id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12950v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12950v1 | MolecularGPT: Open Large Language Model (LLM) for Few-Shot Molecular Property Prediction | 2024-06-18T12:54:47 | 2024-06-18T12:54:47 | Yuyan Liu, Sirui Ding, Sheng Zhou, Wenqi Fan, Qiaoyu Tan | q-bio.QM | q-bio.QM, cs.AI, cs.CE, cs.CL, cs.LG | Molecular property prediction (MPP) is a fundamental and crucial task in drug
discovery. However, prior methods are limited by the requirement for a large
number of labeled molecules and their restricted ability to generalize for
unseen and new tasks, both of which are essential for real-world applications.
To address these challenges, we present MolecularGPT for few-shot MPP. From a
perspective on instruction tuning, we fine-tune large language models (LLMs)
based on curated molecular instructions spanning over 1000 property prediction
tasks. This enables building a versatile and specialized LLM that can be
adapted to novel MPP tasks without any fine-tuning through zero- and few-shot
in-context learning (ICL). MolecularGPT exhibits competitive in-context
reasoning capabilities across 10 downstream evaluation datasets, setting new
benchmarks for few-shot molecular prediction tasks. More importantly, with just
two-shot examples, MolecularGPT can outperform standard supervised graph neural
network methods on 4 out of 7 datasets. It also excels state-of-the-art LLM
baselines by up to 16.6% increase on classification accuracy and decrease of
199.17 on regression metrics (e.g., RMSE) under zero-shot. This study
demonstrates the potential of LLMs as effective few-shot molecular property
predictors. The code is available at https://github.com/NYUSHCS/MolecularGPT. | [
-0.2640832961,
-0.775988996,
0.6435085535,
-0.3346303403,
-0.221713379,
-0.0186461005,
-0.4564536214,
-0.191707179,
-0.210258916,
0.5219493508,
-0.6277666092,
-0.6601384282,
-0.8284819126,
-0.1595397741,
0.1344342828,
1.1773990393,
0.0843370631,
0.2775609195,
-0.0007944872,
0.0677139312,
-0.0710077882,
-0.1380953342,
-0.3762867749,
-0.5463550091,
0.5503585339,
0.673951745,
0.3198667467,
0.8281196356,
0.9015769958,
0.1739884317,
-0.0806375071,
-0.0333220363,
-0.7282987833,
-0.1473041326,
-0.0199984387,
-0.3427559733,
-0.631704092,
-0.000033551,
0.3250599205,
0.5865692496,
-0.0813617706,
0.0282951593,
0.0925040096,
0.6617274284,
-0.6510047913,
0.2446508557,
-0.7848080397,
0.2852628827,
-0.3047038019,
-0.274017334,
-0.1838098019,
0.1559660733,
0.3312542439,
-0.4376180768,
0.2517123818,
-0.0155850044,
0.5613535047,
0.3376284838,
-0.4613088071,
0.0742169917,
-0.4944815338,
0.6269385815,
-0.8340663314,
0.1533596367,
0.278875798,
0.6887500882,
-0.6486926079,
-0.7374859452,
-0.28162691,
-0.7545676827,
0.1755044013,
0.1562234908,
0.0721813887,
0.4376694858,
0.1605995446,
0.2503676414,
-0.7272906303,
0.0797374994,
-0.394756794,
-0.1107726172,
0.2397573292,
0.1715471745,
0.0932297334,
-0.1026061699,
-0.5743746758,
0.057247851,
-0.8539658189,
-0.1628863215,
0.0376925245,
0.7420579195,
-0.0380613953,
0.894737184,
-0.3351426423,
0.7179079056,
-0.0513072722,
-0.184538573,
-0.1950045228,
-0.2649286091,
-0.3190365732,
0.3536140323,
0.7897512317,
0.3262161314,
0.2945069075,
0.0926111117,
0.017038919,
-0.2175166309,
-0.0636359528,
-1.3138694763,
-0.5067141652,
0.2414163798,
-0.1599985212,
-0.2299582213,
0.09148065,
-0.8595828414,
-0.4864079356,
-0.0835596249,
0.3857554197,
-0.560339272,
0.2986510992,
0.1922950298,
-0.2131418884,
-0.1472635269,
0.1581021398,
-1.145116806,
0.1811666638,
0.8340787888,
1.0187487602,
-0.3887092173,
-0.4882660508,
-0.6914508939,
0.3196726441,
-0.0589321665,
0.9539061785,
-0.840524137,
-0.2320610434,
-0.4999231696,
-0.0729406476,
0.1493675113,
-0.5120210648,
0.1480959952,
-0.1321817338,
-0.1511510164,
0.016777873,
-0.7549086213,
0.0529210903,
0.4157607257,
-0.3141429722,
0.4615520239,
0.3793134987,
-0.3780807853,
0.5360625386,
-0.6867930293,
-0.1308558732,
0.244695887,
-0.1927096695,
-0.3942458034,
0.0378471203,
0.1917764843,
0.5687693954,
-0.0600701869,
-0.0690703541,
-0.457898885,
-0.4705495834,
0.1749486625,
-0.3773450553,
0.3588068783,
-0.0621716492,
-0.3105828166,
0.1481959969,
-0.8044477105,
0.1055416986,
-0.2093492448,
-0.5058621764,
0.3595331013,
-0.4091685414,
-0.0506853051,
0.2420252711,
0.1438573003,
-0.5215184093,
0.7855326533,
-0.5423355699,
0.4664241374,
0.854808867,
0.2453885078,
0.6281940341,
-0.0637089461,
0.8645205498,
0.1222322211,
-0.0512018502,
-0.1591413766,
-0.5969535112,
-0.4751063883,
-0.3886206448,
0.3244206309,
0.697868228,
-0.4869866669,
0.164631173,
-0.3131484091,
-0.5382192135,
0.0171657261,
0.5770213604,
0.5025793314,
0.4820456207,
0.4656930566,
-0.1682243049,
-0.3416984975,
-0.7251217961,
-0.4179418683,
0.0288283397,
-0.1922236234,
0.6618663073,
0.7198380232,
-0.3391764164,
0.7047458887,
-0.806866169,
-0.6113934517,
-0.4900767505,
-0.0392368808,
0.3556727171,
0.3182053864,
0.1563408971,
-0.192852214,
-0.7290913463,
0.332600832,
-0.4185145199,
0.0016466447,
0.0787040666,
-0.2685477436,
0.0100089926,
0.3692609072,
-0.7355248332,
0.1741119772,
0.4864464402,
-0.1428232789,
0.3254971802,
-0.0549742617,
-0.1824004054,
-0.901806891,
-0.2345936447,
0.3693056703,
-0.1510337442,
-0.4629859328,
-0.1454464197,
-0.2697917521,
-0.0650684163,
-0.8100661635,
0.7271187305,
-0.1651505381,
0.0891527459,
-0.4564369321,
-0.1112260148,
-0.1893289536,
0.5294060111,
0.0135177663,
0.7421845198,
0.5707983375,
-0.3128758669,
0.3639082611,
0.0375427678,
-0.2436142415,
0.2579821646,
-0.5061148405,
0.1610513777,
0.0970430076,
0.3928108215,
-0.5996240973,
-0.621325314,
0.3545174897,
-0.373225987,
0.5716339946,
-0.8745270967,
-0.2307528853,
-0.0054784329,
-0.2860326171,
0.0222281404,
0.3472631276,
-0.4110647738,
0.4110850692,
0.1020534784,
-0.042163644,
-0.4554923177,
-0.725251615,
-0.0222861897,
-0.1161210388,
-0.4409109056,
0.1659186184,
-0.0146015454,
0.1968615353,
-0.1391829997,
-0.2039624155,
-0.2556481659,
-0.2247068584,
0.3302825689,
0.1910863072,
-0.4050142765,
0.2060765624,
-0.2209666818,
-0.4461750984,
-0.2726982534,
-0.7196255326,
0.4174889028,
-0.4739209116,
-0.0653648451,
-0.0407579057,
0.0111652436,
0.2673654854,
0.0111381616,
0.6053851843,
0.6523089409,
-0.0611237101,
-0.477474004,
0.2335018963,
-0.5132873058,
-0.518231988,
0.5481859446,
-0.3895086646,
-1.0055328608,
0.0831690356,
-0.3592755795,
-0.4624429047,
0.1455574483,
0.7392120361,
-0.2187826484,
0.658662498,
0.6169087887,
-0.0317288339,
0.3924444318,
-0.4630613625,
0.3686386943,
-0.7176846266,
-0.0372941941,
0.051856827,
-0.5742816329,
-0.7782955766,
-0.5052424073,
0.7898940444,
0.3158271015,
-0.4700430036,
0.4172628224,
-0.5753512383,
0.9242327213,
0.7342494726,
0.3885284066,
0.0611136518,
0.2102747262,
-0.0523655601,
-0.0279684309,
-0.6537060738,
-0.5060484409,
1.5765861273,
0.1005647033,
0.7278901339,
-0.0858597159,
0.7812814713,
-0.0363069102,
-0.0035510086,
-1.1719942093,
0.5991694927,
-0.3754097819,
-0.6317149401,
-0.3508279622,
-0.4742488265,
-0.6676934361,
-0.1142597049,
-0.1934711039,
-0.9765598178,
-0.0318889208,
0.501804769,
-0.5569884181,
0.3695637882,
-0.6674232483,
1.1128017902,
-0.2729204595,
-0.6424797773,
0.0602945425,
-0.8011381626,
0.4569002986,
-0.0218172669,
-0.4837677181,
-0.3692258298,
-0.070498161,
0.1972445548,
-0.554969728,
0.6512519121,
-0.0255595148,
0.2085919827,
0.2147509903,
0.2864323854,
0.5272480845,
0.0458818413,
0.0657754093,
0.2087612003,
0.0279599316,
-0.4426893294,
-0.6642580032,
0.8814011216,
-0.3846351206,
-0.3169341981,
-0.3903014362,
-0.4966104329,
-0.2644042373,
0.3443585634,
0.6873699427,
0.087536253,
-0.0469248146,
-0.004214664,
0.4777205884,
-0.1172816902,
0.1893173307,
0.444440484,
0.0044093402,
-0.228839606,
1.1886423826,
0.0807153806,
0.3384209275,
0.6176045537,
0.5871812701,
0.1224214807,
-0.7000170946,
-0.437322855,
-0.1927286685,
-0.7892402411,
-0.2969095111,
-0.3822350204,
-0.1087263823,
-0.234768942,
-0.2667147219,
-0.5742185116,
-0.6638178825,
-0.1411634535,
-0.2605420947,
0.5877942443,
0.5721624494,
-0.0792147294,
0.5300927758,
-0.9336788654,
0.5070270896,
0.4007567763,
0.5611950159,
-0.5287516117,
-0.4627927244,
-0.2592404485,
0.1011960953,
-0.4250245988,
-0.5547106862,
0.311909616,
0.5202993155,
0.2146125436,
0.4654853344,
-0.3645488024,
0.356182307,
-0.7267926335,
0.687519908,
-0.1641579121,
-0.6167939901,
0.837993145,
-0.7114270329,
0.3734185994,
0.7519638538,
0.278526485,
-0.138139382,
0.1012830213,
-0.3624020219,
-0.780136168,
0.5831127763,
0.1854882091,
-0.1235956252,
0.22521092,
0.2971645892,
0.0628949031,
0.1830378771,
-0.6713314056,
-0.2306760848,
-0.2042251378,
-0.2229006737,
-0.108014062,
-0.132961005,
-0.0595462024,
-0.5115323663,
0.71814996,
-0.4463851154,
0.2822363973,
-0.1661724001,
0.0849307179,
-0.0856204554,
0.5737982988,
0.8200778365,
0.471765399,
-0.8625352979,
0.0136734117,
0.1376704276,
-0.6915953159,
0.2542066276,
0.1590925306,
-0.0497184694,
-0.3433888257,
0.3803987205,
0.7595142722,
-0.0525785536,
-0.7470167875,
0.485530287,
0.3463874161,
0.034147948,
-0.0183509979,
0.3123201132,
-0.0160821527,
0.3207468092,
-0.0891003013,
0.1261914521,
0.2520963252,
-0.5836372375,
0.3642822504,
0.3872376978,
-0.5965826511,
-0.1119600683,
0.5713816285,
-0.0621905401,
0.0803022683,
0.5517065525,
-0.3300034404,
-0.459545821,
0.6483570337,
0.3925212026,
1.0200074911,
0.0067331474,
0.1035010517,
0.3391996622,
0.3283551633,
0.0151150888,
0.1324267387,
0.1665550172,
-0.7697734237,
-0.0192206949,
-0.6547677517,
-0.5898527503,
0.0119265243,
-0.0379451513,
0.4205606282,
-0.8375068307,
-0.0700728074,
0.2500433326,
0.1433215737,
-0.3471980393,
-0.0225084312,
0.2602074742,
0.6987793446,
-0.614408195,
1.1164814234,
0.4974260628,
-0.3171461225,
-0.5502910614,
-0.045358669,
0.5013931394,
-0.6668579578,
0.7509844303,
0.232634753,
-0.196617648,
-0.0206684861,
-0.8046435714,
-0.6315028667,
1.0695236921,
0.6361294389,
-0.9059078693,
0.1222661436,
0.4066092074,
0.50998348,
-0.4431315958,
0.1882365048,
1.0546575785,
0.6062831283,
0.3099355698,
-0.6738457084,
-0.2353947908,
-0.0212955475,
-0.0873924568,
0.2111061662,
-0.400441587,
0.7350190282,
-0.5102427006,
0.1814740747,
-0.0019011692,
0.176491335,
0.6855472326,
0.3059377968,
-0.1465117484,
0.6004947424,
0.4760291278,
-0.2244298905,
1.3482249975,
-0.3766626716,
0.2625285089,
1.4095392227,
-0.2560938299,
0.9380136132,
0.4479627311,
-0.3345338702,
0.2000870109,
0.5206690431,
-0.4374409914,
0.6395825744,
0.5326979756,
-0.4799268842,
-0.2160430104,
-0.0396306403,
-0.0431198142,
0.6577470303,
0.475782752,
-0.3317992389,
-0.1868035048,
0.0102618923,
-0.1810149401,
-0.2461027205,
-0.2572269142,
0.7311697602,
0.3028727472,
-0.2327121347,
0.4207127392,
-0.0303863101,
0.5937660336,
-0.6895659566,
-0.3649973571,
-0.2255136222,
0.4491111636,
-0.249943167,
-0.8536090255,
-0.1936288029,
-0.1861024797,
-0.2220924944,
0.1134906039,
0.8153553009,
-0.5482654572,
-0.7208935618,
0.1207519174,
0.1934395134,
0.1965751201,
-0.3597539663,
-0.749936223,
-0.3263798952,
-0.0825682431,
-0.4108124375,
0.3540401459,
0.3559841812,
0.1836270541,
0.8195750713,
0.5520510674,
0.2997424901,
0.1248772666,
-0.170554772,
0.7882683873,
-0.7267965674,
0.0703752488,
-0.9870219827,
0.3546798527,
0.2674998939,
-0.4344885051,
0.5023946166,
0.7054041028,
0.736040771,
-0.248328656,
0.7123826146,
0.4144042432,
0.24592641,
-0.8252456784,
0.615742147,
-0.207793951,
0.5115325451,
-0.0498403646,
-1.0884116888,
-0.420697242,
0.5358135104,
-0.1675406098,
0.3395993114,
0.6826800704,
1.2094786167,
-0.3495161533,
-0.3731429279,
0.2932624519,
0.3759542108,
0.3608627915,
1.011027813,
0.5540387034,
-0.3817155957,
0.4042998552,
-0.5962564945,
0.0444585159,
-0.2592380047,
-1.1045372486,
-1.0083451271,
-0.0027483043,
-0.3297846913,
-0.2862117589,
0.1219807044,
1.2786308527,
0.879532218,
-1.0592740774,
-0.1424779594,
-0.5973159671,
-0.0885847136,
0.0230677202,
-0.2076991796,
0.3149723411,
-0.0161333773,
-0.5594165921,
0.8117490411,
0.7423007488,
0.4921919703,
-0.1272826344,
-0.123787716,
-0.028653061,
-0.1973369569,
0.6047561169,
0.4303846955,
-0.6693190336,
0.024654733,
-0.1317821592,
-0.1815343648,
0.3479994833,
0.8514688611,
-0.747364819,
0.5080725551,
0.615419209,
0.4939337075,
0.7742868662,
-0.0232810788,
0.6942341328,
-0.9882359505,
0.2600170672,
0.4506720304,
0.3139430583,
0.1431977153,
-0.4968892336,
0.6129128933,
0.071239844,
-0.5394247174,
-0.4919746816,
0.2428813726,
-1.2898404598,
-0.4135789573,
1.2121599913,
-0.1102929488,
-0.199613288,
0.3193150759,
-0.1279619336,
-0.0470651612,
-0.6064326167,
0.4711689353,
0.552457571,
-0.3207372725,
-0.633221209,
-0.863008678,
0.7322595716,
0.1559368819,
-0.8052095771,
-0.0256808065,
0.5100371242,
0.2235123217,
-0.3067581356,
0.4988647997,
0.1699326634,
0.2146004736,
-0.057645943,
-0.1798755676,
-0.3288922012,
-0.6025500298,
-0.3910304606,
-0.0721549839,
0.0619737692,
0.0327560902
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12566v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12566v2 | RichRAG: Crafting Rich Responses for Multi-faceted Queries in Retrieval-Augmented Generation | 2024-06-18T12:52:51 | 2024-06-21T18:12:15 | Shuting Wang, Xin Yu, Mang Wang, Weipeng Chen, Yutao Zhu, Zhicheng Dou | cs.CL | cs.CL | Retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) effectively addresses issues of static
knowledge and hallucination in large language models. Existing studies mostly
focus on question scenarios with clear user intents and concise answers.
However, it is prevalent that users issue broad, open-ended queries with
diverse sub-intents, for which they desire rich and long-form answers covering
multiple relevant aspects. To tackle this important yet underexplored problem,
we propose a novel RAG framework, namely RichRAG. It includes a sub-aspect
explorer to identify potential sub-aspects of input questions, a multi-faceted
retriever to build a candidate pool of diverse external documents related to
these sub-aspects, and a generative list-wise ranker, which is a key module to
provide the top-k most valuable documents for the final generator. These ranked
documents sufficiently cover various query aspects and are aware of the
generator's preferences, hence incentivizing it to produce rich and
comprehensive responses for users. The training of our ranker involves a
supervised fine-tuning stage to ensure the basic coverage of documents, and a
reinforcement learning stage to align downstream LLM's preferences to the
ranking of documents. Experimental results on two publicly available datasets
prove that our framework effectively and efficiently provides comprehensive and
satisfying responses to users. | [
-0.8066781163,
-0.8380968571,
0.2615296245,
0.1854189336,
-0.0638768002,
0.1777306199,
-0.1664735973,
-0.4057587981,
0.5445910096,
0.6074695587,
-0.321317941,
-0.0841259658,
-0.5420148373,
0.0210759528,
-0.4332911074,
1.474075675,
0.1467788815,
-0.3185049593,
-0.1939959228,
-0.1847717166,
-0.3208636343,
-0.406144619,
-0.5657844543,
-0.1910611093,
1.0306330919,
0.3921242654,
0.5376423597,
0.2542905509,
0.2116998285,
0.2606818378,
-0.2387230098,
0.5113375187,
-0.8425189257,
0.8179070354,
-0.4229814708,
-0.2344465405,
-0.3991146982,
-0.2244302183,
0.4033729732,
0.5308733582,
0.076886639,
0.309920609,
0.2903497815,
0.6132829189,
-0.8996468782,
-0.2901415527,
-0.8503993154,
-0.0073184851,
-0.4362886846,
-0.4935026765,
-0.2806438506,
0.1050312445,
-0.2564789653,
-0.6554851532,
0.4800802767,
0.097212635,
0.7417345643,
0.2776833475,
-0.3586770296,
-0.3441983163,
-0.8075274229,
0.5961458683,
-0.1878470033,
0.3715554476,
0.4888122082,
0.5991932154,
-0.0392417125,
-0.6197882295,
-0.5908678174,
0.2000479847,
-0.1780026257,
0.3249741793,
0.3610881269,
-0.1596112847,
0.0811386481,
0.6290296316,
-0.6675307155,
-0.096070163,
-0.2132397145,
-0.07440532,
0.6913087964,
0.1126041114,
-0.0608742796,
-0.3818495572,
-0.2712316215,
-0.16077739,
-0.5763757825,
-0.0150061967,
0.5158239603,
0.4248331785,
0.1555404514,
0.9624410868,
-0.5378959775,
0.6444907188,
0.3449510336,
-0.0162953399,
0.0013575458,
-0.3662862778,
0.0226567984,
-0.0310091004,
0.4845350087,
-0.0341756791,
-0.0971041545,
-0.180944398,
-0.625163734,
-0.4140990973,
0.4569678605,
-1.0800837278,
-0.0101298317,
0.4959506691,
-0.2481439561,
-0.3202862144,
-0.0549525954,
-1.0855997801,
-0.7318731546,
-0.2248316407,
0.5510917902,
-0.0648389682,
-0.16512613,
-0.1042192578,
-0.1415013373,
0.3000705838,
0.3111052513,
-0.8366615176,
0.1534382403,
0.8337003589,
0.4301872551,
0.0105072362,
-0.3447755277,
-1.2109899521,
0.3286058009,
-0.1626608223,
1.2107275724,
-0.7112976313,
-0.3306419849,
-0.021806214,
-0.1662579477,
0.0049710851,
-0.668664813,
0.4439172149,
-0.947301805,
0.5217013359,
-0.3103071749,
-0.2705315948,
0.1217862368,
0.6184585094,
-0.7119053006,
1.1356793642,
0.2818131745,
-1.1048092842,
0.4004233181,
-0.4220587313,
-0.3292490542,
0.2846807837,
-0.3048859835,
-0.4920311868,
0.1345481873,
0.2904368639,
0.4667269289,
-0.3061397076,
0.3506223559,
-0.1234426573,
-0.4177663922,
0.1937206835,
-0.1805966645,
0.3962771893,
0.3910889924,
-0.233724311,
0.4030460715,
-0.5050932169,
-0.0181687325,
0.0909629688,
-0.6048892736,
-0.3315103948,
-0.0431759097,
0.3195511401,
0.1256615818,
0.2514759302,
-0.4667652845,
0.2176284194,
-0.3991615772,
-0.1970081329,
0.5334765911,
0.1314903647,
0.3800790012,
-0.4910306633,
0.6372571588,
-0.0349686071,
-0.0130013656,
-0.1358334273,
-0.2238561958,
-0.7324674129,
-0.3491313457,
0.3557898402,
0.3962829709,
-0.9319891334,
0.2660804689,
-0.3009547889,
-0.3574136198,
-0.6404070854,
0.2619107962,
0.3951745331,
0.2765132785,
0.5118384957,
-0.1436345875,
-0.4077195525,
-0.6926311255,
-0.3761666715,
0.0719239861,
-0.1351686716,
0.7490135431,
0.3671952188,
-0.2861922085,
0.758494854,
-0.4141781926,
-0.3380074799,
-0.5177071691,
0.1583600342,
0.0549848154,
0.1914710701,
0.355575949,
-1.1429332495,
-0.5234995484,
0.0994998142,
-0.4759123623,
-0.088823162,
-0.0356083885,
-0.4033731222,
0.0020811409,
0.10880889,
-0.7003030181,
0.0938892365,
0.3404873908,
-0.3110671043,
0.3589173853,
0.0423754528,
0.2014437467,
-1.4216513634,
0.3402207494,
-0.3894492686,
-0.1049855202,
-0.3069639802,
0.4510847032,
-0.1670046449,
-0.3440431952,
-0.1859726906,
0.9648028016,
-0.1768596023,
-0.4000423849,
-0.247514531,
0.1309822351,
0.126283586,
0.303402245,
-0.1229370385,
0.9198477268,
0.1514657289,
-0.5449799299,
0.1906727105,
0.2824811041,
0.0822338015,
0.6722701192,
-0.7613050938,
0.07219892,
-0.4516319931,
0.2841961682,
-0.7023324966,
-0.6356093884,
-0.0576497987,
-0.4646758437,
0.4614077508,
-0.3401825726,
-0.3738553822,
-0.062928997,
-0.4901364148,
0.4930054545,
0.13114582,
-0.5408135056,
0.9328460693,
0.4091267586,
-0.3651356995,
-0.8203508854,
-0.1840325445,
-0.0568625443,
-0.2335588634,
-0.4785452783,
0.4207899868,
-0.1775611192,
-0.1487163603,
0.071900025,
-0.0715816319,
-0.1003676131,
0.1065083742,
0.0618587695,
-0.0865272433,
0.0274625532,
-0.0024663636,
0.1763564646,
-0.0787548274,
-0.3547596335,
-0.0774785951,
0.7679752111,
0.1402025074,
-0.4080408216,
0.3478302658,
0.623065412,
0.4120596051,
-0.8132954836,
0.6350553036,
0.981943965,
-0.1950199157,
-0.5864911675,
-0.4680830836,
-0.1878396422,
-0.4127182961,
0.2483638376,
-0.6146663427,
-1.0604431629,
0.5787239075,
0.07875745,
0.2119515836,
0.4382294714,
0.7097432613,
0.0264057219,
0.9633957744,
0.466999948,
0.0622665547,
0.3115564287,
-0.3599271178,
0.2286724746,
-1.0646916628,
-0.3913366199,
-0.7255429029,
-0.4751248062,
-0.691439867,
-0.4634671509,
0.6241961122,
0.3746244013,
-0.2885083854,
0.0043144552,
-0.591817379,
0.2853283882,
0.4447306991,
-0.1469217092,
0.2164429277,
-0.0131029813,
-0.0514680222,
0.2530679107,
-0.590528667,
-0.2172950208,
0.9251132607,
0.0279038977,
0.9106366634,
0.1205138341,
1.0911781788,
0.1214219853,
0.2784048915,
-0.7880404592,
0.3736595511,
0.0065094172,
-0.7854470015,
-0.3780468106,
-0.5650268793,
-1.1054232121,
0.590898931,
-0.3073062897,
-0.233393237,
0.1433551162,
0.0761422068,
-0.4104225338,
0.0823665857,
-0.1097477302,
0.6510738134,
-0.3901533782,
-0.7607186437,
-0.0733493045,
-0.5121865273,
0.4035522938,
-0.1163957641,
0.1381877363,
0.1874724478,
-0.0329668708,
0.536033392,
-0.0905703977,
0.3780484796,
-0.2081305683,
-0.0096862102,
0.1886652708,
0.2051809877,
0.5044014454,
0.3746420145,
-0.1736349165,
-0.4381303191,
-0.19953987,
-0.445119828,
-0.5654937029,
0.8015635014,
-0.5401459932,
-0.451398313,
-0.3424344957,
-0.6851038933,
-0.3121865392,
0.3486363292,
0.2168958038,
0.4399379492,
-0.0090642534,
0.3224486709,
0.9975231886,
-0.4487318993,
0.1120507419,
0.302690506,
-0.4601272941,
-0.5066864491,
0.9706350565,
-0.0142760715,
-0.1786738187,
0.5556382537,
0.2270308286,
-0.2263474911,
-0.4997879267,
-0.7502960563,
0.1493588537,
-0.3733841181,
-0.4627808928,
-0.9792877436,
-0.3000921607,
-0.3771004081,
-0.0291937888,
-0.3300187886,
-0.3606368899,
-0.0021727106,
0.1021418571,
0.3084169924,
0.7250984311,
0.1415140182,
-0.1340182573,
-0.7410440445,
0.7408748269,
0.6490501761,
0.5138856769,
-0.078891471,
-0.3770538568,
-0.2793668807,
-0.0930515528,
-0.4143627584,
-0.5255486369,
0.3395097554,
0.2409340441,
0.7022157907,
0.0874968842,
0.2681420147,
0.5858199596,
-0.3399534225,
0.7785455585,
-0.4967631698,
-0.2884019315,
0.5730296373,
-0.5364664793,
0.072163865,
0.8282238245,
0.4454675019,
-0.3630132079,
-0.3371948898,
-0.4903708398,
-1.1307336092,
0.3759736717,
0.0396120362,
0.1872495413,
0.0333621874,
0.1826754957,
0.2842438817,
0.3687489033,
-0.3811149001,
-0.0000238881,
-0.386577934,
-0.0901919007,
0.0942704007,
-0.2691923678,
-0.3118984103,
0.0449363478,
0.6885799766,
-0.3206697106,
0.1458660513,
0.1000187248,
-0.0215872526,
-0.1319039613,
0.6094991565,
0.4300288558,
0.5030950308,
-0.205987677,
0.2987344861,
-0.2558012605,
-0.3143890798,
-0.2264070511,
0.5988690257,
-0.2897286713,
-0.2007020712,
0.2694537342,
0.5657104254,
0.090446502,
-0.5827926993,
0.4896169901,
-0.0145341568,
0.0032624297,
-0.0993821397,
0.0650673732,
0.0201954283,
0.2610246837,
0.4742165804,
-0.2123254985,
0.3897599578,
-0.5441073179,
0.2015031874,
0.6594939232,
-0.1455633193,
-0.1776629984,
0.8430027366,
0.1937320679,
-0.1762064546,
0.3649663031,
-0.4027660489,
-0.7752459049,
0.1130657569,
0.3689441085,
0.7925285101,
0.0109329578,
0.2547463477,
0.1563402861,
-0.0834039971,
0.0818035454,
0.4919950068,
-0.4414252341,
-0.460801065,
-0.4756940901,
-1.1886508465,
-0.2986393571,
0.2247366756,
-0.5574098825,
-0.0745494291,
-0.1533938199,
0.1435417831,
-0.1466212273,
0.2450822443,
-0.6859741211,
0.109800674,
-0.2095532566,
0.6021248698,
-0.4431348741,
0.4063063264,
0.7897282839,
-0.6505863667,
-0.7557817101,
0.11377009,
-0.3046799302,
-0.5149716735,
0.5780402422,
-0.076952979,
-0.080453299,
-0.0494446643,
-0.3383148909,
-0.6858103275,
0.952814281,
0.1616890132,
-0.1284417361,
0.0059437836,
0.0288710222,
0.4263485074,
-0.150775671,
0.3681899905,
0.0672911704,
0.4184194505,
0.1891486496,
-0.8649428487,
-0.1697356403,
-0.4214277565,
-0.0362697802,
0.396188736,
-0.6840547919,
0.9488906264,
0.0520323589,
-0.0210195296,
0.0097079882,
0.4736627936,
0.5736601353,
0.5262332559,
0.2823676169,
0.8081552982,
0.6215661168,
0.1866487861,
1.2783280611,
-0.3177381158,
0.1985783577,
1.1075048447,
-0.344647944,
0.903378129,
0.4139665663,
0.1416593939,
0.3688480556,
0.4200085998,
0.3996311426,
0.56273067,
0.1502364427,
-0.5189533234,
-0.2945966423,
-0.4219938219,
-0.4214018881,
0.4748998284,
0.2184179723,
-0.1433762014,
-0.4046463966,
-0.052141238,
-0.2269247919,
0.2013651729,
-0.1811127365,
1.0005079508,
-0.1746187657,
-0.682531476,
0.5231915712,
0.0022579764,
0.7727054358,
-0.4662164152,
-0.1739965975,
-0.6633242369,
-0.0130840736,
-0.3135596216,
-0.8285748363,
0.1279137284,
0.1517059207,
-0.3113978505,
-0.3609663546,
0.9340794683,
-0.5077057481,
-0.3502405584,
-0.0279037841,
0.783443749,
0.1666946858,
-0.2450919002,
-0.5325793028,
0.1088473126,
-0.3288121819,
-0.6250311136,
0.6555853486,
0.745657742,
-0.1196436584,
0.3997728527,
0.5582379103,
0.2538496554,
0.0074027586,
0.2710486054,
1.1852211952,
-0.3705393374,
-0.3849112093,
-0.1020166352,
0.6317299604,
-0.2435567081,
-0.2507582307,
0.7210236788,
0.9271406531,
0.945910275,
0.1875711977,
0.6778916717,
-0.2341699451,
0.7416511178,
-0.2659812868,
0.7906841636,
-0.7568648458,
0.3478542566,
-0.0613850802,
-1.201261878,
-0.040501602,
0.410291791,
0.0273468606,
0.2355527282,
0.2856437564,
0.7969442606,
-0.271250546,
-0.3953920603,
0.1778982729,
-0.0801090077,
0.4288580716,
0.3233950436,
0.7881286144,
-0.354098022,
0.5380933881,
-0.1711573452,
-0.0599819794,
-0.2594622076,
-0.4808715582,
-0.7615882158,
-0.5112606883,
0.3026804924,
-0.2531247735,
0.0968587324,
0.6783300042,
0.5721419454,
-0.6607837677,
-0.0089514805,
0.1625585109,
0.1586895436,
0.0397869051,
-0.2579144239,
0.2763427198,
-0.5787139535,
-0.5892372727,
0.4240805805,
0.1254113764,
-0.2710443139,
-0.5437084436,
-0.1206926629,
-0.0612536594,
-0.0037508379,
0.7946975827,
0.1883268803,
-0.4340889156,
-0.1143681183,
0.1642334163,
-0.0653438717,
-0.1658514738,
0.9141331315,
-1.0190526247,
0.3922318816,
0.7045168877,
1.2196394205,
0.8037391901,
0.3170039058,
0.164744556,
-0.9369382262,
-0.056340903,
0.5446618199,
-0.0370761901,
0.4709339738,
-0.5159551501,
0.5429871082,
-0.0808471292,
-0.701969862,
-0.7870543003,
0.25757128,
-0.9691614509,
-0.2993436754,
1.1591924429,
0.2674248517,
0.0724204853,
-0.1357111782,
-0.2334083021,
0.1427415907,
-0.3741750419,
0.8488441706,
0.2519967258,
-0.3414570093,
-0.1839561164,
-0.7048873305,
0.500459671,
0.3247745335,
-0.9755082726,
0.1727841049,
0.7703747749,
0.0656707361,
0.2665769756,
0.6215869188,
-0.0910323784,
0.0974455997,
-0.0592356212,
-0.2126946598,
-0.2076013684,
-0.6653391719,
0.077527903,
0.6873109341,
0.3347820342,
0.2563789189
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12564v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12564v1 | Low-Resource Machine Translation through the Lens of Personalized Federated Learning | 2024-06-18T12:50:00 | 2024-06-18T12:50:00 | Viktor Moskvoretskii, Nazarii Tupitsa, Chris Biemann, Samuel Horváth, Eduard Gorbunov, Irina Nikishina | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | We present a new approach based on the Personalized Federated Learning
algorithm MeritFed that can be applied to Natural Language Tasks with
heterogeneous data. We evaluate it on the Low-Resource Machine Translation
task, using the dataset from the Large-Scale Multilingual Machine Translation
Shared Task (Small Track #2) and the subset of Sami languages from the
multilingual benchmark for Finno-Ugric languages. In addition to its
effectiveness, MeritFed is also highly interpretable, as it can be applied to
track the impact of each language used for training. Our analysis reveals that
target dataset size affects weight distribution across auxiliary languages,
that unrelated languages do not interfere with the training, and auxiliary
optimizer parameters have minimal impact. Our approach is easy to apply with a
few lines of code, and we provide scripts for reproducing the experiments at
https://github.com/VityaVitalich/MeritFed | [
-0.2012296617,
-0.2798902988,
0.3952648044,
0.3168329298,
-0.1800519973,
0.1111869365,
-0.5320150256,
-0.3077380955,
0.3920668364,
0.5473710299,
-0.8659731746,
-0.5258844495,
-0.7207325101,
0.5835573673,
0.0102951294,
1.0431113243,
-0.2712421417,
0.3704702854,
-0.3903918266,
-0.7624977231,
-0.4312639236,
-0.3274231553,
-0.2412547469,
-0.4398685098,
0.6869925261,
0.8923166394,
0.3726797104,
0.7215085626,
0.9921159148,
0.3356732428,
0.2669237554,
0.0934762657,
-0.7902992368,
0.2368373126,
-0.1797553152,
-0.6945099235,
-0.2203802615,
0.068090722,
0.8927279711,
0.9831818342,
-0.0172115508,
0.7279415131,
-0.0250178464,
0.6266585588,
-0.4915468097,
0.2755987942,
-0.5082749128,
0.1883496493,
-0.4672943354,
0.0193015803,
-0.4243114889,
-0.2114066035,
-0.1776364297,
-0.6348364353,
0.2813622057,
0.254224956,
0.3374632299,
0.6883096695,
-0.0654480085,
0.0906199887,
-0.5429093838,
1.1868128777,
-0.3625609279,
0.4391589165,
0.5387455225,
0.5287384987,
0.0400273725,
-0.7006456852,
-0.315536201,
0.0568895563,
-0.4721176028,
-0.1963308007,
-0.2426907271,
-0.1429703832,
0.2017254978,
0.5614880919,
-0.5142763853,
0.107077159,
-0.2211855501,
-0.1885805726,
0.6122125387,
0.3291429281,
0.0697389171,
-0.133267343,
-0.4017395377,
-0.1035299525,
-0.3162155449,
0.0757827461,
0.3433392346,
0.8472083211,
-0.4441702664,
0.4318762422,
-0.8908170462,
0.5548631549,
0.3361936808,
-0.3132890761,
0.7111230493,
-0.5736632943,
-0.3416382968,
0.0932561681,
0.846688211,
-0.1379268318,
-0.4599210918,
-0.4687655568,
-0.3733230233,
-0.4276000857,
0.0049883132,
-0.6794219613,
-0.0362038985,
-0.1731854528,
-0.6008852124,
-0.2429669648,
-0.2832930386,
-0.5624557734,
-0.2588904798,
-0.4821519256,
0.276563853,
-0.2320503443,
0.0705482215,
-0.271299541,
0.2422512174,
-0.08584892,
0.36656335,
-1.0568618774,
0.3330613971,
0.575394392,
0.9809025526,
-0.2383349389,
-0.3700922728,
-1.2974520922,
-0.1045097411,
0.1661181152,
0.5319628716,
-0.4917034805,
0.0689841211,
-0.1556807458,
0.268231988,
-0.1443483531,
-0.4023583531,
0.7705182433,
-0.392095089,
0.4770926237,
-0.6464645863,
-0.1976647824,
-0.311196208,
0.1769958436,
-0.6659161448,
0.7401735783,
0.5730239153,
-0.7160407901,
0.3811889291,
-0.6407417059,
-0.6804044247,
0.2817853987,
-0.1066939533,
-0.3427707255,
0.2028217018,
0.0740309954,
0.5834570527,
-0.630125165,
0.258058697,
-0.4481831789,
-0.2380657494,
-0.1238372922,
-0.4426503181,
0.8046271801,
0.4511579871,
-0.4951196015,
0.1070861444,
-0.6284494996,
0.040833544,
0.1761758029,
-0.5848695636,
-0.4507073462,
-0.3977114558,
0.3308655918,
0.2805194259,
0.4220612049,
-0.6387528777,
0.0649664924,
-0.4162054658,
-0.0340173468,
0.6318463683,
-0.3248240352,
0.8553066254,
-0.0546980835,
0.5883514881,
-0.2708892226,
0.0664939284,
0.2039657831,
-0.1897345036,
-0.6023119688,
-0.4203270376,
0.3687003851,
0.2515601814,
-0.9365289211,
0.1070607677,
-0.4272847474,
-0.1790760309,
-0.9295728803,
0.6265560389,
0.7083632946,
0.5720188022,
0.5757559538,
-0.4419701099,
-0.3611689508,
-0.9070648551,
-0.0843102187,
0.1739408821,
-0.0463042408,
0.2672904432,
0.2260059118,
-0.5038079619,
0.662901938,
-0.5134248137,
-0.5956024528,
-0.4406020641,
0.1260457486,
0.2298862785,
0.5452076793,
0.6535505056,
-0.7274695039,
-0.6009332538,
0.4582543373,
-0.698194325,
-0.247546196,
0.154703185,
-0.3368811607,
0.0344636254,
-0.0524806082,
-0.2155937999,
-0.2582459152,
0.846015811,
-0.376023531,
0.1685382128,
-0.2074839175,
0.3285967708,
-1.1580121517,
0.2223929465,
0.0245641395,
-0.4872578382,
-0.5270510316,
0.0465251356,
-0.1285111606,
-0.1091649011,
-0.4819874763,
0.5943461657,
-0.3291606009,
-0.3790057302,
-0.1722526401,
-0.1043950394,
-0.3260065019,
0.5261765718,
-0.1196857989,
0.5281385779,
0.0094855502,
-0.257335186,
0.3394224048,
0.3610384166,
-0.1845185757,
0.7954474092,
-0.1995439976,
-0.0084674191,
-0.009116862,
-0.0385895856,
-0.4413199723,
-0.6903431416,
0.5816908479,
-0.266741097,
0.2159861773,
0.0764422491,
-0.4108280838,
-0.1286491901,
0.0040980345,
0.2886606157,
0.2173887789,
-0.738232851,
0.3116347194,
0.4858110845,
-0.0086598787,
-0.4766650796,
-0.6903232336,
-0.1031254381,
-0.136939317,
-0.4687476158,
0.2523084283,
-0.0068737632,
-0.2269337773,
-0.041738756,
-0.0709685758,
-0.2900176346,
0.3930315971,
0.2668943703,
-0.1317626834,
-0.2998281121,
0.1952079237,
0.3308169246,
-0.1169642061,
-0.1772828698,
-0.5348494649,
0.5222680569,
-0.3393030763,
-0.282076925,
-0.6491901875,
0.2712880671,
0.3109709322,
-0.369928658,
0.871555686,
1.1252179146,
-0.3320784271,
-0.1790973097,
-0.3574198186,
-0.1136146486,
-0.427580595,
0.2589188814,
-0.3586863875,
-1.0201861858,
0.3069595397,
-0.0428349338,
0.1116503775,
0.50561589,
0.6724828482,
-0.1979294866,
0.6925465465,
1.0344625711,
-0.5152065754,
0.4897771776,
-0.2569963038,
-0.1569580138,
-0.5782016516,
-0.1433123201,
-0.5093271136,
-0.7711935639,
-0.5624091625,
-0.6893675923,
0.1023729965,
-0.1010256708,
-0.1435592771,
0.3665409088,
-0.243314445,
0.2401373386,
0.8619852662,
-0.1263603717,
0.5172794461,
0.3056896329,
-0.0009567591,
-0.1701521277,
-0.911888361,
-0.2202285826,
1.0261260271,
0.1880441755,
0.5989711285,
0.0401958898,
1.0935907364,
0.5362932682,
0.6722752452,
-0.5700690746,
0.2238124609,
-0.3380833566,
-0.4361110926,
-0.4066990912,
-0.947706461,
-0.5929973125,
0.4917201102,
-0.2664785087,
-0.3452148438,
0.2052115649,
0.3028012812,
-0.0668548197,
0.1233861819,
-0.8052576184,
1.0313559771,
-0.4734302461,
-0.3752877414,
-0.3619085252,
-0.6697896719,
0.5825274587,
-0.2267293036,
0.1307816058,
-0.155059278,
0.1763351262,
0.8069006205,
-0.3997370303,
0.7571726441,
-0.2366042435,
0.2479266375,
-0.1097198948,
-0.2593653798,
0.5630920529,
0.1600432247,
-0.1842398196,
0.3905580342,
-0.3233152926,
-0.7007826567,
-0.2753794193,
0.8351346254,
-0.72689569,
-0.2584864497,
-0.2650784552,
-0.6681531668,
-0.221390456,
0.4006134272,
0.3233047128,
0.1263375282,
-0.3052191734,
0.3572206199,
0.3889466822,
-0.0567338318,
0.3052985072,
0.7593862414,
0.3184414208,
-0.6285184622,
1.0925167799,
-0.0964749977,
0.273494035,
0.6569749117,
0.1967106014,
-0.0997546613,
-0.4709953666,
-0.6307050586,
0.2973585725,
-0.5331891179,
-0.3774507046,
-0.7679054737,
0.5668206811,
-0.3406593502,
-0.1591669619,
-0.6233090162,
-0.2877752483,
-0.2589315176,
0.0727786571,
0.2017048448,
0.3376710117,
0.0792143568,
0.4563592076,
-0.7969429493,
0.095733881,
0.0971070156,
0.3742710352,
-0.3770719469,
-0.3762088418,
-0.6494197845,
0.2013490796,
-0.0148575185,
-0.3984666765,
0.3561884463,
0.103567943,
0.7418725491,
0.4074375033,
0.3717937768,
0.3933746815,
-0.3988914788,
0.3112672567,
0.6153156757,
-0.7953557968,
0.2541907132,
-0.2288994938,
0.4936816692,
1.098826766,
0.3367453516,
-0.700914979,
-0.4564844966,
-0.3948236704,
-0.420481652,
1.1275359392,
0.2551234365,
-0.0006296459,
0.4162803292,
0.0558213405,
0.3841373622,
0.3863108456,
-0.5760375261,
-0.3640451431,
-0.0194459166,
-0.6208555102,
-0.4805676937,
0.0963143557,
-0.258653909,
-0.2086379379,
0.5662622452,
-0.5192652941,
0.1945473552,
-0.1523625404,
-0.464602977,
-0.4205730855,
0.2103044987,
0.591567874,
0.1797771752,
-0.184773013,
0.0125579042,
0.2352550775,
-0.4897832572,
0.2683926523,
0.5561851859,
-0.4192830026,
0.1914187223,
0.4643825293,
0.9918307662,
0.429066509,
-0.5670244694,
0.2541768253,
-0.2077332586,
-0.3281095326,
0.2117787898,
-0.1209568903,
-0.0626905635,
0.4065698683,
0.1463767886,
0.422390908,
-0.0277023502,
-0.1092824265,
0.0707620755,
0.2913810909,
-0.6357469559,
-0.7130089998,
0.79858917,
0.6739721894,
0.0288403612,
0.2867855132,
-0.4944408834,
-0.3812466562,
0.1891443282,
0.3198941946,
1.0558001995,
-0.217476204,
0.6174465418,
0.2435409427,
0.5290994048,
-0.281378746,
-0.1410055757,
-0.3037122488,
-0.4956683218,
-0.3917105496,
-0.9461584687,
-0.2818184495,
-0.0341856144,
-0.4724499285,
0.0936107337,
-0.3009882569,
0.0364582017,
-0.1726538241,
0.3917635977,
-1.0577640533,
0.0970698744,
0.0483390018,
0.40114519,
-1.0319492817,
0.8329629898,
0.8563223481,
-0.5763865113,
-0.6295125484,
0.0425690487,
0.0714609772,
-0.6015329361,
0.9691222906,
-0.0299714692,
-0.0014612742,
0.0944264457,
-0.0727246925,
-1.1791721582,
1.1465528011,
0.7771954536,
-0.4599455297,
0.2580271661,
0.2379616052,
0.4396183193,
-0.4984455705,
-0.2264157534,
0.440223366,
0.5561894178,
-0.2093657404,
-0.8659335971,
0.0702181235,
-0.0213620719,
-0.1818996966,
0.219650194,
-0.6810382009,
0.7027161121,
-0.1882555336,
-0.2752335668,
-0.2943503857,
0.8140243888,
-0.3213403225,
0.5686476827,
0.5306084156,
0.5483067036,
1.1076117754,
-0.0134109184,
1.1563267708,
-0.0415873043,
0.552302599,
1.2662773132,
-0.2626325488,
0.5542663932,
0.5407632589,
-0.1443103552,
-0.0266545173,
0.455992341,
0.1138528511,
0.8108041883,
-0.0946379453,
-0.3074605167,
-0.209989503,
-0.4487782121,
-0.2908788621,
0.5018004775,
-0.2622607648,
-0.549577713,
-0.3280463219,
0.4101365507,
-0.1112182736,
0.2375217825,
-0.3248021603,
0.619564414,
0.1684384048,
-0.390016675,
0.7458233833,
0.400605917,
0.7107607126,
-0.356649816,
0.3562163115,
-0.5714925528,
0.3862512708,
-0.100548856,
-0.1600266546,
0.2933252752,
0.2356810719,
-0.5518583655,
-0.7522007823,
0.6482121348,
-0.6302769184,
-0.6277063489,
0.1369548589,
0.6641287208,
-0.1642279029,
0.1254812628,
-0.5212188363,
-0.1087006554,
0.1969833374,
-0.1791771948,
0.6614667773,
0.2955673933,
-0.0567470565,
0.5702928305,
0.5391555429,
-0.039477855,
-0.1893669218,
-0.0543744266,
0.7962011695,
-0.3094893992,
-0.6112015843,
-0.373396486,
0.179758817,
-0.0319251008,
-0.3395242989,
0.8143506646,
0.5126600266,
1.1871027946,
-0.3351943791,
0.7506343722,
-0.1946668029,
0.4646683931,
-0.3649237156,
0.8135142922,
-0.6189261079,
0.0085885413,
-0.3178243637,
-0.913297236,
-0.1807458401,
0.2251086831,
-0.520155549,
-0.4972312748,
0.636772573,
0.3310983777,
-0.2345978767,
-0.1939142793,
0.3373358846,
-0.2854574621,
0.0410172306,
0.4742475748,
0.3187263906,
-0.3021092415,
0.5384486318,
-0.6510192752,
-0.1512340307,
-0.5042055845,
-0.380726397,
-0.7461510301,
-0.6057826281,
-0.2226961702,
0.1568775773,
-0.0528033115,
1.2932795286,
0.6015859246,
-0.861241281,
-0.1545494348,
0.02457943,
0.5178217888,
-0.4387495518,
-0.1457192451,
0.0064912792,
-0.6488329172,
-0.9280734658,
0.4003146887,
0.1566613764,
-0.301050514,
-0.1406710595,
-0.439627409,
-0.2129886895,
-0.6266900301,
0.6175954342,
0.2294358164,
-0.5251930356,
-0.1820891798,
-0.0201195087,
-0.3834506869,
-0.0318783633,
0.704674542,
-0.6108490229,
0.4322733879,
0.7686221004,
1.1869285107,
0.3122907579,
0.0888471529,
0.7258425355,
-1.0107198954,
0.3806287348,
0.1733368039,
0.192805171,
0.4726132154,
-0.5027481914,
0.5956593156,
0.7155218124,
-0.1337480992,
-0.9184922576,
-0.1052707955,
-0.6412786245,
0.1328291148,
0.89018327,
-0.2557224035,
-0.2442408949,
0.2033427805,
0.1686900109,
0.1712421626,
-0.5325585008,
0.5120106339,
0.4929787219,
0.1185673475,
0.0148666576,
-0.5876235366,
0.5657815933,
0.5174973011,
-0.9979596734,
0.0016298605,
0.6296600699,
0.1313107461,
0.1924013644,
0.7978162169,
0.2498368472,
0.18682006,
-0.2903420031,
0.1182701588,
-0.0466083772,
-0.0997440293,
-0.5672285557,
0.1304085106,
-0.1135146245,
-0.4169684052
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12549v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12549v1 | MultiSocial: Multilingual Benchmark of Machine-Generated Text Detection of Social-Media Texts | 2024-06-18T12:26:09 | 2024-06-18T12:26:09 | Dominik Macko, Jakub Kopal, Robert Moro, Ivan Srba | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recent LLMs are able to generate high-quality multilingual texts,
indistinguishable for humans from authentic human-written ones. Research in
machine-generated text detection is however mostly focused on the English
language and longer texts, such as news articles, scientific papers or student
essays. Social-media texts are usually much shorter and often feature informal
language, grammatical errors, or distinct linguistic items (e.g., emoticons,
hashtags). There is a gap in studying the ability of existing methods in
detection of such texts, reflected also in the lack of existing multilingual
benchmark datasets. To fill this gap we propose the first multilingual (22
languages) and multi-platform (5 social media platforms) dataset for
benchmarking machine-generated text detection in the social-media domain,
called MultiSocial. It contains 472,097 texts, of which about 58k are
human-written and approximately the same amount is generated by each of 7
multilingual LLMs. We use this benchmark to compare existing detection methods
in zero-shot as well as fine-tuned form. Our results indicate that the
fine-tuned detectors have no problem to be trained on social-media texts and
that the platform selection for training matters. | [
-0.3470226228,
-0.8614925742,
0.4495704472,
0.4773660004,
-0.4917431772,
0.53231287,
-0.3683356047,
-0.7121799588,
0.6404844522,
0.1709690839,
-0.4756835699,
-0.8079921007,
-0.7482534647,
0.5691012144,
-0.3091177344,
0.8255877495,
-0.0907912105,
-0.0022789782,
-0.0081636608,
-0.5051386952,
0.1622761488,
-0.5655785203,
-0.6859579086,
0.0461379439,
0.8457832336,
0.4919343889,
0.2888202667,
0.1798756272,
0.53529495,
0.3478226662,
0.0211037323,
0.6834149957,
-0.4578591287,
0.1181217134,
0.1166963652,
-0.0751716346,
-0.2576251924,
-0.0547228046,
0.8163256049,
0.2445565611,
0.240510121,
0.4333935082,
0.2092667967,
0.5465406775,
-0.7414634824,
0.0130087379,
-0.5510103703,
-0.0815062821,
-0.4061740339,
-0.3407369852,
-0.3184832036,
-0.3565206528,
-0.6522411108,
-0.3442620635,
0.2751802504,
-0.1355546564,
0.5666516423,
-0.1325430721,
-0.6024794579,
-0.3893807828,
-0.5602070093,
0.6535745859,
-0.5008115172,
0.4342077971,
0.4305263758,
0.3327379823,
0.0944936424,
-0.5010842085,
-0.5753235221,
-0.0158477798,
0.0599587373,
0.1541383117,
-0.0788791329,
-0.3879378438,
0.0168920923,
-0.2003867477,
-0.6971971989,
0.1776028275,
-0.2817972302,
-0.3717001677,
0.8372068405,
-0.0479232892,
0.1611385494,
-0.2127149552,
-0.1848896742,
-0.0180601273,
-0.6420112252,
-0.1359471828,
0.5676538348,
0.3115539253,
-0.3369347453,
0.4338896275,
-0.3253156841,
0.1173423305,
-0.3666234016,
-0.4123791456,
0.5237872005,
-0.6038173437,
0.1801456958,
0.1741390079,
1.2071522474,
0.547478497,
0.5952140689,
-0.0125350505,
-0.1609637886,
0.2305257022,
-0.1273537278,
-0.7797702551,
0.0571740828,
0.0143566728,
-0.6520380378,
-0.6246569157,
0.0452231728,
-0.5749437213,
-0.4945547581,
0.0318834819,
0.0289909132,
-0.2808185518,
-0.4451642931,
-0.040151,
-0.0070147295,
0.0269029792,
0.1281821132,
-0.4692090452,
0.140962705,
0.4979371727,
0.9994094968,
0.0532475747,
-0.6379470229,
-0.6239487529,
0.1296511441,
-0.3036422133,
1.1499773264,
-0.4097250998,
-0.2186604291,
0.2349101752,
0.237841472,
0.1775241345,
-0.4297266901,
0.6340208054,
-0.284175843,
-0.1466255486,
-0.4387960434,
-0.3421465158,
0.2660078704,
0.2473748475,
-0.4944698215,
1.3199133873,
-0.2819250226,
-0.8457878232,
0.6196963787,
-0.4215587378,
-0.7284695506,
0.150696829,
-0.1450516433,
-0.5247697234,
-0.0563877746,
0.1773192883,
0.9060300589,
-0.205932796,
0.2911701798,
-0.9527679682,
-0.5559208989,
0.5159323215,
-0.551620245,
0.5862593055,
0.2257092893,
-0.1569185257,
-0.0187008064,
-0.9303324223,
-0.0945118293,
0.3122145832,
-0.3237217665,
-0.5205227733,
0.0401956588,
0.4896267951,
0.3718770444,
0.3773031235,
-0.9473208785,
-0.3366672695,
0.1684265435,
0.6183495522,
0.7219073772,
-0.0208768137,
0.1659236103,
-0.2367516309,
0.3367967308,
0.0309798494,
0.0829409882,
-0.340461731,
-0.4780133665,
-0.3811020255,
-0.2867206037,
0.0914867967,
0.4553197026,
-0.9553875923,
0.279320538,
-0.1152020991,
-0.5785660148,
-0.6441906691,
0.3652054369,
0.406275034,
-0.0813661665,
0.1379265785,
0.0147671737,
-0.5389218926,
-0.7673946619,
-0.6358423233,
-0.1334023774,
0.2050679326,
0.2949400246,
0.596511364,
-0.2528473139,
0.4013454318,
-0.3121456802,
-0.2441758364,
-0.1931313127,
0.2161259055,
-0.121296145,
0.0717108548,
0.6520368457,
-0.8182216883,
-1.0497232676,
-0.0701974779,
-1.0332571268,
-0.3495482206,
0.0418609977,
0.0706620663,
0.235325098,
0.8583986759,
-0.4054142833,
0.1845735312,
0.6874191761,
-0.1355656981,
0.4885044098,
-0.321927011,
0.3093284965,
-1.4054006338,
-0.1203926429,
0.4540303946,
-0.4490617812,
-0.527215302,
-0.1135871485,
0.2812542617,
-0.129772082,
-0.6396608353,
0.6950284243,
-0.5270813704,
-0.1885981858,
-0.2501677275,
0.5019274354,
0.0411974639,
0.2067055106,
-0.1928500086,
0.7853844762,
0.3025853634,
-0.5033129454,
0.2550018132,
-0.1541267484,
-0.2745275497,
0.9934422374,
-0.7641470432,
0.2115563005,
-0.2301204652,
0.188848123,
-1.2648231983,
-0.1936414987,
0.1618622094,
-0.6921394467,
-0.0542179346,
0.1124445796,
-1.0312068462,
-0.3197034895,
-0.6740002632,
0.2485556453,
0.000289095,
-0.4062035978,
0.2203441411,
0.6232784986,
-0.2473426163,
-0.5054997802,
-0.5990625024,
0.4216797948,
-0.18539913,
-0.6338748336,
0.336032778,
-0.0314194001,
-0.0592916198,
-0.0107902298,
0.269682616,
-0.1348777711,
0.1377889961,
0.0280607734,
0.0578706972,
-0.1670418829,
0.1399320513,
0.2871049643,
-0.1896799058,
-0.1160439849,
0.1503169984,
0.6142309904,
-0.11097157,
-0.4061918259,
-0.3871832788,
0.5000767112,
0.6322463155,
-0.3202100396,
0.727453351,
1.1500133276,
-0.4760400653,
0.0733791813,
-0.6093975306,
-0.1086070016,
-0.5282194614,
0.1645055711,
-0.3035750091,
-1.0642952919,
0.5239661932,
0.014875385,
-0.1497443616,
0.2880435586,
0.4984490573,
-0.1837104112,
1.1010746956,
0.5092838407,
-0.1296447068,
0.4002523422,
0.2986961305,
0.1772766709,
-0.4030091465,
0.0125818281,
-0.7238761783,
-0.25881657,
-0.9779546857,
-0.3058613539,
0.2320891917,
-0.1880639493,
-0.1749619246,
0.5152127147,
-0.4991385043,
0.6166805625,
0.5685867667,
0.2445642501,
0.3737099171,
0.0024689727,
-0.0480394289,
-0.086298354,
-0.4663254619,
-0.8316649199,
1.1077262163,
0.1541780084,
0.5053724647,
0.0902096033,
1.0297154188,
0.4616259634,
0.4027233124,
-0.3823083639,
0.6233104467,
-0.4954029024,
-0.5679792762,
-0.0831528604,
-0.4061924815,
-0.991366744,
0.2171752453,
-0.4310701191,
-0.6059767604,
0.0465817153,
-0.1221126765,
-0.1587241143,
0.2149967849,
-0.6599431038,
0.8522631526,
-0.3255709112,
-0.4240059257,
-0.1828713119,
-0.6361922026,
0.1274941415,
-0.3285428286,
0.5784655213,
-0.5274181962,
-0.0759017617,
0.6086609364,
-0.0389011241,
1.1429105997,
-0.2099927962,
0.0227274727,
0.3499309421,
-0.1280431896,
0.5062690377,
0.1430089325,
0.1325845867,
0.2798113525,
0.1307882816,
-0.5135068297,
0.0428270698,
0.7095846534,
-0.7101984024,
0.2497384101,
-0.2680367231,
-0.1413281262,
-0.0093249884,
0.4609081447,
0.3721550405,
0.3742294312,
-0.6682107449,
0.3733282685,
0.4428029358,
-0.4600784183,
0.5709018111,
0.8360847235,
-0.1262347251,
-0.6143068075,
1.0539003611,
0.0505567119,
-0.1058304086,
0.4014908671,
0.0773257539,
-0.3787889779,
-0.22450459,
-0.5225619674,
0.372053355,
-0.6487725377,
-0.2053376138,
-0.9044592977,
0.0084644845,
-0.5514529943,
-0.2594898939,
-0.4506686628,
-0.0394212604,
-0.2795874774,
0.1018665135,
0.2765776813,
0.632981956,
-0.3000303805,
0.3320342004,
-0.9849035144,
0.580031991,
-0.13686499,
0.3150540888,
-0.2748104036,
-0.0783670321,
-0.2900364101,
0.1362747997,
-0.116892606,
-0.8748181462,
0.2129735798,
0.3033410609,
0.477286011,
0.5068184733,
0.0010964992,
0.4029481113,
-0.5210623741,
0.3399615586,
0.2645446658,
-0.7408159971,
0.3922280669,
-0.5515038371,
0.2177780122,
0.6946466565,
0.4420313835,
-0.9480435252,
-0.4493448138,
-0.4427976906,
-0.5136076212,
0.3960786164,
0.1979179084,
0.3743635416,
-0.2610398531,
0.2820801735,
0.059605673,
0.350269556,
-0.8963281512,
-0.0864668861,
-0.0462505035,
-0.2741622329,
-0.3846761584,
-0.3421828747,
0.1445847005,
0.0256092232,
0.393656224,
-0.273893714,
0.2929478288,
-0.0808264911,
-0.1040594578,
-0.1463843584,
0.1302489638,
0.6558516622,
0.3949063718,
-0.0240226053,
0.3907518089,
0.0899315178,
-0.5361360908,
0.3170034587,
0.1300048381,
-0.1572552174,
0.2735690176,
0.4252048731,
0.4805321395,
0.3878577352,
-0.5962994099,
0.5429666042,
-0.1757797599,
-0.3605908453,
-0.2781953216,
-0.2246344537,
0.3694963455,
0.3231855929,
0.2983540893,
-0.1056640446,
0.0863750651,
-0.6005820036,
0.2554788589,
0.4700392187,
-0.3539409637,
-0.4239958823,
0.5621122122,
0.3302754164,
-0.4932003021,
0.0840604827,
-0.5563024879,
-0.5098939538,
0.6577369571,
0.4672578275,
0.9798327684,
-0.1250597537,
0.7057945132,
0.1637034416,
0.5370311737,
-0.0713160485,
0.5029512048,
0.0628220737,
-1.1709030867,
-0.3434779048,
-0.5427569151,
-0.4305856526,
0.089014411,
-0.4868542254,
0.5062775016,
-0.3949213624,
-0.229801178,
0.5039266348,
0.0202355459,
-0.5726976991,
-0.0456744693,
0.2354574949,
0.628647089,
-1.11667943,
0.744284749,
0.9379056692,
-0.1080467254,
-0.2393269837,
-0.1358044147,
0.2892260253,
-0.8497418761,
0.3091406226,
0.5454514623,
-0.4266792536,
-0.0444371216,
-0.6331774592,
-0.4450586736,
0.853314817,
0.3048382103,
-0.3916478753,
0.373465687,
0.4618836641,
0.7392459512,
-0.328452915,
0.0807126164,
0.0941790268,
0.416567713,
-0.1653529853,
-0.6851401329,
-0.0445092991,
-0.4567308128,
-0.1115685552,
0.3706502914,
-1.0517585278,
0.7507375479,
0.1147325709,
-0.245328784,
-0.19723396,
0.300211668,
0.4287892282,
0.9049488306,
0.3325650394,
0.2469360828,
0.6735270023,
0.0902322233,
0.6823453307,
-0.5723658204,
0.362749815,
0.8275516033,
-0.7248436809,
0.8614733219,
0.1807315499,
-0.1915975064,
0.3220769167,
0.8626012206,
0.051360026,
0.3557229936,
-0.1948677152,
-0.4833718538,
-0.2668800652,
-0.2683699727,
-0.2374213189,
0.5981214046,
0.2751924992,
-0.3122258782,
-0.222175613,
-0.0991943032,
0.1069052294,
0.2239099443,
-0.0675524175,
0.740427494,
0.1434680372,
-0.2687005103,
0.360901624,
0.3241150379,
0.8995858431,
-0.4191450179,
0.2682573795,
-0.1541822255,
0.3436220586,
-0.1002008021,
-0.7751906514,
0.2889899611,
0.115395233,
0.1429330558,
-0.2753663957,
1.4047099352,
-0.3484215736,
-0.7088010311,
0.6006522775,
0.8095971942,
0.3731402457,
-0.3541230559,
-1.0006597042,
0.0700053498,
-0.242833674,
-0.0038392581,
0.3200258911,
0.9395605922,
0.0167795159,
0.4657946527,
0.7727488875,
-0.1120633483,
-0.0551556647,
0.3040671647,
0.787768662,
-0.5776303411,
-0.4046140909,
-1.126963377,
0.1159561276,
-0.4365434647,
-0.4809319973,
0.9406183362,
0.6703366041,
0.9143531919,
0.1929678023,
0.8851194382,
0.0851482674,
0.6011583209,
-0.2397641838,
0.7464548349,
-0.7667489648,
-0.1041418463,
-0.6537227631,
-0.980342865,
-0.2148194462,
0.5159650445,
0.0113947289,
0.0285189636,
0.5891441107,
0.7542180419,
-0.1056005433,
0.00900923,
0.3778430521,
-0.2346608043,
0.1154362187,
0.3014691174,
0.8411669731,
-0.5541495085,
0.609282434,
-0.235679388,
-0.2258507311,
-0.3657894433,
-0.9674701691,
-1.2421910763,
-0.4733166397,
-0.1937886178,
-0.4092929661,
0.0933198705,
0.7448437214,
0.453853786,
-0.6813120842,
-0.2809675634,
0.1321700513,
0.074734956,
-0.0535292774,
-0.1322404146,
0.035338182,
-0.1004122868,
-0.5542186499,
0.2504825294,
0.5070666671,
0.1055281386,
-0.3848453164,
-0.0979767144,
-0.4346004128,
0.0277144033,
0.9369592071,
0.0458840616,
-0.1356563866,
-0.2578186095,
0.4851008058,
-0.3241529167,
0.0531211384,
0.7350540757,
-0.1384653151,
0.1998628527,
0.4784285426,
0.4596520662,
0.5717110634,
-0.2743903399,
0.0973410681,
-0.9801009297,
0.3086747229,
-0.0565696806,
0.3829252422,
0.5472334027,
-0.3149163425,
0.5382282734,
0.56460464,
-0.6184557676,
-0.8871545196,
0.0531951338,
-0.6733309627,
-0.4628304541,
1.3738723993,
0.0053322772,
-0.0135681042,
-0.2915737927,
-0.13078852,
0.3750036955,
-0.5370800495,
0.8106538057,
0.8238504529,
0.3307028711,
-0.3111668825,
-0.5088561773,
0.1521566659,
0.0863631293,
-0.9638622999,
0.0000143818,
0.3333405852,
0.184890002,
0.1271517575,
1.1331727505,
0.0496520661,
0.1835768372,
0.0426039137,
0.0769002438,
0.2018145919,
-0.3837032616,
0.0617401935,
0.0609617233,
-0.0833917409,
-0.0530076176
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12548v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12548v1 | P-Tailor: Customizing Personality Traits for Language Models via Mixture of Specialized LoRA Experts | 2024-06-18T12:25:13 | 2024-06-18T12:25:13 | Yuhao Dan, Jie Zhou, Qin Chen, Junfeng Tian, Liang He | cs.CL | cs.CL | Personalized large language models (LLMs) have attracted great attention in
many applications, such as intelligent education and emotional support. Most
work focuses on controlling the character settings based on the profile (e.g.,
age, skill, experience, and so on). Conversely, the psychological theory-based
personality traits with implicit expression and behavior are not well modeled,
limiting their potential application in more specialized fields such as the
psychological counseling agents. In this paper, we propose a mixture of experts
(MoE)-based personalized LLMs, named P-tailor, to model the Big Five
Personality Traits. Particularly, we learn specialized LoRA experts to
represent various traits, such as openness, conscientiousness, extraversion,
agreeableness and neuroticism. Then, we integrate P-Tailor with a personality
specialization loss, promoting experts to specialize in distinct personality
traits, thereby enhancing the efficiency of model parameter utilization. Due to
the lack of datasets, we also curate a high-quality personality crafting
dataset (PCD) to learn and develop the ability to exhibit different personality
traits across various topics. We conduct extensive experiments to verify the
great performance and effectiveness of P-Tailor in manipulation of the
fine-grained personality traits of LLMs. | [
-0.7019733191,
-0.7683445215,
0.5743024349,
0.5380083919,
-0.072156176,
0.0878080502,
-0.4928387702,
-0.1765632033,
0.6425372958,
0.6417355537,
-0.6278699636,
-0.4582355022,
-0.4552003741,
0.123524107,
-0.0745494366,
0.6986299753,
0.1879927218,
0.0454739071,
0.1007108018,
0.0218611974,
-0.6024745703,
-0.6208018661,
-0.4473891258,
-0.4782222509,
0.5987118483,
0.6372529864,
0.4396310747,
0.5307407379,
0.2109329104,
0.3105125725,
-0.2184886783,
0.2559060156,
-0.5134751201,
0.0321205296,
-0.5423300862,
-0.3708477914,
-1.0213762522,
0.0664131716,
0.2987672389,
0.6695210338,
-0.2996290624,
0.1471711695,
0.0662767589,
0.5304926038,
-0.6353171468,
-0.0304766428,
-0.7138011456,
0.0490383133,
-0.1928705126,
0.1081420481,
-0.3386082053,
-0.3982758224,
0.2128990889,
-0.407848835,
0.1477274448,
0.0485493839,
0.3947224021,
0.1715258062,
-0.5656250715,
-0.0103099765,
-0.8601329923,
0.90869385,
-0.8975844383,
0.0210481472,
0.64502424,
0.3598848879,
-0.1635144204,
-0.2173146605,
-0.5206122994,
0.0966482982,
0.0577374659,
0.0687551126,
0.2276896685,
-0.216724202,
-0.0797782838,
0.5797960162,
-0.3267299831,
0.4773787558,
0.0031558562,
-0.0749210268,
1.0393044949,
0.3579174876,
0.0225509405,
0.3492268622,
0.0206378903,
0.1707178801,
-0.5308932066,
-0.0052171256,
0.64117378,
-0.0108788926,
0.0108536351,
0.4996814728,
-0.3140151501,
0.4599496722,
0.5191291571,
-0.6485420465,
0.1340843439,
0.0721764341,
-0.0857943445,
-0.1026827097,
0.7498984337,
0.1491086334,
0.6470224261,
-0.0831488594,
-0.0112882573,
-0.3408099711,
0.084475942,
-0.6820091009,
-0.4318360984,
0.2703100145,
-0.5429788232,
-0.361263901,
-0.1673455387,
-0.8581848145,
-0.611366868,
-0.2986335456,
-0.0574749224,
-0.6828302741,
-0.3850618899,
0.1893981695,
0.0758281425,
0.2630428672,
0.1972493529,
-1.040492177,
0.1774054617,
0.4368932843,
0.4168750644,
-0.2660013735,
-0.4500409067,
-0.371779561,
0.2699838579,
-0.0545467474,
0.8688017726,
-0.9853329659,
-0.5927453041,
-0.120423086,
-0.2659229338,
0.0692908317,
-0.3641412556,
0.6875352263,
-0.3179959655,
0.3123532236,
-0.3976908028,
-0.6222258806,
-0.0445334129,
0.1222530603,
-0.2382554114,
0.6629987359,
0.2905736268,
-0.548276186,
0.3446837962,
-0.5087196231,
-0.4480453134,
0.0335749127,
-0.0479430184,
-0.4784629047,
0.2571352124,
0.5171840191,
0.7025486231,
-0.1062769443,
0.102947779,
-0.8192133307,
-0.373894304,
0.6381961107,
0.1351798475,
0.3571531475,
-0.0388158001,
-0.0712337121,
0.2362913787,
-0.8974858522,
0.1683107018,
0.0768908337,
-0.6085138917,
-0.297849685,
0.1158730537,
0.2046800256,
0.1572357863,
0.6251852512,
-0.4683983326,
0.4391880035,
-0.3332744241,
0.3372162879,
1.1911748648,
-0.0460510887,
0.4679647386,
-0.4008320272,
0.5346719623,
-0.0139057022,
0.0303118508,
0.1966742575,
-0.5242494345,
-0.6814389229,
-0.8076441884,
-0.0205834452,
0.4968245327,
-0.2661979198,
1.3352767229,
0.0779929683,
-0.8051268458,
-0.4377577603,
0.4205158949,
0.4122433066,
0.2916133404,
0.1997027993,
-0.3441999853,
-0.5877104402,
-1.0264977217,
-0.6919497848,
0.1620990932,
-0.2109799683,
0.3588918746,
0.3160406351,
-0.338740021,
1.2774027586,
-0.824405551,
-0.2863367796,
-0.5259609818,
-0.2899062037,
0.3321501613,
0.3526681364,
0.6783803701,
-0.533513248,
-0.7134508491,
-0.0324837714,
-0.2969068885,
-0.4705460668,
0.3205876648,
-0.1376024783,
-0.0621246435,
0.0656614527,
-0.2502893209,
0.1033771411,
0.467220068,
-0.6687827706,
0.8183799386,
-0.2995625138,
-0.4079820514,
-1.3448365927,
0.2059593797,
0.2219540477,
-0.1197907627,
-0.4314686656,
0.0291612111,
-0.2024563551,
-0.0634839013,
-0.0798901767,
0.7590702176,
-0.1987179965,
-0.0358216874,
-0.2493880391,
-0.1004640013,
-0.0399604179,
0.7529098988,
0.1275903136,
0.5168936849,
0.5279438496,
-0.5564268231,
0.474948287,
0.5054125786,
-0.1785126328,
1.0429632664,
-0.6665747166,
0.594179213,
0.014280403,
0.3155021667,
-0.4869306982,
-0.568582058,
0.0413460881,
-0.1080706641,
-0.0599561445,
-0.237754792,
-0.3557856083,
0.0475645997,
-0.3062469363,
-0.2062810808,
0.783002317,
-0.2568201721,
0.7894893885,
0.3283364475,
-0.5612868071,
-0.2204007357,
-0.4723754525,
-0.0113611799,
-0.5706428289,
-0.5390410423,
0.5489978194,
-0.5650513768,
-0.1689072847,
-0.3422732949,
0.2077961564,
-0.2394437045,
0.015973771,
0.105942674,
0.0149246035,
-0.2641303539,
-0.2463169992,
0.1649950296,
-0.1400894672,
-0.2527223825,
-0.127252236,
0.7431657314,
-0.2479182631,
-0.3009726405,
-0.4509863257,
0.5571808815,
0.7483847737,
-0.6928833723,
0.9264095426,
0.9140433669,
-0.0150763383,
-0.2777277231,
-0.8588288426,
-0.1556337029,
-0.5195475221,
0.4733498394,
-0.5641605258,
-0.9044597745,
0.7779909372,
0.0629433244,
0.0277511571,
-0.0326199122,
0.8714014292,
-0.0534803458,
1.1048951149,
0.8176848292,
-0.2957598269,
0.7060718536,
-0.0377405211,
0.3313206434,
-1.1436415911,
-0.1778004467,
-0.2791079283,
-0.708252728,
-0.5040606856,
-0.0207449682,
0.441890955,
-0.1304678917,
-0.5981287956,
0.0047088368,
-0.4384920001,
0.5409728289,
0.6157487035,
0.3359698355,
0.2825283706,
0.027857013,
0.1320322752,
-0.2717580497,
-0.265437305,
-0.6825541258,
1.1195373535,
0.4619623125,
0.9914534092,
0.2994919717,
0.6006044149,
-0.0054233107,
0.0958952978,
-0.8179087639,
0.7028939724,
-0.5381476283,
-0.3180487156,
-0.1582492888,
-0.2668123841,
-0.4141284525,
0.154870972,
-0.2270026058,
-1.0662772655,
0.4349486828,
0.3302766085,
-0.2103034109,
0.1489818096,
-0.7942941189,
0.5868321657,
-0.1903271079,
-0.1845556051,
-0.2514833212,
-0.2616051435,
0.3756390214,
-0.3385074437,
-0.1413647979,
-0.151336208,
-0.2178698778,
0.4490849078,
-0.3939186633,
0.9453129172,
-0.0156855397,
-0.1482507586,
-0.3499248922,
0.2713654041,
0.6888900399,
-0.0035559833,
-0.3085972071,
-0.2529139817,
-0.0187409967,
-0.585888505,
-0.6556524038,
0.820027709,
-1.01489079,
-0.4797927141,
0.0639670715,
-0.4330162108,
-0.6704309583,
0.1788906008,
0.2745528221,
0.1016244888,
-0.2582207322,
0.1685625911,
0.7402780056,
-0.3417171538,
0.1827020645,
0.8955308795,
-0.1711423546,
-0.4817010462,
1.0482604504,
-0.1362920105,
-0.0744802803,
0.1516892463,
0.5899759531,
0.0783963054,
-0.6114972234,
0.1252512336,
0.314722389,
-0.5340919495,
0.2241212279,
-0.4725066125,
0.0995675847,
-0.5275366902,
-0.4582907259,
-0.378649205,
-0.0099592255,
-0.2783191204,
0.3192009032,
0.4076182544,
0.5238608122,
0.5507109165,
0.6158028245,
-0.5076360703,
0.1486094147,
0.3935872316,
0.5445600152,
-0.1807894111,
-0.585244,
-0.0743986517,
-0.1808696687,
-0.4524389505,
-0.8039188385,
0.6224300861,
0.4674173892,
0.5138303638,
0.8026123047,
-0.223056674,
0.4824679196,
-0.1741030067,
0.5552104115,
-0.1967880875,
-0.9641265273,
0.5124161839,
-0.5189292431,
0.1647208482,
0.275544554,
0.1642038524,
-0.4758398533,
-0.3458187282,
-0.5000907183,
-0.6050465703,
0.557362318,
0.0508047603,
0.1532531232,
0.3913848698,
0.533000648,
0.2937828898,
0.2727044225,
-0.5349192023,
-0.0341455527,
-0.1510601044,
-0.3796212375,
-0.0408333391,
-0.3606834114,
0.0579930916,
-0.1925295889,
0.7739645243,
-0.4959400594,
0.034662772,
-0.02100976,
0.1215363368,
0.2377053797,
0.4881005585,
0.4952632189,
0.6305215955,
-0.2692317069,
-0.2970022559,
0.1272931099,
-0.4057900906,
-0.0159429908,
-0.1133854762,
0.1197308078,
-0.3475241661,
0.4027347267,
0.6533358097,
0.0505667366,
-0.6512683034,
0.2612353265,
-0.0109860953,
0.1037393138,
-0.5297302604,
0.464312911,
0.2311152816,
0.2792147696,
0.1396267414,
-0.084397018,
-0.1485066861,
-0.6329112649,
-0.2994271517,
0.2549464107,
-0.0777395889,
-0.5040526986,
0.2475145608,
0.5037380457,
-0.5633481741,
0.4962570667,
-0.0383826047,
-0.3450708091,
0.3954748809,
0.5005530119,
0.8202991486,
-0.5451982617,
0.0139680188,
-0.1292525083,
-0.1647033691,
0.046015732,
0.3613241911,
0.1704262197,
-0.9879924655,
-0.4974739254,
-0.7291143537,
-0.4740522504,
0.2935009301,
-0.5559870005,
0.3525314033,
-0.7683188319,
-0.1233505607,
-0.2101007253,
-0.0434762612,
-0.6557103992,
0.0847737268,
-0.0717668161,
0.7951783538,
-0.7072075605,
0.8195981383,
1.2485516071,
-0.2303348631,
-0.6722144485,
0.0685992986,
-0.0574198402,
-0.8687902093,
0.5618207455,
-0.3030948937,
0.2843431532,
0.1415680349,
-0.3448604941,
-0.6313162446,
0.9694211483,
0.7537084222,
-0.4925431013,
-0.3921233714,
-0.0252739768,
0.5928621292,
-0.5321996808,
0.2154281437,
0.7524546981,
0.5125465393,
0.0257321429,
-0.9865499735,
-0.2696302533,
-0.3479216695,
0.1342739463,
-0.083959192,
-0.929754436,
0.7947105765,
0.0725494921,
0.595511198,
0.1828719079,
0.4111039937,
0.4013776481,
-0.0774956197,
0.4304479659,
0.4700322747,
0.7210000157,
0.2591658235,
0.7238547206,
-0.4822644889,
0.2146431655,
1.1453771591,
-0.434440434,
0.7137352228,
0.3752823174,
-0.220488593,
0.6747177839,
0.4838659763,
-0.0969280377,
0.3818924427,
0.0014120601,
-0.2703742981,
-0.4515704215,
-0.0082818363,
-0.1039786637,
0.8146144748,
0.4116689265,
-0.4731110632,
0.2310518175,
-0.0204244796,
0.0815308541,
0.2145064771,
-0.2227775156,
0.7152336836,
0.1288778633,
-0.5818206668,
0.1204851791,
0.4299621582,
0.9035458565,
-0.7331139445,
0.2570151687,
-0.5489862561,
0.5154159665,
-0.4316351414,
-0.7768841982,
0.1906711012,
-0.0550081469,
-0.306712836,
-0.5144791007,
0.7720959187,
-0.301608175,
-0.5518888235,
-0.1681967825,
0.5328717232,
-0.0905580521,
-0.45390293,
-0.396943748,
-0.2205710709,
-0.2090456188,
-0.3200441301,
0.5945313573,
0.3214786649,
-0.0253056474,
0.9269273281,
0.5546790361,
0.355766505,
-0.2669504881,
-0.0246390328,
0.8098118305,
-0.7081923485,
-0.8209812045,
-0.9369406104,
0.4988646209,
-0.076052554,
-0.6894909143,
0.6659738421,
0.2984971404,
0.4789766073,
-0.3785834014,
0.8888493776,
-0.0558438078,
0.5649203062,
-0.4458088875,
0.7210932374,
-0.2011957318,
0.2137559205,
-0.4313808382,
-1.0803556442,
0.1509849876,
0.6340326667,
-0.5301753283,
0.3859407604,
0.3674233258,
0.7221344113,
-0.2154461443,
-0.2478457242,
0.3996076286,
0.4596257508,
0.5720275044,
0.7316262126,
0.5485130548,
0.3450352848,
0.1467105746,
-0.2927422225,
-0.3106489182,
-0.5561825633,
-0.7494285703,
-1.2095687389,
-0.5107013583,
-0.3004056811,
-0.0480928384,
-0.2628884315,
0.9494073391,
0.8713644147,
-0.4596663713,
-0.0828144997,
0.1270862371,
0.0716878846,
-0.1132103875,
-0.2935901582,
0.22385782,
0.0696050972,
-0.7002480626,
0.3801311553,
0.2478676289,
-0.1586686075,
-0.758800149,
0.0262797028,
0.3468654454,
0.1156778112,
0.5964054465,
0.1176553518,
-0.7408676744,
-0.2898725271,
0.0616491325,
0.1824912578,
-0.1054679826,
0.9024531245,
-0.6418767571,
0.2130310386,
0.4405361414,
0.3560549021,
0.1035420373,
-0.1191456318,
0.9401519895,
-0.7852612734,
0.1668441594,
0.3185350299,
0.5967363715,
0.2688120008,
-0.5105721354,
0.1520524472,
0.2201498747,
-0.5449790955,
-0.5721272826,
0.5469898582,
-0.9824371934,
0.0451938324,
1.0890010595,
-0.3204115033,
0.0326498225,
-0.1119412035,
-0.6026621461,
-0.1055390239,
-0.4755476117,
1.0484224558,
0.8040499091,
-0.4097534716,
-0.2121779025,
-0.0645752102,
0.1458378732,
0.4938778877,
-0.8315851092,
-0.0826038197,
0.2547555864,
0.6197066307,
-0.1185348108,
0.5160521865,
0.1495874673,
-0.0702537075,
-0.5446673632,
0.1271722168,
-0.2600817084,
0.2098393738,
-0.1231129691,
0.1396819353,
0.3165709674,
0.2884675562
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12546v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12546v1 | Liar, Liar, Logical Mire: A Benchmark for Suppositional Reasoning in Large Language Models | 2024-06-18T12:24:22 | 2024-06-18T12:24:22 | Philipp Mondorf, Barbara Plank | cs.CL | cs.CL | Knights and knaves problems represent a classic genre of logical puzzles
where characters either tell the truth or lie. The objective is to logically
deduce each character's identity based on their statements. The challenge
arises from the truth-telling or lying behavior, which influences the logical
implications of each statement. Solving these puzzles requires not only direct
deductions from individual statements, but the ability to assess the
truthfulness of statements by reasoning through various hypothetical scenarios.
As such, knights and knaves puzzles serve as compelling examples of
suppositional reasoning. In this paper, we introduce $\textit{TruthQuest}$, a
benchmark for suppositional reasoning based on the principles of knights and
knaves puzzles. Our benchmark presents problems of varying complexity,
considering both the number of characters and the types of logical statements
involved. Evaluations on $\textit{TruthQuest}$ show that large language models
like Llama 3 and Mixtral-8x7B exhibit significant difficulties solving these
tasks. A detailed error analysis of the models' output reveals that
lower-performing models exhibit a diverse range of reasoning errors, frequently
failing to grasp the concept of truth and lies. In comparison, more proficient
models primarily struggle with accurately inferring the logical implications of
potentially false statements. | [
-0.0234153494,
-0.5540909171,
1.0764807463,
0.0341414921,
0.0259569064,
0.1277110279,
0.2058117986,
-0.333930254,
0.0458658449,
0.7588744164,
-0.5779988766,
-0.2579062581,
-0.5020827055,
0.2423524559,
-0.0869411007,
0.6092440486,
-0.0712846294,
0.2226329893,
-0.413213104,
-0.2304551452,
-0.6539108753,
-0.6177158952,
0.0319765955,
-0.1870332509,
0.4676547945,
0.5424086452,
0.8975796103,
0.7412475348,
0.8270190954,
0.419873476,
0.0275989342,
0.021718489,
-0.3026535213,
0.7489913106,
-0.5207084417,
-0.9078298211,
0.2222843915,
0.0990979224,
0.4485273361,
0.9253261685,
-0.1954523176,
0.3382720053,
-0.5589273572,
0.6763055921,
-0.752605617,
0.1719047427,
-0.6616476774,
-0.0361558273,
-0.4153386652,
0.1990537047,
-0.4036591053,
-0.7483691573,
0.1520635337,
-0.6831851602,
-0.197292909,
0.1081842631,
0.8005232215,
0.2857536972,
-0.3958272636,
-0.608705461,
-0.4454464614,
0.9791865945,
-0.9325285554,
0.5674802065,
0.3110422492,
0.6895375848,
-0.3659021556,
-0.4967845082,
-0.741089642,
-0.3792409003,
0.0823017731,
0.0435623005,
-0.0306432229,
-0.3067691028,
0.6438022256,
-0.0209676214,
-0.6493564844,
-0.227065742,
-0.093786329,
-0.1100323945,
0.5017163157,
0.2126536965,
-0.0719029605,
-0.3244119287,
-0.2928865254,
-0.3671440184,
-0.5242131948,
0.1785143167,
0.4866952002,
0.1771775633,
0.257137686,
0.5664869547,
-0.0243999753,
0.5226637721,
0.0124385515,
-0.5502050519,
0.2157332301,
0.0889976248,
-0.0164144523,
-0.1010265127,
0.3514850736,
0.3981945813,
0.4226658344,
0.0873993337,
-0.1988903433,
0.6363773942,
0.1051517576,
-0.5231385231,
-0.2501096427,
-0.0127225202,
-0.3097501993,
-0.2763914466,
-0.1146306917,
-0.699370265,
-0.7302814722,
-0.1872739345,
0.4212993681,
-0.3449203074,
0.0068786871,
0.2017726302,
-0.1861333251,
0.0690302774,
0.2941876948,
-0.6354845762,
0.3339346349,
0.7693038583,
0.2178780735,
-0.1129434705,
-0.1928839684,
-0.6089408994,
0.0836776122,
-0.6446357369,
0.9271436334,
-0.8657897711,
-0.2194946259,
-0.1557976604,
-0.1144313589,
0.0572619922,
-0.6777479649,
1.0642226934,
-0.5039020181,
0.0372677632,
-1.024749279,
-0.6490283608,
-0.3894319832,
0.5076522827,
-0.4687100649,
0.8041474819,
0.2181919068,
-0.6556622386,
-0.0400318429,
-0.2410635948,
-0.3567756414,
0.2071233988,
-0.5441247225,
0.0227536298,
0.3457916975,
0.07185065,
0.298846662,
-0.8290672898,
0.5194857121,
-0.3626922667,
-0.2092225999,
0.7124957442,
-0.1737437397,
0.767246902,
0.0847233981,
-0.2385338545,
-0.3081476688,
-0.7009756565,
0.1921503395,
0.3653462529,
0.2403410226,
-0.5259423256,
0.2747039795,
-0.5909178853,
0.2180962712,
0.4053472579,
-0.6105216742,
0.1148084924,
-0.471814394,
0.2470173687,
0.9156851768,
-0.1003261879,
0.1091746166,
-0.4732610285,
0.4072929621,
-0.0018060099,
0.2820999324,
-0.1219760403,
-0.3545838594,
-0.6460992098,
-0.1273855269,
0.5632584095,
0.7136237621,
-0.9284338355,
0.0518004484,
-0.2045208216,
-0.4979841411,
-0.586959064,
-0.1636608392,
0.5509919524,
0.9713340402,
0.2339044362,
0.1043057516,
-0.3091441393,
-1.3506958485,
-0.5068144202,
-0.4954985976,
-0.000902621,
0.2407085747,
0.7918624282,
0.0900944918,
0.8476331234,
-0.4957317114,
-0.0638548732,
0.0157068856,
0.1860711873,
0.5191546082,
0.1613586396,
0.3652760684,
-1.070507288,
-0.5149729848,
-0.2992915809,
-0.9572461843,
-0.4830909073,
-0.07471589,
0.1717478931,
0.1491404325,
0.0397932008,
-0.4720202088,
0.3504777253,
0.4880692363,
-0.2874933183,
0.920124054,
0.100974977,
0.2536752224,
-0.6259089112,
-0.0088135293,
-0.3192704022,
-0.0824868903,
-0.3683049381,
0.3686998188,
-0.0937732756,
0.069713816,
-0.3072611094,
0.3280195296,
-0.2523896694,
-0.3690011203,
0.0959635824,
0.3523419201,
0.2519290745,
0.4707010984,
-0.0798537582,
0.7311333418,
0.3226405382,
-0.3829772472,
0.474701345,
0.2940185964,
-0.4490697682,
0.9538454413,
-0.7987904549,
0.191894725,
-0.0414133519,
0.1088421419,
-1.075393796,
-0.1234696507,
0.124350749,
-0.5195351839,
-0.3224901557,
0.0540860891,
-0.7776401639,
-0.426115483,
-0.288724333,
0.3517729342,
0.4594065845,
-0.5127152801,
0.6400190592,
0.3294459581,
-0.1715945303,
-0.8405380249,
-0.706251204,
-0.1864798814,
-0.1305665076,
-0.693451643,
0.2367157042,
-0.3102016449,
-0.6048532724,
-0.0177525263,
-0.445951134,
0.0624129511,
-0.0375968851,
0.2457166165,
0.4408600032,
-0.2057570368,
0.0519336425,
-0.1020366624,
-0.4135743082,
0.1705949008,
0.1010111719,
0.3807860315,
-0.4939048886,
-0.7601211071,
-0.3579866588,
0.6043860912,
0.5708068013,
-0.2420939058,
0.4592502415,
-0.2388476729,
-0.2490065694,
0.0251917113,
-0.8201259971,
-0.0542792045,
-0.4936368763,
0.0210363697,
-0.6653490663,
-0.8985142708,
0.7749896049,
-0.3181790411,
0.0126681793,
0.5175173283,
0.2217753828,
-0.3858925402,
1.1437762976,
0.1996806413,
0.2369622439,
-0.320568949,
0.1100249812,
0.2021977454,
-0.5265718102,
-0.0776723772,
-0.733999908,
-0.4342736006,
-0.4247314334,
-0.4895287752,
0.4934527576,
0.2511744499,
-0.4562553465,
0.2754789591,
-0.3867047727,
0.832676053,
0.3665014505,
-0.3984600008,
0.2948624194,
-0.2855108082,
-0.5333465934,
-0.7047464848,
-0.4392933249,
-0.6232867241,
0.863276124,
0.3736560345,
0.4882539511,
0.4621031582,
0.3674912155,
0.1870237589,
0.0220821779,
-0.5673359036,
0.829854846,
-0.1609048098,
-0.7765280008,
-0.1657060534,
-0.6031458378,
-0.5397143364,
0.2502200902,
-0.1919270158,
-0.9634309411,
0.4088045657,
-0.0780405253,
-0.2889275849,
0.1233075038,
-0.346807152,
0.8474872112,
-0.2827275991,
-0.158463642,
-0.1149280593,
-0.9625792503,
0.4300882816,
-0.0660361946,
0.3498246372,
-0.2135246098,
0.1607055366,
0.6008004546,
-0.3349992633,
0.6411905885,
-0.2095811069,
-0.0108611556,
0.1801824272,
0.6834594011,
0.8742437363,
-0.1477532387,
-0.1978410035,
0.1580640674,
0.4588881135,
-0.1761510372,
-1.0957366228,
0.4333620071,
-0.5814154148,
-0.5625385642,
-0.7137879133,
-0.7350341678,
-0.5975583196,
0.2110228688,
0.1342680752,
0.5490272045,
-0.0036663858,
0.3308478296,
0.9265871048,
-0.123928003,
0.1264747679,
0.9527789354,
-0.4474866092,
-0.4499778748,
0.8344656825,
0.2378362864,
0.2480258942,
0.4249533713,
0.3880794942,
-0.5983636379,
-0.4512858093,
-0.204103604,
0.500803113,
-0.9603868127,
-0.3810602427,
-0.1967372894,
-0.1616768539,
-0.1901884228,
-0.2879514992,
-0.5620320439,
-0.5617446899,
0.3110192418,
0.2309468538,
-0.0216355473,
0.48644346,
0.0090940278,
0.3806407452,
-0.5403572917,
0.5846276283,
0.6275988221,
0.1125553697,
-0.2689273357,
-0.5217157602,
0.3335805535,
0.0532480329,
-0.2742847502,
-1.1020222902,
0.0354254842,
-0.3500796258,
0.7059434652,
0.324960351,
0.483512044,
0.6053206325,
-0.6264932752,
0.7030590773,
0.212322861,
-1.1198316813,
0.3733888865,
-0.3555414677,
0.0471618772,
0.9421598911,
0.4893084466,
-0.6598777771,
-0.0808322653,
-0.6982727051,
-0.3194014132,
0.3892691433,
0.2745651007,
-0.3622421622,
-0.2274561822,
0.3049955666,
0.2142297775,
0.3572857678,
-0.6019479036,
-0.1308683455,
0.1198445633,
-0.270819068,
0.1164907068,
-0.3746804893,
-0.3462131321,
-0.1276368499,
0.6108011007,
-0.0542197712,
0.1479037404,
0.0717070848,
-0.2919915915,
-0.112533994,
0.324483186,
0.7226224542,
0.8493502736,
-0.0166173894,
0.2730346024,
0.161794886,
-0.2040340006,
0.2050036043,
0.0784026831,
-0.2806936204,
-0.0628908426,
0.6050388813,
0.5724269152,
0.3163377047,
-0.9313003421,
0.8243480921,
0.1521425843,
-0.361869514,
-0.2622559667,
-0.0455645733,
-0.0484382287,
0.8078163266,
0.2819613516,
0.0555657148,
0.2573304772,
-0.5640295744,
-0.0176076423,
0.3860628903,
-0.0836290866,
-0.0639648438,
0.4530764818,
-0.068181999,
-0.5548686981,
0.5465805531,
-0.215502575,
-0.9326653481,
0.4222092628,
0.7338553071,
0.4504821897,
-0.3843051791,
0.5227140188,
0.0071766102,
0.3205453157,
-0.2178386599,
0.4948428571,
0.1640020311,
-0.7989851832,
-0.3900551796,
-0.5028004646,
-0.5907887816,
0.0453219563,
-0.645839572,
-0.1173495352,
-0.4997632504,
-0.0294550676,
0.0559786968,
0.1390330195,
-0.2466346323,
-0.0555058159,
-0.0449855961,
0.7911888957,
-0.9232222438,
0.3611534834,
0.4572497904,
-0.1389812529,
-0.8839495778,
-0.0286560524,
0.1420670152,
-0.7578979731,
0.7959648371,
0.0480990373,
-0.3764604032,
-0.3098773956,
-0.6616973281,
-0.8157749176,
0.7568434477,
0.7897725701,
-0.6345795989,
0.0561847538,
0.3815540373,
0.4714815319,
-0.3573879898,
0.0750117004,
0.5800380111,
0.6878404617,
0.4795332551,
-0.8317685723,
0.0189075805,
-0.1626420468,
0.1264840811,
0.1605234593,
-0.5515596867,
1.1400169134,
0.0426772125,
-0.0563771017,
0.1065634042,
0.744823873,
0.8996962309,
0.1802170128,
0.7912960052,
0.591514349,
0.9998967648,
-0.1445609927,
0.8289824128,
0.1693725586,
-0.0219827108,
1.2433966398,
-0.7155985236,
1.00090909,
0.36680758,
-0.212102443,
0.7998023629,
0.2380120009,
0.0070024082,
0.5753393173,
0.3367382884,
0.0815166757,
-0.5872942805,
-0.2639693916,
-0.6239735484,
0.6270223856,
0.4880865812,
0.0474243686,
-0.2740653753,
-0.0855922401,
-0.0134183364,
0.5973175764,
-0.0388955437,
0.2911188006,
-0.0545936897,
-0.7368778586,
0.376334846,
0.0306583866,
0.0521010682,
-0.6666401029,
-0.3313602507,
-0.1188684851,
0.2676979005,
0.2147289068,
-0.8896690607,
0.1236011684,
-0.100390628,
-0.1765019,
-0.1878136396,
0.6818401217,
-0.0585022494,
-0.533008039,
-0.0105065964,
0.2371510267,
0.3354816437,
-0.0136110755,
-0.8503760695,
0.4271692634,
-0.100047864,
0.018490022,
0.0359052345,
0.7052862048,
-0.207657516,
0.7871268392,
0.5509247184,
-0.1343326718,
-0.2073288262,
-0.0107823992,
0.7466654778,
-0.5334740877,
-0.6884730458,
-0.7448607087,
0.3874886632,
-0.1786678433,
-0.2883149683,
0.8543972373,
0.4971300066,
0.3680085838,
0.0099243345,
0.4166635275,
0.2228553891,
1.102828145,
-0.4902306199,
0.2399116457,
-0.4170615077,
0.3028777838,
-0.5896635652,
-0.9260181189,
-0.1510796547,
1.1336760521,
-0.6145347357,
-0.134094134,
0.8151364923,
0.4676426351,
0.1445270032,
0.4912928939,
0.2944090664,
0.4306735396,
0.1063964143,
0.8061616421,
1.2086302042,
-0.4454887509,
0.1165194586,
-0.0261297133,
-0.1365913302,
-0.1279399991,
-0.9315172434,
-0.8475410342,
-0.6633282304,
-0.152837649,
-0.1071633622,
0.0388292894,
0.6039168239,
0.4302782714,
-0.7795897126,
-0.1238558218,
0.0834320039,
0.3056515157,
-0.2451810092,
-0.1650338024,
0.2774186134,
-0.0187352356,
-0.2218944281,
0.5847816467,
0.2842018902,
-0.1110681593,
-0.298161447,
0.0377213582,
-0.3100340664,
0.3746177852,
0.2686044574,
0.2561943531,
-0.9577322006,
-0.5465236902,
0.2017568499,
0.0721102133,
-0.0959950611,
0.6915332079,
-0.8262739182,
0.391525805,
0.3516587615,
0.6807992458,
0.4239403009,
0.1216489449,
0.3815215826,
-0.537355125,
-0.0427469872,
0.6240795851,
0.1280122697,
0.2093244046,
-0.1346705109,
0.5360888839,
0.4773908556,
-0.5636022091,
-1.2607522011,
0.5258289576,
-0.9726508856,
-0.4958837628,
0.6047289371,
-0.1162117422,
-0.2292390466,
-0.0585581176,
-0.0045580873,
-0.1998310834,
-0.0231462773,
0.5580045581,
1.1122590303,
-0.1158471927,
-0.0999446735,
-0.9223909974,
0.3193651736,
0.6856408119,
-0.6954811215,
0.1963556111,
0.6143243909,
0.0056030164,
0.5208745599,
0.4880645871,
-0.0504059121,
0.2498245984,
0.1253151745,
-0.3736551404,
0.0310669616,
-0.7416241765,
0.1886359304,
0.2773212194,
-0.2576678693,
0.0124620525
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12534v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12534v3 | Unified Active Retrieval for Retrieval Augmented Generation | 2024-06-18T12:09:02 | 2024-06-27T15:37:15 | Qinyuan Cheng, Xiaonan Li, Shimin Li, Qin Zhu, Zhangyue Yin, Yunfan Shao, Linyang Li, Tianxiang Sun, Hang Yan, Xipeng Qiu | cs.CL | cs.CL | In Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG), retrieval is not always helpful and
applying it to every instruction is sub-optimal. Therefore, determining whether
to retrieve is crucial for RAG, which is usually referred to as Active
Retrieval. However, existing active retrieval methods face two challenges: 1.
They usually rely on a single criterion, which struggles with handling various
types of instructions. 2. They depend on specialized and highly differentiated
procedures, and thus combining them makes the RAG system more complicated and
leads to higher response latency. To address these challenges, we propose
Unified Active Retrieval (UAR). UAR contains four orthogonal criteria and casts
them into plug-and-play classification tasks, which achieves multifaceted
retrieval timing judgements with negligible extra inference cost. We further
introduce the Unified Active Retrieval Criteria (UAR-Criteria), designed to
process diverse active retrieval scenarios through a standardized procedure.
Experiments on four representative types of user instructions show that UAR
significantly outperforms existing work on the retrieval timing judgement and
the performance of downstream tasks, which shows the effectiveness of UAR and
its helpfulness to downstream tasks. | [
-0.2427019477,
-0.7010136247,
0.4523131549,
0.3628606498,
-0.30081141,
0.3471331298,
-0.0416019969,
-0.5798527598,
0.0234257281,
0.5453015566,
-0.0003515133,
0.1950746626,
-0.0859740451,
0.1207868978,
-0.3886191249,
0.894030869,
-0.1443982273,
-0.086232245,
-0.0945479199,
-0.2849803865,
-0.7079696655,
-0.5619202852,
-0.4180163443,
-0.4463120997,
0.758300066,
0.5002019405,
0.5405468941,
0.520303607,
0.7906317115,
0.3294581473,
-0.3697454631,
0.3415087163,
-0.099915795,
0.3809014261,
-0.0868956298,
-0.2516340613,
-0.4055158794,
-0.0262404047,
0.5959062576,
0.7179337144,
-0.2806329131,
0.3144901693,
0.0578940697,
0.7334516048,
-0.9860129952,
-0.4283645749,
-0.5654754639,
0.2790560424,
-0.4243603647,
-0.4562885463,
-0.4622525275,
-0.248800844,
-0.0359892212,
-0.4489080906,
0.580142498,
0.1032279134,
0.7370786667,
0.052007243,
-0.8487744927,
-0.1433747858,
-1.1219981909,
0.7564018369,
-0.1235742792,
0.4036266506,
0.1735616773,
0.4854816198,
-0.1105271131,
-1.025116086,
-0.3256469965,
-0.1872774214,
-0.1343361735,
0.2302167565,
-0.2285916954,
0.0859275833,
0.2329421639,
0.6052420735,
-0.4429506063,
-0.1884305477,
-0.4428096116,
-0.2268158495,
0.5774924159,
-0.0126906037,
0.0806562155,
-0.3848643601,
-0.7378063798,
0.078353323,
-0.5752776861,
0.1312278956,
0.3861301243,
0.3878667355,
0.4889428318,
0.7033420205,
-0.2639328241,
0.6880107522,
0.1845356226,
-0.0044026496,
0.1690236181,
-0.2417812049,
0.1390019506,
-0.2377590686,
0.4883524179,
-0.2810953557,
-0.3655087948,
-0.5658720732,
-0.6447167397,
0.0434501916,
0.7418413162,
-0.4615496695,
-0.0327132456,
-0.1000019237,
-0.471975863,
0.0618246868,
0.3861500323,
-0.6393003464,
0.018339783,
-0.4305306971,
0.8114870787,
-0.0486913845,
-0.067992419,
-0.3417859077,
-0.1769099534,
0.1353767216,
0.2390091419,
-0.3354320824,
0.4028657377,
0.4444063902,
0.4669109881,
-0.5575810671,
-0.0578092486,
-1.0217351913,
0.1103096306,
-0.1392996311,
1.1440553665,
-0.6952807903,
-0.5686487556,
-0.3503211737,
-0.1496951282,
-0.0666184425,
-0.5510287285,
0.8661386371,
-0.8989239335,
0.2150167078,
-0.2900451124,
-0.0816532895,
-0.1275417954,
-0.2485382259,
-0.7161793113,
1.2237745523,
0.1819663644,
-0.4577171803,
0.3989788592,
-0.6586000919,
-0.7766183019,
0.5369184017,
-0.2762678862,
-0.4346976876,
0.1995417178,
-0.0875361338,
0.2932654619,
-0.2258660644,
-0.0046669152,
-0.0912073553,
-0.5385738015,
-0.0070089526,
-0.5136653781,
0.5904206634,
0.6956509352,
-0.4729180038,
-0.153330043,
-0.7404156327,
0.295351088,
-0.0609520823,
-0.8337154984,
-0.3794881105,
-0.0677916482,
-0.0040167086,
-0.124340184,
0.3151650429,
-0.5876449347,
0.2671297193,
0.1846907884,
-0.2015432417,
0.6757014394,
0.2002163231,
0.6541432738,
-0.1725927442,
0.568774581,
-0.3197947741,
0.2397741824,
-0.0877455175,
-0.5501263142,
-0.6399409771,
-0.177638486,
0.4608578384,
0.5566532612,
-0.6730782986,
0.4513560236,
0.1496693939,
-0.2848587334,
-0.4363937378,
0.3038830459,
0.9622728825,
0.5347417593,
0.5674529672,
-0.4640622437,
-0.658360064,
-0.4660643935,
-0.2216234058,
-0.1676390171,
-0.1014267206,
0.6943699718,
0.1678770632,
-0.1914583296,
0.7685148716,
-0.3362369239,
-0.3865760267,
-0.2295939177,
0.4980663359,
0.1482943147,
0.179526329,
0.2291344404,
-1.3222532272,
-0.3896796107,
0.0697462782,
-0.6987785697,
-0.3831550479,
0.0112518705,
-0.1435514688,
0.2174353898,
0.2261087447,
-0.4350856245,
0.6587977409,
0.1260376126,
-0.4518024921,
0.3291977048,
-0.4222894311,
0.4151779115,
-0.6011090875,
0.4347661436,
-0.357875973,
0.0268752407,
-0.2944865227,
0.3760873079,
0.1644437909,
0.046476528,
-0.1851774007,
0.6138679981,
-0.9395013452,
-0.3619422317,
-0.3008190989,
-0.3136566579,
0.1223672852,
0.1512989104,
-0.3985158503,
0.9159357548,
0.2011149079,
-1.0101908445,
0.3462450802,
0.0504342727,
0.1018458381,
0.4195263684,
-0.7222962379,
0.4674936831,
-0.1719394624,
0.1750436872,
-0.9136567712,
-0.2532896996,
-0.2729009986,
-0.4958583713,
0.6120547056,
-0.3098483384,
-0.4041089714,
-0.601733923,
0.0405155048,
0.3240053356,
0.6677635312,
-0.8021082282,
0.9903253317,
0.4696055055,
0.1632872075,
-0.7867944241,
-0.1204266325,
-0.1258058846,
-0.0646658614,
-0.1902718991,
0.5269025564,
0.0341493636,
-0.0710681826,
0.2418832332,
-0.47932446,
0.0500131249,
0.0959667116,
0.1263933331,
0.2761462331,
-0.0198800191,
-0.20179452,
-0.0341133028,
-0.1876953542,
-0.4129103422,
0.2026824653,
0.233019039,
0.1988213062,
-0.6026356816,
-0.0568565764,
0.524015367,
0.205341205,
-0.7145879865,
0.1565084457,
0.8550158739,
-0.0216226988,
-0.1904056668,
-0.8043547869,
-0.0419662818,
-0.4945251942,
-0.1769028008,
-0.5224044919,
-0.6431096196,
0.4960553646,
0.0935179144,
0.3656400442,
0.4431949258,
0.3539297283,
-0.1029929593,
1.5353574753,
0.4176804125,
0.2983008027,
0.4724284112,
-0.2677886188,
-0.0108691836,
-1.0809407234,
-0.5659113526,
-0.7856934071,
-0.3560502231,
-0.192231223,
-0.3771822155,
0.5792365074,
0.4374018312,
-0.1710303128,
0.3825686276,
-0.8781933784,
0.3582079113,
0.564892292,
0.0984060168,
0.3575674295,
0.2101280391,
-0.4175640047,
0.0909175202,
-0.5466245413,
-0.3203526437,
0.958220005,
-0.1817838103,
0.9102746844,
0.4389686882,
0.7406532168,
0.6156311035,
0.42574808,
-0.5766345263,
0.6985920668,
-0.4285655916,
-0.8382901549,
-0.0246346481,
-0.977689445,
-1.5610704422,
0.3196347058,
-0.2474384606,
-0.5096449852,
0.1278580129,
0.0381129161,
-0.3529568911,
0.2374129891,
-0.7609631419,
0.3026512563,
-0.4121415019,
-0.2558107972,
0.0841451734,
-0.7378035784,
0.1835520267,
-0.0740095079,
0.1104434207,
-0.0680501759,
-0.1096644476,
0.7260007858,
-0.1182337776,
0.3012695909,
-0.3482053578,
0.3768306375,
0.4751209915,
-0.0143782152,
0.2394346148,
-0.1153724939,
-0.0111693284,
-0.3996132612,
-0.2087019533,
-0.3062859178,
-0.5775390267,
0.7540823817,
-0.6935064793,
-0.4300041795,
-0.6190007329,
-0.2181498408,
-0.0819415227,
0.406373173,
0.3146189153,
0.5200408101,
-0.0924891904,
0.3123054504,
0.6243761778,
0.2341510803,
0.4014088511,
0.8863885999,
-0.1658003032,
-0.3032841384,
0.8971715569,
0.1981211305,
-0.0201711748,
0.5143608451,
0.2230129093,
-0.5089156628,
-0.4783895314,
-0.5697976351,
0.099092029,
-0.4085032046,
-0.682341218,
-0.767364502,
-0.1313636154,
-0.3797759712,
0.123554334,
-0.3318442702,
-0.4908573329,
-0.3881346583,
0.2316379547,
0.3530133963,
0.7953986526,
-0.292208463,
-0.0874361098,
-1.0815548897,
1.1083772182,
0.558562696,
0.4737462103,
-0.0418743119,
-0.8111414313,
0.0527451076,
-0.1465873569,
-0.6935243607,
-0.7452726364,
0.0015822508,
0.3962282538,
1.1692677736,
0.2835039496,
0.3521617055,
0.8783560395,
-0.6935084462,
0.4474696815,
-0.0477137417,
-0.4711153507,
0.6092363,
0.1058120579,
0.1078710556,
0.4756015241,
0.389657855,
-0.0446154773,
-0.103683725,
-0.6723104715,
-1.2824846506,
0.6062653065,
0.2412002683,
0.2274739593,
-0.073621124,
0.5300179124,
-0.1223950163,
-0.1822445989,
-0.181395933,
-0.425714761,
0.2161139101,
0.3072937727,
0.2296298742,
-0.1843156517,
-0.0655218661,
-0.1587220281,
0.4777991176,
0.083118178,
0.4729717672,
0.3258303106,
0.0186780747,
-0.6300958991,
0.4559589326,
-0.2291741818,
0.5839400291,
-0.3154495358,
0.0843397304,
-0.0585899353,
-0.6465356946,
0.3588480949,
0.5991474986,
-0.3402661681,
0.208900407,
0.1006981656,
0.4258244634,
0.3513272703,
-0.4376474917,
0.4322426319,
-0.1914554983,
0.0407868885,
-0.2856526673,
0.3081791103,
-0.7118076682,
0.1624505222,
1.1756837368,
0.2948156595,
0.6042520404,
-0.7025358677,
0.5506204367,
0.4464697838,
-0.2209032029,
-0.2955346406,
0.969266057,
0.1530490518,
-0.4246643782,
0.5040061474,
-0.576127708,
-0.4493274093,
0.2501370907,
0.587443471,
0.8171563745,
-0.5474560857,
0.095983617,
0.263178885,
-0.2270248234,
-0.3414210975,
0.584463954,
-0.1895932704,
-0.3855094612,
-0.5293366909,
-0.9059895873,
-0.4591851532,
-0.1884824783,
-1.1819486618,
0.0171147548,
-0.0960882455,
-0.4713257253,
0.2113226652,
0.1328042299,
-0.5055306554,
0.0386133865,
-0.1116361022,
0.5866599679,
-0.3888503313,
0.3673169315,
1.2700031996,
-0.5024362206,
-0.8829248548,
-0.2555840015,
-0.03856894,
-0.4019477963,
0.5080097914,
-0.0411725454,
-0.2448514849,
-0.0643564388,
-0.2749679089,
-0.7311835289,
1.0217622519,
0.0503167957,
0.0493455268,
-0.2152138799,
-0.5653015375,
0.4621036351,
-0.1280844212,
0.1809964925,
0.3779518008,
0.3788456619,
0.6143358946,
-1.0306600332,
-0.0904190242,
-0.4231835306,
0.0798998252,
0.578499496,
-0.51299119,
0.9605259299,
-0.4849313498,
-0.5916349888,
0.2880702615,
0.8157675862,
0.4499628246,
0.5293778181,
0.6351018548,
0.6039871573,
0.4699654579,
-0.0514562652,
1.0801467896,
0.1349773556,
0.1331645548,
0.6081321836,
-0.2425880134,
0.9230160117,
0.3357151151,
-0.3648871779,
0.2902290225,
0.1673154533,
0.1383539736,
0.4482828975,
-0.2229934335,
-0.5722923875,
-0.1500328332,
-0.2705295682,
-0.3638275862,
0.5597456098,
0.2349315435,
-0.0264722593,
-0.2231443375,
-0.0495836884,
-0.0418117158,
0.2168292403,
-0.3443139195,
0.9771325588,
-0.1537120491,
-0.9808732271,
0.5572493076,
-0.1204332262,
0.5774912238,
-0.5122419,
-0.5194365978,
-0.3875264823,
0.4705452323,
-0.3479279876,
-0.6931083798,
0.0973955691,
0.2735103071,
-0.1472638696,
-0.2611660659,
0.7634081841,
-0.1369726658,
-0.4598231614,
0.3445546031,
0.6217793226,
0.2423279583,
-0.0148915136,
-0.6427058578,
0.0254662987,
0.0742878914,
-0.3785087466,
0.4641117752,
0.6628180742,
-0.1716224402,
0.4124504924,
0.8820238113,
0.2290770859,
0.2935532331,
0.2387422472,
1.0382349491,
-0.569085896,
-0.1490288526,
-0.0702746734,
0.4358839393,
0.0522113442,
-0.2039165199,
0.8660034537,
0.7642941475,
0.5853028893,
0.3632397354,
0.5510256886,
-0.4494697452,
1.1069643497,
-0.3743627071,
0.4267132282,
-0.8690562844,
0.4875095189,
-0.1240475848,
-1.153517127,
-0.2910737097,
0.5708953738,
0.2573468387,
0.3832526803,
0.4673248231,
0.4572331905,
-0.344381541,
-0.278844595,
0.1474443525,
-0.2089134753,
0.2448256612,
0.147214517,
0.8211390376,
-0.384686321,
1.0305440426,
-0.4024029672,
-0.4010900259,
-0.343016088,
-0.496278882,
-0.5010026097,
-0.5417789221,
0.0761062875,
-0.3410709798,
0.0998408124,
0.6244142652,
0.577346921,
-0.680493474,
-0.0409087278,
0.091591984,
0.0194958169,
-0.2684580684,
-0.2569784522,
0.2505997121,
-0.7681378722,
-0.4771351814,
0.5353412032,
0.1401761472,
-0.0200773664,
-0.0317603163,
0.0292029623,
-0.2934353054,
-0.0936371014,
0.5922805071,
0.7504255176,
-0.5821867585,
-0.1925822794,
0.3862480521,
-0.1925647855,
-0.0661350936,
1.1433099508,
-0.9208570123,
0.6030558944,
0.4452024996,
0.6022558808,
0.5867886543,
0.395329684,
0.3574954271,
-0.9325804114,
-0.1863633245,
0.6352763176,
0.2556819916,
0.2519949973,
-0.4325897098,
0.6868671775,
0.1601774991,
-0.9307664037,
-0.9330148101,
0.1150614768,
-1.0685321093,
-0.1464887559,
1.2571429014,
-0.1522198915,
-0.0388357267,
-0.6029934883,
-0.3077476621,
0.431328088,
-0.5495402217,
0.7786149979,
-0.2117179334,
-0.5804187059,
0.0269094314,
-0.4543228447,
0.2510712445,
0.2641783655,
-0.4253513217,
-0.1715058982,
0.6021092534,
-0.0912979394,
0.4757287502,
0.64362216,
-0.347397387,
0.5323755145,
-0.1342388242,
0.10648413,
-0.0298039783,
-0.6798769236,
-0.1491864026,
0.1898565441,
-0.0108347135,
-0.1877611876
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12527v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12527v1 | FuseGen: PLM Fusion for Data-generation based Zero-shot Learning | 2024-06-18T11:55:05 | 2024-06-18T11:55:05 | Tianyuan Zou, Yang Liu, Peng Li, Jianqing Zhang, Jingjing Liu, Ya-Qin Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Data generation-based zero-shot learning, although effective in training
Small Task-specific Models (STMs) via synthetic datasets generated by
Pre-trained Language Models (PLMs), is often limited by the low quality of such
synthetic datasets. Previous solutions have primarily focused on single PLM
settings, where synthetic datasets are typically restricted to specific
sub-spaces and often deviate from real-world distributions, leading to severe
distribution bias. To mitigate such bias, we propose FuseGen, a novel data
generation-based zero-shot learning framework that introduces a new criteria
for subset selection from synthetic datasets via utilizing multiple PLMs and
trained STMs. The chosen subset provides in-context feedback to each PLM,
enhancing dataset quality through iterative data generation. Trained STMs are
then used for sample re-weighting as well, further improving data quality.
Extensive experiments across diverse tasks demonstrate that FuseGen
substantially outperforms existing methods, highly effective in boosting STM
performance in a PLM-agnostic way. Code is provided in
https://github.com/LindaLydia/FuseGen. | [
-0.158802554,
-0.5196380019,
0.3408258855,
0.0860830322,
-0.3724578917,
0.30733639,
-0.2019673884,
0.01215949,
0.0083389841,
0.5043466687,
-0.7479261756,
-0.6854243279,
-0.2803148627,
0.03853653,
-0.4760117233,
0.7399407625,
-0.057648845,
0.2198831588,
-0.6360750794,
-0.0795030668,
-0.5152865052,
-0.2356332392,
-0.1373143792,
-0.5287950635,
0.3166056871,
0.7525995374,
0.2649286985,
0.6787510514,
0.2939316928,
0.0910216048,
0.6161434054,
0.2803312838,
-0.8888418078,
0.2120069563,
-0.1107974574,
-0.3642141223,
0.1719284356,
0.1395908743,
0.611355722,
0.5920587778,
-0.0673478171,
0.1808831096,
-0.1590553522,
0.3882723749,
-0.8318620324,
-0.0836011991,
-0.836783886,
0.1538608074,
-0.2303031087,
-0.2952279449,
-0.6910628676,
-0.2473037541,
-0.0815654993,
-0.6507743597,
0.7684217691,
0.0643532723,
0.78973943,
0.3710483909,
-0.3712117076,
0.3800987899,
-0.8169502616,
1.1122434139,
-0.3967703581,
0.2774980366,
-0.0158975385,
0.4635126293,
-0.174492687,
-0.3085104525,
-0.5483140349,
-0.0000092649,
0.1446750909,
0.4705607891,
0.1576531082,
-0.0324601978,
0.1334882826,
0.6081383824,
-0.7911811471,
0.0811103731,
-0.4655445814,
-0.062491633,
0.9052872062,
0.0146165341,
0.063318558,
-0.080150336,
-0.6007332206,
-0.3475005329,
-1.1960555315,
-0.2476187199,
0.4075136781,
0.5552313328,
-0.1516830325,
0.3847653568,
-0.3233452737,
1.0498367548,
-0.0203701518,
-0.0374982841,
0.5308381915,
-0.3899064958,
-0.2733648717,
0.0861227661,
0.8636782169,
0.038829498,
-0.1452153623,
-0.1803741902,
0.0151397567,
0.1760086864,
0.0840518475,
-0.6861802936,
-0.3784114718,
0.2872721255,
-0.1249253824,
-0.5663715601,
0.2224145234,
-0.6390350461,
-0.3103521764,
-0.1491938382,
0.4886621833,
-0.5733280182,
-0.2230868489,
0.1664791852,
-0.3929247856,
0.4519574344,
0.0610740706,
-0.5436609387,
-0.1458112746,
0.2408300787,
0.6317924857,
-0.2854849994,
-0.4116536081,
-0.6845498085,
0.3162674606,
-0.2712377012,
1.0991203785,
-0.4985481799,
-0.7604801059,
-0.0773256794,
-0.3346768022,
-0.1746238619,
-0.710451901,
0.3513556421,
0.1358374208,
0.4459407628,
0.0047189556,
-0.7289520502,
0.1081084609,
0.024519518,
-0.3201565444,
1.0660963058,
0.3721753061,
-0.3664767444,
0.6485586166,
-0.3452919126,
-0.7109478712,
0.2888785601,
-0.4575244188,
-0.5747603178,
0.3097599149,
0.1524969339,
0.4820864201,
-0.3406627774,
0.0880795494,
-0.5896000862,
-0.3437674046,
-0.1638800651,
-0.1378370523,
0.5691307783,
0.1821247786,
-0.0590663478,
0.3171918392,
-0.807392478,
0.093240805,
0.2577167749,
0.0164250433,
-0.0249202996,
-0.0179838557,
-0.2426924407,
0.6626909971,
-0.1868627518,
-0.8788933754,
0.2433649302,
-0.6724020243,
0.100093767,
0.4885823131,
0.1468426436,
0.5146345496,
-0.6555225849,
0.4612288773,
0.2086563259,
0.0939368159,
-0.4988471866,
-0.2488969415,
-0.6941999197,
-0.4160682261,
0.3045680821,
0.5019893646,
-1.2759474516,
0.5746355057,
-0.2241462469,
-0.7367828488,
-0.6974359155,
0.5131784081,
0.3076220155,
0.742557466,
0.3784990013,
-0.2210192829,
-0.563151896,
-0.7599895,
0.1111285016,
0.1114677042,
-0.2316155732,
0.3340421021,
0.327934444,
0.0971052721,
1.2269774675,
-0.6240047812,
-0.5092647076,
-0.6734971404,
0.2312358171,
-0.0346919484,
0.3338215351,
0.6195480824,
-0.5042003393,
-0.5386907458,
-0.2763274014,
-0.6966633797,
-0.3347024322,
-0.3292680681,
-0.1091425121,
-0.0002361729,
0.0822511092,
-0.330429107,
0.1702948362,
0.5479474664,
-0.0282904152,
0.4437468648,
-0.215682283,
-0.2311593443,
-1.2385991812,
0.1363137662,
0.0903213546,
-0.1576490998,
-0.8382325768,
-0.1746578962,
0.0888618752,
-0.282787472,
-0.9863294363,
0.6769263744,
-0.1648179889,
-0.0412784852,
-0.3311439455,
0.1335871667,
0.0179506429,
0.367590934,
0.2682044804,
0.6250208616,
0.8465313315,
-0.4497565329,
0.3808570802,
0.3800443411,
-0.1938151419,
0.6482561827,
-0.4676631987,
-0.1202743128,
-0.3066021204,
0.3061941266,
-0.9072532058,
-0.3760959506,
0.0593555458,
-0.3872579932,
0.3601736724,
0.1765595675,
-0.6126127839,
-0.3385976851,
-0.472848922,
0.3230460584,
0.7513185143,
-0.6039592624,
0.3141392171,
0.2511292994,
0.2659322023,
-0.233530432,
-0.4119935632,
-0.2581335306,
0.0586382449,
-0.609869957,
0.4927222729,
0.0264854562,
0.1898526847,
-0.1782602668,
-0.2020846307,
0.1173306257,
-0.0905418396,
0.2704207301,
0.37520051,
0.2787127495,
0.1268148273,
0.0894342214,
-0.2824274898,
-0.4934365749,
-0.4072395861,
0.576941371,
0.4637437761,
-0.4240733385,
-0.004858268,
0.2122568488,
0.1929279417,
-0.1820694357,
0.6411727071,
0.4974118471,
-0.0288587026,
-0.8910750747,
-0.3427935839,
-0.312841177,
-0.3995995224,
-0.109594427,
-0.1176196933,
-0.8980270028,
0.1577076912,
-0.1599184126,
0.2184697092,
0.5098859072,
0.5675598979,
-0.2703448534,
1.075748086,
0.4583491981,
-0.0157408789,
0.4860148132,
-0.393263191,
0.1490411609,
-0.4348159134,
-0.1885348707,
-0.1441757381,
-0.4678192139,
-0.1624308676,
-0.541122973,
0.3503295183,
-0.1034267619,
-0.0514238589,
0.3663928509,
-0.5889489651,
0.5583749413,
0.6925552487,
0.0186719336,
0.1128760576,
0.0228525195,
-0.1465593278,
0.2081594467,
-1.0655523539,
0.0460686497,
1.1727348566,
-0.0655501559,
0.8203626275,
-0.3517704606,
0.9763860106,
0.1362467557,
0.3398114145,
-0.6063867807,
0.4994450212,
-0.4842469692,
-0.4682225287,
0.0828376561,
-0.8395029902,
-0.7294557691,
0.1169914007,
-0.2573541999,
-0.2870586514,
0.1169432476,
0.3186509311,
-0.5834330916,
0.226261124,
-0.6399758458,
0.8612130284,
-0.4237713814,
-0.3972737193,
0.083570838,
-0.662925899,
0.5606450438,
-0.1831004024,
-0.1579589844,
-0.4178096652,
0.3104354143,
0.4402969778,
-0.4211693406,
0.730019331,
-0.3817235231,
0.1430799961,
0.3983494341,
-0.1163897067,
0.2017524987,
-0.2096917331,
0.1054609939,
0.3195647597,
-0.1141311601,
-0.5729615092,
-0.4376064837,
0.8070180416,
-0.6801581383,
-0.243872121,
-0.4330801368,
-0.7726793885,
-0.5155259371,
0.1977801025,
0.5856660008,
0.1208151877,
-0.0907990858,
0.4088591039,
0.8147288561,
-0.3964755535,
0.1659530848,
0.6863694787,
-0.1174161509,
-0.4180585742,
1.5132745504,
0.0830373988,
0.4188558161,
0.4123981297,
-0.0370866209,
-0.2661480606,
-0.4728181958,
-0.4927950501,
0.1944642216,
-0.0961619243,
-0.5668172836,
-0.2292960286,
-0.2894144058,
-0.3732624948,
-0.3332989812,
-0.3327459991,
-0.2715159655,
-0.3448169529,
-0.2228143066,
0.113514699,
0.2178179622,
0.0059153344,
0.4360314608,
-0.7910217643,
0.4905664027,
0.111573644,
0.4460208118,
-0.6266894341,
-0.381275773,
-0.0001146459,
0.1485594511,
-0.4659521282,
-0.7900231481,
0.5494604111,
0.5179512501,
0.5487087369,
0.3778091073,
0.281016469,
0.4943856895,
-0.3087940514,
0.8643118739,
0.3925854266,
-0.6664794087,
0.9203686118,
-0.5491477847,
0.6458696723,
0.6396999359,
0.0882011354,
-0.2323823422,
-0.5122733116,
-0.7944934368,
-0.7699278593,
0.8973413706,
0.1589100957,
-0.0262752715,
0.0809892341,
0.1736459881,
0.4330324233,
0.4077990949,
-0.3403714001,
-0.3167431355,
-0.4556070566,
-0.5107785463,
-0.1125697345,
0.1208839566,
-0.081590876,
-0.2083372325,
0.7976551056,
-0.3192929029,
0.1369162798,
-0.0058488701,
-0.2871592045,
-0.3015753031,
0.0705396682,
0.4956602454,
0.2869536579,
-0.2469300926,
-0.0326506272,
0.1537329257,
-0.0427223407,
0.3174751401,
0.2492625415,
-0.5908679962,
0.1584874839,
-0.0332692191,
0.8461021185,
0.4473417699,
-0.9584536552,
0.5277163982,
0.1316195726,
-0.6508908272,
-0.1152691096,
0.5201690197,
-0.3275229633,
-0.1976765245,
0.4410890043,
-0.0551057458,
-0.3478905559,
-0.2931913733,
0.6490337253,
0.5135138631,
-0.2440372854,
-0.3402611017,
0.6321043372,
0.3972839713,
0.1068627164,
0.5615212917,
-0.2886699736,
-0.0475539789,
0.4143294394,
0.5583725572,
0.8358474374,
-0.3589687645,
0.7344320416,
0.2791570127,
-0.0342175812,
-0.066192247,
0.4251414537,
-0.1391688138,
-0.8004773855,
-0.4798646569,
-0.7943314314,
-0.4265279174,
0.2606026828,
-0.3227415979,
0.460429132,
-0.5984564424,
0.2006284595,
-0.2544030249,
-0.1290704459,
-0.632156074,
0.0723312497,
0.2225341201,
1.0543589592,
-1.0792143345,
1.0858037472,
0.4020499885,
-0.5890489817,
-0.4817322493,
-0.2858391702,
0.1751806736,
-0.7541563511,
0.2689768672,
0.1520231962,
0.2452297062,
0.2846672833,
-0.4305971563,
-0.6840854883,
1.2364990711,
0.6426689625,
-0.312024951,
0.0833043903,
0.4758478105,
0.3207761049,
-0.5034822226,
-0.1384349763,
0.4720225632,
0.0700696558,
0.7906138897,
-0.5920538306,
-0.3619133234,
-0.0644360334,
0.064360559,
0.4444890618,
-0.6810523868,
0.5033578873,
0.1217682436,
-0.4493870139,
-0.1577250957,
0.4698518515,
0.405831188,
0.2512108982,
0.1711746454,
0.8662448525,
0.3611396253,
-0.4131071568,
0.9549248815,
-0.4112861156,
0.3768237829,
1.1981703043,
-0.8787496686,
0.7294479012,
0.3444754183,
0.0892867744,
0.2426148355,
0.4562512338,
-0.515011251,
0.7757906318,
0.0716660395,
-0.5673891306,
-0.4033586085,
-0.3771448135,
-0.1051880419,
0.418546766,
0.1975610256,
-0.3038438857,
-0.6737599969,
0.3488399386,
-0.3983041942,
-0.1566960663,
-0.1443518847,
0.7946079373,
-0.0419268087,
-0.4933835268,
0.2966561317,
-0.225469768,
0.653185308,
-0.8259032369,
-0.0282121394,
-0.2196079493,
0.1926347613,
-0.31008479,
-0.6707114577,
0.4037820995,
-0.0988677219,
-0.1697408855,
-0.6152679324,
1.0818843842,
-0.718532145,
-0.5666522384,
-0.0750209168,
0.7145205736,
-0.1900795698,
-0.0416747294,
-0.5752388835,
-0.0282639097,
0.030334888,
0.1888366491,
0.5532296896,
-0.2928179801,
0.3524495363,
0.586710453,
0.8588417172,
0.3014068902,
-0.0179835483,
-0.0024043524,
0.6908733845,
-0.3796634972,
-0.1954490542,
-0.5562775731,
0.639161706,
-0.2750207186,
-0.1666212231,
1.0267263651,
0.6576884985,
1.2160884142,
-0.1378815472,
1.1897006035,
-0.0278440155,
0.619378984,
-0.1238040552,
0.5442133546,
-0.3283994198,
0.0274882223,
0.1922071874,
-0.8676034212,
-0.5464062691,
0.4648799896,
-0.4316499829,
-0.0490933806,
0.2433551401,
0.737608552,
-0.0905892104,
-0.1545243859,
0.6463853717,
-0.0532929115,
0.3481647968,
0.7344775796,
0.5753289461,
-0.4371183515,
0.6037353277,
-0.4645101726,
-0.1288299263,
-0.1699001342,
-0.6408660412,
-0.6799328327,
-0.4253322184,
-0.4751211405,
0.1391643137,
-0.0473338552,
0.8970124722,
0.8640909791,
-0.8620426655,
-0.1284202337,
-0.3675181866,
0.0004395496,
-0.1912148148,
-0.2861409485,
-0.070410341,
-0.4675626159,
-0.5314854383,
0.7942671776,
0.5017971992,
-0.0150477421,
-0.3153716326,
-0.0965065211,
-0.1979964226,
0.1000867113,
0.5299054384,
0.6162957549,
-0.3198840916,
-0.2672034204,
0.0637706369,
0.0575650148,
0.0531698614,
0.7918019891,
-1.1760863066,
0.6843523979,
0.665810585,
0.5189977288,
0.4093588889,
0.0874118805,
0.8200426102,
-1.5285600424,
0.1576732993,
0.3408346176,
0.2215889543,
0.3026762903,
-0.0474400558,
0.4269585907,
0.5147470832,
-0.3465211093,
-0.8394962549,
0.3506805301,
-0.8117032051,
-0.2375734299,
1.1099178791,
0.1192679405,
-0.1841548383,
0.0730816871,
-0.1432378292,
0.1641533077,
-0.2794800401,
0.7829471827,
0.3486203551,
-0.3990549445,
-0.3583155274,
-0.2614762783,
0.4955114126,
0.3743918836,
-0.9642148018,
0.0527659059,
0.8005300164,
0.2368501872,
-0.0360601768,
0.2337498814,
0.0332157835,
0.3382365704,
-0.061626453,
0.0195424967,
-0.4267446697,
-0.4222448766,
-0.3860011697,
0.4344263375,
-0.3131642044,
-0.2905539572
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12502v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12502v1 | Code-Optimise: Self-Generated Preference Data for Correctness and Efficiency | 2024-06-18T11:05:37 | 2024-06-18T11:05:37 | Leonidas Gee, Milan Gritta, Gerasimos Lampouras, Ignacio Iacobacci | cs.CL | cs.CL | Code Language Models have been trained to generate accurate solutions,
typically with no regard for runtime. On the other hand, previous works that
explored execution optimisation have observed corresponding drops in functional
correctness. To that end, we introduce Code-Optimise, a framework that
incorporates both correctness (passed, failed) and runtime (quick, slow) as
learning signals via self-generated preference data. Our framework is both
lightweight and robust as it dynamically selects solutions to reduce
overfitting while avoiding a reliance on larger models for learning signals.
Code-Optimise achieves significant improvements in pass@k while decreasing the
competitive baseline runtimes by an additional 6% for in-domain data and up to
3% for out-of-domain data. As a byproduct, the average length of the generated
solutions is reduced by up to 48% on MBPP and 23% on HumanEval, resulting in
faster and cheaper inference. The generated data and codebase will be
open-sourced at www.open-source.link. | [
-0.3334712088,
-0.2103167623,
0.4104640484,
0.2331523597,
-0.058456365,
-0.0362214744,
-0.2768038213,
-0.2177163661,
0.1215844229,
0.528986156,
-0.3995882273,
-0.4084540308,
-0.0248922538,
-0.0942977592,
-0.0159648061,
0.8938925266,
0.1253017932,
0.0416495688,
-0.393240273,
-0.2728440166,
-0.1681180298,
-0.7006059289,
-0.2498472482,
-0.4249774218,
0.3799342811,
0.7967601418,
0.6672445536,
0.9213706255,
0.5214199424,
0.081921041,
0.4218302369,
-0.0085892025,
-0.6203439236,
0.0891961679,
-0.1147563607,
-0.5668865442,
-0.3970802426,
0.0501155034,
0.0101806419,
0.4673404098,
-0.2603322566,
0.5007317662,
-0.1016301885,
1.1482294798,
-1.0654156208,
0.2179741859,
-0.5209354758,
0.171704933,
0.0748190805,
-0.3945702612,
-0.4679231346,
-0.6602649689,
-0.1909953505,
-0.2830629945,
0.1366918087,
-0.1669319123,
0.4789074957,
0.5539295673,
-0.1450004131,
-0.4601815343,
-0.3417988718,
0.9351593256,
-0.7762460113,
0.4658160508,
0.2159476876,
0.3668392599,
-0.1402770579,
-0.6286664605,
-0.2405477315,
-0.3765160441,
-0.0275753904,
0.064464882,
0.078455776,
0.0265645366,
0.3628219664,
0.2362565696,
-0.6768612862,
-0.0626793653,
-0.2904496491,
-0.3037161827,
0.8747391701,
0.0742782131,
0.0349563248,
-0.2742959559,
-0.1513710469,
0.0437715352,
-0.7113495469,
0.2475276738,
0.6278973222,
0.2344622314,
-0.0988994166,
0.3596632183,
-0.387932539,
0.7811129689,
0.1915652752,
-0.0862095356,
0.4939006865,
-0.096754767,
-0.1697816849,
-0.012512817,
0.5788467526,
0.233009696,
0.5398328304,
-0.1558665633,
-0.2611021698,
0.3289321959,
0.5337358713,
-0.9716267586,
-0.6520944834,
0.388695091,
-0.6031329036,
-0.5709018111,
-0.3163508177,
-0.5213219523,
0.1217139959,
-0.6505880356,
0.2635471821,
-0.4255435169,
-0.3036129475,
0.5118921399,
0.0689981952,
0.130848974,
0.0684278011,
-0.9453468323,
0.0033934705,
0.4443569481,
0.7411111593,
-0.4193996787,
0.073866494,
-0.59991467,
-0.0792831779,
-0.5281887054,
0.640424192,
-0.3853372633,
-0.5809739828,
-0.1883241087,
-0.4512976706,
-0.0361848027,
-0.66360569,
0.4228383005,
-0.5238827467,
0.0376302712,
-0.1429894567,
-0.6933875084,
0.2439369857,
-0.0195682216,
-0.5944287181,
1.1592186689,
0.3734416366,
-0.6845491529,
0.644874692,
-1.095058322,
-0.4012817144,
-0.1476249695,
-0.2550015748,
-0.4808032513,
0.0747397393,
0.2065691948,
0.5389890671,
0.1981187761,
0.2228655815,
-0.6834562421,
-0.3524471223,
0.0684995055,
-0.1156367734,
0.6148008704,
0.7458162904,
-0.506852746,
0.0481164791,
-1.0541132689,
0.6536333561,
0.1904154867,
-0.5145790577,
-0.1765855402,
0.1055839211,
-0.0137835667,
0.1858599931,
0.2266146988,
-0.4268572628,
0.2698251903,
-0.3876067102,
0.3520467877,
0.8231262565,
-0.2501376569,
0.4203369617,
-0.1669099778,
0.761619091,
-0.0625533536,
0.4984354079,
0.0438620783,
-0.243007198,
-0.6791185737,
-0.1660030037,
0.2379065305,
0.416514039,
-0.7442481518,
0.3134309053,
-0.1079876795,
-0.2766558528,
-0.4040770531,
0.2865853012,
0.4395763278,
0.5354918242,
0.3775984347,
-0.3088464737,
-0.4327079654,
-1.0112285614,
-0.3018608689,
-0.2209171057,
0.3075671792,
0.3571133316,
0.4008913636,
-0.3759111464,
1.3476873636,
-0.8613388538,
0.1933913678,
-0.1598246396,
-0.096348241,
0.3638447225,
0.7043032646,
1.0444324017,
-0.9611859918,
-0.5462418795,
-0.2079569101,
-0.67032516,
-0.3702450991,
0.0719270557,
-0.2550151348,
0.3398922682,
0.2624514401,
0.0761219561,
0.1429673582,
0.6820892096,
-0.1863385737,
0.7337884903,
-0.1599701196,
0.2294371724,
-0.9611704946,
0.3507774174,
-0.1939699501,
-0.4782711565,
-0.1722120345,
0.2062949687,
0.3159840703,
-0.1736321747,
-0.5398012996,
0.3225967884,
-0.2547270656,
-0.189757973,
0.0309391301,
-0.2585102916,
0.0122183338,
0.6334912777,
0.0860546157,
1.3672705889,
0.3301992416,
-0.5736937523,
0.0615531206,
0.0330487154,
-0.2994960546,
0.3469124138,
-0.5295682549,
0.4001094103,
0.0780425966,
-0.4122084081,
-0.6772857308,
-0.3616129458,
0.1637503505,
-0.6022610068,
0.3397762775,
-0.5316535234,
-0.2895853519,
-0.376644671,
-0.3582419157,
0.4722978771,
0.5999863148,
-0.864562571,
0.1284403503,
0.3179148138,
0.2396773845,
-0.7939608693,
-0.5738517046,
-0.2478550375,
-0.0414187089,
-0.4852728248,
-0.0354722142,
-0.4661337435,
0.1065626666,
-0.0244183689,
-0.2682255507,
-0.3799958527,
0.0596007369,
0.0158433169,
-0.0504411608,
-0.276106596,
0.1638655812,
0.063082777,
-0.3427323401,
0.1756108403,
-0.4374240339,
0.4021457732,
-0.2453803569,
-0.4342950583,
-0.1736624688,
0.3783438802,
0.6163822412,
-0.255666554,
0.4662457108,
0.1712207943,
0.1588390768,
-0.50922966,
-0.3739258051,
-0.0264352858,
-0.5376263857,
-0.0087027503,
-0.5651246309,
-0.9295374155,
0.3680125177,
0.1263369471,
0.1245015785,
0.2610663772,
0.4345463514,
0.0638020113,
1.1510206461,
0.6203171611,
-0.0975108519,
0.5352734327,
-0.4106242061,
0.3166702986,
-0.2279530317,
-0.0816298053,
-0.5415577292,
0.2500313818,
-0.4723326266,
-0.2830048203,
0.3734780252,
0.0818691179,
-0.107743375,
0.4441117644,
-0.7558854222,
0.6051122546,
0.4329742193,
0.2661849558,
0.115811035,
-0.0711686015,
-0.1016675159,
-0.2130406052,
-1.0204926729,
-0.419149518,
1.4075918198,
0.1872843802,
1.0229650736,
0.0554989949,
1.0033471584,
0.7245569229,
0.2981044352,
-0.728982687,
0.2577733397,
-0.0091713322,
-0.6301172376,
0.1322316229,
-0.785251081,
-0.6008079648,
-0.0675811619,
0.014980888,
-0.1695101857,
0.1246422008,
0.734797895,
-0.4944038689,
-0.0633986443,
-1.0718823671,
1.1778110266,
-0.3550182879,
-0.3972732127,
-0.2673479021,
-0.4103555381,
0.3168793917,
-0.2734660804,
0.1189992651,
-0.0197226331,
0.1353538632,
0.5475157499,
-0.4136214256,
0.5332998037,
-0.2263504863,
-0.0191654097,
0.433200866,
0.1838762462,
0.2085796893,
0.092790775,
-0.3696879745,
-0.0074307616,
0.1370376199,
-0.6557232141,
-0.7122417688,
0.6135024428,
-0.5155185461,
-0.148136422,
-0.2497641891,
-0.1756146252,
-0.1533144116,
0.2420080751,
0.3090980947,
0.8862249851,
0.1458204389,
0.2315152735,
0.6733794212,
-0.1992644966,
0.497348398,
0.5666534901,
-0.2829600871,
-0.5360772014,
0.8849413395,
-0.052486036,
0.6002668142,
0.0018388764,
0.1917790771,
-0.5195465684,
-0.6098188758,
-0.6561579108,
-0.0345053375,
-0.9046964049,
-0.3222723305,
-0.625323534,
0.0925403237,
-0.457506299,
-0.5571174026,
-0.6661272645,
-0.4536824226,
-0.2174728513,
0.0156039195,
0.3025218248,
0.4163293242,
-0.3559054732,
0.2106676549,
-0.7271494269,
0.3364037573,
0.0274987314,
0.7131968737,
-0.3782906234,
-0.1968488842,
-0.5975818038,
-0.0989176035,
-0.135623157,
-0.6573143005,
0.3074574471,
0.3077650666,
0.5169745684,
0.2780840397,
0.3501937985,
0.5350974798,
-0.2209379822,
0.7046815157,
0.2459088713,
-1.0896867514,
0.8068755865,
-0.2418271303,
0.2895794511,
0.8923723102,
0.3702720106,
0.0394031145,
-0.0297775567,
-0.6686801314,
-0.5064103007,
0.5529543757,
0.2376426756,
-0.0177950934,
-0.1493425071,
0.5648247004,
0.2543869019,
0.2986309528,
-0.6634095311,
-0.3407751322,
-0.1213784963,
-0.3447488844,
0.0576164015,
-0.2129424214,
0.3201298416,
-0.2626524568,
0.7059585452,
-0.7315944433,
0.3990588486,
0.1809906512,
-0.1483643502,
-0.139264971,
0.1507863253,
0.3759138286,
0.9190667868,
-0.2855841517,
-0.1855243593,
-0.1775280833,
-0.3811461926,
0.1767888218,
-0.4761879742,
-0.17521514,
-0.0867425799,
0.1490858644,
0.3697569966,
0.0951081142,
-0.7646181583,
0.6093297601,
-0.0493667349,
-0.0407834426,
-0.261869967,
0.5842353106,
-0.2006548792,
-0.0455026589,
-0.0295652337,
0.4878036082,
0.5763671398,
-0.3510296643,
0.6506976485,
0.1944056302,
-0.1477879584,
-0.0382000655,
0.717046082,
0.3120102882,
-0.067135945,
0.2085092962,
-0.3416797519,
-0.5655810237,
0.8150738478,
0.4261272848,
0.8933352232,
-0.1086205393,
0.2078177929,
0.3906163573,
-0.1996137798,
-0.0476751029,
0.6511384845,
-0.3458204567,
-0.6455283165,
-0.6714006662,
-0.8356420398,
-0.4388331771,
-0.111888729,
-0.8837476969,
0.3117260635,
-0.4052548707,
-0.3269010186,
-0.1598480791,
0.0165903959,
-0.5365188122,
0.4866495728,
-0.1375270337,
1.0185064077,
-0.5464140773,
1.1216282845,
0.5877426267,
-0.3801054657,
-0.9443025589,
-0.0854898021,
-0.3393288553,
-0.6805303097,
0.6092416048,
0.2305153161,
-0.5439140201,
0.1023882702,
-0.6958987713,
-0.8203126192,
0.3815036118,
0.7097938061,
-0.5182008743,
0.2613677084,
-0.037195906,
0.3522825241,
-0.4886069,
0.1010786593,
0.7703437805,
0.1784877479,
-0.1494524032,
-0.8056522608,
-0.4007843435,
-0.303560555,
-0.1544038504,
0.4342374206,
-0.5245555043,
0.3852535188,
-0.3966630399,
0.0583995879,
-0.302877754,
0.2752722502,
-0.0852180794,
0.3154150844,
0.364967227,
0.5321854353,
0.3688358963,
0.1324039847,
1.0736925602,
-0.790928483,
0.7730752826,
0.7999444604,
-0.0763823837,
0.6851551533,
0.3209446073,
-0.2047577202,
0.4090246856,
0.6547073126,
0.2791646421,
0.7070868015,
0.0387059897,
0.0621197186,
-0.488789767,
0.3445200026,
-0.4543451071,
0.4984987676,
0.0894709304,
-0.2644039392,
-0.0798934624,
-0.2011768222,
0.0506110713,
0.2255968302,
-0.1600847691,
0.4874895215,
0.0600177385,
-0.69507128,
1.0232462883,
-0.2631647885,
0.7106995583,
-0.6346204877,
0.0188290589,
-0.3471600413,
0.4417693317,
-0.4472457767,
-0.6762847304,
0.5912253857,
-0.0479918756,
-0.3812752366,
-0.3262104094,
0.6716440916,
-0.2452130616,
-0.2572090328,
0.484844625,
0.427203536,
0.0689688101,
0.040221218,
-0.9497542977,
-0.0842447728,
0.2885909379,
-0.2123701274,
0.1438258737,
0.0499221906,
0.2725926936,
0.8662763238,
0.7593283653,
0.1029323116,
0.0909736007,
-0.0767935738,
0.893225491,
-0.5423498154,
-0.8345575333,
-0.6773144603,
0.404266715,
-0.2379176915,
-0.3756503463,
0.6046555638,
0.9223902822,
1.0556616783,
-0.4502978623,
0.8300189376,
-0.1544510275,
0.4083023965,
-0.7935695648,
0.7505246997,
-0.7028310895,
0.0799908713,
-0.3332666159,
-0.8749408126,
-0.3032823801,
0.6611642241,
-0.4737936258,
0.0843867511,
0.4910685122,
0.9554703832,
-0.3493593931,
-0.1103050336,
0.4805351198,
-0.5273088217,
0.3587169647,
0.7032994628,
0.5800827146,
-0.2141765058,
0.2403167784,
-0.5039678812,
-0.2928648293,
-0.4534493983,
-1.052516818,
-0.8259557486,
-0.3434135318,
-0.47615242,
-0.3156198859,
0.3225249648,
1.3301669359,
1.0659796,
-1.0350297689,
-0.2981912494,
-0.1307667345,
-0.1668956578,
-0.0132777188,
-0.2458821535,
0.2203629464,
-1.0225191116,
-0.2228671759,
0.4546146095,
0.2729433477,
-0.1668447554,
-0.0968460962,
-0.4226775169,
0.3490273058,
0.2682267725,
0.6308748126,
0.3206882179,
-0.0915585607,
-0.334056139,
-0.0258765984,
-0.1979606301,
0.4933091104,
1.2285453081,
-0.8121680617,
0.5826950669,
0.3733219206,
0.6751099825,
0.2473986596,
0.047848139,
0.6195182204,
-0.5543384552,
0.1393895596,
0.3712491393,
0.2988275886,
0.1825755388,
-0.6314845681,
0.7983034849,
0.3259502053,
-0.6758553982,
-0.6328167319,
0.4661125243,
-0.7450000048,
-0.2517357767,
1.0842328072,
-0.2571042478,
-0.2655596137,
-0.1283797771,
-0.1682468355,
-0.1342385709,
-0.6216212511,
0.718390584,
0.2097062021,
-0.5865046978,
0.0897931308,
-0.5779815316,
0.8980693221,
0.6013627648,
-0.7781533599,
0.0607311539,
0.8017715812,
0.5854126811,
-0.0806860104,
0.7412347794,
-0.0367101766,
0.4553049207,
-0.1226035357,
0.1839526296,
-0.1231654286,
-0.3755541742,
-0.3269488215,
0.345589608,
0.2115508616,
-0.314173162
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12494v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12494v1 | LightPAL: Lightweight Passage Retrieval for Open Domain Multi-Document Summarization | 2024-06-18T10:57:27 | 2024-06-18T10:57:27 | Masafumi Enomoto, Kunihiro Takeoka, Kosuke Akimoto, Kiril Gashteovski, Masafumi Oyamada | cs.CL | cs.CL | Open-Domain Multi-Document Summarization (ODMDS) is crucial for addressing
diverse information needs, which aims to generate a summary as answer to user's
query, synthesizing relevant content from multiple documents in a large
collection. Existing approaches that first find relevant passages and then
generate a summary using a language model are inadequate for ODMDS. This is
because open-ended queries often require additional context for the retrieved
passages to cover the topic comprehensively, making it challenging to retrieve
all relevant passages initially. While iterative retrieval methods have been
explored for multi-hop question answering (MQA), they are impractical for ODMDS
due to high latency from repeated large language model (LLM) inference for
reasoning. To address this issue, we propose LightPAL, a lightweight passage
retrieval method for ODMDS that constructs a graph representing passage
relationships using an LLM during indexing and employs random walk instead of
iterative reasoning and retrieval at inference time. Experiments on ODMDS
benchmarks show that LightPAL outperforms baseline retrievers in summary
quality while being significantly more efficient than an iterative MQA
approach. | [
-0.1297788024,
-0.9788320661,
0.6821933389,
-0.0606998987,
-0.5633066297,
0.1871559471,
-0.0256536808,
-0.4592292309,
0.2683507204,
0.499763459,
-0.1763228476,
-0.4253520668,
-0.3377078176,
-0.0007386388,
-0.2420389354,
0.9343767166,
-0.1203543469,
0.0309518855,
0.0714675784,
-0.2638888359,
0.2680282295,
0.1912228912,
-0.5293619037,
-0.2828210294,
0.5540143251,
0.4107947946,
0.7762663364,
0.0764745995,
0.4463123083,
0.179370746,
-0.310597837,
0.176613152,
-0.5069980621,
0.1658011824,
0.0260290932,
-0.1930579394,
-0.6305012703,
0.0116278902,
0.7466193438,
1.2537664175,
-0.2560980916,
0.1966882199,
-0.1254466325,
0.5792597532,
-0.8057049513,
0.0501067415,
-0.3439520597,
0.2322649211,
-0.3322541118,
-0.4126122296,
-0.414154321,
-0.3181378841,
0.2684453726,
-0.6027390361,
0.2541815639,
0.3246667981,
0.1989102662,
-0.2269715369,
-0.6549995542,
-0.1711218506,
-0.5284745097,
0.5026125908,
-0.7528117299,
0.4268405437,
-0.0061162203,
0.5539238453,
0.0935359895,
-0.9180258512,
-0.5773537755,
-0.0929479226,
-0.20924896,
0.2151445448,
0.2169588357,
0.0027445729,
0.1567867696,
0.4502046704,
-0.6445772052,
-0.3669775724,
-0.4960545599,
-0.0199831109,
0.3261107802,
0.2973513603,
-0.0797254667,
-0.3370865881,
-0.772059083,
0.0263303947,
-0.7937274575,
0.2518312335,
0.2074535489,
0.3455422819,
0.0814546943,
0.7110689878,
-0.3870299757,
0.9174966216,
-0.4027879536,
-0.6199203134,
0.1953802258,
-0.7196669579,
0.0135273654,
0.053721413,
0.9048847556,
0.4339664578,
-0.1767750829,
-0.2738027573,
-0.3161974251,
-0.6912891865,
-0.0074556014,
-0.9113860726,
0.0527222715,
0.1714974642,
-0.8867924809,
0.0432328768,
0.1343681961,
-1.0511598587,
-0.3604942858,
0.1461081952,
0.3089230061,
-0.6090745926,
-0.1845083982,
0.1016011313,
-0.4936281741,
0.2807896733,
0.9520463347,
-0.7331727147,
0.540816009,
0.489628762,
1.2065577507,
-0.2084673941,
-0.5078595281,
-0.9160041809,
0.3572025597,
-0.3037063777,
0.5963631868,
-0.4899168611,
-0.5095097423,
-0.2587842643,
-0.3123294413,
-0.1846031994,
-0.228379935,
0.4388356507,
-0.685038805,
0.1851159781,
0.0551881269,
-0.5657569766,
0.0708678812,
0.2109702229,
-0.5823111534,
0.7591261864,
0.3844201565,
-0.9089395404,
0.317127794,
-0.3330927491,
-0.5174155831,
0.2070433795,
-0.3724600375,
-0.1410623938,
-0.0120256608,
0.1594084352,
0.4550301433,
-0.4458602965,
0.0658303723,
-0.2330776006,
-0.4916045368,
-0.2330919355,
-0.2616705298,
0.7462792397,
0.3020943701,
-0.1841085255,
0.0748477578,
-0.6799129844,
-0.1822701544,
0.2900828421,
-0.4576096237,
-0.5503406525,
0.0539160781,
0.1302595139,
0.1546571851,
0.0823268965,
-0.6156336665,
0.3027015328,
-0.1788492352,
0.1290916204,
0.6257976294,
0.1065836176,
0.5302218795,
-0.1765953004,
0.6717306376,
-0.0322421975,
0.147959426,
-0.573530972,
-0.9327476621,
0.0342243612,
-0.1333527416,
0.0161125902,
0.2337215096,
-1.0743274689,
0.0060932171,
-0.3576913476,
-0.5798435807,
-0.6552991867,
0.2188940793,
0.384950608,
1.0723046064,
0.4876863658,
-0.3915681839,
0.3236825466,
-0.353308022,
-0.1631364226,
-0.060888052,
0.0056016692,
0.6388119459,
0.5604910851,
0.0683304816,
0.7774170637,
-0.8950095773,
-0.4581587613,
-0.3557367921,
0.1096886471,
0.3338280916,
0.2445491105,
0.7003317475,
-1.0073121786,
-0.4336547256,
-0.2210381031,
-0.541403234,
0.1433980316,
-0.1443194151,
-0.1926668882,
-0.0918420702,
0.5638406873,
-0.8325980902,
0.4863967597,
0.0361020677,
-0.7867100835,
0.5168856978,
-0.3665340543,
0.4464711249,
-0.8195466399,
0.5312128067,
-0.5521442294,
-0.3428369761,
-0.3246738017,
0.2398676723,
0.2994374335,
-0.3137408197,
-0.4975212514,
0.8323152661,
-0.5743870139,
-0.4687591195,
0.0954109579,
0.9157223701,
0.176021263,
0.2656930685,
0.0740111023,
0.7877243757,
0.5249036551,
-0.6625195742,
0.3904141784,
0.4358124733,
-0.2608814538,
0.6109269261,
-0.485709697,
-0.2471853942,
-0.2007805556,
0.5048840642,
-1.1090174913,
0.0608963035,
0.2305098027,
-0.2445973307,
0.1156892851,
-0.1042943373,
-0.4471271634,
-0.1807581633,
-0.8270328045,
0.6510564089,
0.1957220584,
-0.7302923203,
0.5810037255,
0.0718742013,
-0.2719350755,
-0.7027526498,
-0.2698704898,
0.1129309013,
0.285936147,
-0.7997738123,
0.3551304936,
-0.1550587565,
-0.2163621783,
0.0870392919,
-0.3564903736,
0.2348081768,
0.140861094,
-0.3919099569,
0.0839875266,
-0.3662202954,
0.0149747077,
-0.0651737973,
-0.2026366889,
-0.2712221742,
-0.220177725,
0.4467014372,
0.0763375014,
-0.4122457802,
0.3351713419,
0.6539568901,
0.403306514,
-0.404810816,
0.8524399996,
0.6500197053,
-0.0315365046,
-0.4570861459,
-0.0128476061,
-0.0981697291,
-0.3655244112,
-0.1535838097,
-0.5044641495,
-0.7939153314,
0.4070801735,
-0.1195983738,
0.0845510289,
0.3422088325,
0.1161946952,
0.029329475,
0.8287083507,
0.5469874144,
0.050437998,
0.492878288,
-0.1356138289,
0.1009250656,
-1.0742797852,
-0.4117524028,
-0.5645906329,
-0.1509279907,
-0.1708201468,
-0.5861545801,
0.6747127771,
0.3751341999,
0.1635477096,
-0.0514903516,
-0.0738229081,
0.265271306,
0.5745256543,
-0.0054869945,
0.9072135687,
-0.2666359842,
-0.4093469381,
0.3349740803,
-0.5645483136,
-0.3796804845,
1.1038095951,
-0.2585513592,
1.2135901451,
0.6992784142,
0.6688331962,
-0.0148166725,
0.0930333957,
-0.6226614118,
0.701151669,
0.1504013985,
-0.3498858809,
-0.407576859,
-0.8935343623,
-0.9971357584,
0.7863249779,
-0.0410297886,
-0.9105567932,
-0.0317165032,
-0.0680835247,
-0.2553279102,
0.4643496871,
-0.567645669,
0.8728461266,
-0.0639824271,
-0.2553555965,
-0.2257019877,
-1.004472971,
0.6996745467,
-0.0072148987,
0.1607248336,
-0.0259100925,
-0.5881624222,
0.603721559,
-0.8495091796,
0.3255414367,
-0.2178105265,
-0.2922094464,
0.1556540877,
-0.0439387448,
0.4010384679,
0.3579445183,
-0.1235043183,
-0.3509190977,
-0.1868607104,
-0.5436780453,
-0.6652308702,
0.5067943335,
-0.4443726838,
-0.3681617379,
-0.4338071942,
-0.0577091053,
-0.2055391073,
0.6137300134,
0.2097312361,
0.5246308446,
-0.2248243093,
0.129806608,
0.6860815287,
-0.2035161704,
0.7257761359,
0.7574209571,
-0.5278471708,
-0.4604929388,
0.5244039297,
-0.0006926715,
0.5142463446,
0.5321861506,
0.3112279773,
-0.2384847999,
-0.6419116855,
-0.8434870243,
0.2906840444,
-0.8903668523,
-0.2161429077,
-0.7194947004,
0.1419557184,
-0.5620082617,
-0.2390971631,
-0.2308674902,
-0.7265617847,
0.0325889736,
-0.0047179107,
0.3151266277,
0.5790612102,
0.2933875322,
0.1073350832,
-0.8585482836,
1.0069152117,
0.2106562406,
0.6946956515,
0.1474609524,
-0.3291569352,
-0.0985937864,
-0.4493691325,
-0.1217036918,
-0.9933856726,
0.0439626984,
0.4324707985,
0.6645501852,
0.6261336207,
0.3820107281,
0.4759503603,
-0.6609831452,
0.8740895987,
0.3412267864,
-0.7455143929,
0.7280489206,
-0.243841514,
0.3375118375,
0.4845154881,
0.4888530672,
-0.5662700534,
-0.3344765604,
-0.6538672447,
-1.2261823416,
0.9034429193,
0.3036256433,
-0.3120700121,
0.1633531898,
0.3412580788,
0.2678664327,
0.5756329894,
-0.4338262081,
-0.5219486952,
-0.0975415334,
0.0787055939,
-0.3799381554,
0.0680630282,
-0.1158851907,
-0.0051633487,
0.5861458778,
-0.561006546,
0.2276196331,
0.4314385355,
-0.2119642496,
-0.2902755141,
0.2295722812,
0.4940273166,
0.8529056311,
-0.630895853,
0.396260798,
-0.2763491869,
-0.6525412798,
-0.0713425875,
0.4103045166,
-0.4410526752,
0.2472030371,
0.6831905246,
0.4419246018,
0.1900507659,
-0.9580513835,
0.9684527516,
-0.2321664393,
0.1343253702,
0.1349094957,
0.0690982863,
0.0658112988,
0.2964883447,
0.6363920569,
0.2058146447,
0.4460330307,
-0.7336220145,
0.2021953911,
0.4085063338,
-0.213087827,
0.0111322273,
0.9601938128,
0.1552540809,
-0.121879667,
0.4616982341,
-0.2501626015,
-0.0492968708,
0.3727045655,
0.3207120299,
0.6374564767,
0.0069428422,
0.1994821578,
0.0668780431,
0.2571935654,
0.0113518918,
0.6322564483,
-0.599008739,
-0.3358415663,
-0.3103886843,
-0.4998224378,
-0.6860023141,
-0.4684031606,
-0.4004555345,
0.10149692,
-0.4243758321,
0.2182076275,
-0.0573890768,
-0.1112092212,
-0.2481254488,
0.1061511859,
-0.0855145231,
1.1557558775,
-0.3990119398,
0.5263033509,
0.4475533962,
-0.7114195228,
-0.5815824866,
0.069081448,
0.0140637457,
-0.5074569583,
0.2029053271,
-0.0559833199,
-0.4578740597,
-0.018287275,
-0.3135073483,
-0.548037529,
1.4816668034,
0.366145879,
-0.0859109312,
0.0603191704,
-0.2064476758,
0.3546687961,
-0.2313492,
0.7796215415,
0.2242127359,
0.1914328784,
0.3194409311,
-0.8497033715,
0.2370399535,
-0.2299746573,
-0.3627803028,
0.3599859476,
-1.0067435503,
1.1578102112,
-0.566675961,
0.09775424,
0.0311868638,
0.3189719319,
0.2509026229,
0.4317411184,
0.3307623267,
0.3862586021,
1.0198762417,
0.1749781519,
1.2219194174,
-0.0712353215,
0.255661279,
1.136277914,
-0.2916921079,
1.0155149698,
0.4569559395,
-0.0919789895,
0.0828643739,
0.4491843283,
0.4810130298,
0.7150439024,
-0.1312473714,
-0.3985951245,
-0.0047663874,
0.1072506234,
-0.6009182334,
0.1090492755,
0.0896364599,
-0.3599870205,
-0.6246857047,
-0.1702482402,
-0.0632350221,
-0.2240584195,
-0.4183377028,
0.7473779321,
0.3246871829,
-0.6048079133,
0.3454748392,
0.1572265625,
0.4654198289,
-0.7322448492,
-0.0954838321,
-0.5262975097,
0.1327731907,
-0.1225441247,
-0.7978509068,
-0.1135335118,
-0.1311823577,
0.0823774636,
-0.5550515056,
0.6711540222,
-0.5162405372,
-0.218848452,
0.5135875344,
1.0013464689,
0.09949819,
0.099660717,
-0.5410555601,
-0.5331045389,
-0.2360212058,
-0.6617771387,
0.3595422804,
0.7853142023,
0.028682569,
0.7685383558,
0.3488577306,
0.1909205467,
0.1062164605,
0.3172216117,
0.9965776801,
-0.8590069413,
-0.6650542617,
-0.6582330465,
0.2909237146,
-0.159034878,
-0.5360178947,
0.8803876042,
0.8388772607,
0.6303624511,
0.0174925867,
0.5352517366,
-0.0946983695,
0.5880888104,
-0.8453266025,
0.6820975542,
-0.8066505194,
0.4588814676,
-0.7522161007,
-1.0434045792,
-0.1276923269,
0.5305714011,
0.2137468755,
0.0661218986,
0.899766624,
0.3869175315,
-0.4539220035,
0.0293840691,
0.1835118979,
-0.0253577642,
0.3891430497,
0.4779009819,
0.6907606721,
-0.4093854129,
0.8577986956,
-0.0197255574,
-0.1797004193,
-0.3597466946,
-0.820355773,
-0.7166202068,
-0.3418757021,
-0.2440296263,
-0.185242638,
-0.2989367545,
0.7214512825,
0.4390244186,
-0.4861921966,
-0.1680276096,
0.1188890859,
0.6288673878,
-0.3023663461,
-0.2106661499,
0.523365438,
-0.5026245117,
-0.4613354206,
0.5876728296,
0.4438645542,
-0.0840465873,
-0.2244192809,
-0.2198691219,
-0.4176551998,
-0.1513727754,
0.4975588322,
-0.0074685342,
-0.3444626927,
0.0060104309,
-0.1614102423,
-0.1578421295,
0.1439162195,
1.0346810818,
-0.9167545438,
0.6099273562,
0.7025374174,
0.446507901,
0.8253225088,
0.0281176101,
0.4584971368,
-0.8527950644,
0.0733884498,
0.3652150333,
0.5432699323,
0.1299256831,
-0.0632638335,
0.728951633,
0.5582998395,
-0.157819286,
-0.5058580637,
0.1070064306,
-0.9751996398,
-0.5860483646,
0.8298173547,
-0.2725110352,
-0.3069808185,
-0.2449019104,
-0.3446980417,
-0.146612823,
-0.7343478799,
0.2797586024,
0.2592819333,
-0.4219879806,
-0.3761233091,
-0.6013860703,
0.5547270179,
0.0631205812,
-0.8069041967,
0.0577617064,
0.7188545465,
-0.0440723076,
0.3509706855,
1.393794775,
0.0549750142,
0.3359566629,
0.2809158266,
-0.3447133005,
0.1202847064,
-0.2591419518,
-0.0756423771,
0.705947578,
0.039480228,
0.1452567875
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12480v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12480v1 | The Power of LLM-Generated Synthetic Data for Stance Detection in Online Political Discussions | 2024-06-18T10:36:21 | 2024-06-18T10:36:21 | Stefan Sylvius Wagner, Maike Behrendt, Marc Ziegele, Stefan Harmeling | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Stance detection holds great potential for enhancing the quality of online
political discussions, as it has shown to be useful for summarizing
discussions, detecting misinformation, and evaluating opinion distributions.
Usually, transformer-based models are used directly for stance detection, which
require large amounts of data. However, the broad range of debate questions in
online political discussion creates a variety of possible scenarios that the
model is faced with and thus makes data acquisition for model training
difficult. In this work, we show how to leverage LLM-generated synthetic data
to train and improve stance detection agents for online political
discussions:(i) We generate synthetic data for specific debate questions by
prompting a Mistral-7B model and show that fine-tuning with the generated
synthetic data can substantially improve the performance of stance detection.
