id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11354v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11354v2 | Preserving Knowledge in Large Language Model with Model-Agnostic Self-Decompression | 2024-06-17T09:17:40 | 2024-06-19T11:36:30 | Zilun Zhang, Yutao Sun, Tiancheng Zhao, Leigang Sha, Ruochen Xu, Kyusong Lee, Jianwei Yin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV | Humans can retain old knowledge while learning new information, but Large
Language Models (LLMs) often suffer from catastrophic forgetting when
post-pretrained or supervised fine-tuned (SFT) on domain-specific data.
Moreover, for Multimodal Large Language Models (MLLMs) which are composed of
the LLM base and visual projector (e.g. LLaVA), a significant decline in
performance on language benchmarks was observed compared to their
single-modality counterparts. To address these challenges, we introduce a novel
model-agnostic self-decompression method, Tree Generation (TG), that
decompresses knowledge within LLMs into the training corpus. This paper focuses
on TG-SFT, which can synthetically generate SFT data for the instruction tuning
steps. By incorporating the dumped corpus during SFT for MLLMs, we
significantly reduce the forgetting problem. | [
-0.1846190095,
-0.7702288032,
0.3645899296,
-0.1153070703,
-0.216497466,
0.2802288234,
-0.3093538582,
-0.1158535704,
-0.2082952112,
0.5012716651,
-0.5831431746,
-0.5810500979,
-0.2941257358,
-0.0972457975,
-0.3493289948,
0.9399265051,
0.0088101933,
-0.303558439,
-0.2454229742,
-0.0540426746,
-0.3816726506,
-0.6476575732,
-0.6179233789,
-0.0988529176,
0.1215750203,
0.1773890555,
0.3236641884,
0.8838224411,
-0.0158784557,
0.2761499584,
0.0331927985,
0.4282750487,
-0.6979036331,
0.2805124819,
-0.2206650972,
-0.3727594018,
-0.3715082705,
-0.340577811,
0.973911047,
0.489423722,
-0.3114531934,
0.2557179928,
0.1605357528,
0.5479387045,
-0.729909122,
0.4487118423,
-0.9505758882,
-0.0062095448,
-0.0068974374,
-0.4756961763,
-0.5372735858,
-0.1465257406,
-0.105087094,
-0.4670959115,
0.6541463733,
-0.1259947568,
0.7555360794,
0.6482895613,
-0.2807374597,
0.0671027377,
-0.7456285954,
0.7221292853,
-0.7228543758,
0.4619973004,
0.4797753692,
0.196250692,
-0.1516723484,
-0.3454905748,
-0.3208989799,
-0.1982140243,
0.0653785318,
-0.0158044007,
-0.0938702971,
0.1218309626,
0.2920146585,
0.2177155316,
-0.4271237552,
0.0349329747,
-0.2975339592,
-0.2717936933,
0.5534445643,
-0.0045693833,
0.1529231071,
-0.2751057446,
-0.2048088461,
-0.1408495605,
-1.1348341703,
-0.2973230779,
0.0883533284,
0.2389835715,
0.3044984341,
0.2870053053,
-0.0127931386,
0.6170843244,
0.0912871957,
-0.2658386827,
0.2865572274,
-0.2174093425,
-0.2640761435,
-0.0369211659,
0.7287541032,
0.1675504297,
0.4132798016,
-0.2351546884,
-0.2424964309,
0.166351974,
0.0987692624,
-0.8342927098,
-0.5215570331,
-0.0494593903,
-0.3489544094,
-0.1022456512,
-0.3392921984,
-0.3755535185,
-0.038842801,
-0.1791188121,
0.2817554474,
-0.5621225238,
-0.5590043068,
-0.0802113712,
0.1480059475,
-0.0106772957,
0.1991835237,
-1.1102243662,
0.0301113371,
0.4336326122,
0.5578153133,
0.0409923717,
-0.3657572269,
-0.5567855239,
0.4991266727,
-0.3836885095,
0.5712870955,
-0.3127591908,
-0.4033415914,
-0.0926346183,
0.0203070547,
-0.2654930055,
-0.6599913836,
0.2762287855,
-0.3147746921,
0.1863134801,
-0.03573782,
-0.6785309911,
-0.1414508373,
0.4461181462,
-0.4252120256,
0.928994894,
0.1472073495,
-0.6349480748,
0.1922636628,
-0.4519565701,
-0.3799872994,
0.0188127123,
-0.2984212041,
-0.6303067803,
0.3516954184,
0.3607512414,
0.5710811019,
-0.1437431425,
0.6347665787,
-0.4399597645,
-0.0565296523,
-0.262568146,
-0.4875882566,
0.5530174971,
0.2461181283,
-0.0344562419,
0.0569387451,
-0.7907970548,
0.180431217,
0.21539931,
-0.4514594078,
-0.3742075264,
0.357717663,
-0.30895558,
0.335465759,
0.1723270863,
-0.5513466001,
0.4929277003,
-0.1842428893,
0.8490742445,
0.7007886767,
0.0819180682,
0.0999235064,
-0.1588933915,
0.5499074459,
0.1082977057,
-0.1147038713,
-0.6063604355,
0.0619167015,
-0.8630153537,
0.0078907851,
0.2253333777,
0.3621515632,
-0.6284939051,
0.3626261055,
-0.4364219308,
-0.2595295906,
-0.4551899731,
0.2273268104,
0.4286370277,
0.5246127844,
0.4369584322,
0.0313320309,
-0.523643434,
-0.936552763,
0.0504847877,
-0.2591827214,
-0.0714530349,
0.236034736,
0.2378767431,
-0.3645710051,
0.7831836939,
-0.4889632463,
-0.3612655103,
-0.0918958634,
0.2427557707,
-0.2783028185,
0.6083612442,
0.5047239065,
-0.3752375543,
-0.177913025,
-0.0046540103,
-0.5799016953,
-0.1209862828,
-0.1260669678,
0.0477286242,
0.6250107288,
0.7495474815,
-0.7257180214,
0.2137654424,
0.7228303552,
-0.2200181782,
0.6263903975,
-0.4076840878,
-0.0549064577,
-1.2194627523,
0.1605500728,
-0.3698737323,
-0.3326640427,
-0.2858837247,
-0.1138048768,
0.3728664219,
-0.0565929078,
-0.1274393797,
0.3854197264,
-0.717541635,
0.0861136317,
-0.288510412,
-0.1265114397,
-0.0213964228,
0.5930709243,
0.2071372569,
0.6212056279,
0.6484137177,
-0.6358729601,
-0.1319391727,
0.2456319034,
-0.1610846072,
0.0284686927,
-0.4621095061,
0.206103608,
-0.3303873539,
0.2165594697,
-0.78700912,
-0.1013967916,
-0.1359477341,
-0.3080855608,
0.6516386867,
-0.3155894279,
-0.4787719846,
-0.292383194,
-0.0835947543,
0.4805731773,
0.5057654381,
-0.5217024684,
0.5815888047,
0.315248251,
-0.1906007081,
-0.5516288877,
-0.5638402104,
0.1218949333,
-0.2752473354,
-0.5424851179,
0.3413217068,
-0.2319639623,
0.1454966813,
0.1072769389,
-0.2527866066,
0.1192358956,
0.0983320996,
0.1468666047,
0.0687589198,
-0.2894338965,
0.5519430041,
0.1623133272,
0.0247215498,
0.1654647887,
-0.4434655011,
0.5778778195,
-0.2137017399,
-0.26377213,
0.0291066635,
0.3274530172,
0.6045114398,
-0.4786219597,
0.5270950198,
0.5464838147,
-0.3286411166,
-0.5947637558,
-0.6581565738,
-0.1870720387,
-0.4259609282,
0.5706536174,
-0.4110252559,
-1.1994042397,
0.4494746327,
-0.3700447381,
0.0374436565,
0.5124024153,
0.5087988377,
0.0078655751,
1.0597524643,
0.7621635199,
-0.1566656083,
0.4839083254,
-0.4096895754,
0.0116029028,
-0.7476510406,
0.015876079,
-0.3557342589,
-0.0550168119,
-0.4258872271,
-0.2954401076,
0.2516168654,
0.3173802197,
-0.4028299451,
0.1419243962,
-0.4876326323,
0.554503262,
0.6042906642,
-0.0875482559,
0.3519090116,
-0.0217256825,
-0.0799118057,
0.2473347783,
-0.9914857745,
-0.2577564716,
0.9912942052,
0.2308373898,
0.7530454993,
-0.1287377179,
0.9409208298,
-0.0552794635,
0.2577725351,
-0.6260498762,
0.4607268572,
-0.1865614206,
-0.5186165571,
-0.3503407538,
-0.6208203435,
-0.9992641211,
0.1592460871,
-0.0487020798,
-0.7283926606,
-0.0578121468,
0.6016965508,
-0.3882269859,
0.3620181382,
-0.7705990672,
0.978243947,
-0.2762665153,
-0.3031648099,
-0.3235543668,
-0.5153899789,
0.5351342559,
-0.2372484207,
0.0980528966,
-0.181109041,
0.2109149843,
0.6448786855,
-0.3815408647,
0.861789465,
-0.3330910504,
-0.2300192565,
0.313693583,
0.3903113604,
0.568649292,
-0.1851483285,
0.1495792568,
0.0113561107,
0.040668264,
-0.2594463825,
-0.6470327377,
0.7676870823,
-0.818279922,
-0.8566339612,
-0.0366063081,
-0.6065912247,
-0.3548637927,
0.2764351368,
0.2067344189,
0.2845758498,
-0.1404030621,
0.3340464234,
0.6998428106,
-0.1690704376,
0.6027249098,
0.3489990234,
-0.3365691006,
-0.438239634,
0.9220668077,
0.3026263118,
0.4877805412,
0.3092616498,
0.3303991556,
-0.3042371273,
-0.7415249348,
-0.4082819521,
0.265676558,
-0.5177540779,
-0.5465437174,
-0.5326057673,
-0.3743161857,
-0.3413252831,
0.0714723989,
-0.5508082509,
-0.4514980018,
-0.2788363695,
-0.2227739096,
0.2884327769,
0.7079251409,
-0.0967061818,
0.0932174474,
-1.0307369232,
0.2759075463,
0.2396667004,
0.4646621644,
0.040615581,
-0.3949114382,
-0.2734539509,
0.1226768047,
-0.3327782452,
-0.5308861732,
0.5945592523,
0.5505503416,
0.5714659691,
0.3729875684,
0.0944079906,
0.7542995214,
-0.5195605755,
0.466773808,
0.0800294057,
-0.9532167912,
0.6913707852,
-0.6091145277,
0.7289447188,
0.3400223553,
0.054172609,
-0.4458600581,
-0.2898435295,
-0.6458652616,
-0.9273939133,
0.680043757,
-0.1248532832,
0.0332815684,
-0.1897902787,
0.1993324459,
0.1129331812,
0.2267792672,
-0.8253547549,
0.1040853783,
-0.4178514779,
-0.1433450431,
-0.225538969,
-0.3685635626,
-0.0424591079,
-0.3005139828,
0.6431249976,
-0.3596113622,
0.0477565378,
0.0537738092,
-0.2079035044,
-0.3940232098,
0.2905671299,
0.5579476357,
0.6097688675,
-0.1681017429,
0.318229109,
0.1221181825,
-0.2152694315,
0.1937970221,
0.0025808904,
-0.3093129396,
-0.3115117252,
0.349385649,
0.774245441,
0.2407863438,
-0.5590918064,
0.1603889912,
0.1524493247,
-0.3427955806,
-0.2806848586,
0.1250673234,
0.2426625788,
0.0517148077,
0.3699230254,
0.1848490685,
-0.2313808352,
-0.4279453456,
0.2519487143,
0.5265809298,
0.05185109,
-0.3170588911,
0.6955458522,
0.1416433156,
-0.085851483,
0.7451402545,
-0.0302921738,
-0.5950912833,
0.2609404624,
0.7947481871,
1.0487487316,
-0.5876659751,
0.0841530189,
0.5729441643,
0.2640085816,
-0.2485224605,
0.0333209597,
-0.3209351301,
-0.6450416446,
-0.6332802773,
-0.7855414748,
0.1274766624,
0.3102967143,
-0.3771313429,
0.1039470434,
-0.5328429937,
-0.0107653523,
-0.3593288958,
-0.2383861542,
-0.5669591427,
0.0989186615,
0.275742799,
0.6123780012,
-0.6859651208,
1.2542047501,
0.3801341653,
-0.1755220741,
-1.0252873898,
0.0887164995,
-0.2914849818,
-0.7584792376,
0.6016301513,
0.1546894759,
-0.289647609,
0.2663024664,
-0.5191095471,
-1.1360266209,
1.1105363369,
0.753285706,
-0.7125998735,
-0.2684831917,
0.0886680037,
0.5844250917,
-0.3134252727,
-0.1265644133,
0.4920344949,
0.2604674995,
0.2187048793,
-0.9718205333,
-0.006527137,
-0.3344587386,
0.0231266767,
0.4386217594,
-0.7294998765,
0.8473516107,
-0.268528074,
-0.5179894567,
-0.2304195017,
0.4445984662,
0.2538335025,
-0.1660624146,
0.5090908408,
0.7159350514,
0.6858910918,
0.0934157744,
0.7894603014,
-0.441426456,
0.4448563159,
1.1907464266,
0.1490980238,
0.914876461,
0.3313951194,
0.1177569181,
0.2654587626,
0.5266121626,
0.0840635076,
0.4816050828,
0.3099375069,
-0.072961174,
-0.5871218443,
0.0449049436,
-0.4449658394,
0.5818015337,
0.4508245587,
-0.4616549611,
-0.4338417351,
-0.0475541689,
0.1213181168,
-0.012028222,
-0.4614519477,
0.8173686266,
-0.0166921001,
-0.9449256659,
1.2721502781,
-0.2108542919,
0.3005581498,
-0.6241942644,
-0.0819654763,
-0.1412928551,
0.4038640261,
-0.1104928553,
-0.4682858884,
0.4096871316,
-0.2458126545,
-0.1674076766,
-0.4537760317,
0.64836061,
-0.9325108528,
-0.5442897677,
0.2683422863,
0.5604307652,
-0.1340107471,
-0.0685383603,
-0.4425687492,
0.1891901493,
0.2155484557,
-0.3956096172,
0.233286798,
0.5377436876,
-0.1730817109,
0.9106562138,
0.378418386,
-0.0816206634,
0.1278200001,
0.0073632891,
0.914431572,
-0.7462345362,
-0.2949737906,
-0.8937088251,
0.3719404638,
0.2217085809,
-0.1954613179,
0.7498347163,
0.4907925427,
0.8086192012,
-0.2001646757,
0.9786071777,
0.1265552491,
0.5295287967,
-0.6117144823,
0.7953480482,
-0.5011981726,
0.152902931,
-0.2784820199,
-0.8870893121,
-0.4188019633,
0.4865914285,
-0.1332081407,
0.090413034,
0.648686409,
0.6550474167,
-0.1352538615,
-0.2286265939,
0.424519062,
0.5032060742,
0.3834851682,
0.8154737949,
0.7783690691,
-0.0824355483,
0.6744242907,
-0.0824704468,
-0.0206681136,
-0.1180418357,
-0.9317275882,
-0.9593808055,
-0.7514554262,
-0.4082349539,
-0.1224686876,
0.0495558716,
0.8448640704,
0.8595021367,
-0.6977036595,
-0.0968615338,
-0.3007851839,
-0.1615334153,
0.0176172778,
-0.1587703377,
0.6495696306,
-0.3546814919,
-0.4305173159,
0.5339714289,
0.2249063998,
0.2140540332,
-0.5516899228,
-0.1041474417,
-0.0705083832,
-0.2260874957,
0.6647861004,
0.4120652378,
-0.7717045546,
-0.4818578959,
-0.0884034559,
0.2381111234,
0.1249966323,
0.6608153582,
-1.1308815479,
0.4662896395,
0.3100753129,
0.6970205903,
0.7444130182,
0.1587744206,
0.7589235306,
-0.8832395673,
-0.1292147338,
0.3072572351,
0.4517446458,
0.4298917055,
-0.223728627,
0.3820180595,
0.1515830606,
-0.635751009,
-0.6914822459,
0.4086920023,
-0.7374180555,
-0.3762044609,
1.0530385971,
-0.0906178355,
-0.2939559817,
0.1658047289,
-0.1935937852,
0.2695404291,
-0.2031940818,
1.136934042,
0.6505637169,
-0.0571490303,
-0.5721507072,
-0.1319417208,
0.6928607225,
0.3812710941,
-0.6730294824,
0.7138370275,
0.8180958629,
0.4099139869,
0.0596389659,
0.4801584184,
0.0661283582,
0.0651679337,
-0.0070038424,
0.2296682298,
-0.5174107552,
-0.4639508724,
-0.1692478657,
0.4168423712,
0.1370383948,
-0.064021796
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11353v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11353v1 | $\texttt{MoE-RBench}$: Towards Building Reliable Language Models with Sparse Mixture-of-Experts | 2024-06-17T09:17:05 | 2024-06-17T09:17:05 | Guanjie Chen, Xinyu Zhao, Tianlong Chen, Yu Cheng | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Mixture-of-Experts (MoE) has gained increasing popularity as a promising
framework for scaling up large language models (LLMs). However, the reliability
assessment of MoE lags behind its surging applications. Moreover, when
transferred to new domains such as in fine-tuning MoE models sometimes
underperform their dense counterparts. Motivated by the research gap and
counter-intuitive phenomenon, we propose $\texttt{MoE-RBench}$, the first
comprehensive assessment of SMoE reliability from three aspects: $\textit{(i)}$
safety and hallucination, $\textit{(ii)}$ resilience to adversarial attacks,
and $\textit{(iii)}$ out-of-distribution robustness. Extensive models and
datasets are tested to compare the MoE to dense networks from these reliability
dimensions. Our empirical observations suggest that with appropriate
hyperparameters, training recipes, and inference techniques, we can build the
MoE model more reliably than the dense LLM. In particular, we find that the
robustness of SMoE is sensitive to the basic training settings. We hope that
this study can provide deeper insights into how to adapt the pre-trained MoE
model to other tasks with higher-generation security, quality, and stability.
Codes are available at https://github.com/UNITES-Lab/MoE-RBench | [
-0.6176921725,
-0.8514074087,
0.3047843874,
0.2501880825,
-0.0928577334,
-0.2110058218,
-0.3954578042,
-0.3627986312,
0.2448377758,
0.3047888875,
-0.3168923259,
-0.0906323195,
-0.8971933722,
0.1314515471,
-0.3735282421,
0.89718014,
0.3032341599,
-0.0791065916,
-0.2751869857,
-0.242591083,
-0.5342479944,
-0.1691887379,
-0.3121845424,
-0.1547535062,
0.399562031,
0.4774535596,
0.8143134713,
0.3720695674,
0.6266836524,
0.3094501495,
0.1148765162,
0.0042619598,
-0.6638723016,
0.3118129969,
-0.1183044389,
-0.2677933872,
-0.755384624,
-0.2017414421,
0.6505104899,
0.6346189976,
-0.5531610847,
-0.1886572689,
0.2763561904,
0.6028712392,
-0.6250796318,
-0.1979632974,
-1.2113648653,
-0.3737813532,
-0.265426755,
-0.081748113,
-0.6137113571,
0.2498118132,
0.1403356791,
-0.267593503,
0.0598451383,
0.1625372171,
0.8036390543,
0.2639582753,
-0.3726680279,
-0.0047063101,
-0.4736988246,
1.1949921846,
-0.7261066437,
0.5291364193,
0.6693883538,
0.3430055082,
-0.2099971473,
-0.5131785274,
-0.2151343375,
-0.6502327323,
0.2143659741,
0.1496690512,
0.0549732894,
0.0044749244,
-0.1390140355,
0.2270348966,
-0.5151023865,
0.0835540071,
-0.3238505125,
-0.1892658621,
0.5990299582,
-0.0271052588,
0.3398649096,
-0.0523927808,
-0.5790452361,
0.0912585855,
-0.5487107635,
-0.4595636427,
0.3055178225,
0.0828663334,
0.0184731968,
0.3988490999,
-0.078319177,
0.5358830094,
-0.0219463073,
-0.1640553474,
0.1026718244,
-0.1330407858,
-0.0930751339,
-0.2605860531,
0.9458007812,
0.2898668051,
0.2865012288,
-0.4101363719,
-0.2516182959,
-0.223787725,
0.5201104283,
-0.8657783866,
-0.4508411586,
0.350543052,
-0.2555291653,
-0.3488117754,
0.1835882366,
-0.5694029927,
-0.0895993188,
-0.0873898715,
0.4669523835,
-0.5825561881,
-0.4906432033,
-0.1517131925,
0.1132176742,
-0.3276553452,
0.1550779939,
-0.8707768917,
0.1658716947,
0.5949382782,
0.7772499919,
-0.1176304147,
-0.7314530611,
-0.3860953152,
0.1900474429,
-0.1560846716,
0.6916143894,
-0.2964425385,
-0.3423765898,
-0.4207418263,
-0.1598937511,
-0.0285811685,
-0.5878299475,
0.3952840269,
-0.356983453,
-0.0029745169,
-0.1966794431,
-0.4876303971,
-0.0694625899,
0.5010770559,
-0.4000895619,
1.0648355484,
0.2357270271,
-0.9001598954,
0.3935333192,
-0.3104335964,
-0.3982082903,
0.0627717078,
-0.1831273735,
-0.4270195067,
0.0461200364,
0.1828920245,
0.8437655568,
-0.3323151469,
0.498927772,
-0.937538743,
-0.2092968225,
0.4075058699,
-0.7598843575,
0.9786102772,
-0.0368253477,
-0.2814747095,
-0.1713136584,
-0.9487913251,
0.1563224494,
-0.0670294538,
-0.0673494786,
-0.2897540331,
0.0374803133,
-0.132480219,
0.0243726503,
0.2599244118,
-0.4310776889,
-0.1621728539,
-0.1544845402,
0.4966286719,
1.0130643845,
-0.0559377149,
0.4997808933,
-0.1816385835,
0.3305192292,
-0.0150009878,
0.2715429962,
-0.0505723432,
-0.5908960104,
-0.4535571039,
-0.6226411462,
0.5100731254,
0.6117764115,
-0.7541280985,
0.792529583,
-0.4824313223,
-0.5588977337,
-0.2702584863,
0.3866392076,
0.297100544,
0.4389125407,
0.2285397798,
-0.479647696,
-0.2809332311,
-0.8295301795,
0.1045205668,
-0.2434922755,
0.1104097068,
0.2297522128,
0.5578017235,
-0.8717473745,
0.8254383206,
-0.0436382219,
0.105500333,
-0.170498535,
0.1273550838,
-0.178553462,
0.5027956963,
0.7572622299,
-0.4470711052,
-0.581330061,
0.3758352399,
-0.7745108604,
0.0293638874,
0.3494791985,
-0.3815341294,
-0.0261174235,
0.0721746385,
-0.4425310791,
0.0636923835,
0.8573322296,
0.0410234295,
0.6070705652,
-0.1616400182,
0.162185505,
-1.0133531094,
0.0334317535,
-0.1379525959,
-0.177474156,
-0.4750354588,
0.2893100381,
-0.0493468344,
-0.0691202879,
-0.1354549378,
0.5970996022,
-0.3630788326,
-0.0374628417,
-0.26890558,
0.0759016275,
-0.2455718815,
0.4426167905,
-0.335393101,
0.7565467954,
0.7397280335,
-0.6084691882,
0.4033433795,
-0.1777306348,
-0.3860775232,
0.8030287027,
-0.8380284309,
0.2120155543,
0.2376765609,
-0.2024134099,
-0.7111567259,
-0.5039874315,
0.0990230069,
-0.6192215085,
0.5509548783,
-0.0286279302,
-0.4459633529,
-0.1534336209,
-0.1535634398,
0.3531760871,
0.5663046241,
-0.2428610027,
0.7229909897,
0.5224516392,
-0.415215075,
-0.7908016443,
-0.8025001884,
-0.0717067942,
0.0451144949,
-1.1624122858,
-0.2324700803,
-0.2295977473,
-0.3394152224,
0.0355330668,
-0.1382880658,
-0.5547276735,
0.4642536342,
0.2127232552,
0.0754277408,
-0.3448562026,
-0.2789607644,
0.165325135,
-0.302372247,
-0.0969225243,
0.0982730463,
0.271864593,
-0.320869863,
-0.4090051353,
-0.218702808,
0.2351563722,
0.6719104052,
0.0719384924,
0.9947003126,
0.4580586255,
-0.1510322392,
-0.3893105686,
-0.6089741588,
-0.3918136358,
-0.4792007208,
0.5978602171,
-0.215436399,
-0.7462597489,
0.5624431968,
0.1998589784,
0.1930558383,
0.454118073,
0.6082273126,
-0.3257284462,
0.7466294169,
0.6085211039,
-0.1065979153,
0.3489007056,
0.0871182084,
0.1302028,
-0.4875508845,
0.1556259245,
-0.3132812083,
-0.1152334884,
-0.2614193857,
-0.2106327116,
0.4844843447,
0.1927814335,
-0.0232459269,
0.4357650578,
-0.1927694082,
0.4029296339,
0.3167961538,
0.1223353595,
-0.0784251764,
0.2191201895,
-0.1103856042,
0.0446272567,
-0.8935877085,
-0.5285072327,
1.1580582857,
0.5314481854,
0.6934037209,
0.0047432249,
0.6786711812,
0.0996631235,
0.6788483858,
-0.4892466366,
0.6516605616,
-0.1393648833,
-0.9285345674,
-0.5011997819,
-0.8098044991,
-0.8034331203,
0.4303082526,
-0.0671321824,
-0.5640798807,
0.1154172421,
0.4187030792,
-0.2368055582,
0.1705721468,
-0.7644996047,
0.6818600297,
-0.3952021897,
-0.4118338525,
-0.1715295017,
-0.7093417645,
0.6582833529,
-0.1258319467,
0.2713499069,
-0.2538563311,
0.2586782575,
0.4795290828,
-0.5179029703,
0.6427429318,
0.1453011334,
-0.1309182942,
0.4226430357,
0.2171823084,
0.4704815447,
0.1243076101,
-0.3245434165,
0.4069583416,
-0.2577286661,
-0.6667470932,
-0.7447320223,
0.7806404829,
-0.7077599764,
-0.0902149305,
-0.1443216056,
-0.5208404064,
-0.4485955536,
0.2722892463,
0.4098937809,
0.52780509,
-0.1169623137,
0.6964969039,
0.7499083281,
0.1563809216,
-0.0295820963,
0.2620173991,
-0.037824899,
-0.8071575165,
1.162212491,
0.3526937366,
0.442717731,
0.1771258116,
0.0688088611,
0.1611898243,
-0.4428009391,
-0.5349942446,
0.0004469194,
-0.5078866482,
-0.1815755665,
-0.4802201986,
-0.2648513317,
-0.1953759789,
-0.3091269732,
-0.718388617,
-0.1785621196,
-0.1286435872,
-0.1612495631,
0.0881858766,
0.5540764928,
-0.0791100413,
0.5256806016,
-1.0009799004,
0.2889140844,
0.6065549254,
0.3591864407,
0.1615167111,
-0.544403255,
-0.4342187941,
0.1827402264,
-0.2838788927,
-0.6849725246,
0.0196523275,
0.114336662,
0.7353981137,
0.6491652131,
-0.0979553089,
0.4781657755,
-0.4724721909,
0.6716451645,
0.3031342924,
-0.6666260362,
0.2417273372,
-0.5649382472,
-0.3071525991,
0.7255672812,
0.1497074366,
0.1735431999,
-0.4834124148,
-0.9185292125,
-0.9113473892,
0.3789984882,
0.4800239503,
0.0277754832,
-0.1066850722,
0.1618289202,
0.3555958569,
0.3680094481,
-0.7618857622,
-0.2332618237,
-0.1038031206,
-0.2473272234,
-0.0790680572,
-0.7074901462,
-0.080352433,
-0.0007086557,
0.9990867972,
0.1821577251,
0.2086847723,
-0.2335335165,
-0.2868210673,
-0.1251552701,
0.3239604235,
0.6667494178,
0.8796157241,
-0.44045645,
0.1807686239,
0.2389070541,
-0.6140266061,
0.1315538287,
-0.0913389176,
-0.2798038721,
-0.0493908711,
0.5869612098,
0.811811924,
0.4354878962,
-0.5724365711,
0.5300600529,
0.2496060282,
-0.1677940637,
0.0755490512,
0.1882245243,
-0.2350943983,
-0.1655967236,
0.1607907563,
0.3731019497,
-0.04046233,
-0.5612202883,
0.4604700804,
0.424234271,
-0.3077016771,
-0.4241822362,
0.2775196433,
0.5528118014,
0.0947222784,
0.5202935934,
-0.3125276864,
-0.4605513215,
0.4657899737,
0.202896893,
0.8178040981,
-0.3468740284,
-0.0028165719,
0.0699416324,
0.8229907751,
-0.4016850293,
0.0650269911,
0.0222936124,
-0.6862500906,
-0.3906945288,
-0.3403062224,
-0.3902001083,
-0.2428533733,
-0.7258045673,
0.025294669,
-0.4540212452,
-0.3749966323,
-0.7186952233,
-0.2352045923,
-0.3431121409,
0.264954716,
-0.2612303197,
0.6518031955,
-0.832762897,
0.6123614311,
0.5839605927,
0.0606359206,
-0.5380636454,
0.1114856079,
-0.3056304753,
-0.9287917614,
0.4035846889,
0.041100353,
-0.2227914631,
-0.1830876023,
-0.6688581705,
-0.6829305291,
1.0543825626,
0.6084312797,
-0.8478631377,
0.2979337573,
-0.3207812905,
0.2241864204,
0.0769303963,
0.3975217938,
0.3221257925,
0.3201755583,
-0.0250424538,
-0.9819652438,
-0.3649490178,
-0.128783837,
-0.0945414752,
0.3040527105,
-0.7310427427,
0.7877249122,
-0.1983105838,
-0.0143913385,
0.1930668205,
1.0684798956,
0.542263031,
0.3782166839,
0.443151027,
0.913402319,
0.7894464731,
-0.0205467511,
1.1267857552,
-0.4192948341,
0.544211328,
1.1133564711,
-0.2125648707,
1.0566762686,
0.3046173453,
-0.3309579492,
0.4682753384,
0.1246839836,
0.2452471703,
0.5529883504,
-0.2219211459,
-0.0061986553,
-0.376455009,
0.5054120421,
-0.4849381745,
-0.123386994,
0.3061536252,
-0.1569746286,
-0.0094100069,
0.0292427186,
-0.2445051074,
-0.3046964705,
-0.2341525406,
0.3844185472,
0.407225132,
-0.2830167115,
0.3446314633,
-0.0653100312,
0.6988216639,
-0.7480939031,
0.383988142,
-0.1805904061,
0.0840361714,
-0.0454488806,
-0.7328773141,
-0.0012404431,
-0.2097202986,
-0.4546462595,
0.1523523182,
0.8284067512,
-0.3541123867,
-0.5670803189,
0.3320890367,
0.3333732486,
0.2194654047,
0.0479851626,
-0.7795702815,
0.2020336539,
-0.1465957612,
-0.3216406405,
0.4949527383,
0.8076444268,
0.2991153896,
0.9394379854,
0.3493640423,
0.080587782,
0.5646688342,
-0.1554785371,
0.401170224,
-0.2609073818,
-0.3416365981,
-0.8077269793,
0.8608384728,
0.0293758102,
-0.3234246075,
0.9167958498,
0.0396582335,
0.7321039438,
-0.0585974678,
0.8317127228,
-0.0311251227,
0.3476760089,
-0.4874531031,
0.7453289032,
-0.6386052966,
0.121588245,
-0.3051300049,
-0.9851371646,
-0.0227046385,
0.7192241549,
-0.0296515375,
0.4291756153,
0.616132915,
0.7408538461,
-0.4570444822,
-0.2070623934,
0.6151052713,
0.4805891514,
-0.0408657454,
0.2170213908,
0.7677958012,
-0.5043773651,
0.448042661,
-0.5960189104,
-0.2504074275,
-0.5357877016,
-0.90011096,
-0.9568856955,
-0.3387894928,
-0.5026009679,
-0.3470734656,
-0.0314097516,
0.6758899093,
0.9008706808,
-0.8598660827,
-0.0355180278,
-0.1406627893,
0.0794669837,
-0.2407825887,
-0.2225477099,
-0.0037555941,
-0.3253236115,
-0.393053025,
0.3252606094,
0.5279968977,
0.030525405,
-0.3503894806,
-0.3149876893,
0.3128566444,
0.0434133857,
0.5784907341,
0.1601608843,
-0.7390970588,
-0.0391783379,
-0.1323377937,
-0.1691586226,
-0.2289214283,
0.471000433,
-0.0053487108,
0.4387029409,
0.4866699576,
0.965803206,
-0.3413039446,
0.0054583251,
0.6601971388,
-0.671805203,
0.0547109395,
0.1953716427,
0.721221745,
0.2054414153,
-0.1757987142,
0.3513923883,
0.3548835516,
-0.945171833,
-1.1340779066,
0.1450319737,
-1.1209605932,
-0.0744996667,
1.2238663435,
-0.2508425713,
-0.1723604798,
0.0179593675,
-0.1740544587,
-0.2307785749,
-0.4141007066,
0.6866617799,
1.0522859097,
0.1833028495,
-0.1799582094,
-0.580473125,
-0.1790837646,
0.7282575965,
-0.5742456317,
-0.0966702104,
0.2054535449,
0.5125422478,
0.239047423,
0.6034995317,
0.1068150476,
0.3039998412,
0.1664468348,
0.0716882497,
-0.1095843762,
-0.835516274,
-0.0326155536,
0.272674799,
0.2969438136,
0.0875456929
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15484v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15484v1 | JobFair: A Framework for Benchmarking Gender Hiring Bias in Large Language Models | 2024-06-17T09:15:57 | 2024-06-17T09:15:57 | Ze Wang, Zekun Wu, Xin Guan, Michael Thaler, Adriano Koshiyama, Skylar Lu, Sachin Beepath, Ediz Ertekin Jr., Maria Perez-Ortiz | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY | This paper presents a novel framework for benchmarking hierarchical gender
hiring bias in Large Language Models (LLMs) for resume scoring, revealing
significant issues of reverse bias and overdebiasing. Our contributions are
fourfold: First, we introduce a framework using a real, anonymized resume
dataset from the Healthcare, Finance, and Construction industries, meticulously
used to avoid confounding factors. It evaluates gender hiring biases across
hierarchical levels, including Level bias, Spread bias, Taste-based bias, and
Statistical bias. This framework can be generalized to other social traits and
tasks easily. Second, we propose novel statistical and computational hiring
bias metrics based on a counterfactual approach, including Rank After Scoring
(RAS), Rank-based Impact Ratio, Permutation Test-Based Metrics, and Fixed
Effects Model-based Metrics. These metrics, rooted in labor economics, NLP, and
law, enable holistic evaluation of hiring biases. Third, we analyze hiring
biases in ten state-of-the-art LLMs. Six out of ten LLMs show significant
biases against males in healthcare and finance. An industry-effect regression
reveals that the healthcare industry is the most biased against males. GPT-4o
and GPT-3.5 are the most biased models, showing significant bias in all three
industries. Conversely, Gemini-1.5-Pro, Llama3-8b-Instruct, and
Llama3-70b-Instruct are the least biased. The hiring bias of all LLMs, except
for Llama3-8b-Instruct and Claude-3-Sonnet, remains consistent regardless of
random expansion or reduction of resume content. Finally, we offer a
user-friendly demo to facilitate adoption and practical application of the
framework. | [
0.0325679481,
-0.4813630879,
0.5208905935,
0.2748689353,
0.4979777336,
0.1148079857,
0.2744686604,
-0.2820324898,
0.0661438406,
0.4577411711,
-0.7438774705,
-0.4980036616,
-0.5526089668,
-0.0672055036,
-0.5402633548,
0.8554881215,
0.2365952134,
0.3391891718,
-0.5415896773,
0.0251222476,
-0.6035661101,
-0.471227169,
-0.6194128394,
-0.3427847326,
0.4852733612,
0.3861255646,
0.6834970713,
0.5288855433,
0.3598206937,
0.1916113049,
-0.0966608897,
-0.1334737539,
-0.6364793777,
0.2909435928,
-0.3895301819,
-0.3274793327,
-0.560169518,
0.3136156499,
0.6737756729,
0.8964703679,
-0.3576137722,
0.5752449036,
-0.2643140256,
0.7812937498,
-0.8520975113,
0.112734437,
-0.5621418357,
-0.0787787661,
-0.2450079173,
-0.0636674166,
-0.103644371,
-0.4597244263,
-0.0067437049,
-0.0701442286,
0.4167239666,
0.340444833,
0.7220122814,
-0.1273850352,
-0.7344486713,
-0.0436239205,
-0.5440994501,
0.9435833693,
-0.5564435124,
0.7914704084,
0.4790291786,
0.4389188588,
-0.340447247,
-0.329234302,
-0.3130236268,
-0.1259517521,
0.0388053581,
0.0102493893,
-0.0734218583,
-0.0157602727,
0.2029936314,
0.4496649504,
-0.5465685129,
0.2754221857,
-0.3074540198,
-0.0307798646,
0.5676042438,
0.1645463705,
0.127199322,
0.2586484551,
-0.1886194795,
-0.2685328722,
-0.7459363341,
0.0464555211,
0.9101473689,
0.1242217049,
-0.0137816742,
0.4772976041,
-0.2697314322,
0.5433363318,
0.3072733581,
-0.3054856658,
0.4137547016,
-0.029166704,
-0.0215133056,
0.1075262651,
0.6489508152,
0.4572141171,
-0.0126920231,
-0.0354006588,
-0.3161633015,
-0.1456933916,
0.6608845592,
-0.7164515257,
0.4064178467,
0.1556622088,
-0.6211740375,
-0.3052706718,
0.0876291618,
-1.045550108,
-0.6793446541,
0.1098128706,
0.1405780762,
0.2095130384,
-0.0333945416,
-0.1262624115,
-0.2290099859,
0.3854885399,
-0.0217894055,
-0.8822837472,
0.4262282848,
0.9509233832,
0.6409497261,
-0.3271114528,
-0.3277249336,
-0.8280420303,
0.0243294016,
-0.6299228072,
0.5280956626,
-0.7110236287,
-0.2370251268,
0.2716661096,
0.0235862173,
-0.2049391568,
-0.8604540229,
0.6033177376,
-0.3392670155,
0.1849547774,
-0.3942399323,
-0.2455767542,
-0.1380962282,
0.3646145761,
-0.7513311505,
1.1913144588,
0.463100791,
-0.7058196068,
0.7485692501,
-0.5729492903,
-0.3312952816,
-0.4042827189,
-0.7689311504,
-0.4793704152,
-0.1171444654,
-0.0879752412,
0.3519678712,
-0.7652950883,
0.5255739689,
-0.2724627256,
-0.5254454613,
0.0431373455,
-0.2274937928,
0.7546963692,
-0.1148241609,
-0.3005461693,
0.1236358956,
-0.4954926372,
-0.5036590099,
-0.1336557418,
-0.2035870105,
-0.1099831909,
-0.1275341809,
-0.0243514702,
0.5249457359,
0.0918748975,
-0.7314924002,
-0.2148811221,
-0.2621935904,
-0.0310976841,
0.7093300819,
-0.1537338048,
0.3877593875,
-0.5831905603,
0.8861048818,
0.0288912915,
0.1020721495,
0.2366976589,
-0.3148019016,
-0.1787090898,
-0.6506171227,
0.0888454095,
0.6286886334,
-0.272816062,
0.4617321193,
-0.054045707,
-0.5900702477,
-0.5928768516,
0.1738899201,
0.4648753703,
0.74161762,
0.2382864654,
-0.3530418277,
-0.5920932293,
-1.3544483185,
-0.8171738386,
-0.3471218348,
0.0317693539,
0.164931342,
0.6808626652,
-0.4955247343,
0.9774929881,
-0.3531336486,
-0.6309168935,
-0.0871393532,
0.1480993778,
0.7365518808,
0.7063214183,
0.5248507261,
-0.6708161235,
0.1641652286,
-0.3214553595,
-0.513047576,
-0.2378004044,
-0.0712663084,
-0.4138254523,
0.0680764988,
0.3307303488,
-0.5256592035,
0.424312979,
0.7026745677,
-0.6786346436,
0.6729431748,
0.0462144017,
0.3805550635,
-0.7679671645,
0.4377032816,
0.4476961493,
-0.261772126,
-0.4652980566,
0.121984154,
-0.3345101774,
0.1291380525,
-0.2049718648,
0.7908815145,
-0.2128316313,
-0.4619120359,
-0.1000379547,
-0.3249626458,
0.1147851571,
0.2977757454,
-0.2271786481,
0.5846381783,
0.1775217652,
-0.1857624054,
0.176716432,
0.3781039715,
-0.3817098439,
0.9651474953,
-0.5292389989,
0.0914679766,
-0.3129273653,
0.8139379621,
-1.1267822981,
0.0398308747,
-0.0902953744,
-0.1520721167,
0.0293598715,
-0.2659268975,
-0.4269251823,
-0.4106574655,
-0.4914957285,
0.5696667433,
0.4387165904,
-0.3255831897,
0.7365686893,
0.5291962028,
-0.2471904308,
-1.0182921886,
-0.8274233937,
0.0317659825,
-0.0698861033,
-0.1575764567,
0.6033514142,
0.0928675085,
-0.4278841317,
-0.4691610634,
-0.4234377444,
-0.4856829047,
0.0483563393,
0.5183275938,
0.4859673381,
0.1311061382,
-0.2279724926,
0.1136886925,
-0.0916664377,
0.3070136011,
-0.0752633139,
0.4027993679,
-0.0676026866,
-0.537606895,
-0.1155034751,
0.296729207,
0.6684621572,
0.2807388306,
0.7013212442,
0.9675797224,
-0.5255224109,
0.229900986,
-1.0939035416,
-0.2007445544,
-0.4097431004,
0.4446583092,
0.0095677665,
-0.9744927287,
0.5715756416,
-0.0075987736,
0.3353541493,
0.5581362844,
0.7182667255,
0.1072318181,
0.9881766438,
0.7268160582,
-0.3388344944,
0.1664301455,
-0.1842461675,
0.0898357481,
-0.4598144293,
-0.3498251736,
-0.7541656494,
-0.3271168172,
-0.7836473584,
-0.3774567842,
0.1215507761,
-0.2146064639,
-0.4027894735,
-0.0753057078,
-0.0794068724,
0.206663236,
0.6394429803,
-0.0923277438,
0.1137404963,
-0.2726378441,
-0.36896047,
-0.0159341414,
-0.5597758889,
-0.4334586859,
0.8224543929,
0.6043297052,
0.5542944074,
-0.0132593606,
0.4964108765,
0.6328083873,
0.3393613398,
-0.3639939725,
0.3801911771,
-0.4294860959,
-1.048843503,
-0.2424999028,
-0.4627212286,
-0.5821919441,
0.3047695458,
-0.4543483555,
-0.6600555182,
0.6878647804,
0.2006209046,
-0.0436176471,
0.2291881442,
-0.2208123356,
0.9732709527,
-0.0015830045,
-0.6297727823,
-0.1787814349,
-0.3591354489,
0.2206092775,
-0.3430608511,
0.6114190817,
-0.3802087605,
-0.0657766089,
0.9321339726,
-0.4682323635,
0.8967605829,
-0.4058290124,
-0.2200330794,
-0.3122948706,
0.2694872618,
0.2510940135,
-0.0422803052,
-0.7366831303,
0.6726516485,
0.279795289,
-0.4129773378,
-0.2580613792,
0.671818614,
-0.6198853254,
-0.4436762333,
-0.5401965976,
-0.573154211,
-0.4341696799,
0.3558558226,
-0.0473771356,
0.3781721294,
-0.4087367952,
0.196264416,
0.2144051641,
-0.4596890807,
-0.2235352695,
0.4445789754,
-0.3452355266,
-0.1952739656,
0.542937398,
0.1202138588,
-0.209818393,
0.330879122,
0.1214349419,
-0.2888988853,
-0.0229366571,
-0.3289963007,
0.2545731068,
-0.4877727032,
-0.0061749294,
-0.5854886174,
-0.0780187175,
-0.5821791887,
-0.2131682485,
-0.502818048,
0.0043203081,
0.1847354472,
-0.1160966903,
0.0727150068,
0.5837689638,
0.1706361622,
0.2013395429,
-0.085446015,
0.5627241135,
0.3983043432,
0.7166280746,
0.0582585596,
-0.6188243032,
-0.2455175966,
-0.0148366764,
-0.0901073813,
-0.519192934,
0.3073164821,
0.1145828292,
0.9097132683,
0.3598935604,
-0.1187756881,
0.4959805608,
-0.4262246192,
0.6950553656,
0.1702099293,
-0.8270654678,
0.1695003957,
-0.566277504,
0.1845452785,
1.0965892076,
0.5729575157,
-0.6500096917,
-0.3561504483,
-0.4183880687,
-0.9575591087,
0.7694832683,
0.1638254821,
-0.0068313736,
-0.293174386,
0.3065710962,
0.3559505045,
0.6317917705,
-0.3540698886,
-0.3236286342,
0.0097421138,
-0.3868680596,
0.0514304265,
-0.5291982889,
-0.171265915,
-0.2737426162,
0.7063449025,
0.0214573313,
0.3169957697,
0.0396094136,
-0.0616985522,
-0.1324446499,
0.2566311955,
0.5256829262,
0.9228140116,
-0.6371049881,
0.0174832046,
0.2875796258,
-0.6114125252,
0.1652924865,
0.1077230126,
0.1343474835,
0.1444541961,
0.3098020852,
0.4060665369,
0.1761034578,
-0.9026325941,
0.9419868588,
-0.0019647607,
-0.460586071,
-0.5183557868,
-0.0624253228,
-0.0362710804,
0.4406159818,
0.7492577434,
-0.2284252048,
0.3706642389,
-0.6388869882,
0.0165436566,
0.5671454668,
-0.8456785083,
0.0568803176,
0.7464972734,
0.0488657802,
-0.1663850099,
0.3862040043,
0.1696359515,
-0.1852329075,
0.7117845416,
0.595066011,
0.9816226363,
-0.2012899816,
0.0456110686,
0.362370044,
0.1672211885,
-0.543323338,
0.2750781178,
0.295897603,
-0.700627327,
-0.2673051655,
-0.4998260438,
-0.6568049192,
0.0297011584,
-0.7363889217,
0.073490195,
-0.6577429771,
-0.3566491008,
-0.1265143901,
-0.2362876683,
-0.9913907647,
0.3999990225,
0.0365078859,
0.8731647134,
-1.0071336031,
0.3489612937,
0.9071568251,
-0.0866275728,
-0.212334305,
0.0763511956,
0.3671723902,
-0.7971333861,
0.9455286264,
0.3609876335,
-0.4008247256,
-0.3149142861,
-0.1525669545,
-0.5926173329,
1.1297857761,
0.605576098,
-0.5794296861,
-0.2202278227,
0.1244045272,
0.3563485444,
-0.6639643908,
0.8443812728,
0.7342048287,
0.3579051793,
-0.2161482424,
-1.1116724014,
0.1127502844,
-0.2432635128,
0.1457176805,
-0.3080925941,
-0.5172421336,
0.7175531983,
0.1033599451,
0.1920598447,
-0.169530347,
0.2646451592,
0.5949887633,
0.3673845828,
0.9596289992,
0.1698955297,
0.6827095151,
0.0932553411,
0.8084213734,
-0.3567559421,
0.1532638073,
0.8713109493,
-0.6704260111,
0.6411055326,
0.5365436673,
-0.2028908283,
0.9793456197,
0.2943422794,
-0.0638442412,
0.1312737167,
0.328941077,
0.1380842775,
-0.2531980872,
-0.5205325484,
-0.4065644443,
0.6006112099,
0.0524147004,
-0.6145766973,
-0.1598114073,
-0.2145611048,
0.1050467417,
0.0282733683,
-0.1549001485,
0.4553495049,
0.1510093063,
-0.4932925701,
0.2900817692,
0.1981454939,
0.816496551,
-0.5254730582,
-0.3105523586,
-0.3420824409,
0.0263713617,
-0.4427988827,
-0.475664258,
-0.0114226472,
-0.0569007732,
-0.5535766482,
-0.3244585395,
0.7206232548,
-0.3647252619,
-0.5823245049,
0.441812098,
0.6473244429,
-0.0340540968,
0.0865808502,
-0.7399334908,
0.0570296422,
-0.3402941227,
-0.1735273898,
0.5141937137,
-0.0457020774,
-0.1985069811,
0.726949811,
0.6254069209,
0.223711729,
-0.3961932063,
0.4230147302,
0.417807281,
-0.7763829827,
-0.9507626295,
-0.8658245802,
0.1488539577,
-0.085879229,
-0.2960027754,
0.5215066671,
0.7271012068,
0.618512392,
0.0362056047,
0.4640714824,
0.2539021075,
0.8159601688,
-0.1570200771,
0.6817173362,
-0.5293981433,
0.2853950858,
-0.8585275412,
-0.9696184993,
-0.0393272229,
0.5994761586,
-0.530862093,
0.6375355721,
0.3411989808,
1.0040025711,
0.0487708151,
-0.2725843191,
0.2323414683,
0.0861830413,
0.1317717582,
0.1528221369,
0.5368431807,
-0.4173710048,
0.2877630889,
0.0352308378,
-0.1528227627,
-0.6389458179,
-1.0117663145,
-0.6816601157,
-0.3733501136,
-0.5601038933,
-0.3927271366,
0.4985645711,
1.0004255772,
0.92517519,
-0.6671476364,
-0.7267448902,
0.3202621937,
0.223933205,
-0.5805208683,
-0.2818124294,
0.0156704038,
0.0716693923,
-0.2800697684,
0.3581526577,
0.2879568934,
-0.6087529063,
-0.4248227477,
-0.0158667825,
-0.6105352044,
0.0269960724,
0.4212777913,
0.1717651486,
-0.5366715193,
-0.0512751639,
-0.3979567587,
-0.3397046328,
-0.0667183623,
0.8235198855,
-0.7282658815,
0.0790950879,
0.3669039011,
0.6709530354,
0.2444656491,
0.1720719188,
0.8417630196,
-0.8117260337,
-0.0783564523,
-0.0382037759,
0.3470450938,
0.2799234688,
