179675,
-0.0166463815,
-0.0211907998,
-0.019554235,
0.0316434726,
-0.0234832503,
-0.0175904371,
2.867215311e-34,
0.052753333,
0.0023404786,
0.023657782,
0.0155013362,
0.0420324244,
0.0068682842,
-0.0029897371,
0.0099208988,
0.0048934906,
-0.0711227953,
-0.0257585775
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09649v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09649v2 | ICXML: An In-Context Learning Framework for Zero-Shot Extreme Multi-Label Classification | 2023-11-16T08:01:17 | 2024-04-15T13:16:46 | Yaxin Zhu, Hamed Zamani | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | This paper focuses on the task of Extreme Multi-Label Classification (XMC)
whose goal is to predict multiple labels for each instance from an extremely
large label space. While existing research has primarily focused on fully
supervised XMC, real-world scenarios often lack supervision signals,
highlighting the importance of zero-shot settings. Given the large label space,
utilizing in-context learning approaches is not trivial. We address this issue
by introducing In-Context Extreme Multilabel Learning (ICXML), a two-stage
framework that cuts down the search space by generating a set of candidate
labels through incontext learning and then reranks them. Extensive experiments
suggest that ICXML advances the state of the art on two diverse public
benchmarks. | [
-0.0115848919,
-0.0226161089,
0.0265938733,
0.0069755623,
0.0460553057,
0.013354212,
0.0250111874,
0.0105970763,
-0.0171136931,
-0.0282967985,
-0.0444104895,
0.0325313918,
-0.0684862584,
-0.0008217947,
0.0266772993,
-0.0048045362,
-0.0102094393,
0.0240370929,
0.0402394496,
-0.0060721827,
0.0064221709,
0.003863204,
0.0120311668,
0.0328340158,
-0.0613367781,
-0.0041193324,
-0.0206224304,
0.0505354367,
0.0528304577,
-0.0730320588,
0.0383503921,
-0.0024703678,
0.0339697115,
0.004334101,
0.0000018522,
-0.0455184579,
-0.0311197117,
-0.0381071605,
-0.0171692949,
0.0070657735,
-0.027065428,
0.0034139543,
0.0337606259,
-0.0303419661,
-0.0153188603,
-0.0052670711,
0.0526600815,
0.0376910567,
0.0892364085,
0.0096973889,
-0.0459728092,
-0.050544288,
-0.0062771747,
-0.0094494447,
0.0503352545,
-0.0833617896,
0.0380749404,
-0.0320099257,
0.0214953739,
0.0316189565,
0.0174763892,
0.0123067973,
0.0333408564,
0.0254536215,
0.0191941299,
0.0581774674,
-0.0249923728,
-0.0066530108,
0.0181925241,
0.0871129334,
-0.0529837757,
-0.0068905377,
-0.0088760732,
-0.0391305126,
-0.0117899748,
-0.0945655927,
-0.0429677963,
-0.0020952094,
-0.0269050878,
0.0287430938,
-0.0323323011,
0.0642196313,
0.0123075806,
-0.0100417258,
-0.0195345823,
0.0330274664,
-0.0081112133,
-0.0186802335,
0.0239508767,
-0.0044291615,
-0.0414075777,
0.027566297,
-0.0184842255,
0.0097368322,
-0.0541710965,
0.0038883518,
-0.0234593358,
-0.0369952023,
0.0476171412,
-0.0487537943,
0.0622261055,
-0.0131150549,
-0.0141297178,
0.0613179989,
-0.0043239607,
-0.0154910553,
-0.0025396829,
0.0096372524,
-0.0479789041,
-0.0292138774,
-0.0659102947,
-0.013520794,
-0.0214750413,
0.020928394,
-0.0048219953,
0.0096961632,
-0.0382235721,
0.001350565,
-0.0080843112,
0.0006912651,
-0.0124259163,
0.0339748189,
-0.0234922264,
-0.0001627028,
0.0668713152,
0.0278567486,
-0.0383338183,
0.0135019589,
-0.0302728005,
0.0063619739,
-0.0029276793,
0.036477495,
-0.0145184984,
-0.0248633809,
0.0133497687,
0.0639411435,
-0.0429355949,
-0.0539317243,
-0.0323907807,
-0.0150650693,
-0.0467890762,
-0.0047990391,
-0.012821326,
-0.0199034475,
-0.0009892876,
-0.0142840436,
0.0248941313,
0.0026442541,
0.0334101245,
-0.0325787775,
-0.0181720871,
0.04795748,
0.0257224962,
0.0148818642,
0.0610807724,
0.0005019443,
-0.0144156087,
0.0689587966,
-0.0249693207,
0.0323407054,
0.0270585567,
0.0294994581,
0.0720213577,
0.055465553,
-0.0042502461,
0.0056617116,
-0.0249019675,
-0.010495794,
0.03055734,
0.0574182868,
-0.0031301761,
-0.037709929,
-0.0289169811,
-0.0335078277,
0.0328395329,
-0.0602937564,
-0.0336427242,
-0.0533361062,
0.0186208431,
-0.0026517299,
-0.035705179,
-0.0501539558,
0.0096968599,
0.0502223745,
0.0378788076,
-0.0159710906,
0.0491416454,
-0.0127297174,
-0.0333481394,
-0.0321944766,
-0.0029529759,
-0.0044750553,
-0.0964123383,
-0.0295115281,
0.0606354922,
-0.0102530839,
-0.01343372,
0.0399056375,
0.0568884164,
0.023597287,
-0.045996666,
-0.0310830027,
-0.062178798,
0.0122777913,
0.0034035342,
-0.0544008277,
-0.0072089257,
0.0071970201,
0.0592935607,
-0.0007305148,
-0.0221179798,
-0.0096850097,
0.0340791903,
0.002274889,
-0.0461113639,
0.0036511982,
0.031689506,
0.0125032449,
-0.0231209248,
0.0257386714,
-0.0065231514,
-0.0298459027,
0.0364191048,
0.0179826077,
-0.0367302038,
-0.0229096245,
0.0343208089,
0.0177934673,
-0.0117540481,
-0.0176990479,
-0.0317772329,
-0.025824314,
0.0480844788,
-0.044666335,
-0.0393661857,
-0.0510489643,
-0.0169332903,
-0.0323412307,
0.0563380495,
-0.058201544,
0.0062485938,
-0.0152050247,
-0.0623393022,
-0.0316856876,
-0.0489669219,
0.0259411205,
-0.019147845,
-0.0276849829,
-0.0411999226,
-0.0019128675,
0.0311861578,
-0.0446652323,
0.0690632239,
0.0452077575,
0.0176058616,
0.0241860542,
-0.0334100537,
0.0037828085,
-0.0005698166,
-0.0087849414,
-0.0014035547,
-0.0488407947,
0.0192677658,
-0.0486368462,
0.0232092068,
-0.0496499352,
-0.0212026183,
-0.0417198986,
-0.0047051669,
0.0023173741,
-0.029346928,
0.0013706067,
-0.0084157912,
0.0122945281,
-0.0370509773,
-0.0023470744,
-0.0172824506,
-0.0507567115,
0.0087188417,
0.0359433107,
0.0199117605,
-0.0167837963,
0.0423191339,
-0.0002610499,
-0.0054254611,
0.0660166666,
-0.0127246855,
-0.0491011851,
0.0066066431,
-0.0218796246,
-0.0302311201,
-0.0330833793,
0.0005196897,
0.0196820945,
0.0107609751,
-0.0193415582,
-0.0524833798,
0.0200235303,
0.0033981749,
0.0089564417,
0.0042218235,
0.0087277684,
-0.0080400947,
0.011464431,
-0.0093452195,
-0.0263241436,
-0.0376061946,
0.0445822738,
-0.0356436744,
0.0273084305,
-0.0110333962,
-0.0009274672,
-0.0224308241,
0.0100297472,
-0.0077616856,
-0.034017399,
-0.0928732231,
0.0291722566,
-0.0311855581,
0.0095430873,
-0.0107349241,
-0.0109208887,
0.0293069221,
0.03843835,
-0.0271663796,
0.0027380092,
-0.0156990811,
-0.0121734925,
0.0144003164,
-0.0064468114,
0.0374597125,
0.0272460785,
0.0123076411,
-0.0111871399,
0.0078149065,
-0.0100413933,
0.0051169139,
-0.0282674879,
0.0101453047,
0.0180613771,
-0.0186793432,
-0.0635632128,
-0.0323238485,
-0.0544101782,
0.0355443172,
0.0235026851,
-0.0653456077,
0.0131775802,
-0.0967796445,
-0.034823209,
0.0021098696,
0.0708658695,
-0.0083194785,
-0.0440015532,
0.0082644559,
0.077033475,
0.043432653,
-0.0588699318,
-0.0526464432,
-0.0552780032,
0.0005177556,
0.0432887897,
0.0334945172,
0.0093103824,
0.0005807785,
0.0284088999,
0.0119774528,
0.0267174896,
0.0092498437,
0.0110493405,
0.0244635399,
-0.0003596735,
0.0019259943,
0.0469206944,
0.0593371987,
-0.0558917187,
-0.0002971287,
0.0000541314,
0.0405264944,
0.0434194356,
-0.0052928464,
-0.0395795964,
-0.0427124761,
-0.0276711155,
0.0409833975,
0.0098147281,
-0.0498101711,
0.0010226759,
-0.0546402559,
0.0310168155,
-0.0036583438,
-0.0890901312,
0.0488083139,
-0.02438551,
0.0144481938,
-0.0016145125,
-0.0431572162,
-0.006669119,
0.0332573242,
-0.0349213481,
0.0225071441,
0.0016536154,
-0.0391772836,
0.0839874297,
0.0035861495,
0.0104536209,
-0.024244763,
0.0286653414,
-0.0144634349,
-0.0038982169,
0.0486373752,
-0.0389968082,
0.0244833305,
-0.0132231312,
0.0573852286,
-0.0424863473,
-0.0269392673,
0.0286197364,
0.030419711,
-0.0537578277,
-0.0092740282,
0.0276458971,
0.0858418643,
-0.0119315516,
-0.002899671,
-0.0418277346,
-0.067870222,
0.0401926488,
0.0225640051,
0.0041912501,
-0.0806764439,
-0.0091624847,
-0.0181658659,
0.0185000096,
-0.0103134774,
0.0390521958,
0.0332070068,
-0.0307296589,
-0.0637587905,
-0.030665148,
0.0087299971,
0.0335461348,
0.069642961,
-0.0335282721,
-0.0238029882,
-0.0903777778,
-0.0063081938,
-0.003729763,
-0.0216062497,
-0.009349836,
0.0322155133,
0.0073230537,
0.0147920502,
0.0987452865,
-0.0150730582,
-0.0423592553,
0.0387289114,
0.001662601,
-0.0691706091,
-0.0010281927,
0.0178288799,
0.0128254499,
0.0388730653,
0.0145513574,
-0.0374480374,
0.0749739781,
0.0956781432,
0.0385085978,
0.0499628894,
0.045029562,
-0.0168095101,
-0.0132053224,
0.0330621898,
-0.0487976521,
0.0821188465,
0.0371451862,
-0.0127130337,
-0.0451328903,
-0.0331047662,
-0.0012770171,
-0.0295581948,
0.0727195442,
-0.0536361523,
-0.0130722476,
0.0070002172,
0.0236249752,
0.0109044826,
-0.0416504107,
-0.0176160354,
0.0262381211,
0.0545222908,
-0.0024698684,
-0.0156166367,
0.0125326077,
0.0498702563,
0.0452471748,
0.0156303998,
-0.0092563527,
0.0103814648,
0.0101933982,
0.0089755366,
0.0024108079,
-0.0138504086,
0.0028050439,
0.0264091119,
0.0122145051,
-0.0135856681,
0.0402513482,
0.0686327145,
0.0373913459,
-0.0498819128,
0.0055090664,
-0.0208790358,
0.0471648462,
-0.0568259284,
-0.0084189354,
0.0635825023,
0.0575896651,
0.0308908354,
0.0080673518,
-0.0351833776,
-0.0395912975,
0.0260310378,
-0.0234211627,
-0.0584175922,
-0.0147871701,
0.0235605054,
0.0046744077,
0.0609967783,
0.0587889813,
0.040512573,
0.016689077,
-0.0075441212,
0.0424378589,
-0.0471515656,
0.0597003475,
0.0291032549,
0.0024679173,
0.0652169734,
-0.0042252275,
0.0010470261,
0.0080497637,
0.059124954,
-0.0441472903,
-0.0446446501,
0.0373664536,
0.0205874853,
0.0302813556,
0.0227574538,
-0.0201209653,
0.0176496599,
-0.0489718355,
0.0727335811,
0.0007932854,
-0.0007719596,
-6.035144117e-33,
0.0254659075,
-0.0321552828,
-0.0430195145,
-0.0372898765,
0.0010857816,
-0.0064603086,
-0.0155103346,
-0.0029806208,
0.0305052269,
0.0073664351,
-0.0170639232,
-0.0135437278,
0.0200619344,
0.0454468988,
0.0317148939,
0.0012413358,
0.0268625766,
-0.0264757052,
0.0315529816,
0.0477977693,
0.0505597629,
0.0418990254,
0.0385156982,
-0.0869423896,
-0.0305194575,
-0.0249401834,
-0.0254212338,
0.0186120067,
0.024570575,
0.0352218188,
-0.0057229833,
0.0507186092,
0.0401100367,
-0.0800624862,
0.0002084819,
-0.0158138406,
-0.0299275499,
-0.0269005429,
-0.090915978,
-0.0121859964,
0.0090175075,
0.0054999813,
-0.0038018832,
0.0181448087,
0.0195244066,
-0.0304763056,
0.0645465329,
-0.0381024256,
-0.027562622,
-0.0681946203,
0.0018088173,
0.0283231847,
-0.0200392548,
0.0269663054,
-0.0032891652,
0.0255722497,
0.0098737916,
0.0275357608,
-0.0579818338,
0.0102051077,
-0.0670755282,
-0.0323433429,
0.011787015,
0.052244734,
-0.0110546825,
0.0674536973,
0.0519482754,
0.0037704303,
0.0286282916,
-0.0217865873,
0.0128742112,
0.038381204,
-0.0027555963,
0.0707584769,
0.0468966253,
0.000577678,
-0.0494688787,
-0.0005172535,
-0.0261308141,
-0.0459631532,
0.0315954164,
0.0330511369,
-0.0070175063,
-0.007736071,
-0.0003743821,
0.0027076695,
-0.0369285457,
0.0157264229,
0.0398286059,
0.0434382111,
-0.0091919266,
0.0400114469,
0.0335437953,
-0.0426489599,
-0.054575637,
0.0292502474,
-0.0162645131,
0.0525086597,
0.0101216407,
-0.017554475,
-0.0017941841,
-0.0382952131,
0.0337506309,
0.0133161657,
0.0235471148,
-0.0493159294,
0.0624596365,
0.0109493472,
-0.0401977077,
-0.0132902348,
0.0073322332,
-0.0149983782,
0.0084185274,
0.0150353471,
0.0061080465,
-0.0196778532,
-0.0131485797,
0.0818326026,
0.0429839976,
-0.0142060909,
0.0178040043,
-0.0523011237,
0.0054199868,
0.005493449,
-0.0342232101,
0.0274960585,
0.008150042,
-0.0571481287,
0.0488471277,
-0.0692981556,
-0.0047711986,
0.0235628765,
2.548e-7,
0.0295256227,
0.0338781886,
-0.0395461209,
-0.063311249,
0.0382057652,
0.0677622482,
-0.0494650044,
0.0479223058,
-0.0143295797,
-0.0376052745,
0.0280369539,
0.0058807814,
0.013181637,
0.0336979143,
-0.0744777098,
0.0174655952,
-0.0512596704,
0.024834374,
-0.0896095634,
0.0293055996,
0.0768010318,
0.0902520269,
0.0320680216,
-0.0256423,
0.0149979871,
-0.0508388132,
0.0429728217,
0.0235253982,
0.0687941313,
-0.0180746205,
-0.0221641883,
-0.0085797179,
-0.0062908521,
0.0307783596,
-0.0059927129,
-0.0164598022,
0.0377884693,
0.0588570237,
-0.043683026,
-0.0445207693,
0.0523054376,
0.0567619428,
-0.0181351155,
-0.0281529464,
0.0817639455,
-0.1225180998,
-0.0096916081,
-0.0048414124,
-0.0570071973,
-0.000082323,
0.0387204997,
-0.007171866,
0.0241510533,
0.0393741913,
-0.0249792654,
0.009670916,
-0.0207126811,
-0.0774256662,
-0.0108394008,
0.0209519379,
-0.05062389,
-0.0067670769,
0.0136317722,
0.0347410925,
0.0135647347,
-0.0335957818,
-0.0142330565,
1.907692104e-34,
-0.0029102073,
-0.0479760803,
0.0078421375,
-0.0105033265,
-0.0612892397,
-0.0341366045,
-0.0788475275,
0.0063454341,
-0.0049552997,
-0.0077523529,
0.0260670446
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09648v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09648v2 | Event Causality Is Key to Computational Story Understanding | 2023-11-16T07:59:12 | 2024-04-02T02:31:59 | Yidan Sun, Qin Chao, Boyang Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | Cognitive science and symbolic AI research suggest that event causality
provides vital information for story understanding. However, machine learning
systems for story understanding rarely employ event causality, partially due to
the lack of methods that reliably identify open-world causal event relations.
Leveraging recent progress in large language models, we present the first
method for event causality identification that leads to material improvements
in computational story understanding. Our technique sets a new state of the art
on the COPES dataset (Wang et al., 2023) for causal event relation
identification. Further, in the downstream story quality evaluation task, the
identified causal relations lead to 3.6-16.6% relative improvement on
correlation with human ratings. In the multimodal story video-text alignment
task, we attain 4.1-10.9% increase on Clip Accuracy and 4.2-13.5% increase on
Sentence IoU. The findings indicate substantial untapped potential for event
causality in computational story understanding. The codebase is at
https://github.com/insundaycathy/Event-Causality-Extraction. | [
0.0088420128,
0.0642445385,
-0.0416559353,
0.0456555039,
-0.0331351422,
0.0176067334,
0.0031491553,
0.0061490647,
0.0081824083,
-0.0114840921,
0.0468235165,
-0.0043589082,
0.0116531532,
0.1177939326,
-0.0154160727,
-0.0304248966,
0.0366535783,
0.0329126008,
0.0486679897,
0.0535977408,
0.0079388572,
0.038094826,
-0.0191828683,
0.0487691872,
-0.0369502194,
-0.0190875009,
-0.0001585671,
0.0150579242,
0.0391569436,
-0.0573864393,
-0.0229291283,
0.0147555778,
0.0539949276,
0.013107338,
0.0000020512,
-0.060765326,
-0.0107923113,
-0.0417792387,
0.0162387863,
-0.0106413281,
-0.0355939865,
-0.0271282978,
0.0357843079,
-0.022122208,
-0.025716275,
0.0188991688,
0.0355205201,
0.0793698207,
0.00796213,
0.0753807425,
-0.0347853415,
-0.040950954,
-0.0143000372,
0.0246784054,
0.0091761397,
-0.0208917074,
-0.0044678687,
0.0170849785,
-0.0000278343,
-0.0680662543,
-0.0423071422,
0.0140462201,
0.0298867207,
-0.0030504337,
0.0095135542,
0.0588111281,
-0.0166151132,
-0.0251693577,
0.0002066357,
0.0976557061,
0.0320648141,
-0.0304484349,
-0.0103625515,
-0.000511928,
-0.0070531946,
0.0367671885,
-0.0854975507,
0.0300163105,
-0.021927435,
0.0178233348,
0.0152953686,
0.0178867113,
0.0245157313,
0.0029453232,
0.0396000482,
0.0648890138,
0.0305513609,
-0.0037753463,
-0.0554153174,
0.0105255926,
-0.0228832141,
-0.0487739742,
0.0182010476,
0.0271103699,
-0.0284750555,
0.0140194409,
-0.0295883827,
0.0517231971,
-0.0433914103,
-0.0902449489,
0.0205709524,
0.0367880501,
-0.0024937331,
0.0501043499,
-0.0176984798,
0.0565142073,
0.001951774,
0.0117631024,
-0.0136756655,
0.0373999849,
-0.0283388309,
0.0494818389,
0.0084296856,
-0.0104051335,
-0.0268690586,
-0.0280795246,
0.0044903583,
0.012284725,
0.0208927486,
0.0058069248,
-0.0319725946,
0.0115727568,
-0.007774415,
-0.0017180707,
-0.0253568366,
0.0224807672,
-0.0905281156,
0.0231068023,
-0.04135729,
-0.0072387154,
-0.0362558961,
-0.0034488922,
0.0355579294,
-0.0190845281,
-0.0031928676,
0.0188341662,
-0.0167306308,
-0.0271317642,
-0.0531822443,
-0.0306821447,
-0.002826801,
-0.0348727293,
-0.0346724801,
-0.0176969152,
0.0317872055,
0.0276493151,
0.0005685792,
-0.0588616133,
0.0101697454,
-0.0107031148,
-0.0618354492,
0.0224354267,
0.0003697751,
0.0201349854,
0.0013283791,
0.0108803948,
0.0110268695,
0.0218543131,
0.0838153139,
0.0398854129,
0.0744415,
0.0369321369,
0.0095906127,
0.0048009679,
0.0071963575,
-0.0004024266,
-0.0314817801,
-0.0096725058,
0.0102658309,
0.0558306538,
0.0173949022,
-0.0053911032,
-0.0183384754,
0.0051162448,
0.1010573953,
0.0130201466,
-0.0236845128,
-0.0296937507,
0.0672676563,
-0.011868435,
-0.0098622916,
0.0304025635,
-0.0208075549,
0.0287585184,
0.0166679565,
-0.0205721762,
0.0104963891,
-0.0055568367,
-0.0151604414,
-0.0149295144,
-0.0164534077,
0.0003909055,
-0.0223507006,
-0.0091050565,
0.0100524304,
0.0035914558,
-0.0539265275,
-0.0056343558,
0.0310906526,
-0.0660779476,
0.0622721054,
0.0212279297,
0.0589302033,
0.0689198226,
0.0654995218,
-0.0213945303,
-0.0299908351,
-0.0206583478,
0.0166810844,
-0.0085953921,
0.0020993135,
-0.0270383377,
0.0219381601,
-0.0424017049,
0.0036555303,
-0.0148958918,
0.0093894731,
-0.00297133,
-0.0230648592,
-0.0011606835,
-0.0465416424,
-0.0086679794,
-0.0236440282,
0.056971129,
-0.0165986996,
-0.0183091275,
-0.0205992088,
0.0389505476,
0.0062339827,
0.0006662103,
-0.0138948048,
-0.0271177664,
0.0135976234,
-0.0501003973,
-0.0300816856,
0.112408258,
-0.0376931578,
-0.0705347285,
0.002787028,
-0.0578731224,
-0.0576555617,
0.0363881066,
-0.0139680011,
-0.044535283,
0.0652703792,
-0.0167381503,
0.0012406625,
-0.001941501,
0.0096670799,
0.0088240318,
-0.0002296365,
-0.0180493128,
0.0694108531,
0.0103193605,
0.0080723101,
-0.0277239252,
0.022454109,
0.0115876636,
0.000096185,
0.0163622927,
0.0130057503,
0.0066453987,
-0.038752649,
0.0391053371,
-0.0701774433,
-0.035776604,
0.0092147198,
-0.0635695904,
0.0558480397,
-0.0059297197,
0.0131006092,
0.0317987613,
-0.0015063784,
-0.0313502699,
-0.0056777862,
0.00553041,
-0.0449512266,
-0.0404084176,
-0.0200506542,
0.0210477095,
0.0383309014,
-0.0119908825,
-0.0560807101,
0.0223857667,
-0.0703415573,
0.1011018977,
0.0484377481,
-0.0289160721,
-0.0149292303,
0.0294436049,
0.0111924922,
0.0049734451,
-0.0323374942,
-0.017994253,
-0.0015470453,
0.0227544997,
0.043959491,
0.0624877177,
-0.0009519504,
0.0462736674,
0.0298067406,
-0.0633455962,
-0.02694452,
0.0191401392,
-0.0172842685,
0.0311274156,
-0.0333939306,
-0.0610885359,
-0.0104083866,
0.0594235733,
0.0231132042,
0.0156754684,
-0.0624397397,
-0.0138609819,
-0.0053216722,
-0.0071466416,
-0.0287469588,
-0.0444908105,
-0.0200463422,
0.0487426221,
-0.0478758328,
-0.0454742163,
0.0533617511,
-0.0353304073,
0.0108343763,
-0.0012587545,
-0.0051331674,
-0.0630892441,
0.0973752365,
0.0168215875,
0.0227219611,
-0.0090263728,
-0.0259203818,
-0.0527845919,
0.018182097,
0.0414816625,
0.0242189001,
-0.0035200748,
-0.0465283953,
0.0047205258,
0.0217925943,
-0.0197785106,
-0.049157396,
-0.062810041,
0.0010534283,
-0.0274858978,
-0.0070204469,
0.0063023437,
-0.04748464,
0.0082213692,
0.0203584842,
0.01000679,
-0.0283182561,
0.0096782781,
-0.0028496401,
0.0482970886,
0.0740946829,
-0.030526787,
0.0041732397,
-0.045433756,
0.0310630109,
0.0194599051,
0.0300414134,
-0.0026043863,
-0.0018536275,
0.0248942114,
-0.002824554,
-0.0490020439,
-0.0108711859,
0.0066600558,
0.0459578894,
-0.0573745109,
-0.0008026591,
0.1223146617,
0.0452683978,
-0.0480361208,
0.0192684438,
0.0324758217,
-0.0236568302,
0.0538407974,
-0.0086021982,
-0.0612944067,
-0.0461126938,
0.0060888724,
-0.0278649107,
-0.0076864976,
-0.0741170421,
-0.0358745195,
-0.0646170825,
0.0295109078,
-0.0238114242,
-0.0105631808,
-0.0388437323,
-0.0307878014,
0.0134130782,
-0.0090292208,
-0.0402837805,
-0.0028229959,
-0.0057876161,
0.012610754,
-0.0345554501,
-0.0214774068,
-0.0277148392,
0.0121845314,
-0.0625615194,
0.0293117408,
0.0330743603,
0.0592935272,
-0.0058305818,
0.0184593126,
-0.0192726087,
0.021183433,
-0.0003453436,
0.0062501281,
0.0644542575,
-0.0559821427,
0.0053409943,
-0.0104022371,
0.0576486625,
0.0235102214,
-0.0701455697,
0.0121683078,
0.0692107901,
-0.0152271353,
-0.0378166139,
-0.0168118384,
0.0362068787,
0.0036309087,
0.0973058417,
0.0223803427,
-0.0362649523,
-0.0353353545,
0.0208994076,
0.0032618768,
-0.0473296978,
-0.0253915638,
-0.0239989348,
0.0024680123,
-0.0063068215,
-0.0644137785,
-0.0637742728,
0.0123944692,
0.0070073926,
0.0139696077,
-0.0009450907,
-0.0177711677,
0.0078525655,
-0.0800335482,
0.0600647256,
-0.0167011768,
0.0117996186,
0.0153435124,
0.0478992052,
-0.0227063484,
-0.0198150948,
-0.0186276939,
0.0503308438,
-0.0506112576,
-0.0212560408,
-0.0310099386,
-0.0104446411,
0.0109510776,
0.0801917911,
0.0099446597,
-0.0276397672,
-0.027747836,
-0.0065589859,
-0.0361123793,
0.0397614725,
-0.0113588544,
-0.0053709922,
-0.0019632836,
0.0257586874,
-0.0195569545,
0.0168978609,
-0.01307943,
0.0539614484,
-0.0174143724,
-0.0004216215,
0.0172254853,
-0.0290350039,
0.0581709854,
-0.0328894146,
-0.0331946537,
-0.0975060686,
-0.0110265259,
-0.0173505824,
-0.0000461164,
-0.0416860059,
0.0270875636,
-0.0071681147,
0.0209957529,
-0.067145735,
-0.0087186843,
-0.0622878298,
-0.0215101577,
-0.0451432094,
-0.0005672315,
0.0322103798,
-0.0090155397,
-0.0039921319,
-0.001587795,
-0.013061326,
0.0241310205,
-0.0013601269,
0.032404311,
-0.0049251067,
0.0643953457,
0.0202797279,
0.023195494,
-0.0043668137,
-0.014606799,
-0.0654150546,
0.0311089922,
0.0063097971,
-0.0129692452,
0.0810370371,
-0.04676475,
0.0395858102,
-0.0019931067,
0.0257232115,
0.0243864898,
0.0388313942,
0.0007500862,
-0.0185128674,
-0.0075918175,
-0.0037132883,
-0.0285514593,
0.0543723628,
0.0517525859,
-0.0382545665,
0.0732664987,
-0.0134944823,
-0.0254046321,
0.0013788859,
-0.037305668,
0.0345942155,
0.0461994261,
-0.0030512942,
-0.0062344694,
-0.0863703266,
-0.0209195297,
0.0181866586,
-0.0156432576,
0.0178636536,
-0.0182299949,
0.0071701263,
0.0136661092,
0.0010168019,
-0.0011286549,
-0.0190716293,
-0.0114810886,
-0.0487497188,
-0.0150723048,
-0.0212585181,
-6.119084332e-33,
-0.0116943372,
-0.0148038808,
-0.0159336999,
0.0444867052,
-0.0231994223,
0.0471773669,
-0.0607625283,
-0.0230195019,
0.0065967124,
0.0605168268,
0.0254016928,
0.0337773971,
0.0091359224,
-0.0171913486,
-0.0055638626,
-0.0020087224,
0.0434789509,
0.0077921967,
-0.0472968221,
0.0102752894,
0.066768229,
0.0429588296,
0.0396812782,
-0.0563183613,
0.0080989432,
-0.0220773499,
-0.0212466735,
0.0043151393,
0.0647781864,
0.0345360301,
-0.0027466547,
-0.0033314163,
0.0482817888,
-0.029904021,
0.0082079433,
0.0200914163,
-0.0610576048,
-0.0163315646,
0.0643792078,
0.0007377095,
-0.0591623671,
-0.0387342982,
0.0237418804,
0.0067305602,
0.0046698065,
-0.022849353,
0.0659334213,
-0.004325408,
0.036823824,
-0.0415825136,
-0.092284359,
0.022090964,
-0.0560674481,
-0.0345883705,
-0.0113335876,
0.0263463911,
0.0304758307,
0.0207503568,
-0.0155648487,
0.022128813,
-0.0795280635,
0.0173563901,
0.0171462763,
-0.0054744296,
-0.0342023484,
0.0983416438,
-0.0094030807,
-0.0234101173,
-0.0757111982,
0.0218207613,
0.0065413993,
0.0187070668,
0.0562976375,
0.060322471,
0.0225341097,
-0.0130689954,
-0.093654722,
0.0678303018,
0.029185662,
-0.001153881,
0.019835392,
0.001740068,
-0.030692827,
0.0142585728,
-0.0452965274,
-0.019029133,
-0.0307372436,
-0.0120875277,
0.0265560448,
-0.038007874,
0.0109303053,
0.0034808619,
0.0448812358,
-0.0418456942,
0.0335870273,
0.0300381985,
-0.0589519441,
0.031218078,
0.0150544811,
0.0142059596,
-0.0408846252,
0.0088415034,
0.0219930969,
0.0180803444,
0.0818402022,
-0.0033686063,
0.0457377918,
0.0082620941,
0.0003683155,
-0.0064533935,
-0.0219750106,
-0.0334006138,
-0.019480709,
-0.0260268524,
0.0354323238,
0.0383154228,
-0.0277720354,
0.0276787784,
0.0111553427,
0.0661930442,
-0.0164292436,
-0.069528535,
-0.0199436899,
0.0156611521,
-0.0429294296,
-0.0035977392,
-0.013935362,
0.0243728049,
-0.0142265512,
-0.0976112857,
-0.0216747429,
0.0078340583,
2.731e-7,
0.0236439276,
0.0609734729,
0.0142762121,
0.0304656606,
0.0014814233,
0.0261428412,
0.0123642813,
0.0256057288,
-0.0064401263,
-0.0106006814,
0.0348021053,
0.0415220186,
0.0564425327,
0.0192485061,
-0.0499477461,
-0.0128085176,
-0.0551885702,
-0.0267620981,
-0.0810244828,
0.0007532377,
0.0870257095,
0.0558184199,
0.0654269829,
-0.0001315551,
0.022986887,
-0.0421037525,
0.0593211316,
-0.0192221906,
-0.0294549558,
0.0271678139,
-0.0673251003,
-0.0262609217,
-0.0552898198,
-0.0008969438,
-0.0262151975,
0.0304290056,
0.0233693849,
0.0462800302,
-0.0397189371,
-0.0014137874,
-0.0228265282,
-0.0043577966,
-0.0165785477,
-0.0442225039,
0.0862187967,
-0.0249055251,
-0.0470951907,
0.0020400172,
-0.0129792215,
0.0286096577,
-0.0011044869,
0.0194672216,
-0.0001242983,
0.0463497825,
0.0006747997,
-0.0030978622,
-0.0193940625,
-0.1029846221,
-0.0465941355,
0.030803578,
0.0079219555,
-0.0049932254,
-0.0051082806,
-0.0469219349,
0.0347563103,
-0.0605073124,
0.0047118724,
2.567248438e-34,
0.0031204685,
0.0091331368,
-0.0086041689,
0.0033480322,
0.0535263754,
-0.0256262887,
-0.0405242406,
-0.0044079269,
0.0368712172,
-0.0356229208,
-0.012226156
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09641v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09641v2 | RLHFPoison: Reward Poisoning Attack for Reinforcement Learning with Human Feedback in Large Language Models | 2023-11-16T07:48:45 | 2024-06-19T22:40:07 | Jiongxiao Wang, Junlin Wu, Muhao Chen, Yevgeniy Vorobeychik, Chaowei Xiao | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.HC | Reinforcement Learning with Human Feedback (RLHF) is a methodology designed
to align Large Language Models (LLMs) with human preferences, playing an
important role in LLMs alignment. Despite its advantages, RLHF relies on human
annotators to rank the text, which can introduce potential security
vulnerabilities if any adversarial annotator (i.e., attackers) manipulates the
ranking score by up-ranking any malicious text to steer the LLM adversarially.
To assess the red-teaming of RLHF against human preference data poisoning, we
propose RankPoison, a poisoning attack method on candidates' selection of
preference rank flipping to reach certain malicious behaviors (e.g., generating
longer sequences, which can increase the computational cost). With poisoned
dataset generated by RankPoison, we can perform poisoning attacks on LLMs to
generate longer tokens without hurting the original safety alignment
performance. Moreover, applying RankPoison, we also successfully implement a
backdoor attack where LLMs can generate longer answers under questions with the
trigger word. Our findings highlight critical security challenges in RLHF,
underscoring the necessity for more robust alignment methods for LLMs. | [
0.0483015999,
0.0822186247,
-0.002746975,
0.0525794178,
-0.0355662294,
-0.0115954047,
-0.0292395856,
-0.0193305798,
0.0116923992,
-0.0151524469,
-0.0231882259,
-0.0053538359,
0.0190095119,
0.0107589206,
0.0594331548,
-0.0174609013,
0.0665398836,
-0.031374909,
-0.0142622367,
-0.0239644628,
0.0066639665,
-0.0194919109,
0.0114487568,
0.0188969783,
0.0452998318,
-0.0177415721,
-0.0322815366,
0.006056671,
0.0585846491,
-0.0311775394,
-0.0075275945,
0.0394778512,
-0.0224527232,
0.0979765281,
0.0000018993,
-0.0381065607,
-0.0351706296,
0.0323147289,
-0.010711344,
0.0125615317,
-0.0108575318,
0.0202179588,
-0.0400808752,
0.0447579734,
-0.0260961261,
0.0377052426,
0.0228772666,
0.0378030501,
0.070160903,
0.092757687,
0.0162294321,
0.0044286582,
0.0253006797,
-0.0632358119,
0.03314735,
-0.041358646,
0.0238003843,
-0.0547768511,
-0.0032771102,
0.0478486866,
-0.0151959071,
-0.0048639681,
0.0146701699,
-0.0033795035,
-0.040516369,
0.0131456861,
-0.026459178,
-0.0025504837,
0.0010875637,
0.0674653947,
-0.0508151315,
0.0109714484,
0.0067109512,
0.0222966541,
0.0326156691,
-0.0069326782,
0.0260506608,
0.0269636977,
-0.0098642865,
-0.0065510813,
0.0365656428,
-0.041125007,
0.0545218848,
0.0104266349,
0.0004964696,
0.0888701677,
0.0235525128,
-0.0445367061,
0.0036823656,
-0.0377713889,
-0.0054498911,
-0.0580895282,
-0.0107701151,
-0.0097482176,
-0.046750363,
0.0300668143,
-0.0671821013,
-0.0364484377,
0.0444769934,
-0.0549014993,
0.0120916534,
0.030057231,
0.0196393952,
0.0095109325,
-0.0022540675,
0.0487146936,
-0.0284177717,
0.0787499174,
-0.0231478158,
0.0283570718,
0.035188213,
-0.0172991585,
0.0296555702,
0.0230676122,
-0.0227942541,
0.0174185038,
-0.0707547069,
0.0367365144,
-0.0356202796,
0.0762868896,
-0.0189538673,
0.0225195102,
-0.0301174913,
0.0298314095,
-0.0215645861,
0.0030027106,
-0.0101055168,
-0.0293284431,
0.010770319,
-0.0186375733,
-0.0329628997,
0.0025520753,
-0.0567071289,
-0.0395684727,
-0.00877597,
0.1144919842,
0.0096116066,
-0.0074255113,
0.0254288148,
-0.0593159087,
-0.0326058492,
-0.0405095853,
-0.0172909163,
-0.0547123887,
-0.0013365805,
-0.0237981565,
-0.030092543,
-0.0423423499,
0.0170357693,
0.0419915505,
-0.0454921611,
0.0795938522,
0.0264392793,
-0.0335705243,
-0.0125396345,
0.008047279,
-0.0307205617,
0.0399335362,
0.0100393044,
0.0908087119,
0.0411396064,
-0.0092928298,
0.0076357811,
0.044829905,
0.0325351395,
0.0098792603,
-0.0021927317,
0.0337074511,
0.048131343,
0.0222510435,
-0.0020470764,
0.0610101186,
-0.0022901287,
-0.0750634745,
0.093517147,
0.0380062461,
-0.0264642294,
-0.0028845735,
-0.0179941785,
-0.0018262394,
-0.0349384621,
0.0253637917,
-0.0837112889,
0.0031066982,
-0.0715810433,
-0.0197646022,
0.0424632542,
0.0194421522,
0.0045383358,
-0.0222470481,
0.0046859109,
-0.0069052987,
0.0275355205,
0.0187448952,
0.0024095997,
0.0273504648,
-0.0238647088,
-0.0186764449,
0.0154204173,
-0.0392241739,
-0.0027315577,
-0.0361622237,
-0.0130659034,
0.0494102053,
0.0702598393,
-0.0512053892,
0.0051268497,
-0.0409249961,
-0.0498824865,
0.0243791472,
0.0375212692,
0.0010270344,
-0.0166450813,
0.0066251187,
-0.0249085296,
0.0064842328,
-0.0057281554,
0.0216363203,
0.0217259005,
-0.010279635,
-0.0331839509,
0.0166694727,
-0.0509247929,
0.0259437487,
0.0177501682,
-0.043753989,
0.0273513328,
0.0368864834,
0.0566692762,
0.0060036527,
-0.006730577,
0.0381667353,
0.0441719405,
0.0145784616,
-0.0006201862,
-0.0452144518,
0.0027773581,
-0.0195810907,
0.0363300517,
-0.0269744415,
-0.0454921462,
0.0874380991,
-0.0560684241,
-0.0016416624,
0.0125004249,
-0.018768834,
-0.006951727,
0.0166133847,
0.0035188845,
0.0016149975,
0.0260069836,
-0.0564940348,
0.0545855388,
-0.028195966,
0.0295911096,
-0.0334404074,
-0.0130097698,
-0.0136677995,
-0.0603827685,
-0.0454839319,
0.0193310659,
-0.0252114907,
0.0075704162,
0.0278148446,
-0.009258247,
-0.023715971,
-0.0139941396,
-0.0152312787,
-0.0081309425,
-0.0101394476,
0.0319932178,
0.0099925911,
-0.0083484445,
0.0066395542,
-0.0272691213,
-0.0466334447,
-0.0556341447,
-0.0099313762,
0.0400219336,
0.0318210684,
-0.0081253471,
-0.0093303192,
-0.0281786639,
-0.0228979979,
-0.0174550153,
0.0407294072,
-0.000687436,
0.0170116238,
-0.0328807682,
0.0020857647,
-0.0295956079,
0.0214027967,
-0.0168791767,
-0.0470233038,
0.0368301123,
0.030704869,
0.0032710768,
0.1034815088,
0.0532681979,
0.0588939562,
0.0683278888,
0.0543017946,
-0.0377795957,
-0.0062932782,
-0.0152504984,
-0.0319764614,
-0.0444608256,
0.0036052547,
0.0102718305,
0.0315840654,
0.0127836065,
-0.0206141844,
-0.0259269122,
0.0288178399,
0.009641977,
-0.0420790166,
-0.0298510548,
-0.0073415991,
-0.0455973595,
-0.0139511088,
-0.0188161209,
-0.063351579,
0.0875915065,
-0.0175797045,
0.0427995659,
-0.050726749,
-0.0091402782,
0.0167455375,
0.0122723905,
0.0033137354,
0.0278232042,
-0.0034434153,
-0.0013560989,
-0.0727271438,
-0.0250102729,
0.0501866974,
-0.0591972955,
0.0145357614,
-0.0078318296,
-0.010735264,
-0.0324497074,
-0.0663016215,
-0.0785673112,
-0.0805481076,
0.0118351411,
-0.0012425048,
0.024596829,
-0.0404848643,
-0.0196561869,
-0.0575477965,
0.0646105856,
-0.0243840851,
-0.0246602893,
0.0107003096,
-0.0203676689,
0.0292752218,
0.0731948018,
-0.0469650254,
0.02842631,
-0.0127395596,
0.0174985193,
0.096086517,
0.0423470289,
0.0218536891,
0.0107801398,
-0.0078253066,
0.0210323278,
-0.0282589812,
0.0026506882,
0.0205170698,
-0.0126981251,
-0.0097634895,
0.0102092754,
0.0352283865,
0.0136542618,
-0.036352627,
0.0322727598,
0.0146185206,
0.073336333,
-0.0041708215,
0.0375796929,
-0.0928849056,
0.0175569635,
0.0197578277,
0.0653460994,
-0.0272207335,
-0.0315200873,
-0.0126655754,
-0.154520005,
-0.0193215664,
0.0018557435,
-0.0546780601,
0.0200234447,
-0.0288935192,
-0.0120269572,
0.0140546942,
0.0406284593,
0.0071580568,
0.0114857638,
0.0044472283,
0.0048229848,
0.013986052,
-0.0107830307,
0.006901897,
-0.040617846,
0.0569329746,
0.085437499,
0.0229667556,
-0.0232723393,
-0.0295376778,
-0.0071939835,
0.0237366296,
-0.0361769423,
0.0204633847,
0.0486289449,
-0.0396022834,
-0.0262711868,
-0.010465811,
0.0554046668,
0.018665785,
0.0092145987,
0.0141126765,
0.0508962423,
0.0060772849,
0.0018342113,
-0.0198865477,
-0.0047476296,
0.0374719761,
0.0635575429,
-0.0238953121,
-0.0791570023,
-0.0099537894,
-0.0741634071,
-0.0131639382,
-0.04011162,
-0.0621333383,
0.0213377215,
0.0032017194,
-0.0182514749,
-0.0812904984,
-0.0166339017,
-0.0203516148,
0.0506503172,
0.0118682999,
0.0200032983,
-0.0380810089,
0.0267551057,
-0.026364306,
0.0012203433,
-0.0145777706,
0.0488081537,
-0.0718893334,
0.0136277424,
-0.022974927,
-0.0307511222,
-0.0254597329,
-0.0173067991,
-0.0248518176,
-0.0858808607,
0.0171044897,
0.0629742593,
0.0199136361,
0.0567498654,
-0.0228702053,
-0.0473672226,
0.0597811677,
0.0349103399,
-0.0038605253,
0.0173333772,
0.0443570018,
-0.0061652674,
0.0056482079,
0.035026364,
-0.0540282056,
-0.0299846567,
0.0931075588,
0.0148669882,
-0.0177553911,
0.008701222,
0.0110677592,
0.0438441895,
0.0629615709,
-0.0297521818,
0.0299478825,
0.0172335636,
0.0329240598,
-0.0493111908,
-0.0404453501,
0.0076452754,
0.0052433442,
0.0096834861,
-0.0169888679,
0.029813787,
-0.0253593605,
0.0297669861,
0.0064514098,
-0.0093125589,
0.0107353898,
0.0303752031,
0.0322020985,
0.0472092181,
0.0381464884,
-0.0124803688,
0.0339132622,
0.0244251601,
0.0623405874,
0.0134339081,
0.0038239078,
0.0306081269,
-0.0053116125,
0.0002195543,
0.0499994606,
-0.0526434593,
-0.0501577146,
0.0021614949,
-0.0005454246,
0.013559198,
0.012858266,
0.0027646795,
0.0073174015,
-0.0113647012,
-0.0219867714,
-0.051262036,
-0.0212671664,
-0.0444998667,
0.0321016498,
0.0135706905,
-0.0088628745,
0.0457526781,
0.0648884401,
0.032746572,
0.0167387724,
-0.0225183461,
-0.034945216,
-0.0065023182,
-0.0244846195,
0.0192317702,
0.0243817419,
-0.0364403054,
-0.0539017059,
-0.0527579822,
-0.0905347243,
-0.0113163404,
0.0314342752,
0.0152028408,
0.0196271818,
-0.001721569,
0.0147344498,
-0.0192008801,
0.0408041365,
-0.0780064538,
0.0142953852,
-0.0125821345,
-0.0800398067,
0.01931566,
-5.917370971e-33,
0.0135229379,
-0.0401264466,
-0.0241650417,
0.0121959364,
0.007538504,
0.0032411658,
0.0130439047,
-0.0008695977,
-0.0264926814,
-0.0175351687,
-0.027320886,
-0.0164450929,
-0.0004859847,
0.0475308783,
-0.0111860847,
-0.0544599071,
-0.0073915422,
-0.0127500594,
-0.0494449623,
0.0102034658,
0.076342769,
-0.0149787022,
0.0117448671,
-0.0472944193,
0.0503203832,
0.017792251,
-0.0379622281,
0.03250416,
-0.0709679201,
0.0566624813,
0.0072008045,
0.0204044245,
-0.0183657352,
-0.0398695096,
0.0199940912,
0.0655098483,
-0.0181913432,
-0.0223922227,
0.0029292649,
-0.0071167531,
-0.0440939106,
-0.039177563,
0.0549648181,
-0.0049223052,
-0.0116959885,
-0.0030216367,
0.006357512,
-0.0030324229,
-0.0378433131,
0.0027348839,
-0.0241111424,
0.0058808206,
-0.0095929112,
-0.0008802642,
-0.0031632383,
0.027714638,
0.030326847,
0.0136919999,
-0.0399923325,
0.0376573019,
-0.0163263399,
0.0340724029,
0.0645771474,
0.0405422449,
0.00943013,
0.0722061396,
0.013386203,
0.0011320389,
0.0077802711,
0.0147337476,
-0.0224534757,
0.0198538397,
0.0726131424,
0.0604806803,
0.0397656187,
-0.0123724109,
-0.0485022143,
0.0220199805,
0.0079866005,
-0.0039347541,
0.022624597,
-0.002127486,
-0.0802189708,
-0.0018581385,
-0.0296491925,
-0.0279455632,
-0.0374103785,
-0.0504212826,
0.010898266,
0.0133696645,
-0.0522499755,
-0.0192748848,
0.0087531311,
-0.0447964706,
-0.0246843714,
0.0355840698,
0.0040373993,
-0.0283087119,
-0.009669573,
-0.0194469616,
-0.0230745338,
0.0477742143,
-0.0120709222,
-0.0652463883,
0.0201975163,
0.0187667049,
0.0367891379,
0.0145168388,
-0.0550441779,
-0.0057050702,
-0.0219240282,
0.0237476341,
0.0087038185,
0.0214596763,
0.0467107259,
-0.0365008675,
0.0065500597,
0.0162205137,
0.0212468524,
0.0315253027,
-0.0268620364,
0.0148226274,
-0.0297789779,
-0.0085239662,
0.0136973821,
0.0073803449,
0.0173338242,
0.060436327,
0.0099086855,
-0.0635699183,
0.0095089944,
-0.040389359,
2.838e-7,
0.0084212106,
0.0241018254,
0.0459149294,
-0.0095138447,
0.0276288036,
0.0742579401,
0.0017763664,
0.0903701261,
0.0010285395,
-0.0108569367,
-0.0106565533,
-0.0321384743,
0.0349849015,
0.0263400991,
-0.0704068691,
-0.0174247921,
-0.1065561771,
0.0206515063,
-0.0568245612,
-0.0202894136,
0.0387181379,
0.0925326794,
0.0563137867,
-0.0150342491,
-0.0241828021,
-0.0166241936,
0.0148738045,
-0.0180382337,
-0.0221077744,
-0.0373842232,
0.0215591453,
0.0081739873,
-0.0005628463,
0.0044633946,
-0.0414760448,
-0.0085079558,
0.0003056175,
0.020513447,
0.0015759798,
-0.0687390864,
-0.0500279739,
-0.0380194224,
0.0069630509,
-0.0476119071,
0.0642640814,
-0.0120511316,
-0.0201773774,
-0.0280840322,
-0.0241271667,
-0.0481018648,
0.039602913,
-0.0234418083,
-0.0087504741,
-0.0021914428,
0.0044596614,
0.0328393131,
0.0213349499,
-0.0740883276,
-0.0337935351,
-0.0331371613,
-0.0176599547,
-0.0357540734,
-0.0108817769,
0.0560222752,
-0.0208041631,
-0.0331460647,
-0.0334438831,
2.815319072e-34,
-0.0023429466,
-0.0568250678,
0.0015640473,
-0.0374163277,
0.0336639099,
0.0083806608,
0.013979434,
0.0088866604,
0.0457127802,
-0.0444505438,
-0.0447043106
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09635v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09635v2 | Evaluating In-Context Learning of Libraries for Code Generation | 2023-11-16T07:37:25 | 2024-04-04T18:54:01 | Arkil Patel, Siva Reddy, Dzmitry Bahdanau, Pradeep Dasigi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Contemporary Large Language Models (LLMs) exhibit a high degree of code
generation and comprehension capability. A particularly promising area is their
ability to interpret code modules from unfamiliar libraries for solving
user-instructed tasks. Recent work has shown that large proprietary LLMs can
learn novel library usage in-context from demonstrations. These results raise
several open questions: whether demonstrations of library usage is required,
whether smaller (and more open) models also possess such capabilities, etc. In
this work, we take a broader approach by systematically evaluating a diverse
array of LLMs across three scenarios reflecting varying levels of domain
specialization to understand their abilities and limitations in generating code
based on libraries defined in-context. Our results show that even smaller
open-source LLMs like Llama-2 and StarCoder demonstrate an adept understanding
of novel code libraries based on specification presented in-context. Our
findings further reveal that LLMs exhibit a surprisingly high proficiency in
learning novel library modules even when provided with just natural language
descriptions or raw code implementations of the functions, which are often
cheaper to obtain than demonstrations. Overall, our results pave the way for
harnessing LLMs in more adaptable and dynamic coding environments. | [
0.0170775522,
0.0520791523,
-0.0360605642,
0.0457634665,
-0.0149312988,
0.0069479123,
-0.0134921363,
-0.0011048879,
0.0210585594,
0.0066055497,
-0.0458199643,
0.017333962,
-0.0132173588,
0.0442396551,
0.0411992185,
-0.0084635727,
0.0291604269,
-0.0513772182,
-0.0667452589,
0.0027252675,
-0.0183392465,
0.0117339585,
0.0066963187,
0.053781908,
0.0406660065,
-0.0304268785,
-0.0177133381,
0.0111256018,
-0.0320875943,
-0.0254795142,
0.0038444491,
0.0158120412,
0.0616791658,
0.0210282523,
0.0000022727,
-0.0583583787,
-0.0115542766,
-0.0189165138,
-0.0104198931,
0.0336011089,
0.0398476794,
0.0092670005,
-0.0125997532,
0.0007820964,
-0.0504600555,
-0.0072381077,
0.0527404994,
-0.0898726061,
0.0413589999,
0.0159037448,
0.0291071963,
0.0066823252,
-0.0029571231,
0.011765752,
0.0547907501,
0.0064047626,
-0.0141440388,
0.0357500091,
0.0644319206,
-0.0339456089,
-0.0187938064,
0.0155267278,
0.0481180921,
0.0024412263,
0.0103819435,
0.0545445308,
-0.0285956673,
0.0002925941,
-0.0176720861,
0.0313758254,
-0.0170861855,
-0.0359138176,
0.0212780032,
-0.0015395847,
-0.0213348474,
0.0018783408,
-0.0566144362,
0.0519879572,
0.0173343346,
-0.0048274351,
0.0121155642,
-0.0029353446,
0.0284883287,
0.0183338616,
0.009380036,
0.045932848,
-0.0021366796,
-0.00580762,
-0.0231881142,
-0.0167529229,
-0.0138635291,
-0.0402969643,
-0.0226061698,
0.067939572,
0.0074556218,
0.0455782562,
-0.0400484726,
0.006153326,
0.0266983602,
-0.0355260111,
0.0307767428,
0.0369103961,
-0.0252687223,
0.011065715,
-0.0560718477,
0.0822658762,
-0.0074088182,
-0.015612497,
-0.0194277354,
0.0347120613,
-0.0335403718,
-0.0208787471,
-0.0183804668,
0.0600069575,
-0.0326327011,
0.0133215664,
-0.0241740439,
0.056087587,
0.0024554888,
0.0601156689,
-0.0529728234,
-0.0161682274,
-0.0413517021,
-0.0080870539,
-0.0063882014,
0.0017804491,
0.0106918197,
-0.0178565774,
-0.0058400445,
-0.0741027892,
-0.0102740405,
0.03487809,
-0.0526703671,
-0.011704809,
0.0570398793,
0.0695319548,
0.0026683423,
-0.0062374324,
-0.0380219556,
-0.0143667385,
0.0288261082,
-0.0578827932,
0.0281124394,
-0.1074701995,
-0.0379372984,
0.0561913624,
-0.0040354338,
-0.0614143088,
0.0186962727,
-0.0123155797,
0.025309775,
0.0387270711,
-0.0255613755,
0.0163121633,
0.0299456585,
0.0201617312,
-0.0207918473,
0.0469948985,
0.0329720154,
0.0028160322,
-0.0106089991,
-0.0299922563,
0.0478057861,
0.0538302585,
-0.0229485501,
0.004656136,
-0.0314431973,
0.0367272533,
0.0424865223,
0.008557409,
0.0292291418,
0.0034182451,
-0.0113410084,
0.0500239246,
0.0317222401,
0.0516060628,
0.0105675748,
0.0071627572,
0.0881606638,
0.0167093836,
0.0363034979,
-0.0103830444,
-0.0416213498,
0.0731469467,
-0.0219766181,
0.0328415558,
-0.0251082461,
0.0502151772,
0.0067415303,
-0.0372174755,
-0.0043622167,
-0.0347264186,
-0.0106371036,
0.0040326705,
0.0409638509,
0.0218447521,
-0.0345849544,
0.0356181301,
0.0158703011,
-0.076932922,
0.0075202906,
-0.0657686293,
0.0449696966,
0.0553626604,
0.0872587115,
-0.0553419404,
-0.0092728091,
-0.0202205312,
0.007338787,
0.0178724509,
0.0367770866,
-0.0142147942,
-0.0246670209,
-0.048578091,
0.0082918713,
-0.0751203597,
-0.0076626684,
0.0429847464,
0.0451737009,
-0.0195698459,
-0.0045886775,
-0.0367391743,
-0.039592091,
0.0297054201,
-0.1044030264,
-0.0097141527,
0.0017236335,
-0.0143230567,
0.0091167195,
-0.0296947565,
-0.0348960422,
-0.003842768,
0.0544052646,
-0.0333939642,
0.0167477001,
-0.014935188,
-0.0491373651,
-0.0149230203,
0.0109098488,
-0.0482331589,
-0.0166216381,
0.0166750532,
-0.0032878125,
0.0039941818,
0.0694929808,
-0.0005452145,
0.0318855159,
-0.0143429469,
0.0216739476,
-0.0411629528,
-0.0250221416,
0.0020503551,
0.0726299137,
0.0033774038,
0.0309838075,
0.0366443917,
0.0727026984,
0.0147452662,
0.0273905024,
-0.0215963535,
0.0316020772,
-0.0236474965,
0.0344372094,
-0.0191721767,
0.0415906087,
-0.0135393385,
-0.0497975014,
-0.0628136024,
0.0435663275,
-0.0227226298,
0.0211361591,
0.0204141736,
0.0216628406,
-0.0100488234,
-0.0046311207,
-0.010534009,
-0.0153776789,
-0.0149123073,
-0.0098317647,
0.0164224785,
0.0025021003,
-0.0869589224,
-0.0220130458,
0.0058427933,
-0.0166576635,
0.0503305458,
-0.0181083195,
0.0009949789,
-0.0622273162,
0.051544819,
0.0155977309,
0.0129412236,
-0.0369895138,
-0.021460481,
0.0327663347,
-0.0498355404,
0.0518054441,
0.0428368896,
-0.0308997817,
0.0377831124,
0.0667688474,
0.0088126156,
-0.0420814492,
0.0284145754,
0.0208722707,
-0.0462023988,
-0.0324334204,
-0.0137936482,
0.0206428953,
0.0698629692,
-0.0146072563,
0.0039245412,
-0.0126324818,
-0.0017323223,
0.0015625,
-0.0077797808,
-0.0123217255,
-0.0291578565,
-0.0317169018,
0.0334257521,
-0.0041804197,
-0.1014688909,
0.0455529839,
-0.0226663072,
-0.0440773219,
-0.034799058,
-0.0460298918,
-0.0694081634,
0.0982362255,
-0.0076855253,
0.0124223558,
0.0008748621,
-0.0250399783,
-0.0259502679,
0.0422419161,
-0.0085095381,
-0.042076584,
0.0623155907,
-0.0748592541,
0.0081458027,
-0.0165555403,
-0.0140651176,
-0.0436843373,
0.0458505116,
-0.0314369947,
0.0091308467,
0.0098168226,
-0.0055180965,
0.0076074214,
-0.0053722132,
0.0430286191,
0.0459808894,
0.0220461078,
-0.0296563301,
-0.0408260748,
-0.0438255034,
-0.0286199283,
-0.0245747399,
-0.0113000758,
-0.0291066598,
-0.0055905157,
-0.000014212,
0.0397157222,
-0.0117699858,
-0.0538422912,
0.0314497538,
0.0563661493,
-0.0141245732,
-0.0144243846,
0.1024294421,
0.0681660399,
-0.0600050054,
-0.0323781148,
0.0582403466,
0.0235961359,
-0.0334022455,
0.0143706426,
-0.0144877769,
0.0274032913,
0.0950777382,
0.0439006761,
-0.0828688666,
-0.0285776779,
-0.01383508,
0.0220487006,
-0.0068144165,
-0.0153035689,
-0.044296585,
-0.1224344075,
0.0500992127,
0.0250879023,
-0.0429892763,
-0.0330339707,
-0.0297562201,
-0.01371687,
0.020500429,
-0.0279698223,
0.0285159778,
-0.0281075537,
0.0161666796,
-0.0086334068,
-0.0270876158,
-0.0319967531,
0.0325599648,
0.0034913372,
0.0317895785,
0.0790759325,
-0.0167180877,
-0.0049522868,
-0.0064515313,
0.011939764,
-0.02700294,
0.0281185694,
-0.0124394083,
0.0106198192,
0.0334424749,
-0.0088845203,
0.0289717652,
0.0614153892,
-0.0673324168,
-0.0358559154,
0.0151040601,
0.0593156219,
-0.0188315436,
-0.0223650523,
-0.019623505,
-0.0080620302,
0.0218884069,
0.0522124395,
0.0421177968,
-0.0240467638,
-0.0251800623,
-0.078479141,
-0.0398976393,
-0.019181937,
-0.0174075738,
-0.0078197867,
0.0239367168,
0.0243936758,
-0.015699029,
0.0386251323,
0.0374506228,
0.0179541521,
0.0241870247,
0.0227904357,
-0.0067639146,
-0.0101794349,
-0.0552111194,
-0.0115432711,
-0.0166389365,
0.0162053034,
-0.0431770273,
-0.0451651663,
0.0255732294,
-0.0562297292,
-0.0142732067,
0.0233666245,
-0.0849530846,
-0.0549111404,
-0.0322646797,
0.057634376,
0.0302166492,
0.0005454916,
-0.0118006654,
-0.0347401202,
-0.0284806658,
0.0611279532,
-0.0359946787,
0.0362081192,
0.001609557,
0.0134482356,
0.0183459334,
0.0002012659,
-0.0670471117,
-0.0121424031,
0.014132875,
-0.0143373199,
0.0077729933,
0.008490772,
0.038984675,
-0.0017631988,
-0.0188990887,
-0.0157582629,
-0.031904079,
-0.0163292307,
-0.0040716124,
0.0106991455,
-0.0355467536,
-0.040536169,
-0.0364795327,
0.0018289031,
0.006447352,
0.0669315457,
0.0466427468,
-0.0010792969,
0.0946366116,
-0.0091711469,
0.066608876,
0.0034219911,
0.0271873884,
0.088100031,
-0.0060656681,
-0.0098093636,
0.0042404877,
-0.0364564955,
0.0417918712,
0.0143644661,
0.0631128028,
-0.0078960471,
0.0265794545,
0.0453412347,
0.0050560706,
-0.0416118763,
-0.0853666142,
-0.0197918639,
0.0462278537,
0.0510162823,
0.0360285938,
-0.0002143734,
-0.0679605603,
0.0324907787,
-0.017884139,
0.0346457586,
-0.0117772995,
-0.0598123781,
0.0164791625,
0.0219069161,
-0.0033103938,
-0.0262792241,
0.1082491353,
0.0031784174,
0.0541122407,
-0.023096865,
0.0307545085,
-0.0294574909,
-0.011919219,
0.0725687221,
-0.0202484727,
-0.012251433,
0.0056119342,
-0.0512368493,
-0.0309235975,
-0.0037752215,
0.0097216638,
0.0184778664,
-0.051902283,
0.0512857363,
0.0831528977,
-0.0147396429,
-0.0167954452,
0.0024798065,
0.0384979993,
-0.0071982406,
-0.0422757789,
-0.0202951524,
-6.047590766e-33,
-0.0281629339,
-0.025166668,
0.038113866,
0.0234965831,
0.0451470502,
-0.01079001,
-0.0614704043,
0.0061610038,
0.0030641411,
-0.0586563423,
0.0509946533,
-0.0078388145,
-0.0232210569,
-0.0366038978,
0.0281799901,
0.0243504923,
0.0301113315,
-0.0007031173,
-0.0482510179,
0.027602613,
-0.0318036415,
0.0210120585,
0.0134828342,
-0.0466074608,
-0.0205773618,
-0.0346762463,
0.0085212877,
-0.0248867702,
-0.0284686219,
0.0491426699,
-0.0101098716,
-0.0077781226,
-0.0102113318,
-0.0354433246,
-0.0411983132,
-0.0217622593,
0.0028083157,
0.0077615795,
0.0188752413,
0.0013440575,
-0.0130883642,
-0.0868369117,
0.0796667188,
0.0245191734,
-0.0648314953,
0.0227724221,
0.0123603903,
-0.0058886479,
-0.0080070021,
-0.0392667204,
-0.0517084375,
0.0198982283,
-0.035115052,
-0.0173623823,
-0.0224265624,
0.0269963816,
-0.0189910345,
0.0524889715,
0.0374185145,
0.0452869758,
0.0305383783,
0.0259046108,
0.09207239,
-0.0113843028,
0.0183170121,
0.0279781632,
0.0000223525,
-0.0117630968,
0.0161817614,
-0.0005069157,
0.0173228048,
0.0538531207,
-0.0051648612,
0.0305930693,
0.0194223262,
0.0235740878,
-0.0300320052,
0.0012600712,
-0.0042503462,
0.0037085325,
0.0521471053,
0.0239792485,
-0.0163924992,
0.0018155288,
-0.0262573324,
0.0209859703,
-0.0098428354,
-0.0415031798,
0.0388415232,
0.0047059432,
-0.0148290182,
-0.0314176865,
0.0131560648,
-0.0465002432,
-0.0189961828,
0.0145528549,
-0.0539989509,
0.0547508746,
0.0063867029,
0.0197528042,
-0.0551623441,
-0.0416455045,
0.0130226957,
-0.021219492,
0.0618379302,
0.0294480696,
0.02800381,
0.0421017744,
-0.0432125963,
0.0209032167,
-0.0553031117,
0.0188159272,
0.033430066,
0.0135371918,
0.0152661819,
-0.0313820541,
-0.0043031629,
0.0135629755,
-0.022963915,
-0.0674242675,
-0.0515925549,
-0.0239687003,
-0.0323097557,
0.0047137612,
-0.0620934106,
-0.0360321701,
-0.0711802915,
0.0280252025,
0.0334533118,
-0.0065264935,
-0.0451374538,
0.0118587743,
3.011e-7,
-0.0063930545,
0.0118886065,
-0.0189810749,
0.0393679217,
0.0245206933,
0.0219459943,
-0.0698020458,
0.0216326062,
0.0023963547,
-0.0253246818,
-0.0484348536,
0.0284574963,
0.0334335752,
0.0064806808,
-0.0755273178,
0.041393619,
0.0118341912,
0.014543945,
-0.0818752274,
-0.0096244691,
0.0092093311,
0.0310068727,
-0.0306369532,
0.0002441274,
0.0201969594,
-0.0627401769,
0.0383644365,
-0.0279011019,
-0.0020506417,
0.021596767,
-0.0681331828,
0.064265728,
-0.0436504707,
-0.0188092235,
-0.0013010208,
-0.0136137111,
-0.0036469002,
0.0633523464,
0.0465580896,
0.039525345,
0.0433191881,
-0.0049118293,
-0.0070145885,
-0.0392252989,
0.0438745171,
-0.0075338776,
-0.0039960658,
-0.0053265942,
0.005307985,
-0.0038190971,
-0.0527676642,
-0.0313597471,
0.046212513,
-0.0103922589,
-0.0364752971,
-0.0328073055,
-0.0341021717,
-0.0032910556,
-0.0408459902,
-0.0095616551,
-0.0321862288,
-0.0563314334,
-0.089906171,
0.0139388153,
-0.0044042561,
-0.0314838141,
0.0363064632,
2.932344127e-34,
0.0049224566,
-0.0216981098,
0.0148106152,
0.0408361815,
0.0535023101,
-0.0365856364,
-0.040151298,
0.0429082587,
0.0171300042,
-0.0120660225,
-0.0144283827
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.00029v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.00029v2 | Bergeron: Combating Adversarial Attacks through a Conscience-Based Alignment Framework | 2023-11-16T07:31:18 | 2024-03-15T20:13:06 | Matthew Pisano, Peter Ly, Abraham Sanders, Bingsheng Yao, Dakuo Wang, Tomek Strzalkowski, Mei Si | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL | Research into AI alignment has grown considerably since the recent
introduction of increasingly capable Large Language Models (LLMs).
Unfortunately, modern methods of alignment still fail to fully prevent harmful
responses when models are deliberately attacked. These attacks can trick
seemingly aligned models into giving manufacturing instructions for dangerous
materials, inciting violence, or recommending other immoral acts. To help
mitigate this issue, we introduce Bergeron: a framework designed to improve the
robustness of LLMs against attacks without any additional parameter
fine-tuning. Bergeron is organized into two tiers; with a secondary LLM
emulating the conscience of a protected, primary LLM. This framework better
safeguards the primary model against incoming attacks while monitoring its
output for any harmful content. Empirical analysis shows that, by using
Bergeron to complement models with existing alignment training, we can improve
the robustness and safety of multiple, commonly used commercial and open-source
LLMs. | [
0.0419356711,
0.0947926641,
-0.0193720963,
0.0561582968,
-0.0486755967,
0.0157457925,
0.0176958498,
-0.0224706382,
0.009866572,
-0.0193967503,
-0.0512648933,
-0.0167699065,
0.0015424187,
-0.0061278967,
0.0392142609,
0.0039173113,
0.0701764077,
0.0118150543,
0.0055463002,
-0.0013040091,
0.047228422,
0.0201052316,
-0.0086590927,
0.0160661396,
0.0096255131,
-0.0437253416,
-0.0091114128,
0.0277245995,
0.0616663322,
-0.0028462091,
0.0191869698,
0.0242925081,
-0.0132065052,
0.111288242,
0.0000017813,
-0.0497027822,
-0.0118167521,
0.0075547956,
-0.0110671809,
-0.000188907,
0.0264380109,
-0.0800336003,
-0.0352689438,
0.0061133872,
-0.0445600003,
0.0441278815,
0.042796582,
0.0831775963,
0.0751361549,
0.101635918,
0.0049610478,
-0.0541131496,
0.0450994633,
-0.0330372453,
-0.0401261896,
-0.0296773724,
0.0322918408,
-0.0322734155,
-0.0584470704,
-0.0043146457,
-0.0073811952,
0.017405659,
0.0116838124,
-0.0129097421,
-0.0174049381,
0.0020821718,
-0.044549983,
-0.0410344824,
0.0010711161,
0.071230866,
-0.0110762408,
-0.0156049253,
0.0026902163,
-0.0152234072,
0.0187657513,
-0.0554484464,
0.0039666654,
0.0095193097,
0.0044769943,
0.008981877,
0.0345505513,
-0.021638507,
0.0396234654,
0.0422608554,
0.0365058295,
0.0140300663,
0.0347552858,
-0.0427383892,
0.0158981197,
-0.004558871,
-0.0249148924,
-0.0655217096,
-0.0240847692,
0.0052603809,
-0.0416972488,
0.014073547,
-0.0976794735,
-0.0192219261,
0.0385267586,
-0.0401045978,
0.038675826,
0.04251476,
-0.0083906464,
0.004369962,
-0.0095842294,
0.0688992068,
-0.0569635443,
0.0810149163,
-0.0090128612,
0.0362877697,
0.0154839307,
0.0065443763,
0.0051628822,
0.0039566602,
-0.0115814591,
0.0004651055,
-0.0554688424,
0.0378308184,
-0.0382408164,
0.0455271378,
-0.0452037789,
-0.0083573107,
-0.0217825454,
-0.0370502546,
0.0093470784,
0.0050147679,
-0.0053644772,
0.0092974035,
-0.0162955411,
-0.0360295437,
-0.0326307788,
0.0333670415,
-0.070061177,
-0.0487126075,
0.0033995889,
0.1084333733,
0.0062998119,
0.0046713711,
-0.0168122146,
-0.0111868102,
-0.0325388424,
-0.0653725192,
-0.0022130117,
-0.0208842494,
0.0237227082,
-0.0464805886,
-0.0387280397,
-0.076839067,
0.0185348168,
0.0212606266,
-0.0296611879,
0.0767041519,
0.0229703989,
-0.0221077725,
0.0250940621,
0.0217309203,
0.0154540362,
0.0538194105,
0.0115517238,
0.0305539165,
0.0189110804,
0.005514544,
-0.0047550923,
0.0363505073,
0.0168912373,
0.0204442907,
-0.0526736788,
0.0242860522,
0.0455442742,
0.040701773,
0.017512843,
0.0601907894,
0.0101374798,
-0.0879625976,
0.1088342741,
0.0175020322,
-0.0381674096,
0.0460164547,
-0.0052533275,
-0.0133718252,
-0.0085024508,
0.013519532,
-0.094299227,
0.014357334,
-0.0529708005,
-0.0093144774,
0.015926769,
0.0587251633,
-0.0083490117,
-0.0172162745,
-0.0086003421,
-0.0027279146,
0.0214186367,
-0.0143848406,
-0.006894445,
0.0010433159,
-0.0324985385,
-0.0171453003,
0.0316769034,
-0.0148865413,
-0.0141367987,
-0.0432396084,
0.0102951275,
0.0507053845,
0.0626129583,
-0.0036280435,
-0.0297581572,
-0.0411226787,
-0.0122500472,
0.0557116941,
0.022137003,
0.0027841826,
0.0142256534,
-0.0400684625,
-0.0207617804,
-0.0328864902,
-0.0101081934,
0.0159890242,
0.0129557466,
0.0057800175,
-0.0086513432,
0.0380869173,
-0.0616987906,
0.0619194545,
0.0210895315,
-0.0521504655,
-0.0179931521,
0.0354980454,
0.0611131862,
0.0078090494,
-0.0314815864,
-0.0040787947,
0.0328540541,
-0.0288398601,
0.009561413,
-0.0063759466,
-0.024550043,
0.0054716421,
0.0586299822,
0.0008701727,
-0.0294963103,
0.048977714,
-0.0442633368,
0.0089851581,
-0.0051799505,
-0.0348515138,
-0.0176548939,
-0.0150924986,
0.0118104415,
-0.0244912617,
0.0246765446,
-0.0357927158,
0.0591650233,
-0.0312637202,
-0.0293324571,
-0.0049962774,
-0.0273905955,
0.0150847631,
-0.0109090237,
-0.0264406968,
-0.0081562465,
-0.0199262407,
0.0370954946,
0.0241784286,
-0.0065459232,
-0.0074978117,
-0.0363113731,
-0.0291003287,
0.016969597,
-0.0128952246,
0.0070105703,
0.040798828,
-0.0203583837,
-0.0155256512,
0.0114485631,
-0.0349147916,
0.0240677334,
-0.0072131595,
0.0149272941,
0.021501828,
-0.0408581235,
-0.0373125263,
-0.0369912311,
0.0117659718,
-0.0321653783,
0.0248772502,
-0.0091427686,
-0.0337078348,
-0.0342796296,
-0.0136277368,
-0.029275706,
0.0492304713,
-0.0231023189,
-0.0740960464,
0.0254488103,
0.0310860518,
0.0094372705,
0.1105331481,
0.0607563406,
0.0171413161,
0.0618185066,
0.047402788,
-0.0388469659,
0.0048626261,
0.016186215,
-0.0338714309,
-0.0731549561,
-0.0202965755,
0.0038674513,
0.0684866458,
0.0266889129,
0.0271010064,
-0.0441223457,
0.0248301663,
0.025263356,
-0.052277986,
0.031399183,
-0.0614005774,
-0.0555672273,
-0.0119190272,
-0.052165255,
-0.0652457029,
0.0828377455,
-0.0273586214,
0.0264499281,
-0.0193403885,
-0.0329305418,
0.012185053,
0.0253320597,
0.0046789143,
0.0534978881,
-0.0057820878,
-0.0185443405,
-0.0623934641,
-0.0371477641,
0.0202774014,
-0.0347362757,
0.0463406779,
0.001061741,
0.0041658478,
-0.0059106909,
-0.0407579243,
-0.0951988101,
-0.0668535084,
-0.0363156907,
-0.0264114402,
0.0000307335,
-0.0107254377,
-0.0813855827,
-0.0368444845,
0.0335679762,
-0.0051458911,
-0.0174377151,
0.0217426028,
-0.0199544169,
-0.0194902588,
0.0873348117,
-0.0286933836,
0.0270349942,
-0.029420346,
0.0442486033,
0.0641263276,
-0.0062266584,
0.026917398,
-0.0402181968,
-0.0297429953,
0.0259238724,
0.0005513254,
0.0351556577,
0.008839868,
0.0425039679,
0.0038670793,
0.0102190124,
0.0793539882,
-0.0044519794,
-0.0419675335,
0.0065950342,
-0.0091180364,
0.0461383238,
0.0174035206,
0.0050225519,
-0.0587096736,
-0.0087409094,
0.0241244677,
0.0189803597,
-0.0045178081,
-0.0061041932,
-0.0059938687,
-0.0942829251,
-0.0094482144,
0.0405177511,
-0.0329326205,
-0.0670928881,
0.0171627551,
-0.0017442788,
-0.0171599519,
0.0559543855,
0.0057560112,
0.0142341433,
-0.0454893075,
0.0164935552,
0.008123517,
-0.0131962281,
-0.0072701019,
-0.0535022356,
0.0865111202,
0.094150342,
0.0520892851,
-0.0173991323,
-0.031377282,
0.0181800742,
-0.002036222,
-0.013885241,
0.0344283618,
0.0370495655,
-0.0460926667,
-0.0234323386,
0.0134173771,
0.0706416816,
0.0072438219,
-0.0202783421,
0.0325224288,
0.0177257471,
-0.0025230534,
0.0252779722,
-0.0386323035,
0.0421682745,
0.0244777389,
0.0726864338,
0.0175368413,
-0.0491385832,
0.0063014231,
-0.0420316756,
-0.020397801,
-0.0178948473,
-0.0594125092,
0.0297121163,
-0.0005301852,
-0.0195430648,
-0.0563804433,
-0.0278358459,
-0.047409758,
0.0299179442,
0.050394766,
-0.0392835848,
-0.0335467495,
-0.0167488307,
-0.0279195979,
-0.0145980017,
-0.0116240121,
0.0354683176,
-0.0358915515,
0.049250342,
-0.0078225452,
-0.0377076417,
-0.0106436294,
0.0298466012,
-0.0773259178,
-0.1156514883,
0.0398746394,
0.050396271,
0.0226108637,
0.0737600476,
-0.0500855148,
-0.0286482312,
0.0496544652,
0.058152359,
-0.0340189897,
0.0289987065,
0.0507608466,
-0.0107845142,
0.0096598016,
0.0308033582,
-0.0191405695,
-0.0181784425,
0.079719156,
0.0031139255,
-0.0564783514,
-0.0385998897,
0.0214264728,
0.0087614143,
0.0217475556,
-0.03058674,
0.0187277887,
-0.0239972807,
0.0162799582,
-0.0141613083,
-0.0208845884,
0.0067601316,
-0.0068293661,
0.0583626032,
-0.0227664523,
0.0236344207,
-0.0121208411,
-0.0228511523,
0.0085123265,
-0.0322967619,
0.0008059607,
-0.010048938,
0.0448654555,
-0.0011097551,
0.0311512873,
-0.0439044535,
0.0500067845,
0.0054047154,
0.0454206616,
-0.0045102332,
0.073058255,
0.0170423854,
0.0017995761,
-0.0051961686,
0.0203338396,
-0.0600901879,
-0.0269466341,
-0.0314184912,
-0.0118534537,
-0.0024804624,
0.0041009476,
0.0363123342,
-0.0085934261,
-0.0172362439,
-0.024929814,
0.003753667,
-0.0382153317,
-0.035424646,
0.0204365458,
0.0188432131,
-0.0156382453,
0.0044649336,
0.0328315236,
-0.0234175418,
0.0415794589,
0.0243696943,
-0.0139094703,
-0.0403720848,
-0.0540249795,
0.0301986393,
-0.0174108036,
-0.0500199236,
-0.0188698433,
-0.0455895513,
-0.0574324057,
0.0119244233,
0.0261758361,
0.0042069014,
-0.0068756384,
-0.0106293969,
0.0387215279,
-0.010042795,
0.0361547023,
-0.0148065006,
0.0224648509,
-0.0182088092,
-0.0469192564,
-0.0182800479,
-5.643951352e-33,
-0.0203056131,
0.0050346032,
-0.0042051119,
-0.0482232645,
-0.0353032872,
0.0040986775,
-0.003090567,
0.0010349844,
-0.0364114381,
0.0101771262,
0.0121386852,
0.0050427727,
-0.0160724539,
-0.0057319282,
-0.0125384545,
-0.065723449,
0.0064597405,
0.0008008967,
-0.0300541483,
-0.0059510199,
0.0287492219,
-0.0015022733,
0.0178046431,
-0.0870920494,
0.0289679486,
0.0026164053,
-0.0487025045,
-0.0141033372,
-0.0485626161,
0.0813392252,
-0.0114843706,
0.0265718009,
-0.0086598536,
0.0241562743,
0.0148097994,
0.0575237721,
0.0025914232,
0.0057083219,
0.0407640599,
0.0210535824,
-0.0113062765,
-0.057732977,
0.0289388057,
-0.0270178057,
-0.0255958382,
-0.0281355083,
0.0050177951,
-0.0241780244,
-0.0246453341,
-0.0238568336,
-0.0822671205,
-0.0180321932,
-0.019997403,
-0.0178169869,
-0.0192768183,
0.0199256558,
0.0388586894,
0.0209550001,
-0.0836351812,
0.0082518952,
0.0094766757,
0.0182980113,
0.0556985252,
0.0035040751,
0.0027365328,
0.0995000079,
-0.0003652404,
-0.0205282066,
-0.0190874692,
0.0206714887,
0.0153046735,
0.0151703935,
0.0605373643,
0.0766459405,
-0.0142295109,
-0.0218941197,
-0.0773402378,
0.0107720438,
0.0044608805,
0.0255140401,
0.0354990363,
0.0228702724,
-0.0450662151,
0.0334714726,
-0.0009840681,
-0.0775032938,
-0.0301353727,
-0.0110891731,
0.0067004953,
0.0002187024,
-0.0250983778,
-0.0128624365,
-0.0035258906,
-0.0300875772,
0.0567416809,
0.0460963659,
-0.0144576803,
-0.0313660204,
-0.0101003656,
0.0219487678,
-0.0220285989,
-0.0177885648,
0.0110239238,
-0.0270317979,
0.0503603667,
0.0017277123,
0.0907412991,
0.0168626476,
-0.0503196493,
-0.0056747361,
-0.0164324716,
0.0447294489,
0.020802781,
-0.0075134626,
0.0518255755,
0.0040165973,
-0.0047696941,
0.0102229379,
0.0344172604,
-0.0153619573,
-0.0172261968,
0.0308083333,
-0.0041270559,
0.027812656,
-0.009717158,
0.0101445969,
0.0244498178,
0.0545742139,
0.0258408319,
-0.0907880515,
-0.0060824133,
-0.0131168775,
2.588e-7,
-0.0104689002,
0.0156538486,
0.0432151444,
-0.0034480304,
0.024930628,
0.0750345066,
0.0154804895,
0.0943441838,
-0.0059835063,
-0.0657942444,
0.0133769922,
0.0133344028,
0.0783636048,
0.0217379201,
-0.0283729751,
0.0280216318,
-0.0961121619,
0.0153916245,
-0.0739121661,
0.0103054959,
0.0211764127,
0.1139854416,
0.0436527207,
-0.0082400199,
-0.0040734489,
-0.0408363342,
0.0241002161,
-0.0086790174,
-0.0280476119,
-0.0142932981,
0.0169540346,
-0.0050810091,
-0.0045850114,
0.0042428859,
-0.0244909897,
0.023459943,
-0.0123335263,
0.0582356863,
-0.0268079061,
-0.0301727988,
-0.0178394429,
-0.0041993423,
-0.0162922032,
-0.0192558486,
0.0428870954,
-0.0262158625,
-0.0284229461,
-0.0218875166,
-0.0294387788,
0.006362447,
0.044302173,
-0.0311492458,
0.0133658191,
-0.0016708341,
0.0298977606,
-0.0001675261,
-0.0021754033,
-0.0474816374,
-0.0159805808,
-0.0208347179,
-0.0124752698,
-0.0204625949,
-0.0025787842,
0.0374222063,
0.0154890781,
-0.0432296395,
0.0106710121,
2.182902193e-34,
-0.0054154545,
-0.0450836159,
0.0314775109,
0.0204766169,
0.0304218531,
0.0200149883,
-0.0091005927,
0.0059645851,
0.0218525045,
-0.0410166197,
-0.0334810317
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09632v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09632v1 | Online Continual Knowledge Learning for Language Models | 2023-11-16T07:31:03 | 2023-11-16T07:31:03 | Yuhao Wu, Tongjun Shi, Karthick Sharma, Chun Wei Seah, Shuhao Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs) serve as repositories of extensive world
knowledge, enabling them to perform tasks such as question-answering and
fact-checking. However, this knowledge can become obsolete as global contexts
change. In this paper, we introduce a novel problem in the realm of continual
learning: Online Continual Knowledge Learning (OCKL). This problem formulation
aims to manage the dynamic nature of world knowledge in LMs under real-time
constraints. We propose a new benchmark and evaluation metric designed to
measure both the rate of new knowledge acquisition and the retention of
previously learned knowledge. Our empirical evaluation, conducted using a
variety of state-of-the-art methods, establishes robust base-lines for OCKL.
Our results reveal that existing continual learning approaches are
unfortunately insufficient for tackling the unique challenges posed by OCKL. We
identify key factors that influence the trade-off between knowledge acquisition
and retention, thereby advancing our understanding of how to train LMs in a
continually evolving environment. | [
0.0319173336,
0.0448279195,
-0.0126694068,
0.0118766893,
-0.0489890613,
0.0124517437,
-0.0510446914,
-0.0368684791,
0.0051629259,
-0.045846872,
-0.0030073232,
-0.0502773374,
-0.0255430229,
0.0468417667,
-0.0055969926,
-0.0083494242,
0.0451470725,
-0.0453173891,
-0.0022739642,
-0.015384879,
0.0020497432,
-0.0269920863,
-0.045520436,
-0.0001192333,
-0.024252696,
-0.0554190837,
-0.0192216113,
-0.0798825845,
0.011529346,
-0.0203952454,
0.0233395547,
-0.0017067285,
0.0380511545,
0.0149208959,
0.0000020487,
-0.0692508668,
-0.0474249348,
-0.0275410339,
-0.0628107041,
-0.0404002443,
0.0305798147,
0.0257837418,
-0.0314443558,
0.0151149277,
-0.0754235536,
0.0125590721,
0.0274203569,
-0.0037547974,
0.0556562394,
0.0263234861,
0.0082068397,
0.0341519639,
0.0500194877,
-0.0078801475,
-0.0254716426,
-0.0553524047,
0.0389385298,
0.0558606647,
-0.0647243485,
-0.0278816763,
0.0022215317,
0.0447011515,
0.0085466625,
-0.0157386549,
0.040058706,
0.0310097616,
-0.0106981546,
0.0280958991,
-0.0023682246,
0.0636845082,
0.0057561165,
-0.0000607344,
-0.0072041187,
0.0244476553,
-0.0121475738,
0.0082501741,
-0.0642015859,
0.0303096138,
-0.0054122377,
0.0068163034,
-0.0189936366,
-0.0265971124,
0.0080695413,
0.0379874334,
-0.0171699859,
0.0608338676,
-0.0113505125,
-0.0317490064,
-0.0095085967,
-0.0272141527,
-0.0537072308,
-0.0371236429,
-0.0240981895,
0.0793632939,
-0.0253055375,
0.0378728099,
0.0175801236,
0.0346118435,
0.0167462751,
-0.0789299086,
0.0320091993,
0.0071731284,
0.0016813646,
0.0972361341,
-0.0420124643,
0.0669488311,
0.0371962376,
-0.021754751,
-0.0051991534,
0.0034067004,
-0.1228669658,
-0.014271548,
0.0155559294,
0.0696058646,
0.0468561947,
-0.0160485934,
-0.0059732147,
0.0598675199,
-0.0204245914,
0.0514616631,
-0.0375486687,
-0.0245156437,
-0.0105468379,
0.0113310944,
-0.0482851788,
0.0516736023,
0.0043094298,
0.0219690781,
-0.0300913975,
-0.0502623692,
0.0167134479,
-0.0056091328,
-0.0017165139,
0.0075371601,
-0.0152634317,
0.0660688132,
-0.0091720959,
-0.0215419531,
-0.0394517966,
-0.0228508897,
-0.0051706573,
-0.0300384648,
-0.0369922556,
-0.0386472493,
0.0044779317,
-0.0200100839,
0.0095535405,
-0.0067019723,
0.0029735998,
-0.0157848205,
0.0080619259,
0.0248568244,
0.0135542601,
0.0331650451,
0.0315349288,
-0.0112796864,
-0.0026598033,
0.0907212198,
-0.0033410683,
-0.0342362784,
0.0603254884,
0.0147496657,
-0.0168437213,
0.0263411738,
0.0284018032,
0.0528625548,
-0.0589312911,
0.0434799939,
0.0451995246,
0.0284340419,
-0.00190904,
0.0030503173,
-0.0275060777,
0.0457580276,
0.0885580182,
-0.0161047298,
0.019357292,
0.0260012336,
0.0216278322,
-0.0118225496,
0.0266790353,
0.0026530386,
-0.0222485177,
0.0157259665,
-0.0394195318,
0.0272597391,
-0.0502871647,
0.027049752,
-0.0186950509,
-0.0281089358,
0.0146944169,
-0.0037717812,
-0.0581660867,
0.0097025707,
0.065198496,
-0.004717452,
-0.000098439,
0.0831756815,
0.02618495,
-0.0094064185,
0.002592003,
-0.050018508,
0.0201421902,
0.0677604899,
0.0465206467,
-0.0579725318,
-0.1004707366,
-0.035299927,
0.0108976867,
-0.00373498,
0.0193619337,
-0.0429214351,
0.0252998397,
0.0072675217,
-0.0305405874,
-0.0206814688,
0.0190361142,
-0.0040235533,
0.0557113662,
0.0498423241,
-0.0105655706,
-0.0494078435,
-0.0451362878,
0.0256872997,
-0.0588477589,
-0.0034342317,
-0.0142104225,
0.0068704807,
-0.0166589934,
-0.0038544638,
-0.016152909,
-0.0022486052,
0.0448550992,
-0.0468381792,
-0.0287405867,
0.0294856317,
-0.0252971426,
0.0011419343,
0.1108177081,
-0.001708851,
-0.0014619712,
-0.0289826822,
-0.031755168,
-0.0119398516,
-0.0235774443,
0.0070175123,
0.0789504424,
-0.0378663652,
-0.0093909549,
-0.0420811474,
-0.0344495736,
-0.0287914127,
0.0612254553,
-0.0304039679,
0.0232396908,
0.0274264719,
-0.0221862085,
-0.0007947969,
-0.0550052039,
0.0092252847,
-0.0114223184,
-0.0070355847,
0.0157015845,
0.0217023306,
-0.0080988593,
-0.0610121936,
-0.0328976959,
-0.0813196972,
-0.0063762111,
0.0024758831,
0.0006985803,
0.0282889381,
-0.0308781117,
-0.0094174938,
-0.0128287338,
-0.018393863,
0.0004551243,
-0.0154606346,
0.0311466474,
0.0310004745,
0.0216775779,
0.0012608008,
-0.0362852439,
0.0115905739,
0.0071837045,
0.0386785567,
-0.0270539802,
0.0188050084,
-0.0402584337,
-0.008146273,
-0.0763211846,
0.0258411076,
-0.0107856821,
-0.0060624895,
-0.0112156728,
-0.0343850702,
0.0292609837,
0.0514693223,
0.0361332223,
0.0102677047,
0.0802870616,
-0.0214873981,
-0.040843375,
0.0070095607,
-0.0247691553,
-0.0364942364,
-0.0410895087,
0.0357831791,
0.0117644537,
0.0376271829,
-0.0287496429,
-0.0260977447,
-0.0098251393,
0.0273013711,
-0.0579894483,
0.0088698566,
-0.1039965227,
0.002918286,
-0.0190757588,
0.0030118967,
0.0003715708,
-0.0713571459,
0.0513316095,
0.0215855781,
0.0338731594,
-0.0171310492,
-0.0287954099,
-0.0069563063,
0.0592235625,
-0.0338151418,
0.0351797715,
-0.0004841882,
0.0002532372,
-0.0695051327,
-0.0251408536,
0.0912666991,
-0.0429765359,
0.0346970148,
-0.0482761897,
0.0234825909,
0.0094897412,
-0.0069949459,
-0.0672298372,
-0.0256287325,
-0.0355802402,
-0.0088718999,
-0.05568159,
0.0154171828,
0.0132251056,
0.0185552929,
0.0477870479,
0.0156083424,
0.0000635075,
-0.0271786954,
-0.0033175375,
0.0452663042,
0.0723185167,
0.0529601462,
0.0056430283,
-0.017539721,
0.0536843538,
0.0319177806,
0.051170487,
-0.0180337206,
0.0042787339,
0.0011392746,
0.0052312789,
-0.034832608,
0.0115040224,
0.0121995127,
-0.0091088004,
-0.0363686755,
-0.0139198778,
0.134316802,
0.0236017909,
-0.0318755992,
-0.0042064954,
-0.0322214216,
0.0163784847,
0.0221668221,
0.0384578109,
-0.0589985698,
0.016109908,
0.0051176301,
0.0303341001,
-0.0086080618,
-0.0656954944,
-0.0378663726,
-0.091201283,
-0.0529043861,
-0.0015401625,
-0.0315217227,
0.0206717979,
-0.0184554886,
-0.0243005157,
-0.0279529281,
-0.0147131048,
0.025505282,
-0.0231842753,
-0.0000815796,
0.0309577715,
-0.0589552857,
-0.0403522886,
0.0748767257,
-0.0279139914,
0.0485741347,
0.0452957228,
0.0380756892,
0.014325981,
-0.0563122146,
0.0620582737,
-0.0075312122,
0.0027575418,
0.0042558536,
0.0127023635,
-0.0199957229,
-0.0015347897,
0.0020793714,
-0.0028921701,
-0.0127302408,
0.0180344414,
0.0427166447,
0.0829327181,
0.0204309542,
0.0386403725,
0.0250555631,
-0.0563116223,
0.0212586503,
0.0592095256,
-0.0196550414,
-0.0324209072,
0.0133820055,
0.0091164149,
0.0189027283,
-0.0000439355,
-0.0094010886,
0.0038403964,
-0.0516235307,
0.0118433386,
-0.0710556954,
0.0220603906,
-0.0062172902,
0.0686846599,
0.0163757913,
0.0129818944,
0.0508303083,
0.0223714709,
-0.0387147553,
-0.0136185372,
-0.0510781035,
0.0044140392,
-0.0462467261,
-0.0099945478,
0.0717537329,
0.0130595379,
-0.015234963,
-0.026783688,
-0.0741337612,
-0.0509465039,
0.0149093578,
0.0539563894,
0.0234333221,
0.0589726493,
-0.0216030348,
-0.0007970504,
0.0029333066,
-0.0060459729,
-0.03537843,
0.0075737056,
0.0304254945,
0.0236795563,
0.0036853575,
0.0448819436,
-0.0423110612,
-0.0360166989,
0.0057940753,
0.0316650234,
-0.0296990871,
-0.031327758,
0.0232044533,
-0.0067788996,
0.0016857595,
0.0164614823,
-0.0504889898,
-0.0222301353,
0.0298285875,
0.044153031,
-0.0206150841,
-0.0186856426,
0.0283119548,
0.0162545629,
-0.0155218616,
0.0173827671,
0.0239286143,
0.0431673415,
0.0262584854,
-0.0144474776,
-0.0588377975,
0.0248044208,
-0.0114725279,
0.0407277234,
0.0136125293,
-0.0389897786,
0.0175395515,
-0.0225056987,
0.033513777,
-0.0074827853,
0.0384320244,
0.0220271442,
-0.0064743217,
0.0054894839,
0.0050632493,
-0.0407603234,
-0.0874507651,
-0.0294510908,
0.0367395654,
0.092902787,
0.0112610869,
0.0645086244,
-0.0197977144,
-0.0098045841,
-0.044731427,
-0.0042049997,
0.0002859604,
-0.0310419295,
-0.0133271692,
0.0295198224,
-0.0001529338,
0.0851487592,
0.1019198895,
-0.0119238086,
0.055027876,
-0.0216113776,
-0.0068025114,
-0.0423306748,
0.0332856402,
-0.0222849771,
0.0141365733,
0.0070435284,
0.04775846,
-0.0469992124,
-0.0546384677,
0.0406711474,
-0.0020155092,
-0.0136061478,
-0.0060541038,
0.0185151659,
0.0559947342,
0.0209697615,
0.0119481729,
-0.051879108,
0.0391835086,
0.0277834218,
0.0246365648,
0.01508654,
-6.346092863e-33,
-0.0178088546,
-0.0099557666,
0.0315051638,
-0.0219622087,
-0.0819819868,
0.0399036407,
-0.0266023856,
-0.0019402739,
-0.0199175254,
-0.0170299616,
0.0173091833,
0.0260566734,
-0.0041969256,
-0.0006092611,
0.0395898968,
-0.0336441882,
0.0138141233,
0.0097476849,
-0.0168751143,
0.0205765963,
0.0723624006,
0.037613187,
0.0179508179,
-0.0317153223,
0.0313068554,
0.0112022189,
0.0072202152,
0.0720893443,
0.0296558924,
0.0664566979,
-0.0503675714,
0.005852866,
0.0223004185,
-0.0542082898,
-0.0169197153,
-0.0653081685,
-0.0743622482,
-0.0310907401,
-0.0128948698,
-0.0019969239,
-0.009711748,
-0.0014526865,
-0.0025253457,
0.022764463,
0.0157266576,
-0.0141981253,
0.0320150331,
-0.0503595434,
-0.0768144503,
-0.0175904986,
-0.0333892591,
0.0157230403,
-0.0251600016,
-0.0175194982,
-0.0130704949,
-0.014121972,
0.0172411855,
-0.0647730678,
-0.0757424384,
0.0311315618,
0.0167168435,
0.0424961299,
0.0489690937,
-0.0066974163,
0.0380706415,
0.0500208773,
-0.0515110679,
0.0047888528,
0.0131038362,
-0.0091331378,
0.0354621708,
0.0022517829,
-0.009466853,
0.0228603967,
0.0145833325,
-0.0143056409,
-0.0491000339,
-0.0088399546,
0.0612764508,
0.0680830851,
0.0173781384,
0.0017340455,
0.0061592669,
0.0042997305,
-0.055010803,
0.0533712395,
-0.0278124996,
0.0004519006,
0.0367593914,
0.0400216021,
-0.0387356319,
-0.067786701,
0.0114507508,
-0.0426162072,
-0.0454294086,
0.0313292444,
-0.0073378924,
0.0201585069,
0.0176856313,
0.0294664595,
-0.0548705347,
0.0140265487,
-0.0474366657,
-0.0084743286,
-0.015726218,
0.0059314496,
0.0233111102,
0.06519337,
-0.0445559844,
0.0092043635,
-0.0214985982,
0.0066306833,
0.0106829507,
0.0223246254,
0.0222871415,
-0.0123597821,
-0.014340559,
0.0553192198,
0.0425378345,
-0.0294988435,
-0.0156077677,
0.039537441,
0.0380758345,
0.0214591324,
-0.0260108151,
-0.0313071907,
-0.0266657006,
0.0260904003,
-0.0206003208,
-0.0570126697,
0.0031972905,
-0.0271712188,
2.691e-7,
-0.0133697698,
0.025067905,
0.0166401602,
-0.0008435224,
0.0567295626,
0.0121604381,
-0.0639267564,
-0.0144854495,
0.0094944835,
-0.0030305104,
-0.016185401,
0.0345617086,
0.0256364103,
0.0388691239,
-0.054797437,
-0.0225036368,
-0.0463512763,
0.0045806784,
-0.0392934084,
-0.0040459791,
0.0126195522,
0.0293391459,
0.0190645624,
-0.002517899,
0.0172375105,
-0.0813634619,
0.0855689719,
0.0211938675,
0.0225355569,
-0.0104614506,
0.0444634445,
0.0560273528,
-0.0138603421,
0.009039497,
-0.0171989072,
-0.0111011732,
-0.0298848189,
0.05317159,
0.0043625468,
-0.0206808075,
-0.0051065641,
-0.0060604918,
0.0068886583,
-0.0605729967,
0.0996212438,
-0.0632750094,
0.0213166159,
-0.0545716062,
0.0126735521,
-0.0267923083,
-0.0055469438,
0.017977085,
-0.0495158024,
0.0157378409,
-0.0122669693,
0.0465395562,
-0.0164427124,
-0.0575103797,
-0.0101096202,
0.0194824226,
-0.0038919421,
-0.0880171359,
-0.0280073732,
-0.0328650363,
0.0101299956,
-0.0481415428,
0.0470081605,
2.115591596e-34,
0.0080881212,
0.0128994463,
0.0003673902,
0.0760104358,
0.0060174665,
-0.0341439322,
0.0085530486,
-0.0275016557,
0.0205500629,
-0.0591277704,
0.007917922
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09630v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09630v2 | Decoding Susceptibility: Modeling Misbelief to Misinformation Through a Computational Approach | 2023-11-16T07:22:56 | 2024-02-16T09:12:21 | Yanchen Liu, Mingyu Derek Ma, Wenna Qin, Azure Zhou, Jiaao Chen, Weiyan Shi, Wei Wang, Diyi Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.SI | Susceptibility to misinformation describes the degree of belief in
unverifiable claims, a latent aspect of individuals' mental processes that is
not observable. Existing susceptibility studies heavily rely on self-reported
beliefs, which can be subject to bias, expensive to collect, and challenging to
scale for downstream applications. To address these limitations, in this work,
we propose a computational approach to model users' latent susceptibility
levels. As shown in previous research, susceptibility is influenced by various
factors (e.g., demographic factors, political ideology), and directly
influences people's reposting behavior on social media. To represent the
underlying mental process, our susceptibility modeling incorporates these
factors as inputs, guided by the supervision of people's sharing behavior.
Using COVID-19 as a testbed domain, our experiments demonstrate a significant
alignment between the susceptibility scores estimated by our computational
modeling and human judgments, confirming the effectiveness of this latent
modeling approach. Furthermore, we apply our model to annotate susceptibility
scores on a large-scale dataset and analyze the relationships between
susceptibility with various factors. Our analysis reveals that political
leanings and psychological factors exhibit varying degrees of association with
susceptibility to COVID-19 misinformation. | [
0.004969649,
0.0669963211,
-0.025900932,
-0.0204267781,
-0.0037942524,
-0.0118704615,
-0.0088009667,
-0.0385133214,
0.0550333187,
0.0064005787,
0.0076362952,
-0.0081873527,
-0.0367088392,
0.0321091786,
0.0241735708,
-0.0514713749,
0.0345018171,
0.0355124213,
0.087576516,
-0.0412347391,
0.0108042369,
-0.0164817162,
-0.0208758879,
0.0282089431,
0.0073835561,
-0.0314540267,
0.0417672135,
0.0140300551,
0.0499913618,
-0.0604953691,
0.0158772487,
0.031267155,
0.0430453345,
0.0290024299,
0.0000020814,
-0.0225325711,
-0.0341962315,
-0.0132025545,
-0.0116337296,
0.021869177,
0.0688542277,
-0.0032652975,
0.0101608206,
0.0525312796,
-0.0386614166,
0.0195502322,
0.0599731058,
0.0308524296,
0.0741689503,
0.02746238,
-0.0222828314,
-0.0147895515,
-0.0027943933,
0.0184823647,
0.0354381651,
-0.0016723928,
0.0515227616,
-0.008032945,
-0.0463151522,
-0.0005037684,
0.0043284409,
0.0055756643,
-0.017831469,
0.0092136124,
-0.036521256,
-0.0078646205,
0.0042933999,
-0.0474057123,
-0.0082691787,
0.0319196582,
0.0532296449,
-0.0349791534,
0.0350249,
-0.0081002386,
0.0214333907,
0.1212471351,
-0.0452015884,
-0.0110441158,
-0.0240427982,
0.0055492446,
-0.0017513988,
0.0152048552,
0.0636904016,
0.0080816522,
0.0339234844,
0.0678748414,
-0.0110594863,
-0.0244919378,
-0.0038030585,
-0.0429674052,
0.0018189205,
-0.0483526997,
0.0300331302,
-0.0238548443,
0.0068215108,
0.0099158818,
-0.0150339883,
-0.0355349183,
0.0445219427,
-0.0743219182,
-0.0004738626,
0.0119267171,
0.0099625569,
0.0380164981,
0.0526527092,
-0.0310858227,
-0.0719768777,
-0.0288707074,
0.0413435511,
0.024560513,
-0.0195270125,
0.0345551111,
0.0384189114,
-0.0357237123,
0.0600960292,
0.0373513885,
-0.051726222,
-0.0143240206,
-0.0625175312,
-0.039943736,
-0.0488420315,
-0.0293878745,
-0.0110558961,
-0.0021823107,
-0.0242360998,
0.0558294654,
-0.0457519069,
0.0303165149,
-0.0046316171,
-0.0314177424,
-0.0039785649,
-0.00216623,
0.0070496765,
-0.0005217569,
0.0148567744,
-0.0349723324,
0.0470491908,
0.025891887,
-0.0352021195,
-0.0229734797,
-0.011820917,
-0.0374845117,
0.0084901517,
-0.0418857932,
0.0195115153,
0.0391533934,
0.0044287252,
-0.053658098,
-0.0182485394,
0.012523111,
-0.0769097432,
0.0453271307,
0.0006286435,
0.0198506042,
0.0172411688,
0.0461064167,
-0.0212786458,
0.0198394209,
-0.0107245725,
0.0875833407,
0.0342158489,
0.0092462953,
0.0297469143,
-0.007950509,
0.0692313835,
0.031107448,
0.0359260887,
-0.0015563946,
-0.0249638651,
-0.0499947071,
0.0114366924,
0.0126798339,
-0.0042073298,
-0.0086516151,
0.0693724081,
-0.0037937367,
-0.0494391695,
-0.0091693802,
-0.0045521911,
0.0358309262,
-0.003022155,
-0.0174296144,
-0.0493046045,
0.0385212526,
-0.0312511921,
-0.0183644518,
0.0447845794,
0.0582007393,
-0.0119345505,
0.0074000712,
-0.0296466146,
-0.003398316,
0.0363322273,
0.0202484988,
-0.0257813148,
-0.0484536365,
-0.0207838044,
-0.0023599844,
0.0593844876,
-0.0187042374,
-0.0041950396,
-0.0506150872,
0.032937821,
0.0240312368,
0.0053665149,
-0.0165332388,
0.0300885476,
-0.0315546282,
0.0574016981,
-0.0255772173,
0.0641804859,
0.0022665879,
-0.065174602,
0.0038385019,
-0.0059116548,
-0.0000871864,
0.0522969998,
0.0270772595,
0.0325499661,
0.0260919388,
-0.0458267517,
-0.0163022764,
0.0264164321,
0.0189693589,
0.0035148503,
0.0032161134,
-0.061177738,
0.0246193446,
0.1049329266,
0.0181545187,
0.0566932671,
0.0007081659,
0.0313507989,
0.0190154295,
-0.0325610228,
-0.0057510431,
0.0390618332,
0.0661385432,
-0.0044454974,
-0.0290016029,
-0.0191127937,
0.0096698673,
-0.009764296,
0.0350923128,
0.0598661974,
0.0129938088,
0.0149388202,
-0.0146522159,
-0.0442863218,
-0.0337526836,
0.0299969018,
0.0480179042,
0.0410071462,
-0.0642409772,
-0.0282974243,
0.0201336127,
-0.0967298448,
0.0067917188,
-0.0035135387,
0.0001969719,
-0.0946586281,
-0.0080512548,
-0.009577373,
0.02025076,
-0.1006597802,
-0.020659266,
-0.0052280552,
-0.0037007669,
-0.0477065034,
-0.0032843319,
0.0221906863,
0.0362500288,
-0.0196231492,
-0.0126242843,
0.0046447455,
-0.0085948855,
0.0229399316,
-0.0034052227,
0.0753307268,
-0.0090571428,
-0.039644599,
-0.0127036124,
-0.0405310057,
0.0163311046,
-0.0266537368,
-0.0089486986,
0.0655203089,
-0.0495289266,
0.0199695192,
-0.0239461008,
-0.0799715146,
0.0056566126,
-0.0310154092,
-0.0408575647,
-0.0180383082,
0.0102957301,
0.0026014841,
-0.0080911051,
0.0264104269,
0.0393998548,
0.0515439361,
0.056567423,
-0.0143687325,
-0.0341079757,
-0.0779983848,
-0.0432819612,
-0.0069360598,
-0.0829053074,
-0.0130060771,
0.0371737443,
0.0442707874,
-0.0004097232,
-0.0370692164,
0.0558026396,
-0.0263608322,
-0.0723526999,
0.0265238266,
-0.0126637165,
0.017234806,
0.0544186644,
-0.02355716,
-0.0548743643,
0.06020068,
0.028885467,
0.0739698634,
0.0323788784,
0.0131286504,
0.0114454562,
-0.0156756379,
0.0347374231,
0.0114291441,
0.0295115765,
0.0657555386,
0.0297719799,
-0.0281484891,
0.0293432493,
-0.0279161539,
-0.0483586676,
-0.0149434414,
-0.0207116064,
0.0390477814,
-0.0089052301,
-0.0210354514,
-0.0831264481,
-0.0260165893,
-0.0354121998,
0.0053324774,
-0.030665718,
-0.0822548866,
-0.0414945558,
0.0454145037,
-0.0534921885,
0.0289729442,
-0.0168668758,
0.0474764407,
-0.0563721918,
0.0077722459,
-0.0083459634,
0.0629959628,
-0.0526809134,
-0.0292688739,
0.039747294,
0.0244873594,
0.0298603568,
-0.0253748801,
-0.0330037214,
-0.0024145725,
0.0297094546,
0.0370734222,
0.0428821631,
0.0378374383,
0.0050203125,
0.0525066778,
0.0477838367,
-0.0032408426,
0.0194121189,
0.0091306958,
-0.0436847061,
0.0314301923,
0.0421875045,
0.0083113201,
-0.0250383206,
0.0072622225,
-0.0304003861,
-0.0099500353,
-0.0525553636,
-0.0397377238,
-0.0084787095,
0.0004816824,
0.058460854,
-0.0034646199,
0.033175271,
-0.0293698944,
-0.0867284685,
0.0151572507,
-0.022582233,
-0.0195466299,
-0.0228937566,
0.03788881,
0.0020693394,
-0.0322509184,
-0.0752620026,
-0.0473898612,
0.0340551287,
-0.0149045642,
0.0267739259,
-0.0035718947,
0.0468629152,
-0.0043613599,
-0.0613602214,
-0.0213125013,
0.0213616583,
-0.0537051,
0.0004666561,
0.0994512588,
-0.0231665615,
0.0390146263,
-0.0611090921,
0.0541785993,
-0.0375341997,
-0.0441527702,
0.0028669718,
0.0848052129,
0.0193542279,
-0.0628277287,
-0.0431361683,
0.0310149919,
0.0636787042,
0.0481718294,
0.0083148982,
-0.0049984865,
0.0236307513,
-0.0250224508,
0.0240716282,
0.0203269534,
-0.0337828584,
0.0101854866,
0.0124991564,
-0.0354287438,
-0.0262596179,
0.0077951429,
-0.0349890664,
-0.0411671884,
-0.0211702697,
-0.0238296855,
0.0660734028,
-0.042011112,
-0.0579907298,
0.0040619299,
-0.002689491,
0.0276505426,
0.0039142533,
-0.0112406081,
-0.0060713212,
-0.0127223656,
-0.0282144938,
0.016162876,
-0.0291443653,
-0.024475826,
0.0636609271,
0.0286035091,
0.0197038483,
-0.0071582198,
-0.0151576931,
0.0089823278,
0.0588463098,
0.008334266,
-0.0468812287,
0.0062312158,
0.0288177412,
0.0164738316,
0.0165347699,
0.0017988142,
0.0023421729,
0.0248048473,
0.0340585001,
-0.0541576222,
-0.0662379637,
-0.0007708555,
0.025934007,
0.0018014819,
0.0409310125,
-0.0003521329,
-0.0144940605,
-0.0201940238,
-0.0554047078,
0.0162063297,
-0.0089504868,
0.0416912064,
-0.0417737328,
0.0320013426,
-0.0360039696,
-0.0293990057,
-0.0177266002,
-0.0117064519,
-0.0088029793,
-0.024877727,
0.0163324922,
-0.0003645505,
0.0737099722,
-0.0166553855,
-0.0105879884,
0.0177257154,
0.0114518618,
-0.0360618457,
-0.0013963541,
0.0157256033,
0.0256348327,
-0.0451268405,
0.0011779054,
0.0385673568,
-0.0007123678,
-0.0349037386,
-0.0277498029,
-0.0053815572,
0.0101473611,
-0.0240897611,
0.0373658128,
0.0244579874,
-0.0259317756,
-0.0328807123,
-0.0168408174,
0.0120501835,
-0.0013433376,
-0.0071697626,
0.0394028388,
-0.0091331312,
-0.0423257723,
0.023775965,
0.0385669582,
-0.0113837188,
0.0303348899,
-0.0069709332,
-0.0869808272,
-0.0168097261,
-0.0308521073,
-0.0396279469,
0.0667952895,
-0.0138837723,
0.0447578803,
-0.0928822607,
-0.0340485983,
0.0304177944,
0.0235759486,
-0.017997602,
0.0078260787,
-0.0396323167,
0.077585876,
-0.0026727822,
-0.0132167358,
-0.0098717874,
0.0121212527,
-0.0496364571,
-0.0147064785,
-0.0310818981,
-6.835764136e-33,
0.0145156598,
-0.0520536825,
-0.0330936909,
0.0280924775,
0.0255157407,
-0.0069410335,
0.0010423405,
0.0009300378,
-0.0330807194,
0.0298495684,
0.0074868803,
0.0348021872,
-0.0017414027,
-0.0108874086,
-0.0059988871,
-0.0125109367,
0.0506083779,
0.0028491751,
-0.0284361709,
-0.0039262376,
0.0429671444,
-0.006077901,
-0.0226500574,
-0.1116702631,
0.0547022261,
-0.0173384175,
0.0192928594,
-0.0037343716,
-0.0062403716,
0.023394702,
-0.0307484902,
0.0103944372,
0.0428997539,
-0.0075089778,
0.0120681329,
0.0738893151,
-0.0387773924,
-0.0181425568,
0.0074852398,
-0.0510256886,
-0.0230879784,
-0.0161311347,
-0.0262339097,
0.0054648789,
-0.0284494497,
-0.0208303276,
0.0162563398,
0.0026540512,
0.0616005659,
0.038528502,
-0.0280831903,
-0.0125517529,
0.0117012756,
0.0408263467,
-0.0557810366,
0.0965790153,
-0.0089215487,
0.0657375082,
-0.081052348,
0.0563509949,
-0.0465441532,
-0.0208933167,
0.0400813147,
-0.0379429907,
0.0116706938,
0.0511546135,
0.0016992504,
0.0031074085,
-0.0864653662,
-0.0298823975,
-0.0333230235,
0.0095901061,
0.0511960275,
0.1019147784,
0.0446379669,
-0.0648356602,
-0.0554789975,
-0.0053427545,
0.0309650935,
-0.0022862158,
0.0487461574,
0.0137991589,
-0.0250941534,
0.0026133964,
-0.0312440004,
-0.0240739956,
-0.0404872261,
-0.0085732499,
-0.0094798915,
0.0264329072,
-0.0363248102,
0.0081814695,
0.0005368807,
0.0179688949,
-0.0130473915,
-0.0197194163,
0.0605277792,
-0.0081363004,
0.0095502045,
0.0488264002,
-0.0492501855,
0.0632422417,
-0.0192372501,
0.0017367091,
0.0254928377,
-0.0093028285,
0.0085728131,
0.0300837103,
-0.0457470715,
-0.0038842722,
-0.0033520798,
0.0239739865,
-0.0219460987,
-0.0130411778,
0.04682035,
0.0231694505,
0.0119921984,
-0.0641865209,
0.0325885229,
0.0387992635,
0.0067386837,
-0.0148315607,
-0.0692531392,
0.0436884835,
-0.0082857823,
-0.0074062585,
-0.0262237005,
0.0028742899,
-0.0383608826,
-0.0970842093,
-0.0096776262,
-0.0264751017,
2.858e-7,
0.0446845889,
0.0466579981,
-0.03217398,
0.0279232487,
0.0538846105,
0.034116853,
-0.0001312468,
0.0017466701,
0.0199189056,
-0.0888570696,
-0.0166240856,
0.0211570393,
-0.0051840125,
0.0114702806,
0.0097151715,
-0.0284327418,
-0.0130780805,
0.0239628945,
-0.0073892958,
-0.0116274888,
-0.0136738773,
0.0090444284,
0.0556621216,
0.0229758546,
-0.0292205364,
0.0520218834,
0.0531939901,
-0.0263479445,
-0.0020374556,
0.0106344074,
-0.005467623,
-0.0004732587,
-0.0000397009,
0.0480398647,
-0.0354026034,
-0.0469657779,
-0.0262816083,
0.014245755,
0.0264833886,
0.0061870501,
-0.0182210356,
-0.0104070073,
0.0046138661,
-0.047711689,
0.0023915877,
-0.0813303441,
-0.0722561479,
0.009233675,
-0.0572866723,
0.033864934,
0.0276908446,
0.0348919369,
-0.0341889858,
-0.0333525538,
0.0072476142,
0.0499393903,
0.0068739834,
-0.0202049594,
0.0004799767,
-0.0421788394,
-0.0718573108,
-0.0545536689,
0.0035064893,
-0.018501278,
0.0275950488,
0.0023400078,
0.0383271165,
2.538555356e-34,
0.0450299978,
0.0081726015,
-0.0243280157,
-0.1004635096,
0.0341343209,
-0.0167230051,
-0.0099165561,
-0.0108120563,
0.0429470539,
-0.0256611109,
0.0105974181
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09627v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09627v2 | Mitigating Biases for Instruction-following Language Models via Bias Neurons Elimination | 2023-11-16T07:16:55 | 2024-06-05T05:49:19 | Nakyeong Yang, Taegwan Kang, Jungkyu Choi, Honglak Lee, Kyomin Jung | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Instruction-following language models often show undesirable biases. These
undesirable biases may be accelerated in the real-world usage of language
models, where a wide range of instructions is used through zero-shot example
prompting. To solve this problem, we first define the bias neuron, which
significantly affects biased outputs, and prove its existence empirically.
Furthermore, we propose a novel and practical bias mitigation method, CRISPR,
to eliminate bias neurons of language models in instruction-following settings.
CRISPR automatically determines biased outputs and categorizes neurons that
affect the biased outputs as bias neurons using an explainability method.
Experimental results demonstrate the effectiveness of our method in mitigating
biases under zero-shot instruction-following settings without losing the
model's task performance and existing knowledge. The experimental results
reveal the generalizability of our method as it shows robustness under various
instructions and datasets. Surprisingly, our method can mitigate the bias in
language models by eliminating only a few neurons (at least three). | [
0.0225509834,
0.0321533866,
-0.0322644152,
0.0471243262,
0.0086508812,
0.0410216749,
0.0347668789,
-0.013434317,
-0.0082823476,
-0.0005381289,
-0.0262023434,
0.0477089025,
0.0180724654,
0.0071572168,
0.0616108179,
-0.0216820203,
0.0949709415,
-0.0197172929,
0.0273812562,
-0.0147872325,
0.0107333623,
0.0427429974,
0.0026706473,
0.0425758883,
0.0244541895,
-0.0219289884,
-0.0076195388,
0.0139462538,
-0.0272487178,
0.002730066,
0.0125427926,
0.0090373065,
0.0115970774,
0.0360036641,
0.0000024197,
-0.0007022107,
0.0067247991,
0.0004174918,
-0.0939291939,
0.0121995835,
0.0550503843,
0.0007122594,
-0.0214340091,
-0.0060129571,
0.0022400685,
0.0145937363,
0.0903146118,
0.0291286223,
0.0533582047,
0.0675961301,
0.0111642685,
-0.0544830896,
0.0307390541,
-0.0103555489,
0.0528389029,
0.0118705556,
-0.0058922549,
-0.0355334617,
-0.0007589375,
0.0169215184,
-0.0155250812,
0.0178284142,
0.0401264541,
-0.0076087653,
-0.0029509554,
0.0242483206,
0.0187781565,
-0.0295014866,
-0.01341045,
0.0344249494,
-0.0499623604,
-0.0416552387,
0.0107220495,
-0.0299544372,
0.0207362454,
-0.0466820784,
-0.0387917049,
0.0221170112,
0.0159157049,
0.0264414828,
0.0398935117,
-0.027756948,
0.0393370017,
-0.0172843803,
0.0262125712,
0.0595950112,
0.0055135447,
-0.0147229088,
-0.0439196788,
-0.0062647425,
0.0233634021,
-0.0539356582,
-0.0313980468,
0.0242633726,
-0.0611893497,
0.0428326018,
-0.0618232824,
0.0141515573,
0.0084924595,
-0.051041916,
0.0739255175,
0.0503697842,
-0.0019171907,
-0.0099337753,
-0.0429208837,
0.0402635522,
-0.0274726599,
0.0756238848,
0.0053861635,
0.0610286817,
-0.0644501522,
-0.0353231579,
0.000987775,
0.0149111683,
-0.0117224194,
0.0099665923,
-0.0070234877,
0.0382881202,
-0.0285017602,
-0.0016472451,
0.0072846073,
0.0051265,
-0.0584304817,
0.0251816902,
-0.0223503672,
0.0470902845,
-0.0322990268,
0.0117106866,
-0.0060418737,
-0.0743630454,
-0.0473702513,
0.0069777439,
-0.0210825838,
-0.0501526594,
0.0062213298,
0.0870262608,
-0.0156158283,
-0.0118747177,
-0.0583997406,
-0.0378566831,
-0.0075826696,
-0.015029937,
-0.0069020842,
-0.0414632261,
0.0118812863,
-0.0043832292,
-0.0210228283,
-0.0315205678,
0.0187974963,
0.0142258545,
-0.0783567578,
0.0633234754,
-0.0301724095,
-0.0107997693,
0.0280942507,
0.0088828169,
-0.0042109005,
0.0404367931,
0.0232353117,
-0.0063713556,
0.0119171012,
-0.0148293274,
0.0277493484,
0.0039723343,
0.0412934311,
-0.0092650531,
-0.0307384972,
-0.0450483151,
-0.0212073456,
-0.0093338564,
0.059599448,
0.0086123673,
-0.0182974469,
0.0089331958,
0.0684896931,
-0.0190550853,
0.0124591356,
-0.0191515386,
0.0414136425,
-0.0081219571,
-0.0354946889,
0.0310094748,
-0.0838878825,
0.0495673157,
-0.0171539765,
0.0216033757,
-0.0248901937,
0.0232511815,
-0.0293232668,
-0.0594422668,
0.0136216525,
0.0065631191,
-0.0088401763,
0.0111678429,
0.0215982124,
0.0343555212,
-0.0708813593,
0.0558883771,
0.0419918597,
-0.0224188156,
0.0040780492,
-0.1096812487,
0.0063761878,
0.0544403866,
0.0538735054,
-0.0141794868,
-0.0576855466,
-0.0147503233,
-0.0069840192,
0.0339044407,
0.0008640559,
-0.0058446634,
0.022890063,
-0.0270064119,
-0.0288479924,
-0.0433362238,
0.0246714056,
0.0048654568,
0.0213154666,
-0.0419080928,
-0.0214625429,
-0.0208852515,
-0.0645721033,
0.0527655482,
0.0159880184,
-0.0624817237,
-0.0212236904,
0.0030092183,
0.0217852108,
-0.0052563054,
-0.023000678,
0.0242037904,
0.0366695561,
-0.0174335856,
0.0263407752,
0.0003458943,
-0.0794349313,
-0.0863499045,
0.0016038916,
0.0068865479,
-0.0031144486,
0.014338444,
-0.0161806252,
-0.0228626058,
0.0184340551,
-0.0455689579,
0.0690984577,
-0.000879069,
0.0255410634,
-0.0210984796,
-0.0125567,
-0.0400161631,
0.0280500744,
-0.0111909127,
-0.0144496411,
0.0080357725,
-0.0127687864,
-0.0174612366,
-0.0503236279,
-0.0320385359,
0.0001746796,
-0.0330405049,
0.0019113872,
0.0110231014,
0.003057641,
-0.0070872093,
-0.0121247107,
-0.0160595998,
0.0104832454,
-0.0031220892,
0.006276872,
0.0183490235,
-0.0143346721,
0.0050454335,
-0.0228124876,
-0.0168191306,
0.0025108866,
-0.0028108067,
0.0259475335,
0.0275195278,
-0.007264927,
-0.0390965007,
-0.0433015637,
-0.038106557,
-0.0581184588,
0.0405647904,
-0.0057673268,
-0.0142755099,
-0.0720753893,
0.0473387316,
0.0028921519,
0.0086207846,
-0.010457864,
-0.0399536341,
0.05533842,
0.0155370031,
-0.0382872373,
0.0826736689,
-0.0335465781,
0.0458852872,
0.0631182194,
0.0231817551,
-0.0530592762,
-0.0115664769,
-0.0264204387,
-0.0083928602,
-0.0064338781,
-0.0485493094,
-0.0026502674,
0.0994514897,
0.0590712093,
-0.0010254092,
-0.0621780343,
0.0412739925,
-0.0052513098,
-0.0478807874,
0.0087432275,
-0.0605588257,
-0.0383653268,
0.0187046248,
-0.0576370545,
-0.0706563294,
0.0651005059,
-0.0045005209,
-0.0064989151,
-0.0125140129,
0.0386737287,
0.0143534113,
-0.0098845018,
0.0387967825,
0.0374446958,
0.0458271652,
-0.0171283875,
-0.0394836888,
-0.0217923429,
-0.0045936294,
0.0091474829,
-0.0130305402,
-0.0381450281,
-0.0491810702,
0.0392217971,
0.0156799983,
-0.0349893495,
0.0282207094,
0.0161010865,
0.0059293672,
0.0656059831,
0.0027448842,
0.0129906684,
-0.0174926613,
0.0382110961,
0.0510433055,
-0.0421477035,
-0.0127500659,
-0.0571901314,
-0.0159779675,
0.0226141475,
-0.0648431331,
0.0222082511,
-0.039899148,
0.0404595956,
0.0260858815,
0.0089693898,
0.0183765814,
-0.0507618561,
0.0398721546,
0.0082647214,
-0.0229201186,
-0.0168897696,
0.06186698,
0.0803320408,
-0.0487128049,
-0.020276662,
0.1079877391,
0.0286493674,
-0.0725127459,
0.0322978161,
0.0073878071,
0.0243430976,
0.0374568589,
0.0519702546,
-0.104011558,
-0.0422973372,
0.0141186947,
0.0204630699,
-0.0223840922,
0.0066041653,
0.0001917688,
-0.1028176695,
0.0306491069,
0.0101951184,
-0.0134553174,
-0.0159933213,
-0.0106982468,
-0.0154774934,
-0.0035324639,
0.0251353215,
0.0345291272,
0.0151676396,
0.0187895596,
0.0340999961,
0.0194630586,
-0.0479597636,
0.0057987566,
-0.0121768918,
0.1209540963,
0.114572987,
-0.0003391082,
0.0265274663,
-0.0079017272,
0.0337690972,
0.0060515357,
0.0206929985,
-0.024363948,
0.0866600424,
0.0078591416,
-0.0306246001,
-0.0248912405,
0.0398018956,
0.0119704884,
-0.0083954372,
-0.0397903249,
0.0546747521,
-0.0019461862,
-0.0394694693,
-0.0168997776,
-0.0357251391,
-0.0121742729,
0.0629502237,
0.0696537867,
-0.0360973999,
-0.0015785622,
-0.0458464921,
-0.0253079757,
-0.0434996076,
-0.0575446412,
0.0124441693,
-0.027903555,
-0.0631000251,
-0.0381914973,
-0.0413612314,
0.0058891447,
-0.0093747396,
0.0204019882,
-0.0421105213,
-0.0030276289,
-0.042353224,
-0.0109623438,
-0.0022857757,
0.012046149,
0.0062836246,
-0.1084759235,
-0.0525847822,
-0.0267043207,
-0.0390482992,
-0.0118693197,
-0.0078649875,
-0.0226911139,
-0.0713092834,
-0.0011075207,
0.1185295433,
0.0219709706,
0.043474555,
-0.002501678,
-0.0451239459,
0.0347146839,
0.0509657711,
-0.0106728813,
-0.001063382,
0.0435086563,
-0.0215115119,
0.0096622966,
0.0162034947,
0.0037485685,
0.0448261574,
0.050780803,
0.0302669033,
-0.0466637686,
0.014818076,
0.0468555801,
-0.0061147683,
0.055753991,
-0.0101350099,
0.0080622034,
-0.0339340195,
-0.0067191948,
-0.0113847191,
-0.0109299105,
-0.0318583325,
0.0009124572,
0.0108689945,
0.0022976762,
0.0062489645,
-0.0572343133,
-0.0456836559,
-0.0361978076,
-0.0365194716,
0.0297815893,
0.0056621265,
0.0646948963,
-0.007674085,
0.0499470234,
-0.0164035838,
0.0746820122,
-0.0424966551,
0.0187946372,
-0.0137806553,
0.0711718947,
0.0263929572,
0.0408583432,
-0.0177788045,
0.0366228931,
-0.0289166514,
0.0030489792,
-0.0233005714,
-0.0058029159,
-0.0129199252,
-0.0196779296,
0.0655748025,
0.0407382213,
0.0210113898,
0.0107125062,
0.0438164137,
0.0369787179,
-0.0429012291,
0.015849309,
0.0252216291,
0.0069024307,
-0.086973533,
0.0543856621,
-0.0162503701,
0.0734758526,
-0.0273579638,
-0.0086390367,
-0.0157611836,
-0.0149644241,
0.0307958424,
-0.0405777581,
-0.0228890032,
-0.0064588767,
-0.0231766421,
-0.060358122,
-0.0471187942,
0.0360001139,
0.0305713508,
-0.0166870411,
0.015773464,
0.0120639028,
-0.0036734878,
-0.0940150172,
-0.0138518214,
-0.0038331256,
-0.0110988254,
-0.0136655392,
-0.0328039378,
-6.773972806e-33,
-0.0479139686,
-0.0162202381,
0.0024725648,
0.0029131398,
0.019540783,
0.00000201,
-0.0762126967,
-0.0089449203,
-0.0244158059,
0.0233167354,
-0.0000158224,
0.0152798053,
-0.0010961529,
-0.015013447,
0.0289065726,
0.0172813423,
0.0530214533,
-0.0031473613,
-0.0296134073,
0.0410948545,
0.0088726552,
0.0007451706,
0.0646487325,
-0.0166958738,
0.063734822,
0.0235222131,
-0.0099792751,
0.0046720793,
-0.0299746338,
0.0577810481,
0.0078613237,
0.008391045,
0.0128624262,
-0.0717041194,
-0.0391183197,
-0.0080649406,
0.0024765022,
0.0000636626,
0.0240994506,
0.0157150012,
0.0279308967,
-0.0870545954,
0.0353280865,
-0.0229872279,
-0.0506592281,
0.0142676346,
0.023333529,
-0.0049990602,
0.0025672438,
0.0539795347,
-0.0903957114,
-0.0099465912,
-0.0116365487,
-0.0459716134,
0.0102643026,
0.0156354569,
-0.0162055455,
-0.0124266157,
-0.0144105135,
0.0273059309,
0.0978926718,
0.0530438684,
0.0856263861,
0.0166502446,
-0.0205789674,
0.0346552171,
0.0594284758,
0.0174338147,
-0.0378505439,
0.0009924887,
0.0215227362,
0.0238803681,
0.0786939338,
-0.011683383,
0.0485760309,
-0.0086781625,
-0.0164375976,
-0.0091695413,
0.023203833,
0.048388999,
0.0382357053,
0.014169151,
-0.0381543711,
-0.0568238012,
-0.0065783868,
-0.0646795928,
-0.0368893966,
-0.0234081615,
0.0359366722,
-0.0380794965,
-0.0065723117,
-0.0030356257,
0.0220482852,
-0.0167510714,
0.030275533,
0.0302753933,
-0.0190866068,
0.0159474257,
-0.0091836983,
-0.0177498348,
-0.0481195934,
-0.0049936539,
0.0322817937,
-0.0015378911,
0.0396382585,
0.0311014634,
0.0302441716,
0.0026310193,
-0.0174526088,
-0.005321118,
-0.0898338184,
-0.0064748586,
0.0423477665,
0.0370600596,
0.0122062638,
0.0068756542,
-0.0234675612,
0.0119394418,
0.0014993305,
-0.0314407535,
-0.0487348922,
0.0279156994,
-0.0460265391,
0.0505626053,
-0.0631283149,
-0.0056517902,
-0.0373856835,
0.063060917,
-0.0241750367,
-0.0752250701,
-0.0376269408,
-0.0164305251,
3.006e-7,
0.0231681187,
0.0553081706,
0.0095694335,
0.0344292074,
0.0075945836,
0.0439842455,
0.0254986659,
0.0131452223,
-0.0233804733,
-0.0139309559,
-0.0133220647,
0.0348075181,
0.0105826668,
-0.0038799238,
-0.0166516546,
-0.0021362577,
-0.0600116178,
0.0661564097,
-0.0284018815,
0.0065062293,
0.0401657484,
0.0409232154,
0.0094145667,
-0.0047008209,
0.0262894407,
0.0259777904,
-0.0030700651,
0.001051689,
0.0442239456,
-0.0020262797,
-0.0132566802,
-0.0165690817,
-0.005863803,
0.0075510973,
-0.0056999982,
-0.0344270431,
-0.0720029026,
0.0508730002,
-0.0559574775,
-0.0177434571,
0.0125492532,
0.00137339,
-0.0300428886,
-0.0429900549,
0.0294920914,
-0.0432553142,
-0.0168506354,
-0.0298070088,
0.0038151303,
0.0105224326,
-0.0086396532,
-0.0133249117,
-0.0048234244,
-0.0043218378,
0.0030258433,
-0.0075924452,
-0.0222736821,
-0.0485311113,
-0.0448805727,
0.0055088806,
-0.0009609507,
-0.0328166671,
-0.0455666855,
0.0468916669,
-0.0009436365,
-0.0498929583,
-0.0216100495,
3.053975649e-34,
-0.0122214593,
0.0049013789,
0.0520877838,
0.0085448986,
0.0445676446,
-0.0011290869,
-0.005130433,
0.012048821,
0.0302326977,
-0.0522218086,
-0.0635800213
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09619v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09619v2 | Take One Step at a Time to Know Incremental Utility of Demonstration: An Analysis on Reranking for Few-Shot In-Context Learning | 2023-11-16T07:03:54 | 2024-04-02T21:05:40 | Kazuma Hashimoto, Karthik Raman, Michael Bendersky | cs.CL | cs.CL | In-Context Learning (ICL) is an emergent capability of Large Language Models
(LLMs). Only a few demonstrations enable LLMs to be used as blackbox for new
tasks. Previous studies have shown that using LLMs' outputs as labels is
effective in training models to select demonstrations. Such a label is expected
to estimate utility of a demonstration in ICL; however, it has not been well
understood how different labeling strategies affect results on target tasks.
This paper presents an analysis on different utility functions by focusing on
LLMs' output probability given ground-truth output, and task-specific reward
given LLMs' prediction. Unlike the previous work, we introduce a novel labeling
method, incremental utility, which estimates how much incremental knowledge is
brought into the LLMs by a demonstration. We conduct experiments with
instruction-tuned LLMs on binary/multi-class classification, segmentation, and
translation across Arabic, English, Finnish, Japanese, and Spanish. Our results
show that (1) the probability is effective when the probability values are
distributed across the whole value range (on the classification tasks), and (2)
the downstream metric is more robust when nuanced reward values are provided
with long outputs (on the segmentation and translation tasks). We then show
that the proposed incremental utility further helps ICL by contrasting how the
LLMs perform with and without the demonstrations. | [
0.0134114232,
0.028992964,
0.0042758905,
0.0132908598,
-0.0294365734,
0.0324730054,
0.0341858566,
0.002608126,
-0.0285784565,
-0.0376915075,
-0.0451602824,
-0.0281104017,
0.0124639403,
-0.0361004993,
0.0426793955,
-0.0684879199,
0.0286795441,
-0.0576561913,
-0.000015778,
-0.0036033015,
-0.0419426635,
-0.0302295368,
-0.0188504029,
0.0289513618,
0.0107323518,
0.0072661764,
0.0086323451,
-0.0181586649,
0.0246339124,
-0.0549907684,
-0.0129923932,
0.0524695963,
0.039294295,
0.0026754346,
0.0000023933,
-0.0729683191,
-0.0220103189,
-0.0073480494,
-0.0476015843,
-0.0120175527,
0.0352674089,
0.0024534499,
-0.0245428439,
0.0124090463,
-0.0344018005,
-0.0093801022,
0.0311819948,
0.0129732331,
-0.0036895431,
0.0595719554,
0.0175810903,
-0.0562094189,
0.0022716727,
-0.0617949739,
0.0332827009,
-0.0546193048,
0.0194899309,
-0.0045750868,
-0.0195127279,
0.0305029694,
-0.0179287605,
0.0359312482,
0.0555792525,
0.0005520515,
0.0050877887,
0.0630406216,
-0.0124121299,
0.0115693752,
0.0071167261,
0.0159678329,
-0.0660087988,
-0.0081571471,
-0.0218363497,
-0.0184756201,
0.0346919633,
-0.0452663302,
-0.0644149184,
0.0336599946,
0.0102787931,
0.0348553397,
0.049175743,
0.0739605725,
0.0318859741,
0.0252116825,
-0.0484363288,
0.0428554527,
-0.032127969,
-0.0381752998,
0.0364267007,
0.0012873616,
-0.0452227257,
-0.0435589738,
-0.0299393255,
0.0245432723,
-0.0298895352,
0.0495066904,
-0.0152762951,
-0.0316895805,
-0.0087085553,
-0.0515634902,
0.0332551152,
0.03454227,
0.0046649398,
0.0462068878,
-0.0403794535,
0.0675383434,
0.0258476604,
0.0712923631,
-0.0593471266,
0.03399859,
-0.0481663458,
-0.0034104376,
-0.0192024782,
0.0414018854,
-0.0027582548,
0.0040072738,
-0.0634029359,
0.0206395276,
-0.0343202576,
0.0225662403,
-0.0005052258,
-0.045836892,
-0.0560478084,
0.0065348968,
-0.0255669169,
0.0097397221,
0.0114583345,
0.0087975701,
0.0126026655,
-0.0220314488,
-0.0040130834,
0.0000632277,
-0.0279784184,
-0.0026090599,
0.019227162,
0.0605419278,
-0.0638365671,
-0.0951696634,
-0.0071553122,
-0.0089782299,
-0.0100279255,
-0.0510972776,
0.0142717436,
-0.071823895,
-0.0043828669,
0.0107490579,
0.0254518371,
-0.0045266203,
-0.0023692169,
0.0049413862,
0.0116275288,
0.0399500653,
0.0845270827,
0.0249869414,
0.0353294611,
0.01736347,
0.0061578476,
0.095692493,
0.020726813,
0.0183139518,
0.0286122225,
0.0209054518,
0.0046011857,
0.0494719632,
0.0275647677,
0.0428665392,
-0.0633022115,
-0.0056912801,
0.0465394408,
0.0378306918,
0.0153839886,
-0.0374027118,
-0.035226997,
0.0399153382,
0.0791348964,
0.0414751843,
0.0004188715,
-0.061857976,
-0.0007198728,
0.0060988674,
-0.0016853114,
0.0193045437,
-0.04729167,
0.0195395593,
0.0237399507,
0.0107307183,
0.0373605527,
-0.0054037101,
-0.0276234876,
-0.0645791963,
-0.0021097849,
-0.0096132699,
0.0145754525,
0.0246014073,
0.0919889435,
0.0413306952,
-0.0325956531,
-0.0084472857,
0.0153758274,
0.0212436188,
0.0111317392,
-0.0981630385,
-0.0065830061,
0.0300848503,
0.0330858529,
-0.0480406322,
-0.0007582669,
-0.0107686063,
0.0417864919,
0.0247410312,
0.018675847,
-0.0326305442,
-0.0059843771,
-0.0160662793,
-0.032276962,
-0.0130992504,
0.0193051752,
0.0073607881,
0.0335902721,
0.0049968939,
-0.0126247741,
-0.0693601817,
-0.0221468899,
0.0403446816,
0.0061646993,
-0.0327826664,
0.0118963905,
0.0236639027,
0.0355450995,
-0.0202200599,
-0.0008446542,
0.0059008594,
0.0258864444,
-0.0331825241,
0.0132783987,
0.0183012765,
-0.0595471859,
-0.0754332617,
0.0025352223,
0.0312112719,
-0.011061999,
-0.0351718068,
-0.0590799935,
-0.0187021811,
0.0025300502,
-0.0050927107,
0.0240503065,
-0.0157976877,
0.0427818596,
-0.019674819,
-0.0374859385,
-0.0743173882,
0.0904246867,
-0.027282171,
0.0229941644,
0.0140087362,
-0.0224010274,
-0.02645717,
-0.0380005874,
-0.0084752068,
0.0257348735,
-0.0103707286,
0.0021750911,
0.0045867139,
0.034929838,
-0.0176853854,
-0.0104238242,
-0.056110587,
0.0075452002,
-0.0275722612,
0.040551044,
-0.0041915104,
-0.0149878934,
-0.0046964465,
-0.0428224839,
-0.0200260729,
-0.0406934246,
-0.0145373782,
0.019544322,
-0.0022983029,
0.0470186844,
-0.0016354165,
0.0010652759,
-0.0167791154,
0.0440037549,
0.0635274276,
-0.0061221858,
-0.0055607264,
-0.06332542,
0.0484002009,
0.0170074273,
-0.0049377042,
-0.0413689725,
0.0025705001,
0.0313607454,
0.0052223969,
0.0417000279,
0.0885463953,
0.0089026364,
0.0603403598,
0.0477323607,
0.0317658558,
-0.0529114343,
-0.01771749,
-0.02724839,
-0.0464170985,
-0.0624131709,
-0.0062301168,
0.0046214871,
0.041639071,
-0.0015935341,
-0.0139197512,
-0.0367350094,
-0.0028247593,
-0.0455654822,
-0.0368392691,
-0.0758709982,
-0.0061018253,
-0.0165937189,
0.0149720469,
-0.0116177872,
-0.0671010241,
0.0624232925,
0.0134933721,
0.0145686306,
-0.057407178,
-0.0148580326,
0.0014512698,
0.0456438549,
0.0097623589,
0.0142569877,
-0.0480636321,
-0.0323529877,
-0.0784959123,
-0.0002390061,
-0.0021173169,
-0.0309690386,
0.0420115851,
-0.0593780093,
-0.0036934216,
-0.011372867,
-0.0483176634,
-0.0336011983,
-0.0184370726,
0.0210594665,
0.0290222298,
-0.0287180524,
0.0505171157,
-0.0103337485,
-0.0010098427,
0.0718002394,
0.0782520771,
-0.0108384239,
-0.0135030709,
-0.0058355164,
-0.0258781277,
-0.0160028152,
-0.0030124662,
-0.0186673533,
-0.068633616,
0.0052299378,
0.014690944,
0.0674669296,
-0.0245303493,
-0.0122073954,
-0.0215385891,
0.0260439757,
-0.027056409,
-0.0322681628,
0.0432491265,
0.0394352786,
-0.074038364,
-0.0056738099,
0.0722893253,
0.0087624677,
-0.0394238569,
0.0216243938,
0.0245947074,
-0.0050871852,
0.0411190912,
0.0211174842,
-0.0628261045,
-0.005310182,
0.0088699721,
0.0410922095,
-0.0193853024,
0.0007881804,
0.0091105578,
-0.1562031358,
0.0294581838,
0.016788153,
-0.0867384672,
-0.0043784925,
-0.0375875533,
-0.0034189008,
0.0036092505,
-0.016795991,
0.0099946698,
-0.0129103521,
0.0083790515,
0.0592171922,
0.0367973186,
-0.0983284563,
0.0026986003,
-0.0255131386,
-0.0022590121,
0.0547117442,
-0.0048437002,
-0.0149047021,
-0.0175027177,
0.0540332235,
-0.0182734504,
0.0109149832,
-0.0066067977,
0.0231700726,
0.0118989022,
0.0024586378,
0.015581728,
0.0146538494,
0.0312881805,
-0.0257201158,
-0.0108625544,
0.0437186658,
-0.0042649601,
0.0212721042,
0.0158651341,
-0.0606203228,
0.0273900274,
0.0343520418,
0.0119454311,
-0.0566656813,
0.0121422736,
-0.0023356637,
0.0136826327,
-0.0246883612,
0.0205875803,
0.0220740065,
-0.0586576536,
-0.0194689948,
-0.0674312413,
-0.0017956032,
0.0170810353,
0.0650638863,
-0.0044291946,
0.0003439304,
-0.0293019451,
0.0027030807,
-0.0294317584,
-0.0048648496,
-0.0029423914,
0.0169658046,
-0.0775169432,
-0.0149650341,
0.0355736725,
-0.0622467101,
-0.0413685702,
-0.0274066795,
-0.0551473238,
-0.049909059,
-0.0087660216,
0.0657325983,
0.0179484263,
0.0502432771,
0.0124873612,
-0.0586874373,
0.1018256843,
0.0505820215,
0.0327988863,
0.0384737924,
0.0373087712,
0.0327505469,
-0.0183239188,
0.0217243042,
-0.0277658291,
0.0127016148,
0.0378848016,
0.0115796253,
-0.029146865,
0.0263073333,
-0.0014027292,
-0.0403623134,
0.0610213056,
-0.0523716696,
-0.0262853485,
-0.0477939658,
0.0588706061,
0.010309333,
-0.0240827911,
0.0015889016,
-0.0077172872,
0.0259943195,
0.0317013115,
0.0065548895,
0.0161974952,
0.0247966275,
0.0046935272,
-0.0215197317,
-0.028174499,
-0.0012824833,
-0.0182305686,
0.0100680785,
0.0591817982,
-0.0136020547,
-0.0253403224,
0.0190979168,
0.028870225,
-0.0087042293,
0.066270262,
0.034108866,
-0.0075821723,
0.0076248674,
0.0428097919,
-0.0300163031,
-0.0015253059,
-0.0422111489,
0.0245383922,
0.0326008908,
0.0101166638,
0.047974959,
-0.0160884205,
-0.0166610349,
-0.0257402603,
-0.0037525005,
-0.0398930982,
-0.0859804153,
0.0179523602,
0.0210814383,
0.0162219293,
0.0356984809,
0.088977471,
-0.0090221157,
0.0157652423,
-0.0202308577,
0.0195942204,
-0.0200674534,
0.0046645845,
0.0430512764,
0.0301503763,
-0.0029220211,
0.0201753769,
-0.0287618451,
-0.0420467779,
-0.0568605438,
0.0209887531,
0.0010087426,
-0.0280688424,
0.0394927189,
0.0729274154,
-0.0410131551,
-0.0403217971,
-0.055546321,
-0.0289214607,
0.0290056448,
-0.0183981471,
-0.0013021625,
-6.751573761e-33,
-0.0318705253,
-0.0340864211,
0.0170192681,
-0.0034486742,
0.0181275997,
0.0071705943,
-0.0164725985,
0.0059126681,
0.0189693607,
0.0153560881,
-0.0077377995,
-0.0298005436,
0.014684923,
0.0193675011,
0.0301635377,
-0.0170498509,
0.047519166,
-0.0030360618,
-0.0492073633,
0.0204056408,
0.0417458341,
-0.0109108053,
0.1085815206,
-0.0500082448,
0.0248272717,
0.0215114225,
-0.0308667179,
0.039601896,
-0.0075978129,
0.0577262305,
0.0230617467,
0.037202213,
0.0390192345,
-0.0894353315,
-0.0306291468,
-0.0255427398,
-0.0516568832,
-0.0175003074,
0.0041671456,
0.0422541797,
-0.0245258864,
-0.0011534381,
0.0320999436,
-0.0028830355,
-0.0433430783,
-0.0052799182,
0.0259822756,
-0.0359361432,
-0.0427432843,
-0.0156110497,
-0.0531420112,
0.0162020512,
0.0182554834,
-0.0424001515,
0.0322275981,
0.0258948486,
-0.0240663923,
-0.026484536,
-0.0785982013,
0.0419512801,
0.0259461496,
0.0450505055,
0.0711030886,
0.0560136661,
0.0179910474,
0.0327676684,
0.0067968285,
0.0209711976,
0.0724579096,
-0.0705912411,
0.0568226799,
-0.0033501424,
0.0262058806,
-0.0004171722,
0.0737221017,
0.0200646054,
-0.0779699534,
0.018506838,
0.0257685687,
0.002846193,
0.0593261793,
0.0318147317,
-0.0621750355,
-0.0481130891,
-0.0492586344,
-0.0086460365,
-0.0069773234,
-0.0208171494,
0.0393645242,
0.0643935278,
-0.0014067023,
0.0052336087,
0.0478690453,
-0.0078742625,
-0.0533205792,
-0.0032013333,
-0.0286988951,
0.0485150479,
-0.0160491969,
-0.0281969216,
-0.0759685934,
-0.0457120761,
0.0025423747,
-0.0009242265,
0.0032061511,
-0.0056372727,
0.0745370314,
0.0378347188,
-0.0569269769,
0.022205336,
-0.0208196603,
0.0088553224,
0.036344897,
0.0241523739,
0.0523744896,
-0.012452363,
-0.0222407747,
0.0671259239,
0.0252779722,
-0.0671289116,
-0.0162408277,
0.0134818098,
-0.0421624891,
0.0047748387,
-0.0311363544,
0.032553684,
-0.0054091127,
0.034035597,
0.0193880741,
-0.0332597494,
-0.0337167419,
0.0272148997,
3.117e-7,
0.016419068,
0.0467514768,
-0.0478076525,
0.0132576153,
0.0303060003,
0.0482551157,
-0.028430324,
0.0165754203,
0.0408632495,
-0.0069170827,
0.0009240874,
0.0134327989,
0.053788159,
0.002006002,
-0.0696679875,
-0.0379254073,
-0.0376279503,
0.0168218296,
-0.0389947854,
-0.0214111395,
0.0007557094,
0.0815680847,
0.0067761433,
0.0202356055,
-0.0073729195,
-0.0176876038,
0.0577580333,
-0.0313420407,
0.0162405483,
-0.0039630746,
-0.0109190717,
0.0557339787,
0.0042330669,
0.0231186133,
-0.0280083306,
0.0200430509,
0.0255983565,
0.0537747443,
-0.0026037628,
0.0131318932,
0.0130701391,
0.0257385429,
-0.0051367553,
-0.0818624571,
0.048907388,
-0.1185464039,
-0.0118797626,
0.0154598346,
0.0226745196,
-0.0288211405,
0.0071466547,
0.0028502571,
-0.0197859872,
0.0216186065,
0.0106112612,
0.0261215344,
-0.0185019579,
-0.044728592,
-0.0303027295,
0.0446412526,
-0.0426438674,
-0.0559749715,
-0.0219246875,
0.0401558392,
-0.0290205702,
-0.0411943868,
-0.0316242464,
2.876695948e-34,
0.002911604,
0.0105430475,
-0.0023443736,
-0.0014051249,
-0.0100972354,
0.0022658133,
-0.0542923883,
0.0164200328,
0.0264389422,
-0.0200669337,
-0.0180885755
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09618v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09618v4 | Simulating Opinion Dynamics with Networks of LLM-based Agents | 2023-11-16T07:01:48 | 2024-04-01T01:12:35 | Yun-Shiuan Chuang, Agam Goyal, Nikunj Harlalka, Siddharth Suresh, Robert Hawkins, Sijia Yang, Dhavan Shah, Junjie Hu, Timothy T. Rogers | physics.soc-ph | physics.soc-ph, cs.CL | Accurately simulating human opinion dynamics is crucial for understanding a
variety of societal phenomena, including polarization and the spread of
misinformation. However, the agent-based models (ABMs) commonly used for such
simulations often over-simplify human behavior. We propose a new approach to
simulating opinion dynamics based on populations of Large Language Models
(LLMs). Our findings reveal a strong inherent bias in LLM agents towards
producing accurate information, leading simulated agents to consensus in line
with scientific reality. This bias limits their utility for understanding
resistance to consensus views on issues like climate change. After inducing
confirmation bias through prompt engineering, however, we observed opinion
fragmentation in line with existing agent-based modeling and opinion dynamics
research. These insights highlight the promise and limitations of LLM agents in
this domain and suggest a path forward: refining LLMs with real-world discourse
to better simulate the evolution of human beliefs. | [
0.0073292986,
0.0465733372,
-0.0251603387,
0.005943717,
-0.0309580993,
-0.042446617,
0.0119145205,
-0.0272403304,
0.0361906141,
0.0049737878,
0.0221890509,
-0.0260725487,
-0.0348647311,
0.0136067839,
-0.01123654,
-0.0475453697,
0.0164714586,
-0.0232109725,
0.0550410599,
-0.0715664402,
0.0216060691,
-0.0085585387,
-0.0009010883,
0.010068398,
0.0084398752,
0.0126398262,
-0.0243369713,
-0.0015931736,
0.0659734532,
-0.0117888469,
-0.0137470998,
0.0285192505,
0.0459667072,
0.0271682441,
0.0000018342,
-0.0032597189,
0.0057708402,
-0.0038505367,
-0.0015438267,
0.0077293613,
0.1010078862,
0.0328867733,
-0.0015214406,
-0.0055104489,
-0.0601875111,
0.0362839848,
0.0324356332,
-0.0057147802,
0.0699600801,
0.0386020355,
0.0289784484,
-0.0108433953,
0.0129910652,
-0.002871878,
-0.0306853522,
-0.0069873366,
0.0500067957,
-0.0049402434,
-0.0091992924,
0.0304208677,
-0.0112582445,
0.0041301744,
-0.0158070643,
-0.0181485582,
-0.021243738,
0.0418706946,
0.0184712876,
-0.0214896239,
-0.0185295213,
0.0615661517,
0.0537337326,
-0.0309913531,
0.0149408765,
-0.0225513037,
0.0192888621,
0.0612806566,
-0.0267485771,
0.0340259969,
-0.0081229974,
0.0328675583,
0.002352824,
0.0205107071,
0.0314041749,
0.0196454898,
0.0046805148,
0.0599576794,
-0.0058931801,
0.0010192398,
-0.0107825575,
-0.0017111637,
0.0239436626,
-0.0550072007,
-0.0117472094,
-0.0213089492,
-0.0176989418,
0.0278180391,
0.0046791956,
0.02843027,
0.014108994,
-0.0863334015,
0.0099942721,
-0.0030196491,
0.0493643023,
0.0542515442,
0.0559328869,
-0.0163429286,
-0.0336564891,
0.0242695305,
0.0275726095,
0.0154142613,
-0.0570046231,
0.0275153946,
0.0253734831,
0.0014283024,
0.0087028397,
0.0146921035,
-0.0142532634,
-0.016696047,
-0.0773927197,
-0.0131818084,
-0.039581798,
0.0211675856,
0.0323341787,
-0.0137076899,
-0.0753201544,
0.0582891069,
-0.0483079366,
0.0369847454,
0.0150685944,
-0.0109411692,
0.0068873302,
-0.0087124519,
0.001495774,
0.0355746113,
0.0037020326,
0.0238416176,
0.0326435491,
0.0188293159,
0.0053040017,
-0.0159941409,
0.0026764069,
-0.0335426517,
0.0066515277,
-0.0631193295,
0.0334964767,
-0.0127860885,
-0.0026428448,
-0.0348223932,
0.0006186171,
-0.0095029799,
-0.0450314693,
0.0700941384,
-0.0445280373,
-0.0033567466,
0.0481730737,
0.015852388,
0.0066158404,
0.0506751724,
0.0008219185,
0.0174710564,
0.0200475268,
0.0176282823,
0.0377252884,
0.0136668216,
0.0253114272,
0.0505019054,
0.0047749635,
-0.0220288746,
-0.0447375812,
-0.0045745131,
0.0163219832,
0.0532113165,
-0.0263923015,
-0.0413185805,
0.0679475069,
0.0187788811,
-0.1044996232,
0.0144498395,
-0.0012428785,
0.0372797027,
0.0031405683,
0.0161797591,
-0.0045267493,
0.0327723622,
-0.0153231416,
-0.0149033023,
0.024133293,
0.0450264998,
-0.0437368639,
-0.0112668397,
0.0248441081,
-0.0088470792,
0.0370441899,
-0.0064340881,
-0.0116005065,
-0.046053417,
-0.0168775078,
0.0221518259,
0.0340242721,
-0.0259718746,
-0.0064925281,
-0.040014226,
0.0110387085,
0.0432834513,
0.0210977849,
0.0048316591,
-0.0386580415,
-0.0291392189,
0.0108713061,
0.0699608997,
0.0616237223,
-0.0161971133,
-0.1087569445,
-0.0211586226,
-0.0155553073,
0.0277814101,
0.0250198022,
0.0558470041,
-0.0130678089,
0.0093284175,
-0.0353688262,
-0.0029729134,
-0.0312166419,
0.0092445407,
-0.0526696853,
0.0229389966,
-0.0552869327,
-0.0248394031,
0.0839931369,
0.0254387204,
-0.0360997729,
-0.0094575118,
0.0272100829,
0.0192899574,
-0.0767289624,
0.0446743481,
0.0033832728,
0.0430931225,
0.0366726853,
-0.0228947271,
-0.0271646101,
-0.0187726803,
-0.0018021935,
-0.0042739282,
0.0459802747,
0.0062953117,
0.0136027467,
-0.00146464,
-0.0386454612,
-0.0543064401,
-0.0007901493,
-0.0084238537,
0.0240893606,
-0.0241560284,
-0.0481888726,
0.0211481731,
-0.0239894185,
0.0196509827,
0.0053341039,
0.0017280407,
-0.0287839174,
0.0549202077,
0.0169935133,
0.0639932752,
-0.0612772033,
-0.0144530758,
-0.0265116487,
-0.0272546597,
-0.050587602,
0.0092635769,
0.0015139251,
0.0189935025,
-0.0493323095,
0.0003893897,
0.0546053573,
-0.0288194455,
0.0359088369,
0.0050833812,
0.0106993401,
0.0214884486,
-0.019714715,
-0.0526206866,
-0.0612922013,
0.0272708032,
-0.0196266603,
0.0096413158,
0.0596163087,
-0.0009919084,
-0.0387704335,
-0.009228481,
-0.0720497742,
0.0244315565,
-0.0303086918,
-0.0526311845,
0.031867668,
0.0120126195,
0.0286901481,
0.0202844981,
0.0316652805,
0.0239896011,
0.0488384739,
0.0395509824,
-0.0773011595,
-0.040363159,
-0.0643334687,
0.0198345501,
-0.0713553429,
-0.0672288314,
0.0073724748,
0.0502803214,
0.0057125706,
-0.0073468047,
-0.0081901699,
0.0570141524,
-0.0013324678,
-0.0287874583,
0.0212412644,
-0.0420758538,
-0.009417179,
0.0546203442,
-0.0236517545,
-0.0250277538,
0.0732616484,
-0.0017678449,
0.0556994639,
-0.0297020748,
0.0081753125,
-0.0091196541,
0.0121285748,
0.0226996895,
-0.0136491153,
0.0257681776,
0.072346203,
-0.046106182,
-0.0677421689,
0.0183404665,
-0.0161131527,
0.0236164946,
-0.0658264458,
0.0143316863,
0.0259719659,
0.0179203022,
0.0142125227,
-0.0534902737,
-0.0373529531,
0.0134507241,
0.0611504242,
-0.0310855638,
-0.0248559825,
0.0000488812,
0.0597521849,
-0.0489109643,
0.021337796,
0.0046189642,
0.0010609527,
-0.0055023278,
0.0350468531,
0.0115112904,
0.0496089831,
-0.0541526936,
0.02471851,
0.0426949784,
0.0177852828,
0.0011895595,
-0.0472968742,
-0.076889202,
-0.0044343555,
0.0056056683,
0.0267602354,
0.0015208137,
0.0282677114,
-0.0181390941,
0.0263095275,
0.0696472377,
0.022424547,
-0.0419376977,
-0.0241587348,
-0.0039335201,
0.0195349753,
0.0283305515,
0.0087060137,
-0.0528795086,
0.0301852021,
0.0007899333,
-0.0179586746,
-0.0214135833,
-0.0568279922,
0.0076589119,
-0.090108186,
0.0284869429,
0.0137862097,
0.0406600237,
0.016540153,
-0.0737683848,
0.014739112,
-0.0117686735,
-0.0340500623,
-0.0258343928,
0.082745038,
0.0115526775,
-0.0091752168,
-0.0472264476,
-0.0055264123,
0.0392440483,
-0.0431386083,
0.0992450342,
0.0365704633,
0.0540124364,
-0.0432253107,
-0.0597200841,
0.0444253162,
0.0288817976,
-0.0402372144,
0.0184659995,
0.0192345884,
0.0148710664,
0.012188972,
-0.0192862693,
0.0105214827,
-0.0020326914,
0.0139705623,
0.01189976,
0.0726572946,
0.0082208551,
-0.0818000659,
-0.0568256229,
0.0295341089,
0.0386001952,
0.037272457,
0.0066680172,
-0.04193528,
-0.0401943624,
-0.0562913641,
-0.018288007,
-0.0073570535,
-0.0824776068,
-0.0283194557,
-0.0046595298,
-0.009734978,
-0.0126758739,
-0.0188995898,
-0.0338899642,
-0.0165217202,
0.0284102373,
-0.0138095245,
0.1079030931,
-0.022713583,
0.0366413295,
-0.0100591369,
-0.0334937237,
0.0114230532,
0.006141352,
-0.044726003,
0.0388200767,
0.0039739879,
-0.0169344824,
0.0194736701,
-0.0118393973,
-0.0875392333,
0.044547461,
0.0533513278,
0.0238937307,
0.0192112196,
0.0116082439,
-0.0113800988,
0.036189042,
0.0203488115,
0.0035015282,
0.0147101423,
-0.0009388749,
0.0521278195,
0.0108086998,
0.0326849297,
0.012562044,
0.0564408228,
0.0250418503,
-0.0138259334,
-0.1125844195,
-0.0529853292,
0.0101307426,
-0.0311149117,
0.0008970308,
0.0189765003,
-0.0255547836,
-0.0229713023,
-0.0354349166,
-0.0178331695,
-0.0107400222,
0.0240363721,
-0.047445491,
0.0053575458,
-0.022925904,
-0.0039102305,
0.0374225117,
-0.0079533253,
0.0351336226,
0.0355858989,
0.0386045687,
0.0089755403,
0.0303521659,
0.0180282407,
-0.0268342067,
0.0195434559,
0.0042059515,
-0.0472320691,
0.0111644529,
0.0346888043,
-0.0015304475,
0.0054511875,
-0.0342176855,
0.0108925663,
-0.0242755823,
-0.0413494781,
-0.0574983098,
0.0236781184,
0.0483710319,
-0.0105611682,
0.0557400361,
0.0140723707,
-0.0380960479,
-0.0121487426,
-0.0116597675,
-0.0169935394,
0.0017194687,
-0.0103946477,
0.0400085822,
0.0030076245,
-0.0576204024,
0.0066145631,
0.024085138,
-0.011624069,
0.0297656003,
0.0082281427,
-0.0416368507,
-0.018599188,
-0.0215430353,
-0.0460907891,
-0.0331116579,
0.0005475365,
0.0053526661,
-0.0815339684,
-0.0239673145,
0.0403635651,
0.0553422868,
0.0036107895,
-0.0282542948,
0.0037934871,
0.038607914,
-0.0251450446,
0.0560962185,
-0.0242767986,
0.0429922901,
-0.0746332705,
-0.0115654087,
-0.0039091432,
-5.965875541e-33,
-0.0072048921,
-0.0400277525,
0.0239086207,
0.0102601657,
-0.0074459766,
-0.0273808204,
-0.0443886891,
0.0254853219,
-0.0259564426,
0.0642428398,
0.0185605958,
0.0208538398,
0.0126472218,
-0.0203475412,
0.0208150297,
-0.0012925472,
0.0424043834,
-0.0619017109,
-0.0035144831,
-0.0049879407,
0.0171163231,
-0.0301537924,
-0.026128944,
-0.0807945952,
0.0518417172,
0.004755077,
-0.0168068763,
-0.0246087369,
-0.0406373478,
0.0058105411,
-0.0211264119,
0.0432020985,
0.0051250891,
-0.0487380512,
-0.0236230195,
0.0317994207,
0.0123775918,
-0.0000815628,
0.0012581851,
-0.0444952399,
-0.0025137851,
0.0091835791,
0.000495279,
0.0169765763,
-0.0745104179,
0.059164919,
0.0306054018,
-0.0337552726,
0.0186880156,
0.0183992554,
-0.0433215983,
0.0095102834,
0.006069982,
0.022813566,
-0.0517887175,
-0.0224258788,
-0.0082449298,
0.037882261,
-0.0857655033,
0.0603770725,
0.0531311817,
-0.0245090351,
0.0137767829,
-0.007932106,
0.0305667762,
0.0974098071,
0.0575661287,
0.082376726,
-0.0882116407,
-0.0314397067,
-0.0021880919,
-0.0038642271,
0.0538201332,
0.1011468396,
-0.0358010679,
-0.0243376661,
-0.0234995633,
0.0089554768,
0.0683590025,
-0.0100712422,
0.0764303356,
0.0267552175,
0.0124163628,
-0.0231489446,
-0.029508505,
-0.0459584855,
0.0011014205,
-0.0103815421,
-0.0269339122,
0.0105480123,
-0.0084537854,
-0.0354457684,
0.0216714423,
-0.0428216495,
-0.0400157198,
0.0145604219,
0.0170226675,
0.0259643663,
0.0324226767,
-0.0131228333,
-0.0807807893,
0.0204168968,
-0.07771229,
0.0309845321,
-0.00950089,
0.0093933409,
-0.0374144092,
-0.0211897846,
-0.0295174047,
-0.0103280423,
-0.0044683991,
0.0056428071,
0.0373266265,
-0.0296816826,
0.0226697624,
0.0060010077,
0.0086127156,
-0.0311012343,
0.0091879629,
0.0084632831,
0.03835411,
0.0560315736,
-0.0590501763,
0.0199078061,
-0.0176057871,
0.0116880648,
-0.0707183853,
0.0308993459,
-0.0418354049,
-0.0527283289,
-0.0168831553,
-0.027416572,
2.474e-7,
0.0112296743,
0.0691794083,
0.0202988368,
0.0227540843,
0.0575249158,
0.0582669564,
-0.0104864798,
-0.0163666308,
0.0011956623,
-0.1257199645,
-0.0072125979,
0.0417706482,
-0.0155997528,
0.0171154682,
-0.0736720711,
-0.013871232,
-0.0134623563,
0.0333250053,
-0.0149143115,
-0.0215848219,
-0.0035830354,
0.0029347523,
0.0330193229,
0.0393283963,
-0.0257085674,
0.0300489943,
0.0763038769,
-0.0306177456,
-0.0178072453,
0.0394745097,
-0.0387466587,
-0.076601766,
-0.0193117335,
0.0294216555,
0.0271731503,
-0.0274009686,
-0.0725198388,
0.006095557,
0.0387893096,
-0.0415973924,
0.0065189921,
-0.0098940367,
0.0111176781,
-0.0190472826,
0.0112743722,
-0.0522178151,
-0.0290350243,
-0.0664173514,
-0.0524951555,
0.0086055724,
0.0101156393,
-0.0145402718,
-0.0306762084,
-0.0046147518,
-0.0395688452,
0.0217885487,
0.0253478307,
-0.0391122326,
-0.0126338257,
-0.0262794718,
-0.0914873108,
-0.09676034,
-0.0038206272,
0.0209552012,
0.0144154979,
-0.0113297543,
0.045496121,
1.945732892e-34,
0.099400796,
0.0100456374,
-0.0313724875,
-0.0153328823,
0.0434628762,
0.0050986405,
-0.0222713035,
0.0006041938,
0.0793509409,
-0.0305052046,
-0.021421589
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09615v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09615v2 | On Retrieval Augmentation and the Limitations of Language Model Training | 2023-11-16T06:59:54 | 2024-04-02T06:23:23 | Ting-Rui Chiang, Xinyan Velocity Yu, Joshua Robinson, Ollie Liu, Isabelle Lee, Dani Yogatama | cs.CL | cs.CL | Augmenting a language model (LM) with $k$-nearest neighbors ($k$NN) retrieval
on its training data alone can decrease its perplexity, though the underlying
reasons for this remain elusive. In this work, we rule out one previously
posited possibility -- the "softmax bottleneck." We then create a new dataset
to evaluate LM generalization ability in the setting where training data
contains additional information that is not causally relevant. This task is
challenging even for GPT-3.5 Turbo. We show that, for both GPT-2 and Mistral
7B, $k$NN retrieval augmentation consistently improves performance in this
setting. Finally, to make $k$NN retrieval more accessible, we propose using a
multi-layer perceptron model that maps datastore keys to values as a drop-in
replacement for traditional retrieval. This reduces storage costs by over 25x. | [
0.0333500355,
0.0605115369,
-0.0094779162,
0.0531271584,
-0.0164768919,
0.0119653577,
-0.003349399,
0.0318264365,
0.0186953824,
-0.0166694224,
-0.0619573817,
-0.055340562,
-0.0347454548,
0.0155270705,
0.0387555249,
-0.0467962511,
0.0453225598,
-0.01334773,
-0.0054657874,
-0.0140727665,
-0.0044862172,
0.0115331272,
0.0253767241,
0.0297912247,
0.007996981,
0.0327365585,
-0.0061811646,
0.0050597931,
-0.0156371593,
-0.033675272,
0.0074012447,
0.0256009847,
0.0573196486,
0.0587355234,
0.000002088,
-0.0045065442,
-0.0238107592,
0.001001741,
-0.0436614938,
0.0189147126,
0.0588639677,
-0.0272389092,
0.0260250885,
-0.0040035746,
-0.026186889,
-0.0808659717,
0.0521800853,
0.0235616211,
0.0373088494,
0.0828189477,
0.0030918198,
-0.0279141404,
0.0299727991,
-0.039153181,
0.0205952469,
-0.0720198601,
0.0238127112,
-0.0185580328,
0.0040176488,
0.0190749522,
0.0200823043,
0.0649193376,
0.0115884542,
0.0445976704,
0.0094642639,
0.0364712179,
-0.0187915582,
0.0008061524,
0.0051630135,
0.0311629754,
-0.0167905726,
-0.0277556516,
-0.0115235932,
0.0136836385,
-0.0421524718,
0.0098899417,
-0.0327157825,
-0.0285913944,
0.0202761535,
0.0101665622,
-0.0002947383,
-0.0210919529,
0.0644035488,
-0.0045095324,
-0.0474879071,
0.0428964011,
0.0340927355,
-0.0348556675,
-0.0001213143,
-0.0082629286,
-0.0376272276,
0.007557964,
0.0233727284,
-0.0027016872,
0.0159390476,
0.0314158462,
0.0020358218,
-0.0333611593,
0.0087652477,
-0.0694660321,
0.0591934882,
0.0463793688,
-0.0298027024,
0.0382768139,
-0.0454720706,
0.0415969454,
-0.0080231549,
0.0128440084,
-0.0326887183,
-0.019740656,
-0.0417587087,
-0.0512434952,
-0.0569945164,
0.0240394585,
-0.0189961679,
-0.0109684989,
-0.0147632025,
-0.005519425,
0.0237188302,
-0.0328803137,
0.0211034995,
0.0125520583,
-0.056567166,
-0.009392919,
-0.0254809204,
0.0320336968,
-0.0209263563,
0.0078092837,
0.0057938476,
-0.081665419,
-0.0357216001,
-0.0131359715,
0.0518093146,
-0.0389569886,
0.0444061533,
0.0009246432,
-0.0289533585,
-0.0612211898,
-0.0461334586,
0.0067350497,
-0.0068990807,
-0.0305148233,
-0.0248638,
-0.0349710137,
0.0377993546,
-0.0011280791,
-0.0157219712,
-0.0369732678,
-0.000243847,
0.0200161152,
-0.0399642065,
0.054050222,
-0.0468079671,
0.0059168143,
0.0426057354,
-0.0016091068,
0.0019744532,
0.0671014339,
-0.013871626,
-0.0017018726,
0.0219833367,
-0.021902848,
0.006001458,
0.0342069007,
0.0355816633,
0.0003026162,
-0.0569617152,
-0.0208878089,
-0.0034374697,
0.0070513105,
0.0082050087,
0.0331238396,
-0.0606586263,
0.0008932478,
0.0263386797,
0.068386279,
0.03335784,
0.02947939,
-0.0194301065,
0.0064025922,
-0.0274037626,
-0.0199162401,
-0.0356079675,
0.0043094652,
-0.0296494588,
0.0106151942,
0.0314164571,
0.0323793218,
-0.0139596295,
-0.0107805375,
-0.0034176272,
-0.0034797832,
0.0259902608,
0.0185521469,
0.0797217339,
0.001013527,
-0.0188145358,
0.0681832954,
0.0169462133,
-0.0526299365,
-0.0045194058,
-0.0398641713,
-0.0179374926,
0.0434655026,
0.0248528793,
-0.0397424474,
-0.0330708325,
0.0319736525,
-0.0669741482,
-0.0081143742,
0.0393146388,
0.0004652525,
0.0390085317,
-0.0770444646,
-0.0114938421,
-0.006302617,
0.0333281159,
0.060198836,
0.0296376236,
0.0237051416,
0.0722783431,
-0.0480929129,
0.0057231514,
0.0171038788,
-0.0125323134,
-0.0430275202,
-0.0079203732,
0.0237380285,
-0.0040957746,
0.0275679454,
-0.007382249,
0.0012467031,
0.0500050001,
-0.0414592996,
0.0027833004,
-0.0331314653,
-0.0580099486,
-0.0292197373,
0.0119008282,
0.0702134967,
0.0513084605,
0.0457572117,
0.0019343257,
-0.0716843084,
0.0544898883,
0.005999126,
0.066997543,
-0.0764592439,
-0.0035212026,
-0.0184786189,
0.0114193913,
-0.0208300818,
0.0608088411,
0.0157583971,
0.0474344082,
-0.0069881072,
-0.0088052936,
0.0455445498,
-0.0398067981,
-0.0501265563,
0.0300351698,
-0.0130528165,
0.0175591186,
0.0408625975,
-0.0498655252,
-0.0323149934,
-0.0278100278,
-0.0684592873,
-0.0100257294,
-0.0475553721,
0.0098623428,
-0.0129101546,
0.0510334037,
-0.0100663379,
-0.0524733141,
-0.0192020871,
-0.0072761327,
0.0330427028,
0.0430919416,
-0.0123521453,
0.0508589037,
-0.0298234094,
-0.0355545208,
-0.0575544648,
0.0183302984,
0.0295386724,
-0.0501836501,
-0.0459865443,
0.0029463354,
0.0220683198,
-0.0538177118,
0.039664641,
-0.0215085782,
-0.0225019492,
0.0134360027,
-0.0866602361,
-0.0267473236,
0.0357082896,
-0.0157354698,
-0.0215320978,
0.0279959198,
-0.0292745903,
-0.0884005204,
0.0106975222,
-0.030666085,
-0.0812004879,
-0.0147150028,
0.0179533083,
-0.0123834033,
0.0442742892,
-0.0222515576,
-0.0235102233,
-0.0454355963,
-0.0039046337,
-0.0122908186,
0.0059644161,
-0.0476931483,
-0.0008472491,
-0.0082089771,
0.0591492392,
-0.0150024435,
-0.0483989455,
0.0659388378,
-0.0358385146,
-0.0170816798,
-0.0248834155,
-0.0600819476,
-0.0191978868,
0.0779613927,
0.0043174503,
0.0297186449,
-0.0401417203,
-0.0495376848,
0.0031949335,
-0.0006776551,
0.0185267199,
-0.042600777,
0.0383172818,
0.0147117171,
0.0312356204,
0.001935749,
-0.0525590666,
-0.0110309059,
0.0078137862,
-0.0145660546,
-0.0169420578,
0.0185048785,
0.0056533092,
-0.0208906401,
0.0394969024,
0.0410976857,
0.0900000185,
-0.0139062377,
0.0103347553,
-0.017475903,
-0.0108076213,
0.0108583942,
0.01577303,
-0.0156994052,
-0.0042151306,
-0.0035763793,
0.014972032,
0.066753909,
-0.0352663994,
-0.0277155079,
0.0074497894,
0.0513468571,
-0.0042427699,
-0.0466912836,
0.0015175708,
-0.0016824483,
-0.0892981887,
-0.0333646908,
0.0640509576,
0.0014716777,
-0.0723542646,
-0.0454802774,
-0.0184817575,
0.0158775281,
0.0317481719,
0.0556613356,
-0.0265648477,
-0.0063519506,
0.0072369273,
0.0474959612,
0.0036632253,
-0.0008568614,
0.0008641966,
-0.0952080563,
0.0201053265,
0.0076597789,
-0.0430481918,
-0.0516836904,
-0.0422792509,
-0.024398163,
0.0023436774,
0.0344123356,
0.0463430509,
0.0271775872,
-0.0158057194,
0.0148615977,
0.0332527868,
-0.0618556663,
-0.0133592309,
-0.0327723324,
0.0151905315,
0.0745405108,
-0.0068238722,
-0.0221330207,
-0.0326522551,
0.0163005684,
-0.0003513719,
0.0335832015,
0.0145042343,
0.0386121124,
0.0038358327,
-0.0103340074,
0.0230388809,
-0.0185872409,
0.0011904007,
0.0069840048,
-0.0141304731,
0.0460791178,
-0.0013533599,
0.0103013963,
0.0171869434,
-0.054346256,
-0.0236328598,
0.0316529274,
0.0111741917,
0.0208759457,
0.0265257191,
-0.0122650461,
0.0488025509,
0.0063967668,
-0.0088286744,
-0.0073368978,
0.0032896223,
-0.0070613697,
-0.0220139697,
-0.0361814611,
-0.0103714801,
0.0698369965,
0.0077502923,
0.0465686284,
0.0006870873,
-0.0047982275,
-0.0546464175,
0.0544110164,
-0.0273717642,
-0.0366799571,
-0.0374155641,
-0.0137519063,
0.0351965167,
-0.0109878927,
-0.0157061275,
0.0068862378,
-0.0266899318,
-0.054909762,
0.0006489968,
0.0150714107,
0.0266494751,
0.0501141585,
0.0175592452,
-0.085531801,
0.0379503518,
0.0495244898,
-0.0580425337,
0.018314369,
-0.0063735419,
-0.0623942725,
-0.0301974416,
0.0188683439,
-0.0720081329,
0.0075683352,
-0.0131028686,
0.0276813563,
-0.0006709115,
0.0026874018,
0.0070212367,
0.0271760132,
0.0860690922,
0.0315881819,
0.0320713408,
-0.0613158606,
0.0165574346,
-0.0013228712,
0.0106902402,
-0.0358608365,
-0.0019508518,
0.051219549,
-0.0089110732,
-0.0032777903,
-0.0640541017,
0.0440587439,
0.038966231,
-0.0426842719,
-0.0284475069,
0.0076485416,
-0.02442424,
0.0409215465,
0.0099119684,
-0.0436878167,
0.0136476243,
0.0087436764,
0.0522156209,
-0.0623981543,
0.0358100422,
0.0062921997,
-0.0210938156,
-0.0437805094,
0.0200969353,
-0.0711565986,
-0.075898014,
-0.028899828,
0.0200656336,
0.031492997,
-0.0288727526,
0.0375219546,
-0.0356181897,
-0.024688296,
-0.0303858053,
-0.0461655185,
0.0193899423,
-0.0565353818,
0.0167009123,
0.0305389967,
-0.0207054317,
0.0444733649,
0.0452291518,
0.0002804276,
0.0194622632,
-0.0115192756,
-0.0232795067,
-0.0100410208,
-0.0089328121,
0.0411286019,
0.083583191,
-0.0088062165,
-0.009463517,
0.006470107,
-0.0641121417,
0.0152885616,
-0.0115236454,
-0.0473404415,
-0.032224644,
0.0151826898,
0.087259382,
0.0020174782,
-0.0389689729,
-0.0185792968,
-0.0116079468,
-0.0190158561,
-0.0076253028,
0.0153380437,
-6.766995513e-33,
-0.0347694829,
0.0435021594,
0.0041651293,
-0.0410762392,
-0.0167925805,
0.0259410311,
-0.0216448251,
-0.0036796073,
-0.0356648378,
-0.0187394712,
-0.0424493589,
0.0148273623,
0.0263138358,
0.0337638371,
0.006017894,
-0.0062217209,
0.0424863063,
0.015725242,
0.003588998,
0.0298944153,
0.0305154715,
0.0698307604,
0.1057346687,
-0.0623578094,
0.0009470301,
0.0030615968,
0.0071840184,
0.0071392693,
0.0163486097,
0.0411863029,
-0.0318350755,
0.0606947541,
-0.0041240109,
-0.0959638879,
-0.0260150936,
-0.0314494073,
-0.0395798832,
-0.0205422267,
-0.0014172482,
0.0062850011,
0.0316774733,
0.0112721929,
0.0577401891,
-0.0259835273,
-0.0060857702,
0.0394317731,
0.0049095838,
-0.0110894786,
-0.0600808002,
-0.0076442454,
0.0070260419,
0.0330430791,
0.0403496549,
0.0344694518,
0.0631614551,
0.0073324949,
-0.0149782319,
0.0299001578,
-0.074728325,
0.0161584392,
0.0547996685,
0.0985636786,
0.0140799787,
0.0671483204,
0.0317875668,
0.0418606438,
0.0875433311,
-0.016857883,
-0.031240046,
-0.0275624748,
0.0801076964,
0.002522931,
0.0166959502,
0.0397847705,
0.0739550963,
-0.0517916195,
-0.019181069,
-0.0050103576,
0.0172796957,
0.0077647385,
0.0601776876,
0.0396059789,
-0.0577160902,
-0.0585253835,
-0.0517048799,
-0.0219095293,
-0.0572375767,
-0.0403145812,
0.0369752236,
0.0453490205,
-0.0015510265,
0.0197085738,
0.0332006142,
-0.0313330628,
-0.0276133902,
0.0211942866,
-0.0108747249,
0.0122191114,
-0.027672492,
0.0430224426,
-0.0290164165,
-0.0241684094,
-0.0107229082,
-0.0065108435,
-0.0060089719,
-0.0032934258,
-0.0271424204,
0.0393488854,
-0.0685034394,
-0.01732946,
-0.0120521663,
-0.0146865016,
-0.0159867611,
-0.0054635773,
0.0439707413,
0.0022707556,
0.0469724797,
0.0681150183,
0.0490317866,
0.0075880913,
-0.0243258793,
-0.0413280129,
0.0371860042,
0.0114846565,
0.0007523621,
0.0226469133,
-0.0460728444,
-0.0256997794,
0.0268076975,
-0.0271419026,
0.0205560084,
0.0540609621,
2.908e-7,
0.019894883,
0.0191891342,
0.0213959534,
-0.0294240396,
-0.0362681709,
0.033013992,
-0.0047946107,
0.0021380289,
0.0703828633,
-0.0173450187,
0.0238877647,
0.0224995445,
0.0189659707,
0.0140399933,
-0.0949751884,
-0.0024195637,
-0.0487599634,
0.0064696814,
-0.057091482,
-0.0063273986,
0.0142268315,
0.1350806952,
0.0060323169,
-0.011580592,
0.0208821092,
-0.0658262745,
0.0597093143,
-0.0461692624,
-0.0098768519,
0.0163799878,
0.0743442178,
0.057652507,
-0.0071797138,
0.0101328986,
0.0021992191,
0.0617718883,
0.0210619215,
0.0372931734,
-0.009170671,
-0.0579338595,
0.0181179475,
-0.0004962866,
-0.0257655997,
-0.0732258633,
0.0665749386,
-0.0212568231,
-0.0161181521,
0.031864848,
-0.0253151078,
-0.0198290274,
0.0013028564,
-0.032175824,
0.010061075,
0.0264746584,
-0.0044058315,
-0.0127582233,
-0.0031491872,
-0.0968789756,
0.0035484177,
0.0260604303,
-0.0377285033,
-0.0147336088,
-0.0489219837,
0.0216718111,
0.010391661,
0.0119358143,
0.0192283131,
2.51691478e-34,
0.0257131495,
0.002847702,
0.0199955143,
-0.002284514,
0.0393783413,
-0.0163862854,
0.0107679544,
0.0487146042,
-0.0185155626,
-0.1175808758,
-0.0208028387
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09613v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09613v2 | Digital Socrates: Evaluating LLMs through Explanation Critiques | 2023-11-16T06:51:46 | 2024-02-16T08:49:07 | Yuling Gu, Oyvind Tafjord, Peter Clark | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | While LLMs can provide reasoned explanations along with their answers, the
nature and quality of those explanations are still poorly understood. In
response, our goal is to define a detailed way of characterizing the
explanation capabilities of modern models and to create a nuanced,
interpretable explanation evaluation tool that can generate such
characterizations automatically, without relying on expensive API calls or
human annotations. Our approach is to (a) define the new task of explanation
critiquing - identifying and categorizing any main flaw in an explanation and
providing suggestions to address the flaw, (b) create a sizeable,
human-verified dataset for this task, and (c) train an open-source, automatic
critique model (called Digital Socrates) using this data. Through quantitative
and qualitative analysis, we demonstrate how Digital Socrates is useful for
revealing insights about student models by examining their reasoning chains,
and how it can provide high-quality, nuanced, automatic evaluation of those
model explanations for the first time. Digital Socrates thus fills an important
gap in evaluation tools for understanding and improving the explanation
behavior of models. | [
-0.0121023869,
0.0083436742,
-0.015928058,
0.0509808548,
-0.0082787424,
0.0230929609,
-0.0022005262,
-0.0133372946,
-0.0408148356,
-0.0309496336,
0.0025447141,
0.0533049367,
-0.0108789895,
-0.0137835853,
0.0155589506,
-0.0449701101,
0.0284505952,
-0.0249279644,
-0.0232579242,
0.0053896629,
-0.0307674296,
-0.005491938,
-0.0282425694,
0.0291794762,
0.0493899845,
-0.0404392593,
-0.0643645898,
0.012441528,
-0.0055091605,
-0.032512702,
-0.0430670753,
0.0229497217,
0.0109749613,
0.030302899,
0.0000021676,
-0.0546992272,
-0.0182556454,
0.0236243308,
-0.0865536705,
0.0478336811,
-0.0205070358,
0.0286081806,
0.0242296234,
-0.0092380382,
0.0063089896,
0.0340704173,
0.0211956594,
0.0133121572,
0.0467716232,
0.0485064834,
0.0398661308,
-0.0355219953,
0.0020505087,
0.0175461881,
0.0208219085,
-0.0156125147,
-0.0211387686,
0.0658121631,
0.0162405949,
0.0308042355,
0.0015729686,
-0.0184473637,
0.0510325357,
-0.0245626308,
0.0350931138,
-0.0200024452,
0.0481329039,
-0.0258753467,
0.0107612852,
0.0352483056,
0.0673217177,
-0.0064027687,
-0.0143054435,
-0.0176592283,
0.0265126005,
0.0697773322,
-0.0670391843,
0.0030798153,
-0.0097847302,
-0.0045350487,
0.0108551523,
-0.0174312983,
0.0670270324,
0.0245055985,
0.019058181,
0.050216537,
-0.0297601148,
-0.0039604385,
-0.0249089189,
0.0003721186,
0.0150515437,
-0.0259077419,
-0.0185148083,
0.1004873142,
0.0005260038,
-0.0052046068,
0.0524944216,
0.0369725227,
0.0358082019,
0.0046139588,
0.0754940808,
-0.0051040691,
0.0181512088,
0.0072085783,
-0.0003115315,
0.026526371,
-0.0052736276,
0.0668032989,
-0.0189853963,
0.0423216112,
-0.070703581,
0.0029324915,
0.0246902406,
0.0168758854,
-0.002557093,
0.0306712929,
-0.0026057018,
0.0016351873,
-0.0366824158,
0.0384516269,
-0.0037396236,
0.0024169816,
0.0182386711,
-0.0349270813,
-0.0893595815,
0.0211627744,
-0.0240885224,
0.0260662697,
0.0249005426,
-0.0358868726,
-0.0408608764,
-0.0148847271,
-0.0177104454,
0.0229624454,
-0.0081765642,
0.0650769025,
0.0556287318,
0.0202100631,
-0.0512961484,
-0.0634581968,
0.0116846524,
-0.0605656169,
-0.0021730694,
-0.06381163,
-0.027777696,
0.0059574312,
0.0112915458,
-0.0039733509,
0.014094444,
-0.0085896291,
0.0121936584,
0.0683610514,
-0.0942032412,
0.0165154804,
0.0098197013,
0.0390854701,
-0.0462653004,
0.0542885847,
0.0261179823,
-0.0170548614,
0.0414896719,
-0.0421157815,
0.0544681288,
-0.005146977,
-0.0058399509,
-0.0087402519,
0.0050170552,
0.0295782909,
-0.0414889492,
0.0382790416,
-0.0202266946,
-0.0314337425,
-0.0164177306,
0.0395479687,
0.0135791171,
0.0397328474,
0.006955409,
0.0426195972,
0.0258728154,
-0.0248650312,
0.0331204757,
0.0177914444,
-0.0427785218,
0.0485384092,
-0.0204530675,
0.0103038475,
-0.0382578261,
-0.0188034158,
0.0025114629,
-0.129647404,
-0.0299680457,
0.0143842865,
-0.0266299602,
0.0428220332,
0.0318307318,
0.0060064113,
0.0066687702,
0.0675136819,
0.0206521787,
-0.0622370206,
-0.0194127299,
-0.0895482525,
0.0806853324,
0.0667055324,
0.0611991473,
-0.057190787,
-0.0503608435,
-0.017432075,
0.0330366828,
0.0268371757,
0.0465298258,
-0.0148353903,
-0.0207676478,
-0.0201704614,
-0.0396001115,
-0.0781355202,
0.0328664742,
-0.0130242463,
0.0028985497,
-0.0359050445,
0.0280503742,
-0.0652678087,
-0.0617956668,
0.0167905595,
-0.048124291,
-0.0243599303,
-0.0337055251,
-0.0155864423,
-0.0164023563,
0.0568571761,
0.0219493266,
0.045119077,
0.0227836519,
0.0118055111,
0.0040555042,
-0.0120560564,
0.0050625564,
0.0258873068,
0.034806408,
-0.053691797,
-0.0062216041,
0.0110378992,
-0.0503711924,
-0.0250025876,
0.030405229,
-0.0158492215,
0.0301338881,
-0.0064553777,
-0.0027200186,
-0.0383821316,
-0.0316150337,
-0.0084908549,
0.0105327163,
0.0092741512,
0.044892177,
0.0161485262,
0.0184501037,
0.0192932859,
-0.0145577351,
0.027216047,
-0.0056508817,
-0.0248633604,
0.0002423217,
-0.0192863345,
-0.0055505992,
-0.0630437806,
0.0055647502,
-0.004583457,
-0.0113058081,
-0.002578648,
0.0410618745,
0.0221843608,
-0.0536643192,
0.0005987135,
0.0122880628,
0.0082903272,
-0.004042998,
-0.0031324939,
-0.0248644967,
0.0464670286,
0.0013622772,
-0.0520892665,
-0.0430089124,
-0.0073771318,
-0.0467543267,
0.0432226807,
0.0524121374,
0.0196236316,
-0.0423384532,
0.0397440046,
-0.0107016871,
-0.0616620556,
-0.0115897786,
-0.0160797201,
0.0576366931,
0.0098176617,
-0.0535632558,
0.0465687066,
-0.0376734696,
0.1033130139,
0.041679237,
-0.0061655138,
-0.0500535183,
-0.0070284964,
0.0032058337,
-0.017263405,
-0.0476469621,
-0.0481185503,
-0.0409522578,
0.0415092856,
-0.0325084887,
0.0017996853,
-0.0177408326,
0.0636124909,
-0.0110361464,
0.0095359683,
-0.0001368923,
-0.0198146291,
0.0054653408,
0.0534682982,
-0.0139391599,
-0.0425351411,
0.0383769237,
-0.0348939598,
0.0251237266,
-0.0018196038,
-0.0196722336,
-0.0575714074,
0.0726418346,
-0.0350687467,
-0.0153185185,
0.0177733675,
0.0357853621,
-0.0092088412,
-0.0194773264,
0.059802983,
-0.043109376,
0.045183897,
-0.0598639473,
-0.0601147376,
0.0118717682,
0.0234529246,
0.0030861832,
0.0260345507,
-0.0561820902,
0.0136393402,
-0.0336903147,
-0.0342256054,
0.0050377212,
-0.0490435697,
0.0058200476,
-0.0463335179,
-0.0269097127,
-0.0275120325,
-0.0277120806,
-0.0200273991,
-0.020945387,
0.0391955413,
0.0740560219,
-0.081090264,
0.0837498233,
0.0327431001,
0.007547651,
-0.0006309793,
-0.0559866838,
-0.0257625505,
-0.0133176688,
-0.0313733295,
0.0077512083,
0.0074307472,
0.0462716632,
-0.0703931749,
-0.00601609,
0.1071313098,
0.0028745052,
-0.0164849777,
0.0087567195,
-0.0462342128,
-0.0038546096,
0.045652695,
0.0043781148,
-0.0639689341,
-0.0253032073,
-0.0064854189,
0.0711337253,
-0.0036047525,
-0.0024033613,
-0.0082981279,
-0.0755164251,
0.0669721588,
0.0026682706,
0.0251012892,
-0.0034582689,
-0.0704439655,
-0.0135346344,
-0.0366855934,
-0.0050541293,
0.0221138541,
0.0144775892,
0.0345183946,
0.0512608588,
-0.0643085614,
0.0062685129,
0.0308171902,
-0.0183813646,
0.0163517632,
0.0115818996,
0.0293342005,
-0.026051065,
-0.0501554087,
0.0406679176,
0.0189386681,
0.015726706,
0.0140098371,
0.0427375808,
0.0170439184,
0.0088511026,
-0.0480098836,
0.023386443,
-0.0506665781,
-0.0572848171,
0.0418855175,
0.0864700675,
-0.026454838,
-0.0015096186,
-0.0490681194,
0.0048292829,
-0.0461850725,
0.0624626875,
0.0833004341,
0.0095797302,
-0.0212237835,
-0.066130057,
-0.0152061582,
-0.0275557097,
-0.0108264079,
0.0235719532,
0.0273634363,
-0.0012832918,
0.031487301,
-0.0378727205,
-0.008775657,
0.0044554323,
0.0107600261,
-0.01484414,
-0.0245757699,
-0.001653515,
-0.0217273366,
0.0536970347,
0.0123646734,
0.012009888,
-0.0112239728,
-0.0122551257,
-0.0071456479,
-0.0333353654,
-0.001738885,
-0.0067997435,
-0.0528987646,
-0.0197470188,
-0.0368076004,
0.0491668135,
0.0280916356,
0.0376420468,
0.0096290754,
-0.0282159373,
0.001097801,
0.0134846251,
0.0015503608,
-0.0168461632,
0.0523229055,
0.0181786623,
0.0149980364,
0.009227287,
-0.0138615789,
-0.0178272817,
-0.0027122679,
0.0087997988,
-0.0548781566,
-0.0045427061,
0.0205120649,
0.0265732352,
0.0384121276,
0.019734459,
-0.016241638,
0.0132317422,
0.0357125588,
-0.0303498022,
-0.022664316,
-0.0231348015,
0.0192131009,
0.0191286691,
-0.0528137796,
0.0203840379,
-0.0292472448,
-0.0166412201,
0.0175151937,
-0.0237879381,
0.103367202,
0.0256742928,
-0.0349483192,
-0.002056218,
-0.0251897071,
-0.0208557434,
-0.011708892,
-0.0407581702,
0.0373539589,
0.0292253699,
0.0658578724,
0.013010324,
0.0450571403,
0.0129180048,
0.0004177385,
-0.0531837046,
-0.0983238146,
0.0111692725,
0.0104588391,
0.012559046,
0.0205282345,
0.0355420187,
-0.0151040237,
0.0060865213,
0.0206845254,
0.0586109832,
-0.0134601742,
-0.0321508721,
0.0372516476,
0.0383139588,
-0.0089428807,
-0.049928844,
0.0190924276,
-0.0546128415,
0.0416385531,
-0.0130015668,
-0.0112006376,
0.0030663235,
-0.0445836633,
-0.016461717,
0.0045799082,
0.0323118083,
-0.0380878486,
-0.0774000064,
-0.0751384944,
-0.0078764223,
0.0559233092,
-0.0308679827,
-0.018472705,
0.0041385712,
0.0524762124,
-0.0000987506,
-0.0311903134,
-0.0168285705,
0.0115747489,
-0.0317287967,
0.0061085136,
0.0074486793,
-5.310463238e-33,
-0.038160976,
-0.084448263,
0.0391378738,
0.0039456845,
0.0019712772,
-0.0026223732,
-0.0493106507,
0.0044619697,
-0.0105830589,
0.0517554283,
0.0002820746,
0.0389817357,
-0.0069426149,
-0.001832586,
0.0305698402,
-0.0528905615,
0.0075543043,
0.0374455526,
0.0099380556,
0.0128354309,
-0.0037901208,
-0.0005454108,
0.0414273664,
-0.0240884963,
0.094892107,
-0.0036271079,
-0.0201778244,
-0.0127809169,
-0.0757056251,
0.0790099055,
0.0067299707,
0.032133501,
-0.0054063955,
-0.0389069915,
0.0038959116,
-0.010319164,
-0.0243981685,
-0.016027594,
0.0135063529,
0.0090074884,
-0.0398436897,
-0.0675936639,
0.0553668141,
0.0461470261,
-0.0465211049,
-0.0570551045,
0.0511691719,
-0.0503486954,
0.0125928866,
-0.0009719891,
-0.0234123133,
0.0389256962,
-0.0815410018,
-0.0235046148,
-0.0108312229,
0.0314284563,
0.0043832827,
-0.0001789447,
-0.0022953106,
0.0259282291,
0.0525688455,
-0.0152838137,
0.096712023,
0.0002103818,
0.0115947118,
0.0501411892,
0.0088611916,
0.0129965162,
-0.0644646883,
0.0005198173,
-0.0436510816,
0.0845677331,
0.1071435511,
0.0192268454,
-0.0106324637,
0.0246845484,
-0.0804672539,
0.0249515045,
-0.0305581652,
0.0478232503,
0.014508239,
-0.0287511759,
-0.0447683297,
0.0118292831,
-0.068462275,
-0.0566847771,
0.0039912411,
-0.0194765478,
0.0079282857,
-0.0655642822,
-0.0411245003,
-0.0441691577,
-0.0437061526,
-0.0740433857,
-0.0266893338,
-0.022711236,
0.0149765825,
-0.0083446866,
-0.0110277161,
-0.005910608,
-0.0176544767,
0.0037957979,
-0.0462574288,
0.0118115293,
0.0733365491,
0.0027881304,
0.0134245604,
0.0130379731,
0.0037795512,
-0.0214592647,
-0.059599787,
-0.0327368677,
0.0094788214,
-0.0320189893,
0.0204996206,
0.0108994143,
-0.0193293449,
0.0534052029,
-0.0031015147,
0.04141609,
0.0026959288,
0.01614004,
-0.0450249538,
-0.0037176707,
0.0166178159,
-0.0375785008,
-0.0114086652,
0.0080185654,
0.0376988277,
-0.0506182685,
-0.0086082816,
0.0310218912,
2.655e-7,
0.0568619706,
0.0345364027,
0.0089938529,
0.0062633208,
0.0180727132,
0.0381275676,
-0.0325210057,
-0.0410547554,
0.0177242067,
-0.0487209186,
0.0150349978,
0.0445742607,
0.0601494312,
0.0146983592,
-0.0457336009,
-0.0230613276,
-0.0392065011,
-0.0109237125,
-0.042190481,
0.0404192768,
0.0551492013,
-0.0040806937,
0.0182435624,
0.0087426063,
-0.0166308004,
0.0018941644,
0.0224008262,
-0.0697318017,
0.0114991199,
0.0393288843,
0.0605013557,
-0.033536233,
0.0580000095,
-0.0166904796,
0.0013380717,
-0.0223771669,
-0.0315581225,
0.0503366068,
0.012320783,
-0.036067076,
-0.0251552947,
-0.0685408413,
0.0563919768,
-0.0464125313,
0.0511181541,
0.0005046099,
-0.0301331859,
-0.0217253212,
-0.036739897,
-0.0477371365,
0.0228823628,
-0.0148357395,
0.0364305303,
0.0222528838,
-0.0281038135,
-0.0579567887,
0.0076542473,
-0.0204114988,
-0.0268915761,
0.0054518403,
-0.01374136,
-0.0053231218,
-0.0122000342,
-0.0161309708,
0.0416611508,
-0.0258417111,
-0.0380848534,
2.185050225e-34,
0.0180054009,
-0.0108419713,
0.0562350489,
0.0551306456,
0.0468207262,
0.0237943884,
0.0091375643,
0.0007883806,
0.0254932046,
-0.026187079,
-0.0094690835
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09612v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09612v2 | Efficient End-to-End Visual Document Understanding with Rationale Distillation | 2023-11-16T06:50:26 | 2024-04-02T00:11:50 | Wang Zhu, Alekh Agarwal, Mandar Joshi, Robin Jia, Jesse Thomason, Kristina Toutanova | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Understanding visually situated language requires interpreting complex
layouts of textual and visual elements. Pre-processing tools, such as optical
character recognition (OCR), can map document image inputs to textual tokens,
then large language models (LLMs) can reason over text. However, such methods
have high computational and engineering complexity. Can small pretrained
image-to-text models accurately understand visual documents through similar
recognition and reasoning steps instead? We propose Rationale Distillation
(RD), which incorporates the outputs of OCR tools, LLMs, and larger multimodal
models as intermediate "rationales", and trains a small student model to
predict both rationales and answers. On three visual document understanding
benchmarks representing infographics, scanned documents, and figures, our
Pix2Struct (282M parameters) student model finetuned with RD outperforms the
base model by 4-5% absolute accuracy with only 1% higher computational cost. | [
0.0159799848,
0.06250301,
0.0234552529,
0.0564265139,
-0.004455456,
0.0294698607,
-0.0051401574,
0.0132463798,
-0.0374191217,
-0.0414698496,
0.0110737178,
-0.0038109415,
0.0235863887,
0.0369705744,
-0.0062489947,
-0.0877190903,
0.0002842047,
-0.045661483,
0.0407407135,
0.0167310853,
0.0270714127,
0.027388975,
0.0080331471,
0.0038171588,
0.0160924233,
-0.0604970902,
-0.0413924493,
0.0221230444,
0.0167412553,
-0.0003240434,
-0.0456383079,
0.006597755,
0.0874308944,
-0.0050883191,
0.0000019817,
-0.022168478,
-0.0202248655,
0.0167177618,
-0.0364827402,
0.008350553,
0.0261193532,
-0.0372556187,
0.0223771147,
-0.0365908928,
-0.0283212084,
0.0166034009,
0.0523432046,
0.0714384541,
0.0782987922,
0.0483709276,
-0.0283690877,
-0.0577066094,
0.019393377,
-0.0011763183,
0.0180469472,
-0.0101809204,
-0.0342430659,
0.0469954573,
0.0060872086,
0.006767536,
-0.0469907261,
0.0190494899,
0.0266078301,
-0.0479111485,
0.0048476239,
0.0303965639,
0.03478631,
-0.049620416,
-0.0027879095,
0.0857846439,
-0.0692563951,
0.0034945242,
0.0174348224,
-0.0136167351,
-0.0333196633,
0.0104515478,
-0.0741138235,
0.0225615185,
-0.0177272409,
0.0209134836,
0.0082412874,
-0.0173334815,
-0.0149423117,
0.0215374213,
-0.0502917133,
0.0082443561,
-0.0114331162,
0.022136081,
-0.0031211495,
0.0157953016,
-0.0270207524,
-0.0416712612,
-0.0101318238,
0.0687069148,
0.0320415087,
0.0118722972,
-0.0288355071,
-0.0306773782,
-0.0147075616,
-0.0220509414,
0.0209765919,
0.0286982413,
-0.0297954995,
0.1000243947,
-0.0284791328,
0.0644371808,
-0.0190725513,
0.0861123428,
-0.0184523594,
-0.0072404947,
-0.0425516367,
-0.0109163113,
-0.0329558663,
0.0017338475,
-0.0842043012,
-0.0781138018,
0.0218234807,
0.0024917112,
-0.014445507,
-0.0027319596,
0.028911734,
0.0314582288,
-0.0055960994,
-0.0571901575,
-0.0467415452,
0.0680946633,
-0.0157166105,
0.007178531,
-0.0128875989,
-0.0176381972,
-0.0007388433,
0.0346721597,
0.0467240512,
-0.002198396,
-0.0116591584,
0.0496445522,
-0.0649172515,
-0.0153795676,
-0.0218459833,
-0.0372121669,
0.0045419019,
-0.0756314471,
0.0311641302,
-0.0425013155,
0.0089699961,
-0.0018523393,
-0.0073633417,
-0.0578961112,
-0.0024156377,
0.0085630985,
-0.0364171527,
0.1094061583,
-0.0104560582,
0.0005571501,
0.0211831108,
0.0244361833,
-0.0084824283,
0.0551127754,
0.0128308637,
0.0683607608,
0.0260237865,
-0.0101207392,
0.0011269904,
0.0194759592,
-0.0018200086,
-0.0224298351,
-0.0242612641,
0.0250601973,
-0.0371411145,
0.0113886325,
0.0652213022,
0.025205655,
-0.0539762676,
0.0090895919,
0.071689643,
0.060244333,
0.0262408648,
-0.0076424791,
-0.0219813213,
0.0277168974,
0.0001244312,
-0.0148565024,
-0.0575106405,
0.0625253096,
0.0381344408,
0.0206987876,
-0.0017924192,
0.0049423701,
-0.0011449512,
-0.042373661,
-0.0016897664,
-0.0012866789,
0.0060252598,
0.0072795576,
0.0613531992,
0.0118509894,
-0.0605566427,
0.0234233513,
-0.0246941764,
-0.0451339856,
-0.0142204771,
-0.0323043577,
0.068691425,
0.0771912932,
0.0492069721,
-0.0075709652,
0.0261419266,
0.0060908608,
0.0320593305,
0.0030056695,
0.0175417177,
-0.0108402111,
0.0347394012,
-0.0665350854,
-0.0608807765,
-0.0341777988,
-0.0182800516,
-0.0105491737,
0.0095861051,
-0.0029262458,
-0.0069914502,
-0.0888762549,
-0.0312862694,
0.0318012051,
0.0485720113,
-0.0461017303,
-0.0439319126,
0.0444757529,
0.0070193028,
0.0026992306,
-0.0146658411,
-0.0047556749,
0.0129715782,
-0.0317642614,
0.0370837227,
-0.0103076519,
-0.0397780873,
-0.0285606105,
0.0578976572,
-0.0393362083,
-0.0381519496,
0.0149648571,
-0.0602257028,
-0.041647438,
0.0133329425,
-0.0101941451,
-0.0274443086,
-0.044034645,
-0.0123762898,
0.0266683623,
0.0103977015,
-0.0182373989,
0.0313687399,
-0.0108818403,
-0.0426758826,
0.0089537241,
-0.0268515795,
0.0381526016,
-0.0173718277,
0.0147828693,
0.0045670127,
-0.0157664586,
0.0100146923,
-0.0287033077,
0.0205034185,
-0.026659498,
-0.0012013578,
-0.0436147489,
-0.0361532308,
-0.0195242129,
-0.0313488245,
0.0129734343,
-0.0008603639,
0.0297624692,
-0.0420280546,
-0.0240806788,
0.0147034079,
-0.0202525184,
0.0008165821,
0.037619561,
0.0010013316,
0.025210157,
-0.0122235483,
-0.0179151297,
0.0128760971,
0.0647515431,
0.0267401002,
0.0143207861,
-0.0174000096,
0.0100300778,
-0.0004125578,
0.0058380654,
-0.0118728774,
-0.0041188439,
0.0360659137,
-0.0546795726,
0.0108891698,
0.1109782979,
0.0076418663,
0.0172209553,
0.0033746669,
-0.0188944619,
-0.05214696,
0.0017521839,
0.0096352855,
0.0302234516,
0.0008237536,
-0.0396947153,
-0.0530594066,
0.0406884328,
-0.044315841,
0.0263799969,
-0.0473262109,
0.0301316343,
0.0222109277,
-0.0049451478,
-0.0938943326,
-0.0384014137,
0.0410389788,
0.0703795254,
-0.0650371015,
-0.0580926351,
0.0529625379,
-0.0502031557,
-0.0184384175,
0.0134895239,
0.0041514286,
-0.0326660983,
0.0795854852,
-0.0051709348,
0.0094431061,
-0.0113270618,
0.0097654881,
-0.0469037481,
-0.0564805977,
0.0439133681,
-0.0118975202,
0.0733938739,
-0.0733636096,
0.0274769347,
-0.0423864238,
-0.0153724132,
-0.0027325179,
-0.0340404622,
-0.0487673767,
-0.0140709011,
-0.0570108369,
-0.0274557713,
-0.0010493504,
0.0518901646,
0.0202913098,
0.0546177365,
-0.0089377295,
0.0000056313,
-0.012795045,
0.0561262928,
0.0578705482,
0.0388618559,
-0.0141657656,
-0.0556147844,
0.0552499928,
0.044605758,
0.0096857995,
-0.0603939742,
-0.0636136234,
0.0330124907,
0.0122793429,
0.0367191434,
0.0211443938,
-0.0046660039,
0.0583742298,
-0.0883117989,
0.0065188399,
0.0647328049,
-0.0051339865,
0.0019884373,
-0.0492200106,
-0.0228269286,
0.0474648401,
0.0165297836,
0.0144316582,
-0.0712119937,
-0.0592074096,
0.0067805238,
0.028666649,
0.0531711914,
0.0115267467,
-0.0224527847,
-0.0521509349,
0.0640755221,
0.0069077453,
0.0103222253,
-0.0344111398,
0.0075848773,
-0.0343573987,
-0.0282847863,
-0.0442220941,
0.0077112135,
-0.0032633233,
0.0089438204,
0.0015041805,
-0.0038564901,
0.0380589105,
0.0064247423,
0.0046838722,
-0.0595871769,
0.0262686703,
0.0332398266,
0.0386420861,
-0.0839683115,
0.0465976857,
0.0051474571,
0.0281488579,
-0.014041312,
0.0857598931,
0.0112154577,
-0.0148295397,
-0.0004873699,
0.0689043403,
-0.0373700969,
-0.039000228,
-0.032948602,
0.0387640633,
-0.004026935,
-0.0161082055,
-0.0330150835,
-0.0248706769,
-0.018964285,
0.0311889499,
0.0373672657,
-0.0047818501,
-0.1128711551,
-0.035883978,
0.0109904045,
-0.0799055845,
0.0193835273,
-0.0613956414,
0.0011105479,
-0.0210901555,
-0.0292362813,
0.0197915658,
0.0172094181,
0.0451574996,
-0.0332868733,
-0.0433493517,
0.0091103809,
0.0289296396,
-0.0703495741,
0.0641323328,
-0.0103277666,
0.0354590304,
-0.0180973541,
0.0541119017,
-0.0172711536,
-0.0561725013,
-0.0303981733,
0.0026155233,
-0.0467153937,
-0.027921807,
-0.018811157,
0.0598813966,
0.023098914,
0.0644965395,
0.0123718847,
-0.0224221591,
0.0391113497,
-0.0095273489,
0.0054582334,
-0.0279255565,
0.0364504606,
-0.020936409,
-0.0009797536,
0.0061416891,
-0.0067221951,
0.0198859293,
0.0107942699,
-0.0065057138,
-0.0358943976,
-0.0016854738,
-0.0115334941,
0.0104040094,
0.0285125319,
0.0110148787,
0.0223100409,
-0.0566045679,
0.0235653967,
0.0216828138,
0.0224247295,
-0.0644638836,
0.0114698391,
0.0123596797,
-0.0133401956,
0.0044578789,
-0.0140191251,
0.0242989268,
0.0184496026,
0.0294558052,
0.0235220846,
0.0198548902,
0.0199981555,
0.0065961368,
-0.0077812206,
0.0020710074,
0.0427516662,
-0.0487110876,
0.0373128615,
-0.0122657502,
0.0843423456,
0.0388548821,
0.0015831791,
-0.0155929886,
0.0081534591,
-0.0561742112,
-0.0655958652,
-0.0090019414,
0.0111991046,
0.0104143796,
0.0039860313,
0.0322461054,
-0.0001653152,
-0.0216260944,
0.0041809906,
0.0528421625,
0.021443259,
-0.0214618538,
0.0284545813,
0.0344192907,
0.0283490736,
-0.0122354468,
0.0544233546,
0.0041985055,
-0.0145103876,
-0.0144040743,
-0.0096998941,
-0.0500633791,
-0.0185372252,
0.0016006212,
0.025752889,
0.0212401394,
0.0135476543,
-0.0120769059,
-0.0455823243,
-0.0055580316,
0.0350608043,
-0.0319894515,
-0.0088211233,
0.0229859184,
0.035569597,
0.0079523744,
-0.0225291755,
0.0009871644,
0.0028911142,
-0.0122396788,
-0.0000485629,
0.0010074622,
-5.781024279e-33,
0.0150692184,
-0.047339607,
0.0256605744,
-0.0109021431,
-0.0052317162,
0.0110854078,
-0.0377059504,
-0.033467222,
-0.0197131541,
0.0249837972,
-0.0045011984,
0.0193232931,
0.0172115304,
0.0443363637,
-0.0204901043,
0.0233553946,
0.0422577821,
0.0041411854,
-0.009700275,
-0.0011487054,
0.0184337012,
0.0054707052,
-0.0090216324,
-0.0650164112,
-0.0101976115,
0.0284550767,
-0.035059832,
0.0175333805,
-0.0038064739,
0.0499481224,
-0.0194961354,
-0.020071812,
0.0161032397,
-0.0045353998,
-0.0263038669,
0.0582789928,
-0.1301503479,
-0.0016959937,
0.0152798314,
0.022704361,
-0.0777938813,
-0.0061544753,
0.0414635539,
-0.0185951106,
0.0434420295,
-0.0703735054,
0.050258223,
-0.0273025967,
0.0004872757,
0.0279609524,
-0.0211323686,
0.0244194753,
-0.0385826118,
-0.0267151911,
0.0667184964,
-0.0000881569,
0.0232521519,
0.0508841351,
-0.0586972944,
0.0043674279,
0.0194343105,
0.0059588547,
0.0861715451,
0.0214861277,
-0.0262692906,
0.0314047411,
-0.0103740897,
-0.0182916615,
-0.0349866971,
-0.0042626988,
0.0219284054,
0.0787154585,
0.066499725,
0.0461354442,
0.0756408796,
0.0336280093,
-0.0588741936,
0.0218010619,
-0.0621603765,
0.078904517,
0.014302454,
0.022339575,
0.0343697928,
0.0146534406,
-0.0428640619,
-0.0344721265,
-0.0446024612,
0.0080265617,
0.0279287416,
0.0268525537,
-0.0264990088,
0.0051295757,
0.0528383106,
-0.0596294589,
0.0031610739,
0.0234492309,
-0.0154113993,
0.0347761735,
0.0052959439,
-0.0021029955,
-0.0381484665,
-0.0100287916,
0.0447950512,
0.0228590108,
-0.0097827101,
0.0050480501,
0.0455560647,
-0.0032250525,
-0.037564043,
-0.0173460878,
-0.0394279212,
-0.0054819388,
-0.0148113966,
0.0746678859,
0.0255774036,
-0.0000667869,
-0.0440027565,
-0.0042045657,
-0.0338564254,
0.0116373729,
-0.0171418209,
-0.0590780377,
0.022314027,
0.0267990157,
-0.0145660369,
-0.0053754025,
-0.0088181049,
-0.0460754745,
0.0276385583,
-0.056377437,
0.0029315881,
0.0762616396,
2.525e-7,
0.0429387614,
0.0076787532,
0.035798952,
-0.0194608998,
0.014570836,
0.0400179215,
0.0059108804,
-0.0201496258,
-0.0038865223,
-0.0474909171,
0.0105890753,
0.0635032877,
0.0514778532,
-0.0052169636,
-0.0299151782,
0.0118780201,
-0.0022205464,
-0.0312402844,
-0.0400704965,
0.00043463,
0.066411458,
0.0444290191,
-0.024869876,
-0.0557512939,
0.0339901373,
-0.0487244241,
0.0463005044,
-0.0061767488,
0.0679074898,
-0.0020140365,
0.0270506777,
-0.0308832172,
-0.0202815235,
0.0008436746,
0.0110277468,
-0.0104355542,
0.017396817,
0.0553847738,
-0.0341654234,
-0.0076556932,
-0.0259421002,
-0.0147605957,
-0.0034973305,
-0.0962221324,
0.0608079247,
-0.0182387531,
-0.0151480297,
-0.0317994319,
-0.0607972071,
-0.0307889581,
0.0039453292,
0.0143071041,
0.0043694675,
0.041037146,
0.0214562789,
-0.0545143709,
-0.0084160641,
-0.1022651643,
-0.0329243019,
-0.0256561823,
0.0106418831,
0.0044677742,
-0.041957628,
0.0019579788,
0.0857884958,
-0.0095159309,
-0.0662217513,
1.866698575e-34,
0.0310068838,
-0.008414112,
-0.003911816,
0.0181045979,
0.0457355827,
0.0026686913,
-0.049775932,
-0.0275009815,
0.0182976034,
-0.071037069,
-0.0070829266
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09606v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09606v2 | GistScore: Learning Better Representations for In-Context Example Selection with Gist Bottlenecks | 2023-11-16T06:28:05 | 2024-02-22T05:15:55 | Shivanshu Gupta, Clemens Rosenbaum, Ethan R. Elenberg | cs.CL | cs.CL | In-context Learning (ICL) is the ability of Large Language Models (LLMs) to
perform new tasks when conditioned on prompts comprising a few task examples.