(ii) We examine the impact of combining synthetic data with the most
informative samples from an unlabelled dataset. First, we use the synthetic
data to select the most informative samples, second, we combine both these
samples and the synthetic data for fine-tuning. This approach reduces labelling
effort and consistently surpasses the performance of the baseline model that is
trained with fully labeled data. Overall, we show in comprehensive experiments
that LLM-generated data greatly improves stance detection performance for
online political discussions. | [
-0.9177443385,
-0.7644960284,
0.6883178353,
-0.105203703,
-0.5909368992,
0.1382926852,
-0.2156136781,
-0.359820962,
0.5053722262,
0.4609923363,
-0.4214710891,
-0.5634939671,
-0.6488105059,
0.1578631401,
-0.4096120298,
1.0460710526,
0.3680691719,
0.2755844593,
-0.0632021576,
-0.234816581,
-0.1491657495,
-0.4931879938,
-0.4950881898,
-0.5625846386,
0.3636559844,
0.2963919938,
0.6110160351,
0.7485064864,
0.2101279348,
0.3504972458,
-0.1682584733,
0.4545737803,
-0.7008759975,
0.2185867131,
-0.2037066072,
-0.7167431116,
-0.5321118236,
0.1128036305,
0.6421986818,
0.2331098616,
-0.1421052963,
-0.1266798973,
-0.1684864312,
0.6121074557,
-0.3580358326,
0.0328107066,
-1.0995963812,
0.0687615573,
-0.2208043784,
-0.3226737976,
-0.3784776628,
-0.4832043946,
-0.2702997029,
-0.591217339,
0.4760822058,
-0.1438134462,
0.744177103,
0.1016246155,
-0.5149513483,
-0.2339446247,
-0.9034024477,
0.4609606862,
-0.7612451315,
0.3423222601,
0.1043224484,
0.3142948151,
-0.3408831954,
-0.6292715073,
-1.0430599451,
-0.0088389451,
0.0791474432,
0.2343242317,
-0.3075003028,
0.1206130609,
0.2560825944,
0.2927019596,
-0.2180040479,
-0.005023825,
-0.2999415994,
-0.236967966,
0.6590479016,
0.2550755143,
-0.0997027755,
-0.6091997027,
-0.3489332497,
-0.2300061882,
-0.6475749612,
-0.0134929316,
0.8522855639,
0.4975912571,
0.0963522419,
0.6767544746,
-0.3538084924,
0.5945888758,
0.7785079479,
0.0124751432,
-0.081633158,
-0.2683948576,
-0.0494727939,
-0.0917688981,
0.8180204034,
0.480293721,
-0.0127248513,
0.277913928,
-0.2154112607,
0.2521779239,
0.3154000938,
-0.8013386726,
-0.3058695495,
0.3124161959,
-0.4513231516,
-0.4571081996,
0.5491138101,
-0.8110406399,
-0.985650897,
-0.8273179531,
0.118687205,
-0.1024690866,
-0.3738089502,
-0.0773538202,
-0.344735086,
0.5426692367,
0.6519036889,
-0.4384032786,
0.0526523404,
0.9647253752,
0.744530201,
-0.4488304853,
0.3471929431,
-0.4881107509,
-0.1468907595,
-0.5248523355,
1.1666827202,
-0.5292913318,
-0.3282131553,
-0.0685806796,
0.0273971111,
0.2182991803,
-0.943938911,
0.2875893414,
-0.5041753054,
0.0943170041,
-0.1866345853,
-0.826028049,
0.0943128094,
0.7756066918,
-0.9015648961,
0.9193331003,
-0.2373081595,
-0.7701535821,
0.5047367215,
-0.4944287539,
-0.2248007655,
-0.1646076292,
-0.3395308256,
-0.5471968651,
0.0106322439,
0.3247242868,
0.4529225528,
0.0156065468,
0.3849673271,
-0.3790112138,
-0.1166116297,
0.637807548,
-0.2935481966,
0.5525665283,
-0.0440527499,
-0.4192035198,
0.3218311667,
-0.8129970431,
-0.2427388877,
-0.0512012057,
-0.4290114343,
-0.1607587785,
0.1483350247,
-0.1720307022,
0.1781958044,
-0.0279376116,
-0.5690121651,
0.2162778229,
-0.5817970037,
0.0326368213,
0.8554401398,
0.3091575801,
0.4590733349,
-0.3684416413,
0.5002333522,
0.0742802545,
0.0730855316,
0.2212276906,
-0.4534348249,
-0.9730041027,
-0.0737864152,
0.1167274192,
0.4675474763,
-0.7102221847,
0.2859613001,
-0.1956691891,
-0.5393916368,
-0.5223336816,
0.0964695439,
-0.0036442862,
0.2107340097,
0.323895514,
0.0936568826,
-0.5878428817,
-0.8149152398,
-0.5665313601,
-0.2237281203,
-0.0247207135,
0.1885212958,
0.3482483625,
-0.1616588384,
1.159116745,
-0.3378062844,
-0.028577039,
-0.5534062982,
0.2410928011,
-0.0115624033,
0.0815677792,
0.3274148107,
-0.8644536734,
-0.4549260736,
-0.0120240776,
-0.426338017,
-0.0675795302,
-0.399913162,
-0.3198825121,
0.1767652333,
0.3924004138,
-0.8686389923,
0.3100990057,
0.283496052,
-0.1142674759,
0.2317129821,
0.1629363447,
0.2427142262,
-1.4457651377,
-0.2334062606,
0.1329443008,
-0.5818511844,
-0.8285781145,
-0.1564335674,
-0.1107807234,
0.0385422856,
-0.7578725815,
0.4044540823,
-0.0826928839,
0.2555111051,
-0.5721931458,
0.174206838,
-0.0971108153,
0.1487389803,
0.2036705464,
0.4835602045,
0.1615946889,
-0.5209812522,
0.3363288343,
0.235892415,
-0.0142208394,
0.7059039474,
-0.4675281048,
0.5099141002,
-0.1836685538,
0.5539836287,
-1.0932979584,
-0.4683100283,
0.3789506555,
-0.4486185908,
0.3027906716,
-0.465610683,
-0.3471974134,
0.0711558983,
-0.6422953606,
0.0351546109,
0.1836973876,
-0.7003234625,
0.7023196816,
0.7922427058,
0.2570309639,
-0.4211958349,
-0.2887995839,
-0.0897042155,
-0.4567990303,
-0.357930392,
0.4381491542,
0.3128891885,
-0.5602427125,
-0.2796006799,
-0.1664435565,
0.2520045638,
-0.3812932074,
0.3973143399,
0.1231866851,
-0.0390152261,
0.086349085,
0.0386177339,
-0.1901994497,
0.2042351514,
-0.116499573,
0.6437270045,
-0.0036473207,
-0.375990361,
-0.6648413539,
0.1029335931,
0.677063942,
0.2521523535,
0.7859219313,
0.6386241913,
-0.2942959368,
-0.622618854,
-0.5306751132,
-0.380081892,
-0.5263741016,
0.0930542499,
0.1838531196,
-0.7266795039,
0.4066419303,
-0.4286314547,
0.1162825152,
0.4133118093,
0.7370749116,
-0.366758734,
1.1027286053,
0.3832588196,
-0.0158514958,
0.5083702803,
-0.3585401773,
0.103467077,
-0.4149619639,
-0.288041085,
-0.4123923779,
-0.4557794929,
-0.7303453684,
-0.6473755836,
0.4210665226,
-0.2829688787,
-0.0340887979,
0.1039613783,
-0.5140506029,
0.5164681077,
0.1125447601,
0.3294489086,
0.2983312905,
0.1146292835,
0.4122968614,
-0.1796453893,
-0.3047618866,
-0.5100932717,
1.0590898991,
0.1534411907,
0.7387526035,
-0.0822318271,
0.5786809325,
0.5282812119,
0.4033499062,
-1.1062620878,
0.7415385246,
0.0062254579,
-0.4612411559,
0.0129522895,
-0.4192454815,
-0.827296257,
0.4296143353,
-0.3920219541,
-0.0804160237,
0.0697678849,
0.434620589,
-0.0653516576,
0.5928278565,
-0.1673596948,
0.5932326913,
-0.151234895,
-0.1595660299,
-0.45019418,
-0.4733741283,
0.199869737,
0.0351388678,
0.0899014324,
-0.1458223164,
0.1416619867,
0.7722955942,
-0.3813402057,
1.1695560217,
-0.4699501693,
-0.1128865331,
0.4215719402,
0.0158640314,
0.6080477834,
0.1741151512,
-0.037246868,
0.1120155826,
-0.368296206,
0.0703210607,
-0.5913580656,
0.4437027872,
-0.8481313586,
-0.9333306551,
-0.3312640488,
-0.479555279,
-0.2563937306,
-0.2806975245,
0.2537928522,
0.1807326525,
-0.4507830739,
0.5051221251,
0.595398128,
0.0089853266,
0.0788888708,
0.3291605115,
-0.0414848328,
-0.4726086855,
0.7587807775,
0.0596889928,
0.2535534501,
0.3605927825,
0.4190713465,
-0.6477788091,
-0.3607304394,
-0.1876319647,
0.1362865716,
-0.9126579165,
-0.4777552783,
-0.547603786,
-0.161940068,
-0.0937691107,
-0.1093651503,
-0.504211545,
-0.8424032331,
-0.3153414726,
-0.3756034374,
0.5166885853,
0.9000636339,
-0.0263499394,
0.5633091331,
-0.3716783226,
0.5692362785,
0.2120381296,
-0.0246530157,
-0.4512330592,
-0.5868495703,
0.2042849064,
0.1731459051,
-0.7476887703,
-1.2037448883,
0.3680069447,
0.1669619083,
0.4967148304,
0.6146410704,
0.2666589916,
0.6190053821,
-0.0683561414,
0.7315541506,
-0.1779646277,
-0.7231859565,
0.8262789249,
-0.5466189384,
-0.1309569329,
0.2914568484,
0.4247480333,
-0.0160483681,
-0.7628873587,
-0.5725658536,
-0.6844953895,
0.7729163766,
0.2700093389,
0.3494724631,
0.0482056402,
0.3862514496,
0.291865021,
0.1758238375,
-0.7424709201,
-0.1087704748,
-0.3877325654,
0.0022822008,
0.2565442622,
0.1760398299,
-0.4032985866,
-0.5734373927,
0.5856376886,
-0.3924229145,
0.0788508356,
0.003831309,
-0.0078883925,
-0.0499695018,
0.2558194101,
0.4366881847,
0.4200972915,
0.0889266357,
0.202523917,
0.4020617008,
-0.293813169,
0.1314020455,
-0.1935571134,
-0.2062801719,
0.2268504798,
0.0054432191,
0.7599509954,
-0.2272021323,
-0.2548589408,
0.3180570304,
0.0008264633,
-0.1587310433,
-0.3943726122,
0.2695769966,
0.4024738371,
0.3790504932,
0.1204912737,
0.0971774012,
0.0335777998,
-0.6330374479,
0.339504987,
0.7728432417,
-0.0887222961,
-0.3843418956,
0.5551127791,
0.1004980206,
-0.3501655757,
0.3197425902,
-0.0156746153,
-0.7127743959,
0.8285626769,
0.6041224599,
0.4444413185,
-0.1388758421,
0.5431650877,
0.4028580785,
0.0500776134,
0.0702358186,
0.2490132451,
0.0131177101,
-0.9117205143,
0.0638416782,
-0.4662797451,
-0.6922616959,
0.4203371108,
-0.4898015857,
0.4366183281,
-0.7775046825,
-0.6679854393,
0.0591818057,
0.0526535325,
-0.4794588685,
-0.0612526834,
0.1428587437,
0.4528867304,
-0.9092325568,
0.5643676519,
0.6556780338,
0.0381866358,
-0.5164397955,
0.3150064647,
0.4064413011,
-0.4855099618,
0.2295587212,
0.1520964056,
-0.4334745705,
-0.1210920513,
-0.7503812909,
-0.3778405786,
0.9769403338,
0.7733151913,
-0.3780038357,
0.4985322952,
0.6094431281,
0.6615577936,
-0.3924977481,
0.1195977926,
0.3995366693,
0.5655074716,
0.1980030388,
-0.4004605711,
0.0075328359,
-0.159321323,
-0.2787691355,
0.2286954969,
-0.666801095,
0.8546075821,
0.2266138792,
-0.317966789,
-0.4424719214,
0.6555147767,
0.4717315435,
0.2795289457,
0.61623317,
0.2778061926,
0.7736655474,
-0.142774418,
0.8998558521,
-0.2782030404,
0.3235419989,
0.7259442806,
-0.3017805219,
0.8833384514,
0.5171681643,
0.0622472987,
0.476472348,
0.5932478905,
-0.0046921205,
-0.009328776,
0.1370584071,
-0.4138678014,
-0.6378925443,
-0.1734678298,
-0.1250119507,
0.4641753435,
0.6174423695,
-0.1122454181,
-0.2282644808,
-0.0777889937,
0.0202256013,
0.2549563944,
-0.221689418,
1.0342015028,
0.0707018301,
-0.6636939049,
0.4941074252,
0.0175162069,
0.6321769357,
-0.4028413594,
-0.231662333,
-0.3935163915,
0.3113985658,
-0.3708676398,
-1.0151680708,
0.3567925692,
0.1696348637,
-0.0399834625,
-0.288731873,
0.9536719322,
-0.3582295775,
-0.3165771067,
0.1943899095,
0.6647680402,
0.0281939004,
-0.0470378064,
-0.5668309331,
0.1055435836,
-0.1413181275,
-0.4531357884,
0.4432771504,
0.3118365407,
-0.1400365382,
0.5066101551,
1.0421414375,
0.1103525013,
-0.0203544665,
0.1296687424,
1.249917388,
-0.3738034964,
-0.4332716167,
-0.9047513008,
0.4907719493,
-0.3476354778,
-0.071665585,
0.6313264966,
0.5738099217,
0.9104164839,
-0.0435111038,
0.8067917824,
0.0050259116,
0.3340707123,
-0.497535944,
0.8788599372,
-0.3883993924,
0.1414230615,
0.2269033194,
-0.7835257053,
-0.2533667386,
0.8171898723,
-0.1209929511,
-0.1171207055,
0.3018124998,
1.139759779,
-0.5034951568,
0.0525393821,
0.088933669,
0.1386316717,
0.585528791,
0.0654342473,
1.1299563646,
-0.0954027399,
0.5193142891,
-0.3033418953,
0.2274320424,
-0.090289928,
-0.7962347269,
-1.2412388325,
-0.4950947165,
-0.3304776847,
-0.4913663268,
-0.2230849564,
1.207192421,
0.7008535266,
-1.0041909218,
-0.2219514102,
-0.1714859307,
0.0642972887,
0.2523354888,
-0.2715159655,
0.1712957621,
-0.0534777716,
-0.7625858784,
0.6196067333,
-0.078215085,
0.0417354517,
-0.2095638812,
-0.1654531509,
-0.0858825073,
0.4492916167,
0.4953009486,
0.2984596491,
-0.9011145234,
-0.3690748513,
0.07083112,
0.015615386,
0.4723823369,
1.0367815495,
-0.7469902039,
0.5197612643,
0.6644285321,
0.6040273309,
0.550617218,
0.6370139122,
0.6099178791,
-0.9332072735,
0.1573909521,
0.2173392177,
0.1936215609,
0.4977772236,
-0.4400272369,
0.1683464944,
0.3963033855,
-0.2793466449,
-0.7276248336,
0.2005006969,
-1.038621068,
-0.1613230705,
1.3143242598,
0.2507368028,
0.0554769486,
-0.1349424571,
-0.5267856121,
0.5359349251,
-0.4699868858,
0.8859812617,
0.48960343,
-0.5139763355,
-0.0292047318,
-0.3881524503,
0.6632889509,
0.0360496826,
-1.1098903418,
0.0880751014,
0.5901735425,
0.3157682121,
0.0364806727,
0.5411302447,
0.0519806705,
0.0100016715,
-0.1451420933,
-0.3670129478,
-0.0091633713,
-0.4085589945,
-0.356957823,
0.3384655118,
-0.3086340129,
-0.0491865128
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12474v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12474v1 | Exploring Intra and Inter-language Consistency in Embeddings with ICA | 2024-06-18T10:24:50 | 2024-06-18T10:24:50 | Rongzhi Li, Takeru Matsuda, Hitomi Yanaka | cs.CL | cs.CL, stat.ME | Word embeddings represent words as multidimensional real vectors,
facilitating data analysis and processing, but are often challenging to
interpret. Independent Component Analysis (ICA) creates clearer semantic axes
by identifying independent key features. Previous research has shown ICA's
potential to reveal universal semantic axes across languages. However, it
lacked verification of the consistency of independent components within and
across languages. We investigated the consistency of semantic axes in two ways:
both within a single language and across multiple languages. We first probed
into intra-language consistency, focusing on the reproducibility of axes by
performing ICA multiple times and clustering the outcomes. Then, we
statistically examined inter-language consistency by verifying those axes'
correspondences using statistical tests. We newly applied statistical methods
to establish a robust framework that ensures the reliability and universality
of semantic axes. | [
-0.3334112465,
-0.5559892654,
0.5477193594,
0.3973243535,
-0.2576045394,
-0.0332885832,
-0.2211781442,
-0.4925697148,
0.5636133552,
0.1810376793,
-0.3516809642,
-0.9197536111,
-0.6789650917,
0.1977123022,
-0.3611283302,
0.3904388547,
-0.4421483278,
0.5048021078,
-0.5059121847,
-0.9940042496,
-0.7859079242,
-0.2675067484,
-0.11566405,
-0.2499502897,
0.407646507,
0.382668376,
0.9296768904,
0.8586334586,
0.5859860778,
0.2823851407,
0.423268348,
0.1746590436,
-0.1756844074,
0.1342939138,
-0.3449680805,
-0.2179287821,
-0.2997123003,
-0.1398083717,
0.8009887934,
0.7515618205,
0.2224250883,
-0.1889611036,
0.3912352324,
0.2775841057,
-0.7339488864,
0.698131144,
-0.7045907974,
-0.1358897984,
-0.2765813768,
0.0526701845,
-0.1799595803,
-0.3928914368,
0.0258742422,
-0.6622694135,
-0.1459452659,
-0.2131705582,
0.9507550001,
-0.0467223935,
-0.6086223125,
-0.4255620241,
-0.6261200309,
0.6820661426,
-0.515335381,
0.7910585999,
0.5149151683,
-0.1350199729,
-0.207319811,
-0.5392278433,
-0.7511805892,
-0.2307018489,
-0.2780744135,
-0.0308788829,
-0.3299260437,
-0.0865423828,
-0.4104209244,
-0.2619194686,
-0.4340600669,
0.3904628158,
0.160326466,
-0.3037224114,
0.4704507887,
-0.1085770056,
0.7868537903,
0.0375419632,
-0.493201822,
-0.4553146064,
-0.9417259097,
-0.0817388296,
0.4852433801,
0.5323765278,
-0.1921301186,
0.8927925229,
-0.0403084494,
0.0759428218,
-0.236935541,
-0.2933502197,
0.3002674878,
-0.5255402327,
0.2784709334,
0.2069225013,
0.7869279981,
0.2612243295,
0.0320677347,
-0.5272529721,
0.1351231039,
0.451975584,
0.0825933814,
-0.3236787021,
0.0101009253,
0.227217555,
-0.4165644646,
0.1503317058,
0.2413901687,
-0.4586714506,
0.074239634,
-0.6434128284,
0.6174182892,
-0.7230238914,
-0.3104682565,
-0.0752177611,
0.1066809669,
0.3805031478,
-0.1224749312,
-0.7085672021,
0.1792077869,
1.2016983032,
0.4995557666,
-0.2111181319,
-0.9136803746,
-0.1017026976,
0.208741799,
-0.6691690087,
1.1196731329,
-0.6513518691,
0.0928054154,
0.2394543737,
0.1798803508,
-0.0203322787,
-0.3869737685,
0.3223241866,
-0.3640229404,
-0.1985747814,
-0.6542416215,
-0.8986617327,
-0.2477233112,
0.2935625613,
-0.4073795378,
0.755789876,
-0.1572633088,
-0.7610160708,
0.9501129985,
-0.0106793223,
-0.0789884627,
-0.1047343537,
-0.9050696492,
-0.5855186582,
0.1728258729,
0.1157146841,
0.3218519986,
-0.1342487782,
0.2111795843,
-0.6533122659,
-0.1652673185,
0.2197971642,
-0.3231243193,
0.6802833676,
-0.2577844858,
-0.2559076846,
-0.1262320429,
-0.7639500499,
0.2212867141,
-0.0847554952,
0.1088634804,
-0.6787831783,
0.2976847887,
-0.2693964839,
0.0515386723,
0.1569647491,
-0.9724752903,
0.2990202308,
0.0781567246,
-0.1979806274,
0.7638323903,
-0.1477422267,
0.1618859619,
0.0581096448,
0.2704102695,
0.4669297338,
-0.2583126128,
-0.004470116,
-0.6650675535,
-0.4566185772,
-0.4194966257,
0.3331334889,
0.4082081318,
-0.630392015,
0.7174370885,
-0.4307841361,
-0.4471604824,
-0.5998317003,
0.0596564114,
0.5076088905,
0.1272929758,
0.1925791651,
-0.6326779127,
-0.3997217119,
-1.0734143257,
-0.1438726485,
-0.2688213885,
0.1182585284,
-0.2490520328,
0.3700400293,
-0.4851330221,
1.0883107185,
-0.2716422081,
-0.458593905,
-0.1494287252,
0.2639374733,
-0.20550403,
0.6965451837,
0.7437881827,
-0.3415272236,
-0.6716344357,
0.2378925532,
-1.0135191679,
0.004984424,
-0.0131279239,
-0.3715274334,
-0.0693707764,
0.5114752054,
-0.3809411824,
0.9299030304,
0.6991715431,
-0.4682173431,
0.1706949025,
-0.5310431719,
0.1468169689,
-0.8037304282,
-0.2063984126,
-0.2145683765,
0.1352388412,
-0.576726377,
-0.0294175651,
0.233694911,
0.1880120039,
-0.1299063265,
0.3204607368,
-0.5360492468,
-0.2274141908,
-0.2780823112,
0.3823421001,
0.0212136544,
0.4784164727,
-0.2449941635,
0.6044563055,
0.6896229982,
-0.4470202029,
-0.0307511352,
0.4142431617,
-0.3878513873,
0.8424989581,
-0.5889934301,
0.1889846921,
-0.498899281,
-0.0563306361,
-1.2645076513,
0.1536815614,
0.1637196243,
-0.1691382825,
0.3088497818,
0.0271995701,
-0.6350537539,
0.405066371,
-0.3304634988,
0.61609447,
-0.0360357165,
-0.611977458,
0.7906830311,
0.6807076931,
0.1070796698,
-0.6095517874,
-0.4228554368,
-0.167616725,
0.0153436298,
-0.8470662832,
0.3002210259,
-0.0327623561,
-0.5897563696,
0.3105039895,
-0.0292763785,
-0.1642622948,
-0.0382627994,
0.2156228274,
0.0706403628,
-0.2633040547,
0.2460453808,
0.1241415143,
-0.4134775996,
-0.2609454393,
-0.1829967797,
0.4293035567,
-0.050692603,
-1.1003754139,
-0.8092550635,
0.6081428528,
0.3264933825,
-0.1937110126,
0.791893363,
0.5478905439,
-0.4888143837,
0.0397911705,
-0.2898831666,
-0.0870083943,
-0.3750562966,
0.2933177948,
-0.6675254703,
-0.4781588316,
0.8900970221,
0.262732774,
0.144517526,
0.6221434474,
0.3578027785,
0.1213898808,
1.1810293198,
1.0235235691,
-0.0804083869,
0.037679024,
-0.0334664732,
0.4487431049,
-0.6269940138,
-0.3877251148,
-0.8672407866,
-0.3120971322,
-0.9173086882,
-0.2967275083,
0.4153821766,
0.1656873971,
0.1791515648,
0.2877108455,
-0.1758936197,
0.5410515666,
0.4158035219,
-0.3303107917,
0.3212950528,
0.0051050163,
-0.4771659076,
-0.2648406327,
-0.4835236967,
-0.496276021,
0.8520249128,
0.2207569629,
0.831788063,
0.0374969803,
0.5702472329,
-0.0220279787,
0.2382988185,
-0.6472029686,
0.3498933017,
-0.4433007836,
-0.1844330281,
-0.1078057215,
0.0405806415,
-1.2310720682,
0.6575802565,
-0.1911912709,
-0.8040457368,
0.6720290184,
-0.1367251575,
0.3415310383,
0.4144555926,
-0.4012982547,
0.7997691631,
-0.0011383301,
0.0029612181,
-0.1185869724,
-0.4088836908,
-0.0385588445,
0.0195464268,
0.1961166263,
-0.5494833589,
0.0179076474,
0.4808068871,
-0.472673744,
0.7721610069,
0.2432272136,
-0.3590476215,
0.3912400603,
0.0685281679,
0.4658435583,
0.0942630097,
0.1772732586,
0.6200245023,
0.1880038381,
-0.4863971174,
-0.55799824,
0.8505575061,
-1.0055351257,
-0.107506156,
-0.4784010351,
-0.5431827903,
-0.3964450359,
0.1619573236,
0.0753289387,
0.6689498425,
-0.2482939959,
0.2961003482,
0.5301096439,
-0.0956115797,
0.1956399977,
0.4329984188,
-0.2390472591,
-0.2653614581,
0.9061816335,
0.533079803,
-0.0258601625,
0.476681143,
0.2661933601,
-0.1593207568,
-0.5913136005,
-0.3362544477,
0.3926590383,
-0.8148033619,
-0.1238555908,
-0.6023647785,
0.1411772519,
-0.6520775557,
-0.0837295279,
-0.6785460711,
-0.1901846677,
0.0341696963,
-0.1165369675,
0.1255277693,
1.0604507923,
-0.3343171775,
-0.0738127157,
-0.8938326836,
0.2242763937,
0.2631194592,
0.4471377134,
-0.0225621872,
0.1883298457,
-0.1459328979,
0.1273986399,
0.0440624095,
-0.8419267535,
0.0591082014,
0.143145889,
0.8505373597,
0.5138801932,
-0.0946904197,
0.6545626521,
-0.514539063,
0.6144014001,
0.0161062684,
-0.9386627674,
-0.0456197187,
-0.075713791,
0.5367962718,
0.5825454593,
0.3496280611,
-0.5666740537,
-0.6675792336,
-0.4458545446,
-0.9182966352,
0.458131969,
0.1748308539,
-0.0323012546,
-0.3080440462,
0.1200917065,
0.4360735714,
-0.2193520367,
-0.2377654463,
-0.3618558049,
-0.0481071025,
-0.5665002465,
0.1262994409,
-0.3168346882,
-0.3400428295,
0.1266697347,
0.5806381702,
-0.4431222975,
0.341750294,
-0.0199519396,
-0.1038764045,
0.1355763376,
0.0821222812,
0.4136294127,
1.2127867937,
0.1288898885,
0.4329222143,
-0.0276895538,
-0.5909273624,
0.1594620645,
-0.1071918532,
-0.2743737698,
0.2305871993,
0.6954883337,
0.5354419351,
0.2044607401,
-0.4772397876,
0.5428200364,
-0.4631618559,
0.1058007255,
-0.2796743214,
-0.6116751432,
0.0460685827,
0.0887635797,
0.0439991429,
-0.2389663756,
-0.3100711405,
-0.5713397861,
0.3851677775,
0.6131362319,
-0.4654044211,
-0.6572846174,
0.126423344,
-0.4728143811,
0.2268901616,
0.6437428594,
-0.0776345953,
-0.2889720201,
0.5212060213,
0.3997942209,
1.0471813679,
-0.0288768131,
0.260743469,
0.081659846,
0.4084601402,
0.1118604019,
0.5518007874,
0.3276754916,
-1.1052968502,
-0.1393173635,
-0.3650531769,
-0.492849946,
-0.4233919382,
-0.7431891561,
0.1810450554,
0.0010558098,
0.1260912865,
0.0636714995,
-0.2474916279,
-0.8928328156,
-0.0386124998,
-0.125407517,
0.4884852171,
-0.8985485435,
1.0802153349,
0.5614808798,
-0.419765681,
-0.9465872645,
-0.0572269596,
0.1052439138,
-0.9288916588,
0.5420663357,
-0.0572276004,
-0.2764442861,
-0.780647397,
-0.3646904528,
-1.3758635521,
1.0746566057,
0.4967901409,
-0.0993398577,
0.3126421273,
0.6521404982,
0.5978119373,
-0.5186265707,
0.0598460995,
0.3580279052,
0.3465064764,
-0.2016520947,
-0.7597586513,
-0.0403753892,
0.1266845912,
0.182528317,
0.2486189157,
-0.5326206684,
0.8023698926,
0.175079152,
-0.2915427983,
-0.0071881344,
1.1898010969,
0.1831752956,
0.2595595419,
0.377818644,
0.7685976624,
0.6893408298,
-0.2280307859,
0.8497169018,
-0.6505618095,
0.3111008108,
1.1903162003,
-0.3544090092,
0.8539729714,
0.4062406123,
-0.0513572991,
0.6303940415,
0.0195504613,
0.4287304282,
0.5009247661,
-0.2293570191,
-0.1285804212,
0.1415866464,
-0.3019800782,
-0.2525262833,
1.0350519419,
0.2333903015,
0.0084059266,
-0.4016441703,
0.3062113523,
0.4720874727,
0.0719120875,
0.0528359488,
0.8011007905,
-0.0733904392,
-0.573865056,
0.1897399724,
-0.0196389258,
0.3795868754,
-1.0188552141,
-0.0568219312,
-0.3610689342,
0.4995643198,
0.1024411991,
-0.8104149103,
0.4555598497,
-0.4941827953,
0.1060143635,
-0.0651079789,
0.5543553829,
-0.8155068755,
-0.4326521754,
0.5426434278,
0.4443259537,
-0.0145515967,
0.4464309514,
-0.3540783525,
0.5376513004,
-0.1397540271,
0.223512575,
0.5830118656,
0.8415185213,
-0.150720492,
0.4767685235,
0.3039602041,
-0.1182285324,
0.2519845665,
0.0445754118,
0.6575023532,
-0.3326077759,
-0.3136150241,
-0.6607565284,
0.4066137373,
0.1559793204,
-0.5492137671,
1.232666254,
0.3582721055,
1.1851036549,
0.1829789281,
0.4433830082,
-0.039598573,
0.2210221589,
-0.4945608377,
0.4759756327,
-0.320561707,
-0.0204946734,
-0.278170228,
-0.7665344477,
-0.3897230923,
0.4937410057,
0.2262697816,
-0.3306145668,
0.8228985071,
0.7147827148,
-0.1411522329,
0.0457989648,
0.3822055459,
0.2877375782,
0.6154081225,
-0.1795701683,
0.4061552584,
-0.4094789922,
0.1674989909,
-0.6772108078,
-0.1980953962,
0.3284361362,
-0.8558452725,
-0.3790396154,
-0.8370474577,
-0.4199797809,
-0.4513839781,
-0.1557064801,
0.9479019642,
0.4263034165,
-0.9978507757,
-0.4567831159,
0.2519456446,
0.2888643742,
-0.6380572319,
-0.1688961834,
0.8778774142,
-0.4817461073,
-0.7903974652,
0.4660949409,
0.5730119348,
-0.1709432006,
-0.6933395863,
0.2645596862,
-0.337187916,
0.258218646,
0.5689149499,
0.2449892014,
-0.6346766949,
-0.8603246212,
-0.3128099442,
-0.1556836516,
0.224406302,
0.8967909813,
-0.4876985848,
0.7945458889,
0.8814570904,
0.7627239227,
-0.1434539407,
-0.2374568433,
0.7706484795,
-0.587634027,
0.2342444211,
-0.0219171457,
0.771427989,
0.331384778,
-0.030823024,
0.3930946887,
0.0023719766,
-0.6417919993,
-0.516769886,
0.3217523396,
-0.9590776563,
-0.1691455096,
0.7975023389,
-0.5589746833,
-0.2646900713,
-0.2955701351,
-0.0021795172,
0.0959051251,
-0.032005012,
0.7077168822,
0.81105721,
-0.2444497198,
0.4248722792,
0.0300471764,
0.3110268116,
0.2502417862,
-0.7412449121,
-0.1528229266,
0.234543547,
0.3601121008,
0.4415684342,
0.5408949852,
-0.3920152187,
-0.1096385568,
0.2608527541,
-0.0665070638,
0.6078470349,
-0.5944203734,
-0.1717341989,
0.3175145984,
0.0485328659,
-0.312522769
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12471v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12471v1 | Fighting Randomness with Randomness: Mitigating Optimisation Instability of Fine-Tuning using Delayed Ensemble and Noisy Interpolation | 2024-06-18T10:20:36 | 2024-06-18T10:20:36 | Branislav Pecher, Jan Cegin, Robert Belanec, Jakub Simko, Ivan Srba, Maria Bielikova | cs.CL | cs.CL | While fine-tuning of pre-trained language models generally helps to overcome
the lack of labelled training samples, it also displays model performance
instability. This instability mainly originates from randomness in
initialisation or data shuffling. To address this, researchers either modify
the training process or augment the available samples, which typically results
in increased computational costs. We propose a new mitigation strategy, called
Delayed Ensemble with Noisy Interpolation (DENI), that leverages the strengths
of ensembling, noise regularisation and model interpolation, while retaining
computational efficiency. We compare DENI with 9 representative mitigation
strategies across 3 models, 4 tuning strategies and 7 text classification
datasets. We show that: 1) DENI outperforms the best performing mitigation
strategy (Ensemble), while using only a fraction of its cost; 2) the mitigation
strategies are beneficial for parameter-efficient fine-tuning (PEFT) methods,
outperforming full fine-tuning in specific cases; and 3) combining DENI with
data augmentation often leads to even more effective instability mitigation. | [
-0.6619558334,
-0.7612686753,
-0.0168106258,
0.2763210535,
-0.3378916979,
0.5643984079,
-0.4597539604,
-0.4781965613,
-0.0200000536,
0.3541551828,
-0.6781615019,
-0.0627156124,
-0.5825459361,
0.05794058,
-0.3438687921,
0.842682302,
0.1528750807,
0.2074205279,
-0.0551942699,
-0.0887371972,
-0.180510819,
-0.5522738695,
-1.1409486532,
-0.341409266,
0.5183517933,
0.5477146506,
0.7595806718,
0.4387576282,
0.503806591,
0.2913473547,
-0.022559531,
0.1908011585,
-0.6525197625,
0.3629959524,
0.3448663652,
-0.671830833,
-0.0900931656,
-0.0205355063,
0.9204341769,
0.5299856067,
-0.3129926324,
-0.1318660676,
0.2074003369,
0.7202398777,
-0.6896813512,
-0.0924052298,
-0.7928712368,
0.0792750716,
-0.5185692906,
-0.2734313905,
-0.314509362,
-0.2566958964,
-0.1624909639,
-0.6155380011,
0.3674578071,
0.1913487166,
0.9741103053,
0.5111402273,
0.3115683496,
0.0063309148,
-0.9924069047,
1.0220389366,
-0.8242406249,
0.3429369628,
0.3115561008,
0.249240011,
-0.2917046249,
-0.3450132012,
-0.5225723386,
0.0759369507,
0.2860928178,
0.2075638771,
-0.1427950412,
0.1745033562,
0.2666487396,
0.1088257283,
-0.4031952024,
0.8627530932,
-0.3299896717,
-0.340947628,
0.7852817774,
-0.067961067,
0.1381342113,
0.634660542,
0.009803866,
-0.5010136962,
-0.7544508576,
0.1407524943,
1.1997516155,
0.4056138992,
0.0329710431,
0.387254715,
-0.2397737354,
0.6329936981,
0.3086653054,
-0.0511901714,
0.2368080914,
-0.2434008121,
-0.0049299616,
0.2722175121,
0.5810360312,
0.2277938575,
0.4590883255,
-0.3091309369,
-0.4925430715,
0.1451259553,
0.1621922702,
-0.8023231626,
-0.192475915,
0.4417821765,
-0.3522917032,
-0.8440429568,
-0.2495425642,
-0.9224633574,
0.0107402569,
-0.223696664,
0.2628202438,
-0.3312180936,
-0.1661145687,
0.0245504435,
-0.116335392,
-0.1966017485,
0.3245100975,
-1.2090631723,
0.5263600349,
0.6372270584,
0.6441494823,
-0.1086800992,
-0.2841114402,
-0.4402359128,
0.0012803685,
-0.5908429623,
0.7806959748,
-0.6899251938,
-0.4784749448,
-0.2158504725,
-0.2462720871,
-0.1484288275,
-0.5725925565,
0.4080367684,
-0.3757834136,
0.194767952,
0.0991724208,
-0.3573040664,
0.1820655912,
0.0902603641,
-0.7202073336,
1.2074929476,
-0.0202528443,
-0.7899368405,
0.6209521294,
-0.3995710909,
-0.2884009182,
-0.1167377383,
-0.2389787287,
-0.7740692496,
0.1146923453,
0.2127072364,
0.3969958425,
-0.1329019517,
0.1848610938,
-0.3856938481,
-0.7045497298,
-0.0712549686,
-0.5298582315,
0.362837255,
0.6673244834,
-0.1064223647,
0.1075176597,
-0.9848685265,
0.2111614197,
-0.057550706,
-0.3182509542,
-0.4465076327,
0.185485065,
-0.0987048894,
0.0626699626,
-0.0502061583,
-0.3533853889,
0.2457628399,
-0.7343502045,
0.5885125399,
0.8536108136,
0.0562382601,
0.5996730328,
-0.7421540022,
0.4045060277,
0.339112401,
0.0940462425,
0.1878282726,
-0.4468156397,
-0.5225219727,
-0.1235588938,
0.5722872615,
0.5201812387,
-0.7064058781,
-0.0347828567,
-0.2705665231,
-0.6737775207,
-0.7161768079,
0.0261666682,
0.3666921556,
0.116542466,
0.0991713479,
-0.4340783954,
-0.5203917027,
-0.6326571703,
-0.4495617449,
-0.003557612,
0.0591655895,
0.0493649319,
0.0640975162,
-0.1727963686,
0.5788827538,
0.0203033946,
-0.0252458546,
-0.2026689947,
0.6289070845,
0.1386596411,
0.8089185357,
0.631908834,
-0.7830269337,
-0.2807737589,
-0.1201507524,
-0.0707038417,
-0.1388132721,
-0.2389222533,
0.1291134655,
0.469895035,
0.5500848293,
-0.2619809508,
0.2677721679,
0.3553965986,
0.2549514472,
0.4346387684,
-0.2001322955,
0.2011586428,
-0.7394552231,
-0.1841300875,
-0.1894925237,
0.1551113278,
-0.5559314489,
-0.0025355658,
-0.1678539515,
-0.1756191552,
-0.2525112033,
0.4236886203,
-0.3884845078,
0.4501881301,
-0.0509981029,
0.0020222145,
-0.366927743,
0.2881619334,
-0.037192136,
0.8898794055,
0.5212157965,
-0.6408509612,
-0.3332625329,
-0.2818049192,
-0.485634774,
-0.0132229095,
-0.5390249491,
0.1466826499,
-0.4404318929,
-0.1824618429,
-0.7590354681,
-0.2110604346,
0.1449564695,
-0.3865957856,
0.6993016601,
-0.2001547515,
-0.5857155919,
-0.4794062078,
-0.3657312095,
0.4588596225,
0.524554193,
-0.2797223032,
0.1815987378,
0.3804679215,
-0.1581395417,
-0.7843058109,
-0.5691922307,
-0.2550626397,
-0.3295105994,
-0.5280048251,
0.4370569885,
-0.3413897455,
-0.3976996243,
-0.0881660879,
-0.1912148297,
-0.2428813428,
0.371881932,
0.1191847399,
-0.2035798579,
-0.0358372852,
0.1034242064,
0.2558975518,
-0.1989687532,
-0.2717388868,
-0.2441223264,
0.8464446068,
0.1762836874,
-0.224117443,
-0.1326245666,
0.3295029998,
0.3858781159,
-0.0280810017,
0.6947847009,
0.6330162883,
-0.3833357096,
-0.3556986451,
-0.6937820911,
-0.5070254803,
-0.4889572561,
0.2804645002,
-0.496103853,
-0.9531706572,
0.6567958593,
-0.1443502754,
0.2633343041,
0.1780443937,
0.5199109912,
-0.1478602737,
1.1918485165,
0.7737541795,
-0.2579966784,
0.6326749325,
-0.1019183919,
0.3632100523,
-0.1953025162,
0.0911996514,
-0.7995607257,
-0.5721306205,
-0.8939452171,
-0.2461965829,
0.0881836712,
0.3017301559,
-0.2090847939,
0.0765436664,
-0.631154716,
0.6062723994,
0.6542308927,
-0.055558566,
0.2115317583,
0.402751714,
-0.1098317429,
-0.1488660425,
-1.0707333088,
-0.3443067372,
1.0764985085,
0.2772682309,
0.9789615273,
-0.1663755476,
1.0496042967,
-0.0691161975,
-0.0031171574,
-0.2834374607,
0.3599718809,
-0.140376702,
-0.3952865303,
-0.6109536886,
-0.5461912751,
-1.0601186752,
0.163986668,
-0.456389755,
-0.7844816446,
0.529764533,
0.1970591992,
-0.5585380793,
0.4386655092,
-0.6213888526,
0.4852981567,
0.1056279913,
-0.2699457705,
-0.3918159008,
-0.6533082128,
0.30335024,
-0.2003846169,
0.4834575057,
-0.0545597188,
0.2176614702,
0.8833026886,
-0.3430239856,
0.6978759766,
0.0678633973,
0.1129651666,
0.3379122019,
-0.0412571393,
0.6927611232,
0.058006309,
-0.1661012173,
0.2708036304,
0.1634452641,
-0.5640730262,
-0.6395133138,
0.7842287421,
-0.9369371533,
-0.4456956685,
-0.3271944523,
-0.4501156807,
-0.1471618712,
0.2221402526,
0.6126238108,
0.280166328,
-0.0625254139,
0.1197104156,
0.8531196713,
0.1115647629,
0.7518657446,
0.3902447224,
-0.0237499513,
-0.3289315701,
0.9357752204,
0.5969054699,
0.4833270013,
0.2714746892,
0.0970615447,
0.2608002424,
-0.9556678534,
-0.192960605,
-0.159064889,
-0.2949942648,
-0.1136553064,
-0.7222960591,
-0.4194220006,
-0.5090875626,
-0.0854541287,
-0.4568679333,
-0.7418538332,
-0.1656602025,
0.0170927122,
0.455604881,
0.3767890334,
-0.3799082935,
0.6123535037,
-0.6789550185,
0.0100526083,
-0.0123601407,
0.4537441134,
-0.0243973155,
-0.2613354027,
-0.2033025026,
0.1293317527,
-0.2063192874,
-0.5256242156,
0.5213546157,
0.2293583602,
0.6422826648,
0.4537758529,
0.1379983276,
0.8025337458,
-0.4419749677,
0.470143348,
-0.0043380195,
-0.4621395469,
0.4441093206,
-0.300057441,
0.0945001468,
0.7615391016,
0.1838229746,
-0.0103486953,
-0.7086302638,
-0.7851656079,
-1.0522434711,
0.5682554841,
0.2773902118,
-0.0344809443,
0.1282701343,
0.3234136105,
-0.072394304,
0.4737679958,
-0.5059392452,
-0.17281124,
0.0158142578,
-0.0916316733,
-0.1369584054,
-0.3983663023,
-0.2496462017,
-0.2896918654,
0.8109919429,
0.0466828421,
0.0754202232,
0.0715307444,
0.0534907617,
-0.5959572792,
0.2577699721,
0.5680729747,
0.1997833103,
-0.3539457917,
-0.1397600174,
0.0449315347,
-0.7971884608,
0.1022738442,
0.1884238124,
-0.5446752906,
-0.1106731296,
0.0310443267,
0.7368776798,
0.4801938534,
-0.6506980062,
0.1086676717,
-0.1312054843,
-0.1847590804,
-0.0078052483,
0.2718960047,
-0.3199434876,
0.0224299002,
0.1435000747,
0.5940849185,
-0.0341383405,
-0.186973244,
0.2565217018,
0.4746475518,
-0.3225577176,
-0.1833679527,
0.6964130402,
-0.1229306683,
-0.339371711,
0.5200572014,
-0.1421192884,
-0.0748902187,
0.7386713624,
0.5346567035,
0.7661417723,
-0.2837030292,
0.0876478031,
0.2868263125,
0.722507298,
-0.3636870086,
0.4768303931,
0.1231514961,
-0.8183484674,
-0.3681823015,
-0.660423398,
-0.4879707694,
0.0116408942,
-0.6064379215,
0.4070234597,
-0.7182542086,
-0.0247723218,
-0.2463592291,
0.1771898419,
-0.6362740397,
0.1527879983,
-0.1968260258,
0.8838409781,
-0.716153264,
0.9683318734,
0.3902797699,
-0.3591543138,
-0.8286830783,
-0.0188374072,
-0.150419727,
-0.592328012,
0.339040488,
0.0237803981,
0.0857648998,
0.3276802897,
-0.7511031628,
-1.0786070824,
0.8562295437,
0.2289131433,
-1.2125259638,
0.2320677489,
-0.0519132949,
0.460133642,
-0.1208054796,
0.0961719006,
0.550065279,
0.5250576138,
-0.0367791727,
-0.6384968758,
-0.283475101,
-0.3094236553,
-0.2146387994,
0.3353997469,
-0.7273395658,
0.6890569925,
-0.1605259627,
-0.4161957502,
0.2946187258,
0.4175669253,
0.1875512749,
0.3655373752,
0.5559834838,
1.0164963007,
0.9302002192,
-0.27185449,
0.9150913358,
-0.5020496845,
0.0089595029,
1.0852532387,
-0.1179854572,
0.8099460006,
0.6156110764,
-0.1811953038,
0.0183628444,
0.8436281681,
-0.1392240375,
0.7281588912,
0.3652337193,
-0.2722788751,
-0.0792548209,
0.2940239906,
-0.4256453514,
0.0666736737,
0.2263598591,
0.0693061277,
-0.3575210869,
0.163277477,
-0.0259477459,
0.2117417008,
-0.2257170975,
0.6823143959,
-0.1366740167,
-0.4732985497,
0.6187098026,
-0.1018699184,
0.7270823717,
-0.5509418845,
0.1309355348,
-0.110565722,
0.0520158522,
-0.1086956561,
-0.2727835774,
0.3062092662,
-0.3988204598,
-0.3602113724,
-0.1832431853,
0.588898778,
-0.5974049568,
-0.6193797588,
0.0219013579,
0.3375612199,
0.1172066852,
0.1459288001,
-0.5003807545,
0.1613148451,
-0.2657836378,
-0.2243918628,
0.8261870742,
0.5168762207,
-0.3877721429,
0.8333348632,
0.8359614611,
0.2430559397,
0.2522954047,
0.3488408029,
1.0619907379,
-0.3153552413,
-0.3058020473,
-0.794323802,
0.2780883908,
-0.1173293293,
-0.3720621169,
0.729414463,
0.4835112989,
0.9931365252,
-0.0328976102,
0.6763182282,
0.2448050082,
0.4104563594,
-0.5983473659,
0.9788421988,
-0.3033238649,
0.5014676452,
-0.360296607,
-0.8148043156,
-0.6058011055,
0.3504300416,
-0.1200101078,
-0.1264339238,
0.2574736774,
1.0122191906,
0.0983905569,
-0.0357847884,
0.3564474285,
0.3373376131,
0.0968328267,
0.1707785428,
0.7603389025,
-0.4554745555,
0.2939240038,
-0.7877419591,
-0.1761656702,
0.0591337532,
-0.853943944,
-0.7421489358,
-0.324972719,
-0.4391571283,
-0.3418984115,
0.4723899066,
0.6749626398,
0.7913584709,
-1.0960671902,
-0.0765879005,
-0.3878508806,
0.2906146646,
-0.5161786079,
-0.199242115,
0.1119054854,
-0.800932765,
-0.7775534391,
0.4392791092,
0.2604371607,
0.333979845,
-0.0947478935,
0.1165138558,
-0.0163394827,
0.3118971288,
0.1209116653,
0.3939284384,
-0.4526725709,
-0.1286987662,
-0.2141527981,
0.156068176,
0.0446344353,
0.7020522356,
-0.7655792236,
0.5045992732,
0.3022151291,
0.569996655,
0.3288682997,
-0.0545450039,
0.5921499133,
-0.8112709522,
0.7169403434,
0.5298550725,
0.1690036505,
-0.0253522582,
-0.4722561836,
0.6454046369,
0.1924088597,
-0.7210326195,
-1.2978880405,
0.0074344832,
-0.6778952479,
-0.232376188,
0.7034652829,
0.1650021672,
-0.1839782745,
-0.1129896119,
-0.1395793706,
0.1429689378,
-0.4471724629,
1.16583848,
0.8944921494,
0.138218686,
-0.2221368402,
-0.4821599722,
0.7320181727,
0.6063594818,
-0.3266511559,
-0.2499698997,
-0.0372411013,
0.0027392253,
0.1116017327,
0.6158605218,
-0.2510015965,
-0.0739105642,
0.0797550827,
-0.1576177329,
0.1377329975,
-0.5032209158,
-0.3794046938,
0.1066653654,
0.023309797,
-0.0689079687
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12468v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12468v1 | Adaptive Token Biaser: Knowledge Editing via Biasing Key Entities | 2024-06-18T10:18:06 | 2024-06-18T10:18:06 | Baolong Bi, Shenghua Liu, Yiwei Wang, Lingrui Mei, Hongcheng Gao, Yilong Xu, Xueqi Cheng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The parametric knowledge memorized by large language models (LLMs) becomes
outdated quickly. In-context editing (ICE) is currently the most effective
method for updating the knowledge of LLMs. Recent advancements involve
enhancing ICE by modifying the decoding strategy, obviating the need for
altering internal model structures or adjusting external prompts. However, this
enhancement operates across the entire sequence generation, encompassing a
plethora of non-critical tokens. In this work, we introduce $\textbf{A}$daptive
$\textbf{T}$oken $\textbf{Bias}$er ($\textbf{ATBias}$), a new decoding
technique designed to enhance ICE. It focuses on the tokens that are mostly
related to knowledge during decoding, biasing their logits by matching key
entities related to new and parametric knowledge. Experimental results show
that ATBias significantly enhances ICE performance, achieving up to a 32.3%
improvement over state-of-the-art ICE methods while incurring only half the
latency. ATBias not only improves the knowledge editing capabilities of ICE but
can also be widely applied to LLMs with negligible cost. | [
-0.1986968368,
-0.6372849941,
0.3842023611,
0.0448171645,
-0.3511379063,
0.4185492694,
-0.2573580444,
-0.2575191259,
0.3939536214,
0.4594894648,
-0.1054604426,
-0.6663694978,
-0.6247490644,
0.0453176647,
-0.3100992143,
0.9601932168,
-0.2061974257,
0.2846558988,
-0.1069929749,
-0.4172562659,
-0.5721206069,
-0.3731415272,
-0.9500625134,
-0.1254853159,
0.0255721807,
0.4555904865,
0.7229924202,
0.9058364034,
0.1340882033,
0.229711473,
-0.5427090526,
0.3750286102,
-0.1881884634,
0.2329580784,
-0.3236470819,
-0.621462822,
-0.8429064751,
-0.441221416,
0.7588846087,
0.3948020637,
-0.0360574648,
0.1902391613,
-0.0844907314,
0.680559814,
-0.7984415293,
0.0359336883,
-0.9596877694,
-0.0867286995,
-0.387412101,
-0.1430924088,
-0.4532627463,
-0.1854834706,
0.0781461,
-0.8053089976,
0.1045829952,
0.2977815568,
0.4535546899,
0.4654202163,
-0.1767113805,
-0.3655491471,
-0.2231870145,
0.7856817842,
-0.7914699316,
0.6225267053,
0.2510898411,
-0.1105386391,
-0.3279889226,
-0.5608292818,
-0.4979178905,
0.2344934195,
0.1039051861,
-0.2316009253,
-0.3080159724,
0.2544705868,
0.2712365091,
0.0954539254,
0.2726504505,
-0.0535763577,
-0.1321937442,
-0.4663800299,
0.2402513176,
0.1412681043,
0.3641823828,
-0.2940968275,
-0.0931192264,
0.0736187547,
-0.7213195562,
-0.0787502527,
0.1963417828,
-0.0444293618,
0.0135435117,
0.3891051412,
-0.0537093058,
0.7821831703,
0.5047614574,
-0.2368320078,
0.294100672,
-0.068190001,
-0.2748020589,
0.2320810705,
0.4533086121,
0.5907779336,
-0.0315271281,
-0.341337055,
-0.3586353362,
-0.3104659021,
0.0383506678,
-0.5433576703,
-0.2294923663,
0.0457666516,
-0.6237385869,
-0.3739656508,
-0.1008368731,
-1.0244646072,
-0.5922887921,
-0.1504480392,
0.126570791,
-0.5813709497,
0.0509718843,
0.1336041391,
-0.3632669151,
-0.1390309781,
0.3411268592,
-0.6440271735,
0.2980828583,
0.4145623147,
0.9640986323,
-0.1092940718,
-0.2134011686,
-0.7365594506,
0.3908003867,
-0.4177708924,
0.8403609395,
-0.838744998,
-0.3652040064,
-0.0119714681,
-0.5262111425,
0.128762126,
-0.5961952806,
0.6483021379,
-1.0766819715,
-0.0868380666,
-0.6325460672,
-0.6561152935,
-0.0072700414,
0.0111299027,
-0.6354648471,
0.8605322838,
-0.0328936204,
-0.9493426681,
0.8590474129,
-1.1386122704,
-0.5212491751,
-0.259647131,
-0.0221091453,
-0.2660564184,
0.2623242438,
0.8386290669,
0.1279511899,
-0.2520488501,
0.2401074171,
-0.2764877975,
-0.2766508162,
0.3841704726,
-0.4027176201,
0.7148797512,
0.2820582092,
-0.4349616766,
0.3572789729,
-1.0034998655,
-0.2232811004,
-0.3806132972,
-0.5478835106,
-0.49900949,
0.2254842967,
-0.1194884777,
-0.0722588822,
-0.0125057148,
-0.5033780932,
0.2190092057,
-0.2816880345,
0.6969577074,
1.1340112686,
0.2121815383,
0.9009403586,
-0.1986471713,
0.4256576896,
0.3195804656,
0.0369905941,
-0.1921293885,
-0.2009868026,
-1.0343897343,
-0.6403719187,
0.4837399721,
0.4949244857,
-1.1323227882,
0.2383649647,
-0.2987968624,
-0.13127096,
-0.9033232927,
0.3446119726,
0.3370408714,
0.6803913713,
0.5788579583,
-0.2827647626,
-0.7665675282,
-0.6172690988,
-0.6556817293,
-0.1639728546,
-0.1732114404,
0.3681222796,
0.1148327217,
-0.1909776628,
1.1727967262,
-0.4601900578,
-0.3819247186,
0.0121612707,
-0.0375583731,
0.0211486593,
0.4453998208,
0.7027879953,
-0.3309395313,
-0.5612608194,
-0.3564343452,
-0.748057425,
-0.3254011571,
0.0009187143,
-0.3580810428,
0.3458730876,
0.9367408752,
-0.4514701366,
0.3356387317,
0.1557487994,
-0.5876064897,
0.145920977,
-0.1099728048,
0.2121676654,
-1.0607292652,
-0.1299376786,
-0.2201741189,
-0.2085611224,
-0.7316251993,
-0.0950999856,
0.252435416,
0.0803713426,
-0.5564959645,
0.6290787458,
-0.7820298076,
0.2299610674,
-0.3219996095,
0.0033934787,
-0.0691066906,
0.279256314,
-0.0679435283,
0.859601438,
0.8787904382,
-0.6180819869,
0.1478420347,
0.4261381924,
-0.451356709,
0.6625678539,
-0.3147886992,
0.5374783278,
-0.4574248791,
0.5467579365,
-0.389264971,
-0.1095524728,
0.4414146245,
-0.2792670131,
0.4157545269,
-0.1505867094,
-0.3871018887,
-0.0437270664,
-0.5612881184,
0.7488694191,
0.2590111494,
-0.7360448837,
1.0486388206,
0.4696430266,
0.1088302433,
-0.9215080142,
-0.5895236731,
0.4759974778,
-0.39553684,
-0.5273570418,
0.4566560686,
0.0429149233,
-0.6025497913,
0.1430814117,
-0.1658678204,
0.0441017039,
-0.1917730272,
-0.1260578334,
0.3873766065,
-0.1733203828,
0.0674925372,
0.3981478214,
-0.047120396,
0.0107110059,
-0.7924337387,
0.2373867184,
0.2061530948,
-0.1209261715,
-0.4128468931,
0.0798084885,
0.8791438937,
-0.148344487,
0.8698973656,
0.3712683618,
-0.5275962949,
-0.0586809851,
-0.9293330908,
-0.0895739198,
-0.4760566056,
0.4675199986,
-0.4748238623,
-0.7698929906,
0.8449212313,
0.29497841,
0.1252780855,
0.2232376039,
0.3547229469,
0.238840729,
0.7976255417,
0.4587313235,
-0.7427888513,
0.832249105,
0.2018127292,
0.1346376091,
-1.1559559107,
-0.0679971948,
-0.3157038987,
-0.3134926856,
-0.2793841064,
-0.6612938643,
0.4084941149,
0.0905582458,
-0.1633010507,
-0.0095368586,
-0.1734081656,
0.6961181164,
0.4891227186,
0.4142827988,
0.2483332455,
-0.0615357906,
-0.0891105458,
-0.0102664717,
-0.9120778441,
-0.3992757201,
1.5854907036,
0.5390877128,
0.9746783972,
0.0575128496,
0.3809432089,
0.5792841911,
0.4189901054,
-0.5325751901,
0.3334349394,
0.0232125409,
-0.6497716904,
-0.3407559693,
-0.196827054,
-0.2341164649,
0.0890889093,
-0.379045248,
-0.8006446958,
0.4008191526,
0.6687488556,
-0.4508187473,
0.8336209059,
-0.6234904528,
0.3692110181,
0.20384413,
-0.5407928824,
-0.251649946,
-0.577892065,
0.0556615442,
-0.1644295305,
0.3881754875,
0.2356238514,
-0.2546098828,
1.0427470207,
-0.2794675231,
0.7223815322,
-0.5523913503,
0.0845863,
0.4296990037,
0.1696265042,
0.7945328355,
0.4958438873,
-0.4850238562,
0.181386292,
-0.4154962599,
-0.4730289876,
-0.6319243908,
0.6120393276,
-0.6461457014,
-0.7336937785,
-0.2224757969,
-0.7748523951,
-0.306378603,
0.2086527348,
0.2901413441,
0.4617713988,
-0.1105163768,
0.0039658509,
0.8129386902,
-0.2461756468,
0.3078535497,
0.4217436016,
0.1584316641,
-0.6535210013,
0.6417444944,
-0.0763128921,
0.2092986107,
0.4871911407,
-0.0352264568,
-0.1767637283,
-0.8331686854,
-0.7524083853,
0.025635004,
-1.0992692709,
-0.5284153819,
-0.8508827686,
0.1497288048,
-0.505392909,
-0.4018548429,
-0.2517264187,
-0.3613010943,
-0.4058386087,
-0.2153526396,
0.4765284657,
0.6960852742,
-0.2253581733,
0.2889893055,
-0.6817395091,
0.2488180697,
0.0350129381,
0.4998454154,
0.1603314728,
-0.7488467097,
-0.3419450223,
-0.0864738151,
-0.09986756,
-1.0244714022,
0.025864901,
0.2260554284,
0.5198330879,
0.4507424235,
0.1009329408,
0.8093035221,
-0.5477392077,
0.7045102715,
-0.0842930675,
-1.549403429,
0.2860763371,
-0.2145330906,
0.3440659344,
0.5642613769,
-0.2248089015,
-0.5445117354,
-0.5614327788,
-0.3607605398,
-0.9213585854,
1.0390460491,
0.0103408098,
0.2130148411,
-0.1295220405,
0.7390518188,
-0.059737429,
0.4030345082,
-0.4602021575,
-0.3252432048,
-0.3922289908,
-0.3322004974,
0.123773098,
-0.6483124495,
-0.0867034346,
-0.3095834255,
0.9631185532,
-0.1546909511,
0.3691244423,
0.2593699098,
-0.4039767087,
-0.3690066636,
0.2809125483,
0.5787890553,
0.7746176124,
-0.1686831415,
0.1828231514,
0.9914716482,
-0.4871234,
-0.0150313899,
-0.3021753132,
-0.5414028764,
-0.0264842845,
0.3828983307,
1.1839253902,
0.2358777076,
-0.4444048703,
0.2670359612,
0.010406361,
-0.0432015546,
0.0434076563,
0.0082715573,
-0.3690012395,
0.2769607306,
0.3555373251,
0.5101181269,
0.194588542,
-0.3405066133,
0.1723980457,
0.2726503611,
-0.4148834944,
-0.3215414882,
0.8403725028,
0.3288049698,
-0.3159938753,
0.614387989,
-0.0297586285,
-0.8033043742,
0.1490136087,
0.5544453859,
0.8479214907,
-0.1888450235,
-0.2209984213,
0.2108199298,
0.2212696671,
0.1235511303,
-0.0588166043,
-0.050589025,
-0.9120341539,
-0.2140445262,
-0.4640375972,
-0.1415122151,
0.1356829405,
-0.5645350814,
0.5242102742,
-0.458612293,
-0.1401728392,
-0.2838276029,
-0.6185734868,
-0.5285838842,
0.2323441654,
-0.1866299063,
1.2420797348,
-0.677991569,
0.8076162934,
0.9162147045,
0.0904826596,
-0.4919953644,
0.439670682,
0.1601814628,
-0.7281753421,
0.3568483889,
-0.382016629,
-0.0588383898,
-0.022782715,
-0.2232108265,
-1.053597331,
0.8653056026,
0.6071735024,
-0.2071058601,
-0.3125258386,
-0.1495601386,
0.3203876019,
-0.4333563447,
0.2801684737,
0.7910431623,
0.4714717865,
-0.0956713036,
-0.7316654325,
0.2272736877,
-0.1188455522,
0.0686420724,
0.1305973083,
-0.5475984812,
0.5261315107,
-0.1599511057,
0.0379561707,
-0.2251065969,
1.0311528444,
-0.0342303701,
0.0563511215,
0.7649503946,
0.3421685696,
0.8215946555,
0.1837560534,
0.5957608819,
-0.618193686,
-0.0872268081,
1.0940159559,
0.1100933999,
0.5347591043,
0.8536856771,
0.1673590541,
0.4999159873,
0.3883210123,
0.3470582664,
0.705581069,
0.1596782804,
-0.3628185093,
-0.0807302371,
0.0040736576,
-0.1337826401,
0.2910962999,
0.3007621467,
-0.4645916522,
0.1119309962,
0.2098043114,
0.4216374755,
0.166731447,
-0.5086586475,
0.8116647601,
-0.1122382656,
-0.7937598228,
0.2927981019,
0.3626861572,
0.8466562033,
-0.3193888962,
0.2000827342,
-0.1237780973,
0.2960017622,
-0.2698156834,
-0.4489821196,
0.3749160469,
0.2918261886,
-0.3270046115,
-0.1043597907,
0.8744027615,
-0.2713689208,
-0.3866736591,
0.3125690818,
0.1804463267,
-0.3786253631,
-0.009975709,
-0.5142070651,
0.3237908185,
0.1981427819,
-0.2834529281,
0.0038316317,
0.3898821473,
-0.1655324697,
0.6881697774,
0.4068691432,
0.1722119749,
0.2221717685,
0.0100575602,
1.1319292784,
-0.4127401412,
-0.56746912,
-0.952317059,
0.5050880909,
-0.0780061707,
-0.2384266406,
0.5667643547,
0.5219164491,
0.9045085907,
-0.069302544,
0.9941039085,
-0.1242346168,
0.3538339436,
-0.8702348471,
0.7012904882,
-0.3317182362,
0.4379818738,
-0.5305458307,
-0.9209489822,
-0.3217909336,
0.4823958576,
-0.2437019795,
-0.1659785658,
0.6531673074,
0.7241283059,
-0.0115291327,
-0.0273126829,
-0.0654336438,
0.3002414703,
0.4631132782,
0.2644840479,
0.477727592,
-0.5027853847,
0.4027618468,
-0.0768014789,
-0.4882871509,
0.0326425843,
-0.7807477117,
-1.1612203121,
-0.4260280728,
-0.1446519047,
-0.5425270796,
0.4826592207,
1.298653245,
0.5547889471,
-1.004324913,
-0.1341527253,
-0.0285125747,
0.2722589076,
-0.0911936685,
-0.1479747891,
0.5286065936,
-0.477740705,
-0.8163008094,
0.4785384536,
0.093492955,
-0.0347044095,
0.1653394699,
-0.2289128155,
0.0564650409,
0.3752372265,
0.4159087539,
-0.0241771899,
-0.6071644425,
-0.5305095911,
0.1194055378,
0.3083190918,
0.18562904,
0.9751791358,
-0.655412674,
0.6808667779,
0.3987573683,
0.6106409431,
0.3106524348,
-0.0771672875,
0.8435268998,
-0.5816137195,
0.2624902427,
0.0404334404,
0.5463549495,
0.332575351,
-0.5055712461,
0.0862401426,
0.225067839,
-0.366987735,
-0.8364663124,
0.02980504,
-0.6045001745,
-0.0483056828,
1.137237072,
-0.0783739612,
-0.2748801112,
-0.1869867742,
-0.4369941056,
0.5537021756,
-0.8933805823,
1.1005049944,
0.9312921762,
0.0952031314,
0.1054601371,
-0.0697636977,
0.7960518599,
0.5901364684,
-0.5412006378,
0.1549080312,
0.4568550587,
0.4338655472,
-0.0484579913,
0.7135237455,
-0.1789970547,
0.2975458801,
-0.1360760182,
-0.0214348733,
-0.1569804996,
-0.3536217213,
-0.3152200878,
-0.039720308,
0.5005342364,
-0.1296581477
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12442v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12442v1 | Abstraction-of-Thought Makes Language Models Better Reasoners | 2024-06-18T09:46:44 | 2024-06-18T09:46:44 | Ruixin Hong, Hongming Zhang, Xiaoman Pan, Dong Yu, Changshui Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Abstract reasoning, the ability to reason from the abstract essence of a
problem, serves as a key to generalization in human reasoning. However,
eliciting language models to perform reasoning with abstraction remains
unexplored. This paper seeks to bridge this gap by introducing a novel
structured reasoning format called Abstraction-of-Thought (AoT). The uniqueness
of AoT lies in its explicit requirement for varying levels of abstraction
within the reasoning process. This approach could elicit language models to
first contemplate on the abstract level before incorporating concrete details,
which is overlooked by the prevailing step-by-step Chain-of-Thought (CoT)
method. To align models with the AoT format, we present AoT Collection, a
generic finetuning dataset consisting of 348k high-quality samples with AoT
reasoning processes, collected via an automated and scalable pipeline. We
finetune a wide range of language models with AoT Collection and conduct
extensive evaluations on 23 unseen tasks from the challenging benchmark
Big-Bench Hard. Experimental results indicate that models aligned to AoT
reasoning format substantially outperform those aligned to CoT in many
reasoning tasks. | [
-0.4881323278,
-0.8103280067,
0.8565919995,
-0.1375765055,
-0.1884218156,
-0.0456601642,
-0.0096997637,
-0.5481785536,
-0.4161962271,
0.3228769004,
-0.4249125421,
-0.4280540049,
-0.6379437447,
-0.0770245194,
-0.569227457,
0.8804633617,
-0.351824522,
-0.403304249,
0.0906855464,
-0.1167004257,
-0.3496963978,
-0.2620098591,
-0.8386648893,
-0.6221573353,
0.2041773498,
0.0337078907,
0.7045175433,
0.7961128354,
0.3451866508,
0.2958258092,
0.0367828272,
0.2945964038,
-0.2615320981,
-0.0091463123,
-0.4315625131,
-0.3043032587,
-0.7600954175,
0.0603304282,
0.2822637558,
0.9749848247,
-0.1886189133,
0.0116175972,
-0.0579157323,
0.8150138259,
-0.8473726511,
0.3703759611,
-0.5917617083,
-0.1209267378,
0.1363355666,
0.2004027069,
-0.4808603227,
-0.1155825257,
0.1709431708,
-0.5875932574,
-0.1880533546,
0.0345052481,
0.5976090431,
0.3034873903,
-0.1174443588,
-0.2108495086,
-0.9698967934,
0.6312592626,
-0.5349515676,
0.4117307365,
0.4491189122,
0.2280936986,
0.1307576746,
-0.6894352436,
-0.5182089806,
-0.1024591401,
-0.0446043424,
-0.0308910161,
-0.4414833486,
0.1615566909,
0.1941528767,
0.4676821232,
-0.4011002481,
-0.1360704005,
-0.2966123521,
0.1048723161,
0.4999269545,
0.1260860562,
0.2189205438,
0.0433459766,
-0.383000493,
0.1271482557,
-0.5367969871,
-0.0922353938,
-0.0002084104,
0.1758445799,
-0.1354804486,
0.3535100222,
-0.477337569,
0.8620446324,
0.1601580083,
0.3884644806,
-0.1018456295,
-0.2659322917,
-0.3936802149,
-0.0709031373,
0.6605591178,
0.0764362291,
0.4636256099,
-0.1465368718,
-0.4930306673,
0.1800594032,
0.2292894721,
-0.6621444821,
-0.6366394758,
0.6197715402,
-0.3032315969,
-0.0964981467,
-0.033239115,
-0.0565140061,
-0.1582065225,
-0.7267866731,
0.3048003912,
-0.6331002712,
-0.3981916904,
0.4848936796,
-0.0124906125,
0.0057825604,
0.5683050752,
-0.7331689,
0.5669093132,
0.8647927642,
0.6335906386,
-0.3237711787,
0.0109995268,
-0.1886865646,
-0.0146237882,
-0.4995985627,
1.2631400824,
-0.6424123049,
0.0430638567,
-0.4731405377,
-0.5293473601,
0.0372130834,
-0.4344638586,
0.4363381267,
-0.2640132606,
0.0212541595,
0.0030631453,
-0.5083703995,
-0.0688044429,
0.6459709406,
-0.6808905005,
0.8958447576,
0.2040247172,
-0.5284923315,
0.1174103171,
-0.8329532743,
-0.1522809863,
0.1063161045,
-0.550412178,
0.0328521617,
0.1838280112,
0.3628947437,
0.251163274,
-0.4100344479,
0.2810828388,
0.0194403604,
-0.226092726,
0.1048272699,
-0.5048908591,
0.7426972389,
0.5696786046,
-0.3656448424,
0.0484378859,
-0.7831797004,
0.3041279316,
0.1074527875,
-0.1943059117,
-0.4512698054,
-0.0994281098,
-0.2310108989,
0.5092762113,
-0.0514531955,
-0.4935189486,
0.2049038708,
-0.5593670607,
0.6412376165,
0.7095022202,
-0.1291514784,
0.5085911751,
-0.3915709555,
0.4615099728,
0.1155205593,
-0.1347543746,
-0.2940820754,
-0.1422514766,
-0.6211317182,
-0.2915185392,
0.2563953996,
0.3787232339,
-0.3575031459,
0.2209074944,
-0.1768192798,
-0.5763911605,
-0.660420835,
-0.2381860167,
0.6182234883,
0.3985536397,
0.358225733,
0.013838958,
-0.3959694505,
-0.840914309,
-0.4116255641,
-0.1546892524,
-0.0560137294,
0.1561128795,
0.4631641805,
0.0607770421,
0.8644495606,
-0.5026988983,
0.0954900384,
-0.2508624494,
0.36921525,
-0.0444356874,
0.5554625988,
0.0694429353,
-0.6197028756,
-0.1813353896,
0.1637372226,
-0.6620494723,
0.0932388306,
-0.0167675316,
-0.4353260994,
0.0499886721,
0.5697064996,
-0.7168956995,
0.3587822318,
0.1721863747,
-0.2473402321,
0.5775990486,
-0.0859580114,
-0.0211371928,
-0.7911753654,
0.1676418483,
-0.2212138921,
-0.2712944746,
-0.3529687226,
0.2854619026,
-0.0881927833,
-0.1462733001,
-0.4688163102,
0.7397993803,
-0.6181372404,
0.2034222037,
-0.3518660963,
0.1727693528,
0.2317508906,
0.5524581075,
0.2876999974,
0.4089138508,
0.588016808,
-0.7220540047,
0.1643487066,
0.2153036296,
-0.5572875142,
0.465985328,
-0.6979552507,
0.4380084276,
-0.2839876413,
0.2872813642,
-0.9103094339,
-0.0471593849,
0.0568826497,
-0.0879869908,
0.0112617463,
-0.1327025294,
-0.347754091,
-0.1116738617,
0.0905763581,
0.810565114,
0.3926489353,
-0.1930799037,
0.7048386335,
0.4136675894,
-0.3399200141,
-0.5635825396,
-0.5977466702,
-0.3080888093,
-0.0803625584,
-0.3284833729,
0.3389322758,
0.1569321603,
-0.6487483382,
-0.0065889205,
-0.5729745626,
-0.0958281159,
-0.0068903258,
0.0232985597,
0.1292377412,
-0.3956831992,
0.2172219604,
0.0199788585,
-0.3041141033,
0.1988577545,
-0.6109415889,
0.5649989843,
-0.4282767177,
-0.4947560132,
-0.2907694876,
0.4461902678,
0.4436581433,
-0.4485424757,
0.3560104668,
0.0497964621,
-0.5643381476,
-0.2640025318,
-0.3347321153,
-0.1176895574,
-0.3752050996,
0.2770490646,
-0.621052444,
-0.4708290696,
0.3602380157,
-0.279943496,
0.4321011901,
0.2710265219,
0.2661550045,
-0.1246222705,
1.223308444,
0.3569817543,
0.2162149996,
0.2942354679,
-0.4917169809,
0.272775352,
-0.7999108434,
-0.0785112455,
-0.4506935179,
-0.4107716978,
-0.2483478636,
-0.3835912645,
0.0637628213,
0.1694428623,
-0.483910501,
0.1762494147,
-0.6263631582,
0.8300610185,
0.022470884,
0.1505859792,
0.58947891,
-0.1294240355,
-0.1357872635,
0.4849523902,
-0.5564379096,
-0.8570318222,
0.8444454074,
0.1957200766,
0.701849103,
-0.0578590035,
0.6355971694,
0.0025588709,
0.3717138171,
-0.7779402137,
0.5573649406,
-0.1252328455,
-0.6273695827,
-0.3462778032,
-0.1281958967,
-0.9802680016,
0.4340616465,
0.1369160414,
-0.7980201244,
0.2047608793,
0.4274570346,
-0.5826238394,
0.2640926838,
-0.4551303983,
0.8419662118,
0.0499073416,
-0.1575018764,
-0.1774256378,
-0.533880055,
0.4618189633,
0.0351009704,
0.5241863132,
-0.2569760382,
0.0828385949,
0.4910657108,
-0.6268086433,
0.4818324149,
0.1173262969,
-0.3695143163,
0.586399734,
0.4475162625,
0.6487909555,
-0.3197607994,
-0.2235035598,
-0.0715817511,
-0.1516558975,
-0.3293860853,
-0.7555311322,
0.5593308806,
-0.3576419652,
-0.6534276605,
-0.2806588113,
-0.8122690916,
-0.2713335752,
0.2538551688,
0.2825080752,
0.5457805991,
-0.111605905,
-0.1055687293,
0.6229262948,
0.4872288108,
0.2647298276,
0.2319178879,
-0.23070544,
0.1847528368,
0.5593034029,
-0.079912141,
0.6938570738,
0.4257247448,
0.1679170281,
-0.2624926567,
-0.6878462434,
-0.2842673063,
-0.048626788,
-0.9170451164,
-0.088945657,
-0.9152858257,
-0.304074496,
-0.1128081381,
-0.0068691676,
-0.621691823,
-0.7410823703,
0.3784313202,
-0.2991862595,
0.1912833452,
0.6059777737,
0.1667736769,
0.0441505909,
-0.5494303107,
0.503354311,
0.2296092361,
0.4193059206,
0.241994977,
-0.3517465591,
-0.0359416418,
0.2437378019,
-0.4707556963,
-0.4377536476,
0.0574904792,
0.0695891678,
0.4069799781,
0.2843278646,
0.1257723868,
0.7916046381,
-0.6034314036,
0.4641420841,
-0.0519654825,
-0.8448666334,
0.7025312781,
-0.3369007111,
0.5757816434,
0.5576046705,
0.3578803837,
-0.2152657807,
-0.6316834688,
-0.798478961,
-0.9712448716,
0.6286625862,
0.4579452276,
-0.1077877954,
-0.3331876695,
0.120464921,
0.3821708858,
0.0015873594,
-0.6712677479,
-0.1042220518,
-0.1104380116,
-0.3103191555,
0.2455151677,
0.3761658669,
-0.0138897477,
-0.2470349371,
0.3998705149,
-0.0183411296,
0.2385543734,
0.1250763983,
-0.2108093351,
-0.0576689318,
0.5444507599,
0.2590380907,
0.8271105289,
-0.0000368271,
0.4104486704,
-0.1076762378,
-0.3008492589,
0.1642366797,
0.0001535334,
-0.085425362,
-0.2056332231,
0.2763181627,
0.7982378602,
0.1664055884,
-0.7874853015,
0.202348426,
0.1497197598,
-0.2209163159,
-0.1647026986,
0.3378907442,
0.1173560098,
0.0723427162,
0.1489785314,
0.4256289005,
0.3940573037,
-0.6840344071,
0.0459916145,
0.3517869115,
-0.3984836936,
-0.1539170593,
0.6113219857,
0.1443913132,
-0.179325074,
0.762930274,
-0.0238168258,
-0.0608392879,
0.5839230418,
0.6088581681,
0.8256371617,
-0.0497798584,
-0.1367203891,
0.2911979258,
0.1831742078,
-0.3845665753,
0.478500247,
-0.2831954062,
-0.7480095625,
-0.6173667908,
-0.5971759558,
-0.1072427258,
0.4565770924,
-0.5932613611,
0.1775041819,
-0.495246768,
0.0098101711,
0.2198494673,
-0.4431515336,
-0.7075790763,
0.3525289595,
0.1702338308,
1.0493296385,
-0.8276165128,
0.5918247104,
0.7181053162,
-0.4339850843,
-1.0616830587,
-0.0058383243,
-0.2072478235,
-0.6098710299,
0.5551926494,
0.2096109539,
-0.494497478,
0.3507874012,
-0.4306139946,
-0.7167271972,
0.7653899193,
0.498436749,
-0.5347646475,
-0.2525697649,
-0.0700963289,
0.3555767834,
-0.6257903576,
0.20544599,
0.9004330635,
0.4361797869,
0.18853724,
-0.844374299,
0.1970148683,
-0.4165170491,
-0.150583446,
0.43917346,
-0.1964204758,
0.9992846251,
-0.357139349,
-0.3972013593,
-0.0077937683,
0.4825950265,
0.7534139156,
0.145394519,
0.4779574871,
0.6244247556,
0.7248948216,
-0.1080352738,
1.1716338396,
-0.0192970932,
-0.1467347443,
1.3840491772,
-0.0525409691,
0.9190939069,
0.2566589415,
-0.1522397399,
0.8526934385,
0.3921271265,
0.6078413725,
0.4977138042,
0.1895435154,
-0.1504084617,
-0.544481039,
0.2665856779,
-0.2249687165,
0.5580207109,
0.4826430976,
-0.1898444891,
-0.3338649273,
-0.066414386,
-0.0916113779,
0.375180006,
-0.6324865818,
0.8980708122,
0.2723006904,
-0.9345330596,
0.7582368255,
-0.2044005543,
0.2949535847,
-0.2574502826,
-0.2829355299,
-0.1224331334,
0.263594389,
-0.1830217391,
-0.8919160366,
0.4208554327,
0.0693323612,
-0.207967326,
-0.405238986,
0.5383730531,
-0.3330691457,
-0.422621578,
-0.1909520775,
0.7510246038,
0.4921576977,
-0.3676432371,
-0.6682297587,
-0.120226346,
-0.3875861168,
-0.244389236,
0.126741305,
0.8357917666,
-0.4771644175,
0.7310423255,
0.4172386825,
0.0164850503,
-0.2649298608,
0.1161452457,
0.8260877132,
-0.5831747651,
-0.7031903267,
-1.0903357267,
0.8568979502,
0.0853200555,
-0.1678576022,
0.1803453118,
0.6023231149,
0.7507840395,
-0.0511095338,
0.8558526039,
-0.009711138,
0.2764393687,
-0.5767724514,
0.6613855362,
-0.2609282434,
0.2985328138,
-0.3329139948,
-0.7251949906,
-0.0703853369,
0.9128831625,
-0.4276234508,
0.2504905462,
0.9815413952,
0.2648427188,
-0.5060409904,
0.2286134809,
0.0929595008,
0.1901767403,
0.2111337334,
0.8131480217,
0.9319174886,
-0.4735014439,
0.360509485,
-0.0024816841,
-0.2322385311,
0.2162499428,
-1.0810858011,
-0.6005173326,
-0.5676730275,
-0.4847702384,
-0.0350798219,
-0.0186324064,
1.0312789679,
0.687740922,
-0.7683506012,
-0.0830476433,
-0.780631423,
-0.0353709571,
-0.6844465137,
-0.1659806073,
0.4737668633,
-0.3051432371,
-0.6956000328,
0.2096951008,
0.2673541903,
0.0221534465,
-0.0580032468,
0.0323790126,
-0.2386590242,
0.2930485904,
0.7132564783,
0.2099059969,
-0.9726144671,
-0.1499773115,
-0.1926084161,
-0.0746354982,
0.1979528517,
0.8154609203,
-1.018289566,
0.2806462348,
0.316216588,
0.3698035777,
0.3146176636,
0.2201005965,
0.7249165177,
-0.7177892327,
0.2235990912,
0.4866815805,
0.394136548,
0.0708196089,
-0.2022163123,
0.4831046164,
-0.3100884259,
-0.2781846523,
-0.8020611405,
0.5165096521,
-0.8110178709,
-0.5754218102,
0.9037061334,
-0.16914922,
-0.1824470609,
-0.4446320534,
-0.2993474007,
0.177493304,
-0.3101488054,
0.9373089671,
0.8593785763,
-0.590277791,
-0.331915617,
-0.2894214094,
0.5632399917,
0.3273556828,
-1.0292223692,
0.5437219143,
0.4913673699,
0.1319473088,
0.2252016962,
0.943829,
-0.4407871962,
0.423573792,
0.0363213643,
-0.184712261,
-0.3266125321,
-0.3211425841,
-0.01574306,
0.2515351772,
0.194332242,
-0.0107956026
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12430v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12430v1 | PlanRAG: A Plan-then-Retrieval Augmented Generation for Generative Large Language Models as Decision Makers | 2024-06-18T09:25:35 | 2024-06-18T09:25:35 | Myeonghwa Lee, Seonho An, Min-Soo Kim | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, I.2.7 | In this paper, we conduct a study to utilize LLMs as a solution for decision
making that requires complex data analysis. We define Decision QA as the task
of answering the best decision, $d_{best}$, for a decision-making question $Q$,
business rules $R$ and a database $D$. Since there is no benchmark that can
examine Decision QA, we propose Decision QA benchmark, DQA. It has two
scenarios, Locating and Building, constructed from two video games (Europa
Universalis IV and Victoria 3) that have almost the same goal as Decision QA.
To address Decision QA effectively, we also propose a new RAG technique called
the iterative plan-then-retrieval augmented generation (PlanRAG). Our
PlanRAG-based LM generates the plan for decision making as the first step, and
the retriever generates the queries for data analysis as the second step. The
proposed method outperforms the state-of-the-art iterative RAG method by 15.8%
in the Locating scenario and by 7.4% in the Building scenario, respectively. We
release our code and benchmark at https://github.com/myeon9h/PlanRAG. | [
-0.4707974195,
-0.8861492872,
0.5531615615,
0.3828791678,
-0.1912716031,
0.2306476384,
-0.1399889439,
-0.1538547426,
0.3821661174,
0.5969666839,
-0.4542357326,
-0.5872611403,
-0.0764056891,
-0.1112697273,
-0.3306298256,
0.7188753486,
-0.412076354,
0.0828045234,
0.0192049518,
0.0383829251,
-0.6752842069,
-0.4065444767,
-1.2032539845,
-0.178348437,
0.3680495918,
0.3101452887,
0.645753026,
0.3252614439,
0.429974705,
0.3474179506,
-0.1141710654,
0.4141869247,
-0.6177865863,
0.4130789638,
-0.109963581,
-0.6976042986,
-0.6406135559,
-0.2946737409,
0.4118857384,
0.3675189614,
-0.4346514642,
0.4704096615,
-0.2607137561,
0.976142168,
-0.833925426,
0.1690579504,
-0.6640950441,
0.416633755,
-0.3233780265,
-0.464949578,
-0.3707637489,
-0.3333648443,
-0.2361903787,
-0.5891066194,
0.1835957617,
0.5185374022,
0.6055070162,
0.5237194896,
-0.2057603151,
-0.454552263,
-0.9647138119,
0.5143525004,
-0.5758829713,
0.327126354,
0.3151174784,
0.7324156165,
-0.6063016057,
-0.8573297858,
-0.795653224,
-0.0144121228,
0.21731475,
0.2226254791,
-0.2650862932,
0.0581688546,
0.4807749093,
0.1236497313,
-0.5867824554,
0.1351861209,
-0.4609820247,
0.2087224722,
0.8367914557,
0.3677614629,
0.2010951787,
-0.3909834921,
-0.4226771593,
-0.1181120798,
-0.9266768694,
0.0395853966,
0.1727140695,
0.029183859,
0.2400545478,
0.982322216,
-0.4007741213,
0.6157446504,
0.0390813164,
-0.3025543094,
0.088494949,
-0.0910748616,
-0.4079755545,
0.1978329718,
0.6733366847,
0.418467015,
0.1182070076,
-0.1680158377,
-0.4455794096,
0.251231432,
0.4335805774,
-0.8716718554,
-0.4145450294,
0.3520840406,
-0.4877067804,
-0.1946645975,
-0.3290497661,
-0.959697783,
-0.322247535,
-0.2527546585,
0.4100391567,
-0.1196091324,
-0.1891376674,
0.3212181926,
0.0937869102,
0.5295532942,
0.1758564413,
-0.5676183105,
0.2730811834,
0.6031630635,
0.5904204249,
-0.4254989922,
-0.0769348294,
-0.7609029412,
0.286503166,
-0.9079757929,
1.2001607418,
-0.329921633,
-0.5374667048,
0.0066087861,
-0.51103127,
0.0367626622,
-0.9227535725,
1.0715111494,
-0.8671065569,
0.2651686966,
-0.2178929001,
-0.5687817931,
-0.1422817707,
0.3535477221,
-0.7720270157,
1.0230511427,
-0.094217509,
-0.6459496617,
0.5415232778,
-0.5202927589,
-0.2057614923,
0.300301224,
-0.5481491089,
-0.6381799579,
0.0300450213,
0.1153478622,
0.510799706,
-0.4621225297,
0.5057091117,
-0.2521358728,
-0.2366876155,
0.1649196595,
-0.2297787368,
0.5044113994,
0.2253574133,
-0.3467515111,
0.3748850822,
-0.5748502016,
0.4992794991,
0.1702969223,
-0.7240222096,
-0.003469927,
0.4285888672,
-0.0704235733,
0.3002604544,
0.0213639382,
-0.1565209031,
0.4210600853,
0.1146012619,
-0.1090988517,
0.5241199136,
-0.1541299075,
0.3190076053,
-0.4970270991,
0.8260598779,
-0.5146985054,
-0.0647511855,
0.3795932829,
-0.2643044293,
-0.881391108,
-0.3202246428,
0.362149626,
0.5226715207,
-1.15340662,
0.1467556506,
-0.2393302023,
-0.4527114928,
-0.4044663608,
-0.224102512,
0.4189564288,
0.313185662,
0.3783985674,
0.1522554159,
-0.861985743,
-0.6916072965,
-0.221294716,
-0.3046781421,
-0.1098784581,
0.1505374908,
0.2389672995,
-0.2968699932,
0.8825004697,
-0.6185884476,
-0.3987322152,
-0.5679212213,
-0.0491822287,
0.365503341,
0.0637775511,
0.3945607841,
-1.0294876099,
-0.411180079,
-0.2607609332,
-0.7367408276,
-0.1646807045,
-0.0534224138,
-0.3357823491,
0.2061778903,
0.542537868,
-1.0314948559,
0.3823854327,
0.386359483,
-0.4372047186,
0.9330663085,
-0.2501932979,
0.2170683593,
-1.2508472204,
0.1182723343,
-0.2600882053,
-0.1275081784,
-0.5972624421,
0.1809521168,
-0.0509039946,
-0.0862270072,
-0.1983476579,
0.6211051941,
-0.4583410323,
-0.4440274537,
-0.1768044531,
0.232086733,
-0.1174865663,
0.4630536139,
-0.0736334175,
1.091783762,
0.2480629534,
-0.9193683863,
0.318913728,
0.4710168839,
-0.6476360559,
0.6019089818,
-0.6930870414,
-0.0852388591,
-0.3311168253,
0.3679182529,
-0.7592636943,
-0.2498486191,
0.2874781191,
-0.3228118718,
0.3773231506,
-0.0023768246,
-0.5228540897,
-0.4525387287,
-0.2906303704,
0.2650735676,
0.4291428626,
-0.6448588967,
0.7909227014,
0.8411785364,
-0.2963880897,
-0.4697790742,
-0.1371717751,
0.0826660469,
-0.4816859663,
-0.512285769,
0.8178676963,
-0.3839609623,
-0.6588091254,
-0.0919449702,
-0.1436623484,
-0.1418764442,
-0.1195129231,
0.1458764225,
0.3411466181,
-0.0334652849,
0.1227534041,
-0.0080120508,
-0.3263787627,
0.234006986,
0.1173579171,
0.6834014058,
0.1006874144,
-0.181768924,
-0.0122640086,
0.3089730442,
0.3741488755,
-0.4826532602,
0.2179370672,
0.3189311922,
-0.2917377949,
-0.7094718218,
-0.5681627393,
0.2912517488,
-0.478569448,
0.459649533,
-0.7679505944,
-0.5770435333,
0.4746630788,
-0.4488628209,
0.2641462684,
0.3853821456,
0.6908400655,
-0.3513554633,
0.9647060633,
0.3962579668,
0.0205256753,
0.229902938,
-0.4353494644,
0.2456053644,
-0.8419062495,
-0.3741077483,
-0.5899967551,
-0.5594930649,
-0.4909757674,
-0.8839870095,
0.7013229132,
0.6370517015,
-0.2011606544,
0.0303482655,
-0.1815924644,
0.3162792623,
0.3340837359,
-0.0488051623,
0.347546041,
-0.1514251381,
-0.039433457,
0.0271883421,
-0.930845201,
-0.5213381052,
1.0046824217,
-0.1262347549,
0.7622303367,
0.317955941,
0.8733279705,
0.2015469968,
0.2466519773,
-0.8995580673,
0.8179317713,
0.1617109627,
-0.417069912,
-0.2465201467,
-0.6047897935,
-1.255797267,
0.5204732418,
-0.4481840432,
-0.3684979379,
-0.0318430215,
-0.1150182635,
-0.439624846,
0.4969514608,
-0.2437314838,
0.6275527477,
-0.4257172048,
-0.3657184839,
-0.2169345021,
-0.0554006435,
0.3753777742,
-0.0998575389,
0.2900607288,
-0.1486165076,
-0.1332950145,
0.7628824115,
-0.365980953,
0.1493201852,
-0.1682934314,
-0.03109264,
0.4108159244,
0.2503590882,
0.8307896256,
-0.0663757846,
-0.2202086151,
-0.3329676688,
-0.0627410561,
-0.0784883499,
-0.6247976422,
0.4910474122,
-0.4408110082,
-0.5496066809,
-0.222494036,
-0.3372347355,
-0.2218570411,
0.1872575432,
0.2302837372,
0.3905906677,
-0.1906169504,
0.0150242811,
0.6995874643,
-0.2746129334,
0.5422702432,
0.6625984907,
-0.6875622272,
-0.3466060162,
0.7226380706,
0.1503768712,
-0.29402408,
0.4846038222,
0.1178604215,
-0.4968765378,
-0.8176984787,
-0.5795417428,
0.1681594253,
-0.3323620856,
-0.528167367,
-0.436091274,
-0.018865848,
0.2786013186,
-0.0785022303,
-0.4652596116,
-0.2487918735,
-0.0081411535,
-0.1450706422,
0.0515453294,
0.7537618279,
0.1681287438,
-0.0343297608,
-0.5111080408,
0.692117691,
0.2550610006,
0.3293340206,
-0.3046234548,
0.0105862599,
0.0699970797,
-0.1138015091,
-0.1855544895,
-0.8587812781,
0.5679178834,
-0.2530578971,
0.7554388046,
0.0136273801,
0.3805107176,
0.7396723628,
-0.6407294273,
0.3073522747,
-0.1861600727,
-0.5774586201,
0.4159009457,
-0.2918542325,
0.1045548469,
0.5873585343,
0.2166679651,
-0.2841164172,
0.0407544337,
-0.4390715063,
-0.8709081411,
0.4349660873,
0.2082188576,
-0.249767676,
0.054383155,
0.4161959291,
-0.161213994,
0.2724071145,
-0.4310150146,
-0.391375035,
0.5265273452,
0.1401279271,
0.0788746476,
-0.5645292401,
0.0219012108,
0.0156784784,
0.6966153383,
-0.1294724196,
0.2915952802,
0.0391135551,
0.1484390795,
-0.1613761038,
0.357963711,
0.2757845521,
0.9527193308,
-0.0722307563,
-0.0671231821,
0.3107595444,
-0.0120978476,
-0.0227442142,
0.21478118,
-0.4065337181,
0.173666209,
0.1479247212,
0.7649797201,
0.2599240839,
-0.8479430676,
0.2750555277,
-0.3087596893,
-0.1923015118,
-0.564414978,
0.0182004888,
0.0079207066,
0.6894056201,
0.37515378,
-0.1076256856,
0.3484399617,
-0.3233645856,
0.2605907023,
0.5551407933,
0.0887464285,
0.0584768876,
0.7430388331,
0.0580153391,
-0.4760125279,
0.4397562146,
-0.5889437199,
-0.6468831301,
0.5091293454,
0.5059674978,
0.9456170201,
-0.1408180296,
0.5225649476,
0.4717496932,
0.0475483276,
-0.1934068501,
0.8032565713,
-0.0510094427,
-0.6668089628,
-0.6310116053,
-0.8297781348,
-0.430219382,
-0.1021421105,
-0.5410932899,
0.3678870201,
-0.2474074513,
-0.1318683326,
-0.4090692103,
0.2900876403,
-0.6871823668,
0.1608039737,
-0.0529151969,
0.7654269934,
-0.0069786566,
0.6137061715,
0.6578676105,
-0.0355095714,
-1.0350520611,
0.0037192965,
-0.1677355319,
-0.5903307199,
0.7628283501,
-0.1074820086,
-0.2249138206,
-0.0349814706,
-0.2590018511,
-0.9357687831,
1.3744506836,
0.3176405132,
-0.7120938897,
-0.098701261,
-0.1124737486,
0.4629962742,
-0.152667433,
0.1683634222,
0.5156468749,
0.4328199327,
0.271058172,
-0.7930031419,
-0.0209875926,
-0.2256508768,
0.0418663658,
0.5415514708,
-0.5187443495,
0.9418908954,
-0.5551128387,
-0.6083228588,
0.0121361548,
0.5871600509,
0.8158209324,
0.3080821633,
0.3269805908,
0.87028265,
0.9487057328,
0.0252159443,
1.173440218,
-0.1881079525,
0.3149609864,
1.2867239714,
-0.28506428,
1.4368219376,
0.2007949352,
-0.4840531945,
0.253159821,
0.641079545,
0.3106501102,
0.4650545418,
0.4668743312,
-0.3035592139,
-0.1673085541,
0.0026957793,
-0.3807725906,
0.7320668697,
0.4149308801,
-0.0306252334,
-0.2543261051,
-0.3803353906,
0.2725625634,
-0.0778816044,
-0.5295135379,
0.899466157,
-0.2167176455,
-0.7554565072,
0.6955894828,
0.0711467564,
0.5570403337,
-0.575191021,
-0.0928185433,
-0.4105928838,
0.1541221738,
-0.2493108064,
-0.7723204494,
0.2933552563,
-0.0288239382,
-0.2148217708,
-0.152302891,
0.6258832216,
-0.4795865417,
-0.516335845,
0.26548931,
0.647649765,
0.0808755979,
-0.1816807836,
-0.6653764844,
0.3670347631,
0.052963037,
-0.3375304937,
0.1372786015,
0.3629723191,
-0.1602434069,
0.93705374,
0.5983324051,
0.1966175884,
0.1299795955,
-0.0816506967,
0.9572620392,
-0.6301796436,
-0.2903642058,
-0.5903366208,
0.2290514112,
-0.0828354135,
-0.1474598646,
0.5828319192,
0.8642684817,
0.9061096907,
0.0643625781,
0.6709256768,
-0.1402602047,
0.4821874797,
-0.9437966943,
0.661585331,
-0.3536401093,
0.4287264943,
-0.0490560159,
-1.3718003035,
-0.3024950922,
0.5540548563,
-0.2756063342,
-0.0362029821,
0.6111025214,
0.8735474348,
0.2376541048,
-0.1108419597,
0.2945701182,
0.0967682898,
0.5760425329,
0.5971493125,
0.8765580654,
-0.3433992863,
0.5455411673,
-0.0292825829,
-0.1426116675,
-0.0685342178,
-0.5742098093,
-0.8160922527,
-0.5005202293,
-0.1225483641,
-0.1620091945,
-0.0009892115,
0.7869114876,
0.470362395,
-0.5377582312,
-0.4471383393,
-0.1139525175,
0.2753788233,
0.0037938848,
-0.2234213799,
0.5272480249,
-0.5176645517,
-0.6873754263,
0.5774857998,
0.2513974309,
-0.203792423,
-0.2659557164,
-0.3149784207,
-0.1128791794,
-0.1513045877,
0.8664097786,
0.226640299,
-0.539501369,
0.123711288,
-0.2345619053,
-0.0571735278,
-0.0380919054,
1.0331268311,
-0.9827461839,
0.6120800972,
0.5583556294,
0.8575789332,
0.8505683541,
-0.0832089037,
0.5920299292,
-0.1943151653,
-0.2963857949,
0.2670139968,
0.3920485973,
0.1921156645,
-0.0466890074,
0.7812945843,
-0.3634938002,
-0.6576076746,
-0.5122302771,
0.2467126101,
-0.8019332886,
-0.2446654439,
1.2611055374,
0.1713778377,
-0.1288597584,
0.01169034,
-0.7278639674,
0.0678734258,
-0.2321734428,
0.9125958085,
0.1813768297,
-0.3491579294,
-0.0386680923,
-0.8298892975,
0.9108721614,
0.3068796396,
-1.2774316072,
0.0067739617,
0.7973914146,
-0.1095805764,
0.0583787449,
0.8230329752,
0.0084200259,
0.0403777175,
-0.0441346392,
0.0162022877,
0.0932625234,
-0.4399921298,
0.1139755994,
0.4591594934,
0.070560202,
-0.3055139482
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12428v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12428v1 | PSLM: Parallel Generation of Text and Speech with LLMs for Low-Latency Spoken Dialogue Systems | 2024-06-18T09:23:54 | 2024-06-18T09:23:54 | Kentaro Mitsui, Koh Mitsuda, Toshiaki Wakatsuki, Yukiya Hono, Kei Sawada | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS | Multimodal language models that process both text and speech have a potential
for applications in spoken dialogue systems. However, current models face two
major challenges in response generation latency: (1) generating a spoken
response requires the prior generation of a written response, and (2) speech
sequences are significantly longer than text sequences. This study addresses
these issues by extending the input and output sequences of the language model
to support the parallel generation of text and speech. Our experiments on
spoken question answering tasks demonstrate that our approach improves latency
while maintaining the quality of response content. Additionally, we show that
latency can be further reduced by generating speech in multiple sequences. Demo
samples are available at https://rinnakk.github.io/research/publications/PSLM. | [
-0.250425458,
-0.7283644676,
0.8031990528,
0.1029337347,
-0.3136156797,
0.4199823141,
0.0289704446,
-0.2495542169,
0.122620821,
0.6814858913,
-0.8613513708,
-0.1646917015,
-0.3290037513,
0.2467589527,
-0.3227387965,
1.0055721998,
0.2369196415,
0.1982819289,
-0.5035990477,
0.0542870536,
-0.0887098685,
-0.9313431382,
-0.5811553001,
-0.2621604204,
0.631431222,
0.4147133529,
0.6154484749,
0.0856858492,
0.6487538218,
0.2763875127,
-0.0201258399,
0.3406118155,
-0.5310367942,
0.8574339151,
0.0865195617,
-0.2591142654,
-0.6303161383,
-0.450712055,
0.9294024706,
0.6876937747,
-0.1505273432,
0.2232206911,
0.02462711,
0.4880407453,
-0.304029882,
0.0192578323,
-0.4775659144,
0.2164218426,
-0.401343137,
-0.3481565416,
-0.4282130301,
-0.399818629,
0.0938375667,
-0.2251407504,
0.214502126,
0.1732768565,
0.4705750048,
0.1930605471,
-0.1335882097,
-0.1649361551,
-0.9175853133,
0.9226339459,
-1.1671338081,
0.2464198768,
0.1142753512,
0.3606314063,
-0.105488278,
-0.9569448233,
-0.8095558882,
-0.139388442,
-0.0069689485,
0.2490818053,
0.0247040223,
0.2625561655,
0.5809541345,
0.4035055041,
-0.8671543598,
-0.1713454574,
-0.4106438458,
-0.3334892392,
0.6048365831,
0.8045935631,
0.126445666,
-0.2265711129,
-0.1442993134,
0.2854740322,
-0.6020572782,
0.1131577864,
0.6896299124,
0.6664631367,
-0.0659107417,
0.8366215229,
-0.2871262133,
0.872048974,
-0.3561263382,
-0.6535357237,
0.2247717232,
-0.6580570936,
-0.1703853905,
-0.146115914,
0.870493114,
0.2715604901,
-0.1997216493,
0.0596206374,
-0.3504319191,
0.2833416164,
0.0476873219,
-0.9338337779,
-0.0184303522,
0.2589286566,
-0.5443567634,
-0.2344495505,
-0.2513430417,
-0.832504034,
-0.2274063081,
-0.3034038544,
-0.0092572849,
-0.1515246928,
-0.1498503238,
0.1297865361,
0.015196505,
0.03899353,
0.3532145917,
-0.6735943556,
0.6411603689,
0.2656068504,
0.873152554,
-0.2990397215,
-0.1908025295,
-0.8993808031,
0.2069908828,
-0.0248789228,
0.712805748,
-0.478438735,
-0.5411518216,
-0.1186774671,
-0.1151746064,
-0.0129969269,
-0.3797129989,
0.4163779914,
-0.4658046365,
0.5279281139,
-0.2065293789,
-0.5107017159,
0.2790607512,
-0.2101679146,
-0.3771324754,
0.9992443919,
-0.0889705345,
-0.9243772626,
-0.3713029921,
-0.5149413943,
-0.5958883762,
0.1480832845,
-0.3427037299,
-0.4481567442,
0.2081969529,
0.1104655862,
0.4150692821,
-0.5973464251,
0.3907156587,
-0.2261064798,
-0.2743800879,
0.1697132587,
-0.4569258988,
0.3987788558,
0.48228544,
-0.027447978,
0.3417338729,
-0.9704312086,
0.0386203378,
0.3657698929,
-0.5514039993,
0.232281521,
0.4682397246,
0.1219041795,
0.4686270654,
0.2352725416,
-0.7259168625,
-0.0617700592,
-0.3908468187,
0.493034631,
0.5722001791,
0.0406311639,
0.2732326686,
-0.6284245253,
0.612187922,
0.0639069453,
-0.0004488569,
-0.6220623851,
-0.7623604536,
-0.7017895579,
-0.0406164415,
-0.299212724,
0.7260000706,
-1.0622705221,
-0.0042106519,
0.0374984108,
-0.3415979445,
-0.4142638147,
0.1521757096,
0.464366436,
0.8547101617,
0.171026215,
-0.4001071453,
-0.8086874485,
-0.9088817835,
-0.0395860299,
-0.3838070631,
-0.1631929427,
0.5335999131,
-0.1757577807,
0.0527111143,
1.0720784664,
-0.584861517,
0.2019659281,
-0.3217671514,
0.0172991455,
0.1732051075,
0.1260556877,
0.3086419702,
-0.5955330729,
-0.3719639182,
-0.3010010123,
-0.7799789906,
-0.4142384529,
0.1325373352,
0.2641426325,
0.2348564565,
0.4290800393,
-0.5372319818,
0.1600593626,
0.780569911,
-0.0310965274,
0.6693911552,
-0.0700809434,
0.0777891278,
-1.2124820948,
-0.039422296,
-0.4049590528,
-0.5936028957,
-0.9776306748,
-0.2678978443,
-0.3159531653,
-0.9188890457,
-0.8329384327,
0.2165998369,
-0.239253208,
-0.6456953287,
-0.432233572,
0.4301770031,
0.2043019086,
0.5558072925,
-0.0177490301,
1.0883982182,
0.492233187,
-0.5667953491,
0.690112412,
0.1192222387,
-0.2680616081,
0.3425314426,
-0.7829951048,
0.4159697592,
-0.1992571801,
0.2269465625,
-1.3182560205,
-0.0963019505,
0.2090916485,
-0.2969457209,
-0.0433499031,
0.3738105893,
-0.7094766498,
-0.5366175771,
0.0026272621,
0.3344623744,
0.5761240721,
-0.1020895764,
0.4462514222,
0.2606222928,
-1.002603054,
-0.1594968885,
-0.5930251479,
-0.1153537631,
0.0430290997,
-0.7852703929,
0.0814899355,
-0.3257355988,
-0.2724948227,
-0.1886410415,
0.1937734783,
0.2625390589,
-0.2547027469,
0.1793901026,
0.2104285508,
-0.5226531029,
0.1565918475,
0.2738701701,
0.0638399869,
-0.2294630706,
-0.2230901271,
0.9296494722,
-0.0904600918,
-0.559443295,
-0.5981516838,
0.8687550426,
0.7676938176,
-0.2764719427,
0.5609765649,
0.3955175877,
-0.1357166022,
0.2166231871,
-0.2994430363,
-0.2986961603,
-0.4680253267,
0.3193570673,
-0.4478191137,
-1.1339433193,
0.4299300313,
-0.0352221653,
0.0132132107,
0.1286988854,
0.8287351727,
-0.2094090581,
1.0784898996,
0.5337731838,
0.2161092013,
0.4382816851,
0.4116971195,
0.367701441,
-0.7522690296,
-0.1349678636,
-0.4460112453,
-0.0692081898,
-0.2825192213,
-0.6687273979,
0.1620377302,
-0.0079312604,
-0.1103149727,
0.1353672445,
-0.2694224715,
-0.0779310688,
0.5340451598,
0.1096309498,
0.5013239384,
0.1799039543,
-0.3382084668,
-0.3685303926,
-0.8472067714,
-0.7192699909,
0.7847887874,
0.3821658194,
0.6644740105,
0.2513799369,
0.6492521763,
0.2202446312,
-0.0092846779,
-0.4215771854,
0.7891806364,
-0.2063887566,
-0.2855374515,
-0.4873272777,
-0.4158459008,
-0.5316939354,
0.3521170914,
-0.0979957506,
-0.6817293763,
-0.2150211632,
0.0381148607,
-0.585926652,
0.3025814891,
-0.5056761503,
0.2167321742,
-0.1681841612,
-0.3980590701,
-0.0714700744,
-0.799467802,
0.3575439453,
-0.1321510524,
-0.0079492079,
-0.3361309767,
-0.0153597146,
0.7194996476,
-0.6028921604,
0.9331728816,
-0.0901120752,
-0.2758489251,
0.2659649849,
-0.1571878195,
0.6724606752,
0.0793831646,
-0.0821965784,
-0.1738787889,
-0.3021544516,
-0.4640644491,
-0.4215671718,
0.7086442709,
-0.5823552608,
-0.7403645515,
-0.3059457242,
-0.9006422758,
-0.4172670245,
0.2006191909,
0.1514542699,
0.5004934669,
0.1008563116,
-0.1380816996,
0.5834619403,
-0.5697908998,
0.6068745852,
0.520852983,
-0.5993337035,
-0.6268780231,
0.8631361723,
-0.0743051991,
0.5898726583,
0.1390924007,
-0.0331971943,
-0.3243041337,
-0.5081358552,
-0.2680501938,
0.2921873927,
-0.4362502396,
-0.0585222952,
-0.8145936131,
-0.3226109445,
-0.6630769968,
0.1435695887,
-0.2528633773,
-0.5457166433,
-0.3497375548,
0.0709604993,
0.201060459,
0.7975460291,
0.1517721713,
0.6351767778,
-0.9315891266,
0.6760945916,
0.5119899511,
0.1467688829,
-0.1258749068,
-0.4016171396,
0.0575903952,
0.0645433813,
-0.410457164,
-0.961871624,
0.5614649653,
0.1556873769,
0.4963387847,
0.0858205482,
0.0780509859,
0.6054047942,
-0.9240741134,
1.092874527,
0.5356687307,
-0.8881178498,
0.7985465527,
-0.4164175093,
0.5318467021,
0.0704562292,
0.0715256706,
-0.6595169902,
-0.6863885522,
-0.4479983747,
-0.7975113392,
0.9359918237,
0.5639544725,
0.0871369392,
0.0855612531,
0.0056575998,
0.0334303379,
0.6419596076,
-0.3907389641,
-0.2856394947,
-0.1923435628,
0.0853461921,
-0.3859148026,
-0.5092049837,
-0.1464660615,
0.0391199179,
0.4900141954,
-0.1260845959,
0.4429661334,
0.2622237802,
0.0170052946,
-0.3067637086,
0.2165509015,
1.1406191587,
0.6984158158,
-0.1295265704,
0.0108378902,
0.0914965719,
-0.2002939135,
0.165275678,
0.1981023401,
-0.1490586251,
0.374258846,
0.190900743,
1.1645348072,
0.0598057956,
-0.7176119089,
0.3481586277,
-0.2160275429,
-0.0687929168,
-0.0723639876,
-0.2732604444,
0.2272129208,
0.387878716,
0.404061079,
0.2113341838,
0.0539680049,
-0.2526510656,
0.3283313811,
0.1534186602,
-0.1531352848,
-0.1633513272,
0.7056470513,
0.4183171391,
-0.7583868504,
0.5786632299,
0.0775269419,
-0.3868488371,
0.308523953,
0.7856665254,
0.5827369094,
-0.3126235306,
0.2670577168,
0.1024212241,
-0.0391211696,
0.2173990607,
0.7073161602,
-0.2444916666,
-0.5280200243,
-0.6112833619,
-0.875690639,
-0.5966864824,
0.1759547293,
-0.5789729357,
0.0927560925,
-0.4420385957,
-0.328032881,
-0.2635577321,
-0.1515412778,
-0.3150888085,
-0.014320326,
0.4009471834,
0.4724925458,
-0.8861115575,
0.9094563127,
0.5143367052,
-0.2320015281,
-0.5355367661,
0.0315022692,
-0.0671327636,
-0.5074228048,
0.6285996437,
-0.1634582728,
-0.3187687695,
0.048327066,
-0.2467003018,
-0.8363690376,
0.9555575252,
0.548938334,
-0.9325327873,
-0.1980303079,
0.4321238697,
0.5945696831,
-0.4031466544,
0.070569545,
0.220245719,
0.0087144589,
0.1292004287,
-1.0147863626,
-0.1265480071,
-0.1985355616,
0.4582413733,
0.0814632177,
-0.5466654301,
1.0875302553,
-0.1779647321,
-0.2502085567,
0.4540533125,
0.7574566007,
0.7815700769,
0.3633270264,
0.1971367151,
0.3827556968,
0.7422227859,
-0.1735825986,
0.9563230276,
-0.2171023935,
0.2830941081,
1.327003479,
-0.7082712054,
0.9021729231,
0.7324995995,
-0.3856393099,
0.3718011379,
0.5468638539,
0.4202898741,
0.6746331453,
0.3029304445,
-0.6227557659,
-0.3167673945,
-0.2602836192,
-0.4371719658,
0.0633741915,
0.3791213334,
-0.2776816785,
-0.3230322003,
0.3355263174,
-0.3717755079,
0.2222488374,
-0.0238930527,
0.7231695056,
0.2021619529,
-0.5043313503,
0.328730166,
-0.2547618151,
0.5112748146,
-0.6036652327,
0.0669548064,
-0.3450149894,
0.0361571349,
-0.1165318415,
-0.5771605372,
0.440571785,
0.0449997336,
-0.4653949738,
-0.4323853254,
0.9029529095,
-0.5105403066,
-0.4114055932,
0.2152616233,
0.7507619858,
0.2866136432,
0.3259216547,
-0.613643527,
0.2904388309,
-0.120781593,
-0.2548780739,
0.253659904,
0.1696664989,
0.1861094832,
0.6066955924,
0.8222230077,
0.2534693778,
0.4886696637,
0.3984850645,
0.9114053249,
-0.4467761517,
-0.5398555994,
-0.6637860537,
0.4867265522,
-0.0871178806,
-0.0125888633,
0.7724151015,
0.7099460959,
0.481330961,
-0.2358119041,
1.0137375593,
-0.0244378876,
0.9347792268,
-0.4372089803,
0.3860442638,
-0.4404568076,
0.2684697509,
-0.4227341413,
-0.8172588944,
-0.252961725,
0.2649750412,
-0.160359472,
-0.2579495609,
0.6506583691,
0.8503174782,
0.1614273489,
0.0106354719,
0.8194429874,
-0.034311261,
0.3872290552,
0.6706851721,
1.1005893946,
-0.4499447048,
0.6024727225,
-0.2152486593,
0.1151467115,
-0.0060150665,
-0.6728956699,
-0.8064507246,
-0.6356777549,
-0.0266171619,
-0.4142531455,
0.2494834214,
0.4930050373,
0.5670567751,
-0.7884812951,
-0.4863197803,
-0.1299412102,
-0.068227008,
0.0346804373,
-0.2254761904,
-0.0697263703,
-0.547008276,
-0.8595921397,
0.5466208458,
0.5566102862,
0.2514779568,
-0.4035772383,
-0.4451752901,
-0.2708652318,
0.2304265499,
0.7954458594,
0.2021656185,
-0.9684922099,
-0.0150648151,
0.2151059806,
-0.2638985813,
-0.0074021295,
1.2014362812,
-0.721031487,
0.3987267315,
0.7111825943,
0.5568264127,
0.5937253833,
-0.0691312701,
0.8163733482,
-0.9611657262,
0.3544451892,
0.5221248269,
0.3515524268,
0.4599022865,
-0.1475497782,
0.0155047867,
0.4566228986,
-0.507432282,
-1.009436965,
0.7429286242,
-0.9162665606,
-0.0410853848,
1.0031424761,
-0.1883087307,
0.0620067753,
-0.1505052149,
-0.4082928896,
0.4464020133,
-0.3899226785,
0.1450006217,
0.6824091673,
-0.5077446699,
-0.5597051382,
-0.4625845253,
0.3526165187,
0.5737552643,
-0.7745357156,
0.018783614,
0.515481472,
-0.0968630239,
0.3439352512,
1.0440107584,
-0.0496649295,
0.1984650642,
0.005954369,
-0.1870507151,
0.0286845677,
-0.310898453,
-0.4226489663,
0.3768502474,
0.0000338474,
-0.2191865444
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12422v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12422v1 | Open-Source Web Service with Morphological Dictionary-Supplemented Deep Learning for Morphosyntactic Analysis of Czech | 2024-06-18T09:14:58 | 2024-06-18T09:14:58 | Milan Straka, Jana Straková | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present an open-source web service for Czech morphosyntactic analysis. The
system combines a deep learning model with rescoring by a high-precision
morphological dictionary at inference time. We show that our hybrid method
surpasses two competitive baselines: While the deep learning model ensures
generalization for out-of-vocabulary words and better disambiguation, an
improvement over an existing morphological analyser MorphoDiTa, at the same
time, the deep learning model benefits from inference-time guidance of a
manually curated morphological dictionary. We achieve 50% error reduction in
lemmatization and 58% error reduction in POS tagging over MorphoDiTa, while
also offering dependency parsing. The model is trained on one of the currently
largest Czech morphosyntactic corpora, the PDT-C 1.0, with the trained models
available at https://hdl.handle.net/11234/1-5293. We provide the tool as a web
service deployed at https://lindat.mff.cuni.cz/services/udpipe/. The source
code is available at GitHub (https://github.com/ufal/udpipe/tree/udpipe-2),
along with a Python client for a simple use. The documentation for the models
can be found at https://ufal.mff.cuni.cz/udpipe/2/models#czech_pdtc1.0_model. | [
-0.1916075647,
-0.5352945328,
0.3132734597,
0.3908809125,
-0.782513082,
0.2025541812,
-0.3948487043,
-0.5534645915,
0.3559698164,
0.6321150661,
-0.6246325374,
-1.0274438858,
-0.2406570911,
0.4210696816,
-0.1582048237,
0.6476980448,
0.1059288532,
0.8390794992,
-0.0201727822,
0.2001733631,
0.0775288939,
-0.581556201,
-0.2598751783,
-0.064050667,
0.3162354529,
0.0740545392,
0.3555910885,
0.4199742079,
0.3737829924,
0.3329675794,
-0.2274362296,
0.1004401296,
-0.0937756598,
0.5907459259,
-0.353980571,
-0.2733268738,
-0.5352794528,
-0.4811030626,
0.5459310412,
0.972792387,
-0.1865021139,
-0.0839937776,
-0.027787514,
0.6004456878,
-0.5861986876,
0.2578490376,
-0.8032261133,
0.0974747688,
-0.4998794198,
0.1933356524,
-0.2810797989,
-0.2618720233,
0.275442332,
-0.6073197126,
0.0325863995,
-0.4653989971,
0.6667701602,
0.1817449778,
-0.2878144383,
-0.2206285894,
-0.6281565428,
0.5629799366,
-0.6570846438,
0.4763048589,
0.3353239298,
0.236747548,
-0.1434440315,
-0.5929986835,
-0.3115012348,
-0.2384364754,
0.2552649379,
0.3019987345,
-0.2667028308,
0.2663721144,
-0.3511263728,
0.5470768213,
-0.7045744658,
0.2018418759,
-0.419781208,
-0.4843867719,
0.3545293808,
0.2065987736,
0.2615901232,
-0.1867550164,
-0.1608758569,
0.1117652953,
-0.4913327396,
-0.2853900492,
0.6348927021,
0.7063209414,
-0.1491073072,
0.8030270338,
-0.4365024567,
0.535413146,
-0.0458884761,
0.3315670192,
0.4896278083,
-0.4281617999,
-0.2645717561,
0.0490240939,
0.8352079988,
0.0304204077,
0.038553264,
-0.2742650807,
-0.0967423469,
0.2137715071,
0.1356471777,
-0.7944518924,
-0.650384903,
0.1644835621,
-0.246789813,
-0.2126299888,
0.0902471393,
-1.0227783918,
-0.2533802092,
-0.2319980413,
0.1202607527,
-0.5055499673,
-0.4943164289,
0.2711257637,
-0.119144164,
-0.1140497848,
0.4400050044,
-0.9379412532,
0.4477328956,
0.5775186419,
1.1950838566,
-0.3833261132,
0.0327615738,
-0.4899273515,
-0.1395368129,
-0.2745472193,
1.1180962324,
-0.2482652068,
-0.342713356,
0.1241962388,
0.1618117839,
0.1812102497,
-0.7859256268,
0.4422239661,
-0.3624733686,
0.2096252292,
0.3802532852,
-0.4049464464,
0.1013044193,
-0.0132757081,
-0.8593704104,
1.1103197336,
0.406063199,
-0.5772673488,
0.2482913882,
-0.4574205875,
-0.2061259001,
0.4790940583,
-0.0758200139,
-0.2193080932,
-0.0432495922,
-0.1264591664,
0.2243991196,
-0.0928154886,
0.1478187442,
-0.6644571424,
0.2465768903,
-0.1191512868,
-0.2589324713,
1.5523321629,
0.2509001493,
-0.0760778189,
0.2774583101,
-1.1046144962,
0.0913849995,
-0.1028141528,
-0.658596158,
-0.5285630822,
-0.1826415211,
0.463640362,
0.1312328428,
0.4482813776,
-0.9000615478,
0.3333648741,
-0.8860794902,
0.4450413287,
0.6697084308,
-0.2068499029,
0.2432248294,
0.4609984457,
0.6226447225,
-0.0482117608,
0.2178900987,
0.2203741968,
-0.6893514395,
-0.3237692416,
-0.5861100554,
0.6366546154,
0.615239799,
-0.7236927152,
0.775342226,
-0.3199455142,
-0.6356700063,
-0.6506690383,
0.1566457301,
0.496689111,
0.328060627,
0.2624180615,
-0.4503292441,
-0.9531773329,
-0.904049933,
0.2968840003,
-0.1280054152,
-0.2840724885,
-0.0981326252,
0.6630446315,
-0.3519664407,
0.9968678355,
-0.3037555218,
-0.1439998001,
-0.1128393412,
0.1586806923,
0.108801499,
0.4706979394,
0.675737977,
-0.989305675,
-0.7089701891,
0.3360772133,
-0.3260920942,
-0.451125741,
0.7007939816,
-0.1575273126,
0.6178981662,
-0.1086735353,
-0.7803207636,
0.0776973441,
0.8961394429,
-0.5573804379,
0.9851301312,
-0.0795755759,
-0.1092706919,
-1.3961993456,
0.1926323622,
-0.1266935319,
-0.1718744338,
-0.5398465395,
0.0938693434,
0.0283906404,
-0.0016661261,
-0.7244774699,
0.5545010567,
-0.2106407285,
-0.2527569234,
-0.0377117023,
-0.0165180285,
-0.0703005865,
0.313170433,
0.1860852242,
0.9470322728,
0.6791970134,
-0.4610748291,
0.8055526614,
0.4290673733,
-0.6129008532,
0.2170448899,
-0.2346564084,
-0.0163519904,
0.4954768419,
0.0920727476,
-0.8273119926,
-0.3520842791,
0.4495970905,
-0.6677716374,
-0.1118109077,
-0.686855495,
-0.6556068659,
-0.1858978271,
-0.353184253,
0.1256411523,
0.2626779079,
-0.5305808187,
0.6084491611,
0.4540194273,
-0.3940627277,
-0.3500736356,
-0.8487192392,
0.1348192692,
0.0543501228,
-0.759549439,
0.7543073893,
-0.1924156994,
-0.5603441,
0.3202572763,
-0.0872739255,
-0.985861361,
0.0756884217,
0.174352482,
0.420591414,
-0.3702160418,
0.1327452809,
0.2223766595,
-0.0587808341,
-0.208269462,
-0.6550787091,
0.9264602065,
-0.0801400393,
-0.1792316139,
-0.6908278465,
0.4129844606,
0.6441577077,
-0.2063621432,
0.4122106433,
0.3438043594,
-0.4413124025,
0.09339495,
-0.1735164076,
0.1319304407,
-0.4065966308,
0.2904520035,
-0.2840810418,
-0.7081807256,
0.6759620905,
0.0126165068,
-0.0760304779,
0.7331413031,
0.7751162052,
-0.1402525604,
0.9950149655,
0.7761853337,
0.0479024053,
0.510497272,
-0.3021456897,
-0.3379225433,
-0.5814297795,
-0.2739723027,
-0.7707109451,
0.4291320145,
-0.6677273512,
-0.057648968,
0.1327790916,
0.091960974,
0.125679031,
0.3333596587,
-0.4174900055,
0.0456253365,
0.4176077843,
0.0106048817,
0.4017637372,
0.2228852659,
-0.4720595181,
0.1159130484,
-0.4137979448,
-0.6479558945,
0.8887984157,
-0.0071566235,
0.7332372069,
0.152824685,
0.7389107943,
0.2022074014,
-0.2542992532,
-1.0566378832,
0.4526745379,
-0.446295321,
-0.4493649602,
-0.3834556639,
-0.4625615776,
-1.0810418129,
0.4322234392,
-0.2258360088,
-0.6675575972,
0.1565786749,
0.339551121,
-0.4352256954,
0.3119061589,
-0.6938604116,
0.7994491458,
-0.1169938818,
-0.0855360031,
-0.4063302875,
-0.3840025961,
0.1418470591,
0.1300984174,
-0.0008947554,
-0.0065221307,
-0.1304628998,
0.597483933,
-0.4728772044,
1.0042424202,
-0.2167438716,
-0.3706719875,
0.0360458903,
0.0899376795,
0.153916955,
-0.0319735669,
-0.1466846466,
0.4367689788,
0.2897239625,
-0.4511019886,
-0.4568885565,
0.6356344819,
-0.557158947,
-0.282692939,
-0.3764944375,
-0.2526630461,
-0.0843328461,
0.2999739945,
0.2711094022,
0.5175444484,
-0.2451885492,
0.3425962031,
0.7660022974,
-0.0491964258,
0.2044387907,
0.3990000188,
-0.3120843768,
-0.7186644077,
0.5975543857,
0.2036813945,
0.2174961418,
0.5143591762,
0.222559467,
-0.1585720778,
-0.8782740831,
-0.7320040464,
0.0673139095,
-0.5922394395,
-0.2552645206,
-0.6662404537,
-0.1774885654,
-0.8770716786,
0.2390283644,
-0.5362330675,
-0.6449296474,
-0.3349185586,
-0.0352569818,
0.4132300317,
0.5732573271,
-0.1138254851,
0.2064637691,
-0.7751886845,
0.0364703871,
0.2706467807,
0.3832376897,
-0.4696758986,
-0.2371263057,
-0.3726510406,
0.0597119853,
-0.2811305821,
-1.0350604057,
0.4882064164,
-0.0531683937,
0.4502845705,
0.4012413323,
-0.1948147267,
0.5670014024,
-0.5313721299,
1.0302386284,
0.1474378258,
-0.8521179557,
0.5082262754,
-0.4208296537,
0.249888882,
0.4340875149,
0.258207649,
-0.4523350596,
-0.4634684324,
-0.2383347005,
-0.8982557058,
0.5461894274,
0.076724574,
0.1546653062,
-0.1239283234,
0.2215296328,
0.4622891247,
0.0267717261,
-0.575453639,
-0.0640558377,
-0.2430037856,
-0.3884890378,
0.3264215589,
-0.1772482544,
0.0036764462,
-0.3144076169,
0.9063036442,
-0.1357867569,
0.1699783802,
0.1799901724,
-0.4314619303,
-0.1777938753,
0.2686110735,
0.773134172,
0.7124208212,
-0.2974158823,
0.1016413644,
0.1338037252,
-0.8932373524,
-0.2368148714,
0.1511179507,
-0.1991224438,
0.4369065464,
0.3554480374,
0.4833522141,
0.3241821527,
-1.0181152821,
0.3907458484,
0.0830179304,
-0.3429838121,
-0.5738481879,
-0.0838777795,
-0.0538365357,
0.4340586364,
0.5931901336,
-0.2512952089,
0.2854653299,
-0.3849454224,
0.0511497036,
0.6183931828,
-0.265108794,
-0.6085343361,
0.0448519699,
0.309804678,
-0.4379888475,
0.4145209789,
-0.0782193765,
-0.6668303013,
0.5666233301,
0.5692406297,
0.9449788928,
-0.4215114415,
0.3532797098,
0.1839421093,
-0.033635769,
0.2986600697,
0.4616538286,
-0.2150040269,
-0.5017380714,
-0.6228935122,
-0.8064631224,
-0.4045496285,
0.4623233676,
-0.7376302481,
0.3393896818,
-0.2740517259,
0.015363642,
-0.0006209732,
0.179011479,
-0.1821120828,
0.0806378722,
0.0022306372,
1.2107115984,
-0.7166461349,
1.0642791986,
0.7625210881,
-0.3340066671,
-0.0017612259,
-0.0496217981,
0.036660023,
-0.5753492117,
0.8925487399,
-0.0954575762,
-0.5387761593,
0.0058033364,
-0.3584469855,
-0.8340405822,
0.9310986996,
0.7450703979,
-0.5999627113,
-0.2423951626,
-0.2593009472,
0.6620513201,
-0.2105074376,
-0.1606119424,
0.2117236853,
0.3167099357,
-0.186621502,
-1.2140269279,
-0.3379015625,
-0.3248411119,
-0.0935733989,
0.3694292605,
-0.0394272767,
0.8432489038,
0.3134527206,
-0.4254478514,
0.5942428112,
0.5187710524,
-0.0139908558,
0.0083176894,
0.3987437189,
0.6407701373,
0.6396397948,
0.1658794433,
0.6653927565,
-0.2088483721,
0.4568908811,
1.1094971895,
-0.0738751218,
0.9225199819,
0.6780036092,
-0.2789247632,
0.6229869723,
0.9091922045,
-0.2112180442,
0.7504537106,
-0.08025527,
-0.5349081755,
-0.2836456001,
0.0455116555,
-0.4321970642,
0.5062187314,
0.3122920096,
-0.247444883,
-0.5713304877,
0.1444382966,
-0.2104570866,
0.1660728604,
-0.4504359663,
0.753393054,
-0.287343204,
-0.2314378321,
0.3160127699,
-0.0462003089,
0.7068870068,
-0.6275221705,
-0.1254284084,
-0.0033773126,
-0.0158027876,
-0.1045947969,
-0.708619833,
0.4670597911,
0.1994398534,
-0.2557654679,
-0.0481260456,
0.407792151,
-0.451405853,
-0.4665466249,
0.5805565715,
0.4438738525,
0.3433950245,
0.0534824282,
-0.6250795126,
-0.1726085693,
-0.2479407638,
-0.1432476491,
0.4002764225,
0.4716925323,
-0.1477437764,
0.5824468136,
0.7672902942,
0.5169095397,
0.2228078693,
0.2348153889,
0.9348793626,
-0.3455587327,
-0.5127170682,
-0.9126160145,
0.5551196337,
-0.1224349216,
-0.3426039517,
0.451580137,
0.9165866375,
1.2939814329,
-0.3238739669,
0.8260238767,
-0.141599834,
0.420471102,
-0.8040901423,
0.572630465,
-0.3683999479,
-0.3011739254,
0.0349316709,
-0.7541162968,
-0.5849458575,
0.4479642808,
-0.1964390576,
-0.4360858202,
0.6572352648,
0.712605834,
-0.2387558967,
-0.3449811339,
0.4686379433,
0.3085426092,
-0.0268091839,
0.1268463284,
0.7237480283,
0.2537785172,
0.7188420892,
-0.5521319509,
-0.3350150287,
-0.3028894067,
-0.5633607507,
-0.7560207844,
-0.9839813709,
-0.0876056626,
-0.2302719653,
0.198202461,
1.3057119846,
0.5889205933,
-1.0626981258,
-0.1731984019,
-0.2563855946,
-0.1321457922,
-0.187889874,
-0.1983014196,
0.2652976513,
-0.5341941118,
-0.8460902572,
0.4466691613,
0.5058270693,
0.0943835676,
-0.5659326315,
0.0414847061,
-0.1938194185,
-0.2618203163,
0.6742246747,
0.1802026331,
-0.9956932664,
0.1249730438,
-0.1097964123,
-0.2586567998,
0.4259340167,
0.8562532067,
-0.6340042353,
0.4966006875,
0.512655139,
0.4768491089,
0.3152827621,
-0.3685126007,
0.3548369706,
-0.4170483053,
0.1830240339,
0.4490948319,
0.5544799566,
0.2692573071,
-0.4942795038,
0.3024635613,
0.4936481118,
-0.1015402749,
-0.9592031837,
0.3678893745,
-1.0721071959,
-0.4704045951,
0.9504114985,
-0.3758147061,
-0.3125289381,
-0.3246828318,
-0.296941191,
0.5953438878,
-0.3819171488,
1.0010652542,
0.8231866956,
-0.0278419219,
0.0191255528,
-0.4395028055,
0.3676297069,
0.0260606483,
-1.0183415413,
0.2765605748,
0.7299849391,
0.4116137922,
0.3491725624,
0.4266182482,
-0.3828061223,
0.50152421,
-0.2118769735,
0.4238075316,
0.0268752314,
-0.441644758,
-0.7749757171,
0.0482134596,
-0.2180987597,
-0.2202105522
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12420v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12420v1 | MMUTF: Multimodal Multimedia Event Argument Extraction with Unified Template Filling | 2024-06-18T09:14:17 | 2024-06-18T09:14:17 | Philipp Seeberger, Dominik Wagner, Korbinian Riedhammer | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | With the advancement of multimedia technologies, news documents and
user-generated content are often represented as multiple modalities, making
Multimedia Event Extraction (MEE) an increasingly important challenge. However,
recent MEE methods employ weak alignment strategies and data augmentation with
simple classification models, which ignore the capabilities of natural
language-formulated event templates for the challenging Event Argument
Extraction (EAE) task. In this work, we focus on EAE and address this issue by
introducing a unified template filling model that connects the textual and
visual modalities via textual prompts. This approach enables the exploitation
of cross-ontology transfer and the incorporation of event-specific semantics.
Experiments on the M2E2 benchmark demonstrate the effectiveness of our
approach. Our system surpasses the current SOTA on textual EAE by +7% F1, and
performs generally better than the second-best systems for multimedia EAE. | [
-0.6127410531,
-0.5576608181,
0.6093148589,
0.096181415,
-0.5607516766,
-0.2059185803,
-0.1214747578,
-0.2790728509,
0.0674073696,
0.300637275,
-0.8932769895,
-0.2699360251,
-0.5472385287,
0.2131905109,
-0.1259533018,
0.7165648341,
-0.0986414775,
-0.0172987115,
-0.1759360731,
-0.2335367501,
-0.8020894527,
-0.3215761781,
-0.6893096566,
-0.0749927759,
0.6694325209,
0.8714523911,
0.4010286033,
0.460465461,
0.3926956654,
0.2576160133,
0.4501919746,
0.3274784386,
0.0247540213,
0.1210238636,
-0.2806048095,
-0.1278987825,
-0.2592702806,
0.1657744497,
0.346658051,
0.235980317,
-0.0507971309,
0.1502224654,
-0.0137125319,
0.2524191737,
-0.7896232009,
-0.1597178429,
-0.6240595579,
0.321004957,
-0.3747934997,
-0.592171669,
-0.4264119565,
0.3959520757,
0.1103383601,
-0.7044217587,
0.0033494323,
-0.1775999665,
0.8233292699,
0.0118657583,
-0.5509101748,
-0.1704627275,
-0.5848500729,
0.7261257172,
-0.4763640463,
0.5837357044,
0.0198793989,
0.339458406,
-0.1515166461,
-0.913849175,
-0.8364526033,
0.081703946,
0.2571784556,
0.4734311104,
-0.3451008201,
-0.0024006022,
0.1333739012,
-0.0145678353,
-0.7177915573,
0.1173492745,
-0.1932217777,
-0.2196745872,
0.3748826683,
0.1922323853,
0.6459258199,
-0.7804076076,
-0.6869723797,
-0.2399183661,
-0.3272477984,
-0.0687134787,
0.2683209181,
-0.0816010088,
-0.1092888787,
0.7595924139,
0.1493036449,
0.4885343909,
-0.0448419638,
-0.2806421816,
-0.0997478589,
-0.4018451571,
-0.4571498334,
-0.1021263748,
0.936886847,
0.7337716818,
-0.0226732139,
-0.0484681502,
0.25224787,
-0.0804504827,
0.0250361636,
-0.7424948812,
0.0243207645,
0.2148688436,
-0.478204906,
-0.3147422373,
0.2828245163,
-1.3691409826,
-0.2508454919,
-0.3801679015,
0.4367417991,
-0.3411644995,
-0.2012067735,
0.0486016832,
-0.4399160147,
0.1524561644,
0.5908293724,
-0.7517653108,
-0.1443404257,
0.4738426805,
0.6587210298,
-0.3185539842,
-0.0669308156,
-0.9180988669,
0.5789775848,
0.0243516341,
1.1484575272,
-0.8297176361,
-0.3195699155,
0.0644430593,
0.081057772,
-0.0666292086,
-0.2288039029,
1.0085371733,
-0.3581909537,
0.8027717471,
-0.2511589527,
-0.556446135,
-0.1430170387,
0.1478436291,
-0.6395374537,
1.1058716774,
-0.3006168604,
-0.6058989763,
0.5740276575,
-1.0165497065,
-0.0383735783,
-0.086795412,
-0.6322083473,
-0.1092124656,
-0.0003338596,
0.5146107078,
0.4981081784,
-0.4067732692,
0.2638073862,
-0.4140330553,
0.1440704614,
0.136193037,
-0.9124408364,
0.459063828,
0.2167361379,
-0.3365585506,
0.1292538941,
-0.9030324221,
-0.3359004855,
0.0858341455,
-0.2732405066,
-0.1570693403,
-0.056439247,
0.5484643579,
0.6455783844,
-0.1651469618,
-0.6205752492,
0.4875754416,
-0.0739715546,
0.1520947516,
0.8138930798,
0.0718433335,
0.4685728252,
0.0076038865,
0.4444979429,
0.3502708673,
0.0724990591,
-0.6184275746,
-0.6074752212,
-0.2047409266,
-0.5827587247,
0.3366322815,
0.6613710523,
-0.8876489997,
0.2437146902,
-0.112346895,
-0.0555080399,
-0.291582644,
0.286426574,
-0.2278523445,
0.5501715541,
0.2943091989,
-0.0467173308,
-0.8423407078,
-0.6917490959,
0.1314290911,
-0.1320009083,
-0.1125785708,
0.3179092407,
0.1169318184,
-0.2050576061,
0.8365932703,
-0.2582181394,
-0.5283718109,
-0.3204760253,
0.5100464225,
-0.0229870714,
0.5780704021,
0.6054152846,
-0.9224584699,
-0.2551231682,
0.1378998458,
-0.9817522168,
-0.393728137,
-0.4720553756,
-0.2442686707,
0.2348898202,
0.7282531261,
-0.7081778646,
0.5222402811,
0.453649193,
-0.5369876027,
0.4658544064,
0.0540868752,
0.4903988838,
-1.4898836613,
-0.1324015558,
-0.0961990952,
-0.2246880829,
-0.3099415004,
-0.2614321113,
-0.1003449857,
-0.2896518111,
-0.5464242697,
0.844845891,
-0.4922825098,
0.2561883032,
-0.2909110785,
0.4598767459,
0.3358311951,
0.3499984443,
0.0332213342,
0.4022411108,
0.5833700299,
-0.3144952059,
0.4014755189,
0.2278330475,
0.1441530883,
0.8885547519,
-0.2564139366,
-0.0544256903,
-0.1776922494,
0.0574609637,
-1.1249657869,
-0.3394401371,
0.2475078106,
-0.2863066792,
0.5081735849,
-0.3022797108,
-0.5665481687,
-0.132080853,
-0.3184091449,
0.4004820883,
0.1858814657,
-0.6501241922,
1.1030710936,
0.1615567207,
-0.1936641932,
-0.5927406549,
-0.3974371254,
0.49849841,
-0.3498818278,
-0.937907815,
0.4036970735,
-0.0965885296,
0.179665491,
0.056505952,
-0.1126911491,
0.0111807901,
-0.1949107051,
0.2232621461,
0.3333555758,
-0.7849773765,
0.2460192442,
0.1701525748,
-0.3466306031,
-0.2887609005,
-0.3864122927,
0.3928975761,
0.222373426,
-0.782756567,
-0.7371250987,
0.9989507794,
0.6074821353,
-0.1999311745,
0.4936086833,
1.1772646904,
-0.6144679189,
0.378906548,
-0.886946559,
-0.3194964826,
-0.4100858271,
0.4067867398,
-0.4260836244,
-0.6796950102,
0.4130379856,
-0.1885264814,
0.226148963,
0.6827468276,
0.4371497333,
-0.4068398476,
1.2618303299,
0.4695841968,
0.2922764122,
0.669342041,
-0.0284514874,
-0.3064770997,
-0.5992127061,
-0.1848781258,
-0.3704052866,
-0.3606650829,
-0.1685829312,
-0.6381886005,
0.2647964656,
0.2960563302,
0.3128372729,
0.0447804481,
0.0211083815,
0.5008331537,
0.1607048213,
-0.3986318409,
0.4806572199,
0.3089101017,
-0.4296598732,
-0.6237769127,
-0.76493752,
-0.7430122495,
0.7907672524,
0.1545839608,
0.483271271,
0.3821767271,
0.4965057373,
0.3331435621,
0.465036571,
-0.4405413866,
0.3693345189,
-0.2701031864,
-0.6221352816,
-0.1621876955,
-0.147323668,
-0.9763612747,
0.5087709427,
-0.6216344237,
-1.1837109327,
0.3532509506,
-0.2054743022,
0.0116441846,
0.6032325029,
-0.6233195662,
1.1642774343,
0.090664953,
-0.3886192739,
-0.0225470457,
-0.3573429883,
0.2782667577,
0.0087724235,
0.3460955024,
-0.2857750654,
-0.1899157465,
0.7977600098,
-0.2022039294,
0.61790663,
-0.0137866018,
0.0501194671,
0.2873773575,
-0.0816984475,
0.3321093917,
0.4454665184,
0.185691908,
-0.2967767715,
0.0503316931,
-0.3840670586,
-0.8557054996,
0.385532707,
-0.4508430064,
-0.4748317301,
-0.208893165,
-0.2801824212,
-0.1220682263,
0.1906446815,
0.4318872392,
1.0652678013,
-0.34428671,
0.3459234238,
0.5636139512,
0.0214325413,
0.8675865531,
0.569198668,
-0.2731470168,
-0.6905816793,
0.8529865742,
-0.1173205748,
-0.0953532606,
0.4569500089,
0.1991041154,
-0.4549888372,
-0.1188315377,
-1.1391566992,
0.0048697013,
-0.8812220693,
-0.4127513766,
-1.1898726225,
0.1634751558,
-0.0601731576,
-0.3547746539,
-0.371496141,
-0.5670272112,
-0.5800228119,
-0.0987213701,
0.0333856232,
0.3515971303,
-0.3300097883,
0.3696668744,
-1.3061858416,
0.3795688748,
0.2299257368,
0.1344942302,
-0.2657647729,
-0.294882983,
0.2800032496,
-0.174861744,
-0.7672942281,
-1.3849292994,
-0.0186695941,
0.3452646732,
0.8304046988,
0.717571497,
-0.2183858752,
0.8722418547,
-0.4672425687,
0.7015922666,
0.719540298,
-0.7686493993,
0.5441981554,
-0.3070576191,
0.1148544401,
0.4055998027,
0.244757548,
-0.5396438241,
-0.3080555797,
-0.8719198704,
-0.6074107289,
0.4897559881,
0.3139820695,
0.1190788001,
-0.0725371391,
0.2864356935,
0.2168908566,
-0.1590300798,
-0.7367660999,
-0.0903930739,
-0.101701878,
-0.5686715841,
0.2774171531,
-0.2360449284,
0.0005264365,
-0.0610736087,
0.3818606734,
-0.3197794259,
0.2644690275,
0.3762204647,
-0.2753364742,
-0.2427304089,
0.4144349992,
0.7496187687,
0.4486291111,
-0.0309795979,
0.2217226923,
0.1063949317,
-0.4427132607,
0.1625680923,
0.172939375,
0.1661664695,
0.2663058043,
0.4190145433,
0.4843273163,
0.349793762,
-0.7396745086,
0.6536772847,
-0.3596693873,
-0.3003227413,
0.0298852492,
-0.2452525049,
0.0222497955,
0.3933541179,
0.5016852617,
0.2412927896,
0.3404475451,
-0.4461081326,
0.6904815435,
0.3931002915,
-0.7201651335,
-0.3641473055,
0.7774375677,
0.1830538809,
0.1197336987,
0.2031726539,
-0.1209447682,
-0.1384612918,
0.3213500679,
0.5584981441,
0.7740278244,
0.0700565577,
0.2736633122,
0.281964004,
0.3344400525,
0.3957713246,
0.4784246087,
0.1762822717,
-0.5026364326,
-0.6935728192,
-0.5006877184,
-0.1531016082,
0.2745974064,
-0.4385451972,
0.5980177522,
-0.0858177915,
-0.2022356689,
0.2861711085,
-0.2143189311,
-0.6930545568,
0.1809272915,
0.4704549611,
1.0571229458,
-0.9200638533,
0.4598825276,
0.8973297477,
-0.6173920035,
-0.6522729993,
-0.2660480142,
0.2821825743,
-0.1873109192,
0.3410197794,
0.1680960804,
0.1473516971,
-0.2202377766,
-0.3187664151,
-0.6232937574,
0.9681823254,
0.4587469995,
-0.0044271885,
0.2440918088,
0.0479328297,
0.1479293108,
-0.765388906,
0.3859816194,
0.036628034,
0.7384873033,
0.4366029501,
-0.5086803436,
0.0125878034,
-0.2356341183,
-0.2310633808,
0.0972190797,
-0.1645978987,
0.4003990591,
-0.1980472058,
-0.3240502179,
-0.1261059642,
1.0880936384,
0.1431427598,
0.6866522431,
0.5261243582,
0.4621723294,
0.6092579365,
-0.0065174196,
0.7285262346,
0.3722105026,
0.084234342,
1.0542846918,
-0.2456442267,
0.8745135665,
0.6340782046,
0.0757508799,
0.6141188741,
0.5840232372,
0.0683163032,
0.312759459,
-0.4977295399,
-0.11832086,
-0.5258646011,
-0.2472638339,
-0.3755119741,
0.7879018188,
0.2740050256,
-0.0845946893,
-0.5746960044,
0.2755809128,
-0.0594905913,
-0.1188716292,
-0.0232937094,
0.9360476732,
-0.0272422954,
-0.4528885186,
-0.0511352569,
0.1557250321,
0.3328697681,
-0.483882457,
-0.2471455485,
-0.0221032258,
-0.1195755377,
-0.1561037749,
-0.7381502986,
0.422280997,
0.0354127325,
-0.3786767125,
0.1502565444,
0.8634153008,
-0.5116716623,
-0.458378762,
0.2489781231,
0.7776113749,
-0.0838729143,
-0.0020160652,
-0.6769115329,
-0.0699481145,
0.0170694683,
-0.2919249237,
0.3873458803,
0.8465464711,
-0.2133968174,
0.2638777494,
0.9508295655,
-0.4005753696,
0.2440298349,
0.1949083358,
0.6593797803,
-0.6521692276,
-0.5404923558,
-1.1188126802,
0.9853305221,
-0.4234386384,
-0.3886585236,
0.3667591214,
0.5578169227,
0.2626354396,
-0.172887817,
0.5121907592,
-0.0233535655,
-0.1430687904,
-0.7255327702,
0.3633464575,
-0.9476153851,
-0.0577789359,
-0.4603742957,
-0.8448317647,
-0.2614114583,
0.1041575968,
0.3376621306,
-0.2894911766,
0.6665936112,
0.5503154993,
-0.5884906054,
0.4270923436,
0.5527170897,
-0.2370047867,
0.617778182,
0.3070589602,
0.9338461161,
-0.4640697539,
0.770801425,
-0.0048219305,
-0.2891056836,
-0.4136695564,
-1.4349149466,
-0.828035295,
-0.8040698767,
-0.5232340693,
-0.0940050781,
-0.3844049573,
1.0982533693,
0.7616388798,
-0.8902773261,
0.0414730199,
0.3511931002,
0.1381386369,
-0.091808036,
-0.2180466205,
0.279239893,
-0.260492146,
-0.6347971559,
0.3623488843,
0.7551448941,
0.2307360619,
0.1560388952,
0.0787643194,
-0.5244679451,
0.3171453476,
0.66711092,
0.2250300944,
-0.7535513639,
-0.3378461301,
-0.0480218716,
-0.0996470153,
0.2689481974,
0.8908618689,
-0.3058010042,
0.5416473746,
0.4650354981,
0.7454661131,
0.3634040654,
-0.1663205028,
0.6529117227,
-1.0519933701,
0.2482996285,
-0.2496956587,
0.7599895597,
0.2195442915,
-0.1832888722,
0.395873487,
0.5305108428,
-0.0894985572,
-0.8368725181,
0.1670323908,
-1.5411787033,
-0.0746118128,
1.0107015371,
0.2086267769,
-0.1036921889,
-0.2680256069,
-0.6430237293,
0.2573063672,
-0.2800672054,
0.3514926732,
0.8522645831,
-0.0232759733,
-0.4748605788,
-0.7868133187,
0.3099863529,
0.389239192,
-0.839060843,
-0.2788909376,
0.5268188715,
0.1569453031,
0.318312645,
0.6402204037,
-0.214521423,
0.6241381168,
-0.1186105683,
0.0448567085,
-0.1353293806,
-0.4107175469,
-0.0499665737,
0.5079320669,
-0.444074899,
-0.1670155078
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12419v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12419v1 | AI-Assisted Human Evaluation of Machine Translation | 2024-06-18T09:12:11 | 2024-06-18T09:12:11 | Vilém Zouhar, Tom Kocmi, Mrinmaya Sachan | cs.CL | cs.CL | Annually, research teams spend large amounts of money to evaluate the quality
of machine translation systems (WMT, inter alia). This is expensive because it
requires detailed human labor. The recently proposed annotation protocol, Error
Span Annotation (ESA), has annotators marking erroneous parts of the
translation. In our work, we help the annotators by pre-filling the span
annotations with automatic quality estimation. With AI assistance, we obtain
more detailed annotations while cutting down the time per span annotation by
half (71s/error span $\rightarrow$ 31s/error span). The biggest advantage of
ESA$^\mathrm{AI}$ protocol is an accurate priming of annotators (pre-filled
error spans) before they assign the final score as opposed to starting from
scratch. In addition, the annotation budget can be reduced by up to 24% with
filtering of examples that the AI deems to be very likely to be correct. | [
-0.4688977897,
-0.4736120105,
0.3786315322,
0.4448523223,
-0.2418046445,
0.1274255961,
-0.0836920962,
-0.7607782483,
0.1941636205,
0.3116888702,
-0.3637654483,
-0.1379340589,
-0.885489285,
0.4765014648,
-0.4321958423,
0.851123333,
-0.3760139346,
0.1285639852,
0.1212335229,
-0.1210444868,
-0.4139632881,
-0.4193479717,
-0.8367471695,
-0.2023959756,
0.398381263,
0.3799304366,
0.9952421188,
1.0107127428,
0.9922518134,
0.3544662893,
0.1037388965,
0.4591653347,
0.0134983109,
-0.1391913444,
0.1396353841,
-0.4792257845,
-0.7501673102,
0.2990531921,
0.3448004425,
0.7400591969,
0.1898222417,
0.2120592594,
-0.0590242632,
0.9622894526,
-0.4921847284,
0.0977482572,
-0.2839617729,
0.2066106945,
-0.2090895921,
-0.2551761568,
-0.4451642931,
-0.2054518312,
0.1869830042,
-0.7591692209,
0.0298337284,
0.3869610131,
1.1233330965,
0.8894784451,
-0.1081517413,
0.0191981401,
-0.6760002971,
0.7340452075,
-0.5435880423,
0.1880451143,
0.8308697939,
0.361089468,
-0.1652497053,
-0.7117493153,
-0.5559216738,
-0.283049494,
-0.3041136861,
0.2395681888,
-0.2801518142,
0.3832217157,
0.1924764812,
0.4230354428,
-0.3503504097,
0.0830419511,
-0.3793746531,
-0.452706188,
0.888813138,
-0.0243151411,
0.5359380245,
-0.0159598049,
-0.2655504048,
-0.2748457789,
-0.3650635481,
-0.2788898349,
0.181983605,
0.0621615686,
0.207256034,
0.7085945606,
-0.238924861,
0.6192454696,
0.1167161688,
0.1272574365,
0.4655939341,
-0.4053041339,
-0.4657868743,
-0.1555126011,
0.9005827904,
0.5504811406,
0.5256690383,
-0.3780634999,
-0.4619635642,
0.1991166621,
0.3425771594,
-0.5489861369,
-0.0398604088,
0.1968432963,
-0.4911646843,
-0.0652355999,
0.2103197426,
-0.5248492956,
-0.1513694376,
-0.2907315791,
0.6793748736,
-0.4379898012,
0.2222208828,
0.0424533673,
-0.1174117029,
-0.0334658548,
0.5105025768,
-0.4390845299,
0.2430863529,
0.2094558477,
0.8703862429,
-0.0055868798,
-0.5644862056,
-0.8853493333,
-0.0442332327,
-0.4042086601,
0.8972504139,
-0.2317925841,
-0.3633627892,
-0.3890645802,
-0.1880573332,
-0.1461827308,
-0.4364094138,
0.8258055449,
-0.4953018129,
0.2463946491,
-0.2236824036,
-0.5448988676,
-0.2422124296,
0.1494330019,
-0.8410902619,
1.082926631,
0.1667488068,
-0.6539552212,
0.6314916611,
-1.1892088652,
-0.4967114627,
0.1144512519,
0.1552252173,
-0.2633776665,
0.0270351674,
0.6298470497,
0.3061431944,
-0.1914682835,
0.1350389272,
0.2471890897,
-0.6137189865,
0.2218249887,
-0.4086802304,
0.538623035,
0.5051640868,
-0.6063905358,
0.4761933088,
-0.6497958302,
-0.086905621,
-0.1842058152,
-0.5593748689,
-0.3950919509,
-0.1195363998,
0.1015514806,
0.1662641019,
0.0021866013,
-0.4822948873,
0.2236703336,
-0.4978478849,
0.2321297079,
0.7716950774,
-0.1361515224,
0.4515005946,
-0.381930232,
0.6395502687,
-0.2602163553,
0.255972594,
-0.225034371,
-0.6131279469,
-0.9401740432,
-0.5352602005,
0.719961822,
0.5927584767,
-0.4984360337,
0.7447154522,
-0.0261221081,
-0.4483192861,
-1.2896060944,
-0.0054819221,
0.5268744826,
0.2921411693,
0.6845048666,
-0.4625519514,
-0.5378001332,
-0.9481472969,
-0.2577313483,
-0.3840152323,
-0.0838387311,
-0.1249468774,
0.527120769,
-0.3044234514,
0.8684103489,
-0.1866953373,
-0.5511240363,
-0.090469569,
0.6713840365,
-0.3150889277,
0.6135534048,
0.4605849385,
-0.70204252,
-0.5836932063,
-0.160039708,
-0.3601387739,
-0.5523068309,
-0.2579450011,
-0.2885504663,
0.2678758204,
0.4396473765,
-0.5761607289,
0.6448848248,
0.5255109668,
-0.479079634,
0.4767226279,
-0.4660731256,
0.6512048841,
-0.8780874014,
0.3382396996,
-0.0649757385,
-0.3639520705,
-0.2190024704,
-0.0457965732,
-0.0089093223,
0.1584346443,
-0.1709233522,
0.3364658952,
-0.5388376117,
-0.1909122318,
-0.3236325383,
0.1703677475,
0.1642416418,
0.3055050373,
-0.1298107207,
1.1819143295,
-0.0383756533,
-0.3941850066,
0.1913897544,
0.3759658933,
-0.1287498623,
0.5751157403,
-0.720507741,
0.1498206109,
-0.0851794705,
0.4113752842,
-0.9927283525,
-0.2144594043,
0.3380452096,
-0.7046750188,
0.208976835,
0.0661139116,
-0.6776245832,
-0.3014317453,
-0.2226699889,
0.1802283525,
0.4442317486,
-0.363428086,
0.4439727664,
0.4264538586,
-0.0392099544,
-0.6499066353,
-0.9121857882,
0.4610300362,
-0.0794591829,
-0.4651959836,
0.3283553421,
0.0475442186,
-0.3095573485,
0.2661911249,
0.0936206132,
-0.0036018975,
0.4292691648,
0.2917010784,
0.119265385,
-0.106530942,
0.1217872128,
0.136179015,
-0.5823687315,
-0.0716724843,
-0.2335550636,
0.3684825897,
-0.1604983807,
-0.6708377004,
-0.9398013949,
0.483491689,
0.7726476789,
-0.6592704058,
0.7206099033,
0.6557056308,
-0.5721325278,
0.2170510739,
-0.7020381689,
-0.024060037,
-0.3354389668,
0.5459208488,
-0.2493714243,
-0.4588142633,
0.3064185977,
0.0306277778,
0.1723833829,
0.9620508552,
0.1373862028,
-0.3817717731,
1.2319879532,
0.560746491,
-0.4130176902,
0.3677820861,
-0.1558853686,
-0.096758306,
-0.7366393805,
-0.0210161377,
-0.8449386358,
-0.5946503878,
-0.1930030137,
-0.4993726611,
0.3671463728,
0.1933141351,
-0.1738880575,
0.3752509952,
-0.4440592825,
0.3332004845,
0.8532163501,
-0.0598758869,
0.4512895048,
-0.1781249344,
0.0448021963,
-0.2011415362,
-0.3613773584,
-0.8471903205,
1.0635508299,
0.5330306888,
0.4149165154,
-0.1417791843,
0.5537685156,
0.7454771399,
0.7107977867,
-0.7421055436,
0.4259071946,
0.0836121589,
-0.434235096,
-0.4380385876,
-0.3561817408,
-0.7825751305,
0.0655122548,
-0.3347662985,
-0.5924602747,
-0.1309833974,
0.3925043643,
-0.3649844825,
0.250166595,
-0.8806999922,
0.8059872985,
-0.3578175008,
0.0539542101,
-0.2445396483,
-0.9494621754,
-0.2280985415,
-0.2272732109,
0.0528326035,
-0.0230600052,
-0.0505112484,
1.0968586206,
-0.6063622236,
0.6792998314,
-0.352353245,
0.3158087432,
0.293851763,
0.0239693765,
0.6729819775,
-0.519272387,
-0.1970724165,
-0.0536374189,
-0.2685855925,
-0.4003870189,
-0.2979336679,
0.0080417413,
-0.8768776059,
-0.3757680655,
-0.3282287121,
-0.6629745364,
-0.2304717451,
0.2067435831,
0.3449785709,
-0.0962127596,
0.027704997,
-0.0377587155,
0.0463648364,
-0.1512217671,
0.3778865933,
0.2569153309,
0.0055745509,
-0.4578794241,
0.5791639686,
0.0833198428,
0.1436969638,
0.3743323982,
0.1043225601,
-0.2332476228,
-0.6833289266,
-0.9656819701,
0.1762203425,
-0.4952201843,
-0.3825781941,
-0.6519288421,
-0.0180834588,
-0.1203706935,
-0.1559412181,
-0.5005872846,
-0.604840517,
-0.0367097259,
-0.4094937146,
0.3492444754,
0.4727490544,
-0.164928019,
0.5675056577,
-1.0279577971,
-0.0060574478,
-0.1746194512,
0.1364993602,
-0.2589810789,
-0.596542418,
-0.5323993564,
0.0391653739,
-0.2028294951,
-0.8577010632,
0.3517174125,
0.1654295474,
0.5160756707,
0.2717443705,
0.0506966636,
1.0220749378,
-0.4384138286,
0.7597180605,
-0.0116191432,
-1.2429751158,
0.4550225735,
0.1655890346,
0.0668302551,
0.7525917888,
0.1630769968,
-0.5049442053,
-0.566323936,
-0.4255145788,
-1.1088774204,
0.6417126656,
0.4087244272,
-0.1956170797,
0.083913438,
0.3391611874,
0.0546859838,
0.112938419,
-0.3452308774,
-0.2886260152,
-0.0349061154,
-0.323161453,
-0.0392691083,
-0.1362772137,
-0.0100186048,
-0.1041427776,
0.949977994,
-0.0580250323,
0.2212093323,
0.3883769512,
-0.4542512,
-0.5206543803,
0.2242856771,
0.5894960165,
0.7278284431,
-0.1718579084,
0.1024734303,
0.263861537,
-0.346280843,
0.1182815731,
0.3617402613,
-0.2181821316,
0.1090875939,
0.5473069549,
0.7699831724,
-0.4696602523,
-0.7560760975,
0.5233079791,
0.1189477742,
-0.0916258916,
-0.1049105972,
-0.2530354261,
-0.1937726438,
0.1364489347,
0.6034494638,
0.4430839419,
0.2859724462,
-0.0535791144,
0.3326499164,
0.1761215329,
-0.4570174515,
-0.2898282111,
0.803270936,
0.4629273713,
-0.4102705419,
0.645111084,
-0.1867707521,
-0.7025310397,
0.5883014798,
0.3620789051,
0.9582676291,
-0.3978267312,
0.116397284,
0.2400057018,
0.7192944884,
-0.2001402825,
0.0301304944,
0.0597898141,
-0.3878005147,
-0.9168893099,
-0.5685855746,
-0.4930561483,
-0.1549485922,
-0.6037942767,
0.0768903792,
0.0960881934,
-0.239357233,
-0.1516242176,
-0.0889947861,
-0.5913699269,
0.6320267916,
-0.0347264558,
1.0123851299,
-1.0342309475,
0.6220142841,
0.9668053389,
-0.7682869434,
-0.8328847289,
0.0670094267,
-0.2678586841,
-0.7673002481,
0.7970141172,
0.1836506873,
-0.2709426284,
-0.0458079092,
-0.154308185,
-0.6330658793,
0.8134338856,
0.3865013719,
-0.5697494745,
-0.1465784311,
0.2067112029,
0.7388753295,
-0.103760846,
0.3033038378,
0.6585793495,
0.8429321051,
-0.2935464978,
-1.2799538374,
0.0409056544,
-0.3014872074,
-0.2232720107,
0.4124489129,
-0.3914110959,
0.4786396325,
-0.2150129825,
-0.2021907568,
0.1042765677,
0.7086831331,
-0.3139525354,
0.3490282595,
0.7688000202,
0.4340707362,
0.8080614805,
-0.1893776655,
1.0467808247,
-0.210828051,
0.1872306466,
0.8650470972,
0.0881354436,
0.7722857594,
0.8024194837,
-0.3463580608,
0.0250368472,
0.7605844736,
-0.0649891719,
0.2626233101,
0.3220726848,
0.0919757113,
-0.0756275281,
-0.0820011124,
-0.2829699218,
0.2950484455,
0.211760819,
-0.5077871084,
0.1066877693,
0.0028553247,
0.2044129521,
0.1947616935,
-0.0188651886,
0.7860095501,
-0.1955637783,
-0.8503583074,
0.2057283521,
0.3175368011,
0.5879091024,
-0.3920630813,
-0.041519504,
-0.3629592061,
0.1507812291,
-0.292185694,
-0.4991957843,
0.6519194245,
0.2744244635,
-0.0460129604,
-0.1811800152,
0.3415260911,
-0.3325091004,
-0.3727877736,
0.211407572,
0.620546937,
0.4095801413,
-0.3438316286,
-0.6584014297,
0.0491247438,
-0.1449053884,
-0.4688506424,
-0.0482013524,
0.2137613744,
-0.3256607354,
0.5400465727,
0.5233649611,
0.3050780892,
-0.0697138608,
-0.047202073,
0.5858108401,
-0.5831930041,
-0.4775715172,
-0.8780742288,
0.6741960645,
-0.0850179344,
-0.2530826628,
0.5556938648,
0.4513009489,
0.8263186812,
-0.0143139316,
0.9161543846,
-0.1157744005,
0.3295554519,
-0.3531172872,
0.876914978,
-0.6698468924,
0.1775755137,
-0.503099978,
-0.7367082238,
-0.692055583,
0.833701551,
-0.1880666018,
-0.0100850081,
0.7299631834,
0.4665265083,
0.1213829741,
-0.0605815537,
0.1490796804,
-0.0034353288,
0.4069259763,
0.2401473373,
0.8566709757,
-0.596434176,
0.6234585643,
-0.1500701606,
-0.4624454975,
-0.3092521727,
-0.8603238463,
-0.5358439684,
-0.4679308236,
-0.4663298428,
-0.3747172356,
0.1344703436,
1.3460797071,
0.747507751,
-0.801002562,
-0.0729658455,
0.0302800611,
-0.2667846084,
-0.631495893,
-0.1574470103,
0.7747537494,
-0.4494920671,
-1.0746313334,
0.3205948472,
0.3492303193,
0.0315671042,
-0.0792584345,
-0.22917068,
-0.1529992223,
0.0458420366,
0.3303921819,
0.1114772186,
-0.6877827048,
-0.4918366075,
-0.1110838056,
-0.3377036452,
0.1476201266,
0.4416701496,
-0.4368332028,
0.5444989204,
0.2927069366,
1.2524085045,
0.2768954039,
0.2457722127,
0.6907599568,
-0.5768638849,
0.1381012946,
0.2036810815,
0.4635299742,
0.4379635751,
-0.2854626477,
0.7945939898,
0.1921652406,
-0.6389070749,
-0.78158921,
-0.1429135203,
-0.8239219189,
0.1743346304,
0.7304216027,
-0.4583912194,
-0.1826100647,
-0.0522450283,
-0.7993667722,
0.4951457083,
-0.4592136443,
0.9835867882,
0.7270430326,
-0.261713922,
0.2130714655,
-0.3580798507,
0.5159178972,
0.7293203473,
-1.0460927486,
-0.2966115177,
0.5613333583,
-0.1025499031,
0.4284559786,
0.7100464106,
-0.0931163877,
0.4248916209,
-0.0765091255,
0.3425747156,
-0.3344646096,
-0.2965406179,
-0.0006290186,
-0.018215077,
0.4260595143,
-0.885920763
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12416v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12416v2 | Beyond Under-Alignment: Atomic Preference Enhanced Factuality Tuning for Large Language Models | 2024-06-18T09:07:30 | 2024-06-27T12:07:55 | Hongbang Yuan, Yubo Chen, Pengfei Cao, Zhuoran Jin, Kang Liu, Jun Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) have achieved remarkable success but still tend
to generate factually erroneous responses, a phenomenon known as hallucination.
A recent trend is to use preference learning to fine-tune models to align with
factuality. However, existing work primarily evaluates fine-tuned models on
in-domain (ID) datasets and the factuality on out-of-domain (OOD) datasets
remains underexplored. In this paper, we conduct a comprehensive evaluation of
the factuality of different models tuned by various preference learning
algorithms and demonstrate that their performance on OOD datasets either
increases minimally or decreases. Subsequently, we reveal that the main cause
of model's failure to uphold factuality under a distribution shift is
\textbf{under-alignment}, rather than \textbf{over-alignment}, by analyzing the
token distribution shift of the models before and after tuning. Finally, we
propose \textbf{APEFT} (\textbf{A}tomic \textbf{P}reference \textbf{E}nhanced
\textbf{F}actuality \textbf{T}uning), a framework that enhances model's
awareness of factuality at the granularity of individual facts. Extensive
experiments demonstrate that APEFT improves model performance by an average of
$\boldsymbol{3.45\%}$ on both ID and OOD datasets, which is highly effective. | [
-0.4674374759,
-0.7887582779,
0.7944875956,
-0.3731062114,
-0.3321945369,
-0.084616676,
-0.4125222564,
-0.4644942582,
0.0285952576,
0.5888593197,
-0.308436662,
-0.4315260649,
-0.4381439686,
0.1479897946,
-0.094599396,
1.06102705,
0.188601613,
-0.074728027,
-0.2101973742,
-0.1951144338,
-0.2462488711,
-0.5881322026,
-0.1564822793,
-0.4483437538,
0.1639986187,
0.4172773659,
1.1195145845,
0.9666242003,
0.6338297129,
0.2343138009,
0.0037876603,
0.6366684437,
-0.6028122902,
-0.146109879,
-0.388189286,
-0.4657032192,
-0.656465888,
-0.0299447346,
0.6341810822,
0.6828988791,
-0.1171287447,
0.0418950468,
-0.1681718975,
0.7730483413,
-0.7470632792,
0.0450562537,
-1.0649455786,
-0.1566985399,
-0.1241669431,
-0.2454786301,
-0.5102003813,
-0.5111303926,
0.2613869905,
-0.693877697,
0.3029500842,
0.5046672225,
1.0609921217,
0.3907120824,
-0.5794329643,
-0.2022532374,
-0.7316730022,
0.9202435613,
-0.8903846145,
0.6303795576,
0.5225386024,
-0.0772441253,
-0.1649106592,
-0.2382713407,
-0.6929830313,
-0.2965895832,
-0.0877559483,
-0.1443347186,
0.04928701,
0.1747508049,
0.12190108,
0.6199128032,
-0.3615854084,
0.1816799045,
-0.0287567489,
-0.1220400557,
0.7594666481,
0.0190899502,
0.0782003701,
-0.0130377663,
-0.3813709915,
-0.1535367817,
-0.8358036876,
-0.3433986604,
0.4061729908,
0.5828209519,
-0.0836449862,
0.6933323741,
-0.1743882149,
0.5041381717,
0.4575586319,
-0.0944873765,
0.4209923446,
-0.1865046471,
-0.3619942665,
0.3787844777,
0.480832696,
0.3660623431,
0.2634386718,
-0.1704697609,
-0.3300232589,
0.0976539329,
0.3503871858,
-0.7623701692,
-0.2136192918,
0.2658981085,
-0.4318293631,
-0.2835873067,
0.2008471489,
-0.5441817641,
-0.6531226635,
-0.6992712021,
0.3521694243,
-0.4765817523,
-0.3784211576,
0.318192482,
0.1304406077,
0.0432766005,
0.2741005421,
-1.1515114307,
0.1789929271,
0.9301650524,
0.8752065897,
-0.4388613105,
-0.1826118976,
-0.360483855,
0.0486187078,
-0.596978128,
0.9811221361,
-0.5920068026,
-0.1959746778,
-0.1253999025,
-0.1952679604,
-0.1416966915,
-0.7930564284,
0.5983268619,
-0.7645863891,
-0.0941730887,
-0.6807197928,
-0.8233544827,
-0.2468138188,
0.1987771541,
-0.5345438123,
0.8698940873,
-0.16107741,
-0.6322178245,
0.8419161439,
-0.6430168152,
-0.346252799,
-0.3073211312,
-0.1977445185,
-0.4578576088,
0.4204637706,
0.2137794346,
0.2813427746,
-0.3041367829,
0.5580548644,
-0.6506419182,
-0.3090407252,
0.4872869551,
-0.5741557479,
0.5228272676,
0.1647463888,
-0.4012291133,
0.1969676763,
-0.8872801661,
-0.2374461889,
-0.0881112665,
-0.2237102538,
-0.4157796502,
0.1404006928,
-0.1954175979,
0.0619486161,
0.0909898579,
-0.4870897532,
0.2878039181,
-0.734998405,
0.2096944004,
0.9727886319,
-0.152905032,
0.4511822164,
-0.5802824497,
0.0328302719,
0.0966957211,
0.0725167468,
0.2572914064,
-0.2360419184,
-0.7474730611,
-0.3358666599,
0.2381768525,
0.3464395404,
-0.249080807,
0.7554880381,
-0.5026891232,
-0.1471082717,
-0.6138301492,
0.0479420871,
0.2486382872,
0.6963037252,
0.4758615494,
-0.3151718974,
-0.3302073777,
-0.804444015,
-0.0645130426,
-0.3803650737,
0.267519027,
0.4662751555,
0.4139455855,
-0.3545028865,
1.1810172796,
-0.5819066167,
-0.1062672809,
-0.0344157666,
0.1058832705,
0.1819598675,
0.3002921343,
0.447014451,
-0.9466536045,
-0.2660241425,
0.304458797,
-0.5669951439,
-0.0102594625,
0.0818353295,
-0.1355257034,
0.7247489691,
0.2936771214,
-0.7653690577,
0.3136927783,
0.3023829758,
-0.2278361917,
0.6509187818,
-0.1929503977,
0.2692245841,
-0.8846420646,
0.1214196086,
-0.1497727782,
-0.2516041994,
-0.4300073385,
-0.0419881344,
0.0719247982,
0.3372787237,
-0.4435519576,
0.5609102845,
-0.3398955464,
-0.1506593972,
-0.5179368854,
0.1391697824,
-0.1002706811,
0.3030905128,
0.3276897073,
0.8471875191,
0.40272668,
-0.7577774525,
0.2010457963,
0.4377263486,
-0.4004586637,
0.3438791931,
-0.3916382492,
0.1959607303,
-0.1111374125,
0.0293332152,
-0.9941248298,
-0.2718483806,
0.1539900601,
-0.2645340264,
0.3510507941,
-0.114830181,
-0.341368705,
0.2209220082,
-0.4030387998,
0.4921679795,
0.4507979751,
-0.8361786604,
0.3707861006,
0.4346863329,
0.233707726,
-0.7190930843,
-0.4551110864,
-0.2550138831,
-0.4295727611,
-0.4126193523,
0.3082513511,
-0.098317951,
-0.5146707892,
-0.0665028766,
-0.3296571374,
0.2447064966,
0.0349493511,
0.0890076607,
0.4552599192,
-0.4883841276,
0.282792747,
0.0188366696,
-0.0888666958,
-0.0553630553,
-0.255803138,
0.5984943509,
-0.230827257,
-0.2436981946,
-0.2069873512,
-0.1774633229,
0.4770616591,
-0.015551934,
0.9214766622,
0.1935281008,
-0.2258749604,
-0.2074114084,
-0.579166472,
-0.4266965389,
-0.5013762712,
0.3265433311,
-0.1772190034,
-0.7321817279,
0.366981864,
-0.0487284213,
0.0338182896,
0.552392602,
0.5672035813,
0.1814565212,
1.0125445127,
0.6686789989,
-0.2922234535,
0.4411281049,
0.0505501851,
0.3910155892,
-0.717016995,
0.0817386135,
-0.3968915343,
0.0133932,
-0.7120798826,
-0.2710352838,
0.4015374184,
-0.0248197261,
-0.412971288,
0.0334070884,
-0.0685610473,
0.610979259,
0.2272222936,
0.0549349934,
0.4470575452,
0.1534070522,
-0.007931116,
0.074724704,
-0.5561033487,
-0.5012128353,
1.350591898,
0.2454164475,
0.7489593625,
0.1270469278,
0.3260343671,
0.3789884448,
0.1725410819,
-0.8843969703,
0.3296462893,
-0.2028955966,
-0.8024045825,
-0.5238139033,
-0.4282941222,
-0.5840386748,
0.355869323,
-0.4885088503,
-0.8007100821,
0.5688535571,
0.5224681497,
-0.5490595102,
0.3007606268,
-0.5331112742,
0.6939311624,
-0.2494462281,
-0.311312288,
-0.4538143277,
-0.6715621948,
0.4396677911,
-0.2211226523,
0.1038127169,
-0.3682501912,
0.2127580345,
0.3006994128,
-0.3015306294,
0.7720026374,
0.2045366466,
-0.2943032682,
-0.1735310704,
0.0035531528,
0.6125320792,
0.2299094349,
-0.3846138418,
0.3818612993,
-0.2113430053,
-0.0255072247,
-0.5949823856,
0.6474524736,
-0.9777827263,
-0.7286762595,
-0.4783431888,
-0.5462254882,
-0.4664531052,
0.3464570642,
0.3772866726,
0.5015524626,
-0.2525431812,
0.1679461598,
1.0206005573,
-0.0607414953,
0.1490833759,
0.518512547,
-0.3002737463,
-0.3305335343,
0.9740501046,
0.0856044218,
0.4399612546,
0.4489914179,
0.3634629846,
-0.5944726467,
-0.6216742396,
-0.4397456348,
0.5099517703,
-0.7503370643,
-0.2447167486,
-0.5634349585,
-0.1615050584,
-0.7463178039,
-0.1428901404,
-0.5807981491,
-0.3888257146,
-0.3843942583,
-0.283876121,
0.3879350722,
0.4950920343,
-0.0355950743,
0.2486317158,
-0.5413013697,
0.4968752265,
0.1157332286,
0.4167146683,
-0.1665955484,
-0.8997517228,
-0.26603055,
0.1259857714,
-0.2697033286,
-0.4491361082,
0.3002749383,
0.3256879151,
0.328805387,
0.7984750867,
0.3651518226,
0.8644779325,
-0.4256788194,
0.5523393154,
-0.245833829,
-1.1378918886,
0.1606964767,
-0.2631748915,
-0.0527697802,
0.6671488285,
0.4031772912,
-0.2533340454,
-0.1515650749,
-0.6065960526,
-0.9160175323,
0.9626798034,
0.0647398829,
0.0505783968,
0.0654626563,
0.4732500613,
0.4861742258,
0.570358634,
-0.4920783937,
-0.3265961707,
-0.1127189547,
-0.1133198664,
-0.3460459709,
-0.2550245225,
-0.077958703,
-0.3198679388,
1.0737088919,
-0.3173421919,
0.0136938831,
0.1303571761,
-0.136457935,
-0.4165751338,
0.2284836471,
0.6169765592,
0.9300044179,
-0.5568638444,
0.2119934559,
0.0431601703,
-0.2662571967,
-0.0662351698,
-0.0214105342,
-0.2731908262,
-0.2597131133,
0.2259349376,
1.2020647526,
-0.0551212728,
-0.5759437084,
0.3605877757,
0.2100359946,
0.1018746495,
-0.123237893,
0.2462078333,
-0.4402558208,
0.1074167937,
0.1517046243,
0.2150760889,
0.3419762254,
-0.7060915232,
0.1671882719,
0.7353296876,
-0.1762360632,
-0.4308247268,
0.5523852706,
-0.0750575066,
0.1639670581,
0.6585444808,
0.0432051867,
-0.4092739522,
0.4312532842,
0.7846364379,
0.8706101775,
0.0136547005,
0.2614495754,
0.0856992379,
0.3411061466,
-0.3531985581,
0.0173200965,
-0.1605220735,
-1.3862098455,
-0.1648998857,
-0.6168729663,
-0.4238623977,
0.2112032324,
-0.6503667831,
0.3274985552,
-0.351924777,
-0.3158037066,
-0.0121940589,
-0.024848057,
-0.2483310848,
0.404507637,
0.1457222402,
0.5235764384,
-1.0379101038,
0.8824676275,
0.7470474243,
-0.07120049,
-0.5619058013,
0.4937386811,
0.0818984732,
-0.8244865537,
0.2756075859,
0.0075829434,
-0.3402983546,
-0.0029401837,
-0.512116015,
-1.1713962555,
0.6017968059,
0.8151473999,
-0.4540916085,
0.218944326,
0.2555522919,
0.5169506669,
-0.4045642912,
0.2502613664,
0.9273604751,
0.4350478351,
0.1385027617,
-0.9030480981,
0.0667480603,
0.0493328087,
-0.0897810385,
0.335596323,
-0.9034729004,
0.8299075961,
-0.2362532914,
-0.1554971933,
-0.19032529,
0.7672001123,
0.4179777205,
0.2789720595,
0.5070937872,
0.4650093913,
1.0786859989,
0.1196193546,
0.8959388137,
-0.2265770137,
0.5516700745,
1.02711308,
-0.6497155428,
0.8121383786,
0.4934567511,
-0.0587110259,
0.2236818075,
0.6105721593,
0.0980887339,
0.6344846487,
-0.2645886838,
0.0845082551,
-0.608207643,
-0.1669600308,
-0.4077111781,
0.2907072008,
0.2253675759,
-0.2369885296,
0.0347238183,
-0.1952961683,
-0.0295953751,
0.0553560108,
-0.2639017999,
0.820395112,
0.0246867668,
-0.5718380213,
0.8394643068,
-0.0574776269,
0.5606772304,
-0.3926979899,
0.100337334,
-0.3128355145,
0.2881214619,
-0.305144608,
-0.4142533541,
0.2527134717,
-0.2459690571,
-0.4699881077,
0.102685146,
0.48442325,
-0.3617126942,
-0.3796589077,
0.0765638351,
0.0122833969,
-0.080373466,
0.0044983234,
-0.5249909163,
0.1754838377,
-0.0470437445,
-0.3027148843,
0.2239337564,
0.4655397534,
-0.2118465453,
0.5222042799,
0.5609934926,
0.1938707978,
-0.0957773179,
-0.1324798018,
0.7116559744,
-0.5142951012,
-0.5259882212,
-1.1056091785,
0.1920514107,
-0.0462005176,
-0.4776235223,
0.920232594,
0.6987329125,
1.0115327835,
-0.0636426508,
0.7312397361,
0.1981783807,
0.4020108879,
-0.8568642735,
0.5977908373,
-0.7220464349,
0.3105484843,
-0.3189738691,
-0.9826598167,
-0.4010378718,
0.5335108638,
-0.6215754747,
-0.0437748432,
0.7113214731,
0.876765728,
-0.3985356688,
0.1457759738,
0.4079739153,
0.325917393,
0.1604468822,
0.0686365813,
0.7323718071,
-0.2129456252,
-0.1497669518,
-0.174358502,
-0.1082042083,
-0.4851972461,
-0.9533908367,
-0.9118133783,
-0.4836685956,
-0.445695132,
-0.2379223108,
0.1543275565,
1.4819933176,
0.7977032065,
-1.2487796545,
-0.1947193891,
-0.1114090532,
0.1655830741,
-0.1348419189,
-0.1850228906,
0.616579473,
-0.3590411842,
-0.5913743973,
0.4485853314,
0.2392529696,
0.0629958659,
0.1480282098,
0.0029559876,
0.0494371392,
0.5992877483,
0.4808245003,
0.2159137428,
-0.6748110652,
-0.3966211081,
-0.1650739908,
0.1192948446,
0.496891439,
0.8101121187,
-0.4802936614,
0.3226626217,
0.3866195083,
0.5948168039,
0.1758737713,
0.5483831763,
0.5779097676,
-0.5202661157,
0.2145436853,
0.0500190631,
0.2613402605,
0.2396491468,
-0.7281545997,
0.1658079028,
0.3660005033,
-0.7498897314,
-1.088968277,
0.1398788542,
-0.7773760557,
-0.3501820862,
1.3084869385,
0.2766661942,
-0.18869178,
-0.1415250599,
-0.1984479725,
0.3579799533,
-0.6755506396,
1.2810441256,
0.6549279094,
-0.2860725224,
0.2590663135,
-0.1819398701,
0.8395249844,
0.584959507,
-0.7087349892,
0.4526575506,
0.7531914711,
0.2183274925,
0.0773944482,
0.3864383101,
-0.0033284482,
0.1344670057,
-0.3950041831,
-0.0854392201,
0.0693248957,
-0.6608632207,
-0.5673245788,
0.0226306338,
0.3574105203,
-0.0344440378
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12403v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12403v1 | PDSS: A Privacy-Preserving Framework for Step-by-Step Distillation of Large Language Models | 2024-06-18T08:48:14 | 2024-06-18T08:48:14 | Tao Fan, Yan Kang, Weijing Chen, Hanlin Gu, Yuanfeng Song, Lixin Fan, Kai Chen, Qiang Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In the context of real-world applications, leveraging large language models
(LLMs) for domain-specific tasks often faces two major challenges:
domain-specific knowledge privacy and constrained resources. To address these
issues, we propose PDSS, a privacy-preserving framework for step-by-step
distillation of LLMs. PDSS works on a server-client architecture, wherein
client transmits perturbed prompts to the server's LLM for rationale
generation. The generated rationales are then decoded by the client and used to
enrich the training of task-specific small language model(SLM) within a
multi-task learning paradigm. PDSS introduces two privacy protection
strategies: the Exponential Mechanism Strategy and the Encoder-Decoder
Strategy, balancing prompt privacy and rationale usability. Experiments
demonstrate the effectiveness of PDSS in various text generation tasks,
enabling the training of task-specific SLM with enhanced performance while
prioritizing data privacy protection. | [
-0.1422850192,
-0.7173639536,
0.6687986255,
0.3614540994,
-0.1961199641,
0.2021133453,
-0.2426294088,
0.2234181613,
-0.259483248,
0.6431539655,
-0.5841837525,
-0.5622187257,
-0.4574877024,
0.1230156347,
-0.5114825964,
1.2924971581,
-0.0236525703,
0.0397127308,
-0.1588095725,
0.308065623,
0.2037031502,
-0.5500664711,
-0.8565198183,
-0.0598534085,
0.4584426284,
0.1045205146,
0.3623440862,
0.732636869,
0.2111128718,
0.2770884335,
-0.2133648843,
0.2736112773,
-0.5232021809,
0.5948733687,
-0.3559683859,
-0.5806825757,
-0.5041067004,
-0.0689911544,
0.6250990033,
0.7178276181,
-0.5164816976,
0.3448475301,
0.3818536699,
0.7139268517,
-0.7022452354,
0.1468279511,
-0.4156529605,
-0.0485606678,
-0.2661652267,
-0.2491159141,
-0.5671301484,
-0.4716410041,
0.2832384408,
-0.2650724947,
0.3877582848,
0.0312683955,
0.4545770586,
0.1805259585,
-0.417884469,
0.0224923212,
-0.6092934608,
0.7383517623,
-0.6029977202,
0.3854904175,
0.6898628473,
0.388816148,
-0.3401841819,
-0.7217237353,
-0.6693563461,
-0.0574623533,
0.0879213139,
-0.5047220588,
0.0603568181,
0.2003213763,
0.4807175696,
0.2464908212,
-0.583322823,
-0.0270042103,
-0.0682279766,
-0.3129022419,
0.5088293552,
0.1200454831,
-0.0471626818,
0.0284318905,
-0.4206836522,
-0.0062818564,
-1.0374009609,
-0.0414699763,
0.32148996,
0.3110701442,
-0.1571904719,
0.3503774703,
-0.2799867988,
0.5332463384,
0.3120386004,
-0.8112996221,
0.0607458726,
-0.1201957986,
-0.522720933,
-0.1794461161,
0.8211812973,
0.0525241494,
-0.0598122887,
-0.3666945398,
-0.0986128077,
-0.0331065468,
0.0492742099,
-1.081302762,
-0.3307746053,
0.3359803855,
-0.3786330223,
-0.3974691927,
-0.2812912762,
-0.7904250026,
-0.7226345539,
-0.4494308829,
-0.0615496375,
-0.2717213631,
-0.126716271,
0.1105827987,
-0.0577267669,
-0.2160777748,
0.4286807179,
-1.0024390221,
0.6304435134,
0.7815117836,
0.7652052045,
-0.2554143369,
-0.3195176125,
-0.6843106151,
0.4967310131,
-0.1293913275,
0.111839667,
-0.293207705,
-0.4846407175,
0.0486936681,
0.1434081197,
0.1593827903,
-0.3782242835,
0.1126445085,
-0.6119177938,
0.0768556148,
-0.4814713597,
-0.5805027485,
0.1117424518,
0.1828583181,
-0.5060126781,
0.686424613,
-0.1740274876,
-0.7291023135,
0.4063003063,
-0.5543752313,
-0.4447343647,
0.0538390353,
-0.3339248598,
-0.4990260601,
0.0682640523,
0.0482910946,
0.5976752043,
-0.4165262878,
0.2399162054,
-0.3324059844,
0.0859894827,
0.381202966,
-0.6498377323,
0.9495500922,
0.3656847775,
-0.3827598989,
-0.057506863,
-0.8938197494,
-0.1724144071,
0.1000223756,
-0.4868369997,
-0.3544155359,
0.1105429158,
-0.3101682365,
0.1738941371,
0.4372797906,
-0.7020501494,
-0.0858293623,
-0.1238508672,
0.6451018453,
0.82857728,
0.1063376218,
0.7181639075,
-0.1008480713,
0.5764428377,
0.2257857174,
0.1623947918,
-0.3077156842,
-0.2316929102,
-0.4090456665,
-0.5296754241,
0.2825802565,
0.4698724449,
-0.8061167002,
0.4979562759,
-0.2805714607,
-0.2760336101,
-0.2184111774,
0.2008118778,
0.4482189119,
0.4464091957,
-0.0913930833,
-0.2085113972,
-0.217599988,
-0.7522196174,
-0.0388320982,
0.0758089274,
-0.1680000275,
-0.0462327786,
0.2427017987,
-0.0410460681,
0.9475153089,
-0.5697389841,
-0.320864141,
-0.1646414697,
0.1013635099,
-0.2708718479,
0.6768171191,
0.4834165871,
-0.7585018873,
-0.6855136156,
-0.2630476654,
-0.5785230398,
-0.0374880061,
-0.0082928073,
-0.1107751131,
0.2185037285,
0.340682745,
-0.7996219993,
0.4553170502,
0.554076612,
-0.123098053,
0.2731495798,
-0.4691691697,
0.0660496801,
-1.1262789965,
0.0124361878,
0.2127698958,
-0.5964902639,
-0.6802497506,
0.136280328,
0.2204323858,
-0.3466269374,
-0.4172057509,
0.2130069882,
-0.6866547465,
0.2009254992,
-0.4402212501,
0.0781263039,
0.2161765546,
0.3617798984,
0.0784785673,
0.7516165972,
0.8448287249,
-0.7678266764,
0.281558454,
0.1516530663,
-0.1155079678,
0.7941766977,
-0.3158643246,
0.4023295343,
-0.2691981792,
0.3109924793,
-0.7377043962,
-0.0397100747,
0.1043000519,
-0.0242204498,
0.5073581934,
-0.3185892105,
-0.7882649302,
-0.1293222159,
-0.412873894,
0.0585895367,
0.5936755538,
-0.6490154266,
0.5624542832,
0.6484724879,
-0.4189733267,
-0.6399841905,
-0.6276314259,
0.148034513,
-0.3949529231,
-0.256442368,
0.2485000342,
-0.1350687444,
-0.2660829127,
-0.2683323622,
-0.2967962623,
-0.3632572293,
0.1090365797,
0.3836901188,
0.189180702,
0.2664383054,
-0.3312308788,
0.609913826,
-0.0503459871,
0.1915113628,
-0.3904706836,
0.401936084,
0.3061684966,
-0.2999954224,
-0.6772189736,
0.4430295825,
0.5750715137,
-0.1847369075,
0.9112702012,
0.1663705856,
-0.394500345,
-0.7835018635,
-0.4407418966,
-0.2029373199,
-0.5756358504,
0.2004679143,
-0.5232692957,
-1.0402686596,
0.3104206026,
-0.3510340154,
0.2358763516,
-0.2529509962,
0.4208858609,
0.1741073877,
0.9658387899,
0.7903530598,
-0.1710869372,
0.3440558612,
-0.0633085668,
0.428184092,
-0.6286231875,
-0.2148728371,
-0.5578884482,
-0.0526313521,
-0.2839486301,
-0.3597498238,
0.1743324846,
-0.0375201441,
-0.2073573321,
0.4122713804,
-0.5249159336,
0.7759829164,
0.2108234912,
0.0940037444,
0.3444029987,
0.2016868591,
0.02290898,
-0.1753391623,
-0.4383905828,
-0.7537490129,
1.2664369345,
0.5091205835,
1.1003134251,
0.3018690348,
1.1479943991,
0.3180111051,
0.0544378608,
-0.2979934216,
0.9736703634,
-0.1262108982,
-0.6079885364,
-0.4388590157,
-0.622590065,
-0.647994101,
0.3807326853,
0.280801475,
-0.8961032033,
0.3501172066,
0.3020523787,
-0.4828053415,
0.1359072179,
-0.5687568784,
0.6518802643,
-0.0544436984,
-0.7800840139,
-0.1093920544,
-0.7769089341,
0.2990431786,
-0.1767349243,
0.2746175528,
-0.061178647,
-0.1576547176,
0.4608058035,
-0.5775527358,
1.1505055428,
-0.575617373,
-0.5064128041,
0.0057313247,
0.4889797866,
0.7080922723,
0.2655426264,
0.0920561031,
-0.0737114623,
0.1598442346,
-0.1000704393,
-0.5353813767,
1.0371348858,
-0.2092275023,
-0.6609044671,
-0.5081880689,
-0.4338187873,
-0.191977635,
0.212783739,
0.011004705,
0.2008319944,
-0.1447662115,
0.1277065575,
1.1360197067,
0.0065045441,
0.5123568773,
0.8734456897,
-0.2674969137,
-0.2624506652,
0.9628731608,
-0.0835010186,
0.3853714764,
0.4023228586,
-0.0646988302,
-0.5771734715,
-0.7211480141,
-0.4991926849,
0.1333037168,
-0.6689103842,
-0.1707358956,
-0.5098845363,
-0.0174348801,
-0.3838468194,
0.0520540699,
-0.2823665738,
-0.4475125372,
-0.4869315922,
-0.1603635848,
0.2533947229,
0.4833462834,
-0.0992365628,
0.1991701275,
-0.7284778357,
0.5376042128,
0.3136500418,
0.411157012,
-0.0939691067,
-0.3172720373,
-0.1165745333,
0.197965309,
-0.2595789135,
-0.8515802622,
0.5359360576,
0.2241244167,
0.3766805828,
0.2927155793,
0.3475532234,
0.6147538424,
-0.8839657307,
0.8544711471,
0.1929046363,
-1.0925513506,
0.5120900273,
-0.1141153425,
-0.0951780751,
0.7288607955,
0.3715669513,
-0.1138012484,
-0.4121858478,
-0.417637974,
-0.6607792377,
0.8768265247,
0.111118637,
0.0666188821,
0.0222338047,
0.3709820211,
0.3325921893,
0.6767551899,
-0.6805531383,
-0.3139258623,
0.0186920967,
-0.3065428734,
0.1016536057,
-0.1355894208,
-0.5835641623,
-0.1378737539,
0.5980268717,
-0.010037791,
-0.1963234395,
-0.0405398868,
-0.1325338781,
-0.0165352318,
0.3697599769,
0.3418879509,
0.5194111466,
0.1038169861,
0.2221627235,
0.0137176523,
-0.5426208377,
0.4261882305,
0.3270163238,
-0.3720337152,
-0.1427185237,
-0.5055769682,
0.684697032,
-0.0019948869,
-0.6088915467,
0.5963612199,
-0.1969739199,
-0.2295716256,
-0.1291243136,
0.1570204794,
0.0626190305,
0.1027113646,
0.2165442109,
-0.0716136917,
0.2844018936,
-0.3623206317,
0.0434182994,
0.3502359092,
0.1894719899,
-0.382066071,
0.8226761222,
0.2640636861,
-0.2393018305,
-0.0862789303,
-0.5261000991,
-0.1500589848,
0.120710589,
0.6091861129,
1.0538237095,
-0.4193808436,
0.3511088192,
-0.0842275694,
0.015834637,
-0.5056171417,
0.4092512429,
-0.5540302992,
-0.1820539832,
-0.2281874865,
-0.7908933759,
-0.5288267136,
0.1070499793,
-0.640779376,
-0.004529024,
-0.8054878116,
-0.2922403216,
0.0974733904,
-0.3118064404,
-0.3284763992,
0.1327738166,
0.1678572595,
0.7137352228,
-0.5598911643,
1.2258980274,
0.4308398962,
-0.2615535557,
-0.6176180243,
0.1556363106,
0.2901936471,
-0.3150453866,
0.6458803415,
-0.2225321531,
-0.1749889255,
-0.1062938794,
-0.4521410465,
-0.8091637492,
1.0483883619,
0.7312468886,
-1.0040594339,
-0.2157667279,
0.4543685913,
0.5725644231,
-0.2384367436,
-0.6693017483,
0.5856209397,
0.008985647,
-0.1783128679,
-1.0751091242,
0.4024919271,
0.1271916479,
0.3277416825,
0.2126420736,
-0.3599666655,
0.8427573442,
-0.0327172503,
-0.3670965731,
0.1517291367,
0.3723480701,
0.5037423968,
0.1922999769,
0.3998075724,
0.4014131129,
0.7741798162,
0.0461874194,
0.84610641,
-0.4614095688,
0.2924806774,
1.1679360867,
-0.8512744904,
0.7023456097,
0.4735536575,
-0.4716251791,
0.3864428103,
0.096224688,
0.4817786813,
0.9421543479,
0.4364024699,
-0.664090395,
0.0160454344,
0.1901552528,
-0.2616263032,
0.1015326679,
0.387794286,
-0.540541172,
-0.2818525732,
0.1300058216,
0.2509223521,
0.1851423085,
-0.0181785859,
0.9178665876,
0.2452701479,
-0.5677402616,
0.4320908487,
0.1364313364,
0.5076755881,
-0.8024349809,
0.112306051,
0.1071026176,
0.3945662379,
-0.1187685728,
-0.5391876698,
0.1851064265,
0.3632676899,
-0.3188881278,
-0.6136994362,
0.52219522,
-0.8018372655,
-0.1297005117,
0.037725538,
0.3134523928,
-0.0164444894,
0.022770483,
-0.6052615047,
0.097417362,
-0.0050151511,
-0.2258170247,
0.8603432178,
0.7404151559,
0.2651149333,
0.5615621805,
0.7498544455,
0.2992720008,
0.1246928945,
0.3153817952,
0.8836946487,
-0.4048784673,
-0.8474839926,
-0.9474602938,
0.4269391298,
-0.3435481191,
0.0439262837,
1.0865705013,
0.5792037845,
0.5802921653,
-0.0852313936,
1.0469130278,
0.0377823263,
0.8468299508,
-0.3780790567,
0.9711948633,
-0.166838184,
0.6505144835,
-0.1711423397,
-0.7974048853,
-0.0079982886,
0.5633570552,
-0.1203784719,
-0.2442607582,
0.6033132076,
0.7724164724,
0.1966985166,
0.1523486972,
0.1503652334,
-0.0464551486,
0.5941306949,
0.239984706,
0.4596270919,
-0.0898662135,
0.1913689822,
-0.5947912931,
-0.4703842402,
0.3875930607,
-0.9996666312,
-1.0586844683,
-0.5771303773,
-0.5102027655,
-0.3471238315,
0.15859209,
0.7721145153,
0.7490288019,
-0.6758976579,
-0.3341775835,
-0.3441571891,
-0.224800542,
-0.1649877578,
-0.1494051665,
0.1993895322,
-0.3071376085,
-0.7572062016,
0.4677174091,
0.4179978371,
0.2170331478,
-0.630830586,
-0.035446085,
0.2108118534,
0.0784160569,
0.6727266312,
0.3828754723,
-0.5758546591,
0.0922372118,
-0.2128438205,
-0.2839054465,
-0.3097438514,
0.9100064635,
-0.583440721,
0.3438593447,
0.3709625602,
0.6024105549,
0.6001680493,
-0.0835124403,
0.5716542006,
-1.0809175968,
0.2828427255,
0.1842691898,
0.4655292332,
0.3909516335,
-0.4512677491,
0.102536194,
0.1285875738,
-0.5843222141,
-1.2281426191,
0.2570991516,
-1.0421031713,
-0.2541989684,
1.1147242785,
-0.5859187245,
-0.2722880244,
-0.3521979451,
-0.2004225254,
-0.042273324,
-0.587220192,
0.7585971355,
0.3790117502,
0.21545358,
-0.110750109,
-0.1758814156,
0.9738314748,
0.0613013059,
-0.8039653897,
0.6992599368,
0.7020765543,
0.5184444189,
0.1184407622,
0.8057234287,
-0.2317515463,
0.0405097753,
0.0351312086,
-0.406172663,
-0.1109706983,
-0.5175163746,
-0.3812683821,
0.5111756921,
0.1119144186,
-0.3464528024
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12402v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12402v1 | Flee the Flaw: Annotating the Underlying Logic of Fallacious Arguments Through Templates and Slot-filling | 2024-06-18T08:44:45 | 2024-06-18T08:44:45 | Irfan Robbani, Paul Reisert, Naoya Inoue, Surawat Pothong, Camélia Guerraoui, Wenzhi Wang, Shoichi Naito, Jungmin Choi, Kentaro Inui | cs.CL | cs.CL | Prior research in computational argumentation has mainly focused on scoring
the quality of arguments, with less attention on explicating logical errors. In
this work, we introduce four sets of explainable templates for common informal
logical fallacies designed to explicate a fallacy's implicit logic. Using our
templates, we conduct an annotation study on top of 400 fallacious arguments
taken from LOGIC dataset and achieve a high agreement score (Krippendorf's
alpha of 0.54) and reasonable coverage (0.83). Finally, we conduct an
experiment for detecting the structure of fallacies and discover that
state-of-the-art language models struggle with detecting fallacy templates
(0.47 accuracy). To facilitate research on fallacies, we make our dataset and
guidelines publicly available. | [
-0.4899458289,
-0.764962256,
0.7216919661,
0.0079785315,
-0.256663084,
-0.0712319836,
0.0958878472,
-0.0690081716,
0.0290335156,
0.2792763412,
-0.5871261954,
-0.1954825073,
-0.4937046766,
0.1943958551,
-0.5829516649,
1.0328444242,
-0.2215842754,
-0.1197083294,
-0.2441175133,
-0.2890584767,
-0.4157083035,
-0.5554501414,
-0.3894981146,
-0.1210258454,
0.5021374226,
0.664432168,
0.6565322876,
0.5008103848,
0.302131325,
0.2480968386,
-0.0187462643,
0.1931535751,
-0.2562904954,
-0.2652997971,
-0.1917505264,
-0.3743290007,
-0.1980264038,
0.2619957626,
0.1044954062,
0.6270552278,
-0.3356933594,
-0.0073192208,
-0.5161055923,
0.7772042751,
-0.8298702836,
0.0240122117,
-0.7401561737,
0.1649716049,
-0.2921067178,
0.1905146092,
-0.6638562083,
-0.6154873371,
0.0565343909,
-0.7476148605,
0.3621302843,
0.0779678002,
0.712613225,
0.3012614548,
0.096995756,
-0.5758715272,
-0.620875001,
0.7521446943,
-0.7445796728,
0.0299654901,
0.0679979101,
0.3389323652,
-0.2060842812,
-0.7447124124,
-0.7871283889,
-0.1746925563,
-0.176453501,
0.1452458501,
-0.3756033182,
-0.2547203302,
0.5764462948,
0.2992728949,
-0.3471734822,
-0.160370186,
-0.5950029492,
-0.1963000894,
0.5252289176,
-0.0710099488,
0.4850551784,
-0.0830851719,
-0.3068362772,
-0.0152211543,
-0.918381691,
0.0428496003,
0.4966153502,
0.0983710364,
-0.1680677384,
0.3832478225,
0.3801318407,
0.7813122869,
0.1415976286,
0.2404875457,
0.141358763,
-0.2838788927,
-0.3001092374,
0.1808317304,
0.3428990543,
0.36280334,
0.2498081625,
-0.101638183,
0.0360167995,
0.3650538921,
0.5956995487,
-0.0629475862,
-0.2451815009,
0.2335118055,
-0.3023118675,
-0.6181516647,
0.0310039222,
-0.7179603577,
-0.4955199063,
-0.1418665946,
0.0592839271,
-0.6017881632,
-0.1342917383,
0.3123212457,
-0.6715937853,
0.3608618081,
0.6792443395,
-0.560619235,
0.5701879859,
0.8293893933,
0.7333461046,
-0.090086773,
-0.2666361034,
-0.4456943572,
0.1365593374,
-0.8411742449,
1.1333192587,
-0.6612805128,
-0.0708436817,
-0.0768627971,
-0.1800412685,
-0.2248155624,
-0.4175402224,
1.1576602459,
-0.2070279717,
0.588511169,
-0.3189732432,
-0.5191271901,
-0.4515507817,
0.2362167984,
-0.8496889472,
0.7816711068,
0.243048504,
-0.9747490287,
0.4813230038,
-0.7159724236,
-0.3386627138,
-0.0492762104,
-0.3123834729,
-0.3953587413,
0.6162827015,
0.3409584463,
0.0414022617,
-0.2117797732,
-0.0093285078,
-0.4655621052,
-0.405387193,
0.4400019646,
-0.1430640668,
0.8573477268,
-0.125837788,
-0.5668627024,
-0.150589183,
-0.6674386263,
-0.3124851882,
0.1716413051,
-0.1182415932,
-0.5774288774,
0.287327677,
-0.1704059988,
0.3738212287,
-0.2785865366,
-0.5473890305,
0.1838943511,
-0.7072033286,
0.6057878137,
1.0139393806,
-0.0764108598,
0.1850519776,
-0.5125810504,
0.55289644,
0.3250504732,
0.0422162712,
-0.0180465877,
-0.3175856769,
-0.8295263052,
-0.2680685222,
0.2094958425,
0.2875288725,
-0.4668344557,
0.0063842339,
-0.0591015145,
-0.4111126363,
-0.5223671794,
-0.0876804888,
0.3473363817,
0.8460993171,
0.3155803382,
0.0493812375,
-0.4872032404,
-1.1975976229,
-0.5248648524,
-0.1753795743,
0.1717319638,
0.2200867236,
0.6081326604,
0.1908620596,
1.1381415129,
-0.4292177558,
-0.0103300959,
-0.2547323108,
0.2027916163,
0.4010272324,
0.3923795223,
0.7634686232,
-0.8161373734,
-0.1452013403,
-0.3631615639,
-0.7274961472,
-0.1902197599,
-0.0701562762,
0.045603659,
0.4820200801,
0.6030134559,
-0.6158123612,
0.6374258995,
-0.0169713572,
-0.2569087446,
0.8190490007,
0.1867568791,
-0.0082935877,
-0.9523950815,
-0.1613064557,
0.0808245838,
-0.1400330663,
-0.3049199283,
0.0080459407,
-0.2661933005,
0.002816787,
-0.4052214324,
0.4127706289,
-0.2818417847,
0.2626599073,
0.1359203756,
0.2108572572,
0.0941497609,
0.0159277283,
-0.0419582054,
0.3334944248,
0.2637123466,
-0.3530373275,
0.3020609617,
0.1750763953,
-0.0066349711,
0.8218000531,
-0.7267871499,
0.1385184526,
-0.3558468223,
0.3965653777,
-1.1033445597,
-0.3575583994,
0.482675761,
-0.3444239795,
0.0219084714,
-0.7743453383,
-0.2567788661,
-0.3050811589,
-0.5460957885,
0.2479688674,
0.4295603037,
-0.7080928087,
0.6515720487,
0.2827721536,
-0.0643625781,
-0.818785727,
-0.675788343,
0.0218483713,
-0.6236525774,
-0.3990419507,
0.184740752,
-0.1509297341,
-0.4851637483,
-0.1217483506,
-0.1375880688,
0.0665744096,
0.0741613209,
0.3458018601,
0.0187366586,
-0.3666272461,
-0.0502410308,
-0.1334362179,
-0.3692894578,
0.3503355384,
-0.3156313002,
0.2413825989,
-0.2092350721,
-0.5723353624,
0.0664863437,
0.621815145,
0.692532599,
0.3001582026,
0.4655327201,
-0.1046384647,
-0.7939878702,
-0.4912480712,
-0.6427497864,
0.0723645911,
-0.4448774159,
-0.025076,
-0.3080570996,
-0.2652001977,
0.3706974685,
-0.0697512329,
0.579462111,
0.5609642863,
0.2867034674,
-0.2153421789,
0.8238115311,
0.2188064456,
0.1889657974,
-0.0485513993,
0.0281318147,
0.4913287461,
-0.3755596876,
-0.0335659347,
-0.6708388925,
-0.109324947,
-0.319141537,
-0.5956428647,
0.0644284412,
0.1598502696,
-0.1671312749,
0.0251246244,
-0.5124773979,
0.6822493076,
0.3137980103,
-0.3185084164,
0.0438091867,
0.3427219987,
-0.3006159663,
-0.5638390779,
-0.777985096,
-0.6946417689,
0.542765677,
0.4032607973,
0.6051387191,
0.2187523693,
0.5472822785,
0.5699821711,
0.2884928584,
-0.587456882,
0.3856510222,
-0.0819752365,
-0.7072136998,
-0.0954385102,
-0.3563144803,
-0.5749743581,
0.099344641,
0.0312135238,
-0.9152374864,
0.1318863034,
0.4537405074,
0.1043421254,
0.2411107719,
-0.710558176,
0.9726842642,
-0.022845827,
-0.1797578782,
-0.0621536747,
-0.3394955099,
0.5895426273,
0.0682541281,
0.494812876,
0.0578969494,
0.333468765,
0.8435991406,
-0.7477058172,
0.8660255671,
-0.1551814675,
0.0348681211,
0.2699638009,
0.4432212114,
0.2879464626,
-0.0537538677,
-0.197723195,
-0.0209717676,
-0.068164818,
-0.369550705,
-0.8155193329,
0.375259757,
-0.3447812498,
-0.5284500718,
-0.6590331793,
0.0605371296,
-0.0151596386,
0.1201672107,
0.3446574509,
0.6133885384,
-0.254024297,
-0.1382713467,
0.5767818093,
-0.021027023,
0.4915976822,
0.2149700373,
0.2401864082,
-0.4504721165,
0.9291228652,
0.1571864933,
-0.1863829941,
-0.0566377752,
0.4147948325,
-0.3823505044,
-0.616666317,
-0.5311161876,
0.1793586761,
-1.1834205389,
-0.1693219095,
-0.4656506777,
-0.072341606,
-0.2835561633,
-0.7475592494,
-0.4134589136,
-0.9112283587,
0.0347827598,
-0.2915425003,
0.2376441807,
0.9254373908,
-0.2086665779,
0.0296582505,
-0.5353377461,
0.2908268571,
0.0217712428,
0.2811691165,
-0.0107141938,
-0.4240220189,
0.2043450177,
-0.231456697,
-0.1375394911,
-1.1242204905,
-0.0428045578,
-0.0335517153,
0.8161323071,
0.5342665315,
0.2673417628,
0.7207601666,
-0.5485100746,
0.749366641,
0.338519901,
-1.1399387121,
0.8679718375,
-0.2352148741,
-0.2194207311,
0.6004465818,
0.5443296432,
-0.3897057474,
-0.4257604778,
-0.9861351252,
-1.0317456722,
0.8604875207,
0.2311591059,
-0.2339858264,
-0.1358816922,
0.5056326389,
0.2687098682,
-0.0002359745,
-1.131166935,
-0.1643667221,
-0.2125704288,
-0.3397406936,
0.2277725041,
-0.2901572883,
-0.6693301201,
-0.040790908,
0.6177437305,
-0.3555236459,
0.1130963564,
0.1728887558,
-0.2439012378,
0.0276565906,
0.3660213649,
0.9072191119,
1.034655571,
-0.0569078773,
0.4781904817,
0.0837977752,
-0.227963686,
0.3102975488,
0.2259135246,
-0.4273497462,
0.2280990034,
0.8310950398,
0.2651860416,
0.0428051092,
-0.4969824255,
0.5641102195,
-0.3350323737,
-0.1623848975,
-0.7368662357,
0.0118859503,
0.214074865,
-0.1534000635,
0.1325360686,
0.1416440159,
0.0861966163,
-0.3483890593,
0.0952133536,
0.236828953,
-0.491106838,
-0.2152649611,
0.2042313963,
0.2647390366,
-0.2963719666,
0.5526191592,
0.0373413227,
-0.5834052563,
0.4864732027,
0.518525064,
0.5311712027,
0.1325264126,
0.4202226698,
0.1677301973,
0.7790914178,
-0.0251195319,
0.1936799288,
0.1574541926,
-0.6082888246,
-0.1130939499,
-0.4186042249,
-0.5068678856,
0.331145823,
-0.4948504269,
0.2596313357,
-0.712539196,
0.3332967162,
0.2376381308,
-0.3731615841,
-0.2953234315,
0.2091327757,
0.1680348516,
1.2056409121,
-1.0543904305,
-0.2048428953,
0.9051113725,
-0.6385335922,
-0.568200171,
0.1763713062,
0.1288222969,
-0.549648881,
0.509419322,
0.2404408455,
-0.4075352848,
-0.6212627292,
-0.788664639,
-0.4695474803,
0.3105540276,
0.5834017992,
-0.3420527577,
-0.0408403836,
0.0326488577,
0.2220192999,
-0.5621960759,
0.3457207084,
0.6392300725,
0.5858142972,
0.1168295145,
-0.2685285509,
0.4269145429,
-0.250674367,
-0.3757508099,
-0.1004719958,
-0.3876106739,
0.6302850246,
-0.2417592108,
-0.0827698931,
-0.4868775308,
0.3822008371,
0.5755729675,
0.6635022163,
0.792840898,
0.8988789916,
0.7359791994,
-0.2383960336,
0.9698086381,
0.3282301426,
0.0588125773,
1.1577665806,
-0.3333336413,
0.5901644826,
0.5099157095,
0.063820608,
0.8810148239,
0.7389743924,
-0.0460563488,
0.3344413936,
0.6220766306,
0.0178100746,
-0.4175342619,
0.3491246104,
-0.2928439677,
0.3851414919,
0.6767878532,
-0.2201546282,
-0.3551732302,
-0.4586081803,
0.309563905,
0.1925967336,
-0.025866298,
0.6406290531,
0.0280066933,
-0.7845294476,
0.3828754425,
0.1363796294,
0.0852918103,
-0.3263908625,
-0.5202072263,
-0.2819594443,
0.1845307648,
-0.2818259597,
-0.5349722505,
0.2923122644,
0.0382893495,
-0.2347830683,
0.0980204716,
0.7666147947,
0.4276941121,
-0.7095779777,
0.0491993278,
0.340788722,
0.115419589,
0.3203374743,
-0.8837324977,
-0.0243415441,
-0.1927120984,
-0.1007580757,
-0.2116709203,
0.5614997149,
-0.1478266865,
0.4378092587,
0.7309365869,
0.0901385173,
0.0589233302,
-0.0743287802,
1.072104454,
-0.8010441661,
-0.6843526959,
-1.0194919109,
0.547688961,
-0.668961525,
-0.2761162221,
0.4146110117,
0.5331209302,
0.5848881602,
-0.1746805012,
1.0656772852,
-0.0017020203,
0.7634082437,
-0.6465659142,
0.4645178318,
-0.4805292189,
0.2751803696,
-0.5300599337,
-0.6802718639,
-0.2997721434,
0.8732084632,
-0.3071293533,
0.1044441238,
0.7478437424,
0.392616868,
-0.5137944221,
0.0995887667,
0.0325800776,
0.3580374718,
0.4274893701,
0.5737318397,
1.205786109,
-0.3330559731,
0.4192585051,
0.1019344628,
-0.3072623909,
-0.450378567,
-1.3937362432,
-0.9608948231,
-0.2415933609,
-0.7114896774,
-0.9232278466,
0.1626162231,
0.6689727306,
0.7522553205,
-0.760622859,
0.2591072619,
-0.4013613462,
0.7159626484,
-0.2054436952,
-0.2578713894,
0.2726885974,
-0.2198266238,
-0.3314177692,
0.4709629714,
0.241507262,
-0.0312372278,
-0.1035874635,
0.1505934745,
-0.0403369479,
0.6204485297,
0.0720505193,
0.5846681595,
-0.8754224777,
-0.4156627655,
-0.5181156993,
0.1270487458,
0.1810126603,
1.2582197189,
-0.6290091276,
0.3455454111,
0.4496141076,
0.4304714501,
0.1462987661,
-0.0263970159,
0.861815691,
-0.8534320593,
0.1203251258,
0.3566650152,
0.4648420811,
0.4269568026,
-0.1975588948,
0.5262050629,
0.5681161284,
-0.0499445572,
-1.1688024998,
0.4109447598,
-0.9006923437,
-0.362952441,
0.7697910666,
-0.4105094373,
-0.4592002034,
-0.4642544985,
-0.033747144,
-0.1795443594,
-0.1993066519,
1.014291048,
1.0697618723,
-0.1966468096,
-0.2439654619,
-0.4153806567,
0.9861086607,
0.3751465678,
-0.9485473633,
0.4516623914,
0.7620313764,
0.4920139909,
0.4921528995,
0.673202455,
-0.2981832623,
0.895493567,
0.2608011365,
-0.4461313486,
-0.0468957312,
-0.2346919179,
-0.3678517044,
0.3689239323,
0.0003709056,
0.0029533696
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12399v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12399v1 | QueerBench: Quantifying Discrimination in Language Models Toward Queer Identities | 2024-06-18T08:40:29 | 2024-06-18T08:40:29 | Mae Sosto, Alberto Barrón-Cedeño | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY | With the increasing role of Natural Language Processing (NLP) in various
applications, challenges concerning bias and stereotype perpetuation are
accentuated, which often leads to hate speech and harm. Despite existing
studies on sexism and misogyny, issues like homophobia and transphobia remain
underexplored and often adopt binary perspectives, putting the safety of
LGBTQIA+ individuals at high risk in online spaces. In this paper, we assess
the potential harm caused by sentence completions generated by English large
language models (LLMs) concerning LGBTQIA+ individuals. This is achieved using
QueerBench, our new assessment framework, which employs a template-based
approach and a Masked Language Modeling (MLM) task. The analysis indicates that
large language models tend to exhibit discriminatory behaviour more frequently
towards individuals within the LGBTQIA+ community, reaching a difference gap of
7.2% in the QueerBench score of harmfulness. | [
-0.2598774731,
-0.7395499349,
0.2826535404,
0.3438502848,
0.1456544697,
-0.0555074811,
0.0610236265,
-0.8420264125,
0.1077699363,
0.4783982635,
-0.5022471547,
-0.4165267646,
-0.5403189063,
0.2810781598,
-0.8229976296,
0.7311317325,
0.1756608337,
0.2074251026,
-0.2776124775,
-0.0073552984,
-0.7283561826,
-0.5653402805,
-0.3284350336,
0.298594743,
0.5841363072,
0.0111873737,
0.7855919003,
0.2157150656,
0.4983021915,
0.2860861421,
-0.3500829935,
-0.4072210193,
-0.5609526038,
0.4217070341,
-0.4632734358,
-0.7236789465,
-0.3342533708,
0.1532094777,
0.5748573542,
0.82983464,
-0.0731321722,
0.3132202625,
-0.1344185024,
0.5790851116,
-0.6886785626,
-0.409509033,
-0.7267339826,
0.3199014366,
-0.4556015432,
0.4041492939,
-0.2218892872,
-0.4904942811,
-0.173957482,
0.0494170226,
0.2051226795,
0.2728892863,
0.5269411802,
0.0927970409,
-0.7395502925,
-0.1921711564,
-0.5962308645,
0.6277055144,
-0.8843124509,
0.7640078664,
0.5055927634,
0.1404010653,
-0.1135142073,
-0.4037232399,
-0.5996890664,
-0.1606009305,
-0.151663512,
-0.2069259733,
-0.1708172858,
0.0523366071,
0.3989097774,
0.4604277015,
-0.933226943,
0.4143662453,
-0.6429609656,
-0.099232927,
1.024409771,
0.2035173774,
0.4218944609,
-0.461727947,
-0.4679696262,
0.2718676031,
-0.5576733351,
-0.0056107724,
0.739151895,
0.2997386158,
0.1067117453,
0.6702887416,
0.3331060112,
0.4218109548,
-0.0544665605,
0.3409048021,
0.4643449187,
-0.0945422798,
-0.2618238628,
-0.0553204529,
0.5872882009,
0.5344904065,
0.1842210442,
-0.2131059766,
-0.0697824582,
-0.0193892531,
0.5788958073,
-0.5033656955,
0.392634362,
0.469245851,
-0.349988848,
-0.0597683676,
-0.0647552386,
-0.8878883123,
-0.8916563988,
0.1007730663,
0.0783871263,
-0.0990324542,
-0.2543607056,
0.3180772066,
-0.1644562632,
0.3030670583,
0.3201113343,
-0.6252384186,
0.3447319567,
0.7587258816,
0.6192391515,
-0.4427495003,
-0.0851705819,
-0.6378407478,
-0.1981399804,
-0.2130136192,
0.2790668309,
-0.3651319742,
-0.4352259934,
0.0203837845,
-0.0336285383,
0.0617253482,
-0.5293418765,
0.6951271892,
-0.4005715847,
0.4884241521,
-0.0447999611,
-0.8034870028,
-0.1114475578,
0.269492954,
-0.848741293,
0.981775105,
0.148479566,
-1.0186884403,
0.3095247149,
-0.5280231237,
-0.0959666073,
0.3371148705,
-0.2353001833,
-0.3179428279,
0.1734943092,
-0.3152854145,
0.4970574975,
-0.227442354,
0.4685755968,
-0.4913012385,
-0.2429700643,
0.3064890802,
-0.2219585776,
0.8745611906,
0.0307239406,
-0.6124346852,
0.4190298915,
-0.5859356523,
-0.2010992318,
-0.083409071,
-0.4180080295,
-0.4205810726,
-0.1053606421,
0.5829831362,
0.5429870486,
-0.0448373295,
-0.6890108585,
-0.1884351373,
-0.6888787746,
-0.2179948241,
1.0572327375,
-0.3322118521,
0.1129886061,
-0.1593206972,
0.7914975882,
-0.2681884468,
0.3013157248,
0.601213932,
-0.6629850864,
-0.4253085256,
-0.0570065677,
0.3601200879,
0.5085045099,
-0.2993048728,
0.6414998174,
-0.1348152906,
-0.3253066838,
-0.2704509795,
0.3178237081,
0.384950608,
-0.0611647069,
0.1205284595,
-0.4742748141,
-0.6507458687,
-1.1013867855,
-0.6098492146,
-0.3458360434,
-0.3184320927,
0.0897419155,
0.6452447772,
-0.3955674469,
0.9434228539,
-0.2468060553,
-0.1863055378,
-0.1879112571,
-0.0414650925,
0.0069185905,
0.3961720765,
0.7277640104,
-1.1325170994,
-0.4639927149,
-0.4880867898,
-0.427231431,
-0.283585012,
0.0626716167,
-0.1872289479,
0.1220886707,
0.6190270782,
-0.4823825955,
0.5168519616,
0.5619451404,
-1.1030659676,
0.7624059319,
0.5288925767,
-0.0340755098,
-0.8462594151,
0.1177771464,
0.0379653424,
-0.5561847687,
-0.5885488391,
0.3759738803,
-0.201899156,
-0.002119547,
-0.7371018529,
0.6812618971,
-0.1226914227,
0.1438451409,
0.0395136699,
0.0764948353,
-0.1041556373,
0.1544219106,
-0.3158755004,
0.4500494599,
0.0568390526,
-0.2190965265,
0.4345979691,
0.3649585247,
-0.3302091956,
0.4781191051,
-0.4664713442,
0.0373291411,
-0.3874699175,
0.0725152716,
-0.9977177978,
-0.1380842775,
0.2110265791,
-0.3126963079,
0.0428378433,
0.3650936186,
-0.4455581009,
-0.4437388778,
-0.6721934676,
0.5007869005,
0.1762646288,
-0.1870172769,
0.4756471217,
0.4275150001,
-0.2560918927,
-0.6201787591,
-0.8313093185,
0.1122230664,
-0.4964178801,
-0.4773508608,
0.1277941465,
-0.2282362133,
-0.582852304,
-0.3445325792,
-0.024507951,
0.0396706127,
0.5958160758,
0.4419522583,
0.0856366977,
0.0433158949,
0.4898290932,
-0.2258532047,
0.3577305079,
0.2911213934,
0.2872939408,
0.704474926,
-0.1812808067,
-0.4145836532,
0.0993630216,
0.8085719943,
0.328961134,
0.0227515418,
0.9193812609,
0.6535750628,
-0.4173105955,
-0.1292835772,
-0.5742541552,
0.1313440651,
-0.4449608922,
0.6283625364,
0.0040132632,
-1.3854007721,
0.4022888243,
0.2646386027,
0.2101577967,
0.4706007242,
0.5307844281,
0.0413716175,
0.7144142389,
0.8847153783,
-0.0216115955,
0.4436794519,
0.4353311956,
0.1607980579,
-0.4866343439,
-0.1552746147,
-0.6088931561,
-0.3913369775,
-0.7919778228,
-0.5843713284,
0.1921295673,
0.1607823521,
-0.273455739,
0.1582242399,
-0.2543474138,
0.3789461553,
0.4253080785,
-0.146566689,
0.2524040043,
-0.0825297236,
-0.0278435312,
-0.3810887635,
-0.2473413348,
-0.5475274324,
1.0887649059,
0.5815346837,
0.5046663284,
0.5931995511,
0.4773551524,
0.7548921108,
0.3678380251,
-0.5579469204,
0.5632234812,
0.0198155232,
-1.2997568846,
-0.2279458046,
-0.5072742701,
-0.9771018624,
0.3587355912,
-0.2387664765,
-1.3596681356,
0.3483684063,
-0.1040098518,
-0.0718829185,
0.4237267375,
-0.3939228952,
0.7923767567,
-0.3572345674,
-0.6063545942,
0.016099602,
-0.7361742258,
0.6480627656,
-0.3914093077,
0.4683986008,
-0.3638773859,
0.0166955199,
0.7835709453,
-0.2214219719,
0.9746566415,
-0.1451747119,
-0.6012014151,
-0.2624514997,
0.346311748,
0.2156468481,
-0.1893559396,
-0.6354497075,
0.2210492194,
-0.0811309665,
-0.3186914623,
-0.3179171681,
0.3853757679,
-0.4992345572,
-0.8477644324,
-0.2680234313,
-0.4572481215,
-0.3841195107,
0.02369106,
-0.0215944573,
-0.0731011704,
-0.5559805036,
0.0131678404,
0.3517071307,
-0.7097774744,
0.1321314424,
0.39723441,
-0.9032580853,
-0.135525465,
0.5157977939,
-0.2346102744,
0.2786368728,
0.0236091614,
-0.0534706563,
-0.3001890481,
-0.3879827261,
-0.0644636974,
0.3027359843,
-0.7789263725,
-0.1419285089,
-0.5593008995,
-0.1020372212,
-0.6058588624,
-0.1167436093,
-0.2370387316,
-0.4678718448,
-0.0707844868,
-0.3134012222,
0.1528045535,
0.8157346249,
0.0657126307,
0.1410008073,
-0.7529321313,
0.2823489606,
0.3458445072,
0.4823499918,
-0.2248179466,
-0.3736371398,
-0.1534670144,
-0.1871715337,
-0.1952064782,
-0.9510595798,
0.4160268903,
0.0571831688,
0.4195794761,
0.1746607274,
0.0626979098,
0.2498469204,
-0.418143183,
1.0467649698,
0.4253710806,
-1.1272311211,
0.4132685363,
-0.2403422892,
0.117733188,
0.5546264052,
0.6455414295,
-1.0868980885,
-0.7380745411,
-0.5866770744,
-1.0492459536,
0.5173381567,
0.4434519112,
0.298601687,
-0.1062222049,
0.2342417687,
0.2681912184,
0.5405060053,
-1.1914298534,
-0.3720150888,
0.0933876932,
-0.2154744416,
0.0118747838,
-0.4657452106,
0.0219221767,
-0.3401969969,
0.6096888185,
0.1138759106,
0.1807476878,
-0.0834497437,
-0.2539910078,
-0.0762914047,
0.5728539228,
0.2832652628,
0.378631711,
-0.2004604638,
0.2052769065,
0.1702578068,
-0.3600109816,
0.2318433523,
0.022323912,
-0.0320561789,
0.1820670068,
0.4143018425,
0.7538838387,
-0.1217464283,
-0.9884083867,
0.7807433009,
-0.1265856922,
-0.0266926251,
-0.1798313558,
0.1815749407,
0.1931944042,
0.3462168276,
0.2130937129,
-0.1673436165,
0.4450749159,
-0.4760069251,
0.2436517477,
0.3904531002,
-0.4670855999,
-0.1160298958,
0.7776612639,
0.2809404731,
-0.4153572917,
0.444594115,
-0.1023388207,
-0.7240280509,
0.4984861314,
0.362550348,
0.9079648852,
-0.5067338943,
0.1676678509,
0.3077890575,
0.416346997,
0.2963388264,
0.2799469829,
0.3368058205,
-0.7554406524,
-0.0348485783,
-0.9889392853,
-0.1033250093,
0.0750529766,
-0.5184593201,
0.1792788506,
-0.5166217685,
-0.2847706378,
-0.0082207713,
-0.0804183781,
-0.5644013882,
0.0492098443,
0.7710103989,
0.7753859162,
-0.9085547924,
0.306548655,
0.4912413359,
-0.2455180436,
-0.4063104093,
0.0998646095,
0.3962553442,
-0.2951650321,
0.7770893574,
0.4963192046,
-0.0829834491,
-0.3484594226,
-0.4110472202,
-0.5953982472,
0.4827097654,
0.6297293305,
-0.8378058076,
-0.1977942288,
0.7354006767,
0.6867049336,
-0.1372335851,
0.226577729,
0.4652579427,
0.4474681318,
-0.2531012893,
-1.3038454056,
0.2224155366,
-0.6207225919,
0.1289810389,
0.0901740044,
-0.3217843473,
1.0400679111,
0.2480527163,
-0.5179377198,
-0.1873582453,
0.3114455342,
0.0708457008,
-0.0864930376,
0.6875774264,
0.3447701633,
0.9652699828,
0.3119039536,
0.9307113886,
0.2960272729,
0.4288273454,
1.2637548447,
-0.4123152196,
0.801068306,
0.3790280223,
-0.4956453741,
0.5717285872,
0.3409619927,
-0.060277693,
-0.2025902569,
0.7894838452,
-0.2635214627,
-0.3158041239,
-0.2573091388,
-0.3193761706,
0.4621027708,
0.4345588088,
-0.5313693285,
-0.2715772092,
0.3085412979,
0.0220326521,
0.2810685635,
-0.2415438592,
0.4296958148,
0.1370548159,
-0.0908510908,
0.5006648302,
0.3088683784,
1.1836508512,
-0.428136915,
0.1278366596,
-0.2186779827,
0.0211908277,
-0.4025117755,
-0.7531455159,
0.5701799393,
0.1456459165,
-0.3845849633,
-0.2108390778,
0.479741931,
-0.5015960336,
-0.6286103129,
0.57620579,
0.7379680872,
0.1710525751,
-0.2335429788,
-0.7912117243,
0.1227404773,
0.1356659979,
-0.2093508244,
0.3160077929,
-0.1382281482,
-0.2372970283,
0.7013097405,
0.3730930984,
-0.0593863726,
0.3483400643,
0.0186507273,
0.5797373652,
-0.8795115352,
-0.4704830647,
-0.8864617348,
0.4586523771,
-0.1643755138,
-0.3224022686,
0.9495772719,
0.7044677734,
0.7216124535,
0.1348539591,
0.4221445024,
-0.1865667105,
0.6540414095,
-0.3047885895,
0.8448253274,
-0.7468146682,
0.4940841496,
-0.4846858084,
-0.7505193949,
-0.50051862,
0.3873706758,
-0.2480393797,
0.0794155449,
0.5814720392,
0.8141198158,
0.1257348061,
0.1148810238,
0.5631698966,
0.3961142898,
0.3333262205,
0.3780408204,
0.9894346595,
-0.4219088852,
0.0347825326,
0.1531724185,
0.2320539355,
-0.1166215688,
-0.5577426553,
-0.9143387675,
-0.532446444,
-0.3967336714,
-0.4063615799,
-0.2016483396,
1.1042152643,
0.2473234683,
-0.7269304991,
-0.3877153695,
0.0262465663,
0.3634929955,
0.2584748268,
-0.34619838,
0.1621033996,
-0.0973412544,
-0.7707639933,
0.0673790276,
0.0563813262,
-0.2209607214,
-0.593791008,
0.0944497287,
-0.6251567006,
0.1332846582,
0.6529049873,
-0.0748435035,
-0.7220514417,
-0.236101523,
-0.3359617591,
-0.2208316028,
-0.0443687253,
0.637157321,
-0.6166728735,
0.4001597762,
0.4049735069,
0.3916540444,
0.2069578171,
-0.1533613503,
0.8463169932,
-0.9831694961,
0.0142934276,
0.4256708026,
0.3007355034,
0.420892626,
-0.6570742726,
0.5086205006,
0.3009996712,
-0.1326892078,
-1.0185631514,
0.2604092658,
-0.5988688469,
-0.553817749,
1.1410448551,
-0.1689987481,
-0.1647877693,
-0.3793806434,
-0.1225468889,
0.0912596509,
-0.0584210753,
0.709911406,
0.7165296078,
0.087107785,
-0.0332644843,
-0.6214932799,
0.6099136472,
0.48473984,
-0.9166338444,
0.253952831,
0.8250630498,
0.4013914764,
0.0824291855,
0.3804473877,
-0.0522121042,
0.1655179858,
-0.2546232045,
0.4098272622,
0.2857027352,
0.0522283204,
-0.5549488664,
0.2840157747,
-0.0467880368,
0.3156452179
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12397v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12397v1 | Unveiling the Flaws: Exploring Imperfections in Synthetic Data and Mitigation Strategies for Large Language Models | 2024-06-18T08:38:59 | 2024-06-18T08:38:59 | Jie Chen, Yupeng Zhang, Bingning Wang, Wayne Xin Zhao, Ji-Rong Wen, Weipeng Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Synthetic data has been proposed as a solution to address the issue of
high-quality data scarcity in the training of large language models (LLMs).