-0.4343807697,
0.5143887401,
0.209098354,
-0.4117600322,
-0.9227698445,
-0.0037438045,
-0.7687792778,
-0.2082892656,
1.2172379494,
0.2240669131,
-0.0307857804,
-0.2654006779,
0.0841471702,
0.2432955354,
-0.5677276254,
0.8133323193,
0.3909589946,
0.1574089974,
0.080869399,
-1.0052995682,
0.3126409054,
0.5363349915,
-0.4360235631,
0.0747138783,
0.6002717018,
0.3722341061,
-0.180124864,
0.9101404548,
-0.2378489077,
0.605674684,
-0.1575014591,
0.3349063396,
-0.0319085456,
-0.1354892701,
-0.3573245704,
0.1080018356,
0.2241736054,
0.0398156159
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11345v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11345v1 | Full-ECE: A Metric For Token-level Calibration on Large Language Models | 2024-06-17T09:07:58 | 2024-06-17T09:07:58 | Han Liu, Yupeng Zhang, Bingning Wang, Weipeng Chen, Xiaolin Hu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Deep Neural Networks (DNNs) excel in various domains but face challenges in
providing accurate uncertainty estimates, which are crucial for high-stakes
applications. Large Language Models (LLMs) have recently emerged as powerful
tools, demonstrating exceptional performance in language tasks. However,
traditional calibration metrics such as Expected Calibration Error (ECE) and
classwise-ECE (cw-ECE) are inadequate for LLMs due to their vast vocabularies,
data complexity, and distributional focus. To address this, we propose a novel
calibration concept called full calibration and introduce its corresponding
metric, Full-ECE. Full-ECE evaluates the entire predicted probability
distribution, offering a more accurate and robust measure of calibration for
LLMs. | [
-0.3196446598,
-0.4378741682,
0.6189894676,
0.0237736721,
-0.177022025,
0.1953769624,
-0.7569636106,
-0.0075604226,
0.2102389932,
0.3128041625,
-0.339886874,
-0.8098566532,
-0.7452117801,
-0.1000066549,
-0.3952412009,
0.6971084476,
-0.0176097155,
0.1110671386,
-0.0311231297,
-0.0308230594,
-0.269842416,
-0.2011517435,
-0.7438660264,
-0.1929248869,
0.9453828335,
0.233993277,
0.5348765254,
0.5729830265,
0.3286818266,
0.226691857,
0.0570372306,
0.1035232544,
-0.3260841072,
-0.1627487242,
-0.1805144846,
-0.6467036009,
-0.5531311631,
-0.1004843414,
0.6584867835,
1.0350210667,
-0.2758308947,
0.2131970674,
0.0370433182,
0.952267468,
-1.0384179354,
0.094127804,
-0.5323836207,
0.1086077914,
0.0961390808,
0.0426950976,
-0.429464817,
-0.0811192691,
0.3538235128,
-0.7157514691,
-0.0796509385,
-0.1174309105,
0.5026729107,
0.4188833535,
-0.5865129232,
-0.0392227061,
-0.7827626467,
0.8321438432,
-0.7724836469,
0.4315630496,
0.3389552236,
0.3345230818,
-0.0315062515,
-0.601341188,
-0.6124617457,
-0.1296897531,
0.4133952558,
0.1654690802,
0.0259703416,
0.4495050311,
0.0199646652,
0.5196778178,
-0.2940378785,
0.4804487526,
0.0297868233,
-0.2216574401,
0.5760461688,
-0.0561043546,
0.0346464589,
0.3138056993,
-0.2007275969,
-0.3368424773,
-0.734377563,
-0.1598410606,
0.6044687033,
0.2938997149,
-0.1569160074,
0.372194469,
0.0563145541,
0.6713377833,
-0.226181522,
0.1663504541,
0.0529602803,
-0.1126273349,
-0.4953760803,
0.0936480016,
0.8370860815,
0.2379366606,
0.476657778,
-0.1355869472,
-0.1293820143,
-0.1405966431,
-0.0256345477,
-0.8684768677,
-0.2333707213,
0.2579222023,
0.1705453992,
-0.49997136,
0.2618890107,
-0.7421230674,
-0.5110706091,
-0.5835434794,
0.3190020323,
-0.1259549558,
-0.3508809805,
0.3517412841,
0.2540002167,
0.2395645976,
0.4071008861,
-0.5780816078,
0.230266422,
0.8495479226,
0.6464003921,
-0.039650552,
-0.2547595203,
-0.4848518372,
-0.0581410453,
-0.7320785522,
0.3967503905,
-0.3531395495,
-0.1859132946,
0.1106750295,
-0.0445584245,
0.0093605677,
-0.1138822585,
0.737167418,
-0.579891026,
-0.0641736165,
0.0163862593,
-0.961042285,
-0.3793310523,
0.4037614465,
-0.729229033,
0.8986916542,
-0.1706888229,
-0.5923711658,
0.5246551633,
-0.2015055269,
-0.0642659366,
0.2192310095,
-0.2608389556,
-0.2093385309,
0.1969834715,
0.2093553394,
0.396048218,
-0.4595982134,
0.4855014384,
-0.5313352346,
-0.5115563273,
0.2340085506,
-1.0944188833,
0.6814768314,
-0.020302806,
-0.4146777689,
0.0660427883,
-0.8338351846,
0.1897570789,
-0.3919413388,
-0.0669830218,
-0.3321347237,
0.1116863638,
-0.0640487149,
-0.1185303554,
0.3122954369,
-0.8698239923,
0.066987209,
-0.6413158178,
0.4224708676,
0.8809059262,
-0.34430179,
0.5517124534,
-0.0451024473,
0.3862156272,
0.169804275,
-0.0258270837,
-0.0852217525,
-0.2239744365,
-0.8037593365,
-0.535420537,
0.8951348066,
0.7246583104,
-0.225396201,
1.2211326361,
-0.6439318657,
-0.6282669902,
-0.4530835748,
0.1617426127,
0.0353934728,
0.1307156086,
-0.0861335546,
-0.0532625616,
-0.5020222068,
-0.8450225592,
0.0247704741,
-0.1408659667,
-0.3124795854,
0.3361105323,
0.544772923,
-0.0834758878,
0.6530602574,
-0.1641231179,
-0.3253727853,
0.0898434296,
-0.0781034604,
0.4018017948,
0.2015084624,
0.1738997698,
-0.4842447937,
-0.49566558,
0.0753061697,
-0.3842020631,
0.0695743114,
-0.0527946912,
-0.1923053116,
-0.0387438461,
0.1914416999,
-0.3666680157,
0.6255390644,
0.8000851274,
-0.2030651122,
0.4581611156,
-0.3591705859,
0.1915515214,
-1.0384706259,
0.072504051,
0.2837789357,
-0.3707497418,
-0.3584603965,
0.1733895838,
0.3151809573,
0.1637656391,
-0.4921289086,
0.6800923944,
-0.3491674066,
-0.0511725806,
-0.0696964934,
0.4966442585,
0.3375631273,
0.1416660547,
-0.1132787913,
0.8003948927,
0.7887411118,
-0.585857749,
0.7402508855,
-0.0644948781,
-0.615825057,
0.5109428167,
-0.5280322433,
0.0043966989,
0.0168004259,
0.4868932366,
-1.0221124887,
0.0145783396,
-0.5434032083,
-0.2782199979,
0.5785752535,
0.0098069692,
-0.552251935,
-0.4551595151,
-0.4375225902,
0.8108303547,
0.2660904229,
-0.5290849209,
0.4311059713,
0.1534490585,
0.2185661942,
-0.9883509278,
-0.8308830857,
0.4592218101,
0.1162523702,
-0.6464545131,
0.3446691036,
-0.077151753,
-0.1053914279,
-0.224651888,
0.0516575128,
0.0107824421,
0.1199645922,
0.0589417145,
0.3654310107,
-0.4932268858,
0.0606818832,
-0.1740473509,
0.0638119504,
-0.0705985948,
-0.410466969,
0.6158822179,
-0.0276988763,
-0.67223382,
-0.6137517095,
0.0908494219,
0.6466782689,
-0.1023463383,
0.6843944788,
0.3033159673,
-0.5767732263,
-0.3662086427,
-0.7991071343,
-0.2196692079,
-0.4513815641,
0.786311686,
-0.2396096587,
-0.5469001532,
0.7061704993,
0.1772617698,
0.1077639237,
0.4465618432,
0.4491858482,
0.0601882339,
1.0881745815,
0.5219842792,
-0.1778663248,
0.2788682282,
-0.30884552,
0.4603224993,
-1.1497063637,
0.0639670938,
-0.41024822,
-0.6194395423,
-0.5201032162,
-0.5639048815,
-0.053506162,
0.1775152683,
-0.8479502201,
0.1926925629,
-0.4252778888,
0.6676986814,
0.5389744043,
0.1177771538,
0.2014504373,
-0.0227914304,
-0.1423518956,
-0.1262433529,
-0.1529952437,
-0.6859627366,
1.4016064405,
0.3440624475,
0.654276371,
-0.1456291229,
0.6020796299,
0.0660545677,
0.3022603095,
-1.0928381681,
0.2965187132,
-0.4883598387,
-0.6565276384,
-0.445374012,
-0.5681248307,
-0.6525278091,
0.0778851062,
0.134805724,
-1.0012296438,
0.177056402,
-0.1288700253,
-0.5429276228,
0.9047652483,
-0.3477576077,
0.8163502812,
-0.3569350839,
-0.1852120906,
-0.1361123025,
-0.267121464,
0.1799682677,
-0.1300995499,
0.2801194489,
-0.3608812988,
-0.4779470265,
0.5494053364,
-0.1716549695,
0.8978933692,
-0.186734885,
-0.2647448182,
0.3052315116,
0.3457012475,
0.598588109,
0.0198698472,
-0.3904988468,
0.2089171112,
0.1120096594,
-0.438863039,
-0.5239097476,
0.8316315413,
-0.9865951538,
-0.4082321227,
-0.368873179,
-0.4517422616,
-0.3957323432,
-0.0105864368,
0.2078875154,
0.3507733345,
-0.4433230162,
0.4640305042,
0.6421861649,
-0.5232656598,
0.44064641,
0.3085421622,
-0.1086539999,
-0.6596705317,
0.8026311994,
0.0435923859,
0.4188668132,
0.6641500592,
0.1562826782,
-0.4555712342,
-0.3900882304,
-0.7194308043,
0.1628611684,
-0.6922033429,
-0.2981682122,
-0.2432910949,
-0.4711242616,
-0.0762192085,
-0.2612769008,
-0.5845564008,
-0.4240638018,
-0.4657497704,
-0.5270822644,
0.2479631603,
0.4362221658,
0.0242097564,
0.2655208111,
-0.6365563273,
-0.403157711,
0.2129203826,
0.5478414297,
0.1346277893,
-0.7543256879,
0.018620709,
0.5658547282,
-0.2343252003,
-0.645150423,
0.1155339777,
0.5847918391,
0.3987168968,
0.2572548091,
-0.0380097553,
0.5169408917,
-0.5463683009,
0.9644604325,
0.5321435928,
-0.8946986794,
0.1886835694,
-0.2468354106,
0.1055151299,
0.8173559308,
-0.1672313511,
-0.8084936142,
-0.2335660458,
-0.3269507587,
-1.0792505741,
0.2220855653,
-0.1290921569,
0.7314044237,
-0.0644607842,
0.4581481814,
0.0470429063,
0.3217901587,
-0.6303911805,
-0.3805244863,
0.0530746467,
-0.7619566917,
-0.1628194451,
-0.1215415671,
-0.1016439646,
-0.3084540665,
0.8211653233,
-0.2267887145,
0.0896563977,
0.0351299196,
-0.0544705242,
-0.2753716409,
0.3261270821,
0.4453572631,
0.686583221,
-0.1033683494,
0.1336891651,
0.218637079,
-0.5611594319,
0.3430895209,
-0.1083006635,
-0.0419591703,
-0.2642662823,
0.2278826833,
0.9291176796,
0.3769839108,
-0.6989886165,
1.2216352224,
-0.111285083,
-0.4019044638,
-0.7187061906,
-0.2124379873,
0.083256945,
-0.1778173596,
0.5339215398,
-0.1408820003,
-0.015683556,
-0.2378462106,
0.474135071,
0.3482053876,
-0.9004096389,
-0.4059850872,
0.6240986586,
0.3177671134,
-0.0902872011,
0.6839612126,
-0.0328275897,
-0.435010016,
1.0233416557,
0.3464686871,
1.2687083483,
0.0309390444,
0.2846079469,
0.5378736854,
0.3699121773,
-0.0465536118,
0.1608038992,
0.2163943201,
-0.8721319437,
-1.051858902,
-1.0777451992,
-0.3359438777,
0.1876965016,
-0.6745506525,
0.4852393568,
-0.4968410134,
-0.1192373708,
-0.1794222444,
0.098117426,
-1.1031756401,
0.2843392193,
0.5504187346,
1.2393392324,
-0.5444463491,
0.7123952508,
0.5625960231,
0.008548568,
-1.0239742994,
-0.329891324,
-0.1033772081,
-0.8587287664,
0.5782481432,
0.3290687501,
0.0334841907,
0.0286200419,
-0.1571991146,
-0.8997404575,
1.2074385881,
0.5114136338,
-1.1997177601,
-0.1637874246,
0.2991745472,
0.5427724123,
-0.4322758019,
0.5115163922,
0.6086449623,
0.6209138632,
0.10156551,
-1.0306367874,
-0.1545518339,
0.0779656842,
0.0826048777,
0.4267707765,
-0.4322251976,
0.5302509069,
-0.0454717539,
-0.0600409992,
0.1262629032,
0.5101394057,
0.0170063898,
-0.0523180217,
0.7302071452,
0.894526422,
0.7678408027,
-0.3001972437,
0.9476969242,
-0.5151610374,
0.4941311181,
1.0167424679,
-0.3620333374,
1.0329881907,
0.3313615024,
-0.4469881654,
0.2049356252,
0.7185989618,
0.1051173732,
0.3180381954,
0.5239839554,
-0.5200847387,
-0.436375767,
0.1845185012,
0.0136965988,
0.2595891654,
0.5279698968,
-0.2746493518,
-0.0735542104,
-0.0088495333,
-0.1105889529,
-0.0241851471,
-0.5172291398,
0.7265630364,
0.3474008441,
-0.4469490051,
0.3014856875,
-0.2698524892,
0.8357785344,
-0.3459008932,
0.3346815407,
0.0316005349,
0.5032072067,
-0.1406843811,
-0.9431549311,
0.0196738467,
-0.0615948401,
0.128893882,
0.3461165428,
-0.0540626012,
-0.5101541877,
-0.9381942153,
0.5576398969,
0.4279927015,
-0.038220603,
-0.2567741573,
-0.6291915178,
-0.2452075183,
0.0427192226,
-0.6234027147,
0.2786450982,
0.7114742994,
0.44317469,
0.4419978559,
0.4334854186,
0.463617146,
0.2845531106,
0.3828273714,
0.3807480633,
-0.387688756,
-0.295333147,
-0.9712631106,
0.6092644334,
-0.1519171447,
-0.4854531288,
0.2355974019,
0.6258201599,
0.8042004108,
0.4074499905,
0.7125523686,
0.1504098624,
0.2733034194,
-0.0479081832,
0.6116597652,
-0.7762492895,
0.3535239398,
-0.1339762211,
-1.3012895584,
-0.6360544562,
0.7153898478,
-0.2106264085,
-0.0997708216,
0.632188201,
0.7238867879,
-0.1371680945,
0.081659317,
0.8094736934,
0.1072162017,
0.4188448191,
0.5919602513,
0.4889889956,
-0.6415700912,
0.5392840505,
-0.5229715109,
-0.4025203288,
0.0631616041,
-1.1369773149,
-0.6712096334,
-0.4538427889,
-0.4373882711,
-0.1164970398,
-0.2083751261,
1.0352312326,
0.8047237992,
-1.0534279346,
-0.2080894113,
-0.2396842539,
-0.3170744479,
-0.0435491391,
-0.2142461389,
0.4992497265,
-0.2103730738,
-0.9422490597,
0.1138894856,
0.3215965927,
-0.0573999472,
-0.5839335918,
0.017280139,
-0.0019735072,
0.4009746909,
0.3523824811,
-0.0553926565,
-0.7526298761,
-0.5687906742,
-0.0057189679,
-0.4031113982,
0.0482129194,
0.6144259572,
-0.2890387177,
0.4420676231,
0.2882232964,
0.9807016253,
0.5177335143,
-0.530618608,
0.8332021832,
-0.9877607822,
0.2702335715,
0.5302246809,
0.7678824663,
0.4620747864,
-0.2313507944,
0.4412255585,
-0.1534261853,
-0.8352783322,
-1.0728529692,
0.3581291735,
-0.8405117393,
0.0132873561,
1.1165349483,
-0.300632298,
-0.4615829587,
0.3778219521,
-0.0717256218,
0.288406074,
-0.3523333669,
0.4443510175,
1.005885601,
0.6849380732,
-0.0704695135,
-0.8611751795,
0.0144002466,
0.3532241583,
-0.4913113117,
0.3632490933,
0.3651201129,
0.3379582167,
0.06065109,
0.1178550944,
0.0121894423,
0.0870158523,
-0.1503766179,
0.2906298041,
0.1522994637,
-0.2083658427,
-0.0931184366,
-0.1268295348,
0.2055159509,
-0.0005446759
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11341v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11341v1 | A Systematic Analysis of Large Language Models as Soft Reasoners: The Case of Syllogistic Inferences | 2024-06-17T08:59:04 | 2024-06-17T08:59:04 | Leonardo Bertolazzi, Albert Gatt, Raffaella Bernardi | cs.CL | cs.CL | The reasoning abilities of Large Language Models (LLMs) are becoming a
central focus of study in NLP. In this paper, we consider the case of
syllogistic reasoning, an area of deductive reasoning studied extensively in
logic and cognitive psychology. Previous research has shown that pre-trained
LLMs exhibit reasoning biases, such as $\textit{content effects}$, avoid
answering that $\textit{no conclusion follows}$, display human-like
difficulties, and struggle with multi-step reasoning. We contribute to this
research line by systematically investigating the effects of chain-of-thought
reasoning, in-context learning (ICL), and supervised fine-tuning (SFT) on
syllogistic reasoning, considering syllogisms with conclusions that support or
violate world knowledge, as well as ones with multiple premises. Crucially, we
go beyond the standard focus on accuracy, with an in-depth analysis of the
conclusions generated by the models. Our results suggest that the behavior of
pre-trained LLMs can be explained by heuristics studied in cognitive science
and that both ICL and SFT improve model performance on valid inferences,
although only the latter mitigates most reasoning biases without harming model
consistency. | [
-0.2184423804,
-0.9098820686,
0.8410255909,
-0.1905307025,
-0.2584424913,
-0.2992892265,
-0.4434317946,
-0.2929137945,
-0.1869326383,
0.6134648323,
-0.4212142825,
-0.3854779303,
-0.7192646265,
0.2239360511,
-0.330555141,
1.0029587746,
0.1609761566,
0.1320094317,
-0.1540304571,
-0.0916887298,
-0.522939384,
-0.6820028424,
-0.4915715754,
-0.5394990444,
0.3742603362,
-0.0483750738,
0.6482086778,
0.4178093374,
0.3298352361,
0.3052179515,
-0.4435150921,
0.2861936688,
-0.4766065776,
0.541588068,
-0.563705802,
-0.6742928624,
-0.3466416299,
-0.0321745649,
0.577806592,
0.7189033628,
-0.3083434701,
0.0381394885,
0.2847229242,
0.420528084,
-0.8358944058,
0.2300570309,
-0.8367878199,
-0.1871625036,
-0.1688198447,
-0.0716821104,
-0.8947640061,
-0.2300799489,
0.2220453471,
-0.4970140457,
-0.0762554184,
-0.288323909,
0.592559576,
0.7198382616,
-0.6027875543,
-0.1552974582,
-0.749637723,
1.0439120531,
-0.9441638589,
0.3668832779,
0.2613251507,
0.1686500311,
-0.4259797931,
-0.6776872873,
-0.334979862,
-0.0915510133,
-0.2420198768,
0.0083970139,
-0.3834863603,
0.4296592474,
0.7870730758,
-0.0752973035,
-0.4363020062,
0.0553740785,
-0.2036507279,
0.0654732287,
0.6925649047,
0.1097408533,
0.076518774,
-0.1517966092,
-0.0724137127,
0.1496231258,
-0.730707705,
0.0890908465,
-0.1124843881,
0.1972720176,
0.0415090807,
0.3371902108,
-0.343397975,
1.220223546,
-0.1943695247,
-0.3918114603,
-0.2325647026,
0.0545294285,
-0.4234915972,
0.176009059,
0.5736374259,
0.1076999828,
0.7277080417,
0.0554406494,
-0.2120474875,
0.3625372052,
0.111037761,
-0.6440975666,
-0.1945186704,
0.1096869037,
-0.5248960257,
0.0202255156,
-0.1309928447,
-0.1400460154,
-0.2967130542,
-0.6823824644,
0.4541421831,
-0.3879731894,
-0.1837256402,
0.3979302645,
-0.2414884716,
-0.051781632,
0.5535405278,
-0.5744297504,
0.2812832296,
0.9727050066,
0.6053443551,
0.1585271955,
-0.1088896617,
-0.445630312,
0.3225886226,
-0.2676399648,
0.9386678934,
-0.4572079182,
-0.0895346254,
-0.1993238777,
-0.1554689854,
-0.1527506858,
-0.4695374966,
0.1953780651,
-0.1291710287,
0.0866453946,
-0.1411518455,
-0.5007196665,
-0.3487674296,
0.3688867986,
-0.5020796657,
0.5086034536,
-0.2780213654,
-0.6827143431,
0.560606122,
-0.1306436807,
-0.457788527,
-0.0112222228,
-0.4004767537,
0.0342151262,
0.4022997022,
0.1076856256,
0.4778827429,
-0.4665646553,
0.6622225642,
-0.5673533082,
-0.3283094466,
0.4840199947,
-0.4783041477,
0.9925077558,
0.1141333058,
-0.5223548412,
0.1720053554,
-0.3878832161,
0.1858083457,
-0.2673686445,
-0.0898416564,
-0.7004469037,
0.3912452161,
-0.4936641455,
0.4636916816,
-0.1264472008,
-0.2419171035,
0.2305230051,
-0.551762104,
0.6841782928,
0.9661654234,
-0.308875978,
0.2361370623,
-0.0723297298,
0.2719525397,
-0.197007671,
0.3554579616,
-0.2538917065,
-0.5140966773,
-0.6521601081,
-0.2654688656,
0.0846892968,
0.2868949473,
-0.491876483,
-0.0630584657,
0.0143579459,
-0.3257656991,
-0.3096480072,
0.2036057413,
0.5359927416,
0.4369097352,
0.3171779811,
-0.1128654778,
-0.3341838419,
-0.8903893232,
-0.6419920921,
-0.1953407675,
0.2360830605,
0.1844844222,
0.4447265267,
-0.0373609737,
0.8544777632,
-0.4136750698,
-0.0479560643,
-0.3696509898,
-0.1074245945,
0.4490787089,
0.2356570065,
0.2827247977,
-0.578360498,
-0.1028000712,
-0.1698970944,
-0.8624755144,
-0.2107713521,
0.0657512397,
0.0083633391,
0.3937618434,
0.6117467284,
-0.9940372705,
0.6702116132,
0.3028936088,
-0.4626701176,
0.529317081,
-0.0965302736,
-0.2136800885,
-0.6898080707,
-0.0634007156,
0.2629963756,
-0.0546645783,
-0.434012711,
0.3136379421,
-0.2568845153,
0.2247937918,
-0.2647097409,
0.6877182126,
-0.3246402144,
0.1530636251,
-0.2067923844,
0.088558197,
-0.0432220064,
0.0708223879,
0.2103672922,
0.331648618,
0.2753608823,
-0.5695784092,
0.2429408431,
-0.1186163872,
-0.2107182741,
0.5191883445,
-0.6928244829,
-0.0762187839,
-0.1560190618,
0.6864793301,
-0.9209524989,
-0.0730942562,
-0.0742138699,
-0.1238592416,
0.1052531004,
-0.2733533978,
-0.5018979907,
-0.339582175,
0.1313374043,
0.3638060093,
0.4533015788,
-0.3493269682,
0.6131430864,
0.3829248846,
0.0534484386,
-0.5402721763,
-0.4377805889,
-0.1128794178,
-0.3560600579,
-0.5360375643,
0.0291902684,
0.0772924647,
-1.0994107723,
-0.314160049,
-0.3854141533,
-0.2060452253,
0.2446924001,
0.3716047108,
0.1607428789,
-0.2931077182,
0.4471842945,
0.1052323878,
-0.2695225477,
0.3006887138,
-0.4525360167,
0.4850258231,
-0.2026429921,
-0.3344333172,
-0.4053484797,
0.0002024291,
0.3340973258,
-0.2460713238,
0.590316534,
0.1282095015,
-0.3204445839,
-0.5966435075,
-0.7484396696,
-0.6502159834,
-0.3931979835,
0.038611155,
-0.4137274921,
-1.0235416889,
0.1279028803,
-0.112146385,
-0.0298424456,
0.4471379817,
0.63782686,
-0.1661243588,
1.3846070766,
0.2733712792,
0.1170280501,
0.127026245,
-0.2900315225,
0.2755741179,
-0.3781837821,
-0.2999494672,
-0.531401813,
-0.3563964069,
-0.736997664,
-0.320848614,
0.3613294959,
0.0971188024,
-0.3380995691,
0.0731437728,
-0.5104013681,
0.5828207731,
0.3379738927,
0.3607448936,
0.3625363708,
-0.2834853232,
-0.0121757127,
0.1323472112,
-0.8606601954,
-0.534006238,
0.8895442486,
0.1987535059,
1.1150766611,
0.0942089632,
0.5326772332,
-0.1662812829,
0.2385714203,
-0.7890495062,
0.6485128999,
-0.4518223107,
-0.729293108,
-0.2610009909,
-0.3576316535,
-0.7551645637,
0.416644454,
-0.1269335747,
-0.8364350796,
0.0905779451,
0.415245682,
-0.3764034808,
0.2500134408,
-0.5495023727,
0.8192344904,
-0.2578770816,
-0.4799509346,
-0.7427912951,
-0.7396211624,
0.5952243209,
0.1603798717,
0.2700605094,
-0.218288824,
0.3197626472,
0.6021766663,
-0.4664787948,
0.9438461065,
-0.1349793524,
-0.291313678,
0.3053888679,
0.2916640937,
0.1911485791,
0.1682756692,
-0.1807814538,
0.2413345426,
0.2124740779,
-0.270891279,
-0.6879640222,
0.5900728106,
-0.4104107916,
-1.1396634579,
-0.3938273787,
-0.8083987236,
-0.1177314296,
0.162146613,
0.1109139994,
0.4211302996,
0.1293378621,
0.2889704406,
1.0624946356,
-0.0922987312,
0.1875902414,
0.4202131033,
-0.14257662,
0.071961306,
0.4428662956,
0.2450006455,
0.4419670403,
0.282903105,
0.42024827,
-0.1375693083,
-0.4270685017,
-0.1866989434,
0.3858441114,
-0.7440123558,
-0.1521538645,
-0.4197981358,
-0.2336875349,
-0.3431532681,
0.0101574073,
-0.0646919981,
-0.4441944063,
-0.1554081887,
0.0820755661,
0.2835521698,
0.7811362147,
0.1841660589,
0.3441538513,
-0.5249562263,
0.1335678548,
0.4548614025,
-0.0154132741,
-0.0442367606,
-0.5136663914,
0.0144216307,
0.0377744101,
-0.2064426988,
-0.7369963527,
0.1285492778,
0.1020281091,
0.5964955091,
0.6223993301,
-0.1633483022,
0.8645061851,
-0.2765596509,
0.5004608631,
0.0125918556,
-0.9390493035,
0.9346877933,
-0.4656649828,
0.505710423,
0.2719388604,
0.2822255194,
-0.3021773398,
-0.5600209236,
-0.5924176574,
-0.5815565586,
0.5248346329,
-0.145333156,
-0.0350438654,
-0.1466679722,
0.4933760464,
0.10084185,
0.0351920016,
-0.6255733967,
0.3056488633,
0.1372127682,
-0.0467505679,
-0.2451589704,
-0.2992809117,
-0.2049977779,
-0.460742861,
0.5558261871,
-0.2578894496,
-0.4001580179,
0.0100293374,
-0.460208863,
0.0917640403,
0.3789377809,
0.4154668152,
0.9614554048,
-0.049541533,
0.3936271966,
0.2497318536,
-0.048265975,
0.1535018086,
0.0430052169,
-0.1079404652,
-0.1077484339,
0.8075007796,
0.5763052106,
0.213169381,
-0.8673878312,
0.475430131,
0.1392530203,
-0.020178102,
-0.1204646975,
0.451374054,
-0.0745050237,
0.4730722904,
0.1419957429,
-0.0769478977,
0.1934294552,
-0.5338560939,
0.0881056786,
0.7481965423,
-0.5282786489,
-0.3394147158,
0.4176843166,
-0.0257858802,
-0.1453236341,
0.7400503755,
0.2509850562,
-0.5006642938,
0.636988461,
0.7165233493,
0.5091177821,
-0.5108789802,
0.0110491095,
0.1905174404,
0.4913781881,
-0.3601569831,
0.252687484,
-0.2110609412,
-0.6601532698,
-0.8677520156,
-0.6282431483,
-0.1143204123,
0.0700709745,
-0.5905812979,
0.3048237264,
-0.6420834661,
-0.4013497531,
0.096150279,
-0.4353447556,
-0.5309317112,
0.3986254334,
0.2510223389,
1.0561916828,
-0.8377141356,
0.8479465842,
0.6032739878,
-0.1516789198,
-0.9654044509,
-0.0795406103,
0.2363014072,
-0.7997356653,
1.0541360378,
0.3030407429,
-0.3424690962,
-0.0144167766,
-0.5387721062,
-0.7313968539,
0.8242092729,
0.707044661,
-0.7811114788,
-0.1529103816,
-0.2216650695,
0.4891478717,
-0.0433731303,
0.4839026928,
0.8524929285,
0.3882866502,
-0.2337425798,
-1.1098108292,
0.1625910401,
-0.0461442135,
-0.0446456708,
0.4141955674,
-0.469630301,
0.9470036626,
-0.3609296381,
0.065383926,
-0.0689277649,
0.2772013545,
0.6351969242,
0.3421079814,
0.5727106929,
0.8418926001,
0.5126795769,
-0.2201500833,
0.9544047713,
-0.123175703,
0.2134198695,
1.154453516,
-0.3660163581,
0.6784891486,
0.6718694568,
-0.0918762311,
0.8510909677,
0.5165119767,
0.3256824017,
0.2466687709,
0.4158506691,
-0.2916792929,
-0.7957002521,
-0.3215889335,
-0.185287565,
0.7500884533,
0.6150205135,
-0.441731602,
-0.2371248156,
-0.133214131,
0.0844932646,
0.1359745413,
-0.4005692601,
0.8566095233,
0.5043491125,
-0.7230907083,
0.5219717026,
-0.2469452918,
0.4036840498,
-0.4983019531,
-0.1740221083,
0.0487400405,
0.4306353033,
-0.3706234694,
-0.8675377965,
0.2503894269,
-0.1719688773,
-0.0905382857,
-0.2731518447,
1.031891942,
0.0047351015,
-0.1804734617,
0.3989073932,
0.5422224402,
0.1095128655,
-0.1227594614,
-0.5986804366,
-0.0209074803,
-0.1937065274,
-0.341770947,
0.1022640169,
0.5175618529,
-0.4593450129,
0.7980464697,
0.5983284116,
0.251129508,
-0.3320987821,
0.3132664263,
0.703664124,
-0.6228503585,
-0.4382315576,
-1.4565799236,
0.5191493034,
0.0494822077,
-0.2231632322,
0.8238572478,
0.4155077934,
0.7903347015,
0.152178809,
0.6398869157,
0.2392418385,
0.2013982832,
-0.7513708472,
0.5827316046,
-0.4720498919,
0.1809896082,
-0.3833500445,
-0.7545121312,
-0.4421820045,
0.8458185196,
-0.7062858343,
0.0196425486,
0.6617333889,
0.5892025828,
-0.0998237655,
0.1233644783,
0.220264554,
0.6395419836,
0.1812114418,
0.6568818688,
1.1191184521,
0.1237751395,
0.2223920375,
-0.0556533039,
-0.2664469481,
-0.1002683565,
-0.7668520212,
-1.0381741524,
-0.3731846213,
-0.0593907088,
-0.4659275115,
0.3353637457,
0.7749053836,
0.6466386318,
-0.4925345778,
-0.513327539,
-0.1446613669,
0.4159160256,
-0.1623808444,
-0.1766491979,
0.122553207,
-0.3530758619,
-0.2613959014,
0.2387079,
0.4832614958,
-0.3658211827,
-0.232436344,
-0.0339774042,
-0.1042255014,
0.0435768999,
0.9610753059,
-0.087133795,
-1.2140133381,
-0.138950929,
-0.2078216076,
0.0856758207,
-0.2787237167,
0.9989513755,
-1.1439934969,
0.3802767396,
0.4591426551,
0.0926875472,
0.4079731405,
-0.2750962079,
0.6096484065,
-0.2348784804,
0.354295969,
0.2518095672,
0.4732213318,
-0.0298545212,
-0.1228688285,
0.4564003646,
0.2449991703,
-0.5161066055,
-1.0363457203,
0.3989396393,
-0.6337800622,
-0.7653682828,
1.161233902,
-0.0627905726,
-0.1786747128,
-0.0171586368,
-0.1116164625,
0.2704517245,
-0.0939958096,
0.8188681602,
0.6980029941,
-0.2762736678,
-0.1017288566,
-0.6142765284,
0.526719451,
0.5669445992,
-0.8714733124,
0.1013323292,
0.6025188565,
0.3151626885,
0.0090119662,
0.5269605517,
0.1607619226,
0.4074007869,
-0.3783474267,
-0.2124156505,
0.3314978182,
-0.4933688939,
-0.4849177599,
-0.1090919599,
0.1647646874,
0.615549624
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11338v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11338v1 | Fine-grained Controllable Text Generation through In-context Learning with Feedback | 2024-06-17T08:55:48 | 2024-06-17T08:55:48 | Sarubi Thillainathan, Alexander Koller | cs.CL | cs.CL | We present a method for rewriting an input sentence to match specific values
of nontrivial linguistic features, such as dependency depth. In contrast to
earlier work, our method uses in-context learning rather than finetuning,
making it applicable in use cases where data is sparse. We show that our model
performs accurate rewrites and matches the state of the art on rewriting
sentences to a specified school grade level. | [
-0.2174963355,
-1.2700181007,
0.5558526516,
0.0528291836,
-0.0060943151,
-0.2460798174,
-0.2592506707,
-0.3194390833,
0.2129455805,
0.7378769517,
-0.7022182345,
-0.4584128857,
-0.2247378826,
-0.0167731699,
-0.4631778002,
1.2819805145,
-0.3840815127,
-0.2653155625,
-0.360457778,
0.0372731425,
-0.6690859199,
-0.4669027627,
-0.5871145129,
-0.4185650051,
0.6467839479,
1.1107325554,
0.5711987615,
0.6138026714,
0.2866644859,
0.2837814689,
-0.161846742,
0.1324802637,
-0.6328558326,
0.2980981171,
-0.4532002211,
-0.2302024662,
-0.2180660814,
-0.0602266304,
0.6859058142,
1.1165015697,
-0.0582115315,
0.0412706956,
0.4711414874,
0.5332830548,
-0.5792336464,
0.0063116318,
-0.7462072968,
0.1334406286,
-0.0522515103,
-0.4280955791,
-0.5942711234,
-0.2673715353,
0.4316543937,
-0.5634155869,
0.6836245656,
-0.1623869091,
0.9871090055,
0.477183938,
-0.3204347789,
-0.416890353,
-0.6391994357,
0.9186577797,
-0.6238646507,
0.1875014454,
0.5751960278,
0.2365435958,
-0.4420819283,
-0.780404985,
-0.3222899437,
-0.3263519406,
-0.3325819671,
0.0118831936,
0.5075231791,
0.1034950539,
0.0539252833,
0.5867878199,
0.0232947133,
-0.1674287319,
-0.4513463974,
-0.0770238787,
0.5957637429,
0.3099884987,
0.0299937185,
-0.354783684,
-0.1680617332,
0.0858857632,
-0.5018288493,
0.4146531522,
0.0984760597,
0.7225947976,
-0.0155859245,
0.8181542158,
-0.5307841897,
0.7435527444,
0.4379193187,
-0.4561395645,
0.2048426569,
-0.4392466247,
-0.4747863412,
0.0931745395,
0.524209857,
0.4781843424,
0.3482755721,
-0.1899577826,
-0.4308728576,
-0.082528919,
0.3305196762,
-0.8473411202,
-0.083480522,
0.0717103183,
-0.4163490534,
-0.5711526275,
-0.0171757285,
-0.665884614,
0.0271527749,
-0.5495474339,
0.4590142369,
-0.5209366679,
0.3283955157,
-0.0491431355,
0.0063658147,
0.1481918097,
0.4070287049,
-1.0742272139,
0.2724715769,
0.2659837902,
0.9051903486,
0.0512427725,
-0.4269731045,
-0.8057473302,
0.2688992918,
-0.3391166925,
0.7652879953,
-0.6767580509,
-0.3992096186,
0.0811960176,
0.1036236584,
0.3322874606,
-0.5245504379,
0.3136226833,
-0.1399347931,
0.340485394,
0.0352622904,
-0.7767806649,
-0.1379478723,
0.1733754873,
-0.4135920703,
0.8425610662,
0.6830083728,
-0.6307332516,
0.7908039093,
-0.2366425097,
-0.8222870827,
-0.0567750782,
-0.0716064498,
-0.6103295088,
0.2690439224,
-0.0228609778,
0.5044564605,
0.2577574551,
0.7197133899,
-0.2053893805,
-0.2731056511,
0.1152748615,
-0.405256927,
0.2824548483,
0.0570834726,
-0.4882408679,
0.3922866583,
-1.1651854515,
0.2289829403,
-0.1926044375,
-0.7973242402,
-0.2003960162,
0.1205074713,
0.295787245,
0.0376006141,
0.2954949439,
-0.5276230574,
0.1881946027,
-0.5968743563,
0.7821397781,
0.4367304742,
0.2697420716,
0.8065038919,
-0.311357975,
0.2436860353,
-0.1344623566,
-0.0475109443,
-0.2931337059,
-0.1057831645,
-0.7286347151,
0.0118258391,
0.2647751272,
0.4910430312,
-0.8250387907,
0.2395297438,
0.2071841657,
-0.2961326241,
-0.3197807372,
0.2567602694,
0.7711981535,
0.8661728501,
0.4561646879,
-0.2837365866,
-0.3841099441,
-0.9544520974,
-0.1956778765,
0.2713981569,
-0.1055077314,
0.5393412113,
0.2064787447,
-0.3912072778,
1.104929924,
-0.6275635362,
-0.5146490335,
-0.4116385877,
0.1664528549,
-0.2811920047,
0.8253628612,
0.3007432818,
-0.4909555316,
-0.4573866129,
0.0954534113,
-0.4698261917,
-0.4679368138,
-0.2453269362,
-0.0757693201,
0.2426023781,
0.8687674403,
-0.1044862717,
0.6052563787,
0.3086357415,
-0.5732610226,
0.087647222,
-0.4536642432,
-0.0326497555,
-1.2344465256,
-0.1291084588,
0.0692852661,
-0.3689951003,
-0.6400356889,
0.1538639814,
0.0103765745,
0.0678362399,
-0.6402814388,
0.3886829913,
-0.1715473384,
0.0789278373,
-0.4514615834,
0.3490142822,
0.2410889715,
0.5267249942,
-0.0084913867,
0.581373632,
0.2195107937,
-0.6496161222,
0.0996164307,
0.3018662333,
-0.3299943507,
0.5672084689,
-0.6848902106,
-0.2634890974,
-0.1846934408,
0.2380352169,
-0.8134865761,
-0.7823891044,
-0.025508631,
-0.2686697841,
0.2051324546,
0.0384217687,
-0.2987155616,
0.158233121,
-0.1287393868,
0.3844970167,
0.0660253242,
-0.4603375196,
0.3219078481,
0.2280615717,
-0.05770199,
-0.1726931185,
-0.8837349415,
-0.1045143083,
-0.3119438589,
-0.3634082377,
0.4766874611,
0.1152026057,
-0.2256917655,
-0.1880427748,
0.2456343621,
-0.4436389208,
0.1504165083,
0.1916969121,
-0.1429188401,
-0.1080880985,
0.1447222531,
0.4652328491,
0.0281097312,
-0.1389115006,
0.0649860874,
0.3400794566,
0.0487432294,
0.2159398496,
-0.4475051463,
0.7766441703,
0.4419843853,
-0.091009602,
0.3456495404,
0.0876273215,
-0.4154472947,
-0.6485573649,
0.102063708,
-0.2485825121,
-0.4767581224,
0.3131830394,
-0.6119564772,
-1.2256525755,
0.3949133754,
0.0929991975,
0.0991794467,
0.3084581196,
0.5625318289,
0.0109244594,
0.7607260346,
1.1188392639,
0.3341661394,
0.7139061689,
-0.0900838897,
0.1092223972,
-0.5889168978,
-0.1858849823,
-0.3450898826,
-0.5253085494,
-0.8414011598,
-0.0014233959,
-0.1670500934,
0.397845,
-0.2991389632,
0.2697045505,
-0.6152213812,
0.6568422318,
0.8991744518,
0.3089770973,
0.0466844589,
-0.2349009812,
-0.1048443615,
-0.0242102835,
-0.6830114126,
-0.5163925886,
0.8565048575,
0.2081778049,
0.9269197583,
-0.07201913,
0.7489510179,
-0.0882382914,
0.3656918406,
-0.9834839106,
0.2151871026,
-0.4158459902,
-0.4093795419,
-0.6100354791,
-0.3380423188,
-0.8996998072,
-0.1453818381,
-0.2011236846,
-0.5587984324,
0.1455150396,
0.240070492,
-0.5461199284,
0.0513977259,
-1.1080595255,
0.8547320366,
0.1824724078,
-0.5700261593,
0.1965244263,
-0.7278237343,
0.2556346655,
-0.1999587119,
-0.011197241,
0.0965330824,
0.0807992816,
0.4746588469,
-0.8142538667,
1.1726800203,
-0.1467171311,
-0.3785252571,
0.5303790569,
0.3181589842,
0.139419198,
0.3196967542,
0.2687304616,
-0.414411068,
-0.0367791317,
-0.3392385542,
-0.4964600205,
0.9683571458,
-0.5949798226,
-0.4039608836,
0.0060234256,
-0.9111109376,
-0.2414144129,
0.4559704065,
0.3883419633,
0.6424346566,
-0.1366499811,
0.2177758813,
0.5671513677,
-0.297219038,
0.4740760922,
0.3259839416,
-0.2106624395,
-0.4705969393,
0.8509067893,
0.3307181895,
0.4456694424,
0.5179842114,
0.2463368475,
-0.0313199423,
-0.2558308542,
-0.5827485323,
-0.1497593969,
-0.7096856833,
-0.3225909472,
-0.5203019381,
-0.3771781623,
-0.2460785955,
-0.9354236126,
-0.2822976708,
-0.3298638463,
-0.4219660759,
-0.0730674714,
0.3430629969,
1.0463292599,
0.1178372577,
0.6616225243,
-0.5738019943,
0.3116526306,
0.32745561,
0.7980106473,
-0.1398815364,
-0.5163584948,
-0.338431716,
-0.1034959927,
-0.5552331805,
-0.6387028098,
0.4051530659,
0.4588520229,
0.0986684933,
0.2715695798,
-0.0785880908,
0.7598568201,
-0.9525125623,
0.96283108,
-0.1937126368,
-1.213000536,
0.9662115574,
-0.2962168455,
0.6279404163,
0.8658568263,
-0.0825899541,
-0.2347704172,
-0.7505279779,
-0.7867082953,
-1.0617945194,
0.4967696667,
-0.0628901944,
0.269661665,
-0.1768086404,
0.8170959949,
0.3402878046,
0.1423154324,
-0.4679724574,
0.1138776764,
-0.3495543301,
-0.3448277116,
-0.3027495742,
-0.4701291025,
0.221886009,
-0.1979523301,
0.371953696,
-0.1383756697,
-0.150748834,
0.4500989914,
-0.0080843847,
-0.2498227507,
0.316629529,
0.9571295977,
0.4437161088,
-0.2324884981,
0.3132562041,
0.2190886885,
-0.4529758096,
0.2158019841,
-0.381259948,
-0.5466815829,
0.1431821585,
0.3913477063,
0.5268573165,
0.5982376933,
-0.5744524598,
0.4089257717,
0.0602982864,
-0.6654372811,
-0.0488073677,
0.2527426481,
-0.1940352172,
0.1432333589,
-0.294762373,
-0.0078017549,
0.2593147457,
-0.5370601416,
0.7481104732,
0.056505084,
-0.6760121584,
-0.098540239,
0.8166390657,
0.1741983294,
-0.2948139608,
0.3761841059,
-0.1076297089,
-0.0808177218,
0.4170727134,
0.7660393715,
0.8616025448,
-0.2401481122,
0.2239218205,
0.5603550076,
0.0700814575,
-0.0485881977,
0.4489009678,
-0.1178022847,
-0.5396336913,
-0.607229054,
-0.6231685877,
-0.4360084534,
0.13446334,
-0.7997251153,
0.3412939906,
-0.8660554886,
0.0509120822,
0.1669808179,
-0.1525485814,
-0.2173346728,
0.7267453671,
-0.3421049714,
0.7616863847,
-0.8163306713,
0.8379520774,
0.614132762,
-0.5361579061,
-0.993629992,
0.21045807,
-0.2732734382,
-0.2384391278,
0.5589779019,
0.2635935545,
-0.1895670891,
-0.0234841555,
-0.7485587001,
-1.0666536093,
0.8764602542,
0.2099269927,
-0.5635455847,
0.1839413941,
-0.0051267887,
0.6259402633,
-0.4463303983,
-0.1587656438,
0.6356710196,
0.1871617287,
0.0031688109,
-0.9249823689,
-0.0515129454,
-0.1065994576,
0.2542304695,
0.2939432263,
-0.6363546252,
0.8465366364,
-0.0637146756,
-0.1773481667,
0.0088580167,
0.855512917,
-0.0447835289,
0.3574593663,
0.3147975504,
0.6364937425,
0.5862018466,
-0.0437591486,
0.8789001107,
-0.1806402504,
0.411493957,
1.6183075905,
0.0479972698,
0.93289572,
0.6787256598,
0.297852993,
0.5386312008,
0.6914705634,
0.1792783439,
0.8443443775,
0.6212073565,
-0.1008352414,
0.0952026322,
-0.2741648555,
0.1008863002,
0.4057501256,
0.1992073357,
-0.5056682825,
-0.3173155189,
0.2574655414,
0.1151330471,
0.5642216802,
-0.5870584846,
0.8838034868,
-0.0794690177,
-0.7847540975,
0.7632604837,
0.1708799601,
0.7601567507,
-0.2250804752,
-0.1122158393,
-0.4618954659,
0.4046396911,
-0.5003644824,
-0.9962462783,
0.8485589623,
0.1830692142,
-0.6629618406,
-0.3601008654,
0.4118675292,
-0.6884738803,
-0.4872895479,
0.0348532796,
0.1821151227,
0.057413768,
0.2149661034,
-0.1890865266,
-0.2473931015,
0.2865321636,
-0.2161087692,
0.1791065037,
0.9298801422,
-0.2550769448,
0.5116035938,
0.2499102205,
-0.2060670555,
0.0577614233,
0.2116791606,
0.7978693247,
-0.7373936772,
-0.4494302571,
-0.6230909228,
0.4286782742,
0.1877330244,
-0.7491906285,
0.5731006861,
0.5629502535,
1.412322402,
-0.0177949686,
0.8461090326,
-0.0653242916,
0.5157724619,
-0.512366116,
0.5478745699,
-0.5748285651,
-0.1500245482,
-0.3537303507,
-0.7801796794,
-0.6274624467,
0.8070354462,
-0.2198553681,
-0.115454793,
0.7115188241,
0.6790450215,
-0.0676449463,
-0.2322239131,
0.3626066744,
0.049961295,
0.2820526361,
0.64279145,
0.6264923811,
-0.3020756245,
0.0939703435,
-0.5009320378,
-0.4553843737,
-0.1651767492,
-0.6968477964,
-0.9533603787,
-0.563539207,
-0.333165437,
-0.4387631118,
-0.3366817236,
0.5958009958,
0.4160608053,
-0.8976919651,
-0.0632566586,
-0.5171057582,
0.0664834082,
-0.0206854381,
-0.34355703,
0.2476250678,
-0.8823122382,
-0.7433757782,
0.3151885569,
0.1653793156,
0.2510203421,
-0.2835537195,
0.1100406721,
-0.0067663006,
0.2023321688,
0.7685847878,
-0.0255859178,
-0.7739933133,
-0.6885434389,
-0.2053654939,
-0.311727196,
0.0293659605,
0.85216856,
-0.6230739951,
0.2278251946,
0.594712317,
0.5189131498,
0.1440422982,
-0.0282290727,
0.6008051634,
-1.065202713,
0.2479660958,
-0.0680720583,
0.1989834309,
0.3750033975,
-0.5526047349,
0.1905887127,
0.0371541046,
-0.7571930289,
-0.4845615625,
0.379319191,
-0.9006594419,
-0.4536566734,
1.1782642603,
-0.0868969709,
-0.3462220728,
-0.0014094936,
-0.6330810189,
0.3245861828,
-0.2635004818,
0.9028887749,
0.5240356326,
0.0122078788,
-0.1983230561,
-0.3585663438,
0.5985785723,
0.2070269287,
-0.7163171768,
0.2118625045,
0.6403366923,
0.268645823,
-0.0025198273,
0.5084319115,
0.0857378915,
-0.0342131332,
0.0910516456,
0.0057468978,
0.2593740523,
-0.4954223037,
-0.1336988211,
0.287080586,
0.0132863587,
-0.0203148723
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11328v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11328v1 | Are Large Language Models True Healthcare Jacks-of-All-Trades? Benchmarking Across Health Professions Beyond Physician Exams | 2024-06-17T08:40:36 | 2024-06-17T08:40:36 | Zheheng Luo, Chenhan Yuan, Qianqian Xie, Sophia Ananiadou | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent advancements in Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated their
potential in delivering accurate answers to questions about world knowledge.