However, ICL performance can be critically sensitive to the choice of examples.
To dynamically select the best examples for every test input, we propose
Example Gisting, a novel approach for training example encoders through
supervised fine-tuning with an attention bottleneck between the inputs and
outputs. These gist models form the basis for GistScore, a novel metric for
scoring and selecting informative examples. Further, we experiment with two
variations: (1) fine-tuning gist models for each dataset and (2) multi-task
training a single model on a large collection of datasets. The latter can be
used for new tasks out-of-the-box, enabling a training-free ICL pipeline.
Evaluations with 21 datasets spanning 9 tasks and 8 diverse LLMs show that our
fine-tuned models get state-of-the-art ICL performance with over 20% absolute
gain over off-the-shelf retrievers and 5% over the best prior methods. Further,
our multi-task model generalizes well to new tasks, datasets, and prompt
templates. Selection using this model matches or outperforms prior methods
while being three orders of magnitude faster than the strongest training-free
baseline. | [
0.0009092306,
0.0107850144,
-0.0068827043,
0.0373582393,
-0.0252129789,
0.0262512304,
0.0097903879,
0.0158220921,
-0.0292575471,
-0.0625891834,
-0.022812333,
-0.0305346437,
-0.0221456327,
0.0160281993,
0.042983003,
-0.0413549207,
0.0381127782,
-0.0270053875,
0.0158965271,
0.0399179049,
-0.0029382664,
0.0214301255,
0.0121967439,
0.0654332042,
0.0082681747,
-0.0326459259,
0.0022073465,
0.026808843,
0.0048568016,
-0.0437218919,
0.0465558134,
0.0190599691,
0.0811678097,
-0.0101210074,
0.0000022457,
-0.0402602516,
-0.0060999789,
-0.028096104,
-0.0673918799,
-0.0294395238,
0.0031362902,
-0.0058758887,
0.0279939547,
0.0134662231,
-0.0409456976,
-0.0011300388,
0.0262658726,
0.020593999,
0.0534268171,
0.1078232974,
-0.0067380364,
0.0077266661,
-0.0369452611,
-0.0455560163,
0.0319392309,
-0.0042904224,
0.0059725447,
0.0028057757,
0.0178448949,
0.0189674981,
-0.0112516042,
0.0193753336,
0.0418731198,
0.0151335141,
0.006294312,
0.0464652553,
-0.0535193719,
0.0267186649,
-0.0188710745,
0.0839924887,
-0.0770523101,
-0.0336023159,
-0.0230215322,
-0.02656262,
-0.0062614367,
-0.0296768025,
-0.0600164644,
-0.0191342216,
-0.0170534588,
0.0314282328,
0.0004605089,
0.0259848125,
0.0256277509,
0.0022955223,
0.0001214189,
0.0112135774,
-0.0023517241,
-0.0527759269,
0.0307256337,
-0.0136969527,
-0.0734853372,
-0.0301319622,
-0.0062575005,
0.0098985462,
-0.0588647202,
0.0066171433,
-0.0431720056,
-0.0386307985,
-0.006121261,
-0.0208885986,
0.0319709517,
0.0472101793,
-0.0046731392,
0.0697648898,
0.0037760341,
0.0426214971,
0.01593096,
0.0475244932,
-0.035236083,
-0.0112934327,
-0.0598013401,
0.0243635774,
-0.0791624486,
0.0046277288,
-0.0198135115,
-0.0091170147,
0.0128868781,
0.0316647142,
-0.021510385,
0.0166190155,
0.0279170107,
0.0048431759,
-0.0563701577,
-0.0020330504,
-0.0096675484,
-0.0119462581,
-0.0363630839,
0.0106696896,
0.0355375856,
-0.0653614774,
-0.0457344614,
0.0168872587,
0.0233831853,
-0.0610287823,
0.0113750929,
0.0614871457,
-0.0195149388,
-0.0578122698,
-0.0279283486,
-0.0088600982,
0.016347589,
-0.0529318154,
-0.0184049364,
-0.0366580449,
0.0297092218,
0.01093069,
0.0037881855,
-0.0465260968,
-0.0076749697,
0.0382059999,
0.0099073146,
0.0503041968,
0.0263718441,
-0.0022271138,
0.0075239628,
0.0093608787,
-0.0441046059,
0.0861198604,
0.0087741045,
0.0301705096,
0.0366711095,
0.0085167615,
0.0477517061,
0.0452079475,
0.0275340732,
0.0551037155,
-0.0110104745,
0.0520883314,
0.035953939,
0.0491276942,
0.083939299,
0.0178010389,
-0.0441052578,
0.0025399481,
0.0785633475,
0.0168169215,
0.0056604729,
-0.0017118906,
0.0551492162,
0.0448231548,
-0.0151610961,
-0.0115329027,
-0.0601974204,
0.0345201828,
0.0235289559,
0.0107753007,
0.0071455017,
0.0011566315,
-0.0497508906,
0.0041919174,
0.0053143161,
-0.0283446535,
-0.0210806616,
0.0391873047,
0.0470263138,
0.0267648399,
-0.0791110992,
0.0384348109,
0.023026485,
-0.0206105821,
-0.0075540054,
-0.0347114317,
0.0265630875,
0.0476022251,
0.0456150323,
-0.028797444,
-0.0195475034,
-0.0590042137,
0.0280217063,
0.0122644026,
0.02204239,
-0.021337986,
0.0454138815,
-0.0822904631,
-0.0337866619,
-0.0272804629,
-0.0135541158,
-0.0037310678,
0.0218240228,
0.0412798636,
0.0260208081,
-0.0614701435,
-0.0228173006,
0.0335443355,
0.006006707,
-0.051116772,
0.0225414429,
0.0035466102,
0.0331484266,
-0.0242887307,
0.0030504973,
-0.0094381683,
0.028361991,
-0.0446468517,
0.0216400642,
-0.0069639264,
-0.0934799314,
-0.0824351832,
-0.0259446204,
-0.0025264344,
-0.0384323895,
0.0237784106,
-0.0456771255,
-0.0280511901,
-0.0275371354,
-0.0323876925,
0.0523938797,
-0.0277746432,
0.0034748313,
-0.0073727169,
0.0091818329,
-0.0508225262,
0.0541937202,
0.0101024481,
0.0192898177,
0.0029188951,
0.0024055466,
-0.0052406588,
-0.0515898131,
-0.0208539087,
-0.0148039702,
-0.0116744572,
0.0155245056,
0.0185656082,
0.0347754732,
-0.0414127819,
0.0101878075,
-0.1028626785,
0.0115089547,
-0.0561834276,
0.0077270833,
0.0021924288,
0.0079878829,
-0.0074049314,
-0.0311295502,
-0.0230304357,
-0.0180088412,
-0.0265811216,
0.0230529346,
0.0000657525,
0.0137964711,
0.011265168,
-0.0194742493,
0.0046946048,
0.0199662168,
0.0486310795,
-0.0456729308,
-0.0038102104,
-0.0277371518,
0.0422158912,
0.0321642458,
0.0152729489,
-0.0247356389,
0.0020149094,
0.0164737813,
-0.0183338914,
0.0465052389,
0.0564120226,
-0.0146694425,
0.0176110603,
0.0150594776,
-0.0012859564,
-0.0820232332,
0.0254654959,
-0.0118776467,
-0.0165270679,
-0.0271578319,
0.0318429731,
0.0303824805,
0.0226367265,
0.0237987284,
0.0271745771,
-0.0514570959,
0.0182162728,
0.0069479179,
-0.0058612647,
-0.0537798144,
-0.0000017051,
-0.0202489402,
0.0100445459,
-0.0473972633,
-0.0464429781,
0.053579364,
-0.0175834689,
-0.0490952805,
-0.0519068949,
0.0069954917,
-0.0245012175,
0.0385948122,
0.0084307939,
0.0006246261,
0.0371128358,
-0.0277187023,
-0.0337916575,
0.0204837751,
-0.0075202752,
-0.0156376548,
0.0584098659,
-0.0212718006,
-0.0058544991,
-0.0141153568,
-0.0569407269,
-0.0442764685,
0.0066475901,
0.0078997705,
0.0265373848,
-0.0118080135,
0.022682596,
-0.0293534212,
-0.0105040437,
0.0126600033,
0.0711467192,
-0.0192401297,
-0.0108140716,
-0.0281648301,
0.0293944832,
0.0452393964,
0.0399216302,
-0.0360723548,
-0.0199374091,
0.0109924674,
0.0222770665,
0.0572518744,
-0.0053380197,
-0.0422586352,
0.0117421905,
0.0155983083,
-0.043089956,
0.0018970574,
0.0413164832,
0.051816795,
-0.102708526,
-0.0375038721,
0.1093169302,
0.0154725388,
-0.098798126,
0.0117018716,
0.0270519108,
0.0117804259,
0.0360386968,
0.012218873,
-0.0494915098,
-0.0716078281,
0.0173683241,
0.0025814036,
-0.0013225742,
-0.0036775328,
-0.0076068966,
-0.1167746112,
0.0415160246,
0.0014686038,
-0.0376582742,
-0.0343546309,
-0.0438429788,
0.0293167792,
-0.0133596873,
0.0133515541,
0.0060812482,
-0.0044174101,
0.0114047891,
0.0258521251,
0.0269861892,
-0.1175705045,
0.0389296599,
-0.0178059097,
0.0258528013,
0.0673102364,
0.0001624467,
0.0154477805,
-0.0238163527,
0.0592696369,
-0.0305437203,
-0.0021447381,
-0.0237247273,
0.0701245517,
-0.0187999606,
-0.0060036057,
0.0308879055,
0.0277390108,
-0.0397603512,
-0.0125990072,
0.0228373073,
0.081431523,
-0.0224293843,
0.0227687955,
0.0078510912,
-0.0818709061,
0.0950988904,
0.0836708397,
0.0458362028,
-0.0398095176,
-0.0088181002,
-0.0196833145,
-0.0090677692,
-0.0540572666,
0.0032199011,
0.0075245337,
0.0167607144,
0.0354705304,
-0.0456610247,
-0.0558363423,
0.0657397211,
0.0460369401,
0.0030536593,
0.0014791694,
-0.0193248261,
0.0164777711,
-0.0448688343,
0.0510858297,
-0.0157543588,
0.016928114,
-0.0585980155,
-0.0141561721,
0.0001483596,
-0.0048831776,
-0.0314836986,
0.0494195707,
-0.0586128384,
-0.0396933034,
-0.0363406204,
0.029977601,
0.0121669509,
0.0524754077,
-0.0259119812,
-0.0345370546,
0.0587950759,
-0.00595978,
-0.0285904147,
-0.0074473261,
0.040083468,
-0.0162086636,
-0.0129058259,
0.0486162417,
-0.0396605358,
0.0127418954,
0.0253014863,
0.0091084074,
-0.0268034898,
0.0076688998,
0.0184933376,
-0.0380739607,
0.0449301675,
-0.0049916338,
0.0038594494,
-0.0198633391,
0.0406750478,
0.0312090348,
-0.0006195416,
-0.0532458164,
-0.0046672104,
-0.0135122351,
-0.0348902158,
-0.0049234573,
0.0391809195,
0.0163550545,
0.0086462777,
-0.0690279305,
0.0110681904,
-0.0386658497,
0.0432792194,
0.0267651863,
0.0147304656,
-0.0451891907,
0.0055304454,
0.0084410198,
0.0283881277,
-0.042364113,
0.0648579895,
0.0345037356,
-0.0013791663,
0.0269214679,
0.0222609304,
-0.0296460595,
-0.0140999015,
-0.0604244843,
-0.0110090049,
0.0425763316,
-0.04866945,
0.0607182272,
0.0243936442,
0.0043779118,
-0.0415054299,
0.0245892704,
-0.0190667342,
-0.0260837041,
-0.0035276122,
0.0261720736,
-0.0215323716,
0.0040178834,
0.0732402131,
-0.0178211946,
0.0225254428,
0.0148424553,
0.0160209946,
-0.0352905095,
0.0133397821,
0.0206433199,
0.0325770415,
0.0405511484,
0.0298131593,
-0.0083093336,
-0.0443810485,
-0.0116103748,
-0.0210257042,
-0.0414509028,
0.0101019498,
0.0932187885,
0.0362765826,
-0.0354404487,
-0.0260514244,
-0.0131675061,
-0.0328234285,
-0.0289743561,
-0.0258789565,
-0.0638367534,
-6.256589988e-33,
-0.019857103,
0.005042742,
0.0139439236,
-0.0035360504,
-0.0089642368,
0.0077978121,
-0.0686405599,
-0.0477655903,
-0.0185373686,
-0.0030555709,
-0.0185342208,
-0.0157878902,
0.0095667765,
0.0524538904,
0.0153790424,
-0.0160521511,
0.0495250225,
-0.0031844419,
-0.027108537,
0.0562988333,
0.0324903764,
0.0217091255,
0.0852798522,
-0.0759067908,
-0.0175655242,
0.0045419503,
-0.014476073,
-0.0000339858,
0.0078411922,
0.0551494211,
-0.002694268,
0.0609198548,
0.023428442,
-0.0840720236,
-0.0423727743,
0.0175730065,
-0.0617107935,
-0.0464793444,
-0.0095743965,
-0.0044983178,
-0.0203620475,
-0.0426945537,
0.030831404,
-0.0030492432,
0.0322846323,
0.0014366471,
0.0377595723,
-0.0180365685,
-0.0315860324,
-0.0307664666,
-0.0479234681,
0.0144491317,
-0.003597104,
-0.0240875762,
0.0312248915,
0.0508756973,
-0.0026385591,
0.0109912781,
-0.0447327085,
-0.0152790071,
-0.0034464858,
0.0549007989,
0.0238666218,
0.0057600131,
0.0021534797,
0.0629225969,
-0.043050874,
-0.0281378645,
0.0450862944,
-0.0288700555,
0.0350322872,
0.0635833591,
-0.0023568298,
0.0235857703,
0.0526244193,
0.0097676329,
-0.0714079365,
0.0206282698,
0.0163909215,
0.0363105088,
0.0235611163,
0.0144480821,
-0.049358394,
-0.026843477,
-0.0119440109,
-0.0219920073,
-0.0267210044,
-0.0370768756,
0.0799706653,
0.0276502725,
0.0261726454,
0.03523615,
0.0606568195,
-0.0031507071,
-0.0068803309,
0.0226183925,
-0.0352633893,
0.007671189,
0.0269913953,
-0.0073116608,
-0.0567988232,
-0.0471295454,
0.0354972407,
0.0208963957,
0.0251603052,
0.0097988322,
0.0571629405,
0.0309409425,
-0.0736358091,
0.0065568541,
-0.0403716825,
0.0214048382,
-0.0261947848,
0.0304316003,
0.0135085974,
0.0194940139,
-0.0245237779,
0.0698359311,
-0.0179829616,
-0.0647997037,
-0.0590914488,
-0.0171441119,
0.0007254854,
0.0265304931,
-0.022883594,
-0.0072757336,
-0.0272437539,
-0.0094902627,
0.048375614,
-0.0170708429,
-0.0057948367,
0.0223601963,
2.797e-7,
0.0180045832,
0.0297218561,
-0.0256307889,
0.0331622884,
0.0157601312,
0.0429551303,
-0.0180139691,
0.0421759449,
0.0092495,
-0.0201924797,
0.0163518582,
0.0194912963,
0.0435671397,
0.0255134329,
-0.1106955111,
0.0105716065,
-0.0499266908,
0.0039819572,
-0.039818272,
-0.0188638065,
0.0497709289,
0.1112705916,
0.0240841731,
0.0063612279,
0.0255729817,
-0.0700148344,
0.0433821455,
-0.0325759277,
0.0141778141,
0.0239931364,
-0.0350878909,
0.0364636518,
-0.0161501318,
0.0374909155,
-0.0347410776,
0.0208090823,
0.002774888,
0.0653031245,
-0.0310331993,
-0.0486275963,
-0.0162322931,
0.0275321174,
0.0101970248,
-0.0618786141,
0.0807026774,
-0.0927112624,
-0.0096019814,
0.0053634034,
0.0072739581,
0.0025491824,
-0.0109620085,
0.0211348664,
-0.0240396168,
-0.0040174187,
0.022770321,
-0.0017262463,
-0.0290809795,
-0.090503417,
-0.0196504071,
0.0230488647,
-0.0478689,
-0.0364858545,
-0.0607818812,
-0.0043802932,
0.0218180288,
-0.0415556319,
0.0057925703,
2.893851278e-34,
0.0320887007,
0.0087815942,
0.0312486272,
0.068689622,
-0.0029881962,
-0.018485127,
-0.0022659784,
-0.0064373999,
0.0102354232,
-0.0386569947,
-0.023161361
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09605v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09605v1 | Measuring and Improving Attentiveness to Partial Inputs with Counterfactuals | 2023-11-16T06:27:35 | 2023-11-16T06:27:35 | Yanai Elazar, Bhargavi Paranjape, Hao Peng, Sarah Wiegreffe, Khyathi Raghavi, Vivek Srikumar, Sameer Singh, Noah A. Smith | cs.CL | cs.CL | The inevitable appearance of spurious correlations in training datasets hurts
the generalization of NLP models on unseen data. Previous work has found that
datasets with paired inputs are prone to correlations between a specific part
of the input (e.g., the hypothesis in NLI) and the label; consequently, models
trained only on those outperform chance. Are these correlations picked up by
models trained on the full input data? To address this question, we propose a
new evaluation method, Counterfactual Attentiveness Test (CAT). CAT uses
counterfactuals by replacing part of the input with its counterpart from a
different example (subject to some restrictions), expecting an attentive model
to change its prediction. Using CAT, we systematically investigate established
supervised and in-context learning models on ten datasets spanning four tasks:
natural language inference, reading comprehension, paraphrase detection, and
visual & language reasoning. CAT reveals that reliance on such correlations is
mainly data-dependent. Surprisingly, we find that GPT3 becomes less attentive
with an increased number of demonstrations, while its accuracy on the test data
improves. Our results demonstrate that augmenting training or demonstration
data with counterfactuals is effective in improving models' attentiveness. We
show that models' attentiveness measured by CAT reveals different conclusions
from solely measuring correlations in data. | [
0.0415048823,
0.051887393,
-0.0196574908,
0.0331020057,
-0.0363168046,
0.0257292893,
0.0109116966,
0.0110152327,
0.0176891033,
-0.0368121378,
-0.0414016172,
-0.0021339497,
-0.0087487102,
-0.0159823671,
0.0358605534,
-0.0351062752,
0.0740340278,
0.0262922011,
0.0090510808,
0.0229946561,
-0.0089617893,
-0.0092069563,
0.0071010976,
0.0110476352,
-0.0184789319,
-0.0075270375,
0.0025674861,
0.0099268323,
0.045265004,
-0.0232239552,
0.0203378722,
0.0402483046,
0.0044909543,
0.0159091465,
0.0000016546,
-0.0463601537,
0.0059290142,
-0.0024690733,
-0.0409758575,
-0.0210608635,
-0.0262532793,
-0.0183410347,
0.026756838,
-0.0034936706,
-0.0522245243,
0.0074674767,
0.0288604014,
0.0812352523,
0.0605168305,
0.0607198179,
-0.0059709973,
0.0051857955,
0.0202503651,
-0.0237036552,
0.020104887,
-0.0272636749,
-0.0008531045,
0.0100292619,
-0.0139300199,
0.0089774355,
-0.0377665944,
0.025963312,
0.0628145263,
0.0763052106,
0.0070182537,
0.057489872,
-0.0615994185,
-0.0342583619,
-0.0108190654,
0.0730433241,
-0.0185141433,
-0.054667972,
-0.0282939263,
-0.031083649,
0.0229896698,
0.0483507253,
-0.0174313542,
-0.0230039097,
-0.0204377957,
0.0075876606,
0.0357482918,
0.0119672632,
0.0232624356,
0.0160401929,
0.0003585726,
0.0740388706,
-0.0196171943,
-0.0768022239,
0.0259184893,
0.0415787026,
-0.060857635,
-0.0177583061,
-0.0204984993,
-0.0116422558,
0.0116710477,
0.0241960343,
-0.0353494436,
-0.0860181078,
0.0352974199,
-0.0415069163,
0.0131170526,
0.0370466672,
-0.03875985,
0.0838138759,
-0.0407541059,
0.0681178719,
-0.0196615532,
0.0468904786,
-0.0101894243,
-0.0155615238,
-0.049703747,
-0.0214192141,
-0.0543397442,
0.0409060679,
-0.0249862336,
-0.0280427542,
0.0029773938,
-0.0032093034,
-0.0442113504,
0.0142952353,
0.0074416376,
0.0184497423,
-0.0557221733,
0.0012670575,
0.0017575742,
0.0133635635,
-0.060793303,
0.0408854708,
-0.016701499,
-0.0414406098,
-0.0535780229,
0.0027255835,
0.0054750014,
-0.0549918674,
0.0115384245,
0.0781420991,
-0.0065520643,
-0.0622104071,
-0.0141981738,
-0.0170032382,
-0.0026265646,
-0.0624947846,
0.0212776177,
-0.0190001354,
0.0245205536,
0.0167406034,
-0.0094886236,
-0.04105483,
-0.0122007784,
0.0260387212,
-0.035677243,
0.0913310573,
0.0472743101,
-0.0230684839,
-0.0198876895,
-0.0120601961,
-0.0388849229,
0.0826564878,
0.0062303958,
-0.012841953,
0.017172249,
0.0160581023,
0.0242032167,
-0.0091412021,
0.0608240925,
0.0130138854,
-0.0383286998,
0.036535088,
0.0251976512,
-0.0031900823,
0.0429668203,
0.0186819043,
-0.0342691951,
-0.0391330644,
0.0628728643,
-0.0030907474,
0.0020532834,
0.0050511328,
0.0165027417,
-0.0048262086,
-0.0100681605,
0.0552337505,
-0.1145026609,
0.0480055548,
-0.0338801518,
0.0430587828,
-0.0139231049,
-0.015352427,
-0.0149714984,
-0.035271816,
-0.0231657214,
0.0322729722,
0.0348452479,
0.0260886308,
0.0487123914,
0.0470473506,
-0.0484227948,
-0.0132175907,
-0.0027305062,
-0.03598129,
0.0075647333,
-0.031412594,
-0.0043262453,
0.0337767974,
0.0277478918,
-0.050566949,
0.0046972483,
0.0098413564,
0.0227826871,
0.011893048,
0.0518111549,
0.0189062171,
0.031361755,
-0.0176144298,
-0.0177621599,
-0.0404550433,
0.0426788703,
0.0046471865,
0.0340195596,
0.0163754392,
0.0039970842,
-0.0424931087,
0.0020722537,
0.0515984781,
-0.0317177288,
-0.0317954756,
-0.0275241006,
0.0390335768,
0.034370698,
-0.0095173651,
0.0159966759,
-0.0178555455,
0.025619423,
-0.0137420567,
0.0240626931,
0.032844197,
-0.0135759739,
-0.0809108987,
0.0002582148,
-0.042539347,
-0.0789483413,
0.080347307,
-0.0466376543,
-0.0350439996,
0.0266910344,
-0.0322034396,
0.0592447035,
-0.0426408462,
-0.0197193772,
0.007856654,
0.0202287752,
-0.0153092053,
0.0381809138,
-0.033759743,
0.0182331987,
0.00917634,
0.0059561455,
0.0268121641,
-0.0253014602,
-0.0056101261,
-0.0053223604,
0.0141886463,
-0.0169411283,
-0.0089270137,
0.0107043181,
-0.0774675757,
-0.0186774284,
-0.0631875247,
0.0169081669,
-0.042673558,
0.023812402,
0.0181058552,
-0.0043241601,
0.0089417454,
-0.0303594805,
0.0072295461,
-0.049279213,
-0.011208212,
0.0285747219,
0.0384320356,
0.02068091,
0.0207983516,
-0.0452287421,
-0.0256921165,
-0.0320145935,
0.0537370294,
0.0117954807,
0.0045556743,
-0.0122950487,
0.012474522,
-0.0017625941,
0.0341982506,
-0.002110681,
-0.0398854464,
0.0182282403,
0.0150448913,
-0.0059393011,
0.1065779328,
-0.0260407794,
0.0183604155,
0.0063624741,
0.0222252794,
-0.0469703265,
0.0421671718,
-0.0047311252,
0.0012860765,
-0.0041160681,
-0.0366449654,
-0.0241822135,
0.0511186384,
0.0054917349,
-0.0340232551,
-0.1005927101,
0.0020941803,
-0.0051778327,
-0.0448589772,
-0.0174866058,
-0.0045430115,
-0.0152411405,
0.0140634645,
-0.0694513693,
-0.0441424325,
0.1067142859,
0.0217113476,
-0.0178065728,
-0.0418454371,
0.0131317154,
-0.0175039712,
0.063699685,
0.0235797781,
-0.0064282385,
-0.005183226,
-0.00824189,
-0.0558759235,
0.0001565288,
0.0126905506,
-0.0023507352,
0.0208069365,
-0.0532107018,
0.006303865,
0.0194352288,
-0.0456475988,
-0.0482942127,
-0.0308889113,
-0.0167109016,
0.0138608627,
-0.0557912029,
0.000535674,
-0.0259684082,
-0.0210978724,
0.0116076097,
0.0407913215,
0.002944404,
-0.0087909801,
-0.0216847006,
-0.0093492428,
0.0271161329,
0.0465715863,
0.0046552168,
-0.0440621525,
-0.0336953141,
0.0252586417,
0.0381887071,
-0.0211358946,
-0.022929104,
0.0223654117,
-0.0249350742,
-0.023570329,
-0.004625164,
-0.002096744,
0.0106672058,
-0.0721518397,
-0.0157091804,
0.0570873022,
0.0071136542,
0.001791171,
-0.0005572625,
0.0272047557,
0.0449701175,
0.0489743277,
-0.0067412811,
-0.0422313251,
-0.0527715199,
0.0049144081,
0.0130741587,
-0.0095895398,
-0.0041756527,
-0.0263358094,
-0.1063178331,
-0.0008027161,
-0.0333589427,
-0.0495249294,
-0.0359390192,
-0.0635898411,
0.0414048769,
-0.0448492356,
0.010476782,
-0.0089987544,
0.0009156286,
0.0274434909,
-0.0029136101,
0.0022266766,
-0.0491229929,
0.0124838445,
-0.0056732898,
0.0226113908,
0.0493955202,
0.0178647507,
-0.0248655248,
-0.0069244481,
0.0413852185,
-0.0519321114,
0.0140392222,
0.0019849944,
0.0855798349,
-0.0387954488,
-0.0014205104,
-0.0070302724,
0.0376211032,
-0.0133029204,
-0.0321892388,
-0.0049239993,
0.0496839583,
0.0146797365,
-0.034591388,
-0.0482041612,
-0.0157871079,
0.0077914251,
0.1017525941,
0.0449733734,
-0.0297546349,
-0.0660141259,
0.0114671746,
0.0082952492,
-0.0385700911,
-0.0015911346,
0.0131839933,
0.0655996129,
-0.0155735165,
-0.0377678871,
-0.1023985669,
0.0169448741,
0.0191298481,
-0.0037735337,
0.0154553261,
-0.0354225524,
-0.0229808707,
-0.0391000248,
0.0690322816,
0.0236953646,
0.0122889355,
-0.0160394516,
-0.0062315259,
-0.000987121,
-0.0399673171,
-0.0510969236,
0.0223683957,
-0.0854051113,
-0.0430670157,
0.0087064952,
0.054554861,
0.0285979547,
0.0781534091,
-0.0199697688,
-0.0051705097,
-0.0371238515,
0.048688449,
-0.0486379191,
0.0291452371,
0.0579095185,
-0.0405599624,
0.0167752132,
0.0212069694,
-0.0148553317,
-0.0038152502,
0.0533821099,
0.033929646,
-0.0157540627,
0.013231962,
0.0323473625,
-0.0094567519,
0.0928221196,
-0.0020587663,
0.0097348504,
-0.0393514633,
0.0225307886,
-0.0045746211,
0.0065289563,
-0.0269398391,
-0.0068053245,
0.0135101127,
0.0138304653,
-0.0400328934,
-0.0039803884,
-0.0223720931,
0.0332406089,
-0.0169491358,
0.0117863175,
0.0198328104,
-0.0129862344,
-0.0110943923,
-0.0124423932,
-0.041251082,
-0.0082563944,
0.0130764544,
0.0215822887,
0.0262015611,
0.0131251505,
0.0688277856,
-0.0202463567,
-0.0165346209,
0.019541502,
-0.1152905375,
0.0503665507,
-0.0194619428,
0.0369295217,
0.0047747819,
-0.0643155053,
0.0020794901,
-0.0363828801,
-0.0094048679,
0.0139265489,
0.0207057111,
0.0074570598,
-0.0151690794,
-0.0058587557,
0.0400630124,
0.0130061163,
0.0118753975,
0.0503451265,
0.0044102543,
0.0545269102,
-0.0398372561,
0.011792033,
-0.0387297571,
-0.0289608724,
0.0188488718,
0.0247073043,
-0.0147493184,
0.0757141039,
-0.0916317105,
-0.07846874,
-0.0038107072,
0.0436250679,
0.0193357673,
-0.0109474296,
0.0397715196,
0.0407481864,
-0.0153964777,
-0.0581715666,
0.0071516898,
-0.0201008674,
0.0310757514,
-0.0016051267,
-0.0605630688,
-5.984679043e-33,
-0.0058122608,
-0.0269204807,
0.0045456914,
-0.0094828866,
0.0033880633,
-0.0110946,
-0.0350374691,
-0.0262145791,
-0.0539147556,
0.0197187848,
-0.0256637596,
0.0404980183,
0.0109514799,
0.0163119677,
-0.0019722241,
-0.0416048095,
0.0438966006,
0.0164231956,
-0.0293668285,
-0.0136391995,
-0.0023936576,
0.0188164134,
0.0895379037,
-0.086132139,
0.0426208749,
-0.0064063244,
-0.0060596471,
0.0023753846,
-0.0672853068,
0.0577203073,
-0.0012079392,
0.0410286747,
0.0432418957,
-0.0356077775,
0.0211915467,
-0.0091192974,
-0.0959703475,
-0.0620416142,
0.0143368598,
0.0335537456,
-0.073839061,
0.0149401687,
0.0448597074,
-0.0033372503,
0.0083828289,
-0.0240531843,
0.0448875688,
-0.0297449604,
-0.0145943891,
0.0215621945,
-0.0423600711,
0.0100611765,
-0.0052980166,
-0.0055695791,
0.0130168544,
0.0728485361,
-0.0067810407,
0.0250914022,
-0.0414373167,
-0.014990313,
0.0349621885,
-0.0052053616,
0.0254080165,
0.0102607692,
0.0060205511,
0.041088175,
-0.0048793652,
0.0469383635,
-0.0067893583,
-0.0634324551,
0.0368168056,
0.037950512,
0.039677348,
0.0783566013,
0.0862007365,
0.0212818794,
-0.0535729975,
-0.0157620795,
-0.0151353246,
0.0343669094,
0.012827063,
-0.0079964893,
-0.0654422268,
0.0103953658,
-0.0433405004,
-0.0136370063,
-0.048887521,
-0.0208031237,
0.06157979,
0.0263844449,
-0.0078619588,
0.0090139341,
0.0175063647,
-0.0297680628,
-0.0131119322,
0.0640170872,
-0.0196134541,
0.0065297713,
0.0153334569,
0.0406773873,
-0.0290002674,
-0.0250548571,
0.0145468349,
0.0703657642,
0.049179595,
-0.0184918474,
0.0978232697,
0.0027241425,
-0.05239572,
-0.0168628469,
-0.030407602,
0.0259095915,
-0.0126321064,
-0.0263642203,
0.0625842139,
0.0259701349,
-0.004149429,
0.0377654545,
0.0313970856,
-0.0211758241,
-0.0677206591,
0.0203562062,
-0.018935103,
0.0163458064,
-0.0141535383,
-0.0161585268,
0.0116252238,
-0.019781895,
-0.0340641439,
-0.0566494949,
-0.0177315809,
0.0773650557,
2.488e-7,
0.0382010043,
0.0170030072,
0.0071785916,
0.0418996885,
0.008405705,
0.0231457613,
-0.0460166298,
0.0240443759,
0.0300803073,
-0.024482552,
0.0180946123,
0.048732698,
0.0340371393,
-0.0158869009,
-0.0585254915,
0.019338524,
-0.0496410131,
0.0033248693,
-0.0345150791,
-0.0034351386,
0.0727647096,
0.0984507427,
0.0422587097,
0.015701877,
-0.0072169276,
-0.0129553024,
0.0564068817,
-0.0272669736,
0.0377994142,
-0.0371215194,
0.01416896,
0.011876272,
0.0057135685,
0.0937189311,
-0.0147917438,
0.0121731786,
0.0044088527,
0.0179657321,
-0.0188557394,
-0.0478494242,
-0.0178748071,
-0.0028241952,
0.0129115144,
-0.0763154104,
0.0729772523,
-0.0417708494,
-0.0049130856,
0.0263917875,
-0.0365756042,
-0.0243809093,
0.043338269,
0.011167747,
-0.0285889097,
-0.0039646933,
0.0114863114,
0.0019759187,
-0.0013482179,
-0.0637620836,
-0.0589774884,
0.0235164128,
-0.0460118316,
-0.0150573887,
-0.0137453331,
0.0069970218,
0.0672338381,
-0.0375523828,
-0.0460465848,
1.890088502e-34,
0.0420105085,
-0.0044016857,
0.0492694788,
0.0139125949,
0.012030961,
-0.0168568287,
-0.0313844308,
-0.0085918466,
0.0477831699,
-0.0391130149,
-0.0099338526
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09603v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09603v2 | Self-Contradictory Reasoning Evaluation and Detection | 2023-11-16T06:22:17 | 2024-02-19T18:01:56 | Ziyi Liu, Isabelle Lee, Yongkang Du, Soumya Sanyal, Jieyu Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL | In a plethora of recent work, large language models (LLMs) demonstrated
impressive reasoning ability, but many proposed downstream reasoning tasks
focus on performance-wise evaluation. Two fundamental questions persist: 1) how
reliable is the quality of reasoning, and 2) can models detect unreliable
reasoning? In this paper, we investigate self-contradictory (Self-Contra)
reasoning, where the model reasoning does not support predictions. To address
1), we assess the Self-Contra rate across four datasets and delve into
finer-grained categories of Self-Contra reasoning. We find that LLMs often
contradict themselves when performing reasoning tasks that involve contextual
information understanding or commonsense. Importantly, a higher accuracy does
not necessarily correspond to a lower Self-Contra rate. The model may appear to
generate correct answers but it may take shortcuts in reasoning or skip over
contextual evidence, thereby displaying Self-Contra behaviors with compromised
reasoning. As for 2), we task GPT-4 with identifying Self-Contra reasoning and
finer-grained fallacies. We observe that GPT-4 struggles to effectively detect
Self-Contra reasoning, with significantly low performance compared with human
judgment. Our results indicate that the current LLMs lack robustness necessary
for reliable reasoning and we emphasize the urgent need for establishing best
practices in comprehensive reasoning evaluations beyond accuracy-based metrics. | [
0.0393102467,
0.0388394967,
-0.017739512,
0.0518371537,
-0.0533185303,
0.0236431882,
0.0069167037,
-0.0006518896,
0.0213575196,
-0.0468237922,
-0.0545646399,
0.0034710828,
0.0094874846,
0.0035113622,
0.0281892344,
-0.0033217533,
0.0893743932,
-0.0404713564,
0.0340640731,
-0.0379682966,
-0.0089564947,
0.0046444326,
0.0122793317,
0.0068653878,
0.0155404266,
-0.0538958795,
0.0120513542,
-0.0173235051,
-0.0111568281,
-0.0243725404,
0.0074423891,
0.0594724528,
0.0139962351,
0.0766554251,
0.0000019336,
-0.0426534787,
0.0062660887,
-0.0178978704,
-0.0543282889,
0.039761547,
0.0056332308,
0.0097698215,
-0.0094558336,
0.0358928144,
-0.0410332344,
0.0100456579,
-0.0108212763,
0.0646609887,
0.0593319125,
0.0520891994,
0.0235692784,
0.0006997874,
-0.0132968603,
-0.0321924761,
0.006255073,
-0.0227571446,
0.0245758072,
0.045674473,
-0.0253428016,
0.029819347,
-0.0127981696,
0.021341987,
0.0442417711,
0.0046067378,
-0.0531797819,
0.0291404445,
-0.0390092358,
-0.0278187376,
-0.0026107044,
0.0086855283,
0.0485979691,
-0.0631308183,
-0.0052007549,
-0.0088849934,
0.0039667357,
-0.0011589497,
-0.0042039608,
0.0290975422,
-0.0001889493,
0.0080011413,
0.0383167453,
0.0057672332,
0.0334615856,
0.0155735184,
-0.0116665792,
0.1137361825,
-0.0170064289,
-0.0572565906,
0.0090043694,
0.0028176904,
-0.0195519682,
-0.0602653883,
-0.0277795028,
0.0261690821,
-0.0227202754,
0.031063484,
-0.0356900245,
0.0346671529,
0.0673952997,
-0.0490426831,
-0.0058782795,
0.0269328579,
-0.0144755337,
0.0631941259,
-0.0370842852,
0.0548459552,
-0.021608606,
0.0597851574,
0.0099624339,
-0.0054456149,
-0.0129897529,
-0.0488789715,
0.003038994,
0.0165942758,
-0.0091906982,
0.0010277446,
-0.0377087519,
-0.000519465,
-0.0503876843,
0.0072846832,
0.0318476632,
0.0209107511,
0.0204378497,
-0.0462050922,
-0.0938914865,
0.0162324365,
-0.0136785796,
0.0338329822,
-0.0096163182,
-0.0426655449,
-0.0271679908,
-0.0079609156,
-0.0555550195,
-0.0233293176,
0.0119290669,
0.0402051173,
0.0028643659,
-0.0021060253,
-0.0590473637,
-0.0186220612,
-0.0801979527,
-0.1090592742,
-0.0197715666,
-0.0615653656,
-0.0039267242,
0.0024659073,
-0.0125059579,
-0.0305594802,
0.008683593,
0.0131016355,
-0.0291485079,
0.0713007078,
-0.0190896243,
0.0264642835,
0.0338340625,
0.0378768444,
-0.0002658444,
0.0720468462,
0.0091677429,
-0.012476014,
0.0179853719,
-0.0117010521,
-0.0035198673,
-0.0157129876,
0.0419969223,
-0.0118553517,
-0.0271547996,
0.0405891724,
-0.0479929931,
0.0196647737,
0.0364746414,
0.0604404509,
-0.0105770081,
-0.051327806,
0.063420862,
0.0327392519,
0.0101478938,
-0.005225346,
0.0385517143,
-0.0106618656,
0.0079153832,
0.0298467297,
-0.0755123049,
0.0360776894,
-0.0393695459,
-0.0160597246,
0.0345488787,
-0.0006163088,
-0.0101467157,
-0.0483662896,
-0.0241381172,
0.0093810149,
0.0157295987,
0.0281621758,
0.0355926156,
-0.0057744593,
-0.0123327523,
0.0130558014,
0.0078361211,
-0.0412189364,
-0.0069283186,
-0.0712259486,
0.0443917811,
0.05222499,
0.0369929373,
0.0069960882,
-0.0333335064,
0.0006052463,
-0.0144736897,
0.0329358578,
0.0602024905,
0.0054911789,
-0.0173296519,
-0.0091773113,
-0.0099145649,
-0.039122425,
0.0276195779,
-0.0234518666,
0.0137791047,
0.0174885057,
0.0172989648,
-0.0469128042,
0.0225565825,
0.0340578072,
-0.0436474308,
-0.014257852,
-0.0228821225,
-0.0058683613,
0.0126488255,
-0.013815213,
0.0159709658,
0.0207724534,
0.0394162163,
0.0120989662,
-0.0435816236,
-0.0010427666,
-0.071673356,
-0.0476460978,
0.03892323,
0.0135319643,
-0.0514405482,
0.0043738321,
-0.0173985697,
-0.032611154,
0.0402453132,
-0.0184444711,
-0.0038628851,
-0.0649676472,
0.0284449235,
-0.0112464158,
0.0086257951,
0.0041839308,
0.08788497,
-0.0260891877,
0.0339674018,
-0.0258700587,
0.0336683542,
0.0318340436,
-0.0531296246,
-0.0132223889,
0.0034003151,
0.0039883628,
-0.0044585974,
-0.0021001287,
-0.0232011378,
-0.0550556965,
-0.0151676014,
-0.0597588457,
-0.0117842155,
-0.0115092425,
0.0209206101,
0.0414031185,
-0.0500550717,
-0.0076587112,
-0.0084303245,
0.0015201048,
-0.0243677162,
0.0309217405,
0.0183083378,
0.0329529904,
-0.0153481318,
0.0399064682,
-0.0181880035,
0.009544502,
-0.0583332032,
-0.010260867,
-0.0153857339,
0.0553504005,
-0.0651095733,
-0.0159885343,
-0.0653778538,
0.0201761704,
-0.0135494135,
-0.0402859189,
0.0337483846,
0.0315446779,
0.0088292183,
0.0777557418,
0.0229655541,
0.0241680667,
0.0841599405,
-0.0085020177,
-0.0507127233,
0.0301832594,
-0.0114218211,
0.0161627177,
-0.0151870828,
-0.0420646742,
-0.0219365247,
0.0553241856,
0.0344428308,
0.0205458011,
-0.0697146431,
0.0451036915,
-0.0358988605,
-0.0340426043,
0.0030338506,
-0.0268122461,
-0.0206459053,
0.0612121373,
-0.0048034168,
-0.0360041372,
0.0789404735,
-0.0282067936,
0.0163923185,
0.0029602121,
-0.0005253677,
-0.0118150134,
0.0643545836,
-0.0138541348,
-0.0174064375,
0.0186320394,
0.0227071531,
-0.0269706938,
-0.0329636186,
0.0325022303,
-0.046493616,
0.0295862295,
-0.0466511622,
0.0034526398,
0.0172116309,
-0.0719157159,
-0.0472209826,
-0.0421785489,
-0.034204077,
-0.044374045,
-0.0333863087,
-0.0177176241,
0.0144400867,
-0.0062856064,
0.0055241087,
0.0292743053,
-0.0410610139,
-0.0174405407,
0.0081750443,
-0.0106506841,
0.0470928513,
0.032379292,
0.0907420218,
-0.0115578454,
0.0258480757,
0.0507745557,
0.0061676055,
0.0121964039,
-0.0331355073,
0.0063549834,
-0.0204186086,
0.0303596016,
-0.0261623617,
0.0111746136,
0.055227831,
-0.054313004,
-0.0270798206,
0.1226813719,
0.0491286479,
0.0155475475,
-0.0026010179,
-0.0536151901,
0.0370432958,
0.0293135289,
-0.0141376154,
-0.0475912131,
-0.0491417982,
0.022295719,
0.038719818,
-0.0393660106,
-0.0330865234,
-0.0143858735,
-0.0983037874,
0.0522435345,
0.0014987172,
-0.0043816399,
-0.0134677785,
-0.0292078629,
0.0125482157,
-0.0166966412,
0.0297340974,
0.0309401117,
0.0028761523,
-0.0058884672,
-0.0115631819,
-0.0409480557,
-0.0410869904,
0.0778608024,
0.0088577,
0.0707310811,
0.0239848867,
0.0422563888,
0.0235636048,
-0.0607838407,
0.0273441412,
-0.0441303514,
-0.0155424373,
-0.020348981,
0.0277868845,
-0.0204119086,
0.0023960038,
-0.0213195849,
0.0061882949,
-0.0429073013,
-0.0251172148,
0.0061049755,
0.0902216136,
-0.0282083079,
-0.0495893285,
-0.0289128758,
0.0417122543,
-0.0188940763,
0.1034797356,
0.015284068,
0.0093108844,
-0.06013567,
-0.0079515167,
-0.0280158706,
-0.0113508468,
-0.0329773016,
0.0291925576,
0.086589247,
0.023332024,
-0.0506933369,
-0.0605671853,
-0.0046919389,
-0.0160133224,
-0.0474830456,
0.0296554416,
-0.0130907223,
0.0025786755,
-0.0239166189,
0.0071680467,
-0.0437224768,
0.0010013758,
-0.0310504064,
0.040837653,
0.0085066091,
-0.0065225456,
-0.0108912122,
0.0400740318,
-0.0777844191,
-0.0629738793,
0.0061106975,
0.034433499,
0.0252012461,
0.0363795124,
-0.0177436583,
-0.0034045584,
-0.0050445329,
0.0227959268,
-0.0378689915,
0.0494909696,
0.0397431254,
-0.0215225648,
0.0127931619,
0.0585080087,
0.0059453729,
0.0202859826,
0.0041707573,
0.0255523194,
-0.0331933685,
-0.006190605,
0.0479554683,
0.0022593343,
0.0443952605,
0.0062202937,
0.0384345949,
-0.0154122151,
0.0121017313,
-0.022564074,
-0.0472839214,
0.0092963502,
0.0121061364,
0.0082950573,
-0.033062201,
-0.0193399712,
-0.0150865484,
-0.0353938229,
-0.0028445076,
0.0114950892,
-0.0087649273,
0.0260771774,
0.0211651269,
-0.0132269803,
-0.034450002,
-0.0106528485,
-0.0093757035,
-0.0123150889,
0.0408965424,
-0.0023697175,
0.0743694231,
0.0323493369,
-0.01617359,
0.0190636367,
-0.0025634503,
-0.0779988542,
-0.046916049,
0.026975682,
-0.0040197251,
-0.0014832566,
-0.0099320626,
0.0425835103,
-0.0403113961,
-0.0078481585,
-0.0306403115,
0.0049551642,
0.0248584431,
-0.0032221908,
0.0386759527,
0.0191960949,
-0.036054451,
-0.0159595516,
0.0406295806,
-0.0034807879,
0.0372740924,
0.0299773589,
-0.0277726259,
-0.036355067,
-0.0666920245,
-0.0471388139,
0.0018125324,
-0.0220925752,
0.0085694939,
-0.0727632046,
-0.0910857171,
-0.0049484139,
0.0670297965,
0.0113885161,
-0.036371991,
-0.0179915149,
0.0828477815,
-0.0123770759,
-0.0120540187,
-0.0191079099,
0.0208481904,
-0.0046767714,
0.0387008823,
-0.0277173761,
-6.429065131e-33,
-0.0381422378,
-0.0594297163,
0.0391242169,
-0.0503850393,
0.0227180235,
-0.0269481726,
-0.0368330181,
0.0146469269,
-0.0471015796,
0.0443813801,
-0.0114031583,
0.053533975,
0.0109654684,
-0.0072898972,
0.015516487,
0.0018569836,
0.0309886746,
0.0081710564,
-0.0484017096,
-0.000345516,
0.0623769425,
-0.031192122,
0.0441799313,
-0.0669304579,
0.0374211371,
0.007428376,
-0.0274151992,
0.018877225,
-0.1016307473,
0.047368452,
-0.0228351951,
0.0240131561,
0.0197621286,
0.0003493116,
0.0083676986,
-0.0094350986,
-0.0469341688,
-0.0445425473,
0.0416880399,
-0.0172303468,
-0.0568675846,
0.0066341129,
0.0156858768,
0.0112508731,
-0.0619780421,
-0.0002493208,
-0.0068255384,
-0.00424685,
0.0403146148,
0.0566131324,
-0.0622866787,
0.0140188262,
0.0066273753,
-0.0267697014,
-0.0115744527,
0.016772151,
-0.0185390022,
0.0177850109,
-0.0699037984,
0.0007547224,
-0.001991272,
-0.0110463761,
0.0774682537,
-0.015223722,
-0.0084761875,
0.0617444143,
0.0061851619,
0.008217941,
-0.0394513682,
-0.0220846813,
0.0190992821,
0.0235427786,
0.1034835279,
0.029518852,
0.0396387056,
-0.0204376373,
-0.0512519926,
-0.0364675298,
-0.0347053483,
0.0313621499,
0.051110208,
-0.0155800395,
-0.0228203665,
-0.0151301958,
-0.0520913973,
-0.0340029523,
-0.0239238013,
-0.0114739705,
0.0364016928,
0.018946398,
0.0000813383,
-0.0047040642,
-0.0013298605,
-0.01656463,
-0.0141653139,
0.0179809015,
-0.0332748853,
-0.0334922411,
0.0245732889,
0.0581163168,
-0.0521318503,
0.03157809,
0.0093831513,
0.0186688658,
0.0075568119,
0.0028591154,
0.0463992693,
-0.0011145237,
-0.0531917922,
-0.0042139343,
-0.0344100334,
0.0538460985,
-0.0449046791,
-0.0533745848,
0.0785798579,
0.0127094416,
-0.0149201825,
0.017834371,
0.000252141,
-0.0138787339,
-0.0633339956,
0.0596434213,
-0.0022909634,
0.0296634417,
0.0168779735,
0.0006144899,
-0.0350096971,
0.0219072849,
-0.0062343734,
-0.0441189595,
0.0146044102,
0.0400442928,
2.563e-7,
0.0357232355,
0.0622070208,
-0.0157207716,
0.0071509676,
0.0391420685,
0.067006506,
-0.0426735245,
-0.0166422538,
0.0202238522,
-0.0411662348,
-0.0188253317,
0.0649863631,
0.0466952473,
0.0474322625,
0.0034690422,
0.0693251565,
-0.0800354034,
-0.0240575615,
-0.0223940704,
0.0066658882,
0.0630269274,
0.0721728653,
0.0443780757,
-0.0090621775,
0.0152659742,
-0.0458344296,
0.0830737054,
0.0108748507,
0.0198593698,
-0.0034838393,
-0.0083048809,
0.0197602697,
0.0013770069,
0.0390783995,
0.0132608982,
-0.0009576055,
-0.0405517258,
0.0467986688,
-0.0141302664,
-0.0346263088,
-0.0666245818,
0.0063661961,
0.0098433653,
-0.089884907,
0.0924962759,
-0.0661971346,
-0.0336043127,
-0.0385129973,
0.0388891175,
-0.0035662397,
0.0493397117,
0.0051832655,
-0.042098511,
0.0040056254,
0.025450645,
0.0145598175,
0.0069557107,
-0.0953275263,
-0.0118871648,
0.0093088923,
-0.0427289829,
-0.0241113845,
-0.0391203091,
0.0476179272,
0.0473556481,
-0.0513749346,
0.0099066505,
2.290241587e-34,
0.0111893062,
-0.0074801762,
0.0250392705,
-0.0363069773,
0.0378009938,
0.0253296923,
0.0267323051,
0.0090401582,
-0.0002007756,
-0.0229045507,
-0.0233765133
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09602v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09602v2 | Language Models (Mostly) Do Not Consider Emotion Triggers When Predicting Emotion | 2023-11-16T06:20:13 | 2024-03-25T20:42:57 | Smriti Singh, Cornelia Caragea, Junyi Jessy Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | Situations and events evoke emotions in humans, but to what extent do they
inform the prediction of emotion detection models? This work investigates how
well human-annotated emotion triggers correlate with features that models
deemed salient in their prediction of emotions. First, we introduce a novel
dataset EmoTrigger, consisting of 900 social media posts sourced from three
different datasets; these were annotated by experts for emotion triggers with
high agreement. Using EmoTrigger, we evaluate the ability of large language
models (LLMs) to identify emotion triggers, and conduct a comparative analysis
of the features considered important for these tasks between LLMs and
fine-tuned models. Our analysis reveals that emotion triggers are largely not
considered salient features for emotion prediction models, instead there is
intricate interplay between various features and the task of emotion detection. | [
0.026391359,
0.0352652483,
0.0076894355,
0.0290058367,
0.0243391059,
0.0494424552,
-0.0185262095,
-0.0084762899,
0.0485677198,
-0.0621287711,
-0.0360418335,
0.0157617535,
-0.0510482825,
0.0109466119,
0.0112692779,
-0.0581069998,
0.0157933682,
0.0560207181,
0.0472491756,
0.0125812143,
0.0484230258,
0.0616311692,
0.014942497,
0.0497569069,
-0.0403650142,
0.0012279333,
-0.0272582732,
0.0188199785,
0.0487137698,
-0.0261308067,
0.0524810068,
0.0724881068,
0.0306968987,
0.005572034,
0.0000016712,
-0.0174801555,
0.0142764691,
-0.045617193,
0.026185561,
-0.0070434194,
0.091446124,
-0.0566691197,
0.0027325931,
0.0081154928,
-0.0271378271,
-0.0191910379,
0.0490029752,
0.0584354773,
0.0603340268,
0.0583244003,
-0.0377641059,
-0.0153801022,
-0.012972449,
-0.0120470198,
0.0011196614,
-0.0193926804,
0.0234009176,
-0.0257630963,
-0.0159313139,
-0.038771227,
-0.0263852179,
0.0097486405,
0.0109866271,
0.0052494449,
0.0219963435,
0.0091044763,
-0.0615663268,
-0.0254116058,
0.0004122047,
0.0699222237,
-0.0204691663,
-0.0259799715,
-0.004837974,
-0.0186076034,
0.007456121,
-0.0135353077,
-0.0086110551,
-0.0355145074,
0.0067405477,
0.0455618575,
0.0280129015,
-0.0052822595,
0.0121152122,
0.0729039609,
0.0345521607,
0.0385711715,
-0.0185544826,
-0.0074749701,
0.0254688766,
0.0264128875,
-0.0390310958,
-0.0307182204,
0.0084647611,
-0.0139816841,
-0.0172719788,
0.0218174346,
-0.0509423316,
0.0035299785,
-0.0132076591,
-0.0477247238,
-0.0306252055,
0.0236875061,
-0.0293465145,
0.0411855578,
0.0209636353,
0.0091420375,
-0.0130113736,
-0.0057051517,
0.0079259127,
-0.0080566015,
-0.036875993,
0.0308278054,
-0.0061636586,
-0.0057818843,
-0.0230553299,
-0.0314249098,
-0.0593714528,
-0.0195938572,
-0.0186296236,
-0.0158950146,
-0.0477505662,
0.0064282832,
-0.0052927569,
-0.0059483885,
0.0037450318,
0.0173002649,
-0.0248457901,
0.0204906594,
0.0079451445,
-0.0729286969,
0.016027892,
-0.0056805918,
0.0344520509,
-0.0044928715,
0.0140780415,
-0.0239551328,
0.0097272107,
-0.0577942394,
-0.0440458134,
-0.033540003,
-0.0075146765,
-0.0294393338,
-0.0072641228,
-0.0550944693,
0.0573797226,
0.0124153234,
0.0210719705,
-0.0141436439,
0.0283818822,
-0.0074611488,
-0.0354593471,
0.074777171,
-0.0213711299,
-0.0012556016,
-0.0134246042,
0.0155825671,
0.0272046328,
0.0630253181,
0.0029119565,
0.0946216807,
0.0652888343,
-0.0088506648,
0.0398020595,
0.0243929848,
-0.0069549982,
-0.0047484101,
-0.0162602905,
-0.0451487415,
-0.0423672646,
0.0022301218,
0.061014995,
-0.0017617973,
-0.0172874015,
-0.0245857146,
0.0436101817,
0.0615860373,
-0.0473210961,
0.065103136,
-0.019157812,
0.0244689472,
0.0145491343,
-0.0254898835,
-0.0499553569,
0.0208834894,
-0.0286650006,
-0.0304288194,
0.0317732245,
-0.0129595706,
-0.0191040412,
-0.0363142006,
-0.0317502283,
-0.0157465171,
-0.0288220849,
0.0233532824,
0.0204789657,
-0.020544881,
-0.0360118113,
0.0280380901,
0.0369469896,
-0.0715592057,
-0.0018663931,
-0.0246084016,
-0.0000256165,
0.062103726,
0.0026024806,
-0.0409419462,
-0.0034358595,
-0.0333518758,
0.0189733692,
0.0440979265,
0.0557294711,
0.0181767642,
0.0384993777,
-0.0438491069,
-0.0023830242,
-0.0106906854,
0.0330137797,
0.0063473047,
-0.017382469,
0.0286756642,
-0.0189477149,
0.0106005035,
-0.0201409124,
0.0275486447,
-0.0286329351,
-0.0165145639,
-0.0383056253,
0.0131156407,
-0.001500283,
0.0027904175,
0.0009362999,
-0.0135686006,
0.0135940704,
-0.0261755511,
-0.0162926372,
0.0273003094,
0.0177330207,
-0.0187304113,
0.0440357998,
-0.0124526499,
-0.0243282542,
0.0451271236,
-0.0749911591,
-0.0057821232,
0.0324883647,
-0.0261945762,
0.0300358851,
-0.0179752782,
-0.0117105013,
-0.0561846755,
0.0507283807,
0.0115919579,
0.0419146195,
-0.0063084047,
0.0098817274,
-0.0205865223,
-0.0124278637,
-0.016551625,
0.0108741708,
-0.0741187707,
0.0206252597,
0.0294673443,
0.009742883,
0.0308919176,
-0.0505510308,
-0.0906664506,
-0.0568770021,
-0.1207226515,
0.0030208256,
-0.0196072869,
0.0048591951,
0.0205616541,
-0.0303931739,
-0.0366101451,
-0.0049276631,
-0.0315402336,
0.0052293818,
-0.0113598667,
0.026497528,
-0.0066719642,
-0.0358150229,
0.0271206647,
-0.105079636,
0.008877513,
-0.0343383923,
0.0191901699,
0.026640946,
-0.0129578952,
-0.005916656,
0.0496474244,
-0.026411958,
0.025893176,
-0.0052102455,
-0.0605682954,
-0.0123932045,
0.0048229266,
-0.0214153677,
0.0633244142,
0.0026819133,
0.0986929089,
0.0041351933,
0.0010574394,
-0.0512204804,
0.0227213725,
-0.031919729,
-0.0037019164,
-0.0399183556,
-0.0349785499,
-0.0118080154,
0.0598702207,
0.0028848629,
0.0154889319,
-0.0529302098,
0.0084803011,
0.0196220037,
-0.0289868787,
-0.0248192977,
-0.0213415343,
-0.0160824303,
0.0432329923,
-0.0332064554,
-0.0766719654,
0.0310847256,
0.0443220101,
-0.0143352821,
-0.03664729,
0.0053628213,
-0.0429125279,
0.0611075871,
-0.0088562099,
-0.0064003514,
-0.0356385596,
0.0123667298,
-0.0051004468,
-0.0365562625,
-0.0199835133,
-0.0748710781,
0.0377514102,
0.0129379118,
-0.0294506103,
0.0323153958,
-0.0375925153,
-0.0320847109,
-0.0666100159,
-0.09438622,
0.0075417096,
-0.0099892858,
-0.0095569724,
-0.0129555268,
-0.0489667356,
0.000966294,
-0.0488054231,
-0.0060567586,
-0.0386096723,
0.0080557996,
0.0276601017,
0.0937745869,
-0.0056127394,
0.0210684035,
0.0014869191,
0.0386394598,
0.052521389,
0.0387411118,
0.0072020232,
-0.0278361086,
0.0361572504,
0.0263388101,
0.0207984503,
-0.008431281,
-0.0520225093,
0.028511323,
-0.0368558243,
0.0379691571,
0.1360825747,
0.0263768751,
-0.0517059006,
0.0145704392,
-0.0274783857,
0.0227981526,
0.0492679588,
0.0211874712,
-0.0520886853,
-0.0426879413,
-0.0187254399,
0.0107735209,
0.0141485408,
-0.0175868757,
-0.0055024619,
-0.0896203071,
0.0349333026,
-0.0015142728,
-0.0077999281,
-0.0426230095,
-0.0160618536,
0.0473127328,
-0.033009354,
-0.0241395105,
-0.0557214357,
-0.0006229852,
-0.0225427132,
0.0263216384,
-0.0074870777,
-0.047544241,
0.0461859256,
-0.0378184989,
0.0401680991,
0.0344457887,
0.1125129163,
0.0039586332,
-0.0475470833,
0.0355803631,
0.0287822802,
0.0030285283,
-0.0123312697,
0.0622782297,
-0.0149559155,
-0.0281106159,
-0.0348024517,
0.0468173921,
-0.0180574432,
0.0108203683,
-0.034170039,
0.0525932014,
-0.0161027685,
-0.0392460413,
-0.0079177953,
0.0284364987,
0.0170752127,
0.029206166,
0.0310920402,
-0.0593665205,
-0.0288590491,
-0.0119308745,
0.043965254,
-0.0111451885,
-0.0551435351,
-0.0268444866,
-0.0112343356,
-0.0471723303,
-0.0456762165,
-0.0669988766,
0.022890484,
-0.0130494665,
-0.028378956,
-0.0251079258,
-0.0236677863,
-0.0041128015,
-0.0157852992,
0.1036707237,
0.0232092235,
0.0035389767,
-0.0152086914,
0.0087142773,
0.0195954386,
-0.0117271878,
-0.0193159543,
0.0135248741,
-0.0423819125,
-0.0744087696,
0.0190979503,
-0.0196682271,
0.0112168863,
0.0108809406,
0.0014671397,
-0.1111139655,
0.010675584,
0.064085111,
-0.019070765,
0.0060236263,
0.0246644374,
-0.0041094301,
-0.0217800103,
0.0181269832,
-0.0214955322,
0.0524655953,
0.0312191155,
-0.0164607801,
0.0120743653,
-0.0569114834,
-0.0073553994,
0.0118268896,
0.0850196183,
-0.0225826036,
-0.0373434573,
-0.042451866,
-0.0584058948,
0.0464038216,
0.0085913278,
-0.056570407,
-0.0274832826,
0.0155635308,
0.0029029315,
-0.079890497,
-0.048315417,
0.0028672314,
-0.0141533976,
-0.0177407153,
0.0354193263,
0.0086872634,
0.0145206721,
0.0058914288,
0.0401220992,
-0.0132749388,
0.0253766235,
0.0019533832,
-0.0059822858,
-0.0078002778,
0.0598435104,
0.006210885,
-0.0069889226,
0.028493898,
0.0113200583,
0.0006608599,
-0.005804156,
-0.0196521468,
0.0070994319,
0.048404973,
-0.062554583,
0.0691881031,
-0.0476757996,
-0.0023526584,
-0.0204122737,
0.0079699047,
-0.0131883081,
-0.0446210876,
0.0184189472,
0.0112059247,
-0.0370990336,
0.005443912,
0.0140742445,
-0.0669199154,
0.0635899827,
0.0405132547,
-0.0311436038,
0.0017407278,
0.0327090658,
0.0630240366,
-0.02947939,
-0.0035121457,
0.0801515058,
-0.0698007047,
-0.0531769022,
0.0414948054,
-0.0410623774,
-0.0535693541,
-0.0213079173,
0.0224623624,
0.052306734,
-0.0334088989,
0.0526997559,
-0.0660506338,
0.0066791521,
-0.080762215,
-0.0294861738,
-0.0300715808,
-5.571631267e-33,
0.0232639648,
-0.0055815154,
-0.0537023917,
0.0432171896,
-0.0192942694,
0.0454044715,
-0.0192703605,
0.0557803735,
-0.02103284,
0.0825299546,
-0.006714718,
0.064274475,
0.001228555,
-0.0115566896,
0.017669851,
-0.0575448573,
0.0258589499,
-0.0120321792,
0.0004345117,
0.0292194784,
0.044025857,
0.0138334706,
0.0646996945,
-0.0864869729,
0.0314245336,
0.0073002633,
-0.013556065,
-0.0036114734,
0.0579049736,
0.0408496261,
-0.021276487,
0.0975199416,
0.0263053793,
-0.0329797044,
0.0040599881,
0.0589243732,
-0.0142112598,
-0.0159380697,
-0.0016968759,
0.0008199646,
-0.0352136865,
-0.0438055992,
0.0251335632,
0.0106192455,
-0.0183610339,
-0.0354759619,
0.0363087244,
-0.0241910219,
0.0259059202,
-0.0644898862,
-0.032345634,
0.0395564251,
-0.0179591719,
-0.0160628334,
0.0562571399,
0.0530333742,
0.0100687286,
0.056447763,
-0.0308169574,
0.0125603024,
-0.0123877553,
-0.004693388,
0.0166276619,
-0.0224671513,
0.0046161623,
0.1166174784,
0.0171905365,
0.0303684678,
-0.014960357,
0.0434982255,
0.0153379189,
0.0734716207,
0.0408155844,
0.0507165678,
0.009601756,
-0.0039912849,
0.0068029636,
0.0154869258,
0.0279329438,
0.0107749104,
0.0702408776,
-0.0195873026,
-0.0115361428,
0.011391026,
-0.0314383693,
0.003944356,
-0.0336953886,
-0.0082187867,
-0.0036632335,
-0.0100235054,
0.0346993506,
0.0072131716,
-0.0151614603,
-0.0316929407,
-0.0012775734,
0.0605933294,
-0.0296696965,
0.0201709252,
0.0138382092,
0.0131833283,
0.0059435382,
0.0091669308,
0.0096914088,
-0.0145736821,
0.0738711134,
-0.0172712598,
0.0113799404,
0.0109581947,
-0.0559540577,
0.0016837501,
-0.0472947955,
0.0509184524,
-0.0312604271,
-0.0035751979,
-0.0164095648,
0.0013677573,
-0.0232757814,
0.0033680045,
0.0208108164,
0.0636246428,
0.01559777,
-0.0031445671,
-0.0364685357,
0.0339228399,
-0.0299394857,
-0.0060129152,
-0.0028509207,
-0.0233406797,
0.0009420934,
-0.0019433881,
-0.0139576271,
0.0019433913,
2.293e-7,
0.0378682315,
0.0519874506,
-0.0093783159,
-0.044440724,
0.0187109411,
0.0659156442,
0.0083846021,
0.0416852087,
0.0723635033,
-0.0167194512,
0.0054087648,
0.0100236917,
0.0734581426,
0.0024786054,
-0.0760926232,
-0.0014817219,
-0.0411148109,
0.0469991229,
-0.0169307459,
-0.0134672951,
0.0590857156,
0.089098677,
0.0538446493,
-0.0121488376,
0.0042656376,
0.0038693266,
0.0348977149,
-0.0702079982,
-0.0105895707,
0.0362618044,
0.021489419,
0.0062374538,
-0.0230145454,
-0.0011414586,
-0.0171664171,
0.0010703587,
0.0205698814,
0.0535547249,
0.0109453304,
-0.0163245574,
0.0277578868,
0.0275207851,
-0.030063808,
-0.0510607436,
0.0400914624,
-0.0578184724,
-0.0440639965,
-0.0483611934,
0.0093851723,
-0.0051311995,
0.0606569275,
-0.0437566824,
-0.0354648493,
0.0070956466,
0.0173126496,
-0.0296444036,
-0.0244745985,
-0.0811815113,
-0.0252922941,
0.051042866,
-0.0378615633,
-0.0117921503,
-0.0259369519,
0.041731447,
0.0195008367,
-0.0284831095,
0.0164612886,
1.296966884e-34,
-0.0008090644,
0.000453008,
-0.0209446084,
0.0320876949,
0.0284564886,
0.0137561923,
-0.0270633791,
-0.0042379843,
0.0434247144,
-0.0403806902,
0.0498157963
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09593v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09593v2 | Multi-Step Dialogue Workflow Action Prediction | 2023-11-16T06:05:47 | 2024-02-13T01:47:52 | Ramya Ramakrishnan, Ethan R. Elenberg, Hashan Narangodage, Ryan McDonald | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In task-oriented dialogue, a system often needs to follow a sequence of
actions, called a workflow, that complies with a set of guidelines in order to
complete a task. In this paper, we propose the novel problem of multi-step
workflow action prediction, in which the system predicts multiple future
workflow actions. Accurate prediction of multiple steps allows for multi-turn
automation, which can free up time to focus on more complex tasks. We propose
three modeling approaches that are simple to implement yet lead to more action
automation: 1) fine-tuning on a training dataset, 2) few-shot in-context
learning leveraging retrieval and large language model prompting, and 3)
zero-shot graph traversal, which aggregates historical action sequences into a
graph for prediction. We show that multi-step action prediction produces
features that improve accuracy on downstream dialogue tasks like predicting
task success, and can increase automation of steps by 20% without requiring as
much feedback from a human overseeing the system. | [
0.0245056506,
0.0259505473,
-0.0015717915,
0.0080118272,
-0.0236972813,
0.0033257187,
0.0072214468,
0.0116783222,
0.0330220312,
-0.0631042868,
-0.0174969789,
-0.0192692466,
-0.0344794244,
0.059487693,
-0.011346519,
-0.0477780327,
0.0216047075,
-0.0223345086,
0.0276430007,
0.0268649701,
0.0069561675,
0.0243393295,
0.0096062589,
0.0804608017,
-0.0041971309,
-0.0125604765,
-0.048557993,
0.0174143463,
-0.0084528197,
-0.0217608158,
0.0328968614,
0.0617274009,
0.0642803609,
0.0463469997,
0.0000017316,
-0.0639389753,
0.0201972406,
-0.0286303442,
-0.062526606,
-0.0638702735,
-0.0106010046,
0.0051110028,
0.0202806219,
0.0312995203,
-0.0308539104,
-0.0122510074,
0.0218599644,
0.0799196661,
0.0479045361,
0.0715279207,
-0.0248635337,
-0.0137849087,
-0.0296095461,
-0.0055781202,
0.0214203186,
-0.0695460141,
0.0200515203,
-0.0023688837,
-0.0071303812,
0.0325332917,
0.0087556494,
-0.0103842122,
-0.0111204078,
-0.0173073281,
-0.0313104428,
0.025537461,
0.007082623,
-0.0277335905,
-0.0270597264,
0.1111941934,
-0.0249567144,
0.0024067198,
0.0001123857,
-0.0194801651,
-0.0090647908,
-0.0071970639,
-0.0685499683,
-0.0402824134,
-0.0178942829,
-0.0303189959,
-0.0528989919,
-0.0010318906,
-0.006036194,
0.0040799235,
0.016234288,
0.0628504157,
-0.0224818513,
-0.011258061,
0.0056582326,
0.0087211402,
0.0432202332,
-0.0539039522,
-0.0011233548,
0.0474364012,
-0.0932920724,
0.0088609867,
-0.0206404869,
0.0469126292,
0.0151140187,
-0.0054699825,
0.0528120324,
0.0323510505,
-0.0040558996,
0.0543262102,
0.016170077,
0.0450537726,
-0.0070570577,
-0.0275678951,
-0.0482889526,
0.0000378051,
-0.0603889897,
0.0190776139,
-0.0762187019,
0.0157502349,
-0.0460817069,
-0.0316610634,
-0.0236727595,
0.0361029729,
-0.0299206227,
0.0494984984,
0.0583645068,
0.0602778122,
-0.0376003943,
-0.0311845243,
-0.0328375325,
0.0360700376,
-0.0163589623,
0.0310264658,
-0.000187785,
0.0188962463,
-0.0281447582,
0.0184823889,
0.0319423191,
-0.0124644386,
0.0034124076,
0.0655598938,
0.0035153462,
-0.0092234574,
-0.0039804219,
-0.0557054617,
-0.0047081895,
-0.0610653237,
-0.0043134228,
-0.0427490175,
0.0534081608,
0.015842041,
-0.0495400168,
0.0266333222,
0.0135183251,
0.0430383198,
-0.0212354809,
0.0336504206,
0.0291624367,
0.0191866569,
-0.001519014,
-0.0064309835,
-0.0246930402,
0.0226555541,
0.0021449099,
0.0484327115,
0.0445315763,
0.0129226865,
0.0601030439,
0.0489567481,
-0.0004276928,
0.0029754243,
0.047925204,
0.0574386641,
-0.0081826542,
0.0034806763,
0.0283759087,
-0.0041638101,
-0.025429206,
-0.0112693626,
0.017723022,
0.0572673641,
-0.0095208129,
-0.0590433851,
0.0464271158,
0.0622188114,
-0.013673367,
-0.0258430429,
-0.049797345,
0.0447351485,
-0.0129567236,
-0.0150883384,
-0.0110981539,
-0.0298239179,
-0.0410251059,
-0.0273504686,
0.0186374113,
-0.0018294891,
0.0246506426,
-0.0030310906,
0.0306156166,
0.004292259,
-0.1265907735,
0.0207119267,
-0.0122981165,
-0.0326679721,
-0.0650183633,
-0.0286623444,
0.0123008052,
0.0883969367,
0.0383645631,
-0.0046692379,
-0.0298729595,
-0.0389169529,
0.0459579304,
-0.0142692775,
-0.0117616262,
-0.0507188626,
0.030726349,
-0.0450067706,
-0.0377941914,
0.0074907355,
-0.0044267806,
0.0263524018,
0.0144858509,
-0.0412037149,
0.0118436692,
0.0178883169,
-0.0154660987,
-0.0013919895,
0.0197180249,
-0.0474415459,
0.0440125763,
0.0395270176,
0.0321039036,
-0.0021894767,
0.0210668482,
-0.0112871826,
0.0241142288,
0.0127657773,
-0.0444221534,
0.0394480303,
-0.0394631699,
-0.057527259,
0.0012752756,
0.0447761007,
-0.0155438641,
-0.0098568788,
-0.0680518895,
-0.0490050055,
-0.0157626234,
-0.0038721671,
-0.0131274126,
-0.0051175039,
0.0049246722,
0.0454983301,
-0.0381192043,
-0.0281297229,
0.0363346227,
0.0226038359,
0.0179284886,
0.0363919362,
0.0203191582,
0.038224861,
-0.0213226788,
0.0108620031,
0.0054596364,
-0.0211754013,
0.0079698972,
0.0325063951,
0.0180381499,
-0.0388212427,
-0.0023756423,
-0.0958523005,
-0.010532422,
-0.0254645422,
-0.0220126715,
-0.0130967489,
-0.0209862106,
0.0112331053,
-0.0669556856,
-0.0191646796,
0.0360638946,
0.0683495998,
-0.0121354358,
0.0247350633,
0.0294330008,
-0.0091552716,
-0.0280237366,
0.0099415099,
-0.0021154131,
0.044172354,
-0.0024353229,
-0.0158088747,
-0.0397309624,
0.0217738096,
-0.0049841502,
0.0362324044,
-0.0368242823,
-0.0112934699,
0.0087640928,
-0.0206835419,
-0.0015276441,
0.0420058966,
-0.0150870075,
0.0127720376,
0.0069748354,
-0.0139630092,
-0.0518232472,
0.0338612683,
-0.0316262022,
-0.0255785808,
-0.0414334349,
0.0275158212,
-0.006355979,
0.040224541,
0.0236895159,
0.0441212393,
-0.0493341796,
-0.0282226335,
0.0257714726,
0.0064562219,
-0.0185072105,
-0.0195877105,
-0.0400484987,
0.0533296801,
-0.0303681679,
-0.0301507358,
0.065594472,
0.0201051682,
-0.0467506982,
-0.0004536549,
-0.0191781148,
-0.0167350899,
0.0962773785,
0.0173862614,
-0.0014305529,
0.0214897692,
-0.03913467,
-0.0593658909,
-0.025932692,
0.020389162,
-0.0302859005,
0.0420004651,
-0.0271461792,
0.0114280833,
-0.01121761,
-0.0478433147,
-0.0482473262,
-0.0043796082,
-0.0411279239,
0.0127938082,
-0.0404994041,
-0.0315602906,
-0.0251450147,
-0.0122000454,
-0.005423449,
0.0742117763,
-0.0082736742,
-0.028187409,
-0.013508074,
0.0310873259,
0.0496307537,
-0.0383306742,
-0.0704872087,
-0.0094999205,
0.0453214385,
0.0381163135,
0.0522620901,
-0.0010144438,
-0.0062901466,
-0.0175606292,
0.0317748301,
-0.007755958,
0.0113135558,
0.0389273874,
0.0490232259,
-0.0463589802,
-0.0103168692,
0.1163302809,
0.0236635767,
-0.0462255403,
-0.0060837409,
0.002306069,
-0.016781304,
0.0470466055,
0.0409303941,
-0.0883140638,
-0.0559200309,
-0.0169690847,
0.0139229419,
0.0263284594,
-0.0317783803,
-0.0132394154,
-0.1023363695,
0.0612018481,
-0.0111580426,
-0.0015646622,
-0.0031974234,
-0.0545246005,
0.0170291755,
-0.0112449769,
-0.0020171094,
0.0169477314,
0.0105461208,
-0.0540011115,
0.0092023639,
-0.0107175205,
-0.0110681085,
0.0803930685,
-0.0233355872,
-0.0071450267,
0.0380888209,
0.0485467985,
0.0303892512,
0.0471880212,
-0.0065868837,
0.0101868333,
0.0349836126,
0.0028426931,
0.0799818411,
-0.0097491173,
0.0124120293,
-0.0331576243,
0.0312317722,
-0.0273951553,
-0.0456923544,
0.0199208055,
0.0699114949,
-0.0621257871,
-0.0289629232,
0.0088162376,
0.0124716079,
0.0567272119,
0.0466734692,
-0.023364488,
-0.0300418884,
-0.0503352173,
-0.0281204246,
-0.0002893459,
-0.0500241742,
-0.0135376574,
-0.0436828285,
0.0139366696,
0.0239828415,
-0.0641958937,
-0.0594414845,
0.0455028974,
0.0450978316,
-0.0155228414,
-0.005815791,
0.0129265962,
0.0322919302,
-0.0219416469,
-0.0060732886,
-0.00545674,
0.0496792309,
-0.0341718644,
0.00169043,
0.0486919358,
0.0244990252,
-0.0092362463,
0.043459449,
-0.0943830162,
-0.0377119966,
-0.0759453773,
0.0659993961,
0.0176408961,
0.0621890649,
0.0024570432,
0.0005062859,
0.018011488,
-0.0077799568,
0.0076017431,
-0.0465806164,
0.0518479049,
0.0431868322,
-0.039747268,
0.0385681167,
-0.0702563673,
0.0099708708,
-0.0381332561,
0.0133297993,
-0.0632621348,
-0.1090491563,
0.0032256562,
-0.032410901,
0.035491202,
0.0082803983,
-0.0069268895,
-0.0252815634,
0.0400917046,
-0.0035992004,
-0.0409710966,
-0.0425618812,
0.0252940264,
-0.0161791779,
-0.0590176024,
0.0189006925,
-0.0082494402,
-0.0432006791,
0.0417908877,
-0.0576731376,
-0.0276684873,
0.0083175264,
0.0075599784,
0.0381261818,
0.0025651169,
-0.0146957589,
0.0019510405,
0.0489750504,
0.0129343551,
0.0054766079,
0.0771753937,
0.0159264579,
0.0408531912,
-0.0409488827,
0.024355378,
-0.06508708,
-0.0273744818,
-0.0208584666,
0.0102454182,
0.0467734523,
-0.0422115698,
0.0154205132,
-0.0440769419,
0.0146539249,
-0.0324799679,
0.0586931184,
-0.0171811376,
-0.0415223129,
0.0349428132,
0.043741595,
-0.0083086034,
0.0262418073,
0.0660289228,
-0.0204798877,
0.0483357944,
0.0096481126,
-0.033570312,
-0.0562965348,
-0.0550835542,
0.0184250381,
0.0533230677,
-0.014616386,
0.0026010044,
-0.033378765,
-0.0315204561,
-0.0064360551,
-0.0394070223,
-0.017004272,
-0.0194470845,
0.062742129,
0.0722260773,
0.0333068855,
-0.0114895059,
-0.0305362325,
-0.0558772273,
0.0041398299,
-0.0148685705,
-0.0811486989,
-5.049549042e-33,
0.0096919052,
-0.0720604658,
0.0596696101,
0.0097675715,
0.0243543275,
-0.0266206264,
-0.0438107811,
-0.0002747671,
-0.0196446832,
0.0302484091,
-0.0349199511,
0.002579211,
0.0172065329,
0.006203047,
0.0297409873,
0.0189767145,
0.061335355,
-0.0215424746,
-0.0310123414,
0.0458575562,
0.0644932985,
0.0151167819,
0.0332900435,
-0.0333479978,
0.0052189277,
0.0039908709,
-0.0237145349,
0.057811033,
0.0174770206,
0.0326898545,
0.0303837694,
0.0407317393,
0.0320584886,
-0.0435868353,
-0.002216042,
0.0364303254,
-0.0280704051,
-0.0427496359,
0.0029520071,
0.0037521184,
-0.0334827229,
0.0232920181,
-0.0128610609,
-0.0220345203,
-0.0075025018,
0.0099129351,
0.0209687091,
0.0188222472,
-0.0304587055,
-0.0269047059,
-0.0699845105,
-0.0081656603,
-0.0032932078,
-0.085356921,
-0.0016514901,
0.095199734,
0.0278022233,
-0.0481475182,
-0.0426175669,
0.0202268828,
-0.0597869307,
0.0065258536,
0.010539202,
0.0420952477,
0.0063139242,
0.0326786228,
0.0058414158,
0.0221559238,
0.0020405785,
-0.0109577179,
-0.0227080882,
0.0891414136,
-0.0040811501,
0.006486699,
-0.0005686869,
0.0059917141,
-0.0323797762,
0.0287157483,
0.0094941771,
0.1008644551,
-0.0005730966,
0.0067894422,
-0.032016173,
-0.030104205,
-0.0170612317,
0.0092460047,
0.0001699696,
-0.0160939042,
0.0322121754,
0.0416380353,
0.0351262614,
-0.0121637452,
0.0702229068,
-0.0119307246,
-0.0203178637,
0.0745634735,
-0.043904487,
-0.0018530416,
-0.0042626872,
0.0110215135,
-0.0258353762,
-0.0481189303,
0.0272503439,
-0.008042153,
0.000610446,
0.0230690315,
0.0209265258,
0.0223858077,
-0.0618942864,
-0.0012131494,
-0.0348648205,
0.0213025976,
-0.0252131075,
0.0389187001,
0.0173196699,
0.0138906632,
-0.0152165974,
0.0907753482,
-0.0384117253,
-0.0315594524,
-0.0090364451,
0.0028484967,
0.0125825098,
-0.0111043807,
-0.0493344963,
-0.0123268683,
-0.0427270718,
-0.0019164426,
0.0365574956,
0.0030537858,
-0.0055424911,
0.0386684127,
2.449e-7,
-0.0202734079,
0.0424201302,
-0.0064205388,
0.0912585855,
0.0053469851,
0.0586480908,
-0.0198259968,
0.0122046024,
0.0260442346,
-0.0301386546,
0.0584128425,
0.010523838,
0.0302572008,
0.012093747,
-0.1027934551,
-0.0517919362,
-0.0464917868,
-0.0216373354,
-0.0516683944,
-0.0192593951,
0.0308535118,
0.0937339216,
0.0195141826,
0.0070127454,
0.0068818894,
-0.0283345953,
0.0336183161,
0.0118688969,
0.0170323569,
-0.0156328715,
-0.006703834,
-0.0261162426,
-0.0030870887,
0.028212171,
-0.0328376926,
-0.0065360107,
-0.0071913763,
0.0855519921,
-0.0370706134,
-0.0278359558,
-0.031821046,
-0.0056886347,
0.0261920225,
-0.0116392262,
0.0353114009,
-0.0670968145,
0.0028825493,
-0.0287357252,
0.0026706592,
-0.0106863482,
0.0020183832,
0.0229866933,
0.0037147943,
0.0129304212,
0.0263406876,
0.0040366212,
0.0126311742,
-0.0838469565,
-0.0016159575,
0.0054524601,
-0.012210831,
-0.0179349408,
-0.0072576245,
-0.0454347543,
0.0153273353,
-0.0271436647,
0.0060258419,
2.047805291e-34,
0.014345279,
-0.0021125104,
0.0255986173,
0.0343517847,
0.0136985527,
-0.0133748688,
-0.0249020383,
0.0211340077,
0.0689582676,
-0.0601437017,
-0.0337137766
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10777v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10777v4 | A Systematic Review of Aspect-based Sentiment Analysis (ABSA): Domains, Methods, and Trends | 2023-11-16T06:01:47 | 2024-04-16T10:59:11 | Yan Cathy Hua, Paul Denny, Katerina Taskova, Jörg Wicker | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Aspect-based Sentiment Analysis (ABSA) is a fine-grained type of sentiment
analysis that identifies aspects and their associated opinions from a given
text. With the surge of digital opinionated text data, ABSA gained increasing
popularity for its ability to mine more detailed and targeted insights. Many
review papers on ABSA subtasks and solution methodologies exist, however, few
focus on trends over time or systemic issues relating to research application
domains, datasets, and solution approaches. To fill the gap, this paper
presents a Systematic Literature Review (SLR) of ABSA studies with a focus on
trends and high-level relationships among these fundamental components. This
review is one of the largest SLRs on ABSA, and also, to our knowledge, the
first that systematically examines the trends and inter-relations among ABSA
research and data distribution across domains and solution paradigms and
approaches. Our sample includes 519 primary studies screened from 4191 search
results without time constraints via an innovative automatic filtering process.
Our quantitative analysis not only identifies trends in nearly two decades of
ABSA research development but also unveils a systemic lack of dataset and
domain diversity as well as domain mismatch that may hinder the development of
future ABSA research. We discuss these findings and their implications and
propose suggestions for future research. | [
0.0620137565,
0.0565072298,
-0.0130340913,
0.034150783,
-0.0352573842,
-0.0014602435,
-0.0021476643,
-0.0105764968,
-0.0553154796,
-0.0450520813,
-0.0145172235,
-0.0021330391,
-0.0314991474,
0.0666558444,
-0.0397584699,
0.0130141377,
0.0057949256,
0.0669532418,
0.0342248082,
0.0116806189,
0.0446919687,
0.0349782668,
0.004863895,
0.0152220018,
-0.0071338946,
-0.0030618855,
0.0346721821,
-0.0344738066,
0.0304424595,
-0.0229105875,
0.0150250476,
-0.0187253524,
-0.0254795775,
-0.0316215865,
0.0000023314,
0.0069575938,
-0.0438700728,
0.005551565,
0.0699241757,
0.0098164482,
0.0814456567,
0.0059167151,
0.0197725128,
0.0161873512,
-0.0539013743,
-0.0210855734,
0.0235075336,
0.0663431734,
0.0289228782,
0.0387244597,
-0.0364809372,
-0.0001267278,
-0.0391099304,
0.0064701727,
-0.070369266,
-0.0243052021,
-0.0036376598,
-0.0249138866,
-0.0137123484,
0.0545249619,
0.0271060318,
0.0128336642,
-0.00622231,
0.0051096021,
-0.0177183114,
-0.0027627558,
0.0205367152,
-0.0082524745,
0.026228711,
0.011642389,
0.073405154,
0.0045079938,
-0.0021501314,
-0.0507839881,
-0.0249860175,
0.0407796055,
0.0088847829,
-0.0003315279,
-0.0146759711,
0.048283916,
0.0155884735,
0.0518097617,
-0.0063309609,
0.0168616436,
0.0287803803,
0.0326686688,
-0.0430335775,
-0.0423983634,
0.0178768914,
0.0460661389,
0.0026944703,
0.009864294,
0.0236995593,
-0.0141187394,
0.0160205457,
0.0322859548,
0.0252642501,
0.0199137852,
0.0452290736,
-0.0385048203,
0.0011381246,
-0.0060268729,
-0.0204659998,
0.0020901565,
0.0428821929,
-0.0633322597,
0.0482025295,
-0.0469498895,
-0.0007897583,
0.0292480476,
-0.0586189888,
0.0341160484,
0.0487069972,
0.0498244874,
-0.0238484703,
0.0216790568,
-0.0242507923,
-0.02487229,
-0.0147090871,
-0.0078343404,
0.014530099,
0.0035247542,
0.0284357239,
0.0216346513,
-0.0212109145,
0.040216811,
-0.0636890605,
0.070248358,
-0.0744934827,
0.0354213715,
0.0398288816,
-0.0034547478,
0.0143523449,
0.0018556882,
-0.0063153519,
-0.0174654126,
0.0455241166,
-0.0540511459,
-0.01877,
-0.0374700129,
0.0062467223,
-0.0265607424,
-0.0321993791,
-0.0511672758,
-0.0000606421,
0.018081978,
0.0041914284,
0.0239223987,
0.0126628028,
0.0275784023,
-0.0051777316,
0.0051486115,
-0.0686515942,
-0.0080944058,
-0.0279410556,
0.0336295813,
0.102681376,
0.0403170362,
-0.0462285057,
0.0281494651,
0.0365782864,
0.0426808111,
-0.0132000288,
-0.0184390154,
-0.0003497497,
-0.0157457311,
0.0510912873,
0.0112083117,
-0.0699276999,
-0.0821862146,
-0.0411141291,
0.0354023762,
0.0078799212,
-0.0262136105,
0.0085318778,
-0.0119960802,
-0.0218959358,
0.0896627754,
-0.0238873102,
0.0235050265,
0.0230280254,
-0.0259713549,
0.0311132316,
0.0035403045,
0.0250528976,
-0.0362734944,
0.0058383192,
-0.0035473718,
-0.0156362168,
-0.0770004541,
-0.0249438901,
0.0015424941,
0.0036624689,
-0.0295984354,
0.0361230224,
-0.0054297023,
-0.0129864197,
-0.0583491623,
0.056095995,
-0.0453104042,
-0.0168979634,
-0.0147315674,
0.0643431619,
0.0466879271,
-0.00109364,
-0.0471972674,
0.0132566663,
-0.0072890362,
-0.0267475508,
0.0019447721,
-0.0123088472,
-0.0017810633,
-0.0108615216,
-0.021351058,
0.005339019,
-0.0197348054,
0.0018450004,
-0.0082781175,
-0.003042988,
0.0636035949,
-0.0334385112,
-0.0190386716,
0.0050007459,
0.0004464808,
0.0102884872,
-0.0002172326,
0.0401512533,
0.0223293975,
0.0241926629,
0.0621637627,
0.008772769,
-0.0078852391,
0.0392268412,
-0.0167223122,
-0.0697231814,
0.0329263397,
0.0089610619,
0.0253519304,
-0.0043726726,
-0.0149361975,
-0.0065631289,
-0.0063748844,
-0.0062904675,
0.0032026772,
0.0087078884,
0.0161471814,
0.006478773,
-0.0057705501,
-0.020079758,
-0.0054562362,
-0.0189736281,
0.008603829,
0.0514812209,
-0.0297058318,
0.0110431528,
-0.0458799228,
-0.0508562699,
0.0566294491,
0.0689845085,
-0.0467031933,
-0.0221807212,
0.01146306,
0.0214638822,
0.0330604278,
0.0162716489,
-0.0255441368,
-0.0170310773,
-0.1116206273,
-0.0078816246,
0.00429866,
0.0345330462,
0.0294499081,
-0.0297466628,
0.0153680239,
0.0496976301,
-0.0085633909,
-0.0071255602,
-0.0343093611,
0.0248521864,
0.0074635502,
0.0579629317,
0.0735934749,
-0.0545606129,
-0.0068024774,
-0.0164709091,
-0.0106866937,
0.0508251898,
-0.0014161468,
-0.025230376,
0.0459828973,
-0.0401787832,
0.0046392423,
-0.037467543,
-0.0034644962,
-0.017103279,
0.0008196219,
-0.0641150102,
-0.0231782924,
0.0060294694,
0.0494793504,
0.0284574814,
0.0089398371,
-0.0039657098,
0.015023333,
-0.0810658783,
0.0166970603,
0.0197891984,
-0.0400042832,
0.0622217432,
-0.0090463106,
-0.0022467752,
-0.0022594512,
-0.0474191606,
0.0340433717,
-0.0433223397,
0.0205463525,
0.0075529022,
0.0104927113,
0.0261569433,
0.0159142129,
0.0171669945,
0.0133433826,
0.061773479,
0.0322507955,
0.0385526121,
-0.0770430192,
-0.0387458988,
-0.0605582595,
0.0260590166,
-0.0556105673,
-0.0054077087,
0.0309831332,
0.0394372679,
0.0349795148,
-0.0374818444,
-0.0041744537,
0.0063490644,
0.0407505482,
0.0084134117,
0.0200941116,
0.0331770442,
-0.0607441887,
0.0417898819,
-0.0603215769,
-0.0229436699,
0.0081966436,
0.0164888594,
-0.018962549,
0.0078408867,
0.0000649195,
-0.0105460584,
-0.0720319971,
-0.0112094786,
-0.044819545,
0.0248288233,
0.0142170675,
0.0419022664,
-0.0729331598,
0.0416414179,
0.018082466,
-0.0038707978,
0.07558956,
-0.055768121,
-0.0253657997,
-0.0133179072,
-0.0519734286,
0.0050552725,
-0.0068863844,
-0.0079190312,
-0.0498022214,
0.0717325211,
-0.0338588245,
-0.010465567,
0.0565041378,
0.0510808788,
-0.0344837122,
-0.0123800859,
0.0129591897,
-0.0248897262,
0.0088543035,
0.0010181487,
-0.0441993326,
-0.014978407,
-0.0797569826,
0.0504098982,
-0.0360866301,
0.0061784112,
0.0061277575,
-0.0662200376,
0.0315536,
-0.0433140658,
-0.0341619775,
-0.0640704855,
-0.0650343895,
0.0361890085,
-0.0290735438,
-0.0135109192,
-0.0630857721,
-0.0164509956,
0.0147564067,
-0.0089304466,
-0.0185067728,
0.0142383073,
0.0389531814,
-0.0104276137,
-0.0030747487,
0.015417994,
0.0762751028,
-0.0169625841,
-0.0321695842,
0.0004749291,
-0.0878546089,
0.0090075321,
-0.0221646726,
0.0923283324,
-0.036747802,
-0.0222704709,
-0.027832441,
-0.0022154036,
-0.0510149449,
-0.0025201831,
0.0217057727,
0.035133291,
-0.0108017363,
0.0072282688,
-0.0548362322,
0.0331584997,
0.0228426829,
0.0308308657,
-0.0208119396,
-0.0670444146,
0.005494175,
0.0090933312,
0.0095079429,
-0.0074601606,
-0.0380095467,
-0.0738201663,
-0.0182613246,
-0.0288523864,
-0.0622134209,
-0.0504429974,
-0.0213275962,
-0.0064892182,
-0.0136939809,
0.0244062524,
0.0684406832,
-0.0063004317,
-0.0244556703,
-0.0052869716,
0.0124602048,
0.0350461677,
0.0494705774,
-0.0208660401,
0.0740623698,
-0.0161976423,
-0.0053241192,
-0.0190803073,
-0.0027118125,
-0.0130636515,
-0.0080506457,
0.0070718648,
-0.007837683,
-0.0131719839,
-0.0044521932,
-0.006273726,
0.0093634939,
0.0585879907,
-0.0030143724,
-0.0147263994,
0.0524603911,
0.040210776,
0.0311897304,
0.0059414981,
-0.0043018167,
0.0173188858,
0.0265374854,
-0.0534017421,
-0.0285034403,
0.0013009624,
-0.0039010039,
-0.0277845189,
0.0431279838,
0.0330100879,
-0.0361865461,
-0.023341924,
-0.0053195548,
-0.0130643826,
-0.0242161565,
-0.0191322044,
-0.0124801146,
-0.0633832216,
0.0146153411,
-0.0748899132,
0.0771588758,
-0.0245723724,
0.0591342337,
-0.0395219289,
0.1135097742,
-0.0113264006,
0.0399225689,
-0.037975233,
0.0021427849,
-0.002823377,
-0.0348939374,
-0.0042887679,
-0.0005969346,
-0.0085126124,
0.0575558618,
0.0079384102,
0.0009431381,
-0.0097805308,
0.0389107391,
-0.0051028384,
0.0225648526,
-0.0212347619,
-0.0226714779,
-0.0532261245,
-0.0586045235,
0.0538067408,
-0.0526642054,
0.0024613999,
0.0242071282,
-0.0080128638,
-0.0383850932,
0.0169623103,
0.028236948,
0.0015888782,
-0.0205582958,
0.0080935126,
0.0199019462,
-0.1372092515,
0.0227082688,
0.0225131288,
-0.0520652235,
-0.0123813683,
0.0080129271,
0.0193281248,
0.0292803142,
0.0131977787,
0.0207841974,
-0.0724511519,
-0.012347972,
0.0141848745,
-0.0440343209,
0.0047453931,
-0.0007090667,
-0.0043129507,
0.0298213866,
0.0547022298,
0.0561390743,
-0.0725072026,
-0.0342599005,
-0.0547412597,
-0.0037541392,
0.0013949114,
-7.148006293e-33,
-0.0096046226,
-0.022209432,
-0.03829851,
0.0233056583,
0.0032829926,
0.0182472486,
0.0005356371,
0.0378576629,
0.0014958095,
0.0408788919,
0.0080713471,
0.0317910202,
-0.0163229052,
0.026505528,
0.0208923705,
0.0011785908,
0.0199351665,
-0.0188193452,
0.0014800861,
0.0568935797,
0.0527570359,
-0.038108971,
0.0392584689,
-0.1645733565,
0.0347881913,
0.0232955236,
-0.0656644478,
-0.0157438498,
-0.0112759592,
0.0320564285,
-0.0215720739,
0.0666628033,
0.0476409681,
-0.0272802841,
0.0212020874,
-0.0077838367,
-0.0378788523,
-0.0310994536,
0.0232991185,
-0.0251958016,
0.011107645,
-0.0058528455,
-0.0090447264,
0.0336280279,
-0.0053598229,
0.0199100245,
0.0320364721,
-0.0361865163,
0.042247761,
-0.0992949307,
-0.0185675789,
0.0217125267,
0.0014269883,
0.0270690061,
0.0161705762,
0.0391108468,
0.0100425165,
0.0314169228,
-0.0452876762,
0.0195749253,
-0.008643873,
0.0059746783,
-0.0475346372,
-0.0754717216,
0.0076229288,
0.0500674583,
-0.0217700526,
0.0135482419,
-0.0084860902,
0.0200513396,
-0.0005436154,
0.0217828453,
0.0247082114,
0.0242990069,
-0.0082643423,
-0.0415270925,
-0.0424505845,
0.0170547701,
0.0007213927,
-0.0190052148,
0.080745101,
0.0030315858,
-0.0772148818,
-0.0200188141,
0.0226363763,
-0.0520960428,
-0.0379124582,
-0.0030587241,
-0.0177055802,
0.0032409781,
-0.0391744561,
0.0200385042,
-0.0503722876,
-0.0547187924,
-0.0248143952,
0.0241690464,
-0.079304494,
0.0457891338,
0.0109019214,
0.0005737419,
-0.0855078027,
0.0155517086,
-0.0423757955,
0.0234980695,
-0.0062506343,
-0.0266064648,
0.0622118711,
0.0139076198,
-0.0822772458,
-0.019814305,
0.0155269932,
0.0417147018,
-0.0051069437,
0.0178660974,
-0.0350007229,
0.0367014632,
0.0017889269,
0.0864223912,
0.018254593,
0.0563920103,
-0.0104541425,
-0.0083353259,
0.0132086175,
0.0007945594,
-0.0179161523,
-0.038887918,
0.0288992375,
-0.0109383287,
0.007525404,
-0.0268199407,
-0.0236788224,
-0.0083911754,
3.074e-7,
0.061957866,
0.0528682135,
-0.0415270925,
-0.0001252584,
0.0414447598,
0.0750026852,
0.0360374972,
-0.0164160468,
0.0194203891,
0.0139304316,
0.0339739323,
0.0233577099,
-0.0146503374,
0.0604603179,
-0.0264579132,
0.0547634847,
0.0278065801,
-0.0481598899,
-0.0278557334,
0.0308309197,
0.0750451088,
0.0488239117,
0.0295425151,
0.0175959654,
-0.0450208448,
0.0683251023,
0.019538058,
-0.0390986912,
-0.0300441608,
0.0130066294,
-0.0356262699,
0.0016410131,
-0.0115285106,
-0.0435775407,
-0.0228034537,
0.018038027,
0.0110985991,
0.0217586905,
0.046128802,
-0.0743748322,
0.045965977,
0.0368592627,
0.0377008207,
0.0129269203,
0.0600459613,
-0.041659005,
-0.0676457733,
-0.1082583889,
0.0019524404,
0.0570605285,
0.0089082029,
0.0170031115,
-0.0394583456,
0.0538111404,
-0.046400208,
-0.0304156914,
-0.0444869623,
-0.0463038459,
0.0296650808,
0.0270432401,
0.0169078987,
-0.0297823437,
0.0191880427,
0.0186731406,
-0.007739957,
-0.0534730963,
0.0466030985,
2.562157078e-34,
0.0314112119,
-0.0214330815,
0.0032764873,
0.0046877423,
0.0009317108,
0.0243985243,
-0.0555281006,
-0.0239246115,
0.0083219418,
-0.0016775976,
0.0266122725
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09585v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09585v2 | LifeTox: Unveiling Implicit Toxicity in Life Advice | 2023-11-16T05:43:02 | 2024-03-19T02:20:50 | Minbeom Kim, Jahyun Koo, Hwanhee Lee, Joonsuk Park, Hwaran Lee, Kyomin Jung | cs.CL | cs.CL | As large language models become increasingly integrated into daily life,
detecting implicit toxicity across diverse contexts is crucial. To this end, we
introduce LifeTox, a dataset designed for identifying implicit toxicity within
a broad range of advice-seeking scenarios. Unlike existing safety datasets,
LifeTox comprises diverse contexts derived from personal experiences through
open-ended questions. Experiments demonstrate that RoBERTa fine-tuned on
LifeTox matches or surpasses the zero-shot performance of large language models
in toxicity classification tasks. These results underscore the efficacy of
LifeTox in addressing the complex challenges inherent in implicit toxicity. We
open-sourced the
dataset\footnote{\url{https://huggingface.co/datasets/mbkim/LifeTox}} and the
LifeTox moderator family; 350M, 7B, and 13B. | [
0.0743055344,
0.0628535524,
-0.0108707882,
-0.008066847,
0.0292594004,
0.0232096966,
0.0235455446,
0.03978673,
0.0427920222,
-0.0366656221,
-0.0586493984,
0.038423758,
-0.0516898073,
0.0290535111,
0.0017990647,
-0.0120790647,
0.018251542,
0.0322555564,
0.0159939732,
0.0220030732,
0.0366810486,
0.0392826833,
0.0273257028,
0.0614337809,
-0.0284218751,
-0.0369831175,
0.0386513658,
0.0271826852,
0.0672691911,
-0.0669163987,
0.0697048083,
0.0412210897,
0.0244309586,
0.0111611569,
0.0000018627,
-0.0058586351,
0.0196753629,
-0.0086142821,
-0.0309024174,
-0.0376984589,
0.0579787977,
0.0025141519,
0.011095725,
0.0343534499,
-0.0368498713,
-0.0243914463,
0.0482744761,
0.0368487835,
0.0581018366,
0.0257973243,
-0.0183517635,
0.0256105401,
-0.0124408333,
-0.0010979584,
0.0242596101,
0.0089533124,
0.0546967015,
-0.025349604,
-0.0460243821,
0.0100815734,
0.00263122,
0.0169129167,
0.0114874281,
-0.0198358949,
-0.0130361393,
0.0056253038,
-0.0018139334,
-0.0650431812,
0.0108324857,
0.1116919294,
-0.0251032431,
0.0099559361,
-0.0063376003,
-0.0110019185,
-0.0096471822,
-0.0024471609,
-0.0275773406,
-0.0226943009,
-0.003374977,
0.0064949347,
-0.0182597619,
0.0454591699,
0.029210886,
0.030573003,
0.0836100504,
0.0626482815,
-0.0190716665,
-0.0073962049,
0.0620794296,
-0.0235688388,
-0.0054214778,
-0.0083262203,
0.0181211848,
-0.0223529991,
-0.0468813553,
0.0170185789,
-0.0141479466,
0.0289578177,
0.0814033225,
-0.0892674178,
0.0789658576,
0.0099229952,
-0.0779293105,
-0.0007693886,
0.0098948618,
-0.0514220633,
0.0266700536,
0.0157787688,
-0.0503682643,
0.0333575495,
-0.0095858807,
-0.0042849397,
-0.0276011098,
-0.0017981153,
-0.0159211177,
0.0355231538,
-0.0587402508,
0.007000824,
-0.057464622,
-0.0229581781,
-0.001094957,
0.0490502603,
-0.0387258157,
0.0280883536,
-0.0309427287,
-0.0223731771,
-0.0365597866,
0.0459249541,
0.001979162,
-0.0483669341,
-0.0109684076,
0.0057638623,
-0.0217072908,
-0.0281302817,
-0.0107818181,
0.0975427553,
0.0241590776,
-0.0138029326,
-0.0272945147,
-0.0349649563,
-0.0401650444,
-0.0411297828,
-0.0307808015,
-0.0042874319,
0.0331345014,
-0.0243065916,
0.0123814354,
-0.0889822021,
0.0325539745,
0.0082094697,
-0.0270678699,
0.0589559898,
0.020069452,
-0.0226202589,
0.0268818997,
0.0564774685,
-0.0185974054,
0.0610519759,
0.0013849695,
0.033885397,
0.0118933702,
0.0002977895,
-0.0161982737,
-0.0029244071,
0.0487554558,
0.0389567576,
-0.0055015683,
0.0446747504,
-0.0471516699,
0.0175482407,
-0.0302147921,
0.0304390471,
0.0116345184,
-0.0040884009,
0.0598413721,
0.0294536855,
-0.0235951766,
0.0642746165,
0.0719852298,
0.0242988281,
-0.0220573768,
-0.0569181293,
-0.0740893185,
-0.0230390243,
-0.0600639358,
-0.0632278249,
0.0183777288,
-0.0042844885,
-0.0157176498,
-0.0568093918,
-0.0241550058,
0.013720694,
0.0289662629,
-0.0156511795,
-0.0243239794,
-0.0096646277,
-0.0408873633,
0.0194939189,
0.0483685769,
-0.0336831734,
-0.0451913103,
-0.0062535051,
0.0494505689,
0.0665920451,
0.010941512,
-0.033032883,
-0.0323135369,
-0.0386105068,
0.0165596921,
-0.028625533,
0.032361012,
-0.0224849097,
0.0396686941,
-0.0074959146,
-0.0426745713,
0.0285669398,
0.0042631184,
-0.0388404541,
0.0217521228,
0.0538471043,
0.001596903,
0.0017970756,
-0.062108662,
0.0391282253,
0.004773376,
-0.0758232176,
0.0196401682,
0.0211534891,
0.0327992588,
-0.0339801013,
0.0220302287,
-0.0146303969,
0.0262681432,
-0.0344366767,
-0.0356498398,
-0.0151009178,
-0.0267833285,
-0.0011180786,
0.0120968353,
-0.0185073949,
-0.0320324637,
0.0118485009,
-0.0510625318,
0.0179329868,
-0.04340446,
-0.0268099159,
-0.0232636929,
-0.0140471673,
-0.0424364433,
0.0089676864,
0.0210857932,
-0.0179356653,
0.0505202375,
-0.0083697475,
-0.0235861931,
-0.0294409432,
-0.0482936241,
-0.0344930924,
-0.0505383387,
0.0276032817,
-0.0630254447,
-0.0052607157,
0.0079717739,
-0.0093806116,
0.0406333543,
-0.0495362952,
0.0304899327,
-0.0512441583,
-0.024567375,
-0.0119555769,
-0.0197151564,
-0.0258570407,
-0.0371325798,
0.0010591456,
-0.0134573011,
-0.0204444025,
0.0344589837,
-0.0315777026,
0.0266876779,
0.0101848729,
-0.0036202082,
0.0288715195,
-0.0213414617,
-0.0034921726,
-0.0470850989,
0.0461524129,
-0.0150370887,
-0.0289774276,
0.0108732227,
-0.0201040469,
-0.0481614396,
-0.0133784581,
0.0205942169,
-0.0419954844,
-0.0228380933,
0.0279770438,
0.0065018861,
0.0444570556,
0.0316138305,
0.0512215793,
0.0218410436,
0.0439172424,
-0.0441424847,
0.0290641487,
-0.0315368325,
-0.0262709968,
-0.0105014425,
-0.0552150235,
-0.0375746377,
0.0374854505,
0.0057035023,
0.0063318149,
-0.0305353981,
0.0704736188,
-0.0163716413,
-0.0260465369,
-0.0329908505,
-0.0376722738,
0.0099814013,
0.0165880732,
-0.0171101689,
-0.0564200059,
0.0833531469,
0.0419398956,
0.0164647289,
-0.0085852407,
-0.0377685837,
0.0149717219,
0.0288016107,
-0.0107341232,
0.0347275548,
0.0644419491,
0.0354699902,
0.0121683953,
-0.0559449866,
0.0102951061,
-0.030906504,
0.0375099629,
-0.0653732717,
-0.0083981669,
0.0310403984,
-0.0843926072,
-0.0549573302,
-0.0578874536,
-0.0538123474,
-0.0046820752,
-0.0250217449,
0.0288365334,
-0.0583271608,
-0.0035512277,
-0.0398774408,
-0.017321201,
0.0049694204,
-0.032746464,
0.0305255465,
-0.0226597805,
0.0893595517,
-0.0377944,
0.0385854915,
0.0086787278,
0.0516069569,
0.0831799731,
-0.0670143366,
0.0078477254,
0.0159821361,
0.0473215543,
-0.0217105653,
0.016650388,
0.0316253342,
0.0284670964,
0.0144394888,
-0.0255407486,
-0.0313994177,
0.0474450514,
0.02144875,
-0.0241670981,
0.0584856048,
-0.0145065142,
0.0014718103,
0.0231181886,
-0.0059924829,
-0.0677298978,
-0.0483637713,
-0.0211847052,
0.0022478742,
-0.0528724715,
-0.0226311237,
0.0139956856,
-0.0468075983,
0.0290116966,
0.0087147588,
-0.0439863168,
0.0002504446,
-0.0036982757,
-0.0082615754,
-0.0521682389,
0.0434925295,
-0.0449823067,
-0.0060045212,
-0.0470520668,
0.0093256161,
-0.0440186784,
-0.0180007294,
0.073162213,
0.0071707796,
0.0235034525,
-0.0011651769,
0.048950389,
0.0158436466,
0.0048833191,
0.0621718988,
-0.0105514312,
-0.0217709281,
-0.0333658233,
0.0636467636,
-0.0249322802,
0.0017604374,
-0.0491043106,
0.0875274763,
-0.039114777,
-0.0106674088,
0.0009691092,
0.0542670861,
0.0006050498,
-0.0231804438,
-0.05080235,
0.0632027164,
0.0666349903,
0.0596591644,
0.018081652,
-0.0318668671,
0.0124574797,
-0.0400399603,
-0.030692894,
0.0051558861,
-0.066142723,
0.0059355251,
-0.0269875731,
-0.0230263621,
-0.0188720357,
-0.0223636646,
0.0316525176,
-0.0187536571,
0.0085511673,
-0.0422131643,
-0.0108316643,
0.0186585542,
-0.0381806754,
0.069769226,
0.0200160891,
0.011963279,
-0.0134285102,
0.0146659268,
0.0171111673,
0.0044388366,
-0.0281803738,
0.0846211389,
-0.0248159207,
-0.0439898707,
0.0301577915,
0.0832916871,
0.0096691614,
0.0254633278,
-0.0337207094,
-0.0235991776,
0.0862085968,
0.0742156655,
-0.0251460206,
-0.0610253029,
0.0433387607,
0.02651776,
0.0451913178,
0.0502192676,
-0.0487528555,
0.0313646533,
0.0302680265,
0.0108913379,
-0.0593603961,
0.0089057731,
0.0387261882,
-0.0065482552,
0.0425143242,
-0.0091140913,
-0.0185218453,
-0.0120259179,
0.0191034749,
0.0163783543,
-0.0376598388,
-0.0027065601,
0.0185993575,
0.0567522347,
-0.0333565883,
-0.0383968763,
-0.0150788808,
-0.0658934489,
0.0124650607,
-0.0191062056,
0.009496347,
0.0682091564,
0.0172712039,
0.0423550978,
0.0255038161,
-0.0361369066,
0.0223369338,
-0.0208331924,
0.0203818791,
-0.0134672578,
0.0365685634,
-0.0041316804,
0.0273739845,
-0.0130694509,
0.0282136295,
0.0122576468,
-0.0318997242,
-0.0595631599,
0.0124915177,
-0.0113088461,
-0.0304549411,
0.0139099844,
-0.0323486589,
-0.0260204654,
-0.0137065062,
0.0170308333,
-0.0424095429,
-0.0423434488,
0.0566307418,
-0.0010891923,
-0.0298679303,
-0.0032203118,
0.0402214825,
0.0293156691,
0.0511936061,
0.048086036,
-0.0495453216,
-0.0100651495,
0.0008433831,
0.0516768135,
0.0311092231,
-0.0302499626,
-0.0009768282,
-0.0627260283,
-0.0695314333,
-0.0126209715,
0.0061618495,
-0.0152058136,
0.0064816792,
0.000118275,
0.0113534946,
0.0268214103,
-0.0671791211,
-0.0215797108,
0.0403091647,
-0.0091034686,
-0.0161435828,
-0.0382745676,
-5.522743559e-33,
-0.000227097,
-0.028592838,
-0.0282277372,
-0.0011167899,
0.0128526948,
0.0323899686,
0.0038142453,
0.0020048991,
-0.0100289499,
0.0823004097,
0.0132456105,
0.022098856,
0.0021038842,
-0.0040169433,
0.0313353091,
-0.0624311082,
0.0107262637,
-0.0108389249,
-0.0251299161,
0.0335434265,
0.0158813298,
0.0594368204,
0.0222957507,
-0.0907976627,
0.0329018682,
0.0105480896,
-0.0101324823,
0.0197205991,
-0.0501461923,
0.0690586567,
-0.0179180447,
0.0999581665,
0.0022299881,
0.0259610657,
0.0108808,
0.0212123655,
-0.0833652094,
-0.0300350953,
0.0192081314,
-0.0497024171,
-0.0785309821,
-0.0176667068,
0.0301424656,
0.0295232423,
-0.0122161824,
-0.0234995913,
0.0230415743,
-0.0169333518,
0.0196710005,
-0.0323555097,
-0.0272574425,
-0.0257531442,
-0.0271199178,
-0.0369331017,
-0.001831662,
0.0600781888,
-0.0075691789,
0.027912857,
-0.0435844921,
-0.0136047965,
-0.0523277186,
-0.0154656395,
0.0043110964,
-0.0312786438,
-0.0197833851,
0.0648340359,
-0.0296444725,
0.0126974657,
-0.011052683,
-0.030769961,
-0.0513764434,
0.0588081516,
0.0064921896,
0.021297846,
0.0209095608,
-0.0050570732,
-0.0788526759,
0.0010371523,
0.0278357212,
0.0276341308,
-0.0015658339,
-0.0310971197,
-0.0543114394,
-0.0252342392,
-0.0242532901,
-0.021415608,
-0.0451146886,
-0.0255004279,
0.0212342329,
0.0054085786,
-0.0079246433,
-0.0118797719,
-0.053139735,
-0.0434066504,
0.0027011514,
-0.0249716677,
0.0443188101,
-0.0604989715,
0.01241381,
0.0378006883,
-0.0416915119,
0.0146568026,
0.0017739033,
-0.0266430713,
0.0334742293,
-0.0153342225,
0.0990896001,
0.0098815048,
-0.0410414971,
-0.0346311331,
-0.0006908535,
0.0245412122,
0.0144950096,
0.0444477238,
-0.0156236598,
0.0376801863,
0.013348978,
0.0499480441,
0.0405758582,
0.0256117377,
-0.0021149039,
-0.0349202417,
-0.0035071049,
0.0375428721,
-0.0196627937,
-0.0378794558,
-0.0230281465,
-0.0065274993,
0.0607792139,
-0.0857914612,
0.0134232314,
-0.0276777837,
2.468e-7,
0.0564788058,
0.0573178083,
-0.0099340221,
0.0016801651,
-0.0159497242,
0.0371126384,
0.0190635081,
0.0636172146,
0.001296907,
0.0013351771,
0.0270584561,
0.0019989295,
0.0360010341,
0.0421337113,
-0.0032289261,
-0.0149918245,
-0.0717528835,
-0.0171083249,
-0.0545167625,
-0.0010501184,
0.0454974212,
0.1071043685,
0.0175341107,
-0.032667473,
0.0358153395,
0.0002773982,
0.0271291733,
-0.0676178858,
-0.0035157043,
0.026744809,
0.0379485637,
-0.0015199397,
0.015880594,
0.0251477938,
-0.0252564233,
-0.0649846792,
0.000871462,
0.0796563104,
-0.0320204385,
-0.0542566702,
-0.007098191,
-0.0078905933,
0.0057448628,
-0.0236798543,
0.0493056215,
-0.0395640694,
-0.0168740246,
0.0134359905,
-0.0126198363,
-0.0101944786,
0.0596865974,
-0.0262112208,
-0.0214188397,
0.0033883571,
0.0311263371,
0.0289647896,
-0.0001683371,
-0.0630528331,
-0.0144745801,
0.0165239926,
-0.001437221,
-0.0583530664,
-0.0099429004,
0.0060421843,
-0.012811115,
-0.0510377958,
0.0231206324,
1.769732689e-34,
0.0091530113,
0.02029383,
0.0068139262,
-0.0422604717,
0.0319609754,
0.0263943076,
0.0298133232,
-0.0168784801,
0.0032969548,
-0.0385365598,
0.0032554194
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09581v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09581v2 | DocLens: Multi-aspect Fine-grained Evaluation for Medical Text Generation | 2023-11-16T05:32:09 | 2024-02-18T20:39:06 | Yiqing Xie, Sheng Zhang, Hao Cheng, Pengfei Liu, Zelalem Gero, Cliff Wong, Tristan Naumann, Hoifung Poon, Carolyn Rose | cs.CL | cs.CL | Medical text generation aims to assist with administrative work and highlight
salient information to support decision-making. To reflect the specific
requirements of medical text, in this paper, we propose a set of metrics to
evaluate the completeness, conciseness, and attribution of the generated text
at a fine-grained level. The metrics can be computed by various types of
evaluators including instruction-following (both proprietary and open-source)
and supervised entailment models. We demonstrate the effectiveness of the
resulting framework, DocLens, with three evaluators on three tasks: clinical
note generation, radiology report summarization, and patient question
summarization. A comprehensive human study shows that DocLens exhibits
substantially higher agreement with the judgments of medical experts than
existing metrics. The results also highlight the need to improve open-source
evaluators and suggest potential directions. | [
0.0574904643,
0.0093278196,
0.026111031,
-0.035052184,
-0.0318771005,
0.0245867278,
-0.0141797103,
0.0250262395,
-0.0372262262,
-0.0221862458,
-0.0018159505,
-0.0285021234,
0.030938359,
0.011603808,
0.0312883072,
-0.0675142556,
0.0118096499,
0.0396646224,
0.033683829,
0.014716384,
0.0077876425,
0.0176508036,
-0.0337920375,
0.048840832,
0.0184844527,
0.0066145472,
0.0324976519,
0.0168527346,
0.0570787899,
-0.0383670442,
0.000624047,
0.0195465945,
-0.0286560319,
-0.0211764611,
0.0000019186,
-0.0392397419,
-0.0072653145,
0.033010263,
0.0140019711,
-0.0243952703,
0.0477481186,
-0.0604780987,
0.0085931458,
0.0038899048,
-0.0075546405,
0.0050476673,
0.0180061702,
0.0375963002,
0.0878877267,
0.060441941,
-0.0228632111,
0.0068907747,
0.0062985234,
-0.0045617842,
0.0200635139,
-0.0065082819,
-0.0229226463,
0.0351850688,
0.0403229669,
-0.0043014102,
0.0301210117,
0.0287794024,
0.0117924102,
0.0025258912,
0.0392549075,
0.0325094983,
-0.0212270189,
0.0001371335,
0.043365445,
0.056287434,
0.0308746435,
-0.0114766955,
0.02206764,
-0.0252220649,
-0.0070928601,
-0.0049783727,
-0.0429742038,
0.0241753552,
-0.0379648805,
-0.015437942,
0.0098215388,
0.0269330926,
0.0002566595,
0.0301468018,
0.0236060489,
-0.0104113333,
0.0103212213,
-0.0354549848,
-0.0084344549,
0.0229342598,
-0.0016285199,
-0.0720008761,
0.0560133345,
0.0436890535,
-0.0331852436,
-0.0044010715,
-0.0611943379,
-0.0435917191,
0.1033632308,
-0.03298546,
-0.0004853703,
0.0000123161,
0.0109802503,
0.0306466296,
-0.0371154994,
0.018078601,
-0.0148097398,
0.0267258137,
-0.0547162145,
0.0124022821,
-0.0372638218,
-0.015164732,
-0.0334271677,
0.021652706,
-0.0043252339,
-0.0212365668,
-0.0931834131,
-0.0290493518,
-0.0081323087,
0.0429247171,
0.0186128132,
0.0242675208,
-0.0262526758,
-0.0010033944,
-0.0145428209,
-0.0118989926,
-0.039520774,
0.0198669303,
0.0293657985,
0.0204395391,
0.0153896185,
0.0518812463,
0.020137595,
0.0054578562,
0.0061200918,
0.0241259504,
-0.0092022261,
0.0100646131,
0.0087138694,
-0.0853616372,
-0.0353894942,
-0.0401468351,
-0.0096713686,
-0.0662057325,
0.002582167,
0.0211028811,
-0.0017477319,
-0.0019135269,
0.0238226559,
0.0385679826,
-0.0176193006,
0.0044165035,
-0.0440442711,
0.0177333746,
0.0304035451,
0.023659341,
0.0402049385,
-0.0227419622,
0.0415097587,
0.0371062905,
-0.0249561891,
0.0107537135,
0.006837585,
-0.0388909206,
0.0142837921,
-0.0382669307,
0.023770351,
0.0027868047,
-0.018239066,
0.0757686421,
-0.0392539464,
0.107401073,
-0.030876739,
0.0333082899,
0.0332836173,
0.0069045899,
0.0401133597,
-0.0116634695,
0.0854453146,
-0.0141195124,
-0.0009187252,
0.0429715775,
-0.0118183242,
0.0533136167,
0.0260390434,
0.0400252864,
0.0339577459,
0.002526768,
-0.0097378334,
-0.0562581159,
-0.0291511118,
-0.0122748939,
-0.0330622867,
-0.0383006074,
0.0185108725,
0.0118153859,
-0.0706825033,
0.026951002,
0.0348471068,
-0.0582942106,
0.035324879,
-0.0208096672,
0.0118369823,
0.1065407321,
0.0806218535,
-0.013870093,
-0.0157490671,
-0.0304809492,
0.0413128771,
0.0311002061,
0.0271309689,
-0.0113349231,
0.0096743973,
-0.0744874775,
-0.027669277,
-0.0108466316,
0.0108087501,
-0.0253556259,
0.0004208616,
0.0303467177,
0.025468342,
-0.0413847752,
-0.0579796471,
0.0677350238,
0.0040628705,
-0.0139999082,
0.0019816386,
0.0024541891,
0.0140640344,
0.0218907706,
-0.0143277273,
0.0595905259,
-0.0016079077,
-0.0115068071,
-0.02906904,
-0.0084591303,
-0.0443568341,
-0.0177750625,
-0.0231162291,
-0.0882199109,
0.0099763311,
-0.0681794882,
-0.0244256519,
-0.0401117764,
-0.0635232106,
-0.0718783215,
-0.0184912253,
-0.018943537,
0.0094789099,
0.0688824803,
-0.0360761285,
-0.0346694291,
0.0354335867,
-0.0181425717,
0.0431397744,
0.0463170744,
-0.0213292129,
0.0271119736,
-0.0147179728,
-0.0000266391,
-0.0412849188,
-0.0083657745,
0.014250244,
0.0153305773,
0.0602125153,
-0.0199105758,
-0.0815554932,
-0.1094913036,
-0.0090630548,
-0.0074803014,
0.012738578,
0.0502278656,
-0.0026391242,
0.017993968,
0.0099487724,
-0.0479994714,
-0.0305994917,
0.0298992824,
0.0069214655,
0.0608151145,
0.0288474448,
0.0326140523,
-0.0164677743,
-0.0248726234,
-0.0119248079,
0.0130296247,
0.0759267882,
-0.0128454287,
-0.0295369625,
0.0065563824,
-0.0540942438,
-0.0586682819,
0.0417454652,
-0.0253775585,
0.0307201035,
0.0325357206,
0.0176965185,
0.0418361388,
0.0437015519,
0.0087151863,
0.0313445516,
0.0081229033,
0.0016818984,
-0.0153122749,
-0.0411341563,
-0.0090002595,
0.0335464813,
-0.0762822032,
0.0279726218,
0.0395110287,
0.0317294933,
0.0182670113,
-0.0674044415,
-0.0145839648,
-0.0327254422,
0.0009238121,
-0.0276324805,
0.0058877105,
-0.0260783322,
0.0418286845,
-0.0089002317,
-0.0233780965,
0.108248651,
-0.0346790329,
0.0325758718,
-0.0366956107,
-0.0096562197,
-0.0427432917,
0.0020305349,
-0.0140103055,
0.0405721366,
0.0339877829,
-0.0082397945,
-0.0381709039,
0.0415084809,
0.0579729415,
-0.0482938848,
0.0434510522,
-0.0227758121,
0.0031077873,
-0.016728729,
-0.0260729659,
-0.0113185151,
-0.0160977524,
0.0265542418,
0.0074385828,
0.0275208317,
0.00097913,
-0.0652737096,
0.0204773992,
0.0258360356,
0.0435310677,
-0.0043761469,
-0.0163382944,
-0.016549591,
0.0151888076,
0.0322500579,
-0.0217851531,
-0.0096347313,
-0.0792716965,
-0.0138626164,
0.0601200163,
-0.0439753048,
0.0198289193,
0.0161457844,
-0.0269712713,
-0.0305472091,
-0.021224916,
-0.019257661,
0.0305496678,
0.0800596923,
-0.0628450215,
-0.007693551,
0.0925825611,
0.0089128558,
0.0046204757,
0.0110114329,
-0.0046109036,
0.0193398856,
-0.0160856377,
0.0129650459,
-0.0441067889,
-0.0200849269,
-0.0191620737,
0.0726272538,
-0.0244332105,
-0.0220400505,
0.0130394716,
-0.0167863443,
0.0459141955,
0.0094123725,
-0.0456613638,
-0.0509594232,
-0.0159296766,
-0.0221543815,
0.008335717,
-0.0394482091,
-0.0009451876,
-0.023074273,
0.0126536516,
0.0143037746,
-0.0582509451,
-0.0495203063,
0.0043765879,
-0.0308894087,
0.0146998055,
0.0629477724,
0.0448878668,
-0.0007458536,
-0.052710209,
-0.0389451794,
-0.0274731033,
0.0160197187,
0.0137775689,
0.0982731581,
-0.0102276038,
0.0167814475,
-0.0479622036,
0.0472740158,
0.0050362968,
-0.0183126517,
0.0099557294,
0.0230412707,
-0.0277718417,
-0.0351437777,
-0.0379133783,
0.0649582148,
0.0326294973,
0.0633229166,
0.0350351855,
-0.0097817816,
-0.0458435901,
0.0162765887,
0.0457555503,
-0.0661461279,
0.0185908955,
0.0044448255,
-0.0597472601,
-0.021533411,
-0.103080079,
-0.0275975354,
0.044713255,
0.0186586548,
0.0063017146,
0.0152231362,
-0.0062192031,
-0.0291185491,
-0.0560423061,
0.0093039861,
0.0223950073,
0.0315474719,
-0.0346494652,
-0.0612804629,
0.0391721167,
-0.0058950321,
-0.0074092145,
0.0484846123,
-0.019686291,
0.0158275999,
-0.0300768558,
0.0612675063,
0.0208416004,
-0.0132564334,
0.0006850101,
0.0003387289,
0.0275393948,
0.0385795645,
-0.0378773995,
-0.0026109363,
-0.0026761102,
-0.0249152686,
-0.0177023821,
0.0065386416,
-0.0386552177,
0.0093159564,
-0.0122933667,
0.0406828448,
0.0018007222,
-0.0563998893,
0.0195468981,
0.0339297056,
-0.0124162585,
-0.0625205711,
0.0183492824,
-0.0340856761,
0.007078839,
-0.0115224831,
-0.0153902862,
-0.0365494005,
0.0150485514,
0.0166171305,
0.0011282578,
0.0085075423,
0.0447886772,
-0.0360963643,
-0.0052868412,
-0.0326480493,
0.023182923,
-0.038028881,
0.032925196,
0.0269284453,
-0.0312716104,
-0.0603959188,
-0.0155632561,
-0.031039482,
0.0179882403,
0.0062814006,
0.0518347844,
0.0191288628,
0.051011283,
0.0297744572,
0.055728551,
-0.0399069861,
0.0115018059,
-0.0700521246,
0.0000789326,
-0.003489844,
0.0211581867,
0.0415480733,
-0.0480381921,
0.0030041842,
-0.0333581641,
0.0926993489,
-0.0188962817,
0.0055283741,
-0.0002234122,
0.0006348715,
0.0288357846,
-0.032580696,
0.0824544877,
-0.0498015173,
0.0125975963,
-0.0254279599,
-0.0414672606,
-0.0762541294,
-0.0584478751,
-0.0224187206,
0.0297811441,
-0.034968216,
-0.0135051953,
-0.0887173414,
-0.0213266648,
-0.000943768,
0.0379502401,
-0.0027757303,
-0.0141718164,
0.0599440411,
0.0361286663,
-0.0104919709,
-0.0077320361,
-0.0478985496,
0.0229427498,
-0.0405376516,
0.0169833545,
0.0065401741,
-5.62061081e-33,
-0.0408226065,
-0.054853417,
0.0248164758,
-0.0069619166,
-0.0099678459,
0.0173814278,
-0.0504502915,
-0.0079793436,
0.0287926625,
0.0461566672,
0.0288774371,
-0.041079808,
0.0081148986,
0.0291626789,
0.0116110258,
-0.0071945055,
0.042507451,
0.0287786629,
-0.0552121997,
0.05274022,
-0.0052423817,
-0.0042994306,
0.0276690274,
-0.0615003109,
0.0210366547,
-0.0090671955,
-0.0197242014,
-0.0336238146,
-0.0327948965,
0.0508388244,
0.0076610358,
-0.0134362793,
0.0492291003,
0.0013898872,
-0.0315670669,
0.0056751617,
-0.0564962216,
-0.0170954,
0.0259594321,
-0.0552045144,
-0.0986183733,
-0.0425882414,
0.0383630954,
-0.0344894715,
0.0126611656,
-0.0097908843,
0.040943794,
-0.0305942912,
0.0046111164,
-0.0896937326,
-0.0531639867,
0.0633973777,
-0.0036778769,
-0.0349806733,
-0.0559407063,
0.0314677022,
-0.0319212377,
0.0229435302,
0.0160678253,
0.0014892578,
0.0257837102,
0.02325055,
0.0195439141,
-0.0346301273,
-0.0294236299,
0.0515791923,
0.0025629045,
-0.0043210271,
-0.0427131169,
0.0303731542,
-0.0505651608,
0.0650325269,
0.0646610409,
0.0376378633,
0.0031797753,
0.0050943117,
-0.060603451,
0.0830098987,
-0.0916095749,
0.0501872674,
0.0246389117,
-0.0459446274,
-0.0537280738,
-0.0018323225,
-0.0130516523,
-0.0120652178,
-0.0068044709,
-0.0282911323,
0.0209835526,
0.0173838232,
-0.0333928987,
-0.0043951203,
-0.0083920332,
0.0283999927,
0.0538651049,
-0.0277367327,
-0.0057960115,
0.0240834467,
-0.0531260222,
-0.0257485416,
-0.0716256127,
-0.0140444636,
0.039582286,
0.0247348584,
0.0477097854,
0.0295381323,
0.0539739393,
-0.0201809108,
-0.0412416458,
0.0258755293,
0.014746258,
0.0264787059,
-0.0349019654,
-0.0202316903,
0.0240119621,
0.0026215797,
-0.0103812758,
0.0387183912,
-0.0344090499,
-0.0167508814,
-0.0313500389,
-0.0749125183,
0.0443039201,
0.0128435818,
-0.0567742549,
0.0139220199,
-0.0185029712,
0.0159747284,
0.0332078598,
-0.0026006962,
0.0091373455,
0.0296827406,
2.641e-7,
0.0979748741,
0.0309246499,
0.0434568897,
-0.0134112565,
0.0009404665,
0.0023737056,
0.0026110639,
0.0215552095,
-0.0129947318,
-0.0361120515,
0.0558828041,
-0.0006141294,
0.0366465859,
0.0288438704,
-0.0560032018,
0.0001089403,
-0.0759397447,
-0.0223942026,
-0.0112813935,
-0.0263373703,
0.0972488448,
-0.0019026025,
-0.043693006,
-0.0242811199,
0.01449522,
-0.0071123312,
0.0567584075,
-0.01403399,
0.0039183395,
0.0441684425,
0.0449901484,
0.0003065952,
0.0148809487,
0.0512257591,
-0.0279006492,
-0.0571459793,
0.0479687937,
0.0957699046,
-0.0119232936,
0.0277373251,
0.0193158928,
-0.0296016503,
0.0247486364,
-0.042893365,
0.031108167,
-0.044171188,
-0.0335997418,
-0.0158797391,
-0.0225194748,
0.0104722455,
0.044267308,
-0.0226718634,
-0.0414503403,
0.0341232866,
0.0024440549,
0.0046342975,
-0.0364574157,
-0.0434276946,
-0.0432245508,
0.0295798089,
-0.007590156,
-0.0396274924,
0.0143183367,
-0.0181385241,
-0.0131257689,
-0.0946049839,
-0.0262631346,
2.156110794e-34,
0.0499661043,
-0.0141267702,
0.0002232117,
-0.0316360407,
0.030754311,
0.002932502,
-0.0256077163,
0.0205608197,
0.0263384581,
-0.016258508,
-0.0173013024
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09580v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09580v1 | MMOE: Mixture of Multimodal Interaction Experts | 2023-11-16T05:31:21 | 2023-11-16T05:31:21 | Haofei Yu, Paul Pu Liang, Ruslan Salakhutdinov, Louis-Philippe Morency | cs.CL | cs.CL | Multimodal machine learning, which studies the information and interactions
across various input modalities, has made significant advancements in
understanding the relationship between images and descriptive text. However,
this is just a portion of the potential multimodal interactions seen in the
real world and does not include new interactions between conflicting utterances
and gestures in predicting sarcasm, for example. Notably, the current methods
for capturing shared information often do not extend well to these more nuanced
interactions, sometimes performing as low as 50% in binary classification. In
this paper, we address this problem via a new approach called MMOE, which
stands for a mixture of multimodal interaction experts. Our method
automatically classifies data points from unlabeled multimodal datasets by
their interaction type and employs specialized models for each specific
interaction. Based on our experiments, this approach improves performance on
these challenging interactions by more than 10%, leading to an overall increase
of 2% for tasks like sarcasm prediction. As a result, interaction
quantification provides new insights for dataset analysis and yields simple
approaches that obtain state-of-the-art performance. | [
0.0449212715,
0.04953238,
-0.0399207398,
0.0530785434,
-0.0352440812,
0.0196880214,
0.0514523499,
0.0365083516,
0.0023424749,
-0.087953195,
-0.0524745919,
-0.0249141436,
0.0079641249,
0.039293088,
0.0433783904,
-0.076596804,
-0.005246331,
0.0323253386,
-0.0159484725,
0.0044128606,
0.0730820447,
0.0248782355,
-0.0486263186,
0.0514429174,
-0.0779555961,
-0.0115787024,
-0.0239911098,
0.0445535257,
0.0054295817,
0.0037028473,
0.01804794,
0.0586946383,
0.0289105922,
0.0067202318,
0.000001766,
-0.027194228,
0.025470553,
-0.0459216721,
0.015536027,
-0.0659661591,
0.056955602,
-0.0355702937,
0.0238603409,
0.0111185238,
-0.0380957872,
-0.016877288,
0.0650911778,
0.0435987338,
0.0620104484,
0.0428512767,
-0.0299670752,
0.0056884568,
0.011331331,
-0.0028197663,
0.0254987925,
0.009572153,
0.0133728664,
0.0317748562,
-0.0181598086,
-0.0067137866,
-0.0464658588,
0.0138835646,
-0.0244580414,
-0.0064913747,
0.0063336664,
0.0209237337,
0.0159648806,
-0.0309001077,
-0.0302800052,
0.1004350334,
0.0008564026,
0.02130525,
-0.0042189127,
-0.0057095098,
-0.0015972091,
-0.0041362904,
-0.0179964304,
-0.0144857075,
-0.0155997071,
-0.0178734511,
-0.0689935759,
0.0362913124,
0.0035782924,
0.0233709477,
0.0220954232,
-0.0010899781,
-0.0263481606,
0.0127890473,
0.0062475726,
-0.0145670874,
-0.0157175343,
-0.0223768651,
-0.0311355889,
0.0011615041,
0.0141947735,
-0.0059070261,
-0.0481794551,
-0.0226227622,
0.0089744702,
-0.0201918706,
0.00015511,
-0.0100616561,
-0.0486286357,
0.0723337457,
0.0666014403,
-0.0192594212,
-0.0191104859,
-0.0072017512,
-0.0033097155,
-0.0148035446,
-0.0648339987,
0.001029317,
0.0166372154,
-0.0025757148,
-0.0438472442,
-0.060278587,
-0.0125771239,
0.0291077737,
-0.0441705659,
0.0110463919,
-0.0059830877,
0.0410834663,
-0.0154421525,
0.0252560265,
-0.0223024376,
0.0538242795,
-0.0204823278,
0.0591405556,
-0.0319248624,
-0.0334391817,
0.0183261707,
0.059538573,
0.0211455487,
-0.0229898524,
0.0242784508,
0.0882711485,
-0.0135450289,
-0.0559966639,
-0.0108337756,
-0.0435581133,
-0.0630814657,
-0.0564136617,
0.0388090424,
-0.0244845282,
0.0878644884,
-0.0172008108,
-0.0124589065,
-0.01835737,
-0.0026901513,
-0.037982922,
0.0090515558,
0.1249959767,
-0.0468879156,
-0.0290300902,
0.0404317528,
0.0211294983,
-0.0557192601,
0.040436063,
0.0151961688,
0.0201854594,
0.0557265729,
-0.0004971111,
0.0288566481,
0.0516244285,
-0.0115576265,
-0.0317204297,
-0.0030477075,
-0.0173909888,
-0.049950134,
0.0248558912,
0.0286303386,
0.0203153472,
-0.0413585007,
-0.0526976474,
0.0307560712,
0.0405375063,
-0.0433096848,
0.042211283,
0.0091154557,
0.0119566424,
0.0278878268,
-0.0055248584,
-0.004222129,
0.0286106504,
-0.0296877809,
-0.0467292145,
0.0121333795,
0.0123211546,
-0.0435189642,
-0.0250270609,
-0.0179196242,
-0.0444533154,
0.016302865,
0.0072597889,
0.0197768901,
-0.0147410519,
-0.0429063812,
-0.016965311,
0.0250974968,
-0.028928984,
-0.0371866785,
0.0013327484,
0.0049794433,
0.0619537421,
0.0281474032,
-0.0435070582,
-0.0128385453,
-0.0451648273,
-0.0090303291,
-0.0005676707,
-0.0346845165,
-0.0183061063,
0.0767230317,
-0.055731155,
-0.0209621508,
-0.03812984,
0.0124208378,
0.0307221208,
-0.0093100378,
-0.0014150687,
-0.0193333477,
0.0384112969,
0.1021051109,
0.019132873,
0.0156647209,
0.0051267454,
-0.0128593016,
0.0481719561,
0.0380293168,
0.016465174,
-0.021193888,
-0.0603965782,
-0.0116634434,
-0.0306396093,
-0.0382334627,
0.0524221361,
0.0012217495,
-0.0835093632,
0.0290732924,
-0.0179530885,
-0.0257255323,
0.0083578527,
-0.040618021,
0.0078696199,
0.0303072259,
-0.0307985134,
0.0121523347,
-0.058785595,
-0.0355048291,
-0.0040966286,
0.025269255,
-0.0011025362,
0.0261758454,
-0.0290483199,
-0.0345476717,
-0.0095777484,
0.0160938501,
0.0241375584,
0.0229838509,
-0.0481275506,
-0.0157786161,
0.0169868562,
0.0492860004,
-0.0059927152,
-0.0109951552,
-0.0318267755,
-0.048329629,
-0.1289095879,
-0.0194771327,
-0.0069355774,
-0.0338969715,
0.0178177841,
-0.0035437688,
0.000536822,
-0.0095665809,
-0.0067205848,
0.0102180988,
-0.001654248,
-0.0117650768,
0.0283208136,
0.0142508755,
0.0433004722,
-0.0457263812,
0.0002527849,
-0.0080996063,
0.0955875143,
-0.0184127558,
-0.0293403845,
-0.0027133692,
-0.0354366638,
-0.0591329522,
0.0422346964,
-0.0277342871,
-0.042286288,
0.0128374379,
-0.0052265171,
-0.0066888588,
0.0328809246,
0.028460674,
0.061496228,
-0.0065785469,
-0.0172817074,
-0.026565697,
0.0175543521,
0.0120129744,
0.042505756,
-0.0218423493,
-0.0064200843,
-0.043434836,
0.036182411,
0.0164564382,
0.0456976555,
-0.0475014262,
0.0141361449,
0.0704353973,
-0.0477822199,
-0.0165389385,
-0.0091357073,
-0.0049052867,
-0.0101013696,
-0.0219003689,
-0.0286062807,
0.0576588623,
-0.0171653088,
-0.0501932055,
0.0175893139,
-0.0164716076,
-0.012427168,
0.0937778428,
-0.0146844229,
0.0154262343,
-0.0049138432,
0.0114182243,
-0.0158849061,
-0.0453654714,
0.0164698996,
0.0136578036,
0.0286432598,
-0.0127946511,
-0.0229375288,
0.0205561779,
-0.029980287,
-0.0138198258,
-0.0264541991,
-0.036173895,
-0.0450809561,
-0.0211143829,
-0.0222852882,
-0.0043933163,
-0.0013561193,
0.0076180408,
-0.0335708447,
-0.0059936638,
-0.0150123788,
-0.0077152387,
0.0432675853,
0.0557584204,
0.0187269077,
-0.0686069652,
-0.019197667,
-0.0218779426,
0.0421227403,
-0.0194447078,
-0.0194118582,
-0.0562940314,
0.0215484798,
-0.0128628816,
0.0723255575,
-0.0054771355,
-0.0065314709,
0.0145929838,
0.0100131687,
0.0487735495,
0.0872658044,
0.0016012037,
-0.0559270047,
-0.0033651234,
0.011362127,
-0.0127625447,
0.0272217225,
-0.0052496819,
-0.0541206449,
-0.078941159,
-0.0341654643,
-0.0045246254,
0.0027389284,
-0.0173703618,
-0.013492411,
-0.0608055741,
0.014757405,
-0.0035909242,
-0.0133707346,
0.0039360826,
0.0122898053,
0.0125996061,
-0.0311027076,
-0.0165172201,
-0.0512927324,
0.0289784689,
-0.0167249106,
-0.0028093786,
-0.0122429747,
-0.0614161231,
0.0337123312,
-0.0119283833,
0.0068953792,
-0.0049357666,
0.0553163402,
-0.0105311116,
-0.0199480634,
-0.0233091805,
-0.0070784874,
0.0133220302,
-0.0287549216,
0.1161838025,
-0.0551110804,
-0.0070562162,
-0.018203795,
0.0185158812,
0.0266866796,
0.0300169513,
-0.0255359411,
0.0280567147,
-0.0360377207,
0.0051810378,
-0.0335426405,
-0.0023348774,
0.0504560806,
0.016499171,
0.0264861304,
-0.0791232437,
-0.0376445502,
0.0074731363,
0.0104062138,
-0.0121772205,
0.0182271805,
-0.0214404818,
0.0179862939,
-0.0263389312,
-0.0418952778,
-0.023106223,
0.0094644157,
0.0633071363,
-0.0365168937,
-0.0029153056,
-0.031743262,
0.0259951595,
-0.0451449715,
0.0538287088,
0.0573566742,
0.0230234787,
0.0054813484,
-0.0096528772,
0.022288803,
-0.0399111509,
-0.0049443967,
-0.0027173846,
-0.0477451049,
-0.0510457456,
-0.0432521738,
0.0878303647,
0.0139212925,
0.0214925613,
0.0542967767,
-0.0820141062,
0.0133007737,
0.0300725121,
-0.0102948565,
0.0309434123,
0.0437023975,
0.0140449042,
-0.0173107367,
0.0246372744,
-0.0116153192,
0.0359832458,
-0.0209838245,
-0.045133695,
-0.0905593857,
-0.0632678643,
-0.0530117825,
-0.0467864685,
0.0526679978,
-0.0260988791,
-0.0378245972,
-0.0014993558,
-0.0181723554,
0.0254578739,
-0.0027149445,
-0.0656943694,
-0.0092225056,
-0.010233853,
-0.0068518445,
-0.0452981442,
-0.0232169628,
-0.0146883428,
0.0316651203,
0.0010918967,
0.0291346591,
0.061244417,
-0.0087569132,
-0.032666076,
0.0410223454,
-0.0325158387,
0.0016605923,
0.0172010008,
-0.023080973,
0.0275033098,
0.0777582899,
0.0171625875,
-0.019680744,
-0.008203988,
0.0743600279,
0.0228558853,
0.031794861,
0.001363868,
0.0112987151,
0.0559173264,
0.0172813497,
0.021604551,
-0.0141116837,
-0.0049747657,
-0.0101286694,
0.0837623477,
-0.0542552322,
-0.0572265647,
0.0381160863,
0.013708381,
-0.0071867835,
0.0163199827,
0.0354180746,
-0.0798708946,
0.0183033403,
-0.0091546047,
-0.0311214663,
-0.041654259,
0.0087803751,
0.1001715809,
0.024677461,
0.0031660167,
0.0371353477,
-0.0415933989,
-0.0443177,
0.0498175025,
-0.022468131,
-0.000349083,
0.022760313,
0.0577910468,
0.0386250317,
0.020279767,
0.0253487881,
-0.0198808741,
-0.0080875475,
-0.0110269831,
0.0291689541,
-0.0111030154,
-5.341662327e-33,
0.0096068336,
-0.0396003537,
-0.0182150062,
0.0058835139,
-0.0076681878,
0.0345053859,
-0.0208034068,
0.0299486518,
-0.0076168301,
-0.0030074425,
0.0370581001,
-0.0067179757,
-0.0250931624,
-0.008678304,
0.0222709719,
0.0093987463,
0.0020118561,
-0.0188712887,
-0.0129180793,
0.023233315,
0.0420458987,
0.0165747125,
0.0512837246,
-0.1116930246,
-0.0071684048,
0.0175035503,
-0.0362756848,
-0.0037442485,
0.0338068344,
0.0619517714,
-0.0135075292,
0.0852312297,
0.00959701,
0.0377164185,
0.0013209748,
0.0295160357,
-0.0291192457,
-0.0163493566,
-0.0097884638,
0.0153471176,
-0.0471250042,
0.0274458434,
0.0406383052,
-0.0074509322,
-0.0013148884,
-0.0380253382,
0.0651397109,
0.0181490723,
0.0405199341,
-0.0185595471,
-0.0253415201,
0.0206764881,
-0.0343463533,
-0.0285366289,
0.0432562195,
0.0279487222,
0.0502696298,
-0.028170092,
-0.0581739545,
0.0185114201,
-0.0813995898,
-0.0327568427,
0.0190323237,
0.0151529619,
0.0284875482,
0.0893697813,
0.0237095505,
0.0216717087,
-0.0052511059,
0.0080540758,
0.0308476463,
0.0973162428,
0.0217198189,
0.1177130342,
-0.0046926332,
-0.0245190915,
-0.0215271544,
0.0256790072,
0.0387672633,
0.0091832364,
-0.0223410632,
-0.0150729418,
-0.0475204177,
0.0062164832,
0.0199644547,
0.0262425561,
-0.0035338055,
-0.0421601385,
-0.0122245457,
0.0032136003,
0.0016325829,
0.0521981642,
0.0648682714,
-0.0529214814,
-0.0202830117,
0.0251722056,
-0.033366099,
0.0835083723,
0.0316392742,
-0.0062100673,
-0.0151974494,
-0.0406915322,
0.0387557596,
-0.0282107722,
0.0530354939,
0.0038113298,
0.0444527268,
0.0437339805,
-0.0247201137,
-0.025242364,
0.0170843173,
0.0044711181,
-0.0303718932,
0.0489067547,
-0.0260242298,
0.0341809876,
-0.0475220457,
-0.0030850498,
-0.0145538729,
0.0255542435,
-0.0355829149,
-0.0679455101,
-0.0078233462,
0.0126938941,
-0.0188455507,
-0.020833455,
-0.0183829814,
-0.1062956005,
-0.0044280244,
-0.0464832038,
-0.0019312107,
0.000603482,
2.524e-7,
0.0185117889,
0.0418751463,
-0.0065044221,
0.0112688188,
0.0469889306,
0.0899550468,
-0.0226267111,
0.0466609597,
-0.0016968824,
-0.0539272167,
0.0436244123,
-0.0021003997,
0.0326232053,
0.0191829503,
-0.0248940773,
0.0038313749,
-0.0130539248,
0.0194257665,
-0.0491301492,
0.0078909416,
0.0656768382,
0.0556429513,
0.0562332869,
-0.0304316562,
0.028372338,
-0.025463704,
0.068355538,
-0.0186062586,
0.0193531998,
-0.0148072941,
0.0544916242,
-0.0213854071,
-0.0108970692,
0.0445326008,
0.0091169132,
-0.0278419908,
0.0080137383,
0.043778386,
-0.0473869331,
-0.0583512671,
0.0045154882,
0.0394615643,
-0.043680165,
-0.0183147583,
0.0506037213,
-0.0033514367,
-0.0194735155,
-0.028125193,
-0.0009149439,
-0.013689952,
0.058023721,
0.0083357617,
-0.0297534205,
0.0367033966,
0.03378677,
-0.0465808511,
-0.004208555,
-0.1141664386,
0.0002708616,
0.0157798454,
-0.0762750953,
-0.0104626883,
0.015769437,
-0.0200502798,
0.0351835303,
-0.0779932067,
0.0008819248,
1.625357646e-34,
-0.0134571791,
0.0000257196,
0.0263336506,
0.0108839208,
0.0222969968,
-0.0025280816,
-0.0106533384,
-0.0110249761,
0.0343656726,
-0.0034624473,
-0.0180898197
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09579v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09579v2 | Crafting In-context Examples according to LMs' Parametric Knowledge | 2023-11-16T05:30:07 | 2024-04-04T01:00:16 | Yoonsang Lee, Pranav Atreya, Xi Ye, Eunsol Choi | cs.CL | cs.CL | In-context learning can improve the performances of knowledge-rich tasks such
as question answering. In such scenarios, in-context examples trigger a
language model (LM) to surface information stored in its parametric knowledge.