Studies have shown that synthetic data can effectively improve the performance
of LLMs on downstream benchmarks. However, despite its potential benefits, our
analysis suggests that there may be inherent flaws in synthetic data. The
uniform format of synthetic data can lead to pattern overfitting and cause
significant shifts in the output distribution, thereby reducing the model's
instruction-following capabilities. Our work delves into these specific flaws
associated with question-answer (Q-A) pairs, a prevalent type of synthetic
data, and presents a method based on unlearning techniques to mitigate these
flaws. The empirical results demonstrate the effectiveness of our approach,
which can reverse the instruction-following issues caused by pattern
overfitting without compromising performance on benchmarks at relatively low
cost. Our work has yielded key insights into the effective use of synthetic
data, aiming to promote more robust and efficient LLM training. | [
-0.2719806433,
-1.1365989447,
0.67959553,
-0.1027072892,
-0.1897219568,
0.586253047,
-0.0956368744,
-0.3631881177,
-0.0790444762,
0.8105595708,
-0.6392840743,
-0.376002878,
-0.3240053654,
-0.0485120937,
-0.5370663404,
0.7588594556,
-0.1405702233,
0.2856270671,
-0.5022153258,
-0.102821067,
-0.5685598254,
-0.6954945326,
-0.6584969759,
-0.2842638791,
0.2788875103,
0.6056774855,
0.6115846038,
0.8877971172,
0.2609189749,
0.2988373637,
-0.0351517573,
0.5502628684,
-0.754984498,
0.3267243803,
0.0201663133,
-0.619178772,
-0.1963437498,
-0.0136278011,
0.91734761,
0.8770293593,
-0.0621155351,
0.1104838774,
0.0914965421,
0.8816604018,
-0.4668864906,
0.1718559414,
-0.5882893205,
-0.120707266,
-0.386945188,
-0.148659572,
-0.3636244535,
-0.3850689232,
-0.2745693028,
-0.4583339989,
0.4668049514,
0.1584066004,
0.5527256131,
0.3397383392,
-0.2925635576,
-0.2496888489,
-1.0378706455,
0.8875540495,
-0.8925531507,
0.279845804,
0.3251643777,
0.3167933524,
-0.5828819871,
-0.4482832253,
-0.6519621611,
0.0164811295,
-0.0821032673,
0.0270032454,
0.0701055378,
-0.0636122525,
0.4316437244,
0.5564214587,
-0.7900249958,
0.1080251858,
-0.5944170356,
-0.1814583093,
0.93120116,
0.276655376,
0.3114283383,
0.0993350297,
-0.0370938331,
-0.398989439,
-1.0519032478,
0.0151540097,
0.7415153384,
0.4268944263,
0.1610983163,
0.7421139479,
-0.2449720353,
0.3785048723,
-0.2558035254,
0.2484491467,
0.1784851402,
-0.4709579945,
-0.0962701663,
0.042430196,
0.429150492,
0.0504840091,
0.2922452688,
-0.3200156093,
-0.3780665696,
-0.0178906452,
0.1998561621,
-0.611343503,
-0.2074208558,
0.436490953,
-0.0942807198,
-0.2611574829,
0.1406197548,
-0.8799324036,
-0.4280658662,
-0.5885338783,
0.3597770035,
-0.294406116,
-0.0595319308,
0.0904044956,
-0.2407714278,
0.2698158622,
0.1922193915,
-0.7128403783,
0.2698158622,
0.7224566936,
0.6628479362,
-0.0181930289,
-0.1473300159,
-0.4881133139,
0.0783977956,
-0.5409560204,
0.7231484652,
-0.4420603514,
-0.5866378546,
0.0166540593,
-0.0974917933,
-0.0500010662,
-0.9005318284,
0.5296455026,
-0.3632955551,
0.2122927159,
-0.4700857401,
-0.630845964,
-0.0175199639,
0.2041215003,
-0.6723912954,
1.0555647612,
0.1733935624,
-0.422423929,
-0.0312521346,
-0.4423395395,
-0.2827462256,
-0.1600359827,
-0.2298779339,
-0.553219974,
0.2842444479,
0.2854167819,
-0.0148178805,
-0.3819862306,
0.0044202218,
-0.2934782207,
-0.574508667,
0.6055228114,
-0.7027622461,
0.6845698953,
-0.0425027534,
-0.2223051339,
0.0183584932,
-1.0297636986,
0.1911339313,
0.4424667954,
-0.230861932,
-0.3709663749,
0.0276016556,
-0.0824704468,
0.1251574606,
-0.0617571957,
-0.7278905511,
0.4072814882,
-0.5019778013,
0.3536198139,
0.8994241357,
0.1441250741,
0.39002496,
-0.6341174841,
0.4950061142,
0.0357062519,
0.1670849025,
-0.1984413862,
-0.2246686369,
-0.9726899266,
0.1066065058,
0.4094487429,
0.4717503786,
-0.6109619737,
0.0531505793,
0.0395401157,
-0.4745580554,
-0.8165224791,
0.3794151247,
0.6468929648,
0.3689052761,
0.4745288789,
-0.3244790137,
-0.7977576852,
-0.8847415447,
-0.360774219,
-0.0120439595,
0.1038640961,
0.1516819894,
0.3684785962,
-0.2572020888,
0.8835024238,
-0.565115869,
-0.0104059456,
-0.2728743851,
0.1621930301,
-0.1323958635,
0.6646875143,
0.1964429617,
-0.7172790766,
-0.3016570508,
-0.2804092467,
-0.4073527753,
0.0109276548,
-0.2147674561,
-0.1102321222,
0.4253998399,
0.7656716704,
-0.5286256671,
0.3365764916,
0.5456846952,
-0.1174753457,
0.6577038169,
-0.2053656578,
0.1010430455,
-0.9359226227,
-0.1188448891,
-0.1851358265,
-0.0517454557,
-0.6729750037,
0.0289835669,
0.0141222207,
0.0523293093,
-0.2932661176,
0.5014048815,
-0.3090967536,
-0.0151525773,
-0.0881185979,
-0.1383348405,
0.1484308392,
0.3915519714,
-0.3320438266,
0.9329457879,
0.1492670476,
-0.2583796084,
0.4063171446,
0.2671289742,
-0.1879245192,
0.2340855151,
-0.6797708869,
0.4680603147,
-0.3514901996,
0.0896930769,
-1.122764349,
-0.4517291784,
0.2142112851,
-0.501383245,
0.5552076101,
-0.2431359142,
-0.6093039513,
-0.0661344454,
-0.4717032015,
0.546408236,
0.6073227525,
-0.5738227963,
0.2932211757,
0.2511357367,
-0.0697986856,
-0.4671930075,
-0.6859636903,
-0.13237001,
-0.2573916614,
-0.5173433423,
0.3416875005,
-0.2294966727,
-0.290274024,
-0.0762010142,
-0.2409588248,
-0.1743012071,
0.0250245202,
0.1680383831,
0.1657636315,
-0.2440607697,
0.1914074272,
-0.0870208442,
-0.0875158533,
0.2825588286,
0.007170558,
0.7604886889,
0.1199389994,
-0.4958232939,
-0.2172703892,
0.5245894194,
0.7051743269,
-0.2343100607,
0.7935307622,
0.2258560956,
-0.4062030911,
-0.6033722162,
-0.440710783,
-0.233441025,
-0.5272570252,
0.3669216633,
0.0257841591,
-0.4927364588,
0.5045391321,
-0.2067964524,
0.033254575,
0.1717094481,
0.1425414681,
-0.3185128868,
1.2451558113,
0.5867633224,
0.1088334918,
0.2119570673,
-0.4076963961,
0.3998866677,
-0.7637386322,
-0.4328728914,
-0.6264315248,
-0.2385031283,
-0.6360127926,
-0.4925376773,
0.2808229327,
0.2428439111,
-0.2805633247,
0.0684532449,
-0.0844879746,
0.6609639525,
0.7268331051,
0.0999649465,
0.3186590374,
-0.0381696597,
0.0954032242,
-0.014335976,
-0.5895032287,
-0.5215761065,
1.2001758814,
0.2558074594,
0.7359540462,
0.0522393622,
0.613276124,
0.0625894666,
-0.1427675933,
-0.6304576993,
0.4013440609,
-0.1859076321,
-0.4648606777,
-0.4664314091,
-0.5940006971,
-0.7143024802,
-0.0892171711,
-0.2205497175,
-0.4011254609,
0.1037192196,
0.42356655,
-0.1165859252,
0.3281126618,
-0.792254746,
0.8905764818,
-0.324041307,
-0.2688037753,
-0.0351564214,
-0.3472296894,
0.3813409805,
-0.3715575933,
0.2702513039,
0.1439855844,
0.3074310422,
0.5478546023,
-0.3498596251,
0.8736019135,
0.0162899457,
-0.1323646009,
0.2160964906,
0.0731749237,
0.7143293023,
0.0529895984,
0.141437754,
-0.0074739712,
-0.0426232144,
-0.7316973209,
-0.9529823661,
0.6447368264,
-0.6704457998,
-0.6305027008,
-0.2670795321,
-0.7265709639,
-0.652643919,
-0.0530143753,
0.1650428325,
0.5552935004,
-0.1832404435,
0.2443337291,
0.7655834556,
-0.409704417,
0.3537935615,
0.4293550849,
-0.074237287,
-0.2125546783,
1.0001279116,
0.3525450528,
0.555243969,
0.0239273533,
0.1313257366,
-0.4268728793,
-0.8939417005,
-0.4670869112,
0.277880609,
-0.5006076097,
-0.0717436001,
-0.1935923398,
-0.436898917,
-0.4019738436,
0.0848337784,
-0.6643439531,
-0.5199725032,
-0.0811212957,
-0.0455840789,
0.1966813803,
0.8245143294,
0.0638679489,
0.2372512221,
-0.9000462294,
0.0845054239,
0.1273697466,
0.3503904045,
-0.0611067526,
-0.4876715541,
-0.1747446954,
0.5411612391,
-0.3438906372,
-0.6910491586,
0.4867174923,
0.036599312,
0.4843168557,
0.1294839084,
0.2103923112,
0.8682544231,
-0.3891963959,
0.5725468397,
-0.2695418,
-0.7836458683,
0.561756134,
-0.3204401731,
0.1003433168,
0.3638180494,
0.4011023045,
-0.5553864241,
-0.5246532559,
-0.6617550254,
-0.9586559534,
0.5903204679,
0.2389058024,
0.2520438433,
0.2474634498,
0.5352723598,
0.0882891342,
0.1888213307,
-0.3868846893,
-0.3402926326,
0.0195045583,
-0.2266152203,
-0.3361580372,
-0.2117177099,
-0.1074083075,
-0.2581956089,
0.753144443,
-0.0104969414,
-0.0500374734,
0.0963863805,
-0.0805871263,
-0.3663444221,
0.3325747848,
0.6487666368,
0.5753026605,
-0.1881561577,
-0.0125587853,
0.1135013923,
-0.4876763523,
0.1437431276,
-0.1106532961,
-0.3213933706,
-0.1207005754,
0.3258972168,
0.4458525479,
-0.0847772211,
-0.988958776,
0.135306567,
0.1200079396,
-0.0826381221,
-0.3244643509,
0.3211319149,
0.0227856357,
0.2768633068,
0.3175273836,
0.0368089937,
-0.0525439978,
-0.973354578,
0.1637351215,
0.4785626233,
-0.2437172532,
-0.3090782464,
0.128883034,
-0.1139409766,
-0.345315218,
0.8415154815,
-0.1934693903,
-0.5746356845,
0.7425024509,
0.6627216339,
0.3657691479,
-0.4027962387,
0.2919810116,
0.239432469,
0.3449626565,
-0.1975056976,
0.3390159011,
0.322743088,
-0.7104083896,
-0.4168534875,
-0.4091285467,
-0.5275446177,
0.512622714,
-0.673669219,
0.0401786268,
-0.4714836478,
0.3807278275,
-0.1702691168,
0.0554347038,
-0.4060431421,
0.1526900977,
-0.1625764966,
0.5474496484,
-0.9548524022,
0.661280334,
0.4531632662,
-0.5832061768,
-0.8357630968,
0.0886869654,
0.0865644664,
-0.797070384,
0.464833945,
0.0322988331,
0.2267414927,
0.0164802093,
-0.5800386071,
-0.8806502819,
0.7581226826,
0.5099359155,
-0.7142474651,
0.0314608328,
0.7767022252,
0.4981394708,
-0.0731937885,
-0.102517128,
0.9101117849,
0.4210850298,
0.1799216121,
-0.6560316682,
0.1124794558,
-0.2106350511,
-0.2426412255,
0.5045087337,
-0.5195611119,
0.8298934698,
-0.1284757107,
-0.40135777,
0.1302363425,
0.1103556752,
0.2054926306,
0.3737357855,
0.2417009026,
0.5649071932,
0.754873991,
-0.2848711908,
0.8984202743,
0.1368560642,
0.2057138383,
1.1592885256,
-0.2160282731,
0.9277096987,
0.6396799684,
-0.1913579106,
0.2003442645,
0.5121325254,
-0.017452145,
0.3931277394,
0.6109637618,
-0.1171639413,
-0.1995979249,
-0.0715992302,
-0.2404219657,
0.5426809788,
0.3808940351,
-0.0837014318,
-0.2639037967,
-0.1994677186,
-0.1855778545,
0.3130055666,
-0.1686347127,
0.6960095167,
-0.0145415934,
-0.4682186246,
0.6999558806,
-0.006279096,
0.3177890182,
-0.2585726976,
-0.4138691425,
-0.6430645585,
0.234290421,
-0.1698835492,
-0.5443045497,
0.5155518055,
-0.077850394,
-0.1922858208,
-0.1972130686,
0.4122579396,
-0.5982827544,
-0.490672946,
-0.0264699589,
0.6165702343,
-0.0243625194,
-0.211945951,
-0.4841944575,
0.1622110009,
-0.0274944156,
0.0418281779,
0.3638458848,
0.3165176213,
-0.0936101452,
0.6027736068,
0.9323826432,
0.2354704887,
0.1362976283,
-0.0256175864,
0.9406187534,
-0.7297450304,
-0.0306057148,
-0.7986235619,
0.6289379001,
-0.2100932449,
-0.2214127481,
0.789237082,
0.6952139735,
1.252605319,
0.1333617866,
0.6839632392,
0.5672367811,
0.7797214389,
-0.8164541125,
0.6436419487,
-0.3808158338,
0.7422572374,
0.0131399222,
-1.0466672182,
-0.2970864475,
0.2762854397,
-0.0949976295,
0.0506097414,
0.6419271231,
1.0216727257,
-0.0032182629,
-0.0260159187,
0.2718736529,
0.3970876932,
0.4819023907,
0.4043565691,
1.1383314133,
-0.6658118963,
0.5260443687,
-0.421317935,
0.1363945901,
0.0068427529,
-0.5371651053,
-0.8174512982,
-0.4972648025,
-0.3024968207,
-0.390940845,
0.3677603602,
0.8109303117,
0.4092097878,
-0.9654547572,
-0.1136972681,
-0.5173295736,
0.0282874238,
0.0837516114,
-0.1928737015,
0.3488754332,
-0.4540784657,
-0.6904554963,
0.600527823,
0.0866844431,
0.5128862262,
-0.4230211377,
-0.0383428447,
0.1561792493,
0.3663409054,
0.3683647513,
0.5173585415,
-0.5141627192,
-0.3190832436,
0.1948135346,
0.1162960976,
-0.001779843,
1.0104731321,
-0.6793842912,
0.3591629267,
0.4363038242,
0.8274516463,
0.262663126,
0.1876311153,
0.9016418457,
-1.0900677443,
-0.0072957738,
0.2892965972,
0.268612355,
0.372333318,
-0.3434275389,
0.3852444589,
0.1448556632,
-0.4944587052,
-1.288856864,
0.1277143061,
-0.6765274405,
-0.5682758689,
1.1559977531,
0.030604437,
-0.1337067634,
-0.3264321983,
-0.3385903835,
0.2913836241,
-0.1489976645,
1.0901485682,
0.7317496538,
-0.0562113263,
-0.0899496078,
-0.6814650893,
0.6479898691,
0.4821718335,
-0.9323037863,
0.3858582079,
0.5363478065,
0.0984329879,
-0.0536249839,
0.1387381405,
-0.2323801666,
0.2233587205,
-0.0292658154,
-0.3821866214,
-0.2276473939,
-0.4032680988,
-0.4385147095,
-0.0545522496,
0.1155308187,
-0.1300125122
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12946v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12946v1 | Instruction Data Generation and Unsupervised Adaptation for Speech Language Models | 2024-06-18T08:27:00 | 2024-06-18T08:27:00 | Vahid Noroozi, Zhehuai Chen, Somshubra Majumdar, Steve Huang, Jagadeesh Balam, Boris Ginsburg | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | In this paper, we propose three methods for generating synthetic samples to
train and evaluate multimodal large language models capable of processing both
text and speech inputs. Addressing the scarcity of samples containing both
modalities, synthetic data generation emerges as a crucial strategy to enhance
the performance of such systems and facilitate the modeling of cross-modal
relationships between the speech and text domains. Our process employs large
language models to generate textual components and text-to-speech systems to
generate speech components. The proposed methods offer a practical and
effective means to expand the training dataset for these models. Experimental
results show progress in achieving an integrated understanding of text and
speech. We also highlight the potential of using unlabeled speech data to
generate synthetic samples comparable in quality to those with available
transcriptions, enabling the expansion of these models to more languages. | [
-0.0782101005,
-0.8455294967,
0.5103577375,
0.0021543128,
-0.070131585,
0.1505527943,
-0.4618613124,
-0.2578707635,
-0.1276200712,
0.7118457556,
-0.6860015988,
-0.3255746365,
-0.1492179036,
-0.1414349526,
-0.5983524919,
0.9114655852,
0.2063127607,
0.5136265159,
-0.1983040869,
0.0965820402,
-0.5029776096,
-0.6974590421,
-0.3511349559,
-0.3168301284,
0.090975441,
0.361869514,
0.3696120679,
0.4404051006,
-0.181442678,
0.3513189256,
0.3478114903,
0.300201118,
-0.3244323432,
0.2859158218,
-0.299831003,
-0.3477461934,
-0.237443924,
0.095218204,
1.0115897655,
1.0433183908,
-0.1897189915,
0.1549451053,
0.0159118287,
0.3790978491,
-0.5504450798,
0.2861266434,
-0.7650362253,
-0.1296068728,
-0.2266886681,
-0.3508032858,
-0.7684739232,
-0.1164162606,
0.2186809778,
-0.516680181,
0.414785713,
-0.3300151229,
-0.0238089915,
-0.0012494093,
-0.4536660314,
-0.411469847,
-1.2244479656,
0.9761109352,
-0.6866463423,
0.7145750523,
0.232317403,
0.3686194122,
-0.3749321997,
-0.9002346396,
-0.6589126587,
-0.3041447699,
0.2433938533,
0.1339377612,
-0.0217210557,
-0.0492627621,
0.1623547226,
0.0731653422,
-0.4530313611,
0.0925324708,
-0.6724062562,
-0.1507546902,
0.7906560302,
-0.0209766049,
0.4742083251,
-0.1302641928,
-0.1562446207,
-0.4909645617,
-0.5707098246,
-0.1268370301,
0.5723685026,
0.6171619892,
-0.1615708768,
0.670360744,
0.0245913379,
0.8188101649,
-0.0634562373,
-0.3270119727,
0.3969525993,
-0.4772010446,
-0.2768176198,
0.381909132,
0.7139540315,
0.0848488435,
0.2700900733,
-0.1381994784,
-0.1977438778,
0.1134798005,
0.3316872716,
-0.5525506735,
-0.2181556672,
-0.0041153743,
-0.2087191343,
-0.2387989908,
0.0711059496,
-1.1214255095,
-0.2597673535,
-0.7529447675,
0.3853790462,
-0.4822838902,
-0.2020224333,
-0.0051395413,
-0.2988497615,
-0.072157748,
0.1391096711,
-1.074499011,
0.2802333534,
0.2803403735,
0.3443970382,
-0.3812606633,
-0.2525658309,
-0.6814566851,
0.3873540759,
-0.4603157938,
0.7022565603,
-0.7994624972,
-0.5392146111,
0.1847964376,
0.1025313511,
-0.3655572832,
-0.5347859859,
0.3940659761,
-0.3175073862,
0.4291628003,
0.3226559758,
-0.5273074508,
-0.2074782699,
-0.4560419619,
-0.7135657668,
1.0414764881,
0.2560768127,
-0.2297926843,
0.0190400872,
-0.8137001991,
-0.50514853,
-0.1387984902,
-0.1820031106,
-0.0871384218,
0.2575430274,
0.4460421801,
0.4813522696,
-0.4848587215,
0.330141902,
-0.0083658034,
-0.0525896251,
0.5779429078,
-0.7652063966,
0.6411663294,
0.1980649531,
-0.2372200787,
0.0544214472,
-1.1301668882,
0.3426954746,
-0.0652832836,
-0.4995259941,
-0.2446150184,
0.1562158912,
0.4743996561,
0.0494107679,
-0.0512478836,
-0.6182886362,
0.0348781832,
-0.486895591,
0.723682642,
0.6249086261,
0.0765745342,
0.4374697208,
-0.1382288039,
0.4951187074,
0.0441765003,
-0.1696394533,
-0.4479599297,
-0.1529921591,
-0.7585449219,
-0.072849609,
0.5878562927,
0.5180544853,
-1.0741980076,
0.2918821871,
-0.2514606714,
-0.4996793866,
-0.5964694023,
0.0983492211,
0.4850756526,
0.2782828808,
0.4181624651,
-0.143125847,
-0.7728309631,
-0.6988075376,
-0.0136176171,
-0.0017030045,
-0.2441406697,
0.0190193616,
0.2883924842,
-0.2383906394,
0.7816597223,
-0.2848324478,
0.2328359336,
-0.3600213528,
0.3009717762,
-0.1790141165,
0.733874023,
0.548386395,
-0.6666900516,
-0.1448033899,
0.0636868253,
-0.39338094,
-0.0542447604,
-0.2472063154,
0.1034459993,
0.3058492839,
0.6114417911,
-0.1687018275,
0.1540015042,
0.9293992519,
0.1003387272,
0.4324228168,
-0.3310344219,
0.2495315969,
-1.324540019,
-0.1213559657,
-0.0413484611,
-0.2762116492,
-1.0168415308,
-0.1895605773,
-0.2663804293,
-0.5222654939,
-0.631380558,
0.4166584015,
-0.5238342285,
-0.1986760199,
-0.3164561689,
0.088701807,
-0.1265892833,
0.3591589034,
0.1246321127,
0.9951987267,
0.5531561375,
-0.5769829154,
0.642034471,
0.0428610146,
-0.5782791376,
0.1082977429,
-0.6364908218,
0.4378056824,
-0.1824738234,
0.1987915635,
-0.9789181352,
-0.5562062263,
0.0582016818,
-0.4135979712,
0.4401303232,
-0.0155834351,
-0.3256185055,
-0.0189339891,
-0.0230016056,
0.5319392085,
0.6593521833,
-0.6187671423,
0.660756588,
0.6515066624,
-0.4201930463,
-0.2162385136,
-0.717912674,
-0.0840810761,
0.0599107631,
-0.4668450952,
0.4242354631,
0.077924788,
-0.1256054491,
-0.1428679526,
0.1970786154,
-0.2518871129,
-0.3982153237,
0.232545808,
0.219923228,
-0.2958758771,
0.32716313,
0.3653408587,
0.1246008426,
0.1276475042,
-0.3334572017,
0.6211739779,
0.4606493115,
-0.5087438822,
-0.4941975474,
0.6247446537,
0.720962882,
-0.2186717838,
0.4692625105,
0.471706003,
-0.2325902879,
-0.6134929061,
-0.2889389694,
-0.2358173877,
-0.4583946764,
0.6036590934,
-0.2618420422,
-0.5456303358,
0.0281356685,
-0.1979229599,
-0.0534316339,
0.2216067314,
0.8357685208,
-0.0047006672,
1.2227844,
0.5523837805,
0.2400172651,
0.5651703477,
-0.0715927631,
0.0495273583,
-0.739826262,
-0.2822701931,
-0.5943142176,
0.0043680267,
-0.7098327279,
-0.9245945215,
0.5065307021,
-0.2889791131,
0.1511367559,
0.1562029123,
-0.4079291821,
0.3915704787,
0.8127339482,
0.2292922884,
-0.0127954707,
0.3428334892,
-0.084898442,
-0.0880962983,
-0.7402746677,
-0.4707503021,
1.3123233318,
0.1020405889,
0.7738281488,
-0.1281286478,
0.2510766685,
0.2956867516,
-0.1016411483,
-0.7008848786,
0.3826901913,
-0.3534371853,
-0.5069200397,
-0.348934412,
-0.2643597722,
-0.7750158906,
0.0758369118,
-0.3691698909,
-0.513579011,
0.2273542136,
0.0382611044,
-0.1065588221,
-0.0004329979,
-1.0421802998,
0.531237781,
-0.0870348662,
-0.067636393,
-0.2905001044,
-0.4139155447,
0.3879196346,
-0.4598990679,
0.1775014251,
0.2474600375,
0.2687744498,
0.9406628609,
-0.1533730179,
1.0801584721,
-0.1771821082,
-0.216978237,
0.4500709474,
-0.2245790809,
0.2862575054,
-0.1688923389,
-0.2477338016,
0.0412767567,
0.1652547121,
-0.2719654143,
-0.7123500705,
0.5489453673,
-0.8265429735,
-0.4030671716,
-0.1819115877,
-0.9925958514,
-0.5287944674,
-0.0043136673,
0.0686993673,
0.7845245004,
-0.2946271002,
0.368373692,
0.5206888318,
-0.6057396531,
0.4622613788,
0.4089808166,
-0.0015870009,
-0.5583496094,
0.9069500566,
0.0869250521,
0.5423313379,
0.1793630868,
0.0340661518,
-0.4500845075,
-0.5050638318,
-0.7085007429,
0.1420897841,
-0.6365891099,
0.1680242866,
-0.4312552512,
-0.3935983777,
-0.8265772462,
0.2029909492,
-0.4780944288,
-0.5707543492,
-0.2668097019,
0.0835611075,
0.3393939734,
0.7287755013,
-0.13307257,
0.3535970747,
-0.9246882796,
0.3706128597,
0.4556544721,
-0.2156287879,
-0.1562705934,
-0.6192949414,
-0.1598186344,
0.5910019875,
-0.2281860709,
-0.9491139054,
0.4704077244,
0.4503208101,
0.6356700063,
0.092476204,
-0.0124622528,
0.5466641784,
-0.8882242441,
0.8840776682,
0.1088761464,
-1.1106160879,
0.6937066913,
-0.3739587665,
0.1054726169,
0.136486575,
0.3276736736,
-0.3148314655,
-0.1402504891,
-0.3608353734,
-0.5411336422,
0.9231052399,
0.1375132501,
0.4687564671,
0.2758617103,
0.2048587948,
0.1888266653,
0.1621881127,
-0.4466362,
-0.0332094021,
-0.3496660888,
-0.3501567841,
-0.2094420195,
-0.1948144287,
-0.1073397249,
-0.3305440843,
0.7368488908,
-0.185768798,
0.3295731843,
-0.1416887343,
-0.0308769681,
-0.0106249014,
0.4438902736,
0.7389780879,
0.7410737872,
0.1143982485,
0.0547755286,
0.0292187575,
-0.6106520295,
0.3177432418,
0.123797439,
-0.1018055603,
0.1503064036,
0.4261374176,
1.0988018513,
0.2457684577,
-0.8886805773,
0.1809403449,
0.1860119998,
-0.1449066252,
-0.3056055009,
0.3760538995,
0.018666679,
0.2336669862,
0.0826156065,
-0.1909610778,
-0.011474804,
-1.0061188936,
0.2920996547,
0.306081593,
-0.3296637833,
-0.4462961257,
0.5420487523,
0.1576093286,
-0.3186409473,
0.6020593047,
0.2116988599,
-0.181646511,
0.4461672008,
1.0522911549,
0.6635873318,
-0.6305449009,
0.4556410015,
0.240454942,
0.0106857838,
0.1554481536,
0.2163226902,
0.0153405359,
-0.6485066414,
-0.5968903303,
-0.7084420919,
-0.3740667403,
0.4868979156,
-0.6954319477,
0.2605424821,
-0.0714026764,
0.07252606,
0.4140315354,
-0.3966455162,
-0.2079957277,
0.2741766274,
0.1659324914,
0.5107035637,
-1.034059763,
1.1190816164,
0.7391221523,
-0.1158888042,
-0.7737935781,
0.0200081281,
-0.0789165273,
-0.8008613586,
0.7159428596,
-0.2466495931,
-0.0594321452,
0.0643275902,
-0.3806122541,
-0.8063560128,
0.6813570857,
0.5312353969,
-0.4881828129,
-0.0893996283,
0.5575248599,
0.6194477677,
-0.489454031,
0.0266407114,
0.7509254217,
0.3217008412,
0.2260767221,
-0.7943714857,
-0.2138514668,
-0.1650485247,
0.2593970895,
0.0546455756,
-0.0496851355,
0.9512829781,
0.0595884807,
-0.3100321293,
0.0435428061,
0.5862560272,
0.153730616,
0.021901276,
0.5004351139,
0.1293278784,
0.5904398561,
0.0052031432,
0.7402746081,
-0.1323046982,
-0.067693077,
1.3247039318,
-0.3250326812,
0.7894060016,
0.4355556369,
-0.085306704,
0.400914818,
0.3091363013,
-0.0630207583,
0.5809133053,
0.182405144,
-0.4220966697,
-0.0940399095,
-0.2340520769,
-0.3556162715,
0.9268472195,
0.5090482235,
-0.5218293667,
-0.337190479,
0.4709702432,
-0.2936388552,
0.2183759063,
-0.1090482026,
0.7656369209,
-0.1755929589,
-0.7514392734,
0.6948666573,
0.109742187,
0.1557973921,
-0.5207337737,
-0.2791769803,
0.193715468,
0.1381570101,
0.0635736585,
-0.5439148545,
0.2340714037,
0.2423398346,
-0.4095051885,
-0.2358702421,
0.4888523817,
-0.8276775479,
-0.8019557595,
-0.0536638349,
0.3802802861,
0.1927940398,
0.1890357882,
-0.4778496325,
0.0576922782,
0.1581727415,
-0.1066270322,
0.322255522,
0.4786401391,
-0.1431303173,
0.2635433376,
0.9495087266,
0.2964652479,
0.4207538962,
0.2474408001,
0.8870530128,
-0.3475924432,
-0.2541295886,
-0.5987975001,
0.4434200227,
0.0986927897,
-0.1284614056,
0.5733715296,
0.4580954611,
0.9457603097,
-0.4212646186,
1.0545073748,
0.0826808438,
0.7765738368,
-1.0088902712,
0.4659308195,
-0.2820465863,
-0.0305408817,
-0.2115256637,
-0.9244307876,
0.1964272261,
0.4213315248,
-0.0682402104,
0.0993433446,
0.6195899844,
0.9133001566,
-0.229687199,
0.1766053438,
0.2828777432,
0.0045265243,
0.3313895166,
0.4838293195,
0.8439249992,
-0.5380260348,
0.221483171,
-0.3004600406,
-0.2360145301,
0.1983839571,
-0.621909678,
-0.9354097247,
-0.9107602835,
-0.1503730863,
-0.1786067188,
-0.0253663044,
0.8847531676,
0.9628650546,
-0.9689193964,
-0.3995145857,
-0.0881794915,
-0.3879984915,
-0.0396280959,
-0.2182220817,
0.2828779221,
-0.4812611639,
-1.4058990479,
1.0359972715,
-0.0053953808,
0.3284924626,
-0.4559434056,
0.1416677088,
-0.1335157752,
0.3234809339,
0.7193651795,
0.2059217095,
-0.5736301541,
-0.1088251844,
-0.0476517454,
0.3103899658,
-0.1584685147,
0.9767155051,
-0.728509903,
0.6560966372,
0.5002638102,
0.8117186427,
0.4634934366,
0.0069218446,
0.9842131138,
-1.0655543804,
0.5514615178,
0.2107393891,
0.0485975854,
0.3122272491,
-0.0873422027,
0.2006933242,
0.0279766843,
-0.3936094344,
-1.0648701191,
0.2953867018,
-0.8774145246,
-0.3267150521,
1.2763345242,
0.1106434911,
-0.2872963846,
-0.0072957487,
-0.2885930836,
0.6354327798,
-0.195967257,
0.6220803857,
0.522079289,
-0.2089595348,
-0.0831663534,
-0.7537708282,
0.4964075387,
0.1601008624,
-1.0292077065,
0.2795309126,
0.6994170547,
0.0363691337,
0.2014368773,
0.1882243752,
-0.1853912026,
0.2605642378,
0.1523393691,
0.1388398856,
0.0678559318,
-0.4981167316,
-0.3162549138,
0.0322307795,
-0.3761177063,
-0.4153437316
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12389v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12389v1 | EMO-KNOW: A Large Scale Dataset on Emotion and Emotion-cause | 2024-06-18T08:26:33 | 2024-06-18T08:26:33 | Mia Huong Nguyen, Yasith Samaradivakara, Prasanth Sasikumar, Chitralekha Gupta, Suranga Nanayakkara | cs.CL | cs.CL | Emotion-Cause analysis has attracted the attention of researchers in recent
years. However, most existing datasets are limited in size and number of
emotion categories. They often focus on extracting parts of the document that
contain the emotion cause and fail to provide more abstractive, generalizable
root cause. To bridge this gap, we introduce a large-scale dataset of emotion
causes, derived from 9.8 million cleaned tweets over 15 years. We describe our
curation process, which includes a comprehensive pipeline for data gathering,
cleaning, labeling, and validation, ensuring the dataset's reliability and
richness. We extract emotion labels and provide abstractive summarization of
the events causing emotions. The final dataset comprises over 700,000 tweets
with corresponding emotion-cause pairs spanning 48 emotion classes, validated
by human evaluators. The novelty of our dataset stems from its broad spectrum
of emotion classes and the abstractive emotion cause that facilitates the
development of an emotion-cause knowledge graph for nuanced reasoning. Our
dataset will enable the design of emotion-aware systems that account for the
diverse emotional responses of different people for the same event. | [
-0.4560075402,
-0.7662249804,
0.638450861,
0.0949011147,
-0.1505167782,
0.0293632206,
-0.1452722847,
-0.4314194918,
0.7039382458,
0.3059940338,
-0.7427173853,
-0.451511085,
-0.6349684596,
0.1650221348,
-0.5186184645,
0.9128513336,
0.0876290277,
-0.4167544842,
0.3031505048,
-0.059737727,
-0.0931509882,
-0.0824719667,
-0.8753491044,
-0.0033137607,
0.9925818443,
0.938762188,
0.2313893139,
0.3187598586,
0.3627876639,
0.0959508643,
0.1986641139,
0.0654094517,
-0.733633399,
0.3805242777,
-0.0345932543,
-0.1634695828,
-0.5111260414,
-0.3845872283,
0.164956063,
0.3316430151,
-0.0650264174,
0.1592271924,
-0.3004024625,
0.8853541613,
-0.9171596766,
-0.1782594025,
-0.4741125107,
0.3313849866,
-0.1808994412,
-0.0325151496,
-0.0242192075,
-0.4149957299,
-0.0808323249,
-0.7339045405,
0.0250258967,
0.1095410809,
0.4974730015,
0.2760675848,
-0.741243124,
-0.3035542071,
-0.5482936502,
0.6751400232,
-0.3004891872,
0.2681522071,
0.2358071059,
0.2288136631,
0.2152433991,
-0.4311050773,
-0.4741456509,
0.5897066593,
0.3001464009,
0.3146082759,
-0.5354852676,
-0.0441126153,
0.4744144678,
0.2773863673,
-0.5884939432,
0.0969754308,
-0.2939129472,
-0.0186278634,
0.9286327362,
0.2450824231,
0.6409189701,
0.0240744408,
-0.0804507136,
0.1421724558,
-0.8826471567,
-0.1580445021,
0.3749952316,
-0.2072767764,
-0.1757089049,
0.5810486674,
-0.1419960409,
0.3355560005,
-0.0545251779,
0.3019998074,
0.0937722102,
0.1734700501,
-0.2158122957,
0.2228246629,
0.9403631687,
0.5754656792,
0.4826340675,
-0.2802288532,
-0.2203584611,
-0.0614352487,
0.1551888287,
-1.0696713924,
-0.2457636297,
0.9479681253,
-0.3340318799,
-0.3250364065,
-0.0856099278,
-1.2757269144,
-0.8827208281,
-0.4753281176,
0.526935935,
-0.3068838716,
-0.5431447625,
-0.0183989517,
-0.5385486484,
-0.2514572144,
0.3889018595,
-0.624859333,
0.0587189794,
0.7155761123,
0.6255741119,
0.2185924947,
0.0914920419,
-0.3324821591,
-0.0150320567,
-0.5392246246,
0.7569755912,
-0.5800901055,
0.0467443615,
0.2396921962,
-0.0538179576,
0.3154922724,
-0.3670686781,
0.7603808641,
-0.2559694946,
-0.1239947379,
-0.492944926,
-0.5179392695,
-0.0452208482,
0.3994662166,
-0.692304194,
0.5695208311,
0.0197628718,
-0.8728675842,
0.4838526249,
-0.8367655873,
-0.5016684532,
-0.1808835417,
0.1324833483,
-0.0339710414,
0.3901116252,
0.3250693679,
0.6730391383,
-0.4503247738,
0.4531776309,
-0.687451005,
-0.0942185745,
-0.0831635296,
0.3722532094,
0.6824526787,
0.5160706043,
0.0126972739,
-0.0415504016,
-0.9384413958,
-0.4190253913,
0.0980229527,
0.2538020909,
-0.7361018658,
-0.0615199879,
0.0034840701,
0.5022449493,
0.1323333979,
-1.0373002291,
-0.1086749583,
-0.0563809834,
0.5377640724,
0.7142060995,
0.3963697255,
0.3316580653,
-0.2438718528,
0.626393199,
0.2844417095,
0.2853992283,
-0.4851148427,
-0.2798200548,
-0.4380915761,
-0.1606978476,
-0.3289189637,
0.2900851071,
-0.401828289,
0.2796533704,
-0.0875821263,
-0.8377034068,
-0.3652151227,
-0.1828855872,
0.0312048979,
0.5260699987,
0.0931472406,
0.3613916934,
-0.82901299,
-0.6899815202,
-0.4390694499,
0.4212270975,
-0.2670087218,
0.2000303715,
0.6423657537,
-0.1598448157,
0.8152028322,
-0.6063976288,
-0.2105066627,
0.2695105076,
0.1170017198,
0.1273423731,
0.260371685,
0.522818625,
-0.5492476225,
-0.2151049674,
0.0983169824,
-0.8442931771,
-0.4460597634,
0.0907499492,
-0.4034055471,
-0.1895712614,
0.2358252406,
-0.2354393154,
0.1804222912,
0.6549674869,
-0.4642242789,
0.1506359577,
0.2213272452,
0.3222991824,
-1.3057641983,
0.1610956043,
0.2342996299,
0.3000712395,
-0.4727730751,
-0.5612454414,
0.0015781345,
-0.4909434319,
-0.1764403433,
0.6638147831,
-0.1184352189,
0.1044334248,
0.0474097468,
0.3135179877,
0.2784762979,
0.233415857,
-0.204269588,
-0.0983947814,
0.7450349331,
-0.4330788255,
0.5179409981,
0.2001619339,
-0.0020142496,
0.7129699588,
-0.5409759879,
0.1929610819,
-0.3907129765,
0.0017235996,
-1.0396826267,
-0.7367091775,
0.2314219177,
-0.4398404062,
0.1787805557,
-0.1506121755,
-0.5257549286,
-0.3729362786,
-0.2722854912,
0.118217051,
0.3117559254,
-0.661288023,
0.992543757,
0.6271146536,
-0.2284089178,
-0.3652214706,
-0.426581502,
0.1823429763,
-0.4455401301,
-0.8838919401,
-0.1095761657,
0.1098619998,
-0.5150255561,
0.0128785335,
-0.0945152193,
-0.2173506021,
0.1873975247,
0.6136130691,
-0.5315635204,
0.2445755899,
0.8520436287,
0.3909803331,
0.1664328724,
0.4196160436,
-0.1205529273,
0.3283836544,
0.2074617147,
-0.0583559312,
-0.2061776817,
0.5318749547,
0.6975933313,
-0.0437306091,
0.6770764589,
0.5638567805,
-0.7526161075,
-0.4176112115,
-0.5404062867,
-0.3333857059,
-0.3065338135,
0.1441074312,
-0.1643905938,
-0.8333508968,
0.9503071904,
-0.1683547348,
0.2092140913,
0.6323407888,
0.2964200675,
-0.2504860759,
0.9270405769,
0.2978941202,
-0.0914147571,
0.5424962044,
-0.043540813,
0.2622842193,
-0.6327968836,
-0.2805522084,
-0.6307973862,
-0.4037709236,
-0.6110675335,
0.1179953143,
0.1683329642,
-0.3364741802,
-0.7971839905,
-0.1345696747,
-0.3317781389,
0.2211666852,
0.0859741271,
0.2795497179,
0.125970751,
-0.0683486611,
0.5334079266,
0.0641842037,
-0.5032041073,
-0.4117199183,
1.1347045898,
0.2036009431,
0.777982235,
0.0366131738,
0.7987992764,
0.3556967676,
0.6115652323,
-0.7540881038,
0.1411381662,
-0.1383403838,
-0.8844169378,
-0.1605175734,
-0.4182991087,
-0.9653682709,
-0.2992317677,
-0.1644439548,
-0.8116073608,
0.3367107511,
0.2296243012,
-0.0665046573,
0.2861913443,
-0.9102980494,
0.7548344135,
-0.1776796579,
-0.2293819785,
-0.1488224119,
-0.6076533794,
0.6543257236,
-0.701679647,
0.5140914917,
-0.3361286223,
0.0760508925,
1.1226431131,
-0.4958449304,
0.8123838305,
-0.2211259604,
-0.1692520678,
0.3907833397,
0.192812562,
0.446665138,
-0.0378892608,
-0.2053816617,
-0.0499607623,
-0.3078329563,
-0.2619242668,
-0.6979178786,
0.6110208035,
-0.6828802824,
-0.1421099752,
0.0988610387,
-0.3419562578,
-0.0650921315,
0.0709640533,
0.3494129777,
0.4248579741,
-0.1369875968,
0.2555844188,
0.504784584,
-0.1397700608,
0.3902566433,
0.2535731494,
-0.2970588207,
-0.5619587898,
0.6432737112,
0.1757167727,
0.0098703727,
0.4137316942,
0.617670238,
0.0096822027,
0.0892570913,
0.0822613463,
0.0717383921,
-0.6266710758,
-0.321428448,
-0.7973889112,
0.4564505517,
-0.5570123792,
-0.3030649722,
-0.4597291648,
-0.4181810617,
-0.1834765971,
-0.2588658631,
0.8585187197,
0.9391360283,
-0.3139079809,
0.2773201168,
-0.901825428,
0.3534601927,
0.2539362311,
0.4069668949,
0.1708262116,
-0.3427898884,
-0.2437372506,
0.0434698202,
-0.3254276216,
-1.1615606546,
0.7264478207,
0.3411483765,
0.122074753,
1.0777511597,
0.5993697643,
0.4335278869,
0.0454785712,
0.4758225679,
0.217970714,
-0.918628931,
1.0108163357,
-0.7157770991,
-0.2097447515,
0.0472197309,
0.5596293211,
-0.8916423321,
-0.5060296059,
-0.9666295648,
-0.8568083644,
0.6660321951,
0.1747668087,
-0.1048853993,
-0.1507256925,
0.238435328,
0.0976607502,
0.1408420801,
-0.0439972878,
-0.1487180293,
-0.2607782185,
-0.3924564719,
0.0107215308,
-0.1608429998,
-0.3879994452,
0.0742002055,
0.5426608324,
0.0159682781,
0.054009743,
0.1806732565,
0.0199174769,
-0.6095296144,
0.2025161833,
0.1959488988,
0.50043118,
-0.5140224695,
0.1047729254,
-0.1171709821,
-0.2493706346,
-0.068762809,
0.0144728757,
0.1181781143,
-0.1811194569,
0.2520022392,
0.5824494362,
0.1471247673,
-0.793250978,
0.4237646461,
0.0531697646,
-0.1243152469,
-0.4050715566,
-0.2290468514,
0.2499276102,
0.2055754662,
0.5315945745,
-0.1397681236,
0.3675214052,
-0.6251469254,
0.243296504,
-0.1392934471,
-0.4305456579,
-0.7280490398,
0.5295139551,
0.3791390657,
-0.0824905634,
0.6177482605,
0.0209273361,
-0.4986341298,
1.1099839211,
0.1332113445,
0.9202897549,
-0.2634941638,
0.0871693045,
0.7680765986,
0.1168994382,
0.074112311,
0.609205246,
0.1398894042,
-0.9524972439,
-0.2567924261,
-0.3733684123,
-0.4871871173,
-0.0264817476,
-0.6926117539,
0.2715862393,
-0.4465892315,
-0.2905932963,
-0.0062535391,
-0.1709778905,
-0.932328701,
0.5473662019,
0.152445972,
0.7355389595,
-1.6390650272,
0.1311277449,
0.8165030479,
-0.3203029633,
-0.8973989487,
-0.3728791773,
0.2077237666,
-0.6701290011,
0.7621306777,
0.2594006062,
0.2643958628,
-0.0780919418,
-0.8560421467,
-0.4433344007,
0.9748798013,
0.1301794052,
-0.7676026821,
0.3681976795,
-0.3337097168,
0.6581722498,
-0.728530705,
0.2628355324,
0.5550715923,
0.5344234705,
0.2430983782,
-0.3566717505,
0.0881313458,
-0.3043629527,
-0.4852673709,
0.4808858931,
-0.6847605705,
0.6114504337,
-0.4441767335,
-0.1084068492,
-0.7504951358,
0.1282328814,
0.3532654643,
0.8914241791,
0.4078275859,
0.9328331351,
0.8942217231,
-0.3173193932,
1.0336382389,
-0.2550448477,
0.4319492579,
0.9009476304,
-0.2491182536,
0.5477196574,
0.4608071446,
0.1098261029,
0.0554424711,
0.8063642979,
0.1845884323,
0.1861381233,
0.026156459,
-0.2985224724,
-0.5039752722,
-0.3893431723,
-0.0425945669,
0.3069902658,
0.653296113,
-0.6173881292,
-0.2913511992,
0.1511481404,
0.3309326768,
-0.4105838239,
-0.4610543251,
0.6517852545,
0.1725783646,
-0.4080069363,
-0.2239497006,
-0.8586335778,
0.2412075102,
-0.0875979513,
0.0804758072,
-0.3711890578,
-0.03057798,
-0.5637243986,
-1.1005088091,
0.2870737314,
0.1196453422,
-0.0431570746,
-0.1998836398,
0.8274998665,
-0.2569224536,
-0.3344613314,
0.4121589661,
0.5479665995,
0.3047153056,
-0.6072676182,
-0.1294647753,
0.0501062721,
-0.2096235156,
-0.5524255037,
0.1008937508,
1.3863066435,
0.1354761869,
0.6975240111,
0.4461085796,
-0.1170535684,
-0.0194115303,
0.2622344792,
0.9067298174,
-0.8570005894,
-0.1818920672,
-0.7684267759,
0.7577674389,
-0.2400098145,
-0.5025619268,
0.2886104882,
0.5103623271,
0.2799134552,
-0.0720885843,
0.9436994791,
-0.4059181213,
0.5610503554,
-0.0404578224,
0.5461249948,
-0.9013673663,
-0.115652509,
-0.3599379063,
-0.6917043924,
-0.4190820456,
0.1852494776,
-0.3040901423,
-0.1154175103,
0.3540242016,
0.6185258627,
0.3534659743,
0.2352807522,
0.3818647265,
0.456074059,
0.5368617177,
0.694181025,
0.8871657848,
-0.4178243577,
0.4654468298,
-0.3528535962,
-0.2477403581,
-0.5671542883,
-1.1017309427,
-0.631693542,
-0.7030345201,
-0.5585654974,
-0.2914446592,
-0.0614371523,
0.8538560867,
0.282599479,
-0.6767749786,
0.4814161658,
-0.0593906529,
0.4442106485,
0.1605247259,
-0.2469230592,
0.4153530002,
-0.3590806723,
-0.4326223731,
-0.1751633734,
0.2778895199,
-0.2741089165,
0.5050644875,
0.1221230328,
0.2353124321,
-0.0104015768,
0.7418476343,
0.3848501444,
-0.2985404432,
-0.436073184,
-0.0468642935,
0.1055965573,
0.0120000299,
0.7797368765,
-0.2409739941,
0.7629894018,
0.7641550303,
0.3151342273,
0.1604449749,
-0.1400196254,
0.677908659,
-0.7012563348,
-0.3195736408,
0.3842024803,
0.6881451607,
0.2489827424,
-0.4367229939,
0.7313431501,
0.0970175415,
-0.8554942012,
-0.4976259768,
0.0645574033,
-1.2171068192,
0.1036679894,
1.1046609879,
-0.1811298132,
-0.2298799604,
-0.0057703471,
-0.1599808931,
0.7268048525,
-0.927747488,
1.0041271448,
0.7283193469,
-0.1575645208,
-0.4092624187,
-0.3658317327,
0.2004154176,
-0.1244582608,
-1.1040227413,
0.2771683633,
0.7280259132,
0.31373173,
0.0116893528,
0.1738259494,
0.0054185363,
0.1401515901,
0.0917911008,
0.5058088303,
0.0022651595,
-0.2366827875,
-0.1692700088,
0.3937669396,
-0.3652786016,
0.0014448194
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12387v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12387v1 | Performant ASR Models for Medical Entities in Accented Speech | 2024-06-18T08:19:48 | 2024-06-18T08:19:48 | Tejumade Afonja, Tobi Olatunji, Sewade Ogun, Naome A. Etori, Abraham Owodunni, Moshood Yekini | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.SD | Recent strides in automatic speech recognition (ASR) have accelerated their
application in the medical domain where their performance on accented medical
named entities (NE) such as drug names, diagnoses, and lab results, is largely
unknown. We rigorously evaluate multiple ASR models on a clinical English
dataset of 93 African accents. Our analysis reveals that despite some models
achieving low overall word error rates (WER), errors in clinical entities are
higher, potentially posing substantial risks to patient safety. To empirically
demonstrate this, we extract clinical entities from transcripts, develop a
novel algorithm to align ASR predictions with these entities, and compute
medical NE Recall, medical WER, and character error rate. Our results show that
fine-tuning on accented clinical speech improves medical WER by a wide margin
(25-34 % relative), improving their practical applicability in healthcare
environments. | [
-0.0098154349,
-0.408208698,
0.5542776585,
-0.0280667488,
-0.09113276,
0.2252830863,
-0.3977795541,
-0.8793047071,
0.4412476122,
0.712539494,
-0.1308770478,
-0.4875865877,
-0.7632309198,
0.2875515223,
-0.1191971675,
0.6015145183,
0.107128948,
0.6528292894,
0.0469337441,
-0.5580072999,
-0.4366568327,
-0.748432219,
-1.1181148291,
-0.2823414803,
0.5032782555,
0.4557382762,
0.7801793814,
0.8013455272,
0.7361779213,
0.292878896,
-0.1047502905,
0.3407713771,
-0.0766580999,
0.1218616813,
-0.141367346,
-0.2139854878,
-0.5833005905,
-0.425404489,
0.4279614091,
1.0771487951,
-0.3885012865,
-0.2466781139,
-0.1009610742,
0.4450873137,
-0.3035365939,
0.0696907863,
-0.570392549,
-0.3396037817,
-0.1175926328,
-0.182252273,
-0.1671895087,
-0.3028876185,
0.3926231861,
-0.4736271501,
0.4797012806,
0.1460842341,
0.8174392581,
0.3863567114,
-0.3433734775,
-0.6107657552,
-0.7129482031,
0.352053076,
-0.8409084678,
0.4927593172,
0.2662980556,
0.3789981306,
-0.1283608228,
-0.9521808624,
-0.3809968531,
-0.240488708,
-0.1013369784,
-0.1487697959,
-0.245441705,
0.5121717453,
0.2353740931,
0.4149579704,
-0.3025582135,
0.4494012296,
-0.5406070948,
-0.3693798184,
0.760579288,
0.2672153413,
0.7196241617,
0.1732384562,
-0.0739625543,
0.0394205414,
-0.6082166433,
0.0080661308,
-0.1409177929,
0.8394134641,
-0.0028581184,
0.5887909532,
-0.1213228777,
0.2642703056,
0.080255501,
-0.0393995754,
0.2792264819,
0.0938206017,
-0.0941737294,
0.6181619167,
0.7247157097,
0.4414458275,
0.3315030634,
-0.2356593013,
-0.2567631304,
0.4394073784,
0.5821989775,
-0.7773510814,
-0.4216942191,
0.3507629037,
-0.3967822492,
0.0203939267,
-0.3477561474,
-0.4504487216,
-0.5422658324,
-0.2505330741,
0.6759373546,
-0.6672616005,
0.0380308852,
0.1362457424,
0.012846102,
-0.1710666716,
0.2585428059,
-0.8196356893,
0.7419775724,
0.5302090645,
0.6058027744,
-0.2560788095,
0.1549046636,
-0.5070423484,
-0.1411300898,
-0.3925547004,
0.7129575014,
-0.3994716406,
-0.6740598679,
0.113333866,
0.1197830215,
-0.2537015676,
-0.7804508805,
0.7475482821,
-0.268583864,
-0.4393739998,
-0.4131501913,
-0.6228446364,
-0.1806998849,
-0.179500252,
-0.7131820917,
0.2778072357,
-0.1054838598,
-0.2654141784,
0.4756039381,
-0.7831214666,
-0.935572505,
0.0423198938,
-0.2558970749,
-0.683354497,
0.3999099731,
0.3311959803,
0.2104027271,
-0.2298229635,
0.1298236847,
0.1298321933,
-0.2498283833,
0.3388871253,
-0.3926260173,
0.5585818887,
0.2288062721,
-0.3267527819,
-0.0154211987,
-1.013543725,
0.1059231088,
-0.0568799935,
-0.1786850989,
-0.4347054064,
0.1335775703,
0.2461485267,
-0.035853181,
-0.1200197786,
-0.5556071401,
-0.2141630203,
-0.5576375723,
0.4081888795,
0.0474474914,
0.362575531,
0.1601987034,
-0.4121935666,
0.458868295,
0.0513482206,
-0.2885031402,
-0.1461261064,
-0.5386631489,
-0.8210246563,
-0.5888135433,
0.5455206633,
0.4819827378,
-0.4537369907,
0.0822254717,
-0.2312463373,
-0.3422188461,
-0.9406524301,
-0.4242064357,
0.6497998834,
0.8871910572,
0.5972385406,
-0.5940704942,
-0.5969127417,
-0.9222754836,
-0.6196707487,
-0.1325026304,
-0.2122343779,
0.6919183135,
0.1661695242,
-0.4586303234,
0.4781429172,
-0.1963520199,
-0.3230739236,
0.0461487621,
0.1123737097,
0.0940047577,
0.6124526262,
0.2043927014,
-0.6507095695,
-0.4031667709,
0.0571688563,
-0.299187839,
-0.2230596244,
0.114467375,
0.3015404344,
0.0993324965,
0.3219671845,
-0.3745805323,
0.4046761692,
0.3922888339,
-0.2111671716,
0.2593895793,
-0.4579652548,
0.3912044466,
-0.9474265575,
0.0282784402,
-0.0207371786,
-0.2443720698,
-0.9667493701,
-0.1615866572,
0.1892391145,
-0.0840416774,
-0.2089316547,
0.4927193522,
-0.7007833123,
0.1443072259,
-0.1778264344,
-0.135785237,
0.0977428481,
-0.0162560325,
0.2259322107,
0.7967429161,
0.6107648611,
-0.7781799436,
-0.1185277775,
0.5571169257,
-0.3594945967,
0.7987319231,
-0.8463597298,
0.2399134338,
0.0882304087,
-0.1984687448,
-0.7817950845,
-0.465439558,
-0.42036286,
-0.5995625257,
0.8192242384,
-0.2372644693,
-0.058755029,
-0.3803904951,
0.4618198276,
0.2778988183,
0.4741244614,
-0.3583633602,
0.6096880436,
0.6632018685,
-0.4705325663,
-0.4406648874,
-0.8066331744,
0.221144259,
-0.077704221,
-0.3621572852,
0.4844501615,
0.3157711029,
-0.2652576566,
-0.1499677896,
-0.2129784077,
-0.4054872096,
0.0639349595,
0.3498640954,
0.0619371533,
-0.5668837428,
0.0874640867,
-0.0638400018,
0.0364957973,
0.0803272799,
0.0233798418,
0.3041965067,
0.1226937771,
-0.4646361172,
-0.554228425,
0.4426748455,
0.6996740699,
-0.3034240603,
0.6655575633,
0.1832580417,
-1.0401823521,
0.2079415917,
-0.8009753823,
-0.3740946651,
-0.406175226,
0.5633175969,
-0.3398104012,
-0.5413020253,
0.8462345004,
0.1931309253,
-0.0915618017,
0.4036278427,
0.5106790662,
0.0135016106,
1.1370494366,
0.4365575612,
0.1769521683,
0.0192319956,
-0.0075167958,
0.14352341,
-0.7560077906,
-0.2528249323,
-0.5637261868,
-0.0629943162,
-0.7332575917,
-0.3599778116,
0.6843690276,
-0.2437052578,
0.0606476106,
0.1275819987,
-0.4681140184,
0.2073197961,
0.3064832687,
0.2589481771,
0.2568185627,
-0.0033589331,
-0.2774692178,
-0.1543947011,
-0.4988183975,
-0.565567255,
0.9321405292,
0.4838440418,
0.6706629395,
0.0932461843,
0.5235400796,
0.0849069804,
0.348089397,
-0.7558422089,
0.0088127684,
-0.712447226,
-0.6540721655,
-0.1707023978,
-0.2121631801,
-0.9143406749,
-0.0322777182,
-0.2927632034,
-0.6376359463,
0.4710733593,
0.5351786017,
-0.9681118131,
-0.027950203,
-0.4732316136,
0.6357192993,
-0.1798779368,
0.0793275535,
-0.1082000136,
-0.7236584425,
-0.1189433411,
-0.0882463232,
0.0723725185,
-0.0528874062,
0.0155011453,
0.5414158106,
-0.6759058237,
0.4878396392,
-0.2637507319,
0.2859570086,
0.0575001352,
-0.2477417737,
0.421576798,
-0.0455327183,
-0.3112851083,
0.5245960951,
-0.0757598206,
-0.1640235037,
-0.4614014626,
0.5025681853,
-0.5594858527,
-0.3064421415,
-0.2909175158,
-0.3643524051,
-0.6469342113,
0.1267236173,
0.5502110124,
0.9115296006,
-0.5696104169,
-0.0620472766,
0.6335582733,
-0.2086320221,
0.0394496918,
0.7647458315,
0.4176892936,
-0.6412093043,
0.6659041047,
0.3387015462,
0.40701285,
0.1489618272,
-0.0495384149,
-0.3783736825,
-0.9611809254,
-0.5879893303,
0.2304759026,
-0.5818318725,
-0.2041449994,
-1.1161079407,
-0.4381894767,
-0.4633696377,
-0.2257560194,
-0.4976932406,
-0.5310701728,
-0.4108280838,
0.0445862897,
0.4685269296,
0.5179157853,
0.1506737918,
0.4986286461,
-0.7365885973,
0.3699163496,
0.0163714346,
0.3954004943,
-0.4193670154,
-0.5675370693,
-0.1443907022,
0.2018142194,
0.0054305638,
-0.7977301478,
0.6706643701,
0.5864827633,
0.5520586371,
0.3994844258,
0.120524101,
0.9563805461,
-1.1688376665,
0.5981604457,
0.0622603931,
-0.7267376781,
0.3212146461,
0.0086620962,
-0.0094261197,
0.8456264138,
0.3830960989,
-0.6229662299,
-0.399330467,
-0.642752409,
-0.9877840281,
0.3883098364,
0.1065512225,
-0.0000098766,
-0.2141933888,
0.3519348502,
-0.0702682212,
0.1655948162,
0.1453917027,
-0.5036156774,
0.1951429993,
-0.4425599873,
-0.3314138949,
-0.3116429448,
-0.2812234163,
-0.0330987871,
0.6390575767,
-0.2220000625,
0.3746722639,
0.5631923676,
-0.22813797,
-0.1700204313,
0.2579692304,
0.6070511937,
0.374660939,
-0.0519561172,
-0.0323023014,
0.350322336,
-0.8349241018,
0.0365049727,
0.6541730165,
0.096112445,
0.2745320201,
0.1212306097,
0.9016970396,
0.3215573728,
-0.7148961425,
0.4161798656,
-0.2936931551,
0.1435875893,
-0.4143996239,
-0.0027273586,
-0.0572695695,
0.1096267924,
0.214272961,
0.3895925879,
0.6574869752,
-0.5217875838,
0.4634722769,
0.619318068,
-0.7595697641,
-0.2443015128,
1.0913534164,
0.2514548898,
-0.6065465212,
0.5676999688,
0.2492419034,
-0.6245040298,
0.711602807,
0.7136052847,
0.7813999653,
-0.5499420762,
-0.3732630014,
0.2868207395,
0.1477946043,
-0.2270938456,
0.4595585465,
0.4317721426,
-0.8203437328,
-0.2464887649,
-0.5297566056,
-0.6353976727,
-0.0047797593,
-1.0019854307,
0.4101114273,
-0.4054125845,
-0.464192301,
0.5982490778,
-0.0456731915,
-0.6329057813,
0.6597031951,
0.362955302,
0.7451423407,
-0.6718139648,
0.6775182486,
0.924133718,
-0.1225069985,
-0.9813355207,
-0.1095592231,
0.2402442694,
-0.7824450731,
0.0956883579,
0.2378278077,
-0.070054397,
-0.0236893166,
0.0051354528,
-0.9623081088,
0.6854093075,
0.1540384144,
-0.7811092734,
-0.0360676199,
0.1849575192,
0.8511052132,
-0.5849607587,
0.2527110875,
0.7349137664,
0.0126268864,
0.0204491597,
-1.4655604362,
0.0039390381,
-0.1932605058,
-0.0898479223,
0.1157757267,
-0.2415814698,
0.6238294244,
-0.6585806012,
-0.31535694,
0.2258526385,
0.4169811904,
0.2237931937,
0.6104084253,
0.3875063956,
0.1634214371,
1.147454977,
-0.2070855647,
1.0688705444,
-0.4817216694,
-0.1975894868,
0.9118839502,
-0.4931562245,
0.7398469448,
0.1132074893,
-0.0283418726,
0.3594242036,
0.3959385157,
0.2730844319,
0.502584815,
-0.0144399563,
-0.3884289861,
-0.0429795608,
-0.1858604997,
-0.2628007829,
0.5998103619,
0.8490661979,
-0.6962571144,
0.5169950128,
0.076273866,
0.1074897498,
0.1871014237,
-0.4005559087,
0.8883052468,
0.2969133854,
-0.470138669,
0.690074861,
-0.2092960626,
0.3059151769,
-0.3691816032,
-0.0710680336,
0.126357004,
0.3487036526,
-0.1332008094,
-0.1468742937,
0.2994556129,
-0.0756318718,
-0.3160506189,
0.2241579443,
0.5702195764,
-0.5893028975,
-0.4356282949,
-0.0714548826,
0.0474901386,
0.2252709121,
0.024472652,
-0.3291274905,
-0.0854242295,
-0.138615042,
0.2562922835,
-0.0037594745,
0.3581498265,
-0.1720675081,
0.5395992994,
0.4844223559,
0.60870713,
0.0032656339,
0.2717286646,
0.6582874656,
-0.5690701008,
-0.5706781149,
-0.6394031048,
0.5496606231,
-0.1500217766,
-0.2169780135,
0.3816306591,
0.4977706075,
0.27026245,
0.0651479214,
0.5022076368,
0.2525082231,
1.0094475746,
-0.5811501741,
1.0915222168,
-0.4301583469,
0.2697840333,
-0.2459946424,
-0.3803085685,
-0.5472136736,
0.5369326472,
-0.078121841,
-0.11625579,
0.501291275,
0.8003097773,
0.0913284719,
0.2146746069,
0.5197652578,
0.4632990658,
0.2430883944,
0.2600040734,
0.3166884482,
-0.5229626298,
0.0403645448,
-0.3838047087,
-0.0474541932,
-0.457538873,
-0.5755384564,
-0.5709693432,
-0.2715103328,
-0.4800792038,
-0.4731277525,
0.5026029944,
1.2606630325,
0.8391102552,
-1.3337811232,
0.2569340467,
0.2819467485,
-0.3751784563,
-0.5351670384,
-0.1053107083,
0.4230586588,
-0.184380427,
-0.7270443439,
0.7039310336,
0.1958412677,
0.1311140805,
0.348739177,
0.0145963123,
0.2901037037,
0.4467128515,
0.283973515,
0.5107816458,
-0.7658160329,
-0.2807616293,
-0.0078243362,
-0.3821811378,
0.3377575874,
0.7678584456,
-0.5299320221,
0.6806577444,
-0.2642963827,
0.6943874359,
0.1629548967,
0.1785149276,
0.8065783381,
-0.5632392764,
-0.1043690145,
0.6729954481,
0.5868074298,
0.6897437572,
-0.5378529429,
0.2907274961,
-0.1981063485,
-0.7236664891,
-0.9003428221,
-0.1155905575,
-0.7654241323,
0.302300334,
1.038944006,
-0.2357332557,
-0.0185208526,
-0.4971216023,
-0.1156995296,
0.3944820166,
-0.3630565405,
0.7662157416,
0.2315225452,
-0.3413096964,
0.1449045241,
-0.7193261385,
0.9363720417,
0.4101987183,
-0.564370513,
-0.2309211493,
0.6224450469,
0.5391776562,
0.2629210353,
0.681807518,
-0.2052698582,
0.4904226661,
0.0250867121,
0.2068015039,
0.1368191391,
-0.2005775273,
-0.6906479001,
-0.1719464958,
0.3144212961,
-0.3587784767
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12386v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12386v1 | IPEval: A Bilingual Intellectual Property Agency Consultation Evaluation Benchmark for Large Language Models | 2024-06-18T08:18:18 | 2024-06-18T08:18:18 | Qiyao Wang, Jianguo Huang, Shule Lu, Yuan Lin, Kan Xu, Liang Yang, Hongfei Lin | cs.CL | cs.CL | The rapid development of Large Language Models (LLMs) in vertical domains,
including intellectual property (IP), lacks a specific evaluation benchmark for
assessing their understanding, application, and reasoning abilities. To fill
this gap, we introduce IPEval, the first evaluation benchmark tailored for IP
agency and consulting tasks. IPEval comprises 2657 multiple-choice questions
across four major dimensions: creation, application, protection, and management
of IP. These questions span patent rights (inventions, utility models,
designs), trademarks, copyrights, trade secrets, and other related laws.
Evaluation methods include zero-shot, 5-few-shot, and Chain of Thought (CoT)
for seven LLM types, predominantly in English or Chinese. Results show superior
English performance by models like GPT series and Qwen series, while
Chinese-centric LLMs excel in Chinese tests, albeit specialized IP LLMs lag
behind general-purpose ones. Regional and temporal aspects of IP underscore the
need for LLMs to grasp legal nuances and evolving laws. IPEval aims to
accurately gauge LLM capabilities in IP and spur development of specialized
models. Website: \url{https://ipeval.github.io/} | [
-0.4098105133,
-0.4576335549,
0.209235087,
0.9420602918,
-0.2085507512,
0.4299689531,
-0.1424319744,
-0.540155232,
-0.1010175943,
0.5642855763,
-0.1681223214,
-0.5941858888,
-0.3922323585,
0.0209173411,
-0.2156370133,
0.9744832516,
-0.153267473,
0.3080292344,
-0.0833462328,
-0.1926046461,
-0.399895072,
-0.402248174,
-0.6605979204,
-0.3279578388,
0.1746705472,
0.1675060838,
0.407589525,
0.2505733371,
0.7164229155,
0.193231076,
-0.1459487975,
0.1105608642,
-0.4123989642,
-0.0865506604,
-0.3460028172,
-0.3753528297,
-0.6024394035,
0.0410396345,
0.7092315555,
0.5866187215,
-0.1648271382,
0.4849458337,
-0.0177174527,
0.8208838701,
-0.7245572805,
0.0888430104,
-0.7946282029,
0.0780108869,
-0.3903060555,
0.0176454615,
-0.452737987,
-0.3199660778,
0.4189363122,
-0.2431292981,
-0.1514295936,
0.3959208131,
0.9545565248,
0.0018438131,
-0.4760068059,
0.1061625928,
-0.3273846507,
0.73782897,
-0.4707846045,
0.2093208283,
0.3316478729,
0.4019499719,
0.035186749,
-1.077712059,
-0.4902956784,
-0.6348685026,
0.2902442515,
0.154438138,
-0.1324824095,
-0.1324706376,
0.0494993702,
0.2177817672,
-0.4995928705,
0.1479112059,
-0.4012333453,
-0.0862104818,
0.7428210974,
0.1124034002,
0.5381455421,
0.2333455086,
-0.5150145888,
0.2109290361,
-1.4214372635,
0.0230123438,
0.4443469942,
0.1670725346,
-0.037619561,
0.4913100898,
0.0480978116,
0.3252856731,
0.0179896075,
0.2173759192,
0.274377346,
-0.2772118151,
-0.0525077656,
0.0887397826,
0.625498116,
0.225092873,
0.2864388227,
-0.0582762025,
-0.193254739,
-0.6475133896,
0.237464875,
-0.8825231791,
-0.0879707038,
0.2418582588,
-0.4454804063,
-0.0194500424,
-0.0553616099,
-0.4101448953,
-0.5774224997,
-0.3266985416,
0.4442054033,
-0.2080733776,
-0.4509818852,
-0.0599484146,
-0.0132421181,
0.6121429205,
0.2279743254,
-0.6152732968,
0.4008187652,
0.9001177549,
0.7983542085,
-0.3266952336,
-0.8015694618,
-0.5372353792,
-0.1227890104,
-0.4909717143,
1.0234251022,
-0.4581698179,
-0.3663986027,
0.0662966818,
-0.0128589645,
0.1077917963,
-0.7519930601,
0.4940553308,
-0.9256082773,
-0.1522073448,
-0.3572717607,
-0.1915691495,
0.2169519663,
0.5072448254,
-0.5894886255,
0.7620071173,
-0.0647218451,
-0.6681463718,
0.6121069193,
-0.7928570509,
-0.3395902216,
0.5897215605,
-0.2720594108,
-0.1857728809,
-0.3845407963,
0.2328410298,
-0.0036610905,
-0.9220365286,
0.2726471126,
-0.2229014486,
-0.3488484621,
0.0576417744,
-0.4366700351,
1.1614860296,
0.264706403,
-0.3098164499,
0.058805611,
-0.4442361891,
0.1754635721,
-0.0249450281,
-0.4422667325,
-0.0775083899,
0.058723066,
0.0002011336,
0.1155745611,
0.6316378713,
-0.531169951,
-0.0857924148,
-0.3005253375,
0.1733336747,
0.8688098788,
-0.0403434969,
-0.2292273641,
-0.2663616836,
0.7412971854,
-0.0411754996,
-0.030391613,
-0.0733026192,
-0.4746183157,
-0.6690993309,
-0.4681058824,
0.5323742032,
0.5701909065,
-0.516905725,
0.3649863303,
-0.4215556383,
-0.6434332728,
-0.9158393741,
0.195039764,
0.5017505884,
0.3483043313,
0.1670396924,
-0.1284604222,
-0.2564102113,
-1.1484607458,
-0.4720501602,
-0.4861055613,
-0.0120785423,
0.3320676386,
0.5584051609,
0.1154980212,
0.7284684777,
-0.0133670466,
-0.3416419327,
-0.2844470143,
0.4567087591,
0.3072282672,
0.0144108701,
0.723331511,
-0.7713569403,
-1.2513258457,
0.3240736425,
-0.4426119328,
-0.4880355895,
0.1567206234,
-0.1718106717,
-0.069569543,
0.1670917422,
-0.4029921293,
0.2584446073,
0.2350354344,
-0.3810318708,
0.842822969,
-0.3355214298,
0.1931615919,
-0.7146021724,
0.2522190213,
-0.1439619213,
-0.0846876204,
-0.4279591441,
0.2060805708,
0.2838104665,
-0.1865573674,
-0.8166612983,
0.7067483068,
-0.6730676293,
-0.1146689132,
-0.1231911927,
0.2171423286,
0.0941250697,
0.0227590129,
-0.071655415,
1.3794972897,
0.7597432733,
-0.2804796696,
0.4859591126,
0.1813627034,
-0.4736486971,
0.9727330208,
-0.7793176174,
0.1955774277,
-0.0403473675,
-0.0526535176,
-0.750087142,
0.1805663407,
-0.2139193565,
0.0356369764,
0.3071991503,
-0.2572937012,
-0.4752721488,
-0.3801124692,
-0.4969055355,
0.4130296707,
0.4734443426,
-0.9457529187,
0.3439988792,
0.6944696307,
-0.4827952385,
-1.0658423901,
-0.733804822,
0.4875857234,
-0.1969151199,
-0.6980119348,
0.4803406,
-0.2065339684,
-0.4292921722,
0.1068129912,
0.3234682679,
-0.4886420965,
-0.1390761137,
-0.0952310115,
0.2250926793,
-0.4847954214,
-0.0347529799,
-0.0761687085,
0.1264707595,
0.2012683302,
-0.1160501912,
0.4416393936,
-0.7759569883,
-0.6667729616,
-0.2485990375,
0.2729654312,
0.795627892,
-0.4763341844,
0.5231847763,
-0.0801136345,
-0.2645944655,
-0.4495584369,
-0.596347034,
0.5499469638,
-0.4925692379,
0.4500215948,
-0.6366158128,
-0.3074262142,
0.6150991917,
-0.1588897109,
-0.0222494509,
0.5719201565,
0.8203929663,
0.3416301906,
0.8074569106,
0.481963098,
-0.3891368508,
0.1038203388,
-0.2260707021,
0.5798923373,
-0.8778970242,
-0.2359603196,
-0.3050397336,
-0.1909894049,
-0.412294507,
-0.3195340335,
0.5424780846,
0.0090173921,
-0.3179846704,
0.2738892138,
-0.2678306997,
0.8308927417,
0.3240480721,
-0.1142115593,
0.415340811,
-0.0316762626,
-0.3560130894,
-0.2422204763,
-0.2845018208,
-0.8035594225,
1.3027908802,
0.5058177114,
0.6901753545,
0.124238655,
0.4756662548,
0.5279502869,
0.7107089162,
-0.6912034154,
0.6124604344,
-0.2660309374,
-0.7023208737,
-0.1113244817,
0.067380242,
-0.8099900484,
0.4526114464,
0.258859098,
-0.7054383755,
0.1355349869,
-0.1725467741,
-0.2605134845,
0.3459085226,
-0.6680240035,
0.6655508876,
-0.7936532497,
-0.6956812739,
-0.3751450479,
-0.2664954662,
0.3014726341,
-0.3987258375,
-0.0730073303,
-0.3062589169,
-0.2518388927,
0.4778875113,
-0.5286331773,
0.482886672,
-0.2213920504,
0.2099199891,
0.374987781,
-0.0971550941,
0.3095844984,
0.0939773247,
-0.5615878105,
0.3285238445,
0.1438625902,
-0.34584108,
-0.1031055078,
0.8599062562,
-0.9198843241,
-0.6732846498,
-0.5341446996,
-0.4223333895,
-0.3853933811,
0.3688157797,
0.0951361209,
0.0996940136,
-0.5674164891,
0.2637682855,
0.3047816753,
-0.2597116828,
0.2225766927,
1.0592240095,
-0.1398969293,
-0.2680751085,
0.7916975617,
0.2373881638,
-0.02330615,
0.2374524176,
0.1384863406,
-0.3878350556,
-0.8512203097,
-0.2831835747,
0.149617359,
-0.8245739937,
-0.2178095728,
-0.3777897656,
-0.6734057069,
-0.1313714683,
0.0615198389,
-0.564172864,
-0.0619120188,
0.0403499119,
-0.0389615446,
0.0704672709,
0.5519249439,
0.0403599143,
-0.1759821326,
-0.3606214225,
0.3242724538,
0.3639796376,
0.5718494654,
-0.212092936,
-0.5921700001,
-0.0489209369,
-0.0478268117,
-0.3704906702,
-0.4911272228,
0.4720881581,
0.3390953839,
0.7457256317,
0.3498223126,
0.1344533563,
0.7405427098,
-0.8832322955,
1.0008568764,
-0.0406807102,
-0.9825553298,
0.374265343,
-0.1480830759,
-0.1225918904,
0.6727966666,
0.4364650249,
-0.3111489713,
-0.1321141422,
-0.265232861,
-1.0259538889,
0.5847841501,
-0.1458642483,
0.3791592717,
0.0087216292,
0.1233256981,
0.1917203665,
0.2701662779,
-0.9151866436,
-0.0311993565,
0.1761297137,
0.1186116263,
0.5902970433,
-0.2785171866,
-0.2932829559,
-0.2567850053,
0.6976591349,
0.0531568564,
0.0651722625,
0.0531593971,
-0.3167928755,
0.0170362778,
0.2032212466,
0.2833014727,
1.2925006151,
-0.1469388902,
-0.0555104688,
0.2907702029,
-0.3996812403,
0.0332309045,
0.2141029537,
0.0313576907,
-0.2469494194,
0.3267785311,
0.5707648396,
-0.5109437108,
-0.9941383004,
0.9186666012,
-0.1073893309,
-0.2277995348,
-0.4457147121,
-0.2858709395,
-0.1350825876,
0.3066308498,
0.5443007946,
-0.4196018577,
-0.028202856,
-0.4787738919,
0.2138610184,
0.5085449815,
-0.2897823453,
-0.2730951905,
0.5834415555,
0.2818870544,
-0.4299910069,
0.5311341286,
-0.1374960542,
-0.4898591638,
0.663576901,
0.6225863099,
1.1440937519,
-0.0187565517,
0.2166877091,
-0.0157641843,
0.5126968622,
0.2452022284,
0.4485831857,
0.1012240276,
-0.5472202897,
-0.2281897366,
-0.4701486528,
-0.7712746263,
0.3576690257,
-0.2449277043,
0.5215432644,
-0.6200699806,
0.0358070657,
-0.1410440952,
0.155161351,
-0.8252167702,
-0.1324286163,
0.0479764454,
1.2992969751,
-0.616286397,
0.7760035992,
0.6245189905,
-0.4575992823,
-0.3641155064,
0.215771094,
-0.1870439053,
-1.111700654,
1.2107491493,
0.0786288008,
-0.3348261118,
-0.1484954059,
-0.4505103827,
-0.6140590906,
1.0938403606,
0.5613865256,
-0.3227474093,
0.3840798736,
0.6167606115,
0.9023292661,
-0.580435276,
0.4301528335,
0.6769916415,
0.4947642684,
-0.1734644324,
-1.1327062845,
-0.2452076226,
-0.7028882504,
0.0185838453,
-0.118216686,
-0.8730641007,
0.7639222741,
-0.064625293,
-0.1073751226,
0.1559786797,
0.2343790978,
0.4438945949,
0.2778886557,
0.263353765,
0.3538670242,
0.777119875,
-0.1179084927,
1.2201626301,
-0.807559073,
0.0031384549,
1.1245452166,
-0.8681701422,
1.1595990658,
0.5357936621,
-0.4964035153,
0.3734570742,
0.5038539171,
-0.0784073323,
0.6365059018,
0.3322530985,
-0.4403940737,
0.2160123885,
-0.5029258728,
-0.4826639891,
0.2650954723,
0.4792365432,
-0.1617670059,
-0.2030927539,
-0.2365450114,
-0.240193069,
0.0375786126,
-0.0440072007,
0.531313777,
0.010546674,
-0.7415340543,
0.5298991799,
0.170947358,
0.3063222468,
-0.7572135925,
0.0811062157,
-0.328122437,
0.1771983951,
0.0965060145,
-0.9719651937,
0.0925295427,
0.3209105134,
0.2664506137,
-0.3276705444,
0.4590088129,
-0.3625847995,
-0.350890547,
0.5007320642,
0.3181404471,
0.3018436134,
-0.0929311737,
-0.9372630119,
-0.1674205661,
-0.4407152236,
-0.2634735107,
0.1904934049,
0.5260426998,
-0.2299015969,
0.7041558027,
0.4824729562,
0.6540523171,
0.1726060808,
0.2533849478,
0.8371654153,
-0.3747803569,
-0.3647303283,
-0.7003667355,
0.6795191169,
-0.3393385708,
-0.5615833402,
0.5431342125,
0.6147078276,
0.5959006548,
0.0048452541,
0.8934885263,
0.0039942185,
0.3919386864,
-0.2488514483,
0.9676601887,
-0.4375762045,
0.6905784607,
0.0867610276,
-0.9514609575,
-0.4108268619,
0.339717865,
-0.7421609163,
-0.1618018299,
0.7385692596,
0.8194506168,
-0.0991594344,
-0.3590310216,
0.4394360185,
0.1171374395,
0.5589060187,
0.3175526857,
1.1718238592,
-0.3628377616,
0.5178913474,
-0.198774606,
-0.2567307353,
0.0126277013,
-1.15858531,
-0.9559769034,
-0.2391307652,
-0.2521429062,
0.0316376872,
0.0680316538,
0.9762336016,
0.7988877296,
-0.9881125689,
-0.6340435147,
-0.046721831,
0.0178929605,
-0.0027395142,
-0.2573820651,
0.4328836203,
-0.3075073063,
-0.6488255262,
0.4617060423,
0.812610209,
-0.2813939154,
-0.4614904523,
-0.0345146209,
-0.2534777224,
0.1587550342,
0.5662254095,
0.4432060719,
-0.8087943196,
0.024727745,
-0.180924058,
-0.0913708135,
0.1849826127,
0.723282814,
-0.2757595778,
0.803332746,
0.626663506,
0.9966012836,
0.4708385468,
-0.2403848618,
0.7290710807,
-0.5994071364,
0.3710005283,
0.4347904623,
0.4981278181,
0.2660828233,
-0.2229116261,
0.3986823857,
-0.1949391961,
-0.6645157933,
-0.8241574764,
0.074828513,
-0.3684217334,
-0.0329414755,
0.7115327716,
-0.4798885286,
0.0360905491,
-0.0777332485,
-0.4040561318,
-0.4401860535,
-0.096806936,
0.8304451108,
0.9016441703,
-0.093233265,
-0.0281995907,
-0.5299021006,
0.2305861264,
0.5513271689,
-0.9730327725,
0.0203785356,
0.2314472497,
0.1635392457,
0.0003678825,
0.7694830298,
-0.3940490484,
0.3548727632,
-0.1100975275,
-0.1484516114,
0.1387316734,
-0.4835376143,
-0.2550398409,
0.1705432832,
0.629602313,
-0.0428634249
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12382v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12382v1 | From Instance Training to Instruction Learning: Task Adapters Generation from Instructions | 2024-06-18T08:14:28 | 2024-06-18T08:14:28 | Huanxuan Liao, Yao Xu, Shizhu He, Yuanzhe Zhang, Yanchao Hao, Shengping Liu, Kang Liu, Jun Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have acquired the ability to solve general tasks
by utilizing instruction finetuning (IFT). However, IFT still relies heavily on
instance training of extensive task data, which greatly limits the adaptability
of LLMs to real-world scenarios where labeled task instances are scarce and
broader task generalization becomes paramount. Contrary to LLMs, humans acquire
skills and complete tasks not merely through repeated practice but also by
understanding and following instructional guidelines. This paper is dedicated
to simulating human learning to address the shortcomings of instance training,
focusing on instruction learning to enhance cross-task generalization. Within
this context, we introduce Task Adapters Generation from Instructions (TAGI),
which automatically constructs the task-specific model in a parameter
generation manner based on the given task instructions without retraining for
unseen tasks. Specifically, we utilize knowledge distillation to enhance the
consistency between TAGI developed through Learning with Instruction and
task-specific models developed through Training with Instance, by aligning the
labels, output logits, and adapter parameters between them. TAGI is endowed
with cross-task generalization capabilities through a two-stage training
process that includes hypernetwork pretraining and finetuning. We evaluate TAGI
on the Super-Natural Instructions and P3 datasets. The experimental results
demonstrate that TAGI can match or even outperform traditional meta-trained
models and other hypernetwork models, while significantly reducing
computational requirements. | [
-0.097422123,
-0.691033721,
0.501440227,
-0.1463258117,
-0.1689771116,
-0.288472116,
-0.2674061954,
-0.2272160351,
-0.430398047,
0.3524264991,
-0.6857850552,
-0.2932480276,
-0.5488443375,
-0.1566108465,
0.016429998,
1.0778331757,
-0.0130373659,
0.004595743,
-0.2283899635,
0.2591171563,
-0.7784785032,
-0.3280557394,
-0.5652844906,
-0.6249059439,
0.319981426,
0.7613818645,
-0.062309254,
0.6865733862,
0.1414598376,
0.2723207772,
0.6440122128,
0.3152501881,
-0.4920924604,
-0.1437112093,
-0.3115339279,
-0.8853334188,
-0.2692350447,
0.077391766,
0.4183555543,
0.6432712674,
-0.3421007097,
0.1945682317,
0.4241886139,
0.4619698524,
-0.5635948181,
0.3655084968,
-0.889280498,
-0.1179745048,
0.0968248025,
-0.1572055072,
-0.4860236645,
0.0199278723,
0.1573713571,
-0.8504697084,
0.6601829529,
0.1484721452,
0.7740600109,
0.3025272489,
-0.0981108621,
-0.3510677516,
-0.8455227613,
1.0596426725,
-0.7822539806,
0.2596167922,
0.3474796116,
0.3956530988,
-0.2879405916,
-0.6937996745,
-0.3933702111,
-0.1856947988,
-0.0913063958,
0.1628561467,
-0.2478964478,
0.1636007726,
0.3141875863,
-0.0792087987,
-0.4226106405,
0.2067229152,
-0.3334853649,
0.2196325064,
0.3845297992,
0.1552866846,
0.3076584041,
0.1244536266,
-0.3879560232,
-0.1372183114,
-0.686259985,
0.051707074,
0.3139141798,
0.2891424,
-0.0194319412,
0.213793084,
-0.1525799632,
1.0452326536,
0.2885765433,
-0.2309331745,
0.0170243233,
-0.1951070726,
-0.3329725266,
-0.0713792816,
0.4967090487,
0.3780049384,
0.265483588,
-0.4678904414,
0.0371018797,
-0.0355213545,
0.7316820621,
-0.9072548151,
-0.2520236969,
-0.1092666686,
-0.2637656033,
0.0241700243,
0.0219653826,
-0.33807078,
-0.0635559782,
-0.702491343,
0.4184496403,
-0.6224981546,
0.2056439817,
-0.0130858272,
-0.1082953885,
0.2348850518,
0.3369036019,
-1.0257254839,
0.3748171031,
0.8067968488,
0.4693984389,
0.036590863,
-0.6297482252,
-0.4421054423,
0.4313276112,
-0.1384463906,
0.5808596015,
-0.5224928856,
-0.2274870127,
-0.2502018511,
0.1545592695,
-0.403989166,
-0.6746667027,
0.3292054236,
-0.3200136125,
-0.2050695717,
0.0065434352,
-0.7567521334,
-0.3378001153,
0.0674859658,
-0.3021760881,
0.5945388675,
0.095276311,
-0.5838340521,
0.5565737486,
-0.7146663666,
-0.428894341,
-0.0476734303,
-0.1600630879,
-0.4072296917,
0.2908667028,
0.1621188819,
0.9057671428,
-0.5139891505,
0.2342712432,
-0.1755438447,
-0.4227365851,
-0.1370920092,
-0.1677042544,
0.2810240388,
-0.0267655309,
-0.6584304571,
-0.0176317897,
-0.5949440002,
-0.0460102148,
0.1019896343,
-0.2612259388,
-0.505818367,
0.1992411315,
-0.3629971147,
0.1675362736,
-0.0755171478,
-0.6551839709,
0.2938795984,
-0.102724582,
0.6066237092,
0.5917817354,
0.0492612012,
0.3758913875,
-0.4575147629,
0.2788561285,
0.2043659985,
0.0262437593,
-0.1121217981,
-0.3775979877,
-0.8515136242,
0.1051693484,
0.0986113548,
0.737082243,
-0.8821572661,
0.4395220876,
-0.4133939445,
-0.5075139403,
-0.4707751572,
0.4014286995,
0.703553021,
0.5687375665,
0.4420064986,
-0.1312824637,
-0.6165685058,
-0.8860588074,
-0.0644828156,
0.084325552,
-0.2341509759,
0.3038132787,
0.4183460772,
-0.2079657465,
0.7377980351,
-0.4773128927,
-0.359454006,
-0.3251244724,
0.469639957,
-0.0526595823,
0.7579442859,
0.3275049627,
-0.5674914718,
-0.2674054801,
0.0445901379,
-0.6332840323,
0.1293716431,
-0.2565142512,
-0.1041813418,
-0.0018543385,
0.5232362747,
0.0050367769,
0.2933807373,
0.4994689524,
0.1618704945,
0.2620900571,
-0.5828709006,
0.1476294696,
-1.294636488,
0.0954644904,
0.4584516883,
-0.1126589477,
-0.7153366208,
-0.0942267552,
-0.0537621155,
-0.1074938104,
-0.2806860209,
0.2240930051,
-0.6906214356,
0.0172260497,
-0.51863873,
-0.2002414763,
0.0235932134,
0.6972138286,
0.1772666574,
0.7851495743,
0.5707575083,
-0.6500734687,
0.2857460082,
-0.0416673981,
-0.3187350035,
0.5718805194,
-0.8316857219,
0.2981565595,
-0.0183754545,
0.1901596934,
-0.8384830952,
-0.1205332726,
0.1521792263,
0.0101718688,
0.4451830983,
-0.43409127,
-0.2131090611,
-0.2450365871,
0.0793695003,
0.2881756425,
0.8232854605,
-0.5065357089,
0.6855356693,
0.1676839292,
0.1825323105,
-0.5069980621,
-0.6218760014,
-0.3409462571,
-0.1312376857,
-0.2674715817,
0.3194161057,
0.0080588656,
0.1732914895,
0.0355742425,
-0.2470978349,
-0.3485105932,
0.1349307895,
0.6479868293,
0.2576438785,
-0.1315702498,
-0.1406488866,
0.2317468971,
0.1146432534,
-0.0184425451,
-0.5204328895,
0.2806667089,
0.071483396,
-0.4481803775,
-0.8095620275,
0.2217688113,
0.2135133445,
-0.1308046877,
0.6439658999,
0.6154273152,
-0.2846140265,
-0.6214449406,
-0.5047977567,
-0.2339963913,
-0.4024014771,
0.5580322146,
-0.5381320119,
-0.7541483045,
0.0298383608,
-0.3892476261,
0.3625663221,
-0.0815869868,
0.2018544078,
-0.2472585142,
0.7859323025,
0.7086493373,
-0.0833412483,
0.5431420207,
-0.5313760638,
-0.095826298,
-1.017013669,
-0.155395925,
-0.2759202719,
-0.5096503496,
-0.155434534,
-0.7418495417,
0.1817919463,
0.2220807225,
-0.0240404159,
0.5132552981,
-0.5646814704,
0.4572988153,
0.8395305276,
0.507534802,
-0.0925279707,
0.0493635051,
0.1636770815,
0.1052018926,
-0.9526757598,
-0.4410428703,
1.1960194111,
0.0404238179,
0.8297883272,
-0.4483563304,
1.0239057541,
0.3801000416,
0.3567017317,
-0.5630861521,
0.4575271606,
-0.4541149735,
-0.254206717,
-0.2098669112,
-0.432272017,
-1.0907657146,
-0.0063028107,
-0.158796832,
-0.6652804017,
0.1826975346,
0.5569939613,
-0.3526576757,
0.3948441148,
-1.122512579,
1.0285755396,
-0.0553569496,
-0.3640029132,
-0.286860168,
-0.6493808031,
0.2487582117,
0.0279425699,
0.0869651809,
-0.0347344764,
-0.0392062664,
0.6363779306,
-0.2041496187,
1.2892206907,
-0.4422008693,
0.0119953323,
0.4622571766,
-0.1664728075,
0.3725968897,
-0.2027175575,
-0.0115892384,
-0.1032483503,
-0.4275438488,
-0.6369338036,
-0.8785190582,
0.7515081167,
-0.909153223,
-0.7762761712,
0.1227402687,
-0.8533915877,
-0.1580634117,
-0.0867180973,
0.1707963943,
0.6004167199,
-0.3482712209,
-0.1411872208,
0.7939509153,
0.2006737292,
0.2529343665,
0.3846614361,
0.3361553848,
-0.0256935079,
1.1686645746,
0.0463107042,
0.3128873408,
0.5729675889,
0.0848061144,
0.028745193,
-0.6290768981,
-0.6536061168,
0.1020282581,
-0.4032960832,
-0.1316117048,
-0.3563866913,
0.0427121893,
-0.2438413352,
-0.1173322052,
-0.0324391536,
0.0769760683,
-0.4373067021,
0.1334752887,
0.1170979366,
0.9469601512,
0.1467091441,
0.4751583934,
-0.9299802184,
0.3620759249,
0.7447702885,
0.0450325683,
0.0637575015,
-0.5696445704,
-0.4140135646,
0.3976666331,
-0.2149250954,
-0.6720942855,
0.0172811765,
0.5710892677,
0.7627012134,
0.2449479252,
-0.022330448,
0.9124489427,
-0.9791076183,
0.4131649435,
0.1011894271,
-0.975533247,
0.6848633289,
-0.1385163963,
0.1595640779,
0.4777339399,
0.6917951107,
-0.1916281134,
-0.1596159786,
-0.5138882399,
-0.5553622842,
1.0826576948,
-0.1080387905,
0.1844689548,
0.1856658906,
0.7173455954,
0.2664601207,
-0.0318052061,
-0.3419858217,
-0.0434364192,
-0.3026387095,
-0.3572507799,
-0.2461899668,
-0.036286585,
-0.1866254658,
-0.2081669867,
0.8208361864,
-0.229553178,
0.2347164303,
0.1432598829,
-0.3165964484,
0.1493436992,
0.3085528314,
0.5392276049,
0.6365414858,
-0.0302237067,
0.0958401635,
0.2710717618,
-0.3750288785,
0.3866234422,
0.1864657104,
0.0424748547,
-0.2442016155,
0.2632022798,
1.2046699524,
0.4012516439,
-0.4865308702,
0.3044033647,
0.0414585508,
-0.2436858267,
0.12451756,
0.7235546708,
0.281347543,
0.3020890951,
0.1675561965,
-0.0236997996,
0.1182496622,
-0.605602026,
0.2488318533,
0.2091925591,
-0.3911784887,
-0.5283336043,
0.6372250319,
0.3678063452,
-0.2288103253,
0.3901256621,
-0.3505185246,
-0.1793701798,
0.5007525682,
0.8542904258,
0.6286095977,
-0.3696762025,
0.1093900651,
0.3084774315,
0.1899190098,
-0.1113588139,
0.0010548864,
-0.2528853416,
-0.5340901017,
-0.5259401798,
-0.4642191231,
-0.3240267634,
-0.0025489179,
-0.6833444834,
0.0328686498,
-0.4363510609,
0.0391377918,
0.077114895,
-0.1990203857,
-0.6907805204,
0.3579575121,
0.1149467453,
0.5585146546,
-1.1109811068,
1.2208470106,
1.1646504402,
-0.2855373323,
-1.0413565636,
0.18111296,
-0.350621134,
-0.8368158937,
0.7127969861,
0.203659609,
0.0411368944,
0.2474290431,
-0.4219039083,
-0.2626321614,
1.271940589,
0.4027316272,
-0.8158689737,
-0.3868576586,
0.2839771509,
0.3683348596,
-0.4943675995,
0.2130868584,
0.5735633969,
0.104463689,
-0.0866870359,
-0.7132840753,
0.1234614104,
-0.2139962614,
0.4184348285,
0.1178032905,
-0.3763450682,
0.6465778947,
-0.1588749588,
-0.0328766517,
-0.1373448223,
0.6879225373,
0.2049908042,
0.1060588136,
0.7000222206,
0.701851368,
0.2866613567,
-0.0445924252,
0.9598876834,
-0.1580364257,
0.0349565521,
1.4122698307,
-0.2974818051,
0.6199775934,
0.3658205867,
-0.0599353462,
0.7229138017,
0.1481669694,
-0.1081780493,
0.3036147058,
0.3897079527,
-0.1152454093,
-0.3842059076,
-0.0382162444,
-0.0518035591,
0.4382013083,
0.2734958231,
-0.1934951544,
-0.3634071648,
0.2559919953,
-0.106855087,
0.2146580964,
-0.3082732558,
0.9411548972,
-0.0564655252,
-0.8036616445,
0.7232524753,
-0.0952186882,
0.8184015751,
-0.7004497647,
-0.5271573663,
0.1481122971,
0.2871689796,
-0.082683593,
-0.4527454674,
0.1505271047,
-0.0029680342,
-0.4448709786,
-0.1438135058,
0.7292810678,
-0.5885152817,
-0.4110545218,
0.1164566353,
0.4875621498,
0.1895739734,
0.1197305918,
-0.7384008765,
-0.160180822,
0.048725348,
-0.0327529944,
0.5834322572,
0.4133206904,
-0.0797515884,
0.510658145,
0.5360171795,
-0.1459108442,
0.3147050738,
-0.1551916748,
0.7939738631,
-0.2365819663,
-0.1950525194,
-0.5755700469,
0.3983922005,
-0.0035195458,
-0.1714861393,
0.4914426506,
0.5271931291,
1.0655727386,
-0.3746914566,
0.8223139048,
-0.2112276107,
0.357406944,
-0.5116642118,
0.6163593531,
-0.4808751047,
-0.0059407214,
-0.0782655701,
-0.8396595716,
0.0601046979,
0.3590326309,
-0.4657396376,
0.0701704696,
0.3908477724,
0.5662721992,
-0.5132232308,
-0.1641139388,
0.416216135,
-0.1616279334,
0.0628214106,
0.9914658666,
0.5768815279,
-0.412237525,
0.4746748805,
-0.5686003566,
-0.3316220939,
-0.1128806844,
-0.7949151397,
-1.0729312897,
-0.7279552221,
-0.3218540847,
0.2018257231,
0.5704125762,
0.7897123098,
1.1987886429,
-0.7236453295,
-0.549669385,
-0.4930709004,
-0.1375168115,
-0.5341978669,
-0.1620694846,
0.1548285335,
-0.6636818051,
-0.9720167518,
0.4920130074,
-0.2836921811,
0.0463388599,
0.2175359279,
-0.0048488774,
-0.2665170431,
-0.1107355356,
0.3052985668,
0.3290959299,
-0.668187499,
-0.3001667559,
-0.2257887423,
0.040463157,
0.0669215843,
0.9959110618,
-0.735963583,
0.3603802025,
0.1629618853,
0.7426688671,
0.4307945967,
0.1065829322,
0.66250211,
-0.948240459,
0.2094529271,
-0.1000141278,
0.3417264223,
0.1359163821,
-0.2213502824,
0.3661468923,
0.1470885575,
-0.5968514085,
-0.4554720223,
0.268384546,
-0.8465895057,
-0.3079710901,
0.8834469318,
-0.7318967581,
-0.4476838708,
-0.0790242031,
-0.3299535811,
0.7171241045,
-0.2753786743,
0.7508102655,
0.2584795654,
-0.2825113833,
-0.0338532478,
-0.5603443384,
0.3493218422,
0.5169426203,
-1.1299800873,
0.1054503694,
0.4003072083,
0.5861843824,
0.0560305789,
0.1179275736,
0.4414202571,
0.2975700498,
-0.0473319329,
0.5061958432,
-0.4368460178,
-0.407106638,
-0.0732265487,
0.014764512,
0.072701253,
-0.6180092692
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12381v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12381v2 | QOG:Question and Options Generation based on Language Model | 2024-06-18T08:09:58 | 2024-07-02T09:21:03 | Jincheng Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Question-Options Generation (QOG) is a task that involves generating a set of
question-options pairs given context. This task has various applications,
including fine-tuning large models, information retrieval, and automated
multiple-choice question generation for education. In this paper, we develop
QOG models using three different methods based on fine-tuning
sequence-to-sequence language models (LMs). Experiments demonstrate that the
end-to-end QOG model is computationally efficient and stable during both
training and inference, outperforming other methods. Furthermore, our analysis
indicates that our QOG models are competitive on the QOG task compared to the
large language model Llama 3-8B. | [
-0.4008032084,
-1.2144975662,
0.6891438365,
-0.4319943786,
-0.170963794,
0.2068870366,
-0.0369330086,
-0.341507107,
-0.2865421176,
0.800141871,
-0.4739849865,
-0.2055522352,
-0.1024268344,
0.0781110227,
-0.3603649139,
0.9986391068,
0.0063258144,
-0.0077569759,
-0.4002315402,
-0.0198568925,
-0.4743517935,
-0.4483391941,
-1.0639158487,
-0.0706343502,
0.3677868247,
0.4562835693,
0.8059857488,
0.3345192671,
0.3727216125,
0.2178477645,
-0.0671147779,
0.2316288054,
-0.5282564163,
0.3084215522,
0.0125751598,
-0.7472289801,
-0.2112583816,
-0.0689493194,
0.8987315297,
0.3181275725,
-0.3476219773,
0.6579853892,
-0.135313347,
0.4527837932,
-0.5453390479,
-0.321003288,
-0.702783823,
-0.0819627419,
-0.0508273691,
-0.2437650412,
-0.3774400651,
-0.6604599357,
0.1121547818,
-0.312274158,
0.0415348932,
0.4765011072,
0.6604579091,
0.045350194,
-0.5597668886,
-0.3283504248,
-0.545045495,
0.8541973233,
-1.0584499836,
0.4195095301,
0.3758048713,
0.5338842869,
-0.3992281854,
-0.8461256623,
-0.5056016445,
-0.1611135155,
0.0704169869,
0.0636546388,
0.1621093452,
0.277441889,
0.3210589588,
0.3675404191,
-0.612842977,
0.0929151475,
-0.6405786276,
0.1647466421,
0.7047811151,
0.2972804606,
0.2681004703,
-0.0695823804,
-0.1296938807,
0.0663241073,
-0.827105701,
0.3541812897,
0.5482094884,
0.2099050879,
0.4221668243,
0.6305868626,
-0.4631825984,
1.1520334482,
0.2061398178,
-0.4820106626,
-0.2250528187,
-0.2066733837,
-0.4836808741,
-0.0238343365,
0.5072870851,
0.5489341617,
-0.016962124,
0.0031939403,
-0.2533701062,
-0.2830387354,
0.1592339724,
-0.6462298632,
0.2158382833,
0.5955397487,
-0.5478977561,
-0.4310340583,
-0.4647094607,
-0.4094007909,
0.164845258,
-0.3007771671,
0.6449329257,
-0.253742069,
-0.1748057753,
0.3322783411,
-0.1264086813,
0.3562179208,
0.2433022559,
-0.7703278661,
0.0886138827,
0.3611349165,
0.4582122862,
-0.0535548069,
-0.1328241229,
-0.5267985463,
0.2440116107,
-0.3754749298,
0.8059123158,
-0.7372016311,
-0.4764081538,
-0.0207792614,
-0.1489797831,
0.0339517146,
-0.5650171638,
0.0455962159,
-0.757286787,
0.8025705814,
0.0168883875,
-0.9920246601,
-0.3139737248,
0.2593404353,
-0.5669779181,
1.3516054153,
0.0872996598,
-0.4958952963,
0.062683709,
-0.5685158372,
-0.0542693585,
0.2692273557,
-0.1022289842,
-0.3611926734,
0.0652607903,
-0.0193195492,
0.3939400315,
-0.6265037656,
0.4667530656,
-0.0795403793,
-0.3291969895,
0.236145243,
-0.168883726,
0.9239243865,
0.3080455065,
-0.2089816481,
0.1303343475,
-0.8205425143,
0.4999059737,
0.2428197116,
-0.6072568297,
-0.1624056101,
0.2488873452,
-0.443423599,
0.3320498765,
0.3587360382,
-0.18795757,
0.3313949704,
-0.175055474,
0.4866551459,
0.503620863,
0.1680553555,
0.2305912673,
-0.480962038,
0.8215053678,
-0.2774704397,
0.1778047085,
-0.274153173,
-0.8245952129,
-0.8268379569,
0.1698077023,
0.394493103,
0.8216386437,
-0.6154251695,
0.1014048085,
0.309799403,
-0.4215553999,
-0.7396511436,
0.0223999172,
0.3347218633,
0.4034004807,
0.1428668797,
-0.0720535368,
-0.333102107,
-0.8265119791,
-0.1910604537,
-0.5320339203,
0.0481864475,
0.2607010901,
0.1955043823,
0.1494931579,
0.908986032,
-0.5451383591,
0.6087949276,
-0.3319390714,
0.2407291532,
0.1170826107,
0.3262214065,
0.5722966194,
-0.6538754106,
-0.3229701519,
-0.2702596188,
-0.4600032568,
-0.0620516986,
-0.2476465255,
-0.4579522312,
0.0775328875,
0.5938668251,
-0.5375609398,
0.1594437957,
0.5104177594,
-0.2143233716,
0.6822781563,
0.0849911347,
0.1959590316,
-1.3390057087,
-0.0188621543,
-0.3901967406,
-0.3547321856,
-0.9126153588,
0.4342971444,
-0.0203417987,
-0.3517942727,
-0.6651939154,
0.7251155972,
-0.3050893843,
0.0622255206,
-0.1253448427,
0.106047757,
0.0568865985,
0.4172500074,
0.0040464047,
0.782420218,
0.5666863322,
-0.7184523344,
0.472189337,
0.0761151984,
-0.3456933796,
0.368776083,
-0.5873038769,
0.4131746888,
-0.268974334,
-0.0537149124,
-1.1583936214,
-0.2083681971,
0.1880433857,
-0.2554255724,
0.0463312231,
0.0962336883,
-0.3793057203,
-0.4809619486,
-0.2239707261,
0.6805633307,
0.7330955863,
-0.3533177078,
0.2172943056,
0.2840516865,
-0.3692701161,
-0.3605010509,
-0.1485369354,
-0.129810825,
-0.4472030103,
-0.582868278,
-0.001746373,
-0.4028919041,
-0.3459973633,
-0.1093890741,
0.1765231639,
-0.1719504148,
0.2008421421,
-0.139623329,
0.1300635934,
-0.3496829271,
0.3100321889,
0.2692630589,
0.3697635233,
-0.0818007886,
-0.2960321605,
0.40376845,
-0.0725073516,
-0.3314465582,
-0.0754066706,
0.7455845475,
0.3397870958,
-0.4599767923,
0.4474165738,
0.0930777714,
-0.3778403103,
-0.2328497618,
-0.5787584782,
-0.112220712,
-0.4800102115,
0.2474744171,
-0.2351739258,
-1.2286061049,
0.3718161881,
-0.1497244239,
0.4106342494,
0.1221654862,
0.5919875503,
-0.0882785171,
1.387190938,
0.467454195,
0.163754344,
0.4700587988,
0.1146529168,
0.3142504692,
-0.5281770825,
0.0057441243,
-0.3941415548,
-0.1973311752,
-0.5309941173,
-0.4579477608,
0.3902155757,
0.7080890536,
-0.2821576893,
0.0640379861,
-0.3288972378,
0.5103541613,
1.0636188984,
-0.0214221906,
0.2812356651,
0.0245732125,
0.0024667718,
0.5190807581,
-0.7970474958,
-0.8406133652,
1.3525840044,
0.1774482429,
0.5041739941,
0.1058230773,
0.8691413999,
0.1012624577,
-0.0187478606,
-0.6757580638,
0.7929459214,
0.3896721005,
-0.9207775593,
-0.6665847898,
-0.0583706684,
-0.9195362926,
0.162434116,
-0.2619034946,
-0.7764362097,
-0.1827545613,
0.3504232168,
-0.6526530385,
0.3456418514,
-0.5667713284,
0.6377522349,
-0.4411249459,
-0.2969576418,
-0.2155425102,
-0.6251682639,
0.4132510424,
0.0417487249,
-0.1293932796,
-0.0753018409,
0.2552776337,
0.7128138542,
-0.057261277,
0.6720554233,
0.078580305,
-0.2917423248,
1.056406498,
0.0605873987,
0.5304606557,
0.1793805957,
-0.1316922605,
-0.0380363986,
-0.0551717691,
-0.4406290948,
-0.4618169069,
0.217612043,
-0.4419398606,
-1.0146279335,
0.0323780328,
-0.5996568203,
-0.2507303357,
0.4504056871,
0.2001472265,
0.437564671,
-0.0920407623,
-0.1354871243,
0.6206141114,
-0.4877577126,
0.4256973267,
0.4316574633,
-0.5160752535,
-0.3037371635,
0.7506865263,
0.16936405,
0.675632298,
0.3187636733,
-0.0613007508,
-0.1880479157,
-0.5882065296,
-0.5797794461,
0.1432993561,
-0.5752285123,
-0.2634727359,
-0.3103795648,
-0.3819895089,
-0.3001257479,
-0.1836993545,
-0.1472290307,
-0.5666610003,
-0.2617611289,
-0.222840935,
0.1870251745,
0.7087717056,
0.3064225614,
0.4259954691,
-0.8865075707,
0.3417228758,
0.8918823004,
0.340720892,
-0.1533975154,
-0.2208171487,
-0.3245607615,
0.1473316848,
-0.6616901755,
-1.0897722244,
0.1052074581,
0.1531317234,
0.5641165972,
0.4387926161,
-0.2477625757,
0.5905327797,
-0.6313387156,
1.1856188774,
0.0122188646,
-0.8333191872,
0.6356621981,
-0.4332832694,
0.2586833239,
0.2308956087,
0.2543943822,
-0.5402938724,
-0.6660097837,
-0.7513188124,
-0.7971557379,
0.5786688328,
0.1427148134,
-0.1404949278,
-0.311176002,
0.5108274817,
0.2227116525,
0.5492882729,
-0.5665422678,
-0.0276520848,
-0.013684568,
-0.1311812848,
0.0195572507,
-0.3650069833,
-0.0851554349,
0.0318190902,
0.6341575384,
-0.2292945683,
0.3174063265,
-0.0546219721,
0.0158545095,
-0.3664099276,
0.569532752,
0.7355237007,
0.7289758325,
-0.3661928177,
-0.1004816517,
0.3928972185,
0.0168691296,
0.2788636386,
-0.1995741278,
-0.426758498,
-0.0219441894,
0.0662842244,
1.1622444391,
-0.0934133679,
-1.0341283083,
-0.016544072,
-0.0222207494,
-0.2560718954,
-0.0532697476,
0.340642482,
0.1230649799,
0.4679657519,
0.231971845,
-0.5448923707,
0.4040273428,
-0.5650050044,
-0.0713386089,
0.56522578,
0.2046932727,
-0.1585728824,
0.7639530897,
0.1694265306,
-0.4056269526,
0.5334724188,
-0.2502928078,
-0.2888794541,
0.7280732393,
0.837908566,
0.7832996845,
-0.4582419693,
0.4293812513,
0.4903133214,
0.1381026655,
-0.3908073604,
0.6652243137,
0.0062788455,
-0.5963144302,
-0.5035095811,
-0.5700431466,
-0.5800178647,
0.469175905,
-0.8977574706,
0.2080903053,
-0.1619510502,
-0.3449412882,
-0.4254550636,
-0.1473019719,
-0.4085095823,
0.5980520248,
0.3096587062,
0.7944898009,
-0.512069881,
0.5212366581,
1.0405516624,
0.0380070247,
-0.8786725402,
-0.0253962018,
-0.4232215285,
-0.736415565,
0.595382452,
0.0795899332,
0.0362146161,
0.301792562,
-0.642542243,
-1.2618319988,
1.1049741507,
0.3208881617,
-0.8736306429,
-0.4539908171,
0.3241611719,
0.3473751843,
-0.3852021992,
0.2506804764,
0.6037421227,
0.2261808366,
-0.4651112854,
-0.8593097329,
-0.0130686564,
-0.1980102211,
0.2564770579,
0.3763004541,
-1.0050977468,
0.8642625213,
-0.2087033391,
-0.2453382462,
0.2069990784,
0.5959226489,
0.5207597017,
0.1093529984,
0.459461391,
0.4960348904,
0.92008847,
0.0738817975,
0.9162896872,
-0.6540441513,
0.3899401426,
0.9294498563,
-0.2052170485,
0.8866000175,
0.4980044365,
-0.0682344511,
0.3013447523,
0.9597634673,
0.132151261,
0.5327749848,
0.2587447762,
-0.2575574219,
-0.5435135365,
0.1669924706,
-0.3700835109,
0.3991188407,
0.2638769746,
-0.1468566209,
-0.1196768731,
-0.1304442585,
-0.2353390604,
-0.4493433237,
-0.5711733103,
0.8153224587,
-0.1322260201,
-1.1520929337,
0.6892520785,
-0.0566547625,
0.123530373,
-0.4423433244,
-0.1727264673,
-0.1339238882,
-0.5277757049,
0.0742371604,
-0.7187138796,
-0.185343951,
-0.1122039706,
-0.1369317174,
0.0231090877,
0.7869688869,
-0.7453965545,
-0.5842574835,
-0.2028177083,
0.5626777411,
0.0828946084,
0.4468859732,
-0.7440651059,
-0.4115624726,
0.1288212985,
-0.6213700771,
0.2299911976,
0.1866981089,
-0.3920370638,
0.6315714121,
0.4744338095,
0.0481843986,
0.4896034598,
-0.1335975826,
0.5342171192,
-0.7157361507,
-0.4930031002,
-0.5980130434,
0.7905225158,
0.0060598222,
-0.3202458918,
0.5924578309,
0.4663734734,
0.9617447257,
-0.0599013716,
1.1735956669,
0.028355401,
0.5471461415,
-0.7868132591,
0.1992594451,
-0.6365983486,
0.0451227352,
0.0181115549,
-0.8021583557,
-0.0610221252,
0.4326051772,
-0.0685474798,
0.0825668946,
0.5727416277,
0.7096550465,
0.1459535211,
-0.0500014536,
0.3088418841,
-0.0985985696,
0.221467644,
0.6349005699,
1.035213232,
-0.3714465797,
0.3764963448,
-0.0051082354,
-0.0258193333,
-0.3663213551,
-0.769370079,
-1.089418292,
-0.5599434376,
-0.1672553867,
-0.2132519186,
0.2087559849,
0.8014056683,
0.5553500056,
-0.69643718,
-0.4860182703,
-0.113696143,
0.106470637,
-0.1399482042,
-0.1935077608,
0.2224023342,
-0.5411173701,
-0.8094353676,
0.291582495,
0.1662899107,
0.1689037383,
-0.1714604348,
-0.0071358159,
-0.1244348437,
0.5084634423,
0.6821869612,
0.2643944919,
-0.7289467454,
-0.4697003365,
0.0533781908,
0.1602264941,
0.0134070059,
0.7469488382,
-0.5522822142,
0.4949996471,
0.5240775347,
0.6692560911,
0.1351388246,
0.1416102499,
0.7849828005,
-0.6127624512,
-0.0504513904,
0.0792464837,
0.3036386669,
0.1356940418,
-0.4202649593,
0.3147107959,
-0.2564807534,
-0.8706376553,
-1.0724704266,
0.4826472104,
-0.6205383539,
-0.439057678,
1.241765976,
0.152942881,
-0.0583346076,
0.1478517801,
-0.5767507553,
0.4593722522,
-0.2820576429,
0.7814358473,
0.7641546726,
-0.3329691291,
-0.2061046362,
-0.8071630597,
0.6321463585,
0.6139795184,
-0.8085781932,
-0.2756801546,
0.4449107647,
0.2669645846,
0.0590373799,
0.6351620555,
0.2735517323,
0.4102665484,
-0.2754949629,
0.0534121469,
0.1553856283,
-0.2146221995,
-0.1301936805,
0.3606274128,
0.3893013597,
-0.0792602822
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12373v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12373v2 | WebCanvas: Benchmarking Web Agents in Online Environments | 2024-06-18T07:58:33 | 2024-06-27T16:56:13 | Yichen Pan, Dehan Kong, Sida Zhou, Cheng Cui, Yifei Leng, Bing Jiang, Hangyu Liu, Yanyi Shang, Shuyan Zhou, Tongshuang Wu, Zhengyang Wu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, 68T50, I.2.7 | For web agents to be practically useful, they must adapt to the continuously
evolving web environment characterized by frequent updates to user interfaces
and content. However, most existing benchmarks only capture the static aspects
of the web. To bridge this gap, we introduce WebCanvas, an innovative online
evaluation framework for web agents that effectively addresses the dynamic
nature of web interactions. WebCanvas contains three main components to
facilitate realistic assessments: (1) A novel evaluation metric which reliably
capture critical intermediate actions or states necessary for task completions
while disregarding noise caused by insignificant events or changed
web-elements. (2) A benchmark dataset called Mind2Web-Live, a refined version
of original Mind2Web static dataset containing 542 tasks with 2439 intermediate
evaluation states; (3) Lightweight and generalizable annotation tools and
testing pipelines that enables the community to collect and maintain the
high-quality, up-to-date dataset. Building on WebCanvas, we open-source an
agent framework with extensible modules for reasoning, providing a foundation
for the community to conduct online inference and evaluations. Our
best-performing agent achieves a task success rate of 23.1% and a task
completion rate of 48.8% on the Mind2Web-Live test set. Additionally, we
analyze the performance discrepancies across various websites, domains, and
experimental environments. We encourage the community to contribute further
insights on online agent evaluation, thereby advancing this field of research. | [
-0.7716379762,
-0.3323344886,
0.386875242,
0.324049443,
-0.2012484968,
0.2831048667,
-0.2099517733,
-0.8457427621,
0.1507867426,
0.0164288785,
-0.5946502686,
-0.3613560796,
-0.1984048039,
0.0634080246,
-0.2776207328,
0.7046630979,
-0.0034902943,
-0.0095364889,
-0.7219461203,
-0.2062927634,
-0.2217221409,
-0.0145313395,
-0.7630387545,
-0.3037118018,
0.4999345243,
0.0772888511,
0.5071175098,
0.2218556404,
0.7687460184,
0.3689652383,
0.3211244345,
0.40433833,
-0.6137858033,
0.3546478152,
-0.476408124,
-0.3933666646,
-0.6815261245,
0.0668453574,
0.1504926383,
0.3036719561,
-0.3167454004,
0.3705434501,
0.0952673107,
0.318263799,
-1.0618703365,
0.2946602106,
-0.4212400913,
-0.0484011769,
-0.0425652079,
-0.1986017823,
-0.0740813762,
-0.7779607177,
0.1841314137,
-0.928055644,
0.2947745025,
-0.1640320271,
0.732893765,
0.4072858989,
-0.2620406151,
0.01078727,
-0.614738524,
0.4503221214,
-0.1789868623,
0.4140892327,
0.4833969176,
0.916541636,
-0.2130756676,
-0.8518400192,
-0.554887712,
-0.1693964601,
0.3895118535,
0.3566015363,
-0.4030987322,
-0.1512554437,
0.1299162358,
0.0864377692,
-0.5461267233,
-0.1007581353,
-0.050375931,
-0.4099933803,
0.6300414801,
0.3572018743,
0.1249491796,
0.4351008534,
-0.3216161728,
-0.6420587301,
-0.2703742683,
0.3770481944,
0.3836810589,
0.083820425,
-0.0939559639,
0.1885382384,
-0.4597429931,
0.3702839315,
-0.0474540032,
0.0656142011,
0.3452898562,
-0.1670662761,
-0.0230244771,
-0.4456209838,
0.5637983084,
0.8909113407,
0.1895666718,
-0.421325773,
-0.3054945469,
0.4173056185,
0.7045416832,
-0.8064457774,
-0.1496382058,
0.5215510726,
-0.3535105884,
-0.2469017059,
0.1763212383,
-0.9527888298,
-0.7679088712,
0.0006094993,
0.417945534,
-0.2090110481,
-0.4271990359,
-0.0373886898,
-0.6396961808,
0.3646240532,
0.6918980479,
-0.1666378081,
0.8323565125,
0.7176901102,
0.7190743089,
-0.5300488472,
-0.3292152286,
-0.4515617788,
-0.184555307,
-0.379678905,
1.240855217,
-0.4051184356,
-0.1498811245,
0.191357404,
-0.0546771586,
0.2664236128,
-0.5147300363,
0.303201437,
-0.5828234553,
-0.2186029553,
-0.5189600587,
-0.5417746305,
-0.0920072868,
0.6152098775,
-0.7851499915,
0.9782915711,
0.1209540889,
-0.3992179632,
0.5759109855,
-0.6872683764,
-0.1067853197,
0.1700560749,
0.1496479511,
-0.1523200125,
-0.0988774821,
-0.1711494029,
0.3184146285,
-0.6851260066,
-0.3267557025,
-0.6119621992,
-0.5142650604,
0.5682230592,
-0.1832335144,
0.5926293731,
0.2513947487,
-0.4980278611,
0.1178039908,
-0.7659195662,
0.366219312,
0.1875100136,
-0.1538432091,
-0.3052215576,
0.1826290488,
0.3258045912,
0.193232134,
0.2412654608,
-0.845857203,
0.0144503573,
0.1008030772,
-0.033030808,
0.6589882374,
0.111180231,
-0.2790030837,
-0.5319773555,
0.7249330878,
-0.4988356829,
0.4897225797,
0.3035268486,
-0.4578559697,
-0.7193343639,
-0.3550786674,
0.1361689866,
0.4117409289,
-0.4552195668,
0.2292016745,
-0.4237353504,
-1.0126225948,
-0.4013869464,
-0.0186635032,
0.4832468331,
-0.1013378501,
0.4306939542,
-0.7565246224,
-0.2579948008,
-0.7293593287,
-0.2571416199,
-0.0940306857,
-0.1639712006,
0.0909855142,
0.3220144808,
-0.3228549957,
1.1457066536,
-0.4284764528,
-0.2844541669,
0.0188349318,
0.2033157349,
-0.328487277,
0.1860941052,
0.4811947346,
-0.6530344486,
-0.293340683,
-0.0020628376,
-0.6480539441,
-0.2356341332,
0.1103709415,
-0.1333866566,
-0.3452267051,
0.2599730492,
-0.5959541798,
0.442722261,
0.2328967005,
-0.2391241044,
0.391477406,
-0.1803129613,
0.3024807572,
-0.5705117583,
0.2388172299,
-0.0697939545,
-0.5653357506,
-0.3493662179,
0.3595451117,
0.1268392056,
0.020482678,
-0.6380572319,
0.7136156559,
-0.4936713576,
-0.4421197772,
-0.447532475,
0.395657748,
0.0761472359,
0.6147848964,
-0.4784561992,
0.5992716551,
0.2566766143,
-0.778267324,
0.7970812321,
-0.0150733842,
-0.4361029267,
0.7627974749,
-0.4668329358,
0.335973978,
0.1333423853,
0.5558590889,
-0.8082678318,
-0.0697090104,
0.0520903058,
-0.3038248122,
-0.3265886605,
0.3237304688,
-0.493476063,
-0.4138472676,
-0.607981205,
0.0841617286,
0.2648691833,
-0.1792002916,
0.5521883965,
0.5599752665,
0.2993519604,
-0.4380998313,
-0.3891912997,
0.0655429289,
0.0547311604,
-0.286844939,
0.3442220688,
-0.1431050003,
-0.5107728839,
0.1605561823,
-0.1980795711,
-0.4545605481,
0.4635179043,
0.3146503568,
-0.1448730528,
0.0886544138,
0.0221858211,
-0.0837734193,
-0.0640696809,
0.1234220788,
-0.1656409353,
0.395064801,
-0.3713846505,
-0.528427422,
-0.4799571633,
0.1026814729,
0.7055675387,
-0.3980019689,
0.2703310251,
0.7217239738,
-0.8150022626,
-0.1398094594,
-0.6849124432,
-0.0499982201,
-0.4462350309,
0.2237404287,
-0.6210569739,
-0.3559058607,
0.6305195093,
-0.2581229806,
0.4009510279,
0.4056639671,
0.5235478878,
-0.1924313903,
0.7671726346,
0.4738907814,
0.3422898352,
0.3663149178,
-0.179350391,
-0.3857757747,
-0.7012488246,
-0.2822459042,
-0.3420640826,
-0.3265959024,
-0.5418188572,
-0.6601235271,
0.2511676848,
-0.0242466405,
-0.0271213539,
0.475982666,
-0.300596714,
0.4387945831,
0.32125476,
0.3198240101,
0.0751447082,
-0.2153138816,
-0.295145452,
0.3657130003,
-0.1350488067,
-0.4354513288,
1.2381807566,
0.1132856607,
0.505009532,
0.5635333061,
0.1486536115,
1.0500990152,
0.3957774341,
-0.5118722916,
0.6434909105,
0.3765336871,
-0.6405689716,
-0.335213691,
0.0389177278,
-1.2568330765,
0.4567966759,
-0.2334089875,
-0.8402422071,
0.1896837056,
0.0923367366,
-0.3231134713,
-0.0366243124,
-0.4404532909,
0.8720144033,
-0.2102996111,
-0.7761999369,
-0.9651198983,
-0.406548351,
-0.148323074,
0.0078317085,
-0.0528656393,
-0.502411902,
-0.2612744272,
0.4710108638,
-0.574943006,
0.7665365338,
-0.3403269947,
0.3034986854,
0.4848303497,
0.1143729389,
0.5248970985,
-0.2308727801,
0.0255853105,
0.05530807,
0.1762234122,
-0.6280160546,
-0.7360982895,
0.5048633814,
-0.8539369106,
-0.2685291171,
-0.6087668538,
-0.0148812477,
-0.6669517159,
0.0512999184,
-0.1178733632,
0.4963639081,
-0.6697055697,
0.1216252148,
0.3702465892,
-0.050512135,
0.3967290521,
0.8133504391,
-0.2661395371,
-0.332585007,
0.947781384,
-0.2405903041,
0.1297030598,
0.4576961398,
0.0823848546,
-0.4564617574,
-0.3931542039,
-0.5136876106,
-0.108338505,
-0.8558400869,
-0.1585232317,
-0.6520918608,
0.2445764244,
-0.2804087996,
0.0767673105,
-0.6504768133,
-0.3344486356,
0.0719414204,
-0.0474583395,
0.2844541669,
0.7705445886,
-0.0758758485,
-0.0309189651,
-0.5183824301,
0.1773779839,
0.6480588317,
0.4926579595,
0.1688163728,
0.1211390272,
-0.309442997,
-0.2301280349,
-0.476744324,
-0.918305397,
-0.0294622611,
0.0498945825,
0.9199626446,
0.5665818453,
0.0050591091,
0.8478340507,
-0.1433518678,
0.5767800808,
-0.0195681881,
-0.903326273,
0.3638936281,
-0.3826586306,
0.3494448364,
0.8685408831,
0.3530239165,
-0.4904926717,
-0.3934382796,
-0.3544779718,
-0.5147461891,
0.382548362,
0.3560870588,
-0.3178046048,
0.0713252425,
0.1285772771,
0.2416342944,
0.2802474201,
-0.1769371927,
-0.1328624636,
-0.3929040134,
0.0882304907,
-0.0090793744,
0.2074221075,
-0.1580838561,
0.0695145503,
0.4533836544,
-0.3974965215,
0.5483261943,
0.1824560612,
-0.4654822946,
0.0076487265,
-0.0225619953,
0.591665566,
1.1203999519,
-0.5013500452,
0.0868608877,
0.367308557,
-0.5893238187,
0.2187069654,
0.3015502691,
0.206864357,
-0.334335655,
0.3796060085,
0.460391134,
0.0777544677,
-1.0954372883,
0.6637590528,
-0.5834515095,
0.3233213723,
-0.4969178736,
0.2432150692,
-0.1096089855,
0.3294472992,
0.5725918412,
0.1001401395,
0.4361409843,
-0.4822794199,
0.2395008206,
0.2416858524,
-0.6886744499,
-0.41523543,
0.5672100186,
0.5896596313,
-0.4037628174,
0.2525534928,
-0.4665308297,
-0.3734158874,
0.9074921012,
0.1782347709,
1.2178999186,
-0.1393661201,
0.204960078,
0.1131733283,
0.2858212888,
0.0602986589,
0.3423058689,
-0.3988925517,
-0.6331463456,
0.0807412416,
-0.6718785167,
-1.0103384256,
-0.1384951621,
-0.717805028,
0.1288465708,
-0.476957798,
-0.4798138142,
-0.1884036809,
0.2516864538,
-1.0707538128,
0.4897760451,
0.080245845,
0.8398888707,
-0.519751668,
0.6150758862,
0.8205860257,
-0.2788654566,
-0.1265015751,
0.0974429101,
0.3489687145,
-0.4311238229,
0.0052274843,
0.3681875467,
-0.5498361588,
-0.2473781854,
0.0780765936,
-0.8904242516,
1.18161726,
0.2684391439,
-0.3291714191,
0.4748193026,
0.0177113321,
0.9518797398,
-0.2072360516,
1.0260415077,
0.274217248,
0.5432631969,
-0.3749361038,
-0.9047281742,
0.2822732627,
-0.6322920918,
-0.050395254,
-0.0760852695,
-1.0481271744,
0.4369212985,
0.172056213,
-0.2756686211,
-0.1136530787,
0.6006385088,
-0.0176453181,
0.3950769305,
0.8536669016,
0.3352921903,
0.9316382408,
-0.0093183843,
1.1210731268,
-0.1858489215,
0.2868967652,
0.9874600172,
-0.5215200186,
0.8740923405,
-0.0613907389,
-0.3959483802,
0.5917049646,
0.89326334,
0.1374026686,
0.4674370885,
0.3413788676,
-0.1758393645,
-0.4592611194,
-0.381429553,
-0.2312439829,
0.7299521565,
0.1813803166,
0.3934620321,
-0.2748523355,
-0.0026326445,
-0.2449548393,
0.0441130549,
-0.0532290079,
0.5151357055,
-0.2446801364,
-0.9081591368,
0.2390210629,
0.1225767881,
0.2812342346,
-0.7275623083,
-0.0327913761,
-0.2161250114,
0.3538305163,
0.0296684708,
-0.5361675024,
0.1832354218,
0.1705343425,
0.1172245815,
-0.1600460857,
0.6403448582,
0.2053643018,
-0.1585990936,
0.6859442592,
0.5559247136,
0.5134063959,
-0.2315963358,
-0.7490656972,
0.153509289,
-0.3545603454,
-0.2287179977,
0.3224317431,
0.1013710797,
-0.3450188339,
0.9380331039,
0.7531595826,
-0.0824960694,
-0.0166480616,
0.1281821728,
0.7433431149,
-0.6657347083,
-0.4884564877,
-0.4652096331,
0.2582406998,
-0.4573270977,
-0.6432657242,
0.4954420626,
0.8440511823,
0.6684899926,
0.2419466227,
0.7957646251,
-0.0787038207,
0.5138446689,
0.0570573434,
0.7271885872,
-0.6041696668,
-0.2656834722,
-0.2329171151,
-1.0646914244,
0.1723851264,
0.3593491316,
0.26277861,
-0.1506868154,
0.8111409545,
0.5259215832,
0.099875778,
0.0295939501,
0.3720929623,
-0.0322187394,
0.4391804934,
0.4022894502,
0.9024351239,
-0.3609767258,
0.7054431438,
-0.2644346654,
-0.4123156965,
-0.2724469006,
-0.7423290014,
-0.9353305697,
-0.4459451735,
-0.4023114741,
-0.2877506912,
0.3978711665,
1.1132611036,
0.6639493108,
-0.7660143375,
-0.3681382835,
-0.0912528038,
-0.0075942595,
-0.9216006994,
-0.2019094676,
0.033150252,
-0.0540162437,
-0.750635922,
0.3827191591,
0.3283621371,
-0.129892081,
-0.5728346705,
0.0703828111,
-0.0911672637,
0.2853576839,
0.3377109766,
0.32658571,
-0.7173557878,
-0.2785980403,
-0.0733828545,
-0.4529924989,
-0.1358884573,
0.680065155,
-0.8832165003,
0.6849249601,
0.4996818304,
0.8328568339,
0.8745121956,
0.1030314639,
0.5135515332,
-0.1920776665,
-0.0661126152,
0.2252214849,
0.1678673625,
0.3349461555,
-0.0291065425,
0.6685031056,
0.2905094028,
-0.2194955498,
-0.6670365334,
-0.1458902359,
-1.0177249908,
-0.2603465617,
0.8167832494,
-0.4612261355,
-0.0489020422,
-0.3800480962,
0.3549241722,
0.3680680692,
-0.3362576067,
0.8069706559,
0.6529844403,
-0.1754072607,
0.2809383273,
-0.5519320369,
0.331936717,
0.2260640562,
-1.2371375561,
-0.1753830314,
0.4416845143,
0.2810646296,
0.1056483015,
0.6277592778,
0.4312410653,
0.6676197648,
0.3885624111,
0.525138557,
-0.000573213,
-0.2980599403,
0.117963776,
0.3313633204,
-0.1458531022,
-0.4370394945
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12369v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12369v1 | A Comparative Study of Continuous Sign Language Recognition Techniques | 2024-06-18T07:51:44 | 2024-06-18T07:51:44 | Sarah Alyami, Hamzah Luqman | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | Continuous Sign Language Recognition (CSLR) focuses on the interpretation of
a sequence of sign language gestures performed continually without pauses. In
this study, we conduct an empirical evaluation of recent deep learning CSLR
techniques and assess their performance across various datasets and sign
languages. The models selected for analysis implement a range of approaches for
extracting meaningful features and employ distinct training strategies. To
determine their efficacy in modeling different sign languages, these models
were evaluated using multiple datasets, specifically RWTH-PHOENIX-Weather-2014,
ArabSign, and GrSL, each representing a unique sign language. The performance
of the models was further tested with unseen signers and sentences. The
conducted experiments establish new benchmarks on the selected datasets and
provide valuable insights into the robustness and generalization of the
evaluated techniques under challenging scenarios. | [
0.1341762394,
-0.1052135825,
0.2478117496,
0.0744045153,
-0.3615996838,
0.6303107738,
-0.3461042047,
-0.8462737203,
-0.3046108484,
0.1830880642,
-0.3729503453,
-0.5836586952,
-0.729847014,
0.1593674719,
-0.4349900484,
0.5153599977,
-0.0606036671,
0.7300277948,
0.1842867434,
-0.305002749,
-0.2536599636,
-0.2639940381,
-0.9007979631,
-0.4260727465,
0.117896907,
0.2301115394,
0.6563252807,
0.1047153994,
0.715534389,
0.1992367506,
-0.314602375,
0.0579939336,
-0.2655850649,
-0.0218942333,
0.4010782242,
0.3043504655,
0.2325483561,
-0.0412611254,
0.8410486579,
0.9499499798,
0.0991098732,
0.225585416,
0.1183077171,
0.4601353109,
-0.5727581978,
-0.1729008406,
-0.3096186519,
0.5728231668,
-0.2037829906,
0.4559185505,
-0.5164954662,
-0.5294520259,
0.3251202106,
-0.3029943705,
0.221894294,
-0.1809098274,
0.8062289953,
0.0379674509,
-0.2234860063,
-0.7655563354,
-0.8007552028,
0.9264027476,
-1.0224639177,
1.0057268143,
-0.0495114587,
0.5151664019,
0.1192892045,
-0.7239325047,
-0.468449682,
-0.8241704106,
-0.1718268245,
0.0775979906,
0.194679603,
0.012450818,
0.3278913498,
0.4584594071,
-0.8674556613,
0.5349392295,
-0.604303062,
-0.3245313466,
0.6722750068,
0.3295827806,
0.3017244637,
0.2396010458,
-0.4232072234,
-0.3477180004,
-0.4126763046,
0.5857977867,
0.0399083532,
0.6218811274,
-0.5724927187,
0.3234337866,
-0.2275729626,
0.9151650667,
-0.0879252777,
-0.3298359513,
0.2652918398,
-0.105065167,
-0.3366994262,
-0.3350186646,
0.8331676126,
-0.0666570738,
0.4827343225,
-0.2996559143,
-0.0576355867,
0.0704641864,
-0.3996601701,
-0.5726496577,
-0.1518036425,
-0.0006178541,
-0.6764689684,
-0.1729727834,
0.1450056434,
-0.2443800718,
-0.8473821282,
-0.6634867191,
-0.2858483791,
-0.2950176299,
-0.577046752,
0.2333703786,
-0.2726180553,
0.5592842102,
0.2378006428,
-0.4156193137,
0.519259572,
0.6285694242,
0.8085173965,
-0.6444365382,
0.1584684849,
-0.3793632984,
-0.5321696401,
-0.2806117833,
0.3570440114,
-0.841548264,
-0.4139152169,
-0.0170533974,
-0.1463533044,
-0.1399087608,
-0.2805548608,
0.5044900179,
-0.6206130385,
-0.1848545671,
-0.2706682086,
-0.4986429214,
-0.0110857431,
-0.0653483793,
-0.7985254526,
0.8889659047,
-0.2281762958,
-0.1581116319,
0.8835219741,
-0.4286828339,
-0.6030429602,
0.3720184863,
-0.3007214069,
-0.7862145901,
0.1580716223,
-0.0898772031,
0.6457974911,
0.0520431846,
-0.2764672339,
-0.2138988674,
-0.515265584,
0.6032692194,
-0.4821052253,
0.8126580715,
0.5772647858,
-0.4121968448,
-0.240347892,
-1.0171638727,
0.2727891803,
-0.1588727981,
-0.4150216579,
0.0315217637,
0.0924647078,
0.1693385541,
0.4174961448,
-0.0698370859,
-0.700959146,
-0.2504378259,
-0.1949110627,
0.2888035178,
0.3283549845,
-0.1838766634,
0.2007939368,
0.4728875458,
0.6010339856,
-0.0469724499,
0.3235349655,
0.1257709414,
-0.1962423921,
-0.8186345696,
-0.285356611,
0.178141579,
0.422837019,
-0.0749396309,
-0.1146642566,
-0.1309849024,
-0.5805290937,
-0.3184033334,
0.1192111,
1.0583071709,
0.1612924486,
0.2731517553,
-0.6315888166,
-0.5948415399,
-0.2980237007,
-0.2091285586,
0.0690500587,
0.2943162024,
0.0776045099,
0.2639344931,
0.4076028764,
0.3598345518,
-0.039053306,
0.0337164998,
-0.2511871457,
0.088112548,
0.3448014557,
0.3150130212,
0.3246591687,
-0.7126803398,
-0.8398108482,
0.4725805521,
-0.7861344218,
0.450913161,
-0.5143661499,
0.6410970688,
0.2190379947,
0.631783545,
-0.1526937783,
0.7555411458,
0.6936410069,
-0.4319141805,
0.6115434766,
0.160640195,
0.2700603604,
-0.1246296093,
0.0996887684,
-0.0506572835,
-0.1232894063,
-0.9539088607,
0.0947593749,
0.2123330832,
-0.457082808,
-0.8584262133,
0.379971534,
-1.1895686388,
-0.5858408809,
-0.2301910073,
0.0098645771,
-0.2930315435,
0.2113331109,
0.4362780154,
0.6561222076,
0.6506293416,
-0.8462163806,
-0.0704097003,
0.0326067917,
-0.6543794274,
0.1448960751,
-0.6204914451,
0.4680210054,
0.0010488208,
-0.0758020878,
-1.3559268713,
0.1959255338,
0.3374687731,
-0.5990831852,
0.3525235951,
0.0481622517,
-0.1145794243,
-0.6701586246,
-0.0161090977,
0.1307582259,
0.7100647688,
-0.3882615566,
0.5854563117,
-0.0962465182,
0.3677822053,
-0.7774690986,
-0.8630239367,
0.0462331437,
-0.1921250373,
-0.1577124149,
-0.2079247087,
0.0633306205,
-0.3016863465,
-0.5168212652,
-0.116267398,
-0.1104618683,
0.2895192206,
0.4244904816,
-0.1311333328,
-0.198605448,
-0.1482739598,
-0.1926850677,
-0.1113438755,
-0.3216764331,
0.1062813476,
0.3873665631,
-0.2354210615,
-0.6325136423,
-0.979003191,
0.0115872007,
0.5605932474,
-0.270499438,
0.5319679976,
0.4426410198,
-0.1587981284,
0.1222580448,
-0.4783639014,
0.114959158,
-0.4311736822,
0.021489609,
-0.5249037743,
-0.9627361298,
0.5308299065,
-0.1258482933,
0.398988843,
-0.0635558665,
0.3128268719,
-0.1993443817,
0.8102223277,
0.5337747931,
-0.1032431498,
0.5326990485,
0.0572942868,
0.2663067281,
-0.5452906489,
-0.2383771986,
-0.5107267499,
-0.206074357,
-0.0951940343,
-0.2160358578,
0.0177383497,
0.1405844688,
-0.1893842518,
0.7247266173,
-0.5996828675,
0.3605307639,
-0.1048466936,
0.2058526129,
0.4217459857,
-0.0332533792,
-0.2028558552,
-0.1481927186,
-0.2809098363,
-0.6419118643,
1.0189348459,
0.3036875427,
0.3308030963,
0.0468335003,
0.3582826257,
0.4078928828,
0.3482296169,
-0.5460657477,
0.5240975022,
-0.2646057904,
-0.2184479535,
-0.4238464236,
0.01464359,
-1.0443924665,
0.4925575554,
-0.3563065827,
-0.4082592428,
0.3401777148,
0.193865031,
-0.4212180078,
0.1734518707,
-0.6424002647,
0.5444570184,
-0.5364387631,
0.0984635055,
-0.2499599606,
-0.6972740889,
0.2133693844,
0.0071747042,
0.3308045864,
-0.1455512345,
0.1747959405,
0.4251896143,
-0.1466809064,
1.1146509647,
-0.3048679233,
-0.1986327916,
0.2448300123,
-0.0197986457,
0.4745011032,
-0.2077739537,
-0.4504908025,
0.2948893011,
-0.1714750379,
-0.2658481896,
-0.2762521505,
0.427786231,
-0.5976178646,
0.1561507732,
-0.5044152141,
0.0036820741,
-0.0946899801,
0.1118742824,
0.0671533197,
0.3974606693,
-0.6152404547,
-0.0690484121,
0.4595628083,
-0.098879613,
0.8689162135,
0.802618742,
0.0534827076,
-0.3181593716,
0.5014967918,
-0.0485595167,
0.5472254157,
0.2388867587,
0.153060481,
-0.194451198,
-1.0621522665,
-0.2780126035,
-0.0058369059,
-0.8210197091,
0.0890649706,
-0.2017159611,
-0.0572632514,
-0.5905282497,
-0.1605068892,
-0.0944591984,
-0.441014111,
-0.1657075286,
-0.2456656694,
0.3222189546,
0.4585489035,
-0.1638933867,
0.2571737468,
-0.4465561807,
0.1596685499,
0.0485928766,
0.0255559161,
0.2740091681,
-0.3280864954,
-0.194762066,
-0.0267594419,
0.0387815386,
-0.5092284083,
-0.0491639897,
0.5357431173,
0.4535018802,
0.6821013093,
-0.1222771406,
0.8640088439,
-0.3654333055,
0.9131376147,
0.7216922641,
-0.8867976069,
0.2096054405,
-0.0302093085,
0.4178265631,
0.7278345227,
0.3166847527,
-0.7381072044,
-0.2706792951,
-0.2738966048,
-0.5989003181,
0.023607811,
0.3427631557,
-0.0010329003,
0.1196978465,
0.3755857348,
0.3365117311,
-0.050385002,
-0.8694509268,
-0.0665513575,
-0.0335906968,
-0.1803891957,
0.1934566945,
0.211146906,
0.2895882726,
-0.3466501534,
0.2182951719,
0.0241255593,
-0.0962266475,
-0.0606435388,
-0.3974211216,
0.1179522946,
0.1396976262,
0.850571692,
0.8203031421,
0.3746659458,
-0.2263215333,
0.632401824,
-0.7662181258,
-0.029272642,
-0.3062535524,
-0.1775272042,
0.2797389925,
0.6531282663,
0.9312286377,
0.1669678092,
-0.9063380957,
0.3655753732,
-0.0881481841,
-0.1185280457,
-0.8485058546,
0.0126838172,
-0.2851881087,
0.1864044964,
0.2676147521,
0.0708574951,
0.1814429015,
-0.2575770915,
0.1405141652,
0.6163649559,
-0.7738265395,
-0.2547843456,
0.3204407096,
0.070264481,
-0.3403812051,
0.7124657035,
0.1187661067,
-0.2579781115,
0.6607575417,
0.1413345039,
0.7749233246,
-0.2510235906,
0.2871814072,
0.6204327345,
0.1493788511,
0.0959515944,
0.4096417427,
-0.5994064808,
-0.6649216413,
-0.592419982,
-0.3976277411,
-0.6168743372,
0.0231449306,
-0.7608302832,
0.3627818227,
-0.782065928,
-0.0424613133,
-0.0425351597,
-0.033479616,
-0.9014906287,
0.6382242441,
0.5858914852,
0.7367119789,
-1.0810658932,
0.574984014,
0.3389661312,
-0.2754691541,
-0.6750969291,
-0.194189474,
0.1307348162,
-0.8880515695,
0.9061086178,
0.0909059942,
-0.5043991208,
-0.2007674277,
-0.5269366503,
-0.9712696671,
0.9092954397,
-0.1661420316,
-0.9943112731,
0.3299743831,
0.6518706679,
0.7517395616,
-0.1524573117,
0.1756976843,
0.7872623205,
0.4225185215,
0.0753375217,
-0.9406413436,
0.1162010133,
0.0425041504,
0.0545772165,
0.0763759613,
-0.4825255871,
0.3019340634,
-0.2347884029,
-0.6933068037,
0.5618991852,
0.9984689951,
0.5799130797,
0.4251365364,
0.4683469832,
0.3585995138,
0.885342896,
-0.1367524862,
0.6612747908,
-0.1411720663,
0.2918139398,
0.8465211987,
-0.5690079331,
0.8726648092,
0.3644637764,
-0.3527006209,
0.5555631518,
0.4671284556,
-0.1700212359,
0.5978693962,
0.5715764761,
-0.3178323507,
-0.3678729534,
0.2509127557,
-0.2395938486,
0.1940512508,
0.426926136,
-0.4307108223,
-0.1641948521,
0.5842849016,
0.1054754704,
0.3298009038,
-0.3033884168,
0.6765008569,
0.3818956017,
-0.3554825783,
0.6054720283,
-0.379948169,
0.6712853312,
-0.5247365832,
-0.0236149859,
-0.0694583952,
0.3336080015,
-0.3330365419,
-0.6291826367,
0.2445492297,
0.0799931511,
0.2699711919,
-0.4214943945,
0.838814199,
0.1446139663,
-0.4896673858,
0.2049440593,
-0.0611365661,
0.5774575472,
0.5375156403,
-0.9767095447,
0.4922187328,
-0.1722657382,
0.0688981712,
0.039085146,
0.1254540533,
-0.0659806952,
0.6160672903,
0.796032846,
0.0090184091,
0.1804940552,
0.3950986564,
0.573679626,
-0.6947631836,
-0.2684934437,
-0.5853223205,
0.7650710344,
-0.3610139489,
-0.8587605953,
0.9195249677,
0.5356733203,
0.6844647527,
-0.3081428111,
0.743886292,
-0.0248972438,
0.6832031012,
-0.6892871857,
0.5372094512,
0.0410455167,
0.0290439967,
-0.4259421229,
-0.3414721489,
-0.6325255632,
0.6186963916,
-0.2486179918,
0.0210014563,
0.5902973413,
0.5047384501,
0.0585331656,
0.0386519618,
0.3543815613,
-0.4446500242,
0.2205584943,
0.5973566175,
0.9259819984,
-0.6552506089,
0.4495254755,
0.1021284908,
0.1111949757,
0.0871610194,
-0.8916322589,
-1.1007403135,
-0.4740031362,
-0.7263744473,
-0.3116781712,
0.1965791583,
0.5229658484,
0.8694276214,
-1.0663542747,
-0.4233514667,
-0.2837897837,
-0.3508713543,
-0.8420261145,
-0.1747372448,
0.4471946359,
-0.2055001706,
-0.3781155348,
0.8552995324,
-0.201966539,
0.2409995496,
-0.1235861406,
-0.5148090124,
0.2402251959,
-0.2137514204,
0.5623236299,
0.9387270212,
-0.7705227137,
-0.2717110813,
0.0322511159,
0.0021136436,
-0.102014415,
0.9416680336,
-0.7212827802,
0.1368323267,
0.4846005738,
0.4362205863,
0.6004515886,
-0.0953270644,
0.2812313437,
-0.5538594127,
0.1516634673,
0.2739177346,
0.0473063886,
0.4962039888,
-0.2915465832,
0.54448241,
-0.0515299216,
-0.1068375334,
-0.7757979631,
0.4612289667,
-1.1220754385,
-0.3440725505,
1.071095109,
-0.2549574673,
0.2712367773,
-0.4901298881,
0.151334241,
0.0286027174,
-0.0885487348,
0.2564851046,
0.3915885389,
-0.3701346815,
-0.5389356613,
-0.2856136262,
0.5935608149,
0.2350526899,
-0.2103606164,
-0.1257958114,
0.4471789598,
0.4447467327,
0.0783435479,
0.6002572775,
-0.2990824282,
0.4513274729,
-0.3048619926,
0.158888787,
-0.1102754399,
-0.0427298918,
-0.6627807021,
0.2015587837,
0.1475044638,
-0.2018526495
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12364v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12364v1 | Does Context Help Mitigate Gender Bias in Neural Machine Translation? | 2024-06-18T07:44:13 | 2024-06-18T07:44:13 | Harritxu Gete, Thierry Etchegoyhen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Neural Machine Translation models tend to perpetuate gender bias present in
their training data distribution. Context-aware models have been previously
suggested as a means to mitigate this type of bias. In this work, we examine
this claim by analysing in detail the translation of stereotypical professions
in English to German, and translation with non-informative context in Basque to
Spanish. Our results show that, although context-aware models can significantly
enhance translation accuracy for feminine terms, they can still maintain or
even amplify gender bias. These results highlight the need for more
fine-grained approaches to bias mitigation in Neural Machine Translation. | [
-0.2228941917,
-0.6393787861,
0.4147194326,
0.2954609692,
0.025017174,
-0.5182133317,
-0.133082822,
-0.4107426703,
-0.2809426785,
0.5277418494,
-0.7711498141,
-0.3804627061,
-0.7628711462,
0.3417335749,
-0.5830899477,
0.8927582502,
0.0585558563,
0.7006005645,
-0.1815225631,
-0.1707490832,
-1.0340138674,
-0.719905436,
-0.5438505411,
-0.6587651372,
0.2547304332,
0.0239170305,
0.6319867373,
0.5590503216,
0.2851466537,
0.2274123728,
-0.3607924581,
0.1587944031,
-0.2068841159,
0.2767392695,
-0.191795662,
-0.7021270394,
-0.4989663363,
-0.003144867,
0.6762343049,
0.9998595715,
0.1512848884,
0.0411593318,
0.0627233237,
0.7205492854,
-0.4389281869,
-0.1186827794,
-0.6549060345,
0.4422866106,
-0.0373540521,
-0.313811034,
-0.5245966315,
-0.0516415909,
0.3795134127,
-0.3209362328,
0.4954806268,
0.0536981858,
0.4570016861,
0.4404429197,
-0.968726635,
-0.1125254333,
-0.8373102546,
0.8345447779,
-0.6279659867,
0.3371504545,
0.3828785717,
0.4577802122,
-0.1939775646,
-0.2164453566,
-0.1401503533,
0.133820802,
-0.2890315056,
-0.0497673452,
-0.3891904354,
-0.0869948268,
0.3582624495,
-0.1518122554,
-0.1350331008,
0.0443809405,
-0.4282250702,
-0.1718448699,
0.3709053099,
0.1101813316,
0.655616045,
-0.2718584538,
-0.2817422152,
0.0463916324,
-0.8979972601,
-0.101577796,
0.5417914987,
0.3740011156,
-0.0232853647,
0.4667747915,
-0.068855755,
0.6330506802,
0.0375116058,
0.0361872576,
0.1547071785,
-0.2443311512,
-0.2061545104,
0.366535753,
0.3878517449,
0.5491093397,
0.3456251621,
-0.377728194,
-0.2082384527,
-0.1609176993,
0.5080459714,
-0.6381399632,
0.2001914382,
-0.0325505063,
-0.5071257949,
-0.4095745385,
-0.1672292799,
-0.4962254763,
-0.258095026,
-0.3699673116,
0.1597980857,
-0.1965319812,
-0.0620800368,
0.0641687065,
-0.4568415284,
0.0557981469,
0.3520585895,
-1.0216525793,
0.0608663224,
0.5495486259,
0.6812571287,
0.2513722181,
-0.188445136,
-0.214563936,
0.2404908389,
-0.6019138098,
0.303166002,
-0.3248669505,
-0.3648036122,
-0.128916353,
0.1233802512,
-0.2289989144,
-0.4739088714,
0.4033474028,
-0.3523221314,
0.3237430155,
-0.5248052478,
-0.1088485792,
-0.1996874362,
0.1321023256,
-0.5082775354,
0.7463456988,
0.0166430175,
-1.0250086784,
0.4959461689,
-0.5910565257,
-0.6103348136,
-0.5289629698,
-0.2135574967,
-0.1723123789,
0.3175072968,
0.4595549405,
0.2838896811,
-0.2119567692,
0.5228102803,
0.0471086092,
-0.328717947,
0.5229327083,
-0.5882442594,
0.6960434914,
0.0202689096,
-0.7060958147,
0.2470839173,
0.038669575,
-0.347964108,
-0.1040606424,
-0.0241148081,
-0.6488183141,
-0.0333924778,
0.1729214936,
0.6950380802,
-0.0858496949,
-0.2268051803,
-0.0289541427,
-0.3944014907,
0.7186591029,
0.6633780599,
-0.4124416113,
1.1080867052,
-0.100894995,
0.5142830014,
0.2665220797,
-0.0674286187,
0.1229761317,
-0.5502875447,
-0.5468989015,
-0.242579028,
0.4465394318,
0.6339372993,
-0.7687146068,
0.4216177166,
-0.2482884228,
-0.1882081777,
-0.5828924179,
0.0575854033,
0.7001859546,
1.0227794647,
0.462957412,
-0.0683114529,
-0.598193109,
-1.357260704,
-0.5785572529,
0.4015002549,
-0.2260086983,
0.4458796382,
0.6270818114,
-0.4834650755,
0.9804779291,
-0.1812453121,
-0.3538138568,
-0.1396598071,
0.0524944514,
0.0001773934,
0.7382285595,
0.8906123042,
-0.9347890615,
0.0991239622,
-0.1684084982,
-0.8731589317,
-0.2590941191,
-0.048241891,
-0.6020871997,
0.1622605026,
0.5230884552,
-0.4330046773,
0.3207256496,
0.5413010716,
-0.6333608627,
0.182356298,
-0.2285437435,
0.0744846314,
-1.1214259863,
0.3620229363,
0.0006722595,
-0.5909790993,
-0.7901649475,
-0.0675983503,
0.156747371,
0.2029619813,
-0.5583078265,
0.7747331262,
-0.334934324,
-0.2637546659,
-0.2931085229,
0.0242033135,
-0.0454775356,
-0.0697790757,
0.2614367604,
0.9234621525,
0.2595861256,
-0.7857102752,
-0.4955295026,
0.4765994251,
0.0126932254,
0.7031625509,
-0.5137972236,
0.0232683625,
-0.4146939516,
0.5485113859,
-0.6827812195,
-0.2067724913,
0.1849971116,
-0.4376291931,
0.1964599043,
-0.2576695681,
-0.256634742,
-0.1320800781,
0.0200003702,
0.2888756394,
0.3428043425,
-0.4622724354,
0.2499678284,
0.2640093267,
0.1026205197,
-0.9722182155,
-1.3227533102,
0.0800383911,
-0.3555216789,
-0.5479393005,
0.598207891,
0.1258833259,
-0.2385786325,
-0.2622697949,
-0.2924582064,
-0.092154935,
0.4023571312,
0.0823568031,
0.2434370071,
-0.0396651141,
0.1647936106,
0.3834333718,
-0.0223125666,
0.105055511,
-0.3452220559,
0.5985395312,
0.0043847742,
-0.0790297762,
-0.1443163753,
0.4572870135,
0.5682971478,
0.0323195606,
0.9620748758,
0.6839231849,
-0.5594761968,
-0.1623966843,
-0.2690164447,
-0.6503750086,
-0.4269129932,
0.4011829495,
-0.4418297708,
-0.9226257801,
0.6268841028,
0.0046968153,
-0.1965366453,
0.5706679225,
0.3992346823,
-0.3222652078,
1.4298142195,
0.6168834567,
-0.0316741504,
0.513476789,
-0.056992203,
0.1381187737,
-1.1461766958,
-0.0052159373,
-0.6411287785,
-0.703694284,
-0.710547924,
-0.2417866141,
0.2750479281,
0.1814024597,
-0.2899692655,
0.315810442,
-0.6213781238,
0.2111186683,
0.6182274222,
0.0994359404,
0.1245780736,
0.0258588456,
0.0562070571,
-0.3936241567,
-0.8760637641,
-0.7352656126,
1.079241991,
0.5211903453,
0.1493516117,
0.202141121,
0.3198171854,
0.3137224019,
0.3158750832,
-0.2773037255,
0.3179986179,
-0.4747604728,
-1.094014287,
-0.0647366792,
-0.5853602886,
-0.8245450258,
0.2600421607,
-0.1969074607,
-0.6694030166,
0.5130127668,
0.2844039202,
0.2021654248,
0.2435756475,
-0.5602419376,
0.9547854066,
-0.2062225342,
-0.2303585261,
0.0996384621,
-0.6548995376,
0.4927893281,
-0.0804215819,
0.3202112913,
0.0010849095,
-0.079065375,
0.5766251683,
-0.1857002079,
1.0331002474,
-0.2257149965,
-0.1335770935,
-0.2301034182,
0.2015659213,
0.2201095521,
0.0068785893,
-0.1309388578,
0.4579113424,
-0.1719855517,
-0.4513319433,
-0.2921342254,
0.426009953,
-0.7744373083,
-0.5159044266,
-0.1200253144,
-1.0595654249,
-0.0410381816,
0.2852329612,
0.5741595626,
0.1472664475,
-0.1768869758,
0.1130526587,
0.6613237858,
-0.2143757492,
0.2423010617,
0.309938699,
-0.0981744453,
-0.1048937291,
0.1785638928,
0.1515773088,
0.1960266978,
0.1846295595,
0.128109321,
-0.2431544662,
-0.1355959475,
-0.8065089583,
-0.084985055,
-0.9634572268,
-0.0365261547,
-0.9063199162,
0.0866607353,
-0.5246472359,
-0.3680127561,
-0.2915957868,
-0.5877581835,
-0.1009012759,
-0.0199239552,
0.2734348476,
0.4465685189,
0.4049481153,
0.7001764774,
-0.4637486935,
0.1267164201,
0.1005856693,
-0.1723894924,
-0.2406056821,
-0.6505007148,
0.1784964949,
0.2232446671,
-0.0359470993,
-1.0734797716,
0.8166153431,
-0.0624852069,
0.524710834,
0.2084666342,
-0.2298142165,
0.3204794526,
-0.6284983158,
0.654502213,
0.0718609616,
-1.1746073961,
0.6662073731,
-0.710226953,
0.4672619998,
0.4147608876,
0.2792444825,
-0.7570133209,
-0.2808480561,
-0.3116265535,
-0.8909426928,
0.7803373337,
0.2437471002,
0.6111125946,
-0.0640402958,
0.4893124998,
0.1254051775,
0.7407670617,
-0.7330802083,
-0.3178433478,
-0.1344736367,
-0.1420122087,
-0.0770636275,
-0.1568491459,
-0.4241513014,
-0.3770181537,
0.5790364742,
-0.1531219631,
0.6042613983,
0.2829072475,
-0.3274410665,
0.0778735951,
0.4598447382,
0.9105747342,
0.4815769196,
-0.1817364991,
0.1569862962,
0.4151179492,
-0.3416998088,
0.1712905765,
-0.1575895697,
-0.8651225567,
0.2748045623,
0.31529513,
0.832054615,
0.4030309319,
-0.3618798554,
0.4090819061,
0.012142567,
-0.2539043725,
-0.145893544,
-0.0171163138,
0.2806143165,
0.3023805618,
0.2959726453,
0.5792834163,
0.3291810155,
-0.455321312,
-0.1207926795,
0.4298761785,
-0.5038742423,
-0.098170951,
0.9446485639,
0.2501364946,
-0.2248546332,
0.5521851778,
0.180003494,
-0.8461896181,
0.9771926999,
0.9610518813,
1.0240545273,
-0.3392580748,
-0.0222687218,
0.3475901484,
0.573261261,
-0.3872115016,
0.0919599235,
-0.0125202062,
-0.7655590773,
-0.0758846924,
-0.2578273416,
-0.1692575812,
-0.3521513641,
-0.5545967817,
0.2732700109,
-0.057386186,
-0.525108099,
-0.1967698187,
-0.698990941,
-0.8617898226,
0.2828102708,
0.0543188564,
0.8346302509,
-1.0563004017,
0.9235116243,
0.823679328,
-0.2935634851,
-0.4033709466,
-0.0206185449,
-0.0032637219,
-0.2167773545,
1.1576256752,
0.3995758295,
-0.3021969497,
-0.1193891689,
-0.1961593926,
-0.7151611447,
1.1107742786,
0.6987996101,
-0.4887189567,
-0.1653399765,
0.2134092152,
0.4824280739,
-0.5846680403,
0.3769099712,
0.5366382599,
0.6528957486,
-0.4616912603,
-1.066146493,
0.0176651664,
-0.2963641286,
0.3095877469,
-0.1025318429,
-0.0451057404,
0.9650006294,
0.2683080435,
0.1371976882,
-0.3285571933,
0.2714237273,
-0.0338229388,
0.4340456426,
0.3972138762,
0.0500650592,
0.7280393839,
-0.2799434662,
1.1334294081,
-0.2229858041,
-0.0787020847,
1.1824508905,
-0.1194197014,
0.5672464371,
0.6690167189,
0.3175977767,
0.2537845969,
0.5157808661,
0.2173002511,
0.4830033183,
-0.0026963991,
-0.2246241868,
-0.1626072973,
-0.2959776819,
-0.5630568266,
0.579543829,
0.2152741104,
-1.0616592169,
0.009137189,
0.2754921913,
0.3371141255,
0.1992980689,
-0.2089033425,
0.4868608415,
0.2503801882,
-0.7084929943,
0.3825967908,
0.4218606949,
1.0059956312,
-0.3352344632,
0.1396072209,
-0.2283496708,
0.2240522206,
-0.2886803746,
-0.3043364286,
0.5978171825,
-0.0260547604,
-0.7013028264,
-0.5696605444,
0.9435327649,
-0.5561769605,
-0.3880157173,
0.365470767,
0.7209920883,
-0.0404011644,
-0.1232296452,
-0.5297361612,
-0.4632661045,
-0.0708616599,
-0.1265495121,
0.3580109775,
0.0946742296,
-0.4979129136,
0.6903534532,
0.5179535747,
0.0000887567,
0.2207038999,
0.0118406117,
0.4698574245,
-0.438752532,
-0.5615531802,
-1.0808471441,
0.4406310022,
-0.1565032601,
-0.3376984,
0.8545203805,
0.3191082776,
0.7881006598,
-0.4279561043,
0.608869195,
0.2487916946,
0.0824620053,
-0.388687551,
1.1049146652,
-0.4338142574,
0.2223897278,
-0.4310114384,
-0.9573784471,
-0.4255853295,
0.7181338072,
-0.8274627924,
0.2467767745,
0.5125666857,
0.6705836654,
-0.2211577743,
-0.0031351494,
0.2413925827,
-0.1345691234,
0.0131048029,
0.2404523194,
0.5644690394,
-0.6468550563,
0.2316278815,
-0.1925459206,
0.1124054417,
-0.2756290138,
-1.0921660662,
-0.9354179502,
-0.2512322366,
-0.2256510854,
-0.2832680941,
0.2857668698,
0.7437918782,
1.0902442932,
-0.5554193854,
-0.0699973777,
-0.3610344529,
0.2489407659,
-0.2983592749,
-0.147091046,
0.1620681137,
-0.357670635,
-0.9168838859,
0.4429462552,
-0.2115952522,
-0.0149037372,
-0.27854231,
-0.1482163072,
-0.1081790775,
0.1726768315,
0.4763891995,
-0.2861178815,
-0.613656342,
-0.2052098662,
0.2060298324,
-0.4694215953,
0.089926593,
0.7895117402,
-0.5588200092,
0.49932307,
0.6267501712,
0.5397161841,
0.2810351849,
-0.1451469213,
1.1116659641,
-1.1981406212,
0.4704217017,
0.0897002742,
0.407582581,
0.4963700175,
-0.8219380379,
0.6397894025,
0.1117261574,
-0.260027945,
-0.7994202375,
0.210779205,
-0.3617404997,
-0.5965721011,
1.0239436626,
0.0068723387,
-0.3281655908,
0.0564078167,
-0.3406490088,
0.5699180961,
-0.205621317,
0.655302465,
0.8146427274,
0.2889819443,
-0.0766077414,
-1.342930913,
0.5602662563,
0.9684707522,
-0.6238431334,
-0.0740432888,
0.3924684823,
0.4403510392,
-0.0509172343,
0.4176473022,
-0.130409658,
0.3939255476,
-0.233684063,
0.3151251078,
0.0703571141,
-0.2968990803,
-0.4670044184,
-0.2453786135,
-0.1920688897,
-0.0081811212
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12354v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12354v1 | Cross-Lingual Unlearning of Selective Knowledge in Multilingual Language Models | 2024-06-18T07:40:18 | 2024-06-18T07:40:18 | Minseok Choi, Kyunghyun Min, Jaegul Choo | cs.CL | cs.CL | Pretrained language models memorize vast amounts of information, including
private and copyrighted data, raising significant safety concerns. Retraining
these models after excluding sensitive data is prohibitively expensive, making
machine unlearning a viable, cost-effective alternative. Previous research has
focused on machine unlearning for monolingual models, but we find that
unlearning in one language does not necessarily transfer to others. This
vulnerability makes models susceptible to low-resource language attacks, where
sensitive information remains accessible in less dominant languages. This paper
presents a pioneering approach to machine unlearning for multilingual language
models, selectively erasing information across different languages while
maintaining overall performance. Specifically, our method employs an adaptive
unlearning scheme that assigns language-dependent weights to address different
language performances of multilingual language models. Empirical results
demonstrate the effectiveness of our framework compared to existing unlearning
baselines, setting a new standard for secure and adaptable multilingual
language models. | [
-0.0857747495,
-0.5423616171,
0.0062934798,
-0.0701961964,
-0.2843739092,
0.3429488838,
-0.4352398515,
-0.3740874231,
-0.199532479,
0.7615019679,
-0.4448982477,
-0.298186034,
-0.4989086986,
-0.2201840132,
-0.1900013983,
1.0142143965,
-0.008665395,
0.2158482373,
-0.0738853291,
-0.5343708992,
-0.3583173454,
-0.7583168149,
-0.2677237988,
-0.4561762214,
0.5827608705,
0.4175991118,
0.5506250262,
0.4421584606,
0.19577007,
0.2414203286,
-0.0056753494,
0.0594874956,
-0.704665184,
0.1827902049,
-0.5001055598,
-0.4479324818,
-0.027249651,
-0.1637263,
0.7522600889,
1.021389842,
-0.2678844333,
0.119062379,
0.2739535868,
0.825941205,
-1.0700970888,
-0.0698172078,
-1.0026234388,
0.1730991304,
-0.3264634311,
-0.0639264286,
-0.7166004181,
0.1926207989,
-0.048501242,
-0.7275744677,
0.1410222054,
-0.2385217249,
0.505500257,
0.0730795786,
-0.311488688,
-0.0919808,
-0.7091617584,
1.0399323702,
-0.2121016979,
0.8498198986,
0.602103591,
0.1633317322,
0.2607141733,
-0.5722458363,
0.0784687176,
0.1619828641,
-0.0999155268,
0.0949321166,
-0.4194069207,
-0.2763951123,
0.0155866984,
-0.0431675017,
-0.4944421649,
0.3479820192,
-0.5649485588,
-0.2914114594,
0.3698895276,
-0.3459519148,
0.3435569704,
0.0959436446,
-0.4580743909,
0.0138483476,
-0.8370780349,
0.0047811074,
0.4124399722,
0.501539588,
-0.0780446753,
0.3244965672,
-0.1869592369,
0.3914909959,
-0.134132579,
-0.1926353872,
0.3240873516,
-0.1218441427,
-0.1341460645,
0.0819687843,
0.6749591231,
0.0043392298,
0.4625861347,
-0.5658858418,
-0.1585571617,
-0.1868763715,
0.191950351,
-0.7050077915,
-0.2750589252,
-0.0873175636,
-0.4708990157,
-0.1115496531,
-0.1523294002,
-0.8057906628,
-0.3928970098,
-0.0753234103,
0.3906804323,
-0.4767369926,
-0.4391275644,
-0.1127152368,
-0.0629951209,
-0.208746627,
-0.0091023706,
-1.0059002638,
0.1168131828,
0.3303847611,
0.5131136179,
-0.0646477789,
-0.6979593039,
-0.4971698225,
0.3862406611,
-0.3152990043,
0.3906762302,
-0.6768731475,
-0.3729945421,
-0.0329893678,
0.2435870469,
-0.1624142826,
-0.5534558296,
-0.0460976884,
-0.890006423,
0.1985922158,
-0.208033219,
-0.3996559381,
-0.3562721908,
0.0328154713,
-0.7248194814,
0.7099889517,
0.031679146,
-0.8660358787,
0.5004597306,
-0.4087604582,
-0.610157907,
-0.1813675761,
0.1325509995,
-0.4454636574,
0.0192404427,
0.2453236282,
0.2418166548,
-0.2439286858,
0.2599513829,
-0.3606629372,
-0.0183218475,
0.1574525088,
-0.6334354877,
1.0966389179,
0.4716501534,
-0.0560354739,
0.0536609367,
-0.8523334861,
0.1516727358,
0.1778533608,
-0.4490493536,
-0.6161425114,
-0.1960819364,
0.0657169595,
0.1005859599,
0.4429295361,
-0.4971145391,
-0.088214308,
-0.1642288417,
0.3079246581,
0.7712310553,
-0.1278844625,
0.7454848289,
-0.3780649304,
0.5504215956,
0.1346223503,
0.1765568107,
-0.1359013915,
-0.2246313095,
-0.499271512,
-0.4488844275,
0.4773914218,
0.7098556757,
-0.7519295812,
-0.0852526352,
0.0312724486,
-0.5765282512,
-0.7534529567,
0.6574359536,
0.8120648265,
0.3448035419,
0.4393877089,
-0.2159646899,
-0.5383409858,
-0.7473239899,
-0.6199643016,
-0.0949022919,
0.0585624315,
-0.0476041026,
0.3095836341,
-0.2302385122,
0.5250287056,
-0.1536796838,
-0.0593560264,
-0.4002426863,
0.1661637872,
-0.3134973943,
0.6702234149,
0.440245837,
-0.8886150718,
-0.5278530121,
0.3307981193,
-0.8885647058,
0.016314486,
-0.0222205557,
-0.2315187603,
0.4213231504,
0.4728612602,
-0.1836948097,
0.2191628069,
0.7048091888,
-0.0284482967,
0.2116464972,
-0.5368350744,
-0.0852385238,
-0.9271970987,
0.320436269,
-0.5030863285,
-0.1635563672,
-0.8997247219,
0.2694900334,
0.3161377609,
-0.1338417381,
-0.6477258801,
0.7071133852,
-0.8351109028,
-0.0327760503,
-0.2796105444,
-0.130343616,
0.0541003719,
0.6553493142,
0.1870032698,
0.393769294,
0.6727077365,
-0.5231509209,
-0.0351930372,
0.0492971614,
-0.3709232211,
0.3841234148,
-0.2674253285,
0.2293150276,
-0.3157480061,
-0.2628741562,
-0.5019307733,
0.0689789355,
-0.0351989381,
-0.280479461,
0.5159502625,
-0.543171227,
-0.146088019,
0.3322266638,
-0.0963771194,
0.7639453411,
0.5231744051,
-0.6073147058,
0.6050325632,
0.8730474114,
-0.1863503158,
-0.9097790718,
-0.6990597248,
-0.110474214,
-0.2325951308,
-0.3358175457,
0.1981759816,
-0.1030726731,
-0.2303083241,
-0.0846082568,
0.0086445939,
-0.5918924809,
0.336314857,
0.0987126976,
0.067159161,
0.043106772,
0.128345415,
0.0774079114,
-0.2994863987,
-0.2029996514,
-0.5296587944,
0.5294914246,
0.280569911,
-0.551663816,
-0.1396199614,
0.6390553117,
0.6341603398,
-0.6020777225,
0.7971130013,
0.6781503558,
-0.7668938637,
-0.3905058503,
-0.3064822853,
-0.0290564243,
-0.4502720535,
0.4749278128,
-0.4110417366,
-0.7577821016,
0.6567329168,
0.1154687628,
0.3704363704,
0.0678534433,
0.5481914878,
0.2397500426,
1.0420686007,
1.0439094305,
-0.278567493,
0.5886051059,
0.1877978146,
0.1224297583,
-0.4159226418,
-0.3030704856,
-0.5131941438,
-0.0744794086,
-0.679936707,
-0.3023471534,
0.1203235388,
0.3589045703,
-0.2403428257,
0.2261949182,
-0.1628487557,
0.7063412666,
0.7582806349,
0.1102152914,
0.4406293035,
0.1463853568,
-0.3607293367,
0.0115715098,
-0.8493734002,
-0.1873982847,
1.3288429976,
0.0617551692,
0.8376128078,
0.1909630597,
0.5486425757,
0.0105500929,
0.3910434842,
-0.2622739673,
0.0922570899,
-0.5139939189,
-0.8385565281,
-0.3876094818,
-0.7164568305,
-1.0178933144,
0.5283648372,
-0.0714394897,
-0.8240181804,
0.055665765,
0.0467347987,
-0.1509114057,
0.700589776,
-0.6851671338,
1.0408632755,
-0.3943571746,
-0.3448760808,
-0.2325124741,
-0.4615444541,
0.2849746943,
-0.6747638583,
0.5399618745,
-0.0229530968,
0.0642172918,
0.8793649077,
-0.0418286696,
0.9627460837,
-0.3067518175,
-0.038247712,
-0.0066737016,
0.3219920397,
0.3941156268,
0.0436610579,
-0.1892876178,
0.3164048195,
0.0316964164,
-0.6397534609,
-0.3907275498,
0.4812181294,
-0.7438183427,
-0.3204022944,
0.013784132,
-0.7528387308,
-0.3185840845,
0.5509492755,
0.3832493126,
0.0806325525,
-0.371723026,
0.1013190448,
0.7415269017,
-0.3478818238,
0.4083561599,
0.9569406509,
-0.2293221205,
-0.4111033976,
1.1232198477,
0.2820686102,
0.4747644365,
0.7454475164,
0.0561037175,
-0.1471963227,
-0.3683506548,
-0.4779819846,
0.1099679023,
-0.8651422858,
-0.001962723,
-0.7104625702,
-0.0141794588,
-0.3757902086,
-0.25589481,
-0.6813309193,
-0.3771438897,
-0.1583282351,
-0.1499745548,
0.106050618,
0.5682749152,
-0.2932789326,
0.1395217925,
-0.9374356866,
0.2998128533,
0.2522405386,
0.3859252632,
-0.0728968382,
-0.657068789,
-0.3864261508,
0.2416594625,
-0.1179330945,
-0.5860894918,
0.4743992984,
0.2602174282,
0.8024545312,
0.4279592335,
0.2718793154,
0.546782136,
-0.4360840023,
0.2649766207,
0.3101627231,
-0.9158834219,
0.2624826729,
-0.1573856473,
0.4043783247,
0.6316704154,
0.5369244814,
-0.7576890588,
-0.2865131497,
-0.5371682048,
-0.8154713511,
0.7545699477,
-0.2360103875,
0.0412218273,
0.4861500561,
0.0490522757,
0.4580393434,
0.1952257156,
-0.8173264265,
-0.088797003,
-0.1491892487,
-0.1729203612,
-0.3478544652,
-0.2210268378,
-0.1666609049,
-0.0809106901,
0.6868259907,
-0.1094924062,
-0.2016062438,
-0.3564886153,
-0.658744216,
-0.1781630069,
0.3210157752,
0.2580583096,
0.6700129509,
0.0931390822,
0.2254833281,
0.4354770184,
-0.4197736382,
0.2480228394,
-0.1137226224,
-0.4603115618,
-0.2422398776,
0.345054388,
0.5737482309,
0.4196498096,
-0.6702339053,
0.266841501,
0.0305996072,
-0.0851035938,
-0.0174395144,
-0.1681124419,
0.1142817587,
0.0302155279,
-0.0109659377,
0.1522839814,
-0.2827314138,
-0.5604219437,
0.4744902849,
0.4260806441,
-0.6482987404,
-0.4277623296,
0.6604102254,
-0.054879263,
-0.0168514214,
0.6107484102,
0.0836232379,
-0.4395765066,
0.2579694986,
0.5484111905,
0.7445530891,
-0.5384858847,
0.1865706146,
0.0465032719,
0.5753959417,
-0.1451469064,
0.3417459726,
-0.0302120112,
-0.8818818927,
-0.1267398447,
-0.5404585004,
-0.2899591625,
0.1061327383,
-0.7415612936,
-0.0205847826,
-0.6319597363,
0.1835067123,
0.0672133714,
-0.23801893,
-0.6248981953,
0.0916694775,
0.0666620508,
0.6203362942,
-0.8672493696,
1.0825055838,
0.6586710215,
-0.3490011394,
-0.5366023183,
-0.2905331552,
0.0869472399,
-1.0202928782,
0.415795505,
0.0242809709,
-0.0086012268,
-0.2336304486,
0.0164186675,
-0.8833951354,
0.5829079151,
0.8726264834,
-0.3801450729,
0.1659881175,
0.3892364204,
0.1792242229,
-0.1547941267,
0.0601637661,
0.3454579711,
0.3772337437,
-0.4148134887,
-0.8543620706,
-0.116387479,
-0.3467506468,
-0.3483253121,
0.2344183773,
-0.7081167698,
1.0999543667,
-0.2424825132,
-0.3099862337,
-0.2000585347,
0.4330888987,
-0.0589983873,
0.1943404078,
0.5256522298,
0.4309540391,
1.2255724669,
0.2256726027,
0.5312012434,
-0.5434142947,
0.1324604601,
1.0254346132,
-0.4812901914,
0.6693224311,
0.3195360005,
0.1731647402,
0.1432731003,
0.3992129862,
0.3201134801,
0.7256147265,
0.0363845639,
-0.2557674348,
-0.4682674706,
-0.175993219,
-0.1926742345,
0.6676671505,
0.0023809357,
-0.3041320145,
-0.3035732806,
0.377553761,
0.3133371174,
0.0646659657,
-0.1900715977,
0.7803985476,
-0.0325400457,
-0.6152762771,
0.7327913642,
0.2020912021,
0.500089407,
-0.7822464108,
0.2675446868,
-0.2880083323,
0.5465096235,
-0.151017502,
-0.2383940071,
0.2528848052,
0.3371260464,
-0.5069856048,
-0.5683252215,
0.5769369602,
-0.7192948461,
-0.6182708144,
0.7766806483,
0.7546105981,
0.0199868716,
-0.1027935371,
-0.7011575699,
-0.1837708801,
0.224344641,
-0.2213287801,
0.8381279111,
0.6097011566,
-0.3373492658,
0.8648398519,
0.7965750694,
-0.009256117,
0.1744889021,
0.3539747894,
0.7735633254,
-0.5109194517,
-0.7043833137,
-0.6123550534,
0.4319250584,
0.2652488649,
-0.2470135838,
0.7642999887,
0.6037145257,
1.3589674234,
0.2101564258,
1.0040844679,
0.3935004175,
0.4665369987,
-0.6529886723,
1.219984889,
-0.6936376095,
0.298361659,
-0.2558721602,
-0.5138279796,
-0.3037744462,
0.2393648922,
0.0705657303,
0.187760666,
0.5073967576,
0.9447278976,
-0.1545000672,
0.0304425079,
0.5787668228,
-0.0155730415,
0.0620529614,
0.6433563828,
0.7291042209,
-0.1510509253,
0.7181127071,
-0.5522915721,
-0.3425088823,
0.1176901087,
-0.6222396493,
-0.8767860532,
-0.530711472,
-0.1069962233,
0.0589747988,
0.3274415433,
0.4850747287,
0.7828316689,
-0.9789633751,
-0.4641799331,
0.2658829689,
0.4176068604,
-0.4590745866,
-0.122355476,
0.2615196705,
-0.3413498998,
-0.4944756627,
0.6306595206,
0.0534068383,
0.0026872393,
-0.1915865839,
-0.1594063044,
-0.1845153719,
-0.0919616967,
0.3231768012,
0.5346781611,
-0.2553645074,
-0.0690123588,
-0.0294448566,
-0.0145606417,
-0.0661318973,
0.9607772231,
-0.5314365029,
0.4091501832,
0.4576705992,
0.7199085951,
0.3271419704,
-0.4032863081,
0.5539146662,
-1.0614625216,
0.4709299803,
0.0397681408,
0.6383501291,
0.3617696166,
-0.2999998629,
0.2121890336,
0.2874888182,
-0.2263904959,
-0.9941068292,
0.2636274695,
-0.4471624494,
-0.8681927919,
0.8410938978,
-0.4209265113,
-0.3157441318,
-0.3764921427,
0.2041968107,
0.4210861921,
-0.1703532934,
0.6488260031,
0.4861463904,
0.4577513635,
-0.1718855351,
-0.2871338129,
0.308991909,
0.6228827834,
-0.6120432615,
0.6964452863,
0.2447084039,
0.424256593,
0.0611653887,
0.5551715493,
-0.29977265,
0.3155324757,
0.0899598822,
0.1847712994,
-0.1168404222,
-0.8147420883,
-0.4070994854,
0.4150623977,
-0.0785835162,
-0.0502288379
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12347v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12347v1 | Interpreting Bias in Large Language Models: A Feature-Based Approach | 2024-06-18T07:28:15 | 2024-06-18T07:28:15 | Nirmalendu Prakash, Lee Ka Wei Roy | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) such as Mistral and LLaMA have showcased
remarkable performance across various natural language processing (NLP) tasks.
Despite their success, these models inherit social biases from the diverse
datasets on which they are trained. This paper investigates the propagation of
biases within LLMs through a novel feature-based analytical approach. Drawing
inspiration from causal mediation analysis, we hypothesize the evolution of
bias-related features and validate them using interpretability techniques like
activation and attribution patching. Our contributions are threefold: (1) We
introduce and empirically validate a feature-based method for bias analysis in
LLMs, applied to LLaMA-2-7B, LLaMA-3-8B, and Mistral-7B-v0.3 with templates
from a professions dataset. (2) We extend our method to another form of gender
bias, demonstrating its generalizability. (3) We differentiate the roles of
MLPs and attention heads in bias propagation and implement targeted debiasing
using a counterfactual dataset. Our findings reveal the complex nature of bias
in LLMs and emphasize the necessity for tailored debiasing strategies, offering
a deeper understanding of bias mechanisms and pathways for effective
mitigation. | [
-0.3916598856,
-0.8970774412,
0.6086034775,
0.4078351259,
-0.0801586062,
-0.1540671736,
-0.1823457032,
-0.4819181561,
0.2487726808,
0.819331646,
-0.6953910589,
-0.3406884372,
-1.0188499689,
-0.0479093567,
-0.5547201633,
0.9994905591,
0.0680894107,
0.3545601368,
-0.0772925392,
-0.2802758217,
-0.703867197,
-0.4535104334,
-0.3720903099,
-0.7128449082,
0.4507219195,
0.1285247505,
0.7267210484,
0.6702240705,
0.2347372472,
0.1655809134,
-0.5103174448,
0.058977183,
-0.5875896215,
0.1224234104,
-0.2363330275,
-0.7103331089,
-0.4248741865,
0.0652126521,
0.6108344197,
0.9423667192,
0.0801609382,
0.4808716476,
0.4518523216,
0.557842195,
-0.5818356872,
0.1916131526,
-0.8895998001,
0.0137157477,
-0.334220022,
-0.0435347445,
-0.3275875747,
-0.2272024304,
0.2370904088,
-0.168626979,
0.418816179,
-0.1233039349,
0.5330252647,
0.4319324791,
-0.5418512225,
-0.3152077794,
-0.6296679974,
0.991401732,
-0.5577762723,
0.3239320815,
0.2738007903,
0.0787642002,
-0.3002782464,
-0.2626776993,
-0.4413176775,
0.0215022936,
-0.0836240873,
-0.4088561237,
-0.2088247836,
-0.2470041513,
0.3464502096,
0.1387504339,
-0.037344981,
0.2971863151,
-0.0912672952,
0.034279488,
0.5271265507,
-0.055660069,
0.1823710948,
-0.0305723343,
-0.2636244595,
0.2486370057,
-0.9917772412,
-0.2076574564,
0.420794338,
0.3213341832,
-0.1962023228,
0.5262930989,
-0.0077824057,
0.4551049769,
0.2383175194,
-0.0251709633,
0.2257742584,
0.117467016,
-0.2848987281,
0.1887070388,
0.5837507248,
0.2021565288,
0.3106282055,
0.0585143007,
-0.0073995278,
0.2223117799,
0.2162149996,
-0.3617649078,
0.2296948582,
0.0843559876,
-0.6483570933,
-0.7958058715,
-0.3129800558,
-0.8669324517,
-0.9117562771,
-0.3108401597,
0.2247050107,
0.1778183132,
-0.3494838774,
-0.0001475054,
-0.0433356836,
0.1102089733,
0.2743764222,
-0.8173723817,
0.2346945256,
0.8520872593,
0.6266288161,
-0.1335759312,
-0.296405375,
-0.341950804,
0.1407430619,
-0.1829655617,
0.6140416861,
-0.7414889336,
-0.1448432356,
0.1854507178,
-0.1298249662,
0.1053248942,
-0.7024326921,
0.578900218,
-0.4832036495,
-0.1105119735,
-0.7493599057,
-0.1595498323,
-0.2959609926,
0.1167517677,
-0.8707404733,
0.9756526947,
-0.0065997802,
-1.1354076862,
0.7353158593,
-0.6172910333,
-0.2573034763,
-0.5714437366,
-0.3806469142,
-0.3742986619,
0.2238054574,
0.4979001284,
0.3308614194,
-0.6982253194,
0.7422050238,
-0.6618055701,
-0.31502074,
0.4907668233,
-0.7283297777,
0.9360584021,
-0.1263287812,
-0.8548959494,
-0.0238257255,
-0.5865089893,
-0.5851802826,
-0.0042150021,
0.0740455911,
-0.379874289,
0.2619988918,
-0.062631987,
0.2620699704,
-0.0870287493,
-0.2274263352,
0.0980782583,
-0.0987440348,
0.332149893,
0.7808830142,
0.0579079986,
0.5677179098,
-0.0263609141,
0.3879427314,
0.282089591,
0.3828421831,
0.0696535632,
-0.4769075513,
-0.7443048954,
-0.3921993077,
0.0924066529,
0.3621043265,
-0.5528162122,
0.3460045755,
-0.1325748712,
-0.2558013201,
-0.7326062918,
0.4033183753,
0.3152699471,
0.5145498514,
0.3421227634,
-0.2471338212,
-0.4562015831,
-1.2110943794,
-0.6128197312,
-0.0632321909,
0.0437241234,
0.1278742552,
0.3098487854,
-0.495457679,
0.9650310278,
-0.4392763674,
-0.3598905206,
-0.4057497382,
0.2903694212,
0.2622816265,
0.179180339,
0.5171695948,
-0.5459774733,
-0.0102670789,
-0.2904595435,
-0.6937854886,
-0.7648185492,
-0.181766659,
-0.1865876466,
-0.0163512919,
0.4240374863,
-0.5238322616,
0.5441550016,
0.5703715682,
-0.4278309941,
0.4546823502,
0.3960569203,
-0.1495099664,
-0.6553537846,
0.07489191,
0.3278739452,
-0.1441296786,
-0.6599690914,
-0.1271199137,
-0.3797581494,
0.3682129383,
-0.2176830173,
0.5946574807,
-0.5213293433,
-0.3582051992,
-0.3359836638,
0.0265425257,
0.0174383502,
0.2995302081,
-0.0312122051,
0.2879579067,
0.400763303,
-0.3922502398,
0.0482196696,
0.1940233558,
-0.2725262046,
0.5364906788,
-0.4825070798,
0.0233033486,
-0.3878048956,
0.5046727061,
-0.7991627455,
0.0443307012,
0.3860682547,
-0.1229415238,
0.0765548795,
-0.2921783328,
-0.340031147,
-0.093532674,
-0.3837324679,
0.5066623092,
0.2034456432,
-0.5588183999,
0.441670835,
0.4373321235,
-0.0971622542,
-0.9834033847,
-0.7058262229,
0.036508292,
-0.5020692945,
-0.2882052958,
0.0031171113,
0.3814345896,
-0.6743521094,
-0.1286695451,
0.0009058838,
-0.0718844086,
0.2547076643,
0.4605848193,
0.1504784822,
-0.1096476763,
-0.0684529543,
0.2195967287,
0.0239041746,
0.3047232926,
0.0791098401,
0.5381075144,
0.3520027101,
-0.5554129481,
-0.1644867063,
0.1569333225,
0.6775577664,
-0.1072789654,
0.8070552349,
0.6227326393,
-0.2932765782,
-0.4721134901,
-0.878821969,
-0.3103730381,
-0.3790008426,
0.4339120984,
-0.0683311,
-0.8266273141,
0.6647135019,
0.0121330591,
0.0317046158,
0.4247818887,
0.8453829288,
0.2568380833,
0.9473526478,
0.6847909093,
-0.5661915541,
0.4613013566,
-0.0750775561,
0.1255163997,
-0.9282644987,
-0.1483591348,
-0.475335747,
-0.385753721,
-0.5772106647,
-0.5907180905,
0.2305098474,
0.1330412179,
-0.2635413706,
-0.1931385547,
-0.2710618973,
0.2350549847,
0.4125790894,
0.1394097805,
0.2115589678,
0.0285481717,
0.0947027653,
-0.1381911337,
-0.5139660239,
-0.588491559,
1.1615755558,
0.8449082375,
0.9095827937,
-0.0338619798,
0.2762392759,
0.4545948505,
0.7373664975,
-0.4963256121,
0.3457363844,
0.0511777438,
-0.7389574647,
-0.4089522958,
-0.1274391562,
-0.6446991563,
0.5777201056,
-0.4949712753,
-0.7429407835,
0.4854137599,
0.1680587083,
0.1707091331,
0.3018118441,
-0.4316258132,
0.661922276,
-0.1156587824,
-0.5070956945,
-0.3302811086,
-0.3458556235,
0.6652598381,
-0.2864887118,
0.3647864461,
-0.2001636177,
0.0465980619,
0.5552737117,
-0.0379136615,
1.2906965017,
-0.2631345093,
-0.5274556875,
0.1249433681,
0.1135561466,
0.3464550376,
0.0674964562,
-0.319242388,
0.4461750984,
-0.3335171342,
-0.1545380801,
-0.6215939522,
0.6081339121,
-0.7198565602,
-0.7376354337,
-0.2541586459,
-0.5669871569,
-0.2331773192,
0.1040164605,
-0.0770813152,
0.3534317911,
-0.2306239605,
-0.1032420471,
0.6376941204,
-0.3648506999,
0.1256724894,
0.3771919608,
-0.348850131,
0.0338991247,
0.3695119023,
0.2357979268,
0.1570781618,
0.1292921305,
0.3146281838,
-0.1633459777,
-0.490055114,
-0.3339368999,
0.4399005771,
-0.6796483397,
0.1077767983,
-0.605643034,
-0.0766298324,
-0.2977808416,
-0.0372068696,
-0.3054905832,
0.018995991,
-0.3083370328,
-0.0436606556,
0.087994419,
0.9966164231,
0.1235460117,
0.4233695269,
-0.3979629278,
0.3438074291,
0.248642236,
0.234904319,
0.4182684124,
-0.5187866092,
-0.0976268649,
-0.0274471771,
-0.2725610137,
-1.1014913321,
0.4129124284,
-0.2029271126,
0.5762382746,
0.5212099552,
-0.2528969049,
0.4540136456,
-0.5252404213,
0.6832658648,
-0.0031454889,
-1.0100295544,
0.4307989776,
-0.4806475043,
0.0766849443,
0.3615254462,
0.2112154812,
-0.5296314955,
-0.6349750757,
-0.6611121893,
-0.7786406875,
0.6299903393,
0.00401732,
0.11403054,
-0.0814648122,
0.506377399,
0.1991265267,
0.4289269149,
-0.8259055018,
-0.4277848303,
0.1850512624,
-0.1314845383,
-0.1755108088,
-0.7456287742,
-0.2543437481,
0.0096412562,
0.4777839184,
-0.1211527213,
0.1823849678,
0.0920214057,
-0.5397620797,
-0.0155575899,
0.3805792332,
0.6372119784,
0.8026220202,
-0.1453607678,
0.2282668352,
0.295661062,
-0.5407595038,
0.0457501821,
-0.0947736055,
-0.340249747,
0.1184271127,
0.6497774124,
0.8613913655,
0.1750871986,
-0.285820812,
0.6499993801,
0.4123553336,
0.1044798791,
-0.0753157511,
-0.1356417388,
-0.0007230327,
0.6041502953,
0.3695967197,
-0.2456709594,
0.3831163943,
-0.5482715964,
0.0537008904,
0.5289855003,
-0.6982163787,
-0.4302024841,
0.6196796298,
0.1664684564,
0.2394304574,
0.1428535283,
0.2163882852,
-0.6349927187,
0.6428493857,
0.4268572927,
1.0553710461,
-0.2286120355,
0.187509194,
0.0523706116,
0.5575993657,
-0.3034276962,
0.0721843764,
0.2809670568,
-0.8835924864,
-0.6009981036,
-0.5927983522,
-0.1812260002,
0.2888029516,
-0.752974391,
0.3457581401,
-0.2115266025,
-0.1843577772,
0.1221110076,
-0.4010787606,
-0.7163459659,
0.090429388,
0.3584460318,
0.7820621133,
-1.4022134542,
0.6566413641,
0.5347469449,
0.0339596123,
-0.3871224225,
0.2625198662,
0.4511159062,
-1.0868543386,
1.0120579004,
0.0838885456,
-0.0726874694,
-0.4559959471,
-0.3737413287,
-0.7850180268,
0.7851970792,
0.5150472522,
-0.3997679353,
0.0977880508,
0.4348188043,
0.4487531781,
-0.5206481814,
0.4678534269,
0.9065816402,
0.38401559,
-0.31130144,
-0.9870497584,
0.2447822094,
0.259095788,
0.1576379091,
0.0208516475,
-0.4986437857,
0.6755518317,
0.109443754,
0.3088746071,
-0.4859653711,
0.5139830112,
0.2552832663,
0.2554982007,
0.6815878749,
0.3233839869,
0.6014450788,
0.1159438938,
0.8129689097,
0.0001635123,
0.2815107107,
1.0262098312,
-0.4325777888,
0.5686125755,
0.7439033985,
-0.1782573611,
0.5151033401,
0.3093156219,
0.1144139692,
0.3193615377,
0.439281106,
-0.1301248819,
0.0420226716,
-0.4814466834,
-0.0920012295,
0.5952524543,
0.268894136,
-0.818567574,
-0.2657513618,
-0.0732490644,
0.3629597723,
-0.0707421303,
-0.4892351627,
0.4587982297,
0.2196788192,
-0.4471308291,
0.2581412196,
-0.0509655476,
0.8180472851,
-0.331147939,
-0.2059042007,
-0.1926460713,
0.1779524833,
-0.2979722619,
-0.6608393788,
0.188774243,
0.126035586,
-0.4712907672,
-0.2075329125,
0.7821732163,
-0.4096248448,
-0.4581399858,
0.3258197606,
0.6356768608,
-0.1811147481,
-0.0653269216,
-0.6603552103,
0.4983806908,
0.1198849455,
-0.4111575186,
0.3348110914,
0.3263236284,
-0.5445275903,
0.7371637821,
0.2841598988,
0.3915367424,
0.0699865595,
0.4621796906,
0.8478277922,
-0.5501030684,
-0.3051612377,
-1.1320258379,
0.3613230884,
-0.0280301124,
-0.0467687957,
0.7312455177,
0.2127607763,
0.3764585853,
0.135176912,
0.7678768039,
0.3053957224,
0.553397119,
-0.3848838806,
0.7056135535,
-0.2383144349,
0.5009584427,
-0.5455085635,
-1.1488980055,
-0.2370871305,
0.3872956634,
-0.591653347,
0.1087817699,
0.3151607513,
0.6857075095,
0.0133214723,
-0.0286759809,
-0.0363214463,
0.3866651654,
0.4187222421,
0.1218493059,
0.888433516,
-0.1099085733,
0.0469152741,
-0.0063153123,
-0.3669086099,
-0.353646189,
-1.0101972818,
-1.0144864321,
-0.1517904997,
-0.217713967,
-0.401596427,
-0.0835693777,
0.8419038653,
0.3727073669,
-0.5563488007,
-0.2831437588,
0.2538074255,
0.4386309683,
-0.1800121069,
-0.2156116515,
0.3930631578,
-0.3215120733,
-0.5437449813,
-0.0980387777,
0.0234705415,
-0.3517366946,
-0.7519786358,
0.2097244859,
-0.0711875632,
0.1562316716,
0.7443435788,
-0.0679210424,
-0.9667117,
-0.3654691577,
-0.3083516061,
-0.0300081745,
-0.1408485621,
0.888156116,
-0.6690427065,
0.2482985109,
0.2606697083,
0.5526755452,
0.3184396923,
-0.1973896921,
0.7969589233,
-0.4806489944,
0.2632649541,
-0.1839330196,
0.292825073,
0.3342828751,
-0.3824140131,
0.4522474408,
0.246263355,
-0.2463404238,
-1.0668730736,
0.2357701063,
-0.650318563,
-0.2713172138,
1.4297428131,
0.2030742317,
-0.151126489,
-0.2002893239,
-0.2379941493,
0.3597377241,
-0.1060375944,
1.0188593864,
0.6596940756,
0.0098306555,
-0.1331166029,
-0.8936242461,
0.5784268975,
0.4600532949,
-0.460031569,
0.3515805006,
0.4912827611,
0.4731168151,
0.0411377735,
0.4764462709,
-0.2093079835,
-0.0221158061,
-0.1608868688,
0.2521661818,
0.1678798199,
-0.1476032287,
-0.6744471788,
-0.0669991001,
0.3425919712,
0.2165050805
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12336v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12336v1 | A Compass for Navigating the World of Sentence Embeddings for the Telecom Domain | 2024-06-18T07:03:34 | 2024-06-18T07:03:34 | Sujoy Roychowdhury, Sumit Soman, H. G. Ranjani, Vansh Chhabra, Neeraj Gunda, Subhadip Bandyopadhyay, Sai Krishna Bala | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, 68T50, I.2.7 | A plethora of sentence embedding models makes it challenging to choose one,
especially for domains such as telecom, rich with specialized vocabulary. We
evaluate multiple embeddings obtained from publicly available models and their
domain-adapted variants, on both point retrieval accuracies as well as their
(95\%) confidence intervals. We establish a systematic method to obtain
thresholds for similarity scores for different embeddings. We observe that
fine-tuning improves mean bootstrapped accuracies as well as tightens
confidence intervals. The pre-training combined with fine-tuning makes
confidence intervals even tighter. To understand these variations, we analyse
and report significant correlations between the distributional overlap between
top-$K$, correct and random sentence similarities with retrieval accuracies and
similarity thresholds. Following current literature, we analyze if retrieval
accuracy variations can be attributed to isotropy of embeddings. Our
conclusions are that isotropy of embeddings (as measured by two independent
state-of-the-art isotropy metric definitions) cannot be attributed to better
retrieval performance. However, domain adaptation which improves retrieval
accuracies also improves isotropy. We establish that domain adaptation moves
domain specific embeddings further away from general domain embeddings. | [
-0.2630442977,
-0.6661900878,
0.6527786255,
0.1258016229,
-0.3464951813,
-0.0752218515,
-0.2463781387,
-0.3595519662,
0.2937751412,
0.1844223291,
-0.2001929581,
-0.6220443845,
-0.653716445,
0.2011698633,
-0.146057412,
0.5138351321,
0.0792807713,
0.189706862,
-0.2163607627,
-0.3936222792,
-0.3962387443,
-0.5801414847,
0.0185688734,
-0.1403347403,
0.1401855648,
0.3777003288,
0.95356071,
0.6129273176,
0.4704421163,
0.1632050276,
-0.0380545221,
0.1665278226,
-0.4434672892,
0.1472113431,
0.0353850126,
-0.4635742605,
-0.1575037539,
0.0752301961,
0.4644541144,
0.7266988754,
-0.3377871513,
0.060115356,
0.335422188,
0.4763144851,
-0.7608221769,
-0.1197448224,
-0.8102839589,
0.1993959397,
0.0254681278,
-0.344928354,
-0.4303916097,
-0.5686792731,
0.4711157978,
-0.9445858598,
0.1044542715,
0.3441680372,
1.1905690432,
0.1984575838,
-0.658500433,
-0.4219546914,
-0.2755325139,
0.8791766763,
-0.4946750104,
0.7166842818,
0.3948634863,
0.0558141656,
0.1470576376,
-0.6501245499,
-0.2220112532,
-0.19079566,
0.1994727552,
0.0833755657,
-0.2518873513,
0.1045936421,
0.0278397053,
0.0664563254,
-0.3618597686,
0.0184016246,
-0.1557052284,
-0.1232322082,
0.3013825119,
-0.0486049019,
0.0833459347,
-0.0335664339,
-0.4785914421,
0.0580263212,
-0.9424644709,
-0.144441396,
0.6337117553,
0.2201371491,
0.1374851912,
0.6278080344,
-0.1349165887,
0.7463165522,
0.0543897711,
0.2739015222,
0.352635473,
-0.2187810093,
-0.1595002264,
0.1157192737,
0.4263933599,
0.5826089382,
0.769264698,
-0.2449366599,
0.0498684198,
-0.3609959781,
0.5877373219,
-0.5008322597,
-0.2116186917,
0.0149859525,
-0.5992107987,
-0.0583355241,
0.4526464343,
-0.367546618,
-0.1514988244,
-0.2697947919,
0.4178161621,
-0.6855381727,
-0.0098652253,
0.3965684175,
-0.2901029587,
0.3012990952,
0.2216010988,
-0.6491778493,
0.4118400216,
0.8227543831,
0.9726353884,
-0.09301202,
-0.1208418757,
-0.297560364,
-0.0045971549,
-0.344600141,
0.6040858626,
-0.9355502129,
-0.3650936484,
0.5771317482,
-0.100980565,
-0.3404167593,
-0.5932118297,
0.786056757,
-0.8514932394,
0.1755448878,
-0.3438945711,
-0.8586652875,
-0.4059316516,
0.0771765634,
-0.6040822268,
0.8433328271,
-0.0374993086,
-0.6865304112,
0.4448932111,
-0.2707250714,
-0.2504779398,
-0.2210292518,
0.0156127531,
-0.3322235644,
0.3493829072,
-0.0112854252,
0.4517191947,
-0.2177421898,
-0.1478736699,
-0.4552120566,
-0.5374432206,
0.2786251009,
0.0490837023,
0.8889402747,
0.4335491955,
0.0828835443,
-0.433570981,
-0.5935314298,
0.4567341208,
-0.4334954023,
0.0026970888,
-0.7716506124,
-0.0429849103,
0.1280594468,
-0.046543248,
0.0707647651,
-0.6877077222,
0.0859147161,
-0.1156230345,
0.6706618071,
0.4687685966,
0.223640576,
0.4937257767,
-0.4076362848,
0.3965618014,
0.3690222204,
-0.0831833705,
0.1176253557,
-0.5801497102,
-0.4027075469,
-0.0288093835,
0.5360375643,
0.5760760903,
-0.4595075846,
0.5147035122,
-0.4657449722,
-0.4257245064,
-0.9692963958,
0.1292575598,
0.3368329406,
0.2019034475,
0.5348173976,
-0.2494290322,
-0.2209603786,
-0.8611807823,
-0.7719996572,
0.1104660034,
0.0170885809,
0.3905384243,
0.3643349707,
0.0383583307,
0.945725143,
-0.8269404173,
-0.4582278728,
0.143195644,
0.0657917336,
-0.0342089012,
0.3557546437,
0.4473856091,
-0.9282155633,
-0.5659441352,
-0.2334077358,
-0.5675965548,
-0.0171271525,
-0.1491294056,
0.2702977955,
-0.0812694356,
0.4722948074,
-0.5205724835,
0.1733085513,
0.4121559262,
-0.2381370366,
0.4464173913,
-0.3030458391,
0.2471768856,
-1.1709578037,
-0.2032268494,
0.2732460499,
-0.3005888462,
-0.4580965638,
0.0629342198,
0.2907120287,
0.0744016394,
-0.2813076377,
0.1140407398,
-0.7369214892,
-0.0702404082,
0.03843119,
0.500748992,
0.1628008336,
0.0758953765,
-0.2526769936,
0.9433760047,
0.549061954,
-0.6560354829,
-0.0109560806,
0.4952144325,
-0.7530590892,
0.5586259961,
-0.7944840193,
0.1146830022,
0.1124053821,
-0.0066987928,
-0.803368628,
0.2364563495,
-0.2122053355,
-0.4003728926,
0.0212974641,
-0.2010193765,
-0.3370968997,
0.2772730589,
-0.4636612535,
0.404832691,
0.5292605162,
-0.305387795,
0.0996593162,
0.4767729938,
-0.1349221319,
-0.8142228723,
-0.7194642425,
0.1109195873,
-0.2239772379,
-0.6000772119,
0.8918004632,
0.3092188537,
-0.1850648075,
0.1514802575,
0.0338927433,
-0.2695686519,
0.0453544185,
0.1659811288,
-0.0107312929,
-0.4186301231,
0.3531641364,
0.1590996534,
-0.001647456,
-0.0448559448,
-0.5581923127,
0.2066648304,
-0.1167911589,
-0.2451707572,
-0.4101598561,
0.2518736124,
0.1591900736,
-0.0901450068,
0.6991585493,
0.5258921385,
-0.2218111306,
-0.2818763256,
-0.5246751904,
-0.1187127605,
-0.4607123733,
0.2033951879,
-0.7742370963,
-0.9947566986,
0.4122874141,
-0.3573679328,
-0.2518989146,
0.2231461108,
0.1071920916,
-0.1186235696,
0.6797297001,
1.0107557774,
0.2110344321,
0.4462198913,
-0.1043017283,
0.3622438312,
-0.9828172922,
-0.1467116475,
-0.6643445492,
-0.3096292019,
-0.9189904332,
-0.3415008783,
0.3347721398,
0.0439027287,
-0.1413957775,
0.6042953134,
-0.3553602099,
0.41915223,
0.3522168696,
0.1751155257,
0.3710090518,
0.2415189892,
-0.5341562629,
-0.3137653768,
-0.8034244776,
-0.546348989,
1.0431387424,
0.1367527246,
1.0102620125,
0.2042398453,
0.5829439759,
0.3424259126,
-0.2396073639,
-0.6373755336,
0.2547059655,
-0.3728082776,
-0.2851318717,
-0.0749471486,
-0.4901644886,
-0.8615530133,
0.1300789267,
-0.2280546427,
-0.8587573171,
0.5663523078,
-0.1439247429,
-0.3832669556,
0.0465509593,
-0.7663525939,
0.7000781894,
0.3079823256,
-0.1604224443,
-0.2952388227,
-0.5289905667,
-0.1223446205,
0.0443180315,
-0.0794655606,
0.0290468615,
-0.4498482049,
0.5237879157,
-0.1966436207,
0.674458921,
-0.0813297331,
0.1076304913,
0.2570363283,
0.2197706252,
0.0990925804,
-0.0702296346,
-0.4531652033,
0.2136585116,
0.2903593481,
-0.3066518009,
-0.5713258982,
0.8686419129,
-0.9469905496,
-0.6127776504,
-0.3223573267,
-0.3346007466,
-0.3413477838,
0.1415939629,
0.4162287116,
0.5428132415,
-0.4097697437,
0.5940306187,
0.7267363667,
-0.2121789157,
0.2544516325,
0.149626106,
0.3189195991,
-0.2702294886,
0.545470953,
0.3089532852,
0.3199739754,
0.7124269605,
-0.1223559305,
-0.6059032083,
-0.4226367474,
-0.2287673354,
0.1596958339,
-0.783793807,
-0.371550709,
-0.7220714688,
-0.2236323804,
-0.5500333905,
-0.3519109488,
-0.1354181319,
-0.8603297472,
-0.4947102964,
-0.26160115,
0.530710876,
0.5886746049,
0.176317215,
0.4123955667,
-0.7312082648,
-0.0332292989,
-0.2177218199,
0.3909234703,
-0.213506788,
-0.7515134215,
-0.4216426909,
0.1296108216,
-0.4223791361,
-0.8390369415,
0.2849604487,
0.778581202,
0.3666698933,
0.1789554656,
0.1489272863,
0.7984952331,
-0.6777507663,
0.9919114709,
-0.0159051009,
-1.0506955385,
0.2938600779,
-0.0112193068,
0.1043442041,
0.7319430709,
0.916241169,
-0.4088527858,
-0.1231443509,
-0.6584535241,
-0.5837593675,
0.0757678002,
-0.0587936975,
0.5031989813,
0.0647491291,
0.5418792963,
0.1702561975,
0.137347579,
-0.316295296,
-0.1791623682,
-0.2179665416,
-0.351986587,
0.0984435827,
-0.1876295209,
-0.150456652,
0.065831244,
0.386873275,
-0.0360471755,
0.4436712265,
0.4991144538,
-0.4996558726,
0.160271734,
0.2798591256,
0.3873942792,
0.7040223479,
-0.1517154872,
0.2109166235,
0.0898522139,
-0.6785477996,
0.1679660082,
-0.0227867719,
-0.1381519139,
0.4406579733,
0.2444413155,
0.3994320929,
0.308819741,
-0.3637087047,
0.7456250787,
0.1055593193,
-0.1902139187,
-0.3074311614,
0.0236324165,
-0.071419619,
0.0494014248,
0.4639101624,
-0.0109464834,
0.2612077892,
-0.4226119816,
0.455383718,
0.4049641788,
-0.6033782959,
-0.1864334047,
0.622202456,
0.1779936552,
-0.4546154737,
0.7058827281,
-0.0085382359,
-0.4040981829,
0.3096971214,
0.5596934557,
0.9858641028,
-0.0387007818,
0.3758915067,
0.1672414988,
0.2042434067,
-0.2204694301,
0.4129114151,
0.0582882501,
-0.8813042641,
-0.23147282,
-0.2822062671,
-0.39395836,
-0.5134590268,
-0.8984928131,
0.2725354433,
-0.2589858174,
-0.5210559368,
-0.016678758,
0.0656375512,
-0.7770186663,
0.0901071057,
-0.478082478,
1.2718400955,
-0.5697253346,
0.9656990767,
0.7290173173,
-0.3497771323,
-0.6720770597,
0.3020378947,
-0.0362038277,
-0.7846516371,
0.6223424077,
0.1063980982,
-0.2721138597,
0.3290325701,
-0.1617667824,
-0.693170011,
1.4087293148,
0.1630880237,
-0.4622529745,
0.0418244563,
0.1436977684,
0.4737767577,
-0.7792534828,
0.3667637408,
0.1328467578,
0.1292202175,
-0.3765431941,
-0.823864162,
0.2587299943,
0.026014341,
0.1719833463,
-0.0398977101,
-0.6160097718,
0.6025937796,
-0.329377681,
-0.2870460153,
0.0492847562,
0.4625414908,
-0.1329832226,
0.1308569014,
0.4086150229,
0.6556041837,
0.668566823,
-0.1342606694,
0.979387641,
-0.6109498739,
0.4662732482,
0.8100865483,
-0.33558622,
1.0894690752,
0.4827449918,
0.0937903821,
0.8120324612,
0.5544461608,
0.0049084434,
0.7263196707,
0.1848518997,
-0.0504461415,
-0.1073490977,
-0.0828026012,
-0.4554583132,
0.4244098961,
0.3789621294,
-0.5217729211,
-0.1800731272,
0.011293564,
-0.0796083435,
0.2340332419,
0.090867117,
0.6367251873,
0.5287919044,
-0.5773949623,
0.7928848267,
0.111944817,
0.5688970089,
-0.4358878434,
0.0523518771,
-0.0231528915,
0.1243631169,
-0.1617942601,
-0.7749091387,
0.2266368121,
-0.1475065798,
0.1642757654,
-0.4176129699,
0.6500736475,
-0.4215557575,
0.0177223273,
0.2204024047,
0.7713364959,
0.1036177874,
-0.0399800614,
-0.7985171676,
0.1966451406,
-0.1093478128,
-0.2089182287,
0.2571265101,
0.7634422183,
0.4079543054,
0.7123817205,
0.3623217046,
0.1118271351,
0.0344685763,
0.0961353257,
0.6488795877,
-0.7183846235,
-0.5592415929,
-0.6342935562,
0.1549427509,
-0.2324461937,
-0.8383597732,
0.7640228271,
0.6435955167,
0.908370316,
-0.2374626994,
0.4956036508,
0.0774250403,
0.1272310615,
-0.7797347307,
0.5286170244,
-0.4544231296,
0.3929221034,
-0.0275727026,
-1.1866849661,
-0.2907039523,
0.8303983212,
-0.4015531242,
0.002369456,
0.948572278,
1.0036562681,
-0.4397755861,
0.1659305245,
0.3452702463,
0.1083514243,
-0.014895075,
0.430516392,
0.7038770914,
-0.6694427729,
0.5702934861,
0.1155192405,
-0.09404587,
-0.500477612,
-0.9345223904,
-0.4364698231,
-0.7847540379,
-0.4726483524,
-0.3455070853,
0.4545537531,
0.8388961554,
0.8388738632,
-0.5857591629,
-0.2258655429,
0.111684531,
0.1055041701,
-0.4781565666,
-0.243411988,
0.2339722514,
-0.5662212968,
-0.5279429555,
0.1198482215,
0.1409827024,
-0.076732181,
0.1213968024,
0.1792930067,
-0.3654047549,
0.1233075932,
0.4091919661,
-0.0453127623,
-0.6047493815,
-0.7021112442,
0.392278254,
-0.3988325,
0.10328722,
1.119068265,
-0.616327405,
0.2077029347,
0.3381061852,
0.8613542318,
0.2745038569,
0.1041460633,
0.7308661938,
-0.8810179234,
-0.0791784376,
0.2617435157,
0.3297885358,
0.2501558065,
-0.4198927581,
0.5676659346,
0.1608390063,
-0.7076964974,
-0.7004669905,
0.3315803111,
-1.1169612408,
-0.2948190272,
1.2257163525,
-0.4021704793,
0.0972422957,
-0.3660477102,
0.1208003014,
-0.0259514488,
-0.336481154,
0.9027186632,
0.9631006122,
-0.0359021127,
-0.1010608301,
-0.5656509995,
0.6908850074,
0.5096262693,
-0.3068567812,
-0.0849162489,
0.2433918715,
0.5612919927,
0.1838286668,
0.3024561703,
-0.2183596641,
0.142362684,
0.1794646084,
-0.5173326731,
-0.0516343713,
-0.2692311108,
-0.3762713969,
0.2469088882,
0.0070160897,
-0.3282629848
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12335v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12335v1 | Attention Score is not All You Need for Token Importance Indicator in KV Cache Reduction: Value Also Matters | 2024-06-18T07:01:11 | 2024-06-18T07:01:11 | Zhiyu Guo, Hidetaka Kamigaito, Taro Watanabe | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Scaling the context size of large language models (LLMs) enables them to
perform various new tasks, e.g., book summarization. However, the memory cost
of the Key and Value (KV) cache in attention significantly limits the practical
applications of LLMs. Recent works have explored token pruning for KV cache
reduction in LLMs, relying solely on attention scores as a token importance
indicator. However, our investigation into value vector norms revealed a
notably non-uniform pattern questioning their reliance only on attention
scores. Inspired by this, we propose a new method: Value-Aware Token Pruning
(VATP) which uses both attention scores and the $ \ell_{1} $ norm of value
vectors to evaluate token importance. Extensive experiments on LLaMA2-7B-chat
and Vicuna-v1.5-7B across 16 LongBench tasks demonstrate VATP's superior
performance. | [
-0.3455727398,
-0.4262008369,
0.3149113953,
0.4674053192,
-0.5425118804,
-0.2577678859,
-0.3174467385,
-0.2341472507,
0.3899787366,
0.289506793,
-0.2504985034,
-0.4575097561,
-0.4889894426,
-0.2721546888,
-0.3720709682,
0.8755144477,
0.1500388384,
-0.1209479496,
-0.4491453767,
-0.3182936609,
-0.8626782894,
-0.7644260526,
-0.6566689014,
0.0832982138,
0.6834090352,
0.3831779063,
-0.0740066841,
0.7871720791,
0.7418572307,
0.1810380816,
-0.4405861795,
0.1444507092,
-0.7874414325,
0.2261222154,
0.0473326817,
-0.7740526795,
-0.7230546474,
0.0842547715,
0.6844273806,
0.3317450285,
0.2833788097,
0.5406355262,
-0.2834648192,
0.7642068863,
-0.9979125261,
0.4268466234,
-0.6089348197,
-0.07258863,
-0.4425693154,
-0.3990012407,
-0.4742994905,
-0.0933035165,
-0.2825837433,
-0.2712970376,
0.1125480086,
0.0780437812,
0.9937288761,
0.5014290214,
-0.3292895854,
0.5343449712,
-0.6180406809,
1.0795073509,
-0.3700853884,
0.2087814957,
0.341753155,
0.1401454955,
-0.0239483509,
-0.6713274121,
-0.3828073144,
0.2396977246,
0.1738226265,
0.1718420535,
-0.1883448958,
0.3044845462,
0.1186788455,
0.4178863168,
0.0423108898,
0.0692882016,
-0.5576830506,
-0.3825255632,
0.1685824841,
0.3087690175,
-0.1009920463,
-0.2342432588,
-0.4269389808,
-0.2669950724,
-0.9083520174,
0.4666254222,
0.0285257138,
0.1637896299,
0.2146596014,
0.4189703763,
0.0759593397,
0.5607985258,
0.1188528985,
-0.2868685424,
0.0844653919,
-0.4141866267,
-0.3229032457,
0.0034312198,
0.4172531962,
0.7339585423,
0.3087091446,
-0.0809819624,
-0.0414788313,
0.1081470773,
0.4842424095,
-0.8891266584,
0.0395842642,
0.2830508947,
-0.674505949,
-0.3575720787,
-0.0752440542,
-0.5005675554,
0.0977732465,
-0.192068249,
0.198149085,
-0.0829216912,
-0.3203685582,
-0.2207033187,
-0.3624536693,
0.5070564151,
0.6066443324,
-0.8434377313,
0.3359076381,
0.8295248747,
0.8688783646,
-0.5273151994,
-0.1176869869,
-0.9132166505,
-0.0314308889,
-0.4443585575,
0.6743032932,
-0.5771951675,
-0.4648343027,
-0.3411503732,
-0.119667545,
0.0986547694,
-0.5908251405,
0.6315792203,
-0.5611014962,
-0.3898328245,
-0.7336357832,
-0.4771412611,
-0.1080797613,
0.32894364,
-0.8069456816,
1.3240778446,
0.3703765869,
-0.742554605,
0.6510968804,
-0.4613646269,
-0.5371644497,
-0.0168374553,
-0.007261225,
-0.4056608081,
0.4905439913,
0.1806592643,
0.4308322966,
-0.2969837189,
0.108045876,
-0.165210247,
-0.6674946547,
0.1361390203,
-0.6277302504,
0.3181600273,
-0.0451100357,
-0.3612500131,
0.2360155731,
-0.6543243527,
0.1543318778,
-0.1443612278,
-0.5725004673,
-0.4329462349,
-0.1934389174,
0.3314851522,
0.3157572448,
0.1984304339,
-0.3470053077,
0.2478093058,
-0.5134320855,
0.5907119513,
1.0693640709,
0.067395851,
0.3827556968,
-0.2630470395,
0.585046947,
0.12821199,
0.359038651,
0.0187464375,
-0.5581582785,
-1.2742438316,
-0.6654235721,
0.384916544,
0.0365611874,
-0.0245161764,
0.3426969945,
-0.5393148661,
-0.328850776,
-0.6992162466,
-0.0649417043,
0.467038691,
0.397916317,
0.4237644672,
-0.5804089904,
-0.5048440695,
-0.9395452738,
-0.2560070455,
-0.4251467288,
0.0958734751,
0.4946018159,
0.2336824089,
0.2105050683,
1.2716382742,
-0.2153222412,
-0.4284627736,
-0.090419054,
-0.1459833682,
0.0288270693,
0.2908605635,
0.5307403803,
-0.8005405664,
-0.3135170937,
-0.1946437061,
0.00111558,
-0.1102137715,
0.0163561366,
-0.0328780711,
0.2055522352,
0.6773722768,
-0.7044872046,
0.7652810812,
0.3532893956,
-0.1237094849,
0.4174309075,
-0.0882472545,
0.1563641429,
-0.6647455692,
0.3520139456,
-0.2676596045,
-0.4821904302,
-0.5321480632,
-0.2313820869,
0.3304572999,
0.171511963,
-0.7404364347,
0.9936441779,
-0.2752125561,
-0.2216261476,
-0.2824462354,
-0.0545819215,
0.2386048287,
0.7261850238,
-0.1841574162,
0.9273286462,
0.0871005431,
-0.8886387348,
-0.0394936502,
-0.0849013478,
-0.158842355,
0.3703881204,
-0.5208247304,
0.0025945955,
-0.060513895,
-0.0046233516,
-1.2520076036,
0.2867375314,
-0.0050731367,
-0.4765288532,
0.487827003,
-0.174033761,
-0.440813154,
-0.1419421285,
-0.5180226564,
0.7366927266,
0.5039363503,
-0.4637340903,
0.3553258777,
0.6401875615,
0.1112926453,
-0.5823129416,
-0.5511934757,
-0.0720976666,
-0.4426221251,
-0.2809768617,
0.4673272967,
0.0386122428,
-0.1690977514,
-0.1002979577,
-0.54044348,
-0.0096440474,
0.1874120384,
0.3876180947,
0.0581529774,
0.0046585575,
0.6252885461,
-0.0707247704,
-0.4412721992,
0.0281663109,
-0.2909040749,
0.489893496,
-0.1570458412,
-0.4414415956,
-0.2667668164,
0.201897487,
1.0569353104,
-0.4856828153,
0.7575861812,
0.6745066643,
-0.1743039638,
0.0523307212,
-0.7730528712,
-0.1432050616,
-0.4226229489,
0.3804830015,
-0.1020311266,
-1.1580406427,
0.541005671,
-0.0876244381,
0.0697725192,
0.6485080719,
0.8304821253,
0.2654320896,
0.8082304597,
0.6175073981,
-0.4912311733,
0.6562377214,
-0.018789988,
0.4796061814,
-1.0761173964,
-0.0042337435,
-0.5121998787,
-0.4812002182,
-0.4064092338,
-0.8037913442,
0.3990260959,
0.0135278683,
-0.0180159621,
-0.1277347505,
-0.8013178706,
0.5786668062,
0.4507128,
-0.109486714,
0.1566540003,
-0.0359355696,
0.1828356236,
-0.3045606911,
-0.7114768624,
-0.164675802,
1.2583860159,
0.2979812324,
0.2472196519,
-0.0285091177,
0.3697202802,
0.1656374335,
0.5102816224,
-1.0330561399,
0.4396706223,
0.2110304832,
-0.6143454909,
-0.5547927618,
-0.4562785625,
-0.9613693953,
0.3868716359,
0.2950509787,
-0.7215466499,
0.0138131212,
0.1448994577,
-0.3327123225,
0.0382986926,
-0.7443338037,
0.7175729275,
0.052392669,
-0.1644817591,
-0.4340648651,
-0.4533225894,
0.3049879372,
0.0361807756,
0.1580739617,
-0.2312100828,
-0.2777747512,
1.0245859623,
-0.5949484706,
0.9216344357,
-0.1280591488,
0.3306663036,
0.3123280704,
-0.1001569927,
0.6324886084,
0.1155845299,
0.1901440769,
0.0010653421,
-0.1561430246,
-0.4864270389,
-0.4930458665,
0.8717446923,
-0.6876885295,
-0.7598705888,
-0.1974389106,
-0.24399589,
0.0377763659,
0.1473318934,
0.037395481,
0.0629222021,
-0.0996341631,
0.2867974043,
0.7806817293,
0.1444727182,
0.46858266,
0.1193625778,
0.17798917,
-0.194639191,
0.8269608021,
0.3973617256,
0.3375235796,
0.6042630672,
0.1955980659,
-0.0957886577,
-0.4816603661,
0.178687349,
0.1514304429,
-1.021690011,
-0.3286655247,
-0.6691276431,
-0.200015381,
-0.284796983,
-0.1551952809,
-0.6874294877,
-0.5957899094,
-0.3919554949,
-0.2419237047,
0.8151919842,
0.1094332263,
0.1542530209,
0.2438449264,
-0.6691153646,
0.1675614715,
0.5159198046,
0.4200468063,
0.3432798982,
-0.4606095552,
-0.3090443611,
-0.4627468288,
-0.0326654576,
-0.5224303007,
0.6562171578,
0.0854974464,
0.4993079603,
0.4176693559,
0.0855173692,
0.9047899842,
-0.3127960861,
0.6607174873,
0.1503897458,
-1.1207664013,
0.3838666677,
-0.0985778347,
0.5047205091,
0.71745646,
-0.2721126378,
-0.7215000391,
-0.3369150162,
-0.881485641,
-1.2789736986,
0.6453143954,
0.3957995474,
0.075638786,
-0.3575562835,
0.5557137728,
-0.1757559776,
0.4265806079,
-0.5524427295,
-0.3499812782,
0.052044116,
-0.0488945246,
0.0824737251,
-0.4897589684,
0.0321874693,
-0.5400413275,
0.3044858575,
0.0359240659,
0.4138293862,
0.1822516024,
-0.058633402,
-0.0567304082,
0.1115723401,
0.4817547202,
0.5352699757,
-0.111790508,
0.0688325241,
0.3611945808,
-0.635633409,
-0.0604035668,
-0.6778324246,
0.1068653464,
0.1059773639,
0.2190396637,
0.7001791,
0.5420812368,
-0.5850965381,
0.8653535843,
-0.3642269373,
0.0832256898,
-0.1796835959,
0.0899672955,
0.1627099067,
-0.1711992323,
0.0227301307,
-0.0694355145,
-0.0490582846,
-0.2022587955,
-0.0223365817,
0.2733790278,
-0.7460303903,
-0.1378120035,
0.3620289266,
0.3386571109,
-0.2983858585,
0.6265898943,
0.0159351565,
-0.5016080737,
0.9466711879,
0.1475034803,
0.7569795251,
-0.1882382929,
-0.2576926351,
0.2834506333,
0.508228004,
-0.0338600874,
0.0804852024,
-0.4229110777,
-0.2238256633,
-0.6630249619,
-0.6778132319,
-0.283764571,
0.2644562423,
-0.6384331584,
0.3886770904,
-0.6236028075,
-0.3191067874,
-0.0512050129,
-0.0679321364,
-0.849488616,
0.1641605496,
-0.3761838973,
0.6877161264,
-0.6462580562,
0.8039788604,
0.3018418252,
-0.1896430552,
-0.6937334538,
-0.212236315,
-0.1172973812,
-0.7269640565,
0.8404052854,
0.4502959847,
0.0884662643,
0.0059815636,
-0.2479861826,
-1.0724177361,
1.0214920044,
0.3044504821,
-0.4885094762,
0.1007001325,
-0.1743865013,
0.4334654808,
-0.1825477928,
0.2384724021,
0.6537011266,
0.6850038171,
-0.0328543186,
-0.9413806796,
-0.039010074,
-0.3658109307,
0.0670743063,
0.6482340693,
-1.1920907497,
0.9139267206,
0.0890970826,
-0.2277126163,
-0.4369725883,
0.4334468842,
0.0732673407,
-0.14769876,
0.4143335223,
0.5530055165,
0.8143206835,
-0.0200216249,
0.8632771373,
-0.1858236194,
0.3048346937,
0.69642663,
0.0762186274,
0.7386023402,
1.0682184696,
-0.2642140687,
-0.1701359749,
0.6719697714,
0.1723185033,
0.5254745483,
0.3900288045,
-0.0304957349,
-0.5456287861,
-0.0459584594,
-0.2351342738,
0.5926204324,
0.5499374866,
-0.2926648855,
-0.0479587838,
-0.2698333859,
0.1370904148,
-0.5035424232,
-0.3971886635,
0.6062788367,
0.1707674414,
-0.7292513847,
0.6720927358,
0.1174253449,
0.307867676,
-0.4331344962,
-0.0594344474,
-0.0953689367,
0.3520071208,
0.1368388534,
-0.2627615333,
0.2231762558,
-0.0416214392,
-0.466293782,
-0.2122654468,
0.6277573109,
-0.0270884428,
-0.2682298124,
0.216975674,
0.342291683,
0.2150235325,
-0.2707763314,
-0.1759739518,
0.1065465361,
-0.2000944167,
-0.6133378148,
0.7704893947,
0.5141352415,
-0.4030993879,
0.7086923122,
0.7659444213,
0.2197539657,
-0.0454955846,
0.1451740563,
1.1653786898,
-0.68512851,
-0.6039369702,
-0.8921451569,
0.4499719441,
-0.1952612847,
-0.7088672519,
0.6856433153,
0.3865291476,
0.6478113532,
0.2475394458,
0.6989892721,
0.3810862899,
0.1003513411,
-0.3765689433,
0.6340336204,
-0.5918506384,
0.2181148231,
-0.1726808697,
-0.8133350611,
-0.4856852591,
0.5176926255,
-0.1462397724,
-0.0371954739,
0.8094853759,
0.5141326189,
0.1581408978,
-0.4670983255,
0.5016281605,
-0.0062029189,
0.5204690695,
0.5452975035,
0.2784757018,
-0.3273566663,
0.7187825441,
0.1263945848,
-0.3441970348,
-0.8186405301,
-0.9101534486,
-1.0689105988,
-0.5065143108,
-0.173419714,
-0.2090830058,
-0.082960017,
0.6312772632,
0.7781540751,
-0.5864112377,
0.1422212869,
-0.1333081424,
0.2200645506,
-0.4135199785,
-0.2288353592,
0.714174509,
-0.5515938401,
-0.4535918534,
0.0731840059,
0.8974872231,
-0.1818427891,
-0.3417060971,
0.1450771242,
0.0887672678,
0.2045370191,
0.507420063,
0.236007452,
-0.8178116679,
-0.5037038922,
0.1654324681,
-0.2684236765,
0.3640298843,
0.9459663033,
-0.8498554826,
0.6514396071,
0.5965656042,
0.5616225004,
0.7778427601,
-0.1942516118,
0.5323306322,
-1.0058743954,
0.4257515371,
0.4548712075,
0.3522133827,
0.1740946472,
-0.4516750574,
0.1562777311,
0.2985487282,
-0.527118504,
-0.8833136559,
0.1128700078,
-1.2082959414,
-0.082905598,
1.2360910177,
-0.0960558504,
-0.859847486,
-0.2838370502,
-0.2856033444,
0.2001625896,
-0.4880292118,
0.8778333068,
1.0390958786,
0.304212749,
-0.2471987009,
-0.3290756345,
0.6188079119,
0.6945204735,
-0.6181897521,
0.5315902233,
0.1358979195,
-0.0640333295,
0.1651882231,
0.9293128252,
-0.236612767,
0.5051520467,
-0.0389869735,
0.1669119895,
-0.1331826001,
-0.3711287677,
-0.2426154017,
0.3184975684,
0.4269117117,
-0.1775237769
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12331v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12331v1 | Retrieval Meets Reasoning: Dynamic In-Context Editing for Long-Text Understanding | 2024-06-18T06:54:28 | 2024-06-18T06:54:28 | Weizhi Fei, Xueyan Niu, Guoqing Xie, Yanhua Zhang, Bo Bai, Lei Deng, Wei Han | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Current Large Language Models (LLMs) face inherent limitations due to their
pre-defined context lengths, which impede their capacity for multi-hop
reasoning within extensive textual contexts. While existing techniques like
Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) have attempted to bridge this gap by
sourcing external information, they fall short when direct answers are not
readily available. We introduce a novel approach that re-imagines information
retrieval through dynamic in-context editing, inspired by recent breakthroughs
in knowledge editing. By treating lengthy contexts as malleable external
knowledge, our method interactively gathers and integrates relevant
information, thereby enabling LLMs to perform sophisticated reasoning steps.