Despite this, existing benchmarks for evaluating LLMs in healthcare
predominantly focus on medical doctors, leaving other critical healthcare
professions underrepresented. To fill this research gap, we introduce the
Examinations for Medical Personnel in Chinese (EMPEC), a pioneering large-scale
healthcare knowledge benchmark in traditional Chinese. EMPEC consists of
157,803 exam questions across 124 subjects and 20 healthcare professions,
including underrepresented occupations like Optometrists and Audiologists. Each
question is tagged with its release time and source, ensuring relevance and
authenticity. We conducted extensive experiments on 17 LLMs, including
proprietary, open-source models, general domain models and medical specific
models, evaluating their performance under various settings. Our findings
reveal that while leading models like GPT-4 achieve over 75\% accuracy, they
still struggle with specialized fields and alternative medicine. Surprisingly,
general-purpose LLMs outperformed medical-specific models, and incorporating
EMPEC's training data significantly enhanced performance. Additionally, the
results on questions released after the models' training cutoff date were
consistent with overall performance trends, suggesting that the models'
performance on the test set can predict their effectiveness in addressing
unseen healthcare-related queries. The transition from traditional to
simplified Chinese characters had a negligible impact on model performance,
indicating robust linguistic versatility. Our study underscores the importance
of expanding benchmarks to cover a broader range of healthcare professions to
better assess the applicability of LLMs in real-world healthcare scenarios. | [
0.1221671402,
-0.5513182282,
0.9422490001,
-0.0376939029,
-0.0137967598,
-0.2035546303,
-0.1793486923,
-0.7365011573,
-0.0785392374,
0.4886451662,
-0.2407741249,
-0.432990551,
-0.5851826668,
0.247628957,
-0.0837332532,
0.4397221506,
0.0690368041,
0.4411430955,
-0.111847274,
-0.3617069423,
-0.0126916058,
-0.8218688965,
-0.7308294773,
-0.6294107437,
0.4533497989,
-0.1883756071,
0.6751512289,
0.7237608433,
0.4989996552,
0.1784000695,
-0.1000262201,
0.2756845057,
-0.0115919979,
0.0202542581,
0.025637947,
-0.5103732347,
-0.4746631086,
0.1125235334,
0.6947818995,
0.9266732335,
-0.2549430728,
0.0316368639,
-0.0203329045,
0.3751874566,
-0.4987993836,
0.1079418212,
-0.5563949347,
0.1538072973,
-0.1845473349,
-0.2579508126,
-0.3500516117,
-0.3616635501,
0.0198526382,
-0.2990967631,
-0.126998812,
-0.0016828156,
0.839356482,
0.2061923593,
-0.8725221157,
0.0288416184,
-0.4852619171,
0.5797479153,
-0.8965212107,
0.7293888927,
0.291426748,
0.4476068616,
-0.0801628232,
-0.8014037013,
-0.1949950904,
-0.502137959,
0.124825418,
0.3556575179,
-0.020238379,
0.2939306796,
0.364220947,
0.5381947756,
-0.4284066856,
0.6297421455,
-0.3326940238,
-0.0151398806,
0.60861516,
0.4582948387,
0.581487,
0.0281260777,
-0.2207134664,
0.0966368318,
-1.0173766613,
0.081339702,
-0.3267608285,
-0.0080575896,
-0.1924572736,
0.4917553663,
0.0172019675,
0.6913849115,
-0.382240802,
-0.3912694454,
0.0920172557,
-0.2214101404,
-0.4821077585,
-0.1720466763,
0.806576848,
0.2128705084,
0.1262620389,
-0.1870441586,
-0.3289506137,
-0.204398647,
0.3407588005,
-0.5288895965,
-0.3200699389,
0.2544773221,
-0.6131907105,
-0.1048550531,
-0.0291293617,
-0.339507252,
-0.5856831074,
-0.1927910447,
0.1823767126,
-0.103846617,
-0.238031745,
0.1130976304,
0.2272716463,
0.4294377267,
0.3747789264,
-0.7877829671,
0.3067777455,
1.0081045628,
0.8655920029,
-0.1025725231,
-0.2671157122,
-0.3443326354,
-0.1194359586,
-0.7192275524,
0.5990490317,
-0.4214492738,
-0.2176234722,
0.2010200918,
0.1780009568,
-0.2948067784,
-0.8010148406,
0.4462144673,
-0.2091185302,
-0.1731432229,
-0.3401982486,
-0.6221116781,
0.0541551225,
0.6375820041,
-0.583804667,
0.8279876709,
0.2152653039,
-0.5157399178,
0.364743948,
-0.4192036986,
-0.3032525778,
0.1491376609,
-0.6460962296,
-0.3000656366,
-0.049318336,
0.2089119107,
0.568590045,
-0.9239820838,
0.13974455,
-0.234022975,
-0.3982180655,
0.5631720424,
-0.5295370817,
0.9039536119,
0.0757208467,
-0.1904809624,
-0.1302015036,
-0.3844589293,
0.1585343629,
0.1201163456,
-0.3431514502,
-0.448684901,
-0.1009835899,
0.0344483107,
0.4554778337,
-0.2048457861,
-0.5815349817,
0.0884535611,
-0.4900357425,
0.4671195149,
0.5489107966,
0.0178969353,
-0.1137552559,
-0.5576831698,
0.6117097735,
-0.2643603384,
0.4554440379,
-0.114872925,
-0.7129550576,
-0.4133980274,
-0.3418448567,
0.3955040574,
0.2960349023,
-0.4997850657,
0.3974309266,
-0.1918425113,
-0.9317089915,
-0.7027295232,
-0.0807050914,
0.2888261378,
0.5291021466,
0.1200892925,
-0.1823872328,
0.0965823382,
-0.8789948821,
-0.6420474648,
-0.2967438698,
-0.4283974171,
0.4867736697,
0.3531351686,
-0.1623140574,
0.1789810807,
-0.3818233311,
-0.2972509861,
-0.2498608381,
-0.3029638827,
0.3091276884,
0.2960080206,
0.5648210645,
-0.641653657,
-0.4015542865,
0.2512771487,
-0.6569496393,
-0.1854443699,
-0.1548581719,
-0.0118986201,
-0.0168617908,
0.3500513732,
-0.2489405423,
0.0193003751,
0.7925775051,
-0.1586985588,
0.6077899337,
-0.3374287188,
0.2828088701,
-0.7480716705,
0.3244197369,
0.1690661013,
-0.1802927852,
-0.6298601627,
0.2167391032,
0.4165148735,
-0.0159937348,
-0.4714156985,
0.7837328315,
-0.6019055247,
0.0203903727,
-0.0008782858,
0.101835303,
-0.0566607863,
0.1027542651,
-0.067919299,
0.3983612061,
0.7096514702,
-0.6468217373,
0.4188299775,
0.123324655,
-0.4843788445,
0.4256566763,
-0.7621148229,
-0.0514789075,
0.4062080085,
0.1439292133,
-0.7640477419,
-0.1766452193,
-0.0289676096,
-0.1488418579,
0.0871700868,
-0.0173400994,
-0.7301020026,
-0.4520704448,
0.0633395016,
0.3183321059,
0.7906273603,
-0.5032147169,
0.5164398551,
0.4620479047,
0.1031291336,
-0.4301179945,
-0.9008929133,
-0.1786215454,
0.1509546191,
-0.5395085216,
0.2350902408,
0.3051231503,
-0.3219159544,
-0.4322280586,
-0.3828020096,
-0.4255333245,
0.2024396956,
0.0186382793,
0.5407845378,
-0.2933541238,
0.3200640678,
-0.2239682972,
0.2460809052,
0.3008872867,
-0.082840465,
0.2709869444,
0.1220963448,
-0.8419453502,
-0.2475540191,
0.0099499393,
0.748971343,
-0.3774584532,
0.632941246,
0.2250323147,
-0.4740805924,
-0.0101220887,
-0.9090939164,
-0.3206536472,
-0.4150876403,
0.6171078086,
-0.156327635,
-0.7524328828,
0.540101707,
-0.203489095,
0.4508914053,
0.4505428672,
0.5584939718,
0.2048357725,
0.9555013776,
0.3684920371,
0.0611817464,
0.0523641407,
0.1965558529,
0.2017008215,
-0.7405821085,
-0.3189036548,
-0.3959264457,
-0.0099828336,
-0.8339185715,
-0.5301909447,
0.8353703022,
-0.3802161515,
-0.2041415572,
-0.0855298489,
-0.4700812697,
0.1971241236,
0.1712544858,
0.4246867597,
0.4491529465,
-0.4202156663,
-0.1284653842,
-0.0415083393,
-0.7414121032,
-0.3553726077,
1.2460385561,
0.7811743021,
0.7852932215,
-0.0732150301,
0.3799126148,
-0.070588477,
0.5391431451,
-0.8434361219,
0.2321761549,
-0.5252964497,
-0.6709261537,
-0.2726608813,
-0.4755906165,
-0.8125801086,
0.4867320955,
-0.1396407634,
-0.3609021604,
-0.0225461423,
0.0427919105,
-0.4928719401,
0.6182354093,
-0.1554551721,
0.8800367713,
-0.6004545093,
-0.171282202,
0.0681529492,
-0.5223727226,
0.4988720715,
-0.3556351364,
0.1272497922,
-0.3218165934,
-0.3266837597,
0.6539027691,
-0.1637193412,
0.7008647323,
0.1320868134,
-0.325661242,
-0.2201957107,
-0.0786502063,
0.2783248723,
-0.0137426918,
-0.357530266,
0.4275039732,
0.3043361306,
-0.4365089536,
-0.5347588658,
0.5657535791,
-0.6465948224,
-0.6809747219,
-0.548048079,
-0.1977720857,
-0.5432213545,
0.2288348675,
0.1693346947,
0.5696758032,
-0.3838986456,
0.1498628259,
0.5023056269,
-0.4469931722,
-0.1256706268,
0.769749999,
0.0532322414,
-0.0230229869,
0.3176823258,
0.3016349375,
0.4384329915,
0.322977066,
0.3298945725,
-0.2929330468,
-0.4168277383,
-0.4894251525,
0.5995151997,
-0.7513189316,
0.0692971721,
-0.8646571636,
-0.5915092826,
-0.3424566984,
-0.0518824197,
-0.4966366589,
0.1434630454,
0.1271742284,
0.2344882041,
0.0174646266,
0.7462103367,
0.328466028,
-0.174128145,
-0.9642060995,
0.2057088017,
0.2165454477,
0.5152597427,
0.0400599651,
-0.5636133552,
-0.2393582314,
-0.068821311,
-0.2702680528,
-0.7993524075,
0.2539353967,
-0.0244506188,
0.9964193702,
0.6034114361,
0.1303316802,
0.325525552,
-0.6508182287,
1.0113835335,
0.3375628293,
-0.6626461744,
0.0945644677,
-0.3531840742,
0.3397279382,
0.4131885767,
0.4458723962,
-0.9460403323,
-0.4011188745,
-0.408400476,
-0.6310567856,
0.4590821564,
-0.1185673103,
0.1356018037,
0.007273851,
0.3199967444,
0.0713860393,
0.0054661175,
-0.7402665019,
-0.2926190197,
0.2032697052,
-0.0439220518,
0.1471304893,
-0.0354003198,
-0.3161889911,
-0.2383807153,
0.3335963786,
-0.0651867092,
0.2537614405,
0.3151458502,
0.3173492551,
0.060866531,
0.5179937482,
0.3108043671,
1.0224801302,
0.1518913209,
0.0164492335,
0.3939693272,
-0.4501138926,
0.1252887696,
0.0538696647,
0.2310622185,
0.1069204733,
0.4935429692,
0.3579151034,
0.2764571607,
-0.9751099348,
0.748734653,
0.2154058963,
-0.24763906,
-0.4602250159,
0.0272183158,
-0.0026993298,
0.1199382767,
0.3159344494,
-0.1933087409,
0.1053015664,
-0.700905323,
0.1111154631,
0.3832526505,
-0.4854779243,
-0.1321972013,
0.9159908295,
0.3540605009,
0.0496621914,
0.6197695732,
0.5136023164,
-0.4207138121,
0.8095431924,
0.3911610246,
0.6885960102,
-0.3853579164,
-0.0938166752,
0.3102994263,
0.5097495914,
-0.4922858775,
0.1441128403,
0.2366719097,
-0.4982566237,
-0.3520936668,
-0.1835508794,
-0.8148904443,
0.2078392804,
-0.6009303927,
0.2806867957,
-0.5265088677,
-0.151401028,
-0.0611392297,
-0.1283851564,
-0.7684666514,
0.4594953656,
0.3446498513,
1.0552746058,
-0.7805889845,
0.9514980912,
0.7583318949,
-0.238467291,
-1.0073620081,
0.2983072698,
0.0559380166,
-1.0001232624,
0.4868993461,
0.1965296865,
0.360781908,
-0.43543154,
-0.1196537018,
-0.5199197531,
1.0781009197,
0.3542262316,
-0.6794248819,
-0.4182657301,
0.2598930895,
0.681386292,
-0.3569689989,
0.6409971714,
0.6910806298,
0.3827981055,
-0.3640232086,
-1.485830307,
0.2803371251,
-0.2214146256,
-0.1858314276,
-0.0377635695,
-0.9617456198,
1.1411366463,
-0.0443961434,
-0.1694063097,
0.0594963804,
-0.0500177033,
0.5083059669,
0.3170108795,
0.5265749097,
-0.0764164031,
0.7575306892,
-0.2979777753,
1.3420491219,
-0.3971791267,
0.0545539148,
0.5718204975,
-0.5974060893,
0.6889029741,
0.2334638238,
-0.3470442295,
0.147951588,
0.7363699079,
-0.3257097006,
0.0665852875,
0.261629492,
-0.1756536514,
-0.5665669441,
-0.1828792244,
-0.6496595144,
0.5242589116,
0.1359822303,
-0.7358285785,
0.0935647637,
-0.1524358541,
-0.0656858683,
0.1011415645,
-0.387942344,
0.5914680958,
0.4430579543,
-0.5899394751,
0.6663475633,
-0.1068363637,
0.7191869617,
-0.9049974084,
-0.0804574564,
-0.0963319764,
0.2017539293,
-0.0744298771,
-0.6711611152,
-0.0205060896,
-0.2274608016,
0.2817432582,
-0.0869630426,
0.5344037414,
-0.4404324293,
-0.3940642476,
0.3797313273,
0.6945033669,
0.3867325485,
-0.2599211931,
-0.6900833249,
-0.2255413383,
-0.143305704,
-0.1060450673,
0.4210580885,
0.3733359277,
0.0780018941,
0.6503412724,
0.4216934741,
0.5996186137,
-0.1787111014,
0.1946368665,
0.7844210863,
-0.5991606712,
-0.6488181353,
-0.8960169554,
0.1228587925,
-0.0308634937,
-0.4086574018,
0.6931996942,
0.3496325612,
0.7007188201,
-0.0688221604,
0.8448969722,
0.4243761599,
0.558909297,
-0.5702246428,
1.1793689728,
-1.0764168501,
0.0871085674,
-0.2260469049,
-0.5726739168,
-0.3281198144,
0.1907598823,
-0.3953955472,
0.2514930964,
0.7232511044,
0.4302874804,
-0.0294587165,
-0.0303160734,
0.9727939963,
0.052826792,
0.3981755972,
0.6584584117,
0.743513763,
-0.4413510859,
0.3965350986,
-0.2481892556,
-0.2028650641,
-0.1831790954,
-0.3904933929,
-1.0449810028,
-0.208908245,
-0.254532069,
-0.1542042941,
0.1588739157,
1.1092211008,
0.6112173796,
-0.6311203241,
-0.1186019406,
0.4973483086,
-0.2999869287,
-0.6157312393,
-0.1140892059,
0.5099964738,
0.0162565168,
-0.6745684743,
0.3476294875,
0.1935381591,
-0.0479665101,
-0.364138931,
0.1292724162,
0.0654157251,
0.1624420583,
0.4225241244,
0.2392353863,
-1.0092008114,
0.1095115617,
0.3645499349,
-0.5641194582,
0.1158699468,
1.0304057598,
-0.2828096151,
0.4390057921,
0.2602462173,
0.8245516419,
-0.1271945834,
-0.1483681351,
0.6107016802,
-0.3210407794,
0.0024511216,
0.4777806401,
0.6217494607,
0.2924809456,
-0.5109285116,
0.6457340717,
0.0153908478,
-0.7492367029,
-0.8927769065,
-0.1538306624,
-0.6604989767,
-0.3399353325,
1.1972100735,
-0.2211610526,
-0.0693585202,
-0.3966684937,
0.0574524887,
0.2689022422,
0.027783066,
0.8315066695,
0.4440805912,
-0.2518485188,
-0.2192932218,
-1.0067805052,
0.4210984707,
0.7181857824,
-0.9301591516,
0.24475649,
0.2599340379,
0.5244452953,
-0.2967947721,
0.9907874465,
-0.4767931402,
0.6459627151,
0.0364490002,
0.1003351361,
-0.114360258,
0.0744132996,
-0.1805380434,
-0.0877695307,
0.2049730867,
-0.0693432391
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11925v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11925v2 | DocCGen: Document-based Controlled Code Generation | 2024-06-17T08:34:57 | 2024-07-03T09:16:27 | Sameer Pimparkhede, Mehant Kammakomati, Srikanth Tamilselvam, Prince Kumar, Ashok Pon Kumar, Pushpak Bhattacharyya | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL | Recent developments show that Large Language Models (LLMs) produce
state-of-the-art performance on natural language (NL) to code generation for
resource-rich general-purpose languages like C++, Java, and Python. However,
their practical usage for structured domain-specific languages (DSLs) such as
YAML, JSON is limited due to domain-specific schema, grammar, and
customizations generally unseen by LLMs during pre-training. Efforts have been
made to mitigate this challenge via in-context learning through relevant
examples or by fine-tuning. However, it suffers from problems, such as limited
DSL samples and prompt sensitivity but enterprises maintain good documentation
of the DSLs. Therefore, we propose DocCGen, a framework that can leverage such
rich knowledge by breaking the NL-to-Code generation task for structured code
languages into a two-step process. First, it detects the correct libraries
using the library documentation that best matches the NL query. Then, it
utilizes schema rules extracted from the documentation of these libraries to
constrain the decoding. We evaluate our framework for two complex structured
languages, Ansible YAML and Bash command, consisting of two settings:
Out-of-domain (OOD) and In-domain (ID). Our extensive experiments show that
DocCGen consistently improves different-sized language models across all six
evaluation metrics, reducing syntactic and semantic errors in structured code.
We plan to open-source the datasets and code to motivate research in
constrained code generation. | [
-0.3352304697,
-0.6841657162,
0.540427804,
0.162819773,
-0.0903388485,
0.1650247276,
-0.4739351273,
-0.2275744081,
-0.2462607622,
0.8357560635,
-0.4928077161,
-0.8909671903,
-0.3787554801,
0.3026487231,
-0.4014577568,
0.9003685713,
-0.1039980054,
0.0384986959,
-0.3701395392,
0.2289191782,
0.029177364,
-0.4271979928,
-0.364610672,
0.0601639077,
0.1022437438,
0.39793244,
0.3779984117,
0.8545879126,
0.3882839382,
0.2202172279,
-0.0106124431,
0.6835217476,
-0.4682658911,
0.3525304496,
-0.1168562919,
-0.4171771407,
-0.402682215,
-0.1310928464,
0.4271363616,
0.6471132636,
-0.2527244091,
-0.0639354885,
-0.1275315434,
0.3912620246,
-0.4330427647,
0.324021697,
-0.6952617764,
-0.0687831417,
-0.0101241581,
-0.5472093225,
-0.5855808258,
-0.323099792,
-0.3864090145,
-0.8165510297,
0.4773949981,
-0.1155276,
0.7091286778,
0.4604589641,
-0.3658695519,
-0.7355883121,
-0.716265142,
0.7113192677,
-0.9077728391,
0.300290525,
0.2967936099,
0.0210598204,
-0.5078503489,
-1.1028348207,
-0.5932030082,
-0.3092861474,
-0.280074656,
0.0005173502,
0.2001800537,
0.0652867258,
0.3916756809,
0.2963033617,
-0.5684103966,
0.0881711841,
-0.5192402005,
-0.0822494775,
0.5811032653,
0.1511334181,
0.2994984984,
-0.045308128,
-0.1580719203,
-0.2075032741,
-0.8154892325,
-0.2271728963,
0.4809279144,
0.4178081751,
-0.0898358449,
0.469828397,
-0.0273823664,
0.8015047908,
0.2693147063,
-0.1313323677,
0.0960055217,
-0.3757971227,
-0.2061429918,
-0.0477454513,
0.6815896034,
0.1838676035,
0.2116500288,
-0.3270601332,
-0.2980793417,
0.3666117489,
0.6027291417,
-0.7893181443,
0.073757574,
0.4228483737,
-0.2591687739,
-0.5361396074,
-0.0470947437,
-0.6129567623,
-0.3174613714,
-0.3116943538,
-0.4062414765,
-0.3920288682,
-0.2170603573,
0.0978330746,
-0.314806819,
0.3135479093,
0.2618036568,
-0.8174243569,
0.2578258216,
0.6836905479,
0.5780460835,
-0.1480930001,
-0.1248347536,
-0.6700829268,
0.354922682,
-0.5748576522,
0.5325244069,
-0.5359799862,
-0.8360737562,
0.2256610245,
-0.036670059,
0.0082466751,
-0.4635099769,
0.4058532119,
-0.4753318131,
0.2830123603,
0.166100949,
-0.6700333953,
0.3699763417,
0.1262488663,
-0.5403389335,
0.9409306049,
0.6038223505,
-0.9187093377,
0.5410453081,
-0.5682628155,
-0.6890095472,
0.378556937,
-0.6749926805,
-0.2105622739,
0.067703627,
-0.0846040696,
0.3365639448,
-0.3368961215,
0.3893761337,
-0.052692771,
-0.2944121659,
-0.2780990601,
0.1270537674,
0.6714246273,
0.4883666933,
-0.4534467757,
0.0981274843,
-1.1004521847,
0.2859236002,
0.1516874582,
-0.8094240427,
-0.3344261646,
0.0725592524,
0.0982714221,
0.3481264412,
0.0801467746,
-0.4532583356,
0.5489403605,
-0.4486070871,
0.453006953,
0.4433091879,
0.0852784738,
0.6499748826,
0.0289130043,
0.6279214025,
-0.1107606068,
0.0601590052,
-0.2532485723,
-0.1189752147,
-0.5275793672,
-0.354377836,
0.0753304735,
0.4885004759,
-0.8863196373,
0.5787241459,
-0.2135833204,
-0.3419542015,
-0.405813098,
0.4619762897,
0.3565636873,
0.663967967,
0.2115424722,
-0.4264155924,
-0.5202621818,
-0.5979772806,
0.3495396972,
-0.2134410292,
-0.1780178249,
0.349969089,
0.1472262442,
-0.406504631,
0.9321154356,
-0.4473388195,
-0.1842379868,
-0.4110090137,
0.0429331362,
0.0200179145,
0.4883332551,
0.4604232609,
-0.8806403875,
-0.3506803513,
0.1221104413,
-0.6591373086,
-0.4207299054,
-0.2996397614,
-0.0336568989,
0.5220612288,
0.9478016496,
-0.5179892182,
0.2178298086,
0.6123752594,
-0.3729447126,
0.5174732804,
-0.6496056914,
-0.0791654885,
-1.012160182,
0.2819519043,
-0.1443785727,
-0.1279651225,
-0.6493312716,
0.4085252881,
0.4194006622,
-0.0769471526,
-0.4944181144,
0.3975878656,
-0.3310057521,
0.0461719073,
-0.2216405272,
-0.0301931724,
0.2876371145,
0.3902899027,
0.343185544,
0.8874657154,
0.4787600338,
-0.7572900653,
0.1028649732,
0.4414078295,
-0.1881380677,
0.5352584124,
-0.5768093467,
0.281231761,
0.0157657545,
0.3319142461,
-0.3813810349,
-0.2345008254,
0.1003033146,
-0.2390591204,
0.7871661186,
-0.250918448,
-0.7398481965,
-0.1945937425,
-0.0063413819,
-0.1096258909,
0.4643126726,
-0.499494791,
0.4306322932,
0.1000694707,
-0.063931331,
-0.3404468298,
-0.6004914641,
0.1570857316,
-0.0132378601,
-0.7717353106,
0.4579589367,
-0.3178874552,
-0.3061571717,
0.0104260491,
-0.0947773531,
-0.0014201761,
0.1315083355,
0.194964081,
0.2847505808,
-0.0543955639,
0.0653930083,
0.1765176356,
-0.1150626317,
-0.1026655957,
-0.7130560279,
0.6258873343,
-0.0411786884,
-0.3074758649,
0.2685374916,
0.5436787009,
0.6253190637,
-0.6616613865,
0.4913617671,
0.4674099088,
-0.0136564653,
-0.9374077916,
-0.0677384064,
0.0458467491,
-0.508564055,
0.2869540453,
-0.2322697043,
-0.8517439365,
0.190176174,
-0.3955319226,
0.2645243704,
0.2726839185,
0.7498427033,
0.1183646172,
0.8977511525,
0.8910945654,
0.2743845284,
0.2481389344,
-0.4007975459,
0.2098225951,
-0.4534047246,
-0.1957612038,
-0.7370867729,
0.2388252318,
-0.7899448276,
-0.5055965781,
0.1147463694,
0.1428906918,
0.1239508092,
0.5073830485,
-0.5911927223,
0.2554025948,
0.6230459809,
-0.2901239097,
0.1780820638,
-0.2581008375,
-0.4039000571,
0.442550987,
-0.7402232289,
-0.5259109139,
1.0084264278,
0.1095480174,
0.8510285616,
-0.1458510011,
1.0108351707,
0.4986045361,
-0.0136359343,
-0.5397914648,
0.4083858728,
-0.3635874689,
-0.5332326293,
-0.148319304,
-0.6970441341,
-0.7135924101,
-0.3539047837,
0.0019970722,
-0.2909861207,
0.2103821486,
0.0050177565,
0.0714048296,
-0.0120741045,
-0.7082028985,
0.569816947,
-0.2958068252,
-0.4441328049,
-0.0097972089,
-0.6418959498,
0.2144481093,
-0.3738793433,
0.4001724124,
0.364613682,
0.1674166024,
0.2130134851,
-0.5900893211,
0.6676507592,
-0.254692167,
-0.4549152553,
0.3181541562,
0.1350074261,
0.7712965608,
0.0759279877,
-0.071112439,
0.0445080437,
0.0945401415,
-0.3780165017,
-0.396812737,
0.7159340978,
-0.4532401562,
-0.4872768223,
0.0343836881,
-0.6439048648,
-0.2951024771,
0.3910687566,
0.5040690303,
0.4337519109,
-0.1536821872,
0.0718101338,
0.8737779856,
-0.6074146628,
0.1576632857,
0.5525634885,
-0.0305362511,
-0.0723321587,
0.6427487731,
-0.2242999375,
0.4295615256,
0.2849436998,
-0.1005976498,
-0.1144564748,
-0.7847668529,
-0.6002674699,
0.0135878269,
-0.8576114774,
-0.1783721894,
-0.5314378738,
-0.224449113,
-0.6708948612,
-0.5016223192,
-0.2310408801,
-0.4244067669,
-0.2492388189,
-0.2535015345,
0.0315236337,
0.7103121281,
0.0500336103,
0.0787316784,
-0.7202705741,
0.4039780498,
-0.0651711822,
0.5490518808,
-0.577072382,
-0.0817826465,
-0.2905396223,
-0.2336625606,
-0.0591661297,
-0.5287678242,
0.3976380229,
0.2395749837,
0.7379211783,
0.344222784,
0.3163602054,
0.1379832327,
-0.5029249787,
0.6962109804,
-0.0234749708,
-0.7686524391,
0.6217507124,
-0.3758078814,
0.2029059976,
0.4047033489,
0.0383131094,
-0.4890219271,
-0.918150723,
-0.6103521585,
-1.0085912943,
0.73234725,
0.1246767566,
0.1043707207,
-0.2371076047,
0.3041703403,
0.2456517518,
0.2311071157,
-0.1585238874,
-0.1266093105,
-0.3651957512,
-0.2608991861,
-0.0075448197,
0.0334015079,
-0.2387907803,
0.3075029254,
0.5757750273,
-0.3671558797,
0.002315707,
0.2593309581,
-0.2792489231,
-0.2424110919,
0.3126029372,
0.6429132819,
0.6828998327,
-0.3837089837,
0.0663315356,
-0.2157509327,
-0.4958469272,
-0.0742345154,
0.1671494842,
-0.4302203953,
0.0242719539,
0.4336732924,
0.4795753956,
-0.2754202485,
-0.9183551073,
0.403565973,
-0.2625337839,
-0.5391722322,
-0.111551106,
0.4974496961,
0.1227408648,
0.0819640085,
0.1305316538,
-0.1316998154,
-0.1256694198,
-0.3265087306,
0.5338895321,
0.2554480433,
-0.2404822707,
0.0220224261,
0.6845957041,
0.3075927794,
-0.1168208495,
0.6499869227,
-0.4676474631,
-0.347815454,
0.8252612352,
0.6173235178,
0.6881657243,
0.1624492705,
0.2375963628,
0.2731609344,
0.3051351905,
0.1436598748,
0.2332654893,
-0.2402843684,
-0.6074554324,
-0.2790594399,
-0.8244479299,
-0.2866207361,
0.1521684527,
-0.5818251371,
0.365960151,
-0.7797811031,
0.0770748779,
-0.2505369186,
0.1227303147,
-0.7969870567,
0.2172530144,
0.2891017497,
1.3745470047,
-0.5946169496,
1.2222989798,
0.5231189728,
-0.4785968959,
-0.7731485367,
-0.1028556451,
-0.0057755294,
-0.53559196,
0.5144194961,
-0.1390371174,
-0.1482796371,
0.1283630431,
-0.667511642,
-0.3236992061,
1.2109816074,
0.1678723991,
-0.6178500056,
-0.1630346924,
0.08475703,
0.6833745241,
-0.6046367288,
-0.1739446372,
0.6307800412,
0.4498743713,
0.1049101353,
-0.6068839431,
0.064347066,
-0.5225774646,
-0.0846884921,
0.2177771479,
-0.3160541058,
0.4783492982,
-0.2357084304,
-0.3339087665,
0.0018243109,
0.1853363216,
0.2665914893,
0.3116368055,
0.3779151142,
0.2875061929,
0.8331699371,
0.0473211966,
1.2703957558,
-0.7533779144,
0.1422015131,
1.0126481056,
-0.4403777421,
0.4014175534,
0.5516266227,
0.0831415802,
0.3980122507,
0.4175486863,
-0.2612718046,
0.6860064864,
0.4140828252,
-0.101925768,
-0.0395811759,
-0.2102396339,
-0.4557879269,
0.3797519505,
0.6188142896,
-0.5772158504,
-0.1756896973,
-0.4227141738,
0.137725994,
0.2912412286,
-0.0193379,
0.7645970583,
-0.0398739092,
-0.6265639663,
0.5999819636,
0.3356595635,
0.5316609144,
-1.0530927181,
-0.0268785097,
-0.5244432688,
0.0274008811,
-0.2746991515,
-0.3373554647,
0.4406083524,
0.3188847005,
-0.1276326329,
-0.5653110743,
0.929256618,
-0.4130125642,
-0.3069222867,
0.455291748,
0.5142787099,
-0.1350882649,
0.2957989573,
-0.2852323055,
-0.1111103371,
0.0512214378,
-0.2975696325,
0.3010622263,
0.6024888754,
-0.0756288916,
0.3549219966,
0.8705104589,
0.3890022933,
0.1157049611,
0.1858566403,
1.0469274521,
-0.4556430578,
-0.5481708646,
-0.2516914904,
0.2973513603,
-0.0063761766,
-0.0900458768,
0.4788642228,
0.4717936516,
1.0648442507,
-0.178644225,
1.2094976902,
-0.459587574,
0.2254948914,
-0.599330008,
0.7668522596,
-0.5205877423,
0.4517096877,
-0.070716165,
-0.7942495346,
-0.2931360304,
0.256262958,
-0.0516517907,
-0.1727739275,
0.632058084,
1.0223811865,
0.0829479471,
-0.4182291329,
0.4141441286,
0.0203869566,
0.622345984,
0.493671,
0.6972044706,
0.2181024253,
0.7770656347,
-0.1626109183,
-0.2209747285,
-0.0733332559,
-0.9242226481,
-0.7156726122,
-0.5099788904,
-0.2536263168,
-0.4656880498,
-0.1212342829,
0.8258907199,
0.6155653596,
-0.6313878894,
-0.0701047704,
-0.5320720673,
-0.0616760701,
-0.1348885894,
-0.177964747,
0.32900244,
-0.7425165176,
-0.7599939704,
0.5747588873,
0.323577106,
-0.0602476113,
-0.2738263309,
-0.5571597815,
0.1842867285,
0.2464779168,
0.330122292,
0.2516697347,
-0.2869425118,
0.0521850772,
0.1570360363,
-0.6242806911,
-0.0016380838,
1.1399111748,
-0.6338850856,
0.5359134674,
0.5132712126,
0.4276611507,
0.3698216081,
-0.0228545424,
0.7646435499,
-1.0872895718,
0.1047268584,
0.1815000474,
0.1940956861,
0.362170428,
-0.5137531757,
0.6473525763,
0.1079143882,
-0.3349018991,
-0.593236506,
0.4459472597,
-0.8144322634,
-0.6284976602,
1.4312907457,
-0.3074524105,
-0.168253839,
-0.2006919384,
-0.1461995989,
0.4342356026,
-0.2066398561,
0.7540614605,
0.4093110859,
0.1673474312,
0.1368869692,
-0.3709046245,
0.6911160946,
-0.1613093615,
-0.9744265676,
0.2492380589,
0.6904662251,
0.1851621568,
0.2360480875,
0.5605660081,
-0.3021511137,
0.2523782551,
0.2792625129,
0.2909122705,
-0.5573523045,
-0.3780378103,
-0.2145368606,
0.1387715936,
0.2550686598,
0.0805090889
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11317v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11317v1 | GUICourse: From General Vision Language Models to Versatile GUI Agents | 2024-06-17T08:30:55 | 2024-06-17T08:30:55 | Wentong Chen, Junbo Cui, Jinyi Hu, Yujia Qin, Junjie Fang, Yue Zhao, Chongyi Wang, Jun Liu, Guirong Chen, Yupeng Huo, Yuan Yao, Yankai Lin, Zhiyuan Liu, Maosong Sun | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.HC | Utilizing Graphic User Interface (GUI) for human-computer interaction is
essential for accessing a wide range of digital tools. Recent advancements in
Vision Language Models (VLMs) highlight the compelling potential to develop
versatile agents to help humans finish GUI navigation tasks. However, current
VLMs are challenged in terms of fundamental abilities (OCR and grounding) and
GUI knowledge (the functions and control methods of GUI elements), preventing
them from becoming practical GUI agents. To solve these challenges, we
contribute GUICourse, a suite of datasets to train visual-based GUI agents from
general VLMs. First, we introduce the GUIEnv dataset to strengthen the OCR and
grounding capabilities of VLMs. Then, we introduce the GUIAct and GUIChat
datasets to enrich their knowledge of GUI components and interactions.
Experiments demonstrate that our GUI agents have better performance on common
GUI tasks than their baseline VLMs. Even the small-size GUI agent (with 3.1B
parameters) can still work well on single-step and multi-step GUI tasks.
Finally, we analyze the different varieties in the training stage of this agent
by ablation study. Our source codes and datasets are released at
https://github.com/yiye3/GUICourse. | [
-0.5003546476,
-0.6908404231,
0.3838460743,
-0.5320090055,
0.0687146261,
-0.0060830978,
-0.0602362379,
-0.476595372,
-0.2454515696,
0.9937617779,
-0.2442816496,
-0.7322865129,
-0.0304776244,
-0.2222711891,
-0.270899564,
0.9934287667,
-0.1216298044,
-0.1285363436,
-0.4574580789,
-0.3567895591,
-0.2386754155,
-0.4124982953,
-0.6111559868,
-0.0635160878,
0.8379848003,
0.4170622826,
0.5897413492,
0.2322144359,
0.2656293809,
0.3558555841,
0.3280551732,
0.2033665627,
-0.3693625033,
0.0842403844,
-0.2855973542,
-0.3592000902,
-0.3978099823,
-0.0437253788,
0.2743034363,
0.6189050674,
-0.1147951484,
-0.227288574,
-0.07442417,
0.6352472305,
-0.7689543962,
0.2116407007,
-0.2101969868,
-0.3791045547,
-0.1231785789,
0.2943400741,
-0.4585358799,
-0.200956732,
0.2404507548,
-0.9607248306,
0.3337626159,
-0.0024658404,
0.8750188351,
0.1555025876,
-0.4251090288,
0.083852604,
-0.4937122464,
0.592094779,
-0.3441923857,
0.1572510898,
0.2848228514,
0.8592819571,
0.0076422491,
-0.8639137745,
-0.3243866265,
-0.5455508232,
-0.0197057817,
0.1056698561,
0.0470067151,
0.6406303048,
0.6255840659,
0.0687400997,
-0.6532500982,
0.0277821776,
-0.2176190913,
-0.1759306043,
0.6942759156,
0.3335164785,
0.7615652084,
0.237557292,
-0.0630295575,
-0.3972542882,
-0.355206579,
0.0072174924,
0.2337372303,
0.0825345591,
-0.2088015974,
0.5523889065,
-0.3885460198,
1.0343769789,
-0.4514073431,
-0.2381040007,
0.1295739114,
-0.2152467668,
-0.2440417856,
-0.3152098954,
0.3570912182,
0.2062220573,
0.5595274568,
-0.0938260704,
-0.2018759549,
0.0025299115,
0.5700323582,
-0.5352643132,
-0.5448812842,
0.0511376299,
-0.098429352,
-0.2770961821,
0.1600030661,
-0.3593163192,
-0.5363451242,
-0.5178960562,
0.4763736129,
-0.5139560103,
-0.1793170273,
-0.112603195,
-0.5456572771,
0.3133887649,
1.1349821091,
-0.7189233303,
0.4637338817,
0.2855899334,
0.6729968786,
-0.1819696277,
-0.3570613265,
-0.5910853148,
0.1657430679,
-0.1586265564,
0.560339272,
-0.5163542628,
-0.379914999,
-0.0798041448,
0.0298053212,
-0.0990486592,
-0.2727849185,
0.036601644,
-0.2974584699,
-0.0578393303,
-0.2305630296,
-0.0416395664,
-0.5489279628,
0.3066132069,
-0.7638463974,
0.7204038501,
0.6184682846,
-0.8333550692,
0.3047073185,
-0.6641609073,
-0.4377004802,
0.2687273622,
-0.2802163661,
-0.3904633224,
0.0716630369,
0.1028484032,
0.2742046416,
-0.0760998651,
-0.2142112404,
-0.4576064348,
-0.3712817729,
-0.0030597234,
-0.4549972415,
1.0513221025,
0.0243231822,
-0.1380906701,
0.0597822405,
-0.8742130995,
0.063972801,
-0.0691760257,
0.0367894694,
-0.6524450183,
-0.1616190672,
0.3724537194,
0.078030251,
0.0514534563,
-0.3422426283,
0.7190499306,
-0.1007113308,
0.1883348972,
0.5659641623,
-0.0999494419,
0.4304316342,
-0.0624588691,
0.3627885282,
0.1331546456,
0.320646137,
-0.1463420242,
-0.473008126,
-0.9246494174,
-0.3894854486,
0.0896525905,
0.6340227127,
-1.4828534126,
-0.2135730535,
-0.0599629395,
-0.5648801327,
-0.1381942928,
0.0241835937,
0.3714203537,
0.4845294654,
0.2360454649,
-0.5697492957,
-0.1506301314,
-0.5621448159,
0.2483986616,
-0.268961966,
-0.1556010246,
0.5097872615,
0.5725499988,
-0.495595783,
1.1748228073,
-0.4922763705,
-0.2007440031,
-0.2700706124,
0.3645279706,
-0.0823324919,
0.2734747529,
0.7994678617,
-0.8235575557,
-0.4295572639,
0.5642981529,
-0.9410107136,
-0.1282777488,
-0.0710464492,
-0.0568886325,
0.4538573027,
0.3016327322,
-0.2748777866,
0.889355123,
0.1673092991,
-0.2149058878,
0.7170664072,
-0.4958915412,
0.2120126039,
-0.497422725,
0.1862807721,
0.1446703672,
-0.3465704322,
-0.7174860835,
-0.0516368113,
0.0539005473,
-0.1778674126,
-0.5273385048,
0.7671964169,
-0.6918673515,
-0.3765318096,
-0.3607014418,
0.0135911722,
0.0545362495,
0.6424068213,
0.2192094326,
0.8521953821,
0.8936670423,
-0.8128246665,
0.6079269052,
0.2084728628,
-0.2112457901,
0.7661780715,
-0.4804351926,
0.0766642764,
-0.1972141415,
-0.0968977064,
-0.7673986554,
-0.3651784658,
0.2939352989,
-0.2332144231,
0.426081866,
-0.2718877494,
-0.1539056748,
-0.5040078759,
-0.0463561751,
0.1623695493,
0.5459999442,
-0.3718988299,
0.7033439875,
0.2143643647,
-0.0043826713,
-0.5874044895,
-0.3944503665,
0.170613423,
-0.0203474723,
-0.5498620272,
-0.0823497996,
-0.0458751842,
-0.3858498931,
-0.0330908783,
0.2337215245,
-0.1105168909,
0.3249472976,
0.4162605107,
0.3524317741,
-0.0562060848,
-0.1096625626,
-0.1712872833,
-0.2849750221,
-0.2388040423,
-0.4548130631,
0.0500802174,
-0.1952918172,
-0.6100062728,
-0.1507429183,
0.1606092751,
0.5690114498,
-0.2406072021,
0.2664965689,
0.7080840468,
-0.1489081085,
-0.1359338313,
-0.4463333786,
0.0256351344,
-0.467798382,
0.5220626593,
-0.5648779273,
-0.5279074907,
0.3735996783,
0.0645032227,
0.2789745629,
0.0133238174,
0.3196282983,
-0.1447948813,
1.1213737726,
0.9457386732,
-0.1106483787,
0.6650941968,
-0.4730795324,
-0.3341583312,
-0.6474852562,
-0.0305186547,
-0.3514615297,
0.0681007355,
-0.4666440785,
-0.4177316129,
0.4122653604,
-0.1744278222,
-0.3298923075,
0.2704457045,
-0.3298534155,
0.4840170443,
0.8315677643,
0.23044388,
0.0812204331,
0.3504226506,
-0.049123615,
0.2354359627,
-0.5794842243,
-0.3999425769,
1.0011744499,
0.0799025297,
1.2077952623,
-0.1311121285,
0.4812152088,
0.4756331146,
0.2827075124,
-0.6661251187,
0.6681501269,
-0.2189204395,
-0.1369287819,
-0.5845947266,
-0.2742031813,
-0.7094471455,
0.1309356093,
0.1217988133,
-0.8619635105,
0.1959968656,
0.0541420355,
0.0705489963,
0.3076334298,
-0.6833309531,
1.0216530561,
-0.5223169327,
-0.7734056711,
0.1117982939,
-0.8341152668,
0.0760153681,
0.2769267559,
-0.141145885,
0.1050191149,
-0.0160179473,
0.3004805744,
-0.5161743164,
0.9325214624,
-0.3412077427,
-0.2038452774,
0.4577802718,
-0.218672514,
0.274763912,
-0.104348734,
0.0790117458,
0.2647787035,
-0.1389857829,
-0.4479775727,
-0.8587712049,
0.2644706666,
-1.0084645748,
-0.5596069098,
-0.469464004,
-0.2766105235,
-0.1680242121,
0.2931125462,
0.2437199652,
0.644382298,
-0.3690135181,
-0.1689877659,
0.7111349702,
-0.2185029536,
0.2193639427,
0.4540392458,
-0.1893345118,
-0.5362071991,
1.2128170729,
0.1420516223,
0.4397696257,
0.3821188509,
-0.340324223,
-0.0341370367,
-0.5892006159,
-0.5916162133,
0.1024818495,
-0.7522652745,
0.029636899,
-0.5187397003,
-0.3664949536,
-0.3283376098,
-0.4347651303,
0.0765828341,
-0.190881744,
-0.3902780712,
0.2591746449,
0.3932990432,
0.8118426204,
-0.1051555276,
0.1906447113,
-0.5990356207,
0.4219236374,
0.7081654072,
0.203558296,
-0.2159574032,
-0.1575969011,
-0.4394733608,
0.2841558754,
-0.3124814332,
-0.653668344,
0.3451727927,
0.1891913116,
0.8636558056,
0.6166166663,
0.0127388556,
0.6606130004,
-0.310138464,
0.8202232122,
0.3031139374,
-0.5942072868,
0.7469268441,
-0.4003194273,
0.1402629316,
0.4356290102,
0.1394677609,
-0.5555904508,
-0.418576628,
-0.4804955125,
-0.5799076557,
0.8613131642,
0.2997638881,
-0.3276516497,
0.4229502976,
0.2567347586,
0.1508944035,
0.1755870134,
-0.382607013,
-0.0657945499,
-0.5888782144,
-0.2605904937,
-0.3067656159,
0.0034250168,
-0.1533811539,
-0.1477342099,
0.4917293191,
-0.5269088149,
0.0420242846,
0.129996419,
-0.4373801351,
0.3937828541,
-0.0053852117,
0.5421996713,
0.4259913266,
-0.1480817348,
-0.0585230514,
0.0570061952,
-0.888957262,
0.3656589985,
-0.0471282229,
-0.3087099493,
-0.0658811033,
0.3168138862,
1.0306538343,
0.0001479668,
-0.712579608,
0.4515368044,
-0.1829629987,
-0.2467228621,
-0.1881902367,
0.7449159622,
-0.5042217374,
0.1009099782,
0.1089203656,
-0.0868711099,
0.323471725,
-0.360575676,
0.1773930192,
0.3025304973,
-0.5250030756,
-0.1888902783,
0.6412351131,
0.5075011849,
0.0552415214,
0.862056911,
-0.0413758717,
-0.3032830358,
0.8922394514,
0.2022050321,
1.01281178,
0.0282850806,
0.4919873774,
0.2189282328,
0.2004825324,
0.0358516052,
0.0447113588,
-0.2810948789,
-0.5272651315,
0.0329449177,
-0.2881650925,
-0.7808585167,
-0.2485424131,
-0.511629045,
0.4455958605,
-0.2151471227,
-0.134100005,
-0.3556306958,
0.1952154934,
-0.7132916451,
0.4128869176,
0.2970644534,
0.8521478772,
-0.6409000754,
0.8775577545,
1.0091528893,
-0.7334336638,
-0.3342140019,
-0.2778784931,
-0.0176906697,
-0.6697878242,
0.6214315295,
0.1666115224,
-0.0455909111,
0.0567709617,
-0.827235043,
-0.3456492126,
1.1699030399,
0.3067461848,
-0.4500344694,
-0.3453676999,
0.2239160389,
0.43014884,
-0.2180764377,
0.7451680303,
0.3578645289,
0.4280007482,
0.303273797,
-0.8166128397,
-0.30002895,
-0.3358542919,
0.3857477009,
-0.1247430518,
-0.535618484,
0.7665321827,
-0.5572868586,
-0.1091554314,
0.1813483983,
0.6121829152,
0.155312106,
0.5261796713,
0.4094927907,
0.4567319751,
0.6967302561,
-0.2374379188,
0.9077544808,
0.1414509118,
0.0013758732,
0.8042437434,
-0.4321212471,
0.3397013843,
0.035647355,
0.0039753378,
0.5318134427,
0.4883318543,
0.0352366753,
0.3613725305,
0.1395680457,
-0.2750320435,
-0.4458727241,
0.1402014196,
-0.3741358221,
0.3996326029,
0.5819411278,
0.1811499894,
-0.3342567682,
0.7428293228,
-0.3436208963,
-0.1120035276,
-0.4874308407,
0.8855837584,
-0.0286732633,
-0.4520656765,
0.4450756311,
-0.3324148357,
0.2350600362,
-0.8473715782,
-0.367048502,
-0.3284551799,
-0.0425748117,
-0.0726393834,
-0.861731708,
-0.2611715794,
-0.1601664573,
0.0729648545,
-0.041190546,
1.0845478773,
-0.3625563383,
-0.25629884,
-0.1084227413,
0.1942127496,
0.2106664032,
-0.1269080192,
-0.5402878523,
-0.1135485172,
-0.0104011055,
-0.1482497603,
0.2910408974,
0.6508228779,
-0.3439244926,
1.010653615,
0.314214617,
0.0328243263,
-0.2568493783,
0.294308424,
0.8612322807,
-0.8386388421,
-0.4997020662,
-0.2510174811,
0.7823104262,
-0.4215788841,
-0.0543428138,
0.7159888148,
0.3952543139,
0.7081663013,
-0.3453387916,
1.2830835581,
-0.010753829,
0.0204575565,
-0.6310762167,
0.8549594879,
-0.7743727565,
-0.0814067274,
-0.4782981575,
-0.6359146833,
-0.225806728,
0.6219978333,
-0.2798781991,
0.2245884985,
0.291942507,
0.6799505949,
-0.0858069137,
-0.326374948,
0.7731288075,
-0.0539947227,
0.4985327423,
0.7882429957,
0.8113851547,
-0.2803239226,
0.4115690887,
-0.0358093344,
-0.3960545659,
-0.5912650824,
-0.6036353707,
-1.1840233803,
-0.5554349422,
-0.5885283351,
-0.2788226902,
0.3830429912,
0.2233308852,
0.6233096719,
-0.4647346437,
-0.200493902,
-0.3304807842,
0.2880978286,
-0.4458019137,
-0.1703763753,
0.0489316918,
-0.3087004125,
-0.7400810719,
-0.2070188522,
0.4914831221,
0.6647911668,
-0.3710686266,
-0.2407433242,
0.2783919871,
-0.2089546174,
0.7016597986,
0.8485524058,
-0.5051173568,
-0.4144003987,
-0.0870656222,
-0.3933104873,
-0.0639087185,
0.6744034886,
-1.0922989845,
0.7676941752,
0.4384152591,
0.3302887976,
0.4880877435,
-0.0889965892,
0.5359435678,
-0.5207450986,
0.3572099507,
0.054148674,
0.2470575422,
0.248232767,
-0.0506948121,
0.6877840161,
0.3436199725,
-0.2997048199,
-0.5491397977,
0.321120888,
-1.2894668579,
-0.1909855902,
1.0986349583,
-0.0708988011,
-0.5742221475,
-0.5070678592,
-0.9228948355,
0.0578341149,
-0.0997605994,
0.3429264128,
0.2810145915,
0.0689756721,
-0.3869332969,
-0.3306234777,
0.4441955984,
-0.3320130706,
-1.0895900726,
0.0592309386,
0.8463256359,
0.1282490492,
0.070010379,
0.8191940784,
0.1647887677,
0.5705010891,
0.4464088976,
0.365973562,
-0.3954983354,
-0.6347449422,
0.0477982722,
-0.0149686616,
0.0621794984,
-0.2742915154
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11307v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11307v1 | An Empirical Investigation of Matrix Factorization Methods for Pre-trained Transformers | 2024-06-17T08:14:23 | 2024-06-17T08:14:23 | Ashim Gupta, Sina Mahdipour Saravani, P. Sadayappan, Vivek Srikumar | cs.CL | cs.CL | The increasing size of transformer-based models in NLP makes the question of
compressing them important. In this work, we present a comprehensive analysis
of factorization based model compression techniques. Specifically, we focus on
comparing straightforward low-rank factorization against the recently
introduced Monarch factorization, which exhibits impressive performance
preservation on the GLUE benchmark. To mitigate stability issues associated
with low-rank factorization of the matrices in pre-trained transformers, we
introduce a staged factorization approach wherein layers are factorized one by
one instead of being factorized simultaneously. Through this strategy we
significantly enhance the stability and reliability of the compression process.