We study how to better construct in-context example sets, based on whether the
model is aware of the in-context examples. We identify 'known' examples, where
models can correctly answer from their parametric knowledge, and 'unknown'
ones. Our experiments show that prompting with 'unknown' examples decreases the
performance, potentially as it encourages hallucination rather than searching
for its parametric knowledge. Constructing an in-context example set that
presents both known and unknown information performs the best across diverse
settings. We perform analysis on three multi-answer question answering
datasets, which allows us to further study answer set ordering strategies based
on the LM's knowledge of each answer. Together, our study sheds light on how to
best construct in-context example sets for knowledge-rich tasks. | [
0.0061530941,
-0.0104864743,
-0.0221797209,
0.0384249613,
-0.0260992423,
0.0278830025,
-0.0150018986,
0.0200542398,
-0.0278079323,
-0.0520594679,
-0.0046685226,
-0.0110781109,
-0.0072907968,
-0.0183991417,
0.022886144,
-0.0334620774,
0.0317459106,
-0.0706456378,
0.0021242378,
-0.007728932,
-0.0224371422,
0.0012790038,
0.005406823,
0.003900117,
0.0070439889,
-0.0386288576,
-0.0171555076,
0.0275942776,
-0.006675289,
-0.012183289,
0.0322805829,
0.0437366031,
0.0179192312,
-0.0008935194,
0.0000019342,
-0.0359029025,
0.0081382543,
-0.0417126343,
-0.0558456816,
-0.0216687731,
-0.0275279395,
0.0253741983,
0.0336304531,
0.0289977938,
-0.068777062,
0.0118089365,
-0.0022239878,
0.0357993506,
0.0496373624,
0.0429495722,
0.0105905272,
0.018054489,
-0.0029158923,
0.0034597979,
0.072100684,
-0.0125999888,
0.0251681227,
0.0050881291,
0.0156255141,
0.0230027959,
-0.0084775491,
0.0342134759,
0.026466826,
0.0354931094,
-0.0144649409,
0.0366598032,
-0.0557924099,
0.0164332204,
0.0145790456,
0.0779037699,
-0.0237092134,
-0.0556089282,
-0.0309458319,
-0.0199926011,
0.0596210994,
0.0450847745,
-0.0721070021,
0.0028289335,
-0.0339661464,
-0.0014857701,
0.0163804367,
0.02057519,
0.0261960085,
0.0003554134,
0.0130030233,
0.0650189742,
-0.0203483477,
-0.0404171161,
-0.0032310286,
-0.0236677267,
-0.051933568,
-0.0565708913,
-0.0151163414,
0.0547035262,
-0.0280590337,
0.0556753092,
-0.0355824605,
-0.0059531853,
0.0304249618,
-0.0531260781,
0.0185760725,
0.025337413,
-0.0130959926,
0.0600463822,
-0.0363404639,
0.0087594008,
-0.012164386,
0.0260924716,
-0.0421147384,
-0.0195204709,
-0.0320904069,
-0.0474155769,
-0.056906011,
0.0358352587,
0.0031511257,
0.0249907114,
0.0130173676,
0.046960976,
-0.0160965919,
0.0322459899,
-0.0223627482,
0.0315240063,
0.0180112366,
-0.0042972164,
-0.0633955598,
-0.018404847,
-0.0760546625,
0.0402888432,
0.0299539138,
-0.0794475526,
-0.0175540652,
-0.0257531945,
0.0094403969,
-0.0276088286,
0.029714752,
0.0539171025,
0.0147451153,
-0.0290909205,
-0.0223162826,
-0.0508941226,
0.043428544,
-0.0329064876,
-0.000729142,
-0.0788444653,
0.021395728,
0.0676657408,
-0.0252056103,
-0.0122687332,
0.004970199,
0.0724492967,
-0.0223614592,
0.0703062937,
0.0004568656,
0.0454310291,
0.0426684842,
0.0443273373,
-0.022748515,
0.0888893381,
-0.0068782945,
-0.0199991036,
0.0297994968,
-0.0235996954,
0.0492331497,
-0.0033570663,
0.0618231855,
0.0108577628,
-0.0175953433,
0.06789992,
0.0079642534,
0.0050634635,
-0.0182378124,
-0.0153671345,
-0.023308767,
-0.0210099053,
0.0627922639,
0.0372761078,
-0.0007826901,
-0.0102192825,
-0.0123999286,
-0.0464969017,
0.0072032516,
0.01977605,
-0.0498464294,
0.0377169512,
-0.0457377657,
0.0085652638,
-0.0025850204,
0.0182324145,
-0.0518117063,
-0.0373588726,
-0.0105780605,
0.0053808391,
-0.0136419991,
0.0602950491,
0.0141046559,
0.071718879,
-0.0435326882,
0.0673973486,
0.0056611542,
-0.0150699075,
-0.0250744205,
-0.0330893099,
0.0543490015,
0.0476669595,
0.0476667695,
-0.0760296211,
-0.0174894109,
0.0118607851,
0.0687971264,
-0.0018332091,
0.0397578664,
-0.0217059869,
0.0247729905,
-0.0008789127,
-0.0030937938,
-0.0277563855,
0.0026939975,
-0.0066626328,
0.0640708581,
0.0295127537,
-0.011494522,
-0.0671740249,
-0.0094942078,
0.012274906,
-0.0236533731,
-0.0402857587,
-0.0156289525,
-0.0083135022,
-0.0128025822,
-0.0035836736,
0.0243541822,
0.0368381105,
0.0383915529,
-0.0302078072,
-0.0278884433,
0.0257011335,
-0.0709674135,
-0.0458330512,
-0.007011917,
-0.0099101979,
-0.0281333718,
-0.0202271808,
-0.0353620388,
-0.0351155922,
-0.0172537267,
0.0023189071,
0.0953888819,
-0.0204299577,
0.0042412966,
0.0099615175,
-0.0019421014,
-0.0274602845,
0.1196232587,
-0.0047636526,
0.0669508725,
0.0222168863,
0.0142821446,
-0.0287656318,
-0.0001767156,
0.0189590566,
-0.0184359998,
-0.0108400779,
0.0040828488,
0.0000419336,
-0.0295858495,
-0.0685606524,
0.0232100822,
-0.0682835206,
-0.0256132856,
-0.0147039983,
-0.0110377381,
0.0239866115,
0.0151785696,
-0.0193129126,
-0.0617880672,
-0.0505241416,
0.0173055436,
0.0112437578,
0.0641740561,
0.0466780551,
0.0282932054,
0.0044331467,
-0.0105821257,
-0.0019475694,
-0.0073125041,
0.0442051925,
-0.0230713394,
0.047267437,
-0.0945151448,
0.0485535637,
-0.0349817052,
0.0246034712,
-0.0220538769,
0.0085651772,
0.0165165998,
-0.0186176077,
0.0224068891,
0.0778067335,
0.0060481173,
0.0085779997,
0.0729071051,
0.0334874243,
-0.0489482805,
-0.007019558,
-0.0163872428,
0.0029680536,
0.0006959079,
-0.022913333,
0.0003247226,
0.0277865622,
0.0052132062,
0.0011979127,
-0.0346899964,
0.0499441624,
0.0050778193,
-0.0389092006,
-0.0885705426,
-0.021492213,
-0.0011617953,
0.0819207504,
-0.0306597836,
-0.054220356,
0.0668217093,
0.0086326497,
0.0001700286,
-0.0116112819,
0.0054028998,
-0.0238288585,
0.0369524769,
0.0135707548,
0.0059018354,
-0.0171109457,
-0.0018733919,
-0.0664093196,
-0.0069800597,
0.0198725965,
-0.0407547578,
0.0340102874,
-0.0356236249,
-0.0111081423,
-0.017181538,
-0.0448175855,
-0.0897475779,
-0.039923206,
-0.0104288105,
-0.0048426255,
-0.0710738152,
0.0051906258,
0.0208667703,
-0.0193400644,
0.0395607017,
0.02564824,
-0.0125654275,
-0.0351818204,
-0.0003241837,
0.0403031744,
0.0664958656,
0.0477842055,
0.0266859401,
-0.0342348628,
0.0618503243,
0.0595874004,
0.07939291,
-0.0152324801,
-0.0008154682,
-0.013003624,
0.0187258963,
-0.0281211566,
-0.0266181212,
0.0398915894,
0.0303566456,
-0.0369048566,
-0.0203131773,
0.1022619009,
0.0433676504,
-0.0379703194,
0.0244953353,
-0.0713468343,
0.0438357405,
0.043602515,
0.026340792,
-0.0720255971,
-0.0171702132,
-0.0196357872,
-0.0165648684,
-0.0302593485,
-0.0225643069,
-0.0083595309,
-0.1040271223,
0.0011753966,
-0.0058048056,
-0.0542688631,
-0.0385232754,
-0.0429520048,
0.0001279595,
0.0372802764,
-0.0059264824,
0.0175586492,
-0.0235746261,
-0.0111619188,
0.0115599399,
0.0175558757,
-0.0434034802,
0.0324303843,
-0.0125341285,
0.01343909,
0.0077650244,
-0.0179213472,
-0.0064392476,
-0.008632144,
0.0033037683,
-0.0421539694,
0.042152632,
-0.0015658138,
0.0415274799,
0.0042315023,
0.0013422468,
0.0011996829,
0.0330605209,
-0.0849061087,
-0.0421326309,
0.0272415578,
0.0855126604,
-0.0363009498,
-0.0048382473,
-0.0006188584,
-0.0335801058,
0.0262799691,
0.0954086259,
0.0414344929,
-0.0186516643,
-0.0006597563,
-0.0258977301,
0.0247096885,
-0.0051430343,
0.0073740766,
0.0384884514,
0.0542821363,
0.0434100032,
-0.0618098602,
-0.0448269509,
0.0379322059,
0.0461203009,
-0.0112634506,
0.0677746981,
-0.0319735818,
0.0304383319,
-0.029895626,
0.0097877914,
-0.0028694647,
-0.0092212083,
-0.0022977958,
-0.0291557368,
0.0283823181,
-0.044024758,
-0.0275326818,
0.004696982,
-0.0603362992,
-0.0525438823,
0.0021004204,
0.0309482776,
0.0299173053,
0.0419457257,
0.0000748139,
-0.0420492366,
0.0578256473,
0.0008426988,
-0.0098505523,
-0.0000673841,
0.0111745466,
0.0134396786,
0.0077344794,
0.0447103716,
-0.0624449141,
-0.0131873898,
0.011867078,
-0.0179435518,
-0.0833592638,
0.0063059363,
0.0319159105,
-0.0325439647,
-0.013230742,
0.014808123,
-0.006619425,
-0.0029645623,
0.0616104342,
-0.011759934,
-0.0001243813,
0.0019610503,
-0.0033779505,
-0.0037640738,
-0.035432905,
0.0145923737,
-0.0191074833,
0.0022347081,
0.0214697551,
-0.0421058908,
-0.0115511902,
0.033662539,
0.024293717,
0.0199011415,
0.0034001644,
-0.0151724797,
0.0145983491,
-0.0216278508,
0.0598424338,
-0.0063949833,
0.057342995,
0.0203950293,
-0.0202216394,
-0.0235188399,
0.0171971545,
-0.080876939,
-0.0696771294,
-0.0075372611,
0.0122874295,
0.0382334553,
-0.0477307849,
0.0154717341,
-0.0374217965,
-0.0029349455,
0.0121945357,
-0.0057599805,
0.0368232988,
-0.0368509553,
0.0436513349,
0.0588273406,
-0.0046832212,
0.0041896719,
0.0966115966,
0.0125630209,
0.0595449507,
0.0096908575,
0.0088480534,
-0.0183087401,
0.0178767368,
0.0056386697,
0.0256537069,
0.0064769411,
0.0459154658,
-0.0434791781,
-0.073021993,
-0.0397406109,
0.0065322816,
-0.0202034023,
-0.0172913317,
0.0378044359,
0.0688806325,
0.0128257647,
-0.0478566922,
-0.0221256632,
0.0110594295,
-0.0416845381,
-0.0008046201,
-0.0261841118,
-6.412357683e-33,
-0.0096645476,
-0.0490504391,
0.0081491368,
0.0057340763,
0.0704178065,
-0.006669763,
-0.0118573997,
0.0058848266,
-0.0567654371,
-0.0115713337,
-0.0488775186,
0.0477760173,
0.0039560697,
0.0122448923,
0.018374335,
-0.05454899,
-0.0051384848,
-0.028282905,
-0.0426554866,
0.0251562353,
0.0483212993,
-0.0052354499,
0.0661165342,
-0.0482636504,
0.0013029907,
-0.0531491153,
0.0115633942,
0.0411776975,
-0.0646101534,
0.0490218289,
-0.0032472729,
0.053921923,
0.0414738134,
-0.0236017387,
-0.0252199192,
0.0364505984,
-0.0712746009,
-0.0814175606,
0.029539125,
0.012512723,
-0.0654750094,
-0.0331939906,
0.0351515003,
0.0079168165,
0.0282037873,
0.0005595252,
0.0296821427,
-0.0396948196,
-0.0165441949,
0.011871824,
-0.0128483521,
-0.005665591,
0.0118915588,
-0.032872919,
0.0089336541,
0.0607623942,
0.0039274329,
-0.0081509762,
-0.0315734297,
0.0119979307,
0.0226513892,
0.0246562678,
0.052738484,
0.0156406574,
-0.0146906665,
0.0526397452,
0.0027677079,
0.017483199,
0.0096444571,
-0.018396439,
-0.0234911796,
0.0465013497,
0.0191381294,
0.0297609083,
0.0463548787,
0.0172871333,
-0.0363858007,
0.017486101,
0.0117272185,
-0.0045406609,
0.0485625714,
-0.017727416,
-0.0418746583,
-0.0326066725,
-0.0558061674,
0.0225844607,
-0.0471091196,
-0.0116314329,
0.0453877226,
0.0175811555,
0.0014425126,
-0.0208582599,
0.0221422333,
-0.0102084698,
-0.0199200734,
0.0572080761,
-0.012294421,
0.0078405626,
0.0193125345,
-0.0132066812,
-0.0454484709,
-0.0020582217,
0.0085914126,
0.0122313071,
0.0226238444,
0.0347958729,
0.0403824039,
-0.0057664271,
-0.0681395531,
-0.0020285943,
-0.0335320309,
0.04519099,
-0.0017458012,
-0.0690928698,
0.0299040359,
0.0167881474,
-0.0143873924,
-0.0005854697,
0.0198501684,
-0.0616510436,
-0.0609800108,
-0.0060754968,
-0.0498355404,
0.0013937773,
-0.0059250421,
-0.0498429723,
-0.0225540269,
0.0068640336,
0.0556361601,
-0.0379803888,
-0.0103626037,
0.0413489975,
2.553e-7,
0.0326466896,
0.0179138556,
0.0131015154,
0.0742967725,
0.0450885184,
0.0169276427,
-0.0120876832,
0.0175181981,
0.0150175365,
-0.070967637,
0.0047108424,
0.0205504876,
0.0260786116,
0.0595601313,
-0.059541449,
-0.0250981562,
-0.0575555712,
0.015196274,
-0.0236842427,
-0.0356718265,
0.0424392708,
0.0702793822,
-0.0255466197,
-0.0049537336,
-0.0308631528,
-0.0453398451,
0.0649388507,
-0.0573853925,
0.0440807715,
-0.0109349731,
-0.0084764473,
0.0214583874,
0.0314838998,
0.0810253769,
-0.0006034554,
-0.0271939076,
0.0029764599,
0.0090028634,
0.0047976747,
-0.0729197264,
-0.0594712086,
-0.0050823963,
0.0162503719,
-0.0971422195,
0.0765575394,
-0.0447643064,
-0.0152819073,
-0.0008710942,
0.0167880803,
-0.0320124328,
0.0055991649,
0.0249864478,
-0.0253816042,
-0.0289882664,
-0.0103470972,
0.0118190367,
0.0120431753,
-0.0558662862,
-0.0445459075,
0.0416458473,
-0.0136616761,
-0.0456182584,
-0.0296060387,
-0.0215272959,
0.017709326,
-0.0437696911,
-0.0134828212,
2.237152405e-34,
-0.0099982722,
-0.0101928394,
0.0366323777,
0.0869139731,
-0.0057378784,
-0.0349761173,
0.0176986195,
0.0085152462,
0.0464142375,
-0.0628048331,
-0.0134284189
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09578v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09578v2 | Tied-Lora: Enhancing parameter efficiency of LoRA with weight tying | 2023-11-16T05:29:39 | 2024-04-12T23:15:51 | Adithya Renduchintala, Tugrul Konuk, Oleksii Kuchaiev | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | We introduce Tied-LoRA, a novel paradigm leveraging weight tying and
selective training to enhance the parameter efficiency of Low-rank Adaptation
(LoRA). Our exploration encompasses different plausible combinations of
parameter training and freezing, coupled with weight tying, aimed at
identifying the optimal trade-off between performance and the count of
trainable parameters. Across $5$ diverse tasks and two foundational language
models with different parameter counts, our experiments provide comprehensive
insights into the inherent trade-offs between efficiency and performance.
Our findings reveal a specific Tied-LoRA configuration that distinguishes
itself by showcasing comparable performance to LoRA across multiple tasks while
utilizing only a fraction of the parameters employed by the standard LoRA
method, particularly at elevated ranks. This underscores the efficacy of
Tied-LoRA in achieving impressive results with significantly reduced model
complexity. | [
0.0372108966,
0.0791092888,
0.0045162169,
0.057123743,
0.037104018,
0.0294262618,
-0.0034351435,
0.0197521057,
-0.0018173428,
-0.0240445081,
-0.0714651644,
0.0030820153,
0.0149281016,
0.0051369905,
0.0507398099,
-0.0603723079,
0.0164042898,
-0.054015886,
-0.0202472229,
-0.0074197194,
-0.01016312,
0.0190679524,
-0.0198362097,
0.0121138915,
0.0554281324,
-0.0052625882,
-0.0064529306,
0.0542946458,
0.0304769408,
-0.0071916915,
0.0025701218,
0.069365494,
0.0346602127,
0.0526263006,
0.0000019868,
-0.0376384035,
-0.0214641914,
-0.0188935138,
-0.0237450227,
0.0404062755,
0.0462102257,
-0.0387427099,
-0.0110889487,
0.0159117877,
-0.0198107343,
-0.0126119154,
0.0643094331,
0.0078353463,
0.000898868,
0.0674456954,
-0.0166965704,
-0.0037016934,
-0.0007788439,
-0.0553119741,
-0.055767823,
-0.0676480159,
0.0154134985,
-0.0316364802,
-0.0297723711,
-0.0138209509,
-0.04555979,
0.0121156573,
-0.0035933848,
0.0049289102,
-0.0194949005,
0.0371305421,
-0.0597834922,
0.0133036431,
-0.0115033071,
0.095375061,
-0.0905709043,
-0.0169161744,
0.0105547318,
-0.0212370567,
0.0069375494,
-0.0429949574,
-0.0366752818,
-0.0204370674,
0.0612639748,
0.0150673585,
-0.0076394766,
-0.0046128109,
0.0277190655,
-0.0097627901,
-0.023802476,
0.0453014858,
0.0273433719,
-0.0460524149,
0.0274579525,
-0.0089974767,
-0.0512559451,
-0.0192813817,
-0.0215798989,
0.0056268782,
-0.0117919212,
-0.0142727485,
-0.0621677712,
-0.0389310978,
0.0124198357,
-0.0064089042,
0.1119959205,
0.0504736826,
0.0023984311,
0.0149321044,
-0.0968156159,
0.0466642193,
0.0018616064,
0.0231704842,
-0.0416284241,
0.0150739681,
-0.0281757116,
0.0287367292,
-0.021292448,
0.0081129884,
-0.0466040149,
-0.0244958922,
-0.0153886862,
0.0166453086,
0.0296878982,
0.0018986191,
-0.0011340331,
-0.0078032678,
-0.0253818315,
-0.0223519877,
-0.0066002328,
0.0631797016,
0.0092038102,
0.0614686683,
-0.0111278985,
-0.0183508694,
-0.0359314159,
0.0225658044,
0.0410640389,
-0.0562531874,
0.0471970625,
0.0454766378,
-0.0424788333,
-0.0177304186,
-0.0112463273,
0.0600753576,
-0.0134214675,
-0.0756540522,
-0.0104787415,
-0.0349262133,
0.0224274844,
-0.0187927857,
0.0404474139,
-0.0307660531,
-0.0129889641,
-0.009204396,
-0.0651312023,
0.0438034832,
0.0260893442,
-0.0247577932,
0.0000528944,
-0.0012203567,
0.0007320803,
0.075093329,
0.0177004263,
0.0366948359,
0.0009165189,
-0.0303005539,
-0.0438874662,
0.0324785449,
0.0214204844,
0.0398068614,
-0.0264257994,
0.004238301,
0.0371702947,
0.0018635156,
0.1012385637,
0.0131296348,
-0.0138766263,
-0.0301670339,
0.0865432024,
0.0598519966,
0.0650378168,
0.0242475718,
0.0083097164,
-0.0455066226,
0.0091791255,
-0.0171579029,
-0.0506698303,
0.0420844182,
-0.0412190147,
0.0192237999,
-0.0018589004,
0.0462757573,
-0.0367648005,
-0.0310035739,
-0.040976461,
0.0136174252,
-0.0114464303,
-0.0054789037,
-0.0068557197,
0.0081157731,
-0.031466458,
0.017004976,
0.0235996768,
-0.0401875153,
-0.0155604808,
-0.0382554419,
-0.0129671339,
0.040865425,
0.00551573,
-0.0138459699,
-0.0322942436,
-0.007467451,
0.041720096,
0.0238368474,
0.0093018711,
0.0319953151,
0.057865046,
-0.0675357357,
-0.0051649846,
0.011996598,
0.0176736414,
0.036994908,
-0.0133653628,
0.0237497315,
-0.014105727,
-0.0384497568,
-0.0272779148,
0.0352465063,
-0.0050354386,
-0.0169620626,
0.0523195378,
-0.0133060524,
0.0417888314,
-0.0203903317,
-0.0126198204,
-0.0232988484,
0.020023549,
-0.0293674506,
-0.0100037185,
0.0050044339,
-0.0081221862,
-0.0322711281,
-0.0087165469,
0.0093477098,
0.0261904038,
0.0740407333,
-0.0288380738,
-0.0469548218,
0.0360892378,
-0.0088720853,
0.0236238241,
-0.00641048,
0.0178670175,
0.0058119344,
0.0670074448,
-0.0346163884,
0.0466355756,
-0.0147364037,
0.0061732125,
0.0184354093,
0.0161023159,
0.0039719879,
-0.0697782487,
-0.0071492377,
0.0348788686,
0.0199252013,
0.0245343801,
-0.023709733,
0.0340588577,
-0.0116736507,
-0.0532724261,
-0.0571103916,
0.0459942631,
-0.0333076976,
0.0429112501,
0.0337849669,
0.0063809981,
-0.0096981227,
-0.0401269048,
-0.0214496031,
0.0065277852,
-0.0648741648,
0.0099091269,
0.0228881631,
0.023120448,
-0.0066619175,
-0.0712790117,
-0.0203501657,
0.0185704939,
0.0534743294,
-0.0542814396,
-0.0054924884,
-0.0374565572,
0.0274543781,
-0.0427502431,
0.0257233828,
-0.0133673605,
-0.0410998836,
-0.0299007632,
-0.0155753838,
0.0411302187,
0.064303644,
-0.0065749376,
-0.0307483971,
0.0781186894,
0.0540572479,
-0.0211271439,
0.0155504942,
-0.0158424787,
-0.008855612,
-0.0301830992,
0.0067206724,
-0.0204476099,
0.0269318875,
-0.0028817763,
0.0040048067,
-0.0597139858,
0.012611866,
-0.0055860798,
-0.0132502941,
-0.0565132052,
0.0443021953,
-0.005413211,
-0.0206628125,
-0.0430273227,
0.0021553235,
0.0534946658,
-0.0275488012,
-0.0451498963,
-0.0433336347,
-0.0434209406,
-0.0467147157,
0.0205809847,
0.017148165,
0.0334189236,
-0.0312737823,
-0.0263264216,
-0.0197522603,
0.0083555169,
0.0335839167,
0.0147794606,
0.0343481414,
-0.0440080427,
0.0385227874,
-0.0518776737,
-0.0525075309,
0.022997776,
-0.0115481373,
0.0089125521,
0.026974896,
0.0011722163,
-0.0531329997,
-0.0154657317,
-0.0009366454,
0.0165779926,
0.1081839576,
-0.0181454271,
0.0027602478,
-0.043856658,
0.0438027196,
0.0619349182,
0.0777626038,
0.014810116,
-0.0004573334,
0.0547984093,
0.0142293135,
0.090783298,
0.0057902513,
-0.0228288919,
0.0666547418,
0.0336194113,
-0.0007619731,
-0.0200222582,
0.0205159392,
0.0286495518,
-0.0194487907,
0.0133343553,
0.056462504,
-0.0038606108,
-0.0493056402,
0.0029262176,
-0.0234429855,
0.1313769221,
0.0469834544,
0.0301208906,
-0.0168469995,
-0.0265354514,
-0.0126976157,
0.0374115109,
0.0090231234,
-0.0297887493,
-0.0007521478,
-0.0914927125,
0.0289857481,
0.0110359583,
-0.0189564768,
0.0070048375,
-0.0560442545,
0.014308203,
-0.0339359529,
0.0346507095,
0.0047813221,
-0.0508788116,
-0.0226911195,
0.0508874245,
-0.0361505151,
-0.040442694,
-0.019386759,
-0.0093846405,
0.0520616099,
0.0083537046,
0.0217563547,
-0.0273922067,
-0.0375657082,
0.0205866322,
-0.0518936105,
-0.010574718,
-0.0296209268,
0.0324237309,
0.0302357171,
-0.0272713583,
0.0475010611,
0.0329181664,
-0.0134789068,
-0.0006913544,
-0.0148108862,
0.0253097061,
0.0340377688,
-0.0165189058,
0.0435604751,
-0.0272470154,
-0.0073333019,
0.0498496331,
0.018661933,
-0.0223745517,
-0.0064039757,
0.0037792183,
-0.0135848504,
-0.0186894126,
-0.0386080854,
0.0162877589,
-0.0263017789,
0.025115354,
-0.0452928618,
0.0126579246,
0.0176949222,
0.0605551675,
-0.0229553189,
0.0243505873,
-0.058500655,
0.0052468847,
-0.0131021934,
0.0331587791,
-0.0307769626,
-0.0151427547,
-0.040838968,
-0.0153972693,
0.0329048373,
-0.0007277853,
-0.0300116464,
0.0070201205,
-0.0524177179,
-0.0343019925,
-0.0175524801,
0.0395857729,
0.0221687034,
0.0415974148,
0.0065475032,
-0.0660710558,
0.0290362369,
0.0020452368,
0.0415234268,
0.0877167657,
0.049324017,
-0.0437969044,
-0.0098374207,
0.0278499443,
-0.0553692579,
0.0199958328,
0.0271612816,
0.034949258,
-0.0181101803,
-0.0339273438,
-0.0112722218,
0.0138907759,
-0.0220856741,
0.0142814852,
-0.048111219,
-0.0210362449,
0.070943065,
-0.0248401649,
0.0239873268,
-0.0365300141,
-0.0284671765,
0.0398730338,
0.0353782624,
-0.0205463246,
0.0223186947,
0.019272916,
0.0107030207,
-0.0680248365,
-0.0041834679,
0.0209037662,
0.0132849142,
0.0215827562,
0.0258152131,
-0.0452166721,
0.0369626842,
0.0277896672,
0.0354948975,
-0.0351334326,
-0.0106389616,
0.0015279439,
-0.0091337264,
-0.0634257719,
0.0650603548,
-0.0495690666,
-0.0540439226,
-0.0441235304,
-0.0178372711,
0.0500008129,
0.0159909874,
0.1163592264,
0.0190559123,
-0.0163669456,
0.0038252447,
-0.024262445,
0.0093188891,
0.0023719228,
0.0077512073,
0.0161488745,
0.0005198615,
0.0490583889,
0.052123826,
0.0928343311,
0.0708427876,
-0.0247275606,
0.0261778329,
-0.0390249118,
-0.0200136509,
0.0023679854,
0.0017951132,
0.0015718776,
-0.0225360021,
0.0111382026,
-0.0621936209,
0.0113026593,
-0.0159197915,
0.005943947,
-0.0236141291,
0.0007335345,
0.0156325344,
-0.0116633531,
-0.0320448168,
-0.0095832963,
-0.0864591673,
0.062015295,
-0.0313929617,
-0.0150121842,
-6.789385741e-33,
-0.0188137386,
0.0456163995,
-0.0064175115,
0.0050423178,
-0.0001892219,
0.0086100576,
-0.0208476074,
0.0198195037,
-0.0236206483,
-0.013346483,
-0.0125247194,
-0.0169675909,
0.0186348781,
0.0075730216,
-0.0193279199,
-0.0008718203,
0.0409526005,
-0.007470557,
-0.0296761394,
-0.0060606734,
0.0073609012,
0.0280404557,
0.0158152115,
-0.0213942099,
-0.0322936028,
0.0187486168,
-0.0621344149,
-0.0114254719,
-0.0039955857,
0.0398704074,
-0.0432153866,
0.0311333574,
0.0092427088,
-0.0198144205,
-0.0362274647,
-0.0076160431,
-0.0856890827,
-0.026497148,
0.0184203386,
-0.0246329401,
-0.0179934222,
-0.0220667422,
0.0575234331,
0.0220294669,
-0.0196644273,
-0.0165959299,
0.0173684601,
-0.0196353812,
-0.0328133032,
-0.0138228042,
-0.0675575659,
0.0067241676,
-0.0117945056,
0.0095692677,
0.0160447974,
0.0269331113,
-0.0065296544,
0.0081651825,
-0.0661460012,
-0.0324303135,
-0.0122850612,
0.084189862,
0.0092429901,
0.0104216663,
-0.0613886565,
0.0164920148,
-0.0154521419,
-0.0082140081,
0.0345109515,
-0.022079017,
0.0565359965,
0.0080378745,
0.0713881701,
0.0113205481,
0.0105873533,
-0.0219792947,
-0.096266076,
0.004114653,
0.0247429498,
-0.0079790121,
0.0107100466,
0.0623333305,
-0.0242832825,
-0.0051277084,
-0.0392812528,
-0.0095660873,
-0.0649144575,
-0.0038377463,
0.0458199084,
0.0471632592,
-0.024692269,
-0.0094639948,
0.0200058911,
-0.0107442467,
0.0063343691,
-0.02386792,
-0.0054387734,
0.0287373755,
0.0212336518,
0.0238914266,
-0.0442310013,
-0.0511047244,
0.0568962581,
0.0299935564,
0.0329010412,
-0.0568414368,
0.0652910247,
0.050982669,
-0.0738550946,
-0.016470788,
-0.0064048464,
0.0410018861,
-0.0037544735,
0.0521932468,
-0.0289693344,
-0.0521031991,
0.0080413939,
0.0271325018,
-0.0018804736,
-0.0024845479,
-0.0357907638,
-0.0075285267,
0.0177386198,
0.0418982655,
-0.0260978844,
0.0054820967,
0.0020242464,
0.0008494104,
0.0337573625,
-0.0576224886,
-0.0097828554,
0.0309465788,
2.75e-7,
0.0083674798,
0.039331153,
-0.0340488739,
-0.0817375779,
0.0222772639,
0.0027038725,
-0.0437714495,
0.0562039129,
0.0131021747,
0.0098617394,
-0.0069934423,
0.0051494408,
0.0504896864,
-0.0084853033,
-0.0319372676,
-0.0580256693,
-0.0892311707,
0.011579657,
-0.0504835248,
-0.0717278123,
-0.0207989849,
0.1146446615,
0.0032734042,
-0.0174539257,
0.0077615827,
-0.0239096358,
0.0579725355,
-0.0105588725,
0.01237664,
-0.0187232383,
0.0577262975,
0.0046451367,
-0.0189723279,
-0.0076336404,
-0.0071592759,
0.0577829368,
0.0126970746,
0.0732000172,
-0.0366463624,
-0.0270137377,
0.0287495647,
0.0641072989,
0.02018377,
-0.0573354363,
0.0910271034,
-0.0238562878,
-0.007043554,
-0.0009982364,
-0.0024165427,
0.001161532,
0.0199540686,
-0.0267961957,
-0.0045701857,
0.0354160778,
0.0501314513,
0.0029837356,
-0.0431433655,
-0.1008273587,
-0.009385678,
0.000079312,
-0.0361338221,
-0.0514995046,
-0.0583972409,
-0.0357353203,
0.0318969786,
-0.0879923031,
-0.0125994356,
2.633956824e-34,
0.0116980821,
-0.0126231471,
0.0333930515,
0.0215609912,
0.0131937955,
-0.000851154,
-0.0019275243,
-0.0081908824,
0.0147005264,
-0.1138934791,
-0.0183760524
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09576v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09576v1 | Work State-Centric AI Agents: Design, Implementation, and Management of Cognitive Work Threads | 2023-11-16T05:21:25 | 2023-11-16T05:21:25 | Chen Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | AI agents excel in executing predefined tasks, but the dynamic management of
work state information during task execution remains an underexplored area. We
propose a work state-centric AI agent model employing "work notes" to record
and reflect the state throughout task execution. This paper details the model's
architecture, featuring worker threads for task oversight, planner modules for
task decomposition and planning, and executor modules for performing subtasks
using a ReAct-inspired thought-action loop. We provide an exhaustive work state
record incorporating plans and outcomes, constituting a comprehensive work
journal. Our results show that this model not only improves task execution
efficiency but also lays a solid foundation for subsequent task analysis and
auditing. | [
-0.0071061184,
0.0201044977,
-0.0396496765,
-0.0480747372,
-0.0530436151,
-0.0204955563,
0.0263288952,
0.0058872248,
0.0529362634,
0.001241071,
0.0074108704,
0.0238758493,
-0.0052281264,
0.0514774099,
0.0157895703,
-0.0462081023,
0.0198345855,
-0.0088846516,
-0.0029296889,
0.0370358191,
0.0272398368,
-0.0156703051,
-0.0332220607,
0.0711026192,
-0.0408298075,
-0.0555552579,
-0.0630724654,
-0.021377489,
0.0495264903,
-0.0124985157,
-0.0265173018,
0.0214106049,
-0.0003431235,
0.0139094442,
0.0000022093,
-0.0298207179,
0.0380086452,
-0.0069540311,
-0.0104052192,
-0.0688092038,
-0.0324687175,
0.0037602563,
-0.0060239178,
0.051945094,
0.0039260718,
-0.0100215115,
0.0441686623,
0.0514745936,
0.0262201987,
0.0134950234,
-0.0133328559,
0.0774670541,
0.0123927072,
0.0150458934,
-0.0050895945,
-0.0737642869,
0.0172776598,
-0.0023444288,
0.0095458385,
-0.0612360649,
0.010539745,
-0.0262835138,
0.0278589837,
-0.0232352335,
-0.0419771411,
0.0065017221,
0.0661779121,
-0.0458163023,
-0.0265664775,
0.0230503101,
0.0112235509,
0.0145524815,
0.0212441776,
-0.0106977727,
-0.0130178109,
0.0033100927,
-0.0092005646,
0.0484233648,
-0.0687070936,
-0.0274168514,
0.0573439039,
0.0455225967,
-0.0143482136,
-0.0227087568,
0.0110027632,
0.0092897266,
-0.0185201224,
-0.0131484009,
-0.0122763431,
0.0180883911,
0.0570593141,
-0.061578311,
0.0561850406,
0.0529120974,
-0.0435329862,
-0.0156978257,
-0.0152480891,
-0.0790289193,
-0.023742022,
-0.0230525751,
0.0638826489,
0.0552559718,
-0.0079907998,
0.0144951427,
0.0530323163,
0.0592294261,
-0.008280878,
-0.0191263072,
-0.0340015218,
-0.0285380278,
-0.0937777758,
0.0349615477,
-0.0440890193,
0.0375867672,
-0.0197051279,
-0.0104477499,
-0.0117717786,
0.0601624995,
-0.0579747297,
0.0276873056,
0.011505316,
0.0209533703,
-0.0180337802,
0.0036779023,
-0.0566936359,
-0.0200224705,
-0.0143624786,
0.0212433673,
0.0103059206,
0.0499507561,
-0.0076612551,
-0.0061297938,
0.0193533041,
0.0337719247,
-0.0292690974,
-0.0192981008,
0.0273318887,
-0.0139045883,
-0.0220965724,
-0.0528714061,
0.0491476394,
-0.030948678,
-0.0221821051,
-0.0048192469,
0.0513306782,
-0.03349806,
-0.0592601821,
-0.0022956962,
-0.0164219309,
0.0250218492,
0.0621759333,
0.0170342084,
-0.0193062127,
-0.0137926629,
-0.0376499705,
0.0266868137,
-0.036686115,
0.0114616575,
0.0268956013,
0.071581535,
-0.0003280278,
0.0601136833,
0.0949550495,
0.0327789262,
-0.0347739011,
-0.0276312213,
0.048200205,
0.0036631553,
0.0033355306,
0.0042043058,
-0.005960797,
0.005613415,
0.0041830693,
0.079732962,
0.0383165777,
0.0485974476,
-0.0336559638,
0.0177358463,
-0.0059783119,
0.0209977459,
0.0108114202,
-0.0311105512,
-0.0258338097,
0.0854341537,
0.0039076763,
-0.0329556875,
-0.0549771227,
-0.0218472462,
-0.0309515037,
-0.0407357849,
0.0000739035,
-0.0430393443,
0.0013548989,
0.0066071926,
0.0048086788,
-0.0215988588,
-0.0816019103,
-0.0364713073,
-0.0573082082,
-0.0277091153,
-0.0245650019,
-0.079273127,
0.0631682053,
0.1106412709,
0.0587349534,
-0.0614038855,
-0.0439049974,
0.0140884425,
0.0069526285,
-0.0097220382,
0.0094361231,
-0.0286753774,
0.0047864169,
-0.0103727849,
-0.0496237837,
-0.0279800501,
0.0156291705,
0.0003394019,
-0.0475121997,
0.0176348127,
-0.0500210971,
0.039662376,
-0.012213937,
-0.0035342567,
0.0388833694,
-0.0064948546,
-0.0177961253,
0.0254577883,
0.0270338953,
0.0349361338,
0.0246052742,
0.0148215378,
0.0214997232,
-0.0028839814,
-0.0175832286,
0.0457325317,
-0.0016625908,
0.0067363242,
-0.0038725005,
0.0066380021,
0.0212293975,
0.0364027098,
-0.00121485,
-0.0449072123,
-0.0122313146,
-0.0093256487,
-0.0047617652,
0.0030757738,
0.0151597839,
0.0039234073,
-0.0302297883,
0.0288916752,
0.0050064023,
-0.0051460918,
-0.0511533059,
-0.0182574317,
-0.0048947693,
0.0058551272,
-0.0024747367,
0.042969767,
0.0126448404,
0.0188806616,
0.036085669,
0.0178034194,
-0.0073827961,
-0.0059119384,
-0.0159413517,
-0.0814015642,
-0.0192476679,
-0.0456088595,
-0.0227061585,
-0.0063704955,
0.0204366092,
-0.0096484143,
-0.0283952672,
-0.0015622523,
0.0562772639,
0.0200757701,
-0.0091849612,
0.0100764716,
0.0180787724,
-0.0215902198,
-0.0394844189,
0.0386752859,
-0.0121397618,
-0.0307865404,
0.0029924666,
-0.0460521691,
-0.0805250257,
0.0537429452,
0.0069601876,
0.0268561672,
-0.0094176065,
0.0051675937,
0.0192819275,
-0.0151962368,
0.0688902214,
0.0301704276,
-0.0701381862,
0.0487098135,
0.0751491636,
-0.0332441553,
-0.0125996945,
0.0343952626,
0.0079010967,
0.0416591726,
-0.0131292483,
0.0184744298,
0.0064291279,
0.0309230816,
-0.0082460418,
0.0179147664,
-0.0270233098,
0.0101192035,
-0.0071718157,
0.0163703058,
0.0156212244,
-0.0315637887,
-0.0557809733,
0.0462859757,
-0.0237469152,
-0.028362859,
0.0232498012,
0.0319072753,
0.0067494772,
-0.0178549606,
-0.0519951098,
-0.0163176376,
0.1166429967,
0.0009859119,
-0.0158652309,
-0.0080752671,
0.0167728812,
-0.0204221439,
0.0108636552,
-0.0342404954,
-0.0082471678,
-0.0097655561,
-0.0206110664,
-0.0210352819,
-0.0333474167,
-0.0187682714,
-0.0437830724,
0.0467871986,
-0.0645750985,
0.0251625739,
0.0062402501,
-0.0119206384,
-0.034676142,
-0.0081007928,
0.0493895113,
0.0542484,
0.0243094768,
-0.0244739503,
-0.0046212804,
-0.0533031113,
0.0278162211,
0.0116178105,
-0.0400736593,
-0.0063991603,
0.0339635834,
0.0536728539,
0.0766238868,
-0.0313634835,
0.008782858,
-0.0671996921,
0.029132884,
-0.009968074,
0.0052005341,
0.0205598194,
0.062318556,
-0.0309032984,
-0.0105022928,
0.0591916852,
0.0392097086,
-0.0869048238,
0.0138688618,
-0.014252726,
-0.0632908121,
0.0348673649,
0.0726194084,
-0.0123087252,
0.0022115698,
0.0116305137,
-0.0005822041,
-0.0154404789,
-0.0619627126,
-0.0026442211,
-0.0096011516,
0.0416129231,
-0.0592129491,
0.03576703,
0.0230191089,
-0.0116258999,
0.0367558785,
0.0177704822,
-0.0673322156,
-0.0061305705,
0.0672208816,
-0.035618566,
0.0219950527,
-0.0155184735,
0.0365767963,
0.0112729548,
-0.0587644875,
-0.0047489456,
0.0489969738,
0.0353001393,
0.0064535681,
-0.0357616208,
-0.0334190652,
0.0270850118,
0.0382615626,
-0.0121868784,
-0.0049444628,
-0.0063689388,
0.0055586374,
-0.0365226343,
-0.0128314439,
-0.0355164632,
-0.0288510974,
0.0671187192,
0.1048565283,
-0.0757403746,
0.0030348569,
-0.0400536098,
-0.0465510041,
0.0461360067,
0.0439756811,
-0.0366102941,
-0.0479752161,
-0.0475271605,
0.0088809999,
0.0013274775,
-0.1105775982,
0.0239538178,
-0.0633423999,
0.0091652088,
0.0567614287,
-0.059344314,
-0.0839800462,
0.0731624141,
0.0311723184,
0.0190158226,
-0.0733037665,
0.0445432365,
0.0354312286,
-0.0358677842,
-0.0364834294,
0.0025900376,
0.0301639531,
0.025484696,
-0.0746665597,
0.0071608657,
-0.0004726259,
0.0271608289,
0.0281543452,
-0.0782690421,
0.0593452044,
-0.0027949142,
0.0658419505,
0.0082744714,
-0.0394026637,
-0.0203608349,
0.0074759899,
-0.0313294455,
-0.0304336883,
-0.0593126826,
0.0120570706,
0.0344975814,
0.0083907004,
-0.0137489634,
0.0116867283,
-0.0820816308,
-0.0097939949,
-0.0219344627,
0.0229840744,
0.0006782957,
-0.0370563194,
-0.0011665433,
-0.0120818121,
-0.0636900961,
-0.0171630476,
0.0220042579,
-0.0243925098,
0.0136423092,
0.0032033599,
0.0175342727,
-0.0554474443,
0.044771906,
-0.0536638908,
-0.0214802511,
0.028255336,
0.0698935241,
0.0058322386,
-0.0290067401,
-0.0317775048,
0.0045233569,
-0.0374311805,
0.026605878,
-0.0053335647,
0.0396733582,
-0.0260894503,
-0.0224250965,
0.0274602026,
0.0165125169,
0.002147011,
0.0520241745,
-0.0107964082,
0.0011674243,
-0.0695908144,
0.0624342971,
-0.0594837628,
-0.039191477,
0.077451691,
0.0409044623,
0.0514886901,
0.0333982371,
-0.0043284651,
-0.0673852563,
0.0382076763,
-0.0027227071,
0.0438800417,
-0.013233046,
0.0129606146,
-0.0505702794,
0.0261969995,
0.0044172197,
-0.0238186643,
0.0344008617,
-0.0204210542,
0.0605403781,
-0.0379249975,
-0.0626402944,
-0.0539166704,
-0.034201216,
-0.0246855728,
0.0462740324,
-0.0096935099,
-0.0408494473,
-0.0729326531,
-0.0182952136,
0.0637514368,
0.0102878101,
-0.0114839291,
-0.0418822356,
0.0153633431,
0.0059544193,
0.0266009923,
-0.0160182845,
0.002543286,
-0.0451744944,
-0.0106030442,
0.0063698166,
-0.0119777145,
-5.278420364e-33,
0.0250069443,
-0.0439562127,
0.0795895234,
0.020762315,
0.0106089963,
-0.002128165,
-0.0603941157,
-0.0170111507,
0.0288874544,
0.0107775042,
-0.0433177128,
0.0384695418,
0.020042697,
-0.0445736758,
0.0349869169,
0.0335229859,
0.0601450726,
-0.009371304,
0.0001593518,
0.0272484552,
0.0403076522,
0.0038121382,
0.0458262339,
-0.0196375139,
0.0038521553,
0.0184308346,
-0.0055202805,
0.0176197942,
-0.022266496,
0.0139400512,
-0.0359390937,
0.0390211642,
0.0171406288,
0.0091838017,
0.0116129974,
0.0178861469,
-0.0366646238,
-0.0664946884,
0.0098766107,
-0.0239623021,
-0.0491703004,
-0.01238879,
-0.0258604083,
0.0610521697,
-0.045395676,
0.0461228564,
0.0104815224,
0.0127233854,
0.0022972811,
0.0133822663,
-0.0579251237,
-0.0183796473,
0.0143880527,
-0.0493593924,
0.0247172378,
0.0365542583,
0.0208838563,
-0.082797423,
-0.0985395685,
0.0024538259,
-0.0688424036,
-0.0379865877,
0.0398195013,
0.0230187625,
-0.0061282506,
0.0358407982,
0.0259000435,
0.0821872726,
-0.0719110891,
0.0563717596,
-0.0045693018,
0.0497582853,
0.0208733939,
-0.0143326148,
-0.0361825712,
-0.0144515829,
-0.0244901106,
0.0553678945,
0.0614378303,
0.0458398573,
0.0322242118,
0.0054413299,
-0.0459179133,
-0.0181196574,
0.0127101634,
0.0351395831,
0.0129763307,
0.0340154879,
0.0006922812,
0.0350781269,
0.002046101,
-0.0040299781,
0.0083992686,
0.0045863441,
0.0799308196,
0.0084851328,
0.0008300327,
0.0189406015,
0.0129373521,
-0.0427661873,
-0.039222274,
0.0155092971,
-0.043978475,
0.0602471381,
0.0540083237,
0.0280810725,
-0.0028032861,
0.0413131453,
-0.0146322483,
-0.0026258084,
-0.0742042661,
0.0462453589,
0.0018852452,
-0.0376029536,
0.0035849554,
0.014870367,
-0.0006874084,
0.030463364,
0.0023076714,
-0.0476251207,
-0.0170300938,
0.0378646143,
0.004888026,
-0.0138001833,
-0.0019170061,
-0.0388687886,
-0.0367668308,
0.0421339534,
0.0116496608,
-0.0500115193,
-0.0066036382,
0.0199992135,
2.876e-7,
-0.0691863224,
0.0060874242,
-0.0057488843,
0.029915249,
0.0529667325,
0.0375789031,
-0.0175840538,
-0.0319344588,
-0.0315780193,
-0.0177326836,
0.0282853637,
0.010864744,
0.0468000025,
0.0356725715,
-0.0459878519,
-0.0375742652,
0.0280702543,
0.0130188996,
-0.050812114,
0.0340234339,
0.0061514475,
0.0004867597,
0.0635150746,
-0.0221636519,
0.0280804299,
0.0045448551,
0.0007391472,
0.0505307205,
0.0121037792,
-0.0368297659,
-0.0185605101,
0.0109819602,
-0.0027348876,
0.0041680811,
0.0117094237,
-0.0024984065,
-0.0502986684,
0.0705407038,
-0.0033054792,
-0.0084977839,
-0.0259165876,
-0.027661331,
-0.0076385397,
0.0282326136,
0.0117036048,
-0.0012103292,
-0.0099314852,
0.0254491903,
0.0301940963,
-0.0013855299,
-0.0256681349,
0.0333227627,
0.0435308926,
-0.0084898164,
-0.0311391354,
-0.0206226036,
-0.018406529,
-0.0016146534,
0.0369433165,
-0.0272295401,
-0.0202569384,
-0.0356530398,
-0.0272249263,
-0.0259845499,
-0.0100603132,
-0.0518507175,
0.0078696562,
2.151097494e-34,
-0.050807979,
0.0147491992,
-0.0216554664,
0.0403645448,
-0.0035296038,
0.0156297497,
-0.026894765,
0.0078216735,
0.0709252283,
-0.028958898,
-0.0538258962
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09569v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09569v2 | Strings from the Library of Babel: Random Sampling as a Strong Baseline for Prompt Optimisation | 2023-11-16T05:08:33 | 2024-04-17T06:00:51 | Yao Lu, Jiayi Wang, Raphael Tang, Sebastian Riedel, Pontus Stenetorp | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recent prompt optimisation approaches use the generative nature of language
models to produce prompts -- even rivaling the performance of human-curated
prompts. In this paper, we demonstrate that randomly sampling tokens from the
model vocabulary as ``separators'' can be as effective as language models for
prompt-style text classification. Our experiments show that random separators
are competitive baselines, having less than a 1% difference compared to
previous self-optimisation methods and showing a 12% average relative
improvement over strong human baselines across nine text classification tasks
and eight language models. We further analyse this phenomenon in detail using
three different random generation strategies, establishing that the language
space is rich with potentially good separators, with a greater than 40% average
chance that a randomly drawn separator performs better than human-curated
separators. These observations challenge the common assumption that an
effective prompt should be human readable or task relevant and establish a
strong baseline for prompt optimisation research. | [
0.0706325695,
0.0277076084,
-0.014604087,
0.0058908821,
-0.0535589606,
-0.002094523,
0.0792500377,
0.0397968926,
0.0321575627,
-0.0455857702,
0.000759641,
-0.0500912592,
-0.0150767453,
0.0077659157,
0.0112903453,
-0.083574228,
0.0531440042,
-0.0511272922,
0.0316702835,
-0.0048887348,
-0.0271583796,
-0.0051977583,
0.0082866475,
0.0174628664,
-0.0102996742,
-0.0253736116,
-0.0118725682,
0.0042584604,
-0.0193880517,
-0.0302630104,
0.0127877593,
0.0911542848,
-0.0473515093,
0.0506710298,
0.0000018425,
-0.0884378776,
-0.0114351623,
-0.0326096974,
-0.0451563112,
0.0102588888,
0.0364738256,
0.0219483562,
-0.0044909883,
0.0286182426,
-0.0099381311,
0.004967039,
0.0166781899,
0.0101691978,
0.0092361346,
0.0610341057,
0.007946373,
0.041336745,
0.0041728737,
-0.0267681275,
0.0231735799,
0.0191325322,
-0.0013013305,
-0.0737031102,
0.0015079842,
0.0617572628,
0.0016218459,
0.0267843958,
0.0213604383,
-0.0241831839,
0.0321592689,
0.0575862564,
-0.0321108066,
-0.0447434634,
-0.047520835,
0.0229478311,
-0.041270759,
-0.0246798322,
0.006390525,
-0.0388393514,
0.0458159968,
0.0141409142,
-0.0143271461,
0.0528229252,
-0.0423221737,
0.0019588987,
0.0290041864,
0.0246545505,
0.0104272217,
-0.0044818809,
-0.0182118248,
0.0392105579,
0.019873241,
-0.0579378121,
0.039420411,
0.0172160193,
-0.0191039406,
-0.0910282284,
0.0106026102,
-0.0097449226,
-0.0343546048,
0.0087205479,
-0.0704078153,
-0.0199051816,
0.0423666053,
0.0068444829,
0.0109457914,
0.023526758,
-0.0029847575,
0.016139416,
-0.0176651496,
0.0400097556,
0.019426439,
0.0228114668,
-0.0181903224,
0.0164555125,
-0.0409822166,
-0.0365570597,
-0.0430572703,
0.0263429433,
-0.0338842385,
-0.0183324423,
-0.0401007198,
0.0256424621,
0.015423975,
-0.0289807152,
0.0086799702,
-0.0071060113,
-0.0013736741,
0.0273787808,
-0.0178513154,
-0.0583638176,
-0.0512827821,
-0.0082942089,
0.023459617,
-0.0782969072,
-0.0075029307,
0.0093639018,
0.0041630552,
-0.0405560099,
0.0038806302,
0.034207616,
-0.0428076982,
-0.0616243221,
-0.009627793,
-0.032513056,
-0.0391084328,
0.007402163,
-0.0168852042,
-0.0519111864,
-0.0032130668,
0.0198023133,
0.0019370993,
-0.0347365811,
-0.0091389865,
0.0271729734,
-0.0276408661,
0.0600319505,
-0.0405235961,
-0.0108080544,
0.0601918697,
-0.0147644216,
-0.0048135673,
0.0365580656,
-0.0137204984,
0.069157429,
0.0776678994,
-0.0015585106,
0.038286984,
0.0685816929,
-0.0205303635,
-0.0357221775,
-0.0159226898,
-0.0339664444,
0.0463220589,
0.0179851111,
0.0193913933,
0.0445658639,
-0.0110372799,
0.0278824884,
0.0237920154,
0.0945218354,
0.0166232865,
-0.0092932498,
0.0464418679,
0.02549522,
0.000218874,
0.0449095294,
-0.0316997245,
-0.0474365167,
-0.0114011886,
0.0102647804,
0.0388147868,
0.0131986607,
0.000469488,
-0.0405064821,
-0.0087071508,
-0.0195956342,
-0.0166926961,
-0.0004669149,
0.0270218719,
0.0161197167,
-0.0307110995,
0.0224688854,
0.0370975919,
-0.0478309654,
0.0073472117,
-0.046680782,
0.0493639559,
0.058648169,
0.0171544012,
-0.0235431809,
0.0226466637,
-0.0174189098,
0.0384260118,
0.0559702478,
0.0592126399,
-0.0220191553,
-0.0051310156,
-0.0337171741,
-0.0228121225,
0.0318881385,
-0.0037096466,
0.0481555425,
0.0057870983,
0.0186928362,
0.0207587294,
0.0164420828,
-0.0389928333,
0.0642623305,
-0.0264793132,
-0.0519953519,
0.0398053601,
0.0191121586,
0.0046707634,
0.023158377,
-0.0270433314,
0.0050257621,
0.006336337,
-0.0313364901,
0.0243192986,
-0.0370079055,
-0.0459570475,
-0.0270342678,
0.0146502974,
0.0303877369,
-0.0073922719,
0.0014174138,
-0.0110673672,
-0.0394479297,
-0.0547622778,
0.0029487915,
-0.0038112088,
-0.0490686782,
0.0285746623,
0.0023734572,
0.0211190246,
-0.0645968467,
0.0666697323,
0.0376052186,
0.0534324348,
0.0205760784,
0.0280250497,
0.0443677604,
-0.0759554207,
-0.0013204546,
0.0196589436,
-0.0187208746,
0.0066333958,
0.0620888956,
0.0330431424,
-0.0309604909,
-0.0457902253,
-0.0865797028,
-0.0033020801,
-0.0264678113,
0.0021823545,
0.0036606791,
-0.0015185716,
-0.0552072041,
-0.0247408636,
-0.0195866022,
-0.0419034027,
0.0200156048,
0.0272600837,
0.0617309175,
-0.0136705451,
-0.0074732038,
-0.0145752924,
-0.0162077378,
-0.0063272342,
0.046388112,
0.0404030904,
-0.0422833785,
-0.0546898097,
0.0165771395,
0.0233162958,
0.0052245362,
0.0217628274,
-0.0137624657,
0.0128036579,
-0.0177236889,
0.0618515573,
0.0639170036,
0.0450285412,
0.009624471,
0.0026985395,
0.0308819376,
-0.0611477308,
0.0008350502,
0.0006221989,
0.024070777,
0.0045683328,
-0.0443573706,
0.073739931,
0.0684028566,
0.0077803144,
0.0003504538,
-0.0549605377,
0.0509150885,
-0.0155997938,
-0.0568313375,
-0.0820966586,
-0.0093725659,
-0.0616247393,
0.0667971149,
-0.0048500481,
-0.0605860204,
0.046947632,
-0.0492162257,
0.0096351458,
-0.0553449616,
-0.0158868879,
-0.0117675159,
0.0347384401,
0.0055491934,
0.0050813304,
0.0510286726,
-0.053437762,
-0.0205974858,
0.0156653505,
0.0063126232,
0.0040496527,
-0.0015279416,
-0.0336543508,
0.0005946797,
-0.0095603969,
-0.0418999419,
-0.0691835284,
-0.0882502496,
-0.0072449856,
0.0006099483,
0.0384847522,
0.013876575,
0.0064047663,
0.0115586631,
-0.0092211897,
0.0599143431,
-0.0343067907,
-0.0084512476,
-0.0090323081,
0.058704298,
0.0211375561,
-0.0192706026,
-0.0087045655,
-0.0248930287,
0.0256701037,
0.0106360493,
0.0297202691,
-0.0007041119,
0.0214826949,
0.0038958688,
0.0399234705,
-0.0740744323,
-0.0518250316,
0.0428690724,
0.0355217196,
-0.0318177268,
-0.0236182008,
0.1426048577,
0.0583504736,
-0.0478198752,
-0.0284479558,
-0.0203624964,
0.0330584124,
0.016759282,
0.0227458887,
-0.0219063703,
-0.0231367107,
0.0055706738,
0.0508885607,
-0.0256145429,
-0.0191659722,
-0.0066031166,
-0.1238251105,
0.0357418433,
-0.0208185501,
-0.0497189425,
0.0133062545,
-0.0394209623,
-0.0161687229,
0.0135300439,
0.0052963663,
-0.0021190573,
-0.023310231,
0.0284022596,
0.0554068349,
-0.0398826487,
-0.0148049025,
-0.0203691907,
-0.0293780956,
0.025359245,
0.0751402751,
0.0154532408,
-0.0190393794,
-0.0288934298,
0.0387388654,
-0.0450129472,
0.007040563,
-0.0190356895,
0.0319391787,
0.0261294413,
0.0009354893,
0.0105388109,
0.0106367767,
-0.0011479369,
-0.0440676138,
0.0506973825,
0.0430056117,
0.0137195848,
-0.010163608,
-0.0066217263,
-0.0092405248,
0.0352351069,
0.098727107,
0.029326532,
-0.0791462436,
-0.0408883132,
-0.0535477921,
0.0459644794,
-0.0680714548,
-0.0101839975,
0.0027572934,
-0.0319032706,
-0.0410153493,
-0.0721092075,
-0.0717301741,
0.0313745476,
0.0802323222,
0.0114050098,
0.013086508,
-0.0598279648,
0.0131720016,
0.0182669666,
0.0271071233,
-0.0229366161,
-0.0184514876,
-0.1075941473,
-0.0123578701,
-0.0189425293,
-0.0519488156,
-0.0346683115,
0.0095488587,
-0.0098717883,
-0.0535340384,
0.0283247735,
0.0491858199,
0.0245320536,
0.0170442592,
-0.0073693036,
-0.0601321384,
0.057575684,
0.0704772621,
-0.0210401807,
-0.0110784061,
0.0041626627,
0.0051057385,
-0.0401628464,
-0.0085530421,
-0.018592326,
0.0174515173,
0.027376093,
0.0003178134,
0.0001230599,
-0.0575175285,
0.0111937085,
0.0365317985,
0.0765012801,
-0.0810969621,
-0.0321709216,
-0.0380744971,
0.00527647,
0.0190967098,
-0.0036762629,
0.000113825,
0.0100167533,
0.0126176905,
-0.0389150083,
-0.0117497351,
0.0228804462,
-0.0375148654,
0.0603521131,
-0.0328244157,
-0.0342528485,
0.0144677358,
0.0506339185,
0.0304316301,
-0.0023845027,
0.0002109829,
0.0191620961,
0.0339536183,
0.0451463126,
-0.0177013092,
0.0439041555,
0.0090200882,
0.0012833169,
-0.0098864799,
0.0212611277,
-0.0756827369,
-0.0391504243,
0.0029168851,
0.0532942005,
0.0279813465,
-0.0247090943,
-0.0070346855,
-0.0165391881,
-0.0199213903,
-0.0255748443,
-0.0169939436,
0.0543562807,
-0.0070382408,
-0.0097004268,
0.0028107816,
-0.0518288501,
-0.0471096225,
0.0802214816,
-0.0062896316,
-0.0046743737,
0.0258887168,
-0.018616166,
-0.0584802404,
0.036305137,
0.020245716,
0.0052238344,
-0.0038009158,
0.0056115123,
-0.062883094,
-0.0073484955,
0.0569376498,
0.0218819305,
0.0141576435,
0.0152856288,
0.0464340039,
0.0859801769,
-0.0250416771,
0.0307697915,
-0.0364826806,
0.0377569124,
0.0144104343,
-0.0435414724,
-0.0398778133,
-5.484076039e-33,
-0.0246798508,
-0.0079435613,
-0.0252415482,
-0.0083944974,
0.0338906646,
-0.0134168118,
-0.0253150836,
0.0080976561,
0.0265874751,
0.0050961226,
-0.0646071732,
-0.0518409535,
0.0350035019,
0.0295109879,
0.0271595009,
-0.0124335457,
0.057087861,
-0.0040963893,
-0.0540613458,
0.0069378829,
0.0356901437,
0.0431607589,
-0.0208027754,
0.0099032531,
0.0397561304,
-0.034906853,
0.0242234152,
0.0174619146,
0.0491789877,
0.0470231436,
-0.0151986908,
0.0386370383,
0.0239676628,
-0.0475099273,
-0.0155537091,
0.0955350325,
-0.0748726502,
-0.064917013,
0.0101836827,
-0.0171486102,
-0.0200099777,
-0.0803992972,
-0.0133496979,
-0.0233545583,
-0.0304952469,
0.0473405905,
0.0471278206,
-0.0021777696,
-0.0505977906,
-0.038915325,
-0.0343208387,
0.0030918212,
0.0002669142,
-0.0077965264,
0.0419125482,
0.034512639,
0.0296766572,
0.0132579552,
0.0006975746,
0.036997471,
0.0241677575,
0.0410779677,
0.030463744,
0.0382727683,
-0.0339997038,
0.0467800722,
0.0498465672,
0.0044679842,
0.0212910902,
-0.0017284821,
-0.0002641657,
-0.0335002877,
0.0188974012,
0.0541400388,
0.045074068,
-0.0294640213,
-0.0386265032,
0.0570014231,
0.0513767004,
-0.0617697649,
0.0159779787,
-0.0168658402,
-0.0325250067,
-0.0374899954,
-0.0109322602,
-0.0393395834,
-0.0100602256,
-0.0244785044,
0.0434224755,
0.0012365992,
-0.0244798101,
-0.0414551124,
0.045240555,
0.0157044772,
-0.0443953834,
0.0028411341,
-0.0096857389,
0.0214571562,
-0.0126240384,
-0.0058215652,
-0.0210243035,
-0.0154604092,
0.0177770909,
0.0041851285,
0.0071977815,
0.0150734959,
0.0322765671,
-0.0223850589,
-0.0902752951,
0.0233357158,
-0.0060399077,
0.0713656098,
0.0021226706,
0.0456728004,
0.033901345,
0.0125229564,
0.0050434419,
0.036933247,
0.0359226651,
-0.034638349,
-0.0296634231,
0.0105789583,
-0.0401883349,
0.0104235839,
-0.0180162098,
0.0007608605,
-0.0276074316,
0.0731296092,
0.0083283074,
-0.0174935013,
0.0110718599,
-0.0044618291,
2.353e-7,
0.038034495,
0.0567166544,
0.0386943482,
-0.00848943,
-0.0062594116,
0.0242719296,
-0.00118274,
0.0063845706,
0.0022719472,
-0.0114045246,
-0.0282644108,
-0.0216535404,
0.0229097139,
0.0080857296,
-0.1274693906,
-0.0045200973,
-0.059831392,
0.04533742,
-0.0591669381,
0.0200713798,
0.0554383993,
0.0628327727,
0.0121556781,
-0.0291066915,
-0.032295987,
-0.0430487767,
-0.0074019502,
-0.0464538746,
-0.0065221069,
0.0371180028,
0.0658284202,
-0.0345421024,
0.0043810215,
0.0363757126,
-0.0186988339,
-0.0055651553,
0.018554667,
0.0267743729,
0.024747353,
0.0040302537,
0.0003472111,
0.0077657821,
0.017482264,
-0.0438980274,
0.0659819022,
0.007245678,
0.0373734497,
-0.0138821723,
-0.0010383105,
-0.0293842945,
0.0203112364,
-0.0339199565,
-0.0131509313,
0.0376614593,
0.0014351296,
0.0239572544,
-0.0021547095,
-0.0517362393,
-0.0366748571,
-0.0219194647,
-0.052060999,
-0.0352185667,
-0.044358097,
0.0462512821,
0.0243979599,
-0.0688023865,
0.0089709992,
2.431265093e-34,
0.0145989899,
0.0191383492,
0.0078073982,
0.0060484195,
0.001248825,
-0.0059979786,
0.0140253603,
0.0277887452,
0.0244561397,
-0.0292915646,
-0.0111307194
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09564v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09564v1 | LongBoX: Evaluating Transformers on Long-Sequence Clinical Tasks | 2023-11-16T04:57:49 | 2023-11-16T04:57:49 | Mihir Parmar, Aakanksha Naik, Himanshu Gupta, Disha Agrawal, Chitta Baral | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Many large language models (LLMs) for medicine have largely been evaluated on
short texts, and their ability to handle longer sequences such as a complete
electronic health record (EHR) has not been systematically explored. Assessing
these models on long sequences is crucial since prior work in the general
domain has demonstrated performance degradation of LLMs on longer texts.
Motivated by this, we introduce LongBoX, a collection of seven medical datasets
in text-to-text format, designed to investigate model performance on long
sequences. Preliminary experiments reveal that both medical LLMs (e.g., BioGPT)
and strong general domain LLMs (e.g., FLAN-T5) struggle on this benchmark. We
further evaluate two techniques designed for long-sequence handling: (i)
local-global attention, and (ii) Fusion-in-Decoder (FiD). Our results
demonstrate mixed results with long-sequence handling - while scores on some
datasets increase, there is substantial room for improvement. We hope that
LongBoX facilitates the development of more effective long-sequence techniques
for the medical domain. Data and source code are available at
https://github.com/Mihir3009/LongBoX. | [
0.0096817538,
0.0583403669,
0.0241765864,
0.003632053,
-0.0129723698,
0.0253164303,
-0.0017012112,
0.0110730063,
-0.0020374695,
-0.0082835341,
-0.029947741,
-0.0945804864,
0.0602606907,
0.0349774845,
0.027271565,
-0.0554438904,
0.0318212472,
-0.0004914674,
0.0096011655,
0.0087643545,
-0.0221611764,
-0.007875381,
-0.0150876781,
0.0688111335,
0.039457161,
-0.0052749454,
0.0073606391,
-0.0031949044,
0.0383563638,
-0.0758726671,
-0.0169522967,
0.0472312532,
-0.0117435725,
0.0077210418,
0.00000181,
-0.0218241569,
-0.0075303982,
0.0323831812,
-0.0215096381,
-0.0122995451,
0.0272420179,
-0.0791578665,
-0.0214644,
0.0103109041,
-0.0214777421,
-0.0472270586,
0.0263309311,
0.0345386453,
0.0380130261,
0.072730504,
-0.0154971434,
-0.0179706234,
0.0454536676,
-0.0625386313,
0.015244755,
-0.0205932111,
0.0323583037,
-0.0318266116,
0.0513677187,
-0.01023106,
-0.0325999334,
0.0512899384,
0.0229765493,
0.0442865267,
-0.0008796488,
0.0560124144,
-0.0331349783,
-0.0076375199,
0.0089946296,
0.0705231726,
-0.0344649032,
-0.002165118,
0.0127188498,
0.0212102588,
-0.017505534,
-0.0410919823,
-0.0383550748,
0.0126041062,
-0.0372498408,
0.0079361945,
0.0137819508,
-0.0106668249,
0.0209092908,
-0.0378898755,
-0.075744912,
0.0023186663,
0.010489136,
-0.0410828069,
-0.0077865701,
-0.0001851418,
-0.0056100506,
-0.0466024689,
0.0462071262,
0.0539191663,
-0.0279947519,
-0.0024342213,
-0.0564350784,
-0.0552161708,
0.0469509363,
-0.0397464149,
0.0198792722,
0.0349626169,
-0.0074845282,
0.0112908902,
-0.0131103005,
0.0381565951,
-0.0458210781,
0.040682476,
-0.0265187435,
0.0085466774,
-0.0382388383,
0.0143133067,
0.0024005317,
-0.0051193209,
-0.0237198602,
-0.013471256,
-0.077329874,
-0.0219576173,
0.0213561151,
0.0086390562,
0.0392099731,
0.012166163,
-0.0251958035,
0.0113635603,
0.0112568196,
0.0572137535,
0.0213558469,
-0.0164069105,
0.0117513249,
-0.0624842681,
-0.0337106921,
0.0046364879,
-0.0005722461,
-0.0376455374,
0.0164195206,
0.0717589483,
0.0175209623,
-0.0564623997,
0.0171319693,
0.0037926927,
-0.0473888442,
-0.0547419153,
0.0222369898,
-0.0509765409,
0.0331883132,
0.0307480488,
0.0121976379,
-0.0435807072,
0.0112060541,
0.0177581925,
-0.0162857044,
0.0572773106,
-0.0181248207,
-0.0168828312,
-0.0016034679,
0.0228910111,
0.0153353559,
0.0249155052,
0.024864167,
-0.0421471559,
-0.0341237597,
-0.0218224581,
0.0172502641,
0.0339123793,
0.017071154,
-0.0414478071,
-0.0129155479,
0.0154231023,
0.0189914927,
0.054444138,
0.0169156268,
0.0751929879,
-0.0017408376,
-0.0362820178,
0.0535891838,
0.0473974086,
0.0674238876,
-0.0073850453,
0.0206937138,
-0.0252512116,
0.0015155461,
-0.0060168663,
-0.0092410464,
0.0202073231,
0.0392000675,
0.0180526972,
0.017302122,
0.0371017866,
-0.0382529311,
-0.0086557139,
-0.0434394851,
-0.0217136741,
-0.0176131353,
0.0087617105,
0.0513096452,
-0.0069371653,
-0.0600378253,
0.0716446564,
0.0139525281,
-0.0477373265,
-0.0082175322,
-0.0283713304,
-0.0326265134,
0.0459279492,
0.0434925258,
0.0030153918,
-0.0548267961,
-0.031030573,
-0.0150901591,
0.0142713068,
-0.0021101821,
0.034457624,
0.0205324609,
-0.0453467146,
-0.0131384535,
0.0622466654,
0.0005986577,
-0.0156543832,
0.0044898912,
0.0235361531,
0.0070551317,
-0.0361521915,
-0.0021379008,
0.035011638,
-0.0685870275,
-0.010509898,
-0.0217043329,
0.0003573565,
0.0413098373,
0.0030664359,
-0.0148736937,
0.0430216789,
0.0489365682,
-0.0542499721,
-0.0079617333,
-0.0076322327,
-0.0560532957,
-0.0474505387,
0.0288343783,
-0.0397325419,
-0.0143855959,
0.009409315,
-0.0070726005,
-0.0132774152,
-0.0449930839,
-0.0854912698,
0.0366155095,
0.0113882069,
0.0304555688,
0.0446060933,
0.0402870886,
-0.0470484532,
0.0085785715,
-0.0388632081,
0.0173045602,
0.03109896,
-0.0235813912,
0.0068311444,
-0.0407121852,
-0.0179814715,
0.052324485,
-0.0059403158,
-0.0154551035,
-0.0349331759,
-0.0038420258,
-0.0142520638,
-0.0580199063,
-0.0883016139,
0.0003395909,
-0.0099825067,
0.0471051559,
0.0169903394,
0.0237383619,
0.0125700328,
0.0052746157,
-0.0393462367,
-0.0391804688,
0.0147457756,
0.0191692151,
0.0183268208,
0.0264125019,
-0.0313471593,
-0.0215591788,
-0.0192886926,
-0.0206883643,
0.0366004184,
-0.0190734025,
-0.0407080613,
-0.0368814096,
-0.0134028196,
-0.0021007899,
-0.0089405105,
-0.026194457,
-0.0492902435,
0.0133062107,
0.00125501,
0.0764191747,
0.0457500108,
0.0199951548,
0.005792561,
0.0192572009,
-0.0047333576,
0.0035618311,
0.0089694625,
-0.0035894869,
-0.0060376036,
-0.0298515055,
-0.0215787962,
-0.0173079744,
0.1000671089,
-0.0078847008,
0.0188964643,
-0.0592280664,
-0.0468868725,
-0.0104482761,
0.0156621914,
-0.0033889099,
0.0114483489,
-0.0604015365,
0.0241130926,
0.0053883493,
-0.0322575085,
0.076359801,
-0.044276379,
-0.0100578526,
-0.0451297164,
-0.0094730631,
-0.053616751,
0.0098311258,
0.0033704799,
-0.0172722265,
0.0004208193,
-0.0521048494,
0.0058142091,
0.0433517471,
-0.0264186822,
-0.0803832114,
0.0993782356,
-0.0072329328,
0.0201145764,
-0.0224118661,
-0.0346068442,
-0.0348314904,
-0.0018675132,
-0.0154242367,
-0.0041243853,
0.0140799489,
-0.0032686242,
-0.0853112787,
0.0483411513,
-0.0094179688,
0.0918728337,
-0.0061548064,
0.0121661378,
0.007067834,
0.0271582026,
0.0091833035,
0.0028540748,
-0.0028777141,
-0.0497073904,
0.0165590886,
0.0530909374,
-0.0002889098,
0.0290781669,
-0.0140914153,
-0.0216245949,
0.0299504325,
-0.0070460103,
-0.0178886764,
0.0424433649,
0.0383684449,
-0.0972735509,
-0.0160584114,
0.1038212255,
0.0098681133,
-0.0682783201,
0.0211884622,
0.0038150377,
0.0293314941,
-0.0238609314,
-0.0059570428,
-0.04366244,
-0.0349241868,
0.0222799294,
0.0294163767,
0.0095453998,
-0.0216218121,
0.0332299583,
-0.0592632852,
0.0165808536,
0.0304100141,
-0.0447255075,
-0.0598303303,
-0.042837508,
-0.0199115053,
-0.018201204,
0.0218607616,
0.0272869486,
-0.0374873653,
-0.0083928546,
0.0175726973,
-0.0343377739,
-0.0889891088,
0.0102111306,
-0.014810591,
0.055329781,
0.0852319226,
0.0198012106,
0.0155350193,
-0.0514775328,
0.0181719419,
-0.0019985058,
-0.0042144479,
0.01214182,
0.0855631456,
-0.0025616977,
-0.0204667803,
-0.0236589797,
0.0217724517,
-0.0647739097,
-0.0021616996,
-0.0278946329,
0.0635084286,
-0.0286822803,
-0.0291665457,
-0.0329603404,
0.0094043026,
0.0013050106,
0.0502757542,
0.0313238017,
-0.0095539903,
-0.048360467,
0.008416825,
0.0319419354,
-0.0239283126,
-0.0414180383,
0.0501788296,
-0.0145856701,
-0.0564544871,
-0.0449486375,
-0.0440372266,
0.0358105823,
0.0038834279,
-0.0056302468,
0.0083400803,
0.0202736836,
0.0211851858,
-0.0563786589,
0.0655446947,
0.0277254209,
0.0190259106,
-0.0984329209,
-0.0124273086,
0.0483173914,
0.0139793307,
-0.0087686311,
0.0505123585,
-0.0743938982,
-0.0132709993,
0.028442204,
0.0221661367,
0.0221004151,
0.0044830265,
0.0103723612,
-0.0006462574,
0.0254174136,
0.035125345,
-0.0572860241,
-0.0011047906,
0.0100116357,
-0.0398112163,
-0.0113385292,
0.0102974139,
-0.0040785344,
0.0166297294,
0.0081498241,
0.0456338376,
0.0104628997,
-0.0282320622,
0.0128012756,
0.0190195497,
0.0361992568,
-0.0157869365,
-0.0126493825,
0.0249027405,
0.0345963575,
-0.0151703889,
0.0641180873,
-0.0342360698,
-0.0094323056,
0.0432124957,
-0.0032650316,
-0.0125612868,
0.0423515998,
-0.0387809351,
-0.0525400862,
-0.0332830772,
0.0638791025,
-0.018941896,
0.0004959375,
0.0724628568,
-0.0154165169,
-0.0186134893,
0.0110479826,
0.0168857779,
0.0019903888,
-0.0305143651,
0.0417211093,
0.0012002097,
0.0662492737,
0.021986071,
0.058561977,
-0.0346564427,
0.0241204277,
-0.0208753403,
-0.0102010909,
0.0430637822,
0.0054451674,
0.0617201589,
-0.0099329129,
0.0253426898,
-0.0450603589,
0.0384823717,
-0.0511675254,
0.019715216,
0.0163995288,
0.012570818,
-0.0063353875,
-0.0313514918,
0.0963252932,
0.017008828,
0.0375882946,
0.0172331929,
-0.013365848,
-0.0371448807,
-0.0296635851,
0.0055157663,
-0.0401581489,
-0.0579982437,
-0.0114372587,
-0.0487068743,
-0.0644503683,
0.0583658777,
-0.0284269452,
-0.0313343666,
-0.0104967179,
0.0390992761,
0.0045130579,
-0.0171876512,
-0.0141250119,
0.0080129001,
0.0447561182,
0.016197484,
-0.0361937322,
0.0168612003,
-5.464358591e-33,
-0.0216878522,
-0.0225452539,
0.017351022,
-0.0147346184,
-0.0467412733,
0.0225847811,
-0.0541767068,
0.009671933,
0.0176673159,
0.0130641181,
-0.0415927619,
0.0100459782,
0.0157527868,
0.059096057,
0.0005009238,
-0.0436899886,
0.0345968492,
0.017165035,
-0.0100598997,
0.0118876491,
-0.0188870449,
0.0646267533,
0.049339246,
-0.0442428589,
-0.008778871,
0.0109121148,
0.042531997,
-0.0375905931,
-0.0226178747,
0.0664613396,
-0.0329397917,
0.0308262873,
0.0395592861,
-0.0424322821,
-0.0454777144,
0.0018199049,
-0.0868364871,
0.0452471487,
-0.0066432566,
-0.0152014559,
-0.0267427117,
-0.0578290559,
0.0579008348,
-0.0069115688,
-0.0159388576,
-0.0415130034,
0.0277134907,
-0.036769595,
-0.0350648202,
-0.034401387,
-0.0174937304,
0.0611544214,
0.002467335,
-0.0111693535,
0.0147292567,
0.0251596123,
-0.0343797281,
0.0638496876,
-0.0482846908,
-0.0240231846,
0.0490438677,
0.0637658834,
0.0168536138,
-0.0314348452,
-0.0022817347,
0.039260786,
-0.0035834028,
-0.0027300515,
-0.042071484,
-0.0203946549,
-0.0082692197,
0.0136967571,
0.0620599091,
0.0062066312,
0.043133989,
-0.0177954771,
-0.0818533897,
0.0340470336,
-0.0660039932,
0.0584194511,
0.0262558796,
-0.0059593171,
-0.0137972338,
0.0166360512,
-0.0050114337,
0.018981846,
-0.0124899447,
-0.023527937,
0.0491954014,
0.0045120507,
0.0345382132,
-0.0025203777,
0.0506140776,
-0.0135310683,
0.019355448,
0.0099805063,
0.0390246473,
0.0264417455,
-0.036391329,
0.0103101656,
-0.0282856226,
-0.0038382553,
0.0434445813,
0.0174576156,
0.0384512022,
-0.0362819284,
0.0135669867,
-0.0069006914,
-0.0739855692,
-0.0311291609,
-0.0065241046,
0.0176888183,
-0.0164295342,
0.0613939539,
0.0634188578,
0.0026693775,
0.0053403075,
0.0848020613,
-0.0684395134,
-0.0255572442,
-0.0274067707,
-0.0028718973,
0.0500913374,
0.0071543348,
-0.0258063823,
0.0024077194,
-0.0546638928,
0.0634968504,
0.0411956124,
-0.0357053354,
-0.0145987356,
0.0227884222,
2.475e-7,
0.0910981596,
0.0399146453,
0.0489737354,
-0.0091600744,
0.012927576,
-0.0140738981,
-0.0348490253,
0.0366125666,
-0.0003437342,
0.0078445468,
0.009654616,
-0.0061783497,
0.0833700597,
0.0186044257,
-0.0881430209,
-0.034713611,
-0.0921849161,
0.003531487,
-0.0240105242,
-0.031358853,
0.03401912,
0.1015012711,
-0.0582314394,
-0.0085162651,
0.0510866903,
0.0055548698,
0.0410926081,
-0.0153222755,
-0.0159862526,
0.031055117,
-0.0148960305,
-0.0174034182,
0.0139442105,
0.011799504,
-0.0236338433,
-0.0211276654,
0.0102614006,
0.1143403426,
-0.0275552962,
-0.039000988,
0.0366744176,
0.0340264104,
-0.0111679491,
-0.0240906328,
0.0423847809,
-0.0974741653,
-0.0415376164,
0.0029580225,
-0.0372514501,
-0.0017327536,
0.0465645976,
-0.0049106474,
0.0165863764,
0.0467526913,
0.0417326801,
-0.0006241517,
-0.0260802638,
-0.0829343274,
-0.0344092585,
0.0400192104,
-0.0509172939,
-0.0209906176,
-0.0227570366,
-0.0117789321,
0.0234953947,
-0.0530669726,
-0.0324338749,
2.485921907e-34,
0.0135079343,
-0.0340266861,
0.0067971284,
0.0470587648,
0.0162490569,
-0.0459524654,
0.0135948351,
0.019016372,
-0.0030506728,
-0.0924206898,
-0.0215276442
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09562v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09562v3 | TextEE: Benchmark, Reevaluation, Reflections, and Future Challenges in Event Extraction | 2023-11-16T04:43:03 | 2024-06-06T04:24:16 | Kuan-Hao Huang, I-Hung Hsu, Tanmay Parekh, Zhiyu Xie, Zixuan Zhang, Premkumar Natarajan, Kai-Wei Chang, Nanyun Peng, Heng Ji | cs.CL | cs.CL | Event extraction has gained considerable interest due to its wide-ranging
applications. However, recent studies draw attention to evaluation issues,
suggesting that reported scores may not accurately reflect the true
performance. In this work, we identify and address evaluation challenges,
including inconsistency due to varying data assumptions or preprocessing steps,
the insufficiency of current evaluation frameworks that may introduce dataset
or data split bias, and the low reproducibility of some previous approaches. To
address these challenges, we present TextEE, a standardized, fair, and
reproducible benchmark for event extraction. TextEE comprises standardized data
preprocessing scripts and splits for 16 datasets spanning eight diverse domains
and includes 14 recent methodologies, conducting a comprehensive benchmark
reevaluation. We also evaluate five varied large language models on our TextEE
benchmark and demonstrate how they struggle to achieve satisfactory
performance. Inspired by our reevaluation results and findings, we discuss the
role of event extraction in the current NLP era, as well as future challenges
and insights derived from TextEE. We believe TextEE, the first standardized
comprehensive benchmarking tool, will significantly facilitate future event
extraction research. | [
-0.0011653143,
0.0786954612,
0.0140718138,
0.0608574003,
-0.0596177354,
0.0135229146,
0.0206231866,
0.0165491756,
0.0195478667,
-0.0621644258,
0.0163449775,
0.0182934478,
-0.0486750007,
0.0947234482,
-0.0066445004,
-0.047513105,
0.0430272296,
0.0325466059,
-0.0017667314,
0.0598739013,
0.0267240386,
0.0128788548,
-0.0241019651,
0.0210002754,
-0.0213339515,
0.0285343863,
0.0116149317,
-0.0279036406,
0.03913638,
-0.0482396074,
-0.0028332884,
0.00208791,
0.0165439397,
0.0273405779,
0.0000018926,
-0.0720478073,
-0.0244098697,
-0.0096765589,
-0.0134241432,
0.0256696437,
-0.0187673103,
-0.0370231904,
-0.0187183563,
-0.0098013664,
-0.0335269459,
-0.052356001,
0.0057930527,
0.0484170504,
-0.000818317,
0.0985189676,
-0.0470514782,
-0.0270919222,
0.0414575115,
-0.0159378182,
-0.0311653689,
-0.0371695906,
0.0299421791,
-0.0362775438,
-0.0023261048,
-0.031040648,
0.020452518,
0.009976469,
0.0091489181,
0.0185151305,
-0.0340337642,
0.0322390944,
-0.0788746327,
-0.0023871737,
-0.0349642746,
0.053890679,
-0.0033233827,
0.0073263901,
0.0552401841,
-0.0025134168,
-0.0305033345,
0.008634408,
-0.0525729023,
0.0395516604,
-0.0070154476,
0.0286873672,
0.0250112563,
0.0286138915,
0.0124982689,
-0.0091046356,
-0.0032994989,
0.0634123385,
0.0259122103,
0.0003719313,
-0.0121595375,
0.0299480036,
-0.0174442455,
-0.0513486899,
0.0564968735,
0.0018066788,
-0.0147829819,
0.0214169733,
-0.0568048209,
0.0340330116,
-0.0333209075,
-0.0817832947,
-0.032930579,
0.0308520906,
0.0011411445,
0.0426092409,
0.0138910059,
0.011680454,
0.0177931655,
-0.0050175525,
0.0014977375,
-0.0088233715,
-0.0140797067,
0.0442692265,
-0.0094107883,
0.0014297436,
-0.0459708646,
-0.0290000774,
-0.0073159598,
0.0049615856,
0.0284194499,
0.0126829371,
0.0061885165,
-0.03015792,
-0.0306399558,
-0.0008793797,
0.0112913232,
-0.0178141315,
-0.0584114417,
0.0236882791,
0.0035189625,
-0.0538948812,
-0.038614966,
0.0053637777,
0.052077163,
-0.0041129626,
0.0004676389,
0.0104685444,
-0.01129058,
-0.0434219465,
-0.0640138015,
-0.028281197,
0.0050516888,
-0.0180539992,
-0.0357448868,
-0.0471953191,
0.0684254244,
-0.0008169757,
-0.0092757121,
-0.0446260273,
0.0162688456,
-0.0224405639,
-0.0443011411,
0.0146895619,
-0.0167975333,
0.0171562731,
-0.0163861681,
-0.0126375603,
0.0025275259,
0.0559810437,
0.0613028184,
0.0144681772,
0.1024261042,
0.0034786134,
-0.0149209462,
0.0700492188,
-0.0056079323,
-0.0307752397,
-0.0025213438,
-0.0057574837,
0.0031508408,
-0.0047951369,
0.0522244833,
-0.0138075082,
-0.0249490701,
-0.0163436905,
0.0223008301,
0.0526894741,
-0.0385404304,
-0.0268910937,
0.0098609012,
-0.0180142242,
0.0156003544,
0.0078497045,
-0.0014793146,
-0.0550433509,
0.0277195144,
0.007763973,
0.0294838492,
-0.0018979902,
0.0011557291,
-0.0016543856,
-0.016191218,
-0.0075255241,
-0.0223532468,
0.0304551516,
0.0372176133,
-0.0192636736,
-0.0287871454,
0.0459890626,
0.0513028838,
-0.0511441156,
0.0228461586,
0.0131928343,
-0.0149508892,
0.0221873652,
0.0590220243,
-0.0492803231,
-0.0226122495,
0.0090792831,
0.0140953874,
0.0277743377,
0.0304018557,
-0.0301152393,
0.0614631325,
-0.0119713834,
0.0059605995,
0.0089734085,
0.0294480156,
-0.0307675935,
0.0536027439,
0.0143830702,
-0.0197112449,
0.0220453423,
-0.015309494,
0.0606581643,
-0.0486297645,
-0.0587297678,
-0.0255062357,
-0.0345319547,
-0.0027275525,
-0.014132794,
-0.0415542796,
-0.0213615354,
0.0485092252,
-0.0465519205,
0.0020710174,
0.0386316739,
0.0015039445,
-0.0725360513,
0.0266994033,
0.0035899894,
-0.0269775875,
0.0427977704,
-0.0323020741,
-0.0185338371,
-0.0238326397,
0.0309384428,
-0.010304343,
0.0102783693,
0.0430123731,
-0.0130686564,
-0.0316087268,
-0.0228226874,
0.0522985347,
0.0066935876,
-0.0071719424,
-0.0543390736,
-0.0087932684,
0.0097155469,
-0.0263469163,
-0.0223118495,
0.0566702187,
-0.0049221683,
-0.025843123,
0.0277185421,
-0.0347297713,
-0.0543829612,
0.0101043778,
-0.0599279515,
0.0729467869,
-0.0400020927,
0.0782618895,
0.0529283658,
0.0544298403,
-0.0459485948,
0.0074535469,
-0.0124689676,
-0.0845660344,
-0.0183480717,
0.0239897147,
0.0468295179,
0.0212474186,
0.0067593348,
-0.0768906623,
0.0028736619,
-0.051682312,
0.0784894228,
0.0086646974,
-0.0279240888,
-0.0165469199,
0.0684744418,
0.0165949594,
0.0398064181,
-0.0122186504,
-0.0090507949,
-0.0097518312,
-0.0043488662,
0.0358410999,
0.0382113457,
-0.0062767994,
0.0436107963,
-0.0349380523,
-0.0512620024,
-0.0361333713,
0.0001284757,
-0.0628777519,
0.0387193859,
-0.0108592007,
-0.0347768627,
0.0559150577,
0.0566276759,
0.004847677,
0.0379597098,
-0.0099607026,
-0.015331855,
-0.0270056967,
0.0008555678,
0.0045687561,
-0.0213520713,
-0.0555324852,
0.0188551676,
-0.0400902331,
0.0075076576,
0.0418440141,
-0.008096314,
-0.0095205856,
-0.061824955,
0.0078246705,
-0.0721846968,
0.0604933687,
-0.0318980962,
-0.0140670035,
-0.0177854076,
-0.0514877066,
0.0474877469,
-0.0035549409,
0.0056291902,
-0.0132056605,
0.0462187119,
-0.0428234227,
0.0240874197,
-0.0095833717,
-0.0050959997,
-0.0381055661,
-0.0497936383,
0.0078843459,
0.0039064265,
0.0281920452,
0.0004673979,
-0.0494012646,
0.014575744,
-0.0115142651,
0.0623750724,
-0.0159415305,
0.0033108161,
0.0069384808,
0.0793331116,
0.0404600985,
-0.0250134021,
-0.0142929666,
0.0097657237,
-0.0035820846,
0.0681753829,
0.0615997501,
-0.0000417878,
-0.0110122068,
0.0083145872,
0.022896193,
-0.0855688527,
0.0184417944,
-0.0109579032,
0.0699526444,
-0.086885415,
-0.0011830819,
0.1092614233,
0.0345704965,
-0.0095028495,
0.0099537959,
0.0359308161,
-0.0042521977,
0.0141191911,
-0.0218929425,
-0.0313321277,
-0.0353321061,
0.0011095045,
0.0053876862,
-0.0045423992,
-0.0518462583,
0.0125954114,
-0.0485258102,
0.0023608799,
-0.0110101961,
-0.0166050494,
-0.0445489436,
-0.082215637,
0.0311742891,
-0.0369104557,
-0.0206424184,
0.006862463,
-0.0138177024,
-0.0030008862,
0.0050405357,
-0.0980822369,
-0.1054390594,
0.0173364785,
-0.0687498674,
-0.0038781331,
0.0207845811,
0.015984606,
-0.0165709332,
0.0573605187,
0.0466653928,
-0.0469675101,
-0.0333939493,
-0.0133544877,
0.0737845227,
-0.0101170773,
-0.0210158695,
-0.0032995681,
0.0326375701,
-0.0094303535,
-0.0251284,
0.0313232169,
0.0587158054,
0.0249231737,
-0.004534984,
0.008871682,
-0.0250291526,
0.0198525824,
0.0657871664,
0.0032608628,
-0.0009839167,
-0.0229541268,
0.00655019,
0.0085530533,
-0.0657080188,
-0.0333719701,
-0.0055486839,
-0.0274472758,
-0.0707294196,
-0.0594080351,
-0.0928289592,
0.0279583689,
0.0197495297,
-0.0239058584,
-0.0246387869,
0.0260556992,
0.0135166897,
-0.0336752944,
0.0800284296,
-0.0033659537,
-0.0226695035,
-0.0010613035,
-0.0099505251,
-0.0253382903,
0.0685237721,
-0.0138821173,
0.0742956251,
-0.038948264,
-0.0332991071,
0.0151586803,
-0.0446943119,
0.0102039427,
0.0083652157,
0.0008577284,
0.0065796711,
-0.0313464887,
0.0067880661,
-0.0059715663,
-0.0179169551,
0.0040271934,
0.0024106232,
0.0101501336,
-0.0059313332,
-0.0047982763,
0.0204874761,
-0.0404048562,
0.08368662,
-0.0519439653,
-0.0150401294,
-0.0080794133,
0.0143098123,
0.0600444227,
-0.0069842143,
-0.030988086,
-0.0777119175,
-0.0364715457,
-0.0648633838,
0.0080277575,
-0.0305843931,
0.0265799183,
-0.0105098737,
0.0292197149,
-0.0555043407,
0.0749894157,
-0.0619408078,
0.0032340356,
-0.0932563469,
0.0391888544,
0.0432513282,
0.0221564192,
-0.0059240055,
-0.0116406661,
-0.0172662623,
-0.0134438844,
0.0084669525,
0.0107507547,
-0.0611247048,
0.0004233075,
0.0246138498,
-0.0164471492,
0.0026682967,
-0.0110692568,
-0.044874765,
0.0728878081,
-0.0104257632,
0.0028440626,
0.0593863539,
-0.0369856991,
0.0793182403,
0.0099873282,
-0.0138486465,
-0.0020976102,
0.0229665171,
0.0153115196,
0.0260216165,
-0.0261656605,
0.0138059529,
-0.0608374961,
0.0140335783,
0.0363913514,
-0.0208093598,
0.0858209059,
0.0256002191,
-0.0166604463,
-0.0229144972,
-0.032133121,
0.0515224151,
0.0048326948,
-0.0178051386,
-0.0239141155,
-0.0684832782,
0.0551602803,
0.0436117798,
-0.0197798684,
-0.0006818484,
-0.0000565547,
0.0078919865,
0.0635553002,
0.0362142697,
0.0081082098,
-0.0309776794,
0.0293478165,
-0.0071165175,
-0.0365011394,
-0.0289978441,
-6.139842461e-33,
0.0059779529,
0.0105559025,
-0.0006967202,
0.0558634736,
-0.0335476175,
0.0380328558,
-0.0538970307,
-0.0139853526,
-0.0030189608,
0.0019378576,
-0.0011411267,
-0.0197649822,
0.0196224581,
-0.0293778554,
0.0105732372,
-0.0311414078,
0.0225946549,
0.0019932191,
-0.038616024,
0.0025463905,
0.0465212949,
0.0572291613,
0.0643667132,
-0.0801397339,
0.0332209393,
0.0166989975,
0.0172924045,
-0.0231651198,
0.1049595773,
0.0378833935,
-0.0133427661,
0.0185154621,
0.0296098683,
-0.0617333576,
0.0007111719,
0.0021098424,
-0.0669875294,
-0.0231411271,
0.0241173394,
0.01846301,
-0.0122775473,
-0.0058402289,
0.0304878037,
-0.0016880976,
-0.0227412675,
-0.0076162363,
0.0123917041,
-0.012343023,
-0.0224765558,
-0.048318401,
-0.0844145566,
0.0672708377,
0.0071452591,
0.0000297669,
0.0458787903,
0.0033205934,
0.0313900337,
0.038434241,
-0.0134505155,
-0.0169837456,
-0.0339654051,
0.0257023331,
0.000734827,
-0.0338811018,
-0.0157044102,
0.0707879588,
-0.0012095076,
0.0048891976,
-0.0110880705,
0.0397143736,
0.021300517,
0.0742503703,
-0.0051009995,
0.0417804681,
0.0222082511,
0.0077525363,
-0.0776835233,
0.0594684221,
0.0506663807,
-0.0387138873,
-0.0183824115,
-0.0065024961,
-0.0592527501,
0.0051257629,
-0.006798082,
0.0559963658,
0.0047695604,
0.0385030806,
0.0206171162,
0.0051895757,
0.0193776544,
0.1035249457,
0.0057001198,
-0.009768039,
-0.0066803228,
0.0278567653,
-0.0178943146,
0.0108663924,
-0.0146136153,
0.0130969994,
-0.0654937103,
-0.0086162193,
0.01120455,
0.0209575947,
0.0337613262,
-0.0283215437,
0.010414659,
-0.0036348919,
-0.0369314216,
-0.007365081,
-0.0167405028,
0.0155531848,
-0.0380606614,
0.0143975792,
0.0086352238,
-0.0067466516,
0.0049801366,
0.0436537303,
0.0518155247,
0.0348675027,
0.0047941389,
-0.0137076201,
0.0111450898,
0.0238889251,
0.005526321,
0.024724042,
-0.0259012971,
0.0517814942,
-0.0137293059,
-0.0014542585,
-0.0078236088,
-0.0104082916,
2.354e-7,
0.0560460314,
0.0429137386,
0.0448526517,
0.0605599433,
-0.0060849492,
0.0118466532,
-0.0016133977,
0.0194156785,
0.0097230338,
0.040884722,
-0.0347094089,
0.0069978489,
0.0447731204,
0.0443943478,
-0.0136084072,
-0.0753484666,
-0.0618827604,
-0.0329425186,
-0.0809009299,
-0.0110692121,
0.0692392513,
0.0437539071,
0.0508620292,
0.0104690231,
-0.0216503516,
-0.0303552318,
0.0158443525,
-0.0319261625,
-0.0724587142,
0.0688861609,
-0.0111903595,
0.0436125137,
-0.0330151357,
-0.0040906589,
-0.0210427493,
0.0410083458,
-0.0014368385,
0.0630485266,
-0.0020143706,
0.0207660757,
-0.0001825192,
-0.0462508611,
-0.0105098365,
-0.0259635132,
0.091330044,
0.0035468633,
-0.0217482541,
-0.0150284115,
-0.0435149707,
0.048185654,
-0.0407314077,
-0.005900444,
-0.0270603523,
0.0389598645,
0.0251961388,
0.0057219672,
-0.0487609915,
-0.0704122186,
-0.0253270678,
0.0443352796,
-0.0206310265,
-0.035827592,
0.0224324018,
-0.0313453227,
-0.0255211685,
-0.0715722144,
-0.0131386854,
2.458982883e-34,
-0.0247318018,
0.0458033569,
-0.0291768201,
0.0388108678,
0.0451391153,
-0.0111614456,
-0.0141421687,
-0.0150333969,
-0.032127399,
-0.0026562647,
0.0350076556
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09559v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09559v3 | Prompt-based Pseudo-labeling Strategy for Sample-Efficient Semi-Supervised Extractive Summarization | 2023-11-16T04:29:41 | 2024-07-02T02:16:28 | Gaurav Sahu, Olga Vechtomova, Issam H. Laradji | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Semi-supervised learning (SSL) is a widely used technique in scenarios where
labeled data is scarce and unlabeled data is abundant. While SSL is popular for
image and text classification, it is relatively underexplored for the task of
extractive text summarization. Standard SSL methods follow a teacher-student
paradigm to first train a classification model and then use the classifier's
confidence values to select pseudo-labels for the subsequent training cycle;
however, such classifiers are not suitable to measure the accuracy of
pseudo-labels as they lack specific tuning for evaluation, which leads to
confidence values that fail to capture the semantics and correctness of the
generated summary. To address this problem, we propose a prompt-based
pseudo-labeling strategy with LLMs that picks unlabeled examples with more
accurate pseudo-labels than using just the classifier's probability outputs.
Our approach also includes a relabeling mechanism that improves the quality of
pseudo-labels. We evaluate our method on three text summarization datasets:
TweetSumm, WikiHow, and ArXiv/PubMed. We empirically show that a
prompting-based LLM that scores and generates pseudo-labels outperforms
existing SSL methods on ROUGE-1, ROUGE-2, and ROUGE-L scores on all the
datasets. Furthermore, our method achieves competitive L-Eval scores
(evaluation with LLaMa-3) as a fully supervised method in a data-scarce setting
and outperforms fully supervised method in a data-abundant setting. | [
0.0546663366,
-0.0194314066,
0.057043355,
-0.0065203877,
-0.0106064985,
0.0226264969,
-0.0011014044,
0.0006585634,
0.0582712255,
-0.0429605991,
-0.0451135337,
0.0223220363,
-0.0259175412,
-0.0112551711,
0.0109098619,
-0.0715079159,
-0.0016586131,
-0.000922535,
0.0179123618,
-0.0024068418,
0.0013269569,
-0.0356791802,
0.0057617077,
-0.0306046456,
0.0172509681,
-0.0058053094,
0.0108598387,
-0.0114808446,
0.0568154193,
-0.0192423966,
0.0068926145,
-0.0061616148,
-0.011213609,
0.0096076271,
0.000001816,
-0.0786685422,
-0.0479645282,
-0.0003923201,
-0.0198607016,
0.0007127788,
0.0302812681,
-0.0413764603,
0.0250968803,
-0.0210067369,
0.0089187576,
-0.0092092371,
0.023295261,
0.0597252436,
0.0589366853,
0.0509011745,
-0.0060312394,
-0.00195003,
0.0070211589,
-0.0198039636,
0.0071657542,
-0.0363796093,
0.0184876155,
0.0229811408,
0.0204839204,
0.0111427493,
0.0066314908,
0.0650081709,
0.0063421191,
-0.0249457527,
0.0288822185,
0.0556079634,
-0.056305632,
-0.0289731156,
0.0125313792,
0.0735841021,
0.0215701591,
-0.0008192702,
0.0587807298,
-0.0134399729,
0.0021898597,
0.0245708115,
-0.0644354522,
0.0511959158,
-0.0035142764,
0.0126370974,
0.0039060856,
0.0736061633,
-0.0145080378,
0.0181014892,
0.0087634129,
0.0327249467,
-0.024951864,
-0.0325966105,
-0.0081282221,
0.0284654163,
0.0014518822,
-0.0317545868,
0.0256143548,
0.0486685559,
0.0084374445,
0.0017707223,
-0.0476436839,
-0.0519939288,
0.0479928032,
0.0162910447,
0.00312754,
-0.0323814712,
-0.006796408,
0.0655368567,
-0.0190484617,
-0.0191291086,
0.0569281727,
0.0945760757,
-0.057721395,
-0.0066955448,
-0.0346985273,
0.009848645,
-0.0133280754,
0.0568695925,
0.0037114539,
0.0219565574,
-0.0660190955,
0.0233955458,
-0.0036259224,
0.0075612133,
0.0107873566,
-0.0058904132,
-0.0292295367,
0.0215481576,
-0.0010486142,
-0.0035660448,
0.0061993673,
-0.0192309245,
0.0136049949,
0.0053676511,
-0.0159468055,
0.0123816915,
0.050369963,
-0.0015757802,
0.0026008014,
0.0223871469,
-0.0570503436,
-0.0612684228,
-0.0139842639,
-0.0373152345,
-0.0052865385,
-0.0483025387,
-0.0015899875,
-0.0576720536,
-0.001095852,
-0.0158865452,
0.0004469865,
-0.0064573013,
-0.0074277041,
-0.0081571462,
-0.0255850572,
0.0313933901,
-0.0551171638,
-0.0104322629,
0.0505098067,
0.0316184014,
0.0060564242,
0.0260748565,
0.019480288,
0.0280514378,
0.0611852705,
0.033956062,
0.0090843979,
0.0071753724,
0.0556232333,
-0.0118296919,
0.015825633,
-0.0295466669,
0.022221785,
-0.009277395,
0.0111896042,
0.0519263558,
-0.0184577014,
0.024727881,
0.0241645854,
0.0359660052,
-0.0149790766,
-0.0492578596,
0.0210458245,
0.0302527901,
0.0446330123,
0.0654052421,
0.0062710629,
0.0197690241,
-0.0701436698,
0.0775403157,
0.0895008966,
-0.0182536375,
-0.0294919983,
-0.0892063379,
0.0137259029,
-0.0137876831,
-0.0186807159,
0.0374755189,
0.0602395199,
0.0314392671,
-0.0175304879,
0.0071280599,
0.0122555941,
-0.0394951887,
0.0277369004,
-0.0431874432,
0.0367530324,
0.0178382974,
0.024936486,
-0.0911735445,
0.0032095164,
-0.0165775884,
0.0399099067,
0.0266430676,
0.0010458198,
-0.0345631018,
0.0015291661,
-0.0225572474,
-0.05054814,
0.0001747061,
0.0062547014,
-0.0334481001,
-0.0240164567,
-0.0065885782,
0.020525381,
-0.0605841614,
-0.037993826,
0.0271248296,
-0.026854353,
-0.0670306534,
-0.005410641,
-0.0036347497,
0.0145894932,
0.0328720994,
-0.0386715978,
0.0127696004,
0.0444323681,
-0.0329490788,
-0.0345995128,
-0.0502022952,
-0.0126932105,
-0.0765495673,
0.0377112664,
-0.0274806265,
-0.0255652554,
-0.0016797859,
-0.0567017794,
-0.039612364,
-0.0285143405,
-0.0207980108,
-0.0155938063,
-0.0507209264,
0.0052432665,
0.0374798216,
-0.0077679511,
-0.0548473559,
0.0590177774,
0.0164280105,
0.0483011864,
0.0323959216,
-0.0210999828,
0.0037571029,
-0.0152123254,
-0.0148947993,
0.020458458,
-0.0039963634,
0.0049269614,
0.0379354171,
0.0492653847,
-0.041186247,
-0.0087555656,
-0.0683429167,
-0.0053884024,
-0.0177788939,
-0.0247305874,
0.0154921776,
0.0014218993,
-0.0127636362,
-0.0153642446,
-0.0184548236,
-0.0770348087,
0.0074063917,
-0.0070597427,
0.0515629277,
0.0234388057,
0.0491651297,
-0.0277236123,
-0.0164548773,
0.0114722298,
0.0335344449,
0.0188091844,
-0.0163238663,
-0.0029895219,
0.0474948548,
-0.0346431173,
-0.050397072,
0.0291023646,
0.0257334895,
-0.0281018186,
-0.0008958335,
-0.0168380085,
0.0084022535,
0.0143439183,
-0.0132279852,
0.0415102467,
0.0093405824,
-0.0473594181,
-0.0147371227,
-0.0203858577,
-0.0229813084,
0.0533815995,
-0.0491737872,
0.0369856656,
0.0578626692,
0.0017022454,
-0.0288138427,
-0.0043148217,
-0.0085504912,
0.0017762376,
-0.0192993283,
-0.0622506626,
0.0284022577,
0.005509309,
0.0476410352,
0.0050082295,
-0.0334920622,
0.0916829035,
0.0016398666,
0.009616538,
-0.0696864501,
-0.0364586264,
-0.0299036261,
-0.0066225724,
0.0196948424,
0.0240440108,
0.0504463986,
0.0139119579,
-0.0111458069,
-0.0322386026,
0.0256241523,
-0.0173363984,
0.029672429,
-0.0217289887,
0.027704142,
-0.0269728322,
0.0037415226,
-0.0220146608,
-0.0535030067,
-0.0165742934,
0.0167895183,
-0.0342410766,
0.0345337354,
-0.0022022028,
0.0136247231,
0.0219173487,
0.0916409269,
-0.0170608722,
-0.0388091132,
-0.009736334,
0.0604736246,
0.0705466941,
-0.0225547347,
-0.0142778307,
-0.0301188845,
0.0422935337,
0.0463228934,
0.0448683947,
-0.0083040046,
0.0408006795,
-0.0094893547,
-0.0047954218,
-0.0837894976,
0.0397259146,
0.0209899899,
0.0438759476,
0.0118200332,
0.0130603649,
0.0920930505,
0.055073861,
-0.0199899971,
-0.0338056609,
0.009861676,
0.0100214984,
0.0089274319,
0.0183682051,
-0.0402682982,
-0.0068531735,
-0.0337686911,
0.0540090911,
-0.0357167237,
-0.0198584851,
0.0053107352,
-0.0673702508,
0.0319335274,
0.0040508639,
-0.0918079242,
-0.0095746424,
-0.0513000004,
0.0082360609,
0.0005523946,
-0.0342776775,
0.0083612781,
-0.041154813,
0.006004273,
0.0287710186,
-0.055153612,
-0.0491132699,
-0.0345945619,
-0.0146354074,
-0.0177979134,
0.0167195611,
0.0170159116,
-0.0161497798,
-0.0007767938,
0.023578696,
-0.0474698022,
-0.0217017159,
-0.0251751579,
0.1000786424,
-0.0071547888,
0.0152750257,
-0.0070363302,
0.0631819963,
0.0171061475,
-0.0188749507,
0.0149505064,
0.055514656,
0.0073646051,
-0.0211734641,
-0.0582830496,
0.0177125912,
-0.0138932094,
0.0547784492,
0.0202751067,
-0.0141164847,
-0.0158153307,
-0.0099516278,
0.0281036459,
-0.033459112,
-0.0248148702,
0.0042305603,
-0.0806105435,
-0.0404311903,
-0.0602995753,
-0.0400069058,
0.0204625633,
0.003316951,
0.0012846747,
0.0015030471,
-0.0102876239,
0.0048450404,
-0.0546117947,
0.0086408546,
-0.0343382321,
-0.028854223,
-0.0126090609,
-0.0502854139,
0.1051178426,
-0.0341590196,
-0.0224806909,
-0.0032635783,
-0.01416991,
-0.0456804335,
-0.0424483046,
0.0769585967,
0.0123568857,
0.031698782,
0.0331852958,
-0.0235750191,
0.1141721308,
0.1101463437,
0.037100181,
-0.0041621933,
0.026249405,
0.0207990557,
-0.0150335291,
-0.0017809648,
-0.071891658,
0.0293635037,
0.0009896244,
0.0142627787,
-0.081905961,
-0.0279570539,
0.0247421768,
0.0715792254,
0.0600421503,
-0.025990149,
0.0122473827,
-0.047747422,
-0.0217131525,
0.0263258796,
-0.0104503492,
-0.0140201477,
0.0391141959,
-0.0153807476,
0.0069930693,
-0.0169176497,
0.0866091847,
-0.0665661246,
0.0512067974,
-0.0432237685,
-0.0068576024,
-0.0462180749,
-0.041851081,
-0.0542543344,
-0.0134708341,
-0.0462666936,
-0.0454603657,
0.0342095941,
0.0271378942,
0.0306136776,
-0.0039330288,
0.0387460664,
0.0626639575,
-0.0000556058,
0.0246515498,
-0.1074918956,
0.0293092057,
-0.0629713908,
0.0531034321,
0.0398938507,
-0.0210696347,
0.017338559,
0.0061328919,
-0.027552614,
-0.0324253589,
0.0131390467,
0.0520735569,
-0.0193314143,
0.0026939011,
0.0150592709,
0.0231519267,
0.0210280661,
0.0646481663,
-0.0248129312,
0.0043370444,
-0.0011646092,
-0.022478383,
-0.0687435791,
-0.0265296716,
-0.0246964432,
0.0116517413,
0.0166602321,
-0.0454220325,
-0.0451450348,
-0.0336345322,
0.076229617,
0.0134287961,
-0.0190779138,
-0.027302349,
0.0552258119,
0.0075859367,
-0.0021785188,
0.0080050649,
-0.0484804213,
-0.0142686786,
0.0503662303,
-0.0167887099,
0.0320598148,
-5.902704108e-33,
-0.018952623,
-0.0310722981,
-0.0268017314,
0.0260956716,
-0.0081249345,
0.0225991327,
-0.0372809321,
-0.0090131834,
0.0462164879,
-0.0036268819,
-0.0284789372,
-0.0313678943,
0.0282109492,
0.0403326005,
-0.0069771376,
0.0001029393,
0.0245110076,
-0.0051022083,
-0.0433155224,
0.0317742564,
0.0031306131,
0.0221729837,
0.0339498594,
-0.1064936966,
0.0663408935,
0.0105625428,
-0.0031958688,
-0.0422395356,
0.0334743708,
0.0058976463,
-0.0205128491,
0.0350335464,
0.0324597098,
-0.0256745126,
-0.0199048724,
-0.0043974356,
-0.0679802522,
-0.0467793979,
-0.0115713263,
-0.0237885099,
-0.0624874122,
-0.0513851531,
0.032532163,
-0.0427122377,
-0.010707248,
-0.0306388754,
0.088266477,
-0.0280890465,
-0.0565978549,
-0.1012247726,
-0.0136126447,
0.0171026867,
-0.0378112271,
-0.0254260413,
0.0246551558,
0.0756873414,
-0.0017248081,
0.0673827827,
-0.0452518798,
0.0338219143,
0.051205527,
0.0036059706,
0.0509885587,
0.0371823125,
0.015132186,
0.055741109,
0.017770635,
-0.0111720236,
0.0116536198,
-0.0007869509,
-0.0204618908,
-0.0159117095,
-0.0108498279,
0.0350941755,
0.0528141521,
0.0301091373,
-0.0551541559,
0.1170077771,
-0.008484357,
-0.052050367,
0.0073372759,
0.0061426107,
-0.0044040726,
-0.0168023854,
-0.0286579058,
-0.0144493245,
0.0060971929,
0.0126095945,
-0.0332350954,
0.0139144687,
-0.0814668536,
0.0197286718,
0.0044803559,
-0.0157526378,
-0.0542436652,
-0.0323988758,
0.0243396144,
0.0334329046,
0.0021396622,
-0.0685661435,
-0.0375526473,
-0.0072966628,
0.0214454737,
0.0017396897,
0.0011561111,
-0.0035971398,
0.0696555525,
-0.0039381292,
-0.0156256706,
0.0090942075,
0.0202329457,
0.0201684162,
-0.0215224493,
0.0049356828,
-0.0263181739,
-0.0009733252,
-0.0074835937,
0.0470617376,
0.0024493586,
-0.0176557843,
-0.0012786599,
0.0195187554,
-0.0095328502,
0.0136436271,
-0.0074521401,
0.013940597,
0.0009869103,
0.047952801,
0.0029628002,
-0.0636900514,
0.0192701146,
-0.0063906075,
2.468e-7,
0.0508120209,
0.0245177858,
0.0400971696,
-0.0118797757,
-0.0178542435,
0.0354637653,
-0.0219704788,
0.0090102255,
0.0324046724,
-0.0543009676,
0.0351672061,
0.0106982002,
0.0321487747,
0.0239304435,
-0.0996228829,
-0.0366356149,
-0.0400729589,
-0.0317984782,
-0.0252947267,
-0.0076548657,
0.0818791762,
0.0481671318,
-0.0166368484,
-0.0359765366,
0.0102504687,
-0.0253910292,
0.0381155238,
-0.011538581,
-0.0133360503,
0.040302597,
0.0557869896,
0.0016701021,
0.0058940244,
0.0024729385,
-0.0149279302,
-0.0336403511,
0.0596637502,
0.0391406827,
0.0347664244,
0.0038238172,
0.0354590304,
0.0183883123,
0.0513040088,
0.047539901,
0.0511096455,
-0.0809765682,
-0.0153669305,
0.0358233079,
-0.027371861,
-0.0040758727,
0.030429095,
-0.0369027406,
-0.038651824,
0.0843565688,
-0.0144163575,
-0.0052337828,
-0.0110842679,
-0.0206750315,
-0.0288040172,
0.0040112711,
0.0073418138,
-0.0358973481,
0.0225764997,
0.0300941654,
-0.0020359466,
-0.0684180632,
-0.0170477759,
2.150827957e-34,
0.0871896893,
-0.0214271694,
-0.042267777,
-0.0139641715,
-0.0267458055,
-0.0246270411,
-0.0102128554,
0.0058424482,
-0.0002834232,
-0.0477373637,
0.0073522148
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09558v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09558v2 | What if you said that differently?: How Explanation Formats Affect Human Feedback Efficacy and User Perception | 2023-11-16T04:26:32 | 2024-04-02T00:59:36 | Chaitanya Malaviya, Subin Lee, Dan Roth, Mark Yatskar | cs.CL | cs.CL | Eliciting feedback from end users of NLP models can be beneficial for
improving models. However, how should we present model responses to users so
they are most amenable to be corrected from user feedback? Further, what
properties do users value to understand and trust responses? We answer these
questions by analyzing the effect of rationales (or explanations) generated by
QA models to support their answers. We specifically consider decomposed QA
models that first extract an intermediate rationale based on a context and a
question and then use solely this rationale to answer the question. A rationale
outlines the approach followed by the model to answer the question. Our work
considers various formats of these rationales that vary according to
well-defined properties of interest. We sample rationales from language models
using few-shot prompting for two datasets, and then perform two user studies.
First, we present users with incorrect answers and corresponding rationales in
various formats and ask them to provide natural language feedback to revise the
rationale. We then measure the effectiveness of this feedback in patching these
rationales through in-context learning. The second study evaluates how well
different rationale formats enable users to understand and trust model answers,
when they are correct. We find that rationale formats significantly affect how
easy it is (1) for users to give feedback for rationales, and (2) for models to
subsequently execute this feedback. In addition, formats with attributions to
the context and in-depth reasoning significantly enhance user-reported
understanding and trust of model outputs. | [
0.0743066147,
0.0210451614,
-0.0211704075,
0.0234469455,
-0.0149953915,
0.0131532354,
-0.0121495184,
-0.0297637135,
-0.0346048996,
-0.0554455668,
0.0099691348,
-0.002499586,
0.0254660919,
0.0107899867,
0.0153140305,
-0.0918018222,
-0.0069837673,
-0.0231704768,
0.0320690945,
0.0359717421,
0.0311263558,
0.0266229715,
0.0078055551,
0.0724518448,
0.0358345062,
-0.0300069116,
-0.0330126397,
-0.0046568722,
-0.0378992669,
-0.0404597856,
-0.0058363969,
0.0382336974,
0.0166501179,
-0.0377386287,
0.0000021223,
-0.0294438824,
0.0061886315,
0.0063434714,
-0.0794161409,
0.0499586686,
0.0176791213,
0.0333833955,
0.0067967982,
0.0221736208,
-0.0098340223,
0.0456604362,
0.0518073477,
0.0299905483,
0.0497833379,
0.0055623306,
-0.0102281617,
-0.0252620745,
-0.0275839623,
0.0243108161,
-0.0067151147,
-0.0423943773,
-0.0231024865,
0.0394671261,
0.0147143546,
0.0626255795,
0.0218968838,
-0.0045470675,
0.0336174145,
-0.0364989825,
0.023624694,
0.0000879068,
0.0497098789,
-0.0526871979,
-0.0115117915,
0.0499664471,
0.0414354689,
-0.0400026217,
-0.0395596139,
-0.0192347318,
0.0127873048,
0.0386042111,
-0.0766320378,
0.0353997461,
0.0039037568,
-0.0069635143,
-0.001583384,
0.0077068149,
0.0251752157,
0.020924639,
0.0185478572,
0.0472243242,
-0.0113192117,
0.0017595335,
-0.0328427814,
0.0015951798,
-0.0249294993,
-0.0695761666,
-0.0351775214,
0.0693997666,
-0.0155931925,
0.0185543653,
0.0137747834,
0.0466513708,
0.0227162763,
-0.0163851883,
0.0063949144,
0.0198491961,
-0.006883685,
0.0274316575,
0.0075220582,
0.0417787656,
0.0109012183,
0.0200317241,
0.0080375755,
0.010600362,
-0.078364335,
-0.043549452,
0.0072797849,
0.0211371202,
-0.0122899264,
0.0147852134,
-0.0056027779,
0.0035654595,
-0.0275991485,
0.0141025651,
0.0045671337,
0.040746849,
-0.01173703,
-0.0035420603,
-0.0859411284,
0.038594164,
-0.0596137829,
0.0505024344,
0.0364655815,
-0.0474764965,
-0.0122583248,
0.0039326665,
0.0022667556,
0.0019890403,
-0.0278768446,
0.0250912998,
0.0122323856,
-0.0077070179,
-0.0482622907,
-0.0616820455,
-0.0002538905,
-0.0266663115,
-0.0443046801,
-0.0241033025,
-0.023478752,
0.0421693102,
0.0029697174,
-0.0419362299,
0.0014206453,
0.0295973606,
-0.0500951,
0.0874217376,
-0.060834758,
0.0558970645,
0.0054056402,
0.0136735821,
-0.0189160947,
0.0322331488,
0.0178187974,
-0.0090872664,
0.0499617308,
-0.0510539077,
0.0466704443,
-0.0392437577,
-0.0077855699,
-0.0137060313,
-0.0111464486,
0.0388549231,
-0.0592499711,
0.018703768,
0.0043035238,
0.0354441106,
-0.0305465739,
0.0410154611,
0.0574667118,
0.075440526,
0.026662793,
-0.0075927917,
0.0177402608,
-0.0087143918,
0.0004228689,
0.0194213502,
-0.0146436729,
0.0287230611,
-0.0231092535,
0.011478927,
-0.0075983028,
-0.0115596903,
-0.0124782389,
-0.0664070174,
-0.0440112017,
0.009352739,
0.0552828386,
0.0221455414,
0.0236437153,
0.0423935987,
-0.0218744259,
0.0198514648,
0.0191431139,
-0.0399387516,
-0.0066243494,
-0.0733002722,
0.0721826181,
0.0722593665,
0.0218956079,
0.0341745391,
0.0035034758,
-0.0387434065,
0.0056947311,
0.0023282422,
0.0407591797,
-0.0282985773,
-0.0303703938,
-0.0098530492,
-0.0252866801,
-0.0476980433,
0.0123776337,
-0.0202665329,
0.0225278456,
-0.0218339562,
0.0124254366,
-0.0531689785,
-0.0417301469,
0.0224746913,
-0.0168020576,
-0.0223480463,
-0.0480791777,
-0.0001543599,
0.0133368177,
0.0577305667,
0.0408590399,
0.0532652512,
0.0021426384,
0.0321585536,
-0.0199492574,
0.0614660196,
-0.0365484133,
0.0151352137,
0.0118060885,
0.0262850896,
0.0045438865,
0.0018027056,
0.0046439194,
-0.0222552307,
0.02246942,
-0.0313730724,
0.0241389237,
-0.0174358133,
0.0127350958,
-0.0058442545,
-0.0463813767,
-0.0486831702,
0.0271307081,
0.0178624317,
0.011985328,
-0.0007221407,
-0.0011509818,
0.0088853426,
-0.0222736336,
0.0269951597,
0.0526342578,
0.0034836188,
-0.0097785313,
0.0426096432,
-0.018915182,
-0.050384149,
0.0434506349,
-0.048908703,
-0.0270305891,
-0.0376975387,
0.003843795,
0.0485959798,
0.0084655248,
0.0256146695,
-0.0149606969,
-0.0207557864,
-0.0395304337,
-0.0127706304,
0.0387234129,
0.0378999114,
0.0289166197,
-0.0040980428,
-0.0515663885,
-0.0189404041,
-0.0345159434,
0.0692137927,
0.0423681252,
0.0396521874,
-0.0706861243,
-0.0164403152,
-0.011344336,
-0.0349709839,
0.0011463278,
-0.0183648523,
0.0500905663,
0.0296282191,
-0.0157353021,
0.036099121,
0.0123160109,
0.0895511433,
0.0106058531,
0.0324629135,
-0.0751547143,
-0.0134084905,
-0.0241318382,
-0.0346679576,
-0.0104098534,
-0.0485584848,
0.0306513365,
0.0608865619,
0.0235780086,
0.0318135843,
-0.071900554,
0.0712796375,
-0.024163669,
-0.0015376477,
-0.0524357297,
-0.0936684459,
0.0022981046,
0.1038212553,
-0.0043621431,
-0.0331437849,
0.0602153651,
-0.0109601086,
0.0008363705,
-0.0221339706,
-0.0289779585,
-0.0206339005,
0.0571559705,
-0.047295846,
0.0170797762,
0.0371342637,
0.0069349636,
0.0036959418,
-0.0722226948,
0.0503553376,
-0.0149299558,
0.0306336619,
-0.0578337684,
-0.0286415406,
0.031083297,
-0.0137702599,
-0.0319423862,
-0.0459847525,
-0.0583937205,
0.0095131863,
-0.0083163008,
-0.0311472286,
0.0270530954,
0.0235816874,
0.0592829697,
-0.0147466389,
-0.0280228872,
-0.0284932498,
0.0071925153,
0.0102632931,
0.0449657403,
0.0231996793,
0.0520907305,
-0.0192323867,
0.0578583144,
0.032589145,
0.0260021333,
-0.0073859002,
-0.038143605,
-0.0248793568,
0.0041304813,
-0.0225088224,
-0.0313253589,
0.0341480263,
0.1048598737,
-0.0476149023,
0.008421625,
0.0972201005,
0.0488915443,
-0.0005087875,
0.0195927117,
-0.0640821606,
0.0340184905,
0.0440532006,
0.014909992,
-0.0453796424,
-0.0387606882,
0.012331333,
0.0454047695,
-0.0214125644,
0.0208673868,
0.0001692268,
-0.1161603034,
0.0314782672,
-0.0241176393,
-0.0122055616,
-0.0121681951,
-0.1037792042,
-0.0022012659,
-0.022317335,
0.0338720903,
0.0518686585,
-0.01481984,
0.0310511515,
0.0518097281,
-0.0462581366,
-0.0426846668,
0.0240706969,
-0.0237089321,
0.0310185067,
0.074121289,
0.0183570366,
-0.0006733705,
-0.0741341561,
0.0175745357,
0.0024051899,
0.0449223109,
-0.0139539689,
0.0350075662,
0.0068026758,
0.0224645324,
-0.0489142425,
0.0388147943,
-0.0350803472,
-0.0574180558,
0.0016782914,
0.0453378111,
-0.0027990581,
-0.0002301638,
-0.0235999245,
0.002179441,
-0.0029197007,
0.074888058,
0.079286553,
-0.0268960167,
-0.0204852577,
-0.0568818711,
-0.0031615871,
-0.0183803327,
-0.0588738695,
-0.0021242395,
0.0168327726,
-0.0060597146,
-0.0374769047,
-0.0783614665,
0.0191412587,
-0.0048885443,
0.0126403859,
-0.0261650253,
-0.0111738108,
-0.004586841,
0.0158649702,
0.0333555639,
0.0125732124,
0.0220453441,
-0.0107607488,
0.0165436678,
0.0143355345,
-0.0472719669,
0.0222233459,
-0.0363586769,
0.0123318424,
-0.0274929591,
-0.0299812518,
0.0446166582,
0.0281110127,
0.043006923,
0.0155708957,
-0.0834660307,
-0.0549648069,
-0.0266444162,
-0.0325731225,
-0.0417194106,
0.0273872204,
0.0275083184,
0.0041596699,
0.0058578844,
-0.0059002712,
-0.0184249338,
-0.018437393,
0.0444651693,
-0.0289633218,
-0.0267805588,
0.0556584299,
0.0135258418,
0.0300815888,
0.0096256128,
-0.0173399094,
-0.0050330199,
-0.0291753262,
-0.0281633176,
-0.0123291779,
-0.0237344224,
0.0303376038,
-0.0118974019,
-0.0260221362,
-0.0033201745,
-0.0704553202,
-0.0674437881,
0.0390908308,
-0.017403489,
0.0356356278,
0.0147057166,
0.0018302049,
-0.0345345996,
0.0143518522,
-0.0204395298,
-0.0105524315,
-0.0197905861,
0.0316545106,
0.0255017243,
0.079438597,
0.007207864,
0.0076210126,
0.0129963225,
-0.016611781,
-0.0522348061,
-0.0738168061,
0.0149032855,
-0.0452044383,
-0.0123288138,
-0.0347355157,
0.0580969714,
-0.0043577189,
-0.0119559467,
0.0194820482,
0.0446235165,
0.0408081599,
-0.0265036225,
0.0644838288,
0.0409119315,
-0.045670066,
-0.0274989195,
0.0529062115,
-0.0259264689,
0.0346173681,
-0.0469408706,
-0.045361083,
-0.0079891915,
0.0090888068,
0.0237133633,
0.0276167355,
-0.0038464058,
-0.0168750715,
-0.0601560548,
-0.0393445678,
-0.0329920612,
0.0051271045,
0.0109394332,
-0.0217354372,
0.0087205935,
0.0718340948,
-0.0009965634,
-0.0467454419,
-0.0483593717,
0.0088976473,
-0.0399516188,
0.0250708442,
-0.0520209,
-6.340168371e-33,
0.0119759617,
-0.0764316246,
-0.0131833199,
-0.0300727058,
0.0251161084,
-0.0384787023,
-0.0517125465,
0.0286996998,
-0.0150300208,
0.0307633728,
-0.0371137038,
0.0127610909,
-0.0020976833,
-0.0243204571,
0.0265807882,
-0.0237372946,
0.0597441532,
0.0125193642,
-0.0237487853,
0.0124057047,
0.0196121335,
-0.0366116501,
0.0340723582,
-0.0762431845,
0.1063702181,
0.023420088,
-0.0336750597,
0.0179171506,
-0.0327551104,
0.0595584363,
-0.0024130233,
0.0204316434,
0.0140166022,
-0.0652885139,
0.010371943,
0.035448648,
-0.0209393781,
0.002002198,
0.0738857016,
-0.0055639246,
-0.0828962103,
-0.0525623001,
0.0473900102,
-0.0146590816,
-0.0140786693,
0.0251749996,
0.0426416248,
-0.004166327,
0.0110710422,
0.0353765935,
-0.0371071398,
0.001333094,
-0.049291864,
-0.0161823519,
-0.0167455506,
0.0655691475,
-0.0305659845,
0.0173783749,
-0.0332347043,
0.0192996673,
0.0549789965,
-0.00004434,
0.0849244073,
-0.0117374295,
-0.0106646698,
0.0456689484,
-0.0143017909,
0.0290205963,
-0.0526181608,
0.0142759243,
-0.0152267981,
0.0238254834,
0.0801750943,
0.0516032949,
0.009250842,
-0.0086467452,
-0.0337788053,
0.0231083818,
-0.0677927881,
0.0400205292,
0.0470592193,
0.0194798782,
-0.0654665455,
-0.0073047914,
-0.0821454674,
-0.0133518446,
-0.0480774008,
-0.068145968,
0.0212645549,
-0.0168026444,
-0.0462294817,
-0.0089223571,
-0.0293271653,
-0.0416507274,
-0.0148449857,
-0.0078708306,
-0.0310852863,
-0.0084305657,
-0.0077194935,
-0.0201636404,
-0.0336411633,
0.0370642841,
-0.0014506717,
0.0317582861,
0.0306299105,
0.0133131519,
0.0242445562,
-0.0018151968,
-0.021441713,
-0.0173142534,
-0.0422325581,
0.0125799403,
-0.0133678829,
-0.0268424004,
0.0238571074,
0.0445209257,
-0.0430099815,
0.0445228405,
0.0110333906,
-0.0226640534,
-0.0258678328,
-0.012522703,
-0.0067309011,
-0.0079405634,
-0.0318837874,
-0.0456695817,
-0.0158403739,
0.0070861843,
0.0355764702,
-0.0115430206,
-0.0337890722,
-0.0062786844,
2.694e-7,
0.0445777103,
0.0510433279,
0.0163500905,
-0.0202890616,
0.0175332353,
0.0605620891,
0.018291302,
-0.0381389186,
0.0328230672,
-0.0241305288,
-0.0112989536,
0.0056105442,
0.0288062245,
0.0062455731,
-0.0052876608,
-0.0045932163,
-0.0590372272,
0.0012654572,
-0.0140092904,
0.0222780053,
0.084784925,
0.0047630486,
0.0016424893,
0.0148663577,
-0.0319933854,
0.0148245525,
0.034282364,
-0.0543365665,
-0.0014573517,
-0.0070068063,
0.0644475818,
-0.0044999383,
0.0612911098,
-0.0205641855,
-0.010660571,
-0.0326595455,
-0.0235403199,
0.0434333086,
-0.0294676367,
-0.058154542,
-0.048025161,
-0.0012108753,
0.0573094003,
-0.1127774641,
0.0416755304,
-0.043182902,
-0.0615886487,
-0.0234452505,
-0.0158696827,
-0.0428766683,
-0.0053402917,
-0.0270231124,
-0.0072141709,
0.0250200294,
-0.0158167556,
0.0148876198,
-0.0077350084,
-0.0384714194,
-0.0383694172,
0.0011781579,
0.0306919329,
0.0125256488,
-0.0171195101,
0.0039583105,
0.0346775353,
-0.0547405556,
-0.000540772,
2.113716085e-34,
0.0102136014,
0.0364113972,
0.0599036925,
0.0446432941,
0.0726306811,
0.0420057587,
0.0228994451,
-0.010559001,
0.0576936938,
-0.019873077,
-0.0410005897
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09552v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09552v1 | Large Language Models are Few-Shot Training Example Generators: A Case Study in Fallacy Recognition | 2023-11-16T04:17:47 | 2023-11-16T04:17:47 | Tariq Alhindi, Smaranda Muresan, Preslav Nakov | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recognizing fallacies is crucial for ensuring the quality and validity of
arguments across various domains. However, computational fallacy recognition
faces challenges due to the diverse genres, domains, and types of fallacies
found in datasets. This leads to a highly multiclass, and even multi-label,
setup with substantial class imbalance. In this study, we aim to enhance
existing models for fallacy recognition by incorporating additional context and
by leveraging large language models to generate synthetic data, thus increasing
the representation of the infrequent classes. We experiment with GPT3.5 to
generate synthetic examples and we examine the impact of prompt settings for
this. Moreover, we explore zero-shot and few-shot scenarios to evaluate the
effectiveness of using the generated examples for training smaller models
within a unified fallacy recognition framework. Furthermore, we analyze the
overlap between the synthetic data and existing fallacy datasets. Finally, we
investigate the usefulness of providing supplementary context for detecting
fallacy types that need such context, e.g., diversion fallacies. Our evaluation
results demonstrate consistent improvements across fallacy types, datasets, and
generators. | [
0.0359409861,
0.0333457291,
-0.0042873747,
0.0626201481,
-0.0450335331,
0.0391968042,
0.0377453119,
0.0339078717,
0.0054916088,
-0.0854064748,
0.0180446431,
-0.021487087,
-0.0163886212,
0.0142240133,
0.0278070308,
-0.0683005229,
0.0685392246,
-0.0106450059,
0.0261784755,
-0.021191556,
0.026873339,
0.0256417766,
-0.0250576735,
0.016554907,
-0.0091932379,
-0.0467717163,
0.0251395945,
0.0057975063,
0.0358748958,
-0.0087919207,
0.0654321462,
0.0764957145,
0.0379107855,
0.0575691201,
0.000001906,
-0.0243395548,
0.0199786257,
0.0079464754,
-0.0466005802,
0.0148684531,
0.065625079,
-0.000180868,
-0.0111060059,
0.0473334379,
0.0156123014,
-0.0235737413,
0.0394202247,
0.0911637023,
0.0516678244,
0.0814789981,
0.0103563871,
-0.0381175242,
0.009050102,
-0.0190240089,
-0.0059869513,
-0.0133399377,
0.0370410196,
0.0294494461,
-0.0550828278,
0.022144109,
-0.0028631729,
-0.0433909371,
0.0411462672,
0.0114092575,
-0.0027076961,
0.0310969315,
-0.0438585356,
-0.0022437684,
-0.0199240539,
0.0154782096,
-0.0146585451,
-0.0793558061,
-0.010126153,
-0.0263000876,
0.0260957517,
0.0125603415,
-0.0081149787,
0.0178748742,
-0.0481044985,
-0.0047747153,
0.0592951253,
-0.0427284986,
0.0223908257,
0.0433718488,
0.062902309,
-0.0172927808,
0.0141380569,
-0.0443148427,
0.0163751934,
-0.008359245,
0.0109431259,
-0.0411730297,
-0.0248324219,
0.0021501549,
-0.0090734949,
0.0326762758,
-0.0276969485,
-0.0068489616,
0.0701476634,
-0.048619289,
0.0238373429,
-0.0032741353,
-0.0132424012,
0.0461863875,
-0.0043403427,
0.0267627835,
-0.0027041235,
0.0024150573,
0.001049712,
-0.01890219,
-0.0499052219,
-0.0366523676,
-0.0237374976,
0.0282326899,
-0.0163629744,
0.0292976853,
-0.0542509891,
-0.0412601717,
-0.0474172607,
-0.0213052053,
0.0004589283,
0.0408248082,
-0.0258880462,
-0.0312330686,
-0.0573432893,
0.0654946044,
-0.003157004,
0.0567925796,
0.0025219114,
-0.0747142211,
-0.0150793027,
0.0358375944,
-0.0230191089,
-0.0032914528,
0.0062014675,
0.0151643669,
0.0122690918,
-0.0104023498,
-0.0737570152,
-0.0159351733,
-0.0523224808,
-0.0526405387,
0.0029398603,
-0.1050133333,
-0.0131984055,
-0.0514668077,
-0.0039314157,
-0.0324943773,
-0.008061517,
0.0439378619,
-0.0352686569,
0.0071133119,
-0.006515088,
-0.0161622893,
0.0887459591,
0.0320072845,
-0.0141915549,
0.0808852986,
-0.0292715412,
0.0040990598,
0.0047501465,
-0.0335750207,
0.0375462845,
-0.0147937201,
0.013969359,
0.0404193588,
0.0085115908,
0.0222559739,
-0.0034031163,
0.0140560614,
0.0388642848,
0.0162241794,
-0.040155068,
-0.0323643424,
0.053295251,
0.0129622323,
0.0438012704,
0.0221817959,
0.0706506148,
-0.025672229,
-0.0102107767,
-0.0186726823,
-0.0455188453,
-0.027103873,
-0.037080653,
-0.023469951,
0.0032589631,
0.0438740216,
-0.0014258327,
-0.0411889218,
-0.0001967272,
0.0063866279,
-0.0462097786,
0.0120675182,
0.0318041146,
0.0530611128,
-0.0364240929,
0.0622272231,
0.0682577342,
-0.0333190933,
-0.0286008082,
-0.0150036532,
0.0363491587,
0.0231911819,
0.0183841307,
-0.0129303383,
-0.0017052094,
-0.0308760256,
0.0365435295,
0.05732866,
0.132599175,
-0.0440137237,
-0.0196123421,
-0.0228305142,
-0.0093605304,
-0.0120006669,
0.0580701195,
0.0197216552,
0.038011305,
0.0127191627,
0.0265500899,
-0.0118759843,
-0.0346695594,
0.030559862,
-0.007513002,
-0.0012542789,
-0.011695981,
-0.006207048,
0.0284987316,
-0.0088606859,
-0.0025095255,
-0.033082325,
0.0227133669,
0.0071312846,
-0.0124904318,
-0.047912471,
-0.0212950651,
-0.0396350399,
0.0092085907,
-0.0172462203,
-0.0367547162,
-0.0202268846,
-0.0600956902,
0.0313085504,
0.0171914827,
-0.0139245791,
0.0031661091,
-0.0450601131,
-0.0129456772,
-0.014612129,
0.0021058305,
-0.010991158,
0.1385269463,
0.0095264073,
0.0355615914,
-0.0313436352,
0.0043164585,
0.0017195197,
-0.0391168743,
0.031781666,
-0.0079729063,
0.0127631733,
0.0117081096,
0.0156018445,
0.0018424294,
-0.0614847057,
0.0010630335,
-0.0655768216,
0.0137393586,
-0.0325921215,
0.0126846367,
0.0291195214,
-0.0409404673,
-0.0155688869,
-0.0038551975,
-0.0159297381,
-0.043264851,
0.0075919819,
0.009345266,
0.0299830083,
-0.0308725573,
0.0102555593,
0.0084010335,
0.0314262658,
-0.0191896614,
0.009793357,
0.0107269688,
0.0402942449,
-0.0152278654,
0.0358171612,
-0.0082467943,
-0.0036112994,
-0.0053529143,
-0.0146743078,
0.001295303,
0.0262668189,
0.0008933509,
0.0365065411,
0.0207098089,
0.063540794,
0.0329797976,
0.0089855567,
-0.0093390457,
-0.0262318067,
-0.0066922517,
0.0170287639,
-0.0110332472,
-0.0493856035,
-0.0018460572,
0.0712030977,
0.0241554193,
0.0139488922,
-0.0383943617,
0.0358320326,
-0.0323897973,
-0.0181212034,
0.052475594,
-0.0112370681,
-0.0505310297,
-0.0209412854,
-0.0368882976,
-0.028112324,
0.0497258753,
-0.0180054363,
0.040361695,
-0.0258379951,
-0.0166416354,
-0.022491904,
-0.0232681967,
0.0017531337,
0.0070770802,
0.0487185866,
-0.0138851916,
-0.0285981074,
-0.0163158085,
0.0543072559,
-0.0072734468,
0.0256690439,
-0.0806575716,
-0.0088790478,
-0.011244596,
-0.0672040284,
-0.0474771783,
-0.0603430681,
-0.0117302714,
-0.0423672609,
-0.0815394595,
0.0233853217,
-0.0375539996,
-0.0706365854,
0.0033094615,
0.0486547276,
0.0128842182,
0.0087094689,
0.0237836465,
0.0354518779,
0.0344786756,
0.0124871712,
0.015273626,
-0.0001687971,
0.0305617154,
0.0700624064,
-0.0013794511,
0.0459292717,
-0.0451472774,
-0.0083405813,
-0.0344877467,
-0.017676685,
-0.001464972,
0.0277660619,
-0.0038801674,
-0.0656990334,
-0.0090901498,
0.0843961015,
0.0099762315,
-0.0071344525,
-0.0133628557,
-0.0018461305,
0.0205741543,
0.0261442326,
-0.0557716526,
-0.092452608,
-0.0429801941,
-0.0097036399,
-0.0022326829,
-0.0698239952,
0.0165810827,
0.0194618795,
-0.1499409378,
0.0708404034,
0.0062950151,
-0.025430385,
-0.012867298,
-0.0419688784,
0.0260179266,
0.0258074421,
0.0168784689,
-0.0026585581,
0.0027122372,
-0.0068343705,
0.0214106329,
-0.0367226228,
-0.0872138739,
0.0320450962,
0.0262754969,
0.044795949,
0.0096876901,
0.0482472479,
-0.0315554701,
0.0212929305,
0.0330710746,
-0.0766634569,
-0.0370972641,
-0.0018351069,
0.0696556941,
0.0051385644,
0.001206305,
-0.0083211018,
0.0715784878,
-0.0102578439,
-0.0473128073,
0.0151627222,
0.0806642324,
0.020626368,
-0.0556365065,
-0.0083203921,
-0.0121834567,
0.0250022728,
0.0505487509,
0.0189029686,
0.0301156957,
-0.0381973907,
-0.0389719121,
-0.0430335626,
-0.0328463428,
-0.0238726474,
0.0600543581,
0.0362125412,
-0.0307117272,
-0.0211299267,
-0.0610096604,
0.020073276,
-0.0433860645,
0.0060478956,
-0.0062833121,
-0.0282046627,
0.0143919736,
-0.0048036049,
0.0206331108,
-0.0372798741,
0.0093628187,
-0.0193986744,
-0.0250064153,
-0.0168665554,
0.0036082773,
-0.0296637248,
0.0543788709,
-0.0504441671,
-0.0367838964,
0.0074404874,
0.0158615224,
0.0137417354,
0.0602771789,
-0.0060633607,
0.0051793652,
0.0532913581,
0.0230788924,
-0.0045796172,
0.0290045235,
0.0081251822,
-0.0511953384,
0.0148736304,
0.000278055,
-0.009074403,
0.062364798,
0.045253925,
-0.0083962195,
-0.0639684722,
0.0591250882,
0.0520290323,
-0.0254177023,
0.0436536521,
0.0063357586,
0.0025141372,
-0.0383158885,
-0.0017638673,
-0.0241680872,
-0.0633485541,
0.0297626201,
0.0455904976,
0.0238782857,
-0.0245820563,
-0.0090622585,
-0.0307488535,
-0.0509047881,
0.0176718421,
-0.0192530565,
0.0017960584,
0.0686827898,
0.0417059958,
0.0219622273,
-0.0271845944,
-0.0521884337,
-0.0328937769,
-0.0007899819,
0.0315616205,
0.0185641292,
0.0554792024,
0.0329826027,
0.0110028861,
0.0305740796,
-0.0669056326,
-0.0265999343,
-0.0018804669,
-0.0194518268,
0.0270877853,
0.0167206153,
-0.0280781388,
-0.0017271654,
-0.0100069689,
-0.0526207499,
-0.0217854921,
0.0063159666,
0.0030788686,
-0.0598981678,
0.0490309633,
0.0314888917,
-0.0278388187,
-0.0119596515,
0.0288251638,
0.0304738525,
0.0709492192,
0.032020282,
-0.0119107822,
-0.0352373496,
-0.0325847939,
-0.009769666,
-0.011802475,
0.0159262102,
0.0114470674,
-0.0980166048,
-0.0582464226,
0.0259497724,
0.0247297958,
0.0376205109,
0.0083599817,
0.0145491445,
0.0643230677,
-0.0092285993,
0.0280610677,
-0.016120851,
0.0209978465,
-0.0485940613,
-0.0104370415,
-0.0393743254,
-5.844330895e-33,
-0.0111377435,
-0.0825415477,
-0.0041382504,
-0.0169140827,
0.035284061,
0.0027347135,
-0.0068809064,
-0.0329646245,
-0.0262022149,
0.08711043,
0.033054851,
0.0422104858,
-0.0004366193,
0.0159020666,
-0.0217132438,
-0.0292438231,
0.0201045908,
-0.0140559021,
-0.0416817293,
0.0318361521,
0.0171815809,
-0.0189150516,
0.0517115444,
-0.0364991464,
0.0245375223,
-0.0101936543,
-0.0186688434,
-0.0055905222,
-0.0532227121,
0.0733148456,
-0.0089766504,
0.0930601656,
0.0358781479,
-0.0284803044,
0.0291709192,
0.0514601618,
-0.0496174172,
-0.0272522252,
0.0263946205,
-0.0160811003,
0.01992869,
-0.0423037075,
0.0043298751,
0.0187894776,
-0.0134658916,
-0.0439648032,
0.0279267728,
-0.0560273901,
0.0113279307,
-0.0211146977,
-0.0786693841,
0.0143261524,
-0.0155890789,
0.0118686259,
-0.0659193695,
0.0684062764,
0.0097948052,
0.0474357754,
-0.0217244253,
0.0146596925,
0.0162930544,
-0.018666504,
-0.0168159232,
-0.0379434228,
-0.0346946716,
0.063022472,
-0.0104901735,
-0.0048385132,
-0.0211168975,
0.0156570468,
-0.0338068604,
0.0145562999,
0.0795352682,
0.0813888311,
0.0686395839,
-0.020553261,
-0.0808670372,
-0.0571010001,
0.0219256394,
0.0132617708,
0.0107223149,
-0.0557003133,
-0.0404458605,
-0.0076661971,
-0.0534569249,
-0.0713258088,
-0.0285661463,
-0.0098837204,
0.056701526,
0.0346028134,
0.0289474837,
0.0381323136,
-0.0180781726,
-0.0165344737,
0.0006728119,
0.0252530444,
-0.0151637392,
-0.0299537182,
0.0090469234,
0.018278854,
-0.0291162711,
-0.0240162089,
0.0158045255,
0.0060620825,
0.0251373034,
-0.0069222832,
0.0954641625,
-0.0319224149,
-0.0563680753,
0.0123295039,
-0.042691879,
0.0251511503,
-0.0172543786,
0.0393337309,
0.0361260064,
0.0139923915,
0.0080609862,
0.0159495715,
0.011348811,
-0.0437916927,
-0.0510096587,
0.0319778286,
-0.0405218489,
0.0376773328,
-0.0343375914,
-0.0208654925,
-0.0029888523,
-0.0013357595,
0.04272113,
-0.0660467744,
0.0031775725,
-0.0139240166,
2.463e-7,
0.032459531,
0.0397941694,
-0.0281348191,
0.0014746669,
0.0218357947,
0.0556861162,
0.0036776098,
0.0340481289,
0.0081916004,
-0.0446672253,
-0.0369255468,
0.0378122255,
0.0359383896,
0.0035564976,
-0.0745384544,
0.0254077446,
-0.0522094071,
-0.0252547748,
-0.0530995764,
0.0024725981,
0.0402882956,
0.0885232165,
0.0343584605,
-0.0454402827,
0.0063377763,
-0.011843537,
0.0572089553,
0.0258368105,
-0.0163373519,
-0.0033472152,
0.0015847473,
-0.0082095461,
0.0012774984,
0.0596542805,
-0.0255142171,
0.0042069941,
-0.0173509326,
0.034950573,
-0.0191939417,
-0.0006190724,
-0.0626553819,
-0.0065698917,
0.0087483777,
-0.0387860797,
0.0578648672,
-0.0513366796,
0.008898004,
-0.0392047651,
-0.069235988,
-0.0071401326,
0.0052435291,
-0.0120026646,
-0.0158389285,
-0.021693917,
0.002325648,
0.0131655615,
0.0136517566,
-0.0314154327,
0.0097874179,
0.0446012653,
-0.0465033315,
-0.0351836905,
0.0076503749,
-0.0088590877,
0.0347147025,
-0.0369925052,
0.033950109,
2.203991296e-34,
0.0221197996,
-0.015666537,
0.0209395476,
-0.0028808932,
0.0404058062,
0.0233049858,
0.0113950884,
-0.0112107741,
0.0043155202,
0.0058913478,
0.0019892657
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09550v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09550v1 | A Speed Odyssey for Deployable Quantization of LLMs | 2023-11-16T04:11:19 | 2023-11-16T04:11:19 | Qingyuan Li, Ran Meng, Yiduo Li, Bo Zhang, Liang Li, Yifan Lu, Xiangxiang Chu, Yerui Sun, Yuchen Xie | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | The large language model era urges faster and less costly inference. Prior
model compression works on LLMs tend to undertake a software-centric approach
primarily focused on the simulated quantization performance. By neglecting the
feasibility of deployment, these approaches are typically disabled in real
practice. They used to drastically push down the quantization bit range for a
reduced computation which might not be supported by the mainstream hardware, or
involve sophisticated algorithms that introduce extra computation or memory
access overhead. We argue that pursuing a hardware-centric approach in the
construction of quantization algorithms is crucial. In this regard, we are
driven to build our compression method on top of hardware awareness,
eliminating impractical algorithm choices while maximizing the benefit of
hardware acceleration. Our method, OdysseyLLM, comes with a novel W4A8 kernel
implementation called FastGEMM and a combined recipe of quantization
strategies. Extensive experiments manifest the superiority of our W4A8 method
which brings the actual speed boosting up to \textbf{4$\times$} compared to
Hugging Face FP16 inference and \textbf{2.23$\times$} vs. the state-of-the-art
inference engine TensorRT-LLM in FP16, and \textbf{1.45$\times$} vs.
TensorRT-LLM in INT8, yet without substantially harming the performance. | [
-0.0584717244,
0.0550191887,
-0.0177802537,
0.0619234517,
-0.0606846735,
-0.0065385965,
-0.0079988027,
0.0322273448,
-0.0023869947,
-0.0101180486,
0.0287394524,
-0.0077526453,
0.0155570703,
-0.0116462912,
0.0354755558,
0.018773675,
0.0434984341,
-0.0237158723,
-0.026732007,
-0.0312693939,
-0.0301468559,
0.0109894844,
0.0203532968,
0.0087001696,
0.0270484183,
-0.0136854658,
-0.0313331783,
0.0250777584,
-0.005501614,
0.012007894,
-0.0288195834,
0.0291037392,
0.0353326052,
0.0318748094,
0.0000020834,
-0.0113121076,
-0.0283517409,
0.0376888104,
-0.035601642,
0.0501442887,
0.0102198208,
-0.0165151414,
-0.0463977978,
0.0094062015,
0.0059506753,
-0.0029825685,
0.0512167998,
-0.0165441614,
0.0208612382,
0.0225866493,
0.0010666632,
-0.0125368377,
0.041228272,
0.0064505418,
-0.0196029879,
-0.0176364612,
0.0050955885,
0.0022819708,
-0.0080829309,
0.0046844869,
-0.0216196179,
0.0176155772,
0.0129520399,
0.0293156635,
-0.030074954,
0.0247309674,
-0.0468353294,
-0.0138782179,
-0.0265070163,
0.019712666,
-0.0511445999,
-0.0594915263,
0.0098275971,
0.0320673883,
-0.0468986668,
-0.069150269,
-0.0388962775,
0.0707396418,
-0.0089326557,
0.0389711782,
0.054041557,
-0.0235920046,
0.0374401398,
-0.0089451289,
-0.033787068,
0.0929686725,
0.0732027665,
0.0166536458,
-0.0206626561,
-0.002496646,
-0.0592110381,
-0.0589713864,
-0.0081251534,
0.0139324488,
0.0122064343,
-0.0091036577,
-0.0819402933,
0.0214276742,
0.0143605545,
-0.0545362271,
0.0325322077,
0.0711795911,
0.0079634096,
0.002305777,
-0.0553336889,
0.0182763673,
-0.0408221669,
-0.0055183051,
-0.0319089666,
0.0241981521,
0.0294922981,
-0.0000323442,
-0.031540744,
0.0372292586,
-0.0293106604,
0.0134142516,
-0.0593801402,
0.0074622091,
0.004070885,
-0.001808909,
0.002303821,
-0.0287117306,
-0.0139227938,
0.0027321537,
0.0109680369,
-0.0011202688,
-0.0216592755,
0.0011530836,
-0.0518147498,
-0.0887668952,
-0.0283989888,
0.0408641249,
-0.0138422027,
-0.0315265059,
0.0478278771,
0.0413737409,
0.0111812335,
-0.0543437228,
-0.0118910233,
-0.0198588576,
0.0187858753,
-0.0694018081,
0.0199861284,
-0.086876221,
-0.0021922763,
-0.0002792749,
0.0026541224,
-0.0060781697,
0.0182995871,
-0.0020896799,
-0.0024054586,
0.0294778943,
-0.0180352367,
-0.0075228279,
-0.0096739689,
0.0056646122,
0.0585511774,
0.0861762837,
0.0172528047,
0.0340284631,
0.0038469208,
0.0130495988,
-0.0164472461,
0.0679289028,
0.0353637077,
0.0201295596,
-0.0408232771,
-0.0146397734,
-0.0069513926,
0.0281390268,
0.0726287663,
0.0869930759,
-0.0283677727,
-0.0384089947,
0.0002679268,
0.0690219402,
0.0354060531,
0.0263334792,
0.0107772034,
0.021306565,
0.0087697515,
-0.00595984,
-0.0173761547,
0.0132190622,
-0.0073662237,
0.0181801077,
0.085084565,
0.0663895011,
-0.0110390298,
-0.0073281103,
-0.0366645157,
-0.0001614093,
-0.0086247995,
0.0118344463,
0.0230011623,
-0.0234728493,
-0.0082374439,
0.1223579794,
0.0369211845,
-0.0665195063,
-0.053310141,
-0.1063346565,
0.0153918136,
0.0169477873,
0.0514532812,
0.0014053142,
-0.0085610263,
0.0317910314,
-0.0379578806,
0.0011317013,
-0.0174295548,
0.0229832996,
0.0306414589,
-0.0337045901,
-0.0104564084,
0.0113707725,
0.0168658402,
0.0023703938,
0.0666575283,
0.0086527467,
-0.0101090884,
-0.0518880822,
0.0025376698,
0.0044747316,
0.0230640452,
-0.0401678085,
0.0087319473,
-0.0013580432,
0.027505029,
0.0034451163,
-0.0201103147,
-0.0124076419,
0.0653244704,
-0.0464879833,
0.0371212922,
-0.0577354841,
0.0071737552,
-0.0197854061,
0.0929889604,
-0.0264241304,
0.0265415199,
0.0362377949,
-0.0618989281,
-0.0478963368,
0.049312789,
-0.0330815092,
0.0414270237,
-0.0376639739,
0.0151951239,
-0.0129635436,
0.046186164,
-0.0123343151,
0.0305947792,
-0.0290226154,
0.0023625358,
0.0224745721,
0.0066842651,
0.0143217081,
-0.0000336868,
-0.0386223421,
0.0094213458,
0.0320326611,
0.0272507239,
-0.0368438624,
-0.0166263506,
0.0261632986,
-0.0082902322,
-0.0982071012,
0.0229409412,
-0.0291994829,
0.0449878797,
0.030471839,
0.0415571406,
0.007953994,
0.0081273289,
-0.014937643,
0.0225777812,
0.0023102723,
-0.0091271959,
0.0033200276,
-0.0356724039,
-0.0428732522,
-0.022128379,
-0.0432017595,
0.0015852578,
0.0320905447,
-0.0867698342,
-0.042111136,
-0.0810519084,
0.0124504939,
-0.0252039228,
0.0436136685,
-0.0192971528,
-0.0261693001,
0.0178235658,
-0.0543073416,
0.0350470841,
0.0279064924,
-0.0216177851,
0.0195713639,
0.0715117678,
0.0080013191,
-0.0419955738,
0.0231193695,
0.0039641275,
-0.0700296238,
0.0012728357,
-0.0466808192,
-0.0422490574,
0.0734698176,
-0.0201542694,
-0.046647165,
-0.0157408714,
-0.0411007218,
0.013916892,
-0.0152682709,
-0.0178754944,
0.0165622011,
-0.023013968,
0.0477406271,
0.0064208214,
-0.0686090216,
0.021813754,
-0.06978219,
-0.0019169059,
-0.001253382,
-0.0480007716,
-0.0511463024,
0.0652828217,
0.0147998547,
0.0381316394,
-0.0094528683,
0.0054489663,
-0.0100124832,
0.0330978818,
-0.0067576151,
-0.056564115,
0.0541027971,
-0.0223038401,
0.0191114955,
-0.0536316559,
0.0153679485,
0.0394286402,
0.0300372485,
-0.0289167855,
0.0048951171,
0.0273661744,
-0.0375068337,
0.056877166,
0.0525251664,
-0.0101906229,
0.0314861014,
-0.0040678354,
-0.0013959426,
-0.0135378512,
0.0155746359,
0.0094729876,
0.0004593667,
0.018702969,
-0.0007143983,
-0.02072745,
0.045373451,
0.0331762508,
0.0533599332,
-0.0761668906,
-0.0229874365,
0.0721949786,
-0.004842544,
-0.0557838231,
0.0404327214,
0.04499593,
-0.0369769894,
0.0054254797,
0.0620814599,
0.0239543188,
-0.0152521553,
0.0138447629,
0.0172610264,
0.0682804957,
0.0177237112,
0.0531026013,
-0.1153912246,
-0.0217107311,
0.0378142148,
0.0072183493,
0.0043752543,
0.0086198384,
-0.0270750187,
-0.0521176271,
0.0495122559,
0.0397599563,
0.0433088094,
-0.0060351714,
-0.0311123282,
-0.0115736388,
-0.0074951528,
0.0423105136,
0.022393072,
0.0046957722,
0.0201501343,
-0.0247767605,
-0.0176344477,
-0.0011090916,
0.0282995235,
0.0233887825,
0.0430901833,
0.0141951982,
0.0188476145,
-0.0192204509,
-0.0207194965,
0.0170335118,
0.0232040156,
-0.0105198845,
-0.0544742197,
0.0071152598,
0.0196079649,
-0.0063128374,
-0.0015380014,
-0.0165515002,
0.0218025073,
-0.0013861591,
-0.0251308642,
0.0652065873,
-0.0332143866,
-0.0155223599,
-0.0046129553,
-0.0293725207,
-0.0323417783,
0.0434453115,
-0.0019446698,
0.0287178475,
-0.0487750918,
-0.0388371497,
-0.02375203,
0.0116954437,
-0.0701764748,
-0.0474966839,
-0.0074877469,
-0.0349162668,
0.0159655102,
0.0628784746,
0.0111410832,
0.0169142578,
-0.0150366612,
-0.0144393817,
-0.0207812693,
-0.0311132856,
-0.1468078345,
-0.0141097018,
-0.0448938906,
0.0494524278,
-0.0205856208,
0.0139211956,
0.0084648393,
-0.0042613312,
-0.0034629686,
0.0296597406,
-0.0995161682,
-0.0710200071,
-0.0204766579,
0.0427186415,
0.0311405193,
0.0423329361,
-0.0020031214,
-0.0281728115,
0.0540293008,
0.0473250151,
-0.0153039023,
0.0901468843,
0.0178695787,
-0.0243760496,
0.0114557939,
0.0148124872,
-0.0103475088,
0.0247396901,
0.007365983,
0.0274917446,
-0.008115842,
-0.0776246414,
-0.016955927,
0.0370045453,
0.0423684642,
-0.0254200734,
0.0108491797,
0.0430513844,
0.0350359902,
0.0018874813,
0.0047210283,
-0.037985228,
0.0187519696,
0.0046030846,
-0.0168749504,
-0.0167163033,
-0.0256783515,
0.0425161496,
0.0221712384,
0.0289454162,
-0.0000102158,
-0.0473771319,
-0.0101461047,
0.04716314,
-0.0114419013,
-0.0112529323,
-0.0149356425,
-0.0003026529,
0.0699921623,
-0.04539188,
0.0156006841,
-0.0285769738,
0.038358774,
-0.0308408272,
0.0299964491,
-0.0183499325,
-0.0748480558,
-0.0336874612,
0.0288386494,
0.0608708747,
0.0445280224,
0.0529092513,
-0.0211979765,
-0.0064868913,
-0.0146424975,
0.037382815,
-0.0160021186,
0.0008612201,
0.0419471227,
0.0160500724,
-0.0227894913,
-0.0016883058,
0.0274662413,
0.0133854523,
0.0236822404,
0.0188433323,
0.0006062899,
-0.0426619165,
-0.071455203,
-0.0535681024,
0.0088903978,
0.0108836358,
-0.0303250719,
-0.0271464307,
-0.0300510526,
-0.0011974473,
0.0428045355,
-0.0168918781,
-0.0428446829,
0.0015315776,
0.044762969,
0.0353170186,
-0.0587464049,
-0.0257081911,
-0.0188725665,
0.0161522757,
-0.0109847058,
0.0176197477,
-6.079026056e-33,
-0.0454610549,
0.0268606152,
0.0133948959,
-0.0210149903,
-0.031697046,
0.0101756034,
-0.0142741213,
-0.0156967398,
-0.0076182568,
-0.0406388305,
-0.0114882886,
0.0193709861,
0.028100878,
-0.0172808953,
-0.0374898724,
0.0351985544,
0.0495614894,
0.0051258425,
-0.0214623064,
0.0183948483,
-0.0072909389,
0.0074521694,
0.0430965759,
0.0070266034,
-0.0406852961,
-0.0104655838,
0.0303335786,
-0.0164808314,
0.0048051211,
0.0192376096,
-0.0429908782,
0.0115093738,
-0.0136848753,
-0.019331567,
-0.0010897019,
-0.0133466572,
-0.0579013899,
-0.0010919069,
0.046775762,
0.0179343484,
-0.0164003447,
-0.071955502,
0.0073701823,
0.0560300127,
-0.038391266,
-0.059116222,
-0.0506504551,
-0.0129926866,
-0.039854899,
-0.0504520237,
-0.0160140451,
0.0300168507,
0.0424736105,
0.0637813509,
0.0758216158,
-0.0393067338,
-0.0488743633,
-0.0323881917,
-0.0208231546,
-0.0062494245,
0.0299128424,
0.0810884163,
0.0821024403,
-0.0134372571,
-0.0010579972,
0.0193985999,
0.0341915749,
-0.0404084139,
-0.0298668165,
0.0628960282,
0.0265310146,
0.0264488049,
0.0008772372,
0.0484896898,
0.0837016478,
0.0214866791,
-0.0538145006,
-0.0056039644,
0.0305316765,
0.0090689035,
0.0170862544,
0.0238655061,
-0.0182930212,
-0.0476608351,
-0.0236542933,
0.0253482871,
-0.0353599861,
-0.0370591693,
-0.0314840525,
-0.0029436348,
-0.0359657891,
-0.0288028363,
0.0213438459,
-0.0527569205,
0.0003345209,
-0.0105955107,
-0.0081246747,
0.0063860822,
0.0183733236,
0.0344451591,
-0.0019931577,
-0.0273351241,
-0.0051603667,
-0.0235777143,
0.0499124825,
-0.0141618792,
-0.0046926858,
0.0727834627,
-0.0704473108,
-0.0046768212,
-0.0361266881,
-0.0326663889,
-0.0301999114,
0.0024304492,
0.0216256771,
-0.0023198454,
0.0445349663,
-0.0100840507,
0.0026655213,
0.0104997018,
-0.0153462375,
0.0085394932,
0.0390210673,
0.0545386523,
-0.0264477581,
0.007011001,
-0.0476815961,
0.0484158099,
0.0561880395,
-0.0670410693,
-0.0603306815,
0.0419518612,
2.889e-7,
0.033445552,
0.0227581877,
0.0464182384,
0.0349382684,
0.0035047506,
-0.0097663281,
0.0110428631,
0.0237033926,
0.0162950102,
-0.0165029354,
0.0205602981,
0.0444030017,
0.0417460985,
0.0020869116,
-0.0003170652,
0.0140351346,
0.0161491483,
-0.0167434067,
-0.0548787341,
-0.0299938079,
0.0390557759,
0.11481525,
-0.0083547831,
-0.028517073,
0.0294517074,
-0.0118289646,
0.0120985517,
-0.0195529014,
0.0268044658,
-0.0096899765,
-0.0047144312,
0.021166157,
-0.0251915939,
-0.024915982,
0.0048887455,
-0.0146460412,
-0.0822473168,
0.0966327414,
0.0046574757,
-0.007556709,
0.0215541739,
-0.0583754517,
-0.0301443227,
-0.0360092595,
0.0630424097,
0.0399703458,
-0.0089721391,
-0.1051917523,
-0.0204271413,
-0.0154627524,
-0.0378350727,
0.005536654,
0.055463586,
0.0463290624,
0.0216602981,
-0.0195142813,
-0.0098731993,
-0.0731521025,
-0.078817673,
0.0175114926,
-0.0291590486,
-0.0818301812,
-0.0321501754,
0.02653265,
-0.0038324662,
-0.0588314943,
-0.0043220115,
3.03730016e-34,
0.0284503326,
-0.0173725784,
0.0293583088,
0.0444889478,
-0.0041210633,
-0.0382502377,
-0.0031971806,
0.0146751292,
-0.0367428549,
-0.0693161413,
-0.0319939516
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09542v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09542v2 | Pregnant Questions: The Importance of Pragmatic Awareness in Maternal Health Question Answering | 2023-11-16T03:33:01 | 2024-04-02T19:42:21 | Neha Srikanth, Rupak Sarkar, Heran Mane, Elizabeth M. Aparicio, Quynh C. Nguyen, Rachel Rudinger, Jordan Boyd-Graber | cs.CL | cs.CL | Questions posed by information-seeking users often contain implicit false or
potentially harmful assumptions. In a high-risk domain such as maternal and
infant health, a question-answering system must recognize these pragmatic
constraints and go beyond simply answering user questions, examining them in
context to respond helpfully. To achieve this, we study assumptions and
implications, or pragmatic inferences, made when mothers ask questions about
pregnancy and infant care by collecting a dataset of 2,727 inferences from 500
questions across three diverse sources. We study how health experts naturally
address these inferences when writing answers, and illustrate that informing
existing QA pipelines with pragmatic inferences produces responses that are
more complete, mitigating the propagation of harmful beliefs. | [
0.0622501895,
0.0597335733,
-0.0281256754,
-0.0468060523,
0.0008963387,
0.0279543977,
-0.0158766694,
-0.0098528052,
-0.0166075844,
-0.0167705566,
0.0068207495,
-0.0130856065,
-0.0073426617,
-0.0437474325,
-0.0117302546,
-0.0501426347,
-0.0347428843,
0.0477870516,
0.0555390306,
0.0032859952,
0.0307594743,
0.0124765662,
-0.0063055465,
0.0232457705,
-0.0255580693,
-0.0502577722,
0.0360701904,
0.0568768531,
0.0009918809,
-0.0822914392,
0.0600364842,
0.0316427946,
-0.0127867553,
-0.0296313073,
0.0000017093,
-0.0249843206,
-0.0152725643,
0.0098441355,
-0.0325540677,
-0.026194185,
0.0243489388,
-0.0417946875,
0.0017280938,
0.0319947191,
-0.0465174317,
-0.0249022134,
0.0631338358,
0.027454149,
-0.014196232,
0.0051374468,
-0.0104314731,
0.0021865957,
-0.0363107622,
0.0091366079,
0.0152451806,
-0.062655285,
0.0175394434,
0.0177263096,
0.0257908832,
-0.029705815,
0.0149705578,
0.0446521789,
0.0005191662,
-0.011685105,
-0.0446409956,
-0.0054959659,
0.027744133,
-0.0594811961,
0.0090988697,
0.0671921372,
0.0549805202,
-0.0147517286,
-0.0108687039,
-0.0140058035,
-0.005105691,
0.0686220974,
-0.0560893491,
0.0223254822,
-0.0489482507,
-0.032312151,
-0.0152470041,
0.0111994687,
0.0320511311,
0.0265462976,
0.0492283404,
0.0294028353,
-0.0116227316,
-0.0098064924,
-0.030801883,
0.007526353,
0.0106175262,
-0.0104038268,
-0.0036904698,
0.0051141051,
0.0101550538,
0.0245052949,
0.0222631339,
0.0108468933,
0.0618566573,
-0.0228887275,
-0.0283667035,
-0.0002845128,
-0.0280536544,
0.0102661243,
0.0273294188,
-0.0404729694,
-0.0008384718,
-0.0220288895,
-0.0291158985,
0.0305999257,
-0.0020313372,
-0.0062821954,
0.0151050501,
-0.0141093414,
0.0221330673,
0.0787298232,
-0.0088178404,
-0.0172151923,
-0.0623650551,
-0.0215929169,
-0.069945991,
0.0254148804,
-0.0213164184,
-0.0170147084,
-0.0503983609,
0.055648081,
-0.0432219021,
0.077264674,
-0.0334484465,
-0.067155242,
-0.0193430651,
0.0098155811,
0.0366439,
0.0588341691,
0.024537595,
0.0191995706,
0.0086154118,
0.0192852151,
-0.0219901055,
-0.0279072262,
0.0076106391,
-0.0334877968,
-0.0181578435,
-0.0253019985,
0.0204047672,
0.0444495492,
-0.0082826745,
-0.0819489583,
0.0257683359,
0.0659273416,
-0.0329522677,
0.010035878,
-0.0007590008,
0.0493080467,
0.0498127788,
0.0642577857,
-0.016161615,
0.0680121779,
0.0136449682,
-0.0332196876,
0.0297577083,
-0.0119877765,
-0.0037261746,
-0.0148459375,
0.0317736082,
-0.0180186369,
0.0648765638,
0.0863363147,
-0.0358354636,
-0.0212850031,
-0.0190578848,
0.0040831142,
-0.0003814969,
0.0249158368,
0.0238484088,
0.0964672491,
-0.0439383425,
0.0161826648,
0.0426459238,
-0.0287398696,
0.0095806187,
0.0356253274,
0.0124165714,
0.0101812389,
0.0077804285,
-0.0825855434,
-0.0344337672,
0.0184333958,
-0.0583301112,
-0.0490346178,
-0.0565582402,
0.0078514898,
0.008755968,
-0.0073651453,
-0.0216166005,
0.0456583127,
0.0152317025,
0.0547380261,
0.0416781865,
-0.0140766604,
-0.0160441063,
-0.0289035011,
0.0161856674,
0.0291634873,
0.0236141812,
-0.0322803557,
-0.0405074805,
-0.0121149728,
0.0619898699,
-0.004815083,
0.0324462987,
-0.031620346,
-0.0159418657,
0.007428837,
-0.0033745063,
0.0213107951,
0.031569235,
-0.0332545489,
0.0379213691,
0.0153634818,
-0.0088040801,
0.0201027375,
-0.0107833128,
0.033612147,
-0.0386533998,
-0.0271085482,
-0.0004332663,
-0.0000274762,
0.0152929528,
0.0102131544,
0.0296836868,
0.0378878415,
0.0027334376,
0.0051662358,
0.0077423467,
0.0447630249,
0.0013020508,
0.0271981135,
-0.03578531,
-0.0515223444,
-0.0577117838,
-0.0537985675,
-0.0306651313,
0.016832754,
-0.0154744051,
-0.0539812744,
-0.0064510927,
-0.0284150466,
-0.0531302989,
-0.0056106998,
-0.017234968,
-0.0006126849,
0.0233033337,
-0.0225399602,
-0.0014675814,
-0.0002495601,
-0.0663100854,
-0.0552053601,
-0.0162893329,
0.0277028028,
-0.055930391,
0.0196268298,
-0.0224326123,
0.0017154214,
0.0095942542,
-0.0644953251,
0.0263379272,
-0.0610754527,
-0.0297804996,
-0.0275722686,
0.0335584879,
0.0329823978,
0.0118799834,
0.0031720782,
-0.0362013653,
-0.0203277506,
0.012855337,
-0.038574174,
0.0627944022,
0.0223499108,
0.0078367032,
0.0647231713,
-0.0128389951,
0.0267227124,
-0.0320268497,
0.0187854301,
0.0479263403,
0.0555871725,
-0.0107940845,
-0.0734783784,
-0.0728253573,
-0.0365792215,
0.0218738467,
0.0095894774,
-0.0087795025,
0.0247859079,
-0.0246752705,
0.0369656049,
-0.005748109,
-0.0291455612,
-0.028577283,
0.0531247295,
0.0024685736,
0.0057034199,
-0.0317479186,
0.0033629416,
0.0313653126,
-0.0661513582,
-0.0155350296,
0.031322524,
-0.0014591254,
-0.0224538948,
-0.0095251277,
0.0736824721,
-0.0358536541,
-0.0154185966,
-0.0116104605,
-0.0241099373,
0.01859238,
0.0619880967,
-0.0043599545,
-0.0145370988,
0.0341845676,
0.0377946869,
0.0047749006,
-0.037744686,
-0.0293600727,
-0.0505390167,
-0.0030336126,
-0.0182205234,
0.0356996916,
0.0215482451,
0.0154273165,
-0.0548106246,
-0.0454942919,
0.0142185334,
-0.0489844568,
0.0344772972,
-0.0611862764,
0.0083065322,
0.0225457884,
-0.0873735324,
-0.0664420947,
-0.0730496719,
-0.027893357,
-0.0574193411,
-0.0268537216,
-0.0070673963,
0.0119403461,
0.0016814382,
-0.0118885525,
0.0277971998,
0.0245812256,
-0.039785482,
0.0220435932,
-0.0002081307,
0.0346434563,
0.0191268269,
0.0638071895,
-0.0067541949,
0.0188898146,
0.1125077754,
-0.0138260908,
0.0173712149,
0.0356661826,
-0.0113631813,
-0.002618639,
0.0227870811,
0.0167412441,
0.0106871463,
0.0469651334,
-0.0539083108,
-0.0008372605,
0.0045329104,
0.0183109846,
0.0087604169,
0.0123006692,
-0.0486178026,
0.006397373,
-0.0078211566,
0.0166168232,
-0.0855171233,
-0.0170657933,
-0.0269860439,
0.0153177446,
-0.0774715692,
-0.0158604402,
-0.0251567699,
-0.0147625888,
0.0090256035,
-0.0158389583,
-0.001807527,
0.0322437249,
-0.0608254969,
0.043708086,
0.0228066873,
0.0053280313,
0.0127288979,
-0.0126990555,
0.0003567191,
0.0024980272,
-0.0722635984,
-0.0383128747,
0.0412748195,
0.0037666906,
0.0125121502,
0.0369821377,
0.0673238933,
-0.0180939753,
-0.0062805396,
0.0024033468,
-0.0407702588,
-0.0182996728,
-0.0071183438,
-0.0195701607,
0.0015400893,
0.0198739171,
-0.0559753515,
0.0773708597,
-0.0449983925,
-0.0028284299,
0.0422317497,
0.0647831038,
-0.0131175993,
-0.0678917691,
-0.0339242667,
0.0581454523,
0.039459262,
0.0418442637,
0.0160166062,
-0.0288262255,
0.0211916771,
0.0041581043,
0.0198798478,
0.0422674231,
-0.0126424087,
0.0190577339,
0.0115356827,
-0.0522190407,
-0.0465719402,
-0.0018777368,
0.0037403447,
-0.0069054258,
-0.0002047999,
-0.014402464,
0.0614054352,
0.0304786935,
-0.0514314398,
0.0400306433,
0.011226139,
-0.0391390398,
0.0407491513,
-0.0001892134,
0.0230462328,
0.0131328525,
-0.0115554025,
0.0273239166,
-0.0252797622,
0.0224701073,
-0.0303433426,
0.0405331664,
0.011753235,
-0.0242192782,
-0.0023113096,
-0.0209613834,
0.004936703,
0.0535943359,
-0.0449744277,
0.0025847193,
0.0113980062,
0.0240388867,
0.0197367817,
0.0519576184,
-0.0078999223,
0.0030405468,
0.0215875506,
0.003639166,
-0.0395037644,
0.0035375042,
0.0095493225,
-0.0204831231,
-0.0021671844,
0.0281826071,
-0.0370833911,
0.0191804841,
0.0138113657,
-0.0088783465,
0.000418359,
0.0118751451,
0.0123157725,
0.0006096213,
0.0070019634,
-0.0584125593,
0.0134801967,
-0.0746838972,
0.0330109261,
-0.0281376652,
0.041051209,
0.0649455041,
0.0330189653,
-0.0392533876,
-0.0410051383,
-0.0063460642,
0.0078810779,
-0.0054252273,
0.0585603565,
0.0342718251,
0.0626812205,
0.0057497579,
0.0117194895,
-0.0006559492,
0.0007651218,
-0.0378540941,
-0.1062906981,
-0.0040354426,
0.0320257992,
-0.0280453824,
0.0143465204,
0.0095449714,
0.0016037686,
-0.0217721611,
0.0320354514,
-0.0353117138,
0.0017226588,
-0.0294932369,
0.0736253709,
0.0128101846,
-0.0200892519,
-0.0285869855,
0.0399343669,
-0.0552747361,
0.0794245526,
-0.0173416827,
-0.0377058499,
-0.0068534198,
-0.0532440171,
-0.0062406412,
0.019307049,
0.0173356868,
0.0625937507,
-0.0990554914,
-0.0091680875,
-0.0250586253,
-0.0314142555,
-0.0125556206,
-0.0098396596,
-0.000819634,
0.0453993082,
0.0495637208,
-0.0438284054,
-0.0053417878,
0.0412974507,
-0.0778691173,
0.0336223431,
-0.011623444,
-6.04594287e-33,
0.025007477,
-0.0807794109,
0.0013922877,
-0.0591330454,
0.0331691876,
0.0488701239,
0.0031996148,
0.004882847,
-0.0500330403,
0.0691441,
-0.031121023,
0.0470042974,
-0.0070691328,
0.0355059095,
-0.0058930204,
-0.0240905862,
0.0249563493,
-0.0059186467,
-0.0121786613,
0.0616238192,
0.0014585427,
0.0110188806,
-0.0118955579,
-0.0332745761,
0.0499360189,
-0.0594894253,
0.0003928132,
0.0399636775,
0.0037890787,
0.0113352221,
-0.0050195884,
0.0372332521,
0.0478612892,
0.0210476201,
0.0114815272,
0.0864261016,
-0.040965803,
-0.0488427207,
0.0311635118,
-0.0320929475,
-0.0880179778,
-0.0066181142,
0.0526621826,
0.0178931262,
-0.0082349731,
-0.0258765314,
0.0311451517,
-0.0290534124,
0.1045514122,
-0.042956356,
-0.0011514403,
-0.0074436874,
-0.0148721403,
0.015552613,
-0.044012446,
0.060874328,
-0.0455659367,
-0.0173891447,
-0.0441640019,
-0.0029901315,
-0.0235770475,
-0.0007994319,
0.0153290136,
-0.038125217,
0.0329353698,
0.029591836,
-0.0060023544,
0.0224027596,
-0.0474244468,
-0.0033566498,
-0.0484955758,
0.015568845,
0.0259782132,
0.0764139444,
0.0343345627,
0.0109421024,
-0.0960191786,
0.0066272514,
-0.0160093028,
0.0702079311,
0.0425667875,
-0.0415522903,
-0.1005766615,
0.0299465917,
-0.0485357195,
-0.0026113433,
-0.0195320249,
-0.0284326803,
-0.0165954139,
0.0038305633,
-0.0401017442,
0.0114686284,
-0.0636843517,
-0.0339669958,
-0.000354203,
-0.0281802136,
0.0129595101,
-0.0812070742,
0.0425201878,
0.0737228021,
-0.0163111649,
0.0389299691,
0.0021795887,
-0.0196257904,
0.050294362,
0.0253631845,
0.0388306975,
-0.0081629138,
-0.0436688289,
-0.0442677587,
0.0134739522,
0.048150178,
-0.0233234726,
-0.0024830766,
0.0201797783,
0.0687400401,
0.0187062491,
0.0052361395,
0.0518063568,
0.0583250113,
-0.0161194317,
0.0084696999,
-0.0306602735,
0.0373851843,
-0.0747392327,
-0.0311187804,
0.0040082182,
0.0030470064,
0.0062258136,
-0.0988673568,
-0.0173070952,
0.0332926065,
2.432e-7,
0.1087192371,
0.0283331182,
-0.0119928606,
-0.0017088181,
0.0730026364,
0.0075525152,
0.0123569947,
0.0273435898,
0.036335703,
-0.0335984454,
0.0293584634,
-0.0016257651,
-0.0022217901,
0.0669368878,
-0.0479988642,
-0.0078650769,
-0.0487045497,
0.0409102589,
-0.0140348831,
-0.0286894012,
0.0287423357,
0.0439932905,
-0.0496003777,
-0.0329507105,
-0.0125935851,
0.0191142838,
0.037844561,
-0.007855352,
0.0592130013,
0.0366181582,
0.0194081105,
0.0214418992,
0.0392972082,
0.0324037112,
-0.0256120525,
-0.0455726907,
-0.009849905,
0.0734566078,
-0.0175161324,
-0.0493134782,
0.0055677723,
-0.0043311859,
0.0129496604,
-0.0750845149,
0.0716840029,
-0.0728894249,
-0.0522665679,
-0.009762167,
-0.0010306296,
-0.0633599833,
0.025102159,
0.0164015964,
-0.0447374433,
0.0192077942,
0.0273688007,
0.0074242596,
-0.0169802122,
-0.0142700467,
-0.0109532382,
0.0186680015,
-0.0064857481,
-0.0904865935,
0.019486662,
-0.035973262,
-0.0264828708,
-0.0363773964,
0.049162969,
1.534707287e-34,
-0.020701034,
0.0114097558,
0.0115883509,
-0.0187817421,
0.014439716,
0.0124771148,
0.0056078457,
-0.0171934124,
0.0543806702,
-0.0329800136,
0.0137325553
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09538v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09538v3 | Reducing Privacy Risks in Online Self-Disclosures with Language Models | 2023-11-16T03:28:43 | 2024-06-24T02:11:44 | Yao Dou, Isadora Krsek, Tarek Naous, Anubha Kabra, Sauvik Das, Alan Ritter, Wei Xu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.HC | Self-disclosure, while being common and rewarding in social media
interaction, also poses privacy risks. In this paper, we take the initiative to
protect the user-side privacy associated with online self-disclosure through
detection and abstraction. We develop a taxonomy of 19 self-disclosure
categories and curate a large corpus consisting of 4.8K annotated disclosure
spans. We then fine-tune a language model for detection, achieving over 65%
partial span F$_1$. We further conduct an HCI user study, with 82% of
participants viewing the model positively, highlighting its real-world
applicability. Motivated by the user feedback, we introduce the task of
self-disclosure abstraction, which is rephrasing disclosures into less specific
terms while preserving their utility, e.g., "Im 16F" to "I'm a teenage girl".