Experimental results demonstrate that our method effectively empowers
context-limited LLMs, such as Llama2, to engage in multi-hop reasoning with
improved performance, which outperforms state-of-the-art context window
extrapolation methods and even compares favorably to more advanced commercial
long-context models. Our interactive method not only enhances reasoning
capabilities but also mitigates the associated training and computational
costs, making it a pragmatic solution for enhancing LLMs' reasoning within
expansive contexts. | [
-0.2453332841,
-1.0783647299,
1.3019160032,
0.0017572034,
-0.2829438448,
0.3596016467,
-0.5028567314,
-0.6582072973,
0.1430404633,
0.4639383256,
-0.49587816,
-0.1530811191,
-0.4095207155,
0.1114243567,
-0.2729533613,
0.6808590293,
-0.2969875634,
-0.4852571785,
-0.4397514462,
-0.253200382,
-0.6092425585,
-0.3276244104,
-0.4416755438,
-0.1718974859,
0.6530994177,
0.4237988591,
0.7592671514,
0.5614961386,
0.2113648355,
0.3439767957,
-0.6548627615,
0.7294726372,
-0.498118341,
0.6778903604,
-0.4232084751,
-0.3876200318,
-0.3689480722,
-0.249877587,
0.8763040304,
0.6074486971,
0.1217499673,
-0.0320225097,
-0.0511022136,
0.5978575349,
-0.5558988452,
-0.0841003507,
-0.955314219,
-0.1094426438,
-0.2417386919,
-0.5114130378,
-0.5288048983,
-0.1202475056,
0.1485582888,
-0.8679477572,
-0.3289791346,
-0.0218542125,
0.4327476025,
0.4936111569,
-0.8174964786,
-0.4942214191,
-0.5912304521,
0.6608371735,
-0.3930486739,
0.5215067863,
0.2288601249,
0.4296200573,
-0.513102293,
-1.0199350119,
-0.6485117078,
-0.24961555,
-0.1391546875,
-0.0949157551,
0.1220399067,
-0.1285116076,
0.3982642889,
-0.0135776708,
-0.0532908998,
-0.1998425126,
-0.1290789098,
0.1866285801,
0.4387114644,
-0.0175149385,
0.0997517034,
-0.1575736851,
-0.4801419377,
0.2042889297,
-0.8080663681,
0.075725697,
0.0186247583,
0.1458107382,
0.3165305853,
0.6521545053,
-0.1721673608,
0.7707963586,
0.1039562076,
-0.1586990058,
0.0489785634,
-0.2532964945,
-0.2461933941,
-0.0066014477,
0.2190060467,
0.1395920962,
-0.1009741277,
-0.259771198,
-0.2110466659,
-0.6084143519,
0.1953077167,
-0.620865047,
0.2973198593,
0.2865429819,
-0.2374330014,
-0.1981243789,
-0.1188935339,
-0.8428544402,
-0.5234488845,
-0.4500518739,
0.5022910833,
-0.4620460868,
0.0418419614,
0.0095601836,
-0.3032259345,
-0.0309879631,
0.8458964825,
-0.5400887728,
-0.1097640395,
0.6881875992,
0.7035452724,
-0.1753897667,
-0.1997129023,
-0.6575372815,
0.7083525062,
-0.2098020166,
0.7366541624,
-1.0093166828,
-0.3834773898,
-0.1063870564,
-0.0894149989,
0.2123842388,
-0.5464339852,
0.5533413291,
-1.0701663494,
0.1035939083,
-0.2705381811,
-0.5986028314,
-0.2221164852,
0.4250659049,
-0.576073885,
1.2174726725,
-0.0193526428,
-0.7895131111,
0.3377613127,
-0.7264704704,
-0.3716647625,
0.0066300677,
-0.1842134297,
0.0061693615,
0.0894886106,
0.2982089221,
0.2393175811,
-0.0670074075,
0.4622249305,
-0.2162512094,
-0.4370234907,
0.3935113847,
-0.4346479177,
0.4784531593,
0.1177985743,
-0.252625674,
0.2647341192,
-0.7606194019,
0.0299136825,
0.040919438,
-0.7437394261,
-0.5522530675,
0.2169825882,
-0.3039405048,
0.1787150055,
0.4574002326,
-0.298548162,
0.5949324369,
-0.2793968916,
0.4042315185,
0.7051472068,
0.0724117085,
0.574138701,
-0.1791358739,
0.3293581903,
-0.2664724588,
-0.0023824058,
-0.5184177756,
-0.2363542765,
-0.6691237688,
-0.2610311508,
-0.0364309065,
0.5223171115,
-0.9516486526,
0.1223007664,
-0.3616999686,
-0.2229512036,
-0.2596122026,
0.160310775,
0.0702843145,
0.641133666,
0.702943027,
0.2292219698,
-0.4658593833,
-0.5744369626,
-0.6056162715,
0.0324444063,
-0.0076657105,
0.5927351117,
0.3996779621,
-0.5629829764,
1.0638362169,
-0.4117115736,
0.0624853596,
-0.2906122804,
-0.0229807291,
0.2564382255,
0.3026382625,
0.1583858579,
-0.8902688622,
-0.3565596044,
0.0309691634,
-0.8005465269,
-0.1898054332,
-0.4415312707,
-0.4683413506,
0.0402541906,
0.8209688067,
-0.8177835941,
0.4150581658,
0.2022836357,
-0.3710592091,
0.57243222,
-0.2972501814,
0.1728530377,
-0.9555618167,
0.0854896009,
-0.4408731759,
-0.463524878,
-0.395506084,
0.3625050187,
0.1954187006,
-0.0379624851,
-0.2649110556,
0.9360994697,
-0.8050029278,
0.0188965946,
-0.4656575918,
0.5384826064,
0.2838123143,
0.2105471939,
-0.0315546617,
0.9330487847,
0.1126353145,
-0.5068628192,
0.3860714436,
0.308350414,
-0.5526986718,
0.314243257,
-0.331928879,
0.274351418,
-0.2608796358,
0.8207874298,
-0.6683940291,
-0.3479398787,
-0.0702721626,
-0.1277832836,
0.3879812062,
-0.2766239345,
-0.5993648767,
0.0170792136,
-0.2337063104,
0.7389817238,
0.1429369301,
-1.013815999,
0.8083919883,
0.3389545381,
-0.1579188854,
-0.7218292356,
-0.5032374859,
0.3813374341,
-0.4185899794,
-0.7319046855,
0.6859476566,
-0.0703558922,
-0.608047545,
-0.1404085904,
-0.0829986781,
-0.0942378938,
0.137221396,
-0.1187216043,
-0.0054649352,
0.0915845931,
0.4890147746,
0.5062974691,
0.0811159089,
-0.1441077143,
-0.0793854892,
0.2635403275,
0.0862690881,
-0.417425245,
-0.2513473928,
0.5621951818,
0.7297221422,
-0.3796950877,
0.5333763957,
0.216789633,
-0.3555564582,
-0.3820409179,
-0.6316745281,
-0.0560092367,
-0.5473054051,
0.2707380652,
-0.6296845078,
-1.128788352,
0.3874108791,
-0.5719641447,
0.1057195365,
0.130556047,
0.3705729544,
-0.1653776616,
0.8826467991,
0.5344715118,
0.5473909974,
0.5473069549,
0.0299514495,
0.1136602461,
-1.1695851088,
-0.4505072236,
-0.1038900241,
-0.3519820273,
-0.4104425907,
-0.9713740349,
0.6675117016,
0.4463278055,
-0.2906655669,
-0.0576020144,
-0.2818517685,
0.7208189964,
0.3258387744,
0.2692358494,
0.5165686011,
-0.252551347,
-0.2440426499,
0.0482347012,
-0.4333514869,
-0.5034029484,
0.7089468837,
0.3479555547,
0.6560468674,
0.5227131248,
0.4299763739,
0.0768913254,
0.2910823524,
-0.8736670613,
0.61644876,
0.2874648869,
-0.5558284521,
-0.4097323418,
-0.3811822832,
-0.8992149234,
0.448510617,
-0.2647810578,
-0.7882227302,
0.1126661375,
0.0848155096,
-0.3192455471,
0.4567364454,
-0.4467960894,
0.5615867972,
-0.4488472342,
-0.7911685705,
-0.4094605148,
-0.7005988359,
0.3932189941,
-0.283385843,
0.3935587704,
-0.0342476442,
-0.4571042657,
0.3781807423,
-0.3945581317,
0.5254712105,
-0.208125338,
-0.180799976,
0.3848882318,
0.381572336,
0.7969682217,
0.4300356805,
-0.420951277,
-0.4334834814,
-0.1081572101,
-0.1765961796,
-1.02272439,
0.7661907673,
-0.1777277589,
-0.9009827375,
-0.3587063551,
-0.8057484627,
-0.4783159494,
0.2097426802,
-0.3230362236,
0.4315169752,
0.0798291638,
0.3931373954,
0.6167039275,
-0.4754338264,
0.3881932199,
0.4114343524,
-0.4219045639,
-0.2924356759,
0.3446910977,
0.0708620772,
0.1288762093,
0.6746217012,
0.3023194969,
-0.3960025907,
-0.2944537699,
-0.5371252894,
0.2331748754,
-0.9289687872,
-0.1197069287,
-0.7750755548,
0.1778639704,
0.0289410688,
-0.3648528159,
-0.0618969835,
-0.4433574378,
-0.2336284667,
-0.1483825892,
0.475785017,
0.7126799226,
-0.0312040746,
0.2149696499,
-0.8432871699,
0.1762004048,
0.4107465148,
0.4023895264,
0.1792196631,
-0.6657047868,
-0.3035390973,
-0.2585961223,
-0.2719374299,
-1.130035162,
0.1807992011,
0.1331513375,
0.5681260824,
0.1573407799,
-0.0385195166,
0.9551810622,
-0.7954833508,
0.6956945658,
-0.2693274617,
-1.0433955193,
0.702398479,
-0.4653323293,
0.3949174285,
0.6430305839,
0.3029687405,
-0.5438399911,
-0.1506672949,
-0.3997964561,
-1.1795078516,
0.3881256878,
-0.0819500685,
0.193866685,
-0.1008762419,
0.6558546424,
0.1852378547,
0.1940279752,
-0.3833385706,
0.1243586913,
0.1419161856,
-0.0270916801,
0.1875805557,
-0.5482631326,
-0.0997888744,
-0.5454721451,
0.6339609027,
-0.2445376217,
0.1877265722,
0.3193869591,
-0.3048442006,
0.0990265235,
0.4280455112,
0.5447152257,
1.0922945738,
-0.2296081036,
0.3184704185,
0.5876879692,
-0.0553451851,
-0.0278161857,
0.0822185278,
0.0367591865,
-0.0208973996,
0.3496303856,
0.7519356608,
0.5301744342,
-1.0290323496,
0.3959378898,
0.0064484091,
0.2701592147,
-0.4398167729,
-0.0456960648,
0.1763050854,
0.6398246288,
0.5761821866,
-0.1965160519,
0.0717505291,
-0.7138547301,
0.4298240542,
0.4091093838,
-0.1053863838,
0.0255988538,
0.7362864614,
0.1879555732,
-0.2915107012,
0.4824165702,
-0.0751213506,
-0.5056657195,
0.3150340319,
0.5469761491,
0.5473461151,
0.1240675151,
-0.1505727768,
0.2300079912,
0.0096896617,
-0.0247628558,
0.1013113633,
-0.4169135392,
-0.4879733324,
-0.8239054084,
-0.480537504,
-0.6108515263,
0.1677161455,
-0.3715196252,
0.25059852,
-0.2612875104,
-0.1079622954,
-0.2331831753,
0.0067797201,
-0.3106853664,
0.1455708742,
-0.0175788663,
1.3144283295,
-0.129886657,
0.8990688324,
0.6658889055,
-0.1486761719,
-0.5458682179,
0.3369850516,
-0.0122916801,
-0.4814867675,
0.6522231698,
0.389475286,
-0.2872096598,
-0.0532578528,
-0.5684626698,
-1.0768574476,
1.2232162952,
0.3763455451,
-0.4831149578,
-0.111682117,
-0.2628933787,
0.4645421505,
-0.0723660737,
0.3407412767,
0.611553371,
0.658385098,
0.2364415824,
-0.7984119654,
0.0903643593,
-0.1653104872,
-0.2519006133,
0.2378313094,
-0.6431994438,
0.6199165583,
-0.3192440271,
-0.1956367791,
0.1387874633,
0.7885316014,
0.4664369524,
0.3040058613,
0.5433444977,
0.4492304027,
1.017898798,
0.1401549727,
0.9971807599,
-0.3242630959,
0.1078407168,
1.4041455984,
-0.2053128928,
0.9570931792,
0.7122492194,
0.1162048057,
0.7087623477,
0.4305633008,
0.5731811523,
0.3715173006,
0.0811720043,
-0.6977382302,
-0.3582532108,
-0.0356089585,
-0.1609735787,
0.544303,
0.5292279124,
-0.2298979312,
-0.1399373114,
-0.0504900217,
0.2761795819,
0.3161197901,
-0.2219825834,
0.7086051106,
0.0268301666,
-0.8056128025,
0.4599716067,
0.169458285,
0.6776551604,
-0.4663981199,
-0.2229457647,
-0.0713687837,
0.0687352046,
-0.067076318,
-1.2390304804,
0.5187780261,
0.2097490728,
-0.1257418692,
-0.4487944543,
0.7781972289,
-0.5181738138,
-0.2503536344,
0.4893851876,
0.5691529512,
0.062064033,
-0.1086565107,
-0.4742682278,
0.1939106137,
-0.0917604864,
-0.5425972342,
0.290823549,
0.8264304996,
-0.2101114243,
0.7869166136,
0.632075727,
-0.0842795148,
-0.0431592688,
-0.1076354012,
1.0601035357,
-0.7027606368,
-0.4522179365,
-0.7513326406,
0.6360969543,
-0.3418371677,
-0.144957602,
0.4396197498,
0.5193058848,
0.7137711644,
0.2879391611,
0.7502631545,
0.0337044485,
0.6468344331,
-0.5819085836,
0.5333101749,
-0.9163129926,
0.3675828278,
-0.0403004549,
-0.7109460235,
-0.3019947708,
0.5637885332,
-0.4421574473,
-0.0307487827,
0.553583324,
0.5367719531,
-0.22970061,
-0.1484424472,
0.1054959595,
0.3603260219,
0.5556179881,
0.43975842,
1.0210874081,
-0.0225468259,
0.5288950801,
-0.0677475259,
-0.3028496504,
-0.142914474,
-1.1605417728,
-0.6420857906,
-0.4979149103,
0.2056137472,
-0.2100097239,
0.1715323329,
1.0003999472,
0.3474835753,
-0.1895501316,
0.0133685051,
0.1824756861,
0.3337692022,
0.0777301416,
-0.2446276993,
0.4358169734,
-0.4617758393,
-0.7739080191,
1.1268520355,
0.3381907046,
-0.2314423919,
-0.0372952931,
0.1056894064,
-0.4569830596,
0.3689470291,
1.0870205164,
0.192842558,
-0.6882768273,
-0.5734921694,
-0.2394184917,
0.0268475004,
0.079653196,
0.7012629509,
-1.1049348116,
0.6294922829,
0.7287530899,
0.9766403437,
0.5498071313,
0.3771750331,
0.3724144101,
-0.7449778914,
0.2205449492,
0.2393679917,
0.3407878578,
0.320856452,
-0.4640266299,
0.3474344909,
0.1486634463,
-0.6624862552,
-0.9029518962,
0.4339785576,
-1.0435955524,
-0.6049610972,
1.4318174124,
0.0081022391,
-0.0563948825,
-0.0794892386,
-0.4610033035,
0.3125497997,
-0.2267112136,
0.7124094367,
0.4800698459,
-0.368609339,
-0.065753527,
-0.6027062535,
0.4993622899,
0.3748604357,
-0.9619409442,
0.1628419161,
0.6679316759,
0.1259469092,
0.0087670702,
0.4813065231,
-0.0066672503,
0.0022472898,
-0.4148666859,
-0.4920262694,
-0.2459340841,
-0.5960787535,
-0.0607727915,
0.1968952417,
-0.0043846108,
0.3652139902
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12329v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12329v1 | SNAP: Unlearning Selective Knowledge in Large Language Models with Negative Instructions | 2024-06-18T06:54:05 | 2024-06-18T06:54:05 | Minseok Choi, Daniel Rim, Dohyun Lee, Jaegul Choo | cs.CL | cs.CL | Instruction-following large language models (LLMs), such as ChatGPT, have
become increasingly popular with the general audience, many of whom are
incorporating them into their daily routines. However, these LLMs inadvertently
disclose personal or copyrighted information, which calls for a machine
unlearning method to remove selective knowledge. Previous attempts sought to
forget the link between the target information and its associated entities, but
it rather led to generating undesirable responses about the target,
compromising the end-user experience. In this work, we propose SNAP, an
innovative framework designed to selectively unlearn information by 1) training
an LLM with negative instructions to generate obliterated responses, 2)
augmenting hard positives to retain the original LLM performance, and 3)
applying the novel Wasserstein regularization to ensure adequate deviation from
the initial weights of the LLM. We evaluate our framework on various NLP
benchmarks and demonstrate that our approach retains the original LLM
capabilities, while successfully unlearning the specified information. | [
-0.2803471386,
-0.7838842869,
0.2963812351,
-0.1327487677,
-0.5333205462,
0.2623670697,
-0.5126861334,
-0.1286895871,
0.2489773482,
0.8066241741,
-0.6043202877,
-0.5135880113,
-0.5683564544,
-0.2881462574,
-0.6513841748,
1.1917709112,
0.23145248,
0.0488984063,
-0.1066381857,
-0.0069810492,
-0.2480189651,
-0.5201558471,
-0.2860171795,
-0.5593582988,
0.4491140544,
0.6668794751,
0.5972191691,
0.4739508033,
0.2026971281,
0.2120117247,
-0.1682578325,
0.2105626017,
-0.9131674767,
0.145753473,
-0.2861331999,
-0.385353893,
-0.1479655057,
0.0514569655,
0.6887250543,
0.7872030139,
-0.2105124295,
0.2493361086,
0.4297960401,
0.712585032,
-0.8745813966,
0.1539489627,
-0.8459573984,
0.100554958,
-0.0463105962,
-0.2771413624,
-0.7588874102,
-0.217367813,
0.0813620612,
-0.3464193344,
0.2436549366,
-0.2492442429,
0.7472461462,
0.2242433131,
-0.177428633,
-0.2792099118,
-0.8159478307,
0.7893432379,
-0.6359468699,
0.3177531362,
0.4738526046,
0.2464699745,
-0.2916588485,
-0.2465064973,
-0.2269085199,
-0.0401221067,
0.1110313535,
0.2135423869,
-0.1536785364,
0.0204840247,
0.161399141,
0.1888675541,
-0.477506876,
0.400652349,
-0.4747705162,
-0.1730661094,
0.5872891545,
-0.1149851009,
0.243654117,
-0.0825150833,
-0.5428872705,
0.1045517251,
-0.8670433164,
-0.1850167364,
0.3372929692,
0.4635815024,
0.0462617613,
0.9342808723,
-0.1913259029,
0.3390523493,
0.0924557894,
0.0947094634,
0.3732733428,
0.1891440004,
-0.0558579527,
0.1006882787,
0.7228397727,
0.1807684302,
0.2373055071,
-0.4603690207,
-0.370025754,
-0.0617615916,
0.1124756336,
-0.6448658109,
-0.0283532478,
0.020677371,
-0.2903861105,
-0.1511767805,
-0.0903740749,
-0.5856497288,
-0.5823446512,
-0.2510138154,
0.4973411858,
-0.6198506355,
-0.0964275002,
0.1605401784,
-0.2124326676,
0.3425277174,
0.4573031962,
-0.9038632512,
0.2732652128,
0.7576459646,
0.5711318254,
-0.1293815076,
-0.3901950717,
-0.75543046,
0.1317165494,
-0.1366806626,
0.5438193679,
-0.6849192977,
-0.343841821,
-0.0819467604,
-0.1966020018,
-0.0304416008,
-0.5872645974,
0.2076591253,
-0.790568471,
0.246048227,
-0.1683040559,
-0.7946465015,
-0.3719248176,
0.4273858666,
-0.4195642173,
0.698615253,
0.159204036,
-0.5768154263,
0.1812448353,
-0.3925945759,
-0.3981274664,
0.1556733847,
-0.2016307861,
-0.3938806653,
0.0859430209,
0.2280145288,
0.4417423308,
-0.3005812168,
0.21725972,
-0.4347432554,
-0.6888167858,
0.1166099533,
-0.7048053145,
0.7982134819,
-0.0065616453,
-0.2445825636,
0.0621241704,
-0.7499858141,
-0.0608896837,
0.2146080881,
-0.6688399315,
-0.3219421804,
-0.0815459564,
-0.3820091486,
0.0445398577,
0.2441308945,
-0.6454132199,
0.3119747341,
-0.4383847415,
0.3290965855,
0.8872180581,
0.0774102882,
0.5719814897,
-0.2727530003,
0.5241000652,
0.1332736015,
0.0855406746,
-0.3752309382,
-0.4191685617,
-0.832703948,
-0.259472549,
0.1861502975,
0.5901056528,
-0.7909885645,
0.3350928128,
-0.1504256874,
-0.4115572274,
-0.5975267291,
0.4902981222,
0.5072262287,
0.6226961613,
0.5581706166,
-0.2007296234,
-0.6161196232,
-0.659288764,
-0.3681838214,
0.0234635621,
-0.2899439931,
0.2467063069,
0.314175874,
-0.4506346285,
0.8212245703,
-0.4990166128,
-0.356801033,
-0.4535945654,
0.1036326215,
0.3180474937,
0.2463748306,
0.0480258055,
-0.6360374689,
-0.2148108035,
-0.2416874617,
-0.5098506212,
0.0507724062,
-0.0924522057,
0.050890144,
0.1099188775,
0.4239297807,
-0.7077543736,
0.4931277633,
0.4323246181,
-0.1025520042,
0.7607575655,
-0.1826711893,
0.029718861,
-1.1559833288,
-0.0535671748,
-0.1678338796,
-0.1885662228,
-0.3754549921,
-0.039737381,
0.0609495565,
-0.2843410373,
-0.6888456941,
0.6022738218,
-0.6577238441,
0.0099930298,
-0.3262954652,
0.2839470208,
0.042800609,
0.7372522354,
-0.0019847401,
0.6432987452,
0.2897439599,
-0.6023675203,
0.1502119452,
0.4480882585,
-0.2450894564,
0.014987818,
-0.3759511113,
0.2653298378,
-0.3744873405,
0.0674692392,
-0.8682592511,
-0.2833316326,
0.1918413192,
-0.529068172,
0.3621606529,
-0.4987688065,
-0.3703278005,
-0.2397095114,
-0.4653212726,
0.2747327089,
0.8129253983,
-0.7125861645,
0.5103853345,
0.4691610634,
0.1683804244,
-0.7105453014,
-0.6974512339,
0.0731716454,
-0.0955613479,
-0.2647945285,
0.3214645386,
0.0439679287,
0.0667464137,
0.0146944812,
0.0799045712,
-0.1780960113,
0.0137796933,
0.2335588187,
0.1975494772,
-0.2054988295,
0.2626236677,
0.083924517,
-0.1894062161,
-0.1394428462,
-0.1721513867,
0.8116220236,
-0.0601024479,
-0.6959921122,
-0.3640919328,
0.1930772662,
0.5203381777,
-0.2821471095,
0.7566609979,
0.5614981055,
-0.3522893488,
-0.362866044,
-0.4434241354,
-0.3568367064,
-0.4977051318,
0.3643262386,
0.0627586916,
-1.0230424404,
0.4688272178,
-0.2490989566,
0.2290765792,
-0.1175994575,
0.4548288882,
-0.0335679799,
0.9906305671,
0.6232352257,
-0.2524174452,
0.5944346786,
-0.2097135633,
0.2533419132,
-0.96739012,
-0.05236068,
-0.2526571155,
-0.3603742123,
-0.3139370084,
-0.3870858252,
0.2157921791,
0.3071050346,
-0.3388688266,
0.3690147996,
-0.2762864828,
0.8331095576,
0.7170932293,
0.4826587737,
0.2242702246,
-0.1849403679,
-0.1258894652,
0.2828338742,
-0.679140985,
-0.4484484792,
1.0384830236,
0.2688657641,
1.0965197086,
0.0400717705,
1.0546858311,
0.2336188555,
0.303835541,
-0.9571983218,
0.7077652812,
-0.3664268851,
-0.3560087681,
-0.4123452902,
-0.5350511074,
-0.8278298378,
0.2976101637,
-0.1611064523,
-0.9956306219,
-0.2547357082,
0.4752182364,
-0.3623820543,
0.4834157526,
-0.9934027195,
0.5535649061,
-0.0771561339,
-0.3761261106,
-0.0322705023,
-0.4826930165,
0.4501822293,
-0.093478106,
0.0418844968,
-0.1595442891,
-0.0038903807,
0.5832681656,
-0.3097219765,
1.3461247683,
-0.1912849396,
0.1292667538,
0.3439518809,
0.3219434023,
0.7237909436,
-0.0285307411,
-0.158821255,
0.1015168205,
-0.3699080944,
-0.3311909437,
-0.7007989883,
0.3794163465,
-0.6481242776,
-0.7338081598,
0.2037253678,
-0.4252919853,
-0.2843205333,
0.4701662064,
0.3697524369,
0.3048169911,
-0.1749171764,
0.1550260186,
0.6965783834,
-0.3170711994,
0.3471159637,
0.6450044513,
-0.1492429674,
-0.3404170275,
0.9945309758,
0.1792429239,
0.162464112,
0.602894783,
0.3856435418,
-0.2862675786,
-0.5361661315,
-0.3151691258,
0.2959294617,
-0.7727562785,
-0.2865515053,
-0.4552963972,
-0.4295175374,
-0.3085308671,
-0.235677883,
-0.6664081812,
-0.3689125478,
-0.6880607009,
-0.0206977986,
0.095266372,
0.5500586033,
0.1176573113,
0.3464630246,
-1.1511667967,
0.1375002414,
0.0505579226,
0.4220709801,
0.1593978852,
-0.7406240106,
-0.1353942305,
0.3427123129,
-0.2923044562,
-0.6712303758,
0.3795930147,
0.1268399358,
0.4505583942,
0.6144574881,
0.4275679588,
0.538053453,
-0.5935714841,
0.6173701882,
0.3309173584,
-0.8477171063,
0.484870702,
-0.3546807766,
0.6360512972,
0.4651328027,
0.3786950111,
-0.7084671259,
-0.4877192974,
-0.5196582675,
-1.0417573452,
0.639294982,
-0.2603760362,
0.4139487743,
-0.0893113315,
0.3296158314,
0.3854126334,
0.2808707058,
-0.5707900524,
0.1370926946,
0.0918203443,
-0.1713103801,
-0.0853733122,
-0.4937892854,
0.0816632137,
-0.022293644,
0.8428314328,
-0.0779307187,
0.0371639952,
-0.2161130011,
-0.480968833,
0.0522460043,
0.441821754,
0.3846077919,
0.4375892878,
-0.0490916185,
0.2779091299,
0.1341931522,
-0.5217202902,
0.0712312758,
-0.2877109945,
-0.5079905391,
-0.3856988251,
0.3967950046,
0.5604801178,
0.5065892935,
-0.7724140882,
0.6171761751,
0.0844789743,
-0.0669810399,
-0.2270583808,
0.3501853049,
0.0900212154,
0.2257004231,
0.2048212737,
0.1009754315,
0.0519225076,
-0.2968455553,
0.5033424497,
0.4210193157,
-0.5243907571,
-0.4893579185,
0.3638073802,
0.2331951708,
-0.3863677382,
0.8478417397,
-0.2547820508,
-0.6935341358,
0.2609829307,
0.6896079183,
0.9309036732,
-0.164580211,
0.4172502458,
0.168512553,
0.2566437125,
-0.069372654,
0.1014611274,
-0.1960006505,
-1.0025677681,
-0.442886889,
-0.4386107028,
-0.4329345226,
0.3799442351,
-0.6935560107,
0.4514580071,
-0.5993707776,
-0.0356906727,
-0.1865362078,
-0.3196484447,
-0.5273303986,
-0.1799216866,
0.1186971739,
0.8087715507,
-0.712392807,
0.5558989048,
0.5161122084,
-0.4331900477,
-0.690675199,
0.0709305778,
0.3240225017,
-1.0746482611,
0.2315251678,
0.3023867011,
-0.2508511841,
-0.0299499352,
-0.5823758245,
-0.8298456073,
0.6619238257,
0.7081539035,
-0.5566651821,
-0.0274901725,
0.125750348,
0.238936916,
-0.081208095,
0.185546115,
0.3383021355,
-0.0428070873,
0.2794148028,
-0.5708830953,
0.0130021293,
-0.1946047544,
-0.3117057681,
0.321205914,
-0.6904485822,
0.6506428123,
-0.6711602211,
-0.4074578285,
-0.1443877071,
0.3660900593,
0.0768139213,
0.0275923479,
0.3166708946,
0.4306746721,
0.9226612449,
0.2307521552,
0.5564547777,
-0.0348056704,
0.422824353,
1.5558092594,
-0.3104309142,
0.9373707175,
0.5302166343,
0.2077041268,
0.0018510901,
0.4798414111,
0.0434157625,
0.4925912619,
0.2403691113,
-0.288697958,
-0.2888955176,
-0.0950168744,
-0.0173284877,
0.8436896801,
0.2924196422,
-0.3549510539,
-0.6761730313,
0.1645634174,
0.0906298682,
-0.0272096153,
-0.183237657,
0.9016030431,
0.0531238727,
-0.4499029219,
0.7919012904,
-0.1209452227,
0.5695392489,
-0.5335769057,
-0.2887617052,
-0.1739415228,
0.3192003369,
-0.2499546707,
-0.6938513517,
0.1067000926,
0.052001223,
-0.3434755504,
-0.2532216311,
0.7686875463,
-0.5722328424,
-0.0939028338,
0.4011087716,
0.4378196597,
0.1997619122,
-0.0742616579,
-0.7317061424,
0.0274687652,
0.2267363816,
-0.4404445589,
0.4330452979,
0.3318061829,
0.00278119,
0.9917291999,
0.5899666548,
-0.0425359979,
-0.1321553588,
0.3265930712,
1.2166231871,
-0.6117398739,
-0.4462302923,
-0.9703251123,
0.385658592,
0.0709601045,
-0.2062599212,
0.731751442,
0.6686123013,
0.900637269,
0.0156952441,
0.8096274137,
0.3549377322,
0.6504608393,
-0.6105720997,
0.8572511077,
-0.2966201007,
0.6644628048,
-0.2356489748,
-0.88221699,
-0.3189977109,
0.0413304418,
-0.4565145075,
0.0360208601,
0.2268147916,
0.8076518774,
-0.1892396957,
0.1792004108,
0.5427747965,
0.1867665648,
0.3787724972,
0.4607578814,
0.9483556151,
-0.0926800743,
0.6103803515,
-0.1951913536,
-0.4444473684,
-0.362947613,
-0.781203866,
-1.0055155754,
-0.3928689063,
-0.1527422071,
-0.1472467035,
0.1266392469,
1.1444326639,
0.5659783483,
-0.697471261,
-0.0862836093,
0.0424726978,
0.4020789862,
-0.0351495072,
-0.1922498792,
0.3621346653,
-0.3748133481,
-0.3620532453,
0.5466349721,
0.3431073129,
0.22755301,
-0.1326050311,
-0.0367641114,
-0.0459889621,
0.0045650089,
0.6954103112,
0.3885755539,
-0.4553221464,
-0.3597975373,
-0.0128856385,
0.1317495704,
0.0841760188,
0.7414046526,
-0.7560746074,
0.3751657903,
0.3914228976,
0.874104619,
0.3727977872,
0.0838055834,
0.4973304868,
-0.9597616196,
0.1307567954,
0.5185908675,
0.3104555905,
0.3018724918,
-0.5015306473,
0.1789145023,
-0.0064865951,
-0.2867070138,
-0.8370292187,
0.2262230217,
-0.5808093548,
-0.4883741736,
1.3014690876,
-0.1896979511,
-0.5116405487,
-0.0620957725,
-0.1185426712,
0.2114435881,
-0.557357192,
0.8764742613,
0.4215445518,
-0.1764636785,
-0.2669122815,
-0.1280782074,
0.1452353746,
0.0929134861,
-0.4140944183,
0.4669614434,
0.4156527221,
0.3223167658,
-0.0164838284,
0.6827697754,
-0.1999403983,
0.2402988821,
-0.0762018785,
0.1937484443,
-0.2780030072,
-0.4522123933,
-0.2556824088,
0.0982789248,
-0.0004270802,
-0.3398737311
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12321v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12321v1 | Automatic benchmarking of large multimodal models via iterative experiment programming | 2024-06-18T06:43:46 | 2024-06-18T06:43:46 | Alessandro Conti, Enrico Fini, Paolo Rota, Yiming Wang, Massimiliano Mancini, Elisa Ricci | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV | Assessing the capabilities of large multimodal models (LMMs) often requires
the creation of ad-hoc evaluations. Currently, building new benchmarks requires
tremendous amounts of manual work for each specific analysis. This makes the
evaluation process tedious and costly. In this paper, we present APEx,
Automatic Programming of Experiments, the first framework for automatic
benchmarking of LMMs. Given a research question expressed in natural language,
APEx leverages a large language model (LLM) and a library of pre-specified
tools to generate a set of experiments for the model at hand, and progressively
compile a scientific report. The report drives the testing procedure: based on
the current status of the investigation, APEx chooses which experiments to
perform and whether the results are sufficient to draw conclusions. Finally,
the LLM refines the report, presenting the results to the user in natural
language. Thanks to its modularity, our framework is flexible and extensible as
new tools become available. Empirically, APEx reproduces the findings of
existing studies while allowing for arbitrary analyses and hypothesis testing. | [
-0.3893199861,
-0.7148860097,
0.5595629215,
0.3391296268,
0.049056448,
-0.0558034778,
-0.4709773362,
-0.3317263424,
-0.1234175712,
0.1133558825,
-0.4259548485,
-0.5421605706,
-0.4656432271,
0.4354887903,
-0.5136653781,
0.438234359,
-0.2845824659,
0.166915834,
-0.5440196395,
-0.2697064877,
-0.1594670117,
-0.1344378889,
-0.4131453037,
-0.2069283575,
0.2984364927,
0.2571710348,
0.6058285236,
0.6790422201,
0.5937330723,
0.4161194265,
0.3742285371,
0.2437361032,
-0.382811904,
0.1062569022,
-0.2050766647,
-0.1738791168,
-0.2437478602,
-0.0261347368,
0.8264078498,
0.7618787289,
-0.0097465469,
0.3744010925,
-0.0071522733,
0.239863351,
-0.9077643156,
0.4611813724,
-0.5202980638,
0.0192537084,
0.1196769774,
-0.2192573994,
-0.3999015689,
-0.5150330663,
-0.2299078852,
-0.5793996453,
-0.042530071,
0.1732949018,
0.5383521318,
0.3507980704,
-0.6067917943,
-0.2346155792,
-0.6850119829,
1.0578939915,
-0.868273437,
0.4237545729,
0.3657939732,
0.4696255028,
-0.069987312,
-0.7298886776,
-0.5873405933,
-0.7526230812,
-0.0582350045,
-0.1207642183,
-0.3497826457,
-0.1925781369,
0.1570539325,
0.3125043213,
-0.7008336186,
0.0949951932,
-0.3776355088,
-0.1275904775,
0.9514586926,
0.4704621434,
0.0907682776,
-0.0134687014,
-0.2219498158,
-0.4775225818,
-0.4744074345,
-0.0608727895,
0.0953484252,
0.5198560357,
0.1565355211,
0.6901385784,
-0.473777324,
0.7582481503,
-0.3970198929,
-0.1057252213,
0.467988193,
-0.4481597841,
-0.2605701089,
-0.0998106673,
0.9071015716,
0.5979130268,
0.0495516732,
-0.1421093643,
-0.3468276858,
0.3384994864,
0.284499377,
-0.8194596171,
-0.2160524577,
0.2992430925,
-0.1930132061,
-0.1528407633,
-0.2678660452,
-0.7046543956,
-0.2262342274,
-0.4973835051,
0.8158778548,
-0.4581699073,
-0.3275950849,
-0.0053981058,
-0.0036493288,
-0.2961419225,
0.2144308239,
-0.5916830897,
0.5798461437,
0.4986586571,
0.8116958737,
-0.4260362983,
-0.4616698027,
-0.7759233713,
0.0435174257,
-0.4694240391,
0.9889125228,
-0.757309556,
-0.6526835561,
-0.0185601749,
-0.1097801179,
-0.1166567877,
-0.5438646078,
0.3192470372,
-0.246672973,
-0.0426196568,
-0.0805065408,
-0.6899486184,
0.0363427512,
0.4360814095,
-0.5419211388,
1.3906172514,
0.2072381526,
-0.3762592971,
0.4509835839,
-0.7221350074,
-0.1788052768,
-0.0135643929,
-0.5170938373,
-0.3291938603,
-0.027225595,
0.1789356321,
0.2470027804,
-0.5423436165,
0.1741017252,
-0.501560092,
-0.1353393793,
0.0673007667,
-0.0669015497,
0.4541947842,
0.3014957011,
-0.3852147162,
0.5780134201,
-0.8528584242,
0.4564329386,
0.0897525549,
-0.3021936715,
-0.2546388507,
0.1080257595,
0.2500536442,
-0.0145280939,
0.0368505307,
-0.5657086968,
0.5690248609,
0.004349079,
0.418672204,
0.7237848639,
-0.2617473602,
0.3795086145,
-0.3296351433,
0.4758944511,
-0.4282702506,
0.2940849364,
-0.3448285758,
-0.1519763172,
-0.4374260902,
-0.337202549,
0.3022300005,
0.310402751,
-0.5203222036,
0.1666441113,
-0.1874164492,
-0.6041001678,
-0.2696288228,
0.2842090428,
0.3151116073,
0.3225949109,
0.3238518834,
-0.2513155341,
-0.4747653306,
-1.3019659519,
-0.1393500566,
-0.1343949735,
-0.1202190742,
0.3309156895,
0.751518786,
-0.164628759,
1.0777695179,
-0.714643836,
-0.3517121673,
-0.0452947319,
0.714048624,
-0.0680213794,
0.412725091,
0.5352194905,
-0.7509491444,
-0.3807807565,
-0.2213073671,
-0.8092759848,
-0.3868784606,
0.054652486,
0.0078547169,
-0.244115144,
0.6898491979,
-0.2357993424,
0.220622316,
0.6002142429,
0.011034512,
0.8598574996,
-0.195486784,
0.2872126997,
-0.688904345,
0.311753422,
-0.0064708809,
-0.191759035,
-0.0928416401,
0.1817938685,
0.2638086975,
-0.1863320172,
-0.3291222453,
0.8455537558,
-0.5918198824,
-0.2421732396,
-0.3068293333,
-0.1564344913,
-0.0632488057,
0.350782752,
0.0477368198,
0.8579770327,
0.5675075054,
-0.7081757188,
0.4286387563,
0.1716470271,
-0.4736778438,
0.4964328706,
-0.7365211248,
0.0920199379,
0.0679690987,
0.1246443167,
-0.8845521212,
-0.1500287503,
-0.1890558749,
-0.3035775423,
-0.0263285358,
-0.1355825365,
-0.6239991784,
-0.341180414,
-0.4705005884,
0.2990612686,
0.300701499,
-0.2127536535,
0.9063503742,
0.3633467853,
-0.2310980409,
-0.3212977946,
-0.2425229698,
0.2080783248,
0.1528490931,
-0.6050781608,
0.3417896628,
-0.5245020986,
-0.6149355173,
0.1584987491,
-0.0169831812,
-0.1528253257,
0.0422456451,
0.35830459,
0.023169456,
-0.2056420147,
0.179122746,
-0.2038702816,
-0.0798037723,
0.0961546525,
0.0907463506,
0.5076059103,
-0.2922640145,
-0.6345047951,
-0.1194509938,
0.527359724,
0.4252769351,
-0.4130287766,
0.1953838468,
0.395293355,
-0.3465008438,
-0.5575646758,
-0.393460393,
-0.1296248436,
-0.5189515948,
0.3255432546,
-0.32994923,
-0.5137495399,
0.1693489254,
-0.4367555082,
0.3063208163,
0.2974376976,
0.7056832314,
0.3531623483,
1.4086511135,
0.8548849225,
0.2329918593,
0.4204516113,
-0.2142338306,
-0.2356986851,
-0.672070384,
-0.0233135428,
-0.529617846,
-0.1919288635,
-0.0252692923,
-0.4158183634,
0.8327008486,
-0.2491293252,
-0.1493307948,
0.3302551508,
-0.4396515489,
0.4987205863,
0.5700390339,
-0.2127952576,
0.5486539602,
-0.4283570945,
-0.209942475,
0.1245169863,
-0.4723987877,
-0.5299932957,
1.2933667898,
-0.1445024759,
0.895676434,
-0.0883484781,
0.4513030648,
0.5668330789,
0.7171594501,
-0.6483286619,
0.6381406188,
0.2792904079,
-0.5315791368,
-0.2043529898,
-0.4709072411,
-0.8262041807,
0.3507758379,
-0.2755176425,
-0.6982908249,
0.0445757546,
0.2954814136,
-0.4520176351,
0.0629442781,
-0.7016776204,
0.9509888887,
-0.4023828804,
-0.6845078468,
-0.2821362317,
-0.2317316085,
0.2449939847,
-0.0509134866,
0.3091456294,
-0.2807028592,
0.1401181668,
0.6282923222,
-0.2163231522,
0.5423589945,
-0.1171187088,
-0.1120757759,
0.0318557359,
0.4195141494,
0.4421479702,
0.1864313781,
-0.2887176573,
-0.1184125021,
0.1918794811,
-0.2620411813,
-0.3975888789,
0.8955997825,
-0.5544940233,
-0.4211354554,
-0.5678657293,
-0.7072201967,
-0.4285750687,
0.4777577519,
-0.0716236904,
0.6693481207,
-0.5262072086,
0.1665000916,
0.3545903265,
-0.3078413904,
0.4140809476,
0.823417902,
-0.6085782051,
-0.0427115485,
0.5982847214,
-0.027201822,
0.1419171542,
0.1755904555,
0.2095834762,
-0.1672767699,
-0.8448110223,
-0.6153513789,
-0.1743630767,
-0.6945638061,
-0.2364426851,
-0.7240921855,
0.2027544826,
-0.4471426606,
-0.1768040359,
-0.8090498447,
-0.1582329571,
0.3556528389,
0.109941043,
0.2678820491,
0.7596575022,
-0.3190941811,
-0.0359642804,
-0.6787714362,
0.4534344971,
0.4301578104,
0.4361915886,
-0.0407220684,
-0.0568680838,
-0.2350553572,
-0.0783403441,
-0.2605185807,
-0.4326056242,
0.4771489799,
0.4226642549,
0.630672276,
0.2092059851,
0.2235687226,
0.5493013859,
-0.7249878645,
0.694214642,
-0.0913323015,
-0.9468365908,
0.5274463296,
-0.3222318888,
0.4077814817,
0.7565840483,
0.5241214037,
-0.281909436,
-0.353756994,
-0.1094157398,
-1.205876708,
0.4932847619,
0.1422106326,
-0.0668273643,
-0.0539456382,
-0.2513400018,
0.4281496704,
0.3053820729,
-0.445109129,
-0.0018409208,
-0.0597658493,
0.0099169202,
-0.252233386,
0.0808701888,
-0.7063422799,
-0.3207096756,
0.5146707892,
-0.4332822263,
0.1822627485,
0.1369539201,
-0.5963375568,
-0.2973791659,
0.0670599639,
0.460038662,
1.3292107582,
-0.5484408736,
0.2802503407,
0.1423936635,
-0.0553044118,
-0.1105650589,
0.2651614249,
0.1492024958,
-0.1188760176,
0.5135656595,
0.5459501147,
0.4555112422,
-1.3046371937,
0.4896906912,
-0.2420194,
-0.188670367,
-0.6850458384,
0.1678033918,
0.0475781485,
0.2249640971,
0.729834497,
-0.1100340188,
0.2471222132,
-0.7197566628,
0.523588419,
0.4341827631,
-0.0302569121,
-0.3301140964,
0.8622227311,
0.234448269,
-0.1410539001,
0.5020388961,
-0.3682201207,
-0.2918821573,
0.6585822701,
0.4558450878,
0.6200283766,
-0.1718878448,
0.0522474125,
0.5646957159,
0.2783833146,
-0.1947715878,
0.2345846891,
0.0319924206,
-0.4882506132,
-0.4909110367,
-0.7257841825,
-0.7804062963,
0.0308044814,
-0.7311387658,
0.2902903855,
-0.4412104189,
-0.0229385179,
0.4999307394,
-0.2647625506,
-0.7623137236,
0.1393831819,
0.351372689,
1.0253506899,
-0.9133509994,
0.6239299178,
0.7539995909,
-0.2602936327,
-0.384637922,
-0.5121085644,
0.3914829195,
-0.9082009196,
0.8107449412,
0.1385411769,
-0.2601792216,
-0.0738112107,
-0.7038690448,
-0.9797487855,
1.0016235113,
0.2597074807,
-0.5333682895,
0.3200766444,
-0.0154475737,
0.4898594916,
-0.4787787199,
0.6844293475,
0.3245909512,
0.787122786,
-0.1000471637,
-1.3592011929,
0.0803276226,
-0.8628824353,
-0.2047785372,
0.2454732209,
-0.4178091586,
1.2218788862,
-0.1073381975,
-0.100453794,
-0.0743133798,
0.4923939109,
0.0248797853,
0.3375688195,
0.7271246314,
0.5043114424,
0.4849233329,
0.0809853822,
1.1980448961,
-0.4261858165,
0.4197262228,
1.2078454494,
-0.8497514129,
0.8571375012,
0.2599112689,
-0.2542822957,
0.3103206456,
0.446477741,
-0.3321719468,
0.4326444864,
0.3654441535,
-0.1598820835,
-0.3559730947,
-0.1531903148,
-0.3829885721,
0.4922082126,
0.1334733665,
-0.1715403348,
-0.6264471412,
0.1198984757,
-0.0196542945,
0.195226863,
-0.2670225501,
0.6186846495,
-0.0465664752,
-0.6325440407,
0.7274797559,
0.081018813,
0.7104391456,
-1.1085797548,
-0.1347406805,
-0.1450473666,
0.4665436745,
-0.1289337873,
-0.516102612,
0.3538829386,
0.0336295143,
0.0274975616,
-0.339979589,
0.3508968055,
-0.2709348202,
-0.6243235469,
0.4098413885,
0.4846539795,
-0.0799556449,
-0.2232947648,
-0.6426672339,
0.4210421443,
-0.3114108741,
-0.5293542147,
0.5025370717,
0.0411534943,
-0.2578099072,
1.0085296631,
0.7899048924,
0.0149312327,
-0.1090419367,
0.0188780557,
1.1186680794,
-0.6711782813,
-0.500674963,
-0.8398452997,
0.3551460505,
-0.1215924174,
-0.4311344326,
0.953371644,
0.9289750457,
0.7613868117,
-0.0096521769,
0.9886023998,
-0.2788966596,
0.4369128942,
-0.3765578866,
0.4372988641,
-0.8229630589,
0.1138962582,
-0.1977941543,
-0.9399178624,
-0.1667053849,
0.4066783786,
-0.2944276631,
-0.1170786619,
0.8330133557,
0.8309536576,
-0.3018968105,
-0.1395292729,
0.0620616563,
0.3356385231,
0.3947381377,
0.4551150501,
0.7513249516,
-0.0366917998,
0.5258997083,
-0.3219268322,
-0.438819021,
-0.275556922,
-1.3068736792,
-0.7200844884,
-0.5360217094,
-0.4449849725,
-0.0471398272,
0.0196003243,
1.3114187717,
0.8049407005,
-0.8324096799,
-0.5208674669,
0.3436754644,
-0.2530646324,
-0.5765218139,
-0.226628989,
0.4732267857,
-0.0974145308,
-0.9514120221,
0.7681501508,
0.2823892236,
-0.4701806307,
-0.3559364378,
0.2565430403,
-0.3469507694,
-0.0132435672,
0.6186324954,
0.3741000891,
-0.1617455781,
-0.2428812534,
-0.0285732187,
0.0939181894,
0.0676747188,
0.892008245,
-0.7586447597,
0.6418520212,
0.3765843809,
0.5119085312,
0.5200129151,
-0.0852004588,
0.9232062697,
-0.7063120604,
0.0581761301,
0.5068693757,
0.3052636385,
0.3047313392,
0.121374242,
0.6523962021,
-0.0591337867,
-0.5484939814,
-1.3581066132,
0.12399441,
-0.9686329961,
-0.5619921088,
1.240930438,
0.0504929721,
-0.2381164581,
-0.0256328788,
-0.2022162527,
-0.0111709749,
-0.4112190902,
1.0500515699,
0.6328651309,
-0.3567367196,
0.1080054343,
-0.8982844353,
0.478983283,
0.3182558715,
-0.9016715884,
0.1983473152,
0.4112744629,
0.4208708704,
0.1377515644,
0.529311657,
-0.0418668687,
0.1469967067,
0.219665885,
0.4707717299,
-0.6414543986,
-0.0454084575,
-0.0035242264,
0.2212761343,
-0.0419238582,
0.1994099021
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12319v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12319v1 | PRePair: Pointwise Reasoning Enhance Pairwise Evaluating for Robust Instruction-Following Assessments | 2024-06-18T06:43:04 | 2024-06-18T06:43:04 | Hawon Jeong, ChaeHun Park, Jimin Hong, Jaegul Choo | cs.CL | cs.CL | Pairwise evaluation using large language models (LLMs) is widely used for
evaluating natural language generation (NLG) tasks. However, the reliability of
LLMs is often compromised by biases, such as favoring verbosity and
authoritative tone. In the study, we focus on the comparison of two LLM-based
evaluation approaches, pointwise and pairwise. Our findings demonstrate that
pointwise evaluators exhibit more robustness against undesirable preferences.
Further analysis reveals that pairwise evaluators can accurately identify the
shortcomings of low-quality outputs even when their judgment is incorrect.
These results indicate that LLMs are more severely influenced by their bias in
a pairwise evaluation setup. To mitigate this, we propose a hybrid method that
integrates pointwise reasoning into pairwise evaluation. Experimental results
show that our method enhances the robustness of pairwise evaluators against
adversarial samples while preserving accuracy on normal samples. | [
-0.152797088,
-0.823798418,
0.5714039207,
0.3739739358,
-0.0633706003,
0.3663488925,
-0.4169150889,
-0.0873316303,
-0.0014533979,
0.3306531906,
-0.1143622026,
-0.6798553467,
-0.6437894106,
0.0144962566,
-0.3202688694,
0.8337605,
-0.0073011927,
0.1375421137,
-0.5552355647,
-0.1923877299,
-0.5716118813,
-0.4517946541,
-0.7878988385,
-0.3509162068,
0.1418152601,
0.265172869,
0.7409060597,
0.3422690332,
0.2843049169,
0.3051574826,
0.0134065934,
0.3258446455,
-0.4767954648,
0.2222042233,
0.0393996909,
-0.1796745807,
-0.5725474954,
0.0255319979,
0.5463413596,
0.6347486973,
-0.0174925514,
-0.0809360519,
0.2905758619,
0.6641298532,
-0.9056805968,
-0.1704015434,
-0.6643071175,
-0.1742462218,
0.1799388379,
-0.2297120988,
-0.5912182927,
-0.5380170345,
0.2629112303,
-0.5639103055,
0.0124570066,
-0.1545645744,
0.529990375,
0.4148725867,
-0.1371623874,
-0.1354024559,
-0.5260010362,
1.0215146542,
-1.0310000181,
0.4548986256,
0.4329498112,
0.021251753,
-0.3509106338,
-0.6440736055,
-0.4835649133,
-0.4388136268,
-0.091935277,
0.316210717,
-0.1449922472,
0.2148748785,
0.1183724403,
0.1747640073,
-0.5963911414,
0.3388080597,
-0.215211004,
-0.281167835,
0.8206372261,
-0.0645602867,
0.2388279438,
-0.5149384737,
-0.4037602842,
-0.1982089281,
-0.8432132602,
0.1209815443,
0.5263860822,
0.204431355,
0.0791407228,
0.3650719523,
0.0333014093,
0.9902273417,
0.3266774416,
-0.2250975519,
0.073615469,
-0.4211706817,
-0.2226201445,
0.0452269055,
0.994805932,
0.6681182981,
0.0929746777,
-0.2322135866,
-0.2234170586,
0.1439156681,
0.3267906904,
-0.5909568667,
-0.3573975861,
0.2944504917,
-0.5002077222,
-0.4219099283,
0.1995420903,
-0.8299235702,
-0.3142358959,
-0.2312352359,
0.565082252,
-0.4474771619,
0.0078324387,
-0.1113412902,
-0.0847610384,
0.214089945,
0.1620393693,
-0.7534966469,
0.2732090652,
1.0136432648,
0.6418737769,
-0.4800974131,
-0.313675642,
-0.9316486716,
-0.0096120723,
-0.3461176455,
0.7669124007,
-0.688292563,
-0.6808677316,
-0.1521393508,
-0.4669410288,
-0.213029325,
-0.6425807476,
0.5561393499,
-0.4131920338,
0.52576828,
-0.1363562793,
-0.4214890897,
-0.0521334894,
0.2563483119,
-0.3874046504,
1.3187348843,
0.1787299812,
-0.8722058535,
0.5384508967,
-0.3293612003,
-0.6913143992,
0.0708889514,
-0.4013016224,
-0.3628762662,
-0.0526878498,
0.4662201107,
0.4828930199,
-0.0391413011,
0.3743301928,
-0.433465451,
-0.5542048812,
-0.0476488471,
-0.3425967395,
0.5507439375,
-0.2023697048,
-0.5605590343,
0.5447576642,
-0.7625032663,
0.1429087967,
0.0286176465,
-0.2707360387,
-0.6197788119,
0.160738647,
-0.4613102973,
0.0123075601,
0.2974122465,
-0.2620213032,
-0.0318938419,
-0.5038008094,
0.2656549513,
0.8795393705,
0.1085300371,
0.6397544742,
-0.3697955906,
0.5145714879,
-0.3361510634,
0.241824761,
0.2592953146,
-0.5375282168,
-0.7492776513,
0.0221569445,
0.2189572304,
0.7271722555,
-0.9485080242,
0.6416531205,
-0.1058144122,
-0.3883429766,
-0.3809521496,
0.550180614,
0.7776468992,
0.9458947778,
0.326477617,
-0.0918616429,
-0.4511980414,
-0.6871374249,
-0.340975821,
-0.3399013877,
-0.1667557061,
0.0123161171,
0.115057461,
0.0962810963,
0.7137292027,
-0.0593327545,
0.5544191599,
-0.5302078724,
0.2052063495,
0.1209224239,
0.470759064,
0.4891726971,
-0.6097120643,
-0.2976795137,
-0.4096570611,
-0.5417045355,
-0.2836658657,
-0.1569155306,
-0.3765745461,
0.3225109875,
0.2689515948,
-0.226756677,
0.5091996193,
0.6679793,
-0.3390903473,
0.5672036409,
-0.1352006942,
0.1809214056,
-0.9875377417,
-0.1703486443,
0.2640858293,
-0.0869583711,
-0.6022743583,
-0.0525071807,
-0.1079168618,
0.2320007831,
-0.2685132623,
0.4791275561,
-0.2802392244,
-0.2649257481,
-0.2323593199,
0.4547344446,
0.4358766973,
0.2015746385,
0.1171270981,
0.9220688939,
0.3559952974,
-0.5288997293,
0.2796986699,
0.2862507105,
-0.1443433017,
0.7465193272,
-0.8716549873,
0.4499203563,
0.2240709662,
0.2305351794,
-0.6980522275,
0.0261152815,
0.4045271277,
-0.492534399,
0.4382605255,
-0.0309694931,
-0.3754361272,
-0.2972584665,
-0.8876345754,
0.0945690051,
0.5327576995,
-0.8276715875,
0.3000913858,
-0.0059686187,
-0.1289925873,
-0.5415551066,
-0.544665575,
-0.0967751667,
-0.3792431056,
-0.800704658,
0.2034573853,
-0.0664702654,
-0.6024006605,
-0.1955029517,
-0.3826352656,
0.2145488858,
0.1770664304,
0.1804030389,
0.7020727992,
-0.2058019042,
-0.1519648284,
0.1865472347,
-0.2005194128,
0.3698142469,
-0.2848643661,
0.3625115156,
-0.2342142463,
-0.3813853264,
-0.0788383931,
0.3252496719,
0.2154602557,
-0.2755172551,
0.4682281017,
0.5577164292,
-0.2570558786,
-0.4763481617,
-0.5354624987,
-0.2836450934,
-0.5134193301,
0.158771202,
-0.0671492219,
-0.6360911727,
-0.0010285061,
0.2080858052,
0.051370997,
0.3132913709,
0.3195880949,
-0.137745589,
0.9488610625,
0.2288783938,
0.1154646501,
0.2433671504,
-0.1181676984,
0.4297039211,
-1.0151185989,
-0.2553874254,
-0.2988641262,
-0.3733286858,
-0.3735500872,
-0.2786851227,
0.6445291042,
0.4360343516,
-0.1149923876,
0.1569125205,
-0.6729117036,
0.313097477,
1.0111460686,
0.3310759068,
0.1755812168,
-0.0838314742,
-0.1141108125,
0.0103088235,
-0.8189177513,
-0.8811425567,
1.3912543058,
0.013206698,
0.4379453659,
-0.115252167,
0.8363898993,
0.1412648559,
0.2672024369,
-0.7945744395,
0.7236050963,
-0.2567174137,
-0.0673233718,
-0.2295313776,
-0.5652983785,
-0.6371071339,
0.0311889835,
-0.4791639447,
-0.9788717628,
-0.1208455935,
0.3880775869,
-0.6769621968,
0.4013226032,
-0.8117359877,
0.8343262076,
-0.7437944412,
-0.6918615699,
-0.2096866816,
-0.6291537285,
0.4557754099,
-0.0044700806,
-0.0594405234,
0.1756577492,
0.0299767777,
1.0564600229,
-0.5568789244,
0.637182653,
-0.1473593861,
0.0870620236,
0.3349424303,
0.3160078824,
0.3575946689,
0.1120187864,
-0.2610721886,
0.0480086245,
-0.0498165376,
-0.4422186911,
-0.8884702325,
1.0098360777,
-0.588341713,
-0.943697989,
-0.1560685635,
-0.6093173027,
-0.7109833956,
0.0629750714,
0.3780036271,
0.5556687713,
-0.0072799735,
-0.1024159715,
0.5746997595,
-0.3644548655,
0.5083020329,
0.0664207563,
-0.1023215801,
-0.495311141,
0.902289927,
-0.2259721011,
0.6149085164,
0.385676533,
0.583452642,
-0.2934838831,
-0.9425041676,
-0.4690949023,
0.0706948712,
-0.7321071625,
-0.172088176,
-0.2062145323,
-0.0782666057,
-0.4755835533,
-0.4185890853,
-0.0835893899,
-0.495351553,
-0.0972143039,
-0.2158863395,
0.2878890932,
0.8213086128,
-0.0167753473,
0.3456473649,
-0.7387399673,
0.2400387079,
0.4530662894,
0.2186791003,
-0.2268133461,
-0.4732401371,
0.2713024914,
-0.1364131421,
-0.3575135767,
-0.8996606469,
0.0537578091,
-0.1030808762,
0.6641981602,
0.618912816,
0.1883309931,
0.4731730819,
-0.0214966778,
0.823988378,
0.1634350866,
-1.0514786243,
0.7571515441,
-0.2086621076,
0.1554224938,
0.7410152555,
0.2963349819,
-0.0802057162,
-0.2922151387,
-0.6610310078,
-0.7683020234,
0.3897757828,
-0.0663338602,
-0.3504073918,
0.02305777,
0.1590732485,
0.1615601629,
0.0862425342,
-0.3873099387,
-0.0889968947,
-0.3909350336,
-0.2575645745,
-0.0556431264,
-0.3065547049,
-0.2053442299,
-0.2311767638,
0.5748496652,
-0.0873817727,
-0.0827436373,
0.0685051382,
0.0674368143,
0.0804994777,
0.3977392912,
0.4856100976,
0.8988766074,
-0.2661294341,
0.1191188022,
0.4204162359,
-0.2710152566,
-0.1292501092,
0.2162495255,
-0.5696681738,
-0.051780276,
0.7709940672,
0.7736456394,
0.5735480785,
-0.6585235596,
0.7864136696,
0.030273648,
-0.0323098786,
-0.061069306,
0.0378018729,
0.0204288196,
0.0554975457,
0.0501023382,
0.1428502053,
0.0528456531,
-0.2559270263,
0.0640918389,
0.5491486788,
-0.0752361789,
-0.2930032015,
0.6056861877,
0.4104148149,
-0.3712346256,
0.5580494404,
-0.277835995,
-0.7348991632,
0.4835158288,
0.5315990448,
0.8542940617,
-0.2150635272,
0.1688675135,
0.3247790933,
0.3081769943,
0.1122028381,
0.3425323069,
-0.2147273272,
-0.6902105808,
-0.3901056349,
-0.4770943224,
-0.6382575035,
-0.007792457,
-0.7204148769,
0.1206983402,
-0.8701983094,
0.0474464409,
-0.4651691616,
-0.1310983598,
-0.3964109123,
0.1009245217,
0.2512497902,
0.7915685773,
-0.6849623919,
0.7186545134,
0.7421135902,
-0.1680475324,
-1.0388712883,
0.1833609939,
0.0965130106,
-0.9747036099,
0.3799396157,
0.0514190271,
-0.3359792531,
-0.4391483366,
-0.1676707119,
-0.4072985053,
1.0541471243,
0.1484107524,
-0.6404221654,
-0.0207606629,
-0.0959148407,
0.3441341519,
-0.1034622565,
0.3723596632,
0.8810902238,
0.6878683567,
0.1636199057,
-0.8664932847,
0.1651872694,
-0.1860840172,
-0.072532557,
0.2383513898,
-0.4479517043,
0.4021589756,
-0.3519127369,
-0.1258932352,
-0.0472920462,
0.53196311,
0.6731477976,
0.6973076463,
0.7587776184,
0.5212118626,
0.7320407629,
-0.1839278936,
1.0534350872,
-0.4251398146,
-0.325027138,
1.3051341772,
-0.2967278957,
1.0823904276,
0.5416395068,
-0.2112168521,
0.4680054784,
0.5091773868,
0.1623027623,
0.2754280567,
0.2524826229,
-0.2792836726,
-0.3804018199,
0.1075039729,
-0.2120078355,
0.4440176785,
0.1735520959,
-0.1274973154,
0.0502937995,
-0.374640584,
0.298232913,
0.6886560321,
-0.434453398,
0.6025779843,
0.0483095013,
-0.9536814094,
0.4654392898,
-0.1322004199,
0.9653775096,
-0.5804524422,
0.0159115866,
-0.3159804642,
0.0100939851,
-0.4841598272,
-0.7053819895,
0.3637126982,
0.2075275779,
0.1777636558,
-0.3730903864,
0.9213386178,
-0.1568247825,
-0.5526898503,
0.5080434084,
0.5404549837,
-0.2445212305,
0.068810232,
-0.5787270069,
0.0869009569,
0.0406420752,
-0.0857204944,
0.1578731388,
-0.1186252534,
-0.2416050583,
0.4227632284,
0.7186726332,
0.3019278049,
0.1758890748,
0.1413914114,
0.7141211033,
-0.4337307811,
-0.2121533155,
-0.8554317355,
0.2229212523,
-0.1631584764,
-0.3813268244,
0.9016570449,
0.4608160853,
0.9207293391,
0.3440272212,
0.8662859797,
0.1148790866,
0.485996902,
-0.7052018642,
0.5715506077,
-0.19084768,
0.4781500697,
-0.3509093225,
-0.9373494387,
-0.2727852464,
0.4843904674,
-0.8475285172,
0.1025706753,
0.6360428333,
0.7529550195,
-0.0208403599,
0.0528141521,
0.2160476744,
-0.0236179847,
0.1759196222,
0.7661399841,
1.1648350954,
-0.1326588243,
0.5633848906,
-0.6095938087,
-0.4081858099,
0.2010937482,
-0.9716559649,
-1.1935133934,
-0.1292448342,
-0.2640603185,
-0.4982964396,
0.1763782203,
0.9567050338,
0.6478050947,
-0.8221516013,
-0.185755685,
-0.0442712754,
0.3222084343,
-0.1346980929,
-0.2481421232,
0.4846917391,
-0.0752132908,
-0.670352757,
0.9320013523,
0.3414815068,
-0.2217243016,
-0.4163518548,
-0.4764375985,
0.0463403575,
0.0205173474,
0.4647994339,
0.2024291903,
-0.793612361,
-0.4105557203,
-0.097687386,
0.0708515048,
0.0534174591,
0.7709685564,
-0.8369646668,
0.4213884175,
0.7526016831,
0.6924881339,
-0.048541341,
0.3060946465,
0.880137682,
-0.5193152428,
0.0868861675,
0.3843132854,
0.4631508887,
0.6061064005,
-0.2647916973,
0.3176425695,
0.1396767795,
-0.4210927486,
-0.5970090628,
0.0604465716,
-1.1034207344,
-0.0449512228,
1.2766940594,
-0.3239166141,
-0.0058263377,
0.3458660543,
0.002655766,
0.2359111309,
-0.3474017978,
0.6652038097,
0.4478009045,
-0.3407917619,
-0.071458526,
-0.2919820547,
0.259485662,
0.7438744903,
-0.9567158222,
-0.5495491028,
0.4650307894,
0.1952831447,
-0.0215166751,
0.2205521762,
0.068720594,
0.2800535262,
-0.0583387204,
-0.285772413,
-0.2251960784,
-0.2092615664,
-0.4556182921,
0.0338250063,
0.1985827386,
-0.3297882378
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12317v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12317v1 | Finding Task-specific Subnetworks in Multi-task Spoken Language Understanding Model | 2024-06-18T06:39:41 | 2024-06-18T06:39:41 | Hayato Futami, Siddhant Arora, Yosuke Kashiwagi, Emiru Tsunoo, Shinji Watanabe | cs.CL | cs.CL, eess.AS | Recently, multi-task spoken language understanding (SLU) models have emerged,
designed to address various speech processing tasks. However, these models
often rely on a large number of parameters. Also, they often encounter
difficulties in adapting to new data for a specific task without experiencing
catastrophic forgetting of previously trained tasks. In this study, we propose
finding task-specific subnetworks within a multi-task SLU model via neural
network pruning. In addition to model compression, we expect that the
forgetting of previously trained tasks can be mitigated by updating only a
task-specific subnetwork. We conduct experiments on top of the state-of-the-art
multi-task SLU model ``UniverSLU'', trained for several tasks such as emotion
recognition (ER), intent classification (IC), and automatic speech recognition
(ASR). We show that pruned models were successful in adapting to additional ASR
or IC data with minimal performance degradation on previously trained tasks. | [
-0.2091821879,
-0.5673003197,
0.3179589212,
0.1240516007,
-0.3775823712,
-0.2915963829,
-0.2958550751,
-0.1102194861,
0.2501121163,
0.4413392246,
-0.820106864,
-0.413682282,
-0.3864795864,
-0.2331001014,
-0.3123579919,
0.7203917503,
0.0561113805,
-0.2810873091,
-0.3434647918,
-0.332547754,
-0.7186781168,
-0.6513275504,
-0.7533083558,
-0.6438453197,
0.4042529762,
0.5574259162,
0.1486565024,
0.1516307145,
0.1401120722,
0.3771018684,
-0.3634167612,
0.0858694538,
-0.4810028672,
0.192533493,
-0.0176662877,
-0.7080997229,
-0.3328952193,
-0.3166032732,
0.9126645327,
0.7223008871,
-0.3616954386,
0.2784332037,
0.1233646497,
0.5365743041,
-0.5111886263,
0.2023221105,
-0.6664953232,
0.2455593497,
-0.1541537046,
-0.1933390349,
-0.5001418591,
0.3875931799,
0.2263389826,
-0.6477771401,
0.4565224051,
-0.265665859,
0.6830868125,
0.3745339811,
-0.2571783066,
0.0305716675,
-0.5854210258,
0.7892679572,
-0.887172401,
0.4665950537,
0.3794800341,
-0.0867744461,
-0.2069953382,
-0.5387353301,
-0.2225298882,
-0.3057098389,
-0.1791583598,
0.287352711,
-0.585036695,
0.2000319064,
0.2021051049,
0.0326692574,
-0.5270845294,
0.1413763613,
-0.4703104198,
-0.2581345141,
0.3441473544,
0.016304452,
0.2716244757,
0.0140081616,
-0.1116930097,
0.2167800665,
-0.5779678226,
0.1517340839,
0.3348833025,
0.3292979896,
0.1575574726,
0.3103506267,
-0.1374920905,
0.6832877398,
-0.152422443,
-0.0926957205,
0.4117474854,
-0.3296436071,
-0.4481341839,
-0.0395170003,
0.4664465785,
-0.1291512251,
0.4459725022,
-0.2131508887,
-0.1921443939,
0.0032615489,
0.4917547405,
-0.202736333,
-0.5185949206,
0.1825751215,
-0.5297317505,
0.1016785875,
-0.4126748443,
0.0885286555,
-0.1196744442,
-0.3818055093,
0.2337101847,
-0.4637179673,
-0.5368852019,
-0.046406351,
-0.1142231375,
-0.2740727663,
0.3109333515,
-0.4330122769,
0.2865174413,
0.4772699475,
0.9101840258,
-0.0861294195,
-0.7624831796,
-0.3934929371,
-0.1380246431,
-0.1501551121,
0.5444670916,
-0.2602367103,
-0.1523232609,
-0.3275493681,
0.2079739422,
-0.605342567,
-0.63418293,
0.5105580091,
-0.3076333404,
-0.3852058053,
-0.088721171,
-0.3716883361,
-0.460472405,
0.2264057547,
-0.7815577984,
0.8117137551,
-0.293237716,
-0.7652575374,
-0.1767881364,
-0.6228001118,
-0.7061407566,
-0.0548565798,
-0.0047095148,
-0.5575067401,
0.7078427076,
0.1246026382,
0.4571947455,
-0.1099675223,
0.4290725887,
-0.0788057521,
-0.3538993001,
0.2191420943,
-0.2424389422,
0.5848621726,
0.0598872937,
-0.1313673705,
0.5219135284,
-0.4102241695,
-0.1281285584,
0.0672471896,
-0.3014475405,
-0.5228953958,
0.0923838541,
-0.1050399095,
0.1653462648,
0.0957993791,
-0.5613905787,
-0.0344813578,
-0.0876881704,
0.717649281,
0.6632548571,
-0.0930345654,
0.3801763058,
-0.4729308188,
0.5461137891,
0.5030557513,
0.1367985606,
-0.2345935404,
-0.4301908314,
-1.0672471523,
0.2095075846,
0.1401977539,
0.5781505704,
-0.5404540896,
0.0083685927,
-0.1531294733,
-0.6314588785,
-0.6527913809,
0.1261023581,
0.4954723418,
0.5220676661,
0.3827446699,
-0.4133406878,
-0.4912007749,
-1.1217513084,
-0.282943368,
-0.0506881736,
0.0654842556,
0.5036482215,
0.4317429066,
-0.093392916,
0.7851364613,
-0.2928346097,
-0.4741403461,
-0.4960078895,
0.4315609336,
0.25984326,
0.6030389071,
0.1437247694,
-1.0292161703,
-0.0825166926,
-0.053117685,
-0.4364125431,
-0.0210834965,
-0.4780127704,
0.3583036661,
-0.2952518165,
0.3777663112,
-0.7264965773,
0.4497047067,
0.5054080486,
0.0712203085,
0.7313579321,
-0.3528677523,
-0.1677619368,
-0.8096574545,
0.0775132254,
0.2629891634,
-0.1296014488,
-1.2095504999,
-0.0006014313,
0.0688170493,
-0.2256089151,
-0.5549657941,
0.2271333337,
-0.7636118531,
-0.3453482985,
-0.2462931275,
0.0893442482,
-0.0691671371,
0.8576936722,
0.3331081271,
0.5396154523,
0.8085772395,
-0.7461896539,
0.2269657403,
0.0505045056,
-0.2259906232,
0.1108336747,
-0.6731271744,
0.490073055,
-0.4005658329,
0.3102704585,
-0.7569935918,
0.3165235817,
-0.110984534,
-0.3994425237,
0.2587994635,
-0.5321176052,
-0.0094163436,
-0.1278056651,
0.2240581661,
0.4084543586,
0.177970469,
-0.188667953,
0.9541011453,
0.5457066298,
-0.3177523613,
-0.6457386017,
-0.7816287279,
-0.0159054771,
-0.2136384547,
-0.5583761334,
0.5397230387,
-0.0280726347,
-0.0350033715,
0.0290751345,
-0.3880726993,
-0.1641140878,
0.281252563,
0.4349870682,
-0.1318493932,
-0.2352103889,
0.1417164356,
-0.075084731,
-0.1959328055,
-0.121925883,
-0.3042390645,
0.6324750185,
-0.2061331421,
-0.4890013933,
-0.6585093141,
0.5460789204,
0.6763256788,
-0.5481811166,
0.450215131,
0.7508252263,
-0.5223306417,
-0.3074872196,
-0.5312322378,
-0.2955080569,
-0.4234773517,
0.7715672255,
-0.6758350134,
-1.0013840199,
0.5985969305,
-0.2808383405,
0.2083778679,
0.0390821546,
0.3832199872,
-0.1024661511,
0.7408879995,
0.7322260141,
-0.2147759795,
0.6177890301,
-0.1935397983,
0.1167960018,
-1.0756534338,
-0.151176244,
-0.5058547258,
-0.6011518836,
-0.0600998774,
-0.3916430175,
0.227953732,
0.0988358706,
0.2368124872,
0.5550201535,
-0.4276798368,
0.2096056044,
0.8815582991,
0.2607641518,
0.1300902516,
-0.1458753943,
-0.086542286,
0.1215765998,
-1.091711998,
-0.0393959284,
0.5546043515,
0.3730310798,
0.4922659993,
-0.0191556998,
0.6449393034,
0.1382623613,
0.169135496,
-0.700676024,
0.5527822971,
-0.4638670385,
-0.2743063867,
-0.3339684904,
-0.699907124,
-1.0182218552,
0.405415386,
0.0777842551,
-0.9321850538,
0.2887663841,
0.3903788626,
-0.2851638198,
0.3281039596,
-0.8548475504,
0.8892724514,
-0.1556399018,
0.2659120858,
-0.4143972993,
-0.4875127673,
0.168412298,
0.0960367993,
0.2911606431,
-0.2829241455,
0.3461821675,
0.9738497138,
0.0050289375,
1.0459902287,
-0.4412678778,
0.2634688914,
0.2666114569,
0.1369670033,
0.4715672135,
-0.1830280721,
-0.0084631015,
0.1108076274,
-0.1565959454,
-0.3393597305,
-0.5342635512,
0.7323620319,
-0.6536004543,
-0.5590003729,
-0.1581943333,
-0.9272791147,
-0.1970372349,
0.065548718,
0.1923918277,
0.622507453,
0.0500474609,
0.2054210156,
0.8187534809,
-0.203758508,
0.4556180835,
0.4606568217,
0.2896465063,
0.0885853544,
0.8988208771,
0.2135616839,
0.1582072079,
0.3371960521,
0.2126059979,
-0.0960940123,
-1.0160508156,
-0.176453501,
0.1437540203,
-0.6166729331,
-0.1651651412,
-0.4809063077,
-0.074038066,
-0.3655077219,
0.2651214004,
-0.4955248833,
-0.0998619199,
-0.5449818969,
-0.1062494069,
0.2131948024,
0.593221426,
0.0977647081,
0.4492218196,
-0.856105864,
0.2539345026,
0.1259367317,
0.0908938944,
0.2537895441,
-0.7155864835,
-0.1896132082,
0.1429142803,
0.1715202183,
-1.0801327229,
0.4726700783,
0.5874284506,
0.745824039,
0.0559170172,
0.0524481609,
0.9651764035,
-0.4758351445,
0.508367002,
0.3419088125,
-1.0128448009,
0.597830236,
-0.0376142226,
0.8254246116,
0.4355289936,
0.2559814155,
-0.8824150562,
-0.2297341228,
-0.6069865227,
-0.9125055075,
0.8712430596,
0.2159569263,
0.0710562319,
0.3383702934,
0.4060648978,
-0.264752686,
0.1321637779,
-0.761941433,
-0.3563939631,
-0.1066667959,
-0.1813627034,
-0.1622406542,
-0.088191919,
-0.0907998905,
-0.169694677,
0.7070073485,
-0.1461390555,
0.3586077094,
0.3943944573,
-0.6154918075,
0.0633579195,
0.4073818326,
0.5685519576,
0.5810018778,
0.1175173074,
0.2715735137,
0.4097204208,
-0.5596068501,
0.1005263552,
0.0153361969,
-0.1286812276,
0.2166801691,
0.3972637057,
1.2373377085,
0.3956080973,
-0.6508170366,
0.2633671761,
-0.1255912483,
-0.1476428509,
-0.2821176946,
0.070340842,
0.3699121773,
0.2568208277,
0.5912362933,
0.2401898801,
-0.02231309,
-0.5338560343,
0.3865750432,
0.2492139041,
-0.524271071,
-0.3356798887,
0.1722293496,
-0.0167214032,
-0.5813139677,
0.8027679324,
-0.1330618113,
-0.6844872832,
0.8326906562,
0.7620518804,
0.6223974824,
-0.3305937052,
0.1096003801,
0.1073095277,
0.4925804436,
-0.0583415404,
0.2657685876,
-0.0567809865,
-0.8405097723,
-0.6022184491,
-0.4383807182,
-0.2111825645,
0.2822188437,
-0.8443055153,
-0.1702827364,
-0.1739302278,
-0.2930314243,
0.0143108107,
-0.1807272434,
-0.5859302282,
0.4298871756,
0.1205456555,
0.7975896597,
-0.9891919494,
1.2369616032,
0.8751344681,
-0.0007973689,
-0.9901168942,
-0.2881172895,
0.1197617576,
-0.47799173,
0.3706182837,
0.0895255655,
-0.1072433069,
0.1426851749,
0.0060840254,
-0.8570479751,
1.0391969681,
0.4340469539,
-0.9772817492,
-0.0989777222,
-0.1929490268,
0.2389437705,
-0.2433061302,
0.298899889,
0.526553154,
0.2196347713,
-0.1265689433,
-1.1839374304,
-0.0287724528,
-0.6159713268,
-0.2854266465,
0.3690728545,
-0.4750544131,
0.9922446012,
-0.1954690367,
-0.1195808873,
-0.2165575176,
0.6946691275,
0.2538275123,
0.3686650395,
0.9629926085,
0.716663897,
0.785263896,
-0.1490083635,
0.3810480535,
0.1070503443,
0.4625244737,
1.3316191435,
0.0534234941,
0.6984127164,
0.4152124226,
0.0706619769,
0.151391238,
0.6342343092,
0.1714089662,
0.3687330484,
0.3186114132,
-0.1041416824,
-0.4030936062,
-0.2302624136,
0.0276056882,
0.4629181325,
0.4744310379,
-0.0425507315,
-0.0534048267,
0.3382046819,
0.076752007,
-0.2756170034,
-0.4357290268,
0.7419002652,
0.2361425459,
-0.819719553,
0.5732363462,
0.0568863265,
0.6459174156,
-0.7237383723,
0.1752195656,
-0.2782515883,
0.0959685072,
-0.2356027812,
-0.5021478534,
0.4518373311,
-0.1961830556,
-0.1448343992,
-0.24667795,
1.0860906839,
-0.5721880198,
-0.213497594,
0.4679197967,
0.4445108771,
0.2403796017,
-0.4191139042,
-0.9916314483,
0.2182617337,
0.2851237953,
-0.2441776097,
0.4875126779,
0.1492019147,
0.0962882265,
0.8755668998,
0.7346812487,
0.0466081165,
0.141912207,
0.4435875714,
0.7375665903,
-0.5079447627,
-0.5619386435,
-0.5386264324,
0.360022068,
-0.0284927599,
-0.394946754,
0.5821200013,
0.1936902404,
0.7078412175,
-0.0373007916,
0.6994588375,
0.0606723316,
0.1870504469,
-0.3627449274,
0.5247082114,
-0.6109247208,
-0.0320521481,
-0.138352111,
-0.4852455854,
-0.2155340761,
0.6910316348,
-0.2319912612,
-0.2148703337,
0.6074526906,
0.720218122,
-0.2353246063,
0.1283744127,
0.2760080993,
0.3020492494,
0.0362674557,
0.8698917627,
0.5216971636,
-0.0824323073,
0.5945209265,
-0.5760774016,
-0.2017597556,
-0.0021909163,
-0.7838047743,
-0.7665982842,
-0.8465359807,
-0.477914691,
0.0211653542,
0.1392676681,
0.5171088576,
1.0312856436,
-0.7323799729,
-0.3262165487,
-0.2179059535,
0.1559220254,
-0.6215379238,
-0.1330831349,
0.3629484475,
-0.2031664848,
-0.4750374556,
0.906439364,
0.2376092225,
-0.1934524328,
-0.1001288444,
-0.0450769477,
-0.5583648086,
-0.2405705601,
0.2042927146,
0.3936736584,
-0.6904246211,
-0.1169227064,
0.0348769613,
0.5039447546,
-0.0085362606,
1.1926054955,
-0.6383644938,
0.2078223228,
0.3648892045,
0.507409811,
0.8324236274,
-0.0184141919,
0.4978298843,
-1.1902710199,
0.2484738082,
0.4561806619,
0.755307436,
0.294675678,
-0.2471328825,
0.0736421794,
0.2002329379,
-0.4664813876,
-0.7789006829,
0.4660977423,
-0.9699423909,
-0.4919938445,
0.9223203063,
-0.5545139313,
-0.3034814298,
-0.3890920281,
-0.0245455299,
0.4099035561,
-0.184293285,
0.3194541037,
0.4858817756,
-0.2291579694,
-0.5514225364,
-0.4057734609,
0.2072226703,
0.8829359412,
-0.6260586381,
0.2824760377,
0.1124883443,
0.2843852341,
0.2176246941,
0.6607649922,
0.480753243,
0.2909581065,
-0.1076824069,
-0.0516854189,
-0.3578942418,
-0.6914234161,
-0.3086673021,
0.2615167201,
-0.102242142,
-0.3612247109
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12307v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12307v1 | Can Tool-augmented Large Language Models be Aware of Incomplete Conditions? | 2024-06-18T06:28:06 | 2024-06-18T06:28:06 | Seungbin Yang, ChaeHun Park, Taehee Kim, Jaegul Choo | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent advancements in integrating large language models (LLMs) with tools
have allowed the models to interact with real-world environments. However,
these tool-augmented LLMs often encounter incomplete scenarios when users
provide partial information or the necessary tools are unavailable. Recognizing
and managing such scenarios is crucial for LLMs to ensure their reliability,
but this exploration remains understudied. This study examines whether LLMs can
identify incomplete conditions and appropriately determine when to refrain from
using tools. To this end, we address a dataset by manipulating instances from
two datasets by removing necessary tools or essential information for tool
invocation. We confirm that most LLMs are challenged to identify the additional
information required to utilize specific tools and the absence of appropriate
tools. Our research can contribute to advancing reliable LLMs by addressing
scenarios that commonly arise during interactions between humans and LLMs. | [
-0.278432548,
-0.9204832911,
1.1121532917,
0.2552753687,
-0.1852341741,
0.3994095623,
-0.4457427561,
-0.6617426872,
0.0169200413,
0.4777802527,
-0.7003458738,
-0.2323648632,
-0.6052671075,
0.1137972623,
-0.6259568334,
0.6468371749,
-0.2826257944,
-0.1513524652,
-0.711879313,
-0.056348294,
-0.7865879536,
-0.4772121012,
-0.525083065,
-0.6186269522,
0.3643087745,
0.4443500638,
0.8191031218,
0.3449311256,
0.5048900843,
0.3506677747,
-0.2373185009,
0.1200805083,
-0.3151435852,
0.1859161109,
-0.0899335518,
-0.1532258838,
-0.5920931101,
-0.0609257594,
0.4792810977,
1.250295043,
-0.1951215565,
0.1278242171,
0.4922116995,
0.1602570266,
-0.5524783731,
0.0858255401,
-0.6284329295,
0.2935932577,
-0.227931872,
-0.2417143136,
-0.3660425544,
0.0307234339,
0.195000127,
-0.5629624724,
0.191430971,
-0.0291372165,
0.6133256555,
0.4287026823,
-0.4904821813,
-0.2551421225,
-0.9487099648,
0.5919032693,
-0.6901067495,
0.2917746305,
0.731281817,
-0.0240115635,
-0.7762360573,
-0.3712465763,
-0.7324981689,
-0.014297707,
-0.3473570347,
-0.0109683881,
-0.0952762663,
0.1243115216,
0.605245471,
0.1138754264,
-0.2139417827,
0.5197379589,
-0.4867521524,
-0.4176200032,
0.2030062377,
0.413890332,
0.3919516206,
-0.470597893,
-0.131238699,
0.334323585,
-0.9667143226,
-0.0628132224,
0.2888218164,
0.2838532627,
-0.355465889,
0.8888372183,
0.2203072309,
0.8974704146,
-0.2120744884,
-0.2787381411,
0.280870229,
-0.3123493791,
-0.540350616,
-0.0702350736,
0.5854368806,
0.0951375067,
0.0818647668,
-0.444167465,
-0.6410908103,
-0.4500355422,
0.0604049005,
-0.1596753746,
0.0669181198,
0.6512203813,
-0.0503048226,
-0.0392859876,
-0.1373502761,
-0.4138569534,
-0.8665992022,
-0.4244038761,
0.6306654811,
0.0302963275,
-0.6614233255,
-0.1541181207,
-0.2102092057,
0.1591984332,
0.500597477,
-0.3330349624,
0.2443788946,
0.6180499196,
0.9705366492,
-0.0562048256,
-0.2808734775,
-0.759303391,
0.295976311,
-0.4172402322,
0.3356930912,
-0.5616172552,
-0.6221844554,
0.0504243411,
0.3264479339,
0.1667317748,
-0.6478789449,
0.4242699742,
-0.4127230048,
0.1810439825,
-0.3862282932,
-0.4855931699,
-0.0967293829,
0.175325036,
-0.8736129999,
1.0703411102,
0.2607303262,
-0.8180583715,
0.3214051425,
-0.4091159701,
-0.5432251096,
0.0919977576,
-0.1485910863,
-0.4731186628,
0.1248569563,
-0.0020125932,
0.5856628418,
-0.3458699882,
0.5099151731,
-0.7287153602,
-0.5603603721,
0.1833093017,
-0.397873044,
0.5616514087,
0.0739084333,
-0.197677061,
-0.0518408529,
-0.5518115163,
-0.1457117498,
0.2139571905,
-0.4377410114,
-0.3280037045,
0.2666330934,
0.0525873452,
0.3009281158,
0.431078285,
-0.5439369678,
0.1536262631,
-0.3604255021,
0.4541467726,
0.9219915271,
0.0225687288,
0.3991553187,
-0.0960532799,
0.5809428096,
0.1790940017,
-0.0546405613,
0.0787914619,
-0.0839350969,
-1.2193086147,
-0.1531319916,
0.2982241809,
0.6949529052,
-0.9473974109,
0.531583488,
-0.2239365876,
-0.0854431689,
-0.4371049702,
0.3561537564,
0.3391256928,
0.331625104,
0.1285992861,
0.0159285944,
-0.7668753862,
-0.8265784979,
0.0607622117,
0.0636494905,
-0.1454953849,
0.3887917399,
0.3226759434,
-0.0827035457,
1.0542238951,
-0.0097429538,
-0.1623084843,
-0.5442268252,
-0.110095121,
0.4539015293,
0.2445703596,
0.3791165948,
-0.6624718308,
-0.0990390033,
0.0582559258,
-0.9415028691,
-0.1310269833,
-0.3064464331,
0.3779724538,
0.2671979368,
0.7395119071,
-0.6114714742,
0.6643297672,
0.6878070235,
0.0312513523,
0.4413132966,
-0.4404854178,
-0.1014584228,
-0.7469741702,
0.1998109072,
0.1665293425,
-0.535607338,
-0.5578616858,
-0.3210673928,
0.0958822742,
-0.1128650233,
-0.4793337286,
0.9021743536,
-0.757489264,
-0.2868025601,
-0.339428544,
0.3358576,
-0.104651913,
0.2321463376,
0.1689904034,
0.7813749909,
0.6374408603,
-0.5642800331,
0.0994183943,
-0.0411365442,
-0.3926439881,
0.3196785748,
-0.9351203442,
0.1233785003,
-0.1315824687,
0.0987198949,
-0.7547277808,
-0.6157170534,
0.5850018859,
0.0058173495,
0.2793170214,
-0.4869916439,
-0.950556457,
-0.4285978377,
0.0962182954,
0.2609166503,
0.5677477121,
-0.4123498499,
0.7855209708,
0.3311827183,
-0.4215626717,
-0.4989235699,
-0.5112905502,
0.3247407377,
-0.3219723403,
-0.1960548311,
-0.0680541396,
0.0662118942,
-0.3026661277,
0.1256525964,
-0.2122053206,
-0.190061301,
0.3530688882,
0.709087491,
0.4924991131,
0.2379643023,
0.2997754216,
0.0208839662,
0.2212927043,
0.1586582959,
0.3981514871,
0.3977196813,
0.3778573573,
-0.8847200274,
-0.3512167633,
0.2489704639,
0.6518419385,
-0.054134246,
0.6798625588,
0.4965437651,
-0.5985459685,
0.0833875388,
-0.8744493723,
-0.0506832264,
-0.5193981528,
0.3074314296,
-0.4191780686,
-0.7996735573,
0.7381811142,
-0.1438900679,
0.1336760074,
0.1223571002,
0.5640953779,
-0.2628606558,
1.0649888515,
0.6549207568,
-0.2053974569,
0.2552655041,
0.1804961413,
0.171215266,
-1.1175031662,
-0.2637259066,
-0.3122960925,
-0.1583792418,
-0.2864115238,
-0.1729844511,
0.5821518302,
0.1387582123,
0.0583799519,
0.0661647841,
-0.1197138503,
0.5506972671,
0.2181234062,
0.3355722427,
0.123548761,
-0.1712904125,
-0.2905077636,
0.3099931479,
-0.7201254368,
-0.4270268083,
0.9605089426,
0.2717311382,
0.5353353024,
0.0439060442,
0.5436512232,
0.3491919935,
0.2373687029,
-0.7791454196,
0.4784207344,
0.3065382242,
-0.482837081,
-0.1636349857,
-0.3748175502,
-1.1724110842,
0.1231240481,
-0.2485539019,
-0.834274888,
0.1393510401,
0.2286065519,
-0.4906105399,
0.0789085999,
-0.8169187903,
0.6962993145,
-0.1652351171,
-0.2657304108,
-0.054692734,
-0.5594328642,
0.400164932,
-0.4349241257,
0.686825037,
-0.2710965276,
0.0597468838,
0.6334701777,
-0.5168480873,
1.068739295,
-0.1934822649,
-0.1622860879,
0.1190984473,
0.1895312518,
0.8252161741,
-0.0597314797,
-0.0675773919,
-0.0317294113,
0.01173859,
-0.4721879661,
-0.4557075799,
0.8961725831,
-0.7228407264,
-0.8411788344,
-0.5796802044,
-0.4987951219,
-0.4166751802,
0.2421821803,
-0.2045160532,
0.4389984608,
0.0878702998,
-0.017693704,
0.4111127853,
-0.342597425,
0.6575005651,
0.603965044,
-0.2199719846,
0.1533174217,
0.698599577,
0.1472247541,
0.3087589145,
-0.3886670172,
-0.1626254171,
-0.0253214203,
-0.7811014652,
-0.218706727,
0.3059763312,
-0.7470983863,
-0.1363546848,
-0.2978739142,
-0.2680262029,
0.0448669381,
0.1231068894,
0.0176221766,
-0.076261431,
-0.7218877673,
-0.0792632923,
0.3198102713,
0.8433199525,
0.0699917749,
0.2210362852,
-1.0582355261,
0.1303192228,
0.0285958368,
0.2691953182,
0.2252492309,
-0.50318259,
-0.2285776436,
0.1737073958,
0.1894399822,
-0.6844860911,
0.0965960696,
0.1523506194,
0.7481626868,
0.2073332369,
0.0934012532,
0.8765178919,
-0.5843875408,
0.6242831349,
-0.0440090932,
-0.9888862967,
0.4044246674,
-0.4593566656,
0.3353587985,
0.1495487243,
0.4315606952,
-0.6820073128,
-0.6152175665,
-0.3620619774,
-0.8865358829,
0.8261834383,
0.0388230011,
0.1727048308,
0.0302709062,
0.5130977035,
-0.0111116543,
0.1493638158,
-0.692982316,
0.0388677046,
0.3393073082,
0.0563040599,
0.065248169,
-0.2558709085,
-0.2255698591,
-0.2233314514,
0.3295523524,
0.203740567,
-0.1736772954,
-0.0420528501,
-0.4153332114,
-0.2779268324,
0.3511145413,
0.3823822439,
1.0174895525,
-0.2004465312,
0.0333087817,
0.4334565103,
-0.1150723547,
0.1679844707,
-0.1694476455,
0.1802190095,
-0.1925693452,
0.6350581646,
0.6596748829,
0.2648359835,
-1.0904114246,
0.5220773816,
0.0906958953,
0.1477183551,
-0.6427160501,
0.1192055568,
0.2126764655,
0.2157370895,
0.273573041,
0.0742754787,
-0.0019960639,
-0.530941546,
-0.0766310543,
0.5837387443,
-0.6058650613,
-0.40999192,
0.1988907307,
0.3364730179,
-0.2311554551,
0.8247307539,
-0.2630964816,
-0.4124416411,
0.5186137557,
0.237525776,
0.6314321756,
0.2280521542,
-0.0843630806,
-0.0794649199,
0.486171484,
-0.1338057369,
0.2146153301,
0.2219523489,
-0.6825639009,
-0.8451542854,
-0.5385700464,
-0.4087969959,
0.3392531276,
-0.7165514231,
0.4968898296,
-0.4039013684,
-0.1940032244,
-0.0782599896,
-0.4316063523,
-1.0312994719,
0.0236736462,
-0.0495211557,
0.5718898773,
-0.9900497198,
0.8744299412,
0.6109184027,
-0.1745565832,
-0.8098415732,
-0.115895927,
0.3523338139,
-0.6644846201,
0.4367224574,
-0.16789864,
-0.1368208528,
-0.3233505785,
-0.4007362723,
-0.7286576629,
0.7714613676,
0.5434759855,
-0.6423134804,
0.1394062191,
0.0067412243,
0.4553225935,
0.2201914638,
0.1180739775,
0.7069870234,
0.7741732001,
0.2704862952,
-1.4865577221,
0.1697035581,
-0.0732713491,
-0.2892382741,
0.4453307688,
-0.3392276764,
0.6495102644,
-0.301612705,
-0.4730753303,
0.1296942085,
0.2471833527,
-0.0243442655,
0.2837197483,
0.6270784736,
0.5088828802,
0.639154911,
-0.140828535,
0.9848120213,
0.0794522315,
0.2175401449,
1.2160874605,
-0.6052311659,
0.8794896603,
0.5051799417,
-0.2776733339,
-0.068227455,
0.9354766011,
0.1755144298,
0.1680308431,
-0.1047493517,
-0.4361615479,
-0.7539023161,
-0.1135002673,
-0.3496525884,
0.5793181658,
0.5407186151,
-0.0978441462,
-0.2313494086,
0.2219797224,
0.1168280914,
-0.2901343405,
-0.0961093977,
0.8902349472,
-0.0637442023,
-0.5721386671,
0.616179049,
-0.057546474,
0.4627003074,
-0.5390532613,
-0.1274568886,
-0.1661861688,
-0.2026266158,
-0.4397298992,
-0.8969939351,
0.1806050837,
-0.1035848185,
-0.2119016647,
0.0358013175,
0.488384217,
-0.4480772316,
-0.6975915432,
0.1023983434,
0.8643213511,
0.1551866978,
0.0987090021,
-0.3840783238,
0.4206022322,
-0.1635401547,
-0.1960454136,
0.5278631449,
0.5181670785,
-0.0098187048,
0.9451586008,
0.554101944,
0.3350208402,
-0.3163999617,
0.0042339396,
0.8891064525,
-0.5490423441,
0.199041903,
-0.9774015546,
0.2973982394,
-0.1641941518,
0.0929862037,
0.8219994307,
0.3228879571,
0.4519503117,
0.1510389,
1.0934203863,
-0.1114597842,
0.8187839985,
-0.7738196254,
0.509706378,
-0.9263925552,
0.7474153638,
-0.2524244487,
-0.9407210946,
-0.1611997038,
0.22451666,
-0.2525055707,
0.08322303,
0.5715819597,
0.5854601264,
-0.3027384877,
-0.4463843405,
0.13640441,
0.193612963,
0.4615214169,
0.3629314303,
0.8294175267,
0.1724977493,
0.5161350369,
-0.0120057566,
-0.0874069259,
-0.0610998906,
-1.0538140535,
-0.8866866827,
-0.5205445886,
-0.2559058368,
-0.1705982834,
0.053606227,
1.074078083,
0.4802884161,
-0.5000607967,
-0.2080252767,
0.2554894984,
0.5006976724,
0.1886398196,
-0.1530031562,
0.3101308048,
-0.246593073,
-0.7647615075,
0.4382617176,
0.5246040821,
0.3352980912,
-0.5766806602,
0.0675688013,
-0.0463795364,
-0.0028918823,
0.5339136124,
0.3946838379,
-0.9866249561,
-0.6684090495,
-0.2115549892,
0.1591557115,
0.0130375493,
0.7485503554,
-0.8530905843,
0.4717240036,
0.183786571,
0.4700257778,
0.1155574173,
-0.1820896566,
0.6617686152,
-1.1961374283,
0.4559619129,
0.2458299696,
0.638019681,
0.5191156864,
-0.2405796498,
0.33688429,
-0.0176187884,
-0.4580226243,
-1.1106653214,
0.0881174877,
-0.8897429109,
-0.1876797229,
1.3583369255,
-0.203189075,
-0.0689995661,
-0.5926225781,
-0.1934747547,
-0.1670824587,
-0.121462062,
0.67148,
1.1524072886,
-0.0541978478,
-0.2687734365,
-0.7446815968,
0.3082573712,
0.2519297004,
-0.8284239769,
0.1016621292,
0.6743053794,
0.4246553183,
-0.0889526233,
0.5031545758,
0.2603723109,
0.2381112874,
-0.3870890439,
-0.137911126,
-0.0585501343,
-0.150691703,
0.0277936719,
-0.0041177953,
0.4863633215,
0.3093550503
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12304v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12304v1 | COT: A Generative Approach for Hate Speech Counter-Narratives via Contrastive Optimal Transport | 2024-06-18T06:24:26 | 2024-06-18T06:24:26 | Linhao Zhang, Li Jin, Guangluan Xu, Xiaoyu Li, Xian Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL, 68U15, I.2.7 | Counter-narratives, which are direct responses consisting of non-aggressive
fact-based arguments, have emerged as a highly effective approach to combat the
proliferation of hate speech. Previous methodologies have primarily focused on
fine-tuning and post-editing techniques to ensure the fluency of generated
contents, while overlooking the critical aspects of individualization and
relevance concerning the specific hatred targets, such as LGBT groups,
immigrants, etc. This research paper introduces a novel framework based on
contrastive optimal transport, which effectively addresses the challenges of
maintaining target interaction and promoting diversification in generating
counter-narratives. Firstly, an Optimal Transport Kernel (OTK) module is
leveraged to incorporate hatred target information in the token
representations, in which the comparison pairs are extracted between original
and transported features. Secondly, a self-contrastive learning module is
employed to address the issue of model degeneration. This module achieves this
by generating an anisotropic distribution of token representations. Finally, a
target-oriented search method is integrated as an improved decoding strategy to
explicitly promote domain relevance and diversification in the inference
process. This strategy modifies the model's confidence score by considering
both token similarity and target relevance. Quantitative and qualitative
experiments have been evaluated on two benchmark datasets, which demonstrate
that our proposed model significantly outperforms current methods evaluated by
metrics from multiple aspects. | [
-0.659758389,
-0.6499403119,
0.332972765,
-0.1847680509,
-0.4337579012,
0.1905187964,
-0.0249145254,
-0.2557108104,
0.4414722621,
0.4048282802,
-0.5436825156,
-0.5140542984,
-0.5835854411,
-0.0772577152,
-0.7836617231,
1.114526391,
0.1964249462,
0.0149071617,
0.2239591628,
-0.5382937789,
-0.4220920801,
-0.5728174448,
-0.5804445148,
0.1499935389,
0.5155887008,
0.2403132021,
0.7461898327,
0.6160225272,
0.2600613832,
0.2196292877,
-0.2400500774,
-0.1917456537,
-0.8542650342,
0.33365345,
-0.659242928,
-0.3979959786,
0.1327836066,
-0.2220723629,
0.4190665185,
0.2153805792,
0.0891864598,
-0.0535705164,
-0.0364857689,
0.1409090608,
-0.8062845469,
-0.6315048337,
-0.8739511371,
0.1490928531,
-0.3117872179,
-0.0076354756,
-0.2884892821,
-0.1178899705,
-0.1028669551,
-0.5550712347,
0.580593586,
0.1621120125,
0.5431129336,
0.1043844298,
-0.6977651715,
-0.4105178714,
-0.7462098002,
0.9697486758,
-0.4519292712,
0.2480215281,
-0.0359227695,
0.2298264354,
0.2089752853,
-0.3711204529,
-0.6065663099,
-0.0642854497,
-0.0336739682,
0.2151416987,
-0.462526083,
-0.0633137971,
-0.3180104792,
0.3000450134,
-0.6590519547,
0.3722658455,
-0.5342541933,
-0.2098188698,
0.6720349193,
0.5180291533,
0.3263920248,
-0.1757267267,
-0.8530468941,
0.0686983243,
-0.6136619449,
-0.3065851629,
0.7257176042,
0.47172454,
-0.3606894016,
0.4812906981,
-0.0340746418,
0.3617115617,
0.1317550689,
0.1331839561,
0.1914544255,
-0.2731505334,
0.0217218027,
0.0924622491,
0.787902534,
0.3354232013,
0.0783461854,
-0.3771626055,
-0.1824840754,
0.3399279714,
0.7756069303,
-0.6264324784,
0.1162378863,
0.1334409863,
-0.4695143998,
-0.6712694168,
-0.3273848295,
-1.3772448301,
-0.536391139,
-0.1197748706,
0.3625096679,
-0.6606964469,
-0.366448313,
-0.3868377209,
-0.1746857017,
0.1590582877,
0.126251325,
-0.9254293442,
0.3795858324,
0.3280626833,
0.9108736515,
-0.7986793518,
0.1334833652,
-0.4541204274,
0.2181304693,
-0.3526102602,
0.759562254,
-0.7789572477,
-0.6273466945,
-0.0232715905,
-0.4141160548,
0.1416595727,
-0.4763568044,
0.7260184884,
-0.4348522127,
-0.0006956058,
-0.0762588903,
-0.4436374605,
0.0568734556,
0.3014726937,
-0.4087683856,
0.6461659074,
0.3773949146,
-0.7166383862,
0.144760564,
-0.4647122622,
-0.4229032397,
0.0659233481,
-0.2545469105,
-0.469168514,
0.1084505916,
0.0029169382,
-0.0771847144,
-0.2943304181,
0.2411674559,
-0.1189054623,
-0.2409759015,
-0.1386659145,
-0.421951592,
0.7315165997,
0.6303156614,
-0.5888525844,
0.4194708467,
-0.543469429,
-0.609356463,
0.2096427977,
0.0499199592,
-0.4044211209,
-0.2238313258,
0.2331496924,
0.1837421209,
-0.1568449587,
-0.8519659638,
-0.3351914287,
-0.595173955,
-0.1020064652,
1.0994622707,
-0.0797038972,
0.4252133071,
-0.240361467,
0.8873950839,
0.5070253015,
0.3842741847,
0.241507113,
-0.3551799655,
-0.5419934392,
-0.1010391042,
-0.2232744098,
0.3455312848,
-0.6288031936,
0.1179211736,
0.0865762606,
-0.4464488328,
-0.3167109489,
-0.133408621,
0.4182626903,
0.769731164,
0.8727774024,
-0.2956759036,
-0.8680443764,
-0.9123950005,
-0.1960261464,
-0.1131744385,
0.2238372266,
0.149880752,
0.2043671757,
-0.2135466784,
0.8288673759,
-0.5486726165,
-0.2735472023,
-0.4692487419,
0.2975781858,
-0.3348056078,
0.4553873837,
0.9757379293,
-1.222966671,
-0.6304936409,
-0.2987937629,
-0.3808093965,
-0.1648914218,
-0.0805653483,
-0.5136095881,
0.0739634857,
0.4436266422,
-0.1595938951,
0.7071408629,
0.4626094997,
-0.5735052824,
0.6515728831,
0.4253253043,
0.3588434458,
-0.9965336323,
-0.0960652083,
-0.2136582136,
-0.1049466953,
-0.7313461304,
0.1053529009,
-0.6167547107,
-0.0949605405,
-0.6467001438,
0.5591405034,
0.1686413288,
0.3244768083,
-0.4655222297,
0.3822396398,
-0.2451367974,
0.3983074725,
-0.0586304367,
0.5652337074,
0.3546701074,
-0.5168033242,
0.4071267843,
0.3548502326,
-0.0250444505,
1.099850893,
-0.2048413604,
-0.0403483286,
-0.4262359738,
0.0108906412,
-1.2594966888,
0.4660177827,
0.415156275,
-0.2592580318,
0.0275732111,
-0.1273883432,
0.017523814,
-0.1658251286,
-0.2411734313,
0.8360404968,
0.6313465238,
-0.5170279145,
0.7178188562,
0.457732439,
-0.1525677443,
-0.5436139703,
-0.7381860614,
0.0593188144,
-0.6940463185,
-0.109732002,
0.7188401818,
-0.1764144301,
-0.2926642001,
0.0734654441,
-0.145975247,
0.0774369463,
-0.2375056446,
0.1541220099,
0.1353694797,
-0.1552402079,
0.1428414732,
0.0886691362,
-0.0387851745,
-0.1296624839,
-0.2357997894,
0.6585288644,
0.2509128749,
-0.0035745096,
-0.0044086757,
0.6826233268,
0.3996270597,
0.0548092201,
0.9327179193,
0.9132177234,
0.0768303201,
-0.1491730213,
-0.5475754738,
-0.023136748,
-0.420805037,
0.3134531677,
-0.4626580775,
-0.7292543054,
0.4907599092,
0.0119309844,
0.0233860668,
0.687531054,
0.6603105068,
0.227498129,
0.7290035486,
0.4744744897,
-0.1063815877,
0.4932489395,
-0.0975251645,
0.3255863786,
-0.6742383242,
-0.2205952257,
-0.6125695109,
-0.2390037626,
-0.4995771945,
-0.4889509678,
0.3820725083,
-0.3037489951,
-0.4756492376,
0.3936393261,
-0.4915853143,
0.2233654708,
0.275749445,
0.0528499559,
0.161091283,
0.068343237,
-0.5173362494,
-0.1030129418,
-0.6987151504,
-0.1975707263,
1.0916233063,
0.0851786211,
0.5988058448,
0.459905684,
0.6604602933,
0.5610676408,
0.5300300717,
-0.3966722488,
0.5014312267,
-0.4834569991,
-0.6384964585,
-0.2748644948,
-0.5815486312,
-0.9916347861,
0.3496100903,
-0.2332992107,
-0.7921327949,
0.3130827546,
0.1222444922,
-0.2194182277,
0.7299463749,
-0.5092678666,
0.802971065,
-0.0928728506,
-0.5395834446,
-0.6245856881,
-0.631410718,
0.2996428013,
-0.0486212038,
0.4130650461,
0.0280338377,
-0.061667867,
0.6450607181,
-0.3098765314,
0.690300703,
-0.0693362057,
-0.0731399283,
0.359482497,
0.3641541898,
0.2505322099,
-0.4493245184,
-0.3777519763,
0.0927775726,
-0.3419261575,
-0.4890398383,
-0.4937119782,
0.6599746943,
-0.6483430266,
-0.5847306848,
0.0295278449,
-0.5219610929,
-0.1176199466,
0.0752802715,
0.3878472447,
0.3943730593,
-0.6217304468,
-0.024461709,
0.4925976694,
-0.5655965209,
0.2793659866,
0.3800836205,
0.0167406797,
-0.4337259531,
0.8834460378,
-0.071787864,
0.4692400396,
0.4947566092,
0.3955055177,
-0.5782780647,
-0.6277342439,
-0.3224729002,
-0.0038364143,
-0.8080337644,
-0.316876173,
-0.904943645,
-0.1338392943,
-0.5270854831,
-0.6189334989,
-0.4765090048,
-0.0981814787,
-0.1009849012,
-0.1729329675,
0.2093794048,
0.7631040812,
-0.3494489491,
0.2996859848,
-0.009698702,
0.8344038129,
0.2304099351,
0.2815849781,
0.174596414,
-0.8766638041,
-0.2783904374,
-0.0525214374,
-0.496075809,
-0.9837369323,
0.5238018632,
-0.4792702794,
0.5937873125,
0.3140209019,
0.588127017,
0.5410624146,
-0.3246325552,
0.7257941961,
0.3852331042,
-0.877779901,
0.6061371565,
-0.1053502336,
0.0147018516,
0.4023903906,
0.6132877469,
-0.2161807865,
-0.8795790672,
-0.853503108,
-1.1421587467,
0.5269892216,
0.4988789558,
0.2941400409,
-0.2917991877,
-0.1649521589,
0.169319585,
0.0573046878,
-0.7955723405,
-0.2448416054,
-0.5206539631,
-0.5162882209,
-0.0391554125,
-0.4102436006,
-0.0937700719,
0.0717010722,
0.7161352038,
0.2081094831,
0.0155598978,
0.1266461164,
0.0029425267,
0.115101777,
0.3327221274,
0.5773994327,
0.3744299412,
-0.1227227971,
0.4513213634,
0.2526946366,
-0.4765086174,
0.3529657423,
-0.2638442814,
-0.248820141,
0.1609018147,
-0.0100972122,
0.7354568839,
-0.0147831496,
-0.6667810678,
0.4983609617,
0.1667610109,
0.0540177561,
-0.2306297123,
0.0013087483,
-0.2067442238,
0.2257857472,
0.1588780433,
0.069086194,
0.3231743872,
-0.3461721241,
0.2479725927,
0.3284519613,
-0.468721807,
0.0962222964,
0.8226239085,
0.3467685878,
-0.3356537819,
0.2839934826,
-0.3313448727,
-0.4683567286,
0.5663982034,
0.6265293956,
0.879863143,
-0.5639920235,
0.4158462882,
0.576671958,
0.1371172667,
0.508128345,
-0.3207030594,
-0.1328246742,
-0.8065891266,
0.2477632165,
-0.632974267,
-0.1952801198,
0.0931910649,
-0.5809175372,
0.3694584668,
-0.3229081929,
0.1234350279,
-0.1617030054,
-0.3970595002,
-0.5233473182,
0.3799158037,
0.2594780922,
0.5847648978,
-0.8054864407,
0.3205989003,
0.0265448112,
-0.4887558818,
-0.3650212586,
0.2289604843,
0.1788201183,
-0.6327745318,
0.6488179564,
-0.0611765534,
-0.5134016871,
-0.0842638314,
-0.29344666,
-0.6519888639,
0.5801690817,
0.3000255823,
-0.510874629,
0.2682215273,
0.3560416996,
0.5821069479,
-0.7083852887,
0.2314914763,
0.4317036569,
0.0894832313,
0.372666657,
-0.4541608393,
0.2853478789,
0.1028363854,
0.0618408471,
-0.0596422106,
-0.7753725052,
0.6505851746,
-0.0239688233,
-0.1523020566,
0.0395882539,
0.4178296626,
0.1500123143,
0.1147602275,
0.7617347836,
0.5701819658,
0.279022485,
0.4251441061,
0.8336520791,
-0.0355613083,
0.1324697435,
1.0321327448,
-0.0359148011,
0.4388593137,
0.3652585745,
0.0259619672,
0.6682604551,
-0.0345553569,
0.0259837732,
0.6458175182,
0.7529203296,
-0.5724531412,
-0.0226763934,
-0.4382553995,
-0.1091340929,
0.5979950428,
0.2641706169,
-0.4516820312,
-0.485678345,
0.3253926039,
-0.0262742378,
0.6151164174,
-0.3778131902,
0.7342231274,
-0.2140720487,
-0.3704775572,
0.532305181,
0.156719923,
0.8507162929,
-0.5568758249,
0.2051884085,
-0.3783738017,
-0.0517382622,
0.0269079357,
-0.5637862086,
0.7579597831,
0.2834431827,
-0.1039949581,
-0.2419257462,
0.3009344339,
-0.4723552167,
-0.3622930944,
0.5003344417,
-0.0046928884,
0.1425993592,
0.1769736558,
-0.6480884552,
0.3913952708,
0.1422467083,
0.0226447582,
0.3522349298,
0.3936862946,
0.098567009,
0.4974020123,
0.2113810331,
0.1725799143,
-0.0688783154,
0.2883440554,
0.9225407839,
-0.6832723618,
-0.8733651042,
-0.8349025249,
0.5329218507,
-0.16777955,
-0.3842658699,
0.4054701328,
0.840957582,
0.7559673786,
0.0758164674,
0.8006283641,
-0.0580241717,
0.695733726,
-0.4004415274,
0.3037917912,
-0.47855407,
0.2590772212,
-0.5120773315,
-0.546759367,
-0.0338435918,
0.5171399713,
-0.4117428064,
0.0597605631,
0.6339808702,
1.0507438183,
-0.2002619356,
-0.0760490149,
0.4732593596,
0.4150229394,
0.4591321647,
0.6803179383,
0.7458081245,
-0.450917393,
0.9115951061,
-0.0589845441,
-0.0279616248,
-0.1137587205,
-0.4994165599,
-0.7424539328,
-0.6069806814,
-0.401895076,
-0.4636000693,
0.2965646386,
0.6510747075,
0.7398968339,
-0.8508960009,
-0.1809393317,
-0.3011890054,
0.3817405403,
0.1054505929,
-0.3347194791,
0.2046505809,
-0.4603241384,
-0.6035091877,
0.089927353,
0.3196204603,
0.1194345281,
-0.2200251669,
-0.0701347515,
-0.338139832,
0.3886500895,
0.5652424693,
0.0493871868,
-0.7086027265,
-0.274926126,
-0.4461506903,
-0.0899610668,
0.0611292385,
1.0191688538,
-0.9227079749,
0.4662339091,
0.0688502118,
0.5919920206,
0.575216651,
0.2527841032,
0.6268222332,
-0.6728543639,
0.510696888,
0.5397910476,
0.0235602446,
0.2286646366,
-0.4955931604,
0.4177708924,
0.4527161717,
-0.033296328,
-0.7457559109,
0.6174495816,
-0.8444230556,
-0.5863755941,
1.2043056488,
-0.0654724538,
0.096708715,
-0.4984284341,
-0.3088829815,
0.3795598447,
-0.2194981277,
0.9680606127,
0.3466525376,
-0.1259354353,
-0.2431120723,
0.1279767305,
0.4625580311,
0.5082072616,
-0.5711781979,
-0.0089073861,
0.3612815142,
0.1422071308,
0.1034162492,
0.5364785194,
-0.3283688426,
-0.1349180639,
0.4241588414,
-0.1200443059,
0.2020624131,
-0.3508948386,
-0.0527435802,
0.4177524745,
-0.4728141129,
-0.1642420292
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12295v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12295v1 | Fast and Slow Generating: An Empirical Study on Large and Small Language Models Collaborative Decoding | 2024-06-18T05:59:28 | 2024-06-18T05:59:28 | Kaiyan Zhang, Jianyu Wang, Ning Ding, Biqing Qi, Ermo Hua, Xingtai Lv, Bowen Zhou | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) demonstrate impressive performance in diverse
applications, yet they face significant drawbacks, including high inference
latency, expensive training cost, and generation of hallucination.
Collaborative decoding between large and small language models (SLMs) offers a
novel approach to address these challenges. Inspired by dual-process cognitive
theory, we integrate these methods into a unified framework termed Fast and
Slow Generating (FS-GEN). This paper explores several techniques within the
FS-GEN framework, including speculative decoding, contrastive decoding, and
emulator or proxy fine-tuning. We provide a comprehensive analysis of these
methodologies, offering insights into their similarities and differences under
this framework. Our study delves into the differential knowledge capabilities
of LLMs versus SLMs through the FS-GEN lens, revealing that fewer than 20% of
collaborative interactions are required across various methods. These
interactions adhere to a scaling law relative to the parameter ratios, thereby
facilitating predictable collaboration. Furthermore, we investigate the
specific positions where collaboration is most effective from an uncertainty
perspective, yielding novel insights that could refine FS-GEN methods. Our
findings reveal that the essential difference between models of different sizes
lies in the uncertainty of the next token prediction, where interventions by
larger models are most needed to assist the smaller ones. Code for
Reproduction: https://github.com/TsinghuaC3I/FS-GEN | [
-0.2962245345,
-0.7941974401,
0.7423627973,
0.0893698335,
-0.1421141624,
0.342184782,
-0.5337546468,
-0.5796703696,
0.1133515239,
0.3822900355,
-0.6294752359,
-0.0510952584,
-0.5758118629,
0.1477244943,
-0.2303194255,
0.6231539845,
0.074339129,
0.2956471741,
-0.2064801455,
0.1313998997,
-0.1062242091,
-0.3615587056,
-0.9810985327,
-0.359224081,
0.4874287844,
0.4084795415,
0.9443138242,
0.7331601977,
0.4774790108,
0.3148524165,
-0.1474989802,
0.1528382599,
-0.6705394387,
0.1620709896,
-0.1315975487,
-0.4346691072,
-0.2674998045,
-0.1329018474,
0.423820585,
1.0257894993,
-0.0226794034,
0.2960650325,
0.1781783849,
0.6170988679,
-0.6393093467,
0.1571670175,
-0.792609334,
0.0009749184,
-0.262124896,
0.0784272552,
-0.4920104444,
-0.2838481963,
0.1958513558,
-0.4938519001,
0.5786391497,
0.2656359375,
0.3146007657,
0.3490510881,
-0.1502732337,
-0.6438997388,
-1.0193178654,
0.9508764148,
-0.6731114388,
0.3857182264,
0.2711607218,
0.0777289495,
-0.30648157,
-0.8361888528,
-0.4222037494,
-0.1259219348,
0.0229029264,
-0.3400059342,
-0.1344907135,
0.1194909438,
0.2559079826,
0.5420490503,
-0.4498442709,
0.3732724488,
-0.2061678171,
-0.3902411461,
0.6987403631,
0.4778353274,
0.0380723514,
0.0345300324,
-0.0345959961,
-0.0342698656,
-0.6990936995,
-0.0659503266,
0.3021710515,
0.3759855926,
-0.2062193453,
0.4686422348,
-0.1779331565,
0.4761552811,
0.2640212774,
-0.2076978832,
0.1346448958,
-0.7525562644,
-0.1529132277,
-0.1802960634,
0.9718891382,
0.1521128565,
-0.0838056281,
-0.3994011283,
-0.3050094545,
0.2360654026,
-0.2020990551,
-0.6957481503,
-0.0160735492,
0.1289396435,
-0.6229034066,
-0.2982668579,
-0.07308162,
-0.886175096,
-0.3625529408,
-0.2837525904,
0.2354568392,
-0.315420568,
-0.3492023051,
0.1938180029,
-0.0503133126,
-0.0211284161,
0.2769038975,
-1.1197080612,
0.2834108174,
0.6749315858,
0.7407934666,
-0.1015145108,
-0.4329214096,
-0.7351576686,
0.1831611097,
-0.3278689981,
0.394715637,
-0.203188464,
-0.4371344745,
-0.0933096111,
-0.1866955012,
-0.0535719357,
-0.3854920566,
0.1718100011,
-0.3855730891,
-0.1237217039,
-0.4364998639,
-0.4567330182,
0.3024089932,
-0.307446301,
-0.8271876574,
0.8001778126,
0.0079117846,
-0.8573665619,
0.3681414723,
-0.2924037874,
-0.4116734266,
0.1386990547,
-0.3955488801,
-0.2543866038,
0.5682370663,
0.0524486303,
0.6634125113,
-0.7695643902,
0.2857862413,
-0.4951802492,
-0.4831060469,
0.2240808606,
-0.2114280313,
0.4699006975,
0.5668262243,
-0.2184913456,
0.0221164636,
-0.7478492856,
-0.0040947418,
0.4007362723,
-0.2454102188,
-0.2235743552,
0.194024533,
-0.2551548779,
0.1399146169,
0.4304895699,
-0.2721600831,
0.0159118157,
-0.2909171283,
0.6762762666,
0.5879116058,
-0.0012666986,
0.824070394,
-0.1971900463,
0.4079470038,
-0.1502972394,
0.220885247,
-0.1223674119,
-0.2672350109,
-0.68277812,
-0.1110288203,
0.2778850198,
0.1793344915,
-1.1671808958,
0.0858847648,
-0.269457072,
-0.3972954452,
-0.6304585934,
0.3457610011,
0.5348766446,
0.0208888911,
-0.0045669228,
-0.3537550569,
-0.5757786036,
-0.5938665271,
-0.1912830621,
-0.1586997807,
-0.0243626554,
0.0933787227,
0.4012768865,
-0.1912422329,
0.6495375037,
-0.3850682974,
0.091435045,
-0.4379100502,
0.2861937881,
-0.0972890556,
0.282129705,
0.5339243412,
-0.5168123245,
-0.420792073,
-0.3126579523,
-0.7431258559,
0.1048047543,
0.0044933734,
0.1367837489,
0.2995220423,
0.6679132581,
-0.5425149798,
0.1888001263,
0.7305611968,
-0.2110744864,
0.533324182,
-0.2810622156,
-0.0758626983,
-0.916885376,
-0.2300129682,
-0.1288326383,
0.2200425118,
-0.6950122714,
0.2606136501,
-0.258341372,
0.0821107104,
-0.3760544062,
0.2009419948,
-0.7856145501,
-0.3557762802,
-0.1335215569,
0.1105540991,
-0.2125453502,
0.2854526937,
0.0064626602,
0.8384520411,
0.3662622571,
-0.409981221,
0.1480270922,
-0.1206247061,
-0.3684672117,
-0.004517857,
-0.4645165205,
0.3635900319,
0.162472412,
0.1384972036,
-0.5708068013,
-0.2731140852,
-0.0837282985,
-0.2479749918,
0.1842240244,
-0.125085488,
-0.9371863008,
-0.6325089335,
-0.3284490108,
0.499556005,
0.5924094319,
-0.3240940273,
0.3672864735,
0.3288986683,
-0.1197552234,
-0.3487909734,
-0.8798341751,
-0.1209978163,
-0.1087029725,
-0.8751642704,
0.1686004251,
-0.178489089,
-0.556902945,
0.0146853058,
0.0968820602,
0.0168847498,
0.083806321,
0.2417797446,
-0.064471826,
-0.4085715413,
-0.1250327379,
0.0634677783,
-0.1280266196,
0.0082716309,
-0.240148142,
0.5963706374,
-0.1991497725,
-0.1479174942,
-0.2216327488,
0.4580602348,
0.698730886,
-0.1467905343,
0.8371471167,
0.7600133419,
-0.1594863981,
-0.3236024678,
-0.5189937949,
-0.3114335835,
-0.499352783,
0.064434059,
-0.4555318356,
-1.1148617268,
0.7281193733,
-0.2173285484,
-0.2916322351,
0.2811371386,
0.7490271926,
0.2334360331,
1.0567067862,
0.9682356715,
-0.0618827865,
0.463083744,
-0.3300119638,
0.1221907362,
-0.5325829387,
-0.1436972171,
-0.5300859213,
0.0307608247,
-0.5142618418,
-0.5923862457,
0.0736295283,
0.4478620589,
0.0030513119,
0.0266915392,
-0.3382908106,
0.3647579253,
0.6724904776,
-0.1527892053,
0.4576506615,
0.1620656848,
-0.4199284017,
-0.1668051183,
-0.9819620252,
-0.3765915036,
1.0653475523,
0.2267083228,
0.8190277219,
-0.0106845936,
0.8535271883,
0.1026960611,
-0.0252166577,
-0.6795333028,
0.6611712575,
-0.3101870418,
-0.3199875057,
-0.2620528638,
-0.594262898,
-0.8968654275,
0.1365242898,
-0.462898165,
-0.6393776536,
-0.0076446007,
0.119298242,
-0.5172056556,
0.3592482805,
-0.8136983514,
0.5052684546,
-0.1346923113,
-0.6585944295,
-0.3361138105,
-0.8638769388,
0.4879492223,
-0.3742657006,
0.4388763011,
-0.0075059384,
0.1947848052,
0.5939487219,
-0.4424479008,
0.7283141017,
-0.1237279475,
-0.1584980488,
0.4652631581,
0.1521899551,
0.4707338512,
0.0397338048,
-0.3154209256,
0.1755001545,
-0.1771975905,
-0.2236537635,
-0.2295292765,
0.7968767881,
-0.7523553967,
-0.3808813095,
-0.1654022485,
-0.6892685294,
-0.1632970572,
0.2268164009,
0.5211024284,
0.2278312296,
-0.3576855361,
-0.0017230402,
0.6467839479,
-0.1307469606,
0.621265769,
0.5579277277,
-0.1569023132,
-0.3904391527,
0.7601830959,
0.0401858799,
0.4929371476,
0.2162164003,
0.0227220338,
0.019963434,
-0.8838292956,
-0.323541373,
0.3902299702,
-0.411686182,
-0.0992454514,
-0.3140960932,
-0.096598655,
-0.537504375,
-0.3882788718,
-0.5239266753,
-0.3501282632,
-0.3581896722,
0.0674140453,
0.2481798977,
1.0280647278,
-0.3410826325,
0.4365513921,
-0.8443135619,
0.281940043,
0.075040549,
0.204537794,
0.2904259264,
0.0255784765,
-0.5458033085,
0.2054560333,
-0.0973992422,
-0.6067758799,
0.1488802135,
-0.2097955197,
0.4790095687,
0.358384639,
0.0373096764,
0.5665684938,
-0.501619637,
1.0612421036,
0.3198295832,
-1.0760248899,
0.265134871,
-0.2657361627,
0.1969701052,
0.5612459183,
0.0369141027,
-0.1759843528,
-0.4673811793,
-0.6186152101,
-0.8657950163,
0.8569508195,
0.1816399246,
-0.2212920189,
0.0999787077,
0.3828258514,
0.3314406872,
0.2492492944,
-0.2676935196,
-0.1324815899,
0.2133668661,
-0.2570886612,
-0.3640169799,
-0.3197730482,
0.0256455857,
-0.0313886963,
0.3127881587,
-0.1094229072,
0.3310498893,
-0.1616787612,
-0.1592667252,
-0.5305631757,
0.1461746842,
0.4875464439,
0.4101974666,
-0.0439792126,
0.1240766719,
-0.0061502396,
-0.3773374557,
0.0804338679,
0.1002722308,
-0.1320710927,
-0.0866927952,
0.4875890017,
0.8830054998,
0.1886278093,
-0.4475310147,
0.43531394,
-0.3346765339,
-0.3185023069,
-0.0492299311,
0.0602487139,
0.1802672744,
0.5273838639,
0.4313881993,
0.1426960379,
-0.0600984544,
-0.4882807136,
0.0181948617,
0.3338017762,
0.2065842897,
-0.6086493134,
0.7325164676,
0.3326184154,
-0.2885822654,
0.5139249563,
-0.5218666196,
-0.1518411934,
0.5907552242,
0.3430919051,
0.8368433118,
-0.1658138484,
0.1916973293,
0.0564645976,
0.2764595449,
-0.5852799416,
0.3022526801,
-0.0950113162,
-0.7512691617,
-0.6475223899,
-0.7138127685,
-0.4316629767,
0.2673348188,
-0.8074755669,
0.089379847,
-0.4452381432,
-0.2099351287,
-0.0248075593,
0.3054872155,
-0.8762152791,
-0.1264798343,
0.1285632253,
0.6822497845,
-0.8096903563,
0.8916739225,
0.4766642451,
-0.4064545929,
-1.0273662806,
0.1427189708,
0.191295892,
-0.576277554,
0.4403421879,
-0.0984719396,
-0.3730679154,
0.0597099215,
-0.5079502463,
-0.9347062707,
1.2987959385,
0.4193531275,
-0.7628333569,
-0.4123232365,
0.2088785321,
0.672650516,
-0.5281599164,
-0.2619077563,
0.64136374,
0.1052476987,
0.0912085474,
-1.0182785988,
0.3636054993,
0.2412996143,
0.1993149668,
0.2549131811,
-0.7895060778,
0.9728867412,
-0.5983086824,
-0.2206731588,
0.5734010935,
0.4572983682,
0.2629973888,
0.6464742422,
0.3808248043,
0.4595293403,
0.5803488493,
0.0135460952,
0.7227509618,
-0.565446198,
0.3792638183,
1.1134320498,
-0.4076085389,
0.7246334553,
0.6864476204,
-0.1543037146,
0.2905572057,
0.5237386823,
0.0913567841,
0.6271487474,
0.077931121,
-0.0695424825,
-0.0944400504,
0.1173551977,
-0.3814502358,
0.2144716978,
0.7165514827,
-0.5779649019,
0.0020330232,
0.0147619043,
-0.0183647405,
-0.0331093557,
-0.3461439908,
0.7722719908,
0.3017778695,
-0.5902708173,
0.4593016505,
0.0198997427,
0.7799676657,
-0.5534886718,
0.3432256281,
-0.1430764049,
0.3705041707,
0.0230292473,
-0.4863656163,
0.1813628525,
-0.1311386228,
-0.3663031757,
-0.2482297868,
0.6793208122,
-0.4039982259,
-0.1692366302,
0.5692142844,
0.9469856024,
0.0558374934,
0.3268381059,
-0.714376092,
0.5876947045,
0.0673672333,
-0.1418036669,
0.2855733335,
0.6189108491,
-0.0220660046,
0.4746795297,
0.6673796773,
0.3233071864,
0.1483056396,
0.1001390144,
0.6858966947,
-0.5300773978,
-0.3146399856,
-0.7282449007,
0.1515866518,
0.1931972802,
-0.020306956,
0.927194953,
0.3520849645,
1.0071963072,
-0.1782533526,
0.7651497722,
-0.0190037806,
0.3533747196,
-0.6990018487,
0.5718299747,
-0.3938374817,
0.4116996527,
-0.2824712098,
-0.7178040743,
-0.1247442886,
0.2836947143,
-0.1591870189,
-0.1128207594,
0.7898303866,
0.7494570017,
0.1252650321,
0.1973348558,
0.2433954924,
0.3157085776,
0.1134709418,
0.751191318,
0.8686600924,
-0.1797281206,
0.5538935661,
-0.389681071,
-0.0350576453,
-0.3113245964,
-0.6634397507,
-0.8636853099,
-0.5287393928,
-0.1409980506,
-0.3700546622,
0.0376570225,
0.8100308776,
0.6428517103,
-0.3862630129,
-0.3522655964,
-0.3779243231,
0.0282359812,
-0.1783856004,
-0.1858774871,
0.1051835418,
-0.2048168629,
-0.6741208434,
0.4648996294,
0.0457675494,
0.281683445,
-0.5659102201,
-0.2912767529,
0.1539953202,
0.1579508781,
0.5717963576,
0.2046205401,
-0.7631466389,
-0.0453939699,
-0.0563105978,
-0.2302913368,
-0.3788313568,
1.2351484299,
-0.6960793734,
0.2352280021,
0.6329857707,
0.4092702866,
0.6743631959,
-0.3989117146,
0.6787720919,
-0.6568956375,
0.4594141841,
0.0402947851,
0.3398510814,
0.4697139859,
-0.4322814047,
0.5315673351,
0.3548699319,
-0.6132817268,
-0.96815449,
0.5109804869,
-0.6464679241,
-0.4090846777,
1.1587554216,
-0.0782025456,
-0.0839955807,
0.0189883895,
0.0789313465,
0.3118992448,
-0.4118890166,
0.4764113426,
0.61536479,
-0.1384910792,
0.0911802575,
-0.3201057017,
0.6318220496,
0.2939628363,
-0.351803422,
0.1270631552,
0.588683784,
0.2825751305,
0.3108235598,
0.8374156356,
0.1636978984,
0.028807776,
0.4292558432,
-0.1262385398,
-0.0270382669,
-0.3309009075,
-0.5099734664,
0.2646468878,
0.2727076113,
0.1373914182
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12277v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12277v1 | What Matters in Learning Facts in Language Models? Multifaceted Knowledge Probing with Diverse Multi-Prompt Datasets | 2024-06-18T05:11:35 | 2024-06-18T05:11:35 | Xin Zhao, Naoki Yoshinaga, Daisuke Oba | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) face issues in handling factual knowledge,
making it vital to evaluate their true ability to understand facts. In this
study, we introduce knowledge probing frameworks, BELIEF(-ICL), to evaluate the
knowledge understanding ability of not only encoder-based PLMs but also
decoder-based PLMs from diverse perspectives. BELIEFs utilize a multi-prompt
dataset to evaluate PLM's accuracy, consistency, and reliability in factual
knowledge understanding. To provide a more reliable evaluation with BELIEFs, we
semi-automatically create MyriadLAMA, which has more diverse prompts than
existing datasets. We validate the effectiveness of BELIEFs in correctly and
comprehensively evaluating PLM's factual understanding ability through
extensive evaluations. We further investigate key factors in learning facts in
LLMs, and reveal the limitation of the prompt-based knowledge probing. The
dataset is anonymously publicized. | [
-0.4286163151,
-0.6522180438,
1.0690288544,
0.2897406518,
-0.0991538465,
0.1163956821,
-0.1167376339,
-0.0720862076,
-0.4490491748,
0.2023724169,
-0.3598402739,
-0.6284592748,
-0.6580002904,
0.2105719894,
-0.0587128438,
0.9565030336,
0.1110615134,
0.1565731764,
-0.5427272916,
-0.2358625382,
-0.3822203875,
-0.4255354404,
-0.4733625948,
-0.3213837445,
0.5681779981,
0.5722233057,
0.4547251165,
0.4192455113,
0.195777148,
0.2709606886,
-0.1002523452,
0.4828748107,
-0.3830829263,
0.1113205105,
-0.2856001556,
-0.8215016127,
0.2085159123,
0.0450983718,
0.8334767222,
0.7278179526,
-0.060109701,
0.3022190332,
0.0392989442,
0.4575078487,
-0.4905556738,
0.3696124852,
-0.6923462152,
0.0404252335,
-0.0857871994,
-0.0367729105,
-0.6511547565,
-0.5404571295,
0.3301757276,
-0.3552469611,
0.2510988414,
0.2658357024,
0.6397265792,
0.0383512639,
-0.9475674629,
-0.6176410317,
-0.4754229486,
0.8631163836,
-0.7359598875,
0.6919850111,
0.3540120721,
0.2610176504,
-0.1009030342,
-0.3200454414,
-0.738430202,
-0.3786084056,
-0.105143331,
-0.0661932901,
0.0792271271,
0.1590681076,
0.5491753221,
0.2734134197,
-0.4931132793,
0.0622247048,
-0.2019534558,
-0.33976987,
0.2354059219,
0.0602119863,
0.3615398407,
-0.2243804932,
-0.5228021145,
-0.0641104206,
-0.9940266013,
0.3722407222,
0.2741683125,
0.0332725868,
-0.4205146432,
0.3899348378,
-0.0395074934,
0.6916254163,
-0.070207566,
-0.6975877285,
0.211114794,
-0.269960165,
-0.254514128,
-0.0144278258,
0.5535345674,
0.0801355168,
0.0274613127,
-0.3039174974,
-0.2120100856,
-0.0019773205,
-0.2786276639,
-0.5877484679,
0.1140740514,
0.2345965207,
-0.3328953087,
0.2134772092,
0.2146068811,
-0.557250917,
-0.666044414,
-0.3968095481,
0.4008117318,
-0.6820362806,
-0.1404199153,
0.1923901737,
-0.1825783402,
0.273116678,
0.5853713751,
-0.6767015457,
0.0125416657,
0.6086590886,
0.6131045818,
-0.0335342102,
-0.3827428818,
-0.5529108644,
-0.0051656989,
-0.3178271651,
0.7739267945,
-0.4145398438,
-0.1633530706,
-0.0964408219,
-0.0898898914,
-0.5054429173,
-0.443677634,
0.5173690915,
-0.6734044552,
0.1264349967,
-0.8378419876,
-0.9564416409,
-0.6603845954,
0.412714988,
-0.5333445668,
0.458121419,
-0.2973535061,
-0.7896750569,
0.5712525845,
-0.6115058064,
-0.246873036,
0.0200682022,
-0.3275412619,
-0.0996667519,
0.1580644101,
0.0659263432,
0.4466154873,
-0.2917898893,
0.720626235,
-0.4680119455,
-0.0372314081,
0.7253289223,
-0.7475591898,
0.7920632958,
0.3262742758,
-0.2248681784,
-0.0571380854,
-0.5796619654,
-0.3051961362,
-0.0268050656,
-0.5020441413,
-0.2250266224,
0.1905049831,
-0.5641801357,
0.2235205919,
0.1379592717,
-0.8386521339,
0.0231615957,
-0.3641529679,
-0.1033148617,
0.7225037813,
0.1770338714,
0.101154983,
-0.5244811773,
0.3621912599,
0.3242620528,
0.0951038077,
-0.3956228793,
-0.6209163666,
-1.0170253515,
-0.021515226,
0.0853719562,
0.4113233387,
-0.6757990718,
0.135903731,
-0.0607119463,
-0.3588083088,
-0.4963696599,
0.1012326851,
0.357494086,
0.7778306007,
0.1148376092,
0.2486732751,
-0.462274909,
-0.9221313596,
-0.2387698889,
-0.270861268,
0.2134528309,
0.3059295118,
0.6129319072,
-0.0365723707,
1.0376588106,
-0.3561684191,
0.14646025,
-0.2895294428,
0.3512814045,
0.2432402223,
0.2489215285,
0.5872078538,
-0.8449889421,
-0.5090171695,
-0.0479207188,
-0.8989682794,
0.1539991796,
-0.3129057884,
0.383559823,
0.1785502434,
0.1197828054,
-0.7841560245,
0.2882785797,
0.6582772732,
-0.416585654,
0.5406351089,
-0.1993197948,
0.2988819182,
-0.7832249403,
-0.1595680863,
0.195983246,
-0.188727349,
-0.6059122682,
0.0662956834,
0.2212319374,
0.2618737221,
-0.378991574,
0.488285929,
-0.3506843448,
-0.1197034642,
-0.0792647973,
0.1043257639,
0.0627004653,
0.3112865388,
0.192503497,
0.9339308739,
0.8043163419,
-0.8304453492,
0.267483443,
0.1610934734,
-0.7417362928,
0.0993606746,
-0.3422239125,
0.1659435332,
-0.2593000829,
-0.051481083,
-1.0224969387,
0.022581337,
0.2310512066,
-0.3059501946,
0.107340306,
-0.185804233,
-0.7221419811,
0.0806315541,
-0.0297169723,
0.0277056247,
0.3288101852,
-0.8127399087,
0.5105594397,
0.3395409882,
-0.1278741807,
-0.6521601081,
-0.2615814805,
0.0724814832,
-0.2754248679,
-0.5169398189,
-0.0848284811,
-0.4466729462,
-0.6259219646,
-0.2053314894,
-0.0501781553,
0.0910618976,
0.1500663012,
0.0255732629,
0.1893060654,
-0.3479531109,
0.4451518059,
0.0108168088,
0.1040393859,
0.3349537849,
-0.2467309386,
0.4411329925,
-0.3041746914,
-0.7697159648,
-0.1332777143,
0.0036727481,
0.6918101311,
-0.1414834559,
1.0119917393,
0.41336146,
-0.162678346,
-0.4619786143,
-0.7969197631,
-0.2552589476,
-0.4277011454,
0.2370054573,
-0.4008767903,
-1.0037997961,
0.6596305966,
-0.1301106215,
0.0401395448,
0.3921940923,
0.4323459566,
-0.2035057098,
0.9850311279,
0.4425949156,
0.160658434,
-0.1684484929,
0.1053356081,
0.2198540717,
-0.6741625071,
-0.5087897182,
-0.391928941,
0.2457211018,
-0.3615770042,
-0.4310496449,
0.6588472724,
-0.1131676137,
-0.3145946264,
-0.3859863877,
0.2231618762,
0.364030242,
0.3543227017,
0.179565832,
0.4479954839,
-0.1693103909,
-0.3910091817,
0.0016020694,
-0.6872658134,
-0.5385020375,
0.9869573116,
0.5396637321,
0.6739871502,
0.4699394703,
0.1969656646,
0.2642819881,
0.1620079726,
-0.958329916,
0.4053883851,
-0.0368759967,
-0.6831846237,
-0.1196784824,
-0.4401013553,
-0.4385685027,
0.365521431,
-0.109334372,
-0.447483629,
0.3271284401,
0.0517210811,
-0.455966413,
0.5613421798,
-0.6795486212,
0.5995473862,
-0.4632074535,
-0.0017059363,
-0.3378254175,
-0.4943816364,
0.546508491,
-0.2036325932,
0.3101970851,
-0.0734532401,
0.1148471758,
0.6914864779,
-0.1267374456,
1.2316641808,
-0.3023343682,
-0.2956127822,
0.2836843729,
0.0244541969,
0.3433542252,
0.3724572659,
-0.0703905672,
0.0359684378,
-0.0603874214,
-0.1112214923,
-0.7574288845,
0.3899190128,
-0.802359283,
-0.9148759842,
-0.4475387633,
-0.6076595187,
-0.4468011558,
0.0013360002,
0.0951313749,
0.7519955635,
-0.0567438789,
0.5128480792,
1.294020772,
-0.4440266788,
0.18224819,
0.9012646675,
-0.2214027047,
-0.0413346067,
0.9122307301,
0.1692035496,
0.3387740254,
0.5156615973,
0.3290849924,
-0.6325378418,
-0.714836061,
-0.3431125581,
0.3136713207,
-1.2056263685,
-0.1662082225,
-0.7507225871,
-0.0841091499,
-0.3501751125,
0.2707098722,
-0.0758706257,
0.0963520184,
-0.2101258337,
-0.3366679251,
0.4592531323,
0.7968205214,
0.0117170364,
0.1367716789,
-0.854069829,
0.4281838536,
0.4771481156,
0.2368198633,
-0.1748711914,
-0.5765752196,
-0.2400860041,
0.1999423802,
0.1736079603,
-0.9466008544,
0.1950734556,
0.1985749304,
0.9485231042,
0.554956913,
0.0770098642,
0.3138799071,
-0.1433552504,
0.5714119077,
-0.043329794,
-1.036342144,
0.4176080823,
-0.1383973658,
0.2427928895,
0.3371025324,
0.5223576427,
-0.6912831068,
-0.2482112944,
-0.3804199696,
-0.1358567774,
0.7879018188,
-0.1794877797,
-0.0878998712,
0.0400132872,
0.189810276,
0.5910288692,
0.3887951076,
-0.6613891721,
-0.5001193881,
-0.1318510473,
-0.2397569865,
0.0177820269,
-0.4093876779,
-0.2054585069,
-0.211625129,
0.5260047317,
-0.4119484723,
-0.0089582847,
0.0500078872,
-0.4169591069,
0.1735161096,
0.5673931837,
0.5049151778,
0.9395941496,
-0.1884785295,
0.4094756544,
0.320229739,
-0.3631921709,
0.0643092319,
-0.0293479897,
-0.3888968229,
-0.0868831277,
0.3478717208,
1.1863992214,
0.2657044828,
-0.748460114,
0.5194087029,
-0.0933959484,
0.0066557666,
-0.1201882437,
0.1078414768,
0.0883490667,
0.0167867336,
0.40658167,
0.4625539184,
0.0476680547,
-0.6115011573,
0.2688477933,
0.2261688262,
-0.078757517,
-0.5215908289,
0.1041522399,
-0.017863974,
0.26864627,
0.6056047678,
-0.4146200418,
-0.6703464389,
0.6027052402,
0.6675825119,
0.3750254214,
-0.3059271872,
0.6140130162,
0.2760465145,
0.4359968901,
0.0564849861,
0.2795009017,
0.0062377793,
-1.3701924086,
-0.6006980538,
-0.5258646607,
-0.4337651134,
0.2579762936,
-0.365498513,
0.0995323136,
-0.5328511,
0.0826704204,
-0.359708935,
0.0833949223,
-0.8533925414,
0.4030968249,
0.3249853253,
1.1026600599,
-0.9885611534,
0.8269500136,
0.5575199723,
-0.501960814,
-0.9067768455,
0.0246980432,
0.1521871537,
-0.9201229215,
0.9897933006,
0.0430494733,
-0.241084829,
-0.0494433269,
-0.7051520348,
-1.028924942,
0.7987657785,
0.7372988462,
-0.4223888218,
0.1789472252,
0.1299918294,
0.2054393739,
-0.4707554579,
0.336842984,
0.3883858025,
0.6897681355,
0.1217467934,
-0.7994478941,
-0.1362431049,
0.0105151786,
-0.4889378846,
-0.2927905023,
-0.6292957664,
1.0779412985,
-0.3562191427,
-0.3997392356,
-0.3521778882,
0.6187747121,
0.714497149,
0.3635626733,
0.576610744,
0.3841196895,
1.0764088631,
-0.0365675688,
0.9979106188,
-0.1915243119,
0.3699095845,
0.8929181695,
-0.2527893484,
0.4402289987,
0.2624087036,
-0.2059794664,
0.6248667836,
0.6842700839,
-0.0460306108,
0.3920839429,
-0.1765892059,
-0.3256367147,
-0.5512503386,
-0.2637448609,
-0.1549730748,
0.6065062881,
0.7850465775,
-0.1408139765,
-0.3761253059,
0.0953209251,
0.1169479415,
-0.0102693141,
-0.0772963092,
0.7368161082,
0.1237377301,
-0.6491466761,
0.3117316663,
0.003498659,
0.6343426704,
-0.8203145266,
-0.2172484696,
-0.1044582203,
-0.2063456625,
-0.1018850133,
-1.0051337481,
-0.1068796217,
-0.0279881731,
-0.2105863988,
-0.158792153,
0.8389322162,
-0.4365542829,
-0.2560077906,
0.0999009684,
0.7526475787,
0.0967824459,
-0.1383840442,
-0.6440701485,
0.1158854216,
0.2717568576,
-0.1076020747,
0.2319874167,
0.5931589007,
0.2179352939,
0.9078796506,
0.5947772264,
0.1523177177,
0.0939064324,
0.2454849482,
0.7789518833,
-0.4103536606,
-0.431691736,
-0.8108994961,
0.5029864311,
0.0173206143,
-0.2053399831,
1.1752676964,
0.5145527124,
0.6301276684,
-0.0516814217,
1.1237411499,
0.182117641,
0.671530962,
-0.9620056152,
0.7542942762,
-0.1386855841,
0.3503040373,
0.301004678,
-0.571295023,
-0.0871836841,
0.46858868,
-0.5310741067,
0.0807180181,
0.6774157882,
0.4979501665,
0.0258279089,
0.3893499374,
0.4442555904,
0.4876001179,
0.3639519215,
0.2315378189,
1.1061688662,
-0.1298798174,
0.1370351017,
-0.1186283603,
-0.1824447066,
0.0192905888,
-0.9096429348,
-0.838026762,
-0.7755349874,
-0.2821998,
-0.0183655694,
-0.1450396478,
1.0253458023,
0.5947138071,
-1.0518791676,
-0.2018921226,
0.0527022518,
0.5920760632,
0.1077988893,
-0.2366779447,
0.4586121738,
-0.6716928482,
-0.5080749989,
0.6659507751,
0.2970030606,
-0.0684434548,
-0.3887178004,
-0.1777683198,
-0.2458259314,
-0.0970430821,
0.7399685979,
0.1797068864,
-0.8190216422,
-0.402790904,
0.1028875113,
0.0766534284,
0.0908272862,
0.7778593302,
-0.9312707782,
0.5989763141,
0.4834965467,
0.6635832787,
0.0633852482,
-0.0282548927,
0.5864214897,
-0.6101047397,
-0.1311969161,
0.0228379443,
0.6757509708,
0.6152667403,
-0.4454798996,
-0.0570977405,
0.5202753544,
-0.4184157848,
-0.5670835972,
0.3508636951,
-0.653676331,
-0.3180686533,
1.2686015368,
-0.4051854312,
-0.1846957058,
-0.6022698879,
-0.0328469016,
0.0824362636,
-0.3899626732,
0.5301876664,
0.8001281023,
-0.1367694587,
-0.389077872,
-0.6417028904,
0.5341919065,
0.2250790745,
-0.6612234712,
0.0820180327,
0.4578594267,
0.494838655,
0.207357198,
0.2948558629,
0.0877207443,
-0.049836833,
-0.1148087904,
-0.2195060998,
0.0414452441,
-0.4904559553,
-0.1909825057,
0.3153259158,
0.2805519104,
0.1310276538
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12276v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12276v1 | CodeNav: Beyond tool-use to using real-world codebases with LLM agents | 2024-06-18T05:10:38 | 2024-06-18T05:10:38 | Tanmay Gupta, Luca Weihs, Aniruddha Kembhavi | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.SE | We present CodeNav, an LLM agent that navigates and leverages previously
unseen code repositories to solve user queries. In contrast to tool-use LLM
agents that require ``registration'' of all relevant tools via manual
descriptions within the LLM context, CodeNav automatically indexes and searches
over code blocks in the target codebase, finds relevant code snippets, imports
them, and uses them to iteratively generate a solution with execution feedback.
To highlight the core-capabilities of CodeNav, we first showcase three case
studies where we use CodeNav for solving complex user queries using three
diverse codebases. Next, on three benchmarks, we quantitatively compare the
effectiveness of code-use (which only has access to the target codebase) to
tool-use (which has privileged access to all tool names and descriptions).
Finally, we study the effect of varying kinds of tool and library descriptions
on code-use performance, as well as investigate the advantage of the agent
seeing source code as opposed to natural descriptions of code. All code will be
made open source under a permissive license. | [
-0.2199693322,
-0.190272063,
0.2748535275,
0.0970744342,
-0.1446655542,
0.6357680559,
-0.1191496626,
-0.421217531,
0.3793033361,
0.6766143441,
-0.3860582411,
-0.747730732,
0.0974947214,
-0.0669028759,
-0.5001681447,
0.4745383263,
0.0434978269,
-0.0736825094,
-0.4986565709,
-0.1455149949,
-0.2928195,
-0.9323395491,
-0.1062908396,
-0.2237074673,
0.7335981727,
0.6689345241,
0.8761478066,
0.6433574557,
0.6576121449,
0.224922061,
0.2121540755,
0.0655958131,
-0.5030976534,
0.4326300621,
-0.0966563076,
-0.8900347948,
-0.3097645342,
-0.0288314279,
0.1864191294,
0.3085253537,
-0.1206234172,
0.3060277998,
-0.0706158057,
0.6167836189,
-0.6813806891,
0.0155888759,
-0.5681861043,
0.0644571483,
-0.2266743928,
-0.5565220714,
-0.1737402081,
-0.4970830083,
0.0559715331,
-0.5708887577,
-0.0246305354,
-0.0149330087,
0.6842970848,
0.5686144233,
-0.4296852648,
-0.4017196,
-0.6299307942,
0.4941748977,
-0.4571100771,
0.1534665823,
0.2113059908,
0.6089892983,
-0.2343960851,
-0.9513795376,
-0.2462719232,
-0.4732543528,
0.0295557342,
-0.0109589463,
-0.2946811318,
-0.0309278667,
0.2955228686,
0.2780109048,
-0.5095953345,
0.0735699162,
-0.3898348212,
-0.4373778701,
0.6227693558,
0.2743166387,
0.2457713634,
0.2527134418,
-0.5020688772,
0.0070910617,
-0.9288604259,
0.1925699264,
0.2809110284,
0.0374947488,
0.2993685305,
0.7633569837,
-0.1015006155,
0.5917257667,
-0.5325074792,
0.1352715194,
0.4631735981,
-0.2835445702,
-0.119639948,
-0.1236283109,
0.2698112428,
0.4786912203,
0.4680406749,
-0.4771335423,
-0.3099127114,
0.0034353251,
0.5156302452,
-0.7056644559,
-0.3006283939,
0.1508252919,
-0.4712757468,
-0.4344069362,
0.2055038363,
-0.43059659,
-0.9205967784,
-0.1409974098,
0.1679946631,
0.1554755121,
-0.3542609513,
-0.1458859742,
-0.2786842287,
0.4918223023,
0.3195775151,
-0.0136102438,
0.3309370875,
0.4971507192,
0.8584039807,
-0.3538838625,
-0.2489562333,
-0.7055350542,
-0.0003198492,
-0.3057982028,
0.6677413583,
-0.6213128567,
-0.6522591114,
0.064674817,
-0.0252629723,
0.3911662996,
-0.7419913411,
-0.0891713724,
-0.8043814898,
-0.3635545373,
-0.2235248238,
-0.3383046091,
-0.2701768279,
0.3491988778,
-0.8017421961,
1.0882633924,
0.2373164147,
-0.2316999584,
0.3386292756,
-0.7315277457,
-0.308781445,
0.2354244143,
-0.3374665976,
0.0413676761,
-0.0106835421,
-0.1696162522,
0.3700000048,
0.0004880878,
-0.0637065843,
-0.1240129471,
-0.6569330096,
0.4115535319,
0.1396603435,
0.5883243084,
0.5344610214,
-0.3627984822,
0.2327652276,
-0.5424465537,
0.062921837,
0.1581095606,
-0.484459132,
-0.1895756721,
0.2053833306,
-0.0459427051,
0.1757383794,
0.3423177302,
-0.2833849192,
0.6908265352,
-0.463530153,
0.3770990074,
0.3793056607,
0.012537946,
0.5744080544,
-0.2579568923,
1.0879250765,
-0.1610206515,
0.2129270285,
-0.2191342562,
-0.3880268037,
-0.5432686806,
-0.1154501513,
0.2786438763,
0.7357424498,
-0.9428156614,
-0.0573587604,
-0.0970897228,
-0.6082649827,
-0.2748385072,
0.3411051035,
0.3921279609,
0.0732866302,
0.128402859,
-0.5250756145,
-0.6497783661,
-0.7781569362,
-0.4663998187,
-0.2677418292,
0.0236347169,
0.600967586,
0.4398357868,
-0.483795464,
1.0581231117,
-0.6388427019,
-0.2942383885,
-0.3255751431,
-0.3282145262,
0.1197067797,
0.1563016176,
0.3473210335,
-0.892242074,
-0.2577371597,
0.0658942461,
-0.6836346984,
-0.251555562,
-0.1267090887,
-0.1575330049,
0.2075975835,
0.8408575058,
-0.2695205808,
0.6505737305,
0.3927063346,
-0.2147059143,
0.389434278,
-0.0606948733,
-0.0187095795,
-0.8758175373,
0.1176029444,
-0.3055341542,
-0.5622731447,
-0.4220111966,
0.6734333038,
0.2276283354,
-0.2164962739,
-0.7468756437,
0.4990933836,
-0.7335903049,
-0.6800000668,
-0.2037627399,
0.2111296356,
0.0243589655,
0.3955692351,
-0.3035774231,
1.4497019053,
0.4399653077,
-0.5317062736,
0.5346962214,
-0.0830806196,
-0.0473261364,
0.0343183912,
-0.5525228977,
0.2392299175,
0.3992089927,
0.2095775455,
-0.6999834776,
0.0386084318,
0.3154377043,
-0.3847928047,
0.0140510742,
-0.5948867798,
-0.8213518262,
-0.2849211395,
-0.4419108629,
0.0993722826,
0.6126893163,
-0.4767973125,
0.6868920326,
0.4911822081,
0.3169454038,
-0.6771638989,
-0.6891452074,
0.476038903,
-0.1578633636,
-0.5129201412,
0.0692603365,
-0.2160391659,
-0.4199573398,
-0.023820946,
-0.4658620059,
-0.4272134304,
0.5317254663,
0.5518736243,
0.22776784,
-0.1962858737,
0.4770944417,
-0.2368193716,
-0.0578268692,
0.0752661899,
-0.2433050126,
0.4011898339,
-0.4308691621,
-0.4493074715,
0.2378267497,
0.1208491251,
0.3428251743,
-0.5389480591,
0.2800410688,
0.2002375573,
-0.1734369993,
-0.3490683138,
-0.4797958434,
0.0276710652,
-0.5191470981,
0.1437180042,
-0.512009263,
-0.8639346957,
0.7108932137,
-0.3364699483,
0.0835632011,
-0.081384711,
0.5658186078,
-0.0944271162,
0.5463598967,
0.6961126328,
0.0426151864,
0.6227594018,
-0.4251744449,
-0.0623588562,
-0.4696864188,
-0.385222733,
-0.4590108693,
-0.4153152108,
-0.2594554126,
-0.7909856439,
0.2285515517,
0.16472359,
0.1659993827,
0.8003197312,
-0.7109758854,
0.8986256123,
0.4934997261,
0.0015139719,
0.6601015925,
-0.2549853027,
-0.0269103125,
0.2761707306,
-0.6673992276,
-0.6902352571,
1.3544758558,
0.1783380806,
0.8943500519,
0.10124062,
1.0783845186,
0.6999217868,
0.3088768423,
-0.974332571,
0.7039788365,
0.3512717485,
-0.6583115458,
-0.0556392968,
-0.249717921,
-1.1580492258,
0.3343640566,
0.1346863508,
-0.5011650324,
0.2781005502,
0.1931727082,
-0.1499116868,
0.1184152737,
-0.8725803494,
0.7727139592,
-0.2846159935,
-0.1867931932,
-0.2171612531,
-0.6028319001,
0.0582363866,
0.0909233317,
0.0609551445,
0.0141981663,
-0.7341390252,
0.2987416685,
-0.4447415173,
0.6803074479,
-0.3005705476,
-0.1241748482,
0.383538574,
0.4772658348,
0.5257431865,
0.1036703959,
-0.0053815888,
0.0903463811,
0.1404097676,
-0.3482607901,
-0.6051325202,
0.7603625655,
-0.6226783395,
-0.6812614202,
-0.4153343439,
-0.2870087624,
0.0568511523,
0.2999369502,
-0.0648999661,
0.6144636869,
-0.1598854065,
0.2759131789,
0.5656106472,
-0.0849758908,
0.4516481161,
0.6955429316,
-0.5486444235,
0.1670375913,
0.8609076142,
0.1248557568,
0.0652047321,
0.3165231347,
-0.1456803083,
-0.0811603442,
-0.6053985953,
-0.3109672964,
0.053519886,
-0.8284223676,
-0.3984947205,
-0.4488779902,
-0.0009110484,
0.1762272567,
-0.3039752245,
-0.3384610713,
-0.5776802897,
-0.4425642192,
-0.0324051492,
0.3998979926,
0.7568721771,
0.2102615386,
0.1562328339,
-0.7558762431,
0.2563484907,
0.1258454323,
0.5270796418,
-0.3571041524,
-0.0658898354,
-0.5753222704,
-0.2728453577,
-0.2176826745,
-0.9713512659,
0.3269988298,
-0.0244284607,
0.775747478,
0.0585459657,
0.3132125735,
0.3115414083,
-0.278609544,
0.8196992874,
-0.2174142152,
-0.7906989455,
0.5621201396,
-0.0489848703,
0.1742448658,
0.7343313098,
0.2545838654,
-0.2529446483,
-0.5672338009,
-0.3147355616,
-0.7918288708,
0.3883759081,
0.4469585419,
0.0658830255,
0.2332780659,
0.3688398302,
-0.0873362273,
0.3850900829,
-0.5300249457,
-0.4923773408,
-0.298031956,
0.2613656223,
-0.0142886369,
0.0083121378,
-0.3375656903,
-0.0734897703,
0.2380948663,
-0.2650316358,
0.168920517,
0.3457424641,
-0.8362677693,
0.05409877,
0.2421318591,
0.428116709,
1.078543067,
-0.1920074373,
0.1271701753,
0.1065156087,
-0.3807999492,
-0.0903320834,
-0.0159715042,
0.321963191,
-0.082935743,
0.1779992133,
0.0635600388,
0.2090048045,
-1.0491577387,
0.6408781409,
-0.1550585926,
-0.2029595226,
-0.4647246301,
0.4797857404,
0.2036604881,
0.7116839886,
0.5039910078,
0.191209957,
0.439764291,
-0.5302978754,
0.3090091348,
0.2486381084,
-0.4110979438,
0.0403468199,
0.64243716,
0.4952837229,
-0.556181252,
0.2472782582,
-0.0938135535,
-0.5797342658,
0.9628110528,
0.08084061,
0.9044961929,
0.2940596044,
0.089511916,
-0.2951236367,
0.339202404,
0.2502067089,
0.4748493731,
-0.4351224303,
-0.4380570948,
-0.3431000412,
0.1043563038,
-0.6944634914,
-0.4823362827,
-0.7069738507,
0.190969497,
-0.538787365,
-0.2057400495,
-0.3557163477,
0.2806325257,
-0.7204371095,
-0.2962600291,
0.0755988508,
1.4152659178,
-0.2954953611,
1.1191008091,
1.0539710522,
-0.6546860933,
-0.7143744826,
0.0239998791,
0.2173894495,
-1.0167716742,
0.5125898719,
0.1840307862,
-0.4363919795,
0.1007135287,
-0.8161574006,
-0.6559739709,
1.5728496313,
0.1314174235,
-0.4317231476,
0.1553118229,
-0.3431634605,
0.6795148253,
-0.4646477997,
0.1816657335,
0.6668516994,
0.2605194747,
-0.0830432996,
-0.6037998796,
0.0578086525,
-0.4266507328,
0.0576007403,
0.106449306,
-0.3599872589,
0.488027364,
-0.2809782028,
-0.176419884,
0.0336951092,
0.3084317744,
0.2450708151,
0.3794987798,
0.4737819433,
-0.0971594453,
0.5474795103,
0.1099348143,
1.1333862543,
-0.4921154976,
0.2403952628,
0.8521007895,
-0.3471311331,
0.6898763776,
0.4179832041,
-0.1874749511,
0.5704658628,
0.3690107763,
-0.1024493799,
0.1881240606,
0.4906001985,
-0.1103570238,
-0.1767300665,
-0.0645836219,
-0.5739274621,
0.1695252061,
0.1715334058,
-0.0562551096,
-0.1512778252,
-0.2015360445,
0.0032692975,
0.2986343801,
-0.1859623343,
0.7412411571,
0.1233870313,
-0.315100193,
0.5461931825,
-0.2290198058,
0.5548657179,
-0.6889510751,
-0.1500314027,
-0.4239819944,
0.0503222682,
-0.4213913977,
-0.9169245958,
0.2174933106,
0.1016525105,
-0.0060203574,
-0.35663715,
0.9637430906,
-0.0522957593,
0.0911655724,
0.5109930038,
0.7205372453,
0.4788998961,
-0.2889064252,
-0.7063506246,
0.0129537303,
-0.0428455211,
-0.3734576106,
0.4796101451,
0.2925263643,
-0.0723841786,
1.1592105627,
0.5970439911,
0.1378510892,
0.1117621064,
0.1950920373,
1.2829358578,
-0.7607333064,
-0.3319714963,
-0.5672751069,
0.478461951,
-0.071960628,
-0.0434104912,
0.7936047316,
0.6948512793,
0.8371747136,
-0.1337979436,
0.6685134172,
0.0435856096,
0.4401855171,
-0.3956605792,
0.6083638668,
-0.6587725282,
0.7740157843,
-0.1025321186,
-1.0414835215,
-0.5160233974,
0.3635338843,
-0.0986519009,
-0.234109655,
0.4931061864,
1.1216455698,
0.1576365083,
-0.505110085,
0.4959565401,
-0.1797219962,
0.4312634766,
0.3007992506,
1.2562115192,
0.0253489111,
1.1897877455,
-0.039285671,
-0.0742350146,
-0.5223954916,
-0.7921705246,
-0.9962183237,
-0.1990169436,
-0.0959193036,
-0.4075871408,
-0.0118999165,
1.103136301,
0.5962184668,
-0.5370603204,
-0.565695107,
0.1469902396,
0.5521313548,
-0.1402643472,
-0.2208939195,
-0.2593045235,
-0.3737405837,
-0.2134636343,
0.5675926805,
0.2671824396,
-0.1924591362,
-0.474825114,
-0.2169221193,
0.0587687753,
-0.0474253446,
0.3904425502,
0.5209239721,
-0.6112524867,
0.028208999,
0.2115258276,
-0.3670533895,
0.3499517739,
1.3307163715,
-1.2097318172,
0.5897935629,
0.38682428,
0.6586514115,
0.4868600965,
0.1131099984,
0.6417430043,
-0.8336568475,
-0.0643280596,
0.3590595126,
0.1689410657,
-0.173976168,
-0.4227422476,
0.8592546582,
-0.0734142959,
-0.5175340176,
-0.9148924351,
0.3351278305,
-0.9970076084,
-0.3856712282,
1.1397765875,
-0.2556890249,
0.098227948,
-0.5149056315,
-0.4683083594,
-0.1574043483,
-0.6570788622,
0.0703068152,
0.2345027626,
-0.1220390424,
-0.2156899869,
-0.7028192282,
0.3481087685,
-0.1054066345,
-0.7127831578,
-0.138360709,
0.5478287339,
0.2635696232,
-0.0355117731,
0.6629493833,
0.0195691474,
0.3743798733,
-0.106519632,
0.2777249813,
-0.6055107713,
-0.4419834614,
-0.4755866528,
0.057704255,
0.4410765171,
-0.2672344744
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12274v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12274v1 | SafeInfer: Context Adaptive Decoding Time Safety Alignment for Large Language Models | 2024-06-18T05:03:23 | 2024-06-18T05:03:23 | Somnath Banerjee, Soham Tripathy, Sayan Layek, Shanu Kumar, Animesh Mukherjee, Rima Hazra | cs.CL | cs.CL | Safety-aligned language models often exhibit fragile and imbalanced safety
mechanisms, increasing the likelihood of generating unsafe content. In
addition, incorporating new knowledge through editing techniques to language
models can further compromise safety. To address these issues, we propose
SafeInfer, a context-adaptive, decoding-time safety alignment strategy for
generating safe responses to user queries. SafeInfer comprises two phases: the
safety amplification phase, which employs safe demonstration examples to adjust
the model's hidden states and increase the likelihood of safer outputs, and the
safety-guided decoding phase, which influences token selection based on
safety-optimized distributions, ensuring the generated content complies with
ethical guidelines. Further, we present HarmEval, a novel benchmark for
extensive safety evaluations, designed to address potential misuse scenarios in
accordance with the policies of leading AI tech giants. | [
0.0363904499,
-0.7436228395,
0.0273046829,
0.2805584371,
-0.2319955379,
0.0748781562,
0.0469419062,
-0.6329650283,
-0.3641342521,
0.3753283024,
-0.3051525354,
-0.5236006379,
-0.4098547697,
-0.0318425223,
-0.5655896068,
0.9317361116,
0.1732466966,
-0.0867912024,
0.0235733911,
-0.1939988136,
-0.7565592527,
-0.5516206026,
-1.0445125103,
-0.031740658,
0.3768267334,
0.3427990675,
1.0149363279,
0.8949469924,
0.6084163189,
0.2912454903,
-0.1608070135,
0.0672186986,
-0.2551089227,
0.4165095985,
-0.3593094051,
-0.072291933,
-0.7717139125,
-0.3185444474,
0.4543791711,
0.6211848855,
-0.3862940073,
-0.1865480393,
0.2513491511,
0.3769730628,
-0.9424419403,
-0.1430715621,
-0.6003599763,
0.0710883588,
0.0452722125,
-0.2398159355,
-0.6538068652,
-0.6471344233,
0.063099362,
-0.5251261592,
-0.1145828664,
0.4315630794,
0.5158069134,
0.3583794832,
-0.6088921428,
-0.0935465023,
-0.5244140029,
0.6442814469,
-0.8011192083,
0.4206549227,
0.4117946327,
0.3697985113,
-0.527225554,
-0.7065912485,
-0.4807828069,
0.0551312044,
-0.0347269103,
-0.2856166065,
-0.0797154605,
0.1962238997,
0.1156666651,
-0.0967511311,
-0.5116667747,
0.1989789754,
-0.0786342025,
-0.522234261,
0.7878260612,
0.2328701615,
0.5314495564,
-0.2970409095,
-0.3651477098,
-0.4540026188,
-0.676922977,
-0.0991241634,
0.2328651249,
0.3653107882,
-0.0760057718,
0.3825691342,
-0.3474411368,
0.6288993955,
0.1194026172,
0.0184386689,
0.3089495599,
-0.3658851683,
-0.2169539481,
0.6560806036,
1.0363955498,
0.7414803505,
0.117492795,
-0.1544132978,
-0.1205664352,
-0.295045644,
0.5257065296,
-0.8446478844,
0.0232967343,
0.4184425473,
-0.2565187812,
-0.7916835546,
-0.0721427798,
-0.8977981806,
-0.6591036916,
0.3333612084,
0.4798744023,
-0.466488868,
-0.1627783924,
0.3758920133,
0.1419064701,
0.1002661288,
-0.0761778727,
-0.7394952774,
0.0861725584,
0.7350772023,
0.6692886949,
-0.1281244308,
-0.3891937137,
-1.0411741734,
0.2964678407,
-0.7041936517,
0.559122622,
-0.2928240001,
-0.4594300389,
0.342443645,
0.3312234282,
0.0850744322,
-0.230292514,
0.9606088996,
-0.8490253687,
0.0109389704,
-0.1879975945,
-0.4309325814,
-0.0869171694,
0.0806267112,
-0.6475575566,
0.7053453326,
-0.077576153,
-0.965292871,
0.6703050137,
-0.8805675507,
-0.8125047088,
-0.1066306978,
0.3495508432,
-0.4072960913,
-0.1990314126,
0.3476402462,
0.3999750316,
0.0648183748,
0.4038134813,
-0.3764657974,
-0.2065861076,
0.4014977515,
-0.5356861353,
0.847548008,
0.4155456722,
-0.4431873858,
0.4294066429,
-0.7701058984,
0.0517955646,
0.086724773,
-0.3540094793,
-0.5956807137,
0.3627565503,
0.1379579306,
0.1524842829,
0.1071788222,
-0.5912937522,
-0.2536468208,
-0.4921230972,
0.4282842278,
0.8022591472,
0.196063742,
0.4777733982,
-0.1631234586,
0.0928673297,
0.0611237399,
0.5418707132,
-0.0240355283,
-0.0058580325,
-0.6017876863,
0.2156042904,
0.4402256608,
0.7852497101,
-0.5144190788,
0.4743964672,
-0.3607416451,
-0.1820626259,
-0.3797085881,
0.0082661118,
0.5712400079,
0.7319678664,
0.3969363868,
-0.1735670418,
-0.3621966839,
-0.8453740478,
-0.5030472875,
-0.3336195052,
0.1054266393,
-0.0287046954,
0.2016537189,
-0.2944800854,
0.6737508774,
-0.2468408793,
0.056712877,
0.0646647364,
0.1487793326,
-0.3543907702,
0.9148609638,
0.6497974396,
-0.8198222518,
-0.2247594297,
0.1188779101,
-0.7841696143,
0.0328584276,
-0.0617183521,
-0.4579814672,
0.3877974451,
0.7343601584,
-0.2940727174,
0.2254663408,
0.3710742295,
-0.807107687,
0.0723674819,
-0.1244281903,
0.4887354076,
-1.244740963,
0.0984182283,
-0.4507628679,
-0.5217890143,
-0.7433801889,
0.1692456454,
0.4210630953,
-0.0244374666,
-0.8998034,
0.5172395706,
-0.1753342599,
0.1940472573,
-0.2358669341,
0.2528963089,
-0.0264414418,
0.0694389194,
-0.1990231723,
0.8039538264,
0.3772239387,
-0.4886714816,
0.2417731285,
0.4188334644,
-0.5369307399,
0.3923619092,
-0.7518127561,
0.3515920043,
-0.0369833186,
-0.0802893639,
-0.6104057431,
-0.671503067,
0.2906802595,
-0.2555404902,
0.3219831288,
-0.1480281502,
-0.3371140063,
-0.1052337736,
-0.1673097163,
0.7124695182,
0.4577177763,
-0.4486660659,
0.3415989578,
0.5192739964,
-0.4318661392,
-1.0330116749,
-0.7212578654,
0.2106522471,
-0.263586849,
-0.6109560132,
0.2420566529,
-0.1334641874,
-0.3208487928,
0.1128118485,
-0.0455205105,
-0.1162962243,
0.4326573014,
0.2964832783,
0.1444871426,
0.0647225305,
-0.1065988615,
0.5241873264,
-0.1640488505,
0.0521911532,
-0.085313499,
0.3134879172,
-0.0470035672,
-0.4150286019,
-0.4826645553,
0.6816732883,
0.7913502455,
-0.2128665149,
0.7195209861,
0.3457887769,
-0.6710337996,
0.0413647667,
-0.3569802344,
-0.0890655145,
-0.5422437787,
0.4067935646,
0.0798731744,
-0.8445520401,
0.3016376495,
0.2713625133,
0.5489577651,
0.3598630428,
0.2428444922,
0.0336211473,
1.3403021097,
0.5896046758,
-0.0503879152,
0.4190562069,
0.4449533224,
0.145329237,
-0.2793166041,
-0.4108290672,
-0.5315903425,
-0.0391448215,
-0.4674182236,
-0.1613722742,
0.2529738545,
0.1985408366,
-0.5005316138,
0.2265759557,
-0.3087390363,
0.557712853,
0.4575609863,
0.04168934,
0.2234633565,
-0.0328773968,
-0.1394375861,
0.1151368618,
-0.6970279217,
-0.4438532293,
0.8021191359,
0.1619028151,
0.8451484442,
0.2183104455,
0.408246845,
0.5682759285,
0.1735771596,
-0.486543715,
0.4778251648,
-0.1880884916,
-0.9261687994,
-0.2283243835,
-0.2996859848,
-0.7821158171,
-0.0171494,
-0.5699168444,
-0.6485116482,
0.1648563445,
0.3240767717,
-0.6038961411,
0.1636214256,
-0.6276413798,
0.9746178985,
-0.4579424262,
-0.4448662996,
-0.2969195247,
-0.8377046585,
0.2483460009,
-0.2186698914,
0.3896967769,
-0.0478758924,
0.0494332649,
0.7016056776,
-0.3149682581,
0.6832457781,
-0.1251982898,
0.1356815398,
0.3468337059,
0.423771739,
0.6229108572,
0.1099102646,
-0.3391885757,
0.0462336503,
0.2686255574,
-0.4217122793,
-0.3222464621,
0.7498013973,
-0.4351890087,
-0.5037121177,
-0.5257545114,
-0.6504873633,
-0.3200072944,
0.5236532092,
0.2163979113,
0.5384551883,
-0.3470205367,
0.4698222578,
0.5570932627,
-0.4449237287,
0.8827407956,
0.2715930343,
0.0734113976,
-0.5951052904,
0.5445945859,
-0.3140437305,
0.2674653232,
0.2489508241,
0.0496501736,
-0.4667443335,
-0.6808267832,
-0.4757622778,
-0.24814789,
-0.883253932,
-0.3233252764,
-0.7996174097,
-0.2094780058,
-0.4364319742,
-0.2938918769,
-0.423597753,
-0.366705358,
-0.0398011394,
-0.3116616607,
0.437240839,
0.4090650976,
-0.2706303,
0.2239846736,
-1.0341959,
0.1145562902,
0.2967038155,
0.5403214097,
-0.3818856776,
-0.1582556218,
-0.2045934349,
0.0368291885,
-0.0838490352,
-0.7985502481,
0.1041459367,
0.2627318501,
0.5175333023,
0.3608085513,
0.6826403737,
0.4861826301,
-0.6800705194,
0.8893459439,
0.1575405896,
-1.0139318705,
0.5777733326,
-0.307227999,
0.1000974402,
0.6782317758,
0.2056446671,
-0.5864029527,
-0.178527534,
-0.2050682157,
-0.9049409032,
0.5129497647,
0.2114866227,
0.300735116,
-0.3047092855,
0.3698583245,
0.125847891,
0.0881983563,
-0.4068947136,
0.0758539364,
-0.2892955542,
-0.4066799283,
0.1425873935,
-0.6153337359,
-0.3865969181,
0.2281589359,
0.6328056455,
-0.2305723727,
0.1763234884,
0.1015094668,
-0.1248021871,
-0.2050213814,
0.5105387568,
0.526691258,
0.4883266985,
-0.1516380161,
0.1387340277,
0.3743515909,
-0.4886766374,
0.1729813814,
0.3044168055,
-0.1857244223,
-0.1942126304,
0.3391453922,
0.6304729581,
0.1602815688,
-0.7374466658,
0.5140148401,
-0.3962618709,
-0.0658416972,
-0.0022788397,
0.4802213013,
-0.2125960737,
0.2282633483,
0.2951891124,
0.101643987,
0.1465794146,
-0.1557583809,
0.4207850695,
0.2922957242,
-0.5564100742,
-0.1143522188,
1.0786777735,
0.4772256017,
-0.4301765561,
0.4039750099,
0.0828563869,
-0.1956626922,
0.424746573,
0.4963718951,
1.1805080175,
-0.5011220574,
-0.058252655,
0.3883039355,
0.3916602433,
-0.1631109267,
0.354183197,
0.3475580215,
-0.5954595208,
-0.3914240003,
-0.6260068417,
-0.2529037595,
0.0527928621,
-0.6513195634,
0.0563112535,
-0.4664643705,
-0.2413985729,
-0.2395845801,
-0.3936140835,
-0.298683852,
0.3870325089,
-0.3284788132,
0.9756298065,
-0.5857448578,
0.4900785089,
0.7232338786,
0.0602289587,
-0.7325122356,
0.1463288367,
0.1516287476,
-0.2122577429,
0.1624315083,
-0.0365472436,
-0.2902224362,
-0.2517282069,
-0.4601535499,
-0.7483959198,
0.9821511507,
0.5387391448,
-0.622656703,
0.0650897399,
0.1487168521,
0.2139172703,
-0.247418046,
-0.3597652316,
0.3548091352,
0.1544092745,
-0.256593883,
-0.8988674283,
0.3684922159,
-0.2726781666,
-0.0622425862,
0.2353554219,
-0.4074083269,
0.3822101057,
-0.2004029602,
-0.3270699382,
0.1389882565,
0.6987634301,
0.0071001952,
0.437002033,
0.7939008474,
0.1133970097,
0.6807475686,
-0.1154969484,
0.9782574773,
-0.6492829323,
0.1235444173,
1.0485233068,
-0.0766987652,
0.8770980239,
0.392015934,
0.3940113485,
0.2614405453,
0.6978378892,
0.5329238772,
0.8535873294,
-0.4388050735,
-0.343203038,
-0.4099909961,
-0.2037510425,
-0.5029922724,
0.4175729752,
0.2055448741,
-0.3187541068,
0.0223540273,
0.0830596834,
0.2961927056,
-0.1780272573,
-0.0581034534,
0.7554349899,
-0.1289564967,
-0.8651646972,
0.5269890428,
0.0346888676,
0.3279978633,
-0.3979141414,
0.0027901186,
-0.2861738205,
0.2647870779,
-0.0720384121,
-0.8984109163,
0.4984864593,
0.1603348404,
0.0578142032,
0.0211329218,
0.8516420126,
-0.2671151757,
-0.3491207063,
0.3434457779,
0.0536979884,
-0.2341210991,
0.3690284789,
-0.6098524928,
0.1023567021,
-0.1982919425,
-0.1681226492,
0.2296403646,
0.1860549003,
-0.2938146591,
0.6841868162,
0.6124660969,
-0.3387650847,
0.2112376839,
0.0972511247,
0.6178115606,
-0.7007072568,
-0.6564871669,
-0.6670205593,
0.7463030219,
-0.1913376451,
-0.1621046364,
0.3742837906,
0.1777928323,
0.7392778397,
0.0920742825,
0.852660656,
-0.2206786573,
0.1201976687,
-0.6186956167,
1.1458637714,
-0.7169846892,
0.1689609289,
-0.4906669557,
-0.698105514,
-0.6502210498,
0.3572084606,
0.0003145927,
-0.1292168796,
0.5245885849,
0.9121069312,
-0.0221306812,
0.1048895866,
0.1970081478,
0.1066805273,
0.5070596337,
0.4567095637,
0.7456665635,
-0.5250030756,
0.7977203727,
-0.3814227581,
-0.1843032241,
-0.2620231509,
-1.4300320148,
-0.8166565299,
-0.467179805,
-0.4415874183,
-0.5218024254,
0.5251584649,
1.0264761448,
0.8080010414,
-1.0594049692,
0.0913705453,
-0.0115074543,
0.0472056903,
-0.3193069398,
-0.1347615868,
0.3787699938,
-0.2614273727,
-0.7286672592,
0.7131372094,
0.2078183293,
0.144825235,
0.2566737235,
-0.0430979282,
-0.0028689031,
0.1008243784,
0.5054600239,
0.2966299057,
-0.4424020052,
-0.8275052309,
0.0934877023,
-0.269393146,
-0.2625593543,
0.6208924651,
-0.1771309823,
0.5710200071,
0.6305192113,
0.9492950439,
-0.1525551528,
0.0822539106,
0.697403729,
-0.6356064081,
0.2526787221,
0.0508299768,
0.4549321532,
0.4969595671,
-0.6081681252,
0.3443806469,
-0.1758066416,
-0.646017313,
-0.8907635808,
0.2031476945,
-0.9505878091,
-0.2790867984,
1.1655490398,
-0.0480484366,
-0.2595852613,
-0.2924105227,
-0.1064209715,
0.3913772702,
-0.4700599313,
0.8268912435,
0.4526319206,
0.0516585521,
-0.0222162381,
-0.4352156222,
0.6738872528,
0.5102625489,
-0.805205822,
0.2071424276,
0.6927035451,
0.5016120076,
0.0737243965,
0.228226006,
-0.3831077218,
0.4979321957,
-0.0274736956,
-0.2526311278,
-0.0807906687,
-0.3558296859,
-0.2752991915,
0.3806926608,
0.2067312449,
-0.415197283
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12269v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12269v1 | Unveiling Implicit Table Knowledge with Question-Then-Pinpoint Reasoner for Insightful Table Summarization | 2024-06-18T04:55:09 | 2024-06-18T04:55:09 | Kwangwook Seo, Jinyoung Yeo, Dongha Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL | Implicit knowledge hidden within the explicit table cells, such as data
insights, is the key to generating a high-quality table summary. However,
unveiling such implicit knowledge is a non-trivial task. Due to the complex
nature of structured tables, it is challenging even for large language models
(LLMs) to mine the implicit knowledge in an insightful and faithful manner. To
address this challenge, we propose a novel table reasoning framework
Question-then-Pinpoint. Our work focuses on building a plug-and-play table
reasoner that can self-question the insightful knowledge and answer it by
faithfully pinpointing evidence on the table to provide explainable guidance
for the summarizer. To train a reliable reasoner, we collect table knowledge by
guiding a teacher LLM to follow the coarse-to-fine reasoning paths and refine
it through two quality enhancement strategies to selectively distill the
high-quality knowledge to the reasoner. Extensive experiments on two table
summarization datasets, including our newly proposed InsTaSumm, validate the
general effectiveness of our framework. | [
-0.3853511512,
-0.5434365869,
0.9387344718,
-0.0808783025,
-0.3746970892,
-0.0705656409,
0.1445165873,
-0.2531483471,
-0.1272023469,
0.4326037169,
-0.5349023342,
-0.5562207699,
-0.4378869534,
-0.2050773501,
-0.8262866735,
1.2353423834,
-0.1681352407,
0.0182973985,
-0.5663191676,
-0.0387164429,
-0.5177718997,
-0.2282885164,
-0.285333097,
-0.5157318711,
0.3820627928,
1.191161871,
0.2697727382,
0.6958482862,
0.2727664709,
0.1549945027,
0.0338566229,
0.356325835,
-0.323369801,
0.2943311036,
-0.2899703979,
-0.7446438074,
-0.3922182024,
-0.2692541778,
0.3098308742,
0.762558341,
0.0930492431,
0.3355214894,
0.2419006675,
0.7958775163,
-0.4220525622,
0.5952146053,
-0.7843922973,
-0.0792314559,
-0.1866903603,
-0.0036700373,
-0.3341705799,
-0.6839091778,
0.1198034063,
-0.4469506741,
0.3079134226,
0.0057173544,
0.6309735179,
0.3029922843,
-0.5548952222,
-0.1896299869,
-0.8302779794,
0.2658498883,
-0.5660718083,
0.3753873408,
0.1286536008,
0.5528287292,
-0.2469002753,
-0.9074257016,
-0.7355948687,
-0.1828941107,
-0.3366042376,
0.0364729352,
0.1213823333,
-0.1703325063,
0.2812809348,
0.2981174588,
-0.7165951729,
-0.3552445471,
-0.1259005219,
0.1241667047,
0.5156987309,
0.0206601955,
0.2146441787,
0.1435796171,
-0.3190882802,
0.1513486207,
-0.8051953316,
0.2783178389,
-0.1364525855,
-0.0711166263,
0.2074966729,
0.5794174075,
-0.3687514961,
0.6291216016,
0.1165369377,
-0.0182876308,
-0.4529563189,
-0.1728341877,
0.2719833255,
0.4390810132,
0.3440844119,
0.4146786928,
0.3354485333,
-0.359190613,
-0.154013887,
0.259367317,
-0.1205286086,
-0.8316126466,
-0.5388801098,
0.3355696201,
-0.086264506,
-0.0838619024,
0.0921356902,
-0.6884387136,
-0.3537179828,
-0.286162585,
0.4719622135,
-0.2934453189,
-0.2421647608,
-0.1507216096,
-0.2480774522,
0.3612121642,
0.4701789618,
-0.9495184422,
0.28213498,
0.7715524435,
0.7024163604,
-0.0431034938,
-0.1252047569,
-0.489834398,
0.631439805,
-0.5108138919,
1.1991722584,
-0.1850068122,
-0.1968418956,
-0.0860257596,
-0.1892297566,
0.2518361211,
-0.4036677778,
0.5621141791,
-0.3942661285,
0.3776887357,
-0.7981094718,
-0.5809713602,
-0.172226727,
0.4698230922,
-0.3427385986,
0.9341165423,
-0.0774324015,
-0.5883178711,
0.8952977657,
-0.6428034902,
-0.3359868228,
0.16969423,
-0.4478577375,
-0.391320318,
0.1839060932,
0.4670564532,
0.43909356,
-0.2557933629,
0.517608285,
-0.2043737024,
-0.4389198124,
0.2373979688,
0.0119819939,
0.2952149212,
-0.1324157268,
-0.4112749994,
0.3354577422,
-0.7245037556,
0.129166916,
0.2502376139,
-0.2320640236,
-0.1590428054,
0.2693641186,
-0.413174659,
0.3641861975,
0.0373438038,
-0.4088004827,
0.0235825554,
-0.1827760935,
0.3145942688,
0.5386317968,
0.2313717753,
0.4216786325,
-0.4645751119,
0.200693965,
-0.0022104455,
0.0895227939,
-0.209928602,
-0.3094467819,
-1.0161013603,
0.0783922598,
0.1052239612,
0.3124797046,
-0.7349315882,
0.2189296335,
-0.3139637411,
-0.5564190745,
-0.2941474915,
-0.001240489,
0.4183822572,
1.1038122177,
0.7135980725,
0.365771383,
-0.3194106221,
-0.8027575016,
-0.5283665657,
-0.254524976,
-0.0751376227,
0.0984971002,
0.615532279,
0.2844782174,
1.2890876532,
-0.6724601984,
-0.3136376739,
-0.6935389042,
0.1645168811,
0.3731715083,
0.6586541533,
0.2548252344,
-0.5333461165,
-0.4144615531,
-0.2957526147,
-0.7632561922,
-0.2225115746,
-0.0213114023,
-0.3660551608,
-0.1082688645,
0.730858326,
-0.6793542504,
0.3534626663,
-0.1458093226,
-0.4918150604,
0.6313185096,
-0.1680467725,
-0.0152720101,
-0.8217625618,
0.1064190269,
-0.2940938473,
-0.1296610385,
-0.5525653362,
-0.1428102702,
0.1561995149,
-0.1143794358,
-0.1341714263,
0.3443878591,
-0.5383250117,
0.029091062,
-0.254727155,
0.1759825498,
0.2961049974,
0.5535784364,
-0.0001788255,
0.5939232707,
0.1851107925,
-0.7230120301,
0.0603885576,
0.5441592932,
-0.3591712415,
0.691726923,
-1.0362840891,
0.0763458982,
-0.338835448,
0.1697089821,
-1.3342992067,
-0.2185048163,
0.1339380145,
-0.4235906303,
0.4186050296,
-0.4818128645,
-0.4987565279,
-0.2557569444,
-0.1071414948,
0.2394882441,
0.2915363312,
-0.852081418,
0.594076097,
0.3940643072,
-0.1268341243,
-0.609888196,
-0.5862442851,
-0.0817142352,
-0.2349977195,
-0.7116562128,
0.4775671363,
-0.1701626629,
-0.4229338169,
-0.0863233656,
-0.6935254931,
0.062759079,
-0.0324438289,
0.2352810204,
0.1237221509,
-0.093501091,
0.2796507776,
0.4951724708,
-0.568426609,
0.6392861009,
-0.4697065651,
0.4257290065,
-0.3739710152,
-0.3858169317,
-0.0397185273,
0.4811724126,
0.4182412624,
-0.3507702649,
0.5391106606,
0.3131211996,
-0.4174978137,
-0.3689537942,
-0.7019281983,
-0.5315195918,
-0.4138565063,
0.3280292153,
-0.4381848276,
-0.7536427975,
0.6335996985,
-0.275266856,
0.2628805339,
0.4288677871,
0.1481901109,
-0.3782602847,
1.2179188728,
0.3334111869,
0.2662464678,
0.0290984306,
-0.2721927464,
0.1082790047,
-0.4763429761,
-0.7708064914,
-0.686093986,
-0.1948975623,
0.0428719744,
-0.0258881114,
0.5250136852,
0.170870766,
-0.1694152951,
-0.0553765073,
-0.3637827039,
0.828284502,
0.6123231053,
0.1597607881,
0.4620659053,
-0.322055459,
-0.1355295479,
-0.0284558795,
-0.8012834191,
-0.4818791151,
0.5699745417,
0.1545793265,
0.5693329573,
0.1392797828,
0.570311904,
-0.0032982584,
0.2791285217,
-0.4607168138,
0.6942805648,
0.1819264591,
-0.7371909022,
-0.3331180811,
-0.3619993925,
-0.4121385813,
0.434309572,
-0.2584160268,
-0.4125490189,
0.2804531455,
0.464240849,
-0.0738757178,
0.1936614662,
-0.7124898434,
1.221103549,
-0.2410570234,
-0.544654727,
0.160091117,
-0.6693845987,
0.5456309319,
0.1947107017,
0.1155134514,
-0.3115413785,
0.0618686751,
0.6598846912,
-0.9562678933,
0.4065595567,
-0.404743284,
-0.0783670545,
0.2353467792,
0.3905504346,
0.5745144486,
0.3718942702,
0.2046976388,
-0.0360631421,
-0.1169699878,
-0.1430838853,
-0.8890132308,
0.5567419529,
-0.2849757671,
-0.6798264384,
-0.3643309772,
-0.5757598281,
-0.4004778564,
0.2689800858,
0.3756516874,
0.3931295276,
0.075381726,
-0.0244481638,
0.8128625751,
0.4089568257,
0.4032760262,
0.721413672,
-0.0754936561,
-0.1390775293,
0.8734314442,
0.2796268165,
-0.0888194144,
0.5472749472,
0.4155969918,
-0.6932454705,
-0.7334176898,
-0.5229813457,
0.151844278,
-0.7208592296,
-0.3130708635,
-0.6217010617,
-0.0411889702,
-0.0449588746,
-0.1637314558,
-0.1158788428,
-0.6816366911,
-0.0952986628,
-0.3929468095,
0.5012375116,
0.5084112883,
0.0507205613,
0.3990370929,
-0.6447181106,
0.2652902603,
0.7098446488,
0.4694084227,
-0.1893821806,
-0.5714054704,
-0.1168020219,
-0.1968814433,
0.093480818,
-1.2368860245,
0.3027162552,
0.2041686326,
0.7034851313,
0.439244777,
0.1916224808,
0.7378162742,
-0.4063861668,
0.4046192765,
-0.0115407817,
-1.000159502,
0.9138165116,
-0.2442188263,
0.3848493695,
0.8800723553,
0.3634732664,
-0.1713344157,
-0.4370106757,
-0.3769729733,
-1.1335963011,
0.6688217521,
0.0433760248,
-0.3968113363,
0.2082886249,
0.6760839224,
0.4380066097,
0.2121005356,
-0.9294515848,
-0.2910834551,
-0.310120523,
-0.1645954847,
0.1132061407,
-0.6725351214,
-0.1441490054,
-0.3227510452,
0.6742910743,
-0.2290812433,
-0.0034041675,
0.1409975737,
-0.5146471858,
-0.0339862257,
0.5405037999,
0.3530645669,
1.094096899,
-0.3844618201,
0.528275609,
0.3207108974,
-0.3026593626,
0.1415608078,
0.2319527417,
-0.4800638855,
0.0934938937,
0.3224096298,
0.2242246419,
0.195496887,
-0.3977069855,
0.5322865844,
-0.3099017739,
-0.2806587815,
-0.3854644597,
0.2734707296,
0.0247006211,
0.2808913887,
0.3811305463,
-0.262716949,
0.2802450657,
-0.212763235,
0.3120597601,
0.3965387046,
-0.566891253,
-0.093535006,
0.8427769542,
-0.0902942196,
0.108429797,
0.531999886,
-0.1650194079,
-0.5303955674,
0.3634455204,
0.6089654565,
0.5525760651,
-0.2441333383,
0.206115678,
0.3568219244,
0.4485109448,
0.0466637202,
0.7060171366,
-0.4359121025,
-0.4965985715,
-0.3645554185,
-0.0084225964,
-0.4040471315,
-0.0024428021,
-0.6136395931,
0.0929733366,
-0.4214145243,
0.2302743793,
-0.2542649209,
-0.2410714477,
-0.2705971599,
0.1303857863,
-0.191426605,
0.7764495015,
-0.8364664316,
0.4946549535,
0.390514493,
-0.5378221273,
-0.9052414298,
-0.0991550386,
-0.1617897898,
-0.68123281,
0.347784847,
0.1360048205,
-0.0812412128,
0.082471326,
-0.6726459861,
-0.8193699121,
1.1414374113,
0.5773633122,
-0.5912943482,
0.0479062833,
0.331569314,
0.3551973999,
-0.0793394819,
0.5441823602,
0.9360880852,
0.511064589,
0.3967808783,
-0.1609389037,
0.3647947013,
-0.4067938328,
-0.3922789693,
0.4014818072,
-0.2042720914,
0.5754951835,
-0.5621740818,
-0.101789102,
-0.5546240211,
1.0130820274,
0.5021958947,
0.5254745483,
0.606597662,
0.4495696127,
0.6234054565,
-0.5717439055,
0.5745577812,
-0.25810197,
-0.1638814062,
1.4693746567,
-0.124952361,
0.5309922695,
0.4680720866,
0.0705255568,
0.7252539992,
0.4405727983,
0.0974058658,
0.46976915,
0.1792824417,
-0.133850798,
-0.3865220845,
-0.2222847492,
-0.6460219622,
0.4453911185,
0.4814184308,
-0.0331123061,
-0.4532390833,
-0.4546890557,
0.1287211627,
0.0993602052,
-0.4938934445,
0.893815577,
-0.0100609967,
-0.6040478349,
0.2011740357,
-0.2120272517,
-0.0198517591,
-0.534460187,
-0.4176517725,
-0.5941268206,
0.122101225,
-0.3837854862,
-0.8505165577,
0.2854003608,
-0.0212154798,
-0.2253843546,
-0.1556682885,
0.7152891755,
-0.7264297009,
-0.2148832977,
-0.1290986091,
0.695392251,
0.0817730799,
-0.42918697,
-0.5084248781,
-0.4186644256,
-0.2494173199,
0.1437167525,
0.0320367403,
0.5827128291,
0.0210700985,
0.7145754695,
0.8182185888,
-0.1751068681,
-0.248022601,
0.2397202849,
1.0486619473,
-0.5491709113,
-0.8691924214,
-0.9635497928,
0.8283723593,
-0.1525187343,
-0.1992126852,
0.8595502377,
0.7102409601,
0.5496122241,
-0.0170862209,
0.4197171628,
0.273050189,
0.7034605145,
-0.5261420012,
0.9058596492,
-0.5095549226,
0.3708767295,
-0.4047321081,
-0.9355580807,
-0.3280474842,
0.5058178306,
-0.3271281421,
0.063257888,
0.7527091503,
0.5797460079,
0.1754042655,
0.2025906742,
-0.0139689706,
0.3896815777,
0.5769940019,
0.5985301733,
1.2055422068,
-0.1323682964,
0.991609931,
-0.334820807,
-0.4127616286,
-0.1127819568,
-0.9672798514,
-0.8962728977,
-0.6485024691,
-0.3028414249,
-0.2830526829,
-0.0345501825,
0.7385472059,
0.6701948047,
-0.8290950656,
-0.0895018727,
-0.5853925943,
0.4750357568,
-0.1844798774,
-0.2459864765,
0.7512519956,
-0.1496833414,
-0.0916251242,
0.3572223485,
0.2440663576,
0.1109520122,
-0.0083980206,
0.1602465957,
-0.0185211468,
-0.1750643104,
0.5375273824,
0.3593981862,
-0.3196993172,
-0.0473020524,
-0.0285833552,
0.257770896,
-0.0820017084,
1.0115920305,
-0.6927748919,
0.3471010029,
0.5222797394,
0.2252474129,
0.7891051173,
0.015935462,
0.5542261004,
-0.8094716072,
-0.111230135,
0.3351199925,
0.6128441691,
0.0058298758,
-0.4278316498,
0.4094753265,
0.0402650312,
-0.5763939023,
-0.7501117587,
0.1374131441,
-0.9497783184,
-0.1681371033,
0.6434309483,
-0.16214481,
-0.1973235309,
-0.4822804332,
-0.2315483391,
0.2944447696,
-0.3806926608,
1.104686141,
0.2086763829,
-0.3071477413,
-0.4129253626,
-0.0008461639,
0.8359722495,
0.3823410273,
-1.2605605125,
0.007291059,
0.5312359929,
0.059431918,
-0.1310076565,
0.4061620235,
-0.2657029629,
0.4266755879,
-0.1009790972,
0.0146802822,
-0.5541969538,
-0.795381248,
0.0044653392,
0.5072715282,
0.1324199438,
-0.0455696173
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12266v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12266v2 | Towards a Client-Centered Assessment of LLM Therapists by Client Simulation | 2024-06-18T04:46:55 | 2024-06-20T22:06:47 | Jiashuo Wang, Yang Xiao, Yanran Li, Changhe Song, Chunpu Xu, Chenhao Tan, Wenjie Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | Although there is a growing belief that LLMs can be used as therapists,
exploring LLMs' capabilities and inefficacy, particularly from the client's
perspective, is limited. This work focuses on a client-centered assessment of
LLM therapists with the involvement of simulated clients, a standard approach
in clinical medical education. However, there are two challenges when applying
the approach to assess LLM therapists at scale. Ethically, asking humans to
frequently mimic clients and exposing them to potentially harmful LLM outputs
can be risky and unsafe. Technically, it can be difficult to consistently
compare the performances of different LLM therapists interacting with the same
client. To this end, we adopt LLMs to simulate clients and propose ClientCAST,
a client-centered approach to assessing LLM therapists by client simulation.