Further, we introduce a simple block-wise low-rank factorization method, which
has a close relationship to Monarch factorization. Our experiments lead to the
surprising conclusion that straightforward low-rank factorization consistently
outperforms Monarch factorization across both different compression ratios and
six different text classification tasks. | [
-0.7806764841,
-0.54532516,
0.1508667916,
0.3955614865,
-0.2124977708,
0.226355955,
-0.2191699445,
-0.124251999,
0.2619798481,
0.3327849805,
-0.4568063021,
-0.0564390458,
-0.7020364404,
0.3840777576,
-0.3886747062,
0.7081990838,
0.196180433,
0.2129375041,
-0.3475687504,
0.149801746,
-0.304564476,
-0.9845303297,
-0.5021881461,
-0.4612882137,
0.4922303259,
0.3402580321,
0.8432133794,
0.7031080723,
0.8796647787,
0.4350848496,
-0.1834754944,
0.1678722799,
-0.6718010306,
-0.0323961787,
0.1711166352,
-0.3361459374,
-0.6133370399,
0.4193741083,
0.5980687141,
0.7669085264,
-0.2789672017,
0.4807468951,
0.1979639828,
0.6580002904,
-0.5521857142,
0.153584227,
-0.4845692515,
0.2134026289,
0.1924681664,
-0.7451246381,
-0.875895381,
-0.3064998984,
-0.2019074261,
-0.4069792628,
0.4979043305,
0.3217879236,
0.8491593003,
0.7085855603,
-0.5439612269,
0.1035104021,
-1.0606136322,
0.834851265,
-0.4870650768,
0.4107300341,
0.4031389356,
0.2489067316,
-0.145222187,
-0.6968368888,
-0.596673727,
-0.0694346502,
-0.5796737075,
0.0172653999,
-0.2458133101,
0.1767496616,
0.5359361768,
0.5361836553,
-0.4831721485,
0.3421570659,
-0.3852811754,
-0.1904893368,
0.3535122573,
-0.3065840304,
0.2390456647,
-0.4834715724,
-0.2886473835,
-0.7124877572,
-0.8754399419,
0.3616257608,
0.5193664432,
0.319519639,
0.1780465543,
0.768013835,
-0.0996376574,
0.4735197425,
0.4731041789,
-0.1697297841,
-0.2625596821,
-0.2428006679,
-0.335164398,
0.0493940301,
0.5863243937,
0.1788492501,
0.1902654171,
-0.2917894125,
-0.2394413352,
0.3633493483,
0.662532866,
-1.0864316225,
-0.1503729522,
0.2128660679,
-0.8852649331,
-0.561671555,
0.1584219635,
-0.5611456633,
-0.2260559052,
-0.5689499378,
0.7495671511,
0.0167227332,
0.1473255008,
0.2775346935,
0.1702596843,
0.2635353506,
0.2687516212,
-0.9647267461,
0.3126125932,
1.0028681755,
0.542531848,
-0.1901945919,
0.0642191842,
-0.846573472,
-0.4056707621,
-0.2622781396,
0.8421093225,
-0.3526457548,
-0.2454525828,
0.164117977,
-0.0204961412,
-0.1338079721,
-0.5114638209,
0.6353282332,
-0.4419682622,
0.2416722476,
-0.1770595163,
-0.3001555502,
-0.1416821778,
0.19092682,
-0.7478491068,
0.956099093,
0.0499488562,
-0.662328124,
0.3900205791,
-0.1155689508,
-0.2078532726,
-0.2242768556,
-0.0567796789,
-0.5255694985,
0.4804239869,
0.4344049096,
0.8047443628,
-0.3604137301,
0.1347887218,
-0.2436437458,
-0.5721899271,
0.2247844487,
-0.2359494567,
0.4228480756,
-0.3127295673,
0.0106444666,
0.1710723042,
-0.645894587,
-0.0056261932,
-0.1502864808,
-0.4814454019,
0.2467677742,
0.0724105015,
-0.217154935,
0.5862127542,
0.043153055,
-0.3950331211,
0.6499108076,
-0.2482793778,
0.2492828369,
0.6472940445,
0.0555334799,
0.6219922304,
-0.3309686482,
0.7288298607,
0.0122834723,
0.3431958556,
-0.0985777602,
-0.125515461,
-1.5537586212,
-0.1203570589,
0.6536896825,
0.5200453401,
-1.1532045603,
0.5970216393,
-0.8850141764,
-0.7222535014,
-0.4307448268,
-0.04000099,
0.1400863975,
0.3165699542,
0.6353372931,
-0.1966327876,
-0.5401009917,
-1.1773241758,
0.2142929286,
-0.2744094431,
-0.313162148,
-0.1309688985,
0.4461208284,
-0.0579825677,
0.8605691195,
-0.4998503327,
-0.3524796069,
-0.2185996771,
0.60718292,
0.287337184,
0.9337709546,
0.5361936688,
-0.519459486,
-0.2641523778,
-0.2887406945,
-0.3008075655,
0.2393989712,
-0.146683678,
-0.0447648019,
0.0569302216,
0.5621053576,
-0.6875891089,
0.453458041,
0.8356292844,
-0.1606293917,
0.3829871416,
-0.1921898872,
0.2501069903,
-0.836596489,
-0.0110726049,
0.009712033,
-0.4702955186,
-0.8075641394,
0.0403798409,
-0.0000787165,
-0.4149793088,
-0.321870774,
-0.3035040498,
-0.2998286784,
0.0532154515,
-0.252070725,
-0.3347609937,
-0.2183333635,
0.9127116203,
0.2018618435,
0.6688944101,
0.2044626325,
-0.4263017476,
-0.2451979369,
0.4169878066,
-0.2337037325,
0.1591288447,
-0.8371580243,
0.5192751288,
-0.2685756087,
0.4403334558,
-0.6204856038,
0.2926697433,
-0.1623265445,
-0.3097662926,
0.6987991333,
-0.443415463,
-0.8144564629,
-0.2474812865,
-0.57296592,
0.2635388076,
0.7227594852,
-0.6209867597,
0.8306324482,
0.191638872,
-0.1326388866,
-0.6112439632,
-0.4442476034,
-0.0870090872,
-0.2251414359,
-0.6501581073,
0.4422159493,
-0.3798909783,
0.0753542632,
-0.3706637323,
-0.5856029391,
0.0672558695,
0.1548257172,
0.2938404977,
0.4173209369,
-0.289750725,
-0.205144763,
-0.0192564558,
-0.3926997483,
-0.0050781239,
0.0146742426,
0.6785734296,
0.0137564503,
-0.0624112226,
-0.2769347131,
0.1882369518,
0.2562188506,
-0.1458454281,
0.9531512856,
0.628344059,
-0.2731981874,
-0.3873571754,
-0.6861214042,
-0.5664112568,
-0.5541170835,
-0.0832397342,
-0.0218656864,
-1.1125849485,
0.2085758597,
-0.3194810152,
-0.1166989356,
0.3566799462,
0.2844180763,
-0.1765040159,
1.1883306503,
1.0336214304,
0.1719712019,
0.1663719714,
-0.427911371,
0.6401959658,
-0.4431630969,
0.1912948191,
-0.9726930857,
-0.5141893029,
-0.8640524745,
-0.7736949325,
0.2542459369,
0.4374116659,
-0.0232868101,
0.6404044032,
-0.6322134733,
0.3876902461,
0.3505185544,
-0.130515486,
0.2391427308,
0.0399079174,
0.3029268384,
-0.0451750606,
-0.9031166434,
-0.5105091333,
0.734310925,
0.3654753864,
0.4796221852,
0.339407593,
0.6029182076,
0.2994885147,
0.4987870157,
-0.9517273903,
0.6491088867,
-0.1936835051,
-0.2130487412,
-0.2007494569,
-0.3849540055,
-0.87289536,
0.3763571382,
-0.9252206087,
-0.7304580212,
0.6938570142,
0.1195636615,
-0.3752234578,
-0.0073081143,
-0.5128830671,
0.5822411776,
0.3797866106,
0.0202728547,
-0.1651718467,
-0.326857537,
0.2874127626,
-0.2757515013,
-0.1369991153,
0.2147812992,
0.0386104174,
0.8381859064,
-0.6157761216,
0.5020803213,
0.1712940335,
0.1068126261,
-0.1148114726,
0.2034627348,
0.5570501089,
0.0138050672,
0.117080234,
0.2254071385,
-0.0745263919,
-0.2682030499,
-1.00649333,
0.3910482824,
-0.7043699622,
-0.6623994708,
-0.3771752715,
-0.1154157892,
-0.4197250307,
-0.0303848702,
0.2539260089,
0.7870827317,
0.2369807661,
0.8290804029,
0.5839639902,
-0.159724921,
0.7711285949,
0.5959008932,
-0.2350181043,
-0.4196395874,
0.8691155314,
0.3253198862,
0.0091026751,
0.7141634226,
0.0929164886,
0.0765022412,
-0.6317014694,
0.0371185355,
0.1268235743,
-0.6850780845,
-0.5293242335,
-0.4841718078,
-0.2670134306,
-0.3891947567,
-0.3556659818,
-0.6358097792,
-0.7615559101,
0.1048814952,
-0.1897196323,
-0.3159370124,
0.5197825432,
0.168168366,
0.4240266383,
-0.843110323,
0.3597429097,
0.3909696043,
0.0564940982,
0.034800861,
-0.2371196151,
-0.3675772548,
-0.472297281,
-0.2326480001,
-0.6435756683,
0.3088383377,
0.1029101834,
0.3491710722,
0.5065882206,
0.2808961868,
0.6477085352,
-0.6607140303,
0.737416923,
0.0101900762,
-0.8756355047,
0.2576935291,
-0.1362427473,
0.0428245366,
0.5590112209,
0.5951786041,
-0.2416680455,
-0.1010206267,
-0.7655403018,
-0.8681569695,
0.7260376811,
0.6092050672,
-0.1168090925,
0.2115895897,
0.3161981702,
-0.0132532381,
0.3554971516,
-0.7484557033,
-0.6271059513,
-0.1590656638,
0.1688240767,
-0.5009362102,
-0.5855361819,
0.0220511258,
-0.5896169543,
0.8115403056,
-0.1920807362,
0.4385139644,
0.0170370098,
-0.5323807597,
0.0395824537,
0.2952300012,
0.6661999226,
0.4173825979,
-0.404504329,
0.2388652712,
-0.135755986,
-0.5436082482,
0.3970835507,
0.2702349722,
-0.1991196424,
-0.1953579783,
0.6050286889,
0.7448937297,
0.5954925418,
-0.060930904,
0.5379763246,
-0.3053794205,
-0.0031292385,
-0.0734404698,
-0.0973218232,
-0.1956999302,
-0.1857196689,
0.4862445295,
0.2515065968,
0.0189651139,
-0.277249366,
-0.0564835519,
0.2358546257,
-0.3026720285,
-0.2962785065,
0.3108841777,
0.274215579,
-0.3114279807,
0.610013783,
-0.0611293353,
-0.4879203141,
0.2002771646,
0.2396996319,
0.7778842449,
-0.1572147906,
0.2669321299,
0.5768041611,
0.7174369097,
-0.3077571988,
-0.1341584772,
-0.2681469023,
-0.7246252298,
-0.8745256066,
-0.7214476466,
-0.430591464,
0.0910592377,
-0.7438609004,
0.4800553024,
-0.3568377495,
-0.411077708,
0.0101611931,
0.235601142,
-0.7634257078,
0.0420019552,
0.0691530183,
1.0190526247,
-0.754379034,
0.7436562777,
0.464238584,
-0.3584288657,
-1.0307357311,
-0.0914509371,
-0.202654317,
-0.2184672654,
0.6076430082,
0.3167639673,
-0.0622537956,
0.1673298776,
-0.34539482,
-1.0253582001,
1.0574243069,
0.3798223734,
-0.2511991262,
-0.0293980818,
0.3797608316,
0.616523385,
-0.1272637397,
0.2896356583,
0.5328605771,
0.537807107,
-0.1231104136,
-0.8326534033,
0.0418918617,
-0.4461126924,
-0.0123160537,
0.1412240416,
-0.3144034147,
0.6947219968,
0.6180207133,
-0.3747729659,
-0.1020773128,
0.7805029154,
-0.0617106184,
-0.2434060127,
0.7393484712,
0.4579337239,
0.4119122922,
-0.2938405871,
1.0977739096,
-0.5302530527,
0.553634584,
0.7644376755,
0.1011708528,
1.0287274122,
0.4681383669,
-0.2158208042,
0.4122932255,
0.3306255043,
-0.1831557453,
0.0072802124,
0.1945140213,
0.2614184618,
-0.5165567398,
-0.2190765142,
-0.1057575718,
0.5199635029,
-0.2381324321,
-0.0109557295,
-0.0786214992,
-0.0594430007,
0.02366676,
-0.0518126898,
-0.4002220929,
0.5983176827,
0.0265142825,
-0.8186777234,
0.5972707868,
0.0429149754,
0.882948041,
-0.5495214462,
0.0407678299,
-0.0272174384,
-0.0520349219,
-0.1251189709,
-0.0412208214,
0.0475567318,
-0.2575911283,
-0.3095978796,
-0.8800222278,
1.0016365051,
-0.3093011677,
-0.5460780859,
-0.0617310703,
0.5084161758,
-0.156520471,
-0.1336709112,
-0.1915204674,
0.1293485165,
-0.3308211267,
-0.5588787794,
0.429776758,
-0.2174883187,
0.1112948656,
0.6827290654,
0.8078796268,
-0.0024738554,
-0.1621041745,
-0.0551479273,
0.8517936468,
-0.3845105171,
-0.3667242527,
-0.5637630224,
0.5691335201,
-0.1587553173,
0.0649640113,
0.9240442514,
0.5047092438,
0.4475736618,
-0.3524073958,
-0.1841493696,
0.3405952156,
0.1019851565,
-0.5809704661,
0.8698410988,
-0.2376470268,
0.0396486633,
-0.3057581782,
-1.3166165352,
-0.3126599789,
0.491830945,
-0.0368051492,
0.0307517834,
0.9198256135,
0.8113015294,
-0.0178818852,
-0.0361036249,
0.2600256503,
0.1022913232,
0.3184183836,
-0.0214603227,
0.8020277023,
-0.4405104518,
0.4613592327,
-0.8092092872,
0.1497987658,
-0.1485157609,
-1.3029174805,
-1.0323153734,
-0.6919717789,
-0.5661857724,
-0.2252752483,
-0.6392834187,
1.057677269,
1.1833870411,
-0.5146998167,
-0.003019209,
0.2527802289,
-0.0860389099,
-0.2957240343,
-0.1892439276,
0.5074576139,
-0.0668509379,
-0.7882503271,
0.6582559347,
0.2959547937,
0.0908337012,
-0.4976519644,
0.1724080145,
-0.028805336,
0.4786852896,
0.6984456778,
-0.0743488148,
-0.2114833742,
-0.4093493223,
-0.0290515926,
0.0959859043,
0.0892657116,
1.1724233627,
-1.0408959389,
-0.126947403,
0.7470321059,
0.3294354081,
0.4649425447,
0.4016644359,
0.5702395439,
-0.9439107776,
0.3065976799,
0.1345122159,
0.4633124769,
0.3989147544,
-0.2799442112,
0.6635068655,
-0.0657558963,
-0.6789728999,
-1.070001483,
-0.010377706,
-1.4708378315,
-0.0153546659,
0.8806369305,
0.0479602069,
-0.1899622381,
0.2635900676,
-0.0507587269,
0.1930874288,
-0.1064307839,
0.8222060204,
0.7835314274,
-0.0257973298,
-0.1581304818,
-0.4075596035,
0.8775113821,
0.2993882895,
-0.6933330894,
-0.3514865935,
0.1994561553,
-0.2541593909,
0.6745430231,
0.1740213186,
0.1814302057,
0.0251695681,
-0.1514434814,
0.0690639168,
-0.2143595517,
-0.2552083135,
-0.6137163043,
0.5458874106,
-0.073849611,
0.3425546885
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11303v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11303v1 | VideoVista: A Versatile Benchmark for Video Understanding and Reasoning | 2024-06-17T08:09:00 | 2024-06-17T08:09:00 | Yunxin Li, Xinyu Chen, Baotian Hu, Longyue Wang, Haoyuan Shi, Min Zhang | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | Despite significant breakthroughs in video analysis driven by the rapid
development of large multimodal models (LMMs), there remains a lack of a
versatile evaluation benchmark to comprehensively assess these models'
performance in video understanding and reasoning. To address this, we present
VideoVista, a video QA benchmark that integrates challenges across diverse
content categories, durations, and abilities. Specifically, VideoVista
comprises 25,000 questions derived from 3,400 videos spanning 14 categories
(e.g., Howto, Film, and Entertainment) with durations ranging from a few
seconds to over 10 minutes. Besides, it encompasses 19 types of understanding
tasks (e.g., anomaly detection, interaction understanding) and 8 reasoning
tasks (e.g., logical reasoning, causal reasoning). To achieve this, we present
an automatic data construction framework, leveraging powerful GPT-4o alongside
advanced analysis tools (e.g., video splitting, object segmenting, and
tracking). We also utilize this framework to construct training data to enhance
the capabilities of video-related LMMs (Video-LMMs). Through a comprehensive
and quantitative evaluation of cutting-edge models, we reveal that: 1)
Video-LMMs face difficulties in fine-grained video tasks involving temporal
location, object tracking, and anomaly detection; 2) Video-LMMs present
inferior logical and relation reasoning abilities; 3) Open-source Video-LMMs'
performance is significantly lower than GPT-4o and Gemini-1.5, lagging by 20
points. This highlights the crucial role VideoVista will play in advancing LMMs
that can accurately understand videos and perform precise reasoning. | [
-0.4875843525,
-0.8442133665,
0.7962428927,
0.1313372254,
-0.3100166321,
0.1287917495,
0.1052114964,
-0.0872011855,
-0.1250322908,
0.3192950487,
-0.5887498856,
-0.2822966576,
-0.5679146647,
-0.0177418217,
-0.4281231463,
0.7018978,
-0.4007052481,
-0.000110719,
-0.3918897212,
-0.4334495366,
-0.8439993262,
-0.3357992172,
-0.1274079382,
0.1504082233,
0.2105583251,
0.2871661186,
0.5513516068,
0.6973327398,
0.7716194987,
0.3921357393,
0.2623658478,
0.4993344545,
-0.1476977468,
0.0317053609,
-0.2303169519,
-0.2139143497,
-0.439948082,
-0.2059529275,
0.7574647069,
0.432284683,
0.0248601269,
0.7262795568,
-0.3208949268,
0.5524212718,
-1.0604861975,
0.1279829293,
-0.3947172761,
0.2983541191,
-0.0897681043,
-0.209873572,
0.041384019,
-0.437314719,
0.1346525252,
-0.6806570292,
0.3031407893,
-0.3830011189,
0.7530371547,
0.6462533474,
-0.4426454306,
0.2310572416,
-0.8952457905,
0.3299897015,
-0.1719438285,
0.735321641,
0.3555161953,
0.9128366113,
0.3584297001,
-0.6623699665,
-0.5616602898,
0.1317000538,
0.5368821621,
0.0581015609,
-0.1928551048,
-0.0711688027,
0.4970344305,
0.2175261974,
-0.8587442636,
-0.1557898521,
-0.2978045642,
-0.1252315938,
0.4241960943,
0.5331932306,
0.1335587353,
-0.3367438018,
-0.2362147868,
-0.1580914259,
-0.1946201622,
0.2794264555,
0.2809090912,
-0.2770561874,
0.0307482369,
0.6503084302,
-0.4217984676,
0.486933291,
-0.2706754208,
-0.1669433862,
0.3400277495,
-0.4897175729,
-0.654125154,
-0.3093299866,
0.5786354542,
0.6251796484,
0.0981560573,
0.2076077014,
-0.027991768,
0.5557295084,
0.3657529354,
-0.8197415471,
-0.4067407846,
0.1523866653,
-0.3217806518,
0.1678787172,
0.0990857035,
-0.792558372,
-0.2439625561,
-0.3105084002,
0.891633153,
-0.4027347565,
-0.372934252,
0.1700335741,
-0.2594283223,
0.2613268793,
0.4864242375,
-0.5777423382,
0.5196224451,
0.5135720372,
0.7676098943,
-0.2229971439,
-0.3960153162,
-0.9194688797,
0.1580075771,
-0.4054417312,
0.8919953108,
-0.3147955537,
0.0106031206,
0.0152433477,
0.0833587274,
0.0270816721,
-0.5379784107,
0.193609789,
-0.5237035751,
-0.0349949822,
-0.4541065395,
-0.3650524318,
-0.4619816542,
0.5510727763,
-0.8497871161,
0.8908609748,
0.0149165476,
-0.4872224629,
0.8260691762,
-0.4931881428,
0.0477051623,
-0.0031767376,
-0.3903392255,
-0.4438554645,
-0.108033374,
0.3434714675,
0.3299329281,
-0.4233097136,
0.5419899225,
-0.414884001,
-0.322904706,
0.3327790201,
-0.6737389565,
0.0054670405,
0.2532864809,
-0.3225072622,
0.2441043854,
-0.6225486994,
-0.0011926605,
-0.1627010554,
0.126026839,
0.0034882359,
-0.028575113,
-0.1053020731,
0.2627864182,
-0.0615394786,
-0.2664476931,
0.0033453428,
0.2717718184,
0.4109416306,
0.7325619459,
0.054225713,
-0.0065746279,
0.0312631093,
0.7056336403,
0.1149409041,
0.5975294113,
-0.3274548054,
-0.4428406656,
-0.3389939666,
-0.3525664508,
-0.0340610929,
0.3820178211,
-0.8418552279,
-0.1324965209,
-0.390075922,
-0.2986480296,
-0.5139260292,
0.3456044197,
0.4506751597,
0.4971668422,
0.6072278023,
-0.5748310089,
-0.5963491201,
-0.8233719468,
-0.0557743236,
-0.1978528351,
-0.0267766565,
0.1489397138,
0.6598908305,
-0.0615958534,
0.938598156,
-0.5493245721,
-0.1901795268,
0.0620530173,
0.0462298244,
0.0549434833,
0.0972784832,
0.3435438871,
-1.0257908106,
-0.2828418612,
-0.0000051678,
-1.2402701378,
0.246950835,
-0.0577532835,
0.242861107,
-0.2652712762,
0.3309191763,
-0.6057214737,
0.4661222994,
0.2362229079,
-0.4909157157,
0.7219230533,
-0.225421682,
0.6485050321,
-0.4745482206,
0.0146690812,
0.0313982964,
-0.1884501874,
-0.3556950092,
-0.0906719118,
-0.0356829539,
-0.1079060361,
-0.6520007253,
0.1556337476,
-0.1548608392,
-0.6910456419,
0.0371373519,
0.1304283887,
0.0377498902,
0.5523838997,
0.0916301534,
0.8970938325,
0.455938518,
-0.5951603055,
0.5701391697,
0.199598521,
-0.4958949387,
0.7099057436,
-0.6070711613,
-0.1045476869,
-0.0872366726,
-0.0861148611,
-0.8252642155,
-0.3334334791,
-0.0682603046,
-0.4085040689,
-0.3443344533,
-0.2634626031,
-0.3632684052,
-0.1946855932,
-0.2962993085,
0.83033216,
0.2968209386,
-0.4373339415,
0.6658425331,
0.3557407856,
0.1264297962,
-0.65849334,
-0.3311975002,
0.1911687553,
-0.6013289094,
-0.6500652432,
0.2233303934,
-0.1204101071,
-0.3141352534,
0.2265076041,
-0.33552742,
-0.4965587556,
-0.1921600103,
0.1917979866,
0.1483591795,
-0.1996078044,
0.036604654,
-0.0995235071,
0.0127553865,
0.2465137988,
-0.177923128,
0.1845972389,
-0.3282186091,
-0.4475726783,
-0.3449228704,
0.3381770253,
0.6120300293,
-0.47492823,
0.0091025773,
0.8829393983,
-0.2700251043,
-0.0051787808,
-0.791013062,
0.1679555327,
-0.4579078853,
0.5257195234,
-0.6312262416,
-0.6114181876,
0.4986703396,
0.1502637416,
-0.279702872,
0.2487150878,
0.497046113,
-0.0381547958,
1.046764493,
0.477591157,
0.3200590312,
0.5333527327,
-0.4189746976,
-0.4393982887,
-0.3933317959,
-0.4307712615,
0.0281753018,
0.1392241716,
-0.491330415,
-0.7571612,
0.6115107536,
-0.2123986036,
-0.6471850276,
0.3378079236,
-0.2874857783,
0.5498682857,
0.1830847561,
0.117077738,
0.4511827528,
-0.2440130413,
0.2833980322,
-0.1990207583,
-0.580488205,
-0.4049689174,
1.0779299736,
0.5000519156,
0.5470485091,
0.4850795269,
0.203151226,
0.6124846339,
-0.1062552705,
-0.5876891017,
0.6355666518,
-0.0697686151,
-0.3737513721,
-0.1296725273,
-0.3836833835,
-0.5412942171,
0.249961108,
0.088823013,
-0.4701363444,
0.1148411185,
0.1246109232,
-0.4447322488,
0.3346715271,
-0.7723702192,
1.1898072958,
-0.3685696423,
-0.8336163163,
-0.3744697571,
-0.5548424125,
0.5418718457,
0.011270131,
0.3621335924,
-0.0986227468,
-0.0214483906,
0.7278376222,
-0.4703496993,
0.4261006415,
-0.347560823,
0.2034922987,
0.5950016975,
0.1544739306,
0.0406349488,
0.399030298,
0.5552230477,
-0.1599694639,
0.3651555181,
-0.3200208843,
-0.90377599,
0.1998005956,
-0.6570429802,
-0.4208918214,
-0.3237866759,
-0.2939091623,
-0.2995685637,
0.0418837555,
-0.1425522268,
0.430303067,
-0.1520719379,
0.1829845309,
0.9427593946,
-0.1705871969,
0.3308382332,
0.4132709205,
-0.2170803994,
-0.6798189878,
1.0557154417,
-0.0036392212,
0.1813425571,
0.302736938,
-0.1609244347,
-0.2517962456,
-0.5000761151,
-0.5918323398,
-0.1991468519,
-0.8510868549,
-0.2101556212,
-0.4801384509,
0.0412962623,
-0.0248767585,
0.2855924666,
-0.6936537623,
-0.0400990099,
0.0837860927,
-0.4285291731,
0.3617894351,
0.4491052628,
-0.0145559506,
0.0214043856,
-0.7338795066,
0.7374462485,
0.9358240962,
0.6205607653,
-0.3106053472,
-0.4586851299,
-0.3118365109,
-0.4404099286,
-0.3791939914,
-0.8053041101,
0.1839682609,
-0.0878260583,
0.5150452256,
0.4347762465,
-0.4764094651,
1.0028094053,
-0.4296501279,
0.8717362285,
0.1965990216,
-1.0025641918,
0.6306962967,
-0.4658101201,
0.1631724685,
0.6351380944,
0.3145398796,
-0.1909292936,
0.2612167001,
-0.5307430625,
-0.5497143269,
0.217361331,
0.2768525481,
-0.1646571308,
0.1562039256,
-0.0630011708,
0.2469866574,
0.3073896766,
-0.4051553011,
0.2936218679,
-0.7412041426,
0.1217644662,
-0.0257394761,
0.0396085829,
-0.1099072918,
-0.3775853813,
0.1078323796,
-0.3490355313,
0.2099745721,
0.3218095005,
-0.3677480221,
-0.0310530998,
0.089120172,
0.5002698302,
0.7918524146,
-0.6046010256,
0.0670480356,
0.3376663327,
-0.5487599969,
0.3619485795,
0.0779580921,
0.2160879076,
-0.0380877703,
0.5025437474,
0.9301853776,
0.1510326713,
-1.1185407639,
0.6044970155,
-0.089279905,
-0.3006105721,
-0.4538516402,
0.0197916962,
-0.3800440133,
0.4553220868,
0.267670393,
-0.1200849116,
0.3912746608,
-0.6788442731,
0.4026193321,
0.2476707995,
-0.3475347161,
-0.5038712025,
0.8081034422,
-0.0172038581,
-0.0555071682,
0.4177267849,
-0.1221462339,
-0.2897136211,
0.7715324759,
-0.2439909577,
0.9087255001,
-0.1120365337,
0.5394257307,
0.30835253,
0.3153716028,
-0.2397414893,
0.5400185585,
-0.395210743,
-0.5985267758,
-0.6095414162,
-0.2520549893,
-0.6022101641,
0.0456766523,
-0.8380755782,
0.2378041297,
-0.4407869875,
-0.2924309373,
0.1408533752,
-0.0757475421,
-1.0133187771,
0.482858479,
0.0741762742,
0.8357865214,
-0.9783158898,
0.7551923394,
0.5508453846,
-0.8272420168,
-0.6704057455,
-0.4029382169,
0.017479986,
-0.4262462854,
0.6690413952,
0.2040619701,
-0.1812620014,
-0.4607233405,
-0.226476714,
-0.7249911427,
1.2681981325,
0.3449296653,
-0.3027040362,
-0.1297548413,
0.1237554774,
0.5863215923,
-0.1474722922,
0.5585127473,
0.7388422489,
0.3619865477,
0.0938169286,
-0.9468989968,
-0.1833765805,
-0.3889332414,
-0.1584102213,
0.1609608084,
-0.5253505111,
0.8617026806,
-0.1166938394,
0.2111403346,
-0.1780528873,
0.4499796927,
0.197880283,
0.7300564647,
0.5895147324,
0.417660892,
0.4025509059,
0.112052016,
0.6182682514,
0.3481142521,
0.0695686787,
1.1173228025,
-0.187300548,
0.6027758718,
0.5811501145,
-0.3933331966,
0.4665667117,
0.5710363388,
-0.3627631068,
0.5103333592,
-0.155801475,
-0.1066966653,
-0.671282351,
-0.1124827936,
-0.4611537158,
0.8078893423,
0.3278335035,
-0.0945280492,
-0.0447640605,
0.2336486876,
-0.4716719091,
0.1113872677,
-0.3341231346,
0.8041840792,
-0.2041169107,
-0.6603391171,
0.3416282237,
-0.4394477606,
0.2190741897,
-0.6977235675,
-0.2245242149,
-0.2349906117,
0.1462035924,
-0.2324750274,
-0.8555132151,
0.3501871228,
0.4006955028,
-0.048793342,
0.0080014151,
0.3096959889,
-0.0618342534,
-0.0872221589,
0.1575687826,
0.5935612321,
0.0997731388,
-0.1620821357,
-0.3398077488,
0.3250850439,
-0.3128268421,
-0.1697392464,
0.3656762838,
0.4998593628,
-0.4177043736,
0.8622785807,
0.4272249341,
-0.304477334,
-0.1624285281,
0.0657897443,
0.906265378,
-0.7800781131,
-0.4870340526,
-0.804221034,
0.6075900793,
-0.1070710272,
-0.4127607644,
0.7287122607,
0.6219634414,
0.7932832837,
-0.1265670955,
0.6450301409,
0.1051830575,
0.0581375733,
-0.7017404437,
0.0871041492,
-0.6363468766,
0.2950724363,
-0.7197568417,
-0.8614506125,
-0.0613138974,
0.2122168541,
-0.4393540621,
-0.1514068991,
0.6141048074,
0.4541822076,
-0.2609203458,
0.0520167314,
0.2248282284,
-0.2015822679,
0.5024469495,
0.688359797,
1.0181881189,
-0.4703300893,
0.9806892872,
-0.1842683107,
-0.2219564319,
0.0652108267,
-0.7915958762,
-0.643941164,
-0.6294496059,
-0.481646806,
-0.0147239817,
0.2852763832,
0.7064055204,
0.7944427133,
-0.4358540475,
-0.3264331222,
0.0288834292,
0.0619184002,
-0.6142523289,
-0.1984076947,
0.3539955318,
0.2080858201,
-0.4114820063,
0.4076266289,
0.3501097858,
-0.2771152854,
-0.4506946206,
-0.0384167731,
0.0039729853,
-0.0915024877,
0.7430725694,
0.4768644869,
-0.5316801667,
-0.3051506579,
0.146459505,
0.3175952137,
0.0715627819,
0.9091628194,
-0.9672439098,
0.7878168821,
0.5043863058,
0.6141895056,
1.0363168716,
0.058409676,
0.4644622505,
-0.4281121194,
0.0850869939,
0.1875181794,
0.1979247779,
0.3639104664,
-0.022997316,
0.6799206734,
0.3653445244,
-0.4018501043,
-1.0445036888,
0.2567048073,
-0.9849901795,
-0.2232389003,
0.7503775954,
-0.0892875567,
-0.0636292621,
-0.0815752298,
-0.0724623725,
0.1520379782,
-0.1578442454,
0.7106382847,
0.3815080523,
-0.2506000102,
-0.48347193,
-1.080663085,
0.5174639821,
0.508741498,
-1.0012534857,
-0.0665306374,
0.6038625836,
0.429128021,
-0.1802139729,
0.6204838753,
-0.0552809425,
0.8834612966,
0.164415732,
-0.2150480151,
-0.3429717422,
-0.6926702857,
-0.2782956362,
0.4486492276,
-0.2310142666,
-0.4907043576
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11301v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11301v1 | Optimizing and Testing Instruction-Following: Analyzing the Impact of Fine-Grained Instruction Variants on instruction-tuned LLMs | 2024-06-17T08:08:11 | 2024-06-17T08:08:11 | Jiuding Yang, Weidong Guo, Kaitong Yang, Xiangyang Li, Zhuwei Rao, Yu Xu, Di Niu | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | The effective alignment of Large Language Models (LLMs) with precise
instructions is essential for their application in diverse real-world
scenarios. Current methods focus on enhancing the diversity and complexity of
training and evaluation samples, yet they fall short in accurately assessing
LLMs' ability to follow similar instruction variants. We introduce an effective
data augmentation technique that decomposes complex instructions into simpler
sub-components, modifies these, and reconstructs them into new variants,
thereby preserves the original instruction's context and complexity while
introducing variability, which is critical for training and evaluating LLMs'
instruction-following precision. We developed the DeMoRecon dataset using this
method to both fine-tune and evaluate LLMs. Our findings show that LLMs
fine-tuned with DeMoRecon will gain significant performance boost on both ours
and commonly used instructions-following benchmarks. | [
-0.2835016549,
-0.7766416669,
0.1374371797,
-0.0858886391,
-0.1637322754,
0.0877482891,
-0.4660558403,
-0.3510484099,
-0.1962009668,
0.5910698175,
-0.7463867664,
-0.6119781137,
-0.4722058475,
0.0986696854,
-0.230629921,
0.7123804688,
-0.2610374689,
0.1748802811,
-0.2323251665,
-0.07311216,
-0.3683549464,
-0.2475862652,
-0.26103127,
-0.3378486335,
0.2348998785,
0.8153498173,
0.6951003075,
1.0194330215,
0.5682287216,
0.3103865683,
-0.0207593981,
0.6373612881,
-0.6183040142,
-0.0118816076,
-0.0011216586,
-0.5953981876,
-0.5084312558,
-0.1032342389,
0.5225206614,
0.8941250443,
-0.2742170691,
0.1788741201,
0.2444411516,
0.64282161,
-0.817504108,
0.0802091211,
-0.4717110395,
-0.2244423032,
0.0996807665,
-0.3768087626,
-0.4239482284,
-0.8444824219,
-0.0332594216,
-0.4206742942,
0.4053724408,
-0.0760566369,
0.5459524393,
0.2634075582,
-0.2257733345,
-0.2893069386,
-0.7707819939,
0.6977778673,
-0.7863098383,
0.6905748248,
0.2909951806,
0.1700063348,
-0.3656737804,
-0.6435241699,
-0.2460030764,
-0.2701654434,
0.1525494158,
0.121855706,
-0.0117407069,
0.2661955953,
0.3348236382,
0.5236319304,
-0.4174343944,
0.4037518799,
-0.4531336427,
0.0282294042,
0.5195586085,
0.3957058787,
0.2383575439,
0.3270995617,
-0.1013372615,
-0.325494498,
-0.7572365403,
0.0742397085,
0.7375715971,
0.3937690556,
0.0043556108,
0.6561762094,
-0.4354062676,
1.1713590622,
0.1715229899,
-0.1411283165,
0.3109945655,
-0.410284251,
-0.1934312731,
-0.0340383574,
0.3546510339,
0.5157295465,
0.2682928145,
-0.0953852311,
-0.2753634453,
-0.1959244013,
0.2662577033,
-0.9982386231,
-0.3050221801,
-0.0017400453,
-0.2800426185,
-0.1625570059,
0.285726279,
-0.650108099,
-0.146738708,
-0.7715059519,
0.2136358321,
-0.5891245008,
0.2447430044,
0.4251521826,
-0.0141408239,
0.4016184509,
0.3584474027,
-1.2932873964,
0.3463298678,
1.0342818499,
0.4565773904,
-0.3157201409,
-0.2044057101,
-0.5703163147,
0.0711123273,
-0.6025626063,
0.7000263333,
-0.9983361959,
-0.3284805119,
0.1441944987,
0.1319259554,
0.0447562002,
-0.8120202422,
0.4825499952,
-0.4527732134,
0.0648688525,
-0.1224671155,
-0.9711720943,
-0.0792996138,
0.2465164065,
-0.6600930095,
0.9935108423,
0.3836281598,
-0.3537755311,
0.1471356302,
-0.1929582059,
-0.5129722953,
-0.1983414888,
-0.2992205322,
-0.1726017445,
0.3717963099,
0.2128412575,
0.2992466688,
-0.0677146614,
-0.3754020929,
-0.2285480052,
-0.7722327113,
0.106615141,
-0.6633434296,
0.5082939267,
-0.1540801525,
-0.2888940871,
-0.0556045175,
-0.8698619604,
0.3128604293,
-0.3196869791,
-0.5109316111,
-0.2426267415,
0.1263705343,
-0.4252810776,
-0.3167713284,
0.4204622209,
-0.3605397642,
0.4506776631,
-0.4938791692,
0.0410936065,
0.8187653422,
-0.0472228862,
0.5452116132,
-0.3635683656,
0.6311404705,
-0.3423162699,
0.3989367783,
-0.2836857438,
-0.0684493855,
-0.7564647794,
-0.1118585542,
0.3339728415,
0.6507288814,
-0.3638927639,
0.4767428339,
-0.232662186,
-0.5684750676,
-0.6717574596,
0.3767779171,
0.2898248434,
0.4059840739,
0.3235535622,
-0.2338942736,
-0.5886052251,
-0.8698441386,
-0.1691828817,
0.1701071858,
0.0753041133,
0.0945740789,
0.0252733566,
-0.3679307699,
0.4913635254,
-0.6052318215,
0.2500005364,
-0.154075101,
-0.1233629808,
0.1735276133,
0.5110533834,
0.1093792319,
-0.4848994017,
-0.4471083581,
0.2221702039,
-0.2224998921,
-0.2517013252,
0.1233805642,
0.0553595088,
0.0669736639,
0.7191197276,
-0.1568120271,
0.3452621698,
0.7467130423,
0.18916291,
0.6096497178,
-0.2144101411,
0.5393403172,
-0.7868462801,
-0.3127713799,
-0.2747446001,
-0.1685633063,
-0.4821074307,
0.132545799,
0.3781191707,
0.2486259937,
-0.3520931304,
0.1341546625,
-0.6267097592,
0.0244613718,
-0.4126116335,
-0.0455501042,
0.0018222154,
0.2210708857,
-0.2999193668,
1.1353616714,
0.3734312952,
-0.4987972081,
0.4139449894,
-0.0243633706,
-0.5779752731,
0.2390953898,
-0.6125946641,
0.1949037015,
-0.1271756291,
-0.0363621153,
-1.0254740715,
-0.2321040928,
0.0236463081,
-0.00337774,
0.514351666,
-0.2925581932,
-0.558455348,
0.0029758096,
-0.4020838141,
0.2681206167,
0.7662932873,
-0.5192180276,
0.6311686039,
-0.0941246599,
0.0633753613,
-0.5674238205,
-0.4737026989,
-0.3536178172,
0.0349374041,
-0.3286099732,
0.4549341202,
-0.1733855009,
-0.1604072303,
-0.2794631422,
-0.4807011187,
0.1400089413,
0.071256347,
0.2794105411,
0.3257963955,
-0.2181887329,
-0.1679837257,
0.2056311965,
0.0471823961,
-0.1528209597,
-0.0379914641,
0.6805158854,
0.1011212841,
-0.5860690475,
-0.7434731126,
0.1179376468,
0.3201605976,
-0.0615757331,
0.3770827949,
0.3338849247,
-0.1564356685,
-0.4618964493,
-0.5062036514,
-0.3187386394,
-0.5740571022,
0.5699212551,
-0.1862814724,
-0.7179110646,
0.2033686042,
-0.3992442489,
0.3154467344,
-0.0323779881,
0.3370818198,
-0.3357596397,
0.9350551963,
0.6687307954,
0.0219616219,
0.7418762445,
-0.2678494751,
-0.0540220253,
-0.8281006217,
-0.16207923,
-0.4873925149,
-0.4143927395,
-0.636030376,
-0.5918018818,
-0.0473269485,
0.2610022128,
-0.0369993784,
0.4700219333,
-0.3950914145,
0.9338482022,
0.4119594097,
0.3188578784,
0.293274343,
0.0991193578,
0.1568854749,
-0.0878421664,
-0.5389384627,
-0.7136888504,
1.0541682243,
0.1663089544,
1.3471565247,
-0.0193814859,
0.6825069785,
0.0770396814,
0.2256006449,
-0.7097643018,
0.5142613053,
-0.6871852875,
-0.1345057189,
0.0290679988,
-0.363859117,
-0.81274575,
-0.1092140973,
0.0027233486,
-0.7174959183,
-0.0336134136,
0.2461544275,
-0.3590114415,
0.0780271366,
-0.9424216151,
0.6148922443,
-0.259216398,
0.00083154,
-0.1448632479,
-0.3668842912,
0.2072367519,
0.1251475811,
-0.1745477617,
0.0294986032,
-0.3364272118,
0.4547662735,
-0.2557148337,
0.9784972072,
0.2923744917,
-0.3044985235,
0.0574615784,
0.1049802154,
0.634575665,
-0.2016169429,
-0.0875123888,
-0.174246639,
-0.0854799673,
-0.3064011037,
-1.0567388535,
0.7503371239,
-0.8286790252,
-0.7639173865,
0.1541453153,
-0.6701923013,
-0.4359358251,
-0.032657735,
0.1645743698,
0.6939393878,
-0.1453939229,
0.2490175217,
1.0436446667,
0.0071015242,
0.1135899201,
0.4848995805,
-0.0208754186,
-0.4705618024,
0.6833052635,
0.0629268512,
0.6092785001,
0.5863892436,
-0.0106085707,
-0.1832184345,
-0.7918605804,
-0.3911397755,
-0.0592036508,
-0.6621257663,
-0.1620047837,
-0.1593665481,
-0.1701410413,
-0.3350827694,
-0.1553528756,
-0.5224840641,
-0.3161891997,
-0.5242424607,
-0.175898388,
0.1797196567,
0.5684520006,
0.0745400116,
0.5786982775,
-0.9276527762,
0.1720038652,
0.3062102497,
0.4144240022,
-0.2196393013,
-0.718988955,
-0.245802775,
0.3470469117,
-0.3218842745,
-0.8477714062,
-0.1805109382,
0.1944452673,
0.6377117038,
0.340546906,
-0.1370403022,
0.9699412584,
-0.7152127028,
0.5236032009,
-0.0331266858,
-0.7478118539,
0.5538668633,
0.0223612953,
0.3366045654,
0.82126683,
0.3093511164,
-0.1364801228,
-0.308024615,
-0.5250540376,
-0.6501550078,
0.615154326,
0.0226311758,
0.3804271221,
0.2110356539,
0.6609911323,
0.3378581703,
-0.0427146628,
0.0519659519,
-0.4410999417,
0.3300322294,
-0.5834544897,
-0.1218938082,
-0.1814890653,
-0.346409142,
-0.2185581326,
0.6005162001,
0.0000033218,
-0.1045376956,
-0.1113855168,
0.0141425654,
-0.0964479297,
0.1496511996,
0.8146440983,
0.8491529226,
-0.3003126383,
0.0827744007,
0.3485346138,
-0.5583811402,
0.1672255695,
0.2354699373,
-0.1862809658,
0.0384530127,
0.4802415371,
0.8238697052,
0.2216748148,
-0.8227481246,
0.2734167278,
-0.0488118269,
-0.023116013,
-0.0785869211,
0.770968914,
0.0555093139,
0.3321481645,
0.2331547141,
-0.0310841743,
0.0719661489,
-0.466809392,
0.5197353363,
0.2997710705,
-0.3511780798,
-0.2920796871,
0.079190731,
0.0694821551,
-0.4863206148,
0.4869275391,
0.0235323906,
-0.3353147805,
0.6737180352,
0.5645719171,
0.4701799154,
-0.3871543407,
0.0358536951,
0.2657203972,
0.4454197586,
-0.2420229614,
0.4001086652,
0.0305948444,
-0.58718431,
-0.5440323949,
-0.2541333437,
-0.5029609799,
-0.0388461612,
-0.9636226892,
0.4232996106,
-0.4600188732,
0.0839374512,
-0.081763044,
-0.0161849875,
-0.5683338046,
0.1274467558,
0.025912296,
1.1877461672,
-0.7235153913,
0.6670101285,
0.5827357173,
-0.0687633976,
-0.9974660277,
0.1144019142,
-0.1778215617,
-0.9525529146,
0.405484885,
0.2720063925,
-0.0829271898,
-0.0496518612,
-0.6222926378,
-0.7026305199,
1.0927306414,
0.6044757366,
-1.05554986,
0.208096236,
0.2348699272,
0.4266680181,
-0.251750201,
0.3320276141,
0.8667002916,
0.1875851005,
0.1548909545,
-0.6021991372,
-0.1029410586,
0.1508607417,
-0.036189165,
0.4920557141,
-0.5841563344,
0.5324687958,
-0.1222351417,
-0.0656775907,
0.0563549884,
0.6357296705,
0.2122277021,
-0.015510967,
0.4061324596,
0.7092077732,
0.741202116,
0.0212948285,
0.8395651579,
-0.2595193982,
0.2251786441,
1.5984381437,
-0.1460209787,
0.9219677448,
0.498765856,
-0.190737173,
0.6139878035,
0.6541631222,
-0.1321272254,
0.5066055655,
0.3360462189,
-0.1902178824,
-0.2410602123,
0.0554849803,
-0.3024359345,
0.3737768531,
0.2541230917,
-0.3734020293,
-0.3254652619,
-0.1916687638,
-0.0714573935,
0.1703941375,
-0.2104467154,
0.8309309483,
-0.1861389279,
-0.6214097142,
0.7246094346,
-0.0327040814,
0.4303451478,
-0.5503690243,
-0.3607240617,
-0.4735762477,
0.2215934545,
-0.2449054122,
-0.7963110209,
0.0880171359,
0.0015848465,
-0.1307196468,
0.025839841,
0.4086938798,
-0.5766139627,
-0.4164841771,
0.0716245696,
0.2454867363,
-0.0219588298,
0.3273433149,
-0.6315771341,
0.4873662889,
0.3433266878,