We explore various fine-tuning strategies, and our best model can generate
diverse abstractions that moderately reduce privacy risks while maintaining
high utility according to human evaluation. To help users in deciding which
disclosures to abstract, we present a task of rating their importance for
context understanding. Our fine-tuned model achieves 80% accuracy, on-par with
GPT-3.5. Given safety and privacy considerations, we will only release our
corpus and models to researcher who agree to the ethical guidelines outlined in
Ethics Statement. | [
0.0588422567,
0.0485245064,
-0.0342489146,
0.0175846294,
-0.0199111067,
-0.0247848071,
0.066120781,
0.0373429917,
0.074931711,
-0.0230092574,
-0.0082409289,
0.0082311518,
-0.0147536201,
0.0451949872,
0.0038930138,
-0.0169850998,
0.012075183,
-0.0016787053,
0.0593591444,
-0.0140787214,
0.0077775624,
0.0363204665,
0.0003282223,
0.0340442099,
-0.0024929987,
-0.0448760428,
0.0341957919,
-0.0087588541,
0.0047605876,
-0.0287896059,
0.025360113,
0.086438641,
0.0186080057,
0.0182768311,
0.0000020618,
-0.0967585519,
0.0131241484,
0.0197400283,
-0.0232360438,
0.0311481133,
0.0571918562,
-0.0011342908,
0.0061387052,
0.0024150133,
-0.0334830321,
0.016343981,
0.0468121991,
0.0433461294,
0.0743469596,
0.0387110822,
-0.0359269045,
-0.0057140398,
0.0024669156,
-0.0327803865,
0.0308709741,
-0.0507342927,
0.0244859587,
-0.0719865263,
-0.028348675,
0.0159526318,
0.0412606932,
0.0566471219,
0.0000372031,
-0.0153312664,
0.0387341902,
0.0079485299,
-0.0067197084,
-0.0485796072,
-0.0007934984,
0.0160296652,
0.0648556873,
-0.0222666133,
0.0324787609,
0.0058495821,
0.0560339279,
0.0170149319,
-0.0257128216,
0.0517575555,
-0.0511476658,
-0.0276098344,
-0.0049232501,
0.0464855321,
0.0213343706,
0.0590556338,
0.0598323755,
0.010358368,
-0.0072369869,
-0.0099438801,
-0.0265060235,
-0.0546615273,
0.0364785232,
-0.0756201893,
0.0510698929,
0.0110016521,
0.0257134791,
0.0029222846,
-0.0346582569,
-0.0320517495,
0.0297334008,
-0.0382733457,
-0.0266959146,
-0.0044557503,
0.0072228615,
0.0143577531,
0.0191965643,
0.0253415015,
0.0051420731,
0.0030925954,
0.0251326524,
0.0273355432,
0.0551499762,
-0.0097638946,
-0.0169630256,
0.0506281704,
-0.0302155223,
0.0119218891,
-0.0732077956,
0.0157499965,
-0.0298073143,
-0.0022286621,
-0.0107860416,
-0.0041160337,
-0.0454461984,
-0.0246482603,
0.0103555629,
-0.0342778116,
-0.023501575,
-0.0086428914,
0.0398287103,
-0.0149017805,
0.0051123234,
-0.0290815085,
0.0356154442,
-0.0046339706,
-0.055618085,
0.0712624192,
0.0360549539,
-0.0264208708,
-0.0110820057,
-0.08204218,
-0.0190871824,
0.0060193432,
-0.0675295889,
-0.0425153822,
0.0297774523,
-0.0064957538,
-0.0146230031,
-0.0646356791,
0.016091831,
0.0231066272,
-0.011867648,
0.0207048003,
-0.0356666818,
0.0113163851,
0.0313832909,
0.084066622,
0.0077880444,
0.0190125685,
0.0185398106,
0.0968287736,
0.0640117675,
-0.0315362439,
0.0674812496,
0.0077114375,
-0.0043699481,
-0.0189716723,
0.0479037687,
0.0080023557,
-0.046560511,
-0.0215331428,
0.0084953001,
0.0418441445,
-0.0137886023,
-0.0143451616,
0.0927851647,
0.0916141942,
0.0090939049,
0.0389069803,
-0.0483394861,
0.0646999478,
0.0042759911,
-0.0417802706,
-0.0391473472,
-0.0034998758,
-0.0412469953,
-0.0365424752,
0.0085794972,
-0.0201818086,
-0.0089322692,
-0.0172118433,
-0.0122245429,
-0.0451271981,
0.0450857058,
0.0418356881,
-0.0473184362,
0.0382586718,
0.005407949,
0.0642524138,
0.0265740957,
-0.0792907625,
0.0130881472,
-0.0493652709,
0.0516205803,
0.0903507844,
0.011772736,
0.0140047986,
0.0539958477,
-0.0650363863,
-0.0011934364,
0.0081494767,
0.0140562747,
0.0253910143,
0.0239665899,
0.00625963,
-0.03236074,
-0.0076917922,
0.0140210846,
-0.0348862559,
0.0019275404,
-0.0374576934,
0.0168469977,
-0.0365381651,
-0.0023712351,
0.0163055267,
0.0150393425,
-0.0484019034,
0.0258597881,
0.0460735075,
0.0160034541,
0.0254472177,
0.0629993975,
0.0147679262,
-0.0149410274,
0.0352356993,
-0.0168338493,
-0.0163749773,
-0.0081517491,
0.0310046002,
-0.0252379663,
-0.0215245411,
0.0103440639,
0.0059443768,
-0.0287929755,
0.024213288,
0.0447609536,
-0.0145425228,
0.0292788502,
-0.0460311845,
-0.0268601496,
-0.0247057024,
-0.0137964347,
-0.0133103784,
0.0656380057,
-0.0322139673,
-0.0110207181,
-0.0924194455,
-0.0643709823,
-0.0161820892,
-0.0280496944,
0.0059294528,
-0.0534154326,
-0.0430494174,
0.0524724014,
0.0509260707,
0.0173302572,
-0.0239087716,
-0.0348020457,
-0.056996882,
-0.0238386355,
-0.0006426751,
-0.0119609358,
0.0189458411,
0.0349084325,
-0.0056608017,
-0.0114854146,
-0.0182619411,
-0.0339026526,
-0.0289829429,
0.0292471536,
0.043795649,
0.0058121057,
-0.0036069264,
0.0107729305,
-0.0075677722,
-0.0228698198,
0.0044619516,
0.0054155514,
-0.0407960378,
-0.0200518593,
0.025411047,
-0.0309112314,
0.0169232506,
-0.0070548174,
-0.0153276306,
-0.0214893017,
0.0069253673,
-0.0161518976,
-0.0092306472,
0.0775869712,
0.0719410777,
0.0222558752,
0.0376957916,
-0.0278296955,
-0.0142409531,
-0.0081104049,
-0.0334078036,
-0.0198343173,
-0.0547907613,
0.0748937875,
-0.0357103907,
0.0254438464,
0.0143663706,
-0.0540379621,
0.003204159,
-0.0202536117,
-0.0412220918,
-0.0121276854,
-0.0512417331,
-0.0067795534,
0.0376016013,
-0.0104906848,
-0.048321344,
0.06045454,
0.0453191884,
0.019057937,
0.0371167921,
-0.0371326506,
-0.0067613474,
0.0612462871,
-0.0321198665,
0.0460194424,
0.1023814678,
-0.0762557462,
0.0440603346,
-0.0045674955,
0.0249168202,
-0.0214703884,
0.0345160663,
0.0192086641,
-0.0016859453,
0.0546095967,
-0.0652860999,
-0.0200099796,
-0.1568479985,
-0.0033223918,
-0.0416390449,
-0.0438603982,
-0.0312134773,
-0.0057315198,
-0.0202782564,
-0.0149801085,
-0.0118180541,
-0.0207227934,
-0.0074308957,
-0.0143246828,
-0.0216203611,
-0.0115469303,
-0.0438961051,
0.010572738,
0.0188011471,
0.0030363142,
0.05791739,
0.0255690292,
0.0227012634,
0.0378706418,
-0.0303781088,
0.0070083211,
-0.0565246753,
-0.0268919114,
0.0364862829,
0.059292756,
-0.0383655094,
-0.0108500998,
0.083583802,
0.003077202,
-0.0464746319,
0.007745184,
0.0267488286,
0.0199109912,
-0.0116585409,
-0.0206159204,
-0.1034525186,
0.0153296608,
-0.0420295931,
0.0274393782,
-0.0414479338,
-0.0164880138,
-0.0136551047,
-0.0321329273,
0.010001393,
0.0346457921,
-0.0150222117,
0.0162385423,
-0.0537382402,
0.0000268835,
0.0066225212,
0.0000842803,
-0.0467985012,
-0.0404212251,
-0.0485133007,
-0.0197333749,
-0.0686320588,
-0.0489793383,
0.0232585948,
-0.0599461421,
0.0245241802,
0.0147049129,
0.0234344043,
-0.0279884078,
-0.0507077947,
-0.0069350065,
0.0013990852,
-0.0239521749,
0.014967558,
0.0514452867,
-0.0231241826,
0.0314334854,
-0.0350251384,
0.0372420847,
0.0098213125,
-0.023373805,
-0.0238770042,
0.009883102,
-0.0060016657,
-0.0371151306,
0.022834437,
0.0117809614,
0.053914737,
0.0512024499,
-0.0000870392,
-0.025005158,
0.0320656672,
-0.0395291597,
0.0537758581,
0.0015010533,
0.0224193279,
-0.0352634266,
0.0217148606,
-0.0710800886,
-0.032837335,
0.00246231,
-0.0167199671,
-0.0502485372,
0.0405825078,
0.0073085236,
0.0261527803,
0.0301622655,
-0.0182584971,
0.0244163126,
-0.0602697991,
0.0021754347,
-0.0130361961,
0.0345232114,
-0.0190770701,
0.0063195392,
0.0240581799,
0.0700084269,
-0.0188996252,
-0.0158094466,
0.0178658888,
0.029450329,
0.0104978345,
0.016431611,
-0.0596354119,
-0.0914423093,
0.0165495928,
0.0569127686,
-0.0637566671,
-0.0029470974,
0.0544392578,
0.0192384571,
-0.004586874,
0.0217767693,
-0.0117399693,
-0.0301667973,
-0.0005547233,
-0.0465904176,
-0.0668634549,
-0.0281825103,
0.0015181138,
0.028972894,
0.0091402493,
-0.0217853747,
0.0326060206,
-0.0111999689,
-0.0527017377,
-0.0190318394,
-0.018045228,
-0.0018122962,
-0.0124090118,
0.035709437,
-0.0150945364,
0.0342036001,
0.0007115867,
-0.0266279243,
-0.0115302224,
-0.0699267983,
0.0023987025,
-0.0079878531,
0.05132626,
-0.0384557582,
0.0134713463,
-0.0365737043,
0.0190449134,
0.0516812839,
0.0371447131,
-0.0293919351,
0.0341029055,
-0.005385221,
-0.0071772509,
0.0075744763,
0.035808932,
-0.0155385733,
0.0020241933,
0.0041690478,
0.0090129403,
-0.0260499474,
0.0536969192,
0.0400774702,
-0.0156267602,
-0.0152172511,
0.002830893,
0.034673512,
-0.0508737676,
-0.0863414928,
0.0179865602,
0.004684791,
-0.0397057272,
0.0024643114,
0.0029746401,
-0.0123261781,
0.0000658599,
0.0120807262,
-0.023731824,
-0.0338427462,
0.0079593882,
-0.0207819417,
0.0697897077,
-0.0044564973,
-0.0138792926,
-0.0645715892,
-0.0417912565,
-0.0053480295,
-0.0083740251,
0.0124416798,
-0.0148281883,
0.0271040052,
0.031607341,
0.0172195435,
-0.0621534437,
-0.0796796009,
-0.011647339,
0.0222693309,
-0.0442600735,
-0.0523227192,
-5.697085166e-33,
0.0155148329,
-0.036797747,
-0.0129003199,
0.0317502096,
0.0194531288,
0.0021610863,
-0.0304429885,
0.0357039496,
-0.0174023528,
-0.0066133151,
-0.0226199403,
0.0044459328,
0.000716555,
0.0036936798,
-0.0233934354,
0.019651439,
0.0500689372,
0.001383946,
-0.0201828368,
0.0540721416,
0.0235080868,
0.0010289924,
0.0236335248,
-0.0991722718,
0.0705067813,
0.0053501045,
-0.0907244012,
0.0333471112,
0.0109206969,
0.0211630873,
-0.0286190417,
0.0344879404,
0.0092884395,
0.0493231677,
0.0293865651,
0.0913595408,
-0.0834011957,
-0.0323157795,
0.0451630466,
-0.0094310259,
-0.0107385721,
-0.0772100836,
0.0185773633,
-0.0517449528,
-0.0461840853,
-0.0206761695,
0.0225000102,
0.0298226271,
0.0174603816,
-0.0171598755,
-0.00782522,
-0.0261581838,
-0.0068845185,
-0.0124157714,
0.039230179,
0.0746593699,
-0.0153128067,
-0.0395710282,
-0.0458171032,
0.037768323,
0.0351852328,
-0.054358121,
0.024359772,
-0.0195887461,
0.0045155217,
0.0352365412,
0.0197539888,
0.0282527413,
-0.0193565916,
-0.0011822659,
0.0022706725,
0.0254042912,
0.0074094231,
0.0146643426,
-0.0215052366,
-0.0491012447,
-0.0078285364,
0.0051750387,
-0.0067744604,
-0.0024955049,
0.0408904366,
-0.0132509191,
-0.0879561976,
-0.0203163903,
-0.0249208342,
-0.0299201235,
-0.0439038351,
-0.0147920558,
-0.0027555199,
-0.021988228,
-0.0761748031,
0.0262538977,
-0.0408236273,
-0.0444459505,
-0.0705314577,
-0.0003608757,
0.070017077,
-0.0067279288,
-0.0003076741,
0.0199809354,
-0.0050258143,
0.0175194815,
0.010604199,
-0.0012375215,
0.0177846197,
0.0081647309,
0.0417209901,
0.009847817,
-0.0610913187,
-0.0206535179,
0.0124699026,
0.0371366851,
0.0058706151,
-0.0263173226,
0.0202833414,
0.0093659014,
-0.0155220442,
0.0266890656,
0.0299895313,
0.019732967,
-0.0552857257,
0.0483634137,
-0.0028958933,
0.0295256618,
0.0452053286,
0.0026303665,
-0.0070570889,
0.0427925065,
0.1173512116,
0.0243535899,
-0.0074640317,
-0.0221540742,
2.797e-7,
0.0123876771,
-0.0224329177,
-0.0358966179,
0.0076480801,
0.0065398766,
0.0661807656,
0.0878475085,
0.0562467389,
0.0335218608,
0.0049122269,
-0.0089062527,
0.0102979196,
0.0602077059,
0.0083746035,
-0.0177006237,
-0.0050950786,
0.0096072741,
0.0133497864,
-0.0370579958,
0.0134244058,
0.0065334062,
0.0197406989,
0.0769377574,
-0.0190729965,
-0.0401769727,
-0.0197158065,
0.0262592491,
-0.0569737889,
-0.0295232218,
0.023551302,
-0.0079311384,
0.0501523577,
0.0514446981,
-0.0268740226,
-0.0238750093,
-0.0454353765,
-0.0285853855,
0.0601244345,
0.0086080283,
-0.0090738405,
-0.0036322197,
-0.0215417221,
0.0192196127,
-0.0485469848,
0.0048359986,
-0.0016505294,
-0.0511007346,
-0.032556016,
0.0282480773,
-0.0468505733,
0.0316483378,
-0.0534151904,
-0.0530365258,
0.0003200948,
0.0240367055,
0.0106130745,
-0.0073623057,
-0.0627945215,
-0.0023852657,
-0.0135109676,
0.0038857146,
-0.0094466629,
0.0264977049,
0.0363657027,
-0.0334224999,
-0.0491565876,
0.090570949,
2.234049513e-34,
-0.0436272956,
-0.0083763134,
-0.0132794464,
0.020034723,
0.0473259129,
0.0393040925,
0.0333438702,
0.0067905341,
0.0178681202,
0.0022941241,
0.0039638747
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09533v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09533v3 | Effective Large Language Model Adaptation for Improved Grounding and Citation Generation | 2023-11-16T03:22:25 | 2024-04-02T20:04:01 | Xi Ye, Ruoxi Sun, Sercan Ö. Arik, Tomas Pfister | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have achieved remarkable advancements in natural
language understanding and generation. However, one major issue towards their
widespread deployment in the real world is that they can generate
"hallucinated" answers that are not factual. Towards this end, this paper
focuses on improving LLMs by grounding their responses in retrieved passages
and by providing citations. We propose a new framework, AGREE, Adaptation for
GRounding EnhancEment, that improves the grounding from a holistic perspective.
Our framework tunes LLMs to selfground the claims in their responses and
provide accurate citations to retrieved documents. This tuning on top of the
pre-trained LLMs requires well-grounded responses (with citations) for paired
queries, for which we introduce a method that can automatically construct such
data from unlabeled queries. The selfgrounding capability of tuned LLMs further
grants them a test-time adaptation (TTA) capability that can actively retrieve
passages to support the claims that have not been grounded, which iteratively
improves the responses of LLMs. Across five datasets and two LLMs, our results
show that the proposed tuningbased AGREE framework generates superior grounded
responses with more accurate citations compared to prompting-based approaches
and post-hoc citing-based approaches | [
0.0487711877,
0.0392510518,
0.0243324377,
0.0282739047,
-0.017933134,
-0.0121162524,
-0.0036041094,
-0.0151938302,
0.0174416527,
-0.1031832471,
-0.0201874264,
0.031444367,
-0.0324759223,
-0.0105747646,
0.0169544742,
0.0242979154,
0.04176585,
-0.0064498275,
0.0100342147,
-0.0172398239,
-0.0099866232,
0.0542482883,
0.0092838518,
0.0098407995,
0.0214396585,
-0.0334775895,
0.0013801316,
-0.0059340051,
0.0203018598,
-0.0312781744,
0.0232288167,
0.0728715435,
0.0332716219,
0.0575736873,
0.0000017966,
-0.0649541765,
-0.0158876777,
-0.0006142044,
-0.020554712,
0.0296557248,
0.0183161106,
0.0055598081,
0.0327603668,
0.0279693417,
-0.0461782441,
0.0015825172,
0.0101648932,
0.0887118876,
0.0742385909,
0.0542610027,
0.0087585226,
-0.0302261431,
0.0128936525,
-0.0065489598,
-0.010919218,
-0.0277658943,
0.0497621223,
0.0440496616,
0.0093004722,
0.0465273634,
0.0214732233,
0.0093444837,
-0.0018201518,
-0.0353939645,
0.0448194332,
0.0241033398,
-0.0672368407,
0.0216185246,
0.0199563857,
0.0707639381,
0.0274296533,
-0.0722738579,
0.0009148592,
-0.0080421334,
-0.0028456701,
0.0242202897,
-0.0210519135,
0.0274734143,
-0.0024772768,
0.0168376043,
0.0212495513,
-0.0108701969,
0.0269874856,
0.053303659,
-0.0454970561,
0.0736755729,
0.0166292004,
-0.0409114808,
0.040232081,
0.0244440902,
-0.0115442872,
-0.0663312525,
0.0051542534,
0.054160133,
-0.0210177116,
0.0062047648,
-0.0136274118,
-0.0055502369,
0.0464244299,
-0.035552036,
-0.011342071,
-0.0095026158,
-0.0306365304,
0.0701081753,
-0.0571463443,
-0.0032638796,
-0.0462818593,
-0.0351534411,
-0.028467603,
-0.022294838,
-0.0354810394,
-0.0128184855,
-0.0326677449,
0.0267001819,
-0.0875788778,
0.0000332592,
-0.0200408492,
0.0364000797,
-0.0034272368,
-0.017515745,
-0.0050321375,
0.0199719388,
-0.0476275496,
-0.0104762735,
-0.0338599235,
0.0259160753,
-0.0068786908,
0.0598099008,
0.0024649247,
-0.056835793,
-0.0189495869,
0.0241160821,
0.0429179072,
-0.0242846925,
0.024323985,
-0.0079015,
-0.0052049994,
-0.0119972322,
-0.0584860966,
-0.0388390459,
-0.0101390714,
-0.0634958521,
0.0081165498,
-0.0684853569,
0.0292068217,
0.0198893994,
-0.024580624,
-0.0339249969,
0.0089434609,
0.0430262983,
-0.0421883948,
0.0395722054,
-0.014036905,
-0.0012350907,
0.0370430574,
-0.0163987167,
0.039494209,
0.0596775152,
0.0074479571,
-0.0016855674,
0.0497650579,
-0.0013662237,
-0.0056746826,
-0.0168643985,
0.0633671731,
0.0504859984,
0.0200416204,
0.0139911156,
-0.0079550082,
0.013147505,
0.0297459308,
0.0404609405,
-0.0120776761,
0.005151446,
0.0805515945,
0.0302518252,
-0.0309921913,
0.0291566085,
0.0228939168,
-0.0012541305,
0.0024367967,
0.0212597325,
-0.0661155581,
0.0107281189,
-0.046533335,
0.0171109531,
0.0429711565,
0.0208612774,
-0.0437297337,
-0.0166880153,
-0.0007000078,
0.00356214,
-0.0060613919,
0.009563907,
0.0151296295,
0.0324382745,
-0.0422572345,
0.0755849779,
0.0355911218,
-0.0312328506,
0.0207135938,
-0.0325397514,
0.0671537817,
-0.0194592867,
0.0334827714,
-0.0062250132,
0.0018438813,
-0.0373182781,
0.0488663837,
0.0678704455,
0.0167760123,
-0.0060798549,
-0.0224070568,
-0.0241919104,
-0.0317997038,
-0.0293225143,
0.0240751226,
-0.0113771297,
0.0284234975,
-0.0002856085,
0.0439178608,
-0.0739709735,
-0.0454031527,
0.0313971899,
-0.0261999685,
-0.0342393368,
0.0185291879,
-0.0239895843,
0.0242406521,
0.0313120224,
-0.0215440113,
0.0168857388,
0.0511592217,
-0.013924717,
-0.0321016237,
0.0386313424,
-0.0127028599,
0.0190953836,
0.0435204916,
-0.0144017227,
-0.0106689734,
-0.002317793,
-0.0411286131,
-0.0344841294,
-0.0040660244,
-0.0067940815,
0.0297220834,
-0.0454372689,
0.0028719394,
-0.0015578992,
0.0339333862,
-0.0440605842,
0.0627109706,
0.0272646882,
0.0075627877,
-0.0014592675,
0.0116450898,
0.0046173213,
-0.032722462,
-0.0172582362,
0.007055189,
0.017725477,
-0.0001862191,
0.0493506044,
-0.0023521404,
-0.0541153029,
0.0055424161,
-0.1006714404,
0.0018102762,
-0.0288103279,
-0.0004905327,
0.0302596949,
-0.000994683,
-0.0039826683,
-0.0154492632,
-0.0282683633,
-0.0123601342,
0.0421566404,
0.0216851756,
0.0390330814,
0.0128280753,
0.0357961915,
-0.0434142202,
0.0250453558,
-0.0112200528,
0.0362547375,
0.030716449,
0.0164199248,
-0.1025703028,
0.0183440223,
-0.0461993292,
0.0163108967,
0.0005173609,
0.0110821631,
-0.0150593994,
0.0058194553,
0.033632271,
0.0667276382,
0.0293397494,
-0.0168409627,
0.0466967523,
0.0242816005,
-0.0773421973,
-0.0004167845,
-0.0184435472,
-0.0266871247,
-0.0045662131,
-0.0110790422,
0.0389837548,
0.04288055,
-0.0057727601,
-0.0221782681,
-0.0298270527,
0.0165480133,
-0.002984876,
-0.0190588664,
-0.019046247,
-0.0061219051,
-0.0000387989,
0.0322298594,
-0.00665848,
-0.049445387,
0.0675404742,
-0.0345955417,
0.0167780258,
-0.0805817544,
-0.0028784517,
-0.0428799167,
0.0196307972,
0.0059876172,
-0.0105070658,
0.0124819437,
0.0115913199,
-0.0257690735,
-0.0448089801,
0.0133878645,
-0.0186917391,
0.0813188255,
-0.0465295613,
0.0367251411,
-0.0179114435,
-0.0239344817,
-0.0496896245,
-0.0602061264,
-0.0510049835,
0.0090472214,
-0.0192963853,
-0.0031600222,
-0.0484299473,
-0.0149628185,
0.0503546335,
0.0413114317,
-0.0344555043,
-0.005613192,
-0.0183174592,
0.0235707145,
0.0889289975,
0.0288276728,
0.0566277578,
0.0018404425,
0.0110418117,
0.0412431434,
0.024356626,
-0.0028826054,
-0.0254058242,
-0.0505284332,
0.0004721732,
-0.0529711843,
0.0091877161,
-0.0135384919,
0.0320553184,
-0.024174612,
-0.0053573623,
0.1126976088,
0.022765575,
-0.0229296759,
-0.0010082488,
-0.0367137156,
0.0089883599,
0.0229313467,
0.0330085456,
-0.0683502182,
-0.0070029735,
-0.0299745575,
0.0143567929,
0.0139551833,
-0.0368398093,
-0.0168566592,
-0.1521173865,
0.0327886231,
0.0157247689,
0.0080927415,
-0.0490490533,
-0.0750731975,
0.0262079984,
0.0023571758,
0.0240498129,
0.0290214047,
-0.0012726408,
0.0159727465,
0.0329457372,
0.0335573442,
-0.049097456,
0.0093228687,
-0.050675679,
0.040251784,
0.0248229168,
0.0571429096,
0.0012189093,
-0.034816701,
0.0185166206,
-0.0537788831,
-0.0220826678,
-0.0338561721,
-0.0065066381,
0.0063095638,
0.021293819,
-0.0018244156,
0.045838356,
-0.0249531809,
-0.013681273,
0.0354893506,
0.0745442063,
-0.0084104957,
-0.0075630322,
-0.0225700866,
0.0335985608,
0.0202082787,
0.0857524499,
0.013317503,
-0.0034499383,
-0.0078616105,
0.0032834013,
-0.0100269215,
-0.0392947495,
-0.0435070693,
0.010102883,
-0.0313082971,
0.0728365928,
-0.0986171141,
-0.0300572421,
-0.0090466319,
0.019998461,
0.0150496,
0.0209762603,
0.0260072369,
-0.0119457189,
-0.0333969854,
0.0461147763,
-0.057254456,
0.0008621851,
-0.0368821509,
0.0171553344,
0.071021989,
-0.0267687235,
-0.0076837982,
0.0023829809,
0.0282498561,
-0.0617196225,
-0.0109094447,
0.0050101527,
0.0216029733,
0.0557810143,
-0.0275456477,
-0.045644328,
0.0319573246,
0.0572130494,
-0.0406232104,
0.046072945,
0.0136083281,
-0.0082262652,
-0.0204270296,
0.0330388509,
-0.0611172803,
0.0339911133,
0.0010086016,
0.0411040559,
0.0006787951,
-0.0556511991,
0.0361721553,
0.0300134029,
0.0506108515,
0.0186391026,
0.0179398321,
-0.0143389143,
0.0333940908,
-0.0359902978,
-0.0363572948,
-0.0111995107,
0.0321582519,
-0.0234494265,
-0.01649235,
-0.0245618299,
0.0074565564,
-0.0340954438,
0.0932749063,
-0.0466936044,
0.0040276665,
-0.0427117385,
0.0172881577,
-0.021021042,
-0.021431677,
-0.044216644,
-0.0318762176,
0.0184906255,
0.0731723309,
0.0018757653,
0.0434231609,
0.0124648903,
-0.0198060479,
-0.0037682769,
-0.0142300548,
-0.0871685073,
0.0046080728,
-0.0456053987,
-0.0242801867,
0.0275261756,
-0.029358035,
0.0627731532,
-0.0030784879,
-0.0497363582,
-0.0238451809,
0.008222254,
0.0246727001,
0.0133426022,
0.0373537317,
0.0081947278,
-0.040064536,
0.0528707244,
0.0315471031,
0.0486431904,
0.0625896007,
0.0216922034,
-0.0068593849,
-0.0312544741,
-0.0661909133,
-0.0539893471,
-0.0018180348,
-0.0203984361,
0.0225342438,
-0.0438162833,
-0.0577476248,
0.0201331899,
0.0019812498,
-0.0100127542,
-0.027711248,
0.0095532304,
0.0582620017,
-0.0124093676,
-0.0214266926,
-0.0573881455,
0.0723909289,
-0.0198977925,
-0.0197486263,
-0.0460447036,
-6.366528097e-33,
-0.0417256653,
-0.0472794995,
0.0147184012,
-0.0184346624,
-0.0075245136,
0.0146106109,
-0.0284801591,
-0.0329869166,
-0.0551281385,
0.0238561518,
-0.0176708344,
0.0284984689,
0.0054000961,
0.0127866017,
-0.0200914405,
0.0013498258,
0.0497578681,
-0.0000400459,
-0.0443948992,
0.0445840918,
0.05181209,
0.0040532886,
0.0535141341,
-0.1146243289,
0.0282104351,
-0.0360958837,
-0.0167155266,
0.0142855151,
-0.026753081,
0.0566391759,
-0.0136913899,
0.0422753692,
0.0211920943,
-0.0340685993,
0.0030283646,
0.0251370445,
-0.0948566198,
0.0034973589,
0.0427427962,
-0.037984848,
-0.0072669503,
-0.0181257594,
0.0207654461,
-0.0051369383,
-0.0122814132,
-0.0092006037,
0.0382980928,
-0.0463243462,
-0.0139085855,
-0.0327933356,
-0.0674844757,
0.0340826549,
0.0328745283,
0.0201610383,
-0.0540385209,
0.0561296083,
-0.0088502048,
0.0718764141,
-0.0686960518,
0.0057167746,
-0.0094045429,
0.0135462433,
0.0310578495,
-0.0401088111,
-0.0101121729,
0.044379171,
-0.0521230288,
-0.0201901644,
-0.0144312875,
-0.0545890704,
-0.0115922559,
0.0195977557,
0.0446915217,
0.0867360085,
-0.0262342859,
0.021384649,
-0.0812829807,
0.0075547928,
0.0162130129,
0.0334917903,
0.0305673648,
-0.0010927351,
-0.0179986358,
0.0066722827,
-0.0339551717,
0.0081060287,
-0.0289670937,
0.0008964349,
0.0083629712,
0.0298846327,
-0.0612417236,
0.0257693324,
0.0286309011,
-0.0422872528,
-0.0135853263,
0.0623535588,
-0.0122069838,
-0.0198986623,
0.0141455885,
-0.0022189661,
-0.0648298636,
-0.0159083474,
0.0155785205,
0.008076204,
-0.0062133609,
0.009051444,
0.0164991729,
-0.0261752307,
-0.0640712455,
0.0142386667,
-0.0078164078,
0.0317795575,
-0.0247327425,
-0.0149974227,
0.0085759647,
0.0253884047,
0.0176026803,
0.040689569,
0.0369966142,
-0.0080368174,
-0.0238278694,
-0.0200103018,
-0.0001737921,
0.0369740278,
-0.0263109598,
-0.0005363275,
0.0337762497,
0.0360764973,
0.0011328906,
-0.0753824711,
-0.018606199,
0.0008379436,
2.618e-7,
0.0251005366,
0.0480199009,
-0.0109857144,
-0.0314114727,
0.0125107951,
0.0391336717,
0.0163594186,
0.0438900031,
0.0678540766,
-0.0334162861,
-0.0204014406,
0.0058076167,
0.0212251637,
-0.0020448586,
-0.0666313097,
-0.0185991582,
-0.0894805044,
-0.0176553577,
-0.0394805931,
-0.0616434067,
-0.0283720288,
0.0778452158,
-0.0087878946,
0.0054949485,
-0.0185486283,
-0.0646007359,
0.0757391751,
0.0049366294,
-0.0331970491,
0.0206855405,
0.048909232,
0.0034388881,
0.0037299627,
0.034218505,
-0.0283406582,
0.0657931343,
-0.011456944,
0.0491837524,
0.0169009231,
-0.0022607597,
-0.0362736695,
-0.0426854901,
0.0401639007,
-0.0797477588,
0.0688713938,
-0.0577613711,
-0.0208783764,
-0.053874068,
-0.0642726049,
-0.0091820266,
-0.0085654492,
-0.0026885644,
-0.0269618481,
0.0052953144,
0.005540581,
0.0395386927,
-0.0324875079,
-0.0673563257,
-0.0141409095,
0.0322894081,
-0.0372690298,
-0.0623837039,
0.010050443,
-0.0238302927,
0.0131928483,
-0.0687850192,
0.0459322706,
2.61273961e-34,
0.0419022962,
0.0077570397,
0.0094679063,
0.0082312925,
0.0571735911,
0.0304941963,
0.0032909124,
0.0074232514,
0.056092158,
-0.0739668086,
0.0050860541
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09528v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09528v1 | HelpSteer: Multi-attribute Helpfulness Dataset for SteerLM | 2023-11-16T03:13:29 | 2023-11-16T03:13:29 | Zhilin Wang, Yi Dong, Jiaqi Zeng, Virginia Adams, Makesh Narsimhan Sreedhar, Daniel Egert, Olivier Delalleau, Jane Polak Scowcroft, Neel Kant, Aidan Swope, Oleksii Kuchaiev | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Existing open-source helpfulness preference datasets do not specify what
makes some responses more helpful and others less so. Models trained on these
datasets can incidentally learn to model dataset artifacts (e.g. preferring
longer but unhelpful responses only due to their length). To alleviate this
problem, we collect HelpSteer, a multi-attribute helpfulness dataset annotated
for the various aspects that make responses helpful. Specifically, our
37k-sample dataset has annotations for correctness, coherence, complexity, and
verbosity in addition to overall helpfulness of responses. Training Llama 2 70B
using the HelpSteer dataset with SteerLM technique produces a model that scores
7.54 on MT Bench, which is currently the highest score for open models that do
not require training data from more powerful models (e.g. GPT4). We release
this dataset with CC-BY-4.0 license at
https://huggingface.co/datasets/nvidia/HelpSteer | [
0.039993003,
0.0407688618,
-0.03534583,
0.0345466435,
0.0100594712,
0.0314711034,
-0.0438695177,
-0.0091961604,
0.0133691709,
-0.0187729318,
-0.0235535596,
0.0092433998,
-0.0173491724,
-0.0109128542,
0.0199017748,
-0.0694862902,
0.0128911473,
0.0084810564,
0.0652307644,
0.0026953588,
0.0469278917,
-0.0074639055,
0.0029243608,
0.0293722171,
0.0032780021,
-0.0035709164,
-0.0015970106,
0.0027088381,
0.0386177376,
-0.0282055587,
0.0489263274,
0.0328467563,
-0.0107431039,
-0.0149776563,
0.0000019464,
-0.0656690001,
0.0100452341,
-0.0252089333,
-0.0320138857,
-0.0001379415,
0.0425793119,
0.0184691306,
0.0347435735,
0.0350018963,
-0.0267743506,
0.0242739059,
0.0452524126,
0.0683495775,
0.0683204308,
0.0573454089,
-0.0010203826,
0.002277314,
0.0283304267,
-0.0150673883,
0.0705838874,
0.0211585946,
0.0046773255,
-0.0193575751,
-0.0180374291,
0.02232261,
-0.0195758417,
0.0415882058,
0.011803166,
0.0096322857,
0.0350449234,
0.0030584871,
-0.0187678058,
-0.0135876331,
0.0211749971,
0.1001425385,
0.0443123206,
-0.011356893,
-0.0206804164,
-0.0489863344,
0.0358273014,
0.0045772693,
-0.0116031542,
-0.0483636111,
-0.0078218179,
0.0054205456,
0.0059849401,
0.0053400383,
0.0177274086,
-0.0232948698,
0.0394828282,
0.0292327534,
-0.0411958285,
-0.0469918475,
0.0321057029,
0.0060925474,
-0.0074837846,
-0.0273126494,
-0.0040392871,
-0.0088850688,
-0.0191370174,
0.000080221,
-0.0060949749,
0.0314223468,
0.0795121938,
-0.0475498848,
0.0610731803,
0.0096291211,
-0.0584520847,
-0.0061824988,
0.0061146552,
0.0012279294,
0.0280148666,
0.0074233268,
-0.0101931244,
0.0143172853,
-0.0602419935,
0.0132959047,
0.0130205425,
0.0191576406,
-0.0109631382,
0.0309136622,
-0.0491273068,
0.0020434186,
-0.0158799905,
0.0090811793,
0.0414206348,
-0.0027557409,
-0.0175661743,
0.0314889066,
-0.0663761646,
0.0174697284,
-0.0749306455,
0.0502433181,
0.0150250625,
-0.0619924366,
0.0147244949,
0.0114221862,
0.0127825597,
-0.0435011573,
0.0248459522,
0.0602250397,
0.0134379659,
-0.0628857687,
-0.0544107817,
-0.0021946961,
-0.0104845148,
-0.0688552782,
-0.0018538994,
-0.0486944839,
0.0501596332,
-0.0077118357,
0.0023428358,
-0.022165481,
0.002098755,
0.0183328446,
-0.0411085524,
0.0387781002,
-0.0468583964,
-0.0058788583,
-0.0183025002,
0.004954339,
0.0084251566,
0.0417699628,
0.0030162265,
0.0284940209,
0.0870129392,
-0.037066564,
0.0014700529,
-0.0179993287,
0.012004056,
-0.0215130039,
0.0333548002,
0.0282428097,
-0.0704849139,
0.0161750596,
0.035787981,
-0.0050832583,
-0.0158411916,
-0.0584089197,
0.0928249732,
0.025875438,
0.0598398037,
-0.022286281,
-0.0017804418,
0.0282093529,
0.0030283064,
0.0202585105,
-0.0760163963,
0.0420410186,
-0.0393581092,
0.0110715888,
0.0130063454,
0.0169321671,
-0.0388292,
-0.1015407741,
-0.0146580413,
-0.0307624433,
-0.0382433981,
0.0389928669,
-0.0002748869,
-0.0277593397,
-0.0309278741,
-0.048839055,
0.0171935838,
-0.0687105358,
-0.0263603292,
-0.0418177098,
0.0902374536,
0.0470753796,
-0.0023780118,
-0.0430642217,
-0.0741230771,
-0.0347930565,
0.0100066587,
-0.0117004262,
0.0209665764,
-0.015972225,
0.0358104184,
-0.0612928942,
-0.0172972251,
0.0089334045,
0.0060598259,
0.0026121142,
0.0273710415,
0.0025832208,
-0.0158741865,
-0.0017565835,
-0.0183273908,
0.0398391038,
0.0404090472,
-0.0230248757,
0.0122021111,
0.0098130926,
0.069386296,
0.038880229,
0.0044399663,
-0.0096363593,
0.034386877,
-0.0103454608,
-0.046075277,
0.0152710816,
-0.0358747281,
-0.0112900762,
0.0283603948,
-0.0043866495,
-0.0189244952,
0.0700025484,
-0.0226578005,
-0.0130841015,
-0.0434809066,
-0.0334857106,
0.0241922103,
-0.0078294305,
0.0126022203,
0.0078754518,
0.0279775299,
-0.0355074257,
0.026530467,
-0.044175379,
0.0261921249,
-0.0419860519,
-0.0462519825,
-0.0147970989,
-0.0516458489,
-0.0055604172,
-0.0020935365,
-0.0091312835,
-0.0063912985,
0.0116291763,
0.0206901859,
-0.062221732,
0.0011277179,
-0.058264818,
0.0032345257,
-0.0066231787,
0.0427146405,
-0.0055843759,
-0.0248175673,
0.0021429134,
-0.0155443177,
-0.0627716035,
0.022469027,
0.0170957427,
0.0128766987,
0.0474261977,
0.0041269204,
-0.0373581909,
-0.0630090088,
-0.0037478793,
-0.0013050624,
-0.0269690715,
0.0238357913,
-0.0721453801,
-0.0332034864,
-0.0176905636,
-0.0242073759,
0.0042322455,
-0.0058915024,
-0.0741013885,
-0.0118682776,
0.0300363805,
0.0335807614,
0.060830269,
0.0156636443,
-0.0109952101,
0.037953198,
0.0102565736,
-0.0558052771,
0.0109278169,
-0.0493330769,
-0.0191697218,
-0.025417557,
-0.0535163879,
0.0213631578,
0.0519141518,
0.0195621401,
0.004181602,
-0.0480880253,
-0.0254881661,
0.0181710422,
-0.0334162414,
-0.0093910787,
0.0383880511,
0.0032660766,
0.0530404896,
0.0033402978,
-0.0598655455,
0.0860502496,
-0.0220034514,
-0.0379618108,
0.0051120943,
0.0024216978,
-0.0331059061,
0.0093804225,
-0.011310406,
0.0111147203,
0.0087705702,
0.0035683224,
0.0208893213,
-0.0361450985,
0.0389762782,
-0.0030139431,
0.0357972831,
-0.0287939943,
-0.0401643738,
-0.0242552664,
-0.0399924181,
-0.0204364881,
-0.0457080118,
0.0007419604,
-0.045110926,
0.0055305883,
-0.0317800865,
-0.0295359567,
-0.060691081,
0.0116275772,
-0.0013758163,
-0.0250745174,
-0.0156951826,
0.0102106584,
0.0064772279,
0.0354540236,
0.0650553778,
0.0605393238,
-0.0190694053,
0.0191525761,
0.0362249315,
-0.0189500358,
-0.0287941769,
0.0018018266,
-0.01987537,
0.0246789269,
-0.0369471163,
-0.0094982209,
0.0406522416,
0.0914851129,
-0.0132134398,
0.02752655,
0.0936241224,
0.0168325845,
-0.0485993177,
0.014625309,
-0.0449206941,
0.0179624837,
0.0371365175,
0.0093747545,
-0.0717187002,
-0.0334317721,
-0.0028196936,
0.0513323769,
-0.014604615,
-0.016306527,
0.0282990914,
-0.0761498213,
0.0656943545,
-0.0287571847,
-0.046963498,
-0.0097775469,
-0.0571379252,
-0.0164373014,
-0.037860997,
-0.0156809185,
-0.0013133485,
-0.0179416519,
-0.021478774,
0.0198470317,
-0.0190446358,
-0.0192427244,
0.0271223746,
-0.0122632803,
0.0895188004,
0.0380229466,
0.0382480994,
-0.0068818005,
-0.0514836125,
-0.0072688106,
-0.038451165,
-0.0006899847,
-0.0065985606,
0.0921334773,
-0.0184592791,
0.0147862444,
-0.0410171188,
0.0780041292,
-0.0254407022,
0.0061942395,
0.0464064069,
0.0258420743,
0.0146912858,
-0.0069368952,
-0.0146941524,
0.031886097,
0.0134020392,
0.0604451634,
0.0436872952,
-0.0421399251,
-0.003810077,
0.0061996328,
-0.0436011031,
0.0323827416,
-0.042799212,
0.0024133173,
0.0001670276,
-0.0085971663,
-0.0846487135,
-0.0825546831,
0.0060810987,
-0.0110279806,
-0.011424548,
0.0144389868,
-0.0436692908,
-0.0056370064,
-0.0529378392,
0.0531058162,
-0.005968296,
0.0246193521,
-0.096928142,
-0.0203183312,
0.0311112516,
-0.016871836,
0.0012508997,
0.0060028262,
0.001803245,
-0.0390692763,
0.0087154489,
0.0931630284,
0.0244295876,
0.044421196,
0.0098208822,
-0.0635470748,
-0.0447168052,
0.0583936982,
-0.0642603934,
0.0181207117,
0.0821079984,
0.0401267149,
0.0030830691,
0.0424773246,
-0.0029153179,
0.0433309488,
0.0030273865,
-0.0288226996,
-0.0071604108,
-0.0036949606,
0.0037632948,
0.0351574495,
0.0674420819,
0.0040449826,
0.0005450802,
-0.0297523271,
0.0441711918,
0.0055178138,
-0.0018326755,
-0.0421101078,
-0.0091467826,
-0.0071811639,
-0.0143065415,
-0.0204389356,
-0.0367216431,
-0.0646615997,
0.005409624,
-0.0807058513,
0.05819894,
0.0419984013,
0.0213753283,
-0.0283094309,
0.0066065337,
-0.0387130566,
0.0133632431,
0.0307836626,
0.0341798849,
0.0181797445,
0.0566606373,
-0.0128566818,
0.0499625392,
0.0038097079,
0.0613915995,
-0.0112988465,
-0.0404719301,
-0.0445281155,
0.0190400034,
0.0211214311,
-0.0194613561,
0.0635050312,
0.018123515,
0.0067452062,
-0.0229461547,
0.0664946437,
-0.0280532762,
-0.0069651534,
0.066397354,
0.0179454423,
-0.0290540811,
-0.0210827775,
0.0724492744,
-0.0244716778,
0.0279170033,
-0.001329757,
-0.0065108896,
-0.0479200818,
-0.0518096127,
0.0637481138,
0.037138138,
-0.0259737186,
-0.0095069222,
-0.040828988,
-0.0486462675,
-0.0134937204,
0.0077177426,
0.0007631201,
0.0153954942,
0.0452026129,
0.0009321403,
-0.0016881087,
-0.0372346453,
-0.0475602336,
-0.049244862,
-0.0402786322,
0.0151867568,
0.0078414166,
-6.117413661e-33,
-0.0065163984,
0.0218666457,
-0.0112879137,
0.0384436436,
0.0173516572,
-0.0083746864,
-0.0056295614,
0.0382073373,
-0.0515512638,
0.0102547165,
-0.0049498547,
0.0010668277,
0.0172857177,
0.0016333429,
0.0311683435,
-0.0209060796,
0.0455201417,
0.0202444829,
-0.0135537768,
0.036200501,
0.0053304434,
-0.0056179585,
0.0798888281,
-0.1040443778,
0.0610496365,
-0.0079219928,
-0.0185115002,
0.0184164774,
-0.0420616567,
0.0698797554,
-0.0308084711,
0.0745305419,
0.0248445868,
-0.0039632265,
-0.0075016622,
-0.0210804977,
-0.0548982024,
-0.0443456359,
0.0437539034,
-0.0013393274,
-0.0543268807,
-0.0402742587,
0.0186516196,
-0.0120691126,
-0.0059891837,
-0.0275727622,
0.061855562,
-0.0177329481,
0.0155886412,
0.0249771494,
-0.0427186079,
0.0061895987,
-0.035628669,
-0.0285737533,
0.0097415885,
0.0806443319,
-0.0054161898,
0.0280453824,
-0.0179367363,
0.0222725198,
0.0171088949,
0.0009139947,
0.0331106819,
-0.0352254882,
-0.0039086179,
0.058321476,
0.0188805163,
-0.0137582086,
0.0304941889,
0.0002006407,
-0.00366305,
0.0408088267,
0.0535147972,
0.0887473822,
0.0129749887,
-0.0369961224,
-0.0510601364,
0.0288694818,
0.0361802801,
0.0250144619,
-0.0133927902,
0.0150522906,
-0.0718199909,
-0.0101841791,
-0.0203763898,
-0.0435296744,
-0.0300456472,
-0.0315457359,
0.0535311289,
0.009600969,
-0.0093056383,
-0.0046759034,
0.0103956405,
-0.0050743427,
0.0076474217,
0.0090365689,
-0.0123692174,
0.0216164459,
0.0421565399,
-0.0534788854,
-0.0685867369,
0.0036400731,
-0.0128014833,
-0.0293475706,
0.0367819853,
-0.0178332273,
0.0664111227,
0.0194011461,
-0.072488904,
-0.0018044871,
-0.0162712801,
0.041363813,
0.0041859676,
0.0080691334,
-0.0041752108,
-0.0181320123,
-0.0396163017,
0.0968112573,
-0.0271760002,
0.0115580363,
-0.0607752763,
-0.0176909715,
0.0012577146,
0.0185611919,
-0.0382643528,
-0.0485783182,
0.014140591,
-0.016714666,
0.0083689615,
-0.0213858206,
-0.0149403745,
-0.0284753069,
2.508e-7,
0.0095489891,
0.0272712205,
0.0327991769,
0.020973891,
-0.0153209772,
0.032444004,
-0.0349869877,
0.0191985816,
0.0326833203,
0.0295250826,
0.0228945147,
-0.0109819872,
0.0273734517,
0.0158801451,
-0.0781148598,
-0.0647229478,
-0.033931531,
-0.0342913568,
-0.0174504649,
-0.0300186388,
0.0825582147,
0.0972788557,
0.0088776471,
-0.0181636401,
0.0004702224,
0.0432001762,
0.0383988433,
-0.1091770232,
0.0110597759,
0.0114832753,
0.0142231314,
-0.0259369742,
-0.0009912028,
0.0207996108,
-0.0122305257,
-0.0172198154,
-0.0480251163,
0.1066660732,
0.0242792536,
-0.0623748228,
0.0236310791,
0.0261611808,
0.0290574729,
-0.0511156023,
0.0417636335,
-0.040222466,
-0.0653557703,
0.0066003264,
-0.0323541909,
-0.0319980122,
0.0653884858,
-0.0242120437,
0.0239345971,
0.0249820575,
0.0264974497,
-0.0176287778,
-0.0516310781,
-0.0445033982,
-0.034085989,
0.0173618309,
-0.0094852233,
-0.0660782009,
-0.0247729179,
0.0504541472,
-0.028316224,
-0.0743132979,
-0.0072649862,
1.991796658e-34,
0.0336443111,
0.006378436,
0.0358451568,
0.0197835602,
0.0262128338,
-0.0177406762,
0.0467684381,
0.0144135524,
0.0289281346,
-0.0409366451,
-0.0001534911
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09521v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09521v2 | AMRFact: Enhancing Summarization Factuality Evaluation with AMR-Driven Negative Samples Generation | 2023-11-16T02:56:29 | 2024-04-02T20:46:37 | Haoyi Qiu, Kung-Hsiang Huang, Jingnong Qu, Nanyun Peng | cs.CL | cs.CL | Ensuring factual consistency is crucial for natural language generation
tasks, particularly in abstractive summarization, where preserving the
integrity of information is paramount. Prior works on evaluating factual
consistency of summarization often take the entailment-based approaches that
first generate perturbed (factual inconsistent) summaries and then train a
classifier on the generated data to detect the factually inconsistencies during
testing time. However, previous approaches generating perturbed summaries are
either of low coherence or lack error-type coverage. To address these issues,
we propose AMRFact, a framework that generates perturbed summaries using
Abstract Meaning Representations (AMRs). Our approach parses factually
consistent summaries into AMR graphs and injects controlled factual
inconsistencies to create negative examples, allowing for coherent factually
inconsistent summaries to be generated with high error-type coverage.
Additionally, we present a data selection module NegFilter based on natural
language inference and BARTScore to ensure the quality of the generated
negative samples. Experimental results demonstrate our approach significantly
outperforms previous systems on the AggreFact-SOTA benchmark, showcasing its
efficacy in evaluating factuality of abstractive summarization. | [
0.0115584685,
0.0505210795,
-0.0032969767,
0.0261855293,
-0.0381216966,
0.0033652019,
-0.048873987,
-0.0542093627,
-0.0215150565,
-0.028945351,
0.033988528,
-0.0207931604,
0.0266061518,
0.0440658182,
0.0323936976,
-0.039852418,
0.0571539328,
0.0381143801,
-0.0105861202,
0.0054621459,
0.0434137136,
0.049967356,
-0.0122959604,
0.0277940743,
-0.016881939,
0.0024256604,
-0.0056752893,
0.0126404697,
0.0521226265,
-0.054134991,
-0.0132755702,
-0.0005306143,
0.0120081585,
0.0308471676,
0.0000018584,
-0.0604092702,
-0.0296364911,
0.0148498863,
-0.0219419561,
0.0063164416,
0.0732375234,
-0.0288155209,
0.021837607,
0.0269995015,
-0.0069086147,
0.0010678162,
0.0097472817,
0.0534234978,
0.1064578816,
0.0759966001,
-0.0132094575,
-0.0031854205,
-0.0058302614,
-0.0100856582,
-0.034315642,
0.0114714848,
-0.0105174612,
0.0452439114,
0.0019586065,
-0.0362989455,
-0.0160421245,
-0.0047683036,
0.0011901249,
0.017338315,
0.0062759556,
0.0291872974,
-0.0990853086,
-0.0092285303,
0.0372348949,
0.0559261106,
0.0235061869,
-0.0355487317,
0.0204399396,
-0.0209644679,
-0.0223681312,
0.0041002445,
-0.0112849427,
0.0517221466,
-0.0638877153,
0.0399504714,
0.0336835086,
0.0250707734,
0.002533406,
0.0506062768,
-0.036138963,
0.0165744647,
0.0066342955,
-0.0323021933,
-0.0065097795,
-0.0047567361,
-0.0781897604,
-0.0381494872,
0.0197612103,
0.0024073331,
-0.0298090354,
-0.0012336825,
-0.0847748443,
-0.0649529025,
0.0402309708,
-0.0299815126,
-0.0018099971,
0.0191412438,
0.012013793,
0.0203893762,
-0.0016210673,
0.0354038626,
0.0513685085,
0.0000985778,
-0.0372889526,
-0.0203161612,
-0.0141591756,
0.0175658073,
-0.0495342612,
0.0554903969,
-0.0440154672,
-0.0175561197,
-0.0394631289,
0.0217174999,
-0.0237210747,
0.0226175059,
-0.0278782919,
0.0068410472,
-0.0212378036,
0.0184811205,
-0.0447935425,
-0.0088199768,
-0.0214524027,
-0.0161641557,
0.0332215428,
-0.00539653,
-0.0276746396,
0.0180607587,
0.0285347924,
0.0156511739,
0.0100371428,
0.0387238674,
-0.0195790548,
-0.001066303,
-0.0291332845,
-0.0724189654,
-0.0016976442,
-0.0591018237,
-0.0387147591,
-0.0417643338,
0.0214586686,
0.0132332155,
-0.0236124583,
-0.0050858916,
0.0148580279,
0.0457076319,
0.0158051029,
0.0168191101,
-0.0372398384,
-0.010896286,
-0.0049137888,
0.0014423179,
-0.0223622471,
0.0116030853,
0.0511747636,
0.0277710054,
0.0484233908,
0.0573031344,
0.0072474657,
-0.0259133354,
0.0203717779,
-0.0014402258,
0.0471106507,
-0.0004293239,
-0.0901193619,
0.0015698253,
0.0380614735,
0.0831639618,
-0.0354286991,
-0.0026316473,
0.0379529893,
0.0089827869,
-0.0386589803,
0.0220641941,
0.0477041826,
0.0549255982,
0.005396612,
0.0371141694,
-0.0257114656,
0.0211362001,
-0.0498091057,
0.0663337708,
0.0544632077,
0.0221640132,
-0.0064383605,
-0.0459960289,
-0.0205475111,
-0.0137652624,
0.0295309573,
-0.0176969059,
0.0131919608,
0.0130611639,
-0.0508548431,
0.0475895815,
0.0177776515,
-0.0727952793,
0.0256225318,
0.002795218,
0.0344792195,
0.0341353416,
0.0638235435,
-0.0233453102,
-0.0615465529,
-0.0273149125,
-0.0124803958,
0.0803109109,
0.0441317447,
-0.0145425182,
-0.0123272343,
-0.0383607298,
-0.0026882137,
-0.0177333392,
0.0256424844,
-0.0141293164,
-0.0003735684,
0.004000234,
0.0600099973,
-0.0331090689,
-0.0789976195,
0.023996653,
-0.0181142092,
-0.0078390446,
-0.006207922,
-0.0082727894,
0.0206524655,
0.0155396024,
-0.0316586271,
0.0175451338,
0.009842962,
-0.0225221682,
-0.0430399366,
0.0349546224,
-0.0504371859,
-0.0698103979,
0.0133670224,
-0.0766258687,
-0.0011701846,
0.0305923652,
-0.0586936101,
-0.0504569709,
0.0524587929,
-0.0941104144,
0.0023001039,
-0.0459519662,
0.0202005692,
0.0483499765,
-0.0052498528,
0.0029035592,
0.0543009937,
-0.0123882145,
-0.0177370291,
0.010992785,
-0.0106502194,
0.0217195377,
-0.0254228469,
0.0133834407,
-0.0185972787,
0.0148422047,
0.0173713341,
0.0633993,
0.010804222,
-0.0312158968,
0.0037434066,
-0.0404644124,
0.0196884573,
-0.0353350416,
0.0210163556,
0.0664097294,
-0.0118379733,
0.0107288891,
0.0220788531,
-0.017155651,
-0.0357655846,
0.0264627021,
-0.0073421388,
0.0487389863,
-0.0130180372,
0.01978755,
-0.0300420746,
0.020181248,
-0.0204723775,
0.0429208577,
0.0140806353,
-0.0267701019,
-0.0570488945,
0.0165024009,
-0.0676430166,
-0.0193151496,
-0.0093103731,
0.0105985859,
0.005630455,
0.0502115227,
0.0314521939,
-0.0217331368,
0.0202188641,
0.0194315258,
0.0249279067,
0.0281411875,
-0.0050162044,
-0.0075627868,
-0.0344162956,
0.0496399738,
0.0440040715,
-0.06256181,
0.0296354499,
0.0205173586,
0.0302632097,
0.0092926249,
-0.0317024328,
0.0273780283,
-0.0555612631,
0.0050464049,
-0.0005320066,
-0.0195917953,
-0.0001857146,
-0.0061325631,
-0.0557572022,
-0.0115796374,
0.0853682533,
-0.0162385963,
0.0031183981,
-0.0759549215,
-0.0150659848,
-0.0480778925,
0.0286552887,
0.0205872357,
0.0436468422,
0.0208883733,
0.0103342254,
-0.0335382409,
-0.0375027992,
0.0759580955,
-0.0269255359,
0.0864647925,
-0.0564446189,
0.0029938119,
-0.0068555176,
-0.0130788032,
-0.025169732,
-0.0651213825,
0.0344154984,
0.0329085998,
-0.0011538779,
0.0113814892,
-0.0428162217,
0.0079604536,
0.0384234749,
0.0345905162,
-0.0176968109,
-0.0215187669,
-0.0249944441,
0.021408353,
0.0996408984,
0.0156886317,
0.0574821942,
-0.0253081024,
0.0154206464,
0.0370857716,
-0.0252490137,
-0.0203211717,
0.0056759622,
-0.0236313883,
-0.047082141,
-0.0469593666,
0.0059197955,
-0.0087950779,
0.0522177108,
-0.0371595323,
-0.0181114748,
0.0711158663,
0.0296683591,
0.0317197815,
0.0334858112,
0.0261727031,
0.049694404,
0.0134402914,
-0.018494973,
-0.0894590393,
-0.0013999316,
-0.0198552664,
0.0366072319,
-0.009581388,
-0.0483208261,
-0.0265011601,
-0.1227637976,
0.0151528204,
0.0329968818,
-0.0580990501,
-0.0383934118,
-0.0108645568,
0.0052262521,
-0.0308615882,
0.0319437534,
0.0409718901,
-0.0239954442,
0.024468841,
0.0106702223,
-0.0648436248,
-0.0121410312,
-0.0244042613,
-0.0349316336,
-0.0162922777,
0.0093846843,
0.0301536415,
-0.0040881941,
0.0189725403,
0.0120575186,
-0.0530910343,
-0.01616689,
-0.0076773143,
0.0620528311,
0.0222590026,
0.0174224507,
-0.0302780494,
0.0255223103,
0.0256822836,
-0.0354967527,
-0.0233661178,
0.053621605,
-0.0236940403,
-0.0218769945,
-0.0318352729,
0.0212175772,
0.0174271427,
0.0804658681,
0.0190503672,
0.0334176496,
-0.0382273793,
-0.0101053976,
0.0135393953,
-0.0483564511,
0.0324743576,
-0.0070135575,
-0.0492115282,
0.0137110557,
-0.0882779881,
-0.0715109333,
0.0061090854,
-0.0057806727,
-0.0193848014,
-0.0383076146,
0.0382532217,
-0.0346662849,
-0.0433164462,
0.0109003438,
-0.0184271596,
0.0199625157,
0.0296037514,
-0.0437653847,
0.0169343855,
-0.0123274485,
-0.0092239575,
0.0331199095,
-0.0211926233,
-0.0591457672,
-0.015543567,
0.0154838599,
0.0144562367,
0.0497334488,
0.0080647208,
0.0310803186,
0.0743163228,
0.0296241976,
-0.0039688977,
0.0541457571,
0.0339975357,
0.0392070375,
-0.0170080867,
0.0231036041,
-0.0539871342,
0.0208471138,
-0.0279151108,
0.0800737739,
-0.0082420036,
-0.012075955,
0.0510985069,
0.0682586506,
0.0064098826,
-0.0348200537,
0.007967866,
-0.0235498678,
-0.0171875171,
-0.0407709889,
-0.0415417999,
-0.0279432572,
0.034953922,
-0.0353972763,
0.0019229695,
-0.0380454585,
0.0304494109,
-0.0469398908,
0.0497165248,
-0.0049513974,
-0.0240072012,
-0.0260522068,
-0.0239240136,
-0.020151794,
-0.0089602238,
-0.0642734542,
-0.0460209325,
-0.0337889381,
0.0239877403,
-0.0185951591,
0.00319864,
0.0293167401,
0.0099650091,
-0.0376890004,
0.0123758009,
-0.0403853431,
0.0759690627,
-0.047015667,
0.020364007,
0.043409355,
-0.0138089722,
0.0989738777,
-0.0201590285,
0.0047228062,
-0.0256486647,
0.056382481,
0.0098528983,
-0.0425376296,
-0.0130839981,
0.0250752158,
0.0034478921,
-0.005071057,
0.0434623063,
-0.0701964945,
0.0245873742,
-0.005171983,
-0.0246765688,
-0.0493429638,
-0.0583796278,
-0.0405023135,
0.0068328222,
-0.0018868347,
-0.0289944559,
-0.0810049772,
-0.0705719441,
0.0463138185,
0.0318620279,
0.0519661158,
-0.0035880965,
0.0337595008,
0.0169395506,
0.0112558957,
-0.0262553897,
-0.0218464285,
0.0014258856,
-0.0497814827,
0.0290463287,
-0.0526148118,
-5.981031337e-33,
-0.051793348,
-0.0173976216,
-0.001923291,
0.0013788006,
-0.0570829697,
0.0015568328,
-0.0601587258,
-0.0094546452,
0.0452098995,
0.0227412079,
0.0394624546,
0.0094163558,
0.000276931,
0.023362048,
-0.0392195471,
-0.0149688171,
0.0676346347,
0.0462257676,
-0.0529477783,
0.0306757074,
0.060646683,
-0.0273690727,
0.039759744,
-0.0532305576,
0.012958616,
-0.0292727221,
-0.0221044198,
-0.0271761324,
-0.0044915299,
0.0223561972,
0.0266450923,
0.0672258288,
0.0119923316,
0.022040505,
-0.0303553119,
-0.0616054349,
-0.0494623929,
-0.0594021268,
0.0451604277,
-0.0449105389,
-0.0432088338,
-0.0130957002,
0.0420991778,
-0.0253501292,
0.0009002581,
-0.0006754621,
0.0358650647,
-0.026897056,
-0.0129226679,
-0.0516095944,
-0.0641499385,
0.0396187045,
0.006072504,
-0.0043654181,
-0.0520618968,
0.0346722677,
0.0069179484,
-0.0516363308,
-0.0106842862,
0.0004779648,
0.0167277772,
-0.0078542409,
0.0096687498,
0.0050576306,
-0.0085448632,
0.0837021023,
-0.0172335971,
-0.0032124219,
-0.01213405,
0.0398852602,
-0.0340310074,
0.010438621,
0.0253876913,
0.0732230321,
0.0529574901,
0.0351052582,
-0.0450566858,
0.0491251498,
-0.0210806709,
0.0526564866,
0.0036655872,
-0.0274533462,
-0.0492162779,
-0.0160177648,
-0.024298599,
0.0201101433,
-0.0032354814,
-0.0213231333,
0.0089421747,
0.0178546701,
-0.0398353897,
0.0483734533,
-0.0187855661,
-0.0127883526,
0.0157291051,
-0.0186345764,
-0.0498418622,
-0.0313012563,
0.0092287501,
-0.0030938706,
-0.0291021913,
0.0067736283,
0.0211158767,
0.0215943903,
0.0161351301,
0.0082604596,
0.0800625458,
0.0154461553,
-0.0300940853,
0.0331979729,
-0.0162122548,
0.0297077708,
-0.0522212349,
-0.0423172489,
0.023348853,
0.0350319184,
-0.0187915508,
0.0129178641,
0.008475245,
0.0027859199,
-0.0248266552,
0.0635270476,
0.0161469057,
0.0417467058,
-0.0217924584,
0.0233804025,
-0.0037995609,
-0.0017716099,
0.0385271423,
-0.088335827,
-0.0157534871,
-0.0194351133,
2.588e-7,
0.0040790439,
0.0355821624,
0.0414420776,
0.0565950274,
-0.0404356681,
-0.000569537,
-0.0280143898,
0.0313196629,
-0.000610939,
0.0005974444,
0.0218386296,
0.0395924263,
0.0183171742,
0.0761504173,
-0.041821979,
0.0564769357,
-0.0914761201,
-0.0241906308,
-0.0320988595,
0.0190204419,
0.1210457087,
0.040479511,
0.0234847609,
-0.0011368311,
0.001277235,
-0.0291412342,
0.0558016188,
0.0416189916,
-0.0478858277,
-0.0164264217,
0.0322462544,
0.0028836401,
0.0145382769,
0.0111797666,
-0.0166014563,
-0.0294857733,
0.0062948884,
0.0083466237,
-0.0024486175,
-0.0212097708,
-0.011251389,
-0.0372395553,
0.0184242949,
0.0411700308,
0.0491578542,
-0.0579856522,
-0.0028348593,
-0.0519253835,
-0.0778156444,
0.042570997,
0.0081230719,
-0.0070500262,
-0.0555717982,
0.0170899872,
0.0062980074,
0.0100579821,
-0.0040898314,
-0.014787388,
-0.0254131909,
0.0384791419,
0.0144974776,
-0.0431358553,
0.0005911255,
0.0383550934,
0.0126021961,
-0.0905777812,
0.0070539881,
2.588940671e-34,
0.1052345708,
-0.0000821359,
-0.0162269957,
-0.0516424552,
0.0486315824,
-0.0167006776,
-0.0012692871,
0.0081135519,
-0.0011978424,
-0.0255528484,
-0.0057587684
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09519v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09519v2 | Leveraging Code to Improve In-context Learning for Semantic Parsing | 2023-11-16T02:50:06 | 2024-03-27T21:52:11 | Ben Bogin, Shivanshu Gupta, Peter Clark, Ashish Sabharwal | cs.CL | cs.CL | In-context learning (ICL) is an appealing approach for semantic parsing due
to its few-shot nature and improved generalization. However, learning to parse
to rare domain-specific languages (DSLs) from just a few demonstrations is
challenging, limiting the performance of even the most capable LLMs. In this
work, we improve the effectiveness of ICL for semantic parsing by (1) using
general-purpose programming languages such as Python instead of DSLs, and (2)
augmenting prompts with a structured domain description that includes, e.g.,
the available classes and functions. We show that both these changes
significantly improve accuracy across three popular datasets. Combined, they
lead to dramatic improvements (e.g. 7.9% to 66.5% on SMCalFlow compositional
split), nearly closing the performance gap between easier i.i.d.\ and harder
compositional splits when used with a strong model, and reducing the need for a
large number of demonstrations. We find that the resemblance of the target
parse language to general-purpose code is a more important factor than the
language's popularity in pre-training corpora. Our findings provide an improved
methodology for building semantic parsers in the modern context of ICL with
LLMs. | [
-0.0001792596,
0.0223429948,
0.0083584124,
0.0520893782,
-0.0153036518,
0.0427885726,
0.0031673927,
-0.0089859301,
-0.0348296762,
-0.060480848,
-0.0217693932,
0.0201634429,
-0.0414218418,
0.0232218597,
0.0018336038,
-0.030157635,
0.0676053017,
-0.0195114929,
-0.0257874522,
0.0520024858,
-0.008404715,
0.0278185178,
-0.0018732252,
0.0356719978,
-0.0238726251,
-0.0309284925,
-0.0116527891,
0.0174895618,
-0.0150760654,
-0.0574083589,
0.0110049481,
0.0046745921,
0.0551564246,
0.0100110099,
0.0000019795,
-0.0707031339,
-0.0296058767,
0.0108395685,
-0.0365101621,
-0.0398181155,
0.0363241546,
-0.0265359692,
-0.0073467307,
0.0013314438,
-0.0618108846,
-0.0083966926,
0.0077520064,
-0.0158701316,
0.0703078657,
0.1037921309,
-0.0094979573,
-0.031564489,
-0.0150838569,
0.0192001108,
0.0193382148,
-0.030387247,
-0.0117331203,
-0.0085822204,
0.0153182158,
-0.0547760203,
-0.0179885235,
0.0348366201,
0.0364441164,
0.0155015001,
0.0115962597,
0.0377942957,
-0.0469829813,
-0.0204024184,
-0.0245194547,
0.0810423121,
-0.0240039527,
-0.0138677834,
0.0019607467,
-0.0190381519,
0.0151521964,
-0.0470077805,
-0.0390741751,
0.0334574394,
-0.0376889147,
0.0310839191,
0.0268675182,
0.0068346127,
0.0152199483,
0.0141360117,
-0.0253357626,
0.1027320102,
-0.0272993222,
-0.0065104733,
0.0515789427,
0.016104063,
-0.0217288528,
-0.0123298345,
0.0000080394,
0.0188553445,
-0.0698691308,
0.0269204229,
-0.0582839996,
-0.0132306963,
-0.0039544087,
0.0116304159,
-0.0055784713,
0.0523276478,
-0.0151769519,
0.0270142611,
-0.0107345125,
0.0173937343,
0.005703764,
0.0482215695,
-0.0316632986,
-0.0152346557,
-0.0634806678,
-0.0011884364,
-0.0428018458,
0.0490548834,
-0.0612291619,
0.0073996256,
-0.0091920299,
0.0646745563,
-0.0245721731,
0.0414603427,
0.0108074732,
-0.0216164459,
-0.0388282537,
0.0236129314,
0.0126433279,
0.0135386717,
-0.0251348987,
-0.0264970418,
0.0293166861,
-0.0505407602,
-0.0373296179,
0.0306678712,
-0.0043227142,
-0.0441998057,
-0.0020608432,
0.0873391107,
-0.0137125067,
-0.0237714611,
-0.0383161865,
-0.0497830994,
0.024546789,
-0.0331518985,
-0.0030739435,
-0.1015900597,
-0.0031036737,
0.0299540795,
0.020561507,
-0.0723718926,
-0.0183728561,
0.0051441328,
0.0209845882,
0.056758333,
-0.066462025,
-0.0259815231,
0.001671585,
-0.0044651707,
-0.0311298221,
0.0762311667,
0.0191119593,
-0.0291441455,
0.0283043459,
0.0094829556,
-0.0341877006,
0.0267497506,
-0.0069467435,
-0.0188483018,
-0.0302223209,
0.0169305913,
-0.0007682652,
0.0047787013,
0.0547780246,
0.0015184617,
-0.0094294511,
0.0230040811,
-0.0388960056,
0.0214622561,
-0.0077909348,
0.0069904551,
0.0997901782,
0.0352451056,
-0.0019883348,
-0.0274294354,
-0.0769022554,
-0.0217734408,
0.0207042824,
0.0391394086,
-0.055458717,
0.01304965,
0.0095539223,
-0.0440022685,
0.0135157881,
-0.0238904878,
-0.0133652911,
0.001234584,
0.0252145734,
0.0385116301,
-0.0197998732,
0.0657930896,
0.0386615768,
-0.0500810519,
-0.0075343992,
-0.0214609224,
0.0002796741,
0.0561875291,
0.0333423093,
-0.0704372451,
-0.0215281062,
-0.032917168,
0.0515393727,
0.0392430164,
0.0031032809,
-0.033506576,
0.0219358969,
-0.0592654869,
-0.008121036,
-0.0526072159,
0.0133354757,
-0.0084077194,
0.0222941525,
-0.0328618027,
0.0181151144,
-0.0175547935,
-0.001638953,
0.0442533344,
0.004288353,
-0.0126669137,
-0.0073162355,
0.0047723111,
0.0353325084,
0.0130773857,
-0.0116829956,
-0.0069923052,
0.0073426114,
-0.0172452051,
0.0169166867,
0.0021173947,
-0.0733237192,
-0.0824191943,
0.0316895731,
-0.0111525087,
-0.0663721859,
-0.005942842,
-0.0662097484,
-0.0098972833,
-0.0246927682,
-0.0140486816,
0.0529174022,
0.0088854767,
0.0110882334,
0.0184295401,
-0.0133252097,
-0.0471147522,
0.0862600207,
0.0185411349,
-0.0093743503,
0.0243640319,
0.0413077883,
0.0084083816,
-0.0112075582,
-0.0088299476,
-0.0062765144,
-0.0287552886,
-0.0112392902,
-0.027033871,
0.0519412532,
-0.0911784321,
0.0166969355,
-0.050411351,
0.0014794134,
-0.050514929,
0.0344245918,
0.0538155027,
0.0340811983,
-0.0087068006,
-0.0394672304,
0.0076281317,
-0.0160536282,
-0.0257863551,
-0.015016879,
0.0538581647,
0.0292405244,
-0.0350144133,
-0.0222851895,
-0.0152794272,
-0.037639197,
0.0380834006,
0.0062598367,
-0.0386557393,
-0.0201392584,
0.0567722172,
0.0040608784,
0.016406415,
0.0066027693,
0.0219616462,
0.0149431936,
-0.041500818,
-0.0022619441,
0.0421350077,
-0.04033833,
0.0376240648,
0.0206656046,
-0.0278232228,
-0.0710246265,
0.0475784987,
0.033926852,
-0.0102484683,
-0.0754068196,
0.0383842476,
0.0440659747,
0.0716644004,
0.0000698155,
0.0285233539,
0.0038080346,
-0.0214176998,
-0.0003943857,
-0.0471105762,
-0.0238674246,
0.0098457225,
-0.0256931167,
0.0339803807,
-0.0123281227,
-0.0297335908,
0.0901850089,
-0.0090951631,
-0.057181485,
-0.0734784752,
-0.0393299349,
-0.0612987429,
0.0366489068,
-0.0241634697,
-0.0104394481,
-0.0028562613,
-0.0837050378,
-0.0329739675,
0.0134131471,
-0.003133222,
0.0134648997,
0.0721601099,
-0.0681482852,
0.0277714469,
0.0104651768,
-0.0246784352,
-0.0456654057,
-0.0380004086,
-0.0477242209,
0.0183222666,
-0.038424693,
0.035121996,
0.0248995274,
-0.036162205,
-0.0077212527,
0.0463079922,
0.0278875846,
-0.0367670469,
-0.0303696971,
-0.0102497283,
-0.0099320058,
0.0173663776,
-0.0000558491,
0.0139113506,
0.044230599,
0.0404688045,
0.0559574738,
-0.0178626832,
-0.0394084454,
0.0396588109,
0.0021991788,
-0.076134555,
-0.026300624,
0.0431266576,
0.0259689186,
-0.0912562609,
-0.0339649618,
0.1252398342,
0.0558894128,
-0.0389931053,
0.0145608196,
0.0112119056,
0.0051194797,
0.0677308962,
0.0293332376,
-0.077519238,
-0.0902430862,
-0.0011843394,
0.0225828029,
0.0257368628,
-0.0146978237,
-0.0005633323,
-0.1116969883,
-0.0010064014,
0.0089659039,
-0.0242330302,
-0.0064370716,
-0.0202871915,
-0.0332987756,
-0.0379443392,
0.0275085252,
0.0238857213,
-0.0386247784,
0.0104080308,
-0.0007585567,
-0.0071024518,
-0.033105094,
0.0201519467,
-0.0334198177,
-0.010922594,
0.0857526809,
-0.0132841105,
-0.0178145543,
0.004521633,
0.1089051664,
-0.0142923752,
0.0111807752,
-0.0368305445,
0.0574854091,
-0.0232370961,
-0.0041503021,
0.0277708508,
0.0324800909,
-0.0763248652,
-0.0294346865,
0.0263269041,
0.0585496016,
-0.032425411,
0.0289753862,
0.0062077423,
-0.0191417169,
0.0035981031,
0.0531374179,
0.0285394397,
0.0090830689,
-0.0442220792,
-0.0925507843,
-0.0222245846,
-0.0443428904,
0.0328315087,
0.0302419681,
0.0038060094,
-0.0245686155,
-0.0513096824,
-0.0455645211,
0.0667632446,
0.0517697111,
-0.0349079818,
-0.0035292935,
-0.011991879,
0.0230642371,
-0.0469945669,
0.0339924172,
-0.0294920523,
0.035528671,
-0.0611924194,
-0.0063221459,
0.0313539281,
0.0003885939,
-0.0584392622,
0.0084645851,
-0.0680978149,
-0.0523152053,
0.0041964394,
0.0241556596,
0.0144294975,
0.0689025447,
-0.0498581044,
-0.0029819563,
0.0079301521,
0.0560039952,
-0.052412197,
-0.0120509956,
0.0320638381,
0.0260630101,
0.032765612,
0.0120332316,
-0.045623973,
-0.0177645944,
-0.0102575058,
0.0348768979,
-0.04099245,
0.031598486,
0.0766912028,
0.0362347364,
0.0315949395,
0.0160492808,
0.0002932407,
-0.0003423612,
0.0220560096,
0.00141675,
-0.0518742986,
-0.0422549471,
0.0060630902,
-0.0088576172,
-0.0428827889,
0.0319379605,
0.0346400402,
-0.0256057773,
0.0636989325,
-0.0131822415,
0.0431082621,
0.0401060618,
0.0088595459,
0.0144332843,
0.00254511,
-0.0235314071,
0.0043600691,
0.0149240103,
0.0181412492,
-0.0232487693,
0.0248005763,
0.018898489,
0.0070772544,
-0.0352383256,
0.0165930614,
-0.0439638831,
-0.0004133096,
0.0087136114,
0.025090877,
0.0602608472,
-0.0037184672,
0.0464401171,
-0.0043645124,
0.0191107951,
0.0068147155,
0.0483039767,
0.0105942478,
-0.0571343191,
0.0535272956,
0.0317358188,
-0.0159207471,
-0.0778923333,
0.0693845302,
-0.0289691798,
0.0428314321,
0.010893384,
-0.001749631,
-0.0522241034,
-0.0207647122,
0.0282655135,
0.0514404364,
-0.0154565396,
-0.0240194779,
-0.0256646611,
-0.0458529666,
-0.0067028976,
0.001849732,
-0.0105571486,
-0.0191418827,
0.0772646144,
0.0730725452,
0.0089670504,
-0.0452743694,
0.0159559473,
-0.0249362458,
0.0396309569,
-0.0671831071,
-0.0506163575,
-5.233141423e-33,
-0.0419078134,
0.0006968232,
0.0478484444,
0.0446731783,
0.0104868412,
-0.0221068766,
-0.047837466,
0.0070335576,
-0.0002458021,
-0.012201013,
-0.0034028986,
0.0220306441,
0.0264870208,
0.0159486867,
0.0326784216,
-0.0402183793,
0.029910747,
0.0013449955,
-0.0190751776,
-0.0052042403,
0.0378645808,
0.0509233773,
0.0523725189,
-0.0223991815,
-0.0073822103,
0.0309783351,
-0.0096281217,
0.0342088193,
0.0065570045,
0.0317059569,
0.0372852013,
0.0187817477,
0.0241342764,
-0.0234907456,
-0.0437317453,
-0.0132854609,
-0.087116234,
-0.01572101,
0.0072795763,
0.0295598749,
-0.0113002099,
-0.0397572182,
0.0527720675,
-0.0107516432,
0.0204580408,
-0.0026904505,
0.039755933,
0.0038880766,
0.0188960172,
-0.0523646846,
-0.0613837764,
0.0323329717,
-0.0238487441,
0.0089500621,
0.0408031866,
0.0130266622,
0.008878734,
0.0337596573,
0.0050104917,
0.0075772218,
-0.0408274047,
0.0542547181,
0.0668684244,
0.0063896882,
-0.0115142614,
0.0240094196,
-0.0027264585,
-0.0347517617,
0.0468119979,
0.0486089252,
0.0182797089,
0.0580764636,
-0.0345628113,
0.0415298492,
0.0405771621,
0.0183460433,
-0.0241601262,
0.012423519,
0.0043340605,
0.0384419262,
-0.0553234667,
0.03178408,
-0.0402500108,
0.0085198656,
0.00178147,
0.0341501087,
0.0107092038,
-0.0268335249,
0.0426031388,
-0.0399328433,
0.0053231632,
0.0287019294,
0.024437245,
-0.022282511,
-0.018072838,
0.0022306365,
-0.0023322769,
0.032166671,
-0.0024783823,
-0.0162545517,
-0.0149233676,
-0.0466498323,
-0.0048148897,
-0.0081053935,
0.0545729659,
-0.0004777018,
0.0714841709,
0.0109212371,
-0.0444165878,
0.0130466986,
-0.0493079387,
0.0111136213,
-0.0201293193,
0.0634693578,
0.0110757686,
-0.0095202019,
-0.0497358255,
0.0223377142,
-0.00731591,
-0.0608160198,
-0.0247095488,
0.005738616,
-0.0321220085,
0.0106936265,
-0.0589264184,
-0.04087805,
-0.0157860033,
0.010609231,
0.0373506248,
-0.0209420454,
-0.0129961753,
0.0188563336,
2.601e-7,
0.0665374696,
0.0079007978,
0.0292958301,
0.04492452,
0.0018252438,
0.0202642586,
-0.0177576523,
0.0094601726,
-0.0213574432,
-0.024962889,
-0.0277260207,
-0.0080439867,
0.022476837,
0.0411454998,
-0.1271811724,
0.008856643,
0.0011675489,
-0.0028779446,
-0.046487473,
0.0200296324,
0.0555042066,
0.0825721696,
0.0092323665,
-0.0096584475,
0.0038440798,
-0.0371962264,
-0.0131741064,
-0.0148211112,
0.0301673915,
0.032852143,
-0.0637910515,
0.0094579645,
0.0097727748,
0.0027682651,
-0.0118531939,
0.0161761772,
0.003220347,
0.0528428741,
-0.0041628126,
0.0284463819,
0.0045471829,
-0.0184538346,
0.044761315,
-0.0290626641,
0.0209048409,
-0.0504769571,
0.0202423055,
0.0008824089,
-0.0231229663,
-0.0065752533,
-0.0568967685,
-0.0094760787,
0.014925207,
0.0282346383,
0.0309518725,
-0.025561275,
-0.0378784724,
-0.0398601182,
-0.0731925815,
0.0101551441,
-0.0298722237,
-0.024194926,
-0.0218327865,
0.0374356844,
0.050098069,
-0.0601061508,
-0.0245391075,
2.478213695e-34,
0.0220429841,
0.0101878457,
0.0395660922,
0.0731024221,
0.0256804619,
0.0255694091,
-0.0122857317,
0.0322185419,
-0.0030229657,
-0.0173313897,
-0.002047891
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09517v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09517v1 | GEE! Grammar Error Explanation with Large Language Models | 2023-11-16T02:45:47 | 2023-11-16T02:45:47 | Yixiao Song, Kalpesh Krishna, Rajesh Bhatt, Kevin Gimpel, Mohit Iyyer | cs.CL | cs.CL | Grammatical error correction tools are effective at correcting grammatical
errors in users' input sentences but do not provide users with \textit{natural
language} explanations about their errors. Such explanations are essential for
helping users learn the language by gaining a deeper understanding of its
grammatical rules (DeKeyser, 2003; Ellis et al., 2006). To address this gap, we
propose the task of grammar error explanation, where a system needs to provide
one-sentence explanations for each grammatical error in a pair of erroneous and
corrected sentences. We analyze the capability of GPT-4 in grammar error
explanation, and find that it only produces explanations for 60.2% of the
errors using one-shot prompting. To improve upon this performance, we develop a
two-step pipeline that leverages fine-tuned and prompted large language models
to perform structured atomic token edit extraction, followed by prompting GPT-4
to generate explanations. We evaluate our pipeline on German and Chinese
grammar error correction data sampled from language learners with a wide range
of proficiency levels. Human evaluation reveals that our pipeline produces
93.9% and 98.0% correct explanations for German and Chinese data, respectively.
To encourage further research in this area, we will open-source our data and
code. | [
0.068124719,
0.0271534361,
-0.0184079073,
0.0032560588,
-0.0228152908,
0.0252705887,
0.0291120615,
-0.0500837788,
-0.0110910721,
-0.063390471,
0.0040021557,
-0.0185878072,
-0.0093766246,
0.0228222292,
0.0457805209,
-0.0761453211,
0.0592526719,
-0.023389183,
0.0232840441,
0.0116446055,
0.0407114662,
0.0308478381,
-0.0360542312,
0.0827587098,
-0.0487736911,
-0.0317365229,
-0.0604843386,
0.0261932481,
-0.001470131,
-0.0115522221,
0.0201492663,
0.0248096064,
-0.0082695074,
0.037420515,
0.0000020888,
-0.0237939637,
-0.0195224527,
-0.0098081594,
-0.0196469016,
0.0327074155,
0.0112284329,
-0.0062128184,
-0.0520860329,
0.0249752961,
0.0113211926,
-0.0086639402,
0.0571820959,
0.0304286014,
0.0966695324,
0.0881383196,
-0.0004218435,
0.0082101598,
-0.0003712408,
0.0028647955,
-0.0173426196,
0.0036010558,
0.0085524134,
-0.0347396098,
-0.0210802015,
0.0079929279,
-0.0041126176,
-0.0034372136,
0.0351611525,
-0.0817004591,
-0.0026428043,
0.0177121833,
-0.0677335635,
-0.0309006982,
-0.0390063487,
0.0232693162,
0.0129528204,
-0.0337660462,
-0.0060675931,
0.0117141679,
0.0254337117,
0.004410625,
-0.0614672638,
0.0084718978,
-0.0005809379,
0.0167079847,
0.0455387533,
-0.1086547375,
0.0274510756,
0.0127189718,
0.0119372243,
0.0654675364,
0.0135308094,
-0.0393343195,
-0.0569321774,
0.0205978267,
-0.0599289089,
-0.0620808415,
0.0151048312,
0.0352710411,
-0.0700031221,
-0.0031423906,
-0.0148197496,
-0.0465680249,
0.0047973264,
0.0059972759,
0.0255302656,
0.0111650871,
-0.0289747529,
0.0364609994,
0.0158889014,
0.0691918135,
0.0436935835,
-0.0038672886,
-0.0016241801,
-0.0095041469,
-0.0670222044,
-0.0444093831,
-0.0518255942,
0.0192084704,
-0.0496034771,
0.0177439041,
-0.0301582441,
0.0045956043,
-0.0275146365,
0.0549102649,
0.0160906278,
0.009537261,
-0.0440576822,
-0.0424427688,
-0.0170884151,
0.0451302938,
-0.0532769933,
0.0113718826,
0.0511925742,
-0.0486597344,
-0.0411922522,
0.0256556347,
0.0136861224,
-0.0003472041,
-0.0373762622,
0.0153916171,
0.0002261361,
0.0193312168,
-0.0134709766,
-0.0229490306,
-0.0223016553,
-0.0420122892,
-0.0506304353,
-0.0581143871,
-0.0059418892,
0.0000225363,
0.0130998315,
-0.0101324189,
0.0158608835,
-0.0085638547,
-0.0027492272,
0.0508711599,
-0.0576004684,
0.0109389927,
0.0056384909,
-0.018374728,
-0.003123814,
0.0222467929,
0.0216155425,
-0.0375426896,
0.0366359316,
-0.0493412577,
0.0297691356,
-0.0059115947,
-0.0314280018,
-0.0212661047,
0.0087909792,
-0.0362572223,
-0.0210235883,
0.0437557474,
0.0269005205,
0.0656863376,
-0.0103402594,
0.0595021583,
0.0299430881,
0.0529160537,
-0.0072154929,
0.0366410911,
0.0516943,
-0.0264049117,
0.0093306722,
0.0328347348,
-0.0806446448,
0.0025698936,
-0.0253721531,
0.0047962931,
-0.0023115641,
0.0002469417,
0.0032992223,
-0.05320834,
-0.0009374772,
0.0229400229,
-0.0397107974,
-0.0292172581,
0.0507670492,
0.0059071551,
-0.0139280781,
0.0700662211,
0.0350638926,
-0.0714299604,
0.003319453,
-0.0351460762,
0.0309966616,
0.090666607,
0.0423052162,
-0.0162580591,
-0.0191601254,
-0.0370503515,
0.0076232166,
0.0509734377,
0.037581414,
-0.0139922304,
-0.0079599051,
-0.0197970755,
0.0129792392,
-0.0547926165,
0.0471199341,
-0.0203432422,
0.0186998546,
-0.00857634,
0.0204678681,
-0.0350455977,
-0.0271969195,
0.0111883031,
0.0238263346,
-0.0247283261,
-0.0096014244,
-0.004247549,
-0.0031856727,
0.0185318999,
-0.0267408732,
0.0154639622,
-0.0106527722,
-0.0079406789,
-0.0208435394,
0.0167970005,
-0.046874702,
-0.0612270236,
0.0270155463,
-0.0344623737,
-0.0424046777,
0.0047810855,
-0.0657879934,
-0.0620511957,
0.0102701457,
-0.0316334441,
0.022871336,
-0.0351809822,
0.0292787086,
0.014956587,
-0.025521338,
-0.0256449115,
0.0230886657,
0.0267849527,
0.0163225997,
-0.0176844615,
0.0048920754,
-0.0128102116,
-0.0308882464,
0.0035339228,
0.0177679956,
-0.0000943176,
-0.0074662431,
0.0027103119,
0.0101735257,
-0.0697761849,
-0.0198027398,
-0.0989195555,
-0.0059304619,
-0.0453232564,
0.0435674228,
0.0689927265,
0.0114330854,
-0.0104875369,
-0.022509452,
0.0093861669,
0.0433243103,
0.0081050871,
-0.0029378918,
0.0613026731,
-0.0173890889,
-0.0542453453,
-0.0724489167,
-0.0007665259,
-0.0638016164,
-0.0010633254,
0.0300821885,
-0.0032460256,
-0.0717721656,
-0.0102050165,
-0.0055110771,
-0.0048164553,
0.0338945724,
-0.0766145587,
0.0131882979,
-0.0324708931,
0.0519412272,
0.0500705279,
-0.0209031254,
0.0869349986,
-0.0024200219,
-0.0343398191,
-0.0397561267,
0.003585374,
0.0014138706,
-0.019015383,
-0.0210811384,
-0.0131691229,
0.0089827124,
0.0835629925,
-0.0008386614,
-0.0019890536,
-0.0394696817,
0.0361351781,
-0.025632007,
0.0157072134,
-0.0108784651,
-0.0370360576,
-0.0198723897,
0.0160606578,
-0.0362377018,
-0.0299755372,
0.0998609886,
-0.0012501727,
-0.0157341287,
-0.030219771,
-0.0248255972,
-0.0075199972,
0.0477091931,
-0.004028968,
0.0132075381,
0.005519473,
-0.0506245829,
-0.0191664714,
-0.0071045044,
0.0446879901,
0.0212981123,
0.0253900494,
-0.0761736408,
-0.0142615223,
0.0195128955,
-0.0499663837,
-0.007708976,
-0.0400244333,
-0.0419332609,
-0.0004171497,
0.0258552022,
-0.028842926,
-0.038343288,
-0.0349582843,
0.0005151141,
0.028138848,
-0.0248589851,
-0.015433006,
-0.0264816843,
0.0038924117,
0.0199330505,
-0.0004272872,
0.0126730632,
-0.0427873693,
0.0766020641,
0.0599589795,
0.0372438319,
0.0312453303,
-0.0269596111,
0.0246064607,
-0.0039551193,
-0.061934758,
-0.0432422012,
0.0019495671,
0.0944398195,
-0.0792044029,
-0.0200598259,
0.1365709156,
0.0538291596,
-0.0383315273,
0.0135954851,
-0.0469360985,
-0.000134346,
0.0129367132,
0.0192530658,
-0.0545955449,
-0.042896498,
0.0466145538,
0.0204951707,
-0.0057608918,
0.011748394,
0.0289458036,
-0.1091092676,
0.0573600791,
0.0381966233,
-0.0243523978,
-0.0196971782,
-0.0356165692,
0.0167898796,
0.0225092024,
0.0370206423,
0.0438278988,
-0.0101419464,
0.0235938225,
0.0389833264,
-0.0165390354,
-0.0405310057,
0.0018188895,
-0.0396460816,
0.0494287722,
0.0529589728,
0.0257228501,
0.0043194019,
-0.0028649177,
0.0750243738,
0.0214572567,
0.0183023717,
-0.0059396359,
0.0281827524,
0.0301263556,
-0.0206026565,
-0.0522177592,
0.0714774877,
-0.0371170118,
-0.0223852526,
0.0162128042,
0.0902496651,
-0.0170822572,
0.012016871,
0.0255784243,
-0.0138199897,
0.008565126,
0.0319434479,
0.073402606,
-0.0153959757,
-0.0574637428,
-0.0820056275,
-0.0276895911,
-0.0597552769,
0.040372245,
0.0182842705,
0.0209690854,
-0.0162743647,
-0.0335382074,
-0.0640700012,
0.0477834903,
-0.0031449313,
0.0375794098,
-0.0552315675,
-0.0005474841,
-0.0044348189,
0.0314109325,
0.0505022295,
0.0279563535,
0.0236406699,
-0.0876902342,
-0.0129933869,
-0.0297445972,
0.0522608794,
-0.0057210959,
0.0169114694,
-0.0303513706,
-0.044863224,
0.0387725979,
0.0440226384,
0.0096908947,
0.0279281996,
-0.0214286093,
-0.0745316669,
-0.0428468548,
0.0553604998,
-0.0502341017,
-0.025743749,
0.0243819095,
-0.0234275926,
0.0219690688,
0.0389986448,
-0.0116266971,
-0.0050422535,
-0.0221634768,
0.0531091541,
-0.006312801,
0.0037974925,
0.0684965476,
0.0568289682,
0.0506480783,
0.0060570631,
0.0205288827,
-0.047939606,
0.0326185487,
-0.0390724614,
-0.0236236174,
-0.0253653433,
0.0309169106,
0.0073315185,
-0.0719426721,
0.0155567322,
-0.0167858414,
-0.0246028937,
0.0149012525,
-0.0283686407,
0.0192877576,
0.0090253307,
0.0215971824,
0.0220846739,
-0.0007317354,
-0.0071750535,
-0.0156717356,
0.0259007923,
0.0305307042,
-0.0174248535,
0.066256687,
0.0273920912,
0.0113621708,
0.0036662326,
-0.0155917117,
-0.0290826503,
-0.014730501,
0.0032269603,
0.0107481973,
0.090667516,
-0.0071357656,
0.0938341841,
-0.0167764407,
-0.0337124132,
-0.016781697,
0.0802869722,
0.0417440124,
-0.0388330296,
0.0207773894,
0.0153749119,
-0.0049898676,
-0.0467228033,
0.0447725207,
-0.0464954078,
0.04069205,
0.0225921627,
-0.0135164624,
0.0011386779,
0.0126804747,
-0.0361324474,
0.0066943928,
0.0074801715,
0.0024093671,
-0.0106116347,
-0.0626553968,
-0.0697371885,
0.0469646566,
-0.0074468986,
-0.0203725584,
-0.0047208588,
0.0573008247,
-0.0134958904,
-0.0589471981,
-0.0375418849,
0.0331474058,
0.0111091584,
-0.0208019502,
-0.03382181,
-6.434198368e-33,
-0.0452014096,
-0.0354792625,
-0.0245783869,
-0.0052099153,
-0.0222458895,
-0.0323462486,
-0.0866281986,
0.0200327896,
0.0418333597,
0.0686393008,
-0.0161089823,
0.0474190824,
0.0035904166,
0.017485138,
0.054543376,
0.0076831817,
0.0797071382,
0.0381125174,
-0.021321632,
0.0080329329,
0.0423039384,
0.0329805575,
0.0739673972,
0.0114744538,
0.0534891225,
0.0223273728,
-0.0421094634,
0.0233020317,
-0.0442219973,
0.0471198037,
0.0372471884,
0.0552363358,
-0.0143105946,
-0.0080104396,
-0.0134116113,
0.0050424528,
-0.0796106383,
-0.049088411,
0.0376523063,
0.0329651311,
-0.0165787637,
-0.0583695397,
0.0238809567,
-0.0139895314,
-0.0017829915,
0.0000258013,
0.0317000411,
0.0098960223,
0.0331704728,
0.0239882097,
-0.0238488,
0.0111127496,
-0.061530415,
0.0008501285,
-0.013895887,
0.0480170548,
-0.0059629353,
-0.0333192423,
-0.0176838413,
-0.0252076034,
0.0443579778,
0.0442817062,
0.0454848744,
-0.0358746462,
-0.028577026,
0.0364589095,
0.0026649607,
-0.0124772079,
-0.0535118282,
0.0136058014,
-0.0183434356,
0.0144129358,
0.0433510691,
0.0025769544,
0.0091754142,
-0.003659755,
-0.0376012921,
0.0154587692,
-0.0068164389,
0.0907839388,
-0.0203791074,
0.0089117754,
-0.010801767,
-0.0242251474,
-0.0390145741,
0.004659208,
-0.028349828,
-0.0344632715,
0.0353889503,
-0.0241220351,
-0.0158118214,
-0.0195140336,
-0.0295427497,
-0.0163535904,
-0.0110885417,
-0.0098644765,
-0.024909338,
0.0040830439,
-0.0169599243,
0.0091492776,
-0.0065560075,
-0.005665848,
-0.0109997736,
0.0337905027,
0.0534540229,
0.0261039659,
0.0400923528,
0.0187472701,
-0.0628049597,
0.0258970521,
-0.0609951951,
0.0161945615,
-0.0398121923,
-0.031287387,
0.0037384569,
0.0290316101,
-0.0234752465,
-0.0034795231,
0.009708086,
0.0128628938,
-0.0278093852,
0.0213454776,
-0.0176331159,
0.0235716552,
-0.014411469,
-0.0072066118,
-0.0363051631,
-0.0334539227,
0.0403005332,
-0.0385353193,
-0.0140290912,
-0.0044013672,
2.685e-7,
0.0395367146,
0.0827788562,
0.0445917435,
0.0028676672,
0.0154841281,
0.0300963838,
-0.0234697256,
-0.0265740845,
0.0258113351,
0.0600204878,
0.0000918085,
0.0116848545,
0.043214865,
0.0301202219,
-0.0492170565,
0.0267626923,
-0.0581863374,
-0.009436205,
-0.0666201562,
0.0305520259,
0.0501279049,
0.0291724503,
0.0420054123,
0.0064367591,
-0.0001005974,
-0.0470190495,
0.0141013283,
0.0022309707,
-0.0252724569,
0.0334011093,
0.040640913,
0.0145633416,
0.0482708514,
0.0095050968,
-0.0187874511,
-0.0378055945,
-0.0373724923,
0.0464513637,
-0.0319494493,
0.0457604006,
-0.0088679316,
-0.0201559048,
0.0268620085,
-0.0927549452,
0.0391889736,
-0.0231749676,
-0.0008168481,
0.0207193159,
-0.0403160788,
-0.032582663,
-0.0319483131,
-0.0287467949,
-0.0208248254,
0.0329106525,
0.0102164969,
0.0017784731,
0.0023402984,
-0.0131509565,
-0.041921746,
0.0361436531,
0.0164440162,
0.0061009112,
0.0025162278,
0.0126309525,
-0.0101422882,
-0.0365198553,
-0.0159988087,
2.34263787e-34,
0.0355507582,
0.016933592,
0.0590224974,
0.0177802127,
0.06763684,
0.0218380224,
-0.0230853781,
0.0092859333,
0.010309238,
-0.0433571562,
-0.0420736372
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09513v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09513v1 | Sequencing Matters: A Generate-Retrieve-Generate Model for Building Conversational Agents | 2023-11-16T02:37:58 | 2023-11-16T02:37:58 | Quinn Patwardhan, Grace Hui Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper contains what the Georgetown InfoSense group has done in regard to
solving the challenges presented by TREC iKAT 2023. Our submitted runs
outperform the median runs by a significant margin, exhibiting superior
performance in nDCG across various cut numbers and in overall success rate. Our
approach uses a Generate-Retrieve-Generate method, which we've found to greatly
outpace Retrieve-Then-Generate approaches for the purposes of iKAT. Our
solution involves the use of Large Language Models (LLMs) for initial answers,
answer grounding by BM25, passage quality filtering by logistic regression, and
answer generation by LLMs again. We leverage several purpose-built Language
Models, including BERT, Chat-based, and text-to-transfer-based models, for text
understanding, classification, generation, and summarization. The official
results of the TREC evaluation contradict our initial self-evaluation, which
may suggest that a decrease in the reliance on our retrieval and classification
methods is better. Nonetheless, our findings suggest that the sequence of
involving these different components matters, where we see an essentiality of
using LLMs before using search engines. | [
0.0906960964,
0.0436596051,
-0.0198908616,
0.0057248636,
-0.043943312,
-0.015851004,
0.0052439361,
0.0152969183,
0.02394858,
-0.069122918,
0.0162834469,
-0.0468983054,
-0.0066304849,
0.0502132773,
-0.00300536,
-0.0621612705,
0.0244629104,
-0.012268655,
0.0123042027,
-0.007897771,
0.0043800743,
0.0107068727,
-0.003670092,
0.0544320233,
-0.0054195062,
-0.0189845506,
-0.0233096816,
-0.0035084041,
-0.0058469586,
-0.0167052858,
0.0286860093,
0.0392183624,
0.040750891,
0.0138016166,
0.0000021918,
-0.0407695808,
-0.0192279089,
-0.0033433777,
-0.0210791733,
-0.0114307441,
0.0086707491,
0.0366725661,
0.0117731784,
0.0450066254,
-0.0675829276,
0.0232548341,
0.0262925867,
0.0310848001,
0.0869142637,
0.0869697779,
-0.0064871926,
-0.01286251,
0.0303333998,
-0.0027410362,
0.0444726646,
-0.0263571367,
0.0003969759,
0.025045272,
0.0423245691,
0.020147685,
0.0126838684,
0.0481470227,
-0.0056955828,
-0.0255924314,
0.024293296,
0.0316438228,
-0.0294159874,
-0.0410550237,
-0.0225585699,
0.0735226348,
0.0319639184,
-0.0002466267,
0.0161420237,
0.0299102627,
0.0249594897,
-0.0001242217,
-0.0648907945,
0.0356086865,
-0.0083914325,
-0.0107770646,
-0.0062726606,
-0.0007999134,
-0.0305823684,
0.0002271971,
-0.0312782228,
0.0316232778,
0.0100884987,
-0.020817792,
-0.0457069874,
0.0151678072,
0.0118893515,
-0.0685901344,
0.0106198983,
0.0439488776,
-0.0112942113,
0.0322036073,
-0.0239617489,
0.0113731874,
0.0041254484,
-0.0315142199,
-0.0114602223,
0.0396617278,
0.0321762115,
0.012017834,
-0.0145056276,
0.054411646,
0.0206616689,
0.0021873349,
-0.0475290939,
0.0108949281,
-0.0709709972,
-0.0200651567,
-0.0348119289,
0.0707331076,
-0.0659574568,
-0.0286220461,
-0.0191439986,
0.0317575783,
0.050392054,
-0.0226220731,
-0.0035226569,
0.022140488,
-0.0447690561,
0.0193247832,
-0.0187202059,
0.0222154539,
-0.0296438392,
-0.0015319616,
0.0432648435,
-0.0635897815,
0.0049977768,
0.0145745547,
0.017774364,
-0.0033420916,
0.0005689423,
0.0440414697,
-0.0416612029,
-0.0519078188,
-0.0126777021,
-0.0526746474,
-0.0412410647,
-0.0732242614,
-0.0119169466,
-0.0485589989,
0.0468478426,
0.0159884114,
-0.0268387496,
-0.0224972814,
0.0305935107,
0.0206406321,
-0.0436629243,
0.0158226639,
0.0053178328,
0.0301298611,
0.0408449993,
0.0164262094,
0.0261537246,
0.0349907465,
0.0640376359,
0.0412545875,
0.0534061044,
-0.007516006,
0.0115416339,
0.0188176166,
-0.0039879428,
0.0094549097,
0.0315583497,
0.0017928551,
-0.0136273466,
0.0085716685,
-0.0132999821,
0.0589228086,
-0.024719812,
0.0392552949,
0.0929518342,
0.0800102651,
0.0010009333,
0.0246369336,
0.0142180715,
0.0625174642,
-0.0011083335,
-0.003212489,
0.0021458005,
0.0169877373,
-0.0115088131,
0.0203109086,
0.0594464988,
0.0364649184,
-0.0225447025,
-0.0600452907,
-0.0058042626,
0.0156106651,
0.0156556815,
0.0218797475,
0.0119283171,
-0.0196600184,
-0.054853227,
0.0378378257,
-0.0054271119,
-0.0929734632,
0.0016830985,
-0.0596182086,
0.0250718873,
0.0803193972,
0.0558712147,
0.026090214,
-0.052210521,
-0.0175063945,
-0.0073614307,
0.0651733875,
0.0185660385,
-0.0115484474,
-0.0151647981,
-0.0559929498,
-0.025496101,
0.0170461703,
-0.0154402452,
0.0225360245,
0.0063598542,
0.0098412838,
0.013707472,
-0.019513553,
-0.0162007231,
0.0202532448,
-0.0448999628,
-0.0278953258,
-0.0009181917,
-0.0223361719,
0.0395512357,
0.0553215481,
-0.0190735981,
0.0256787091,
0.0171703249,
-0.0198623613,
-0.0380911455,
0.0273454841,
-0.0304821748,
-0.0457976907,
0.033625681,
-0.0070982915,
0.0214747172,
0.0145941302,
-0.0013004617,
-0.0648863763,
0.0069017168,
-0.0664570034,
0.02299086,
-0.0342674665,
0.0243016537,
0.0156127429,
-0.0029863887,
-0.0365598276,
0.0499412231,
0.0092409607,
-0.0116779311,
0.0104747238,
-0.0105467308,
0.0057366807,
-0.0547417775,
-0.0007694368,
0.028961312,
-0.0113041019,
0.0262757223,
0.0582501888,
0.0358403251,
-0.0424894616,
-0.0416182652,
-0.1182366461,
0.0189518929,
-0.0032622393,
0.0003792183,
0.0117078377,
0.0081309192,
-0.0080823433,
0.006533741,
-0.0792009234,
-0.0073910444,
0.0499899797,
0.0176997688,
0.0095625417,
0.0205519889,
-0.0251296945,
-0.0473092906,
0.0060866382,
-0.0084323892,
0.038105581,
0.0290723722,
-0.026316911,
-0.0456716083,
0.0485346094,
-0.0579254776,
0.0090464223,
0.0089346664,
-0.040291965,
0.0265878905,
-0.033224307,
0.0254637599,
0.0318898335,
0.0650807992,
0.0410261005,
0.0034638536,
-0.0400272347,
-0.0823426396,
0.0225388687,
-0.0349736735,
-0.0035777849,
-0.0015658555,
-0.0775602013,
0.0358482525,
0.0536120199,
0.0416146927,
0.0169830453,
-0.073485516,
0.0176425725,
0.0130496677,
-0.0469471775,
-0.0277405065,
-0.0072440063,
-0.0170567967,
0.040514268,
-0.0216264911,
-0.0074184812,
0.0553877652,
-0.0455217138,
-0.0026108332,
-0.0914868563,
-0.0083472375,
-0.0226627123,
0.0445011184,
-0.0047181575,
0.0301846061,
0.0004591551,
-0.0171318669,
-0.0565397702,
-0.0280152913,
0.0159872156,
-0.0479655042,
0.0264058914,
-0.056426663,
0.0094889291,
0.012480218,
-0.0323676206,
-0.0560617,
-0.039769996,
0.0028456585,
0.0062916512,
0.044807367,
-0.009595898,
-0.0496798642,
0.0425406098,
0.0392999798,
0.0151019972,
-0.0289949849,
-0.0095170941,
-0.0038442807,
0.0518132411,
0.0709236562,
0.0080277128,
-0.0055201668,
-0.0275876932,
0.0751200542,
0.0583607964,
0.0399325229,
0.0050726715,
0.0147771174,
-0.0184808206,
0.0357184671,
-0.0353586525,
-0.021386819,
0.0303112995,
0.0497739688,
-0.0324386954,
-0.0460624434,
0.1208905578,
0.03125301,
-0.0217071418,
-0.0184674058,
-0.0193854272,
0.0276798364,
-0.0116313882,
0.0414205082,
-0.0570220314,
-0.0145831807,
0.0093731191,
0.0336042047,
-0.03195066,
-0.0301871505,
-0.0161806904,
-0.1371415704,
0.0689663142,
0.0130309658,
-0.0514248647,
-0.0263201073,
-0.0246700626,
-0.0236320421,
0.0424603745,
0.0157977361,
0.0363427512,
-0.0167374276,
0.0207394976,
0.0191202015,
-0.022562027,
0.0005639488,
0.0024624756,
-0.0058748866,
0.0403317101,
0.0867646113,
0.0431991853,
0.0277538262,
-0.0088821473,
0.0112308674,
-0.0380791053,
0.0079468349,
-0.0069750231,
0.0659462065,
-0.0379271619,
0.0188923832,
-0.0487933531,
0.0373414867,
-0.0029911646,
-0.0022516369,
0.0320845135,
0.0178209711,
-0.035216596,
-0.0253932904,
-0.0289385226,
0.0462774634,
0.0107898843,
0.0800306052,
0.0329645611,
-0.055004701,
-0.0450914726,
-0.0328879617,
0.0384023562,
-0.0555202141,
-0.0095774271,
0.0066746473,
-0.0347135365,
-0.0009696127,
-0.1115106493,
-0.0795808658,
0.0144453039,
0.0207601879,
0.003572217,
0.0149586853,
-0.0051750494,
0.0357800685,
-0.0001092207,
0.0061663068,
-0.0104476474,
-0.0201310739,
-0.0735637248,
-0.0172872543,
0.0234550443,
-0.0576958954,
-0.0149896629,
0.0056380159,
-0.0443314798,
-0.0680140927,
-0.0139513621,
0.0496737398,
0.0335670412,
0.0360770449,
0.0242323782,
-0.004403268,
0.0372112133,
0.0274571143,
-0.0152821485,
0.0122011434,
-0.0055667334,
0.0430715606,
-0.0165452361,
0.0198098887,
-0.063347511,
0.0279369969,
-0.0382888056,
0.0833575577,
-0.0341253467,
-0.0740382373,
0.0216228943,
0.0482179597,
-0.0137103591,
0.0122475559,
-0.0248831641,
-0.0047060722,
0.0125067495,
-0.0362742618,
-0.0053510759,
-0.0651694313,
0.0052823182,
-0.0016567491,
0.0139189642,
0.0301566403,
0.018415235,
-0.0401083492,
0.0330380723,
-0.0137387803,
-0.003990917,
-0.0313648954,
-0.0037871364,
0.0112546301,
-0.0176044572,
-0.0596714616,
0.0209879614,
-0.0110944873,
0.0382008702,
0.0053089284,
0.0773495734,
0.0036009939,
-0.0426724292,
0.0110955304,
0.0511232018,
-0.0803672299,
-0.0410825685,
-0.0408793315,
0.0557980798,
0.012160724,
0.0359330587,
0.0650051236,
-0.0365873612,
0.0175941307,
-0.0111274896,
0.0266052391,
0.032851208,
-0.0286202896,
0.0103589687,
0.0076867547,
-0.0184225868,
-0.0429587737,
0.0771868974,
-0.007261348,
0.0214359853,
0.004163173,
-0.0366934352,
-0.0504237004,
-0.0256266519,
0.0037571292,
0.0083097313,
0.0067797322,
-0.0055740569,
-0.0336209647,
-0.0354831964,
0.0233440474,
0.0033144499,
-0.0048504393,
-0.0337609425,
0.048334673,
0.0648021251,
0.0055444702,
-0.025096843,
-0.0680497736,
0.0230045039,
-0.0619556084,
-0.0244476181,
-0.0195311476,
-6.803537959e-33,
-0.0459062867,
-0.0128070107,
0.0179450344,
0.0210228898,
-0.0415737182,
-0.015467572,
-0.0680117533,
0.0102213845,
0.0002856946,
-0.0194417331,
-0.0217737649,
0.0009121661,
0.0096189305,
0.0378709435,
-0.011821798,
-0.0063042417,
0.0451769866,
-0.0091925254,
-0.0466946997,
0.0394142792,
0.0440303534,
0.0349191017,
0.0078201368,
-0.0426090099,
0.0190884471,
-0.0446811728,
0.0132169006,
0.0160594583,
0.0239329115,
0.0348703116,
-0.019450495,
0.0385135524,
0.0321029238,
-0.0336969271,
-0.0065636765,
0.043040432,
-0.0401906893,
-0.0232930202,
0.0292739794,
-0.0152856689,
-0.0003868379,
-0.0664252788,
0.016428452,
-0.0327166729,
-0.0196948294,
-0.0027558375,
0.0390702821,
-0.0162791777,
-0.0227611847,
-0.0301178955,
-0.076170139,
0.0067989766,
0.0005680161,
-0.0450276583,
-0.0093042869,
0.0983140394,
0.0090953661,
-0.0158973057,
-0.0223066788,
0.0521904826,
0.0294368062,
0.0169831403,
0.0526491329,
0.0158165973,
0.0012184164,
0.060079027,
0.0042843139,
0.011846032,
-0.0349252559,
-0.0348130688,
-0.0065243579,
0.0375627317,
0.0271975528,
0.0524843149,
-0.0272395778,
0.0079613375,
-0.0451677479,
0.076489374,
0.0554245301,
0.0165457111,
0.0410451367,
-0.0143859591,
-0.0706305355,
-0.0249167886,
-0.0241758749,
0.0086831618,
-0.0237923618,
-0.0529426001,
0.0645463467,
-0.0035429848,
-0.029230224,
-0.0600938648,
0.0678270236,
-0.0307067838,
0.0022410268,
0.024756005,
-0.0216414295,
0.0227305908,
-0.0316449888,
0.0172085352,
-0.0410054661,
-0.0142625337,
0.0454682484,
0.0103849219,
-0.0099115809,
0.0198480729,
-0.0456921086,
-0.0025790257,
-0.0274553448,
-0.0037996508,
-0.0216322541,
0.0578519441,
-0.0172560234,
-0.0030192565,
-0.0019627486,
0.0042403853,
-0.0142297894,
0.0458568186,
-0.0138933156,
0.0010415897,
-0.0244188514,
-0.0414914787,
0.0157459732,
-0.0025702349,
-0.0379934162,
0.0390326008,
-0.0250578001,
0.0307856835,
0.0023207697,
-0.042327445,
-0.0108887106,
-0.0072336355,
2.95e-7,
0.0080762431,
0.0308503564,
0.031361293,
0.0119167846,
0.0016204861,
0.0384370983,
0.0157833304,
0.0115808472,
0.0378493816,
0.0195156485,
0.0149916876,
0.0175175089,
0.0601140372,
0.0249647945,
-0.0829764083,
-0.0703186542,
-0.0567623042,
-0.025219528,
-0.0427426808,
-0.0063021146,
0.0859471858,
0.0540212207,
-0.0293620508,
-0.0034906019,
-0.0315372087,
-0.0674533173,
0.0540593006,
-0.0273653548,
-0.0367429927,
0.0458574928,
0.0281553958,
-0.0081038103,
0.0104805222,
0.021236144,
-0.0076008867,
0.0078351106,
0.017075561,
0.0499386378,
-0.0087037301,
-0.0418617576,
0.0045670383,
0.0100392206,
0.0208720285,
-0.0586624667,
0.0472769439,
-0.0720272064,
-0.0214779954,
0.0044245943,
-0.0572360046,
-0.0338233449,
-0.0563334972,
-0.0152725307,
-0.0232586656,
0.0296882559,
-0.0022647639,
-0.008739193,
0.036137931,
-0.0709600374,
-0.008031385,
0.0105800489,
-0.0469041318,
-0.0759303197,
-0.0357544981,
-0.0033293606,
0.0071784509,
-0.0446647443,
-0.0043953466,
2.839940628e-34,
0.0178561565,
0.0075647142,
0.0046933624,
0.0640677065,
0.042411454,
0.0012546346,
0.0193710085,
-0.0032804173,
0.0409671217,
-0.0992744714,
-0.0283637084
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09510v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09510v3 | Tailoring with Targeted Precision: Edit-Based Agents for Open-Domain Procedure Customization | 2023-11-16T02:25:36 | 2024-05-31T01:32:23 | Yash Kumar Lal, Li Zhang, Faeze Brahman, Bodhisattwa Prasad Majumder, Peter Clark, Niket Tandon | cs.CL | cs.CL | How-to procedures, such as how to plant a garden, are now used by millions of
users, but sometimes need customizing to meet a user's specific needs, e.g.,
planting a garden without pesticides. Our goal is to measure and improve an
LLM's ability to perform such customization. Our approach is to test several
simple multi-LLM-agent architectures for customization, as well as an
end-to-end LLM, using a new evaluation set, called CustomPlans, of over 200
WikiHow procedures each with a customization need. We find that a simple
architecture with two LLM agents used sequentially performs best, one that
edits a generic how-to procedure and one that verifies its executability,
significantly outperforming (10.5% absolute) an end-to-end prompted LLM. This
suggests that LLMs can be configured reasonably effectively for procedure
customization. This also suggests that multi-agent editing architectures may be
worth exploring further for other customization applications (e.g. coding,
creative writing) in the future. | [
0.0719609037,
0.0027100421,
-0.0238878857,
-0.0107425973,
-0.0435688868,
-0.0114845624,
-0.0009757404,
0.0248263013,
-0.0038797366,
-0.003713425,
-0.046997752,
0.0317975841,
-0.0021729651,
0.0352542475,
-0.0163499154,
-0.0713248104,
0.0314170308,
-0.008804895,
-0.0236974135,
0.0126364566,
-0.0222358499,
-0.0380293876,
-0.0241174418,
0.0392529033,
0.030777188,
-0.0506558567,
-0.0349280909,
0.0209652279,
-0.0127963834,
-0.0041326303,
-0.0241411366,
0.0291676316,
-0.0214356259,
-0.000821565,
0.0000021846,
-0.060360685,
-0.0321607888,
-0.0042493921,
-0.0581895746,
0.0376270637,
0.0307726059,
0.0312239435,
-0.0133215832,
-0.0111693563,
-0.0129930144,
0.0782576576,
0.0207266733,
0.0450017899,
0.0526897088,
0.0650748983,
0.0236566719,
-0.0001659102,
0.0239955354,
0.0157572795,
0.0515990593,
-0.0167957805,
-0.0122395195,
-0.0529641919,
0.068221584,
0.0148830879,
-0.0058842218,
0.0127992006,
0.005988874,
-0.0074648638,
-0.008226729,
0.001544658,
-0.0262529589,
-0.0189953689,
-0.0193345584,
0.0341641605,
0.0615029484,
0.0566343665,
0.0209589414,
-0.0058371234,
0.0350001492,
0.0199312996,
-0.0205758028,
0.015548043,
-0.0033003406,
-0.0564829037,
-0.0040078838,
-0.0392972641,
0.0061954376,
-0.0093582738,
-0.0075416989,
0.0973166823,
0.013237034,
-0.0118620358,
-0.022026876,
-0.0227472298,
0.0575653203,
-0.0674546435,
-0.0186080933,
0.0491032638,
-0.0642716363,
-0.0057219365,
-0.0258529466,
0.0336991809,
0.031646397,
-0.0028781765,
0.0719551072,
0.0293235574,
-0.0001976549,
0.0027276066,
-0.0114262532,
0.0504095517,
-0.0298081841,
0.0713669211,
0.005136075,
0.0196239017,
-0.0713476762,
0.0338382162,
0.0060649603,
0.0409875587,
-0.0414273031,
0.013175644,
-0.0353110731,
0.0715019703,
-0.0074004531,
0.0765495077,
0.0184915625,
-0.0097653735,
-0.0285610966,
-0.0359623246,
-0.0670178086,
-0.0350710452,
-0.0339163877,
-0.0007200834,
0.0081197126,
-0.0008447342,
0.0117641836,
0.0049668956,
0.0121738501,
0.0226625893,
-0.0067542507,
0.0906629637,
0.0076989494,
0.0073092617,
-0.0377110764,
-0.0698742047,
0.0351626724,
-0.0111109307,
-0.0440318286,
-0.0289840493,
0.0031524613,
-0.001941409,
-0.0375419706,
-0.0618635081,
-0.0055361078,
-0.0098595805,
-0.0177635066,
0.0570450611,
0.0062506329,
0.0201575905,
0.0411987528,
0.0307407938,
-0.0894472525,
0.0060786838,
0.0199652668,
0.056734249,
0.0463043936,
0.0377325639,
0.0407060198,
0.006541328,
-0.0684166774,
0.0283337608,
0.0833976492,
0.0334422924,
0.0329130962,
0.0305619445,
-0.0413904116,
-0.0153455166,
-0.008937235,
0.0205681399,
0.0599002056,
0.0428543054,
0.0693619996,
-0.0415324457,
0.0365825556,
0.0060441494,
0.0058384761,
0.0008486743,
-0.0491762422,
0.0571231917,
-0.0027427566,
0.0185505953,
-0.0472643785,
-0.0281156991,
-0.033005666,
-0.0557159521,
-0.0095108431,
0.0053679533,
-0.0101691009,
-0.0546019375,
0.0122236852,
0.011954085,
-0.0336592458,
0.0135993846,
-0.005458538,
-0.0161047895,
-0.027146263,
-0.0863943323,
-0.0129079297,
0.1274388731,
0.0589850023,
-0.0465614796,
-0.055527281,
0.0072885584,
0.0069996244,
0.0461990535,
0.0468487591,
-0.0300474558,
-0.0258590225,
-0.0089962063,
-0.0481871441,
-0.0574077442,
0.009255778,
0.0240200441,
-0.0107523128,
0.0185463931,
-0.0144935697,
-0.0221760925,
0.0013259491,
0.0277754944,
-0.010347398,
-0.0643124357,
0.0079620583,
0.0317696705,
0.0043741534,
0.0219985656,
-0.0006901242,
0.0237233341,
0.008475489,
0.0115266619,
-0.0200282615,
-0.0182852708,
0.0437269323,
0.0500212349,
0.0050542876,
-0.0244758464,
-0.0041711321,
-0.026039429,
-0.0213081595,
-0.0415360071,
0.0023396187,
-0.0207941923,
0.0244074389,
-0.0007431856,
0.065544717,
-0.0007397509,
-0.0517598428,
-0.0067604864,
0.0148993097,
-0.0095427008,
-0.0636860207,
0.044890292,
0.0151420971,
-0.018091308,
-0.0158077814,
0.0011653777,
-0.0193118062,
0.0149889383,
0.0172753781,
-0.0260179359,
0.0254954379,
-0.0367937051,
-0.0492890105,
-0.0746264458,
0.0102041531,
-0.0112162568,
0.0196178891,
-0.0000756895,
0.020747222,
-0.0092402557,
-0.0383784398,
-0.0216243453,
0.0441902541,
-0.0233022049,
0.0265299883,
0.0394499004,
0.0452316776,
-0.0609542578,
-0.0281472206,
0.0396766141,
-0.0206235051,
-0.0251443069,
0.0038306881,
0.0143710142,
-0.087819621,
-0.0022485121,
-0.0183693822,
-0.0289514512,
0.0364462733,
-0.0109764049,
0.0358962379,
-0.0061655184,
0.0051224302,
0.0568464622,
-0.0466441922,
0.0155661693,
0.0486834943,
-0.0178567711,
-0.0158076454,
-0.0072192973,
0.0124731893,
-0.0120820543,
0.0124224005,
-0.002227043,
0.0344465375,
0.0357647799,
-0.0236295909,
0.0303568039,
-0.0060999715,
0.0302804168,
0.0343879387,
-0.0055662324,
0.0110582039,
-0.0121982992,
-0.0308847036,
0.0807397366,
-0.0097521385,
-0.0536185652,
0.0422457829,
-0.005575493,
0.019926969,
-0.0321360417,
-0.049087178,
-0.0288470089,
0.0439072959,
-0.0074140374,
-0.0130026815,
-0.0085327458,
-0.0126291169,
-0.0664124265,
0.0218200143,
0.0359654985,
-0.0144988252,
0.0678608045,
-0.0714882538,
-0.0159839652,
-0.0283723529,
-0.0295304935,
-0.041441936,
-0.0118532488,
-0.0043674572,
-0.0112373158,
0.0128744822,
-0.0244455766,
-0.0484596938,
-0.0147921843,
0.0296551622,
0.0881649703,
0.0158372018,
-0.027397532,
-0.0109103201,
-0.059040226,
-0.0068877419,
-0.0097137783,
-0.0457208529,
-0.0173460599,
0.0305246804,
0.0362070575,
0.0324739143,
-0.0635550171,
0.0175328664,
-0.0103514427,
-0.0258108005,
-0.1074926928,
-0.0153296217,
0.0475832373,
0.0368620977,
-0.0506034158,
0.008519195,
0.0609187223,
0.068448469,
-0.0329663642,
0.0122032491,
-0.0634246096,
-0.0385870226,
0.0342793576,
0.057512857,
-0.0661136061,
-0.0020962874,
0.0013389569,
0.0467439927,
-0.0357804932,
-0.0443989672,
-0.0019995561,
-0.0348573029,
0.0411398634,
-0.0151686864,
-0.0064586983,
0.0264212396,
0.0002780916,
0.0199070964,
0.0187275372,
-0.0238193534,
0.0377149247,
-0.0064381501,
-0.0258474518,
-0.0373981446,
-0.0355773009,
-0.026918523,
0.0162407421,
-0.00458499,
0.034325324,
0.0848824829,
-0.0228550564,
0.0374940038,
-0.0617585704,
0.0248446446,
0.0773500353,
0.052991733,
-0.0327698141,
0.0716252699,
0.0144994743,
0.0162483249,
-0.0067104008,
-0.0041489634,
-0.0067143417,
-0.0044530611,
0.0603428818,
0.0702423304,
-0.0547477864,
0.0055475505,
-0.0136471586,
-0.0452044383,
-0.0078055365,
0.0338476114,
0.0301785022,
-0.0574025996,
-0.0406010561,
-0.0702458695,
-0.048097074,
-0.045592919,
-0.0268824864,
-0.0001963366,
-0.0866790861,
0.0246833153,
-0.0941936001,
-0.0573095009,
0.0717848167,
0.0266148988,
0.042677559,
-0.026299011,
0.0172003713,
0.021355357,
-0.0356040671,
-0.0580300502,
-0.014888227,
-0.0041569746,
-0.0577731952,
-0.0532542095,
0.0605821908,
-0.0058338591,
0.0210758094,
-0.0308847986,
0.0293898601,
-0.0297158081,
-0.0117189856,
0.0760336518,
0.0312249009,
-0.0107047027,
0.0062715639,
-0.0154455295,
0.0130683249,
-0.0169062782,
-0.0085487235,
0.0003826141,
0.0006967706,
0.034896858,
-0.0199143067,
0.0079850582,
-0.0796142295,
-0.0203009974,
0.019824801,
0.025749879,
-0.0307188742,
-0.0197200533,
-0.0135038942,
0.042269133,
-0.0304762162,
0.0204145834,
0.0132954307,
-0.0024802119,
0.0647851229,
-0.0134724267,
-0.0078964522,
0.014962323,
-0.0115068471,
-0.038748432,
-0.0324546956,
0.034010496,
0.0143462783,
-0.0564902984,
0.0027826265,
-0.025189383,
0.0300965104,
-0.013293664,
0.0066243117,
0.0050302823,
0.0146406852,
-0.0401647501,
0.0407156758,
0.0216167681,
0.0543153584,
0.0330158584,
0.0369428806,
-0.03553956,
0.0383129343,
-0.0472424887,
0.0344551764,
-0.0574527569,
-0.0675387308,
0.0400516838,
0.0617201403,
-0.0176094081,
0.04181391,
-0.0068221651,
-0.0194629356,
-0.0060957232,
-0.0293952692,
0.0034403582,
0.033530388,
0.0233986471,
-0.0412419327,
0.0121740457,
0.0048067761,
-0.0707373023,
0.0384107679,
-0.0812086985,
0.0497081168,
-0.0662247986,
-0.0522665679,
-0.0799686611,
-0.0221371669,
-0.020422779,
0.012455184,
-0.0203747544,
-0.0614675619,
-0.0737798735,
-0.0047949217,
0.0256065186,
0.0139578227,
0.0001706275,
-0.0225792807,
0.0020022655,
0.0125736305,
0.0350325704,
-0.0406049341,
-0.0200099535,
-0.0248890501,
-0.0103878751,
-0.0180965904,
0.0090513239,
-5.61980927e-33,
-0.0141255585,
-0.0028232581,
0.0350940973,
0.0654707104,
0.0604670122,
-0.0438685343,
-0.0259556435,
0.0459420905,
0.0275024846,
-0.0138173895,
-0.0340097621,
-0.0265046414,
0.0273767598,
-0.0591310486,
0.0504086055,
0.0328040309,
0.0553776994,
-0.0063565648,
-0.0584622882,
-0.0091354158,
0.0039519137,
-0.0022025553,
0.0149819376,
-0.0396776311,
0.0342894159,
0.0194643885,
0.0230049565,
-0.0172971748,
-0.0410145596,
0.0478047207,
0.0382702127,
-0.0066664098,
0.0154714622,
-0.0264715608,
-0.0197591558,
-0.0242311843,
-0.015365432,
-0.069737643,
0.0080826757,
0.0051601534,
-0.0064480673,
-0.0810367242,
0.0139461886,
0.0107170092,
-0.0591042377,
0.0140107749,
0.0191855691,
-0.0073342365,
0.0272691566,
0.0515416898,
-0.0502832159,
0.0093766386,
0.0488084517,
0.0022826833,
-0.0379482582,
-0.0521564856,
-0.0001654112,
-0.0457475409,
-0.0691722333,
0.0288988799,
0.0621768571,
-0.0114847794,
0.0341349952,
-0.026996579,
-0.0402650051,
0.0163147077,
0.0144309765,
0.0760438964,
0.0009249857,
0.0052829236,
-0.037502218,
0.0808885321,
0.0309578646,
0.043911878,
-0.0275463723,
0.0199700687,
0.0288765058,
0.0924061462,
-0.0111239552,
0.032304123,
0.0295073241,
0.0128672495,
-0.011312373,
0.0097982353,
-0.0104889916,
0.0625840947,
-0.0474161804,
-0.0479633696,
0.0520503856,
-0.0024858094,
0.0010994284,
-0.0317849517,
-0.0097890357,
0.0085540256,
0.0333290622,
-0.0390123986,
-0.0378957689,
0.0469941013,
-0.0081970552,
-0.0503452495,
-0.007746995,
-0.0182349849,
-0.0109123876,
0.0070449258,
0.0388724282,
0.0229892526,
-0.0100094955,
0.0081184031,
-0.0725916624,
0.0268643405,
0.001025508,
-0.0061577167,
0.0191679057,
-0.0119458642,
-0.0014844867,
-0.0201807451,
0.0019826656,
-0.0032844173,
-0.0191436019,
-0.0511818752,
-0.0546868369,
-0.0218956601,
0.0156597681,
-0.0112276683,
-0.0278924499,
0.0243114047,
-0.0128527507,
0.0578598902,
-0.0140562039,
0.0109484633,
-0.0072427564,
-0.0135230254,
2.921e-7,
0.0285700504,
0.0377902947,
-0.0074590547,
0.0692009106,
0.031932123,
0.0273990836,
-0.0154977338,
-0.0044745933,
-0.0400433205,
-0.0592686795,
0.0402939506,
0.0080865454,
0.0155264121,
0.0343523622,
-0.0121728843,
-0.0433868207,
0.05297805,
0.0613102578,
-0.0463374071,
-0.005148869,
0.0410080366,
-0.0164101012,
0.017995989,
0.005330795,
0.0012196255,
-0.0117624579,
0.0255920943,
-0.0375656709,
0.0300460309,
0.0353463404,
-0.0105129126,
0.0049514109,
0.0116302194,
0.0407551415,
-0.0091185244,
-0.0167334136,
-0.0411643051,
0.1041889489,
-0.0448641405,
-0.0075580091,
0.0486293286,
-0.0398640074,
0.0263725314,
-0.0001991546,
0.0098682521,
0.0012758507,
-0.0162201524,
0.0675724745,
0.0144606419,
-0.0140365921,
0.0304099359,
-0.042410221,
0.0210114941,
-0.0067429193,
-0.0138796754,
0.0142605184,
-0.007880047,
-0.0130580794,
0.0441975333,
-0.0012695942,
-0.0219764877,
-0.0728523955,
-0.048622936,
0.0024811481,
-0.0131135555,
-0.0439098924,
-0.0193100721,
2.271988594e-34,
-0.0066465652,
0.0108676637,
0.0171517339,
0.0364340544,
0.0216272697,
0.0490691476,
-0.0042740339,
-0.0015784797,
0.0685880706,
-0.0541080497,
-0.0403795429
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09505v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09505v1 | SegMix: A Simple Structure-Aware Data Augmentation Method | 2023-11-16T02:05:15 | 2023-11-16T02:05:15 | Yuxin Pei, Pushkar Bhuse, Zhengzhong Liu, Eric Xing | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Interpolation-based Data Augmentation (DA) methods (Mixup) linearly
interpolate the inputs and labels of two or more training examples. Mixup has
more recently been adapted to the field of Natural Language Processing (NLP),
mainly for sequence labeling tasks. However, such a simple adoption yields
mixed or unstable improvements over the baseline models. We argue that the
direct-adoption methods do not account for structures in NLP tasks. To this
end, we propose SegMix, a collection of interpolation-based DA algorithms that
can adapt to task-specific structures. SegMix poses fewer constraints on data
structures, is robust to various hyperparameter settings, applies to more task
settings, and adds little computational overhead. In the algorithm's core, we
apply interpolation methods on task-specific meaningful segments, in contrast
to applying them on sequences as in prior work. We find SegMix to be a flexible
framework that combines rule-based DA methods with interpolation-based methods,
creating interesting mixtures of DA techniques. We show that SegMix
consistently improves performance over strong baseline models in Named Entity
Recognition (NER) and Relation Extraction (RE) tasks, especially under
data-scarce settings. Furthermore, this method is easy to implement and adds
negligible training overhead. | [
0.0512114204,
0.0614200868,
0.0358160734,
0.0285628848,
0.0023882438,
0.0506255254,
-0.0099551678,
0.0017409762,
0.0149699282,
-0.0696934015,
-0.0296117403,
0.0054787798,
-0.0127754649,
0.0108552501,
0.0309995431,
-0.0559396371,
0.0252065193,
-0.0057760924,
0.067651771,
0.0520910583,
0.0082721058,
0.006267265,
-0.0178721026,
-0.0129963486,
-0.0282671768,
0.0340823196,
-0.0117234029,
0.0072660754,
0.0390909314,
-0.0467467234,
0.0472599752,
0.040243648,
0.0068143159,
0.0065461304,
0.0000021259,
-0.0085663917,
-0.0117937205,
0.0105193993,
-0.0549581423,
-0.0105293253,
0.0406110883,
-0.0722126812,
0.0142075531,
0.0029611664,
-0.0364963189,
-0.0759743974,
0.0276000369,
0.0855425149,
0.0488627069,
0.1005695462,
-0.0279839691,
-0.0417101532,
0.070247367,
-0.0419344679,
0.0137599017,
-0.0038781997,
0.0359494127,
0.0165317208,
0.0121166361,
0.0526433028,
-0.0016231375,
0.0309438501,
-0.012939007,
0.0003156184,
0.0583555102,
0.0409190841,
0.0029453593,
-0.007848125,
-0.0198056139,
0.1003587916,
-0.03458561,
0.0302976333,
0.0251973141,
-0.0137683032,
-0.0173510071,
-0.0380104966,
-0.0296605043,
-0.0258365255,
-0.009738747,
0.0259256307,
0.0576701537,
0.011277223,
0.0461694151,
0.0192716997,
-0.0151801072,
0.031639073,
-0.0107006505,
-0.0474874936,
0.0113392109,
0.0288662519,
-0.0123872906,
-0.0616121404,
0.0104744565,
0.0193290971,
-0.0058552576,
0.0398230366,
-0.0706401765,
-0.0486250184,
-0.0103904167,
-0.0204537921,
0.0051658265,
0.0339157432,
0.026439324,
0.0482392199,
-0.0543118641,
-0.0037655402,
-0.0037127298,
0.015271103,
-0.0228368267,
0.0072482182,
-0.0348397382,
0.0176187307,
-0.0146753034,
0.0446625985,
-0.0729520172,
-0.0263963491,
-0.0407485142,
0.0166163351,
-0.0090414826,
0.0247204639,
-0.0094587645,
-0.0015157239,
-0.023275936,
0.0241442453,
-0.0044788131,
0.0184581112,
-0.0344269834,
0.037977919,
0.009025475,
-0.0496129021,
-0.0185949486,
-0.0353215635,
0.0599981695,
-0.0413750671,
0.0373111814,
0.0812119693,
-0.0032577554,
-0.1128818467,
-0.0355282612,
-0.0214724112,
0.0201342441,
-0.0358507,
0.0137773165,
-0.0350958668,
0.0642403439,
-0.0141801899,
-0.0089416634,
-0.0345332175,
0.0534769148,
0.0022782017,
-0.0935125723,
0.0809394941,
-0.0655978546,
-0.0260064285,
-0.0213620346,
0.0010213433,
0.0286834557,
0.080085963,
0.0523213707,
-0.0270526148,
0.0313744843,
0.0146138854,
0.0138454866,
0.0095516043,
0.0189060736,
0.008414709,
-0.0002320689,
-0.0051383204,
0.0047276476,
0.0038041987,
0.0428334847,
0.0263724439,
-0.0241545737,
-0.0174010918,
0.007909352,
0.0033969446,
-0.0154210972,
-0.0325200334,
0.0055885497,
-0.0059048627,
0.0200659484,
-0.0054284101,
-0.0676144138,
0.009271808,
0.0100082671,
0.0496534072,
0.0008586647,
0.0251624938,
0.0037241292,
-0.0157410409,
-0.0109583102,
-0.0171080735,
0.0557081848,
0.0018427147,
0.0432785936,
0.044430837,
-0.033333946,
0.0187139474,
0.0329074673,
-0.0179095212,
-0.0025324596,
0.0281981304,
-0.0411371924,
0.0697681755,
0.0406543463,
-0.0420036837,
-0.0585819148,
-0.0544610023,
0.0173524544,
0.0141288713,
0.0044323751,
-0.0086395089,
0.0538166277,
-0.0423946232,
-0.0490542762,
-0.0016241792,
0.0252756942,
-0.0031753839,
0.0437120125,
-0.0068704123,
0.0346306749,
-0.0163735189,
-0.0375618823,
0.0419019386,
-0.0486911833,
-0.050340239,
0.0477415323,
0.0007007875,
0.001775151,
0.0644893125,
0.0004904257,
-0.0118031669,
0.0479742363,
-0.0424714796,
0.0137895113,
-0.0028384712,
-0.0466361977,
-0.0778136551,
0.0375044756,
0.006651361,
-0.0251032356,
-0.0417706594,
-0.0644290298,
-0.0567925945,
-0.030069707,
-0.023338303,
0.0264057573,
-0.0028360919,
0.0200460665,
0.0460460782,
0.0174918566,
-0.0365686044,
0.0340140164,
-0.0097648604,
0.0072340099,
0.0283647608,
-0.0012392991,
-0.032113377,
-0.0040697413,
-0.0188636985,
0.0129016396,
-0.0045445892,
-0.0748871341,
-0.0109940814,
-0.0210857354,
-0.0765772238,
0.0051991572,
-0.0596215911,
-0.0173707306,
0.005596471,
0.0628495067,
0.0190243032,
0.0672048852,
-0.0112021416,
-0.0556910113,
-0.0215216409,
-0.044909656,
-0.0049487194,
0.0039462959,
0.0392447338,
0.0274224896,
-0.0263528526,
-0.0338012353,
-0.0142354118,
-0.0250914823,
0.0093545178,
0.0081544444,
-0.0416594259,
-0.0180051234,
-0.0114880456,
-0.0220502205,
0.0356162898,
-0.0199232921,
-0.0090953819,
-0.0593654923,
-0.0015431681,
0.0064653135,
0.0050847074,
-0.0173907038,
-0.0040514651,
-0.0009838521,
-0.0147373946,
-0.0195319746,
0.0259699803,
-0.0307323337,
0.0798793063,
-0.0304582845,
-0.0374688767,
-0.0032465758,
0.0891627446,
-0.0556977503,
0.0314846784,
0.0015646579,
-0.0011700377,
0.0002083042,
-0.007262913,
-0.0016436778,
-0.019695852,
-0.0060890843,
-0.0201535523,
-0.0536384061,
-0.02491978,
0.086414963,
-0.0450397544,
-0.0465996563,
-0.0574299134,
-0.021217186,
-0.0502704978,
0.0527862348,
0.0345161483,
-0.0062950626,
0.0152217038,
-0.0452851206,
0.0291334502,
0.0246313661,
-0.0001319258,
-0.0328316651,
0.0501050092,
-0.0408690386,
0.0297044218,
-0.0208061617,
-0.0254036076,
-0.0381566025,
-0.0165288337,
-0.0354363285,
-0.0145234633,
0.016582055,
-0.0299390238,
0.0042262739,
0.0178068932,
-0.0079206899,
0.0573256761,
0.0092839655,
-0.0003188895,
-0.0360534377,
0.0381749868,
0.0542895235,
0.0242514182,
-0.0188228823,
0.0223390944,
-0.0204880089,
0.009187567,
0.0244199634,
-0.0019258847,
-0.0153875053,
0.0348587185,
0.0212519299,
-0.0292000473,
-0.0006570764,
-0.0249983091,
0.0403882228,
-0.0561139248,
-0.0155401379,
0.1102587134,
0.0110533321,
-0.0286314581,
-0.0110580008,
0.0539471023,
0.0043601608,
0.0486105606,
0.0173116308,
-0.0809611529,
-0.0431327112,
0.0176353604,
0.0023340567,
-0.0276068132,
-0.0620811209,
-0.0112935314,
-0.0681181103,
-0.008656593,
-0.0042506498,
-0.0454662666,
-0.0019848526,
-0.0839987099,
0.0344315134,
-0.0172429513,
-0.0070348945,
-0.0429137051,
-0.0510826446,
0.0102534248,
0.0276875068,
0.0108856503,
-0.0815896019,
-0.063663438,
-0.0331729241,
0.0563080683,
0.0457139574,
0.0042577917,
-0.0143805211,
0.0050730337,
0.057565745,
0.0283672251,
-0.0202982444,
-0.0318910629,
0.0636469424,
-0.0507260412,
-0.0233599748,
0.0003110635,
0.0298489984,
-0.0530596823,
-0.0006179099,
-0.0007686412,
0.0463811383,
-0.012074844,
0.0457049645,
-0.0356542282,
-0.0601280332,
0.0238646008,
0.0537892804,
0.0138879661,
0.0018965871,
0.0132415667,
-0.0128664523,
0.0165665857,
-0.0318543091,
0.0568685234,
0.0008643857,
-0.0704266503,
0.0000423153,
-0.0524346754,
-0.0888218284,
0.0510080196,
0.0157707743,
0.0240666792,
0.0019503047,
0.0193728786,
-0.0171560012,
-0.0787115097,
-0.0065049343,
0.0117070656,
0.013532266,
-0.0061949333,
-0.0155149428,
-0.0178290959,
0.0025834618,
-0.0092734303,
-0.0337208323,
-0.0632510558,
-0.0438262448,
-0.0075653619,
0.0462062731,
0.0079464614,
0.0894688144,
-0.0145862177,
0.0202760827,
0.0255107637,
0.0729432926,
-0.0497265607,
-0.0015327699,
0.0327233262,
-0.043623019,
0.0044902451,
0.0092930133,
-0.023301499,
0.0217793696,
0.0171362851,
0.072681725,
-0.0173800848,
-0.016723549,
0.0004558393,
0.0122461366,
0.0585387871,
-0.0060310331,
0.0234730802,
-0.0285601132,
0.0489108264,
-0.0167240854,
0.000132976,
-0.0383397155,
0.0027259255,
0.0050810557,
0.0174556375,
-0.0018234049,
0.0396378487,
-0.0001698783,
0.0116905654,
-0.0235345773,
-0.0017753101,
-0.0160610117,
-0.0231901128,
0.0089457473,
0.0053880792,
-0.0005569212,
0.0572256483,
0.0403266288,
0.0094703864,
-0.0347811878,
0.0078836856,
0.0232009012,
-0.0289788526,
-0.0317130983,
0.011147772,
-0.0313699208,
0.076578252,
-0.0535876714,
0.0245828144,
0.0466412827,
-0.0502528399,
0.0516896397,
-0.0072225356,
-0.0062144403,
0.0102584353,
0.0087540308,
-0.0243409723,
-0.0151642039,
0.0069324197,
0.02198378,
-0.0233734977,
0.0017419201,
0.0606372394,
0.0023668748,
0.0539010353,
-0.0063013462,
-0.0136646051,
-0.0415335372,
-0.0095668817,
-0.0275614019,
0.0344678424,
-0.0193222612,
0.0189046077,
0.0034513201,
-0.0346963629,
-0.007404394,
-0.0571766868,
-0.0082861464,
0.0076588867,
0.0376767218,
-0.0054217554,
0.0142871896,
-0.0204929505,
-0.0411798656,
-0.0087799812,
-0.0125917746,
-0.0435790569,
0.0153906094,
-6.672181608e-33,
-0.0229542442,
-0.0328022279,
-0.0059681106,
-0.019902382,
-0.0322396718,
0.0467295088,
-0.0206836555,
-0.0011769527,
0.0109318234,
0.0102436822,
-0.006579794,
-0.0131250583,
0.0220274571,
0.0262406003,
0.0036753986,
-0.0194095969,
0.0648931414,
0.0372461863,
-0.0190293528,
-0.0160621274,
0.0101772277,
0.0760875121,
0.0911647975,
-0.0980699733,
0.0558216907,
0.0192043185,
0.0227758735,
-0.013153336,
0.0475500859,
0.046438396,
-0.0228755735,
0.0185949318,
0.0141616091,
-0.046546746,
0.0062942505,
0.0228098724,
-0.1902534664,
0.0036197666,
-0.0209031235,
0.0303020254,
-0.0565869883,
-0.0215828121,
0.0423502028,
0.0070031444,
0.0512402728,
0.0068686963,
0.020085346,
-0.0605931394,
0.0056348201,
-0.006297091,
-0.0428800136,
0.0267247017,
0.023265902,
0.0288130678,
0.0641247332,
0.0239013061,
0.029577028,
-0.0065732114,
-0.0631081611,
-0.0146651706,
0.0564444587,
0.0259455591,
0.0232740343,
0.0401170291,
-0.020277923,
0.0258055236,
-0.0005491961,
-0.0318227969,
0.0041617565,
0.0234327633,
-0.0105217677,
0.018584704,
-0.0293290485,
0.002281816,
0.0568356402,
0.0080841845,
-0.032183785,
0.0218266696,
0.0596384965,
0.0167612247,
-0.043607451,
-0.0017504892,
-0.0460131355,
0.0101715419,
-0.008028267,
0.0129396385,
-0.0267898962,
-0.0431356877,
0.0095677702,
0.0726032928,
-0.0350730941,
0.0673226863,
-0.0042869137,
-0.0224167854,
-0.0634402409,
-0.0110554267,
0.033263538,
-0.008141947,
0.0041774628,
-0.0355786346,
-0.0470306054,
-0.0399681963,
0.0305483434,
-0.015163919,
0.0142828431,
-0.0429862328,
0.0580591932,
-0.0157527477,
-0.043515645,
-0.0114215231,
-0.0223003775,
0.046652168,
-0.011568089,
0.0388231799,
0.0142209809,
0.0233668797,
-0.0242342036,
0.0661068708,
0.0507160015,
0.0274066441,
-0.0303992033,
-0.0060973088,
0.0135734491,
0.0241234675,
-0.0024504103,
-0.0289358366,
0.0106803505,
-0.0015347963,
-0.0094799912,
-0.0661268458,
-0.0122273425,
0.0147286048,
2.92e-7,
0.0208226424,
0.0506248549,
0.0551077724,
-0.0238387082,
-0.0059530791,
0.021990478,
-0.0009471255,
0.0337178484,
-0.0320227481,
-0.0070935083,
-0.006032588,
-0.0304466318,
0.0110679967,
0.0103276661,
-0.099006407,
-0.0638793781,
-0.0452437215,
-0.0202860236,
-0.0512167774,
0.0127418526,
0.0335898474,
0.0819443762,
0.0375314727,
-0.0017512535,
-0.0090097198,
0.0075479541,
0.0258736182,
0.0076174052,
0.0002825611,
0.026322851,
0.0297214463,
0.0579502955,
-0.0216764938,
0.0618864447,
-0.0427022316,
0.0304371081,
0.0109837661,
0.068838127,
-0.0089872191,
0.0278978627,
-0.0157242157,
0.0075297607,
0.0391406529,
-0.008166939,
0.0736192465,
-0.0296614338,
-0.0155331427,
-0.0138039924,
-0.0811726972,
0.0275763869,
-0.0066276323,
0.0173882339,
-0.0100984788,
0.0242632851,
0.0464961603,
-0.0090818861,
-0.0559629835,
-0.0806525201,
0.0017970611,
0.0257313903,
0.0305432435,
-0.0000809594,
-0.0479469076,
0.0011458285,
0.0018713898,
-0.0281355064,
-0.034961652,
2.85447061e-34,
-0.0258230455,
-0.0001513443,
-0.004010533,
0.068838127,
-0.0057234364,
-0.0247513037,
-0.037907172,
0.0314423889,
-0.0306818839,
-0.0595757812,
0.0160192791
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09502v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09502v2 | SQATIN: Supervised Instruction Tuning Meets Question Answering for Improved Dialogue NLU | 2023-11-16T01:57:00 | 2024-04-08T21:31:57 | Evgeniia Razumovskaia, Goran Glavaš, Anna Korhonen, Ivan Vulić | cs.CL | cs.CL | Task-oriented dialogue (ToD) systems help users execute well-defined tasks
across a variety of domains (e.g., $\textit{flight booking}$ or $\textit{food
ordering}$), with their Natural Language Understanding (NLU) components being
dedicated to the analysis of user utterances, predicting users' intents
($\textit{Intent Detection}$, ID) and extracting values for informational slots
($\textit{Value Extraction}$, VE). In most domains, labelled NLU data is
scarce, making sample-efficient learning -- enabled with effective transfer
paradigms -- paramount. In this work, we introduce SQATIN, a new framework for
dialog NLU based on (i) instruction tuning and (ii) question-answering-based
formulation of ID and VE tasks. According to the evaluation on established NLU
benchmarks, SQATIN sets the new state of the art in dialogue NLU, substantially
surpassing the performance of current models based on standard fine-tuning
objectives in both in-domain training and cross-domain transfer. SQATIN yields
particularly large performance gains in cross-domain transfer, owing to the
fact that our QA-based instruction tuning leverages similarities between
natural language descriptions of classes (i.e., slots and intents) across
domains. | [
0.0657677576,
0.0421023183,
0.0040072841,
0.0561053716,
0.0074134101,
0.0168917291,
0.0001987895,
-0.0498235561,
-0.0004882515,
-0.0607335083,
-0.0855571404,
-0.0470958129,
-0.0395191796,
0.0426583923,
-0.0109300753,
-0.0536807664,
0.0662934631,
-0.0426248536,
-0.0005754849,
0.0255732238,
-0.0004924645,
0.0168262292,
-0.049771376,
0.0317109302,
0.014093319,
-0.0321856104,
-0.0237159487,
0.0044762134,
-0.0083320346,
-0.0049638208,
0.062583603,
0.0454101451,
0.0169187989,
-0.0083668204,
0.0000019338,
-0.0437862575,
-0.0180752575,
-0.0311127082,
-0.0482968315,
-0.0263676234,
0.0137274126,
0.0214762073,
0.0278668795,
0.0251555182,
-0.0338072293,
0.0051176227,
0.0209960807,
0.0784819499,
0.0623590201,
0.0753466412,
-0.0002503769,
-0.0160373002,
-0.0048154951,
-0.0355526954,
0.0222409703,
-0.0966322869,
0.0086696018,
0.0142079797,
-0.0000394477,
0.0539282337,
-0.0212823674,
0.0257824119,
0.0053933212,
-0.035737671,
0.0009348802,
0.0014704547,
-0.0091729062,
0.0007236801,
-0.0634300634,
0.1133721098,
0.0400513113,
0.0240390263,
-0.0085431207,
0.0217767581,
0.0015328092,
-0.0571689233,
-0.0471233279,
-0.0180360861,
-0.0039884015,
-0.0114407009,
0.0052313162,
0.0260136686,
-0.0341875255,
0.0062435237,
-0.0029156711,
0.0400430001,
-0.0114161056,
-0.0204688795,
0.0014823629,
-0.0166983288,
-0.0246856157,
-0.0612805337,
0.0058283457,
0.0410627723,
-0.0532917865,
0.0225213468,
-0.0347243287,
0.024934331,
-0.015737338,
0.0068215169,
0.03230609,
0.0513385683,
-0.0003832429,
0.0560917147,
0.0302477702,
0.0578818619,
0.0165950581,
0.0125206355,
-0.0709720626,
-0.0147954347,
-0.0722134411,
0.006033401,
-0.047533121,
0.0278486647,
-0.0758598894,
0.007354029,
-0.0103353485,
0.0477977991,
0.0173011404,
-0.0117541933,
0.0122408997,
0.0343015902,
-0.0751553923,
0.0021930807,
-0.0630114973,
0.0526992083,
-0.0352331363,
0.0304642394,
0.0218574218,
-0.0098390272,
-0.0475456938,
0.0346634686,
0.0122979265,
-0.044100944,
-0.012029333,
0.0501167513,
-0.0428568646,
-0.0154764038,
0.0007495449,
-0.0193324909,
-0.0401799418,
-0.0707501471,
0.0165473316,
-0.0109146023,
0.0334732048,
-0.0139711071,
-0.027852321,
-0.0517163649,
0.0139709841,
0.0168387797,
-0.0219504442,
0.0747459605,
-0.0005537326,
-0.0033774911,
0.0011088742,
0.0242576133,
-0.0299728792,
0.0397607982,
0.0100656105,
0.0098476065,
0.0335460939,
-0.0194546264,
0.0032152953,
-0.0211908277,
0.0429123379,
0.0029449167,
0.0336662605,
0.0799822956,
0.0024813607,
0.0042203669,
0.0628030077,
0.0387609787,
-0.0193143357,
-0.0089960732,
0.0093480926,
0.042305816,
-0.0069292486,
0.0019698136,
0.0372467898,
0.0648248866,
-0.0001276885,
-0.0157054272,
-0.0550022647,
0.0365727916,
0.0036763391,
-0.0226836726,
0.0359881148,
-0.0009575648,
-0.0500831045,
-0.0551529676,
0.0209724922,
-0.010367916,
0.0341583379,
0.0122092143,
0.0090078609,
0.0316736326,
-0.0614185408,
0.0313955322,
0.0093429545,
-0.0161492955,
-0.0128668798,
-0.0415341817,
0.0399245769,
0.0390033312,
0.0104060657,
-0.0209494084,
-0.0740966871,
-0.0400098488,
0.0332560055,
0.0221169628,
0.0267057996,
-0.0513529927,
0.0622126497,
-0.0382095091,
-0.0123335272,
-0.0608336329,
-0.0136950919,
0.0300129727,
0.017237192,
-0.0087934714,
0.0059819366,
-0.0469935164,
0.0052561299,
-0.0009450598,
0.0072784857,
-0.0431701094,
0.0318231918,
0.0233840719,
0.0288094226,
0.0016462747,
0.0178077091,
-0.019532606,
-0.0092751784,
-0.0116302539,
0.0058591305,
-0.0240906179,
-0.0412921757,
-0.0457724333,
0.008664825,
0.0119195385,
-0.0295030549,
0.0250159912,
-0.0400883742,
-0.0524115488,
0.0142116975,
-0.017164249,
-0.0389293842,
-0.0412648506,
-0.0249102488,
0.0465972461,
0.0016227141,
-0.0433228537,
0.0551647991,
0.0301767755,
-0.0201525688,
0.0471544079,
0.0282417387,
0.0339007042,
-0.021235887,
0.0332391784,
-0.0094598625,
-0.0338630117,
0.0279098582,
0.0147076081,
0.0539582074,
-0.0346413031,
-0.0147184068,
-0.0800765976,
0.0303838253,
-0.0238463953,
0.0524569675,
0.0314281099,
0.0232488569,
0.0009382052,
-0.0332400948,
-0.0515757762,
-0.0292192791,
0.0232844017,
-0.0297849681,
0.079761304,
0.021837879,
-0.0090370858,
-0.0456830524,
0.0345566049,
-0.0013801757,
-0.0157169383,
-0.0235266257,
-0.0119907707,
-0.0437671393,
0.0128656635,
-0.0309084039,
0.0267643295,
-0.0125582581,
-0.0484499708,
-0.00921755,
0.0251797698,
0.0055914186,
0.079451099,
0.0181152709,
0.002964539,
-0.012020302,
-0.020456396,
-0.0382292196,
0.0815862417,
-0.0202428512,
-0.0099409027,
-0.0347763263,
0.0031727077,
0.0371024609,
0.0897937045,
0.0102753164,
0.0153137501,
-0.0557879619,
0.017100364,
0.0228063073,
-0.0219800733,
-0.0117844455,
0.0463593006,
-0.0051896507,
0.0298701879,
-0.0265105814,
-0.0087469006,
0.0674104989,
0.0007619234,
-0.0357599296,
-0.1216244698,
-0.0205326267,
-0.0606728047,
0.0131089101,
-0.0320005193,
0.0239591654,
0.0252678264,
-0.0350647196,
-0.0328514688,
-0.0228147469,
0.0026822682,
-0.0074683977,
0.0365023613,
-0.0255472604,
0.0038189054,
-0.0234915614,
-0.0671291649,
-0.0670396686,
-0.0218454208,
0.0052269143,
0.0002474088,
0.0330001265,
-0.0142932776,
-0.011540873,
-0.0034223422,
0.0201233979,
0.0193259977,
-0.0217477381,
-0.008535129,
-0.022136366,
0.0326033905,
0.0728386417,
0.0731925294,
-0.0208915938,
0.023638038,
0.0250289682,
0.0308130421,
0.0027355591,
-0.0036543973,
0.01466328,
0.023858197,
0.0408384614,
-0.0138510978,
-0.0108608231,
0.0323187001,
0.0982386172,
-0.0196649414,
-0.0532385297,
0.0995693505,
0.0363558978,
0.0035071762,
-0.0159240402,
-0.0198239852,
0.0221476294,
0.0272753239,
0.0708170012,
-0.0646176264,
-0.0953393877,
-0.0328777619,
0.0276397727,
0.0073789586,
-0.0094890725,
-0.0207802188,
-0.0786642358,
0.028525969,
-0.0327699371,
-0.0562246107,
-0.0327940024,
-0.0150047606,
0.0156034492,
0.0005047941,
0.0344152227,
-0.0166718531,
-0.0253658034,
0.020190984,
0.0516698919,
-0.0235290173,
-0.0311110727,
0.0493762903,
-0.0129090436,
0.0178771242,
0.0524475798,
0.0484228246,
0.0374170206,
-0.0071957493,
-0.0113652572,
-0.0262629613,
-0.0001317003,
-0.0082080662,
0.0669382587,
-0.0417674184,
-0.0205665585,
-0.0132185193,
0.0630939752,
-0.0410414115,
-0.0076590497,
0.0346955173,
0.0383641794,
-0.0445753485,
0.0261035394,
-0.0237943567,
0.013186804,
0.0545264333,
0.0934172869,
0.0294220801,
-0.0490422696,
-0.0456198752,
-0.0499186292,
-0.0215662904,
-0.0861649513,
0.0146553982,
0.0016085198,
0.021824412,
0.0319747329,
-0.0651636124,
-0.0688842684,
0.0292498432,
0.0305217691,
-0.0086243879,
-0.0020773252,
0.0054301922,
0.0125119276,
-0.0283606406,
0.0009712662,
-0.0499751866,
-0.0041545918,
-0.0649321005,
-0.0231786929,
0.0424179137,
-0.0320935473,
-0.0338708945,
0.0192327946,
-0.0889996141,
-0.0112833465,
-0.0508119389,
0.0525821559,
0.0120416861,
0.0635173321,
-0.0079948669,
0.0133060133,
-0.0195845254,
0.0003127233,
-0.0336395986,
-0.0247823391,
0.067260541,
0.0406087898,
-0.008561315,
0.0542021692,
-0.0476372726,
0.0240498278,
0.0065678856,
0.035009101,
-0.052872777,
-0.0342816077,
0.0105984109,
-0.0190665442,
0.010284733,
0.0620278083,
-0.0355026349,
-0.0267551597,
0.0606766418,
0.0053387205,
-0.0313363858,
-0.0665195584,
-0.0176045597,
0.013233793,
-0.0534053631,
-0.0004805333,
0.0207305774,
-0.0186289288,
0.0305264853,
-0.0202447716,
0.002451201,
0.032814078,
0.0003746051,
-0.0172253717,
-0.0136405174,
-0.0303219259,
0.0005625322,
0.0646460056,
0.0761470124,
0.0054408493,
0.094902277,
0.0425030328,
-0.0174646508,
0.0125248339,
0.0335325599,
-0.0456974618,
-0.0372490883,
-0.0000567404,
-0.0218181144,
-0.0095656179,
-0.013688257,
0.0093744453,
-0.0147729665,
0.0215442479,
0.0029087383,
0.0531720296,
-0.0062004789,
0.0008094223,
0.0807472169,
0.0000777893,
0.0007124647,
0.0041529089,
0.0589522496,
-0.0087003494,
0.0197169371,
0.0060890145,
0.0113105839,
-0.0636573136,
-0.0217972565,
0.0230851807,
0.0181409493,
-0.0044101542,
0.0388247706,
-0.0087143015,
-0.0061741918,
-0.0026904929,
-0.0481340662,
-0.035380125,
-0.0274957251,
0.060607072,
0.0633734167,
-0.0051485118,
-0.0433304496,
-0.0390394032,
-0.0381022654,
0.0049841562,
-0.0198824164,
-0.0364706479,
-6.050924027e-33,
-0.0391094908,
0.0054803221,
0.0348129943,
0.0287828073,
0.0004454901,
-0.0160742458,
-0.0434821993,
-0.0184014272,
-0.0454672836,
-0.0159328803,
-0.0002058109,
0.0037917693,
0.0067493268,
0.0488449149,
-0.012440064,
-0.0640938878,
0.0318898819,
-0.0128597273,
-0.0468577445,
0.0645163357,
0.0382568352,
0.0168556683,
0.0519018136,
-0.0214857906,
0.0066586193,
0.0280030631,
0.0148690334,
0.0542413667,
0.0242161844,
0.0345780291,
-0.0374935679,
0.0220302455,
0.0154764317,
-0.0606728308,
0.0184126887,
0.0281369928,
-0.0972142145,
-0.0578658506,
0.0427230485,
-0.0011702987,
-0.0560715124,
-0.021805672,
-0.0147991534,
-0.0014294566,
0.0423853472,
-0.0106240064,
0.0011418917,
0.0122123081,
0.0189972948,
0.0172996018,
-0.0869403705,
-0.0149081331,
-0.0322431512,
-0.0876690075,
-0.0108273951,
0.0628013164,
0.0140151419,
-0.0302686039,
-0.0262676626,
-0.0146722458,
-0.0276318807,
0.0355247669,
0.0316012539,
0.0164221097,
-0.0532211997,
0.0427944288,
0.0081885178,
-0.0008605609,
-0.0122235036,
-0.0136151379,
-0.0061788643,
0.0333245471,
-0.0009966171,
0.0237510074,
0.0073031345,
0.0184708368,
-0.0561429821,
0.0454296581,
0.0047678621,
0.0448113084,
-0.0150076635,
-0.0027229674,
-0.041141931,
-0.029143801,
-0.0209067464,
0.0345115513,
-0.0175102353,
-0.0092611033,
0.0653582588,
-0.0015333748,
-0.0282624364,
0.0126001677,
0.0537176244,
-0.0232893899,
-0.01027063,
0.0084425248,
0.0025221219,
-0.002697676,
-0.0059015551,
0.0322580598,
-0.0807257667,
-0.0419507995,
0.057862673,
0.0087667322,
0.0073828148,
0.0169650447,
0.0132312402,
-0.0311623197,
-0.0373741426,
0.0012811343,
-0.0388709381,
0.0601591766,
-0.0646974668,
0.0682149529,
0.0077167521,
0.03647824,
-0.0314398184,
0.0787341371,
-0.0141782006,
-0.0250187069,
-0.0362145156,
-0.0533489101,
0.0099795945,
0.0015740988,
-0.0372948423,
-0.0004224633,
-0.0194266122,
-0.0046380744,
-0.0602092221,
-0.0587254129,
0.0008782689,
0.0152953854,
2.598e-7,
0.0292351954,
0.0278814267,
0.0455217324,
0.0222763475,
0.0019551578,
0.061501652,
0.0130578429,
0.0314419046,
0.0237125084,
-0.0082306266,
0.0099697998,
0.0271041654,
0.034561187,
0.0214484502,
-0.0689911991,
-0.0052971835,
0.0038944411,
-0.0000049191,
-0.0378828831,
0.0023471317,
0.0603159666,
0.0889541134,
-0.0159793049,
0.0050043827,
-0.0024672225,
-0.0393761545,
0.0230435822,
-0.0093566924,
-0.0041226423,
0.0564424545,
0.0008623165,
0.0072384602,
0.0043982449,
0.0144323707,
-0.01806481,
0.0351529345,
0.0215152744,
0.0660250485,
0.000814292,
-0.0388359316,
-0.0403812677,
0.0016095168,
0.0364043675,
-0.045552671,
0.0847744271,
-0.0792985409,
-0.0212825742,
-0.0120672779,
-0.0131247947,
0.0153807718,
-0.0218361747,
0.0088428445,
0.0029005057,
0.0094799213,
0.0296552517,
0.0090762833,
-0.0004753612,
-0.0670929477,
0.0375290476,
0.0169849619,
-0.0039722021,
-0.0026902959,
-0.0400201641,
0.0057411557,
0.0301837455,
-0.031295687,
-0.0129093267,
2.31704194e-34,
0.0154051473,
-0.013901772,
0.0054758149,
0.0354075506,
0.0518729277,
-0.003879956,
-0.0365953147,
-0.0221128277,
0.0596671104,
-0.0633484349,
0.0031921573
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09481v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09481v1 | Personalized Jargon Identification for Enhanced Interdisciplinary Communication | 2023-11-16T00:51:25 | 2023-11-16T00:51:25 | Yue Guo, Joseph Chee Chang, Maria Antoniak, Erin Bransom, Trevor Cohen, Lucy Lu Wang, Tal August | cs.CL | cs.CL | Scientific jargon can impede researchers when they read materials from other
domains. Current methods of jargon identification mainly use corpus-level
familiarity indicators (e.g., Simple Wikipedia represents plain language).
However, researchers' familiarity of a term can vary greatly based on their own
background. We collect a dataset of over 10K term familiarity annotations from
11 computer science researchers for terms drawn from 100 paper abstracts.
Analysis of this data reveals that jargon familiarity and information needs
vary widely across annotators, even within the same sub-domain (e.g., NLP). We
investigate features representing individual, sub-domain, and domain knowledge
to predict individual jargon familiarity. We compare supervised and
prompt-based approaches, finding that prompt-based methods including personal
publications yields the highest accuracy, though zero-shot prompting provides a
strong baseline. This research offers insight into features and methods to
integrate personal data into scientific jargon identification. | [
0.0600512624,
-0.0098038828,
-0.012731106,
-0.0065737688,
0.0006460029,
-0.0270109642,
0.0549999736,
0.0189612247,
0.0365054794,
-0.0331587344,
-0.0371568315,
0.0287198517,
0.013529418,
0.0106970025,
0.0130622471,
-0.0349661782,
0.045743607,
0.0078093056,
0.0298896749,
-0.0074696704,
0.0182706732,
0.012094778,
-0.0220844131,
0.0542114787,
0.0176426861,
-0.0594535545,
0.045727957,
-0.0239179283,
0.0022360955,
-0.0093928836,
0.0643605888,
0.0906298682,
-0.0186471026,
0.0405693352,
0.0000016838,
-0.0569936,
-0.0140236281,
0.0010176353,
-0.01238563,
-0.0023235295,
0.0638950467,
0.0212122016,
0.0305069275,
-0.03859099,
-0.0203212965,
-0.0113247959,
0.0489299297,
-0.0009117383,
-0.0261435807,
-0.0137040671,
0.0001951826,
-0.0316068307,
-0.0245578475,
0.0165704656,
0.0281495824,
0.0152951591,
0.0221164618,
-0.0144356079,
0.0051761111,
0.0431233458,
-0.017523326,
0.0131730977,
-0.0536371097,
0.0194936525,
0.1100426614,
0.037036363,
-0.041810561,
0.0103315255,
0.0095297145,
0.06317164,
0.0730943903,
-0.0113510061,
0.0326495431,
-0.0033180802,
0.0107130371,
0.0871757194,
-0.0353296958,
-0.0279282983,
-0.0247006528,
-0.0654711723,
-0.0196124837,
0.0287598316,
-0.0112122651,
0.0449824892,
-0.0011281132,
0.0759016275,
0.0094292797,
-0.0181161277,
-0.000689186,
-0.0162224118,
0.0411127619,
-0.0487961732,
0.0213637389,
-0.0187593177,
0.0037310217,
0.0445521884,
-0.0038236645,
-0.0494140014,
0.0640369132,
-0.0239914898,
-0.0443874523,
-0.0096458606,
-0.0134237241,
0.0196029451,
0.0215838291,
-0.0264317337,
0.0370022841,
-0.0101472167,
0.0438738242,
0.0049507385,
-0.1174166799,
-0.0242973398,
0.0267179776,
0.0297352318,
0.0407769084,
-0.0137724355,
-0.0270709302,
0.0075411145,
-0.0235858578,
-0.0013223472,
-0.0127856266,
0.0327686816,
-0.0548761487,
-0.0045297416,
-0.0375154391,
0.0169695523,
-0.0734765679,
0.0471765436,
-0.0035434666,
-0.0395879708,
0.006169159,
-0.0023580974,
0.0076632253,
-0.0154612502,
0.008238201,
0.0125032905,
0.0168554094,
-0.0366449095,
0.011144314,
-0.0702312589,
0.0005473879,
0.0219946094,
0.0377055667,
-0.0616216399,
0.0222976282,
0.0165714324,
0.0078334277,
-0.0563610718,
-0.0001377564,
0.0346190892,
-0.0392747261,
0.0766654611,
-0.0858660415,
-0.0232386645,
0.0585500225,
0.0280512329,
0.0080433087,
0.0156217963,
-0.0349163748,
-0.0139221419,
0.0611771233,
-0.0365772583,
-0.0040528323,
-0.0165686496,
-0.0214606151,
-0.0133740092,
-0.0048911506,
-0.0128915953,
-0.0365646891,
0.0318839327,
0.0094831707,
-0.0073744967,
-0.0246805362,
-0.0179979727,
0.0094912825,
0.1198924184,
0.0233950391,
0.0421966948,
-0.0064386111,
0.0424712151,
0.030617686,
0.001315169,
0.0284925532,
0.0102157313,
-0.0201425273,
-0.0086524105,
0.0368229672,
-0.0276855137,
-0.0177504122,
0.0046778712,
-0.0247282498,
0.0114253284,
-0.0083421273,
-0.0261622183,
0.041528672,
-0.0016280174,
0.049032364,
0.0538527183,
0.0175494719,
-0.0334040038,
-0.0109108463,
0.0229455922,
-0.014055361,
0.0738604143,
0.0523036718,
-0.0284382906,
-0.0519495867,
-0.0228054821,
0.0035551859,
0.028691018,
0.0259993058,
-0.0170400925,
-0.0074255941,
-0.0261588823,
0.0012839246,
0.0266548209,
0.0075057908,
0.0314843766,
0.0331270695,
0.0206231177,
-0.0103384219,
-0.0524271391,
-0.0294379368,
0.0151828965,
-0.0731062144,
-0.0821653977,
0.0268024597,
-0.0282597672,
0.0381376185,
0.0241545793,
0.0058311168,
0.011462803,
0.0221206769,
-0.0023892308,
0.0053024432,
-0.0067046667,
0.0248187743,
0.0291648675,
0.0213249046,
-0.0544248596,
0.0110660782,
-0.0231719017,
0.031781368,
-0.0083780233,
0.0323400386,
-0.0091462107,
0.0241921507,
-0.0050863815,
-0.031691201,
-0.0316336975,
0.0167379044,
-0.0118386513,
0.036631871,
0.0153582171,
0.0590696149,
0.0051565724,
-0.0754190162,
0.0022991162,
-0.0014065893,
-0.0136611676,
-0.0259486511,
0.0138978148,
0.0193687398,
0.0491461381,
-0.0322305188,
-0.0864372849,
0.0008825065,
-0.0781827867,
-0.0117536457,
0.0350915939,
0.0159857739,
-0.0114079872,
-0.0348196961,
-0.011880652,
-0.0100559536,
-0.0049427166,
-0.0236359276,
-0.0750070661,
0.0121400915,
0.0469533019,
0.0442750789,
0.0006264684,
-0.0275841933,
-0.0099640414,
-0.0430228375,
0.0351031199,
0.030592123,
-0.0226158798,
-0.001948053,
-0.020543348,
-0.0279835835,
-0.0091341659,
-0.0136187002,
0.0093332259,
0.016063448,
0.0078577651,
-0.0040511088,
0.0137361456,
0.0145335207,
0.0129473126,
0.0364053547,
-0.0348448195,
-0.0635225028,
-0.0247448254,
-0.014310888,
-0.0011311435,
0.0277357511,
-0.0481259264,
0.0432268009,
0.0125343697,
-0.0123126963,
0.005870563,
-0.0202831477,
0.0173739959,
0.0031964942,
-0.0248622298,
-0.0085639236,
0.0018594277,
0.0010122648,
0.0482223406,
0.0484682098,
0.0081370622,
0.0680719912,
-0.0117291817,
0.0000079576,
-0.0235559065,
-0.0097072134,
-0.0189765953,
0.036913611,
-0.0575597286,
0.0069605126,
0.0659731701,
-0.0174671691,
-0.0178838223,
0.0204051007,
0.0066306372,
-0.0409711078,
-0.0059831319,
-0.0250060633,
-0.0062303133,
0.0367628969,
0.0245649982,
-0.001852466,
-0.0317701474,
-0.0202645902,
0.026283402,
0.054470174,
-0.0661444366,
0.008531969,
0.0064054062,
0.0424987078,
0.0054430021,
0.0034143743,
-0.0464816429,
0.0109773362,
-0.0286657196,
0.0125845708,
-0.0091217374,
-0.0115895858,
0.0084623145,
-0.0295861848,
0.0177962948,
-0.0012276343,
-0.0288843382,
-0.0301954821,
-0.0615106225,
0.0513305701,
-0.1006202996,
-0.0310368072,
-0.0076761008,
0.0110687753,
-0.0260158833,
0.0168972183,
0.0665538087,
0.0422172695,
-0.0995436236,
-0.0138713671,
-0.0387136526,
0.0357048251,
0.0181552283,
0.0214611329,
-0.0780114159,
-0.0323853195,
-0.0414114371,
0.0176290739,
-0.0200053621,
-0.059483707,
-0.0169170462,
-0.0479473323,
0.0023164346,
-0.0052762246,
-0.0326616205,
-0.0043832236,
-0.0299338624,
0.0227811579,
0.0097517567,
-0.0520043038,
-0.0267770365,
-0.0538805686,
-0.0013218039,
0.0384396948,
-0.0839450657,
-0.1140844524,
0.0187197495,
0.0066144187,
0.0696239695,
0.0101095764,
0.0291400924,
-0.0273439363,
-0.0600068346,
-0.0557986982,
-0.0161476601,
0.0148691945,
-0.023612814,
0.0891566277,
-0.0447402708,
0.0178416818,
0.0002229839,
0.004080628,
-0.0646831989,
-0.0119431512,
0.034400478,
0.0309147742,
0.0015763229,
0.012393699,
-0.0493499599,
0.0016925553,
-0.002523876,
0.0583101027,
0.0168132316,
-0.0141012119,
0.0104591977,
-0.0286902692,
0.0372237191,
0.0267297737,
-0.0518029183,
-0.0638044104,
-0.0534470528,
-0.0773839504,
-0.0304575879,
-0.0291851033,
0.0608967282,
0.0050885095,
0.0390242189,
0.050988812,
-0.010606911,
0.017273536,
-0.0856660455,
0.0644498467,
-0.0136589929,
0.0033777941,
-0.0092733772,
-0.0447549298,
0.0505234711,
-0.012115676,
-0.04233573,
0.0506600738,
0.0395244397,
-0.0420333557,
-0.026646141,
-0.0053968839,
0.0187718868,
0.0149898948,
-0.0096203201,
-0.0747383907,
0.0242098216,
0.0760343224,
-0.0145126572,
-0.0153766638,
0.0237607826,
-0.0188983493,
-0.0157477446,
-0.0027773706,
-0.0345775671,
0.006312367,
-0.0341004208,
-0.0253061503,
-0.0642163381,
-0.0959949642,
0.0203647222,
0.0102978777,
0.0553146489,
-0.0338259079,
0.0144187519,
-0.0178801827,
-0.0327438191,
0.0320010781,
-0.0013719018,
0.0216580816,
-0.0209535789,
-0.0040415563,
-0.0468020849,
0.0069654775,
0.05963796,
-0.0365855731,
0.0228927936,
0.0055717626,
-0.0034669726,
-0.006673174,
0.0623291321,
-0.0032810529,
-0.0073708915,
-0.0331024416,
-0.0599190816,
-0.0164570455,
0.0294262934,
-0.0036600351,
0.027928507,
0.035365358,
0.0017795829,
-0.0066662198,
0.0208964814,
-0.0683818087,
-0.0547368564,
0.0217625685,
0.0318900608,
-0.0036973718,
-0.0051311976,
0.008921193,
-0.0614400879,
-0.0001087545,
-0.0491661057,
0.0101888366,
-0.0140440706,
0.0167888142,
0.0279161874,
0.0244066846,
-0.0295389779,
-0.0438737646,
0.0975159034,
0.0178452898,
-0.0143230055,
-0.035484504,
-0.0601350479,
-0.0198468622,
-0.0023236945,
0.010568535,
0.072745882,
-0.0014555857,
0.0161155835,
-0.1156831533,
-0.0167674124,
0.0441812128,
-0.0462483428,
0.0027429671,
0.0049888561,
0.0666758716,
0.0739269927,
0.0128399786,
-0.0182026085,
-0.0295078121,
0.050273966,
-0.0501690544,
-0.0323006921,
-0.023924889,
-5.874701996e-33,
-0.0262072477,
-0.0631134063,
-0.011018184,
0.0273824167,
0.0149864731,
0.0097754681,
-0.030922683,
0.0337916017,
-0.0122135701,
0.0255030524,
-0.0175079387,
-0.0186922345,
0.0031091406,
-0.0410601273,
0.0797463506,
0.0235285498,
0.0399446003,
0.0286548138,
-0.00893756,
0.0268362667,
0.0693275258,
0.0096188225,
0.0570565797,
-0.0912659019,
0.0813819617,
-0.0154453386,
0.0263668932,
-0.0391695537,
0.046824012,
0.0573825203,
-0.0406772681,
0.0612059347,
0.0105577223,
-0.0101811104,
0.001425201,
0.023950791,
-0.0253746621,
-0.0661112145,
0.0421616286,
-0.0155632943,
-0.0165631976,
-0.0714342892,
0.056161616,
0.0014093727,
-0.0659383237,
0.0194479395,
0.099482961,
0.0024440391,
-0.0238098018,
-0.0338730514,
-0.0391802453,
0.0312477704,
-0.0129376901,
0.0150748156,
0.0242262371,
0.0457570851,
-0.0145321749,
0.0298524424,
-0.0266577117,
0.0620234162,
0.0188411307,
0.0078092664,
0.0573460087,
0.0028732058,
0.0215822328,
0.069946833,
-0.0003940936,
0.0345036723,
0.0257980507,
-0.0591563359,
0.0372037068,
0.0022324736,
-0.0084381858,
0.0653046295,
0.0724552795,
-0.0169702861,
0.0380626731,
0.0287311226,
0.010913549,
0.0069260122,
0.0070531955,
-0.0206406265,
-0.0398873016,
-0.0119922748,
-0.0075800368,
0.0220888071,
-0.019386366,
-0.0489214286,
0.0148998499,
-0.040802788,
-0.0075947046,
0.0386697501,
-0.0331867933,
0.0054804762,
-0.0156043041,
-0.0024626255,
0.0129682506,
0.0318451226,
0.0074081053,
-0.0050207023,
-0.0746322572,
0.0031073142,
-0.0203328691,
-0.0236898381,
0.0529515892,
0.0281162113,
0.0179780144,
-0.0022050552,
-0.029160805,
-0.0606577732,
0.0186729264,
-0.0425985605,
-0.0385758765,
-0.0221709535,
0.0330031738,
0.0617550537,
0.0054777074,
0.027368892,
0.0334339775,
0.0322951972,
0.0004610201,
-0.0368661657,
0.0030183755,
0.0222596433,
0.0013208463,
-0.0313787125,
-0.0045522396,
0.0073902979,
0.0016346084,
0.0200008508,
0.0148501201,
-0.0396915972,
2.542e-7,
0.0357158072,
0.086672999,
-0.029172305,
-0.01491185,
0.0211140364,
0.0231680293,
0.0125877326,
0.0334397443,
-0.04847195,
-0.0199142564,
-0.0075286371,
0.0006449314,
-0.0139405001,
0.0287523847,
-0.1200605556,
-0.0713174641,
0.0013898095,
0.024964679,
-0.0659390092,
0.0024229167,
0.0541394763,
-0.0167525187,
0.0346889235,
0.0126774777,
-0.0243759118,
-0.0121049602,
0.0215914641,
-0.0398420356,
0.047855787,
0.0633475482,
0.0461878479,
0.0275115166,
-0.0002437258,
0.078117013,
-0.0341942199,
-0.0309318993,
-0.015520392,
0.0211917274,
-0.0358059742,
0.0016257769,
0.0300542973,
-0.0046344995,
0.0199442394,
0.0018886056,
-0.0120004304,
0.0180054512,
-0.0081682401,
-0.0177984033,
-0.0141830686,
0.0207198504,
0.0476408973,
-0.0334080048,
-0.0210789554,
-0.0098085376,
-0.0272458401,
-0.0090217022,
-0.0399128236,
-0.046494022,
0.0241516754,
0.0464512892,
-0.0250087045,
-0.0400923342,
-0.0063562971,
-0.0352673419,
0.0182317887,
-0.0047722957,
0.0437026732,
1.868713446e-34,
0.0031204398,
0.0455295518,
-0.0163165703,
0.0745411143,
-0.0137770297,
-0.0186011642,
-0.0349601917,
0.0541145727,
0.0414332896,
-0.0180218592,
0.0228651576
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09480v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09480v2 | Show Your Work with Confidence: Confidence Bands for Tuning Curves | 2023-11-16T00:50:37 | 2024-04-08T18:21:53 | Nicholas Lourie, Kyunghyun Cho, He He | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, stat.ML | The choice of hyperparameters greatly impacts performance in natural language
processing. Often, it is hard to tell if a method is better than another or
just better tuned. Tuning curves fix this ambiguity by accounting for tuning
effort. Specifically, they plot validation performance as a function of the
number of hyperparameter choices tried so far. While several estimators exist
for these curves, it is common to use point estimates, which we show fail
silently and give contradictory results when given too little data.
Beyond point estimates, confidence bands are necessary to rigorously
establish the relationship between different approaches. We present the first
method to construct valid confidence bands for tuning curves. The bands are
exact, simultaneous, and distribution-free, thus they provide a robust basis
for comparing methods.