Specifically, the simulated client is utilized to interact with LLM therapists
and complete questionnaires related to the interaction. Based on the
questionnaire results, we assess LLM therapists from three client-centered
aspects: session outcome, therapeutic alliance, and self-reported feelings. We
conduct experiments to examine the reliability of ClientCAST and use it to
evaluate LLMs therapists implemented by Claude-3, GPT-3.5, LLaMA3-70B, and
Mixtral 8*7B. Codes are released at https://github.com/wangjs9/ClientCAST. | [
-0.4206168056,
-0.5004409552,
0.5322277546,
0.3819812238,
-0.1911614835,
0.3776297569,
-0.1786538661,
-0.5241723061,
0.337587893,
0.2491092533,
-0.4912164211,
-0.2856301665,
-0.5147558451,
0.0914698392,
0.066048488,
0.5703172684,
-0.1208877936,
0.8585609794,
-0.4047144353,
-0.2088187635,
-0.5518060923,
-0.5086272955,
-0.6510156393,
-0.6608532667,
0.5061686635,
0.3120605946,
0.2617288232,
0.136418581,
0.3605498374,
0.2092340738,
0.1250649542,
-0.0517086312,
-0.6107994318,
-0.0379855521,
-0.0257946234,
-0.256311208,
-0.9504554868,
0.5355594754,
0.5915262699,
1.0396243334,
-0.5147849917,
0.3866722286,
0.043746464,
0.2625805438,
-0.3808666766,
-0.3609743416,
-0.4963093698,
0.3046128452,
0.0691409037,
-0.2702167034,
-0.4685954154,
-0.5411483645,
0.304138273,
-0.1149679795,
0.2844956815,
0.0532080196,
0.180189088,
0.0182933193,
-0.6105404496,
0.0215045586,
-0.6470476985,
0.5644955635,
-0.5516157746,
0.3673850596,
0.048957523,
0.5763078332,
-0.2282468975,
-0.5985812545,
-0.2124346495,
-0.3735851347,
0.2625063658,
0.5031762719,
0.2362528294,
0.2039780021,
0.4751857221,
0.0855469331,
-0.517054081,
0.4512014091,
-0.1065757573,
-0.1581530422,
0.6003298163,
0.3923405409,
0.1045012176,
0.2568460703,
-0.6637175083,
0.2483190149,
-0.7840710878,
0.1694040149,
0.2517297268,
-0.0523116551,
0.1827409565,
0.563714087,
0.344247818,
0.3088165522,
0.0616083778,
-0.4966038167,
-0.0965680107,
0.2969492674,
-0.3972119987,
0.4756537974,
0.5602400303,
0.933595717,
-0.0718992427,
-0.1411175132,
0.0803010836,
-0.0011739233,
0.6869117618,
-0.9659394622,
0.1809566468,
0.5571640134,
-0.7052301764,
-0.3442088664,
-0.1908794194,
-0.5921315551,
-0.4580308497,
-0.3009518385,
0.2913822234,
-0.2367061973,
-0.4843724966,
0.1815532148,
0.0528442673,
0.3577447534,
0.7226810455,
-0.4187101424,
0.7689250708,
0.5596293807,
0.4089811742,
-0.3173071146,
-0.2784645259,
-0.4025371373,
0.2267795205,
0.0267932434,
0.5877861977,
-0.0467693247,
-0.8816791773,
0.0478134491,
0.0656762719,
-0.0655791238,
-0.5339185596,
0.2663800418,
-0.4221417308,
0.1676226407,
-0.4579481781,
-0.9657718539,
0.1062499806,
0.7236946225,
-0.216952607,
0.5170688033,
0.3195827901,
-0.6853635907,
0.4302081466,
-0.6292924881,
0.0226601195,
0.375852406,
-0.2163057029,
-0.2484091669,
0.1177848876,
-0.2249504775,
0.2652423084,
-0.1773428768,
0.0656291768,
-0.7801390886,
-0.7046312094,
0.799441278,
-0.3940942883,
0.6596209407,
0.0905746892,
-0.0240342263,
-0.0045031728,
-0.514224112,
0.2189888507,
-0.0403263085,
-0.1559904218,
0.0989477783,
-0.2272207439,
0.2596786618,
-0.0347403437,
0.1688371301,
-0.8198838234,
0.4249760211,
-0.1616542488,
-0.0789743736,
0.6143186092,
0.2229769081,
0.1509780288,
-0.6061650515,
0.9473567009,
-0.2747696638,
0.6537617445,
0.3753550649,
-0.2916980386,
-0.332237035,
-0.4740525782,
0.0515323952,
0.202821508,
-0.3872023821,
0.0508360378,
-0.0035641459,
-0.7803256512,
-0.4419584572,
0.0966033414,
0.4330185056,
0.5826676488,
0.0823670998,
-0.8403630257,
-0.349242419,
-0.6049989462,
-0.3326441944,
-0.1458978653,
0.0467911474,
0.2504930198,
0.1915497929,
-0.2479390204,
0.7692418098,
-0.1708192378,
-0.3279614151,
-0.304012835,
-0.2461439073,
0.1437279433,
0.5430518985,
0.6140800118,
-0.3656148016,
-0.5983246565,
-0.1103099883,
-0.8356235623,
0.002411576,
-0.04780332,
0.1844125837,
-0.2895587683,
0.2255598605,
-0.2548488677,
0.4746855795,
0.3124192953,
-0.2311800569,
0.713255465,
-0.5159941316,
0.1082563624,
-0.6295172572,
0.196027413,
-0.2131754309,
-0.3820002079,
-0.6142188311,
-0.272270292,
-0.2429080606,
0.0013193485,
-0.7611692548,
0.53837502,
-0.3718019724,
-0.4630870819,
-0.3373361528,
0.1844305098,
-0.0572262444,
0.28044945,
-0.2971141636,
0.6028878093,
0.435283035,
-0.2384526879,
0.394336313,
0.0012488802,
-0.071470812,
1.021597147,
-0.5655827522,
0.4588366747,
0.112637192,
0.3130167723,
-0.5331699848,
-0.0820670873,
0.3108661473,
-0.2285379618,
0.4023816586,
-0.3346164525,
-0.3310358822,
-0.2713433206,
-0.4335942566,
0.645911634,
0.393956989,
-0.1763149202,
0.5149463415,
0.2311414331,
0.0733083561,
-0.5697040558,
-0.2940673232,
0.055365283,
-0.5276529789,
-0.445443958,
0.0651634708,
-0.3657438457,
-0.1939617246,
-0.2529941201,
0.0155972168,
0.1703059077,
0.3634610176,
0.4970242381,
0.3842751682,
0.171408698,
-0.230149135,
0.05968979,
-0.1116987839,
0.3425003886,
-0.166353941,
0.4142451286,
-0.4639626741,
-1.0671538115,
-0.5562163591,
0.2537988424,
0.4408102632,
0.1653548032,
0.4808494747,
0.7302034497,
-0.2728247643,
0.0649196878,
-1.0085821152,
-0.1453698575,
-0.3823152781,
0.0979095623,
-0.2408594638,
-0.9775053263,
0.696713388,
-0.3966456056,
-0.0376805142,
-0.1251242608,
0.9720884562,
-0.3670662642,
0.9421106577,
0.3401113749,
0.2245345712,
0.133836478,
-0.4782676995,
0.0453624502,
-1.0676347017,
-0.3329402804,
-0.0387308709,
-0.4151249528,
-0.4313229322,
-0.4692075253,
0.6542961597,
0.0338643342,
-0.2591449618,
-0.061604917,
-0.4162106216,
0.2079571933,
0.2679773569,
0.2661364079,
0.38115412,
-0.2552902997,
-0.4602760971,
-0.2718418241,
-0.4916989207,
-0.7001309991,
1.2232826948,
0.8025137782,
0.4739575982,
0.1261136383,
0.828002274,
0.0502713583,
1.337443471,
-0.8119363785,
0.5425081253,
0.4707117081,
-0.6803757548,
-0.1244635582,
-0.0967997387,
-0.8444453478,
0.5282874107,
-0.0005726039,
-0.8916177154,
0.1771815121,
-0.1127677634,
-0.2499171197,
0.1341916919,
-0.3953536153,
0.7792183757,
-0.411547333,
-0.4199019372,
-0.4426246583,
-0.6743450761,
0.3541991413,
-0.1445965916,
0.2493509352,
-0.3650826514,
-0.0213620812,
0.4529676139,
-0.4840555191,
0.8877714872,
-0.5963285565,
0.0815720186,
0.2370198816,
0.439042598,
-0.0023357423,
0.4148260355,
-0.121995613,
-0.2326769829,
0.6062449813,
-0.704146564,
-0.8520120978,
0.5802384615,
-1.008310914,
-0.5346272588,
-0.4590606689,
-0.4291608334,
-0.7184609771,
0.0439599119,
-0.0606720299,
0.4292310476,
-0.8375331759,
-0.1496196687,
0.2621384263,
-0.1949805319,
0.1065538228,
0.8437294364,
-0.6410828829,
-0.7112312317,
0.6241371632,
-0.0537585728,
0.3245021403,
-0.4447393119,
0.0127013978,
-0.3314128816,
-0.7186537385,
-0.0627294481,
0.3806827366,
-0.6522313356,
-0.0237532444,
-0.1944061816,
-0.1546205133,
-0.1249258965,
-0.1745507717,
-0.38039276,
-0.025649555,
-0.1888722628,
-0.239148289,
-0.241624698,
0.7002628446,
0.0460833237,
0.3831157088,
-0.5379359722,
-0.3078700304,
0.3394666612,
0.3459499478,
0.0410782732,
-0.170003742,
-0.1988915354,
0.018937299,
-0.7560956478,
-0.6380650997,
0.3540976644,
-0.3477589488,
0.6979270577,
0.8982252479,
-0.0848657414,
0.666834116,
-0.3300924003,
0.653917551,
0.6343827248,
-0.6714591384,
0.2448156029,
-0.419798702,
-0.3017969429,
0.740803957,
0.2361721992,
-0.4499134719,
-0.380559355,
-0.9278999567,
-0.0806020945,
0.3881424069,
-0.0602798648,
0.0656582192,
0.091726087,
0.7037412524,
0.0951447561,
0.2252771407,
-0.6615484357,
-0.069324635,
-0.1087945178,
-0.00474614,
0.0496528484,
-0.4574202895,
-0.6750871539,
-0.115147911,
0.3005806804,
-0.253233552,
0.4192660451,
0.5945132375,
0.0822104663,
-0.4103864133,
0.1267645061,
0.5005431175,
0.7457405925,
-0.6540870667,
0.3077629805,
0.6564750671,
-0.3805140555,
0.3043137789,
-0.0687475577,
0.4979436398,
-0.2541956306,
0.5050252676,
0.2391427457,
0.2252840251,
-0.7472339272,
0.8137632012,
-0.382899195,
-0.5262233019,
-0.4864545763,
-0.0910951719,
0.1745471507,
0.427610904,
-0.0543538146,
-0.0373226851,
0.1369267404,
-0.3566883206,
0.1675953269,
0.5146068931,
-0.9070022702,
-0.3255822659,
0.405210346,
0.0348180085,
-0.3684895933,
0.4857881367,
0.0471919887,
-0.3632562757,
0.6619369984,
0.467829138,
0.7803459764,
-0.1611954868,
0.0121470559,
-0.1029423997,
0.0444678478,
0.0758797899,
0.2488189638,
0.1616273522,
-0.7157387137,
-0.4032809734,
-0.3098275363,
-0.9668784738,
-0.3102695346,
-1.0402474403,
0.126541689,
-0.723122716,
-0.5972011089,
-0.5795913935,
0.554587841,
-0.6442245245,
-0.1215621829,
0.1992694587,
1.1236714125,
-0.6170474887,
1.1073285341,
1.0221369267,
-0.1883419305,
-0.8346908689,
-0.3344932497,
0.0764333308,
-0.950137496,
0.6133856773,
0.1585147828,
-0.0697351098,
-0.166909039,
-0.5020002127,
-0.2733027041,
1.6268913746,
0.5600249171,
-0.1059486791,
0.0944862664,
0.4006663859,
0.796490252,
-0.5972614288,
0.7086430192,
0.3444997668,
0.3336575031,
0.2510793805,
-1.1037392616,
-0.0159894153,
0.0006794606,
0.1458511353,
-0.6468923688,
-0.7167001963,
0.3394168019,
-0.1811445653,
0.1959026307,
0.2305552363,
0.3477331698,
0.6623827815,
0.5484477282,
0.7474383116,
0.4006481171,
0.7286568284,
0.3235222399,
0.8879740834,
-0.4234239161,
0.5994479656,
0.8825377226,
-0.7827134728,
0.35430336,
0.7987152338,
-0.4573529959,
0.1549642831,
0.6437464952,
-0.1432434022,
0.0822121873,
0.4715929329,
-0.4531054497,
-0.2948491275,
-0.5762224197,
-0.3129988909,
0.3462912738,
0.2362622023,
-0.0038393277,
-0.2202169895,
0.273352921,
-0.071542412,
0.0375946723,
-0.0605616719,
0.5171204805,
0.630746603,
-0.2368335575,
0.2414338291,
-0.0994782373,
0.0164559148,
-0.3405301571,
0.0473097898,
-0.2113951892,
0.3952495456,
-0.1474646479,
-0.3006512523,
0.0030096434,
-0.1975375414,
0.3785536885,
-0.6924869418,
0.7314870954,
-0.2315304577,
-0.2725374401,
0.48364079,
0.8797137737,
0.3036606312,
0.289280355,
-0.7231808305,
0.1448783278,
-0.3285872638,
-0.3954995871,
0.9436326623,
0.2986986637,
0.3195778728,
0.9547929168,
0.6234468222,
0.4114647508,
-0.2368724495,
0.437466532,
0.8499462605,
-0.2231807858,
-0.0973308012,
-0.6275069714,
0.1099010184,
-0.0235841572,
-0.0476947911,
0.629648149,
0.5326467752,
0.3128693998,
0.1088334396,
0.3310011029,
0.2804274261,
0.5937238336,
-0.2320658863,
0.6581961513,
-0.6166629195,
0.4785268009,
-0.2826029658,
-0.8969874382,
-0.2243892699,
0.3936698437,
-0.2390781939,
-0.139976725,
0.5363482237,
0.5556589961,
0.1510094851,
0.1191954762,
0.514010489,
0.02803302,
0.7545620799,
0.5042700171,
1.2586660385,
-0.1613886952,
-0.0150187947,
-0.313118875,
-0.3283771873,
-0.2572703063,
-0.84176898,
-0.9225720167,
0.0394981466,
-0.283259511,
-0.439312309,
-0.3134488463,
1.24426651,
0.568502903,
-0.2993255854,
-0.7607042789,
0.342117995,
0.0073622894,
-0.2482124269,
-0.1606635749,
0.2242028266,
-0.0760940611,
-0.451014936,
0.3783861399,
0.2522098124,
0.2154368758,
-0.6491969228,
-0.2770807743,
0.3137696683,
-0.2906624675,
0.2643511891,
-0.0190900285,
-0.6617029905,
-0.4959514737,
-0.0629996136,
-0.2758842707,
-0.0481899939,
0.8826500177,
-0.7352804542,
0.4226279557,
-0.3387801647,
0.468324244,
0.6150121689,
0.0932934061,
0.6409852505,
-0.1103448793,
0.1687051803,
0.4160951972,
0.365681231,
-0.0095915534,
-0.2530905604,
0.32597211,
0.3103580773,
-0.5890522599,
-1.0421460867,
-0.1510309279,
-1.3898941278,
-0.0196160953,
0.7685894966,
-0.5930415988,
0.0458636433,
-0.192255199,
-0.4882708192,
0.2087363154,
0.0504242666,
0.5915405154,
0.3818587959,
-0.4660750329,
0.0392413475,
-0.683442235,
0.414760828,
0.5582909584,
-0.4637145102,
-0.2804001868,
0.1196126863,
0.8534775376,
-0.1600257456,
1.0349258184,
-0.1369934082,
0.1144680828,
-0.3905827999,
0.3844547272,
-0.2492729574,
0.1615697891,
-0.3112693131,
0.225203976,
0.5358681679,
0.2172774076
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12263v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12263v1 | Defending Against Social Engineering Attacks in the Age of LLMs | 2024-06-18T04:39:40 | 2024-06-18T04:39:40 | Lin Ai, Tharindu Kumarage, Amrita Bhattacharjee, Zizhou Liu, Zheng Hui, Michael Davinroy, James Cook, Laura Cassani, Kirill Trapeznikov, Matthias Kirchner, Arslan Basharat, Anthony Hoogs, Joshua Garland, Huan Liu, Julia Hirschberg | cs.CL | cs.CL | The proliferation of Large Language Models (LLMs) poses challenges in
detecting and mitigating digital deception, as these models can emulate human
conversational patterns and facilitate chat-based social engineering (CSE)
attacks. This study investigates the dual capabilities of LLMs as both
facilitators and defenders against CSE threats. We develop a novel dataset,
SEConvo, simulating CSE scenarios in academic and recruitment contexts, and
designed to examine how LLMs can be exploited in these situations. Our findings
reveal that, while off-the-shelf LLMs generate high-quality CSE content, their
detection capabilities are suboptimal, leading to increased operational costs
for defense. In response, we propose ConvoSentinel, a modular defense pipeline
that improves detection at both the message and the conversation levels,
offering enhanced adaptability and cost-effectiveness. The retrieval-augmented
module in ConvoSentinel identifies malicious intent by comparing messages to a
database of similar conversations, enhancing CSE detection at all stages. Our
study highlights the need for advanced strategies to leverage LLMs in
cybersecurity. | [
-0.1922965944,
-0.8803128004,
0.3668246865,
-0.0600528046,
-0.095539026,
0.7788729072,
0.038879998,
-0.4951540232,
0.3925828934,
0.4179235697,
-0.6990145445,
-0.482056886,
-0.5806810856,
-0.0943096131,
-0.6411812901,
0.681923151,
0.4021059573,
0.0794601664,
-0.1301661134,
0.2202715129,
-0.3027863801,
-0.7403030992,
-0.934022069,
-0.2567566037,
0.4751931727,
0.4301916659,
0.5611871481,
-0.2214733064,
0.3828387558,
0.4147410393,
-0.1539853066,
0.0650700405,
-0.8551473022,
0.3804774284,
-0.1567471474,
-0.5248916745,
-0.1793146133,
-0.198134467,
0.1259416938,
0.3315406442,
0.0192872249,
0.0515625812,
0.3281518817,
0.582560122,
-0.6917696595,
-0.1789503843,
-0.9632882476,
-0.3048472106,
-0.1941892356,
0.0261407215,
-0.6155508161,
-0.4442833662,
0.1494917125,
-0.3806556165,
0.0674286336,
-0.0270827748,
0.536583066,
-0.0375314318,
-0.3271807432,
-0.2829820216,
-0.499194324,
0.5013678074,
-0.6081601381,
0.2557780147,
0.1258706897,
0.492087096,
-0.5429935455,
-0.7213566899,
-0.1528086364,
-0.3458971977,
0.031114893,
-0.069515489,
-0.4374007881,
0.2229474038,
0.1648074538,
0.0736643299,
-0.578279376,
0.3338938057,
-0.6173006892,
-0.5641825199,
0.9124734998,
0.2124113441,
0.5088152289,
0.0064956448,
-0.2929864824,
0.0845884308,
-0.730283618,
0.0902909487,
0.5462591648,
0.1608288735,
-0.3387084603,
0.3117284179,
0.0386243276,
-0.0178656951,
0.1544036567,
0.1571391672,
-0.2316613942,
-0.0754777864,
-0.243728891,
0.2257684767,
0.8307077289,
0.0879364163,
0.3252714276,
-0.1503669769,
-0.0570545606,
0.4499017,
0.5720803738,
-0.8656930923,
-0.204780519,
0.3454661667,
-0.4394065142,
-0.6863747835,
0.0248154774,
-0.6370241642,
-0.8357409239,
-0.1400248557,
0.1396046579,
-0.4086960554,
-0.3212438226,
0.2373831421,
-0.2613295019,
0.2295744568,
0.1202766001,
-0.3926103413,
0.6296239495,
0.9340106845,
0.916018188,
-0.207752645,
-0.009557914,
-0.4145627022,
-0.0691265911,
-0.4482991397,
0.579982996,
-0.4438201785,
-0.7788543701,
0.2210564613,
0.0241561551,
0.249109298,
-0.3060000241,
0.5537568331,
-0.7814338207,
-0.2832370996,
-0.2108931988,
-0.4421439171,
0.0584474877,
0.3806942105,
-0.479916364,
0.8232833743,
-0.1674205214,
-0.8659344912,
-0.1253341734,
-0.406665355,
-0.3887127638,
0.3100720644,
-0.4265353382,
-0.3259533942,
0.2231828719,
-0.2713691592,
0.6320494413,
-0.3785203695,
0.2183205783,
-0.7902297974,
-0.509544909,
0.3548127711,
-0.4634665549,
0.830396533,
0.2752686143,
-0.194975093,
0.0309341624,
-0.4458670318,
-0.2359823138,
0.184630096,
0.0774806365,
-0.5243355632,
0.3378405571,
-0.4352647662,
-0.1000704542,
0.3423691392,
-0.7769010067,
-0.1279187053,
-0.5492084622,
0.409514159,
0.88390553,
0.1708223969,
0.4735087156,
-0.1918695718,
0.5803741813,
-0.1594966203,
0.4368374646,
0.247142598,
-0.1433738023,
-0.4306044877,
-0.3272381425,
-0.1477517486,
0.7357311249,
-1.1186840534,
0.0325565301,
-0.2203861624,
-0.8360346556,
-0.210207656,
-0.0866695568,
0.3292712569,
-0.1754695922,
0.0013652549,
0.1535553932,
-0.5807964206,
-1.12642169,
-0.3024721146,
-0.168426916,
-0.0443933345,
0.1348820329,
0.3657292724,
-0.2445984781,
0.7075443268,
-0.4765202701,
0.1262585819,
-0.2533906698,
-0.1483592987,
-0.0061598131,
0.2647905052,
0.6208658814,
-0.6822256446,
-0.4354524016,
0.0368929617,
-0.8490033746,
-0.254745245,
-0.1323440373,
-0.0727037266,
-0.2285898477,
0.7885283232,
-0.3897942305,
0.2850829065,
0.540122211,
-0.3763746917,
0.806356132,
0.2316523939,
0.2882102132,
-1.236042738,
-0.3952766955,
0.1792050749,
-0.1827690154,
-1.0282241106,
0.1305983067,
0.0384216793,
-0.4532731473,
-0.8986410499,
0.4368109703,
-0.4548006356,
0.2222108245,
-0.4092126191,
0.3378240168,
-0.1221690923,
0.189234212,
-0.5370203853,
0.8579653502,
0.8421607614,
-0.6095703244,
0.4863500595,
0.0511367284,
-0.2603204548,
0.8316056728,
-0.9476152062,
0.3598940074,
-0.0710994974,
0.3107498884,
-0.8579897285,
-0.1615842432,
0.040626131,
-0.5824423432,
0.4749597311,
-0.2501677871,
-0.2923841178,
-0.3971191347,
-0.8696150184,
0.219542563,
0.119734548,
-0.4841614366,
0.8686951399,
0.6590412259,
-0.2194288522,
-0.643473506,
-0.8194829226,
0.3482560515,
-0.2792966068,
-0.8915088773,
0.435713321,
-0.0250403509,
-0.5996094942,
-0.4663023651,
-0.139354974,
0.1791667193,
0.6005844474,
0.3424117863,
0.4072194397,
-0.0403821878,
-0.156593129,
0.0394774824,
-0.016946137,
0.4107855856,
-0.1650621146,
0.6490866542,
0.1899009347,
-0.6017808914,
-0.510238409,
0.4676089585,
0.6231978536,
0.1584276855,
0.5966858268,
0.1085310429,
-0.3191757798,
-0.3183982968,
-0.6482431889,
-0.5424830317,
-0.6422206759,
0.4433206618,
-0.2691838443,
-1.1279104948,
0.4716350436,
-0.2428012341,
0.2563292086,
-0.0075409845,
0.2664448023,
0.002211222,
0.7379935384,
0.3256319761,
-0.3784023523,
0.5131911635,
-0.2324619889,
0.4371067286,
-0.5893493891,
-0.2495045066,
-0.4635790884,
-0.2679833174,
-0.8412032723,
0.0857484341,
0.3844047487,
-0.1862653196,
-0.2262102962,
0.5383775234,
-0.5562737584,
0.5165995955,
0.2196888477,
0.4345445931,
-0.1288024634,
-0.1078072563,
0.1863891929,
0.128462851,
-0.4792176783,
-0.7589064837,
0.8331134915,
0.4826815426,
0.9503977299,
0.3702889681,
0.6737833619,
0.7141808271,
0.0684268102,
-0.5194451809,
1.0698100328,
-0.2374377996,
-0.5285642743,
0.067973204,
-0.2494335175,
-0.8914670348,
0.3211761415,
-0.2367372811,
-0.9066303372,
0.3457145095,
-0.046930518,
-0.4013106525,
0.3881039023,
-0.7166008353,
0.5881202221,
-0.3416002095,
-0.6152285337,
-0.5065069795,
-0.3449905813,
0.319462955,
-0.0538635366,
0.2531519532,
-0.2123552263,
0.1578071117,
0.4638575017,
-0.1013953388,
1.400549531,
-0.0624500178,
-0.0347407833,
0.3272710443,
0.5415410995,
0.8118677735,
0.0999682024,
-0.1058569029,
0.2812424898,
0.2104625702,
-0.4790359139,
-0.3152853847,
0.9531936646,
-0.6559866667,
-1.03010571,
-0.4955316484,
-0.1295333058,
-0.0310553629,
-0.1262715459,
0.0685972869,
0.4587163031,
-0.8154665232,
0.4163253605,
0.8130743504,
-0.392645359,
0.3109472096,
0.4607658386,
0.073953867,
-0.3591644168,
0.7011899352,
0.0296065789,
0.5695180297,
0.1377714425,
0.1181490868,
-0.1045184955,
-0.5237144828,
0.1406430453,
0.1615580171,
-0.5006944537,
-0.3658582568,
-0.7284682393,
-0.4528647661,
-0.5641804934,
-0.5783607364,
-0.1285612732,
-0.1995543838,
-0.1424204558,
-0.2739715576,
0.3620454073,
0.6569982171,
0.0165634546,
0.3970386088,
-0.4081145525,
0.0210210942,
0.3369154334,
-0.0652546361,
-0.0787388831,
-0.3656544387,
-0.0944409519,
0.2129225433,
-0.4043436348,
-1.1363885403,
0.0281570628,
-0.2182589918,
0.5380749106,
0.2907120883,
0.3141957521,
0.2075984031,
-0.3387040794,
0.9582224488,
0.0641924217,
-0.7118410468,
0.4222742021,
-0.3469474912,
-0.0589407161,
0.4805292785,
0.3780196011,
-0.5607724786,
-0.6098691225,
-0.7126270533,
-0.6115521789,
0.4334963262,
0.2714960873,
0.4294940829,
-0.1115693673,
0.3029717207,
-0.3011966348,
0.0034056583,
-0.5692412257,
-0.1457024515,
0.1880995929,
-0.2186607867,
0.3884029686,
-0.560554564,
-0.1914560646,
0.2177891135,
0.9599998593,
0.055608809,
0.0481336154,
0.0347498916,
0.0594015568,
0.5256571174,
0.350903064,
0.321344316,
0.1133549213,
0.2632204592,
0.1723318994,
0.6337723136,
-0.4707278609,
0.3114597201,
-0.1214958504,
-0.2607268989,
-0.1430667192,
0.1767948419,
0.3772232831,
0.3550156653,
-0.5144691467,
0.6434605718,
0.0672310442,
-0.2449184358,
-0.5619910955,
0.2271385789,
0.1426721215,
0.5003422499,
0.2810204923,
-0.2873262167,
0.2589322329,
-0.5745809674,
0.0959188268,
0.9472068548,
-0.2816496193,
-0.3255376816,
0.527379632,
0.2852630615,
-0.6362351775,
0.0933541134,
-0.0671766177,
-0.6348931193,
0.6729384065,
0.3211658895,
1.08875525,
-0.4012967944,
0.1956183463,
-0.0085542556,
0.471434325,
0.0380240232,
0.1228439435,
0.1914495081,
-0.6831954122,
-0.1848336011,
-0.1643013656,
-0.4630823731,
0.0195933189,
-0.3038714826,
0.6219388247,
-0.6051510572,
-0.2297036052,
0.0791605636,
-0.1386626065,
-0.398301512,
-0.312033236,
0.194737047,
0.9778324962,
-0.7373666167,
0.617990613,
0.3210020363,
-0.0531770959,
-0.4397484958,
-0.2285413444,
0.5880662799,
-0.4952014387,
0.4933453202,
0.1211327389,
-0.7330428958,
-0.2378151715,
-0.8804309964,
-0.4827824235,
1.1568362713,
0.5302665234,
-0.6853021979,
0.0316727944,
0.324826628,
0.4652813971,
-0.1973072737,
0.1135956794,
0.5033658147,
0.0620751716,
-0.0516520068,
-0.5186397433,
0.0672744736,
-0.1298414916,
-0.0529191941,
0.2516562939,
-0.8344849944,
0.3566857576,
0.2389908731,
-0.5818831325,
-0.3055470884,
0.5317806602,
0.3623353243,
0.4616693556,
0.3590340912,
0.0788627639,
0.5927011967,
-0.033535175,
0.8985490203,
-0.3939418197,
0.0284743551,
0.9559242129,
-0.4519138932,
0.5493994355,
0.2268723398,
-0.0571592189,
0.5343052149,
0.6188143492,
0.1325694323,
0.222296387,
0.4267556369,
-0.5636723638,
-0.2355241627,
-0.1709747463,
-0.0683660656,
0.1657429785,
0.4743973315,
-0.0166157782,
-0.1269924492,
0.1437822282,
0.4235489666,
0.4530867934,
-0.2861703634,
0.8142869473,
0.3711682558,
-0.2166781127,
0.2632721663,
-0.1347932816,
0.8480622768,
-0.8283330202,
0.3409515321,
-0.1784808487,
0.3262797594,
-0.1625630707,
-0.6502255797,
0.4213135839,
-0.1017722562,
0.180719316,
-0.016110165,
1.0866323709,
-0.0967479721,
-0.2844172716,
0.6598939896,
0.1760537773,
-0.1092730835,
-0.1540633887,
-0.8358679414,
0.2464410365,
-0.1423291862,
0.0239433404,
0.3692025244,
0.483825624,
-0.0410065204,
0.9647949338,
0.6947643161,
-0.0211210083,
-0.1503787637,
0.1592073292,
1.0888129473,
-0.1485970169,
-0.481990695,
-1.350528717,
0.2282171994,
-0.7269303799,
0.2510163784,
0.8402538896,
0.656946063,
0.6017497778,
0.2385510504,
0.7033960819,
0.1594033241,
0.4442312419,
-0.3642403781,
0.5889593959,
-0.2740445137,
0.6113449335,
-0.1897898465,
-0.3796381354,
0.0939468816,
0.0204925817,
-0.3745715916,
-0.447683543,
0.499699682,
1.2625591755,
-0.0743468776,
0.2628890872,
0.4209972322,
0.2713762224,
0.6964318156,
0.4348753095,
1.0248246193,
-0.2937965989,
0.5570739508,
0.2011672407,
-0.2728729844,
0.0573561341,
-0.5393230319,
-1.3898975849,
-0.2235685736,
-0.2686778307,
-0.6999284625,
0.4236342609,
1.0322051048,
0.5471455455,
-0.8374775052,
-0.2868974805,
0.2354686111,
0.1130903065,
0.0589103065,
-0.2075076699,
-0.0617800951,
-0.2533451915,
-0.4145466983,
0.7695099115,
0.4148940146,
0.0942370445,
-0.6511172652,
0.1318310797,
-0.3770025074,
0.6763786077,
0.7123121619,
0.196117416,
-0.5393335223,
-0.4195495546,
0.22834225,
-0.277677238,
-0.3896034956,
0.9479845762,
-0.4127171338,
0.0301419497,
0.6041360497,
0.9840934277,
0.2227794081,
-0.2634707689,
0.5882089734,
-0.7733789086,
0.2417224348,
0.1000058427,
0.4396190643,
0.2355901748,
-0.7013667822,
0.5722429752,
0.2037529945,
-0.5390777588,
-0.7484158874,
0.4027385116,
-0.5451417565,
-0.6542329192,
1.2186299562,
0.1078667641,
-0.1642733216,
-0.4572819471,
-0.3956413865,
-0.062438298,
-0.4718352258,
0.8702467084,
0.6202139258,
0.5187966228,
0.0775891393,
-0.5805193782,
0.446492523,
0.0937048644,
-0.6717217565,
0.1576849371,
0.4548110962,
0.2639214694,
0.2180546075,
0.47434026,
-0.003084735,
0.1490343511,
-0.2284335643,
-0.0936296806,
0.0389835089,
-0.2128934562,
0.0631093755,
0.2283891737,
-0.1478704512,
-0.2908111513
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12260v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12260v1 | Self-Supervised Time-Series Anomaly Detection Using Learnable Data Augmentation | 2024-06-18T04:25:56 | 2024-06-18T04:25:56 | Kukjin Choi, Jihun Yi, Jisoo Mok, Sungroh Yoon | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Continuous efforts are being made to advance anomaly detection in various
manufacturing processes to increase the productivity and safety of industrial
sites. Deep learning replaced rule-based methods and recently emerged as a
promising method for anomaly detection in diverse industries. However, in the
real world, the scarcity of abnormal data and difficulties in obtaining labeled
data create limitations in the training of detection models. In this study, we
addressed these shortcomings by proposing a learnable data augmentation-based
time-series anomaly detection (LATAD) technique that is trained in a
self-supervised manner. LATAD extracts discriminative features from time-series
data through contrastive learning. At the same time, learnable data
augmentation produces challenging negative samples to enhance learning
efficiency. We measured anomaly scores of the proposed technique based on
latent feature similarities. As per the results, LATAD exhibited comparable or
improved performance to the state-of-the-art anomaly detection assessments on
several benchmark datasets and provided a gradient-based diagnosis technique to
help identify root causes. | [
-0.351574719,
-0.6506482363,
0.2779516578,
-0.0783616602,
-0.3933867812,
0.1222683266,
0.4002488852,
-0.6566318274,
0.2922464907,
0.4083887637,
-1.0225422382,
-0.4224818945,
-0.2880622745,
-0.0643626451,
-0.4525338113,
0.9573985338,
-0.2042753696,
-0.4379859567,
0.0942328274,
-0.2328786999,
-0.3741285801,
-0.6548284888,
-0.5858223438,
-0.1845061183,
0.2254867852,
0.1741026789,
0.2410570681,
0.7248308063,
0.4792747796,
0.24332349,
0.2381629497,
0.6656247377,
-0.1438676119,
0.2381277233,
0.12803936,
-0.2711348832,
-0.5343676805,
-0.2783994675,
0.4038902819,
0.6618116498,
-0.1548680365,
0.1588950008,
0.2035604268,
0.672360301,
-0.4471596777,
0.1628235728,
-0.3104046881,
0.524861455,
-0.3527764082,
-0.3087520003,
0.1898643821,
-0.1818667799,
-0.2849330306,
-0.6059660912,
0.8288301229,
-0.0884380862,
0.5011186004,
0.6732530594,
-0.1501996517,
-0.1743264496,
-0.7103224397,
0.8857452273,
-0.7708594203,
0.1475301385,
0.0945974067,
0.5296700597,
0.0130972946,
-0.6602071524,
-0.4311452806,
0.2051347941,
-0.1285955906,
0.1203159019,
-0.1074126661,
-0.4202884734,
0.2290115952,
0.5493506789,
-0.6136101484,
0.7734093666,
-0.1931666732,
-0.2099600285,
0.4362430274,
0.6671546102,
-0.1614868343,
-0.1330678612,
-0.4388743043,
-0.0448643304,
-0.2018971741,
0.0745335445,
0.646949172,
0.5359792709,
-0.3440067768,
0.0302676074,
-0.5128276944,
0.4261392355,
0.0757114291,
0.1535813808,
0.6939301491,
-0.2127975225,
-0.2260008007,
0.2016024888,
0.4432581663,
0.0287295319,
-0.2486079782,
0.0491151102,
-0.4041664004,
-0.0231627338,
0.1408896297,
-0.5153377056,
-0.4553428888,
0.3618909717,
-0.4674306512,
-0.5115259886,
-0.0045549902,
-0.8947315216,
-0.5518017411,
-0.2253765762,
0.4917825758,
-0.1136722341,
-0.5875180364,
-0.1030720845,
0.0833116323,
0.164111346,
0.2323935926,
-0.7536225319,
-0.1727604121,
0.6080040932,
0.7780931592,
-0.5264361501,
-0.0129497517,
-0.6318787336,
0.0624856949,
-0.3504034579,
0.7939000726,
-0.1865299493,
-0.6654749513,
-0.2019823492,
0.2069809139,
0.1974252313,
-0.9445920587,
0.4192326963,
-0.4495593607,
-0.04003115,
0.0704881772,
-0.3273516595,
0.049222704,
0.4091959596,
-0.6198946834,
1.1233395338,
0.3524621129,
-0.7216532826,
0.5747237802,
-0.7264242768,
-0.3551630378,
0.0346541107,
-0.2539246082,
-1.0519226789,
-0.1813666672,
0.5788828731,
0.77186203,
0.0914450511,
0.2146217078,
-0.5773480535,
-0.1396430731,
0.2700914145,
-0.7536018491,
0.4878415465,
0.3583523929,
-0.4303699136,
-0.1710426658,
-0.9123666286,
-0.0219932962,
0.0978986919,
0.0656076223,
-0.2779344916,
-0.3158189654,
-0.2922456563,
0.038950935,
0.1865730286,
-0.5230109096,
0.126166746,
-0.2916216254,
-0.1194152012,
0.8854919076,
0.489667207,
-0.0766559839,
-0.4089837968,
0.5352912545,
0.7461671829,
0.1528998613,
-0.3736710548,
-0.0699137673,
-0.8329212666,
-0.4050660729,
-0.00288849,
0.5759811997,
-0.7473381758,
0.5815272331,
-0.0178146847,
-0.2910954058,
-0.3870682418,
0.3389082253,
0.0928288847,
0.9599938393,
0.5454509258,
-0.2151555568,
-0.6029751301,
-0.8915423751,
-0.3122795224,
0.5272067785,
-0.0420754291,
0.0570293255,
0.2856144607,
-0.3234048486,
0.8432940841,
-0.8188480139,
-0.7365540266,
0.2176337391,
0.4253246784,
0.762771666,
0.7392828465,
0.5666297078,
-0.5486590862,
-0.3532217741,
0.1984440684,
-1.0712822676,
-0.095594503,
-0.0999389738,
0.5110691786,
0.3762015104,
0.7457212806,
0.2249612212,
0.5445432067,
0.3509210944,
-0.0283295903,
0.4322697222,
-0.3022003174,
0.1695177704,
-1.1747970581,
-0.0807527453,
0.1599874347,
-0.1474440247,
-0.6287564635,
-0.434705019,
-0.0322893411,
-0.098199673,
-0.3767192662,
0.1910711527,
-0.1955519915,
0.0428798534,
-0.2072787881,
-0.4179736078,
0.0142512638,
0.518103838,
-0.1378500015,
0.8240318894,
0.4808053076,
-0.8012595773,
0.5063829422,
-0.301099956,
-0.5406355262,
0.5966968536,
-0.3592927754,
0.1450517774,
-0.2195723653,
-0.2009120435,
-0.9044705629,
-0.2984485924,
0.4976028502,
-0.2650833428,
0.5389720798,
-0.095871903,
-0.1656703353,
-0.2220375389,
-0.2475281358,
0.5492414236,
0.3888505399,
-1.0427600145,
0.4797611237,
0.1415731609,
0.0876511335,
-0.7553887963,
-0.8687195182,
-0.6420222521,
-0.6020242572,
-0.2338137627,
0.209840551,
0.1085779816,
-0.0956469551,
-0.0598669089,
-0.4062050283,
-0.3689014912,
0.2904731631,
0.178797394,
0.1628712267,
-0.2693620622,
0.1650259346,
0.0659590587,
-0.2081079334,
0.1397060156,
-0.1036677584,
0.3424724936,
-0.1483889967,
-0.6645085812,
-0.6508443952,
0.2981778085,
0.2020994425,
0.2445579022,
0.4500335157,
0.8177840114,
-0.360593766,
-0.4693960547,
-0.4442870915,
-0.263048321,
-0.5982037783,
0.3577944934,
-0.1927771717,
-0.5545173883,
0.7071045041,
-0.2365722656,
-0.1722893566,
0.5816063881,
0.0335635729,
-0.4227989912,
0.6878603697,
0.4243208766,
-0.1785293519,
0.4404530525,
-0.631812036,
0.2718672752,
-0.84232831,
-0.4427154362,
-0.2127584964,
-0.2710351646,
-0.5801723599,
-0.2499710172,
0.7717272043,
-0.2820815146,
-0.2329907268,
-0.023521902,
-0.4861995876,
0.194331333,
0.2663294971,
0.4811130762,
0.2845543623,
0.2259905934,
0.1410074383,
-0.3426725566,
-0.5138532519,
0.121228829,
0.7987397909,
0.2901678681,
0.7643260956,
0.0433320217,
0.7347350717,
1.1590967178,
0.045989573,
-0.4896211028,
0.112456426,
-0.2907869518,
-0.2530812621,
-0.3730746508,
-0.4826527834,
-0.9853282571,
-0.0774277821,
-0.1749986112,
-0.4163061678,
0.6768906713,
0.4450242519,
-0.4903340638,
0.4497370422,
-0.7542812824,
0.7321285009,
-0.6318312883,
-0.3708299398,
-0.0687923729,
-0.2655447125,
0.2918200195,
-0.4693124294,
0.2909711897,
-0.1267524213,
-0.0265109427,
0.640497148,
-0.4800957143,
1.0858608484,
-0.3946036398,
-0.2480206937,
0.1986964494,
-0.0722079054,
0.5154601336,
0.0499951132,
-0.041348692,
0.2933588922,
-0.3501770198,
-0.4604413807,
-0.6927492619,
0.7481452823,
-0.5768358111,
-0.6207327247,
-0.6516379118,
-0.4004282653,
-0.2567168176,
0.0568809994,
0.1184299886,
0.6438372135,
0.0240216143,
0.1895778626,
0.5945734382,
0.0009914902,
0.7658127546,
0.599794209,
0.1594753116,
-0.150248915,
1.2365086079,
0.2149666995,
-0.0814892128,
0.2265624851,
0.0527538061,
-0.2790664732,
-0.4412662685,
-0.0818077102,
0.0044762483,
-0.5613877773,
-0.3324152827,
-0.5162503719,
-0.33732602,
-0.2876789272,
-0.0332793556,
-0.3392805159,
-0.4520852268,
-0.8212519288,
0.1938040555,
0.3829022646,
0.488550216,
-0.3792500794,
0.4066851139,
-0.8487694263,
0.3938216865,
0.6363828182,
0.3951689005,
0.0799982846,
-0.7154045105,
-0.2511187792,
-0.0056571565,
-0.4650563598,
-0.2944667041,
0.6191048026,
0.0994579047,
0.7226873636,
0.7779355645,
0.4014967084,
0.6013122797,
0.1495112479,
0.4932417572,
0.1335773766,
-0.6146063209,
0.547190547,
-0.56721735,
0.2028030902,
0.0636940226,
0.3198058307,
-0.0621517375,
0.160403952,
-0.6509459615,
-0.9277641177,
0.7415806055,
-0.0439200997,
-0.1275233179,
0.249796465,
0.4476544261,
0.4278230667,
0.2706817985,
-0.4984644353,
-0.3472329676,
-0.3384693861,
-0.0634866357,
-0.1278487742,
0.067237027,
0.0713557303,
-0.0154430391,
0.553689599,
-0.1876423806,
0.1588276476,
0.2732900381,
0.0739766881,
0.0466488078,
0.2541232705,
0.4091380537,
0.4835958779,
-0.3306591809,
-0.2170752138,
0.4217840135,
-0.3980161846,
0.0451877229,
0.3339306712,
0.1903707236,
-0.1713289618,
0.2376850098,
0.5667899251,
-0.2496670336,
-0.3663195372,
0.2391030639,
0.4019290507,
-0.0116409836,
-0.7109028697,
0.379662931,
-0.5253686905,
0.6226121783,
0.7090438008,
0.1136359349,
0.3207672536,
-0.4105276167,
0.1947398931,
0.4936987162,
-0.4178046286,
-0.0686851963,
0.4805481434,
0.1737130582,
-0.1346246898,
0.5531713367,
-0.1100011244,
-0.4423924387,
1.0978341103,
0.3530203402,
0.6388679743,
-0.379671216,
-0.0344927832,
0.0881232396,
0.3653610349,
0.0690600425,
0.2521137595,
-0.2108103037,
-0.7621120214,
-0.1896929741,
-0.215511173,
-0.383910656,
0.813934505,
-0.7900998592,
0.3496026695,
-0.4780057669,
-0.0106840646,
-0.1125997156,
-0.0978007093,
-0.560844779,
0.3575390279,
-0.1309036016,
0.461114198,
-1.1326738596,
0.6015499234,
0.1749579757,
-0.1077938825,
-0.4445603788,
0.0332205892,
-0.1189965904,
-0.775488019,
0.4827347696,
0.3392807841,
-0.117612645,
-0.0308207031,
-0.0719786584,
-0.5769519806,
1.0902980566,
0.0782925338,
-0.5260161161,
0.3991270661,
0.1388125718,
0.4767466486,
-0.3185985386,
-0.1293463707,
0.7064989209,
0.1645792276,
-0.2342835665,
-0.4068318307,
-0.1385228336,
-0.2297718823,
-0.4421208203,
0.7059551477,
-0.683028996,
0.6641839743,
-0.1405386627,
0.0486370027,
-0.1935781687,
0.8477025032,
0.027109284,
0.9277864695,
0.5571140051,
0.612894237,
0.8547345996,
-0.0504446998,
0.6832435131,
-0.0045032958,
0.2907625437,
1.1167126894,
-0.1759546995,
0.4086230695,
0.1850793511,
-0.217284441,
0.500344336,
0.730250597,
-0.3554552197,
0.6778542995,
-0.1959353983,
-0.3822613955,
-0.37107566,
-0.1373575479,
-0.8548036218,
0.3983774781,
0.7430446148,
-0.336122334,
-0.177593708,
-0.08570382,
-0.3123234808,
-0.0657181144,
-0.477974385,
0.4474441111,
-0.0697085634,
-0.1910681129,
0.6059797406,
-0.4870729446,
0.7918373346,
-0.4872021377,
-0.3426723778,
-0.4599713683,
0.3143417239,
-0.3896749616,
-0.7070543766,
0.4500537813,
-0.1806894094,
-0.1627132446,
-0.0639382079,
0.6531715989,
-0.0442355126,
-0.4079212248,
0.0013440561,
0.4974679053,
0.1213178039,
0.2296055555,
-0.2384467423,
-0.2503322363,
-0.0267735124,
0.1560102254,
0.2506388724,
0.2692515254,
-0.1221499145,
0.7602995634,
0.5711479187,
-0.0347828716,
-0.1529067606,
-0.0492764302,
0.9137935638,
-0.4637227654,
-0.7659540176,
-0.5634505153,
0.4003072977,
-0.375934422,
-0.0943799242,
0.4742251933,
0.5802109838,
0.7112009525,
-0.3161902726,
0.8777313828,
0.3205563724,
1.0507739782,
-0.7294651866,
0.5392789245,
-0.6507608294,
0.8654167056,
0.0237038638,
-0.6186593175,
-0.2952787578,
0.1661512852,
-0.3025020957,
0.2913625538,
0.4650447071,
0.726765871,
-0.5175410509,
0.0266078636,
0.2387898266,
0.2528682947,
0.0880840719,
0.3407683372,
0.8716434836,
-0.288050741,
0.6177137494,
-0.4693748653,
-0.1110470518,
-0.4027763307,
-1.201233983,
-0.9814050794,
-0.295235455,
-0.3707341552,
-0.2311998755,
0.0116950162,
0.8622702956,
0.5072153807,
-1.1438236237,
0.109346509,
-0.0393283702,
-0.1064643338,
-0.4374340475,
-0.2881585062,
0.6849710345,
-0.2758269906,
-0.5857634544,
0.6464850307,
0.0292687826,
0.3776325881,
-0.2729578912,
0.2881484926,
0.2868083715,
-0.4573793411,
0.1436726153,
0.6716761589,
-0.2294949144,
-0.1561859995,
-0.0437775739,
0.5607925057,
0.1505550444,
0.7627096772,
-0.9812117219,
0.5947412252,
0.244867757,
0.7160096169,
0.6626495123,
0.0988280624,
0.1994945407,
-1.0219012499,
0.5029145479,
0.0445281826,
0.2881014645,
0.459277153,
-0.8813652396,
0.4458919466,
0.4535022974,
-0.4849479795,
-0.9199175835,
0.2320231497,
-0.6453015804,
-0.0427805968,
0.482726723,
-0.083305575,
0.1197508648,
-0.5991413593,
0.335264504,
0.3789337575,
-0.5317286253,
1.2153862715,
0.0301017221,
-0.7642197013,
0.0586228333,
-0.3085434437,
0.3384885788,
0.187994957,
-0.9249981046,
-0.177989617,
0.1571115106,
0.32062307,
0.0998996422,
0.1231297925,
0.1615210176,
0.4109675586,
-0.2018492222,
-0.4177860022,
-0.5048056245,
-0.1990640908,
-0.6829057336,
0.142371282,
-0.265198946,
-0.6745129824
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12255v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12255v1 | A Hopfieldian View-based Interpretation for Chain-of-Thought Reasoning | 2024-06-18T04:07:13 | 2024-06-18T04:07:13 | Lijie Hu, Liang Liu, Shu Yang, Xin Chen, Hongru Xiao, Mengdi Li, Pan Zhou, Muhammad Asif Ali, Di Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC, cs.LG | Chain-of-Thought (CoT) holds a significant place in augmenting the reasoning
performance for large language models (LLMs). While some studies focus on
improving CoT accuracy through methods like retrieval enhancement, yet a
rigorous explanation for why CoT achieves such success remains unclear. In this
paper, we analyze CoT methods under two different settings by asking the
following questions: (1) For zero-shot CoT, why does prompting the model with
"let's think step by step" significantly impact its outputs? (2) For few-shot
CoT, why does providing examples before questioning the model could
substantially improve its reasoning ability? To answer these questions, we
conduct a top-down explainable analysis from the Hopfieldian view and propose a
Read-and-Control approach for controlling the accuracy of CoT. Through
extensive experiments on seven datasets for three different tasks, we
demonstrate that our framework can decipher the inner workings of CoT, provide
reasoning error localization, and control to come up with the correct reasoning
path. | [
-0.355235219,
-0.8748386502,
0.9053951502,
-0.118608281,
-0.2278492302,
0.3718183637,
-0.0925700739,
-0.5395563245,
0.1086085588,
0.6272456646,
-0.4568687379,
-0.3046337366,
-0.7098626494,
0.0893854722,
-0.2881298959,
0.9873555899,
-0.5272952318,
-0.4450672865,
0.2103680968,
0.1041355282,
-0.6109886765,
-0.3922391832,
-0.5884346962,
-0.213753745,
0.7116615772,
0.3316245675,
1.0301201344,
0.551428318,
0.5326468349,
0.0871973485,
-0.5880120993,
0.414600879,
-0.5214650035,
0.0522136874,
-0.4401396811,
-0.9603905082,
-0.4849851727,
0.0244686082,
0.3084821403,
0.7179327607,
0.0885391608,
0.0034281206,
-0.0664422363,
0.637825489,
-1.1856964827,
-0.2699420154,
-0.585328877,
0.0709798411,
0.1418256164,
-0.3203366101,
-0.7156490684,
-0.2149789631,
0.0555159152,
-0.2050647438,
0.0354726836,
0.2853074968,
0.3447775245,
-0.0261691995,
-0.6651152372,
-0.3945758045,
-0.8266203403,
0.7161822915,
-0.6030670404,
0.358962208,
0.5806247592,
0.0709257945,
-0.3991172612,
-0.3099512458,
-0.7286040187,
-0.1073442325,
-0.2639145553,
0.1163488254,
0.0661846846,
0.1328126043,
0.4314056039,
0.2943840921,
-0.3590520322,
-0.3644789755,
-0.2550054789,
0.1897813529,
0.5108881593,
0.184642449,
-0.0499688759,
0.0430109985,
-0.4771347046,
0.0138635449,
-0.5872029066,
0.1639464796,
-0.0355256163,
0.2676652074,
-0.0249998122,
0.490213424,
-0.1336562186,
1.0096468925,
0.1049416289,
0.1910499334,
-0.2053284049,
-0.291017592,
-0.5342744589,
0.0046890252,
0.5576674938,
0.1237173676,
0.2270205021,
-0.2290729433,
-0.02616168,
-0.0507736802,
0.599398613,
-0.4992406964,
0.1601127684,
0.6231315136,
-0.2768653035,
-0.613914907,
0.0829743892,
-0.4435688257,
-0.3806030452,
-0.1826082766,
0.3451373577,
-0.4173291922,
-0.2971721292,
0.2943277657,
-0.0523518063,
0.3007108569,
0.5095495582,
-0.8069266081,
0.422157526,
0.6950136423,
0.8906117678,
-0.2981031239,
-0.3879536986,
-0.6007061005,
0.2876344919,
-1.1806638241,
0.8219391108,
-0.4862582684,
-0.0950139314,
-0.2333644032,
-0.3056958914,
-0.1965265572,
-0.1958964318,
-0.1209534407,
-0.6381148696,
0.057324864,
-0.4419561327,
-0.5131394863,
-0.0421765707,
0.5263121128,
-0.4449676871,
0.6535169482,
-0.1811947227,
-0.9696355462,
0.5232406855,
-0.3604449332,
-0.1441511661,
-0.1595119238,
-0.4250725806,
0.2459682971,
0.3423561156,
0.3037314713,
0.1832568944,
-0.2734519541,
0.2004491985,
-0.1723997444,
-0.5224326849,
0.4096054733,
-0.4789182246,
0.8665083051,
0.2657043934,
-0.6080254912,
0.1010356322,
-0.5313014984,
0.3612958491,
-0.1499477327,
-0.0275353864,
-0.2760053277,
0.051365111,
-0.4835670292,
0.2135904878,
-0.3132157326,
-0.2398873568,
0.3448996842,
-0.3354052007,
0.0813963562,
0.5997738242,
0.3145891726,
0.415719837,
-0.4255877435,
0.6663484573,
0.176451087,
0.3322605491,
-0.0484637953,
-0.2715218365,
-0.516741991,
-0.1084693447,
0.0920304433,
0.3172809184,
-0.6304063201,
0.1167272702,
0.2162756473,
-0.2825378776,
-0.3323863745,
-0.0634183362,
0.3365851939,
0.5986590385,
0.3487387598,
-0.1899966151,
-0.051094491,
-0.5433141589,
-0.4467322528,
-0.3525476754,
0.2333970368,
0.0815606192,
0.4551608264,
0.0483182706,
0.8676787019,
-0.3815900981,
0.3000965714,
-0.4194712937,
0.1016086116,
0.5547432899,
0.3425887823,
0.037498828,
-0.6263573766,
-0.1346837878,
0.1152364165,
-0.6950296164,
0.1406825483,
-0.4647527337,
-0.7931346893,
0.0308896266,
0.4717477858,
-0.5489997268,
1.0004197359,
0.0792922452,
-0.5323998332,
0.6940765381,
-0.1580474377,
0.4113348126,
-0.6886191964,
-0.1595080197,
-0.4968675673,
-0.3232633471,
-0.4564218223,
0.4820393622,
0.0728181005,
0.4070363939,
-0.4296573997,
0.0382001251,
-0.3012176156,
-0.0309059843,
-0.4920529425,
0.3751367927,
0.2584634721,
0.3784816265,
0.2411229312,
0.754457891,
0.5091065764,
-0.7407504916,
0.1777621508,
0.4675653577,
-0.1681257039,
0.3851371706,
-0.4181509912,
0.3101938367,
-0.2300117314,
0.5386552215,
-0.9036456347,
0.0338877663,
0.251703918,
-0.2830200493,
0.0078355307,
0.0757345855,
-0.147531867,
-0.132774055,
-0.2707862258,
0.3997732401,
0.1809466928,
-0.7656383514,
0.506374836,
-0.135180667,
0.2708469331,
-0.7842858434,
-0.7644042969,
-0.1410428584,
-0.0591262281,
-0.1601067483,
0.1161174923,
0.1286462396,
-0.5525826812,
-0.1753743887,
-0.5301932693,
0.0294201355,
-0.1106637418,
-0.0354886949,
0.4791389704,
0.0521325804,
0.4553909302,
0.0065192925,
-0.0115585662,
0.1487533152,
-0.4835401475,
0.4227706492,
-0.1866415739,
-0.1729287803,
-0.3230589926,
0.2980028391,
0.5553169847,
-0.2295227051,
0.8643145561,
-0.1085083783,
-0.2174762338,
-0.4624585211,
-0.2609620094,
0.1278268397,
-0.3590154052,
-0.1384097934,
-0.568128109,
-0.4973085225,
0.3491943777,
-0.1650444865,
0.0856816471,
0.3161206543,
0.6126513481,
-0.428463906,
0.7524499893,
0.4151318371,
0.1585142761,
0.1729562432,
-0.5949656963,
0.3582190573,
-1.0664726496,
-0.3555097282,
-0.3435293138,
-0.2934578955,
-0.5756514668,
-0.5740399361,
0.1249523237,
0.561793983,
-0.4884145856,
0.5049443841,
-0.3472633064,
0.564432621,
0.2499584109,
0.3364661634,
0.6010146141,
-0.3032856286,
-0.5486843586,
0.5162326694,
-0.7864617705,
-0.6895997524,
0.8675858974,
0.1414131671,
1.0735281706,
0.112819016,
0.6813112497,
0.1861213744,
-0.0378911197,
-0.8361092806,
0.2556192577,
0.3810414672,
-0.8630532026,
-0.1990173459,
-0.3783756793,
-0.6025537848,
0.4482060969,
-0.2121345103,
-1.1166151762,
0.4107958674,
0.4565233886,
-0.4279402196,
0.6408392787,
-0.4735645652,
0.6692399383,
-0.4550925195,
-0.6834053993,
-0.3677175045,
-0.6253734827,
0.2707961202,
0.0546791963,
0.3707502484,
0.4605534077,
-0.0735150799,
0.4758091569,
-0.6842556596,
0.5923312306,
0.3187886477,
-0.2502511144,
0.7189147472,
0.5187153816,
0.6677744985,
-0.1020336822,
0.025510909,
0.0320815146,
0.3883915246,
-0.4603422284,
-0.9316225052,
0.348677814,
-0.4751534164,
-0.6732419729,
-0.6506586671,
-0.7113947272,
-0.5375230908,
0.0070604361,
0.3145259619,
0.5082892179,
0.2490571588,
-0.061193794,
0.3745292723,
-0.1961537749,
0.2434363067,
-0.0160878692,
-0.8646702766,
-0.1301575452,
0.284629494,
-0.0426642969,
0.8743401766,
0.5615370274,
0.1425394416,
-0.1294418126,
-0.3898148239,
-0.2768102288,
0.1270410568,
-0.738719821,
0.0958825648,
-0.4782674611,
-0.0255023111,
-0.1903915107,
-0.2708262503,
-0.3391783834,
-0.3055867553,
0.1847665161,
-0.4318061769,
0.2648792565,
0.9094651341,
0.0863244534,
0.3892885149,
-0.2595943511,
0.344958216,
0.1186746359,
0.630889833,
0.2789840698,
-0.2753994465,
-0.1829230785,
0.0186147243,
-0.3601672947,
-0.901938498,
-0.0102906628,
-0.4751988649,
0.1374996454,
0.3058253825,
0.025539238,
0.9232079387,
-0.34869349,
0.5628114939,
0.1626511961,
-1.0481885672,
0.8842273951,
0.0500542894,
0.3333368301,
0.545937717,
0.4890069067,
-0.3751920462,
-0.50089854,
-0.6104663014,
-0.5586439967,
0.6478580832,
0.484669894,
-0.2777204216,
-0.202505216,
0.5110758543,
0.1507004201,
-0.0170612596,
-0.3279541433,
0.1449455321,
0.2261703014,
0.1285849214,
0.1505576223,
-0.0529191084,
0.0239750408,
-0.087954469,
0.6307815909,
-0.079800874,
0.2145029306,
0.587997973,
-0.1240217462,
-0.4043597877,
0.3972627819,
0.3271042109,
1.1978924274,
-0.4795055985,
0.451836884,
0.250908047,
-0.4278015494,
0.1955246329,
-0.73471421,
-0.1979213208,
-0.1400617808,
0.9654756784,
0.9165343046,
-0.2656536996,
-0.554084003,
0.3324840069,
0.0198290758,
-0.0918451473,
-0.0834844708,
0.4219752848,
-0.1550003886,
0.3890935183,
0.0978637487,
0.2888850868,
0.076883927,
-0.8088998795,
0.1370672882,
0.3325735033,
-0.5537996888,
0.0724129528,
0.546487391,
-0.2352260202,
-0.3597726822,
0.508693099,
0.1333937794,
-0.4268064797,
0.5572170019,
0.6215328574,
0.6617569327,
0.3663701415,
0.2702305615,
0.1592754871,
0.473634541,
-0.0804112479,
0.4370039999,
-0.3952200413,
-0.887648046,
-0.7547158003,
-0.302939266,
-0.6414961219,
0.1243620813,
-1.0261011124,
0.1380742937,
-0.5773968697,
-0.2121579051,
-0.1199421436,
-0.1690615416,
-0.6207828522,
0.5106752515,
0.0635267422,
1.2733228207,
-0.464223057,
0.5621901155,
0.2052730918,
-0.5000298023,
-1.1340332031,
0.570278585,
-0.2161651999,
-0.6040420532,
0.4506046772,
-0.0374418534,
-0.6622824669,
-0.1635871828,
-0.6831973195,
-0.7980342507,
0.9170507789,
0.0214371774,
-0.9738750458,
-0.1659604013,
-0.2903168797,
0.4542038441,
-0.5177463293,
0.5768666267,
0.8380108476,
0.028251145,
0.413518846,
-0.826253593,
-0.0173429325,
0.172497794,
0.0704905614,
0.3248480856,
-0.397651732,
0.4909898341,
-0.6872109175,
0.1679812372,
-0.2899331152,
0.4058910906,
0.4782794714,
0.2512558103,
0.5256454945,
0.2403579652,
0.8010783195,
0.285690248,
1.5749783516,
0.0092062894,
0.4491626918,
1.3108977079,
-0.2594524026,
0.9653410912,
0.730872035,
-0.4145984352,
0.784153223,
0.4751379192,
0.5990614891,
0.569585681,
0.1608962268,
-0.1317584515,
-0.3573330343,
0.1980778277,
-0.037594948,
0.571552515,
0.2085961848,
-0.5432035923,
0.0009732811,
-0.1182251349,
-0.1087511331,
-0.0945528597,
-0.5155664086,
0.6046484709,
0.0267400779,
-0.759753406,
0.7635719776,
-0.478815645,
0.1461358219,
-0.3044451773,
-0.0661618337,
-0.0238500554,
0.2556006908,
-0.1066415533,
-0.816912353,
0.4056665301,
0.4477247596,
-0.0412734076,
-0.1022675633,
0.4719899297,
-0.1118891835,
-0.5674203038,
0.4076197147,
0.67512393,
0.3509051204,
0.1005865932,
-0.3780233562,
0.258703649,
-0.1472520977,
-0.3177289069,
-0.2014072388,
0.5043874383,
-0.4490376711,
0.4761489034,
0.3351840079,
0.592143774,
-0.1182558164,
0.0751151964,
0.7190942764,
-0.9661880136,
-0.4569323957,
-1.020123601,
0.3829475939,
-0.0976717249,
-0.3369093239,
0.0728259236,
0.2922644019,
0.982670784,
0.2034005374,
0.8341709971,
-0.2720262408,
0.4202948511,
-0.5990472436,
0.5308737159,
-0.3500894904,
0.2803411186,
-0.3855268657,
-0.7133352757,
-0.2513434589,
0.9536400437,
-0.6796684861,
0.0556738935,
1.3030616045,
0.4934760928,
0.0832364559,
0.2741603851,
0.4571362734,
0.5724827647,
0.4008930027,
0.6494221091,
0.9509444833,
-0.4415217936,
0.2973087132,
-0.2794876099,
-0.5430324078,
0.365209341,
-1.0111774206,
-0.8448019028,
-0.2027368397,
-0.2898436785,
-0.4891983271,
0.0937712863,
1.0989795923,
0.5167009234,
-0.9977734089,
-0.3397535384,
-0.6681999564,
0.209409669,
-0.5953543782,
-0.1196270436,
0.4521877468,
-0.6043852568,
-0.326507628,
0.1279581785,
0.4806075692,
-0.3979487717,
0.0860580504,
0.0100383041,
-0.5782415271,
0.3618140519,
0.5985050797,
-0.2067896724,
-0.9580594897,
-0.4236737192,
0.0085941581,
-0.0326658338,
0.0078479126,
0.9344234467,
-1.04243958,
0.8242849112,
0.2985923588,
0.4973424673,
0.6793972254,
0.2279679626,
0.6491453648,
-0.1270019114,
-0.0827109069,
0.1578142345,
0.2071930468,
-0.1535551995,
-0.5691615939,
0.6401908398,
-0.0037444767,
-0.445340246,
-0.5029118657,
0.3580261767,
-0.9051018953,
-0.4061620831,
0.9368315935,
-0.1068840474,
-0.3423279524,
0.0704116002,
-0.5077931285,
0.4172193706,
0.1073507965,
0.8088726997,
0.8603061438,
-0.7400792837,
-0.291405797,
-0.4091667831,
0.3380616307,
0.2086639702,
-0.7520649433,
0.2824062109,
0.3691212535,
0.1082485467,
0.1302838475,
0.7540978193,
-0.1163791865,
0.2536220849,
0.0381115824,
-0.3432011008,
0.13042216,
-0.6000378132,
-0.1712797433,
-0.0105332052,
0.1342584193,
-0.2371123284
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12252v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12252v1 | Language and Multimodal Models in Sports: A Survey of Datasets and Applications | 2024-06-18T03:59:26 | 2024-06-18T03:59:26 | Haotian Xia, Zhengbang Yang, Yun Zhao, Yuqing Wang, Jingxi Li, Rhys Tracy, Zhuangdi Zhu, Yuan-fang Wang, Hanjie Chen, Weining Shen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent integration of Natural Language Processing (NLP) and multimodal models
has advanced the field of sports analytics. This survey presents a
comprehensive review of the datasets and applications driving these innovations
post-2020. We overviewed and categorized datasets into three primary types:
language-based, multimodal, and convertible datasets. Language-based and
multimodal datasets are for tasks involving text or multimodality (e.g., text,
video, audio), respectively. Convertible datasets, initially single-modal
(video), can be enriched with additional annotations, such as explanations of
actions and video descriptions, to become multimodal, offering future potential
for richer and more diverse applications. Our study highlights the
contributions of these datasets to various applications, from improving fan
experiences to supporting tactical analysis and medical diagnostics. We also
discuss the challenges and future directions in dataset development,
emphasizing the need for diverse, high-quality data to support real-time
processing and personalized user experiences. This survey provides a
foundational resource for researchers and practitioners aiming to leverage NLP
and multimodal models in sports, offering insights into current trends and
future opportunities in the field. | [
-0.3095016181,
-0.5919795036,
0.124259159,
0.3532368243,
0.1461047977,
0.3697567284,
-0.1530007273,
-0.7464552522,
0.2908690572,
0.148239553,
-1.0006738901,
-0.4948500693,
-0.5159561634,
-0.080743134,
-0.3481084406,
0.9763317704,
-0.2061000317,
0.2949729562,
-0.4980868399,
-0.5526745915,
-0.7547132373,
-0.8989105225,
-0.5350464582,
-0.2946562171,
0.1705639809,
0.0469084308,
0.5174705982,
0.421153605,
0.9453388453,
0.2927432358,
0.344004333,
0.256452471,
-0.3469148874,
0.6438024044,
0.0256822091,
-0.1208434179,
-0.7331941724,
0.2298228145,
0.6707196236,
0.9821821451,
0.0015717819,
0.177837044,
-0.3248445392,
0.5214354992,
-0.5600733161,
0.4298223555,
-0.0545075871,
0.2537201047,
-0.262916863,
-0.5044752955,
0.0365302153,
-0.1867447346,
-0.0042522508,
-0.620415926,
0.2569822073,
0.0556485057,
0.2055747509,
0.1032902226,
-0.5771026015,
-0.3472524881,
-0.9709042311,
0.9933019876,
-0.5620943308,
0.8663227558,
0.2896071374,
0.5208127499,
0.0751849115,
-0.2491931468,
-0.224881053,
-0.0806655213,
0.0715188012,
0.3555354774,
-0.1438574195,
0.0185282417,
0.1194037125,
0.1044141576,
-0.7090443969,
0.1344070137,
-0.2275636494,
0.1333248019,
1.0270223618,
0.6550140381,
0.3641862571,
0.2334014922,
-0.0927221105,
-0.1006831303,
-0.3757157624,
0.1677701175,
0.2440965921,
0.3116680384,
-0.2341696769,
0.7016277313,
-0.6672766209,
0.8162183166,
-0.5167085528,
-0.4451616704,
0.3726359308,
-0.7105223536,
-0.1186160669,
-0.0547005981,
0.6749280095,
0.7019765973,
0.126123637,
-0.4979157448,
0.004445245,
0.0048873327,
-0.2909400463,
-0.562728703,
-0.2095975578,
0.3680261672,
-0.6639233828,
-0.246686846,
0.0761218593,
-0.975481689,
-0.5083745122,
-0.6107308269,
0.0263612196,
-0.3098032176,
-0.2919295728,
0.4122387767,
-0.4128651023,
0.2594747841,
0.1413044333,
-0.8245389462,
0.4782890081,
0.4624018073,
0.5686684847,
-0.0872288421,
-0.2555628419,
-0.3427383006,
0.2452856004,
-0.3129447997,
0.9770543575,
-0.7250496745,
-0.1081687883,
0.6096518636,
-0.1535543501,
-0.0603744313,
-0.3554970622,
0.3165237904,
-0.3118561804,
0.2323456705,
-0.0540805422,
-0.4858644009,
-0.4002211094,
0.5133854151,
-0.9140284061,
0.9240070581,
-0.1554976702,
-0.4674713016,
0.7280513644,
-1.0973827839,
-0.6234163046,
-0.207127437,
-0.0548232868,
-0.3574851751,
0.1140455902,
0.2945894897,
0.6285315752,
-0.4592719376,
0.1513618976,
-0.7149674296,
-0.0856891274,
0.4224515557,
-0.4117055535,
0.5335361362,
0.1113194749,
0.2744801044,
-0.1417563707,
-0.7483543158,
-0.0296381488,
-0.065945372,
-0.2254446447,
0.0311929695,
0.5464923382,
0.4069966078,
0.4850693643,
0.0470160395,
-0.4569240808,
0.1760611087,
0.0656343997,
0.1697430611,
0.3346212506,
-0.0606516115,
0.4740563333,
-0.1577610672,
0.8537161946,
0.0538784899,
0.3580752015,
-0.2483636439,
-0.5109469295,
-0.075945504,
-0.1046600044,
0.157531485,
0.5585566759,
-0.7595849037,
0.0058396268,
-0.5685812831,
-0.605522573,
-0.2577506304,
0.1178278923,
-0.1299783587,
0.3967131078,
0.2629619539,
0.1726506352,
-0.7965237498,
-0.7389093637,
-0.3506008089,
-0.1811082214,
0.3891929686,
0.3433087766,
0.376948446,
0.0821017474,
0.8413951397,
-0.65323174,
-0.2725853026,
-0.5403417349,
0.1491381973,
0.2113126367,
0.5411374569,
1.0842411518,
-1.0637003183,
-0.4963895679,
-0.0246582981,
-1.1078544855,
-0.0176124796,
-0.0270261131,
0.292434305,
-0.1429452002,
0.1764407903,
-0.290019989,
0.3861069977,
1.0318208933,
-0.5428160429,
0.5491667986,
0.0207137633,
0.7543788552,
-0.7122173309,
0.2687308192,
0.1377667785,
-0.237731263,
-0.9431602359,
-0.3219813406,
-0.4567410648,
-0.1358081549,
-0.4001937211,
0.6277859211,
-0.4604982138,
-0.2418638021,
-0.391305685,
-0.2924647629,
0.086397104,
0.1018643528,
0.397375226,
0.558303535,
0.6397593021,
-0.6748325229,
0.8264513612,
0.386045903,
-0.3862533271,
0.4694545567,
-0.3405994773,
-0.2736217976,
-0.4179250598,
0.2929629087,
-0.795422852,
-0.5541900396,
0.3640973866,
-0.2280725539,
0.150707677,
0.0289811715,
-0.4697853923,
-0.4325845838,
-0.4361728132,
0.831425488,
-0.0423451141,
-0.0539491437,
0.6132923365,
0.664894402,
-0.2349848449,
-0.4335220754,
-0.6928961277,
0.1756237,
-0.2131476104,
-0.3825435936,
0.1514632106,
-0.3845734,
-0.1947792917,
-0.0063646748,
0.1176444441,
-0.7516036034,
0.1522230059,
0.0022074864,
0.4013476372,
-0.2498262078,
0.1831036955,
-0.3003341258,
0.1552947164,
-0.2350376397,
0.1020234451,
0.3682441413,
0.1435531676,
-0.043521408,
-0.5384587049,
0.8679814935,
0.2382885665,
-0.165008679,
0.7578774095,
0.5388473868,
-0.1802308261,
0.1318916827,
-0.3756519556,
-0.1128341779,
-0.3339727521,
0.5290417075,
-0.2504401207,
-0.8000603318,
0.4658665955,
0.0740616471,
0.1502892226,
0.219638899,
0.5399779081,
-0.6244108677,
1.3295769691,
0.3100759089,
-0.1649528593,
0.5459648967,
-0.1750843525,
0.0649039,
-0.424793601,
-0.423430264,
-0.5999237299,
-0.5945965052,
-0.4352026284,
-0.1196591109,
0.1453047991,
-0.3109178841,
-0.0172361489,
0.3391534388,
-0.132258907,
0.6266155839,
0.1841517091,
-0.0594150797,
0.3015563488,
-0.2623589933,
0.7720745802,
-0.4474417567,
-0.8417564631,
0.0613104776,
0.9928774834,
0.2499354184,
0.7260544896,
0.4114950895,
0.2805417776,
0.5872074366,
0.2013103366,
-0.8509668112,
0.1939161122,
-0.4075762033,
-1.2364127636,
-0.1784021407,
-0.2905605435,
-0.7211672664,
0.0125776017,
-0.4488785267,
-0.3284145296,
0.3703142405,
0.1724046916,
-0.2262291461,
0.3362387419,
-0.5471737385,
0.4803397655,
-0.2769360244,
-0.3168475628,
0.2791777253,
-0.2617280483,
0.6353520155,
-0.0488141887,
0.5302992463,
-0.4131217897,
-0.1349122375,
0.9840456247,
0.0328017734,
0.6636096835,
-0.2042219341,
0.0493485294,
0.1726969182,
-0.0433307812,
0.0000985311,
-0.0160848629,
-0.1658289284,
0.1587096155,
0.3142411411,
-0.4502593577,
-0.6817547083,
0.4376614392,
-0.353451699,
-0.1450635344,
-0.5774227381,
-0.6230852604,
-0.7398517132,
0.0003067603,
-0.2065285295,
0.7218310833,
-0.2761523128,
0.5736737251,
0.2804272473,
-0.0149987601,
0.7895653248,
0.4235466421,
-0.3045107424,
-0.3620660603,
0.8615991473,
0.2792291939,
-0.2788821161,
0.4092290103,
0.0090917116,
-0.6360768676,
-0.7696384788,
0.0361832418,
0.0570060648,
-0.4668852389,
-0.3823541701,
-0.1640430242,
0.0867305472,
-0.7208132148,
0.2058238536,
-0.4432037175,
-0.4487041235,
0.0172661189,
-0.1977080405,
0.4034819901,
0.8317707777,
-0.1825822145,
0.3854061663,
-0.825006485,
0.4653080702,
-0.0680371672,
0.8299018145,
-0.2726479769,
-0.1824240386,
-0.4143183529,
0.0644061491,
0.0524286926,
-0.8108845353,
0.4877821505,
0.4401933551,
0.6188014746,
0.408867538,
-0.414373517,
0.6073002815,
-0.6024383307,
1.055003643,
0.3932180405,
-0.3609957099,
0.2932211757,
-0.7091748714,
-0.023370998,
0.7779717445,
0.4837771058,
-0.8829170465,
0.4333170652,
-0.1638673693,
-0.4061607718,
0.8622679114,
-0.0507826172,
0.1617766917,
0.1326253116,
0.0875676423,
0.2782912552,
0.4617955685,
-0.402684778,
-0.2103871852,
-0.3189041913,
-0.3018494844,
-0.37989977,
0.2374800295,
-0.0929901525,
-0.2999511361,
0.5003232956,
-0.2005961388,
0.2272908092,
-0.2960606515,
-0.0015461959,
0.2404239029,
-0.0825031772,
0.6767688394,
0.6791702509,
-0.3327145875,
-0.2653264701,
-0.0938703343,
-0.378262639,
0.147940442,
0.0063722739,
-0.00910623,
0.1586284637,
0.6682066917,
0.6606040001,
0.4324809611,
-0.7678055763,
0.4774652421,
0.1221714541,
-0.4336738586,
-0.0508501567,
-0.3888404071,
-0.1425058693,
0.1448208839,
0.1126060262,
0.1040121689,
0.5500179529,
-0.7211800218,
0.0650995597,
0.4407049417,
-0.361648798,
-0.5937372446,
0.8163301349,
0.2122088075,
0.0584244989,
0.2777710855,
0.4871679246,
-0.1522480994,
0.1727767885,
0.2868468761,
0.5558545589,
-0.0515352301,
0.4230481088,
0.0591380112,
-0.2220837325,
0.023682978,
0.3453249037,
0.0330775157,
-0.7938507795,
-0.6001102924,
-0.5101267695,
-0.3428687751,
0.0268999599,
-0.5714324117,
-0.0369962268,
-0.0758712962,
-0.5135020614,
0.2808552384,
-0.0833554715,
-1.151001215,
0.5195708275,
0.5356627703,
0.9318929911,
-1.0009280443,
0.6241109371,
0.8574047089,
-0.8359356523,
-0.1092276797,
-0.4966561198,
0.1284878403,
-0.426043421,
0.9099015594,
-0.410649538,
0.1911515445,
-0.2141644359,
-0.459418118,
-0.3733644485,
0.8424441814,
0.0404221714,
0.0380650833,
-0.3277638555,
0.6737928391,
0.2194615155,
-0.3211923242,
0.277683109,
0.7338413,
0.5197789073,
-0.0380234495,
-0.7171618342,
-0.6088162661,
-0.1452591121,
-0.0833067819,
0.0159791224,
-0.7477397919,
0.5269508362,
0.4576978683,
0.2097869515,
-0.1375685334,
0.5714953542,
0.1020630971,
0.2846099436,
0.1073055044,
0.278268218,
0.3521199226,
-0.2221244723,
1.0885182619,
-0.0660021827,
0.3456206322,
0.8728917241,
-0.5588098764,
0.5733758807,
0.4160865545,
-0.3122948706,
0.241697073,
0.3417681456,
-0.1075609922,
0.4327677786,
-0.2737194002,
-0.3551933467,
-0.4330120087,
-0.2501653731,
-0.3122887313,
0.9522312284,
0.2225884944,
-0.1659327447,
-0.5378303528,
0.3682925403,
-0.0155246165,
-0.0231189728,
-0.2184314579,
0.963589251,
-0.4009970427,
-0.4521282911,
-0.2344990224,
-0.0889867246,
0.6042268872,
-0.8542404175,
-0.2181990594,
-0.117493473,
0.0636612549,
-0.0714056939,
-1.1301953793,
0.34710747,
-0.0309093371,
-0.42118752,
-0.5544983149,
0.8037421703,
-0.3201542199,
-0.5531369448,
0.0155683672,
0.5843384266,
0.1725494266,
-0.0036734189,
-0.7514987588,
0.2486903369,
-0.2813687921,
-0.2115451247,
0.2024560124,
0.1707309783,
0.0558494851,
0.6302450299,
0.5815166235,
0.3352620006,
0.4453422427,
0.1361910105,
0.5663970113,
-0.6782690883,
-0.2324523628,
-0.5819352269,
0.5390631557,
-0.1827239692,
-0.3498725891,
0.7634232044,
1.0605410337,
0.4411836863,
-0.4061786532,
0.9662263989,
-0.0864069611,
0.6372910142,
-0.5181804895,
0.6828730106,
-0.4901135862,
-0.2913868427,
0.0416441709,
-0.6187558174,
-0.7381045222,
0.1513523906,
-0.1347526461,
0.0251214243,
0.2019835562,
0.102650322,
-0.082154125,
0.2614748776,
0.3371226192,
-0.2780179381,
0.5893506408,
0.1721578985,
0.648409307,
-0.6889150739,
0.3716731966,
-0.2251721323,
-0.2333644927,
-0.4804571569,
-0.7759509683,
-0.7934293747,
-0.6889584064,
-0.378467679,
-0.0511034988,
0.1021180153,
0.851931572,
0.8086903691,
-1.0804260969,
-0.4296728373,
0.4518314898,
-0.4679768682,
-0.4308809042,
-0.1725617051,
0.1917250305,
-0.397764504,
-0.9455880523,
0.5229583979,
0.1507732421,
-0.0388673246,
-0.1286408603,
0.0061555402,
-0.4889152944,
0.0107101267,
0.96167624,
0.7671521306,
-0.3872438371,
-0.1724956483,
0.3056940138,
0.2772580385,
0.1077486277,
0.9846824408,
-0.7943993807,
0.5847379565,
0.8545432091,
0.5003359914,
0.2987134755,
0.0716324821,
0.69604671,
-0.6705443859,
0.2013924867,
0.4979348183,
0.1761974096,
0.0534426793,
0.2409323305,
0.5222008228,
0.5672902465,
-0.1516906619,
-0.7557279468,
-0.0161505882,
-0.9531484246,
-0.1883323938,
1.0072811842,
0.4332146943,
-0.1080165282,
-0.3250254393,
-0.0088476958,
0.0896206126,
-0.1585109532,
0.3902681768,
1.1552292109,
-0.6247417331,
0.0857988372,
-0.9369046688,
0.7508362532,
-0.1791387349,
-0.8843337893,
0.268229723,
0.6897761226,
-0.0679062456,
-0.2607890964,
0.5674057603,
-0.0512980409,
0.1863776892,
0.0426025204,
0.0058336551,
-0.2747891843,
-0.4948151708,
-0.0876257718,
0.304340601,
-0.4383894205,
-0.2330123186
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12251v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12251v1 | Mitigate Negative Transfer with Similarity Heuristic Lifelong Prompt Tuning | 2024-06-18T03:57:49 | 2024-06-18T03:57:49 | Chenyuan Wu, Gangwei Jiang, Defu Lian | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Lifelong prompt tuning has significantly advanced parameter-efficient
lifelong learning with its efficiency and minimal storage demands on various
tasks. Our empirical studies, however, highlights certain transferability
constraints in the current methodologies: a universal algorithm that guarantees
consistent positive transfer across all tasks is currently unattainable,
especially when dealing dissimilar tasks that may engender negative transfer.
Identifying the misalignment between algorithm selection and task specificity
as the primary cause of negative transfer, we present the Similarity Heuristic
Lifelong Prompt Tuning (SHLPT) framework. This innovative strategy partitions
tasks into two distinct subsets by harnessing a learnable similarity metric,
thereby facilitating fruitful transfer from tasks regardless of their
similarity or dissimilarity. Additionally, SHLPT incorporates a parameter pool
to combat catastrophic forgetting effectively. Our experiments shows that SHLPT
outperforms state-of-the-art techniques in lifelong learning benchmarks and
demonstrates robustness against negative transfer in diverse task sequences. | [
-0.3021096587,
-0.508587122,
0.4386049807,
0.2610283494,
-0.3303849697,
0.0867168978,
0.0143698491,
-0.3593972921,
0.1445457935,
0.2271805853,
-0.9934595227,
-0.1391461939,
-0.471457094,
-0.21892263,
-0.1520896256,
0.9523112178,
-0.0080247344,
-0.1580293924,
-0.2441104949,
-0.3880898952,
-0.9327545762,
-0.3281040788,
-1.0037240982,
-0.5274107456,
0.7100467682,
0.5948158503,
0.2289837599,
0.44219625,
0.6488287449,
0.1500580758,
0.2946569622,
-0.1797890663,
-0.7353601456,
0.3372423053,
-0.6297185421,
-0.2587834299,
0.0802368,
-0.1762336195,
0.4984294772,
0.4729356766,
-0.0238354802,
0.4405671656,
0.2779857516,
0.8397507668,
-0.8080598116,
-0.069047153,
-0.7511383295,
0.2400784045,
-0.3737538159,
-0.4892123938,
-0.2300453484,
-0.6165828705,
0.0460392907,
-0.5806859136,
0.2596720457,
0.0526310131,
0.6381291151,
0.481898874,
-0.2585153878,
-0.0653522611,
-0.5712415576,
0.7619969845,
-0.5395685434,
0.1885534823,
0.2582068443,
0.4839279354,
0.1939353645,
-0.0815898031,
-0.3158145845,
-0.3673647344,
0.2807982266,
0.1678745747,
0.2417278141,
-0.0733860582,
0.1807358712,
0.0486526005,
-0.6778571606,
0.2045384645,
-0.4369462729,
-0.4677378237,
0.2521717548,
0.2304012924,
0.316647172,
0.1070958003,
-0.5749263763,
0.0793105513,
-0.8521152139,
-0.1015236229,
0.0785033479,
0.371779263,
0.0860571116,
0.225928545,
-0.0608450845,
0.5518023968,
0.1739200354,
0.0141968196,
0.069024682,
-0.3361585736,
0.2093446255,
-0.0001541443,
0.4033173919,
0.4972885251,
0.2737114131,
-0.4409340024,
-0.0482302867,
0.1377040893,
0.448939532,
-0.6090943813,
-0.2505038679,
-0.2957192957,
-0.3335929513,
-0.1378353536,
-0.0886780545,
-0.7601582408,
-0.3543058038,
-0.4478042424,
0.8990975618,
-0.5762752891,
0.1317489594,
-0.0779357329,
-0.150159359,
0.2326038629,
0.2061958462,
-0.870908916,
0.1602375656,
0.8318423629,
0.9454294443,
-0.6493621469,
-0.714618206,
-0.9462328553,
0.3355583251,
-0.0239921287,
0.8178287148,
-0.4017212689,
-0.1836761087,
-0.249816373,
-0.0597727112,
-0.4507434666,
-0.5971140265,
0.438798219,
-0.4931082428,
0.1467017978,
-0.7443887591,
-0.6138345003,
-0.1723662615,
0.2195312977,
-0.4722995162,
0.793857038,
0.3288577795,
-0.5282304883,
0.4160982668,
-0.5284266472,
-0.7500007153,
0.1176929548,
0.2344061285,
-0.6016563177,
0.1544328779,
-0.317687571,
0.2708913386,
-0.2433771342,
0.0440427735,
-0.7121090293,
-0.8557347059,
-0.1681045443,
-0.3796985745,
0.7359492183,
0.2086773813,
-0.522546351,
0.098080501,
-0.5325478315,
-0.179847151,
-0.2090948969,
-0.0201249998,
-0.4514817894,
-0.3684194088,
-0.1449556351,
0.4699951708,
0.3936039507,
-0.5024735928,
0.2832749486,
0.0497768782,
0.5775683522,
1.0182875395,
0.3545711339,
0.5510669351,
-0.8551296592,
0.5539628863,
-0.004241392,
0.2636030018,
0.0054365587,
-0.22199139,
-0.4725365639,
-0.0662647039,
-0.176687181,
0.9396758676,
-0.4328742325,
0.4963469505,
-0.0487479195,
-0.370490849,
-0.274181515,
0.2120667696,
0.2608509362,
1.1268396378,
0.5779708624,
-0.4555963874,
-0.4307583272,
-0.7741910815,
-0.4047737718,
-0.0126562566,
0.2249540538,
0.2178082317,
0.4007959068,
-0.1368049383,
0.5575459003,
-0.416374594,
-0.5361919999,
0.1667257696,
0.0330921784,
0.3297052681,
0.8765306473,
0.4993581474,
-0.6029397249,
-0.705354929,
-0.2366259992,
-0.5485653281,
-0.0615771897,
-0.8736056685,
-0.3081169724,
0.0118663916,
0.5717115402,
-0.8096499443,
0.1712122709,
0.1581175923,
-0.4890387952,
0.716103971,
-0.3142569661,
0.2941809595,
-1.0037887096,
0.4142640829,
-0.1793201864,
-0.248343572,
-0.1318057925,
0.1817564964,
0.2437341958,
-0.0401793495,
-0.414878279,
0.7689329982,
0.0059659691,
0.098164767,
-0.1403086782,
-0.1735696197,
-0.2369133383,
0.6061924696,
-0.4077107906,
1.0097023249,
0.6426613331,
-0.6542791724,
0.3674534857,
0.304566294,
0.1094145998,
1.2907155752,
-0.5280122757,
-0.0138265174,
-0.0793734416,
0.2677449286,
-0.8890131116,
0.2784597576,
0.4757314026,
-0.2193414867,
0.2269451171,
-0.0405849703,
-0.0696338564,
-0.4115816057,
-0.4329707026,
0.4033588767,
1.0202125311,
-0.4205890894,
0.2202622294,
-0.3987463713,
-0.3424377441,
-0.543451488,
-0.4300353527,
0.081310913,
-0.6950585842,
-0.1814691722,
0.6019249558,
-0.461014092,
0.3358267546,
0.0416435935,
-0.5073296428,
-0.0745868385,
0.3334666491,
0.3119141161,
0.2419615388,
-0.2153179497,
0.1408162862,
0.2032131255,
-0.4206759632,
-0.1020674482,
-0.6507400274,
0.4008738399,
0.131929636,
-0.6582565904,
-0.7917051315,
0.2932107747,
0.7067602277,
0.0919125453,
0.6955638528,
1.0177083015,
-0.0566663295,
-0.0765609369,
-0.696054101,
-0.457804352,
-0.4728735089,
0.1292294115,
-0.2981636226,
-0.9354375005,
0.6683399677,
-0.1670109183,
0.1711735874,
0.3271102309,
0.2470881194,
-0.5359752774,
0.3957242072,
0.6129747629,
-0.4283432961,
0.8086319566,
0.1256088018,
-0.0633053258,
-0.659244597,
0.0501013026,
-0.5100189447,
-0.550870955,
-0.1819082201,
-0.1429486126,
0.1403719783,
0.2639225423,
-0.8159760237,
0.5668244958,
-0.3914047778,
0.6560764313,
0.7860313058,
0.2132969052,
0.1494463235,
-0.013307536,
-0.0689352304,
-0.2712322772,
-0.467209518,
0.0994103402,
0.7976150513,
-0.0144534996,
0.5417517424,
-0.0511606,
1.1490315199,
0.8075606227,
0.2527293265,
-0.3638970852,
0.4797572196,
-0.3833209276,
-0.326782763,
-0.479049623,
-0.5884325504,
-0.6616954207,
-0.034132272,
0.0390030853,
-0.7924160957,
0.058848951,
0.5030889511,
-0.4205359221,
0.3465839922,
-0.563924849,
0.7476692796,
0.0680567771,
-0.6737260222,
-0.5219699144,
-0.7936823368,
0.015742423,
-0.350939244,
-0.1547966003,
-0.2244855165,
0.009304435,
0.5150886178,
-0.0977112353,
0.780161798,
-0.6166748405,
-0.0517824851,
0.0086140409,
0.3467572033,
0.7137436867,
0.0545037873,
-0.1934732497,
-0.0835703835,
-0.0359335877,
-0.877548337,
-0.5851554871,
0.8438051343,
-0.5148797631,
-0.5744857192,
-0.0433848388,
-0.5018317699,
-0.2580043077,
0.5396924019,
0.4940964282,
0.2365741134,
-0.0312869661,
-0.1881710291,
0.8588837385,
0.0589595065,
0.3609745204,
0.4067985415,
0.4823844731,
-0.1607185006,
1.5509928465,
0.0089959372,
0.3085084856,
0.6097736955,
0.2808936536,
-0.3061319888,
-0.5026160479,
-0.3567015529,
0.2847613692,
-0.5776745081,
-0.3261831701,
-0.2343924642,
-0.1258044392,
-0.2100691795,
-0.7714450359,
-0.3601699173,
-0.4677511156,
-0.4679902792,
0.0722321123,
0.2060929537,
0.3213703334,
-0.4550016224,
0.1524625868,
-0.9405001998,
0.6143305302,
0.7353506088,
0.4676555097,
0.1366517991,
-0.7466939688,
0.1488146931,
-0.0821672976,
-0.4159545302,
-0.7196208239,
0.1713921726,
0.5403959751,
0.6861096025,
0.2506387234,
0.2383943647,
0.8213921785,
-0.4540723562,
0.5914225578,
0.3786171079,
-1.0215373039,
0.2649386227,
-0.4538995922,
0.6620915532,
1.2249852419,
0.4669003487,
-0.7550242543,
-0.1709361523,
-0.3955122232,
-0.8423137069,
0.3474170268,
-0.2536255419,
0.1309432834,
0.2620542347,
0.5583797693,
0.7106190324,
0.0545940772,
-0.5177803636,
-0.0484380908,
-0.1487199962,
-0.1604702175,
-0.1280517876,
0.1403800696,
0.0328261219,
-0.1618629098,
0.7274692655,
-0.1675391644,
0.3312557042,
0.0572995767,
-0.3638722003,
-0.2578774393,
0.2758460045,
0.5748831034,
0.5199747682,
-0.3176935911,
0.1699243337,
0.3103325963,
-0.4107603729,
0.5582320094,
-0.0118091824,
-0.3580440283,
-0.4287112653,
0.3881172836,
0.5667199492,
0.4016075432,
-0.368414849,
0.3354431987,
0.1941589117,
-0.1997702718,
-0.1921380311,
0.2938517034,
0.1791914254,
0.28241992,
0.4320944548,
0.7573316097,
0.1478128135,
-0.2072500139,
0.5449515581,
0.2753300369,
-0.7953350544,
-0.3781662583,
0.56340307,
0.3160600066,
-0.5166860819,
1.046672821,
-0.33193174,
-0.479529649,
0.6018038392,
0.7062697411,
0.9028481245,
-0.2218631506,
0.3949601352,
0.5269816518,
0.0909239873,
-0.2890917063,
0.2379392534,
-0.6424406767,
-0.3643084466,
-0.3496384621,
-0.331020534,
-0.2606473565,
-0.1357154101,
-0.9018544555,
-0.0270854328,
-0.4102109969,
0.1292159408,
-0.4888493121,
-0.1480495781,
-0.7184167504,
-0.2559974194,
0.1173089296,
0.9075546861,
-1.0377633572,
0.7170965672,
0.4123244882,
-0.1258343607,
-0.2371149212,
0.1009553,
0.0742999837,
-0.8762745261,
0.3944473267,
0.3220961392,
-0.101671204,
0.152244553,
-0.1213562191,
-0.8501288295,
1.1321380138,
0.3947670758,
-0.8695597649,
-0.2786560357,
-0.1885053366,
0.2291894406,
0.1560013741,
-0.2217005938,
0.5109097958,
0.5840175152,
0.2255494595,
-0.905483067,
0.4236278236,
0.0243665837,
-0.2173323482,
0.3908843696,
-0.748480916,
0.5581815243,
-0.5570275784,
-0.2651233375,
0.2435248792,
0.3048518598,
0.4283453822,
0.3891080916,
0.3997229934,
0.6933859587,
0.6767580509,
0.2608147264,
0.5185946822,
-0.2949183881,
0.4082232416,
1.1281993389,
-0.4519259632,
0.5351809859,
0.7132546902,
-0.1494974643,
0.1361120045,
0.5935437083,
-0.1689628214,
0.9019691348,
0.2379503697,
-0.1895060092,
-0.3646171093,
-0.0687372759,
-0.5199918151,
-0.1013692841,
0.1627777666,
0.0674163848,
-0.4976314902,
0.2056755424,
-0.2457354069,
0.0519365557,
-0.3238657713,
0.8007965684,
0.1531602442,
-0.8215992451,
0.6048392057,
-0.6202282906,
1.0665341616,
-0.6501198411,
-0.1985931993,
-0.3825478852,
0.1613789499,
-0.102905646,
-0.4011566043,
0.4958440363,
-0.7849344015,
-0.1722531021,
-0.4500910342,
0.7100211382,
-0.166955322,
-0.086833328,
0.1132545769,
0.4469192326,
-0.3186936378,
-0.0095549161,
-1.0104718208,
-0.1251558065,
0.2050523162,
0.0413892306,
0.5790611506,
0.1908910871,
-0.1331914812,
0.9304190874,
0.5042168498,
0.3059360683,
-0.0401164144,
-0.1109599024,
0.6009938121,
-0.9046524763,
-0.8414354324,
-0.8668779731,
0.1201506853,
0.174851954,
-0.4781598151,
0.6679495573,
0.2111345083,
0.6066094041,
-0.2576621175,
0.6400699615,
0.0037649742,
0.3758403659,
-0.4224795699,
0.636619091,
-0.2981697023,
0.1700237989,
-0.3197972775,
-1.2320774794,
-0.294980377,
0.4671173692,
-0.2598626018,
-0.0620249622,
0.6905055046,
0.6039461493,
-0.2338349819,
-0.0577536598,
0.3091093898,
-0.0949491337,
0.300832063,
1.1138421297,
0.8320209384,
-0.1106028035,
0.3204650879,
-0.2323277742,
-0.1469894797,
-0.366794765,
-1.0457475185,
-0.5547544956,
-0.7622475028,
-0.4672749639,
-0.1276760399,
0.6048400998,
0.8829578161,
1.0337405205,
-0.8361757994,
0.0188335385,
-0.4927249849,
0.1475481838,
-0.6679276824,
-0.259993732,
0.4386268556,
-0.4249509871,
-0.0185073093,
0.1953786016,
0.2733044922,
0.0017963548,
-0.1065729782,
-0.0809404179,
0.1557390988,
-0.088565737,
0.4252752364,
0.7555905581,
-0.3218799531,
-0.4583957791,
-0.1897400767,
-0.0487706549,
0.0065111634,
1.0928964615,
-0.8878572583,
-0.0219219197,
0.5192085505,
0.9874813557,
0.2964638472,
-0.0521229059,
0.365880549,
-0.4440541565,
0.0082674911,
0.5589616895,
-0.0368206799,
0.1768155694,
-0.6356859803,
0.1960399598,
0.3723450899,
-0.6656592488,
-0.5695699453,
0.3552311659,
-0.9879475236,
-0.4587406218,
0.7064295411,
-0.1685089767,
0.0029296295,
-0.2353444099,
-0.163784951,
0.0545147769,
-0.6176226735,
1.1738532782,
0.3983890712,
-0.3518257737,
-0.2081607282,
-0.2452791482,
0.3726532757,
0.7174317837,
-0.7041819692,
-0.0605465025,
0.2940416634,
0.7278572917,
-0.1104118079,
0.6462496519,
0.1012462452,
0.6968281865,
-0.1239238456,
-0.3023456335,
-0.2094863504,
-0.4212904572,
-0.4544868171,
0.4584865272,
0.0180072747,
-0.038059514
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12246v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12246v2 | TroL: Traversal of Layers for Large Language and Vision Models | 2024-06-18T03:42:00 | 2024-06-19T21:40:03 | Byung-Kwan Lee, Sangyun Chung, Chae Won Kim, Beomchan Park, Yong Man Ro | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CV | Large language and vision models (LLVMs) have been driven by the
generalization power of large language models (LLMs) and the advent of visual
instruction tuning. Along with scaling them up directly, these models enable
LLVMs to showcase powerful vision language (VL) performances by covering
diverse tasks via natural language instructions. However, existing open-source
LLVMs that perform comparably to closed-source LLVMs such as GPT-4V are often
considered too large (e.g., 26B, 34B, and 110B parameters), having a larger
number of layers. These large models demand costly, high-end resources for both
training and inference. To address this issue, we present a new efficient LLVM
family with 1.8B, 3.8B, and 7B LLM model sizes, Traversal of Layers (TroL),
which enables the reuse of layers in a token-wise manner. This layer traversing
technique simulates the effect of looking back and retracing the answering
stream while increasing the number of forward propagation layers without
physically adding more layers. We demonstrate that TroL employs a simple layer
traversing approach yet efficiently outperforms the open-source LLVMs with
larger model sizes and rivals the performances of the closed-source LLVMs with
substantial sizes. | [
-0.3066098392,
-0.4846278131,
0.5717635155,
0.2414258569,
-0.5600465536,
0.3584406078,
0.0044260141,
-0.7658684254,
-0.1602646261,
0.9609463811,
-0.4127394855,
-0.6134708524,
-0.4131507874,
-0.3424304724,
-0.3561069965,
0.5716854334,
0.0854106247,
-0.2013381869,
-0.0954649895,
-0.1010175422,
-0.1836687475,
-0.2410086393,
-0.6974309087,
-0.2618617117,
0.8520339131,
0.2759984136,
0.6259545088,
0.832901001,
0.6252545714,
0.3481354415,
-0.1680058688,
0.4142634273,
-0.3634851873,
0.0701915398,
-0.1216980293,
-0.3185563684,
-0.3581726849,
-0.0596501045,
0.8538822532,
0.5816245079,
-0.1736584306,
0.2641566098,
-0.164209187,
0.8304162621,
-0.7264850736,
-0.0375948995,
-0.5386679769,
0.1692430377,
-0.1599932909,
-0.1874697655,
-0.6718635559,
-0.1016612574,
0.5658628345,
-0.6242078543,
0.1991043687,
0.1406430602,
0.5381255746,
0.1248556376,
-0.2523835003,
0.1600313485,
-0.6862649322,
0.8930157423,
-0.7151067853,
0.7746132016,
-0.0167118572,
0.4389128387,
0.2150340229,
-1.0978144407,
-0.3941470385,
-0.3459356129,
0.1794334799,
-0.1247416735,
-0.1990117431,
0.270608604,
0.3406162858,
0.1832376868,
-0.519744873,
0.0127396798,
-0.5263271928,
-0.1359660476,
0.3225948811,
0.0308471266,
0.2633686364,
0.0308013894,
-0.623460114,
-0.3029926121,
-0.7321490645,
0.0046646288,
0.0346086286,
0.1444274783,
-0.0373390242,
0.3671104014,
-0.0357438996,
1.0461941957,
-0.1894582957,
-0.3135321736,
0.3172815144,
-0.2278276831,
-0.450474143,
-0.1191415489,
0.4161181748,
0.2192191631,
0.2382489443,
-0.2105293423,
-0.1910928488,
-0.260822624,
0.2887813151,
-0.7811789513,
-0.1001051292,
0.1091888472,
-0.3111014664,
-0.3823909163,
-0.1545165926,
-0.8682770729,
-0.1536613852,
-0.0851958022,
0.4513553083,
-0.3429406285,
0.0128827719,
0.1886800528,
-0.0789187625,
0.5719898343,
0.6304323673,
-0.5192421079,
0.2990138233,
0.5513584018,
1.0468683243,
-0.0674735457,
-0.3096603453,
-1.0705177784,
0.306042999,
-0.3511200249,
0.5272169709,
-0.7888402939,
-0.2546477914,
-0.056928128,
-0.1446577162,
0.0540637188,
-0.541724205,
0.4241107702,
-0.7235912085,
0.1335611045,
0.0446198024,
-0.188128382,
-0.4242280126,
0.3493905663,
-0.7692393661,
0.7370294929,
0.1800119281,
-0.673943758,
0.0191493109,
-0.4119480848,
-0.4334316254,
0.2334119827,
-0.0253972374,
-0.4641818702,
0.2682866752,
0.4851135612,
0.2017067522,
-0.4285328686,
-0.1643567532,
-0.1035795212,
-0.4406013191,
-0.2862164676,
-0.2164589167,
0.8208953738,
0.2080249786,
-0.2352955192,
0.232645005,
-0.6905468106,
0.2091008574,
-0.0039562974,
-0.4868254364,
-0.4852262139,
0.0064795506,
-0.2733785212,
0.2455140203,
0.1318758577,
-0.5521746278,
0.2066863924,
-0.5285640955,
0.5903693438,
0.7819478512,
-0.2147329599,
0.3781361282,
0.0376048014,
0.5759737492,
0.2780562341,
0.3742225468,
-0.1591263115,
-0.5138371587,
-0.8917325139,
-0.2489203513,
0.0149036031,
0.3857809007,
-1.2202422619,
-0.1188952997,
-0.3450006545,
-0.453799665,
-0.3725686371,
0.2684811652,
0.5411375761,
0.6163454652,
0.3902269304,
-0.302220732,
-0.5193393826,
-0.922524631,
-0.0355160087,
-0.3079697192,
-0.1046365723,
0.5944321752,
0.4548027813,
-0.0682511628,
0.5193247199,
-0.4751753807,
-0.0546780601,
-0.3735607564,
-0.1715054363,
-0.0178303346,
0.2960419655,
0.4540754259,
-0.6368761063,
-0.3020712137,
0.3106324971,
-0.4890298843,
-0.0927880928,
0.1189770252,
-0.1766974181,
0.1230007038,
0.3766462207,
-0.5237099528,
0.1552050263,
0.7959685922,
-0.24118267,
0.4592031837,
-0.2432174683,
-0.2430140823,
-0.7400510311,
-0.0311772041,
0.1047271565,
-0.5070909262,
-0.7695858479,
0.5298521519,
0.1049099565,
-0.1109918803,
-0.830848217,
0.5657924414,
-0.6430366039,
-0.4374952912,
-0.0169433895,
0.2296592444,
0.329090476,
0.5301836133,
0.0400420055,
0.7123976946,
0.7523037195,
-0.4149237275,
0.67559582,
-0.0677691549,
-0.3503376245,
0.1707798243,
-0.6815243363,
0.4388406873,
-0.0353838801,
0.2153119445,
-0.5628234744,
0.1495781392,
0.2350926101,
-0.0404494405,
0.2211797833,
-0.2174664438,
-0.1921484768,
-0.474912703,
-0.5235282183,
0.6760834455,
0.5828831196,
-0.9810801744,
1.138792038,
0.2073255628,
0.2570824623,
-0.7446559668,
-0.887245357,
0.3571065068,
-0.2314849645,
-0.9696856141,
0.1876400411,
0.01295882,
-0.1160940528,
-0.122663185,
-0.1290462017,
-0.0218096897,
-0.2172073126,
0.0001910533,
0.329559058,
-0.3944870532,
-0.1590770036,
-0.2965439856,
0.2071525902,
0.042495925,
-1.0442075729,
0.6275516748,
-0.2984996736,
-0.1623648107,
-0.0461755954,
0.1376825571,
0.6441755295,
-0.7006556988,
0.5766102076,
0.3812109232,
-0.1836006641,
-0.6570475698,
-0.6581106186,
0.1524024904,
-0.5287403464,
0.4912054539,
-0.3812509179,
-0.932730794,
0.4722704589,
0.1897162795,
0.0680138022,
0.1190839037,
0.3071967065,
0.0275799874,
0.8220604658,
0.4468147755,
-0.0000141513,
0.5715620518,
-0.4315811396,
-0.0041890671,
-0.9252145886,
-0.2655117512,
-0.1830161959,
-0.4453776479,
-0.4616653919,
-0.9482732415,
0.3101318181,
-0.2702559531,
-0.183140263,
0.1086601689,
-0.4337635636,
0.6165640354,
0.8219522238,
0.3818607628,
0.4356063902,
0.3870286942,
-0.2250134945,
0.3978658915,
-0.7362917662,
-0.185354352,
0.8579210639,
0.5866031051,
0.9130313396,
0.1357523948,
0.4750783443,
0.0785860866,
0.0783958957,
-0.6409870982,
0.9875266552,
-0.635368526,
-0.3264294565,
-0.3361363113,
-0.5753099322,
-0.5843684077,
0.3853481114,
0.1689731181,
-0.6760274172,
0.3007180393,
0.226152882,
-0.1422730684,
0.8401908278,
-0.6301826835,
0.5648394823,
-0.2819485664,
-0.6223141551,
-0.1635480374,
-0.7933964133,
0.5345104337,
0.0275331438,
-0.2164976448,
0.2578784525,
-0.189944908,
0.5101780295,
-0.4921916127,
0.8641175032,
-0.2668627799,
-0.141241923,
0.5351495743,
0.1271738559,
0.6623488069,
-0.2295500487,
0.2317270935,
0.2099574804,
-0.2967329621,
-0.3675266206,
-0.7258240581,
0.8066772223,
-0.7432045341,
-0.7450324297,
-0.255384177,
-0.5845695138,
-0.1230211109,
0.1706658155,
0.0143361837,
0.6114583015,
0.27681005,
0.3191872239,
0.6337274909,
-0.526781559,
0.2751461864,
0.3294271827,
-0.4388127625,
-0.2214405537,
1.0486924648,
-0.0555363558,
0.6038486362,
0.6154716611,
0.3037337065,
-0.3534404933,
-0.9242060781,
-0.4968264401,
0.2193949819,
-0.6222817898,
-0.0672167614,
-0.3722633719,
-0.5804920793,
-0.0929738879,
0.0512843728,
-0.3253045082,
-0.390473038,
0.0213991031,
-0.144316256,
0.0502887927,
0.5238982439,
0.0826056004,
0.3081744909,
-0.7620543242,
0.285069406,
0.6383321881,
0.6469542384,
0.2006461471,
-0.5483977795,
-0.2977722585,
-0.2338722497,
-0.1449610442,
-0.564997375,
0.4577265084,
0.2388380915,
0.3414494991,
0.3055097163,
-0.2946678698,
0.7597516179,
-0.6690263748,
0.6965562105,
0.2107240409,
-0.8890991211,
0.4549113214,
-0.210563153,
0.3531009853,
0.0902999043,
-0.1577244997,
-0.3997283876,
-0.4074831605,
-0.3523040414,
-0.7967860103,
0.6485504508,
0.1154722348,
-0.0530902259,
0.2561546266,
0.5045468807,
-0.1963486671,
0.0873288214,
-0.7032722235,
-0.0224457644,
-0.4457908571,
-0.0684372261,
0.0012103942,
-0.3674560785,
0.0242475308,
-0.0579342432,
0.4601279795,
-0.0512626022,
0.0309775323,
0.3641862571,
-0.1379642189,
-0.1243163869,
0.1055618823,
0.6192907691,
0.7306885123,
-0.3470029533,
0.6475293636,
0.1994113475,
-0.7664640546,
0.0453188866,
-0.1120305806,
-0.4343592227,
-0.180076465,
0.5477308631,
1.144428134,
0.0610158592,
-0.737644732,
0.3425611258,
0.0735470057,
-0.2914840877,
-0.0096752113,
0.2463452816,
0.1118397266,
0.6028800607,
0.1410776973,
-0.158878684,
0.0484647714,
-0.414647758,
0.1704558283,
0.4907901287,
-0.2342740446,
-0.242375046,
0.6221278906,
0.4038500786,
-0.4005649686,
0.7567208409,
0.1494705677,
-0.5217308402,
0.5058483481,
0.5510280132,
0.936681211,
-0.174972564,
0.2836809456,
0.2155158222,
0.4758931696,
-0.0155815305,
0.0973568559,
0.1075106263,
-0.7533791065,
-0.7321689725,
-0.6661375761,
-0.4616784155,
0.2404648364,
-0.2740653455,
0.0309433267,
-0.7370779514,
0.1602423936,
-0.272903651,
-0.0364620052,
-0.6115018725,
0.2897660434,
0.4978161454,
1.2886248827,
-0.3701099455,
1.1306678057,
0.6176506281,
-0.1908305734,
-0.8321281075,
-0.0144342221,
-0.2535471022,
-1.11223948,
0.9796854258,
0.1494537443,
-0.5885845423,
0.1943601519,
-0.7034636736,
-0.652017653,
1.1381217241,
0.4244717062,
-0.7655073404,
-0.585796833,
0.2525734007,
0.4930688143,
-0.5545686483,
-0.0032574148,
0.3688172996,
0.3313278556,
0.4656994045,
-0.6000465751,
-0.0033472253,
-0.1051284075,
0.310125798,
0.1448537409,
-0.7298785448,
0.8132974505,
-0.5182704926,
-0.2535926402,
0.013649351,
0.6164040565,
0.4787804484,
0.207597211,
0.9663068056,
0.5731706023,
0.3948733211,
0.0291873775,
1.0888912678,
-0.2692713439,
0.1644739658,
1.0715898275,
-0.1466626525,
0.7971445918,
0.620064497,
0.0229443498,
0.4406376183,
0.3191082776,
-0.0968699306,
0.4958626628,
0.2593112886,
-0.2937087119,
-0.4119086862,
-0.0055183228,
-0.134833172,
0.4409705698,
0.0870636553,
-0.3987673223,
-0.1970951706,
-0.1340976954,
-0.5965304971,
-0.2340383083,
-0.610032618,
0.2923136353,
0.1525185853,
-0.4272152483,
0.3665871918,
-0.1169820875,
0.3194898069,
-0.6501042247,
-0.1284421533,
-0.2742154896,
0.1286545992,
-0.0159223955,
-0.9612150192,
0.0355225988,
0.0178456679,
0.1237359196,
-0.0739706904,
0.8354857564,
-0.3639482558,
-0.7629420757,
0.5480694175,
0.6049574614,
-0.0166135337,
-0.0068516815,
-0.3881162107,
0.1096826419,
0.107654348,
-0.4734949172,
0.0723490193,
0.3839594424,
-0.1149067432,
1.115858078,
0.6879829764,
0.3944990933,
0.3985189497,
0.3126851022,
1.0514435768,
-0.7504643202,
-0.4931388199,
-0.7259927392,
0.4516175091,
-0.0091641396,
-0.0334940441,
0.4121069908,
0.5260858536,
0.9522818923,
0.0049764491,
0.5081188083,
0.3401680291,
0.3209582269,
-0.6959331036,
0.2410355657,
-0.8223528266,
0.5229904652,
-0.1922329515,
-1.0633863211,
-0.5784407258,
0.6336034536,
-0.2872230709,
0.1646154821,
0.3853159845,
0.4892636836,
-0.1832645386,
-0.1602015495,
0.5376894474,
0.5476462245,
0.6261992455,
0.8765689135,
0.8156257868,
-0.0643921867,
0.764800787,
-0.3640139997,
-0.04673329,
-0.0648265332,
-0.9949114919,
-0.9025646448,
-0.2675240636,
-0.0680837408,
-0.1934982985,
0.2926822603,
0.5099272728,
0.8453016877,
-0.4283635318,
-0.213991195,
-0.0975218192,
0.150504753,
-0.1098731905,
-0.1550136358,
0.3406460583,
-0.0397277735,
-0.6933563948,
0.320895195,
0.5179163814,
0.0108860303,
-0.6623543501,
-0.1926056296,
-0.0965039507,
0.014069587,
0.9180652499,
0.2132026702,
-0.9198092818,
-0.6529340148,
0.1160103157,
0.0505528636,
0.2848206162,
0.6685344577,
-0.9510881305,
0.4660025835,
0.6235095859,
0.6125386953,
0.8128765821,
-0.0327319615,
0.5805419683,
-0.862193644,
0.1375891119,
0.218584612,
0.369064182,
0.3174688816,
-0.0446007997,
0.569811523,
0.1568099856,
-0.3113247454,
-0.8028321862,
0.3642265797,
-1.3387912512,
-0.2020929456,
0.9993255734,
-0.0834351629,
-0.3536264598,
0.2962314785,
-0.1459664851,
-0.0242882296,
-0.1892984062,
0.4724570811,
0.4201136529,
-0.0078210635,
-0.8789293766,
-0.6804282665,
0.0881346464,
0.0782191828,
-0.6829795241,
0.1860519499,
0.3315209448,
0.2581032217,
0.1349692047,
0.3661215603,
-0.0548883788,
0.1292666495,
-0.159928903,
-0.055561427,
-0.4658833146,
-0.6395974159,
-0.0855999738,
0.2313936204,
-0.0114953462,
-0.2743479311
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12238v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12238v1 | PFID: Privacy First Inference Delegation Framework for LLMs | 2024-06-18T03:27:09 | 2024-06-18T03:27:09 | Haoyan Yang, Zhitao Li, Yong Zhang, Jianzong Wang, Ning Cheng, Ming Li, Jing Xiao | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper introduces a novel privacy-preservation framework named PFID for
LLMs that addresses critical privacy concerns by localizing user data through
model sharding and singular value decomposition. When users are interacting
with LLM systems, their prompts could be subject to being exposed to
eavesdroppers within or outside LLM system providers who are interested in
collecting users' input. In this work, we proposed a framework to camouflage
user input, so as to alleviate privacy issues. Our framework proposes to place
model shards on the client and the public server, we sent compressed hidden
states instead of prompts to and from servers. Clients have held back
information that can re-privatized the hidden states so that overall system
performance is comparable to traditional LLMs services. Our framework was
designed to be communication efficient, computation can be delegated to the
local client so that the server's computation burden can be lightened. We
conduct extensive experiments on machine translation tasks to verify our
framework's performance. | [
-0.1616189331,
-0.8462510705,
0.5259479284,
0.3353956044,
-0.1310536563,
-0.1127277389,
0.160022065,
-0.1175681502,
0.1028720662,
0.6941256523,
-0.5036478043,
-0.6182989478,
-0.3436153829,
-0.2210089117,
-0.3748972416,
0.6741536856,
-0.0297192261,
-0.0175961498,
-0.5835548043,
0.2937970161,
0.3880423307,
-0.9196449518,
-0.4131924212,
-0.200778529,
0.2275642902,
0.5013083816,
0.6609787941,
0.6340230703,
0.4280548692,
0.2765455246,
-0.0925423354,
0.3152726889,
-0.7371507883,
0.2831007838,
-0.3711902201,
-0.3364337683,
-0.6203072071,
-0.1602043509,
0.7763743401,
0.7419756055,
-0.1452118605,
0.2835769653,
0.0323908739,
0.4009425044,
-1.0393695831,
0.1781644672,
-0.1886461526,
0.1334016174,
-0.2308957428,
-0.0391468033,
-0.5196899772,
-0.1834741384,
0.0629500449,
-0.4333113432,
0.2994381189,
0.1086785495,
0.7199395299,
0.3231246471,
-0.5765333176,
0.4551036656,
-0.7024509907,
0.4355135262,
-0.4740892947,
0.3803171813,
0.6716149449,
-0.0045630396,
-0.3240135908,
-0.9900283217,
-0.3321635127,
0.0977734923,
-0.2952547371,
-0.1471014172,
-0.2367611527,
0.4115757346,
0.1368502825,
0.6113011241,
-0.1545985639,
0.1621266454,
0.082059525,
-0.5825254321,
0.7346931696,
0.1831290275,
-0.2135753036,
0.0768935382,
-0.8289323449,
0.0848520324,
-0.9419233203,
0.147989437,
0.4205477834,
-0.2143899798,
-0.2549071312,
0.4545652568,
-0.5552479625,
0.3203856945,
0.1790271997,
-0.2898242176,
0.1396821439,
-0.1752024442,
-0.5943812728,
-0.3053079844,
0.7702488303,
0.3988230228,
-0.3674085736,
-0.4064652622,
-0.3321828544,
-0.3629668653,
-0.125698179,
-1.0363277197,
-0.3046758771,
0.1780588776,
-0.8701468706,
-0.4606964886,
0.3651684821,
-0.5571235418,
-0.6761564016,
0.1376349032,
0.1917459518,
0.0594227426,
-0.4885875881,
0.1293344796,
0.1693213284,
0.2981472611,
0.3483625352,
-0.7824695706,
0.838439703,
0.8876623511,
0.6277237535,
-0.5553072095,
-0.221556589,
-0.3891909719,
0.2407167703,
-0.1013275832,
0.3960013092,
-0.2051883936,
-0.8106681705,
-0.0443511419,
0.2543215156,
-0.0037693188,
-0.6002836227,
0.6561436057,
-0.5575997233,
-0.0207166262,
-0.4730966389,
-0.7595030665,
-0.2079890072,
-0.1091408581,
-0.6493638158,
0.7634137869,
0.0275823716,
-0.7176300287,
0.0290398691,
-0.712882936,
-0.2814805806,
0.2650528252,
-0.1082410887,
-0.686838448,
0.2360250205,
0.1936676502,
0.8073691726,
-0.1980593652,
0.1917650104,
-0.5913638473,
-0.4202381074,
0.4253516495,
-0.5598813891,
0.828114748,
0.6257532239,
-0.2283436656,
0.0857785046,
-0.4136437774,
-0.041598551,
0.0769498423,
-0.2575753331,
-0.011867254,
0.1566305757,
0.0854554251,
-0.3577845693,
0.506937027,
-0.5784356594,
-0.0349659547,
-0.3741925955,
0.3956481814,
0.8573976159,
0.5370172858,
0.7722691894,
-0.5190652609,
0.5913881063,
0.191369161,
0.361841619,
-0.1475863457,
-0.4776246846,
-0.3203128576,
-0.6854899526,
0.1836378276,
0.6411738396,
-0.3789600134,
0.2658872902,
-0.1620711982,
0.0035776428,
-0.3371093571,
0.2296592295,
0.5167871118,
0.5027171969,
-0.2203141302,
0.0234369077,
-0.0835517123,
-1.4605813026,
-0.0105690621,
-0.133930847,
-0.2423776984,
0.3573753536,
0.3640524149,
-0.105524525,
0.8932484388,
-0.4534472227,
-0.1690979898,
0.2053641677,
-0.1868431568,
-0.1406000257,
0.8329835534,
0.1071832329,
-1.1051012278,
0.0760308802,
-0.1979920864,
-0.6290079355,
-0.1192580089,
0.0028999562,
-0.4786736667,
0.0603091344,
0.4477995634,
-0.4574341178,
0.6222980618,
0.4917001724,
-0.5203549862,
0.3352953196,
-0.3475793898,
0.2175615579,
-1.0485808849,
0.0568773821,
-0.4063213766,
-0.7744514346,
-0.5174533129,
0.4560459852,
0.2782215178,
-0.4338475168,
-0.6735807061,
0.5891539454,
-0.5822883248,
-0.2026798874,
-0.0962171853,
-0.2885015607,
-0.0426423363,
0.3365829289,
0.1803001463,
0.9504466057,
0.5769889951,
-0.683124423,
0.2140749693,
0.1239852384,
-0.0887174159,
0.6255959272,
-0.4223295152,
0.4536776543,
0.1625833362,
0.0608530082,
-0.9218449593,
-0.3901169598,
0.3607516289,
-0.3901011646,
0.2219734937,
-0.272543788,
-0.6304925084,
-0.0004216065,
-0.3618180454,
0.3265748322,
0.4851834178,
-0.5446997285,
0.7182300687,
0.5894298553,
0.0399197899,
-0.2625878453,
-0.7010311484,
0.1128637046,
-0.2621571124,
-0.8409515619,
0.6968583465,
-0.1943750232,
-0.5289949775,
0.0730496496,
-0.1164596751,
-0.4725435674,
0.6216467023,
0.8150006533,
0.0091095231,
-0.2072077245,
-0.1565570682,
0.3256306052,
-0.1492145509,
0.2295423299,
-0.318798244,
0.1660362333,
-0.2115189135,
-0.6670080423,
-1.0259790421,
0.7832500935,
0.3612119853,
-0.2627592683,
0.8320122361,
0.436050415,
-0.5346968174,
-0.2889432907,
-0.660657227,
-0.2783673108,
-0.5416878462,
0.1306445897,
-0.5675137043,
-1.0132610798,
0.6337528825,
-0.3747206926,
0.1191810519,
-0.1205322146,
0.6517954469,
-0.1796863377,
0.8280138969,
0.8701692224,
-0.1052066088,
0.4769845009,
-0.179086417,
-0.023250822,
-0.6797834635,
-0.2729921639,
-0.3169235587,
-0.2484531552,
-0.454300642,
-0.5010536313,
0.315464586,
0.311098963,
-0.0506724082,
-0.3585032523,
-0.3705331683,
0.6892309189,
0.5999647975,
0.4941678643,
0.187442705,
0.0967895836,
0.0702021345,
0.096840553,
-0.3923366964,
-0.6239162087,
1.0232114792,
0.4941346645,
0.9493713379,
0.2745860219,
1.2246364355,
0.4383250475,
0.2094649076,
-0.5864723325,
0.6819963455,
0.1800500453,
-0.5222420692,
-0.0510017015,
-0.4837574363,
-0.6831160188,
0.4113455713,
0.0042986926,
-0.9322432876,
0.5219647884,
0.1873206049,
-0.4856030345,
0.4081234932,
-1.041711688,
0.5867974758,
0.1143430397,
-0.8848858476,
0.1191183999,
-0.5711485147,
0.5418866873,
0.1635882258,
-0.0248867702,
0.0051059034,
-0.4090906978,
0.7786687016,
-0.6876564622,
0.9540858865,
-0.6723201871,
-0.0891256407,
-0.0341395847,
0.5550521612,
0.6510685682,
0.5127215981,
-0.122855179,
0.1572729498,
0.2247005999,
-0.4758355618,
-0.4500133395,
0.9085842967,
-0.5584154129,
-0.8460349441,
-0.1360599101,
-0.5439351797,
-0.0927436873,
0.2640164793,
0.0420577638,
0.032507211,
-0.1106589735,
0.4027217329,
1.0771921873,
0.0006356707,
0.4898756444,
0.727850318,
-0.2074745744,
-0.2900134623,
0.549292326,
-0.2310046852,
0.3369035423,
0.4191020429,
0.0899330676,
-0.4287769496,
-0.6597563624,
-0.2941427529,
0.1721010953,
-0.7666602731,
-0.1785137355,
-0.3568180799,
0.0525958166,
-0.485296309,
-0.2549279332,
-0.3521696925,
-0.4055840373,
-0.502645731,
-0.3316722512,
0.0751387328,
0.5266287923,
-0.0574698746,
0.3065748215,
-0.2702845633,
0.3499585092,
-0.0936725065,
0.3103689253,
-0.473361671,
-0.2128545642,
0.1956458092,
0.0453213416,
0.014557397,
-0.8981062174,
0.1346885711,
0.1132964194,
0.8100670576,
0.611789763,
0.5202869773,
0.497612685,
-0.0202633776,
1.0001482964,
-0.2340093553,
-1.0709971189,
0.2568379641,
-0.1004524827,
0.0226478539,
0.5253337026,
0.09409751,
-0.1635687947,
-0.1778054237,
-0.7209069133,
-0.7719908357,
0.7107852101,
0.0917926431,
0.1571183205,
0.2817829251,
0.628421545,
0.0110398913,
0.2692355812,
-0.5693976879,
-0.6675788164,
0.1256080121,
-0.0385413207,
0.2493914962,
-0.5834446549,
-0.3973927796,
-0.1564377993,
0.5555687547,
-0.0058738738,
0.673771143,
0.4118588865,
-0.2093574852,
0.1686373949,
-0.1379501373,
0.4900092781,
0.6164013743,
0.0626132712,
0.3484895527,
0.1325900704,
-0.3426942825,
0.1629904211,
0.0734980404,
-0.6142770648,
-0.258199811,
0.0296916012,
0.5850602388,
0.3562178612,
-0.0920842215,
0.8883223534,
-0.1048318222,
-0.4199382067,
-0.3201753497,
0.1201290861,
0.1708758771,
0.2315237075,
0.2416702211,
-0.0075913044,
0.2784572542,
0.0358003043,
0.2800234854,
0.4978989363,
0.0685600042,
-0.1944579929,
0.9057537317,
0.1851793677,
-0.4754205942,
0.2811594903,
-0.4345771968,
-0.2736556232,
0.2629581094,
0.5441852212,
0.9479486346,
-0.2948712111,
0.214002043,
-0.2108532488,
0.0758161619,
0.0760285333,
0.4136698842,
-0.8177224994,
-0.4836288095,
-0.0275671277,
-0.5626128912,
-0.5041005611,
0.0299671572,
-0.8458455205,
0.0405440256,
-0.7465094924,
-0.1056417301,
-0.3768537045,
0.0653173178,
-0.512385726,
-0.2798659503,
0.2783123255,
0.8161723614,
-0.6167892218,
1.0912754536,
0.4697511494,
-0.0653027669,
-0.6170660853,
-0.0787453279,
0.3915470243,
-0.652775228,
0.4924587011,
-0.2488362342,
-0.448882848,
0.1158380583,
-0.6360138655,
-0.6955859661,
1.2560251951,
0.7641144991,
-0.3295827806,
0.1216188148,
0.0609526038,
0.1040189341,
-0.1742274612,
-0.0807989985,
0.3477201462,
0.4308947921,
-0.0904798359,
-0.8303689957,
0.2118955255,
-0.0767118037,
0.0450953804,
-0.1388655901,
-0.530793786,
0.8400865793,
-0.1019832194,
-0.5052981973,
0.2427636981,
0.8404197097,
-0.0171875879,
0.367932111,
0.2211408913,
0.186288178,
1.1114102602,
-0.0581908077,
1.1566443443,
-0.2978683114,
0.4036141634,
0.9682457447,
-0.5022262931,
0.7650923729,
0.5980238914,
-0.1491853893,
0.1452071071,
0.5774037838,
0.2596647739,
0.5360178947,
0.1237558722,
-0.7167398334,
-0.2772147954,
0.0114623588,
-0.2563701868,
0.2333802134,
0.1904431432,
-0.5730542541,
-0.2029013187,
-0.0282239541,
0.3173679113,
0.0702483431,
-0.2282668501,
0.8492423296,
0.0306175854,
-0.2406122833,
0.5223103166,
0.6077125669,
0.6942581534,
-0.5791009665,
0.1486185044,
-0.4616732001,
0.4078349173,
-0.4908418357,
-0.4134272635,
0.097201027,
-0.2450344414,
-0.2934203744,
-0.8255801797,
0.7421423793,
-0.2102934569,
-0.308927387,
0.0000724815,
0.2910012603,
0.227661863,
-0.1323162466,
-0.6362463236,
0.1049710065,
0.015997624,
-0.4242674708,
0.4942515492,
0.2054813057,
-0.2085078657,
0.7345548868,
0.7420936823,
0.1698098332,
0.1129249707,
-0.074042283,
0.7931656241,
-0.2531718016,
-0.7449011207,
-0.904296577,
0.2334699929,
-0.1839603186,
-0.1152246967,
0.8785829544,
0.730646193,
0.7171245217,
0.0484640487,
0.4305403531,
0.1845247746,
0.4539512694,
-0.6105282307,
1.0433336496,
-0.0136531815,
0.3428713381,
0.0598659776,
-0.4309584796,
-0.2877955437,
0.5028026104,
-0.2445479184,
-0.2618158162,
0.5075169802,
1.3063739538,
-0.1944102347,
0.0586412996,
0.4903330505,
0.0556331426,
0.4534624815,
0.536213696,
0.6593064666,
-0.2648642659,
0.018483514,
-0.6954811811,
-0.3204165995,
-0.0360586047,
-0.8006948233,
-0.7354124784,
-0.5952755809,
-0.352789849,
-0.1277171671,
-0.040155258,
0.7394824028,
1.1118609905,
-0.7326544523,
-0.2471363991,
0.0156357456,
0.367849201,
-0.1408153921,
-0.2518298626,
0.3423860073,
0.1678661853,
-0.5766593814,
0.6087450981,
0.121760942,
0.0084903687,
-0.6450007558,
-0.2670860887,
0.0349227414,
-0.2412191033,
0.2477993369,
0.1690634638,
-0.8014654517,
-0.0995573029,
-0.1677782983,
0.0056480514,
-0.2709774375,
1.004319787,
-0.6866298318,
0.3318305016,
0.3790406585,
0.8277167082,
0.7257099748,
0.4219412506,
0.4216439128,
-0.8818898201,
0.4466744661,
0.3200690746,
0.3766673505,
0.1915378422,
-0.9042059183,
0.0457842611,
0.392341584,
-0.5783005953,
-1.0361548662,
0.2367499173,
-0.640976727,
-0.101113826,
1.0723290443,
-0.80559659,
-0.6569666862,
-0.1619469225,
-0.104827486,
-0.2760555148,
-0.3663029075,
0.2122520804,
0.452021569,
-0.144415766,
-0.2213840187,
-0.2739342749,
0.5985641479,
0.3465663493,
-0.6819142103,
0.3672231436,
0.7418521643,
0.6188605428,
-0.288176775,
1.0348153114,
-0.3981183469,
0.2618998289,
0.0618140362,
-0.2219945192,
-0.6661109328,
-0.157840386,
-0.6575165987,
0.5473384261,
0.0991980955,
-0.5535143018
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12233v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12233v1 | SyncVSR: Data-Efficient Visual Speech Recognition with End-to-End Crossmodal Audio Token Synchronization | 2024-06-18T03:14:22 | 2024-06-18T03:14:22 | Young Jin Ahn, Jungwoo Park, Sangha Park, Jonghyun Choi, Kee-Eung Kim | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV | Visual Speech Recognition (VSR) stands at the intersection of computer vision
and speech recognition, aiming to interpret spoken content from visual cues. A
prominent challenge in VSR is the presence of homophenes-visually similar lip
gestures that represent different phonemes. Prior approaches have sought to
distinguish fine-grained visemes by aligning visual and auditory semantics, but
often fell short of full synchronization. To address this, we present SyncVSR,
an end-to-end learning framework that leverages quantized audio for frame-level
crossmodal supervision. By integrating a projection layer that synchronizes
visual representation with acoustic data, our encoder learns to generate
discrete audio tokens from a video sequence in a non-autoregressive manner.
SyncVSR shows versatility across tasks, languages, and modalities at the cost
of a forward pass. Our empirical evaluations show that it not only achieves
state-of-the-art results but also reduces data usage by up to ninefold. | [
-0.0328131616,
-0.438557893,
0.0395923518,
-0.0479178876,
-0.4945423603,
0.0657688454,
-0.040866185,
-0.3210781217,
0.2350326329,
0.0507552885,
-0.4416778982,
-0.3710588217,
-0.5078270435,
-0.1138816178,
-0.687777102,
0.5164123774,
-0.0400154889,
0.3307713568,
-0.5667728186,
-0.4051699638,
-0.3143440187,
-0.3457604647,
-0.2855632603,
-0.0790672377,
0.1833420694,
0.2966129482,
0.6170226336,
0.9479157925,
0.4681226015,
0.3692002594,
-0.0016693855,
0.0924787149,
-0.334312737,
0.2911051214,
0.0255635921,
-0.3359899819,
-0.2591602802,
-0.2586062849,
0.4761258662,
0.3731993437,
-0.325217545,
0.4194381535,
-0.1074354425,
0.5197253227,
-0.6452178359,
0.1899066269,
-0.4988085926,
0.3791828752,
-0.3889298737,
-0.4588607848,
-0.0412409492,
-0.0316882096,
0.4339493513,
-0.7134337425,
0.1057808697,
0.0350516587,
0.6408357024,
0.5537486076,
-0.2553294599,
-0.0600773878,
-0.6729607582,
0.656018436,
-0.0218713153,
1.0647177696,
0.2658820152,
0.5776855946,
0.2712059617,
-1.0399791002,
-0.7168925405,
0.3027253449,
0.4798260331,
0.3930471241,
-0.3075498939,
-0.0568958819,
0.2235713303,
0.5001610518,
-0.8678532839,
-0.1609641612,
-0.3397622108,
-0.4416062236,
0.2410565615,
0.0812225193,
0.2572856843,
-0.1542751938,
-0.7977563739,
-0.3958691359,
-0.0776789188,
0.4178126156,
-0.0942604542,
0.1337874234,
-0.3164979815,
0.6516155601,
0.0010610559,
0.7637193203,
0.133478865,
-0.2063975781,
0.4377661347,
-0.4253956974,
-0.6381143928,
0.3977051973,
0.7253698111,
0.4532140493,
0.1658597291,
-0.123140648,
-0.3158809245,
0.3989824057,
-0.0309097692,
-0.5904613137,
-0.0629466176,
0.109644644,
-0.3155947924,
0.2145104706,
0.0177911054,
-0.501591444,
-0.0243534707,
-0.5697003603,
0.5576246381,
-0.4451350272,
0.0191385075,
-0.0306072142,
-0.4129482508,
0.4210294485,
0.3000859916,
-0.6637311578,
0.3730432987,
0.5766403079,
0.930244565,
-0.008866109,
-0.0421402007,
-1.0196896791,
0.2875738442,
-0.313387841,
0.3750698566,
-0.6660821438,
-0.5479630232,
-0.0591413341,
-0.2033992112,
0.1312909275,
-0.7219740748,
0.1581971198,
-0.122592546,
0.3776501715,
-0.3184020221,
-0.5582756996,
0.1239552051,
-0.211468488,
-0.2436978072,
0.8527158499,
-0.0638713092,
-0.6472696662,
0.8043867946,
0.0715091527,
-0.3343807757,
0.2942028046,
-0.4601547718,
-0.5927735567,
0.0572506376,
0.0960785598,
0.3242443502,
-0.2799044549,
0.1782455146,
-0.1007943749,
-0.3054645956,
0.0240778103,
-0.429928571,
0.3084362745,
0.2785055637,
-0.1908096075,
0.3673902154,
-1.0340467691,
-0.1263194829,
-0.1767285764,
0.0094869006,
-0.4928269386,
0.0271218009,
0.3856394291,
0.2774719,
0.1502506286,
-0.6944976449,
-0.2644760311,
-0.0043663741,
0.6270550489,
0.6921375394,
-0.4397011101,
0.5111657977,
-0.3369364738,
0.3565562367,
0.1876691282,
0.4721008539,
-0.5401954651,
-0.4316500425,
-0.6888771057,
-0.7004808784,
-0.006287952,
0.6305945516,
-0.8149725795,
0.4280730188,
-0.4709209502,
-0.1693685651,
-0.7616633177,
0.0694633797,
0.6553346515,
0.5408631563,
0.4259069562,
-0.7406554818,
-0.8240672946,
-0.5807673931,
-0.0304974839,
-0.0834152326,
-0.0313454196,
0.3082168102,
0.3000052571,
-0.2087731808,
1.1732950211,
0.2243952155,
-0.7197678089,
0.3223718703,
-0.0009953622,
-0.1415960342,
0.496099025,
0.208609134,
-1.1615307331,
-0.3797145486,
0.2283121943,
-0.7345722914,
0.0747209638,
-0.1444975436,
0.091785945,
-0.1048113927,
0.7168474197,
-0.1274046004,
0.2902892232,
0.7095258236,
-0.2681908607,
-0.0176760741,
-0.0672489852,
-0.0109530753,
-1.0401039124,
-0.0764686093,
0.0226435438,
-0.68339926,
-0.4893702865,
-0.7306860685,
-0.1484260112,
-0.3230279684,
-0.5802541971,
0.2919893563,
-0.4648880064,
-0.4333917499,
0.1649619341,
0.2583066821,
-0.2470572591,
0.357196182,
0.1768036932,
0.8801919818,
0.8300279379,
-0.1524012536,
0.5835695267,
0.3954305351,
-0.1281640977,
0.8048152924,
-0.693541646,
0.0183055066,
-0.2259764373,
-0.082455121,
-0.9392747879,
-0.128240481,
-0.0363927335,
-0.691670537,
0.2642974257,
-0.1677577943,
-0.074994877,
0.0136795584,
-0.2135995626,
0.4679080546,
0.69309479,
-0.6865658164,
0.7482094169,
0.482139051,
0.0914636403,
-0.5410971045,
-0.996075213,
0.0419575647,
0.0316102467,
-0.4142455757,
0.2818889618,
0.1184091344,
-0.0138844745,
0.1073015332,
-0.6690095663,
-0.1441053152,
-0.5766823292,
0.6979269385,
0.1675475389,
-0.087555401,
-0.2014719546,
-0.2260710299,
-0.139708057,
-0.0499849878,
-0.588552177,
0.3273429275,
-0.0318473689,
-0.4731145799,
-0.7637900114,
0.3457082212,
0.9088532925,
-0.3891305327,
0.1176324934,
0.6368473768,
-0.2267689556,
-0.0512567796,
-0.306452632,
0.1653337032,
-0.4836673141,
0.3698637187,
-0.3642618358,
-1.025006175,
0.4840078056,
0.0893386453,
-0.1062091142,
-0.1777794808,
0.3715245426,
-0.1316514015,
0.7127529979,
0.4699604511,
-0.0322143212,
1.1307399273,
-0.1513279229,
0.0139329704,
-0.766397655,
-0.6800329089,
0.0180367902,
-0.1240509525,
-0.5355808139,
-0.8949447274,
0.334426254,
-0.0808691904,
-0.0715920329,
0.394449532,
-0.4030022323,
0.4346573055,
0.6813790202,
0.1597007811,
0.0598113984,
0.156671837,
-0.0868277773,
-0.1656800359,
-0.5603702664,
0.0160298944,
0.6320511699,
0.166645959,
0.7787617445,
-0.0973313153,
0.6072579026,
0.434302479,
-0.4427480698,
-0.6129789352,
0.6268948317,
-0.0831133872,
-0.0508915335,
-0.277621001,
-0.5135455132,
-0.5126039982,
0.3253562748,
-0.2983988822,
-0.4935554564,
0.5824148059,
0.3781591654,
-0.0305205546,
0.2340608835,
-0.3734585941,
0.6870779395,
-0.1536287069,
-0.532697618,
0.0171468984,
-0.9925775528,
0.0208625291,
0.0496215969,
0.1683297306,
0.0622688271,
-0.1411097348,
0.5161226392,
-0.3464278281,
0.6987350583,
-0.1913765818,
0.0545809343,
0.1870601177,
-0.0423255824,
0.2788994014,
-0.1578702778,
0.4281787276,
0.0933340564,
-0.1501799822,
-0.2389619648,
-0.3669716716,
0.3190424144,
-0.4071239531,
-0.0017502557,
-0.3697930574,
-0.4714941382,
-0.093415603,
-0.0066806474,
0.1650651246,
0.8170753121,
-0.1577218026,
0.2154211849,
0.640248239,
-0.2168755978,
0.5123510361,
0.1607696563,
-0.3037312329,
-0.9680668116,
1.1798126698,
0.0020946828,
0.3539654315,
0.6220487356,
-0.0949320421,
-0.225763455,
-0.1390925795,
-0.4243684709,
-0.1265394986,
-0.5990815163,
-0.0405077972,
-0.3694727421,
-0.0002266869,
-0.2980532348,
-0.2384519726,
-0.6310519576,
-0.352996856,
-0.309989959,
0.0954366103,
0.2588838339,
-0.0489923321,
-0.2324383855,
0.2871728241,
-0.759737432,
0.6612864733,
0.874710083,
0.2301345915,
-0.3504872322,
-0.5423403978,
-0.2687295675,
-0.1770217419,
0.2072021961,
-0.5302658677,
0.4675769806,
0.55298841,
0.3123447895,
0.6444829702,
-0.0782608092,
1.2509839535,
-0.6514529586,
0.7051902413,
0.8086916804,
-1.450594306,
0.4351809621,
-0.0625100359,
0.205166012,
0.1705640256,
0.2675522566,
-0.7118035555,
-0.1217921898,
-0.2098515332,
-0.9960594177,
0.3516481221,
0.137241587,
-0.1084452197,
0.0330599248,
-0.0916961879,
-0.0014279677,
0.3266898692,
-0.3271739483,
-0.1314647347,
-0.6437426805,
-0.2815939784,
0.0743453875,
0.0112255365,
-0.0187142827,
-0.4079589844,
0.1812595874,
-0.1857885122,
0.2125767171,
0.6699652076,
-0.3507455587,
-0.3167657256,
0.2628550231,
0.4625297785,
0.2843986452,
0.0545826592,
0.2370266765,
0.1348383278,
-0.481205821,
-0.040776372,
0.0470435545,
0.1488849968,
0.1081377342,
0.4161422253,
1.1225481033,
0.1763359904,
-1.0087114573,
0.9038798213,
-0.1537130326,
-0.2354567349,
-0.4213235676,
-0.2567738593,
-0.2753385305,
0.6966254115,
0.3086580038,
0.1941419095,
0.2301646322,
-0.4950855076,
0.5896580815,
0.4150613546,
-0.8458713889,
-0.4594492316,
1.0922341347,
0.2474671304,
-0.2776765823,
0.4849162102,
0.2220023572,
-0.3426208496,
0.2169210464,
0.3490100801,
0.9016283154,
-0.3826711774,
0.0862048343,
-0.0315163694,
0.0441162549,
0.2942530513,
0.88636446,
-0.8704565167,
-0.2814215124,
-0.4043158591,
-0.6759670377,
-0.5050023198,
-0.5961780548,
-1.0089273453,
0.1500048637,
-0.3913409412,
-0.2051664591,
-0.1777950227,
-0.8342368007,
-0.2949252129,
0.2528702915,
0.577506423,
0.6620411277,
-0.838973403,
0.8650246263,
0.5034814477,
-0.3392432332,
-0.3330890834,
-0.2813975513,
0.2370822579,
-0.7415861487,
0.6688722372,
0.0736323744,
-0.2595871985,
-0.038775526,
-0.2584115565,
-0.6788792014,
1.1040309668,
0.3794111013,
-1.221411705,
-0.0176695213,
0.2379273623,
0.4678950608,
0.0528147817,
-0.0060700453,
0.1726688594,
-0.003812846,
0.4003390372,
-1.2569975853,
-0.3049424887,
-0.2980892658,
0.2139416486,
0.3349524736,
-0.4990516603,
0.8593896031,
-0.300765872,
-0.3480394483,
-0.2608180046,
0.9994646907,
-0.0275272541,
0.4860673547,
0.6097080112,
0.6293691397,
0.6295012832,
-0.1100937128,
0.7096841335,
-0.210204348,
0.142620191,
1.0372481346,
-0.3434838951,
0.9870470166,
0.9085817337,
0.0664740428,
0.1933838874,
0.2996270061,
-0.0543298945,
0.9160938263,
0.1280277073,
-0.3596057296,
-0.4792262316,
-0.490421921,
-0.2215669602,
0.6068753004,
0.1169723943,
-0.2241512537,
0.1259787828,
0.5714113712,
-0.4759971499,
0.0713231191,
-0.2860603631,
0.9160004258,
0.2425615042,
0.0797720924,
0.4259839654,
-0.8703247905,
0.7151145935,
-0.5772919059,
-0.2526507378,
0.1597753763,
0.2991451025,
-0.1958886087,
-0.677609086,
0.1914929152,
0.0564781018,
-0.2559915781,
-0.5467495322,
0.2041412443,
-0.7937310338,
-0.0524479561,
0.3871029019,
0.3577482104,
-0.0702269003,
0.2481404692,
-0.4161010981,
0.1727991253,
-0.1454616189,
0.0180132203,
0.1310536712,
0.5722594857,
-0.0668561086,
0.7097976208,
0.8101426363,
0.1262295991,
0.3508600295,
0.1050099134,
0.7144883871,
-0.6192768812,
-0.654540956,
-0.6236417294,
0.4894128144,
0.0500070974,
-0.2627484202,
0.7934885621,
0.8746124506,
1.2460763454,
0.1550735831,
0.5725972056,
0.0303131249,
0.2647563517,
-0.4975820482,
0.154513374,
-0.7372543812,
0.0272741355,
-0.3825234175,
-0.5642955303,
-0.322876364,
0.559992075,
0.2643916011,
-0.2483967543,
0.2894644141,
0.4239373505,
-0.1986166388,
0.0552465953,
0.5712803006,
-0.0091489647,
0.0966016501,
0.5272177458,
0.8862250447,
-0.5528781414,
0.5643462539,
-0.236534372,
-0.0384201743,
0.1008462235,
-0.4950713813,
-0.7368811965,
-0.856943965,
-0.3764127493,
-0.0236196592,
0.4272705019,
1.0940202475,
0.9717933536,
-0.5022384524,
-0.379335165,
-0.1012152657,
-0.3211620152,
-0.3369010389,
-0.106931828,
0.161859408,
0.0164871905,
-0.7620611191,
0.5188470483,
0.5470952392,
0.2846833467,
0.1403342336,
-0.3554415405,
0.2315838188,
-0.0781225264,
0.5641655922,
0.3766354322,
-0.6867758632,
-0.1290956736,
0.0883561671,
0.065007396,
0.2670789659,
0.8099013567,
-0.9337598681,
0.9239571095,
0.7487339377,
0.4642354846,
0.7325987816,
-0.0932501405,
0.5059344769,
-0.8299795985,
0.2325822562,
0.1211397573,
0.4988463223,
0.424125582,
0.1935153157,
0.2039697915,
0.4883210063,
-0.4252412319,
-0.9617390633,
0.0267345682,
-1.4733059406,
0.0348385014,
0.6653566957,
0.0433885492,
-0.36979568,
0.0451859832,
-0.1665594578,
0.4383696914,
-0.5041569471,
0.0798568055,
-0.0388934016,
-0.1121761575,
-0.4314109385,
-0.3615211248,
0.3959203959,
0.3099918365,
-0.4852521718,
0.26061064,
0.6178236604,
0.1997971982,
0.0542394668,
0.3939192891,
-0.1822980046,
0.5630121827,
0.1849015653,
0.1822685599,
-0.2998128831,
-0.4053079784,
-0.5465265512,
0.0338665321,
-0.6397974491,
-0.8449522257
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12232v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12232v1 | "You Gotta be a Doctor, Lin": An Investigation of Name-Based Bias of Large Language Models in Employment Recommendations | 2024-06-18T03:11:43 | 2024-06-18T03:11:43 | Huy Nghiem, John Prindle, Jieyu Zhao, Hal Daumé III | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Social science research has shown that candidates with names indicative of
certain races or genders often face discrimination in employment practices.
Similarly, Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated racial and gender
biases in various applications. In this study, we utilize GPT-3.5-Turbo and
Llama 3-70B-Instruct to simulate hiring decisions and salary recommendations
for candidates with 320 first names that strongly signal their race and gender,
across over 750,000 prompts. Our empirical results indicate a preference among
these models for hiring candidates with White female-sounding names over other
demographic groups across 40 occupations. Additionally, even among candidates
with identical qualifications, salary recommendations vary by as much as 5%
between different subgroups. A comparison with real-world labor data reveals
inconsistent alignment with U.S. labor market characteristics, underscoring the
necessity of risk investigation of LLM-powered systems. | [
-0.1077439934,
-0.3307189941,
0.9007693529,
-0.1386716962,
-0.0835531428,
-0.0209451951,
-0.1309215426,
-0.6317163706,
0.5666264296,
0.3701393902,
-0.4831427932,
-0.2290308475,
-0.7895553708,
-0.0672794655,
-0.4285692573,
1.0621620417,
0.328071028,
0.6066262722,
0.1781440079,
0.1230577454,
-0.4369514585,
-0.4168015122,
-0.7260394096,
-0.2045221031,
0.8131782413,
0.281278789,
1.0224815607,
0.5820708275,
0.2330832034,
0.1767975092,
-0.1675928086,
-0.1649669856,
-0.3203040957,
0.2351233065,
-0.3716032505,
-0.4427300096,
-0.398519814,
0.3705355823,
0.1199983433,
1.0323110819,
-0.079764463,
0.5031630993,
-0.4965659678,
0.7693852782,
-0.5809055567,
-0.176529184,
-0.7287566662,
0.0051918677,
-0.2235387564,
0.0936618,
-0.2185943872,
-0.8140541315,
0.4479906857,
-0.2179456651,
0.3074716926,
0.2501628697,
1.0127717257,
-0.048498325,
-0.5699752569,
-0.1206707433,
-0.862562716,
0.5454482436,
-0.6035988927,
0.4810764194,
0.52427423,
0.4119561017,
0.0923281312,
-0.4463939667,
-0.3679499328,
-0.2289525121,
-0.1100686491,
-0.1735976189,
0.0907534137,
0.0918178707,
0.5031133294,
0.1977212578,
-0.3718008101,
0.4884253144,
-0.7251107693,
-0.0849298835,
0.8503599167,
0.3398222625,
0.3318310678,
0.3697780371,
-0.0963242725,
-0.0322422348,
-0.8151311278,
-0.0183001012,
0.9037663341,
0.1788511723,
-0.017614238,
0.4900235832,
-0.2975867391,
0.7077014446,
-0.0180545058,
-0.0738610104,
0.0444342196,
-0.0282215979,
-0.3198388815,
0.3196061254,
0.7271144986,
0.5805906057,
0.7327797413,
-0.2093209177,
-0.0051107253,
-0.0517299026,
0.4503159523,
-0.4875474274,
-0.1069745421,
0.0171455983,
-0.4098406136,
-0.4019257128,
-0.0631420389,
-0.7697538137,
-0.7989643216,
-0.2916355431,
0.0346223861,
0.0322904848,
-0.2468853593,
-0.0914328322,
-0.0719002262,
0.1563350111,
0.3187199235,
-1.1784906387,
-0.0074163019,
0.6320486665,
0.3955339193,
-0.1170698553,
-0.2307152748,
-0.3265446424,
0.0592620559,
-0.3819118738,
0.4827535152,
-0.6502841711,
-0.533449173,
-0.0765786916,
0.1335434169,
0.0587646775,
-0.4790956378,
0.3322486281,
-0.4603542387,
0.0707232952,
-0.5541213751,
-0.3168976605,
-0.0547851324,
-0.0301633794,
-0.4404672682,
0.6289716959,
0.3707181811,
-0.5343376398,
0.9306460023,
-0.3164710104,
-0.3927800953,
0.1043371111,
-0.6446694732,
-0.2930181623,
0.1908994615,
-0.0462759733,
0.3085767329,
-0.4902538657,
0.5592638254,
-0.2292232364,
-0.4118687212,
0.2425670028,
-0.1901145726,
0.9463837147,
0.012611649,
-0.4567571878,
-0.0294441562,
-0.3740322888,
-0.1439574063,
0.0441350713,
-0.059294913,
-0.4217330217,
0.051685784,
-0.1900250316,
0.0574816838,
-0.15156883,
-0.679541707,
0.418649137,
-0.281324178,
0.0319157988,
0.9682456255,
-0.3510348797,
0.2171312571,
-0.3862636387,
0.7707823515,
-0.1516523063,
-0.0387420319,
0.4380222261,
-0.5754339099,
-0.5281279087,
-0.075739257,
0.5213887095,
0.5500143766,
-0.3298739493,
-0.0412041768,
-0.0838397145,
-0.6656366587,
-0.5636862516,
-0.0265812259,
0.0923079327,
0.4382701516,
0.0030533972,
-0.0332485139,
-0.73730129,
-1.2774326801,
-0.6880581379,
-0.3657737076,
-0.1148497462,
0.6444105506,
0.3455623388,
-0.4218043685,
1.0120272636,
-0.74492836,
0.011531204,
0.0748576298,
-0.1700094044,
0.6920617819,
0.1620392352,
0.7288999557,
-0.3351415098,
-0.4384177029,
-0.0389878415,
-0.2382787466,
-0.2695265114,
0.085394688,
-0.44762519,
-0.1394441128,
0.4162936509,
-0.238994658,
0.3635017276,
0.7198334932,
-0.5905730128,
0.9727609158,
-0.1504081935,
-0.2928576171,
-0.9378426075,
0.1238626838,
0.2764387131,
-0.237387225,
-0.4502846897,
-0.2473290861,
-0.0640979111,
-0.1905305982,
-0.3117901385,
0.7391983867,
-0.4827471673,
-0.1211879253,
-0.1347990334,
-0.1269741356,
-0.30314219,
0.0164886024,
-0.1387945563,
0.7239684463,
0.5027778149,
-0.9396341443,
0.44948861,
0.1024793983,
-0.4827281535,
0.7461236715,
-0.725923121,
0.2702060342,
-0.0951270908,
0.2682307661,
-0.7722209096,
-0.2615447342,
-0.1510226429,
0.0125254029,
0.0597946532,
-0.1090918854,
-0.2432959676,
-0.7296145558,
-0.0505772829,
0.6034861207,
0.3732017875,
-0.4508207738,
0.1716208309,
0.6139013767,
-0.4509910941,
-0.633838594,
-0.7180945873,
-0.0653626844,
-0.1769021004,
-0.3781758845,
0.3519043624,
-0.1393109709,
-0.4166954458,
-0.2825172246,
0.0225728452,
-0.4563771784,
0.1114054695,
0.2849501371,
0.7021786571,
-0.0856819674,
0.0358515047,
-0.2102845013,
0.0173706599,
0.27985847,
-0.0387773775,
0.2923098505,
0.3509228826,
-0.3403607905,
-0.065359883,
0.028662445,
0.7276576757,
0.1675364375,
0.544885993,
0.4693513215,
-0.1701180041,
0.0131143825,
-0.7526277304,
-0.3585913479,
-0.4539975226,
0.3936269283,
0.0946287662,
-0.8519352078,
0.4087953568,
0.0409354717,
0.1315349489,
0.3103729486,
0.7155821323,
-0.0158850607,
1.0124672651,
0.5710338354,
-0.4338745773,
0.2575258613,
0.161250338,
0.4430474043,
-0.629843533,
-0.0571642183,
-0.4407067895,
-0.7810283303,
-0.7742725611,
-0.1332708001,
0.3738723993,
-0.5307071805,
-0.2607604563,
0.0077105537,
-0.6858419776,
0.5720412135,
0.5103026032,
-0.0911309645,
0.0058943131,
-0.1079645753,
-0.231310457,
-0.1038904041,
-0.1973302364,
-0.2911665142,
1.2037130594,
0.5194479227,
0.8360360265,
0.2216839641,
0.4132062793,
0.2403301597,
0.347966224,
-0.4886672199,
0.3193171918,
-0.3946014345,
-1.0792111158,
-0.5031987429,
-0.1846808344,
-0.962205112,
0.3038084507,
-0.2026063353,
-0.8664503098,
0.4168420434,
0.0287888069,
-0.3902539313,
0.4229822457,
-0.4180010855,
0.4467878044,
-0.5347637534,
-0.0675385818,
0.120640412,
-0.3184501827,
0.7308140397,
-0.1973577738,
0.353592068,
-0.4785450101,
0.1148321107,
0.5550810695,
-0.6957390904,
0.7076727152,
-0.1864814907,
-0.057095442,
-0.33412081,
0.1594816595,
0.6514665484,
0.2338684797,
-0.6876726151,
0.4440416098,
0.0809363797,
-0.1323862523,
-0.1654037088,
0.571831286,
-0.7120653391,
-0.6442257762,
-0.4429794252,
-0.5953959227,
-0.2822757065,
0.2487929761,
0.4729318619,
0.0051248511,
-0.1819907725,
-0.0416352749,
0.2231503874,
-0.3588490486,
-0.1998593956,
0.5417255759,
-0.4278788567,
-0.0767134726,
0.6243482232,
0.2306637913,
0.104314059,
-0.4532395601,
0.2536382377,
-0.1652727723,
-0.0619615801,
-0.5033198595,
0.556030333,
-0.2983608246,
-0.009708819,
-0.4967429042,
-0.3961907327,
-0.3577071726,
-0.2654744685,
-0.14923051,
-0.0524619967,
-0.025614433,
-0.2444509566,
0.3331017196,
1.0618523359,
0.3450744152,
0.143377319,
0.0487223454,
0.2694950998,
0.7317498326,
0.6759209633,
-0.1680014431,
-0.3482451439,
-0.1261556298,
0.0506418757,
-0.0553545468,
-0.8532668948,
0.3678898513,
-0.0272287894,
0.7752561569,
0.4491145313,
-0.069925867,
0.2384582013,
-0.5314334631,
0.7648604512,
0.2256287038,
-0.5443136692,
0.314206332,
-0.4112812281,
0.019744914,
0.7579950094,
0.2869847715,
-0.6615264416,
-0.4104368389,
-0.4814044833,
-0.9794302583,
0.9308671355,
-0.086597167,
0.3079373837,
-0.1209467128,
0.2812311649,
0.2777421176,
0.2921380997,
-0.6932744384,
-0.7106829882,
0.3439146876,
0.049196355,
0.0053494759,
-0.7294605374,
-0.2302485406,
-0.3377657831,
0.5138759017,
0.1327565163,
0.0939039737,
0.0572469868,
-0.0128265759,
-0.0544857942,
0.3226676881,
0.9533051848,
0.6983092427,
-0.0883768946,
0.0587620214,
0.5221583843,
-0.5183108449,
0.3592058122,
-0.115807265,
-0.0068271933,
0.4772062302,
-0.0901277736,
0.8725460768,
0.1355037093,
-0.4248278439,
0.3491854072,
-0.1015239507,
-0.5391385555,
-0.374196291,
0.0473854728,
0.1622384489,
0.0665230304,
0.2493854612,
-0.3385596275,
-0.0504325628,
-0.6144946218,
-0.2986238003,
0.5806658268,
-0.5401126146,
0.0650609583,
0.8415805697,
0.4409967065,
-0.4098498225,
0.6074596643,
-0.2547258139,
-0.4698108137,
0.733507812,
0.3585211635,
0.7387559414,
-0.3678436279,
0.2352463752,
0.3292461932,
0.1834124178,
-0.3015018106,
0.1239857972,
0.424341172,
-0.6412898898,
-0.1570783406,
-0.636819303,
-0.7120274305,
0.0234314464,
-0.3699110448,
0.5018263459,
-0.65348351,
-0.4619728923,
0.1381492317,
-0.5023339391,
-0.9205277562,
0.2405194938,
0.4009415209,
0.6912629008,
-0.8318954706,
0.6995273232,
0.8958456516,
-0.1015466154,
-1.1097474098,
0.0260035954,
0.1553350389,
-0.8735682368,
1.2904247046,
-0.0505803227,
0.2172739357,
-0.2590482533,
-0.1078451052,
-0.9579465389,
1.1538062096,
0.823552072,
-0.7367666364,
-0.3616060913,
0.146529302,
0.2300604135,
-0.4076145887,
0.8750063181,
0.6082417369,
0.6488905549,
-0.3487548828,
-1.4101961851,
-0.1494143456,
0.1260541528,
0.1758373678,
0.0488518924,
-0.5445938706,
1.1744619608,
-0.4578432441,
0.0286501776,
-0.2887775898,
0.2191901654,
0.5472128391,
0.3049488664,
0.713724196,
0.0592345148,
1.198450923,
0.0011478058,
1.1320924759,
-0.4772489965,
0.3880367577,
0.7774035335,
-0.5285797119,
0.0719658509,
0.226305455,
-0.4472515583,
0.8909878135,
0.6073525548,
-0.2395059764,
0.1541826874,
0.4894518256,
-0.0777021423,
0.0548671596,
-0.3201335669,
-0.6975223422,
0.4385498464,
0.1822871119,
-0.8145487309,
0.0323562063,
-0.2941396236,
0.0420089513,
-0.1924056411,
-0.2741461992,
0.3023293614,
0.237617895,
-0.5427181125,
0.1897275448,
-0.1363180429,
0.8894119859,
-0.5353696346,
0.0863203034,
-0.0785519257,
-0.1350208223,
-0.4785366952,
-0.6317769885,
0.0049741119,
-0.0247975234,
-0.5365207791,
0.0023303642,
0.5158125758,
-0.3559568524,
-0.7054436207,
0.2553019226,
0.3235228956,
0.2934964597,
0.0477313474,
-0.4523593783,
-0.2952768803,
0.1338322163,
-0.1065403596,
0.3793412447,
0.0986936241,
-0.0309424289,
0.5929406285,
0.6488519907,
0.7321391702,
0.0193954222,
0.3337201476,
0.4267118871,
-0.755243659,
-0.8288119435,
-1.0164325237,
0.1818058193,
-0.1476003081,
-0.3530245423,
0.3450739384,
0.3974499404,
0.5276022553,
-0.1467546076,
0.6766896248,
0.2385540605,
0.6732940078,
-0.4394350648,
0.8310865164,
-0.474588722,
0.348995477,
-0.5580742955,
-1.0979623795,
0.1925574392,
0.3463155627,
-0.5169167519,
0.5965427756,
0.6520899534,
0.6638239622,
-0.0580833182,
-0.1105745733,
0.5804510713,
0.1084666625,
0.0962280482,
0.284466356,
0.3088474274,
0.0434098095,
0.2719624937,
-0.0647013038,
0.1214679256,
-0.8300228119,
-0.7509582639,
-0.4988870025,
-0.0100648077,
-0.3892373443,
-0.3760464489,
0.0288503896,
0.7585828304,
0.9473868012,
-0.6999801397,
-0.3891386092,
0.444431901,
0.2733278275,
-0.0225480348,
-0.2447093278,
-0.0180347152,
0.0706184432,
-0.6657118201,
0.4352312982,
0.0118614258,
-0.2069617808,
-0.31888327,
-0.0129877245,
-0.0384685956,
-0.0510560423,
0.2369320989,
0.3850337863,
-0.9311541915,
-0.4087423682,
-0.3037768602,
-0.5207235217,
-0.3343777061,
0.8882459402,
-0.5323355198,
0.5446295142,
0.1059926897,
0.5372114182,
0.1672451049,
0.0015018689,
1.0063376427,
-0.671203196,
0.1140991151,
0.0269092023,
0.4780349135,
0.0444836542,
-0.8119513392,
0.7673772573,
0.1490923911,
-0.8227194548,
-0.9237524867,
0.1948650926,
-0.6703152061,
-0.217479676,
1.3306150436,
0.4763685167,
0.1429815441,
-0.1320132613,
-0.2532380223,
0.0874517113,
-0.4834536016,
0.6719740629,
0.814606607,
-0.1411914527,
0.0297357719,
-1.1579222679,
0.438739568,
0.6110960841,
-0.1805212349,
-0.0487072878,
0.1855568588,
0.5890653729,
-0.1517053992,
0.8705316782,
0.2393266857,
0.4662998617,
-0.3196471632,
0.3278457224,
-0.1273716092,
0.2339993417,
-0.2750437558,
-0.2735644579,
0.5241699815,
0.0733264461
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12230v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12230v1 | MCSD: An Efficient Language Model with Diverse Fusion | 2024-06-18T03:08:01 | 2024-06-18T03:08:01 | Hua Yang, Duohai Li, Shiman Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Transformers excel in Natural Language Processing (NLP) due to their prowess
in capturing long-term dependencies but suffer from exponential resource
consumption with increasing sequence lengths. To address these challenges, we
propose MCSD model, an efficient language model with linear scaling and fast
inference speed. MCSD model leverages diverse feature fusion, primarily through
the multi-channel slope and decay (MCSD) block, to robustly represent features.
This block comprises slope and decay sections that extract features across
diverse temporal receptive fields, facilitating capture of both local and
global information. In addition, MCSD block conducts element-wise fusion of
diverse features to further enhance the delicate feature extraction capability.
For inference, we formulate the inference process into a recurrent
representation, slashing space complexity to $O(1)$ and time complexity to
$O(N)$ respectively. Our experiments show that MCSD attains higher throughput
and lower GPU memory consumption compared to Transformers, while maintaining
comparable performance to larger-scale language learning models on benchmark
tests. These attributes position MCSD as a promising base for edge deployment
and embodied intelligence. | [
-0.6943216324,
-0.8420631886,
0.3602204025,
0.2349560857,
-0.0540595464,
0.3976571858,
-0.1615677774,
-0.3270709217,
0.2098591924,
0.5672050714,
-0.6444586515,
-0.4536091089,
-0.6010228992,
-0.1374083757,
-0.4149491191,
0.8370666504,
0.3902262151,
-0.1181195974,
-0.0211210009,
-0.2500385642,
-0.157924369,
-0.1421384364,
-0.6377281547,
-0.3434071541,
0.2907138467,
0.1452111006,
1.0429981947,
0.9323854446,
0.3936112225,
0.3587714434,
-0.1100165099,
0.0609117635,
-0.4260027409,
0.169205904,
-0.3545506597,
-0.1735457778,
-0.5320512056,
-0.1655887067,
0.6284148097,
0.9740458727,
-0.2070115954,
0.1211299598,
-0.1494615674,
0.3812533319,
-0.6706359386,
-0.1184258685,
-0.811927855,
-0.1857595146,
-0.0906372666,
0.3181152642,
-0.5002629161,
-0.0630657673,
0.1090318561,
-0.3029366732,
0.3940666616,
-0.2670039237,
0.6258594394,
0.368753165,
-0.3585935831,
-0.2806625664,
-0.7788058519,
1.0273424387,
-0.5911232829,
0.8636612296,
0.1932065934,
0.5378531218,
-0.1140959114,
-0.9758611321,
-0.6324737072,
-0.1107987911,
0.2192165107,
-0.0626600981,
-0.0398328416,
0.175920859,
0.1713730991,
0.3464396596,
-0.3741599321,
0.3079919517,
-0.115861319,
-0.3554124832,
0.5362330079,
0.2571669519,
0.5098828673,
-0.5053569078,
-0.3709399402,
-0.2072492689,
-0.3490474224,
0.067640014,
0.2509988844,
0.6146444082,
-0.2280100435,
0.5562705398,
-0.048543226,
0.7596590519,
-0.3091650009,
-0.4509204924,
0.2150224596,
-0.4010121524,
-0.0666746125,
-0.1315289438,
0.6653651595,
0.0451913476,
-0.1022480503,
-0.1462899894,
-0.1394160688,
0.4011922181,
0.3144079149,
-0.7424939871,
-0.2249514908,
0.2993042767,
-0.4858787656,
0.1419958919,
-0.1536082476,
-1.1683585644,
-0.4194819331,
-0.1856371611,
0.0209592208,
-0.6113325953,
-0.5156980157,
0.0085805757,
-0.2937209308,
0.0259019695,
0.1044378057,
-0.9869977236,
0.5491294265,
0.7549420595,
1.0097110271,
-0.3839032352,
-0.2697764933,
-0.5344253778,
0.0373645015,
0.0960806161,
0.6952386498,
-0.8563444614,
-0.5505781174,
-0.3034979701,
-0.3739920259,
0.0616599284,
-0.343685627,
0.4917449057,
-0.2162602544,
-0.2511855662,
0.0690064952,
-0.2540730536,
-0.0357109345,
-0.1004818827,
-0.8719141483,
1.1610865593,
0.2041296959,
-0.6545830965,
0.1636765897,
-0.6090479493,
-0.41708529,
0.1571794897,
-0.2014182657,
-0.2417007983,
0.1234780774,
0.381131798,
0.5443570614,
-0.3510406017,
0.3269050419,
-0.5811294317,
-0.1543120146,
-0.0107199969,
-0.5832805634,
0.6346509457,
0.3262297809,
-0.2287839651,
-0.0483407304,
-1.0727739334,
-0.0889329836,
0.0379867069,
-0.2435514927,
-0.3359230757,
0.1964543164,
-0.038666252,
0.3421275914,
-0.0578055009,
-0.7316223979,
0.0600565486,
-0.109390147,
0.4584137499,
0.5751547813,
-0.1409211308,
0.708093226,
-0.0438139364,
0.4654535353,
0.0156355631,
0.0137634296,
-0.5311214924,
-0.5991068482,
-0.5346153378,
-0.9165185094,
0.1782965958,
0.3315984309,
-0.9176974893,
0.2879291773,
-0.5244888663,
-0.6806705594,
-0.9701142907,
0.1928682029,
0.3014322817,
0.551841557,
0.601552248,
-0.0202199928,
-0.4604658484,
-1.0212129354,
-0.105968155,
0.1148119047,
-0.2847682536,
0.1601643264,
0.2596865594,
-0.537432611,
1.1469714642,
-0.5632505417,
0.0155533683,
-0.6244407892,
0.2520337999,
0.0475637577,
0.3405945301,
0.3588179946,
-0.8587489128,
-0.1766272336,
-0.0640227273,
-0.3983709812,
-0.1576166302,
-0.2405590415,
-0.0879679099,
0.0624905452,
0.4335104823,
-0.683382988,
0.2562987208,
0.8312449455,
-0.1351572424,
0.2029082626,
-0.0825800225,
-0.1577105522,
-1.0620658398,
0.087766923,
0.0428316668,
-0.2108553648,
-0.7419647574,
0.0486769788,
0.144878611,
-0.3889524639,
-0.5309448838,
0.5878466368,
-0.4380614161,
-0.2594694197,
-0.1885674745,
0.52308321,
-0.1196570694,
0.5722434521,
0.0162566882,
0.5431147814,
0.4155235589,
-0.9219615459,
0.1675711423,
0.0314244851,
-0.0565806441,
0.6110526323,
-0.4264569879,
-0.1281479597,
-0.2328027934,
0.2534272075,
-0.9433582425,
0.0332053937,
-0.2615291476,
-0.236878261,
0.3093990088,
-0.0037282666,
-0.3529073894,
-0.474327147,
-0.2420524806,
0.3421779871,
0.599298656,
-0.6403462291,
1.1746203899,
0.5907609463,
-0.1881206483,
-0.6000913978,
-0.6406263113,
-0.0613742545,
0.1221535876,
-0.631911099,
0.5294821262,
0.1215899959,
-0.0808608606,
0.0185494535,
-0.0009860767,
0.181693837,
0.1838525832,
0.3798404932,
0.0696025193,
-0.1577455699,
0.2542058825,
0.2699526548,
-0.3868231773,
-0.3470006287,
-0.0028615633,
1.0851353407,
-0.1433442533,
-0.590005517,
-0.2896132171,
0.5371293426,
0.8100143075,
-0.402269572,
0.7088350654,
0.7533057928,
-0.43258214,
-0.5075085163,
-0.5728123784,
-0.0185368787,
-0.4755139053,
0.7140650153,
-0.560321033,
-0.6144961119,
0.7443677187,
-0.3760692179,
0.1017403454,
0.7219408751,
0.3977010846,
0.125415653,
1.2804254293,
0.7190858722,
0.0644517541,
0.3731794953,
-0.428022176,
0.3055182099,
-1.0632278919,
-0.2577885389,
-0.618721962,
-0.2960851789,
-0.571316123,
-0.4037578702,
-0.0071357149,
0.0589037091,
-0.186118573,
0.3324535191,
-0.3240512908,
0.2344237268,
0.2876653075,
0.0612888001,
0.2098100334,
-0.145592317,
-0.3072001934,
-0.246883586,
-0.6154022217,
-0.4246160686,
0.8173322082,
0.6078185439,
0.8671498895,
0.1391662359,
0.490945369,
0.1774484068,
0.1844833344,
-0.5526992679,
0.7277069092,
-0.4900007546,
-0.2009067535,
-0.219485566,
-0.4687320888,
-0.6592345834,
0.3183411062,
-0.3496640623,
-0.7119541168,
-0.1138389111,
-0.0544719249,
-0.0774172768,
0.6501913071,
-0.6907026768,
0.6389756799,
-0.1857442707,
-0.0770306811,
-0.3965896368,
-0.6578461528,
0.4367287755,
0.0449365526,
0.2354983538,
-0.2307514101,
-0.1447755545,
0.5027300715,
-0.2509429455,
0.7083711624,
-0.0817916617,
0.138618052,
0.084393166,
0.170968011,
0.2159829885,
0.0286854524,
-0.1476408392,
0.2604599297,
-0.4879198968,
-0.4199124575,
-0.7836164236,
0.825571239,
-0.6273603439,
-0.3024255335,
-0.0720852092,
-0.7156009674,
-0.1418176591,
0.2005552053,
0.1672642082,
0.6598895788,
-0.1419795752,
0.1277309209,
0.6575730443,
-0.3609423637,
0.8774869442,
0.0571652912,
-0.5486320257,
-0.5084012747,
0.9918925166,
0.1478653401,
0.8252376318,
0.1942884028,
-0.1015231386,
-0.3651179075,
-0.4457269013,
-0.6008656025,
0.3765819669,
-0.7944805026,
-0.1833702922,
-1.2480865717,
-0.4176341891,
-0.250910759,
-0.321331799,
-0.8507024646,
-0.4620055556,
-0.1132720113,
-0.0933059379,
0.1745362729,
0.6536226869,
0.1327824146,
0.418515563,
-0.766962409,
0.8607954979,
0.2649548352,
0.5888695121,
0.200168103,
-0.1656904817,
0.0385602824,
0.2230665982,
-0.2683428228,
-0.706443727,
0.2915958464,
0.2784813344,
0.9180989265,
0.3073482215,
-0.0706897527,
0.7733249664,
-0.3457774222,
0.9959203005,
0.2435532212,
-1.1451538801,
0.3084565997,
-0.0190319493,
0.6446294785,
0.3926901817,
0.4291742444,
-0.6247555017,
-0.7128738761,
-0.7175664902,
-0.8511344194,
0.4723918736,
0.0071102935,
0.2189801335,
-0.183562398,
0.0000924243,
0.263576299,
0.0409431756,
-0.4870066345,
-0.2630189955,
-0.3443242908,
-0.4552518129,
-0.1227779016,
-0.1714887917,
0.3004082739,
-0.1502232254,
0.4854447842,
-0.2594942749,
0.1919359267,
-0.0407800376,
-0.4098485112,
0.3808000088,
0.1551978141,
0.6442602873,
0.4644178152,
-0.0726107433,
0.4845544696,
0.3196804821,
-0.7403862476,
0.037917655,
-0.0322540812,
0.0785513148,
0.1201612055,
0.3540067375,
0.7455649376,
0.4443508387,
-0.6193093061,
0.1804871112,
-0.1379189044,
0.3017399311,
0.2279458493,
0.0809972733,
0.4050340354,
0.1533481628,
0.4793030322,
0.287742883,
-0.029256681,
-0.4521614015,
0.4722596705,
0.4925071001,
-0.4305574298,
-0.083300516,
0.5470266342,
0.2693530917,
-0.4592145383,
0.8752478957,
-0.1435069144,
-0.4939213097,
0.4746238589,
0.709185183,
0.7325541973,
-0.4718565047,
0.4767847359,
0.1938190907,
0.1527907401,
-0.0004756451,
0.1436517686,
-0.0605830513,
-0.5769507885,
-0.447894752,
-0.9115813375,
-0.2332962155,
-0.2771163881,
-0.4818850458,
0.3138917983,
-0.6203237772,
-0.3075474799,
0.0665274262,
-0.3045395315,
-0.5639893413,
0.0846628249,
0.2383003831,
1.0800045729,
-0.8622536063,
0.7506119013,
0.188017875,
-0.286580503,
-0.4493144751,
-0.3541599512,
0.0308222175,
-0.5723142624,
0.5942844152,
0.3274641931,
-0.4384059012,
0.1797787845,
-0.3387108147,
-0.9582283497,
1.1041656733,
0.5588870645,
-0.2328723669,
0.1625323296,
0.1570170224,
0.4861309826,
-0.6435126066,
0.4605844915,
0.6760356426,
0.1803730279,
0.3689385056,
-0.7734076381,
-0.0161795244,
-0.1714919955,
0.3895336986,
0.6025881767,
-0.2699486911,
1.1281709671,
-0.2510538101,
-0.5038689971,
-0.1686475724,
0.8820980191,
0.2539836764,
-0.0501850434,
0.4128524065,
0.7523198724,
0.8347455859,
-0.1536802799,
1.0478249788,
-0.0615687408,
0.2465324253,
0.9050158262,
-0.1744731069,
0.9935364723,
0.2725447416,
-0.0397235788,
0.7543349266,
0.2403206229,
0.2088142186,
0.5595989227,
0.0914806426,
-0.210186556,
-0.2178481221,
-0.2619452477,
-0.2167321444,
0.5001562834,
0.5864607692,
-0.2197922468,
-0.4661900997,
0.2556137443,
0.1229601502,
0.1787332296,
-0.4168052077,
0.5738713741,
0.0747073665,
-0.5763167739,
0.2843664587,
0.0650358051,
0.7841745615,
-0.8056489229,
-0.141373381,
-0.1401140243,
0.3669441044,
-0.1528433114,
-0.7573230863,
0.3574133813,
-0.2256132215,
-0.2037124485,
-0.2308036387,
0.5519114137,
-0.4555000961,
-0.5589607954,
0.5250912905,
0.2050989419,
-0.2038655579,
0.1422904432,
-0.5780333281,
0.2728296518,
-0.156232208,
0.0426840261,
0.2612789571,
0.0294506494,
-0.001952566,
1.2181731462,
0.7270357609,
0.0986283422,
0.3853309751,
0.0271805767,
0.8059500456,
-0.7051121593,
-0.5853666067,
-0.9096018672,
0.9267276525,
-0.339653939,
-0.2353729755,
0.4870680571,
0.3608129025,
0.5583791137,
0.1666393131,
0.6188386083,
0.0407021232,
0.4771846533,
-0.6142451167,
0.5935993195,
-0.2269538045,
0.250883013,
-0.334998697,
-1.0737022161,
-0.3421780765,
0.2939758599,
0.08504498,
0.1396262199,
0.6898264289,
0.6078265905,
-0.3622354567,
0.2551409006,
0.2059195042,
0.0376263782,
0.6910873652,
0.4221063852,
0.3438429534,
-0.2275765538,
0.4587699175,
-0.3070332706,
-0.2677205205,
-0.0557429306,
-0.9530658722,
-0.7532988191,
-0.7379378676,
-0.147884652,
-0.2416646183,
-0.4171651006,
0.8853510022,
0.6552725434,
-0.6584047079,
-0.127899304,
0.0172001347,
0.3379768133,
-0.2684143186,
-0.2088271827,
0.3515713513,
-0.3758862913,
-0.664458096,
0.3189011812,
0.5710883141,
0.0880276039,
-0.7172112465,
-0.1840422302,
-0.4465112686,
0.0361228883,
0.6261240244,
0.223707661,
-0.809252739,
-0.240693897,
0.124825649,
-0.3765712082,
-0.0627723485,
0.7638929486,
-0.9698076248,
0.6281552911,
0.4702387452,
0.9742039442,
0.5673184395,
-0.0408395156,
0.7622492313,
-0.5882522464,
0.235703975,
0.187583372,
0.3311956823,
0.5472098589,
-0.0744970217,
0.3154288828,
0.1308757067,
-0.1829690039,
-0.8472394943,
0.579767406,
-1.0403487682,
-0.3210718632,
0.945189774,
0.0839737803,
-0.2319579571,
-0.2236403972,
-0.102092348,
0.2284980863,
-0.2331049293,
0.3969935477,
0.4511906505,
-0.003694921,
-0.3573885858,
-0.4138543606,
0.4696782529,
0.1733978242,
-0.6166792512,
-0.0401039347,
0.1885310113,
-0.0435662232,
0.6159807444,
0.3329120874,
-0.0431646705,
0.0252523776,
0.3967919946,
0.1636534631,
-0.0858035982,
-0.4691987634,
-0.3127349615,
0.3991397321,
-0.3620543778,
-0.0483075827
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12223v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12223v1 | ToxiCloakCN: Evaluating Robustness of Offensive Language Detection in Chinese with Cloaking Perturbations | 2024-06-18T02:44:56 | 2024-06-18T02:44:56 | Yunze Xiao, Yujia Hu, Kenny Tsu Wei Choo, Roy Ka-wei Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY | Detecting hate speech and offensive language is essential for maintaining a
safe and respectful digital environment. This study examines the limitations of
state-of-the-art large language models (LLMs) in identifying offensive content
within systematically perturbed data, with a focus on Chinese, a language
particularly susceptible to such perturbations. We introduce
\textsf{ToxiCloakCN}, an enhanced dataset derived from ToxiCN, augmented with
homophonic substitutions and emoji transformations, to test the robustness of
LLMs against these cloaking perturbations. Our findings reveal that existing
models significantly underperform in detecting offensive content when these
perturbations are applied. We provide an in-depth analysis of how different
types of offensive content are affected by these perturbations and explore the
alignment between human and model explanations of offensiveness. Our work
highlights the urgent need for more advanced techniques in offensive language
detection to combat the evolving tactics used to evade detection mechanisms. | [
-0.0347197689,
-1.0496404171,
0.0063267383,
0.2144743502,
-0.4546781182,
0.1055227071,
-0.1308407485,
-0.6268938184,
-0.0659370497,
0.64903754,
-0.2665204406,
-0.6108970046,
-0.8400906324,
0.0922459289,
-0.5583461523,
0.8617831469,
0.1985972971,
0.0089963581,
0.5208500624,
-0.2314565927,
-0.0610196069,
-0.7143769264,
-0.7719764709,
-0.05119735,
0.7609624267,
0.2007974237,
0.8707951307,
0.4214617312,
0.5929815173,
0.2833778262,
-0.3894129395,
0.0041893763,
-0.700181663,
0.3941178024,
0.1653069407,
-0.2421472371,
-0.3388497531,
-0.2565205991,
0.4910791814,
-0.0388025045,
-0.0158168674,
-0.1310486048,
-0.0580605268,
0.2528506219,
-0.9277134538,
-0.0625605434,
-0.8130114675,
0.2575776875,
-0.5517299771,
0.3009762764,
-0.5565832853,
0.0242432822,
-0.1000772193,
-0.4065976739,
-0.368730098,
-0.3020627201,
0.5826681852,
0.0322516076,
-0.3902681768,
-0.4481717944,
-0.5818657279,
0.7697945833,
-1.1226540804,
0.3662921488,
0.4027507603,
0.1044801995,
-0.1272051483,
-0.6054195166,
-0.7060912251,
-0.5891094208,
0.0818672851,
0.369238615,
-0.3875226676,
0.0353198946,
0.2231983393,
0.3155495822,
-0.4450432658,
0.5311704278,
0.1355232894,
-0.488532722,
0.822435081,
0.3257331848,
0.868314743,
-0.1999078095,
-0.2501084208,
-0.1519080549,
-0.6297900081,
-0.0994977802,
0.8707016706,
0.4368844628,
-0.1663146168,
0.3804542422,
0.1012903601,
0.4393841922,
-0.1308834404,
0.0203953739,
-0.0091512548,
-0.2154702842,
0.0279231369,
0.0351925492,
0.9566456079,
0.2992351949,
0.217257008,
0.0478158481,
-0.3981620371,
0.1012672111,
0.1703474224,
-0.6648057103,
-0.4175648689,
0.1335116029,
-0.271295011,
-0.6735583544,
-0.0265210234,
-0.7865152955,
-0.9445062876,
0.2771130502,
0.0685693473,
-0.333437413,
-0.4895118177,
-0.1541338116,
-0.11808718,
0.2280763835,
0.1902200133,
-0.7704157233,
0.0896153003,
0.6522798538,
0.7169095278,
-0.3713827729,
-0.2060168535,
-0.3450376689,
0.0278266799,
-0.438560158,
0.4323013425,
-0.7423235774,
-0.2059509456,
0.386533469,
0.0461088158,
0.3728505075,
-0.7440372109,
0.7545350194,
-0.6065970063,
-0.0521518588,
-0.1765271872,
-0.1560946405,
-0.0484739318,
0.3179771006,
-0.7224996686,
0.8435587883,
0.1706207544,
-1.200245142,
0.0978360325,
-0.5250546336,
-0.6246285439,
0.1873968989,
0.2291903794,
-0.6337584853,
-0.0506250747,
-0.073434189,
0.25001809,
0.0953131244,
-0.1101956218,
-0.5733600259,
-0.3897995353,
0.4141125977,
-0.4282459319,
1.0783526897,
0.5310189128,
-0.4920052886,
0.3857110441,
-0.4635148644,
-0.4872822762,
0.5342595577,
-0.4651219547,
-0.654188931,
0.1676672697,
0.4806267619,
0.1135138795,
0.1742743403,
-0.7285217643,
-0.2980403304,
-0.5420700312,
0.431629926,
0.9249085784,
-0.3522821069,
0.0425470211,
-0.2285947055,
0.5203966498,
0.2157171071,
0.344861567,
-0.1271773428,
-0.4852996767,
-0.2716201246,
0.0137230055,
-0.1486309916,
0.7411206961,
-0.8227784038,
0.2672850192,
0.0973647982,
-0.3969368339,
-0.1077650562,
0.0087484969,
0.3983891308,
0.2365598381,
0.0391626693,
-0.1884041131,
-0.6492165327,
-0.704076767,
-0.6167672873,
-0.3871575892,
-0.2140325159,
0.4139255881,
0.2059907168,
-0.3507065177,
0.2567578852,
0.0037314871,
-0.095753774,
-0.2105588168,
0.0399828851,
-0.0539356209,
0.1819516867,
0.5293812752,
-1.046764493,
-0.9736744761,
0.1670103371,
-0.5792074203,
-0.538521409,
0.1140214652,
0.1619957387,
0.2047856003,
0.4840222001,
0.0140680736,
0.3442099988,
0.9762992859,
-0.3091060817,
0.7801730037,
0.3703229129,
0.2366823703,
-0.6918153167,
-0.0830866098,
-0.0700964928,
-0.2150795758,
-1.1098035574,
0.6244770885,
-0.0323679782,
-0.0146067571,
-0.8185306191,
0.4491658807,
-0.0862449855,
0.443102628,
-0.3845925331,
0.3031541407,
-0.4188359082,
0.1638161987,
-0.0976569057,
0.5006672144,
0.3131990433,
-0.3454961181,
0.6785811186,
0.1430025548,
-0.210071221,
0.1458678246,
-0.4087780416,
0.327654779,
0.0035866052,
0.1327271014,
-1.2237126827,
-0.3428948224,
0.7040482163,
-0.326962769,
0.2309655845,
-0.1901063025,
-0.5993890166,
-0.3572964668,
-0.5779109001,
0.7812765837,
0.3471026421,
-0.6891217828,
0.4850986898,
0.6551672816,
0.1213603467,
-0.7257767916,
-0.8631978631,
0.267119348,
-0.5441075563,
-0.5834933519,
-0.0497537479,
-0.1614819318,
-0.2785978615,
-0.5712533593,
0.0343345776,
-0.1508581936,
0.3611161411,
0.0899469182,
0.2216670215,
-0.3063471615,
-0.2900097668,
-0.1713995785,
0.4504164159,
0.3613444865,
-0.0485304967,
0.5150383115,
-0.0070430562,
-0.1265979558,
-0.3791655898,
0.0079009142,
0.7637056708,
0.096217595,
0.6287969351,
0.6259784698,
-0.361428678,
-0.0103303557,
-0.4433470368,
-0.0701528043,
-0.5701862574,
0.723654449,
0.1084472016,
-0.8745170236,
0.8343808055,
0.2303305417,
-0.0023121047,
0.379095614,
0.6067224741,
0.1721086353,
1.0978964567,
0.2017616183,
-0.3298602104,
0.7659783959,
0.345051527,
0.2734884918,
-0.764752388,
-0.0968012959,
-0.360338062,
0.0068823765,
-0.925888896,
-0.0577460863,
0.1478618085,
-0.430531919,
-0.5309907198,
0.4046620429,
-0.3770919442,
0.4786215425,
-0.2343741208,
0.4080329537,
0.1037232354,
0.1008651257,
-0.0772475377,
-0.1418080181,
-0.5458363295,
-0.3170295358,
0.8962897658,
0.7250909805,
0.7412665486,
0.3397538066,
0.152219072,
0.3994995952,
0.5163290501,
-0.8034332991,
0.4072670341,
-0.8304265141,
-0.9322434068,
-0.4031087756,
-0.4407888949,
-0.7870816588,
0.2011061162,
-0.250539422,
-0.9745937586,
-0.0525578335,
0.2142800093,
-0.07467518,
0.8731896281,
-0.3926661611,
0.6495623589,
-0.3661523461,
-0.5818746686,
0.1249984875,
-0.3443176746,
0.6985169649,
-0.3191432357,
0.3970244229,
-0.0304200612,
-0.1986721754,
0.6756082177,
0.0703611225,
1.0489127636,
-0.0228058491,
-0.7191616297,
0.256619662,
0.5170396566,
0.5379347205,
-0.2348777205,
-0.3199504018,
0.5589246154,
-0.1552745402,
-0.4509943426,
-0.3346641362,
0.5521209836,
-0.2972240746,
-0.7165020704,
-0.2399238646,
-0.6215748191,
0.0905397385,
0.3457570672,
0.5020213127,
-0.0074112406,
-0.2580978274,
0.015458703,
0.5421401262,
-0.7857192159,
0.1414197534,
0.4891230166,
-0.4752499163,
-0.122066088,
0.8896849751,
-0.0260824151,
0.3605462909,
0.2400771528,
0.5854415894,
-0.0937930718,
-0.6890692115,
-0.1639958322,
0.0332306139,
-0.7346181273,
0.0399189256,
-0.4109425247,
-0.4197459221,
-0.4892293513,
0.137659654,
-0.411564976,
0.0487730168,
-0.1445728838,
0.287568599,
-0.0993649587,
1.0202592611,
-0.0434546284,
0.4290644228,
-0.6254982948,
0.1568248719,
0.1340719014,
0.3889936805,
0.1736814231,
-1.0762997866,
-0.2139313966,
0.2557152808,
-0.3455348611,
-1.0938981771,
0.3615411222,
-0.1228850409,
0.4213371873,
0.9395619631,
0.325045377,
0.2445980012,
-0.2842838764,
0.966113925,
0.1353689581,
-0.8830491304,
0.5001425147,
-0.6806503534,
0.3191145957,
0.0082896892,
0.5632240176,
-0.7287576795,
-0.8270148039,
-0.3357034326,
-0.7267677188,
0.5966204405,
0.2367698401,
0.7114075422,
-0.0870478973,
0.321892947,
-0.0242353212,
-0.1444412321,
-1.0730093718,
-0.472684443,
-0.4073265493,
0.0692085549,
0.0447850227,
-0.627135396,
-0.05433321,
-0.1038513854,
0.3769666255,
0.1543582827,
0.0911700726,
0.0045763021,
-0.0780037269,
-0.2195042521,
0.0436802134,
0.743891418,
0.309263289,
-0.0047510406,
0.1778986007,
0.452404201,
-0.8451254964,
-0.0328083634,
-0.434542805,
-0.1120899916,
-0.1599066556,
0.5512313247,
0.5681684613,
0.0216697156,
-0.8276720047,
0.6755859256,
-0.0575373061,
0.0877004713,
-0.2854851782,
0.0601038896,
-0.2480805218,
0.0035469607,
0.0708311349,
-0.2416053861,
0.2716184556,
-0.6041274667,
0.1892133206,
0.4894371033,
-0.4935628474,
-0.5046349764,
0.6352782845,
-0.0604897477,
-0.4811738133,
0.563551724,
0.1055255607,
-1.1112964153,
0.5404653549,
0.7780528665,
0.7608698606,
-0.6807284951,
0.1727514416,
0.4964778125,
0.4633725584,
0.3390407264,
-0.0557698309,
0.1003052518,
-0.9979602098,
-0.1067195162,
-0.3214116991,
-0.2623561919,
0.6255843043,
-0.3292627931,
0.2262200564,
-0.9197583199,
-0.1605671793,
-0.1020629331,
-0.4216305912,
-0.0211051572,
-0.0095409108,
0.718287468,
0.7884741426,
-0.9298321605,
0.4790509343,
0.4712255299,
-0.1082490161,
-0.6238649487,
0.3257859647,
0.3526952267,
-0.8128046393,
0.5648493767,
-0.1251929551,
-0.1100623384,
-0.4819555581,
-0.9558137655,
-0.362983793,
0.3619980812,
0.4509589076,
-0.3888971508,
0.2361139357,
0.2442777604,
0.7592760921,
-0.139271155,
0.2615094483,
0.628700912,
0.5658019185,
0.0213051401,
-0.684145391,
0.2510276735,
-0.2516080737,
-0.1186841577,
0.0136604477,
-0.7683941722,
0.9459581375,
0.1170263663,
-0.5423176289,
0.1090527996,
0.3127381802,
0.0470417626,
0.3666737378,
0.5734548569,
0.2409171909,
0.4229633808,
0.0220161937,
1.0571650267,
0.0832529142,
0.1483391672,
0.9003648758,
-0.1634650975,
0.8346446157,
0.1781215966,
-0.1775531769,
0.6892986298,
0.5741470456,
-0.1336711943,
0.1629292667,
0.5072849989,
-0.4374460578,
-0.1646137238,
-0.2446290702,
-0.224541977,
0.73871243,
0.4304718077,
-0.197037667,
-0.0409836583,
0.0792081729,
0.170621559,
0.2755280733,
-0.2654672265,
0.8318380713,
-0.0246463064,
-0.1773555577,
0.7407491803,
-0.0047401125,
1.0629805326,
-0.5015922189,
0.1437600106,
-0.2732061744,
-0.0252367761,
-0.3946774304,
-0.811488986,
0.3238929808,
0.0406759791,
0.4005981088,
0.1925658137,
0.8035565615,
-0.3211490512,
-0.1625167131,
0.7978782058,
-0.2781551778,
0.2253351212,
-0.070309706,
-0.7544231415,
0.3321063221,
-0.0025368768,
-0.076276727,
0.3318585753,
0.3431212306,
0.0197081827,
0.6902893782,
0.6466231942,
0.2806215584,
0.2313873321,
0.1510578841,
0.8383461237,
-0.2884117663,
-0.4606564343,
-1.0007688999,
0.3387923241,
0.0466213264,
-0.0139962295,
0.9260041118,
0.3963471949,
0.986240685,
-0.0373642929,
0.6825524569,
0.1278626919,
0.13205567,
-0.4095959961,
1.1835672855,
-0.5990434289,
0.483625263,
-0.6271893382,
-0.7127038836,
-0.695037961,
0.3964003921,
-0.2412123978,
-0.0119969202,
0.3436934948,
0.8970319033,
-0.0318886638,
0.0279645734,
0.7580451965,
0.6893748045,
0.4528361261,
0.4356572032,
1.2466412783,
-0.6239824295,
0.6097737551,
-0.3711960614,
-0.2054460049,
-0.0750853196,
-0.8661226034,
-0.9688848853,
-0.5173293948,
-0.1946740448,
-0.6091604233,
0.3558299243,
0.4650489986,
0.4388735294,
-1.3140695095,
-0.3652455509,
0.1589720696,
0.335051626,
0.1876555979,
-0.233322382,
0.1103190035,
-0.0245648939,
-0.7558739781,
0.206177026,
0.1543966979,
0.0777517632,
-0.1671470106,
-0.2258872688,
-0.2438974082,
0.2186770439,
0.8234273195,
0.3620994985,
-0.9122593999,
-0.3773997724,
0.0023802731,
-0.1488521397,
-0.0187734049,
0.8710787892,
-0.0687833056,
0.6500233412,
0.5198674202,
0.7288935781,
0.0431631617,
-0.0807427689,
0.294588536,
-0.5314267278,
0.347985059,
0.3018054366,
0.1652049124,
0.3366635144,
-0.7072502971,
0.1404650509,
0.1477741748,
-0.5294488668,
-0.9383558035,
0.3221459985,
-0.6953257322,
-0.4116832316,
1.3645079136,
-0.4182874262,
-0.1692385823,
-0.3900880516,
-0.3060924113,
0.3657953441,
-0.3431071639,
1.0583688021,
0.7973672152,
0.1977229416,
-0.2546019256,
-0.2378677428,
0.4923396111,
0.4934482574,
-0.4086303711,
0.4198689163,
0.2900156975,
0.1890042275,
0.1637729406,
0.1386408359,
-0.3036989868,
0.4783247411,
0.0181941874,
-0.3945063055,
0.0993678942,
-0.1023818478,
-0.4842633605,
-0.0166239496,
-0.0114080226,
0.0375408269
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12221v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12221v1 | On-Policy Fine-grained Knowledge Feedback for Hallucination Mitigation | 2024-06-18T02:43:49 | 2024-06-18T02:43:49 | Xueru Wen, Xinyu Lu, Xinyan Guan, Yaojie Lu, Hongyu Lin, Ben He, Xianpei Han, Le Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL | Hallucination occurs when large language models (LLMs) exhibit behavior that
deviates from the boundaries of their knowledge during the response generation
process. Previous learning-based methods focus on detecting knowledge
boundaries and finetuning models with instance-level feedback, but they suffer
from inaccurate signals due to off-policy data sampling and coarse-grained
feedback. In this paper, we introduce \textit{\b{R}einforcement \b{L}earning
\b{f}or \b{H}allucination} (RLFH), a fine-grained feedback-based online
reinforcement learning method for hallucination mitigation. Unlike previous
learning-based methods, RLFH enables LLMs to explore the boundaries of their
internal knowledge and provide on-policy, fine-grained feedback on these
explorations. To construct fine-grained feedback for learning reliable
generation behavior, RLFH decomposes the outcomes of large models into atomic
facts, provides statement-level evaluation signals, and traces back the signals
to the tokens of the original responses. Finally, RLFH adopts the online
reinforcement algorithm with these token-level rewards to adjust model behavior
for hallucination mitigation. For effective on-policy optimization, RLFH also
introduces an LLM-based fact assessment framework to verify the truthfulness
and helpfulness of atomic facts without human intervention. Experiments on
HotpotQA, SQuADv2, and Biography benchmarks demonstrate that RLFH can balance
their usage of internal knowledge during the generation process to eliminate
the hallucination behavior of LLMs. | [
-0.5087830424,
-1.2320599556,
0.5677331686,
0.1637101769,
0.1557707638,
-0.1310216039,
-0.4498018622,
-0.4006104767,
0.1981409043,
0.6199948788,
-0.717703104,
-0.2838586271,
-0.1246350259,
-0.1907391697,
0.0663056672,
1.0706710815,
0.1123277321,
0.0307087973,
-0.35273844,
0.1275713444,
-0.3486360312,
-0.4474270046,
-0.5560855865,
-0.6618559361,
0.4568190277,
0.518758893,
0.4972030818,
0.4276115894,
0.3746319711,
0.2271630168,
-0.0750487223,
0.4548460245,
-0.7488433123,
0.1489359885,
-0.2207665443,
-0.2262659073,
-0.2856502831,
-0.3390957713,
0.4631732404,
0.4978136718,
-0.556887269,
-0.173669681,
0.163604036,
0.5884742141,
-0.7500974536,
0.2549914122,
-0.6508515477,
0.2410346419,
0.1790353209,
-0.5021457076,
-0.5040114522,
-0.6670694947,
-0.0372634269,
-0.4390103221,
0.1041010618,
0.0838240162,
0.8624815941,
0.4168455601,
0.0965034142,
-0.417031914,
-0.9239094853,
0.9003072977,
-0.6530381441,
0.5468940139,
0.7295719981,
0.3929533958,
-0.3489925563,
-0.4811492562,
-0.4934063554,
-0.4470478892,
-0.2097802013,
0.0110715218,
0.1166885123,
0.214826405,
0.2372045964,
0.3457580209,
-0.2166424692,
0.2245763987,
-0.2346832752,
-0.5605932474,
0.4512887299,
0.0648896694,
-0.1399907917,
-0.1477234066,
-0.4604977071,
-0.2158713043,
-0.7505825162,
0.0690528005,
0.269620508,
0.5032139421,
0.1126614213,
0.4019753635,
-0.4864618778,
0.4040466845,
0.1030838341,
-0.0528837182,
0.1475764662,
-0.0865058228,
-0.0416075625,
0.2948560715,
0.563629508,
0.2816364169,
0.1739100367,
-0.4259787202,
-0.6737957597,
-0.0030289609,
0.2594045997,
-1.0213791132,
-0.008992224,
0.1576741934,
-0.4447704256,
-0.2730305493,
0.1065551639,
-1.1382279396,
-0.5831018686,
-0.1788377166,
0.664675951,
-0.3477047384,
-0.2637693286,
-0.0189076737,
0.0060318233,
0.3595815897,
0.2548710406,
-1.0566035509,
0.457279563,
0.5750793815,
0.8450202346,
-0.1553867459,
-0.3848751783,
-0.9583851695,
0.0529586226,
-0.0062435344,
0.8840247393,
-0.3606372774,
-0.2518579066,
0.2443397343,
-0.0879763067,
0.1173561662,
-0.8233359456,
0.1972495914,
-0.3111139834,
-0.0750449151,
-0.298350364,
-0.5923284292,
-0.2292771488,
0.5152531266,
-0.4961165786,
0.838173151,
0.1065671146,
-0.5138861537,
0.2242513001,
-0.5874373317,
-0.4126346409,
-0.0661363602,
-0.3789406717,
-0.5450294614,
0.1490094662,
0.1776928306,
0.5630370975,
0.0079122987,
0.3616670966,
-0.4730797708,
-0.3768744469,
0.2585073709,
-0.450034678,
0.2102551013,
0.1479490399,
-0.6591069102,
0.4553284645,
-0.8126555681,
-0.0157435909,
0.0782810599,
-0.3564144969,
-0.1028971374,
0.1923287064,
-0.0507929549,
0.1617722064,
0.0630444214,
-0.5195118785,
0.066159375,
-0.4283725321,
0.2301904857,
0.7693517804,
0.3145253658,
0.220022887,
-0.6905668974,
0.3334985971,
-0.1560945809,
0.2560452521,
0.1632554829,
-0.2567037344,
-0.7619974613,
-0.0509160459,
0.0859909803,
0.4652162492,
-0.6462338567,
0.4547191262,
-0.0351364203,
-0.226268962,
-0.4165208936,
0.0276495833,
0.4850557148,
0.1758549809,
0.5831241608,
-0.1416774839,
-0.3278760612,
-0.5417014956,
-0.0640280619,
-0.0102514066,
0.1322501749,
0.3754719198,
0.4203115404,
-0.3791119158,
0.9379778504,
-0.5099955797,
-0.6350260377,
-0.2764193416,
0.369317174,
-0.2699009478,
0.3908319771,
0.0498480052,
-0.3808293045,
0.1061013043,
0.1871874779,
-0.5645082593,
-0.1398244649,
-0.3324580789,
0.0547256358,
0.5273965597,
0.5870836377,
-0.5183432102,
0.4011156261,
0.3067788482,
-0.2924081683,
0.574192524,
-0.2880745828,
0.046140179,
-0.4603439867,
-0.0639291108,
-0.2299080193,
-0.3359207809,
-0.4495378137,
0.1690162867,
-0.2901828587,
0.3891081512,
-0.5419106483,
0.6162228584,
-0.1203236207,
-0.3000790775,
-0.4383172095,
0.1807683557,
-0.3066189587,
0.8834155798,
0.1828770936,
0.52339077,
0.1963082105,
-0.9158594012,
0.2677857876,
0.1164684594,
-0.373829186,
0.4021580815,
-0.2724919021,
0.095739767,
-0.0429371186,
0.1440900117,
-0.5120999217,
-0.2179884911,
0.3456836939,
-0.3401708007,
0.1206058413,
0.3226190209,
-0.3141078353,
-0.0337002091,
-0.483414799,
0.1361172646,
0.3519273698,
-0.6564521194,
0.5676781535,
0.3608539999,
0.0577922165,
-0.3654558659,
-0.574952662,
-0.4829373956,
-0.086674735,
-0.2491884083,
0.2896146774,
-0.2014314085,
-0.3506012261,
0.0260577016,
-0.1210272312,
0.012278459,
0.194780916,
0.1409561336,
0.0383039601,
-0.0271032527,
0.1204180941,
0.0586742796,
0.0695044398,
0.2597425878,
-0.0151823871,
0.9073122144,
-0.1562632024,
-0.2755396664,
-0.3455917537,
0.0181524716,
0.4415036738,
0.0999858901,
0.6328810453,
0.8024678826,
-0.4705402851,
-0.5520784855,
-0.5026601553,
-0.8990448713,
-0.4324303567,
0.3587796092,
-0.3055977225,
-0.9467697144,
0.5283046365,
-0.2147682756,
0.1391669065,
0.3232457936,
0.6493771672,
0.2959729731,
0.8403693438,
0.2912183106,
0.0760545284,
0.3087700605,
-0.2931140959,
0.1576837003,
-0.6683145165,
-0.5308819413,
-0.3714473248,
-0.159880355,
-0.4946204126,
-0.3411485255,
0.1023986563,
0.2000048161,
-0.2297566533,
-0.1729016453,
-0.3538433909,
0.4221185148,
0.4914886057,
0.4840852916,
0.3626448512,
0.1003737524,
-0.1623418033,
0.1628006399,
-0.7353714705,
-0.0570237823,
0.8140845299,
0.5477308631,
1.0523462296,
-0.0025738399,
0.7910129428,
0.5601573586,
0.1295000166,
-1.1136213541,
0.5614004731,
0.2782646716,
-0.2394478172,
-0.5720418096,
-0.798786819,
-0.6487216949,
0.1485075355,
-0.3852818608,
-0.7748049498,
0.0871562213,
0.2183489799,
-0.6876679659,
0.3113392293,
-0.1931233108,
0.5915552378,
-0.2795803845,
-0.5312363505,
-0.6536866426,
-0.4077020288,
0.392416507,
0.0424484983,
0.3505728543,
0.1641072333,
0.5673026443,
0.6996473074,
-0.4482584596,
1.0165559053,
-0.5351079702,
-0.1817587018,
0.1769548953,
0.1179327592,
0.8870491385,
-0.0578644946,
0.2303618491,
0.0139862625,
-0.1448597163,
0.0430674069,
-0.5786794424,
0.7817079425,
-0.7136167288,
-0.5750414133,
-0.2985714972,
-0.7020994425,
-0.2908451259,
-0.0647781342,
0.1358882636,
0.3991912901,
-0.1712531447,
0.2730297744,
0.9721916914,
-0.3502652347,
0.3487228155,
0.3936544359,
-0.7999764681,
-0.5482847691,
1.3850574493,
-0.0413804688,
0.3709573448,
0.3138353527,
0.6114485264,
-0.4046562314,
-0.3325597644,
-0.3380440474,
0.2015314549,
-0.6776975393,
-0.3427997231,
-0.5976809859,
-0.5198792219,
-0.3737550676,
-0.0641960576,
-0.364266336,
-0.3290165067,
-0.1003336236,
-0.0762406588,
0.4198572636,
0.8407883048,
-0.3042335808,
0.2887794971,
-0.6413357258,
0.369671315,
0.428594172,
0.4214464128,
0.2406944633,
-0.4405097365,
-0.3461815119,
0.1451939195,
-0.5442922115,
-0.6132162213,
0.1716194451,
0.2488028854,
0.6326468587,
0.6928540468,
0.1807651818,
0.5507321358,
-0.1842546314,
0.499316901,
-0.067539908,
-0.8779330254,
0.4419215024,
-0.0908843204,
0.0569978915,
0.3713326752,
0.132497862,
-0.4128079116,
-0.6031264663,
-0.4430953264,
-0.8313887715,
0.8250007033,
0.0821535662,
-0.2249908,
0.1020347178,
0.2132040709,
0.2388344556,
0.2673751116,
-0.8673040867,
-0.0164770205,
-0.1913265884,
-0.0285021439,
0.3506435752,
-0.1784382612,
-0.1107725725,
-0.2305472791,
0.9418432117,
-0.2805820107,
0.2524112761,
0.1654895544,
-0.2592530251,
-0.2959122956,
0.3291037083,
0.830201149,
0.4202779531,
-0.4130583405,
0.0851406083,
0.2290860564,
-0.2654842138,
-0.0440024287,
-0.1381810457,
-0.3321831822,
-0.2235355973,
0.1022736058,
1.0373601913,
0.2687871158,
-0.6791840792,
0.3960405886,
0.1165973395,
-0.3480990529,
-0.207311973,
0.1683450192,
-0.3971999884,
0.4250796139,
0.1326497644,
-0.1896770597,
0.0593895167,
-0.7147556543,
0.5916119814,
0.5598263741,
-0.5600448847,
-0.0895040855,
0.3857730925,
0.1612352133,
-0.207835108,
0.5609224439,
-0.5169852972,
-0.6832326651,
0.4591425359,
0.7914786935,
0.8229242563,
-0.3361482024,
0.513884902,
0.3514594138,
0.3074689507,
-0.3668608367,
0.4534104168,
-0.1938757449,
-0.7373253703,
-0.2648798525,
-0.9134864807,
-0.4187306166,
0.391343087,
-0.7145469189,
0.13890405,
-0.7372953892,
-0.0164116882,
-0.5044214725,
-0.1315146983,
-0.3705343604,
0.0411885008,
0.0877422467,
0.4934611917,
-0.8264951706,
0.734069705,
0.3250001669,
-0.4917000532,
-0.6650575995,
0.4114478827,
-0.0343116783,
-0.7812799215,
0.4948857427,
0.3750988841,
-0.2788135409,
0.2338871211,
-0.2659848928,
-0.6247012019,
0.901761353,
0.080402337,
-0.5782935619,
0.1165877655,
0.1938379109,
0.2084420919,
-0.2372670919,
0.1687956303,
0.7302026153,
0.7498306036,
0.2037303597,
-0.6971386671,
0.2883272171,
0.3238000274,
-0.190025866,
0.3375355899,
-0.5619637966,
0.5699386001,
-0.3009235561,
-0.1196955442,
-0.0547766648,
0.7805832028,
0.4492705762,
0.3698706627,
0.6292176843,
0.7491208911,
0.800119698,
-0.0873437524,
0.7059395313,
-0.1542282701,
0.545814693,
0.9462126493,
-0.23425439,
0.9123803377,
0.6794300675,
-0.0140276756,
0.5941173434,
0.454308629,
-0.1308623552,
0.7972640395,
0.549603343,
-0.1820806265,
-0.2414008081,
-0.4638589621,
-0.1973870993,
0.3320331872,
0.4817071855,
0.150930658,
-0.3636002839,
0.3574831784,
0.0316610597,
0.0998860002,
-0.551517725,
0.9657837152,
-0.022065904,
-0.7663466334,
0.7135205269,
-0.1193215325,
0.7102603912,
-0.5850148201,
-0.3289013207,
-0.3978012204,
0.4167833924,
-0.4020736814,
-0.4279402494,
0.4764296412,
-0.1873301119,
-0.1181905121,
-0.0180823654,
0.6308985353,
-0.6346933246,
-0.1920072734,
0.4569637477,
0.326077193,
0.1854415387,
-0.1290246546,
-0.3474878371,
0.1419180185,
0.0460113287,
-0.2939449847,
0.3861482143,
0.2692089975,
-0.1491826326,
0.5901027918,
0.4741171002,
0.3903540969,
-0.0125706419,
0.3294046521,
0.7420533895,
-0.7074904442,
-0.4522687793,
-0.7889984846,
0.1292501241,
0.0507893935,
-0.0038084721,
0.5108905435,
0.4202486277,
1.019375205,
-0.0742196664,
0.6792601943,
-0.0554333553,
0.2160153389,
-0.9263620377,
0.8876604438,
-0.6488339305,
0.2806198299,
0.0702566206,
-0.999986887,
-0.2304268628,
0.8455269337,
0.0394182578,
0.0105892513,
0.8785198927,
1.1167972088,
0.046295695,
0.0614584051,
0.435634017,
0.4514712989,
0.064562954,
0.3390765786,
0.9725740552,
-0.0328471474,
0.4274701178,
-0.3631219268,
-0.2473620027,
-0.4767302275,
-0.5759741068,
-0.9226903915,
-0.4169376194,
-0.21104756,
-0.5326273441,
0.1115060672,
1.2653691769,
0.4041971266,
-0.9867988825,
-0.4057720304,
-0.3967508078,
0.2143090963,
-0.4898749888,
-0.348400861,
0.2930009365,
-0.7156632543,
-0.3410311937,
0.4440101385,
0.1203825548,
-0.1322772503,
-0.7364619374,
-0.5558117628,
-0.0944609493,
0.1707382053,
0.5727161169,
0.3452706039,
-0.8423050642,
-0.3671401441,
-0.1968086511,
-0.0459144413,
-0.0776247755,
0.8503107429,
-0.8824945688,
0.1274178177,
0.4530158341,
0.9293048382,
0.3199388087,
-0.140384391,
0.3459506035,
-0.7150329351,
0.0373830721,
0.1372689456,
0.1984177679,
0.2071397007,
-0.5030021071,
0.2740192711,
0.3426727057,
-0.7286368012,
-0.8468563557,
0.2313929051,
-0.6995370984,
-0.4751884639,
1.3616678715,
0.0145501867,
-0.3133081496,
-0.0271441564,
-0.0929567441,
0.3777728677,
-0.5530902147,
1.3798122406,
0.6062620878,
-0.1763222218,
-0.0945421532,
-0.4814571738,
0.8035840988,
0.4613073468,
-1.197685957,
0.2922314703,
0.6636217237,
-0.1713941097,
0.0543493368,
0.4116547108,
0.1775508523,
0.1557851881,
-0.1928072125,
0.296143502,
-0.1490734667,
-0.8454493284,
-0.2873491943,
0.1588708758,
0.1329068393,
-0.1627631634
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12216v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12216v1 | Is persona enough for personality? Using ChatGPT to reconstruct an agent's latent personality from simple descriptions | 2024-06-18T02:32:57 | 2024-06-18T02:32:57 | Yongyi Ji, Zhisheng Tang, Mayank Kejriwal | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Personality, a fundamental aspect of human cognition, contains a range of
traits that influence behaviors, thoughts, and emotions. This paper explores
the capabilities of large language models (LLMs) in reconstructing these
complex cognitive attributes based only on simple descriptions containing
socio-demographic and personality type information. Utilizing the HEXACO
personality framework, our study examines the consistency of LLMs in recovering
and predicting underlying (latent) personality dimensions from simple
descriptions. Our experiments reveal a significant degree of consistency in
personality reconstruction, although some inconsistencies and biases, such as a
tendency to default to positive traits in the absence of explicit information,
are also observed. Additionally, socio-demographic factors like age and number
of children were found to influence the reconstructed personality dimensions.