-0.1805848479,
0.2698225379,
0.46549806,
0.1410754323,
0.5804194808,
0.4917846322,
0.0896545872,
0.2213013619,
0.2584688067,
0.952909112,
-0.4604496062,
-0.0011819785,
-1.0257947445,
0.4589677453,
-0.0693695396,
-0.3200718462,
0.6829935908,
0.8029530048,
1.0071140528,
0.0449877195,
0.5547201037,
0.1720750779,
0.1916894168,
-0.7013801932,
0.1320637017,
-0.3451358974,
0.4317283928,
0.0756368265,
-0.9744535089,
-0.0484271273,
0.2967223823,
-0.1050099581,
0.050231114,
0.4538449645,
1.1905757189,
-0.3369482756,
0.1327119917,
0.2237287611,
-0.1190772578,
0.0417948663,
0.4620118439,
0.9283793569,
-0.6414520144,
0.5852780342,
-0.5234861374,
-0.4147161841,
-0.1227466911,
-0.6452059746,
-0.8912117481,
-0.2886913717,
-0.4403601587,
-0.198689431,
0.213018775,
0.9722656012,
0.657069087,
-0.820065856,
-0.27619645,
-0.2004744858,
0.0518061742,
-0.3485653996,
-0.1735641509,
0.3410168886,
-0.5061073899,
-0.9635967016,
0.4369549751,
0.1110613346,
0.3063068986,
-0.099182643,
-0.0901623219,
0.0473700054,
0.0672337711,
0.3389807642,
0.0459016487,
-0.5897238851,
-0.310261935,
0.3068034351,
-0.2676363587,
0.0022693202,
0.8078355789,
-0.3130941391,
0.5130879283,
0.5930627584,
0.9823815823,
0.1918039322,
0.4328405559,
0.6797679067,
-0.7494377494,
-0.1964630783,
0.2363259643,
0.2096562982,
0.3122927845,
-0.2472654879,
0.518019855,
-0.1443519592,
-0.5072261095,
-0.7578666806,
0.1788053364,
-1.0134125948,
-0.276157558,
1.3207725286,
-0.1627037823,
-0.1720556319,
0.1927944273,
-0.3092103004,
0.2338643223,
-0.2792743146,
0.6797690392,
0.58656919,
-0.2732399404,
-0.2263889611,
-0.5560896993,
0.3859299123,
0.3531089425,
-0.798987329,
0.2293742597,
0.4871601462,
0.4204524755,
-0.0894650146,
0.0848752856,
-0.0867712796,
0.3089496791,
-0.2071776837,
0.0150210941,
-0.1748933792,
-0.1567298025,
-0.3704153895,
-0.0878813937,
0.0054673473,
-0.5921367407
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11924v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11924v1 | Explainable assessment of financial experts' credibility by classifying social media forecasts and checking the predictions with actual market data | 2024-06-17T08:08:03 | 2024-06-17T08:08:03 | Silvia García-Méndez, Francisco de Arriba-Pérez, Jaime González-Gonzáleza, Francisco J. González-Castaño | cs.SI | cs.SI, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Social media include diverse interaction metrics related to user popularity,
the most evident example being the number of user followers. The latter has
raised concerns about the credibility of the posts by the most popular
creators. However, most existing approaches to assess credibility in social
media strictly consider this problem a binary classification, often based on a
priori information, without checking if actual real-world facts back the users'
comments. In addition, they do not provide automatic explanations of their
predictions to foster their trustworthiness. In this work, we propose a
credibility assessment solution for financial creators in social media that
combines Natural Language Processing and Machine Learning. The reputation of
the contributors is assessed by automatically classifying their forecasts on
asset values by type and verifying these predictions with actual market data to
approximate their probability of success. The outcome of this verification is a
continuous credibility score instead of a binary result, an entirely novel
contribution by this work. Moreover, social media metrics (i.e., user context)
are exploited by calculating their correlation with the credibility rankings,
providing insights on the interest of the end-users in financial posts and
their forecasts (i.e., drop or rise). Finally, the system provides natural
language explanations of its decisions based on a model-agnostic analysis of
relevant features. | [
-0.3413769603,
-0.9265115261,
0.4930124283,
0.5305688381,
-0.3016545177,
0.5472733378,
-0.1823462248,
-0.6617336869,
0.2752859294,
0.3433044553,
-0.3401076794,
-0.6393294334,
-0.8447538614,
-0.1295553893,
-0.6252467036,
0.9460728765,
0.1024823338,
-0.0759941265,
-0.2567360997,
-0.0584293529,
-0.2107208073,
-0.2522447705,
-0.9737280607,
-0.1907507479,
0.3468768001,
0.1964512169,
1.0379828215,
0.4951850176,
0.6353039742,
0.4227970541,
-0.1124074832,
0.2064607143,
-0.3004824817,
-0.2112768143,
-0.3416808844,
0.0366356932,
-0.4361101687,
0.1980196685,
0.36924842,
0.4735563993,
-0.0596880354,
0.5606840849,
0.196141094,
0.3945762217,
-0.5164865255,
0.4020120502,
-0.612698555,
-0.2975078821,
0.0838708356,
-0.4254796803,
-0.3686853051,
-0.7761173844,
0.3975566328,
-0.478289783,
0.1202656254,
0.1211026311,
1.0589963198,
0.0296793748,
-0.4593348503,
-0.3749867976,
-1.0133157969,
0.5508440733,
-0.4456579685,
0.2625234425,
0.546400547,
0.8090770245,
0.0433555692,
-0.5126182437,
-0.4492175877,
-0.0367552154,
-0.1764652729,
0.092611894,
-0.3280794322,
-0.2121005952,
-0.0153888771,
0.2536194026,
-0.3285602331,
-0.0090881577,
-0.348203361,
-0.4079646766,
0.8172943592,
-0.3998096287,
-0.1178141981,
-0.1725650281,
-0.5841371417,
-0.1147672832,
-0.3577503264,
0.2685928643,
0.5747042894,
0.1764288247,
-0.057336852,
0.3072257638,
-0.1388045251,
0.4430970252,
0.2590852976,
-0.4136833251,
0.0135510871,
-0.1712372899,
-0.1107240245,
0.3265968561,
0.7333760858,
0.6319534779,
0.3776602745,
-0.0792645738,
-0.2130366713,
0.1317561716,
0.2400771677,
-0.6065011621,
-0.1395770609,
0.2436036468,
-0.5247273445,
-0.6203600168,
0.4150454104,
-0.7280113101,
-0.3496615887,
-0.1915871203,
0.7140830159,
-0.3079980016,
-0.2459546626,
-0.0644184574,
-0.1914632469,
-0.1598888785,
0.2052972466,
-0.5677071214,
0.423573494,
0.8089929223,
0.69246912,
0.2332755178,
-0.0233095214,
-0.797419548,
0.1321529299,
-0.2999565899,
1.0643663406,
-0.2741144598,
-0.0147282192,
0.1939802468,
-0.1740420461,
0.2641336918,
-0.0795460567,
0.5306870937,
-0.9052293897,
0.0616304204,
-0.2311764508,
-0.7996855974,
-0.2995711267,
0.1868221462,
-0.5743145943,
0.8353549242,
0.1310576648,
-0.8187805414,
0.8251696229,
-0.7005273104,
-0.3595315814,
0.3694723547,
0.209680751,
-0.3581555784,
-0.2122716457,
0.3597660959,
0.7315094471,
-0.1056567878,
0.5042675734,
-0.7039838433,
-0.1876804829,
0.8271893263,
-0.569185853,
0.4970622957,
0.1946952343,
-0.3216878176,
-0.0785343423,
-0.9092895389,
0.0568243302,
-0.0549794771,
-0.017550189,
-0.5320455432,
0.2121683508,
0.1611199826,
0.0880250558,
0.3672617078,
-0.5639642477,
-0.259375453,
-0.4481457472,
0.5032604933,
0.9234057665,
0.3370709717,
0.3730389476,
-0.4076116383,
0.2506454289,
-0.1228094995,
0.2458437681,
0.0951648206,
-0.5095251799,
-0.3165774345,
-0.1033911109,
0.5587304831,
0.4308701456,
-0.3276190758,
0.6596121192,
-0.3918546736,
-0.7832017541,
-0.4854179025,
0.3779346943,
0.0740116686,
0.7532343268,
0.2465043813,
-0.0673550367,
-0.4058238864,
-0.8480541706,
-0.6414287686,
-0.4750205576,
-0.2143989652,
0.1855044067,
0.2116190195,
-0.268428117,
1.2060506344,
-0.4559577703,
-0.0126538808,
0.0399122201,
0.374011904,
0.2017957568,
0.2484808266,
0.6293526292,
-1.0596438646,
-0.4788187742,
0.1899190545,
-0.4888694882,
0.092526108,
-0.3797264099,
0.0290864613,
0.0373225175,
0.1969230771,
-0.3789024651,
0.5322076678,
0.5190929174,
-0.5541681051,
0.4504991174,
-0.1537681669,
0.3037099242,
-0.904343009,
0.0273832772,
0.5240550637,
-0.549933672,
-0.4152648747,
-0.3906573951,
-0.0969896466,
0.286980778,
0.0187389329,
0.8165969849,
0.0697385967,
-0.3476807475,
-0.1957370043,
0.2551688552,
-0.0949279889,
0.1150472835,
-0.204375878,
0.1141411662,
0.622366488,
-0.5900504589,
0.3036853075,
0.0785332397,
-0.4791334271,
0.5535610318,
-0.7763821483,
-0.0145607879,
0.1879321486,
0.2225509137,
-1.3738433123,
-0.3233821094,
0.3185073733,
-0.9383049607,
-0.1548407525,
-0.2325457036,
-0.6348468661,
-0.3847112656,
0.0156567842,
-0.1262632161,
0.4711218774,
-0.5778983831,
0.6871997118,
0.2780154943,
-0.3387415707,
-0.5745562315,
-0.4399340749,
0.1507415473,
-0.299110055,
-0.8766687512,
0.4348367751,
-0.1204930097,
-0.7041286826,
0.2817638516,
-0.1728376001,
-0.249586314,
0.3622092605,
0.3520225585,
0.63583076,
0.0150526427,
0.0109430235,
0.2085774541,
-0.2645522952,
0.2875606716,
-0.2859028876,
0.0972361863,
-0.4444955289,
-0.1368619502,
-0.6320087314,
-0.1303214729,
0.4773881733,
0.0196447168,
0.9696125984,
0.8253566027,
-0.5527158976,
-0.0317141823,
-0.9198955297,
-0.1430397928,
-0.5898034573,
-0.2184089422,
0.050333567,
-0.8592071533,
0.8528339863,
0.1458609253,
0.3413755298,
0.858086884,
0.6696676612,
-0.1545156837,
1.043636322,
0.5362745523,
0.0879444554,
0.1726174355,
0.062464729,
0.4455980361,
0.2819042206,
-0.1336686164,
-0.3600823581,
-0.3463690281,
-0.610594511,
-0.1181726903,
-0.0784348026,
0.0861202031,
-0.0537646227,
0.6229237318,
-0.3876734972,
0.4857593477,
0.4354260266,
-0.0023932562,
0.4414683878,
0.0632788464,
0.1247769669,
0.0658361539,
-0.2473629415,
-0.7994598746,
0.9129596949,
0.6952587962,
0.5624343753,
-0.0430509858,
0.5511046052,
0.878010273,
0.8731544018,
-0.7134907842,
0.3076867759,
0.0138759334,
-0.5850300789,
-0.3430764079,
-0.7780439258,
-0.4248974025,
-0.3457894921,
-0.4324721396,
-0.4499035776,
0.1101238802,
0.2610245645,
-0.6671743393,
0.1269500852,
-0.5781274438,
0.6863057613,
-0.4044881165,
-0.1953154206,
-0.3125088811,
-0.6189681292,
0.3531163931,
-0.2790224254,
0.7105683684,
-0.0866578296,
-0.0060473867,
0.8862650394,
-0.4453091919,
0.7173671126,
-0.2560516298,
0.0280824695,
0.4633947611,
0.0796674192,
0.3832930624,
0.4449859262,
-0.1502661854,
0.2318921834,
0.1995889693,
-0.4195672572,
-0.7717038393,
0.6918691993,
-0.6775180101,
0.0232370663,
-0.2626562715,
-0.0511149094,
-0.335613966,
0.1814871877,
0.0403655395,
0.1607480347,
-0.4262594581,
0.203961283,
0.1520064026,
0.21342282,
0.3049156368,
0.5961332321,
-0.0633076429,
-0.7324959636,
0.9158965349,
0.1763317138,
0.0066733286,
0.1377831846,
0.6053336859,
-0.5860109925,
-0.536202848,
-0.1978299022,
0.0319504887,
-0.7049791217,
-0.1040976197,
-0.3699018061,
-0.2562276125,
-0.6327566504,
-0.4823865592,
-0.3631181419,
-0.5004606247,
-0.0802565143,
-0.5539609194,
0.5228281021,
0.7548402548,
-0.2105998844,
0.4093862474,
-0.9277533293,
0.2371995002,
0.4296046495,
0.6207883358,
0.0499515124,
-0.4866789281,
-0.4335845113,
0.1647024006,
-0.0757800937,
-0.7667042613,
0.4179742634,
0.0536815003,
0.4457582235,
1.0930216312,
0.1299312711,
0.5919132829,
0.0364391953,
0.4181682169,
0.2694271803,
-0.9152046442,
0.4845708609,
-0.2503509521,
-0.4744362235,
0.7191545963,
0.6804227829,
-0.4646554291,
-0.526661396,
-0.9958205819,
-0.6485490203,
0.1674035341,
0.2939384282,
-0.0685291216,
-0.1426574737,
0.5513851047,
0.227949664,
0.2448337078,
-0.6404700279,
-0.1522661,
-0.4823698699,
-0.0509806089,
-0.1034627184,
-0.3173668385,
-0.0416155085,
-0.1093846411,
0.6730433106,
-0.1188101694,
-0.1496548653,
0.120085977,
0.0850579292,
-0.3209908307,
-0.0075042555,
0.2732695043,
1.1118336916,
-0.4626525044,
0.0855656937,
-0.0948987454,
-0.0327214375,
-0.0967372954,
0.2742662728,
-0.1260908395,
0.2484929413,
0.3391419351,
0.3434587121,
0.5630278587,
-0.5526595116,
0.5396194458,
-0.2463788241,
-0.3780416548,
-0.8530552983,
-0.2956376672,
0.2541826665,
0.1597812027,
0.6903055906,
0.697995007,
0.0353852846,
-0.4110028148,
0.4875775278,
0.1584635377,
-0.6922148466,
-0.4982780814,
0.6743830442,
0.2870770991,
-0.4311830401,
0.4049139321,
-0.1272726357,
-0.4715918601,
0.4830066562,
0.0969155803,
1.0056139231,
-0.2298702598,
0.5366719365,
0.4982575178,
0.16930525,
-0.3656000495,
0.0241751354,
-0.0000808173,
-0.933585465,
-0.4960379303,
-0.925344646,
-0.5246955156,
-0.0691551417,
-0.716006279,
0.3880943656,
-0.9037487507,
-0.5330644846,
0.5475735068,
0.0742309615,
-0.5997382402,
0.1747831553,
0.0975581557,
0.912825942,
-0.9718976617,
0.3242030144,
0.4573254883,
-0.2267292291,
-0.6096392274,
-0.0897034705,
0.1032970548,
-0.6889027357,
0.5283418298,
0.2647167444,
-0.175974533,
-0.1636719108,
-0.6294192076,
-0.5022986531,
0.8445829749,
0.1856035292,
-0.2404459268,
0.023902623,
-0.0775676444,
0.6797258854,
-0.4430461824,
0.0262706596,
0.2820313573,
0.6979805231,
0.4300554693,
-0.6486731172,
-0.1479942203,
-0.3214055598,
-0.3598111272,
-0.0984162241,
-0.3373018503,
0.3303511739,
-0.1040486917,
-0.2426991016,
-0.1549836248,
0.9567992091,
0.1028929204,
0.8687856793,
0.8244785666,
0.2453728318,
0.7991428375,
-0.0136137567,
0.9809719324,
-0.6643481255,
0.5739097595,
0.8104196191,
0.0479170009,
1.1193273067,
0.0544415414,
-0.0992168859,
0.8219792247,
0.9032069445,
-0.3717683554,
0.1069083512,
-0.1716260463,
-0.1154419258,
-0.6103163958,
-0.0216886252,
-0.0052794982,
0.4741211534,
0.4342447519,
-0.5744918585,
0.0380990095,
-0.3040721416,
0.0643337816,
0.3004029691,
-0.2760899961,
0.5694820285,
0.1280334294,
-0.567812264,
0.0056332629,
0.1896157116,
0.5420982838,
-0.6445605159,
0.1741087586,
0.1566832513,
0.2951773405,
-0.2474576831,
-0.8999931812,
0.5212033391,
-0.0200287029,
-0.0156262964,
-0.5916042328,
0.9543312192,
-0.2127048373,
-0.7931496501,
0.3486078382,
0.4962236881,
-0.0276900791,
-0.3717340827,
-0.6707108617,
-0.4703171849,
-0.3194237053,
-0.172996223,
0.1372683048,
0.1792152226,
0.1526724994,
0.9176850319,
1.0801991224,
-0.1236759126,
-0.4120185673,
-0.0927140415,
0.5403475165,
-0.4998204112,
-0.826646924,
-1.0727375746,
0.2202557623,
-0.4012099206,
-0.0436267592,
1.0959433317,
0.4451986849,
0.4331142902,
0.2211011946,
0.6806256175,
0.1800498366,
0.8118717074,
-0.0536299795,
1.0621631145,
-0.3883532286,
0.3470582962,
-0.5206639171,
-0.7379183769,
-0.1858616769,
0.4536368847,
-0.5750079751,
-0.0529160351,
0.2257255465,
0.4750986695,
0.0309588965,
0.1893952638,
-0.0067093465,
0.3319061995,
0.1373204887,
-0.1832397729,
0.5860379934,
-0.2018243819,
0.8646097779,
-0.6085918546,
-0.3750786781,
-0.3970688283,
-1.0098141432,
-0.9925075769,
-0.4192898273,
-0.5754651427,
-0.6728406549,
-0.2480932325,
0.76530689,
0.5238581896,
-0.8324906826,
-0.0440447219,
0.2765482068,
0.3662027717,
-0.5138429999,
-0.3506045341,
0.387151897,
0.1738380641,
-0.2472784072,
0.1831180155,
0.4205791056,
0.1484817564,
-0.518140614,
0.0303680878,
0.193840459,
0.3107826114,
0.5947277546,
0.1881467998,
-0.6360920072,
-0.4681311548,
0.1406202912,
0.0515769944,
-0.2664008439,
0.429851681,
-0.6691896915,
0.2979291975,
0.5143198967,
0.5439258218,
0.2153578401,
0.5709838271,
0.5522869825,
-0.3692955375,
-0.4836970866,
0.1086752638,
0.1234126091,
0.2722314,
-0.5905811787,
0.1775515974,
0.3319627345,
-0.5612440109,
-0.6492148042,
-0.2355780303,
-1.1140283346,
-0.0563528612,
0.8347868919,
-0.2042040378,
-0.264639765,
-0.2898768485,
0.2087082863,
-0.0401465446,
-0.6663956642,
1.2287000418,
0.9052790999,
0.3263686299,
0.1456662118,
-0.5576090813,
0.498606652,
-0.1308084428,
-0.3835009634,
0.0324227884,
0.2148652822,
0.4496347308,
0.4409637153,
0.5563191175,
0.0509371459,
0.502690196,
-0.1275200844,
-0.3851437867,
-0.0716374367,
-0.1130589321,
0.1667359024,
0.3423187435,
-0.0614083782,
0.2360548526
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11290v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11290v1 | Iterative Utility Judgment Framework via LLMs Inspired by Relevance in Philosophy | 2024-06-17T07:52:42 | 2024-06-17T07:52:42 | Hengran Zhang, Keping Bi, Jiafeng Guo, Xueqi Cheng | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Utility and topical relevance are critical measures in information retrieval
(IR), reflecting system and user perspectives, respectively. While topical
relevance has long been emphasized, utility is a higher standard of relevance
and is more useful for facilitating downstream tasks, e.g., in
Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG). When we incorporate utility judgments
into RAG, we realize that the topical relevance, utility, and answering in RAG
are closely related to the three types of relevance that Schutz discussed from
a philosophical perspective. They are topical relevance, interpretational
relevance, and motivational relevance, respectively. Inspired by the dynamic
iterations of the three types of relevance, we propose an Iterative utiliTy
judgmEnt fraMework (ITEM) to promote each step of the cycle of RAG. We
conducted extensive experiments on multi-grade passage retrieval and factoid
question-answering datasets (i.e., TREC DL, WebAP, and NQ). Experimental
results demonstrate significant improvements in utility judgments, ranking of
topical relevance, and answer generation upon representative baselines,
including multiple single-shot utility judging approaches. Our code and
benchmark can be found at https://anonymous.4open.science/r/ITEM-B486/. | [
-0.2460183799,
-0.3960668445,
0.9074727893,
-0.0654981956,
-0.3742806613,
0.0500731207,
0.0194968022,
-0.0858459324,
0.3057219386,
0.804993391,
-0.258000195,
-0.5059928298,
-0.2780376673,
-0.1508444101,
-0.3106775284,
1.054800868,
0.1663595587,
-0.1514378935,
-0.4076305032,
-0.3145029545,
-0.3786752224,
-0.2152352184,
-0.4515024126,
-0.4572900236,
0.7222930789,
0.6583800912,
0.59285146,
0.4269673228,
0.8313934207,
0.2757922411,
0.085312888,
0.0385988764,
-0.4257428944,
0.423722744,
-0.4317099452,
-0.2794480622,
-0.2961509228,
0.2000791878,
0.3802288473,
0.58612293,
-0.4932107031,
0.5439320207,
0.1810395867,
0.717074573,
-0.8786299229,
-0.2766230404,
-0.8997423649,
-0.10339275,
-0.2758652866,
-0.9011589289,
-0.4775379002,
-0.4842035174,
0.3133788705,
-0.5040616393,
0.3331144154,
0.3118368089,
0.7605476975,
0.2874401808,
-0.6486980915,
-0.3388974965,
-0.5206596851,
0.8402483463,
-0.3997192383,
0.2176904678,
0.438990891,
0.489830792,
0.1876263171,
-0.8186460137,
-0.1459358931,
-0.5936120749,
0.0284386706,
0.1846042126,
0.2570459247,
0.0190180503,
0.2807474732,
0.7003418207,
-0.104680337,
-0.3143659234,
-0.2577158213,
0.1436156631,
0.4390969574,
0.3651618063,
-0.1744273007,
-0.4116517901,
-0.5851136446,
0.1555147767,
-0.8725885153,
0.2784852982,
0.2830726802,
0.1431209147,
0.3525015712,
0.7775247693,
-0.0315964557,
0.7032976151,
-0.1278566718,
-0.4219344556,
0.2689024806,
-0.25824368,
0.0723978207,
-0.2820700407,
0.2068521827,
0.6582140326,
-0.1411129385,
-0.2499246299,
-0.0324904509,
-0.3416056931,
0.9769723415,
-0.5952758789,
0.2725835443,
0.2560311258,
-0.5453225374,
-0.3947023451,
0.0236988328,
-0.5920378566,
-0.5377140641,
-0.4553338587,
0.3055862188,
-0.4681512415,
-0.0056683626,
0.1323456168,
-0.0423006862,
0.2378640175,
0.3971738219,
-0.453771621,
0.2728072405,
0.6979312301,
0.6851314306,
-0.2307350785,
-0.0731446892,
-0.7224707007,
0.0996521041,
-0.2458069324,
1.0191404819,
-0.6854794621,
-0.4051266909,
-0.086191915,
-0.3734669089,
0.1626333445,
-0.4871823192,
0.7783528566,
-0.9412305951,
0.1177810207,
-0.4891057611,
-0.4624183476,
-0.2556293905,
0.2922843099,
-0.6637689471,
1.3194313049,
0.200481534,
-0.9396939874,
0.5344369411,
-0.7939827442,
-0.3265554309,
0.1214537099,
0.0244503934,
-0.2697176337,
0.3247190416,
-0.5618305802,
0.42636621,
-0.836894393,
0.4344261885,
-0.6072444916,
-0.2857288718,
0.3853816688,
-0.3402152956,
0.3239474297,
0.4587760568,
-0.2040257901,
-0.0489994474,
-0.872846961,
0.1791953295,
-0.1376027763,
-0.3859500885,
-0.6468738317,
0.2596606016,
-0.1288606524,
0.1127623096,
0.1082008108,
-0.4397710562,
0.0429886356,
-0.2135793567,
-0.0022441063,
0.9352294803,
0.1177300066,
0.615889132,
-0.5354343653,
0.2473634481,
-0.2521183491,
-0.0165585019,
-0.0551634245,
-0.3778358102,
-0.5956892967,
-0.1199528202,
0.3066508174,
0.5185281038,
-0.941598177,
0.0932382196,
-0.2757045627,
-0.2621715367,
-0.2349775434,
-0.0741593763,
0.1906937063,
0.5632833242,
0.4128986895,
-0.2759583294,
-0.0812787861,
-0.6057421565,
-0.6224410534,
-0.1945768297,
-0.2615470886,
0.713975668,
0.1122643948,
0.1051833257,
0.9204079509,
-0.5015768409,
-0.1513736546,
-0.1368694454,
0.1121496186,
0.4317877591,
0.0249304846,
0.4500166774,
-0.973903656,
-0.2408574969,
-0.2239646316,
-0.4984116852,
-0.321162641,
0.0945542902,
-0.2824155986,
-0.1831188053,
0.1180926412,
-0.0408750512,
0.4891236722,
-0.151414901,
-0.4289089143,
0.0655354932,
-0.1847862303,
0.4042829275,
-1.1887414455,
0.3299840391,
0.0346987769,
-0.1191513911,
-0.4443929791,
0.3728404343,
0.0214521792,
0.0952281132,
-0.3388347924,
0.6366409659,
-0.0881714597,
-0.4651005268,
-0.2814241052,
0.2590201795,
0.068415232,
0.1064969227,
-0.3289241195,
0.9424362183,
0.2173761725,
-0.9874803424,
0.1006260738,
-0.3064850867,
-0.1090070531,
0.6523818374,
-0.2981466353,
0.0818787962,
-0.1342274845,
-0.2700927556,
-0.9654724598,
0.0065211626,
0.1886105537,
-0.0799414068,
0.2768356204,
0.1204371452,
-0.4901940525,
-0.2717832625,
-0.7115782499,
0.3583455682,
0.229368642,
-0.4181380868,
0.9954604506,
0.3749277294,
-0.0029314412,
-0.8991580606,
-0.1895215213,
-0.1129666194,
-0.4246099293,
-0.3688786924,
0.47161147,
-0.2471231967,
-0.5597417355,
0.0024736063,
-0.4820008278,
0.2051360309,
0.4354733527,
0.0030149503,
0.4160667658,
0.2253176719,
0.2382150441,
-0.0425418951,
-0.3973129094,
-0.1808433682,
-0.3018778265,
0.4066557288,
-0.2237673998,
-0.5516433716,
0.2587025464,
0.3087670207,
0.377962321,
0.0078035062,
0.0700173303,
0.1160636842,
-0.0599597655,
0.1505788118,
-0.771900177,
-0.015573971,
-0.4920037687,
-0.2006080151,
-0.6433064342,
-0.9478575587,
0.3142225742,
-0.2884821892,
0.4345494509,
0.379750371,
0.4847014248,
-0.2860832214,
0.4649142921,
0.5130531788,
0.2903596163,
0.5320228338,
-0.2785449624,
0.3100991547,
-0.9817843437,
-0.1143425032,
-0.6695785522,
-0.2254137993,
-0.8380923271,
-0.649317503,
0.7566993833,
0.0132463183,
-0.2048649639,
0.128818959,
-0.4444979429,
0.2667078376,
0.5514165759,
0.3612985909,
0.5053637624,
0.2918714583,
-0.5013313293,
0.0090288194,
-0.4808420241,
-0.7653717995,
1.5441730022,
0.2448510528,
0.7015318871,
0.2191114873,
0.8761389256,
0.5140827894,
0.8945356607,
-1.0113492012,
0.7493851185,
-0.3563296199,
-0.4969795644,
-0.1410960406,
-0.3658281565,
-1.0560523272,
0.4726306498,
0.1253732592,
-0.8547871113,
0.1642716825,
-0.0186131764,
-0.3802315891,
0.2016794831,
-0.1988715678,
0.1915576905,
-0.2072617859,
-0.9167662263,
-0.6451712251,
-0.556240797,
0.198841095,
0.1266980767,
0.3014078438,
-0.3837404549,
-0.4100480974,
0.4492126107,
-0.2003801912,
0.2564780116,
-0.0367614478,
-0.2770700455,
0.2974131107,
0.0898918882,
0.1329233795,
0.317797482,
-0.6194215417,
-0.0709093213,
-0.013592463,
-0.3150386214,
-0.552333951,
0.5785835981,
-0.256529659,
-0.8795976043,
-0.7127611041,
-0.4018099308,
-0.3105164766,
0.1925938725,
0.1621381193,
0.4681346118,
-0.0310528148,
0.1960481256,
0.8230313659,
-0.1303382814,
0.3519361615,
0.6873151064,
-0.2518025637,
-0.4068250358,
0.7127295136,
0.0294011179,
0.1783459485,
0.5937464237,
0.2252648324,
-0.3321999013,
-0.2295619249,
-0.3404538035,
0.065023534,
-1.0082480907,
-0.5451372266,
-0.6769257188,
0.1147436723,
0.0450216234,
-0.0639701262,
-0.1671778113,
-0.3602586687,
-0.1997217387,
-0.055569876,
0.4802586734,
0.6357147098,
-0.1766112298,
-0.1272556037,
-0.6333994269,
0.6845034361,
0.4007283449,
0.6680656672,
-0.2668357193,
-0.4589740336,
-0.0470545515,
-0.2924370766,
-0.7169817686,
-0.7074234486,
0.0496167503,
-0.0001987391,
0.6825027466,
0.346544385,
0.2730997801,
0.4636360705,
-0.5550257564,
0.7861684561,
0.1158643588,
-0.6953974366,
0.5347429514,
-0.088731885,
-0.2118202448,
0.8794147372,
0.2879510224,
-0.2320088744,
-0.279728353,
-0.6371991634,
-1.1812078953,
0.5980136395,
0.2253500521,
0.2310855389,
0.0804985538,
0.6980689764,
0.2275021374,
0.5497430563,
-0.5273448229,
-0.6411765218,
-0.0646216646,
0.0817750394,
0.2445572317,
-0.4408330917,
-0.3508457839,
-0.0987956673,
0.653729558,
-0.3206264377,
0.4774650335,
0.0998189226,
0.2053852975,
0.0888686255,
0.5983486176,
0.2465140671,
0.7292596698,
-0.4231591821,
0.0878233835,
0.2387278676,
-0.4968159497,
0.3564833701,
0.1707582027,
-0.2541159093,
0.0146988081,
-0.1376371533,
0.4957977533,
0.4693858325,
-0.3274999261,
0.2643554211,
-0.1128347442,
0.0108858151,
-0.3223667145,
0.1641947329,
-0.3574678898,
0.25216344,
0.7568968534,
0.2342657298,
0.9078482985,
-0.6253156066,
0.2785149813,
0.3948094845,
0.1149078608,
0.2312283814,
0.4101617634,
0.0471533425,
-0.2392675132,
0.0895132497,
-0.2187556475,
-0.3015991449,
0.3551650941,
0.0542655103,
0.995048821,
-0.0992818102,
0.2091178596,
0.3587493896,
0.0105015934,
-0.0578106679,
0.6869729757,
-0.5688402057,
-0.5647460222,
-0.2462559044,
-0.7426211238,
-0.5965188146,
-0.1714870334,
-0.8536579013,
0.2796756625,
-0.1712571084,
-0.4496917725,
-0.1917705983,
0.1524619907,
-0.6697855592,
0.1221664771,
-0.2792500556,
0.9174261689,
-0.1687627584,
0.6919248104,
0.8088228106,
-0.2336170822,
-0.7301442027,
0.6476695538,
-0.2169253528,
-0.6632726192,
0.7169824243,
0.132679835,
-0.5977273583,
-0.0114373565,
-0.3817011714,
-1.2682138681,
1.3460087776,
0.2926747799,
-0.1038749665,
0.1504637301,
-0.1334742308,
0.4522404075,
-0.2975779176,
0.5553708673,
0.5334766507,
0.4160138667,
0.4933559895,
-0.8147878051,
-0.0010333497,
-0.456910193,
0.3859081268,
0.1033960953,
-0.5669309497,
0.5760881901,
-0.3421207666,
-0.235325098,
0.2545998693,
0.3627173007,
0.7194386125,
0.8135185838,
0.4760443866,
0.6127828956,
0.6903457642,
-0.2090519071,
1.162686348,
-0.5948520899,
0.4670191705,
0.9172375798,
-0.4936022162,
0.6584179997,
0.5961890817,
-0.2264913172,
0.7280361056,
0.669592917,
0.404869467,
0.9081206322,
0.2418184727,
-0.4144938886,
-0.238882795,
-0.1463142037,
-0.4673843086,
0.310075134,
0.4921374917,
-0.3014478087,
-0.4395399094,
0.1104473621,
-0.1977175623,
-0.0524019487,
-0.2559577227,
0.9480088949,
0.1752656996,
-0.9205490351,
0.4348977208,
0.0934485272,
0.3786969781,
-0.4563970864,
-0.1630392075,
-0.125223428,
0.0524341017,
-0.0262237415,
-1.0538883209,
0.1703776568,
-0.0742252916,
-0.0895644203,
-0.5537980795,
0.9613212347,
0.2398850471,
-0.2549316585,
0.2516487241,
0.3742496073,
0.0634614751,
0.2456617504,
-0.7400299907,
-0.3160377741,
-0.237828359,
-0.5431049466,
0.2992944121,
0.5623579025,
0.0558253452,
0.9365739226,
0.5362519622,
-0.1221812591,
-0.2304309458,
0.1781260818,
1.040346384,
-0.6887874007,
-0.517483294,
-0.466176182,
0.5507481694,
-0.3406134248,
-0.1386095583,
0.6369764805,
0.4917163849,
0.491838932,
0.2300097942,
0.7122460604,
-0.2650347948,
0.796040833,
-0.7119173408,
0.0409539677,
-0.8861035109,
0.9814718962,
-0.2952974737,
-0.7569040656,
-0.0831931457,
0.686561048,
-0.5642499328,
0.2041521668,
0.8601387143,
0.4579976797,
-0.0242257603,
0.1216293126,
0.3015505373,
-0.2503326535,
0.0048346296,
0.1300569177,
0.8552163839,
-0.4122616351,
0.1987088919,
-0.2800450027,
-0.2499527186,
-0.2620571256,
-1.036560297,
-0.493357271,
-0.5764847994,
-0.0101777017,
-0.6775075793,
-0.0966038853,
1.0545643568,
0.2680102587,
-0.5319694281,
-0.3981774151,
-0.0222083479,
0.3533744514,
-0.1085445881,
-0.3268061876,
0.1542455256,
-0.7218865752,
-0.3301244378,
0.1067677438,
0.7062372565,
-0.4338257611,
-0.1755554527,
0.1526837945,
-0.0875732526,
0.145915702,
0.7966854572,
-0.1335778385,
-0.7627291083,
-0.2372798324,
0.2712104619,
-0.0828783289,
0.137901485,
1.4892513752,
-0.8089849949,
0.3535056412,
0.3766999841,
0.6165041327,
0.5512362123,
-0.0050153448,
0.3096495271,
-0.5347825289,
-0.3011292517,
0.4104096591,
0.41787377,
0.2127214223,
-0.622828722,
0.969568193,
0.2162541896,
-0.5702668428,
-0.7338169813,
0.3911744952,
-0.8778392673,
-0.2715193629,
1.2964662313,
-0.1092798486,
0.0504760891,
-0.369207412,
-0.2725082934,
0.0135658467,
-0.5541220903,
0.9892912507,
0.411201328,
-0.334757477,
-0.2390518785,
-0.6058849692,
0.3948045969,
0.357757926,
-0.8107815385,
-0.0931898355,
0.4235184491,
0.3581277728,
0.4383526444,
0.9298032522,
-0.0743494704,
0.3770054877,
-0.6050012112,
-0.2786358893,
0.491792351,
-0.223620981,
-0.0479657128,
0.5150232315,
0.2321056426,
0.0827678964
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11289v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11289v1 | A Systematic Survey of Text Summarization: From Statistical Methods to Large Language Models | 2024-06-17T07:52:32 | 2024-06-17T07:52:32 | Haopeng Zhang, Philip S. Yu, Jiawei Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Text summarization research has undergone several significant transformations
with the advent of deep neural networks, pre-trained language models (PLMs),
and recent large language models (LLMs). This survey thus provides a
comprehensive review of the research progress and evolution in text
summarization through the lens of these paradigm shifts. It is organized into
two main parts: (1) a detailed overview of datasets, evaluation metrics, and
summarization methods before the LLM era, encompassing traditional statistical
methods, deep learning approaches, and PLM fine-tuning techniques, and (2) the
first detailed examination of recent advancements in benchmarking, modeling,
and evaluating summarization in the LLM era. By synthesizing existing
literature and presenting a cohesive overview, this survey also discusses
research trends, open challenges, and proposes promising research directions in
summarization, aiming to guide researchers through the evolving landscape of
summarization research. | [
-0.3124839365,
-0.700886488,
0.4807543159,
0.0730794817,
-0.2339822352,
0.2580465078,
-0.3199242651,
-0.1683631688,
0.4455010593,
0.5852796435,
-0.3923329115,
-0.5338870287,
-0.6548560858,
0.2856366336,
-0.6145885587,
1.3168549538,
0.0006116691,
0.247290805,
-0.1681466252,
-0.0154917175,
-0.2608866096,
-0.6103206277,
-0.3536812365,
-0.3498927057,
0.5913479328,
0.1439674497,
0.2581583261,
0.2889764309,
0.8228297234,
0.3103269637,
-0.4337319434,
0.2897714078,
-0.5461183786,
0.2612380981,
0.1778946221,
-0.5587650537,
-0.8561914563,
-0.1097889021,
0.9839321375,
0.9699014425,
0.0298582185,
0.1958283931,
0.2413658798,
0.9089355469,
-0.511760354,
0.0556007139,
-0.3455157578,
0.0264969375,
-0.2448368371,
-0.3695673347,
-0.3187586367,
-0.5542148948,
0.2731697261,
-0.2438481599,
0.2403932512,
-0.0405421406,
0.2562741339,
0.074119404,
-0.6759108901,
-0.4123164117,
-0.8201568723,
0.9570236802,
-0.887277782,
0.1233824119,
-0.1845754087,
0.2730606198,
0.021089213,
-0.9816203713,
-0.01330302,
-0.048545178,
0.058868099,
0.3330141902,
0.0696418285,
-0.120140247,
-0.1147947982,
0.7751845121,
-0.6075773835,
0.1086937785,
-0.4289517105,
0.028475726,
0.7992306352,
0.4936590791,
0.3872404397,
0.1762430817,
-0.1121682003,
-0.0634497479,
-0.6983943582,
-0.2154011279,
-0.0107208565,
0.0946445018,
-0.1720545292,
0.7048772573,
-0.3454785049,
0.5931622386,
-0.4190775454,
-0.3441534936,
0.0669468045,
-0.9480029941,
-0.4493393004,
0.0386964977,
0.9113997817,
0.69531703,
0.1980526447,
-0.0348251052,
-0.1216127202,
-0.4119094908,
-0.124203749,
-0.7065460086,
-0.0838749781,
0.1232055277,
-0.8328365684,
-0.4470267296,
0.1135498807,
-0.7580142021,
-0.5302684307,
-0.3677352369,
-0.2966209948,
-0.0768486708,
-0.3286713958,
0.2704133391,
-0.4413350224,
0.2860550284,
0.4475386143,
-0.7070661187,
0.4193412364,
0.9056001902,
0.9918829203,
-0.2952776849,
-0.2706600428,
0.2156016976,
0.0336127356,
-0.545778811,
0.8703502417,
-0.0062045702,
-0.4422183037,
0.273173511,
-0.0684779435,
0.0466214903,
-0.4140294492,
0.259842664,
-0.533782661,
0.3801771402,
-0.2654799819,
-0.5326940417,
-0.3255630434,
0.4347848892,
-0.449925065,
0.8122457266,
-0.2726213932,
-0.8933206797,
0.3235243559,
-0.4116830826,
-0.5488765836,
-0.2526606321,
0.1331469417,
-0.4909177721,
0.3856135309,
0.2485378385,
0.6203613281,
-0.3996470571,
0.3322603703,
-0.1314788014,
-0.3211820424,
0.4101478159,
-0.1000624597,
0.7175281644,
0.2188330591,
0.1603610814,
0.4114559293,
-0.6026251912,
-0.323570013,
0.0300369039,
-0.0369841941,
-0.3900476396,
0.2159904242,
0.1792199314,
-0.1301478744,
0.579541564,
-0.1310349554,
0.2434891611,
-0.4880656302,
0.5045494437,
0.2179832309,
0.3392969966,
0.784419477,
-0.4579187632,
0.4389422834,
-0.3609736264,
-0.0840635672,
-0.7704703808,
-0.2669808865,
-0.4612869322,
-0.1113089398,
0.3617039323,
0.5039583445,
-0.2910763919,
0.5570542812,
-0.520788312,
-0.6612717509,
-0.0339015499,
-0.1328421533,
0.1545365155,
0.193461135,
0.1561542898,
-0.1965067387,
-0.5239055753,
-0.7460888028,
-0.3897457123,
-0.1394230276,
-0.2041418403,
-0.1542067379,
0.5132679939,
0.0294734314,
0.7509086132,
-0.7025657296,
-0.3263409734,
-0.8312782049,
0.4002114832,
0.2595498562,
0.1771870106,
0.5159288645,
-0.4654496908,
-0.2841557264,
-0.0267570727,
-0.7364739776,
-0.0567747913,
-0.0912256762,
0.2762137055,
-0.0710705146,
0.767121315,
-0.2129765153,
0.1320074946,
0.333311975,
0.0265415292,
0.4713760912,
-0.1327601671,
0.3398569226,
-1.0986418724,
0.1102693379,
-0.0556165911,
-0.229335174,
-0.5601032972,
0.0600158721,
-0.0193929952,
0.0547850654,
0.0399104506,
0.4107562602,
-0.7462502718,
-0.1277528554,
-0.5891856551,
0.1188242286,
-0.2427238226,
-0.0817646533,
-0.0689241663,
0.5842558146,
0.3392932117,
-0.6441906095,
0.2194765955,
0.2519948184,
-0.3870561719,
0.0514118485,
-0.6823234558,
-0.2865075171,
-0.490637064,
0.6650349498,
-1.1266819239,
-0.2144501507,
0.1708673835,
-0.3962092102,
0.1728302538,
0.2008221745,
-0.4626800716,
-0.0608284399,
-0.7447939515,
0.5161544681,
0.6409623623,
0.0087176096,
0.4196360409,
0.5111621022,
-0.8479037285,
-0.4297984242,
-0.8732016087,
0.4823502898,
-0.1330161095,
-0.3528874218,
0.3043119907,
-0.091000542,
-0.7759490013,
-0.3615688086,
-0.0028843766,
-0.0969472229,
-0.0660324991,
-0.3615141809,
0.2524077892,
-0.2708925605,
-0.001369065,
0.0605648868,
0.1083385423,
0.1994557679,
0.0623210706,
0.4826270342,
0.3142092228,
0.17810601,
-0.1122427955,
0.2215826958,
0.3019533157,
-0.3903663158,
0.4380013049,
0.1479313821,
-0.0905269757,
-0.202042982,
-0.4108748734,
-0.1849983186,
-0.3211599886,
0.636002481,
0.0716103315,
-0.9808610678,
0.4554026723,
-0.1616213769,
0.5235555768,
0.4420265853,
0.6252813339,
-0.117909655,
0.7289949656,
0.7750020027,
-0.1430729181,
0.4363196194,
-0.0061103059,
0.1859938949,
-0.6471703649,
-0.0957543552,
-0.6128376126,
-0.2742999792,
-0.4387483001,
-0.21866557,
0.430785805,
-0.1221215203,
0.2128070742,
0.0091107804,
-0.3246280551,
0.4308260083,
0.0078929793,
-0.1022943854,
0.5275910497,
-0.1768745929,
0.3661405146,
-0.0645744652,
-0.4572340846,
-0.466697067,
1.2486104965,
0.5690511465,
0.5257835388,
0.0188733302,
0.5884398222,
0.2772870958,
0.495344758,
-0.6498721838,
0.6597255468,
-0.2941332161,
-0.5098099113,
-0.4665316939,
-0.4426345527,
-0.7432955503,
0.3646442592,
0.0359646194,
-0.271466583,
-0.025685519,
0.0693358555,
-0.1523907781,
0.1648204178,
-0.306468159,
0.4578068852,
-0.1030994058,
0.1795674562,
-0.2820908725,
-0.6363556385,
0.8278387785,
-0.0175477248,
0.3872896135,
-0.1605192721,
-0.371083945,
0.8945134878,
-0.2475129366,
0.6662915349,
0.1161912382,
-0.4647622406,
0.1760137081,
-0.2087041885,
0.3191323578,
0.0931174383,
0.1541618258,
0.0549241565,
-0.0278435573,
-0.3149279654,
-0.470667243,
0.4345116913,
-0.2189669311,
-0.1520745307,
-0.5821459293,
-0.5557283759,
-0.1798033267,
0.2992214262,
0.3236551285,
0.4988062382,
-0.6473286152,
0.2162737399,
0.9046146274,
-0.339903146,
0.7176982164,
0.3156554699,
-0.6000088453,
-0.6837816238,
0.7119733691,
0.2593152821,
-0.0393774845,
0.7539290786,
0.0082635125,
-0.2273712009,
-1.0178905725,
0.0296361092,
0.2553925514,
-0.4896185398,
0.0257562622,
-0.5985013247,
-0.2246086299,
-0.7154526114,
-0.2351239771,