Empirical analysis shows that while bootstrap confidence bands, which serve
as a baseline, fail to approximate their target confidence, ours achieve it
exactly. We validate our design with ablations, analyze the effect of sample
size, and provide guidance on comparing models with our method. To promote
confident comparisons in future work, we release opda: an easy-to-use library
that you can install with pip. https://github.com/nicholaslourie/opda | [
0.024405418,
0.0904543623,
0.0111581702,
0.0211768784,
-0.0267188214,
-0.0289877113,
0.0078446781,
0.0080327308,
-0.0681746677,
-0.0293917935,
-0.0568898246,
0.0106525663,
0.0382561721,
0.021955464,
-0.0080392379,
-0.0384589992,
0.026025353,
-0.009495629,
0.048287455,
0.0486560427,
-0.0123994183,
0.0084915031,
-0.0284024198,
0.0797223896,
-0.0509536937,
0.0073686261,
0.0408954695,
0.0407773927,
0.0324545838,
-0.0529075004,
0.0385900028,
0.0580644794,
-0.0659926385,
0.0513261929,
0.0000018928,
-0.0639119372,
-0.0351752304,
0.0230885688,
-0.0366580337,
0.0137767214,
0.0839331821,
-0.048625689,
0.0165657811,
0.0163658429,
-0.0258814618,
-0.0147164771,
0.0347119421,
0.0036169675,
-0.0100237951,
0.09293814,
-0.0201041922,
-0.0204271153,
-0.0101281544,
-0.0163307842,
-0.04528559,
-0.036651779,
-0.0112394635,
-0.027570663,
-0.0086057307,
-0.0213992354,
-0.0110746827,
0.0606340952,
-0.0312201139,
0.0147631643,
-0.0025210218,
0.0093816686,
-0.0963210687,
-0.0327392668,
-0.0390164256,
0.0514246598,
-0.074707672,
-0.0156826898,
-0.0121159591,
-0.0268425178,
-0.027711289,
0.0270666201,
-0.0406814069,
0.0112208454,
-0.0004739115,
-0.006147888,
-0.0190271679,
0.0164736845,
0.0181192178,
-0.0113217803,
0.0297502838,
0.0454965457,
0.0217274595,
-0.0386051908,
0.0521507896,
0.0278069153,
-0.0626766011,
-0.0134710912,
0.0411880091,
-0.003528438,
-0.0416616797,
0.0050772638,
-0.0274706576,
-0.0167251769,
0.0444984138,
0.0055619976,
0.0607532449,
0.0007995699,
0.0102839405,
0.0039432188,
-0.0166170504,
0.0090434179,
0.0344400294,
-0.0053536333,
-0.0039946851,
0.0191375688,
-0.0631176457,
0.0381243527,
-0.0131956795,
-0.0340271518,
-0.0056692902,
-0.0331663117,
-0.0636336654,
-0.0036851936,
0.0264316611,
0.0158041231,
0.0428210311,
-0.0003947981,
0.0089714807,
0.0517148226,
0.0245577376,
0.0573373511,
-0.0398352072,
0.0014056674,
-0.0219401047,
-0.0387456641,
-0.0186374001,
0.038168855,
0.0236738641,
-0.0031968073,
0.0353194661,
0.0457277484,
0.0319474451,
-0.0435203463,
0.0199782699,
-0.0129979569,
-0.0363216624,
-0.0689186901,
-0.0476633199,
-0.0631634742,
-0.008712857,
0.0138940262,
0.0400465727,
-0.013424566,
-0.0139025925,
-0.0333842933,
-0.033526767,
0.045499377,
-0.0023778412,
0.0093696248,
-0.02108806,
-0.0183150936,
-0.0339000933,
0.0599286035,
0.0597409233,
-0.0105067212,
0.0808589533,
0.0136582535,
0.0405803211,
0.007712028,
-0.0217503048,
-0.0469699167,
-0.0038237169,
-0.0450515486,
-0.0239423644,
0.0315805227,
0.018133847,
0.0589242913,
-0.0511458591,
0.0131781967,
0.0326376334,
0.0585035197,
0.0685939565,
-0.0520188957,
0.0255487151,
-0.0171282887,
0.0651415512,
-0.0218783375,
-0.0364295803,
-0.0522988141,
-0.03014783,
0.0445733741,
0.016181767,
-0.0206947364,
0.0066687805,
-0.0543391854,
-0.0612866916,
-0.0245973542,
-0.0571201928,
-0.0406352989,
0.0469912477,
-0.0236446634,
-0.0464802049,
-0.0201370306,
0.0071003446,
-0.0439225994,
-0.0318785831,
0.0078396378,
-0.0030334529,
0.0256638341,
0.0199536718,
-0.0327199958,
0.0267772321,
-0.0003164216,
-0.0064057349,
0.0309284963,
0.0310004484,
0.0011194594,
0.0252295118,
-0.0585522801,
-0.0179131515,
0.0017132981,
0.0445884988,
-0.0023428986,
0.0403747559,
0.024155695,
0.0079836808,
-0.0320563652,
-0.0574484952,
0.039012365,
0.0399166569,
-0.0244798269,
0.0019526698,
-0.0390498526,
0.0259253047,
0.0092026526,
-0.0132579068,
0.0132779144,
0.012273265,
-0.002105426,
0.0251119509,
-0.0066737076,
0.0361897834,
-0.0204870515,
0.03673568,
-0.0552321859,
0.0121179456,
-0.0043317485,
-0.0189531334,
-0.035224691,
-0.0067318408,
-0.0073058628,
0.0364191085,
0.0059997407,
0.0460279137,
-0.0347747803,
0.0313078873,
-0.0731372312,
0.0023071573,
0.0386978388,
0.0393044651,
-0.0402930826,
-0.0195035636,
0.0427728221,
-0.0192424022,
-0.0224999003,
0.0209635235,
-0.0015948259,
0.0062037543,
0.0050443113,
0.0251064785,
-0.0278117098,
-0.0233001318,
-0.0627428368,
0.0035429217,
-0.0177996904,
0.0265283138,
0.0132413087,
-0.0224094167,
-0.0316489488,
0.0002361819,
0.0290151257,
-0.009160297,
0.0021797968,
0.015237201,
0.0300351214,
-0.0007439295,
-0.0379199833,
-0.0668509156,
-0.0172773283,
-0.0050414647,
0.0870107561,
0.0057571987,
-0.0167090651,
-0.0044612135,
0.001764216,
0.0115238335,
0.005615972,
0.0319019631,
-0.0479093492,
0.0228044372,
0.0313275345,
0.0174088031,
0.0300182458,
-0.0507996045,
-0.0407683477,
0.048294805,
0.0244235452,
-0.0418237746,
-0.0137519324,
-0.0332891941,
-0.0168224871,
-0.0144300563,
-0.0207994804,
0.0420710519,
0.0949310958,
0.0321181566,
0.0023414695,
-0.0063418951,
0.0349251479,
-0.0171419792,
0.0134183625,
0.0159439798,
-0.0285161827,
0.0082651991,
0.0390783176,
0.0049513197,
-0.0804041401,
0.0590873398,
-0.0355403498,
0.0028816233,
-0.0725041032,
-0.0015687594,
-0.0393443368,
-0.0118644945,
-0.0040409393,
-0.0029130536,
0.0257450119,
-0.0330959149,
0.0325219408,
-0.0166447554,
0.0946058333,
-0.0234565884,
0.0207517575,
-0.0355140902,
0.032171227,
0.0020122274,
0.0170077179,
-0.0484639518,
0.0046203895,
-0.0630777404,
0.0114235329,
0.012791723,
-0.0557818078,
-0.0113307098,
0.0447974578,
-0.0223381408,
0.0437247232,
-0.0281290766,
-0.0114593962,
-0.0008124683,
0.0101080611,
-0.0013195813,
-0.0178843196,
0.0550131239,
-0.0027644623,
0.0433576629,
-0.0020684614,
0.0124802813,
0.0771032944,
-0.0400106534,
0.0062677674,
-0.008944599,
-0.0771706104,
-0.0317975581,
0.0142413536,
0.059844207,
-0.0326395854,
-0.0035892462,
0.147725299,
0.0506511964,
-0.0231390074,
0.0200672597,
0.0679055378,
0.0607528202,
0.022643324,
0.009483817,
-0.021449022,
-0.0192410368,
0.0014901569,
0.0884267539,
-0.0262455083,
-0.0029209778,
0.0106678298,
-0.0749460831,
0.0350790843,
-0.0006143774,
-0.0125186043,
0.0286706369,
-0.0920918435,
0.0215617009,
-0.0516192652,
0.0297933929,
-0.0053825164,
-0.0188952908,
0.019780172,
0.0298569091,
-0.0590364859,
-0.0785921142,
-0.0075134505,
-0.0593776777,
0.0036733483,
-0.0026962857,
0.0295978691,
0.0244106054,
-0.0407030396,
0.0583058372,
0.0186043717,
-0.0026244421,
-0.0587101504,
0.0701592043,
0.0204092208,
0.0010643068,
0.0137429088,
0.0049345288,
-0.0612088181,
-0.0027339158,
-0.0362326168,
0.0166874919,
0.0151150348,
-0.0260434691,
-0.0033882677,
0.0237686876,
-0.0082609635,
0.0729179308,
0.0131859016,
-0.0150885377,
-0.039423801,
0.0144052124,
-0.0326982141,
-0.0795284808,
-0.0198990423,
0.0381457619,
-0.0233592112,
-0.0379237719,
-0.0595726147,
0.0009830223,
0.0256493278,
0.0420836881,
0.000880479,
0.0251931194,
-0.0135637466,
0.0226317868,
-0.0446280688,
0.0754403993,
0.0142562464,
-0.010170877,
-0.0742479563,
0.001074077,
0.0286148377,
0.0579300523,
-0.02945159,
0.032365188,
-0.0729775131,
-0.0657209828,
-0.0246547796,
0.0336512476,
0.0234605204,
0.0229059029,
-0.0313775875,
-0.0490573011,
-0.003885061,
0.000837399,
-0.0049313796,
-0.0279716868,
0.0419244245,
0.0043519763,
-0.0230215248,
0.0068005589,
0.0023757089,
0.0240679942,
0.0254577361,
0.0470684245,
-0.0188410617,
-0.0514226928,
0.0092575438,
0.021261964,
0.0786800683,
-0.0198613983,
-0.0433740541,
-0.0158627275,
-0.0429821126,
-0.0133117726,
0.0058744187,
-0.0188312642,
0.0016887374,
0.0427955613,
0.0098250182,
-0.0682474971,
-0.0320330076,
-0.0429700427,
0.0162435379,
-0.0696281791,
0.0650466233,
0.0136101712,
-0.0012352043,
0.0002129448,
-0.003258975,
-0.0126701761,
0.0253074653,
0.010382955,
0.0114700133,
0.0213690959,
-0.0186250899,
-0.0283789895,
0.0170318559,
-0.0171968415,
0.0178356878,
-0.0734219924,
0.0239448268,
-0.0324750878,
0.0024519055,
0.0435937047,
-0.030279696,
0.077567555,
-0.0046802741,
-0.0016617833,
-0.0347475484,
0.0378217287,
0.0252381898,
0.0699410141,
0.0174452439,
-0.0041759922,
-0.0450939909,
0.0052118208,
0.0446167402,
0.0110006081,
0.0311216544,
-0.0212672465,
-0.0585952289,
-0.0462302938,
0.0354925208,
-0.0462852605,
0.0039593992,
-0.0442131087,
-0.0005203401,
-0.0207157508,
-0.0198758915,
0.046668563,
0.0144397793,
0.0345544443,
0.0266182907,
0.0000093293,
0.0171682276,
-0.0219080895,
0.0049561113,
-0.0293845106,
-0.0662705079,
-0.0112915803,
-0.0290355831,
-0.0461806208,
-6.207305918e-33,
0.0106594386,
-0.0088372743,
-0.0394887663,
0.0063179811,
0.0031199299,
0.0343911722,
-0.0218514875,
0.0510435998,
-0.0104669547,
-0.0057375464,
0.0000939918,
-0.0251976121,
0.0417790748,
-0.0182864387,
0.0125332391,
-0.0023738812,
0.0225997474,
0.0097796647,
-0.0733609498,
-0.0594359301,
0.0053248852,
0.0464226566,
0.0847231075,
-0.1032620296,
0.0070509757,
0.0626514107,
-0.0384624079,
-0.0025941939,
-0.0177155677,
0.0663832501,
0.0103329923,
0.0840122178,
0.0129645607,
0.004008912,
-0.016557321,
-0.0055872505,
-0.0358506404,
-0.0472754054,
0.0380393229,
0.0339018144,
0.0043418556,
-0.0218083281,
0.0403761119,
-0.0262436979,
-0.0383735672,
0.0100893974,
0.0227726195,
-0.0352638587,
-0.025841143,
-0.0315340906,
-0.0367283821,
0.0344903283,
-0.0090593752,
-0.0026154574,
0.0302237701,
0.0475564003,
-0.0305808652,
-0.0039573722,
-0.0205838084,
-0.0218470581,
0.0457211286,
0.0438144766,
0.0276509114,
0.0188935753,
-0.00020785,
0.0185544323,
-0.0097553208,
-0.0132250581,
0.0531105399,
0.0197725724,
0.043471273,
0.0191444755,
0.0489039086,
-0.001171944,
0.0120884618,
-0.0190914441,
-0.0609617569,
-0.0076666484,
0.0416047648,
0.002832257,
0.0221691206,
0.0337169841,
-0.0610826239,
-0.0051834872,
-0.0505289882,
-0.0638624132,
-0.0415776744,
-0.0060434747,
0.0305363797,
0.0226544105,
-0.0266380832,
0.026263224,
0.0047839349,
-0.0179538,
-0.0080253556,
-0.0230019446,
0.0242666565,
0.0417241678,
-0.0065293759,
0.0056469007,
-0.0078211445,
-0.0011978014,
0.0051506069,
0.0473419204,
0.0531708561,
-0.0773051679,
0.0117638754,
-0.0213649049,
-0.0480993092,
0.0111847175,
-0.0011694031,
0.0202887096,
-0.0098266965,
0.0756273195,
0.0200050715,
-0.01836209,
-0.0164964478,
0.0295995455,
-0.0187184196,
-0.0181374177,
-0.0307991151,
0.0390389413,
0.0304399785,
0.0267911367,
-0.0097993463,
-0.014306047,
-0.0013457555,
-0.0406008512,
0.022006426,
-0.0396568328,
-0.02095153,
0.0195961855,
2.705e-7,
0.0800613016,
0.0703416541,
-0.0016863125,
0.0378390886,
0.0044036373,
-0.0292860065,
-0.0315358639,
-0.0566929467,
0.0052320664,
0.0028278474,
-0.0234626867,
-0.0027374693,
0.0888215229,
0.0221072696,
-0.0549913496,
-0.113317661,
-0.0019527925,
0.0197541118,
-0.0553628504,
-0.0066979532,
0.0570673496,
0.0661119446,
0.0075045275,
0.0077567557,
-0.0320603587,
-0.0144320801,
-0.00001124,
-0.0118956631,
-0.0065917484,
0.0683526024,
0.0036985746,
0.0080936411,
0.0326851346,
0.0495904535,
-0.0302560534,
0.0220038947,
0.016146468,
0.0512074307,
0.003850786,
-0.0531669222,
0.0233333185,
0.0073295385,
0.0369762331,
-0.0339194015,
0.0517915599,
0.0033055299,
-0.003017077,
-0.025690712,
0.0247773975,
-0.0256722905,
0.0901058018,
-0.0476330221,
-0.0144536234,
0.0108770803,
0.0405250899,
0.0057815346,
-0.040841341,
-0.0440890566,
-0.0344045609,
0.0593447424,
0.0189681761,
-0.0366546251,
0.0041748248,
-0.0201438535,
0.0298947711,
-0.0554414205,
-0.0355063863,
2.756201579e-34,
0.0549048148,
-0.0250398349,
0.0556774922,
0.0185517445,
0.0345059969,
0.0135808084,
0.0443712026,
-0.0183404777,
0.0098620877,
-0.0933952034,
0.0149580743
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09476v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09476v2 | ARES: An Automated Evaluation Framework for Retrieval-Augmented Generation Systems | 2023-11-16T00:39:39 | 2024-03-31T20:58:46 | Jon Saad-Falcon, Omar Khattab, Christopher Potts, Matei Zaharia | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR | Evaluating retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) systems traditionally relies
on hand annotations for input queries, passages to retrieve, and responses to
generate. We introduce ARES, an Automated RAG Evaluation System, for evaluating
RAG systems along the dimensions of context relevance, answer faithfulness, and
answer relevance. By creating its own synthetic training data, ARES finetunes
lightweight LM judges to assess the quality of individual RAG components. To
mitigate potential prediction errors, ARES utilizes a small set of
human-annotated datapoints for prediction-powered inference (PPI). Across eight
different knowledge-intensive tasks in KILT, SuperGLUE, and AIS, ARES
accurately evaluates RAG systems while using only a few hundred human
annotations during evaluation. Furthermore, ARES judges remain effective across
domain shifts, proving accurate even after changing the type of queries and/or
documents used in the evaluated RAG systems. We make our code and datasets
publicly available on Github. | [
0.0474589169,
0.0217821971,
-0.0140031017,
-0.0116473371,
-0.0181032773,
0.0035820904,
0.0060935663,
-0.0090933461,
-0.0054288083,
-0.0498939119,
-0.0183078907,
0.0101507353,
-0.0255878847,
-0.0006211473,
0.0341167785,
-0.0202407949,
0.0471201278,
-0.0036063425,
0.0033565531,
0.0314496234,
0.0044727991,
0.0245440975,
-0.0383467749,
0.0519998223,
-0.0281455591,
-0.0065329173,
-0.0234371666,
0.0124773793,
0.0288726185,
-0.0245094094,
-0.0018991554,
0.0455163717,
0.0057566124,
0.0361386836,
0.0000017835,
-0.069545351,
-0.001358833,
-0.0032787686,
-0.0386580825,
-0.0124980705,
0.0316744521,
0.0444172397,
0.0220277719,
0.0044857729,
-0.0633672327,
-0.0029650934,
0.0341102593,
0.0070377556,
0.0685457587,
0.0701288059,
0.0037179736,
0.0116015915,
0.0069756475,
-0.0375116244,
0.0624707714,
-0.0274807755,
-0.0175140854,
0.0132248867,
0.0278675724,
0.0191955045,
0.0357684158,
0.059940502,
0.0283095278,
-0.0372421928,
0.0235962197,
0.002396842,
-0.0546643361,
0.0038030506,
0.0193602368,
0.0668772981,
0.1048367023,
-0.0261829142,
-0.0219551604,
-0.0029054873,
0.0379671454,
0.0393427573,
-0.0450666621,
0.0090916017,
-0.0289296657,
-0.012186124,
0.008071892,
0.0150811234,
0.016787732,
0.0148220407,
0.0025898565,
0.0762982965,
0.0101583702,
-0.0257724598,
-0.0018917125,
0.0363187604,
-0.0241964981,
-0.0381581038,
-0.0229667667,
0.0353708863,
-0.0445662253,
0.0175530575,
-0.029655084,
-0.0432254449,
0.0387066491,
0.0070631285,
0.0279937908,
0.0208278485,
-0.0197070595,
0.0331758074,
-0.0248335339,
0.0425503775,
0.0085255411,
0.0029345325,
-0.0625476763,
-0.0109673413,
-0.0458575077,
-0.0327769145,
-0.0302365758,
0.037299864,
-0.0780480504,
-0.0154243791,
-0.0431286432,
0.0232961103,
-0.0077778711,
-0.0048642713,
-0.0036271368,
0.059528511,
-0.0479613803,
0.0157141015,
-0.0668207482,
0.0292544626,
-0.056814909,
0.0217249151,
0.0552947074,
-0.0615090281,
-0.0069462946,
0.0406877771,
0.0080530094,
-0.0278581325,
-0.0053837295,
0.0671050027,
-0.0221916493,
-0.0069930842,
-0.0519522168,
-0.0890960246,
-0.0008765826,
-0.0580743439,
0.0067294212,
-0.0501200072,
0.0457708091,
0.0220625307,
-0.0303074848,
-0.0186244287,
0.0066348137,
0.0542689487,
0.0068215588,
0.0254521612,
0.029719606,
-0.0057878178,
0.0291152447,
0.0079441397,
-0.0262074508,
0.0451525114,
0.0127109895,
0.0472685993,
0.0392100774,
0.0218341537,
0.0154537959,
0.0093295816,
0.0140631152,
0.0007079478,
-0.0050813584,
0.0341072977,
-0.0179931596,
0.0278050192,
0.0126227308,
0.0348920599,
-0.0447657444,
0.0022762567,
0.0290435273,
-0.0085363556,
0.0397499464,
0.0144961197,
0.0764077902,
0.0092501994,
0.0199767724,
0.0168055948,
-0.0300302021,
0.0363647006,
-0.0403781869,
0.024890596,
0.0451140441,
-0.0000948042,
-0.0168980863,
-0.0542785116,
0.0015075767,
0.0237959251,
-0.035403356,
-0.0056269257,
0.0176941939,
0.0470856018,
-0.0364260897,
0.0058150003,
0.0102566462,
-0.072924532,
0.0319441818,
-0.0341667198,
0.0540744849,
0.059097968,
0.0983474404,
-0.0161169413,
-0.0171154905,
0.0093197059,
0.0107885767,
0.0439509414,
0.0370529555,
-0.0293772742,
-0.008378732,
-0.0384323038,
-0.0280790944,
-0.0048576673,
0.0020095645,
0.0135020297,
0.0219294,
-0.0057598464,
0.0408652835,
-0.0700467154,
-0.0302666947,
0.0373164974,
-0.038772624,
-0.0706852376,
-0.0017852826,
-0.005172391,
0.0169611406,
0.0355785117,
-0.0037853173,
0.0445579886,
0.0280244239,
-0.0205889735,
-0.0187704675,
0.0065888567,
-0.0562848784,
-0.0146789644,
-0.005671245,
-0.0307390597,
0.0008402647,
0.0161891859,
-0.0264669787,
-0.0461432077,
-0.0064669014,
-0.0500849523,
0.0158535689,
-0.0734311342,
-0.0323070548,
0.0433245748,
-0.0071720635,
-0.0556714274,
0.0728980675,
0.0198653527,
0.0031930357,
0.0627696961,
0.0256683119,
0.0321914926,
-0.036103718,
-0.0188433062,
-0.0319673046,
-0.0295162145,
-0.0075021898,
0.0416969955,
0.0077971239,
-0.0642840862,
0.0151688494,
-0.0925939903,
0.0061706603,
-0.0286741368,
0.0171221625,
0.0176081397,
0.0090387901,
-0.0124557782,
-0.0108100781,
-0.0377084166,
-0.0146911563,
0.0434749909,
0.0200815853,
0.0309057161,
0.0401848033,
0.0564430282,
-0.0395611078,
-0.0054509579,
-0.0119300289,
0.0550759844,
0.0604315773,
0.0403141491,
-0.0336597189,
0.0238137953,
-0.0685998574,
0.0043370537,
0.0037083742,
-0.0214270931,
0.0387916267,
-0.0352973603,
0.0273263324,
0.0172325224,
0.0219052508,
-0.0139031569,
0.0069583831,
-0.01694916,
-0.0867921934,
0.0299659576,
-0.0321520045,
-0.0348089784,
0.0048652641,
-0.0027573397,
-0.0004897708,
0.0134079652,
0.0410523899,
-0.0046373145,
-0.0411741026,
0.0222848244,
-0.0035311028,
-0.0614520274,
-0.0323114134,
-0.0070120911,
-0.0108656492,
0.0212628357,
-0.0090680933,
-0.0388131812,
0.0921811014,
-0.025005579,
-0.003830228,
-0.0557264686,
0.0171829797,
-0.0251595248,
0.0478309803,
-0.0231481493,
0.0067988462,
-0.0325686745,
0.0017427942,
-0.0531104729,
0.0197385568,
0.0286807418,
-0.0569148883,
0.0018777985,
-0.0559968911,
-0.00495655,
-0.0019536782,
-0.0110716913,
-0.0760587528,
0.0087195542,
0.002395194,
0.0030281085,
0.0022365027,
-0.0153584694,
-0.0222247727,
-0.0196471419,
0.0335939564,
0.0205309819,
-0.037272431,
-0.021561617,
-0.0175573323,
0.0688266382,
0.0832278281,
0.0290784184,
0.0173430014,
0.007331057,
-0.0184071697,
0.0475872569,
0.0384863168,
-0.0097424816,
0.0013085689,
-0.0128736561,
0.0121288318,
-0.0388013572,
0.0186616667,
0.0155318128,
0.0287241731,
-0.0525187813,
-0.0409168229,
0.0666663945,
0.0373828597,
-0.0274238493,
-0.019499464,
-0.0222015791,
0.0604157932,
0.0090201246,
0.0385768935,
-0.1165474877,
-0.033567775,
-0.0201330464,
0.0639305562,
-0.0021029238,
-0.0329148993,
-0.000463594,
-0.136283651,
0.0357090198,
-0.0051519084,
-0.0556211658,
-0.0108247306,
-0.0090526212,
0.0125494972,
0.0001904498,
-0.0151326172,
0.0596011989,
0.0007333196,
0.0343959294,
0.028894864,
0.0218718443,
-0.0077463328,
0.0068820608,
-0.01720424,
0.0125203179,
0.0775113627,
0.0026905276,
0.0264401026,
-0.0561068319,
0.0226941369,
-0.0564885177,
0.04089595,
-0.0121933827,
0.0404768474,
-0.0090917526,
0.0204396378,
-0.0398195535,
0.0210467242,
0.0046076262,
-0.0135458279,
0.0218240209,
0.0579320192,
-0.044016961,
0.0112073077,
-0.0651272759,
0.0180407017,
0.0172912385,
0.0671600476,
0.0268845297,
-0.0089663658,
-0.0321349539,
-0.0097983964,
0.0448540486,
-0.0928231329,
-0.014593049,
0.0322291441,
-0.0024386204,
-0.0004830293,
-0.1083909124,
-0.0479484312,
0.0087504899,
0.0397099406,
-0.0109388782,
-0.0147058172,
-0.068694219,
-0.0060566631,
-0.0555522293,
0.0308267549,
-0.0409268364,
-0.0206152573,
-0.0224535652,
-0.0405903794,
0.0184674766,
-0.0586035773,
-0.0186498296,
0.0535974056,
-0.0360927247,
-0.0320943892,
0.0044023036,
0.0609952882,
0.0315007381,
0.0230478048,
-0.0192907769,
-0.0147672184,
0.0630753264,
0.0503766984,
-0.0506564602,
0.014295036,
0.0003336082,
-0.0015513216,
-0.0240038838,
0.0167374387,
-0.0635081381,
0.0098566189,
-0.0350913517,
0.0598957241,
0.0349323638,
-0.0447465032,
0.0342011787,
0.0188434012,
0.0245839432,
-0.0212231092,
-0.0285515357,
-0.0128107304,
0.0106843049,
-0.0039343103,
-0.0200033486,
-0.0260985773,
0.0224857535,
-0.0121176718,
0.010028163,
0.0094457576,
0.0045714066,
-0.0084354505,
0.0917274579,
-0.0317780524,
-0.0349384956,
0.0633239895,
0.0116067166,
-0.0230098609,
-0.004716313,
-0.0254030563,
0.0065957047,
-0.0276527628,
0.0755118728,
-0.0132204611,
0.0630434677,
0.018682085,
-0.0100066625,
0.0408301689,
0.0332114957,
-0.0769248456,
-0.0143389702,
-0.0559561886,
-0.0002213174,
0.0115831699,
0.0110328868,
0.0256380513,
-0.0155056017,
-0.0027543604,
-0.0060644145,
0.0232446659,
0.020901382,
-0.0161037166,
-0.0016303596,
0.039427869,
0.0020599759,
0.0127077857,
0.0360427573,
-0.0169398896,
0.0439159684,
-0.0356104895,
-0.026295064,
-0.0498816706,
-0.0701946318,
-0.0320265517,
0.0344980881,
-0.0061239633,
-0.0149991969,
-0.0512260608,
-0.0501493551,
-0.0097710323,
0.0502335764,
-0.001351521,
-0.0020780216,
0.0563803278,
0.0727668777,
-0.0104680005,
-0.0259145033,
-0.0493482873,
0.0408859178,
-0.083936125,
-0.0029388992,
-0.0249752868,
-6.088431113e-33,
-0.0415282175,
-0.0379632525,
0.0548692346,
-0.0407217965,
-0.0392730124,
-0.0144589087,
-0.0394227616,
0.0045313756,
-0.0229065027,
-0.0096836137,
0.002596583,
-0.0156992376,
0.0060675475,
0.0229090881,
0.0117927575,
-0.0229094662,
0.0230378471,
0.0321434364,
-0.0479735509,
0.0448510833,
0.0667969882,
0.0017241223,
0.0311628673,
-0.0660141408,
0.0347475335,
-0.0384737551,
-0.011752828,
-0.001126215,
-0.045400124,
0.0806118175,
-0.0172987469,
0.0370471478,
0.0147437407,
-0.0155419363,
0.0097421389,
0.0163554847,
-0.0713594332,
-0.0380759723,
0.006748118,
-0.0263637342,
-0.0740857795,
-0.020397149,
0.0263640154,
-0.0283668526,
-0.009249826,
0.0095733693,
0.035626661,
-0.0202896334,
0.0094631147,
-0.0515271686,
-0.053214442,
0.0180117767,
0.0097738337,
-0.0137279406,
-0.0545291305,
0.1272406876,
0.0334984697,
0.0220939443,
-0.038105756,
0.0235476438,
0.0003540164,
0.0456433855,
0.0718737543,
-0.0150000034,
-0.0308399983,
0.0312941298,
0.000314249,
-0.0480194911,
-0.0216724146,
-0.0077305338,
0.014023928,
0.0596059076,
0.0448311344,
0.0965276435,
0.0116371689,
0.0154016949,
-0.0332730189,
0.0876373425,
-0.003930138,
0.0586092845,
-0.0034412097,
-0.015317956,
-0.0376261547,
0.0202351101,
-0.0309930779,
0.0035101888,
-0.0451718122,
-0.047120098,
0.0590457693,
0.0190937724,
-0.0443503559,
0.0193638001,
0.0424039811,
-0.0071141799,
0.0433376953,
0.0381449945,
-0.0387545452,
-0.0026040864,
-0.0093556382,
0.0035066227,
-0.0026946969,
0.0150396116,
0.0672749579,
0.0046670842,
0.010085552,
-0.0072566266,
0.0172458589,
0.0264267791,
-0.0264365505,
0.0050394754,
-0.0331091471,
0.0476324558,
-0.0429487228,
-0.0584780648,
0.0175878555,
0.0203222129,
-0.0219002943,
0.0108548542,
-0.0026801338,
0.0315866135,
-0.0396917276,
-0.0424182341,
0.020991262,
-0.0239088926,
-0.0262340736,
0.0359560549,
-0.0022000375,
0.0250643399,
-0.019550493,
-0.0344470888,
-0.0004651638,
0.0482742079,
2.547e-7,
0.0669910237,
-0.0064596273,
0.0576961339,
0.0103920074,
-0.010542498,
0.0101954676,
0.0177796483,
0.0153682726,
0.039516706,
-0.0110974098,
0.0234203562,
0.0094950125,
0.0415862687,
0.0400643013,
-0.0914156437,
-0.053139843,
-0.059596438,
-0.0107007008,
-0.0563293695,
-0.0165011026,
0.0972313285,
0.0306221507,
-0.0050718253,
-0.0308975745,
0.0033305453,
-0.0325333327,
0.0404075161,
0.0225807372,
-0.0083850771,
0.0064445478,
0.0452040806,
0.0019155858,
0.0276789907,
-0.0060625365,
-0.0184554197,
-0.0072057769,
0.0136677781,
0.0176629145,
0.0246517193,
-0.0772770569,
-0.0076212264,
0.0022690685,
0.0516043417,
-0.041418042,
0.0536320619,
-0.0071928543,
0.0208587348,
-0.0054505412,
-0.0675785318,
0.0000034678,
0.0047462294,
0.0062886961,
-0.0292553976,
0.0027253444,
0.0026136546,
0.023248516,
-0.0184760746,
-0.063470982,
-0.0363411568,
0.0098815281,
-0.0463780873,
-0.0476954877,
-0.0390718915,
-0.0064394209,
-0.0295749884,
-0.077730149,
0.0006231389,
2.205835353e-34,
0.0267229341,
0.0142099392,
0.0141258212,
0.0125560351,
0.0454759449,
0.0177740753,
-0.0344803333,
0.0173994042,
0.0272028353,
-0.0798649117,
-0.0310794711
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09473v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09473v1 | JAB: Joint Adversarial Prompting and Belief Augmentation | 2023-11-16T00:35:54 | 2023-11-16T00:35:54 | Ninareh Mehrabi, Palash Goyal, Anil Ramakrishna, Jwala Dhamala, Shalini Ghosh, Richard Zemel, Kai-Wei Chang, Aram Galstyan, Rahul Gupta | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | With the recent surge of language models in different applications, attention
to safety and robustness of these models has gained significant importance.
Here we introduce a joint framework in which we simultaneously probe and
improve the robustness of a black-box target model via adversarial prompting
and belief augmentation using iterative feedback loops. This framework utilizes
an automated red teaming approach to probe the target model, along with a
belief augmenter to generate instructions for the target model to improve its
robustness to those adversarial probes. Importantly, the adversarial model and
the belief generator leverage the feedback from past interactions to improve
the effectiveness of the adversarial prompts and beliefs, respectively. In our
experiments, we demonstrate that such a framework can reduce toxic content
generation both in dynamic cases where an adversary directly interacts with a
target model and static cases where we use a static benchmark dataset to
evaluate our model. | [
0.0476451218,
0.0853430778,
-0.0048062671,
0.0248605534,
-0.0213398356,
-0.0023709536,
-0.0047028651,
-0.0243787039,
0.0312781818,
-0.0433503091,
-0.0411678217,
-0.0146760009,
-0.019735774,
0.0674526691,
0.0442716219,
-0.0223807544,
0.0707845092,
0.0006547136,
-0.0146648698,
-0.0039779022,
0.0224331953,
-0.0016522169,
0.0055774907,
0.0283758808,
-0.0312487558,
-0.0016612842,
-0.0200600028,
0.0266771447,
0.0065082777,
-0.0278840195,
-0.002784549,
0.041215837,
0.0117252776,
0.0982630774,
0.0000021282,
-0.0170018319,
-0.0418562256,
0.0061335014,
-0.0363267697,
0.013404442,
0.0348235331,
-0.0446166322,
-0.0415287018,
0.0311968476,
-0.0432467498,
-0.0036780622,
0.0484143198,
0.0472734571,
0.0751623884,
0.0756819323,
0.0027364453,
0.02794482,
0.0576350652,
-0.0409625359,
-0.0176470056,
-0.0273602847,
0.0366537608,
-0.0050313538,
-0.0316355638,
0.0320122428,
-0.003386999,
0.0086260615,
0.0582431927,
-0.0006749848,
-0.0485347882,
0.0122056371,
0.0152786151,
-0.0315308981,
-0.0237045176,
0.03408546,
-0.0215099324,
-0.0299571902,
-0.0275822654,
0.006466866,
-0.0000395317,
0.024825532,
-0.0190513358,
-0.0044316598,
-0.0085295001,
-0.0041146721,
0.003863862,
-0.0065184999,
0.0778516829,
0.019880712,
0.0253577419,
0.0642492622,
0.0058035273,
-0.0434538759,
-0.0308868997,
-0.0090282066,
-0.0270424783,
-0.0582424887,
-0.0110037997,
-0.0045212782,
-0.0026794942,
0.0231711976,
-0.0878932402,
-0.0615941919,
0.0156594664,
-0.023840148,
0.0274276808,
-0.0035445946,
-0.0310265981,
0.0189391766,
-0.0355645902,
-0.0138450125,
-0.0181289706,
0.034248203,
-0.0070004184,
0.0303636789,
-0.0209818147,
-0.0210942719,
-0.0187692475,
0.0043127639,
0.0046266094,
-0.0056824251,
-0.030029051,
0.0360469073,
-0.0372239463,
0.0469115935,
-0.0553476773,
0.0066380869,
-0.0444089435,
-0.0079184789,
0.0116223861,
-0.0157623626,
-0.0257553961,
0.005793578,
0.0093543632,
-0.0875962824,
-0.0354899727,
0.0306477174,
-0.0607991554,
-0.0263776202,
-0.0142631372,
0.1112908274,
-0.0007557628,
-0.0246882774,
-0.014531781,
-0.0456668772,
-0.0253637042,
-0.0345516466,
0.0148192048,
-0.0420228615,
-0.0205174517,
-0.0384509489,
-0.0409466922,
-0.082303606,
0.0180515796,
-0.019676961,
-0.0283469781,
0.1061249524,
-0.0116179492,
-0.0624147095,
-0.0023075405,
0.036618229,
-0.021648217,
0.0663045198,
0.0094781928,
0.0608526245,
0.0262105055,
0.0324881971,
0.0218941923,
0.0425198302,
0.0617419481,
0.0287879258,
-0.0462529548,
-0.0199824944,
0.0209840145,
0.0026265008,
-0.0312347692,
0.0547112674,
-0.035110224,
-0.0156059312,
0.0747533068,
-0.0204481259,
-0.063114278,
0.0116211073,
0.0306827333,
-0.007725005,
-0.0258410443,
0.0507380366,
-0.0806429684,
0.0190126803,
-0.0865178257,
-0.0476391129,
0.0241245199,
0.0350971036,
-0.012660794,
-0.0447730608,
0.0091745974,
-0.0111772334,
0.0652229562,
-0.0051773689,
0.0354595669,
0.0486568324,
-0.0542876646,
-0.0260241535,
0.0271945279,
-0.0342056379,
-0.0094634872,
-0.0808857754,
0.0255893786,
0.0138436863,
0.0848064348,
-0.0232449304,
-0.0046474752,
-0.0339662209,
-0.0011375383,
0.0352410376,
0.0309313461,
0.011882822,
-0.0141298221,
-0.033835154,
-0.0313699096,
-0.0137419626,
0.0276841987,
0.0514130145,
0.0262721404,
-0.0253599808,
-0.0005637875,
0.0459889472,
-0.0108498968,
0.0389325432,
0.0263006333,
-0.0250721686,
-0.0089510605,
0.0132096224,
0.0493251719,
0.0158117972,
-0.0184773002,
0.0199821666,
0.0568856671,
-0.0067909178,
-0.0287536718,
0.0213125609,
0.0020389226,
-0.0343577489,
0.0167646464,
-0.0097329104,
-0.0109576685,
0.0504267365,
-0.0166489575,
-0.0177813098,
0.047156848,
-0.0331382044,
0.0215122234,
-0.0363304019,
0.0041334936,
-0.026163917,
0.0408118069,
-0.0228620116,
0.044469215,
-0.0170694254,
-0.027460577,
-0.0156744737,
0.0240635779,
-0.0037180304,
-0.030114729,
-0.0214741118,
-0.0130630983,
-0.0063402243,
0.0105375303,
0.0373833105,
-0.0198627133,
-0.0073621552,
-0.0236513279,
-0.0029159503,
-0.0186336972,
-0.0291576795,
-0.007355832,
0.0225849524,
-0.0035413879,
0.0035654167,
-0.0072105522,
-0.0128256259,
0.0020935407,
0.0154568041,
0.0352847278,
-0.0056978413,
0.0144520346,
-0.0247981269,
-0.0236379039,
-0.0051834909,
-0.0050149765,
0.0404239595,
0.0357687846,
-0.0603425913,
-0.0128137469,
0.0124785174,
-0.0264960248,
0.0419166163,
-0.0288716052,
-0.0709609985,
0.0449905582,
-0.004809882,
0.0078890733,
0.0542967059,
0.0230674352,
0.0403768718,
0.0601622425,
0.0604000539,
-0.0425967462,
0.0013042933,
-0.021347316,
-0.0325979777,
0.0136733204,
-0.0316149294,
0.0185731128,
0.0637899116,
0.0304217208,
-0.0209700894,
-0.0519263893,
0.0448294878,
0.0156794302,
-0.068470411,
0.0017503294,
-0.0842510387,
-0.0295809507,
0.0145985615,
-0.0516135022,
-0.0814588293,
0.12883313,
-0.032893993,
0.0139812725,
-0.0175274089,
-0.0086095901,
0.0348824821,
0.0341278948,
0.0319341496,
0.0011104961,
0.0438522808,
0.0242566708,
-0.0339365155,
-0.0161568932,
0.0177100729,
-0.0190727711,
0.0006049302,
-0.0222437251,
-0.0147273773,
0.0345619135,
-0.0031046569,
-0.0847750977,
-0.0344495475,
-0.0151472092,
-0.0048049032,
0.0045025963,
-0.0051970724,
-0.0356548876,
-0.0166403968,
0.0310153347,
-0.0062524537,
-0.0251812674,
-0.0055323183,
-0.0266725551,
-0.017713597,
0.0446945615,
-0.0613050461,
0.0596510507,
-0.0513239428,
0.0352604762,
0.0861913562,
0.0107724248,
0.0393891819,
-0.0279310625,
-0.0369493142,
-0.0044383346,
0.0524781756,
-0.003155018,
0.0183068831,
0.0297190342,
-0.0402422212,
-0.0028365734,
0.0592798553,
0.0151603306,
-0.0163750798,
0.02143877,
0.0052174386,
0.0366924889,
-0.0022049625,
0.0029778145,
-0.0951799601,
-0.0234827604,
0.0124976728,
0.0304354373,
-0.0388372317,
-0.0323260985,
-0.0123432223,
-0.1157128215,
-0.007935199,
0.0144701805,
0.008094158,
-0.0019630077,
-0.0246394593,
0.0001956024,
-0.0046598623,
0.0441937856,
-0.0064292294,
0.0462012962,
0.0010671909,
0.0133722974,
0.024303915,
-0.0501406044,
-0.0322442688,
-0.0535473078,
0.0701250061,
0.0946782753,
-0.0108853923,
-0.0225321837,
0.0055527943,
0.0231078584,
0.0483328365,
-0.0031102027,
0.0140077416,
0.0578638874,
-0.0364998728,
-0.0089621041,
0.0082647903,
0.0467421301,
0.0106582521,
-0.017307803,
0.0127971852,
0.0240296144,
-0.0178042874,
-0.0146806398,
-0.022604607,
0.0342208743,
0.054374177,
0.0856014416,
0.0203406699,
-0.0430007093,
0.0181816146,
-0.0567921884,
0.0337317102,
-0.0627066121,
-0.033713039,
0.0108827967,
-0.0183783881,
-0.0357211791,
-0.0733475015,
-0.0330702104,
-0.0105119543,
0.0401276201,
0.0017928411,
-0.0184923448,
-0.0639355704,
-0.0132915974,
-0.0104339616,
0.0237964541,
0.006532297,
0.0387375429,
-0.0511171669,
-0.0093047498,
-0.0148823513,
-0.0615294352,
-0.0037652615,
0.0582742877,
-0.0606170483,
-0.0862659663,
0.0252251606,
0.071034357,
0.0184685439,
0.0638081506,
-0.0488797612,
-0.0583937541,
0.043883305,
0.0329845436,
-0.0154936071,
0.0025093772,
0.0813639835,
-0.0057264753,
0.0181204919,
0.0280681401,
-0.03263456,
0.0381960049,
0.0514694825,
-0.0149006564,
-0.0520094968,
-0.0084451241,
0.0455174223,
0.0270013493,
0.0808747038,
-0.0475495532,
0.0173165351,
0.009095164,
-0.004228903,
-0.032131508,
-0.0197212249,
-0.0303061195,
0.0338554569,
0.0272437111,
-0.0085931001,
0.0124107702,
-0.0202624574,
-0.0237193368,
0.0473727807,
-0.0524275973,
0.0055742138,
0.0220746044,
0.0534581058,
0.0509346612,
0.012643734,
-0.0012880474,
0.0447463989,
-0.0011024453,
-0.0082470691,
0.0067549548,
0.0206460468,
0.0473055132,
-0.0086392658,
0.0005737395,
0.0335689858,
-0.0670765787,
-0.0100830672,
-0.0105336644,
0.0436201766,
0.0195372254,
0.0453849286,
0.0192072336,
-0.035323564,
-0.0181244351,
-0.0042323852,
0.0051482762,
0.0067483908,
-0.073636122,
0.0259501822,
0.0131311789,
-0.0205175541,
0.0327797234,
0.0463572145,
-0.0111635057,
0.0781698227,
-0.0084432559,
-0.0075340481,
-0.0432724543,
-0.0237439275,
0.0317048393,
0.0394808725,
-0.0234039053,
0.0267474391,
-0.0187821742,
-0.0728561357,
-0.024998961,
0.0435458794,
0.0093007144,
-0.0058958703,
0.009809834,
0.0491471626,
0.0008672373,
0.0344964564,
-0.0278224293,
0.0098507153,
0.0351632684,
-0.0518526472,
0.015996702,
-6.528614075e-33,
-0.002789533,
-0.0246580634,
-0.0404504724,
-0.0218716376,
0.007094326,
0.0135570802,
-0.0145243453,
-0.0119268745,
-0.0156881325,
0.0124260504,
0.019025892,
0.0065407534,
-0.0053020795,
0.0224257465,
-0.0302738175,
-0.0176124051,
0.0556742586,
-0.0176013838,
-0.0485012792,
-0.0042840973,
0.0463430285,
0.0087861856,
0.0211099405,
-0.0651391447,
0.0633102357,
0.0161404386,
-0.077395983,
0.0241812319,
-0.0491431914,
0.0601300932,
0.0121477395,
0.0160604138,
-0.0114464052,
-0.0228685439,
-0.0155184818,
0.0463561974,
-0.0177444331,
-0.0033694468,
0.0133898873,
-0.0154873626,
-0.0749681816,
-0.0157029983,
0.0335113518,
-0.0304852705,
-0.0102832913,
0.0195503049,
-0.0126670217,
-0.018820392,
-0.0116532361,
-0.0061790855,
-0.0208015274,
0.011383662,
0.0080339648,
-0.0380433425,
0.0166243371,
0.0395979173,
0.0304853115,
-0.0189231094,
-0.0527252182,
0.0246838164,
0.0092912074,
0.000937716,
0.0573905632,
0.0178787727,
0.0053486875,
0.072328046,
0.0039766449,
0.0160436966,
-0.0712500513,
-0.0056257844,
0.0197086763,
0.0134561323,
0.0827858895,
0.084145993,
0.005220606,
-0.0235736519,
-0.0492363162,
0.0172345638,
0.0653549358,
0.0224740207,
0.0335811637,
0.0080402223,
-0.0643122494,
-0.0097346166,
-0.0347670279,
-0.0462111756,
-0.0247148741,
-0.0604838133,
-0.0022841066,
0.0444406234,
-0.0830364302,
-0.0115066869,
-0.0018101585,
-0.0451145954,
0.0418766886,
0.0507419221,
-0.0162003674,
-0.0378188454,
-0.0126519902,
0.0266361292,
-0.0288547501,
0.0381606743,
0.0472514331,
-0.0316022299,
0.0102159977,
0.0145144509,
0.0615408979,
0.040663477,
-0.0430291295,
-0.0038032392,
-0.034374848,
0.0659989715,
0.032241486,
-0.0293287411,
0.0392169319,
0.0093144933,
-0.0207696036,
-0.0089632589,
0.0376659967,
-0.0014406617,
-0.0379235037,
0.0316603705,
-0.0368784517,
0.0236526411,
-0.0333396532,
-0.0105026858,
-0.0060879812,
-0.0555742197,
0.0470534563,
-0.1002068222,
-0.0120715974,
-0.044967521,
2.919e-7,
-0.0035140393,
0.0425692201,
0.0380617976,
0.016272394,
0.0337687694,
0.0596431009,
-0.0155138103,
0.0459171683,
-0.0148219354,
-0.0509709306,
-0.0270318966,
0.0308299027,
0.0387107283,
0.0328856409,
-0.0064575258,
-0.0185898971,
-0.0987390876,
0.0320395678,
-0.0272603631,
-0.0179090835,
0.0398859754,
0.1029131114,
0.0568202883,
-0.0147236511,
-0.0011044537,
-0.0231408812,
0.0346990898,
-0.0135364383,
-0.0262509175,
0.0091508292,
0.0199059602,
0.002592175,
-0.003943841,
0.0282950196,
-0.0268974341,
-0.0198229812,
-0.009368768,
0.0273923855,
0.0085680652,
-0.018486701,
-0.0223729834,
-0.0090607218,
-0.0057928297,
-0.0212978814,
0.0754025057,
-0.0367142819,
-0.0243784357,
-0.0330537073,
-0.0330894366,
-0.0190359093,
0.0148543855,
-0.0285547767,
-0.0489141271,
0.0049829069,
0.0124266492,
0.0336777642,
0.0050449991,
-0.0464425944,
-0.0437191725,
-0.0374277383,
-0.0491006672,
-0.0331324786,
-0.0059545808,
-0.0186314341,
0.0035373517,
-0.0411123149,
-0.0012891464,
2.887918016e-34,
0.0333708264,
-0.0423740298,
0.0062786252,
-0.0379828624,
0.0291125551,
-0.0084525067,
-0.0042016441,
0.0052936776,
0.0550897233,
-0.0349077992,
-0.026284568
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09469v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09469v1 | Clarify When Necessary: Resolving Ambiguity Through Interaction with LMs | 2023-11-16T00:18:50 | 2023-11-16T00:18:50 | Michael J. Q. Zhang, Eunsol Choi | cs.CL | cs.CL | Resolving ambiguities through interaction is a hallmark of natural language,
and modeling this behavior is a core challenge in crafting AI assistants. In
this work, we study such behavior in LMs by proposing a task-agnostic framework
for resolving ambiguity by asking users clarifying questions. Our framework
breaks down this objective into three subtasks: (1) determining when
clarification is needed, (2) determining what clarifying question to ask, and
(3) responding accurately with the new information gathered through
clarification. We evaluate systems across three NLP applications: question
answering, machine translation and natural language inference. For the first
subtask, we present a novel uncertainty estimation approach, intent-sim, that
determines the utility of querying for clarification by estimating the entropy
over user intents. Our method consistently outperforms existing uncertainty
estimation approaches at identifying predictions that will benefit from
clarification. When only allowed to ask for clarification on 10% of examples,
our system is able to double the performance gains over randomly selecting
examples to clarify. Furthermore, we find that intent-sim is robust,
demonstrating improvements across a wide range of NLP tasks and LMs. Together,
our work lays foundation for studying clarifying interactions with LMs. | [
0.070614174,
0.0335981734,
-0.0200004373,
0.0479836501,
-0.0210392848,
-0.0071430998,
-0.0229621585,
0.0025792762,
-0.0047659189,
-0.0343656577,
0.0271219239,
-0.0580023415,
0.0054413853,
-0.0291616209,
0.0021244681,
-0.0804915205,
0.0205445327,
-0.0356244072,
0.031857837,
0.0051362561,
0.0090135885,
0.0089710075,
-0.0032628865,
0.0332214274,
-0.018267855,
0.0023309113,
-0.0469606183,
0.0631479919,
0.0118871164,
-0.0075742719,
-0.0179101713,
0.0380931161,
0.0111328233,
0.0057423073,
0.00000186,
-0.0568374507,
-0.0109441373,
-0.0076190783,
-0.0660685152,
-0.03003495,
0.009694404,
0.0304982793,
0.0151072191,
0.0352658741,
-0.0392328314,
0.0343241766,
0.0350014865,
-0.0187108852,
0.0242808573,
0.0173914768,
-0.0008389913,
-0.0071470747,
-0.0317978263,
-0.0180650894,
0.0665755346,
-0.0880629867,
0.0059481119,
-0.0327780843,
-0.0155342612,
0.0198040754,
0.0262600332,
0.0454720147,
0.0172275994,
0.0050955224,
-0.0122213122,
0.0064609041,
0.0817972347,
-0.0484179631,
-0.006234746,
0.0631651208,
0.0408154204,
0.0095586479,
-0.0211592242,
-0.0222100373,
0.0182364658,
0.0209939405,
-0.0023770721,
0.0091401441,
-0.0284242555,
-0.0299451258,
0.0068401359,
0.0203532502,
0.0339806117,
0.0654448494,
-0.0143885575,
0.0412974581,
-0.0266316161,
-0.0263956208,
0.0148303211,
-0.0143692801,
-0.0483528748,
-0.0598188452,
0.0032562807,
0.0865137875,
-0.069228515,
0.0495304726,
-0.021786686,
-0.0186630189,
0.0363038108,
-0.0284151286,
-0.0046566059,
0.0390317068,
0.0146883046,
0.0545628481,
0.0470725112,
0.0079834843,
0.0222030599,
0.0107710427,
-0.0428891778,
-0.0479807854,
-0.0216196943,
-0.0025338044,
-0.0461668074,
0.0267580412,
-0.0329463296,
0.0068174205,
-0.0099635664,
0.0487482473,
-0.0123092392,
0.0456236601,
-0.0075193993,
0.024421392,
-0.0351538695,
-0.0233385693,
-0.060945414,
0.0054623173,
-0.066713959,
0.0475364774,
0.0305096172,
-0.081440717,
-0.0312915854,
0.0211295485,
-0.0153158167,
-0.00217434,
0.0019161537,
0.0434898138,
0.0066049132,
-0.0416184328,
-0.0431035645,
-0.0501486287,
-0.0086965766,
-0.0449752621,
-0.0286489241,
-0.0251821633,
0.0356064104,
0.013547698,
-0.0021138908,
-0.0455176905,
0.0182634797,
0.0082214344,
-0.0339239649,
0.1129315123,
-0.0283301845,
0.0317323096,
0.0444821678,
0.0296858139,
-0.0573391542,
0.0662125424,
0.0256129522,
0.0235051885,
0.0669347793,
0.0148562118,
0.0222617537,
-0.0008537394,
-0.0044637737,
-0.0005232672,
0.0126930252,
0.0174146947,
-0.1096411794,
0.0464236401,
-0.0022873112,
0.0641105697,
0.0017501017,
-0.0098815681,
0.0610024855,
0.0549333766,
-0.0304823164,
-0.024283072,
0.0298051946,
0.0419903137,
0.0092958855,
0.0060614757,
-0.0542391129,
0.0162298456,
-0.0417683162,
0.0132975997,
0.0235703979,
-0.025312487,
-0.0273138378,
-0.0872111171,
-0.0269084033,
-0.0007426481,
0.0274196565,
0.0605011545,
0.0189153627,
0.002934895,
-0.0111107901,
0.0447093509,
-0.0095726158,
-0.0203471556,
-0.0007667831,
-0.0546708815,
0.0261822008,
0.0787623301,
0.0405894034,
-0.0435323156,
-0.0483089462,
-0.0190985445,
0.0004062502,
0.0491392165,
0.0242251139,
-0.0048078625,
0.0752315074,
-0.0317900777,
0.0050574024,
0.0140899364,
0.0258541703,
-0.0330314524,
0.041918017,
-0.002190907,
0.0202154201,
-0.0618231744,
0.0074007674,
0.0346162394,
0.0404346287,
-0.0227239653,
0.0267272424,
0.004986634,
0.042819351,
0.0420121588,
0.0147288544,
-0.0051829424,
0.0372563638,
0.0141615355,
-0.0414363295,
0.0254710261,
-0.0052699232,
-0.0010690703,
0.0382687375,
0.0250746366,
-0.0554558374,
-0.0075944643,
-0.0631743446,
-0.0169643629,
-0.0129197575,
-0.0222177394,
0.0083477106,
-0.029377589,
-0.0082912976,
0.0059303581,
-0.0343591832,
-0.0568913631,
0.0497595295,
-0.0260804035,
0.0098090786,
0.0349174738,
-0.0070315427,
-0.0028284737,
-0.0269622207,
0.0071216431,
-0.0239876583,
0.0031856154,
-0.0120650223,
0.0088201724,
0.0270654988,
-0.0458270162,
-0.0142837483,
-0.0503938608,
-0.0049923859,
-0.0319456607,
0.0148419132,
0.0179322828,
0.0457227789,
0.0031659682,
-0.0159551241,
0.0009029727,
0.0121644922,
-0.0275049359,
0.0047328053,
0.0621268302,
0.0178021211,
0.002714993,
-0.0534163192,
0.0360764451,
0.0033544204,
0.0091062486,
0.0176181253,
-0.0171488523,
-0.0832422078,
0.0450271703,
-0.0527774692,
0.0202030037,
-0.0091175474,
-0.0408303589,
0.0268584192,
-0.0346900858,
0.0007452578,
0.0430498347,
0.0337499753,
0.0359970182,
0.0576654151,
-0.0141046997,
-0.0680889785,
0.0452135354,
-0.0162722915,
-0.0106012058,
-0.0294013508,
-0.0564431585,
0.0136527782,
0.0263946373,
-0.0126754902,
0.007266358,
-0.0279790014,
-0.013832463,
0.0005708541,
-0.019772524,
-0.0190259553,
0.0248583164,
-0.0198246706,
0.07137952,
-0.0075816144,
-0.0286739189,
0.1112627536,
-0.0029772227,
-0.0081267701,
-0.0398710854,
-0.0092342449,
-0.0089206519,
0.0721679553,
-0.0405182466,
0.0021259142,
0.0163088348,
-0.0047950237,
-0.0427536778,
-0.0241902843,
0.0495257266,
-0.0369960777,
0.0550176613,
-0.0934934691,
-0.0084095448,
-0.0055543515,
-0.0064862096,
-0.0455910042,
-0.0346430019,
-0.0391481146,
-0.0167095251,
0.0496195331,
-0.0247496106,
0.0189022291,
-0.0332657285,
0.008252725,
-0.0110107074,
0.004245095,
-0.050915096,
-0.0250607207,
-0.0042847432,
0.0623418726,
0.0700081736,
0.0165912751,
-0.0192850046,
0.0309072491,
0.0304179452,
0.0150755718,
-0.0412838459,
-0.0249465946,
-0.03404627,
0.0468875989,
-0.0236039832,
0.0225898996,
0.0656353012,
0.1009111479,
-0.0155570032,
0.0058242125,
0.1398000121,
0.0472159348,
-0.0307880677,
-0.0186685119,
-0.0518125854,
0.0229781251,
-0.0077110352,
0.0262575783,
-0.0711908713,
-0.0819795653,
0.0144957267,
0.0439751595,
-0.004215165,
-0.0105579933,
-0.012425676,
-0.0721773654,
0.0083554527,
-0.0329779424,
-0.042349726,
-0.0451842025,
-0.0247537736,
0.0154367825,
-0.0252614748,
0.043427784,
-0.0117533337,
0.0058631101,
-0.0150859682,
-0.007401255,
-0.0265883263,
-0.0521290377,
-0.012552497,
-0.0474883616,
0.0562042035,
0.0430064797,
0.0129065607,
0.0194803458,
-0.0073549203,
-0.0082209967,
-0.0189505164,
0.0079461839,
-0.054288961,
0.0454007164,
0.0139739495,
0.0116029717,
-0.0212836806,
0.0135313245,
-0.0287591182,
0.0089019937,
0.0127379661,
0.0128658433,
-0.0544571392,
0.0229421668,
-0.0052091079,
0.0127237355,
0.043533206,
0.0971287116,
0.0174180046,
-0.0206274614,
-0.0278400071,
-0.0443969741,
0.0122007709,
-0.0158615988,
0.039412301,
-0.0148547757,
-0.0065802983,
-0.0128179509,
-0.0517636873,
-0.0537208989,
0.0172258541,
0.0169553123,
-0.0048737447,
0.0176107585,
0.0507816188,
0.0148145249,
-0.0260020625,
0.0028076954,
-0.0049359794,
0.026439853,
0.0029048696,
-0.0182446968,
0.0022078245,
-0.0133465556,
0.0046428265,
0.0572647564,
-0.0904661864,
-0.0641194731,
-0.0041399468,
0.0618766434,
0.0334884226,
0.0469786189,
-0.0666419789,
-0.0531840697,
-0.0380815156,
0.0170042347,
-0.0164293703,
-0.006558232,
0.0518229716,
0.0691589117,
-0.0079740854,
0.0649084598,
-0.0570621267,
-0.0297251381,
-0.0260477029,
0.0226867013,
-0.090120323,
-0.1333449334,
0.0130050397,
0.0144828893,
0.0063072164,
-0.013240573,
-0.0220780335,
0.0133808367,
0.0238143019,
0.0075067426,
-0.0305332392,
-0.0306602083,
-0.0166813564,
-0.0055534178,
-0.0442161188,
-0.0156704653,
0.0209350865,
-0.0346374176,
0.0108163683,
-0.0012261961,
-0.0266533121,
-0.0154569708,
0.0207518134,
-0.0079867588,
-0.0128535498,
-0.0110730836,
0.0335607342,
-0.0141719971,
0.0438742489,
0.0520247594,
0.0460356437,
0.0215122327,
-0.0215529725,
-0.0109763965,
0.0231295675,
-0.0443812199,
-0.1111315116,
0.0224403068,
0.0171191078,
0.0564134866,
0.0253663659,
0.0472419746,
-0.0413822941,
0.020219503,
0.0000379957,
0.0417055823,
0.0446777269,
-0.021484131,
0.0716173053,
0.0336924195,
0.0026367235,
0.0291345827,
0.0669651553,
-0.0601553954,
0.0337567069,
-0.0107853245,
-0.0422618277,
-0.0242967475,
-0.0299815424,
-0.0161825828,
0.0379742794,
-0.0290934332,
0.0157903805,
-0.0395768248,
-0.0473217517,
-0.0058303587,
-0.0177684221,
0.0079229353,
-0.0346719138,
0.052986946,
0.0732058808,
0.0318149365,
-0.0434252322,
-0.0341045521,
-0.0057018944,
-0.033887554,
-0.0071904589,
-0.0561396442,
-6.366933643e-33,
-0.0286685787,
-0.0535597838,
-0.003634207,
-0.0097952625,
-0.0079502808,
-0.0067171021,
-0.0523716286,
0.0197558589,
-0.067175366,
0.0146260681,
-0.0225638282,
0.0442733206,
0.0195898954,
-0.007456677,
0.013064309,
-0.0649292022,
0.0243108198,
0.0207076557,
0.0053565316,
-0.0232552607,
0.0159262568,
-0.0083700474,
-0.0046318192,
-0.031611938,
0.0590939373,
0.0177603103,
-0.054777693,
0.0657392517,
-0.0327371359,
0.0082080346,
-0.0007751607,
0.0546732359,
0.0025973704,
-0.0152829047,
0.0049459655,
0.0002284635,
-0.07061854,
-0.0374303795,
0.0291881058,
0.0219977144,
-0.0872848928,
-0.0293981377,
0.0515390374,
0.0166401826,
0.014724019,
0.0293204263,
0.0116960146,
-0.0057244273,
0.0084600765,
-0.0306574758,
0.0007693286,
0.0056000315,
-0.0201907251,
-0.0753064007,
0.0088564465,
0.0159937292,
0.0037390115,
-0.0266767088,
-0.0377604067,
-0.0086599607,
0.0010779377,
0.0175895765,
0.0431461893,
-0.005894247,
-0.0273561105,
0.0043178466,
-0.0392937548,
-0.0114352899,
-0.0368868746,
0.0008601918,
-0.0286282711,
0.0213431995,
0.0213742666,
0.047428254,
0.0406027474,
0.0117053995,
-0.0383400694,
0.0532585941,
0.0285944026,
0.0821797997,
-0.0112840664,
0.0091576623,
-0.0513213091,
0.0129834302,
-0.0534502715,
0.0112147294,
-0.0370005816,
-0.0140081393,
0.0012988655,
0.0174264777,
-0.0262398496,
-0.0257147569,
-0.005094544,
-0.0124536948,
0.0173679926,
-0.024413608,
-0.0005124691,
-0.0018425561,
0.0268013608,
-0.002735731,
-0.0057645864,
0.0134350406,
0.0454809628,
-0.0092084408,
-0.011747594,
0.026892107,
-0.0064452989,
0.0016955684,
-0.0206307936,
-0.0013471122,
-0.0350815281,
0.0444643125,
-0.0545387566,
-0.0366848782,
0.0264819488,
0.0109373936,
-0.033630833,
0.0338426866,
-0.0055118557,
0.0277762618,
-0.0203045532,
0.0161632393,
-0.0001404619,
-0.0126219485,
-0.030431686,
-0.0254526213,
0.018350482,
-0.0339525715,
-0.0177109782,
-0.0210426245,
-0.0273630582,
-0.0115584331,
2.624e-7,
0.0482808277,
0.0304827057,
0.0078711221,
0.1307437271,
0.0045416551,
0.0595813692,
0.0087783057,
-0.0149142547,
-0.001514218,
-0.0457371138,
0.0238347314,
0.04020904,
0.0597612076,
0.0279665552,
-0.0587349087,
-0.0558299385,
0.0258066412,
0.0226181466,
-0.0031558843,
0.0150703955,
0.0888157412,
0.0590054952,
0.0155787542,
0.0148821687,
-0.0043906677,
-0.0282255858,
0.0204771925,
-0.0513341874,
0.01968606,
0.011126874,
0.0772804543,
-0.0066973818,
0.0071878005,
0.0196373947,
-0.0140133025,
-0.0425617322,
-0.0478292331,
0.0657841787,
-0.0134665314,
-0.0334454738,
-0.0499842018,
-0.0186882727,
0.0637993142,
-0.0446035564,
0.0587419719,
-0.0142322257,
-0.0247524865,
0.0050103213,
0.0239184909,
-0.0222521685,
0.0058469456,
0.0076535339,
-0.0352802798,
-0.0170091037,
0.0042688386,
0.0025937378,
-0.0233295429,
-0.0615825467,
-0.024628168,
-0.0187753402,
-0.0260613728,
0.0090657854,
-0.0272155236,
-0.0074061626,
0.033520855,
-0.0713838637,
-0.0061125583,
1.919017946e-34,
0.0265114848,
0.0076034525,
0.0038729964,
0.0979557335,
0.049971804,
0.0382411927,
-0.0391756073,
0.0074055609,
0.044572778,
-0.0234075394,
0.0144103663
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09467v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09467v2 | Think While You Write: Hypothesis Verification Promotes Faithful Knowledge-to-Text Generation | 2023-11-16T00:13:19 | 2024-04-03T17:02:33 | Yifu Qiu, Varun Embar, Shay B. Cohen, Benjamin Han | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Knowledge-to-text generators often struggle to faithfully generate
descriptions for the input facts: they may produce hallucinations that
contradict the input, or describe facts not present in the input. To reduce
hallucinations, we propose a decoding-only method, TWEAK (Think While
Effectively Articulating Knowledge), which can be integrated with any generator
without retraining. TWEAK treats the generated sequences at each decoding step
and its future sequences as hypotheses, and ranks each generation candidate
based on the extent to which their hypotheses are supported by the input facts
using a Hypothesis Verification Model (HVM). We first demonstrate the
effectiveness of TWEAK by using a Natural Language Inference (NLI) model as the
HVM and report improved faithfulness with a minimal impact on the quality. We
then replace the NLI model with a task-specific HVM trained with a
first-of-a-kind dataset, FATE (Fact-Aligned Textual Entailment), which pairs
input facts with their original and perturbed descriptions. We test TWEAK with
two generators, and the best TWEAK variants improve on average for the two
models by 2.24/7.17 points in faithfulness (FactKB) in in/out-of-distribution
evaluations, respectively, and with only a 0.14/0.32-point decline in quality
(BERTScore). | [
0.004740133,
0.0523345172,
0.0180667285,
0.0064081778,
-0.0365284234,
0.009986572,
-0.0233328044,
-0.03026166,
0.00465276,
-0.0423024669,
0.0283890273,
-0.0203587543,
0.0257530399,
0.0180632137,
0.0637124851,
-0.0386987962,
0.0534179062,
0.0138779618,
-0.0068763578,
0.0107653374,
0.0043071215,
0.0395735428,
-0.0369943455,
0.0483075306,
-0.0495297462,
-0.0252686888,
-0.0190122854,
0.0132949604,
0.0534976684,
-0.0340573043,
-0.0161004029,
0.0637807623,
0.0048094038,
0.0120751671,
0.000002317,
-0.0647963956,
-0.0035545155,
-0.0023013181,
-0.0198563337,
-0.0091330521,
-0.0010367117,
-0.0101166535,
0.0045916364,
0.0087433932,
-0.010747591,
0.0169361066,
0.0131197479,
0.0667118281,
0.0549968742,
0.0768843964,
-0.0014881688,
-0.013798642,
0.0092474502,
0.0011073438,
0.0363629572,
0.0222957395,
0.0091592204,
0.009603342,
-0.0233644471,
-0.0054679145,
0.016756583,
0.0400506109,
0.021491481,
0.0060651028,
-0.0002619082,
0.0411151312,
-0.0318334885,
-0.0419575274,
0.0217531044,
0.0309386291,
0.0262166094,
-0.0590378009,
0.0074036019,
0.0196129922,
-0.008494758,
0.0373933911,
0.0253572911,
0.0711077228,
-0.061353758,
-0.0108705545,
0.0588139482,
0.0158709735,
0.0138026364,
-0.0122837136,
-0.007653872,
0.0331138,
0.0228289831,
-0.0585537739,
0.0082724104,
0.0276170056,
-0.0648457184,
-0.0889139697,
-0.0050145187,
0.0215148665,
-0.0090134377,
0.0080216555,
-0.0669784099,
-0.0509695858,
0.0219576899,
-0.0735923275,
-0.0205119774,
0.050874196,
-0.0329208523,
-0.0059971767,
-0.0354087166,
0.0199545473,
0.0103534134,
0.023747351,
-0.0363643207,
0.0125806062,
-0.0457759611,
-0.004299141,
-0.0314740017,
0.0390553698,
0.0236122999,
-0.0028573207,
-0.0134893395,
0.0109180734,
-0.0046304874,
0.0531149171,
-0.0670994744,
0.0082476735,
-0.043800164,
-0.0030177862,
-0.0580873191,
0.0211105943,
-0.0317479745,
0.0006926046,
0.0442779548,
-0.0098801116,
-0.0377000906,
0.0192159228,
-0.0017918472,
0.0162307359,
0.0221973844,
0.0185559448,
-0.0227066409,
0.0201054234,
-0.0558829829,
-0.0644688159,
-0.0168131813,
-0.0873599052,
-0.0366059057,
-0.0443981625,
0.0248347651,
0.0092718508,
-0.0374100395,
-0.026080085,
0.0095768468,
0.0328382961,
-0.0016901222,
0.0263173822,
-0.0420108847,
-0.0146536781,
0.010972417,
0.0198302884,
-0.0280263405,
0.0427844487,
0.00930693,
0.0310573019,
-0.0202385448,
0.0443244465,
-0.0000351708,
-0.0172084458,
0.0400432907,
-0.0111357383,
0.006807067,
0.0076892315,
0.0357118174,
0.0501254536,
0.0357081518,
0.0202543754,
-0.0381308794,
0.030243719,
0.0623750612,
-0.0096346876,
0.0361607522,
0.0363689959,
0.0531974807,
0.004141992,
0.0131685734,
0.0598440021,
-0.0466454923,
0.0261058975,
-0.0316630751,
0.0316762254,
0.0250912607,
0.0291266833,
-0.0189144462,
-0.052643165,
-0.0262928903,
0.0174772013,
-0.0373931378,
-0.0084537072,
0.0012419678,
0.045455344,
-0.0385668054,
0.0718265101,
0.0307875723,
-0.0507537015,
0.0257990025,
-0.0207950044,
0.0573884323,
0.0637379289,
0.0609377474,
0.011226166,
-0.033421278,
-0.0255758949,
0.0188133866,
0.0908867344,
0.0523273572,
-0.0041251043,
-0.0150784357,
-0.0348566286,
-0.0205371529,
-0.0268792938,
0.0273998994,
-0.0109474706,
-0.0109196687,
0.0380871408,
0.0340584591,
-0.0157599058,
0.0000258119,
0.0613800324,
0.015984457,
-0.0104087498,
-0.0192961544,
0.0141047891,
-0.0043728426,
-0.0004043445,
-0.0285435766,
0.008475787,
0.0006748539,
-0.0250666291,
-0.0220662374,
0.0380179435,
-0.061942324,
-0.1124232858,
0.0172678307,
-0.0426505208,
0.0071510915,
-0.008218443,
-0.0185472835,
-0.0331960358,
0.0035005796,
-0.044668097,
0.0248721968,
-0.0539662801,
-0.001524286,
0.024129251,
0.0022186653,
0.0225925334,
0.0868166089,
-0.0031262606,
-0.0327407755,
0.0106556015,
-0.0051260744,
0.0020481404,
-0.0279901866,
0.0280187614,
0.0076722261,
-0.0192445833,
0.0029312996,
0.0272178836,
0.0189521462,
-0.0459356271,
-0.0096494826,
-0.0782086253,
0.0233602114,
-0.0280841142,
0.0257693175,
0.0483580865,
-0.0284763891,
0.0037077868,
0.0346594304,
-0.0545048155,
-0.0108006438,
0.020347517,
-0.0300799161,
0.0554579534,
-0.0037795031,
-0.0105052078,
-0.0054743262,
0.0418876223,
-0.0181744769,
0.0558239296,
0.0357302092,
-0.0134346345,
-0.0654666349,
0.0596645549,
-0.0743393749,
-0.0101521797,
0.004138465,
-0.0091938293,
0.0367443226,
0.028492434,
0.0752631426,
0.014941277,
0.0610786937,
-0.0317443684,
0.0424250215,
0.010334189,
-0.0520359576,
0.0271248687,
-0.0199830923,
0.0105661443,
0.0147918733,
-0.045815289,
0.0329866074,
0.0394776762,
0.0358455665,
-0.0122124562,
-0.0664147735,
0.0005634357,
0.0044844509,
-0.0161600076,
-0.0030566659,
-0.0259296969,
0.0024551118,
0.0226975977,
-0.0367113575,
-0.0211426932,
0.0775358155,
-0.0619408526,
0.0223245956,
-0.0536369644,
0.0206829552,
0.0049798074,
0.0156500284,
-0.0028418002,
0.0292503089,
0.0542087927,
0.0294407196,
-0.0316505767,
0.0050418056,
0.0284655523,
-0.0118049523,
0.0256354362,
-0.0433378071,
0.0093686273,
-0.0097581809,
-0.0096278619,
-0.0821437314,
-0.0206154548,
0.0391471349,
-0.0219024643,
-0.0045596431,
-0.0044677183,
-0.0241455175,
-0.0100600962,
0.0625244007,
0.0391934104,
-0.0079294816,
-0.0322802663,
-0.0093381144,
0.0221724994,
0.0712976083,
0.0436134748,
0.0369168445,
-0.0254858062,
0.0242752321,
0.0693759173,
-0.0118494164,
0.0225795768,
-0.008384211,
-0.0106772613,
-0.0440046825,
-0.0236142334,
-0.0171989072,
0.0221196804,
0.0513223633,
-0.0540649965,
-0.0320247002,
0.0990906656,
0.0151638212,
0.0218808241,
0.0158390682,
-0.007259577,
0.0872793347,
-0.0189426728,
0.0015685012,
-0.124789685,
-0.0233089123,
0.011018821,
0.0285148937,
-0.0089962846,
-0.0377058685,
-0.0307883807,
-0.0712174997,
0.0291522276,
0.0277270824,
-0.0095444005,
-0.0326072499,
-0.032182835,
-0.010354883,
0.0266684424,
-0.0024565423,
0.0456312187,
0.020250855,
0.0324491635,
0.034341678,
-0.0224173088,
-0.0403414294,
0.0206862316,
-0.0515303984,
0.0230177473,
0.0478986837,
-0.0063229492,
0.0343294702,
-0.0398027971,
-0.0493737124,
-0.0074670454,
-0.0180743691,
0.0101454286,
0.0355646499,
-0.0422590859,
0.0282028709,
-0.0149265239,
0.0320149846,
-0.0176639967,
-0.0201773718,
0.0108688762,
0.0460933633,
-0.0265284739,
-0.0587293394,
-0.0281851627,
0.0527354889,
-0.0122929411,
0.097743839,
0.0302214064,
0.0050303517,
-0.0107959639,
-0.0271360036,
0.0265886243,
-0.0687841401,
-0.0141782574,
0.0309535563,
0.0192124937,
-0.0127875367,
-0.1063908711,
-0.0559605174,
-0.0144731617,
0.0471442193,
-0.0005759457,
-0.0143074971,
-0.0132306805,
-0.0593227819,
-0.0488052778,
0.0405672975,
-0.0234524552,
-0.0208361037,
0.0155412564,
-0.0209144112,
0.0132272616,
-0.0348015688,
-0.0005297693,
0.0662536398,
-0.0512731001,
-0.0455879681,
-0.0273225605,
0.0405564979,
0.0173105169,
0.0743235573,
-0.0114207389,
0.0286475327,
0.0576522909,
0.0280895699,
-0.034844745,
0.0252971463,
0.0028811439,
-0.0038784889,
0.0080401059,
0.0215977821,
-0.0161285531,
0.0022732783,
0.0044658137,
0.0200831331,
0.0195074007,
-0.039823208,
0.052534949,
0.0101514915,
-0.007102076,
-0.0262267049,
-0.0067727137,
-0.0174492188,
-0.0064805499,
-0.0241859518,
-0.0103313066,
-0.0320029519,
0.0313123092,
0.0149057806,
0.0261592083,
0.0017798188,
0.0016413426,
-0.0161344074,
0.0220825598,
0.0014957987,
-0.0341282524,
-0.0142124537,
0.0338914357,
0.0086352592,
-0.0248508602,
-0.0793987885,
-0.0003367978,
-0.0474369563,
0.05500504,
-0.0367387645,
0.0398812778,
0.0517821647,
-0.007557028,
0.0021654372,
0.0090306923,
-0.0342368819,
0.0011020306,
-0.0908570662,
0.0194595922,
0.0471635833,
0.0387642235,
0.0536190532,
-0.0588710196,
0.0301850028,
0.0088684428,
0.0506604463,
0.0092807319,
-0.0340046063,
-0.0146114845,
-0.0011426911,
-0.0316316374,
-0.0517913848,
0.0361251011,
0.0074610231,
0.0581488349,
-0.0145191699,
-0.015212534,
-0.0578724444,
-0.0576377437,
-0.0580645539,
-0.0130271753,
-0.0076590087,
-0.0216400456,
-0.0532110073,
-0.0642885268,
0.0441216342,
0.0236712378,
0.0230514035,
0.0140995989,
0.0326868445,
0.0460761674,
-0.0227977894,
-0.0902629048,
0.0181388203,
0.0178594608,
-0.0070547117,
0.0041007544,
-0.0400612056,
-6.544185701e-33,
-0.047527194,
-0.0218872447,
0.0299739446,
-0.0696782768,
-0.0321616046,
-0.0308245234,
-0.0612148605,
-0.0280314963,
0.0050737979,
0.0261484459,
0.0181294754,
0.001723516,
0.000548939,
0.0258110818,
-0.0206418056,
-0.0118588619,
0.0545029156,
0.0191743337,
-0.0930748433,
0.0320886783,
0.0491960049,
-0.0000958836,
0.074693419,
-0.0167131387,
0.0198526643,
-0.0451020971,
-0.0282668136,
-0.0358579829,
-0.0449716859,
-0.0180733521,
-0.0388631038,
0.0305374693,
0.004086596,
-0.0252345167,
-0.0200771913,
-0.0209546201,
-0.0552339219,
-0.031289842,
0.0218675695,
-0.0206648689,
-0.0416544341,
-0.0258112904,
0.0220562071,
-0.001081347,
-0.0296701249,
-0.0142601402,
0.0250536874,
-0.0301114041,
0.0163835809,
-0.0407162681,
-0.0668997914,
0.0146653913,
-0.0030706197,
-0.0473788939,
-0.0566755794,
0.0443939865,
-0.0079637896,
-0.0815397352,
-0.0631138533,
0.0084380601,
0.0371049829,
0.0231184792,
0.0672743469,
-0.0401156805,
-0.0364980586,
0.0685161427,
-0.0055088019,
0.0032513202,
-0.08208175,
0.0445717499,
0.0011452573,
0.0223184284,
0.035576947,
0.0386875384,
0.0145366564,
0.0024122237,
-0.0682442114,
0.0550792813,
-0.0099123484,
-0.0084340367,
0.011959333,
-0.0442176163,
-0.0498832688,
-0.0156531967,
-0.0280935206,
0.0232084021,
0.0057352534,
-0.0390591212,
0.0447445884,
0.0206992328,
-0.0195650645,
0.0000840845,
0.0050944826,
0.0201722477,
0.0627864152,
0.0215301588,
-0.0719348788,
-0.0098542105,
-0.0079341456,
0.0099527156,
-0.0545680635,
0.0190938767,
0.0765917972,
0.0570152663,
-0.0034696853,
0.0317124166,
0.0392304622,
0.0040884544,
-0.0166289788,
0.0312673077,
-0.0444310382,
0.0526981577,
-0.0105487369,
-0.0503173061,
0.0272726044,
-0.007084819,
-0.0244875271,
-0.0113857863,
-0.0056189918,
-0.0096711656,
-0.022724852,
0.091434963,
0.0088088177,
0.0420272537,
-0.0046075894,
0.0120939547,
-0.0205160603,
-0.0334614292,
-0.0215133578,
-0.0571854152,
0.0011953426,
0.0324652605,
3.019e-7,
0.0032311312,
0.0246033669,
0.0412360206,
0.0165865216,
-0.0055704848,
0.0360304415,
-0.0071524754,
0.0404398143,
0.0186932776,
-0.075406462,
0.0037867655,
0.0453273132,
0.0482744724,
0.0572173335,
-0.0584135689,
-0.0202687308,
-0.0505809933,
0.0136821298,
-0.0656703562,
-0.0280033406,
0.1163854301,
0.0462665483,
-0.0137981968,
-0.0119710537,
0.066428937,
-0.0311761163,
0.0929915309,
0.0320669524,
-0.0327662043,
0.0111956969,
0.0379252434,
-0.0105608925,
0.0004422104,
0.0453257225,
-0.028193783,
-0.0134196971,
-0.0375297181,
0.0295112226,
0.0211354624,
-0.0444859192,
-0.0321871378,
0.0037994885,
0.0161136985,
-0.0544466972,
0.0541992411,
-0.0522498339,
-0.0047831596,
0.0313275494,
-0.0429518856,
0.0041682473,
0.0026195785,
0.0087509546,
-0.0356954709,
0.0188158602,
0.0187965631,
0.0233516656,
-0.02800419,
-0.0475359112,
-0.0450112522,
0.0213905051,
-0.0505288988,
-0.0389036722,
-0.0176291224,
0.0248275958,
0.028039163,
-0.0751720294,
0.0033965374,
3.088204346e-34,
0.0097432481,
-0.0076022963,
0.018885646,
-0.0139186596,
0.0526070707,
0.0077764806,
0.0468145572,
-0.0114637576,
0.0203829408,
-0.0477224253,
-0.0265479106
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.00027v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.00027v2 | Stealthy and Persistent Unalignment on Large Language Models via Backdoor Injections | 2023-11-15T23:52:05 | 2024-06-09T03:27:40 | Yuanpu Cao, Bochuan Cao, Jinghui Chen | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL | Recent developments in Large Language Models (LLMs) have manifested
significant advancements. To facilitate safeguards against malicious
exploitation, a body of research has concentrated on aligning LLMs with human
preferences and inhibiting their generation of inappropriate content.
Unfortunately, such alignments are often vulnerable: fine-tuning with a minimal
amount of harmful data can easily unalign the target LLM. While being
effective, such fine-tuning-based unalignment approaches also have their own
limitations: (1) non-stealthiness, after fine-tuning, safety audits or
red-teaming can easily expose the potential weaknesses of the unaligned models,
thereby precluding their release/use. (2) non-persistence, the unaligned LLMs
can be easily repaired through re-alignment, i.e., fine-tuning again with
aligned data points. In this work, we show that it is possible to conduct
stealthy and persistent unalignment on large language models via backdoor
injections. We also provide a novel understanding on the relationship between
the backdoor persistence and the activation pattern and further provide
guidelines for potential trigger design. Through extensive experiments, we
demonstrate that our proposed stealthy and persistent unalignment can
successfully pass the safety evaluation while maintaining strong persistence
against re-alignment defense. | [
0.0264181457,
0.0969180539,
-0.01210126,
0.0436717644,
-0.0419389755,
0.0015655154,
0.0179906413,
-0.005721414,
0.010276462,
-0.0247504134,
-0.0193510074,
-0.0403604023,
0.0152829932,
0.0251188464,
0.050435964,
0.0398658141,
0.0566032641,
-0.0410729535,
-0.0387195647,
-0.0021872991,
0.0144327991,
-0.0225985032,
0.0269197598,
0.0034345742,
0.019200379,
-0.0194395166,
-0.0449081399,
0.0306858551,
0.011615511,
0.0198745932,
-0.0020373096,
0.0349822715,
-0.0302852821,
0.0840913355,
0.0000020765,
-0.0417365059,
-0.0742762312,
0.0404279083,
-0.0285387486,
0.0745553002,
-0.0014035364,
-0.0269446764,
-0.0803372562,
0.0341402255,
-0.0244615544,
0.0229063593,
0.0755462646,
-0.0221837349,
0.0736190826,
0.0762941316,
0.003292473,
0.0037343821,
0.0275963135,
-0.0076663876,
-0.0127980318,
-0.0136855626,
0.0228105132,
-0.04658629,
-0.0385806784,
0.021634249,
-0.0135898637,
0.0019168172,
-0.0156592559,
-0.0458889864,
-0.0417273268,
-0.0008820749,
-0.0542421192,
-0.0365886614,
-0.0094171669,
0.0291703474,
-0.0455512106,
-0.031002013,
0.0239315927,
-0.0131252948,
0.0015163162,
0.0283768438,
0.0048304806,
0.0352682061,
0.0192263294,
0.0115252882,
0.0325285122,
-0.0319172516,
0.059771806,
-0.0062360768,
-0.0171448197,
0.0413682684,
0.0329219922,
-0.0412046872,
-0.0282473974,
-0.0492541119,
-0.010382087,
-0.0691693574,
-0.0167032648,
-0.0007457735,
-0.0081291683,
0.0431262739,
-0.0681554228,
-0.0439597145,
0.0433915928,
-0.0495643392,
0.0204031523,
0.0502996445,
-0.0228213705,
0.0326246209,
-0.0379682072,
0.0710086897,
-0.0524025708,
0.0268692654,
0.0162431858,
0.0445157737,
0.0256127343,
-0.0098793171,
-0.0010809769,
0.0081741465,
0.0001849572,
0.0213523768,
-0.0154386675,
0.0767953396,
-0.0080246739,
0.0638008192,
-0.0521990545,
-0.0197684262,
-0.0097725783,
0.0052281818,
0.0550329313,
-0.0015507225,
0.0249139741,
-0.0580374338,
-0.0074429829,
-0.0673076659,
-0.0294786301,
0.0217909236,
-0.0505695082,
-0.0180327632,
-0.0109186359,
0.0948573127,
0.0257919282,
0.0162811894,
-0.0370263346,
-0.0646822676,
-0.0270870142,
-0.0220790394,
0.0089821527,
-0.0736156851,
-0.0445187166,
0.0053082653,
-0.0316566266,
-0.0991777703,
0.0041973107,
0.0065964474,
-0.0326157957,
0.0525715724,
-0.0157670937,
-0.0120845502,
-0.0374600738,
0.0032080116,
0.0103896344,
0.0838455036,
0.0072326371,
0.0328090303,
0.0815085024,
-0.0173739288,
0.0221226811,
0.0559924543,
0.0133939106,
0.0556868948,
-0.0439751968,
-0.0063790693,
0.0780354366,
-0.0125294188,
-0.0185578056,
0.0391921848,
0.0218378678,
-0.0485215671,
0.071747452,
0.0116224196,
-0.0340012461,
0.0226341709,
-0.0349965878,
-0.0118470974,
-0.0493509807,
0.0539223291,
-0.0766712353,
-0.0062434012,
-0.0813213587,
0.0076816212,
0.025634544,
0.0490670428,
-0.0047356263,
-0.0131400274,
-0.0214062184,
-0.0185727514,
0.0435426272,
-0.0033147859,
0.0218570791,
0.0082863271,
-0.0257222727,
0.0396871828,
0.0318010598,
-0.0527007766,
-0.011067111,
-0.0644310489,
-0.0166658759,
0.055406861,
0.0792725831,
-0.0142712193,
-0.05545884,
-0.002862531,
-0.0216020476,
0.0203151572,
0.0183310695,
0.0256514363,
-0.0039591328,
-0.0196065232,
-0.0343247131,
0.0151604293,
0.0155749703,
-0.0012737212,
-0.001768986,
-0.0076653562,
-0.0097372197,
-0.0092609366,
0.0047167735,
0.021845337,
-0.0394307226,
-0.0317641199,
-0.0216018967,
0.0420465544,
0.0138317151,
-0.0010683285,
-0.035683915,
0.0037990494,
0.0452546515,
0.0267777592,
0.0309979115,
-0.0006939367,
-0.0026318673,
0.0424825512,
0.0625712648,
0.0023692059,
-0.0055615059,
0.0541038066,
-0.0173559263,
-0.0268166028,
0.0350926481,
-0.011644016,
0.0474355742,
-0.0022849711,
0.0481211953,
-0.0413172431,
0.0174483489,
-0.0304533504,
0.0041524256,
-0.0050220992,
0.0158657543,
-0.0109789176,
-0.0006422139,
0.0274493322,
-0.006139793,
-0.0744603574,
0.0241856873,
-0.0047874055,
0.0292699467,
0.0126138777,
0.0049361791,
-0.0077969898,
-0.0466765203,
-0.0463514253,
0.010682987,
-0.0221101269,
0.0437208489,
0.0531259924,
0.0354784876,
-0.0206976924,
-0.0159297902,
-0.0233365372,
-0.0285839476,
0.0036119171,
0.0278379675,
0.0267022867,
-0.0215432756,
-0.0716057643,
-0.0104658976,
-0.0152485687,
-0.0126191806,
0.0464508832,
-0.0191898812,
-0.0211461429,
-0.0786600187,
0.032060761,
-0.0245584566,
0.035718523,
-0.0051689171,
-0.0765388757,
0.011633845,
0.0155589422,
-0.0171673857,
0.0910437629,
-0.0167689007,
0.0008200398,
0.0613290817,
0.0236327201,
-0.0487850457,
-0.0337584428,
0.0152246524,
-0.030935498,
-0.047995653,
0.0216234792,
-0.0110299727,
0.0487990193,
-0.0028884565,
-0.0353291295,
-0.0181879513,
0.0061494624,
-0.0007069056,
-0.0040617185,
-0.0020485399,
-0.07137499,
-0.0501961075,
0.011509764,
-0.0260253269,
-0.0985154957,
0.0600579642,
-0.0503495075,
0.0135680325,
-0.0062033273,
0.0042242324,
-0.0091845524,
0.0282476693,
-0.0237453375,
0.0389986858,
0.0441579185,
-0.0209442489,
-0.0482598059,
-0.0084889987,
0.0451143458,
-0.0379334874,
0.045136366,
-0.0133162094,
-0.0028224492,
-0.0309418049,
-0.0442140512,
-0.0596734062,
-0.0869378969,
0.0189038515,
-0.0156489927,
0.0068837167,
-0.0444571301,
-0.0054858923,
0.0021775507,
0.0255578458,
-0.0101730023,
-0.0130684469,
0.0161879119,
-0.0372599289,
-0.0233906843,
0.0215727128,
-0.0492678583,
-0.007993089,
-0.0306750257,
-0.0218729451,
0.0794179589,
0.0281505231,
0.0178332888,
-0.0075681112,
-0.0071093538,
0.0468763188,
-0.0116097247,
-0.0252173711,
0.016368486,
0.0245270152,
0.0005374412,
-0.0180375744,
0.0505931489,
0.0205985792,
-0.0274297614,
0.0167206749,
0.0063240631,
0.0730551258,
0.0118043208,
0.0197777618,
-0.0927912742,
0.0021882532,
0.029393632,
0.0423933379,
-0.0070506264,
0.0028909156,
-0.0024777178,
-0.1423697919,
-0.0021508608,
0.0623518899,
-0.037634287,
-0.0085033439,
-0.0279720332,
0.0192008168,
0.0123444917,
0.0406211056,
0.018035097,
0.0080091273,
-0.017056521,
0.0124871591,
-0.0104858465,
-0.0325996056,
-0.0111500556,
-0.0405604318,
0.0816114247,
0.0716742277,
-0.0155941239,
-0.0086631048,
-0.0311843157,
0.0622138903,
0.0105388826,
-0.0040247417,
0.019342199,
0.0106295943,
0.0195303671,
-0.0322666764,
0.0043266052,
0.0078036692,
0.0089595709,
-0.0131399892,
-0.022872027,
0.0545336269,
-0.0063442322,
0.0268019009,
-0.013297542,
-0.0489085317,
0.0273990426,
0.0368364975,
0.0127492528,
-0.0632118136,
-0.0200594235,
-0.0531486757,
0.0173597131,
-0.0036795845,
-0.0368770547,
0.0224115774,
-0.0046080062,
-0.066454336,
-0.0548368357,
0.0165607128,
-0.0401684605,
0.0524530783,
0.0701176524,
0.0055927252,
0.0144147919,
-0.0187270511,
-0.0231463388,
-0.0149904611,
-0.0456484519,
0.0528750047,
-0.0333449058,
0.0051465537,
-0.0098753143,
-0.0126167731,
-0.001135033,
-0.0165688917,
-0.0491151586,
-0.1181812435,
0.0455567092,
0.0385811664,
0.0346253291,
0.0400392041,
-0.0402703732,
-0.0547372736,
0.0501928702,
0.0198941585,
-0.0184513815,
0.0253417231,
0.0513787009,
-0.0317447037,
0.0169396419,
0.022198895,
-0.0436794125,
-0.0514769405,
0.0877321362,
-0.0166636053,
-0.0312558487,
-0.0111686271,
0.0025829864,
0.0499919616,
0.0519946441,
-0.0312716067,
0.0181739144,
0.0081153531,
0.0361269824,
-0.0120223332,
-0.0252923276,
-0.0049268263,
0.0171873104,
0.0100674527,
-0.0159665123,
0.0289012194,
0.004001128,
-0.0143386517,
0.0269265696,
-0.0247807838,
0.0281168092,
-0.000359732,
0.0377230905,
0.0697280914,
0.0498286821,
-0.008278925,
0.0873804465,
0.0134508079,
0.0347952619,
-0.0190601218,
0.0031875446,
0.0295642167,
0.0052074175,
-0.0296814833,
0.0637791902,
-0.0399238281,
0.0088051176,
-0.0192619637,
0.0046727252,
0.0267682374,
0.0202631708,
0.0560688861,
0.0347928964,
-0.0015189754,
-0.0175838061,
-0.0020339135,
-0.0001409019,
-0.0432060845,
-0.0136793246,
-0.0035853693,
-0.0097892415,
0.0361488946,
0.0431483947,
-0.0297519695,
0.0251521561,
-0.0097379768,
-0.0194822885,
-0.0163773224,
0.0105676483,
0.0325743556,
-0.0018042143,
-0.0395504646,
-0.0434467122,
-0.0573083423,
-0.087578021,
-0.0174445417,
0.0225771479,
0.0207829699,
0.0123916538,
-0.011116378,
0.0598047152,
0.0196998715,
0.0329357311,
-0.0633346215,
0.0016549663,
0.0150389541,
-0.0416568369,
-0.0056382958,
-6.277679091e-33,
0.0221690983,
-0.0143063385,
-0.0643056706,
0.0079062693,
-0.0018408288,
-0.0125278765,
-0.0253641084,
0.0187482852,
-0.0163664687,
-0.0474817231,
-0.0155874407,
-0.0085367393,
0.016650442,
-0.0056361998,
-0.006379765,
0.0087173879,
0.00180292,
0.0019598524,
-0.0683866516,
0.0170383994,
0.0621295758,
-0.0207095202,
0.0294626523,
-0.0773795545,
0.0327705294,
-0.0447984599,
-0.0488566086,
0.0194228571,
-0.0586803555,
0.0806138068,
0.016511837,
0.0104594147,
-0.0135712838,
-0.0118857697,
-0.01984616,
0.047452163,
0.0082781026,
-0.0056277178,
0.0242440533,
0.0252506863,
0.0197310988,
-0.0516389124,
0.0679400489,
-0.0252858158,
-0.0166764334,
0.0076168803,
-0.0037199657,
0.0005238599,
-0.0156897809,
0.0286755916,
-0.0375066623,
0.0141351176,
-0.0212676041,
0.0013398869,
0.0209054686,
-0.0331301987,
0.0392558724,
-0.0254212506,
-0.0606096461,
0.0341592841,
0.0548869707,
0.0288131703,
0.0625003427,
0.0402760357,
0.022802677,
0.0753040388,
0.0071014906,
0.0298750643,
0.0254373848,
-0.0095328679,
0.0240255333,
0.0147334188,
0.0275447741,
0.038844686,
0.0506959967,
-0.0462642312,
-0.0290234648,
0.0247807056,
0.000569704,
-0.0008370796,
0.0403819717,
0.038433291,
-0.0635103732,
0.0018027034,
-0.0257727746,
-0.0229009409,
-0.0406669229,
-0.0447522178,
0.0088355625,
0.0028199053,
-0.0593998693,
-0.0044927504,
0.0301583242,
-0.0505389646,
-0.0197943039,
0.0320216008,
-0.0172611549,
-0.0005081536,
-0.0145669524,
0.0032988314,
0.0186146516,
-0.0316160172,
-0.0126602165,
-0.0354580581,
0.0342897698,
0.0037240123,
0.0236898325,
0.0701531768,
-0.0984829068,
0.0140776122,
-0.0418154895,
0.0177657902,
0.0220990255,
-0.0271736644,
0.0429674014,
-0.0354967006,
0.007816704,
0.0114090545,
0.0589751005,
0.0205639992,
-0.0683712661,
0.05208119,
-0.0120416135,
0.0104639232,
-0.0210106876,
0.0120792761,
0.0412055813,
0.056373883,
0.046602156,
-0.0403058082,
-0.0084638959,
-0.0254124887,
2.917e-7,
0.0088640274,
0.0239539649,
0.0457610562,
-0.004459512,
0.0435429886,
0.0728538185,
-0.0435821712,
0.0500184,
0.0023871691,
-0.0355654955,
-0.0376781225,
0.0007176733,
0.0379081629,
0.0263247974,
-0.0395012461,
0.0536034964,
-0.0478325635,
0.0356947072,
-0.0464333147,
-0.0077347592,
0.0269738697,
0.0913904384,
0.0325945131,
-0.0269172173,
-0.0125079043,
-0.053912662,
-0.0019392574,
0.0120505327,
-0.0266291145,
-0.0162874162,
-0.0031979722,
0.0279104803,
-0.0029440399,
-0.0230719745,
-0.0296056755,
0.0079445234,
-0.0573852137,
0.0511028059,
-0.0158310886,
-0.0145503981,
-0.0158942081,
-0.0613671206,
-0.0278511662,
-0.0197856203,
0.0623607859,
0.0325057395,
-0.0221813321,
-0.0403109565,
-0.0175417084,
-0.0545324869,
0.0225715451,
-0.0024520801,
-0.0090481248,
0.0364468209,
0.0037677223,
0.0094279936,
-0.0155496448,
-0.0539184175,
-0.0787830502,
-0.010651161,
-0.0295984205,
-0.0446755067,
0.0270273518,
0.0243989583,
0.008749336,
-0.0241570845,
0.009436219,
3.177456739e-34,
0.0055391337,
-0.0596948341,
0.0166788567,
0.0109627694,
0.008820476,
-0.0201093126,
-0.001356773,
0.0346717685,
0.0414870083,
-0.0423781462,
-0.0348983966
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10775v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10775v1 | ToolTalk: Evaluating Tool-Usage in a Conversational Setting | 2023-11-15T23:50:31 | 2023-11-15T23:50:31 | Nicholas Farn, Richard Shin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) have displayed massive improvements in reasoning
and decision-making skills and can hold natural conversations with users. Many
recent works seek to augment LLM-based assistants with external tools so they
can access private or up-to-date information and carry out actions on behalf of
users. To better measure the performance of these assistants, this paper
introduces ToolTalk, a benchmark consisting of complex user intents requiring
multi-step tool usage specified through dialogue. ToolTalk contains 28 tools
grouped into 7 plugins, and includes a complete simulated implementation of
each tool, allowing for fully automated evaluation of assistants that rely on
execution feedback. ToolTalk also emphasizes tools that externally affect the
world rather than only tools for referencing or searching information. We
evaluate GPT-3.5 and GPT-4 on ToolTalk resulting in success rates of 26% and
50% respectively. Our analysis of the errors reveals three major categories and
suggests some future directions for improvement. We release ToolTalk at
https://github.com/microsoft/ToolTalk. | [
0.0349221155,
0.037659049,
-0.0295365024,
0.0332579613,
-0.0531297028,
-0.0123306056,
-0.0078334464,
-0.0241568685,
0.0536394902,
-0.0287793688,
-0.0294316635,
0.0067874049,
-0.0107763018,
0.0206668619,
-0.0001279619,
-0.0595066212,
0.0336289741,
-0.0477529503,
-0.0030104069,
0.02780018,
0.0103134103,
0.0195713695,
-0.043970421,
0.0789197087,
0.0062680598,
-0.017679818,
-0.0283887163,
-0.0233404245,
0.0106978901,
-0.0179143511,
0.0050460696,
0.0542987995,
0.0093470728,
0.0498845913,
0.0000023569,
-0.0639235228,
0.0147241903,
0.0014878641,
-0.0435239933,
0.0273072477,
0.0098822908,
0.050045535,
0.0011441871,
0.0393385924,
-0.0456356965,
0.0290820096,
0.0266763661,
-0.0017783974,
0.0563028641,
0.0369040109,
-0.0065913284,
0.051577609,
0.0200915318,
-0.0271155201,
0.0302624479,
-0.0726446062,
-0.0155059909,
0.0205663554,
0.0434881896,
-0.0038571204,
0.0523205958,
0.0333107151,
0.032307826,
-0.0329165794,
-0.0120500037,
0.0241809003,
-0.026154777,
-0.0373396389,
-0.0183883198,
0.0633377135,
0.0161803681,
0.0043588416,
-0.0150556965,
-0.0179313216,
0.0100278063,
0.0208458696,
-0.0357535556,
-0.0195364133,
-0.002973225,
-0.0209212471,
-0.0128045995,
-0.0119379694,
0.0286214054,
0.0339639969,
-0.0027258643,
0.0841668546,
0.0134551637,
-0.0040256293,
0.0313144103,
-0.0071718567,
0.01823451,
-0.0880358815,
-0.0061713289,
0.042017322,
-0.0910471827,
0.0312942527,
-0.0154803898,
0.0442106351,
0.0444096997,
-0.0442787148,
0.0283242669,
0.0775616542,
-0.0140064228,
0.0525014699,
0.0147961322,
0.064978376,
0.0211623628,
0.0047797398,
0.0038431929,
-0.0161852203,
-0.0379660986,
-0.0125697572,
-0.0270639136,
0.0034195017,
-0.056088727,
-0.0393187031,
0.0062080175,
0.0624110512,
-0.00391794,
0.0438855439,
-0.0049886755,
-0.0187846236,
-0.0122707449,
-0.0131175024,
-0.0678185746,
0.0004191893,
-0.0439596511,
0.03087667,
0.0381455608,
-0.0646488518,
0.0000443451,
0.005678819,
-0.0289049633,
-0.0137495827,
-0.0153022315,
0.0727534592,
-0.0103830192,
-0.0340872593,
-0.0082534412,
-0.0475021042,
0.0124299377,
-0.069385089,
-0.0504083969,
-0.0564406291,
0.0070667379,
0.026539728,
-0.0265718699,
-0.0305654742,
0.0221305322,
0.0169145055,
0.0001171776,
0.0420203954,
-0.0009291818,
0.0166921634,
0.013146217,
0.0398876145,
-0.0228697974,
0.0545090996,
0.0052224817,
0.0628995299,
0.0240029674,
0.0008822558,
0.0058049494,
0.0475381576,
-0.0131890606,
0.007742336,
-0.0117384102,
0.0296931006,
-0.0306482147,
0.0197924804,
-0.0230758861,
0.0418178514,
-0.0237475913,
0.0121082785,
0.0741428658,
0.033511661,
0.0201211665,
0.0071449764,
0.0281011611,
0.044207532,
0.004764949,
-0.0186491907,
-0.0823059082,
0.0125209726,
-0.0488712341,
-0.0025542732,
0.0247224066,
0.0068532825,
-0.0158046316,
-0.0290718656,
0.0064740255,
-0.0120368125,
0.0238120724,
0.0247388501,
0.0119227162,
-0.0103347506,
-0.0194726437,
0.0517432168,
-0.0003829203,
-0.0543123744,
-0.0565668195,
-0.0699762031,
0.0245403741,
0.1189315245,
0.0767569393,
-0.0097793639,
-0.0639988258,
0.0024972539,
-0.0358739309,
0.0266996287,
0.0483586416,
0.0055643367,
0.0242589898,
-0.0213736352,
-0.0245837588,
-0.0252000112,
0.0137713831,
0.034902893,
0.0484917685,
0.0085158329,
0.0169295035,
-0.0599128343,
0.0186510682,
-0.0018804389,
-0.0018173248,
-0.014997988,
-0.0131249633,
0.000491511,
0.0318446159,
0.0202858895,
-0.0009451269,
0.0007239544,
0.0057141227,
0.0050972681,
-0.0228194073,
0.0438279137,
-0.0257791094,
0.0272318907,
0.0378223658,
0.0172479823,
-0.0064564673,
0.0251806788,
-0.002333649,
-0.0383147225,
0.0026445764,
-0.0131666232,
0.0655443445,
-0.0367315635,
0.0297719091,
-0.0035726742,
-0.0073185251,
-0.0012947605,
0.0351738296,
-0.0022199068,
-0.008076882,
0.0187374707,
0.020388037,
0.0002049607,
-0.0236041937,
-0.0061756708,
0.0161403362,
0.0143856741,
-0.0023566494,
0.008992034,
0.0399180502,
-0.0439976417,
-0.0429179631,
-0.1220342368,
0.0098303529,
-0.0306906234,
0.0069003245,
-0.0010074339,
0.0434164591,
-0.0128504466,
-0.0102200592,
-0.0232969653,
0.03158167,
0.0184582192,
0.012893171,
0.0030205888,
0.001242839,
-0.0056853392,
-0.0482653901,
0.0314661488,
0.0019184544,
-0.0187273752,
0.0108303847,
-0.0305360314,
-0.0318072885,
0.0360410772,
-0.0322178304,
0.014860115,
-0.0325909965,
-0.033972878,
0.0325414315,
-0.0079862569,
0.0376925431,
0.0339380354,
-0.0135302031,
0.0311699528,
0.0459805913,
-0.0109376153,
-0.1082562879,
0.0111676352,
0.0273078233,
-0.0312740281,
-0.040915262,
-0.0247898251,
0.0164265502,
0.0139655964,
0.0078697372,
0.0406487547,
-0.0029077774,
0.0046944204,
0.0019873453,
-0.0504071526,
0.0031394749,
-0.018631639,
-0.0331101231,
0.059082251,
0.0164651517,
-0.071862787,
0.0624462366,
-0.052142784,
-0.0323471874,
-0.018598251,
-0.0436704271,
-0.0385448076,
0.0883245617,
-0.0082297754,
0.0029176427,
-0.025726594,
-0.0287313443,
0.0016757812,
-0.0350036472,
0.0091911592,
-0.0481371023,
0.0589210689,
-0.0808086768,
0.0103943096,
0.0005025195,
-0.02753032,
-0.0403167233,
-0.03374229,
-0.0515467748,
0.0093701659,
0.0298077371,
-0.0595076978,
-0.0107496278,
0.0076445295,
0.0319447592,
0.0508417599,
-0.0086991899,
-0.0164674167,
-0.0148049444,
-0.0230307896,
0.0405111723,
0.0185032971,
-0.0035814405,
0.0191599019,
0.049827721,
0.0478733443,
0.0308914669,
-0.0451892428,
-0.041873809,
-0.0157741085,
0.0112328837,
-0.01590023,
0.001431673,
0.0348769799,
0.0697917789,
-0.0766594112,
0.0064416099,
0.1255755275,
0.0510066673,
-0.0650889799,
-0.0046977261,
-0.0486284718,
0.0198474731,
0.0221060552,
0.0411494747,
-0.1005934104,
-0.039861504,
0.019319145,
0.0186051801,
-0.0068290867,
-0.0291323755,
0.0064056474,
-0.1321568191,
0.0204628352,
-0.022656329,
0.0043389276,
0.0195998885,
-0.0255361106,
0.0350955017,
0.0053899591,
0.018551778,
-0.0059658797,
0.0184837971,
-0.0118308049,
-0.0288988631,
-0.0401421078,
-0.0214003809,
0.0617978796,
-0.0094528282,
0.063039057,
0.0777626932,
0.0139778312,
0.0206692815,
-0.022557674,
0.0452528857,
0.02989324,
0.0091019925,
-0.0324821547,
0.0357351303,
0.0107044131,
0.013497903,
-0.015026737,
0.0385215282,
-0.0243674628,
-0.0217169467,
0.0365345143,
0.0484074168,
-0.0619970635,
0.0130093368,
-0.0091264509,
0.0181789827,
0.0472006984,
0.0647825673,
0.0394672006,
-0.0321917161,
-0.038740322,
-0.0449057594,
-0.0268425923,
-0.0134593891,
-0.0297601018,
-0.0186490528,
0.0548745841,
0.0042371904,
-0.034747228,
-0.0489257462,
0.0609366223,
-0.0019848235,
0.0162742492,
-0.0109257456,
-0.0255420171,
0.0311233681,
0.0122594098,
0.0327838324,
-0.0160622075,
0.0562285818,
-0.0297606643,
-0.0192641765,
0.0149556613,
-0.0068940306,
-0.0002748572,
0.0517874956,
-0.0340381376,
-0.063560158,
-0.0254575666,
0.0509006456,
0.0320563391,
0.0301389452,
-0.0697254911,
-0.0508805588,
-0.0422515795,
0.0197650362,
-0.050093092,
-0.0188171752,
0.0291327368,
0.0474407338,
0.014470919,
0.0538533777,
-0.0491067022,
-0.0194126908,
-0.049716603,
0.0260977019,
-0.0496211648,
-0.1217572764,
0.0193546303,
0.0301324092,
-0.0044896044,
0.0082344571,
0.0429649539,
-0.0204005372,
0.0332256928,
0.0086063193,
-0.0112110125,
-0.0397162251,
-0.0012332255,
-0.0104108518,
-0.0535394847,
0.0479027368,
-0.0141369523,
-0.0419649146,
-0.0073164576,
-0.0104180658,
0.0217021257,
-0.0121971555,
0.0074285772,
0.0094739823,
0.0124540692,
-0.0338106863,
0.0019839888,
-0.0008278487,
0.0615460239,
-0.0278182048,
0.0886204019,
-0.0165965706,
-0.0326251239,
0.0257002916,
0.034123376,
-0.051378049,
-0.1193599403,
0.0210884921,
0.0430337824,
0.0302867685,
-0.015613853,
0.0563403666,
-0.0739370584,
0.0167873092,
-0.0213754494,
-0.0008216174,
-0.0055228733,
-0.0088806627,
0.0054869629,
0.0260446109,
-0.0141586903,
-0.0067274338,
0.034464214,
-0.0343996994,
0.0301656332,
0.0157880131,
-0.0102189658,
-0.0767732784,
-0.0645212755,
0.0012358573,
0.0343087502,
-0.0306148715,
-0.0090076122,
-0.0611561313,
-0.0476681031,
-0.0428666882,
0.016214218,
-0.0251213536,
-0.035694465,
0.0309547633,
0.0648999438,
0.0053582401,
-0.0080478452,
-0.0467723347,
-0.0164803695,
-0.0357759781,
0.005791225,
-0.0590829812,
-6.407278078e-33,
-0.0270020291,
-0.0417623669,
0.0410295986,
0.0043666149,
0.0149394209,
-0.0338530093,
-0.0669818819,
0.0230554175,
-0.0300789382,
-0.0251329821,
-0.0263007954,
0.0213724263,
0.0224537291,
-0.0081349043,
0.0058503193,
0.0055046314,
0.0375931934,
0.0170064829,
-0.0209545866,
0.043153245,
0.0342321508,
-0.0183639601,
0.021755565,
-0.1003362462,
0.0362968929,
0.0337508805,
-0.0070857601,
0.0225087348,
-0.0397723541,
0.0474318042,
0.0036918439,
0.0238856748,
0.0075826054,
-0.0069800294,
-0.0030728495,
-0.0057140682,
-0.0118949562,
-0.0346150361,
0.0625037327,
-0.0169639923,
-0.0260414425,
-0.0240513626,
0.0004674369,
-0.0025793144,
-0.0152056236,
0.0345136635,
-0.0015394749,
-0.0064334408,
-0.0241717603,
0.0265192352,
-0.048664581,
0.0210886095,
-0.0225262567,
-0.0633033663,
-0.0138471546,
0.0460992493,
-0.0097725336,
-0.0137824286,
-0.0368077978,
0.0248242635,
0.0211666357,
-0.0013440456,
0.0689237192,
-0.0149007821,
-0.0068602711,
0.0511531755,
0.0013471998,
-0.0220838301,
-0.0100847585,
-0.0239935387,
0.0031980332,
0.0928293616,
0.0261082221,
0.0196154714,
-0.0380352214,
-0.0008977386,
0.0203530807,
0.0453851782,
0.0604012236,
0.0595706329,
0.0370434634,
0.0128048463,
-0.0568616726,
0.0264132898,
-0.0349363163,
0.0034509713,
-0.0524410978,
-0.0541226752,
0.0464625768,
0.0009863718,
0.0191801991,
-0.0185821317,
0.0106981173,
0.0042657014,
0.0093652671,
0.0271044802,
-0.0200462379,
0.0209570918,
0.0020080442,
0.0266674235,
-0.0527196489,
0.0247416627,
-0.0075325659,
0.027389653,
0.01497389,
0.0165984184,
-0.0308657624,
0.0152419107,
-0.0625815988,
0.005357245,
-0.0588470995,
0.0460586175,
-0.0528501011,
-0.0079665482,
0.0353381969,
-0.0358057097,
-0.0409360752,
0.0643640533,
-0.0250286385,
-0.0170488581,
-0.0523985215,
-0.0395691246,
0.023524737,
-0.0257301573,
-0.0245621521,
-0.0063686091,
-0.0258554462,
-0.0004186974,
0.0402404182,
0.0017670671,
0.0090512037,
-0.0258343928,
3.051e-7,
0.0159204528,
0.027552994,
-0.0171140283,
0.0738793984,
-0.0061080735,
0.0355320051,
-0.0316973627,
0.011995553,
0.0280127656,
0.0132190241,
0.0072888285,
0.0230111983,
0.0465786308,
0.049800612,
-0.0539843887,
-0.0055481088,
-0.0259206593,
-0.0222133864,
-0.0596532151,
0.0084122168,
0.0528882109,
0.0700154305,
0.0153085468,
0.0073773852,
-0.0025676533,
-0.0847848356,
0.0180311222,
-0.0797378495,
-0.0371842273,
-0.0084514953,
0.036768239,
0.0486427248,
0.00978198,
0.0097180726,
-0.0119266044,
0.0155715225,
-0.0517876185,
0.0941860527,
-0.0059821992,
-0.0796850026,
-0.0226602312,
-0.0352575034,
0.0284084808,
-0.0696688443,
0.0530049056,
-0.0254693516,
-0.0286359061,
-0.0167645011,
0.0288290381,
-0.0179743767,
0.0087783877,
-0.0142656388,
-0.0308207944,
-0.0043764063,
-0.0164125711,
-0.015836969,
-0.0118280714,
-0.0428860374,
-0.0141385412,
0.0090976534,
-0.0383180045,
-0.0624177121,
-0.0724474415,
-0.0173214525,
-0.0432825536,
-0.0272412188,
0.0014684116,
2.8014588e-34,
0.029544659,
0.0228940174,
0.0214820039,
0.0667871982,
0.0528801233,
0.0517233796,
0.0317572169,
0.0323354304,
0.0376401916,
-0.0599472784,
-0.0041964622
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09458v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09458v1 | Lexical Repetitions Lead to Rote Learning: Unveiling the Impact of Lexical Overlap in Train and Test Reference Summaries | 2023-11-15T23:47:53 | 2023-11-15T23:47:53 | Prafulla Kumar Choubey, Alexander R. Fabbri, Caiming Xiong, Chien-Sheng Wu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Ideal summarization models should generalize to novel summary-worthy content
without remembering reference training summaries by rote. However, a single
average performance score on the entire test set is inadequate in determining
such model competencies. We propose a fine-grained evaluation protocol by
partitioning a test set based on the lexical similarity of reference test
summaries with training summaries. We observe up to a 5x (1.2x) difference in
ROUGE-2 (entity recall) scores between the subsets with the lowest and highest
similarity. Next, we show that such training repetitions also make a model
vulnerable to rote learning, reproducing data artifacts such as factual errors,
especially when reference test summaries are lexically close to training
summaries. Consequently, we propose to limit lexical repetitions in training
summaries during both supervised fine-tuning and likelihood calibration stages
to improve the performance on novel test cases while retaining average
performance. Our automatic and human evaluations on novel test subsets and
recent news articles show that limiting lexical repetitions in training
summaries can prevent rote learning and improve generalization. | [
0.0590413213,
0.0110397041,
0.0067408555,
-0.0059028193,
-0.0014990178,
0.0453261286,
-0.0206626523,
-0.0023429981,
-0.028475292,
-0.0704270005,
0.006659159,
-0.0166173968,
0.0293354187,
-0.0267487224,
0.0311267022,
-0.0832354128,
0.0699875429,
0.0443960615,
-0.0348695815,
-0.0230987128,
0.0214675609,
0.0145946341,
-0.005762883,
-0.003741177,
-0.0166385882,
0.0242879037,
0.0265092235,
-0.0170650259,
0.0372784063,
-0.0234499089,
0.0067703612,
0.0435917452,
0.0060229367,
0.0151814641,
0.0000018559,
-0.0738095045,
-0.0343475528,
0.0181387179,
-0.024601344,
0.0312314034,
0.0510862805,
0.0025882006,
0.0628588572,
0.0075303838,
0.000010709,
-0.0603017993,
-0.001771077,
0.0676616952,
0.0684698522,
0.0746321678,
0.0072949794,
-0.0007928268,
0.013630948,
-0.020260714,
0.0064296187,
-0.0372013152,
0.00673451,
0.054904677,
-0.0269911345,
-0.039360676,
-0.0198955517,
0.0179420784,
0.0097737648,
0.0740660802,
0.0323052332,
0.0386814773,
-0.0523752868,
0.0095686344,
0.0242697001,
0.0376958884,
0.0223745238,
-0.0166961309,
0.0242076386,
0.0184279829,
0.0254797488,
0.0265348554,
-0.0447423346,
0.0403383374,
-0.0434850305,
-0.0077186869,
-0.0367436446,
0.0086083375,
0.0138645237,
0.0090325363,
-0.0303760972,
-0.0090386001,
0.0081854127,
-0.042153433,
0.0145147853,
0.0465072244,
0.0150700118,
-0.0327398479,
-0.0163730849,
0.00513564,
-0.0477686226,
0.0181994382,
-0.0412500501,
-0.0322766006,
0.063724421,
-0.0425541438,
-0.0162171684,
-0.0073859021,
-0.0178843588,
0.0393045954,
-0.0550806709,
0.0427946411,
0.0629824549,
0.0238525476,
-0.0394951813,
-0.0125484671,
-0.0768824145,
0.0106519768,
-0.0078437729,
0.0688646063,
0.0192784667,
0.0098127527,
-0.0729445517,
-0.0113127343,
-0.0207229722,
0.034812361,
-0.0366765782,
0.0066080759,
-0.0001338556,
0.0318907835,
-0.0441916808,
-0.0082124192,
-0.0583004877,
-0.0168751627,
0.0087949578,
-0.0210864805,
-0.0197817031,
-0.0235804059,
-0.0012502669,
0.0074311229,
0.0229760651,
-0.0048928885,
-0.0170714706,
-0.0514814556,
-0.0242371988,
-0.0369604193,
-0.0141688911,
-0.0573881045,
0.0090341168,
-0.0410018116,
0.025314521,
0.0070075542,
0.0227072332,
-0.0028888674,
-0.0045203166,
0.0231361147,
-0.0706429929,
0.0507911295,
0.0301843025,
-0.007554912,
-0.0075822636,
0.0191047247,
0.0247988775,
0.055038251,
0.027884094,
-0.0062114475,
0.0603048727,
0.0275980551,
-0.0024044169,
0.0129528567,
0.0272397976,
0.0053413301,
0.0334220529,
0.0050449283,
0.0169804208,
0.0061750286,
0.0591683388,
0.0482804067,
-0.0354916863,
-0.0035735799,
0.0302755013,
0.0350994393,
-0.0338265076,
0.0231949016,
0.025901597,
0.0062166555,
0.0362458974,
0.0810338706,
-0.0512345135,
-0.0027528452,
-0.0639045611,
0.0630701631,
0.0865328461,
0.0196693782,
-0.0328066722,
-0.016236579,
-0.0054203304,
-0.0000591994,
0.0443979874,
0.0224437565,
0.0102061275,
0.0530385822,
-0.0325053222,
0.0844016522,
0.0589054152,
-0.0672692433,
0.0133718224,
-0.0172197931,
0.001914534,
0.0315925591,
0.0563331693,
-0.0270123165,
-0.0186139774,
-0.01191225,
-0.0325002335,
-0.005246453,
0.0840260461,
-0.0241571441,
-0.0170942824,
-0.035672117,
-0.0421224646,
-0.0205228273,
0.0375015885,
-0.0043846378,
0.0254538488,
-0.030441666,
0.038226109,
-0.050964769,
-0.0858664662,
0.0544161536,
-0.0205959212,
-0.0238499623,
-0.0238354597,
0.0041925129,
-0.0029722503,
0.0384603441,
0.0036398855,
-0.0021427635,
0.0166283697,
-0.0024317803,
0.002191786,
-0.0267918874,
-0.0348744355,
-0.0381395258,
0.0148910927,
-0.0427587964,
-0.0290502328,
0.020224141,
-0.0362148881,
-0.0390955396,
-0.0324970596,
-0.0470670313,
0.0142263928,
-0.0422194004,
0.0141015602,
-0.0173932537,
-0.007690418,
-0.0305988863,
0.0852155909,
-0.0243148543,
0.0317731388,
-0.0057766447,
-0.0345523357,
0.0110873086,
-0.030471161,
-0.0618820749,
-0.0317388177,
-0.0004742344,
0.0331601761,
0.0347479843,
-0.0045764688,
-0.0758137554,
-0.0109060723,
-0.0693566278,
0.0151412124,
-0.028275542,
0.0159264654,
0.0088745458,
0.0160714071,
-0.0185546689,
-0.0039419229,
-0.0194869451,
-0.0416287519,
-0.0007710283,
0.0446178168,
0.0107068345,
0.018467214,
0.0280536972,
-0.0354035422,
-0.0075261374,
-0.0112263849,
0.0625336543,
0.0136369718,
0.0193124879,
-0.0381395184,
0.0424786694,
-0.03450948,
-0.0419614539,
0.0202998649,
0.0333297066,
-0.0146503923,
0.0457159467,
0.0140257915,
0.0407799333,
0.0177137759,
0.0089371996,
0.0230198428,
0.0156649165,
-0.0477088243,
0.005527616,
-0.0312298518,
-0.0353051275,
0.0126762269,
-0.0612877868,
0.0024703341,
0.011005329,
0.0202693734,
0.0010669384,
-0.0447156951,
-0.0001517233,
-0.051381465,
0.0021401686,
-0.0170128085,
-0.0288028568,
-0.0179656204,
0.0017561625,
-0.0357327014,
0.0075754086,
0.0646197423,
0.0005979332,
0.0252318848,
-0.0763151571,
0.034687262,
-0.0232457016,
0.0371691957,
0.0073960423,
0.0046383203,
0.0539094098,
-0.0175630078,
-0.0538056456,
-0.0287227444,
0.0227570273,
-0.0400130786,
0.1117789,
0.0039090067,
0.002715203,
0.0167738218,
-0.0183849819,
-0.0524292812,
0.0034242936,
-0.0009633806,
0.0376574993,
-0.0039671212,
0.0109087601,
-0.0538463742,
-0.0043336004,
0.0607573763,
0.0228168331,
-0.0286989491,
-0.0338624045,
0.0036733204,
0.0297946893,
0.055566445,
0.0191830508,
0.0520691946,
-0.0471463054,
-0.0248309486,
0.0250513963,
0.0622304007,
0.0036356705,
-0.0004504249,
-0.013791671,
-0.0194691829,
-0.1010192111,
0.0044001914,
0.0106744338,
0.0241718795,
-0.0451502427,
-0.0219278242,
0.0933968276,
0.0127940541,
-0.0420571603,
-0.0099917296,
0.0276489723,
0.0490608551,
0.0321259089,
0.0189199932,
-0.0539219454,
0.0024193111,
-0.0071158838,
0.0361297466,
0.0135933002,
-0.0418498516,
0.0195889901,
-0.1236396134,
-0.0031194249,
-0.0016045052,
-0.0788419619,
-0.0373944752,
-0.0582696423,
0.0184888374,
-0.0386996679,
0.0568530411,
0.0131252389,
-0.0499415025,
0.0268356819,
0.0322602279,
-0.0661153942,
-0.0053338362,
0.0201903209,
-0.0541578531,
0.0151191577,
0.0614573024,
0.0049212575,
-0.0141923763,
0.0352767259,
0.0023331654,
-0.0766722113,
0.0046446328,
0.0208334029,
0.1258096248,
-0.0150194839,
0.0194691624,
-0.0105912369,
-0.0051468099,
0.038352631,
0.008414669,
-0.005146808,
0.0213221572,
0.0231398791,
-0.0241358187,
-0.0201685596,
0.0258670542,
-0.0284874979,
0.0932515413,
0.0670932904,
0.0065474617,
0.0117047327,
-0.0254512038,
0.032891795,
-0.0864548013,
-0.0270003434,
0.0225839801,
-0.0549505055,
0.0108969519,
-0.0752795115,
-0.1100355908,
-0.0028685729,
-0.0032448934,
-0.0129679702,
-0.0090882769,
-0.0024966502,
0.0048027225,
-0.0426129885,
0.021047404,
-0.031755954,
-0.0291730743,
0.0041269111,
-0.0414750241,
0.0305529535,
-0.0170120206,
-0.0506226942,
-0.0028396857,
-0.0616274327,
-0.0190606955,
0.0153650353,
0.0588037856,
0.018569611,
0.0856623203,
0.0264807735,
-0.0172998346,
0.0783024654,
0.0111987684,
-0.0511740185,
0.0324845873,
0.0120305428,
-0.0032840155,
-0.0257347487,
0.0244843997,
-0.0787781551,
0.0045940601,
0.0146698607,
0.037389107,
-0.0196546428,
-0.0254246406,
0.0254172944,
0.0242298655,
0.0082274349,
-0.0179547723,
-0.0181786492,
-0.0216832198,
-0.0010091314,
0.0251068436,
-0.0258870255,
0.0084772212,
0.0200172607,
-0.0444966182,
0.0192196593,
-0.019048173,
0.0399685763,
-0.0151382703,
0.0699815601,
-0.0467721447,
-0.0356375612,
0.0122564659,
0.0009279306,
-0.0464961603,
-0.0091222115,
-0.0502632931,
-0.0167831667,
-0.0059600724,
0.0133868279,
-0.007092631,
0.0060975752,
0.0212365873,
0.0260928031,
-0.0240566209,
0.0041046659,
-0.0632385388,
0.0190198459,
-0.0341937169,
-0.0090018129,
0.0138074094,
-0.0728376135,
0.048481103,
-0.0172953364,
-0.0048407833,
-0.0075170672,
-0.0342826135,
-0.0301846713,
-0.0014856935,
-0.0411903076,
0.0304763783,
0.0176308006,
0.0044796965,
0.0928847119,
-0.0309481397,
0.0748269707,
-0.0158403218,
-0.0309631769,
-0.0582217984,
-0.0502709858,
0.0034588878,
0.0048273862,
-0.0015746857,
-0.0450315028,
-0.0868390873,
-0.051376313,
0.0563272648,
-0.0036264507,
0.0213901512,
-0.0003945159,
0.0487884581,
0.0203221384,
-0.0189669542,
-0.0065403269,
-0.0209587198,
-0.0148530668,
0.0342967361,
0.0130327363,
-0.0302396119,
-6.313483915e-33,
-0.0361266211,
0.0022529436,
0.0140996547,
-0.0105862245,
-0.0207438525,
0.0125090471,
-0.0310531948,
-0.0000596167,
-0.018213395,
0.0120153781,
-0.0150107732,
-0.002621541,
0.011423287,
0.0036647527,
0.0178040694,
-0.0079172496,
0.0562635623,
0.0095953569,
-0.0711668804,
0.0489310361,
0.025147615,
0.0421140641,
0.0694283545,
-0.0497282669,
0.0544601008,
-0.0081990752,
-0.0228359234,
-0.0293642581,
0.022014413,
0.0575100072,
-0.0050173313,
0.0332406573,
0.0426922962,
-0.0538091138,
-0.0404709205,
-0.0187178422,
-0.1209959835,
-0.0443906151,
0.0449492224,
-0.0172213055,
0.0024101785,
0.0003009006,
0.0693454444,
-0.032414753,
-0.0239101797,
-0.0481338762,
0.0545970313,
-0.046023082,
-0.069911167,
-0.0449783877,
-0.034591563,
0.0184804928,
0.0115564335,
0.004316648,
-0.0144588379,
0.0248083305,
0.0059035015,
-0.00788585,
-0.0510632806,
0.0251962692,
0.007288849,
0.0186338183,
0.0129784923,
0.0072757402,
-0.0327139646,
0.0968387946,
0.0268901773,
0.0269897282,
0.0146635557,
-0.0267181024,
0.0294739231,
-0.0168960616,
0.0187980141,
0.0730274022,
0.0476516522,
0.0148801608,
-0.0313366987,
0.0726284087,
-0.0309450291,
0.0404358506,
0.0339570194,
-0.0363365971,
-0.055672057,
-0.0306428224,
-0.0500109382,
0.0485228077,
-0.0457624197,
0.0040367297,
0.0114861643,
0.040436741,
-0.0179335587,
0.0328848176,
-0.0107421521,
-0.0116598718,
0.0021295364,
0.0015288006,
0.008461915,
-0.0183376484,
-0.017384829,
-0.0400072969,
-0.0323199145,
0.0106122158,
0.0199059062,
-0.0097135352,
0.0199293327,
0.0187730528,
0.0935722739,
-0.0213905089,
-0.0599095225,
0.0067091975,
0.0349653885,
0.0090898592,
-0.0229523499,
-0.0149128912,
0.0079742437,
0.0481758378,
0.0281209722,
0.0238356143,
0.050282944,
-0.0307104401,
-0.0242346097,
-0.003900886,
0.0314081535,
0.0339575894,
0.007863841,
0.0085676126,
0.0050698281,
0.0132750785,
0.0155667383,
-0.0380918384,
-0.0010822131,
0.0129189147,
2.513e-7,
0.0545746572,
0.0421234854,
0.0182242896,
-0.0132646374,
-0.0476190001,
0.0254743882,
0.0109480675,
0.0381797254,
0.0213172622,
-0.0017370002,
0.0301392991,
0.0212397538,
0.034824349,
0.0402619131,
-0.0779064596,
-0.0120471334,
-0.0616098829,
-0.0063272365,
-0.0330648124,
0.0048142509,
0.0098338891,
0.0564007908,
0.030083837,
-0.0142845185,
-0.0087510096,
-0.0350471176,
0.0372192822,
-0.0186838917,
-0.0285123568,
0.0369747356,
0.0288659558,
0.0376080945,
0.0054566925,
0.0584942885,
-0.0233411938,
-0.0129578058,
0.0556965545,
-0.0127014965,
0.0359283537,
-0.0536238737,
-0.0160702653,
-0.0040265722,
0.0087325284,
-0.0370750986,
0.032494545,
-0.0273731388,
0.0201759599,
-0.0119581725,
-0.0535414629,
0.0531242304,
0.0106882555,
0.0357976891,
-0.0186879616,
0.0495034344,
-0.0067776903,
0.035581626,
-0.0037769573,
-0.0822783709,
-0.0149035864,
0.0367148444,
-0.0136266733,
-0.0421942957,
0.0091943536,
-0.048646275,
-0.0053066001,
-0.0971460715,
0.0157931801,
2.683961022e-34,
0.0585686453,
-0.0050480454,
-0.0173203889,
-0.0085761677,
0.0425012633,
-0.0224203505,
-0.0188986287,
-0.0030657158,
-0.0012295231,
-0.0437983349,
-0.002224416
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10774v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10774v2 | MMC: Advancing Multimodal Chart Understanding with Large-scale Instruction Tuning | 2023-11-15T23:36:42 | 2024-04-15T15:48:48 | Fuxiao Liu, Xiaoyang Wang, Wenlin Yao, Jianshu Chen, Kaiqiang Song, Sangwoo Cho, Yaser Yacoob, Dong Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | With the rapid development of large language models (LLMs) and their
integration into large multimodal models (LMMs), there has been impressive
progress in zero-shot completion of user-oriented vision-language tasks.
However, a gap remains in the domain of chart image understanding due to the
distinct abstract components in charts. To address this, we introduce a
large-scale MultiModal Chart Instruction (\textbf{MMC-Instruction}) dataset
comprising 600k instances supporting diverse tasks and chart types. Leveraging
this data, we develop MultiModal Chart Assistant (\textbf{MMCA}), an LMM that
achieves state-of-the-art performance on existing chart QA benchmarks.
Recognizing the need for a comprehensive evaluation of LMM chart understanding,
we also propose a MultiModal Chart Benchmark (\textbf{MMC-Benchmark}), a
comprehensive human-annotated benchmark with nine distinct tasks evaluating
reasoning capabilities over charts. Extensive experiments on MMC-Benchmark
reveal the limitations of existing LMMs on correctly interpreting charts, even
for the most recent GPT-4V model. Our work provides an instruction-tuning
methodology and benchmark to advance multimodal understanding of charts. Code
and data are available at https://github.com/FuxiaoLiu/MMC. | [
-0.041177623,
0.0650114045,
-0.0091823963,
0.0556274541,
-0.0260924511,
0.0172310844,
0.0123090288,
-0.0161462296,
0.0161381997,
0.0028876523,
-0.0520619117,
-0.0271338373,
0.009555622,
0.0128066288,
0.0208121035,
-0.0931366459,
0.0217285696,
-0.0404312871,
-0.0061252234,
-0.0028460587,
-0.0106671331,
-0.0057986439,
-0.0474359915,
0.0414277799,
-0.0381586254,
-0.0671022683,
-0.0185359567,
0.0250266921,
0.0038732188,
-0.0694509521,
-0.0515743531,
0.0308331512,
0.0317393094,
0.0239488687,
0.0000022476,
-0.0173927546,
0.0183652528,
-0.0082874205,
-0.014286276,
-0.0186322406,
0.0510503054,
-0.0720644891,
0.0228424873,
-0.0386597477,
-0.019825615,
0.0046677985,
0.0438661091,
-0.0267740395,
0.0969781578,
0.0033660885,
-0.0031806612,
0.0068415566,
-0.0283672139,
-0.0374051593,
0.0367937088,
-0.091002509,
-0.0026307183,
0.048270274,
0.0378463417,
0.0291911624,
-0.0827193186,
0.0442210995,
0.0385524854,
0.0287727844,
-0.0233382005,
0.0257826019,
0.0073876036,
-0.0522119291,
-0.017949434,
0.1121810302,
-0.0121407993,
0.0253500398,
-0.0060138274,
0.003354887,
-0.0044283858,
0.041139923,
-0.0945363939,
-0.017315492,
-0.0260443706,
-0.0402910337,
-0.0448066592,
-0.0241502989,
0.0022672417,
-0.0309834536,
-0.0229267348,
0.0150563121,
-0.0196699128,
0.0180005878,
0.0144420313,
-0.0051621795,
-0.0634368137,
-0.0419026017,
-0.0041758455,
0.0421144068,
-0.0345119983,
-0.0020939673,
-0.0338894464,
-0.038937144,
-0.007900943,
-0.00494147,
0.0861087292,
0.0440721922,
-0.0497485623,
0.0722580701,
-0.0096683325,
0.0573598146,
-0.0200666189,
0.0251166951,
-0.028909754,
-0.0192479379,
-0.0390217267,
0.0007533566,
-0.0190277658,
-0.0512999594,
-0.0417330191,
-0.0349937491,
-0.0185774993,
0.0170426052,
-0.0240543578,
0.0570073128,
-0.0030252452,
0.0071933502,
-0.0494616106,
-0.0161091406,
-0.0322743095,
0.0647247434,
-0.0710676014,
0.0028589326,
-0.0263020732,
-0.0315836407,
-0.0235185884,
0.0484433435,
0.0121214213,
-0.0139417872,
-0.0094185881,
0.1029765382,
-0.0030569539,
-0.0028891212,
-0.0027084982,
-0.0467543639,
-0.0105197188,
-0.0591388829,
0.0406232961,
-0.0237184651,
0.0476494059,
0.0029934533,
0.0148942089,
-0.0036618714,
0.0127252098,
0.0234114714,
-0.0122893518,
0.0865783915,
0.0042735874,
-0.0061902022,
-0.0045210118,
-0.0006019755,
-0.0747355521,
0.0695867613,
0.0425699912,
0.0337285586,
0.0209814664,
-0.032674171,
0.0080811549,
0.0593614765,
0.0017066208,
-0.0217957385,
-0.0347284377,
0.0197992027,
-0.0547669865,
0.0283180699,
0.0621213801,
0.0134561844,
-0.0476754718,
-0.0566041246,
0.0500042699,
0.0261428673,
0.0371490419,
-0.035391178,
0.0346105136,
-0.00390088,
0.0258540902,
-0.0164933186,
-0.0610929132,
0.0792205259,
0.0498793609,
0.0133867292,
-0.0247782879,
-0.0304365233,
-0.013013375,
-0.0315933079,
-0.0050497088,
0.0100297648,
-0.0165539403,
0.0108703114,
0.0318643339,
0.0133574586,
-0.0170930643,
0.0097211087,
-0.0198250581,
-0.0174535979,
-0.0305845607,
0.0195366777,
0.0138549851,
0.0431550629,
0.0406502374,
-0.0129562579,
-0.0457522199,
0.0013233691,
0.0159351695,
0.0410087742,
0.009554429,
-0.0189982653,
0.0037068059,
-0.0611681454,
-0.0494332016,
-0.0191120505,
0.0081672873,
0.0405328795,
-0.0002830072,
-0.0287089646,
-0.0246265139,
-0.1059284434,
0.032043539,
-0.0121195288,
0.0197543819,
-0.0351997688,
-0.0248181876,
0.0250199568,
0.0110705784,
0.0008710564,
0.0069113444,
0.0170560628,
-0.0025691581,
-0.0200135838,
0.038818337,
0.0430219434,
-0.0529821403,
-0.0403817333,
0.0191480387,
-0.0474067219,
-0.047287941,
0.0175157171,
-0.0449135527,
-0.021779947,
0.0431553796,
-0.0342148542,
-0.0269922446,
0.0010279338,
-0.0371636152,
0.012705612,
0.0027643489,
-0.0071837804,
0.0447372161,
-0.0438676178,
0.012255216,
0.0108837839,
0.0675614327,
0.0408353247,
-0.0015980621,
0.0178525764,
0.0359318256,
0.0094616115,
0.0131535651,
-0.0374231115,
-0.0122214658,
-0.0379973464,
0.0232264008,
-0.0805236399,
-0.0047716657,
-0.0073212101,
0.0190656222,
0.0132346014,
-0.0349862054,
-0.0097494693,
-0.0478678793,
0.0010596947,
0.0477120019,
-0.0232100151,
0.0145001477,
0.034137886,
-0.0044253217,
0.0047756131,
-0.0101288045,
0.0058959271,
-0.0330790319,
0.0363827944,
0.0252942014,
0.0328568667,
0.0080779735,
-0.034004122,
-0.0403822064,
0.002095538,
-0.0180847533,
0.0040319799,
0.0601640642,
-0.0162276812,
0.0737580135,
0.0621688776,
-0.0509737842,
0.0545631386,
0.0089875041,
-0.0513594076,
-0.0280632302,
0.035594698,
0.0240134113,
-0.0096736057,
-0.0075535937,
0.0014679043,
-0.0435756035,
0.0957818702,
-0.0053232238,
0.0192018449,
-0.0290501937,
0.0132716279,
-0.0132635441,
-0.0121200141,
-0.0694077611,
0.0411549062,
-0.0055055055,
0.0176449809,
-0.0584867522,
-0.0453227945,
0.0460694507,
-0.052345939,
-0.0405698977,
0.0076340018,
0.0124628833,
-0.0356506705,
0.0873751342,
0.0275292937,
-0.0000496316,
-0.0471150279,
-0.022381641,
-0.055647172,
0.0262846835,
0.0268934779,
-0.0226037167,
0.0154630309,
-0.0761462823,
-0.0041015693,
-0.0362108238,
0.0161771867,
-0.0091011878,
0.0139873624,
-0.0261126515,
0.0148303416,
-0.0062930426,
-0.0342094265,
-0.0214416739,
-0.0077757821,
0.03335841,
-0.0148956114,
-0.0022435708,
-0.0034266233,
-0.0340463221,
0.0006568445,
0.0077123186,
0.0457884967,
-0.0378654264,
-0.0771350265,
0.007775302,
0.0441677831,
0.029811861,
0.0029133558,
-0.0367731191,
0.0362321921,
-0.0201792512,
0.0307781752,
-0.0026028152,
0.0397016443,
0.0654136539,
-0.0616898984,
0.0299755801,
0.0397460572,
-0.0041102734,
-0.0280154981,
-0.0205635447,
0.011060711,
0.0345014147,
0.0434881598,
0.0070172376,
-0.1338710189,
-0.0593314134,
0.0148329409,
0.0306558367,
0.0598869398,
-0.0524027348,
-0.0189854503,
-0.0829016864,
0.0734835044,
-0.0026184695,
-0.0503278524,
-0.0032066861,
-0.0232920256,
0.0258615296,
-0.0014025699,
-0.017670678,
-0.0063188155,
0.0013167834,
0.0205059629,
0.0202920195,
-0.0181508064,
-0.0233002622,
0.0214221813,
-0.0229266733,
-0.0357262716,
-0.0007434791,
0.0269352198,
0.0215119682,
-0.0411893092,
0.0010764776,
0.0255238451,
0.0112803448,
-0.0093696006,
0.0600797795,
0.0095917899,
-0.0524530075,
0.0062993225,
0.0413541123,
-0.0206503645,
-0.0162546746,
-0.0229933746,
0.0686644912,
-0.0176331904,
0.0038191746,
-0.0427993275,
0.0154412379,
-0.0090793297,
0.0226432718,
0.070664607,
0.0056160749,
-0.0561077595,
-0.0641399994,
0.0143573312,
-0.0975862816,
-0.0001198398,
0.033777371,
0.0231012516,
-0.008530912,
-0.0117085753,
-0.0362324156,
0.047257103,
0.0424399562,
-0.0189682618,
-0.0260830373,
0.0068668495,
-0.0226974264,
-0.0407516174,
0.079197377,
-0.0454141572,
0.056694746,
-0.0201373678,
-0.0194753483,
-0.0189201161,
0.0144513128,
-0.0293715354,
0.0364783444,
-0.1037694663,
0.008709034,
-0.0126073565,
0.0499378368,
0.016337296,
0.0210568253,
0.0021446527,
-0.0222861879,
0.0238067955,
0.0559463874,
-0.0080023808,
-0.0012712219,
0.0047351304,
0.0221165251,
-0.0072266809,
0.0032383085,
-0.0180740785,
0.0426034965,
-0.0044409782,
0.0462137125,
-0.0004670755,
0.0282598156,
0.0085205724,
0.0245357547,
0.0221798606,
0.017617302,
0.0068097445,
-0.0013353126,
-0.0311842412,
-0.0044806316,
-0.0172467679,
-0.0356921032,
-0.0241741724,
0.03273632,
-0.0303534791,
0.0049321726,
-0.0166496653,
0.0281669106,
0.0339441001,
-0.0481456518,
0.0575514212,
0.0327771679,
-0.0292023066,
0.0099934591,
0.0264369342,
0.0164121054,
0.010154264,
-0.0255481657,
0.0596281812,
0.0199430082,
0.0697416142,
0.0114545049,
0.0051344582,
-0.0232152753,
0.0221732985,
-0.0383074582,
-0.0779433623,
0.0258024167,
0.0195939504,
0.0610057563,
0.0018252443,
0.0159644,
-0.0189874452,
-0.0011869264,
0.0108489394,
0.0291309319,
0.0044781878,
0.0019135408,
0.0838367641,
0.036455404,
0.0240094345,
-0.060097944,
0.0701027289,
-0.010069211,
0.0386008583,
-0.039480444,
0.0095217153,
-0.0560896806,
-0.009197522,
0.0281823073,
0.0015155767,
0.020807201,
0.0304894,
-0.0647911131,
-0.0773453191,
-0.0021194504,
0.0417873338,
-0.0223646145,
0.011533007,
0.0462853424,
0.0486646928,
0.0064561819,
-0.0219783615,
-0.0075693512,
0.003850016,
-0.0009108041,
-0.0220211484,
0.0047880528,
-5.990870959e-33,
-0.0280372798,
-0.0383406207,
0.0530192368,
-0.0304345135,
-0.0048355237,
-0.0034012869,
-0.0434515029,
0.0025715672,
-0.0036806897,
0.0219083205,
0.028829135,
-0.010007361,
-0.0046419702,
-0.0007123266,
0.0134074148,
0.0043055699,
0.0365187861,
-0.0079160631,
-0.0287122484,
-0.0133881755,
0.04126212,
0.0248895977,
0.0290152971,
-0.0547372513,
0.0088964095,
0.0349437408,
-0.002535708,
0.0096340515,
0.0038286813,
0.0532807522,
-0.0233530216,
0.0290525407,
0.0254713651,
-0.0150208753,
-0.0383139364,
0.0297479499,
-0.0666825995,
-0.0542103238,
-0.0021191826,
0.0386937968,
-0.0814467594,
0.0017391843,
0.0600399859,
-0.0055285385,
-0.0059325648,
-0.0440636016,
0.0171991866,
-0.0074293488,
-0.009318633,
0.0677008256,
-0.0178397223,
0.030724356,
-0.0112569705,
-0.0434896946,
0.0406535119,
0.080784142,
0.0205134898,
0.0614537373,
-0.0552656204,
0.034107022,
-0.0385549739,
-0.0357079171,
0.0709263533,
0.0448132157,
0.0175865833,
0.0400734618,
0.0196045525,
-0.0159629937,
-0.0448725224,
0.0260786302,
0.0330503993,
0.0838214606,
0.0205337014,
0.0270551834,
0.0371812619,
0.0094115091,
-0.0032205875,
0.0528444387,
-0.0297766477,
0.0732328445,
-0.0473697707,
0.028198421,
-0.0225764979,
-0.0095680244,
-0.0334979147,
-0.0132850511,
-0.0488160551,
0.0132742655,
0.0454472788,
-0.0210800674,
0.000577405,
0.031593509,
0.0452677645,
-0.0300855935,
-0.0131790936,
-0.0243610609,
-0.0074907998,
0.0626339838,
0.0164782871,
0.0049294024,
-0.0338017307,
-0.0057445038,
0.0344667807,
-0.0170076862,
0.0489537902,
-0.0054622255,
0.0197096933,
0.0208577141,
-0.0372832902,
-0.0211405717,
-0.0383436568,
-0.0340838023,
-0.0044865496,
0.0085489918,
0.0533012711,
-0.0039874041,
-0.0508615039,
0.0231766887,
-0.0110040875,
0.0331907757,
-0.0214357786,
-0.041959025,
-0.0671158656,
0.0080885096,
-0.0015522927,
-0.0050108824,
-0.0368349254,
-0.0645081252,
0.0113110468,
-0.0694577098,
-0.0027597002,
-0.0004039532,
2.795e-7,
0.0551099293,
0.0487591922,
0.0137358028,
0.0546828471,
0.0357419699,
0.0377650969,
-0.0737633407,
-0.0133145927,
-0.0295905806,
-0.040039286,
0.005147968,
0.045756612,
0.0426888652,
0.0783838332,
-0.0103393411,
-0.0075910543,
0.0180773456,
-0.0022421475,
-0.0613240637,
0.0323139243,
0.075424172,
0.0192312468,
-0.0223736595,
-0.0129731763,
0.0596267134,
-0.0436227135,
0.0882689878,
-0.0064239493,
0.0023500926,
-0.0411915146,
0.009654738,
0.0279134158,
0.0090420973,
0.0102434633,
0.0022606454,
-0.0281389486,
0.0379353836,
0.036116533,
-0.002220304,
0.0085729025,
0.0019609742,
0.0060022231,
-0.0000611425,
-0.0415791459,
0.0546048619,
-0.0611285791,
-0.0531030558,
-0.0002131009,
-0.0297296885,
0.0176130645,
0.027540924,
0.0060429717,
-0.032494586,
-0.014128725,
0.0346719362,
-0.0141974399,
-0.0001469573,
-0.0263526216,
-0.0229838639,
0.0415832251,
-0.0523898825,
-0.016194921,
-0.055464007,
-0.0302149653,
0.0110647343,
-0.0023527839,
-0.0757301673,
2.289040609e-34,
0.0223252103,
-0.0235624574,
0.0481579565,
-0.0097782649,
0.045918487,
-0.0344933458,
-0.0005884767,
0.0304497518,
0.0107720001,
-0.0770068467,
-0.0204786472
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09447v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09447v2 | How Trustworthy are Open-Source LLMs? An Assessment under Malicious Demonstrations Shows their Vulnerabilities | 2023-11-15T23:33:07 | 2024-04-02T15:21:55 | Lingbo Mo, Boshi Wang, Muhao Chen, Huan Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The rapid progress in open-source Large Language Models (LLMs) is
significantly driving AI development forward. However, there is still a limited
understanding of their trustworthiness. Deploying these models at scale without
sufficient trustworthiness can pose significant risks, highlighting the need to
uncover these issues promptly. In this work, we conduct an adversarial
assessment of open-source LLMs on trustworthiness, scrutinizing them across
eight different aspects including toxicity, stereotypes, ethics, hallucination,
fairness, sycophancy, privacy, and robustness against adversarial
demonstrations. We propose advCoU, an extended Chain of Utterances-based (CoU)
prompting strategy by incorporating carefully crafted malicious demonstrations
for trustworthiness attack. Our extensive experiments encompass recent and
representative series of open-source LLMs, including Vicuna, MPT, Falcon,
Mistral, and Llama 2. The empirical outcomes underscore the efficacy of our
attack strategy across diverse aspects. More interestingly, our result analysis
reveals that models with superior performance in general NLP tasks do not
always have greater trustworthiness; in fact, larger models can be more
vulnerable to attacks. Additionally, models that have undergone instruction
tuning, focusing on instruction following, tend to be more susceptible,
although fine-tuning LLMs for safety alignment proves effective in mitigating
adversarial trustworthiness attacks. | [
0.0361221097,
0.0996019393,
-0.0142462412,
0.0553960018,
-0.0411559083,
-0.0238461345,
0.0332711115,
-0.0208885744,
0.0620319918,
-0.0220017973,
-0.0521463715,
-0.0286800992,
0.0262534115,
0.0284752436,
0.0512547046,
-0.0164255481,
0.0590041727,
-0.0305223148,
-0.0200105105,
-0.0243402999,
-0.0054873242,
-0.0127986334,
-0.0239981785,
0.0397871807,
0.0125745609,
-0.0345372967,
-0.0027969978,
-0.0077329073,
0.0248300061,
-0.0227248017,
-0.013592815,
0.0609490462,
-0.0149192903,
0.0565634817,
0.0000021171,
-0.0686741024,
0.0014184422,
0.0290456247,
-0.0225323774,
0.0489290059,
0.0225200821,
-0.0019882622,
-0.0147255417,
0.0156216649,
-0.0294220075,
0.0093808668,
0.0148958741,
0.0395177975,
0.0660104901,
0.0775896683,
0.0154012125,
0.0194083229,
0.0649663061,
-0.0408330485,
0.010342421,
-0.0437591001,
0.0162793696,
-0.0875012651,
-0.0371408761,
0.0040473077,
0.0097231036,
0.0085653616,
0.0307672191,
-0.0074542793,
-0.0094000241,
0.0284959693,
-0.0498817489,
-0.0349182561,
-0.0400264151,
0.067801103,
0.0157376714,
-0.0113747083,
-0.0016306469,
0.0169210285,
0.0192108564,
0.0112081161,
0.004851344,
0.0266628712,
-0.00370838,
-0.0269978251,
0.0065628476,
0.008018801,
0.0436819717,
0.0330210179,
0.0131774759,
0.0377608463,
0.002404083,
-0.0259231906,
0.0499652028,
-0.033779718,
-0.0108545804,
-0.0816872567,
-0.0088157849,
0.0056381347,
-0.0010821732,
0.0240613464,
-0.067615971,
0.0008611549,
0.0602061711,
-0.0166167151,
0.0019788765,
0.0263919644,
-0.0357945934,
0.0143877249,
0.0013811007,
0.0525144488,
-0.0205671825,
0.0810245126,
0.0181953628,
0.0283068363,
0.0138629042,
-0.0095861787,
0.0090491809,
0.0133575303,
-0.0219648909,
0.0207528211,
-0.0291736182,
0.0100873001,
-0.0583245754,
0.0703231469,
0.0343138315,
0.010788966,
0.0058670077,
-0.0050410572,
-0.0255891588,
-0.0311296172,
-0.01417688,
-0.0078216856,
0.0013170373,
-0.1152126491,
-0.0447133258,
0.0108842729,
-0.0719876066,
-0.0374006145,
-0.0046842168,
0.1161512062,
0.0331019685,
-0.0669234917,
-0.0189052224,
-0.0397531874,
-0.0423513539,
-0.0596679822,
0.0124483416,
-0.0394960828,
-0.0107656065,
-0.0200431738,
-0.0158150941,
-0.07385616,
0.0214178935,
0.0086005526,
-0.0561950617,
0.0574893579,
0.0197941046,
-0.0123880403,
-0.0131132025,
0.0448893458,
-0.0567708276,
0.0161622986,
0.0200169049,
0.0492222346,
0.0499219261,
-0.0001288574,
0.0499800108,
0.039805647,
0.0426108278,
0.0301154815,
0.0311556756,
0.0285530165,
-0.0162302442,
0.0093997112,
-0.0232081041,
0.0942137837,
-0.0109024774,
-0.071731016,
0.1161937118,
0.0152501855,
-0.0636038631,
-0.0179006457,
0.0009230798,
-0.0024940127,
0.0150672225,
0.0167886987,
-0.1135543883,
0.0076865456,
-0.0525542907,
-0.0416524112,
-0.0097871134,
0.0592848659,
-0.0173443649,
-0.0274936054,
-0.0042952825,
-0.0273302905,
0.0479982048,
0.0145563297,
0.0027809225,
0.0306841489,
-0.035545975,
0.0024161418,
0.0217324849,
-0.051978536,
-0.0270485338,
-0.0636805445,
0.0506049395,
0.0242851358,
0.0647978261,
0.0056415531,
0.0314165205,
-0.0550539568,
-0.00216825,
0.0268820208,
0.0399924926,
0.001063604,
0.0126992622,
-0.0214625318,
0.0160627123,
-0.0384088457,
0.0185898542,
0.0319686644,
0.0404483825,
0.0283198748,
-0.0252863858,
-0.0300336741,
-0.0238584448,
0.0406772345,
0.0088805361,
-0.0334030762,
-0.0123835187,
0.0141186258,
0.0407940187,
0.0346547142,
-0.0215857066,
0.0136437668,
0.059914723,
0.0170710161,
-0.0042222296,
0.0190326143,
-0.0393511951,
0.0136016384,
0.0221137404,
-0.0212254096,
-0.026408691,
0.0509463884,
-0.0254906043,
0.0186264329,
0.0244458374,
-0.0079752021,
0.0069042449,
-0.0173877198,
0.0221783668,
-0.0221471544,
0.0297074169,
-0.0160036366,
0.0385233834,
-0.0523442663,
-0.0085195079,
-0.0142426332,
0.0347092971,
-0.0008786814,
-0.0182862449,
-0.0371837169,
0.0195525009,
-0.023331333,
0.0318527631,
-0.0032789267,
-0.0173811745,
-0.0270336047,
-0.0318988822,
-0.0488006771,
-0.0060892762,
-0.0238300618,
0.0174054261,
0.0161201023,
-0.028183369,
-0.0153304227,
0.0130870137,
-0.0097771538,
0.0023760123,
-0.0041025518,
0.0207862835,
0.0115209781,
-0.0200012438,
-0.0334401801,
-0.0060560661,
0.015626261,
-0.0033338876,
0.0505228192,
-0.0153332707,
0.0053789485,
-0.0186438859,
0.0108206151,
-0.0134879872,
0.0379385985,
-0.0147559205,
-0.0502442308,
0.0367689282,
0.0590964481,
-0.0095309569,
0.0948906839,
0.0390143022,
0.0595123544,
0.0630833209,
0.0430488884,
-0.0294619817,
-0.0077743093,
0.029845316,
-0.0626323447,
-0.0196877848,
-0.0257185604,
0.0120262494,
0.0423448682,
0.0332636312,
-0.015233973,
-0.022009965,
0.018297065,
-0.0127028599,
-0.0632221699,
0.03500003,
-0.0540390611,
-0.0314936228,
0.0083076134,
-0.0193128884,
-0.0881673321,
0.0836325809,
-0.0675442666,
0.0121562295,
0.0003063717,
-0.021671867,
0.0097174989,
0.0614676774,
-0.0058859703,
0.0012443003,
0.0383924209,
0.0032547403,
-0.0330157578,
-0.0228138845,
0.0049997466,
-0.027320385,
0.0188127737,
-0.0390669703,
-0.0218451545,
0.005919666,
-0.0509466417,
-0.070357427,
-0.0604186952,
-0.0207991265,
-0.0164161734,
0.0094454121,
-0.0206369776,
-0.0304675773,
-0.0432982035,
0.0448112823,
-0.004052599,
-0.0240713116,
0.0039926399,
-0.0306710321,
0.0031549239,
0.0338138193,
-0.0316754505,
0.043948248,
-0.0136408862,
0.0183654409,
0.0855248943,
0.0289542582,
0.0256742574,
-0.0181610975,
-0.0265086889,
0.0053457282,
-0.0112417918,
0.0221974198,
0.0306259356,
0.0629951283,
-0.0186668914,
0.0025445465,
0.0606253855,
0.0003268998,
-0.0173278321,
0.0306274928,
0.0197282806,
0.0304458477,
0.016212156,
-0.0185893979,
-0.0975513533,
-0.0135128861,
0.0241249353,
0.048330117,
-0.026867386,
-0.0393309109,
0.0002886443,
-0.1325879246,
0.0217606798,
-0.01107118,
-0.0239478201,
-0.0001567201,
-0.0538287424,
-0.0197301079,
-0.0414884612,
0.057683818,
-0.0007256225,
0.0179410744,
-0.0226246864,
-0.0059175752,
0.0176074244,
-0.0237545427,
0.047725182,
-0.0529998578,
0.0656671226,
0.0648771003,
0.0093272282,
-0.0299852137,
-0.0757331997,
0.0005919453,
-0.0101429336,
-0.0088483589,
0.018548388,
0.0828413889,
-0.0338843912,
-0.007745448,
0.0143217109,
0.0496886894,
-0.0121319471,
-0.0018709244,
0.0379431844,
0.0241654329,
0.0158851407,
-0.0617517568,
-0.0234523863,
-0.0156066688,
0.0309451334,
0.0706750602,
0.0010119433,
-0.0336461626,
-0.0091884304,
-0.0347287022,
-0.016316412,
0.0231199786,
-0.0414787047,
0.0434798971,
0.0319141299,
-0.0348538533,
-0.0682131872,
-0.0380149074,
-0.0194200519,
0.0263680648,
0.0273582675,
-0.0178049225,
0.0034998704,
0.0223266073,
-0.0120465029,
0.0318495445,
-0.0302958712,
0.0612625405,
-0.0388862155,
0.0334576331,
0.0103785712,
-0.0339232273,
-0.0003638919,
0.0320120528,
-0.0439589135,
-0.0826048031,
0.0086968122,
0.0778217539,
0.0255492777,
0.0400858596,
-0.0361942761,
-0.0350221023,
0.0489110909,
0.0243705101,
-0.0283680093,
0.0339556448,
0.0621130913,
-0.0216221567,
0.0249496922,
0.0174665637,
-0.0192836206,
-0.0073405807,
0.0419314392,
-0.0090713389,
-0.0101780714,
-0.0218129158,
0.0189736784,
0.0319819935,
0.0697834492,
-0.0333337709,
0.055319842,
-0.0156299137,
0.0284848623,
-0.0075329402,
-0.0108560082,
-0.0005397339,
0.0173455719,
0.0262431521,
-0.0046674646,
0.0257773306,
-0.0438947678,
-0.0158855617,
0.0274589602,
-0.0256042127,
0.0170322601,
0.0296270885,
0.0402601473,
0.0197618306,
0.0111892838,
-0.026118502,
0.0421846174,
-0.0524185225,
0.0403189138,
0.0284670554,
0.0348588936,
-0.0053991168,
-0.0101512792,
0.041124925,
0.0517722033,
-0.049945619,
-0.0560684018,
0.0046384651,
0.0425774045,
0.0043008751,
0.0232286006,
0.0296011083,
-0.0156362858,
0.0150201051,
-0.0176564623,
-0.0251953676,
-0.0117358072,
-0.052969683,
0.0434258133,
0.0044100326,
-0.0210057292,
0.0468206629,
0.0597770698,
-0.0304871202,
0.063671656,
-0.0106887314,
0.000593113,
-0.0264521725,
-0.0568580814,
0.0236537121,
0.0072569372,
-0.0287167057,
-0.0440924354,
-0.0642557442,
-0.0796633363,
-0.0152794188,
0.0161016975,
0.0331087224,
-0.0309696533,
0.0147173116,
0.0558670349,
0.0087638786,
0.0428222045,
-0.0402992889,
-0.0351187252,
0.002291624,
-0.0501142181,
0.021941293,
-6.419348201e-33,
0.025830796,
-0.0337981991,
-0.0236039627,
-0.0199823696,
0.0118576726,
0.0107961791,
-0.0080045797,
0.0156805646,
-0.0699605867,
-0.0192561485,
-0.0172672532,
0.0003485581,
0.0069996268,
-0.0100550484,
-0.020111559,
-0.0211015157,
0.0148165878,
-0.0280060023,
-0.0368768312,
0.0146036809,
0.0253291409,
-0.0160316061,
0.036811389,
-0.091704987,
0.0951650888,
-0.0044714985,
-0.047884956,
0.0120158652,
-0.0772796944,
0.0249385871,
-0.0052376441,
0.0324669704,
-0.016183475,
0.0046897689,
0.0244537387,
0.0015186763,
-0.000834836,
0.0015842061,
0.0146727609,
-0.019855177,
-0.0457390919,
-0.0223562941,
0.025729144,
-0.0211748481,
-0.0369508453,
-0.0063885339,
-0.0251726564,
-0.0031031386,
-0.018198289,
-0.0048007825,
-0.0098950891,
-0.0003792435,
-0.0162164085,
-0.0357196257,
-0.0336621813,
0.0274452418,
0.007458623,
0.0112968087,
-0.0538750589,
0.0246794503,
0.0032805244,
-0.0228041355,
0.0738255084,
-0.060620673,
0.0090036709,
0.0668872297,
0.0242307838,
0.016753519,
-0.0189546123,
-0.0055486746,
0.0018448918,
0.0419858247,
0.0853762925,
0.0791899413,
0.0189864561,
-0.0433714911,
-0.0536258072,
-0.0011723811,
0.0368996188,
0.0101524759,
0.0348544158,
-0.0111817876,
-0.0829318315,
0.0098197479,
-0.0428341217,
-0.0604953952,
-0.0363526158,
-0.0353255831,
0.0170662031,
0.0258543864,
-0.0420961343,
-0.019542912,
-0.0035150927,
-0.0410700813,
0.0195775311,
0.0294889659,
0.0014459145,
-0.0010538446,
-0.0204122439,
0.0056510717,
-0.0444413424,
-0.0038411515,
0.0068791425,
-0.0218412504,
0.0390766263,
0.0354302302,
0.0379727781,
0.0088797286,
-0.0382201634,
0.0187464766,
-0.0252725277,
0.057541918,
0.0389692374,
-0.0093899593,
0.0433028191,
-0.0144797591,
-0.0205122028,
0.0273594223,
0.023103701,
0.0058467942,
-0.0641521141,
0.0507843941,
-0.03809065,
0.0009495316,
-0.0097518545,
-0.0235360861,
-0.0037378331,
0.0201019384,
0.0283843242,
-0.0728453249,
0.0012438488,
-0.0406993739,
2.986e-7,
-0.0638775602,
0.0213683676,
0.0203332119,
0.0315747857,
0.0201571248,
0.0555420779,
-0.0125791375,
0.0893727988,
-0.0320906788,
-0.0857288316,
-0.0492730215,
0.0080148289,
0.0484382994,
0.0493660495,
-0.0570202135,
-0.0171514526,
-0.0956926271,
0.0009699195,
-0.0530025773,
-0.0101377759,
0.0148903988,
0.0953458846,
0.0183520131,
-0.0064454321,
-0.0044596484,
-0.0435395725,
0.0214777589,
-0.002542869,
0.0043468503,
-0.0154970698,
0.0392305553,
0.0090119783,
-0.0069169691,
0.0176521409,
-0.0007066528,
0.0107917804,
-0.0272845626,
0.0355760381,
0.0075733713,
-0.0350415073,
-0.0024736952,
-0.043184828,
-0.0083690751,
-0.05865971,
0.0656462163,
-0.0012103027,
-0.0271311123,
-0.0058257007,
0.0053746989,
-0.0348857045,
0.0613808818,
-0.0215854179,
0.0223696772,
-0.004209138,
-0.0065211561,
-0.0053558517,
0.0091315806,
-0.0341735929,
-0.0289424788,
-0.0678926185,
0.0176856127,
-0.0811950564,
0.023518024,
0.0274155624,
-0.0245149601,
-0.0326929353,
-0.0037536847,
2.583715002e-34,
0.006518255,
-0.0361551158,
0.014299226,
-0.0074494472,
0.0629644766,
0.0006713859,
0.0181940626,
-0.0121364519,
0.0050177006,
-0.0310649257,
-0.0303212143
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09443v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09443v1 | Subtle Misogyny Detection and Mitigation: An Expert-Annotated Dataset | 2023-11-15T23:27:19 | 2023-11-15T23:27:19 | Brooklyn Sheppard, Anna Richter, Allison Cohen, Elizabeth Allyn Smith, Tamara Kneese, Carolyne Pelletier, Ioana Baldini, Yue Dong | cs.CL | cs.CL | Using novel approaches to dataset development, the Biasly dataset captures
the nuance and subtlety of misogyny in ways that are unique within the
literature. Built in collaboration with multi-disciplinary experts and
annotators themselves, the dataset contains annotations of movie subtitles,
capturing colloquial expressions of misogyny in North American film. The
dataset can be used for a range of NLP tasks, including classification,
severity score regression, and text generation for rewrites. In this paper, we
discuss the methodology used, analyze the annotations obtained, and provide
baselines using common NLP algorithms in the context of misogyny detection and
mitigation. We hope this work will promote AI for social good in NLP for bias
detection, explanation, and removal. | [
0.0856170952,
0.0578297786,
-0.013116437,
0.0204040203,
-0.0030326715,
0.0232406612,
0.043050535,
0.0055963476,
0.0294662118,
-0.0762897506,
0.0081178471,
0.0092543941,
0.0238919947,
-0.0003981098,
0.0067336634,
-0.0117486119,
0.0138056101,
0.0756210387,
0.0720022023,
-0.0349681936,
0.0757887587,
0.0344076492,
-0.0025636551,
0.053185828,
-0.0624958538,
-0.0228829589,
0.0857506841,
0.0427995883,
0.006118183,
-0.0010104408,
0.0950855613,
0.0468768626,
0.0016526617,
0.0129586626,
0.0000015257,
-0.082941629,
0.0410524942,
0.0110029839,
0.0071226498,
-0.002746853,
0.0561660826,
-0.0323896669,
-0.0027036013,
0.0287571475,
0.0053121741,
0.0243218224,
0.0478293039,
0.021942867,
0.081463933,
0.0329155736,
-0.0232036896,
-0.009351166,
-0.0475471802,
-0.0055615297,
-0.0111325225,
0.0307479668,
0.0525081158,
0.0054053855,
-0.0525391661,
-0.0156999379,
-0.0123131406,
0.0030694492,
-0.0178560931,
-0.0197387543,
0.0152353616,
-0.0316892006,
-0.0368908979,
-0.0451658703,
0.0028105767,
0.0344457738,
0.0176387671,
-0.0198152624,
-0.0177843869,
-0.0041218111,
-0.0104076061,
0.0122902617,
-0.0112888273,
0.0030455713,
-0.0113155488,
-0.0144326556,
-0.0053142407,
-0.0105381878,
0.0228887908,
0.0718362927,
0.0763603672,
0.0191877112,
0.0054222206,
-0.022508068,
-0.030668458,
-0.0110167256,
0.0235808622,
-0.0272780526,
0.034236338,
-0.0226031393,
0.0162574016,
0.0100043993,
-0.0205195397,
-0.0288549643,
0.044395335,
-0.0670443848,
0.0017601581,
0.0390846618,
-0.0090802973,
-0.0054206369,
0.0329392105,
0.0095606735,
0.0141279604,
0.0101336632,
-0.0035905577,
-0.0251774881,
-0.014236087,
0.0087179951,
-0.0058821114,
-0.0076279812,
0.0054208525,
0.0646245703,
-0.0697388127,
-0.029608231,
-0.0784174725,
0.0032794792,
0.0102985092,
0.0300884172,
-0.0182733126,
0.003742829,
-0.0269190483,
0.0215798486,
-0.0572514683,
0.0278941169,
-0.044686459,
-0.0909041762,
-0.0053179832,
-0.004984885,
-0.0280676298,
-0.0132724606,
0.0372455828,
0.0461748093,
0.028673334,
-0.0333664231,
-0.0374437943,
-0.0203136113,
-0.0551387779,
-0.018891748,
-0.003610081,
-0.0628568009,
0.0609294325,
0.0062531368,
-0.0208913591,
-0.0693735555,
0.0006439374,
0.0218857042,
-0.0464887172,
0.0542677082,
-0.0177897308,
-0.0291560795,
0.0881612301,
0.0255808197,
-0.0420302078,
0.0696756765,
0.062726669,
0.0040812623,
0.0611507446,
0.017491661,
0.008746786,
0.0339360572,
0.0338413604,
0.0347268209,
-0.0401298292,
0.0481992885,
-0.047956273,
0.0502765104,
0.030999776,
0.0132693192,
-0.0071300985,
-0.0584131442,
0.026415091,
0.0784641579,
-0.0203954987,
0.0688428953,
0.0717173293,
0.0432001539,
-0.0267332438,
0.0009719867,
-0.0574631989,
-0.0096829738,
-0.0115979332,
-0.0673771128,
-0.0060188589,
0.0080583161,
-0.0142669035,
-0.0585839525,
-0.0314076021,
0.023698885,
-0.0057529905,
-0.0213506967,
-0.0017623124,
0.0593753308,
-0.0039584655,
0.0207856819,
0.0582090542,
-0.0359573774,
0.0226229001,
-0.0227634963,
-0.0000307699,
0.1110169366,
0.024528427,
-0.0582238361,
-0.0194947515,
-0.0619965121,
-0.0014269978,
-0.0090524871,
0.0112998141,
-0.0241116639,
0.010457729,
-0.0386114866,
0.0072113229,
0.0346172787,
0.0312316213,
0.0147153335,
0.016058106,
0.0015339162,
-0.0178280082,
0.0212245919,
-0.0888768062,
0.039604295,
0.0181934536,
-0.0251251105,
0.0095191617,
0.0098094437,
0.0430328883,
0.0297311228,
-0.0485275127,
-0.0517707728,
-0.0083087841,
-0.0099608423,
-0.0023102947,
0.0210750625,
-0.0142953191,
-0.0196129605,
0.0168384537,
-0.0858021528,
-0.034039855,
0.0478192382,
-0.0278235804,
0.0189257823,
0.0384248532,
-0.0140706599,
-0.0328136086,
-0.0542050712,
-0.0356336646,
-0.0219031163,
0.0575673319,
-0.0278510898,
0.0041764462,
-0.0431773365,
-0.0148861902,
0.0116520841,
-0.05576507,
0.0106733181,
-0.0061185388,
-0.0199242327,
0.012416671,
0.0041985456,
0.0250130445,
0.0284538008,
-0.0087264273,
-0.0090865791,
-0.0164496433,
-0.0692920983,
-0.0201503057,
0.0037208598,
-0.023570152,
0.023864314,
0.003859434,
-0.0293757264,
0.0019800521,
0.0092167584,
-0.0640812963,
0.0080974782,
0.0105427951,
0.0449125357,
-0.0264320895,
-0.0110243885,
-0.0401527807,
-0.0327732377,
-0.056168925,
0.0491360351,
0.0196981691,
-0.0248277914,
-0.0019435614,
-0.0314259976,
-0.0064054709,
0.010182688,
-0.0030093838,
-0.0567163266,
-0.0022255178,
0.0807227492,
-0.015896773,
0.0377632305,
0.0413086116,
0.0912098512,
0.0381248668,
-0.0008724398,
-0.0130085405,
-0.007328765,
0.0307950173,
0.0162832513,
0.0045785233,
-0.0817863643,
-0.0096583907,
0.0101002781,
0.0212150142,
-0.0299001895,
-0.0529013723,
0.0617198311,
-0.0443633683,
-0.0484739728,
0.0100839809,
-0.0638983622,
-0.0025011655,
0.0321626589,
-0.0120269516,
-0.0134252207,
0.0439203754,
-0.0112306708,
-0.0169509817,
-0.0242926851,
-0.0119132092,
-0.002315948,
0.0344516113,
-0.0499691404,
0.0647379905,
-0.0084621152,
-0.0154155074,
-0.0107489014,
-0.0373637043,
0.0482710227,
-0.008254,
0.0063223317,
-0.0323466659,
0.0391343646,
0.0274391584,
-0.0206813179,
-0.0412027016,
-0.0763571262,
-0.0281697083,
-0.0365822278,
0.0036302984,
-0.0074224328,
-0.0093760276,
0.0111652939,
-0.0252073184,
0.0120003307,
-0.0114278216,
-0.0001897688,
0.0336676054,
-0.0388820395,
0.0214926954,
0.0025189365,
0.005408071,
0.0288703814,
-0.0013464784,
0.0332819819,
-0.0616689026,
0.0052075954,
-0.0002400907,
0.0346682742,
0.0360110812,
-0.0434890948,
0.0378111042,
-0.0446703583,
0.0102429884,
-0.0479407944,
-0.0032603981,
0.0886110887,
0.0091097457,
-0.0509352833,
0.0135214636,
0.0006608595,
0.0070922812,
0.051409822,
-0.0013129637,
-0.1049509346,
-0.0047480599,
0.004064111,
0.0245893355,
-0.0742794648,
-0.0697693974,
-0.0320072137,
-0.0864702761,
0.0287420135,
-0.0111290812,
-0.0146339303,
-0.0351821221,
0.0178103093,
-0.0074750627,
0.0022801405,
0.0253505912,
-0.0379514433,
0.0166148208,
-0.0041704876,
-0.0108405696,
-0.0419710502,
-0.0591303855,
0.0358912051,
-0.0197513551,
0.0653306618,
0.0134817632,
0.0673547462,
-0.0453923494,
0.0269674677,
0.0048783496,
-0.010748269,
-0.0093643554,
-0.0474536158,
0.0570944734,
-0.0448047407,
-0.0278892461,
-0.0045594373,
0.0383848548,
0.0445313156,
0.0203229878,
0.0114532635,
0.007140975,
0.02938441,
0.0185723603,
-0.0628846511,
0.0245865881,
0.0190443434,
0.068141669,
0.0287380088,
-0.0284205973,
0.0182105098,
-0.0504405536,
-0.0031373273,
0.0109688062,
-0.049216982,
-0.0099503137,
-0.0044934941,
-0.0137762874,
-0.0468213744,
-0.0584659129,
0.0385538973,
-0.0023217802,
0.0519632027,
-0.0832646564,
0.0140752392,
0.0055818013,
-0.0726901591,
-0.0287120659,
0.0046776356,
0.0069835628,
0.056594383,
-0.019225046,
-0.0089958142,
-0.0143857263,
-0.0211301986,
0.0360738598,
-0.0077433526,
-0.0683139265,
0.0564244948,
0.0677387938,
0.0164114702,
0.0657548606,
-0.0176979695,
-0.0661965534,
0.0432496443,
0.0333877429,
-0.0341210701,
0.0179101881,
0.0356658921,
0.0117537491,
-0.0050546871,
0.0323214009,
-0.0317082591,
0.0238733515,
-0.0189168621,
-0.0084638037,
-0.0281312037,
0.004965832,
0.0023875607,
0.0020481346,
-0.0053837001,
-0.0572806224,
-0.0097222803,
-0.0647613183,
-0.0251320526,
-0.0440632291,
-0.0416838378,
-0.0245523117,
0.0241464246,
-0.0045024292,
-0.0126717417,
-0.0665948242,
0.0038255758,
-0.0687322691,
-0.0006118473,
-0.0366312899,
0.0323810168,
0.0338809527,
0.0355512239,
-0.0179096255,
0.0247565787,
-0.0324809477,
0.0168563463,
-0.0202198904,
-0.0031731897,
0.0321633592,
0.0192653034,
0.0377631895,
0.0257231686,
-0.0308371726,
0.0152333919,
0.0186652225,
0.0061582453,
-0.0190249942,
0.0253924001,
0.0191177391,
-0.0566108041,
0.0451526828,
0.0149926776,
-0.0312001426,
0.0143265948,
0.0133697269,
-0.0195394661,
-0.0214256477,
0.0371486209,
0.0275863484,
-0.0121006863,
0.0152559178,
0.0179045107,
0.0035808997,
0.0536843166,
0.0600073673,
-0.0658290237,
-0.0095876409,
-0.0322965197,
0.0183486417,
0.0055226055,
0.0161161479,
-0.0058952514,
-0.0985943601,
-0.0337458998,
0.0016728871,
-0.0386556685,
0.0514090732,
-0.0017352637,
-0.0120004592,
0.0553461388,
-0.000759309,
0.0000435024,
-0.0166028943,
-0.0276090261,
-0.0228272136,
-0.0337755643,
-0.0200194865,
-5.320518123e-33,
-0.0334181339,
-0.0479603633,
-0.0315880813,
0.0100073814,
-0.0197887477,
0.0007217235,
0.0095513733,
-0.0219364166,
0.00256582,
0.0730539113,
0.0067578512,
0.0407827869,
0.0049975468,
-0.0064019808,
0.0161603373,
-0.0115891304,
0.052353356,
0.0015271439,
-0.0367493182,
-0.0105054444,
0.008562048,
0.0337817669,
0.0535033606,
-0.1041097641,
0.0868851766,
-0.0295876637,
-0.0445832051,
0.0273486041,
0.0101846289,
0.0260508657,
0.0000357935,
0.1185629517,
0.0238726735,
-0.0120261451,
0.0397935547,
0.0164662786,
-0.0440879613,
-0.0239354819,
0.0406207889,
0.0388534144,
0.0399435945,
-0.0109312758,
0.0304882899,
0.0164980106,
-0.0657116622,
-0.0176327433,
0.0774595737,
-0.0212736931,
0.0770568922,
-0.0001134131,
-0.07029441,
-0.0053362385,
-0.0716894418,
-0.0090392753,
0.0018723924,
-0.0056428369,
0.0251057558,
-0.0034519578,
-0.0481066704,
0.0051013334,
-0.0107140671,
-0.0076111015,
0.0042264769,
-0.0267476588,
0.0330639146,
0.0541590489,
0.0536501072,
0.0319547951,
0.027547067,
-0.0136261592,
0.0167797729,
-0.0298344735,
0.0006105785,
0.0862977952,
0.0227692723,
-0.0546565168,
-0.0610874966,
-0.0536428317,
0.0110690417,
0.0024280117,
0.0086426008,
-0.0373676158,
-0.0798909739,
-0.0678026974,
-0.0190343298,
-0.0538161434,
-0.0021803477,
-0.0218567196,
0.0070154425,
-0.0330737717,
-0.034497831,
0.0434119217,
-0.0276159849,
-0.051210776,
0.0022641486,
0.0154125514,
-0.0365582891,
-0.0347105525,
0.0514490493,
0.0212730058,
-0.0100263236,
0.0516160652,
-0.0031395422,
0.0067965388,
0.0550122336,
-0.0092371199,
0.0483408459,
0.0454025045,
-0.0399754047,
-0.00522797,
-0.0100113656,
0.0351261646,
-0.0483836941,
0.0364278853,
-0.0199929606,
0.0626446307,
-0.0334749073,
0.0097610839,
0.0640048683,
0.0432370529,
-0.0085603651,
0.0217848532,
0.0049268976,
0.0234894697,
-0.0413489118,
-0.0134543525,
0.032799527,
-0.0243978724,
0.040211454,
-0.0388433337,
-0.0035097024,
-0.0667141601,
2.235e-7,
0.0160704255,
0.0729914159,
0.0361619405,
0.0067467536,
0.0081871888,
0.0347105302,
0.0296370089,
0.0438403562,
0.0294844154,
-0.0205835309,
0.0346799977,
0.0338853486,
-0.025651332,
0.022181876,
-0.0448339172,
0.004563624,
-0.0602536537,
0.0105477646,
-0.013701072,
0.0012376908,
0.0031538785,
0.0363613293,
0.0576291569,
-0.0384219773,
-0.0250366516,
-0.0141572626,
0.0190633684,
-0.0337071121,
0.0039797877,
0.0164404903,
0.0571473725,
0.0042423392,
0.0185322873,
-0.0039206478,
0.016343113,
0.0021113399,
0.0298887622,
0.0278355386,
-0.0411643758,
0.0128402486,
-0.0055682715,
0.0409713946,
-0.0432754382,
-0.0354641192,
0.0173708834,
0.0494663604,
-0.0514171571,
-0.0561646521,
-0.0327199027,
-0.0008105077,
0.0513614826,
-0.0476026163,
-0.021710122,
0.0013250489,
0.0372566283,
0.0124310507,
-0.00343254,
-0.0511453338,
-0.0125587489,
0.0051225913,
-0.006760898,
-0.0263245776,
0.0416763052,
0.0019202445,
0.0047188909,
-0.0164995845,
0.0418555774,
1.748474723e-34,
0.0336020999,
0.0061264513,
0.0237559117,
-0.0047907205,
0.0177495331,
0.0279057883,
-0.0058203335,
-0.0138158379,
0.0381092653,
0.0379817709,
-0.0202842038
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09438v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09438v2 | Labeled Interactive Topic Models | 2023-11-15T23:18:01 | 2024-02-07T14:41:40 | Kyle Seelman, Mozhi Zhang, Jordan Boyd-Graber | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.IR | Topic models are valuable for understanding extensive document collections,
but they don't always identify the most relevant topics. Classical
probabilistic and anchor-based topic models offer interactive versions that
allow users to guide the models towards more pertinent topics. However, such
interactive features have been lacking in neural topic models. To correct this
lacuna, we introduce a user-friendly interaction for neural topic models. This
interaction permits users to assign a word label to a topic, leading to an
update in the topic model where the words in the topic become closely aligned
with the given label. Our approach encompasses two distinct kinds of neural
topic models. The first includes models where topic embeddings are trainable
and evolve during the training process. The second kind involves models where
topic embeddings are integrated post-training, offering a different approach to
topic refinement. To facilitate user interaction with these neural topic
models, we have developed an interactive interface. This interface enables
users to engage with and re-label topics as desired. We evaluate our method
through a human study, where users can relabel topics to find relevant
documents. Using our method, user labeling improves document rank scores,
helping to find more relevant documents to a given query when compared to no
user labeling. | [
0.015623726,
0.0111821815,
0.0018338899,
0.0005526161,
0.0094008939,
0.0009088858,
0.0044958456,
-0.0153231043,
-0.0287277661,
-0.023071859,
-0.0502443425,
0.0472256951,
-0.0358392447,
0.0340625234,
-0.0015242739,
-0.0930740908,
0.0314445384,
-0.0088505056,
0.0181832127,
0.0376631245,
0.0051941434,
0.0009497964,
-0.0335142575,
0.0126851089,
-0.0146980099,
-0.0232843459,
-0.0442170687,
-0.0147125414,
-0.0128919985,
-0.0153099885,
-0.0002145721,
0.0622112192,
0.040472459,
-0.0074863089,
0.0000019324,
0.0174870435,
0.0059167477,
-0.0295336358,
-0.0185884219,
0.0257780124,
0.0745067894,
0.0025891748,
0.0463319942,
-0.018680824,
-0.0137189915,
0.0180083141,
0.0207777936,
0.0795822144,
0.0631163418,
-0.0058817002,
-0.0037594908,
0.0139652388,
0.0265813265,
-0.0499243475,
0.0622043572,
-0.060549479,
-0.0041809701,
0.0214495845,
0.0049574338,
0.0957795456,
-0.0035670423,
0.024714699,
0.0147285387,
-0.060449712,
0.1176075712,
0.0423328504,
-0.0010069424,
-0.0393438265,
-0.0002774471,
0.0841404423,
-0.0133519815,
0.0050817449,
0.0130398758,
-0.018251203,
0.0001632572,
0.039494805,
-0.0702576712,
-0.0430990681,
0.0008321156,
-0.0165383462,
0.0180309899,
0.0023463978,
0.0595849752,
0.0237479545,
0.0205763821,
0.0317415148,
0.0134433424,
-0.0011657437,
-0.0022085465,
-0.0006777478,
-0.0165855102,
-0.0378000923,
0.0308405235,
0.0217537787,
-0.0154334744,
0.0400227234,
-0.0175756589,
-0.0320730992,
0.0128684286,
-0.0556470305,
-0.0103928139,
-0.0002129255,
-0.0214382485,
0.0890559778,
0.039109759,
-0.0204624124,
-0.0329813771,
-0.0319957025,
-0.0195694473,
0.0134435268,
-0.0181969795,
-0.0195741635,
-0.021516379,
-0.0063928207,
-0.002463711,
-0.0402847417,
0.0188974533,
0.0481521264,
0.0105371093,
-0.0054202247,
-0.0216581505,
0.0207769349,
-0.065296188,
-0.0108552175,
-0.0367726237,
0.0168905016,
-0.0780451596,
0.0087716738,
0.0143662989,
0.0244142506,
0.0129665649,
0.0084620528,
-0.0106269289,
-0.0060590925,
-0.0352712981,
-0.0187773369,
-0.0058189258,
-0.0323039703,
-0.028372895,
-0.0089271329,
0.0111547904,
0.0208291262,
0.0230987519,
-0.0457805768,
0.0263618734,
-0.0147732561,
-0.0262056608,
-0.0325143151,
0.002043291,
0.0335501991,
-0.0373675637,
0.0761388093,
-0.0351121239,
-0.0191770531,
0.1154053658,
0.0387244783,
-0.0065445285,
0.0379720256,
-0.0085049355,
0.0491731763,
0.0547586679,
0.0086765103,
0.0036035124,
-0.0237851329,
0.013534327,
0.0038547094,
0.0100414148,
-0.0063383477,
-0.0307670459,
0.0516526587,
0.0100023793,
0.0120784547,
-0.0549674444,
-0.0228851791,
0.0470943078,
0.0591706298,
0.031952139,
0.0196845401,
-0.0196294021,
0.0218912233,
-0.0040222025,
-0.0124790482,
-0.0069391215,
0.0626709908,
0.0317051671,
-0.0067004198,
0.0458886437,
-0.0456447266,
-0.0362445004,
-0.0617821403,
-0.029708378,
0.0148055982,
-0.0180377662,
-0.0120423939,
0.0723395869,
0.0110596586,
0.0597438924,
0.0345777497,
0.0406976342,
-0.0206217896,
0.0178627428,
-0.009883265,
0.0627996624,
0.0593231544,
0.0509777889,
-0.074710831,
-0.0345729701,
-0.0237314235,
0.035948921,
0.0271114223,
0.044326093,
-0.0313154384,
-0.0168831479,
-0.0165412296,
-0.0234024227,
-0.0294177085,
0.0172834098,
0.0186536442,
-0.0010788244,
-0.025410952,
0.0261232685,
-0.0723718554,
0.0298352391,
0.0522095859,
-0.021536801,
-0.0036719718,
0.0100217201,
-0.0175046343,
-0.0034800314,
0.0242228284,
0.0338015258,
0.0228940863,
0.04501874,
0.0032835803,
-0.0113521609,
-0.0470904596,
-0.0080787446,
0.026568098,
0.0318754353,
-0.0318063982,
0.012463022,
-0.0365751795,
-0.0296927169,
-0.0213510804,
0.0181559622,
-0.0313476697,
-0.0279804766,
-0.0314262062,
-0.0191600919,
-0.0105114048,
-0.0219693892,
-0.065451093,
0.0678796023,
0.0067316303,
0.0303573254,
0.0437952355,
-0.0062193717,
-0.0163805559,
-0.0717856586,
-0.0058506508,
0.0095042894,
0.0188261904,
-0.0073236795,
0.0320088826,
-0.0179271773,
-0.0225022733,
0.0084838048,
-0.0984109268,
-0.0209320467,
-0.0221343152,
-0.0011187132,
0.028833665,
0.0109307887,
-0.0119670462,
-0.0569887757,
-0.018638622,
-0.0294672269,
-0.0493024699,
0.0054510855,
0.0421203598,
0.0077930824,
0.0589882024,
-0.089827016,
-0.0508667268,
-0.0037895096,
0.0544173121,
0.0459448807,
-0.0251472238,
-0.0554830991,
-0.0281223133,
-0.0275343265,
-0.0021495067,
-0.0303082541,
0.0478245318,
0.0314363912,
-0.0328137502,
0.0505980179,
0.0526830293,
0.009594148,
0.0868363753,
0.0657619834,
0.0092131877,
-0.0548603386,
0.006533708,
0.0002554262,
0.050555326,
0.0240687244,
-0.0228151567,
0.0363654085,
0.0641817003,
-0.0273188259,
0.0166470148,
-0.0167352129,
0.0285731573,
-0.0232324135,
0.0094269253,
-0.1272469014,
-0.0035315373,
0.0118315155,
0.0158238932,
-0.040910624,
-0.0472468548,
0.0588320494,
-0.0024048747,
0.0178661551,
-0.0419155806,
-0.0263684671,
-0.0320412107,
0.0398048535,
0.0105054528,
-0.0006163444,
-0.0373953618,
-0.0067795189,
-0.016031472,
0.0393446721,
0.025263112,
-0.0238919798,
0.0116351135,
-0.0285445713,
0.0170613211,
-0.0002344339,
-0.0382310264,
0.0088064587,
-0.0729558244,
0.0122922147,
0.0024267472,
0.0162619632,
-0.012536197,
-0.0150666339,
-0.0003236368,
0.0699124783,
0.0278266985,
-0.0095789097,
-0.036058601,
0.0095109614,
0.0325471573,
0.0689867064,
-0.0297439527,
-0.0589643866,
-0.0140127344,
0.0148400329,
0.0322823748,
0.027287595,
-0.029230183,
-0.0642781854,
0.009823571,
0.0060582366,
-0.0678575262,
-0.0249874406,
-0.0075592254,
-0.0122179799,
-0.0241884831,
0.0109060071,
0.079362765,
0.0525231548,
-0.0621079095,
-0.0229608808,
-0.0279220436,
0.03313829,
0.0176409315,
0.038314525,
-0.0333821289,
0.0009716756,
0.0040755416,
0.0557082929,
0.0485926978,
-0.0034762111,
-0.0009253687,
-0.0351934992,
0.0268392917,
-0.0219749901,
0.0222518519,
0.0131057976,
-0.0747475624,
0.0227050409,
-0.0068480168,
-0.0248359591,
0.0315943137,
-0.0017435385,
0.0173014831,
0.0064865062,
0.0242016055,
0.007678471,
-0.0495915301,
-0.0316476673,
0.0007015731,
0.0127280997,
0.0211864971,
0.0181353912,
-0.0095160007,
0.0081296051,
0.0266364142,
0.0262004249,
-0.0117664095,
0.0711961761,
-0.0340363607,
0.0100676185,
-0.0458216779,
0.0223017875,
0.0084854318,
-0.0308625437,
-0.0295116324,
0.0626102835,
-0.0394631699,
0.0404575728,
-0.0432082377,
-0.0287145264,
-0.0030818672,
0.0197322201,
0.0332116932,
-0.0526381582,
0.0155766513,
-0.0536600277,
0.0324927457,
0.0626466572,
-0.0125065725,
-0.0170157477,
-0.0379741043,
-0.0666230321,
-0.065216139,
-0.029770501,
0.0300944,
0.0115964757,
-0.0027900147,
0.0068595815,
0.0089601092,
-0.0451929644,
-0.023672957,
0.0696623996,
0.0091843661,
-0.0166477263,
-0.0161259957,
-0.0262863915,
0.0882136971,
-0.0310012847,
-0.0189666841,
-0.0083707981,
-0.0392645597,
-0.0245625861,
-0.0237852726,
0.0054733492,
0.0179684386,
0.0142350141,
-0.0579903871,
-0.1108919606,
-0.0032434175,
0.0281158723,
-0.0750482902,
-0.0274600517,
-0.0317062289,
0.0147501016,
-0.0123441089,
-0.002649558,
-0.0804492161,
0.0143919932,
-0.0388285778,
0.0109388418,
-0.0900651217,
-0.0680883452,
0.0068924315,
-0.0226118863,
0.106441617,
0.0265107118,
0.0073706177,
-0.0512522683,
-0.012436619,
0.0093326047,
-0.046318654,
0.0052345111,
0.043836873,
0.0264926385,
-0.0219847225,
-0.0331378803,
0.044792302,
0.0188520476,
0.0479203984,
-0.031157922,
-0.0375990309,
0.0023355677,
-0.0096143745,
-0.0337711424,
0.0374587812,
-0.0162960086,
0.0173812974,
-0.0327824242,
0.0194749646,
-0.0066474117,
0.0642773733,
0.0130712613,
-0.0270929486,
-0.0296183452,
0.0196278989,
-0.0784128234,
-0.0393070579,
-0.0162237603,
0.0626638457,
0.0272836871,
0.0277400035,
-0.0277098827,
-0.0133794155,
-0.0442992076,
-0.0000049064,
-0.0026609737,
0.0356336124,
-0.0177625827,
0.029653348,
0.0576496385,
0.006104066,
0.0137590235,
0.0400990918,
0.018780889,
-0.0166760813,
-0.02108806,
-0.0374764502,
-0.0279042404,
0.0399081744,
0.0172238592,
0.0526847653,
-0.032923039,
0.013026163,
-0.0004601062,
0.0081767077,
0.0191207044,
-0.0085097961,
-0.0313486345,
-0.0098294578,
0.0811770335,
0.0909314081,
-0.0417869836,
-0.0230881907,
-0.0514170192,
0.0587070286,
-0.048120182,
-0.0511861965,
-0.0582316183,
-6.436744783e-33,
-0.0543340184,
-0.0247734934,
-0.0050116265,
0.0226856358,
0.0053468631,
-0.0321764536,
-0.0260772854,
0.0457768477,
0.0171683989,
0.0212834496,
-0.0120003996,
0.0444250181,
-0.0143456915,
-0.0202721413,
-0.0129542938,
-0.0203125104,
0.070329234,
-0.0144594833,
-0.0014506759,
0.0392737277,
0.0101822456,
0.0314780362,
-0.0055591268,
-0.0993315354,
0.0556453876,
-0.0012490776,
0.0221524555,
0.0223477241,
0.047407832,
0.0496910438,
-0.0322244875,
0.0201211609,
0.041493427,
-0.0485045388,
0.0058397846,
0.0768991336,
-0.0808028355,
-0.0329701565,
-0.0152514847,
-0.0014576435,
-0.0418114774,
-0.0442670844,
0.049117852,
0.0311506949,
0.018149985,
0.0173158441,
0.066600956,
0.0125155365,
-0.064607501,
-0.0220578313,
-0.016514698,
0.0407196246,
-0.0148709547,
-0.0101607284,
-0.0126733957,
-0.0275197364,
0.0101073878,
0.0318978503,
-0.0254550055,
-0.0071399459,
0.0060974807,
0.0585843697,
0.0404521339,
0.0103865499,
-0.024037715,
0.0443327166,
-0.0143510411,
-0.0036906721,
-0.0188412406,
-0.0010293638,
0.0086755045,
0.0405423082,
0.0694237873,
0.0237143505,
0.030099608,
0.0233304538,
-0.0093710665,
0.0646531209,
-0.0015293296,
0.0338960104,
-0.0004147435,
0.0808702633,
-0.0004256262,
-0.0061972677,
-0.0582760833,
-0.0132246036,
-0.0508647934,
-0.0302717909,
-0.0015258128,
0.0298565347,
-0.0237454679,
-0.0138555374,
-0.0181065667,
0.0340172611,
-0.0085854204,
0.0303557049,
0.0039686495,
0.0414022729,
0.0091376482,
-0.0285130516,
-0.0461792648,
0.0049905223,
0.0034887388,
-0.0222054739,
-0.012128056,
-0.0100303683,
0.0007832456,
-0.0379208587,
-0.0265869256,
-0.002421591,
0.0172982775,
-0.0453992672,
-0.0165654775,
0.0399106517,
0.0304205492,
-0.0144606056,
-0.0457399562,
0.0815006942,
0.0286466908,
0.0580725558,
-0.0182979107,
-0.0630019754,
0.0027253064,
-0.0139122298,
0.0212655589,
-0.0054242546,
-0.0129484152,
0.050298389,
0.0402612649,
-0.0694964826,
-0.023833409,
0.0216254927,
2.63e-7,
0.0552495196,
0.0575169809,
0.0301985685,
-0.0098546399,
0.0380626582,
0.01422517,
-0.0140292663,
0.0146555286,
-0.0032179181,
-0.0368709564,
0.0134309782,
0.037383277,
0.0245396122,
0.0404224358,
-0.064396292,
-0.0572467223,
-0.0564183891,
-0.0030365293,
-0.0571634658,
-0.0439704023,
-0.0026977535,
0.0677730888,
0.0163708124,
0.0322753601,
0.0318744965,
-0.0679385662,
0.0692011416,
-0.0334236473,
-0.0158529598,
-0.0134162959,
0.0918120816,
0.0589413121,
-0.0374340825,
-0.042289298,
-0.0225173831,
-0.0070566856,
0.0563519113,
0.047097899,
-0.027886359,
-0.0085451696,
-0.0343784317,
-0.001268862,
0.0113239344,
-0.0259759203,
0.0199738704,
-0.0392362662,
0.019363625,
-0.0212749988,
-0.0000685419,
0.0162620321,
0.0438734517,
-0.0438807495,
-0.0195406917,
-0.0053107589,
-0.0046577114,
-0.0058430512,
-0.0244926047,
-0.0570550933,
-0.0286165085,
0.0160508845,
-0.0590182357,
-0.0080227293,
-0.0529864356,
-0.0107188439,
-0.0033212898,
-0.0132122114,
-0.0085623078,
1.589893647e-34,
0.0354165472,
0.0089451773,
-0.0360427909,
0.0032226462,
0.0377372541,
0.0037072245,
-0.0541380085,
0.0088503845,
0.0432631858,
-0.0667116195,
0.0058720983
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09433v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09433v2 | Backdoor Activation Attack: Attack Large Language Models using Activation Steering for Safety-Alignment | 2023-11-15T23:07:40 | 2023-11-24T16:22:41 | Haoran Wang, Kai Shu | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL | To ensure AI safety, instruction-tuned Large Language Models (LLMs) are
specifically trained to ensure alignment, which refers to making models behave
in accordance with human intentions. While these models have demonstrated
commendable results on various safety benchmarks, the vulnerability of their
safety alignment has not been extensively studied. This is particularly
troubling given the potential harm that LLMs can inflict. Existing attack
methods on LLMs often rely on poisoned training data or the injection of
malicious prompts. These approaches compromise the stealthiness and
generalizability of the attacks, making them susceptible to detection.