These findings have implications for building sophisticated agent-based
simulacra using LLMs and highlight the need for further research on robust
personality generation in LLMs. | [
-0.3051172495,
-0.5060904026,
0.9430369735,
0.4508258104,
0.0249318574,
0.2617184222,
-0.440988034,
-0.3029722869,
0.3362399042,
0.7058078647,
-0.5761110783,
-0.0382314958,
-0.3821118176,
-0.1416287869,
-0.1277515739,
1.1513082981,
0.4504074156,
-0.0523678511,
-0.2708400786,
0.1505102515,
-0.3307998478,
-0.7408794165,
-0.8524546623,
-0.5304635763,
0.7715536356,
0.5396242738,
0.6787530184,
0.4101332128,
0.1571537554,
0.2642371655,
0.0324951969,
0.0030614752,
-0.608923614,
0.1508423388,
-0.3591622412,
-0.3675332367,
-0.7869919538,
0.2415748686,
0.6694680452,
0.9198408723,
-0.1170388386,
-0.1017672643,
0.2496770322,
0.4736518264,
-0.423754245,
0.3440884352,
-0.6309813857,
-0.1582423449,
0.0112120491,
-0.1388879716,
-0.5121123791,
-0.2539385259,
0.2280324101,
-0.1693774611,
0.2184052318,
0.0889693052,
0.6672282219,
-0.03312416,
-0.7670071125,
-0.1837198287,
-1.3023912907,
0.7279596329,
-0.4383513927,
-0.0650551841,
0.609017849,
0.555357635,
-0.3440286219,
-0.3618349135,
-0.6411926746,
-0.3399939537,
-0.3019760251,
0.1037236825,
-0.0969957188,
-0.1956541389,
0.3742184639,
0.1838579178,
-0.3482471406,
0.1407667398,
-0.243989408,
-0.479660362,
0.7516476512,
0.5017306209,
0.2834741175,
-0.2181672305,
-0.1580210626,
-0.1522437036,
-0.7957648039,
0.1770087928,
0.6147273779,
0.2192385048,
-0.1805229932,
0.5757152438,
-0.109814845,
-0.0451969914,
0.2184127271,
-0.5650299191,
0.012483052,
-0.1113944426,
0.2176055312,
-0.1060793027,
0.6329844594,
0.1226033494,
0.6336275339,
-0.2155391127,
0.009089265,
0.0929731652,
0.5451087952,
-0.8380764723,
-0.2143600434,
0.4644289315,
-0.3734976947,
-0.1013744622,
-0.0357537419,
-0.8154361844,
-0.5958320498,
-0.231903404,
-0.1220012158,
-0.532574594,
-0.3074872792,
-0.1786025316,
0.1885197312,
0.6912373304,
0.5244035125,
-0.7922097445,
0.2295303941,
0.669893086,
0.4867938161,
-0.2464974225,
-0.3565968573,
-0.2971066236,
0.1039532125,
-0.2382298857,
0.7969586253,
-0.5311601162,
-0.3928977549,
-0.1076670587,
0.19345285,
0.0935412645,
-0.333630681,
0.4984816313,
-0.327424258,
-0.0137742907,
-0.6138902903,
-0.3763264418,
0.1698720902,
0.2708029747,
-0.5426552296,
0.4597694576,
0.2980799079,
-0.5018962026,
0.1252615452,
-0.0875148624,
-0.2521350682,
0.2265536338,
-0.3736441731,
-0.4524249136,
0.1302141249,
-0.1498814821,
0.6919572949,
-0.0797957852,
0.1842154562,
-0.4599305987,
-0.0673062056,
0.7797909975,
-0.257414937,
0.6243203878,
0.0882935375,
-0.0697401986,
0.0014243504,
-0.7571225166,
-0.0224915016,
0.2533125579,
-0.4511447251,
0.1488022357,
0.2871196866,
-0.0338194072,
0.2082214504,
0.5312136412,
-0.819868505,
0.3464001715,
-0.0239465795,
0.4541654885,
0.7755710483,
0.0104440441,
0.4867237806,
-0.571800828,
0.5123525858,
-0.0280736051,
-0.2719275653,
0.0042705648,
-0.2540481389,
-0.6502523422,
-0.6085904837,
-0.2098512352,
0.5356647372,
-0.6771700978,
0.588591516,
-0.4176452458,
-0.6580067873,
0.0295355879,
-0.0744673237,
0.3771467805,
0.1958048344,
-0.1766285151,
-0.3521998525,
-0.6382984519,
-1.1031467915,
-0.0328353941,
-0.3633801937,
-0.2727056742,
0.6115058661,
0.5087049603,
-0.4030684233,
0.917606473,
-0.4911398888,
-0.0177827403,
-0.5728790164,
-0.2870201766,
-0.1585452855,
0.2538014948,
0.8715688586,
-0.4522778094,
-0.4727036953,
-0.1240491271,
-0.6437644958,
-0.1186307669,
-0.106737867,
-0.0690618455,
-0.1413042396,
0.1086330712,
-0.7492951751,
0.456101954,
0.2663204074,
-0.497497201,
0.6995275617,
-0.3098924756,
-0.1276553273,
-0.9180471301,
0.0695911124,
-0.0437336229,
-0.4981102943,
-0.6525908709,
-0.0349625312,
-0.1241233572,
-0.121611312,
-0.1952619851,
0.7357478142,
-0.3754323423,
-0.3476630449,
-0.5383682847,
0.1394128948,
-0.0750096962,
0.6522505283,
0.1051761135,
0.6248438954,
0.5143216848,
-0.4656174779,
0.2395737767,
0.2906470895,
-0.0281063672,
1.0687966347,
-0.5814825296,
0.5546962619,
-0.5664461851,
0.5587174296,
-1.0144789219,
-0.7008154988,
-0.0339563563,
-0.3004966974,
0.1237249598,
-0.056499064,
-0.3963670433,
-0.1357751042,
-0.1901773512,
-0.066251196,
0.66579175,
-0.2135739028,
1.0789552927,
0.2646850348,
-0.5146122575,
-0.0256905761,
-0.3181702197,
0.0471275039,
-0.1997715533,
-0.4114085436,
0.1947757453,
-0.4449168444,
-0.3638049662,
-0.3883093596,
0.1482803226,
-0.19933635,
-0.0173198879,
0.4142542183,
0.4138434529,
0.0256228577,
-0.0555456653,
-0.290315479,
-0.0078046783,
-0.0661956072,
0.1126966625,
0.8804078102,
-0.3834195137,
-0.0512608588,
-0.1109795496,
0.2354578972,
0.6901039481,
-0.0789483413,
0.8640549183,
0.5376942158,
-0.2716593742,
-0.1168453917,
-0.4231384397,
-0.1999729425,
-0.3882469535,
0.2665398121,
-0.4755406678,
-0.9086896181,
0.9329141974,
0.0983353257,
-0.1569215357,
0.3005096316,
0.7305858731,
-0.3585576117,
0.7895130515,
0.6140829325,
0.0847883597,
0.3035156131,
0.1431461573,
0.0067597441,
-0.9690825343,
-0.3319423795,
-0.4698145986,
-0.2688201964,
-0.6628075242,
0.0059566949,
0.0798006281,
-0.4956219494,
-0.407859087,
0.2585971057,
-0.1280143708,
0.386425972,
0.1421076357,
0.2836317122,
0.0703634396,
-0.0197554994,
0.3007671535,
-0.2656720281,
-0.1902173907,
-0.9662876129,
1.1932351589,
0.4238796234,
0.7667201757,
0.4107496142,
0.5111677647,
0.1851273626,
0.3315945268,
-0.8414658308,
0.76983428,
-0.1782328188,
-0.6089399457,
-0.2620005906,
-0.4643287063,
-1.0876078606,
0.1293030679,
-0.4437300563,
-1.2423795462,
0.3030723333,
0.1718120724,
-0.543051362,
-0.1045147404,
-0.3962626457,
0.3126319051,
-0.2573241591,
-0.3960536718,
-0.0960139111,
-0.5611756444,
0.2738345861,
-0.3093910515,
-0.2181951702,
-0.3354952037,
0.0203194153,
0.3669329584,
-0.4768683314,
1.0378551483,
-0.0067804921,
-0.1912804842,
0.1697881669,
0.2648450434,
0.4844028354,
0.0164621845,
0.0597011968,
-0.0776766539,
0.4113671482,
-0.631282866,
-0.8211911321,
0.6930028796,
-1.0664249659,
-0.5365123749,
-0.2526315153,
-0.5513883233,
-0.3731167614,
-0.0357010476,
-0.0145056602,
0.1543713957,
-0.6039131284,
0.4688791633,
0.8138442039,
-0.3729485273,
0.2081031203,
0.6040105224,
-0.2867002785,
-0.0637449399,
0.844884932,
0.063439548,
0.2499272078,
0.016372541,
0.2866889536,
0.1689282507,
-0.1742582619,
0.0867788121,
0.4427175224,
-0.4407592118,
0.267139405,
-0.6668157578,
-0.3498368561,
-0.4294705987,
-0.0406367816,
-0.5986015797,
-0.1836374104,
0.0262826961,
0.2528686225,
-0.0843902528,
0.7031735778,
0.2595967054,
0.7748405933,
-0.3386656046,
0.3073821664,
0.5236949921,
0.0963987708,
0.1607184261,
-0.4592205882,
0.0561693907,
0.1452879161,
-0.3603993058,
-0.852897346,
0.4925521314,
0.3353478312,
0.606033802,
0.4907261133,
-0.2997834384,
0.1551606953,
-0.3602760732,
0.6702578664,
-0.3073925376,
-0.6052559018,
0.4115155041,
-0.4766883254,
0.3495297134,
0.3401322961,
0.3456424177,
-0.4283317029,
-0.0895008445,
-0.7530938387,
-0.4586722851,
0.4641207159,
0.5617378354,
0.4084648788,
-0.0401119739,
0.7861805558,
0.0810323432,
0.2717071176,
-0.6638929248,
-0.0960269049,
-0.2235049605,
-0.2652201653,
-0.1255580336,
-0.5346230865,
-0.1217155829,
0.0412751026,
0.3585212231,
-0.3353957832,
0.5965655446,
-0.1564586759,
0.0945987105,
0.2487930804,
0.5228090286,
0.4459647238,
0.4271112382,
-0.2359547913,
0.178655684,
-0.1332291067,
-0.5567042828,
0.1734046787,
-0.3409710228,
0.0079268357,
-0.5570127964,
0.567291379,
0.6569740772,
0.053511817,
-0.6553530097,
0.6744823456,
-0.1707606018,
0.0780284479,
-0.8380978703,
0.2694041431,
0.2851392627,
0.3476608694,
0.2832680047,
-0.1381343752,
-0.3052261174,
-1.1458292007,
-0.021733975,
0.5571112037,
-0.1588036567,
-0.6827881336,
0.372695744,
-0.0564143993,
-0.3994184434,
0.7811754346,
-0.1491236389,
-0.3282189369,
0.657147944,
0.5068320036,
0.8386722207,
-0.2563178837,
0.2759889364,
0.2251829505,
0.0516009852,
-0.0693011433,
0.3707747757,
0.095376119,
-1.1864557266,
-0.2077870667,
-0.6877205372,
-0.3810346723,
0.0805988237,
-0.4538407922,
-0.0470922962,
-0.9510045052,
-0.242693603,
0.0411273353,
0.0088958303,
-1.0089373589,
0.1527120471,
0.1545725763,
0.3508896232,
-0.7832387686,
0.8766887188,
0.5793752074,
-0.5049415827,
-0.8644410372,
0.1238714084,
0.1597637534,
-0.7430424094,
0.5880745053,
-0.138188079,
-0.1130211353,
-0.1157994941,
-1.0150310993,
-0.7870923877,
1.1840087175,
0.5785243511,
-0.3182642758,
-0.2769836485,
0.242019251,
0.9171253443,
-0.8691812158,
0.1847541034,
0.501178205,
0.371886462,
0.463437885,
-0.8382223248,
-0.0900139734,
-0.0261582918,
0.103656292,
-0.3977797031,
-0.8906986117,
0.9868025184,
-0.2961416841,
-0.2023302913,
0.3875895441,
0.6146656871,
0.3102540076,
-0.2046714127,
0.3764543831,
0.066618897,
0.7348632216,
-0.0731813088,
1.1720514297,
-0.205490455,
0.1646485478,
1.2824077606,
-0.479867667,
0.7137486339,
0.2116729021,
-0.168201074,
0.7442704439,
0.4097928703,
0.1487817019,
0.1966371387,
-0.1205330417,
-0.0519209616,
-0.4404673278,
-0.1485611349,
0.2506129444,
1.0388455391,
0.3446795642,
-0.355915606,
0.0563529693,
0.0433999561,
0.2383186668,
0.0265603084,
-0.165215984,
0.7942005992,
0.1461417228,
-0.6286392808,
0.0110260891,
-0.1386176199,
0.4502178431,
-0.6024947166,
0.0489696302,
-0.4796193838,
0.1504104435,
-0.2780168355,
-0.8482266068,
0.2746231258,
-0.3241397738,
-0.2036877722,
-0.2806023657,
1.0196863413,
-0.4284009039,
-0.1864520311,
-0.0557432473,
0.7861151695,
0.4522708058,
-0.1663568914,
-0.1412193328,
-0.154814437,
-0.0091357017,
-0.1725075096,
0.4636690319,
0.4454177916,
-0.2380363494,
0.9221221805,
0.3678301275,
0.2061676979,
-0.3652411699,
-0.0585271753,
0.5752200484,
-0.7653625011,
-0.3447453678,
-0.7990264297,
0.5349102616,
-0.0997169986,
-0.0298677161,
0.7018568516,
0.3120105565,
0.4671823978,
-0.1559193581,
0.7661340833,
-0.0250549819,
0.4930248857,
-0.2227350026,
0.6998056173,
-0.1609743983,
0.251324892,
-0.2433234602,
-1.2198174,
0.3848795891,
0.5252891779,
-0.3481980562,
0.3431198001,
0.5726884604,
0.6223894954,
0.1166878939,
-0.2997178137,
0.5586572289,
0.3280070424,
0.3886932135,
0.5588257909,
0.7482540011,
0.1442780793,
0.3562960625,
0.0531266369,
-0.3901257515,
-0.0742674246,
-0.6911953688,
-1.0277471542,
-0.4989058077,
-0.315752089,
-0.6270565391,
-0.350014478,
0.7940411568,
0.5134218335,
-0.3379459381,
-0.1251146793,
0.543322444,
-0.0883276984,
0.0607859083,
-0.2210853845,
0.0119633377,
0.1280436069,
-0.6937043071,
-0.0251124818,
0.4056374431,
0.2755327225,
-0.996368885,
-0.1248024106,
0.2702633142,
0.5634806156,
0.7644394636,
0.430842042,
-0.7373579741,
-0.814345181,
0.0438647233,
-0.4239312708,
0.0976174995,
0.9206708074,
-0.6248176098,
0.0989637524,
0.2127856612,
0.348897934,
0.3902668059,
-0.0304805096,
0.5748471618,
-0.937271595,
0.1422606409,
0.0797121748,
0.5471730828,
0.5593814254,
-0.5069372058,
0.4043626189,
0.1494537592,
-0.5567142963,
-0.2781815231,
0.7667606473,
-1.4496096373,
-0.1332179457,
1.5182409286,
-0.2813075483,
-0.4062392712,
-0.1020005941,
-0.4611823559,
-0.1473714709,
-0.314632982,
0.8150286078,
0.8901500702,
-0.2845340669,
-0.4705688357,
-0.3081443012,
0.2339125872,
0.0213543866,
-0.8347441554,
0.0472402982,
0.6322075129,
0.4905112684,
0.1897592396,
0.9179489613,
0.011690245,
-0.0469551943,
0.1325334907,
0.1220163032,
0.3704238832,
-0.1718196273,
0.0961969197,
0.2429570854,
0.3601002991,
0.5767700076
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12213v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12213v3 | LLM-Oracle Machines | 2024-06-18T02:25:33 | 2024-07-03T12:59:21 | Jie Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.FL, F.1.1; F.4.1; I.2.0 | Contemporary AI applications leverage large language models (LLMs) to harness
their knowledge and reasoning abilities for natural language processing tasks.
This approach shares similarities with the concept of oracle Turing machines
(OTMs). To capture the broader potential of these computations, including those
not yet realized, we propose an extension to OTMs: the LLM-oracle machine
(LLM-OM), by employing a cluster of LLMs as the oracle. Each LLM acts as a
black box, capable of answering queries within its expertise, albeit with a
delay. We introduce four variants of the LLM-OM: basic, augmented,
fault-avoidance, and $\epsilon$-fault. The first two are commonly observed in
existing AI applications. The latter two are specifically designed to address
the challenges of LLM hallucinations, biases, and inconsistencies, aiming to
ensure reliable outcomes. | [
-0.3973117471,
-1.1126585007,
1.063121438,
0.0561295301,
0.0312631913,
0.0436141901,
-0.087523587,
-0.8788560629,
0.4407599568,
0.9242337346,
-0.6789339185,
-0.3894539475,
-0.4775512218,
0.4337551892,
-0.5695317388,
0.5779678822,
0.0839836001,
-0.1933869421,
-0.2395963967,
-0.0733367279,
-0.4642495513,
-0.5361840129,
-0.7412130237,
-0.596129775,
0.3881629109,
0.3255634308,
0.8265072703,
0.8764737248,
0.4899414182,
0.3217419982,
0.2253141254,
0.2654471397,
-0.0352385342,
0.2895903289,
0.0869604051,
-0.8105623126,
-0.6871249676,
-0.2382230759,
0.5555336475,
0.9074042439,
-0.056978453,
-0.0312516689,
-0.3096301854,
0.633769691,
-0.472537905,
0.2819232941,
-0.7255676985,
0.0559512042,
-0.0956060961,
0.1497015953,
-0.4878605306,
-0.5880094767,
0.0309069045,
-0.543839395,
-0.2965259552,
0.2806575298,
0.5198748708,
0.8250604868,
-0.1287261546,
-0.3832997382,
-0.9575930834,
0.7538942099,
-0.6179127097,
0.1399667263,
0.1400451213,
0.5786697865,
-0.0974697322,
-0.5261727571,
-0.7129917145,
-0.3680106401,
-0.0982215405,
-0.1163440272,
-0.1253078878,
0.1976756006,
0.0736957565,
0.3936789334,
-0.4574615359,
0.4671093225,
-0.3652109206,
0.0667739213,
0.5473006368,
0.6008889079,
0.2359707952,
0.1666633934,
-0.18145594,
0.1384657174,
-0.861477375,
-0.3133913875,
-0.022374481,
0.2225653976,
0.2715872824,
0.9167531133,
-0.1181952655,
1.0973863602,
-0.0913921818,
-0.253054589,
0.001284458,
0.0232357066,
-0.4973889589,
0.2329266071,
0.6524647474,
-0.1341884285,
0.1705819815,
-0.3749471605,
-0.2233051658,
0.2220478952,
0.4122953117,
-0.3327002823,
0.1114121154,
0.4447486103,
-0.3864918053,
-0.2298657596,
-0.0466642641,
-0.7844187617,
-0.6426279545,
-0.4738811553,
0.6280001402,
-0.5335987806,
-0.0101736933,
0.0595741384,
0.0398486182,
0.5002087951,
0.3223843277,
-0.5588784814,
0.5123807788,
0.8328814507,
0.51232934,
-0.440231353,
-0.3766593337,
-0.5315422416,
0.368068397,
-0.3629196882,
0.8485320807,
-0.8829733133,
-0.2006791383,
0.2018588185,
-0.1786343157,
0.0379244499,
-0.737337172,
0.500577569,
-0.4347414672,
0.1945243776,
-0.0543556474,
-0.6018584967,
-0.4601977766,
0.461545825,
-0.7259385586,
1.0425308943,
-0.0500817075,
-0.2257542312,
0.2069440931,
-0.9884926081,
-0.5399253368,
-0.0123641929,
-0.2534983456,
-0.3205216825,
0.1177212968,
0.1167222559,
0.3787803948,
-0.7179145813,
-0.1498938054,
-0.3651618659,
-0.5219882131,
0.0287809931,
-0.0757965073,
0.5068470836,
0.1524916738,
-0.2798036337,
0.33881706,
-0.9556196928,
-0.1359280944,
0.2376633435,
-0.2598802745,
-0.428245455,
0.1392725408,
-0.5227701664,
0.0005165654,
0.4978012741,
-0.3220263422,
0.3358559906,
-0.5826817155,
0.420791477,
0.7504333854,
-0.3344812691,
0.5451484919,
-0.4426922798,
0.4672753215,
-0.2265348881,
0.0641540214,
-0.2961235046,
-0.6469007134,
-1.2301524878,
-0.2841767669,
-0.127116397,
0.900796175,
-0.8736561537,
0.660841763,
-0.0261206459,
-0.3914983869,
-0.7565280199,
0.0900573656,
0.2300095111,
0.2467876226,
0.3499704301,
0.1603087634,
-0.5805407763,
-0.9939109087,
-0.2269099057,
-0.3567125499,
-0.1560056061,
0.4779214263,
0.2105201483,
-0.406332016,
0.9502474666,
-0.3061892688,
-0.2813048065,
-0.2692587972,
-0.0280268658,
0.4318090379,
0.0889288485,
0.2298184484,
-0.4976308644,
-0.357188195,
0.0568006188,
-1.1290820837,
-0.1984559447,
-0.1941045076,
0.2405647337,
0.614728868,
0.710382998,
-0.8300898075,
0.3121222854,
0.3060366809,
-0.1757104844,
0.5883030295,
-0.2005320191,
0.061494939,
-1.0231078863,
-0.1727519184,
-0.4473839104,
-0.0416704603,
-0.7304415703,
0.096209541,
-0.2922094762,
-0.0297306906,
-0.4847367406,
0.6275705099,
-0.4466429949,
-0.4624704123,
-0.4842319489,
0.1564300507,
-0.3329661489,
0.3741223812,
0.1175052598,
0.7478453517,
0.6564397216,
-0.7986844182,
0.5812929273,
0.0243074428,
0.1197503805,
0.7122907043,
-0.742390275,
0.3330072761,
-0.2026456445,
-0.2970496416,
-0.6752003431,
-0.1748294979,
0.208882764,
-0.2110528499,
0.1522704959,
0.211464107,
-0.6932026148,
-0.5541026592,
-0.1944447309,
0.3032956719,
0.6938107014,
-0.596572578,
1.0041472912,
0.3576010764,
0.015192152,
-0.5362451077,
-0.8103681803,
0.2758252919,
-0.4419906437,
-0.7269739509,
0.1924922466,
0.085444741,
-0.6449008584,
0.2802012563,
0.2387293726,
-0.1869038194,
0.0057821251,
0.4149733484,
0.2781595886,
-0.5360925794,
0.0720211491,
-0.1714007109,
-0.1628875881,
0.1059357747,
-0.4711968899,
0.7095179558,
-0.3549005687,
-0.6633006334,
-0.3029841781,
0.2983134985,
0.6661711335,
0.0312268138,
0.8761926293,
0.1955989003,
-0.7203610539,
-0.2027062923,
-0.7578157187,
-0.3158595562,
-0.4782565832,
0.2469669282,
-0.3595576882,
-1.0360827446,
0.4193573892,
0.0605055913,
0.0766311884,
0.4152761698,
0.7563893795,
-0.0409180559,
0.5576353669,
0.8753944039,
-0.3307232261,
0.0677764341,
0.1595424414,
0.3228046,
-0.5663843751,
-0.1801787019,
-0.7265786529,
-0.1120211482,
-0.4206251502,
-0.4470263422,
0.3737055063,
-0.2329928428,
-0.4171407521,
0.4442583919,
-0.4959539175,
0.5005180836,
0.6770115495,
-0.1861523092,
0.4496586323,
-0.1562274992,
0.063447766,
0.1133231893,
-0.6646223068,
-0.6836518645,
0.937972188,
0.2381854951,
0.8158404827,
-0.045409359,
0.5838797688,
0.3994365335,
0.2799854279,
-0.5719529986,
0.7493814826,
-0.101805307,
-0.6598178744,
-0.5330072045,
-0.2184760273,
-1.0839509964,
0.0988032743,
-0.2386454791,
-0.9556549191,
-0.1990604103,
-0.0047101495,
-0.3034490049,
0.4358164072,
-0.6217612624,
0.6875090599,
-0.3357433379,
-0.0361224525,
-0.3294350505,
-0.4389715493,
0.701176703,
-0.1303928047,
0.1389812827,
0.088842243,
-0.1544289738,
0.3241456449,
-0.3910788894,
0.928258121,
0.2370605469,
0.111331597,
0.3702229559,
0.1835032403,
0.5089774132,
-0.1134916469,
-0.1813257784,
0.0712790638,
-0.4407040179,
-0.30466488,
-0.3319731355,
0.6276869774,
-0.7619581819,
-0.8010639548,
-0.4307144284,
-0.651309967,
-0.2130027413,
0.3859048784,
-0.2388730496,
-0.2305184454,
-0.1661600173,
-0.0423501134,
0.6902822852,
-0.5654688478,
0.4891279638,
0.5413329601,
-0.3025747836,
-0.1197005957,
0.7666330338,
-0.2118720263,
0.3143455684,
0.5558171868,
-0.1469092071,
-0.1966283321,
-0.6420523524,
-0.2941892147,
0.2383285761,
-0.5754514337,
-0.0517855734,
-0.6384994984,
-0.541939795,
-0.1029229537,
-0.2041576803,
-0.4576103091,
-0.489844352,
-0.1134215891,
-0.000375163,
0.4762722552,
0.9541574121,
0.1418336332,
0.3105166852,
-0.7295684218,
0.5131540298,
0.6821796894,
0.4010590911,
-0.1388827562,
-0.1959721595,
0.1846043617,
-0.0987222493,
-0.1870351881,
-0.8404589295,
0.3360624313,
0.0590527058,
0.700130105,
0.2123893201,
-0.0597723797,
0.4855317473,
-0.6748087406,
0.7873884439,
0.0823647901,
-0.7116225362,
0.5272879004,
-0.1200097129,
-0.0166344289,
0.353672415,
0.1141071096,
-0.3534653187,
-0.5588071346,
-0.4014001191,
-0.6459524035,
0.6829628348,
0.3537407219,
-0.2888953984,
0.0528085865,
0.5352885723,
0.3769875169,
0.2871913314,
-0.7071665525,
-0.5082189441,
0.1120478138,
-0.098199591,
-0.0032935792,
-0.1054872498,
-0.0022142928,
0.255979836,
0.4448950887,
-0.034062352,
0.4798043966,
0.0371603705,
-0.1784757823,
-0.0812774524,
0.2146606445,
0.4654980302,
0.447938621,
-0.119853653,
0.225151062,
0.3506502807,
-0.0682319775,
-0.0141112329,
0.0214754082,
-0.4715538323,
-0.1210697517,
0.2353015095,
0.660276711,
-0.2647182941,
-0.897388339,
-0.129243359,
0.047441449,
-0.0323780291,
-0.6342769861,
0.3279375732,
0.2628786862,
0.4262735248,
0.3525904119,
-0.0085937623,
0.1555436254,
-0.7976049781,
0.1763615012,
0.5748900771,
-0.4154026806,
-0.0730281472,
0.8171741962,
0.0755051896,
-0.8370055556,
0.6104272604,
-0.1209435165,
-0.3807033598,
0.8932390213,
0.4664473832,
0.8734046817,
-0.0843634233,
-0.0380792581,
-0.1159516573,
0.7620876431,
0.0456771739,
0.259010911,
0.4177324474,
-0.680342555,
-0.6523471475,
-0.681073308,
-0.6857606769,
0.1862422526,
-0.2574029863,
0.3585134149,
-0.4574755728,
0.1700010002,
-0.0962604433,
-0.263084501,
-0.574280858,
0.0300246086,
0.423207432,
0.9253032804,
-0.4837055504,
1.0187975168,
0.7987317443,
-0.3959704936,
-0.3920883834,
-0.2412215918,
-0.0494258329,
-1.1563800573,
0.3248845637,
0.0797296464,
0.1897983104,
-0.4115001261,
-0.2377705276,
-0.6894100904,
1.1304454803,
0.5108457208,
-0.3001946211,
0.1395500004,
0.7863264084,
0.5789381862,
-0.6130252481,
0.1514934152,
0.9730825424,
0.7691115141,
-0.1115230545,
-1.040356636,
0.0335862823,
-0.013977116,
-0.3040187061,
0.2767943144,
-0.5543108582,
0.8383404613,
-0.1129067615,
0.2608835995,
0.2947163284,
0.5982422233,
0.646214962,
0.3874092698,
0.5393894911,
0.6682863832,
0.7378478646,
-0.3452252448,
1.1575828791,
-0.1891773939,
-0.3512890041,
0.957711041,
-0.3943015635,
0.5972943902,
0.5071320534,
-0.3645452261,
0.3204178214,
0.5001147985,
0.0374175906,
0.1577686965,
0.0952276811,
-0.0340790153,
-0.2269320041,
-0.0646918938,
-0.3171736896,
0.2293953449,
0.664560616,
-0.0363917574,
-0.0892772377,
-0.2483457476,
-0.1754713506,
0.1828231364,
-0.4396214485,
0.9087809324,
0.2001167238,
-0.6758179665,
0.4756864011,
-0.015515252,
0.5540313721,
-0.3529233932,
-0.1180436388,
-0.1255069822,
0.2049351782,
-0.0263638198,
-0.7930268645,
0.635915935,
-0.1524074972,
-0.3010333776,
0.0148931332,
0.8120911717,
-0.33420223,
-0.6763307452,
0.4080185592,
0.5630987287,
0.2799048126,
-0.152251929,
-0.6060193181,
0.1342532635,
-0.247712031,
0.1321920007,
0.1975604594,
0.612631917,
-0.1647518277,
0.936806798,
0.3539372683,
0.1256303042,
0.502358973,
-0.1956484318,
0.7616249323,
-0.8348498344,
-0.3325625658,
-0.9483555555,
0.2322988361,
-0.0959311575,
-0.0174090732,
0.511637032,
0.3296134472,
0.3240123391,
-0.1627608538,
0.911745131,
-0.0605697744,
0.5555558801,
-0.6103780866,
0.443459332,
-0.6613128185,
0.5628163815,
-0.2060219049,
-1.1578420401,
-0.4779196382,
0.5495467782,
-0.1576692015,
-0.1058512628,
0.7459256649,
0.5585591793,
0.1784718186,
0.1591185778,
0.3906265199,
0.5595933795,
0.3537231088,
0.8957854509,
0.9601686001,
-0.2462738454,
0.6919870377,
-0.1063031182,
-0.1056201607,
-0.2978540957,
-0.8721014857,
-1.1189050674,
-0.236914739,
-0.1184352487,
-0.1708590835,
0.3125624955,
0.7065625191,
0.6928831935,
-0.873565197,
-0.3170321286,
-0.1648746729,
0.5059463382,
-0.2000402659,
-0.1245329753,
0.3106173575,
-0.5476523042,
-0.7105448842,
0.5381458402,
0.6444458961,
-0.1823670268,
-0.3521214724,
-0.3316989839,
0.1526281536,
0.3327045739,
0.5071279407,
0.4420911968,
-0.8973481655,
-0.2337470353,
0.2980756462,
0.0307990424,
0.0713528395,
0.5825445056,
-0.7641040683,
0.1561012566,
0.174526155,
1.1233433485,
0.3848924637,
-0.335562855,
0.7674660087,
-0.3106666207,
0.4489549994,
0.4246025383,
0.5373769403,
0.1494847834,
-0.3112676442,
0.6053523421,
0.108221963,
-0.4609100521,
-0.7809976339,
0.3486435413,
-0.9749705791,
-0.4385409951,
0.9696327448,
0.2238746881,
-0.329287827,
-0.2357949167,
-0.1444855928,
-0.1468248367,
-0.2624552548,
1.094124794,
0.6700922847,
-0.4022834003,
-0.2367645502,
-0.5382633805,
0.322006315,
0.4533360004,
-1.1396068335,
-0.1639422029,
0.3014260232,
-0.2271117419,
0.3496389091,
0.4916937947,
-0.201556012,
0.3530778289,
-0.1080606058,
0.2229584605,
0.0003397686,
-0.4931171536,
-0.170947507,
0.397028923,
0.2718711793,
-0.0494605862
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12209v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12209v1 | Interface Design for Self-Supervised Speech Models | 2024-06-18T02:13:48 | 2024-06-18T02:13:48 | Yi-Jen Shih, David Harwath | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS | Self-supervised speech (SSL) models have recently become widely adopted for
many downstream speech processing tasks. The general usage pattern is to employ
SSL models as feature extractors, and then train a downstream prediction head
to solve a specific task. However, different layers of SSL models have been
shown to capture different types of information, and the methods of combining
them are not well studied. To this end, we extend the general framework for SSL
model utilization by proposing the interface that connects the upstream and
downstream. Under this view, the dominant technique of combining features via a
layerwise weighted sum can be regarded as a specific interface. We propose
several alternative interface designs and demonstrate that the weighted sum
interface is suboptimal for many tasks. In particular, we show that a
convolutional interface whose depth scales logarithmically with the depth of
the upstream model consistently outperforms many other interface designs. | [
-0.61267519,
-0.4021920562,
0.4020099044,
0.27595222,
-0.2317148596,
-0.0880719274,
0.2588335276,
-0.7334463596,
0.3485040665,
0.5588587523,
-0.5536281466,
-0.0884261131,
-0.4401593804,
-0.3346762061,
-0.6206191182,
0.9550172687,
0.25817734,
-0.0838074461,
-0.2771463692,
-0.0537063926,
-0.4218558371,
-0.677206099,
-0.7674915195,
-0.6364465356,
0.5585029125,
0.2970528901,
0.5428743958,
0.4271044731,
0.5228988528,
0.2959032953,
0.1238448694,
-0.1896117926,
-0.2343347669,
-0.0355819277,
-0.0624837689,
-0.0497350469,
-0.57693398,
0.3289820552,
0.4678558111,
0.9629420042,
-0.1732720435,
0.4283903241,
0.3279666007,
0.7791308165,
-0.7251971364,
-0.0427249856,
-0.1631133109,
0.1296699494,
-0.2240978926,
-0.0396467261,
-0.3188250065,
0.0752920583,
0.4859915078,
-0.3186256289,
-0.0905323699,
-0.23199597,
0.1375595331,
0.4141933918,
-0.3596378863,
-0.1515344977,
-0.7761796117,
0.6909657717,
-0.9017652869,
0.5101065636,
0.2391710281,
0.2512935996,
0.1788527519,
-0.7171453238,
-0.1204075143,
-0.2159294039,
-0.418384403,
0.3309905827,
-0.3418647647,
0.0808002278,
-0.0182600971,
0.3153564632,
-0.5195515156,
0.4671261013,
-0.5956833363,
-0.0337119028,
1.0467196703,
0.171718806,
0.1406293213,
0.0552442633,
-0.5749909878,
0.2029839903,
-0.6101815701,
0.5797153711,
0.5652546287,
0.467354387,
-0.4894914329,
0.3960368633,
-0.4735372066,
0.9011898637,
0.302339226,
-0.0056718909,
0.2423577458,
-0.1640509963,
-0.2195941508,
0.3830106258,
0.5739530921,
-0.0219043475,
0.4408239126,
-0.010845365,
-0.2452885211,
-0.2879377306,
0.403429836,
-0.6621471643,
-0.6073726416,
0.6107934713,
-0.6583367586,
-0.3619651496,
-0.2841881514,
-0.2655599415,
-0.0808153749,
-0.7098283172,
0.5801244974,
-0.0259369258,
-0.6187072992,
-0.2516054213,
-0.3687447608,
0.2786805034,
0.0950103998,
-1.0846550465,
0.4428943992,
0.6049062014,
0.9154109955,
-0.3776281476,
-0.1053713113,
-0.7346943021,
0.1558790207,
-0.3185297847,
0.63528198,
-0.5261417031,
-0.5566405654,
-0.2329663932,
-0.3513323665,
0.0296249054,
-0.3509694934,
0.3680085242,
-0.1280701756,
0.2360510677,
0.0145447385,
-0.7207362056,
0.1831823289,
-0.4792361856,
-0.5203813314,
0.5942323208,
0.1704382896,
-0.8555362821,
-0.0484951772,
-0.6801499128,
-0.7092971206,
0.3458451033,
-0.2411132008,
-0.4991334975,
0.2623155415,
0.0413184091,
0.494920671,
0.0837005675,
0.2717561126,
-0.6067746282,
-0.4958907664,
0.1333341897,
-0.1542212665,
0.9487433434,
0.6161212325,
-0.1089724451,
0.0663214251,
-0.9295040965,
-0.0427776314,
-0.2491885722,
-0.3258554935,
-0.7068602443,
0.1240913495,
-0.0422859974,
0.0919576362,
0.3029257953,
-0.6437202096,
-0.312119782,
-0.1718685329,
0.7823835015,
0.6868826747,
-0.1809771061,
0.5500521064,
0.0223201104,
0.255864799,
0.3335781991,
0.4384322464,
0.1175986454,
-0.3723770082,
-0.6396659613,
-0.2913391292,
0.4092095792,
0.4387819767,
-0.3856979907,
0.2482857555,
-0.0067596314,
-0.6770935059,
-0.6276279092,
0.2279352546,
0.5238471031,
0.8189102411,
0.5716127753,
-0.2560047507,
-0.3312024474,
-1.337220788,
-0.369422406,
-0.1137883142,
-0.4377787709,
0.2875255346,
0.0510649011,
0.4224496782,
1.1123259068,
-0.2338945866,
-0.4499643445,
-0.241467312,
0.3502686024,
0.329728812,
0.8948756456,
0.5483462811,
-0.81308496,
-0.3875871897,
-0.2095117122,
-0.8550687432,
-0.1811552495,
-0.0150337582,
0.1578948051,
-0.1913139224,
0.3754038513,
-0.4691428542,
0.4689426422,
0.7032185793,
0.1045739874,
0.1247960702,
-0.1665322036,
-0.2731766403,
-0.7204363942,
-0.1866509914,
0.4354766309,
-0.0760635361,
-1.1848199368,
-0.0824947655,
0.2396768928,
-0.2075137198,
-0.8079896569,
0.5117026567,
-0.410325557,
-0.3041218519,
-0.4557910264,
0.0679090247,
-0.1293604821,
0.6525253057,
0.349270165,
0.7104972601,
0.5934742689,
-0.7199318409,
0.2411922514,
0.0416461527,
-0.020074252,
0.6666520238,
-1.0870536566,
0.0779425353,
-0.1802191585,
0.2171397358,
-1.2441232204,
-0.0881504714,
-0.0472129993,
-0.5176259279,
0.3283177018,
-0.299266845,
0.4302045703,
-0.2592022419,
-0.3280462921,
0.5543664694,
0.6293485165,
-0.5595930219,
0.9992766976,
0.7661171556,
-0.2386921495,
-0.2386680245,
-1.2259134054,
-0.0687580183,
-0.5269652009,
-0.6814823747,
0.4136377573,
0.0790972039,
-0.1179943457,
-0.1044780165,
-0.0965503082,
0.030280428,
0.0761575848,
0.3996577263,
0.0807510987,
-0.2776217461,
0.0501641519,
0.1788856834,
-0.1934548169,
0.0822857022,
-0.2900876701,
0.1566866636,
0.1043452471,
-0.4152106941,
-0.7384403348,
0.6797565818,
0.1767614931,
-0.3712812364,
0.2584837973,
0.4591797292,
-0.2643191218,
0.0270939376,
-0.6914321184,
-0.054237444,
-0.521887362,
0.0381888747,
-0.7772238255,
-0.9582826495,
0.5069228411,
0.0783103406,
0.2556260228,
0.4515129626,
0.2870323956,
-0.609406352,
1.1361997128,
0.7493790984,
-0.2877809703,
0.4644905627,
-0.1944027841,
0.2943923473,
-1.3780864477,
0.1277021915,
-0.4311544597,
-0.4242190421,
-0.7926129103,
0.5191907287,
0.3297526538,
-0.0302652735,
-0.2523881793,
0.4447952807,
-0.5201467872,
0.0405810252,
0.9599713683,
0.130178377,
0.0866434202,
-0.2661686242,
0.1852378845,
0.2231801152,
-0.6340769529,
-0.0459287576,
0.7819917798,
0.5231491923,
1.0644304752,
0.0866970345,
0.9317559004,
0.5899080634,
0.1106171608,
-0.3056899011,
0.2902493477,
-0.6138539314,
-0.4406657219,
-0.6551996469,
-0.3073635697,
-0.7521734834,
0.361969471,
0.0657194778,
-0.6926571131,
0.6935369968,
0.5504804254,
-0.5151698589,
-0.1925704926,
-0.927790761,
0.6903784275,
-0.25103423,
-0.1511276066,
-0.2235776782,
-0.6481238604,
0.5129727721,
-0.1218362376,
0.2685949504,
-0.1266995519,
0.3011393249,
0.62141186,
-0.4281909764,
1.0612891912,
-0.4434836209,
-0.2475335747,
0.379355818,
-0.0732796341,
0.3436115086,
-0.1216333434,
0.1426403224,
0.3692476749,
-0.0800096467,
-0.3067426085,
-0.359510541,
0.8733683228,
-0.7607704401,
-0.7147938609,
0.0066252719,
-0.2731289566,
-0.2505023479,
-0.128130421,
0.0722379088,
0.9197620153,
0.294716239,
0.1834619194,
0.374184221,
-0.0133512923,
0.6449363828,
0.5070009828,
0.0652389973,
-0.0962407142,
1.1517660618,
0.3769338429,
0.5149724483,
0.2365403473,
0.4781831503,
-0.5228068829,
-0.6533021927,
-0.3614624739,
-0.2781968415,
-0.541056931,
-0.0373414271,
-0.4852750301,
-0.9302628636,
-0.6107445955,
0.1307061613,
-0.3087432086,
-0.6409710646,
-0.2456971705,
0.0023458845,
0.0715892762,
0.322229892,
-0.3266012967,
0.4430567622,
-0.408988148,
0.5412108898,
0.8854515553,
0.351218611,
0.1912404746,
-0.7452340722,
-0.1621282995,
0.0600635223,
-0.0523480587,
-0.5531190038,
0.2584117651,
0.350237608,
0.7515452504,
0.3458729088,
0.1318096817,
0.7790977955,
-0.5078905225,
0.736407876,
0.2585547268,
-0.9001021981,
0.750469327,
-0.1309579611,
0.458586216,
0.3041414917,
0.4512832463,
-0.3957439661,
-0.7957379222,
-0.5847754478,
-0.5393814445,
0.3133182526,
0.2497359961,
0.2456380725,
0.2377347648,
0.2264140695,
0.0774376914,
0.0402952544,
-0.7473552227,
-0.2545750737,
-0.5410017371,
-0.3502993584,
0.0108020902,
-0.2054568231,
0.0152418893,
-0.2547803521,
0.4656021297,
-0.1237013265,
-0.1460059434,
0.3762391508,
0.0364547856,
0.0507061183,
0.0509987846,
0.5311684608,
0.7273256183,
-0.1159629449,
0.4273787737,
0.0400329493,
-0.1777933985,
-0.0911704525,
-0.0646526441,
-0.2994316518,
-0.2640562952,
0.5048561692,
0.7862999439,
0.2707373798,
-0.1150868237,
0.3683491945,
-0.0667554662,
-0.3701236844,
-0.4475212991,
0.3045368195,
0.3324435353,
0.527341485,
0.5828383565,
-0.156535387,
0.7152460814,
-0.3256870806,
0.2218476832,
0.8308247924,
-0.4085354805,
-0.0280302446,
0.913600564,
0.5496957302,
-0.5791355968,
0.5732581615,
0.3064579964,
-0.1861501783,
0.4998925626,
0.2863162458,
0.9384612441,
-0.3637101948,
0.0101289582,
0.2026794106,
0.0132437814,
0.4393965006,
0.030970566,
-0.4602003396,
-0.4722574353,
-0.6053797603,
-0.7059982419,
-0.484269917,
0.2117843181,
-0.618419826,
0.0694366693,
-0.2573751211,
-0.1376198083,
0.4837527871,
-0.3216618896,
-0.593895793,
0.4614459872,
0.3860968649,
0.7100555301,
-0.9121118784,
1.0496451855,
0.073045738,
-0.4066782892,
-0.6563325524,
-0.5164223313,
-0.1375033706,
-0.893320322,
0.7798583508,
-0.0233861934,
-0.3455118239,
0.1344205141,
-0.4088764787,
-1.058836937,
0.7159027457,
0.0202921778,
-0.7138656378,
0.1398852915,
0.3199853003,
0.4311967194,
-0.7025542855,
0.1548752338,
0.4254760742,
0.2220896631,
0.1496363133,
-0.8522468805,
-0.1194798648,
-0.2057231516,
0.2884042561,
-0.1064182147,
-0.8233745098,
0.9261621833,
0.0954451188,
-0.1831187457,
-0.2045821249,
0.9654797316,
0.1315842122,
0.2093197256,
0.8612352014,
0.4425936937,
0.2362585664,
0.0752972662,
0.7012280822,
-0.2003093511,
0.204357326,
1.404540658,
-0.1121766269,
0.8543256521,
0.4346033931,
-0.2655674219,
0.2237686962,
0.8770359755,
0.1251375377,
0.7818466425,
0.3046929836,
-0.0281954147,
-0.3701066077,
-0.1053542867,
-0.5046101809,
0.6182098389,
0.0912162662,
-0.1151544377,
-0.0928568393,
0.0479556061,
-0.6627520919,
-0.3357124031,
-0.4863013327,
0.9041127563,
0.3214399517,
-0.5586938262,
0.2530508339,
-0.3313822448,
0.5796147585,
-0.4361111522,
-0.02145271,
-0.5883669853,
-0.0508834496,
-0.422860384,
-0.9430427551,
0.2525578737,
-0.2958754301,
0.0555702634,
-0.2086946964,
0.7726073265,
-0.5378857255,
-0.6170212626,
0.3769799173,
0.3735861182,
0.2124249488,
-0.0500801355,
-0.3895505369,
-0.0839408562,
-0.3656617403,
-0.2159497738,
0.5178354383,
0.099251762,
-0.0167141613,
0.8419753313,
0.6210964322,
0.072440207,
0.3171140254,
0.5941597223,
0.8017147183,
-0.4456206858,
-0.6377153993,
-0.7981240749,
0.6414018273,
-0.2222746611,
-0.2281785011,
0.4631987512,
0.4801908433,
0.8448168039,
0.0788768604,
0.8433874846,
0.3655090332,
0.7302933931,
-0.6153438687,
0.4011584818,
-0.6984578371,
-0.0757742301,
-0.1885486394,
-0.7514939904,
0.1806556135,
0.5115514398,
-0.0253257211,
0.1326919198,
0.2593182325,
0.2231116146,
-0.388500005,
0.2286716998,
0.4402979612,
-0.0429209955,
0.3983022869,
0.5677713156,
0.8338130713,
-0.1188324317,
0.2184331864,
-0.4923517108,
-0.3700190485,
-0.077762045,
-0.9088419676,
-0.8497394919,
-0.7128525972,
-0.4033820033,
0.3634782732,
-0.1083387062,
0.2435707003,
1.1246228218,
-0.7791993022,
-0.3956365585,
0.0095974132,
-0.0347656012,
-0.1734105647,
-0.230862096,
0.1939183027,
-0.498901993,
-0.5440533757,
0.5624786019,
0.4964838028,
0.1847538799,
-0.853515327,
0.071160607,
0.0129065458,
-0.0067271218,
0.5653823018,
0.4469016492,
-0.8135359883,
-0.4765033722,
-0.3907608688,
0.067201145,
0.0007191019,
0.9002797008,
-0.8328213096,
0.1198040023,
0.3654380441,
0.6698895097,
0.8186094165,
0.3190616369,
0.4761298001,
-0.8373419046,
0.0676258877,
-0.2061602175,
0.3211423755,
0.1927359104,
-0.4523801804,
0.6317657828,
-0.2309916466,
-0.455350101,
-0.5455183387,
0.3395297527,
-0.9897440672,
-0.3693698049,
0.5885685086,
-0.0526465587,
-0.1439369023,
-0.0383762456,
0.1762325913,
-0.0093555562,
-0.1232760698,
0.6623570919,
0.6161181331,
-0.7666662931,
-0.4636552632,
-0.3923315704,
0.3862215877,
0.2117453814,
-0.5583224893,
-0.0466765724,
0.1812744588,
0.3141596317,
0.1889021248,
0.8106458783,
0.1314494163,
0.0938760787,
-0.1907541454,
-0.1831823438,
-0.135076642,
-0.4620884955,
-0.4254632294,
0.1677186489,
-0.1433506012,
-0.4209012389
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12208v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12208v1 | Knowledge Fusion By Evolving Weights of Language Models | 2024-06-18T02:12:34 | 2024-06-18T02:12:34 | Guodong Du, Jing Li, Hanting Liu, Runhua Jiang, Shuyang Yu, Yifei Guo, Sim Kuan Goh, Ho-Kin Tang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, cs.NE | Fine-tuning pre-trained language models, particularly large language models,
demands extensive computing resources and can result in varying performance
outcomes across different domains and datasets. This paper examines the
approach of integrating multiple models from diverse training scenarios into a
unified model. This unified model excels across various data domains and
exhibits the ability to generalize well on out-of-domain data. We propose a
knowledge fusion method named Evolver, inspired by evolutionary algorithms,
which does not need further training or additional training data. Specifically,
our method involves aggregating the weights of different language models into a
population and subsequently generating offspring models through mutation and
crossover operations. These offspring models are then evaluated against their
parents, allowing for the preservation of those models that show enhanced
performance on development datasets. Importantly, our model evolving strategy
can be seamlessly integrated with existing model merging frameworks, offering a
versatile tool for model enhancement. Experimental results on mainstream
language models (i.e., encoder-only, decoder-only, encoder-decoder) reveal that
Evolver outperforms previous state-of-the-art models by large margins. The code
is publicly available at {https://github.com/duguodong7/model-evolution}. | [
-0.4296179414,
-0.4865263104,
0.2433229536,
-0.1698131859,
-0.0298063979,
0.3167598844,
-0.3591941893,
-0.4653175473,
-0.0850731954,
0.5411432981,
-0.3997200727,
-0.1378030181,
-0.634552896,
-0.2223141342,
-0.4033521712,
0.795563221,
0.1517250687,
0.1713836193,
-0.531933248,
-0.1904897541,
-0.3192570508,
-0.2104486823,
-0.1922836155,
-0.7826983929,
0.0459688529,
0.2196660042,
0.7812983394,
0.7727912068,
0.2898702025,
0.281585902,
-0.1184627786,
0.4296762049,
-0.7071277499,
0.0513538942,
-0.3359561861,
-0.146175459,
-0.1737665832,
-0.3631691337,
0.5870068073,
0.8412712216,
-0.1793806255,
0.0013002672,
0.1285096854,
0.4377533197,
-0.6773001552,
-0.1825918108,
-0.660551548,
-0.1858766228,
-0.1503024995,
0.0550926104,
-0.3129003942,
-0.4347272217,
0.3310529292,
-0.4133958519,
0.0305049904,
-0.0814035684,
0.7568892241,
0.0465823971,
-0.2477902025,
0.0434786044,
-1.066395402,
0.8467158079,
-0.7907974124,
0.7570020556,
-0.1433922201,
0.2441666424,
-0.3251416385,
-0.6536659598,
-0.744990468,
0.0392059311,
-0.0683486313,
-0.0141652683,
-0.4186725914,
-0.0263782982,
-0.23904109,
0.4411090016,
-0.5491752028,
0.2987833023,
-0.5140103698,
0.0624002479,
0.6592293978,
-0.1441247314,
0.6831358671,
0.3293312192,
-0.1304148585,
-0.2946156561,
-0.7191538811,
-0.2312640101,
0.3808524013,
0.5170987844,
-0.0694499314,
0.5198404789,
-0.2709698081,
1.0054694414,
0.1401301324,
-0.0404040217,
0.2638756931,
-0.3172318041,
-0.0662123039,
-0.1053359583,
0.7369243503,
0.013686629,
0.1607015431,
-0.4955191612,
-0.1402828842,
0.1065831631,
0.2001520097,
-0.4641909003,
-0.4634808898,
0.0424104333,
-0.2950921953,
-0.2996948361,
-0.2379471362,
-1.0150296688,
-0.5060901046,
-0.2801192999,
0.7413573265,
-0.6066969633,
-0.5663826466,
0.4729653001,
-0.3404411972,
0.2672777772,
-0.0460511073,
-1.0598270893,
0.2801150382,
0.6825300455,
0.4511443377,
-0.2046518624,
-0.4698745906,
-0.2653591633,
0.1022741199,
-0.0708459541,
0.8230018616,
-0.7530664802,
-0.4202722013,
0.0342381746,
-0.3900577128,
-0.3393001556,
-0.5070002079,
0.3323656917,
-0.7015253901,
0.3981153667,
0.1256148517,
-0.796028614,
-0.272426039,
-0.0907039344,
-0.5564088225,
0.9894009233,
0.4625644982,
-0.5519894361,
0.5207102895,
-0.9702567458,
-0.5937114954,
0.395616293,
-0.0767638385,
-0.2622047067,
0.0544676408,
0.4458474815,
0.3692410886,
-0.4925020337,
0.2243254632,
-0.3755064011,
-0.0581488609,
-0.0679395497,
0.1309302598,
0.7067421675,
0.3821618855,
-0.1883712709,
0.0446432456,
-0.6829916239,
0.1550730616,
0.3059402108,
-0.3841228187,
-0.5515511632,
0.0682628304,
-0.2752259076,
0.1738289595,
0.3254788816,
-0.4503852129,
0.3957694769,
-0.4583872855,
0.3457480669,
0.2324856222,
0.0078686103,
0.7899425626,
-0.3872600794,
0.413640976,
0.0031860042,
0.158987686,
-0.0544949546,
-0.5141072869,
-0.9076634049,
0.0895160064,
0.484547168,
0.2706114054,
-0.6739820242,
0.7576141953,
-0.8425465226,
-0.6826136112,
-0.9060277343,
0.4455913007,
0.3074095249,
0.3057010174,
0.4898054302,
-0.2370010912,
-0.6343454719,
-0.7675566673,
-0.3075561523,
-0.0993234813,
0.0440281108,
0.0831661448,
0.274641335,
-0.5103625059,
1.1505471468,
-0.4137551188,
0.2242132425,
-0.6455371976,
0.059450537,
-0.1325137764,
0.7571050525,
0.5119242668,
-0.8479425311,
-0.0719859973,
0.5394536257,
-0.6715497971,
0.0527851544,
0.0366166756,
-0.2036803663,
-0.2838981748,
0.1999825835,
-0.343562901,
-0.2249992341,
0.8249632716,
-0.1813073903,
0.289003104,
-0.2421067059,
0.1437798887,
-1.2449948788,
0.0079917843,
-0.0827346146,
0.0398717821,
-1.157119751,
0.4070580602,
0.1624161899,
-0.0501679778,
-0.3743781447,
0.7462109327,
-0.4136669636,
0.0834598467,
-0.1380303353,
0.1395022273,
-0.0725210682,
0.1520300359,
0.0183875188,
0.5589053631,
0.7384078503,
-0.8266069889,
0.4159714282,
0.254106909,
-0.4790500104,
0.138386488,
-0.3727825284,
0.2075516582,
-0.1966544539,
-0.1363994628,
-0.5994533896,
-0.1964686662,
-0.074817434,
-0.311886102,
0.3760626316,
-0.2638726532,
-0.2734276354,
-0.5745993853,
0.0764789358,
0.330209434,
0.8921898007,
-0.9240830541,
1.0521888733,
0.5090445876,
-0.1681050062,
-0.2930010855,
-0.4636156261,
-0.0444329605,
-0.3375285268,
-0.9255099893,
0.4503839314,
-0.1184559539,
-0.1437776685,
0.0954950377,
0.121972844,
-0.0368489772,
-0.1186536103,
-0.2276664227,
0.2077009827,
-0.4208205044,
0.1584186405,
0.4659849107,
0.2648539245,
-0.3838450015,
-0.7241563201,
0.7614303827,
0.0439826995,
-0.33401829,
0.0251551233,
0.0884397477,
0.7681381702,
-0.4028698802,
0.9155442119,
0.3710097373,
-0.3583955467,
-0.349394232,
-0.792645514,
-0.0303942692,
-0.4570989311,
0.3973878026,
-0.3380588889,
-0.9790691137,
0.4890632331,
-0.6144015193,
0.2047007233,
0.6089949012,
0.3697377443,
0.3210456669,
1.2458295822,
1.0500551462,
-0.1430382133,
0.4642326236,
-0.1954296678,
0.1628843844,
-0.8808916807,
-0.3872806132,
-0.4391991794,
-0.2226158679,
-0.2716622353,
-0.3231502473,
0.0110632526,
0.358934015,
-0.1819310039,
0.5499125719,
-0.5202720165,
0.610432744,
0.309881866,
0.0495744869,
0.293723017,
0.0072172019,
-0.253878504,
0.1829296201,
-1.104634285,
-0.1782444715,
1.1044808626,
0.2278953642,
0.8345024586,
0.226465404,
0.7196135521,
0.0765308365,
0.1989464015,
-0.3750302792,
0.2611117661,
-0.4139323533,
-0.2897040844,
-0.242521286,
-0.6446247101,
-0.8649556637,
0.3708240986,
-0.4684165716,
-0.7356020212,
0.4286181629,
0.0393304639,
-0.3621325195,
0.3395474553,
-0.8010462523,
0.7285180092,
-0.4548652768,
-0.015497514,
-0.2214988172,
-0.3369680941,
0.7748199701,
-0.4884324968,
0.2929995954,
0.131433323,
0.276668936,
0.8260586858,
-0.1526629925,
0.4210380614,
-0.0866155028,
-0.097980231,
0.0562703013,
-0.0050871982,
0.495585978,
-0.380051136,
-0.1676951349,
0.1170594618,
-0.3549085557,
-0.3246574998,
-0.6729676723,
0.6505376101,
-0.9730846286,
-0.4411966205,
0.2309944183,
-0.5382121205,
-0.4777789116,
0.3442780375,
0.272867471,
0.3688317835,
-0.157179296,
0.1341056973,
0.6631495357,
-0.1460568756,
0.1570764482,
0.6283385754,
-0.3254916966,
-0.3556824923,
0.9255338311,
-0.2162072957,
0.4674906731,
0.340996474,
0.4005978405,
-0.2527479827,
-0.6656637192,
-0.4828940034,
0.0960688144,
-0.6355945468,
-0.3380432129,
-0.8816777468,
-0.3154476285,
-0.5888698697,
-0.1830026805,
-0.4696260989,
-0.1713286936,
-0.0156768188,
0.1430494785,
0.4951978624,
0.908828795,
-0.0946574211,
0.5106464028,
-0.9307915568,
0.1516550183,
0.5027735233,
0.4130484462,
0.1512241513,
-0.64489007,
-0.2766817212,
0.364267379,
-0.0740384907,
-0.5985454321,
0.3906344473,
0.4908099174,
0.8664084077,
0.495411545,
-0.0852105096,
0.7852526307,
-0.2565408349,
0.7772068381,
0.2439079732,
-0.9015873075,
0.583917141,
-0.3064440191,
0.5077183843,
0.5219402313,
0.3221923113,
-0.4294326007,
-0.3461328149,
-0.4897685647,
-0.6663010716,
0.5988630056,
0.0203244984,
0.2160530239,
0.3994839787,
0.3897159994,
0.3094235659,
-0.1336882114,
-0.4899315536,
-0.099063769,
-0.0686766058,
-0.3605598211,
-0.0501526967,
0.0689385384,
-0.0859922767,
-0.5606700182,
0.7123581171,
-0.0183737706,
-0.0377180502,
-0.4396803677,
-0.4410633445,
-0.207871452,
0.1810236275,
0.3791027069,
0.6029346585,
0.1630146652,
-0.0009907226,
0.3910433054,
-0.4508585334,
0.0514497422,
0.337127924,
-0.1271796972,
-0.3294319212,
0.2640601099,
0.8473339677,
0.4387354851,
-0.5794126987,
0.2656852603,
-0.1569657624,
-0.2196284533,
0.3650212586,
0.3859840631,
0.1868201345,
0.39060992,
0.2974015176,
0.1874797642,
-0.1744578481,
-0.3796301782,
0.3260353208,
0.3379588723,
-0.1176415309,
-0.3320162594,
0.4984183311,
0.2768022418,
-0.0563456044,
0.6023619771,
-0.1539610922,
-0.7225807905,
0.1799293458,
0.8211839795,
0.8359357715,
-0.4828858376,
0.1233646646,
0.0673401579,
0.1366474032,
-0.3671178222,
0.1153677925,
0.0356227644,
-1.2551887035,
-0.4586336017,
-1.0281752348,
-0.2845263779,
0.1890369356,
-0.3020316362,
0.3084640801,
0.0622456968,
0.1841192842,
0.0683783218,
-0.2341551334,
-0.7128075361,
0.0831286237,
0.2792741358,
0.7845447659,
-0.896808207,
0.9833938479,
0.9238106608,
-0.2309871465,
-0.6478922367,
-0.0864399299,
-0.1687933505,
-0.9307678342,
0.5456209779,
-0.2589579225,
-0.1825245023,
0.4279656112,
-0.4210904539,
-1.1431819201,
0.9088609815,
0.4007230401,
-0.4393199086,
0.0757239684,
0.0420467667,
0.4684146941,
-0.7098771334,
-0.0615103245,
0.8864741325,
0.3803792,
0.2048266232,
-0.7033396363,
-0.2304196358,
-0.38492167,
0.0894234106,
0.424292028,
-0.2510106266,
0.6463593841,
-0.3210809529,
-0.4093305767,
-0.0705037564,
0.6766784191,
0.0596089102,
-0.3577950299,
0.5005156398,
0.6725955606,
0.7644851208,
-0.0552521385,
0.8075321317,
-0.6057201028,
0.3051007688,
0.8773764372,
-0.2706807554,
0.6968124509,
0.0714822188,
-0.1678413302,
0.5516138673,
0.2713024318,
-0.146770373,
0.5438988209,
0.0988186523,
-0.3120773137,
-0.2585573196,
-0.0546180271,
-0.3750207126,
0.6266879439,
0.3211171031,
-0.1490280777,
-0.3034514487,
0.2126870006,
-0.0380940586,
0.0019273231,
-0.2094186246,
1.0883300304,
-0.280148834,
-0.7095749974,
0.4754809737,
-0.068779245,
0.9772706032,
-0.7911022902,
0.1543651521,
-0.1456689835,
0.3060391247,
-0.1007185653,
-0.5496566892,
0.0495369993,
-0.1222994328,
-0.0442156419,
0.0038624962,
0.9266554713,
-0.8272887468,
-0.4768792689,
0.48424685,
0.7118934393,
-0.2535447776,
0.310282737,
-0.4690068066,
0.1618192941,
-0.0105597945,
0.0900642723,
0.4844019115,
0.1153571457,
0.3259242177,
0.6598245502,
0.785147965,
0.1890342981,
0.258336544,
0.1417132169,
1.0754351616,
-0.3427205086,
-0.4106758237,
-0.8326835036,
0.6349139214,
-0.1578200161,
-0.3778044581,
0.5145015717,
0.5091753602,
0.8384357095,
-0.0429493561,
1.0132136345,
-0.1121692136,
0.3294597864,
-0.3782036901,
0.9662870765,
-0.5534520745,
-0.0529672951,
-0.2004443109,
-1.0247009993,
-0.2708360255,
0.1924100965,
-0.2128449231,
0.2240779996,
0.336530745,
0.6384536624,
-0.2173637897,
0.1812999696,
0.2943591475,
0.0315364674,
0.2456986606,
0.4466046393,
0.7224771976,
-0.3053508401,
0.4197461307,
-0.236202985,
-0.3336206675,
-0.1545764953,
-0.6465952992,
-0.7058846354,
-0.6335939765,
-0.3295113444,
0.0263609309,
0.2330455035,
0.7583450079,
0.9270631671,
-0.7805823088,
-0.2202284634,
-0.1299450248,
-0.0216229707,
-0.2918196023,
-0.1953536272,
0.0772625133,
-0.3717103004,
-0.6520366073,
0.7312867641,
0.1143418774,
0.1426004171,
-0.3442236483,
-0.3984746635,
-0.12292061,
0.1302226186,
0.4678710103,
0.4518805444,
-0.4773687422,
-0.1680060327,
-0.0888586715,
0.2834308743,
-0.1823860854,
0.6740240455,
-0.9307998419,
0.8230327964,
0.4273082912,
0.8991469741,
0.2923768759,
0.0344357304,
1.0555064678,
-0.6156755686,
-0.2128619552,
0.1592859328,
0.3986999989,
0.4918985367,
-0.2865367532,
0.2438197434,
-0.0010726623,
-0.466129899,
-0.8361907005,
0.2644884288,
-0.466614604,
-0.2756894231,
0.9952192307,
0.2200074196,
0.0658786818,
-0.1363414675,
0.3658234477,
0.2786936164,
-0.285644114,
0.7527270317,
0.4655789435,
-0.1724186391,
-0.2463226914,
-0.0093718842,
0.4616231322,
0.1596369445,
-0.9233871698,
0.203806594,
0.0730665177,
0.246178627,
0.3492491841,
-0.0183009859,
-0.100466758,
0.1759476811,
0.1671009362,
0.3798086643,
-0.0364737548,
-0.1506002843,
-0.6431061625,
0.0084605431,
0.0993151069,
0.1458737999
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12197v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12197v1 | Debate as Optimization: Adaptive Conformal Prediction and Diverse Retrieval for Event Extraction | 2024-06-18T01:53:49 | 2024-06-18T01:53:49 | Sijia Wang, Lifu Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We propose a multi-agent debate as optimization (DAO) system for event
extraction, where the primary objective is to iteratively refine the large
language models (LLMs) outputs through debating without parameter tuning. In
DAO, we introduce two novel modules: the Diverse-RAG (DRAG) module and the
Adaptive Conformal Prediction (AdaCP) module. DRAG systematically retrieves
supporting information that best fits the debate discussion, while AdaCP
enhances the accuracy and reliability of event extraction by effectively
rejecting less promising answers. Experimental results demonstrate a
significant reduction in the performance gap between supervised approaches and
tuning-free LLM-based methods by 18.1% and 17.8% on ACE05 and 17.9% and 15.2%
on CASIE for event detection and argument extraction respectively. | [
-0.666230619,
-0.8211539388,
0.4621621966,
0.0062624998,
-0.3494832218,
0.1722619534,
-0.4427641034,
-0.5518194437,
0.3661040068,
0.3882882893,
-0.7075029612,
-0.1349303424,
-0.6002271175,
0.1047785878,
-0.0246793088,
0.9748535156,
0.1234384775,
0.0763171017,
-0.0779651031,
-0.2207419872,
-0.2325835824,
-0.2503363192,
-0.8847869635,
-0.1778361797,
0.4348352551,
0.6465072036,
0.3427406549,
0.6846114397,
0.2855772674,
0.3837693036,
-0.4228852093,
0.3983929157,
-0.4013058245,
0.5699790716,
-0.1864815652,
-0.2949216068,
-0.4500150979,
0.0184641574,
0.9108265638,
0.2832213044,
-0.5360326171,
-0.0574025065,
-0.1577295661,
0.748005569,
-0.8576177955,
-0.0782652944,
-1.3349092007,
-0.2509621978,
-0.2305245996,
0.007265063,
-0.3638368249,
-0.2311611176,
0.2542195916,
-0.7947238684,
0.2690281868,
-0.0467703491,
0.9521906376,
0.2803177536,
-0.4123290479,
-0.4408604205,
-0.7098349929,
0.9052451849,
-0.654594183,
0.0887493417,
-0.0341077521,
0.3455875516,
-0.3070738912,
-0.8934496641,
-0.6467775106,
-0.030051671,
0.3753274381,
0.3127171397,
-0.3591045737,
0.0496406443,
-0.0203232076,
0.137126714,
-0.1516421139,
0.3164878488,
-0.4493436515,
-0.0562605448,
0.9321385622,
0.1970940679,
-0.0388141386,
-0.1387140453,
-0.2287196964,
0.0533274263,
-0.336165309,
-0.0311089419,
0.4655219316,
0.2772991657,
0.0746242553,
0.0693948418,
-0.2382350862,
0.4689257443,
0.2961641252,
0.0484974533,
0.0795002282,
-0.2145064026,
0.0271705873,
-0.1899496466,
0.9652321935,
-0.0458895043,
-0.0416074544,
-0.1622913629,
-0.1002744883,
-0.1164538041,
0.4305934012,
-0.7239311934,
-0.2989593446,
0.1925737858,
-0.2659780681,
-0.3605810404,
0.1500750929,
-1.4571572542,
-0.3470747769,
-0.2100832462,
0.0315304659,
-0.0284853317,
-0.3629927635,
0.126540333,
-0.4377928972,
0.1349395812,
0.932675004,
-0.6316510439,
0.4116076529,
0.7233672142,
0.6487342715,
-0.8461815715,
-0.0333299041,
-1.0581507683,
0.2684356868,
-0.2148212492,
1.2889180183,
-1.0904474258,
-0.3804720938,
-0.2807685137,
-0.1409240216,
-0.1258135885,
-0.6684480906,
0.8583323359,
-0.768258512,
0.1554635614,
-0.2998396158,
-0.6516174674,
-0.127433911,
0.0694227964,
-1.0706120729,
0.7818137407,
-0.4799957275,
-0.479357034,
0.3152811825,
-0.8970967531,
-0.2588638067,
0.0298247319,
-0.372604996,
-0.6616821885,
-0.0330344848,
0.4102682471,
0.050118722,
-0.3754476905,
0.1183111966,
-0.6687425971,
0.0007799705,
0.116346702,
-0.1860464662,
0.603053987,
0.4925569296,
-0.3618339598,
0.2876100242,
-1.04322052,
-0.1841436177,
-0.0419750735,
-0.6340400577,
-0.0609224476,
0.5076370835,
-0.0662868246,
0.0088741379,
0.1008296981,
-0.8232315183,
0.3581228554,
-0.527207911,
0.269956708,
1.0726110935,
0.050071165,
0.5512472987,
-0.2132054269,
0.8203234076,
0.1308083385,
-0.1535201967,
0.1816871911,
-0.6520382166,
-0.5384813547,
-0.4581331015,
0.1404659003,
0.335980773,
-0.7252554893,
-0.0032702619,
0.0033280395,
-0.3258857727,
-0.5151254535,
0.1233706772,
0.1631077826,
0.3064823449,
0.1430440545,
-0.0261568762,
-0.6468610764,
-0.4850035906,
-0.3148564696,
-0.395144999,
0.1862015426,
0.3704383075,
0.151872471,
-0.030723827,
0.7913316488,
-0.6801846623,
0.0300790388,
-0.3234643936,
0.4403967261,
-0.0371808819,
0.2074638754,
0.5603729486,
-0.9540146589,
-0.7149491906,
0.4792227149,
-0.227297321,
-0.2354813963,
0.026402235,
-0.1193811446,
0.6183899641,
0.371868968,
-0.4536070228,
0.3979714215,
0.2531250715,
-0.1438304484,
0.6531031132,
0.1726703644,
0.0201547109,
-1.0567003489,
0.0298563614,
-0.1580044925,
-0.1869109273,
-0.6309272647,
0.10506735,
-0.0649403632,
0.0321773663,
-0.1650774628,
0.7322545648,
-0.6085489392,
0.2139341533,
-0.6607191563,
0.4642493725,
0.1678310037,
0.3992927074,
0.2245984226,
0.5636875033,
0.4999575615,
-0.6761059165,
0.4357754886,
0.2693534493,
0.0428975411,
0.3770307899,
-0.3536619842,
0.5860907435,
-0.3303676546,
-0.0374021232,
-1.0914481878,
0.080170311,
0.1377730668,
-0.4124618471,
0.4036665261,
-0.2903310061,
0.1906027198,
-0.2104416937,
-0.5265933275,
0.2940156758,
0.2242164165,
-0.3428760469,
0.6065323353,
0.9758307338,
-0.4667338133,
-0.8778732419,
0.1157375127,
-0.0126865376,
-0.3679418266,
-0.3037634194,
0.0212312415,
-0.1999932826,
-0.2942495942,
-0.1545255035,
-0.2861689329,
-0.3783459961,
0.1201841757,
-0.0619824305,
0.1974889487,
-0.351626873,
0.2644100189,
0.0595948696,
0.1152730063,
-0.1237999499,
-0.1334374547,
0.1429654807,
-0.1923668087,
-0.1459549963,
-0.2405746281,
0.6688959599,
0.3579275906,
-0.2390298247,
0.3943271935,
0.6655008793,
-0.1989200115,
-0.3516890705,
-0.8247821331,
-0.1046075895,
-0.5315599442,
0.4770331085,
-0.4597661197,
-1.0347391367,
0.7448425889,
-0.2502490282,
0.4261142313,
0.6428959966,
0.724116087,
-0.067174904,
0.8087549806,
0.5819692016,
0.0027149564,
0.7040838599,
0.128042087,
-0.4407769442,
-0.755998373,
-0.0870503932,
-0.9940239787,
-0.325399071,
-0.434063226,
-0.3108808994,
0.3385160565,
0.0956878662,
0.033292409,
0.077387847,
-0.4443462789,
0.3931791484,
0.2820413709,
-0.2339582592,
0.4775596559,
-0.0686427951,
-0.000521437,
-0.1496527195,
-0.5791730881,
-0.4676536918,
1.1097146273,
0.0836985186,
0.8157650232,
0.2006500065,
0.6596031189,
0.1137301773,
0.5080701113,
-0.8908286095,
0.4429151714,
-0.1628596038,
-0.7852110267,
-0.5399782658,
-0.5894002914,
-1.2830293179,
0.5757929683,
-0.1252266169,
-0.9962065816,
0.558232367,
-0.050797049,
-0.2190505564,
0.5220488906,
-0.3264142871,
0.6180176735,
0.3359004259,
-0.1141051501,
-0.5286645293,
-0.4840063751,
0.1192941964,
-0.220775947,
0.2564947903,
-0.2015687674,
-0.3022249043,
0.9230272174,
-0.1889887452,
0.4506070316,
-0.0266161971,
-0.0491777062,
0.6199667454,
0.0277524181,
0.60712713,
0.1000593826,
-0.5394641161,
-0.141346395,
0.183635816,
-0.1246731728,
-0.6036376953,
0.4757795632,
-0.9599282146,
-0.9628922939,
-0.1318695098,
-0.4473176599,
-0.0855787769,
-0.0847603977,
-0.0292931963,
0.3964505494,
-0.3591905832,
0.1912216991,
0.3433850706,
0.1291572005,
0.7026262283,
0.9526831508,
0.1321447045,
-0.7223330736,
0.7875642776,
-0.0407787338,
0.1968715191,
0.3386304975,
0.4546274841,
-0.191125527,
-0.716293335,
-0.5566689372,
0.1782840341,
-0.8142971396,
-0.401953578,
-0.9049769044,
-0.0162199717,
-0.3725880384,
0.0881323367,
-0.6325412989,
-0.8349729776,
-0.5681491494,
-0.0495816395,
0.2848055959,
0.9271737933,
-0.2602537572,
0.2417792827,
-0.8150503635,
0.2668165565,
0.2306200415,
0.1153656021,
-0.0133201564,
-0.6463971734,
-0.201101467,
-0.1317695379,
-1.1021739244,
-1.1390852928,
0.336078316,
0.6457722187,
0.9237460494,
0.6639655828,
0.258030206,
0.8236351609,
-0.5743315816,
0.6033734083,
0.0813990906,
-0.8697658777,
0.7988915443,
-0.1868077368,
-0.1438958496,
0.5753649473,
0.4078366458,
-0.2145468444,
-0.6482408047,
-0.6041100621,
-0.6534770131,
1.1923772097,
0.0841021314,
-0.1883655488,
-0.0248235483,
0.6568447351,
0.3503019512,
0.2273020446,
-0.709030509,
-0.2096685618,
0.137021035,
0.0826030225,
0.2470197082,
-0.2188622952,
-0.292178005,
-0.1993416697,
0.5824205875,
-0.3296509981,
0.0290669091,
0.2458328307,
0.23040241,
-0.669033587,
0.2388932556,
0.5943952799,
0.7805793881,
-0.1085932404,
-0.0827516392,
0.2808326185,
-0.5691903234,
0.1445969641,
0.2257846892,
0.0792161226,
0.123717986,
0.1932447404,
0.7391196489,
-0.211767897,
-0.6023144126,
0.2297846973,
-0.192231968,
-0.2509203553,
0.0707832724,
0.1059245542,
0.0118578514,
0.4834704101,
0.4100391865,
-0.1092352793,
0.5239859819,
-0.4190308452,
0.5938228369,
0.7278589606,
-0.4765891731,
-0.4598653018,
0.803191483,
0.4118558764,
-0.2254725546,
0.2749707103,
-0.1349042058,
-0.3367491961,
0.8473563194,
0.3915565014,
1.0562831163,
-0.4436807036,
0.2942611575,
0.3645663857,
0.1076810434,
0.2504805624,
0.2891015708,
-0.0950670689,
-0.9017056227,
-0.5148496032,
-0.6994503736,
-0.6637563705,
0.1843466908,
-0.8143832684,
0.4220542908,
-0.3531883359,
-0.1801340729,
0.4054171145,
0.4402965009,
-0.1415469944,
-0.3185920417,
0.4125858843,
0.7669213414,
-0.5567163825,
0.9301556945,
1.0888006687,
-0.0105926953,
-0.5035687089,
0.0816892609,
0.1300350726,
-0.4229261577,
0.4275535643,
-0.1724177897,
-0.1757377237,
-0.222795099,
-0.4862881899,
-0.903214097,
0.7948789597,
0.7247431278,
-0.4744621217,
0.114437297,
-0.2596077621,
0.3793920875,
-0.427582562,
0.2688494027,
0.3252331614,
0.4612609446,
0.720577836,
-1.0728569031,
-0.0323644355,
-0.1988239437,
-0.2400967926,
0.1364876926,
-0.8794726729,
0.8691323996,
-0.1349708587,
-0.493411243,
0.0767337903,
0.8051187396,
0.2364533693,
0.4445922077,
0.4545546174,
0.2793441415,
0.8525285721,
0.0612566322,
0.774315536,
0.1121772677,
0.3877298236,
0.9932606816,
-0.3639110923,
0.7951487303,
0.453430593,
-0.1834942251,
0.5723885894,
0.5134939551,
0.4552800357,
0.4301323891,
0.0759885237,
-0.3023116887,
-0.5677733421,
0.3322288692,
-0.092669867,
0.6216368079,
0.4296050966,
0.3225024343,
-0.3262603879,
-0.2826184034,
0.0037019823,
0.2038946301,
-0.2211683542,
1.2825418711,
0.1214099973,
-0.8113913536,
0.5826208591,
0.1024018824,
0.3703623116,
-0.5826940536,
-0.0940643102,
-0.1904199868,
0.1712179929,
0.1341883093,
-0.4516605735,
0.4724804759,
-0.2869065106,
-0.0732125342,
0.2072578818,
0.7821017504,
-0.4779621959,
-0.3485468924,
0.2741787732,
0.5664359331,
0.1618293822,
0.0353960954,
-0.9386866093,
0.2092814147,
-0.0052630967,
-0.7056334019,
0.2519530058,
0.8486852646,
-0.0303549636,
0.7600601912,
0.3945801258,
0.3074697256,
0.0425940976,
-0.0974829346,
1.3197768927,
-0.5543022156,
-0.5819318891,
-1.0240002871,
0.3205672801,
-0.2665465772,
-0.1691452861,
0.2704545259,
0.4374020398,
0.364176333,
0.1349539608,
0.5937013626,
0.1903003752,
0.480209142,
-0.3385464251,
0.4575068057,
-0.7962309122,
0.177268669,
-0.4555989206,
-0.5625728965,
-0.0369295478,
0.466119647,
-0.0292787291,
-0.1776173711,
0.6665728092,
0.5863980651,
-0.0249841604,
0.3676074147,
0.1902322769,
0.1169320196,
0.5956882238,
0.556193769,
0.9790155292,
-0.1695473045,
0.8250315189,
0.2535249591,
-0.3378172815,
-0.1771111339,
-0.826888442,
-0.8315801024,
-0.7263872027,
-0.5995315313,
-0.0096728401,
0.1289315075,
0.7416170835,
0.6109300256,
-1.1088173389,
-0.5525988936,
0.1954077333,
0.5671551228,
-0.2516733408,
-0.2486548275,
0.2692678571,
-0.8251250982,
-1.1292403936,
0.4121074677,
0.3698047698,
-0.3104545474,
0.2046672404,
-0.043980822,
-0.4634792805,
0.2866235375,
0.3814253807,
0.414717108,
-0.707493484,
-0.4844087958,
-0.2413831055,
0.0928881019,
0.3675934374,
0.7807243466,
-0.5909298062,
0.6037253737,
0.4651141167,
0.8593173623,
0.7481050491,
0.0873606503,
0.8414416909,
-0.6624906063,
0.2884818614,
0.3068750203,
0.2098107189,
-0.1441295445,
-0.3669787049,
0.3788158894,
0.5070515275,
-0.6645316482,
-0.8940989375,
0.3719213605,
-1.1756424904,
-0.3384415209,
1.3071671724,
-0.2672667205,
-0.0921551287,
-0.4032146931,
-0.3330566287,
0.2391237468,
-0.6849091649,
0.9571193457,
0.7429460287,
-0.2678861916,
-0.2504141927,
-0.3535898924,
0.7882570624,
0.3067609966,
-0.792008996,
0.188594684,
0.5505914688,
0.2293601185,
0.1980115324,
0.7678997517,
-0.1671827286,
0.3096415699,
-0.1407536566,
0.0140110152,
0.1047660634,
-0.3997873962,
-0.3681063354,
0.3970721662,
-0.03714348,
-0.195017904
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12182v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12182v1 | Aqulia-Med LLM: Pioneering Full-Process Open-Source Medical Language Models | 2024-06-18T01:30:07 | 2024-06-18T01:30:07 | Lulu Zhao, Weihao Zeng, Xiaofeng Shi, Hua Zhou, Donglin Hao, Yonghua Lin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recently, both closed-source LLMs and open-source communities have made
significant strides, outperforming humans in various general domains. However,
their performance in specific professional fields such as medicine, especially
within the open-source community, remains suboptimal due to the complexity of
medical knowledge. We propose Aquila-Med, a bilingual medical LLM based on
Aquila, addressing these challenges through continue pre-training, supervised
fine-tuning (SFT), and reinforcement learning from human feedback (RLHF). We
construct a large-scale Chinese and English medical dataset for continue
pre-training and a high-quality SFT dataset, covering extensive medical
specialties. Additionally, we develop a high-quality Direct Preference
Optimization (DPO) dataset for further alignment. Aquila-Med achieves notable
results across single-turn, multi-turn dialogues, and medical multiple-choice
questions, demonstrating the effectiveness of our approach. We open-source the
datasets and the entire training process, contributing valuable resources to
the research community. Our models and datasets will released at
https://huggingface.co/BAAI/AquilaMed-RL. | [
0.0370672718,
-0.5929199457,
0.6496972442,
0.4105385542,
-0.3395064175,
0.0681945011,
-0.5329299569,
-0.3788669109,
0.3851181567,
0.5572871566,
-0.7262613773,
-0.5203318596,
-0.4465534985,
0.0787580311,
0.0649145246,
0.8372359872,
-0.3670288324,
0.8665833473,
0.0112942178,
-0.4388572872,
-0.1073629484,
-0.5687311292,
-1.0271189213,
-0.4041653574,
0.8553888202,
0.4078844488,
0.8524273634,
1.0226908922,
0.2088416368,
0.1481162906,
0.1606699377,
0.2326074392,
-0.4768930972,
0.0915544927,
-0.3219195902,
-0.4646728933,
-0.3573071659,
0.0158321671,
0.4585372508,
0.448014766,
-0.5388217568,
0.0732376501,
-0.3184778094,
0.704821825,
-0.2293889523,
0.0861352831,
-0.4222210348,
0.223328203,
-0.1142687723,
-0.2173300833,
-0.1073362231,
-0.663369298,
0.1947588623,
-0.7352941036,
-0.2189693004,
0.066470243,
0.8532208204,
0.3987512887,
-0.3044748902,
-0.4170980453,
-0.6653612256,
0.7842515111,
-0.7441945672,
0.4031204879,
0.1938040107,
0.2550983429,
-0.2368867397,
-0.4674936235,
-0.2949165106,
-0.3230799437,
0.1757830828,
0.1814662963,
-0.0970314145,
0.0925933942,
-0.1589746773,
0.3978126347,
-0.3988499343,
0.4853411615,
-0.4583982527,
-0.0299827866,
0.4053236246,
0.2384744138,
0.5342959166,
0.5690014958,
-0.4349074364,
0.2183633298,
-0.8465479016,
0.1184296757,
-0.0660840124,
0.0577186085,
-0.2360402495,
0.592502296,
-0.1403800994,
0.3710022569,
-0.2533690333,
-0.152653873,
0.3199746609,
-0.1842465997,
-0.2429154813,
-0.0646474734,
1.2059599161,
-0.0128393639,
0.2914478481,
-0.3035925031,
-0.0573086403,
-0.1043271497,
0.23030743,
-0.8231393099,
-0.3023920655,
0.5613399744,
-0.465192169,
-0.3515485525,
-0.3732570112,
-0.3529325128,
-0.3986849189,
-0.5284618735,
0.4084501863,
-0.3588925898,
-0.2250273377,
0.366247952,
0.4726450741,
-0.0292313248,
0.4989601374,
-0.6925905943,
0.3065434098,
0.3846545517,
0.791875422,
-0.4912632704,
-0.4252602756,
-0.3683715761,
-0.0432133675,
-0.3140039444,
0.63363868,
-0.1178644449,
-0.3573276699,
-0.0691346526,
0.1778013408,
-0.0697940439,
-0.6636709571,
0.4628553689,
-0.3060074449,
0.3945582509,
-0.2098690718,
-0.2207721472,
-0.086391449,
0.3040032983,
-0.6008974314,
0.4380631149,
0.1578027159,
-0.7214850783,
0.0735526979,
-0.5982676148,
-0.3313884139,
-0.0590830296,
-0.3583290577,
-0.443815887,
-0.1256315559,
0.3373831213,
-0.0136525966,
-0.7342404723,
0.5061265826,
-0.2543008327,
-0.2075557411,
0.3695836961,
-0.2965092659,
1.1130335331,
0.1467485428,
0.0821246505,
0.5975051522,
-0.6028234959,
-0.1224041805,
0.1306727678,
-0.5915313959,
-0.0652913898,
0.1701464951,
-0.1013151482,
0.5764975548,
0.376606971,
-0.8306120634,
0.206247434,
-0.5743753314,
0.4861047864,
0.5571968555,
0.0173152331,
0.2306557298,
-0.5201711059,
0.7266296148,
0.0957053602,
0.6594306827,
0.1159613132,
-0.5529543161,
-0.595975101,
-0.7414918542,
0.3695223331,
1.0016605854,
-0.7705180049,
0.0955092832,
0.0323842876,
-0.304977566,
-1.1993424892,
0.2745891809,
0.3988212645,
0.7806391716,
0.5119870901,
-0.4369607568,
-0.3809348345,
-0.9489859343,
0.0726536363,
-0.2392226607,
-0.1483562887,
0.4128707647,
0.0940328985,
-0.583915174,
0.7679203749,
-0.477569133,
-0.5306985378,
0.0163746048,
-0.124951005,
0.3187951446,
0.3507745564,
0.4250328243,
-0.4372298717,
-0.3385184705,
0.1940103024,
-0.7570011616,
-0.2386753261,
0.3010415435,
-0.4744507968,
0.1196652427,
0.0947566032,
-0.4673839211,
-0.0451132692,
0.640776217,
-0.1969809085,
0.4858950675,
-0.527893126,
0.2591642141,
-1.2268785238,
0.1192866713,
-0.1824734956,
0.0231547616,
-0.6298273206,
0.0126847988,
0.1122710183,
-0.043104548,
-0.7760896087,
0.725407958,
-0.0161501393,
0.3207599819,
-0.1952560395,
-0.2817642093,
-0.2781215012,
0.4983899593,
0.2144776732,
0.6211618185,
0.6534072161,
-0.4172829092,
0.6118300557,
0.3095435798,
-0.0456925668,
0.2769624889,
-0.6137068272,
-0.1208920479,
-0.0490821823,
0.1130102202,
-0.5089841485,
-0.2618828118,
0.3484167755,
-0.3596171141,
0.0068621538,
0.0073562902,
-0.5345814824,
-0.2960853875,
-0.3425576389,
0.4551754594,
0.3691105247,
-0.5759682059,
0.2456420958,
0.4716206491,
-0.3072420359,
-0.4703085721,
-0.486918807,
-0.1381980926,
0.1646103263,
-0.4932169616,
0.0838278159,
-0.1867919862,
-0.1288992614,
0.1510580927,
0.221546039,
-0.4477964044,
-0.0588154569,
0.0913336948,
0.4858233929,
-0.3411500156,
0.3101682365,
0.2704846561,
0.0449563712,
0.0603743792,
-0.3661878705,
0.3050560355,
0.1150202155,
-0.2150080651,
-0.3969756663,
0.2608882189,
0.6113980412,
-0.5066146255,
0.6744238138,
0.3575671911,
-0.4052222371,
-0.0840647519,
-0.4268817604,
0.0926998556,
-0.3575973213,
0.2140347511,
0.144964397,
-1.0310851336,
0.5389760137,
-0.0538208149,
0.2885164618,
0.2737293541,
0.9665261507,
-0.1729811728,
0.994354248,
0.3780535161,
-0.1414401233,
0.3368619978,
0.1098066419,
-0.1357936114,
-0.3777717352,
-0.4275526404,
-0.2760836482,
-0.0601527877,
-0.4480979145,
-0.6040859818,
0.6640239358,
-0.0883641243,
-0.2209926099,
-0.1874911785,
-0.2890509665,
0.2672106624,
0.5711081028,
0.4873384833,
0.4999763668,
-0.2461382896,
-0.321644634,
0.0492947958,
-0.5890276432,
-0.1062474176,
1.1561501026,
0.5348437428,
0.8295570612,
-0.0395902134,
0.7235459089,
-0.0569235496,
0.5521401763,
-1.0019030571,
0.2110731155,
-0.4091465175,
-0.4397338927,
-0.3928806186,
-0.6320625544,
-1.0754556656,
0.2586645782,
-0.4162507653,
-0.2152929008,
-0.1494763047,
0.2183950096,
-0.3982290328,
0.3185324967,
-0.4172644913,
0.804432869,
-0.5087949634,
-0.373390466,
-0.1957101077,
-0.5623723865,
0.6461960673,
-0.344291538,
0.4116165042,
-0.30972296,
-0.2981011569,
0.3442161977,
-0.4174915552,
0.6004959941,
-0.1051327363,
-0.2757428288,
0.0827809796,
-0.0272602215,
0.0266700145,
0.2778362632,
0.0578434616,
0.2678373456,
0.0698538646,
-0.4891090691,
-0.3509749472,
0.7633731365,
-0.9655454159,
-0.414960593,
-0.2880302072,
-0.4835314751,
-0.5248181224,
0.2377991825,
0.2115441859,
0.2723611593,
-0.3637300134,
-0.0985275432,
0.8577964306,
-0.6519882679,
-0.1318934262,
1.0370361805,
-0.3597799242,
-0.7157060504,
0.8224382401,
-0.0345172398,
-0.1126004606,
0.3207449019,
0.3971426785,
-0.2250964195,
-0.5411186814,
-0.8698384762,
0.4945579171,
-0.1930297613,
-0.1050454453,
-0.603362143,
-0.4077455997,
-0.2606782317,
-0.012621888,
-0.3957170248,
-0.3087357581,
-0.367749095,
0.1722640991,
0.2236815989,
0.7872952223,
0.1392102242,
-0.0254912842,
-0.9666969776,
0.5429035425,
0.2864952981,
0.6573220491,
-0.1035598367,
-0.206439212,
-0.4696887434,
0.0644487441,
-0.1976462901,
-0.9189372063,
0.5522924066,
-0.0434073098,
0.6892827153,
0.2775755525,
-0.1932523698,
0.1916527003,
-0.6903889775,
0.5653218627,
0.3075323701,
-0.4262459576,
0.7556353807,
-0.4681319594,
0.463429302,
0.659470439,
0.6280531287,
-0.3956750333,
-0.5920758843,
-0.0705280602,
-0.619196713,
0.7898533344,
-0.0315774493,
-0.1783427745,
-0.0165144894,
0.2360681444,
0.1614366025,
0.278837949,
-0.5343668461,
-0.1198909655,
-0.0037797221,
-0.425691098,
-0.0404537842,
0.019417597,
-0.4447781146,
-0.4887154996,
0.8303006887,
-0.0263743605,
-0.0461806692,
0.2091753632,
0.0624158643,
-0.2588229179,
0.3480866253,
0.6080094576,
0.5289590955,
-0.0617626533,
-0.320340246,
0.0603667311,
-0.5623398423,
0.2900849581,
0.162991643,
-0.1555315256,
-0.0935321674,
0.081378907,
0.6238998771,
0.234379828,
-1.0887949467,
0.5198040605,
-0.1925396323,
-0.3409599066,
-0.1379692852,
-0.0988648161,
0.008373661,
0.2806043327,
0.0782169849,
-0.1764071882,
0.1608400941,
-0.4811299145,
0.1562488824,
0.174982205,
-0.5248558521,
-0.3424745798,
0.7576903105,
0.2273000479,
-0.0614971109,
0.4220009148,
0.1029305384,
-0.2893304229,
0.4388632178,
0.4066858292,
0.7905513048,
-0.4719254076,
0.2062827349,
0.4251537323,
0.138185665,
-0.5123226643,
0.5393592715,
0.1015388072,
-0.6100117564,
-0.3997467458,
-0.6612701416,
-0.8383781314,
0.0928461552,
-0.6398566365,
0.3724731505,
-0.5685273409,
-0.1101293936,
-0.3808170557,
-0.0354304761,
-0.3925228119,
0.2975064814,
-0.09360715,
0.8210419416,
-0.6317700744,
1.2569419146,
0.8781782389,
-0.4536257684,
-0.650254488,
-0.1634429097,
0.0292794202,
-0.9260902405,
0.1724828333,
-0.2784594595,
-0.0620264113,
-0.2063843906,
-0.4123154581,
-0.6942614317,
1.1175019741,
0.7295300364,
-0.4034968019,
-0.3949387074,
-0.0915463343,
0.8443855643,
-0.419100672,
-0.0628420785,
0.4838697612,
0.0009601315,
0.1446088552,
-1.3135871887,
-0.0516259521,
-0.1680536121,
-0.253679812,
0.0886948556,
-0.9146526456,
0.7941101193,
-0.3789688945,
-0.0368664972,
0.1183524653,
0.2766254246,
0.4150617123,
0.1748304665,
0.2306443602,
0.5328009725,
0.6789834499,
0.0391395353,
0.724686563,
-0.5972876549,
0.0469713435,
1.016271472,
-0.1596709639,
0.9976101518,
0.4112261236,
-0.1274521649,
0.3937058747,
0.5421746969,
0.1481047422,
0.4314942956,
0.2609328628,
-0.5068675876,
-0.1154491752,
-0.3076417446,
-0.3967989981,
0.322889775,
0.4465983212,
-0.5449932218,
-0.0030614117,
0.0753611252,
0.0624911562,
0.1142311692,
-0.3844488561,
0.864205718,
0.1763903946,
-0.7562716603,
0.4793312848,
0.0688708723,
0.7161363363,
-0.8283133507,
0.1686652303,
-0.3046499491,
-0.0797290131,
-0.1741534024,
-0.4884190261,
0.0681059286,
-0.0370322391,
-0.1744151115,
-0.2259132564,
0.4452555478,
-0.8692436814,
-0.4141325653,
0.4443285465,
0.6152379513,
-0.0313780531,
0.2746724486,
-0.6054289937,
-0.1519830823,
-0.116287671,
-0.0270623993,
0.4626919925,
0.4125877023,
-0.074915044,
0.7215451002,
0.6532952189,
0.6396605372,
0.0415909477,
0.140705511,
1.0333846807,
-0.4567109942,
-0.4548853934,
-0.6095731258,
-0.0407466926,
0.3054806888,
-0.3456314206,
0.2821113765,
0.7282822132,
0.6365996003,
-0.1511025429,
0.653845787,
0.5545387268,
0.7767934203,
-0.5636547208,
0.9601249695,
-0.5622509718,
0.0297351517,
0.3989230096,
-0.5228101015,
-0.2911776602,
0.244203493,
0.1352121085,
-0.3092924356,
0.4486048222,
0.6648374796,
0.1083683744,
-0.2000315636,
0.3571957052,
0.389834553,
0.1521827281,
0.9695101976,
0.7001653314,
0.034028329,
0.4584143758,
-0.1068249568,
-0.5034915209,
0.0058819912,
-0.4759649336,
-0.8204327226,
-0.1472115368,
-0.1776573807,
-0.3166527152,
0.1052822247,
1.4196047783,
0.4811534286,
-0.9141976237,
-0.4146240056,
0.2797560096,
-0.0771024078,
-0.0279803555,
-0.0986897573,
0.1893406212,
-0.4550330937,
-0.5729392171,
0.6282453537,
0.4651126266,
0.0685423389,
-0.5419186354,
-0.2547851503,
-0.1141657829,
0.2697851062,
0.4353693724,
0.7135673165,
-0.762549758,
0.2826319933,
0.1198832467,
-0.4846895635,
0.126786232,
0.8749133348,
-0.6872864366,
0.6756188869,
0.2887434661,
0.6348583102,
0.3153296411,
-0.1742040217,
0.8896118999,
-0.3088494539,
0.0472489521,
0.4281256795,
0.2876747549,
-0.0141985491,
-0.2011395544,
0.4732592106,
0.0709982589,
-0.4217372239,
-0.5957875848,
0.0919088423,
-0.8570567369,
-0.2614972293,
1.1821116209,
-0.3129480481,
-0.1159710065,
-0.2005141526,
-0.6019213796,
0.4812874794,
-0.3949358165,
0.8562030792,
0.5803982019,
-0.3294650018,
-0.0005466284,
-0.6172800064,
0.6745527983,
0.3390874863,
-0.9096630216,
-0.2780215144,
0.4179761112,
0.443148315,
-0.3147962987,
1.3354173899,
-0.4412324727,
0.4299728572,
-0.6105268598,
0.1933223009,
-0.1743027419,
-0.2691443563,
-0.5298054814,
0.0926894173,
0.3424045742,
-0.245486334
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12168v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12168v2 | BPO: Supercharging Online Preference Learning by Adhering to the Proximity of Behavior LLM | 2024-06-18T00:41:40 | 2024-06-19T05:25:27 | Wenda Xu, Jiachen Li, William Yang Wang, Lei Li | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Direct alignment from preferences (DAP) has emerged as a promising paradigm
for aligning large language models (LLMs) to human desiderata from
pre-collected, offline preference datasets. While recent studies indicate that
existing offline DAP methods can directly benefit from online training samples,
we highlight the need to develop specific online DAP algorithms to fully
harness the power of online training. Specifically, we identify that the
learned LLM should adhere to the proximity of the behavior LLM, which collects
the training samples. To this end, we propose online Preference Optimization in
proximity to the Behavior LLM (BPO), emphasizing the importance of constructing
a proper trust region for LLM alignment.
We conduct extensive experiments to validate the effectiveness and
applicability of our approach by integrating it with various DAP methods,
resulting in significant performance improvements across a wide range of tasks
when training with the same amount of preference data. Even when only
introducing one additional data collection phase, our online BPO improves its
offline DAP baseline from 72.0% to 80.2% on TL;DR and from 82.2% to 89.1% on
Anthropic Helpfulness in terms of win rate against human reference text. | [
-0.5664548278,
-0.4328991771,
0.6268063784,
-0.0928820893,
-0.0896485671,
0.0332807489,
-0.2140299976,
-0.6143444777,
0.3798556328,
0.2457521558,
-0.671777308,
-0.0871408731,
-0.4960431755,
-0.0388401076,
0.3333554268,
0.9559008479,
0.1442387551,
0.0913457051,
-0.3825278282,
0.0692219362,
-0.337828666,
-0.8538993597,
-0.7356744409,
-0.4074454904,
0.2480429262,
0.4132920504,
0.5072342157,
0.9178878665,
0.4628057778,
0.2949790061,
-0.0416342355,
0.5085052252,
-0.6579546332,
0.0919412076,
-0.1138190106,
-0.4294332564,
-0.7322586775,
-0.0042260652,
0.3379139006,
0.4858659208,
-0.3484638929,
0.051001139,
0.0785060972,
1.092746973,
-0.5980178118,
0.0691341087,
-0.6878860593,
0.1458396763,
0.0960860252,
-0.1942158937,
-0.1204344183,
-0.7400941253,
0.6296905875,
-0.7342661619,
0.0311235897,
0.1387574822,
1.0653650761,
0.4107300043,
-0.2816322744,
-0.0806970373,
-0.581377089,
0.8702569604,
-0.4814487696,
0.4188030362,
0.6400695443,
0.0687351227,
-0.2444607317,
-0.1748859584,
-0.6341516972,
0.0201734342,
0.294664681,
0.0135332467,
0.0842430592,
0.211288318,
0.0056573972,
0.2497258931,
-0.1382150352,
0.1784322113,
0.1492798775,
0.0325732306,
0.6263281703,
-0.1336847097,
-0.0377077684,
0.2135302573,
-0.3814214468,
-0.0644347966,
-0.4637721181,
0.2854036689,
0.5406848192,
0.3286525011,
-0.1159569547,
0.308870852,
-0.0088264607,
0.7473663688,
0.8339383602,
-0.2927463651,
0.3027105033,
-0.3082383871,
0.0561033264,
0.2146804333,
0.4832765758,
0.7419435382,
0.305295676,
-0.2648317814,
0.0475580618,
-0.1070603505,
0.5368682146,
-0.5570804477,
0.1472905427,
0.5128406882,
-0.2832014859,
-0.2914265394,
0.0634820461,
-0.7191127539,
-0.4932880402,
-0.7511770725,
0.1928883046,
-0.1706885993,
-0.2271184921,
0.0465128943,
-0.0479578711,
0.3104369938,
0.1611519158,
-1.4542570114,
0.3055348992,
0.859860301,
0.975812912,
-0.4467132092,
-0.0936901644,
-0.6701693535,
0.3943733871,
-0.2816064656,
0.770788908,
-0.6380752325,
-0.2620432973,
0.2155545205,
-0.3557555974,
0.0933068693,
-0.6497927904,
0.6037968397,
-0.6409469247,
0.1223968416,
-0.4141539037,
-0.8641006947,
0.0033367367,
0.2897386551,
-0.4460969567,
1.0588366985,
-0.0897358358,
-0.6403844357,
0.559694171,
-0.7439523935,
-0.1315248907,
-0.4942674935,
-0.1270431727,
-0.5256040096,
0.134207651,
0.2430071086,
0.5239991546,
0.1757843345,
0.0995169133,
-0.650859952,
-0.2361827791,
0.1935238242,
0.3482452333,
0.6039323807,
0.0072676903,
-0.593963027,
0.2500366569,
-0.6037969589,
-0.0175987538,
0.0529910028,
-0.2192174792,
-0.5645163059,
0.0959167331,
-0.3430863619,
0.3561933041,
0.4810177386,
-0.6845727563,
0.5060937405,
-0.7254671454,
0.2401451319,
1.3570433855,
-0.2721827626,
0.6869641542,
-0.4880595505,
0.3869365752,
-0.337113142,
0.3006663024,
0.5279935002,
-0.3693356514,
-0.5322239995,
-0.3964150846,
0.0246752258,
0.3253238201,
-0.2902229428,
1.0113910437,
-0.4541217387,
-0.2872807086,
-0.5471845865,
0.1230660602,
0.4201192856,
0.6926951408,
0.3336844444,
-0.4395470619,
-0.4712694883,
-0.8190094829,
-0.0285026841,
-0.0168316439,
-0.0251490641,
0.542465806,
-0.1436050534,
-0.2334417552,
1.3458565474,
-0.6762430072,
-0.6094844341,
-0.1810428649,
-0.2412047833,
0.0827892497,
0.1209398806,
0.5793523192,
-0.8073707819,
-0.7271596193,
-0.1118610725,
-0.3656818271,
-0.2090229243,
0.2588510215,
-0.3028688729,
0.6188765764,
0.0446264707,
-0.2675027549,
-0.1162828729,
0.7875151038,
-0.0583408102,
0.1351566762,
-0.4196236134,
0.2039812952,
-1.1449759007,
-0.0310488306,
0.0181767195,
-0.2260024101,
-0.7097836137,
0.0041892338,
-0.1949570626,
0.0949968472,
-0.3896963298,
0.5185582638,
-0.4096287191,
-0.2459037602,
-0.4300083816,
0.3459631503,
-0.1284732521,
0.5599191785,
0.5992011428,
0.5925742984,
0.4425289929,
-0.872682631,
0.3126701117,
0.478161484,
0.0302065555,
0.5875342488,
-0.2946518064,
0.6576941013,
-0.066920653,
0.2615000606,
-0.8641622066,
-0.1218048185,
0.1155831665,
-0.2826773822,
0.4052706063,
-0.2022704482,
-0.1521404833,
0.1423172951,
-0.643661201,
0.2511000335,
0.4412758946,
-0.8082178831,
0.4790571332,
0.8870472312,
-0.0666892603,
-0.7031243443,
-0.2878107727,
-0.3979019821,
-0.3927464783,
-0.4485552609,
0.4189456403,
-0.0981970727,
-0.2302702367,
-0.5690490007,
-0.2364282012,
-0.0804793835,
0.0598176271,
0.3574519455,
0.4222048521,
0.3518874943,
0.0271020737,
-0.2450970262,
-0.2821196616,
-0.0571792349,
-0.4063660502,
0.7334287167,
-0.0338534638,
-0.1121787056,
-0.5174164176,
0.2524707615,
0.127157703,
0.0350887328,
0.7557207942,
0.2368737608,
-0.1580271125,
-0.106973052,
-0.5975244045,
-0.3272633553,
-0.548371613,
0.1557891667,
-0.3218363822,
-0.6379861236,
0.1022859514,
0.0420731977,
0.146527186,
-0.1666926295,
0.4193151891,
-0.2756040394,
0.931229949,
0.8939114213,
-0.3855749071,
0.845995605,
-0.039400775,
0.1393427551,
-0.68542099,
-0.2065643221,
-0.4377439618,
-0.3269640505,
-0.6207458973,
-0.3174737096,
0.365247041,
-0.1130079702,
-0.1841659844,
0.2966704667,
-0.4746055901,
0.4046289921,
0.7030993104,
0.4242399037,
0.274310261,
0.363768518,
-0.0469397306,
-0.4527111053,
-0.4805290103,
-0.4642711878,
1.3848922253,
0.3129564822,
0.3070108593,
0.2134834975,
0.8575179577,
0.2483507693,
0.0428555086,
-0.9883545637,
0.4458917975,
0.0053042984,
-0.5115531683,
-0.2705092132,
-0.2849026918,
-0.9688634872,
-0.076485768,
-0.210872978,
-0.7414089441,
0.0771689862,
0.6694673896,
-0.4843171835,
0.2430933416,
-0.6960886121,
0.6943436265,
-0.3854380548,
-0.5762194991,
-0.4457319379,
-0.7793744802,
-0.0151613681,
-0.1549331695,
0.2396073192,
-0.0709285885,
-0.2990659773,
0.535811007,
-0.2763889134,
0.6257205606,
-0.1804273725,
-0.2950151563,
-0.1070350334,
-0.0709845573,
0.6874725819,
-0.3982875645,
-0.1908048987,
0.4430056512,
-0.0909077823,
-0.4353747666,
-0.5237883329,
0.7093029022,
-1.0014599562,
-0.5546372533,
-0.6755108237,
-0.3786607683,
-0.6998972297,
-0.1438081264,
-0.0171701536,
0.1833715737,
0.0772164986,
-0.0494994,
0.7967865467,
-0.0158639271,
0.3551718295,
0.5489398241,
-0.1391688734,
-0.4262507558,
1.0586358309,
-0.062486168,
0.527461946,
0.7198837996,
0.4942851961,
-0.8053315282,
-0.510273397,
-0.2370194495,
0.228872478,
-0.4015854001,
0.2121392936,
-0.4779171944,
0.3951661885,
-0.5188208818,
-0.4537951052,
-0.4515679181,
-0.2162532657,
-0.235987395,
-0.0607599057,
0.2619996071,
0.4596815705,
-0.2270009518,
0.1835694462,
-0.8212604523,
0.4609120488,
0.3734886944,
0.4414710104,
-0.1806851923,
-0.7730406523,
-0.2031672746,
0.0840670913,
-0.4366278052,
-0.6634978056,
0.3074308038,
0.2661552727,
0.6026626825,
0.8708438277,
0.2355944514,
0.9318038225,
-0.4672152698,
0.5003390312,
0.120628193,
-0.8851121664,
0.6011267304,
-0.3932057321,
-0.1723284125,
0.742805779,
1.0752818584,
-0.3644910753,
-0.0318280868,
-0.5766156316,
-0.7675791979,
0.8358878493,
-0.0056631761,
0.0554032326,
0.1534813046,
0.5141466856,
0.2005063295,
0.4359879494,
-0.6394276023,
-0.5414844751,
-0.1130271703,
-0.1531282514,
-0.029933922,
-0.1060904488,
-0.2288890779,
-0.0663808659,
0.8675671816,
-0.3159002662,
0.1916212887,
0.0914591327,
0.2682790756,
-0.1459334642,
0.0750292316,
0.3714224398,
0.7862334847,
-0.5831840634,
-0.1378432512,
-0.025742162,
-0.4222774506,
0.2923598886,
-0.0444913581,
-0.2436477989,
-0.4820695817,
-0.0767136589,
0.4301442504,
-0.128011167,
-0.6676673889,
0.4761389196,
-0.0096355276,
0.1211470887,
-0.2566476762,
0.1179483905,
-0.0738322437,
0.0743634552,
0.2111706138,
-0.1022939757,
0.1629586816,
-0.636983335,
0.1589787751,
0.7398286462,
-0.4987410307,
-0.1727783829,
0.4517074525,
0.575822711,
-0.2437883615,
0.2735241055,
-0.1601978242,
-0.4734698236,
0.4065279365,
0.4408013225,
0.8280548453,
-0.1911845952,
0.0796812549,
0.4031049907,
-0.1458238363,
-0.1172814593,
0.0499980561,
-0.2435762733,
-1.003621459,
-0.2450087816,
-0.6807649732,
-0.7357812524,
0.0683781803,
-0.7369401455,
0.411296308,
-0.6124599576,
-0.2683702111,
-0.2992636263,
0.1633252203,
-0.1886695772,
0.1037211269,
0.2693014145,
0.3410163522,
-0.6234431863,
0.8481837511,
0.7648142576,
-0.2163227946,
-0.6087722182,
0.335372299,
0.2023482621,
-0.9892462492,
0.5892346501,
0.2120034099,
-0.377112776,
0.2267160416,
-0.2852414548,
-0.8887601495,
0.797955811,
0.5328784585,
-0.8206916451,
-0.0943410024,
-0.0101767089,
0.4502388239,
-0.3524459004,
0.3425217867,
0.5543192029,
0.3000757098,
-0.0596893877,
-1.1389209032,
-0.0145507976,
0.2713672519,
-0.127291441,
0.2979581058,
-0.9446689487,
0.0788963288,
-0.3003518283,
-0.0093463063,
-0.2860185504,
0.5349166989,
0.4206856489,
0.0408204421,
0.6322300434,
0.569568038,
0.6585440636,
-0.0110719241,
0.956500113,
-0.301047951,
0.1969796121,
1.2118140459,
-0.5003852248,
0.9442047477,
0.7988630533,
-0.3928106427,
0.2877113819,
0.9635198116,
0.1961514503,
0.6723939776,
0.1035571098,
-0.2388737798,
-0.2881935239,
-0.5334696174,
-0.4680708051,
0.3242004812,
-0.1212761849,
-0.0205671843,
0.2303733975,
-0.3242499232,
-0.0331222787,
0.3557696044,
-0.3685127497,
1.0463505983,
-0.1454667002,
-0.798491776,
0.4866318107,
-0.1822483987,
0.8234112859,
-0.9046491385,
0.0952539071,
-0.2706153989,
0.4390619397,
-0.2727560997,
-0.4288289845,
0.2684687972,
-0.2216385901,
-0.197241351,
-0.4944148958,
0.2778682709,
-0.3085859418,
0.0001789092,
0.5871244669,
0.2083659023,
0.1271166205,
-0.2047065645,
-0.5712742209,
-0.1482903212,
0.0096656149,
-0.1119492128,
0.8154249191,
0.1071119159,
0.2774801552,
0.7670063972,
0.75140661,
0.3022212982,
-0.0443728305,
-0.058433868,
0.7184605002,
-0.362881124,
-0.7886735797,
-0.8739914298,
0.0973152071,
-0.1818094701,
-0.2725256383,
0.8330857754,
0.6959071755,
1.1491209269,
-0.0916352049,
0.6750679016,
-0.0042138631,
0.6035618782,
-0.5060540438,
0.3670505583,
-0.5634565353,
-0.0040973327,
-0.3436038196,
-1.0676646233,
0.1181499436,
0.6654615402,
-0.4241303504,
-0.0657871962,
0.6026768088,
0.6989975572,
0.0185288563,
-0.1998320818,
0.2413488179,
-0.1994679868,
0.1118855178,
0.5402194262,
0.4534668028,
-0.0441183932,
0.5611360073,
-0.4815476239,
-0.4773111939,
-0.2307903469,
-1.2091767788,
-0.9189040065,
-0.5118162036,
-0.3106019497,
-0.4020477831,
0.0103561953,
1.6931855679,
0.9012727141,
-0.862650156,
-0.3845964372,
-0.1281355768,
-0.0226819701,
-0.4178583324,
-0.1971708983,
0.3463904858,
-0.3933954835,
-1.1254441738,
0.2791854441,
0.1900111586,
0.1606396586,
-0.1425029486,
-0.3673251569,
-0.3559318185,
0.0093355021,
0.4740463495,
0.2739162147,
-0.6696495414,
-0.3311045766,
0.0797092393,
-0.0626031533,
0.3924641311,
0.8171662688,
-0.4427732527,
0.6907220483,
0.4924404323,
0.9827053547,
0.406047076,
0.4993535578,
0.8730854988,
-0.7098425627,
0.0450857729,
0.1113546938,
0.1552792639,
0.258259356,
-0.4890009761,
0.3483346105,
0.3274751604,
-0.7028480768,
-0.5150361657,
0.3247287571,
-1.1131558418,
-0.0689484924,
1.2980378866,
-0.2592933476,
-0.0498563685,
-0.4394796789,
-0.3981878459,
0.2843212783,
-0.8595470786,
1.4710767269,
0.7277029157,
-0.6434755921,
0.1938583553,
-0.2347529083,
0.9196718335,
0.5239374638,
-0.9864123464,
0.0568905286,
0.5440081358,
0.1437065303,
0.191656962,
0.7284965515,
0.2880866826,
-0.0096109034,
-0.4130714536,
0.2060237676,
-0.1291798651,
-0.1825817674,
-0.5654767156,
0.1842053533,
0.1164681762,
-0.4480853677
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12165v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12165v1 | Statistical Uncertainty in Word Embeddings: GloVe-V | 2024-06-18T00:35:02 | 2024-06-18T00:35:02 | Andrea Vallebueno, Cassandra Handan-Nader, Christopher D. Manning, Daniel E. Ho | cs.CL | cs.CL | Static word embeddings are ubiquitous in computational social science
applications and contribute to practical decision-making in a variety of fields
including law and healthcare. However, assessing the statistical uncertainty in
downstream conclusions drawn from word embedding statistics has remained
challenging. When using only point estimates for embeddings, researchers have
no streamlined way of assessing the degree to which their model selection
criteria or scientific conclusions are subject to noise due to sparsity in the
underlying data used to generate the embeddings. We introduce a method to
obtain approximate, easy-to-use, and scalable reconstruction error variance
estimates for GloVe (Pennington et al., 2014), one of the most widely used word
embedding models, using an analytical approximation to a multivariate normal
model. To demonstrate the value of embeddings with variance (GloVe-V), we
illustrate how our approach enables principled hypothesis testing in core word
embedding tasks, such as comparing the similarity between different word pairs
in vector space, assessing the performance of different models, and analyzing
the relative degree of ethnic or gender bias in a corpus using different word
lists. | [
-0.1589565128,
-0.9659944773,
0.5931869149,
0.1265976578,
-0.2014659196,
0.1359587908,
-0.0575299151,
-0.1251094043,
0.285390228,
0.18665497,
-0.3426093459,
-0.7591894865,
-0.9839764833,
-0.1567990184,
-0.3272871375,
0.3452005684,
-0.1640578508,
0.2757924199,
-0.353782177,
-0.2847808897,
-0.2872354984,
-0.1973778456,
0.1022316813,
0.2221103758,
0.0109264608,
0.3766572773,
0.9375072122,
0.4869998395,
0.3892057538,
0.1851775795,
0.2366669923,
0.2340458184,
-0.2628215253,
0.2028184533,
0.105184868,
-0.5426258445,
-0.4222765267,
0.1307264119,
0.2482548654,
1.0121538639,
-0.0613974221,
0.3170522153,
0.0837741494,
0.3311517537,
-1.0703103542,
0.0595416799,
-0.4103695154,
0.2056975216,
-0.1815155596,
-0.0661106855,
-0.2545005381,
-0.3646816611,
0.2240702063,
-0.5560629964,
0.504519105,
0.3565149605,
0.6248838902,
0.2446950823,
-0.0763389319,
-0.3863651454,
-0.5437033772,
0.8871251345,
-0.5065039992,
0.6964613199,
0.9425520301,
-0.114269577,
-0.137027815,
-0.267285496,
-0.398431927,
-0.3308829665,
0.2711388171,
0.2024093866,
-0.2319613546,
-0.1794808358,
0.1131210402,
0.0318243317,
-0.2947930694,
-0.1293424517,
-0.1936764568,
-0.2250246704,
0.5940944552,
-0.0538600944,
0.2958020568,
0.031751208,
-0.1101732999,
-0.2883351743,
-0.4550360739,
-0.0298239309,
0.6049044132,
0.2579861283,
-0.2869283259,
0.8628176451,
0.0829298496,
0.4825505614,
-0.0649965107,
-0.0463349782,
0.4125924408,
-0.1701226234,
-0.0931266397,
-0.1946781725,
0.4819360971,
0.5913341045,
-0.0650928169,
-0.2149662822,
0.1006347239,
0.0450524762,
0.3943734765,
-0.2532627583,
-0.1048304737,
0.3110808134,
-0.3130976558,
-0.281765759,
0.3412459791,
-0.9875326157,
-0.7311769128,
-0.1047678515,
0.4561264515,
-0.4417927265,
-0.2038910389,
0.3004606962,
-0.5645693541,
0.1916953921,
0.3320128322,
-0.4431630671,
0.5719327927,
0.5741827488,
0.7419584394,
-0.0425925404,
-0.0236204322,
-0.3087887168,
-0.0234696381,
-0.6934565306,
0.4789824486,
-0.668251574,
-0.8834035993,
0.2297901362,
-0.2524184287,
0.1665397286,
-0.1233149618,
0.6216244102,
-0.0934450775,
-0.2068734914,
-0.6586040854,
-0.8088863492,
0.0520737655,
0.1308403611,
-0.490211606,
1.0195753574,
0.238361761,
-1.2186675072,
0.7713001966,
-0.1203899384,
-0.1151576266,
-0.2395693809,
-0.2412037402,
-0.7191878557,
0.4351525605,
0.3620982468,
0.7496888638,
-0.256745249,
-0.3063430786,
-1.1905972958,
-0.2929846346,
0.535132885,
-0.3190156221,
0.4955222309,
-0.119947888,
-0.3943594694,
-0.2332588881,
-0.6153622866,
-0.2046599537,
-0.0828461871,
0.4795996845,
-0.7126080394,
0.3694788516,
-0.0835728943,
-0.33641994,
0.123837091,
-0.6658331752,
0.1258796453,
0.1240720153,
-0.0731183663,
0.590284884,
-0.0464159586,
0.5093862414,
-0.3594897091,
0.523633182,
0.013652443,
0.0480467267,
0.5764837265,
-0.5994061232,
-0.477460593,
-0.5194747448,
0.3724510074,
0.5608415008,
-0.5228077769,
0.5047593117,
-0.2829397023,
-0.7653845549,
-0.6660109162,
-0.0481418632,
0.2697336376,
0.0417938456,
0.336686939,
-0.1718976498,
-0.4223328233,
-0.7818653584,
-0.4934667647,
-0.0267734509,
-0.1241569147,
0.2337431312,
0.6341691017,
-0.3118432462,
0.8715027571,
-0.7020019889,
0.0552633591,
0.0452595539,
0.5408720374,
-0.0796221346,
0.379134506,
0.387213707,
-0.4337758124,
-0.342894733,
-0.2439535558,
-0.5224234462,
0.0906088203,
0.1056064144,
-0.0329728387,
-0.1620685905,
0.4789310098,
-0.3176825941,
0.9750930667,
0.5891953111,
-0.2507083714,
0.6924363971,
-0.409850657,
0.2644840479,
-0.90363729,
-0.1052721664,
0.3775650859,
-0.1859610677,
-0.3647132218,
-0.0104587078,
0.2404336035,
0.1712338179,
-0.0407961309,
0.2515477538,
-0.7746228576,
-0.2820335925,
-0.1315379292,
-0.079076916,
-0.3554341793,
-0.2019135058,
-0.018359594,
0.7882139683,
0.6387860179,
-0.5200712681,
-0.1571997702,
0.1046602651,
-0.3720760643,
0.5498396754,
-0.7786614299,
-0.1038036346,
-0.2829457521,
0.1605145931,
-1.0493446589,
-0.3408530056,
0.1638861597,
-0.5142527819,
0.3412974775,
0.0603481531,
-0.3075505793,
-0.4214669466,
-0.8528334498,
0.1563103497,
0.5485274196,
-0.0401724204,
0.0854867324,
0.9601826072,
-0.1012085527,
-0.7603032589,
-0.4995759726,
-0.2708775997,
-0.1566174179,
-0.2482697368,
0.2022186816,
0.0446672887,
-0.5081750751,
0.040349476,
-0.3715377152,
-0.212178573,
0.2407066822,
0.4518307745,
0.1940552145,
0.0476074293,
0.0733923241,
0.2340319008,
0.0834497586,
-0.0444085784,
0.0594988018,
0.0786800906,
-0.0205915049,
-0.8157357574,
0.0711499006,
0.3465001285,
0.4496549666,
0.136783883,
0.4830188155,
0.8212444186,
-0.7213500738,
-0.3023964763,
-0.6546419859,
-0.0366227031,
-0.3888093829,
0.4412832856,
-0.2819053233,
-0.7009527087,
0.4349751174,
0.0352330729,
0.0256284326,
0.4011797309,
0.5274921656,
-0.3970298469,
0.8599671125,
0.5625262856,
-0.0295711942,
0.0468882956,
-0.0549494699,
0.0828269795,
-0.7145496011,
0.1804106236,
-0.6947433352,
-0.0899220258,
-0.7513651848,
-1.1143208742,
0.467776835,
0.0269195773,
-0.0615611747,
0.2711700201,
-0.2307045013,
0.0750065595,
0.6288555264,
0.3838960826,
-0.2669761181,
0.0259141866,
0.0336735956,
-0.2534250319,
-0.4815971553,
-0.4665173888,
1.2665216923,
0.4150792956,
0.9301819801,
0.0593739636,
0.8238033056,
0.3860028982,
0.2563098073,
-0.5532378554,
-0.1156941056,
-0.1334471256,
-0.4338907897,
-0.3947301209,
-0.1739746034,
-0.8895885348,
0.3615107834,
-0.6609115005,
-1.145475626,
0.3429501057,
0.1659648865,
-0.3897776306,
0.424148649,
-0.4703382254,
0.3781090677,
0.4300196469,
-0.3430980146,
0.0057406155,
-0.5130714774,
0.373936981,
-0.012402596,
0.7010092139,
-0.2001768649,
-0.3308380842,
0.8189091086,
-0.3549364805,
1.1156822443,
-0.1764445156,
0.0514771827,
0.3147895932,
0.240138948,
0.4654222429,
0.0778758451,
-0.2063492984,
0.166972667,
0.2780859172,
-0.5153626204,
-0.3851740062,
0.2641614377,
-0.7976123691,
-0.5594421625,
-0.6052183509,
-0.4778947234,
-0.538829267,
-0.1708295345,
0.4503219426,
0.3251742721,
-0.4646175206,
0.4245717824,
0.7799170017,
-0.3385021985,
0.1288035512,
-0.0824131593,
0.1912505478,
-0.1945194751,
0.6907144189,
0.4689685404,
-0.1134405658,
0.3215291798,
0.4816177487,
-0.3956473172,
-0.4858219922,
-0.2004755884,
0.0089021837,
-0.3516315222,
-0.0670457706,
-0.7197362185,
0.183585003,
-0.501932323,
-0.4252945185,
-0.4913350046,
-0.268234551,
-0.2797537744,
-0.37768507,
0.3315593004,
0.8046547771,
-0.2690553069,
0.0551806688,
-0.721517086,
0.2518481314,
0.0388418473,
0.2966411412,
-0.3140177131,
-0.2657761872,
-0.1403035969,
0.233535856,
-0.1338928342,
-1.3061255217,
0.3143549263,
0.0891039595,
0.6174119115,
0.2017529011,
0.3447106183,
0.5641462207,
-0.5307917595,
1.0089805126,
0.2292178422,
-1.0837638378,
0.1154689938,
-0.325335741,
-0.2576886415,
0.4788205624,
0.6581545472,
-0.1478496641,
-0.4989277422,
-0.9283921123,
-0.7405250072,
-0.0968560427,
0.0995893404,
0.0054817772,
-0.1091720015,
0.1289363205,
0.339482218,
0.1268841326,
-0.0178776905,
-0.3581031263,
-0.0816776678,
-0.2982474267,
-0.2630333602,
-0.4064347446,
-0.274890244,
-0.2126924843,
0.3703476787,
-0.1280973554,
0.5672895312,
0.2866061926,
-0.2863901556,
0.0916691348,
0.0883908644,
0.6171091795,
0.6446211934,
-0.2950620353,
0.3816643655,
0.5200887918,
-0.6891676784,
0.179855749,
-0.0880564526,
0.0561378226,
0.3001900017,
0.6544436812,
0.4030923247,
0.4337855577,
-0.3742222488,
0.9975506067,
-0.0836252123,
-0.2231628597,
-0.2770095468,
-0.3612588942,
0.1460762322,
-0.0210128911,
0.1136627048,
0.136941582,
0.3817714155,
-0.2199562788,
0.4742162526,
0.4392260909,
-0.5639685392,
-0.2858781517,
0.4355638027,
-0.0494879223,
0.1701039821,
0.0149756139,
-0.2071202844,
-0.3276005983,
0.4102613926,
0.2510946095,
0.7481396794,
-0.0065418552,
0.3443434536,
0.4943403602,
0.4147509336,
-0.2264607698,
0.5048792362,
0.161803171,
-0.8899866343,
-0.0566690415,
-0.4402842224,
-0.6487899423,
-0.5566313267,
-1.0470080376,
0.0207905956,
-0.3225440681,
-0.4533902109,
-0.1514233202,
-0.1112930775,
-0.9728296995,
0.0895300135,
-0.1446692348,
0.7477158904,
-1.0411278009,
0.4246843457,
0.4146863818,
-0.1956887394,
-0.6002606153,
0.2106779367,
0.3197556734,
-0.9355232716,
0.2313784212,
-0.176600799,
-0.029415274,
-0.5048185587,
-0.6174923182,
-0.8703542352,
0.8813145161,
0.1976581514,
-0.4215722382,
0.3269205093,
-0.0095313685,
0.0924776569,
0.1779881865,
0.3445936441,
0.39194116,
0.4348382652,
-0.3995102644,
-0.5437608361,
0.284182936,
0.0955138803,
0.0202459283,
-0.0231404379,
-0.0919085294,
0.7868127823,
-0.2547380924,
-0.0268970393,
0.0161553454,
0.8765755892,
0.336805284,
0.1438811123,
0.6457616687,
0.4766194224,
1.109385252,
-0.023633752,
1.2235972881,
-0.3220732212,
0.5093810558,
0.9730650783,
-0.1290698946,
0.8902468681,
0.5053498745,
-0.5517110229,
0.1146110743,
0.6035245657,
0.1914337873,
0.1927802265,
0.6229760647,
-0.1735990942,
-0.1583071202,
0.0837082416,
-0.5079439878,
0.2968524694,
0.7593665123,
-0.0375031047,
-0.0401326492,
-0.213840574,
0.1061865613,
-0.0207065884,
0.101445362,
0.4122566879,
0.1745458394,
-0.2273687571,
0.0240304638,
0.0173505768,
0.8079643846,
-0.4708915055,
0.009787838,
0.2022272199,
-0.0724713579,
0.0009079278,
-0.7207576036,
0.3711986244,
-0.0921581239,
0.1558158398,
0.1335132569,
0.7067975402,
-0.3116258383,
-0.8428906202,
0.0336073153,
0.6622724533,
0.0306985639,
0.0861544535,
-0.5133756995,
0.2945756614,
-0.2678166926,
-0.2735367417,
0.1763347834,
0.3893101215,
0.103368178,
0.4932338893,
0.4564250112,
0.2590782642,
0.2748449743,
-0.2051091939,
0.3294391036,
-0.2846732736,
-0.3470148444,
-0.7063313127,
0.4954202771,
-0.2604554296,
-0.5819829106,
0.9376760721,
0.1791024059,
0.5190735459,
-0.3751182854,
1.0632964373,
-0.0663837269,
0.431001693,
-0.4131392241,
0.6182590127,
-0.5170672536,
-0.2730559409,
-0.7331852913,
-0.4970001578,
-0.4555270076,
0.8753790855,
-0.1612974256,
-0.1476848423,
0.5787711143,
0.81334728,
-0.1626178473,
0.1401706189,
0.6255660653,
0.0100646643,
0.0916632488,
-0.2354055196,
0.4030350447,
-0.5216602087,
-0.2967856526,
-0.4899214506,
-0.6110937595,
-0.2565939128,
-0.9511555433,
-0.4899752438,
-0.6848959327,
-0.4738933146,
-0.6304991245,
0.0570107698,
1.1483631134,
0.704985261,
-0.7259092331,
-0.1521946788,
0.1839883029,
0.1381483227,
-0.5992226005,
-0.1152949482,
0.7359555364,
-0.1834774762,
-0.6095545292,
0.1671234369,
-0.1096493825,
-0.0237091724,
-0.0042656087,
0.1953510791,
-0.0168881807,
0.340929091,
0.3725554645,
0.0886846855,
-0.5816794038,
-0.6740859151,
-0.1085735559,
-0.1327565163,
-0.5135267973,
0.687201798,
0.0950267017,
0.5537663698,
0.6574708223,
0.9755838513,
0.3528800309,
-0.2499050945,
0.8793423176,
-0.7806780934,
0.016184723,
0.0726104677,
0.7597756982,
0.1836058795,
-0.2631813586,
0.3828689456,
0.34371984,
-0.1673159152,
-0.8091275096,
0.0905214474,
-1.078417778,
-0.3817935586,
1.2320605516,
-0.2998870909,
-0.4012494981,
-0.2502095997,
-0.0657553002,
0.383960247,
-0.20702447,
0.6971929669,
0.8553964496,
0.3106455207,
0.1801280081,
-0.7328184843,
0.4239067137,
0.1923377812,
-0.3381924629,
0.0710581467,
0.10215801,
0.4023762345,
0.1614592075,
0.4593277574,
-0.0396394096,
0.2601554394,
0.6653875709,
0.1591151506,
0.2452497929,
0.0489930026,
0.1254748851,
0.1964555383,
0.0316071063,
-0.4506798387
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12159v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12159v1 | Exploring the Impact of a Transformer's Latent Space Geometry on Downstream Task Performance | 2024-06-18T00:17:30 | 2024-06-18T00:17:30 | Anna C. Marbut, John W. Chandler, Travis J. Wheeler | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | It is generally thought that transformer-based large language models benefit
from pre-training by learning generic linguistic knowledge that can be focused
on a specific task during fine-tuning. However, we propose that much of the
benefit from pre-training may be captured by geometric characteristics of the
latent space representations, divorced from any specific linguistic knowledge.
In this work we explore the relationship between GLUE benchmarking task
performance and a variety of measures applied to the latent space resulting
from BERT-type contextual language models. We find that there is a strong
linear relationship between a measure of quantized cell density and average
GLUE performance and that these measures may be predictive of otherwise
surprising GLUE performance for several non-standard BERT-type models from the
literature. These results may be suggestive of a strategy for decreasing
pre-training requirements, wherein model initialization can be informed by the
geometric characteristics of the model's latent space. | [
-0.3754065931,
-0.5849965811,
0.5798467398,
0.0703609586,
-0.0535625815,
-0.1893212348,
-0.0812606066,
-0.1599726081,
0.1549926549,
0.2686948776,
-0.5588156581,
-0.2093279213,
-0.7785226703,
-0.4174250662,
-0.3245134056,
0.9719665051,
-0.1152122989,
-0.2344004363,
-0.3803033233,
0.123981908,
-0.3940610886,
-0.602343142,
-0.1198063716,
-0.1638905853,
0.7952685356,
-0.1792022884,
0.86676687,
0.5994059443,
0.6106200814,
0.3501695395,
-0.1380853802,
-0.5255350471,
-0.5981231332,
-0.0438605882,
0.1047628522,
-0.7556405663,
-0.5712955594,
0.4249660075,
0.7443267107,
1.0531573296,
-0.0715831667,
0.0234520826,
0.4167357385,
0.5995692015,
-0.6924445033,
0.1885295808,
-0.472728312,
0.0867204368,
-0.4032280147,
-0.0757884681,
-0.3501481116,
-0.3641929626,
0.4798657298,
-0.7888275385,
0.3976881802,
-0.1367461532,
0.9818258286,
0.7292945385,
-0.2892848551,
-0.130599454,
-0.8904054761,
0.8164786696,
-0.5567346811,
0.5163419843,
0.3293033242,
0.3062476814,
-0.1063360199,
-0.741263628,
-0.0624049492,
-0.0006528283,
-0.5058994293,
0.1573893577,
-0.1290558726,
-0.1008368358,
0.3870602548,
0.3930177093,
-0.5304775238,
-0.0380860269,
-0.5266478062,
-0.1775646061,
0.309248507,
0.0242210273,
0.1994351894,
0.1047495902,
-0.2573116124,
-0.358294338,
-0.7637462616,
0.4830548167,
0.3925766051,
0.2354651839,
-0.1955002695,
0.5193669796,
0.1194872633,
0.428304553,
0.0218364559,
0.1285918206,
0.0325050093,
0.0134765273,
-0.0589150488,
-0.2487405092,
0.5707613826,
-0.2933561206,
0.0521347374,
-0.3438206017,
-0.1610270739,
0.1204133183,
0.736028254,
-0.86288625,
-0.6682417989,
-0.2746951282,
-0.5743966103,
0.1574448496,
0.1660278887,
-0.2139664739,
0.1038211361,
-0.4108567238,
0.419724673,
-0.4765838981,
-0.1503158659,
-0.3121055663,
-0.0469116829,
0.1976762861,
0.1395005882,
-0.8124730587,
0.2342653424,
0.8498466015,
0.9240268469,
-0.2441917658,
-0.0983231813,
-0.4927180409,
0.138792187,
-0.347060442,
1.0888324976,
-0.6843512058,
-0.3513226509,
-0.0807558969,
0.0822886899,
-0.4104260504,
-0.5949588418,
0.3519695103,
-0.5078747869,
0.2966872454,
-0.420578897,
-0.6370235085,
-0.1740923375,
-0.2624450326,
-0.9201753736,
1.0073503256,
0.487875253,
-0.5032648444,
0.7656502128,
-0.4701286852,
-0.5038253665,
0.0998809338,
-0.3317368031,
-0.5368608832,
0.5828059912,
-0.0044498732,
0.5496075749,
0.0809794217,
0.2774356902,
-0.4177767634,
-0.5426141024,
0.2018411905,
-0.2370684892,
0.2397248,
-0.0259620287,
-0.3205403388,
0.1073753759,
-0.4924929738,
-0.1114389673,
-0.2903386652,
-0.3645693362,
-0.348172754,
0.1781712323,
-0.1367406994,
0.3548201919,
0.2581521273,
-0.3811215162,
0.0743978694,
-0.4465091228,
0.0352242589,
0.5791859627,
-0.3200286329,
0.6928162575,
-0.2356975675,
0.4309878349,
0.1073306948,
-0.0232999027,
0.0430183038,
-0.5474322438,
-0.7952614427,
-0.3183014393,
0.1058793366,
0.1924435496,
-0.5857355595,
0.4584564567,
-0.3316434324,
-0.7114431262,
-0.2850628495,
0.1359557807,
0.4174962342,
0.3413390517,
0.1980629265,
-0.3478711247,
-0.2266268283,
-1.0725077391,
-0.3034931421,
-0.010913399,
-0.3602462411,
0.4686637819,
0.3471266329,
0.1100773662,
1.2349165678,
-0.9102404118,
-0.4530578852,
0.036278747,
0.2338715643,
0.58359164,
0.4253234863,
0.6972268224,
-0.5798559189,
-0.423370719,
-0.1782073081,
-0.535356164,
-0.1268355101,
0.209978804,
-0.1344117671,
0.2238231897,
0.5782468915,
-0.5640659332,
0.7202184796,
0.860884726,
-0.5734069347,
0.6616224051,
-0.3459022343,
-0.0070312428,
-0.8407095671,
0.2184140086,
0.0571315251,
0.162095964,
-0.6028650403,
-0.5788288116,
-0.0313558951,
-0.2667779922,
-0.6269903779,
0.2081926167,
-0.2704382837,
-0.3598292768,
-0.2996724546,
-0.0265527982,
-0.1855999827,
0.6533499956,
0.3175943196,
1.1454859972,
0.3092500865,
-0.5841608644,
-0.2580653131,
0.271381557,
-0.41120556,
0.2740612328,
-0.8952230811,
-0.0953079462,
0.1061225161,
0.274769187,
-1.2369344234,
0.0199369546,
-0.4993780553,
-0.2770316601,
0.2613998353,
0.0432650447,
-0.2667029798,
-0.3296670914,
0.1088594422,
0.4756090343,
0.7489230633,
-0.2524839938,
0.6013935804,
0.2980469167,
-0.195838958,
-0.1952886432,
-0.4239742756,
-0.540922761,
-0.4401104152,
-0.8448937535,
0.5099087358,
0.210667178,
0.2057162225,
0.0113826375,
-0.3100542724,
-0.2634078562,
0.1510935575,
0.4596823156,
0.2411911488,
-0.5645300746,
0.0467070714,
0.1160478517,
-0.2777280807,
0.3218855858,
-0.3238203526,
0.4318976402,
-0.2682730556,
-0.2680929303,
-0.28438434,
0.0719306916,
0.3032940626,
0.0131524988,
1.0974135399,
0.787507534,
-0.129227832,
-0.0108164772,
-0.4938063323,
-0.4105424583,
-0.5246943831,
0.416456461,
-0.4101827741,
-1.0034906864,
0.579631865,
-0.2880502641,
-0.1191150919,
0.5537742972,
0.489682883,
-0.4612803757,
0.7087336183,
0.9674916863,
0.1739613861,
0.5465644002,
-0.3793510497,
0.5130088329,
-0.9583814144,
-0.1216222495,
-0.496589303,
-0.4829725921,
-0.6325702667,
-0.6373676062,
0.4045680165,
0.235861972,
-0.180821687,
0.6574923396,
-0.3037514091,
0.2609823048,
0.4983270168,
-0.0865797922,
-0.1350715011,
-0.0966241583,
-0.0885573849,
-0.3172287047,
-0.8071124554,
-0.7423451543,
0.8164978027,
0.3082973659,
0.6974550486,
0.011210274,
0.2241064608,
-0.0995661095,
0.2137057036,
-0.4059167802,
0.3139938116,
-0.6106540561,
-0.3558619618,
-0.310159564,
-0.3850215375,
-1.0989189148,
0.1659554094,
-0.1181411445,
-0.9519803524,
0.0806697011,
0.2519244552,
-0.3068705201,
0.3178210258,
-0.6954430938,
1.0375273228,
-0.1459168047,
-0.2642634809,
-0.2369911969,
-0.3862888813,
-0.0122808618,
-0.2261450887,
-0.1042189077,
-0.1364854276,
0.0380030759,
0.9478071928,
-0.4555053711,
0.8686916232,
-0.3008314967,
-0.2688999474,
0.154468894,
0.0562434271,
0.2653257549,
-0.1668345928,
0.2980523407,
0.4305156171,
-0.1215017587,
-0.4511436522,
-0.726344943,
0.5898626447,
-1.1361783743,
-0.6434506774,
0.1243241504,
-0.9558613896,
-0.3932106495,
-0.0438922495,
0.4220224023,
0.4352455437,
-0.1569589376,
0.6532050371,
0.5882037878,
-0.2860993445,
0.7068555355,
0.2223429978,
0.1297388226,
0.215705812,
0.6698989272,
0.3185857236,
0.1385163069,
0.4856886566,
0.0850627273,
-0.4306662083,
-0.2303169072,
0.1843581349,
0.3015775084,
-0.3623642921,
0.1063582227,
-0.6163788438,
-0.355114311,
-0.2431629449,
-0.4058749974,
-0.7283892035,
-0.4841772914,
-0.2962514758,
0.2611681223,
-0.0258275885,
0.8680401444,
0.3516406715,
0.6594766974,
-0.801291585,
-0.1029992253,
0.3357299566,
0.8004549146,
-0.0318734758,
-0.5678308606,
-0.5394141078,
-0.1040046439,
-0.6139501333,
-0.3692603111,
0.3168388903,
0.1464360654,
0.7249624133,
0.4487520754,
-0.284409374,
0.6295278668,
-0.6865059733,
0.8463452458,
0.1673953086,
-0.9231795669,
0.7276967764,
-0.5644100904,
0.4638209045,
0.0797036663,
0.5050416589,
0.0275814254,
-0.6317141652,
-0.6743286848,
-0.6897452474,
0.6977021098,
0.529658854,
-0.0289234333,
0.2376612723,
0.1978866458,
0.1439023465,
0.0627865121,
-0.6706348658,
-0.0378899798,
-0.2164946198,
0.0999587551,
-0.3419722915,
-0.1882712692,
0.2216169536,
-0.1458947212,
0.3902049661,
-0.0789159164,
0.406083107,
-0.1496425569,
-0.2211945504,
0.1330254078,
0.0010720746,
0.6591739655,
0.5228071213,
-0.1722718924,
-0.1783877313,
0.0889418274,
-0.6334255338,
0.0478207208,
0.0264257826,
0.2488075495,
-0.0510144047,
0.6039082408,
0.9671820402,
0.4097470641,
-0.185164392,
0.4043847919,
-0.013671862,
-0.271410048,
-0.1147512794,
0.3133127093,
0.0712976456,
0.2381792665,
0.5058568716,
0.1051748544,
0.0378412679,
-0.1117573529,
0.3485352993,
0.323812902,
-0.7718812227,
-0.7143259645,
0.5330848694,
0.1619659364,
-0.2438334078,
0.664573431,
0.275151968,
-0.3568644226,
0.6363289356,
0.3753193319,
0.7756243944,
-0.3976183534,
-0.0826264098,
0.2008176297,
0.1871003062,
0.3743548393,
-0.260363549,
-0.0977256,
-0.4587322474,
-0.7758466601,
-0.643814683,
0.1224619672,
0.1225920841,
-0.690933764,
0.1086780056,
-0.0946698636,
-0.3517066836,
-0.0703641549,
-0.0637432784,
-0.8514236808,
0.2490826696,
0.2521182001,
0.6080595851,
-0.9891937971,
0.869423151,
0.7764240503,
-0.0376931801,
-1.0922031403,
-0.014660269,
-0.1408242732,
-0.3351836205,
1.061468482,
0.370531261,
-0.0174577981,
-0.348706156,
0.0676464215,
-1.3900147676,
1.0300447941,
0.5372250676,
-0.5105394721,
-0.1844725758,
0.4748040438,
0.6533299685,
-0.453967005,
0.4649755657,
0.6036934257,
0.1216156259,
0.1829739362,
-0.9890499711,
-0.1040518656,
-0.3005430996,
0.4516961575,
0.5789846182,
-0.3811493516,
1.0350170135,
0.0438586771,
-0.3501918018,
-0.1952186674,
0.8969461322,
0.2543014586,
-0.1446556002,
0.5326992273,
0.5769652128,
0.3335506916,
-0.579675734,
1.1160987616,
-0.4167892635,
0.4538864493,
0.8761736155,
-0.0289474986,
0.9613402486,
0.5824325085,
-0.3422473669,
0.7431639433,
0.335192591,
0.0433959514,
0.6000378132,
0.2662439644,
0.2248956561,
-0.1001652181,
-0.0399890095,
-0.3429672718,
0.6437364817,
0.5061030984,
-0.0313255712,
-0.2503317595,
-0.0577565618,
-0.2601627111,
0.0249451566,
-0.0593773648,
0.8077988029,
0.1562280208,
-0.8211228251,
0.4377874732,
-0.6898623109,
0.5115453005,
-0.435985595,
0.070186682,
-0.0651799142,
0.3043497801,
-0.1902837306,
-0.8766906261,
0.8293476105,
-0.2856972814,
-0.3734444082,
-0.3782138228,
0.5889740586,
-0.2685147524,
-0.312004745,
0.4363571107,
0.5452557802,
0.150125131,
-0.0544190668,
-0.385538429,
0.0500079915,
-0.3361622393,
-0.4249739051,
0.3318628073,
0.4060203731,
0.0523468778,
0.4986791015,
0.5996413827,
0.0597627871,
0.1149255484,
0.0936499834,
0.9384377599,
-0.4417797625,
-0.6915897727,
-0.5988282561,
0.7403675318,
0.0851757675,
-0.2137643248,
0.6887514591,
0.6472666264,
0.7444663644,
-0.2745407224,
0.3129853904,
0.0231452063,
0.3967794776,
-0.5736497045,
0.9236608744,
-0.4929094017,
0.2155663073,
-0.4597507119,
-1.4513181448,
0.0986204594,
0.6954883933,
-0.794069767,
0.2909917235,
1.0164679289,
0.4869750738,
-0.2721307576,
-0.0717161894,
0.5299353004,
0.1340538114,
0.4959205687,
0.8149569631,
0.9925115108,
-0.3890458941,
0.5572986603,
-0.2113190442,
-0.2186691016,
-0.0107169254,
-0.840040803,
-1.0852262974,
-0.9527974725,
-0.3094078302,
0.0581200533,
-0.393206358,
0.0371467136,
1.2130008936,
-0.6192783117,
-0.3630899191,
-0.0549257249,
-0.3498853743,
0.1374929845,
-0.2002113461,
0.546076417,
-0.7171772122,
-0.4836940467,
0.0834321305,
0.3560502827,
0.0294552259,
-0.0097510237,
0.177331537,
-0.0925775394,
-0.068911463,
0.5399210453,
-0.2184531391,
-0.794870913,
-0.1238058209,
0.0958675817,
-0.1024505273,
0.190244168,
1.1929811239,
-1.0415972471,
-0.0812332109,
0.2677566111,
0.4906706512,
0.6198952198,
-0.0695345029,
0.8740171194,
-1.0599002838,
0.4721237719,
0.1122682169,
0.3745828569,
0.1035026461,
-0.5360675454,
0.4063363075,
0.0132635031,
-0.6597498655,
-0.3439735472,
0.0779105797,
-0.6718825698,
-0.2409980893,
0.7137998343,
-0.4964095056,
-0.3872056603,
0.1288199872,
0.1547787637,
0.3126447499,
-0.2357537299,
0.7039441466,
0.729624033,
-0.197341308,
0.0430141315,
-0.415533185,
0.6445616484,
0.764927268,
-0.8478363752,
-0.1181845441,
0.226536274,
0.0899407491,
0.5358130932,
0.1827036291,
-0.0088200094,
0.2415010333,
-0.0792415664,
-0.2707938254,
0.3503349721,
-0.5218169093,
-0.1268964261,
0.2392177433,
-0.1581735909,
0.1072083786
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12158v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12158v1 | LLMs Are Prone to Fallacies in Causal Inference | 2024-06-18T00:14:07 | 2024-06-18T00:14:07 | Nitish Joshi, Abulhair Saparov, Yixin Wang, He He | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recent work shows that causal facts can be effectively extracted from LLMs
through prompting, facilitating the creation of causal graphs for causal
inference tasks. However, it is unclear if this success is limited to
explicitly-mentioned causal facts in the pretraining data which the model can
memorize. Thus, this work investigates: Can LLMs infer causal relations from
other relational data in text? To disentangle the role of memorized causal
facts vs inferred causal relations, we finetune LLMs on synthetic data
containing temporal, spatial and counterfactual relations, and measure whether
the LLM can then infer causal relations. We find that: (a) LLMs are susceptible
to inferring causal relations from the order of two entity mentions in text
(e.g. X mentioned before Y implies X causes Y); (b) if the order is randomized,
LLMs still suffer from the post hoc fallacy, i.e. X occurs before Y (temporal
relation) implies X causes Y. We also find that while LLMs can correctly deduce
the absence of causal relations from temporal and spatial relations, they have
difficulty inferring causal relations from counterfactuals, questioning their
understanding of causality. | [
-0.046535939,
-1.0880427361,
1.1242153645,
0.1228943914,
-0.1933643818,
-0.2870341241,
0.2196269333,
-0.5431244373,
0.1127997264,
0.4931131899,
-0.7856307626,
-0.2903864682,
-0.5664741993,
0.1521194279,
-0.3694332242,
0.9076887369,
-0.06504336,
0.2503353953,
-0.5580375195,
-0.0794313475,
-0.1930262893,
-0.7901797295,
-0.4074184,
-0.7738952637,
0.8178750277,
-0.0031127261,
0.4997577071,
0.4462251365,
0.4872984588,
0.3226356804,
0.0934108421,
0.2219169438,
-0.7335705757,
-0.0201151371,
-0.4516908526,
-0.9421365857,
-0.1956520677,
0.1864680201,
0.4699829519,
0.6892765164,
-0.1534765661,
0.0720598325,
-0.0332715064,
0.6810082197,
-0.4910341799,
0.1979152858,
-0.8204632401,
-0.0309772752,
-0.1786797196,
-0.4060956836,
-0.529391408,
-0.4083903432,
0.118086867,
-0.6972117424,
0.4097205102,
0.2995516956,
0.9436742663,
0.4094108343,
-0.7332401872,
-0.2825697958,
-0.8600572348,
0.614775002,
-0.5844564438,
0.2351567,
0.4116369784,
0.0818162486,
-0.3946142495,
-0.7726899385,
-0.7389894724,
-0.2797281742,
-0.5312012434,
0.194427669,
0.0473132208,
-0.1277174801,
0.7701872587,
0.2054058164,
-0.3927162588,
-0.0526626185,
-0.193576023,
0.0233791079,
0.4196842015,
0.4348886609,
0.3457939029,
-0.1919727027,
-0.6506596208,
0.2945481539,
-1.1937391758,
-0.1990977079,
0.2606810331,
0.1522161663,
-0.1421196163,
0.5933700204,
0.2663803995,
0.2448461354,
0.0053221229,
-0.0743543729,
0.0192995388,
-0.328643918,
-0.3087847829,
0.2246109098,
0.8421519399,
0.2444932014,
0.4060731232,
-0.2672970593,
0.1944908053,
0.2982458174,
0.1293815076,
-0.494773984,
-0.0881091729,
-0.0380845219,
-0.3081187308,
-0.051868014,
0.1451999992,
-0.3817276359,
-0.4017443359,
-0.4055018723,
0.5569335222,
-0.1221506968,
-0.0391403809,
-0.2183257192,
-0.2440788448,
-0.147423774,
0.3521164358,
-0.5706602931,
0.2890911698,
0.4205388129,
0.5945677161,
-0.1870339662,
-0.6499302983,
-0.1350758076,
0.5641679764,
-0.388913095,
0.8343392611,
-0.3389460742,
-0.5270926356,
-0.1897871047,
0.3043739796,
-0.5060066581,
-0.5045343041,
0.3246169984,
-0.7259351015,
0.1879740953,
-0.5604286194,
-0.7805519104,
-0.1514413357,
0.1332967877,
-0.6160274148,
0.8606951237,
-0.1476015598,
-1.1865805387,
0.5454578996,
0.1517259181,
-0.6051042676,
-0.5345299244,
-0.5191235542,
-0.4484792352,
0.0699688718,
-0.0362933427,
0.2854506075,
-0.4135653973,
0.6729582548,
-0.7178111672,
-0.2095467597,
0.6393415332,
-0.403470248,
0.839936316,
-0.0502850562,
-0.3648890257,
-0.1563045233,
-0.8378789425,
-0.558680892,
0.2608697414,
-0.3540408909,
-0.6257756948,
0.390655905,
-0.488669306,
0.2871108055,
-0.1580307484,
-0.4782616198,
0.0641744435,
-0.1530484557,
0.0567760691,
0.7337793112,
0.4081628919,
0.2960565686,
-0.6121584773,
0.0736932456,
0.4876116514,
-0.1458788514,
0.0394607373,
-0.2918968499,
-0.6781116128,
-0.0199811719,
-0.1826364249,
0.7010089755,
-0.8491638303,
-0.0192068201,
-0.211183399,
-0.3783742785,
0.3027571142,
-0.03740317,
0.4640128911,
1.0490686893,
0.316250056,
0.177864477,
-0.693541944,
-0.6088367701,
-0.5286815166,
-0.4351651669,
0.0770157278,
0.4630769193,
0.6937179565,
-0.0774102584,
0.8875504136,
-0.645370841,
0.082684353,
0.0238414668,
0.171961993,
0.3817308545,
0.3417477906,
0.5769987106,
-0.5211015344,
-0.0340044126,
-0.5558526516,
-1.2377521992,
-0.1291945279,
-0.2203035355,
-0.0790116712,
0.2355977297,
0.9055268168,
-0.9514037371,
0.5884956717,
0.0970310122,
-0.3815289438,
0.7070137858,
-0.1991423368,
0.0677182153,
-0.8311151862,
-0.1531828642,
-0.1398676485,
-0.0861401036,
-0.5629866719,
-0.7046752572,
-0.2330266833,
0.514847219,
-0.5118686557,
0.5358617902,
-0.3298794627,
-0.0186352301,
0.0244961716,
0.1674600989,
-0.074152559,
0.3435615003,
0.2700832784,
0.3282550573,
0.3303004205,
-0.9935774207,
-0.0264738854,
0.20918262,
-0.3268117011,
0.5687537193,
-0.5823075771,
-0.2588798106,
-0.3598265052,
0.277382791,
-1.101023078,
-0.0395665541,
0.2008135766,
-0.3582183719,
0.1993171126,
-0.182212919,
-0.6482967138,
-0.2551273108,
0.000690117,
0.2576911747,
0.3628341258,
-0.657435894,
0.2256677449,
0.353400439,
0.185460493,
-0.452534914,
-0.9577510953,
-0.3258754313,
-0.4557142854,
-0.325391084,
0.0926636159,
0.0294733867,
-0.601639986,
0.0545498095,
-0.1793343574,
-0.1040054411,
0.1047461554,
0.6054794192,
0.2114602923,
-0.2219228148,
0.4038888216,
-0.206785351,
-0.0907379761,
0.5790265203,
0.1375225037,
0.0181306154,
0.5103020072,
-0.5271795988,
-0.1654151827,
0.0127616674,
0.3546869159,
0.5442969799,
0.9303349257,
0.2188140303,
-0.522936821,
-0.1781911552,
-0.4996205568,
-0.41432935,
-0.3828835785,
0.1368884444,
-0.1733937413,
-0.6123090982,
0.6208539605,
-0.245928973,
-0.2304812223,
0.5308001637,
0.4378532171,
-0.4455115497,
0.5555713773,
0.2786453664,
0.0799016953,
0.3054985404,
-0.1685793847,
-0.0314296596,
-0.6327458024,
-0.3633398414,
-0.4176636934,
-0.0479310565,
-0.7573460937,
-0.2078851908,
0.2100322098,
0.1700717956,
-0.5727199316,
0.0637878701,
0.2588439882,
0.3365176618,
0.4682587087,
0.4234633446,
0.45119977,
0.1208329052,
-0.171088472,
-0.304182142,
-0.8510217667,
-0.3778639138,
0.9949809909,
0.0504930243,
0.9330257177,
0.1629514992,
0.5439668298,
0.0560855381,
0.5258564949,
-0.3127192259,
0.5003699064,
0.1109975204,
-0.9444762468,
-0.2460235804,
-0.6386284828,
-0.9833215475,
0.2473082691,
-0.3389589787,
-0.8085556626,
0.274829179,
0.2373844832,
-0.0573364161,
0.3030927181,
-0.4706361294,
0.5512857437,
-0.0951399803,
-0.7130025625,
-0.1054186374,
-0.8238434196,
0.7650995851,
0.0348357931,
0.4046892822,
-0.3098568618,
0.2608194649,
0.9682360888,
-0.73526752,
1.1967117786,
-0.0602683723,
-0.0192403905,
0.5242945552,
0.2357734889,
0.5119433999,
0.3202772737,
0.0537384115,
0.2072787732,
-0.0165534485,
-0.2284584641,
-0.6873136759,
0.6108715534,
-0.7982647419,
-0.6874600649,
-0.6004295349,
-0.471778065,
-0.2344967276,
0.3097414672,
0.3508301973,
0.3551580608,
-0.3692401052,
-0.2159575075,
0.5462847948,
-0.0486365519,
0.6321343184,
0.780272305,
-0.1761785597,
-0.3644036353,
0.5127412081,
0.3016725481,
0.2749898136,
0.5520601273,
0.3035124838,
-0.403876394,
-0.3818769455,
0.1509740353,
0.6715943217,
-0.8112715483,
0.0611821376,
-0.4961271584,
-0.1265873462,
-0.0569463633,
0.0706726313,
-0.1600702107,
-0.4856507182,
-0.4983267784,
-0.3097450435,
0.3534411192,
0.8503099084,
-0.1280778199,
0.2746256292,
-0.8326747417,
0.5003415942,
0.3596135974,
-0.1412063986,
0.0301479418,
-0.5662061572,
0.0349385254,
-0.0688935965,
-0.1416364759,
-0.982339561,
0.0583685376,
-0.0823226124,
0.7908623219,
0.605463326,
0.223085016,
0.8734961748,
-0.7700506449,
0.6443497539,
0.2431508303,
-0.4987432361,
0.4223131239,
-0.4566437006,
-0.064046897,
0.3287786543,
0.6592947245,
-0.1672038585,
-0.4765717387,
-0.9497742057,
-0.6141585112,
0.7076473236,
0.1524793804,
-0.1503984332,
-0.4764897227,
0.6209246516,
0.0105496459,
0.3046680689,
-0.993216753,
-0.6797914505,
0.2492798269,
0.0402433313,
-0.2759316862,
-0.5662534237,
-0.3164419234,
-0.1096802503,
0.4871318638,
0.3373106718,
0.0642064735,
0.5703441501,
-0.347950846,
-0.1985986233,
-0.1191551313,
0.6421036124,
1.1530704498,
-0.2040870488,
0.7029992342,
0.3278321624,
-0.3392596245,
0.3168596327,
-0.0205266494,
-0.4196890593,
0.1042694226,
0.941227138,
0.6377281547,
0.5136132836,
-0.3179920614,
0.2982016206,
0.0296351127,
-0.1189255416,
-0.2154610604,
0.0161389057,
0.3944703341,
0.3200917244,
0.1466819048,
-0.0080177989,
-0.1533050835,
-0.731328547,
0.3036486208,
0.3161376119,
-0.2049974948,
-0.4474666119,
0.8143103719,
-0.0973668918,
-0.0420528054,
0.4600726068,
0.0964919031,
-0.2876583338,
0.7395294905,
0.7934439182,
0.4988623559,
-0.2859825492,
0.0542725511,
0.6678107381,
0.4564833939,
-0.0402954072,
0.259991169,
0.2034234852,
-0.8409950733,
-0.2249711156,
-0.2759177983,
-0.299073875,
0.0992552042,
-0.4748797417,
0.1905620694,
-0.3202969432,
-0.3475733101,
-0.2198078632,
-0.2419997901,
-0.4524122775,
0.2525803745,
-0.0669001043,
0.5163968205,
-1.0527946949,
0.6396511197,
0.2941289842,
-0.4412760437,
-0.5827745199,
-0.090758644,
0.0775869042,
-0.7657543421,
1.1200091839,
-0.0169336367,
-0.156461969,
-0.2833385468,
-0.3711973727,
-0.8374628425,
1.1037560701,
0.6131763458,
-0.5800343156,
-0.133056879,
0.3263360262,
0.3842352927,
-0.1045230553,
0.3183331192,
0.3534622192,
0.3182576597,
0.213585794,
-0.5270068049,
0.3895022273,
0.2501575053,
-0.2691352069,
0.0869497359,
-0.6063508391,
1.0043811798,
-0.59432441,
-0.3446758091,
-0.456700474,
0.4939310551,
0.5357064009,
0.8531066179,
0.4185495079,
0.5917133689,
0.7508343458,
0.0396821126,
0.9845038652,
0.0227374602,
0.2598855197,
1.4984041452,
-0.3269247115,
0.4807715714,
0.8128311038,
-0.5328984857,
0.5447466373,
0.8106962442,
0.2046212852,
0.5715114474,
0.1986397952,
-0.0218632761,
-0.2719277442,
0.1820646375,
-0.3848975301,
0.0279324241,
0.4415189028,
-0.5135669708,
-0.3053119481,
-0.5581464171,
0.4117608964,
0.0070852195,
-0.2299752086,
0.7564250231,
0.5440191627,
-0.6001969576,
0.3752413094,
-0.4719031453,
0.0694633946,
-0.5426543355,
0.0107310871,
-0.2160600424,
0.2775430381,
-0.3190720081,
-0.4154098332,
0.496948719,
-0.3309834301,
-0.3452235758,
0.0705245659,
0.5984172225,
-0.3547825813,
-0.6228624582,
0.3832677901,
0.7823136449,
0.0987576246,
0.2343037277,
-0.4224039614,
-0.3901619911,
-0.2102234513,
-0.4735378921,
0.247060284,
0.6721634269,
-0.2475016862,
0.6110019684,
0.5669221878,
0.1108129099,
0.2623590231,
0.0631176904,
0.6886782646,
-0.868722558,
-0.3764191568,
-1.4391833544,
0.1981414407,
0.0581461005,
-0.0774567798,
1.1008323431,
0.3211548626,
0.6694882512,
-0.1932716668,
0.6449337602,
0.3082856536,
0.5743160844,
-0.9243284464,
0.6275664568,
-0.3978636861,
0.3864571154,
-0.3151654005,
-0.6713199019,
-0.2826376855,
0.1961755753,
-0.7320443392,
0.0139162717,
1.1432195902,
0.6295775771,
0.1258243769,
-0.0815583989,
0.1997650564,
0.4277896881,
0.1806703061,
0.614438355,
1.0902389288,
-0.344770968,
0.4342754781,
0.0058624581,
0.2159273773,
-0.100684762,
-1.0363326073,
-1.3053935766,
-0.4106497467,
-0.5094356537,
-0.2602879107,
-0.0891446769,
0.3094463348,
0.2822197378,
-0.5625250936,
-0.1411266923,
-0.3641938865,
0.812471807,
0.1147559211,
-0.199299261,
0.4304033816,
-0.1324039847,
-0.3041994572,
0.171113506,
0.0624601059,
0.3852186203,
0.2251159251,
0.0212508738,
-0.4513446391,
0.2199257612,
0.5116739273,
0.1328235865,
-0.6091560125,
-0.3332096934,
-0.3207404017,
-0.072215654,
-0.0196349397,
1.0674915314,
-0.6981551647,
0.1137800366,
0.5993070602,
0.147767067,
0.5701614022,
0.001467891,
0.442918092,
-0.629312396,
0.2795565128,
-0.1973187327,
0.5542405248,
0.143491298,
-0.3833068013,
0.4802556038,
0.8488640785,
-0.5197111368,
-0.8123813868,
0.3985753059,
-0.5284093022,
-0.3895597756,
0.9909749031,
-0.3652210832,
-0.3922762275,
-0.1922277659,
0.1451017112,
0.4854111075,
0.1764736027,
0.7162185907,
0.717345953,
-0.502528429,
0.0919914469,
-0.6561518908,
0.5513206124,
0.1592240781,
-0.8039625883,
0.0248610936,
0.551150322,
0.4174863994,
0.0482538268,
0.9193860888,
0.0188968144,
0.1345657408,
0.215498209,
-0.4852777421,
-0.0225056522,
-0.1390669644,
0.1832514405,
-0.0191532802,
-0.0060401587,
-0.1096894667
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15487v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15487v1 | Improving Text-To-Audio Models with Synthetic Captions | 2024-06-18T00:02:15 | 2024-06-18T00:02:15 | Zhifeng Kong, Sang-gil Lee, Deepanway Ghosal, Navonil Majumder, Ambuj Mehrish, Rafael Valle, Soujanya Poria, Bryan Catanzaro | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS | It is an open challenge to obtain high quality training data, especially
captions, for text-to-audio models. Although prior methods have leveraged
\textit{text-only language models} to augment and improve captions, such
methods have limitations related to scale and coherence between audio and
captions. In this work, we propose an audio captioning pipeline that uses an
\textit{audio language model} to synthesize accurate and diverse captions for
audio at scale. We leverage this pipeline to produce a dataset of synthetic
captions for AudioSet, named \texttt{AF-AudioSet}, and then evaluate the
benefit of pre-training text-to-audio models on these synthetic captions.
Through systematic evaluations on AudioCaps and MusicCaps, we find leveraging
our pipeline and synthetic captions leads to significant improvements on audio
generation quality, achieving a new \textit{state-of-the-art}. | [
-0.504663229,
-0.4415787756,
0.3566000462,
0.1475301981,
-0.332316041,
0.5246298909,
-0.3254705667,
-0.4463126361,
0.4886875749,
0.4838159382,
-0.9228663445,
-0.4123079479,
-0.4747800231,
0.2906636596,
-0.728987813,
1.0037420988,
-0.0013563191,
0.2558592856,
-0.1219660416,
-0.1887136102,
-0.8744753003,
-0.1876867414,
-0.6921053529,
0.0403613225,
0.176105231,
0.4855079353,
0.505253315,
0.6784992218,
0.4969641566,
0.1607777774,
0.1819456816,
0.3790585399,
-0.1867445856,
0.2265425622,
0.0928356797,
-0.2052699327,
-0.5418288112,
0.275860399,
0.6375284195,
0.4871616364,
-0.0799305588,
0.2466263622,
-0.3072322905,
0.4590555131,
-0.2397896498,
0.159932062,
-0.6955267787,
0.1572110951,
0.108479917,
-0.4635985494,
-0.4847190082,
0.0873819664,
0.3342402577,
-0.9286307693,
0.5248263478,
0.5812423229,
0.7383337021,
0.4583928883,
-0.1550338417,
-0.2213910222,
-0.960285604,
0.7394747734,
-0.7532866001,
0.5991978645,
0.1463418454,
0.7345887423,
0.3948390782,
-0.9918413758,
-0.5684264898,
-0.2714914083,
0.0241667517,
0.1373131126,
0.07167501,
0.0339092501,
0.207536146,
0.921408236,
-0.2795932889,
-0.1076916829,
-0.5033218861,
-0.3451730013,
0.8608743548,
-0.0598178208,
0.6456804872,
0.0694505721,
-0.3044854105,
-0.4342237413,
-0.6988040209,
-0.2380062491,
0.492616415,
0.533813715,
-0.3319881558,
0.6792818904,
-0.1312994957,
0.4445521832,
0.1751179099,
0.2421791553,
0.3467609882,
-0.6396734118,
-0.1563079357,
0.2711792588,
0.7881600261,
0.3526532948,
0.3770707548,
-0.401894927,
-0.3895582855,
0.1201596335,
0.3855639398,
-0.5899261236,
-0.484631896,
0.4235952795,
-0.1430949271,
-0.2659831047,
0.1901433468,
-0.5902658105,
-0.1694702655,
-0.8264850974,
0.6999521852,
-0.3361921012,
-0.2446699589,
0.0090960786,
-0.3821231425,
-0.0935769305,
0.0353365019,
-1.0205160379,
0.3456331491,
0.3291053474,
0.8971111774,
-0.2851276994,
0.0367254205,
-0.9721707106,
0.1963192523,
-0.2832031846,
0.8241562843,
-0.3443847299,
-0.1841492802,
0.102617301,
-0.2961215973,
0.2750455439,
-0.6258612871,
0.4853490591,
-0.2068773508,
0.3627040684,
0.0023809019,
-0.5970083475,
0.0572760291,
-0.0397977792,
-0.9427338243,
0.799159646,
0.0389186591,
-0.477665931,
0.5631711483,
-0.9954875708,
-0.6055135727,
-0.1376303136,
0.0163208563,
-0.5534839034,
0.1505828947,
0.7540614605,
0.3325112164,
-0.3183784783,
0.3903059661,
0.0246082433,
-0.4291172922,
0.2390780002,
-0.4992339909,
0.3288920224,
0.189499259,
-0.0670454055,
0.3195299804,
-0.9387831092,
-0.1749810576,
-0.0690606162,
-0.1370512545,
-0.0154166827,
-0.0318019316,
0.5658270717,
-0.1982299387,
-0.1199541911,
-0.6808714271,
-0.2440648973,
-0.6979113221,
0.9068570733,
0.4413734674,
0.0322821587,
0.8577917814,
-0.6131525636,
0.5410996675,
-0.2181940973,
-0.0973426774,
-0.6322595477,
-0.1750632823,
-0.6510000229,
-0.7032161951,
0.5317775011,
0.3710189462,
-0.4344091713,
0.539562583,
-0.4000234008,
-0.459238559,
-0.7928732038,
-0.1049943492,
-0.012873468,
0.2036931962,
0.6315599084,
-0.4876964688,
-0.8379948139,
-0.7537145019,
-0.2392274588,
-0.0052409749,
-0.4279261529,
0.3347814977,
0.0943115875,
-0.2047470361,
1.3280060291,
-0.238854602,
-0.4283142388,
-0.0398913734,
0.2310543805,
0.0617512986,
0.727756381,
0.478928566,
-0.7469450831,
-0.367418319,
-0.237430945,
-0.4326689541,
-0.205100596,
-0.2809913456,
-0.1448874027,
-0.1485646963,
0.7520524263,
-0.6574009061,
-0.2405163348,
0.654600203,
-0.0327196531,
0.6353643537,
0.1407766342,
0.2259956747,
-1.1643331051,
0.0282586273,
-0.1794086844,
-0.472656846,
-0.5863413811,
-0.1163349971,
-0.3393224776,
-0.495207876,
-0.539680481,
0.6410701275,
-0.4416171014,
-0.2950728238,
-0.0726430938,
0.167559877,
0.1201548949,
0.3948765397,
0.3353352547,
0.8611546159,
0.6167613864,
-0.188809216,
0.5100700855,
0.4538577497,
-0.4922928214,
0.4318122268,
-0.6279421449,
0.1217539087,
-0.0395437069,
0.3632492423,
-1.2289222479,
-0.4074400365,
-0.053584747,
-0.6757680774,
0.5347923636,
0.0468557887,
-0.5881180167,
-0.0803433731,
-0.0925883427,
0.5946139693,
0.3785554469,
-0.7105228901,
0.7362784147,
0.3545209765,
-0.3116499186,
-0.1581094563,
-0.6021328568,
0.2470317334,
-0.3397788703,
-0.543789506,
0.4389370382,
-0.1477438658,
-0.0006559681,
-0.2745105922,
-0.3310823739,
-0.3566951752,
-0.3567488492,
0.0904759988,
0.1757941395,
-0.3352360129,
0.2855115831,
0.4688681364,
-0.0064550205,
0.2075555474,
-0.4971247315,
0.4916736484,
0.1651096493,
-0.0372987427,
-0.5647017956,
0.3713156879,
0.6570960879,
-0.5916205645,
0.3034879565,
0.4351513684,
-0.2318188846,
-0.4059638083,
-0.4994623661,
-0.7857732773,
-0.4855920374,
0.3121231794,
-0.10950955,
-0.876726687,
0.2784693241,
-0.0881009325,
0.3625939488,
0.3646781147,
0.252412647,
-0.505538106,
1.006206274,
0.2843495309,
0.1593292058,
0.652146101,
-0.548805356,
0.0997562781,
-0.6061992645,
-0.0283351466,
-0.3606630564,
-0.2299560457,
-0.5288071036,
-0.42410478,
0.2746495306,
-0.418713063,
-0.4679963589,
0.7095763087,
-0.5162028074,
0.4286457002,
0.6139352322,
0.2055926025,
0.3655529022,
0.5958526134,
0.0988563895,
-0.0679753721,
-0.7829181552,
-0.2706745565,
1.2884117365,
0.6173774004,
0.455367893,
-0.088802211,
0.6142023206,
0.6568595767,
0.3308955431,
-0.753169179,
0.1544186622,
-0.2981780767,
-0.8262015581,
-0.6052734852,
-0.3612397015,
-0.4855901301,
-0.0166956857,
-0.5923500657,
-0.1728517264,
-0.165873751,
0.1786417067,
-0.3350380957,
0.086857371,
-0.5486516356,
0.847155571,
0.0253413916,
0.0093226703,
-0.0161823966,
-0.5811436176,
0.0950855091,
-0.2233071774,
0.3817105591,
-0.0752566457,
0.2246687561,
0.6847586632,
-0.4594484568,
0.6208419204,
-0.031789355,
-0.220216617,
0.6777753234,
0.0349413194,
0.2318692207,
0.2293157429,
0.2361391932,
0.3707306087,
0.0063491259,
-0.2616122365,
-0.5516570807,
0.3886042535,
-0.7347406149,
-0.2723922133,
-0.1009890363,
-0.9828362465,
-0.517734468,
0.0739229694,
0.3755653203,
0.7428054214,
-0.0856384113,
0.3210709989,
0.516554296,
-0.3311474621,
0.4683869183,
0.2233798951,
-0.0130819064,
-0.8871457577,
0.7839606404,
-0.1932852417,
0.5505700707,
0.5835935473,
0.1095322594,
-0.6591852903,
-0.5221235752,
-0.6754011512,
0.1654680818,
-0.3707912266,
-0.1882161945,
-0.5204227567,
-0.2481778115,
-0.4254908264,
-0.0294416361,
-0.7481905818,
-0.6545670629,
-0.2128213942,
-0.3301107287,
0.5039522648,
0.0935577154,
-0.145367682,
0.6287879944,
-1.0843297243,
0.522139132,
0.3186914623,
0.2646276951,
-0.2866733968,
-0.7465001941,
-0.2947826385,
0.263230592,
-0.0371185504,
-0.5777398944,
0.4593972564,
0.4538052082,
0.1646857858,
0.0496134646,
0.1550388932,
0.3020437658,
-0.7960376143,
0.7936961055,
0.4379286468,
-1.0048412085,
0.6032706499,
-0.7369232774,
0.2358498871,
0.6061215401,
-0.11417,
-0.3658619225,
-0.673407197,
-0.3993616104,
-0.8768343925,
0.4376570284,
0.7162698507,
0.6005172133,
0.1327626109,
0.2323259562,
0.1737118512,
0.4416993558,
-0.9049933553,
-0.0715287179,
-0.5726456046,
-0.5104358196,
-0.238338992,
0.1930171996,
-0.1060718819,
-0.1283528805,
0.7485364676,
-0.1455604583,
0.2746155858,
0.1270861179,
0.1065629199,
-0.2718855739,
0.2040416002,
0.3937719762,
0.2515097558,
-0.2668880522,
-0.1068153232,
0.1143663526,
-0.3791491687,
0.352601558,
0.0374913923,
0.0264637899,
0.1219184399,
0.5087866783,
0.9433117509,
0.1086660028,
-0.9502129555,
0.3552299738,
0.1140706763,
-0.2443896085,
-0.6011561751,
0.0391104706,
-0.0128691467,
-0.0514408797,
0.2751903236,
0.3897197843,
0.2522053123,
-0.5603507161,
0.4265692532,
0.0401935652,
-0.5817949176,
0.0088676224,
0.9746524096,
0.5203480124,
-0.3774626851,
0.6138178706,
0.3598825634,
-0.015521042,
0.6005693674,
0.4316011071,
1.0167851448,
-0.0719069913,
0.0962651372,
0.5746526122,
0.2669281363,
-0.1303485483,
0.0431336164,
-0.2667253911,
-0.5359203815,
-0.8068761826,
-0.6596719623,
-0.4898405969,
0.1395199448,
-0.5252720714,
0.5152017474,
-0.3943659067,
-0.0999079943,
-0.0966316536,
-0.4071087837,
-0.3874851167,
0.6724980474,
-0.0041247089,
0.8645378947,
-1.0887364149,
0.384265393,
0.5833866596,
-0.60977,
-0.811809659,
-0.0170026384,
-0.4202469885,
-0.2374900877,
0.2547099292,
0.406945318,
0.0974403769,
0.1317389607,
-0.6733192205,
-0.7787534595,
0.9019058943,
0.3466041684,
-0.9659565687,
-0.0375477634,
0.5864064097,
0.7235050201,
-0.6753440499,
-0.1376615018,
0.4666564167,
0.4370044172,
0.1754367054,
-0.9092020392,
-0.2758240104,
-0.1103173047,
-0.2899919748,
0.0284103267,
-0.2288905978,
0.5435791016,
0.0333684869,
-0.1427270323,
0.2984882891,
0.8367618918,
0.3629443347,
0.4110254049,
0.7784113884,
0.4787546694,
0.2260554135,
-0.2941876352,
1.0235470533,
-0.1434493512,
0.2101235688,
1.3238484859,
0.1423549056,
0.8141773343,
0.4884212017,
0.0025391483,
0.3427392542,
0.6617155075,
-0.2430646718,
0.7399654388,
0.3877087235,
-0.2402453572,
-0.4330901504,
-0.131960988,
0.0070560365,
0.527864337,
0.023255771,
-0.5263878703,
0.2599717081,
0.2368306369,
-0.4694077373,
0.4218059778,
-0.1029500142,
0.6622212529,
0.0607900023,
-0.4827747643,
0.3176007271,
-0.2844191492,
0.5431904197,
-0.2661382854,
-0.1313970983,
-0.0335319899,
-0.2545803189,
-0.0463345982,
-0.4413336217,
0.3762741387,
0.1590965837,
-0.5201299787,
-0.2036230564,
0.2681312859,
-0.871460557,
-0.5677953362,
0.1119165644,
0.1925678849,
0.0510045663,
-0.3151735961,
-0.2125345916,
-0.0858947486,
-0.1781514138,
0.2478051633,
-0.2479757369,
0.1458436102,
0.1080929413,
0.3777111173,
0.9390323162,
0.2740502059,
0.0007091593,
0.4377049506,
0.3848976195,
-0.2877019346,
-0.7327714562,
-0.4536301792,
0.7114937901,
-0.0559358746,
0.1217742711,
0.2870560884,
0.7913229465,
0.9167715311,
-0.4950062931,
0.9844915271,
0.1142142266,
0.7694756389,
-0.6760676503,
0.8800824881,
-0.6929802895,
0.3354709744,
-0.391906023,
-1.3765530586,
-0.3254048228,
0.3998533785,
0.1843227744,
0.0326751135,
0.4560540915,
0.798966527,
-0.4503387809,
0.2383280843,
0.1302430481,
0.150261879,
0.389442265,
0.1788627356,
0.8161010146,
-0.8872932196,
0.7274528146,
-0.1488335729,
0.0633144155,
0.1452403218,
-0.8801054358,
-0.8719034195,
-0.6611740589,
-0.6542342901,
-0.1572752297,
0.0283371229,
0.8946116567,
1.027780652,
-1.1770868301,
-0.1998821646,
-0.4124855399,
-0.4505350888,
-0.313880533,
-0.2526317239,
0.2601469159,
-0.2551091611,
-1.089099884,
0.6745381951,
-0.0158044547,
0.2831142545,
-0.1915477514,
-0.2254252732,
0.1864333749,
0.4480555058,
0.605068326,
0.1004941911,
-0.543277204,
-0.4528838098,
-0.0196984019,
0.2829816043,
0.1454680711,
0.794025898,
-0.3621571958,
0.7125828266,
0.4547511339,
0.5700704455,
0.7115903497,
-0.1175942793,
1.035379529,
-1.2045150995,
-0.026639659,
0.2181872874,
0.1769711673,
0.6636530161,
0.0265813246,
0.5774922371,
0.1578151733,
-0.3231832981,
-0.9169510007,
-0.0388132893,
-1.2185479403,
0.0928509459,
1.1535925865,
0.0925283507,
0.3096213937,
0.2714032829,
-0.5830886364,
0.6187807322,
-0.53486377,
0.822778523,
0.588589251,
0.2638314068,
-0.3083045483,
-0.473043412,
0.690828979,
0.3431023359,
-0.7499323487,
0.1158313602,
0.7871774435,
0.2755456865,
0.288700521,
0.1107793823,
-0.2079054117,
0.4969184399,
0.0255293269,
-0.0214357469,
-0.399445504,
-0.6400324106,
-0.0194383003,
-0.0102711227,
-0.2551642358,
-0.4457457662
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12141v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12141v1 | A dual task learning approach to fine-tune a multilingual semantic speech encoder for Spoken Language Understanding | 2024-06-17T23:07:53 | 2024-06-17T23:07:53 | Gaëlle Laperrière, Sahar Ghannay, Bassam Jabaian, Yannick Estève | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Self-Supervised Learning is vastly used to efficiently represent speech for
Spoken Language Understanding, gradually replacing conventional approaches.
Meanwhile, textual SSL models are proposed to encode language-agnostic
semantics. SAMU-XLSR framework employed this semantic information to enrich
multilingual speech representations. A recent study investigated SAMU-XLSR
in-domain semantic enrichment by specializing it on downstream transcriptions,
leading to state-of-the-art results on a challenging SLU task. This study's
interest lies in the loss of multilingual performances and lack of
specific-semantics training induced by such specialization in close languages
without any SLU implication. We also consider SAMU-XLSR's loss of initial
cross-lingual abilities due to a separate SLU fine-tuning. Therefore, this
paper proposes a dual task learning approach to improve SAMU-XLSR semantic
enrichment while considering distant languages for multilingual and language
portability experiments. | [
-0.1469500214,
-0.5047369599,
0.4112090468,
-0.1760983169,
-0.3960265815,
0.1744570732,
-0.4737823308,
-0.5914135575,
0.1137378663,
0.5007254481,
-0.7458643913,
-0.2491178513,
-0.6758844852,
0.1424509883,
0.198656857,
0.9058489203,
0.0498475581,
0.4277909994,
-0.1670318544,
-0.3509666026,
-0.4550824761,
-0.3929451704,
-0.7933190465,
-0.1781515181,
0.4282019138,
0.4871385694,
0.4441741705,
0.4292325974,
0.1452463269,
0.2828728855,
-0.1279612184,
0.3168672025,
-0.3918529451,
0.2689427733,
-0.5058842301,
-0.4568817914,
-0.120470196,
-0.3513837755,
0.9510010481,
0.5295695066,
0.0828390792,
0.3505424857,
0.1957212687,
0.4615296125,
-0.5516979098,
0.4381709695,
-0.8780016899,
0.0172247719,
-0.2937598825,
0.0051133474,
-0.406847626,
0.3221517205,
-0.1067321002,
-0.4622685611,
0.112455219,
-0.451731503,
0.792501092,
0.624489367,
-0.7043272853,
-0.2707203031,
-0.6328189969,
1.012244463,
-0.4718189538,
0.8994147778,
0.3892328441,
0.2101903558,
0.2348115742,
-0.4407495558,
-0.3345102072,
-0.1833178401,
-0.3393821418,
0.2720154226,
-0.0361152105,
-0.0449528135,
0.0017276743,
0.0587135144,
-0.6549760103,
0.1651921421,
-0.3868292272,
-0.2016190439,
0.6486805081,
0.0112724714,
0.3360016346,
-0.230931282,
-0.3248365819,
0.012257087,
-0.5176699758,
0.1766932458,
0.2715066969,
0.728533864,
-0.1034485623,
0.3570213318,
-0.0796206146,
0.5956845284,
-0.015706338,
-0.3068143427,
0.4562363327,
-0.6452414989,
-0.0373276249,
0.2667390704,
0.4023157656,
-0.2164793015,
-0.199195087,
-0.4194412231,
-0.0836111382,
0.2779725492,
0.1669148803,
-0.397631377,
0.1916394234,
0.1370874047,
-0.1993129104,
0.2988966405,
-0.0274536274,
-0.3090763092,
0.16434066,
-0.8687992692,
0.5361941457,
-0.4057393372,
-0.5076560974,
-0.0050672968,
-0.0226297248,
-0.0266050976,
0.0000471958,
-0.8053799868,
0.3042826951,
0.6846577525,
0.5766183138,
-0.124090679,
-0.5408068299,
-0.9108998179,
0.5182423592,
0.1492132843,
0.4660378993,
-0.5621414781,
-0.2648109496,
-0.309437573,
0.2584877014,
-0.3337799013,
-0.3476499021,
0.5376447439,
-0.3644276261,
-0.1415192485,
-0.15793401,
-0.3298841417,
-0.2228921652,
-0.2718137801,
-0.4576589167,
0.9108558893,
0.0508749075,
-0.5817213058,
0.55914253,
-0.4939203858,
-0.7272244096,
0.1530074328,
-0.3966544867,
-0.3425914645,
0.0159085393,
0.0767913833,
0.5542347431,
0.1822542846,
0.3643127084,
-0.0244850013,
-0.3484407961,
0.0192981455,
-0.0636297986,
0.6600400209,
0.3775720596,
-0.4968971014,
0.1635510474,
-0.657346487,
0.1932082027,
-0.0873946622,
0.0483415984,
-0.6130355597,
-0.1217880324,
0.0706698522,
0.4653653502,
0.329447329,
-0.8530709147,
-0.4872379005,
-0.3907543123,
0.6093037724,
0.5301383138,
-0.3454710543,
0.4398760498,
0.0179551933,
0.3152463734,
0.2400723845,
-0.0774178207,
-0.0136509836,
-0.2054881155,
-0.7095753551,
-0.2225198448,
0.1495893598,
0.6832213402,
-0.6378540397,
0.4018214941,
-0.3915586472,
-0.2594893873,
-1.0051091909,
0.3582297564,
0.7445058227,
0.2878144085,
0.5970631242,
-0.1587051749,
-0.6262325048,
-1.0129250288,
-0.3150283694,
0.154734239,
0.1628410518,
0.3161656857,
0.3790189624,
-0.496203959,
0.7942454815,
-0.1024818718,
-0.6593922973,
-0.4645142257,
0.074594602,
-0.1624099612,
0.550970614,
0.1184353158,
-1.0505423546,
-0.6419254541,
0.3710230291,
-0.5980732441,
0.2619262338,
-0.1944223642,
-0.086701408,
0.3621415496,
0.4032172561,
-0.5486718416,
0.3437473178,
0.5786240101,
-0.1448204815,
0.2636305392,
-0.4475260377,
0.1474695504,
-1.0399553776,
-0.1159194857,
-0.0430505723,
-0.276794225,
-0.8015468717,
0.3421841264,
0.3756174743,
-0.2244181782,
-0.4003000557,
0.3906176388,
-0.5273376703,
-0.1721553802,
-0.3151606917,
0.5103725195,
-0.0856820866,
0.4085293412,
0.4619951844,
0.8482359648,
0.7098921537,
-0.460247606,
-0.0190164819,
0.1760350615,
-0.0142833106,
0.4288809001,
-0.4690645337,
0.1535900235,
-0.3935543001,
0.0832791328,
-0.8937140107,
0.0310181808,
0.1168703362,
-0.4142204821,
0.7277613282,
-0.2517080009,
-0.3121207654,
-0.0732678846,
0.1849055588,
0.3957877755,
0.3921854198,
-0.5221619606,
0.6342682838,
0.5518103242,
-0.2767932713,
-0.7016146779,
-1.0623208284,
0.0164108966,
-0.1852733046,
-0.6336207986,
0.4154184163,
0.0913504511,
-0.128353104,
0.0291033983,
-0.1602893472,
0.086922504,
-0.1908064932,
0.3011665642,
-0.0478933044,
-0.2366593331,
0.3403654397,
0.5148327351,
-0.3847346008,
-0.0389366858,
-0.4268449247,
0.1800256371,
-0.2876957655,
-0.4109942615,
-0.7847262025,
0.5878658295,
0.1284238994,
-0.5289415717,
0.7482414246,
0.7826920748,
-0.0458804816,
-0.0997308716,
-0.6025280952,
-0.1330284923,
-0.4447489977,
0.3681084812,
-0.9472140074,
-1.1378501654,
0.3694927692,
0.0179816131,
-0.0962555334,
0.4234907627,
0.3579995334,
0.1921637505,
0.7733432651,
0.5921349525,
0.0181992147,
0.175959006,
-0.1948724836,
0.1206615567,
-0.7383357286,
-0.1646520346,
-0.4443805814,
0.0505660586,
-0.6163589954,
-0.5401617885,
0.1655091345,
-0.2094227076,
-0.0756621212,
0.5632250905,
-0.2672615647,
0.204617992,
0.4920385778,
0.3302336335,
0.3029280007,
0.0448604636,
-0.2433229089,
-0.2144647539,
-0.6029183865,
-0.3430648446,
0.6960490346,
0.2063419521,
0.5310513973,
0.1611932367,
0.9985522628,
-0.0070565678,
-0.3995739222,
-0.4278151691,
0.4272353947,
-0.5434913635,
-0.3078512847,
-0.6109329462,
-0.6253172755,
-0.8899974823,
0.6076427102,
0.1071038619,
-0.6105323434,
-0.0235438943,
0.1066251844,
-0.1239589527,
0.2224173546,
-0.7916094661,
1.0172960758,
-0.2991973758,
-0.3649366796,
-0.6666946411,
-1.0444624424,
0.0134708099,
-0.1686929017,
0.5920351148,
-0.0525609739,
-0.1633693576,
0.4829468131,
0.0544044189,
0.9503535628,
-0.3217727244,
-0.2440497726,
-0.0155284191,
-0.2054184079,
0.3844414353,
0.2662558854,
-0.0489090756,
0.1655962914,
0.1121638939,
-0.5120265484,
-0.4016956687,
0.8137223721,
-0.7840115428,
-0.4543249905,
-0.2650265992,
-0.4379166067,
-0.2950883806,
0.0446260162,
0.1789853126,
0.5293384194,
-0.0130022923,
-0.1295027435,
0.6887928247,
-0.0470816605,
0.155545041,
0.5696382523,
0.2021038681,
-0.1996732503,
1.0626958609,
0.062253546,
0.5729875565,
0.6386282444,
0.0450580083,
-0.3995738924,
-0.4502711892,
-0.7559619546,
0.5107492805,
-0.6912516356,
0.0069290902,
-0.7541115284,
-0.1334487051,
-0.6623464227,
0.1384233534,
-0.387327373,
-0.3354498446,
-0.5211727023,
-0.0316480882,
0.1540646404,
0.5420737863,
-0.2594442368,
0.0596763045,
-0.9452956915,
0.3777080774,
0.0976219848,
0.161554724,
-0.1165602282,
-0.7147769332,
-0.3381815553,
0.4296041727,
0.1995866597,
-0.5503159761,
0.1798273027,
0.5705212951,
0.7893672585,
0.2585708797,
0.0474559925,
1.063598156,
-0.6198439598,
0.6990824342,
0.1278216988,
-1.0653837919,
0.8174920082,
-0.0065152147,
0.5849951506,
0.6550650597,
0.5135723948,
-0.6196051836,
-0.6192820668,
-0.5215499401,
-0.5421007872,
0.9141756892,
0.0752550215,
0.1419022232,
0.0979455858,
0.269305706,
0.5571742654,
-0.1893187314,
-0.7199058533,
-0.3441821337,
-0.2201622128,
0.0106680263,
-0.4209224582,
-0.2907806933,
0.1273600757,
-0.3012762368,
0.9167241454,
-0.1167330369,
-0.0039068959,
0.0546428189,
-0.5338819623,
-0.1787249297,
0.5771415234,
0.4656353593,
0.5970084071,
0.1490955502,
0.1970446706,
0.3316968381,
-0.4090653956,
0.0880920067,
0.4059002399,
-0.1170482188,
0.0504057445,
0.1032505035,
1.0279127359,
0.5332117677,
-0.753203094,
0.2562257349,
-0.0646474287,
-0.0223378465,
-0.4143217802,
-0.068119064,
0.0722532198,
0.1487953812,
0.2526017725,
0.0275145192,
0.166824922,
-0.4825502932,
0.3665945828,
0.6385333538,
-0.5329952836,
-0.2324639112,
0.6084188819,
-0.066432409,
0.1246466488,
0.2744769752,
-0.531897068,
-0.35983482,
0.2207910717,
0.6797115207,
0.6519093513,
-0.5593584776,
0.1893504411,
0.3506239355,
0.0950964093,
0.2847905457,
0.296043545,
-0.5132744312,
-0.5160920024,
-0.6893208623,
-0.6392509937,
-0.116721876,
-0.1577218771,
-0.884626627,
0.2590475082,
0.3472091556,
-0.0811522976,
0.0878705531,
-0.0712995827,
-0.4986293912,
0.2027423233,
0.2200648934,
0.4074893892,
-0.7035526037,
1.1850117445,
0.8981463909,
-0.2473846376,
-0.6673517823,
-0.1995591372,
-0.1084579378,
-0.616699338,
1.100967288,
0.1412590593,
-0.6722828746,
-0.0167434122,
0.245476082,
-1.0824273825,
0.9746178985,
0.3982970715,
-0.5237327218,
0.0306300744,
0.4762248993,
0.4450392425,
-0.1132890061,
0.0831064507,
0.4433729351,
0.1621502936,
0.1299160719,
-1.1919137239,
-0.0617884621,
-0.0471480526,
0.1068804413,
0.4672460258,
-0.6407631636,
0.4413135648,
-0.2525504529,
-0.3535161912,
0.0542264618,
0.8987551332,
-0.1875436753,
0.3853889108,
0.4930335879,
0.4960928261,
0.5680964589,
0.0733206123,
0.4534341097,
-0.1721503884,
0.3430985212,
1.3542337418,
-0.3268091083,
1.0457900763,
0.5190421343,
-0.1548351645,
0.4109884799,
0.3676510155,
0.2798187733,
0.6045120955,
-0.0831835344,
-0.5232982039,
-0.4351867735,
-0.0974909738,
-0.3700737357,
0.7419911027,
0.6063294411,
-0.1769439578,
-0.337549746,
0.6309810281,
-0.0665498301,
0.1979016215,
-0.346745342,
0.8642134666,
0.1503501087,
-0.5563204885,
0.5458478332,
-0.0230932813,
0.6544196606,
-0.760951519,
0.133708775,
0.1044057235,
0.2661882639,
-0.1419330984,
-0.5719124675,
0.5719921589,
-0.2817027867,
0.0828103647,
-0.3372486234,
0.7928711772,
-0.7880023718,
-0.3234187365,
0.6103765965,
0.4598865509,
0.2737293541,
0.0323748812,
-0.7394583225,
0.0348134525,
0.0823764727,
0.3406639099,
0.6639363766,
0.3540428877,
0.2700000405,
0.5712525249,
0.3876665533,
-0.0671163276,
0.0454966314,
0.2124961764,
0.59708184,
-0.4847736061,
-0.8256660104,
-0.6704446077,
0.3995914161,
0.0220425148,
-0.0810769424,
0.9038738012,
0.7328326106,
1.1737017632,
-0.2393612117,
0.8300589919,
-0.0042306669,
0.6988947988,
-0.6593026519,
0.4819477201,
-0.7553600073,
-0.0692253932,
-0.1675888747,
-0.3744551241,
-0.2486979216,
0.5346114635,
-0.1551909298,
-0.177134335,
0.7161216736,
0.7886610627,
-0.2559400201,
0.3110043108,
0.5629171729,
-0.0269315988,
-0.274722904,
0.5691857934,
0.6702430248,
-0.2410366237,
0.5094681382,
-0.5269163847,
-0.2280764878,
0.1273523718,
-0.5353789926,
-0.9338517785,
-1.0407836437,
-0.4073407948,
-0.1215721592,
0.3299472928,
0.7601373196,
0.7301604748,
-0.8130713701,
-0.3914829195,
0.1265579015,
-0.1280642748,
-0.5139095187,
-0.1461268663,
0.4792206287,
-0.8888478875,
-0.6309112906,
0.6689304709,
0.194364652,
-0.1785718054,
-0.1201707423,
-0.1735386997,
-0.1695392281,
-0.4624390006,
0.7486578822,
0.18701832,
-1.1120120287,
-0.1204885542,
-0.168688044,
0.0912731513,
0.1003762558,
0.752736032,
-0.8771857619,
0.4134434462,
0.1483016908,
0.7362397313,
0.7233074903,
-0.206324324,
0.2269167602,
-0.8149291277,
0.2668235302,
0.0579958297,
0.4099329412,
0.2166018337,
-0.5929483771,
0.4020995796,
0.0468759239,
-0.5662353039,
-0.4661611021,
0.3689609766,
-1.1712509394,
-0.3409737945,
1.2025657892,
-0.2193477601,
0.0189232249,
-0.3453885615,
-0.2418659031,
0.4985471666,
-0.4256923199,
0.1947734654,
0.3324976265,
-0.2249858975,
-0.2138314247,
-0.5785024762,
0.4343616366,
0.6312751174,
-0.5508105159,
0.2787353992,
0.2706796229,
0.2192939967,
0.1355438232,
0.2639489174,
-0.0611691438,
0.4216835797,
-0.0857734606,
-0.286675632,
0.0876801834,
-0.1971998811,
-0.5727393031,
-0.1329155564,
0.1313087195,
-0.2162445188
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12138v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12138v1 | Bias in Text Embedding Models | 2024-06-17T22:58:36 | 2024-06-17T22:58:36 | Vasyl Rakivnenko, Nestor Maslej, Jessica Cervi, Volodymyr Zhukov | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Text embedding is becoming an increasingly popular AI methodology, especially
among businesses, yet the potential of text embedding models to be biased is
not well understood. This paper examines the degree to which a selection of
popular text embedding models are biased, particularly along gendered
dimensions. More specifically, this paper studies the degree to which these
models associate a list of given professions with gendered terms. The analysis
reveals that text embedding models are prone to gendered biases but in varying
ways. Although there are certain inter-model commonalities, for instance,
greater association of professions like nurse, homemaker, and socialite with
female identifiers, and greater association of professions like CEO, manager,
and boss with male identifiers, not all models make the same gendered
associations for each occupation. Furthermore, the magnitude and directionality
of bias can also vary on a model-by-model basis and depend on the particular
words models are prompted with. This paper demonstrates that gender bias
afflicts text embedding models and suggests that businesses using this
technology need to be mindful of the specific dimensions of this problem. | [
-0.1454959065,
-0.5979396701,
0.6078453064,
0.3416167498,
0.033358302,
-0.0237426907,
0.1819419116,
-0.5527012348,
-0.0717774555,
0.490883708,
-0.6217738986,
-0.3630359769,
-0.9180060029,
0.1976137012,
-0.2964016795,
1.0175340176,
0.1275061816,
0.6007446051,
-0.6877073646,
-0.3644655347,
-0.7718730569,
-0.7268103361,
-0.210708797,
-0.5446207523,
0.159102574,
-0.0718467757,
1.1142517328,
0.755834043,
0.4366617203,
0.2204718888,
-0.0838059783,
0.0480308123,
-0.07526806,
0.1354511082,
-0.1884670854,
-0.540428102,
-0.4915696084,
0.2645277679,
0.3061009943,
0.866509378,
0.1882628798,
0.2745188475,
0.1868203878,
0.7290356159,
-0.4627211988,
0.2511031926,
-0.3765873611,
0.1466114521,
0.0957049057,
0.2428027987,
-0.3447387218,
-0.3816410303,
0.7708539963,
-0.2229741514,
0.2874722183,
0.29668051,
0.5816468596,
0.1685284823,
-0.7543591857,
-0.5611716509,
-0.7942401171,
0.8556805253,
-0.365663588,
0.595416069,
0.5599070787,
-0.0052143703,
0.3434010744,
-0.1168441325,
-0.1123400629,
-0.0818079337,
-0.0241779443,
-0.3453864157,
-0.271802783,
-0.0675241947,
0.3568325341,
0.0324401297,
0.025443878,
0.2733157277,
-0.1218948513,
0.3405077159,
0.5087785125,
0.0383658186,
0.4653677642,
-0.0523541532,
-0.2765073776,
-0.0532281026,
-0.5994150639,
-0.1804172397,
0.8116391301,
0.2421251386,
0.0664660186,
0.5891661644,
0.337303251,
0.6037735939,
0.1988644898,
-0.0074293762,
0.206730336,
-0.2645174861,
-0.276597172,
0.3284944892,
0.6600220203,
0.4133650661,
0.4246018231,
-0.0319109038,
-0.0888635442,
-0.129346624,
0.7698601484,
-0.4604409933,
0.1710868627,
0.2277508527,
-0.7548173666,
-0.4930025339,
0.1082986072,
-0.54099828,
-0.7914857864,
-0.0875087529,
0.2794785798,
-0.1253746152,
-0.1467532367,
-0.2695046663,
-0.5831645727,
0.0497585163,
0.1145591438,
-0.9902257919,
0.0639986098,
0.8246013522,
0.7198476195,
0.2488523573,
-0.1707615554,
0.0231890865,
0.3153747916,
-0.459659934,
0.5062340498,
-0.947573185,
-0.6241109967,
0.2547608018,
-0.1810978651,
-0.0524041578,
-0.4675973654,
0.2970702648,
-0.1584190577,
0.3671413362,
-0.6098878384,
-0.6017850637,
-0.2637235522,
0.244197309,
-0.8708619475,
0.744233191,
-0.0498921908,
-1.0702580214,
0.8049471974,
-0.5739032626,
-0.1419050545,
-0.3562864065,
-0.7046080828,
-0.750987947,
0.1144255623,
0.2587953806,
0.6309431791,
-0.4890236259,
0.442997545,
-0.3666340709,
-0.1194297522,
0.3845561445,
-0.4356762469,
0.7831724882,
-0.1940372884,
-0.4742698967,
-0.0880024284,
-0.2660642564,
-0.6321917176,
-0.1492508948,
0.0080722198,
-0.8836752176,
0.3537954688,
0.0563017167,
0.17978625,
0.1105071604,
-0.4894064665,
0.1752998084,
-0.1494017988,
0.4462061822,
0.8588023782,
-0.1447331309,
0.8559966683,
-0.6204519868,
0.4889514446,
0.1212733239,
-0.1138043702,
0.1755535603,
-0.7323429585,
-0.1534038335,
-0.37964347,
0.3937810957,
0.478836,
-0.3088257909,
0.3742685318,
-0.2220126837,
-0.5828449726,
-0.7592263818,
0.027578989,
0.4563312829,
0.1038346887,
-0.030829275,
-0.0355798528,
-0.1094069406,
-1.337028861,
-1.0224938393,
0.1256155819,
0.0125705553,
0.6995096803,
0.5699272752,
-0.5201484561,
1.107545495,
-0.57200104,
-0.6460323334,
-0.2471090853,
0.0350541249,
0.2012419701,
0.482858479,
0.8747993708,
-0.8308427334,
-0.2598023713,
-0.1985534728,
-0.5832757354,
0.0583539456,
-0.3696318269,
-0.1881327331,
0.1819204837,
0.3300493658,
-0.5035902858,
0.6718111038,
0.5446760654,
-0.6237318516,
0.3467320502,
-0.1855148673,
-0.1876415759,
-1.0922532082,
-0.0916339159,
0.5635945797,
-0.4071243703,
-0.5785477161,
-0.0921862274,
-0.0302889887,
-0.0219821222,
-0.0425743051,
0.4358543158,
-0.7017971873,
-0.3655770421,
-0.2525530159,
0.0246199295,
0.1139519438,
0.003200666,
0.1576951593,
0.4779310822,
0.4285711944,
-0.675554812,
-0.0360923596,
0.58847785,
-0.3300526142,
0.6043307185,
-0.7895497084,
0.1492996514,
-0.2336397916,
0.4314946532,
-0.7409542203,
0.2297777534,
0.124032937,
-0.2717530429,
0.1929032505,
0.0252983831,
-0.4537914097,
-0.2181203365,
-0.3772521019,
0.5208393335,
0.2135709971,
-0.4042284489,
0.7670783401,
0.4714160264,
-0.0124964025,
-0.7144665122,
-1.1298488379,
-0.271240294,
-0.089074403,
-0.552446723,
0.5678129196,
0.2019560933,
-0.4134389162,
0.0361945108,
-0.019027289,
-0.1875632554,
0.0558493137,
0.477628082,
0.1812726408,
0.2354194969,
0.0714160353,
0.1753559709,
0.0908937752,
0.223422274,
-0.0616097376,
0.417119652,
0.2632017136,
-0.5734949112,
-0.361853838,
0.5036450028,
0.6471785307,
-0.1082207188,
1.0980490446,
0.5319030881,
-0.7068943977,
-0.1835367084,
-0.4046030343,
-0.2297384292,
-0.454639852,
0.5761334896,
-0.0086872969,
-0.7082569599,
0.509141326,
0.0325360894,
0.2992677391,
0.4043422639,
0.5903658271,
-0.0011069245,
1.4468176365,
0.9336948991,
-0.4113577604,
0.3956362605,
-0.1688242257,
0.4869765639,
-0.7474442124,
-0.3650316298,
-0.8988941908,
-0.5493514538,
-1.2002829313,
-0.076154612,
0.0145708043,
-0.475856185,
-0.3119608164,
-0.0793941468,
-0.6444537044,
0.0248530675,
0.8370816112,
0.1702349037,
-0.1185048297,
-0.0340300761,
-0.1070548594,
-0.2537553012,
-0.6237754822,
-0.697289288,
0.9764730334,
0.7730000019,
0.7414782643,
0.2613453567,
0.4551144242,
0.6381056905,
0.1847014427,
-0.6185273528,
0.0190543421,
-0.5110011101,
-1.1594713926,
-0.0656759664,
0.0064951549,
-0.6433163881,
0.0603003055,
-0.4006697237,
-0.6466507912,
0.6087270379,
0.0439634025,
-0.0534744188,
0.4818482399,
-0.4460426569,
0.683062315,
0.1050562561,
-0.3594949245,
-0.0437663682,
-0.2665009201,
0.1402287185,
-0.0555540994,
0.4616437852,
0.0661517829,
0.0702299476,
0.7931173444,
-0.3830749094,
1.1879392862,
-0.1120051593,
-0.2207793593,
-0.1026177928,
-0.0030182824,
0.490188092,
0.0274953619,
-0.2268668264,
0.3432394266,
-0.0552039072,
-0.3614277244,
-0.2418080866,
0.4378841221,
-0.9870145917,
-0.6381370425,
-0.8270730972,
-0.3981715143,
-0.2605141401,
0.0263742991,
0.3797783554,
0.571500361,
-0.3016636968,
0.2074330151,
0.6788246632,
-0.5715143085,
0.2538096309,
-0.1082975268,
-0.1564962119,
-0.0215935335,
0.5341255665,
0.3295231164,
0.0367172845,
0.2495825589,
0.1511795819,
-0.1201820299,
0.0652624816,
-0.4057721794,
0.1362149864,
-0.476744473,
-0.0651341453,
-0.7722482681,
-0.2832095325,
-0.4514297545,
-0.4082795978,
-0.3374396861,
-0.1524936855,
-0.6765450835,
-0.2066349685,
0.3597068191,
1.0362528563,
0.5927442908,
0.3508229256,
-0.5599024892,
0.2015169561,
0.2750101984,
0.3226322234,
0.2214660794,
-0.2523346245,
-0.0907228589,
0.0928799659,
-0.3206580579,
-1.222017765,
0.3558468521,
0.0428152457,
0.6665330529,
0.6659513116,
-0.2526241839,
-0.0061425162,
-0.551789999,
0.9864297509,
-0.0292685516,
-1.0015817881,
0.2417027354,
-0.5543945432,
0.1318399161,
0.3301413357,
0.8339576721,
-0.4650760293,
-0.3747595549,
-0.5599295497,
-0.732855618,
0.6821331978,
-0.019091798,
0.6426597834,
-0.1201582253,
0.360042721,
0.5194956064,
0.6866118312,
-0.8720849752,
-0.5367593169,
-0.0570866764,
-0.317982018,
0.3315547407,
-0.7173252702,
0.1298995167,
-0.1857272983,
0.5736065507,
0.2133967131,
0.8842650652,
0.0740342662,
-0.1366529316,
0.2831908166,
0.1321952045,
0.3639100194,
0.8069275618,
-0.3117277622,
-0.0721982047,
-0.1507387161,
-0.6886864901,
-0.0156164523,
-0.2130166143,
-0.3309770525,
0.2500447035,
0.4158470631,
0.9282073975,
0.0407647826,
-0.1873600781,
0.7156672478,
0.1410047561,
-0.4251942933,
-0.3263019621,
-0.0638178289,
0.00632626,
0.4127748907,
0.4413678944,
0.1948918998,
0.2171814144,
-0.6995018721,
-0.2964368761,
0.7088341713,
-0.7440656424,
-0.0003774928,
0.8933139443,
0.3682917655,
-0.4747212529,
0.6081718206,
0.1498368382,
-0.7788063884,
0.7586729527,
0.5250092745,
1.2022173405,
-0.1445922405,
0.2179121077,
0.0370942391,
0.6010394692,
-0.180500105,
0.3069682717,
0.4496967494,
-0.853638351,
0.1497831792,
-0.2503277063,
-0.4723495841,
-0.3339862227,
-0.5908331275,
0.4226606786,
-0.5832082629,
-0.6716433764,
0.048117023,
-0.3269393742,
-1.0901608467,
0.2191574126,
0.0262331571,
0.7525096536,
-0.8760656118,
0.4425200224,
0.9189017415,
-0.186556071,
-0.3106454611,
0.2237091213,
0.0181164276,
-0.5780208111,
0.7067795396,
0.4374111593,
0.1357745081,
-0.226003021,
-0.2287739068,
-0.5813521147,
1.1360726357,
0.0755212381,
-0.6790060997,
-0.3409573138,
0.2974219322,
0.3452945352,
-0.7813891768,
0.5735933781,
0.2330103815,
0.3256205022,
-0.9202647805,
-0.8470302224,
0.1084234864,
0.1090227813,
0.392716527,
-0.1721850783,
-0.6815477014,
0.7243627906,
-0.0016616912,
0.3227061927,
-0.4012576342,
0.3956227899,
0.1738667041,
0.5314278007,
0.3746709228,
0.2632823288,
0.7815083861,
0.0462710187,
1.0468430519,
-0.3264303803,
0.0646641999,
0.8710017204,
-0.1675072163,
0.5038176179,
0.1880936623,
-0.0822043046,
0.9284059405,
0.4051583409,
-0.3450320363,
0.3678033054,
-0.0262850672,
0.0371636264,
0.0623188801,
-0.3056667447,
-0.49264884,
0.6173805594,
0.2527405024,
-1.2174198627,
0.2918033302,
0.0940232947,
0.1576156467,
-0.0206786022,
-0.1994683295,
0.5223568678,
0.2475727499,
-0.2722132206,
-0.3834216893,
0.4170542359,
0.8875665069,
-0.3562712073,
0.133883521,
0.0482419059,
0.0332182981,
-0.2551452219,
-0.6352365017,
0.2293293476,
-0.007553495,
-0.6227220297,
-0.474413991,
0.8590533137,
-0.3224034905,
-0.5540186167,
0.207136333,
0.7393350601,
-0.3265244067,
-0.2648559809,
-0.58045578,
-0.1632256061,
0.1497645676,
-0.1627180427,
0.3679329157,
0.2445153445,
-0.1754225045,
0.6691243649,
0.286772728,
-0.2323578745,
-0.0975163728,
0.1143981591,
0.5109991431,
-0.6831894517,
-0.7504228354,
-1.1244274378,
0.205233112,
-0.0690174997,
-0.3643245995,
0.8126665354,
0.4425110817,
0.4565906525,
-0.1767822206,
0.8946449757,
0.4533606172,
0.2906383872,
-0.1840441525,
1.0833054781,
-0.4367512465,
0.3145802021,
-0.6153222322,
-1.276356101,
0.1345993131,
0.5146200657,
-0.5040275455,
0.6558185816,
0.4203563929,
0.2470889091,
0.0492141694,
0.2931092978,
0.0673546791,
0.037543904,
0.1423516124,
-0.1281375289,
0.4683380127,
-0.2473501712,
0.0336725898,
-0.1234926432,
-0.1500802636,
-0.4292941093,
-1.1528819799,
-1.0852600336,
-0.480068475,
-0.6361202002,
-0.2619295418,
-0.0001906918,
0.9585155845,
0.553463161,
-0.3362047374,
-0.1381847113,
0.0979958847,
0.4730601013,
-0.1899131685,
-0.2442531288,
0.1629192531,
0.1913997233,
-0.7538847923,
-0.3615444899,
0.0341510698,
-0.1057668328,
-0.5604429245,
0.3709174097,
-0.3379796445,
0.4379033148,
0.3197266757,
-0.3976717889,
-0.5114911795,
-0.2012916356,
-0.016332129,
-0.2221452445,
-0.1464437991,
0.7725363374,
-0.6402914524,
0.3445134461,
0.4485761225,
0.6408907175,
0.0229191463,
0.0449597612,
0.8595572114,
-0.9565718174,
0.0262136851,
0.009767089,
0.2348475158,
0.4228361249,
-0.7975486517,
0.2717520297,
0.2907876074,
-0.5127725005,
-0.8069292307,
0.1612896621,
-0.435011059,
-0.6404107809,
1.1640474796,
0.3725579083,
-0.1886388958,
-0.0350335203,
-0.1833089441,
0.1852376163,
-0.4153964221,
0.6361857653,
0.9325924516,
0.0432051718,
0.067160897,
-0.8215238452,
0.5548642278,
0.3742197156,
-0.3125136197,
-0.0321933776,
0.3817107677,
0.3123939931,
0.0877882689,
0.3995376229,
0.0414323285,
0.0665067807,
0.0751451552,
-0.0148243578,
0.0579602569,
-0.1840458512,
-0.2337329537,
-0.1049323976,
0.2527180314,
-0.1038759127
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12131v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12131v1 | Gram2Vec: An Interpretable Document Vectorizer | 2024-06-17T22:42:14 | 2024-06-17T22:42:14 | Peter Zeng, Eric Sclafani, Owen Rambow | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present Gram2Vec, a grammatical style embedding algorithm that embeds
documents into a higher dimensional space by extracting the normalized relative
frequencies of grammatical features present in the text. Compared to neural
approaches, Gram2Vec offers inherent interpretability based on how the feature
vectors are generated. In our demo, we present a way to visualize a mapping of
authors to documents based on their Gram2Vec vectors and highlight the ability
to drop or add features to view which authors make certain linguistic choices.