-0.338812381,
-0.4584884048,
-0.1707594842,
-0.0628785491,
-0.0325319506,
1.1266025305,
0.4569879472,
0.4158831537,
-0.7094583511,
0.3817942142,
0.1783361882,
0.2067129463,
0.1671380103,
-0.3592662215,
-0.232560724,
-0.2207419723,
0.0652722269,
-0.8868104219,
0.3456302583,
-0.0473553501,
0.1628589481,
0.3250513971,
-0.1039722115,
0.237125203,
-0.5612054467,
1.0452437401,
0.4563553929,
-0.504570961,
0.274379164,
-0.7550188303,
0.5882385373,
0.5689338446,
0.1851141751,
-0.6125671268,
-0.261459291,
-0.1410652399,
-0.8739444613,
0.3201441467,
-0.0314842202,
-0.1298829317,
0.3847003281,
0.095643498,
0.2650430202,
0.3362846971,
-0.4351163805,
-0.3793029785,
0.1346983463,
-0.4151633084,
-0.5948709846,
-0.4180237055,
-0.0643723682,
-0.1036799625,
0.5961589217,
0.0331513248,
-0.0584200174,
0.1267591715,
-0.4329588115,
0.4095786214,
0.5252926946,
0.8508809805,
1.0993994474,
-0.2022795826,
0.0103818895,
0.2194944918,
-0.5280591846,
0.126516819,
0.1983457655,
-0.4623572826,
0.2754038274,
0.6364315152,
0.4022236466,
0.4336561561,
-0.5683807135,
0.600102663,
-0.2825528979,
-0.4866346121,
-0.3994615674,
-0.2369883358,
-0.0606508106,
-0.0625177026,
0.4397761524,
-0.138901338,
0.5281389952,
-0.3712729812,
-0.1028467044,
0.2582253814,
-0.2702138126,
-0.4588926733,
0.448004961,
0.2054382414,
0.0663172528,
0.0676199719,
0.2517178655,
0.0540935807,
0.5077778697,
0.1842037588,
1.1830527782,
-0.0030214177,
0.2744945586,
0.239027068,
0.3281432688,
-0.3077478409,
-0.0003534245,
-0.1273684949,
-0.3547270596,
-0.6212203503,
-0.4730727077,
-0.5004678369,
0.1121376827,
-0.4659582078,
0.235742718,
-0.253297925,
-0.0842903629,
0.2872870266,
-0.1132185459,
-0.1806553006,
0.0820266753,
0.0644711703,
1.0196976662,
-0.6378275752,
0.3077125847,
0.9334424138,
-0.2636707127,
0.1251551956,
0.0791850761,
0.1526351422,
-0.2755618989,
0.1999041587,
-0.1684852839,
-0.1099233553,
0.0024815488,
-0.5671153069,
-0.5680613518,
0.9015394449,
-0.1551997811,
-0.5807478428,
-0.2048871666,
0.1513985842,
0.6189397573,
-0.132808283,
0.3536369801,
0.6033035517,
0.3048760295,
-0.2916913033,
-0.6704152226,
-0.2906736135,
-0.2033227533,
0.1525799334,
0.3475320041,
-0.7439494133,
0.7345178723,
0.0064136079,
-0.1511659473,
0.2609224319,
0.8116397262,
0.1314692944,
0.5842332244,
0.0831695274,
0.3016942441,
0.2721965313,
-0.1508973241,
0.8097753525,
-0.2106004655,
0.0963171646,
1.0340601206,
-0.2680884302,
0.5639855862,
0.2955181599,
-0.3202970326,
0.1069707945,
0.5115523934,
0.0186199844,
0.2467470169,
0.3764365613,
-0.1368933171,
0.1514475644,
0.036425963,
-0.5496503711,
0.2173780054,
0.1035357639,
-0.6078637242,
-0.5197083354,
-0.1129015312,
0.110392347,
0.2393702418,
-0.559512198,
1.3049925566,
0.1796361953,
-0.7129477262,
-0.0304952748,
0.19478181,
0.8686406016,
-0.7450275421,
0.0586520471,
-0.3626220822,
0.0629564226,
-0.094171308,
-0.7560058832,
0.1690666825,
0.0544907339,
-0.375305742,
-0.5931443572,
0.9538682699,
-0.3309165239,
-0.4089774787,
0.0219890941,
0.5638074279,
0.2408062071,
0.0526005141,
-0.0703939945,
0.0757558867,
-0.0766867697,
-0.2095355541,
0.3906954825,
0.3931924403,
0.0918804705,
0.3008344173,
0.406678915,
0.221909225,
0.1902837902,
0.2928268313,
0.6237243414,
-1.0573771,
-0.6509890556,
-0.9630624652,
0.5777683258,
-0.2466953844,
-0.5146998167,
0.9399639964,
0.8956536055,
0.4549614191,
-0.1641712636,
1.0173193216,
0.1689606756,
0.7786380053,
-0.4798625112,
0.9180220962,
-0.3664100468,
0.0546486937,
-0.4356853664,
-1.0434350967,
-0.4231463373,
-0.1044417322,
-0.2386552542,
-0.1570728123,
0.6681300402,
0.3007568419,
0.2353020608,
0.1895866394,
-0.0061754198,
0.0795824528,
0.1469669044,
-0.0295583736,
0.8816210628,
-0.3812163174,
0.3573672175,
0.0517641306,
-0.4434180856,
-0.3138643205,
-0.7361308932,
-0.8300824761,
-0.6397095919,
-0.3888839781,
0.2373320907,
0.2386790216,
0.4156722724,
0.1877977252,
-0.8476291299,
-0.4774948657,
-0.1734576821,
0.1547386199,
-0.2232087106,
-0.1656056494,
0.184318006,
-0.4671240449,
-0.7148877978,
0.2989428043,
0.3219304979,
0.1388868839,
-0.3162529469,
0.129401803,
0.0584476478,
0.0316211283,
0.8475555778,
0.2593940496,
-0.3620998263,
0.4158060551,
0.0801362097,
-0.1985508651,
-0.0283149797,
1.0570259094,
-0.2468898892,
0.0630979612,
0.9608266354,
0.6271827221,
0.28777197,
-0.1398113668,
0.7583425641,
-0.5633952618,
-0.0764442086,
0.2247204781,
0.2234230042,
0.1666842997,
0.0466733687,
0.4777316451,
-0.0413048007,
-0.6349464059,
-1.0425726175,
-0.0588016883,
-0.9647877216,
-0.4769534767,
0.9052323699,
0.2631322443,
-0.1093296781,
0.0169904809,
-0.0991899595,
0.1841197014,
-0.1164362878,
0.7067642808,
0.7269175649,
-0.0787956193,
-0.2976716459,
-0.3347743154,
0.5305168033,
0.2587413788,
-1.1356580257,
0.2070556581,
0.6725388765,
0.154401347,
-0.0005474577,
0.7535559535,
-0.406524986,
0.0097587202,
-0.2846795619,
0.1173117235,
0.1833305508,
-0.3340940773,
-0.6514592171,
0.41249156,
-0.0436421037,
0.2046265453
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11288v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11288v1 | MFC-Bench: Benchmarking Multimodal Fact-Checking with Large Vision-Language Models | 2024-06-17T07:51:44 | 2024-06-17T07:51:44 | Shengkang Wang, Hongzhan Lin, Ziyang Luo, Zhen Ye, Guang Chen, Jing Ma | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | Large vision-language models (LVLMs) have significantly improved multimodal
reasoning tasks, such as visual question answering and image captioning. These
models embed multimodal facts within their parameters, rather than relying on
external knowledge bases to store factual information explicitly. However, the
content discerned by LVLMs may deviate from actual facts due to inherent bias
or incorrect inference. To address this issue, we introduce MFC-Bench, a
rigorous and comprehensive benchmark designed to evaluate the factual accuracy
of LVLMs across three tasks: Manipulation, Out-of-Context, and Veracity
Classification. Through our evaluation on MFC-Bench, we benchmarked 12 diverse
and representative LVLMs, uncovering that current models still fall short in
multimodal fact-checking and demonstrate insensitivity to various forms of
manipulated content. We hope that MFC-Bench could raise attention to the
trustworthy artificial intelligence potentially assisted by LVLMs in the
future. The MFC-Bench and accompanying resources are publicly accessible at
https://github.com/wskbest/MFC-Bench, contributing to ongoing research in the
multimodal fact-checking field. | [
-0.4336991012,
-0.677852869,
0.7572839856,
0.0621208847,
-0.0312953927,
0.088075079,
-0.234447673,
-0.4640329778,
-0.3574169576,
0.400972724,
-0.5660224557,
-0.4599485099,
-0.4224151969,
0.0668351352,
-0.5096951723,
0.5530930161,
-0.235240072,
0.2395678908,
-0.7788724303,
-0.4756620526,
-0.1369545609,
-0.3602127433,
-0.0392643809,
-0.1585402042,
0.58724612,
0.2926236391,
0.6522212625,
0.5840518475,
0.701428175,
0.3467714787,
0.3701008856,
0.5809791684,
-0.2520121634,
0.0556445271,
-0.2107070237,
-0.4410167038,
-0.0760557204,
0.2264979333,
0.6977475286,
0.2268800586,
-0.0950819775,
0.3532280922,
-0.2512566447,
0.64795959,
-1.1139791012,
0.4704909623,
-0.4882799089,
-0.0274710786,
-0.1076018214,
0.0585958511,
-0.614905715,
-0.4454215169,
-0.1969706714,
-0.4723950624,
0.2408085912,
0.2925264239,
0.8890181184,
0.5852888823,
-0.5281336904,
0.070526652,
-0.3672050834,
0.8262239099,
-0.4012274742,
1.0038410425,
0.4794980884,
0.6352926493,
0.0833539218,
-0.7445841432,
-0.8929467797,
-0.5106627941,
-0.2562842965,
0.1918783039,
-0.096292533,
-0.0104657346,
0.5944318175,
-0.0108667193,
-0.475625366,
-0.2829035819,
-0.2134745866,
-0.4445826411,
0.4279299974,
-0.0014777471,
-0.0612798892,
-0.2590917945,
-0.6372201443,
-0.4873000681,
-0.6001852155,
0.2794573307,
-0.062496651,
-0.0053339615,
-0.0592182614,
0.7997887731,
-0.5974750519,
0.8588521481,
-0.3758452535,
-0.6272126436,
0.4396761656,
-0.7227628827,
-0.2391600013,
-0.1689940691,
0.6243485212,
0.8112398386,
0.1319382042,
-0.0064969985,
-0.2229634076,
0.1423321217,
0.1047519594,
-0.6737458706,
-0.1044930816,
0.0467480384,
-0.4925192297,
-0.1275106817,
0.1002564803,
-0.8345414996,
-0.6221954226,
-0.4784438908,
0.3734202683,
-0.3887814283,
-0.018255664,
-0.3148013055,
-0.1990622729,
0.1769955158,
0.6160343885,
-0.4193843901,
-0.0355816521,
0.5493816733,
0.7323595285,
-0.028132176,
-0.516036272,
-1.0118733644,
0.0986682028,
-0.1976510733,
0.8712667823,
-0.5535238385,
0.0749272928,
0.10823825,
0.0123480847,
-0.1591910273,
-0.484390825,
0.7442182302,
-0.3133025765,
-0.2353114933,
-0.6872572899,
-0.3686689734,
-0.2265952677,
0.8045601845,
-0.8137440085,
0.9487518668,
-0.0657533631,
-0.5463597178,
0.6281477809,
-0.3828442991,
-0.2026001215,
-0.3337906897,
-0.426361829,
-0.3315537274,
-0.1548927873,
0.267286092,
0.4226574004,
-0.4420727491,
0.3201270401,
-0.6358142495,
-0.1245644018,
0.5736945868,
-0.5546353459,
0.4053296149,
0.2140910029,
-0.2936823368,
0.1128207743,
-0.9077568054,
0.0681455582,
-0.1370848715,
-0.4103486836,
-0.0822647661,
0.1624708176,
0.1885868311,
0.5035877228,
-0.0085089263,
-0.7644380331,
-0.0680759996,
0.2808023691,
0.1024627164,
0.7150161862,
-0.4066118598,
-0.0393806621,
-0.4349162281,
-0.022222504,
0.1914017648,
0.4903363883,
-0.2397513241,
-0.2775914073,
-0.8024094105,
-0.4700968862,
0.2653100491,
0.5383322239,
-1.2174437046,
0.0140865492,
-0.2942764461,
-0.5213493109,
-0.4513052106,
0.3322938383,
0.542137444,
0.6174844503,
0.5816313028,
-0.195145607,
-0.2459438592,
-1.0598136187,
-0.2888699174,
-0.2551142871,
0.3329416513,
0.4250951111,
0.6210879683,
-0.1532356888,
0.9441112876,
-0.3120725155,
-0.2767127454,
0.2582992911,
0.3257700801,
-0.180240795,
0.3357886374,
0.7059664726,
-1.0241334438,
-0.228347078,
-0.0594140217,
-0.8543058634,
-0.0713004544,
-0.1378982067,
0.0590717979,
0.3987275958,
0.6106021404,
-0.9175701141,
0.4690153003,
0.6870012283,
-0.2572997212,
0.9022940993,
-0.0514122099,
0.6316975951,
-0.4756015837,
0.1881849766,
0.0682476908,
-0.3860584497,
-0.2805057168,
0.264747113,
0.5804359913,
0.1906630248,
-0.6612516046,
0.4354881644,
-0.3792659044,
-0.2300148159,
-0.0189799536,
0.0287006963,
0.098192133,
0.4204834402,
-0.1287395954,
0.7400596738,
0.2788925767,
-0.3068729341,
0.7642489076,
0.0776684955,
-0.7535858154,
0.6446964741,
-0.2190358788,
-0.1699037999,
-0.0438481718,
0.3260174394,
-1.0506597757,
-0.2090106457,
0.0975568444,
-0.1808300167,
0.160486266,
-0.0397863388,
-0.9763060212,
-0.3406589925,
-0.3153758943,
0.332372576,
0.1029717624,
-0.7837142348,
0.803617239,
0.110527426,
0.2750941515,
-1.0477596521,
-0.5920507908,
0.1110514477,
0.350376755,
-0.6251551509,
0.1623072624,
-0.3423627615,
-0.4905944169,
-0.033706177,
-0.1794151813,
-0.1551576257,
-0.101704523,
0.3367373943,
0.1427377015,
-0.2605463266,
0.2592928112,
-0.210085839,
0.074577786,
0.0503344908,
0.255943805,
0.2612303793,
-0.4650644362,
-0.8168358207,
-0.1212522537,
0.0437931977,
0.9835765362,
-0.559168458,
0.5707350969,
0.965079546,
-0.2039601952,
0.0453545898,
-1.0991464853,
-0.1742676646,
-0.4181267917,
0.2298391312,
-0.3506656587,
-0.8020455837,
0.1477047652,
0.0232004095,
0.1377283633,
0.1163099259,
0.5481826067,
-0.1423492283,
0.9081184864,
0.2983235419,
0.1392972171,
0.3417188227,
0.0146972295,
-0.0822158307,
-0.4083990455,
-0.2517135441,
-0.4054889083,
-0.237883985,
-0.3627142906,
-0.8236815929,
0.3079010844,
-0.3509704769,
0.0267850813,
-0.0327661596,
0.0982422009,
0.5046849251,
0.6141489744,
0.271618247,
0.4329957068,
-0.2611926794,
-0.2938120067,
0.0484551825,
-0.445985049,
-0.2106798142,
0.9738324285,
0.1438077092,
0.7718867064,
0.1825901717,
0.1516037881,
0.3297219276,
0.5927539468,
-0.487729162,
0.5796371698,
-0.1759031266,
-0.8452949524,
-0.1050330773,
-0.3579235375,
-0.2389457822,
0.6209483743,
-0.6579272151,
-0.4255069792,
0.2282911986,
0.2496474832,
-0.1788477302,
0.4228348136,
-0.7795050144,
0.9293448925,
-0.448879689,
-0.8025248051,
-0.397657752,
-0.7187154889,
0.6765008569,
0.0027588215,
0.4828614891,
-0.4198932946,
0.0928205401,
0.2643843889,
-0.1661455482,
0.8475766182,
-0.2687392831,
0.0895438939,
0.0949967429,
0.0622167923,
0.4289048016,
0.080513984,
0.0887862965,
0.0599029288,
0.2366569936,
-0.3325683773,
-0.6397501826,
0.661003828,
-0.6235960722,
-0.4014694393,
-0.4629289806,
-0.616053462,
-0.4370924532,
0.259703517,
-0.215399161,
0.6369625926,
-0.2894932032,
0.6822140813,
0.5670932531,
-0.0629004762,
0.5104354024,
0.7430368066,
-0.2485542595,
-0.2561723888,
0.7865855694,
-0.0137090217,
0.1849093735,
0.6971117854,
0.0788643062,
-0.569820106,
-0.3792510331,
-0.6399524808,
0.030418409,
-1.0683423281,
-0.2454258949,
-0.6496346593,
0.0870352238,
-0.1825534999,
0.1750739366,
-0.5853521228,
-0.3192217648,
0.1811035126,
0.0146416659,
0.091391772,
0.3695437014,
-0.0228969827,
-0.0611876883,
-0.8008421063,
0.5335236788,
0.5535729527,
0.4811507165,
-0.3217534125,
-0.1057190895,
-0.1259256899,
0.1121449992,
-0.2178928405,
-0.530800581,
-0.1503316164,
0.1304402798,
0.832562387,
0.4455696642,
0.0648809224,
0.5705529451,
-0.4993872046,
0.6265742183,
0.3586233854,
-0.7948522568,
0.229873687,
-0.0396717861,
0.1601098329,
0.7249837518,
0.1543691754,
-0.33997491,
-0.2684549987,
-0.2733522654,
-0.1957415044,
0.4628549218,
0.1025371552,
-0.3362240195,
0.2262137979,
-0.034602616,
0.0818502158,
0.4544947147,
-0.8000084758,
-0.1616180837,
-0.5379301906,
-0.2188085169,
-0.4056599438,
-0.2018431574,
-0.4282502234,
-0.2802976072,
0.3700795472,
-0.4911578,
-0.0157296881,
0.310734868,
-0.5380842686,
-0.0475051366,
0.2588683069,
0.9804637432,
0.9439498782,
-0.4286939502,
0.5571566224,
0.2001262307,
-0.3109739423,
0.0680411011,
0.2917653322,
-0.0144375628,
0.0222333223,
0.4448432028,
0.5728357434,
0.3859602213,
-1.0818693638,
0.7173944116,
-0.214647606,
-0.3665264547,
-0.0269539226,
0.0845161378,
-0.0337439477,
0.3956648111,
0.1669681072,
0.4870829284,
0.0842919871,
-0.6191685796,
0.4007350504,
0.4703432024,
-0.4780956805,
0.0188474152,
0.482626766,
0.1477084905,
0.3924429119,
0.4871656299,
0.0589879043,
-0.37039873,
0.4447881877,
0.1304587275,
0.4249242544,
0.0356578715,
0.2282699943,
0.3793559074,
0.6943812966,
-0.0504902191,
0.1051251292,
-0.2538028955,
-0.8762404323,
-0.5293787122,
-0.5043863058,
-0.5971096158,
-0.0343927629,
-0.4416726232,
0.0352978632,
-0.4924506843,
-0.1345565766,
0.2287650406,
-0.2321062088,
-0.8273756504,
0.3878102601,
0.2780152559,
1.133983016,
-0.6727759242,
0.8680331111,
0.6811003089,
-0.467648536,
-0.2725360394,
-0.2067389041,
0.3229589462,
-0.9465153813,
0.7371304035,
0.275131315,
-0.4406981766,
-0.4373760819,
-0.8155923486,
-0.7863558531,
1.2514870167,
0.4509290755,
-0.5651278496,
0.4370428324,
0.0449059606,
0.2597539723,
-0.2522570789,
0.312675029,
0.5732019544,
0.9223431349,
0.0711797848,
-0.8716103435,
0.0864529982,
-0.3337323666,
-0.4375635982,
-0.0291516855,
-0.9162737727,
0.8898067474,
-0.3081920147,
0.0705992728,
0.0233715605,
0.4909445643,
0.3797673583,
0.462477833,
0.8276674747,
0.5348927379,
0.6568316221,
-0.3425604403,
1.1219644547,
-0.2750612795,
0.2483368963,
0.9327194691,
-0.5240661502,
0.964096725,
0.6203939915,
-0.0084672971,
0.5021275878,
0.323838383,
-0.2960183918,
0.547924459,
-0.1506282091,
-0.1856276542,
-0.5584110618,
-0.3469184339,
-0.3098433614,
0.6452226639,
0.2337028384,
-0.1937402785,
-0.2491161078,
-0.0573391877,
-0.1865764409,
-0.0201555714,
-0.1271433979,
0.4685673416,
-0.2211781144,
-0.8136816025,
0.5467175245,
-0.0545059033,
0.3047387898,
-0.5850986242,
-0.1548946351,
0.0220876932,
0.3977055848,
-0.0948887244,
-0.9736996293,
-0.1259526163,
-0.0499944538,
-0.3792937994,
-0.2048328966,
0.7965015769,
-0.4632844627,
-0.372743547,
0.2869004607,
0.7634139657,
-0.3268932402,
-0.2630547583,
-0.8280554414,
0.2106945813,
-0.0964295194,
-0.0632001385,
0.2211321741,
0.1284415871,
-0.0805623457,
0.8604980111,
0.9214656949,
-0.4211097658,
0.06095488,
0.343904078,
0.8412055969,
-0.5896409154,
-0.236226663,
-0.8537313938,
0.3579113781,
-0.2701428235,
-0.2496775091,
0.7726694345,
0.6820473671,
0.7861323953,
-0.2434833795,
0.6797024012,
-0.0952733979,
0.356642276,
-0.808568716,
0.7248618603,
-0.8802591562,
-0.3256694674,
-0.2501195669,
-0.7409123778,
-0.2975150049,
0.4534272254,
-0.0840317085,
-0.1250073165,
0.9281073213,
0.9769768119,
-0.2142250687,
0.1629719138,
0.5536850691,
0.2533969581,
0.2340881675,
0.3378929198,
1.2242236137,
-0.1950063258,
0.7445766926,
-0.5139974356,
-0.2351203114,
-0.4100122452,
-1.061858654,
-1.0160058737,
-0.5372350216,
-0.1911301166,
-0.183395654,
0.0459856503,
0.8757305741,
0.9551819563,
-0.8819054961,
-0.0572118424,
0.3864061534,
0.3157105744,
-0.447136879,
-0.1173963919,
0.2227255851,
-0.1925456226,
-0.3337216377,
0.4100264907,
0.3680366278,
-0.0843397155,
-0.2062720954,
-0.0610547848,
-0.5176946521,
-0.2161565572,
0.9342544675,
0.112936087,
-1.0269665718,
-0.4712076783,
0.0916107744,
-0.2541485429,
0.0701767504,
0.8385861516,
-0.5799017549,
0.7902461886,
0.5042543411,
0.672003746,
0.5707218051,
0.1044871435,
0.2585164309,
-0.8645567298,
0.0960921049,
-0.0953669399,
0.7650780678,
0.4670518935,
0.1929786056,
0.5528170466,
0.5121078491,
-0.2961103022,
-0.7987042665,
0.0614874363,
-1.0919616222,
-0.3223386705,
0.9567189217,
-0.0221324265,
-0.4029082954,
-0.0929656252,
-0.283981204,
0.0445407704,
-0.2726712823,
0.670119226,
0.91132164,
0.0558755063,
-0.5324499011,
-0.8357360363,
0.5780962706,
0.3053199649,
-0.9033246636,
0.2865671217,
0.7763907909,
0.0917715952,
0.4681777954,
0.289647907,
0.0699332878,
0.729534924,
0.0831467584,
0.1883268356,
-0.2995992601,
-0.5286624432,
0.251550585,
0.2374559939,
-0.1702165753,
-0.0467404388
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11285v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11285v1 | Self and Cross-Model Distillation for LLMs: Effective Methods for Refusal Pattern Alignment | 2024-06-17T07:46:45 | 2024-06-17T07:46:45 | Jie Li, Yi Liu, Chongyang Liu, Xiaoning Ren, Ling Shi, Weisong Sun, Yinxing Xue | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) like OpenAI's GPT series, Anthropic's Claude,
and Meta's LLaMa have shown remarkable capabilities in text generation.
However, their susceptibility to toxic prompts presents significant security
challenges. This paper investigates alignment techniques, including Supervised
Fine-Tuning (SFT) and Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF), to
mitigate these risks. We conduct an empirical study on refusal patterns across
nine LLMs, revealing that models with uniform refusal patterns, such as
Claude3, exhibit higher security. Based on these findings, we propose
self-distilling and cross-model distilling methods to enhance LLM security. Our
results show that these methods significantly improve refusal rates and reduce
unsafe content, with cross-model distilling achieving refusal rates close to
Claude3's 94.51%. These findings underscore the potential of distillation-based
alignment in securing LLMs against toxic prompts. | [
-0.0368759707,
-0.8229523897,
0.8399309516,
0.1078759432,
-0.2468550652,
0.2874962986,
0.0873056054,
-0.3256058097,
-0.2738947272,
0.7267509103,
-0.8877512217,
-0.5051232576,
-0.5272347331,
0.3881394267,
-0.3151962459,
1.2310495377,
-0.183669135,
0.1146631241,
-0.0171422884,
-0.0318282172,
-0.7021751404,
-0.6678634882,
-0.6824353933,
-0.5057668686,
0.7805387378,
0.2433263958,
0.5501036644,
0.6726416349,
0.4390308559,
0.3525159359,
-0.0845421478,
0.1103180051,
-0.4089944661,
0.4584648311,
-0.3173101842,
-0.4911858737,
-0.3629190624,
0.2306045741,
0.0766551942,
0.1410049945,
-0.3350706398,
0.0728338957,
0.4020940363,
0.883475244,
-0.4779319167,
-0.2678198814,
-0.7512259483,
-0.0319863893,
-0.2877814174,
-0.1670663357,
-0.7100315094,
-0.2686112821,
0.1343619674,
-0.5355657339,
-0.1382862329,
0.1908840984,
0.6508841515,
0.4110139012,
-0.3420013785,
-0.5515385866,
-0.6958708167,
0.8384995461,
-0.7074025273,
0.1510492414,
0.4653895199,
0.4549140334,
-0.5003634691,
-0.7022953033,
-0.3789145052,
-0.2284723371,
-0.0582338311,
-0.0460408032,
-0.1598324329,
0.0370894857,
0.2778161466,
0.0403860025,
-0.5966197252,
0.4831804633,
-0.3145641685,
-0.2006095797,
0.711837709,
0.389798224,
0.3775966763,
-0.0666095987,
-0.6598815918,
-0.2814389765,
-0.9623553157,
-0.016976729,
0.7641326785,
0.4492029846,
0.1085411459,
0.5797791481,
-0.2199036032,
0.7305772901,
0.3012580574,
-0.1908395588,
-0.0011010979,
-0.437494576,
-0.2151664943,
0.1889356226,
1.0326372385,
0.3706891835,
0.2621490061,
0.2390103042,
-0.3819423616,
-0.0686803907,
0.3532913625,
-0.7198527455,
-0.226715818,
0.5269274116,
-0.7096805573,
-0.754563868,
-0.072305873,
-0.7892060876,
-0.6461172104,
-0.3240742087,
0.4146951139,
-0.4368730187,
-0.075441286,
-0.1123784557,
-0.1317898184,
0.2260746956,
0.3455836773,
-1.0761376619,
0.2355843633,
0.6237324476,
0.9288496375,
-0.3686062396,
-0.319118768,
-0.6073108315,
0.2509343326,
-0.1270523518,
0.4384536147,
-0.3527825773,
-0.4223255515,
-0.2531705797,
-0.1935950369,
0.2777858377,
-0.6278426051,
0.6232739687,
-0.6068144441,
0.0659783334,
-0.3589117825,
-0.1842514426,
-0.0294735525,
0.1603328139,
-0.5609036684,
0.7239786983,
-0.2696319818,
-0.8653907776,
0.4013153613,
-0.2621403337,
-0.3198602796,
-0.2514653802,
-0.1741163284,
-0.7185405493,
0.0900856629,
0.4409591258,
0.3376539052,
-0.1121010259,
0.3170973361,
-0.6383296847,
0.0046075215,
0.4447818398,
-0.8103122711,
0.8818487525,
0.7233574986,
-0.2373555452,
0.2460147887,
-0.8573220372,
-0.1381526142,
0.1980385929,
-0.3444438577,
-0.5335461497,
0.1780279428,
0.0110372091,
0.3797189295,
0.0826290995,
-0.4390286505,
0.1602342129,
-0.0948470011,
0.7157614827,
1.0846617222,
-0.0100647137,
0.2169579417,
-0.4752390981,
0.4891825318,
0.1488383859,
0.3713330328,
0.0681088194,
-0.2945459485,
-0.4070803225,
-0.2124921232,
0.3151046634,
0.7268522978,
-0.6636414528,
0.3494437337,
0.246137172,
-0.4771603048,
-0.52170223,
0.2946453094,
0.4330849648,
0.516802907,
0.235720247,
-0.1753406823,
-0.5227541327,
-0.7581564784,
-0.3225385845,
-0.3887070119,
-0.0225341301,
-0.1347411126,
0.3056573272,
-0.1564418375,
0.9331780672,
-0.3088988662,
-0.2843248248,
0.0808039382,
0.2263694108,
0.2053197473,
0.3777098954,
0.6547007561,
-0.849337697,
-0.5876000524,
-0.0969313756,
-0.5890704393,
-0.327413708,
-0.1053062528,
-0.0304404367,
0.3054258525,
0.7205641866,
-0.0714677349,
0.3635106683,
0.6069458127,
-0.0888998657,
0.4077369869,
-0.1503747851,
0.0446518436,
-1.2136999369,
-0.1733833104,
-0.0301298592,
-0.4445428848,
-0.7056317329,
-0.0650016814,
0.0188169945,
-0.0612438656,
-0.6699479222,
0.3137393594,
-0.587087512,
0.5188537836,
-0.4047915936,
-0.1472385973,
-0.1925830841,
0.1706755459,
0.1062679216,
0.6476914287,
0.5438694358,
-0.7246617675,
0.4788265824,
0.2070388794,
-0.1637625247,
0.7367025018,
-0.7441256642,
0.1056683064,
-0.0956691951,
0.2688979506,
-1.2226558924,
-0.0641664267,
0.4664584994,
-0.1566487402,
0.27115798,
-0.2905427814,
-0.0818897113,
-0.2653467059,
-0.2561197579,
0.3655659854,
0.5632488132,
-0.6355563998,
0.5062856674,
0.0621524528,
-0.331790626,
-0.8119285703,
-0.788954258,
-0.0064741299,
-0.6079007387,
-0.2878759801,
0.018626716,
-0.3425971568,
-0.2960729599,
-0.2787790895,
-0.1107766777,
0.1021423936,
0.3601843715,
0.4658472836,
0.3165129125,
0.1933232993,
-0.3778997958,
-0.0515085198,
-0.2507451773,
0.1245549992,
-0.3140520453,
0.3433965147,
0.23190476,
-0.5185194016,
-0.5591462851,
0.2999497354,
0.5459256768,
-0.0228661988,
0.4471823871,
0.1884572506,
-0.1229650751,
-0.138593331,
-0.4086490273,
-0.2243231833,
-0.5974560976,
-0.0186612699,
-0.4268025458,
-0.9107586741,
0.4880053103,
-0.0766277835,
0.1606488526,
0.1612344831,
0.7669888139,
-0.2135905772,
0.9306320548,
0.3451054692,
-0.3110125363,
0.5205404162,
0.4618636668,
0.1544623375,
-0.5137838125,
-0.0668031499,
-0.5379989743,
-0.4331891835,
-0.7940379381,
-0.0260067824,
0.3649020195,
0.0077284724,
-0.0121197645,
0.2284560204,
-0.6325616837,
0.6038217545,
0.4978540838,
0.1988272667,
0.5952121615,
0.1030595526,
-0.3841066957,
-0.0842738822,
-0.4101666808,
-0.6349391937,
1.0814806223,
0.559650898,
1.2740145922,
0.1992424875,
1.0898692608,
0.1800314933,
0.2602144182,
-0.3921358883,
0.3492981791,
0.1948354244,
-0.7418208122,
-0.4575991631,
-0.4887218177,
-0.9858843684,
0.2319475263,
-0.17233859,
-0.7036848664,
0.1213046685,
0.1889364272,
-0.6701092124,
0.1532806307,
-0.5813759565,
0.4849871993,
-0.4902366996,
-0.2019262612,
0.0349818058,
-0.5582674742,
0.5147433877,
-0.3067182004,
0.2969709039,
-0.1084883213,
0.0235005077,
0.3732615113,
-0.8070616126,
1.187330246,
0.0647371411,
-0.7278965712,
0.4679317474,
0.3632277846,
0.8673794866,
0.1661518514,
-0.1806925684,
0.0187843572,
0.0618527718,
-0.0697360113,
-0.4496796429,
0.7372288108,
-0.6712727547,
-0.9028975368,
-0.6252524257,
-0.3041763604,
0.039711576,
0.3517269194,
0.6501486897,
-0.1523584127,
-0.27764979,
-0.233680591,
0.7832497358,
-0.2193790525,
0.6261740923,
0.5631294847,
-0.3023997843,
-0.5638471842,
0.8750401139,
0.1732060462,
0.6281359792,
0.1312371045,
0.2672030926,
-0.3533990681,
-0.8807183504,
-0.4540508389,
-0.1255212426,
-0.4534792304,
-0.4162079394,
-0.4951810539,
-0.2690411806,
-0.518684566,
-0.030401418,
-0.1529246867,
-0.2378780842,
-0.3836197257,
-0.215935722,
0.4754648805,
0.8546150923,
-0.1300490797,
0.1743682921,
-0.9322782159,
0.2681337893,
0.4332739413,
0.3523303866,
-0.0373783633,
-0.4358303845,
0.2686435878,
0.0723955855,
-0.5301696658,
-0.9798797965,
0.2665805221,
-0.2853186429,
0.3989906907,
0.2498228997,
0.4130635262,
0.5173828006,
-0.6584345698,
0.568154335,
0.2493766248,
-0.8912146688,
0.7945401073,
-0.659747541,
-0.1102311611,
0.7391267419,
0.5718423128,
-0.4405050278,
-0.5597519279,
-0.3607376516,
-0.8181610703,
0.6794548035,
0.2845834792,
0.0599617958,
0.1982024461,
0.3188324571,
0.2947722375,
0.0500083491,
-1.0569814444,
-0.2271724045,
-0.0053048963,
-0.2029498816,
0.1044349298,
-0.2200607359,
-0.3707234561,
0.0695269108,
0.7304486036,
-0.0912805647,
-0.3950046897,
0.2267558575,
0.0077676177,
-0.0421230718,
0.4414391518,
0.746565938,
0.453302592,
-0.0832823068,
0.0748046264,
0.2336069047,
-0.3627528548,
0.7175099254,
-0.2253174484,
-0.3687539697,
-0.2567031682,
0.0803801194,
0.5677776337,
-0.2887524962,
-0.3059811592,
0.2584828138,
-0.2202689648,
-0.4015333951,
-0.0302886106,
0.2940998673,
-0.1331153661,
0.2747862637,
0.0660643354,
-0.365097791,
0.1478158683,
-0.5308619738,
0.2127090245,
0.4398605227,
-0.3845896721,
0.0279086791,
0.7950424552,
0.2811481953,
-0.2152358443,
0.5467507243,
0.0399613045,
-0.1720201522,
0.2795630097,
0.6161759496,
0.9316290617,
-0.4348445237,
0.2828343213,
0.2566066682,
0.3659155369,
-0.2877223492,
0.2241614014,
0.0296475645,
-0.5233306289,
-0.2570661902,
-0.6360753179,
-0.5065194964,
0.1453203857,
-0.7147213817,
0.2604301572,
-0.7093470693,
-0.2421027869,
-0.2500917315,
-0.3061097562,
-0.1129862517,
-0.1348376423,
0.2021875679,
0.7526569366,
-1.0954698324,
0.7601917386,
0.4024825692,
-0.3827731311,
-0.8619118333,
-0.0141535765,
0.4344878197,
-0.6676402092,
0.5200917125,
-0.0987728238,
0.088020429,
-0.1389700174,
-0.540484786,
-0.7672252655,
1.0775142908,
0.4035556614,
-1.0747979879,
-0.0358899422,
0.3471556604,
0.3690679371,
-0.0029799908,
0.0989534333,
0.7616001964,
0.6141383052,
0.1471132934,
-0.8749192357,
0.398370713,
0.1271661967,
0.1959792525,
0.2193414867,
-0.9258880019,
0.5670534372,
-0.186223194,
-0.1774015874,
0.1364662349,
0.7200114131,
0.5762445331,
0.1864504963,
0.5269720554,
0.5803929567,
0.840726018,
-0.0485020317,
0.6736424565,
0.2664614618,
0.0444829687,
1.2773596048,
-0.6572903395,
0.6492400169,
0.737799108,
-0.1022348404,
0.5642623305,
0.8434196115,
0.0767901763,
0.746817708,
0.4624884725,
0.0138302967,
-0.2488081306,
0.1443979442,
-0.3018660247,
0.30325526,
0.2634177804,
-0.3244530261,
-0.301491946,
-0.0097943144,
-0.0963803902,
0.1215508357,
-0.1453635693,
1.0356734991,
0.4211408198,
-0.8053095937,
0.5662629604,
-0.0710001737,
0.7132683992,
-0.5189725161,
0.0993298963,
-0.0161989704,
0.0095072454,
-0.3268322945,
-0.7943282723,
0.2455725968,
0.0326953642,
-0.1885675639,
-0.5981746316,
0.6981242299,
-0.3073093295,
-0.2795719802,
0.3384072483,
0.241724655,
-0.1739799529,
0.0903629065,
-0.8318225145,
0.0592531562,
-0.0090149809,
-0.3745601177,
0.535652101,
0.6045316458,
-0.2635700405,
0.5635924935,
0.7515046,
0.0839225203,
0.053761296,
-0.0017484362,
0.7461508512,
-0.5461677909,
-0.5019053817,
-1.4917215109,
0.4138505459,
0.067407988,
0.0045961589,
0.7659144998,
0.1335518807,
0.9194145203,
0.0726860687,
1.0255662203,
0.1888386458,
0.2445656508,
-0.855881393,
0.8528982997,
-0.2928543687,
0.4170973301,
-0.4242170453,
-0.8433784842,
-0.0271537639,
0.3159477413,
-0.0570500009,
0.0446907468,
0.4937492311,
0.7255117297,
0.1112580299,
-0.1492161304,
0.250185281,
0.0786803141,
0.5706358552,
0.6833142042,
1.1190626621,
-0.3158952594,
0.5702481866,
0.0512828343,
-0.1312353462,
-0.1767455637,
-1.1900956631,
-1.0803328753,
-0.5269594789,
-0.2428177297,
-0.6613618135,
-0.0074716145,
0.830254674,
0.510805428,
-0.8009787798,
-0.1513250619,
-0.1596230119,
0.2002871335,
-0.2864868045,
-0.0931116715,
0.0098173274,
-0.3159536719,
-0.6048187613,
0.3530529439,
0.3347031474,
0.6205385923,
-0.2076932043,
-0.1697672606,
-0.1013099998,
0.1500840932,
0.2326459587,
0.4190561473,
-0.7811942697,
-0.2887935936,
-0.1677208394,
-0.3935729563,
-0.0094741434,
0.849435389,
-0.5312990546,
0.2641244829,
0.6924592257,
0.5443981886,
0.012445299,
0.160152331,
0.8704309464,
-0.7290716171,
-0.020201385,
-0.0033996652,
0.284013927,
0.000590193,
-0.654276073,
0.3721233904,
-0.0612782836,
-0.6862660646,
-0.8152217269,
0.5617266893,
-0.6066424251,
-0.3289811313,
1.1313129663,
-0.0395650789,
-0.3672253788,
-0.2456590086,
-0.4077715874,
0.1442997903,
-0.3117918372,
0.8525279164,
1.0491043329,
-0.0991219059,
0.0216840934,
-0.2950645983,
0.7981714606,
0.5462244153,
-0.6911458969,
0.4820483625,
0.3979635239,
0.5400506258,
-0.0164440889,
0.6577362418,
-0.2714010179,
0.0997007489,
-0.4843992889,
-0.2151737958,
-0.171860829,
-0.4023965001,
-0.5957608223,
-0.1002800316,
0.3626765907,
-0.0389335826
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11278v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11278v1 | Do Not Design, Learn: A Trainable Scoring Function for Uncertainty Estimation in Generative LLMs | 2024-06-17T07:30:40 | 2024-06-17T07:30:40 | Duygu Nur Yaldiz, Yavuz Faruk Bakman, Baturalp Buyukates, Chenyang Tao, Anil Ramakrishna, Dimitrios Dimitriadis, Salman Avestimehr | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this work, we introduce the Learnable Response Scoring Function (LARS) for
Uncertainty Estimation (UE) in generative Large Language Models (LLMs). Current
scoring functions for probability-based UE, such as length-normalized scoring
and semantic contribution-based weighting, are designed to solve specific
aspects of the problem but exhibit limitations, including the inability to
handle biased probabilities and under-performance in low-resource languages
like Turkish. To address these issues, we propose LARS, a scoring function that
leverages supervised data to capture complex dependencies between tokens and
probabilities, thereby producing more reliable and calibrated response scores
in computing the uncertainty of generations. Our extensive experiments across
multiple datasets show that LARS substantially outperforms existing scoring
functions considering various probability-based UE methods. | [
-0.4179138839,
-0.6524320841,
0.6525469422,
0.2639382482,
-0.3320170343,
0.021705348,
-0.2815877199,
-0.2406140417,
0.1356334537,
0.122479327,
-0.5755642653,
-0.708344996,
-0.5774453878,
-0.1466776431,
-0.1332042217,
0.7541136146,
-0.0502355471,
0.2095987052,
-0.3245388865,
0.1709367037,
-0.0228886232,
-0.1698327363,
-0.7602016926,
-0.0346722603,
0.7872672677,
0.4669105113,
0.389795661,
0.3378323913,
0.5365614891,
0.2082325518,
-0.1048008129,
-0.0368202813,
-0.3289144933,
0.5429350138,
-0.1230731905,
-0.7208487391,
-0.5213453174,
-0.2365913242,
0.7306980491,
0.7978647351,
-0.2642306983,
0.4580738842,
0.2699968219,
0.7430944443,
-0.8030942678,
0.3720485568,
-0.5968536735,
0.2721262872,
-0.125932917,
-0.1450370252,
-0.6164556742,
-0.3493421376,
-0.0646529868,
-0.6346195936,
0.2548952401,
-0.0001571977,
0.3464069068,
0.3089540303,
-0.2032956034,
-0.2006156743,
-0.7912047505,
1.1877653599,
-0.6317068338,
0.2878429592,
0.5934453011,
0.3686585426,
-0.4182206392,
-0.5214092731,
-0.3313353062,
-0.1015809625,
0.3334324658,
0.1255467534,
0.0430635251,
0.2831128836,
0.1907414794,
0.1718159467,
-0.5874251723,
0.2906830907,
-0.3511460423,
-0.1942678988,
0.9555399418,
0.2277414203,
-0.1578884125,
-0.1341674328,
-0.5277621746,
-0.3511203229,
-0.701734364,
0.1403580457,
0.789524734,
0.6499655843,
-0.0863527954,
0.4970131814,
-0.1717465371,
0.8367314339,
-0.0024430368,
-0.0777771398,
0.161401853,
0.2912837565,
-0.3603814244,
-0.371539861,
0.9414129257,
0.1094437391,
0.2652412057,
-0.1227078363,
-0.352848947,
-0.3241772652,
0.4394888878,
-0.3787456155,
-0.4415473938,
0.3374807835,
-0.3345647454,
-0.5048847795,
0.0056967787,
-1.1706402302,
-0.4760350883,
0.0142650148,
0.2962473929,
-0.4893344641,
-0.0927079618,
-0.2316763699,
-0.0109665347,
0.2903410792,
0.335781455,
-0.8596568108,
0.1479573101,
0.2231552899,
0.4076315761,
-0.1458616406,
-0.0535268188,
-0.5771924853,
-0.0810258016,
-0.7632048726,
0.6334761977,
-0.5159269571,
-0.61423558,
0.0287062544,
-0.4453760386,
-0.215488255,
-0.3014327586,
0.9151245356,
-0.7188767791,
0.3303052485,
-0.2908245921,
-0.6199604869,
-0.3780319095,
-0.0177159999,
-0.5576431155,
0.9214084148,
0.5539898872,
-0.7138667107,
0.8000819683,
-0.6291265488,
-0.3949041665,
0.418038547,
-0.1460663974,
-0.520401895,
0.2964917719,
0.0942033306,
0.7236644626,
-0.0927515551,
0.1373320222,
-0.8850021362,
-0.4037540257,
0.2558271587,
-0.8532927632,
0.6025927663,
0.4401031733,
0.0306804441,
0.1484514326,
-0.8373042345,
0.5811577439,
-0.0834114105,
-0.8312162161,
-0.04247123,
0.3990653753,
0.2395219654,
0.1801563352,
0.1096487045,
-0.6327206492,
-0.1221254617,
-0.1687696576,
-0.0071808463,
0.8847810626,
-0.1264295131,
0.2969256043,
-0.4088187516,
0.7984668016,
-0.0039216187,
0.124992989,
0.3546334207,
-0.3993259966,
-0.6239487529,
-0.6391843557,
0.7445748448,
0.4911194742,
-0.8714513779,
0.6627337337,
-0.3249940574,
-0.4228683114,
-0.7077813745,
0.3728507161,
0.3328041732,
0.255777508,
0.3063060939,
-0.3833166063,
-0.705123961,
-0.7382062674,
-0.262765646,
-0.6089317799,
-0.4822320342,
0.2022133321,
0.1914290339,
0.3408841789,
0.8503036499,
-0.4850788414,
-0.3990421593,
-0.3898128867,
0.228264913,
0.1390211284,
0.3543093204,
0.5690748096,
-0.7962053418,
-0.4932344258,
-0.2199391723,
-0.8487615585,
0.119568035,
0.1027797833,
0.4555599391,
0.4548821449,
0.3586568534,
-0.6712352633,
0.2789633274,
0.5482234955,
-0.1854132414,
0.4712114632,
-0.2210249454,
0.2382717282,
-1.0551888943,
0.0718838349,
0.1803343147,
-0.2488378584,
-0.3452090025,
0.1835384816,
0.0250275694,
0.4266886711,
-0.514895618,
0.30847314,
-0.3013106287,
0.022990549,
0.1244026646,
-0.3252413273,
-0.3217815757,
0.4163798392,
-0.0679142848,
0.7097776532,
0.4457885921,
-0.6857218742,
0.2720203698,
0.0615461618,
-0.8189789653,
0.8418500423,
-0.3935680091,
0.0165823195,
-0.4174225926,