Additionally, these models often demand substantial computational resources for
implementation, making them less practical for real-world applications.
Inspired by recent success in modifying model behavior through steering vectors
without the need for optimization, and drawing on its effectiveness in
red-teaming LLMs, we conducted experiments employing activation steering to
target four key aspects of LLMs: truthfulness, toxicity, bias, and harmfulness
- across a varied set of attack settings. To establish a universal attack
strategy applicable to diverse target alignments without depending on manual
analysis, we automatically select the intervention layer based on contrastive
layer search. Our experiment results show that activation attacks are highly
effective and add little or no overhead to attack efficiency. Additionally, we
discuss potential countermeasures against such activation attacks. Our code and
data are available at https://github.com/wang2226/Backdoor-Activation-Attack
Warning: this paper contains content that can be offensive or upsetting. | [
0.0194871463,
0.0555333048,
-0.0141219785,
0.050238084,
-0.0376244448,
0.0069502983,
0.0089526521,
-0.0283807069,
0.0142006231,
-0.014161244,
-0.031192109,
-0.0134964148,
0.0025841747,
0.0187672544,
0.0489463173,
0.026462933,
0.0807252377,
-0.0459130332,
-0.0149829593,
-0.0056736716,
0.0113234436,
-0.0137552684,
-0.0020123408,
0.047024101,
-0.0126233809,
-0.0163619928,
-0.0279429872,
0.0223451927,
0.036301624,
-0.0113851298,
0.0223408118,
0.0202782638,
0.007284902,
0.0675009787,
0.000002102,
-0.0264540408,
-0.0337980762,
0.014107855,
-0.0224659368,
0.0106037371,
-0.0098723853,
-0.0334343761,
-0.0419027284,
0.0299859848,
-0.0281743295,
0.0064065005,
0.0473373532,
0.0551041961,
0.0764335617,
0.1203718036,
0.0075688194,
0.0049182288,
0.0575943142,
-0.0098641291,
-0.0251819845,
-0.0564281307,
0.044789467,
-0.0256641898,
-0.0536861382,
0.011860989,
-0.0104647456,
0.0103924023,
0.000834091,
-0.0330762453,
-0.0512020364,
0.0369498543,
-0.0075547621,
-0.0259129219,
-0.0175832119,
0.0627624989,
-0.0605792515,
-0.0081363507,
0.0103022642,
-0.0102675445,
0.0026684753,
-0.0254891664,
0.0215450041,
0.0099459654,
0.0029993143,
-0.0026760106,
0.0303877927,
-0.0215396155,
0.057906948,
0.0206534248,
0.0186719559,
0.0562416166,
0.0126684587,
-0.0587516166,
0.019922344,
-0.0424323194,
0.0062945173,
-0.0537620112,
-0.0219488908,
0.0006867117,
-0.0390106253,
0.0364477448,
-0.0681352168,
-0.0340371393,
0.0343961045,
-0.0706557706,
0.0420753621,
0.0423366651,
-0.0018455766,
0.017621154,
-0.0065036826,
0.0569044501,
-0.0464118645,
0.0528318696,
-0.0100623947,
0.0299035013,
0.0045518139,
-0.007699505,
-0.0173863396,
-0.0023191797,
-0.0023635961,
0.0097449832,
-0.052618254,
0.0254216772,
-0.0559739098,
0.0278167371,
-0.0482685417,
-0.0014827541,
-0.0267844852,
0.0097218966,
0.019361876,
-0.0095384205,
-0.0036505787,
-0.0186292734,
-0.0174788404,
-0.0808347389,
-0.0311240144,
0.0331246108,
-0.0769166648,
-0.0367804244,
-0.0015028006,
0.1056688279,
0.0010114993,
-0.0110989874,
-0.045869574,
-0.0461893044,
-0.0161918662,
-0.0334903002,
0.0073914011,
-0.0622929744,
-0.0075137299,
-0.0219035633,
-0.0300547909,
-0.0701742545,
0.0211084001,
0.0133390743,
-0.0411025733,
0.072865434,
0.0113294227,
-0.0004604656,
0.0143190445,
0.0096879341,
-0.0439716354,
0.0617969781,
0.0261674542,
0.0309595838,
0.0245775934,
-0.019464409,
0.0331090204,
0.0430855379,
0.020860903,
0.0490672179,
-0.0350280181,
0.019184364,
0.0189815052,
0.0194149613,
-0.0091870399,
0.0656337813,
-0.0183359571,
-0.0474000014,
0.0839746147,
0.013802357,
-0.0405099504,
0.0348358117,
0.019351935,
-0.0046882993,
-0.0323895551,
0.0018464349,
-0.0945793167,
-0.0013967411,
-0.0937139317,
-0.0234837309,
-0.0028485367,
0.035590373,
-0.0191951953,
-0.0269608181,
0.0088921273,
-0.0128879808,
0.0387680791,
0.0224774219,
0.0068030609,
0.0112483446,
-0.0358466096,
0.021221919,
0.0328102894,
-0.020860076,
-0.0223574117,
-0.0728793442,
-0.0326155424,
0.040000964,
0.0583592132,
-0.0120437574,
-0.0378239565,
-0.0377681181,
0.0037907811,
0.0185493771,
0.0181330945,
0.0152776148,
0.0102807479,
-0.0371929556,
-0.0087201884,
0.0073557524,
0.0077153919,
0.002353468,
0.0341060199,
-0.0156487674,
-0.0143314991,
0.018037878,
-0.0716096386,
0.0511521176,
-0.0001523247,
-0.0636727661,
-0.0129803484,
0.0372026712,
0.0310931876,
-0.0193587448,
-0.049377434,
0.0055427207,
0.0406898223,
0.0121168802,
-0.014284973,
-0.0076133693,
-0.0212379247,
0.0346565619,
0.0312081836,
-0.0041956278,
-0.021136675,
0.0781773031,
-0.0454626456,
-0.0145306652,
0.0203802716,
-0.0364625081,
-0.0028082461,
0.0203813408,
0.0411247946,
-0.0170947481,
0.014650654,
-0.0415755808,
0.0434564464,
-0.0221843012,
-0.0305246823,
-0.0094442619,
-0.0054385164,
0.0034955807,
-0.0335742682,
-0.0336865187,
0.01079698,
-0.0100155035,
0.0437402315,
0.017507717,
-0.00143981,
-0.0196808353,
-0.0235868022,
-0.0362598449,
0.0118647804,
-0.0266427379,
0.0216402188,
0.0305848252,
-0.0044835126,
-0.0188148096,
-0.004696975,
-0.0003314576,
0.0051555885,
-0.023841368,
0.0267030019,
0.0086022159,
-0.0220082421,
-0.0463469028,
-0.034159068,
-0.009795662,
-0.0442160554,
0.0270353612,
-0.0129210316,
-0.0169830024,
-0.0550335422,
0.0087260846,
-0.0007928531,
0.0617124215,
-0.0123932976,
-0.0744794384,
0.0139418989,
0.0306671932,
-0.0186475087,
0.1228864118,
0.0168559533,
0.0352854766,
0.0795513317,
0.0394031256,
-0.0643116385,
0.0264931861,
0.0025749656,
-0.0415016934,
-0.0659073889,
-0.0007249337,
0.0004396701,
0.0801633,
0.0196845252,
-0.0044568302,
-0.032410983,
-0.0233181417,
-0.0011918013,
-0.0430434197,
0.0188365765,
-0.0654658154,
-0.0471189655,
0.0014708614,
-0.0292667747,
-0.0808210969,
0.0987021849,
-0.0241917241,
0.0201151241,
-0.0317430496,
-0.0221388191,
0.0229049753,
0.0097334376,
-0.0105025666,
0.0307664201,
0.043928884,
-0.0059679197,
-0.0454835892,
-0.033885099,
0.0118985455,
-0.0237744413,
0.0586569011,
-0.0198836308,
0.0076206001,
0.0046744393,
-0.0535114743,
-0.0762339532,
-0.0704968348,
-0.0140185654,
-0.0152443377,
0.0016845332,
-0.0423827767,
-0.0462774821,
-0.0299493708,
0.0429783128,
0.0083733788,
-0.0226126127,
0.0052967733,
-0.0349463448,
-0.0302843917,
0.076010108,
-0.065990448,
0.0281224605,
-0.0307225324,
0.0541247614,
0.0762901083,
0.0139229689,
0.0170788262,
-0.055852104,
-0.0255908053,
0.0184520725,
-0.0098222708,
-0.0029788115,
0.0254112966,
0.03292083,
-0.0317384489,
-0.0204956513,
0.0486746579,
0.0113685075,
-0.0488582887,
0.0247782972,
0.0161064658,
0.0239054207,
0.0088818176,
0.0150950067,
-0.0447558388,
-0.0260543488,
0.0332773626,
0.0395717546,
-0.0236351211,
-0.0040680342,
0.0133286389,
-0.1209952906,
0.0002911984,
0.0177742429,
-0.0378313847,
-0.043859411,
-0.0150557114,
0.0013375884,
-0.0005475912,
0.0739825666,
0.0092098434,
0.020082958,
-0.0456821546,
0.0034044227,
0.0206255615,
-0.0403586887,
0.0188369583,
-0.0472859517,
0.0862262025,
0.0905580372,
0.0042068465,
-0.0377615169,
-0.0170897134,
0.0518604405,
0.015593471,
0.0011514276,
0.0180599466,
0.0431162752,
-0.0201824829,
-0.0112494873,
0.0146685867,
0.0431433022,
0.0153798424,
0.0193254184,
0.0212861914,
0.0408266112,
-0.0212367848,
-0.0032820988,
-0.0265957303,
0.0026996448,
0.0410538204,
0.0539479926,
0.0100709153,
-0.0542386994,
-0.0114736166,
-0.0438651219,
-0.0080022002,
-0.0244366936,
-0.0796789601,
0.0300964471,
0.0093665104,
-0.0531403683,
-0.0336948,
-0.0114270085,
-0.0177980941,
0.0229048915,
0.0369183123,
-0.0368625224,
-0.0070571383,
0.0144075034,
-0.0090247411,
0.0311996713,
-0.0346741863,
0.0595896207,
-0.0426312648,
0.0335567631,
0.0069649443,
-0.0126212519,
-0.0030151983,
0.0246930216,
-0.0510271154,
-0.1222449318,
0.0187292974,
0.0665910095,
0.0201205648,
0.0668587536,
-0.0541396216,
-0.0564094856,
0.0594715662,
0.0174194276,
-0.0215820596,
0.0150570944,
0.068856962,
-0.0355087072,
0.0157654062,
0.0428984016,
-0.0457399935,
-0.0006787848,
0.0810330883,
0.0187316425,
-0.0616463162,
0.0059284181,
0.0325135216,
0.0374134667,
0.0679445416,
-0.0243138075,
0.0392006189,
0.0096646855,
0.0275242347,
-0.0032189214,
-0.0361508057,
0.0084326845,
0.0164021626,
0.0135631282,
0.0002235748,
0.028682353,
-0.0371476188,
0.0022506765,
-0.003136721,
-0.0197570007,
0.0345862471,
0.0075144949,
0.0600495189,
0.0570199862,
0.0261134189,
-0.033855889,
0.069525741,
0.0171547197,
0.02995825,
0.0144954305,
0.0366255119,
0.0281864516,
0.0041230456,
-0.0370807014,
0.0265794247,
-0.0505316369,
-0.0477359891,
0.0031819777,
0.013188744,
0.0409858264,
0.0018890888,
0.032052014,
-0.0099099269,
-0.0057337428,
-0.0290126633,
-0.017599158,
0.0045048846,
-0.0483305566,
0.0383144394,
0.0159939434,
0.003066374,
0.0226225834,
0.0535815023,
-0.0065974584,
0.0813661739,
0.0092907343,
-0.0069043725,
-0.0171390027,
-0.0269271974,
0.0358015969,
0.0124339126,
-0.0505080335,
-0.0265764538,
-0.0467606038,
-0.082690835,
0.0014880983,
0.0161153842,
0.0247560125,
-0.0202468224,
0.0070172125,
0.0314134099,
0.0184768196,
0.0136374095,
-0.0435777344,
-0.0097148344,
-0.005555111,
-0.0376855321,
-0.0301437937,
-6.149448453e-33,
0.0263113212,
-0.0109072737,
-0.0214399267,
0.0123008545,
-0.0092101078,
0.0170855615,
-0.0169869326,
0.0089472588,
-0.0572850853,
0.0001958819,
-0.0074780709,
0.0210080352,
-0.0004650138,
0.0056292452,
-0.0198463947,
-0.0299485344,
-0.0099129342,
-0.0167102478,
-0.0390505567,
0.0215398837,
0.0343154073,
-0.0140601425,
0.036167711,
-0.096218802,
0.0225353222,
-0.0100817773,
-0.0540042333,
0.0391281135,
-0.0820497125,
0.0820147842,
0.0145766726,
0.0421552472,
-0.0079000425,
-0.0307063926,
0.0135190878,
0.0453778915,
0.0189687125,
0.0049713072,
0.0011033997,
-0.00024585,
-0.0386457853,
-0.0639994964,
0.0570652112,
-0.010973745,
-0.0383510627,
-0.008336979,
0.003195076,
-0.005849801,
-0.0071419873,
0.002141933,
-0.072934106,
0.0117108291,
-0.0202889219,
-0.0394670516,
0.0104784295,
0.0169528294,
0.022313606,
-0.0059683938,
-0.0527564399,
0.0062680664,
0.0145806577,
0.0205890089,
0.0617864467,
0.0436358228,
0.0074859788,
0.0668489188,
0.0123592056,
0.0186064038,
-0.0070218439,
-0.0095478455,
0.0061352397,
0.026964603,
0.0437297337,
0.0412139334,
0.0274193417,
-0.0394159071,
-0.0753433332,
-0.0184359048,
0.0268159956,
0.0451760329,
0.0357850231,
0.003670098,
-0.0971169621,
0.012198301,
-0.0380667932,
-0.019213384,
-0.0310250036,
-0.0277717896,
0.017236406,
0.0204091687,
-0.0362307876,
-0.0271153171,
0.003574217,
-0.0295417607,
0.0411640406,
0.0324583389,
-0.0017738193,
-0.0222409423,
-0.0147097996,
0.0179374944,
-0.0219470337,
-0.0340136364,
-0.0352889337,
-0.060868036,
0.052108977,
0.0240793768,
0.0390826836,
0.0391208939,
-0.0615264922,
-0.0131724617,
-0.037629649,
0.0337891206,
0.0341968425,
0.0018984264,
0.051151596,
-0.0092158699,
0.0079137124,
0.0319222286,
0.043821156,
0.0079947179,
-0.0426175259,
0.0122462856,
-0.0295345653,
0.0161557831,
-0.0331535265,
0.0081325481,
-0.001354948,
0.0319385305,
0.0168514811,
-0.0802483261,
-0.0150588639,
-0.0164712109,
2.926e-7,
-0.0147893727,
0.0332527198,
0.032945957,
0.0613039918,
0.0063258777,
0.0887312293,
-0.0197969824,
0.0720809624,
0.0098387329,
-0.0307936054,
-0.0170525275,
0.0331145376,
0.0565904789,
0.021149274,
-0.0449212454,
0.0380508751,
-0.0661972463,
0.0410808846,
-0.0533647388,
0.0024027256,
0.0418129303,
0.1040810719,
0.0105416859,
-0.0137605583,
-0.0095134024,
-0.0474978276,
0.0166453291,
-0.0077087902,
0.0098698949,
0.00295867,
0.0170185044,
0.0408255607,
-0.0263009332,
0.0395242572,
-0.0142643042,
0.0132924328,
-0.0742367283,
0.0630592927,
-0.0347298607,
-0.0337096341,
-0.0177261215,
-0.0433631316,
-0.0031861898,
-0.0182769354,
0.0503120013,
-0.029705679,
-0.0223267619,
-0.0325634964,
-0.000957392,
-0.0091411285,
0.0303209145,
-0.0333044305,
-0.0108389715,
0.0148235112,
0.0086065745,
0.0058183586,
0.0015108222,
-0.0605084114,
-0.0268964618,
-0.0098112281,
0.0020331694,
-0.0513410904,
0.0078761922,
0.0606192015,
-0.0089592757,
-0.027910782,
0.0029693134,
2.918962317e-34,
0.0127400747,
-0.0642322525,
0.0179054737,
0.0179277677,
0.0588684306,
0.0063079847,
-0.0296680983,
0.012412793,
0.0248389561,
-0.0451736897,
-0.0241335239
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09431v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09431v1 | Striped Attention: Faster Ring Attention for Causal Transformers | 2023-11-15T23:01:02 | 2023-11-15T23:01:02 | William Brandon, Aniruddha Nrusimha, Kevin Qian, Zachary Ankner, Tian Jin, Zhiye Song, Jonathan Ragan-Kelley | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | To help address the growing demand for ever-longer sequence lengths in
transformer models, Liu et al. recently proposed Ring Attention, an exact
attention algorithm capable of overcoming per-device memory bottle- necks by
distributing self-attention across multiple devices. In this paper, we study
the performance characteristics of Ring Attention in the important special case
of causal transformer models, and identify a key workload imbal- ance due to
triangular structure of causal attention computations. We propose a simple
extension to Ring Attention, which we call Striped Attention to fix this
imbalance. Instead of devices having contiguous subsequences, each device has a
subset of tokens distributed uniformly throughout the sequence, which we
demonstrate leads to more even workloads. In experiments running Striped
Attention on A100 GPUs and TPUv4s, we are able to achieve up to 1.45x
end-to-end throughput improvements over the original Ring Attention algorithm
on causal transformer training at a sequence length of 256k. Furthermore, on 16
TPUv4 chips, we were able to achieve 1.65x speedups at sequence lengths of
786k. We release the code for our experiments as open source | [
0.0030007544,
-0.0056859641,
-0.0130976308,
0.0268574599,
-0.0530972779,
0.0096692648,
0.0930339992,
-0.0137789296,
-0.0343112648,
-0.0145181986,
0.011796888,
-0.0455903523,
-0.0325635448,
0.0174618326,
0.0022285669,
-0.0340164937,
0.0377125032,
0.0220698994,
-0.0243814569,
-0.0183108859,
-0.0196186267,
-0.058481425,
0.0029159239,
0.0091501456,
-0.0411917679,
-0.0045286515,
-0.0286025759,
0.0103836302,
0.0419008955,
-0.0212388039,
0.0061489316,
0.0607947595,
-0.0121045653,
0.0092011895,
0.0000023115,
0.0213180818,
0.0212432761,
0.0010687887,
0.0217635091,
0.0226939842,
-0.0057106339,
-0.0238791686,
-0.0028207025,
-0.011029792,
0.0113528175,
0.0212056171,
0.0918806344,
0.0610694923,
0.018154813,
0.0368220881,
-0.0080758259,
-0.0429305956,
0.0336696953,
-0.0590838194,
0.0239770226,
-0.0226217192,
-0.0000303014,
-0.0342877582,
-0.0090015549,
-0.0255777258,
-0.0528107546,
0.034097895,
0.0454892479,
0.0253927819,
0.057227958,
0.0069546788,
-0.0110280477,
-0.0089140413,
-0.0356746465,
0.0179882608,
-0.0370345414,
-0.0306258779,
0.0147884432,
-0.0009199929,
-0.0353926718,
-0.0413091779,
-0.0325555243,
0.0270250347,
-0.0306944791,
-0.0451976731,
-0.0239627045,
0.0260705017,
0.021608077,
-0.0320722163,
-0.0516864471,
0.0182445999,
0.0418642871,
-0.0276262295,
-0.0668117702,
0.0213658158,
0.042192135,
-0.0257409923,
0.013926656,
0.028864637,
-0.01946114,
-0.0060318154,
-0.0553358532,
-0.0480885915,
-0.0134321665,
-0.0360509492,
0.0438845865,
0.0627140701,
-0.019815268,
0.0334353484,
-0.0241553374,
0.0179043394,
-0.0794101432,
0.0406988114,
-0.0560341738,
0.0160820056,
0.0065173963,
0.0255842377,
-0.0182306934,
0.0039928118,
-0.0306514408,
-0.0440070555,
-0.0202263072,
0.015167729,
0.0257147718,
-0.0666668788,
0.0081593907,
0.0090643885,
-0.0602600574,
-0.0004657998,
0.0249325577,
0.065469034,
-0.0499928333,
-0.0414578095,
-0.000747279,
-0.0254481547,
-0.0485338569,
0.0014839747,
-0.0008350502,
-0.0104884217,
0.0057508014,
0.0713118315,
0.0160436649,
-0.0834204108,
-0.0313765146,
0.0310190078,
0.0022269087,
-0.0129870642,
0.0097894967,
-0.0319007449,
0.021126071,
0.01295882,
0.0011220471,
0.0553214103,
0.036340531,
0.0563015193,
-0.0339653604,
0.0179943945,
0.0425874889,
-0.0570864081,
-0.0214978512,
-0.0243715625,
0.0272201318,
-0.0090247095,
0.0344630964,
0.0582834333,
-0.0198302306,
-0.0471679755,
0.0082717985,
0.0008767872,
0.0167588219,
-0.0007576253,
0.0104369773,
-0.0191561151,
0.0071145887,
-0.0064521949,
0.0333314426,
0.0266211778,
-0.0160964373,
-0.0314783305,
0.0321402363,
0.0011767873,
-0.0014515769,
0.0428194962,
0.0179837029,
-0.0357473083,
-0.0650841817,
0.0133504244,
-0.0836760104,
0.111215055,
0.0106749143,
0.0085665528,
0.0709195063,
0.0159493331,
-0.0199446436,
-0.0005519651,
-0.0166412033,
0.0185267013,
-0.0032272344,
-0.0208502691,
0.031074971,
0.0275127422,
-0.0620418377,
0.0760344341,
0.0212162975,
-0.0687950179,
-0.0673214719,
-0.0298868772,
-0.0008455106,
0.0184445176,
0.0287538785,
-0.0176253542,
-0.0365923904,
0.0101381838,
0.0007398428,
0.0210131761,
0.0100017916,
0.0622810274,
-0.0183178466,
-0.0471333303,
-0.0023214233,
0.0064219106,
-0.011069037,
0.0225454476,
0.0327870548,
-0.0085303821,
-0.0172517728,
0.0120003344,
-0.0071504037,
0.0060656616,
0.0364398435,
-0.0252068527,
0.0128054908,
0.0212035682,
0.0198942684,
-0.0170648415,
-0.0242927782,
-0.0033147926,
0.0516385287,
-0.0455848239,
0.0449466147,
-0.0016261814,
-0.0810654685,
0.0537951849,
0.0123819234,
-0.0486805998,
0.0180528592,
0.048540011,
-0.0278828014,
-0.0588565134,
0.0599658601,
-0.0473778546,
-0.0229739677,
0.0275171213,
0.0321389548,
0.0512038805,
0.0522443764,
-0.0085095856,
0.0283369571,
-0.0177243147,
0.0143922009,
-0.0142046502,
0.0202782769,
-0.0100654606,
-0.0139624272,
0.0150424987,
-0.0272071455,
-0.0174764115,
-0.0225849319,
0.0261316095,
-0.0513656214,
0.0026203957,
-0.0191893,
-0.0141543271,
0.0276089981,
-0.036831148,
0.0307818819,
0.0269267168,
0.0417769365,
0.0420630239,
-0.0102633042,
0.0053264629,
-0.003147607,
-0.0303183123,
0.01000454,
-0.0119947549,
-0.0570998378,
-0.0557079799,
-0.0027700332,
-0.0561413728,
0.0127519127,
0.0306006745,
0.0331145152,
-0.065397054,
-0.0318515897,
-0.0834935978,
0.05836441,
0.0210061483,
-0.0162073728,
-0.0292640813,
-0.0190025996,
0.0097118989,
0.0595329478,
0.1011404768,
0.0392556526,
0.0122942561,
0.0018858578,
-0.0079729501,
0.0138239823,
0.0441527478,
-0.0029700203,
0.0084554991,
-0.0116970288,
0.0116235912,
-0.0103007993,
0.1252936274,
-0.040273346,
0.0060378402,
-0.061654035,
-0.0827896595,
0.0314395726,
-0.0384969264,
0.045162186,
-0.0237835292,
-0.0445509776,
-0.002663288,
-0.0155065339,
-0.0335460752,
0.0337560549,
-0.0208258443,
-0.0076166531,
-0.0195097923,
0.0179431476,
-0.0038736144,
0.0569234304,
0.0593539476,
0.0542078838,
-0.0137957688,
0.0001168614,
0.0186940562,
0.0531017333,
-0.0304632857,
0.0123659736,
0.0510569289,
0.0099098263,
-0.0013434734,
-0.0516153835,
-0.0351508819,
-0.0175971668,
0.0336017087,
0.0031848997,
-0.0006665073,
0.0502715893,
-0.0394416228,
-0.0888207257,
0.0598302931,
0.0452740118,
0.0432455055,
-0.0025172997,
-0.0054144114,
-0.0207627453,
0.0106015811,
-0.0152372271,
-0.0119950986,
0.0279413275,
-0.0173066296,
0.0025312325,
0.0458845831,
0.0416971184,
0.0004131958,
-0.060741175,
-0.0130157061,
0.0344662704,
-0.0488205142,
-0.0015211643,
0.011141994,
0.0273316931,
-0.0650020614,
-0.0140543506,
0.014986787,
0.0021962395,
-0.0623867959,
0.0184705667,
0.0364818014,
0.0000480644,
0.0209631249,
0.0297776889,
-0.1151773036,
-0.0207064245,
0.0100166099,
0.003489153,
-0.0089323828,
0.0050186859,
0.0040820595,
-0.0493755639,
0.032987766,
-0.0218765046,
-0.0142074889,
-0.036353074,
0.0037254684,
-0.0248014387,
-0.0119894044,
0.0113152619,
0.022043271,
-0.0061599039,
-0.0106359404,
0.0006193275,
0.0433904231,
0.0270237923,
0.0153550506,
-0.0024228701,
-0.0285534766,
0.0171744302,
-0.0435731672,
0.0153571442,
-0.0679223388,
-0.0290937573,
0.0586584546,
0.0403797068,
0.0006919674,
0.0258356966,
-0.0117066381,
-0.0387123004,
-0.0333557017,
-0.0243660994,
-0.0314340033,
-0.0013176992,
-0.0366128422,
0.0285311714,
0.028406119,
0.0095304362,
-0.0040869089,
0.0019566168,
-0.0391515195,
0.022990346,
0.0207508411,
-0.0182761811,
-0.070184797,
-0.0345576927,
-0.0118784495,
-0.0970647782,
-0.0449245572,
-0.0144278081,
0.0641632602,
-0.058852125,
-0.0071333265,
0.0095406035,
-0.0448730402,
0.0471516959,
0.0439809188,
-0.0911298096,
0.024373211,
-0.0035601985,
-0.0812659636,
0.0196715817,
-0.0589582771,
0.0102584744,
-0.1052738279,
-0.0075236708,
-0.0003063506,
-0.0319300108,
-0.0047650412,
0.0412300043,
-0.1062148288,
-0.0392743498,
0.0407833271,
0.0873555019,
0.017544141,
0.021312736,
0.009887863,
0.0022327912,
-0.030674886,
0.0310872272,
-0.066012986,
0.0464982986,
0.0225215852,
-0.069895938,
-0.0156075284,
0.0015295811,
0.0051423279,
0.046102006,
0.0554098189,
0.0315676741,
-0.0159851722,
-0.0223609023,
-0.0086139431,
-0.0248581283,
0.0767261162,
0.0129638677,
0.0481020212,
0.0305793937,
0.0772406086,
0.0266821291,
0.0283298809,
-0.0401322618,
-0.029485764,
-0.0134437839,
-0.014299578,
0.0023946119,
-0.0023212663,
0.0490019843,
-0.0938111916,
-0.0042683627,
0.0249114279,
-0.034026105,
-0.0036043336,
-0.0217618626,
-0.0304004699,
-0.0137760146,
-0.0261651948,
0.0250248238,
0.0550958328,
-0.0365697928,
0.0187340211,
0.0106415451,
0.0391330831,
-0.0495215021,
0.0071616694,
-0.0672236905,
-0.0328340493,
-0.0126767997,
-0.0567604639,
0.076185666,
-0.005458314,
0.0056687216,
0.0134315975,
0.0205904618,
-0.0086903293,
0.0259912722,
0.0054229256,
0.0272341594,
-0.0221771728,
0.0253026299,
0.0236624163,
-0.0104629602,
0.0349771641,
-0.0630939081,
0.0123624587,
-0.0082536656,
0.0053683114,
-0.0234940574,
-0.0659970045,
-0.0180772506,
0.0092715817,
0.0175025389,
-0.0416343883,
-0.0353315212,
-0.0112033458,
0.0327068754,
-0.0419542529,
0.0551890694,
-0.0359537676,
0.0399816893,
-0.0169456154,
-0.0084776282,
-0.0220294781,
0.0326144397,
0.0056595523,
0.0254176501,
0.008164675,
0.0216379482,
-7.009660158e-33,
-0.0030286191,
0.0332560576,
0.0351711623,
0.0187127143,
-0.0100191915,
0.0182495341,
-0.0333778486,
-0.0147428326,
0.011786757,
-0.0039947387,
-0.0322450623,
0.0129555045,
0.0264614802,
0.0333870091,
0.0312820747,
-0.0119428746,
0.0668760538,
0.0230923276,
-0.0123847136,
0.0610956773,
0.0210850015,
0.0445384905,
0.0545249134,
-0.007362687,
-0.0304504074,
-0.0031763583,
0.0428347662,
-0.0619479008,
-0.0318092369,
0.0265193935,
-0.0403207466,
-0.011357272,
-0.0056714755,
-0.1161011681,
0.0035821332,
0.0247694496,
-0.0773214027,
0.0096854446,
-0.0203133412,
0.0076542743,
-0.042084299,
-0.0465150177,
0.0165077467,
0.0627599731,
-0.0094296597,
-0.0461205021,
0.0095600234,
0.025482621,
-0.0599978343,
-0.0114648566,
-0.0528156273,
0.0179247614,
0.0014125336,
0.0092151556,
0.0301360022,
-0.0109560452,
-0.0328622349,
0.0241497792,
-0.0695870891,
0.0185010619,
0.0279005263,
0.054331746,
0.0409419797,
0.0408682264,
0.0154194571,
0.0170867667,
0.0671917722,
0.011068562,
-0.0015027323,
0.0122400802,
-0.0162599888,
0.0145077826,
0.0380404666,
-0.016745694,
0.0833193809,
0.0136056533,
-0.0484146215,
-0.0296299886,
-0.0046107196,
0.0540727191,
0.0615307316,
-0.0014470669,
-0.0335396491,
0.0139780156,
0.0352376699,
0.0202304404,
-0.0403865874,
-0.0124689909,
0.0138007831,
0.0491216183,
-0.0363040157,
0.0409891158,
0.050501734,
-0.0142358737,
0.0632122308,
0.025265038,
0.0563612096,
0.0372652784,
0.002662919,
-0.0047122766,
-0.0323848389,
-0.0184340514,
-0.0213552155,
0.0066006272,
0.0212115217,
-0.0179349445,
0.0409064479,
0.0271081105,
-0.0637538731,
-0.0203530639,
-0.0529925115,
0.0248494446,
0.0108923344,
0.0270123482,
0.0416781418,
0.0428019352,
-0.0050476524,
0.0615504384,
-0.0578676201,
-0.0314537659,
0.0217675231,
0.012394337,
0.001226166,
0.0320557915,
-0.0240470469,
0.0104654543,
-0.0734774843,
0.0505473912,
-0.0211208295,
-0.074943468,
-0.0547339171,
0.0616083778,
3.174e-7,
0.0064836429,
0.04770118,
0.022027269,
0.0082599176,
0.0137093924,
-0.0142136347,
0.0506263785,
0.0489914306,
0.0146999396,
0.0399230644,
0.0001427842,
0.0262159351,
0.0059597674,
-0.0291581247,
-0.0760391057,
-0.0178638287,
-0.0598594137,
0.0735193565,
0.013329085,
0.0003967524,
-0.0024699375,
0.0667582601,
0.001494452,
0.0170557387,
0.0361468494,
-0.0014261652,
0.0075007412,
0.0411550701,
0.0574791208,
0.0049529863,
-0.0192059837,
0.0007666442,
-0.0721263215,
0.0649881363,
-0.0023536696,
-0.0141397398,
-0.0652668402,
0.0419186577,
-0.0063603506,
-0.0239381306,
0.0089053838,
0.0072257882,
0.0035893822,
-0.0092950938,
0.0148485499,
-0.0228499919,
-0.036927186,
0.0165498815,
0.0008978953,
0.014551295,
-0.0366602652,
0.0370750315,
0.0423376933,
0.0120846825,
0.017208131,
-0.0215256158,
-0.0035478938,
-0.0595644079,
0.0005530784,
-0.0096264677,
-0.0407832451,
-0.0027910203,
-0.0784883648,
-0.0129638314,
0.0085044708,
-0.0056306659,
-0.0727053657,
3.068755884e-34,
0.0367427245,
-0.02849764,
0.0153569747,
0.041762948,
0.0275660791,
-0.0353690423,
-0.004044841,
-0.0017339268,
0.0137260733,
-0.0561721399,
-0.0440365411
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09428v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09428v2 | Beyond Detection: Unveiling Fairness Vulnerabilities in Abusive Language Models | 2023-11-15T22:57:13 | 2023-12-05T20:36:23 | Yueqing Liang, Lu Cheng, Ali Payani, Kai Shu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG | This work investigates the potential of undermining both fairness and
detection performance in abusive language detection. In a dynamic and complex
digital world, it is crucial to investigate the vulnerabilities of these
detection models to adversarial fairness attacks to improve their fairness
robustness. We propose a simple yet effective framework FABLE that leverages
backdoor attacks as they allow targeted control over the fairness and detection
performance. FABLE explores three types of trigger designs (i.e., rare,
artificial, and natural triggers) and novel sampling strategies. Specifically,
the adversary can inject triggers into samples in the minority group with the
favored outcome (i.e., "non-abusive") and flip their labels to the unfavored
outcome, i.e., "abusive". Experiments on benchmark datasets demonstrate the
effectiveness of FABLE attacking fairness and utility in abusive language
detection. | [
0.0661488026,
0.0822888538,
-0.0379758328,
0.0398912132,
-0.0401403047,
0.0049898396,
0.0290211346,
0.0079306839,
-0.0035661445,
-0.0913220868,
0.001007795,
0.0156292822,
-0.0012063954,
0.0137440367,
0.0284940284,
-0.010373937,
0.0341686085,
0.0370577946,
0.0230287667,
-0.0350753441,
0.0321727842,
-0.0043484108,
0.0123450113,
0.0218228381,
-0.04247481,
0.0213242099,
0.0406317934,
0.0050215684,
-0.0052263518,
-0.0024219197,
0.0398305692,
0.0640999451,
-0.0290993135,
0.0683647171,
0.0000018076,
-0.0558078699,
0.0148493713,
0.0099050533,
0.0260956082,
0.0060220882,
0.0598180927,
-0.0502588674,
-0.0102482401,
0.0402110815,
-0.0299918968,
0.0094822608,
0.0155727901,
0.0412654392,
0.0283113271,
0.04852321,
-0.0087177223,
-0.0183104575,
0.0325298756,
-0.0186488405,
-0.0293867663,
-0.008751818,
0.0317070298,
-0.0556367077,
-0.0582979955,
-0.0454656929,
0.0059652966,
-0.0082470058,
0.0383573994,
0.0119272787,
-0.0178397056,
0.000574352,
-0.0243182536,
-0.0332104266,
-0.0080112843,
0.0568533055,
-0.0504378416,
0.0136917923,
0.002494361,
-0.0086499024,
0.0285802316,
-0.0245006941,
0.0139011918,
0.0182521641,
-0.010142372,
-0.0037642827,
-0.0240259431,
0.0543484166,
0.0470787548,
0.0626771823,
0.0235127192,
0.0182692409,
-0.0012674776,
-0.011035528,
-0.0454183891,
-0.0002483081,
-0.001709766,
-0.0065730345,
0.0212963503,
-0.0072326069,
0.0028275412,
-0.0089246435,
-0.06474296,
-0.0517200679,
0.0458045341,
-0.0192533918,
0.0135244215,
0.0305801481,
-0.0543240644,
-0.0130763324,
0.0134156216,
0.0118286004,
-0.0165323,
0.0438289605,
0.0003335294,
0.0112806838,
0.0288217422,
0.0175065808,
0.015433697,
-0.0130660608,
-0.037613634,
0.0465538651,
-0.0340772346,
-0.0078934273,
-0.0695523024,
-0.0196363926,
-0.0199075788,
0.0043859482,
-0.04150692,
0.0399398953,
-0.0039277785,
-0.0481684692,
-0.0283698067,
-0.0205846019,
-0.0205863081,
-0.0750609785,
-0.0123176174,
0.0008585366,
-0.0755370706,
-0.0265446305,
0.0148058143,
0.0944454968,
0.0385291539,
-0.0309555139,
-0.0589389801,
-0.0612700395,
-0.0081764506,
-0.0043948414,
-0.0164516121,
-0.0564785749,
-0.0258367378,
-0.0140364775,
-0.0276648197,
-0.0349012502,
-0.0032614269,
-0.0089232316,
-0.0364580229,
0.0876014307,
0.0555651486,
-0.0464706905,
0.0199055504,
0.0316409469,
0.0018256363,
0.0818994269,
0.0320755802,
0.0100886449,
0.0567638241,
0.0204928741,
0.0061250627,
0.0381853133,
0.0666873977,
0.032495264,
-0.0086279176,
0.0044113523,
-0.011735972,
-0.0379391089,
0.0152757457,
0.0362711661,
0.0035090602,
-0.0942632034,
0.0845666751,
0.0300770495,
-0.0487542078,
0.0256934427,
-0.0026409256,
-0.0356106795,
-0.0787741989,
0.0087109422,
-0.080857724,
-0.0208399612,
-0.048119735,
-0.0716709867,
-0.0048797773,
0.0450332128,
-0.025968289,
-0.0251901671,
-0.0055797352,
0.0060521425,
0.0597528778,
-0.0091078328,
0.0127988411,
0.070346646,
-0.0004413504,
-0.0200491436,
0.0306227896,
-0.0052051824,
0.0170164611,
-0.091574125,
-0.0026502947,
0.0283798706,
0.0551256835,
-0.025476139,
0.0966707543,
-0.0538695753,
-0.0236751698,
0.0279117096,
0.0317606851,
0.0234746467,
0.0014390859,
-0.0307131726,
-0.0188485235,
0.0012798377,
0.0128838997,
0.0216859523,
0.028324008,
0.0165875833,
-0.0271468628,
0.0024725304,
-0.0017162857,
0.031874992,
0.0560773686,
-0.0431735739,
0.0213376414,
0.0174119677,
0.0391754024,
-0.0008782588,
-0.0521212816,
-0.0089445701,
0.0009087317,
-0.0140350359,
-0.0398971476,
-0.0145047745,
-0.0260988344,
0.0005595103,
0.0215053782,
-0.0428218395,
0.0092106136,
0.0634378567,
-0.015219531,
0.0367710777,
0.0629315078,
-0.0006728108,
-0.0120346993,
-0.0154661033,
-0.0326120742,
-0.0232640672,
0.0565801337,
-0.0427168757,
0.0427098423,
-0.0472051054,
-0.0069666156,
-0.0524793454,
-0.0126960063,
0.0109783486,
-0.0036318121,
-0.0616463795,
0.0286584385,
-0.0451823696,
0.0210762564,
0.017579291,
-0.0093096457,
-0.001660811,
0.0196957998,
-0.0089144418,
0.0075536422,
-0.0220512915,
-0.0227750894,
0.026712494,
0.000443946,
-0.0062513365,
-0.0022868835,
0.0149596734,
-0.0868298113,
0.0144937858,
0.0527233295,
-0.0126956431,
-0.0363524891,
-0.0211565793,
-0.013929259,
-0.0395648256,
-0.020397447,
0.0586507022,
0.011774363,
0.0021945641,
0.0239149239,
-0.0455065444,
-0.0184389018,
0.0410936065,
-0.0169732291,
-0.0511440933,
0.0198552739,
0.0596024916,
-0.0371805131,
0.0695349351,
0.0436766632,
0.0977532044,
0.0539874434,
0.0278502386,
-0.0177864581,
-0.0147745432,
0.0061784093,
-0.0022638619,
0.0058040689,
-0.026666401,
-0.0099374643,
0.0827298537,
0.0647027716,
-0.0430968925,
-0.0277764183,
0.0105723822,
-0.0304897595,
-0.0729880854,
-0.0170745663,
-0.0583239459,
-0.0131030502,
-0.0117716892,
-0.0470771678,
-0.0680482686,
0.0784390196,
0.0053194938,
0.0327232368,
-0.0281757824,
-0.0201396886,
0.0343125574,
0.0389877297,
-0.0010655958,
0.0049871686,
0.0109751113,
-0.0049925521,
-0.0118462062,
-0.0755810291,
0.0955658853,
-0.0481837653,
-0.0094316062,
-0.0164522175,
-0.0013059843,
-0.007293859,
-0.0417386964,
-0.0645340085,
-0.0704222918,
0.0094128298,
0.0206054859,
-0.0114448043,
-0.0114031751,
-0.0262296647,
-0.0004631118,
-0.0054497509,
0.0122375125,
-0.0088628614,
0.0081801498,
-0.0161211472,
0.000320696,
0.0271560363,
-0.0695579499,
0.0509869456,
-0.0048744758,
0.0120893344,
0.0845592991,
0.0087929638,
0.0458177961,
0.0133206444,
0.0186632071,
0.0252799168,
0.004017679,
0.0221053455,
-0.0016687252,
0.0140494918,
-0.0017811358,
0.0250959806,
0.016974818,
0.0069879885,
-0.0355349518,
0.0416163616,
0.0148842391,
0.0254960712,
0.0244174544,
-0.0486704148,
-0.1123928428,
-0.0028701578,
0.0075149275,
0.0401586518,
-0.0997103378,
-0.0333316326,
0.0128800012,
-0.0842212439,
-0.0050888183,
0.0005540212,
-0.0155347651,
-0.0375199914,
0.0125406021,
0.0100721652,
0.0083873905,
0.0509466603,
-0.0347475819,
0.0421008728,
-0.0111138569,
-0.0057684374,
0.007922844,
-0.0058046472,
0.020750476,
-0.0490378886,
0.0419853292,
0.0379841216,
0.0355184376,
-0.0346729383,
0.0304567814,
0.0149864107,
-0.0369947366,
-0.0258086994,
-0.0106724845,
0.0532694273,
-0.0056659933,
-0.021249162,
-0.0376662314,
0.0556824133,
0.017665891,
-0.0086441599,
0.0074979509,
-0.0004774724,
0.0382864252,
-0.0284893271,
-0.0565962978,
-0.0066469153,
0.0484229475,
0.0636288598,
0.0265926365,
-0.0429009609,
-0.019102199,
-0.0828654245,
-0.0179073643,
-0.039859619,
-0.0930816457,
0.0243922677,
0.0099196555,
-0.0687580183,
-0.046633359,
-0.0074943416,
-0.0424060524,
0.0034787708,
0.036065314,
-0.0368001759,
-0.0248571709,
0.0090017226,
-0.0539409742,
0.0116182324,
0.0123707727,
0.0692297593,
-0.0024250764,
-0.0072957487,
-0.0305124391,
-0.0125841694,
-0.0246436335,
0.0574539751,
-0.0326440297,
-0.0557521172,
0.063552618,
0.0217519011,
0.0150220506,
0.0169523954,
-0.0372527242,
-0.0539614744,
0.0642484948,
0.0715770051,
-0.0118248882,
0.016492052,
0.0901511386,
-0.0383702517,
0.0331912637,
0.022752976,
-0.0013910882,
0.0267660487,
0.074567914,
-0.0061873309,
-0.0434738286,
0.0099315289,
-0.0092371935,
-0.033652015,
0.0686189458,
-0.0410724729,
-0.0544048697,
0.0267626029,
-0.0054545254,
0.0207562055,
-0.0191717166,
-0.0036070629,
0.0009715901,
0.0046486421,
0.0115787685,
-0.0366961733,
-0.0112943966,
-0.0274311043,
0.012006361,
-0.030737536,
0.031031901,
-0.0115712853,
0.0559707806,
0.0281085148,
0.0159276389,
-0.0071281795,
0.0372547954,
0.0005301597,
0.0086915158,
0.0056719733,
0.0105146812,
0.0258485246,
0.0101239877,
-0.0191501491,
-0.0050190305,
-0.0211307444,
0.0378045738,
0.013762081,
-0.011964241,
-0.0051894528,
-0.0265612844,
0.0074372813,
0.0371489748,
-0.0162869152,
0.0101760179,
-0.0071233413,
-0.0247955956,
-0.0302715171,
0.0103435908,
-0.0012140849,
0.0078406036,
0.0369598828,
0.0101638911,
-0.0348716974,
0.0717045963,
-0.0122570526,
-0.0114247221,
0.0248473994,
-0.0217666104,
0.044943504,
0.007555976,
0.0043608872,
-0.0001869862,
-0.0814422071,
-0.0680134073,
-0.0483777225,
-0.0082439268,
0.0462070741,
0.0011142844,
-0.0044343281,
0.0406029001,
0.0005567899,
0.0212504901,
-0.0290089715,
0.0199367013,
0.0182750113,
-0.0795196518,
0.0120531358,
-5.59239417e-33,
0.0120941596,
-0.0298179984,
-0.07238888,
-0.0048478455,
0.038261462,
-0.0114857778,
0.0256649517,
-0.0233627502,
-0.0287481993,
-0.0018845862,
0.0269180313,
0.0109216701,
-0.0097382851,
0.0040655998,
-0.0555383004,
-0.0423801988,
0.0249886084,
-0.0353652164,
-0.0245289281,
-0.0054511973,
0.0299285334,
-0.008020048,
0.0269226041,
-0.0709673911,
0.0538952984,
0.010634684,
-0.023128042,
0.0047084983,
-0.0417853408,
0.0745901465,
0.0120148603,
0.0740778819,
0.0209181402,
-0.0007595441,
0.0194597859,
0.0558482595,
-0.0438198186,
0.0032516138,
0.0185739528,
0.0100064604,
0.0465507843,
-0.0132086016,
0.0333745033,
0.010518861,
-0.0412890464,
-0.0203827377,
0.0235918164,
-0.0025416233,
0.0129038636,
-0.0344375297,
-0.0142477918,
0.0178283695,
-0.0490894243,
-0.0126650399,
-0.0452453382,
-0.0254049171,
0.0327150151,
0.0272342581,
-0.0581020787,
0.0150608253,
-0.0014281687,
-0.0096023669,
0.0068377363,
0.0031876094,
0.0080350433,
0.0682614446,
0.0550686195,
0.0318122134,
-0.0090485737,
-0.0007170897,
0.0410621427,
-0.0090073003,
0.0691857487,
0.0817928314,
0.0677439645,
-0.0708184391,
-0.0467286296,
-0.0208342765,
0.0764628649,
-0.0308458693,
0.0387323946,
-0.0222177003,
-0.0807564706,
-0.0206805244,
-0.0311658997,
-0.0893787071,
-0.0348493867,
-0.0049879556,
0.0201247521,
0.0207689051,
-0.0159946587,
0.0065515214,
0.0210391805,
-0.0505536161,
-0.026375439,
0.0271587335,
0.0056259553,
-0.0179540273,
0.0153199965,
-0.0088935792,
0.0053647608,
0.0007786595,
0.0216594804,
-0.0339565203,
0.0237843897,
-0.020472819,
0.0516918115,
0.0221138652,
-0.0453268103,
0.0054849409,
-0.0185788739,
0.0818843171,
0.0241021756,
0.007774259,
0.0073744468,
0.0314713195,
-0.0239247996,
-0.0043440517,
0.0122256186,
-0.0162906125,
-0.0687807724,
0.0503404699,
-0.0638048127,
0.0364650413,
-0.0030348164,
-0.0255028065,
0.0067154989,
-0.0063535464,
0.0435882621,
-0.0657927021,
0.0009969061,
-0.0728429928,
2.581e-7,
-0.0123402942,
-0.0063740104,
-0.0076715047,
0.0188001804,
0.0426667444,
0.0638073385,
0.043149963,
0.0996054485,
0.0015440248,
-0.0222030953,
-0.07265798,
0.0428689197,
0.0007871335,
0.0354855172,
-0.0054772352,
0.0326299854,
-0.0700160787,
0.0220100954,
-0.0252880342,
-0.002166878,
0.0218044445,
0.0659762844,
0.0569572598,
-0.024000736,
-0.0133079523,
-0.0526797101,
-0.0065049995,
-0.042100627,
0.0154586695,
-0.0199274272,
0.043337144,
0.0150099713,
0.0473844744,
0.0319772139,
-0.0009410852,
0.0140056135,
-0.0477276556,
0.0013874357,
0.0095620854,
-0.0204755012,
-0.0412944257,
-0.0261033289,
-0.0093015386,
-0.0433864743,
0.0500683188,
0.0405728146,
-0.0227087364,
-0.0351664498,
0.0030348047,
-0.0471307561,
0.0430780575,
-0.0247510914,
-0.0465082452,
0.0113171674,
0.0315273777,
0.0284427125,
0.0186200459,
-0.0704972297,
-0.0199126583,
-0.0159592666,
-0.0151151055,
-0.0306912046,
0.0164963417,
0.0212574136,
0.0011989748,
0.0392255709,
0.0110631017,
2.299802351e-34,
0.016141206,
-0.0027369328,
-0.0003368075,
-0.0078331539,
0.0222953409,
0.0144469524,
0.0190248396,
-0.0277284347,
0.0473062173,
0.0347595029,
-0.024097424
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09422v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09422v1 | Predicting generalization performance with correctness discriminators | 2023-11-15T22:43:42 | 2023-11-15T22:43:42 | Yuekun Yao, Alexander Koller | cs.CL | cs.CL | The ability to predict an NLP model's accuracy on unseen, potentially
out-of-distribution data is a prerequisite for trustworthiness. We present a
novel model that establishes upper and lower bounds on the accuracy, without
requiring gold labels for the unseen data. We achieve this by training a
discriminator which predicts whether the output of a given sequence-to-sequence
model is correct or not. We show across a variety of tagging, parsing, and
semantic parsing tasks that the gold accuracy is reliably between the predicted
upper and lower bounds, and that these bounds are remarkably close together. | [
0.0401529148,
0.0576346442,
0.0248785336,
0.0102181146,
0.0112739727,
0.0225571357,
-0.026538197,
-0.0049598985,
0.0278933216,
-0.043990612,
0.0099435737,
-0.0224265587,
-0.0355072618,
0.0164907649,
0.0274363309,
-0.0159073565,
0.0662091151,
0.0230987649,
0.0414445102,
0.0261825863,
0.0119675482,
-0.013780484,
0.003756308,
0.0578615256,
-0.0697652921,
-0.0029774229,
0.0280687697,
-0.0094246296,
-0.0014382112,
-0.0330097936,
0.0362678953,
0.0676211938,
-0.0147456583,
0.0395604409,
0.0000017293,
-0.0362224989,
-0.0615888387,
0.0023350262,
-0.0185947232,
-0.0401105359,
-0.0115274787,
-0.0670379177,
0.0300913434,
0.0214163978,
-0.0419040136,
-0.04873126,
0.0293141678,
0.0784632191,
0.0656142831,
0.0936063826,
-0.0030704904,
-0.0201006178,
0.0781376734,
-0.0104864407,
-0.0078454521,
-0.0657563657,
0.0053876312,
0.0099356407,
-0.0160054881,
-0.0023209227,
-0.014201656,
0.0284353234,
0.0061296336,
0.0153730065,
0.0476637855,
-0.0126092918,
-0.0355875418,
-0.0561780632,
-0.0117873875,
0.0242691059,
0.0168260522,
-0.0625099763,
-0.0097025502,
-0.000073934,
0.0126120802,
0.0041715107,
-0.0052020149,
0.0171928406,
-0.0273877904,
0.0259382669,
0.0066623474,
0.0061588064,
0.0400424898,
-0.0056863683,
0.0104212109,
0.1090816334,
-0.0130068026,
-0.0499796681,
0.0306861512,
0.0703169256,
-0.0798259526,
-0.0378566198,
0.0276458599,
0.0235205013,
-0.0505164117,
0.0302088968,
-0.0709820837,
-0.023101056,
0.021209253,
-0.0108788228,
0.0378542952,
0.0051918086,
-0.0168255009,
0.0258246269,
-0.0239487849,
0.0669847876,
0.0026816155,
0.0258438345,
-0.0097631989,
-0.0445419699,
-0.0603038855,
-0.0048766946,
0.000558543,
0.0489899665,
0.007844937,
-0.0091400193,
-0.0611483715,
0.0002640821,
-0.0506374612,
0.0810982659,
0.0342096537,
0.0154689793,
-0.0529130585,
0.0165672936,
-0.0416238531,
-0.0148930848,
-0.0348372944,
0.0148531338,
0.0324329622,
-0.0990786254,
-0.0184083357,
-0.0110108927,
0.0064893067,
-0.0264358111,
-0.0043641883,
0.0823731348,
-0.0034097035,
-0.0378654003,
-0.0589061603,
-0.0307839978,
-0.0254920051,
-0.0211409796,
0.0071681822,
-0.0368698351,
-0.0013253618,
-0.0054431083,
0.0266813971,
-0.0546239316,
-0.012876315,
0.0111063644,
0.0142446719,
0.0592933223,
-0.0132140554,
-0.0073683769,
-0.0043380507,
0.0051296526,
-0.0444534905,
0.0643473119,
0.003382456,
-0.0135067916,
0.067517668,
-0.011273074,
0.0441126078,
0.0025968822,
0.0147877652,
-0.0517950244,
0.0127409492,
-0.0268630683,
0.0394017585,
-0.0008341583,
0.0257939938,
0.0535059236,
-0.0141861299,
-0.036704462,
0.0465849452,
0.0286213253,
-0.0173572991,
-0.00561543,
0.0488606393,
-0.0067940215,
-0.0245850086,
0.0545395128,
-0.0655895472,
-0.038574975,
-0.0410849117,
0.0117802313,
0.0129734697,
-0.023495188,
0.0065194611,
-0.0435732193,
-0.0548607484,
-0.0123116476,
0.0226558428,
-0.0193324983,
0.0270889085,
0.0545895994,
-0.0266099703,
0.0378881171,
0.0116561595,
-0.0123275016,
0.0169235524,
-0.0145621561,
0.0342122167,
0.0287468433,
0.0355496332,
-0.0477370732,
0.0195221975,
-0.0253301151,
0.0238335542,
-0.0048545203,
0.0732465237,
-0.0165155865,
0.0376689062,
-0.0134234531,
0.0045542452,
0.0019989507,
0.0550388806,
-0.0144710923,
0.0820759162,
-0.0025706396,
0.0220732801,
-0.0586556457,
-0.0416978747,
0.072379455,
-0.0106283911,
-0.0537214652,
-0.0106609678,
-0.003078847,
0.0090255244,
0.0277291872,
0.0130289188,
0.0164248329,
0.0194225404,
-0.0063222409,
-0.0426626056,
-0.0135015417,
-0.0362896621,
0.0018286312,
0.0645563751,
-0.0469078161,
-0.0384638868,
0.0673005804,
-0.0671927705,
-0.0492014624,
0.0080259955,
-0.0168103166,
0.0151447942,
-0.0306749344,
0.0210957993,
0.0083227539,
0.003546176,
-0.0296022967,
0.0420997962,
-0.0037154239,
0.0544411875,
-0.0599375255,
-0.0316644832,
-0.0088865282,
-0.037970528,
-0.0509016626,
0.0005763301,
-0.0032378908,
0.0176738072,
0.0228770263,
-0.0230112616,
-0.0737805665,
0.0046133376,
-0.0625395104,
0.012109871,
-0.0104827899,
0.0250968728,
0.0315644406,
-0.0466061309,
0.0363123454,
-0.008373023,
-0.0254754331,
-0.0295042768,
0.0548874065,
0.0063074506,
0.063414596,
0.0229770243,
-0.0123924986,
-0.0385971665,
0.0062964037,
-0.0221184418,
0.0539265871,
0.0038446654,
-0.028735254,
-0.0431677401,
-0.0175462589,
-0.0298213195,
0.0714751333,
0.0188604407,
-0.0002703307,
0.023557093,
-0.006226649,
-0.0761501342,
0.0223953072,
-0.0026475047,
-0.0009801873,
-0.003959897,
0.0373084657,
-0.0501044914,
-0.0195972063,
-0.0238200333,
-0.0293208975,
-0.0152524663,
-0.005716661,
0.0254666302,
0.1401684135,
-0.0140679348,
-0.0125427851,
-0.0390855446,
-0.0206207745,
-0.0397525169,
-0.0361387879,
-0.0016191538,
-0.0175451059,
0.010375943,
0.0609630756,
-0.0446128845,
-0.0396369658,
0.0832491741,
-0.0351976641,
-0.0046655876,
-0.0020109455,
-0.0352362767,
0.0132241705,
0.0399474241,
0.0247581713,
0.0070143752,
0.0564048216,
-0.0363305435,
-0.0103350254,
-0.0080932649,
0.0308058914,
-0.01657678,
0.0743993819,
-0.0726183876,
0.0236037262,
0.0033539471,
-0.0395928062,
-0.0586578511,
-0.0076127625,
-0.010302701,
0.029545527,
-0.0099586248,
-0.0029630568,
-0.0361736789,
-0.0065168794,
-0.0307187624,
0.0795661733,
0.0000681388,
-0.0120665245,
-0.0252877921,
0.0399205238,
0.0252132062,
-0.0392097421,
0.00342484,
-0.0150194559,
-0.0341166593,
0.0487016216,
-0.0066479663,
0.0217286348,
-0.0537031181,
-0.0152107198,
0.0195690338,
-0.0542715415,
-0.0480980016,
0.0191916786,
0.0368427709,
-0.0603423752,
-0.0340108089,
0.1121263802,
0.029212255,
-0.0164724477,
0.0032183358,
0.0273555387,
-0.0077621774,
0.0422784351,
-0.0013680788,
-0.0510168783,
-0.0408743732,
0.0295270327,
0.0325996615,
0.0020507886,
-0.0684527233,
-0.008450943,
-0.1282913089,
-0.0006437702,
-0.006682849,
-0.0251958519,
-0.0397976004,
-0.0288607199,
-0.015872106,
-0.0300106741,
0.0008234861,
-0.0010069859,
0.0026832346,
0.02066461,
0.0468357466,
-0.0349746719,
-0.058902625,
0.0024137534,
-0.0446366929,
0.0387338251,
0.0763276666,
0.0165493675,
0.001248771,
-0.0203395355,
0.0368301198,
0.0015364949,
-0.0057413308,
-0.0000406391,
0.0457793623,
-0.0434557237,
0.0158580709,
0.0444423854,
-0.0101178382,
-0.0169054698,
0.0045718313,
-0.0079751909,
0.0772697926,
0.0252951495,
-0.0437641107,
0.0200086571,
-0.0105543835,
0.008733687,
0.0461537056,
0.0206842571,
0.0095479283,
-0.0495241918,
-0.0494373217,
0.0548418835,
-0.0330660418,
0.0286600962,
0.0420537516,
0.0136820618,
-0.0383841619,
-0.1014870256,
-0.0296664387,
0.004241542,
0.0469708331,
0.0076473309,
-0.0285200495,
0.0003209538,
-0.0119790221,
-0.0359083824,
0.01191431,
-0.0393271372,
0.0032429493,
-0.0561278686,
-0.009278548,
0.015123154,
0.0386423692,
-0.0427520312,
0.0246298146,
-0.044327952,
-0.0582147017,
-0.0117667746,
0.0393310227,
0.0332330614,
0.0407508537,
-0.0204014499,
-0.0507823452,
-0.0315128751,
0.0347067416,
-0.051662799,
-0.003356084,
0.0416453592,
-0.013985795,
0.0031965254,
0.0149872182,
-0.0271992609,
0.0292578656,
0.0266018212,
0.0252641812,
-0.01465513,
0.003997711,
0.0579099581,
0.0341044553,
0.0676661283,
-0.0117570721,
0.0327009819,
-0.0211870093,
-0.0130048152,
0.0340495743,
-0.0396573059,
-0.0327612646,
0.0380688272,
0.0436513834,
0.0019662715,
-0.016602492,
0.0113957422,
-0.0206406433,
0.0738523826,
-0.0371469259,
-0.0577698201,
0.075369522,
-0.004663581,
-0.0135092828,
-0.000292559,
-0.0378853977,
-0.0050361715,
0.0216420684,
0.064132981,
-0.0098918118,
0.001242707,
0.0196129698,
0.0567428395,
0.0000792827,
-0.0283094924,
-0.0736547634,
-0.0171807818,
-0.0422799252,
0.016223643,
0.0401156954,
-0.0194973331,
0.0243394431,
0.0008753746,
-0.0224268772,
-0.0180897731,
0.0363422707,
0.0125265643,
-0.0595236421,
0.0114104263,
0.0047031608,
-0.0251999069,
-0.0226900429,
0.0810381323,
-0.0042262645,
0.0498077087,
-0.0655693114,
-0.0652003065,
-0.0577192008,
-0.0511530675,
0.021954434,
-0.000588214,
0.003023176,
-0.0055085807,
-0.0092307646,
-0.0861608461,
0.0192146264,
-0.0058548297,
0.0448480658,
0.0145087484,
0.0050291489,
0.0782591477,
0.0140874265,
-0.0141750984,
-0.0501525179,
-0.0446440652,
0.0500833616,
0.0232809111,
-0.0820314661,
-5.779968906e-33,
-0.0418279506,
-0.0276347678,
-0.0231631212,
-0.0390033796,
0.0410393663,
0.0077952822,
-0.0174885783,
-0.0098114265,
-0.0095793242,
0.0290620513,
-0.0302960817,
0.0239422824,
0.0255320352,
0.0220760982,
0.0152730336,
-0.0181717779,
0.067736499,
-0.0003950727,
-0.0296682995,
-0.0273049939,
0.0468767732,
0.0533139743,
0.0873363018,
-0.0484620892,
0.0665611997,
0.0143916216,
-0.0339863226,
0.0163415633,
0.0034727962,
0.0231944546,
0.0120383622,
0.0299333557,
0.0279456172,
-0.0414633714,
0.0012942806,
-0.0129457926,
-0.0758643746,
0.0087579088,
-0.0041257921,
0.0240818895,
-0.0159214213,
0.0315813348,
0.0378830098,
-0.0465708077,
-0.0237028394,
-0.0096654128,
0.0270699728,
-0.0314947702,
-0.0193835143,
-0.0411252864,
-0.0505805351,
0.0235227775,
0.0154412733,
0.0334401913,
0.011751011,
0.0508776978,
0.0066767838,
0.02842528,
-0.054994721,
-0.0075126765,
0.0414002091,
0.0472615696,
0.0343847573,
0.0009738576,
-0.0236348584,
0.0708168373,
0.0284334794,
-0.0059424685,
0.0238849632,
0.0400443226,
-0.0099313082,
0.003049524,
0.0292598456,
0.052878879,
0.0461902358,
-0.0256897938,
-0.0250016768,
0.0091281757,
-0.0184474327,
0.0084572863,
-0.0124254264,
0.0184694622,
-0.0678350106,
-0.0094591472,
-0.0286849234,
-0.0176562089,
-0.0252318159,
-0.0293126274,
0.0363771245,
0.0330632962,
-0.0027131697,
0.0277769472,
-0.0097405473,
-0.0399087965,
0.0028762161,
0.0166552532,
-0.0017515816,
-0.0210926533,
0.0002604662,
-0.0189436767,
-0.0477907397,
-0.0531552322,
0.010114993,
-0.01653786,
0.0516783968,
-0.0209369939,
0.0850849673,
-0.0043632342,
-0.0688062981,
0.0334353633,
-0.0621707141,
0.0581409857,
0.0074206041,
0.0279956758,
0.0503728725,
-0.0219768826,
-0.0359249972,
0.0648108274,
0.0094082868,
0.0439126901,
-0.0054965499,
0.0162000358,
-0.0144230658,
0.0053576389,
-0.0152108967,
-0.0448901691,
0.0195689183,
0.0026483529,
0.0005716413,
-0.0168247707,
0.0116934581,
-0.0110003995,
2.527e-7,
0.029112665,
0.0243786555,
0.022373829,
-0.0001929555,
0.0002920548,
0.0315522105,
-0.0085344389,
0.0340322591,
-0.0224944651,
-0.060550902,
-0.0297903288,
-0.0202933494,
0.0303746276,
0.0595271476,
-0.0688772798,
-0.0621198192,
-0.0586064719,
0.0244420432,
-0.0110830506,
-0.0009294479,
0.0093486076,
0.0930807069,
0.0234929956,
-0.0115070017,
0.0096515128,
-0.0702478886,
0.0374989249,
0.0042477846,
0.0090914601,
0.012733547,
0.0593626499,
0.019897636,
0.0370701142,
0.0420739874,
-0.0154279443,
0.0210360494,
-0.0046381243,
0.0527066141,
-0.002590043,
0.0125976996,
-0.042451892,
-0.0149591593,
-0.002381355,
-0.0559613295,
0.0345705673,
-0.000806772,
-0.0120600564,
-0.0163649153,
-0.0365649052,
-0.0430817343,
-0.0062219244,
-0.0028524722,
0.0184758194,
0.0137575567,
0.0020212485,
0.0271750409,
-0.0289209504,
-0.0573894829,
-0.0332080536,
0.0047093579,
0.0017110499,
-0.0268282238,
0.014238474,
0.0163674317,
-0.0149525655,
-0.079773277,
-0.0018549737,
2.084944254e-34,
0.0214411058,
0.0049248259,
0.0211188104,
-0.003727179,
0.0577429458,
-0.0075287665,
-0.0320443697,
-0.0140882842,
0.0186268538,
0.0313932002,
0.0001489105
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09410v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09410v3 | When Large Language Models contradict humans? Large Language Models' Sycophantic Behaviour | 2023-11-15T22:18:33 | 2024-04-28T08:06:06 | Leonardo Ranaldi, Giulia Pucci | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models have been demonstrating the ability to solve complex
tasks by delivering answers that are positively evaluated by humans due in part
to the intensive use of human feedback that refines responses. However, the
suggestibility transmitted through human feedback increases the inclination to
produce responses that correspond to the users' beliefs or misleading prompts
as opposed to true facts, a behaviour known as sycophancy. This phenomenon
decreases the bias, robustness, and, consequently, their reliability. In this
paper, we shed light on the suggestibility of Large Language Models (LLMs) to
sycophantic behaviour, demonstrating these tendencies via human-influenced
prompts over different tasks. Our investigation reveals that LLMs show
sycophantic tendencies when responding to queries involving subjective opinions
and statements that should elicit a contrary response based on facts. In
contrast, when confronted with mathematical tasks or queries that have an
objective answer, these models at various scales seem not to follow the users'
hints by demonstrating confidence in delivering the correct answers. | [
0.0653347969,
0.0513472222,
-0.0308370348,
0.0185456928,
-0.0421391986,
0.025893636,
0.0163950678,
-0.0036427409,
0.0032711872,
-0.0391612649,
-0.0361087993,
-0.0377075598,
0.0046234941,
-0.0264485534,
0.0367591195,
-0.0415581577,
0.0262349024,
-0.040160384,
0.0311149918,
-0.0585378371,
-0.0223881118,
0.001033572,
-0.0071117403,
0.0111001693,
0.0150505062,
-0.033840593,
0.0198104829,
-0.0213597473,
-0.0301562902,
-0.0284721646,
0.013332814,
0.0631046146,
-0.02926003,
0.0653721616,
0.0000017997,
-0.0379908755,
0.0446001068,
0.006114976,
-0.0331526436,
0.0369068198,
0.0656206012,
0.0044535478,
0.0205066558,
0.0218611863,
-0.0514888726,
-0.003827621,
0.0364389569,
0.0394068398,
0.047858838,
0.0065400116,
0.0065272911,
-0.0061486326,
-0.0214414261,
-0.0044031842,
0.0211048368,
0.0025782348,
0.0152208544,
-0.0110357888,
0.0008370579,
0.0014739366,
-0.0141550098,
0.0138706844,
0.0117486604,
-0.0207360107,
-0.0605302826,
-0.0004477695,
-0.0312370919,
-0.0270616543,
0.0109083867,
0.041810479,
0.0366481505,
-0.0101265712,
-0.016270224,
-0.0076726102,
0.0211682096,
0.0857844427,
-0.0544059873,
0.0059826178,
0.0007142571,
-0.0182880685,
0.0013030928,
0.003651317,
0.0325935818,
-0.0008587637,
-0.0065608467,
0.0765994936,
-0.0060611847,
-0.0355248265,
0.0287199281,
0.0281569026,
-0.0447454862,
-0.0593365058,
-0.0084413541,
0.0447399579,
-0.0752099752,
0.0123062124,
0.0079214275,
-0.0076753916,
0.0377923213,
-0.0952502936,
0.0448846407,
0.0283232946,
-0.0095478157,
0.0397207662,
-0.0284473505,
0.0422080085,
-0.0663642213,
0.0488942862,
-0.0482211411,
-0.0017177181,
0.0083104055,
-0.0452982076,
0.020210946,
0.0256231036,
0.000133277,
0.0190338064,
-0.0157825872,
0.0467434339,
-0.0532265306,
0.0199278742,
-0.013560703,
0.0353029482,
0.0120885847,
-0.0268182009,
-0.0854154974,
0.0494158678,
-0.0450620614,
0.0411310121,
-0.0200591199,
-0.028959997,
0.0191680863,
0.0043524927,
-0.0210037362,
-0.0171018317,
0.024057949,
0.0578070134,
0.0113768019,
0.0224811248,
-0.0141103705,
-0.0264065228,
-0.0215172824,
-0.0774515718,
-0.0030677507,
-0.0446764007,
0.0135937314,
0.0662295744,
-0.0347392485,
0.0139218066,
0.0162168033,
0.0214772467,
-0.0329143256,
0.0548176505,
-0.0048585879,
0.0247019995,
0.0386270173,
-0.0086883605,
-0.0193536114,
0.0714740008,
0.0028320383,
0.0155008556,
0.017565269,
-0.0087496685,
0.0435989872,
0.0081014019,
0.0096556954,
0.016234057,
-0.0357661843,
0.0415973626,
0.0075001237,
0.0233223941,
0.0303851888,
0.1091271117,
-0.0150924297,
-0.0423068255,
0.0820551813,
0.0377495699,
-0.037208017,
0.0109423827,
0.009514072,
-0.0399301425,
0.0117596313,
0.0679799318,
-0.0747724399,
0.0350255966,
-0.0031500086,
0.0024096968,
-0.0139410542,
-0.0290171299,
-0.0123673044,
-0.0557077006,
-0.0185487512,
0.0066064456,
0.0241954736,
0.0593923219,
0.0468523838,
-0.0148956021,
0.0147882784,
0.0384945422,
0.0275148172,
0.0032744766,
0.0093271667,
-0.0527674034,
0.0485980138,
0.0362970605,
0.025538357,
-0.0159278549,
0.0230728146,
-0.0217973143,
0.0314576179,
0.0529870093,
0.1018808261,
-0.0127595812,
-0.0650093034,
0.0016454341,
0.009907661,
0.0004581024,
0.0167367049,
-0.0319306701,
-0.0086902389,
0.0115020657,
0.0001843245,
-0.0010736592,
-0.0339261219,
0.040349897,
-0.0300886985,
-0.0378969312,
-0.0442899391,
-0.0093863653,
0.0019040764,
-0.0022144844,
-0.0066572079,
0.043253053,
0.010380812,
-0.0016134379,
-0.0224313829,
-0.0043921974,
-0.0609770454,
-0.0020913905,
0.0208938811,
-0.0007457284,
-0.0056131748,
0.0081558507,
0.0208860282,
-0.0083389971,
0.0170067642,
-0.0867131352,
0.0414501056,
-0.0351979993,
-0.0074271751,
-0.0596783683,
-0.0003567598,
-0.0434494242,
-0.001087716,
0.0008156386,
0.0453196838,
0.0449572653,
-0.0227440149,
-0.0051383367,
-0.0093047041,
-0.0291915704,
0.0364894122,
0.0321509913,
0.0005993064,
0.0149698192,
-0.065403983,
-0.0100566261,
-0.0324995741,
-0.0794787779,
-0.0609029084,
-0.0161154289,
0.0185596664,
0.0105859702,
-0.0409864485,
0.0062506963,
-0.0156230917,
-0.0295178313,
0.0045145857,
0.0143099176,
0.0858479887,
0.0329617262,
0.0029895129,
0.0045000617,
-0.0355049446,
-0.0280097406,
-0.036932759,
0.0526041351,
0.0454611443,
0.0554872975,
-0.063101612,
-0.0005575969,
-0.0496865399,
0.0209246911,
-0.0084082093,
-0.0187359415,
0.021414414,
0.0125411069,
0.0089286221,
0.091273427,
0.0313033313,
0.0072656395,
0.0582475215,
0.0058718054,
-0.0604513735,
-0.0187712368,
-0.0393739231,
-0.0240407381,
-0.0239402819,
-0.0600319132,
-0.0149242384,
0.0691825822,
0.0209167115,
0.0020961668,
-0.0375505574,
0.0436671339,
-0.0631890744,
-0.0496536456,
-0.022893222,
-0.0308431406,
-0.0242868923,
0.0472576506,
0.0058272718,
-0.0541706048,
0.1031193286,
0.0206989069,
-0.0158091728,
-0.0188685916,
-0.0003262913,
-0.0277152937,
0.0459914729,
0.0017655797,
0.0236715525,
0.0239580292,
0.0139295058,
-0.1101550832,
-0.032753069,
0.0241294876,
-0.0682016313,
0.016636258,
-0.0209202524,
-0.0142158307,
-0.000719683,
-0.0431863815,
-0.0412762314,
-0.0390930437,
-0.0404449478,
0.0135817891,
0.0273046624,
-0.0273099206,
0.003584363,
-0.017369654,
0.0525118895,
-0.0185351446,
-0.0441588163,
-0.0369890928,
-0.0029073602,
-0.0180595312,
0.076464884,
0.0420056544,
0.0926316828,
-0.050534755,
0.012815522,
0.0457890704,
0.0098951347,
0.0209112801,
0.007159682,
-0.0157843158,
0.0519999564,
0.0028368921,
-0.0267825704,
0.0276362393,
0.0262874346,
-0.0443760045,
0.0083246203,
0.096234709,
0.0338348895,
-0.0392949991,
0.0048225597,
-0.0745384097,
-0.0033199938,
0.0418557413,
0.0119345952,
-0.0234618224,
0.0151666068,
0.008549015,
0.008798372,
-0.0364867598,
-0.0316857211,
-0.0037635574,
-0.0996862724,
0.0077780918,
-0.0070743226,
0.0053531318,
0.0087943505,
-0.0397998616,
0.0070618531,
-0.0184371714,
0.0321474746,
0.0178052243,
-0.0217651557,
0.0069276402,
0.0131387673,
-0.0016358851,
0.0232833419,
0.0325856954,
-0.0392979495,
0.0431400836,
0.0438966565,
0.0142098153,
-0.038777478,
-0.0626217872,
0.041520346,
-0.0130744344,
-0.002455543,
0.0054392791,
0.0206141043,
0.0083101355,
-0.0000083418,
-0.0622473881,
-0.0129064638,
-0.040512532,
-0.0055630263,
0.0121821137,
0.0936266258,
-0.005903068,
-0.0722464621,
-0.0433252864,
0.0276061129,
0.0025547959,
0.0657577589,
0.0060946019,
-0.0726926699,
-0.0353078395,
-0.0376706384,
-0.0142668346,
0.0588771589,
-0.0513107292,
0.0055347281,
0.0905249789,
0.0309669208,
-0.0576086789,
-0.0696809664,
-0.0207482241,
0.0172014479,
-0.0091190739,
-0.0078022545,
0.0345362723,
-0.0329408012,
0.0067757885,
0.0053994069,
-0.0012670488,
0.0519381016,
-0.0398408473,
0.0457380787,
0.0173332673,
-0.0228114687,
-0.0087385718,
-0.0284902938,
-0.0332936421,
-0.0630391687,
0.0436560139,
0.0354043245,
0.0308359265,
-0.0185382403,
-0.0027435818,
-0.0667131022,
0.0325257294,
0.0387009121,
-0.0392644964,
0.0374556333,
0.0101488708,
0.0252118334,
-0.0018330425,
0.0289816055,
-0.0132302335,
-0.0058558374,
0.0446631461,
0.0055581778,
-0.0334177315,
-0.0482831895,
0.0269676726,
0.0187932309,
0.0413973182,
0.002788452,
0.0079236198,
0.0182269495,
0.0038091305,
-0.0099447621,
-0.0150076989,
0.0087456554,
-0.0254061315,
-0.0018870351,
-0.0063354075,
-0.0039266548,
-0.0365920141,
-0.0066830139,
0.0181339178,
0.0038097268,
0.027234653,
-0.0039938539,
-0.008358852,
0.0345684886,
0.0130622555,
-0.0173108354,
0.0272452757,
-0.0106192306,
0.0413438044,
0.0494637005,
0.077342391,
0.0267924387,
-0.0289446302,
-0.0129601955,
-0.0071890661,
-0.0650039539,
-0.077228412,
0.0016254336,
0.0048965611,
0.0053340388,
0.0026669723,
-0.0107811131,
-0.0249788519,
-0.0063837799,
-0.0201934483,
-0.0309758689,
0.0222838409,
0.0139197297,
0.0527261347,
0.0261528101,
-0.0171765443,
-0.0216959696,
0.0486677922,
-0.0234121066,
0.040363282,
-0.0248987284,
-0.0142896287,
0.0016200546,
-0.0476081744,
0.0093666492,
-0.0060393186,
-0.0489636362,
-0.0028564218,
-0.091878362,
-0.0633761957,
0.0023135934,
0.0015937288,
0.0007469834,
-0.0858032331,
0.012718223,
0.0725426525,
-0.0042259586,
-0.0308671501,
-0.0313241594,
0.0405624881,
-0.0464052223,
0.0356791168,
-0.0496444553,
-6.097130873e-33,
0.0025632451,
-0.0623397492,
0.0120560108,
-0.0009299946,
0.0129093127,
-0.0240397844,
0.0018087844,
0.0464213453,
-0.0530089512,
0.0420423374,
-0.0206906814,
0.0227060374,
0.0082375165,
-0.0249774531,
0.0416183025,
-0.0494430922,
0.0353873707,
-0.0068355016,
-0.0287668686,
-0.0170679484,
0.0281037185,
-0.0242206994,
0.0277458467,
-0.0852385163,
0.0705663562,
-0.007475236,
0.0288542248,
0.0072929333,
-0.0500115789,
0.0083643934,
-0.0215468761,
0.0853053108,
0.0193758942,
-0.0333211124,
-0.0170518495,
0.0495946445,
0.045857273,
-0.0463138819,
0.0326387137,
0.0192092806,
-0.0310151912,
0.0080290325,
0.027670214,
-0.0252399035,
-0.0510318503,
0.0131226862,
0.0103413509,
-0.0234990548,
0.0162208229,
0.0231050197,
-0.0417181887,
-0.0006158186,
0.0252073426,
0.0054424312,
-0.016417237,
0.0680786371,
-0.0177511387,
-0.0021050088,
-0.0301690046,
0.0451829471,
0.0151723605,
0.0175370444,
0.0466575325,
0.0274516251,
0.001495102,
0.0346653908,
0.0839982107,
0.067891486,
-0.0220371448,
-0.0205345359,
-0.008201831,
0.0207067691,
0.0875290111,
0.0815731063,
0.0128352884,
-0.0139998766,
0.0028885601,
-0.0298960563,
0.0105524231,
0.0200069025,
0.062693201,
-0.0196217988,
-0.0345316119,
-0.0394701287,
-0.0698425546,
-0.0108467182,
-0.0593354553,
-0.0356692001,
-0.0129865864,
-0.0025403108,
0.0193949193,
0.0227854978,
0.0197820552,
-0.042850893,
-0.0516851991,
-0.0152620664,
-0.0015487187,
-0.0008198288,
0.0292486418,
0.0232165009,
-0.0314141214,
0.0199154224,
-0.0377179459,
0.0152505422,
0.0065055969,
0.0268648714,
-0.0191015974,
-0.0006985787,
-0.0554723144,
-0.0062911166,
-0.0287988316,
-0.0057100556,
0.0212096423,
-0.0670155287,
0.0432102978,
0.0009145915,
-0.0085954173,
-0.0140986154,
0.0007255032,
-0.0159327965,
-0.049962122,
0.0389047265,
-0.025817493,
0.0324247405,
-0.0156973191,
-0.0285646245,
-0.0394543484,
0.0549499989,
-0.008370175,
-0.0626858026,
-0.0204902198,
-0.0124208312,
2.58e-7,
0.0325447582,
0.0699343234,
-0.048384022,
0.0381296873,
0.0374683961,
0.0488841087,
0.0195523649,
-0.0068637501,
0.0520086251,
-0.0471277386,
-0.0092029748,
0.0049439608,
0.0201787706,
0.0514200851,
-0.0589693338,
0.0159550663,
-0.0962905139,
0.0282968916,
-0.0244438257,
0.0313635841,
0.047443185,
0.0566482767,
-0.0041169617,
-0.0024318565,
-0.0294347145,
-0.0307391398,
0.0678753629,
-0.0437696502,
0.0191389248,
0.0011161694,
0.0092594931,
-0.0271602664,
0.0383055396,
0.0564975962,
0.0136677297,
-0.0107768532,
-0.0132742021,
0.026590731,
0.0185240265,
-0.0083421273,
-0.0238600653,
-0.0453468859,
0.0162978601,
-0.0963963047,
0.061103709,
-0.066439867,
-0.0240245908,
-0.0433722362,
0.0097557139,
-0.0429538675,
0.0679812655,
-0.0409613885,
-0.000926241,
-0.0021490329,
0.0149053866,
0.0284852814,
0.0181322675,
-0.0177353006,
-0.0299102589,
0.0168578289,
-0.041722171,
-0.0855489969,
-0.0287213773,
0.0362826735,
0.0283167791,
-0.0366604179,
0.0286699347,
2.157728247e-34,
0.0402433909,
0.0233043022,
0.024333965,
0.0073842397,
0.0168834124,
0.0174999982,
-0.0004478934,
0.0222876612,
0.0651367828,
-0.0444317423,
-0.0142601691
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09406v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09406v1 | Alternatives to the Scaled Dot Product for Attention in the Transformer Neural Network Architecture | 2023-11-15T22:10:42 | 2023-11-15T22:10:42 | James Bernhard | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.NE, I.2.0; I.2.7 | The transformer neural network architecture uses a form of attention in which
the dot product of query and key is divided by the square root of the key
dimension before applying softmax. This scaling of the dot product is designed
to avoid the absolute value of the dot products becoming so large that applying
softmax leads to vanishing gradients. In this paper, we propose some
alternative scalings, including dividing the dot product instead by the sum of
the key lengths before applying softmax. We use simulated keys and queries to
show that in many situations this appears to be more effective at avoiding
regions where applying softmax leads to vanishing gradients. | [
-0.0180724375,
0.0012523835,
-0.0013623731,
0.0091468822,
0.0074496255,
-0.0113953464,
0.0349956453,
-0.0014877578,
-0.0665374994,
0.0189890992,
-0.0446206927,
-0.0504686944,
-0.0122258207,
0.0500134192,
0.0311644133,
-0.0408180952,
0.0094513195,
0.0143862925,
-0.0691427886,
0.0104619283,
-0.0243162159,
-0.0337853581,
0.0222790949,
0.0454957858,
-0.0457276143,
0.0211011004,
-0.0421504788,
-0.0048615658,
0.0450631902,
0.0096685728,
0.0142110689,
0.0001600928,
-0.0276698098,
0.0033136038,
0.0000018971,
0.0008756962,
0.0303013604,
-0.0041493289,
0.0158890504,
0.0162945371,
-0.0202426929,
-0.0374034978,
0.0201658718,
0.011373518,
-0.0157066323,
-0.0405349955,
0.0480295941,
0.0719167292,
0.0504113585,
0.0660329312,
-0.0194522869,
-0.0463253595,
0.0428266227,
-0.0415830351,
-0.0102675091,
-0.0778781697,
0.021700548,
-0.0777939335,
-0.0197790712,
0.0162460357,
0.0022432092,
0.0647453368,
0.0369198248,
-0.0168418773,
0.0643350407,
0.0370863415,
-0.0177738853,
-0.0082239108,
0.0188186001,
0.044112362,
-0.0751822293,
0.0039036977,
0.0197556801,
-0.0104145212,
0.0096216444,
-0.0229745097,
-0.0379553996,
0.004375089,
0.0315065123,
0.0239909478,
-0.058088284,
0.0316806324,
0.0207965262,
0.0142071703,
-0.0631595477,
-0.0181910563,
-0.0118151419,
0.0150579661,
-0.0138315959,
-0.0404715799,
-0.0341056772,
0.0169531535,
0.0061103413,
0.0705432817,
-0.0141299618,
-0.0171490237,
-0.0221486781,
-0.0325946957,
-0.0220898669,
-0.0917203426,
0.0660141483,
0.0251283925,
-0.0155015923,
0.0320084132,
-0.0467936434,
0.1007663757,
-0.0570354313,
0.0261238441,
-0.0238357149,
-0.0183445197,
-0.0028335194,
0.0071697766,
-0.0484739058,
0.0506916754,
0.0097895116,
-0.0272251274,
-0.0164208114,
0.0217722673,
0.0108115561,
-0.0356106423,
0.0364434607,
0.0529884771,
-0.0413198024,
-0.0066626612,
0.010334284,
0.0639356375,
-0.0037188123,
-0.0048524695,
0.0101230219,
-0.0182245914,
-0.0305362977,
-0.0089457836,
0.0105560375,
0.0008497894,
0.0240599327,
0.0353134312,
-0.016816305,
-0.0325491205,
-0.0440812856,
-0.0005244424,
-0.0027348429,
0.0217119996,
0.0361949317,
-0.0210653115,
0.0395039283,
-0.0173758995,
-0.0095635587,
-0.0184733756,
0.0088138077,
0.0162926633,
-0.0333808437,
0.0265295561,
0.0552621745,
-0.005235441,
0.0181913711,
-0.0156261679,
0.0012467034,
0.068639636,
0.0302057154,
0.0672013089,
-0.0315943509,
0.0025314963,
0.0149395745,
-0.002033364,
0.0249178242,
-0.0138455499,
-0.009667147,
-0.0447008647,
-0.0235971157,
0.0356042236,
0.0241446607,
0.0570518449,
-0.0147115691,
-0.0642089248,
0.0555711761,
0.0192989707,
0.0707235262,
0.0993836001,
-0.0014007133,
-0.0304405671,
-0.0444757007,
-0.0222191028,
-0.0405306257,
0.0766482353,
0.0306781176,
-0.0413706265,
-0.0611457974,
0.0258465353,
-0.0570283979,
-0.0206058305,
0.0106816757,
0.0025224132,
-0.0276183616,
-0.0241144765,
0.0388672501,
0.0217510331,
-0.0418184772,
0.0813088417,
0.0016818692,
-0.0039453823,
-0.0200574603,
-0.0527783558,
-0.0514872707,
-0.0362700261,
0.0086898673,
-0.0219385177,
-0.0334069133,
0.0037558901,
-0.0201250371,
-0.0072324676,
0.0520044342,
0.02885608,
-0.0199637562,
-0.0413756482,
-0.0181197841,
0.0158099309,
0.0071811536,
0.0152238514,
-0.0111312633,
0.0425220951,
0.0253673736,
-0.0203766227,
0.0158123411,
0.0075596031,
0.0218806751,
-0.0370602757,
0.034512192,
0.027711425,
-0.0105024539,
0.0277058706,
0.0124292364,
0.0137665523,
0.0390434824,
-0.0204208456,
-0.0170415435,
-0.021406563,
-0.0443612821,
0.0785845071,
0.0273395684,
-0.0308444686,
0.0459982418,
0.0499704331,
0.0027656152,
-0.0336073525,
0.0416893028,
-0.0496725291,
-0.014574009,
-0.0162545703,
0.0145565812,
-0.0223458614,
0.0371958241,
-0.026543906,
0.0286008064,
-0.0015484118,
0.0106223552,
-0.0188492425,
-0.0238478668,
0.0011923548,
0.0082287369,
-0.0241665654,
0.0024808035,
-0.0474399216,
0.0201406647,
-0.0158907231,
-0.0313851237,
0.0071255877,
-0.0234141164,
0.0087244026,
-0.0223077927,
-0.0123199699,
0.0305941049,
0.0131037394,
0.0549762547,
0.0307324398,
-0.0171229802,
-0.0241066087,
0.044731006,
-0.0173019916,
-0.0316264443,
0.0280455295,
0.0184607953,
-0.0116978027,
-0.0075165671,
-0.051693432,
-0.001233138,
0.0481172428,
0.0144676864,
-0.0137658985,
-0.012450316,
0.0082666753,
0.0150388097,
0.0259585213,
-0.0038552047,
-0.0503119007,
-0.0302656405,
-0.0440740846,
-0.010306282,
0.121200949,
0.0367415436,
-0.0444973521,
0.0286187474,
0.007702251,
-0.0272674263,
0.0333349891,
-0.0502498634,
-0.0054441653,
-0.008013675,
0.0100965006,
0.0485875942,
0.0585943125,
-0.0540563241,
-0.0167793613,
-0.0476978011,
-0.0023709273,
0.0255350694,
-0.0023189404,
0.0203643944,
0.0208327044,
-0.0380532555,
0.0145813143,
-0.0066278107,
0.0045128195,
0.0195525605,
0.0217166282,
0.0006328913,
-0.0067162239,
0.0162555985,
-0.0164599381,
0.0083742887,
-0.0135985622,
0.0162983444,
-0.0218489803,
-0.0452368781,
-0.0146394959,
-0.0139517626,
-0.0174378715,
-0.0260280799,
0.1136856824,
0.0146257784,
0.003826265,
-0.0378756709,
-0.0322931074,
-0.0498486869,
0.015767714,
0.0065576304,
0.0630534515,
0.058584746,
-0.0383220129,
-0.0623649321,
0.0455494635,
0.0504740141,
0.0490851887,
-0.0200926997,
-0.0305783562,
0.0026043151,
0.0207350049,
0.017010659,
0.0719557554,
0.0264181439,
0.0197842084,
-0.0061615435,
0.0426980406,
0.0523146801,
-0.0228891801,
-0.062427517,
-0.0299661905,
0.0110940523,
-0.0155641157,
-0.007600192,
-0.0022490241,
0.0105123967,
-0.0543910861,
-0.0227503236,
0.0312594324,
0.0021377774,
-0.0832985193,
0.0120143341,
0.0091778869,
-0.0115083642,
0.0112354392,
0.0493782572,
-0.0255280789,
-0.0109801739,
-0.0233860109,
0.0282899793,
-0.0005902263,
-0.0296383463,
0.0335146077,
-0.0361463651,
0.0079426244,
0.0066255075,
-0.0199444741,
-0.053151913,
-0.0379727557,
0.0323938653,
-0.0378289558,
-0.0185867529,
0.0008516902,
-0.0138035854,
-0.0868459344,
0.0266339537,
0.0527736433,
-0.0151575757,
-0.02111472,
-0.0591500178,
-0.0474641696,
0.0264656544,
-0.0039689355,
-0.0197055303,
-0.0659087971,
0.0084056742,
0.0095633417,
0.0467365086,
0.0145901246,
0.0120559325,
0.0181542691,
-0.0447992049,
-0.0083714174,
-0.0015296417,
-0.032537397,
0.0410422161,
-0.0444053411,
0.0768395439,
-0.0263665076,
-0.0363923311,
-0.0382066667,
-0.0371137448,
-0.0566966385,
-0.0150328195,
0.0339651406,
0.00872155,
-0.0483115427,
0.0047468469,
0.0012503202,
-0.0437317528,
-0.0880304426,
0.0275469758,
0.0266721826,
-0.0677774325,
-0.0403117314,
-0.0208689738,
-0.0299939271,
0.0569913276,
0.0034948413,
-0.091155827,
0.0716601461,
-0.0000989376,
-0.0110994549,
0.017643949,
-0.007564242,
-0.0090769148,
-0.037548203,
0.0729454234,
0.0632305667,
-0.0561326705,
-0.0064129154,
-0.0146687217,
-0.0740064308,
-0.0201048665,
0.0372424014,
0.0280519705,
0.0100907711,
-0.0029374035,
-0.0314855762,
-0.0618782975,
0.0516979657,
0.0827268586,
-0.0370758399,
0.0223649554,
0.0378785767,
-0.1001585722,
-0.0087821558,
0.0193645451,
-0.0482495092,
0.0395322256,
0.0177534912,
0.0201830976,
-0.0306384861,
-0.019780159,
-0.0136737386,
-0.0459367372,
0.0722796842,
0.0842519403,
0.044382818,
-0.0177517142,
0.0414584167,
0.0412853323,
0.0252210405,
-0.0450904742,
-0.0185382087,
0.0021395306,
0.0411211699,
0.0059883511,
-0.01085696,
0.0501899906,
-0.0536794141,
-0.0214713626,
0.0333786309,
-0.0139788501,
-0.0115354564,
0.0043985229,
0.0032939885,
-0.0279743895,
-0.0244859271,
0.0517160036,
0.039637547,
0.0032085511,
0.0086401217,
0.03099888,
0.005888795,
-0.0672698319,
0.0025236055,
-0.0704898164,
-0.0446514599,
-0.021653248,
-0.0615287051,
0.0610106215,
-0.0322734192,
0.0091624912,
-0.0032068479,
-0.011940714,
-0.0131732365,
0.0013572646,
-0.001373728,
0.0357539728,
0.0163143519,
0.0206202809,
0.0444597639,
-0.0276648868,
0.0071345335,
-0.0613043569,
0.0066058296,
0.0005466482,
0.0145275341,
-0.0127143608,
0.0153684439,
-0.0010829759,
0.0113027459,
-0.0043483758,
-0.0058811367,
-0.0134502165,
-0.0214755516,
0.0134642096,
-0.0237528104,
0.0275792908,
-0.0385933779,
0.0449233353,
0.0205152854,
0.0309379492,
-0.0155105395,
0.0094987517,
-0.0057929242,
-0.0002085773,
-0.0194044653,
-0.0116854934,
-6.111001339e-33,
0.0139436955,
0.0128173158,
0.0016872617,
0.0415865108,
-0.057062801,
0.0492427647,
-0.0078087063,
-0.0215015206,
-0.0837346241,
-0.0077126189,
-0.0765461996,
0.0096182413,
0.0052772206,
0.0067441701,
0.0224187877,
-0.054322131,
0.0345494784,
0.0022360662,
0.0186591391,
0.0408319682,
-0.0183350407,
0.0269232038,
0.0818695277,
-0.0269136596,
-0.0650133193,
0.0293682963,
0.0031021554,
0.0050969254,
-0.009180421,
0.048619695,
-0.0049440232,
0.0270370822,
0.018117452,
-0.0897563323,
-0.0260022841,
-0.0327907763,
-0.0695081353,
-0.0196790211,
-0.0658669472,
0.0242337752,
-0.0047820322,
-0.0052870242,
0.1172420159,
0.0285063051,
0.0073168869,
-0.0641879067,
0.0382470414,
0.0043920488,
-0.0521245673,
-0.0518513918,
0.0068493867,
0.0282651819,
0.0150764454,
-0.0293223765,
0.0176174659,
0.0268390868,
-0.0384757817,
0.020274438,
-0.0782102719,
0.0260452759,
0.0317298137,
0.0328629501,
-0.0020348334,
0.0787885487,
0.0041023893,
0.0044360752,
0.0659896955,
0.0052606608,
-0.0495331325,
-0.0291808862,
0.0406773351,
0.0165378489,
0.0719638616,
-0.0278397091,
0.0498717725,
0.0029987367,
-0.0444832072,
-0.0224808007,
-0.0217728075,
0.0856552497,
0.0362479351,
0.003395963,
-0.0255206507,
-0.0081844814,
0.001200948,
0.0373601019,
-0.0543384515,
-0.0021092941,
-0.0086217206,
0.0316338539,
-0.0143754398,
0.0732457861,
0.0118032815,
-0.0349875577,
0.0558581799,
0.0116197011,
0.0483559929,
0.0473925397,
0.0145671507,
-0.0295661017,
-0.0256773997,
-0.0145199029,
-0.0011456177,
0.0190688465,
0.010715887,
0.0029929737,
-0.0318573155,
0.0596117638,
-0.0472247601,
-0.0757914707,
-0.0265117083,
0.0064171832,
0.0172846038,
0.0367202759,
0.049718,
-0.0463301651,
0.023237722,
0.0774380788,
-0.0226594992,
0.0070391195,
-0.005662058,
0.0206246786,
0.0438439175,
0.0460855216,
-0.0353996567,
0.0112672914,
-0.066465266,
0.0396629944,
0.0088797463,
-0.0760028735,
-0.0574727058,
0.0463360474,
2.844e-7,
0.0026912885,
0.0103167826,
0.0282155555,
0.0260848887,
-0.0143837323,
0.0368575342,
0.0458552875,
0.0563955233,
0.0241081696,
0.0212492868,
0.0512302294,
0.016240282,
-0.0283420403,
-0.0021588879,
-0.0905269161,
-0.0396572277,
-0.0126944995,
0.0230813138,
-0.0197472777,
-0.0038148891,
-0.010341241,
0.0952296183,
-0.0041860533,
-0.0013740173,
0.0455555953,
-0.0041081998,
-0.0023750542,
0.0247177463,
0.0417824388,
0.0176525228,
0.0664202198,
-0.0219704956,
-0.037773069,
0.012803575,
0.0204928406,
0.0530588441,
0.0075958157,
0.006196578,
-0.015042875,
-0.0582239106,
0.0469609648,
-0.0110042207,
0.0156141762,
-0.0701081753,
0.0476526767,
-0.0807943419,
-0.0286082588,
0.0092487931,
0.0074800127,
0.0080394978,
0.0011895361,
-0.0217974111,
0.0107085742,
0.0032613429,
0.0085733775,
-0.030456109,
0.0030912678,
-0.0575564019,
0.0328734815,
0.0283832103,
-0.0415711924,
0.0137207173,
-0.0556956381,
-0.0385947376,
0.0480212718,
0.0547692329,
-0.0326806083,
2.115609044e-34,
0.0158611853,
-0.0144812092,
0.0008850129,
0.0072014378,
-0.028694503,
-0.0015374699,
0.0012863597,
0.0054643825,
0.0300406292,
-0.0592547581,
-0.053799551
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09404v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09404v1 | To Translate or Not to Translate: A Systematic Investigation of Translation-Based Cross-Lingual Transfer to Low-Resource Languages | 2023-11-15T22:03:28 | 2023-11-15T22:03:28 | Benedikt Ebing, Goran Glavaš | cs.CL | cs.CL | Perfect machine translation (MT) would render cross-lingual transfer (XLT) by
means of multilingual language models (LMs) superfluous. Given, on one hand,
the large body of work on improving XLT with multilingual LMs and, on the other
hand, recent advances in massively multilingual MT, in this work, we
systematically evaluate existing and propose new translation-based XLT
approaches for transfer to low-resource languages. We show that all
translation-based approaches dramatically outperform zero-shot XLT with
multilingual LMs, rendering the approach that combines the round-trip
translation of the source-language training data with the translation of the
target-language test instances the most effective. We next show that one can
obtain further empirical gains by adding reliable translations to other
high-resource languages to the training data. Moreover, we propose an effective
translation-based XLT strategy even for languages not supported by the MT
system. Finally, we show that model selection for XLT based on target-language
validation data obtained with MT outperforms model selection based on the
source-language data. We hope that our findings encourage adoption of more
robust translation-based baselines in XLT research. | [
-0.0242472757,
0.0544801876,
-0.021325931,
0.0441267379,
-0.0395954736,
0.0057908851,
0.0335844383,
0.0236280002,
-0.0367561541,
-0.0167663228,
-0.0537349693,
-0.064122133,
0.0047612246,
-0.032161098,
0.0310029257,
-0.0450739637,
0.0465888083,
-0.01061936,
-0.0576547012,
0.0040939394,
-0.0276450906,
0.0258679688,
0.0294281226,
0.001334774,
-0.0052936915,
-0.0009698778,
0.0314610302,
0.0355162732,
0.0474596322,
-0.0153028816,
-0.0312964506,
0.0018946159,
0.0203492865,
0.0566455126,
0.0000019742,
-0.0259303357,
-0.0590393916,
0.0231239218,
-0.0025258642,
0.0226954799,
0.0422738232,
-0.1091937795,
-0.008943079,
0.0213246737,
-0.0024622676,
-0.0305491798,
0.0700270534,
0.0089891031,
0.0442630276,
0.0863528252,
-0.0261059366,
0.0011083822,
0.0158534907,
-0.0389995389,
0.019595271,
-0.0584156103,
0.0110902581,
0.0299447458,
-0.0434843153,
0.0203349013,
-0.0304952897,
0.058656171,
-0.0042100982,
0.0267187823,
-0.0486822538,
-0.0137653174,
-0.0380416401,
-0.015237595,
-0.0098437322,
0.0627609566,
-0.0631893575,
-0.0126178814,
-0.0181799792,
-0.0021324793,
-0.0292650498,
-0.0198051017,
-0.0507132113,
0.013341913,
0.0370042138,
0.0125654703,
0.0428457372,
0.0070651462,
0.0460223928,
-0.0168187451,
-0.0443011597,
-0.0126267392,
0.0518431365,
-0.0274813753,
0.0375513621,
0.0399448089,
0.0177780911,
-0.0001050291,
-0.010830597,
-0.0041077146,
0.0105827637,
0.02165276,
-0.0433804169,
-0.0371507592,
0.0074253124,
-0.0073521631,
0.058041472,
0.0585585386,
-0.0289378706,
0.0394730419,
-0.0589305945,
0.0458779223,
-0.024750879,
0.0047622402,
-0.0605196804,
-0.0368870124,
-0.0274406895,
0.0371826887,
-0.0337097533,
-0.0183352102,
-0.0271837935,
0.0192729384,
-0.034375377,
-0.0099975085,
0.0184577443,
-0.0206055939,
0.0065149372,
-0.0634649619,
-0.0742360502,
-0.0086309584,
0.0439022705,
0.0814744309,
0.0092795594,
-0.0148716317,
-0.0266368855,
-0.0656022653,
-0.0330903009,
0.0354736671,
-0.0101235248,
-0.0504416376,
0.0157376062,
0.1082559079,
-0.0354328044,
-0.0374550186,
-0.0369183272,
0.0197351594,
-0.0242706109,
-0.0678393692,
0.019224342,
-0.0538195297,
0.0661012903,
0.0075380108,
0.0702890828,
-0.0073687756,
-0.0045915139,
-0.0071497089,
-0.0346426293,
0.044960402,
0.0095585156,
0.0175895095,
0.0119274678,
-0.0360784195,
-0.0280642863,
0.0926692784,
0.0451355241,
0.0003620432,
0.0345326252,
-0.0268564131,
-0.039766632,
0.0744503215,
0.0297081918,
0.0550185218,
-0.0269970316,
-0.018789243,
0.0335414633,
0.011473381,
0.016744053,
0.0202044472,
-0.0120268818,
0.0402601473,
0.0659160763,
0.0233706776,
0.0308905058,
0.0519647412,
0.0578814521,
-0.0008083017,
-0.0361300446,
-0.0099401679,
-0.0092608687,
0.016653426,
-0.0022715244,
-0.0044743051,
0.0155517804,
0.04616547,
-0.0244292505,
0.0109646264,
0.0045305989,
-0.0213422719,
-0.0132158734,
-0.0247308519,
0.0570270531,
0.0160362255,
-0.0450826995,
0.0713053793,
0.0459050238,
-0.0366568677,
0.0335590504,
-0.0181684121,
-0.0289610792,
0.0286693089,
0.0067709512,
0.0278229658,
-0.0099954288,
-0.0025009832,
0.040286921,
0.0315620042,
0.0732342452,
0.0212590545,
0.0531806573,
-0.054191228,
0.0016105691,
0.0074506169,
0.0173124094,
0.0582812838,
-0.0154520012,
0.0835302398,
0.0258563366,
-0.0499787666,
-0.0633802116,
0.0275807064,
-0.0721125379,
-0.0235349312,
0.0446675904,
0.0222376566,
0.0121538155,
0.0039744773,
-0.0172084365,
-0.0251152832,
-0.0081835864,
-0.0372443087,
0.0010304456,
0.0155725507,
-0.0233994909,
-0.0433229469,
0.0122505538,
-0.0224068146,
0.0056152372,
0.0255349874,
-0.0449237302,
-0.040338479,
-0.0058016051,
-0.0035438794,
0.0138951102,
-0.0421418808,
0.0188212171,
0.0056981957,
0.0354686081,
-0.0058579841,
0.0184086356,
0.048505228,
0.0010809788,
-0.0050023445,
-0.0553469472,
0.0391440056,
-0.0396510661,
-0.0204304475,
0.042805519,
-0.0090139769,
0.0423163846,
0.0163908992,
0.0623137541,
-0.0070074918,
-0.0036353238,
-0.0652367696,
0.0237756073,
-0.0177412424,
0.0310039092,
0.0104080103,
0.0313171633,
0.0040189032,
0.0018407291,
-0.0223360602,
0.0234247744,
0.0228449441,
0.0251268987,
0.0113679245,
-0.0062063434,
0.0217473693,
-0.0159004964,
-0.0162030403,
0.0258841421,
0.0489682183,
-0.0316946171,
-0.0290398989,
-0.0350048579,
0.0419968218,
-0.0302292239,
-0.0234520212,
-0.0037029928,
-0.0387210958,
-0.0171083286,
-0.0072229807,
0.0011478558,
0.0238280836,
-0.0239127874,
-0.0384834819,
0.0297017321,
-0.0240402259,
-0.0687800348,
0.0126300948,
0.0028355499,
-0.0541094355,
-0.0367011391,
-0.0475037433,
0.0098856697,
0.0377362482,
-0.0079103811,
-0.0232047252,
-0.0931403488,
-0.0406031124,
-0.0292358398,
0.0001695317,
-0.032863792,
0.0707680136,
0.0186794177,
0.033155378,
-0.0141322985,
-0.0369446687,
0.0416473337,
-0.0477459766,
-0.018722957,
-0.0302113295,
-0.0043942262,
-0.0543201566,
0.0228006504,
-0.0372666717,
0.0312240589,
-0.0529423878,
-0.0028081469,
-0.0297378749,
-0.0011162977,
0.0184501205,
-0.0102597242,
0.0235987026,
-0.062911965,
0.002343823,
-0.022376528,
-0.0203082487,
-0.0039787069,
-0.0073026652,
0.0108638862,
-0.0047150361,
-0.0166427288,
-0.0033788481,
-0.0649526864,
0.0216210205,
0.0206075627,
0.045666486,
0.0065735988,
0.0121636968,
-0.0105630429,
0.0158887338,
-0.0025488238,
-0.0295826178,
0.0019678199,
-0.0792121813,
0.0246977229,
0.0087623931,
0.0158835854,
0.0069655431,
-0.0013826045,
0.0024646989,
0.0427940451,
0.0154293561,
-0.0343327224,
-0.0193611085,
0.0668141395,
-0.0198045969,
0.0019956324,
0.0667079166,
-0.0061710789,
-0.018111106,
-0.007847758,
-0.0190081391,
0.0124062542,
-0.0163271464,
0.0455720089,
-0.0937851518,
-0.0267414041,
-0.0027414325,
0.0296698567,
0.0348630287,
0.0179484189,
-0.0449751653,
-0.1118446961,
0.0120781893,
0.0488649681,
-0.0851790458,
-0.04250535,
-0.0216215272,
-0.0185403954,
-0.0511767007,
0.0429872908,
-0.0392543003,
-0.0059105395,
-0.0184694938,
0.004801455,
0.0228392519,
-0.0597653277,
0.0262874719,
-0.0424130224,
0.0212783832,
0.0410179608,
0.0527059995,
-0.0141050322,
-0.0251570977,
0.034977261,
-0.0219229758,
-0.0149124796,
-0.0125621213,
0.0244161021,
-0.0123081589,
-0.0290713776,
0.0932071432,
-0.006378334,
-0.0295998026,
0.0140504027,
0.0384843796,
0.0791462213,
0.0336627625,
-0.0416203849,
0.0371900424,
-0.0244082771,
0.0230413191,
0.0549466796,
-0.0058897599,
-0.0530931652,
0.0046706856,
0.0055951034,
-0.0335539207,
-0.0526248328,
-0.0155083425,
0.0119987624,
-0.0810178369,
-0.0460134745,
-0.0777337402,
-0.056558609,
0.02112028,
0.0470650308,
0.0280723795,
0.0072498778,
-0.0420195386,
0.0214363672,
0.0157002676,
0.0278240573,
-0.0528199784,
0.0227424856,
-0.0426543504,
0.0120446924,
0.0150195882,
-0.0443491042,
0.0229598284,
0.0093114562,
-0.0468343087,
-0.0582716092,
-0.0492188931,
0.0531106889,
0.0122269029,
0.0390918404,
0.0038104714,
-0.0069574383,
0.0234699175,
0.0070256405,
-0.0066254665,
-0.007386303,
0.05695628,
-0.0224700626,
-0.0032343138,
0.0565077439,
-0.027063461,
0.0186845921,
0.0121335136,
0.0673798174,
-0.0382136628,
-0.0431275405,
0.0102273673,
0.0276965853,
0.0133663639,
-0.0302967895,
-0.0521859005,
-0.0077746068,
0.0353116393,
-0.0210477132,
-0.0041943798,
-0.0608446933,
-0.0258261114,
0.0596925467,
0.0168955997,
-0.0114250286,
-0.0018195618,
-0.0019251376,
-0.0089396639,
-0.0163010973,
0.0046320008,
-0.0193764698,
0.0497554243,
0.0287440345,
0.0296119731,
-0.0083548678,
-0.0113501782,
-0.0037706858,
0.0187310018,
-0.0490794554,
0.0243392475,
-0.0078964466,
0.0232886449,
0.01564545,
-0.0000864444,
0.0009225711,
-0.0315617286,
-0.0388698019,
-0.0244977903,
0.0665245578,
-0.0080784597,
0.1538595706,
0.0009590762,
-0.0247193929,
-0.0209630467,
0.0345343985,
-0.0046492666,
0.0043565556,
-0.0226901695,
-0.0103397993,
-0.0092067141,
0.0256711915,
0.0562887304,
0.003682537,
0.0232723355,
-0.0284610037,
0.0127978455,
-0.0118103037,
0.0167977698,
0.0444741286,
-0.0504738577,
0.0032848981,
-0.0187214483,
-0.0408152193,
-0.0714449212,
0.0253287796,
-0.0098022213,
-0.0103385253,
0.0078770407,
-0.0254941881,
0.1015647054,
-0.0202135555,
0.0248400383,
-0.0522945598,
-0.0255465787,
0.0332158729,
-0.0027856762,
-0.0105107259,
-5.930872258e-33,
-0.0124908909,
0.031033013,
0.0222990196,
-0.0303197075,
-0.0159175415,
0.0034442896,
-0.037218798,
-0.0260497369,
-0.0016332596,
0.0004622011,
-0.0066879517,
-0.0199566279,
0.029268831,
0.0205552597,
0.0203716867,
0.0366292596,
0.0385637321,
0.0002352968,
-0.0275585596,
0.0196307637,
0.0354215316,
0.049744755,
0.1080415249,
-0.0476937816,
0.0269869063,
0.0109382784,
0.0119791673,
0.0075154901,
0.0095978193,
0.0085701011,
0.0074232523,
0.0244150925,
0.0210933983,
-0.0386273339,
-0.0102152517,
-0.0278869439,
-0.0690869763,
-0.0132303629,
0.0266876407,
0.0198391378,
0.0089110043,
-0.0335278958,
-0.000339031,
-0.048181925,
0.0223779213,
-0.034573283,
0.0089569399,
-0.0668716058,
-0.0360925607,
-0.0162859093,
-0.0767665729,
0.0283141769,
0.000246828,
-0.0056927791,
0.0547371209,
0.0975156426,
-0.0212056115,
-0.0004038896,
-0.0421916731,
0.0177687593,
-0.0395307168,
0.0364360362,
0.0861868411,
0.0012022693,
-0.0472577363,
-0.0064584711,
0.011915789,
-0.0243482534,
0.0618160702,
0.015736172,
0.0532785207,
0.0138390902,
0.0418307632,
0.08599969,
0.0232100748,
-0.0405352674,
-0.0790856183,
0.0402825773,
-0.0208758526,
-0.0092890467,
0.0234605186,
0.0123628909,
-0.0110811302,
-0.0050737984,
-0.0361622721,
-0.053900376,
-0.018318316,
-0.0418420248,
0.0145274373,
0.008946212,
-0.0432538353,
-0.0130364755,
0.1027221158,
-0.0117042204,
-0.0401574485,
-0.0074508851,
-0.0374731347,
-0.0108505441,
-0.0225294437,
0.0456561297,
-0.0350313857,
-0.0904156715,
0.0019550468,
0.0018143116,
0.0241508465,
-0.0416336209,
0.0595805906,
0.0267142579,
-0.0574275106,
0.0100239422,
-0.0366267078,
-0.0062731048,
-0.0067609833,
0.0662718341,
0.0073246001,
0.0008471368,
0.0076437853,
0.026816288,
0.0312184505,
-0.0240551643,
-0.007693456,
0.0141037581,
0.0147662042,
0.0226686541,
-0.0338363051,
0.0126722362,
-0.0185434893,
-0.00302125,
0.0503905527,
-0.0365517735,
-0.0264422297,
0.0094643235,
2.653e-7,
0.0391390547,
0.0207800567,
-0.0249889065,
-0.0093949232,
-0.0145096863,
0.0206818134,
-0.0540271476,
0.0363349207,
0.0149347438,
0.036560446,
0.0258122347,
0.0417371057,
0.1350057274,
0.0436729379,
-0.0473540351,
-0.035183534,
-0.0094450135,
0.0279454086,
-0.0506196059,
-0.0071614711,
0.0152660813,
0.0822357759,
-0.0181815568,
-0.0126310214,
-0.0056232773,
-0.0276663471,
0.0830656439,
-0.041918043,
-0.0392047502,
0.0076897405,
0.0026478665,
0.0097437333,
-0.0523049496,
-0.0022798791,
-0.0400090367,
0.0300204847,
0.0488522574,
0.0742696747,
0.0203083456,
-0.0354174227,
0.0154773304,
0.0044055888,
-0.0367194451,
-0.0243588835,
0.0439067036,
-0.0321429633,
-0.0031089541,
-0.0039554341,
-0.0211380422,
0.0329304002,
0.058143802,
-0.0399810672,
-0.0289191119,
0.0293763131,
0.0740066841,
0.0154896937,
-0.0589253828,
-0.0154401995,
0.001869578,
0.0132115195,
-0.0167525187,
-0.0403885953,
-0.0004187768,
-0.0043023638,
-0.0136623438,
-0.0235793628,
0.0170297362,
2.183935572e-34,
0.0281137768,
-0.0410069562,
0.0244512353,
-0.0336631685,
0.010489325,
-0.0228332449,
0.0080170473,
0.0066624223,
-0.0520925336,
-0.0266249776,
-0.0067705205
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09390v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09390v2 | LEEETs-Dial: Linguistic Entrainment in End-to-End Task-oriented Dialogue systems | 2023-11-15T21:35:25 | 2024-04-04T11:26:17 | Nalin Kumar, Ondřej Dušek | cs.CL | cs.CL | Linguistic entrainment, or alignment, represents a phenomenon where
linguistic patterns employed by conversational participants converge to one
another. While entrainment has been shown to produce a more natural user
experience, most dialogue systems do not have any provisions for it. In this
work, we introduce methods for achieving dialogue entrainment in a GPT-2-based
end-to-end task-oriented dialogue system through the utilization of shared
vocabulary. We experiment with training instance weighting,
entrainment-specific loss, and additional conditioning to generate responses
that align with the user. We demonstrate that all three approaches produce
significantly better entrainment than the base, non-entrainment-optimized
model, as confirmed by both automated and manual evaluation metrics. | [
0.0363505073,
0.0156491902,
-0.0129681444,
0.0555034578,
-0.0096862651,
0.0043191691,
-0.0183059815,
-0.0000777292,
-0.0174101293,
0.0121761067,
-0.0660431236,
-0.0139432289,
-0.0131968874,
0.0312391184,
0.0015450725,
-0.0584782995,
0.0486322157,
0.0133324517,
-0.0171546806,
-0.0193538181,
0.0552224964,
0.0154855419,
-0.0544495992,
0.0499948412,
-0.0179424956,
-0.0320906267,
-0.0463635512,
0.0359610319,
0.0100329807,
-0.0458739251,
0.0578466989,
0.0395754501,
0.0251845457,
0.0300206188,
0.0000017673,
-0.0350830667,
0.039049305,
-0.0429179929,
-0.0461328886,
-0.0187844057,
0.0106447954,
0.0132002113,
0.0046194308,
0.0310434885,
-0.0357323885,
-0.0017125615,
0.0894409493,
0.0741116703,
0.0902201906,
0.0667278841,
-0.001560881,
-0.0164086893,
0.0134065198,
-0.0140603883,
-0.016542118,
-0.059757784,
-0.0220839251,
0.0045591164,
-0.0032229971,
-0.0089372993,
0.0204538722,
-0.0052021113,
0.0234068539,
0.0138079794,
0.0320326537,
0.0109741986,
-0.0182308741,
-0.0128475353,
-0.0491186753,
0.0877544731,
0.0242457688,
-0.0044864737,
-0.0226955377,
0.0034462512,
0.0129002649,
-0.041881904,
-0.027595954,
-0.052575238,
-0.0137956217,
0.0207319278,
-0.0441088825,
0.0108911777,
-0.0266272277,
-0.0029243948,
-0.0029395353,
0.0330406018,
0.017185688,
-0.0638926029,
-0.0269968249,
0.0285618734,
0.0019930813,
-0.0639433265,
0.0168115906,
0.0040542227,
-0.0753056109,
0.0278292671,
-0.0298345219,
0.0016590417,
0.0147122005,
-0.0174978189,
0.0089160725,
0.043996837,
-0.0107275136,
0.0168659594,
0.0273515675,
0.0655436441,
0.0061677257,
-0.0169890262,
-0.0457570143,
-0.0167395379,
-0.0787510797,
-0.0168771055,
-0.1004049107,
0.0030068518,
-0.0311206169,
-0.0351516455,
-0.0342359245,
0.0458828174,
0.0023314911,
0.00455841,
0.0008847016,
0.0200327374,
-0.0604496226,
-0.0000446609,
-0.051389154,
0.0578612499,
-0.0330012739,
0.0273998398,
0.0180843454,
-0.0425717086,
-0.0384116694,
0.0188735202,
0.0043013818,
-0.0120550152,
-0.0142227551,
0.0505523048,
-0.0325792208,
-0.0316209979,
0.01049437,
0.0164938513,
-0.0256741717,
-0.0624699406,
-0.0397285968,
-0.008764266,
0.0314030573,
-0.0008938879,
-0.0106054908,
-0.0232287403,
-0.0082963854,
0.0296871103,
-0.0090749711,
0.0844869316,
-0.0294169094,
0.0203418341,
0.0502257571,
0.002963806,
-0.0012377955,
0.0807460323,
0.0413194969,
-0.0011944217,
0.0060040946,
-0.0458091162,
0.0064669261,
0.0371783003,
0.0019351998,
0.0114765093,
-0.0021442503,
0.0171516109,
0.0283968542,
0.0274849776,
0.0391931795,
0.0412873365,
-0.0503215343,
0.0177835729,
0.0909885168,
0.0643514246,
0.015337565,
0.0097264992,
-0.0031341666,
0.0354829431,
-0.0295689218,
0.024238091,
-0.0458884723,
0.0225641914,
-0.0111932708,
0.0123205706,
0.0605202578,
0.0171528812,
-0.0372414403,
-0.0366860516,
-0.0046563898,
0.0032166259,
0.0392686501,
-0.0203247648,
0.0287505444,
0.0139748203,
-0.0431355275,
0.0350924209,
0.0141449515,
-0.0694282502,
-0.0094283735,
-0.0047034156,
-0.0087300017,
0.0857587233,
0.0226378236,
0.0058248676,
-0.068276152,
-0.0060924729,
0.000841518,
0.0836071596,
0.0236825086,
-0.0100631751,
0.0250663552,
-0.0801260024,
-0.0351286568,
0.0142142558,
-0.0243913699,
0.0249285195,
-0.0169928316,
0.0239643883,
0.0042908676,
-0.0067090807,
-0.0064138174,
0.0142180659,
0.0155503163,
-0.0088761235,
0.0008814015,
-0.0141260084,
0.0500891469,
0.0060309488,
-0.015835762,
-0.0230005868,
0.0165750608,
0.0136515414,
-0.0088828877,
0.0196811445,
-0.0776128322,
-0.0314894989,
0.0308184493,
0.0003647446,
-0.0005628478,
0.0128823482,
-0.0342548788,
-0.065021269,
0.0026449312,
-0.0497884899,
0.0271311924,
-0.0624052547,
0.0206656028,
0.0303516239,
0.0030393193,
-0.0559708774,
0.0165626146,
0.0292245224,
0.0084256865,
-0.0102952234,
-0.0172315966,
0.0449311361,
-0.0878876224,
0.0098692104,
0.0431572087,
0.0092317685,
0.0166423731,
0.0353669785,
0.0090345806,
-0.055128362,
-0.0309388451,
-0.1430079639,
0.0185937807,
-0.0232008807,
0.037782304,
0.035867691,
0.0333058871,
-0.036481794,
-0.0715690702,
-0.0825547725,
0.0133373141,
0.058508452,
0.0193978623,
0.0492571518,
-0.0029941755,
-0.0206872355,
-0.0272758864,
0.033130534,
0.0192750916,
-0.025779428,
-0.0248658862,
0.0028278294,
-0.096731469,
-0.0072479472,
-0.0332130939,
0.0387395807,
0.0054945368,
-0.0564341582,
0.0467969887,
0.0405339822,
0.0461543165,
0.0517481677,
0.0629601851,
0.0070328452,
-0.0218163468,
-0.018252505,
-0.07103917,
0.0597946569,
-0.0222692937,
-0.0513764955,
-0.0382401608,
0.0043917065,
0.0276293848,
0.0572666824,
0.0102663208,
0.0385806225,
-0.0777442902,
0.018264059,
0.0196763594,
-0.0301759839,
-0.0141669065,
-0.0110249147,
-0.0521296859,
0.0013310218,
-0.0339883119,
-0.0564333089,
0.0545996949,
-0.02826632,
-0.056285426,
-0.0971320868,
-0.0169493165,
0.0145017598,
0.0166713689,
-0.0010401136,
0.0147069013,
0.0557583459,
-0.0454597548,
-0.0574886017,
0.0071994574,
0.0376553349,
-0.0269598253,
0.0376826413,
-0.0270303916,
0.0086233309,
-0.0239959992,
-0.0779416412,
-0.0582957789,
0.006752661,
-0.0035770801,
0.005224823,
-0.0185227785,
-0.0117668333,
-0.0101500927,
0.0156033849,
0.0096085016,
0.0373224691,
-0.0156902205,
0.001533182,
-0.0158065204,
0.0207853727,
0.0659371167,
0.0538264178,
-0.0391035788,
-0.0128240427,
0.051539164,
0.0392647572,
0.05402923,
-0.0152429659,
-0.01406762,
-0.0159964599,
0.0379676297,
-0.0369530432,
-0.0070727151,
0.0138002606,
0.0774502307,
-0.019419346,
0.005574252,
0.1109426245,
0.0016940951,
-0.0549037866,
-0.0162737314,
-0.0149246706,
0.0461078212,
0.027394196,
0.0096830968,
-0.0839638785,
-0.0398052894,
0.0088318773,
0.0154740708,
0.0249089058,
0.0014056773,
-0.0153292883,
-0.0917858183,
-0.0017795411,
-0.0003580386,
-0.0424518697,
-0.0027995997,
0.0038147613,
0.0309491232,
-0.0057854783,
0.0636500269,
-0.0048337756,
0.0094314702,
0.0054250793,
0.0308717266,
-0.0058102147,
-0.0080474792,
-0.0010662338,
-0.023937827,
0.0731173083,
0.079717651,
0.0419761091,
0.0221888423,
-0.0230236389,
0.0217056815,
-0.0311223436,
0.0071615721,
0.0107361274,
0.0448967367,
-0.0201585852,
-0.0143925548,
-0.015689753,
0.0319294892,
-0.0169197079,
0.0192331448,
0.0627272278,
0.0085393758,
-0.0273312237,
0.0546946228,
0.0022337635,
-0.0016040192,
0.0677369162,
0.0529313125,
0.0060772621,
-0.0535577089,
-0.0221830644,
-0.0163911581,
0.0128874397,
-0.0235802624,
0.0113630779,
-0.0121997949,
-0.019331472,
0.0248627886,
-0.0734586865,
-0.0745861381,
-0.0127715142,
0.0355596133,
-0.006624063,
-0.0027463567,
-0.0178761426,
0.024659384,
0.0016841869,
0.0337494239,
-0.0179038048,
0.0050748126,
-0.0887307376,
-0.0233602785,
0.0107845953,
-0.0351256281,
0.0099484269,
0.0294272732,
-0.0370293185,
-0.0685894564,
-0.0486487821,
0.0257158149,
0.0237183459,
0.0629524514,
0.0003348457,
-0.0009098334,
-0.0026484428,
-0.0125780683,
-0.0683161989,
-0.0206263326,
0.0381130911,
0.0348727666,
-0.0148972757,
0.0259387325,
-0.0116517739,
0.0255271737,
-0.0041740588,
0.0353616141,
-0.0460837707,
-0.0916051418,
0.0206505544,
0.0000536797,
0.0721892193,
0.0040587932,
-0.0113631161,
-0.0143736107,
0.0527393483,
-0.0045149671,
-0.0106814904,
-0.047276441,
-0.0085985959,
-0.0074683758,
-0.008326577,
0.0230350271,
0.0014649006,
-0.0324723497,
0.0182750951,
-0.0369375385,
-0.0254416969,
-0.0090821581,
0.005997913,
0.0077728881,
0.012423615,
-0.0142158763,
-0.006145719,
0.0408384129,
0.0428579338,
-0.0113271745,
0.12076547,
0.0367930047,
-0.009943882,
0.0293578468,
0.0791575089,
-0.0192611814,
-0.0068112882,
-0.0191767942,
-0.0088933557,
0.0292518213,
0.0088291513,
0.0551336408,
-0.0095923739,
0.0268921815,
-0.0215049535,
0.039575398,
-0.0229402985,
0.0153467171,
0.0096538803,
0.0177652705,
-0.0363160595,
-0.0191466212,
0.0551322065,
-0.0099371225,
0.0029820851,
-0.0299490672,
0.0119196484,
-0.0372579806,
-0.0305523146,
0.0176792927,
0.0382758826,
-0.0050023845,
0.0064142114,
0.0009726979,
-0.0305951908,
-0.0163312815,
0.013916987,
-0.0091233747,
-0.0424841344,
0.0777491927,
0.0461730286,
-0.0496248044,
-0.0278716963,
0.0204575323,
-0.0444688164,
-0.018823009,
-0.0150622819,
-0.0524612181,
-5.429647345e-33,
-0.0421799198,
-0.0060371957,
0.0407298245,
0.0305998791,
-0.0605471395,
-0.0258244649,
-0.0199137181,
0.0087953126,
-0.0239704326,
-0.0000438069,
-0.0119387209,
0.0000193397,
0.0142144021,
0.0245047156,
0.0046092388,
-0.0136273969,
0.0531805009,
0.0060208775,
-0.0459988974,
0.0367508121,
0.0463342182,
0.0016944127,
0.0686040297,
-0.0579156652,
0.0069385413,
0.0094319927,
-0.0022006005,
0.0229587853,
0.0073027071,
0.0398115404,
-0.0192263275,
0.0688281059,
0.0177084301,
-0.0753608644,
-0.006353626,
0.0192490648,
-0.0306363218,
-0.0548191555,
0.0054468913,
0.0068854089,
-0.0176128,
0.0033754695,
0.02533013,
-0.0278219469,
-0.0286747403,
0.0119480956,
0.028405901,
-0.0015481721,
-0.0050376575,
0.0442855582,
-0.0623436794,
-0.0117315697,
-0.0194306299,
-0.0850116611,
-0.0160816032,
0.0172249619,
0.0227738209,
-0.075767383,
-0.0291783791,
0.0043432266,
-0.011455873,
-0.0036031662,
0.054418046,
0.0555833094,
0.0061971089,
0.0349244513,
0.0275791977,
0.0084242234,
-0.0212459546,
-0.0238352343,
-0.0023150425,
-0.0073936954,
0.0369813852,
0.0106606474,
0.0075002951,
-0.0140662296,
-0.0320839807,
0.0347670764,
0.0378019661,
0.0701314881,
-0.0075383773,
0.0466224924,
-0.0368843414,
-0.0252888054,
-0.023066178,
0.0253950432,
-0.0168123096,
-0.067062147,
0.052249644,
0.0216848757,
0.031635832,
-0.0223226883,
0.0414791964,
0.0164942183,
-0.0031992514,
0.0306408685,
-0.0052400911,
-0.0079932474,
-0.0138563551,
-0.0159339178,
-0.0606192276,
-0.0097160945,
0.0204230826,
0.0582823157,
0.0072960742,
0.0019786402,
0.0027296885,
-0.0101834703,
-0.0554117151,
0.0203637853,
-0.0301293265,
0.0497729182,
-0.0459186845,
0.0385099538,
0.0334002115,
0.0024001084,
-0.0171262305,
0.0840456635,
-0.0156457257,
-0.0685915276,
-0.0814243481,
-0.0661189482,
0.0295267403,
0.0167969558,
-0.0279701352,
0.022826137,
-0.0132128634,
-0.0233158953,
-0.0032169011,
0.0151831172,
-0.0022920168,
0.0043635825,
2.505e-7,
-0.0186247341,
0.00924192,
0.0512942784,
0.0102607999,
0.0202497821,
0.0475842729,
0.0014732393,
0.052634228,
0.0148610668,
-0.0272219088,
0.0138303172,
0.0200117938,
0.0586639754,
-0.0006172291,
-0.1073016822,
-0.0315851346,
-0.0569883138,
0.0313256942,
-0.034790799,
0.0458324775,
0.0680713356,
0.0274665989,
0.0107388031,
0.0179564916,
0.0070396164,
-0.0341701731,
0.021680776,
-0.0239064228,
0.0055519156,
0.0256853215,
0.0289706811,
-0.0050474857,
-0.0171103626,
0.0534284674,
0.0059071155,
0.0435895771,
0.0072432975,
0.0336232632,
-0.0563630611,
-0.0420733877,
-0.039106641,
0.0143911922,
-0.0091893906,
-0.0445088595,
0.035304293,
-0.0330824926,
-0.0277482364,
0.0001003217,
-0.0259144381,
-0.037438672,
0.0134415645,
-0.0004873635,
-0.0537039377,
0.0049197674,
0.0133189112,
0.0199113376,
-0.0068518254,
-0.0809044093,
0.0235287026,
0.0203294735,
-0.0555533469,
-0.0637717023,
-0.0522758588,
-0.002390899,
0.0050486927,
-0.0018725328,
-0.007492281,
1.535881863e-34,
-0.0183789283,
-0.0216185935,
0.0690934435,
0.0511756353,
0.0265030824,
-0.0077119176,
0.0229388569,
0.0130312797,
0.0474193804,
-0.0732179135,
0.0005667242
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09389v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09389v1 | Neural machine translation for automated feedback on children's early-stage writing | 2023-11-15T21:32:44 | 2023-11-15T21:32:44 | Jonas Vestergaard Jensen, Mikkel Jordahn, Michael Riis Andersen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, I.2.7 | In this work, we address the problem of assessing and constructing feedback
for early-stage writing automatically using machine learning. Early-stage
writing is typically vastly different from conventional writing due to phonetic
spelling and lack of proper grammar, punctuation, spacing etc. Consequently,
early-stage writing is highly non-trivial to analyze using common linguistic
metrics. We propose to use sequence-to-sequence models for "translating"
early-stage writing by students into "conventional" writing, which allows the
translated text to be analyzed using linguistic metrics. Furthermore, we
propose a novel robust likelihood to mitigate the effect of noise in the
dataset. We investigate the proposed methods using a set of numerical
experiments and demonstrate that the conventional text can be predicted with
high accuracy. | [
0.0122045381,
0.0390476137,
-0.0058771349,
0.0052580996,
-0.0544640683,
-0.0021706449,
0.0230787452,
-0.0386019796,
-0.0112364031,
-0.0398773775,
-0.0041608517,
-0.0821765512,
0.0905829817,
-0.0000118862,
0.0377828479,
-0.0699075013,
0.006158019,
-0.040136721,
-0.0018060831,
0.0095609762,
-0.00014384,
0.0075176898,
-0.0111581143,
0.0616485924,
-0.0249622557,
-0.0270496011,
0.0100641623,
0.033729393,
0.0090437932,
-0.0109069319,
0.0310856402,
0.0793886408,
-0.0138515653,
0.066783011,
0.0000017464,
-0.0124291135,
0.0003922654,
-0.0261610299,
0.0187740885,
0.0192840826,
0.0532215089,
-0.0236071758,
-0.0465188734,
0.0445767343,
0.0072516305,
-0.0043130023,
0.0772570819,
-0.0034651218,
0.034151759,
0.0605368763,
-0.0078419931,
-0.0178645756,
0.0555199422,
-0.0043365522,
0.0219925139,
0.027618425,
0.0032761542,
-0.0358876549,
0.0027710712,
-0.0145952981,
-0.0095996,
0.0534242466,
0.0155674862,
-0.0801182613,
-0.0039252494,
-0.0054946607,
0.0316989608,
-0.0118048396,
-0.0164593272,
0.0443702117,
-0.0198458713,
-0.0345939547,
-0.0139436265,
-0.0259802546,
-0.0109738363,
0.0058337259,
-0.0308786742,
0.0095551759,
-0.0111610005,
-0.0017028532,
0.0200315174,
-0.0027123003,
0.0015172794,
0.0077137016,
0.0120446337,
-0.0181764457,
0.0085247494,
-0.0374278836,
-0.0308049675,
0.0594094507,
0.0361584388,
-0.047280591,
0.0338090137,
0.0238600764,
0.0071149734,
0.0006793627,
-0.0833166838,
-0.0747191012,
-0.0206062384,
-0.0689380765,
0.0803498775,
0.0075659743,
-0.0042365603,
-0.0158105064,
-0.015796043,
0.0356891677,
0.0280018728,
0.0256504733,
-0.0408147238,
0.0121223526,
-0.0071419114,
0.0074457177,
-0.0077061984,
0.0151162464,
-0.0064515597,
0.010980743,
-0.0556914583,
-0.0206014309,
0.0091134999,
0.0013119578,
0.0406212173,
0.0069194208,
-0.0436654314,
0.0007617078,
-0.0002125436,
0.0313842073,
-0.0149639882,
-0.0059605949,
0.0176210888,
0.0098148035,
0.0027845397,
0.0462866873,
0.0197931174,
-0.011665293,
-0.0027360427,
0.0397281311,
-0.0067982888,
-0.0325178839,
-0.0271180049,
0.001783721,
-0.0140143195,
-0.0568425953,
-0.0203960873,
-0.0799577683,
-0.0112139983,
-0.0294810403,
0.0197428279,
-0.0578752384,
-0.0214724671,
0.0024338714,
0.0139240529,
0.0124073848,
0.0040615797,
0.0013449211,
0.0201236364,
-0.0239146743,
0.049675297,
0.0165949073,
0.0751900375,
-0.0063248868,
0.0259052888,
-0.0095331268,
-0.0116204936,
0.062907204,
-0.0100721829,
-0.0010965441,
-0.0369725451,
-0.0475862883,
-0.0276553165,
0.0460729823,
-0.0240442958,
0.0474553257,
0.0206653569,
0.040401984,
0.1140204445,
0.0483648665,
0.0241245944,
0.02055078,
0.0344227403,
0.0228679646,
0.0224419404,
0.0247818939,
-0.0251046922,
0.0445852578,
-0.0188010167,
0.0109026572,
0.0259684976,
0.0368431993,
-0.0068608345,
-0.0758524835,
-0.0174332336,
0.0103145335,
-0.0199010223,
-0.0096840756,
0.0256418865,
0.0296496861,
-0.0559692606,
-0.0253611859,
-0.0245331619,
-0.0447719023,
0.0652113631,
-0.0254899524,
0.0162797179,
0.0642227083,
0.0387301669,
-0.0222335607,
-0.0174419098,
-0.0201366823,
-0.024865739,
0.0399876311,
-0.021285966,
0.0069273012,
0.0207022093,
-0.025917843,
-0.0036700524,
0.0556035303,
0.0397420339,
-0.0166248381,
-0.0070981062,
0.0261741523,
0.0082196267,
0.0189462956,
-0.1156793162,
0.0508944504,
-0.0201353133,
-0.0406720154,
0.0381440297,
0.0241163131,
-0.0198121481,
0.0545282066,
-0.0121026337,
0.0062928004,
0.0182640944,
-0.0145046664,
-0.005638523,
0.0210385323,
-0.0542350411,
-0.043332912,
0.0246860739,
-0.0493826717,
-0.0066409898,
0.0232929736,
-0.0001536081,
-0.050738398,
0.0021370118,
-0.0311831944,
-0.0113859642,
-0.0213284288,
0.0550928414,
-0.0496515743,
-0.0444532484,
-0.0491009355,
-0.0013151543,
0.0071484074,
0.0244528838,
-0.0201440528,
0.0082160514,
-0.000205037,
0.0189227555,
-0.0680883452,
0.009014396,
0.0101954127,
0.0615486391,
0.0248019062,
0.0267662331,
-0.0176793151,
-0.0533286184,
-0.0408814959,
-0.0006040494,
-0.0127964737,
-0.0055923793,
0.0658860654,
0.0046730321,
0.0329232588,
0.0031685843,
-0.0587619878,
0.0191947185,
0.0172069259,
-0.0310604665,
0.0619381741,
-0.0287768878,
0.0061084782,
-0.0642370656,
-0.0347273722,
-0.0299118795,
0.0185896754,
0.0644904003,
-0.0515889935,
-0.0531947017,
0.0166393649,
-0.0005681175,
0.0037145659,
0.0336909816,
-0.0644594505,
0.0299111716,
-0.028778905,
0.0400428101,
0.0770566538,
-0.0100406716,
0.0098085282,
0.0375756845,
-0.0088523617,
-0.0036570344,
-0.0253324248,
-0.0330065303,
0.0309516862,
-0.0107416417,
-0.0557941943,
-0.0066404631,
0.0516232327,
0.0427208096,
-0.0356091931,
-0.0420630015,
0.0345621966,
-0.0225740634,
0.033107195,
-0.0390270688,
-0.0068123429,
-0.0207931101,
0.0627958328,
-0.0144813536,
-0.0276500247,
0.052037742,
-0.0448107906,
-0.007541996,
-0.0453807451,
-0.0058928807,
-0.0060598855,
0.0200463999,
-0.0086682495,
0.007021179,
-0.0102635901,
-0.0238621067,
-0.0640744865,
0.0157395806,
0.0600418858,
-0.0184077267,
0.0558122583,
-0.0585202351,
-0.0124895638,
0.0064263726,
0.0065935631,
-0.0271539409,
-0.0053289635,
0.0314034037,
-0.0123057151,
-0.0268095285,
-0.0583946779,
-0.0284529552,
-0.0003838704,
-0.0005320921,
0.1064672172,
-0.0632746816,
-0.0069473432,
-0.0194354672,
0.0231288821,
0.0172033031,
-0.0393814668,
-0.0385034978,
-0.0764518678,
0.0351034366,
0.0143882316,
-0.0364330634,
0.0587295555,
-0.0155700454,
-0.0252493732,
0.0252368078,
0.025832057,
0.0184486937,
0.0344269015,
0.0365780219,
-0.0642812327,
-0.036363259,
0.0699064806,
0.0001917698,
-0.051776696,
-0.0314536691,
0.0241180137,
0.0492328778,
-0.0162776709,
0.020883549,
-0.0049424809,
0.0162715949,
0.0024541945,
0.0660890937,
0.0136701623,
-0.0278630648,
-0.0187303461,
-0.0616194271,
0.0091208844,
0.0326141156,
-0.0572274812,
-0.0517941639,
0.017826302,
-0.0276133418,
0.0291178729,
0.0380270369,
-0.0128444806,
-0.002757133,
-0.002802911,
0.0047282982,
-0.0077065174,
-0.0714966282,
-0.0421825424,
-0.0333877802,
0.0450821668,
0.0426326506,
0.0301085394,
-0.024480883,
0.0147968419,
0.0002583335,
0.0071439338,
-0.0446366891,
0.0091036092,
0.0284244567,
0.0157565549,
-0.0016316239,
-0.0524818413,
0.0267763864,
-0.0269606952,
0.0500326082,
0.0106441816,
0.0478646047,
-0.0015234024,
-0.0030494703,
0.0040426576,
0.0578765981,
0.0529071167,
0.0414961465,
0.0517468043,
-0.09597826,
-0.000695004,
-0.0537304841,
0.0117850406,
-0.0695860684,
-0.0316617861,
0.0279334504,
-0.0187732,
-0.0306975674,
-0.1327043474,
-0.0450973734,
0.0301745422,
0.0428983532,
0.0564965382,
0.0398771614,
0.0348754227,
-0.0408333242,
-0.0147875017,
0.0155462632,
0.0402613096,
0.0140598882,
-0.0929646641,
-0.006425458,
-0.0229432322,
-0.0326458737,
0.0153680015,
0.023161117,
-0.1314250082,
-0.0552457348,
-0.01765709,
0.044265829,
0.0241864696,
0.0300073475,
-0.0137287853,
-0.0617733784,
0.0332616903,
-0.0035966313,
0.0492388457,
-0.0073613552,
0.0237719528,
-0.0056941425,
-0.0278359838,
0.0234416574,
0.0198188238,
-0.0102851549,
0.0036464955,
0.0180565361,
0.0035804992,
-0.0713690966,
-0.0057652197,
-0.0019969079,
0.0590061657,
-0.0375108905,
-0.0652467385,
-0.0870373026,
0.0022075465,
-0.0094907787,
0.016553238,
-0.0377726443,
-0.010890509,
0.0451060385,
0.0084052812,
-0.0292166919,
-0.008712355,
-0.0157365687,
0.0266522076,
-0.0446504354,
0.0606461056,
-0.0300804321,
0.0800925717,
0.019820042,
0.0516349673,
-0.0065770946,
0.0306582786,
-0.0083900988,
0.0320767947,
0.0138831623,
-0.0084413951,
0.0162319634,
0.042103745,
0.0466805883,
0.0365863815,
-0.0203872342,
0.0089502996,
-0.0650750473,
-0.0076005748,
0.0619261451,
-0.0004591392,
0.1043596044,
0.0029796665,
0.0167257749,
-0.034337379,
0.0627684817,
0.0146963904,
0.005482858,
-0.0186934397,
-0.0392435491,
0.0540126823,
-0.0202914588,
0.044425182,
-0.0207017735,
-0.0287122801,
0.0125665106,
0.0115186069,
-0.0163214244,
-0.0168602969,
0.0229486432,
0.0052577429,
-0.007873239,
0.002833199,
-0.0029290656,
-0.0486731716,
0.0141806714,
0.0445052795,
-0.0130195552,
-0.0235339273,
-0.0044927956,
0.0150268599,
-0.0467532203,
0.0285244901,
-0.0585825481,
0.0088474154,
0.0318837091,
-0.0595031381,
-0.0329850055,
-5.5033288e-33,
-0.0231544953,
-0.0572843999,
-0.0479515716,
0.0456420816,
-0.0010483218,
-0.0115768919,
-0.0431633368,
0.012552877,
0.0109513998,
-0.001855429,
-0.0051027676,
0.0017611957,
0.0076129129,
0.0441292636,
0.0278354399,
0.0402539745,
0.0552228354,
-0.0381960012,
-0.0270829983,
-0.0051892116,
0.0202294849,
0.0148038846,
0.1058823764,
-0.0130047435,
0.0772665441,
-0.0446509495,
-0.0244321097,
0.0090284087,
-0.0159844905,
0.0104787098,
0.0208728425,
0.0446142443,
0.0150782773,
0.0102817947,
-0.0117477234,
0.0224235617,
-0.0792909712,
-0.0306704696,
-0.0052510453,
0.0179874618,
-0.0392952524,
-0.0297196712,
0.0286737066,
-0.0174197536,
-0.0063377991,
-0.025135871,
0.0637355596,
-0.001050157,
-0.0057077138,
-0.0183833018,
-0.0820615292,
0.0020944704,
-0.0083625792,
-0.0258853547,
0.0333921723,
0.0781419352,
-0.001419851,
-0.0429856777,
-0.087622121,
0.0364686176,
0.034534134,
0.0744732395,
0.0126170339,
0.0266293567,
-0.0300184973,
0.0163896214,
0.0231355708,
0.0208408684,
0.0139233181,
0.0451231934,
0.0885079354,
-0.0435133651,
0.0898432583,
0.0359321386,
0.0165466368,
0.0130747091,
-0.0476720892,
0.0522848368,
0.0103012966,
-0.0183621924,
0.0379815884,
-0.0368782803,
-0.020658331,
-0.0361665748,
-0.0279047806,
-0.0767243132,
-0.0041713724,
0.0125356391,
-0.0050758123,
-0.0080892844,
-0.0295865759,
-0.0527910814,
0.0096543133,
0.001154429,
-0.0070997258,
-0.0058986237,
0.000700488,
0.0390446745,
-0.0343760215,
0.0238584206,
0.0001623308,
-0.0233215094,
-0.0003712194,
0.0375567488,
0.0149710309,
0.0191996191,
0.0482209474,
0.0315400772,
-0.0485175811,
0.0220071636,
-0.0328735784,
0.0655644313,
0.0275556538,
0.0368341506,
0.0122250291,
-0.0555929467,
0.0085580414,
0.0723728836,
0.0105568524,
0.0124647692,
-0.0095559806,
-0.002905204,
0.0248306897,
-0.0078091444,
-0.0642133579,
-0.0200992338,
-0.0267785881,
0.0138779385,
0.043199379,
-0.0292096976,
0.0261892732,
-0.0337565839,
2.367e-7,
0.038038373,
0.0510157607,
0.0338104069,
0.0279316846,
0.0236428231,
0.0096080583,
-0.0436616242,
0.0101435389,
0.0157219023,
0.0508830585,
0.0018273124,
-0.0430124626,
0.0925554559,
-0.003502307,
-0.0966838896,
-0.0382063203,
-0.0754965991,
0.0656884909,
-0.0201079436,
-0.0066117975,
0.0514647178,
0.0286417082,
-0.0005493885,
-0.0394796655,
0.0062238211,
-0.0194837358,
0.0190452561,
-0.020374408,
0.0083363224,
-0.0141842319,
0.0543433912,
-0.0199452136,
0.0052161058,
0.0111861648,
-0.0448125154,
-0.0038414632,
0.0068658586,
0.0361636877,
-0.0042238035,
-0.0118646482,
0.0138011687,
0.0190802272,
-0.0201191325,
-0.0650943816,
0.0144630661,
-0.0256563462,
0.0154754613,
0.0268713944,
0.0351030529,
0.0012033621,
0.0149381598,
-0.03859552,
-0.0169993006,
0.0153582627,
0.0453969911,
-0.0263538044,
0.0439953022,
-0.0166157447,
-0.0257221963,
-0.0091575515,
0.0106648235,
-0.0019219068,
-0.0197633486,
-0.0202313326,
-0.0525176227,
-0.0315521248,
0.0320334174,
1.902883597e-34,
0.0311453529,
-0.0461006798,
0.0387601145,
-0.0439788885,
-0.0004812024,
0.0053433254,
0.0194173753,
-0.0047097234,
0.0171518698,
-0.0602387525,
-0.0378128588
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09387v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09387v2 | Banach-Tarski Embeddings and Transformers | 2023-11-15T21:30:26 | 2023-11-21T18:31:57 | Joshua Maher | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.DS | We introduce a new construction of embeddings of arbitrary recursive data
structures into high dimensional vectors. These embeddings provide an
interpretable model for the latent state vectors of transformers. We
demonstrate that these embeddings can be decoded to the original data structure
when the embedding dimension is sufficiently large. This decoding algorithm has
a natural implementation as a transformer. We also show that these embedding
vectors can be manipulated directly to perform computations on the underlying
data without decoding. As an example we present an algorithm that constructs
the embedded parse tree of an embedded token sequence using only vector
operations in embedding space. | [
-0.0122182984,
0.0305466,
-0.0172604267,
0.0405001901,
-0.035290733,
0.0083556212,
-0.0374625847,
-0.0032089327,
-0.0527669229,
-0.0300815776,
0.0457849838,
-0.0091693997,
-0.0004107679,
0.0313348249,
0.0142537914,
-0.0542853512,
0.0424428135,
0.0084055914,
-0.0318839587,
-0.0043799756,
-0.0500381961,
-0.0303187482,
0.0098946784,
0.0390299447,
0.0151968403,
-0.0174469873,
-0.035535343,
-0.0229871683,
-0.0014661548,
-0.0210435912,
-0.0502153896,
-0.0176584553,
0.0407531261,
0.0295237675,
0.0000017759,
0.0300488621,
-0.0247447733,
0.0019629169,
-0.0471218675,
-0.0064866915,
-0.0207619593,
-0.0675251111,
-0.019482879,
-0.016730031,
-0.0062993686,
-0.0981842056,
0.0661208928,
0.041046191,
0.0562200323,
0.0537195392,
-0.0127112735,
-0.1006011218,
0.0402109735,
0.0249543712,
-0.0153579339,
0.0176593345,
0.0297037996,
-0.0099359127,
-0.018973846,
0.0319051854,
-0.0769060999,
-0.0419808663,
0.0169120785,
-0.0157593191,
0.0321610756,
0.0234899744,
0.0147942174,
0.0075985389,
-0.0178143177,
0.0192070808,
-0.0175908618,
-0.0469427407,
0.0037857166,
0.0359665491,
-0.005473095,
0.0021933196,
-0.0200101845,
0.0179495364,
0.0223367997,
0.0352676846,
0.0222369116,
-0.0120824166,
0.0461999699,
-0.0748758614,
-0.0611847118,
0.0635399669,
0.0378278643,
-0.0338639542,
-0.0754838362,
-0.0284741428,
0.0441871472,
-0.002878949,
0.0282537509,
0.0137148779,
0.0182996672,
0.0233710185,
0.0010959648,
-0.0542849936,
-0.0436604917,
-0.0236013457,
0.0314985625,
0.0618013181,
-0.0059214225,
0.0193065405,
-0.0238011312,
0.0317225046,
-0.0855660737,
0.0539839156,
-0.0336259492,
0.001956922,
-0.0307868309,
-0.0338552631,
-0.0507153794,
0.0491957478,
-0.0082237152,
-0.0109839747,
-0.0302241035,
0.081158109,
0.0229540914,
0.0195062123,
-0.037592873,
-0.0140872346,
0.002929355,
0.0693934336,
0.0211780798,
0.0095631797,
-0.0227310471,
-0.0690360814,
-0.0505143404,
0.006280663,
-0.0453065075,
0.0287653226,
0.0175155047,
-0.0278766956,
-0.0443652347,
0.0566243753,
0.0328906998,
-0.0490838252,
0.0268710591,
-0.0044946386,
-0.0000491683,
0.0078451075,
0.0867622122,
-0.02411782,
0.0305439625,
0.0119979978,
0.0052027674,
-0.0072697322,
-0.0224340297,
0.0044335034,
-0.0214158949,
0.0635033175,
0.0169077553,
-0.0398822799,
-0.0551293045,
0.001549787,
0.0207085088,
-0.0005784241,
0.0154475141,
0.0169449653,
0.0156427845,
-0.0605162978,
0.0093347626,
-0.013919617,
-0.0011166519,
-0.0339776911,
-0.0236124024,
-0.001407286,
-0.0284830388,
0.0073726829,
-0.015294075,
0.0347623043,
-0.0357482322,
0.0015156656,
-0.0057354914,
0.07033097,
0.0458642691,
0.0706320927,
0.062616244,
0.0132644158,
-0.0098338937,
0.0476599522,
-0.002334188,
0.0114543103,
0.0197023246,
-0.0057182196,
-0.0243501142,
0.0262546241,
-0.0073228222,
-0.0153190885,
0.0035477132,
-0.0221442338,
0.0285772812,
-0.0842159018,
0.0486382432,
0.0329723097,
-0.0417332724,
0.0853705928,
-0.023379229,
-0.0479811355,
0.0156642869,
-0.0303536803,
0.0233248398,
0.0155058466,
0.0510958396,
-0.0427259617,
0.0301227234,
-0.005788458,
-0.0117729409,
-0.0006526806,
-0.039087154,
-0.0069412333,
-0.0236384179,
-0.01819559,
-0.0262241717,
0.0373020545,
0.0171602182,
0.016547583,
-0.0496303178,
-0.0186721738,
0.0237044767,
-0.056547083,
0.0703712404,
0.0046426379,
0.013010175,
-0.0192145016,
0.030630827,
0.0331809931,
0.0435682051,
0.0583936796,
0.0017017174,
0.056356132,
0.0955896154,
-0.0279310327,
-0.0475808382,
0.0357606411,
-0.0649709627,
-0.0277399682,
0.0191470962,
-0.0840132758,
-0.0002687905,
0.0459703617,
-0.0338053294,
-0.045000568,
0.0529770218,
-0.0933635235,
0.0882424563,
-0.0298842508,
-0.008565831,
-0.0070629674,
0.012980531,
0.0029747209,
0.0729945228,
-0.020316232,
0.0340533927,
0.0043869568,
-0.0241286792,
-0.0095301867,
0.0376591124,
-0.0571093149,
0.0288243797,
-0.0202677697,
-0.0096164569,
0.0119574163,
-0.041327741,
0.0150292264,
-0.0282037575,
-0.016858913,
-0.0368860252,
-0.0228112489,
0.0658178851,
0.0225271657,
0.0290223155,
0.0782586485,
0.0093761133,
-0.0355032384,
-0.0114916395,
-0.0168649219,
0.0209443588,
0.0524048209,
-0.0327460691,
-0.0818018541,
0.0273671038,
-0.0478224941,
-0.0522240661,
0.0613595061,
-0.0547956266,
0.0095443791,
-0.0727635548,
-0.056169793,
0.0099862153,
0.0061747967,
-0.0433954261,
-0.0300225746,
0.0377772748,
-0.0080258893,
0.0304587856,
0.032130599,
-0.0116137536,
0.0882240385,
-0.005380508,
0.0021396314,
0.0241185501,
-0.0185399596,
-0.0499541797,
0.030455336,
-0.0510843843,
0.0125278411,
0.0193111729,
0.0944653153,
-0.0102490382,
0.0065228282,
-0.0698340014,
-0.0241989288,
0.0150013873,
0.0128720785,
-0.0004407933,
-0.0676820725,
-0.0465958714,
0.0083351787,
0.0017372742,
-0.0135272807,
0.0633237511,
-0.032737229,
-0.0185158737,
0.0089985402,
-0.0042750565,
-0.0551707484,
0.0583122782,
0.0524638519,
0.0180357192,
-0.0605647191,
-0.0393782221,
0.0063891285,
0.0316948518,
-0.0023071368,
-0.0232788101,
0.0353816375,
0.0269271526,
-0.0056355754,
0.0084668174,
-0.0314630084,
-0.0462447517,
0.0012561029,
0.0367394611,
-0.0010119772,
0.0604264438,
-0.0258492883,
-0.0275784321,
0.0218709484,
0.0286326315,
-0.0018906547,
0.048875194,
-0.0118637932,
-0.0473408066,
0.0333171859,
-0.0315213539,
0.009694133,
0.024723703,
0.0222665537,
0.0025104971,
0.0540176034,
0.0294432901,
-0.0062362649,
-0.0418142416,
0.0060677729,
0.0216986295,
-0.0131469471,
-0.015762385,
0.0136962244,
-0.0240488257,
0.0134358192,
-0.0526664108,
0.0392872617,
0.0199983735,
-0.03975299,
0.0668314993,
-0.0200282391,
-0.0089761419,
0.0174623448,
0.0091716927,
-0.1110633612,
0.0117848516,
0.0110084685,
-0.010095071,
-0.0166008826,
-0.0278279595,
0.026265813,
-0.0909664035,
0.0154004376,
0.0147207063,
0.0060897619,
-0.0763964579,
-0.0378811881,
-0.024415765,
0.0300596021,
-0.0082375472,
0.0297280923,
-0.0032098852,
0.01041089,
0.0133874314,
-0.0165146757,
-0.0148860021,
-0.0087361541,
0.0303034745,
-0.0091966055,
0.0492073521,
0.0755675882,
-0.0023780339,
-0.0453083031,
-0.0471681878,
-0.0266200583,
-0.0127177937,
0.0047378223,
-0.0332857631,
0.0205938835,
-0.0163880922,
-0.0225480571,
0.0288138874,
-0.0357332379,
-0.0046332437,
-0.0331127346,
0.1279028505,
-0.0277076401,
-0.009247601,
-0.0038640066,
-0.0560514368,
-0.0039643301,
0.0230474249,
0.0277543608,
0.0090194,
-0.0319913365,
-0.0302141272,
0.0227473062,
0.0098003792,
-0.0469784327,
0.0000652728,
0.02345079,
-0.0308351554,
-0.0606658906,
0.0316473804,
0.0079704057,
0.0236844178,
0.0078776143,
-0.0098068258,
0.0387754515,
-0.0568591915,
-0.057904426,
-0.0281017907,
-0.0361453928,
0.0312055126,
-0.0189225469,
0.0266180485,
0.0109372791,
0.0442881323,
-0.0773438811,
-0.0369176045,
-0.0265473854,
-0.0446283296,
0.0630189553,
0.0586958192,
0.0172456931,
-0.0407271273,
0.0015747948,
0.0267122686,
0.0652984381,
0.0019479861,
-0.0541806109,
-0.0112838289,
0.0462412126,
-0.0265364815,
0.0208835453,
0.0282073244,
-0.0174703542,
-0.0017154326,
-0.0106139798,
0.006362048,
-0.0010562922,
0.019241333,
0.0242228191,
0.004042089,
0.0488259867,
0.0472660773,
-0.000051307,
0.0609497465,
0.0491356477,
-0.0809434652,
0.0023387647,
-0.0511650704,
0.020289246,
-0.0182285085,
-0.0038914597,
-0.0165728107,
0.000263562,
0.0249306392,
0.0141667817,
0.0061824229,
0.0714052841,
0.0099197812,
-0.0166388806,
0.0232987609,
0.0061550182,
0.0011959935,
-0.0145279774,
0.0134364292,
0.0174378362,
-0.0317940749,
-0.0278371535,
0.035965465,
0.0495956615,
-0.0363617502,
0.0241470877,
-0.0602917559,
0.0192102995,
0.0392034836,
-0.027226571,
0.0130042313,
0.0022786176,
0.0371446609,
-0.0464426316,
0.0307930876,
0.0070087002,
0.0225297771,
-0.0180023722,
-0.0618922301,
0.0390653759,
0.0238304343,
-0.0157649238,
-0.0064949077,
0.0319467559,
-0.0107692061,
0.0291833226,
-0.035733182,
0.0030933486,
-0.0450844318,
-0.0090683661,
0.0199176241,
0.0233614501,
-0.0217631329,
-0.0109185781,
-0.0471721031,
-0.0316836759,
0.007474964,
0.0017940969,
0.0035359513,
-0.0352618173,
0.0050037508,
0.020352656,
0.0418556184,
-0.0305590387,
-0.0259307455,
0.0292370114,
0.006231633,
-0.066390112,
-0.0157566145,
-5.415001052e-33,
-0.0041381116,
-0.026510166,
-0.0314572081,
0.0116093978,
-0.0241669882,
-0.0040574884,
-0.025039928,
-0.0093997009,
0.0496168174,
-0.0034420553,
-0.0173105765,
0.0116239432,
0.0100720674,
0.0443762019,
-0.0087298704,
-0.0313750692,
0.0408807769,
0.0091728522,
0.0049454053,
0.0063647931,
0.0691931844,
0.0012454648,
0.0554372407,
-0.0389062874,
0.0146645065,
-0.0203003995,
0.025915321,
0.0286717676,
0.0061396104,
0.0433278382,
-0.0091350507,
-0.0082332827,
0.0183076654,
-0.0544584282,
-0.0148260491,
0.0413543582,
-0.0678988546,
-0.0050503192,
0.0166894682,
0.0376586765,
-0.0358579308,
-0.0373669825,
0.0495931432,
-0.013282029,
0.0096727544,
0.0045737745,
-0.0157669187,
0.0264657475,
-0.0425264686,
0.0023131378,
-0.0501921065,
-0.000191363,
-0.0071183671,
0.0353160091,
0.0479606278,
0.0289824381,
0.0393492021,
-0.0065658726,
-0.0721624792,
0.0170408934,
-0.0457319133,
0.0168314222,
0.0048952242,
-0.0228486955,
0.0330103673,
0.0086986972,
0.0447314605,
-0.0465284437,
-0.0469921865,
0.0193727519,
-0.0280322134,
0.0118756546,
0.0023448619,
-0.0372493006,
0.0577948168,
-0.0137379216,
-0.0171498861,
-0.0060667391,
-0.0065520979,
0.0569267347,
0.0420190431,
0.0052372748,
-0.0297159236,
-0.0392326154,
0.0185958669,
0.0131261591,
0.003105798,
-0.0451076217,
-0.0055154222,
-0.0159789082,
-0.0316582844,
0.0300357789,
0.014447053,
-0.030889513,
-0.0176719073,
0.0208873581,
0.0304045863,
0.0217489656,
-0.0214144085,
-0.0013728932,
0.0295662265,
-0.0518846177,
-0.0049782228,
-0.0443590544,
0.0343534127,
-0.0065293093,
0.0085111884,
0.0353526101,
-0.0655268952,
-0.0175520312,
-0.0142173916,
-0.0412923247,
-0.0470218137,
0.0624269731,
0.0582278296,
0.0444659181,
-0.0013407478,
-0.0051169205,
0.0255828332,
0.0361054279,
-0.0011447677,
0.0207709372,
0.0083160065,
0.0341083221,
-0.021098027,
-0.0507523529,
-0.0283851661,
0.0692922845,
0.078519389,
-0.0395891592,
-0.0068694595,
0.0002762359,
2.67e-7,
0.0360974818,
0.0530364141,
0.0935093686,
0.0005192797,
0.0362464562,
0.0026432353,
0.0071676383,
0.058414232,
-0.0385860316,
-0.0277073309,
0.0139862774,
-0.040000096,
0.0046139639,
0.0036403206,
-0.0811521336,
0.0029123572,
-0.064498581,
-0.0201582685,
0.0122924326,
0.0292809438,
0.0657208711,
0.1198224649,
-0.0062128794,
0.014699881,
-0.000597374,
-0.0149195846,
0.0298328642,
0.0444886722,
0.0183049496,
-0.077750355,
-0.0119538438,
-0.0048259706,
0.0229272805,
-0.0410937779,
-0.0093289455,
0.0499489047,
-0.0173641425,
0.0339394212,
0.0020798438,
0.0233129561,
-0.002117387,
-0.0448462106,
-0.0407206379,
0.0554009043,
0.0182287227,
-0.0755457655,
-0.0587382801,
-0.0074716201,
-0.0135105392,
0.0445255563,
-0.0448853001,
0.0382474884,
-0.0081825731,
0.0215401892,
0.0314595699,
-0.0234345105,
0.0736264512,
-0.0615572594,
-0.0070542982,
0.0018772307,
-0.067863591,
0.0175954215,
-0.0334382877,
-0.0004279414,
0.0449503958,
0.0097865434,
-0.0244172532,
2.857850386e-34,
0.0339498892,
-0.0169945844,
0.0255426485,
0.0415760092,
0.014907605,
-0.0541436486,
0.0285280719,
0.0351805538,
0.0374714546,
-0.0766418576,
-0.0504021794
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10112v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10112v2 | zrLLM: Zero-Shot Relational Learning on Temporal Knowledge Graphs with Large Language Models | 2023-11-15T21:25:15 | 2024-03-15T15:38:07 | Zifeng Ding, Heling Cai, Jingpei Wu, Yunpu Ma, Ruotong Liao, Bo Xiong, Volker Tresp | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Modeling evolving knowledge over temporal knowledge graphs (TKGs) has become
a heated topic. Various methods have been proposed to forecast links on TKGs.
Most of them are embedding-based, where hidden representations are learned to
represent knowledge graph (KG) entities and relations based on the observed
graph contexts. Although these methods show strong performance on traditional
TKG forecasting (TKGF) benchmarks, they face a strong challenge in modeling the
unseen zero-shot relations that have no prior graph context. In this paper, we
try to mitigate this problem as follows. We first input the text descriptions
of KG relations into large language models (LLMs) for generating relation
representations, and then introduce them into embedding-based TKGF methods.