Next, we use authorship attribution as an application to show how Gram2Vec can
explain why a document is attributed to a certain author, using cosine
similarities between the Gram2Vec feature vectors to calculate the distances
between candidate documents and a query document. | [
-0.1721354574,
-0.5921775699,
0.876942277,
0.0972564071,
-0.0194004271,
-0.0583011694,
-0.2360318452,
-0.2856282294,
0.3228605092,
0.2078951746,
-0.4608268738,
-0.70897609,
-0.9289343953,
-0.1405645311,
-0.5007347465,
0.7400990725,
0.0752684027,
0.0727805123,
-0.9056591392,
-0.09973187,
-0.5561305285,
-0.4089492261,
-0.3846780062,
-0.1942250729,
0.3919726014,
0.6531289816,
0.7963409424,
0.5701566935,
0.4211123288,
0.2633794546,
-0.3404888213,
0.030736167,
-0.7303455472,
0.1329059154,
-0.2204313576,
-0.8313587308,
-0.3956388235,
0.2583214343,
0.6104384065,
0.2333234102,
0.0311453063,
0.043648839,
0.1699853092,
0.3411743343,
-0.5233887434,
0.5682761073,
-0.2698890865,
-0.0439720191,
-0.2613122761,
-0.3043165207,
-0.5302445292,
-0.8590875268,
-0.2056256235,
-0.7173522711,
0.3104296327,
-0.1234224886,
0.7669709921,
-0.0147049772,
-0.387894243,
-0.7510026693,
-0.6143023372,
0.6579279304,
-0.1436631829,
0.4902155995,
0.5755447745,
0.3979221284,
-0.0700607523,
-0.8692191839,
-0.5938107371,
0.1699944586,
-0.3210946321,
0.3303282857,
-0.2407116443,
-0.1952322125,
-0.0332467705,
0.3938046694,
-0.5604320168,
0.0153718349,
-0.3833458424,
-0.0415478349,
0.3155996501,
-0.1760302335,
0.5458127856,
-0.4378194213,
-0.228140533,
-0.1430483162,
-0.5511649251,
0.2982518673,
0.7108137012,
-0.06795948,
0.1228580922,
0.6246509552,
0.3524777293,
0.4890333712,
-0.2464371175,
0.1034226716,
0.2450715452,
-0.1392968446,
0.1889860481,
0.0695798025,
0.5259673595,
0.4756016731,
0.4424714744,
-0.1231691986,
-0.0340895578,
0.1095528454,
0.6496275663,
-0.658176899,
-0.3816372156,
-0.0783203095,
-0.7719535232,
-0.5555171371,
0.5992914438,
-1.0742013454,
-0.4641580582,
-0.2633304298,
0.2191026807,
-0.5632264614,
-0.1992135346,
-0.256490916,
-0.6235375404,
0.431045562,
0.1953766644,
-1.1349157095,
0.3957501054,
1.2058845758,
0.9868835807,
0.0470282175,
0.0368733406,
-0.7586599588,
-0.081406936,
-0.2905614674,
0.8850413561,
-1.0940135717,
-0.7067455053,
0.3381031454,
0.0789441615,
0.1712432504,
-0.247673586,
0.6848551035,
-0.5470625758,
0.2213947326,
-0.2664059997,
-0.6166906357,
-0.2914440632,
-0.0818828568,
-0.6560084224,
1.120716691,
0.4478972554,
-0.6116172671,
0.2256082147,
-0.4517274201,
-0.3388537169,
0.1053064093,
-0.4470716417,
-0.3492023051,
0.2393491864,
0.151391834,
0.4808610976,
0.0626793578,
-0.1340595484,
-0.228114903,
-0.1818675846,
0.1871287972,
-0.121583946,
0.6849483848,
0.3018060029,
0.0692912042,
0.2243274599,
-1.0322545767,
-0.0075476998,
0.1324994862,
-0.3653064072,
-0.619271934,
0.2616326213,
0.3596987128,
0.0233163889,
0.2327515632,
-0.4149309397,
0.2647206485,
-0.30012995,
0.4720121026,
0.7191835642,
0.0133045977,
0.7686645389,
-0.0024663499,
0.8121872544,
-0.729806304,
-0.025252983,
0.079865694,
-0.8773133755,
-0.5321774483,
-0.4012479186,
0.1927001774,
0.733117342,
-0.5861488581,
0.5193913579,
-0.5774368048,
-0.37301898,
-0.5376849174,
0.4583331943,
0.5563462377,
0.3472986221,
0.2707490921,
-0.1141393259,
-0.3330793679,
-0.8404476047,
-0.3011293411,
-0.3823914826,
-0.2941588461,
0.2962917984,
0.2451059371,
-0.106322661,
0.8019861579,
-0.8307675123,
-0.3960655332,
-0.2192976773,
0.3383566737,
-0.2537029088,
0.3543526232,
0.7443153262,
-0.7776150107,
-0.3736124039,
0.0511620902,
-0.8729389906,
-0.3185935915,
-0.0297990125,
-0.4603242576,
-0.0265630204,
1.0419327021,
-0.1544949114,
0.5356165171,
0.6317539215,
-0.7793796659,
-0.0974267349,
-0.3872850239,
0.0389226601,
-1.1982761621,
-0.0904170647,
0.0521542355,
-0.3988090456,
-0.4104141891,
-0.0414475203,
0.374802947,
-0.0558538064,
-0.1068023145,
0.2990634441,
-0.5126435757,
-0.3040122092,
0.0463596657,
0.380265981,
0.350979507,
0.0738850012,
-0.1821208447,
0.6110136509,
0.1908707619,
-0.0822637677,
0.3911828101,
0.8371081352,
-0.4412806332,
0.7222838402,
-0.4036390781,
0.3196344376,
-0.3228995204,
-0.0064091678,
-1.2852425575,
-0.1794567257,
0.1363990456,
-0.776398778,
0.4425166845,
-0.3199536204,
-0.2966988981,
-0.0096518118,
-0.5213136673,
0.0914573669,
0.6588028669,
-0.7217845321,
0.957455337,
0.1415081173,
-0.3987190425,
-0.0071028699,
-0.9325584173,
0.106003575,
0.1851009429,
-0.9352499247,
0.2955161333,
0.3033119738,
-0.3837584555,
0.455588758,
0.4104360342,
0.1369415522,
0.0816196278,
0.7726863027,
0.206001237,
-0.0988120288,
0.3491275012,
0.2667800784,
-0.2606818378,
0.120082505,
-0.3323550224,
0.3233869076,
-0.1073344424,
-0.1743706614,
-0.2397891581,
0.5675089955,
0.3725764751,
-0.4001258016,
0.6408448219,
0.8174650669,
-0.2883522213,
-0.277376622,
-0.2938174009,
0.2317992002,
-0.450831145,
0.3109612167,
-0.6051061749,
-0.7384466529,
0.5058708787,
0.0091350609,
-0.2915853262,
0.7683444023,
0.576002717,
-0.0615406707,
0.5591698885,
0.7732491493,
0.0863381848,
0.6919710636,
-0.3753985763,
0.1555063277,
-0.7680804133,
-0.8823124766,
-0.67825073,
-0.4213633835,
-0.5903460979,
-0.734624505,
0.1318636984,
0.0683682784,
0.3694743812,
0.3114526272,
-0.6030400395,
0.5502276421,
0.7646238208,
-0.211076647,
-0.0231052916,
0.0622357167,
-0.1500925571,
-0.0930272788,
-0.2932112813,
-0.6286328435,
0.7816277742,
0.4968550205,
0.7939912677,
0.5400176048,
0.5329508185,
0.3818001449,
-0.1367452592,
-1.180029273,
0.2335711569,
-0.4488693774,
-0.2306564599,
-0.1446583122,
-0.0543566085,
-0.6296592951,
-0.0016986714,
-0.496113658,
-0.7233998775,
0.6929607987,
0.0146114537,
-0.2401502281,
0.1466815919,
-0.910071373,
0.9571334124,
0.0249445029,
-0.0790201947,
-0.1605411619,
-0.3867454827,
-0.2288166732,
0.2176004797,
0.2628243864,
0.3149780929,
-0.0858452469,
0.6729853153,
-0.3938894272,
0.6640189886,
-0.2280451506,
-0.0299027916,
0.2661006451,
0.3590415716,
0.6201974154,
0.2092802376,
-0.1877299994,
0.1309799254,
-0.1265091896,
-0.2432810068,
-0.9950517416,
0.9047141075,
-0.7000421882,
-0.323738724,
-0.3387496173,
-0.1315631717,
-0.055211693,
0.0370890908,
0.3784340024,
0.6116775274,
-0.6019414067,
0.2960304022,
0.4379146993,
-0.2530522645,
0.1656467915,
0.0425023101,
-0.1642318666,
-0.3805496395,
1.0444692373,
0.0283618141,
0.0832487941,
0.4448800683,
0.2598082125,
-0.3452578783,
-0.5212452412,
-0.2344317138,
0.0032630484,
-1.0519444942,
0.2246402204,
-0.8169220686,
-0.1526360065,
-0.6259053349,
-0.5882373452,
-0.141069755,
-0.6980608106,
-0.7751937509,
-0.3586298525,
0.5039586425,
1.2701212168,
-0.0586921163,
0.3650687039,
-0.5461116433,
0.3106742203,
0.4437998533,
0.3168600798,
-0.4875090122,
-0.7154112458,
-0.0371240303,
-0.5829778314,
-0.1253526509,
-0.7272167206,
0.2414285094,
0.3281339407,
0.3894571662,
0.7754118443,
-0.5561920404,
0.2752123475,
-0.6320477128,
0.9726015329,
0.025560746,
-0.9252759814,
0.8827688098,
-0.0648908913,
-0.0257322378,
0.4904074967,
0.3745189607,
-0.7027984262,
-0.2110566348,
-0.3929753006,
-0.773552537,
0.4792202413,
0.289950788,
0.1183846667,
0.0080742845,
0.6470612884,
0.0684498325,
-0.3563320041,
-0.1267673224,
0.0109599084,
-0.5657804012,
-0.6776383519,
-0.4504057765,
-1.1472109556,
-0.0769342855,
-0.1419394761,
0.5281066895,
-0.0468421802,
0.4788686037,
0.0123063447,
-0.1843032837,
0.1982363164,
0.2579666674,
0.6229661107,
0.5751239657,
-0.2866066098,
0.3437103331,
-0.2501054108,
-0.6305324435,
-0.1345926076,
0.1704212427,
-0.1148238033,
0.086554043,
0.8080049753,
0.9068865776,
0.063343972,
-0.0420737378,
0.905148387,
-0.2305962592,
-0.5046211481,
-0.529804647,
0.0728659555,
0.2340491116,
0.3033517897,
-0.1774867028,
0.1245843396,
0.2818368375,
-0.5584869981,
0.1393282861,
0.2339525074,
-0.9036046863,
-0.4671409726,
0.8666638136,
0.3916999102,
-0.3765254319,
0.6102295518,
-0.2438658327,
-0.6062342525,
0.5347998738,
0.3542428613,
1.0528140068,
-0.0955024362,
0.2967655957,
0.2763106823,
0.3804385364,
-0.0019978664,
0.3904679418,
0.1992234439,
-0.4766539633,
-0.0073080692,
-0.6303564906,
0.011736651,
-0.4390311837,
-0.7659538388,
0.3013332486,
-0.5576930046,
0.0139493626,
0.4541102946,
-0.3895069063,
-0.5516323447,
-0.2081808299,
0.3449244797,
0.6434177756,
-1.0405608416,
0.853320837,
0.8103734255,
-0.4628534913,
-0.5843716264,
-0.0781288594,
0.6584296227,
-0.8288039565,
0.7742048502,
0.0335449502,
-0.238278836,
-0.1547444761,
-0.2952990234,
-0.6851177216,
1.1884652376,
0.1582963914,
-0.3199582994,
-0.0271651875,
-0.00745244,
0.5471677184,
-0.2935652733,
0.1364498883,
0.569534421,
0.6297194362,
0.1899282485,
-0.2855678499,
0.0022024012,
-0.6268868446,
0.5082266927,
0.073890239,
-0.3439938426,
0.7258195281,
0.0651358068,
-0.27347368,
-0.0106471321,
0.7978838086,
-0.7378415465,
0.1050532758,
0.4199604988,
0.5717259645,
1.0590857267,
-0.1570519656,
1.3518037796,
0.021755781,
0.3774853945,
1.2766156197,
0.2187432051,
0.8480277061,
0.3865566552,
-0.0396966562,
0.8537650108,
0.1975034475,
-0.5003550053,
0.5261291862,
0.1722610742,
-0.2523536384,
-0.1650410146,
-0.0627700239,
-0.0756297633,
0.617451489,
0.2733961344,
-0.6981663108,
0.0837114975,
0.1145274937,
0.1013788655,
0.7412188053,
-0.1378959417,
0.8726422787,
0.1777145118,
-0.3596744835,
0.0992718637,
0.1913809329,
0.509511292,
-0.4409359992,
-0.3322945833,
0.002188806,
0.3245403171,
-0.618383944,
-1.101077199,
0.4411365986,
0.0790526271,
-0.4297200441,
-0.4494772851,
0.9178282619,
-0.4429124892,
-0.7785609365,
0.4888573885,
0.2489099205,
0.1554208249,
-0.0869845673,
-0.1029261202,
-0.0319399759,
-0.1213068664,
-0.2678185701,
0.0279373843,
0.6092550159,
-0.0792375952,
0.4389226139,
0.4297809005,
0.0621433221,
0.0053675286,
0.3832027316,
0.7216701508,
-0.514636755,
-0.5455238223,
-0.7977403402,
0.2661808431,
-0.0506254174,
-0.1796185672,
0.7096883655,
0.6613307595,
0.6645193696,
-0.1681522727,
0.7566261888,
-0.20103845,
0.3084008098,
-0.7284757495,
1.0459965467,
-0.5587502122,
-0.0404982045,
-0.0313601829,
-0.8427993655,
-0.3336462677,
0.6635613441,
-0.2663956881,
-0.1589722186,
0.7436731458,
0.9077793956,
-0.0675566345,
0.003914163,
0.3214607537,
0.153442204,
0.6228940487,
0.1028607935,
0.6609668732,
-0.2079583108,
0.6719146967,
-0.0667048916,
-0.2883583009,
-0.4031655192,
-0.675834775,
-1.0239063501,
-0.7385505438,
-0.143413499,
-0.486048609,
0.0060075349,
0.7526970506,
0.187930584,
-0.6931090355,
0.2179052383,
0.0628371239,
0.1124897078,
-0.1602692157,
-0.2441028059,
0.5713558793,
-0.2921620607,
-0.8220458627,
0.2932198942,
0.2870188653,
-0.0877277404,
-0.1828218699,
-0.0773912445,
-0.2420667261,
0.0677231401,
0.7815627456,
0.016389817,
-0.6433401704,
-0.6843855977,
-0.2585226595,
-0.1468278766,
0.1068539023,
0.8739888668,
-0.3430840075,
0.9480487108,
0.9021881819,
0.5739921331,
0.504365921,
0.221698001,
0.5495863557,
-0.802528441,
0.1995998323,
-0.0630482733,
0.3202464581,
0.2733182311,
-0.6944582462,
0.5801512003,
0.2806536257,
-0.3171727359,
-0.1774655879,
-0.1133417338,
-1.2930315733,
-0.3351051509,
1.6067457199,
-0.375287503,
-0.4356292784,
0.0464433469,
-0.2954674363,
0.2148506343,
-0.4617690742,
0.1903755963,
0.9679669142,
0.3166617155,
0.0832940638,
-0.8953860998,
0.6932250857,
0.102759406,
-0.5730936527,
-0.1149103194,
0.6425794959,
0.3044577837,
0.2082798779,
0.4722063243,
-0.449637413,
0.0261896998,
0.2632818222,
0.3530493677,
-0.3724404275,
-0.4548857212,
-0.6346454024,
0.1418505013,
0.2124645412,
-0.3792354465
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12128v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12128v1 | AI "News" Content Farms Are Easy to Make and Hard to Detect: A Case Study in Italian | 2024-06-17T22:19:00 | 2024-06-17T22:19:00 | Giovanni Puccetti, Anna Rogers, Chiara Alzetta, Felice Dell'Orletta, Andrea Esuli | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) are increasingly used as "content farm" models
(CFMs), to generate synthetic text that could pass for real news articles. This
is already happening even for languages that do not have high-quality
monolingual LLMs. We show that fine-tuning Llama (v1), mostly trained on
English, on as little as 40K Italian news articles, is sufficient for producing
news-like texts that native speakers of Italian struggle to identify as
synthetic.
We investigate three LLMs and three methods of detecting synthetic texts
(log-likelihood, DetectGPT, and supervised classification), finding that they
all perform better than human raters, but they are all impractical in the real
world (requiring either access to token likelihood information or a large
dataset of CFM texts). We also explore the possibility of creating a proxy CFM:
an LLM fine-tuned on a similar dataset to one used by the real "content farm".
We find that even a small amount of fine-tuning data suffices for creating a
successful detector, but we need to know which base LLM is used, which is a
major challenge.
Our results suggest that there are currently no practical methods for
detecting synthetic news-like texts 'in the wild', while generating them is too
easy. We highlight the urgency of more NLP research on this problem. | [
-0.4588137269,
-0.7392084002,
0.5659080744,
0.1219331101,
-0.4566921294,
0.2669976056,
-0.3299876153,
-0.7887620926,
0.3744677007,
0.4777883887,
-0.734521389,
-0.6304520965,
-0.7053153515,
0.4901334047,
-0.9188170433,
1.2257304192,
0.1237027422,
-0.0843228102,
0.0052075898,
-0.1155003905,
-0.0466969758,
-0.3140327632,
-0.9688026309,
-0.1498660296,
0.6614867449,
0.2259470075,
0.7870485187,
0.8591845036,
0.2940401435,
0.292490989,
-0.2360293865,
0.7643896341,
-0.6133352518,
-0.0881291404,
-0.1937218457,
-0.5697325468,
-0.0229451749,
0.20687069,
0.6430608034,
0.5398791432,
0.2544890344,
0.0520290732,
-0.0146451248,
0.7401450872,
-0.3694247305,
-0.1221433431,
-1.0862711668,
0.1230451316,
-0.3341265023,
-0.2210976034,
-0.4756416976,
-0.1487156451,
-0.2552621961,
-0.5912670493,
0.3527081609,
0.1836831421,
1.0448257923,
0.2378829718,
-0.6198585033,
-0.5342109203,
-0.8977065682,
0.7731801271,
-0.6677894592,
0.0909911543,
0.2650106549,
0.0120026441,
-0.6045741439,
-0.6244503856,
-1.0338792801,
-0.3109855652,
-0.1845389307,
-0.0825634152,
-0.2576383352,
-0.1998003721,
-0.0047328332,
0.4367813468,
-0.4260536134,
0.3714990914,
-0.2945328653,
-0.2839154303,
0.6676790118,
0.1931506544,
0.3392989337,
0.0127999093,
-0.1594190896,
0.0517957509,
-0.7491224408,
-0.1802508682,
0.592427671,
0.300468117,
0.0156938527,
0.6664696336,
-0.2228259444,
0.6816090345,
0.0341802575,
-0.3820422292,
0.0914381221,
-0.3527499735,
0.0048806728,
0.1651923507,
0.9144915342,
0.2035060674,
0.452429831,
-0.0948686078,
-0.4151399434,
0.3026836514,
0.4005501866,
-0.5028374791,
0.0690499619,
0.1454572529,
-0.2117104083,
-0.4833374023,
0.0044860146,
-0.3731026649,
-0.4900818765,
-0.1961398721,
0.3359379172,
-0.1624217033,
-0.103041552,
0.0487536043,
-0.1347116977,
0.2686615586,
0.2641913593,
-0.7244798541,
0.074393101,
0.7199949622,
0.9370788336,
-0.4507517219,
-0.2507400811,
-0.6603178978,
0.1022118106,
-0.6677942276,
1.1631795168,
-0.2487638444,
-0.147142604,
0.1398222744,
0.1855276227,
0.0335394368,
-0.59322083,
0.5833598971,
-0.5492863655,
0.1145172119,
0.0275673401,
-0.5457050204,
0.0081031695,
0.4756662846,
-0.8971809149,
0.80553931,
0.0540176854,
-0.6836526394,
0.4414983094,
-0.1307849735,
-0.9846943617,
-0.2764203548,
0.0019774784,
-0.4641681314,
0.2292219102,
0.1708728075,
0.3631528914,
0.0711072907,
0.2671636343,
0.1323050261,
-0.4590898752,
0.2760605514,
-0.7665296793,
0.3053741753,
0.3724960089,
-0.3480037451,
-0.2213888019,
-0.9328306913,
-0.3244713545,
-0.1123457998,
-0.7282291055,
-0.2660518587,
0.3598808646,
-0.0359677598,
-0.0411284082,
0.1704149246,
-0.4421116412,
0.1153881475,
-0.5849232674,
0.3956831992,
0.5355128646,
-0.2467178851,
0.3700655401,
-0.6784363389,
0.3055056036,
0.2057970017,
-0.1881516725,
-0.4175035059,
-0.4643265009,
-1.0628300905,
-0.2563565075,
0.2128431499,
0.4262494743,
-0.8449324965,
0.2289479375,
-0.1858257055,
-0.6865252256,
-0.6500532627,
0.422488153,
0.2335572541,
0.2223957777,
0.1874583066,
-0.0670900494,
-0.3939347267,
-0.8975034356,
-0.672490418,
0.097629346,
0.047794994,
-0.0561154298,
0.2215701789,
-0.2224784791,
0.8679981232,
-0.1799215674,
-0.3690721989,
-0.3252353966,
0.2791040838,
0.5638558269,
0.3823899031,
0.4933455586,
-1.0213394165,
-0.3812222481,
0.1181974113,
-0.6830364466,
0.0615648739,
-0.3365726471,
0.0638263524,
0.4466025233,
0.4927281439,
-0.9128972292,
0.2362284958,
0.651335597,
-0.122707665,
0.4411610067,
-0.1711890548,
0.0618076958,
-1.1769329309,
-0.2057160288,
0.1868873686,
-0.5367534161,
-0.6804828644,
0.1514420807,
-0.2827441096,
-0.0197123419,
-0.7649154663,
0.690985918,
-0.4156427681,
-0.0227780864,
-0.5626826882,
0.0236718263,
-0.0148006938,
0.3109734356,
0.1919332743,
0.8397677541,
0.0679319948,
-0.7193151116,
0.3620858788,
-0.0506772995,
-0.6820147038,
0.259549439,
-0.4611402452,
0.1027780026,
-0.3823246658,
0.5091052055,
-0.8368077278,
-0.3790796399,
0.2437129021,
-0.3733890653,
0.0609348379,
0.0267332699,
-0.7557541728,
-0.268302232,
-0.2671013176,
0.1837480068,
0.3381321728,
-0.6319523454,
0.4581743181,
0.334317863,
-0.0797176063,
-0.2874354422,
-0.8321301341,
0.3686133623,
-0.1094617918,
-0.5569127798,
0.3299151659,
0.0792271718,
-0.2303603888,
0.1308134943,
-0.1528990567,
-0.161715731,
0.1608288288,
-0.0312420968,
-0.1458460242,
-0.2510558963,
0.1821513176,
0.284930706,
-0.0635153353,
-0.0840196088,
-0.4449568689,
0.4764696062,
0.0861996412,
-0.2132204324,
-0.6527336836,
0.3243931234,
0.7133823037,
-0.1121385247,
0.8614785075,
0.758228898,
-0.4607613683,
-0.5662126541,
-0.5392559767,
-0.15960446,
-0.4852030575,
0.2017348111,
0.007719289,
-0.7212411165,
0.216434449,
-0.0463480428,
0.196687758,
0.6609739661,
0.6307446957,
-0.1545402855,
1.3835937977,
0.4799726307,
-0.1510487497,
0.370633781,
-0.2270983309,
0.2122512013,
-0.187292397,
-0.1926996559,
-0.6407991648,
-0.5683714151,
-0.9117627144,
-0.1571319401,
0.4585683048,
-0.2458647937,
-0.0198039189,
0.2733526826,
-0.4645261467,
0.7295701504,
0.843383193,
0.0427298322,
0.8583285213,
0.2478695512,
0.2312847674,
0.2510404289,
-0.7015838027,
-0.7748237848,
0.7559497356,
0.1362557709,
0.7732255459,
-0.1973505467,
0.5290244222,
0.5923983455,
0.4622370899,
-0.9303504825,
0.3523999453,
-0.7395359874,
-0.5279625058,
-0.0185562279,
-0.3335971236,
-0.8898713589,
0.0277565848,
-0.533721745,
-0.2636198401,
-0.0141061554,
0.1330651045,
-0.2736080885,
0.392398417,
-0.601650238,
0.4533113837,
-0.1774742454,
-0.2912667692,
-0.3132961392,
-0.1565643251,
0.3148860633,
-0.276065886,
0.6693995595,
-0.3066697419,
-0.0739480779,
0.4280707538,
-0.3877276182,
1.0909664631,
0.3127548695,
-0.3078813851,
0.5589988828,
0.1693119109,
0.7457260489,
0.3080056906,
-0.1620372236,
0.2637924552,
-0.054905884,
-0.4026474357,
-0.3459176421,
0.8521235585,
-0.9085352421,
-0.7699530125,
-0.4908969998,
-0.4761732519,
-0.040305756,
0.2387305796,
0.539214313,
0.2122650594,
-0.0505454205,
0.1674923301,
0.4547577798,
-0.2230939716,
0.3602799475,
0.6336730123,
0.2094082832,
-0.044950597,
1.1011545658,
0.0413816608,
0.0553985052,
0.3406979144,
0.0737306252,
-0.0431482568,
-0.6389656663,
-0.8140989542,
-0.0083487844,
-0.2178273648,
-0.335596621,
-0.6194658279,
-0.5044261217,
0.0738558024,
-0.2612399459,
-0.5018383265,
-0.2861145139,
-0.7069990635,
-0.0606410578,
0.1738855392,
0.7662495375,
-0.0258213524,
0.4854043722,
-0.9978919029,
0.5234237313,
0.2252103537,
0.1073862687,
-0.3366940618,
-0.3330105543,
-0.4404651523,
0.6550188065,
-0.3541375399,
-0.7245308757,
0.6312388778,
0.3859312832,
0.2500632107,
0.5541865826,
0.1140137687,
0.3090381622,
-0.4874011874,
0.8310406208,
-0.1477124691,
-0.7898545861,
0.5897294283,
-0.5353643894,
0.1178133562,
0.4718509614,
0.6314980388,
-0.3324935436,
-0.8962844014,
-0.2306873798,
-0.6441429853,
0.5395970345,
0.1156172678,
0.8323767185,
-0.6070465446,
0.427728653,
0.2389096022,
0.3979641199,
-1.0122381449,
0.0503564365,
0.0375443734,
-0.2884232402,
-0.0478825644,
-0.1468942314,
0.0434555225,
-0.1199840382,
0.6477068067,
-0.2359309793,
-0.051429186,
0.3187213838,
-0.1063722372,
-0.3500009775,
0.0873369277,
0.4124111235,
0.4205449522,
0.2121012062,
0.243475154,
0.0057701129,
-0.2776135206,
0.2441305816,
-0.0816197097,
-0.5332819223,
0.2987882793,
0.7043287158,
0.7254104018,
0.3080739081,
-1.0400259495,
0.4945172071,
0.0793547183,
-0.2771238983,
-0.6074371934,
0.3886766732,
0.0604828224,
0.2913909256,
0.4834609628,
0.0279645007,
-0.0378124267,
-0.9516227841,
0.0135988006,
0.5371848941,
-0.2993186116,
-0.292031467,
0.6421281099,
0.2595886886,
-0.3949078321,
0.8012022376,
-0.4463983774,
-0.4833414853,
0.8792532086,
0.6612901092,
0.4433408678,
0.1886591762,
0.5290876627,
0.0772212148,
0.4549623728,
-0.3652742803,
-0.0000418214,
0.392254889,
-1.1683591604,
-0.640897572,
-0.8458855152,
-0.2587789893,
0.320884496,
-0.3221123219,
0.4999758601,
-0.4657260776,
-0.0799672902,
0.2414446771,
0.0680851415,
-0.646818161,
0.2273572534,
0.2534042001,
1.0778397322,
-0.8351984024,
0.7052466273,
0.803312242,
-0.0462159738,
-0.6087778211,
0.0041155629,
0.0777489245,
-0.8332930207,
0.3426018059,
0.3922840059,
0.1404421628,
0.1636176258,
-0.7646059394,
-0.469769001,
0.8759680986,
0.4293904006,
-0.7910538912,
-0.1687710583,
0.3507135212,
0.8009312153,
-0.4295078814,
-0.0515726618,
0.6102359891,
0.6572541595,
0.1925322115,
-0.6730878353,
-0.2670080066,
-0.0392926894,
-0.362467438,
0.1543600261,
-0.9342558384,
0.8102163672,
-0.3244747221,
-0.4538181722,
0.211079523,
0.6415417194,
-0.0057929233,
0.7167360187,
0.5704458356,
0.5321722627,
0.555439353,
-0.0916598439,
1.1313362122,
-0.3913688958,
0.013450183,
0.7788225412,
-0.0145821106,
0.8096051812,
0.3441230953,
0.1019623876,
0.6830145717,
0.7736680508,
-0.2318238169,
0.3776271939,
0.4285395443,
-0.5036729574,
-0.4969074428,
-0.5154585242,
-0.0619879439,
0.7690679431,
0.3494248688,
-0.4168107212,
-0.1318131387,
0.0376317874,
0.2170805335,
0.3175314069,
-0.4315871596,
0.9450469017,
0.2232791185,
-0.8668534756,
0.4423870146,
0.3190180063,
0.7217010856,
-0.5030105114,
0.0733803138,
-0.5676562786,
-0.0433780625,
-0.2466576695,
-0.5768222213,
0.5614480376,
0.3232595623,
-0.3344550133,
-0.0529826805,
0.6610355973,
-0.4549564421,
-0.8023458123,
0.0879597738,
0.6488694549,
0.0114427377,
-0.2710325122,
-0.1340305358,
0.0950144157,
-0.115182355,
-0.4522767961,
0.2822543979,
0.4745230079,
-0.135462597,
0.6398255825,
1.1017043591,
0.3119291067,
-0.0275639296,
-0.185576275,
0.9237415791,
-0.5292093158,
-0.2955383658,
-0.8924951553,
0.0239451174,
0.0555590205,
-0.2369282097,
0.4466428459,
0.4932342768,
1.0864263773,
-0.022215195,
0.816083312,
0.2085944265,
0.3488669097,
-0.7743493319,
0.7683408856,
-0.7515812516,
0.3483623862,
0.160217315,
-0.9699616432,
-0.168132931,
0.3328314722,
0.1090423614,
-0.2647016048,
0.5116089582,
0.8517158628,
-0.0978826657,
0.049911879,
0.2117216289,
0.5509293079,
0.164066419,
0.4768100679,
1.0463863611,
-0.1381992698,
0.8178731203,
-0.1166396067,
-0.0269149113,
-0.0383142456,
-1.1226955652,
-0.9507082105,
-0.3260565698,
-0.0865562409,
-0.1838435531,
0.4043732584,
0.7767266035,
0.7660570145,
-0.778504014,
0.1444867998,
-0.2202732414,
0.4378767312,
-0.2006467879,
-0.1952920854,
0.1406806856,
-0.479668498,
-1.2275328636,
0.5344502926,
-0.0062189423,
0.0507522784,
-0.3149949014,
0.1427521855,
-0.0864312574,
0.2632306516,
0.5505821109,
0.2251074761,
-0.4558162689,
-0.3078636825,
-0.1343441904,
-0.2183933705,
-0.1595965773,
0.6915646195,
-0.9949034452,
0.128194049,
0.3700182438,
0.7264176011,
0.4808400869,
-0.0959094316,
0.5892503262,
-0.8388212323,
0.195100531,
0.1130249202,
0.1065632328,
0.3536769152,
-0.5229871273,
0.348688513,
0.3868284225,
-0.3151765466,
-0.5779154897,
0.1297691166,
-0.6287804246,
-0.314383924,
1.3168036938,
0.0847376361,
-0.343249619,
0.031047225,
-0.1739760935,
0.1112453341,
-0.2196540833,
1.0695607662,
0.6639717221,
0.2716460824,
0.1559337974,
-0.6403517127,
0.6461535692,
0.1972949654,
-0.753015101,
-0.4814381301,
0.4800234139,
0.2833171487,
0.1746940464,
0.4652555287,
0.2024852037,
0.1860237569,
-0.1487317979,
-0.4974886179,
-0.1736661941,
-0.5350878239,
0.1205154136,
-0.0087582879,
-0.0250074565,
0.1831170619
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12125v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12125v1 | Efficient Sequential Decision Making with Large Language Models | 2024-06-17T22:13:22 | 2024-06-17T22:13:22 | Dingyang Chen, Qi Zhang, Yinglun Zhu | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | This paper focuses on extending the success of large language models (LLMs)
to sequential decision making. Existing efforts either (i) re-train or finetune
LLMs for decision making, or (ii) design prompts for pretrained LLMs. The
former approach suffers from the computational burden of gradient updates, and
the latter approach does not show promising results. In this paper, we propose
a new approach that leverages online model selection algorithms to efficiently
incorporate LLMs agents into sequential decision making. Statistically, our
approach significantly outperforms both traditional decision making algorithms
and vanilla LLM agents. Computationally, our approach avoids the need for
expensive gradient updates of LLMs, and throughout the decision making process,
it requires only a small number of LLM calls. We conduct extensive experiments
to verify the effectiveness of our proposed approach. As an example, on a
large-scale Amazon dataset, our approach achieves more than a $6$x performance
gain over baselines while calling LLMs in only $1.5$\% of the time steps. | [
-0.2758489549,
-0.709913671,
0.8731841445,
0.5752594471,
-0.1085379645,
0.3569169939,
-0.59464252,
-0.3394435346,
0.1021127775,
0.4866367579,
-0.6097055674,
-0.3559484482,
-0.3123579919,
0.2082492262,
-0.237508595,
0.5541698337,
0.0390942916,
0.2694151402,
0.0276556127,
0.0477348305,
-0.2194343805,
-0.2133612484,
-1.4232699871,
-0.4882188141,
0.5869621634,
0.2074672878,
0.6330307722,
0.603048861,
0.4000204504,
0.4194988012,
-0.0570322014,
0.2321585715,
-0.4922965765,
0.272277534,
-0.1773749739,
-0.5984506607,
-0.3851744235,
-0.2308055162,
0.7299357653,
0.7321750522,
-0.405765146,
0.1249504983,
-0.0449173003,
0.7678479552,
-0.5266407132,
0.0224936865,
-0.7011167407,
0.3550932705,
-0.0208520573,
-0.2011630684,
-0.8258036375,
-0.580414176,
0.2641888559,
-0.592422843,
-0.0762235671,
0.2008948326,
0.1246915981,
0.2590526938,
-0.1911129504,
-0.1741043329,
-0.9024291039,
0.9326730967,
-0.7897212505,
0.577608943,
0.3229266703,
0.3211587667,
-0.3708121777,
-0.9655998349,
-0.4088474214,
-0.5572213531,
0.0986966863,
-0.0924515948,
0.11114005,
-0.0287881996,
0.4151287377,
-0.0634163171,
-0.4562730491,
0.6932867169,
0.0347710922,
0.1511214674,
0.6587819457,
0.2173071057,
-0.0896017849,
0.2608460784,
-0.2206540704,
-0.0741304308,
-0.8102494478,
-0.0914236754,
0.260499686,
0.3774153888,
0.1073980778,
0.3076906502,
-0.2766774893,
0.7980779409,
0.2487647086,
-0.3197636604,
0.2939500213,
-0.2047336251,
-0.2383066267,
-0.1756703258,
0.8001781106,
0.1955670863,
0.3607546687,
-0.1068515331,
-0.4484134316,
-0.2985209227,
0.0755775198,
-0.9297146797,
0.0833298489,
0.4377522767,
-0.5542783737,
-0.209167555,
-0.303150326,
-0.7674761415,
-0.6259722114,
-0.4641544223,
0.214873597,
-0.0420462489,
0.0163486451,
0.1225929186,
-0.0179503728,
0.1080172062,
0.7944936752,
-0.9194186926,
0.3527320623,
0.6032329202,
0.9878572822,
-0.1924628168,
-0.2262224704,
-0.7433081865,
-0.0608087182,
-0.6876682043,
0.7640274763,
-0.6084835529,
-0.4564655721,
0.0561409444,
-0.2421210259,
0.1505783796,
-0.6290977597,
0.414493531,
-0.8864359856,
0.0407513119,
-0.0174944159,
-0.4696028531,
-0.0040683262,
0.1741654724,
-0.8200032115,
0.9918937683,
-0.1328470111,
-0.4609049857,
0.4284338057,
-0.3270035088,
-0.4487175047,
-0.0319446176,
-0.2158325911,
-0.3814891577,
-0.0590884984,
0.1730570495,
0.6396923065,
-0.5653570294,
0.2592983246,
-0.548853457,
-0.2113830596,
0.1742437035,
-0.0788522661,
0.6347097754,
0.285969615,
-0.3221132159,
0.2664340734,
-0.7644838691,
0.0689469203,
0.1517017335,
-0.6091893315,
-0.1903783977,
0.5126536489,
-0.2862779498,
0.2399263829,
0.1735263765,
-0.2035535276,
0.5079666376,
-0.2643754482,
0.4183856249,
1.0103540421,
-0.2677408755,
0.7383244038,
-0.4800794721,
0.5525727868,
-0.4489645958,
0.1260610223,
-0.0021754645,
-0.4458650351,
-1.0738166571,
-0.4799563289,
0.564214766,
0.6409226656,
-0.8413524032,
0.5138736963,
-0.2642622888,
-0.3472944498,
-0.3344331384,
0.0985544324,
0.0433660708,
0.0312598683,
0.1400226653,
-0.2548741102,
-0.6666454673,
-0.6416745186,
-0.0579511411,
-0.0471424237,
-0.1510125101,
0.1333046257,
0.3329489827,
-0.363761276,
0.9730396867,
-0.4330434203,
-0.0520050153,
-0.3202517927,
0.1568698585,
0.4302483797,
0.2087859809,
0.4513767958,
-0.3938443661,
-0.5698419213,
0.1544142663,
-0.6512940526,
-0.0780554116,
-0.5580979586,
-0.0513787754,
0.2057659775,
0.6461771727,
-0.7593525648,
-0.0013638141,
0.2389375269,
0.0840779617,
0.2156585157,
-0.350289464,
-0.1005854532,
-0.7010971308,
-0.1023066193,
0.0667720512,
-0.5116090178,
-0.6369962096,
0.0485658608,
-0.064911738,
0.172402665,
-0.4832844734,
0.8046874404,
-0.7089247704,
-0.3344345391,
-0.1182127967,
0.1280962527,
-0.4961555898,
0.6023731232,
0.1942124218,
0.4904420078,
0.5702729821,
-0.7188145518,
0.2807833552,
0.0573344193,
-0.7520858645,
0.0386759602,
-0.5513799787,
0.3502770066,
-0.4492341578,
0.6522618532,
-0.688760519,
0.0607670285,
0.2450506687,
-0.0935570449,
0.1988373101,
-0.0335227847,
-0.5264138579,
-0.3338450193,
-0.5084548593,
0.1599439383,
0.551792264,
-0.6852595806,
0.8264276981,
0.280674994,
-0.4742303789,
-0.4664161205,
-0.6283372641,
-0.0381962769,
-0.2331275493,
-0.4698568285,
0.1855867356,
-0.353551209,
-0.5462831259,
-0.2950033545,
0.2504091859,
0.1821788549,
0.2372240126,
-0.1105043888,
0.235661298,
-0.0819371268,
-0.0163068194,
-0.3198569417,
-0.1036655977,
-0.1722888649,
-0.6053828597,
0.6559009552,
0.2138852626,
-0.1673643142,
-0.2906852961,
0.1829615384,
0.5611835122,
-0.2740549445,
0.7093234062,
0.2803764939,
-0.2676049471,
-0.8896589875,
-0.6410697103,
-0.214054361,
-0.4974611998,
0.3307776451,
-0.2072575092,
-0.8355304003,
0.5140493512,
-0.330763191,
0.3133829236,
0.0967972577,
0.7928712964,
0.0750406757,
1.1630749702,
0.279358089,
0.0076453011,
0.9132065177,
-0.1491920352,
0.1656250507,
-0.4805569947,
-0.1270401925,
-0.4326082468,
-0.2520001233,
-0.6987274289,
-0.7620761991,
0.3516414762,
-0.0549302138,
-0.4090508223,
-0.0968597531,
-0.0037918726,
0.5213466883,
0.5467799306,
0.1467945874,
0.3589056134,
0.0500351861,
-0.1185676679,
0.2309242934,
-0.7644522786,
-0.3937672377,
1.1927785873,
0.3545362949,
0.7835304737,
0.2786308229,
0.5930428505,
0.4002954662,
0.5503626466,
-0.8765391707,
0.7813253999,
0.0023103391,
-0.2567381561,
-0.4367327988,
-0.5734175444,
-1.1252917051,
0.6522388458,
-0.5174859166,
-0.5508140326,
0.0728945136,
0.0161324367,
-0.7405552864,
0.126741007,
-0.4941684604,
0.4584134221,
-0.536262095,
-0.4918572903,
-0.5575169325,
-0.5858666301,
0.295666337,
-0.5829746127,
0.404836297,
-0.0183059033,
-0.2470893711,
0.77082479,
-0.5585274696,
0.7961252928,
0.0752655417,
-0.0412722863,
0.2388386279,
-0.0036189777,
1.0569714308,
-0.1789822131,
-0.4074387848,
-0.0028826015,
-0.5392760634,
0.032594502,
-0.7079053521,
0.7816329002,
-0.6903377175,
-0.6058353782,
-0.5060675144,
-0.043122787,
-0.5026627779,
0.3429380655,
-0.097832635,
0.4145456851,
-0.1237291247,
0.1307522953,
0.4593484104,
-0.3826107085,
0.7255003452,
0.8342664838,
-0.5330688357,
-0.5480389595,
0.7348026633,
0.2110670954,
0.357963264,
0.5010812879,
0.4513265491,
-0.5338762403,
-0.9540759325,
-0.269731611,
0.2353711277,
-0.6743662953,
0.0007661186,
-0.4923974276,
0.1504068226,
-0.2603280246,
-0.0635160059,
-0.1703818738,
-0.4207033217,
-0.231449157,
-0.1382500231,
0.0941083133,
0.9053344727,
-0.076955758,
0.3977192044,
-0.7919173241,
0.3343127966,
0.393017143,
0.3966459632,
0.4159640074,
-0.435203135,
-0.1741943061,
-0.1888555139,
-0.2760073245,
-0.6722369194,
0.4414946437,
0.1316742897,
0.7264674902,
0.3818912506,
-0.1202633083,
0.6551226377,
-0.9135624766,
0.3925522566,
0.1266616881,
-0.7014074326,
0.3964178264,
-0.476842612,
0.1960378289,
0.5304484367,
0.4830860496,
-0.4212549925,
-0.1805112362,
-0.4756160378,
-0.8487696648,
0.8246449828,
0.1010088697,
-0.2694745362,
0.0264514051,
0.0576943681,
0.0695410594,
0.3023196459,
-0.5152730942,
-0.3647194207,
0.4979505241,
0.0866859555,
-0.2284026295,
-0.031655021,
0.1327696741,
-0.334513098,
0.6444484591,
-0.1718247831,
0.0339103267,
-0.0639968589,
-0.0364079587,
-0.0732702017,
0.082554087,
0.4129659534,
0.7726425529,
-0.1083952263,
-0.2588089705,
0.3713648915,
0.0059987502,
0.0652181953,
0.0702095851,
-0.2388813943,
-0.1310929656,
0.4040308893,
0.9330607057,
0.3854161799,
-0.8215867877,
0.2759973407,
-0.162485525,
0.024108408,
-0.5354835987,
-0.2095663249,
0.0647174641,
0.5384569764,
0.2716781795,
0.2008167207,
0.0628760532,
-0.6841043234,
0.1748989969,
0.440328449,
0.3935287297,
0.0492657311,
0.3633432388,
0.5878247619,
-0.4467758536,
0.7166416645,
-0.2698196173,
-0.4417063594,
0.5367285609,
0.3372421563,
0.8388134241,
-0.2407164723,
0.3085945249,
0.3409177065,
0.0764132142,
-0.8225840926,
0.1552664191,
0.063384369,
-0.9101866484,
-0.6228352189,
-0.6236044168,
-0.6036141515,
0.0608887449,
-0.2619217634,
0.5100539327,
-1.0043311119,
-0.3189167678,
-0.1963858902,
-0.051635582,
-0.6868777275,
0.1891299486,
0.4694162309,
0.9337570667,
-0.4091397524,
0.8448944688,
0.3811164796,
-0.056150645,
-0.5912676454,
-0.1662743837,
0.0826098248,
-0.8687590957,
0.6914745569,
0.0457864814,
-0.1922176927,
0.2259335965,
-0.3490705192,
-0.9933760166,
1.0819579363,
0.5307442546,
-0.9935389161,
0.1012322232,
-0.1611081362,
0.4633923769,
-0.3763738871,
0.7463362813,
0.6806656718,
0.520382762,
0.4371671081,
-0.9909981489,
-0.0424028374,
0.0606609434,
-0.0531051457,
0.3721555769,
-0.7599385977,
0.99586308,
-0.563202858,
-0.4234205186,
0.173421815,
0.7368240952,
0.4967027307,
-0.086691387,
0.6764710546,
0.5956349373,
1.1722947359,
0.1882964671,
1.2386243343,
-0.1032020524,
0.3196394742,
1.2904367447,
-0.6127607226,
1.2451159954,
0.1514242887,
-0.3537617922,
0.4520782828,
1.0546820164,
-0.0314900205,
0.6088839173,
0.3596656024,
-0.3884040713,
-0.6587000489,
-0.024339769,
-0.1717071831,
0.1592641473,
0.2064096779,
-0.208195433,
-0.0326049328,
-0.2893261909,
0.0546156801,
-0.2665452659,
-0.4268245697,
0.7178856134,
0.1713561714,
-0.9176396728,
0.4322029054,
0.1682384163,
0.7372543812,
-0.7837130427,
0.053842105,
-0.1408393979,
0.4184892178,
-0.197415933,
-0.5911130309,
-0.2467193753,
-0.1543334126,
0.0292563252,
-0.6482661963,
0.4791257083,
-0.4934076071,
-0.6734884381,
0.4352849126,
0.6014521718,
-0.1562128514,
0.062628068,
-0.5796689391,
0.2436280847,
-0.1062979475,
-0.2763922513,
0.3273696005,
0.1262855381,
-0.3484247625,
1.0885791779,
0.8912108541,
0.4327334464,
-0.0054873605,
0.3113774657,
0.5955110192,
-0.717510581,
-0.8451026082,
-0.9364919066,
0.3206275105,
-0.1343142539,
-0.0981475711,
0.5734696388,
0.3494517505,
0.9136091471,
-0.1279085875,
1.0505937338,
0.2128296643,
0.356423527,
-0.8922306299,
0.3139198422,
-0.3513100445,
0.498211652,
0.0920178443,
-0.9523527026,
-0.3513959348,
0.8216125369,
-0.4939625263,
0.1466758251,
0.8615413308,
0.8127191067,
0.3303014338,
0.1437388957,
0.1538013965,
0.4361483753,
0.2819399536,
0.5644672513,
1.1933116913,
0.0896596089,
-0.0566183217,
0.106848143,
-0.3504741788,
-0.1446991712,
-1.1375635862,
-1.1024522781,
-0.1539090723,
-0.2428240329,
0.0204314739,
-0.0803743079,
1.5884740353,
0.6817042232,
-0.7555388808,
-0.4884396791,
0.1492873132,
0.2438871711,
-0.1290976405,
-0.0521327779,
0.061260961,
-0.3504912555,
-0.7303612232,
0.7267304659,
-0.0165384635,
-0.0312938653,
-0.2561372221,
-0.3366647363,
-0.2930877507,
0.1296864003,
0.8955159187,
0.1769399047,
-0.6860728264,
-0.0611744002,
-0.3757668436,
0.0342089608,
0.009822295,
1.1762139797,
-0.8679441214,
0.2615911961,
0.7371152043,
0.9587666988,
0.6148508191,
-0.0785107017,
0.7725090384,
-0.3091872334,
0.1320995986,
0.2837784588,
0.5932686925,
0.4302686155,
0.0243258495,
0.4417366683,
0.1974555254,
-0.5065945387,
-0.5692492127,
0.074575901,
-0.8167325258,
-0.3349357247,
1.5454080105,
0.1123315617,
-0.0164787825,
-0.0150243053,
-0.1876689196,
-0.2035062015,
-0.6189832687,
0.4147837758,
0.5945959091,
-0.2003056556,
-0.0295668095,
-0.6369901299,
0.4968301058,
0.3100285828,
-0.7804664969,
-0.0117453067,
0.6199893951,
0.1285254657,
-0.1362273544,
0.9333260655,
0.3513104916,
-0.1254579425,
-0.3488614857,
-0.2343382686,
0.2317854315,
-0.5185756683,
-0.5315839648,
0.1605921388,
0.3746365309,
-0.0406016372
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12117v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12117v1 | Decoding the Narratives: Analyzing Personal Drug Experiences Shared on Reddit | 2024-06-17T21:56:57 | 2024-06-17T21:56:57 | Layla Bouzoubaa, Elham Aghakhani, Max Song, Minh Trinh, Rezvaneh Rezapour | cs.CL | cs.CL | Online communities such as drug-related subreddits serve as safe spaces for
people who use drugs (PWUD), fostering discussions on substance use
experiences, harm reduction, and addiction recovery. Users' shared narratives
on these forums provide insights into the likelihood of developing a substance
use disorder (SUD) and recovery potential. Our study aims to develop a
multi-level, multi-label classification model to analyze online user-generated
texts about substance use experiences. For this purpose, we first introduce a
novel taxonomy to assess the nature of posts, including their intended
connections (Inquisition or Disclosure), subjects (e.g., Recovery, Dependency),
and specific objectives (e.g., Relapse, Quality, Safety). Using various
multi-label classification algorithms on a set of annotated data, we show that
GPT-4, when prompted with instructions, definitions, and examples, outperformed
all other models. We apply this model to label an additional 1,000 posts and
analyze the categories of linguistic expression used within posts in each
class. Our analysis shows that topics such as Safety, Combination of
Substances, and Mental Health see more disclosure, while discussions about
physiological Effects focus on harm reduction. Our work enriches the
understanding of PWUD's experiences and informs the broader knowledge base on
SUD and drug use. | [
-0.3798598051,
-0.6675958037,
0.7596011162,
0.1876327693,
0.0026065211,
0.2383116335,
0.0579865798,
-0.7462482452,
0.3774664998,
0.5821440816,
-0.4741318226,
-0.9108029008,
-0.9288399816,
0.3584493697,
-0.2493254989,
1.5500888824,
-0.2191214561,
-0.1955801696,
-0.0699079409,
-0.0071728197,
-0.7403199673,
-0.8248556852,
-0.6097922325,
-0.0655305833,
1.0526192188,
0.1195930988,
0.038991224,
0.0862241015,
0.6205455661,
0.215490669,
0.1396605223,
-0.1896246076,
-0.6793991327,
-0.095411852,
-0.2625797987,
-0.228777349,
-0.3439357579,
0.0904696807,
0.0629907399,
0.5909897089,
-0.2631773651,
0.1465349495,
0.1650589705,
0.1449836791,
-0.6103175879,
-0.1176224947,
-0.1247416586,
0.0643672645,
-0.1318444312,
-0.3406429589,
-0.4168965816,
-0.4108400047,
0.013085288,
-0.7763890624,
0.3034642339,
0.1306312084,
0.6666725278,
-0.0265562534,
-0.7257006168,
-0.4918753505,
-0.7500335574,
0.4029324949,
-0.5414010286,
0.2228970379,
0.4778150916,
0.1417873949,
-0.0941177756,
-0.9578711987,
-0.5387039781,
0.3973066509,
-0.6953642368,
-0.1365711987,
-0.054272566,
0.204790771,
0.2182742357,
0.4437761009,
-0.6666631103,
-0.0298456103,
-0.7099403739,
-0.3975800872,
0.4284182489,
0.4660840034,
0.5985704064,
-0.2659485936,
-0.763378799,
0.3406538367,
-0.4924560189,
0.0704787523,
0.1839287579,
0.0541399941,
-0.1613572091,
0.6194526553,
0.0797196776,
0.4672768116,
-0.2896709442,
-0.4533678293,
0.4916588664,
-0.6421051621,
0.0227731559,
-0.0145877376,
0.9565778375,
0.9262379408,
-0.1225017309,
-0.0808475986,
-0.1479280591,
0.0690747425,
0.4889086485,
-0.9194251299,
-0.5781186819,
0.2298898697,
-0.8842570782,
-0.2699527144,
-0.0300745387,
-0.7931761146,
-0.9914911985,
-0.1353210956,
0.5146936178,
-0.1904536784,
-0.4557725191,
0.0832438618,
-0.2692973912,
-0.2515503168,
0.1871043593,
-0.8731016517,
0.662024498,
0.6042659879,
1.0740971565,
-0.511485219,
-0.2745664716,
-0.1366203576,
0.2284494638,
0.2042530626,
0.9319534898,
-0.3393920064,
-0.3793669045,
-0.0111469114,
0.3823707402,
-0.0299942326,
-0.4966081083,
0.8731846213,
-0.4188580513,
0.1529686004,
-0.4974188805,
-0.7293995023,
-0.3120208383,
0.2396091819,
-0.6051838398,
0.344671905,
0.0570312142,
-1.1389305592,
0.6193435192,
-0.8214212656,
-0.2669868171,
0.0573225319,
0.0575443655,
-0.0738936961,
0.14046821,
0.0031243905,
0.3096633554,
0.0241351109,
0.1797953397,
-0.083068721,
-0.3442343175,
0.3169313967,
-0.2805759609,
0.7590787411,
0.2495750785,
0.1804524511,
0.2691533566,
-0.6191945076,
-0.2787188292,
-0.2425941527,
-0.5074813366,
-0.6884950399,
-0.2981868684,
0.2086905539,
0.2789934576,
-0.0247300118,
-0.8152936101,
0.0296117794,
-0.2139219642,
0.3081746399,
0.5319874883,
0.7520815134,
-0.0512971319,
-0.3714122176,
0.6082341075,
0.1804228574,
0.1519879252,
-0.2468484193,
-0.6136517525,
-0.1329452097,
-0.272369951,
0.2695227563,
0.5032248497,
-0.5846017003,
0.2092093825,
-0.043714527,
-0.2890803516,
-0.4900139868,
0.141797334,
0.350015223,
0.6926771402,
0.7925693989,
-0.3298302293,
-0.4245042801,
-0.926661849,
-0.4347262681,
0.1421120912,
-0.225465402,
0.2488036901,
0.628723979,
-0.4235569537,
0.7514938116,
-0.8465980887,
-0.6565374136,
-0.0916112959,
0.7111360431,
-0.0523123406,
0.1349838376,
0.3164387345,
-0.674454391,
-0.6496828198,
-0.0473888703,
-0.6775920391,
-0.1018830761,
-0.0977751464,
-0.0606678165,
-0.3673835099,
0.1853282303,
-0.2569807768,
0.4494032264,
0.3131129146,
-0.6769768,
0.5051804781,
-0.2627661824,
0.3563645184,
-0.7663581967,
-0.1442682594,
0.2325983047,
0.2423631847,
-0.7789269686,
-0.4138524234,
-0.1851121187,
-0.0761517212,
-0.2486139387,
0.2830808461,
-0.4292464256,
-0.0568050481,
-0.2803220153,
-0.1157721579,
0.0514536202,
0.2781898975,
0.2420209199,
0.364328891,
0.5880555511,
-0.4270563722,
0.2291508466,
0.099920705,
-0.4678797126,
0.5541275144,
-0.4278963506,
0.0119171282,
-0.1004121378,
0.2991203666,
-1.2200737,
-0.5730141997,
0.5419614315,
-0.3817671537,
0.1370966285,
-0.087987721,
-0.4346287549,
-0.2596887052,
-0.1117550135,
0.5773140192,
0.108237341,
-0.217392236,
0.3074138165,
0.8729614019,
-0.3465998173,
-0.3941958249,
-0.4651500285,
0.1824069917,
-0.5891492367,
-0.2490812987,
0.3487331867,
-0.1056922451,
-0.3027875721,
0.1742763072,
0.167760089,
-0.1947006434,
-0.0409503542,
0.1836548448,
0.0325991437,
0.1106578112,
0.2932683229,
0.1785880029,
-0.1773734987,
0.3521318138,
0.2878909111,
0.5519160628,
-0.1792935133,
0.2769714892,
-0.634123385,
0.6213028431,
0.2664642334,
-0.059505634,
1.1472209692,
0.5765841007,
-0.3901245594,
-0.1680226773,
-0.2415821701,
-0.2866791785,
-0.4261247516,
-0.0466134883,
-0.2935388088,
-0.7570900917,
0.3948310018,
-0.1588017493,
0.1042297557,
0.0330657586,
0.5382328629,
-0.5026336312,
0.6744615436,
0.433665365,
0.5617719889,
-0.0748001933,
-0.0884199962,
0.3352699578,
-0.6490121484,
-0.3385651708,
0.096711047,
-0.4447921813,
-0.3582451642,
-0.3855167031,
0.5397318006,
-0.1071476266,
-0.1164001152,
0.1506901979,
-0.5961127877,
0.5859827399,
0.2579972446,
0.1394646317,
0.4915289879,
-0.0267269444,
0.3399942815,
-0.5335867405,
-0.3678768575,
-0.3933803141,
1.0669273138,
0.6176353693,
0.6107993722,
0.1235482767,
0.8464927673,
0.5570252538,
0.8488323689,
-0.7228986025,
0.349538058,
-0.096199587,
-0.6226217747,
-0.0027875674,
-0.5135139823,
-1.1469963789,
0.3754668534,
-0.4035481811,
-0.6643490791,
0.1304469854,
-0.1653885841,
-0.5982782245,
0.308013767,
-0.9389175177,
0.9635592699,
-0.3429557681,
0.0088528004,
-0.160234496,
-0.8478854895,
0.9275717735,
-0.3333148658,
0.8315229416,
-0.0397601165,
-0.0619499311,
1.074464798,
-0.278655529,
0.84397012,
-0.2541021407,
-0.2303959727,
0.362826407,
-0.0351067334,
-0.2283066958,
-0.1097075567,
0.4274584651,
0.1955824643,
0.1831060797,
-0.0643604398,
-0.5781817436,
0.8044981956,
-0.8458560109,
-0.2369680405,
-0.2597281933,
-0.308890909,
-0.3216283321,
0.270968318,
0.3559511304,
0.4077437818,
-0.0087494953,
0.0683767647,
0.5071362853,
-0.6183089614,
0.0511980429,
0.1573226005,
-0.4527690709,
-0.4434835017,
0.801933229,
0.3166825473,
0.099849008,
0.1657252759,
0.4166816473,
-0.4531587362,
-0.6471773982,
0.0763188154,
0.5967068076,
-0.7305720448,
-0.097281158,
-0.7378355265,
-0.019581683,
-0.4827765822,
0.2148413807,
-0.0676474422,
-0.2242175043,
-0.1232520118,
-0.5426693559,
0.2301886529,
1.1878390312,
-0.2495039254,
0.2577437162,
-1.0490019321,
0.7231007218,
0.2046665102,
0.5326523781,
-0.0298554543,
-0.1140779555,
-0.0818682089,
-0.2474494129,
-0.2666591704,
-1.2742607594,
0.3117859662,
-0.0317079276,
0.693343401,
0.334220171,
0.6411035061,
0.3177764118,
-0.1625247747,
0.7580852509,
0.5102236271,
-0.4551427364,
0.5074624419,
-0.4521814287,
-0.290243119,
0.588245213,
0.9377828836,
-0.8762231469,
-0.0839804038,
-0.297244966,
-0.9397010803,
0.6145715714,
0.2225526124,
0.100963667,
-0.2303336859,
0.1325472593,
0.4991343021,
0.1287347823,
-1.0770554543,
-0.5379514694,
-0.1806759685,
-0.1367370933,
0.2299954593,
-0.4571808875,
-0.4142114222,
-0.207876429,
0.3308248222,
0.2725303173,
0.2581568062,
-0.0185298398,
-0.0366608649,
0.2333171815,
0.4167515039,
0.341309607,
0.6699102521,
-0.1198471263,
0.4583177865,
-0.1164810583,
-0.6023982167,
0.2808876038,
-0.3220709562,
-0.0853358582,
-0.2934455276,
0.2661485672,
0.8341739774,
0.1203274876,
-0.6512289643,
0.4320258796,
-0.4920559227,
-0.2785803974,
0.0028536362,
-0.0559173115,
0.1043545753,
0.0256442204,
0.2480569631,
0.1163531914,
0.3716595173,
-0.9824590683,
0.4749282897,
-0.2935314775,
-0.2657282948,
-0.3408387005,
0.5163664222,
0.3758803904,
-0.5027381182,
0.4489817321,
-0.2425539196,
-0.2946956456,
0.1198793277,
0.452621609,
0.6735037565,
0.0523484983,
0.4361992478,
0.8696841002,
-0.0928864256,
0.1829392165,
-0.2185165584,
-0.0168428253,
-0.8317847252,
0.0551370122,
-0.764508605,
0.1572689712,
0.2961292267,
-0.6955247521,
0.1286518127,
-0.4883973598,
-0.4893649817,
-0.0596997626,
-0.2667808533,
-0.3078525066,
0.1825921834,
0.1114237458,
0.3069962263,
-1.0354510546,
0.5430809855,
0.3690455854,
-0.4484154284,
-0.5969212055,
0.1845245808,
0.0814701915,
0.0146420524,
0.4303050339,
0.2662878931,
-0.2992402315,
-0.011762606,
-0.1779279113,
-0.4988404512,
0.9800309539,
-0.2930023968,
-0.3526391685,
-0.0081163179,
0.1197932437,
0.8172744513,
-0.4802508056,
-0.0674670339,
0.7516111732,
0.3051911592,
0.2230103761,
-0.8991910219,
0.005688224,
-0.2249381989,
-0.1916449815,
0.0553587154,
-0.2917608917,
0.9178751707,
-0.4397040904,
-0.6318368912,
-0.1644850969,
0.2456558943,
0.370113492,
0.4462625086,
0.5611427426,
0.3712718785,
1.0075771809,
0.0396661311,
1.0566459894,
-0.0610623956,
0.5145177841,
1.2051432133,
-0.1243895665,
0.72591573,
0.3217615187,
-0.162599057,
0.7725699544,
0.7391852736,
0.0057110689,
0.8056129217,
0.1954769194,
-0.2935539782,
-0.0917530432,
-0.0941318348,
-0.4095374644,
0.0709500164,
0.7168442011,
-0.567561686,
-0.2164048553,
0.4516495466,
-0.1022499651,
0.061722409,
-0.3829559982,
0.9543367028,
0.100603655,
-0.4991610348,
0.4018153548,
-0.0415753238,
0.6728954315,
-0.1877921075,
0.0300543997,
-0.0181338377,
0.2090549767,
-0.4520961642,
-1.1417524815,
0.5113189816,
-0.0109566683,
-0.0255065095,
-0.3992310762,
0.9425356984,
-0.5762442946,
-0.4828796387,
0.4253220558,
0.4985448718,
0.3423285186,
0.2058170736,
-0.5258934498,
-0.0087776436,
-0.1161855683,
-0.0551057123,
0.4338384569,
0.45643273,
0.096263513,
0.5002965927,
0.4628870487,
0.2085909694,
0.1531795561,
0.1470653266,
0.5122920275,
-0.578135848,
-0.5316179991,
-0.5488697886,
0.5675033927,
-0.1424438357,
-0.5518142581,
0.8606098294,
0.5712295771,
0.7244321704,
-0.1631703824,
0.8153846264,
-0.0232888144,
0.9867277145,
-0.2857569456,
1.0652449131,
-0.478027463,
0.4345924854,
-0.2395167947,
-0.5408957601,
-0.3092053831,
0.6807209253,
-0.3960433006,
-0.0696488842,
0.7338176966,
0.5729060173,
0.1722128391,
0.0196141396,
0.0693272948,
0.4014750421,
0.2723481655,
0.4314350188,
1.1095386744,
-0.3005711734,
0.5695070624,
-0.2961866558,
-0.0222200267,
0.228561461,
-0.3723775446,
-0.9306301475,
-0.6626856923,
-0.23237966,
-0.3591926396,
-0.3710827231,
0.5688163042,
0.2650886774,
-0.702703774,
-0.1933498085,
0.0543408431,
0.2039069235,
0.0838567987,
-0.3279763162,
0.0258221608,
-0.1388611048,
-0.3911147118,
0.1264223903,
0.1363267452,
-0.1334056556,
-0.2157892734,
-0.1825795919,
-0.2232842892,
-0.2912611365,
0.6889901161,
0.0271303132,
-0.6043801904,
-0.152366057,
-0.0601930134,
-0.0994322598,
0.1449883729,
1.2333134413,
-0.4894364774,
0.4589161575,
0.5894578099,
0.3202167451,
0.461659193,
0.4042099118,
0.4857457578,
-0.5509143472,
-0.6226698756,
0.3428691924,
0.251742959,
0.3035057187,
-0.3514310122,
0.3450260758,
0.5111945868,
-0.4670673013,
-0.8008586764,
0.0042372327,
-0.7574014664,
-0.8481055498,
1.1481975317,
-0.4317118227,
0.0983300582,
-0.869207263,
-0.6245114803,
-0.0304641295,
-0.3751347959,
0.9440491199,
0.971381247,
-0.6197668314,
-0.3084473312,
-0.731103301,
0.7900204062,
-0.6000715494,
-1.083029747,
0.3474368155,
0.7478078008,
0.7267693877,
0.3450749815,
1.0097064972,
-0.0299781375,
0.0308126565,
0.1592028141,
-0.2929785848,
0.0961808711,
-0.4459668994,
0.0274302717,
0.680737257,
-0.417658478,
0.0664734319
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12114v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12114v1 | Enhancing Text Classification through LLM-Driven Active Learning and Human Annotation | 2024-06-17T21:45:48 | 2024-06-17T21:45:48 | Hamidreza Rouzegar, Masoud Makrehchi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, 68T50, I.2.7 | In the context of text classification, the financial burden of annotation
exercises for creating training data is a critical issue. Active learning
techniques, particularly those rooted in uncertainty sampling, offer a
cost-effective solution by pinpointing the most instructive samples for manual
annotation. Similarly, Large Language Models (LLMs) such as GPT-3.5 provide an
alternative for automated annotation but come with concerns regarding their
reliability. This study introduces a novel methodology that integrates human
annotators and LLMs within an Active Learning framework. We conducted
evaluations on three public datasets. IMDB for sentiment analysis, a Fake News
dataset for authenticity discernment, and a Movie Genres dataset for
multi-label classification.The proposed framework integrates human annotation
with the output of LLMs, depending on the model uncertainty levels. This
strategy achieves an optimal balance between cost efficiency and classification
performance. The empirical results show a substantial decrease in the costs
associated with data annotation while either maintaining or improving model
accuracy. | [
0.0448400714,
-0.648278296,
0.463391304,
-0.0610694289,
-0.2714776397,
0.1936378032,
-0.3683559299,
-0.7695431113,
-0.2555817664,
0.5128957629,
-0.0914732367,
-0.4870477319,
-0.3478068709,
0.0724654272,
-0.3109591901,
1.0086599588,
-0.4895354509,
0.0034477788,
0.0610237382,
-0.2193276137,
0.0951895118,
-0.7592812181,
-0.6071318984,
-0.1541467607,
0.6842247844,
0.2360477298,
0.7514224648,
0.8633870482,
0.4525402784,
0.1787040383,
-0.0692946315,
0.445091933,
0.0594302379,
0.2467463762,
-0.017477259,
-0.4854680598,
-0.3424149454,
0.4318812788,
0.6442907453,
0.5082719326,
-0.071752429,
0.0457333662,
-0.0056153499,
0.3194506168,
-0.6893647313,
0.3077283502,
-0.5365860462,
0.1312319338,
-0.3208126724,
0.0355590917,
-0.3257244229,
-0.3089129329,
0.0726059079,
-0.5371097326,
0.256675601,
0.0342913158,
0.9402256012,
0.4344083369,
-0.3321316242,
-0.4065333009,
-0.8062220812,
0.6771120429,
-0.3592342436,
0.2436218262,
0.5832203627,
0.1618202627,
0.2535357773,
-0.5494588017,
-0.6760274768,
-0.0707179457,
0.0670418218,
0.1253553182,
0.1150477156,
0.1136235967,
0.093288064,
0.4451340735,
-0.0506955124,
0.4140002131,
-0.2303933054,
-0.3812893927,
0.6183944345,
-0.345682323,
0.1423807442,
-0.2402973026,
-0.4635750651,
-0.101771459,
-0.5543128252,
-0.2034422308,
0.5167476535,
0.4053992033,
0.295134455,
0.5802552104,
-0.0350408852,
0.4923178852,
-0.2971716225,
-0.2289277911,
0.4371498525,
-0.1654131413,
-0.1843318641,
0.1715729982,
0.6903473139,
0.1003617942,
0.2394873947,
-0.1600475609,
-0.5563031435,
0.0643453971,
0.2220018208,
-0.5490866303,
-0.2821389437,
0.0944897234,
-0.1018834859,
-0.6747421622,
0.2340802848,
-0.4997622967,
-0.6513069272,
-0.3061553836,
0.6555265784,
-0.0776610896,
-0.2317327261,
-0.1162853539,
0.1891965717,
-0.0099757714,
0.763574481,
-0.6420507431,
0.1184464097,
0.2861236334,
0.9467350245,
-0.33600384,
0.0960027352,
-0.3994834125,
0.3713540137,
-0.1577904373,
0.8740760088,
-0.2891597748,
0.0019672972,
0.1419278383,
-0.0986727476,
0.2262693942,
-0.3497799337,
0.809836328,
-0.5215328336,
0.3156429529,
0.1982366741,
-0.3599805832,
-0.4724127054,
0.383690238,
-0.9993489385,
1.2787547112,
0.1846329719,
-0.7629990578,
0.5741556287,
-0.6865051985,
-0.4390957654,
0.253602922,
-0.2029010355,
-0.8377978802,
-0.1821539849,
0.2758361697,
0.9148467183,
-0.1156896129,
0.3640106916,
-0.201688394,
-0.3976172507,
0.4384295046,
-0.7232367396,
0.3623496592,
0.2204952836,
-0.5042257905,
0.0281001478,
-0.8273211122,
-0.3347199857,
-0.1511290967,
-0.8466318846,
-0.36787498,
0.0926188752,
0.2332453579,
0.1060242131,
0.1310130507,
-0.3919470906,
0.343644321,
-0.1461248547,
0.181657806,
0.7377818227,
0.186811015,
0.6063385606,
-0.1365647316,
0.4107378125,
-0.1046387628,
-0.0423483588,
-0.2097536623,
-0.4620121419,
-0.7446748614,
-0.680087924,
0.6580081582,
0.7456545234,
-0.62002635,
0.4735510051,
-0.1452343762,
-0.4942442775,
-0.5837657452,
0.338457644,
0.1267828047,
0.219053492,
0.4199776053,
0.003739665,
-0.3247690499,
-0.6929110289,
-0.1103167385,
-0.485996604,
-0.2159865052,
0.1421007216,
0.1846626401,
-0.3470791876,
0.831376195,
-0.2947820127,
-0.3750440776,
-0.2053293288,
0.4771410525,
-0.0928634852,
0.2779641747,
0.1965855509,
-1.0002243519,
-0.3678668737,
0.062681064,
-0.6060587168,
-0.1810816973,
-0.376300633,
0.1187862083,
0.4469886422,
0.3709864616,
-0.2870709896,
0.4327267408,
0.25954777,
-0.098449856,
0.1311080009,
-0.0864462256,
0.1052925587,
-0.7554531097,
0.0212210342,
0.2532092631,
-0.2471660525,
-0.3541448116,
-0.3219928443,
0.2901421189,
-0.0039552003,
-0.225393489,
0.606128931,
-0.6270084381,
0.1587724388,
-0.3037786186,
0.2080036402,
-0.1284572035,
0.429605782,
0.2163332552,
0.6694726944,
0.3556594253,
-0.5454728007,
0.340462029,
-0.081698969,
-0.3903390467,
0.1342739761,
-0.12086723,
0.0627316087,
-0.1227396354,
0.2648205757,
-0.9913563728,
-0.4695728123,
0.3677718341,
-0.3304605782,
0.4684598446,
-0.1840672344,
-0.7547377348,
-0.0329672918,
-0.288947016,
-0.0809062198,
0.4792280793,
-0.5086953044,
0.748154819,
0.4136344492,
-0.2083242685,
-0.5450721383,
-0.789083004,
0.1501308233,
-0.2854694128,
-0.0504829362,
0.2176177055,
0.3261757791,
-0.2928766608,
-0.0388318859,
-0.2125396878,
-0.2209618241,
0.426505506,
0.2344170511,
0.3054911494,
0.1777432412,
0.5383549333,
0.1604435891,
-0.0875815526,
-0.1570842266,
-0.3279863596,
-0.0482703298,
0.1978630126,
-0.2896814346,
-0.4368776977,
0.000916256,
0.388353467,
-0.3657792509,
0.5976504087,
0.9780672193,
-0.482319504,
-0.388489157,
-0.662825942,
0.0132218152,
-0.3950845897,
0.3763433099,
-0.0059556989,
-0.7977137566,
0.1546505094,
-0.1659248322,
0.2991802096,
0.5248586535,
0.5324489474,
-0.1294875741,
0.8425670862,
0.4691381156,
-0.0309757181,
0.7824431062,
-0.009729363,
-0.047783237,
-0.3938002884,
-0.1232236251,
-0.3840896487,
-0.2572697401,
-0.3421381712,
-0.8316863775,
0.0963682011,
0.1731659919,
-0.1251103133,
-0.0582269207,
-0.4964460135,
0.4267642796,
0.5199207664,
0.2801907957,
0.3956406415,
0.2155146152,
0.1828865558,
0.0797243565,
-0.48518911,
-0.9618455172,
1.1527881622,
0.7312611341,
0.801990211,
0.2882366478,
0.5259882808,
0.4527707398,
0.9784694314,
-0.889855504,
0.4204030037,
0.0623913743,
-0.784650147,
-0.36945346,
-0.5679672956,
-0.5752587318,
0.0905420408,
-0.5669211149,
-0.3937837481,
0.0807689354,
0.1809596866,
-0.3464952409,
0.4823479652,
-0.7552232146,
0.4583634734,
-0.4785144329,
-0.512906909,
0.166534394,
-0.5135536194,
0.1213126704,
-0.6527982354,
0.3591848314,
-0.1537662297,
-0.5642213821,
1.0751240253,
0.1261265129,
1.1247093678,
-0.3418296576,
-0.1168543696,
0.4635729492,
-0.2138663977,
0.6423703432,
0.163851127,
-0.3486834168,
0.0361419618,
-0.6143702269,
-0.2850095332,
-0.3858094513,
0.3635970652,
-0.9006012082,
-0.2268287987,
-0.6446048617,
-0.3664879203,
-0.2575124204,
0.1154674515,
-0.2214528173,
0.1629864573,
0.1740394086,
0.1911643893,
0.7958846688,
-0.0999650657,
0.4219452143,
0.3709455431,
0.048224017,
-0.7346250415,
0.6428963542,
0.2956721187,
0.1414999962,
0.464810431,
0.1450887173,
-0.3615677655,
-0.9000533223,
-0.4283874631,
0.1597395837,
-0.8843542337,
-0.4706211388,
-0.71763134,
-0.0397535712,
-0.1511993408,
-0.0947107896,
-0.1037516072,
-0.5877860785,
-0.4455346465,
-0.6098272204,
0.5800585747,
0.7279573083,
0.1203296036,
0.5296555161,
-0.6497274041,
0.1226110309,
0.4456848502,
0.4253970385,
-0.1806004941,
-0.4235424399,
-0.4816068709,
-0.119949095,
-0.3105050623,
-0.8662763238,
0.1991642118,
0.4182754457,
0.6815993786,
0.4620638788,
0.2438786328,
0.2202979177,
-0.1944000274,
0.6632769108,
0.0571622252,
-0.885936439,
0.4638170302,
-0.4207758307,
0.0374010801,
0.7537973523,
0.6155776381,
-0.1705671996,
-0.3563343287,
-0.5703702569,
-1.1075704098,
0.6904261708,
0.227853328,
-0.0579930097,
0.0605824627,
0.7329187393,
0.0446489342,
0.1214228868,
-1.0667939186,
-0.0128227929,
-0.059366487,
-0.6284700036,
-0.1577606201,
-0.176834166,
-0.0057925414,
-0.1420959085,
0.9350336194,
-0.2470069379,
0.0499492735,
0.261043638,
-0.2579197288,
-0.1232779026,
0.1022659168,
0.1784045845,
0.2827385366,
-0.2815841138,
0.3338415623,
0.2822602689,
-0.6764672399,
0.2453927398,
0.214903757,
-0.2407701463,
-0.0482446924,
0.4644637108,
0.7187220454,
0.2112344652,
-0.6671033502,
0.5530057549,
-0.0234262124,
-0.1784561574,
-0.3448863029,
0.137199387,
-0.1223245114,
0.1943709105,
0.7522185445,
0.1085257754,
-0.0000566719,
-0.4311152399,
0.251765281,
0.0003213201,
-0.7044140697,
-0.1695942283,
0.5353296399,
0.4217375815,
-0.1668352783,
0.5159527063,
-0.2386780381,
-0.7693786025,
0.1252144277,
0.1527054161,
0.8644903302,
-0.2437778562,
0.0976363793,
0.2830017209,
0.3672278523,
-0.5628676414,
0.0114297764,
-0.2166361511,
-0.7040570974,
-0.6161932349,
-0.8020886779,
-0.7783750296,
-0.1531859934,
-0.4969500303,
0.5919222236,
-0.4100040495,
-0.1240937039,
-0.1811346859,
0.275967747,
-0.2786470354,
0.4360152185,
0.425039649,
0.6429572105,
-1.064150095,
0.9101070762,
1.0840617418,
-0.5203551054,
-0.6125069857,
0.0911738575,
-0.1449423134,
-0.3418045938,
0.5254821181,
0.4433827698,
0.0795935616,
0.0368205495,
-0.5559309125,
-0.5755189061,
1.1266027689,
0.0495789945,
-0.4289433658,
-0.0049447888,
-0.2111113518,
0.4276922345,
-0.1626337171,
0.0370193087,
0.1626726687,
0.5533187389,
0.1089662835,
-0.6974639297,
-0.0051324414,
-0.1287671328,
-0.4339908659,
0.4317024946,
-0.3739043176,
0.5314327478,
-0.0562086813,
-0.2527617812,
-0.2785325348,
0.8245280385,
0.1716861129,
0.3076739609,
0.8261035681,
0.227636531,
1.0932942629,
-0.1930004507,
0.7465002537,
0.0796447694,
0.349786967,
0.6562251449,
-0.3165814281,
0.9871445894,
0.3281812072,
-0.3152511418,
0.2483966053,
0.8410981297,
-0.3128425777,
0.2256738394,
0.2632299066,
-0.5570904613,
-0.3941232562,
0.0946576819,
0.1874289513,
0.3143154383,
0.4337607324,
-0.386888057,
0.0153186247,
0.2225230187,
0.3355813026,
0.1253372282,
-0.305292964,
0.8629053235,
-0.1861159056,
-0.3554100394,
0.1543205529,
0.0634724498,
0.9005194306,
-0.6200454235,
0.0605966449,
0.0929622874,
0.2561633587,
-0.2656838596,
-0.6923875809,
0.1127779931,
0.2692229152,
-0.1474823356,
-0.4001983106,
0.6281318069,
-0.5233985782,
-0.6249324679,
-0.0191618688,
0.2422501147,
0.1423460543,
-0.2332678139,
-0.5014176369,
0.0024633759,
0.0635528788,
-0.4008187056,
0.2223335952,
0.6321622729,
-0.286267221,
0.523655951,
0.7145177722,
0.2484048605,
-0.1476825178,
-0.0673544407,
0.7792087793,
-0.6667891145,
-0.3969372511,
-0.6872399449,
0.4147456586,
-0.2204889506,
-0.1590013206,
0.750264883,
0.5208553672,
0.5930434465,
0.2108067423,
1.0587152243,
0.1321820468,
0.6886368394,
-0.5097333193,
0.7881362438,
-0.4651877582,
0.49977988,
-0.2835030854,
-1.0343319178,
-0.7955513,
0.7958653569,
-0.3247084916,
-0.0058476403,
0.4757600725,
0.4294953644,
0.0341791995,
-0.0813966468,
0.0760589764,
-0.0386480577,
0.4310233593,
0.0333042406,
0.8094484806,
-0.3871769905,
0.6472725272,
-0.2579461634,
-0.493904978,
-0.1027938724,
-0.879110992,
-0.9190763831,
-0.4377086759,
-0.6681744456,
-0.1981149018,
0.0158390552,
0.952618897,
0.6164439917,
-0.6382110715,
0.0765607953,
0.1098435298,
-0.0253654588,
-0.1474355459,
-0.2062292099,
0.6141036153,
-0.3434980512,
-0.8316953182,
0.1162380129,
0.1342233121,
0.4067815542,
-0.4100371599,
0.1616851985,
-0.337150991,
-0.0004565623,
0.4370460808,
-0.0015041173,
-0.5393022895,
-0.237939477,
-0.253000617,
-0.1120733917,
-0.0887868479,
0.5523810387,
-0.7856004834,
0.2541435361,
0.206795007,
0.9137508273,
0.4624754786,
0.2862792611,
0.3910642564,
-0.8924769759,
0.0603030808,
0.4343623817,
0.1458743811,
0.659899354,
-0.4482161105,
0.6451436877,
0.2609718144,
-0.6042830944,
-1.0000064373,
-0.1017049551,
-1.0664036274,
-0.2422717065,
1.3846445084,
-0.2380616516,
-0.3005845845,
-0.4759168029,
-0.3367212713,
0.3170318007,
-0.3592336476,
0.6363011003,
0.7260277867,
-0.0092837801,
-0.2337023914,
-0.5948667526,
0.4415733516,
0.0680434331,
-0.8240303993,
0.3445700109,
0.5313304067,
-0.0213259254,
0.2818108201,
0.2510751486,
-0.1195727587,
-0.0411812924,
-0.2589672506,
0.5460115671,
-0.2328794301,
-0.2742090821,
-0.4324915707,
0.3657110333,
0.2491566986,
-0.0323890597
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12109v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12109v1 | Can LLMs Learn Macroeconomic Narratives from Social Media? | 2024-06-17T21:37:09 | 2024-06-17T21:37:09 | Almog Gueta, Amir Feder, Zorik Gekhman, Ariel Goldstein, Roi Reichart | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CE | This study empirically tests the $\textit{Narrative Economics}$ hypothesis,
which posits that narratives (ideas that are spread virally and affect public
beliefs) can influence economic fluctuations. We introduce two curated datasets
containing posts from X (formerly Twitter) which capture economy-related
narratives (Data will be shared upon paper acceptance). Employing Natural
Language Processing (NLP) methods, we extract and summarize narratives from the
tweets. We test their predictive power for $\textit{macroeconomic}$ forecasting
by incorporating the tweets' or the extracted narratives' representations in
downstream financial prediction tasks. Our work highlights the challenges in
improving macroeconomic models with narrative data, paving the way for the
research community to realistically address this important challenge. From a
scientific perspective, our investigation offers valuable insights and NLP
tools for narrative extraction and summarization using Large Language Models
(LLMs), contributing to future research on the role of narratives in economics. | [
-0.2177867591,
-1.0544832945,
0.7201854587,
0.2513239384,
-0.4112802446,
0.4651578367,
-0.1411765963,
-0.7447482944,
0.6436052918,
0.5733317137,
-0.7189412713,
-0.4599235058,
-0.6956709623,
0.1326245517,
-0.3532796204,
1.0188772678,
0.1584384292,
-0.2468692213,
-0.0049398821,
0.1987857223,
0.0925747678,
-0.0707519054,
-0.7222767472,
-0.0209627971,
0.8578701019,
0.2794061005,
0.81539464,
0.7145588994,
0.2015150785,
0.1988680065,
0.1305749714,
0.4183988869,
-0.573567152,
0.0047160382,
-0.1704667956,
-0.3234876692,
-0.3167058825,
0.0432644635,
0.6243390441,
0.4743383825,
-0.0786772668,
0.5827312469,
0.3410246372,
0.5022593737,
-0.3260419071,
0.4443592429,
-0.615794301,
-0.2258302718,
0.1585743278,
-0.2506755292,
-0.2150736153,
-0.7761745453,
0.2431222796,
-0.2443639189,
0.0511826463,
0.1542508155,
0.8000258207,
-0.1172196567,
-0.6953520179,
-0.3381669819,
-0.949598074,
0.57400769,
-0.5578346848,
-0.026459476,
0.299474895,
0.323669076,
0.2559871972,
-0.8707080483,
-0.2690400481,
0.20619452,
-0.0572573245,
0.2119232863,
-0.5585446954,
-0.2212316543,
0.1899163574,
0.1999485195,
-0.2763932049,
-0.0591193847,
-0.73246032,
0.1264469028,
0.729834497,
0.2202016264,
0.2120289803,
-0.3750889301,
-0.2069343477,
-0.0192675516,
-0.6208002567,
0.0967768356,
0.2644932568,
0.4371212721,
-0.4001705647,
0.6215944886,
0.0532486998,
0.1577849537,
-0.2455385476,
-0.4169492126,
0.1230452135,
-0.3215247393,
-0.2647989988,
0.2272548974,
0.7535523176,
0.8125398159,
0.5186660886,
-0.1045870781,
-0.2875552773,
-0.2832652926,
-0.0302129276,
-0.6377886534,
0.1550363749,
-0.0684049428,
-0.5105008483,
-0.5341973305,
0.0222701933,
-1.2696173191,
-0.5329194069,
-0.2035877407,
0.2096177936,
-0.0910986289,
-0.119092837,
-0.0810032785,
-0.4895751774,
0.1497482657,
0.0392573774,
-0.9850796461,
0.3322534263,
0.769141078,
1.1894780397,
0.2911908627,
-0.0898858607,
-0.2957683504,
0.4255885482,
-0.3133449852,
1.0984936953,
-0.2451258898,
-0.4269032776,
0.4524840713,
-0.0716499612,
-0.2718892694,
-0.424313724,
-0.0516911335,
-0.287907809,
-0.2221650332,
-0.3455448151,
-0.5101927519,
-0.0346444882,
0.1650016159,
-0.7622813582,
0.6279236674,
0.0258785877,
-0.8386263251,
0.3751161993,
-0.418148458,
-0.4912464619,
-0.3853659332,
0.0843292102,
-0.2156590372,
0.2194841504,
0.5112887621,
0.4640180767,
-0.4089583158,
0.5478306413,
-0.5538955331,
-0.0771396458,
0.354916811,
-0.775568068,
0.910856545,
-0.1500215828,
-0.1971182227,
-0.2869585454,
-0.7517825961,
-0.4940783679,
0.1668708771,
-0.0484903306,
-0.0427325666,
0.3011836708,
-0.0420643948,
-0.1541682631,
0.0833178982,
-0.3730611503,
0.3491497338,
-0.1967579871,
0.6236197948,
0.9275959134,
0.5843198895,
0.2652952075,
-0.727473557,
0.5713641047,
-0.4205090702,
0.002131514,
-0.3335472345,
-0.4112938344,
-0.2258428633,
-0.0388696827,
-0.064749606,
0.5151370168,
-0.6572623849,
-0.3808621168,
-0.0802087113,
-0.6140286922,
-0.0906688869,
0.1404337138,
-0.22344248,
0.4894524217,
0.2034126222,
0.556826055,
-0.9462507963,
-0.716409266,
-0.5941342115,
-0.3726613224,
-0.2141131759,
0.4042024016,
0.40626809,
-0.3981852233,
0.991518259,
-0.7149344683,
0.097720392,
-0.7556596398,
0.6869215965,
0.4956407845,
-0.2118176222,
0.676373601,
-0.598115027,
-0.4979337156,
-0.0647744909,
-0.6075229049,
-0.2509537041,
-0.3603076339,
0.4699883759,
0.464625746,
0.4336265922,
-0.6212247014,
0.496471405,
0.58414042,
-0.3183179796,
0.7752233148,
-0.1905474067,
0.0241288561,
-1.0799242258,
-0.5449470282,
0.5025886893,
-0.4072600007,
-0.1850530654,
-0.6546694636,
-0.3185113668,
0.2803331614,
-0.2488541454,
0.4973026514,
-0.2837063968,
-0.2772575021,
-0.1195447892,
0.050144054,
0.0011527687,
0.0236621052,
0.1376750022,
0.6032256484,
0.3557603061,
-0.3970644176,
0.3823568821,
-0.0015240962,
-0.5399188995,
-0.0838214755,
-0.707863152,
-0.2747172117,
-0.1396664083,
0.2698444128,
-0.9433621764,
-0.4043947756,
-0.1103431284,
-0.3323429525,
-0.0014165402,
0.0294836983,
-0.7527267933,
-0.2283749431,
-0.4090426266,
-0.4186602831,
0.5541504025,
-0.4414134622,
0.5857878923,
0.4665520191,
-0.5594853163,
-0.1956749856,
-0.6012512445,
0.1994068921,
-0.4688394964,
-0.4541136324,
0.0579958223,
0.1795580834,
-0.758879602,
-0.0194554012,
-0.0968404487,
-0.054747723,
0.1051767468,
-0.0152048422,
0.5510009527,
-0.3954507411,
0.19148615,
0.1284591407,
-0.0462299287,
0.6368108392,
-0.2953922749,
0.3426861167,
-0.068570748,
0.3774882555,
-0.0280332603,
-0.0680385679,
0.3653394282,
0.4218735993,
0.9511093497,
0.6628853083,
-0.3485757113,
-0.1033030599,
-0.5639781356,
-0.029807914,
-0.455763489,
0.062657319,
0.2827650905,
-0.9086783528,
0.4526098073,
-0.1903295666,
0.1140114889,
0.7001725435,
0.3847690821,
-0.4691643119,
0.8550612926,
0.8582103848,
-0.2544210553,
0.4169655144,
-0.4399231374,
0.3158272207,
-0.3139891028,
-0.0579773895,
-0.3029757738,
-0.2036444545,
-0.6448258162,
-0.2035518885,
0.245738402,
-0.1303916723,
-0.2074098289,
0.1914186776,
0.3256244063,
0.691257596,
0.3747109175,
0.2329228222,
0.3652225435,
-0.0172911733,
0.3363798261,
-0.1038126796,
-0.3971898258,
-0.9044310451,
1.0254718065,
0.2648703158,
0.5468020439,
-0.1002111509,
0.5845834613,
0.5935468078,
0.3058610559,
-0.3083606958,
0.3493185639,
-0.0782284811,
-0.2293152958,
-0.3545896113,
-0.5511778593,
-0.6483592391,
-0.2997736633,
-0.416285634,
-1.1070961952,
0.1194653139,
-0.1530112028,
-0.6338034868,
0.5125712156,
-0.5330594182,
0.8129936457,
-0.2974536419,
-0.4056451917,
-0.2214870155,
-0.522557795,
0.3798637986,
-0.2173367739,
0.6588653326,
-0.2067396343,
-0.0166553576,
0.6471396089,
-0.1687696576,
1.2994065285,
0.2727758884,
-0.0319960304,
0.484734863,
-0.0089589842,
0.4106600583,
0.4955293238,
0.0182871372,
0.1215499938,
0.0929948986,
-0.3746469915,
-0.3167321384,
0.4626937807,
-0.7263373137,
-0.4913575351,
-0.1265991181,
-0.6614754796,
-0.2275565267,
-0.136551097,
0.2194399685,
0.3898504078,
-0.5304375291,
0.2067751139,
0.4576988816,
-0.1000757888,
0.9256136417,
0.1644920409,
-0.4991995096,
-0.5085166693,
0.7867503762,
0.5018413663,
0.2965253294,
0.4918247461,
0.6103541255,
-0.1825845987,
-0.1815536767,
0.0088945739,
0.3343887329,
-0.4617303312,
-0.2007868439,
-0.6595802307,
-0.1942672729,
-0.700381577,
-0.6018835902,
-0.1243696585,
-0.3618669808,
-0.5197618008,
-0.9794691801,
0.5009045005,
1.1356903315,
-0.7084985375,
0.3473652601,
-1.1311250925,
0.430277586,
0.3615409434,
-0.0922622755,
0.0907068625,
-0.0555489324,
-0.5493856072,
0.3593978882,
-0.1561262012,
-0.9142711759,
0.9882422686,
0.0502675325,
0.0289707985,
0.7307738662,
-0.0331730917,
0.7375670075,
-0.3500282168,
0.6662821174,
0.1304362565,
-0.7747306824,
0.5113477111,
-0.8136249185,
0.1161503866,
0.309369117,
0.6162568331,
-0.4255659282,
-0.5088019371,
-0.7908977866,
-0.9437045455,
0.4742401242,
0.0486637168,
0.3550734222,
-0.3951283991,
0.2605272532,
0.3746049702,
0.3885115981,
-0.69272995,
-0.0870344713,
0.0568313301,
-0.1006412432,
-0.411924243,
-0.7259243131,
0.3964184523,
-0.3031583726,
0.3127441704,
0.1914141625,
-0.0896616504,
0.0757554024,
-0.0315711014,
-0.3083864152,
-0.2540724576,
0.2813445926,
0.9591705799,
-0.5869919658,
0.2698054016,
0.1296562105,
-0.2558648586,
-0.2101599425,
-0.0446939655,
-0.0980022922,
0.2569096982,
0.6226987243,
0.5394682884,
0.5527510047,
-0.9198020697,
0.2970994711,
-0.1387951225,
-0.3763046265,
-0.575429976,
-0.3072874546,
0.4621762037,
0.8219488859,
0.4715562463,
-0.0316107199,
0.1643970311,
-1.0528297424,
0.1572479606,
0.0884830058,
-0.1636641771,
-0.5911440253,
0.7665154934,
-0.1473111957,
-0.2423278242,
0.394788146,
-0.0006755607,
-0.282132417,
1.0181533098,
0.7996375561,
0.8564395905,
0.1145279333,
0.6780215502,
0.3084201515,
0.4672374427,
-0.4476031065,
-0.0465782732,
0.0992750227,
-0.6167740822,
-0.4666163921,
-0.5970616341,
-0.4596709907,
-0.0152602112,
-0.6381289363,
0.4562622309,
-0.3841840923,
-0.0010402948,
0.1199186966,
-0.1766738147,
-0.4172924459,
0.1523834169,
0.4923951328,
0.761970222,
-1.0285909176,
0.470179379,
0.1202201322,
-0.5013613105,
-0.6221865416,
0.0783485323,
0.1422110945,
-0.8001146913,
0.6027094722,
0.3241076767,
-0.0271682125,
-0.0589210726,
-0.639901042,
-0.8397008181,
1.1854562759,
0.3915804625,
-0.4263855219,
-0.2989654839,
0.3865858614,
0.3912599385,
-0.7800509334,
0.20500049,
0.7299315333,
0.4490951598,
0.1970905513,
-0.5275880098,
-0.2786623538,
0.0165905971,
-0.3555361331,
-0.067864567,
-0.4851870835,
0.8002823591,
-0.4508439302,
-0.1411534101,
-0.1988246292,
0.7322559953,
0.0508197546,
1.0217599869,
0.2807796597,
0.1630803943,
0.7005329728,
0.2655583918,
1.2660087347,
-0.3646034598,
0.5213701725,
0.9133205414,
-0.1521020234,
0.807872653,
0.207760781,
-0.1774856448,
0.7303512096,
0.8042867184,
-0.0266610552,
0.3741045296,
-0.1139263958,
-0.1465497315,
-0.1477968544,
-0.0638875663,
0.1169600487,
0.2542034984,
0.4438888729,
-0.3983897567,
-0.2527915239,
-0.0679494441,
0.3108667135,
0.0348574035,
-0.7062400579,
0.8861236572,
0.4372919202,
-0.201309815,
-0.1918328553,
-0.4217012227,
0.3995545805,
-0.3307444155,
-0.0349737704,
-0.2873411477,
-0.0096337805,
-0.0095118415,
-0.545620203,
0.8664132357,
0.2666411102,
-0.1048366725,
-0.7509961724,
0.8906990886,
-0.3005886078,
-0.869268775,
0.3253477216,
0.7917718291,
-0.1179829463,
-0.2088086158,
-0.1164151058,
-0.4380604029,
0.0763002709,
-0.4336782098,
0.3833043873,
0.6544906497,
0.4346555471,
0.5024738312,
0.2721325159,
0.0679290295,
-0.0772717446,
-0.0691911653,
0.6903487444,
-0.9255867004,
-0.4816968739,
-1.4514279366,
0.2352611423,
-0.1826277822,
-0.0628789961,
0.7620426416,
0.5781254768,
0.6131039262,
-0.0420650207,
1.0213780403,
0.2907111645,
0.6605956554,
-0.569426477,
0.555521369,
-0.340248853,
0.3106016219,
-0.1975415945,
-0.6951791048,
-0.0572828837,
0.3015436828,
-0.4677116275,
-0.2847097814,
0.744913578,
0.1873127371,
0.1953472942,
0.3616926968,
0.1896060854,
0.4734043479,
-0.0404853374,
-0.1325865239,
0.6479955316,
0.203615889,
0.6663275957,
-0.4088265598,
0.1150278375,
-0.33114779,
-0.9545066357,
-0.9739180803,
-0.2310196757,
-0.3725390732,
-0.5006566644,
0.2866258621,
0.9801508784,
-0.1998440027,
-0.1729899347,
-0.6671731472,
-0.0185254421,
0.5298087001,
-0.1157117337,
-0.2897036076,
0.3545072973,
-0.4114618003,
-0.610130012,
0.048041705,
0.5937211514,
0.1185056567,
0.0377098396,
0.4259597063,
-0.2581228316,
0.5546336174,
0.6698727012,
-0.0595525727,
-0.1818086803,
-0.269007504,
0.2817237973,
0.0260887053,
0.0326234475,
0.8990067244,
-0.6228140593,
-0.1209299266,
0.2638463676,
0.3865441978,
0.5152342319,
0.0016886272,
0.7174203396,
-0.4169622362,
-0.1981368959,
-0.0357256122,
0.6067550182,
-0.1187446043,
-0.3057916462,
0.5051863194,
0.4757480621,
-0.4320559204,
-0.6217771173,
-0.1390654594,
-0.7366828322,
-0.5579879284,
1.2847361565,
-0.1261185706,
-0.6371836066,
-0.0396241732,
-0.0003028291,
0.2574605048,
-0.4795677066,
1.157566905,
0.6889641285,
0.2289166301,
-0.4834281206,
-1.0029705763,
0.1358145773,
-0.5888265967,
-0.5158830285,
0.2681967914,
0.3990069628,
-0.0236067101,
-0.3632125258,
0.7699387074,
0.355807811,
0.0329224989,
0.2302228808,
-0.2435919493,
0.1112366617,
-0.059401378,
0.091252096,
0.1695193201,
-0.3940242231,
0.2857532501
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12104v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12104v1 | End-to-end Text-to-SQL Generation within an Analytics Insight Engine | 2024-06-17T21:33:01 | 2024-06-17T21:33:01 | Karime Maamari, Amine Mhedhbi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.DB, cs.LG | Recent advancements in Text-to-SQL have pushed database management systems
towards greater democratization of data access. Today's language models are at
the core of these advancements. They enable impressive Text-to-SQL generation
as experienced in the development of Distyl AI's Analytics Insight Engine. Its
early deployment with enterprise customers has highlighted three core
challenges. First, data analysts expect support with authoring SQL queries of
very high complexity. Second, requests are ad-hoc and, as such, require low
latency. Finally, generation requires an understanding of domain-specific
terminology and practices.
The design and implementation of our Text-to-SQL generation pipeline, powered
by large language models, tackles these challenges. The core tenants of our
approach rely on external knowledge that we extract in a pre-processing phase,
on retrieving the appropriate external knowledge at query generation time, and
on decomposing SQL query generation following a hierarchical CTE-based
structure. Finally, an adaptation framework leverages feedback to update the
external knowledge, in turn improving query generation over time. We give an
overview of our end-to-end approach and highlight the operators generating SQL
during inference. | [
-0.2396319211,
-0.8218050003,
0.6624807119,
0.0465992019,
-0.199430719,
0.1649887562,
-0.0975307524,
-0.4947988689,
0.1195011586,
0.5180294514,
-1.0053297281,
-0.5291337371,
-0.3943827748,
0.1707584858,
-0.4754730165,
1.1169711351,
0.2918060422,
-0.1706410348,
-0.3949711323,
0.0651126355,
-0.5051433444,
-0.7845358253,
-0.8561427593,
0.237085253,
0.2151076496,
0.3127697408,
0.2037096024,
0.5989043117,
0.2842829227,
0.2773571312,
0.1164129153,
0.395452559,
-0.7711381912,
0.6298607588,
-0.2064096481,
-0.5072907209,
-0.649987936,
-0.4050826728,
0.1744156927,
0.7103281021,
-0.3644050062,
0.1536419392,
-0.1305862814,
1.0491025448,
-0.7000668049,
0.1969722956,
-1.070333004,
-0.1691168398,
-0.1824129075,
-0.2524745464,
-0.7305182815,
-0.1409775615,
0.2243500203,
-0.4503088593,
0.1464521587,
0.1838509142,
0.5794016123,
0.482904762,
-0.5736425519,
-0.5908113718,
-0.6939171553,
0.5017178655,
-0.4764134288,
0.1696502119,
-0.0447270013,
0.5365808606,
-0.1992056221,
-1.0939127207,
-0.3642625809,
0.1149251163,
-0.0510746017,
0.1848184466,
-0.1933951527,
-0.1558806598,
-0.0434532389,
0.1029678658,
-0.4042158127,
-0.0180551521,
-0.2086732537,
0.2726868987,
0.9351629615,
0.4498333931,
-0.0999840796,
0.1561117321,
-0.1321086437,
0.2230279893,
-0.6777072549,
-0.3993817568,
0.2463760823,
0.3717723787,
0.1755972952,
0.4825083017,
-0.3373517692,
0.5916080475,
0.1498937607,
0.706826508,
-0.0524396934,
-0.4830988944,
-0.2481928021,
0.2719128728,
0.7121415138,
0.3177259862,
0.165358603,
-0.2710345685,
-0.0914831758,
-0.2034074068,
0.3833494782,
-1.0082368851,
-0.1504443884,
0.4395904541,
-0.2563553751,
-0.341170907,
-0.2228980064,
-0.9130368233,
-0.5823099017,
-0.4674917459,
0.1917747408,
-0.4184627235,
-0.3388349116,
-0.1202705577,
-0.1978687644,
0.4349187911,
0.2629607618,
-0.8208221197,
0.4716537297,
0.5331447721,
0.679394424,
-0.1341730207,
0.1443113387,
-0.4981070757,
0.2992260456,
-0.4848272502,
0.7692308426,
-0.3435926735,
-0.4105252624,
0.1151731461,
-0.2633629739,
0.152251631,
-0.4099795222,
0.2129004896,
-0.6107503176,
0.4139739871,
-0.1232161298,
-0.925934732,
0.1141717508,
0.0809534639,
-0.268576473,
0.9018313885,
0.065468505,
-0.6715985537,
0.6674456596,
-0.7871723175,
-0.4920371473,
0.3139654994,
-0.3900416195,
-0.4245002866,
0.4274157882,
0.2652864456,
0.3867482841,
-0.7361255288,
0.127635166,
-0.0628550425,
0.0988549963,
0.0269796327,
-0.2110580802,
0.6697880626,
0.4550893605,
-0.2577079237,
0.0013076526,
-1.0345007181,
0.1855563521,
0.5158025622,
0.1666990519,
-0.3509256542,
0.4844162762,
0.0789043978,
-0.0724468306,
0.3181088865,
-0.2535689771,
0.1372333467,
-0.3055273592,
0.6129232049,
0.7172845602,
0.2954499424,
0.1661971211,
0.3066076338,
0.3950252831,
0.229419902,
0.1498684585,
-0.5041656494,
-0.1028065383,
-0.6642574668,
-0.0938450396,
-0.0049039777,
0.4909516573,
-0.5259091854,
0.5457500815,
-0.3690697849,
-0.615015626,
-0.2998328209,
-0.150913313,
-0.0388251767,
0.3827372789,
0.2471945435,
-0.0192665793,
-0.6431833506,
-0.8577168584,
-0.2565660775,
-0.117239885,
-0.0340878367,
0.285631299,
0.3559859991,
-0.065135017,
1.2096905708,
-0.9921172261,
-0.2401939481,
-0.3107720613,
0.0419039316,
0.1854127198,
0.2433822304,
0.5101585388,
-0.860081017,
-0.6573283076,
0.156788975,
-0.7992507815,
-0.0080979308,
-0.0738016143,
-0.4464472234,
0.5306783915,
0.4659591913,
-0.4237956405,
0.2203160971,
0.0694209039,
-0.4518026412,
0.4346373677,
-0.1292552352,
-0.0414564312,
-1.5465552807,
0.0238979217,
-0.0068438766,
-0.1251115203,
-0.7305310965,
-0.1265400052,
-0.2412615716,
-0.2724848688,
-0.1641271263,
0.1745867282,
-0.6611466408,
-0.0583438985,
-0.0834708959,
0.0236814804,
0.1488958001,
0.1576438099,
0.2089833319,
0.7089536786,
0.6912734509,
-0.7782049179,
0.4201698601,
0.2931228578,
-0.216281414,
0.8193695545,
-0.6583150029,
0.4209658206,
-0.1866558045,
0.0542324595,
-0.717330873,
-0.3469387889,
-0.2082560211,
-0.6410203576,
0.368460089,
-0.2021847516,
-0.375680536,
-0.0024214108,
-0.1159798577,
-0.0319115296,
0.5472863913,
-0.6018581986,
0.6627836227,
0.4722928107,
-0.3922002316,
-0.420972079,
-0.6193842292,
0.4328895211,
-0.3372069597,
-0.7507659793,
0.1542201936,
0.0926684812,
-0.4233016074,
-0.0446888618,
0.1453405023,
-0.4090881348,
0.0230499338,
-0.1732622385,
0.2545045614,
-0.2698410451,
0.0950125307,
0.4110620916,
0.0940399915,
0.4588231444,
-0.5688335299,
0.3745774925,
0.3972947001,
-0.2218157649,
-0.2124388665,
0.7280258536,
0.5445360541,
-0.4195551574,
0.9832082987,
0.1697473824,
-0.4558340013,
-0.5599555969,
-0.2829069197,
-0.2433252335,
-0.4359555244,
0.8180877566,
-0.4192984402,
-0.287337333,
0.2771285474,
-0.2077970654,
0.3626136184,
0.5471293926,
0.5972073078,
-0.1586496532,
1.2669385672,
0.7959620953,
0.2420846373,
0.3194314837,
-0.2245175838,
0.4414722025,
-0.5048434138,
-0.460357368,
-0.6345181465,
0.0902746394,
-0.3916039467,
-0.0776181221,
0.4959217012,
0.0440571606,
-0.1325975358,
0.0473051444,
-0.5573732257,
0.3251905143,
0.1176534593,
-0.1994191855,
0.2958326936,
0.1748279929,
0.5802559853,
-0.1603543311,
-0.5911446214,
-0.2179537863,
1.1261712313,
0.0140609052,
0.716003716,
0.2807675302,
0.6258739829,
0.4808270335,
0.067109473,
-0.626303494,
0.5336040854,
-0.2279079705,
-0.6012077332,
-0.0818759799,
-0.4281470776,
-0.4634519815,
0.037135303,
-0.1132586226,
-0.5025606155,
0.10784439,
0.3031401038,
0.1035895273,
-0.0040847911,
-1.0323349237,
0.736897409,
-0.2977534831,
-0.7206907272,
-0.1581338346,
-0.6576130986,
0.2923376858,
-0.1119014546,
0.1350246072,
0.3386288285,
0.024324825,
0.3798167408,
-0.6407974362,
0.688152194,
-0.4539293945,
-0.14247787,
0.5517448783,
0.0481630079,
0.7124572396,
0.0186704192,
-0.1471890509,
-0.0419336595,
-0.0957168564,
-0.1894270629,
-0.6152386665,
0.3583154082,
-0.3352639973,
-0.4287822545,
-0.3213391006,
-0.3961226642,
-0.2822158039,
0.0089527182,
0.4728660583,
0.5270063877,
-0.3377642035,
0.2439026982,
0.5688397288,
-0.0747197494,
0.2482395321,
0.3363560438,
-0.2629829645,
-0.1580452472,
0.8829120994,
0.0525790676,
0.3114733696,
0.4185566008,
-0.1181433722,
-0.8419581652,
-0.7452188134,
-0.6415619254,
-0.0831210986,
-0.619574368,
-0.162852183,
-0.5568556786,
-0.1597130448,
-0.6128094792,
-0.1132848039,
-0.4026255906,
-0.3759531975,
-0.2821442187,
-0.0915556848,
0.6050338149,
0.7733772993,
0.3300347328,
0.2585778236,
-0.7257205844,
-0.2511637211,
-0.1218837723,
0.048068665,
-0.1422229558,
-0.1784550548,
-0.6020896435,
-0.1033626497,
-0.2019426227,
-0.9406353831,
0.3422671556,
0.536754787,
0.1993954778,
0.154215619,
0.1600390822,
0.4746592045,
-0.5487751365,
0.8850960732,
0.0205483269,
-0.8645996451,
0.8765730858,
-0.181817919,
-0.0349205695,
0.4856436253,
0.3248010874,
-0.2042187899,
-0.2095640898,
-0.3506348133,
-1.1943019629,
0.5627812743,
0.1384763271,
-0.0234442391,
-0.0789577514,
0.5293889642,
0.3394720852,
0.5486661792,
-0.3911694884,
-0.193243593,
-0.3025190234,
-0.4455948472,
0.0418793745,
0.0332372896,
0.0246098414,
0.06453114,
0.5998485088,
-0.4667296708,
0.0000911566,
0.1111068279,
-0.1856710017,
0.3737004101,
0.3590375483,
0.0434256569,
0.8779413104,
-0.0862608999,
-0.3599410653,
0.0042672046,
-0.3072482049,
-0.2218545377,
-0.0290084127,
-0.2688959539,
-0.0318396688,
0.2018864006,
0.9283842444,
-0.5545998812,
-0.7314221263,
0.2778938413,
-0.2133158594,
-0.2912195921,
-0.5050227046,
-0.0077741416,
0.0247885529,
-0.0251984019,
0.6301754117,
-0.3801077604,
0.439365983,
-0.5163279176,
0.0989310741,
0.5530347824,
-0.2404481173,
-0.3429309428,
0.9825280905,
0.4158055782,
0.080413118,
0.7303929925,
-0.14990592,
-0.1567172259,
0.5800108314,
0.5887775421,
1.1226524115,
-0.1048601195,
-0.0621371791,
0.2425130904,
0.13970384,
0.5137320757,
0.4145841599,
-0.1059914231,
-0.3254950345,
-0.6149128675,
-0.631783843,
-0.298322916,
-0.1428887993,
-0.8170015216,
0.4406307936,
-0.1637824029,
0.0180986673,
0.0320847854,
-0.1645266712,
-0.424733907,
0.2473123819,
-0.209024474,
0.9560490847,
-0.6831291914,
0.5437215567,
0.7192355394,
-0.3497138917,
-0.453740716,
-0.2729464471,
0.0619892105,
-0.5015671253,
0.5620375872,
0.0299857948,
-0.1233226433,
0.2590761185,
-0.5048004985,
-0.2455183119,
1.0790758133,
0.2809731066,
-0.7011464834,
-0.2097235322,
0.2247243822,
0.6944578886,
-0.7165340185,
0.2811652124,
0.8463022113,
0.1886003762,
0.1841823906,
-0.2317174673,
-0.0850707442,
-0.1577324718,
-0.0433803312,
0.4896757603,
-0.3856953382,
0.6166957617,
-0.2877041698,
-0.2449035048,
-0.3866513669,
0.7952619791,
-0.0161591768,
0.4084433913,
0.4432327449,
0.4112649858,
0.5294750929,
-0.0228397585,
0.8951847553,
-0.3642150462,
0.0625163913,
1.3173480034,
-0.5870409608,
0.8784022927,
0.4655135572,
-0.2054748088,
0.373640269,
0.6414750814,
0.2261793613,
0.5600466728,
-0.0141379042,
-0.2536251247,
0.0372254625,
-0.295031935,
-0.3651713431,
0.4150976539,
0.6110862494,
-0.1741882116,
0.0076072379,
-0.4945295751,
-0.0842306241,
0.2426526546,
-0.2424097657,
1.2309590578,
-0.0645774081,
-0.516830802,
0.143830806,
-0.356674552,
0.1878795177,
-0.7831820846,
-0.0990456343,
-0.2311225981,
0.2008524537,
-0.2180338651,
-0.7572548985,
0.6336190104,
0.2355846763,
-0.2336906791,
0.0150044309,
0.5212016702,
-0.3944949806,
-0.3461383283,
0.3001177609,
0.5845992565,
0.088642478,
-0.2077835351,
-0.3745148182,
-0.1075325608,
0.1927669197,
-0.4236281514,
0.3001084328,
0.8026164174,
0.0964457765,
0.448284328,
0.5163831711,
0.2047336549,
0.3155391216,
0.2095288932,
0.7580392361,
-0.4696367085,
-0.5884190798,
-0.8823388219,
0.7197594047,
-0.3788927197,
-0.1652527153,
0.3943862021,
0.8201285005,
0.2895960212,
0.1152774841,
0.9396067858,
-0.3450663388,
0.4550097287,
-0.6661918163,
0.807136178,
-0.8641831875,
0.2560826242,
-0.0256916638,
-1.0604310036,
0.2117417604,
-0.0803294033,
0.1724633425,
-0.0362991169,
0.7436850071,
0.6041587591,
0.2314702272,
0.1803345382,
-0.0390266031,
0.4621342421,
0.6855306029,
0.4459821582,
0.5655563474,
-0.3202902675,
0.6469974518,
0.1050422043,
-0.2988057435,
0.0683101043,
-0.8644066453,
-0.5285186172,
-0.8114155531,
-0.2009613812,
-0.1655865759,
0.1443966776,
0.7083075047,
0.6466732025,
-0.5531338453,
-0.2390052527,
-0.526491344,
-0.3522365391,
-0.0614163354,
-0.2715640664,
0.3922415972,
-0.628143847,
-0.9233133197,
0.3895833194,
0.4057143629,
-0.2611400485,
-0.3899234533,
0.1871947646,
0.0166679565,
0.1282186806,
0.7797353268,
-0.0360588133,
0.035179615,
0.0254546218,
0.10303431,
0.2146765739,
-0.0575379394,
0.7318245769,
-0.6465349793,
0.3138601184,
0.4116283953,
1.0350773335,
0.7510044575,
0.020054752,
0.8992886543,
-0.9659035802,
-0.0002400829,
0.3378707469,
0.1812453866,
0.3372468352,
-0.6116164923,
0.5881611705,
0.1205775365,
-0.6216790676,
-0.9813237786,
0.4113325775,
-0.5871037245,
-0.2735786736,
0.5726315379,
0.2835837603,
-0.3075783551,
-0.0650189519,
-0.1284101158,
0.1123914346,
-0.4482696056,
0.5249469876,
0.539178431,
-0.4857024848,
-0.0410449542,
-0.4738123119,
0.4026045799,
0.4372926056,
-1.2985560894,
0.5513632298,
0.8021348119,
0.020479681,
-0.0648080409,
0.5773651004,
-0.0078516714,
-0.1757638305,
0.2695637941,
-0.0155631071,
-0.004493075,
-0.364418298,
-0.0541882701,
0.0378472209,
0.1105106622,
-0.2759766877
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12094v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12094v1 | Who's asking? User personas and the mechanics of latent misalignment | 2024-06-17T21:15:12 | 2024-06-17T21:15:12 | Asma Ghandeharioun, Ann Yuan, Marius Guerard, Emily Reif, Michael A. Lepori, Lucas Dixon | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Despite investments in improving model safety, studies show that misaligned
capabilities remain latent in safety-tuned models. In this work, we shed light
on the mechanics of this phenomenon. First, we show that even when model
generations are safe, harmful content can persist in hidden representations and
can be extracted by decoding from earlier layers. Then, we show that whether
the model divulges such content depends significantly on its perception of who
it is talking to, which we refer to as user persona. In fact, we find
manipulating user persona to be even more effective for eliciting harmful
content than direct attempts to control model refusal. We study both natural
language prompting and activation steering as control methods and show that
activation steering is significantly more effective at bypassing safety
filters. We investigate why certain personas break model safeguards and find
that they enable the model to form more charitable interpretations of otherwise
dangerous queries. Finally, we show we can predict a persona's effect on
refusal given only the geometry of its steering vector. | [
-0.2264152169,
-0.7444691658,
0.7108077407,
0.136926204,
0.105101712,
0.0801217183,
0.4320004284,
-0.5927485824,
-0.125774622,
0.663197875,
-0.7537274361,
0.180740118,
-0.5387117267,
-0.1839096546,
-0.2554041147,
0.9314032197,
0.4437652528,
0.0050043617,
-0.2758048475,
0.0892912745,
-0.6491740942,
-0.6093322635,
-0.5603458285,
-0.4015555382,
0.8755460382,
0.3065722585,
1.0910141468,
0.4035569131,
0.2949460745,
0.2979975641,
-0.1398935765,
-0.4648973346,
-0.5444952846,
0.4655267596,
-0.4721248448,
-0.6888099313,
-0.3994955122,
0.3167500496,
0.2017061412,
1.0054428577,
0.0149128092,
-0.2877102494,
0.2333644629,
0.4279847145,
-0.8850690722,
-0.3736070693,
-0.4566999972,
-0.1871039271,
-0.3356225193,
-0.3589387834,
-0.5992649198,
-0.2950633764,
0.3590332568,
-0.5434345603,
0.1003973186,
0.2912902832,
0.7433509231,
0.49292624,
-0.7954860926,
0.0184825491,
-0.9198730588,
0.7588988543,
-0.3261168897,
0.4468070865,
0.8785806298,
0.3629291654,
-0.283772856,
-0.516648531,
-0.5384907126,
0.0513813831,
-0.2106085122,
0.0158632416,
-0.4078731239,
0.2278987914,
0.3963318467,
-0.1200640351,
-0.6596236229,
0.3567097783,
-0.5693922639,
-0.3776637614,
0.735304296,
-0.0191496983,
0.4359714389,
-0.5363265276,
-0.606687367,
-0.1569781154,
-0.953175962,
0.0199560821,
0.8533270955,
0.0433037169,
-0.0146362679,
0.6646107435,
0.121159412,
0.5547814369,
0.4831431508,
0.1266094893,
-0.0746332109,
0.0135197788,
-0.0963727981,
-0.0051027811,
0.742461741,
0.5305091143,
0.2646827698,
-0.1452671885,
-0.1502978355,
-0.2537701428,
0.7849815488,
-0.35362795,
-0.3206138015,
0.2715510428,
-0.5636665225,
-0.4496078193,
0.1653300524,
-0.702442348,
-0.7954807878,
-0.2335049808,
0.4455409646,
-0.3960073888,
-0.318423003,
0.1379826069,
0.0620912053,
0.2616499662,
0.1609591246,
-1.0100297928,
0.0337349623,
0.680426836,
0.2928140163,
-0.0203205757,
-0.1369910836,
-0.7420281768,
0.2267504781,
-0.212291643,
0.8439415693,
-0.5716017485,
-0.7296788096,
-0.1784882247,
0.1049868241,
-0.2213995606,
-0.5191552639,
0.432363838,
-0.7918955684,
0.4954807162,
-0.7901352048,
-0.2084243298,
-0.2428420335,
0.1217826381,
-0.6411602497,
0.6942863464,
-0.0371471941,
-0.8368987441,
0.2614940703,
-0.541470468,
-0.3333728015,
0.0428491719,
-0.215272963,
-0.2011691034,
0.202205047,
0.0107495561,
0.4026980698,
0.0712952465,
0.2948279679,
-0.4173527658,
0.0072278841,
0.6657199264,
-0.486812979,
1.035849452,
0.2856443524,
-0.1188014373,
0.0720503405,
-0.311642617,
-0.1602659523,
-0.022418417,
-0.176980719,
-0.4716117382,
0.1608413905,
0.0161872581,
0.4075528681,
0.0944572091,
-0.29613778,
-0.2084287852,
-0.3711380959,
0.2232208997,
0.8286673427,
0.4513204396,
0.7129721045,
-0.4895084798,
0.7820738554,
0.057666298,
0.2964037657,
0.1182218939,
-0.7009728551,
-0.4918560982,
0.5340083241,
0.0478004031,
0.6663392186,
-0.759770453,
0.2169830948,
0.0926769078,
-0.1488903463,
-0.2367341518,
-0.120686233,
0.6208292246,
0.8666456938,
0.2089651525,
-0.2504549026,
-0.2338809818,
-1.0592663288,
-0.5201753974,
-0.8259938955,
-0.1137409732,
0.2330832332,
0.2063270211,
0.0837869048,
0.8902504444,
-0.4850403368,
0.2671023309,
-0.1375871152,
0.3930146396,
-0.5304445028,
0.7550142407,
0.7986103296,
-1.1621489525,
-0.2265385389,
-0.3870508075,
-0.646643281,
-0.2740541101,
-0.2468670458,
-0.2858664989,
0.1224062592,
0.6858274937,
-0.5692270398,
0.571636498,
0.2367292941,
-0.541331768,
0.5480728745,
-0.2182065994,
0.1663386077,
-0.8921117783,
0.2264645249,
0.1058917418,
-0.2114901394,
-0.8111514449,
0.0088658417,
0.0926545933,
-0.1558928639,
-0.6953883171,
0.1808583587,
-0.3649017513,
-0.0044074869,
-0.3343212008,
0.1133599803,
0.0776161924,
0.1929737031,
-0.2267102152,
0.8513514996,
0.3746237755,
-0.9906714559,
-0.0536705814,
0.4043347239,
-0.1283892393,
1.1759710312,
-0.775708437,
0.4206190705,
-0.4503411055,
-0.0910302401,
-1.0405400991,
-0.5800414085,
0.6413215995,
-0.6290183663,
0.4059101343,
-0.2993666232,
-0.2530232072,
-0.2524604201,
0.1445539743,
0.3088925779,
0.4968544245,
-0.1781383902,
0.5107821226,
0.722727716,
-0.2758630216,
-0.5926187634,
-0.6738801599,
-0.116977416,
-0.5662899613,
-0.6432772279,
0.4035899639,
-0.3640666604,
-0.5060502887,
-0.124582544,
-0.2228134125,
-0.237164855,
0.4630242288,
0.5490361452,
0.1463910639,
0.0727469921,
0.2693146467,
0.3597487509,
-0.3602669239,
0.3470495641,
0.0005362517,
0.2665166855,
0.1022394001,
-0.5550606251,
-0.5624137521,
0.5006267428,
0.4852875769,
-0.2611804903,
0.7370558977,
0.1920981407,
-0.4565999806,
0.4385855794,
-0.5207363367,
-0.5345802307,
-0.5422956347,
0.0505988635,
-0.1487410665,
-0.7960714102,
0.4713618159,
0.0209791288,
-0.0025878677,
0.2527165413,
0.1847285181,
-0.4593681097,
1.2153100967,
0.8564317226,
0.0407982804,
0.1708515286,
0.105907023,
0.2601470351,
-0.5167608857,
-0.5712897778,
-0.7719534039,
-0.5191038251,
-0.4302569926,
-0.2384884357,
0.438462317,
0.0401029363,
-0.2369225621,
0.3921965957,
-0.1466839612,
0.5826390386,
0.267786324,
0.1221282035,
0.2459744811,
-0.185621053,
-0.0376245268,
-0.4763388336,
-0.4756202996,
-0.6757713556,
0.6456552744,
0.3476949632,
1.0243196487,
0.4341973066,
0.2419945002,
0.1869050115,
0.0168784857,
-0.5283879638,
0.5633077025,
0.3504168689,
-1.2837991714,
-0.0910589248,
-0.0202161521,
-1.1081018448,
0.191152975,
-0.419310987,
-1.0495671034,
0.5412522554,
0.4087264836,
-0.772069633,
0.2340297401,
-0.6910294294,
0.7139025331,
-0.5118320584,
-0.5478879809,
-0.1555800885,
-1.1455903053,
0.2579205334,
0.0488618687,
0.0469584204,
-0.0516613908,
-0.1360260993,
0.6537123322,
-0.2583471835,
1.0578752756,
-0.383628428,
-0.1212717667,
0.0924443677,
0.4162798524,
0.3087536991,
-0.0341823064,
-0.0443225801,
-0.2824304998,
-0.1474915743,
-0.3165253699,
-0.7611556053,
0.6796875,
-0.5996789336,
-0.9804193974,
-0.3855440617,
-0.3601379097,
-0.4185240567,
0.3003787994,
0.5314965844,
0.0491775349,
-0.2259943932,
0.2168597728,
1.0912926197,
-0.3051711321,
0.4333209097,
0.4762961566,
-0.1181245074,
0.2794648707,
0.5573219657,
0.0290693548,
0.4707172215,
0.2460900545,
0.0436927006,
-0.4840811491,
-0.4325912893,
-0.3965537548,
0.2621389329,
-0.5196729302,
0.0383780301,
-0.7914327383,
-0.1058662683,
-0.4024582505,
-0.0841866583,
-0.2820785046,
-0.4329299629,
-0.6533043385,
-0.3372524083,
-0.0878312364,
0.7738028169,
-0.0322481431,
0.7525886297,
-0.4381403923,
0.0441071354,
0.4567486346,
0.1207271367,
-0.2105304599,
-0.4191594124,
0.2613007724,
-0.142869547,
-0.7277159095,
-1.3503252268,
0.2826317251,
-0.2398935556,
0.8133916855,
0.7838310599,
0.4417026937,
0.4283416271,
-0.2005502284,
0.649353981,
0.0800888985,
-0.6507796049,
0.6674733162,
-0.5230030417,
-0.041038502,
0.641892314,
0.8744280338,
-0.5796512961,
-0.1584025025,
-0.7369717956,
-0.5273560286,
0.7316083312,
0.174867779,
0.3793145418,
0.1809060425,
0.5318099856,
0.1860655695,
0.1701626927,
-0.743924439,
-0.3646622598,
-0.1511370093,
0.1472952813,
0.1094763502,
-0.6448444724,
-0.1426053196,
0.1514100283,
0.4502054751,
-0.0414614715,
0.2042516768,
-0.0552019216,
-0.0893408284,
-0.4560674131,
0.313454777,
0.5012838244,
0.702598691,
0.0439203307,
0.0759602115,
-0.1462115198,
-0.4090310633,
0.0754181519,
-0.0054754005,
-0.3615972102,
-0.5103396177,
-0.0045582252,
0.7384679914,
0.5833370686,
-0.3235295415,
0.5626170039,
-0.0754506811,
-0.1801323891,
-0.1433748156,
0.4001107514,
-0.0382242091,
0.156897828,
0.3504392505,
0.3735170364,
0.1261398941,
-0.3241514266,
0.0641040727,
0.4185798764,
-0.615032196,
-0.6373010278,
1.0956426859,
0.2498527616,
-0.493385613,
0.6643113494,
0.2136260718,
-0.4498316944,
0.2372672409,
0.3533940613,
0.7017768025,
-0.503865242,
0.4094375372,
0.2857707739,
0.399505198,
0.1300984174,
0.3218586743,
0.0214152802,
-0.6686890721,
-0.2515569329,
-0.0744241476,
-0.4353168607,
0.3452424705,
-0.8969378471,
-0.0140785091,
-0.6105946302,
-0.4989052713,
0.0217586756,
-0.4340311587,
-0.3320108056,
0.172418952,
-0.0523359142,
0.6406744719,
-0.8786814809,
0.3453868926,
0.7626018524,
-0.3955101073,
-0.7920091748,
0.506308496,
0.4448367357,
-0.4490627348,
0.4030314386,
0.0375389233,
-0.0147282118,
-0.134420082,
-1.0001591444,
-0.8812155128,
0.811686039,
0.6127691865,
-0.2408547103,
-0.3721852005,
0.0715585276,
0.251353085,
0.0472768806,
-0.1846230626,
0.3193852007,
0.5072522163,
0.1644653827,
-0.8363654017,
-0.1114242598,
-0.2154378891,
-0.0669545829,
-0.07257393,
-0.5810676813,
0.8653267622,
-0.3897990882,
-0.3350080848,
0.0607974753,
0.6332340837,
0.2803285718,
0.3205032945,
0.7402223349,
0.2358277142,
0.9394295812,
-0.1238443181,
1.2734640837,
0.0786931291,
-0.1746868491,
0.8682870865,
-0.1001425087,
0.5639306903,
0.5829460621,
0.0472993776,
0.6462441087,
0.6774298549,
0.5022698045,
0.5369678736,
-0.2983839512,
-0.2353124768,
-0.696439147,
0.0163563043,
-0.4121649265,
0.5943837166,
0.5096852183,
-0.2506396472,
-0.0750642344,
0.1395175159,
0.2226488888,
0.2586091161,
0.0760950074,
0.5755969286,
0.1252816767,
-0.9846374393,
0.046230115,
0.1443531364,
0.2765032649,
-0.4059880376,
0.3876623809,
-0.0703967214,
-0.0689089,
-0.1045513377,
-0.8075562119,
0.458840847,
-0.2272990942,
-0.1501522958,
-0.4295198619,
1.1230741739,
0.0063117607,
-0.1370559782,
0.0615283512,
0.8378420472,
0.2262394875,
-0.053133443,
-0.8732434511,
-0.1121125594,
-0.1438654214,
-0.1803997606,
0.3948313296,
0.1790579259,
-0.3315612078,
0.911741972,
0.544750154,
-0.2912181616,
0.1035418883,
-0.0396723375,
0.7774258852,
-0.6270118356,
-0.7789945602,
-0.5191764832,
0.8586756587,
-0.0070725023,
-0.2808130085,
0.7982484698,
0.2391767055,
0.9219612479,
-0.0296614803,
0.6414391398,
-0.0661015213,
0.4700905085,
-0.4396540523,
1.3060230017,
-0.5970531106,
0.3450537622,
-0.3587638438,
-0.6051467061,
-0.1635186821,
0.6837499142,
-0.7000994682,
0.367736876,
0.4013209939,
0.8499546051,
-0.0437239259,
0.2737409174,
0.2737223506,
0.0632974356,
0.365688622,
0.4628821313,
1.1758788824,
-0.2405874431,
0.334327668,
-0.1541658342,
0.0433920175,
-0.3169019818,
-0.8600173593,
-0.8292336464,
-0.8036679029,
-0.4539346993,
-0.4528551102,
-0.0183588527,
0.3826700747,
1.0730415583,
-0.5516862869,
0.080089964,
-0.0035437772,
0.3435205817,
0.3174315095,
-0.1579424143,
-0.2187170833,
0.0476218797,
-0.7503125668,
0.5144580603,
0.1854534745,
0.5588065386,
-0.5562443733,
-0.1135309711,
-0.282153368,
0.0560381301,
0.2619859576,
0.6432493329,
-0.5323745608,
-0.4060521722,
0.198126331,
-0.1876030117,
-0.0026879783,
0.9817969799,
-0.8546978831,
0.4411216378,
0.3859980702,
0.3571433723,
0.0849757269,
0.3349748552,
0.7301404476,
-0.7260594964,
0.0658035204,
0.3057696521,
0.2042141855,
0.4863888621,
-0.7578376532,
0.1393666714,
0.3965140581,
-0.5732349157,
-0.6498883367,
0.5271894932,
-0.7930105329,
-0.2811665833,
0.8995773792,
0.1259641796,
-0.2526137829,
-0.5399166942,
-0.2565523982,
-0.0163810793,
-0.1779678315,
0.6795148849,
0.561473906,
-0.3159969449,
-0.3457933664,
-0.6481497884,
0.5723864436,
0.6271672845,
-0.6428079605,
-0.0963739902,
0.7446445227,
0.4329013228,
0.1399903893,
0.6121561527,
-0.1972009391,
0.3811229169,
-0.2532529235,
-0.588092804,
0.0243451484,
-0.6375238895,
-0.2722705305,
0.2998957634,
0.1619926095,
0.0639994219
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12091v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12091v2 | Is poisoning a real threat to LLM alignment? Maybe more so than you think | 2024-06-17T21:06:00 | 2024-06-19T17:56:17 | Pankayaraj Pathmanathan, Souradip Chakraborty, Xiangyu Liu, Yongyuan Liang, Furong Huang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CR | Recent advancements in Reinforcement Learning with Human Feedback (RLHF) have
significantly impacted the alignment of Large Language Models (LLMs). The
sensitivity of reinforcement learning algorithms such as Proximal Policy
Optimization (PPO) has led to new line work on Direct Policy Optimization
(DPO), which treats RLHF in a supervised learning framework. The increased
practical use of these RLHF methods warrants an analysis of their
vulnerabilities. In this work, we investigate the vulnerabilities of DPO to
poisoning attacks under different scenarios and compare the effectiveness of
preference poisoning, a first of its kind. We comprehensively analyze DPO's
vulnerabilities under different types of attacks, i.e., backdoor and
non-backdoor attacks, and different poisoning methods across a wide array of
language models, i.e., LLama 7B, Mistral 7B, and Gemma 7B. We find that unlike
PPO-based methods, which, when it comes to backdoor attacks, require at least
4\% of the data to be poisoned to elicit harmful behavior, we exploit the true
vulnerabilities of DPO more simply so we can poison the model with only as much
as 0.5\% of the data. We further investigate the potential reasons behind the
vulnerability and how well this vulnerability translates into backdoor vs
non-backdoor attacks. | [
0.0282128323,
-0.6221215129,
0.579046011,
0.0091822445,
0.1600678116,
-0.037821319,
0.0347306281,
-0.3806845546,
-0.3015056551,
0.8324315548,
-0.6452638507,
-0.3935510218,
-0.3422668874,
-0.0341972299,
-0.075057894,
1.0322757959,
0.1150185615,
-0.1026337072,
-0.024129048,
0.1648100317,
-0.7208218575,
-0.8187850118,
-0.5715342164,
-0.3905592263,
0.7645292282,
0.4574348032,
0.8189820647,
0.5754362941,
0.5312733054,
0.2569662929,
-0.0425571874,
-0.1048642695,
-0.6384379268,
0.3855835497,
-0.3161215484,
-0.5120251775,
-0.5250942707,
0.0397081524,
0.2914842367,
0.1171325967,
-0.3028456569,
-0.2909787297,
-0.087165609,
0.8985587955,
-0.8470001221,
-0.4395309687,
-0.9557138681,
0.2713467777,
-0.0530217662,
-0.2616763413,
-0.7702271342,
-0.2068310976,
0.3064126968,
-0.5498152971,
-0.4208059907,
0.1583952159,
0.7613322139,
0.5855964422,
-0.4433223605,
-0.1935778409,
-0.5597122312,
0.8951244354,
-0.5805231929,
0.0874499902,
0.2842741609,
0.3369489312,
-0.701603353,
-0.2476005554,
-0.5469273329,
-0.4210381508,
0.0277577676,
0.0486808345,
-0.2234309614,
0.3354468346,
0.0438981876,
0.283210367,
-0.7185432911,
0.6085203886,
0.2039721608,
-0.2887267172,
0.8267106414,
0.4536189735,
0.5711658597,
-0.3273961246,
-0.7672379613,
-0.3970624804,
-1.0087502003,
-0.1827488989,
1.0087952614,
0.1680232137,
0.125939846,
0.2769984603,
0.224644199,
0.6794582605,
-0.0153970486,
-0.1855340153,
-0.2269625515,
-0.2176156193,
-0.1170212105,
0.3205642402,
0.913920939,
0.6215217113,
0.3646829724,
-0.2170953155,
-0.0504912138,
-0.1472604722,
0.5772307515,
-0.5163419843,
-0.3390029371,
0.6127099991,
0.1101618707,
-0.8312240243,
-0.1684740186,
-0.9628813267,
-0.5712039471,
0.2554321289,
0.3240537643,
-0.2878420949,
-0.3273295164,
0.0513515137,
0.0294165425,
0.4223317802,
-0.028313823,
-1.1110128164,
0.0964272618,
1.0669817924,
0.5482496023,
-0.4221435785,
-0.4976433218,
-0.485496223,
0.2441017032,
-0.3227065504,
0.5672520995,
-0.3621406555,
-0.5463299155,
0.075568974,
-0.2424998134,
0.0471380241,
-0.8116185665,
0.5859228373,
-0.7265545726,
0.0867519751,
-0.1715715379,
-0.2808727324,
0.0588524565,
0.2762271762,
-0.6041974425,
0.7247759104,
-0.2296246588,
-0.9523396492,
0.1763796657,
-0.1039844826,
-0.3400515616,
-0.3848472834,
-0.0062254639,
-0.572281599,
-0.2828742862,
-0.00210684,
0.2052764297,
0.0178627353,
0.4194231331,
-0.472048074,
-0.1927139461,
0.5706903934,
-0.5311254263,
0.733953774,
0.3236433864,
0.0367938504,
0.3926166296,
-0.6451868415,
-0.0253398512,
0.2233461142,
-0.3740297258,
-0.3675633073,
0.1455645859,
-0.2123958021,
0.374428302,
0.1988604665,
-0.319938153,
0.4637720287,
-0.5685213208,
0.4398600459,
1.1847280264,
0.4417979121,
0.5216742754,
-0.4170452058,
0.5694844723,
0.0243376177,
0.6143761873,
0.1412535012,
-0.1426511705,
-0.2766445279,
-0.3061957061,
0.1318661124,
0.9046955705,
-0.5013028383,
0.6403114796,
-0.1330937743,
-0.571321249,
-0.2338238806,
-0.0897183865,
0.7991620302,
0.8053027987,
0.1808050573,
0.0023747471,
-0.3395056129,
-0.9013380408,
-0.4194861054,
-0.2802300453,
0.2338873148,
0.249769032,
0.4157902598,
-0.3550517261,
0.8752978444,
-0.6545889974,
-0.2215278,
-0.1038173139,
-0.4259301722,
0.1296888888,
0.557957232,
0.5275033116,
-0.4213718176,
-0.3997477889,
-0.0934531018,
-0.6612987518,
-0.3208157718,
-0.1610732228,
-0.465326786,
0.2424900681,
0.1401335746,
-0.3380741179,
0.2346197814,
0.6244704127,
-0.0051968438,
0.8024399877,
-0.0286589544,
-0.1730824262,
-0.8944203854,
-0.0328635201,
-0.0992798805,
0.0110580921,
-0.9270672202,
0.2023978978,
0.0639384165,
-0.2719715834,
-0.8646402955,
0.4810651243,
-0.0993027315,
0.1727343351,
-0.1019756645,
-0.0656327084,
0.051879745,
0.498811245,
-0.0747288689,
0.9168201685,
0.5136614442,
-0.5659128428,
0.4418947697,
0.1337562352,
-0.0603523701,
0.2911966741,
-0.4635469913,
0.3123858571,
0.2623093724,
0.251506567,
-0.7994993925,
-0.4004737437,
0.5679091811,
-0.2146015912,
0.6324314475,
-0.1820129752,
-0.3363873363,
-0.018335253,
-0.7661867142,
0.2669186592,
0.2781910598,
-0.7001569867,
0.1651491523,
0.3656543493,
0.1850977093,
-1.098857522,
-0.4797607958,
0.0872150362,
-0.6164265871,
-0.7419275045,
0.387881577,
0.0630212724,
-0.4756998718,
-0.2623662651,
-0.3163351119,
0.1680137366,
0.5124689937,
0.1947336495,
0.3247117996,
0.3620512784,
-0.2282420099,
-0.0279798638,
-0.2967312038,
0.1079982892,
0.0256237015,
0.6795691252,
0.1833460629,
-0.344758451,
-0.8065001965,
0.452478677,
0.4253323972,
-0.0272356812,
0.5492691994,
-0.2514865994,
0.016405914,
-0.2685321569,
-0.1503232419,
-0.2616811693,
-0.5214087963,
0.476580143,
-0.2322045118,
-0.4212395847,
0.5064763427,
0.1150262728,
-0.0511288382,
0.157676369,
0.4246054292,
0.0873812512,
0.8832480907,
0.4396002591,
-0.3837980926,
0.6147203445,
0.0166892484,
0.1242153496,
-0.9326511025,
-0.106349349,
-0.1270340681,
-0.1768143624,
-0.6798947453,
0.0366497859,
0.4067416489,
-0.0268358756,
-0.4320733249,
0.2838983834,
-0.4714210331,
0.6889455914,
0.462405324,
0.0843128487,
0.298327148,
-0.0340826958,
-0.2138886601,
-0.146856606,
-0.4901042879,
-0.5297127366,
1.2143058777,
0.5326578617,
1.1835230589,
0.2427383959,
0.9536404014,
0.2032309175,
0.0558415465,
-0.9039321542,
0.4772775471,
0.1480270475,
-0.7018991113,
-0.2079211324,
-0.360319078,
-1.0804796219,
0.3558571041,
0.0103347907,
-0.7682350278,
0.1244207099,
0.3089910746,
-0.4228332937,
0.2138203532,
-0.8664048314,
0.9251599908,
-0.6554077864,
-0.6328054667,
0.0147378379,
-0.6876972914,
0.6174329519,
-0.0885285437,
-0.0405901149,
-0.1456370354,
-0.0022880908,
0.5947304964,
-0.5614260435,
0.8307923675,
0.0037833482,
-0.5059791803,
0.0085222144,
0.2510244548,
0.5554136038,
0.0427189134,
-0.152484104,
0.1768306345,
-0.0101199988,
-0.3055804968,
-0.5215901732,
0.8916708231,
-0.9612321854,
-1.0896681547,
-0.9098045826,
-0.2812801898,
-0.3220952153,
-0.0108746868,
0.243927449,
0.0935440287,
-0.0292920507,
-0.4505872726,
0.6684754491,
-0.5280143023,
0.3838750124,
0.5249071121,
-0.2381042093,
-0.5897315145,
0.9635728002,
-0.0159905069,
0.6323635578,
0.3882124722,
0.4134578109,
-0.0950323567,
-0.5746712685,
-0.3077712953,
0.445409596,
-0.6407505274,
-0.3050103486,
-0.3238746226,
-0.0992844477,
-0.539085269,
-0.0753201097,
-0.2871016562,
0.0313512385,
-0.4050386548,
-0.1743153781,
0.3568707705,
0.5510860085,
-0.0191124808,
0.4700058699,
-0.6422250867,
-0.2179917395,
0.4148102403,
0.0352165177,
0.013669746,
-0.3839618266,
0.2150691599,
-0.2998633385,
-0.6390129328,
-1.4983823299,
0.5532246232,
-0.1217322201,
0.5260698795,
0.5446794629,
0.3019658625,
0.520996809,
-0.6077035666,
0.7516709566,
0.1502599567,
-0.6874361038,
0.5721558332,
-0.4256046712,
-0.201099515,
0.6088479757,
0.5018277168,
-0.6676642895,
-0.1602225006,
-0.3188199997,
-1.0588519573,
0.7416929603,
-0.1454642564,
0.0813324153,
-0.0389232673,
0.4473285079,
0.109527126,
0.0632623732,
-0.5948576331,
-0.1782885343,
0.1536818594,
-0.0190041475,
0.2906996906,
-0.5167393684,
-0.2425627261,
-0.0065279729,
0.7748778462,
0.2155260891,
-0.0751601979,
0.1644929349,
-0.0742206126,
-0.08612784,
0.3860084713,
0.7054963708,
0.3948532343,
-0.2838366628,
0.203135699,
0.0513881594,
-0.5085010529,
0.3574807346,
-0.2428196967,
-0.0454716943,
-0.7348618507,
0.5334332585,
0.5992776155,
0.1618347466,
-0.8246738315,
0.4551951289,
-0.0995021164,
0.1633822918,
-0.3928471506,
0.3028713465,
-0.2600847185,
0.0148373675,
0.1781723499,
-0.3737729788,
-0.1148777157,
-0.7192211151,
0.1943611801,
0.5502117276,
-0.2970873713,
-0.2824030817,
0.3767208159,
0.2754046321,
-0.3578644991,
0.514387548,
0.1901324838,
-0.9212973714,
0.3565964699,
0.5866748691,
0.785176754,
-0.6160610318,
-0.0955786556,
0.1205281615,
0.2723211646,
0.2014418244,
-0.0067748441,
0.0244462993,
-0.8241360188,
-0.2513518929,
-0.5175622702,
-0.6007515788,
0.2374935895,
-0.5652446151,
0.0598567426,
-0.6420292854,
-0.1898254603,
-0.2362713069,
-0.0600432158,
0.1918459684,
-0.227597177,
-0.0189652536,
0.4499723315,
-0.9346847534,
0.7115873694,
0.3035434484,
-0.3193312287,
-0.6459608674,
0.4808513224,
0.2433464229,
-0.9563911557,
0.7151129246,
0.0460327081,
-0.1381693929,
-0.0657810718,
-0.3920274079,
-0.7035556436,
0.8671892881,
0.402843684,
-0.6633772254,
-0.1839013994,
0.0340893231,
0.3581851125,
0.149575457,
-0.1753201336,
0.8015730977,
0.492998302,
-0.1121638566,
-0.8355486989,
0.06312868,
0.1289541572,
-0.0548890829,
0.3673443496,
-0.6826095581,
0.5711401701,
-0.166775316,
-0.2530068755,
-0.2391435206,
0.3407692909,
0.2843118608,
0.0883464813,
0.3841172755,
0.9637015462,
0.6167860031,
0.0657945573,
1.2314972878,
-0.0136208693,
0.1709002256,
1.1712185144,
-0.8060081601,
0.9816095829,
0.7634642124,
-0.3037344515,
0.3497836292,
0.7087064385,
0.1619016677,
0.881367445,
0.5100616813,
-0.3231267631,
-0.1222973466,
0.0220211521,
-0.2398566753,
0.2163066566,
0.3033869267,
-0.1776578277,
-0.0616182089,
0.0226109736,
0.5526356101,
0.1710370183,
-0.0448301919,
1.0595171452,
0.0336087123,
-1.043000102,
0.6337668896,
-0.1729987264,
0.6621257067,
-0.4814102352,
0.2123852074,
-0.2332394123,
0.4378839433,
-0.4196332097,
-0.9062847495,
0.3589608371,
-0.092679143,
0.0624610968,
-0.0332677066,
0.5988011956,
-0.1898641735,
0.2950435281,
0.5259028077,
-0.0993781313,
-0.1236523464,
-0.100407891,
-0.6058787704,
0.2428869307,
0.0049681221,
-0.3201034963,
0.6749468446,
-0.0826394409,
-0.0522923656,
0.8044083118,
0.6852570176,
0.2371239811,
0.2639212012,
-0.2627493143,
0.8542625308,
-0.4177057743,
-0.2176700979,
-1.2876852751,
0.2119041979,
-0.096423462,
-0.1158106178,
0.8310539722,
0.3496323824,
0.7329631448,
0.0570679195,
0.5423488617,
0.3944482207,
0.0537817441,
-0.6565952301,
0.8165905476,
-0.4193985164,
0.4281643331,
-0.1635605693,
-0.7148263454,
-0.3450151086,
0.2934110165,
-0.726968646,
-0.3288001716,
0.6635285616,
1.0252289772,
0.4168006182,
-0.2411235422,
0.2008245587,
0.1279784888,
0.5884635448,
0.7014467716,
1.2249060869,
-0.070008263,
0.586144805,
-0.385104239,
-0.249612689,
-0.4449346066,
-1.001912117,
-0.8020563722,
-0.2960548401,
-0.2560119629,
-0.6021028161,
0.188324526,
0.7377225161,
0.4482254386,
-0.5969142914,
-0.0863349438,
-0.0954373404,
0.4837789237,
-0.0159174316,
-0.2732117474,
0.2808662951,
-0.2375480831,
-0.5395411253,
0.389126718,
0.3097928762,
0.0299992468,
-0.4457495511,
-0.0974183455,
-0.2903366983,
0.0320362784,
0.2506614923,
0.5048199892,
-0.804518342,
-0.4429523051,
-0.2097693533,
-0.2588108182,
0.0300411936,
0.5904972553,
-0.3758188188,
0.4588955045,
0.6852278113,
0.6692923307,
-0.0269959997,
0.125550732,
0.6173798442,
-0.8124238253,
0.1400456429,
0.4372626841,
0.2549600899,
0.2286528051,
-0.8043943644,
0.2583411932,
0.0647102743,
-0.7994585633,
-1.1274853945,
0.7361810207,
-0.9985526204,
-0.3103541136,
1.3326132298,
-0.1317156255,
-0.6234171391,
0.0443154387,
-0.3220938444,
-0.002997454,
-0.5685640574,
0.7603907585,
0.6168006659,
-0.2223493606,
0.2898217142,
-0.5691813827,
0.6598457098,
0.396720171,
-0.7996246219,
0.3361308277,
0.4061093628,
0.4918310046,
0.0801512599,
0.3252991736,
-0.2144733816,
0.1021583974,
-0.2352318168,
-0.0866192132,
-0.0246254466,
-0.3941368461,
-0.6408736706,
0.0148992846,
0.2740339935,
-0.1725039482
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12084v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12084v1 | When Reasoning Meets Information Aggregation: A Case Study with Sports Narratives | 2024-06-17T20:49:35 | 2024-06-17T20:49:35 | Yebowen Hu, Kaiqiang Song, Sangwoo Cho, Xiaoyang Wang, Wenlin Yao, Hassan Foroosh, Dong Yu, Fei Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Reasoning is most powerful when an LLM accurately aggregates relevant
information. We examine the critical role of information aggregation in
reasoning by requiring the LLM to analyze sports narratives. To succeed at this
task, an LLM must infer points from actions, identify related entities,
attribute points accurately to players and teams, and compile key statistics to
draw conclusions. We conduct comprehensive experiments with real NBA basketball
data and present SportsGen, a new method to synthesize game narratives. By
synthesizing data, we can rigorously evaluate LLMs' reasoning capabilities
under complex scenarios with varying narrative lengths and density of
information. Our findings show that most models, including GPT-4o, often fail
to accurately aggregate basketball scores due to frequent scoring patterns.
Open-source models like Llama-3 further suffer from significant score
hallucinations. Finally, the effectiveness of reasoning is influenced by
narrative complexity, information density, and domain-specific terms,
highlighting the challenges in analytical reasoning tasks. | [
-0.2471360117,
-0.8978893161,
1.0049412251,
0.1360600889,
-0.1984641999,
0.3110970855,
0.1547011733,
-0.6736109853,
0.0143453442,
0.1309775412,
-0.3522591591,
-0.4879389405,
-0.7149367332,
-0.0624680966,
-0.4422495961,
0.7538025379,
-0.2467080206,
-0.121790722,
-0.5844677091,
-0.3415448666,
-0.5171693563,
-0.6048179269,
-0.5855441093,
-0.3881182373,
-0.0785502046,
0.3138750494,
0.6868979931,
0.7706006169,
0.7466242909,
0.3771581054,
0.2044611126,
0.605694592,
-0.737090826,
0.5281631947,
-0.2291347384,
-0.6655211449,
-0.5801491737,
0.2062499523,
0.3094428778,
0.6543679237,
-0.2006890327,
0.2618143559,
-0.1235985383,
0.5857380033,
-0.4345384538,
0.1257951558,
-0.3523182273,
0.0551038682,
-0.0134147629,
-0.5507803559,
-0.1506025344,
-0.4307385087,
-0.0384187549,
-0.695672214,
0.1674492508,
0.0410048291,
0.6799246073,
0.3708666563,
-0.3104637861,
-0.4098562896,
-1.0671151876,
0.6947982311,
-0.4460344911,
0.2382674813,
0.4328072965,
0.2342974395,
-0.1478231847,
-0.3415654004,
-0.4149609804,
0.032008674,
0.0177382194,
0.3803771436,
-0.4168950617,
-0.160022676,
0.329798162,
0.1367797554,
-0.4602191448,
-0.2075063884,
-0.7063622475,
0.2051166296,
0.9087776542,
0.5298579335,
0.2418372333,
0.156519115,
-0.4342553616,
0.4014751911,
-0.4671579003,
0.275367707,
0.322026372,
-0.1772889346,
0.1282876283,
0.7240977883,
-0.2112980485,
0.5165775418,
0.1005066782,
-0.4442977905,
0.05593336,
-0.185156405,
-0.2254439443,
0.5805112123,
0.6787328124,
0.7443934083,
0.0757659897,
-0.4348083436,
0.1299692243,
0.0940501764,
0.2884830832,
-0.3833171129,
-0.0483875349,
0.6399900913,
-0.4918040633,
-0.1630617231,
0.1315564215,
-0.4685143828,
-0.5085749626,
-0.5332064629,
0.4386593699,
-0.6365842223,
0.1679598987,
0.1082360819,
-0.6511514187,
0.3068058193,
0.4422232509,
-0.7054997087,
0.1955739558,
0.7847092748,
0.7981964946,
-0.1892575026,
-0.4013967216,
-0.4723398685,
0.5809637904,
-0.5766713023,
1.224247098,
-0.4833712578,
-0.1925839335,
-0.2542566955,
-0.6857590079,
0.2077359557,
-0.5313392282,
0.4187414646,
-0.0786427706,
-0.1024580523,
-0.0418793932,
-1.0216155052,
-0.062118791,
0.4223110378,
-0.4253810048,
0.9216495156,
0.0854839385,
-0.3998755813,
0.6145431399,
-0.4076454341,
-0.4345324636,
0.1207726672,
-0.3425580859,
-0.0258509982,
0.3691312373,
0.1511297822,
0.2722479403,
-0.4252256751,
0.2108352184,
-0.2802665234,
-0.5654543042,
0.3926632106,
-0.0214799326,
0.3882124424,
0.1976920068,
-0.0134285437,
-0.2319042236,
-0.5068474412,
-0.1345611513,
0.1160845682,
-0.3503929675,
-0.2774112225,
0.4698578417,
-0.9443587065,
-0.117737934,
-0.0678180754,
-0.0406440645,
0.3252049685,
-0.1484268308,
-0.0225757342,
0.6312584281,
-0.0357381478,
0.6317548156,
-0.4213801026,
0.5151563287,
-0.1803376973,
0.350299269,
0.0265937969,
-0.6510323286,
-0.1365532577,
-0.0542880371,
-0.1861929148,
0.730784297,
-0.6818974614,
0.1492144167,
-0.3063803613,
-0.8298825026,
-0.1524832398,
0.1233229637,
-0.1444292068,
0.7727659941,
0.2233396173,
0.1131229773,
-0.4224668443,
-0.5328940749,
-0.6430452466,
-0.4027513862,
0.1212596372,
0.3395476341,
0.2012170404,
0.2108738422,
0.7471575737,
-0.6948440671,
-0.2398722321,
-0.5822315812,
0.2321383655,
0.413667053,
0.1491590291,
0.7627425194,
-0.6055196524,
-0.0523890629,
-0.2354042083,
-1.3587663174,
-0.2157474607,
-0.1897970289,
-0.3088392913,
-0.4050227404,
0.4632855654,
-0.9847450256,
0.6411671042,
0.4276101589,
-0.6386855245,
0.4586877525,
-0.2555641234,
0.5765736103,
-0.3636058271,
-0.3900514245,
0.2552184463,
0.1061877459,
-0.891420424,
-0.0702777058,
-0.5591532588,
0.2963427603,
-0.057700336,
0.4293058813,
-0.3744261861,
-0.2733765244,
-0.4825004637,
0.3281013966,
0.1647382975,
0.1431809515,
-0.0781668052,
0.4346622527,
0.5132108927,
-0.9084025025,
0.8867764473,
0.2074081898,
-0.6579977274,
0.6326523423,
-0.2423376441,
-0.162208885,
-0.4521850646,
0.2780196965,
-0.7432923317,
-0.4000879824,
0.2024409473,
-0.5434619188,
0.0071215956,
0.155093357,
-0.3712673187,
-0.3347324729,
-0.3102111816,
0.5333142281,
0.28527987,
-0.1858626902,
0.9883477688,
0.7209972143,
-0.0948045626,
-0.2694704533,
-0.6984229088,
-0.0443066396,
-0.4882880151,
-0.6791114807,
0.1379088163,
-0.2815059721,
-0.8930607438,
0.0232352559,
-0.374945581,
-0.3560919762,
0.1950992048,
0.1441821456,
0.378341645,
-0.1765825003,
0.2713652253,
-0.0699178353,
0.0965268463,
0.1915722191,
0.0198966246,
0.1966005713,
0.142553851,
-0.1971096545,
-0.0822473019,
0.3788662255,
0.2230723798,
0.2084283978,
0.759162128,
0.2164472342,
-0.1363110095,
-0.1575824022,
-0.5271182656,
-0.0540539995,
-0.3436565399,
0.0549852252,
-0.3589029014,
-0.8128421903,
0.3693613708,
-0.0459655784,
0.1200323477,
0.5145312548,
0.5544993877,
-0.4867518544,
1.2931725979,
-0.1411884725,
0.1537344158,
0.0079945773,
-0.0052958466,
0.3284914196,
-0.4942854345,
-0.4680869877,
-0.2352021933,
-0.5527951121,
-0.1485363096,
-0.4269797206,
0.3850226104,
0.3665961921,
-0.2095005065,
-0.0843525082,
-0.3727734685,
1.0421830416,
0.5627216101,
0.3362233937,
0.3876124322,
-0.2435547113,
0.4713356495,
0.1677133441,
-0.6868268251,
-0.3845529854,
0.8023145199,
0.0953458399,
0.603472352,
0.4883443713,
0.7183855176,
0.3716830611,
0.2262030542,
-0.9218361974,
0.4533241093,
-0.1065287143,
-0.6610079408,
-0.3199673891,
-0.5280684829,
-0.7642223239,
0.0528414883,
-0.3294536769,
-0.8179671764,
0.0450820029,
0.1662997007,
-0.6588110328,
0.2994529307,
-0.7728568316,
0.3167420626,
-0.4594818056,
-0.4650120139,
0.1049578935,
-0.2960493267,
0.8602950573,
-0.0629429221,
0.6586952209,
-0.46189183,
-0.082361348,
0.6295082569,
-0.3760848939,
0.3296951354,
0.230960235,
0.1124580875,
0.8894894719,
0.4786106348,
0.2644088566,
-0.1025850177,
-0.1087570935,
0.2201436758,
-0.1284946054,
-0.4512538314,
-0.8028142452,
0.4857160449,
-0.5911134481,
-1.0526298285,
-0.4643854797,
-0.6476562619,
-0.4817470312,
-0.3218574524,
0.2375781983,
0.2012421191,
-0.0323881246,
0.1163143516,
0.4067520201,
0.1326599419,
0.2268266827,
0.1449914128,
-0.031538859,
-0.0394962057,
0.6462812424,
0.1822315454,
-0.1059453264,
0.2301349789,
0.4349573553,
-0.1141390502,
-0.7359109521,
-0.0218211878,
0.1047806814,
-0.977537632,
-0.350938499,
-0.1433414072,
-0.0946956873,
-0.3186952174,
-0.1446928382,
-0.0734355375,
-0.281670481,
-0.1071209833,
-0.7584024072,
0.2202635407,
0.9187356234,
-0.3675195873,
0.0794338435,
-1.1679799557,
0.3863435686,
0.2303030938,
0.2196225226,
-0.0492343269,
-0.419842571,
-0.1539680958,
-0.2148897648,
-0.1346085966,
-1.0126017332,
0.272616148,
-0.1936710626,
0.9806478024,
0.5098047853,
-0.2602404356,
0.7499080896,
-0.3964610696,
0.9735456705,
0.2627791166,
-0.6932266355,
0.5794348717,
-0.4446594417,
0.3582179844,
0.3842913806,
0.3479736745,
0.0634590015,
-0.4678261578,
-0.6565752029,
-0.5896279216,
0.8204051852,
0.2970984876,
-0.0611078702,
-0.2773911357,
0.4214243591,
0.2012426555,
0.0955763012,
-0.2919980884,
-0.2822984159,
-0.0431496203,
-0.1908028126,
-0.0755778924,
-0.3511953056,
-0.1548789442,
-0.3414001465,
0.5846657157,
0.246963039,
0.008894098,
0.1681188047,
0.0303210691,
-0.0805419832,
-0.2170666158,
0.6460072994,
0.9637287259,
-0.0546781346,
0.2586212158,
0.2323592752,
-0.1414603591,
0.1968282908,
-0.1647476703,
0.0873916969,
-0.1254585087,
0.8434464335,
0.714989841,
0.1115261391,
-0.8688194752,
0.3944959044,
-0.0506327972,
-0.6671819687,
0.1023987681,
0.3462076783,
0.1472279727,
0.6436581612,
0.4853958488,
0.1879575849,
0.2080823034,
-1.0486074686,
0.0607251599,
0.0893509686,
-0.1329826713,
-0.0437676311,
0.7290174961,
-0.063136369,
-0.0333371125,
0.4594874084,
-0.0078906994,
-0.5259487033,
0.6704174876,
0.159705326,
0.2682309747,
-0.3535736799,
0.2989628911,
0.3890148401,
0.1791257262,
-0.3849516809,
0.0462306775,
0.0530898124,
-0.8610234261,
-0.5913259387,
-0.3506058156,
-0.3414528668,
-0.1320089251,
-0.107204102,
-0.1268673092,
-0.1840315014,
-0.1601802558,
0.0262937862,
-0.4688608348,
-0.4443057179,
0.3006801605,
0.3326002955,
0.6430568099,
-0.6967189908,
0.0189303271,
0.4234652221,
-0.6335754395,
-0.9537166357,
-0.317216903,
0.255567193,
-0.8606977463,
0.9474055171,
-0.2229602039,
-0.0118500879,
-0.1713264734,
-0.8436533809,
-0.5726832151,
1.2055448294,
0.3756561279,
-0.2662177682,
-0.0532668866,
0.0626604035,
0.4640331566,
-0.4100067914,
0.2589934766,
0.9421713948,
0.4224713743,
0.7334306836,
-0.4584775269,
-0.2298217565,
0.0529403947,
-0.7210723758,
0.1453434378,
-0.7383505106,
0.7453967333,
-0.4300612211,
-0.0427387543,
-0.2315115333,
0.6264652014,
0.5496495962,
0.6892833114,
0.2021968067,
0.542992413,
1.0824644566,
-0.2257179767,
1.2751209736,
-0.0537472032,
0.0433333963,
1.0461058617,
-0.4938562512,
0.3240897655,
0.2958979309,
-0.2005753964,
0.1918662637,
0.3927993476,
-0.1380335093,
0.2144883722,
0.1421443075,
-0.2899677753,
-0.6080933213,
-0.0532940254,
0.0792677552,
0.9823891521,
0.2905092537,
-0.3692375422,
-0.2865480483,
-0.3932488859,
0.1336601228,
0.1667659581,
-0.6491186619,
0.9014539719,
0.0805805251,
-0.8960137963,
-0.3449639678,
-0.3831332326,
-0.1355485618,
-0.3434532583,
-0.2280986309,
-0.5029127598,
0.0775635391,
-0.2606706917,
-0.9797605872,
0.3406323493,
0.2992869616,
-0.0593612604,
-0.0843511224,
0.8458158374,
-0.1892290264,
-0.4962350428,
0.0418336764,
0.8979811668,
0.4247342944,
-0.195703581,
-0.5333920717,
0.1941448897,
-0.0845310315,
-0.2436106354,
0.3088980019,
0.8794965148,
0.1046216562,
0.6903922558,
0.5508497953,
0.3561032116,
0.1609644294,
0.0753937587,
0.5027871132,
-0.6515464187,
-0.2960665822,
-1.3195883036,
0.2926755548,
-0.4627160132,
-0.0727121904,
0.799660027,
0.9263920188,
0.2592462003,
0.0552541725,
0.9444881082,
0.2476196885,
0.4299298525,
-0.6670041084,
0.3134716749,
-0.3366916478,
0.4000841081,
0.1302711368,
-0.8824239969,
-0.4279027283,
0.433188349,
-0.3385416567,
-0.1375352889,
0.6086889505,
0.0214768406,
0.1774792224,
0.2440720499,
0.2849976122,
0.280960381,
0.327360332,
0.5519496202,
1.0405781269,
-0.1567653567,
0.8781856298,
0.0753689706,
-0.4162523448,
-0.1162238568,
-0.7076446414,
-0.9346808791,
-0.169620946,
-0.3729069829,
-0.3191213906,
-0.0031806275,
0.6172702909,
0.1412092,
-0.4324261546,
-0.2223912328,
0.0654816628,
0.3392075002,
-0.2655758262,
-0.2831032276,
0.2615310848,
-0.3174972832,
-0.5106076598,
0.4535139501,
0.615392983,
-0.0303035323,
0.3091757298,
-0.1283811778,
-0.2285294086,
0.4555679858,
0.8066711426,
0.1113755405,
-0.4779478908,
-0.3124438822,
-0.0608026087,
0.0153766647,
0.2083000392,
0.8540700078,
-0.6837893724,
0.4464741945,
0.6359857321,
0.3614477217,
0.3420378566,
0.5563456416,
0.6417132616,
-0.3128109276,
-0.2303023487,
0.1393422335,
0.3908965588,
0.0162733663,
-0.2413849533,
0.8445048928,
0.4732968807,
-0.4846028686,
-0.4937554002,
-0.1078512743,
-0.8250579834,
-0.6279781461,
1.1562958956,
0.147433266,
-0.3188985884,
-0.1330655962,
-0.2090326846,
0.1417363137,
-0.3101283312,
0.9064987898,
1.1820331812,
-0.9035317898,
-0.1530984789,
-0.5828511119,
0.5730392337,
-0.4529257119,
-0.8625728488,
-0.1728971899,
0.6567550302,
-0.251016289,
0.1445298791,
0.8042311668,
0.3018503785,
0.2186556756,
0.4623007178,
-0.6027870178,
-0.1879765838,
-0.1399308294,
0.4998658597,
0.4767075181,
-0.2699492872,
0.1788537502
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12074v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12074v1 | COMMUNITY-CROSS-INSTRUCT: Unsupervised Instruction Generation for Aligning Large Language Models to Online Communities | 2024-06-17T20:20:47 | 2024-06-17T20:20:47 | Zihao He, Rebecca Dorn, Siyi Guo, Minh Duc Chu, Kristina Lerman | cs.CL | cs.CL | Social scientists use surveys to probe the opinions and beliefs of
populations, but these methods are slow, costly, and prone to biases. Recent
advances in large language models (LLMs) enable creating computational
representations or "digital twins" of populations that generate human-like
responses mimicking the population's language, styles, and attitudes. We
introduce Community-Cross-Instruct, an unsupervised framework for aligning LLMs
to online communities to elicit their beliefs. Given a corpus of a community's
online discussions, Community-Cross-Instruct automatically generates
instruction-output pairs by an advanced LLM to (1) finetune an foundational LLM
to faithfully represent that community, and (2) evaluate the alignment of the
finetuned model to the community. We demonstrate the method's utility in
accurately representing political and fitness communities on Reddit. Unlike
prior methods requiring human-authored instructions, Community-Cross-Instruct
generates instructions in a fully unsupervised manner, enhancing scalability
and generalization across domains. This work enables cost-effective and
automated surveying of diverse online communities. | [
-0.4876997471,
-0.5639490485,
0.5875973701,
-0.1007754058,
-0.1313222498,
0.5974447727,
-0.5340625048,
-0.1948463321,
0.6203243732,
0.4480758309,
-0.5042006373,
-0.5802484155,
-0.5834769607,
-0.3133607805,
-0.4649567008,
0.8742007017,
0.1749842912,
0.3065263331,
-0.6172260642,
-0.0263979249,
-0.0140142925,
-0.5095775127,
-0.2675594687,
-0.3951427341,
0.2920876443,
0.6557261944,
0.5719100237,
0.3850380778,
0.102671802,
0.2584042847,
0.2198170125,
0.2906691134,
-0.7010665536,
-0.1282068342,
-0.3241989911,
-0.390635401,
-0.0732150376,
0.1120263934,
0.5120443702,
1.0673478842,
-0.1320535392,
0.4611816704,
0.3584113419,
0.6493376493,
-0.755356729,
-0.0777438283,
-0.5757383704,
-0.3162035942,
-0.0127155231,
-0.187982589,
-0.3613101244,
-0.789090693,
0.0609838292,
-0.3583734035,
0.4752596915,
-0.1323529482,
0.2484468669,
0.0073946915,
-0.5187059641,
-0.3533303738,
-0.7471223474,
0.8895540237,
-0.4000013471,
0.4641980827,
0.2678710818,
0.2922669947,
-0.2231153101,
-0.4376397431,
-0.5068858266,
0.2716684341,
0.0321487375,
0.1140721068,
-0.0882901326,
-0.1173962876,
-0.1157822609,
0.1766862422,
-0.3824656606,
0.2399649471,
-0.3709935844,
0.0885626525,
0.7348954678,
0.172963798,
0.1646468788,
-0.0482521057,
-0.1347396672,
-0.1159201562,
-0.8857021928,
-0.1515545249,
0.4993388355,
0.304422766,
-0.0712478906,
0.6321558356,
-0.0760511309,
0.4204508364,
0.6877980232,
0.1363773197,
0.1642313004,
-0.2887224257,
0.005720546,
0.1244421527,
0.666495502,
0.6267408133,
0.2914296091,
-0.0667012706,
0.0144929197,
0.2806248069,
0.1228021085,
-0.5912789106,
-0.2336942255,
0.1270975769,
-0.5245326757,
-0.3503164053,
0.3507124782,
-1.1107976437,
-0.5466712117,
-0.3715092242,
0.1740379333,
0.1876027435,
-0.3735013604,
0.1251283139,
0.0302839354,
-0.0149929998,
0.4157354534,
-0.9638849497,
0.3993466794,
0.7661083937,
0.5822347999,
-0.2315217108,
-0.1562740505,
-0.4180701971,
0.3358911276,
-0.1221540123,
0.7883996367,
-0.9292305708,
-0.3666423857,
0.323004812,
-0.0066652652,
0.1590615809,
-0.406973511,
-0.3793598115,
-0.4834246635,
0.4621383548,
-0.2698738277,
-0.7596846223,
0.1721007824,
0.2957403958,
-0.5328869224,
1.0240119696,
0.1077447608,
-0.6311530471,
0.154687807,
-0.6689682603,
-0.2702047825,
-0.1331636608,
-0.2511785924,
-0.2183277309,
0.0612417646,
0.4204437733,
0.4217579067,
-0.2795904875,
0.0513618477,
-0.4695979655,
-0.1402507275,
0.3999257982,
-0.2135670334,
0.889233768,
-0.0533053316,
-0.5695520043,
0.121839419,
-0.3293708265,
-0.0485309064,
0.0174770933,
-0.2855735421,
-0.5393836498,
0.3395811915,
-0.1315615028,
-0.1821492016,
0.2902347445,
-0.753769815,
0.3293145895,
-0.4077537954,
0.5296254158,
0.7571493387,
0.0603957027,
0.6606032848,
-0.2517744899,
0.4945895374,
-0.3498878777,
0.3634724617,
0.2513988316,
-0.5229887366,
-0.7177478075,
0.0736759827,
0.2220777571,
0.2799182236,
-0.6218832731,
0.3882735372,
-0.2619963884,
-0.5939657092,
-0.5710505247,
0.2120198905,
0.284761548,
0.061068546,
0.4157588482,
-0.1562316865,
-0.4737192094,
-0.5399977565,
-0.159855336,
-0.0716106668,
-0.1536476314,
-0.0247950684,
0.3641242683,
-0.4606663287,
0.7533297539,
-0.6163759232,
0.1380578727,
-0.2591203153,
0.3933825791,
-0.3074558377,
0.2070350647,
0.380330503,
-0.4604402483,
-0.6889625192,
0.0118467882,
-0.2838730216,
-0.2466359884,
0.0553294308,
-0.2646511197,
-0.0114156073,
0.3895367384,
-0.2071782947,
0.3329290748,
0.7594445348,
-0.0080660973,
0.110256061,
-0.0643314719,
0.4418032169,
-1.3037068844,
-0.3133658469,
0.0843077898,
-0.293725878,
-0.3525874019,
0.1897813827,
-0.2046757042,
0.048558794,
-0.2464933544,
0.305280745,
-0.6846727729,
-0.1377134472,
-0.3667960465,
0.2942591608,
-0.1450568438,
0.2458717823,
0.1032535955,
0.4493237138,
0.2186663598,
-0.3596539795,
0.4017542601,
0.2395463139,
-0.3606387079,
0.4903818071,
-0.3097067475,
0.5135800838,
-0.2288690954,
0.4011606574,
-0.8485566974,
-0.417529285,
0.1347988397,
-0.4505551755,
-0.0647687986,
-0.2654147446,
-0.4274127483,
-0.2844988108,
-0.3951955438,
0.5395305753,
0.5588034987,
-0.8585076928,
0.5375068188,
0.7879296541,
0.0677381679,
-0.2616446614,
-0.6468121409,
-0.1813715547,
-0.0911804214,
-0.3191590011,
0.0223283842,
-0.108808659,
-0.4866419137,
0.1173288673,
0.2821196318,
-0.2338261157,
-0.2367877215,
0.2472274601,
0.1782159209,
-0.0796681494,
0.1750941575,
0.3092914522,
0.1205067337,
0.1771289855,
-0.4502060115,
0.7017282844,
0.0446308926,
-0.9080670476,
-0.1979321688,
0.8319044113,
0.4514994919,
-0.3087669909,
0.5203040242,
0.1272516996,
-0.4514503777,
-0.4448913634,
-0.6206877828,
-0.3749096096,
-0.4958788157,
0.2114972621,
0.5213273168,
-1.1642580032,
0.1557617038,
-0.3084453344,
0.3000603914,
0.249712944,
0.7169114351,
-0.3729285598,
0.9463911653,
0.4756358564,
0.038696073,
0.363535732,
0.0188989304,
0.0471487902,
-0.3286834955,
-0.3017193973,
-0.5348536968,
-0.5588424802,
-0.3777307868,
-0.8497784734,
0.3716888428,
-0.2078357786,
-0.3690233529,
0.2099322677,
-0.7554239035,
0.7450927496,
0.4934300482,
0.2985499799,
0.1505197883,
0.2918751538,
0.2161826938,
-0.2017870098,
-0.6729965806,
-0.4667349458,
1.353120923,
-0.0256147813,
0.8997253776,
0.2223688215,
0.992656827,
0.4970580339,
0.6973546743,
-0.6019931436,
0.3227667511,
-0.3324057162,
-0.5136907697,
-0.1273207664,
-0.344907701,
-0.9910414219,
-0.1261744052,
-0.5608654618,
-0.4384199679,
0.2634974718,
0.424554348,
-0.4118188024,
0.5859917402,
-0.4795084,
0.6201112866,
-0.4791605175,
-0.1074081585,
-0.6974676847,
-0.4210346639,
0.2466122508,
-0.2094997019,
0.3287390769,
0.2494468838,
0.099445872,
0.5209433436,
-0.3349024355,
1.3697488308,
-0.1178841963,
0.0818691328,
0.4264308512,
-0.0283901095,
0.2974368334,
-0.176219821,
0.0627132133,
-0.0415925868,
0.0003855836,
-0.3023381829,
-0.6545177102,
0.841011107,
-0.9607458711,
-0.5728729963,
0.0268885735,
-0.2626383603,
-0.2247155309,
-0.1011091918,
0.0791959688,
0.3487872481,
-0.4585469663,
0.2091193348,
0.9712538123,
-0.2466795743,
-0.0348633789,
0.2831225693,
-0.3545484841,
-0.5576292872,
0.828613162,
-0.0300514419,
0.710785985,
0.5177829862,
0.3395016789,
-0.295265615,
-0.1275102645,
-0.2765847743,
0.1296071112,
-0.8178316951,
-0.2062256485,
-0.3831501007,
-0.0009671567,
-0.4469488263,
-0.4709886014,
-0.4642260373,
-0.3732458353,
-0.2149743587,
-0.0352014974,
0.2909758687,
1.317656517,
-0.232905969,
0.4122471213,
-0.8086360097,
0.1003337204,
0.619304657,
0.1158712208,
0.089017801,
-0.2034931481,
-0.230806157,
0.5379107594,
-0.1086074635,
-1.1524968147,
-0.0341545716,
0.0905081853,
0.5850652456,
0.4579301476,
0.3422120214,
0.6985449791,
-0.3139185011,
0.5415588617,
0.4114474356,
-0.900676012,
0.5386936665,
-0.0794477165,
0.0818701163,
0.7141331434,
0.6149126887,
-0.6689140797,
-0.5326357484,
-0.4305194914,
-0.5484861732,
0.2703139484,
-0.1925104111,
0.3293207586,
-0.2585260272,
0.2535605431,
0.2981482148,
0.0909600481,
-0.524911046,
-0.0825651139,
-0.5004652143,
-0.325391829,
0.2261481732,
-0.0989153311,
-0.4262214899,
-0.4042883515,
0.4372933805,
-0.2976384163,
0.2481479347,
-0.0946274847,
-0.0126705244,
-0.5104623437,
0.1202212796,
0.3530406356,
0.6189353466,
0.2055076808,
0.2604958713,
0.1136411875,
-0.1121753454,
0.0366416648,
-0.2809396088,
-0.2338117659,
-0.0937717482,
0.4203191996,
0.35155195,
0.3673234582,
-0.3788458705,
0.7915081382,
-0.0076016109,
-0.2139533609,
-0.2932761014,
-0.0013728796,
0.5248854756,
0.2876093984,
0.1465385854,
-0.0946571976,
-0.3003417552,
-0.6733856797,
0.0687424093,
0.6417108774,
-0.2724687457,
-0.3265131712,
0.6663931012,
0.5972577929,
-0.3345379829,
0.5875669122,
-0.1182443351,
-0.6311067343,
0.4742940366,
0.2351543158,
0.8783910275,
-0.1983697861,
0.3302620947,
0.5254506469,
0.3292506933,
-0.1445496827,
0.1573519558,
0.0073497654,
-0.7464900613,
-0.4625893831,
-0.5299122334,
-0.5787741542,
-0.0879155621,
-0.7420643568,
0.0745019764,
-0.6858343482,
-0.0072859875,
-0.0075859567,
-0.1736761779,
-0.4979918897,
-0.0197040495,
0.2024387866,
0.6564728618,
-1.1826162338,
0.7433673739,
0.747379601,
-0.1709210724,
-0.7569620013,
0.4000952542,
0.2956397533,
-0.7620417476,
0.3753086925,
-0.0251591466,
-0.4003930688,
-0.1064860001,
-1.0789198875,
-0.5724708438,
0.860969007,
0.424433291,
-0.6870152354,
0.1630678177,
0.5464199781,
0.5394251347,
-0.6990192533,
0.0339071266,
-0.0073323483,
0.429063797,
-0.0924304649,
-0.6991578341,
-0.044415582,
0.0376771688,
-0.3821900785,
0.2646415532,
-0.6551450491,
0.5378869772,
-0.1621211171,
-0.2988811135,
-0.1510823518,
0.7760297656,
0.0381854475,
0.0966887623,
0.7396513224,
0.2696190774,
0.7767675519,
0.1455052048,
0.6365393996,
-0.4044796824,
0.4046652913,
1.0417313576,
-0.2183274329,
0.9188834429,
0.4256972969,
-0.2119189948,
0.708760798,
0.6563639045,
0.0292530768,
0.2975252569,
0.1295126677,
-0.407179594,
-0.6862089634,
-0.0084973723,
-0.3038368523,
0.3762596548,
0.3384766579,
-0.304726243,
-0.2984015048,
-0.245788902,
-0.2217931449,
0.7007640004,
-0.3870212436,
0.6523115039,
-0.0797563344,
-0.7540771365,
0.2580091357,
-0.1650180072,
0.6942160726,
-0.4645914435,
-0.2798719704,
-0.2257031351,
0.1861691028,
-0.3837741613,
-1.0049524307,
0.3502192795,
0.1329497397,
-0.1991824806,
-0.3877120614,
0.4799303114,
-0.7941424251,
-0.6618474126,
0.4424093068,
0.4563571215,
0.2283469737,
0.1906090975,
-0.5140716434,
-0.0763143525,
0.2343575805,
0.1050425619,
0.4294576049,
0.2710136175,
-0.3174687326,
0.3597933054,
0.6525651813,
-0.0666867122,
0.1467475593,
0.2800316215,
1.0324146748,
-0.2224746346,
-0.1358753294,
-0.6226418614,
0.2671527863,
-0.2185411304,
-0.1417545974,
0.6420001984,
0.6414185762,
1.1813769341,
0.078156732,
1.0177115202,
-0.0698317289,
0.5832204819,
-0.2398030013,
0.8038977981,
-0.5934459567,
0.0663774088,
-0.0565039217,
-0.9587165713,
-0.1309996545,
0.3227728605,
-0.2448845357,
-0.161876902,
0.4575242698,
0.9846788049,
-0.3756088018,
0.0267454125,
-0.1052215844,
-0.1174182519,
0.0442949347,
0.5140247941,
0.875615418,
0.2378222346,
0.5607914925,
-0.283110261,
-0.4384566247,
0.1393745542,
-0.7211978436,
-1.2353999615,
-0.3463355303,
-0.4777580202,
-0.4284836054,
0.0348501876,
1.4064526558,
0.482770741,
-0.8863476515,
-0.496486932,
0.1892892569,
-0.0891084149,
-0.0842360407,
-0.1674895883,
0.2505823374,
0.1637491733,
-0.8962913752,
0.3275763094,
0.1008375511,
-0.2079187483,
-0.8629515767,
-0.2957049906,
-0.3847048283,
0.0924761966,
0.3633060157,
0.3856911361,
-0.696475327,
-0.4578492641,
0.0349777155,
-0.2385379225,
0.0028637981,
0.9021878242,
-0.4008695185,
0.4728290737,
0.5033308864,
0.9360868931,
0.4226641357,
0.1610312313,
0.5672104955,
-0.659263432,
-0.3005996644,
0.0891648382,
0.0966744348,
0.5098303556,
-0.3462664485,
0.2163393795,
0.3688635826,
-0.5418489575,
-0.3578426242,
0.3488619924,
-0.7089529037,
-0.4019416273,
1.1427441835,
0.0845187008,
-0.200608328,
-0.1737337559,
-0.0165500958,
0.3298707604,
-0.3141020536,
1.048355937,
0.385027051,
-0.0509213582,
-0.1630408615,
-0.2209260762,
0.0674245805,
0.2783225179,
-0.9260078073,
0.2363547534,
0.5607813597,
0.3504033685,
0.067536965,
0.4518131018,
0.2085529417,
0.243928805,
-0.1708540916,
0.2902805209,
0.1193524823,
0.046587117,
0.0493647419,
0.1670300364,
-0.1809909642,
-0.0283297151
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12069v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12069v1 | Satyrn: A Platform for Analytics Augmented Generation | 2024-06-17T20:14:16 | 2024-06-17T20:14:16 | Marko Sterbentz, Cameron Barrie, Shubham Shahi, Abhratanu Dutta, Donna Hooshmand, Harper Pack, Kristian J. Hammond | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) are capable of producing documents, and
retrieval augmented generation (RAG) has shown itself to be a powerful method
for improving accuracy without sacrificing fluency. However, not all
information can be retrieved from text. We propose an approach that uses the
analysis of structured data to generate fact sets that are used to guide
generation in much the same way that retrieved documents are used in RAG. This
analytics augmented generation (AAG) approach supports the ability to utilize
standard analytic techniques to generate facts that are then converted to text
and passed to an LLM. We present a neurosymbolic platform, Satyrn that
leverages AAG to produce accurate, fluent, and coherent reports grounded in
large scale databases. In our experiments, we find that Satyrn generates
reports in which over 86% accurate claims while maintaining high levels of
fluency and coherence, even when using smaller language models such as
Mistral-7B, as compared to GPT-4 Code Interpreter in which just 57% of claims
are accurate. | [
-0.0947126821,
-0.8625720143,
0.5703908801,
0.21302028,
-0.1060542911,
0.2698630989,
-0.5145446062,
-0.3559931219,
0.8047480583,
0.6743362546,
-0.3897040486,
-0.5988800526,
-0.4323556423,
0.0507945828,
-0.442935288,
1.2795990705,
0.1845998913,
0.0892187357,
-0.3127659261,
-0.0052111326,
-0.2996080816,
-0.6478072405,
-0.5586326122,
-0.4571875334,
0.4742560089,
0.4029792845,
0.7958446145,
0.6773508191,
0.5377321243,
0.2966897488,
0.2040346265,
0.4959901571,
-0.4002148509,
0.5938144922,
-0.1078532264,
-0.4136837721,
-0.8406550288,
-0.0694500282,
0.5040533543,
0.6421352625,
-0.466201365,
0.3126806915,
-0.0309770145,
0.5090639591,
-0.4594580829,
0.304595679,
-0.5404492021,
-0.2894099653,
-0.2537648976,
-0.3005323112,
-0.4087613821,
-0.4912659526,
-0.1190542802,
-0.8335772753,
0.4619035721,
-0.0382775851,
0.783056438,
0.3434624374,
-0.4184818268,
-0.6572331786,
-0.5693378448,
0.5736803412,
-0.8023729324,
0.2150874138,
0.4255955219,
0.1701751202,
-0.546726346,
-0.95725739,
-0.5890765786,
-0.5014042258,
-0.1037150249,
0.2294210047,
0.1661529839,
0.0056367363,
0.2757926881,
0.1833779365,
-0.5536830425,
-0.1306708306,
-0.1420393884,
0.0418524295,
1.0095168352,
0.2914119363,
0.2340678722,
-0.6490504146,
-0.1119946018,
-0.0869226009,
-0.5987012982,
-0.5724775195,
0.213882342,
0.5143743753,
0.0895617306,
0.8167254925,
-0.1364413053,
0.6536030769,
0.3339549601,
-0.3372797668,
0.2246166617,
-0.1526848674,
-0.0682124272,
0.4997921288,
0.6444097161,
0.1857611388,
-0.0559315085,
-0.2541999519,
-0.2255301774,
0.2652507424,
0.4739887416,
-0.8111667633,
-0.5998176932,
0.2302290499,
-0.2368628681,
-0.3078780174,
-0.1742576063,
-0.8011633158,
-0.8954014182,
-0.5943326354,
0.3598924577,
-0.5306168199,
-0.3817135692,
-0.0774409249,
-0.0096554803,
0.0310901869,
0.3139232397,
-0.7373326421,
0.4466174543,
0.6828719974,
0.8103222251,
-0.4634697139,
0.0491168238,
-0.6618177891,
0.2991167605,
-0.4840529859,
0.9289311767,
-0.3264121413,
-0.0130512873,
-0.1749224961,
-0.4647667706,
-0.184208408,
-0.4098292887,
0.3727062047,
-0.5407302976,
0.1029103398,
0.0619097389,
-0.6074671745,
-0.098244898,
0.4864754677,
-0.6888733506,
1.1953897476,
-0.0464112274,
-0.69967556,
0.6174456477,
-0.641048491,
-0.5239366889,
0.4854056835,
-0.518429935,
-0.2002022713,
0.3206073344,
0.2883470058,
0.4454822242,
-0.3929412365,
0.667758286,
0.0486032329,
-0.0899109766,
0.3842855096,
-0.2736332119,
0.4931025505,
0.2134293914,
-0.4450057745,
-0.0468271896,
-1.1927820444,
0.2174046338,
-0.0302582793,
-0.6571537256,
-0.2570947111,
0.1278364807,
0.0941274539,
-0.0998242944,
0.3755010664,
-0.6739130616,
0.0084225778,
-0.5733262897,
-0.0469674841,
0.4722337723,
0.025675863,
0.1982614696,
-0.0721916482,
0.6802197695,
-0.265437752,
-0.476171881,
-0.1258214712,
-0.0737508759,
-0.782757163,
-0.462521255,
0.5867397189,
0.4602796137,
-0.954788208,
0.3690001667,
-0.6317287087,
-0.2733996511,
-0.2332510203,
0.0061309654,
0.1236084402,
0.5042960048,
0.0615448207,
0.0842794627,
-0.6986173391,
-0.7484692931,
-0.5298396349,
-0.0868308619,
0.0137811275,
0.3432289064,
0.3329052329,
0.0197702106,
0.751234293,
-0.5026350021,
-0.0537281558,
-0.4137868583,
0.2295051813,
0.5579364896,
0.4366827905,
0.318998158,
-0.7704169154,
-0.553199172,
0.3424215317,
-0.946901679,
-0.0872925222,
-0.2481029034,
0.1277987659,
0.382910192,
0.2956577539,
-0.811557591,
0.5584256053,
0.4505904913,
-0.3721528649,
0.3904268444,
-0.2439763397,
0.2118167579,
-1.4021323919,
0.2093595415,
-0.0317094848,
-0.4954586923,
-0.5559145212,
0.0287413895,
-0.2237954289,
-0.4029114842,
0.2134679705,
0.3295592666,
-0.4352760613,
-0.0108002443,
-0.5364363194,
0.2897015512,
-0.0475851707,
0.1621027589,
-0.1085871235,
0.8963909149,
0.4126128554,
-0.439786613,
0.5841892362,
0.4753736556,
-0.3268166184,
0.6295897365,
-0.535800159,
0.0806479752,
-0.1668103933,
0.1216199845,
-0.8527372479,
-0.8914799094,
0.0175023768,
-0.7780631185,
0.4632828236,
-0.0703561231,
-0.7035554647,
-0.0505064242,
0.0780194327,
-0.1017591283,
0.3656470776,
-0.8193287849,
1.2070635557,
0.4897656143,
-0.4367108345,
-0.426802516,
-0.7108432651,
0.5399303436,
-0.2242053598,
-0.9183207154,
0.0833278447,
0.3222019076,
-0.2786712348,
-0.0894677192,
-0.3773708642,
0.0481253713,
-0.1757178009,
0.3503023982,
0.3110987544,
-0.3444056511,
0.231298402,
-0.043823991,
-0.1090207845,
0.1821811497,
-0.298171252,
0.493285805,
0.0473388471,
0.0779927447,
-0.0969433561,
0.2847551107,
0.355806917,
-0.1478342265,
0.8689443469,
0.2038808763,
-0.341316402,
-0.6468092203,
-0.5623114705,
-0.122392647,
-0.5082248449,
0.1594145298,
-0.3381937146,
-0.6125087738,
0.4494804442,
-0.331422478,
0.0468775071,
0.4375456274,
0.5060734749,
-0.1248288602,
1.3295731544,
0.6189625859,
0.5597776175,
0.2684657872,
-0.2474336326,
0.4011215568,
-0.4652549922,
-0.3763206899,
-0.4571754336,
-0.1716145873,
-0.5211976767,
-0.1329989582,
0.6793296337,
0.012956256,
-0.0784490481,
0.2455978394,
-0.3974916041,
0.5569109321,
0.3548136353,
0.1953069568,
0.266830951,
0.4466401637,
0.0457020737,
-0.0762244388,
-0.962818563,
-0.5330960155,
1.3020778894,
-0.0784525126,
0.9419214725,
-0.0011383106,
0.8024030328,
0.5457360148,
0.5482862592,
-0.7538915277,
0.6149362326,
-0.2421361655,
-0.821346581,
0.0907339677,
-0.7223531008,
-0.8104972243,
0.2333824337,
-0.4980388284,
-0.6622704268,
0.2466628551,
0.2413797975,
-0.3030325472,
-0.0625284538,
-0.6514366865,
0.4847681522,
-0.312256068,
-0.4757063985,
-0.3185364902,
-0.3888896406,
0.357139498,
-0.0912449285,
-0.1691832542,
0.1159812436,
0.0864024833,
0.8495227695,
-0.5005736947,
0.703766942,
-0.1320624501,
0.1217687801,
0.412989974,
0.2966415584,
0.5777081847,
0.1268986166,
-0.3226298988,
-0.1467368305,
-0.0524060242,
-0.3236134052,
-0.6509789824,
1.0020908117,
-0.5643677711,
-0.4675471783,
-0.799158752,
-0.989248693,
-0.3069250882,
0.2987320721,
0.0567934886,
0.6621863246,
-0.1331651807,
0.4069477916,
0.6554346681,
-0.0139750261,
0.1400680095,
0.3886993825,
-0.2782481909,
-0.918633163,
1.0336354971,
0.2759466767,
-0.1133246198,
-0.2602756917,
0.0233958121,
-0.3209463656,
-0.6178714633,
-0.4958830774,
0.4009579122,
-0.6891084313,
-0.5516527295,
-0.5804536939,
-0.1025093496,
-0.4215688109,
-0.0568215139,
-0.2674606144,
-0.7747409344,
0.0040118545,
-0.2631989419,
0.6056873202,
0.8580430746,
-0.1488099992,
0.7695242763,
-0.4999649227,
0.5195881128,
-0.2106537372,
0.3359470665,
-0.2996012866,
-0.1734000742,
-0.4918536842,
0.1718195826,
-0.196881175,
-0.7962738872,
0.5643466711,
0.2181372941,
0.4007664919,
-0.0478693321,
-0.109122701,
0.6455860138,
-0.1996433735,
0.8215472102,
0.3076657057,
-0.8128127456,
0.4758603275,
-0.60563761,
-0.0581681021,
0.6135650277,
0.2058997452,
-0.1666368991,
-0.1686028987,
-0.830324173,
-0.8528410196,
0.8685962558,
0.2628673315,
-0.0547741093,
-0.1607579589,
0.6762006283,
0.0350991637,
0.4220022261,
-0.4905304313,
0.045537807,
-0.2127688974,
-0.5555553436,
-0.1090256348,
0.1151232496,
-0.3905478418,
-0.0430390947,
0.73907727,
-0.3890617192,
-0.1883601248,
0.2889886498,
-0.135626018,
-0.0077798748,
-0.0644201636,
0.0511688739,
1.0265761614,
-0.0352940187,
0.2065605819,
-0.0053429236,
-0.7683211565,
-0.1014525965,
0.3460172415,
-0.3741018176,
0.0963673815,
0.2265228629,
0.6662894487,
-0.3135490716,
-0.7301787734,
0.3059467077,
0.1884900928,
-0.2282115966,
-0.4391560256,
0.2355773151,
0.0451010726,
0.2558220029,
0.3845852613,
-0.0086439569,
0.058372695,
-0.3867736459,
0.3449294567,
0.2479274571,
0.0039351205,
-0.134913072,
0.6273326278,
0.0894483328,
-0.1975695193,
0.6685817838,
0.068312712,
-0.3102898896,
0.6341004372,
0.8656159043,
0.8542829752,
-0.0609347187,
0.4940727949,
0.3743827343,
0.1281169653,
-0.0950502008,
0.5780165195,
0.0118620908,
-0.4764221609,
-0.8250619769,
-0.8546735048,
-0.1050540805,
0.0688586906,
-0.6011016369,
0.0225740504,
-0.738634944,
-0.4502372146,
0.2608353198,
0.1456892937,
-0.311203748,
0.38929528,
0.0362146012,
0.7263728976,
-0.6269481778,
0.4595602155,
0.7812038064,
-0.4625808895,
-0.9345439076,
-0.0592770129,
-0.1684212238,
-0.509596169,
0.6769337654,
-0.0852140412,
-0.231531918,
-0.0092053972,
-0.9934644699,
-0.8997217417,
1.0299725533,
0.5135803819,
-0.1628682166,
0.1443380266,
0.2546795011,
0.8187867403,
-0.6752972603,
-0.1546816826,
0.7056379914,
0.5136467218,
0.205077827,
-0.5627233982,
0.0382893607,
-0.2682896554,
-0.1126078069,
0.5272194743,
-0.3797038198,
0.6214603186,
0.0232638549,
-0.3558630049,
0.1068056226,
0.7050486803,
0.4429813027,
0.5343308449,
0.185960874,
0.6519608498,
0.8569946885,
0.0217532422,
1.1551795006,
-0.2818121612,
0.0542246625,
1.2986514568,
-0.3851859272,
0.726428628,
0.4427314103,
0.2744350135,
0.6341254115,
0.142380774,
-0.0256281979,
0.1379113346,
0.1350898296,
-0.2826801538,
-0.461981833,
-0.2119676918,
0.0388276204,
0.4986490309,
0.6804705858,
-0.2865963578,
-0.3000993431,
-0.0166187286,
0.1917500049,
0.4125209451,
-0.3452320099,
0.8835527301,
-0.010653764,
-0.8044742942,
0.700428009,
-0.0556793623,
0.1601841152,
-0.6271203756,
-0.3686575294,
-0.2425534129,
0.382606864,
-0.5757627487,
-0.6148859262,
0.2426637113,
0.3319126666,
-0.1169116423,
-0.0743563473,
1.0333002806,
-0.3995548189,
-0.6854341626,
-0.1348074377,
0.5084212422,
0.1476876289,
0.1380813718,
-0.3993643224,
-0.0251798518,
-0.1163925305,
-0.2808083594,
0.089464128,
0.3250489831,
-0.061944019,
0.5927516818,
0.8585214615,
0.3900123239,
0.2616274953,
-0.1814709753,
1.0468864441,
-0.6090431213,
-0.606094718,
-0.3998508453,
0.4653787613,
-0.4241870046,
-0.2624709606,
1.1133421659,
0.813418746,
0.1745764166,
0.1913123429,
0.7666679025,
-0.4320480525,
0.6648570299,
-0.4762322605,
0.759737432,
-0.4328252971,
0.243930459,
0.1101609766,
-1.10551548,
-0.3802671731,
0.5186623931,
-0.3390660286,
-0.1181411147,
0.5573506951,
0.872702539,
-0.3081305325,
0.2344329357,
-0.0532330535,
0.4808299839,
0.2897596061,
-0.0273090433,
0.7794194221,
-0.4466057122,
0.4681614935,
0.1355912834,
-0.3616590202,
0.0254851393,
-0.6897589564,
-0.9956506491,
-0.2331128269,
-0.2953067124,
-0.9715804458,
0.2671815753,
0.778411448,
0.5897023678,
-0.7757487297,
-0.3733844459,
-0.2681951225,
-0.2567747533,
0.1072518826,
-0.2515414357,
0.6496686935,
-0.4406604469,
-0.2973772585,
0.6894472241,
0.1029519886,
-0.3850466013,
-0.1444628239,
-0.0827078819,
-0.239411816,
0.3120886087,
0.4522279203,
0.0876845941,
-0.2402770966,
-0.1230860278,
0.1405696273,
-0.0325843953,
0.0538730249,
1.0241508484,
-1.0557588339,
0.4068291485,
0.7058214545,
0.8271318078,
0.8884211183,
0.294061929,
0.6989324093,
-0.7006812692,
-0.0586894713,
0.4849798381,
-0.036186561,
0.4803445339,
-0.5313290358,
0.5015377998,
0.1024839059,
-0.7009431124,
-0.9529765844,
0.103862159,
-0.9170201421,
-0.2215280235,
1.0849577188,
0.0294581763,
-0.56445539,
0.0432932042,
-0.1617689431,
0.1511882544,
-0.3061586022,
0.7910214067,
0.4362186193,
-0.4157930613,
0.1155017242,
-0.5556457639,
0.505133152,
0.3761290908,
-0.8672269583,
0.316622287,
1.0642117262,
0.2881706953,
0.5368120074,
0.2626779974,
-0.0995167121,
0.2911296189,
0.3869496286,
0.0801060721,
-0.0634042621,
-0.6144438982,
-0.2600097954,
0.2197632194,
-0.2087905705,
0.119624801
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12066v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12066v2 | Language Models are Surprisingly Fragile to Drug Names in Biomedical Benchmarks | 2024-06-17T20:09:24 | 2024-06-19T03:59:41 | Jack Gallifant, Shan Chen, Pedro Moreira, Nikolaj Munch, Mingye Gao, Jackson Pond, Leo Anthony Celi, Hugo Aerts, Thomas Hartvigsen, Danielle Bitterman | cs.CL | cs.CL | Medical knowledge is context-dependent and requires consistent reasoning
across various natural language expressions of semantically equivalent phrases.