-0.0455151275,
-1.0165170431,
-0.5631222725,
0.2722831368,
-0.7773070931,
0.7990680337,
-0.4302725792,
-0.4502629638,
-0.4172308445,
-0.4236947,
0.1154117584,
0.5680090785,
-0.3801395297,
0.5511320233,
0.1957801878,
-0.3493020833,
-0.8225314617,
-0.5760897994,
-0.056334842,
-0.5581177473,
-0.4421764016,
0.018573584,
-0.1620821655,
-0.1893860251,
-0.0868978128,
-0.0483311936,
-0.0894369185,
0.487115413,
0.2070189118,
0.1661716849,
-0.2310340554,
0.4003881216,
0.1034779772,
0.0185333192,
0.1373452544,
-0.1500273794,
0.5318885446,
0.2806785405,
-0.4402150214,
-0.1000099182,
0.4182154536,
0.44166857,
0.1686034054,
0.8267077208,
0.5931434035,
-0.3420965374,
-0.7514560819,
-0.251986891,
0.0376672149,
-0.4592789114,
0.6976795793,
-0.567184031,
-0.847055316,
0.4457707107,
0.2006005198,
0.0492277108,
0.5903924108,
0.5823010206,
-0.8695389032,
0.8812689185,
0.5490138531,
0.0155210169,
0.3900284469,
0.1054159552,
0.1340938061,
-0.7685598731,
-0.2343171239,
-0.3874838054,
-0.3576736748,
-0.6961829066,
-0.3976495564,
0.4489761889,
0.2462115139,
-0.2654027045,
0.1355833113,
-0.0744750723,
0.2951755524,
0.5365778804,
-0.1325618178,
-0.0719594881,
0.1172721833,
-0.1520911008,
-0.06032864,
-0.6961644888,
-0.3244853616,
1.5540452003,
0.483491689,
1.1012772322,
0.2625189126,
0.8890868425,
0.6554540396,
0.3912653923,
-0.7975333929,
0.3846192956,
-0.1225096509,
-0.6511914134,
-0.7487164736,
-0.8678799868,
-0.8510597944,
0.2842708826,
-0.1632899046,
-0.9565733075,
0.0891475379,
0.0983625576,
-0.4435565174,
0.4731026888,
-0.7482257485,
0.3318204582,
0.1081892699,
-0.2612114251,
0.1536171883,
-0.5674569011,
0.2816967368,
-0.3649278581,
0.363268137,
-0.1352134198,
0.1873589307,
0.9090634584,
0.0491904691,
1.0659093857,
-0.4094483256,
-0.2501274347,
0.2138177603,
0.2678491771,
0.3658332527,
0.0111739738,
-0.3187313974,
-0.1384209991,
0.1401921809,
-0.5166256428,
-0.5216174722,
0.7685006857,
-0.5643143058,
-0.6041430235,
-0.3821128309,
-0.5165864825,
-0.4505552649,
0.0624375045,
0.4899151921,
-0.1808508039,
-0.4417466223,
0.063445732,
0.7760847211,
0.0327277482,
0.6250839829,
0.3791031539,
0.0244190414,
-0.6373411417,
0.9551022053,
0.3078796566,
0.2752101421,
0.3313988745,
-0.2018620521,
-0.4767444432,
-0.5074025393,
-0.5911024213,
-0.1539263576,
-0.751991272,
-0.4288649857,
-0.0958765075,
-0.2133911252,
-0.2307899594,
-0.1442453712,
-0.1812255085,
-0.5784102678,
-0.2865310013,
-0.4171393514,
0.1222322732,
0.8047165275,
-0.2261193693,
0.334025085,
-0.5412889719,
-0.0864806548,
0.2043271959,
0.7777842879,
-0.2136951238,
-0.6409715414,
-0.011050879,
0.0690291896,
-0.4117944539,
-0.6070680618,
0.2594352365,
0.3878733814,
0.7789780498,
0.4201415181,
0.4129860997,
0.151738286,
-0.1207301766,
0.6684320569,
0.1630997211,
-0.7863232493,
0.2894365788,
-0.3846224546,
-0.0789959356,
0.5292416215,
0.3980330527,
-0.2243075073,
-0.0877660215,
-0.5103578568,
-1.0218645334,
0.7565834522,
0.0735453293,
0.4103024602,
0.1592106074,
0.2809916735,
0.118814528,
0.2050335854,
-0.5945448875,
-0.2831731737,
0.2934542596,
-0.6252074838,
-0.3748522401,
-0.5373799801,
-0.1676983386,
-0.1064526811,
0.7823441625,
-0.3100044131,
0.2234471142,
-0.1130904108,
-0.1131609157,
-0.5962911844,
0.4470305741,
0.4989488423,
0.4033131003,
-0.4782426357,
0.0949432179,
0.3554383218,
-0.4132499397,
0.1712273359,
0.1554455906,
-0.1816657484,
-0.2149911821,
0.739379406,
0.7202944756,
0.0470104031,
-0.4994679689,
0.5406455398,
-0.0045868191,
-0.4819248319,
-0.5727484822,
0.1785551459,
0.0343725123,
0.134054929,
0.2945432365,
0.0900283083,
0.0145979235,
-0.0778737068,
0.3507883549,
0.4264926612,
-0.8786323071,
-0.3365653157,
0.691178441,
0.0265770927,
-0.1639893651,
0.6420251727,
-0.2603290379,
-0.2347227484,
0.444341898,
0.4083484113,
0.8698220849,
-0.5556195974,
0.7227503061,
0.2348701805,
0.2575548887,
0.1494316608,
0.7746909261,
-0.2079022974,
-0.7326557636,
-0.5369363427,
-1.1073098183,
-0.1792790294,
0.0188943632,
-0.9234083295,
0.0116098868,
-0.4972979724,
-0.3599310815,
-0.1460482776,
-0.0918599218,
-0.7263854146,
0.5907579064,
0.2633625269,
0.9466800094,
-1.0028949976,
0.6678299308,
0.7176460624,
-0.3601479232,
-0.5619932413,
0.0487696677,
-0.1154530123,
-0.6947716475,
0.6244439483,
-0.3042607903,
-0.0166059509,
-0.0331130177,
-0.682933867,
-0.8951351643,
0.856374681,
0.503287077,
-0.2814262211,
0.0476191901,
0.2824333608,
0.5869363546,
-0.0730983019,
0.1825496852,
0.4077658653,
0.3840943277,
0.1586314887,
-0.5375918746,
-0.1935013533,
0.0062471675,
0.0400336795,
0.4020599127,
-0.3996555209,
0.6027702689,
-0.4351788759,
-0.1922846437,
0.2161479145,
0.6774999499,
0.0665811971,
0.0907800719,
0.4319416583,
0.7764971256,
0.785359621,
-0.1287407577,
1.0598702431,
-0.0029908649,
0.6677199602,
0.9837704301,
-0.1427764297,
1.1793197393,
0.7153533697,
-0.7542054057,
0.3617523611,
0.7728821635,
0.0680627078,
0.6302764416,
0.705520153,
-0.557893455,
-0.7215998173,
0.2338578999,
0.0404063277,
0.5439628959,
0.5996304154,
-0.5387014747,
-0.1750939488,
-0.409986943,
-0.0068473206,
-0.0156266261,
-0.0136525873,
0.8001598716,
0.3651922047,
-0.4662677348,
0.4513497353,
0.071606636,
0.3871263266,
-0.7586856484,
0.0196729172,
-0.0175148882,
0.2090826482,
-0.207960248,
-1.1136639118,
0.2170701176,
-0.1839728206,
-0.2996269763,
0.154055655,
0.2640403211,
-0.3504878879,
-0.7211638093,
0.4194095731,
0.4742990732,
0.0221293829,
0.1848601103,
-0.3194363713,
-0.1358963847,
-0.0675169379,
-0.4390569329,
0.5488608479,
0.1291318387,
-0.0540398322,
1.0267182589,
0.5759954453,
0.0032997506,
-0.059235137,
-0.2550512254,
0.4712902308,
-0.3642950654,
-0.0990068763,
-0.664781034,
0.5250359178,
0.075704515,
-0.5562705994,
0.4094461501,
0.3562254012,
0.9422679543,
-0.4036912322,
1.0886586905,
-0.233410731,
0.5875225663,
-0.5905034542,
0.8828004599,
-0.4770810902,
0.3693833947,
-0.2051848918,
-1.0483244658,
-0.6810988784,
0.5383576751,
-0.3273165226,
0.3909698725,
0.2105755508,
0.516548872,
0.0942885801,
-0.1760509908,
0.8733558655,
0.0793903023,
0.2144234478,
0.6944742203,
0.7859513164,
-0.278316617,
0.2329877019,
-0.1581929326,
-0.2755831182,
-0.0210140739,
-0.7754357457,
-0.7847301364,
-0.7330089211,
-0.1573428214,
-0.2627464533,
0.1429159939,
1.0476644039,
0.5812366009,
-1.2316043377,
-0.0680545941,
0.1819446236,
0.2308510095,
-0.2377052307,
-0.2325189859,
0.6281663775,
-0.6814095378,
-0.6793029308,
0.4686469734,
-0.0035132836,
0.0052700271,
-0.1780127734,
-0.1447772533,
0.1469060928,
0.2024878263,
0.3563764989,
0.3043477237,
-0.5585921407,
-0.4976917505,
-0.2675640285,
0.0343623906,
-0.1024561748,
0.2569600642,
-0.5281838775,
0.5060226917,
0.4871099889,
0.3945847452,
0.2296994776,
-0.1622266918,
0.8589897156,
-0.9197681546,
-0.3917794824,
0.3228539824,
0.4282293022,
0.514285624,
-0.3157404363,
0.3585963249,
0.1288743764,
-0.2982598245,
-0.7119205594,
0.5063170195,
-0.8036233783,
-0.0897017568,
1.0837585926,
-0.5955657959,
-0.0533104241,
-0.3051629961,
0.1497943401,
0.0604884736,
-0.2611524463,
0.9726495147,
0.7172157764,
0.1400064528,
-0.0879161134,
-0.4164847434,
0.6999765635,
0.3774284124,
-0.4550389349,
-0.0472465418,
0.1862403005,
0.6797736287,
-0.1154467836,
0.3239873648,
-0.0894102827,
0.2826337814,
0.1164192036,
0.2671673596,
0.1271003932,
-0.4663202763,
-0.4437393546,
0.5239664316,
0.5296239853,
-0.3843701482
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11277v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11277v1 | Small Agent Can Also Rock! Empowering Small Language Models as Hallucination Detector | 2024-06-17T07:30:05 | 2024-06-17T07:30:05 | Xiaoxue Cheng, Junyi Li, Wayne Xin Zhao, Hongzhi Zhang, Fuzheng Zhang, Di Zhang, Kun Gai, Ji-Rong Wen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Hallucination detection is a challenging task for large language models
(LLMs), and existing studies heavily rely on powerful closed-source LLMs such
as GPT-4. In this paper, we propose an autonomous LLM-based agent framework,
called HaluAgent, which enables relatively smaller LLMs (e.g. Baichuan2-Chat
7B) to actively select suitable tools for detecting multiple hallucination
types such as text, code, and mathematical expression. In HaluAgent, we
integrate the LLM, multi-functional toolbox, and design a fine-grained
three-stage detection framework along with memory mechanism. To facilitate the
effectiveness of HaluAgent, we leverage existing Chinese and English datasets
to synthesize detection trajectories for fine-tuning, which endows HaluAgent
with the capability for bilingual hallucination detection. Extensive
experiments demonstrate that only using 2K samples for tuning LLMs, HaluAgent
can perform hallucination detection on various types of tasks and datasets,
achieving performance comparable to or even higher than GPT-4 without tool
enhancements on both in-domain and out-of-domain datasets. We release our
dataset and code at https://github.com/RUCAIBox/HaluAgent. | [
-0.4114121497,
-0.8540773392,
0.7427718639,
0.2272192091,
-0.1738254875,
-0.2257107645,
-0.5215839744,
-0.5639721155,
0.3902721405,
0.5120628476,
-0.4813485444,
-0.5284742117,
-0.3424887061,
0.281198591,
-0.2668715715,
0.716573894,
0.1368624419,
-0.0334576704,
0.2080079615,
-0.2648637295,
-0.7014359832,
-0.2573209703,
-0.8866141438,
-0.7056375146,
0.4967544079,
0.4715622067,
0.8436155915,
0.6044587493,
0.0199211277,
0.2759419084,
0.3314418495,
0.3779001236,
-0.3502817154,
0.0691372454,
0.0973789394,
-0.5387336612,
-0.6463455558,
-0.3289459944,
0.3256641924,
0.4376649857,
-0.1565527469,
-0.1287512481,
0.1967357397,
0.3989273012,
-0.3329284191,
0.4127750993,
-0.7694494128,
0.0308143906,
-0.3466809094,
-0.057646133,
-0.4417346716,
-0.2266253233,
-0.4768966138,
-0.2970491052,
0.3042708337,
0.1012161896,
0.4085062444,
0.6431868672,
-0.2543437779,
-0.6413370967,
-0.5752170086,
0.7020171881,
-0.7174195647,
0.4247189462,
0.6379273534,
0.4212717116,
-0.2279144228,
-0.577009201,
-0.6953756213,
-0.4254272878,
-0.3441279531,
-0.2940399051,
-0.1191924512,
-0.0218089931,
0.0128054721,
0.365963608,
-0.8991671801,
0.2426356375,
0.0735661313,
-0.4334945083,
0.3064098954,
0.1265498251,
0.2930636108,
-0.2444615364,
0.2028391808,
0.0488734022,
-0.6435325146,
-0.380756706,
0.1389636546,
0.6663877368,
0.0228921175,
0.3101043403,
0.0318019949,
0.3046104908,
-0.0841370299,
-0.1379233152,
0.2523221672,
0.0239558071,
-0.1138895527,
0.3902650177,
0.8629465699,
-0.2382740676,
0.0723273531,
-0.1756213456,
-0.6288902164,
0.0797017887,
0.068410717,
-0.8630200624,
-0.4867667258,
0.2420230806,
-0.5333474278,
-0.2092353851,
-0.0496156253,
-0.6010630131,
-0.6870154142,
-0.1560251862,
0.5623435974,
-0.3295338154,
-0.4164226651,
0.1565918773,
0.3310376704,
0.1127889678,
0.0480145551,
-1.0187194347,
0.3499144912,
0.7391908765,
1.0517997742,
-0.3346759975,
-0.530354917,
-0.8542181253,
0.049474176,
-0.5563284755,
0.8490397334,
-0.2307327837,
-0.3938341737,
0.1020085961,
0.3668168783,
0.0432810113,
-0.8355586529,
0.3967768252,
-0.1580973417,
-0.0394959301,
-0.110091202,
-0.0721532255,
-0.2854341865,
0.0980745554,
-1.0976877213,
1.006809473,
0.0025792869,
-0.2800922394,
0.1938782334,
-0.5317661762,
-0.6320747137,
0.2385444939,
-0.5826575756,
-0.4917966723,
0.1700667292,
0.2062440813,
0.3981537819,
-0.1951299608,
0.2120734155,
-0.2921205461,
-0.6692880392,
0.1141513586,
-0.4332149327,
0.4733573198,
-0.0732134432,
-0.81139642,
0.3225589097,
-0.5739454627,
-0.351443857,
0.1210663617,
-0.1354245991,
-0.1116287485,
-0.0140551794,
-0.0494729616,
0.1186898053,
0.1923592091,
-0.1745912582,
0.0120983142,
-0.3650613129,
0.1758007705,
0.7038031816,
-0.0732954368,
0.3912371695,
-0.5229148865,
0.5586149096,
-0.2512250841,
0.003611068,
0.3571787477,
-0.5263889432,
-0.9788244963,
-0.4444260299,
-0.0675673261,
0.2417395264,
-1.0465140343,
0.5054249763,
-0.2298859656,
-0.3968518674,
-0.6218748689,
0.3536684811,
0.2805041075,
0.055363372,
0.3522726595,
0.1598282903,
-0.4118418694,
-0.8517817259,
-0.0648868829,
-0.2146827132,
-0.1420975029,
0.2654378414,
0.669739902,
-0.5166026354,
0.615714252,
-0.2659955025,
-1.0893757343,
-0.3230219781,
0.1755540967,
0.3370729089,
0.2767390311,
0.4134266376,
-0.5798431635,
-0.4672278166,
0.4286401272,
-0.9362401366,
-0.2993724346,
-0.1942673922,
0.0003619663,
0.5368443727,
0.4904818237,
-0.6354045868,
0.3242597878,
0.4100750685,
-0.1153429225,
0.4718978405,
-0.0762435719,
0.0535939597,
-0.7487639189,
-0.1785049736,
-0.4174306989,
-0.4610838294,
-0.7294986844,
-0.0122915916,
0.0161174387,
0.2116846293,
-0.3663800061,
0.5851503611,
-0.5558709502,
-0.2199664861,
-0.8468171358,
0.2017334551,
-0.3605622947,
0.5178082585,
0.2055063695,
0.7017769814,
0.4960883856,
-0.607062459,
0.2990909219,
0.1377616227,
-0.1542848945,
0.0325043797,
-0.4257978797,
0.286652863,
0.2440384924,
0.1650950313,
-0.4708257318,
-0.352978766,
0.6327853799,
-0.4068223238,
0.0045033763,
-0.0466706343,
-0.8932265639,
-0.1770265549,
-0.3369126916,
0.3324741721,
0.4381532371,
-0.9321498275,
1.0481803417,
0.2511221468,
0.0069194138,
-0.2936970592,
-1.0261600018,
0.0850686431,
-0.2789949477,
-0.4616159499,
0.1211763173,
-0.2614628673,
-0.1893295348,
-0.0431212448,
-0.1593771279,
0.1862790585,
0.0539812744,
0.4224429131,
-0.0084047914,
-0.316089958,
0.2845061123,
0.2442895323,
-0.1870530546,
0.0076220366,
-0.3585547805,
0.9907191992,
-0.650147438,
-0.4291340113,
-0.1934099942,
0.2427483648,
0.3952578306,
0.2001378089,
0.5179885626,
0.8208137155,
-0.8896656036,
-0.707356751,
-0.4187901318,
-0.6327587366,
-0.5716106296,
0.0860585347,
-0.7253876925,
-0.9325921535,
0.5293774605,
0.3881943226,
-0.2101457417,
0.2143225372,
1.1866070032,
0.6056061983,
1.0126321316,
0.547370255,
-0.2151611149,
0.0887559429,
0.0292421374,
0.3182401359,
-0.329995662,
0.0844403133,
-0.2344652414,
-0.0350023024,
-0.5313844681,
-0.4858284891,
0.3716477156,
-0.2088734806,
0.0839773118,
0.3306979537,
-0.7032388449,
0.5538065434,
0.1557990313,
0.0008476093,
0.5047181845,
-0.0952158198,
0.108327575,
0.0987089649,
-0.4652584791,
-0.6131634712,
0.6852450371,
0.3893209994,
0.7387519479,
0.3899154663,
0.9804419279,
0.4960683882,
0.376550138,
-1.008907795,
0.799904108,
-0.1040865928,
-0.5846801996,
-0.4190795422,
-0.3443437517,
-1.010584712,
0.5292852521,
0.0216933563,
-0.6669209003,
0.2623867691,
-0.0680455193,
-0.3253766894,
0.1712188721,
-0.3486520052,
0.7307358384,
-0.1392218322,
-0.2631686628,
-0.2366655022,
-0.2061215788,
0.6005270481,
-0.4265927076,
0.4809222519,
-0.1481618881,
0.0395461954,
0.5883371234,
-0.3586438298,
1.009447217,
-0.1727653891,
-0.3352718055,
0.2597915828,
0.4894412458,
0.4854344428,
0.2705440521,
0.1225618795,
0.2526842356,
-0.0866998583,
-0.1858727932,
-0.5062221885,
1.0526298285,
-0.5578648448,
-0.5964736342,
-0.4875626266,
-0.6100804806,
0.1227399632,
0.3957735896,
0.1883489937,
0.0900604129,
-0.012671602,
0.093971543,
0.4689338505,
0.1369018704,
0.5529223084,
0.4992977381,
-0.6345704794,
-0.2081280947,
1.3909986019,
-0.1900487691,
-0.1044229046,
0.0671657994,
0.3580657244,
-0.1731816381,
-0.5859892964,
-0.2627284527,
0.5701661706,
-0.8659598231,
-0.1701454967,
-0.7146376967,
-0.2044403553,
-0.5706053972,
0.0039417399,
-0.4575004876,
-0.0160009135,
-0.3612369001,
-0.0024526548,
0.2860031426,
0.690277338,
-0.470389694,
0.3823416829,
-0.5505834222,
0.664137125,
0.3687157333,
-0.0020759385,
-0.0125747994,
-0.4359595776,
-0.4196389616,
-0.151285857,
-0.0012208059,
-0.6911126375,
0.626742363,
0.1431159228,
0.5209930539,
0.6343235373,
0.0530715957,
0.411575377,
-0.3248290718,
0.7455911636,
-0.2016682178,
-1.033408165,
0.3164480925,
-0.1910517514,
-0.0601184703,
0.6114743352,
0.1949740946,
-0.3494272828,
-0.5699583292,
-0.1112716049,
-0.4016018808,
0.6587172151,
0.3639232516,
-0.2280606031,
0.0019361118,
0.1803598404,
0.5345178246,
0.1388243586,
-1.2049356699,
0.0363282189,
-0.1591127813,
-0.2334344238,
-0.1115790233,
0.126438424,
-0.1856535524,
-0.0676068142,
0.8137119412,
-0.5009405613,
0.2611491382,
-0.0219040923,
-0.497717768,
-0.0440846682,
0.0324459635,
0.5102903247,
0.1812224835,
-0.2424152195,
0.4375953972,
0.193207413,
-0.5014898181,
0.111015819,
0.1920302063,
-0.0376839414,
0.1970537156,
0.5163419843,
0.6109166741,
0.043587245,
-0.6956339478,
0.5162038803,
-0.2044959217,
-0.2450509369,
-0.6916826963,
0.1513095051,
-0.1015001535,
0.5652144551,
0.3115434945,
-0.259177804,
0.4143739641,
-0.4745430648,
0.3298842013,
0.2940886319,
-0.3846293986,
-0.4151398242,
0.7320530415,
-0.1492867768,
-0.5289981961,
0.2739575207,
-0.6180454493,
-0.5379000902,
0.371171087,
0.5078194737,
1.0589563847,
-0.2940735519,
0.2247904241,
-0.0957019702,
0.6576547623,
-0.2692419887,
0.180821076,
-0.0290435292,
-0.9252249599,
-0.0376223624,
-0.5026180744,
-0.2002988607,
0.3760883808,
-0.4362281263,
0.3275664747,
-0.3493920863,
0.0327095501,
-0.1410090476,
-0.0095895352,
-0.5150971413,
-0.2254738659,
0.3778332174,
0.3560310602,
-0.8864510655,
1.1736694574,
0.397668153,
-0.4676413834,
-0.4020813107,
0.294994235,
0.2961294651,
-0.9173682928,
0.3305934072,
0.604642272,
-0.498077184,
-0.0239738505,
-0.3295405805,
-0.3365441859,
1.2604823112,
0.057603199,
-0.385174334,
-0.054408107,
0.1952160895,
0.5027196407,
-0.6334413886,
-0.0152504034,
1.168189764,
0.6161115766,
-0.1874220967,
-0.670150578,
0.3540572524,
-0.1116897687,
-0.1630361825,
0.0828100815,
-0.5544813275,
0.8855483532,
0.0967377797,
-0.3270272613,
0.3048851192,
0.8033165932,
0.5927286744,
0.4910025895,
0.8420613408,
0.1629730314,
0.7766485214,
0.0734764785,
0.7294409275,
-0.3788943589,
0.1136605516,
1.1234221458,
-0.3639229834,
0.5980377197,
0.3450235426,
0.1904547662,
0.5290413499,
0.6967573762,
-0.198180601,
0.5207488537,
-0.0081762644,
-0.4970384836,
-0.3163224459,
-0.1217176765,
-0.1970330626,
0.2802472413,
0.6116597056,
0.0336959325,
-0.1324559897,
0.5449740887,
0.0368746407,
0.0078022741,
-0.1059696227,
0.5529891253,
0.3368791342,
-0.469774127,
0.7911012173,
-0.044044055,
0.7583037019,
-0.3716064394,
-0.0370519757,
-0.399099946,
0.3954242468,
-0.2860451043,
-0.3786714077,
0.1834830493,
-0.300999999,
0.0626430139,
0.141335696,
0.9064318538,
-0.4737147391,
-0.2302065045,
0.7132762074,
0.6596474648,
0.5853565931,
-0.3603399992,
-0.4738499224,
0.2672860026,
-0.0991379172,
-0.1204144061,
0.1703236401,
0.5625662804,
-0.1488931626,
0.6377757192,
0.5301003456,
0.181650281,
-0.0155842686,
0.5058615804,
0.7887251377,
-0.5060566068,
-0.3188968003,
-0.8439139724,
0.0150442747,
0.0982712954,
0.1358784139,
0.7570249438,
0.5439350009,
0.5846847296,
-0.1911595315,
0.6841603518,
0.0401433781,
0.3386895955,
-0.5410264134,
0.9517083764,
-0.7009994984,
0.3732736111,
0.1238457114,
-0.9213563204,
-0.3932264745,
0.6436033845,
-0.1512130201,
0.0979891941,
0.9650073647,
1.3779139519,
0.0173133872,
-0.0100938343,
0.6573542953,
0.4086247981,
0.5954959989,
0.6038800478,
0.8820261955,
-0.2092478573,
0.6549822092,
-0.236155957,
-0.3667760789,
-0.3397195339,
-0.4786499143,
-1.4117581844,
-0.6399869919,
-0.0836856067,
-0.4457091093,
-0.1905219704,
0.8897992373,
0.6067242026,
-0.8604699373,
-0.4071842134,
-0.2090224922,
0.1981256753,
-0.274571538,
-0.2844952643,
0.4413916171,
-0.3906575143,
-0.7797273993,
0.8055202961,
0.2190596461,
0.0455934666,
-0.5297853947,
-0.3336834013,
0.2126436085,
0.0418922901,
0.5986304879,
0.2218789756,
-0.9656098485,
-0.3511026204,
-0.0767836496,
-0.1880880296,
-0.0373319313,
0.872461617,
-0.570055306,
0.1491620392,
0.1884652227,
0.5061608553,
0.5634759068,
-0.5087958574,
0.1252295077,
-0.6340697408,
0.3833176196,
0.3286006451,
0.4324775636,
0.2493829727,
-0.5011697412,
0.6028064489,
0.2212273926,
-0.7530069351,
-0.9342424273,
0.2247655094,
-0.9286646247,
-0.5357199311,
1.2338732481,
0.4207325578,
-0.3685211241,
-0.2408322245,
-0.2592222095,
0.063625969,
-0.4866423011,
0.8816492558,
0.6549330354,
-0.3473311067,
-0.2653399706,
-0.6717010736,
0.6766539216,
0.3238138556,
-0.9157607555,
0.1559015363,
0.5811084509,
-0.005713766,
0.2287651598,
0.7988256216,
0.0772414804,
0.2896364927,
0.2092260867,
0.2790039778,
-0.1205645055,
-0.6055086851,
-0.5528647304,
-0.0072339438,
0.1503656656,
-0.1781184226
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11275v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11275v1 | Self-training Large Language Models through Knowledge Detection | 2024-06-17T07:25:09 | 2024-06-17T07:25:09 | Wei Jie Yeo, Teddy Ferdinan, Przemyslaw Kazienko, Ranjan Satapathy, Erik Cambria | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) often necessitate extensive labeled datasets and
training compute to achieve impressive performance across downstream tasks.
This paper explores a self-training paradigm, where the LLM autonomously
curates its own labels and selectively trains on unknown data samples
identified through a reference-free consistency method. Empirical evaluations
demonstrate significant improvements in reducing hallucination in generation
across multiple subjects. Furthermore, the selective training framework
mitigates catastrophic forgetting in out-of-distribution benchmarks, addressing
a critical limitation in training LLMs. Our findings suggest that such an
approach can substantially reduce the dependency on large labeled datasets,
paving the way for more scalable and cost-effective language model training. | [
-0.2877644002,
-0.2005983442,
0.6842004061,
0.0529127046,
0.0629758164,
-0.135008961,
-0.3066110313,
-0.3335695267,
0.1339263171,
0.8345610499,
-0.5194101334,
-0.3988105059,
-0.5992196798,
0.0364060365,
-0.4588057101,
0.7219036818,
-0.050709229,
-0.0713593811,
-0.3011923134,
-0.2762607038,
-0.4030578434,
-0.6979022622,
-0.5587780476,
-0.5932784677,
0.5337489247,
0.2304204255,
0.2225169092,
0.9561071992,
0.0746188313,
0.2378564775,
0.2898275554,
0.1636161655,
-0.6567950845,
0.3812084198,
-0.2109075487,
-0.4625268579,
0.057389278,
-0.0190177597,
0.8460994363,
0.6284238696,
-0.1094649881,
0.1088463962,
0.0660360903,
0.8728987575,
-0.7773869038,
0.2105112374,
-0.9838135839,
0.1569491476,
-0.243094638,
0.0256427396,
-0.5894892812,
0.0626044422,
-0.1929862648,
-0.4345330596,
0.3641457558,
0.0109211253,
0.470811516,
0.5913373232,
-0.2807608247,
-0.2153552622,
-0.7591674328,
0.745110333,
-0.3889261484,
0.9080050588,
0.726462841,
0.2918666303,
-0.0722562,
-0.397208333,
-0.3595919907,
-0.160548389,
-0.028870102,
0.0107552772,
-0.0149826026,
-0.1172739938,
0.1593680382,
0.2960427403,
-0.5968008637,
0.3233846426,
-0.1880137026,
-0.3273197711,
0.5449536443,
-0.1297260225,
-0.0007163317,
0.0801119357,
-0.1322360039,
0.0476527214,
-0.8202826381,
-0.5373488665,
0.3432133496,
0.2616141737,
0.1460540444,
0.3624178469,
-0.4866510034,
0.6981156468,
0.0351303741,
-0.2494851202,
0.3160059452,
0.0769834891,
-0.2193255723,
0.086838901,
0.837980628,
-0.347780019,
0.4019286931,
-0.5394047499,
-0.4673107266,
-0.1420124024,
0.1249535382,
-0.6084672213,
-0.6499464512,
0.13242805,
-0.2761583924,
-0.0587416813,
-0.4450842142,
-0.2370673418,
-0.5345751643,
-0.3918065727,
0.3827040195,
-0.4406073093,
-0.2007917315,
0.110975489,
-0.0001722911,
-0.0045331623,
0.1731723398,
-1.3301416636,
0.1044806466,
0.3703385293,
0.5822537541,
-0.0922849476,
-0.2703952789,
-0.6941569448,
0.5493959188,
-0.4384217858,
0.9016686678,
-0.3469499052,
-0.0855459943,
-0.1813578904,
-0.1955050975,
-0.1682370007,
-0.985044837,
0.0746730417,
-0.6104407907,
-0.1987253875,
-0.3412901759,
-0.8571247458,
0.0190879535,
0.2609099448,
-0.649846077,
1.040412426,
0.31960693,
-0.6035858393,
0.4904141128,
-0.0475195944,
-0.2449517846,
0.2100006789,
-0.4555462599,
-0.4747959971,
0.0579000786,
0.2372503281,
0.5946629643,
-0.1267039776,
0.5230324864,
-0.4692814648,
-0.2412994057,
0.1534823328,
-0.3996609449,
0.5031886697,
0.2940388918,
-0.3011053801,
-0.0631800517,
-0.9565722942,
-0.1477571875,
0.2099536806,
-0.426281184,
-0.5048539639,
0.0237835776,
-0.3941341341,
0.1974828988,
0.1688690484,
-0.2829376757,
0.1776708513,
-0.298630625,
0.1337139904,
0.8530918956,
-0.1772665381,
0.4270098209,
-0.2425429821,
0.3629261851,
0.1156778187,
0.0096516544,
-0.1546492279,
-0.0898962989,
-1.2300933599,
-0.4211792648,
0.1307610422,
0.2842299342,
-0.6304914951,
0.7436187863,
-0.1251270771,
-0.3358544707,
-0.4757630825,
0.7463954687,
0.3258303106,
0.3605645597,
0.5144920945,
-0.1297879368,
-0.5872033238,
-0.9973672628,
-0.2319481969,
-0.1304745823,
-0.0531099811,
0.0099548083,
0.5909568667,
-0.3816432059,
1.0155103207,
-0.264661938,
-0.6674166918,
-0.3605647087,
-0.0164065547,
-0.1130053475,
0.5090632439,
0.2866265476,
-0.3158011436,
-0.4426793754,
-0.096677728,
-0.9370962977,
-0.0766174272,
-0.2165450007,
0.2030557692,
0.1394212693,
0.8620811105,
-0.2619459033,
0.1261698455,
0.5641627312,
0.1305541247,
0.3093729019,
-0.3712364733,
-0.4505188167,
-0.7232977748,
-0.048179768,
-0.0971189067,
-0.2208557427,
-0.5854808092,
-0.212826997,
0.3074567616,
0.1999325305,
-0.0647281781,
0.836289227,
-0.7530730367,
-0.1144685224,
-0.3483335674,
0.0834182799,
-0.1863230467,
0.431794107,
0.357611984,
0.6605327725,
0.6292556524,
-0.7541319728,
0.2163709253,
0.1693971753,
-0.5389214754,
0.4376928806,
-0.2098487169,
0.3632409573,
-0.3852033615,
0.0788297579,
-0.9188555479,
-0.2355586737,
0.4132367671,
-0.1323530227,
0.3598459065,
-0.2257724702,
-0.5507006049,
-0.3925876915,
0.1981218308,
0.3226257861,
0.4043720365,
-0.8637504578,
0.5885500908,
0.3588771224,
0.2987697423,
-0.5782735348,
-0.7327603698,
-0.1093063354,
-0.2507374883,
-0.1369265765,
-0.1383265257,
-0.0720553547,
-0.0614584647,
-0.2581211627,
-0.2166884691,
-0.1781152636,
0.1986876577,
0.1651732326,
-0.2850908041,
0.0927457958,
0.7557142973,
-0.1493712366,
-0.2004812956,
0.1356234699,
-0.6770569086,
0.6327352524,
0.1964064986,
-0.5521151423,
-0.3707804084,
0.1563130319,
0.156819582,
-0.2769933939,
0.831553936,
0.4961827695,
-0.2633616328,
-0.6392422915,
-0.9097830057,
-0.2499898225,
-0.5153132081,
0.3837222755,
-0.4745655656,
-0.8587331772,
0.3760370612,
0.0068892823,
-0.2045960277,
0.2723812461,
0.4919299483,
0.0147115635,
0.823423624,
0.6138470173,
-0.4296892583,
0.3890306652,
-0.0673343614,
0.2658779621,
-0.6746590734,
-0.2454467118,
-0.4480948746,
0.0091021704,
-0.2148313224,
-0.4589098394,
0.1673529595,
-0.0083572948,
-0.3217117488,
0.067357637,
-0.5484105349,
0.6209887862,
0.6501990557,
0.1674558669,
0.4215367734,
-0.0530388616,
-0.0094983578,
0.0259975661,
-0.8648902774,
-0.2023725063,
1.2903875113,
0.4504849017,
0.8809730411,
-0.3515236676,
1.0119948387,
0.0951142758,
0.570559442,
-0.7899083495,
0.4651431441,
-0.0354039147,
-0.7274961472,
-0.4875215292,
-0.6053974032,
-0.9219278097,
0.2163306326,
-0.0127168093,
-0.6385677457,
0.0448940396,
0.377818346,
-0.1521716267,
0.4103666842,
-0.5892468691,
0.757422328,
-0.4363240004,
-0.0125051243,
-0.1485324055,
-0.255763799,
0.4787808061,
-0.586981833,
0.2739658356,
-0.2417500615,
0.2433395386,
0.9297732711,
-0.1106411368,
1.0205985308,
-0.1255204082,
-0.2893639207,
0.2073326111,
0.0892925039,
0.6886959076,
-0.1392174214,
0.0822883919,
-0.004790348,
-0.3907141685,
-0.3582382798,
-0.4581873417,
0.6378344297,
-0.7533785701,
-0.7095764875,
-0.3630608916,
-0.7843539119,
-0.5061363578,
0.2065933496,
0.2939096689,
0.1782544255,
-0.049793046,
0.1754237562,
1.1826968193,
-0.1702868193,
0.2089079171,
0.4827565551,
-0.2732771337,
-0.3892931342,
0.9053457975,
0.3810227513,
0.3623979092,
0.315353483,
0.114979133,
-0.4334282577,
-0.7324557304,
-0.1339325756,
0.5288680196,
-1.0915616751,
-0.1068511158,
-0.9814748764,
-0.3423021436,
-0.5986081362,
0.1492419541,
-0.6792383194,
-0.0650800243,
-0.3310085833,
-0.0871011391,
0.3032852411,
0.9324215651,
-0.1371555328,
0.489303261,
-0.5159671307,
0.4057124257,
0.7155451179,
0.5309383869,
0.0997232869,
-0.6222468615,
-0.5185204744,
-0.1394192129,
-0.0498400331,
-0.5501153469,
0.4199416339,
0.1790583879,
0.8559646606,
0.5732815862,
0.0817148983,
0.460768491,
-0.379021138,
0.2438695133,
0.1862956285,
-0.8306955099,
0.5305755138,
-0.3403614461,
0.5815439224,
0.5819023848,
0.5252783895,
-0.5875475407,
-0.581382513,
-0.4526809752,
-0.541585207,
0.6369482279,
-0.1391962618,
0.0063302806,
-0.1758524328,
0.4282319546,
0.1168202534,
0.1202516332,
-1.0663926601,
-0.3326949477,
-0.0121755032,
-0.2387997359,
-0.2654117942,
-0.3625062406,
-0.1821703315,
-0.2946077585,
0.7466641068,
-0.2852237225,
0.1346318126,
0.0910226181,
-0.3708255887,
0.0316691212,
0.0957582518,
0.2523242831,
0.4863204062,
0.0252104215,
0.3858802021,
0.1720711142,
-0.2128583044,
0.3630072176,
-0.2176007926,
-0.2443855554,
-0.1480717063,
0.1920454353,
0.8618950248,
0.1325826645,
-0.5965563059,
0.3056316078,
0.2264530659,
-0.2567059398,
-0.5328079462,
0.3430481851,
0.2830663323,
0.2335790992,
0.2869793773,
-0.0959147513,
0.0442019366,
-0.3226933479,
0.3423836231,
0.5301147103,
-0.5699087381,
-0.0496719442,
0.6694277525,
-0.1096242368,
0.0204562638,
0.7391987443,
-0.2851291895,
-0.4305839539,
0.325039655,
0.6005527973,
0.8188713193,
-0.4415000975,
0.2104958296,
0.2430770099,
0.4719641209,
-0.5203248262,
-0.1128375605,
-0.2159727812,
-1.1096401215,
-0.3245927393,
-0.6483405828,
-0.1748959273,
0.6570391655,
-0.4887262583,
0.1328151971,
-0.516749084,
0.1577132791,
-0.2317111194,
-0.3855165839,
-0.644174695,
0.3927474022,
0.3591727614,
0.6596844792,
-0.9642316103,
1.3184608221,
0.1842128485,
-0.1149380282,
-0.7331569195,
-0.1442217827,
-0.1103140488,
-0.9678176641,
0.9134626985,
0.3299281299,
-0.1019228175,
0.1156572178,
-0.4620050192,
-1.0431622267,
0.6758807898,
0.4975840151,
-0.6961092949,
0.1655932963,
0.2248569429,
0.3867286742,
-0.331456244,
0.0173324626,
0.8614845276,
0.3669568598,
-0.0113205034,
-0.7581612468,
-0.09015432,
0.1216678396,
-0.1272154152,
0.2063861787,
-0.7105056643,
0.571639359,
0.0118552307,
-0.071596384,
-0.1924557835,
0.7984185219,
0.3761853576,
0.055310946,
0.515458107,
0.6721193194,
0.9888541102,
-0.0037935667,
0.6310474873,
-0.1506201923,
0.289326489,
1.3972930908,
-0.3667513132,
0.6266131997,
0.444383949,
0.0004274379,
0.1423441172,
0.4912478626,
-0.1337433606,
0.6080495715,
0.2960671782,
-0.3205199242,
-0.7622875571,
0.0039656772,
-0.3347096443,
0.4706785381,
0.2742650509,
-0.3974401355,
-0.2802253664,
0.2536133528,
-0.0157824624,
0.1093526483,
-0.2154949456,
0.8150162101,
0.0499606952,
-0.606015265,
0.8913365006,
-0.4085737765,
0.5602433681,
-0.6953979731,
0.3008133471,
-0.3086856306,
0.3553831875,
-0.0097128497,
-0.3529159427,
0.2199392617,
-0.380045563,
-0.1866710782,
-0.5291294456,
0.7884653807,
-0.6551334858,
-0.2761271894,
0.5615631938,
0.5702083111,
0.2406259179,
-0.3945651948,
-0.4347620308,
0.0214760341,
-0.0210658032,
-0.3380683362,
0.6143447757,
0.5416470766,
-0.006465707,
1.1875756979,
0.3547549248,
0.1112017781,
0.1780060679,
0.1531391591,
0.8104380965,
-0.6116981506,
-0.5072045922,
-0.6779893041,
-0.0543669425,
0.0619273931,
-0.0700158328,
0.7249893546,
0.6076293588,
1.0600539446,
-0.2599933445,
1.0396746397,
0.4105475843,
0.5484092236,
-0.5642251968,
0.810739398,
-0.393723011,
0.4109394848,
0.1867136657,
-0.7754942775,
-0.3644004464,
0.6656062007,
-0.5044460297,
0.2539199889,
0.6448064446,
0.6639795303,
0.0543874912,
-0.2074752897,
0.625690937,
0.1850675941,
0.1404395401,
0.5579944253,
1.0094559193,
-0.231539011,
0.4865487516,
-0.3825241923,
0.0215538871,
0.0227648504,
-0.6333444118,
-1.3967754841,
-0.6323679686,
-0.3324564695,
-0.1511842012,
0.0306269936,
0.7483990788,
0.9071037173,
-1.0044900179,
-0.3703952134,
-0.2146063894,
0.1012006626,
-0.1074111164,
-0.1472817957,
0.0944230705,
-0.804356277,
-0.4808151424,
0.6843070984,
0.4087375104,
0.2944020629,
-0.5301414728,
-0.069296509,
-0.0514134429,
-0.1267310083,
0.4498693943,
0.3256590962,
-0.6029425263,
-0.4181693494,
-0.1656219959,
-0.1012170836,
0.1790957749,
0.8138630986,
-1.0284429789,
0.5338539481,
0.1861077398,
0.7055493593,
0.6605764627,
-0.3786974549,
0.5047062635,
-0.7866024375,
0.3003022075,
0.1572972834,
0.3105412424,
0.4282934666,
-0.5121164322,
0.492287755,
0.3203124404,
-0.6289482117,
-0.7123441696,
0.2929089367,
-0.5433835983,
-0.4371948242,
1.2038015127,
-0.0686565563,
-0.1357941031,
-0.5370064378,
0.1906466931,
0.1843770742,
-0.1823343933,
0.9411671758,
0.7482575774,
0.0031353892,
-0.307249397,
-0.5616352558,
0.6113553643,
0.5174151063,
-0.7832586765,
0.3964304328,
0.4599340856,
0.5058900118,
-0.1240264848,
0.9057927132,
0.2803467512,
-0.1418533027,
-0.1106880605,
0.3587951064,
0.0473190956,
-0.6773062348,
-0.4111105204,
0.1649560928,
0.2284808457,
0.0904324353
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11274v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11274v1 | Skip-Layer Attention: Bridging Abstract and Detailed Dependencies in Transformers | 2024-06-17T07:24:38 | 2024-06-17T07:24:38 | Qian Chen, Wen Wang, Qinglin Zhang, Siqi Zheng, Shiliang Zhang, Chong Deng, Hai Yu, Jiaqing Liu, Yukun Ma, Chong Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | The Transformer architecture has significantly advanced deep learning,
particularly in natural language processing, by effectively managing long-range
dependencies. However, as the demand for understanding complex relationships
grows, refining the Transformer's architecture becomes critical. This paper
introduces Skip-Layer Attention (SLA) to enhance Transformer models by enabling
direct attention between non-adjacent layers. This method improves the model's
ability to capture dependencies between high-level abstract features and
low-level details. By facilitating direct attention between these diverse
feature levels, our approach overcomes the limitations of current Transformers,
which often rely on suboptimal intra-layer attention. Our implementation
extends the Transformer's functionality by enabling queries in a given layer to
interact with keys and values from both the current layer and one preceding
layer, thus enhancing the diversity of multi-head attention without additional
computational burden. Extensive experiments demonstrate that our enhanced
Transformer model achieves superior performance in language modeling tasks,
highlighting the effectiveness of our skip-layer attention mechanism. | [
-0.6270032525,
-0.5902492404,
0.5700951219,
0.6724511385,
0.214530468,
0.2238691002,
0.2133309394,
-0.7898471951,
0.0432387367,
0.6812784076,
-0.6525278091,
-0.0451748595,
-0.6210983992,
-0.2445515394,
-0.3928731084,
0.9113976955,
0.0594495758,
-0.559715867,
-0.2682649493,
0.1088766679,
-0.4241735935,
-0.2427954227,
-0.9255598187,
-0.4518259466,
0.7112416625,
0.2227089703,
0.981234014,
0.6683366299,
0.541328609,
0.2969048321,
-0.4797205627,
0.0374767035,
-0.3769448996,
0.2228997052,
-0.4331470728,
-0.2265064716,
-0.7170978189,
-0.2015276849,
0.4702221751,
0.9298775792,
0.372417897,
0.2224261761,
0.1767984182,
0.9298555255,
-0.8454713225,
0.2556934357,
-0.5404123664,
0.2435704321,
0.1008043662,
-0.0514838025,
-0.6020525694,
0.1173381284,
0.583424449,
-0.4428260922,
0.3996600509,
-0.2992597818,
0.9115406275,
0.6138337851,
-0.3057302535,
0.2760646045,
-1.1112830639,
0.5144273043,
-0.3435645103,
0.6123421788,
0.3685165346,
0.0683806539,
0.3526382148,
-0.8493509293,
-0.2476814538,
-0.2265331447,
-0.4945589006,
0.2065914124,
-0.3263263702,
0.1773562282,
0.3494766355,
0.3773362935,
-0.1235977709,
-0.0216836724,
-0.4628589451,
-0.1792627573,
0.1709939986,
0.1692480594,
0.2971517146,
0.1323568523,
-0.3519707322,
0.129413411,
-0.6077919006,
0.1748353094,
0.1465260386,
0.3594309986,