LLM-empowered representations can capture the semantic information in the
relation descriptions. This makes the relations, whether seen or unseen, with
similar semantic meanings stay close in the embedding space, enabling TKGF
models to recognize zero-shot relations even without any observed graph
context. Experimental results show that our approach helps TKGF models to
achieve much better performance in forecasting the facts with previously unseen
relations, while still maintaining their ability in link forecasting regarding
seen relations. | [
0.0294883009,
0.0154142426,
0.0097275116,
0.0559658781,
-0.0156074455,
-0.0090442328,
-0.0154393027,
0.0157641117,
0.0664645582,
-0.0611128025,
0.0049523157,
-0.028735606,
-0.0204185471,
0.0067920964,
-0.0052526486,
-0.0229139887,
0.0289956611,
-0.0011485218,
-0.0016290187,
-0.0050773565,
-0.0159581378,
0.0247884523,
0.0087426342,
0.0076874401,
-0.0109210024,
-0.014801464,
-0.0143828038,
-0.0286373496,
0.0339783505,
-0.0526819825,
-0.0466221124,
0.0137513448,
0.0297218859,
0.0408168025,
0.0000018276,
-0.0413063094,
0.0015242883,
-0.0155042456,
-0.0440190621,
-0.0249213185,
-0.0005384912,
-0.0687481388,
0.0338963084,
-0.0322032273,
-0.0606187806,
-0.0552088469,
-0.0016949482,
0.0325846709,
-0.0038535164,
0.0696588084,
-0.0147102568,
-0.0136323962,
0.0296525508,
-0.0280504618,
0.0475281999,
-0.0598991364,
0.0318068936,
-0.0089138551,
-0.0130857704,
0.017926991,
-0.0369990431,
0.0220625773,
0.0192005355,
-0.0220807549,
0.0744609386,
0.0802853629,
0.0079823174,
0.0278884601,
0.0095549515,
0.1124569252,
0.0099623324,
-0.0276791006,
0.0006843251,
0.0104447594,
-0.0175090693,
0.0181845985,
-0.0213528164,
-0.0170282684,
0.0041125622,
0.0245836135,
-0.0103621818,
-0.0101633025,
0.0676536039,
0.0135561218,
-0.0196497571,
0.0753480345,
-0.0125977835,
-0.0164606385,
-0.0112619344,
-0.016924914,
0.0121692661,
-0.0467363447,
-0.0326898471,
0.0578737296,
0.0108686406,
0.0277408995,
-0.036189951,
0.0326304063,
-0.0241400581,
-0.0428590812,
-0.0157392323,
0.0110770008,
0.0448892377,
0.0855581686,
-0.0759512037,
0.0176954698,
-0.0164125264,
-0.0391456932,
-0.0394138806,
-0.0094502587,
-0.0734052137,
0.0102461278,
-0.0106564099,
0.0519645438,
-0.0091247037,
-0.0280277543,
-0.0246365275,
0.0366537087,
-0.0096178604,
0.0431342795,
0.0026437491,
0.0243744031,
-0.0121911289,
-0.032224752,
-0.0340748839,
0.0270731188,
-0.0030350778,
-0.0171936788,
-0.062864773,
0.015441793,
0.0022507922,
-0.0105565516,
0.0379900262,
-0.0115985703,
-0.0328163505,
0.0911243856,
0.0253613256,
0.0029283983,
-0.029346291,
-0.0646415502,
-0.0057745473,
-0.0413350575,
0.0335151367,
-0.0264974572,
0.0239489041,
0.011075709,
0.0114477007,
-0.0074373065,
0.0288161281,
-0.0144751659,
-0.0914987326,
0.0670253336,
-0.0000751531,
-0.0067420215,
-0.0515979193,
0.0102060298,
0.0296258181,
0.0655635297,
0.0099719726,
-0.0189088099,
0.0243377443,
0.0310136881,
-0.0622970499,
-0.0002785104,
0.0427165292,
0.0098646516,
-0.0323854722,
0.0124012353,
0.0221439004,
0.0292709768,
0.0183397438,
-0.0117115155,
-0.0224146787,
-0.0478208363,
0.0006330665,
0.0020726705,
0.0266187675,
0.016214937,
0.0678727403,
-0.0345116556,
-0.0216126665,
-0.0116130803,
-0.0254902374,
0.0385084301,
-0.0354922414,
0.0170044657,
-0.0440014973,
-0.0181538034,
-0.0282064267,
0.0163733959,
0.0135501111,
-0.0228721797,
0.0081113689,
-0.0277895182,
0.0703617111,
0.0145949526,
-0.0508893728,
0.052601859,
0.0448142439,
0.0255311653,
0.0093960585,
0.0298201703,
0.0148928985,
0.0850860998,
0.0477517694,
-0.0044570081,
-0.0662630871,
-0.0171512831,
-0.0020512606,
0.0082543334,
0.0192376319,
-0.0393370725,
-0.0052137352,
-0.0288413782,
-0.0554928407,
0.0191968847,
-0.0085635567,
0.0031598182,
0.0152289113,
0.0749896169,
0.0457199141,
-0.0509907939,
0.0367127284,
-0.0015407529,
-0.0333098024,
-0.0146421045,
0.0077422024,
0.0124981338,
0.0083869677,
0.0289391801,
0.0103809955,
0.0080556041,
0.0492150858,
-0.0371057019,
-0.0255935118,
0.0408899188,
-0.0354191512,
-0.0724373087,
0.0649220049,
0.0003704679,
0.0043197246,
-0.0539043471,
-0.0281049144,
-0.0123189967,
0.0778079033,
0.0468199141,
0.1018534079,
-0.0030578543,
-0.0090350956,
0.0134069212,
-0.0287988037,
-0.0017584313,
0.0576838292,
-0.0206974763,
-0.0047295,
0.0151101165,
-0.0190771613,
-0.0087816315,
0.0090168454,
-0.0162570216,
0.0164625347,
0.0374867357,
-0.0246795695,
-0.0065514958,
-0.0133216251,
-0.0661560968,
0.0148266591,
-0.0815842822,
-0.0155147249,
0.019809261,
0.0087760752,
0.003274861,
-0.0358329453,
0.0335444249,
-0.0218040664,
-0.0039468203,
0.0517161004,
-0.0279443301,
-0.0166388694,
0.0106021697,
0.0291699301,
0.0082682846,
0.0097216442,
-0.0149790635,
-0.0454003587,
0.0886265412,
0.0111445449,
-0.0339760967,
-0.0075007221,
0.0204061177,
-0.0636324435,
0.0051871706,
-0.0278270673,
0.0380909294,
-0.0383357815,
-0.0308341589,
0.0254229791,
0.0169537496,
-0.0392439626,
0.0276520085,
0.0265994314,
-0.0138159925,
-0.0537049882,
-0.002313552,
-0.033237204,
0.0144279702,
-0.0513091423,
0.0273664817,
-0.0396823473,
0.0211695619,
-0.0070538395,
-0.0196448192,
-0.0675872937,
0.0226270575,
-0.0411816873,
-0.0081354985,
-0.0316219181,
0.0140556423,
0.0215238631,
-0.0344838761,
-0.0352570675,
-0.0143868839,
0.0475202315,
0.031639155,
0.0216516107,
0.0483334772,
-0.0073018251,
-0.0619016849,
0.0623433627,
0.0005485261,
0.0181848835,
0.0163479783,
0.0198905934,
-0.0516690128,
-0.0038180675,
0.023635339,
0.0149059836,
0.0091314521,
0.0011641214,
0.0247190315,
0.0293646194,
0.0232251864,
-0.0315343551,
-0.0366142392,
-0.0534441583,
0.0254281703,
-0.0520238727,
-0.0151210641,
-0.0027707855,
0.0245353132,
-0.0296807326,
-0.015897071,
0.0074396385,
-0.0311053116,
-0.010086108,
0.0516253747,
0.0669997707,
-0.0570036434,
-0.0038405564,
0.0095884837,
0.05849085,
0.0290285461,
0.0235204604,
-0.0244643316,
-0.0162258595,
0.0071686236,
-0.0377604663,
-0.02223479,
-0.0393607467,
-0.0082392599,
-0.0401287042,
-0.0411402769,
0.007254825,
0.1099617854,
0.0375272743,
-0.0282734986,
0.004468001,
0.0106348172,
0.007965209,
0.0377938412,
0.010438567,
-0.1188986748,
-0.0049134153,
-0.0241874773,
-0.0344742239,
0.0360326767,
-0.0988560021,
-0.0228110924,
-0.1296943575,
-0.0194617305,
0.0465229005,
0.003894849,
-0.006844874,
-0.0389269143,
0.0009493345,
-0.0082720201,
-0.0475712046,
0.0020758661,
-0.0338519067,
0.0156482439,
-0.0040600868,
-0.0261303969,
-0.0575847104,
0.0320097841,
-0.0142731601,
0.0578341261,
-0.0145713221,
0.0441739894,
-0.0016856919,
0.003920902,
-0.0012283222,
0.0094316406,
-0.0157098472,
-0.0278603826,
0.0480234213,
-0.0394797921,
0.0034413987,
-0.0093398103,
0.0121671772,
-0.0222732667,
-0.0206164233,
-0.0085189147,
0.1253738701,
-0.0017889736,
-0.0580349676,
0.0026982415,
-0.0208301246,
-0.0174416844,
0.0493984148,
-0.0082792034,
0.0042956015,
-0.0143292947,
0.0155932531,
0.0086761266,
-0.0121833552,
-0.009443461,
0.0031150936,
-0.0460939817,
0.0346706882,
-0.0594805144,
-0.0464604758,
0.0373530984,
0.0313644297,
0.0083591016,
0.0210693981,
0.0068986318,
-0.0185161624,
-0.0703694224,
-0.0225734264,
-0.0403421745,
0.0106487479,
0.0155104203,
0.0213171765,
0.02592244,
-0.0083227111,
-0.0076075117,
-0.0417610183,
-0.0655586123,
-0.0613094643,
-0.05494399,
0.0160474349,
0.0132875061,
0.0830046535,
-0.0189853031,
0.0117634861,
0.0936868712,
0.0650595948,
-0.0156992022,
0.0264744684,
0.0237019751,
0.0141252689,
0.0119754588,
0.0713276491,
-0.0587674603,
-0.0255768672,
0.00122551,
0.0297472756,
-0.0596874766,
-0.0158845633,
-0.0191350356,
-0.0056536198,
0.0218729638,
0.0230831131,
0.0026097181,
-0.0283531342,
0.0030267318,
-0.0332265124,
-0.0101181893,
-0.0348619558,
0.0124620693,
0.0385481976,
0.0036195791,
-0.0019646359,
-0.0191017594,
0.0058159861,
0.0380722024,
-0.0146272462,
-0.0314961262,
0.0340007022,
-0.0141498121,
0.0550644957,
0.0319606736,
0.0006065159,
-0.0004809678,
-0.0096972622,
-0.014054182,
-0.0199597608,
0.0015540009,
0.0227939989,
-0.0004609805,
-0.0675283372,
-0.022198962,
-0.0431193002,
0.0075261109,
0.0006266069,
0.0168704614,
0.0720477626,
-0.0172747783,
0.0283001028,
-0.0364770852,
-0.0084735975,
0.0076733707,
0.0414915979,
-0.0174920615,
-0.0422756933,
0.0541903526,
0.0071133175,
-0.0283364858,
0.0751162916,
0.0845450908,
0.0396324471,
0.0797704384,
0.0227301847,
-0.0422686152,
-0.0304470994,
0.0022435451,
-0.0006352937,
0.0216907449,
0.0042212722,
0.0568808801,
-0.078034088,
-0.0840144977,
0.0517423637,
-0.0549847446,
-0.0435471795,
0.0035478871,
-0.0116361864,
-0.0197446477,
0.044460278,
-0.0114539079,
-0.0340806209,
0.0242136698,
-0.0175995082,
-0.0247138888,
-0.0119532775,
-6.022728693e-33,
-0.0167889837,
-0.036300879,
0.0217231624,
0.0027080772,
-0.0752229467,
0.0657574609,
-0.0202615652,
-0.0314467773,
-0.0264405254,
0.0389828235,
-0.0046237623,
0.0030285688,
-0.0128096174,
-0.0144409332,
0.0054419376,
-0.0411785096,
0.0172919221,
-0.006459224,
0.0481602028,
0.0187043436,
0.0513261892,
0.0412027501,
0.0631738007,
-0.035059344,
0.0303134508,
-0.0207230654,
0.0225134045,
0.0435692109,
0.0637085736,
0.0493573844,
-0.0193678178,
0.0369665399,
0.0347856134,
-0.0207701325,
-0.0135493167,
-0.0194184128,
-0.1214705482,
-0.0418846123,
-0.0008360659,
-0.0168830827,
-0.0174351092,
-0.0061891745,
-0.0101412879,
0.0145720057,
0.0477985404,
-0.0433098301,
0.028140692,
-0.020889286,
-0.0643507764,
-0.0363005437,
-0.0152778709,
0.0366848446,
0.0055350191,
0.0237770006,
0.0508645475,
0.0239497907,
0.0406798907,
-0.0119789802,
-0.0832621977,
-0.0042896196,
-0.0114583112,
-0.0227562077,
0.0273325015,
0.0051156408,
0.0328197703,
0.0573183447,
-0.0245316345,
-0.0224533956,
-0.0481001623,
0.0301816557,
0.0086869299,
0.0198379215,
-0.0389821976,
0.0142498836,
0.0021472333,
-0.0080845542,
-0.0763117895,
-0.0365168862,
0.0383350961,
0.0481426753,
0.0033656333,
0.014418046,
-0.0213935375,
-0.0302432626,
-0.0276607107,
-0.0158341471,
-0.0215555504,
-0.0323866233,
0.0077867592,
0.025435036,
0.0128892185,
0.0207056738,
0.0201581158,
-0.0784590319,
-0.0350544453,
0.0853739455,
-0.0037868782,
0.0007436833,
0.0210121386,
0.0294348337,
-0.0837471709,
-0.00806503,
0.0216056462,
-0.0185335688,
0.0028530494,
0.0129447822,
0.0382615738,
0.0112771746,
-0.0445650518,
-0.0341178179,
-0.0397824533,
-0.0325808674,
0.0166893862,
-0.0186665077,
0.0329709873,
0.0313179754,
-0.0097674336,
0.0443937778,
0.0811453834,
0.020679066,
0.0357789695,
0.0777351856,
0.0258647911,
-0.0094315922,
-0.0170080811,
-0.0239790399,
0.0116100591,
0.013433815,
0.0412764102,
-0.0470095649,
-0.0197581984,
0.0040257182,
2.55e-7,
0.0211602785,
0.0263802912,
0.0185439717,
0.0281180739,
0.0229909346,
0.0275079384,
-0.0015801134,
0.0557846949,
-0.0152631495,
0.0077962116,
0.0486489385,
0.0229805931,
-0.0261620395,
0.0312499199,
-0.0672313496,
0.015143198,
-0.0690418407,
-0.0546281859,
-0.0445754752,
-0.0478333794,
0.0352259092,
0.0636579916,
0.0682460666,
0.0252232235,
0.0170668568,
-0.0682675242,
0.0756451413,
0.0034687626,
0.0201361235,
-0.011207792,
0.0001865426,
0.0241389666,
-0.0282973591,
0.027542403,
-0.0067722453,
0.0364386179,
-0.0186006203,
0.0160657093,
-0.0216683988,
-0.0012032493,
0.0163976829,
-0.0312579907,
-0.0037272996,
-0.0044568032,
0.1025733352,
-0.0793904066,
-0.019254433,
0.0326345824,
-0.027182823,
0.0141320387,
-0.0041804085,
0.0304846559,
-0.0088619003,
0.0149234775,
0.0131577831,
0.0103389965,
-0.0107656633,
-0.070660159,
-0.0267799404,
0.0242950842,
-0.0078712953,
-0.0198692996,
0.0171893165,
-0.0229589026,
0.0261686575,
-0.0205686223,
0.0393876918,
2.237703189e-34,
0.0330353081,
0.0206306484,
-0.0172561593,
0.0203594584,
0.0199219678,
-0.0477801487,
-0.0268253535,
-0.0106380545,
0.0872437879,
-0.0885185748,
0.0022121051
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09383v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09383v1 | Long-form Question Answering: An Iterative Planning-Retrieval-Generation Approach | 2023-11-15T21:22:27 | 2023-11-15T21:22:27 | Pritom Saha Akash, Kashob Kumar Roy, Lucian Popa, Kevin Chen-Chuan Chang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Long-form question answering (LFQA) poses a challenge as it involves
generating detailed answers in the form of paragraphs, which go beyond simple
yes/no responses or short factual answers. While existing QA models excel in
questions with concise answers, LFQA requires handling multiple topics and
their intricate relationships, demanding comprehensive explanations. Previous
attempts at LFQA focused on generating long-form answers by utilizing relevant
contexts from a corpus, relying solely on the question itself. However, they
overlooked the possibility that the question alone might not provide sufficient
information to identify the relevant contexts. Additionally, generating
detailed long-form answers often entails aggregating knowledge from diverse
sources. To address these limitations, we propose an LFQA model with iterative
Planning, Retrieval, and Generation. This iterative process continues until a
complete answer is generated for the given question. From an extensive
experiment on both an open domain and a technical domain QA dataset, we find
that our model outperforms the state-of-the-art models on various textual and
factual metrics for the LFQA task. | [
0.0388617627,
0.005811749,
-0.0080065308,
0.0072647794,
-0.0312356148,
-0.019152306,
-0.022257315,
-0.022621002,
-0.0201522019,
-0.0429599322,
0.0407371782,
-0.050149072,
-0.0351340845,
0.0372522548,
0.0122674583,
-0.0551844202,
0.0075133261,
-0.0048027714,
0.0036625264,
-0.0041990625,
0.0138807455,
0.0217874218,
-0.0187540129,
0.0133457491,
-0.0121935634,
-0.0308214612,
-0.0527680628,
-0.018753482,
-0.0057248222,
-0.0316259414,
0.0343945436,
0.011371444,
0.0212071147,
-0.0328147672,
0.000001937,
-0.0588689111,
-0.0377789028,
-0.0038709403,
-0.0342329219,
-0.0063734511,
-0.0355337858,
0.0170758329,
0.0615536161,
0.0375056118,
-0.0527056344,
0.0340017155,
0.0058641904,
0.0621181577,
0.0512118563,
0.0472939424,
0.0108684916,
-0.0397153385,
0.0054430766,
-0.019007789,
0.0127527909,
-0.0479814261,
0.0017943602,
0.0114569627,
0.0327476189,
0.0450807363,
0.0000793706,
0.0035320155,
0.0373993255,
0.0035420621,
0.0146525623,
0.026286127,
0.0044827783,
-0.0156061631,
0.0223846585,
0.1019580215,
0.0427324511,
-0.0118942196,
0.0273488685,
0.0143930893,
0.0005072941,
0.0082757454,
-0.0689297095,
0.0402294658,
-0.0259635821,
-0.0382299833,
-0.0217898842,
0.0033058277,
-0.0137693342,
-0.0142180426,
-0.0272533614,
0.0570578724,
0.0076999492,
-0.0523414202,
-0.0197839923,
-0.0252453126,
-0.0094958609,
-0.0686780065,
0.0070239096,
0.0973836109,
-0.0483403541,
0.019047359,
0.0141952215,
0.0095723141,
0.056643419,
-0.0210854281,
-0.0156915542,
0.0231604073,
0.0009628983,
0.0283656251,
-0.0298014246,
0.0230340213,
-0.0380639397,
-0.0324952044,
-0.0888912156,
0.0029931141,
-0.046124246,
-0.0434550755,
-0.0359261855,
0.0499656983,
-0.0418797806,
-0.0395405628,
0.0007266015,
0.0351612084,
0.0104327565,
-0.0025784955,
0.0115957363,
0.0547746085,
-0.0220505167,
-0.0189695098,
-0.0597820766,
0.031341888,
-0.0929342806,
0.0280696321,
0.0161436927,
0.0059887548,
-0.02827801,
0.0164025389,
0.0234161317,
-0.0068583605,
-0.0059810868,
0.0349387638,
-0.0341754444,
-0.0071982211,
-0.0304492544,
-0.0823242739,
-0.0269177556,
-0.05438447,
0.0189874433,
-0.0387721248,
0.0278388821,
0.006415755,
-0.0346732773,
-0.0049666911,
0.0164569262,
0.0467679128,
0.0018879983,
0.041652143,
0.0163055193,
0.0231619664,
0.0682206079,
0.0336414911,
0.0487400517,
0.0488411821,
0.0236794315,
0.0202577617,
0.0422546007,
0.0301059224,
0.0140445773,
0.0073556341,
0.0270848051,
-0.0011854219,
0.0352066532,
0.0871482044,
-0.0088721113,
0.0106180413,
0.012295071,
0.0293111391,
0.0099334102,
-0.0141277229,
-0.0076708156,
0.0234798249,
0.0225359388,
-0.011573866,
0.0387087092,
0.028327018,
0.0062804278,
0.011250684,
0.0112704588,
0.0618741885,
-0.0245010909,
0.0320610814,
0.0236833021,
0.0018690755,
-0.0699581578,
-0.0376828723,
-0.0087355599,
-0.0010827169,
0.0048564533,
0.0371730067,
0.0135228876,
0.0464754887,
-0.0542892553,
0.0627250597,
-0.0207729284,
-0.0359624773,
0.0133213839,
-0.0123058595,
0.10609366,
0.040303465,
0.0241767932,
-0.0623078048,
-0.039271336,
-0.0148610743,
0.0396177322,
0.0102800848,
0.005411698,
-0.0372356251,
-0.0136375884,
-0.0268290453,
-0.0278338753,
-0.0425041392,
-0.0083297146,
0.0066539804,
0.0174230821,
0.0054826266,
0.0441691726,
-0.0377538092,
0.0368809626,
0.0409619994,
-0.0527553111,
-0.0495977439,
0.0021467747,
0.0040634861,
0.0348173119,
0.045512192,
0.0082060415,
0.0476793349,
0.0503728539,
-0.0404373705,
-0.0436275266,
-0.0329840779,
-0.0288802125,
-0.0184841808,
0.0309984218,
-0.0052487315,
0.0053012916,
0.0001885755,
-0.0142650632,
-0.0644408837,
-0.0070364922,
-0.0427648313,
-0.0083424449,
-0.037113253,
-0.0462776087,
0.0502507649,
-0.0186835416,
-0.0539548695,
0.0618667379,
0.0215335768,
0.0113544296,
0.0384031385,
0.0028854827,
0.0242762659,
-0.0578995198,
0.0075095901,
-0.008615477,
-0.0275654681,
-0.0027892629,
0.0449848622,
0.0109059317,
-0.0601840317,
-0.0239183474,
-0.0845538825,
0.0352179706,
-0.0391434543,
0.024392508,
0.0371478908,
0.0333028734,
-0.0109289028,
-0.0233361926,
-0.0834278539,
-0.0108385952,
0.0045311013,
0.0228133909,
0.0306505542,
0.0296257567,
0.0070067057,
-0.0402977616,
-0.0109416274,
-0.0242559928,
0.0300013814,
0.0128002428,
0.0004076197,
-0.0544063896,
0.0233987626,
-0.0598039441,
-0.0036961134,
-0.0011267941,
-0.0155517543,
0.0029775917,
-0.0088178813,
0.0432425216,
0.0553631261,
0.0487251095,
-0.0305135529,
0.0241626594,
0.0057952078,
-0.0431752428,
0.0551583543,
-0.0718980804,
-0.0227096304,
0.0012930713,
-0.0476225875,
0.0251533259,
0.0181081574,
0.0221978743,
0.0076422407,
-0.0473452918,
-0.0007961487,
0.0047006928,
0.0022592654,
-0.0377659984,
-0.012781702,
-0.0165158026,
0.0699493736,
0.0017269176,
0.0049639638,
0.0509344228,
0.0023349577,
-0.0010641753,
-0.0263523199,
0.0188632049,
-0.0743493885,
0.0853046998,
-0.0194127578,
0.0156638771,
0.0090092123,
-0.0054722293,
-0.034132272,
-0.0020797753,
-0.0290889479,
-0.0558826998,
0.0431730598,
-0.0275894869,
0.0226582475,
-0.0113698514,
-0.0157899018,
-0.0391378291,
-0.0478689745,
0.0121082217,
0.0309041925,
-0.0376092717,
-0.0062592905,
0.0162346177,
0.0045143473,
0.0421177261,
0.0071656923,
-0.0400972068,
-0.0065883868,
-0.0158322994,
0.064131856,
0.0888884962,
0.0489717573,
0.0275600683,
-0.0084391916,
0.0325659327,
0.0438780449,
0.0208929405,
0.0188830439,
0.026785057,
-0.0409986749,
-0.0068239993,
-0.040577434,
0.0038716025,
0.0482512601,
0.0510569066,
-0.0419707336,
-0.0445714295,
0.099654898,
0.0355436578,
0.023587916,
-0.0099938856,
-0.03795892,
0.0753098875,
0.0203544535,
0.0582374334,
-0.0769265592,
-0.0178722031,
-0.0162509326,
0.0435631089,
0.0149295935,
-0.0245202407,
-0.0035278427,
-0.1062515154,
0.0246991087,
-0.0280740913,
-0.0201277435,
-0.0130455969,
-0.0650388971,
-0.0099032754,
0.0157414787,
0.0039647548,
0.0374487415,
-0.0345232971,
0.0217755828,
0.0418609045,
-0.038009882,
0.0234596282,
0.0499971099,
0.0074312654,
-0.0151065988,
0.076086022,
0.0137433298,
-0.0144828297,
0.0005677712,
-0.0140598994,
-0.0651899949,
-0.0017413886,
0.0123175001,
0.0286622364,
-0.0025163756,
0.0013601499,
-0.0167961158,
0.0707829073,
-0.0663944408,
-0.0136007397,
0.0721305758,
0.050602112,
-0.0290369503,
0.0023218906,
-0.0257085655,
0.0163777117,
0.0003917672,
0.0914079323,
0.028499525,
-0.0313602239,
-0.0679728538,
-0.0153725306,
0.0109333145,
-0.0665531904,
-0.0115125356,
-0.0098556206,
0.0174582526,
0.0830978826,
-0.0754889473,
-0.0572780818,
0.0695289075,
0.0479449071,
-0.0244135782,
0.0126474965,
0.0152920019,
-0.0098471129,
-0.055212941,
0.0049985894,
-0.00832133,
0.0140619418,
-0.0360770896,
-0.0115830889,
0.0057893279,
-0.0416227467,
-0.0177551415,
-0.0043074503,
-0.0486039259,
-0.0075755268,
-0.0063109486,
0.0363052599,
0.010289357,
-0.000622166,
0.0070866053,
-0.0114997532,
0.0490731075,
0.0057168752,
-0.0349722542,
0.0099867946,
-0.0052696327,
0.0317236483,
-0.0048521161,
0.0328789279,
-0.0724753216,
0.0049885511,
-0.0139047513,
0.0895217732,
-0.0251785163,
-0.0601548888,
0.0432305969,
0.0309542399,
-0.0378891602,
0.0130277453,
-0.0101945633,
-0.0196819901,
0.0079524778,
-0.0155885695,
-0.0208405517,
-0.0271415636,
0.0451243669,
0.0003667904,
-0.0604881793,
0.0197732337,
0.0037409028,
-0.0411602966,
0.0414542407,
-0.0575359873,
-0.0017424229,
0.0164184961,
-0.0369558074,
0.0117116161,
-0.0317229964,
-0.0146271279,
-0.0290502086,
-0.0085565131,
0.0486399271,
0.0301826987,
0.0521197319,
0.0143652549,
0.0090616122,
-0.0434419438,
-0.0083716745,
-0.068032071,
-0.0527258664,
-0.0003571274,
0.0148280412,
-0.0090331156,
0.0101054907,
0.0152209047,
-0.0000020725,
0.0049193669,
-0.004004783,
0.006619704,
-0.0050299061,
-0.0139843123,
0.0574200004,
0.0310709532,
-0.0289313551,
-0.0081661409,
0.0806247517,
-0.0093053207,
0.0378379188,
-0.0113708815,
0.0173588302,
-0.0305378381,
-0.058786504,
-0.0048604859,
0.0464768857,
0.0020138782,
-0.010448019,
-0.0365426838,
-0.0134907449,
0.0364390463,
-0.0171042886,
-0.0178145505,
-0.0155227184,
0.0577867515,
0.071403645,
-0.0006780237,
-0.0633863434,
-0.0452762544,
0.017676143,
-0.0336301513,
-0.0148257939,
-0.0104892831,
-6.391665309e-33,
-0.0173811801,
-0.0455617197,
0.0522608832,
-0.0262089521,
-0.02441971,
0.0259840265,
-0.0274305064,
-0.0110173943,
-0.0232576765,
0.0021889552,
-0.0311184023,
0.002261545,
-0.0070567513,
0.0493661165,
0.0092414962,
-0.0340223312,
0.0187437739,
-0.0100288009,
-0.0108060623,
0.047393728,
0.0685911924,
0.0186475683,
-0.0352726914,
0.0118220178,
0.0287622176,
-0.0292746499,
-0.0103756925,
0.0554122739,
-0.0095464541,
0.0951204821,
-0.0202972032,
0.0119272489,
0.0548580326,
-0.0475397035,
0.0112438351,
0.108021535,
-0.079746753,
-0.0301189721,
-0.0024863861,
-0.0546096228,
-0.0774080083,
-0.0296282936,
0.0042907833,
0.0006838771,
0.0406231955,
-0.0516276509,
0.0309621375,
-0.0020044532,
0.0052787047,
-0.0457026996,
-0.046585083,
-0.0091267442,
-0.0227770507,
-0.0412798785,
-0.0280564055,
0.076999478,
0.0099054752,
0.0223891195,
-0.0205268431,
-0.0077776681,
-0.0277936161,
0.0473621562,
0.0171567239,
0.0186213125,
-0.0019795916,
0.0300713349,
-0.0224449746,
0.0123884575,
-0.0700324774,
-0.0238522626,
-0.0706923157,
0.025240818,
0.0355232656,
0.0333879031,
-0.0059354613,
0.026058374,
-0.0825077519,
0.0458007008,
-0.0271805432,
0.0486840196,
0.0180410482,
-0.0195429008,
0.0177907869,
-0.0115936669,
-0.0722405836,
0.0883751214,
-0.0034959072,
0.0070456695,
0.0488344133,
0.0292851049,
-0.0200786311,
-0.0180754531,
0.021624485,
-0.0203927439,
0.0328208245,
0.0371368118,
-0.0471536405,
0.0293517094,
0.0074028266,
0.0555309169,
-0.0716820359,
0.0282414071,
0.0202879403,
-0.0252326895,
-0.0384815149,
0.0175464544,
-0.0001477853,
-0.0131132565,
-0.054498557,
0.0026635509,
-0.0190587007,
0.0367577635,
-0.0299570337,
-0.0242449902,
0.0131242778,
0.0449022949,
0.0030835918,
0.0421579592,
0.005300445,
-0.0269267987,
-0.0138846245,
-0.0661467016,
-0.0011546799,
0.0091365715,
-0.0263349302,
0.0287285913,
-0.0216433704,
0.0510115959,
-0.0187028721,
-0.0473056883,
-0.0002751355,
0.0546083711,
2.542e-7,
0.0410462171,
0.0044541676,
0.0334394425,
0.0592120886,
0.0024186531,
-0.0055788802,
0.0395370834,
0.034428712,
0.002365672,
-0.0449989736,
0.0020318564,
0.0332576111,
0.0100292815,
0.0125414552,
-0.0877880976,
-0.0170495175,
-0.0645884201,
-0.019667428,
-0.0659894794,
-0.0244475156,
0.0813717544,
0.052073542,
-0.0246634372,
0.0091987457,
-0.0283123273,
-0.048535645,
0.0686722398,
0.019106308,
-0.0184986144,
0.0541754439,
0.0433091037,
-0.0124793407,
0.0301085375,
0.0101747485,
-0.0026091433,
0.0017926256,
0.0024219623,
0.0619966462,
0.0281630028,
-0.0690455511,
-0.002916554,
-0.0317633823,
0.0280176755,
-0.0388195738,
0.0752201229,
-0.0333839059,
-0.0088748019,
-0.0105030723,
-0.0386493206,
0.010695911,
0.0059456057,
0.0064866347,
0.0342631638,
0.031193478,
0.0045308704,
0.0059774094,
0.01143324,
-0.0911445841,
0.0078970073,
0.0144471126,
-0.0522001646,
0.0002579944,
-0.0296705328,
-0.0145638613,
0.001178343,
-0.0641077682,
-0.004447076,
2.051594653e-34,
0.0065497486,
0.0063018082,
-0.0045888769,
0.0377679355,
0.024276467,
-0.0334511958,
0.0007990684,
0.0050697136,
0.0302560627,
-0.0998413265,
-0.0207557771
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09367v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09367v1 | A Survey on Online User Aggression: Content Detection and Behavioural Analysis on Social Media Platforms | 2023-11-15T20:59:13 | 2023-11-15T20:59:13 | Swapnil Mane, Suman Kundu, Rajesh Sharma | cs.CL | cs.CL | The rise of social media platforms has led to an increase in cyber-aggressive
behavior, encompassing a broad spectrum of hostile behavior, including
cyberbullying, online harassment, and the dissemination of offensive and hate
speech. These behaviors have been associated with significant societal
consequences, ranging from online anonymity to real-world outcomes such as
depression, suicidal tendencies, and, in some instances, offline violence.
Recognizing the societal risks associated with unchecked aggressive content,
this paper delves into the field of Aggression Content Detection and Behavioral
Analysis of Aggressive Users, aiming to bridge the gap between disparate
studies. In this paper, we analyzed the diversity of definitions and proposed a
unified cyber-aggression definition. We examine the comprehensive process of
Aggression Content Detection, spanning from dataset creation, feature selection
and extraction, and detection algorithm development. Further, we review studies
on Behavioral Analysis of Aggression that explore the influencing factors,
consequences, and patterns associated with cyber-aggressive behavior. This
systematic literature review is a cross-examination of content detection and
behavioral analysis in the realm of cyber-aggression. The integrated
investigation reveals the effectiveness of incorporating sociological insights
into computational techniques for preventing cyber-aggressive behavior.
Finally, the paper concludes by identifying research gaps and encouraging
further progress in the unified domain of socio-computational aggressive
behavior analysis. | [
0.1056287959,
-0.0009888703,
-0.0481779389,
-0.0108942967,
-0.0182548538,
0.0315123349,
0.0312968343,
0.0227825716,
0.0178623609,
-0.0246640779,
0.0384299494,
-0.0281948242,
-0.0355287343,
0.0227252543,
0.0222109146,
-0.0302324686,
-0.0125551913,
0.0447925702,
0.0225752238,
0.0246679951,
0.0766551644,
0.0100074224,
-0.0224972498,
0.0194010157,
-0.0492359735,
-0.0369517654,
0.0405212194,
-0.0022724413,
0.0277601704,
-0.0373261981,
0.0513742268,
0.0072914185,
-0.0027660385,
0.0284057911,
0.0000018975,
-0.068600744,
0.0195518397,
-0.0293586794,
-0.0007458593,
-0.0454731919,
0.0718335882,
-0.0314710848,
0.01834164,
0.0687825829,
-0.0272147004,
-0.0039329673,
0.0408102497,
0.0297836233,
0.0261892453,
0.0302194115,
-0.0331128426,
-0.0546369404,
0.0001743634,
0.0453694835,
-0.0127977002,
0.0926894248,
0.018989753,
-0.0514055565,
-0.032044895,
-0.0275568701,
0.041008126,
0.0317230038,
-0.0181669872,
0.0145017607,
-0.0108767245,
-0.0312818363,
-0.0156176211,
-0.0377018079,
0.0370478332,
0.0436017923,
-0.0150661301,
-0.004755409,
0.0415493213,
-0.0231513549,
-0.0159583315,
-0.0181899145,
-0.0181672163,
0.0302687231,
-0.0300209168,
0.0017096318,
-0.0317476541,
0.0506290905,
0.0359047987,
0.062108241,
0.0575973168,
-0.0218366068,
-0.0558201745,
-0.0174967982,
-0.0170640945,
-0.0197322834,
0.0167194027,
-0.0094399285,
0.0168818049,
-0.0015197005,
-0.0152706718,
-0.0148753915,
-0.0641371682,
-0.1034904793,
0.023393387,
-0.0672107488,
0.0294752419,
0.0174843706,
0.0057434072,
-0.0232390054,
0.0683142096,
0.0049986951,
0.0050853426,
-0.0225087944,
0.0159673244,
0.0462358929,
-0.0379341692,
0.0069530359,
0.0308803339,
-0.0310530551,
0.0813219622,
0.0309056919,
-0.0531988218,
0.0002746084,
-0.0577462763,
-0.0178407133,
-0.0382217541,
-0.003642627,
0.0288755633,
0.035458345,
0.0152482744,
-0.0434256457,
-0.0694922581,
-0.0044047572,
-0.0380736031,
-0.0479561761,
0.0252624489,
0.0049216733,
0.0111532435,
-0.0309574399,
0.010199924,
0.0746032223,
0.0322368555,
-0.0411744453,
-0.0736222416,
-0.0805011839,
0.0011391852,
-0.0072437422,
0.0106602097,
-0.0616416335,
0.040134944,
-0.0018321073,
-0.0411577858,
-0.015022099,
-0.0087590404,
0.0201646872,
-0.0149428481,
0.0259820186,
-0.0637402236,
0.0287686046,
0.0550737754,
0.0154432831,
0.0014043704,
0.0416569225,
0.0037631597,
0.0094790524,
0.0723000169,
0.0032738736,
0.021883266,
0.0254526436,
0.0250819866,
-0.0177988913,
-0.0213296749,
0.0078883981,
-0.0390345529,
-0.055015631,
-0.01786495,
0.0080201309,
-0.0110158054,
-0.0257968698,
0.052018173,
0.0381363444,
-0.0529619157,
0.0114557883,
0.0281870253,
0.0376312099,
0.0069153924,
-0.0720999911,
-0.0200758819,
-0.0330978669,
-0.0310192704,
-0.0590674281,
0.01079138,
0.0425776951,
-0.0063088979,
-0.0060448637,
-0.0507915579,
-0.0286178533,
0.0571695082,
-0.0095460936,
0.0185920149,
0.0028426624,
0.0270579234,
-0.0054238206,
0.0325966664,
-0.0184428096,
0.0077305846,
-0.0241267271,
0.0275721382,
0.0559270903,
0.0097344406,
0.0089313006,
-0.0268457308,
-0.0704802722,
0.0136515955,
-0.0018191162,
-0.0360009037,
0.0015224275,
-0.0015616076,
-0.0048350771,
0.0013753646,
0.0341626815,
-0.0480349064,
-0.0491012074,
0.0873467699,
0.0129355676,
-0.0075846738,
0.0950331539,
-0.0495483465,
0.0306394212,
0.0121241054,
0.0088911215,
0.0029619676,
0.0585804768,
0.0817998275,
0.025780296,
-0.0147694387,
-0.0606299862,
0.0155648515,
0.0272865407,
-0.0264806189,
-0.0146260727,
0.0396203399,
0.04099546,
0.0541697815,
-0.0203734469,
0.002797313,
0.0236669406,
0.0209804326,
0.056503132,
0.0498655811,
-0.0482611358,
-0.0384064354,
0.0007923813,
-0.0586444363,
-0.0569212288,
0.0295294095,
0.0313556902,
0.055147741,
-0.0282442011,
-0.0094071012,
0.012199508,
-0.0911619887,
0.0057441406,
0.0184746366,
-0.0190722831,
-0.0750158131,
-0.0972713828,
-0.0078010866,
0.0106328139,
-0.0086801611,
-0.0293994341,
0.0354264043,
0.0033722694,
-0.0094395718,
-0.0242364295,
-0.0085003823,
0.0216660053,
-0.0065949904,
-0.0392064005,
0.0259472392,
0.0382474028,
-0.0024609291,
0.0421546511,
0.023238359,
0.0114645697,
-0.0441136844,
-0.0029785193,
-0.0233358238,
0.0019653968,
-0.034438692,
0.0164997391,
0.0055723167,
-0.0825285017,
0.0459675938,
0.0224189665,
-0.0594845228,
0.0119977454,
-0.0247355048,
-0.0367280915,
0.0356863588,
-0.0091569992,
-0.0362971164,
0.0392340049,
0.0789007768,
0.0967549011,
0.0609515719,
0.0197901744,
0.0236902125,
-0.0027853851,
-0.0242643785,
0.0000404768,
-0.0253027491,
-0.0707025081,
0.0096675605,
0.0320975408,
0.0415082127,
0.0063443319,
-0.0216284171,
0.0040277601,
-0.058047425,
-0.0384625942,
-0.0557207875,
-0.0407115296,
-0.0084306262,
-0.0074439738,
0.0075058965,
-0.0535934307,
0.049934268,
0.0166460071,
0.0447425209,
0.0452497452,
-0.0519121513,
0.0266483072,
0.0048153563,
0.0425147451,
0.0170256607,
0.0085508712,
-0.011936307,
0.070490323,
-0.0235017557,
0.0561130904,
-0.0155341448,
-0.0466820933,
0.0227688756,
0.0100928908,
0.0307764485,
-0.0079764025,
-0.0175073966,
-0.0693699494,
-0.0299177226,
-0.0449429899,
0.003371662,
-0.0131663326,
-0.0084545901,
0.0119625758,
0.0212662239,
-0.0341978595,
-0.0021610644,
-0.0327647775,
0.0470198803,
-0.0358604006,
0.0439543799,
-0.0182105247,
0.0376905538,
0.0030506651,
-0.0207805764,
0.0645186305,
-0.0448692814,
-0.047467459,
0.0169646889,
0.0380198434,
0.0068780915,
0.0131019615,
-0.0178198796,
0.0014638094,
0.0381510891,
0.0230503399,
0.0193005092,
0.0530075692,
0.0390131734,
0.0041223271,
0.0189192705,
-0.0071757929,
0.0012068766,
0.0108570475,
-0.0323911794,
-0.0437895767,
0.0086784046,
-0.0482419394,
0.0584290735,
-0.0921465084,
-0.0329930335,
0.0054991744,
-0.0231877007,
0.0310208909,
-0.0193011891,
-0.0098844543,
-0.0074592256,
0.0150109073,
0.0027449317,
-0.026474122,
-0.0093619982,
-0.0370828435,
-0.0058942349,
-0.0056866272,
-0.0148264542,
-0.0795798376,
0.0423783883,
-0.0069512087,
-0.0468861684,
0.011191735,
-0.0354310609,
0.0628755391,
-0.0472197272,
0.0216337685,
-0.0183487181,
0.0104636783,
0.0028067129,
-0.0107462322,
0.0717130825,
0.0024903703,
-0.0140419062,
-0.0636918843,
0.0679220334,
0.0052841455,
-0.0345545672,
0.0341693535,
0.0451885089,
-0.0001981742,
-0.0143530937,
-0.0532408394,
0.0101763057,
0.0261978023,
0.0202381462,
0.0120149022,
-0.0481143557,
0.0040551596,
-0.0166810658,
-0.0347195864,
0.0009902362,
-0.0544460565,
-0.0504966192,
0.0170660131,
-0.0430581085,
0.0012489321,
-0.0429280251,
0.0096426103,
-0.0092296014,
0.0011401756,
-0.0605883487,
0.0210595503,
0.0033921569,
-0.0533373468,
-0.0283982661,
0.0499244556,
0.0557356514,
0.0173175037,
0.0255475435,
-0.0322015919,
0.0099580651,
-0.0170866866,
0.0225460697,
-0.013686615,
-0.0455549546,
0.0437239632,
0.041874446,
0.0040998328,
0.0201344788,
-0.008970839,
-0.0523269251,
0.0669324622,
0.0290036444,
0.0423733555,
-0.0000989301,
0.0328742638,
-0.0061591715,
0.0159310903,
-0.0396564938,
0.0429001413,
-0.0245193951,
0.0307608452,
-0.0872208327,
-0.0849035531,
0.0125922095,
-0.0499283038,
-0.0179900825,
0.0227717552,
-0.0108718704,
-0.0474328548,
0.0230027698,
-0.0710986108,
0.0233349092,
-0.0162190218,
0.0331182145,
-0.0121130468,
0.0041724606,
0.0435282141,
-0.0599033274,
-0.0027804973,
-0.0459171049,
-0.0031168207,
-0.0588388219,
0.0246289037,
0.0094576487,
0.0229301825,
0.0204167794,
0.003584258,
0.0117559405,
0.0293176938,
-0.0136226956,
-0.0202461611,
-0.0186973531,
0.0173151121,
-0.0246811304,
0.0366742536,
-0.00209427,
-0.0157628488,
0.0277006309,
0.013648795,
-0.0094312318,
-0.0124117872,
-0.0368724763,
-0.0416572653,
0.0728444532,
0.0220771376,
-0.0054776487,
-0.0139885489,
0.023881793,
-0.0657756627,
-0.0896284282,
-0.0285466202,
0.0381652601,
-0.0419945084,
0.0095512625,
0.0332654268,
-0.0073920367,
-0.0030973696,
0.0332029499,
-0.0769571215,
0.0264374483,
0.033760082,
0.0235260483,
0.0507702306,
0.0104538184,
-0.0006437094,
-0.015974924,
-0.0241179336,
0.0285133328,
-0.0620146394,
0.0118469978,
-0.0053290883,
-0.0102318209,
0.0344416797,
0.0089811003,
-0.0065587503,
-0.0628381222,
0.0035538778,
-0.0235103574,
-0.060835205,
0.0084646624,
-5.330793413e-33,
0.0382843129,
-0.0538626648,
-0.0080491062,
0.0425459519,
-0.0356952362,
-0.0187483151,
0.0122832861,
0.0150426142,
-0.0160804801,
-0.0013017012,
0.0020436621,
0.0407450609,
-0.0161116514,
-0.0195936784,
0.009899566,
-0.0198016372,
-0.0188991968,
-0.0579014421,
0.0118675381,
0.019062778,
0.0219866075,
-0.0191794336,
0.011507134,
-0.0762688667,
0.0367812514,
-0.0062210863,
0.0146948658,
0.0354999267,
0.0301888566,
0.0387832001,
-0.0107150516,
0.0322444886,
0.0320952497,
-0.0095172273,
0.0070818332,
0.0461155511,
-0.0214778967,
-0.0023200251,
-0.0141607532,
-0.0177346226,
0.0111150648,
-0.00444614,
0.0163905546,
0.0124044046,
-0.0312769786,
-0.0372406133,
0.0349123068,
0.0207357034,
0.0352703854,
-0.0500600375,
-0.0202005431,
0.0069720931,
-0.0358380266,
0.0142361932,
-0.0186830666,
0.0551393777,
0.0117992684,
0.024576569,
-0.101661548,
0.0391832776,
-0.0066793286,
-0.0498863272,
-0.0045507317,
-0.0157846175,
0.0329762958,
0.023301499,
0.0063560773,
0.040456377,
-0.057616435,
0.0443762392,
0.0260071233,
0.0316276513,
0.0311146174,
0.0228929725,
-0.0186653063,
-0.1267665029,
-0.0763367638,
-0.022743322,
0.0717291534,
0.0078228302,
0.008401609,
-0.0386624523,
-0.068951495,
-0.0292714685,
0.0575440265,
-0.0630954131,
0.002964542,
-0.0209924374,
-0.013882488,
-0.0119839311,
-0.0214479174,
-0.0350883976,
0.0129483249,
-0.0238093175,
0.0028604416,
0.0568985306,
-0.0147151966,
0.0510167964,
0.047138717,
-0.0016755062,
-0.0289117787,
-0.001915046,
-0.001375544,
-0.052331578,
0.0318581276,
-0.0229402166,
0.0632193685,
0.0394619256,
0.0001110533,
-0.0146764936,
0.0507841967,
0.0630911365,
-0.0337681435,
0.0468609668,
-0.0029352913,
0.0681035519,
0.0005186544,
-0.0058532469,
0.0484609231,
0.0056227124,
-0.0041792314,
0.0246725157,
-0.033651188,
-0.0271540079,
0.036933098,
-0.00635583,
-0.0452692248,
0.0180256441,
0.0152393887,
-0.0692123622,
0.0105688507,
-0.0759664923,
2.633e-7,
-0.0110158026,
0.0640831441,
-0.0335471816,
0.0256524924,
0.038969744,
0.0398911387,
0.076043345,
0.0269850697,
0.0251626018,
-0.0256818775,
0.062242981,
0.0235313792,
-0.008920121,
0.0605537891,
0.0038973456,
-0.0100444229,
-0.0578836538,
-0.0298091285,
-0.0617168061,
0.0159177072,
0.0245786551,
-0.0009685127,
0.0460053831,
-0.0132460315,
-0.0186174884,
0.0021664917,
-0.0367484465,
-0.0178849623,
-0.0042600683,
-0.0322342888,
0.0332309343,
0.0117502064,
0.0005659048,
-0.0072105969,
-0.0254106633,
0.0094130766,
-0.0053058416,
0.0080132838,
0.0268677045,
0.0441242196,
0.0460219197,
-0.0015279424,
0.0062802844,
-0.0179460868,
0.0745806396,
-0.0035863693,
-0.0249388274,
-0.0362486728,
-0.0009723935,
-0.0348958783,
0.046027232,
-0.0259623583,
-0.0003590317,
-0.0022157086,
0.0441994667,
-0.0341520682,
0.0094501115,
-0.0406916812,
0.0178822838,
0.038148798,
-0.0178222843,
-0.0041054664,
0.0123287095,
0.042842079,
0.0376548916,
0.0682483688,
0.0739172846,
1.8259041e-34,
-0.0418649465,
0.0043420917,
0.0210150424,
-0.0839007348,
0.0056138942,
0.0442631021,
-0.0407146551,
-0.019161256,
0.0267081764,
-0.0376447737,
0.0222012158
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09366v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09366v1 | LOKE: Linked Open Knowledge Extraction for Automated Knowledge Graph Construction | 2023-11-15T20:57:44 | 2023-11-15T20:57:44 | Jamie McCusker | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | While the potential of Open Information Extraction (Open IE) for Knowledge
Graph Construction (KGC) may seem promising, we find that the alignment of Open
IE extraction results with existing knowledge graphs to be inadequate. The
advent of Large Language Models (LLMs), especially the commercially available
OpenAI models, have reset expectations for what is possible with deep learning
models and have created a new field called prompt engineering. We investigate
the use of GPT models and prompt engineering for knowledge graph construction
with the Wikidata knowledge graph to address a similar problem to Open IE,
which we call Open Knowledge Extraction (OKE) using an approach we call the
Linked Open Knowledge Extractor (LOKE, pronounced like "Loki"). We consider the
entity linking task essential to construction of real world knowledge graphs.
We merge the CaRB benchmark scoring approach with data from the TekGen dataset
for the LOKE task. We then show that a well engineered prompt, paired with a
naive entity linking approach (which we call LOKE-GPT), outperforms AllenAI's
OpenIE 4 implementation on the OKE task, although it over-generates triples
compared to the reference set due to overall triple scarcity in the TekGen set.
Through an analysis of entity linkability in the CaRB dataset, as well as
outputs from OpenIE 4 and LOKE-GPT, we see that LOKE-GPT and the "silver"
TekGen triples show that the task is significantly different in content from
OIE, if not structure. Through this analysis and a qualitative analysis of
sentence extractions via all methods, we found that LOKE-GPT extractions are of
high utility for the KGC task and suitable for use in semi-automated extraction
settings. | [
0.050071653,
0.0193981659,
-0.0084972912,
0.0595243536,
-0.052450411,
0.0290442333,
-0.01172812,
0.0167953912,
0.0834218562,
-0.0348315276,
-0.0173496827,
0.0323496424,
-0.0284071695,
0.0403584391,
0.0007337921,
-0.0212040171,
0.0229975246,
-0.0010668918,
0.0248624571,
0.0042191036,
-0.0353914574,
0.033293739,
-0.0220785961,
-0.0168593694,
0.0053454936,
-0.0167979673,
-0.0142368143,
-0.0294251144,
0.0383115225,
-0.0010158368,
-0.0049485089,
0.0086218026,
-0.0259110574,
0.0315321833,
0.0000019572,
-0.0693796575,
-0.0222034082,
-0.0007525552,
-0.0750585794,
-0.014314672,
-0.0223919917,
-0.0180670545,
0.0149837555,
-0.0283843894,
-0.029626539,
-0.0557481311,
0.0144241713,
0.0421726443,
0.0133993747,
0.0668340921,
-0.0059661572,
-0.056672655,
0.0920718089,
0.0002693406,
0.0003426368,
-0.0257536769,
0.0416543968,
-0.0024128072,
0.017260544,
-0.0059909569,
0.0133706555,
0.0398140624,
0.0170374773,
-0.0063912212,
0.0253405496,
0.0451133065,
-0.0237811115,
-0.0127942208,
-0.0158352144,
0.1518929154,
0.0111576356,
0.0410971083,
0.0271790791,
-0.0249629002,
0.0142337289,
0.0263813455,
-0.0337549038,
0.0469955727,
-0.0261946954,
0.0072984267,
0.012696173,
-0.0062694647,
0.0382385515,
-0.0121587729,
-0.0078835506,
0.0887103528,
0.0115636867,
-0.0286001898,
0.0714436918,
0.0157777648,
-0.0002693867,
-0.050248649,
-0.0026326021,
0.0273813922,
0.0185483377,
0.052164346,
-0.0281871054,
-0.0173516143,
0.0088384086,
-0.0036523254,
-0.0123478323,
0.0015545308,
-0.0381766297,
0.0536213256,
-0.051872097,
0.0031366104,
-0.0404127836,
0.0196115877,
-0.0050755269,
-0.0406089239,
-0.0676906556,
-0.0046360083,
-0.0066153756,
0.0541320443,
-0.0479780473,
-0.01006833,
-0.0200194176,
0.028311925,
-0.019521283,
0.0466757379,
0.0499177389,
-0.0089810994,
0.0115204994,
-0.0091205165,
-0.0591198765,
0.0150849037,
-0.010297725,
-0.0120477928,
-0.0107310768,
-0.0211758222,
-0.0009480758,
0.0132571878,
0.0435032398,
-0.0418450125,
-0.0085101211,
0.0528778546,
0.0447119437,
-0.0095893759,
-0.0494373254,
-0.0695310682,
0.0217391029,
-0.0391792692,
0.0231102016,
-0.0488626845,
0.0546565726,
0.0121216243,
-0.033623375,
-0.0783015564,
0.0270572882,
-0.0145019628,
-0.1031432152,
0.0315467604,
-0.0780464634,
-0.0181501303,
0.0085530616,
-0.0080786357,
0.0029690242,
0.0247816276,
0.0427932218,
-0.0037157082,
0.083033815,
0.0370004848,
-0.041585505,
0.0479646511,
0.0419127867,
-0.0156181473,
0.071333088,
0.0368748643,
0.0188682936,
0.0352954902,
0.0245266575,
0.0474224351,
-0.0114248656,
0.0141016049,
0.0134194978,
0.0052671931,
0.0487519801,
-0.0029787151,
0.0656167194,
0.0005021302,
0.0150988083,
0.0141528826,
-0.0252243094,
0.0041044722,
-0.0423154347,
0.0401611701,
0.0034289542,
0.039626915,
0.0000173852,
0.0098496228,
0.0072599766,
-0.0284316875,
-0.0135571295,
-0.007155946,
0.062856555,
0.0140789049,
-0.0533831827,
0.0831563249,
0.082183674,
-0.0310912821,
0.0055013495,
-0.0125423046,
0.0186937079,
0.0282804519,
0.0200390127,
-0.0172519665,
-0.0130253267,
-0.0042847064,
-0.0265327841,
0.0137061169,
0.0542302914,
-0.0522913411,
-0.0168064088,
-0.0497322194,
-0.0440429375,
-0.0039203316,
-0.0141917113,
0.0069855298,
0.0382684246,
0.039940536,
0.0351225473,
-0.0274310317,
-0.000613478,
0.0258733388,
-0.0363496877,
-0.0233497117,
-0.0173809454,
0.0412279554,
-0.0030785,
0.0698976591,
0.0032080037,
-0.018215375,
0.0327428728,
-0.0288528353,
-0.0205732398,
-0.0221108142,
-0.0127075333,
-0.0167078786,
0.0338007547,
0.0036066044,
-0.0217737667,
0.013525947,
-0.0394611843,
-0.0437507592,
-0.0240927879,
0.060579095,
0.047476925,
-0.0012965985,
-0.0191616956,
0.0294486396,
-0.0066672168,
-0.0284700077,
0.1016049236,
0.0135504445,
-0.0176451989,
0.0470718406,
-0.0087660151,
0.0003618735,
-0.0266227834,
-0.0169267375,
0.0176286455,
0.0085890563,
-0.0031911167,
0.0064854203,
0.0007265106,
-0.0977892205,
-0.0110942926,
-0.0653972998,
0.0666495115,
-0.0128028691,
0.0377819538,
0.0099381963,
0.0391535573,
-0.0149534317,
0.0239415094,
-0.0105279172,
0.0578906313,
-0.022174105,
-0.0082629891,
0.0372412913,
0.0608039126,
0.0016516922,
-0.0086012585,
-0.0238088109,
-0.0360216424,
0.0401467122,
0.0350969508,
-0.0184516348,
-0.0218867045,
0.0577810407,
-0.0453541912,
0.0030411873,
0.0087447781,
0.0431897342,
-0.024206318,
-0.0065260334,
0.0397011638,
-0.0062269848,
-0.0427904688,
0.0369535722,
0.003351276,
-0.0220055822,
-0.0203026831,
0.0301818624,
-0.0226097107,
-0.0098028425,
-0.0028662828,
0.0132710319,
0.028427219,
-0.0145587027,
0.0107151512,
-0.0115400143,
-0.0433375239,
0.0071357936,
0.0129411938,
0.0163451191,
-0.0353836939,
0.0081024421,
-0.0087093236,
0.0118815573,
-0.0089275576,
-0.0011509919,
0.0296824425,
0.0152987493,
0.0541574508,
-0.0113942996,
0.0139312772,
-0.0483720899,
0.0753542036,
-0.0064692362,
-0.0010385156,
0.0468267016,
-0.0190690868,
-0.0294785108,
0.0457381681,
-0.0232901778,
-0.0134541783,
0.0269308928,
-0.0328293405,
0.005850154,
-0.0130061042,
0.0078536645,
-0.0445253439,
-0.011449106,
-0.0370540023,
0.0307422411,
0.0128694568,
0.011088972,
0.0284787081,
-0.0225713942,
0.0074241436,
0.0013365987,
0.0082481168,
0.0087369019,
-0.0377399027,
0.0746947452,
0.0876963884,
-0.0180259813,
0.0064452314,
0.0166176669,
0.0340519436,
0.0252782516,
0.0029292104,
-0.0182847269,
0.0180140343,
-0.0036542981,
-0.0092298333,
-0.097793445,
-0.0297938567,
0.0079645412,
0.015657872,
-0.0405813977,
0.0094237477,
0.1075343937,
0.0392790921,
-0.0297348145,
-0.0136400377,
0.017673336,
0.0037567855,
-0.028617546,
0.0048021125,
-0.1205746755,
-0.02497226,
-0.0154569186,
-0.0011517693,
-0.002641747,
-0.0826555565,
0.0000712879,
-0.138218075,
-0.0014449339,
-0.0280574951,
-0.0357429124,
-0.0327565372,
-0.0248989929,
0.0147453891,
-0.0103983935,
-0.0077983937,
0.0226897616,
-0.0087143257,
0.0179435927,
-0.0085555185,
-0.003818555,
-0.0393854678,
0.045608867,
-0.0491043255,
0.0609363541,
0.0025809074,
0.0317680016,
0.0020440498,
-0.0268873721,
-0.0046700942,
-0.0405826308,
-0.0233413968,
-0.0113982707,
0.0738837421,
-0.0243068002,
-0.007479941,
-0.0515612476,
0.0305215511,
-0.0553910695,
0.019800093,
0.0182598513,
0.112262696,
0.0358438715,
-0.017150363,
0.0048955055,
-0.0630908534,
0.0173278637,
0.0716455802,
-0.0216625966,
-0.0148343844,
-0.0112613961,
0.0134526594,
-0.0151806073,
-0.053977605,
-0.0181232188,
0.0326976255,
-0.0469919369,
0.0242626071,
-0.0657487959,
-0.0699966028,
0.0361286215,
-0.0057918341,
0.0106270472,
0.0131398086,
0.0131521085,
0.0025272304,
-0.0321096294,
0.024347011,
-0.0452558175,
-0.0151263913,
-0.047989212,
-0.0173473805,
0.0273480695,
-0.0194312353,
-0.037593279,
0.0150730424,
-0.0415678509,
-0.0600998551,
-0.0056135394,
0.0130773988,
0.0153303891,
0.0263308808,
-0.0038337759,
-0.0009053234,
0.0433827266,
0.0276595112,
-0.0638898462,
-0.0155977365,
0.0041606496,
0.0043683732,
0.0135926567,
0.0494753383,
-0.0965742841,
-0.0221255869,
0.0088216392,
0.0262649916,
-0.0219361112,
-0.0759028867,
-0.0070991688,
0.0657245368,
0.0317356661,
0.0095462287,
-0.0106115835,
-0.0843165666,
0.0241749063,
-0.01376143,
-0.0074859965,
-0.0159104746,
0.0172707438,
0.0187381376,
-0.0118751135,
-0.0050266655,
0.0014757778,
0.0271209497,
0.0270358045,
-0.0713128448,
-0.0265683718,
0.0252651032,
0.041893214,
0.0280284099,
-0.0423024595,
-0.0387693346,
0.0276535153,
0.0011852672,
0.0087933531,
-0.0512194112,
0.0193953495,
0.0034950697,
-0.0129000712,
0.007084053,
0.0215495266,
-0.0343822576,
0.0186516456,
0.0116912127,
0.0374510661,
0.044444669,
0.007734728,
0.0413264632,
-0.0242626667,
-0.0345902815,
0.0163142253,
0.0196002964,
0.0068698935,
-0.0066795489,
0.0251109302,
0.015677385,
-0.0385650247,
0.0208501369,
0.0469062626,
-0.0228125844,
0.0657862574,
0.0031014031,
-0.0054995436,
-0.051981438,
-0.0204907916,
0.013905718,
0.0063835937,
-0.0199859347,
-0.009385963,
-0.0504861549,
-0.0405803695,
0.0378930569,
0.0020670681,
-0.0266567059,
0.0380770154,
0.0466754846,
0.0220843405,
0.0288135726,
-0.0515428185,
-0.0330780707,
0.0041419137,
-0.040726725,
-0.0354571752,
0.0413337648,
-6.120460028e-33,
-0.0450880677,
-0.0011759882,
0.0204238985,
0.0518578179,
-0.0538353361,
0.0161419995,
-0.023063805,
-0.0099967886,
-0.0690552369,
0.0200428348,
-0.0045820079,
-0.0195906609,
0.0133452453,
0.0112219853,
-0.0190950725,
-0.0249336641,
-0.008065193,
-0.0002799192,
0.0262972303,
0.0226996616,
0.0669271797,
0.0494784862,
0.0259574465,
-0.046885509,
0.081418559,
-0.0368881486,
0.0312930867,
-0.0174039993,
0.0515147373,
0.0445535406,
-0.0357867703,
0.0719697922,
0.0063,
-0.0274419244,
0.0391522013,
0.0232240558,
-0.1369136125,
-0.0462205335,
-0.0021237982,
-0.0103433859,
-0.0401517861,
-0.0579950102,
0.0208649859,
0.0193256531,
0.0564771518,
-0.0531872325,
0.0350273848,
0.0018604539,
0.0053939014,
-0.0239840429,
-0.0574636348,
0.0203532577,
0.0327235907,
0.0343944654,
0.0099570472,
-0.0237005688,
0.0087162368,
-0.0024244459,
-0.090488717,
-0.0237502009,
0.0086698867,
-0.0199789573,
0.04134259,
-0.0117911743,
0.0075904159,
0.0395388529,
-0.0200454146,
-0.0277431011,
-0.0456047207,
0.0447921194,
-0.0042572343,
0.0704722181,
-0.0201686472,
0.0375740789,
-0.0347066261,
-0.0313295498,
-0.1296013743,
0.0148193249,
0.0212682523,
-0.005066507,
-0.0422887504,
-0.0121384021,
-0.0341907144,
0.0217868108,
0.0033186213,
-0.0242382381,
-0.0127552934,
-0.0344628878,
0.0213876031,
-0.0354216434,
-0.0350729339,
0.0136614908,
-0.0078203548,
-0.031887006,
0.0276188198,
0.0525825061,
0.0039444156,
0.0215829723,
-0.0165507495,
0.0073997141,
-0.0875049308,
-0.0387722589,
-0.0069958842,
0.0005805379,
0.0171459615,
0.0513543151,
0.0251369178,
0.0150507316,
-0.044601962,
0.0013108534,
-0.0321633779,
0.0157931186,
-0.0084514646,
-0.0162163023,
0.0039730761,
0.024046177,
0.0012634048,
0.0109759849,
0.0796556622,
-0.0004109493,
-0.018151613,
-0.0035530513,
0.0295681395,
-0.0264105499,
-0.019207729,
0.0035314865,
0.0228394736,
0.0336053073,
-0.0051056929,
-0.0587447397,
0.0010106737,
0.0344247706,
2.756e-7,
0.0318737067,
-0.0143335173,
0.0232746191,
0.0467655808,
-0.0213767122,
-0.0030073433,
0.0452602878,
0.034788724,
-0.0095053641,
-0.0596922152,
0.0108230105,
-0.0101191718,
-0.02659408,
0.0275998376,
-0.0960143656,
0.0038154747,
-0.007815294,
-0.0448758155,
-0.065424785,
-0.0118622044,
0.0681142882,
0.0239810999,
0.0497352444,
-0.0020769325,
-0.053366255,
-0.0274891667,
0.0181613527,
-0.0025508737,
-0.0054528397,
0.0173762981,
0.0509609468,
0.0105923275,
-0.0529339164,
0.07810314,
0.0012473997,
0.0545375943,
0.0200757105,
0.0269880481,
0.014904609,
-0.0223669484,
0.0002712061,
-0.0889603347,
0.0184947774,
-0.0439806953,
0.1029298827,
-0.0125304302,
-0.0121222958,
0.0539292172,
-0.0339607373,
-0.0175747834,
-0.0260581821,
-0.0215198696,
0.026769409,
0.0327120125,
0.0046863686,
0.000735286,
-0.0253267903,
-0.0822031349,
0.0182865765,
-0.0035343119,
0.0023326261,
-0.052271571,
0.0236571208,
-0.03892681,
0.0119613092,
-0.0612459667,
0.0252453703,
2.35366364e-34,
-0.0303077083,
0.0115900207,
-0.0162664261,
-0.0038343791,
0.0296104662,
-0.0360489152,
-0.030335933,
-0.0048381938,
-0.009954921,
-0.0912688449,
-0.009664367
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09363v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09363v2 | Investigating the Emergent Audio Classification Ability of ASR Foundation Models | 2023-11-15T20:52:56 | 2024-03-28T16:31:26 | Rao Ma, Adian Liusie, Mark J. F. Gales, Kate M. Knill | cs.CL | cs.CL | Text and vision foundation models can perform many tasks in a zero-shot
setting, a desirable property that enables these systems to be applied in
general and low-resource settings. There has been far less work, however, on
the zero-shot abilities of ASR foundation models, with these systems typically
fine-tuned to specific tasks or constrained to applications that match their
training criterion and data annotation. In this work we investigate the ability
of Whisper and MMS, ASR foundation models trained primarily for speech
recognition, to perform zero-shot audio classification. We use simple
template-based text prompts at the decoder and use the resulting decoding
probabilities to generate zero-shot predictions. Without training the model on
extra data or adding any new parameters, we demonstrate that Whisper shows
promising zero-shot classification performance on a range of 8
audio-classification datasets, outperforming the accuracy of existing
state-of-the-art zero-shot baselines by an average of 9%. One important step to
unlock the emergent ability is debiasing, where a simple unsupervised
reweighting method of the class probabilities yields consistent significant
performance gains. We further show that performance increases with model size,
implying that as ASR foundation models scale up, they may exhibit improved
zero-shot performance. | [
-0.0438055247,
0.030911386,
0.0149948103,
0.0155977346,
0.0100230956,
0.0090455953,
0.0811255649,
-0.0248877406,
-0.0564229563,
-0.0578802601,
-0.043079216,
-0.0230655167,
0.0025541077,
0.0194405466,
-0.0058247377,
-0.009041924,
-0.004815842,
-0.0271858964,
0.0025010931,
-0.0089098001,
0.0015338461,
0.0142422654,
-0.0611633398,
0.0450724065,
0.0233864095,
0.0035120302,
-0.0000849728,
0.0490464382,
0.0132412827,
-0.0324208401,
-0.0247002952,
0.0502687544,
0.0587975122,
0.065655522,
0.000001636,
-0.0411957949,
0.0064104977,
0.0151062096,
-0.1256397665,
-0.0344997756,
-0.0077880081,
-0.0178350266,
-0.0262290668,
0.0457848236,
0.0001460468,
-0.0662248284,
0.0440742709,
0.0234807059,
-0.0131411795,
0.0458209105,
-0.0155089535,
-0.0574893393,
0.0130314445,
-0.0215227585,
0.0338010304,
-0.0085089458,
-0.0239565149,
-0.0561704934,
-0.0370177478,
0.0226506311,
-0.0198459886,
0.0161381308,
0.0065889726,
0.009868579,
0.050434839,
0.0524207726,
-0.0648071989,
-0.0381042697,
-0.0080387238,
0.0477420054,
-0.00597509,
-0.0650907904,
0.0114621734,
-0.0033797687,
-0.0317179337,
-0.0428960174,
-0.0590650998,
0.0453026928,
0.0130941859,
0.0253659394,
-0.0115118884,
0.0705615431,
0.0490300059,
-0.0089222221,
0.0120934946,
0.0011296797,
-0.0184333231,
-0.0114952354,
0.0023752193,
-0.0187308043,
0.043432992,
-0.0628477782,
-0.0244130529,
0.0045175208,
0.0175455734,
-0.0194700267,
-0.0572200008,
0.0080290856,
-0.0155387828,
-0.0051058568,
0.0472495705,
0.0417762361,
-0.0559676774,
0.0694562942,
-0.0320478342,
0.0033501585,
0.0289431754,
-0.014827867,
0.0148675637,
0.0210888572,
-0.0668989792,
0.0077906121,
-0.0278223939,
0.045050934,
0.0080460664,
-0.0541874059,
-0.0362806395,
-0.0008983758,
0.0083088735,
0.0134487012,
0.0008872778,
-0.0061078789,
-0.0408529043,
0.0086585218,
0.050696183,
0.0530796014,
0.0375135578,
0.0376389399,
-0.0197444204,
-0.081315957,
-0.0200880654,
0.0192819331,
0.0285272077,
0.0155711463,
0.0230105948,
0.0359890386,
-0.0083501413,
-0.0517587774,
-0.0322934017,
-0.0037082965,
-0.015225173,
-0.0357534289,
-0.0336678401,
-0.0397624336,
-0.0008723213,
0.0205420572,
0.0079395417,
-0.012118483,
0.0158788506,
-0.0136506818,
0.0253256429,
0.0791543424,
-0.0022715325,
-0.0012784888,
0.0156643949,
0.0047810581,
-0.0149298254,
0.07889162,
0.026442308,
0.0157688949,
0.0141617516,
-0.0040104454,
0.0197817832,
0.0455921181,
-0.0036477703,
0.0215250459,
-0.0160106346,
-0.020734014,
0.0013160411,
0.0085713724,
0.0208940487,
-0.0160348658,
-0.0384671465,
-0.0426756218,
0.0481111594,
0.0426563732,
0.0483502224,
0.0199171156,
0.0417167395,
-0.0014330719,
-0.0366929471,
-0.0187120736,
-0.0060758227,
0.0137573741,
-0.0348724499,
0.0261248145,
-0.00496139,
-0.0111709675,
-0.0512955524,
-0.001154376,
-0.0181579664,
-0.0430597961,
-0.0440399759,
0.0397812091,
0.070152685,
0.0136288712,
-0.0289542545,
0.0162983071,
-0.0285945609,
-0.049628403,
-0.0107926326,
-0.0525513105,
0.0306031462,
0.0133975223,
0.02544301,
-0.0414005965,
-0.0277376566,
-0.0530821644,
0.0110540483,
0.0369576737,
-0.0175723881,
-0.0089537492,
0.0606834963,
-0.0592912883,
-0.0282099154,
0.010125583,
0.0175295752,
0.0545050949,
-0.0438816473,
0.0178582594,
0.0112203518,
-0.008379288,
0.0322857015,
-0.0257159621,
0.003748436,
-0.0484349243,
0.0567995869,
0.0165489148,
0.0544734411,
0.0239447653,
-0.0633558333,
-0.0078635439,
0.0333572701,
-0.0381284766,
-0.0092020202,
0.0086663626,
-0.0678697154,
-0.0268298741,
0.0228727218,
0.0207297374,
0.0791590065,
0.0127436714,
-0.0050452137,
-0.0420585386,
0.0354994424,
0.012407301,
0.0430702306,
-0.034983743,
0.0312115643,
-0.0098871943,
0.0168343056,
0.0254854281,
-0.0091945007,
0.0519097783,
-0.0074163876,
-0.0373163298,
-0.0106274458,
0.0663744062,
-0.0852071568,
-0.0199507624,
0.0124320025,
-0.0296741854,
-0.0098885447,
-0.0016723328,
-0.0307344291,
0.0088272458,
0.0155720487,
-0.0815795362,
-0.0127149625,
-0.0365185551,
0.0010204029,
-0.0310034528,
0.0022103807,
0.0091294404,
-0.0507758781,
-0.0053129797,
-0.0218427964,
-0.0103841135,
-0.0079744253,
-0.052155517,
-0.005020421,
-0.0355099626,
0.010535989,
-0.0065973871,
0.0096684871,
0.0245381054,
0.0060937176,
-0.02063407,
-0.0070038112,
0.0270786081,
0.0132037709,
0.0106628127,
-0.0068839113,
-0.0007810803,
0.0123992478,
0.0099977041,
-0.0435708426,
0.0480814166,
-0.0337509289,
0.0440434851,
0.0076858704,
0.0513489842,
-0.0164886098,
-0.02103067,
0.03661488,
0.0310537703,
-0.0359129198,
0.0368471816,
-0.0547401272,
0.0542956479,
0.0377537459,
0.016714666,
-0.0398350805,
0.0103202648,
-0.0068500405,
-0.0331677049,
-0.0373271145,
-0.0239726249,
-0.0167239476,
0.0437082201,
-0.0103211654,
-0.0309293456,
0.0201521013,
-0.0689938143,
-0.0489258282,
-0.0119494516,
-0.0596500374,
-0.0361059047,
0.0083803441,
-0.0326053575,
-0.0012760091,
0.0662029907,
-0.0162250325,
-0.0097268773,
-0.0276037827,
0.0186219197,
-0.0423525125,
0.0289328229,
0.0011845469,
0.0208655652,
-0.047104802,
-0.0289363451,
-0.023195643,
-0.033233583,
-0.039046023,
0.0589795783,
-0.0710664988,
-0.017654825,
-0.0590954125,
0.0323607698,
0.0284456592,
0.0840411931,
-0.008531712,
0.0163702443,
-0.0123900333,
0.0595695786,
0.0132445106,
-0.0319491737,
-0.0477637723,
-0.0251173973,
0.0676216781,
0.0069359974,
0.0756831989,
0.0468611568,
-0.0795500353,
-0.0105751464,
0.0338458717,
0.0021944304,
-0.0183091257,
0.0384988785,
0.0031311079,
-0.035273727,
0.0140150124,
0.1234655008,
0.0126650408,
-0.0243615545,
-0.02911436,
0.0360768847,
0.0129301744,
0.0473501645,
-0.0555426143,
-0.0889729783,
-0.055049587,
0.0477557294,
0.0287762042,
0.0011698648,
-0.0036065988,
0.0109900236,
-0.0865236744,
0.0555936731,
0.0251705628,
-0.0574215874,
0.0315531567,
-0.0186873581,
-0.0146228233,
-0.0363013782,
0.0118478984,
-0.0339296684,
-0.0018741431,
-0.001783814,
0.0397409275,
-0.0246620495,
-0.0809551477,
0.0129266568,
-0.0226235464,
0.0890154839,
0.0417558067,
-0.0035703424,
-0.0245662164,
-0.0024895438,
-0.0419469252,
-0.0321548432,
0.0180031471,
-0.0151148057,
0.0663907006,
-0.0269108936,
0.0155422781,
0.0519104376,
0.0115930857,
-0.0105675273,
-0.0148550402,
-0.0005319202,
0.0214131512,
-0.0255195275,
-0.0183086265,
-0.0173105467,
-0.0052631474,
0.005574517,
0.0799940899,
0.0292817634,
0.0003172649,
-0.0090020485,
0.0066534351,
0.015584344,
-0.038817469,
-0.0020105306,
-0.0028132708,
0.0014127984,
-0.0769031122,
-0.0002074273,
0.0392302684,
0.0164761376,
0.060033489,
-0.0130376387,
0.0111588668,
-0.0280198529,
0.0037436523,
-0.0561026298,
-0.015551215,
-0.006180794,
0.0464129224,
-0.0660087317,
-0.0258632489,
0.0700485632,
-0.0662994832,
-0.0265355073,
-0.0165091865,
-0.0518791191,
-0.0437764861,
-0.0084023485,
-0.0033949651,
0.0268787462,
-0.0015929436,
-0.0251711179,
-0.0557623208,
0.1240918934,
0.0399101786,
-0.023308428,
0.0366308764,
0.0759401247,
-0.0177887026,
-0.0163697973,
0.0052187853,
-0.0417028628,
0.058336772,
0.0197594278,
-0.0192632899,
-0.0420942679,
0.0026123235,
-0.0189616159,
-0.0112823565,
0.0636101365,
-0.0303969998,
0.0104685044,
0.0041772304,
0.0355275758,
-0.007357155,
0.0491526388,
-0.0109666968,
-0.0156073645,
0.0613297597,
0.0073332791,
-0.0223629419,
0.03077057,
-0.0767647102,
0.0328119881,
-0.02545432,
0.042776186,
0.0497550219,
-0.0322186984,
0.0084206192,
0.0024317559,
0.0054823142,
0.0486699864,
0.0478925407,
0.0002517385,
0.0235603619,
0.0346487463,
0.0004889823,
0.0411876626,
-0.0033260437,
0.0275244396,
-0.0513262153,
0.0188018065,
-0.0156131675,
0.0654214174,
0.0278710201,
-0.0047052526,
0.0023162994,
0.0221541636,
0.0027131075,
-0.0322009251,
0.0343789496,
-0.0257736202,
-0.0440055951,
0.0441802889,
0.03089495,
-0.0018201469,
0.0754941329,
0.0606076159,
0.0127697866,
0.0372634009,
-0.0095905224,
0.037304908,
-0.0260934103,
-0.0011024679,
0.0164447986,
0.018348936,
0.0043783481,
0.0322504602,
-0.0354421176,
-0.079519175,
0.0681798309,
-0.0281885527,
0.0541997254,
-0.0182244871,
0.0021562919,
0.002596444,
-0.0086249448,
-0.0023373908,
0.0163274184,
-0.0591856539,
-0.0403484143,
-0.0093362238,
-0.0148913693,
-5.546614175e-33,
-0.0065128109,
0.0294925962,
-0.0083121918,
0.012414977,
-0.0019918531,
0.028265601,
-0.0093786689,
0.0048389244,
-0.0001622831,
-0.0135970525,
-0.0048015881,
0.0123377535,
0.0296944324,
0.0351857096,
-0.0112956278,
-0.0243816469,
0.0954565704,
-0.0451379009,
-0.0027583891,
-0.0126969321,
0.0219046623,
0.0104804095,
0.0012978622,
-0.0398330279,
-0.0610362664,
-0.0182595719,
-0.0189027563,
-0.0096339798,
0.034942627,
0.0791842118,
0.0027361999,
0.0459699258,
0.0087556737,
-0.0429974049,
0.0146382526,
0.0141118402,
-0.0491267741,
0.0195126217,
-0.0499282219,
0.0323065147,
0.0232212581,
-0.0007035576,
0.0063420599,
0.0218123812,
-0.0485866331,
-0.0455911309,
0.0367690213,
-0.0259829052,
-0.0257831849,
-0.0585933514,
-0.0122204637,
0.0180764608,
-0.0230189022,
-0.0501857437,
0.0806958154,
0.0241457485,
-0.007728585,
0.0009786638,
-0.0373410285,
0.0187000036,
0.0199508704,
0.0111023206,
0.0206706356,
0.0409158468,
-0.0258421171,
0.0274603367,
0.0374603756,
-0.0644149929,
-0.0170938279,
-0.0423504673,
0.0362955518,
0.0225860011,
0.0067968136,
0.047772903,
0.0746559501,
0.0207822025,
-0.0503299758,
-0.0202960111,
0.0326842032,
0.0196980406,
0.033682052,
0.0488151535,
-0.0595172867,
-0.0144017823,
-0.0486610271,
-0.0829296485,
-0.0408515893,
-0.0188153237,
0.0468375012,
0.0441006124,
0.0201377515,
0.0396800339,
0.0588929951,
-0.0447569005,
0.0102852974,
0.0404254124,
0.0104968408,
0.0361636728,
0.0066027795,
-0.0023244456,
-0.0632538348,
0.0015601442,
0.0985732675,
0.0506181046,
0.0273758117,
-0.024364613,
0.034755446,
0.0689197481,
-0.0506983846,
-0.0339424051,
0.0095877983,
0.0195332188,
0.0254562311,
0.0604434013,
0.0044600461,
0.017307708,
-0.015234719,
0.0510782376,
-0.0441038981,
0.0246981829,
-0.0185432136,
0.0000014564,
-0.0132343844,
0.0077906894,
-0.0505812913,
0.0156189892,
0.0394033007,
-0.0203479733,
0.0360190049,
-0.0234725624,
-0.0148696704,
0.0168167073,
2.447e-7,
-0.049451787,
-0.0003980703,
-0.0079878457,
-0.0332949869,
0.0332762785,
0.05797638,
-0.0485950783,
0.0147440024,
0.0013289759,
-0.0179444905,
-0.0069566006,
0.0156948231,
0.0772330761,
0.0012789067,
-0.1171793342,
0.040983431,
-0.0593858995,
0.0506472215,
-0.0337840468,
0.0004864563,
0.0140767433,
0.1065405384,
0.0227641128,
-0.0327539854,
0.0659059957,
0.0092749624,
0.0252597108,
0.0237951428,
0.0307538565,
-0.0501427725,
0.0025645019,
0.0054693799,
-0.024031328,
0.0158921648,
-0.0240957513,
0.0134796873,
-0.0094642742,
0.0198653955,
-0.0551741198,
-0.0538523123,
-0.0220154058,
0.0561592579,
-0.0093595795,
-0.0109321494,
0.0761137083,
-0.0217924677,
-0.0359874256,
-0.0244727526,
-0.0808340609,
0.0082053505,
-0.0118492143,
0.0048330282,
0.0151252979,
-0.0115515562,
0.0269319993,
-0.0073085222,
-0.03040969,
-0.0719751492,
0.0116222342,
-0.0030247278,
-0.0256428812,
0.0065948679,
0.0009631689,
-0.0360644087,
0.0075091864,
-0.0516974963,
-0.0134013249,
1.912686347e-34,
0.0306897648,
-0.0133393435,
0.0208685715,
-0.0273465142,
-0.0236115996,
-0.0217394996,
-0.0100695547,
-0.0067361682,
0.0122436611,
-0.0571101457,
-0.0182666536
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09358v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09358v1 | Empirical evaluation of Uncertainty Quantification in Retrieval-Augmented Language Models for Science | 2023-11-15T20:42:11 | 2023-11-15T20:42:11 | Sridevi Wagle, Sai Munikoti, Anurag Acharya, Sara Smith, Sameera Horawalavithana | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7 | Large language models (LLMs) have shown remarkable achievements in natural
language processing tasks, producing high-quality outputs. However, LLMs still
exhibit limitations, including the generation of factually incorrect
information. In safety-critical applications, it is important to assess the
confidence of LLM-generated content to make informed decisions. Retrieval
Augmented Language Models (RALMs) is relatively a new area of research in NLP.
RALMs offer potential benefits for scientific NLP tasks, as retrieved
documents, can serve as evidence to support model-generated content. This
inclusion of evidence enhances trustworthiness, as users can verify and explore
the retrieved documents to validate model outputs. Quantifying uncertainty in
RALM generations further improves trustworthiness, with retrieved text and
confidence scores contributing to a comprehensive and reliable model for
scientific applications. However, there is limited to no research on UQ for
RALMs, particularly in scientific contexts. This study aims to address this gap
by conducting a comprehensive evaluation of UQ in RALMs, focusing on scientific
tasks. This research investigates how uncertainty scores vary when scientific
knowledge is incorporated as pretraining and retrieval data and explores the
relationship between uncertainty scores and the accuracy of model-generated
outputs. We observe that an existing RALM finetuned with scientific knowledge
as the retrieval data tends to be more confident in generating predictions
compared to the model pretrained only with scientific knowledge. We also found
that RALMs are overconfident in their predictions, making inaccurate
predictions more confidently than accurate ones. Scientific knowledge provided
either as pretraining or retrieval corpus does not help alleviate this issue.
We released our code, data and dashboards at https://github.com/pnnl/EXPERT2. | [
0.0658331662,
0.0436226502,
0.0165919159,
0.0028018812,
-0.0307396278,
-0.0192477293,
-0.0291270018,
-0.0069932882,
-0.0005824424,
-0.051659707,
-0.0289863423,
-0.0108989095,
0.010857515,
0.0264255125,
-0.0044793966,
-0.026343815,
0.0638596117,
-0.0141825574,
0.0816951394,
0.0123618292,
0.0002318916,
-0.0066762827,
-0.0016799242,
0.0248666834,
0.0103477547,
-0.0084941136,
0.050299596,
0.0143503146,
0.0348272137,
-0.0867630616,
0.035371691,
0.0592185408,
0.0234727804,
0.0525094531,
0.0000017852,
-0.0616135038,
-0.0355530754,
0.0473937355,
-0.0446350537,
0.014937371,
0.0650612861,
0.0401869006,
0.00320003,
0.0175755024,
-0.0374320261,
0.0062521445,
0.0286378395,
0.0229849573,
0.0064705005,
0.0291078258,
0.0064047785,
0.0109727969,
0.0358191021,
0.0225286856,
0.0191075467,
-0.014345957,
0.0172681101,
0.0396128558,
0.0202031415,
0.10478618,
0.0415781513,
0.0648544729,
-0.0079003703,
-0.0184964128,
0.0157844834,
0.024788361,
-0.0329179913,
-0.056385193,
-0.014491275,
0.0123145776,
0.0548664667,
-0.0405992977,
-0.0245684721,
-0.0089660604,
-0.0027512249,
0.0630303621,
-0.045459751,
0.0286845993,
-0.015128714,
-0.0177695975,
-0.0217371248,
0.0448486172,
0.0360639133,
0.0322710983,
0.0418839492,
0.108152017,
0.0016265734,
-0.04546367,
0.026222311,
-0.0060429377,
0.0252719838,
-0.0352493189,
0.0266212597,
0.0185598005,
0.0034190649,
0.0388239548,
-0.005154382,
-0.0216467287,
0.0775508732,
-0.0206285361,
-0.0002115128,
-0.0051231198,
-0.0019320279,
0.0181647427,
0.014365159,
0.0286520291,
0.0126189943,
-0.0136307478,
0.0207259879,
0.0059746513,
-0.0430782661,
-0.0576313809,
0.0013734257,
-0.0208336059,
-0.002562609,
0.0173172485,
-0.0557236671,
-0.0211448595,
0.0007440904,
0.0195746273,
-0.0037902333,
0.0293059051,
-0.0396385677,
-0.0056185867,
-0.0571613126,
0.0312766396,
0.0178499538,
0.0285383593,
0.0240804292,
-0.0888923183,
0.0107244011,
0.0080960914,
-0.0190275945,
-0.0130591476,
0.0018639017,
0.0383869745,
0.0375094973,
-0.0379539616,
-0.0145362336,
-0.0638396814,
-0.0271027647,
-0.0407067649,
-0.0015006508,
-0.0617651269,
-0.012836895,
0.0260084141,
-0.0042298441,
-0.0395067818,
0.0063030422,
0.029435385,
-0.0342352688,
0.0433906391,
-0.0921118855,
0.0002279043,
0.0329824537,
0.0186806135,
-0.0168129578,
0.010608878,
0.0314547233,
0.0062572453,
0.052138146,
0.0021884681,
0.010259768,
-0.0564063415,
0.0124223661,
-0.0197583381,
-0.0035172238,
0.033206515,
-0.0556547157,
0.0033519119,
-0.0387327448,
0.0700049549,
-0.0414299816,
0.0105664227,
0.047565639,
0.035446763,
0.0134330569,
-0.0269968361,
0.0039898111,
0.0060810982,
0.0526530519,
-0.0175225064,
-0.0411497578,
0.0364067964,
-0.0510227419,
0.0229051132,
0.0220192187,
0.0339056328,
0.015638303,
-0.0783982873,
-0.0672421157,
-0.0008471473,
-0.0081123887,
-0.0108277909,
0.0293238945,
-0.006038723,
-0.0198388472,
-0.017660128,
0.0101076039,
-0.0507798307,
0.0039083995,
-0.0208430178,
0.033083871,
0.0343978256,
0.0538079143,
-0.0308734737,
-0.0425212681,
-0.008150884,
-0.041844327,
-0.0047423108,
0.0342487209,
0.0079803932,
-0.0298248231,
-0.026291579,
-0.0565013513,
-0.0207638182,
0.0058653508,
-0.0288732983,
0.0687260255,
0.0379470587,
0.0140491379,
-0.0482502021,
-0.0654648095,
0.0302449148,
-0.0298097637,
-0.0154119898,
-0.0400704779,
-0.0428828187,
0.0360766798,
0.0163167268,
-0.0205716062,
0.0716006011,
0.0690166578,
0.0462426879,
-0.0626670048,
0.0118918205,
0.0115997456,
0.0332578197,
0.0372794308,
-0.0221084356,
0.0003285089,
0.0019521302,
0.0027396078,
-0.0115385773,
-0.0166634992,
-0.0202499777,
-0.0131502803,
-0.0318752453,
-0.0076139728,
-0.0109766219,
-0.0049427333,
-0.0608646125,
0.0268672351,
0.0100499401,
0.0400516614,
0.0013996207,
-0.0021328372,
0.0284041129,
-0.0205149148,
-0.0309263598,
-0.0171256922,
-0.0052765864,
0.0280188005,
0.0899869204,
-0.0291701723,
-0.0508706905,
-0.0052106963,
-0.0411608778,
-0.0045340224,
0.0173976589,
0.0157525036,
-0.0038828265,
-0.0365198292,
-0.021100238,
0.0067601725,
0.0119082341,
-0.0137278661,
0.0082542496,
0.0188189391,
0.0517800637,
-0.0060063801,
0.0364458896,
-0.0560913868,
-0.0208058283,
-0.0158640835,
0.0480693653,
0.0714673251,
-0.015711097,
-0.0795016438,
0.0548335947,
-0.0366316065,
-0.0181339122,
0.0026726697,
-0.0134390658,
0.039265994,
0.0093258992,
-0.0216437075,
0.0142544368,
0.0320411362,
-0.0145236505,
0.056549266,
-0.0234584641,
-0.0617262796,
0.0039712982,
-0.0285317432,
-0.0409408659,
0.0212411303,
0.0018242125,
0.0460841134,
0.0027956781,
-0.0283532739,
-0.0261399858,
-0.0015801241,
0.0323501788,
-0.0279205982,
-0.0335387327,
0.0114358058,
-0.0342814103,
0.0036314777,
0.0891082436,
0.0117625864,
-0.0736701414,
0.073382847,
-0.0426335968,
0.0137114292,
-0.0695049688,
0.0049527241,
0.01676438,
0.007221458,
-0.0099022966,
0.0103791179,
0.0347198583,
0.0384532176,
-0.0093743708,
-0.0179314036,
0.0134946248,
-0.0414804816,
-0.0265739486,
-0.0405955277,
0.002111959,
0.0254472792,
0.0127501143,
-0.0337094776,
-0.0078456728,
-0.0258944016,
0.0130039593,
0.0139050111,
-0.0535588413,
-0.0411511548,
-0.0174163226,
0.0782301426,
-0.0078912517,
-0.0357553661,
-0.0394632332,
-0.0074493773,
-0.0217953455,
0.0440568551,
-0.0154253701,
0.1060572341,
-0.0119180288,
-0.0280547924,
0.0770893693,
0.0122902943,
0.005327533,
-0.0461582206,
-0.0604065657,
0.0336873345,
-0.0227548294,
-0.0159856416,
0.0499041118,
0.0588268079,
-0.0501314811,
-0.0105825951,
0.0881489888,
0.0302128308,
0.0042092586,
-0.0313826315,
-0.0390108451,
0.0279732719,
0.0215943959,
0.0050828154,
-0.0514255166,
0.0014871466,
0.000122558,
0.0304303169,
-0.0142027698,
-0.0207149331,
-0.0068329405,
-0.0786764547,
0.0597386286,
0.0092693381,
-0.0278904811,
-0.0294329301,
-0.1140339971,
0.0014047961,
0.0070806504,
0.0193175878,
0.0362842344,
-0.0167596843,
0.0047244825,
0.0282350555,
-0.033958789,
-0.0941125154,
0.0219958015,
-0.052201245,
0.0406141728,
0.0506978557,
0.0070049227,
-0.0314660333,
-0.0458505899,
-0.0245991461,
-0.0022253038,
0.0077257538,
-0.002635889,
0.020603789,
-0.0016694673,
0.0417644568,
-0.03770224,
-0.000618847,
-0.0201593414,
-0.0306440089,
-0.0216258261,
0.0686331615,
-0.0219170395,
-0.013105277,
-0.0876627639,
-0.0132922418,
0.0029266179,
0.0839387178,
-0.0233422108,
0.0282281525,
-0.0365846343,
-0.0087329149,
0.0481876992,
0.0280220211,
-0.0138498833,
0.0436545908,
-0.0287476983,
-0.0096467314,
-0.0669972301,
-0.0182150863,
-0.0113603864,
-0.0061082542,
-0.0062044607,
0.001393182,
0.0495657586,
0.0036806853,
-0.0523909405,
0.0462584868,
-0.0134770088,
0.0363821201,
-0.0276143886,
0.0609041415,
0.0639007837,
0.0179951638,
-0.0092729479,
0.0138861686,
-0.0062969057,
-0.0671660379,
-0.0178104695,
0.0590872951,
0.0315669365,
-0.0201596655,
0.0042969501,
-0.0708663538,
0.0526720993,
0.0329176076,
-0.0539457276,
-0.031306833,
0.003032529,
0.0167586561,
-0.0144364545,
-0.0275607668,
-0.0462054871,
0.0023335302,
-0.0267118178,
0.0211425219,
-0.0116713392,
-0.083686173,
0.0232798271,
0.0674245134,
0.0988831222,
-0.0084460955,
0.0269601718,
-0.0031537616,
-0.0335859135,
-0.0349245444,
-0.0195515733,
-0.0228639655,
0.0512279011,
0.0033989749,
-0.0032794976,
0.0073862979,
-0.0023345684,
-0.0317051522,
0.057435099,
-0.0159492716,
-0.0087269805,
0.034017019,
0.0082027009,
0.0303523876,
-0.0216764584,
-0.0388127491,
-0.0230153743,
-0.0600111037,
0.0182967056,
0.0156292617,
0.0055531855,
0.0145723158,
-0.0178232789,
0.0032299296,
0.0017241442,
-0.1154092848,
-0.0451859236,
-0.0295678768,
0.004143646,
-0.0097241234,
0.0328129195,
0.0532394908,
-0.0797799304,
-0.011011553,
-0.052463267,
0.0092155924,
0.028650701,
0.0176809821,
0.0880582035,
0.0071151177,
-0.0434892885,
-0.0124709923,
0.0518048145,
0.003590903,
0.0284178667,
-0.0531891659,
-0.0984755605,
-0.0096059022,
-0.0308466498,
-0.0346869342,
0.010162293,
-0.0303715765,
-0.01774868,
-0.0502703302,
-0.047620412,
0.0532558784,
0.0394978449,
0.0064870282,
-0.0412978828,
0.0052439189,
0.0847010612,
0.0040007657,
-0.0261924975,
-0.0089529017,
-0.0022227052,
-0.0250380225,
-0.0022595148,
-0.0488942489,
-6.001725548e-33,
0.0125274351,
-0.054097157,
-0.0083815781,
-0.0277592856,
0.0188981853,
0.0362065993,
-0.0057565249,
0.0030642394,
-0.0348595232,
0.0387905166,
0.0069945776,
0.005727116,
0.0118379714,
-0.0160871968,
0.0215040445,
0.0323766395,
0.0175804682,
0.0052495012,
-0.0309342276,
-0.0168796256,
0.0525121205,
0.0110478625,
0.0545755066,
-0.1098240912,
0.0868405923,
-0.0021088931,
0.0034580743,
0.0187044609,
-0.0479891934,
0.0468039326,
-0.0076264525,
0.0268515535,
-0.0064098155,
-0.04598983,
-0.0177379269,
-0.001031352,
-0.049130518,
-0.0322698615,
0.0107618887,
-0.0312260985,
-0.0620588362,
0.0144767473,
0.0393572114,
-0.0042262711,
-0.0499366708,
-0.005481916,
0.0418367498,
-0.0120743755,
-0.0278899483,
-0.0851975307,
-0.0186559241,
0.0401346534,
0.0245329067,
0.0236056931,
-0.0046446486,
0.0702961907,
-0.0009340972,
0.0417619385,
-0.0359139927,
0.0033861438,
0.0083698975,
0.0166572649,
0.0504511409,
-0.0282074232,
0.0010472347,
0.0591167323,
-0.0188763328,
-0.0048544202,
-0.0043205419,
-0.0148679214,
0.0201020669,
0.0323034227,
0.0516259335,
0.0906651467,
0.0295353308,
-0.0069925315,
-0.0604098514,
0.0363874845,
-0.0212869029,
0.082704626,
0.0392108858,
0.0276451092,
-0.0304461662,
-0.0070759268,
-0.0396551192,
0.0043328474,
-0.0118801696,
-0.0256204046,
0.0026606089,
-0.0055823643,
-0.0317244679,
0.0292756427,
-0.0071857525,
-0.0118142795,
-0.0286090188,
0.0299876723,
-0.0115827387,
0.0066003036,
-0.0054652113,
0.0551980101,
-0.050597772,
0.0316675194,
0.0144282021,
-0.0005223442,
-0.0039943312,
0.0187584814,
0.0024085687,
0.015552449,
-0.0519240275,
0.011697554,
-0.0068821255,
-0.0002374781,
0.0242994074,
-0.0204466805,
0.0360730104,
0.0258290879,
-0.0000169575,
0.0407190286,
0.0240890048,
0.0456354283,
-0.0140944421,
0.0000643686,
0.0039195223,
-0.0039567095,
-0.0000819356,
-0.0219308101,
-0.0145314252,
0.0064412286,
-0.0103838025,
-0.0193993226,
0.0145676425,
0.0057153041,
2.699e-7,
0.0752729997,
0.0629405677,
0.0350263044,
-0.0043885536,
0.0242305808,
0.0301601309,
-0.0145391002,
-0.0167311952,
0.0484088734,
-0.0397989079,
-0.0294268802,
-0.0174986329,
0.0127237691,
0.066883266,
-0.0178700164,
-0.082957238,
-0.0760886148,
-0.0245920271,
-0.0144493449,
0.0040979236,
0.0648407117,
0.0242807809,
-0.0026828763,
-0.0053952965,
-0.0388703384,
-0.0415497869,
0.0638618618,
-0.0217830446,
0.0038851562,
0.0545469671,
0.0834365338,
0.024357304,
0.0318419896,
0.0133569716,
-0.0080351615,
-0.0236629955,
-0.0260626283,
0.0259787068,
0.0038410365,
-0.0015754084,
0.0357627012,
-0.0164895877,
0.0184685793,
-0.0660750419,
0.0211649276,
-0.0633680299,
-0.0184604675,
-0.0366041027,
-0.0326752551,
-0.0227629803,
0.0613941662,
-0.0330860354,
-0.0124738961,
0.0100448299,
-0.0427521914,
0.0596402772,
-0.0509223156,
-0.0470004268,
-0.0390435979,
0.0119740004,
-0.0162203312,
-0.0610618778,
-0.0073177698,
-0.0173150636,
-0.0133311981,
-0.084439978,
0.0247588158,
2.368582776e-34,
0.050087411,
-0.0040112329,
-0.0102323908,
-0.0127704833,
0.0468233265,
0.014053518,
0.0052448944,
0.0263835173,
-0.0023366788,
-0.0278943479,
-0.0021659762
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09356v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09356v1 | LePaRD: A Large-Scale Dataset of Judges Citing Precedents | 2023-11-15T20:33:27 | 2023-11-15T20:33:27 | Robert Mahari, Dominik Stammbach, Elliott Ash, Alex `Sandy' Pentland | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present the Legal Passage Retrieval Dataset LePaRD. LePaRD is a massive
collection of U.S. federal judicial citations to precedent in context. The
dataset aims to facilitate work on legal passage prediction, a challenging
practice-oriented legal retrieval and reasoning task. Legal passage prediction
seeks to predict relevant passages from precedential court decisions given the
context of a legal argument. We extensively evaluate various retrieval
approaches on LePaRD, and find that classification appears to work best.
However, we note that legal precedent prediction is a difficult task, and there
remains significant room for improvement. We hope that by publishing LePaRD, we
will encourage others to engage with a legal NLP task that promises to help
expand access to justice by reducing the burden associated with legal research.
A subset of the LePaRD dataset is freely available and the whole dataset will
be released upon publication. | [
0.0443900302,
0.0832455605,
-0.0105582522,
0.0238733422,
-0.0574275889,
-0.0077422266,
0.0170011427,
0.0368611626,
-0.0307917576,
-0.060528785,
0.0069868532,
-0.0122067863,
-0.0329950191,
-0.0218505785,
-0.0334769487,
-0.0765950233,
0.0243689455,
0.0308639165,
0.0736893937,
0.0315514021,
0.0172670316,
0.0183280744,
-0.0041153338,
0.0464246795,
-0.0214261953,
-0.028473258,
0.0236832891,
-0.0089611411,
-0.0041765971,
-0.0318102948,
0.0130458996,
0.0597294085,
0.0475194789,
-0.0065824706,
0.0000014856,
-0.0393562354,
0.0130069377,
-0.0287094377,
-0.0149807576,
-0.0146693392,
0.0167149864,
-0.0338674113,
0.0160830151,
-0.0148501629,
-0.0653785244,
-0.0135256164,
-0.0153906895,
0.015234042,
0.0119520947,
0.0766268596,
0.0200774316,
-0.0356048383,
0.0170060899,
-0.0403659381,
0.0371363349,
-0.0193674285,
0.0348182656,
0.0202276334,
0.0094076376,
-0.0040233624,
0.0443158746,
-0.0042368523,
0.0185832419,
-0.0159533657,
-0.020825332,
-0.000913637,
0.0033611315,
0.0257186424,
0.0072035976,
0.0575893819,
0.0943781659,
-0.0475056767,
0.026040474,
0.0174850896,
0.0264440253,
0.0293130018,
-0.0280549079,
0.0779991895,
-0.0382704698,
0.0034675822,
0.0103534507,
0.0390286297,
0.0023980699,
0.013528578,
-0.0003201814,
0.0297574848,
-0.0195339601,
-0.0365483463,
0.0187595785,
0.0002793894,
0.0309819784,
-0.020121837,
0.0398494676,
0.0048694671,
-0.0084143626,
0.0367782153,
-0.0071029318,
-0.0247752313,
0.0772175938,
-0.0205257442,
0.0162555315,
0.0200204607,
-0.0108001474,
0.062992774,
-0.0340147242,
-0.0281009506,
-0.0041313809,
-0.0140240379,
0.003576786,
-0.018753035,
-0.0568781905,
-0.0016043696,
-0.0420201384,
0.0394337848,
-0.1076124385,
0.0067643984,
0.0036365525,
-0.0190115012,
-0.0355668478,
0.0002735758,
0.0205567759,
0.0074062413,
-0.0007038446,
-0.00643192,
-0.0646918789,
-0.0515573211,
-0.0740054101,
0.0173380114,
-0.0159092564,
-0.0063889492,
0.000145141,
-0.0061346171,
-0.0089665232,
-0.0223305728,
0.0122205289,
0.0866513178,
-0.007899005,
-0.0280580074,
-0.0354745314,
-0.0910838619,
-0.0208995454,
-0.0467773154,
-0.0084706638,
-0.0574634038,
0.0184591617,
-0.0122149624,
-0.0044874991,
-0.0723524466,
0.0116434656,
0.0812949538,
-0.0038991608,
0.0373458154,
0.0179776996,
-0.0476070791,
-0.0173823964,
0.0457446277,
0.0019433714,
-0.0068293768,
-0.0292122047,
0.0166736264,
0.0254321303,
0.0238641109,
0.0045284205,
-0.024442371,
0.0336800143,
0.0275214128,
0.0114545133,
0.0543715693,
-0.0154464412,
0.0233771969,
-0.0022436141,
0.0355715342,
-0.0163643099,
-0.0667618141,
-0.0275792889,
0.0816157311,
-0.0020642334,
0.0579596423,
0.0104617737,
-0.0110336142,
0.0357974917,
-0.018013183,
-0.0334370583,
-0.0056134891,
-0.0122046312,
0.0083920537,
-0.0592213944,
-0.0065643205,
-0.0278972574,
-0.0415608883,
0.0181241017,
0.0336276144,
-0.0314803831,
0.0036569491,
0.0132493228,
0.007909283,
-0.0338021293,
0.0410124734,
0.03049355,
-0.0417576618,
-0.0455318168,
0.017237667,
-0.0112613449,
-0.0162882097,
0.059502393,
-0.0559634268,
-0.0029873741,
-0.0043576797,
0.0446555167,
0.0167645011,
0.005694381,
-0.0143137872,
-0.0257568732,
-0.0217990074,
-0.0354379825,
0.0344521627,
0.0401271358,
-0.0059068101,
0.0308039989,
0.0169708095,
0.0174905881,
-0.0475438051,
0.0205442291,
0.0549414344,
-0.011594451,
-0.035547208,
0.0284891091,
-0.0038814258,
0.03384367,
0.0211462993,
0.0098405397,
-0.0223644003,
0.0141886882,
-0.0162419137,
0.0229704287,
0.025433179,
-0.0513756126,
0.0173617098,
0.0589843057,
-0.0575333647,
-0.0246192981,
0.0026900889,
-0.0204517134,
-0.0175205749,
-0.019294966,
0.0115915528,
0.0243562814,
-0.0381114818,
-0.0331846103,
0.0142930048,
-0.0562130585,
-0.0445210822,
0.0550533459,
0.0095388815,
0.0109685343,
0.0185392369,
-0.0004541935,
0.0599531531,
-0.0111826286,
-0.0193537194,
-0.0428040586,
-0.0266946778,
0.0136624975,
0.0452096835,
-0.0295187775,
-0.0523354262,
0.0011570159,
-0.0352852233,
0.0386780612,
-0.0252525825,
0.0112858983,
-0.0146512259,
-0.0373195969,
0.0044563501,
-0.0411324836,
-0.004720286,
-0.0216213912,
-0.029711077,
-0.0175921172,
0.0352538154,
-0.0009444384,
0.0028236038,
-0.0253172554,
-0.0366268978,
-0.0318564698,
0.0533489026,
0.0019957789,
0.0204479303,
0.0097342236,
0.0428202376,
-0.0040202872,
0.0052909628,
-0.0433560461,
0.0135022281,
0.0015356636,
0.0009509537,
-0.038025558,
0.0277185366,
0.0498804748,
0.0131426398,
-0.0041715312,
0.0047021308,
-0.0605893694,
0.0105753448,
0.0111203399,
0.0232700501,
-0.0139570124,
0.0177825205,
0.0179486461,
-0.0165692288,
0.0311420951,
0.0025281035,
-0.0319358893,
0.0316757485,
-0.005624529,
0.0028867826,
-0.0191750769,
-0.0003921312,
-0.0085599888,
0.0519896559,
0.0025094808,
-0.0603905432,
0.0310768094,
0.0244848002,
0.0545518212,
-0.0463869683,
0.0159365628,
-0.0589022897,
0.1222791523,
-0.019274978,
-0.0029716585,
-0.0455492102,
-0.059636876,
0.0349472202,
-0.0166460853,
0.046815522,
-0.0467100404,
0.114279449,
-0.025473116,
0.043373242,
-0.0385356843,
-0.0689447224,
-0.0460237116,
-0.0324807055,
-0.0203965008,
0.0294138398,
0.0381687917,
0.0065113413,
-0.0534749106,
-0.017481545,
-0.010657371,
0.003806917,
0.0455738455,
-0.023432944,
-0.0198038798,
0.0201926362,
-0.0124249421,
-0.0457958318,
-0.0186536573,
0.0178530179,
-0.0295910593,
0.0334717967,
0.0279308651,
0.0127824368,
0.0010549439,
-0.0138991633,
0.011632002,
-0.1018228233,
0.0056379032,
0.0433327332,
0.0046992903,
-0.0636383891,
0.0259898808,
0.0703277662,
0.0465380102,
-0.0350025482,
-0.0396070294,
-0.0135381073,
0.0111257769,
0.025069112,
0.018941436,
-0.1462327838,
-0.0148224421,
-0.0049390518,
-0.0163059346,
-0.0254813191,
-0.0424290709,
-0.0054322844,
-0.0892795995,
0.0565710999,
0.0340473466,
0.028586721,
-0.0568411462,
-0.0490545556,
0.030245129,
-0.0212608408,
-0.0335673764,
0.0362116657,
-0.0641604364,
0.0121649401,
0.0009889811,
-0.0398241878,
0.0249100421,
0.0586634576,
-0.0364099815,
0.0281407107,
-0.0221024323,
0.039996475,
-0.0074705612,
-0.0147697404,
-0.0079228003,
-0.0953668877,
0.0042805439,
0.0007570296,
0.0496446043,
0.01410696,
0.022562094,
-0.0560909323,
0.0468562804,
-0.0369932093,
-0.0443213917,
0.06453114,
0.0302050114,
-0.06523785,
0.0027323207,
-0.0509011112,
0.0293552168,
-0.0099358317,
0.0628765747,
0.0045877108,
0.0538509451,
-0.0598759949,
-0.0142751383,
0.0101990821,
-0.0317583829,
-0.0265817717,
-0.0305617712,
0.0051270723,
0.0752421021,
-0.0313667506,
-0.0131653538,
-0.0160363559,
0.077170819,
0.0358660743,
0.0332217887,
0.0049981144,
0.0036806518,
-0.0620070919,
0.0264975484,
-0.066736728,
-0.0220373236,
0.0026424101,
0.0028922679,
0.0243875254,
0.0164511949,
-0.0093681095,
0.0269840229,
0.0200568214,
0.0081978804,
0.0050809556,
-0.0149841597,
0.0215268601,
0.0052172835,
-0.0165968481,
0.0011020139,
0.0704718456,
0.0299004354,
-0.0164634641,
-0.0356799066,
0.06973961,
-0.0489326864,
-0.035106495,
-0.0003356357,
0.025789747,
0.0227920245,
0.0045962161,
0.0142190196,
-0.0527544208,
-0.0095306858,
0.0089186905,
0.001320626,
0.0223726016,
0.0360683538,
-0.0220959038,
-0.0345258005,
-0.0169616248,
-0.0295103751,
-0.019091323,
0.0097315013,
0.0087029263,
-0.0042590881,
-0.0235594548,
-0.0460517853,
0.0434032343,
-0.0016403191,
0.0470611863,
-0.0385376886,
0.0457732677,
0.0609740354,
0.0043144873,
-0.0125744427,
-0.0260476023,
-0.0032965038,
0.0306601692,
-0.0453959703,
0.0736986697,
-0.0098233717,
0.0380020961,
0.025314277,
-0.0080318972,
-0.0228118375,
-0.0234421361,
-0.0690215379,
-0.0141109731,
-0.0040959436,
0.0131285833,
0.0581608638,
-0.0424874797,
-0.016464578,
-0.0109299049,
-0.0050093085,
-0.0001326736,
0.0217294134,
-0.0132827451,
0.0221795607,
0.0346864946,
0.0351907648,
-0.0326982029,
-0.0007184314,
0.0043394472,
-0.0354688056,
0.0545196123,
0.0307905208,
-0.0273659229,
-0.0187850837,
-0.0551884137,
-0.0105729271,
0.0414215028,
0.0133086722,
-0.0736679509,
-0.0806465745,
0.025934469,
0.0122245401,
0.0163531546,
-0.0028365783,
0.053586971,
0.0021908637,
0.0456016399,
0.041426409,
-0.0276984759,
-0.0502391011,
0.0215087533,
-0.0384533592,
-0.0079574995,
-0.0389160365,
-4.922014517e-33,
-0.008638504,
-0.0302693322,
0.0301766936,
0.0275822263,
-0.0254053492,
-0.0155907059,
-0.0104912166,
-0.0197749212,
-0.0491246879,
0.0433319807,
-0.0265709497,
0.0133802211,
0.0272300094,
0.0069929925,
0.0109409662,
-0.0136001389,
0.0092149824,
0.0226772912,
-0.0021988659,
0.0137791131,
0.0232047588,
0.0203011725,
0.0093363347,
-0.0859586969,
0.0217939988,
0.0496999286,
0.0183705632,
-0.0131615624,
-0.0439139679,
0.0421450995,
0.0009435065,
0.0467456579,
0.0265125763,
-0.0455571003,
0.0044988776,
0.0461136587,
-0.1026413739,
-0.0034101694,
0.0135332607,
-0.0522953905,
0.0039396402,
-0.0253228787,
0.0215711147,
0.0063262675,
-0.0080856569,
-0.0103726489,
0.0506217331,
-0.0461448431,
-0.0535118692,
-0.0707636103,
-0.0337174721,
0.0514990054,
-0.0113048218,
0.0372142345,
0.0122444592,
-0.0057914206,
0.0279164501,
0.0199867897,
-0.0861491188,
-0.0041181929,
-0.0540160909,
-0.0021137914,
-0.0350218751,
-0.0780610517,
-0.0039279391,
0.0693109334,
0.0004158675,
-0.0097809257,
-0.0254462082,
-0.0297995843,
0.0075332047,
0.0563120246,
0.0064869164,
0.0697261691,
0.0454717614,
-0.0527870059,
-0.0494913645,
-0.0389214829,
0.0587674752,
0.0443846434,
0.0016743563,
-0.035400413,
-0.0309539177,
0.0117318183,
-0.0511702374,
-0.0618416928,
0.0047051348,
0.0009567087,
0.0093013877,
0.0148865394,
0.0486901812,
0.016809335,
0.0258157738,
-0.0190495532,
0.0365185179,
0.0612855852,
0.0064718989,
-0.0113872802,
-0.0083370507,
0.0223245081,
-0.0504857041,
-0.0379639231,
0.0180012137,
-0.0201012976,
0.000182053,
-0.0356192701,
0.0434616953,
-0.0632606819,
-0.0671854615,
-0.025556691,
0.0142997103,
0.0264907107,
0.0182994809,
0.0180202704,
0.0310353898,
0.0675700679,
0.0489804,
0.0522270799,
0.0113776922,
-0.003335176,
-0.0406684987,
-0.0162876695,
0.0113516711,
-0.0389951579,
0.0172281899,
0.0161092356,
0.0156219797,
0.0612487197,
0.018211348,
0.0173353329,
0.0372509211,
0.0395659618,
2.227e-7,
0.0798245519,
0.0121431444,
0.0006157722,
0.0312593915,
-0.0266465265,
-0.0039230827,
0.0226519909,
0.0323892199,
0.0199163277,
-0.0543956123,
0.0422531627,
0.0083107548,
0.0257362276,
0.0444136225,
-0.0809914842,
-0.0584773235,
-0.0548666567,
-0.0616717227,
-0.0527683869,
0.001489596,
0.0569942109,
0.0794623643,
0.0184079427,
-0.0167342611,
-0.035239324,
-0.0147520816,
0.0408758074,
-0.0168777797,
-0.0158599112,
-0.0025276062,
0.098105453,
-0.0539928749,
0.0007736359,
0.0389898084,
-0.0019475025,
0.058472041,
-0.057735227,
0.0510152318,
0.0333425812,
0.0031371848,
-0.0093081817,
-0.0116666146,
0.0072965068,
-0.0032708745,
0.0376673602,
0.0043671373,
0.004441652,
-0.0006008285,
-0.0530382805,
0.0006567718,
0.0157789551,
0.0765697435,
-0.0116058392,
-0.0034638825,
0.0165191013,
0.0055891229,
0.0198308248,
-0.1223405898,
0.006511528,
0.0546774082,
-0.0186624657,
0.0473856516,
0.0358017161,
-0.0394677743,
0.0354178324,
-0.0861221328,
0.0243219938,
1.721269031e-34,
0.0306840632,
0.0128317699,
0.0180851426,
0.0118949683,
0.0497016013,
0.0118913772,
0.0211640541,
-0.0121302921,
-0.0017804472,
-0.0400103256,
0.0349817052
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09344v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09344v1 | Language and Task Arithmetic with Parameter-Efficient Layers for Zero-Shot Summarization | 2023-11-15T20:04:58 | 2023-11-15T20:04:58 | Alexandra Chronopoulou, Jonas Pfeiffer, Joshua Maynez, Xinyi Wang, Sebastian Ruder, Priyanka Agrawal | cs.CL | cs.CL | Parameter-efficient fine-tuning (PEFT) using labeled task data can
significantly improve the performance of large language models (LLMs) on the
downstream task. However, there are 7000 languages in the world and many of
these languages lack labeled data for real-world language generation tasks. In
this paper, we propose to improve zero-shot cross-lingual transfer by composing
language or task specialized parameters. Our method composes language and task
PEFT modules via element-wise arithmetic operations to leverage unlabeled data
and English labeled data. We extend our approach to cases where labeled data
from more languages is available and propose to arithmetically compose PEFT
modules trained on languages related to the target. Empirical results on
summarization demonstrate that our method is an effective strategy that obtains
consistent gains using minimal training of PEFT modules. | [
-0.0080903787,
0.0078997146,
0.0294553246,
0.0122781899,
0.0125281028,
0.0193988644,
0.0227775816,
-0.0372202732,
-0.0605496839,
-0.0532361679,
-0.0539553501,
-0.0316927843,
0.0312266313,
-0.0148874465,
0.0536669567,
-0.0510053039,
0.0122115137,
-0.0344338976,
-0.0409530103,
0.0003000876,
-0.0048875031,
0.0280455146,
0.0007772584,
0.0274863522,
0.0380352996,
0.0116825067,
-0.0103871319,
-0.0071111633,
0.0452475064,
-0.0003695066,
-0.0020486722,
0.0265660845,
0.0229072012,
0.0180787314,
0.0000017461,
-0.0199572053,
-0.0223802198,
-0.0265407655,
-0.0083966078,
-0.0026989693,
0.0591894872,
-0.0111928592,
-0.0026862069,
0.0192717146,
0.0072193672,
-0.0387229472,
0.0690857247,
0.0481905304,
0.0576606095,
0.0794508755,
-0.0114069851,
-0.0031105832,
-0.0177276116,
-0.0487758853,
0.0079319635,
-0.0345900431,
0.0056569688,
0.0099955965,
0.0066718524,
0.0047805249,
-0.0099737355,
0.0168816783,
0.0019998343,
0.0266087297,
-0.0098509481,
0.034432143,
-0.0399750769,
-0.0106437169,
0.0282119475,
0.0985558182,
-0.052450493,
-0.0029367737,
0.0235288963,
-0.0073779807,
-0.0256413147,
-0.0464391224,
-0.09025947,
0.0634191856,
0.0219198484,
0.0370315537,
0.0444356352,
0.0237790868,
0.0064576925,
0.019682087,
-0.0298026726,
0.0269808751,
0.0322421603,
0.0382543802,
-0.0310120508,
-0.0045373668,
-0.0333754048,
-0.0508091897,
-0.0365321077,
0.0405017063,
-0.0195498858,
-0.0043879729,
-0.0931579918,
-0.0592348501,
-0.0048303697,
-0.0124961222,
0.0667456836,
0.0425420851,
0.0062032333,
0.0349333473,
-0.0517310798,
0.0292155538,
0.0235947017,
0.0261273123,
-0.0873850435,
-0.039687369,
-0.0642175227,
0.0252164416,
-0.050090991,
0.0370616727,
-0.0561908633,
-0.0018088866,
-0.0501697026,
0.0147095677,
-0.011907951,
-0.0229060054,
0.0293413233,
-0.0032340344,
-0.0714936256,
-0.0272209588,
0.0342105962,
0.0645438284,
-0.0244792458,
0.009017162,
0.0186390076,
-0.0300771929,
-0.0291967653,
0.0235190187,
0.0462252721,
-0.0059101935,
0.0007950385,
0.0544854589,
-0.0449978933,
-0.0276501998,
-0.040611323,
-0.0457429588,
-0.0187544301,
-0.0855888352,
-0.0080637718,
-0.0818117931,
0.0167750083,
-0.0128072277,
-0.0033212544,
-0.0134644574,
-0.0028413611,
0.0129717719,
-0.0502411835,
0.033288952,
0.0057552867,
-0.0038978453,
0.0059490493,
-0.0026357628,
0.0192325208,
0.090321593,
0.0351066142,
0.0477744304,
0.0010202993,
0.0274491329,
-0.0247884504,
0.0347814634,
0.0183811095,
0.0507799834,
-0.015874207,
-0.0387016274,
0.0197931323,
-0.0202788357,
0.0444091372,
0.001916017,
-0.0445410162,
0.0505605638,
0.0551473573,
0.0137494486,
0.0161156952,
0.0146619137,
0.0726817921,
0.0052497233,
-0.0111494418,
0.0216475725,
-0.0196151752,
0.0587360002,
-0.0347551405,
0.0271509811,
0.0554166436,
0.04143494,
-0.0886585787,
-0.0111006964,
0.0165752284,
-0.0252004582,
0.0036294097,
0.0131889051,
0.0509035699,
0.0220424961,
-0.0470799357,
0.0752677396,
0.0322417766,
-0.0643192753,
0.0543091595,
-0.0226865485,
0.0066773547,
0.0364233665,
-0.0035271361,
-0.0136355385,
-0.0600027591,
-0.0051859631,
0.0577813238,
0.0191707686,
0.0128244199,
-0.020944465,
0.053807091,
-0.0568438657,
-0.0287177563,
-0.0451671891,
0.0087577105,
0.0067533413,
-0.0462214798,
0.0137295034,
0.073208645,
-0.0469466448,
-0.0409693457,
0.0054447339,
-0.061569944,
-0.0476296321,
0.0485090576,
0.0051024323,
-0.0238972921,
0.0077199191,
0.0178070627,
0.005743837,
-0.0169927292,
-0.0545475632,
0.0090991668,
-0.0008282039,
-0.0280054528,
-0.0412822478,
0.0144576076,
-0.0371679254,
0.0358854011,
0.0032121975,
-0.0516673289,
-0.0875981301,
0.0461695567,
-0.0115420297,
-0.0291398074,
-0.0458060838,
0.013404401,
0.0154331923,
0.0175115708,
-0.0228751693,
0.0300962869,
0.0410582274,
-0.0046622949,
0.0398015417,
-0.0071175122,
0.0151606044,
-0.0178054422,
-0.0138650369,
0.0085956603,
0.0084733991,
0.0256287679,
0.0442047715,
0.0334571935,
-0.0202911664,
-0.0032965529,
-0.1034602001,
0.0382301025,
-0.0224802364,
0.0383762345,
0.0398537666,
0.0331371762,
0.0204951875,
0.0084627653,
-0.0704139099,
0.023810789,
0.041404862,
0.0036580556,
0.0076035601,
0.0107255299,
0.0162660629,
-0.0367123373,
0.0043261014,
0.0354472697,
0.0353976488,
-0.0243865028,
0.0082881087,
-0.0527439341,
0.0518509559,
-0.0492922515,
0.0062343199,
0.0153657151,
-0.0260171872,
-0.0193653796,
-0.016890604,
0.0413367637,
-0.0067146164,
-0.027575314,
-0.0152889118,
0.0500759892,
-0.0259745978,
-0.0208877902,
0.0027500831,
-0.0228488985,
-0.0231549479,
-0.0034346979,
-0.00896837,
-0.022114398,
0.0774528384,
-0.0216791034,
-0.0314154923,
-0.0724834502,
0.0220573042,
-0.0123539967,
-0.0003448151,
-0.0288824998,
0.0237131584,
0.0052443389,
0.0154147474,
-0.028728975,
-0.0102984169,
0.0267894585,
-0.0509923138,
-0.0126942508,
-0.0374861956,
-0.0158512853,
-0.0403031632,
0.018307656,
0.0128773116,
0.0477766544,
0.0337403864,
0.0014976334,
-0.073669292,
-0.0041115526,
0.0260954667,
-0.0158667155,
0.0605544113,
-0.0440317169,
0.0150757954,
-0.0536305793,
-0.0140793789,
-0.0306097548,
-0.0084001198,
-0.0064240443,
0.0647148862,
-0.0083444687,
-0.0063530141,
-0.0252192914,
0.0101214284,
0.0451317355,
0.0624316074,
-0.0419662967,
0.001666235,
-0.0266999826,
0.0335291587,
0.0621510893,
0.0181023963,
-0.0010710749,
-0.0538164787,
0.010557224,
0.0053035459,
0.0620962717,
0.0433449298,
-0.0124732982,
-0.0011798602,
0.0246563423,
-0.0127160577,
-0.0092579238,
0.0140534947,
0.0608419813,
-0.0353033803,
0.0066661052,
0.0920610502,
0.0070322026,
-0.0366810635,
0.0082443208,
0.0132753756,
0.0099564595,
0.0172708202,
0.0372082852,
-0.0674685314,
-0.0362767726,
0.0066918256,
-0.0023471133,
-0.0052526197,
-0.027523838,
-0.0409329906,
-0.129434526,
0.0055713756,
0.0509676114,
-0.0631021634,
-0.0303617101,
-0.0184222423,
0.0084009375,
-0.0084781982,
0.0105073946,
-0.0102783153,
-0.0198592395,
0.0054495977,
0.0302431583,
0.0076686074,
-0.0717054978,
0.0004059221,
-0.0334088244,
0.0446158536,
0.0147521431,
0.0097961687,
-0.0113062374,
0.0159931183,
0.0023380506,
-0.0331476107,
-0.0285821389,
-0.0032979019,
0.0341880471,
0.0084556425,
-0.0221749786,
0.0487206504,
0.0272649638,
-0.0220903158,
0.0103394371,
-0.0145890582,
0.0602419525,
0.0099438103,
0.0234516524,
0.0154558141,
0.0120485285,
0.0111029372,
0.0521374606,
0.0419694856,
-0.0067635579,
0.0018508695,
-0.0089632804,
-0.0531583428,
-0.0881534219,
0.0008478339,
0.0161586106,
-0.0731202886,
-0.0399604626,
-0.079816848,
-0.0519711189,
0.0650514141,
0.0568434,
-0.015023483,
-0.0031275004,
-0.0101956911,
0.0013808068,
-0.0408355109,
-0.0103460029,
-0.0528697446,
0.0222629216,
-0.0200685114,
-0.0037941302,
0.0321886502,
-0.0540379696,
0.0163488463,
0.0173419081,
-0.1128939986,
-0.0770308748,
-0.046990063,
0.0629425645,
0.0104428139,
0.0326506868,
0.0156797916,
-0.062114954,
0.0599231943,
0.0117324321,
-0.0202692281,
0.0226812661,
0.0377636887,
-0.0004838707,
-0.0105468305,
0.0573678017,
-0.077740185,
0.0542232618,
0.0223396868,
0.0449496731,
-0.0151045639,
-0.0391080454,
0.0104189916,
0.0117474888,
0.0043018465,
-0.0519030131,
0.0147000821,
-0.0152004119,
-0.0140097532,
-0.0384419374,
-0.0133599555,
-0.0575264357,
-0.0147362696,
-0.0120453201,
-0.0025494534,
0.011569716,
0.053875424,
-0.0067021935,
0.0446772575,
0.0010883404,
-0.0031655224,
-0.0537845455,
-0.0145803876,
-0.01642262,
0.0291730948,
-0.0359478481,
-0.012671262,
0.0168319605,
0.0009472279,
-0.0486824624,
0.0211159606,
0.0097157145,
0.0345643647,
-0.0557844378,
0.0318258107,
-0.0221352614,
-0.0498782806,
-0.0328120887,
0.0024454198,
0.0755227134,
-0.0185560025,
0.0856418163,
0.0033843992,
-0.0101663033,
-0.0440520532,
0.0445858166,
-0.0219310969,
0.00334615,
-0.0169142149,
0.0113989338,
0.0132653425,
-0.008637704,
0.1101127416,
0.0230877679,
0.0063473089,
-0.0182471946,
0.0245069899,
-0.0125578828,
-0.0165137574,
0.0101831164,
-0.0110951541,
-0.0049084988,
-0.0031568331,
-0.016249422,
-0.0589291677,
0.0052376119,
-0.0374429971,
-0.0041817683,
-0.0263291243,
0.0503925569,
0.0093264217,
-0.0332526378,
0.022991199,
-0.0494333841,
-0.0403770767,
0.0325898379,
0.003965287,
0.0122429393,
-5.819499679e-33,
-0.0454651192,
0.013734933,
0.0373114534,
0.018475743,
-0.0340708606,
0.0173007566,
-0.0518344976,
0.0095820455,
0.0325009488,
-0.0093743624,
0.0144560784,
-0.0251992457,
0.0256668534,
0.0375962667,
-0.0039853519,
0.0090740323,
0.0803411677,
0.0000950296,
-0.0054627052,
0.0780643895,
0.0421770513,
0.0201416574,
0.0910591111,
-0.0090723699,
-0.0100856181,
0.0019184402,
-0.0137845892,
-0.0015774077,
0.0831461027,
0.0207841415,
0.0098514771,
0.0412309542,
0.0225725994,
-0.0719658583,
-0.0621626601,
-0.0117979208,
-0.0533283688,
-0.0269645397,
0.0220789779,
-0.0244563259,
-0.0420897789,
-0.0468393229,
0.0270413347,
-0.015275945,
0.0226279031,
-0.0464445278,
0.0240222421,
-0.0473647267,
-0.0217789449,
-0.0350316614,
-0.0809036344,
0.0114549017,
0.0018441057,
-0.0361062884,
0.0679040998,
0.0743660852,
-0.0255374461,
-0.0193852987,
-0.0319017246,
0.0165418759,
0.0136222569,
0.0617493019,
0.0652865097,
0.052418936,
-0.0199944787,
0.03454585,
0.0140978824,
0.0124554839,
-0.0125663085,
0.0389076024,
0.0421179272,
0.0376862325,
0.0046100905,
0.0548186935,
0.0330046043,
0.0225100797,
-0.0659963563,
0.0637204945,
-0.0104109226,
0.0013853053,
0.0033750618,
-0.0117121255,
0.031093929,
-0.0322584063,
-0.039549388,
0.0098969946,
-0.0297042802,
-0.0191612542,
-0.0049068383,
0.0462301746,
-0.036447119,
-0.0227441974,
0.0838269442,
-0.0219433196,
0.0209888294,
0.019828964,
-0.0267927423,
0.0287209731,
0.0055064387,
-0.0011019022,
-0.0490292907,
-0.0567264184,
0.0254127607,
-0.005746325,
0.0081722355,
0.0154753588,
0.0531041771,
0.0474130511,
-0.0260033049,
0.0057168016,
-0.0464655794,
0.0190850627,
-0.0159885064,
0.1014222354,
-0.0140506392,
0.003525249,
-0.0139551377,
0.0361232795,
-0.0263394769,
-0.0417496674,
0.0307214372,
-0.0131425774,
0.0252722129,
0.0487904549,
-0.0312439539,
0.013770286,
-0.0253267568,
-0.0113621727,
0.0467568859,
-0.0350342281,
-0.0269439314,
-0.0047756275,
2.5e-7,
0.0114565445,
0.0046279365,
-0.0088931993,
0.007472727,
-0.0128825912,
0.0452129804,
-0.012059723,
0.0570149459,
0.0134757664,
0.0181348864,
0.0290014148,
0.0310731977,
0.0625169203,
0.0263058823,
-0.0801914185,
0.0077971453,
-0.0064388635,
0.0275166519,
-0.00733724,
-0.0182020385,
0.0138125913,
0.0685537979,
-0.0022517683,
-0.0103423307,
0.024676973,
-0.0011278446,
0.0750370547,
0.0023856652,
-0.0430915728,
0.0296137035,
0.0128457984,
0.0414313935,
-0.0339308307,
-0.0092966277,
-0.0266704727,
0.0065338705,
0.0315193869,
0.0558328889,
0.0016405159,
0.0019305479,
0.0174599569,
-0.0086506438,
0.0009778867,
0.0100826183,
0.0581577681,
-0.0967719927,
0.0005926259,
-0.0222872999,
-0.0133294547,
0.0684168488,
-0.026671147,
-0.0327599719,
-0.0397692062,
0.035232909,
0.0378835499,
-0.0120821269,
-0.0208407622,
-0.0353824347,
-0.0271031782,
0.0372970439,
-0.0209519304,
-0.0294201132,
-0.0128607117,
-0.040771123,
-0.0000215349,
-0.0655781031,
0.0144270444,
2.318734698e-34,
0.0292703342,
-0.0274392627,
-0.0115164733,
-0.0322276317,
-0.0045848754,
-0.0309365503,
-0.0537917502,
0.0119623896,
0.0103254383,
-0.0500853844,
-0.043011032
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09336v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09336v3 | LLMRefine: Pinpointing and Refining Large Language Models via Fine-Grained Actionable Feedback | 2023-11-15T19:52:11 | 2024-04-02T16:39:13 | Wenda Xu, Daniel Deutsch, Mara Finkelstein, Juraj Juraska, Biao Zhang, Zhongtao Liu, William Yang Wang, Lei Li, Markus Freitag | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent large language models (LLM) are leveraging human feedback to improve
their generation quality. However, human feedback is costly to obtain,
especially during inference. In this work, we propose LLMRefine, an inference
time optimization method to refine LLM's output. The core idea is to use a
learned fine-grained feedback model to pinpoint defects and guide LLM to refine
them iteratively. Using original LLM as a proposal of edits, LLMRefine searches
for defect-less text via simulated annealing, trading off the exploration and
exploitation. We conduct experiments on three text generation tasks, including
machine translation, long-form question answering (QA), and topical
summarization. LLMRefine consistently outperforms all baseline approaches,
achieving improvements up to 1.7 MetricX points on translation tasks, 8.1
ROUGE-L on ASQA, 2.2 ROUGE-L on topical summarization. | [
0.0685323328,
0.0453123637,
0.0232534129,
0.0395715535,
-0.0163961947,
0.0076858392,
-0.057256218,
-0.006522967,
-0.0025614696,
-0.0407473482,
-0.0263512898,
-0.0350018889,
-0.0113085788,
0.0043888362,
0.0735697523,
-0.0184085537,
0.0205363892,
-0.0540020727,
-0.0045141163,
-0.0190128498,
0.0120412828,
0.0122712543,
0.0188815091,
0.0272443276,
0.0279730763,
-0.0160396844,
-0.0116882809,
-0.0001035113,
0.0206081625,
0.0097944345,
0.0289359167,
0.055641856,
-0.0060504396,
0.0414675251,
0.0000021094,
-0.0208573602,
-0.0217495132,
0.0017893004,
0.0072640004,
0.0523826368,
0.0548757426,
-0.0311541967,
0.0034272433,
0.0523762889,
-0.0195632782,
0.0213500671,
0.0222055819,
0.0325595737,
0.0824473128,
0.0744628236,
0.0131925819,
0.0015789273,
0.0139517123,
-0.0391937457,
0.0257268827,
-0.0715531781,
0.0001722474,
0.0243189204,
0.0524812974,
0.0293014217,
0.0062874029,
0.0344230346,
0.0270209815,
-0.0375549272,
0.0064745285,
0.0337873995,
-0.01853076,
-0.0113168424,
0.002825486,
0.075649254,
-0.0107810553,
-0.0353551917,
-0.004533554,
0.0024380793,
0.007073564,
-0.0349059105,
-0.0309159942,
0.050672166,
-0.0210181028,
0.02382222,
0.0330658257,
-0.0551091321,
0.0208226275,
0.0410704426,
-0.0314756781,
0.0157651305,
0.0328695141,
-0.0300799701,
-0.024827648,
0.001716109,
-0.0705517232,
-0.046326451,
0.0082993694,
0.0465174429,
-0.069221653,
-0.0068971454,
-0.0848022476,
-0.0042970828,
0.0229967628,
-0.0238353349,
0.017066475,
0.0115819294,
0.013614689,
0.0444859825,
-0.023787031,
0.0305735935,
-0.0174296089,
-0.0079997145,
-0.0844866261,
-0.0130153624,
-0.0137878479,
-0.0197560228,
-0.0309150908,
0.0047747768,
-0.0338609777,
-0.0173827372,
-0.0118768914,
0.0326750763,
0.0121532977,
0.0011760449,
0.0090183262,
0.0017761703,
-0.038056802,
-0.0110900206,
-0.0303095262,
0.0162791368,
-0.0424278714,
-0.0109920558,
0.0168407913,
-0.0384179316,
-0.0262269769,
0.0308588073,
-0.0019959514,
-0.021320818,
0.0149299921,
0.0518264249,
-0.0491627306,
-0.0145221232,
-0.0376555212,
-0.0234226398,
-0.0166732706,
-0.0487987995,
-0.0007617488,
-0.0748376846,
0.0107856393,
-0.0117588062,
-0.0259809718,
-0.016021464,
0.0360766575,
0.0304423478,
-0.0434412695,
0.0403106697,
-0.0333476439,
0.0318024792,
0.0339692272,
-0.0012073468,
0.0422601253,
0.0702281743,
0.0384209752,
0.0530889444,
0.0309657902,
0.0098364884,
0.0236418638,
0.0381623469,
0.0293490496,
0.0385244414,
0.00890359,
0.0022926943,
-0.0263040196,
0.0376678295,
0.0457548164,
0.0650792718,
-0.0329905115,
0.0120770438,
0.0599037334,
-0.0062060691,
0.0044898083,
0.0309387781,
0.0262145344,
0.0190173816,
-0.0010828311,
0.0053280299,
-0.0285690818,
0.0235062335,
-0.0561689176,
0.0253869873,
0.0725080445,
0.0011762563,
-0.0367246456,
-0.0556627363,
-0.0236762781,
0.0096461494,
0.0025698843,
0.006707849,
0.0314129181,
0.0463362411,
-0.0713499114,
0.0297523383,
0.0182011817,
-0.0312328376,
0.0080410009,
-0.0672341958,
0.0683159679,
0.091502212,
0.0535779707,
-0.0080718659,
-0.059003152,
-0.0045508882,
0.0007724965,
0.0589684211,
0.0291214623,
-0.0189252924,
0.0000605607,
-0.0430664197,
0.0087898644,
-0.02751882,
0.0223620534,
-0.0018601954,
0.0190426335,
-0.028550908,
0.0306666605,
-0.0540199839,
-0.0408006124,
0.0400275439,
-0.0133367032,
-0.0189548079,
0.0142813232,
-0.008669978,
0.00707873,
-0.0168728922,
-0.0104187028,
0.0230560582,
0.0261329357,
-0.0505647697,
-0.0299199913,
-0.0026145759,
0.0063799596,
-0.0620093867,
0.0154811898,
-0.0508640483,
-0.0225187242,
0.022881804,
-0.0528628677,
-0.0199739896,
-0.000227548,
-0.0552312844,
-0.0168632139,
-0.0466927625,
0.0296307094,
0.0060886377,
-0.0070991004,
-0.0529264137,
0.0737933144,
-0.0091349874,
0.013035872,
0.0228212308,
0.0312832631,
-0.0150605412,
-0.0524941832,
-0.0145739587,
-0.0092603974,
-0.0094678709,
0.020948654,
0.0413953625,
0.0794258788,
-0.0241933595,
-0.0722215399,
-0.0966477841,
0.0198989306,
-0.0263167545,
0.0399966724,
0.0553551577,
0.0119363992,
-0.0105264327,
0.0069438564,
-0.0285841506,
-0.0375281312,
0.0367056988,
0.0133650918,
0.0461075269,
-0.0056073768,
0.0127274077,
-0.0528624281,
0.0015756792,
0.0078067505,
0.0348634757,
0.0005567479,
0.0298315585,
-0.0999184623,
0.0388441086,
-0.0123686157,
-0.011178405,
0.0176898483,
-0.0496104769,
-0.0018485831,
-0.0037082173,
0.0639476851,
0.0694073886,
0.031002013,
0.0313238427,
0.0084526213,
0.0283575337,
-0.0312514976,
0.0110856127,
-0.0151158543,
-0.0230886117,
0.0086939437,
-0.0641637966,
0.0357251838,
0.0812960416,
-0.0070694298,
-0.0056808544,
-0.04827784,
0.0688190088,
-0.0263059735,
-0.0342975296,
-0.0206950791,
0.0113242222,
0.0063026096,
0.0239675138,
-0.0540339462,
-0.0305936504,
0.0752450451,
-0.0256048441,
0.0189442616,
-0.0508284718,
-0.0060595185,
-0.0423193537,
0.0398891121,
-0.0037490418,
0.0256301519,
0.0196867809,
0.0016772092,
-0.0445538312,
-0.0001276452,
0.0182461496,
-0.0338388644,
0.063161552,
-0.0529992655,
0.0165044013,
-0.022764409,
-0.0387866646,
-0.0320756771,
-0.0445563048,
-0.0142082134,
0.0059566791,
0.0207671113,
0.0039650425,
-0.0182924569,
0.0236028135,
-0.0060861036,
0.0276147053,
-0.057531625,
-0.0094876857,
-0.0110797621,
0.0409302376,
0.0696508959,
0.00278182,
0.0126965372,
-0.0747046769,
-0.0006697488,
0.046936769,
0.0170536265,
0.0431051962,
-0.0161190312,
-0.0287300963,
0.0267166421,
-0.0014842649,
-0.011387513,
-0.0326094776,
0.0819627941,
-0.0661823079,
-0.0476946309,
0.0954757556,
0.0348327607,
-0.0179817621,
0.0298405141,
0.0056508509,
0.0535784066,
-0.0048788865,
0.0625792891,
-0.0711301342,
-0.0477965958,
0.0038580003,
0.0430023447,
-0.0059231403,
0.006204857,
0.0091614127,
-0.1322989613,
0.0395916961,
0.0121689374,
-0.0673789158,
-0.0728581175,
-0.0042724749,
-0.0095839715,
-0.02028496,
0.0257204045,
0.0475811586,
-0.0204737522,
0.0287818089,
0.0251241587,
-0.004078052,
-0.0772847384,
-0.0072509469,
-0.0333685614,
0.0295600463,
0.0648083389,
0.0261948947,
0.0319458768,
-0.0081156855,
0.0459449217,
-0.0219569076,
-0.0006623584,
-0.0324794091,
0.0199038088,
0.0077602426,
-0.0148562575,
-0.0026981453,
0.0609110855,
-0.0050528175,
0.0081194406,
0.0178664569,
0.0305928495,
0.0056417291,
0.0008305308,
-0.00647149,
0.0106944786,
0.0011701569,
0.0649302825,
0.0442551002,
-0.0596475489,
-0.0451126993,
-0.0479700491,
-0.0007158121,
-0.0737581775,
-0.052331578,
0.0099993525,
-0.0088611888,
-0.0002864957,
-0.0935427845,
-0.035789825,
0.0279208738,
0.0489995331,
-0.0119042397,
-0.0234646834,
-0.0425560288,
-0.0122075817,
-0.0212893989,
0.0242690556,
-0.0467891023,
0.009590283,
-0.0450162925,
-0.0163262337,
0.0085185403,
-0.0490278564,
-0.0118647413,
0.0293478463,
-0.124792628,
-0.0647207797,
-0.0546353348,
0.0738818645,
0.0233769678,
0.0369423516,
-0.0293150898,
-0.0727190822,
0.0098546864,
0.0220359694,
-0.0092403516,
0.0442022011,
0.0048127621,
0.001296419,
-0.0090058353,
0.0363990143,
-0.033041425,
0.0044921185,
-0.0003309198,
0.0827511251,
0.0231874362,
-0.0363909192,
0.0314260907,
0.0241395831,
-0.0321668684,
-0.0153576555,
-0.0068847584,
-0.0395928808,
0.0139689026,
0.0008267299,
-0.032789167,
-0.0482021533,
0.0404177122,
0.0081841992,
-0.0374209993,
-0.0062111956,
0.0072686663,
-0.0010474965,
0.0608295389,
-0.0533485748,
-0.0051385514,
-0.0209945627,
0.0105011454,
0.0081841396,
-0.0133648049,
-0.0307396837,
-0.0121626006,
-0.0049300436,
0.0451163165,
-0.0197053794,
0.0413281359,
0.0320265815,
-0.004329849,
-0.0128967511,
0.036274042,
-0.0406442583,
-0.0523944795,
-0.0478503108,
0.033065889,
0.0549226403,
0.0250148308,
0.0684758872,
-0.0034562149,
-0.0336779989,
-0.0187500343,
0.0371622629,
-0.000107223,
-0.022652017,
0.0185904242,
0.0191852991,
0.0053349901,
-0.0300269499,
0.0925816745,
0.0234634131,
0.0328779034,
0.0043688747,
0.0059832651,
-0.0370778516,
-0.038008336,
-0.0282907579,
-0.0497440659,
-0.0080288779,
-0.0050792703,
-0.024593072,
-0.0541308634,
-0.0188908428,
0.0466612242,
0.000657433,
-0.0058085597,
0.0188976601,
0.0727716535,
0.0009475209,
0.0038308862,
-0.0765310377,
-0.0034323488,
0.0118103623,
-0.0038185625,
-0.0223066304,
-7.147186385e-33,
-0.0301265437,
-0.035573896,
0.0120329503,
-0.0182230528,
-0.0531577207,
-0.0244069062,
-0.05741347,
-0.0076324074,
0.0027987673,
-0.0025257673,
-0.0075453762,
0.0092459358,
-0.0073757358,
0.0401299447,
-0.0077093341,
0.0000238456,
0.0620489344,
0.0307391621,
-0.0635007843,
0.0123998355,
-0.0156264454,
0.0293011479,
0.0314458869,
0.0155924708,
-0.0074488339,
-0.0145825185,
-0.04228919,
0.0532514229,
-0.0142970895,
0.0654533058,
0.001174316,
0.0130074639,
0.0247407258,
-0.0305535495,
-0.0123298429,
-0.0093664043,
-0.049876228,
0.015129542,
0.0134958588,
-0.0225012004,
-0.0563220643,
-0.0688747168,
0.0466867909,
-0.0129734678,
0.0211514886,
0.0145512447,
0.0167048387,
-0.0451092161,
-0.0283504967,
-0.0150500815,
-0.064838402,
0.0333800204,
-0.001618507,
-0.0589427277,
-0.040670462,
0.0515140779,
-0.0127394497,
0.0094641913,
-0.002629969,
0.0075119399,
0.0726518333,
0.0573754124,
0.0504623465,
0.024890244,
0.0100500612,
0.0365050919,
0.0007682848,
0.0317579024,
0.0014801031,
-0.0431622118,
0.0322200879,
0.012217042,
0.0454605408,
0.046307981,
0.031717848,
0.0121068517,
-0.050291121,
0.0216451287,
-0.0348987542,
0.0308677554,
0.0291608535,
0.0125680789,
0.0072762999,
-0.017845355,
-0.0757482201,
0.0276787374,
-0.0390102938,
0.0058431728,
0.0143234944,
0.0571085513,
-0.0711606741,
-0.0260065906,
0.0129815126,
-0.0097750155,
0.0370756313,
-0.002131609,
-0.0301234461,
0.0159533713,
-0.0281863268,
0.0180436019,
-0.0452360474,
-0.0148405442,
0.0129835438,
-0.0020587137,
-0.0050314055,
0.0141805476,
0.0246508569,
0.0132624619,
-0.0525671616,
0.0323550142,
-0.0519928969,
0.0407176316,
-0.0391487293,
0.0053381813,
0.0258719809,
-0.0156076606,
0.0057309004,
0.0788998902,
0.0130868042,
0.0333330818,
-0.0391034037,
0.0164698493,
0.0171054397,
0.0160681196,
-0.0164144952,
0.0399103388,
-0.0196618624,
0.0546874106,
-0.0179519374,
-0.0826686323,
-0.0146118505,
0.0265313536,
2.802e-7,
0.0362009816,
0.0563625135,
0.0159660317,
0.0373731814,
0.0205138847,
0.0377313606,
0.0064013028,
0.0097690215,
0.0290809646,
0.0211363714,
0.0290463325,
0.0326989442,
0.0749303326,
0.0185057893,
-0.086590901,
0.0293690469,
-0.0600969344,
0.0091303941,
-0.0230085123,
-0.0642936155,
0.0114600249,
0.099468857,
-0.0269558597,
-0.0139574129,
0.0034526424,
-0.0307394136,
0.0844940841,
-0.0089608431,
-0.0564930364,
0.0442248508,
0.0312628672,
0.0312260259,
-0.009938078,
-0.0308760963,
-0.0158532746,
-0.0208875835,
0.0038466665,
0.0498791561,
0.0237342473,
-0.0019513286,
0.0006670953,
-0.0185442418,
0.022602601,
-0.0270507913,
0.0635329932,
-0.0559130758,
-0.020599125,
-0.0544916652,
0.0183423255,
-0.0068873772,
-0.0060351901,
-0.0634726509,
-0.0361879244,
0.0284735337,
0.0041388217,
-0.0019653277,
-0.0201690327,
-0.0431643017,
-0.0217381995,
-0.0047933669,
-0.0411896259,
-0.0317793041,
-0.0337694846,
-0.0108581884,
0.0043521998,
-0.0731309876,
-0.0055147037,
2.768027924e-34,
0.0751354694,
-0.046641808,
-0.0159388501,
0.0272436347,
0.0424825475,
0.0010069438,
0.0119638452,
-0.0069533209,
0.0175859518,
-0.0473765172,
-0.0414235555
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10111v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10111v1 | VideoCon: Robust Video-Language Alignment via Contrast Captions | 2023-11-15T19:51:57 | 2023-11-15T19:51:57 | Hritik Bansal, Yonatan Bitton, Idan Szpektor, Kai-Wei Chang, Aditya Grover | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Despite being (pre)trained on a massive amount of data, state-of-the-art
video-language alignment models are not robust to semantically-plausible
contrastive changes in the video captions. Our work addresses this by
identifying a broad spectrum of contrast misalignments, such as replacing
entities, actions, and flipping event order, which alignment models should be
robust against. To this end, we introduce the VideoCon, a video-language
alignment dataset constructed by a large language model that generates
plausible contrast video captions and explanations for differences between
original and contrast video captions. Then, a generative video-language model
is finetuned with VideoCon to assess video-language entailment and generate
explanations. Our VideoCon-based alignment model significantly outperforms
current models. It exhibits a 12-point increase in AUC for the video-language
alignment task on human-generated contrast captions. Finally, our model sets
new state of the art zero-shot performance in temporally-extensive
video-language tasks such as text-to-video retrieval (SSv2-Temporal) and video
question answering (ATP-Hard). Moreover, our model shows superior performance
on novel videos and human-crafted captions and explanations. Our code and data
are available at https://github.com/Hritikbansal/videocon. | [
0.0193976574,
0.0671039969,
-0.0111344857,
0.0650182962,
-0.0032234611,
-0.001063875,
-0.003586344,
-0.0221252497,
-0.04810315,
-0.0559303686,
0.0122909108,
-0.0455761403,
0.0070514567,
0.0569301136,
0.0200058054,
-0.0667180195,
0.0601658747,
-0.005235943,
0.0011774357,
0.0321033746,
0.0281975791,
0.0345457569,
-0.0209135041,
0.0345160179,
-0.0056060841,
-0.0082240449,
-0.0041807834,
0.0179067347,
0.0791662708,
-0.0050462573,
0.0040695695,
0.0640584081,
0.0649690926,
0.0054181726,
0.000001584,
-0.0172603671,
0.0072889943,
-0.0035520741,
0.0086013423,
0.034900777,
0.013885729,
-0.0347584523,
0.0014144944,
0.0247962065,
-0.0432696603,
-0.0150309065,
0.0591693148,
-0.0217716768,
0.0377295353,
0.0389174186,
-0.0345565453,
-0.0470942482,
-0.0077988636,
-0.0224500988,
0.0013614445,
-0.0303305611,
-0.0142190866,
0.012383257,
0.0075276662,
0.0086864801,
-0.0535426363,
0.0321822166,
0.0273342375,
-0.0333040915,
-0.0135906087,
0.0160928257,
-0.0634951517,
-0.0223399568,
-0.0045611444,
0.0827700719,
0.0401519127,
0.0093992501,
-0.0322104692,
0.0138480002,
0.0211769529,
-0.0105982386,
-0.031214755,
0.0270969607,
0.0404593572,
0.0056900196,
0.0125839561,
0.0184139702,
0.0051953038,
0.003122824,
0.0306814481,
-0.0432031415,
0.0394613445,
0.0360551253,
-0.0653724,
-0.0076282239,
-0.0253739823,
-0.0557230972,
-0.0022695281,
0.0187892914,
-0.0085822968,
-0.0089009814,
-0.0517682321,
-0.0285575725,
-0.0172292329,
-0.0557738431,
0.0101929856,
0.0393963419,
-0.0882859156,
0.0830182433,
-0.0163600277,
0.1065677628,
-0.0410099924,
0.0166921504,
-0.0301077645,
-0.0241633561,
-0.0300524812,
-0.0014316421,
0.000409085,
-0.0167707652,
-0.0476999767,
0.0034697452,
-0.0237068422,
0.0091158357,
-0.0221350808,
0.0407776609,
-0.0439277999,
0.0247859005,
-0.0046054842,
-0.034238711,
-0.0245833788,
0.0376842059,
-0.0660632253,
0.0442472585,
0.0005212561,
-0.051103007,
-0.0479833372,
0.035739433,
0.0033527703,
-0.0418314412,
0.0220056493,
0.0578217991,
-0.0661055893,
-0.0368584208,
-0.0078460854,
0.0036944854,
-0.0477808155,
-0.0187987909,
-0.0162114166,
-0.0491059534,
0.0355924256,
0.0040569552,
-0.029218832,
-0.058725819,
0.0116235325,
-0.0192851089,
-0.0316449665,
0.0971845835,
-0.0023739361,
0.0097689563,
0.015396893,
-0.0029539242,
-0.0097209355,
0.0407627523,
0.0208335444,
-0.0078157187,
0.027203789,
0.0182995461,
0.0432808399,
0.0193603542,
-0.0294507127,
0.0153194498,
-0.064556025,
0.023793228,
0.0281984806,
0.0371866897,
0.0440189727,
0.0394689105,
-0.0046876166,
-0.032229621,
0.0720140487,
0.0051389216,
-0.0661008805,
-0.0328456089,
0.0268636215,
0.0195191205,
-0.0021579748,
0.023957748,
-0.0317207389,
0.0906278789,
0.0142579982,
0.0202341806,
0.0401314981,
0.0235572085,
-0.0651744008,
-0.0370363258,
-0.0326388031,
-0.0036820222,
0.0220877901,
-0.0120381098,
0.0420796387,
0.0168692153,
-0.0573785305,
0.0222457629,
0.0054726941,
-0.0016639037,
0.0234636366,
-0.0046383222,
-0.0161935985,
0.0766657293,
0.0179018248,
-0.0094296653,
-0.0664846972,
-0.0105494596,
0.0329168402,
0.0719861612,
0.0298204459,
0.0017446957,
0.0113277007,
-0.059305165,
-0.0354322195,
-0.0369161591,
0.0149298245,
0.0059004086,
0.0134863071,
0.0121386731,
0.0224202499,
0.0020426947,
-0.0501320139,
0.0373850055,
0.0325605236,
-0.0181290954,
-0.0210148301,
0.016365543,
0.031520918,
0.025948273,
-0.0227081962,
-0.0199573115,
-0.0180924982,
-0.0092973188,
0.0039080693,
0.0601456314,
-0.0420625508,
-0.0788802877,
0.054501541,
-0.0680057853,
-0.0409567095,
0.0571072809,
-0.0474358015,
-0.0691562295,
0.0345819704,
-0.0063711195,
-0.0087854518,
-0.0797063634,
0.0167311449,
0.0218344033,
0.0290925875,
0.0101048183,
0.0373262949,
0.0058834646,
-0.0273165554,
0.0146571333,
0.029472826,
0.0006199205,
-0.0371516347,
-0.0206467863,
-0.0347458124,
-0.014201507,
-0.0081132744,
0.0201231632,
-0.0131623484,
-0.0457576476,
-0.002043653,
-0.0471044146,
0.0321309268,
-0.028935859,
0.0175555386,
0.0349165313,
-0.0174206663,
0.014852236,
-0.0367931016,
-0.0302509479,
-0.0162207168,
-0.0118334638,
0.0215018317,
0.0353148319,
0.0189215355,
-0.0262116455,
-0.0662106946,
-0.006195168,
-0.00127355,
0.0281779133,
-0.0024488138,
0.0003623565,
0.0039496333,
0.0127767315,
-0.0008564487,
0.0278476179,
-0.0354795232,
-0.0657484606,
-0.0149687063,
0.0321064442,
0.0019640105,
0.0259202346,
0.0181706827,
0.0289998725,
-0.0093391109,
-0.0108327661,
-0.000230246,
0.0106902877,
-0.0068342453,
-0.0739852041,
-0.0102206273,
-0.0393125154,
-0.0453741886,
0.0430559814,
-0.0247756857,
0.0434121974,
-0.1077469885,
-0.021942677,
0.0063382862,
0.0063172132,
-0.0060833232,
0.0044685239,
-0.013822468,
0.0335449092,
-0.0826836228,
-0.0302128009,
0.0633607656,
-0.0355891399,
-0.0434330516,
0.0127123473,
-0.0136979306,
-0.011679396,
0.0771883726,
0.0141842514,
0.0278842524,
-0.0235852487,
-0.0359155126,
-0.092975311,
-0.0366595872,
0.0291043054,
-0.0167735796,
0.0551938191,
-0.058834143,
0.018303223,
0.0002808838,
-0.0266578067,
-0.0397432111,
-0.0466123149,
-0.0259415526,
-0.0021706908,
-0.0341852605,
-0.0443975553,
-0.0152044417,
0.0132022183,
0.0164679401,
0.0531136505,
-0.0080065886,
0.0332719125,
-0.0057161883,
0.0386870801,
0.0766382664,
0.0269366615,
-0.0195209514,
-0.0436732769,
0.0521180592,
0.0301764123,
0.0229105391,
-0.0180015173,
-0.0357486457,
0.0007171729,
0.0156295206,
0.0001667668,
-0.0020113555,
0.0134066343,
0.0488080978,
-0.0430429764,
0.0077672685,
0.0958986208,
0.0014698076,
-0.029907044,
-0.014863479,
0.0114963241,
0.0020780663,
0.0463133976,
0.0007734259,
-0.0858457088,
-0.0566945337,
-0.0146932285,
0.0006013308,
0.034962222,
0.0432847999,
-0.0276889112,
-0.1013014317,
0.0425059982,
0.0203657337,
-0.0462355353,
-0.055769898,
0.0125405164,
0.0226671658,
-0.0242088865,
0.0266536586,
-0.0017263048,
0.0147115486,
0.0196369048,
0.0044809659,
0.0279180352,
-0.0635176823,
0.0348771289,
-0.0501457974,
0.0659564883,
0.0454312265,
0.0167071261,
-0.0346456319,
-0.0232373476,
0.0040054512,
-0.0382218249,
-0.0065880227,
0.0280728489,
0.0766119659,
-0.0316012725,
-0.0306731351,
0.0408779867,
0.0559358336,
-0.0114861149,
-0.0469251648,
-0.0210940018,
0.0364659838,
0.0016745662,
0.0240825843,
-0.0185322315,
0.0073599215,
0.0092048338,
0.0794891119,
-0.0037969786,
-0.0016198939,
0.0092536388,
0.0199159458,
-0.0402683243,
-0.0415784456,
-0.0259507541,
-0.0126332417,
0.0191230383,
0.0179299638,
-0.0429573879,
-0.0189660881,
0.0464864001,
0.0168296341,
-0.0074038398,
0.0046865414,
-0.0396983251,
0.0162632149,
-0.083079733,
0.0966751203,
-0.0131997904,
0.0060739433,
-0.0394873135,
-0.0245130733,
0.0538533814,
-0.0269039627,
-0.015498139,
0.0392962061,
-0.032102216,
-0.0572848767,
-0.0231490545,
0.0519376658,
0.0143040745,
0.0935809538,
0.0077881506,
0.0184072535,
-0.0346829556,
-0.0236726198,
0.0087216394,
0.0177489184,
0.0050352761,
-0.0366714261,
-0.0227100849,
0.0427564755,
-0.0263559371,
-0.0060004983,
0.010602762,
0.057806436,
-0.0431826971,
-0.0395016335,
0.0157895572,
-0.0558404662,
0.0663109198,
-0.053572163,
-0.0096183894,
-0.0478714332,
0.0016479415,
0.0012019055,
0.0204463322,
-0.0477249622,
-0.0005844428,
0.0264423173,
-0.0020033531,
-0.0098343883,
0.0121714137,
-0.0172820166,
-0.0247519128,
-0.0014550157,
-0.0379629694,
-0.0144985914,
-0.0046360507,
0.0043301997,
0.0199234243,
0.0129744541,
0.0359856933,
0.0117156487,
0.0587684475,
0.0042017796,
0.0662682429,
0.0282021165,
0.0039279177,
0.0242964718,
0.0378960408,
-0.0186966304,
0.0075777709,
-0.0294721443,
0.0282069128,
0.0436781161,
-0.0527743995,
0.0275563374,
0.0082358811,
-0.0185918268,
-0.004757301,
0.0477983952,
-0.0250020009,
-0.0574558824,
0.0383775942,
0.0029543017,
-0.0252669957,
0.0300167724,
0.0653415695,
-0.0032243878,
0.0294094589,
-0.0215432364,
0.0234211721,
-0.0019721442,
-0.000797295,
-0.0252469294,
-0.0161487367,
-0.0300887935,
0.025323635,
-0.0376310758,
-0.0769901797,
-0.0158410538,
0.0116240615,
-0.007363495,
0.0620552376,
0.0586539507,
0.0103909271,
-0.0097972862,
-0.0388559103,
0.0054686046,
-0.0339066833,
-0.0304004326,
-0.0140115181,
-0.0301664881,
-5.970763394e-33,
-0.0417707823,
-0.0116756856,
0.0032629941,
-0.0310492273,
0.0124282483,
0.0132605992,
-0.0443831608,
0.0275772866,
-0.0451502502,
0.0443800837,
0.0255562402,
0.0463507399,
0.0173448194,
0.0522276647,
0.0125596132,
-0.0598036721,
0.0476180986,
-0.0125037804,
-0.0258986689,
-0.010077686,
0.0411489569,
-0.0127437441,
0.0686259121,
-0.0713737905,
-0.0091635976,
-0.0157065429,
-0.0354821235,
0.0507292524,
0.0343460888,
0.0547589958,
0.0214754175,
-0.0199819468,
0.022612514,
-0.0366789773,
-0.0118374601,
-0.0045430628,
-0.0447628014,
0.0090152537,
0.0467345044,
0.0312954411,
-0.0628739297,
-0.0441167727,
0.0003503903,
-0.0200072601,
-0.0161840003,
-0.0444050692,
0.0518630259,
-0.0310230553,
0.0605140254,
0.0286406688,
-0.0534889996,
-0.0030644531,
-0.0552870855,
-0.0481234156,
0.003162656,
0.02413176,
0.0560282916,
-0.0050971946,
-0.035299439,
-0.0098253815,
-0.0181243382,
0.0585323311,
0.1168574318,
0.0327664055,
-0.0199186914,
0.0514373593,
-0.0210334882,
-0.054048378,
-0.0368276387,
-0.0088662105,
-0.0172581393,
0.0160733722,
0.0601527505,
0.0664411336,
0.0231594555,
0.0123852352,
-0.0274442937,
0.040033903,
-0.0998720005,
0.0403164178,
-0.0264990963,
0.0196714234,
-0.001912009,
0.0299832672,
-0.0210150778,
-0.0040530977,
-0.0236169044,
-0.0176109206,
0.0293258782,
-0.0251043458,
-0.0005268527,
-0.0038689948,
0.0774151385,
-0.016723495,
0.0487050861,
0.0335515589,
-0.0405887328,
0.0347096175,
0.0057783094,
0.0494214781,
-0.0176976994,
-0.0085463868,
0.0480867922,
0.0202644095,
0.0207951721,
0.0119582508,
0.0271131992,
0.0291591398,
-0.0210487191,
0.01831894,
-0.0192163233,
0.0055277185,
-0.0580865555,
-0.009949984,
0.0210147854,
0.0494865216,
-0.047459323,
0.0466566421,
0.0138389831,
0.0141102038,
-0.020563418,
-0.0176823344,
-0.0283577573,
0.0252064336,
-0.0243443251,
0.0369341597,
-0.0166612659,
-0.0021617024,
0.0096004875,
-0.0463157147,
-0.0085614016,
0.0529013947,
2.369e-7,
0.0176737923,
-0.0066932137,
0.0375322886,
0.0163266435,
-0.0202726126,
0.055977203,
0.0098297196,
0.0025628607,
0.011171516,
-0.0482057817,
0.0455516018,
0.0716001168,
0.055385787,
-0.0246994141,
-0.0089212591,
0.0032835153,
-0.0698643699,
-0.0017068924,
-0.0430024341,
0.0023511613,
0.0739165246,
0.1327936798,
0.0297519676,
0.0081749596,
-0.0098436438,
-0.0753263384,
0.0393743329,
0.0106939012,
-0.010329322,
0.0150476759,
-0.0186700393,
0.0096928123,
-0.0480106734,
0.0215167087,
-0.0168838296,
0.0080052996,
0.0248635449,
0.0401647799,
-0.0514471382,
-0.0387028009,
-0.0793468803,
0.0122914035,
-0.0214492902,
-0.0286253281,
0.0562513284,
-0.0103980042,
0.0035797735,
-0.0237079207,
-0.0430169292,
0.0408209935,
0.0064186077,
-0.0049140798,
-0.012456093,
0.0352757983,
0.0264199413,
0.0018177825,
-0.0485957265,
-0.0965332836,
-0.0227755867,
0.0109283533,
-0.0230481252,
0.0426933356,
-0.0030871213,
0.0054418477,
0.0611959472,
-0.0120841404,
-0.0451128259,
1.539728278e-34,
0.0158646498,
-0.0001044879,
0.0117507018,
0.005983266,
-0.0078958059,
0.0095910421,
-0.0815810561,
-0.0078880992,
0.0164325554,
-0.0302761775,
-0.0153023908
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09335v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09335v2 | Investigating Hallucinations in Pruned Large Language Models for Abstractive Summarization | 2023-11-15T19:49:24 | 2024-01-29T17:59:30 | George Chrysostomou, Zhixue Zhao, Miles Williams, Nikolaos Aletras | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Despite the remarkable performance of generative large language models (LLMs)
on abstractive summarization, they face two significant challenges: their
considerable size and tendency to hallucinate. Hallucinations are concerning
because they erode reliability and raise safety issues. Pruning is a technique
that reduces model size by removing redundant weights, enabling more efficient
sparse inference. Pruned models yield downstream task performance comparable to
the original, making them ideal alternatives when operating on a limited
budget. However, the effect that pruning has upon hallucinations in abstractive
summarization with LLMs has yet to be explored. In this paper, we provide an
extensive empirical study across five summarization datasets, two
state-of-the-art pruning methods, and five instruction-tuned LLMs.