This is particularly crucial for drug names, where patients often use brand
names like Advil or Tylenol instead of their generic equivalents. To study
this, we create a new robustness dataset, RABBITS, to evaluate performance
differences on medical benchmarks after swapping brand and generic drug names
using physician expert annotations.
We assess both open-source and API-based LLMs on MedQA and MedMCQA, revealing
a consistent performance drop ranging from 1-10\%. Furthermore, we identify a
potential source of this fragility as the contamination of test data in widely
used pre-training datasets. All code is accessible at
https://github.com/BittermanLab/RABBITS, and a HuggingFace leaderboard is
available at https://huggingface.co/spaces/AIM-Harvard/rabbits-leaderboard. | [
0.1455884278,
-0.6559506059,
0.5263931751,
-0.1363982409,
0.0183289312,
0.2365332246,
-0.2579194307,
-0.7983614802,
-0.1487935781,
0.4336665273,
-0.2991248071,
-0.4524292648,
-1.031580925,
0.3457994163,
-0.2454990149,
1.037592411,
-0.2338998616,
0.3238812983,
-0.2079607844,
-0.8031780124,
-0.2631703317,
-0.5793445706,
-0.3096714616,
-0.4602656066,
0.4235610664,
-0.1456429064,
0.9678348899,
0.8402741551,
0.9064536095,
0.2983710468,
-0.0488840155,
0.0001419072,
-0.3182668984,
0.3081024289,
-0.3937333524,
-0.5905359387,
-0.4585340023,
-0.0212093089,
0.2362196594,
0.7998416424,
-0.1336533129,
0.0109278336,
-0.1891098768,
0.4656429291,
-0.5755759478,
0.255159229,
-0.9104052782,
-0.2984369993,
-0.3325792849,
0.0931674987,
-0.2326256484,
-0.3318709731,
0.1775216162,
-0.7474518418,
0.0995445102,
-0.0064163143,
1.4945092201,
0.5583660603,
0.0455948226,
-0.3685444593,
-0.2140254378,
0.8005856872,
-0.6816728711,
0.3824940622,
0.4972779155,
0.4387280941,
-0.4370221794,
-0.6595717072,
0.0360169709,
-0.2391000539,
0.0502877422,
-0.1737305224,
-0.1883847564,
-0.1213068068,
0.1529842913,
0.2263628095,
-0.2699354887,
0.0929767117,
-0.3394368589,
-0.3485902548,
0.4074987769,
0.1432730108,
0.4105722606,
-0.0263001304,
-0.5650494099,
-0.230698511,
-0.7820997834,
0.1362250447,
-0.1852303445,
0.6351683736,
0.102506049,
0.4277119637,
-0.0172796696,
0.4428783357,
-0.0207361393,
-0.2213110626,
0.7816432714,
-0.1457488537,
-0.5240568519,
-0.0460537151,
0.8046863675,
0.4926661551,
0.3224544525,
-0.3344306648,
-0.1232864857,
0.2681237459,
0.2266471386,
-0.6521456242,
-0.6759884357,
0.4909903407,
-0.3615913987,
-0.4014885426,
-0.4171362221,
-0.5253356695,
-0.6980258226,
-0.0418385826,
0.5185186267,
-0.7242549658,
-0.1888780892,
0.2400478721,
-0.0583994314,
-0.0334437899,
0.1348298788,
-0.7279322147,
0.4098176062,
0.6977122426,
0.6181994677,
-0.341958493,
-0.2934397161,
-0.45976457,
0.020561995,
-0.4563865066,
1.0480852127,
-0.5891002417,
-0.5433769226,
-0.1023066193,
0.1940968484,
-0.1891888231,
-1.3636553288,
0.5350974202,
-0.1247927174,
-0.1115327105,
-0.5284900069,
-0.7546252012,
0.1307581663,
0.1889796555,
-0.671872735,
0.7321493626,
0.154534176,
-0.8340089321,
0.9306516051,
-0.1972876191,
-0.3825551867,
0.1070749313,
-0.4976810813,
-0.5893831253,
0.0383193828,
0.1552564949,
0.1943275183,
-0.0428913459,
0.3618236482,
-0.646903038,
-0.1682462394,
0.6946749091,
-0.0017274981,
0.7245541215,
0.1235677302,
-0.1167778745,
-0.2282287031,
-0.8567607999,
0.002634523,
0.1024151444,
-0.3950481117,
-0.4873025715,
0.0216403324,
0.1430257559,
0.1002988443,
-0.1268316209,
-0.3625442386,
0.1469967216,
-0.3392545581,
0.543592453,
0.7783099413,
-0.0807105377,
0.0571902469,
-0.6894650459,
0.3901541233,
0.1620333642,
0.2449091524,
0.1890993267,
-0.5346667767,
-0.3881511092,
-0.4954535961,
0.7057712674,
0.6002233624,
-0.4840522408,
-0.0068693403,
-0.3177058995,
-0.3402800858,
-0.664617002,
0.2951154113,
0.5672784448,
0.6612693667,
0.5788020492,
-0.2919716835,
-0.2849887908,
-1.1491214037,
-0.989867568,
-0.4406298101,
-0.1487438977,
0.3878774941,
0.3941562176,
-0.6166111231,
0.6370311379,
-0.3123512566,
-0.1942092776,
-0.0086048357,
-0.0239421222,
0.1686503291,
0.3441832364,
0.560104847,
-0.3669276237,
-0.0617100708,
-0.4289451838,
-0.5602924824,
-0.2740311623,
-0.0305146277,
-0.348100841,
0.0377956443,
0.4015812874,
-0.6814308167,
0.1229538918,
0.5448844433,
-0.1373727173,
0.5847508311,
0.0306076296,
0.1065278202,
-1.1061555147,
0.0600150339,
0.2594299912,
-0.0866884142,
-0.5122112036,
-0.0421847664,
0.0308584347,
0.2800479233,
-0.6242465973,
0.615346849,
-0.2182102799,
0.3298822641,
0.2065553367,
0.0621138103,
0.1104770526,
-0.1288701743,
-0.1547105461,
0.7017531395,
0.698633194,
-0.4997502863,
0.0598661117,
0.4812319875,
-0.3443317711,
0.6552588344,
-0.6421502829,
-0.494201839,
0.5329287052,
-0.0562975071,
-0.5196478367,
-0.5273814201,
0.2823337018,
-0.4519300461,
0.5913288593,
-0.1065318882,
-0.6927698255,
-0.1478629708,
-0.1925255358,
0.3763843477,
0.4961045086,
-0.4215016365,
0.0900941789,
0.7090574503,
-0.0498355292,
-0.4785527289,
-1.0568255186,
0.1274427623,
-0.3414033651,
-0.3417952955,
0.1753365546,
-0.1987680048,
-0.5355210304,
0.0479143932,
-0.2811841369,
-0.4065019488,
0.0817590132,
0.3551024795,
0.316801697,
-0.0235574953,
0.6600023508,
-0.0333633311,
-0.1252288222,
0.3433958888,
0.2722290754,
-0.1319992542,
-0.1347283125,
-0.0948285833,
-0.1691989601,
0.066846475,
0.7264559269,
-0.0278711673,
0.6005300879,
0.127415508,
-0.4946746528,
-0.3046550453,
-0.3781812787,
-0.0706158653,
-0.4264597297,
0.1834674329,
-0.3109209239,
-0.4638245702,
0.5558014512,
-0.3853421509,
-0.1048526019,
0.4333153963,
0.6966918707,
-0.0744711235,
0.7014265656,
0.3735500574,
0.1374406964,
0.0171279591,
0.1453659832,
0.0833407268,
-0.534058392,
-0.2987863123,
-0.3651562333,
-0.146181494,
-0.5169980526,
-0.5615855455,
-0.0101049654,
-0.0979963318,
-0.1652955413,
0.3740935028,
-0.6200540066,
0.2003779411,
0.2090758085,
0.1620016545,
0.3094508648,
-0.0700522885,
-0.4005622566,
-0.1602316797,
-0.3607046008,
-0.544255197,
1.3707283735,
0.4107696414,
1.0414180756,
-0.1890235543,
0.6642792821,
0.0726646483,
0.4857689142,
-0.5110432506,
0.3944576085,
-0.3654658496,
-0.680473268,
0.2215427458,
-0.4753319025,
-1.0370312929,
-0.0840039402,
-0.3712507188,
-0.6318862438,
0.147939086,
-0.0611833967,
-0.4579332471,
0.3160773218,
-0.6324941516,
0.7651628852,
-0.3987669647,
-0.3310824335,
0.3554863632,
-0.6580440998,
0.2719711661,
-0.4079660177,
0.4686230719,
-0.614833951,
-0.1726776212,
0.5766205192,
-0.78858459,
0.4480597973,
0.2082648426,
0.002213093,
-0.1805221885,
0.2048810273,
-0.0088797407,
0.1415728033,
-0.1618061215,
0.551830411,
0.3797571659,
-0.5083816051,
-0.1740745753,
0.8725281954,
-0.7000880837,
-0.2027389854,
-0.4867091775,
-0.5747165084,
-0.6483487487,
0.2095214725,
0.4675255716,
0.3791652918,
-0.0090220515,
0.0855729431,
0.778539598,
-0.4536701739,
-0.1439031512,
0.6546617746,
0.0140681425,
-0.465373069,
0.4909413755,
0.2765048742,
0.2900623381,
0.114352949,
0.164910242,
-0.3208275735,
-0.542324543,
-0.3879428208,
0.288638413,
-0.643864572,
-0.3338935673,
-0.5916243196,
-0.0691626295,
-0.2298587263,
-0.20714055,
-0.7157444954,
-0.1877872646,
0.0470747687,
-0.0083990889,
0.5173612833,
0.6791245937,
0.069609493,
-0.1831950545,
-0.7394179702,
0.2583598495,
-0.0029149521,
0.7456037402,
-0.7660904527,
-0.2345653772,
-0.1414306462,
-0.0668775737,
-0.0085181538,
-0.8348133564,
0.1061607078,
0.2677788734,
0.8993787169,
0.2569389045,
0.2234736532,
0.4358621538,
-0.4062607586,
0.5908740759,
0.0640483126,
-0.6768069267,
0.7051139474,
-0.3650854528,
0.3140272498,
1.1133259535,
0.191847235,
-0.1145985052,
-0.7854141593,
-0.4869615138,
-0.9791938663,
0.2899700403,
0.3217837811,
-0.2923992574,
-0.1365009546,
0.3104535043,
0.4285921752,
0.1120456606,
-0.4023087323,
-0.2921676934,
0.1917589009,
-0.3593343794,
-0.0396571755,
-0.0257501062,
-0.5551931858,
-0.2023778707,
0.4949798882,
0.1145354286,
-0.1197671145,
0.1542078853,
-0.1532756537,
-0.1457821429,
0.2266186625,
0.2798313498,
0.6802067161,
-0.3353659809,
-0.0270000026,
0.1110440493,
-0.6236801744,
0.0392720476,
0.3536663651,
0.062186107,
0.1721911877,
0.4370393753,
0.2582821846,
0.6303696036,
-1.2439755201,
0.380094707,
-0.37530303,
-0.3303559422,
0.0658985525,
-0.0372612812,
-0.0856229067,
0.1574288011,
0.0842615217,
0.4164645672,
0.0812361985,
-0.4610930979,
0.5459195971,
0.1336972117,
-0.3863197863,
-0.0843539834,
1.0100471973,
0.0403767116,
-0.0481836274,
0.3470206857,
0.1448440403,
-0.2143172473,
0.5068906546,
0.0496334918,
0.7594008446,
-0.2089026719,
0.0455358215,
0.1513752788,
0.2293256819,
-0.0831243917,
0.0593062267,
0.4058127999,
-0.3418951929,
0.0181845855,
-0.5715884566,
-0.5994530916,
0.1655371189,
-0.6387643814,
0.362675041,
-0.4499702156,
-0.7220566273,
0.2001138479,
-0.0371239968,
-0.6101886034,
0.2529372871,
0.0735286102,
0.8991600275,
-0.9623358846,
0.8525950909,
1.1507689953,
-0.3881037533,
-0.8262059093,
-0.039963726,
0.1562452316,
-0.7017468214,
0.4816689789,
0.2279568017,
0.1749742478,
-0.8621475697,
-0.33612293,
-0.8596485257,
1.0265880823,
0.3660150766,
-0.4521521926,
0.0871217251,
0.1769208014,
0.7501349449,
-0.1955918074,
0.0455964319,
0.6446883082,
0.1844103336,
0.0243222695,
-1.0494053364,
0.14108935,
-0.5596707463,
-0.2299355865,
0.0528022349,
-0.5480049253,
1.0202896595,
-0.2378339022,
-0.1849644631,
0.2868669927,
-0.1889159828,
0.5735579133,
0.4571782649,
0.2922585905,
0.754907012,
0.8045175076,
-0.3600588143,
0.8962085843,
-0.5664430261,
0.4823918939,
1.1649872065,
-0.3760719895,
1.0342811346,
0.4363263547,
-0.4025628269,
0.5672941208,
0.828666091,
-0.2997472286,
0.590932548,
0.2444014549,
0.0852113217,
-0.3754158914,
0.0890791565,
-0.5713993907,
0.3304297924,
0.5563847423,
-0.4850181341,
-0.3558177948,
-0.0120369401,
0.2890301943,
0.0402833745,
0.145475924,
0.5677779913,
0.1360753775,
-0.3612443805,
0.9084048271,
-0.3994545341,
0.3038968742,
-0.566516757,
0.1315557212,
-0.2000151426,
0.6818393469,
-0.1812523901,
-0.6288125515,
0.1433849186,
-0.1143034026,
-0.0590172336,
0.0937876999,
0.5280098915,
-0.3223585486,
-0.514746964,
0.6309797168,
0.498722136,
0.2425468862,
0.2100004256,
-1.0842195749,
0.4843954444,
-0.439419806,
-0.078940399,
0.5244030356,
0.3726787269,
0.0994889736,
0.9984042048,
0.29182145,
0.4137736559,
0.0688875839,
0.0511236675,
1.0643737316,
-0.1965179741,
0.0307967365,
-0.6193332076,
0.2382651567,
-0.0463764332,
-0.4663100243,
0.7422956824,
0.6023224592,
0.6378793716,
0.0625807419,
0.58376652,
0.2734929919,
0.7795590758,
-0.3539557755,
1.1245228052,
-0.7605343461,
0.5329475999,
-0.2904386818,
-0.4743880928,
-0.5907741189,
0.0937334374,
-0.1765293181,
0.0227829069,
0.7105649114,
0.6847974062,
0.1047108099,
-0.3161521554,
0.3301559985,
0.5519766808,
0.4726407528,
0.8680715561,
0.4274522662,
-0.5783373117,
0.6745105982,
-0.31328547,
-0.3028665483,
-0.37904796,
-0.67872715,
-0.9920312166,
-0.2437606603,
-0.6251809597,
-0.6132898331,
0.5651829839,
0.7370824814,
0.8580797911,
-1.0857173204,
0.214937523,
0.1191927567,
-0.2615512311,
-0.1932210773,
-0.1821411252,
0.4786055684,
-0.5856299996,
-0.4768894613,
0.3440955877,
0.2452759743,
-0.0947259888,
0.0904317498,
0.0587850921,
-0.0515838861,
0.3074937463,
0.1913375854,
0.4084379971,
-0.9842954874,
-0.280087471,
-0.0899819806,
-0.5091437697,
0.1170012802,
0.533246696,
-0.8596876264,
0.9557011127,
0.1755719632,
0.6679958105,
-0.2925825119,
0.1953408867,
0.5178331733,
-0.2992425561,
-0.179594636,
0.1897891462,
0.4919112623,
0.4952317476,
-0.0830441713,
0.4666950107,
0.4874927402,
-0.6657133698,
-0.9156521559,
-0.0222548619,
-1.0417084694,
-0.4750373662,
1.2693891525,
-0.1946675479,
-0.4333978295,
-0.2250740826,
0.0752180815,
0.0705740154,
-0.4131848216,
0.9547132254,
0.7948352098,
-0.293674171,
0.2208538204,
-0.8406982422,
0.8442271352,
0.3505422473,
-0.6823362708,
0.1459805071,
0.3254604042,
0.7006745934,
0.0303199254,
0.6077807546,
-0.5162463188,
0.1587316841,
0.2379418015,
-0.0260204058,
0.0688621029,
0.1118052304,
-0.2310749292,
-0.1027607098,
0.1921502054,
-0.343372196
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12060v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12060v1 | Not Eliminate but Aggregate: Post-Hoc Control over Mixture-of-Experts to Address Shortcut Shifts in Natural Language Understanding | 2024-06-17T20:00:04 | 2024-06-17T20:00:04 | Ukyo Honda, Tatsushi Oka, Peinan Zhang, Masato Mita | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Recent models for natural language understanding are inclined to exploit
simple patterns in datasets, commonly known as shortcuts. These shortcuts hinge
on spurious correlations between labels and latent features existing in the
training data. At inference time, shortcut-dependent models are likely to
generate erroneous predictions under distribution shifts, particularly when
some latent features are no longer correlated with the labels. To avoid this,
previous studies have trained models to eliminate the reliance on shortcuts. In
this study, we explore a different direction: pessimistically aggregating the
predictions of a mixture-of-experts, assuming each expert captures relatively
different latent features. The experimental results demonstrate that our
post-hoc control over the experts significantly enhances the model's robustness
to the distribution shift in shortcuts. Besides, we show that our approach has
some practical advantages. We also analyze our model and provide results to
support the assumption. | [
-0.3291302025,
-1.0223915577,
0.570366025,
0.0648836419,
-0.4789965451,
0.3077371716,
-0.1422483623,
-0.3059121668,
0.345328927,
0.6432911158,
-0.4239291847,
-0.4607926011,
-1.1229654551,
0.0851617455,
-0.4181503952,
1.2079681158,
0.0345066488,
-0.4933867753,
-0.1605225652,
-0.3089018762,
-0.3109735548,
-0.2907349467,
-0.4491705,
-0.2522462606,
0.4303981066,
0.2102464139,
1.1275992393,
0.6040115356,
0.429979682,
0.2934322953,
-0.5264934301,
-0.0322464034,
-0.3696967959,
-0.1733850986,
-0.362242192,
-0.4837721288,
-0.5824624896,
0.0826704875,
0.3986139596,
1.1964229345,
-0.4060512185,
-0.241894871,
0.1967765391,
0.3738416433,
-0.5249940753,
-0.1585147828,
-0.9648568034,
-0.2578463256,
-0.2950870097,
-0.1531900167,
-0.1779236048,
-0.292081207,
0.3663119376,
-0.5615919232,
0.3479046524,
-0.0437118448,
0.52751261,
0.4349338412,
-0.499982655,
-0.284001857,
-0.5200779438,
0.9540861845,
-0.6952996254,
0.1655821502,
0.6083619595,
0.2875377536,
-0.0533331707,
-0.233720988,
-0.226487577,
0.155681625,
-0.2350308001,
-0.0456245504,
0.0996285975,
-0.0087633459,
-0.2719793916,
0.2661628723,
-0.2959938347,
0.2851626277,
-0.2402039617,
-0.2010158002,
0.6799302697,
0.1866336763,
0.173981443,
0.0604626387,
-0.1639653593,
0.2488643974,
-0.6150987148,
0.1223727986,
0.0825912654,
0.3403937519,
-0.2345021218,
0.6334474087,
-0.1326423138,
0.8896161914,
0.2184745371,
-0.3096936643,
0.172014758,
-0.3803020716,
-0.1824209392,
0.1042829826,
0.7202911377,
0.0860385671,
0.0748221651,
-0.5183233619,
-0.2319002599,
0.0894583687,
-0.096061185,
-0.2304842174,
-0.5765039921,
0.0671137124,
-0.3977288604,
-0.4851506054,
-0.0770257711,
-0.6388038397,
-0.2739867568,
-0.3112924099,
0.3463744819,
-0.2667304873,
-0.383164376,
0.0709261224,
-0.2119808495,
-0.1331002563,
0.4346332252,
-0.856321454,
0.4920005202,
0.7669495344,
0.7805137038,
-0.2285903692,
-0.3675710857,
-0.6087414026,
0.3764424324,
-0.3169045746,
0.7571158409,
-0.8631198406,
-0.6819860339,
-0.2762444317,
-0.3986829817,
-0.2356576025,
-0.6085135937,
0.263867259,
-0.3823914826,
0.5188711286,
-0.1393420845,
-0.5185586214,
-0.0100605628,
0.1074901,
-0.3516203165,
0.9150288701,
0.1242085919,
-0.9678667188,
0.4458973408,
-0.2662506104,
-0.5972889066,
-0.2811605334,
-0.4070307016,
-0.4208814204,
0.3061371446,
0.4332582057,
0.13008973,
-0.0902095437,
0.6854829788,
-0.5169573426,
-0.0668779984,
0.2976448536,
-0.2874226272,
0.6577118039,
0.0033887341,
-0.2884830534,
-0.0757221803,
-0.6411224604,
-0.338735193,
-0.1027146429,
-0.243176356,
-0.9141192436,
0.1080293506,
-0.4666854441,
0.4605413973,
-0.0171879381,
-0.0226140507,
0.251331389,
-0.5454983115,
0.1771515012,
0.934741199,
0.4110291898,
1.1122564077,
-0.1615918875,
0.506993711,
0.2070697099,
0.1482340097,
0.2221460789,
-0.60264045,
-0.5433658361,
-0.2549585998,
0.0912107825,
0.324450165,
-1.1026893854,
0.6234712601,
-0.2756404579,
-0.4395818412,
-0.3747909069,
0.4249259531,
0.477468878,
0.7607342005,
0.4907138944,
-0.24760741,
0.0312028453,
-0.7952752709,
-0.8683131337,
-0.0430089608,
-0.2134908438,
0.2076076567,
0.2068173438,
-0.0859071612,
1.1438785791,
-0.7266125679,
-0.0033799214,
-0.3758680224,
0.6947264671,
0.3281155527,
0.4371576905,
0.6022825837,
-0.7508094311,
-0.5938053727,
-0.1969460249,
-0.3144512475,
-0.2199366838,
-0.0983580053,
-0.3312086165,
-0.1677050442,
0.2509121597,
-0.6712933779,
0.4661121666,
0.359474659,
-0.3557169735,
0.3871328831,
0.0176668316,
-0.1844327301,
-0.8501261473,
-0.2483933866,
0.0326032899,
-0.0567885824,
-0.731795013,
-0.4216325283,
-0.1070097461,
0.127081424,
-0.3121213019,
0.4936841726,
-0.4042322934,
0.0713774636,
-0.3081426322,
-0.1121638641,
0.0963180661,
0.4168419838,
0.3702481687,
0.6318802834,
0.6672921777,
-0.9573537707,
-0.4917807877,
0.3505794406,
-0.1500376165,
0.4309484065,
-0.5497274399,
0.2003198862,
-0.2103140056,
0.0486653559,
-0.6881409883,
-0.1993735284,
0.3359804451,
-0.5036168098,
0.2208588868,
0.0164981056,
-0.191437155,
-0.0464637391,
-0.1599166691,
0.139342308,
0.5562825203,
-0.0827930346,
0.7565582991,
0.5065448284,
-0.5484107733,
-0.3963395655,
-0.7129254341,
-0.1734187007,
-0.5169202685,
-0.3660694063,
0.3880114257,
0.1402146071,
-0.5733429193,
0.0888705701,
-0.2701447606,
-0.3994573355,
0.3452079892,
-0.0656051859,
0.0800487027,
0.1337065995,
0.2030810267,
0.4913018048,
-0.2027125508,
0.0338454358,
-0.1431892961,
0.1448459327,
0.3714376688,
-0.3422243893,
-0.1349615306,
0.580940485,
0.451529026,
-0.3411247134,
0.9118882418,
0.3336129487,
-0.1718289852,
0.0944257006,
-0.4488561451,
-0.3381251693,
-0.5136529803,
0.3162574172,
-0.127781406,
-0.8667359948,
0.523653686,
-0.0591311343,
0.1459654421,
0.4086282253,
0.2503838837,
-0.3038243949,
1.0150003433,
0.750767231,
-0.3561680317,
0.4339394569,
-0.0146820918,
0.3327123821,
-0.4945447147,
-0.0585880205,
-0.6799913049,
-0.1350157559,
-0.303951025,
-0.3898934722,
0.4671258628,
0.1755207777,
0.163402319,
0.0499780737,
-0.2986390591,
0.3354494572,
0.3908321857,
0.1927012652,
0.1094348356,
-0.1111832336,
-0.003102629,
-0.0585720278,
-0.7642379999,
-0.2271225303,
0.7927513719,
0.0605316497,
0.8012025356,
0.0711802989,
0.8359094858,
0.242557928,
0.249761194,
-0.566908896,
0.4311647713,
-0.0370482318,
-0.4331340492,
-0.399746567,
-0.5862210393,
-0.7771592736,
0.3019581735,
-0.1747276336,
-0.7332180142,
0.4709380269,
0.5210434198,
-0.4982652068,
0.2476383895,
-0.7142439485,
0.7184904814,
-0.330573976,
-0.3436962366,
-0.1615538448,
-0.9345631003,
0.3391623795,
-0.2912628949,
0.6865649819,
-0.0968080685,
-0.0688193291,
0.9192959666,
-0.6878654957,
0.7785487771,
-0.187283054,
0.0327410586,
0.5034058094,
0.1457434744,
0.9828810096,
-0.1443477124,
-0.0079741273,
-0.1012987345,
-0.5094789863,
-0.5725498796,
-0.6624792218,
0.3048092127,
-0.8817082047,
-0.5186562538,
-0.1137236133,
-0.2899241745,
-0.4038855135,
0.0561972223,
0.4115269482,
0.3633809388,
-0.0171144363,
-0.0107127177,
0.5376311541,
-0.0091276914,
0.5036404133,
0.3699241579,
0.0576940179,
-0.4293960631,
0.8349137902,
0.213835001,
0.5401963592,
0.4103816748,
0.4351548851,
-0.4330595434,
-0.8896685243,
0.162302196,
0.1051083729,
-0.6364023089,
0.0798640028,
-0.9607585669,
0.2318219841,
-0.6937227249,
-0.4138177633,
-0.3974192441,
-0.3803246617,
-0.6398578882,
-0.2856851518,
0.2394163013,
0.5237661004,
0.1191403791,
0.8850228786,
-1.0484570265,
0.2904101014,
0.5544890165,
0.0472127311,
0.0047370233,
-0.5819997191,
-0.4897158742,
-0.0225600842,
-0.232413739,
-1.1935112476,
0.6448375583,
0.3829255104,
0.8637083173,
0.6873359084,
0.13243559,
0.6679342389,
-0.2309567481,
0.6940551996,
0.3390979767,
-1.0304906368,
0.5077213049,
-0.5271631479,
0.3850080669,
0.9165209532,
0.3430320024,
-0.3398912549,
-0.8729601502,
-0.9086710215,
-0.8761931062,
0.6699981689,
0.3730776608,
-0.1816044897,
0.0025955341,
0.0160956457,
0.5064874291,
0.498019278,
-0.4409492612,
-0.1121807992,
-0.0940295458,
-0.1531355828,
-0.2435224652,
-0.4207384586,
-0.0827793106,
-0.3129901886,
0.4776421189,
0.1102307439,
-0.1432478577,
-0.1252285838,
-0.4108293951,
0.0807427093,
0.4348419309,
0.3361742198,
0.8506516814,
-0.2875006497,
0.3944436014,
0.0783950388,
-0.3638577163,
0.085207127,
0.0429430455,
-0.1663885862,
0.2301859111,
0.4278153479,
0.6518149376,
0.4185382426,
-0.1673362106,
0.3327799439,
0.2234410793,
-0.0782167763,
0.2576915324,
0.040103469,
-0.0021711371,
-0.1596531272,
0.3696351051,
0.6213614941,
0.3332289159,
-0.2124295682,
0.2741760314,
0.179338038,
-0.2450548112,
-0.6219723821,
0.4993427396,
0.3474616706,
-0.2136826962,
0.4298125505,
-0.1725494713,
-0.5521972179,
0.6230162382,
0.0335248932,
0.8855647445,
-0.3807196915,
0.2626329362,
-0.0555454083,
0.3592739701,
0.0272007994,
-0.1205524281,
-0.2620132864,
-0.7440694571,
-0.4193805456,
-0.1991687119,
-0.3902206123,
-0.2354228944,
-0.8362753987,
0.2755679488,
-0.1450086534,
-0.2296652347,
-0.0041128104,
-0.4699495137,
-0.726380527,
0.2013828605,
-0.2447079718,
0.6786184311,
-1.5207853317,
0.9771390557,
0.6849381924,
0.0270815678,
-0.6781919599,
0.2395931035,
0.0272599608,
-0.3952638805,
0.0839947164,
-0.0767293721,
0.1891177297,
-0.2205663323,
-0.4564819634,
-0.8711263537,
0.537797749,
0.0604430996,
-0.4768551886,
-0.006687704,
0.0196855366,
0.3588922024,
-0.1386008412,
0.2485470623,
0.8738597035,
0.3527054787,
0.2030269653,
-0.9652500749,
-0.2739491463,
-0.0256314185,
-0.3110107481,
0.3139289021,
-0.2436618805,
1.1947196722,
-0.063444145,
-0.0577635951,
-0.5114751458,
0.6865324974,
0.3102588356,
0.480758816,
0.7425703406,
0.4343019426,
0.8059695363,
0.2733147442,
1.0443029404,
-0.0064986018,
0.3469758332,
1.5868066549,
-0.1023140997,
0.5107762218,
0.7316029072,
-0.3383298218,
0.1507250369,
0.819514215,
0.707793355,
1.2460209131,
-0.4687491655,
-0.2595748901,
-0.5235285759,
0.0414360575,
-0.5824556947,
0.3640878797,
0.6308445334,
-0.5203687549,
-0.5158646107,
-0.1791302115,
0.0923471898,
0.1440459192,
-0.3312396407,
1.0048729181,
0.1838694513,
-0.7647266984,
0.3805777729,
-0.1847508848,
0.7797902822,
-0.4787867665,
0.1740369648,
-0.2164655179,
-0.1216326803,
-0.0335494615,
-0.6637817621,
0.6482208371,
-0.2594124675,
-0.0437951349,
-0.2447638065,
0.7660335302,
-0.608795464,
-0.6873481274,
0.0947725847,
0.6899145246,
0.1465814412,
-0.2897668481,
-0.781336844,
-0.2641636729,
0.1505652368,
-0.1112053096,
0.38140589,
0.5747547746,
-0.1531215608,
0.3120784163,
0.2855870128,
0.1750012934,
0.2298214138,
-0.154529348,
1.1215097904,
-0.4294381142,
-0.8255957961,
-0.9878881574,
0.5375374556,
-0.1602125615,
-0.2796461582,
0.6370222569,
0.2463923991,
0.4389122725,
-0.0650362894,
0.908893466,
0.1996209919,
0.7441202402,
-0.4483669996,
0.540135324,
-0.5294662714,
0.2469256818,
-0.4075936079,
-0.719245851,
-0.2456157357,
0.2543863058,
-0.864851892,
-0.1031058058,
0.5228026509,
0.4997427762,
-0.1282423288,
-0.0942644477,
0.1565842181,
0.1730988622,
0.4798278809,
0.420561403,
0.6773087978,
0.3147681355,
0.4045767486,
-0.5175411105,
-0.2105976641,
-0.2562024593,
-0.7916309834,
-0.8929934502,
-0.0186456721,
-0.4692111015,
0.0647743195,
-0.0554782785,
0.8040531278,
0.4748658538,
-0.820184052,
0.1174821705,
-0.3520804048,
0.5605970025,
-0.3039572835,
-0.1797539741,
0.481914103,
-0.2020570636,
-0.474745363,
0.2869030237,
0.4177418351,
0.3096120656,
0.0615883954,
-0.0859436914,
-0.1261241734,
0.1049712971,
0.3119253218,
0.0879325345,
-0.705565989,
-0.097365126,
-0.0825524405,
-0.029427303,
0.1698027849,
0.8263631463,
-0.6223068237,
0.431548059,
0.7080128193,
0.4401422739,
0.0233286005,
0.3477168381,
0.6662046909,
-0.9344776273,
0.5754060149,
0.3996681571,
0.2671128809,
0.2386462539,
-0.4766842723,
0.1993473023,
0.2115385085,
-0.3610157967,
-0.5338008404,
-0.0280435607,
-0.7494283319,
-0.3292214572,
0.9596428871,
-0.1492955685,
-0.3660341501,
-0.4709807634,
0.0363064185,
0.2986631989,
-0.4301720262,
0.8992469907,
0.5053198934,
-0.1495877653,
-0.247595191,
-0.1351479143,
0.4572613835,
0.5493395925,
-0.7644076943,
-0.2515540421,
0.3979406059,
0.1659318358,
-0.0336050726,
0.9875476956,
0.0685283989,
-0.0706670135,
-0.1837313324,
-0.1856510341,
0.2436862737,
-0.4475491047,
-0.2226098031,
0.1113873422,
0.2816331983,
-0.4122790992
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12058v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12058v3 | WellDunn: On the Robustness and Explainability of Language Models and Large Language Models in Identifying Wellness Dimensions | 2024-06-17T19:50:40 | 2024-06-28T04:08:12 | Seyedali Mohammadi, Edward Raff, Jinendra Malekar, Vedant Palit, Francis Ferraro, Manas Gaur | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Language Models (LMs) are being proposed for mental health applications where
the heightened risk of adverse outcomes means predictive performance may not be
a sufficient litmus test of a model's utility in clinical practice. A model
that can be trusted for practice should have a correspondence between
explanation and clinical determination, yet no prior research has examined the
attention fidelity of these models and their effect on ground truth
explanations. We introduce an evaluation design that focuses on the robustness
and explainability of LMs in identifying Wellness Dimensions (WD). We focus on
two mental health and well-being datasets: (a) Multi-label Classification-based
MultiWD, and (b) WellXplain for evaluating attention mechanism veracity against
expert-labeled explanations. The labels are based on Halbert Dunn's theory of
wellness, which gives grounding to our evaluation. We reveal four surprising
results about LMs/LLMs: (1) Despite their human-like capabilities, GPT-3.5/4
lag behind RoBERTa, and MedAlpaca, a fine-tuned LLM fails to deliver any
remarkable improvements in performance or explanations. (2) Re-examining LMs'
predictions based on a confidence-oriented loss function reveals a significant
performance drop. (3) Across all LMs/LLMs, the alignment between attention and
explanations remains low, with LLMs scoring a dismal 0.0. (4) Most mental
health-specific LMs/LLMs overlook domain-specific knowledge and undervalue
explanations, causing these discrepancies. This study highlights the need for
further research into their consistency and explanations in mental health and
well-being. | [
-0.2954874635,
-0.6931148171,
0.8857215643,
0.0847238302,
0.0017403855,
-0.1320241988,
-0.3233802617,
-0.5648424625,
0.0257500764,
0.1591050327,
-0.7234556675,
-0.5241872072,
-0.7370151281,
0.0510606617,
-0.0222333204,
1.0384539366,
0.2617094517,
0.0101345982,
-0.2743825316,
-0.2196083069,
-0.5691287518,
-0.4441335499,
-0.4854800999,
-0.6512734294,
0.534480691,
0.0611225292,
1.0433034897,
0.4355313778,
0.6641449332,
0.1877461523,
-0.2334248871,
0.0098490287,
-0.8394476175,
-0.1235995665,
-0.3341627419,
-0.253480792,
-0.6965559125,
-0.1302924752,
0.3678839207,
0.9549783468,
-0.1223614439,
0.3102567792,
0.3410108685,
0.6240572333,
-0.7480306029,
-0.0437780954,
-0.2067887485,
0.0680572316,
-0.0264981613,
0.057479281,
-0.144433111,
-0.3106373549,
0.106795989,
-0.4806287885,
-0.0343090668,
-0.0523567721,
0.9416347742,
0.6436661482,
-0.3617396057,
-0.2032681704,
-0.8418832421,
0.8824407458,
-1.0182983875,
0.4977706373,
0.6124954224,
0.0942317024,
-0.0397021286,
-0.4790243506,
-0.4100744724,
-0.0613662191,
-0.1885581613,
0.3239174187,
-0.4241864681,
0.1624380201,
0.5999535918,
0.5950555205,
-0.7359237671,
0.1459061801,
-0.0291886646,
-0.3730263412,
0.5843303204,
0.331430465,
0.2603414655,
-0.2664249837,
-0.1812184751,
0.3690730929,
-0.4651765227,
0.3493940234,
-0.2790391147,
0.0367657579,
-0.2811922729,
0.6672356129,
-0.038455151,
0.5856573582,
-0.0380667895,
-0.9143947363,
0.0866035521,
-0.2637732327,
-0.3828985095,
-0.0182159748,
0.738288939,
0.6660940647,
0.2102527767,
-0.3717334569,
-0.1390361786,
0.1852124035,
0.2445143759,
-0.746737957,
-0.1904681772,
0.5033355355,
-0.820813179,
0.2315789461,
-0.1512380689,
-0.6762057543,
-0.5717621446,
-0.3805978,
0.3975640237,
-0.548343122,
-0.3504205346,
0.4461820424,
0.2857788503,
0.0016458114,
0.0511604249,
-0.751704514,
0.2124351114,
0.7797275782,
0.7178452015,
-0.4634042978,
-0.1483424306,
-0.3182674944,
-0.0080625582,
-0.28086707,
0.5401874781,
-0.3330890536,
-0.2310407013,
-0.0021625704,
0.1337484717,
-0.0865072533,
-0.4861496389,
0.6903946996,
-0.2022050321,
0.1357603222,
-0.7105402946,
-0.5766989589,
-0.0140705323,
0.3253585398,
-0.5057224631,
0.7666887641,
0.2302862704,
-1.0858045816,
0.3553253412,
-0.5575773716,
-0.4661495388,
-0.0517270379,
0.1836265773,
-0.3540117145,
0.2548179328,
0.0507538356,
0.4687868357,
-0.2221597731,
0.4118243158,
-0.675377965,
-0.4415595233,
0.616464138,
-0.545904696,
0.8926542401,
0.3154887855,
-0.1127736419,
0.0108589921,
-0.8761703968,
0.1263954192,
0.0721959472,
-0.2079175413,
-0.4433708191,
-0.0547143705,
-0.2600355744,
0.2536803782,
0.2821122408,
-0.2143888175,
-0.4797881544,
-0.3976858854,
0.2787925303,
0.3867960572,
0.0203007553,
0.1989051104,
-0.1830029935,
0.7970836163,
-0.2825631499,
0.3298287094,
-0.2851857841,
-0.3615329862,
-0.1423418075,
-0.7355643511,
0.0658475459,
0.3986572325,
-0.2072932422,
0.3839403987,
-0.4003479779,
-0.0996409804,
-0.5660120249,
0.0946798846,
0.398888737,
0.6107345223,
0.2786566317,
-0.3194458485,
-0.2540451288,
-0.965649724,
-0.5164495111,
0.0086089466,
-0.1380251646,
0.0919851065,
0.336040616,
-0.4750844836,
0.8558291793,
-0.2127892226,
0.1028143838,
-0.1827493608,
-0.1135983095,
0.1418330818,
0.0223549139,
0.5560513139,
-0.4112274349,
-0.1530572176,
-0.2911784351,
-0.8406239748,
-0.0277182907,
0.0998974442,
-0.0244729538,
-0.3217148781,
-0.0768895447,
-0.7254755497,
0.4248306751,
0.4554354548,
-0.2924624979,
0.6010917425,
-0.099031277,
-0.1775534451,
-1.0088895559,
-0.0274754874,
0.2556025088,
-0.2882591188,
-0.6794114709,
0.0665104017,
-0.0757607445,
-0.1295968145,
0.0044412129,
0.367593497,
-0.3450022936,
-0.0663203299,
-0.3379153907,
0.1224709526,
0.2425201982,
0.1982119679,
-0.3552975059,
0.3850257695,
0.8324813247,
-0.4874938428,
0.3799071312,
-0.0195612498,
-0.2999875546,
0.8216522336,
-0.7121711969,
-0.11003685,
-0.1820324063,
0.1146041229,
-1.0513131618,
-0.4387256503,
0.1682617068,
-0.3061481118,
0.3019988835,
0.2776369452,
-0.3546820283,
-0.5002495646,
-0.1778451055,
0.1740291566,
0.4218696058,
-0.3302972317,
0.268458873,
0.5554286838,
-0.0421632566,
-0.3879878223,
-0.7156318426,
0.1332328469,
-0.7185069323,
-0.4506538212,
0.1631807834,
-0.0574253313,
-0.6399074197,
-0.0021013021,
-0.4230862856,
0.0290004611,
0.5658757687,
0.2764272988,
0.1602544039,
-0.324429512,
0.5278252363,
-0.2040263563,
-0.2190851122,
0.5784451365,
-0.077402167,
0.1372645944,
-0.2307091653,
-0.3330901563,
-0.5759102702,
0.3846733272,
0.5998023748,
-0.455571264,
0.9641013741,
0.6912806034,
-0.7968814373,
0.1046340466,
-0.3356562555,
-0.3439076841,
-0.3383831382,
0.4407979548,
-0.3264884949,
-0.860974133,
0.5659803748,
-0.0848095119,
-0.0858085677,
0.4795936048,
0.6290071607,
-0.1574424058,
1.237451911,
0.7811780572,
0.0610879809,
0.0950880125,
-0.0042755487,
0.8195975423,
-0.8055335283,
-0.2222496718,
-0.4097984731,
-0.2099984139,
-0.654307425,
-0.0291520972,
0.3069221079,
0.2763912082,
-0.2368202657,
-0.2502796948,
-0.4441638291,
0.2021580637,
0.0352024026,
0.063332282,
0.2752490044,
-0.0878956467,
0.0042848163,
-0.4185453653,
-0.6325917244,
-0.7276663184,
0.8574726582,
0.8854690194,
1.2566195726,
0.2873366475,
0.5401485562,
0.1607817262,
0.5328727365,
-0.967100203,
0.2166781723,
0.0438307077,
-0.6147077084,
-0.5325655937,
-0.3613481522,
-0.8554596901,
0.11654374,
-0.1194990724,
-1.2458935976,
0.1634765118,
0.144274205,
-0.7501524091,
-0.0759719238,
-0.6813879609,
0.9468856454,
-0.4154996276,
-0.4173832238,
-0.2002076805,
-0.6746905446,
0.7422869205,
-0.1689364314,
0.3820645809,
-0.3659663796,
0.3162092566,
0.6126279831,
-0.2199825197,
0.667650938,
0.1775069386,
-0.5403365493,
-0.1456045806,
0.0169751998,
0.0998741165,
0.3340333402,
-0.2180998474,
0.0379934609,
0.287676245,
-0.2360843271,
-0.8384447098,
0.8400773406,
-0.6917784214,
-0.6764858961,
-0.2116027623,
-0.6524685621,
-0.592748642,
0.1394981742,
0.1580248475,
0.5284115076,
-0.1268808246,
0.1069402173,
0.9004355669,
-0.318158865,
-0.0358328335,
0.3511635065,
-0.3256895542,
-0.2069125175,
0.8527188897,
0.005285352,
0.3234908283,
0.1243534535,
0.3555331826,
-0.393304348,
-0.250005573,
0.0792918578,
0.3908981085,
-0.8073827624,
-0.0046093427,
-0.5439080596,
-0.1779853553,
-0.3462162614,
0.2273412794,
-0.4049638212,
-0.1594690531,
-0.2101856023,
-0.2249192894,
-0.0145949684,
0.7288422585,
-0.1789970547,
-0.0958246738,
-0.5485266447,
0.575258553,
0.2630845904,
0.548807323,
0.3640820384,
-0.4822104275,
-0.6656329632,
0.3185478151,
-0.4364304245,
-1.2588801384,
0.1020981073,
0.140206933,
0.7890606523,
0.8479119539,
0.1158291772,
0.7098717093,
-0.1743379235,
0.7158406973,
0.2314498425,
-0.8871052265,
0.5345438719,
-0.0749610364,
0.4387308359,
0.3370526135,
0.5610886216,
-0.3439632952,
-0.4187887907,
-0.5399485826,
-0.481974721,
0.4952969849,
0.0522247739,
-0.0435408652,
-0.0466401614,
0.5556254387,
0.1954308599,
-0.1144146025,
-0.6644722223,
-0.3946135044,
-0.3792108297,
-0.1608090401,
-0.2695085406,
-0.6650351286,
-0.4512325227,
-0.255623728,
0.4577410221,
-0.2313117534,
0.3710576594,
0.3299326301,
0.1195332259,
-0.2403727323,
0.5551536679,
0.6806564927,
1.1247023344,
-0.2021235377,
0.5648680925,
0.118520759,
-0.1946767718,
-0.022984609,
0.1628481448,
0.1242541671,
-0.0258604363,
0.7259113193,
0.7851993442,
0.1352895349,
-0.5694689751,
0.2278128564,
0.0325106047,
0.0109622749,
0.155431971,
0.0743654966,
0.4430231452,
0.2644396722,
0.0900316238,
-0.1798758209,
0.3727313876,
-0.7351220846,
-0.1223342791,
0.6574112177,
-0.5845903754,
-0.5643409491,
0.6751999855,
-0.3074671328,
-0.3538615108,
0.3706223965,
-0.1092278212,
-0.4658377469,
0.3637534678,
0.6087880731,
0.718000114,
-0.2287151814,
0.3386380076,
0.3881135881,
0.4136089683,
-0.10665185,
0.3550193608,
0.043579191,
-0.6661567092,
-0.562207222,
-0.6846507192,
-0.1554733217,
0.567737639,
-1.0522857904,
-0.4426491559,
-0.1177095473,
-0.6548255682,
-0.0110725779,
-0.0175321233,
-0.7733023763,
0.2959757745,
0.3738842309,
0.6405636072,
-0.8295527697,
0.4909718335,
0.7410873771,
-0.0738935694,
-0.9008277655,
0.6084694266,
0.0848511681,
-0.5591461658,
0.2014668882,
0.2124023438,
-0.1901898235,
-0.3004485369,
-0.4276300073,
-0.9567970037,
0.9083664417,
0.7664887309,
-0.3334770501,
0.0841141269,
0.2002536058,
0.8630845547,
-0.1813597977,
0.1557584107,
0.6327189803,
0.6815705895,
-0.0824749842,
-1.0124928951,
0.144535169,
0.0483863652,
0.1931045502,
-0.3649967611,
-0.5274134874,
0.5654895306,
-0.7127926946,
-0.3788780868,
-0.1261306107,
0.5031228662,
0.4465022683,
0.4716746509,
0.1531035602,
0.7187759876,
1.1209405661,
-0.110170193,
1.323481679,
-0.2726293802,
0.7786087394,
0.9564157128,
-0.4090133011,
0.4576322436,
0.383530587,
-0.4326416552,
0.2949092686,
0.9855831861,
0.3318569958,
0.7118970156,
0.2997798622,
0.0123942178,
-0.5116987824,
-0.3454400301,
-0.2673321962,
0.2075980902,
0.3716216981,
-0.2982358336,
-0.2807286084,
0.248435095,
-0.0204603039,
-0.0284872204,
-0.1464017928,
0.5559738874,
0.521625936,
-0.4894742072,
0.6934699416,
0.0927681774,
0.1260458231,
-0.3697736859,
0.0982150212,
-0.2089805603,
0.3542062938,
-0.3160950243,
-0.7753110528,
0.3785307407,
-0.0869617984,
-0.3584352434,
-0.1896902919,
0.8689115644,
-0.3038122654,
-0.4982478321,
0.250174284,
0.681702137,
0.2000957578,
0.0078388788,
-0.7594431639,
0.1718774736,
-0.2639904618,
-0.2985797822,
0.3792640269,
0.8546457887,
-0.0461404398,
0.8720188141,
0.3551012874,
-0.0099797696,
-0.1079794988,
0.1800213456,
0.5038425326,
-0.4433096945,
-0.2531368434,
-1.0535104275,
0.442692101,
0.1368348598,
-0.2064613253,
0.8584879637,
0.3866812885,
0.2487642467,
0.042221725,
0.7114849687,
0.3143586516,
0.3760885,
-0.5185414553,
0.7384765744,
-0.8483874202,
0.2146769911,
-0.0635095537,
-0.8170701861,
-0.1890221685,
0.7072321177,
-0.3833220899,
0.2353818566,
0.8596815467,
0.5204954743,
-0.0639143735,
-0.0223389324,
0.5429588556,
0.5929757357,
0.2834933698,
0.6425815821,
0.7700748444,
0.0170537829,
-0.0680738315,
-0.209572345,
-0.2449695021,
-0.1667288542,
-0.8100631833,
-0.9832134843,
-0.2714690864,
-0.3965268731,
-0.4579164684,
0.1538632959,
0.5568833947,
0.6427406073,
-0.6339702606,
0.1782554835,
0.3577390909,
0.4335650802,
-0.4632559121,
-0.2325777262,
0.4374256432,
-0.1637635231,
-0.163662523,
0.13677077,
0.514667213,
-0.2314945906,
-0.7323516011,
-0.2659747601,
0.349442631,
-0.0061727404,
0.6085003614,
0.1599692702,
-1.2183012962,
-0.2030420154,
0.0718723312,
-0.3322361708,
-0.0023187269,
0.468814224,
-0.5571682453,
0.3769513667,
0.0238297619,
0.5550279021,
-0.0566078536,
0.0155712552,
0.3824453652,
-0.1200499162,
-0.4569057524,
0.067251496,
0.4525127113,
0.4652567506,
-0.5759872794,
0.2388324142,
-0.0155922398,
-0.4731975496,
-0.8192234039,
0.2101347148,
-0.989402771,
-0.0452275835,
1.2208669186,
-0.3964110613,
-0.2218378484,
-0.0921799392,
-0.05809962,
0.0513760187,
0.0288502611,
1.1091405153,
1.0631276369,
-0.1939856559,
-0.3857866228,
-0.8105473518,
0.4919293523,
0.3951202333,
-0.7960089445,
0.2011983693,
0.406986624,
0.4837737381,
0.2799487412,
0.4883539379,
-0.0726262778,
0.3841510117,
-0.3930364847,
-0.1002172306,
0.2278319597,
-0.0465930775,
-0.3494989872,
-0.0084800562,
0.1692814529,
0.1649917811
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12053v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12053v1 | InternalInspector $I^2$: Robust Confidence Estimation in LLMs through Internal States | 2024-06-17T19:46:05 | 2024-06-17T19:46:05 | Mohammad Beigi, Ying Shen, Runing Yang, Zihao Lin, Qifan Wang, Ankith Mohan, Jianfeng He, Ming Jin, Chang-Tien Lu, Lifu Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Despite their vast capabilities, Large Language Models (LLMs) often struggle
with generating reliable outputs, frequently producing high-confidence
inaccuracies known as hallucinations. Addressing this challenge, our research
introduces InternalInspector, a novel framework designed to enhance confidence
estimation in LLMs by leveraging contrastive learning on internal states
including attention states, feed-forward states, and activation states of all
layers. Unlike existing methods that primarily focus on the final activation
state, InternalInspector conducts a comprehensive analysis across all internal
states of every layer to accurately identify both correct and incorrect
prediction processes. By benchmarking InternalInspector against existing
confidence estimation methods across various natural language understanding and
generation tasks, including factual question answering, commonsense reasoning,
and reading comprehension, InternalInspector achieves significantly higher
accuracy in aligning the estimated confidence scores with the correctness of
the LLM's predictions and lower calibration error. Furthermore,
InternalInspector excels at HaluEval, a hallucination detection benchmark,
outperforming other internal-based confidence estimation methods in this task. | [
-0.3174098432,
-0.3955266774,
0.7156773806,
0.1118928716,
-0.0534878857,
0.296831578,
-0.315099448,
-0.5992876887,
0.1534167975,
0.2087233961,
-0.4312941432,
-0.4318730831,
-0.5865760446,
0.1380246729,
-0.3474722207,
0.3958410621,
0.0899679139,
0.3339124024,
-0.4955879748,
0.3345690668,
-0.2966937125,
-0.4265658855,
-0.5548173785,
-0.6537155509,
0.148124665,
0.6248798966,
0.416503042,
-0.0719058365,
0.3288443387,
0.4100402296,
-0.0459727049,
0.5053741932,
-0.5081393719,
0.3266199529,
-0.1294509023,
-0.4422396421,
0.0761125088,
-0.2161634117,
0.7672539949,
0.4026602507,
-0.0153857451,
-0.129665792,
0.5801348686,
0.5763320327,
-0.9646311402,
0.2446204424,
-0.8663737178,
0.1179731265,
0.0318825766,
-0.2381994724,
-0.4043496251,
-0.6181186438,
-0.012613574,
-0.1977535337,
0.0411019213,
-0.1418691725,
0.6868260503,
0.4570460618,
-0.2021396458,
-0.2782408595,
-0.3928392529,
0.6664972305,
-0.6965003014,
0.4495019615,
0.6488881111,
0.2015153617,
-0.3870119452,
-0.8251318932,
-0.6046944261,
-0.6114599705,
-0.2092918605,
0.1708521694,
-0.0319800153,
0.2151870728,
-0.0253539011,
0.5666377544,
-0.4771683514,
0.3141263723,
-0.018316403,
-0.4493048787,
0.3325305581,
0.0090489406,
-0.1036209911,
-0.0459252894,
-0.2545363009,
-0.0494890362,
-0.4873265624,
0.202070564,
0.4085440636,
0.3025206327,
0.0622453392,
0.5098606944,
-0.2746297419,
0.2803486884,
0.4526712894,
-0.2412064075,
0.3439459503,
-0.0943805575,
-0.3323720396,
0.3400970399,
0.5810685754,
0.1365875155,
0.205464378,
-0.3440606296,
-0.3054713309,
0.302454561,
0.4406766593,
-0.9667491317,
-0.3993824422,
0.5188302398,
-0.157709077,
-0.2859662771,
0.4200502634,
-0.7416135073,
-0.7425559163,
-0.33676669,
0.5926580429,
-0.6795420051,
-0.3136775792,
-0.1255665869,
0.1904342473,
0.2833688855,
0.1516982019,
-0.4385764897,
0.5508472323,
0.78798908,
0.8767580986,
-0.5533690453,
-0.2102248818,
-0.7426169515,
-0.0989844128,
-0.5053448677,
0.9203373194,
-0.548509419,
-0.2262175381,
0.1503361017,
0.1439952552,
-0.0698235258,
-0.7904812694,
0.5256798267,
-0.114074178,
0.1253727376,
-0.0532102957,
-0.8930771947,
-0.2446369678,
0.479388535,
-0.3879107833,
1.3859952688,
0.1181894466,
-0.7343395948,
0.2375156134,
-0.2271762043,
-0.2542973161,
0.1419348717,
-0.3390115201,
-0.305170089,
0.3188326359,
0.0934832767,
0.6505507827,
-0.1387546957,
0.0267021637,
-0.185974583,
-0.7446704507,
0.5817062855,
-0.1329115927,
0.4480827749,
-0.0993138105,
-0.503328979,
0.5086756349,
-0.6920744777,
0.1473686993,
-0.2468055934,
0.0206544455,
-0.1878957897,
-0.1263878793,
-0.192394942,
0.1060160026,
0.19013533,
-0.6106823087,
-0.2966363728,
-0.4795865715,
-0.0778528303,
0.8619794846,
0.2086285204,
0.3282074332,
-0.1626890451,
0.475484699,
0.2014955282,
-0.101500161,
0.0190590471,
-0.3556716144,
-0.6445021629,
-0.4835034013,
-0.0697257966,
0.4808763862,
-0.5533750653,
0.7457447648,
0.0075178659,
-0.6195703149,
-0.4795158803,
0.2734890878,
0.5910032988,
0.8500503898,
0.3205637038,
-0.1537628025,
-0.4260047376,
-0.9300789237,
-0.1822740883,
-0.1707191169,
-0.1823707521,
-0.2256618142,
0.4275949299,
-0.3521851897,
0.4973470271,
-0.2530798316,
-0.4917944968,
-0.1738649458,
0.1181175858,
0.2020603269,
0.4568959773,
0.0892359912,
-0.4839808047,
-0.6526637077,
0.0583832972,
-0.7419194579,
0.0900312588,
-0.0440834872,
-0.1907069832,
0.2838255167,
0.7636393905,
-0.4057095945,
0.3267792165,
0.5411333442,
-0.2194839269,
0.4573522806,
-0.1044806316,
0.0959039554,
-1.1103048325,
-0.141637519,
0.3123700619,
-0.2340647131,
-0.5320099592,
0.1927951723,
0.379922539,
0.4417663813,
-0.1723135561,
0.4325148761,
-0.5586676598,
-0.0343341194,
-0.3308836818,
0.2661234438,
-0.228640765,
0.3713732362,
-0.0332810953,
0.9092449546,
0.5321787596,
-0.502399683,
0.0730910078,
0.10709209,
-0.8859115243,
0.7345991135,
-0.4462466836,
0.2498392761,
-0.1775429845,
-0.0135215977,
-1.3542978764,
-0.36466524,
0.2541595995,
-0.5290001631,
0.6016831398,
0.056411989,
-0.5918428302,
-0.0688112676,
-0.4577976763,
-0.1710121781,
0.5078529716,
-0.6465399265,
0.6625213027,
0.4868967831,
-0.0404607244,
-0.6345769167,
-0.7667835355,
0.102557756,
0.0059909089,
-0.3031073511,
0.3014861941,
-0.2527302802,
-0.5018221736,
-0.1291399598,
-0.2519257069,
-0.3238195479,
0.020062197,
0.5240927339,
0.0844461694,
-0.0154763218,
0.3138755858,
0.0782002732,
-0.0957554281,
0.1909048259,
0.0196680203,
0.5046752095,
-0.2541384101,
-0.3964093924,
-0.6471738815,
0.128248468,
0.3404924572,
-0.0178785324,
0.619125247,
0.5879926085,
-0.6989328265,
-0.4507049918,
-0.7833738327,
-0.5012524128,
-0.5130032301,
0.5840560794,
-0.5719877481,
-0.7179477215,
0.398642242,
0.1243226975,
-0.1327405274,
0.2785268128,
0.535314858,
-0.1070590839,
0.7692896724,
0.5317627192,
-0.0392718539,
0.2855014205,
0.0091505535,
0.0421620123,
-0.8673644066,
-0.4909559786,
-0.4639219046,
-0.2753010094,
-0.4671351314,
-0.4623837769,
0.4369583726,
-0.0433894545,
-0.3550700843,
0.0384400487,
-0.6264051199,
0.5172085166,
0.4858253598,
0.3651862741,
0.3485229313,
0.1699808985,
-0.1988994032,
-0.4879542887,
-0.3406318128,
-0.3097519279,
0.8502401114,
0.4594853818,
0.9079038501,
0.0825107396,
0.7377215028,
0.0121712815,
0.5722165704,
-0.9205887318,
0.512668848,
0.0354888998,
-0.2908394337,
-0.183135286,
-0.3071834743,
-0.3670489788,
0.313159734,
-0.2016042173,
-0.9261699319,
0.3970761001,
0.1285705715,
-0.154993847,
0.3181382418,
-0.4609617591,
0.4723952115,
-0.1286276281,
-0.5193488598,
-0.2528870106,
-0.5452946424,
0.5579289198,
-0.0872534588,
-0.2881052494,
-0.1587774605,
-0.2419499755,
0.1595834047,
-0.1002933085,
1.0518298149,
0.0051613552,
-0.2611043453,
0.1831098795,
0.3537983894,
0.7238361835,
0.0921724066,
-0.4938113689,
0.1697053313,
-0.2311784327,
0.018950101,
-0.3810327351,
0.9948777556,
-0.5596038103,
-0.2411560118,
-0.579762578,
-0.4320703745,
-0.6516880989,
-0.1351866871,
0.5360777378,
0.3145031929,
-0.2020290941,
0.385905534,
0.816888392,
-0.0936347395,
0.3166223466,
0.1879007667,
0.1328086555,
-0.5046436191,
0.8252316713,
-0.0953613445,
0.2780708075,
0.5611612797,
0.1949778497,
-0.4896488488,
-0.4434277415,
0.1490935087,
0.2501645684,
-1.0394176245,
-0.4110104442,
-0.6035267711,
-0.570328474,
-0.302894026,
-0.033991728,
-0.4233154058,
0.0128659774,
-0.2358019501,
-0.3562881351,
0.0802875161,
0.6345579624,
-0.0173121784,
0.152567178,
-0.3255647719,
0.343290925,
0.3343856037,
0.4253817201,
-0.1799310446,
-0.8366861939,
-0.2630938888,
-0.2578555644,
-0.1637996882,
-0.8710413575,
0.3940399289,
0.267216742,
0.8237225413,
0.6278444529,
0.0538092032,
0.8944476843,
-0.1673966795,
0.664639473,
0.0622982569,
-1.0327585936,
0.1572452337,
0.401480794,
0.4556391239,
0.932099998,
0.5076006651,
-0.2033399493,
-0.6910869479,
-0.197596252,
-0.530878067,
0.2440640777,
0.1179589182,
-0.0711284429,
-0.0557763651,
0.2719641626,
0.3448888361,
0.3381927609,
-0.806581676,
-0.0263689645,
-0.1412720531,
-0.4444162846,
-0.1988453418,
-0.5319164991,
-0.0795442984,
-0.2689265013,
0.926854074,
-0.4769872129,
0.3102377951,
0.476775974,
-0.3457540572,
-0.2846391201,
0.0462754034,
0.5047467351,
0.8057451844,
-0.4843462408,
0.3377495706,
0.1173974872,
-0.4433180094,
-0.0282173697,
0.1088252366,
-0.0392921716,
0.1930039525,
0.4088748097,
0.4403617084,
0.4813316762,
-0.6811767817,
0.487082243,
-0.0603432916,
-0.1642575711,
-0.8249878287,
-0.0863194242,
-0.0720576122,
0.4879595041,
0.3173772097,
-0.1689458638,
0.2812077403,
-0.4026533961,
0.2254531085,
0.5919989347,
-0.9635808468,
-0.2309331149,
0.4596760571,
0.0471797623,
-0.1008858904,
0.5377851129,
-0.1641505212,
-0.4048760831,
0.4019839466,
0.6387094855,
1.5133094788,
-0.5195603371,
0.1585634351,
0.671592772,
0.5911833048,
-0.1616236567,
0.4899208844,
-0.0222161654,
-0.9608098865,
-0.3990271389,
-0.5831873417,
-0.6499120593,
0.3694401085,
-0.5839035511,
-0.0979686752,
-0.4703523815,
0.0540531315,
-0.4848181307,
0.0361911505,
-0.490789026,
0.1004874855,
0.2384786904,
0.8534847498,
-0.5182740092,
0.9336184263,
0.3684434295,
-0.3315765262,
-0.4303168058,
0.543112278,
0.1702991277,
-0.6530437469,
0.5336090326,
0.5509909987,
-0.694809258,
-0.1425928622,
-0.6362816691,
-0.754904151,
0.9471571445,
0.4274464846,
-0.5654774904,
0.2077788264,
-0.1918799877,
0.3612534106,
-0.4673739672,
0.1763529778,
0.5156014562,
0.5078201294,
0.0295954477,
-0.4941618443,
0.2045345455,
-0.1773528606,
-0.0729473606,
0.0293202922,
-0.2949779332,
0.7523770332,
-0.123950392,
-0.336345762,
0.3295846879,
0.8316314816,
0.3883944154,
0.0101632411,
0.640190661,
0.3415664434,
0.8840048909,
-0.1203816682,
1.0367000103,
-0.6563135386,
-0.1400596797,
1.6141377687,
-0.3065021932,
1.0017054081,
0.6453575492,
0.117970936,
0.7562953234,
0.6167840362,
0.1111441702,
0.4695016742,
0.1482206583,
-0.4267493486,
-0.3175098598,
0.0032827854,
-0.2609502673,
0.3516759574,
0.5439671278,
-0.2630669475,
0.2506448328,
-0.2692905068,
-0.038029559,
0.2491451353,
-0.1723973304,
0.8015271425,
0.1815292537,
-0.7377750874,
0.3249157667,
-0.2916746736,
0.8036527038,
-0.8564022183,
-0.1688259989,
-0.3591857255,
0.6444991231,
-0.1493973434,
-0.8379135132,
0.0127078444,
-0.3874998689,
0.3831657171,
0.1144825071,
0.7484298348,
-0.6000160575,
-0.5565132499,
0.4847281873,
0.2863759398,
-0.0660630167,
-0.5450201631,
-0.4101037085,
-0.0515644066,
-0.2748174965,
-0.2001494914,
0.156913206,
0.325596571,
0.2974760532,
0.725898087,
0.3196310103,
0.1357134283,
-0.1547993869,
0.0041392334,
0.6565991044,
-0.4991131425,
-0.5075198412,
-0.6825085282,
0.6576706767,
-0.4796125591,
-0.4642595649,
0.9322320223,
0.5038415194,
0.8657355309,
-0.1263873875,
0.6316285133,
0.4401973486,
0.6065702438,
-0.4706250429,
0.5173060894,
-0.5171325207,
0.0769768208,
-0.2971752584,
-1.0333286524,
-0.2427476346,
0.7187364101,
0.1034020856,
-0.1311824769,
1.0191081762,
1.1901589632,
0.0441460833,
-0.1741701514,
0.5810602307,
0.536488533,
0.0597853027,
0.2925460637,
0.8649442196,
-0.2405569851,
0.274143666,
-0.748732686,
-0.222612679,
-0.1624855101,
-0.8220393658,
-1.1240570545,
-0.6711833477,
-0.1897406131,
-0.4649645984,
-0.1123304218,
1.0150821209,
0.6490383148,
-1.0660543442,
-0.6063343883,
-0.0979306027,
-0.0450568125,
-0.3576817214,
-0.2622143924,
0.1996925771,
-0.6121742725,
-0.8356366158,
0.7765648365,
0.4742634892,
-0.0901670083,
-0.6014068723,
-0.1998735219,
-0.099831976,
0.225933969,
0.560131371,
0.1107554585,
-0.8688009381,
-0.2635103762,
-0.2009282857,
-0.1696329415,
0.0926738977,
0.6391870975,
-0.8114001155,
0.5841241479,
0.4226980507,
0.7441507578,
0.5392892957,
-0.0940333754,
0.4492665231,
-0.7989569902,
0.3842040598,
0.2814282179,
0.451472193,
0.6370655298,
-0.5455169678,
0.7655321956,
-0.1278195381,
-0.4629123211,
-0.9339248538,
0.1857603341,
-0.71750319,
-0.3576567173,
0.955581665,
0.1988937259,
-0.0707017034,
-0.1144739315,
-0.0418071039,
0.0274462663,
-0.4399814904,
0.8668637872,
0.4451005459,
-0.1796345264,
-0.3603276014,
-0.4699204862,
0.7630463839,
0.3056637049,
-1.0437873602,
-0.2676444054,
0.4014521539,
0.1587031633,
0.1887623519,
0.3616743386,
-0.0893944129,
0.0558078364,
-0.1017542258,
0.2083543986,
0.0712589547,
-0.4278191924,
-0.4532380998,
0.4323831797,
-0.0223914441,
-0.2375981212
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12052v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12052v1 | UniGLM: Training One Unified Language Model for Text-Attributed Graphs | 2024-06-17T19:45:21 | 2024-06-17T19:45:21 | Yi Fang, Dongzhe Fan, Sirui Ding, Ninghao Liu, Qiaoyu Tan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, cs.LG | Representation learning on text-attributed graphs (TAGs), where nodes are
represented by textual descriptions, is crucial for textual and relational
knowledge systems and recommendation systems. Currently, state-of-the-art
embedding methods for TAGs primarily focus on fine-tuning language models
(e.g., BERT) using structure-aware training signals. While effective, these
methods are tailored for individual TAG and cannot generalize across various
graph scenarios. Given the shared textual space, leveraging multiple TAGs for
joint fine-tuning, aligning text and graph structure from different aspects,
would be more beneficial. Motivated by this, we introduce a novel Unified Graph
Language Model (UniGLM) framework, the first graph embedding model that
generalizes well to both in-domain and cross-domain TAGs. Specifically, UniGLM
is trained over multiple TAGs with different domains and scales using
self-supervised contrastive learning. UniGLM includes an adaptive positive
sample selection technique for identifying structurally similar nodes and a
lazy contrastive module that is devised to accelerate training by minimizing
repetitive encoding calculations. Extensive empirical results across 9
benchmark TAGs demonstrate UniGLM's efficacy against leading embedding
baselines in terms of generalization (various downstream tasks and backbones)
and transfer learning (in and out of domain scenarios). The code is available
at https://github.com/NYUSHCS/UniGLM. | [
-0.0468358062,
-0.4877000153,
0.255679965,
-0.0827898681,
-0.5836957097,
0.5691556334,
-0.0051535745,
-0.2077588588,
0.1047521606,
0.5046112537,
-0.2199161649,
-0.896912694,
-0.3404580951,
-0.2854735255,
-0.1484627128,
1.1551806927,
-0.1235801056,
0.1325164437,
-0.3020012379,
-0.3926894665,
-0.305375278,
-0.5724554062,
-0.3605645001,
-0.8613844514,
0.5374718904,
0.0770967305,
0.3969253004,
0.4519349039,
0.3361848295,
0.2214127034,
0.1326715648,
0.4256961644,
-0.5151370168,
-0.1805963218,
-0.2429977208,
0.1361949742,
-0.3296613693,
-0.1106872559,
0.7074253559,
1.1355304718,
-0.0802387893,
0.0110924467,
0.3915540874,
0.5190138817,
-0.3643235564,
0.1858989,
-0.7656316757,
-0.150414288,
-0.0460266583,
0.0470940173,
-0.6691961288,
-0.0068357592,
0.0713958219,
-0.7077558637,
0.1080045104,
0.2548984587,
0.891523242,
0.1574660987,
-0.6041278839,
-0.0659179688,
-0.2747012079,
0.5060259104,
-0.4110608101,
0.5205776691,
0.2031487674,
0.0453836359,
-0.2111655623,
-1.1618189812,
-0.0588363223,
0.0666132793,
-0.4267489016,
-0.0657668412,
-0.4302280247,
0.228756696,
-0.3313853741,
0.0343800969,
-0.6494073272,
0.2469985187,
-0.1171211377,
-0.2353292257,
0.3571102321,
-0.0319381095,
0.262353152,
-0.0263262708,
-0.8004237413,
0.195719257,
-0.6446728706,
-0.1041839197,
0.2896023989,
0.660443902,
0.0872983336,
0.2477730215,
-0.0136445407,
0.7332603931,
-0.2550845742,
0.3680290878,
0.402480036,
-0.0349531509,
-0.4774813354,
-0.0813458189,
0.9711068869,
0.2252519429,
0.3438628614,
-0.544836998,
-0.0701677576,
0.1748458743,
0.2029004991,
-0.6369082332,
-0.6621151567,
-0.1917977929,
-0.3585121632,
-0.1245645881,
0.053382881,
-0.4717141688,
-0.2704848349,
-0.0088253003,
0.3074463308,
-0.3636218607,
-0.1143147051,
0.2040128559,
-0.1936827451,
-0.3165775537,
0.0709872544,
-0.6445413828,
0.3797871768,
0.3952242732,
0.734601438,
-0.1651269644,
-0.478522718,
-0.2964315116,
0.3533953428,
-0.1705597639,
1.0459215641,
-0.8020695448,
-0.3368352652,
0.1424366981,
0.1185401678,
-0.1852753311,
-0.0428554937,
0.6131346226,
-0.5037587881,
0.0015526388,
-0.0368616767,
-0.8169465661,
-0.308100611,
0.0820234865,
-0.5642112494,
1.2150149345,
0.3900357485,
-0.9574465752,
0.259408772,
-0.6613801122,
-0.5327404737,
0.274027288,
-0.0782706812,
-0.4635951817,
-0.1310849488,
0.2447128594,
0.6798405647,
-0.2771017551,
0.1467457712,
-0.5430617929,
-0.2929224968,
-0.0000803334,
-0.1630431563,
0.7121879458,
0.1390603483,
0.1588627398,
0.1743669361,
-0.6686825752,
0.331394285,
0.2895611227,
-0.2340630889,
-0.7722315192,
-0.1068965197,
0.2452663183,
-0.1250008047,
0.1762379557,
-0.8527941108,
0.4071507454,
-0.3585293293,
0.6170980334,
0.7149762511,
-0.0251640156,
0.3702445626,
-0.1010648087,
0.12530002,
-0.1842539757,
-0.215609923,
-0.3430396318,
-0.349296093,
-0.3567309976,
-0.4294101298,
0.5986200571,
0.1200344488,
-0.5841762424,
0.4498810172,
-0.2761553526,
-0.4518585801,
-0.6196663976,
0.3215025961,
0.7325224876,
0.53412956,
0.4066773653,
-0.4083964527,
-0.515316844,
-0.5257068276,
-0.317273587,
-0.1196302325,
0.1589516103,
0.2024525851,
0.4144484699,
-0.4559374154,
0.9426105618,
-0.7197458148,
-0.7146832347,
-0.1748387814,
0.3778173625,
-0.048624862,
0.4441092014,
0.6526226401,
-0.6247082949,
-0.8513832092,
0.3058862388,
-0.6078265309,
-0.0624967478,
0.165517807,
-0.0972139984,
0.2027610093,
0.4088067114,
-0.290682137,
0.2701468766,
0.6986099482,
-0.4585473239,
-0.0215947703,
-0.5227178931,
-0.3263400197,
-0.974709034,
0.0536014512,
-0.0513665751,
-0.5187398195,
-0.4805331826,
-0.022759838,
0.1023208871,
0.0006813616,
-0.1268457621,
0.6596460342,
-0.7587326169,
-0.0591519512,
-0.1396994293,
0.2255680263,
0.3158218563,
0.7861711979,
-0.3224126101,
0.3799287975,
0.7574084401,
-0.3480257988,
0.2812877893,
0.2304066569,
-0.1416046172,
0.4614842534,
-0.7113065124,
0.4605241716,
-0.1031008214,
0.227801159,
-1.4496846199,
0.0010400948,
0.0691791624,
-0.4533984661,
0.5432161689,
-0.4418651164,
-0.4227133691,
-0.4635410905,
-0.1721508652,
0.2733732164,
0.4368833303,
-0.8656424284,
0.7493240237,
0.6090192199,
0.2765716612,
-0.614336431,
-0.6487274766,
-0.2589792609,
0.0557108149,
-0.3450249732,
0.4838663936,
-0.0415978655,
0.4119694531,
0.5345253944,
-0.0374357738,
-0.2022288144,
0.2283363789,
0.363112092,
0.0975390077,
0.0885967761,
0.5486845374,
0.1509381235,
-0.328661412,
-0.2562766075,
-0.8392682076,
0.6698966026,
-0.1711253226,
-0.5408002734,
-0.1769741029,
0.3725861907,
0.2031471133,
-0.4791975617,
0.4239146709,
0.7177963257,
-0.3216666281,
-0.4880777299,
0.0032485072,
0.3443992138,
-0.4577703774,
0.5209550858,
-0.3206680119,
-1.0175507069,
0.5201112032,
-0.4845932126,
-0.0172224771,
0.4270100594,
0.4387385249,
-0.3067581356,
1.1782399416,
0.8539306521,
-0.2396797538,
0.3743160665,
-0.2921386361,
0.0771685615,
-0.9639232159,
-0.3353269994,
-0.4953664243,
-0.1770447642,
-0.5232026577,
-0.4087401927,
-0.0106716761,
0.189716056,
-0.4637950957,
0.22456792,
-0.9067589045,
0.7474858761,
0.3024650812,
-0.0597603284,
0.3120892048,
0.2518986464,
-0.6573629379,
0.1023782045,
-0.6986883283,
-0.4154518247,
1.2409876585,
0.2342604101,
1.2385048866,
-0.1675851792,
0.6112610698,
0.5191091895,
0.6058030725,
-0.5651728511,
0.1977576762,
-0.7169901133,
-0.3398453891,
-0.2085572481,
-0.3222874403,
-1.1762287617,
0.4145936966,
-0.0543251336,
-0.9033743143,
-0.1104822159,
0.233506605,
0.0335235856,
0.5881461501,
-0.6986563206,
0.9445175529,
-0.2382324934,
0.1028952077,
0.2378894687,
-0.651475966,
-0.2851932347,
0.0544340909,
0.113652803,
-0.3320685625,
0.1131354049,
0.6401177049,
0.088934496,
1.0938662291,
-0.1452301741,
0.196133554,
0.2862884998,
0.1095490977,
0.5106990337,
-0.0679977015,
0.1461234987,
0.2824516296,
-0.2140639275,
-0.3872338831,
-0.4340660572,
0.7405548096,
-0.9350811839,
-0.1142662019,
-0.2809865177,
-0.5860419273,
-0.2664805949,
0.5368852019,
0.2563561499,
0.626752615,
-0.6491043568,
0.1301970482,
0.4962434471,
0.2777522206,
0.3595249951,
0.379365176,
-0.4318683147,
-0.4843293726,
0.9139118195,
0.0129638687,
0.097307533,
0.5572514534,
0.146717608,
-0.4284894168,
-0.5186098814,
-0.3997894824,
0.321189791,
-0.9980000257,
-0.5239197016,
-0.8321441412,
-0.022129463,
-0.5235604644,
-0.2414355725,
-0.3504242599,
-0.2862266004,
-0.3936400414,
-0.2383458614,
0.2342322618,
1.0371025801,
0.0991918445,
0.4402325749,
-0.5648309588,
0.011722466,
0.2175691724,
0.7236850262,
-0.1686168313,
-0.4232174158,
-0.2851508856,
-0.0304889623,
-0.1661045998,
-0.782940805,
0.3042326272,
0.4133087695,
0.8917092085,
0.2720428705,
0.0725394636,
0.4042623341,
-0.5999997854,
0.3878758848,
0.3530405462,
-0.9293370843,
0.1294348389,
-0.3008205295,
0.0481377281,
0.4374341667,
0.599724412,
-0.5005775094,
-0.0947265625,
-0.4658287168,
-0.6731535196,
0.4031271636,
-0.1095343381,
0.3388826847,
0.1153064147,
0.2824781537,
-0.019453954,
0.1223093271,
-0.8793205023,
-0.4849038124,
-0.3085213304,
-0.4773795605,
-0.0776143372,
-0.122081019,
-0.2725351751,
-0.3813900948,
0.5071828365,
-0.6520698071,
0.3609078526,
0.1322431266,
-0.2339996547,
-0.1463142931,
0.1669220179,
-0.1155427247,
0.503844142,
-0.1649027914,
0.4294027388,
0.0674675331,
-0.086676836,
0.0394837409,
0.3802373111,
-0.1165040061,
0.1371792257,
0.3767187297,
0.9309239984,
0.3241440952,
-0.3344898224,
0.4247703552,
0.0583890118,
-0.1269105226,
0.2243876457,
-0.3313233852,
0.2554170191,
0.0092240358,
0.2818811238,
-0.1098192781,
0.0240465607,
-0.5559269786,
0.3503382206,
0.7026035786,
-0.8054252267,
-0.3178898692,
0.6035871506,
0.2813311815,
-0.2222010344,
0.4302482307,
-0.5101933479,
-0.8207010031,
0.2467143834,
0.9629184604,
0.8253517747,
-0.2184088975,
0.5580307245,
0.0741620436,
0.2231168598,
0.3133752048,
0.1046441719,
0.2169132978,
-0.8564751148,
-0.1064934283,
-0.5657634139,
-0.2036386132,
-0.4905109704,
-0.5391589403,
-0.0172311682,
-0.4062666595,
-0.0594323203,
0.1906562895,
0.0183420759,
-0.6187281609,
-0.0033417905,
-0.029665444,
0.5939643383,
-1.0379744768,
1.1286623478,
1.1645514965,
-0.395211637,
-0.829194665,
-0.4087149203,
-0.2273216397,
-1.013649106,
0.4850183725,
0.101879701,
-0.2221836746,
0.3750109673,
-0.6678705215,
-0.8093084097,
1.031539917,
0.5064611435,
-0.1932400018,
-0.0497476347,
-0.0018138088,
0.6605997086,
-0.948463738,
0.0412873067,
0.231048584,
0.087409161,
0.1692476124,
-0.6483398676,
0.1139079332,
-0.1691452116,
0.0681509301,
0.5540673137,
-0.665350914,
0.994273603,
-0.2865340412,
-0.4477779269,
-0.0613035969,
0.4843951762,
-0.1998045444,
0.1754549742,
0.3032251596,
0.7488127351,
1.115231514,
-0.1338008642,
1.0187900066,
-0.1915605664,
0.8680487871,
1.3036789894,
-0.3847292364,
0.5479839444,
0.1597197801,
0.0045414916,
0.9147020578,
0.5198312998,
-0.0722766444,
0.6783766747,
0.0581888109,
0.0986970887,
-0.3970798552,
-0.4866776168,
-0.2925715148,
0.3352875412,
0.1742492467,
-0.3864141703,
-0.5463214517,
-0.031577535,
0.0979543552,
0.2585215271,
-0.1991797835,
0.6936249137,
0.0362686925,
-0.2123170495,
0.4369556308,
0.0112878634,
0.4520350695,
-0.7609226108,
-0.1199103296,
-0.1078353375,
0.2707460225,
-0.0921251327,
-0.8786351085,
-0.0828974098,
-0.1839126199,
-0.0035843325,
-0.2185639441,
1.0848165751,
-0.6450479627,
-0.417757839,
0.7887895703,
0.3737616241,
-0.1191105098,
0.0625717342,
-0.8104209304,
-0.1461415738,
0.0499875247,
-0.0012499326,
0.3203047514,
0.647546947,
-0.0360059105,
0.6829366088,
0.6986032724,
-0.1577582061,
-0.0760889277,
0.3856353164,
1.2916725874,
-0.4244507849,
-0.5609630346,
-0.705072701,
0.5045027733,
-0.1211361587,
-0.3383644223,
0.7472625375,
0.3741655648,
0.9510717392,
0.2635859251,
0.6754374504,
0.1458336562,
0.3528274894,
-0.3784891963,
0.678334713,
-0.6322231293,
-0.0870111212,
-0.356485635,
-0.708784461,
-0.5338917375,
0.4991370142,
0.226658687,
0.0423301756,
0.7600029707,
0.4278458953,
0.0200768244,
-0.2728702724,
0.3740228415,
0.086449109,
0.2106812,
0.6978365779,
0.5797899961,
-0.372315973,
0.5912858844,
0.0419890434,
-0.0329289809,
-0.0019372674,
-0.9138279557,
-1.3260064125,
-0.6921257377,
-0.204453066,
-0.1153238788,
0.0274376851,
0.8486811519,
0.6731252074,
-0.5849823356,
0.0001639384,
0.0501372926,
0.3108048737,
-0.0244583935,
-0.1024548635,
0.5926041603,
-0.3770136237,
-0.4645529687,
0.1871778816,
0.444518894,
0.1855360866,
-0.1721358746,
-0.1118545532,
-0.395144403,
-0.0867555737,
0.3672296703,
0.1637839824,
-0.4600687921,
-0.4979611337,
-0.1374673247,
-0.2323374301,
0.2834949791,
0.9961730242,
-0.6854247451,
0.6814094782,
0.3999683857,
0.7631143332,
0.4997940958,
0.0446298383,
0.2394193113,
-1.2854830027,
0.1012025923,
0.119580254,
0.6892749071,
0.547201097,
-0.2721903026,
0.6499619484,
0.3486623168,
-0.4895787835,
-0.9508282542,
0.2329959124,
-0.9567866921,
-0.5112089515,
0.9646031857,
-0.5689880252,
-0.0493003391,
-0.3658354282,
-0.143437773,
0.4874726832,
-0.3350422978,
0.2789635062,
0.4349220097,
0.0051295436,
0.1526985019,
0.1786969602,
0.27386415,
0.089510493,
-0.6479593515,
0.3169875741,
0.2750526071,
0.3375620246,
0.1586714089,
0.8702156544,
0.1633595228,
-0.1680571437,
-0.0279260986,
0.2274125218,
-0.4312981665,
-0.5165783763,
-0.313159734,
0.2134741545,
0.0457023419,
-0.1643175036
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12050v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12050v1 | Learn Beyond The Answer: Training Language Models with Reflection for Mathematical Reasoning | 2024-06-17T19:42:22 | 2024-06-17T19:42:22 | Zhihan Zhang, Zhenwen Liang, Wenhao Yu, Dian Yu, Mengzhao Jia, Dong Yu, Meng Jiang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Supervised fine-tuning enhances the problem-solving abilities of language
models across various mathematical reasoning tasks. To maximize such benefits,
existing research focuses on broadening the training set with various data
augmentation techniques, which is effective for standard single-round
question-answering settings. Our work introduces a novel technique aimed at
cultivating a deeper understanding of the training problems at hand, enhancing
performance not only in standard settings but also in more complex scenarios
that require reflective thinking. Specifically, we propose reflective
augmentation, a method that embeds problem reflection into each training
instance. It trains the model to consider alternative perspectives and engage
with abstractions and analogies, thereby fostering a thorough comprehension
through reflective reasoning. Extensive experiments validate the achievement of
our aim, underscoring the unique advantages of our method and its complementary
nature relative to existing augmentation techniques. | [
-0.6986575127,
-0.8415898085,
0.6401121616,
-0.0212642588,
-0.0652125701,
0.2870259881,
-0.3910203874,
-0.364417702,
-0.0890021846,
0.8029794693,
-0.9156633615,
-0.2064932734,
-0.4672335684,
-0.0991806686,
-0.1471178532,
1.0523426533,
-0.0134750307,
0.3407360315,
-0.5410789847,
-0.044690799,
-0.4811967313,
-0.2506127059,
-0.4907091856,
-0.3772784173,
0.1759427637,
0.4732206762,
0.5186075568,
0.2622435391,
0.5330222249,
0.2969846427,
0.2001435757,
0.7606184483,
-0.4842661619,
0.223059848,
-0.2230509222,
-0.840068996,
-0.1528911293,
0.1408869475,
0.6418292522,
1.1266443729,
-0.1567248255,
0.3321104348,
0.0342893712,
0.7785641551,
-0.7633545995,
0.3017934859,
-0.72568959,
0.1029685512,
0.210690558,
-0.0548610352,
-0.3420467973,
-0.6396903992,
0.1837439984,
-0.8373664021,
0.2567539811,
-0.3758289814,
0.4014427662,
0.3486966789,
-0.2144654095,
0.04129529,
-0.7547813058,
0.8972794414,
-0.620616138,
0.3436852992,
0.3489440382,
0.3809001744,
0.1511452049,
-0.5205141902,
-0.4749998748,
-0.0410201624,
-0.1246580929,
0.2336716056,
0.3391301036,
0.0796662271,
0.5478817821,
0.4788946807,
-0.3775999248,
-0.5620310903,
-0.4804629385,
0.2259614766,
0.7693516016,
0.2033634037,
0.1930903345,
0.383279264,
0.1079678908,
-0.010895675,
-0.5588567257,
0.1366738975,
0.169425115,
0.4138945043,
0.4131339788,
0.3765874803,
-0.2782693207,
0.8630279899,
-0.0650426522,
0.2463388443,
0.2088861614,
-0.2051188201,
0.0262458734,
-0.0874115899,
0.118207939,
0.1762087345,
0.4986078441,
-0.192248106,
-0.2062224597,
0.101999335,
0.4400641918,
-0.7681147456,
-0.3757602274,
-0.0304193627,
-0.0468402877,
-0.3254330158,
0.2250601202,
-0.6263145804,
-0.1949460059,
-0.8509867191,
0.5406581163,
-0.2982057333,
-0.569206059,
0.5541776419,
-0.1205763444,
0.0990417153,
0.4777017832,
-0.9766743779,
0.558821559,
1.0507011414,
0.5282819271,
0.2868345082,
-0.139500007,
-0.7308579087,
0.0579550192,
-0.6520543694,
0.821485877,
-0.9513363242,
-0.3394984603,
0.1872171462,
-0.1260940731,
-0.1058156639,
-0.7362570763,
0.3944991231,
-0.5598471165,
0.5811038017,
-0.4158454239,
-0.5543863773,
-0.4131788909,
0.3662312031,
-0.4962084591,
1.3305331469,
0.2627191842,
-0.4139932394,
0.3561176658,
-0.9099169374,
-0.3533400297,
0.094421424,
-0.1292658299,
-0.3385276496,
0.4915745556,
0.5843617916,
0.2195816785,
-0.0354757346,
0.0605278313,
-0.5194221735,
-0.3371733427,
0.1812548786,
-0.2643841505,
0.6992428303,
0.003957334,
-0.0761587173,
-0.0993401185,
-0.7843521237,
0.4567710459,
0.0411414653,
0.0801826492,
-0.542834878,
-0.1769042462,
-0.2620398402,
0.261747241,
0.231607303,
-0.7568570375,
0.3505077064,
-0.8074315786,
0.1246996671,
0.636033237,
0.1031034142,
0.3879917562,
-0.453543514,
0.47807464,
-0.0673082024,
0.1904922575,
-0.3500762284,
-0.3245356679,
-0.8450414538,
0.0195251945,
0.014665775,
0.6546126008,
-0.9330701232,
-0.1624778509,
-0.1549999118,
-0.3366527855,
-1.0503964424,
0.4337351024,
0.6420886517,
0.8394904733,
0.694896698,
-0.1317417473,
-0.7339443564,
-0.8044033051,
-0.4748093486,
0.2756719887,
-0.0158140045,
0.369064182,
0.496178031,
0.2022534758,
0.8932834268,
-1.0275132656,
-0.1409281641,
-0.0789787173,
0.1369022429,
0.255969584,
0.6507496238,
0.2658478618,
-0.8471354246,
-0.5353368521,
-0.0190370735,
-0.9228000641,
0.1689892262,
-0.1512774676,
-0.0353438333,
-0.1155901104,
0.4036656618,
-0.2997006476,
0.3286556005,
0.0793439075,
-0.0074666063,
0.5155275464,
-0.3014394045,
0.2813497484,
-0.8085858226,
-0.255977273,
0.1289917529,
-0.2789797187,
-0.831731379,
0.3353942931,
-0.130174458,
-0.1078392118,
-0.2938766181,
0.4287678599,
-0.4523692429,
0.2183087468,
-0.308513701,
0.3368697464,
0.2879161239,
0.2694982588,
0.2716032267,
1.1170605421,
0.6167487502,
-0.4802725315,
0.336748898,
0.3823947012,
-0.5417284369,
0.6213950515,
-0.7249016166,
0.3493188024,
-0.4254966676,
-0.0800912678,
-1.0503816605,
-0.0148943458,
-0.075284563,
-0.5052679777,
0.2663501203,
-0.0942625031,
-0.3474510312,
-0.335144937,
-0.3627918363,
0.5153107643,
0.5294932723,
-0.674326241,
0.5786328316,
0.3100935519,
-0.1717620492,
-0.5814894438,
-0.790045023,
-0.0346531123,
-0.1324586272,
-0.7403495312,
0.0715924352,
-0.0933031589,
-0.4835780263,
-0.2379001081,
-0.0408679098,
-0.21079202,
0.1288675219,
-0.149343878,
0.3204109669,
-0.3309674263,
0.281314224,
0.3287370801,
-0.2914694548,
0.3119941652,
-0.3374186456,
0.3055784702,
-0.3848865926,
-0.4432217181,
-0.2967414558,
0.6694527864,
0.037263304,
-0.660353899,
0.8296816945,
0.4732441604,
-0.4128358662,
-0.4780939221,
-0.726090014,
-0.5471657515,
-0.5228513479,
0.3770138323,
-0.6079399586,
-0.7844693065,
0.5936006308,
-0.1229866073,
0.1157896742,
-0.0132002626,
0.2221676409,
-0.1920466721,
1.6243737936,
0.6275190115,
0.4549822509,
0.5015119314,
-0.5563738942,
0.1700337529,
-1.2121105194,
-0.2259305865,
-0.211561054,
-0.0184538811,
-0.2875530124,
-0.4154182673,
0.3856977522,
-0.0017754842,
-0.2579307258,
0.1425280422,
-0.7453902364,
0.7544865608,
0.3555012941,
0.5602651238,
0.4498976767,
-0.2361463457,
0.143504709,
-0.2951470912,
-0.4505906701,
-0.3980030715,
1.0722347498,
0.0876966417,
0.5025283098,
-0.077359207,
0.6370486021,
-0.2934977114,
0.6133700013,
-0.6114407182,
0.4905198216,
-0.1125883684,
-0.8190335631,
-0.309709847,
-0.3376247585,
-0.543869853,
0.5491073132,
-0.0935390592,
-0.5643411279,
-0.0154339746,
0.0691390634,
-0.4520859122,
0.2229125947,
-0.635489881,
0.684451282,
-0.0351370238,
-0.3800769746,
-0.3482695222,
-0.4789192975,
0.4807612896,
0.0945836604,
0.2800656557,
0.2434593886,
-0.1168812737,
0.3491525948,
-0.3478234112,
0.7147865891,
-0.4531629384,
-0.3171897829,
0.334151268,
0.1865945011,
0.3266122937,
0.2820715606,
-0.0151895313,
-0.3007627726,
0.1493771672,
-0.5430839062,
-1.3704032898,
0.4739072323,
-0.3450417221,
-0.9059724212,
-0.1402982175,
-0.8699332476,
-0.7504133582,
0.1233731806,
-0.2148485333,
0.5227536559,
0.1092810854,
0.0681887344,
1.3163713217,
0.1661374718,
0.1460739672,
0.4762795269,
-0.4276428223,
-0.4032736421,
0.9864413738,
0.1502522081,
0.5212624073,
0.3414729238,
0.1039375663,
-0.333635509,
-0.5060720444,
-0.3221678138,
0.1438999325,
-0.7551214695,
-0.0033804828,
-0.3307746947,
-0.1815814078,
-0.3659980297,
-0.0458199978,
-0.3921972513,
-0.7349780798,
-0.2495085448,
-0.2783733606,
0.3192671835,
0.4218107462,
-0.0037780316,
0.1271368414,
-0.834926486,
0.2331184447,
0.5221550465,
0.4779317677,
0.0799842924,
-0.5850206614,
-0.2426237911,
0.5343220234,
-0.3189424872,
-0.5069045424,
0.1091936603,
0.3418872952,
0.5602642894,
0.3410505652,
-0.0270731747,
0.9186647534,
-0.6706437469,
0.6510667205,
0.021091748,
-0.9738100171,
0.8144975901,
-0.3651134074,
0.2175227106,
0.9851757288,
0.2549476624,
-0.3288125396,
-0.4157695472,
-0.5151725411,
-0.4066532552,
0.4655898511,
-0.1281817257,
0.5483853817,
0.0082987277,
0.6920550466,
0.1562018692,
0.3263556957,
-0.5175731182,
-0.1496627778,
-0.2501856387,
-0.2206861675,
-0.1723635793,
0.1996011138,
-0.444310993,
-0.7906734943,
0.7828375697,
-0.3804008067,
-0.0248578619,
0.2012341022,
-0.1108436361,
-0.1796915382,
-0.0503352582,
0.6786918044,
0.91922158,
-0.0070629437,
0.0677452311,
0.5684034824,
-0.3443584144,
-0.1258036047,
0.0658417195,
-0.0669087693,
-0.1319294125,
0.3684751987,
0.627636373,
0.1679137349,
-0.7350343466,
0.3953584433,
0.1643226594,
-0.3912030458,
-0.2847708762,
0.4297009706,
-0.1389197707,
0.2975582778,
0.430201292,
0.0721517429,
0.3996806741,
-0.5460777283,
0.3346262872,
0.7856513262,
-0.6756006479,
-0.1985787898,
0.4186998904,
-0.2366116494,
-0.2855550051,
0.5071225166,
-0.0039269836,
-0.6827998161,
0.5009073019,
0.6191276312,
0.7003322244,
-0.2092392594,
0.3243890703,
0.3686035872,
0.2144479156,
-0.1301600486,
0.6263597608,
-0.3816242814,
-0.7256737947,
-0.89878124,
-0.1471331716,
-0.414103508,
-0.1466449946,
-1.0931998491,
-0.0558391213,
-0.3831214607,
0.1437832266,
-0.0504480191,
0.1798927635,
-0.365631938,
0.3439815342,
0.0672037974,
0.9224449992,
-0.8719440699,
0.5534796715,
0.7951855659,
-0.6001746058,
-0.7092048526,
-0.2835610509,
-0.3699826002,
-0.9594224691,
0.6147865653,
0.1421897858,
-0.3730886877,
-0.0267296527,
-0.8515719175,
-0.6085679531,
0.6759198904,
0.4360419512,
-0.2169216722,
0.1008667126,
0.2694753408,
0.7246248722,
-0.4264832437,
0.4241131246,
0.6666377187,
0.4843451381,
0.2518773973,
-0.7194220424,
0.0374621674,
-0.3818127215,
0.163040325,
0.3815100193,
-0.5612190962,
0.6186602712,
-0.3332950771,
0.0655037314,
0.0049112383,
0.653419435,
0.1502301991,
0.3105511069,
0.2791092098,
0.7773469687,
0.6574042439,
-0.1782706082,
0.8634675741,
-0.0945214778,
0.4899294376,
1.3188967705,
-0.1328541785,
0.6454264522,
0.6446864009,
-0.2729724348,
0.6827080846,
0.3105237782,
0.0590896048,
0.7525247931,
0.1452503204,
-0.5428457856,
-0.7867158055,
-0.0617813803,
-0.5860423446,
0.2073273063,
0.5369462967,
-0.0366639271,
-0.2780942917,
0.324480623,
-0.2290281057,
0.7461793423,
-0.5120546222,
0.9082021713,
0.2085939646,
-0.8607423306,
0.6648263931,
-0.460973978,
0.2232544869,
-0.223995477,
-0.4248707294,
-0.0189622715,
0.4361296892,
-0.3074359298,
-0.988550663,
0.5467866063,
-0.4118184149,
-0.23358199,
-0.3628029525,
0.4014085233,
-0.6244639158,
-0.745192349,
-0.1152391508,
0.5727683902,
-0.1623044461,
-0.1794601679,
-0.7461730838,
-0.30243963,
-0.1287835985,
-0.0720267445,
0.1757435501,
0.5209796429,
0.3091683686,
0.9002898932,
0.7345622778,
0.0267315675,
-0.067892164,
0.3459740579,
1.1783733368,
-0.2604198456,
-0.2952466607,
-0.7203285098,
0.7285535932,
-0.3921352923,
-0.3142105043,
0.8475337625,
0.6813687086,
0.9564263225,
-0.1771565527,
0.7071405649,
0.5757430792,
0.9693095684,
-0.4959623516,
0.2398450375,
-0.4948516786,
0.3086957037,
-0.4524530768,
-0.7637240887,
-0.6601493955,
0.9863957763,
-0.9294525385,
0.0712477937,
0.4554849565,
0.6937859654,
-0.1638580561,
0.4281716347,
0.1716193557,
-0.1707089394,
0.3753730059,
0.7080233097,
1.1502330303,
-0.5509545803,
0.3087270856,
-0.437496841,
-0.2214394659,
0.3094123304,
-0.5577262044,
-1.1000347137,
-0.5419180989,
-0.3183507621,
-0.3192343116,
0.0686288923,
0.8101120591,
0.8204889297,
-0.8987068534,
-0.0503789522,
-0.4189788997,
0.0068637757,
-0.408454746,
-0.2757917941,
0.1868928224,
-0.8719081283,
-0.6437414885,
0.2437793314,
0.2028732449,
-0.2969407439,
-0.4882616401,
0.1237704381,
-0.2378072143,
0.3204424083,
0.521907568,
0.1102161482,
-0.3546657562,
-0.3578120768,
0.1905335188,
0.4229729772,
0.2435673773,
0.9487905502,
-0.9062235355,
0.7118533254,
0.2109848857,
0.8961097598,
0.7924849987,
0.2613735199,
0.5501928926,
-0.6201821566,
0.094103381,
0.5577462316,
0.0405704975,
0.3017215729,
-0.4067408741,
0.3841278255,
-0.0434928164,
-0.3235247433,
-1.1288918257,
0.4083994031,
-0.5297641158,
-0.3586001992,
0.6626750231,
-0.1386982352,
0.0829547271,
-0.17059879,
-0.3205907941,
0.0666807443,
-0.0758561417,
0.9439154863,
0.8314168453,
-0.3236947954,
-0.44117558,
-0.7339579463,
0.5603367686,
0.7540549636,
-0.9946597219,
0.1428180188,
0.2521143854,
0.2528173625,
0.2285120338,
0.2254244238,
-0.1787966341,
0.4289115071,
-0.1307080984,
-0.42309618,
-0.3237808347,
-0.3971422017,
-0.3224261999,
0.058466915,
-0.1312563419,
-0.0867159292
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12045v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12045v1 | $τ$-bench: A Benchmark for Tool-Agent-User Interaction in Real-World Domains | 2024-06-17T19:33:08 | 2024-06-17T19:33:08 | Shunyu Yao, Noah Shinn, Pedram Razavi, Karthik Narasimhan | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Existing benchmarks do not test language agents on their interaction with
human users or ability to follow domain-specific rules, both of which are vital
for deploying them in real world applications. We propose $\tau$-bench, a
benchmark emulating dynamic conversations between a user (simulated by language
models) and a language agent provided with domain-specific API tools and policy
guidelines. We employ an efficient and faithful evaluation process that
compares the database state at the end of a conversation with the annotated
goal state. We also propose a new metric (pass^k) to evaluate the reliability
of agent behavior over multiple trials. Our experiments show that even
state-of-the-art function calling agents (like gpt-4o) succeed on <50% of the
tasks, and are quite inconsistent (pass^8 <25% in retail). Our findings point
to the need for methods that can improve the ability of agents to act
consistently and follow rules reliably. | [
-0.410605073,
-0.9718640447,
0.4667912722,
0.1087231115,
-0.0800730661,
0.4065762758,
-0.17815575,
-0.6946101785,
0.087266095,
0.1092365161,
-0.5409728885,
-0.3723369539,
-0.1661889553,
-0.0562622659,
-0.2664324343,
0.5770798922,
-0.1185775101,
-0.0833771974,
-0.1099137515,
-0.2683263421,
-0.4436882734,
-0.5778054595,
-0.8794788122,
-0.5598018169,
0.3856391311,
0.099612914,
1.1107106209,
0.4961155653,
0.4117811024,
0.3045903146,
0.348770231,
0.1236394644,
-0.4665390551,
0.2956759334,
-0.2448339909,
-0.4213900268,
-0.7029979825,
0.2261006832,
0.4517702758,
0.4570058286,
-0.2128278166,
-0.044383131,
-0.1844122261,
0.1568195224,
-0.5940600634,
0.3771798313,
-0.382209748,
-0.1734043509,
-0.0233706646,
-0.0845511332,
-0.3370474875,
-0.5933672786,
-0.0272396281,
-0.7996387482,
-0.2003341168,
0.0362007804,
1.2447435856,
0.1765981168,
-0.2602443695,
-0.0326133184,
-0.7010487914,
0.7893813252,
-0.6726216078,
0.434981674,
0.6972581744,
0.634182632,
-0.3772333264,
-0.978484273,
-0.7267269492,
-0.6052676439,
-0.0021165158,
-0.0268037077,
-0.186022222,
-0.0802836195,
0.1936889887,
-0.0505166613,
-0.0780899972,
-0.1334304959,
0.253978312,
-0.031930875,
0.5356398821,
0.240205124,
0.2001082599,
0.3416860104,
-0.3132699728,
-0.6250858307,
-0.5664462447,
0.1656981558,
0.2958896458,
0.2638069391,
-0.0424582586,
0.1895511001,
-0.2375756353,
0.4437268674,
-0.208438158,
-0.1415167004,
0.4046435654,
-0.3511587679,
-0.0123400753,
-0.4052943587,
0.6461110115,
0.4748174548,
0.5189899206,
-0.6390473843,
-0.40699175,
0.1508529186,
0.6523388028,
-0.5922920108,
0.180601269,
0.2211244553,
-0.0543355905,
-0.1502824426,
-0.0098816557,
-0.5866528749,
-0.3096463084,
-0.4052142501,
0.5043151975,
-0.5478611588,
-0.4777286947,
-0.331825614,
-0.075327538,
0.570174396,
0.2559548914,
-0.5176195502,
1.0664805174,
1.0215040445,
0.6532544494,
-0.2374599725,
-0.8095998764,
-0.7028597593,
0.0699495375,
-0.4119473696,
0.7804412842,
-0.6857705116,
-0.5923108459,
0.1839848012,
0.0537078008,
-0.1144677699,
-0.5695214868,
0.6776459813,
-0.3493361473,
-0.4713276327,
-0.7023536563,
-0.5361140966,
0.1761876494,
0.6000316143,
-0.2973415554,
1.2690360546,
0.4844719768,
-0.0536541641,
0.6461969614,
-0.6178089976,
-0.4576975703,
0.1419425756,
-0.3580905795,
-0.2640659809,
-0.2218057513,
-0.1978582442,
0.015373108,
-0.423417449,
0.0653905198,
-0.5117433667,
-0.682032764,
0.5677974224,
-0.2054470181,
0.3390436172,
0.1465348601,
-0.8242284656,
0.0183666125,
-0.6116571426,
0.2690479755,
0.1924949139,
-0.0622334518,
-0.163752839,
0.1020250842,
0.3619410992,
0.0480022952,
0.1297121346,
-0.7069782019,
0.1332126409,
-0.0892398953,
0.0327629931,
0.6905333996,
-0.1937982738,
0.1070092097,
-0.6115474701,
0.5891688466,
-0.4712049067,
0.3041931689,
0.4027808309,
-0.260081321,
-0.4944632649,
-0.2261309028,
0.3377310336,
0.293756336,
-0.5847728848,
0.4576202929,
-0.3869886994,
-0.8525964618,
-0.3279513121,
-0.1159073189,
0.6363207102,
0.5091756582,
0.1946365833,
-0.6452929378,
0.0064020189,
-0.6769369245,
-0.3785721958,
-0.4324087799,
0.2239857614,
0.6724037528,
0.2341315597,
-0.291316241,
1.0922738314,
-0.0846127868,
-0.1442371756,
-0.1168366149,
0.2440862954,
-0.1684583873,
0.3307515085,
0.7090616226,
-0.5834470391,
-0.6146874428,
-0.0629376471,
-0.7876942754,
-0.2795914412,
0.2445853353,
-0.1853220165,
0.2924098074,
0.3665096462,
-0.6628143191,
0.4906494319,
0.1911726147,
-0.397952348,
0.6802358627,
-0.2441341579,
0.3953928351,
-0.549074173,
0.2727650404,
-0.0321294069,
-0.3804503083,
-0.604239583,
0.1815669537,
0.0360030197,
-0.1939930171,
-0.6349084377,
0.9537175894,
-0.2839876413,
-0.5459415913,
-0.3753159046,
0.1213235334,
-0.1443497092,
0.5492251515,
-0.1215544492,
1.0219646692,
0.4115076959,
-0.6372272968,
0.3716493249,
0.236529246,
-0.2978895605,
1.0379667282,
-0.7759771943,
0.235284701,
0.4527107477,
0.3689065278,
-0.8292473555,
0.0832527429,
0.1340221912,
-0.1344450861,
0.0393744037,
-0.0563112125,
-1.0399768353,
-0.2412898391,
-0.3192092478,
0.3670689762,
0.5701806545,
-0.3249698579,
0.6663451195,
0.5133505464,
0.2097720653,
-0.6548914909,
-0.5014804006,
0.1800697744,
0.019705832,
-0.3487641513,
0.1736086607,
-0.0016881168,
-0.3741190732,
0.0994139835,
-0.189915508,
-0.0259000883,
0.2757511735,
0.2413434833,
-0.1252280623,
-0.1055479497,
-0.0135328136,
-0.2399300188,
-0.1434912533,
0.1010003239,
0.1274838746,
0.7220445275,
-0.3473044038,
-0.6801253557,
-0.5753026605,
0.0507234633,
0.6480857134,
-0.1728080958,
0.462892592,
0.4926722646,
-0.2440720648,
-0.1431370676,
-0.5749313235,
-0.4481511712,
-0.5118281245,
0.1021138951,
-0.8958291411,
-0.2863138616,
0.5324082375,
-0.4532741904,
0.3686906993,
0.1068136171,
0.4840999842,
-0.0731575713,
0.8014281392,
0.5023310781,
0.047387749,
0.4555125535,
-0.1234806851,
0.0631406978,
-0.4422509968,
-0.0245887861,
-0.4763652384,
-0.4675593972,
-0.3414842188,
-0.2090353072,
0.2244976014,
-0.1579481214,
-0.3529102206,
0.6594106555,
-0.2993929684,
0.3120687008,
0.6647909284,
-0.1321209818,
0.0737301111,
-0.2808437645,
-0.1983333975,
0.0037720418,
-0.3217155635,
-0.5697792768,
0.9085555077,
0.2401987761,
0.9410821199,
0.4533253312,
0.5311751962,
0.6865457296,
0.4589594901,
-0.598839879,
0.7960010171,
0.2295164168,
-0.4765914381,
-0.453329891,
-0.277970612,
-1.2397755384,
0.3739897609,
-0.0898651779,
-0.9581874609,
0.2437320352,
0.0728446171,
0.007851135,
0.0995668098,
-0.7715435624,
1.2015094757,
-0.3326132596,
-0.5519760251,
-0.3136749268,
-0.3624038696,
-0.1068387255,
-0.0102159744,
0.2074066997,
-0.6866046786,
-0.2320566624,
0.3670066297,
-0.9368088245,
0.8636983037,
-0.4349761903,
0.19944942,
0.3195905387,
0.2117533684,
0.6989665627,
-0.2000155449,
-0.1161752045,
-0.1332455873,
0.4095551372,
-0.5456548333,
-0.6191521883,
0.685392797,
-0.9594705105,
-0.2752461731,
-0.6319547892,
-0.4750241339,
-0.731797874,
0.174392134,
-0.3639303744,
0.504170537,
-0.6966705322,
-0.0566758178,
0.0424171053,
0.1486848295,
0.3222971857,
1.0205688477,
-0.0455550887,
-0.036432717,
0.9059332013,
0.0280020293,
0.2849074304,
0.0671129152,
0.0758847222,
-0.5907422304,
-0.0834209025,
-0.4110876322,
0.3353625536,
-0.6945992112,
-0.0096532237,
-0.4618298709,
0.016471792,
-0.2461875826,
-0.0987845734,
-0.5003265738,
-0.2633198798,
0.3234723508,
0.1526904404,
0.3520522118,
0.4867150486,
0.0767773986,
0.3108361661,
-0.4912126362,
0.1142377406,
0.3029744923,
0.6251773238,
0.0593795963,
-0.2210657299,
-0.2265129536,
-0.1533887386,
-0.334107399,
-0.662296474,
0.0420315191,
0.1728224158,
1.0144326687,
-0.0405751392,
0.3611986339,
0.453312099,
-0.4539545476,
0.5109345317,
-0.2211832404,
-0.8942420483,
0.3333574533,
-0.2955605388,
0.3429172933,
0.9593632221,
0.1818771064,
-0.5521695018,
-0.6517897844,
-0.8672484159,
-0.6944112778,
0.7256850004,
0.3158040047,
0.1005504653,
-0.0512008145,
0.2838552296,
-0.0166124012,
0.3046362996,
-0.2119793594,
-0.3308165371,
-0.1138974354,
-0.0799950361,
-0.0153630292,
0.1318527609,
-0.364091903,
0.1133613959,
0.5835337639,
-0.223651439,
0.1180874258,
-0.0345126539,
-0.1113436818,
-0.1046401858,
0.244353354,
0.4261462688,
1.1481095552,
-0.4519588351,
0.0495049432,
0.0771847144,
-0.4756949246,
0.2148473561,
0.4937172234,
-0.0598858669,
0.0138972579,
-0.1575022787,
0.4409287274,
0.4398006797,
-1.0793782473,
0.4935612082,
-0.4554573894,
-0.1313942969,
-0.4461734593,
0.1036135554,
-0.110126704,
0.1499695629,
0.3056707978,
-0.3415024281,
-0.0852118507,
-0.9882004261,
0.5394507647,
0.3771701157,
-0.5500941873,
-0.3221268952,
0.6369894743,
0.4614822567,
-0.7135340571,
0.2917441428,
-0.421218127,
-0.2045279145,
0.6326149106,
0.3601362109,
0.8006960154,
0.0292666536,
0.1717001498,
0.0248841587,
0.1220970154,
-0.1684215963,
0.4203028679,
-0.1415832192,
-0.6966328025,
-0.1585042775,
-0.3855520785,
-1.1432859898,
-0.0816006362,
-0.4455281794,
0.0771553144,
-0.5377980471,
-0.658413291,
0.133102417,
0.3349784315,
-0.7293673754,
0.0679957494,
-0.2664562464,
1.0260602236,
-0.5152776241,
1.1559302807,
0.7307101488,
-0.5687634349,
-0.5906043649,
-0.15487279,
0.1391265839,
-0.8637094498,
0.3569515944,
0.0339341946,
-0.2938600183,
-0.1463534683,
-0.1618136913,
-0.4794863462,
1.1578941345,
0.3194245994,
-0.2280805558,
0.4484396577,
0.2683830857,
0.7527603507,
-0.2844924927,
0.5121311545,
0.9226866961,
0.6050155163,
-0.0791136101,
-1.1979755163,
0.1655666828,
-0.3844615519,
-0.2805686891,
0.2419854403,
-0.9702767134,
0.5584254265,
0.2970681787,
-0.1334511191,
0.1899719387,
0.4136843979,
0.4066065252,
0.4272645712,
0.9028711319,
0.5218316317,
0.7694355845,
-0.3456051052,
1.4439057112,
-0.5990567803,
0.2121448964,
1.062913537,
-0.7777680159,
0.9714755416,
0.2311507165,
-0.3400557637,
0.4924119413,
0.3935125172,
0.0136368815,
0.4177365005,
0.2851680517,
-0.2956830263,
-0.0327060148,
-0.4123853445,
-0.1507464945,
0.2549067736,
0.2896262109,
0.3979296386,
-0.1082617417,
-0.3343626559,
0.1936009824,
0.3042851388,
0.1273505837,
0.6863618493,
0.1301743388,
-0.8274626732,
0.7208650708,
-0.0387870856,
0.4376142025,
-0.8349856734,
0.0003186078,
-0.3152247965,
0.4329997599,
0.1696024686,
-0.6905891299,
0.0530228578,
-0.0332013741,
0.347745955,
-0.1364408135,
0.537699163,
-0.0588753186,
-0.0868666247,
0.4729242325,
0.7330716848,
0.537609756,
0.1206045821,
-1.0460193157,
0.361156702,
-0.7264894843,
-0.1746159494,
0.471883893,
0.3417291045,
-0.2175747603,
0.8682636619,
0.4657946527,
-0.1107093617,
-0.1434357911,
0.5959974527,
0.6581309438,
-0.6166280508,
-0.5195181966,
-0.3845125437,
0.1436246634,
-0.3950763047,
-0.3988758922,
0.5687101483,
0.5316441655,
0.581669867,
0.3084459305,
0.6190772653,
-0.104970105,
0.6374772191,
0.0809666738,
0.7161594629,
-0.5616011024,
0.1871603876,
-0.1852167845,
-0.9423260093,
0.2251608521,
0.3257030249,
-0.1272956729,
0.3192463219,
0.7148544788,
0.7608805895,
-0.2282399088,
-0.1461339742,
0.5508611202,
-0.0471412055,
0.5033331513,
0.2076212615,
0.8244481683,
-0.3705374599,
0.7765857577,
-0.2618482709,
-0.322023958,
-0.2238779515,
-0.464310348,
-0.6866753101,
-0.3669469357,
-0.2704300284,
-0.5223234296,
0.5082503557,
0.7995060682,
0.8998440504,
-0.6389561296,
-0.5959339142,
0.0151792318,
-0.1508996338,
-0.8786643147,
-0.1901566386,
0.3510915935,
-0.7368400693,
-0.866642952,
0.3892816007,
0.1092845723,
-0.0381809957,
-0.1758471578,
-0.3343007267,
-0.1185716838,
0.2650672495,
0.2672714591,
0.8219097257,
-0.8119860291,
-0.434517622,
-0.0592548028,
-0.5129351616,
0.060700763,
0.7952516675,
-0.7861722708,
0.4169547558,
-0.0108110672,
0.9997781515,
0.6478286386,
0.2110123485,
0.8856525421,
-0.6997794509,
0.0603658408,
0.2378029972,
0.2709982693,
0.2773634195,
0.1450429708,
0.9439167976,
0.2093136609,
-0.6319257021,
-0.7778252959,
0.1208896264,
-1.1087944508,
-0.1688667387,
1.0475157499,
-0.3511967063,
-0.2375597507,
-0.479478687,
-0.1449142247,
-0.0263831299,
-0.7073457241,
0.6255711913,
0.4419483542,
-0.2226456255,
-0.145235613,
-0.5638310313,
0.6559002995,
0.519156754,
-1.0038506985,
0.1853766888,
0.2999074161,
0.1595190614,
0.0136226295,
1.1215583086,
0.0012933322,
0.5704686046,
0.307451427,
0.0622571036,
0.0191590395,
0.1086907238,
0.2276718616,
-0.0351547524,
0.5173282623,
-0.2921845317
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12038v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12038v1 | Soft Prompting for Unlearning in Large Language Models | 2024-06-17T19:11:40 | 2024-06-17T19:11:40 | Karuna Bhaila, Minh-Hao Van, Xintao Wu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | The widespread popularity of Large Language Models (LLMs), partly due to
their unique ability to perform in-context learning, has also brought to light
the importance of ethical and safety considerations when deploying these
pre-trained models. In this work, we focus on investigating machine unlearning
for LLMs motivated by data protection regulations. In contrast to the growing
literature on fine-tuning methods to achieve unlearning, we focus on a
comparatively lightweight alternative called soft prompting to realize the
unlearning of a subset of training data. With losses designed to enforce
forgetting as well as utility preservation, our framework \textbf{S}oft
\textbf{P}rompting for \textbf{U}n\textbf{l}earning (SPUL) learns prompt tokens
that can be appended to an arbitrary query to induce unlearning of specific
examples at inference time without updating LLM parameters. We conduct a
rigorous evaluation of the proposed method and our results indicate that SPUL
can significantly improve the trade-off between utility and forgetting in the
context of text classification with LLMs. We further validate our method using
multiple LLMs to highlight the scalability of our framework and provide
detailed insights into the choice of hyperparameters and the influence of the
size of unlearning data. Our implementation is available at
\url{https://github.com/karuna-bhaila/llm_unlearning}. | [
0.0363436826,
-0.7198810577,
0.4219562709,
-0.1116086319,
-0.3927876055,
-0.1894582063,
-0.7466349006,
0.2103367448,
-0.3701810539,
0.7007257342,
-0.6687093377,
-0.4541378319,
-0.3695099354,
-0.06652987,
-0.2117521167,
1.3385545015,
0.1166399866,
-0.0100125168,
-0.3919450641,
-0.2847370803,
-0.5460037589,
-0.5049212575,
-0.5585657954,
-0.4152006805,
0.6964013577,
0.6906032562,
0.3168208897,
0.5429103971,
-0.1655362695,
0.3431478739,
-0.3026516736,
0.2846764624,
-0.6921257377,
0.4487566948,
-0.3525677621,
-0.4320764244,
-0.1708056778,
0.064075388,
0.726479888,
0.9580181837,
-0.4417020082,
0.3326849043,
0.6074353456,
0.8805855513,
-0.9332331419,
0.2720997632,
-0.9261879325,
-0.0772918537,
-0.1547604352,
-0.4925296605,
-0.8085980415,
-0.1547456086,
0.0122784199,
-0.2545316517,
0.2411560863,
-0.2224153727,
0.5973453522,
0.4133989215,
-0.2954806387,
-0.3855240941,
-0.3845148385,
1.0379830599,
-0.3725716472,
0.391957283,
0.5187348127,
0.0111854626,
-0.1863821894,
-0.7313470244,
-0.3682492077,
-0.1262063533,
0.087660864,
0.1571667343,
-0.0521530211,
0.0204136819,
0.2343745232,
0.2459254712,
-0.1844085455,
0.5088321567,
-0.4009553492,
-0.1366250962,
0.5123620629,
0.056046173,
-0.0170130786,
-0.0213063229,
-0.3920314014,
-0.0298204757,
-1.1842554808,
0.109466657,
0.5253559351,
0.4643450677,
0.1143289953,
0.4405198097,
0.0630106255,
0.2791754603,
0.0462610498,
0.0339803733,
0.3363880515,
0.2968120277,
-0.2333123982,
0.1260846257,
0.6969781518,
0.3319336474,
0.5473999977,
-0.2382384688,
-0.480701685,
-0.3519924581,
0.0793586522,
-0.8198897243,
0.0743436366,
0.1545654535,
-0.5959405899,
-0.1570696533,
-0.0016533118,
-0.6903568506,
-0.5966027975,
-0.3844873309,
0.4763195813,
-0.3409225941,
-0.4101610184,
0.3384248614,
-0.0170627404,
0.0850201324,
0.1007803828,
-1.0179960728,
0.1045485884,
0.6448889375,
0.5662773252,
0.000205138,
-0.5168067813,
-0.8603380919,
-0.0258392561,
-0.1259530038,
0.4419685304,
-0.219764635,
-0.5343960524,
0.3140989542,
0.2722079754,
-0.1945592314,
-0.6529031396,
0.489244014,
-0.458232373,
0.3512136936,
-0.2218095511,
-0.7432620525,
-0.3198117316,
-0.0549506247,
-0.463226974,
0.9063503742,
-0.0877992958,
-0.6178609729,
0.7866925597,
-0.4834657013,
-0.4510591328,
0.242413342,
-0.1420960873,
-0.7541571259,
0.2508360445,
-0.0587888956,
0.8869097233,
-0.1962581575,
0.5934700966,
-0.3847202063,
-0.4835099578,
0.3370445967,
-0.9405733347,
0.9702593088,
0.1944737136,
-0.3986416757,
0.1896459013,
-0.5950078964,
-0.055331666,
0.1974103004,
-0.4675940275,
-0.3853925765,
0.0798534974,
-0.1525589526,
-0.0795806423,
0.2338120937,
-0.3964096606,
0.2606268525,
-0.4239716828,
0.5473659635,
1.2168762684,
-0.029845329,
0.5856305361,
-0.2323317528,
0.2599777281,
0.0077503989,
0.0417844951,
-0.3763221502,
-0.1331845373,
-0.7129024267,
-0.3338139057,
0.3792526722,
0.4120623171,
-0.5836305022,
0.386007905,
-0.0510762781,
-0.2152510285,
-0.5210134983,
0.7495489717,
0.485766083,
0.4241685271,
0.157978341,
0.1198416725,
-0.3609711826,
-0.5666348934,
-0.4043527842,
0.0131054828,
-0.2095912844,
0.4502061605,
0.3459109664,
-0.1741457731,
0.8462741375,
-0.2571511567,
-0.2565219104,
-0.6229147315,
0.0754005462,
0.2945995927,
0.46353212,
0.2782218158,
-0.842707634,
-0.2127873003,
-0.3767524362,
-0.7252754569,
-0.2222016752,
-0.2179944217,
0.2101151347,
0.5130853653,
0.7683609128,
-0.6271220446,
0.4329587221,
0.1736333072,
-0.1270498782,
0.5532049537,
-0.5261438489,
-0.2213585228,
-0.9588404298,
0.1440450996,
-0.1930524409,
-0.076666683,
-0.3922951519,
-0.2013476342,
0.2208774835,
-0.1023112833,
-0.7887414098,
0.7112067342,
-0.6179972291,
0.214114517,
-0.4059310257,
-0.2101831138,
-0.0819338113,
0.6267297268,
0.085950762,
0.7830200195,
0.7001241446,
-1.0226466656,
-0.1541007012,
0.0603226982,
-0.2103447318,
0.369245857,
-0.7021297812,
0.3274741471,
-0.4191706777,
0.2006279826,
-0.6137626171,
-0.0570221469,
-0.0135458801,
-0.2807650566,
0.4091939032,
-0.4760173559,
-0.6444994807,
-0.0629696622,
-0.4134607017,
0.29323861,
0.7249789238,
-0.9263191819,
0.3801815212,
0.3346904516,
-0.1445001811,
-0.6050251722,
-0.4495185018,
-0.0944292322,
-0.6768895984,
-0.1469501257,
0.0539441407,
-0.1210259646,
-0.097253263,
-0.1652694941,
0.0063623586,
-0.00323819,
0.1869674921,
0.485383451,
0.3337637782,
-0.1609745622,
0.3499402106,
0.1016245112,
-0.4593060017,
0.0374780148,
-0.4128763974,
0.438021332,
-0.085977003,
-0.3094708323,
-0.3702423573,
0.2192083746,
0.642179966,
-0.1286494434,
0.9272027612,
0.5200153589,
-0.3996188939,
-0.6086581945,
-0.5063151121,
-0.2628946304,
-0.6535443068,
0.0776938722,
-0.1628253013,
-0.9795820117,
0.2520460188,
-0.3656013608,
0.2772421539,
0.1915026307,
0.7318623066,
0.0016430523,
1.0471537113,
0.7424314618,
-0.1291068941,
0.4279852509,
-0.171752736,
0.038805265,
-0.5182698965,
-0.4176265895,
-0.4314828217,
-0.0491820984,
-0.5012763143,
0.0087394295,
0.2166690081,
0.1631404161,
-0.2592223585,
-0.02908439,
-0.4179730415,
0.8105742335,
0.6425963044,
0.0779413879,
0.0756365955,
0.090014182,
-0.0228421818,
0.0711795688,
-0.7984364629,
-0.4589188695,
1.0024427176,
0.3966532648,
0.8604388237,
-0.062594831,
0.6795396805,
0.2784499228,
0.1534530073,
-0.8865295649,
0.6636381745,
-0.3396046162,
-0.2674966455,
-0.1998607367,
-0.7451115847,
-1.2670732737,
-0.0234745163,
0.0232703555,
-0.818639636,
0.047308933,
0.3048789799,
-0.34407565,
0.4355161786,
-0.8378741741,
0.7352969646,
-0.2610723972,
-0.4846267998,
-0.1534363031,
-0.3987763226,
0.1665361673,
0.0023934434,
-0.0203868225,
-0.1270688772,
-0.0064433045,
0.8343780637,
-0.4294252992,
1.2588354349,
-0.4395551682,
-0.0973303989,
0.3497637808,
0.1107128263,
0.4309761226,
0.1407240033,
-0.2572496533,
0.0880576968,
-0.2238936573,
-0.3838406503,
-0.3554458916,
0.6462675333,
-0.4164209068,
-0.4957073927,
-0.3266742229,
-0.5477112532,
-0.2928415835,
0.3709480762,
0.487682879,
0.4574111104,
0.1139002666,
0.5244176984,
0.9840637445,
-0.4155471325,
0.5169190168,
0.8044900298,
0.1403731555,
-0.0728627816,
1.2172619104,
0.1246893108,
0.0841895342,
0.1401497722,
0.5631539226,
-0.66558218,
-0.5987336636,
-0.4582338333,
0.1687813401,
-0.6570764184,
-0.484886229,
-0.4156708121,
-0.1354317516,
-0.3156366944,
-0.2892584503,
-0.2178657055,
-0.1065136716,
-0.5406742096,
-0.2186923325,
0.5822361708,
0.7978675365,
0.0271411221,
0.3063858449,
-0.8192474246,
-0.1412642747,
0.1461259574,
0.5863012671,
0.0430368781,
-0.7235360146,
-0.1324268878,
-0.1685099453,
-0.0945513919,
-0.3704940975,
0.2708440423,
0.3341422975,
0.6197858453,
0.5809744596,
0.3050432801,
0.3403475285,
-0.5208961368,
0.4534260929,
0.2442388386,
-0.9109573364,
0.3968359828,
-0.4945641756,
0.3044659495,
0.9674161673,
0.3267481923,
-0.5371692777,
-0.133398816,
-0.7594342828,
-1.2296802998,
0.6194428205,
-0.4023885429,
0.4517782331,
0.0051193596,
0.5308552384,
0.5290281773,
0.4195581377,
-0.5121977329,
-0.1152525544,
0.1143253595,
-0.3339557648,
-0.0032496052,
-0.444968164,
0.1611976922,
-0.0994177237,
0.6753150225,
-0.1541278809,
-0.2590180337,
-0.229494065,
-0.4916278124,
0.0322411507,
0.3946766257,
0.089832969,
0.5051637292,
0.0617221333,
0.2113170177,
0.4953956604,
-0.3810921013,
0.0716047585,
-0.1979038268,
-0.3674882054,
-0.2536566854,
0.1070640981,
0.5166044831,
0.5666571856,
-0.8777695894,
0.608618319,
0.1098060459,
-0.3980284929,
-0.1660839617,
0.1779825389,
-0.0884601325,
-0.1130132601,
0.3020237684,
-0.2861916125,
0.0100079421,
-0.4563307762,
0.4887925386,
0.2274247855,
-0.4790793061,
-0.1849995703,
0.4732681215,
0.2559533417,
-0.2268136591,
0.8163394928,
-0.3379301727,
-0.5249724984,
0.2382156998,
0.5446738601,
0.8391156793,
-0.1838677377,
0.1352157295,
0.0908382237,
0.0207837541,
-0.279979825,
0.0947948024,
-0.2140991092,
-0.4280355573,
-0.4096531272,
-0.5708975792,
-0.3462586999,
0.4440529943,
-0.6294252276,
0.2426751852,
-0.6413294077,
0.2000002712,
-0.2119533718,
-0.0216758773,
-0.5104552507,
-0.0151130995,
0.0587584935,
0.9229688644,
-0.7600536346,
0.5916879177,
0.5101544261,
-0.3666983247,
-0.7692520022,
-0.026191961,
0.3926564157,
-0.9260668159,
0.4029823244,
0.4234518409,
-0.2931511998,
-0.0659632459,
-0.5971619487,
-0.2023661435,
0.857565999,
0.6110928059,
-0.5465941429,
0.3074036837,
0.0547755994,
0.0374474674,
0.0448572226,
0.0368334092,
0.4967786372,
0.1811312586,
-0.0573541522,
-0.6322630644,
0.1800740361,
-0.144477278,
-0.5204113126,
0.3361564577,
-0.6926560402,
0.7258762717,
-0.3354352415,
-0.3595537543,
0.0373554043,
0.4778483212,
0.2507376373,
0.5821437836,
0.9046403766,
0.1913751215,
1.0124228001,
0.1071335971,
0.6971760392,
-0.0299630854,
0.3800926507,
0.9739441872,
-0.362724483,
0.6816052794,
0.3957446218,
0.1593323201,
0.1636815667,
0.5960067511,
0.11207816,
0.342271179,
0.3694376945,
-0.454169482,
-0.2131253034,
-0.2855219543,
-0.0928483084,
0.4645265043,
0.3657664061,
-0.1904984713,
-0.3288538456,
0.2378279567,
0.4052678347,
0.0601263717,
-0.4738382101,
0.9037684798,
0.3113123477,
-0.5961825848,
0.5556833148,
-0.1429686546,
0.8132431507,
-0.7273917198,
0.0457679667,
-0.1906618774,
0.5685496926,
-0.1853147745,
-0.7230141759,
0.0188481305,
0.2687968314,
-0.2123362273,
-0.692599833,
0.7830955982,
-0.6215916276,
-0.3065113425,
0.2814459205,
0.5203611851,
0.2581593692,
-0.0802127793,
-0.8933752179,
-0.1338377446,
-0.1143895537,
-0.3879886866,
0.6793010235,
0.7550804615,
0.0268312711,
0.7723680735,
0.8446142077,
-0.0200975481,
-0.3967279494,
0.6097666621,
0.7770812511,
-0.5947006345,
-0.6196669936,
-0.9771007895,
0.4228906333,
0.1220193282,
-0.417822212,
0.8301920295,
0.4757838845,
0.6400724053,
0.2188264877,
0.6854116321,
0.320243001,
0.4259964824,
-0.8769884706,
1.0267561674,
-0.6799041629,
0.3998999596,
-0.0428632386,
-0.5466281772,
-0.1107461154,
0.1573256701,
-0.2189127058,
0.2662540376,
0.4367052019,
0.7114277482,
-0.1908411235,
-0.0394643433,
0.3248457313,
0.0191048216,
0.0250743032,
0.3636054695,
0.8720932007,
0.2490345538,
0.6401780844,
0.046279978,
-0.3009774387,
-0.2872306705,
-0.9763071537,
-0.9168234468,
-0.5930413008,
-0.2055308074,
-0.5149302483,
0.2422910333,
1.0209025145,
0.6516595483,
-0.6570963264,
-0.19444637,
-0.1104462072,
0.176873669,
-0.1749631464,
-0.2112606913,
0.6210666299,
-0.6370951533,
-0.521658659,
0.4601727426,
0.1764980704,
0.0300261062,
-0.239222154,
-0.1371894032,
0.1496302783,
-0.0635739416,
0.5132861733,
0.5479427576,
-0.1576214433,
-0.0493250079,
-0.064370431,
0.2468109131,
-0.2495341599,
1.193782568,
-0.7894823551,
0.0356372334,
0.2836488187,
0.8942331076,
0.2601881027,
-0.2464260161,
0.5995208621,
-1.1055227518,
0.3196287155,
0.2173700482,
0.5910155177,
0.3737437427,
-0.5911905766,
0.1853555143,
0.0244406108,
-0.6689081788,
-1.1192032099,
0.0776697546,
-0.5363022089,
-0.4712766409,
1.2751921415,
-0.1108669639,
-0.4914622009,
-0.265539974,
-0.2109137326,
0.1386766732,
-0.6292636991,
0.7269025445,
0.361000061,
0.2519312203,
-0.0835664347,
-0.4996603131,
0.5923461914,
0.7484331727,
-0.5164557695,
0.817982018,
0.3481914997,
0.4780994952,
-0.367508024,
0.6430458426,
0.0193149708,
0.4454447925,
-0.2525632381,
-0.2027920932,
-0.30734694,
-0.5463115573,
-0.6897589564,
0.0518102907,
0.0336666331,
-0.2829308808
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12036v4 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12036v4 | MedCalc-Bench: Evaluating Large Language Models for Medical Calculations | 2024-06-17T19:07:21 | 2024-06-30T15:12:10 | Nikhil Khandekar, Qiao Jin, Guangzhi Xiong, Soren Dunn, Serina S Applebaum, Zain Anwar, Maame Sarfo-Gyamfi, Conrad W Safranek, Abid A Anwar, Andrew Zhang, Aidan Gilson, Maxwell B Singer, Amisha Dave, Andrew Taylor, Aidong Zhang, Qingyu Chen, Zhiyong Lu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | As opposed to evaluating computation and logic-based reasoning, current
benchmarks for evaluating large language models (LLMs) in medicine are
primarily focused on question-answering involving domain knowledge and
descriptive reasoning. While such qualitative capabilities are vital to medical
diagnosis, in real-world scenarios, doctors frequently use clinical calculators
that follow quantitative equations and rule-based reasoning paradigms for
evidence-based decision support. To this end, we propose MedCalc-Bench, a
first-of-its-kind dataset focused on evaluating the medical calculation
capability of LLMs. MedCalc-Bench contains an evaluation set of over 1000
manually reviewed instances from 55 different medical calculation tasks. Each
instance in MedCalc-Bench consists of a patient note, a question requesting to
compute a specific medical value, a ground truth answer, and a step-by-step
explanation showing how the answer is obtained. While our evaluation results
show the potential of LLMs in this area, none of them are effective enough for
clinical settings. Common issues include extracting the incorrect entities, not
using the correct equation or rules for a calculation task, or incorrectly
performing the arithmetic for the computation. We hope our study highlights the
quantitative knowledge and reasoning gaps in LLMs within medical settings,
encouraging future improvements of LLMs for various clinical calculation tasks. | [
-0.1254877597,
-0.6931762695,
1.1926929951,
0.296620369,
-0.1051794365,
-0.1249360293,
-0.3694680929,
-0.2398169339,
-0.0492852964,
0.3914113045,
-0.4625399411,
-0.7681150436,
-0.6575661898,
0.1218819246,
-0.2184176445,
0.5665224195,
-0.0802182481,
0.8002517819,
-0.6128386259,
-0.3555579782,
-0.3922800124,
-0.5066167712,
-0.6556236148,
-0.4734184146,
0.5175444484,
0.3139271736,
0.6793923974,
0.3640881777,
0.8951917887,
0.2573438287,
0.1944541186,
0.309905678,
-0.3284544349,
0.0072663771,
-0.2560014129,
-0.6107936502,
-0.5763661861,
-0.0030825622,
0.5549271703,
1.0657584667,
-0.2713436484,
0.0476135574,
-0.6349798441,
0.7936199903,
-0.6426214576,
0.4058909416,
-0.3392722309,
0.0760789663,
-0.1057377681,
-0.1970778555,
-0.4779564142,
-0.7411369681,
-0.0373347402,
-0.4158581197,
-0.0304386001,
-0.0555812269,
0.4391442537,
0.3060518205,
-0.2730049789,
-0.2099064291,
-0.4439245462,
0.7588428259,
-0.8074031472,
0.3598541617,
0.7790054679,
0.7808773518,
-0.3372297585,
-0.7161489129,
-0.2699886262,
-0.486438632,
0.1104159355,
0.145385474,
-0.0923185423,
0.070979245,
0.3578879535,
0.3308699429,
-0.5457565188,
0.2207966447,
-0.314043045,
-0.0641672164,
0.6663814187,
0.5758066177,
0.245250091,
0.0444778949,
-0.1276753992,
-0.0491103381,
-0.8992210031,
-0.2582418919,
-0.6063418388,
-0.0150183719,
-0.2216496319,
0.6354840398,
0.0686522648,
0.7158626914,
-0.2193871588,
-0.3362115026,
0.1775656939,
-0.2684825063,
-0.2458247095,
0.1208536923,
0.8272494674,
0.6355511546,
0.3102101088,
-0.1855285019,
-0.1294893622,
0.1640390456,
0.3441980481,
-0.8951407075,
-0.0338166207,
0.1968339533,
-0.4901275039,
-0.3267962635,
-0.3753846288,
-0.446143657,
-0.7039400935,
-0.3842290044,
0.1491959542,
-0.4503148794,
0.079850316,
0.1515873075,
0.2578109205,
-0.1159885824,
0.4514552653,
-0.3996821642,
0.7096375823,
0.5131242871,
0.6340587139,
-0.0750988573,
-0.0557089895,
-0.3869835734,
-0.3097658455,
-0.4992320538,
0.9410396218,
-0.43203637,
-0.509850502,
-0.0202573761,
0.0816286281,
-0.1571001112,
-0.9602556825,
0.7486389279,
-0.2195297182,
-0.1427661777,
-0.3868676424,
-0.6987370849,
0.1052402034,
0.2031608075,
-0.7169311047,
0.7122522593,
0.4025759399,
-0.4521782994,
0.3165821731,
-0.5356017351,
-0.4254134893,
0.1091605127,
-0.5912107825,
-0.2586475909,
0.1444577724,
0.2638073862,
0.2488458157,
-1.1674948931,
0.5002243519,
-0.2936273813,
-0.2488007247,
0.7373946905,
-0.3312472105,
0.5209691525,
0.3583984077,
-0.0871824771,
-0.1275328249,
-0.7771615386,
0.2937175035,
0.1045026183,
-0.2363200635,
-0.2645341754,
0.1230940223,
-0.072144933,
0.3107147217,
0.0579299778,
-0.5460976958,
0.0306987278,
-0.3911100328,
0.3188014925,
0.4776738286,
0.0037839557,
0.0625817701,
-0.6399970651,
0.5456796885,
-0.2327300906,
0.1665775329,
0.0455229543,
-0.2583651245,
-0.2680653334,
-0.375993073,
0.4765217304,
0.529317677,
-0.4418376684,
0.1234093681,
-0.1851388216,
-0.5701221228,
-0.523152411,
-0.2544948757,
0.5818035007,
0.7732735276,
0.2445241809,
-0.0332898535,
-0.4891445339,
-1.0968908072,
-0.2562333047,
-0.0958374664,
-0.0030695666,
0.6976866722,
0.3491303921,
-0.2533236444,
0.8610191941,
-0.5208078027,
-0.2567548752,
-0.0708295777,
-0.0012510782,
0.365360707,
0.3321936429,
0.7132065892,
-0.467620641,
-0.2190436572,
0.1193746626,
-1.0563294888,
-0.5790745616,
0.0894532725,
-0.0001967988,
0.0139772939,
0.545614779,
-0.5640615225,
0.4760844409,
0.4833585322,
-0.0868473947,
0.7007471919,
-0.4274042249,
0.5930861235,
-0.6969967484,
0.2343529463,
0.061461851,
-0.2747656107,
-0.2726466358,
-0.054020986,
0.3079743981,
-0.0348495431,
-0.2684040964,
0.7023135424,
-0.0627504587,
0.0447543971,
-0.2024193406,
0.244072482,
-0.1140002608,
0.0134801371,
-0.2037505805,
0.7774264812,
0.2364606708,
-0.3881498575,
0.3413955271,
0.1053595766,
-0.60461694,
0.719635129,
-0.6055255532,
0.0012581281,
0.0420704596,
0.2411860973,
-0.8023099303,
-0.1788692772,
-0.2765369415,
-0.3104219735,
0.1835517436,
-0.0110437414,
-0.7686818242,
-0.6343283057,
-0.1091925353,
0.8594546318,
0.280706495,
-0.2557574511,
0.3430740833,
0.5820522904,
-0.3005799949,
-0.3158723414,
-0.7184842229,
0.0424522087,
0.2010215074,
-0.6754422188,
0.2705265582,
-0.1678225398,
-0.4915510416,
-0.1616204381,
-0.105789654,
-0.3171387613,
-0.1132602245,
0.4082987607,
0.4218327105,
-0.2006903738,
0.3616789281,
0.0185043998,
-0.1278649122,
0.4640173912,
0.1205030531,
0.5530740619,
-0.1943597943,
-0.7273916006,
-0.3094892204,
0.2713275254,
0.9750166535,
-0.2208556533,
0.6245213151,
0.0639000759,
-0.7761441469,
0.1219325066,
-0.9855633378,
-0.0437039845,
-0.316896826,
0.5758504272,
-0.3410033882,
-0.6003292203,
0.5814529657,
-0.4185441732,
0.0711839423,
0.4820083082,
0.9650292397,
0.014136523,
1.3351984024,
0.0834231228,
0.2459787726,
-0.1033952683,
0.0118172271,
0.048202455,
-0.6497171521,
-0.4157671928,
-0.5782729983,
-0.1322274208,
-0.2789639831,
-0.6786293387,
0.7141819,
-0.3861712813,
-0.2812191844,
-0.0211738292,
-0.1403797865,
0.3553759456,
-0.0029170192,
0.4608314037,
0.2068987489,
-0.1646413356,
-0.7029299736,
-0.2293619215,
-0.5647261739,
-0.3338697851,
1.3268239498,
0.286942184,
0.9402987957,
-0.0531972349,
0.432425946,
0.4396752417,
0.6128019691,
-0.9327487946,
0.634790659,
-0.386680305,
-0.5652810931,
0.0432552472,
-0.71462816,
-0.8776185513,
0.2309159189,
-0.1522575766,
-0.4964386821,
-0.1628213525,
-0.2354191691,
-0.3721970618,
0.1187204272,
-0.7923637629,
0.8373372555,
-0.4836758673,
-0.3691150546,
-0.4284959435,
-0.4102215171,
0.2996887267,
-0.3586555421,
0.6159723997,
-0.2403125912,
-0.0787656456,
0.6188156009,
-0.8094649911,
0.5641836524,
-0.1882850081,
0.025730988,
-0.0074586556,
0.2619257569,
0.1197883785,
0.1194095016,
-0.3439232409,
-0.1711824685,
0.5392974615,
-0.3855323792,
-0.7445452809,
0.7877029181,
-0.5542422533,
-0.319874078,
-0.4977886081,
-0.7463493347,
-0.6935161948,
0.1562158465,
-0.1298503131,
0.6157574058,
-0.5365205407,
0.1944954693,
0.3111717403,
-0.246140182,
-0.1099090725,
0.9165231586,
-0.3212580085,
-0.5769729018,
0.3874735534,
0.0187857822,
0.2248501629,
0.2065909654,
0.4354566634,
-0.3409129977,
-0.5725857615,
-0.3625216782,
0.491764605,
-0.7951353788,
-0.2820139229,
-0.3970710635,
-0.2871557772,
-0.1221278161,
-0.082923755,
-0.3861127496,
-0.3470802307,
0.2631757855,
0.1436386704,
0.2945692837,
0.5170248151,
0.0916499868,
0.075983271,
-0.8510729074,
0.2665396035,
-0.0174258463,
0.4848136604,
-0.1577893347,
-0.358229816,
-0.2999949157,
0.0652568191,
-0.0142208589,
-0.7275875807,
0.3766239882,
0.0086203152,
0.6495540142,
0.2865152061,
-0.0925945267,
0.7226677537,
-0.7245031595,
0.2726554871,
0.5193052292,
-0.503247261,
0.409894675,
-0.0642303601,
0.4877558947,
0.8206374645,
0.2034047395,
-0.4840934873,
-0.0403207131,
-0.3620552123,
-0.4298403561,
0.6194976568,
0.0996109471,
-0.4037424922,
-0.127962485,
0.4086513519,
0.0360298902,
0.1003268585,
-0.1342142671,
-0.1499884725,
0.4593803883,
-0.525826335,
-0.1048051715,
-0.0431577489,
-0.4530754089,
-0.5612893701,
0.2791289687,
-0.1304650158,
0.1739080697,
0.3000834584,
-0.1395613253,
-0.2989064157,
0.315297991,
0.648930788,
1.1456843615,
-0.3306604624,
0.1352656037,
0.5110793114,
-0.7015685439,
-0.1244688034,
0.3137572408,
0.2524328232,
-0.0605645105,
0.1991178095,
0.3241197169,
0.6270967722,
-1.2717087269,
0.6981196404,
-0.3635216951,
-0.3753814399,
-0.3911326528,
-0.1904996186,
0.1314981878,
0.1113914102,
0.0665846094,
0.196900934,
0.0559504479,
-0.5362684131,
0.2813192904,
0.322045207,
-0.3793102503,
0.0585135408,
0.4504662454,
-0.0480273068,
-0.1506923735,
0.6109603643,
0.2572709918,
-0.3162027299,
0.7916357517,
0.7493767142,
0.4375646114,
-0.1251024753,
-0.0559382029,
0.3984526098,
0.1602648795,
-0.0278995596,
0.339727968,
0.1952008605,
-0.3917383254,
-0.4903292954,
-0.5568830371,
-0.5975549221,
0.1083367243,
-0.5457492471,
0.3140602112,
-0.6438989639,
-0.4907935262,
0.2713303566,
0.0016464945,
-0.703111589,
0.3509485722,
0.1623267978,
1.0958909988,
-0.4331004322,
0.709713459,
0.6981753707,
-0.1989228278,
-0.6987146735,
-0.6145785451,
0.09584333,
-1.0412372351,
0.5335549116,
0.0105958637,
-0.1272316426,
-0.5173727274,
-0.5148021579,
-0.4507716298,
1.0465335846,
0.5783447027,
-0.6018180251,
-0.0042010257,
0.3464848101,
0.6860705018,
-0.5740261674,
0.6015708447,
0.8291243315,
0.460567385,
0.1540251225,
-1.3150525093,
0.1780167669,
-0.4413249195,
-0.3761745393,
0.2842792869,
-0.3598339856,
0.8822526336,
-0.3589741886,
0.096901387,
0.2300830781,
-0.1976064444,
0.5236070156,
0.5952896476,
0.3267212212,
0.7055505514,
0.8719314933,
-0.2169265747,
1.3235223293,
-0.3817811608,
0.2390151918,
0.9134575725,
-0.5905869007,
0.6742369533,
0.2231647372,
-0.6435299516,
0.3651167452,
0.4457970262,
0.037936043,
0.2554454207,
0.5493738055,
-0.4139325023,
-0.4755673707,
-0.1705483794,
-0.4797421992,
0.205324769,
0.7468758225,
-0.6608800888,
-0.3267011642,
-0.1928258091,
0.1878090799,
0.1235241592,
-0.3957411051,
0.5467897654,
0.3928914368,
-0.7112258077,
0.9268925786,
0.0476366915,
-0.1046131253,
-0.7636927366,
-0.1819148511,
-0.0816022009,
0.4886255264,
-0.3980659544,
-0.7402088642,
-0.019982025,
0.1839936227,
-0.1733298004,
0.1909515262,
0.5786159039,
-0.0789217576,
-0.6390945315,
0.1535176039,
0.6052415371,
0.3573883772,
-0.1177307516,
-0.6047177315,
0.0083348183,
-0.2872137129,
0.3307263851,
0.4270817637,
0.3876104355,
-0.1848757863,
0.8025580049,
0.6202964783,
0.1098234802,
-0.1306315213,
0.7172537446,
1.0078961849,
-0.6550137997,
-0.0660386384,
-0.7634171844,
0.0273202229,
-0.0004235188,
-0.1825731993,
0.2011168599,
0.7139667273,
0.0944824889,
0.0082500512,
0.5535361171,
0.1620032191,
0.5829425454,
-0.4947316349,
0.8389260769,
-0.6494142413,
0.2658926845,
-0.021110896,
-0.5555590987,
-0.4938616157,
0.561065793,
-0.6394789219,
0.0506633259,
1.1459364891,
0.6336519718,
0.0968498588,
0.3166850209,
0.4323054552,
0.364161998,
0.2093016356,
0.8882536292,
0.7052133083,
-0.2706058621,
0.2851331532,
-0.2083517313,
-0.6765965223,
-0.1930939853,
-0.5641878247,
-0.8613157868,
-0.1921995431,
-0.0912824869,
-0.4046183228,
0.0560991615,
1.1758726835,
0.7243664265,
-0.8646327257,
-0.3347511292,
0.0001241056,
-0.2400235683,
-0.0985799283,
-0.1300819516,
0.5476392508,
-0.2907382548,
-0.3698709607,
0.5458703041,
0.3350424469,
-0.3633230031,
-0.1226321161,
-0.0052583385,
-0.1442221701,
0.0485259071,
0.6651780605,
0.20285514,
-0.6076142192,
0.1745337248,
0.1551333368,
-0.4249992967,
0.1818941534,
1.0063595772,
-1.0150252581,
0.6228042841,
0.1690827012,
0.7717657685,
0.5758304,
-0.1303658783,
0.5791575909,
-0.0802407488,
-0.083731927,
0.5421154499,
0.6372705102,
0.0912258625,
0.0679769665,
0.5061932206,
0.1470766664,
-0.757471621,
-0.717517674,
-0.0862685218,
-1.0841240883,
-0.2018426061,
0.8945671916,
-0.1129162088,
-0.4030139148,
-0.0375250541,
-0.4167481363,
0.0530591719,
-0.1885527968,
0.6641695499,
0.5512537956,
-0.2975985706,
0.0672619492,
-0.9853321314,
0.2449792624,
0.6046048999,
-1.0067511797,
0.0371093303,
0.6295141578,
0.3492394686,
-0.0753167197,
0.6249661446,
-0.7722379565,
0.7136784196,
-0.0961652473,
-0.1310647428,
0.0516239032,
0.0576891229,
0.0025454129,
0.08056885,
0.1801286191,
0.1230700091
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12034v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12034v1 | Self-MoE: Towards Compositional Large Language Models with Self-Specialized Experts | 2024-06-17T19:06:54 | 2024-06-17T19:06:54 | Junmo Kang, Leonid Karlinsky, Hongyin Luo, Zhen Wang, Jacob Hansen, James Glass, David Cox, Rameswar Panda, Rogerio Feris, Alan Ritter | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | We present Self-MoE, an approach that transforms a monolithic LLM into a
compositional, modular system of self-specialized experts, named MiXSE (MiXture
of Self-specialized Experts). Our approach leverages self-specialization, which
constructs expert modules using self-generated synthetic data, each equipped
with a shared base LLM and incorporating self-optimized routing. This allows
for dynamic and capability-specific handling of various target tasks, enhancing
overall capabilities, without extensive human-labeled data and added
parameters. Our empirical results reveal that specializing LLMs may exhibit
potential trade-offs in performances on non-specialized tasks. On the other
hand, our Self-MoE demonstrates substantial improvements over the base LLM
across diverse benchmarks such as knowledge, reasoning, math, and coding. It
also consistently outperforms other methods, including instance merging and
weight merging, while offering better flexibility and interpretability by
design with semantic experts and routing. Our findings highlight the critical
role of modularity and the potential of self-improvement in achieving
efficient, scalable, and adaptable systems. | [
-0.5239217877,
-0.6892952919,
0.4995174706,
0.3572759032,
0.1798511893,
0.2298208028,
-0.4034211636,
-0.391536057,
0.6806899905,
0.6381005645,
-0.5344188809,
-0.3608502448,
-0.4891055524,
0.0556835085,
-0.3599374592,
0.6477968693,
0.2512806356,
-0.0806096643,
-0.2266620398,
0.0234053079,
-0.6400463581,
-0.4294194281,
-0.3602616787,
-0.2305689007,
0.5717878938,
0.563557744,
0.4857174456,
0.7495889068,
0.1713641882,
0.3997841477,
0.3255467415,
0.1946407557,
-0.4557921886,
0.3787541389,
-0.5102981925,
-0.5031909347,
-1.0068116188,
-0.1722085923,
0.5456439257,
0.730866909,
-0.1891276836,
-0.0290856995,
0.0118355379,
0.6511321068,
-0.583914876,
0.0671167523,
-0.7125117183,
0.1036032736,
-0.3540183902,
-0.0412335955,
-0.3620569408,
0.3720277548,
0.1046191528,
-0.4862035215,
-0.0414981097,
-0.0398247354,
-0.1323549002,
0.4733705819,
-0.4297774434,
-0.1297287345,
-0.5447692871,
0.9232541323,
-0.9734489322,
0.3979984522,
0.1476158649,
0.2506795824,
-0.316444993,
-0.4223531485,
-0.3266972005,
-0.0173926335,
0.1465766877,
0.386121273,
0.0385349877,
-0.0197763313,
-0.2146861851,
0.5145266652,
-0.4454886913,
0.3632847369,
-0.4357281923,
-0.1896487027,
1.0697948933,
0.3341861665,
0.4945904016,
-0.1339533925,
-0.3833786249,
0.3821826279,
-0.5962385535,
-0.2360771298,
0.3614577651,
0.0572490953,
0.1094030216,
0.619564116,
-0.4634549916,
0.627561152,
0.2959462106,
-0.1268634349,
0.0649886876,
-0.2128728479,
-0.1645795256,
-0.001794113,
0.99165833,
-0.02951614,
0.1868696362,
-0.4400486648,
-0.3284386992,
-0.4417364597,
0.4665367603,
-0.3813233972,
-0.6282911301,
0.2397613227,
-0.3759096563,
-0.2058983296,
-0.1922572851,
-0.6843069196,
0.0303996652,
-0.4666767716,
0.6204973459,
-0.3681107759,
-0.4929371178,
0.2315324992,
0.121027559,
-0.1798440963,
0.4108467102,
-1.3220251799,
0.3532861173,
0.6645588279,
0.6283336282,
-0.6731240153,
-0.5354355574,
-0.0562612079,
0.6352434158,
-0.457378,
0.6946167946,
-0.5676879883,
-0.6734137535,
-0.4339645505,
-0.4920496643,
-0.0933720693,
-0.7125672102,
0.1240238175,
-0.4694587886,
0.0845293328,
0.0513597317,
-0.7326304913,
-0.0794459656,
0.2302910089,
-0.4263527393,
1.072460413,
0.1545525342,
-0.4433424473,
-0.0425474197,
-0.7196347117,
-0.7169608474,
0.1303913295,
-0.2895889878,
0.2192730755,
0.3810633421,
0.2136899531,
0.7038571835,
-0.1140048057,
0.2118939012,
-0.433021754,
0.1119900644,
0.2300845385,
-0.2789469361,
0.4797427356,
0.339166671,
-0.2020344436,
0.1528538465,
-0.77512604,
0.1648623645,
-0.1503370106,
-0.602016151,
-0.435603261,
0.2376201451,
-0.3364844918,
0.1129177511,
0.8296449184,
-0.3828072846,
0.5238070488,
-0.3171656728,
0.4012992084,
1.1322411299,
-0.3710353673,
0.8118412495,
-0.2614074051,
0.3983678222,
0.1288813204,
0.1464401186,
-0.3988908529,
-0.61247015,
-1.0817489624,
-0.6405485868,
0.1448024064,
0.3256947398,
-0.559166193,
0.7388681769,
-0.3021893799,
-0.4592366517,
-0.5312795043,
0.5309992433,
0.189899236,
0.5669459105,
0.6266020536,
-0.381480515,
-0.3565552235,
-1.2843621969,
-0.1578229964,
-0.0356123745,
0.1011479571,
0.0750032589,
0.1699274033,
-0.5284966826,
1.255625844,
-0.5439295769,
-0.2271826118,
-0.1972100586,
0.0645020232,
0.0948646218,
0.8126959801,
0.3354085386,
-0.3677590489,
-0.7142361999,
0.2158940732,
-0.9183908105,
-0.2597924173,
0.1404050142,
-0.3200508952,
-0.0093246195,
0.4986746311,
-0.4802669287,
-0.1524755657,
0.6456728578,
-0.0238185264,
0.6045529246,
-0.3572896421,
-0.1400659978,
-1.2962657213,
-0.320453316,
-0.2576800287,
-0.2736288607,
-0.6844246387,
0.2558509111,
0.0186921209,
0.0625091791,
-0.0976365656,
0.7077303529,
-0.5352469087,
-0.09401346,
-0.3223320842,
-0.2892029881,
-0.321113646,
0.4866944849,
-0.1579390764,
0.9335033894,
0.9642502069,
-0.679843843,
0.4641281068,
-0.0279315952,
-0.1392666548,
0.6008650661,
-0.6053251028,
0.1603537202,
0.062173795,
-0.0423175544,
-0.8744624257,
-0.4588696361,
0.1745808423,
-0.2390116602,
0.3817330003,
-0.089431949,
-0.461102128,
-0.1503623277,
0.0073758173,
0.5626541376,
0.5470100641,
-0.2080360651,
1.0782395601,
0.4743435681,
-0.4876756072,
-0.4001308382,
-0.9430690408,
0.2952285111,
-0.047914546,
-0.9217574596,
0.2567840517,
-0.5240180492,
-0.0870000497,
0.0439007394,
-0.1087562144,
-0.2293770015,
0.2173856348,
-0.0077586984,
-0.1509090662,
-0.5257416964,
0.2916695476,
0.4338643849,
-0.2682613134,
0.1570131928,
-0.5605313182,
0.4143672884,
-0.0214599948,
-0.7078946829,
-0.3828140497,
0.7056534886,
0.6353850365,
-0.3743416667,
0.3756191432,
0.3286849856,
0.021218542,
-0.6015494466,
-0.8707690239,
-0.0592176132,
-0.5317095518,
0.2259688824,
-0.6487319469,
-1.067833066,
0.6172534227,
0.0304770749,
0.0411100723,
0.5876303315,
0.7387013435,
-0.247063145,
0.8912699819,
0.4651163518,
-0.2685266137,
0.3978237212,
-0.1763309836,
0.1770916581,
-0.8475532532,
-0.1539923996,
0.0488399826,
-0.5036668181,
-0.3749996722,
-0.6698141694,
0.4848003685,
-0.1888948977,
-0.035450846,
0.263958782,
-0.304916352,
0.4314795434,
0.6347043514,
0.0941767767,
0.4070052207,
-0.2566851377,
-0.0324116573,
0.0636761487,
-1.0427197218,
-0.3612637818,
1.3228565454,
0.2892868817,
1.1360504627,
0.1467762291,
1.018827796,
0.4132098556,
0.3285152018,
-0.7985812426,
0.8002455831,
-0.1419595033,
-0.767787993,
-0.416379571,
-0.5114229321,
-0.6619238853,
0.4575535655,
-0.0844714269,
-0.4543500543,
0.024989225,
0.1473363042,
-0.143940717,
0.2699243128,
-0.774215579,
0.6795315742,
-0.4754526913,
-0.1272972524,
-0.55590415,
-0.3906133175,
0.4398491383,
-0.4962423146,
0.2743225694,
-0.2712605298,
-0.3767202199,
0.4839539528,
-0.1977895349,
0.9921286702,
0.3027134538,
-0.3645559549,
0.1762612909,
0.4887995422,
0.2579606175,
0.0723480433,
-0.4012922943,
0.2817721963,
-0.2856470346,
-0.6817086339,
-0.7737985253,
0.993070066,
-0.9058713913,
-0.9098092318,
0.142713055,
-0.7875988483,
-0.3169320524,
0.3484951556,
-0.0043199477,
0.5789403319,
-0.1144232899,
0.2128237337,
0.7533880472,
0.1986483783,
0.3773171902,
0.6859942675,
-0.0878977254,
-0.5569109321,
0.9471744895,
0.4253495336,
0.3374482095,
0.4021533132,
0.2758963406,
-0.0031983308,
-0.6457698345,
-0.4751275778,
0.0931578949,
-0.8089846373,
-0.0049096281,
-0.8436954021,
-0.0512649342,
-0.4074755609,
-0.327206552,
-0.8890408278,
-0.4293008149,
-0.4510963857,
0.0512683354,
-0.1650143713,
1.0588605404,
-0.1677665412,
0.3008532226,
-0.813426435,
0.0964497551,
0.7340028882,
0.3688366413,
0.2334123701,
-0.4156222343,
-0.4748036563,
-0.0665117577,
-0.2350403219,
-0.7390604615,
0.13169007,
0.1244360283,
1.0646084547,
0.4359561205,
0.0763179213,
0.6667155623,
-0.6998585463,
0.6464774609,
0.2435136586,
-1.1148272753,
0.5253255963,
-0.6801941395,
0.2060167342,
0.4011058509,
0.1704320759,
-0.1694395393,
-0.6182570457,
-0.5127213001,
-0.6617492437,
0.532069087,
0.1499052197,
0.5347951651,
-0.1279949993,
0.2453816533,
0.3810419738,
0.2428554446,
-0.7139884233,
-0.2669122517,
-0.0715005696,
-0.3977489471,
-0.0549008958,
-0.3094178736,
-0.1679650694,
-0.2601456344,
0.5253718495,
-0.2507438064,
0.1315430701,
0.1973534226,
-0.2394209057,
0.0530544929,
0.3230587542,
0.5409077406,
0.9536299706,
0.3070823252,
0.3611656725,
0.3360794187,
0.1563848704,
0.0093043167,
-0.4507263303,
0.0104843099,
-0.3293096125,
0.4782711565,
0.4427314997,
0.6903085113,
-0.496932596,
0.2999760211,
0.4657408297,
-0.0611942969,
-0.0682636946,
0.4991051555,
0.1736102402,
0.3997192979,
0.4703634679,
0.0547985286,
0.2733058631,
-0.5914597511,
0.214127019,
0.3833362162,
-0.0091697779,
-0.5900740623,
0.4631756842,
0.6282755136,
-0.3996054232,
0.0552504659,
0.0776620954,
-0.3708436787,
0.3788071871,
0.5453056693,
0.8542969823,
-0.6032274961,
0.011953366,
-0.0134079726,
0.2490694523,
-0.1240351498,
-0.0508005321,
-0.3080428243,
-0.6427472234,
-0.5338212252,
-0.3957198262,
-0.2940361202,
-0.3517955542,
-0.5109995604,
0.0524326824,
-0.5587453246,
-0.0623781644,
-0.2123199999,
-0.4748264253,
-0.3525685966,
0.1488599628,
0.0073417258,
0.8205292225,
-0.5817969441,
0.7327003479,
0.9246348739,
-0.1356274188,
-0.5457060933,
-0.0121454466,
-0.4028716385,
-0.8459146619,
0.8238319755,
-0.1030302867,
-0.1130120531,
0.1804381907,
-0.3729121685,
-0.9366435409,
0.9605989456,
0.3346480727,
-0.3921890855,
0.044015158,
-0.0219475888,
0.5646237731,
-0.5486230254,
0.1346755177,
0.1661323756,
0.3959204555,
-0.0887573585,
-1.130931735,
-0.2409067601,
-0.1594596654,
0.0085590873,
0.228956759,
-0.935279429,
1.0080690384,
0.2296322286,
0.137740761,
-0.1049443111,
0.9132063985,
-0.2363341004,
0.0236747675,
0.3531682789,
0.7167223096,
0.6181806326,
0.3809649646,
0.8010070324,
-0.504698813,
0.3377403617,
1.0144901276,
-0.0969389379,
0.8987547159,
0.3822733462,
-0.1304877549,
0.7065784931,
0.3358905911,
0.3247457743,
0.3961173594,
-0.0943378359,
-0.4425602853,
-0.8476602435,
0.4702835083,
-0.3480717838,
0.5882703066,
0.3678962886,
-0.1358203441,
-0.3119043112,
-0.0050856522,
-0.2365261167,
0.0154423993,
-0.3779163659,
0.8778239489,
0.0520809554,
-0.680595696,
0.158735916,
0.0774315149,
0.8408240676,
-0.6218162179,
0.4199637175,
-0.2531128824,
-0.0113526387,
-0.2918809652,
-0.9946568608,
0.3512935638,
-0.4133988023,
-0.4057691097,
-0.424284339,
0.7794522643,
-0.512712121,
-0.555113852,
0.3861270249,
0.8304319382,
0.0784102604,
0.0360117964,
-0.6475853324,
-0.198019743,
-0.2659726441,
-0.2709113657,
0.4214405417,
0.7083005309,
0.1048328057,
1.1013411283,
0.5989585519,
0.0227536,
0.4655031562,
-0.3141160309,
1.0562182665,
-0.5967313051,
-0.7415528297,
-0.7871388793,
0.6454489827,
0.0514435284,
-0.1083376482,
0.8773398995,
0.5547302365,
0.8642325401,
-0.2996005714,
0.8725234866,
0.0942198932,
0.2944856286,
-0.6309152842,
0.6142668724,
-0.8634744287,
0.2402677089,
0.0069427108,
-0.8281222582,
0.0034590282,
0.4745015204,
-0.3971776366,
0.1755512953,
0.3259121776,
0.7055417299,
-0.6023997664,
-0.3207706511,
0.6831335425,
0.2220411599,
0.2733820677,
0.3392715454,
0.812460959,
0.0336384326,
0.2343997955,
-0.0406239182,
-0.1995344311,
-0.4891548157,
-0.6337201595,
-1.0477695465,
-0.4136508703,
-0.2673946917,
0.4086200297,
-0.2030064017,
0.9305689931,
1.1995532513,
-0.6175267696,
-0.4703985453,
0.0092883203,
0.1877448261,
0.28401196,
-0.1908195913,
-0.2608273029,
-0.7434093952,
-0.762589395,
0.9267366529,
0.8759481311,
-0.0686535239,
-0.8269783258,
-0.1551003009,
0.1723042279,
0.2911356688,
0.7970052361,
0.0979377925,
-0.9126525521,
-0.0700959191,
0.0468396172,
-0.1859993637,
0.1404540241,
0.8932055235,
-0.4962132275,
0.8141213655,
0.630006671,
0.9661371708,
0.2052320093,
-0.1060917228,
0.7761183977,
-0.5570604801,
-0.083665207,
0.1695973873,
0.4322081804,
0.0914321467,
-0.3568488359,
0.3459656239,
0.2329217941,
-0.6374031901,
-0.3640855551,
0.4757012129,
-1.1624187231,
-0.3282077909,
0.9873465896,
-0.1825021654,
-0.1408823431,
-0.0988915041,
-0.1040116176,
-0.3242560625,
-0.35991624,
0.7942116857,
0.8485070467,
-0.270105958,
-0.2238572538,
-0.4309486747,
-0.1527151018,
0.6897664666,
-0.9012881517,
-0.1950613409,
0.3894115984,
0.7167816162,
0.1977619231,
0.8632009625,
0.1449930221,
0.0044020051,
-0.2956607044,
0.1840904057,
-0.2576661706,
-0.4186250269,
-0.0722773597,
0.1037183776,
0.0441565141,
0.1138739064
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12033v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12033v2 | Unveiling and Mitigating Bias in Mental Health Analysis with Large Language Models | 2024-06-17T19:05:32 | 2024-06-19T18:28:22 | Yuqing Wang, Yun Zhao, Sara Alessandra Keller, Anne de Hond, Marieke M. van Buchem, Malvika Pillai, Tina Hernandez-Boussard | cs.CL | cs.CL | The advancement of large language models (LLMs) has demonstrated strong
capabilities across various applications, including mental health analysis.
However, existing studies have focused on predictive performance, leaving the
critical issue of fairness underexplored, posing significant risks to
vulnerable populations. Despite acknowledging potential biases, previous works
have lacked thorough investigations into these biases and their impacts. To
address this gap, we systematically evaluate biases across seven social factors
(e.g., gender, age, religion) using ten LLMs with different prompting methods
on eight diverse mental health datasets. Our results show that GPT-4 achieves
the best overall balance in performance and fairness among LLMs, although it
still lags behind domain-specific models like MentalRoBERTa in some cases.
Additionally, our tailored fairness-aware prompts can effectively mitigate bias
in mental health predictions, highlighting the great potential for fair
analysis in this field. | [
-0.358191222,
-0.7111181021,
0.9544341564,
0.2233427167,
0.153532505,
-0.1080885902,
-0.277592808,
-0.4207704961,
-0.1210225746,
0.3103136122,
-0.7924649715,
-0.3779721856,
-0.9342877865,
0.1040705219,
0.0619428866,
1.3294248581,
0.3063579202,
0.5553945899,
-0.0578323007,
-0.0197414346,
-0.602478981,
-0.7003370523,
-0.9033084512,
-0.6808740497,
0.5472288728,
0.0959095731,
0.782035172,
0.1681839675,
0.3992555439,
0.2047063261,
-0.116524078,
-0.1624827087,
-0.6734133363,
0.0655419976,
-0.4057900012,
-0.4341351688,
-0.7477226257,
0.1807438582,
0.5270529985,
0.8200803399,
-0.2615079284,
0.31206882,
0.1550779194,
0.7212100029,
-0.483040601,
0.13535586,
-0.5719829798,
0.2198685855,
-0.5260254145,
-0.0767447576,
-0.1859320998,
-0.5047760606,
0.1025639027,
-0.2997902334,
0.3065872788,
-0.0195350666,
0.4421569109,
0.3932732642,
-0.577128768,
0.0605284721,
-0.4975773394,
0.9088560343,
-0.8572756648,
0.2646149099,
0.402747035,
0.3877267241,
-0.3024595976,
-0.3927238286,
-0.4099412262,
0.2344464213,
0.1784735024,
0.0214255434,
-0.3478153944,
0.168619141,
0.7100637555,
0.1900782138,
-0.4698323309,
0.1185024455,
-0.4169392586,
-0.4454607666,
0.4932923019,
0.3565233648,
0.413526088,
-0.0550934412,
0.1498411447,
0.2843596935,
-0.7158192992,
0.1209495366,
0.4044679999,
0.1460654587,
-0.1094256863,
0.5844109058,
-0.0073351674,
0.1850025505,
0.1012966037,
-0.2409089804,
0.3582553864,
-0.0528937094,
-0.1445698291,
0.0356171802,
0.6795381904,
0.8323177695,
0.4265453815,
-0.1694328487,
-0.1838351339,
0.3540109396,
0.0985417515,
-0.94866395,
0.0412263684,
0.2005816996,
-0.6402716041,
0.0596144125,
-0.2957905531,
-1.1308960915,
-0.6703904271,
-0.3252928257,
0.0183787066,
-0.2229831368,
-0.2986248434,
0.2757112384,
-0.0122174043,
0.0726933852,
0.349050045,
-0.7923503518,
0.4491097033,
0.7191460133,
0.7055350542,
-0.2114690989,
0.0705040246,
-0.7954906821,
0.2156624347,
-0.1329139173,
0.537078917,
-0.7007104158,
-0.2527404726,
-0.0040686782,
-0.0991064832,
0.2525664866,
-0.3457089961,
0.7358965874,
-0.143249765,
0.4830416441,
-1.0085120201,
-0.4676099718,
-0.1027769148,
0.0263455641,
-0.6139605045,
0.6470204592,
0.1934154481,
-1.1740566492,
0.5687175393,
-0.7289010286,
-0.4216684103,
-0.0730861723,
-0.5503857732,
-0.4560917616,
0.2955625653,
0.6029083729,
0.3457164466,
-0.4629205763,
0.6519547701,
-0.6226424575,
-0.5117260218,
0.1119281873,
-0.6032068729,
0.7758851647,
0.2119202465,
-0.6715636253,
0.1526765078,
-0.2015219331,
-0.1150941625,
0.1194600388,
0.0704655498,
-0.1565544903,
-0.0677502453,
-0.0331617594,
0.4062508941,
0.0543212257,
-0.4529979825,
-0.1508274525,
-0.4662794173,
0.3640010953,
1.0364726782,
-0.2129418105,
0.3070440292,
-0.4529807866,
0.8166720271,
-0.1574534774,
0.4640517831,
0.3034410179,
-0.7811051011,
-0.0182208885,
-0.5905883312,
0.1141940802,
0.438783884,
-0.5867008567,
0.1500704885,
-0.2024092078,
0.0122487415,
-0.6601005197,
-0.0003344193,
0.3290481865,
0.3807702661,
0.1707127243,
-0.3324832916,
-0.3431051075,
-0.9567159414,
-0.5545768142,
0.075349465,
-0.0548310727,
0.2050745338,
0.3226369023,
-0.3332876861,
0.7995188832,
-0.3092184961,
-0.2686012387,
-0.2290644646,
-0.0440098457,
0.2523915768,
0.0902543217,
0.7712581158,
-0.4384295344,
-0.2318883687,
-0.349485755,
-0.6565653086,
-0.7167480588,
0.443695128,
-0.1631198078,
-0.0402018018,
0.1581889987,
-0.497169435,
0.3820756078,
0.6444596648,
-0.4924113154,
0.3847201467,
0.109083131,
0.1496033221,
-0.6519474387,
0.0049026976,
0.1586653143,
-0.144819364,
-0.4701313972,
-0.2799066603,
-0.0698012933,
-0.0387793779,
-0.2444316149,
0.6876444221,
-0.2616322339,
-0.1506661624,
-0.2865963578,
-0.0722236559,
-0.1369307041,
0.1162622571,
-0.3965138495,
0.7247578502,
0.4647865593,
-0.0715868622,
-0.0879473835,
-0.1575662047,
0.0239436366,
0.6494365931,
-0.5959286094,
0.1088948101,
-0.3397330642,
0.5680899024,
-0.7358907461,
-0.1401666999,
0.3350336552,
-0.3608053923,
0.1383164376,
0.0942021981,
-0.3996464312,
-0.4591165781,
-0.5710493326,
0.626454711,
0.454995513,
-0.1860221624,
0.408184886,
0.7180080414,
-0.4677326381,
-0.6717537642,
-0.3663582504,
-0.0498088524,
-0.6397152543,
-0.5435820818,
0.304797262,
-0.3373472691,
-0.4979346395,
-0.2038377374,
-0.1840689331,
0.1825615615,
0.0842677578,
0.2812410891,
0.369022727,
0.155608356,
0.1321736276,
0.0401950367,
-0.1541588157,
0.347207278,
-0.0882211551,
0.5057173967,
-0.1991927475,
-0.2905515134,
-0.2325499505,
0.5233825445,
0.467846781,
-0.2476773113,
0.5590478778,
0.654391408,
-0.6685310006,
-0.011982969,
-0.7954699993,
-0.3157432675,
-0.4591315985,
0.3352463543,
-0.111124143,
-1.2412980795,
0.5305362344,
0.2188980132,
-0.0152185373,
0.2567637861,
0.7941533327,
0.2521699369,
1.3933358192,
0.6577202082,
-0.3668017089,
0.4140040576,
0.2512508035,
0.5470852256,
-0.6144228578,
0.0272763968,
-0.4533871412,
-0.134452194,
-0.7603052855,
-0.4901172817,
0.4766494036,
-0.1943956912,
-0.4387457073,
-0.6396000385,
-0.516656816,
0.2850255072,
0.2176115513,
0.1793368459,
0.2839448452,
-0.119376868,
-0.172473073,
-0.4784300625,
-0.4713049233,
-0.5217511058,
1.4026391506,
0.6927408576,
0.7810232043,
0.0929246694,
0.5072852373,
0.316129446,
0.7339018583,
-0.4561165273,
0.3390280008,
-0.1175146699,
-0.9126935005,
-0.3605188131,
-0.7320659161,
-0.8810963631,
0.252638489,
0.0260878336,
-0.8724741936,
0.0173120871,
0.0867898837,
-0.4019653201,
0.1711914241,
-0.6694110632,
0.478895992,
-0.2781820893,
-0.3494925797,
-0.2082831264,
-0.4701548517,
0.6755299568,
-0.3038859367,
0.6595543623,
-0.7251397967,
0.1766967773,
0.7600911856,
-0.1052311584,
0.6542147994,
-0.3211856484,
-0.3273971081,
-0.2402642667,
-0.0983391702,
0.2598684132,
0.384334296,
-0.2613292933,
0.2525854111,
0.0681462809,
-0.4870087802,
-0.6345204711,
0.8600410819,
-0.6989096403,
-0.7776240706,
-0.5173686743,
-0.6451003551,
-0.5484623313,
0.2191183269,
0.1226229891,
0.1835200638,
-0.0485720299,
-0.3248874545,
0.7031844258,
-0.5469205379,
0.1596752405,
0.4998022914,
-0.5093653202,
-0.4507991076,
0.4931929708,
0.1841902137,
0.0521641336,
-0.261213243,
0.4196042418,
-0.3242078424,
-0.3984217346,
0.0043397276,
0.5031296611,
-0.5970675349,
-0.1996011138,
-0.5751896501,
-0.0260307118,
-0.6768263578,
-0.0287624039,
-0.228651762,
0.0159410741,
0.1816331297,
-0.3370370865,
0.2876635194,
0.7593740225,
-0.0881812647,
0.1172033176,
-0.341578871,
0.3804080486,
0.3089158237,
0.6400116682,
0.267870605,
-0.2625849247,
0.1374114007,
-0.0532491766,
-0.3843228221,
-0.8762902021,
0.3154286444,
-0.1970555335,
0.7842108011,
0.4959238172,
0.0438694097,
0.4466192424,
-0.7105525136,
0.686422348,
0.5541716814,
-0.9697752595,
0.6024726033,
-0.4801677465,
0.267863065,
0.4094025493,
0.3114286959,
-0.5319827795,
-0.5267791152,
-0.5633410215,
-0.7087711692,
0.5190944076,
0.2483795881,
-0.0576685667,
-0.1853486151,
0.3025210798,
0.3052524328,
0.1699902415,
-0.8425173759,
-0.194208473,
-0.1660492867,
-0.3499918878,
-0.0837069973,
-0.3403187096,
-0.4668890238,
-0.4344597161,
0.4363943636,
-0.1949329823,
0.3674748242,
0.091743134,
0.1943412721,
-0.3424123526,
0.4053904414,
0.4575125575,
0.7445448041,
-0.2258925885,
0.1684215814,
0.2562475204,
-0.5487525463,
0.2426052988,
0.2023029178,
-0.0569930337,
-0.220754832,
0.3485870063,
0.5853942633,
-0.0749415606,
-0.6581169963,
0.6633848548,
-0.2291692346,
0.0043385355,
0.1242955849,
0.0314790495,
-0.0044808108,
0.5304844379,
0.2457389683,
-0.4449086487,
0.4399843514,
-0.4866970181,
0.1195771918,
0.6260953546,
-0.4012914002,
-0.3771165013,
0.7763510942,
0.1551408768,
-0.1132562235,
0.4477064312,
-0.0074648429,
-0.4240320027,
0.4837186635,
0.4789275825,
0.6505728364,
-0.2847681046,
0.1744662076,
0.1482181698,
0.482706517,
-0.128439039,
0.460141331,
0.5336435437,
-0.6883164048,
-0.5725967884,
-0.5263155103,
-0.1729569435,
0.3151699901,
-0.7510029078,
0.0278548431,
-0.405942142,
-0.8331537247,
-0.0948372334,
0.3051493764,
-1.14483881,
0.2221141756,
0.4519340098,
0.6655868888,
-0.9293034077,
0.6257100105,
0.4041078389,
-0.1929206997,
-0.5935959816,
0.3259194791,
0.3158679903,
-0.701161921,
0.3328787684,
0.443685025,
-0.0611951649,
-0.2841953635,
-0.4933575988,
-0.7191277742,
0.9262109995,
0.9597611427,
-0.6409657598,
-0.1117230877,
0.1046759412,
0.400100857,
-0.2266221941,
0.4531735182,
0.8403577805,
0.756393671,
-0.3765499294,
-1.0525895357,
0.2474252135,
-0.1370764524,
0.2185087651,
-0.0658699572,
-0.5187315941,
0.6677524447,
-0.2673220634,
-0.1051862016,
-0.3927579522,
0.3806799948,
0.5626776814,
0.5159984231,
0.5163414478,
0.4369398057,
1.1957297325,
-0.0729355291,
1.0723558664,
0.0415038913,
0.279206723,
1.1319385767,
-0.7192831039,
0.1644158661,
0.4729960859,
-0.4494599998,
0.0636473224,
0.6380482912,
0.2475679368,
0.5233855247,
0.504083097,
-0.2557404637,
-0.0628749952,
-0.2824557424,
-0.5109999776,
0.1428459287,
0.4509054124,
-0.3125107288,
-0.193310082,
0.1026873887,
0.3734685779,
-0.0076613985,
-0.3552998304,
0.3375806212,
0.2877611518,
-0.410520345,
0.0844660103,
0.0434743688,
0.9805458784,
-0.5008060932,
-0.0055149565,
-0.4247379601,
-0.1106808111,
-0.1028444245,
-0.6886180043,
0.1659236699,
-0.041242592,
-0.4851824641,
-0.0696388781,
0.7653698921,
-0.2123108506,
-0.5281091332,
0.7193893194,
0.7146208882,
-0.026896216,
-0.1703413278,
-0.6551458836,
0.2289774418,
-0.061031919,
-0.1512354463,
0.6362344623,
0.7666188478,
-0.377296567,
0.7312133908,
0.5205830932,
0.3134548366,
0.0115120392,
0.403231591,
0.6896437407,
-0.7643486261,
-0.3765418828,
-1.0461622477,
0.2708462477,
-0.1152582988,
-0.1067361012,
0.7681722641,
0.2208870053,
0.39329952,
0.2400496751,
0.872941792,
0.4001092017,
0.4734011889,
-0.304397136,
0.8648971915,
-0.3465464413,
0.2752803266,
-0.5552853942,
-0.7638190389,
-0.2532058954,
0.4882465005,
-0.6499224305,
0.3909650147,
0.6378718615,
0.7344546318,
0.3289346397,
0.0486491881,
0.2744402587,
0.1655178517,
0.7301625609,
0.616892457,
0.7353606224,
0.0732052773,
-0.0459289774,
0.1234959662,
-0.4861122668,
0.0759520754,
-1.0607402325,
-0.9909182787,
0.0324768052,
-0.0745333955,
-0.3108996451,
0.3231728077,
0.7321118712,
0.5225995183,
-0.6877515316,
0.001186022,
0.4335846603,
0.2265422493,
-0.1490348428,
-0.2243498266,
0.291397959,
-0.1131911129,
-0.4861277044,
-0.0395448916,
0.2628392279,
-0.3418809772,
-0.3454396725,
-0.1073170602,
0.2463609576,
0.1894529015,
0.6105126143,
-0.2498045713,
-0.927046299,
-0.3705132604,
-0.3613382578,
-0.1232622936,
0.0035023591,
0.7776927948,
-0.5815247893,
0.2239376903,
0.223169148,
0.5797786713,
0.0138102463,
-0.2630335689,
0.9112627506,
-0.3764235973,
-0.177548632,
0.2619642913,
0.5577737093,
0.4214049578,
-0.7263432741,
0.5402336121,
0.1034459099,
-0.6136044264,
-0.8033898473,
-0.0301211886,
-0.6530106664,
-0.29228881,
1.1702541113,
0.1053160131,
0.0035609978,
-0.1654784828,
-0.36258322,
0.317990154,
-0.6947928071,
0.984438777,
0.9339331388,
-0.1502073854,
-0.1604806334,
-1.1527056694,
0.5636440516,
0.5821567178,
-0.8534356952,
0.136487484,
0.5686218739,
0.5421948433,
-0.4704751074,
1.0949219465,
-0.4204525054,
0.2838915288,
-0.6399137378,
0.0589372665,
0.349342078,
-0.1225678027,
-0.5496433973,
0.0427340344,
0.0496816561,
0.461438179
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12031v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12031v1 | Large Scale Transfer Learning for Tabular Data via Language Modeling | 2024-06-17T18:58:20 | 2024-06-17T18:58:20 | Josh Gardner, Juan C. Perdomo, Ludwig Schmidt | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Tabular data -- structured, heterogeneous, spreadsheet-style data with rows
and columns -- is widely used in practice across many domains. However, while
recent foundation models have reduced the need for developing task-specific
datasets and predictors in domains such as language modeling and computer
vision, this transfer learning paradigm has not had similar impact in the
tabular domain. In this work, we seek to narrow this gap and present TabuLa-8B,
a language model for tabular prediction. We define a process for extracting a
large, high-quality training dataset from the TabLib corpus, proposing methods
for tabular data filtering and quality control. Using the resulting dataset,
which comprises over 1.6B rows from 3.1M unique tables, we fine-tune a Llama
3-8B large language model (LLM) for tabular data prediction (classification and
binned regression) using a novel packing and attention scheme for tabular
prediction. Through evaluation across a test suite of 329 datasets, we find
that TabuLa-8B has zero-shot accuracy on unseen tables that is over 15
percentage points (pp) higher than random guessing, a feat that is not possible
with existing state-of-the-art tabular prediction models (e.g. XGBoost,
TabPFN). In the few-shot setting (1-32 shots), without any fine-tuning on the
target datasets, TabuLa-8B is 5-15 pp more accurate than XGBoost and TabPFN
models that are explicitly trained on equal, or even up to 16x more data. We
release our model, code, and data along with the publication of this paper. | [
-0.1835456789,
-0.879596889,
0.2938061357,
0.109384045,
0.0821363851,
-0.0162805263,
-0.3523477614,
-0.5592234731,
-0.1722940058,
0.8143846989,
-0.1335324794,
-0.6487967968,
-0.5107588768,
-0.2741244435,
-0.5868760943,
1.1144483089,
-0.1478399783,
0.0021229188,
0.1070239246,
0.1266786307,
-0.680532217,
-0.1461502761,
-0.1875002682,
-0.2075427473,
0.5475838184,
0.7223447561,
0.4379526675,
0.9434688091,
0.7216827869,
0.1386203319,
0.0653116554,
-0.032176327,
-0.7168284059,
-0.2313562036,
-0.1024470255,
-0.6123885512,
-0.5979763269,
-0.1333466768,
0.857026875,
0.7719006538,
-0.354398489,
0.4901822805,
0.0530903675,
0.6347426772,
-0.2830668092,
0.5410121679,
-0.9898289442,
0.2419628799,
-0.3575887084,
0.0814100206,
-0.8383886814,
-0.4341754615,
-0.0081174634,
-0.310474515,
0.106619291,
0.335698694,
0.7061449289,
-0.070644021,
-0.3140339553,
0.1595853418,
-0.7782370448,
0.5051258206,
-0.424543649,
0.4618162811,
0.4712486565,
0.5190588832,
-0.3329760134,
-0.5228876472,
-0.6297652721,
-0.4636054933,
0.1681833416,
-0.188560769,
0.0774888247,
-0.0630415604,
0.3272981048,
0.1115116626,
-0.9175162315,
0.2738485038,
-0.7164620161,
-0.0046688449,
0.3965613246,
0.0848213658,
0.0670278966,
0.0777194798,
-0.4465918243,
-0.1976584494,
-0.7584165931,
0.1441301703,
-0.0224948414,
0.6032004952,
-0.077218622,
0.3755920529,
-0.2714059651,
0.9204283953,
0.040110033,
-0.1716657132,
0.1981386542,
0.0293692406,
-0.3183609545,
-0.1019741148,
0.4462389052,
0.2787214518,
0.1602329761,
-0.2486127019,
-0.1286023706,
0.1321222037,
0.2953070998,
-0.7612276673,
-0.3721303642,
0.0090542529,
-0.2501426339,
-0.3249731958,
-0.0240407716,
-0.8312196732,
-0.4352618456,
-0.3588595688,
0.4630770981,
-0.2371510565,
0.1264859885,
-0.102448225,
0.4588178098,
0.242107898,
0.5034577847,
-0.8661348224,
0.3098969758,
0.4422738254,
0.6554481983,
-0.5427010655,
-0.3929314911,
-0.8506324291,
0.2532463372,
-0.717030108,
1.1822916269,
-0.5868472457,
0.0579220392,
0.0351323858,
0.0927719995,
0.0818810835,
-0.6288858652,
0.3728217781,
-0.2944023609,
-0.2828762829,
0.0174614098,
-0.4566513002,
-0.2454241514,
0.234640345,
-0.850605309,
0.8706072569,
0.4252146184,
-0.2424449325,
0.6722038984,
-0.3591704071,
-0.3677915335,
0.2950478196,
-0.2387753576,
-0.6934883595,
-0.0788151771,
0.0151480511,
0.6557410955,
-0.3236449659,
0.4966471195,
-0.629137814,
-0.1620910764,
0.3502036035,
-0.1458261311,
0.150773257,
0.1210119575,
-0.1679262668,
0.1299191713,
-0.8476815224,
0.1453755647,
-0.2012502551,
-0.4426639974,
0.3879736066,
-0.544270575,
0.3239421546,
0.3149353266,
-0.0189089663,
-0.4229204655,
0.459452033,
0.0140067199,
0.1502332836,
0.6321893334,
-0.3152640462,
0.7642129064,
-0.3655383587,
0.5152499676,
0.1204149872,
0.0128058866,
0.0765224323,
-0.2395047396,
-0.3752349615,
-0.0779932067,
0.5386884809,
0.4478882849,
-0.5557991266,
0.2514949739,
-0.4194554985,
-0.7123958468,
-0.1388308257,
0.3109428287,
0.2989435494,
0.640732646,
0.3629507124,
-0.1281021833,
-0.4331522286,
-0.8072226644,
0.0406412818,
0.0014454203,
0.2300781608,
0.1371651888,
0.4252491891,
0.0223039612,
0.5121030807,
-0.5930017233,
-0.7342148423,
-0.849421978,
0.1768832505,
0.3643903136,
0.5039694309,
0.4234697521,
-0.6311355829,
-0.9822453856,
0.5211925507,
-0.5061939359,
0.0426097065,
-0.2183857858,
-0.2471684217,
0.2298811227,
0.3529988825,
-0.5559070706,
0.6440679431,
0.5156106353,
-0.2935099602,
0.6932315826,
-0.0092435293,
-0.079451479,
-1.0351376534,
0.1803135574,
0.172215119,
-0.2829901576,
-0.938485086,
-0.1976988614,
0.3736520112,
-0.2316764444,
-0.44710356,
0.6416891217,
-0.5510526896,
-0.3085675836,
-0.3305735886,
-0.1106896996,
-0.0315744765,
0.612000525,
0.0829698443,
0.6985007524,
0.5226513147,
-0.3706817329,
0.3732659221,
0.506398201,
-0.6727004051,
0.4296286702,
-0.1587111205,
-0.1902819425,
-0.0153054791,
0.6173527837,
-0.9020884633,
-0.242990613,
-0.0700279325,
-0.4047469795,
0.6472226977,
-0.2408542484,
-0.0812833831,
-0.4752152264,
0.0127161527,
0.1425722539,
0.3400865793,
-0.3535557091,
0.5603191853,
0.5630736351,
-0.2329736501,
-0.7284341455,
-0.7379662395,
0.0143082784,
-0.2150841653,
-0.2705488205,
0.3244400918,
0.1088918447,
0.1807197928,
-0.0405539423,
-0.212369442,
-0.4158405662,
-0.1358781308,
0.2617085278,
0.5688771009,
-0.0702666342,
0.1211457849,
-0.1945042014,
0.056787204,
-0.0903424919,
-0.272279501,
0.5174613595,
-0.0909183472,
0.1623772532,
-0.3347964883,
-0.0106400261,
0.3718566597,
-0.2314325571,
0.920435071,
0.8040115237,
-0.5599042773,
-0.6260948181,
-0.5596792698,
-0.0860336497,
-0.37145257,
0.6729806066,
-0.495039165,
-0.5330092311,
0.7713921666,
0.1420551836,
0.0512190983,
0.0097677428,
0.5959234834,
-0.1012723595,
0.5283410549,
0.7475547194,
-0.2786803246,
0.7894752026,
-0.5632202029,
0.0917103663,
-0.7401530147,
-0.2525393963,
-0.6637721658,
-0.4058306813,
-0.5904203057,
-0.4432389438,
0.2707112432,
-0.2824234366,
-0.1410229206,
0.6347438097,
-0.0821750015,
0.5032827258,
0.3066087067,
0.4468704462,
0.1702984124,
0.2507883012,
0.1319238544,
0.2509166002,
-0.5574551821,
-0.2335019708,
1.3179795742,
0.3624492288,
1.1210727692,
-0.256993562,
0.3597584069,
0.4279410541,
0.6530187726,
-0.6572952271,
0.450660944,
-0.2884344757,
-0.5240297318,
-0.6027123928,
-0.7206906676,
-1.0163499117,
0.0904105082,
-0.3402119875,
-1.0851066113,
0.0771243572,
0.3102441728,
-0.3011210263,
0.4251577854,
-0.6846025586,
1.1218158007,
-0.0484250523,
-0.7158841491,
-0.0509384833,
-0.6226315498,
0.2378198355,
-0.1773161292,
0.1843709648,
-0.2672008276,
0.4962109923,
0.7167480588,
0.0023543027,
0.6173246503,
-0.1462890059,
-0.031950824,
0.2368652374,
0.4121528566,
0.6521648765,
-0.3784562051,
-0.0270529054,
0.0336646922,
-0.131362319,
-0.3341140747,
-0.595836103,
0.6657466888,
-0.6867214441,
-0.2556455433,
-0.0272922739,
-0.9402236342,
-0.3712335527,
0.1554617584,
0.0056217792,
0.6739318371,
0.0307069179,
0.6016865969,
0.6339435577,
-0.1057281569,
0.0811722204,
0.3253712058,
-0.3641240597,
-0.2793279588,
1.0100860596,
0.5548221469,
0.1515066773,
0.6764369011,
0.1734390259,
-0.4063716233,
-0.6886348724,
-0.5820410848,
0.1902174652,
-0.4789890647,
-0.7218836546,
-0.3770214617,
-0.2266707718,
-0.5305437446,
0.007142663,
-0.3212774694,
-0.2982839346,
-0.0883898064,
-0.3427730203,
0.2535456717,
0.6796156168,
0.1934589744,
0.4520952702,
-0.8296423554,
0.3757114112,
-0.1379693002,
0.5984797478,
-0.0070321974,
-0.9619526267,
-0.5643894672,
-0.2212689668,
-0.3761043251,
-0.868583262,
0.7665285468,
0.262734741,
0.5254202485,
0.1245729998,
-0.109749034,
0.7380113602,
-0.5455719233,
0.1752958149,
0.1818122715,
-0.6391632557,
0.2723719776,
-0.4041532278,
0.2012471855,
0.4726209044,
0.2526860535,
-0.3116788268,
-0.126961574,
-0.3304153979,
-0.4956307709,
0.8341426849,
-0.216311872,
-0.3235228956,
0.5580620766,
0.3308961391,
0.49812603,
0.2410168052,
-1.1493326426,
0.1680857539,
0.2498798221,
-0.3782022595,
-0.0379297063,
0.0925687477,
0.3186210692,
-0.1411601603,
0.5505439043,
-0.3097479939,
0.1426169723,
-0.1804793924,
-0.4382216632,
-0.3260881603,
0.2694844902,
0.3817553818,
0.8232062459,
-0.2791012228,
0.0174343977,
0.1751988381,
-0.670683682,
0.2264497876,
0.1011050269,
-0.0672725961,
-0.3871623278,
0.0378481708,
0.89166224,
-0.0675793961,
-0.5094774961,
0.3166464865,
0.1581666023,
-0.2399511486,
-0.10433653,
-0.1924562007,
-0.1819397956,
0.2573863268,
0.2829808891,
-0.378713876,
0.4341056645,
-0.7560982108,
0.3256964982,
0.3564307094,
-0.144909218,
-0.3299631178,
0.4605124295,
-0.0912587941,
0.0861521661,
0.552307725,
-0.0058447532,
-0.3630109131,
0.6413874626,
0.7090903521,
0.3991420269,
-0.3466517925,
0.4545622468,
0.439008981,
0.2222327292,
-0.1792467237,
0.2435571253,
0.0361801758,
-0.5902263522,
-0.4024158716,
-0.8393492103,
-0.5226634741,
0.4497120678,
-0.6994099021,
0.39530164,
-0.284712702,
-0.1687950641,
-0.0106575666,
0.28851372,
-0.8598144054,
0.1563229561,
0.4037071466,
0.8571829796,
-1.0511143208,
0.9743824601,
0.4913640916,
-0.2765913606,
-1.09575665,
-0.3721124828,
-0.5728418231,
-0.7091758251,
0.6423714161,
0.3576980829,
0.4738925397,
-0.2029200792,
-0.5357670784,
-0.9508834481,
0.8165880442,
0.5366348624,
-0.7787385583,
-0.2690832019,
0.4694856107,
0.3981936574,
-0.3568280935,
0.2194745839,
0.853787899,
0.455733031,
0.1421405673,
-1.1195845604,
-0.0494142398,
0.0718557462,
0.0715445951,
0.3187655509,
-0.4780584276,
0.6965066195,
-0.2465779036,
0.1645422727,
-0.1966291666,
0.7273406386,
0.0142979631,
0.2054134458,
0.1107565388,
0.5488421917,
0.547942102,
-0.0144014079,
0.5880569816,
-0.0347083397,
0.3161205053,
1.3177312613,
-0.6316934228,
1.126540184,
0.2805183232,
-0.240842104,
0.3351632357,
0.4324729741,
-0.2623253167,
0.4182077646,
0.2065160424,
0.218886286,
-0.1094838455,
-0.0938739032,
-0.1037044078,
0.5793515444,
0.5826039314,
-0.1558808386,
-0.2402491271,
0.1880738437,
-0.2635610104,
-0.073750414,
-0.4906035662,
0.8037688732,
-0.1352879852,
-0.620049417,
0.6360619068,
-0.3966171145,
0.0402552411,
-0.2367056161,
-0.2306307554,
-0.3402007222,
0.2499535084,
-0.3515515029,
-0.8952730298,
0.0477639288,
-0.1465665698,
-0.0838074759,
-0.1653236896,
0.6373393536,
-0.836738646,
-0.5683888793,
-0.0431469269,
0.5014432073,
0.2938750386,
0.0560190454,
-0.4612448812,
0.2192913592,
0.0356387496,
-0.2112432867,
0.6353234649,
0.4290553629,
-0.292517066,
0.9608879685,
0.4923884869,
0.4483111501,
0.2777935266,
-0.0304674637,
0.898381412,
-0.5840911269,
-0.5670459867,
-0.4844859838,
0.3214350045,
0.1754761189,
0.0380292498,
0.2377393395,
0.6516429782,
0.7755227089,
-0.3082234561,
0.6151428223,
0.0669434294,
0.5077694058,
-0.4830232859,
0.626997292,
-0.1885995567,
-0.0771997571,
-0.1498626173,
-1.1070693731,
-0.38977018,
0.6702471972,
-0.4558357596,
-0.1314326823,
0.6290899515,
0.7275750041,
-0.0190584324,
-0.3651917577,
0.7137156725,
0.4716078639,
0.3267256021,
0.6282275915,
0.586984396,
-0.3993400335,
0.8062186241,
-0.117268838,
-0.3453072309,
-0.4316651523,
-0.6205353141,
-0.7343454957,
-0.6381486654,
-0.0927569494,
-0.2346836776,
0.0843278393,
0.892490685,
0.8293890357,
-0.7641787529,
-0.6136204004,
-0.0908248872,
-0.084836483,
-0.1625814885,
-0.2373345047,
0.4098547101,
-0.2025002986,
-0.3862878978,
-0.0070521701,
0.1491808891,
0.0868593454,
-0.1268810779,
0.417216599,
-0.0407633074,
-0.3243212998,
0.5022159815,
0.2099868655,
-0.42965886,
-0.1333584189,
-0.0160096828,
-0.071591571,
0.4981202185,
0.3808873594,
-0.6920200586,
0.1522192359,
0.274390161,
0.707370162,
0.8285928369,
0.0937925801,
0.4060688615,
-0.3868865669,
-0.0475139841,
0.1981027722,
0.4291492701,
0.2648248672,
-0.4385671616,
0.4052978456,
-0.1739258915,
-0.7932832241,
-1.0557557344,
0.009464452,
-1.2325277328,
0.0880177617,
1.1952729225,
-0.1817921102,
-0.7297250032,
0.1846290976,
-0.2700014114,
0.3032222092,
-0.6716766357,
1.0233507156,
0.4067387283,
-0.0736675709,
-0.3714224696,
-0.6325085759,
0.3863170147,
-0.0390738361,
-1.2098314762,
0.5438467264,
0.5976362228,
0.2625367641,
0.0010203482,
0.1457910687,
-0.0146754561,
0.435988307,
-0.0346289501,
0.3096615374,
0.0783192515,
-0.9039312601,
-0.1834005564,
0.3751340508,
0.2341141254,
0.0799495429
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.