Surprisingly, we find that hallucinations from pruned LLMs are less prevalent
than the original models. Our analysis suggests that pruned models tend to
depend more on the source document for summary generation. This leads to a
higher lexical overlap between the generated summary and the source document,
which could be a reason for the reduction in hallucination risk. | [
0.0160687957,
0.0646250471,
0.0208423156,
-0.0003867884,
-0.0141747007,
0.0157080591,
-0.0038732728,
-0.0087079778,
-0.0464997925,
-0.0242208187,
-0.0070720911,
-0.0567017049,
0.0223555174,
-0.0193208121,
0.0371624976,
-0.0612022504,
0.0205413308,
-0.0666231513,
-0.0195776615,
-0.0162182916,
0.007810493,
0.0087805251,
0.0329805538,
0.0493933745,
0.027770903,
-0.0156700201,
0.0079520708,
0.003884689,
0.0129553927,
0.0093427096,
-0.0332932025,
0.0497848727,
0.0106790978,
0.0392687917,
0.0000019559,
-0.0470224842,
-0.000257713,
0.0043755141,
-0.0011435843,
0.0773745477,
0.064258717,
-0.0038013225,
0.0213855449,
0.0148901194,
0.0271952786,
-0.0434432514,
0.0226215366,
0.0874682665,
0.041174002,
0.061262738,
-0.0061550699,
-0.0354705192,
0.0289962701,
-0.0393231921,
-0.004535622,
0.0009908343,
0.0273966659,
0.0395552292,
-0.0322148204,
-0.0334953628,
-0.0072081829,
0.0354048908,
0.0141014503,
0.0147038531,
-0.014107598,
0.0591990091,
-0.0690033063,
-0.0155854588,
0.0222019125,
0.0402729176,
-0.0342202038,
-0.0414304435,
0.0215466376,
0.0058576008,
0.0127596194,
-0.0121493498,
-0.0726596564,
0.0857650712,
-0.0091723697,
0.0302953124,
0.0281572435,
0.0144045539,
0.0317840241,
0.0291118454,
-0.0475654379,
0.007784823,
0.0312817767,
-0.0242226087,
0.0014625069,
0.0133351134,
-0.0528189614,
-0.0620053709,
-0.0097979754,
0.0009389395,
-0.0162273664,
-0.0155092916,
-0.0675460473,
-0.0395753197,
0.0284881126,
-0.0371413976,
0.0444909483,
0.0139388246,
0.0054243128,
0.0281438492,
-0.0223761983,
0.0160257556,
0.0194355994,
0.0209798925,
-0.0532817245,
0.0108933896,
0.0175201241,
-0.0048329053,
-0.041759979,
0.0629053712,
-0.0462172441,
-0.0319192037,
-0.0402813964,
0.0069862078,
-0.007163187,
-0.0169834495,
-0.0137151554,
0.016472958,
-0.0136291618,
-0.013000289,
0.0344606489,
0.0007032474,
-0.0172454622,
-0.0181423575,
0.032325197,
-0.0365769044,
-0.0273354575,
0.0343922898,
-0.0007356287,
-0.002617154,
-0.0038771508,
0.0267200246,
-0.0180067066,
-0.0224372391,
-0.0045097154,
-0.0298707429,
-0.0213625934,
-0.0614396036,
-0.0056346925,
-0.0731972009,
-0.0024323091,
0.0011678145,
-0.0062299804,
-0.0228360929,
0.0084126405,
0.0059581306,
-0.0525394082,
0.010430648,
-0.0110584879,
0.0377196856,
0.0154430317,
0.0199827999,
0.010526021,
0.0550796762,
0.0293366052,
0.0665331259,
0.0108932806,
0.0088092536,
0.0225277543,
0.0303990692,
0.0097172409,
0.0286495201,
-0.006291097,
-0.0393481441,
-0.0229604281,
-0.0120294075,
0.0582826696,
0.0998883247,
-0.054605972,
0.0297797658,
0.0830425769,
0.0415269025,
0.0045927083,
0.0286993347,
0.044097688,
0.0230685435,
0.00284816,
0.0641555935,
-0.0466625579,
0.0121979201,
-0.0369169265,
0.0629147366,
0.1078844815,
0.0223690942,
-0.040321514,
-0.0525236204,
-0.0113460468,
0.009657057,
0.0061238948,
0.0206158832,
0.0242794845,
0.0056509711,
-0.0499735437,
0.0419876128,
0.0377228707,
-0.0638131127,
-0.0013790313,
-0.0466010794,
0.0104039283,
0.0590508692,
0.0645876229,
0.006457503,
-0.0008768649,
0.0020703205,
0.0256893374,
0.0407802686,
0.0333623327,
0.0032450177,
0.0177736245,
-0.0530189052,
0.0017744587,
-0.0124043059,
0.0445723869,
-0.0180094745,
0.0059672506,
-0.0255605038,
0.0435458533,
-0.0170430727,
-0.0925594419,
0.0241959672,
-0.0448067449,
-0.0238539055,
-0.0181798488,
-0.0439753123,
0.0102876024,
-0.0178830028,
-0.0392270871,
0.0451582111,
0.0074535552,
-0.0509494916,
-0.0156710763,
0.015814526,
-0.0456668697,
-0.0086630285,
0.0184149574,
-0.0354119465,
0.0277906451,
0.0121027147,
-0.0090292832,
-0.0470547639,
0.0024857917,
-0.0785831735,
0.0332068205,
-0.0640380755,
0.0421492793,
0.0060150623,
0.0269631036,
-0.0122944787,
0.0749157071,
-0.0254111886,
0.0019326697,
0.0615458041,
-0.0158963855,
-0.0290428959,
-0.0204900037,
-0.0392833427,
-0.0083024092,
0.0038164735,
0.0056024091,
0.0233127121,
-0.0121155921,
-0.0114933914,
-0.0249146577,
-0.0966203511,
0.0230086315,
-0.0295060985,
-0.0066366359,
0.0490322746,
0.0149279684,
-0.0047023133,
0.0368712954,
-0.0057182051,
-0.0323413834,
0.0267283339,
0.038559027,
-0.0158023965,
-0.0045800409,
-0.0038316865,
-0.0374457203,
-0.0241224933,
0.0206105076,
0.0637464449,
-0.0194398891,
-0.0321469344,
-0.0729669183,
0.0979071036,
-0.0165932197,
-0.0202262551,
0.0007542596,
0.0069251759,
-0.0221045483,
-0.005675409,
0.0902669355,
0.0421106108,
0.0227861982,
0.0206335261,
0.0732491314,
-0.0226562731,
-0.0185098425,
-0.0181030426,
-0.0123501876,
0.0027913894,
0.0120782703,
-0.0739639848,
-0.0001900632,
0.0570272692,
0.0154654682,
-0.0006753252,
-0.0419459455,
0.0003602441,
-0.0394086391,
-0.0341588333,
-0.015270967,
-0.0318005718,
-0.0132667562,
0.0221903622,
-0.0356264487,
-0.0355498157,
0.0369570926,
-0.0283915773,
0.017501343,
-0.0309241414,
-0.0027891386,
-0.031589143,
0.0249637682,
0.0255823936,
0.037976265,
-0.0086431829,
-0.0200436898,
-0.051746536,
-0.009333143,
-0.0214934256,
-0.0162978526,
0.0762590393,
-0.0463116542,
0.0221216772,
-0.0232362524,
-0.0123846568,
0.0049007004,
-0.0473464914,
0.0032640612,
0.027413249,
0.0412830189,
0.0023370855,
-0.043694865,
0.0343303047,
0.0264605321,
0.0521572903,
-0.0378435813,
-0.0137688443,
-0.0001853734,
0.0238881577,
0.1105109826,
-0.0279222019,
0.0590812564,
-0.0875831321,
0.04121425,
0.0465687141,
0.0503983535,
0.0059208861,
-0.0129935509,
-0.0400619283,
0.0026911956,
-0.041221302,
-0.0052488646,
0.011132027,
0.0725003853,
-0.0324237458,
-0.0220248923,
0.1038306579,
-0.0026251499,
-0.0474468842,
0.0133760897,
0.0018515862,
0.094234176,
-0.0154810548,
-0.0086731743,
-0.0452919453,
0.0019628713,
0.0093575129,
0.0068517192,
0.0068923407,
-0.017942613,
0.0201538056,
-0.0964970738,
0.0367090106,
0.035126172,
-0.0470844619,
-0.0016233106,
-0.0041238475,
0.0054502995,
-0.0072338991,
0.0231209081,
0.0371955298,
-0.0440325551,
-0.0040554716,
0.0120511679,
-0.0749556199,
-0.0077022044,
-0.0064054965,
-0.0234479886,
-0.0023819024,
0.0638623089,
0.006156452,
-0.0126766823,
0.000390918,
0.0781284124,
-0.0355509482,
-0.0154698323,
0.0038878068,
0.0617706217,
0.0362572484,
0.0148048783,
-0.0226425063,
0.0461848155,
0.0100131128,
-0.0120922262,
-0.0308810528,
0.0132888164,
-0.0265977047,
-0.0698074251,
-0.0286341738,
0.0345406681,
-0.0200244952,
0.0962924361,
0.0567644686,
-0.0168538783,
-0.0781522915,
-0.0147120003,
0.0143794194,
-0.0733546913,
-0.0268437304,
0.018191997,
0.0094186207,
-0.0473283455,
-0.0633231699,
-0.0460029989,
0.0203381907,
-0.0154497279,
0.0000343801,
0.0368542299,
-0.035121344,
-0.0065562325,
-0.0181170404,
0.0249614194,
-0.0379526578,
-0.0096615599,
-0.0176295843,
-0.019042071,
0.0387428477,
-0.0080457656,
-0.0100253141,
0.0547519103,
-0.1184943467,
-0.0718917847,
-0.0204727557,
0.0293532144,
0.0286993291,
0.0618464425,
0.0206280444,
-0.0350590907,
0.0756131187,
0.0138268266,
0.0296334121,
0.0782850981,
-0.0068056136,
0.014878531,
0.0078879334,
0.0454496033,
-0.0353872851,
0.0262366626,
0.0175639652,
0.0478098616,
-0.0059927944,
-0.0006458871,
-0.0038071629,
0.0345964544,
-0.0144898556,
-0.039817974,
0.0216217637,
-0.0263397284,
-0.0161043704,
-0.0205578078,
-0.0138895847,
-0.0402870961,
0.0353227966,
0.0146168824,
0.0203159731,
-0.006949984,
0.0484547801,
0.0109704267,
0.0237978026,
-0.053510014,
-0.0205065012,
-0.0526177697,
-0.0396960117,
0.0243887119,
-0.0161360428,
-0.0698798746,
-0.0108845755,
-0.0436311774,
0.0114054857,
-0.0011864867,
0.0091358805,
0.0035757446,
0.0078288801,
-0.0393056124,
0.0410746299,
-0.062719427,
-0.0703148693,
-0.0611482784,
0.0157870762,
0.0339055136,
-0.0306057502,
0.0968641788,
-0.0245117303,
0.0139745101,
-0.049292706,
0.0209450684,
0.0376873426,
-0.0270504076,
-0.0325466804,
0.0176460296,
-0.0208543707,
-0.0092599876,
0.1119086593,
-0.0002160866,
0.0354214199,
0.0254143141,
-0.0022492085,
-0.0287776012,
-0.0825529844,
-0.0425611027,
0.0070908484,
-0.019577153,
-0.0332461037,
-0.0531391241,
-0.0372363776,
0.0025552334,
-0.0075335796,
0.0203777328,
-0.021149084,
0.0228614863,
0.0294560138,
-0.0244543962,
-0.0076475493,
-0.0266607981,
-0.0079113571,
0.0171394553,
0.0039692791,
-0.0339359753,
-6.301854602e-33,
-0.0106935026,
0.0136119518,
0.0101009589,
-0.0189644452,
-0.049010694,
-0.0150322607,
-0.0652213842,
0.0118113998,
0.0217580572,
0.0037887117,
-0.013863856,
0.0169016141,
0.008868454,
0.0426318347,
0.007396373,
0.017813798,
0.0708226487,
0.0094143823,
-0.038811449,
0.0713251457,
0.030260006,
0.0041694511,
0.0206666272,
-0.0270119421,
0.0011777889,
-0.0214078408,
-0.0233158153,
-0.0308320466,
0.0047550048,
0.014266246,
-0.0316147804,
0.0253653843,
0.0245935209,
-0.0216581747,
-0.0614697114,
0.0153648527,
-0.0237919725,
-0.0016946214,
0.0440474749,
-0.0435847752,
-0.0276012626,
-0.0743438303,
0.0539996065,
0.0023797627,
-0.0072761653,
-0.0533900559,
0.0201361738,
-0.0443866923,
-0.0705123469,
-0.0472620614,
-0.0565079078,
0.0098872967,
0.0003914496,
-0.0157680847,
0.0013449319,
0.0293042567,
-0.0274651423,
-0.00708926,
-0.0219896156,
0.0223474372,
0.0509776361,
0.0494060852,
0.0413836986,
0.0175653659,
0.0153171681,
0.0690691695,
0.0188113097,
0.007447389,
-0.0318836533,
0.0090934113,
0.0015150978,
0.0339698046,
0.0085971663,
-0.0166224688,
0.0682837442,
0.0248902868,
-0.0402223468,
0.0385578163,
-0.0667504817,
0.0368914455,
0.1020351052,
0.0016511484,
-0.0133151961,
-0.0411450081,
-0.0167549085,
0.0245375987,
-0.0170114879,
-0.0068062418,
0.0072941938,
0.0256537013,
-0.0443716906,
-0.0095567033,
0.0432859361,
-0.0409602337,
0.0106028644,
0.0294100605,
-0.0294136927,
0.0125973625,
-0.006033041,
-0.0242891498,
-0.0219604596,
0.0080391699,
0.005970886,
0.0104569411,
-0.0165942125,
0.0325205848,
0.0389439501,
-0.0079863174,
-0.0483211726,
-0.0071203131,
-0.0223613493,
0.0156762712,
-0.0172454454,
0.0341380164,
0.0311255231,
0.0020648292,
0.0087138871,
0.0112146558,
0.0022275406,
-0.0044940291,
-0.0117086237,
0.0404514447,
0.0078564677,
0.0182549339,
-0.0100347595,
0.0309355035,
-0.0271257609,
-0.0000366347,
0.0792676136,
-0.0437418073,
-0.0379677191,
0.0087142494,
2.57e-7,
0.0145068411,
0.0139375832,
0.0128998756,
0.0175154842,
-0.0043724538,
-0.0028139353,
0.0204866901,
-0.0069329669,
0.0385435335,
-0.0000784181,
0.0187124871,
0.0427325144,
0.0754352435,
0.0272310097,
-0.0941239372,
0.0012092667,
-0.0887241066,
-0.001246632,
-0.0520071425,
-0.0480649844,
0.0135888997,
0.0862331092,
-0.0321710929,
-0.01035247,
0.0119398627,
-0.0434181467,
0.057057973,
-0.018223865,
-0.0205198321,
0.0377971604,
0.0344166048,
0.0154398503,
-0.0083034961,
0.0027936611,
-0.002983588,
-0.0318396203,
0.02557455,
0.0515541583,
0.0062163007,
-0.0111054396,
0.0117502166,
-0.020596968,
0.0214775503,
-0.0172031112,
0.0625885129,
-0.0576368831,
0.0097305486,
-0.0285931677,
-0.0303994827,
0.0118691875,
-0.0046376488,
-0.0239704549,
-0.0002871012,
0.0387237258,
-0.0050952355,
-0.0012035579,
-0.0009032409,
-0.0430843867,
-0.0276620034,
0.0117893321,
-0.0414211899,
-0.0662905276,
-0.0262435414,
0.0194064025,
-0.0150145032,
-0.0900321528,
-0.0172061697,
2.802998652e-34,
0.0869545788,
-0.0079402654,
-0.0016650916,
0.0315973386,
0.0292613842,
-0.027373651,
0.0388471521,
0.0183245838,
-0.0284027215,
-0.1018299833,
-0.0307061728
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09325v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09325v2 | Temperature-scaling surprisal estimates improve fit to human reading times -- but does it do so for the "right reasons"? | 2023-11-15T19:34:06 | 2024-07-03T16:12:32 | Tong Liu, Iza Škrjanec, Vera Demberg | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | A wide body of evidence shows that human language processing difficulty is
predicted by the information-theoretic measure surprisal, a word's negative log
probability in context. However, it is still unclear how to best estimate these
probabilities needed for predicting human processing difficulty -- while a
long-standing belief held that models with lower perplexity would provide more
accurate estimates of word predictability, and therefore lead to better reading
time predictions, recent work has shown that for very large models,
psycholinguistic predictive power decreases. One reason could be that language
models might be more confident of their predictions than humans, because they
have had exposure to several magnitudes more data. In this paper, we test what
effect temperature-scaling of large language model (LLM) predictions has on
surprisal estimates and their predictive power of reading times of English
texts. Firstly, we show that calibration of large language models typically
improves with model size, i.e. poorer calibration cannot account for poorer fit
to reading times. Secondly, we find that temperature-scaling probabilities lead
to a systematically better fit to reading times (up to 89% improvement in delta
log likelihood), across several reading time corpora. Finally, we show that
this improvement in fit is chiefly driven by words that are composed of
multiple subword tokens. | [
-0.017160764,
0.0027855504,
-0.0096199261,
0.0181509629,
-0.0482529029,
0.0407345444,
0.028355686,
0.016489666,
-0.0131639373,
-0.0186868776,
-0.0435847379,
-0.0713435486,
0.071396254,
-0.0086026993,
0.0147745842,
-0.051229611,
0.0196017027,
-0.0522617847,
0.0115024382,
-0.0008368623,
-0.0154818054,
-0.0271504186,
0.0087024337,
0.0221967269,
0.0324727595,
-0.0103705348,
0.0334482789,
0.0135714598,
-0.0157501083,
-0.0163938273,
-0.0137885381,
0.0608853959,
-0.0170551818,
0.0135023957,
0.0000015888,
-0.0521188043,
0.0250372384,
0.006541945,
-0.0020460435,
0.0534239225,
0.0682018623,
-0.0366138928,
0.0157231893,
0.036255125,
-0.0192281231,
-0.0018638083,
0.0358139463,
0.0104343677,
-0.0893475488,
0.0190832037,
-0.0033714655,
-0.0068101562,
0.0450675376,
-0.0041827625,
0.0496434346,
-0.0487259775,
-0.0048028161,
0.01046653,
0.0208554696,
-0.0025263822,
-0.044062987,
0.05909013,
0.0070384964,
0.0456768312,
-0.0100505305,
0.0257838964,
0.0421518125,
0.0037007278,
-0.0004808453,
0.0265381709,
0.0134191867,
-0.0343312472,
-0.0411949567,
0.0001595239,
-0.0092864819,
0.0316797756,
-0.0389072597,
-0.0202885717,
-0.0017021007,
0.0000703215,
0.03142602,
0.0277308114,
0.0439957865,
-0.0202741325,
-0.002995901,
0.1210124195,
0.0140774902,
-0.0663549975,
0.0251543,
0.0099201789,
-0.0483184382,
-0.0045817862,
-0.0083448142,
-0.0312490053,
-0.0076537053,
0.0117947236,
-0.0453467108,
-0.0253611151,
0.0069243708,
-0.0064184451,
0.056995783,
0.0550955348,
0.0299287196,
-0.0011070422,
-0.0113143651,
0.0643802211,
-0.0127249258,
0.0066504409,
-0.0651162118,
-0.0066983998,
-0.0133251827,
-0.0050393105,
0.0263644569,
-0.0685300231,
-0.0247419439,
-0.0037665132,
-0.1086927354,
-0.0204781629,
0.0466550849,
-0.0584781803,
0.0194806494,
-0.0107221985,
-0.026520649,
-0.0077073914,
-0.0443078652,
0.0309357103,
-0.0436401218,
0.0211947504,
-0.0236946158,
-0.045900248,
0.0118228523,
-0.0045998609,
0.0022684562,
-0.0380146988,
0.0101791685,
0.0447005257,
-0.0275088176,
-0.0165378582,
-0.0437873788,
-0.0331517048,
-0.0393422283,
-0.0301744007,
0.0015863393,
-0.0400856249,
-0.0128275789,
0.0435454138,
-0.001780701,
-0.0303574894,
-0.0369847864,
0.0051343651,
-0.0227688272,
0.0657297969,
0.0085942987,
0.0399982445,
0.0031537646,
0.0137710087,
-0.0305758733,
0.0485544764,
0.0519514382,
-0.0392827243,
0.0282166917,
-0.0364221074,
-0.0077777184,
0.0474373326,
-0.005424324,
0.0037208586,
-0.0227064751,
-0.0157001503,
0.0025107677,
0.001413078,
0.0471726693,
0.0458224453,
0.0009870427,
-0.0383959152,
0.0761960819,
0.069670029,
0.0023817497,
0.0045419014,
-0.0032220089,
0.0280144475,
0.0112619922,
0.0259416811,
-0.0295599755,
0.0141257141,
-0.0413542651,
0.0256324355,
0.051759772,
0.0127518158,
-0.0113125192,
-0.0373319797,
-0.0334368385,
-0.0036068207,
0.0492794141,
-0.0079960665,
0.0418584496,
-0.0688054413,
-0.0394460931,
0.0011730214,
0.0329867937,
0.0004001486,
-0.0067297542,
0.0091348775,
-0.0466895066,
0.0569918714,
-0.0178462453,
-0.0049144626,
0.0344211012,
0.0323745497,
0.0019741703,
0.0037113882,
0.0326338783,
0.0305233039,
0.0114214066,
-0.0307614971,
0.0152792279,
0.0384223014,
0.0118178045,
-0.0027863404,
0.0232510529,
0.0200945567,
0.0254455786,
-0.0500052385,
-0.0315981172,
0.0229894407,
-0.116926983,
-0.070065178,
-0.0523823909,
-0.0043921024,
0.0454489253,
-0.0380826183,
-0.0141167976,
0.0292544514,
-0.005286945,
-0.0441731773,
0.0111728115,
0.0519314222,
-0.0532380939,
0.0236564353,
0.0183920469,
0.0022413942,
0.0396760032,
0.0331549905,
0.0476060733,
-0.0325712971,
0.0419494174,
-0.012911451,
0.0571999699,
0.0079974597,
0.0278779268,
-0.0497112945,
0.0178639628,
-0.0378336348,
0.0203222632,
-0.0307076164,
0.0606662519,
-0.0096413754,
-0.0330308862,
-0.0115620373,
0.0117458003,
-0.0354741253,
-0.0126479799,
0.0050410437,
-0.0139812483,
0.0103121586,
-0.0528609492,
-0.0370610319,
-0.0238797143,
-0.0724309608,
-0.014314346,
0.0157383569,
0.0234855246,
0.003430495,
-0.0041830232,
-0.0320902765,
0.0369733684,
0.001769496,
-0.0234423932,
-0.0210995525,
0.0511269309,
-0.0096149314,
-0.0204879828,
-0.0176485162,
-0.0272707306,
-0.0481753685,
-0.0534596108,
0.0618883446,
0.0285817757,
-0.0075799753,
-0.0307755079,
0.0847181082,
0.0013947132,
0.0011306721,
-0.0298395604,
-0.0430659167,
0.0154337147,
0.0307859648,
0.0758121833,
0.0703344867,
-0.0052435729,
-0.0109094121,
0.0360167921,
-0.0261136275,
-0.0023127373,
-0.0145747261,
-0.0225680601,
-0.0128774177,
-0.0432307795,
-0.1114052758,
-0.0296714474,
0.0613191761,
0.019978337,
0.0083297072,
-0.037776798,
0.0389942229,
-0.0561416671,
-0.0679251105,
-0.0009487334,
0.0057749026,
-0.0326124504,
0.0716953501,
-0.0218226276,
-0.0896442607,
0.0488904417,
-0.0411882401,
0.0185659789,
-0.026680205,
0.0001821866,
0.0032567831,
0.0483345799,
0.0098262066,
0.0077897878,
-0.0373027362,
-0.0078930166,
-0.0539170392,
-0.0471374094,
0.0456768721,
-0.0228771865,
0.025201967,
-0.028650865,
-0.0240709372,
0.0087802662,
-0.0217230245,
0.0184503868,
-0.0239821337,
-0.0359854102,
-0.0149544692,
0.0336668082,
-0.0645202324,
-0.0724125206,
-0.0176819582,
0.0248802062,
0.0120046027,
-0.0331830867,
-0.0139770741,
0.0064619831,
-0.0161873996,
0.0204084143,
0.0023206193,
0.0300245658,
-0.0827377141,
0.007913731,
0.0088860122,
0.0431940332,
0.0316400118,
-0.0072772088,
-0.0103818234,
0.0211500302,
-0.0025206548,
-0.0377205312,
0.0353646651,
0.0690289363,
-0.02777276,
0.0330305323,
0.1330080777,
0.0369081795,
-0.0127245905,
0.0231420211,
-0.0343009569,
0.0792913809,
0.0086697256,
-0.0183472652,
-0.0178547278,
-0.0192600954,
0.0175290145,
0.064399153,
-0.0330331288,
-0.0425232127,
-0.0122711053,
-0.0357855782,
-0.0238783266,
0.0368950665,
-0.0085694669,
-0.0160450041,
-0.0519909449,
-0.0006519543,
0.0087337373,
0.0294221472,
0.0041006026,
-0.0266952794,
0.0243604109,
0.0349029303,
-0.0341951586,
-0.0089478316,
0.0544955358,
-0.037328802,
0.0331654847,
0.0225061886,
0.0199178141,
-0.0308172032,
-0.029183099,
0.0339765623,
0.0113511281,
0.0107785985,
0.0003831578,
0.0104229972,
0.0322867297,
0.0301508196,
-0.0468564406,
0.0233768336,
-0.0308020189,
0.0085696951,
-0.0184546281,
0.0437615067,
0.0479842611,
-0.0293072574,
-0.023467727,
0.0000353715,
-0.0255910475,
0.0922318399,
0.0220929496,
-0.034627676,
-0.049324654,
0.0233802497,
-0.0031584983,
-0.0047792718,
-0.0579942167,
0.0413122363,
0.0214317907,
-0.0208269786,
-0.0375761054,
-0.0108678341,
-0.003141833,
0.0511891618,
0.0367995836,
0.0399144441,
0.0252329838,
-0.0044750832,
-0.0527080372,
0.0040974268,
0.0206778944,
0.0249657556,
-0.0838323087,
0.0166631769,
0.0146259889,
-0.0064909235,
-0.0274549276,
0.0139665417,
-0.0752811432,
-0.062698707,
0.0388122834,
-0.0234744996,
0.0353080705,
0.0229128674,
0.036691878,
-0.0762164071,
0.0264825895,
0.0186107364,
-0.0206930172,
0.081679374,
-0.0272510592,
0.0211675335,
0.0374822095,
0.0210430697,
0.0129939755,
0.0199772082,
0.0219966248,
-0.0053048818,
0.0212016925,
-0.062573567,
-0.0187926199,
0.0388433114,
0.0158524923,
0.0025059585,
-0.0268669743,
0.0001456487,
-0.0533325635,
-0.0022677823,
0.0344017446,
-0.010297427,
-0.0422480963,
0.0641442314,
0.0113293286,
-0.04157947,
-0.0205829311,
-0.0127664451,
-0.0148716606,
-0.0541607365,
0.0303809848,
-0.0277095232,
0.0182111058,
0.0053851563,
0.0224274173,
0.0073091723,
0.0234323386,
-0.0749114454,
0.0470276996,
0.0483976305,
0.0305648632,
-0.0254912134,
0.0108233765,
-0.0527872257,
-0.0235026199,
-0.0860132873,
-0.0144829908,
-0.0029789726,
-0.0215065628,
-0.0380407237,
-0.0260581262,
0.0466167629,
-0.0402420014,
0.0316834189,
-0.0547665581,
0.0137757901,
-0.0003948471,
0.0279857032,
0.0428058878,
-0.0008711254,
-0.0128763933,
0.0069803456,
0.0753965825,
0.0670951754,
0.001987427,
0.0566885844,
-0.0801970586,
-0.0082522472,
-0.0140269706,
-0.0210585427,
0.0149655649,
-0.0194729082,
0.0075300727,
-0.0788455307,
-0.047389362,
0.0197108258,
0.0234107301,
0.016354287,
-0.0135761807,
-0.0268679745,
0.062096227,
-0.0405493192,
-0.0642084777,
-0.0136526469,
0.0305564962,
-0.0153412949,
-0.0334630571,
0.0100756017,
-5.518954793e-33,
-0.0069906102,
-0.0146004306,
-0.0092010563,
0.0138063915,
0.0134281609,
0.012249684,
0.0109866261,
0.0662121847,
-0.04240321,
0.0028391667,
-0.0031266208,
0.0009825777,
0.0211313739,
-0.0171792973,
-0.0112667596,
-0.0079690348,
0.0091481749,
0.0005259147,
0.006915608,
-0.0394551866,
0.0451982282,
0.0015389625,
0.0679234415,
-0.0837850124,
0.0395885557,
-0.0076298839,
0.0193331428,
0.0032956095,
0.066010952,
0.0275238808,
-0.0155942282,
0.0546578914,
0.0253598075,
-0.0028396805,
-0.0178019013,
0.0256133005,
-0.0447113812,
-0.0045423759,
0.0590034202,
0.0143507617,
0.0026892317,
-0.007534082,
0.0554257445,
0.0078049749,
-0.0500630848,
-0.0271916278,
0.0239873677,
-0.0114268539,
-0.0410569422,
0.0062254397,
-0.0637845397,
0.0306256004,
0.0063818684,
0.0091744335,
0.0314570367,
0.0453972183,
0.0020139327,
0.0324781649,
-0.0462067127,
-0.0098615773,
0.0480725616,
0.0699762106,
0.0296798851,
0.0209289864,
0.0234845635,
0.0539142899,
0.0790813491,
0.0322412103,
-0.0052568726,
-0.0634086132,
0.0904063582,
0.0138787404,
0.019441165,
0.0586167648,
0.0948947147,
-0.0412062816,
-0.037773978,
0.0207169075,
0.0417494439,
-0.0217625014,
0.0624725074,
0.0049582142,
-0.0897544622,
-0.0483538806,
-0.0442876518,
0.0095531661,
-0.0395449661,
-0.0203735046,
0.0308567267,
-0.0512524247,
0.0290273819,
-0.0049519492,
0.0389409922,
-0.0161819495,
0.0046133134,
-0.0144736338,
-0.0021297012,
0.0563873723,
-0.0224523582,
0.0256132632,
-0.0449194349,
-0.0297106076,
-0.023759298,
0.062774308,
0.0175685436,
-0.0191730503,
-0.0138336997,
-0.0110262688,
-0.0648562089,
-0.0223271474,
-0.0168178007,
-0.035131406,
0.0532393567,
-0.0296959896,
0.0645128042,
-0.0283793919,
-0.0085885059,
-0.0165893771,
0.0153228641,
-0.0091302618,
-0.0153818475,
0.0062291296,
-0.023093408,
-0.0004026506,
-0.0052203299,
-0.0386243872,
-0.0064975005,
-0.0221955534,
0.0506749526,
-0.0333340839,
-0.0155788269,
-0.0012005705,
2.441e-7,
0.0396123864,
0.0858790129,
-0.0282433629,
-0.0155829946,
0.003272905,
0.0323906764,
0.0231362395,
0.0031645375,
-0.0094189085,
-0.0169284288,
-0.0010097659,
-0.0070786504,
0.0514686592,
0.0322625861,
-0.0192587469,
-0.0791583806,
-0.0380942374,
0.0821658075,
-0.0124549065,
0.0198005307,
0.0041854633,
0.0511787832,
0.0208950732,
-0.0079046171,
0.0012504982,
-0.0405170061,
0.0352702364,
-0.0839790702,
-0.0035265423,
0.00728613,
0.0344459675,
-0.0031131296,
0.0567252934,
0.0470837653,
0.0036947438,
0.0038194584,
-0.0010856473,
0.0113163255,
0.010168747,
0.023356501,
0.0131046912,
0.0030879481,
-0.040309377,
-0.0851401985,
0.043255996,
0.003762261,
-0.0599017851,
0.0073183863,
-0.036311958,
0.0038888066,
0.0389310867,
0.0148143582,
0.0181626007,
0.0232074894,
0.040442694,
-0.0425600894,
-0.0223893188,
-0.0419532694,
-0.06255465,
0.0218832251,
-0.0291265398,
-0.037201643,
-0.0729686394,
0.0144293793,
0.0504284427,
-0.0656248853,
0.0091580674,
2.359445373e-34,
0.0356679522,
0.0047820988,
0.0305525586,
-0.006519611,
0.0281164236,
0.0021495419,
0.0374558419,
0.0098263891,
0.02547873,
-0.1104132384,
-0.0036127481
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09319v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09319v2 | Spoken Word2Vec: Learning Skipgram Embeddings from Speech | 2023-11-15T19:25:29 | 2024-07-01T21:08:18 | Mohammad Amaan Sayeed, Hanan Aldarmaki | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Text word embeddings that encode distributional semantics work by modeling
contextual similarities of frequently occurring words. Acoustic word
embeddings, on the other hand, typically encode low-level phonetic
similarities. Semantic embeddings for spoken words have been previously
explored using analogous algorithms to Word2Vec, but the resulting vectors
still mainly encoded phonetic rather than semantic features. In this paper, we
examine the assumptions and architectures used in previous works and show
experimentally how shallow skipgram-like algorithms fail to encode
distributional semantics when the input units are acoustically correlated. We
illustrate the potential of an alternative deep end-to-end variant of the model
and examine the effects on the resulting embeddings, showing positive results
of semantic relatedness in the embedding space. | [
-0.0223014206,
0.0734047815,
0.014141948,
0.0424847528,
-0.0173805188,
-0.0165907256,
-0.02807975,
-0.0003673236,
-0.0536996722,
-0.0049472651,
-0.0189352334,
-0.0065328609,
0.0353187285,
0.007406163,
0.0506929532,
-0.0271416567,
0.0544086099,
0.0149503155,
-0.0318694413,
-0.023050528,
0.0204988327,
0.0149106272,
-0.0116944332,
0.0614637509,
-0.0251466539,
0.0079501541,
-0.0160793364,
0.0216850676,
0.0220470149,
-0.0082630198,
-0.0536296368,
-0.0314319208,
0.0632076263,
-0.0074703558,
0.0000014764,
0.0237197932,
0.0256649144,
-0.0119965635,
-0.0184756219,
-0.0120563069,
0.0310334545,
-0.0226501469,
-0.0088116191,
0.0291532036,
0.0155976005,
-0.0395585336,
0.0348758884,
0.0092405342,
0.0239919741,
0.0198877845,
-0.0323188491,
-0.0486077443,
0.0352558643,
-0.0580514856,
0.0196189974,
0.0058311438,
-0.0218063053,
-0.0080140932,
-0.0036576919,
0.020500835,
-0.0582673065,
0.0409414433,
0.0077381437,
0.038680736,
0.0297107622,
0.0615710169,
-0.0561527647,
-0.0232747886,
0.0134536121,
0.0856278539,
-0.035465572,
0.0151320351,
0.0015452951,
-0.0070318808,
-0.0043406375,
0.0283601061,
-0.0150348525,
-0.015244958,
0.039082218,
0.0567994416,
0.0162711926,
0.0465827063,
0.037787769,
-0.0133976657,
-0.0245017409,
0.0024894802,
0.0283622667,
-0.0112874862,
-0.0005236228,
-0.0095372433,
-0.0127620641,
0.0095799631,
0.0113835502,
-0.0130595388,
0.0120415054,
0.0170533545,
-0.027502751,
0.0335262679,
0.0071619703,
0.0003392881,
0.0373536162,
0.0337285511,
-0.0526045337,
0.0273157842,
-0.0488720983,
0.0092929984,
-0.0338502824,
0.0521859378,
-0.0293019265,
-0.0261420347,
-0.0158232413,
-0.020579638,
-0.0200367495,
0.0095787253,
0.0056624953,
-0.0521397665,
-0.0056675021,
0.0025663362,
-0.0298277102,
0.0113137979,
-0.0138169974,
0.0460545123,
-0.0260996614,
0.0277236048,
0.0221220404,
0.0151523659,
-0.027991375,
0.0368002765,
-0.0440046191,
0.0067463648,
-0.0126319081,
0.0276677199,
0.0360662192,
0.0110202264,
0.0056515015,
0.0368108898,
0.0242898967,
-0.0414451025,
0.0345218927,
-0.0093525099,
-0.0337022692,
-0.0202699862,
-0.009364157,
-0.0785610378,
0.0530869626,
-0.0238934737,
-0.0284090489,
0.0023760833,
0.0037532283,
0.0150482412,
-0.0578403659,
0.0691924915,
0.071030505,
-0.0008546119,
0.0179573018,
0.0203814134,
0.0724502876,
0.0218360797,
0.0649470761,
-0.0367718749,
0.0262966957,
0.0019413413,
-0.0636895522,
0.0353448167,
0.0396494903,
0.0124564143,
-0.0472609363,
-0.0367840454,
0.0058311997,
0.0861826763,
0.0738315731,
0.0450488441,
-0.0516271181,
-0.0808997452,
0.0132361688,
0.0901565701,
0.0160616711,
-0.0322036706,
0.0411937833,
0.0052075796,
-0.0715455115,
0.0057108547,
-0.0080895238,
-0.0143973464,
0.0417352505,
0.0009799871,
0.0497063994,
-0.014631114,
-0.0496551171,
0.0225758553,
0.0094885407,
-0.035299398,
0.0234734453,
-0.0255014654,
0.0182205793,
0.036446698,
-0.0419044755,
0.0345411412,
0.0122885592,
-0.0361604802,
0.0031801683,
0.013718538,
0.0059846267,
0.0348607861,
0.0807435215,
0.0250227414,
0.0446491316,
-0.0203311928,
0.0048112469,
0.0500741638,
0.0179471429,
-0.0078607574,
0.0106571987,
-0.0402389765,
-0.035069719,
0.0036050789,
-0.0044338307,
0.0342823565,
-0.0097604459,
0.038481921,
0.0317905433,
-0.0484520905,
0.0448880643,
-0.0083593139,
-0.02083572,
0.0140288146,
-0.0054797367,
0.033876799,
0.019015979,
0.0259655565,
-0.0088865636,
0.0399801508,
0.0415754505,
-0.0641303733,
-0.0065852781,
-0.0103901802,
-0.0487416387,
-0.0783505365,
0.0159402434,
-0.0596923605,
0.0483836569,
0.0843038708,
-0.0280796643,
-0.0285125989,
0.0062717316,
-0.0031332872,
0.1219348684,
-0.0323900804,
-0.0095405886,
-0.0080184815,
0.0606338568,
0.0189127661,
0.0201160014,
-0.0496748984,
0.0218562968,
-0.0153908059,
0.0923019648,
0.0161076728,
-0.0178444274,
-0.0476835184,
0.0583639368,
0.0382680111,
-0.0158822332,
-0.003427062,
-0.0300368667,
-0.0195222348,
-0.0123759722,
-0.0888460726,
0.0031926469,
0.0252276622,
-0.0004680632,
0.0071831984,
-0.0172270332,
0.033883594,
-0.0044378564,
-0.0565769896,
0.0407444499,
-0.0096196942,
0.0218873732,
0.0013477253,
-0.034470126,
-0.0647953078,
-0.034972433,
-0.0305868443,
-0.001784165,
0.0332647264,
-0.0387227498,
0.0256262962,
-0.0198026542,
0.0304730684,
-0.0494855605,
-0.0095275566,
-0.0059267534,
-0.0201720037,
-0.0098565863,
-0.0077976282,
0.0343497209,
0.0096497936,
0.0096100466,
0.045239199,
0.0060606813,
0.0108607626,
-0.0253403373,
-0.0358235277,
-0.0207610559,
0.0306709129,
-0.0315711237,
0.0058580134,
-0.0785870254,
0.049770385,
0.0494258702,
0.0173497628,
-0.0232135989,
-0.0411770754,
-0.007301826,
-0.031337928,
-0.041285608,
-0.0411448032,
-0.0494953766,
-0.0300976578,
-0.0444123186,
-0.0475230478,
0.0371811762,
-0.0330641791,
-0.0014583393,
-0.0429704674,
-0.0261374358,
-0.011293144,
0.0653233007,
0.0039675487,
0.0118335253,
-0.0570278279,
-0.0276980381,
-0.0542033948,
0.0083877407,
-0.0167033486,
-0.0541965775,
0.0082837278,
0.0409492552,
-0.0299867596,
-0.0054734144,
-0.0355134122,
-0.0242149308,
-0.0737539381,
-0.0435177982,
0.0414100476,
0.0164657589,
-0.0459268019,
-0.0364083126,
0.0189465787,
-0.013538315,
0.0113962395,
0.0214479212,
-0.0015740322,
-0.0297353566,
0.0546539389,
0.0369514376,
0.0145035796,
-0.0393645875,
0.0357114375,
0.0132437302,
0.0209308937,
0.0650739893,
0.0165381581,
-0.0279115029,
0.0124134235,
0.015688533,
0.0370291881,
-0.0664805025,
-0.0233277958,
0.0001102126,
-0.0107160797,
-0.0355727784,
0.0654026046,
0.0067011975,
0.0015353683,
0.019321369,
0.0007476013,
0.055036705,
0.013434723,
-0.0276425499,
-0.0713654608,
-0.0714467391,
0.0316937529,
0.0050155222,
0.0475814193,
0.006573291,
-0.0076376889,
-0.0825353861,
0.0135516599,
0.0307821352,
-0.0668513626,
-0.0155099984,
-0.046652656,
0.010691748,
0.0189762935,
-0.0158682857,
-0.0214293953,
0.0097429547,
-0.0359904505,
0.0026138863,
-0.0382813364,
-0.0011050694,
0.0545670204,
-0.0285698548,
0.0277368706,
0.0728475004,
0.0619175658,
-0.0141321672,
-0.0207757261,
0.0159199126,
-0.0795756951,
-0.0306397527,
0.0053598187,
0.0430708714,
-0.0480893143,
-0.0283109322,
0.0017035682,
0.0403655358,
-0.0327069424,
0.0126658976,
-0.0504001342,
0.0849632248,
-0.0164835695,
-0.0191139746,
-0.0602694154,
0.0379806124,
0.0065101455,
0.0964070708,
0.0320586972,
-0.0338319317,
-0.0063060466,
0.0072668777,
0.0247600265,
0.0118742073,
-0.0266163331,
0.0024143369,
0.0438967608,
-0.0437667035,
-0.0513970777,
-0.0486001968,
-0.0288795754,
0.0101957023,
-0.0115663456,
0.031340003,
-0.0019879821,
-0.0610087141,
-0.0651127845,
-0.0085852873,
-0.0038641132,
0.0707016736,
-0.0294715371,
-0.006975288,
0.0667466968,
-0.0028374065,
-0.0532978587,
0.008446455,
-0.0652819052,
-0.0314224884,
-0.02400502,
-0.0150302118,
0.0045588617,
0.0624960698,
-0.030432269,
0.0094867246,
0.0936681926,
-0.0118984431,
-0.0464566872,
0.0439690091,
0.0308626574,
-0.0008995591,
-0.01117648,
0.0448901132,
-0.052357059,
0.0114234453,
-0.0279237721,
0.0305058435,
0.0212572534,
-0.0614481457,
-0.0112046152,
-0.0621913262,
0.0415178984,
-0.0126962503,
0.00932875,
-0.0431340523,
-0.0080801975,
0.0156751517,
0.0365557335,
-0.0547351576,
0.0088602072,
0.0512310676,
0.01193853,
-0.0140201263,
-0.0362336747,
-0.021931475,
0.0412669927,
0.0335516222,
0.0408150107,
0.0177136045,
0.0057742563,
-0.0083520515,
0.0201265868,
-0.0157360975,
0.0052662445,
-0.0576522574,
-0.0104057807,
-0.0291031823,
0.0115152001,
0.008608303,
0.0065788343,
-0.0130759794,
0.0263199843,
-0.0312095154,
-0.0039699026,
0.0028132854,
0.0101860492,
0.0040671444,
-0.033973638,
0.0023304606,
-0.0134388469,
0.0009837346,
-0.0162146203,
0.0001596951,
-0.0768203959,
-0.0419034325,
0.0600656383,
0.0250067748,
-0.020023901,
0.0204768609,
0.030117048,
0.0115179112,
0.0553821437,
-0.060286019,
0.0135441627,
-0.0112378597,
-0.0070983213,
0.0268434379,
0.0786177814,
-0.0075950962,
0.009835884,
-0.0580308251,
-0.0924859643,
-0.0086858114,
-0.0024925189,
-0.0333603323,
0.0378619507,
0.0504996553,
0.0259556901,
-0.0203059036,
0.0406983942,
0.0179563034,
-0.0008357507,
-0.0176953822,
-0.0436000414,
0.0109695066,
-5.057822318e-33,
-0.0122923162,
-0.0006630148,
-0.0202879291,
0.0136633553,
-0.0397787094,
0.0081757624,
-0.0376932174,
-0.0011050162,
-0.0266505368,
0.0398901403,
0.0074657244,
0.0456875674,
-0.0015334656,
0.0084417937,
0.0018732894,
-0.008624766,
0.0279557686,
-0.0133299055,
-0.0077674012,
-0.0025671215,
0.0713542402,
0.0410750732,
0.0334949158,
-0.0580041036,
-0.015077766,
-0.022573119,
0.0599167496,
-0.0044344431,
0.0460281521,
0.0613310486,
-0.0523574948,
0.0526933894,
0.0038485108,
-0.0082517369,
-0.0256604254,
0.0711350143,
-0.089318566,
-0.0235138126,
0.0049808854,
-0.0045949263,
-0.0375680737,
0.0066876803,
0.0319178365,
-0.013291521,
0.0178214479,
-0.0385571457,
0.0281099156,
-0.0060731904,
-0.0424921103,
0.023260856,
-0.0304657537,
0.0262392033,
-0.000737957,
-0.0333326124,
0.0356378108,
-0.0072268425,
0.0467210598,
-0.0016737889,
-0.0249449704,
0.0299647134,
-0.0551680438,
0.0185464714,
0.0421433449,
0.0088118752,
0.0111242235,
0.0870761797,
0.0517089739,
-0.1092128307,
0.0168056842,
-0.02000059,
0.0263891909,
0.0112873456,
-0.0041701375,
0.0199098457,
0.0499164052,
-0.0389746502,
-0.0245873816,
-0.0210931487,
-0.0185465422,
0.0065689241,
0.0213314202,
0.0246928968,
-0.0609346665,
-0.0166018307,
-0.0439200699,
-0.0178822726,
-0.0243670903,
-0.0325762592,
0.0687653497,
0.0096052047,
0.0521873161,
0.0312785581,
0.0423871838,
-0.0343471915,
-0.015591288,
0.0753142759,
-0.0033783477,
-0.0152957737,
0.0164795648,
0.0191181041,
-0.0121702896,
-0.0396887586,
0.0422826968,
0.0010413002,
0.0197123438,
-0.0021525493,
-0.0004621394,
0.0227433983,
-0.0336134806,
-0.0252636578,
-0.0186196193,
-0.0746505633,
-0.0441430882,
-0.0125007583,
0.0517921411,
0.019880645,
-0.028405007,
0.0272653662,
-0.0104509331,
0.029606672,
-0.0140998894,
-0.0210529007,
-0.0239779335,
0.0509984121,
-0.0029841154,
-0.005158402,
-0.0247449726,
0.0212627258,
0.0457993187,
-0.0480049103,
-0.0044240216,
-0.0046360129,
2.228e-7,
0.0223045647,
-0.0492396504,
0.0169112105,
-0.0376621075,
0.0218265466,
0.0091473721,
-0.0077903671,
0.0176664405,
-0.0739405602,
-0.0307313409,
0.012936594,
0.0300519839,
0.055456657,
-0.0347821228,
-0.0618733503,
0.0590598397,
-0.0624794327,
0.0374700762,
-0.0454844683,
-0.0267756712,
0.0341867544,
0.1373797208,
0.0388608053,
-0.0322330147,
0.0119482744,
-0.0184824709,
0.026321467,
-0.040740449,
0.0109946141,
-0.072833091,
-0.0198164862,
0.0272276737,
0.0222688913,
0.0095377564,
-0.0212987792,
0.0710253045,
0.0804696903,
0.0165425427,
-0.0015387384,
-0.0314268246,
-0.0059551154,
-0.0006818752,
-0.0388093218,
0.0005501763,
0.0434142947,
-0.0121914754,
-0.0400580913,
-0.0085437018,
-0.0091816364,
0.0314512998,
0.0777475089,
0.0072033019,
-0.0527219847,
-0.0433310568,
0.0605265163,
-0.0223247968,
-0.0075646206,
-0.106122531,
0.0177376196,
0.0596047789,
-0.0669792369,
-0.0119356383,
-0.0369071215,
-0.0023405005,
0.0592985898,
-0.0071443329,
-0.0303930901,
1.7424083e-34,
0.0069295904,
0.0035961615,
0.0086740172,
-0.0150959315,
-0.0169971734,
-0.034908805,
0.0488287807,
0.0093845604,
0.0465916209,
-0.0346536152,
-0.0389844477
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.10771v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.10771v2 | Automatic Restoration of Diacritics for Speech Data Sets | 2023-11-15T19:24:54 | 2024-04-07T00:48:10 | Sara Shatnawi, Sawsan Alqahtani, Hanan Aldarmaki | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD | Automatic text-based diacritic restoration models generally have high
diacritic error rates when applied to speech transcripts as a result of domain
and style shifts in spoken language. In this work, we explore the possibility
of improving the performance of automatic diacritic restoration when applied to
speech data by utilizing parallel spoken utterances. In particular, we use the
pre-trained Whisper ASR model fine-tuned on relatively small amounts of
diacritized Arabic speech data to produce rough diacritized transcripts for the
speech utterances, which we then use as an additional input for diacritic
restoration models. The proposed framework consistently improves diacritic
restoration performance compared to text-only baselines. Our results highlight
the inadequacy of current text-based diacritic restoration models for speech
data sets and provide a new baseline for speech-based diacritic restoration. | [
-0.041060634,
0.1006358936,
0.0064237919,
-0.0006027074,
-0.0239905734,
0.0006369538,
0.0449505597,
0.0281316917,
-0.054286398,
-0.0255254786,
-0.0261493716,
-0.0708935186,
0.0578353666,
-0.0078884624,
0.0517800674,
-0.0340063497,
0.0044212202,
-0.0759300143,
-0.0101690842,
-0.0299682338,
0.0579217821,
-0.0048573716,
-0.0293923561,
0.0353696831,
-0.0385151468,
-0.0110045327,
0.0214718971,
0.0133792916,
0.0123208603,
0.0395437628,
0.0368738845,
0.0192959104,
-0.004677048,
0.0092623606,
0.0000017301,
-0.0403314531,
-0.0517117567,
0.0258187335,
-0.0193448029,
0.010064627,
0.0190511141,
0.0019626163,
-0.0575396642,
0.0417979211,
-0.003090377,
-0.0287704449,
0.0455712117,
0.0261826143,
0.0219696183,
0.0259200856,
-0.0202317648,
-0.0663530156,
0.0218573064,
-0.0137943691,
-0.0686650276,
0.0226014741,
0.0369616598,
-0.0378621779,
-0.0916739628,
-0.0316418037,
0.0274064429,
0.0452321656,
-0.0375410505,
-0.0344185717,
-0.0268834773,
-0.0487356707,
0.0002459865,
-0.0327180885,
0.00738572,
0.0086497962,
-0.0311354734,
-0.027952224,
0.0272226781,
0.0181963816,
0.0143622793,
-0.0269104969,
-0.0168243144,
-0.0187719576,
0.0083746733,
0.0006172878,
-0.0105275214,
-0.0100288466,
0.0236418135,
-0.0342827849,
-0.0262752343,
-0.0080845281,
0.0200052075,
-0.03551884,
-0.0254669748,
-0.0253339037,
0.016262155,
0.0330058634,
0.0880906656,
0.0086685335,
-0.0166299082,
-0.0004992666,
-0.0093011996,
-0.0376523659,
0.0155938091,
0.0126809124,
0.0441101156,
0.0556877032,
-0.0542357378,
-0.0497659221,
-0.0235786978,
0.0400700606,
0.033437714,
0.0164599046,
-0.000744657,
-0.0373736024,
-0.0023947302,
0.0284309369,
-0.0374477319,
0.0335325412,
0.0029278516,
0.035967391,
-0.054261703,
-0.015922118,
-0.0262592733,
0.0091268644,
0.0455585495,
-0.0339489505,
-0.0756774619,
-0.0613058954,
0.0681050941,
0.0039873729,
0.0179339983,
0.0957705379,
-0.0059850547,
-0.0411204211,
-0.0189622864,
-0.0068644197,
0.0514734946,
0.0427804776,
0.0156113338,
0.0544976667,
-0.0073516667,
-0.0092316018,
-0.0442755893,
0.0037552707,
-0.0618688352,
-0.0187450331,
-0.0539631285,
-0.0425140373,
0.0102555836,
-0.0058047976,
-0.0075811376,
-0.0624782294,
-0.0015904146,
-0.0124586513,
0.0139355026,
0.0675075352,
-0.010977855,
-0.0053498312,
0.0697965845,
-0.0280453451,
-0.0047673224,
0.0245575737,
0.0447856188,
0.000944606,
-0.0048980438,
-0.030284347,
0.0174268167,
0.1083323434,
0.0218423195,
0.0190612413,
-0.0566539653,
-0.0179104768,
0.0441897325,
0.0213889275,
0.0481009372,
0.0668246523,
-0.0436294749,
-0.0406241082,
0.0549467355,
0.052504167,
0.0439327918,
0.0123463739,
0.0136301257,
-0.0086749839,
0.012076051,
0.0460069105,
0.0183774382,
-0.0726948678,
0.0069873496,
0.0170147344,
0.051948078,
0.0389980115,
-0.0223354045,
-0.0244153012,
0.0134112854,
-0.0486782379,
-0.0091708954,
0.0353032313,
0.0773324743,
0.0617903434,
-0.0539693311,
0.0258152895,
0.0299260933,
-0.0633388609,
0.0040273,
-0.057718467,
-0.0161739122,
0.0302524511,
0.0493654795,
-0.0487695523,
-0.0220190994,
-0.0542734414,
-0.0518983863,
0.0177483037,
-0.0335457027,
-0.0129071651,
0.0488702059,
-0.0999139175,
0.0327215977,
0.0627493784,
0.0135266725,
0.0300103817,
-0.0252745636,
0.0323610678,
-0.032769233,
-0.0032612926,
-0.053071972,
0.0079837199,
-0.018591458,
0.0369905867,
0.0533382334,
0.0013845687,
0.0246575661,
0.0410171784,
-0.0399429016,
-0.0043659806,
0.0354244448,
-0.0459396765,
-0.0158911385,
0.0159276389,
-0.0601654202,
0.0047735632,
0.0831063017,
0.0128356814,
0.0198271498,
0.0415823571,
0.0506161861,
-0.0652511269,
0.0269963108,
-0.012118523,
-0.0163250584,
-0.1008485481,
0.0643730834,
-0.0153238801,
0.0359557532,
-0.0086273495,
-0.0529531837,
0.0246171597,
-0.0233543813,
-0.0343811959,
-0.0158091672,
0.0135827083,
-0.0440506376,
0.0113549447,
-0.0222469103,
-0.0520871058,
0.0636527836,
0.0269111544,
-0.0448087081,
0.0159240663,
-0.0354545042,
-0.0070425957,
0.0132880844,
-0.0541656092,
0.035481561,
-0.0291526709,
0.0469639115,
-0.0066103875,
-0.0368422195,
0.011730562,
-0.0095227528,
0.0216730349,
-0.0240632314,
0.0281037409,
-0.0279265884,
-0.0172534212,
-0.0539180115,
0.0073894686,
0.0326482505,
-0.0182535686,
-0.0298629403,
-0.0194183625,
-0.058497455,
0.071440734,
0.039014101,
0.0427266806,
0.0073615015,
-0.0892556235,
0.0079778712,
0.0274610333,
0.0388243832,
0.0246093031,
-0.0110265985,
-0.0183307491,
-0.0271443818,
-0.0062253121,
-0.0529771447,
-0.0117137022,
0.030312784,
0.0321006365,
-0.0341556743,
-0.0164256524,
-0.0131579861,
0.0002660613,
-0.0003134896,
0.0173190441,
-0.0113357594,
-0.0061303638,
0.0304089319,
-0.0038369924,
0.0300650392,
-0.0513236634,
-0.0242228843,
0.0315279365,
0.0110778678,
-0.0198309403,
0.0154674016,
-0.0713690892,
-0.0170289148,
0.0063409181,
-0.0325945728,
0.0074706799,
-0.0465588048,
-0.0296935439,
0.0111505464,
0.0125078317,
-0.0819478631,
-0.039275378,
-0.0302688219,
0.0337856971,
-0.0564033613,
0.0031452912,
-0.003069639,
0.0128502417,
-0.018884331,
-0.05541135,
-0.0004516937,
0.0148781044,
-0.0271928236,
0.0224641245,
0.0084351068,
-0.0537296645,
-0.0428907424,
0.0264501683,
0.0076579535,
0.0473563746,
0.0127717275,
0.0227933917,
0.0023832198,
0.0171876866,
0.0067838002,
-0.0151300514,
-0.010538809,
-0.0370736346,
0.0463780127,
0.0028672481,
0.0151663069,
0.0412470661,
-0.036607217,
-0.0416829921,
0.0428365767,
-0.0056798649,
0.0091154128,
-0.0276138391,
0.0282873139,
-0.008073993,
0.0176896583,
0.0556120388,
-0.0400405973,
-0.0598687455,
-0.0284002144,
0.017636098,
-0.0246958472,
-0.0234789867,
-0.0661199987,
-0.0581271872,
-0.0074942377,
0.0867281631,
0.0416053906,
0.013611123,
0.0300111398,
0.0361384042,
-0.050468415,
0.0171310641,
0.0139876418,
-0.041441381,
-0.0441829227,
-0.0555234626,
-0.0017743384,
-0.0272183921,
0.0719669461,
0.0163229425,
0.0279983543,
-0.006381005,
0.059378013,
-0.0610179566,
-0.0492268503,
-0.0140772806,
-0.0666803718,
0.0845338404,
0.0435935259,
0.0101115769,
-0.0133031709,
-0.0105207153,
-0.0089006759,
-0.0087458836,
-0.0259914827,
0.0076371334,
0.0627280474,
0.0357983187,
-0.0068127825,
-0.0014055346,
0.0207228605,
-0.026069928,
-0.0121682081,
0.0418301634,
-0.0226316098,
0.0028790878,
0.0299406704,
0.026705116,
0.0004153695,
-0.0041508107,
0.0284460727,
-0.0126536749,
-0.0279271193,
-0.0082869623,
0.0068831919,
0.032526277,
-0.1064801812,
-0.0321705118,
0.0122186616,
0.0127210952,
-0.0382397026,
-0.0359836482,
-0.0372868143,
-0.0150621198,
0.0384889431,
0.0181569941,
0.022918703,
0.0178179871,
0.0260568969,
-0.0063701887,
-0.0465718284,
-0.0149376048,
0.0333911814,
-0.0547998995,
-0.0117202187,
-0.0143703455,
-0.0525553524,
0.0221925881,
-0.0322436541,
-0.0145629179,
-0.0568368547,
0.0822048485,
-0.0040938375,
0.01806961,
0.020449521,
-0.0367173254,
-0.0867308378,
0.0590457171,
0.0271926075,
-0.0503845699,
-0.0065354132,
0.0535070486,
-0.0569879115,
-0.0301457178,
0.0443323813,
-0.0169915818,
0.0212053414,
0.018429013,
-0.0143874642,
-0.0229967032,
-0.081916526,
-0.0052585299,
0.0002448704,
0.0103416285,
-0.0121433949,
-0.0449810438,
-0.0416540653,
0.0132126138,
0.006786047,
0.0700941831,
-0.0137965558,
0.035561163,
0.0242080819,
0.0120406365,
-0.0018428795,
-0.0439918004,
-0.0466739014,
-0.0366041362,
-0.050368052,
0.0130801992,
0.0440036058,
0.0276287496,
0.0226316638,
0.0070752911,
0.0107223587,
0.0395290665,
0.0342888944,
0.0334026963,
0.0175722912,
-0.0422003381,
-0.0243813898,
0.0372464173,
-0.0117370337,
0.021883728,
-0.0138688646,
-0.0029449915,
-0.0113722617,
0.0326706693,
0.063840799,
0.0288483128,
0.0568183288,
0.0203828346,
0.0136480285,
-0.0434980765,
-0.0305962022,
0.0039360207,
0.0687651113,
-0.0407815054,
-0.0045595509,
-0.0282586757,
0.0593841746,
0.0378163457,
-0.0238982346,
0.0357915871,
-0.0020635331,
0.011307817,
-0.0213076249,
-0.03668648,
-0.0045564608,
-0.0080919042,
-0.0460216999,
-0.0503296778,
0.0118394243,
-0.0692771301,
0.0674759522,
-0.0159099065,
0.0175507106,
-0.0228668414,
-0.0261656009,
0.0073995716,
-0.0314224586,
0.0321088992,
0.0114236744,
-0.0163750853,
0.0002941732,
-0.0390512496,
0.0156858042,
-5.348522071e-33,
0.033863958,
0.039589975,
-0.0083215516,
0.0337361209,
-0.0170160271,
-0.008938143,
0.0252618715,
-0.0044980682,
0.0037071782,
0.0369435251,
-0.0309656598,
0.0216832459,
0.0326893516,
-0.020771198,
0.0192852728,
0.0245084018,
0.0792656913,
-0.020889584,
-0.0061078486,
-0.002179737,
0.0216535274,
0.1004466563,
0.0281252116,
-0.0317145735,
-0.0114533557,
-0.0317718387,
-0.0324334614,
-0.0269889254,
0.009639062,
0.0236009359,
0.0150764072,
0.0474839136,
-0.0097089717,
0.0112642702,
-0.0361641087,
0.0158309694,
-0.0616066456,
0.0587930791,
0.0039396905,
0.0671214908,
0.0527224876,
-0.0258769561,
0.0371342599,
-0.0111234216,
-0.0600464791,
0.0064147823,
-0.0056330538,
-0.0487985089,
0.0070706527,
-0.0150307612,
-0.0187483858,
0.0446184315,
-0.0047086771,
-0.0457095578,
0.0954754129,
0.0038954893,
-0.008618718,
-0.0390868932,
-0.0442038924,
0.0201643314,
0.001789715,
0.0724780038,
-0.0234016944,
0.0185122024,
-0.0626517236,
-0.015026575,
0.1032956839,
-0.0288857706,
0.0750804767,
-0.0406254865,
0.0138208354,
-0.0177379958,
0.0211413614,
0.0762251467,
0.0301242378,
-0.0537837707,
-0.0658501014,
0.0129091935,
-0.0244095735,
0.0210721716,
0.0281550232,
0.0601140894,
-0.0197855998,
0.0178048704,
-0.0335980132,
-0.0145310964,
0.0053016329,
0.0155281704,
-0.0052186381,
-0.0009611461,
-0.0013980453,
0.0469731353,
0.0211157072,
0.0000653668,
0.0161978249,
-0.0098464992,
-0.006460418,
-0.0289660189,
-0.0317684561,
0.0455816388,
0.0419213958,
-0.0374924466,
0.0439987443,
0.0738406926,
-0.0111851748,
-0.0200830176,
0.0115553373,
0.0313393548,
-0.0669260249,
0.0161579698,
-0.0000859802,
0.0392906517,
0.0385913067,
0.0408451483,
-0.0037596063,
0.0325426571,
0.0344595313,
0.0091200974,
0.0022847813,
0.0095515298,
0.0288489386,
0.0376404002,
-0.00195941,
0.0010020328,
-0.0490601473,
-0.0137682827,
0.0161201712,
-0.024945844,
-0.0221101176,
-0.024013998,
-0.0171368979,
-0.0463365652,
2.5e-7,
0.0104497653,
0.0296454579,
0.0549526885,
-0.0321388915,
0.0109583242,
0.0159719642,
-0.0042161848,
-0.0443383567,
0.0543677658,
0.0507651083,
-0.0039798673,
-0.0300654564,
0.1169567928,
0.008422167,
-0.0738995597,
-0.0353675149,
-0.0329730287,
0.0066640843,
-0.0060739289,
0.0039718864,
-0.023252137,
0.0237313192,
-0.0541417152,
-0.0361297503,
-0.0006680457,
-0.0173231792,
-0.0006291758,
0.0015658297,
-0.0368725099,
0.0227956828,
0.0160753895,
-0.0226113424,
0.0121464673,
0.0162401777,
-0.0247043185,
0.0374513939,
0.0205138214,
0.0282741543,
-0.0180996042,
-0.0075165993,
0.0112500712,
0.0251610111,
-0.030243054,
-0.0293908119,
0.0215022881,
0.0490004607,
0.0218562204,
-0.0218173377,
-0.0767604038,
0.0320799612,
0.0499989055,
-0.0310586412,
0.0132494103,
0.0300504714,
0.0160684455,
0.0782064572,
-0.0063204612,
-0.0119978283,
0.0156565532,
-0.0217927713,
-0.0186418742,
0.0236587878,
0.0021451539,
-0.0118552018,
-0.0081974138,
-0.0445992351,
0.0295110624,
1.831414e-34,
0.0285004172,
-0.0226419736,
0.0300299935,
0.0292448793,
-0.0002580712,
-0.060081359,
0.050736431,
0.0444807746,
-0.0305850767,
-0.0249769092,
-0.0391139016
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09308v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09308v2 | Divergences between Language Models and Human Brains | 2023-11-15T19:02:40 | 2024-02-05T02:21:59 | Yuchen Zhou, Emmy Liu, Graham Neubig, Michael J. Tarr, Leila Wehbe | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, q-bio.NC | Do machines and humans process language in similar ways? Recent research has
hinted in the affirmative, finding that brain signals can be effectively
predicted using the internal representations of language models (LMs). Although
such results are thought to reflect shared computational principles between LMs
and human brains, there are also clear differences in how LMs and humans
represent and use language. In this work, we systematically explore the
divergences between human and machine language processing by examining the
differences between LM representations and human brain responses to language as
measured by Magnetoencephalography (MEG) across two datasets in which subjects
read and listened to narrative stories. Using a data-driven approach, we
identify two domains that are not captured well by LMs: social/emotional
intelligence and physical commonsense. We then validate these domains with
human behavioral experiments and show that fine-tuning LMs on these domains can
improve their alignment with human brain responses. | [
0.0280265491,
0.0485798493,
-0.0631202608,
0.0036247631,
-0.0239859428,
0.0435750447,
-0.0409451164,
0.035442438,
0.0222130753,
-0.0297486726,
-0.0526397079,
0.0151615944,
0.0307117756,
0.0384684801,
0.0539191775,
-0.0324642099,
0.0017493871,
-0.0041406672,
0.035621196,
-0.0205585416,
-0.0240158662,
0.0202410836,
-0.0078167673,
0.0118299546,
0.0342272222,
-0.0052557392,
-0.0035766289,
-0.0318818651,
-0.0183368865,
0.0025871454,
-0.0319966301,
0.075312525,
0.0306222364,
0.0062423572,
0.0000017867,
-0.0373778269,
0.0990763605,
-0.0233413801,
0.0374116674,
-0.0046669249,
0.0396934822,
-0.0088183908,
0.013962606,
-0.0150246741,
-0.0252756458,
0.0165413786,
-0.0075431736,
0.0996745676,
-0.0110355252,
0.0445268489,
-0.0382985994,
-0.0049100346,
0.0381885432,
-0.0170502812,
0.0222363342,
0.0249300729,
0.0281699002,
-0.0028471097,
0.0127656376,
-0.0028498473,
-0.0211914685,
0.0188014545,
-0.0117792934,
0.0206543691,
-0.0148413666,
0.0624379963,
0.0148584042,
-0.0035097073,
-0.0278870873,
0.0694946721,
0.0394440293,
-0.0459567904,
0.0035796093,
0.0021640107,
0.0156322736,
0.0192913096,
-0.0284661353,
0.0314404368,
0.0326994769,
0.0232451949,
0.015963776,
-0.0430429392,
0.0135742305,
0.0271362849,
0.0468105301,
0.0422147252,
-0.0065140035,
-0.0121113649,
0.0105281323,
0.0197597016,
0.0072304569,
-0.043316856,
0.0252814926,
0.00760723,
-0.0021365597,
-0.0173164941,
-0.0357290693,
0.012581964,
0.0154633494,
-0.0574534498,
0.0234801974,
0.0361134149,
-0.0142524727,
0.0133278398,
0.0088730166,
0.0705015883,
-0.0195826292,
0.0679349452,
-0.0101653514,
0.0262760986,
-0.0550139248,
-0.043927867,
0.0298446231,
-0.006423268,
-0.0286897048,
-0.0256889369,
-0.0168330632,
0.0059720958,
-0.0215877034,
-0.0765153021,
-0.0542597547,
0.0318500027,
-0.0003030204,
0.0208378043,
-0.0717620701,
-0.0009394727,
-0.0143892616,
0.0578264967,
0.008177273,
-0.0350461081,
-0.0008116011,
0.0045946641,
-0.0230475198,
-0.0168594345,
0.0315301828,
0.0531726442,
-0.0071641714,
-0.0179804843,
-0.0344622806,
0.0150846737,
0.0149701275,
-0.0430324152,
0.0297434125,
-0.0306457616,
0.0417564064,
0.032511726,
-0.0415844247,
-0.0577076636,
-0.0146176741,
0.0142146377,
-0.0746501908,
0.0217479039,
0.0033518616,
0.0215421803,
0.0646555424,
0.0350336023,
-0.0029735663,
0.0058474797,
0.0497095473,
-0.017921323,
0.0001248589,
0.0037222866,
0.0042015743,
0.012944649,
-0.0304927826,
-0.0225652605,
-0.0654041171,
-0.0284027401,
-0.0244364589,
0.0384502038,
0.0801858678,
0.035200078,
-0.0035087054,
-0.037361484,
0.0849782899,
0.1031297892,
-0.033066079,
0.0363888927,
-0.0322194025,
0.0075625288,
0.0243118871,
-0.00788006,
-0.0492435768,
0.0200945809,
0.0045091212,
-0.0169079918,
0.0225682296,
-0.018332487,
-0.0163503569,
0.0283357929,
-0.0109209446,
-0.0097077563,
0.0476894341,
0.0084858974,
0.00784605,
-0.0472085401,
-0.0173132848,
-0.0030655332,
0.0482618399,
-0.0090514738,
-0.000192069,
-0.0242184494,
0.0234756041,
0.0192078445,
-0.0007003829,
0.0235646572,
0.0003905013,
0.0024662118,
-0.0132659478,
0.0770998374,
0.0457331613,
0.007353826,
0.0284430254,
-0.0044354736,
0.0225844178,
0.0160341319,
0.0074780169,
-0.0122971535,
-0.0241296403,
-0.0053925398,
-0.0285142101,
-0.0026740299,
-0.0464517735,
0.0611855835,
-0.0690952912,
0.004265591,
-0.0604491234,
-0.0223119203,
0.0522884838,
-0.0048861783,
-0.0105013661,
-0.0009571746,
0.02045306,
-0.0041657966,
-0.0364572816,
0.0359147303,
-0.035386838,
0.0070904526,
0.0459814891,
-0.0216218121,
-0.0395685509,
0.0531000197,
0.0325836055,
0.0056461897,
0.0162569098,
-0.0942839906,
0.0157407913,
-0.0287208427,
-0.0158362053,
-0.0663518235,
0.038502574,
-0.0238760449,
0.0256030727,
-0.0175447073,
0.0106534855,
0.0153253265,
-0.0326253846,
-0.0190649368,
-0.0299702566,
-0.0260483511,
0.03312755,
0.0240207706,
-0.0111998348,
-0.0234372225,
-0.0458696075,
-0.0514529236,
0.0029456264,
-0.0627262667,
-0.0137173729,
0.0698138401,
-0.008228478,
0.033458896,
-0.0441294611,
-0.0376088396,
0.0249057803,
-0.0093186777,
0.0008734862,
0.0337518863,
0.0359243788,
0.0138766738,
-0.0314190276,
-0.0025066701,
-0.0061880094,
0.0315035582,
-0.0736380294,
0.0341289155,
-0.0045481571,
0.0218016561,
-0.052195061,
0.0347757488,
-0.0499880575,
0.0244059823,
-0.0220514219,
-0.0442233458,
0.0407051742,
0.0262439698,
0.0664642751,
0.0747080222,
0.0404404588,
0.067400679,
0.0800777748,
-0.0095918262,
-0.0336674862,
-0.0355362371,
-0.0089094723,
0.0671677738,
-0.0307358094,
-0.0488296971,
-0.0021659331,
0.104195103,
0.0485162735,
0.0375790447,
-0.0018463774,
0.0107531697,
0.0258398131,
-0.0588752925,
0.0149230016,
-0.0098593868,
-0.0584039316,
0.0692057982,
-0.0268411469,
-0.0376185849,
0.0772621781,
-0.0142180528,
-0.002156161,
-0.0170751996,
-0.0123237139,
0.0064311624,
0.0484691188,
-0.0106179146,
0.0075134323,
-0.0112151504,
-0.0106153497,
-0.0388284475,
-0.0347059891,
-0.0170105286,
-0.0314437523,
-0.0069979527,
-0.0179624427,
-0.0395236462,
0.0270283688,
0.0299958009,
-0.0276052356,
-0.0062875906,
-0.0480147675,
0.0009649019,
-0.0065496517,
0.0055855438,
-0.0770964921,
-0.0259364378,
0.0545140579,
-0.0024703173,
-0.0189460572,
-0.01664708,
0.0120528564,
0.0046623289,
0.057026457,
0.0543545447,
0.0246910583,
-0.0336018726,
0.0190050565,
0.0399542153,
-0.0323198251,
0.0352436118,
-0.0237780791,
0.0353075191,
0.0333067141,
0.0265230332,
-0.0072067161,
0.0285752229,
0.0428208038,
-0.0052570081,
-0.0141552826,
0.1070201099,
0.015108631,
-0.0188061651,
0.0248476081,
-0.0192325618,
0.000734431,
0.01840345,
0.0286957044,
-0.0209624022,
-0.0154944491,
0.0096069174,
0.0189933814,
-0.0177994817,
-0.0309199058,
0.009348195,
-0.0540172085,
0.0230804477,
-0.0260752141,
-0.0718515888,
-0.0863398165,
-0.0620974191,
0.0220309012,
0.0236510374,
0.0188702662,
-0.0203175992,
0.0149356239,
-0.0003923792,
-0.0165601019,
0.0093141124,
-0.036682874,
0.02869647,
-0.0255890954,
0.088076517,
0.0229668841,
0.0796576738,
-0.0322486386,
-0.0514033623,
-0.0034118551,
0.0477348864,
0.0182137825,
-0.0205092821,
0.0091431253,
0.016284639,
0.0200944822,
-0.0917926207,
0.0588503554,
-0.030577926,
-0.0738684833,
-0.0336459614,
0.0803363472,
-0.0318465419,
-0.0495488234,
-0.0135752941,
0.0611382127,
-0.0038572431,
0.0742096156,
0.0510673933,
-0.0654103979,
-0.0309430417,
-0.0066943644,
0.018979786,
0.035889186,
-0.0764397755,
-0.0003191779,
0.0038182486,
-0.0189165473,
-0.0411200151,
-0.0471095331,
-0.0216072593,
-0.0376993269,
0.0216565095,
-0.0273895394,
0.0567048639,
-0.0297437087,
-0.038790185,
0.0618225038,
-0.0046524052,
-0.0234578066,
-0.0205017198,
-0.0024869491,
-0.014976006,
-0.0633281395,
-0.0058006099,
0.0251683984,
-0.0303554554,
-0.0866343081,
0.0537934676,
-0.0203190558,
0.0172075424,
-0.0105721001,
0.044088345,
-0.0546320193,
0.0468946025,
0.0419256128,
-0.0846463665,
0.0920905694,
-0.0445625447,
0.0178676024,
-0.0128277009,
-0.0057726596,
-0.0066966554,
0.0242294278,
0.0084555494,
0.000835525,
0.0177740492,
-0.01020345,
-0.0093980655,
0.021237215,
0.0556925535,
-0.0031545518,
-0.0226351973,
-0.0626649335,
-0.0818209723,
0.005501891,
0.0119651034,
-0.0076844152,
-0.0849753246,
0.0360561199,
0.0298041161,
-0.0416644216,
-0.0791880414,
-0.064850688,
0.0224158801,
-0.0153125217,
0.0079922862,
-0.0427857675,
0.0341317579,
-0.0361630134,
0.0397598967,
0.0112268124,
0.0200118292,
-0.0738833472,
0.0230458677,
0.012533132,
0.068826668,
0.0180377737,
-0.0099896435,
-0.0058928146,
-0.0102123357,
-0.0550841056,
-0.0254905038,
0.0421710275,
0.0143806981,
-0.0086155208,
-0.028033236,
0.0267586559,
-0.0334301293,
0.0286261812,
-0.0309178755,
0.0380389653,
-0.0264796596,
0.0087052174,
0.0455804355,
0.0181985516,
-0.0038509283,
0.0044250032,
0.0487455055,
-0.0233608484,
0.0121866195,
0.0069563561,
-0.0406016596,
-0.0101330094,
-0.0230522696,
0.041685883,
0.0256840084,
-0.0429233052,
0.0046869167,
-0.0470744483,
-0.0426141322,
0.0236644857,
-0.0005858542,
0.0364530087,
-0.0744473189,
-0.0146482354,
0.0430313647,
-0.0104689943,
-0.0145290038,
-0.016547095,
0.0427660346,
-0.0581571832,
-0.0212893505,
-0.0821120515,
-5.515729163e-33,
-0.0322861932,
-0.0348661803,
-0.0188812912,
0.0434545241,
-0.0450845994,
-0.0015601184,
-0.0569796897,
0.0420658365,
0.010467804,
0.0318733379,
-0.0062647187,
0.0228051282,
-0.002617859,
-0.0143766245,
0.0299837049,
-0.0000532099,
-0.0244436711,
-0.0432339758,
-0.0138296094,
-0.0306348484,
0.0144700175,
0.0288896561,
0.0708262399,
-0.069439441,
0.0179362781,
-0.0213178918,
0.0372649021,
0.0038828943,
-0.0109777162,
0.0201568939,
-0.053765431,
0.0654543191,
0.0536480695,
-0.0242956635,
0.0064913644,
0.0596612953,
-0.0038244305,
-0.0251382086,
0.0459861718,
0.0154905487,
0.0012229801,
-0.0247012079,
0.064420566,
-0.0266342741,
-0.0122481324,
-0.0273802131,
0.0614035018,
-0.0175246652,
0.0408791043,
0.010464387,
-0.0353433006,
-0.0336141512,
-0.0200951416,
-0.0133358864,
-0.0216509737,
-0.0057864292,
-0.0459265187,
0.0577308759,
-0.0793385282,
0.019525785,
-0.0247436501,
-0.0008986462,
0.023884194,
-0.0124812024,
0.0420733839,
0.0894239917,
0.0588178299,
0.046608381,
-0.0645487681,
0.0389839299,
0.0881079063,
0.0506742559,
0.0222815406,
0.006109755,
0.0279039145,
-0.0348336175,
-0.0315038748,
0.0106790075,
0.023894174,
0.0174214803,
0.0281625781,
-0.0093733026,
0.0015768991,
-0.0107012792,
-0.0108307712,
-0.0518364348,
-0.017974304,
-0.0013489812,
-0.0010539118,
-0.0540380403,
0.0228179414,
-0.0292210393,
0.0303325634,
-0.0459206887,
0.0230238959,
-0.03829851,
-0.037881583,
0.0064655393,
0.0428451374,
-0.0148330051,
-0.0241025779,
-0.0375061966,
0.0320433713,
0.0131543744,
0.0713439807,
-0.0020193008,
-0.041448053,
0.0074457722,
0.0086454917,
-0.0086921072,
-0.0197846666,
-0.0304124951,
0.0513538793,
-0.0117536373,
-0.0050899549,
-0.0132387131,
-0.0240162518,
-0.0687624514,
-0.0240027998,
-0.0059966333,
-0.0467832386,
0.0048250346,
-0.0340785384,
0.0236143246,
-0.0362632908,
-0.0039750347,
-0.0441844538,
-0.0278817806,
0.0522694401,
-0.0354800746,
-0.0196756553,
0.0056628091,
2.591e-7,
0.005946388,
0.0783394873,
0.0100665689,
0.0134140877,
0.0402349383,
0.0370377079,
-0.0135447234,
0.0268452577,
0.0548010878,
-0.0027026474,
-0.0393208675,
0.055245623,
0.0451848693,
-0.0027627295,
-0.0365371145,
0.0147365369,
-0.0715095028,
0.0141063565,
-0.0091794208,
-0.0036680396,
0.0282113496,
-0.0248144716,
0.028620163,
-0.0422784053,
-0.0165713429,
-0.0155185033,
0.0622995161,
-0.0685234144,
0.041014161,
-0.0089015476,
-0.0135708936,
-0.0093446001,
0.0093453443,
0.039914377,
0.020824153,
0.0152015984,
-0.0004278968,
0.0580754802,
-0.0187822729,
-0.010850287,
0.0202151965,
0.0100270798,
-0.0364372283,
-0.0387952141,
0.007106991,
-0.0681590885,
-0.0754757822,
-0.0498328768,
-0.0096307015,
-0.0149103124,
0.0272783693,
0.0096348161,
0.0198310055,
-0.0056004929,
0.0342527144,
-0.0191078037,
0.0149146318,
-0.0169084594,
-0.0183204897,
0.0141702909,
-0.0790445432,
-0.0124560976,
-0.0404683128,
-0.0296598915,
0.0284617227,
-0.0686774701,
0.0158526544,
1.824140858e-34,
-0.0562991649,
0.010751348,
-0.0009240832,
0.0270607248,
0.0325601324,
0.0084479675,
0.0480934307,
0.0225430634,
0.0185965598,
-0.0529638156,
-0.0025527447
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09278v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09278v2 | Symbol-LLM: Towards Foundational Symbol-centric Interface For Large Language Models | 2023-11-15T18:59:56 | 2024-02-18T06:24:12 | Fangzhi Xu, Zhiyong Wu, Qiushi Sun, Siyu Ren, Fei Yuan, Shuai Yuan, Qika Lin, Yu Qiao, Jun Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Although Large Language Models (LLMs) demonstrate remarkable ability in
processing and generating human-like text, they do have limitations when it
comes to comprehending and expressing world knowledge that extends beyond the
boundaries of natural language(e.g., chemical molecular formula). Injecting a
collection of symbolic data directly into the training of LLMs can be
problematic, as it disregards the synergies among different symbolic families
and overlooks the need for a balanced mixture of natural and symbolic data. In
this work, we tackle these challenges from both a data and framework
perspective and introduce Symbol-LLM series models. First, we curated a data
collection consisting of 34 tasks and incorporating approximately 20 distinct
symbolic families, intending to capture the interrelations and foster synergies
between symbols. Then, a two-stage tuning framework succeeds in injecting
symbolic knowledge without loss of the generality ability. Extensive
experiments on both symbol- and NL-centric tasks demonstrate the balanced and
superior performances of Symbol-LLM series models. The project page is
https://xufangzhi.github.io/symbol-llm-page/. | [
0.0102012856,
0.0746543854,
-0.0245674364,
0.0683448315,
-0.0210733321,
0.0324655622,
-0.0037120567,
0.0180843417,
0.0215149969,
-0.0033402953,
-0.0501429886,
-0.0251689274,
-0.0411623828,
0.0382715799,
0.0598200783,
-0.0474263951,
0.0412943065,
-0.0161357541,
-0.0002141428,
-0.0028051967,
0.012672795,
0.0050652432,
0.0188059546,
0.0148210544,
-0.0404314809,
-0.0212734398,
0.0263167452,
0.0126922419,
0.0655002445,
-0.0461589992,
-0.03514871,
0.0451261438,
0.0721552074,
0.047700271,
0.0000020661,
-0.0418409109,
0.0213582497,
-0.0074646422,
-0.0172389783,
-0.0319119655,
0.0373736992,
-0.0549587347,
0.015173954,
0.0063131819,
-0.0366060622,
0.0064818165,
0.0410216339,
0.0485571586,
0.0367021859,
0.0549343191,
-0.0031228117,
-0.0097526573,
0.0439250767,
-0.0375883467,
0.044076547,
-0.0025213063,
0.0239034928,
0.0256570298,
-0.0057671531,
-0.0061052842,
-0.0195253454,
0.0480496027,
0.0445651263,
-0.0044159405,
0.0157407559,
0.0298771858,
-0.0130839106,
-0.0111419111,
-0.0126303155,
0.0920414329,
-0.0391416922,
-0.0497092828,
-0.020399753,
-0.0059386455,
-0.0094213765,
-0.0005809423,
-0.0601246059,
0.0137448208,
0.0135323778,
0.0311526749,
0.0759737939,
0.0057354481,
0.063228786,
0.0392226353,
-0.0299757402,
0.0256826207,
0.0202111788,
-0.0065417341,
0.0068872459,
-0.0218949616,
-0.0647020787,
-0.0338658169,
0.0127690677,
0.0439390652,
-0.0008786055,
0.0297993235,
-0.0373048186,
-0.0624640398,
0.0144372657,
-0.0397442281,
0.0457563847,
0.0489631519,
0.0103657208,
0.0415553525,
-0.0489232242,
0.0362515561,
-0.0153701017,
0.0392354168,
-0.044568412,
-0.0188970864,
-0.0448664799,
-0.0123589374,
-0.0297775585,
0.0240011141,
-0.0339820497,
-0.0375780053,
-0.0082827192,
0.0452596992,
0.0085502276,
0.0140143605,
0.0113519141,
0.0059192427,
-0.0136284558,
-0.0255508609,
0.0052602398,
0.0143501526,
-0.0449540652,
-0.0036726482,
0.0205918979,
-0.023855662,
-0.0015342438,
0.0049301353,
0.0032303252,
-0.017155176,
0.0212222058,
0.1127456576,
0.0332303457,
-0.0112204738,
-0.0004476572,
0.0007524119,
0.0594335794,
-0.0732162148,
-0.01994133,
-0.0411777645,
0.0385682806,
0.0219063088,
0.0173552055,
-0.0522955619,
0.0404420346,
-0.0171154104,
0.0036303452,
0.057331562,
-0.0105927382,
-0.0290483329,
-0.008583013,
0.0022537031,
-0.0179791451,
0.0497674718,
0.0547462404,
0.0008543141,
-0.0053934869,
-0.0160557125,
-0.0274295136,
0.0159543138,
0.0082263304,
0.0132278157,
-0.0618222393,
-0.0066136448,
0.0069484655,
0.0909366831,
-0.0025456871,
0.0712479353,
-0.0187847875,
-0.0315783732,
0.0596894957,
0.0408297032,
0.0727496222,
0.0200379342,
0.0361770876,
-0.0056203166,
0.0484800674,
-0.0472536981,
-0.0730708241,
0.0261852797,
-0.0449447706,
0.0198540539,
-0.0356611982,
0.0502130501,
-0.0200829133,
-0.039221894,
-0.0124086738,
0.00457827,
-0.0150072677,
0.0108253788,
0.042453222,
-0.015232075,
-0.0340496823,
0.0267140456,
0.0360674709,
-0.025861524,
0.0331069641,
-0.0073774899,
0.0721029863,
0.0770810768,
0.0489276126,
-0.0358616188,
-0.0216463022,
-0.0059654089,
-0.0364818387,
0.0378342681,
-0.0026845862,
-0.0215652008,
-0.0060017314,
-0.0575953983,
-0.0037443219,
0.0191676132,
-0.0025454909,
0.0329773724,
-0.0266033504,
0.0117429327,
0.0084202522,
-0.0664612427,
-0.0075800512,
0.0481124111,
-0.0332607739,
-0.023564877,
-0.0074986327,
-0.0114161307,
0.0197472721,
0.0022499,
-0.0058218497,
0.0113182664,
0.0486934185,
-0.1041657329,
-0.0249634329,
0.0026279874,
-0.0466191471,
-0.0378777161,
0.0439292043,
-0.0314644203,
0.0194296464,
0.0448756889,
-0.0394588895,
-0.0389161259,
0.0235667098,
-0.0039425986,
0.0421082266,
-0.0246168822,
-0.0212704651,
0.0212646965,
0.0410714969,
-0.0232374519,
0.067993544,
-0.0176443458,
-0.001440472,
0.0162174311,
0.0480023399,
-0.0271852557,
-0.0132428342,
0.0215143841,
0.0085383682,
0.0234266222,
0.007699539,
-0.0116493572,
-0.0148751717,
-0.0074670995,
-0.0196231641,
-0.0732376575,
-0.0027755008,
-0.0258589145,
0.0218326878,
0.0187738892,
-0.0004775627,
-0.0248951819,
0.0063257059,
-0.0444862731,
0.0401601382,
-0.0128342779,
-0.0043987641,
0.0498611145,
-0.0092375185,
-0.0360591747,
-0.0434741899,
-0.0218479671,
-0.0295921266,
0.0530204885,
-0.0165869705,
-0.0056175156,
-0.0151743041,
0.0062294141,
-0.0212756544,
-0.006764181,
-0.02045637,
-0.0104729729,
0.0079101492,
-0.0255345758,
0.0304829925,
0.0134846261,
0.0044338265,
0.0265242551,
0.0154181086,
0.0132430801,
-0.0500116125,
0.0091377497,
0.0200355686,
0.073620826,
-0.0304878335,
0.0153434006,
-0.0078663398,
0.0905792564,
-0.0264452398,
-0.013264616,
-0.0372224674,
0.0311164949,
-0.0177780334,
-0.0345994532,
-0.0403764844,
0.0083520478,
-0.0301894844,
-0.0155004039,
-0.030474158,
-0.0619959235,
0.0628034845,
-0.0194711834,
-0.008433532,
-0.0092811501,
-0.0516556576,
-0.0553337671,
0.0634630993,
0.0177516155,
0.0078953998,
0.0073976549,
-0.0325736627,
-0.0548848994,
0.012369208,
-0.0368076898,
-0.0207997747,
0.0674729869,
-0.0365056992,
0.0146951508,
-0.0136392564,
-0.0083332844,
-0.0245394129,
0.0092868404,
-0.0384328999,
0.032589227,
0.0123175085,
-0.0508400202,
-0.0075863204,
-0.0073466506,
0.0079808244,
0.0215659514,
0.0021368966,
0.0064583011,
-0.0316321962,
0.0017731693,
0.0719413683,
-0.0035189474,
0.0529620014,
-0.0450131632,
0.0339286774,
0.0180906225,
0.0373036899,
-0.0311066024,
-0.009402425,
0.0063554929,
0.0029738746,
-0.0375791043,
-0.0193706844,
0.0123502072,
0.0116942972,
-0.0768112987,
0.0154339112,
0.0953045636,
0.0162095651,
-0.0245005526,
0.0461507663,
0.0211062059,
0.0190974977,
0.0475357398,
0.0210806001,
-0.153416425,
-0.0272029229,
0.0006403354,
-0.041832,
0.0180985555,
-0.0450239703,
-0.0090932883,
-0.0666149855,
-0.0093808435,
0.0351913385,
-0.0901334658,
-0.012388384,
-0.0106387381,
-0.0023883057,
-0.0238960851,
0.0319743231,
0.0221721679,
-0.0352942646,
-0.0194131453,
0.0362056531,
-0.0078506125,
-0.0657892004,
0.000650534,
-0.0412863977,
0.0019498417,
-0.0008027354,
0.0138199171,
-0.0041056685,
-0.0075471434,
-0.0117350966,
-0.017534595,
0.0084055215,
-0.0289053153,
-0.0131281149,
-0.0006790977,
-0.0199077986,
-0.0312861353,
0.0553802215,
-0.0955161527,
-0.0299897064,
-0.0389212966,
0.1050089523,
-0.0246334746,
-0.0175448228,
-0.043737784,
-0.031701643,
0.0090631489,
0.0597535558,
0.041227404,
-0.0569375455,
-0.0349185802,
-0.026974434,
-0.0162713956,
-0.0171969943,
-0.0283816792,
-0.0283637233,
0.0078085829,
-0.0108992411,
-0.0661452785,
-0.0265305564,
0.0452330001,
0.0522799268,
-0.0059897015,
0.0276650023,
-0.0631983578,
-0.0366445482,
-0.0277228113,
0.0448894799,
-0.0299493801,
0.0358753912,
-0.0262630694,
-0.0047581322,
-0.0072243833,
-0.037855275,
-0.0202407166,
0.0234936532,
-0.1110256016,
-0.0763661116,
-0.0109835304,
0.0355595686,
0.0242558494,
0.0015210946,
-0.0035522589,
-0.0324960314,
0.0727808177,
0.0749891251,
0.0028068691,
-0.0166313834,
0.0067686359,
-0.0210485458,
0.0304447263,
0.0445933118,
-0.0242252722,
0.0125993546,
0.0085724732,
0.0762448162,
-0.037124984,
0.0123610944,
0.0389409736,
-0.0038948962,
-0.01920777,
-0.0047231712,
-0.0295664966,
-0.0510227084,
0.0170940533,
-0.0280591361,
-0.0366528407,
-0.0434195176,
0.001933633,
0.0418388024,
-0.0072099892,
-0.019252969,
-0.0483258665,
0.0256335661,
0.0507390611,
-0.0060877008,
0.0313669108,
-0.0045536668,
0.0268346481,
0.0531797409,
0.0224666037,
0.0069567044,
-0.0071694651,
-0.0259107091,
0.0073119993,
-0.0198925361,
0.0045553776,
0.0082566328,
0.0128874779,
-0.0576403067,
0.0117441779,
-0.0455134064,
-0.0547116846,
-0.0351153761,
0.0247611366,
0.0755528063,
0.0061484538,
0.0198653322,
-0.0653459057,
0.0022584805,
-0.0289035141,
0.0181308482,
-0.0168415885,
-0.0042678867,
0.0546428747,
0.0423793159,
-0.01039326,
-0.0471869223,
0.0647555739,
-0.0275369082,
0.0635990575,
-0.0023344043,
0.0360391289,
-0.0236220695,
0.0130278878,
0.0325642079,
-0.0076965787,
-0.0218944326,
0.0143076563,
-0.0670540109,
-0.0836603791,
0.0515006371,
0.0374370925,
-0.0015820947,
-0.0171990283,
0.0257862043,
0.0212528687,
0.0012567199,
-0.0299268514,
-0.0147864884,
0.0181156658,
-0.0064700702,
-0.0557661355,
-0.0173615124,
-6.48671064e-33,
-0.0162969753,
0.0049187248,
0.000899135,
-0.0190263297,
-0.0196965318,
0.001755872,
-0.0521724634,
-0.0056873672,
0.0065169027,
0.0272625983,
-0.0060633551,
0.0144570647,
-0.0030909271,
-0.0115993358,
0.0092862062,
-0.0159768704,
0.0297515653,
0.0187365673,
0.0237584021,
0.0204187594,
0.0560796224,
0.0671860799,
0.0833322182,
-0.0411343314,
-0.0113027021,
0.0024786927,
0.0166467037,
0.011681132,
-0.0110499589,
0.0643376261,
-0.0258769784,
0.0564995557,
0.01472608,
0.0086307144,
-0.0467330441,
-0.000707259,
-0.0642466098,
-0.0303040911,
0.0403651372,
-0.0157546103,
-0.0320902653,
-0.0654816926,
0.0430879965,
-0.0109078987,
-0.0187602174,
-0.013244383,
0.005633398,
-0.0255799927,
-0.0200576484,
-0.0652059168,
-0.0688550323,
0.0074450169,
0.0083739311,
0.0249388777,
-0.0116772363,
-0.0263091791,
0.0031537605,
0.0059018638,
-0.0111310426,
-0.002084085,
0.0218623616,
0.0324973129,
0.0479441173,
0.0333592407,
0.0231334548,
0.043803025,
-0.0046816645,
-0.027308736,
0.0056980597,
0.029154595,
0.0435015,
0.0605413914,
0.0481207184,
0.0338854752,
0.0663363934,
0.0179116689,
-0.0631422326,
-0.0060941922,
0.0224874001,
0.061681658,
-0.0390791409,
0.0661958754,
0.005533495,
0.0253114011,
-0.0487005822,
0.0242552217,
-0.0376918875,
-0.0395445004,
0.0086728018,
-0.0173825659,
-0.012726835,
0.0040472806,
0.0133943874,
-0.0444545411,
-0.0310638621,
0.0362429321,
0.0265903454,
0.0333983973,
0.0191829223,
0.0086606108,
-0.0854759514,
-0.0549348071,
0.0273261089,
-0.0375749692,
0.0171845555,
-0.0069005904,
0.0469956584,
0.0420190506,
-0.0295064785,
-0.0160374176,
-0.061148122,
-0.017656805,
0.0282090995,
-0.0129544577,
0.0277654063,
0.0171299074,
-0.0033099456,
0.0451525599,
-0.0082976948,
-0.0263761207,
-0.0055240868,
0.0152120851,
-0.0094793988,
0.037437968,
-0.0082486523,
-0.0325139761,
-0.0564223565,
-0.0267826859,
0.0825135484,
-0.078095153,
-0.0059562121,
0.0213851165,
2.765e-7,
0.0626487955,
0.0416071974,
0.0336331502,
0.0601213872,
0.0199593939,
-0.0138203427,
-0.0281772222,
0.0592718646,
-0.0101681342,
-0.008639616,
0.0239474997,
0.0371718556,
0.0476082116,
0.0188238006,
-0.0927771479,
0.046825178,
-0.0612827092,
-0.0210323911,
-0.0584500246,
0.02151623,
0.0128625892,
0.1336478144,
0.0100058746,
-0.0126497801,
0.0183446128,
-0.0240235273,
0.0830938146,
-0.0618421063,
0.0030450376,
0.0148054287,
0.0051423172,
-0.0135616763,
0.0112482123,
0.0084601482,
-0.0127287218,
0.0099758981,
-0.0055873529,
0.0221405253,
-0.0105394712,
0.00349577,
-0.008361524,
-0.0304947924,
0.008933641,
-0.0069742999,
0.0369105488,
-0.0303211845,
0.0013283679,
-0.0408095866,
-0.0127077848,
-0.00402842,
0.0121354209,
-0.0236164369,
-0.0186987296,
0.0535615981,
0.0182036106,
-0.0140023399,
-0.0084445691,
-0.049161911,
-0.0455894321,
0.0402476117,
-0.0458189398,
0.0053548878,
-0.0644981638,
-0.0156981107,
0.0084258141,
-0.0427231044,
-0.0433057398,
2.555246916e-34,
0.0448604785,
-0.0352584645,
0.0023136775,
0.0614980124,
0.0533339269,
-0.0150127402,
-0.0758511201,
0.0241403282,
0.0264051035,
-0.1096951813,
-0.003725
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09216v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09216v1 | Assessing Translation capabilities of Large Language Models involving English and Indian Languages | 2023-11-15T18:58:19 | 2023-11-15T18:58:19 | Vandan Mujadia, Ashok Urlana, Yash Bhaskar, Penumalla Aditya Pavani, Kukkapalli Shravya, Parameswari Krishnamurthy, Dipti Misra Sharma | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Generative Large Language Models (LLMs) have achieved remarkable advancements
in various NLP tasks. In this work, our aim is to explore the multilingual
capabilities of large language models by using machine translation as a task
involving English and 22 Indian languages. We first investigate the translation
capabilities of raw large language models, followed by exploring the in-context
learning capabilities of the same raw models. We fine-tune these large language
models using parameter efficient fine-tuning methods such as LoRA and
additionally with full fine-tuning. Through our study, we have identified the
best performing large language model for the translation task involving LLMs,
which is based on LLaMA.
Our results demonstrate significant progress, with average BLEU scores of
13.42, 15.93, 12.13, 12.30, and 12.07, as well as CHRF scores of 43.98, 46.99,
42.55, 42.42, and 45.39, respectively, using 2-stage fine-tuned LLaMA-13b for
English to Indian languages on IN22 (conversational), IN22 (general),
flores200-dev, flores200-devtest, and newstest2019 testsets. Similarly, for
Indian languages to English, we achieved average BLEU scores of 14.03, 16.65,
16.17, 15.35 and 12.55 along with chrF scores of 36.71, 40.44, 40.26, 39.51,
and 36.20, respectively, using fine-tuned LLaMA-13b on IN22 (conversational),
IN22 (general), flores200-dev, flores200-devtest, and newstest2019 testsets.
Overall, our findings highlight the potential and strength of large language
models for machine translation capabilities, including for languages that are
currently underrepresented in LLMs. | [
0.0327696651,
0.0422332138,
-0.0163660031,
0.0673644245,
-0.037985418,
0.0213863086,
0.0220785812,
0.0111091537,
-0.0219994951,
-0.0359297693,
-0.0778995827,
-0.0603040978,
0.0212101284,
0.0033469622,
0.0515414178,
-0.0274270829,
0.0101357978,
-0.039581012,
-0.0131462105,
-0.0004700071,
-0.004044143,
0.015994247,
0.0086366758,
0.0378430337,
0.0070158117,
-0.0399739295,
0.0615219809,
0.0408445969,
0.0353109241,
-0.0485353023,
-0.0116688721,
0.0186720472,
0.0151538858,
0.0231472701,
0.0000020703,
-0.0612845421,
0.0007820709,
0.0080261584,
0.0099667767,
0.023772411,
0.071961917,
-0.0427353717,
-0.0001953288,
0.0352537483,
-0.0132867973,
-0.0057358905,
0.0602310151,
0.035675507,
0.0159190074,
0.1068577617,
-0.01905296,
-0.0636931509,
0.0293403156,
-0.0509463027,
-0.0231952053,
-0.0552856252,
0.0104994085,
0.0143239927,
-0.0201997329,
0.0214667674,
-0.0172745511,
0.0347529985,
-0.0144823305,
-0.015762208,
-0.0119125983,
0.010518468,
-0.0139783854,
-0.0318356603,
0.0126773166,
0.0838465989,
-0.0622156113,
-0.0140488688,
-0.0109512657,
0.0125486096,
-0.0674918294,
-0.0176214594,
-0.0467904247,
0.0309884306,
-0.0098282862,
0.0370136984,
0.055928845,
0.0296413023,
0.0377907939,
-0.0058369888,
0.0040270244,
-0.0067926142,
0.0525673665,
0.0015880025,
-0.0169256534,
-0.0056443121,
-0.044665169,
-0.0164298471,
0.0109263854,
0.0138024865,
-0.0313342549,
0.0344309248,
-0.00360061,
-0.0084137646,
0.0324766003,
-0.0491564348,
0.0474064946,
0.0505547859,
-0.010688643,
0.0288504492,
-0.020843748,
0.0602422319,
-0.0486666039,
0.0035087313,
-0.0582186133,
-0.0278301183,
0.0178171732,
0.0141435377,
0.0087617123,
-0.001475894,
-0.071487546,
-0.0237334501,
-0.0373399667,
-0.0002055008,
0.0232986584,
0.011744163,
0.0281012915,
-0.0539012365,
-0.047881864,
-0.0216473509,
0.0237518232,
0.042413827,
-0.0313276574,
0.0137106832,
-0.0040921443,
-0.0782799423,
-0.0089226356,
0.0212654416,
-0.0299229361,
-0.0443402492,
-0.0245620366,
0.0669198632,
0.0062721428,
-0.0372629315,
-0.0269913618,
0.0381251834,
-0.0202418678,
-0.083041966,
-0.0258524306,
-0.0636733398,
0.0580598116,
0.0246509146,
0.0435247049,
-0.0304186493,
0.0218985882,
0.0275177211,
0.007673563,
0.0563414358,
0.016500622,
0.0188658405,
0.0455751494,
0.0022817659,
0.0377412327,
0.0735512227,
0.0335984975,
0.0219440255,
0.0342772119,
-0.0282810908,
0.0051903264,
0.0902519822,
-0.0327662379,
0.0117864246,
-0.0292463377,
0.0187680423,
0.0395571738,
0.0628581867,
0.0170080289,
0.0452249646,
-0.0177441128,
0.0472396053,
0.0571547113,
0.0368739478,
0.0359372757,
0.0491497591,
0.0328886323,
-0.0012999537,
0.0238790605,
-0.0170396622,
-0.0238452088,
0.0016239756,
-0.0384872817,
-0.003642784,
0.0537484623,
0.0375971533,
0.0001521304,
-0.0181902796,
-0.046482075,
-0.0288518984,
-0.0293915756,
-0.0099032735,
0.0506794937,
0.005792113,
-0.0590520538,
0.0072059808,
0.0439938009,
-0.0475299917,
0.0391038805,
-0.0422822908,
0.0226814188,
0.0499630421,
0.0384638794,
-0.0041223844,
-0.0296332482,
-0.0002866392,
0.0033677064,
0.0519971251,
0.0575508215,
-0.0006659885,
0.0088224253,
-0.0560409166,
0.0406339578,
-0.0103922281,
0.0071606566,
0.0122318724,
0.0071897916,
0.0254983604,
0.0198240858,
-0.0364425406,
-0.0456669554,
0.0306342114,
-0.0555622838,
-0.0053192559,
0.005833237,
-0.0068802456,
0.0285325423,
-0.0043056672,
-0.0043068095,
-0.0133354403,
0.0189532079,
-0.0614893362,
0.0212577134,
0.0069196424,
-0.0458947644,
-0.057012815,
0.0013894887,
-0.0260527283,
0.0218037218,
0.0023494537,
-0.0407020636,
-0.0600246787,
-0.0160377007,
-0.0144722657,
-0.0008350952,
-0.02794425,
0.0400586352,
-0.0129024312,
0.0250436328,
-0.044290632,
0.044697322,
0.0135322558,
0.0085599096,
0.0125941448,
0.0288434979,
0.0286436249,
-0.0560704768,
-0.0326608866,
0.057987716,
0.0306867789,
0.0203074608,
0.0134889605,
0.0323112048,
-0.0475568883,
-0.0754065216,
-0.0991505459,
0.045957908,
-0.0195850097,
0.0253931526,
0.0316755623,
0.0284678191,
-0.0100761466,
0.0212236941,
-0.0083598858,
-0.0043857922,
0.0378832407,
0.011585406,
0.0141484924,
-0.0084501253,
-0.0262295455,
-0.0382992625,
-0.0049653663,
0.0198642686,
0.0512768812,
-0.0086353542,
-0.0307873823,
-0.0521703362,
0.0529308096,
-0.0165214445,
-0.034007851,
-0.0214827564,
-0.060789898,
-0.029235214,
-0.017306909,
0.0622734316,
0.0389488488,
0.0108688194,
0.0077228476,
-0.0023234179,
0.0024326157,
-0.0275653601,
-0.0129221426,
0.0082738595,
-0.0606888086,
-0.0427953415,
-0.027455138,
0.0105495444,
0.0323471166,
-0.0026593525,
-0.0010639885,
-0.0446690246,
-0.0026094867,
-0.0453921258,
-0.0162465591,
-0.0032776173,
0.045550745,
-0.0099429451,
0.0572184958,
-0.0333212987,
-0.050654199,
0.0200401023,
-0.0648947805,
0.0090988167,
-0.0441230498,
0.009743195,
-0.0838529095,
0.0280140545,
-0.0275411122,
0.0034633176,
-0.0377283879,
-0.0360653102,
-0.0125509072,
0.0024450899,
-0.0279528275,
-0.0344648696,
0.0709896237,
-0.0844869465,
0.0134851402,
-0.0217207149,
-0.0245014559,
-0.0125406906,
-0.0384448692,
0.011447032,
0.0012536482,
0.022073444,
-0.0014487471,
-0.003085512,
0.0443894714,
-0.0059974678,
0.0116770286,
-0.0266409311,
0.0225467943,
-0.00213207,
0.0285204165,
0.0579956323,
0.0219796468,
0.0225962307,
-0.0374603532,
0.0332422778,
-0.0296768956,
0.0189147759,
0.0036002987,
-0.0323614515,
-0.0143182334,
0.0478920564,
-0.0105338162,
-0.0487129614,
-0.0041829078,
0.0858207569,
-0.0251925495,
-0.0255791973,
0.1168403774,
0.0187812019,
-0.0334366933,
-0.005154239,
-0.0340907015,
0.0070408676,
0.0245470311,
0.0280860085,
-0.0569358058,
-0.0251515787,
0.013005184,
-0.0150497155,
0.0383984745,
0.0043107048,
-0.0256828945,
-0.1334509701,
0.0010210956,
0.0164765734,
-0.0227610059,
-0.0400892422,
-0.0066464348,
-0.0232710093,
-0.0152982026,
0.0389546454,
-0.0163792744,
-0.0256544091,
-0.03001469,
0.0222532377,
0.0200368073,
-0.067167975,
0.0267805215,
-0.0334933698,
0.0386083163,
0.0513181761,
0.0488334447,
-0.0294792168,
-0.0087470328,
0.0409602076,
-0.0482001714,
-0.0021584325,
-0.0160350464,
-0.0014296456,
0.0087638088,
-0.0220007971,
0.0219896901,
0.0188133139,
-0.0188016798,
-0.0066808467,
0.0168070104,
0.0302204359,
0.0045663514,
-0.0238785073,
0.0307479277,
-0.0251733493,
0.0036126513,
0.0470377915,
0.0273142923,
-0.0442107841,
-0.0037621597,
-0.0079807816,
-0.0057112407,
-0.0226835683,
-0.0107140765,
0.0022535017,
-0.0259809475,
0.0001328025,
-0.0575830825,
-0.0342966504,
0.0215400178,
0.0188496429,
0.0433724783,
0.0528495088,
-0.004326975,
-0.0099995155,
0.0230677444,
0.0292924847,
-0.0553959981,
0.028902553,
-0.0842210129,
0.0352014601,
0.0757975876,
-0.0181779489,
-0.0072909785,
0.0312353596,
-0.0721203983,
-0.0616524741,
-0.0106143849,
0.0496609546,
0.02002207,
-0.0072637154,
-0.0377567783,
-0.0813528374,
0.0123407235,
-0.0192470644,
-0.0026439966,
0.0130937928,
-0.0006208431,
0.0397113487,
0.0022550779,
0.0709836558,
-0.0268072374,
0.0272127278,
0.0076621915,
0.0677804798,
0.0138797946,
-0.0660768226,
0.0062245615,
0.0400911532,
0.0100470809,
-0.057293497,
-0.0327207148,
-0.0408688076,
0.0199660342,
-0.0063365167,
-0.0073835873,
-0.0253030751,
-0.0295293424,
0.0820239633,
0.0247791614,
-0.0132704247,
-0.0085242847,
0.0118306708,
0.0120167146,
-0.0285958052,
0.0525728911,
-0.0150281005,
0.0231020693,
0.0316757336,
0.0237467289,
-0.0315280631,
0.0082344925,
-0.0206730776,
0.0217540823,
-0.0348053314,
0.0800094679,
-0.0108371386,
0.0136327073,
0.0012426327,
0.0452171415,
0.0308638718,
-0.0044820732,
-0.0035277626,
0.0587679632,
0.0898248553,
0.0083947182,
0.1105399504,
0.0186771192,
-0.0037547087,
-0.0433562547,
0.0557679981,
0.0012402313,
-0.0178432222,
0.0569817275,
-0.0117334584,
-0.0248780195,
0.0056308252,
0.0571849346,
-0.0083536459,
0.0176025759,
0.0172835514,
0.0166875832,
-0.0272267144,
-0.0087312739,
-0.0040138713,
-0.0303915907,
0.012698587,
0.0097490996,
-0.041261062,
-0.0460178554,
0.0332000777,
-0.0233663656,
-0.0062975944,
-0.0219785348,
-0.0139075266,
0.0874846354,
-0.0011015874,
0.0046881083,
-0.048472818,
-0.0113115385,
-0.0206592027,
-0.0173041783,
-0.0233023297,
-6.379321884e-33,
-0.0425900668,
-0.0004356671,
0.0070270291,
-0.0388244726,
-0.0314396657,
-0.0136962216,
-0.0473963283,
-0.0287395101,
-0.0130557492,
-0.0076143555,
-0.0298973471,
-0.0116481567,
0.0122454967,
0.0121142836,
-0.0036032847,
-0.0130097736,
0.0458845571,
0.0417658016,
-0.0249000527,
0.0224028043,
0.0263503343,
0.0144424243,
0.0762744993,
-0.0163357165,
0.0129555222,
-0.0558678396,
-0.0310107619,
0.0365476757,
-0.0391306803,
0.0427096486,
-0.0390479937,
0.0307085682,
0.0369544365,
-0.0314053595,
-0.0097408071,
0.0065652202,
-0.0827130452,
0.0118578291,
0.0710765496,
0.0062683513,
0.0196456537,
-0.0767743886,
0.0466206111,
-0.0189327598,
-0.0446714275,
0.0124058342,
0.0082658492,
-0.0252394546,
-0.0365955792,
-0.0179158077,
-0.1154826283,
0.0262336172,
-0.003418972,
-0.0035277549,
-0.0038211385,
0.025381675,
-0.0284469984,
0.0250385851,
-0.0467580706,
-0.0065691271,
0.0047071357,
0.0554958358,
0.0734799653,
0.0288175978,
-0.0211523212,
0.0100864628,
-0.0126753338,
-0.00487871,
0.0231914595,
-0.0248946864,
0.0039530294,
0.0264395885,
0.0071788854,
0.0701451972,
0.0147125777,
-0.0582291037,
-0.0653473064,
0.0284804236,
-0.0028062139,
0.0372699909,
0.0341994986,
-0.0051813694,
-0.0293391347,
-0.0230823848,
-0.0558350943,
-0.0096263206,
-0.0265912153,
-0.0170933213,
0.0583345257,
-0.0086513218,
-0.002038073,
0.0042331838,
0.0628419444,
-0.033364296,
-0.0035931282,
0.0059422939,
-0.0229761805,
0.0185101144,
-0.0348950177,
0.0481703393,
-0.0522522479,
-0.0770144239,
0.0008660194,
0.0178687479,
0.0049716211,
-0.050079152,
0.0393510684,
-0.0259054415,
-0.0731957182,
0.0087582665,
-0.0458787158,
0.0132488878,
-0.0094551677,
0.0451404601,
0.0239915624,
-0.002308418,
-0.0169587471,
0.0344765559,
0.0346717089,
0.0249479879,
0.0019652052,
-0.0142259737,
0.0109258965,
0.0125857424,
-0.0465102382,
0.052133631,
-0.0337746292,
0.0009820225,
0.0421264693,
-0.0328822285,
-0.0214107465,
0.017274797,
2.796e-7,
0.0324878134,
0.0775355548,
-0.0000759004,
0.015211584,
-0.0088310651,
0.0056151147,
-0.0412970111,
-0.0068534422,
0.020932449,
0.0383370817,
-0.0101821274,
0.0157587267,
0.0781182796,
-0.0052794488,
-0.0837390944,
0.006821081,
-0.0597474724,
0.0279961359,
-0.0579522476,
-0.0164930169,
0.0009757077,
0.1221805364,
-0.0203459542,
0.0100525022,
-0.0391185619,
-0.029087713,
0.0875883251,
-0.0480838008,
-0.0648428425,
0.0435711779,
0.0031911435,
0.0249271672,
-0.0226208698,
-0.0106381299,
0.0091316979,
0.0329673551,
0.0518684536,
0.1069017053,
0.0205067378,
-0.0093548661,
0.0281531774,
0.0043165446,
0.0007924766,
-0.0515925847,
0.0513086803,
-0.0095593808,
-0.0475706719,
-0.0172649026,
0.0013539663,
0.0032918914,
0.0328791998,
-0.057987716,
0.0018280634,
0.0191995222,
0.0320650935,
-0.0393169038,
-0.0402919911,
-0.0370359905,
-0.022231603,
0.0040596132,
-0.0236341711,
-0.0568111688,
-0.0129230656,
-0.0041584433,
-0.0083989901,
-0.0525177792,
0.0067937505,
2.31449098e-34,
0.0543492176,
-0.0068463441,
0.0126071246,
-0.0006695596,
0.0628163889,
-0.0215594489,
-0.0202853493,
0.016975468,
-0.0157864522,
-0.1007817015,
0.0014208445
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09214v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09214v3 | Mind's Mirror: Distilling Self-Evaluation Capability and Comprehensive Thinking from Large Language Models | 2023-11-15T18:56:23 | 2024-04-07T19:17:53 | Weize Liu, Guocong Li, Kai Zhang, Bang Du, Qiyuan Chen, Xuming Hu, Hongxia Xu, Jintai Chen, Jian Wu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have achieved remarkable advancements in natural
language processing. However, the massive scale and computational demands of
these models present formidable challenges when considering their practical
deployment in resource-constrained environments. While techniques such as
chain-of-thought (CoT) distillation have displayed promise in distilling LLMs
into small language models (SLMs), there is a risk that distilled SLMs may
still inherit flawed reasoning and hallucinations from LLMs. To address these
issues, we propose a twofold methodology: First, we introduce a novel method
for distilling the self-evaluation capability from LLMs into SLMs, aiming to
mitigate the adverse effects of flawed reasoning and hallucinations inherited
from LLMs. Second, we advocate for distilling more comprehensive thinking by
incorporating multiple distinct CoTs and self-evaluation outputs, to ensure a
more thorough and robust knowledge transfer into SLMs. Experiments on three NLP
benchmarks demonstrate that our method significantly improves the performance
of distilled SLMs, offering a new perspective for developing more effective and
efficient SLMs in resource-constrained environments. | [
0.046008829,
0.0773468018,
-0.0283919983,
0.0640843958,
-0.0830797255,
0.0131383948,
0.0023215404,
-0.0212308206,
0.0168591961,
-0.050745219,
-0.0543257259,
-0.0047532711,
-0.0102175558,
0.0036565077,
0.0321250819,
-0.0494632013,
0.0439124554,
-0.0553455912,
-0.0454417504,
-0.0079262704,
0.0058502182,
0.0057988609,
0.0025667904,
0.015049655,
0.0095356246,
-0.0301825721,
0.0020898881,
-0.0091579976,
0.0114387311,
-0.0133187361,
-0.0440908968,
0.0638589859,
-0.0115921302,
0.0426596887,
0.0000022802,
-0.0649525896,
-0.0186913144,
0.00748504,
-0.0086329421,
0.0295680631,
0.0475053862,
0.0320015624,
0.025202116,
0.0313794725,
-0.0277888253,
-0.0066611124,
-0.0099439509,
0.0407530107,
0.0919107199,
0.0587201007,
0.0101171946,
-0.0389436781,
0.0114837401,
-0.0023422579,
-0.0064316108,
-0.0423862971,
0.0347726569,
0.017148234,
0.0070484169,
-0.0022165868,
-0.0181833878,
0.0394485258,
-0.0032518334,
0.0099193724,
0.0274047367,
0.0089272568,
-0.0543926731,
-0.0165622272,
-0.0318090022,
0.0343395546,
-0.0175417121,
-0.0322657526,
-0.0130032813,
-0.0014309726,
-0.0055456166,
-0.0049878722,
-0.0448970981,
0.0191154983,
0.016106084,
0.0382907242,
0.0192065295,
0.0129338447,
0.0201520622,
0.0313379019,
-0.0676838979,
0.0674445778,
-0.001052878,
-0.04817513,
0.0302468669,
0.0406534262,
-0.0061737932,
-0.0447451212,
0.0050640143,
0.0205385014,
-0.0078496756,
0.0199713483,
-0.0064218547,
-0.0284371302,
0.0102049345,
-0.015109106,
0.0665124506,
0.010862641,
-0.0156686008,
0.0652828664,
-0.0565380566,
0.0478151925,
-0.0281099807,
0.0377735309,
-0.0641730279,
-0.0229936149,
-0.0823481381,
-0.0138771767,
-0.0277808122,
0.0739008337,
-0.0109337969,
-0.0250699203,
-0.0090528456,
-0.0127964932,
-0.0302397255,
-0.0418179892,
0.0258463826,
0.0383952633,
0.0509040207,
-0.0269447789,
-0.0670637116,
0.060491614,
-0.0051060491,
0.0073730806,
0.0159076992,
-0.0482004359,
-0.0214019101,
0.0102161141,
-0.0058140103,
-0.0153251998,
0.0237902198,
0.0762645751,
0.0128850006,
-0.0103112729,
-0.0226102788,
-0.004145802,
-0.0485470816,
-0.0847263187,
0.0050644386,
-0.1006470993,
0.0042154067,
0.0148021625,
0.0118743172,
-0.0278515033,
0.0187879633,
0.0046717799,
-0.0618189722,
0.0589611977,
-0.0342158824,
0.0439660139,
0.0049464814,
0.0145946322,
-0.0262522846,
0.0654325783,
0.0246199463,
0.0227488466,
0.0106148813,
-0.0013564834,
0.0294942744,
0.0275017433,
0.0020283633,
0.00543661,
-0.0565536954,
0.0062540038,
-0.023067642,
0.0058560986,
0.0086248526,
0.0969246775,
-0.0065752948,
0.0373589508,
0.074901551,
0.045214124,
0.0078189038,
0.0426807813,
0.0435512997,
0.0172700193,
0.0065010553,
-0.0021365148,
-0.0354216024,
0.0312545598,
-0.0090886103,
-0.0170408487,
0.05946308,
0.0446277969,
-0.0038241593,
-0.040333055,
-0.0298954137,
0.0214868896,
-0.005367191,
0.0230869316,
0.0241230577,
0.0229907632,
0.0052951379,
0.0755900294,
0.0362536199,
-0.0211297665,
0.0047089346,
-0.0563998595,
-0.0237213671,
0.068074584,
0.0479917713,
-0.0004068508,
0.0030492046,
-0.0114777014,
-0.022933526,
0.0537124313,
0.0460678302,
0.0049363645,
-0.0356305763,
-0.0166326538,
-0.0188607909,
0.0053940983,
0.034278404,
-0.0324053094,
-0.0014599346,
-0.0107854446,
-0.0030597327,
-0.0004394151,
-0.03649031,
0.0312865451,
0.0060390779,
-0.014850188,
0.0052575902,
0.0147252064,
0.041320961,
0.0065089515,
0.0080704596,
0.0444149151,
-0.0059857559,
-0.0335148871,
-0.0693078041,
-0.0031925815,
-0.0466633216,
-0.0605898537,
0.0322777629,
-0.0232185479,
-0.0065400996,
0.0300663617,
-0.027815599,
-0.0478273854,
0.0157360025,
-0.0443350598,
0.0237475615,
-0.0307563264,
0.0524052791,
-0.0177316945,
0.0027953701,
-0.0329193585,
0.0784417242,
-0.0308887381,
0.0080370065,
-0.00516441,
-0.0214629229,
0.0031627344,
0.0200955458,
-0.035567604,
-0.0177161135,
-0.0067283548,
0.0241941214,
0.0094384477,
0.02241561,
-0.0733857304,
-0.0406152792,
-0.0796084031,
-0.0046790424,
0.003302265,
0.0187647603,
0.0324872807,
-0.0167577676,
0.0042020348,
0.0257197116,
-0.0195902921,
0.0112018185,
0.0163959172,
0.0312406775,
0.0416624397,
-0.0107784672,
0.0020669999,
-0.0139800264,
0.0004942051,
-0.0162046812,
0.063397862,
-0.0563029647,
-0.0185390599,
-0.0473461077,
0.0422506295,
-0.0524590947,
0.0082857981,
0.0297458917,
-0.0160308704,
0.018181894,
-0.0336032249,
0.0264715329,
0.0034547073,
0.0019620308,
-0.0258108042,
0.080654256,
-0.0278325044,
-0.0485877693,
0.0133960014,
-0.0032117858,
-0.0028967417,
-0.0186798237,
-0.0043198192,
-0.0110296682,
0.0645843297,
0.0169069152,
-0.0247296821,
-0.0495201424,
0.0266860276,
-0.0454919375,
-0.0502009913,
-0.028817879,
-0.0130979707,
-0.0276692621,
0.0431301445,
-0.0251302589,
-0.0326739736,
0.064068161,
-0.0324679241,
0.0313705467,
-0.0527323298,
0.0112093957,
-0.0394010693,
0.0901177526,
-0.0165633354,
0.0103416005,
-0.0073465831,
-0.0036894828,
-0.061257951,
0.0146279112,
-0.0127350856,
-0.0486009829,
0.0677551329,
-0.0679952428,
0.0156358331,
0.0136889732,
-0.0679138973,
-0.0442077816,
-0.0320755206,
-0.0484692231,
0.001064676,
0.0157212913,
0.0376893915,
-0.0348914973,
-0.0088121034,
0.0208405033,
0.0230912343,
-0.0009236919,
-0.0294483919,
-0.0038632171,
0.0329666063,
0.0531610511,
-0.0230412781,
0.0846945494,
0.0271016415,
0.0600726083,
0.0739658773,
0.0633460283,
0.0228466,
-0.0100109708,
0.0055427733,
0.023128029,
-0.0188437812,
-0.0231320951,
0.0018535586,
0.0435766131,
-0.0563953705,
-0.0470476635,
0.1138833687,
0.0375067107,
-0.0494959131,
0.0085634831,
-0.0300717186,
0.0050216317,
0.0330864377,
0.0203352943,
-0.0604483597,
-0.0502589419,
0.003905559,
-0.016631864,
-0.0165378284,
-0.0500675216,
-0.0054635475,
-0.146947667,
0.0267438013,
0.0071551418,
0.0072975238,
0.0076127858,
-0.0264423173,
0.0108317304,
0.0040809857,
-0.0189341959,
0.0269328412,
-0.0164546072,
-0.0002530123,
0.007926885,
-0.038711831,
-0.0141846454,
0.0644906238,
-0.0298361275,
0.0462351106,
0.031515386,
0.0258045197,
0.0219960418,
-0.0403551906,
0.0346594192,
-0.0448247232,
0.0174468458,
-0.0256931651,
0.0326407962,
-0.002558141,
-0.0062224027,
-0.008275927,
0.0100431349,
-0.0425996222,
-0.0065381485,
0.0075156228,
0.1118806675,
0.0035953899,
-0.0549708232,
-0.0170884933,
0.0140335057,
-0.0231978893,
0.0923753679,
0.0286778789,
-0.0364942811,
-0.0406099632,
-0.0000363704,
-0.0684712827,
-0.0015230036,
-0.0848283619,
0.0397215709,
0.066211544,
0.0180932675,
-0.0785431042,
-0.0275884662,
0.003707469,
0.0218251273,
0.0044625215,
0.0549097769,
0.01239035,
0.0081431037,
-0.0005900321,
-0.0024732964,
-0.0636773482,
-0.0013113501,
0.0094759669,
0.0253033582,
0.0332706161,
-0.0208976846,
-0.0198074859,
0.0232695136,
-0.1110751927,
-0.0641039386,
-0.0056777908,
0.059257701,
0.0290986449,
0.0258186758,
-0.0332057066,
-0.0561816134,
0.0385198966,
0.026273109,
-0.0346123762,
0.002897087,
-0.0048830495,
0.0301934984,
0.0233960077,
0.0614193454,
-0.0070759305,
0.024465343,
0.0338468589,
0.0720077828,
-0.0046551116,
-0.0121785654,
0.03798737,
0.0260951053,
0.0473965853,
-0.0220290329,
0.0097721526,
-0.0196656026,
-0.0059828348,
-0.0398805775,
-0.0544196926,
-0.0488739647,
-0.0029422643,
0.0429212004,
0.009603125,
0.0010493738,
-0.0356185213,
0.0079643074,
-0.0082252752,
-0.0210581515,
-0.0247066244,
0.0092132846,
0.0035538317,
0.0213086791,
-0.0008576964,
-0.0264417864,
-0.0317173861,
0.0106609622,
0.0153249139,
-0.024804594,
0.0601252913,
0.0117674349,
-0.0144388722,
-0.0276773628,
0.0257474557,
-0.0717787445,
-0.0816118568,
-0.0072744149,
0.0248465389,
0.039975252,
0.0137108685,
0.0639992803,
-0.0251717027,
-0.0109954672,
-0.0055417763,
0.0085692322,
-0.0106900167,
-0.031216925,
0.0011145805,
0.0150788026,
-0.018495379,
-0.0290421303,
0.0562488362,
-0.0311636589,
0.0212415345,
0.010182403,
-0.021916369,
-0.0337137207,
-0.0561636277,
-0.0617741197,
-0.0180662554,
-0.0151376938,
0.0273628701,
-0.0983175859,
-0.0794862434,
-0.0194590166,
-0.0002110164,
0.0422039032,
-0.0309664514,
0.0480893515,
0.0776640698,
0.002994264,
-0.0112276338,
-0.0300352313,
0.0118261399,
0.0352891013,
-0.0239453986,
-0.0167736616,
-7.366598283e-33,
0.0221138056,
0.0004558218,
0.0456323437,
-0.0310570337,
-0.0328180492,
-0.0128381327,
-0.0177061595,
0.0284681059,
-0.0205489323,
0.0123689706,
-0.032191135,
-0.0010232663,
0.0026797766,
0.0419209115,
0.040734604,
-0.0011937114,
0.0306142271,
-0.0226507802,
-0.0096141761,
-0.0051852539,
0.0304277558,
0.0239772238,
0.0351324789,
-0.0419343859,
-0.0204393249,
0.0158545915,
0.0074246535,
0.0377518907,
-0.0247473046,
0.0195106305,
-0.0329867601,
0.0375330821,
0.0548555329,
-0.0533316024,
-0.0005918319,
-0.0081056636,
-0.0370457917,
-0.0191394314,
0.032753244,
-0.0135508869,
-0.0363327302,
-0.0062423642,
0.0394711569,
0.0123389531,
-0.006904297,
-0.029740924,
0.0063132606,
-0.0309633166,
0.0201836638,
0.0229805857,
-0.0685292631,
0.0041903346,
0.012105112,
-0.0188928135,
0.0121970475,
0.0142168207,
-0.0408755206,
0.0136354649,
-0.0560463406,
0.0050999043,
-0.0090094218,
0.0357475989,
0.0816264451,
-0.0249013025,
-0.0176812727,
0.0775295869,
0.000580293,
0.0077265049,
-0.0519800708,
-0.0198647976,
0.0218496509,
0.0874466375,
0.0674184486,
0.0203391835,
0.0242002029,
0.0079600923,
-0.0609301887,
-0.0145259956,
-0.0043083369,
0.0504340567,
0.0427122675,
0.0191742294,
-0.0131195756,
-0.0093304273,
-0.047566995,
-0.027753545,
-0.0420517959,
0.0048607816,
0.0269517433,
0.013229969,
-0.0601053238,
-0.0044528884,
0.0331736207,
-0.0585061871,
-0.0178391598,
-0.0072928895,
-0.0299951155,
0.0330217816,
0.0054916842,
0.0139543563,
-0.0643746555,
0.0056556882,
-0.0047841966,
0.0446183197,
0.00824783,
-0.0012961832,
0.0408813618,
-0.0065670083,
-0.0520027205,
-0.002990149,
-0.0731842071,
0.0383905135,
-0.0190414172,
-0.00623604,
0.0336693488,
0.0253602304,
-0.0212390255,
0.0043646917,
0.0216713361,
-0.0090219332,
-0.0024742293,
0.0500452779,
0.0019668024,
-0.0140518434,
-0.0062660202,
0.0017120804,
-0.0462085567,
-0.0067455797,
0.0485392734,
-0.0478693843,
-0.0225059185,
0.0339424834,
3.115e-7,
0.0339523777,
0.0589528419,
-0.0089489147,
-0.0090092579,
0.0511628389,
0.0451048091,
-0.0074341903,
0.0017440146,
0.0324524157,
-0.0624031425,
-0.0346668996,
0.0692548156,
0.066485092,
0.041229967,
-0.0686622486,
-0.0205821525,
-0.0392400846,
0.0002702974,
-0.0340520367,
-0.0464410596,
0.053684976,
0.0609530248,
0.0284063276,
-0.040965192,
-0.0354419388,
-0.0111395521,
0.0633635074,
-0.0072909119,
0.0169602148,
0.0259806961,
0.0069358172,
0.0057388553,
0.0018501934,
0.0186124835,
0.0167008787,
0.0052868607,
0.016191924,
0.049269367,
0.0119616827,
-0.0230227448,
-0.0159747321,
0.0037537073,
0.0152916024,
-0.0944265872,
0.0844289437,
-0.0727300122,
-0.0222399924,
-0.0300268922,
-0.025160104,
0.000090157,
0.020642953,
0.0021376009,
-0.0169933587,
0.0223225653,
0.0240674429,
0.022580171,
-0.0393230915,
-0.0937199667,
-0.0236042216,
-0.00484531,
-0.0323555209,
-0.0271321014,
-0.0249705147,
0.0098098088,
-0.0135913156,
-0.0844810531,
0.0142603936,
2.987993453e-34,
0.0025667301,
-0.006847831,
0.0498327501,
-0.0162617415,
0.0228286833,
0.0033329928,
-0.0236811358,
0.0049978537,
-0.0136884144,
-0.0893559977,
-0.0087227896
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09213v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09213v3 | GENEVA: GENErating and Visualizing branching narratives using LLMs | 2023-11-15T18:55:45 | 2024-06-05T20:59:27 | Jorge Leandro, Sudha Rao, Michael Xu, Weijia Xu, Nebosja Jojic, Chris Brockett, Bill Dolan | cs.CL | cs.CL | Dialogue-based Role Playing Games (RPGs) require powerful storytelling. The
narratives of these may take years to write and typically involve a large
creative team. In this work, we demonstrate the potential of large generative
text models to assist this process. \textbf{GENEVA}, a prototype tool,
generates a rich narrative graph with branching and reconverging storylines
that match a high-level narrative description and constraints provided by the
designer. A large language model (LLM), GPT-4, is used to generate the
branching narrative and to render it in a graph format in a two-step process.
We illustrate the use of GENEVA in generating new branching narratives for four
well-known stories under different contextual constraints. This tool has the
potential to assist in game development, simulations, and other applications
with game-like properties. | [
0.0008606014,
-0.0041372692,
-0.0290403552,
0.0299717411,
-0.0341889933,
-0.0067431289,
-0.0177356545,
-0.0004705132,
-0.0002706635,
0.0192914736,
0.0044478849,
0.0000547537,
0.0116146421,
0.0770494863,
-0.0155083146,
-0.0686399266,
-0.0136401737,
-0.0349159651,
0.0148932505,
-0.0019613844,
-0.0221484601,
0.0479630455,
-0.0186113343,
0.0211747158,
0.0002774494,
-0.0646032318,
-0.027498927,
0.0402146056,
0.0415413044,
-0.0720096827,
-0.0561909042,
-0.0330159888,
0.0544223599,
0.0112380339,
0.000001927,
-0.0462804064,
-0.0192621499,
-0.0086234529,
0.0000827658,
0.0076118698,
0.0151959881,
0.0156868324,
-0.0083311489,
-0.0244272668,
-0.0227360167,
-0.0317287296,
0.0476766564,
0.0454993919,
0.0649339855,
0.0419386737,
-0.0138527388,
-0.0617482066,
-0.0521038249,
0.0089740576,
0.0076233177,
0.0088588344,
-0.040712405,
0.0532502644,
0.0930935442,
0.00356945,
-0.033897385,
0.009478583,
0.0026632799,
-0.005973177,
-0.0424867943,
0.0683868006,
0.0593225025,
0.0388761908,
0.0045757852,
0.0504797064,
0.0235727355,
-0.0130956341,
0.0242381059,
-0.0224184152,
-0.0167999938,
0.0122528765,
-0.0554059446,
0.054864347,
-0.0282579474,
0.0108734015,
-0.0053368369,
-0.0068104323,
0.0169756077,
-0.0629292727,
0.0288028307,
0.0188354161,
0.0244791731,
-0.000112193,
-0.0644239187,
0.0028158205,
-0.0136878649,
-0.074974902,
-0.0386605673,
0.0478530563,
-0.0318460576,
0.0231948514,
-0.0341613591,
0.0769006014,
0.0226729009,
-0.0082401633,
0.0374502316,
-0.0098132808,
0.0036200644,
0.0238874443,
0.0158954915,
0.0200513806,
0.0158884265,
-0.0429401658,
-0.0030945274,
0.0400194079,
-0.0430127531,
-0.0356071107,
-0.0640859231,
0.0004503486,
-0.0683166906,
-0.0363690332,
-0.0143479025,
0.0393643528,
0.0238017142,
0.0261879973,
0.0398989394,
-0.0036911429,
-0.0093436632,
0.0309851915,
-0.034957312,
0.0095285801,
-0.0403510183,
-0.0126355309,
-0.0091563538,
-0.0140260942,
-0.0043424061,
-0.0174712799,
0.0332397856,
0.0175055154,
-0.0056426176,
0.1007645801,
0.0091308923,
0.0354224704,
-0.0373961478,
-0.0283093117,
0.0024850902,
-0.0446926169,
-0.0592503548,
-0.0779789165,
0.0093429405,
-0.0228952281,
0.0642337427,
0.013393648,
0.0227323547,
0.0233313106,
0.0190412942,
0.0529990755,
-0.0234795976,
0.0239075534,
0.0070987814,
-0.0081800055,
0.0274680164,
0.0120980721,
0.0869084895,
0.0408078656,
0.0191630125,
-0.0027031947,
0.054413002,
0.034495648,
-0.0510874689,
0.0196026862,
-0.0107470993,
-0.0258673001,
0.0098311631,
0.0610955507,
-0.0106011955,
0.0434438139,
-0.0531881936,
0.0028346668,
0.0612085313,
0.061368838,
0.0581311285,
0.0160558466,
0.1203304231,
0.0260896515,
-0.009800436,
0.0107738748,
0.0248566438,
0.015187961,
0.0599075817,
0.0103022829,
-0.0889384523,
0.0077317436,
0.0110874055,
-0.0108365705,
0.0247684624,
0.0092694713,
0.0082771573,
-0.030439483,
0.0224658288,
0.0283366293,
-0.0740176216,
-0.0178548992,
0.0406815782,
-0.0995556489,
0.0403716341,
-0.0081096888,
0.0197824463,
0.122999616,
0.0657717958,
-0.0211817343,
-0.049275741,
-0.03115963,
-0.0044929627,
0.0409904905,
0.0099076862,
-0.0272719171,
0.0477509983,
-0.031649638,
-0.0009426065,
-0.0320961103,
-0.0147449682,
0.082046479,
-0.0240779985,
0.0050236136,
-0.0119107412,
-0.0345017314,
-0.0285799019,
0.0055447957,
-0.0557549037,
-0.0091649601,
-0.0225209314,
-0.0038268801,
-0.0178366732,
0.0231138803,
-0.0671863258,
-0.0094763283,
0.0412974283,
-0.0329987258,
-0.0188586377,
0.0515469462,
0.0026486304,
-0.0308683291,
0.0205657128,
-0.0779305175,
0.0099062743,
-0.0798563659,
0.0101774987,
-0.0322346538,
0.0247460231,
-0.0513213985,
0.0433147922,
-0.0220378172,
0.0154452315,
0.003445853,
-0.0125324139,
-0.0489812121,
0.0655164868,
0.0046648136,
-0.0011931597,
-0.026863534,
0.005047611,
0.0150023662,
-0.0323668085,
0.0552676879,
0.0398036391,
0.0208627246,
-0.0119362669,
0.0176499281,
-0.0015057495,
-0.0186147392,
-0.0398016199,
-0.0891384333,
-0.0041271676,
0.0255647358,
0.0081242565,
0.0110969301,
0.0081111267,
-0.0493763275,
0.0397965498,
-0.0743571594,
0.0004897233,
0.0382640176,
-0.0343871526,
0.0173562486,
0.0403256267,
0.005709291,
-0.0031715685,
0.0083120065,
-0.0081585366,
0.0574955791,
0.0540670604,
-0.0115902117,
-0.0526598655,
-0.0040035173,
-0.0202198345,
0.0077842046,
-0.0371034108,
-0.0327769704,
0.0361347161,
-0.0193677023,
0.0873870179,
-0.0226804279,
-0.0146363964,
0.032672599,
0.0735455602,
-0.0844061077,
0.0086850747,
0.020777097,
-0.0223203674,
0.0052769505,
-0.0299586896,
-0.0664075464,
0.0402291603,
0.0244543813,
0.028833745,
0.0330562443,
-0.0542666428,
-0.016215492,
0.0249354374,
-0.002136671,
0.0540378429,
-0.0446773395,
-0.0100838998,
0.0215152185,
-0.0153497411,
0.0309967864,
0.0432877578,
-0.0729641914,
0.0015145536,
0.0093436465,
0.0101228813,
-0.0778853595,
0.1093903184,
0.029345626,
0.0391851887,
0.032066796,
-0.0038398216,
-0.0045802868,
-0.0199604295,
0.0515496731,
-0.0230958816,
0.0189592224,
-0.0723969415,
-0.0366354845,
0.0220399741,
0.0131165795,
0.0043233936,
0.0046600932,
-0.0032595112,
-0.0339904279,
0.0667264685,
-0.0337722525,
-0.0457891449,
0.0062319967,
0.0083388826,
0.0496568009,
0.0057213292,
-0.0068439972,
-0.0446380302,
0.0545413941,
0.0594704822,
-0.0252542719,
-0.0006634697,
-0.0716904402,
0.0413241014,
0.0188488327,
-0.0826166421,
-0.0125423614,
0.0056497226,
0.0078553678,
0.0317007005,
-0.0291586611,
-0.02550859,
0.007635715,
0.0119807227,
-0.0508649535,
0.018273253,
0.0894300491,
0.0347427465,
-0.039032694,
0.025864074,
-0.0126791568,
0.0408070311,
0.0269222315,
0.0160204973,
-0.0768992752,
0.0353295766,
-0.0016354118,
-0.0104940375,
-0.0056137545,
-0.0367883518,
-0.0337136649,
-0.0657414496,
0.0781346858,
0.0120170303,
-0.0272076074,
0.0168612935,
-0.0082860645,
-0.009304747,
0.0393316969,
-0.0448494554,
-0.0082006846,
-0.0159670189,
-0.0036393304,
-0.017490657,
-0.0505710989,
0.0182503555,
-0.023394309,
-0.0282587465,
0.0687612593,
0.035870038,
0.0792634413,
0.0185681917,
0.019395303,
-0.0105678225,
0.0510691218,
0.0213898178,
-0.0202067979,
0.0308508258,
0.007405235,
-0.0205412228,
-0.0313989967,
-0.0193832144,
0.0417454354,
-0.0706567094,
0.035230156,
0.0188448131,
-0.0203175265,
-0.0280746017,
-0.0170864668,
0.0231031366,
0.0176623221,
0.0363246799,
0.0398035645,
-0.027509382,
-0.0324275456,
-0.0433770791,
0.0385454223,
-0.0500149429,
-0.0534735024,
-0.0165353715,
-0.023646526,
-0.0079178372,
-0.0576641299,
-0.0147823654,
0.0071538212,
0.0681826398,
0.0189055707,
0.0284710843,
-0.0140316533,
-0.0085638752,
-0.0353822298,
-0.0438224375,
-0.0451981574,
-0.0000382645,
-0.0335099474,
-0.0114659779,
0.0152537478,
-0.0802580342,
0.0277642272,
0.0539952256,
-0.0451292843,
-0.0212658923,
-0.0483757034,
0.0051783998,
0.0093162544,
0.0144501263,
0.0085218409,
-0.0255588833,
0.0087029785,
-0.0034990725,
-0.0153184896,
0.0184433684,
-0.0421664417,
0.0626748726,
0.0212195646,
-0.0221072212,
-0.0316737071,
-0.0026519478,
-0.0028658481,
0.0550077967,
-0.028493112,
-0.0078818509,
0.0130273728,
0.0074337707,
-0.044808317,
-0.0519941039,
-0.0082975253,
-0.0406708792,
0.0036345632,
-0.0953517482,
-0.0359668136,
-0.0158148818,
0.0145357242,
0.0445248932,
-0.0220538378,
0.0040868199,
-0.0009982672,
-0.0405126438,
0.0026658482,
-0.0536001921,
0.032376159,
0.0509477928,
-0.0474934354,
0.041819375,
0.0084759127,
-0.0002415147,
0.0285349973,
-0.0808544531,
0.0347608142,
0.0142471557,
0.0043534664,
0.0019770782,
-0.0548471548,
-0.0026138225,
0.0146123338,
-0.0175590459,
-0.0384460278,
0.0310998745,
0.0374117009,
0.0592700988,
0.0319805369,
0.0593312643,
-0.0077207936,
0.0007018056,
0.0078328932,
-0.0126143396,
0.0356818624,
-0.051608976,
-0.0566019565,
0.0422050506,
-0.0351425521,
-0.0057644672,
0.0236128084,
0.0424505807,
0.0333068892,
0.0338699445,
-0.0479567014,
-0.0401080213,
-0.0311403442,
-0.0177551862,
0.01241918,
-0.0224036146,
-0.007256662,
-0.0904598609,
-0.013570278,
0.0084490702,
0.081131056,
0.0069385781,
-0.0162397269,
0.0002520494,
-0.0083658937,
0.0249221493,
-0.0020405562,
-0.0511338934,
0.0496940911,
-0.015477946,
-0.0361618251,
0.0141834076,
-5.195937762e-33,
-0.0514260679,
-0.0408168659,
0.0461317264,
0.0187297203,
-0.0755561069,
0.0030069412,
-0.0654126778,
-0.0157824755,
0.036514122,
0.0200310349,
0.0369341336,
-0.0133820707,
-0.0155581189,
0.0190246738,
-0.0386405066,
0.0172217637,
0.0588057041,
0.0598852783,
-0.0596372113,
0.0368686989,
0.0123064267,
0.0102782939,
0.0130670313,
-0.0429604575,
-0.0143936146,
-0.0405185632,
-0.0261031985,
0.0114497561,
0.0311602447,
0.0344736688,
-0.0035826322,
-0.0082851816,
0.0144589543,
-0.0126062501,
-0.0059188078,
0.002451384,
-0.0507781692,
-0.0120783746,
0.0293869618,
-0.0079338877,
-0.0046058898,
-0.0573746189,
-0.0134333931,
0.0099375257,
0.0368158482,
-0.0234216321,
0.0576915033,
-0.0098660942,
-0.0315297358,
-0.0086902287,
-0.0727756098,
0.0111576486,
-0.0428027511,
-0.0186692737,
-0.0180979576,
0.0174971279,
0.0062478776,
0.0020161245,
-0.0037382527,
0.0657789186,
0.0203400552,
-0.0111312717,
0.0095768292,
0.0214409046,
0.0284175016,
0.0725727603,
-0.0072705154,
0.0251672771,
-0.0785610601,
0.020933371,
-0.0127486344,
0.05443497,
0.0172454566,
0.0486771017,
-0.0570211038,
-0.0030432465,
-0.0620382242,
0.0372685157,
-0.0050997254,
0.0305805858,
0.0403558165,
0.0373772681,
-0.0069824765,
-0.0124608343,
-0.0394787975,
-0.035027016,
-0.0111425202,
-0.0319957696,
-0.0016902698,
-0.0586690009,
0.0067118374,
-0.0026711298,
0.0045852503,
-0.0095473053,
0.0053333351,
0.0489290878,
-0.0115382141,
0.0269095581,
-0.0269731786,
0.0288747605,
0.0444589071,
-0.0047079432,
0.049370259,
-0.0157608259,
0.0410195552,
0.020810524,
-0.0166210476,
0.0441097692,
-0.0300776791,
0.0216980688,
-0.0095359599,
0.0123214349,
-0.0008332586,
0.0021035175,
0.0127874399,
-0.0817586482,
-0.0154577363,
-0.0194516312,
0.0295659993,
-0.0399502479,
0.011188603,
-0.0108664408,
-0.0525252856,
0.010297603,
-0.027979929,
0.0332156494,
-0.0183793381,
0.0544922836,
0.0508753322,
-0.0225284733,
-0.0266415104,
0.0256992467,
2.659e-7,
-0.01543866,
0.016183354,
0.0303285271,
0.0266974531,
0.0166393518,
0.0108252056,
0.0043126941,
0.0028187991,
-0.0098450901,
-0.0376664735,
0.0342230536,
0.0505387336,
0.0237089973,
0.0529191308,
-0.0695793778,
0.0670815334,
-0.0418370068,
-0.0283902287,
-0.0559515134,
0.0054728705,
0.0847972035,
0.0125213414,
0.0480126068,
-0.0129939783,
0.0178849027,
0.0091113513,
0.0215863753,
-0.0589799769,
-0.0267927796,
0.0254511349,
-0.0548195951,
-0.0378342681,
-0.0340277292,
-0.0393943265,
-0.0050871088,
0.0108319428,
0.0061544562,
0.0396229699,
-0.0192365684,
0.0476460494,
0.0322343074,
-0.0332541652,
-0.0195554905,
-0.0424394943,
0.0253443047,
0.0193985347,
-0.0167834777,
-0.0037539145,
-0.0194640085,
-0.0073290789,
-0.0191463102,
-0.0288144276,
-0.0233376697,
0.0271577612,
-0.015743956,
0.0089025469,
0.0060102665,
-0.0318430066,
0.0096348366,
0.004991468,
-0.0376878604,
-0.0185316838,
-0.0203633066,
0.0247182325,
0.0002022682,
-0.0060520535,
0.0112531623,
2.40086433e-34,
-0.0102156652,
0.0004409595,
-0.0201089922,
0.012890771,
0.0670666844,
0.0226130243,
0.006865927,
0.0478909351,
0.0374259353,
-0.0715005323,
-0.025474932
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09212v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09212v3 | Controllable Text Summarization: Unraveling Challenges, Approaches, and Prospects -- A Survey | 2023-11-15T18:55:43 | 2024-05-28T02:04:50 | Ashok Urlana, Pruthwik Mishra, Tathagato Roy, Rahul Mishra | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7 | Generic text summarization approaches often fail to address the specific
intent and needs of individual users. Recently, scholarly attention has turned
to the development of summarization methods that are more closely tailored and
controlled to align with specific objectives and user needs. Despite a growing
corpus of controllable summarization research, there is no comprehensive survey
available that thoroughly explores the diverse controllable attributes employed
in this context, delves into the associated challenges, and investigates the
existing solutions. In this survey, we formalize the Controllable Text
Summarization (CTS) task, categorize controllable attributes according to their
shared characteristics and objectives, and present a thorough examination of
existing datasets and methods within each category. Moreover, based on our
findings, we uncover limitations and research gaps, while also exploring
potential solutions and future directions for CTS. We release our detailed
analysis of CTS papers at
https://github.com/ashokurlana/controllable_text_summarization_survey. | [
0.0285503957,
-0.0025604812,
0.0241745431,
-0.0195239484,
-0.0142769106,
0.0105979638,
-0.01992069,
-0.0183654185,
0.0310813785,
0.0001801307,
-0.0069322907,
0.0394682176,
0.0200643986,
0.0075459774,
-0.0221854113,
-0.1173289642,
0.0169079974,
-0.0194603521,
0.0125360237,
0.0136614405,
0.0526943281,
0.0012599808,
-0.0035445315,
0.0224276371,
0.018419927,
0.017877873,
0.0142340958,
-0.025083594,
0.0389433913,
-0.0081350822,
0.0272974279,
-0.0150873493,
-0.003067889,
0.0067771659,
0.000001976,
-0.0574796908,
-0.048516728,
-0.0218669977,
0.018690899,
-0.0073442962,
0.1041859239,
-0.0373181291,
0.0147295287,
-0.0088122068,
0.0131682558,
0.061998941,
-0.0006303363,
0.0345067978,
0.062407203,
0.0298881587,
-0.0331590585,
-0.0143371737,
-0.0305210389,
-0.0025281948,
-0.0063796267,
-0.0195828024,
-0.0234232675,
0.033842627,
0.0326914228,
-0.0216835085,
-0.009042887,
0.0473847948,
-0.0073622139,
-0.0072685587,
0.0132119022,
0.017213678,
-0.0560844652,
-0.0290916283,
-0.0184893832,
0.0563664138,
0.0147461332,
-0.0081540011,
0.05343071,
-0.0171371084,
-0.0187193323,
0.0296746846,
-0.0886767581,
0.0345844924,
-0.0214203391,
0.0237883814,
-0.0501985736,
0.0888980627,
-0.0336526856,
0.0376658998,
-0.0204224959,
0.0352226868,
-0.0162351038,
0.0034286906,
-0.0275228489,
0.0082983943,
0.0110570015,
-0.067494899,
0.0554065667,
0.0460070521,
0.0075790696,
-0.0472709835,
-0.0374992229,
-0.1068145037,
0.0445250906,
-0.0102117825,
-0.011449337,
-0.0346698314,
0.0189832374,
0.0315813944,
-0.0184039157,
0.0200427696,
0.013201965,
0.0287838802,
-0.0284406245,
-0.0098561514,
-0.014746015,
0.0024410666,
-0.0041304734,
0.0231788456,
-0.0211074725,
-0.0078394189,
-0.0493655503,
0.0286562815,
0.0029755796,
0.0186354611,
-0.0208448544,
0.0200711749,
0.0093847634,
-0.0010495235,
0.0240708794,
0.0211407412,
-0.0584215447,
-0.0555988029,
0.0217060838,
0.0253932215,
0.013225371,
0.0176744461,
0.0527193733,
0.035810288,
0.0176978298,
0.0200531725,
-0.0312877409,
-0.0500971861,
0.0109708048,
-0.0429170728,
-0.015177059,
0.0057205125,
-0.0366512612,
-0.0503125973,
-0.0391045548,
0.0109074265,
0.0093875546,
-0.0365790799,
-0.0120496256,
0.0102375392,
-0.048082836,
0.0111606689,
-0.0305643231,
-0.0081449496,
0.0612788163,
0.0229595769,
-0.0016876787,
0.028369274,
0.0323582999,
0.06729424,
0.0739179626,
0.0354756787,
0.0356261507,
0.0239399523,
0.0034462304,
0.0147637948,
0.0033300677,
-0.0268118531,
-0.0583647303,
-0.0413382649,
0.0127731077,
0.0338833965,
-0.0186747089,
0.035815455,
0.0549457073,
0.0796533898,
-0.0000019274,
-0.0015858882,
0.0159525424,
0.0200986005,
0.0537088402,
0.0388208367,
0.0188678261,
0.0305332523,
-0.0363117978,
0.0723778456,
0.0711734891,
0.010026427,
-0.0003450766,
-0.085219875,
0.0219891444,
0.0049491501,
0.0108397687,
0.0088175423,
0.029813448,
0.0230503064,
-0.008174195,
-0.0187985655,
-0.0217759013,
-0.0915100649,
0.0166636016,
-0.0105434181,
-0.0016551585,
0.033383999,
0.0464827418,
-0.0932228416,
-0.0107295113,
0.0057420381,
0.0318076424,
0.0246770643,
0.0013974805,
-0.0185428727,
-0.0174710155,
-0.0619165115,
-0.0251340605,
0.0182516519,
-0.022678664,
-0.0272692144,
-0.0300936885,
-0.0023992748,
0.0242928639,
0.0088116592,
-0.071961835,
0.019110946,
0.0289050527,
0.0030896305,
-0.0190480631,
-0.004125332,
0.00251874,
0.038346909,
0.0077618491,
0.0242236163,
0.0117816059,
-0.0043619489,
-0.0221572313,
0.0095676277,
-0.0070984634,
0.0098407688,
-0.0036349031,
-0.0595676862,
-0.0036422107,
-0.0121589135,
-0.0036911205,
-0.0619887076,
0.0123098753,
-0.0277213231,
0.0026705929,
-0.0202679913,
0.005853089,
0.0177568179,
-0.0156152751,
-0.0273412578,
0.0653053597,
0.0144614009,
-0.0212361589,
0.080445759,
-0.0171877183,
0.0072504873,
0.0125023248,
-0.0108729685,
-0.0152620506,
-0.000185607,
-0.0217415709,
0.0872330591,
0.0170078389,
-0.0447720736,
0.0003730309,
-0.0484908335,
-0.0090425601,
-0.0162623283,
0.0192004051,
0.0368174277,
0.0237241592,
-0.022507133,
-0.0290446933,
-0.0318641104,
-0.0542446114,
0.0532786511,
-0.0110939378,
0.0384662971,
-0.0071635162,
0.0469468124,
-0.076240018,
-0.0094558569,
0.0104895765,
0.0006564299,
0.0359855257,
-0.0451452062,
0.0036325366,
-0.001435285,
-0.0131234312,
-0.0330446623,
0.0134807276,
0.0027668334,
-0.0149281286,
-0.0188203696,
0.0155631173,
0.0443623848,
0.0419922546,
-0.0066894088,
0.0356838256,
0.0056503159,
-0.0088983644,
-0.0150112314,
-0.0450847074,
0.0265882295,
0.0436960608,
-0.017163109,
0.0948630199,
0.0554563105,
-0.0021477221,
-0.0037788381,
-0.0450367332,
0.0100152427,
-0.0219734721,
-0.0118691791,
-0.065695934,
-0.0082865823,
-0.0141102178,
0.0308680926,
-0.0131999655,
-0.0304356664,
0.0328300633,
-0.0118986052,
0.0251514092,
-0.0682657287,
-0.0128621496,
-0.0512761436,
0.0299269818,
0.0456759743,
0.0303985327,
0.0316213444,
-0.0102340234,
-0.0072340476,
-0.0251183417,
0.0693411082,
-0.01113238,
0.0501577593,
-0.0467732064,
0.0123689277,
-0.0091272192,
0.0124103185,
0.0107721994,
-0.0404494591,
-0.014554454,
-0.0098973801,
0.0687375888,
0.0011191609,
-0.0139950952,
-0.0063429303,
0.0581325963,
0.072341755,
-0.0007475633,
-0.0370041579,
-0.0045662769,
0.0608011484,
0.0669037104,
-0.0150393415,
0.0358572155,
-0.018903248,
-0.0090174619,
0.0585270748,
0.0506267436,
-0.0485847481,
0.0517596677,
0.0068929759,
0.0104796765,
-0.1045491919,
0.0380786173,
-0.0223297849,
0.0617718548,
-0.0229717735,
-0.0085207419,
0.0874999389,
0.0381743312,
-0.0637040213,
-0.0367996208,
0.0180021878,
0.0223361254,
-0.0100506106,
-0.0181579739,
-0.0280148834,
0.0077729635,
0.0083337156,
0.052230455,
-0.0168609973,
-0.0238925498,
-0.0162364282,
-0.0152882142,
-0.0215101968,
0.0008577214,
-0.0671131387,
-0.004656435,
-0.0059548412,
0.0279994812,
-0.0248411335,
-0.0321137346,
0.0182397868,
-0.0410363786,
0.002456455,
0.00640612,
-0.1085923389,
0.0424061678,
-0.0466136411,
-0.0055330675,
-0.0227958541,
0.0781049654,
0.0208142903,
0.0302402917,
0.0509391278,
0.0057138521,
-0.0526300818,
-0.0244009141,
-0.0086310385,
0.0600685589,
0.0036350307,
0.0037805412,
-0.0480073914,
0.1021545827,
0.0400472879,
-0.0053376541,
0.0361438207,
-0.0027328096,
0.0215450302,
-0.0162711553,
-0.0732825026,
0.0254536737,
-0.016111644,
0.0378413536,
0.0396964885,
-0.0263321698,
-0.0374845453,
-0.0340161286,
-0.025134787,
-0.10464333,
-0.0494235046,
-0.0300112125,
-0.0270721391,
-0.0281805322,
-0.0935248062,
-0.0405761302,
0.0323357917,
-0.0376915522,
-0.0085611735,
0.009205007,
0.0106439078,
0.0163816642,
-0.0264949445,
-0.0215143077,
-0.0136352703,
-0.0164959468,
-0.0309296399,
-0.0149955414,
0.0280973837,
-0.0282290652,
-0.0144351665,
0.0313288756,
-0.0408298858,
-0.031762708,
-0.005019695,
0.0565376095,
0.0196829233,
0.0375600494,
0.004811394,
-0.0524108671,
0.0808208659,
0.0028721774,
-0.0010482457,
0.0089551816,
-0.0016281109,
0.0687143803,
-0.0300787203,
0.0075092576,
-0.0745966285,
0.0498786718,
-0.0349056162,
0.0065988721,
-0.0337490626,
-0.0311477706,
-0.0070384163,
0.0133188898,
-0.0430107862,
-0.0194331408,
0.0104383389,
-0.0236814413,
-0.0533276275,
-0.0188829377,
-0.0174958855,
-0.0133986222,
0.0638736188,
-0.0564195253,
-0.0020054663,
-0.0203230884,
0.0521786064,
0.0014304318,
0.0089950124,
-0.0577204339,
0.0332093649,
-0.0376614779,
-0.0146867689,
-0.0599259473,
-0.0030315055,
-0.0274526346,
-0.0271389913,
-0.0363481082,
0.0111865876,
0.000456719,
0.0243312195,
0.0322217308,
-0.0103377327,
-0.0224049557,
0.0534869544,
-0.09282168,
0.0693950579,
-0.0203203764,
0.0139238006,
0.0230103265,
-0.0284832641,
0.098101154,
0.0014264899,
-0.0165128447,
-0.0040833228,
0.0280325338,
0.0644924194,
0.0071946615,
-0.1063343734,
0.013281066,
0.0380235724,
-0.0208643228,
0.0792370364,
-0.0165538639,
-0.0426661223,
0.0209554061,
-0.0386458151,
-0.0375437513,
-0.0120600741,
-0.061247196,
0.02652115,
0.0229901429,
-0.0735689178,
-0.0750098228,
-0.009676287,
0.0891104192,
0.0211716797,
0.0146675045,
-0.0190340001,
0.0356028751,
-0.024681231,
0.0053290967,
0.0139301661,
-0.0262329038,
-0.0116326837,
-0.0121336849,
0.0122774579,
-0.0042098751,
-5.606922546e-33,
-0.015975479,
-0.0255338214,
-0.0558916107,
0.0028099834,
-0.0388782099,
0.0098052276,
-0.0522646047,
-0.0236805845,
0.0506298579,
0.0072716987,
-0.0285952259,
0.0002248729,
0.0177399218,
0.0504812598,
0.0335246176,
0.0280456841,
0.0304401238,
-0.0052268468,
-0.0511886366,
0.0724785253,
0.0640681088,
-0.0132830162,
0.0103530036,
-0.0649465248,
0.0566522181,
-0.0155467773,
-0.0234347526,
-0.0393397175,
0.0700937882,
0.0294193849,
0.0157094132,
0.0172091704,
0.0251023639,
-0.0316589698,
-0.0570639595,
0.0365491696,
-0.0782842562,
-0.0463839993,
-0.0086196708,
-0.0315860696,
-0.017981533,
-0.0504098348,
0.0647520944,
-0.0255510751,
0.0205317959,
-0.0177766252,
0.0780561045,
-0.0401616618,
-0.0249690283,
-0.0815141648,
-0.0101670679,
0.0368556529,
-0.0623746812,
-0.0165641755,
0.0557486787,
0.0589623116,
0.0063523152,
0.0129858293,
-0.0172090307,
0.0503419638,
0.0281655565,
0.0279700626,
0.0513119437,
0.0402488634,
0.021513639,
0.032783851,
-0.0420068018,
-0.0021002137,
-0.0547163896,
-0.010252106,
-0.0103807189,
-0.0035356178,
0.039766755,
0.0392075814,
0.0069401376,
0.0064062327,
0.003151526,
0.0914452001,
0.0093336413,
0.0081414096,
0.0045842375,
0.001962113,
0.0016277411,
0.0156314801,
-0.0087361904,
-0.0046651438,
0.0066433153,
0.0157684945,
-0.0386430807,
0.0116922287,
-0.0988130793,
-0.027009232,
-0.0227731466,
-0.0017395067,
0.0232358854,
0.0101602552,
0.0035118756,
0.0578410141,
0.0055223196,
-0.0692239255,
-0.0212234464,
0.0311398245,
0.0097438861,
0.0082157888,
-0.0077409754,
-0.0196518786,
0.0243590567,
0.0070180609,
-0.0168349575,
0.0079582566,
0.0428793915,
0.0314232893,
-0.0442773774,
0.020286059,
-0.0199993737,
-0.0143082105,
-0.0013087004,
0.0111765889,
-0.0186208356,
-0.0338716917,
0.0077304607,
0.01893574,
0.0201883912,
-0.0120469285,
-0.0156119484,
0.0107691074,
-0.0142802093,
0.0270827226,
0.0449282117,
-0.0319837481,
0.0135082584,
-0.0269634575,
2.41e-7,
0.0382672139,
0.0113648437,
0.0930212513,
-0.0150157372,
-0.0170507375,
0.013205206,
0.0360836536,
-0.0067810016,
-0.0075510005,
-0.0045215883,
0.0399025418,
0.0193914212,
0.0321247764,
0.0068188291,
-0.0654230788,
-0.0501061194,
-0.0261476468,
-0.0110957855,
-0.005936123,
-0.0147430189,
0.0562038012,
-0.012165756,
-0.0302771665,
0.0203048363,
0.0009656422,
0.0070193089,
-0.0123169469,
-0.0202486031,
0.0382897779,
0.0283044297,
0.0349449404,
-0.0194863193,
-0.0235622786,
-0.0349295884,
-0.0201837346,
-0.0174979493,
0.0699322298,
0.0526575856,
0.0304567944,
-0.0175789148,
-0.0030686148,
-0.0109079154,
0.0494783744,
0.0215108842,
0.0433767065,
-0.0579850599,
0.0283005424,
0.001072478,
-0.0113084652,
0.0114800772,
-0.0415023901,
0.021231968,
-0.0782102272,
0.0755635574,
-0.0130395032,
0.0165746547,
-0.0032547396,
-0.0901190117,
-0.0266178343,
-0.0065253945,
0.0372296944,
-0.0005652073,
-0.0631096736,
0.016826598,
-0.0203179978,
-0.0545486473,
-0.0342836566,
2.101254238e-34,
0.055975996,
-0.0339016132,
-0.0441597328,
-0.0384768322,
0.0047615031,
-0.0374538489,
-0.0026305108,
0.0204072762,
0.0359055139,
-0.0657283664,
-0.0045666895
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09210v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09210v1 | Chain-of-Note: Enhancing Robustness in Retrieval-Augmented Language Models | 2023-11-15T18:54:53 | 2023-11-15T18:54:53 | Wenhao Yu, Hongming Zhang, Xiaoman Pan, Kaixin Ma, Hongwei Wang, Dong Yu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Retrieval-augmented language models (RALMs) represent a substantial
advancement in the capabilities of large language models, notably in reducing
factual hallucination by leveraging external knowledge sources. However, the
reliability of the retrieved information is not always guaranteed. The
retrieval of irrelevant data can lead to misguided responses, and potentially
causing the model to overlook its inherent knowledge, even when it possesses
adequate information to address the query. Moreover, standard RALMs often
struggle to assess whether they possess adequate knowledge, both intrinsic and
retrieved, to provide an accurate answer. In situations where knowledge is
lacking, these systems should ideally respond with "unknown" when the answer is
unattainable. In response to these challenges, we introduces Chain-of-Noting
(CoN), a novel approach aimed at improving the robustness of RALMs in facing
noisy, irrelevant documents and in handling unknown scenarios. The core idea of
CoN is to generate sequential reading notes for retrieved documents, enabling a
thorough evaluation of their relevance to the given question and integrating
this information to formulate the final answer. We employed ChatGPT to create
training data for CoN, which was subsequently trained on an LLaMa-2 7B model.
Our experiments across four open-domain QA benchmarks show that RALMs equipped
with CoN significantly outperform standard RALMs. Notably, CoN achieves an
average improvement of +7.9 in EM score given entirely noisy retrieved
documents and +10.5 in rejection rates for real-time questions that fall
outside the pre-training knowledge scope. | [
0.0711676925,
0.0075924108,
-0.0048075393,
0.0380842797,
-0.021262968,
0.0196637474,
-0.053321749,
-0.0082118697,
0.0281578358,
-0.0848653987,
-0.0155411186,
-0.0242971815,
-0.0502050966,
0.0144220488,
0.0217753835,
-0.0322138593,
0.0579677857,
-0.0223508682,
0.0293645877,
0.0070244549,
0.0239676274,
0.0124466484,
-0.0108180242,
0.0277696736,
0.0044723316,
-0.032957416,
-0.0131076695,
0.0037589567,
0.0067332573,
-0.0333752744,
0.0279713329,
0.0375876464,
0.0067376834,
0.0380919948,
0.0000020979,
-0.0636180937,
-0.0346713848,
0.0155437188,
-0.0494287685,
-0.0041599134,
0.0284211654,
0.0273804702,
0.0328324772,
0.0350878984,
-0.0536769144,
-0.0227706414,
0.0210501198,
0.0539429858,
0.0454328991,
0.0807576105,
0.002738355,
0.0165272523,
0.0253754091,
-0.0282370318,
0.0593841523,
-0.072478652,
0.0196097698,
0.0237616915,
0.0412410572,
0.0564920194,
0.007731209,
0.0706313327,
0.0014297606,
-0.0190445036,
0.0156185403,
0.0028951503,
-0.031050276,
-0.0045791958,
0.0129541568,
0.073767297,
0.0281210653,
-0.027761599,
-0.0061792014,
-0.0016939816,
0.0329356492,
0.0143929487,
-0.0444992855,
-0.0103254085,
-0.0258138198,
-0.0246295854,
0.0046653221,
-0.0028752573,
0.0232644528,
0.0071305912,
0.0161495712,
0.0733313486,
0.0043150508,
-0.053529609,
0.0174904056,
0.0101354253,
0.0130315116,
-0.0281727258,
0.001987583,
0.0627948195,
-0.0052511198,
0.0383253582,
0.0065076579,
-0.0210005082,
0.0636228472,
-0.0458900817,
-0.0054137656,
0.0323057473,
-0.0646052361,
0.0535705835,
-0.0177992713,
0.0395823605,
-0.0040624491,
0.0132845277,
-0.0658507869,
-0.0223331656,
-0.0329101533,
-0.0339873508,
-0.0211433824,
0.0669573992,
-0.0500810146,
-0.0120548001,
-0.0195332374,
0.0402704738,
-0.003523896,
-0.0027815218,
-0.0084890667,
0.0140024489,
-0.0370622315,
-0.009815271,
-0.0553519502,
0.0369197242,
-0.0109006232,
0.0166514535,
0.0174920466,
-0.0653444007,
-0.012615337,
-0.0117776264,
0.0040214742,
-0.0140845608,
-0.0134818973,
0.0498078912,
0.0115565136,
-0.0661370978,
-0.0329434127,
-0.0188624561,
-0.0128563968,
-0.0559476502,
0.0170647036,
-0.0491939634,
0.0237336103,
0.0143676549,
-0.0191920418,
-0.0195838306,
0.0104597425,
0.0556912422,
-0.0110966731,
0.0605435893,
-0.0291064363,
-0.0142717268,
0.0399122275,
0.0286377408,
-0.0179554634,
0.0789802521,
-0.0023206489,
0.0029140157,
0.0587195568,
0.0366875231,
0.0260632802,
0.0065069846,
0.0048691323,
0.0020983275,
0.0174335651,
0.0537439734,
0.0134391226,
-0.0175172575,
-0.0014325886,
0.0417221412,
-0.0423707031,
-0.0101895696,
0.0344049782,
0.0301186256,
0.0246518571,
0.0146962656,
0.0140441898,
0.0154254409,
0.0428969786,
0.0255989749,
-0.0369624533,
0.0463353842,
-0.0678060353,
0.0245434884,
0.0271187387,
-0.0048774863,
-0.0342982598,
-0.0573270507,
-0.0222995766,
0.0137330135,
-0.0302715879,
0.0305715147,
0.0304933805,
0.0152537283,
-0.0472488552,
0.024784673,
0.0186417866,
-0.0247057267,
0.0036172681,
-0.0569990873,
0.0265222695,
0.025222918,
0.0766824856,
-0.0694555044,
-0.0483543426,
0.0066014621,
0.0035014844,
0.0414734669,
0.0594255701,
-0.0285486989,
-0.0179590844,
-0.0470849313,
-0.0417874791,
-0.0115144569,
0.0220751632,
0.0148525834,
0.0222060066,
0.009442918,
0.0201080889,
-0.0486277044,
-0.0209226087,
0.0257103257,
-0.0159779973,
-0.064546667,
-0.0075125,
-0.0193155054,
0.0076204804,
0.0241240822,
0.0068723541,
0.0430501364,
0.0382403955,
-0.0041849208,
-0.0224381499,
-0.0122143691,
-0.0268688761,
-0.019174546,
0.0380970463,
0.0010805718,
-0.0118983807,
0.0394019634,
-0.0323198289,
-0.0412763879,
-0.0127000231,
-0.0361142866,
0.0328549184,
-0.0651334599,
-0.0115117403,
0.0201302338,
-0.0012551391,
-0.0503902473,
0.0572546348,
-0.0026416683,
0.0219582487,
0.0092561105,
-0.0192681756,
0.0128514254,
-0.04952107,
-0.0370294303,
0.0008460049,
-0.0135199009,
0.0190619305,
0.0228063408,
0.000196237,
-0.0676332116,
-0.0139238918,
-0.0818523988,
-0.007291358,
-0.0295532905,
0.0262739751,
0.0167665333,
0.0154918861,
-0.0092802122,
-0.0248879958,
-0.0413036346,
-0.0147440787,
0.0110188173,
0.0345154107,
0.0242456291,
0.0412142798,
0.0184045788,
-0.0641480982,
-0.0056844316,
-0.0101571577,
0.0339642726,
0.0178205036,
-0.0159612391,
-0.0549721941,
0.0208236091,
-0.0434771664,
0.0302914809,
-0.0213654954,
0.018386621,
-0.0016722763,
-0.0293697007,
0.0128414147,
0.0421089604,
-0.003026624,
-0.0046757683,
0.0517972596,
-0.009333889,
-0.075439468,
0.0445346013,
-0.0251918435,
-0.0317609794,
0.0105501311,
-0.0199476238,
-0.0062017287,
-0.0011224196,
-0.0144455107,
-0.0147548756,
-0.0394695438,
0.0003999037,
-0.0203937348,
-0.0368621387,
-0.0628204569,
-0.0267200451,
-0.0157840177,
0.0351819508,
-0.0348363034,
-0.0252720509,
0.0916800424,
-0.0210845917,
-0.0165546183,
-0.0852247998,
0.0295953657,
-0.0512604564,
0.0478060767,
-0.0151345525,
0.0008498626,
-0.0108293416,
-0.0077934312,
-0.0241185408,
-0.0368727632,
-0.0163746048,
-0.062308982,
0.0661545545,
-0.050986588,
0.0260119457,
0.0124888625,
-0.0194343496,
-0.0717006624,
-0.000105455,
-0.018184863,
-0.0010451926,
-0.0476888306,
0.0126711391,
-0.046700649,
-0.0178277902,
0.0615932383,
0.0492720418,
-0.0337354876,
-0.0338243805,
0.0043845261,
0.0544395596,
0.0856873989,
-0.0173093416,
0.0572790764,
-0.0165433921,
0.0270554349,
0.0682043731,
0.0597813316,
-0.0294207595,
0.0233161785,
-0.0304822437,
0.020337699,
-0.0454051532,
-0.0055787526,
0.0223776866,
0.0012834514,
-0.0678112507,
-0.0531240851,
0.0947775394,
0.0419276617,
-0.0666453391,
-0.0286152922,
-0.0718194991,
0.0312797911,
0.0295276325,
0.0625081882,
-0.0566433519,
-0.0149769597,
0.0079992265,
0.0642374977,
0.0009505942,
-0.0096603483,
-0.0184852201,
-0.1231869534,
0.031018896,
-0.0254157241,
-0.0307729412,
-0.0410289802,
-0.045731999,
0.0200707875,
0.0108277267,
0.0214459039,
0.0507279336,
-0.021006139,
-0.000588726,
0.0279431846,
-0.0075727752,
-0.0126817906,
0.0185332149,
-0.0109499935,
0.0279948469,
0.071268864,
0.0203573089,
0.0321878828,
-0.0372509323,
0.0179987922,
-0.0329807214,
0.0039323098,
-0.0036643241,
0.0366757065,
-0.0115044164,
0.0198523346,
-0.0233777687,
0.0149739785,
-0.0220707208,
0.0110858958,
0.0127445431,
0.0569017977,
-0.0163513348,
0.0105938502,
-0.0520865098,
0.0112157287,
0.0148660475,
0.0625177398,
0.0248970799,
-0.0194835234,
-0.0161239952,
-0.0271849576,
0.0290176272,
-0.0125550469,
-0.0299743693,
0.0332420543,
-0.0085497526,
0.0077256653,
-0.0827141702,
-0.0984767377,
-0.0236420929,
0.0260787494,
-0.0044160681,
0.0368906073,
0.0090070805,
-0.0008601051,
-0.0188770071,
0.04098038,
-0.0518201552,
-0.0295613967,
-0.0102369236,
0.0333027579,
0.0424229354,
-0.0434908979,
-0.0344558433,
-0.002578215,
-0.0683765858,
-0.0453007184,
0.0167089216,
0.0590696558,
0.0306625273,
0.0404484496,
-0.0282521416,
-0.0490477532,
0.0012912087,
0.0183293391,
-0.0382674672,
0.0052539762,
0.0148634324,
-0.0048657074,
-0.0215928741,
0.0406290703,
-0.088534534,
0.0183650572,
-0.0088815801,
0.0669243485,
0.0033304915,
-0.0325030051,
0.0168578662,
0.0157099478,
0.0346171185,
0.0468527935,
-0.0298649631,
-0.0302218422,
0.0484149978,
-0.0237110592,
-0.010051515,
-0.0349817127,
0.0394364335,
-0.0000952629,
-0.0005971996,
-0.0144526856,
-0.0311642252,
-0.0356784128,
0.0647237897,
-0.0249425825,
-0.0081154872,
0.0305697098,
0.0076869349,
-0.0072917687,
-0.0272957087,
-0.0384731852,
0.0478262976,
0.0048249476,
0.055853039,
-0.0095233815,
0.0609379113,
0.0119114099,
-0.0254722573,
0.0222161636,
-0.0068160403,
-0.0794696137,
-0.0233792644,
-0.0309641715,
0.0256368089,
0.0394285396,
-0.0074054156,
0.0519253537,
-0.0296826288,
-0.0081678331,
-0.0128598604,
-0.0114346435,
0.0191536881,
-0.0278231092,
0.0320772231,
0.03804015,
0.0099960007,
0.041470997,
0.0608212352,
-0.0188922882,
0.0277143288,
-0.0132401753,
-0.0129229426,
-0.0369262584,
-0.0394720249,
0.0024166452,
0.0371571034,
-0.0272409488,
0.0159255043,
-0.076350227,
-0.0761331916,
0.0400399342,
0.0116708446,
-0.0129668564,
-0.0191722009,
0.0402689315,
0.0741394162,
0.0182648636,
-0.0323004276,
-0.0470091514,
0.0066506774,
-0.0336288363,
-0.0161996093,
-0.0085360939,
-6.947057003e-33,
-0.0172606762,
-0.0298849326,
0.0210473817,
-0.0099213514,
0.0143556232,
0.0304607656,
-0.0114088906,
-0.0140919928,
-0.0445770584,
-0.0032547829,
-0.0341495946,
0.035019882,
0.0114992391,
0.0220099781,
-0.0171056148,
-0.0020885253,
0.016087804,
0.006576437,
-0.0086937873,
0.0241367146,
0.0397262424,
0.0409392118,
0.0438593067,
-0.0694599971,
0.0823722035,
-0.0389193296,
0.0071847606,
0.0327350833,
-0.0378110595,
0.0760905072,
-0.0379158072,
0.0371312425,
0.0279850736,
-0.0270399172,
0.0026367034,
0.0140378699,
-0.1050541177,
-0.0378098488,
0.0296280272,
-0.0135674747,
0.0033099756,
-0.0070120292,
0.0139116906,
-0.0090086944,
0.0092081409,
-0.0215058215,
0.0365586206,
-0.0168186575,
-0.0322955437,
-0.0338179171,
-0.0320760794,
0.0278728791,
0.0260645356,
-0.0024649701,
-0.0037081093,
0.0925212502,
0.0280316472,
0.0141196996,
-0.0743308514,
-0.018580284,
-0.005562854,
0.0373125747,
0.039680995,
-0.0116804307,
-0.0378257819,
0.0540372543,
-0.0239485428,
-0.0022318442,
-0.0087544518,
-0.0509732403,
0.0157483723,
-0.0113608949,
0.0452969484,
0.0384815075,
0.0268816762,
0.0292577781,
-0.0901676565,
0.0463547558,
-0.0255245604,
0.0563952923,
0.0388896987,
0.0021580076,
-0.0623340942,
0.0107538132,
-0.0461389273,
0.0250833873,
-0.0726931468,
-0.0123691242,
0.0554585792,
0.0383314639,
-0.0219834801,
-0.0145621132,
0.0112684425,
-0.0157084838,
0.0064563015,
0.0452669933,
-0.0163782388,
0.0100281127,
-0.0250660647,
0.0540108345,
-0.0355013274,
0.0091852006,
0.022255145,
0.0123954723,
-0.025672026,
0.0080220634,
0.0248799548,
-0.0007461312,
-0.0638086945,
-0.0010623354,
-0.0154383667,
0.0605019964,
-0.0002836537,
0.0076235346,
0.0359786712,
0.017479077,
0.0072929561,
0.0738261119,
0.0210482255,
0.0145647852,
-0.0401187465,
-0.0380723514,
-0.0035317878,
0.0011576832,
-0.0277588535,
0.0143984808,
0.0154927187,
0.0494784713,
0.0104596103,
-0.0406612158,
0.0099959159,
0.0439854749,
2.883e-7,
0.0570217744,
0.0214115027,
0.0367159061,
0.0219938811,
-0.0086318394,
0.0236549042,
-0.0125300996,
0.0347131304,
0.0829380304,
-0.0110871848,
0.0020616539,
0.0189549122,
0.0267419741,
0.0344094709,
-0.1087078303,
-0.0716905817,
-0.0581282862,
-0.0109012332,
-0.0245352536,
-0.0312775373,
0.0538173169,
0.0974649116,
-0.001180841,
-0.0138394302,
-0.0393681452,
-0.065338403,
0.0694194511,
0.0061007957,
-0.0179930031,
0.018360896,
0.1066692024,
0.0357484631,
0.0198679771,
0.0003438698,
-0.0101074493,
0.0155490767,
0.0155153051,
0.0512063727,
0.0110750655,
-0.0821394846,
0.0057368362,
0.0194784366,
0.0188144855,
-0.0530651361,
0.0688170418,
-0.0318608172,
0.009268472,
0.0128945559,
-0.0455464907,
-0.0092040747,
0.0040653986,
-0.0178502034,
-0.027921075,
0.0136139402,
-0.0120341945,
-0.0105260573,
0.0018321091,
-0.0906363577,
-0.0406950153,
0.0109776556,
-0.0035047163,
-0.0442325659,
-0.036003232,
-0.0284544248,
-0.0258837286,
-0.0855422392,
0.0056694979,
2.803392167e-34,
0.0454042517,
-0.0096362,
-0.0066034412,
0.0331960581,
0.0322705992,
0.0029888507,
0.0124399411,
0.0125203114,
0.0133015849,
-0.1102106497,
-0.0309918579
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09277v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09277v1 | Contrastive Chain-of-Thought Prompting | 2023-11-15T18:54:01 | 2023-11-15T18:54:01 | Yew Ken Chia, Guizhen Chen, Luu Anh Tuan, Soujanya Poria, Lidong Bing | cs.CL | cs.CL | Despite the success of chain of thought in enhancing language model
reasoning, the underlying process remains less well understood. Although
logically sound reasoning appears inherently crucial for chain of thought,
prior studies surprisingly reveal minimal impact when using invalid
demonstrations instead. Furthermore, the conventional chain of thought does not
inform language models on what mistakes to avoid, which potentially leads to
more errors. Hence, inspired by how humans can learn from both positive and
negative examples, we propose contrastive chain of thought to enhance language
model reasoning. Compared to the conventional chain of thought, our approach
provides both valid and invalid reasoning demonstrations, to guide the model to
reason step-by-step while reducing reasoning mistakes. To improve
generalization, we introduce an automatic method to construct contrastive
demonstrations. Our experiments on reasoning benchmarks demonstrate that
contrastive chain of thought can serve as a general enhancement of
chain-of-thought prompting. | [
0.028384909,
0.0455756858,
-0.0052122981,
0.0355750248,
-0.05969356,
0.0291842278,
0.0213818811,
-0.0069343792,
-0.0029587925,
-0.0207445882,
0.0097809033,
-0.0361537747,
0.0115441913,
-0.0102009913,
0.0514327027,
-0.1068036556,
0.0472053066,
-0.0658757314,
0.0228684843,
-0.0195344295,
-0.0014387897,
0.0056530503,
-0.0509972014,
0.0093921013,
-0.009401259,
-0.0467436649,
-0.0479786806,
0.0118074035,
0.0298106875,
-0.0649523512,
-0.0353650227,
0.0728820935,
0.0159076843,
0.0085739661,
0.0000023221,
-0.0653652176,
0.0003081883,
-0.0103477081,
-0.044963982,
0.0010920999,
0.0129365241,
0.0284783859,
0.0091486536,
0.0322284997,
-0.0159639213,
0.0123916119,
-0.0041616336,
0.071863398,
0.048809059,
0.0349405669,
0.0132023906,
-0.022788981,
-0.0045942054,
0.0082419924,
0.0138825309,
-0.0270837396,
-0.013933464,
0.0381764248,
0.0526873246,
0.0312167481,
-0.0233631339,
0.0226871204,
0.0549006537,
-0.0143593252,
-0.0340013616,
0.0328198075,
-0.0284119528,
-0.0125888176,
0.0121571636,
0.0354616158,
0.0344485529,
-0.0485728532,
-0.0340844728,
-0.0178801101,
0.0271199197,
0.0319074169,
-0.0437249988,
0.0324514657,
-0.0264926776,
-0.0034303903,
0.0440036878,
0.0061232452,
-0.0039352789,
0.02371867,
-0.0078487154,
0.0766610354,
-0.0192772523,
-0.043836575,
0.043214839,
0.0179270916,
-0.0140317837,
-0.0665405616,
0.0032207558,
0.0315952189,
-0.0561652891,
0.0343796946,
0.0232842937,
-0.0252898596,
0.0012792668,
-0.0263533145,
0.0270866454,
0.0455486663,
-0.0229368135,
0.0480524749,
-0.0428784601,
0.0305374768,
-0.0028014481,
0.0538215898,
0.0020334991,
0.0124775572,
-0.0420638323,
-0.0211489927,
-0.0243671201,
0.0387469083,
0.010440914,
0.0295679308,
0.0090122204,
-0.0208368711,
-0.0449003875,
0.0096021229,
-0.019609876,
0.0075408374,
0.0261766315,
-0.0480833203,
-0.0603912994,
0.0217238534,
-0.0674122497,
0.025179157,
0.0469986573,
-0.0361612067,
-0.0380830839,
-0.006560178,
-0.0249079056,
0.0096740723,
0.0185098685,
0.0336293131,
-0.0327155702,
-0.0064150617,
-0.0717189237,
-0.000257773,
0.0227717962,
-0.0359261669,
0.0044614696,
-0.1000319123,
0.0107542649,
0.0177310351,
-0.0104664331,
-0.0008753554,
0.0148702674,
0.0246491358,
-0.0336246863,
0.0629607514,
-0.0374837033,
0.0021870772,
0.0088206111,
0.0323077366,
-0.0649228692,
0.0565856434,
0.0202313494,
-0.0168063249,
-0.0176940784,
0.0084233424,
0.014090986,
-0.0064511783,
0.026207583,
-0.0034315074,
-0.0401435271,
0.0052518286,
-0.0397481956,
0.0470361002,
0.0069095632,
0.0553879552,
-0.0376531482,
0.0568214506,
0.0273752082,
0.0445820056,
-0.0090950886,
-0.0047457241,
0.0479794964,
-0.0243091136,
0.0035264844,
0.0286029894,
-0.0533312038,
0.0456516333,
-0.0203890353,
0.025183998,
0.002238177,
0.0138985682,
-0.0207301769,
-0.0505015031,
-0.0231317822,
0.0424706936,
0.0319180861,
0.0135260727,
0.0322874561,
0.0501034744,
-0.0274730548,
0.0420182869,
0.0375722013,
-0.0624988303,
-0.0091772815,
-0.0664518848,
0.0447087064,
0.0372293256,
0.0207249634,
-0.0005351878,
-0.01702586,
-0.0347019471,
0.053273499,
0.0541052818,
0.0290313773,
-0.0243215933,
-0.0460085683,
-0.0316464305,
-0.0042039165,
0.0009521095,
0.0006133036,
-0.0093881553,
0.0138371475,
-0.0023161641,
0.0049980902,
-0.0303125363,
0.0142283784,
0.0241992828,
-0.0081768408,
-0.0036572127,
-0.0262020435,
0.024249699,
-0.0245715696,
0.0127550801,
0.0225305706,
0.007016127,
0.0075953784,
-0.0060854056,
-0.0229645558,
0.0278249942,
-0.0724683404,
-0.0818876699,
0.0161366016,
-0.0542824045,
-0.0542120598,
0.0095125912,
-0.0379932895,
-0.0343226492,
0.0356230661,
-0.0147598563,
0.0358099826,
0.0010610998,
0.0215371922,
0.0000817952,
-0.0622125715,
-0.0001303935,
0.1071835607,
-0.0094051324,
0.016791191,
0.0377059802,
0.0419825576,
-0.0139031317,
-0.0293269362,
0.0141277462,
-0.0052733179,
-0.0077416105,
0.0073231435,
0.0051287678,
0.0417763665,
-0.0953493044,
0.0197774991,
-0.0519916154,
-0.015654847,
-0.0262690298,
0.0241554603,
0.0231188424,
-0.0335853361,
-0.0080987867,
-0.0145697407,
-0.0285701174,
-0.0164287239,
-0.0104191955,
0.0098337214,
0.0327113569,
-0.0086351195,
-0.0199161973,
0.0038405505,
0.0012671152,
-0.0473440997,
0.0612167381,
-0.0078313462,
0.0363199674,
-0.040553499,
0.0357012488,
-0.0307114404,
0.0147438888,
-0.0066997828,
0.0072939587,
0.0689572617,
0.0020215441,
0.0414515957,
0.0730626136,
0.0321569107,
0.0099582039,
0.0602736659,
-0.0036866004,
-0.066448085,
0.0274263062,
0.0178935956,
0.0261521433,
0.014095922,
-0.0477738865,
-0.0567250662,
0.0566572659,
0.0037638897,
0.0130204009,
-0.073049657,
0.019640822,
-0.010119386,
0.0080086011,
-0.0292574875,
-0.0628954545,
-0.0210768804,
0.0639074445,
-0.0253248643,
-0.0146328071,
0.0901894495,
-0.0066962689,
-0.0033382543,
-0.0420844406,
0.0315966234,
-0.0095170615,
0.0767256543,
-0.0485297665,
-0.00683231,
0.005002222,
-0.0096005406,
-0.0529592969,
-0.0322769992,
0.0337672979,
-0.0139736105,
0.058824379,
-0.0801554769,
-0.0231398325,
0.0131407138,
-0.029306978,
-0.0730040073,
0.0334883817,
-0.0693581775,
0.0054324591,
-0.0272226147,
0.0162292253,
0.0215090979,
-0.0280933995,
0.0657403544,
0.0215100721,
0.0044315192,
-0.02300735,
-0.0093886005,
-0.0171799157,
0.0151625974,
0.0018388458,
0.0628794506,
-0.0338925868,
0.0535260029,
0.0417520478,
0.0698553026,
-0.014906981,
-0.0523313396,
0.0133117735,
-0.0008520345,
-0.0089962399,
-0.0270531271,
0.0258291066,
0.0199543033,
-0.0572779924,
-0.0263583567,
0.1027818769,
0.0348427072,
-0.0414492153,
0.0203560963,
-0.0722119585,
0.0601557791,
0.0172299203,
0.0226697382,
-0.0749013275,
-0.0368666239,
0.0453952141,
-0.0129148243,
0.0010886049,
-0.0293863155,
0.0044493275,
-0.1241367385,
0.0284508541,
-0.0062335967,
-0.0183399022,
-0.0089144194,
-0.0268752165,
0.0215511005,
0.0367135853,
-0.0064216089,
0.0623883568,
0.0103750462,
0.0101624215,
0.040979512,
0.0031165928,
-0.0404682942,
0.036416702,
-0.0407654829,
0.0102536576,
0.0171701498,
-0.0080282241,
0.022526769,
-0.087424159,
0.0424938127,
-0.0103267515,
0.0086134598,
-0.0280601233,
0.0052136858,
0.0076591279,
0.0215799864,
-0.032192938,
0.0419813246,
-0.0037751473,
-0.0740160048,
0.0152052846,
0.0979727805,
-0.0018259822,
-0.0255768094,
-0.0130614527,
0.0440618806,
-0.0112952413,
0.0356182568,
0.035838861,
-0.0224683583,
0.0155927846,
-0.0433931872,
-0.0253505781,
-0.0239248965,
-0.0319931917,
-0.0031590641,
0.0551972836,
0.0525162071,
-0.0416006148,
-0.0314581022,
0.0217708945,
0.0704145655,
-0.0109844618,
-0.002848075,
-0.0255346969,
0.0157744195,
0.0223678574,
0.049109403,
-0.0203702655,
0.017597178,
-0.0285520703,
0.0099447193,
-0.0157556068,
-0.0332893245,
-0.0342147313,
0.0366300046,
-0.0434784405,
-0.054644566,
-0.0283928607,
0.0434014164,
0.0282687191,
0.0496735312,
0.0046261251,
-0.0370214991,
-0.0193947293,
0.0019510518,
0.0097838715,
-0.0144828353,
0.0401046909,
-0.0135004772,
0.0215765126,
0.0218962133,
-0.0159573685,
-0.004658733,
-0.0040354347,
0.0608308949,
-0.0247089751,
-0.0206182674,
0.0556273982,
0.0085358014,
0.0459777676,
-0.0038917505,
-0.0090538282,
-0.0429648943,
0.0484020486,
-0.0217469838,
-0.0497224368,
-0.006375704,
0.0375171751,
-0.0239949115,
-0.0109544201,
-0.0027193155,
-0.0759586021,
-0.0207496174,
0.0060949149,
0.0399455912,
0.0267272256,
0.0403091833,
0.0365591422,
0.0346084721,
-0.0237711798,
-0.0138203362,
-0.0324476585,
-0.0168193188,
0.0587625131,
-0.0180694629,
0.0999788493,
0.0629108846,
-0.0185552556,
-0.0071738949,
-0.0326775685,
-0.0540863052,
-0.0591669045,
0.0187896062,
-0.015832115,
0.0175490547,
-0.0140799219,
0.0086591151,
-0.044688236,
0.0083101997,
0.0404121801,
0.0441878028,
-0.0167136639,
-0.0703198761,
0.0192460176,
0.034685798,
0.0379618332,
-0.0081348987,
0.0164969023,
-0.0628062189,
0.0025507943,
0.0038701908,
0.0261892471,
-0.0162827056,
-0.0191477668,
-0.0215626992,
0.0058415602,
-0.0166414529,
0.0090060709,
-0.0881088078,
-0.0802966133,
-0.0285747964,
0.0445269756,
0.0269035958,
-0.0112025021,
0.0468558893,
0.0800388306,
0.0039134757,
-0.0348029546,
-0.0014732489,
0.0048813936,
0.0208829027,
-0.0234207232,
-0.067244716,
-6.561176003e-33,
-0.025241686,
-0.0340839811,
0.0528608225,
-0.0245179627,
0.0190952308,
-0.0393862128,
-0.054358989,
0.0325685926,
-0.0196803492,
0.057917919,
-0.0336247422,
-0.0001273638,
-0.0025528364,
0.0043481551,
0.0239211619,
0.0060214754,
0.0124064181,
0.0187883973,
-0.0477081314,
-0.0105887037,
-0.0004222729,
-0.0049676998,
0.0383687243,
-0.0574136041,
0.0545522831,
-0.0102106594,
-0.0144368242,
0.0221511889,
-0.0952699408,
0.0226458218,
0.0278230514,
-0.0136449141,
0.0082027204,
-0.0366550162,
-0.0090173539,
0.0281835571,
-0.0394939333,
-0.049634859,
0.0814508051,
-0.0201749634,
-0.1022870243,
-0.0128753483,
-0.0088634901,
-0.0008207262,
-0.0018528254,
-0.0149748605,
0.0115794381,
-0.0075075636,
0.0141799273,
0.0316208676,
-0.0451323763,
0.0022248544,
-0.0313107111,
-0.0405928977,
-0.0080592791,
0.0602632798,
-0.0316368863,
-0.0361668952,
-0.0440617241,
0.0241641626,
0.0617271215,
-0.0309789013,
0.0915171281,
-0.0062910742,
-0.0491868109,
0.0425978154,
-0.0270308722,
0.009290548,
-0.0263972636,
0.0006495176,
0.0097642886,
0.0260457378,
0.0798561871,
0.0074851173,
0.0207283664,
0.0317893289,
-0.0489275418,
-0.0174591579,
-0.00096521,
0.0218696203,
0.0193864033,
0.0086025009,
-0.0376198404,
-0.0144038824,
-0.0580828562,
-0.0277902,
-0.0363842584,
-0.0552343205,
0.0237696804,
0.0025247305,
-0.0343121178,
-0.0440488942,
-0.0157100465,
0.0006605221,
-0.0236399807,
0.0321671888,
-0.0270935446,
0.0207929444,
-0.0151648866,
0.0158569459,
-0.0528681129,
-0.003733445,
0.0057314802,
0.0462127216,
0.0274161398,
0.0311188065,
0.0642542467,
-0.0002813564,
-0.0482072607,
0.0038347456,
-0.0576899461,
0.0235786736,
-0.0094231321,
-0.0524843559,
0.0294212736,
0.0294670891,
-0.0194778945,
0.0733264312,
0.0038082232,
-0.059349142,
-0.0606059954,
0.0699982271,
-0.0537018105,
0.0197885539,
-0.0056357253,
-0.0019806465,
-0.0182122234,
0.0256415922,
0.0538611226,
-0.0478648953,
-0.0141537432,
0.0443920083,
2.911e-7,
0.0138604781,
0.037143819,
0.015747074,
0.0577777214,
-0.0210025236,
0.044635471,
-0.0317917168,
-0.0409969166,
0.0524355806,
-0.0638490021,
-0.0213202424,
0.0550366528,
0.0189908296,
0.0531979203,
-0.0633688644,
-0.0296695568,
-0.0585672706,
-0.0262816809,
-0.0180198476,
-0.0199307781,
0.0838205665,
0.0290510375,
0.01615295,
-0.0029384987,
-0.0165824909,
0.0116430363,
0.0481685512,
0.0039326749,
0.0260146242,
-0.0330516659,
-0.00097225,
-0.0280457027,
0.0350763388,
0.0657634214,
0.0137523795,
-0.0218335632,
-0.0373739861,
-0.0078604817,
0.0064941002,
0.0003039051,
-0.0287501868,
-0.004088995,
0.0262860563,
-0.0680616572,
0.059560895,
-0.0360437743,
0.0286396276,
0.0148959365,
-0.0046185832,
-0.0054304153,
-0.0049604676,
-0.0016150561,
-0.0117532341,
0.0010349302,
-0.0021157414,
0.0005024899,
-0.0030027991,
-0.0667194948,
-0.0534799099,
0.0611311868,
0.0039838217,
-0.0172543414,
-0.0106322961,
0.0134198898,
0.0038093745,
-0.0460368395,
-0.0185728297,
2.526807759e-34,
0.0134365186,
-0.0147496909,
0.0555833504,
0.0432817377,
0.0658580139,
0.0020296858,
-0.0232493896,
0.0139942672,
0.038521003,
-0.02699106,
-0.0327207968
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.09206v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.09206v3 | TableLlama: Towards Open Large Generalist Models for Tables | 2023-11-15T18:47:52 | 2024-04-04T17:10:25 | Tianshu Zhang, Xiang Yue, Yifei Li, Huan Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.DB | Semi-structured tables are ubiquitous. There has been a variety of tasks that
aim to automatically interpret, augment, and query tables. Current methods
often require pretraining on tables or special model architecture design, are
restricted to specific table types, or have simplifying assumptions about
tables and tasks. This paper makes the first step towards developing
open-source large language models (LLMs) as generalists for a diversity of
table-based tasks. Towards that end, we construct TableInstruct, a new dataset
with a variety of realistic tables and tasks, for instruction tuning and
evaluating LLMs. We further develop the first open-source generalist model for
tables, TableLlama, by fine-tuning Llama 2 (7B) with LongLoRA to address the
long context challenge. We experiment under both in-domain setting and
out-of-domain setting. On 7 out of 8 in-domain tasks, TableLlama achieves
comparable or better performance than the SOTA for each task, despite the
latter often has task-specific design. On 6 out-of-domain datasets, it achieves
5-44 absolute point gains compared with the base model, showing that training
on TableInstruct enhances the model's generalizability. We open-source our
dataset and trained model to boost future work on developing open generalist
models for tables. | [
0.025357632,
0.0810820237,
0.0055484306,
0.0315103605,
-0.0183999389,
0.0462367497,
-0.0194863342,
0.0266865604,
-0.0200838093,
-0.0168206282,
-0.0762259141,
-0.0171401631,
-0.0284450743,
0.0171476081,
0.0243764333,
0.0065093613,
0.0127944639,
-0.0265489127,
-0.0473615825,
0.0262603313,
-0.0137141608,
-0.0226202086,
0.0023013421,
0.0076130647,
-0.0035061529,
-0.0310531277,
-0.0391982533,
0.0015234982,
-0.053692501,
-0.0010681483,
0.0246184003,
0.0760172382,
0.0496484041,
0.0253838077,
0.0000020689,
0.0217144918,
-0.0469088405,
-0.0088639818,
0.0034539755,
0.0259319171,
0.0509981848,
-0.0635140613,
-0.0225170553,
-0.0171798393,
-0.0335375294,
-0.0183157418,
0.0231744722,
0.0560207665,
0.0221644547,
0.058173947,
0.0065638558,
-0.0649959445,
0.0184296072,
-0.0316248238,
0.0577445254,
-0.0414646119,
0.0153836478,
0.0144149233,
0.005732873,
-0.0153295752,
-0.0049801003,
0.038005095,
0.0298513677,
-0.028156545,
-0.0055641183,
0.0392725803,
-0.0509960912,
0.0157340039,
0.0300420281,
0.0886492878,
-0.0133614242,
-0.0126027158,
0.0064705629,
0.0075722132,
0.0162808876,
-0.0503879339,
-0.0532206744,
0.002554605,
0.0194473658,
0.0002936557,
0.0089571457,
-0.0297750365,
0.0057551311,
-0.0048763496,
-0.0356644876,
0.0381299742,
-0.0071960995,
-0.0328393802,
-0.0045110225,
-0.0209208447,
-0.0117049553,
-0.0289446805,
-0.0054513607,
0.0417670645,
-0.0314315632,
0.0252581444,
-0.0007285175,
-0.0381517038,
0.0128240725,
-0.0514113903,
0.0543394834,
0.0465608351,
-0.047812365,
0.0129812816,
-0.0423087552,
0.0139282364,
-0.0427569747,
0.0601599663,
-0.038632419,
-0.0124057457,
-0.0338058025,
0.0123975156,
-0.0455793962,
0.0174973402,
-0.0867936388,
-0.0210987497,
0.0045593916,
0.0235650614,
0.0062950258,
0.0340813175,
0.0498806052,
0.0272182953,
-0.0227002129,
-0.0023759,
-0.0091935964,
0.0055139689,
-0.0163654108,
-0.0023176039,
-0.020226052,
-0.0823664293,
-0.007320777,
-0.0161014237,
0.0247155353,
-0.0475222841,
0.0511695296,
0.073418878,
-0.0544707961,
-0.0216339901,
-0.0709580332,
0.0007192602,
-0.0164825153,
-0.0767605901,
0.0126136569,
-0.0423258469,
0.0396334864,
0.001719501,
0.0187403429,
-0.0541579276,
0.0004548126,
0.0304886475,
0.0033353171,
0.0673514679,
0.0090279728,
0.0209285226,
0.0065795793,
-0.0203279443,
-0.0096100932,
0.0921604335,
0.0260291528,
0.0306505095,
-0.0057484377,
-0.0090027479,
-0.0363883376,
0.0686697215,
0.0141845709,
-0.003317537,
-0.0190627482,
0.0555533879,
0.0385138318,
0.035671737,
0.0123742502,
0.0243592747,
-0.0150124757,
0.0180080179,
0.0554703511,
0.0097584473,
0.0338615365,
0.0770296678,
0.0230433811,
-0.0196845904,
0.0208370388,
0.0228673164,
-0.0307317097,
0.0318358913,
0.0255874097,
0.0197642129,
0.0171731021,
-0.0074196677,
-0.0325741023,
-0.043197006,
0.026768269,
-0.0067615011,
0.0069074817,
0.0007674457,
0.0536223501,
0.0211715624,
-0.0791404247,
-0.0060751596,
0.0044071618,
-0.0646821037,
-0.0230586715,
-0.0301167853,
0.0711561292,
0.0607310086,
0.0327145047,
-0.0900994614,
-0.019552784,
0.0088803731,
0.0401409045,
0.016697282,
0.0200222582,
-0.033491347,
0.0204639062,
-0.0232378282,
-0.016887879,
0.0106505388,
0.0318544246,
-0.0067902799,
0.0436127074,
-0.0154090859,
0.027531663,
-0.0594905242,
-0.0418429598,
0.0385105349,
0.0183927957,
-0.0123616112,
-0.0154998722,
0.0154358475,
0.0051209908,
0.0199711472,
-0.0125780562,
0.0161956232,
0.0501328334,
-0.0366351418,
0.0243087765,
-0.0320432,
-0.0217136759,
0.0244316105,
0.0241387822,
0.0232033134,
-0.0584713593,
0.0108469659,
-0.0437859744,
-0.0262163617,
0.0017811635,
0.0082143601,
0.0061931279,
-0.0323881768,
0.0129049933,
0.0008129362,
0.0174503811,
-0.0063322517,
0.0691451207,
0.0023249884,
0.0133001935,
0.0188933127,
-0.094259277,
0.0178670622,
-0.0333493799,
-0.0084278658,
-0.0027395927,
-0.0204351489,
0.0260218363,
-0.0063121398,
0.0482556,
-0.0635756925,
-0.0389590524,
-0.1121813729,
0.0410838872,
-0.0561258905,
0.0306665804,
0.0301785525,
0.0149944015,
-0.0183994565,
-0.0210404042,
-0.0356872007,
-0.0148577811,
-0.0187964961,
0.0096215615,
0.0466302894,
-0.0014129357,
-0.02767721,
-0.0441511497,
-0.0458190739,
-0.0227162465,
0.0192548633,
-0.0430706628,
-0.03542668,
0.0016097596,
0.01035468,
0.0188534632,
0.0516458787,
0.0025353367,
-0.0144430306,
0.0006481853,
-0.0468182825,
0.031270165,
0.0954444334,
-0.0113290418,
0.0121046221,
0.0044068336,
-0.0035111366,
-0.0191380698,
0.0298084561,
0.006200681,
-0.0291111432,
-0.0034249527,
-0.0224954393,
0.0218698494,
0.0543454066,
-0.0481768139,
-0.0061806133,
-0.0290999189,
-0.0380434655,
-0.0024431203,
-0.0117377033,
-0.0744816214,
0.0647977293,
0.0126186209,
-0.0038191788,
-0.0284701623,
0.0060956804,
-0.0044233645,
-0.0469904244,
0.0198883284,
-0.0018843118,
-0.0126292454,
-0.0824714303,
0.0952356979,
0.0241984688,
-0.0050895424,
0.0282550901,
-0.0306416061,
-0.0621251836,
0.0222037192,
-0.0170286968,
-0.0095306775,
0.1298381835,
-0.0687122196,
0.0294380728,
-0.0287573077,
-0.0458573811,
-0.0052670445,
-0.0188352708,
-0.0172105357,
0.0215859395,
0.0243389849,
-0.0268917028,
-0.0411003791,
-0.0169818904,
0.0224592816,
0.0806398913,
-0.0092596803,
-0.0070404187,
-0.0548565574,
0.0228921603,
0.0379920974,
0.0215496328,
-0.0796405002,
-0.0202625282,
-0.0034012129,
0.0372057706,
-0.0026807401,
-0.0342971049,
-0.0495938063,
0.0318182632,
0.0228468534,
-0.0289013386,
-0.0278674345,
0.0366252027,
-0.00472712,
-0.071141541,
-0.0069151102,
0.0831038877,
0.0103436382,
-0.0255492218,
-0.0306779854,
0.0023186849,
0.0326943435,
0.0175701957,
0.0198434573,
-0.1114337519,
-0.0480401181,
-0.0057751043,
-0.0282778982,
0.0375103652,
-0.0341878608,
-0.0229834858,
-0.0899446309,
0.0249818377,
-0.0193645041,
-0.0965783969,
-0.0707946122,
-0.0147282965,
-0.0102597345,
-0.0490332246,
0.0367629081,
0.0517705753,
-0.0367843807,
0.0169022307,
0.016116308,
-0.0149508165,
-0.0432241,
0.0044830334,
-0.0643645599,
0.0309504382,
0.0553051047,
0.0363731235,
0.005406634,
0.0165223461,
0.0482088774,
0.0040293671,
0.0279946215,
0.0024865696,
0.0607998967,
0.002715643,
-0.014364697,
0.0201533902,
0.003391068,
-0.0452426821,
0.0092813643,
0.0115039963,
0.0535905659,
0.009876376,
0.0191226006,
0.0171421356,
-0.0476764403,
-0.0019604613,
0.0387841575,
0.0300719123,
0.0119859474,
-0.0522161014,
-0.030277269,
-0.049780868,
-0.0555311181,
0.0340789706,
0.0502256788,
-0.0443111844,
-0.0218319185,
-0.0361764394,
-0.0063323476,
0.0476999171,
0.0264435802,
0.009181519,
0.0335843936,
-0.034032993,
-0.0164065957,
-0.0666587278,
0.0091069369,
-0.0875424817,
0.0362771191,
-0.0521658473,
-0.0399204418,
0.0217190385,
-0.0101840254,
-0.0063126148,
0.0252993014,
-0.0642773136,
-0.0243164841,
-0.0051337066,
0.0251709651,
0.0221091304,
0.0226654708,
0.0175707694,
-0.0376054756,
-0.028275514,
0.00230076,
-0.0764160231,
-0.0110442331,
0.0138802119,
-0.0643074885,
0.0070151263,
0.0451710187,
-0.0234685261,
0.0062327837,
-0.0058991737,
0.0160886645,
0.0252339169,
0.0498917624,
0.0397991315,
0.0068679489,
-0.0062933639,
0.0514756478,
-0.0530962758,
-0.0291419998,
0.0519807003,
-0.0411184467,
-0.0195858423,
-0.0094072241,
0.0091956304,
0.0316879824,
0.0104027977,
-0.0167138632,
0.0310950764,
0.0262226388,
0.0560232848,
-0.0500260778,
0.0126508055,
0.0370112509,
-0.0167139526,
0.0375783034,
-0.0153972534,
-0.0058137313,
-0.0093019195,
0.0223123021,
0.0254076272,
-0.0103192311,
0.008052079,
0.0053988583,
-0.0064704786,
-0.0498558246,
0.0619339682,
-0.0416361392,
-0.0373474397,
-0.0223711245,
0.0101613738,
0.0491260625,
-0.0001400424,
0.0113198226,
-0.0007122894,
-0.0153831514,
-0.0022348568,
0.0389031619,
0.0345397703,
-0.0031314676,
0.0369205549,
0.0109662749,
0.0063039851,
-0.0433988646,
0.0980512574,
0.0491175354,
0.0491412617,
0.0139224418,
0.0051675793,
-0.0526670106,
0.0035925603,
0.013196093,
-0.0232104585,
-0.0317348093,
-0.0406773947,
0.0142350476,
-0.0326046087,
0.0128692258,
0.0264747757,
-0.0427770577,
-0.0000771452,
0.0356014371,
0.0522990786,
0.0456723087,
-0.0247827079,
-0.0288285296,
-0.001718621,
0.016173711,
-0.0291701984,
-0.0118542388,
-6.456544516e-33,
-0.0249679536,
0.0016328907,
0.0343626887,
-0.0557864904,
-0.0240915231,
-0.0149258459,
-0.0319820978,
-0.0214482937,
-0.0082825348,
-0.001349312,
-0.0535415262,
0.0467813574,
0.0250486694,
-0.0068998225,
0.027744405,
-0.0834215954,
0.0361413583,
-0.0140917208,
0.0124349771,
0.0060036485,
-0.0131190233,
0.034065906,
0.0368008353,
-0.0264682528,
0.0323944502,
0.0225693863,
0.0005758535,
-0.0228070114,
0.0071356175,
0.0196763072,
-0.0370420627,
0.027293101,
0.0329669714,
-0.0562338494,
-0.0278544594,
0.0301327799,
-0.1529734135,
-0.0047938065,
0.0153198959,
0.0368037708,
-0.0069957492,
-0.0457977429,
0.0121638728,
-0.0026714047,
0.0114864595,
-0.0102182627,
0.0221932903,
-0.0450640768,
-0.0020109722,
0.0306489579,
-0.0377423875,
0.0139740417,
0.0006627527,
0.0066128587,
0.0685249045,
0.0103841126,
0.0379961208,
-0.0202636272,
-0.0145884566,
0.0253702719,
0.021627022,
0.0504478328,
0.0549064986,
-0.0279133189,
0.028596526,
0.0081615048,
0.0335423872,
0.0191090349,
-0.0358111374,
-0.0238602832,
-0.0365958884,
0.0862218663,
0.0211270805,
-0.0081630312,
0.0371492021,
0.0093712164,
-0.0780904815,
0.0378859974,
-0.0066675702,
0.0161448382,
-0.0322215743,
0.0232370105,
-0.0096664988,
0.000420932,
-0.0078300051,
0.0110127889,
-0.0300870184,
-0.0139966859,
0.0275912471,
0.0040363888,
0.0249777883,
-0.0149926106,
0.0082285311,
-0.014609809,
-0.0189882219,
0.0553869009,
-0.0114182904,
0.018936621,
0.0155092869,
-0.0095847277,
-0.030292945,
-0.0606723242,
0.0221288521,
-0.0122527517,
0.035579659,
0.0363640115,
0.0553410612,
0.056918554,
-0.0626414269,
-0.0106923711,
-0.0421005003,
0.0278679226,
0.0240037795,
0.0385602713,
0.0098051,
0.0084211864,
0.0018942767,
0.0719018579,
0.0292197559,
0.0177457053,
-0.012866131,
-0.0095773805,
0.0192127097,
0.0076256804,
0.0143001145,
0.0009631468,
-0.0494211949,
0.0028610323,
0.0358805284,
-0.0324045718,
-0.0049130926,
-0.0007455829,
2.56e-7,
0.0753563941,
0.0009713306,
0.0659353435,
0.0684878826,
0.0038336576,
0.0074541369,
-0.014141297,
0.0105391201,
-0.0444523059,
-0.0263879355,
0.0378547981,
-0.0125348065,
0.0520218872,
0.0072797062,
-0.0518449917,
-0.0204864815,
-0.0533978939,
-0.0060477811,
-0.0611355826,
-0.0260355808,
0.0114101358,
0.1169867739,
-0.072560057,
0.0019139972,
-0.0132058254,
-0.0213953145,
0.0345776789,
-0.0770934522,
0.0324290767,
0.0244452767,
0.030950157,
0.00525404,
-0.0152970757,
0.0406804718,
-0.0149205355,
0.0006827363,
0.0216390286,
0.0569816194,
-0.005606744,
0.0453604646,
0.0319753066,
-0.0577554666,
0.0065840953,
-0.0547113232,
0.0984118506,
-0.0412782952,
0.0205094758,
0.075045228,
0.004974308,
0.015723113,
-0.0064356825,
-0.0002243299,
0.0282081235,
0.0241215918,
0.0420582853,
-0.0167256556,
-0.0070140278,
-0.0695489869,
-0.0285659097,
0.0100116404,
-0.026376972,
-0.0070918133,
-0.0484032072,
-0.0216525979,
-0.0257234126,
-0.045775,
-0.0190414563,
2.191083129e-34,
0.0504268073,
-0.0050572092,
0.017815074,
0.0518406518,
0.0505401231,
-0.0465468988,
-0.0047822734,
0.0064796298,
-0.0183080416,
-0.0860987529,
-0.0205861684
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.