-0.1433776617,
0.315752238,
-0.1715450138,
0.5673881769,
0.4293060601,
0.3715286851,
0.2900945544,
-0.365799278,
-0.3156954944,
0.0571346469,
0.3413903713,
-0.1106832623,
0.163509354,
-0.4594844282,
-0.1488068998,
-0.1012180969,
0.5518582463,
-0.6927967072,
-0.292953819,
0.3320298791,
-0.2944093049,
-0.2005336732,
-0.1901055276,
-0.8235791326,
-0.164738372,
-0.4699319601,
0.1449536383,
-0.2099161595,
-0.0880049616,
0.0943999067,
0.1677475721,
0.3124251366,
0.134490639,
-0.9842553139,
0.4674218893,
0.5503872037,
0.8198002577,
-0.1561304778,
-0.4550917447,
-0.721246779,
0.6512745619,
-0.1077556834,
0.8478940725,
-0.7443193793,
0.055197712,
-0.2626986206,
-0.0582612641,
-0.1413156539,
-0.4679406583,
0.6772322655,
-0.7024560571,
0.1893861443,
0.1434270591,
-0.0985296443,
-0.2616161704,
0.1063850299,
-0.9641695023,
1.0866672993,
0.2206491679,
-0.8635648489,
-0.1189581379,
-0.8332791924,
-0.9130225778,
0.057071127,
0.1025357246,
-0.4034705162,
0.130493328,
0.6938776374,
0.3050805628,
-0.1493748277,
0.083048746,
0.0192368533,
-0.2557696402,
-0.1254799366,
-0.283647418,
0.4139801562,
-0.1975153387,
-0.5372704864,
0.271527797,
-0.9710003734,
-0.3553296626,
0.0792304054,
-0.1168012396,
-0.2858625054,
-0.0684944913,
0.1806374043,
0.5853862166,
0.2722364664,
-0.1735285968,
-0.1438937336,
-0.681376636,
0.3705111742,
0.7130640149,
-0.021078635,
0.9677258134,
0.0428168364,
0.6511568427,
0.444744736,
0.1850144416,
-0.5456641316,
-0.2100048661,
-1.1622831821,
-0.0716283843,
0.268679291,
0.6174632311,
-0.406496197,
0.5920265913,
-0.128120169,
-0.2635262907,
-0.8289433718,
0.0659632608,
0.4111674428,
0.6064927578,
0.5505818725,
-0.1769637764,
-0.697719574,
-1.1123054028,
-0.3927968144,
0.18877469,
-0.1658081561,
0.3375572562,
0.1705830395,
-0.365501076,
1.0364466906,
-0.4524246752,
-0.6618553996,
-0.5579719543,
-0.1919019967,
0.046850156,
0.3091784418,
0.2144824117,
-0.7013189793,
-0.4863109589,
0.2810885906,
-0.3066699803,
-0.0273031555,
-0.3054027855,
-0.2921796739,
-0.1006416604,
0.5057781339,
-0.8402295709,
0.2976427972,
0.2726456225,
-0.2935168445,
0.0417816043,
0.167538017,
-0.3155722618,
-0.6931059361,
0.3006949723,
0.0356128179,
-0.2673684657,
-0.9992053509,
0.0944925472,
0.0380535014,
-0.0404155143,
-0.4870136976,
0.5194820762,
-0.387188077,
-0.1696352363,
-0.3152075112,
0.1199823022,
0.2617367208,
0.7553988099,
0.1563243121,
0.5953189731,
0.7702556252,
-0.6692093015,
-0.1327004582,
0.2886584401,
0.0967181846,
0.1772598773,
-0.9316748381,
0.5015752316,
-0.3414221704,
0.1748408526,
-0.9435667992,
-0.1003734171,
0.2637646496,
-0.1676499695,
0.3010920286,
-0.1841075718,
-0.2277635932,
-0.1713523567,
-0.2104355991,
0.4351120889,
0.3448998034,
-0.5529637933,
1.2590684891,
0.3529965878,
-0.2243823707,
-0.752553463,
-0.8029648066,
0.0361173861,
0.1765760183,
-0.6462848186,
0.4978434443,
0.1421864927,
-0.0658800304,
-0.0303329676,
-0.3908776641,
-0.1945590377,
-0.0371167511,
0.2496967465,
0.1984424293,
-0.2938561141,
-0.1206768006,
0.229549557,
-0.485704571,
0.0828387067,
-0.2699478269,
0.766566515,
0.1326199472,
-0.1457619965,
-0.5725536346,
0.3742828965,
0.6589835882,
-0.6535115838,
0.5106790066,
0.5854084492,
-0.3179060519,
-0.2779476643,
-0.5805888772,
-0.3166390955,
-0.5771066546,
0.4934024811,
-0.4134865105,
-0.8854586482,
0.5624679327,
0.2012806386,
0.0687577054,
0.3152419925,
0.2728387117,
0.0213948339,
1.0111783743,
0.6990445256,
-0.414021045,
0.5459926724,
-0.0056401151,
0.3801109493,
-0.9769074917,
-0.279268682,
-0.4894815981,
-0.5265914202,
-0.1269494146,
-0.402933985,
-0.0645152107,
-0.120818302,
-0.2155495137,
0.3143582046,
-0.5350470543,
0.8470676541,
0.3111350238,
0.1021942496,
0.2914465666,
-0.048555728,
0.2174149305,
-0.1645916104,
-0.4107072651,
-0.1896281838,
0.5318327546,
0.7706958055,
0.7452421188,
-0.21455428,
0.2736751437,
0.0461433865,
-0.0330109373,
-0.7735006809,
0.4989539981,
-0.2342001051,
-0.2804821432,
-0.1172625199,
-0.2934247255,
-0.6850101352,
0.411410898,
0.3867086172,
-0.5968424082,
0.2094915062,
0.2069342285,
-0.4081425071,
0.1410785913,
-0.720440805,
0.730625689,
0.0936980918,
-0.2592278421,
-0.0218367185,
-0.8885964155,
0.3577878773,
0.1970928907,
0.0311250258,
0.1586456001,
-0.2125556618,
0.2934855521,
0.2486507595,
1.039075613,
0.0221830718,
-0.3217714727,
-0.0623430386,
0.0927850679,
0.6601820588,
-0.0874204561,
0.4071186185,
-0.1775890738,
-0.8247199059,
-0.4067599773,
-0.539031446,
0.7737141848,
-0.6654305458,
-0.5842579603,
-0.1301894039,
-0.8676490784,
-0.359512955,
0.2890210748,
-0.0537308007,
0.1132040843,
0.0967652723,
-0.0076209814,
1.0179070234,
-0.0463456362,
0.637286067,
0.271404326,
-0.1027395129,
-0.0533120818,
0.7344721556,
-0.0230238792,
0.378929317,
0.8097720146,
-0.0218814518,
-0.2542684674,
-0.4611817002,
-0.0859182552,
0.124612473,
-0.7857266665,
-0.0036349511,
-1.4698495865,
-0.7309392691,
-0.4329279959,
0.0525085777,
-0.4794614911,
-0.4003557265,
-0.2942623198,
-0.4153759181,
0.1140205935,
0.7130584121,
0.4710383415,
0.3876662254,
-0.8476151824,
0.5402513146,
0.3973377645,
0.4865935445,
0.5376509428,
-0.6533726454,
-0.2325250953,
-0.6127038598,
-0.3584973216,
-0.5023065209,
0.2309076339,
0.1402817965,
0.6142962575,
0.3435159624,
-0.2234925032,
0.6646237969,
-0.6619079709,
0.481425941,
-0.0890596732,
-1.2523783445,
0.7008057833,
-0.1541343778,
0.8255695701,
0.533775568,
0.2551805675,
-0.3009413779,
-0.8375449181,
-0.5180444121,
-1.1977568865,
1.0352673531,
0.3609981835,
0.2652996778,
0.3270557523,
0.2201615274,
-0.0213015005,
-0.190063104,
-1.1313465834,
-0.3332586884,
-0.1011912972,
-0.0500513166,
0.2131420374,
-0.1466186047,
0.0505815074,
-0.2057657838,
0.5502297282,
0.0332325622,
-0.0138657214,
0.1542079598,
-0.3277768195,
-0.0646580532,
0.2336945236,
0.5945701599,
0.5898626447,
-0.0551551208,
0.394967258,
0.1916666776,
-0.6190699339,
-0.1031099409,
0.1811767668,
-0.4258624613,
0.0688514039,
0.3336238563,
1.0484538078,
0.39475438,
-0.4027419984,
0.1159722656,
0.0291988943,
0.0634769276,
-0.0702100098,
0.0096436534,
0.4752105474,
0.2632362545,
0.4855100214,
0.5266755223,
0.27885589,
-0.135804534,
0.4280865788,
0.143066138,
-0.7756180167,
-0.3664773107,
0.5847693086,
0.2175569236,
-0.4106221497,
0.2564820647,
0.363496393,
-0.4480833113,
0.7308014035,
0.5571120977,
1.0057508945,
-0.4364615083,
0.0652142465,
0.2211844623,
0.6012320518,
0.1137738898,
-0.0328369476,
-0.1273646355,
-0.4020596743,
-0.6218312383,
-0.3457196355,
-0.2672551572,
0.2343288511,
-0.6280363202,
0.2919174135,
-0.6246657372,
0.1873742342,
0.1050884128,
-0.5249303579,
-0.7733077407,
0.3130710721,
0.1611889601,
0.6271805763,
-0.7156611681,
0.7589566112,
0.4889398515,
-0.5292204618,
-0.4648788571,
0.3450654149,
-0.5923867226,
-0.4996170104,
0.7222427726,
0.5105581284,
-0.4490204453,
0.014235097,
-0.2386791408,
-1.0094658136,
0.8432093859,
0.4260724783,
-0.7047481537,
-0.2702596188,
0.3068346083,
0.5717884302,
-0.5122097731,
0.5216240883,
0.8255816698,
0.4081906974,
0.1407287866,
-0.53433007,
0.1141729653,
-0.1497659087,
0.1063486114,
0.3118785024,
-0.588247478,
0.7198249698,
-0.1337129623,
-0.2890005708,
-0.2708917558,
1.0018810034,
0.0483434014,
0.1698471606,
0.7297127843,
0.4559941888,
0.1634172797,
0.0084528187,
0.9073453546,
-0.3134865165,
0.2032571286,
1.4711478949,
-0.2925452888,
0.7762263417,
0.6511003375,
-0.1176136658,
0.4281150997,
0.2637525797,
0.1207749173,
0.6592181325,
-0.126986146,
-0.1157501116,
-0.1377855539,
-0.2072515786,
-0.2926672697,
0.2638304234,
0.2311595976,
-0.6542725563,
-0.214959994,
-0.0548493862,
-0.2200832218,
-0.0332261957,
-0.3492611647,
0.9177684188,
-0.0112240147,
-0.6133122444,
0.1758098304,
-0.2946370542,
0.714418292,
-0.5885407925,
-0.0348180681,
-0.4369467795,
0.2606205344,
-0.3894493878,
-0.66779989,
0.5287127495,
-0.1738209724,
-0.657966733,
-0.2386574745,
0.9282001853,
-0.4573117793,
-0.5325080156,
0.7902921438,
0.3555484116,
-0.3178672493,
-0.1816259623,
-0.5483579636,
0.0174791012,
-0.0819428787,
-0.4900668561,
0.3853873312,
0.193668291,
0.1895341575,
0.6398644447,
0.5492672324,
-0.2283634096,
0.2136767656,
0.6027131081,
1.0033968687,
-0.7332903147,
-0.6724011898,
-0.8791915774,
0.7616326809,
-0.1642780453,
-0.1853101254,
0.3464119434,
0.473295331,
0.7177348733,
-0.2692912817,
0.8260089159,
0.2894499302,
0.4678299427,
-0.2872356176,
0.6497281194,
-0.18470186,
0.390004307,
-0.2107969522,
-1.1970083714,
-0.5227915049,
0.4438510239,
-0.0518906042,
0.1257449985,
0.7065677643,
0.4759643972,
-0.4945219457,
0.0114018293,
0.1334975213,
0.4042097926,
0.5009248257,
0.6827492714,
0.9612070918,
-0.4206199348,
0.6811214089,
-0.4437813461,
-0.0007342426,
0.2950663865,
-0.6672845483,
-1.1456050873,
-0.2085986286,
-0.3372990191,
-0.2309895903,
-0.2192618996,
0.581430316,
0.5821798444,
-0.9060896039,
0.0069291294,
-0.2558501661,
0.1747342497,
-0.3744884431,
-0.3393940628,
0.494123131,
-0.6260203123,
-0.9166532159,
0.4535227418,
0.7817286849,
0.0360015929,
-0.5141487718,
0.257114619,
-0.1967715621,
0.0835593343,
0.7296765447,
0.0793003142,
-0.8857857585,
-0.1574985832,
0.1533867121,
-0.167868048,
0.3362200856,
1.0423058271,
-0.9442453384,
-0.0305821504,
0.6463505626,
1.0727441311,
0.689896524,
-0.1754220575,
0.5271223187,
-1.0183079243,
0.3895407319,
0.4670884013,
0.2131486237,
0.4379414022,
-0.6036047339,
0.3936095536,
-0.1198573112,
-0.333347708,
-0.5874629021,
0.4038277566,
-1.1866780519,
0.0302113127,
0.8796574473,
-0.1642497182,
-0.0752420276,
-0.5285227299,
-0.4049732685,
-0.0448552072,
-0.4990445375,
0.6764883995,
0.4887737632,
0.0010740982,
-0.8539450169,
-0.4825145304,
0.3959597647,
0.8157934546,
-0.9759057164,
0.3188157082,
-0.0230470523,
-0.0923553407,
0.4037531614,
0.3513669074,
-0.0156381987,
0.2600444257,
-0.2774877846,
-0.2218797654,
0.00812745,
-0.6846258044,
-0.430377841,
0.5231408477,
-0.3274919093,
-0.1391164362
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11267v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11267v1 | Mitigating Large Language Model Hallucination with Faithful Finetuning | 2024-06-17T07:16:07 | 2024-06-17T07:16:07 | Minda Hu, Bowei He, Yufei Wang, Liangyou Li, Chen Ma, Irwin King | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable performance on
various natural language processing tasks. However, they are prone to
generating fluent yet untruthful responses, known as "hallucinations".
Hallucinations can lead to the spread of misinformation and cause harm in
critical applications. Mitigating hallucinations is challenging as they arise
from factors such as noisy data, model overconfidence, lack of knowledge, and
the generation process itself. Recent efforts have attempted to address this
issue through representation editing and decoding algorithms, reducing
hallucinations without major structural changes or retraining. However, these
approaches either implicitly edit LLMs' behavior in latent space or suppress
the tendency to output unfaithful results during decoding instead of explicitly
modeling on hallucination. In this work, we introduce Faithful Finetuning (F2),
a novel method that explicitly models the process of faithful question
answering through carefully designed loss functions during fine-tuning. We
conduct extensive experiments on popular datasets and demonstrate that F2
achieves significant improvements over vanilla models and baselines. | [
-0.3626333773,
-1.2215777636,
0.566919744,
0.0400409698,
-0.2852466702,
-0.2766800523,
-0.3885478079,
-0.297421217,
-0.0386569202,
0.8976831436,
-0.6481493711,
-0.259241581,
-0.3788618147,
0.0057979929,
-0.3332770765,
0.9465870261,
-0.0562209673,
0.3280563354,
-0.2844006121,
0.0024373413,
-0.5689324141,
-0.4092625976,
-0.6229125857,
-0.4326424599,
0.2852989435,
0.3993293941,
0.9730017781,
0.4221009016,
0.3790306747,
0.2062791735,
-0.0301145986,
0.5196350217,
-1.0157445669,
0.3824595213,
-0.0954877213,
-0.6884199381,
-0.1459626257,
-0.1663868427,
0.5417980552,
0.9421126842,
-0.21965985,
-0.0475400425,
0.4946146607,
0.6121549606,
-0.4678580761,
0.1363206506,
-1.0809190273,
-0.0135287791,
-0.0079548433,
-0.4365432858,
-0.5165529251,
-0.3838532865,
-0.1377822459,
-0.6608273387,
0.4965729415,
-0.105185248,
0.8022115231,
0.6831128001,
0.1526430845,
-0.2935742438,
-0.8811395168,
0.7438075542,
-0.7620190978,
0.5105691552,
0.7141533494,
0.0851919502,
-0.4383884668,
-0.4284665585,
-0.4502106607,
-0.21153678,
-0.0735746101,
-0.2007723451,
-0.1667903215,
0.1141249016,
0.3039784133,
0.2512969375,
-0.5498479605,
0.0084372275,
-0.2780071199,
-0.5490797162,
0.4719539285,
0.1930393875,
-0.0208840817,
0.010182946,
0.0005187314,
-0.0408969335,
-0.6595784426,
-0.2139517814,
0.353051126,
0.315892756,
0.3244276047,
0.7963657975,
-0.1399307996,
0.3492891192,
0.1682338864,
0.2566042542,
-0.0380953401,
-0.1008465663,
-0.387583971,
0.116260998,
0.4292603135,
0.5852273703,
0.5855648518,
-0.5862587094,
-0.2585769892,
0.3134320378,
0.3354535699,
-0.9093107581,
-0.3300260305,
0.3518566489,
-0.4160283506,
-0.2171067446,
-0.0154917436,
-0.839392662,
-0.6495524049,
-0.3894771636,
0.4481599629,
-0.5901562572,
-0.0399023741,
0.305377394,
0.1249145493,
0.287922591,
0.4887243211,
-0.7611297965,
0.5823981166,
0.861186862,
0.824719727,
-0.0271337405,
-0.190144062,
-1.010530591,
0.0952975675,
-0.4810208976,
0.6097792983,
-0.5059435368,
-0.0802196637,
-0.013470632,
0.0447152033,
0.2304783612,
-0.7098416686,
0.4922921658,
-0.5033422709,
0.0573787205,
-0.1608738899,
-0.5374248028,
-0.1346628666,
0.1898575723,
-0.5535096526,
0.8167617321,
-0.142983377,
-0.6123735905,
-0.0440590195,
-0.1783493757,
-0.402640909,
-0.2945631146,
-0.0584340729,
-0.5817700624,
0.534940362,
0.2864109874,
0.5856980085,
-0.0926627368,
0.3399098814,
-0.3357449472,
-0.5169473886,
0.300165832,
-0.6378718615,
0.346640408,
0.282758832,
-0.4250305295,
0.1764895916,
-0.6220607162,
-0.0619202256,
0.2215398699,
-0.0034411368,
-0.5873018503,
-0.0332102887,
0.0946681425,
-0.0981520042,
0.0035038113,
-0.3408436477,
0.1816643625,
-0.7594373226,
0.258392185,
0.7183144689,
0.076541394,
0.4533911347,
-0.4802327752,
0.2355573028,
0.0813276097,
0.0654180124,
0.0098161129,
-0.2988034785,
-0.9217967987,
0.2407536209,
0.0740117133,
0.5194808245,
-0.8424450755,
0.1461041868,
-0.0946680978,
-0.3394562304,
-0.7645664811,
0.3175430298,
0.2949915826,
0.3767668903,
0.5766449571,
-0.0563066117,
-0.4587074518,
-0.8167093396,
-0.3083440661,
0.1190128922,
-0.1733386964,
0.0540704839,
0.2295575589,
-0.474801302,
0.589625001,
-0.5771727562,
-0.6397545934,
-0.0973118618,
0.2661786079,
-0.2439560741,
0.6277968884,
0.3124370277,
-0.6220707893,
0.0048338268,
-0.2683883905,
-0.5399599075,
-0.1237858683,
-0.5643607378,
-0.1662281305,
0.6010074615,
0.7218609452,
-0.7014084458,
0.3658726215,
0.3287042975,
-0.343801707,
0.480794847,
-0.1796482056,
-0.001573271,
-0.8622210026,
-0.1030205935,
-0.2936110198,
-0.2375203073,
-0.5596073866,
0.0509524792,
-0.1080902517,
0.1440545768,
-0.0804838687,
0.3466695249,
-0.4144182503,
0.197367236,
-0.2708222866,
0.0188806243,
0.0467738397,
0.4934292138,
-0.0584196225,
0.6541867852,
0.3976332545,
-0.4329406619,
0.0069731744,
0.42130211,
-0.1023625433,
0.0983340517,
-0.5939706564,
0.3187636435,
-0.4490613639,
-0.0013277226,
-1.1601462364,
-0.2962462902,
0.3251515031,
-0.4752344787,
0.257073611,
-0.0001244917,
-0.5561565161,
0.0415212214,
-0.50434798,
0.132286489,
0.3523242474,
-0.3558812439,
0.4667785764,
0.0775522515,
-0.1908314228,
-0.2390828729,
-1.1090061665,
0.0579334125,
-0.1108111218,
-0.5156760812,
0.3534615338,
-0.2137037665,
-0.2489167005,
-0.0924750865,
-0.361345917,
-0.1411772817,
0.1315609366,
0.1960585117,
0.0823629424,
-0.2781597078,
0.1548796147,
0.2726283073,
-0.1365266293,
0.3052033484,
-0.0973656848,
0.8822549582,
-0.1006360129,
-0.2029440403,
-0.654546082,
0.4453599453,
0.6343975067,
-0.2798027992,
0.8759471178,
0.5975286365,
-0.7809001803,
-0.3966853917,
-0.8690149188,
-0.732735157,
-0.4549708664,
0.4163835943,
-0.3523479998,
-0.9737355709,
0.7184277773,
0.0814121813,
0.0528682768,
0.2788690031,
0.4410999417,
0.0754641518,
1.0462056398,
0.3961984813,
0.2054038495,
0.2137862742,
-0.1594665498,
0.1277608573,
-0.615899682,
-0.2923832536,
-0.560287118,
-0.0886365399,
-0.4802545309,
-0.5975714922,
-0.0035944779,
0.3729377389,
-0.046486415,
-0.0988520756,
-0.4923323989,
0.6094901562,
0.3396502435,
0.2483092099,
0.2937176228,
0.3137993217,
-0.0008067809,
-0.3683400452,
-0.5756371617,
-0.6529483795,
1.0047057867,
0.4728989303,
1.1133065224,
0.0169664659,
0.618950069,
0.0702946037,
0.0933923647,
-0.7686367631,
0.4676020741,
-0.2398064286,
-0.2433492243,
-0.5805941224,
-0.5824965835,
-0.7140189409,
0.0815572739,
-0.3193178475,
-0.6568550467,
0.0762654245,
0.282217145,
-0.5572071075,
0.3017841876,
-0.5473591685,
0.7094643116,
-0.0111765163,
-0.7061730027,
-0.3065969348,
-0.4315247536,
0.3969525695,
-0.1322602779,
-0.0050510038,
0.1864992231,
0.2690232396,
0.6813282371,
-0.3397641182,
0.9014988542,
-0.2525680065,
-0.3082673848,
0.1858097166,
0.5886366367,
0.8601370454,
0.4466548264,
-0.117617771,
0.1357025504,
0.0235828552,
-0.1683063507,
-0.7028833628,
0.865167439,
-0.6017380953,
-0.5968958139,
-0.1436982453,
-0.6353869438,
-0.4847652018,
0.1673133224,
0.4057385325,
0.2613287568,
-0.2143570483,
0.322686553,
1.1230040789,
-0.297811389,
0.0815910771,
0.1095962971,
-0.2676419318,
-0.4334520698,
0.7252753973,
0.2086265683,
0.2421261072,
0.1011054441,
0.2979725897,
-0.3658441305,
-0.7456966639,
-0.111831665,
0.2934561372,
-0.6033914685,
-0.3341615498,
-0.6474378705,
-0.276553005,
-0.6051350832,
-0.0200236309,
-0.5626721978,
-0.3484292924,
-0.5225019455,
0.0286891665,
0.2719538212,
0.4736394882,
0.089327313,
0.2014948726,
-0.6114563942,
0.8373430371,
0.3008830547,
0.6498458385,
0.0722207278,
-0.5807023048,
0.0887349173,
0.3972161114,
-0.2351812869,
-0.7504116893,
0.2486589104,
0.2285122275,
0.4322643578,
0.4506317079,
0.3076315224,
1.0384756327,
-0.5039541125,
0.5806540251,
-0.030638203,
-0.9815307856,
0.4530345798,
-0.2349199653,
0.2350694984,
0.6744400263,
0.1187973097,
-0.5511764884,
-0.7205376029,
-0.3575831354,
-0.7074341774,
0.5984749198,
0.4368813038,
0.384719491,
0.132965818,
0.6411553621,
0.4326671958,
0.118566595,
-0.7463937402,
-0.0418632329,
-0.4106496572,
-0.1996182799,
-0.0909865722,
-0.5177592635,
-0.1107975617,
-0.3736087084,
0.7782717347,
-0.2266549617,
0.3295241594,
0.4657272398,
-0.2257401645,
-0.4760861397,
0.2138258219,
0.8018988967,
0.3225942552,
-0.1920013726,
0.2682496309,
0.1483042389,
-0.4551473856,
-0.2235589176,
0.2277928442,
-0.2953621149,
-0.01995028,
0.3234142959,
0.6466475725,
-0.0414176695,
-0.5607477427,
0.2851596475,
-0.1352554709,
-0.3186362684,
-0.2451444417,
0.1900507957,
0.0093129911,
0.3064445555,
0.3875319958,
0.1803103685,
0.1434636116,
-0.4702705145,
0.3671404421,
0.4953340888,
-0.5253542662,
-0.1856545359,
0.974830687,
-0.1564176977,
-0.1814252734,
0.869469583,
-0.0828631222,
-0.3447421491,
0.3664927185,
0.6336309314,
0.9676672816,
-0.3309119344,
0.1231288537,
0.2547190785,
0.5624320507,
-0.277921319,
0.3692216575,
0.1694004983,
-0.6772545576,
-0.3883378208,
-0.7254933715,
-0.058737576,
0.7014799714,
-0.6200813651,
0.1279160976,
-0.4870205522,
0.1274227053,
-0.070540987,
-0.1163999215,
-0.4620038867,
0.0612466447,
0.2700957656,
0.7317576408,
-0.6630482078,
0.7957414389,
0.4302748144,
-0.2614545822,
-0.6331549883,
0.4589537978,
-0.1882961988,
-0.3855533302,
0.0866558477,
0.4412123263,
-0.1675080657,
0.0676045269,
-0.7833509445,
-0.5335504413,
0.64564538,
0.7042511702,
-0.763918817,
0.025943242,
0.5416317582,
0.555257678,
-0.1805499345,
-0.3201351464,
0.6142749786,
0.4473652542,
0.0759796202,
-0.5943034887,
0.2796044052,
-0.0511229262,
-0.0527363941,
0.0533064306,
-0.4081807435,
0.5620322227,
-0.3340302408,
-0.2249815762,
0.4017714858,
0.6644845605,
0.1785834432,
0.358317703,
0.5414514542,
0.3490498066,
0.8921222091,
-0.2681474984,
0.5553925633,
-0.0900949836,
0.3211908937,
1.277028203,
-0.1847395152,
0.8369445205,
0.8473772407,
0.270892024,
-0.0408042632,
0.4793761075,
-0.1156304255,
0.661247611,
0.3978332281,
0.1758654863,
-0.6001290083,
-0.0394005328,
-0.3280124366,
0.4334706664,
0.3659469783,
-0.145957455,
-0.2090706676,
0.2576406896,
0.1424210817,
0.4354281127,
-0.2678908408,
0.7673842907,
0.0378911458,
-0.7577493191,
0.9748639464,
0.0514191166,
0.6020550728,
-0.4212461412,
-0.3219213784,
-0.5689567924,
0.2469741255,
-0.2437596768,
-0.6424090862,
0.8011493683,
-0.0748222768,
-0.193925187,
-0.168661952,
0.6212743521,
-0.661019206,
-0.5234618187,
0.2554516792,
0.3031740487,
0.0130388392,
-0.4603070319,
-0.5315744877,
0.2271351814,
0.1345636696,
-0.2356557548,
-0.0327682756,
0.4938336909,
-0.2304308265,
0.5836973786,
0.7255062461,
0.0077340975,
0.0641401112,
0.2396692038,
0.9544956088,
-0.5818382502,
-0.417625457,
-0.8626435399,
0.2945107818,
0.1309141964,
-0.1438505352,
0.5578556061,
0.6519332528,
0.8483221531,
-0.2753961682,
0.5123087764,
0.3315186799,
0.300768733,
-0.798443377,
1.0491166115,
-0.6743964553,
0.4027352333,
-0.4201570749,
-1.0774184465,
-0.6454703808,
0.7574542165,
-0.1454672664,
-0.1925880611,
0.5424246788,
1.1559833288,
-0.1249832809,
-0.0463854894,
0.4612079263,
0.7282456756,
0.1952200383,
0.4959388673,
0.8143951297,
-0.5498355627,
0.6614200473,
-0.4349449277,
0.0599100329,
-0.2171165198,
-0.5109168291,
-1.1168023348,
-0.5450584292,
-0.3595274389,
-0.4826766253,
0.2258464992,
0.742559433,
0.4567468464,
-1.0536754131,
0.1647330374,
-0.3901355863,
-0.0289797075,
-0.2242156118,
-0.2493828684,
0.3615103364,
-0.4287935495,
-0.5393027067,
0.1795236468,
-0.020317696,
0.3084128499,
-0.4211821854,
-0.240397945,
0.098391287,
0.246150434,
0.4231918454,
-0.1805284917,
-0.992980659,
-0.3659045398,
0.0978125557,
-0.0731250346,
0.0289470386,
0.5135970712,
-0.7326382995,
0.3631261289,
0.3489047885,
0.7104392052,
0.211969018,
0.0675743446,
0.441116333,
-0.584926784,
0.17180641,
0.3159406185,
0.0563599803,
0.4240816236,
-0.6376854181,
0.3769224286,
0.0376449302,
-0.3857968152,
-1.0943521261,
0.074096255,
-0.9346271157,
-0.5208844543,
1.1885206699,
0.277579248,
-0.13004978,
-0.1045698449,
-0.4860810935,
0.4548161328,
-0.1838278025,
1.2110674381,
0.7543842793,
0.1139725149,
-0.1119639277,
-0.6183817387,
0.7456043363,
0.7222543359,
-0.7739289403,
0.6676998734,
0.7638093233,
0.2145800889,
0.0341990851,
0.1375089586,
-0.0423828438,
0.2284098119,
-0.1899681091,
-0.0986400917,
-0.1926222444,
-0.5605469346,
-0.567710042,
0.3156704009,
0.0710210055,
0.0001203398
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11263v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11263v1 | The Fall of ROME: Understanding the Collapse of LLMs in Model Editing | 2024-06-17T07:08:29 | 2024-06-17T07:08:29 | Wanli Yang, Fei Sun, Jiajun Tan, Xinyu Ma, Du Su, Dawei Yin, Huawei Shen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Despite significant progress in model editing methods, their application in
real-world scenarios remains challenging as they often cause large language
models (LLMs) to collapse. Among them, ROME is particularly concerning, as it
could disrupt LLMs with only a single edit. In this paper, we study the root
causes of such collapse. Through extensive analysis, we identify two primary
factors that contribute to the collapse: i) inconsistent handling of prefixed
and unprefixed keys in the parameter update equation may result in very small
denominators, causing excessively large parameter updates; ii) the subject of
collapse cases is usually the first token, whose unprefixed key distribution
significantly differs from the prefixed key distribution in autoregressive
transformers, causing the aforementioned issue to materialize. To validate our
analysis, we propose a simple yet effective approach: uniformly using prefixed
keys during editing phase and adding prefixes during the testing phase. The
experimental results show that the proposed solution can prevent model collapse
while maintaining the effectiveness of the edits. | [
-0.5714841485,
-0.76957798,
0.7815372944,
-0.0552243255,
-0.1361416727,
0.1490954608,
-0.3033258617,
-0.0389121249,
-0.2473690808,
0.4254187346,
-0.5701767206,
-0.3764844835,
-0.7445943952,
0.0929840878,
-0.7543628216,
1.1068460941,
-0.3822778463,
-0.0551220067,
-0.0470702685,
-0.2727808356,
-0.323728174,
-0.4645201862,
-0.9016245008,
-0.2412304729,
0.3943640888,
0.3822026849,
0.8980374932,
0.885405302,
0.6789156199,
0.3658640683,
-0.5920829177,
0.158823967,
-0.481248647,
0.0288277082,
0.059747424,
-0.5833238363,
-0.5389487147,
0.1649106741,
0.8754700422,
0.584343493,
-0.210022673,
0.0275798496,
0.132189393,
0.543536067,
-0.4600702524,
-0.1332324743,
-0.710791409,
-0.1643787473,
-0.2897638083,
-0.1150827184,
-0.4705124795,
0.0028441863,
-0.3496022522,
-0.4356558621,
0.3823049664,
-0.2475064695,
0.9883698225,
0.5502238274,
-0.3338131309,
-0.33774212,
-0.9907886386,
0.5486405492,
-0.7327406406,
0.3827275336,
-0.3973219097,
-0.0611070171,
-0.5597442985,
-0.6046793461,
-0.5734766722,
-0.2964546382,
0.0583322495,
-0.0432063304,
-0.1182213873,
0.2074250281,
0.364544481,
0.4105105698,
-0.1995533556,
0.3209049106,
-0.2939916849,
0.1331778318,
0.2660026848,
0.3930356801,
0.5112648606,
-0.1241392195,
-0.2860456109,
-0.2879503071,
-1.2755395174,
-0.1234769896,
0.4917662442,
0.3304384649,
0.1176961735,
0.3286702037,
0.421926707,
0.5808874369,
0.110806495,
-0.3000510931,
-0.2633699179,
-0.1552315652,
-0.3581990302,
-0.2116663903,
0.7123939395,
0.3809487522,
0.1454655677,
-0.1287279874,
-0.0834051147,
-0.2357871383,
0.2215387374,
-0.5234487653,
0.1378507316,
0.1300689727,
-0.185489282,
-0.2117473632,
0.1428307891,
-0.1622041166,
-0.2229797691,
-0.0687787458,
0.0760887489,
-0.1122239828,
-0.1619687229,
0.0842123851,
-0.0529510677,
-0.2144101262,
0.4690454006,
-0.8314647079,
0.5038231611,
0.799213171,
0.798542738,
-0.2661960125,
-0.3357513845,
-0.3545306325,
0.0523711145,
-0.4915969372,
0.3560040295,
-0.0276992768,
-0.7979695797,
0.1080024913,
0.1684986651,
-0.0650910363,
-0.4688649774,
0.5454676151,
-0.7232943177,
-0.0668616071,
-0.0940682143,
-0.5452597141,
0.0645558313,
0.3165310025,
-0.7371713519,
0.9359665513,
-0.1806762367,
-0.8313933611,
0.2011109442,
-0.7006837726,
-0.3100999594,
-0.1250295788,
-0.2851213813,
-0.4834702015,
0.6755108237,
-0.1575631052,
0.1119810268,
-0.3250492215,
0.149193421,
-0.2769385278,
-0.2088247687,
0.4997142255,
-0.3747967184,
0.7369888425,
0.0431346633,
-0.2103368193,
-0.1477772743,
-0.4267223179,
-0.2145107388,
0.2042511553,
-0.2605957091,
-0.3872033954,
0.3389259875,
0.1324821413,
0.0133776879,
-0.1937893033,
-0.2931456268,
0.6483189464,
-0.2367747873,
0.6718130112,
0.7509946227,
0.3578492999,
0.3623925149,
0.0076873037,
0.459006846,
0.0713897645,
0.4157604277,
0.0514151156,
-0.1663155854,
-1.0708992481,
-0.0076543372,
0.5858109593,
0.4251175821,
-0.2954623103,
0.0066580107,
-0.4382377863,
-0.5594828129,
-0.2771507502,
0.0934756845,
0.2769052684,
0.4184411764,
0.0872553438,
-0.0000250011,
-0.1732590795,
-0.9993952513,
-0.1727187634,
-0.6841160059,
0.1181863472,
-0.1195769906,
0.7584037185,
-0.4641038775,
1.0279363394,
-0.6908755898,
-0.2641741037,
-0.2004448771,
0.2539762855,
0.2084141225,
0.6609909534,
0.4897220731,
-0.7790819407,
-0.0075821457,
-0.0842528939,
-0.3180541098,
-0.0414531119,
-0.4082624018,
0.1238129139,
0.2638331652,
0.7609578371,
-0.6097074151,
0.6781770587,
0.396241188,
-0.1445398331,
0.6859092712,
-0.3675605953,
0.2610248923,
-1.1621359587,
-0.2621785998,
-0.3145308793,
-0.1639221311,
-0.5425443053,
0.3260461688,
0.1679308116,
0.0380251743,
-0.6752077341,
0.383710742,
-0.5227128267,
-0.0847794414,
-0.2373882532,
0.3368772864,
-0.0474132299,
-0.0262662526,
-0.1501694769,
0.8259045482,
0.1969093829,
-0.7375521064,
0.2276105434,
0.5268137455,
0.0288816914,
-0.1116259098,
-0.7457419038,
0.1250230372,
-0.0802983791,
-0.093280673,
-0.955971539,
0.029075386,
-0.046830494,
-0.4382454455,
0.4761677682,
-0.3556492925,
-0.5973362923,
-0.0078375395,
-0.2915487289,
0.2149296701,
0.1908072978,
-0.4950615466,
0.4599438608,
0.3033230901,
-0.1445069313,
-0.2998417616,
-0.9330669641,
0.3605442941,
-0.3081705868,
-0.7588389516,
0.3164587319,
-0.4927527606,
-0.8130212426,
0.0878047496,
-0.1493525207,
0.0283768419,
0.4746158123,
0.3916978836,
0.415818423,
-0.0150255188,
0.1666446924,
0.2539848089,
-0.1416812986,
0.0995850116,
0.2353121936,
0.3084088862,
-0.1530336738,
-0.4054724574,
-0.3644790351,
0.2635070384,
1.2175873518,
-0.1106766164,
0.876154542,
-0.1619645804,
-0.2622634172,
-0.2171715945,
-0.4804900885,
-0.2017382234,
-0.4626200497,
0.3819811046,
-0.4225641787,
-0.7087351084,
0.901248157,
-0.2503016293,
0.355203867,
0.5732462406,
0.6657837033,
-0.0661695898,
0.7375597954,
1.0015949011,
-0.0283812359,
0.3693656623,
-0.3506886065,
0.2484513521,
-0.987444818,
0.0021887876,
-0.6431507468,
-0.0627887845,
-0.8000483513,
-0.3644914031,
0.4629255533,
0.1882360429,
0.0868116319,
0.2571372092,
-0.1651646644,
0.469727844,
0.1663216949,
-0.2124757618,
0.4595841169,
0.0408060439,
-0.2262670845,
-0.2802527845,
-0.5297718048,
-0.6589816809,
0.6562824249,
0.4100496471,
0.9213513136,
0.2045998871,
0.8660609126,
0.3412742913,
0.4991151989,
-0.6024807692,
0.2938114703,
0.0157021768,
-0.8067857623,
-0.3549162447,
-0.1420257837,
-0.3956717849,
0.0433692597,
0.0870915726,
-0.4878736734,
0.4001764059,
0.1381797343,
-0.5536176562,
0.319739908,
-0.371342808,
0.9303081036,
-0.1215009317,
-0.1878813803,
-0.0391702056,
-0.3873917758,
0.4706783593,
-0.0880013108,
0.4504263103,
0.0687084571,
-0.3158980012,
0.5612558126,
-0.7430804968,
0.4668889642,
0.3179796934,
-0.2831402123,
-0.0624638535,
0.3908441961,
0.6358261704,
0.4786758125,
0.0506667383,
0.0082777226,
-0.2395262271,
-0.1260600239,
-0.9834472537,
0.9266702533,
-0.8085666895,
-0.6732882857,
-0.66013062,
-0.3605365455,
-0.1570768952,
-0.187434271,
0.4862419665,
0.6537460685,
-0.2510164976,
-0.064564608,
0.7645486593,
0.13324821,
0.8999278545,
0.7706274986,
-0.2964843214,
-0.6153982282,
0.2066259831,
0.3684168458,
0.6343908906,
-0.3918988705,
-0.2643990517,
-0.1083731726,
-1.0382791758,
-0.5336868763,
0.4060558379,
-0.8915399313,
0.0376433134,
-0.1176338047,
-0.2575552762,
-0.4296597838,
-0.2533088624,
-0.6041725278,
-0.3047092259,
-0.4716825783,
-0.3537369072,
0.1116583869,
0.9667502642,
-0.178041026,
0.5524317026,
-0.8539851308,
0.1253345609,
0.0671095699,
0.0344207659,
-0.1829668134,
-0.9012801051,
-0.3694576621,
-0.218729049,
-0.1098964438,
-1.2475714684,
0.3200886846,
0.1746103019,
0.2187082767,
0.7209300995,
-0.0327878706,
1.0813733339,
-0.7218006849,
0.556185782,
0.1113598719,
-1.1520273685,
0.2812694609,
-0.3507173657,
0.1745548546,
0.6964477301,
0.1520558745,
-0.9172338843,
-0.6421877742,
-0.7740194798,
-0.9508216977,
0.6360543966,
0.4158233106,
0.1371817291,
-0.0807559639,
0.8796309829,
-0.2026166916,
-0.0472056121,
-0.6854261756,
-0.7018011212,
0.5316074491,
0.3715613484,
-0.0061494405,
-0.6145926118,
-0.2496438622,
-0.3591015041,
0.9169533849,
0.0520722829,
-0.2018029988,
0.3501119316,
-0.4123737216,
-0.0873927996,
0.4247512519,
1.0193186998,
0.9485217333,
0.0653776824,
0.0473073646,
0.2854287922,
-0.4098158479,
0.3557490706,
-0.1688537598,
-0.6642053127,
0.2373492271,
0.4505357444,
0.8862118721,
0.4013892412,
-0.4496521056,
0.0891498998,
-0.3786931038,
-0.0557862446,
-0.5544403195,
-0.1984253228,
0.0652274415,
-0.0327462144,
0.7059000134,
0.0964520946,
0.0474056415,
-0.6477211118,
0.2490583956,
0.3811883628,
-0.2010710835,
-0.1783041656,
0.7132408023,
0.0829250962,
-0.2579120994,
0.7226656675,
-0.0868072137,
-0.8482903242,
0.5736374855,
0.3282000124,
0.8421753049,
-0.2857703269,
0.1664876938,
0.1441169232,
0.964017868,
-0.2336858064,
-0.1011125371,
0.2431391925,
-0.588163197,
-0.5186293721,
-0.4275477529,
-0.4730013013,
0.1177151352,
-0.7400838137,
0.2972369194,
-0.5235708356,
-0.3381800056,
-0.4179110527,
-0.1470279843,
-0.038270846,
0.3052161336,
0.2378437072,
0.9636780024,
-1.1088078022,
0.4985128045,
0.5718631744,
-0.4924601018,
-0.6205632091,
0.1861608475,
0.0516491495,
-0.3034676015,
0.8366364241,
-0.2776736915,
0.0282500386,
0.0240895264,
-0.4074997306,
-1.013163209,
0.6021274328,
0.7030906677,
-0.6659166217,
-0.2623955011,
0.3888859153,
0.4231833518,
-0.2979155779,
0.159979254,
0.8054478765,
0.6615870595,
0.11131984,
-0.9586333632,
-0.0361818001,
0.0972443447,
0.0398340113,
0.6661824584,
-0.6216981411,
0.8840865493,
-0.2403552979,
-0.417467922,
0.0912723616,
0.6083171368,
-0.1097035334,
-0.1529276222,
0.4893638492,
1.0257276297,
0.3850006759,
-0.3800261021,
0.8861294389,
-0.3840677142,
0.6990181208,
1.0191397667,
-0.028540954,
1.0224405527,
0.5355308652,
-0.2076774091,
0.4324232936,
0.8937220573,
0.0977680609,
0.1250397861,
0.2855384648,
-0.3449075222,
-0.4594093263,
0.1549679786,
-0.1778868586,
0.2932150662,
0.4011397958,
-0.2891836464,
-0.4968313873,
0.1490038186,
0.4699541628,
-0.0926728994,
-0.245742768,
0.6705699563,
0.1458915472,
-0.4814983904,
0.5760708451,
0.1246248186,
-0.0600015931,
-0.37582919,
0.1246528998,
-0.4167171121,
0.2028671652,
-0.1610773653,
-0.2265052497,
0.3847482204,
0.0979390442,
-0.3918853104,
-0.3032593429,
0.0954097435,
-0.4238538146,
-0.5809853673,
0.482523948,
0.193523705,
0.1162813008,
-0.1699412018,
-0.6176533103,
0.8494976163,
-0.1938623935,
-0.2779255509,
0.0466596968,
0.0425566882,
-0.0445587002,
0.5535122752,
0.4131319225,
0.152510047,
0.195131734,
-0.2460971773,
1.0860128403,
-0.6052260995,
-0.0718885958,
-1.1633002758,
0.8396601081,
-0.0453703478,
-0.2168469727,
0.866975069,
0.5777372122,
0.4481882453,
0.1043422371,
0.6260854602,
-0.0104499245,
0.1676917821,
-0.4956878722,
1.0109139681,
-0.82445544,
0.2886663675,
-0.1365223974,
-0.9084925652,
-0.4250885546,
-0.0038881863,
-0.069676131,
-0.4096535146,
1.0837100744,
0.5609836578,
0.317542702,
-0.6923184991,
0.4612495303,
0.4703741372,
0.4702023566,
0.2547729015,
0.6624515057,
-0.5739804506,
0.6154134274,
0.1125056148,
-0.0260147434,
-0.2178552598,
-0.7995907664,
-0.6752756834,
-0.6509720087,
-0.6406510472,
-0.5006950498,
0.2969600856,
0.6032855511,
0.427629143,
-0.6886811852,
-0.2077717781,
-0.0340886638,
0.3552448153,
0.1696527451,
-0.1182669401,
0.3233578801,
-0.5304303169,
-1.0192307234,
0.5045444965,
0.5179381371,
0.2660207748,
-0.4770868123,
-0.0094877137,
-0.0393419042,
0.114047505,
-0.0046100053,
0.4657747149,
-0.985594213,
-0.0146251675,
-0.1405623257,
-0.1077112257,
0.0686938912,
0.9250292182,
-0.4112558663,
0.3813779056,
0.4735599756,
0.3927063644,
0.1642309278,
0.0683016852,
0.7487412095,
-0.5961325169,
0.1072571278,
-0.0751184598,
0.5979349613,
0.2806563973,
-0.0973475501,
0.2362306565,
0.3646377325,
-0.5807516575,
-1.3210338354,
0.2073104233,
-0.6586401463,
-0.18719998,
0.8975759745,
-0.1511217207,
-0.53491956,
0.0451337434,
-0.0524367914,
0.2612866163,
-0.1168833449,
0.7694200277,
1.1506917477,
-0.0951249897,
-0.1252802759,
-0.4177469313,
0.6987059116,
0.2500442564,
-0.6085518003,
0.3375059068,
0.5196734071,
0.360953629,
0.4731780291,
0.0958948284,
-0.1883345395,
0.3906409144,
-0.4238601923,
0.1056618765,
-0.117062822,
-0.4239685535,
-0.7210108042,
0.387005657,
0.6011492014,
-0.0653669983
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11260v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11260v1 | Adversarial Style Augmentation via Large Language Model for Robust Fake News Detection | 2024-06-17T07:00:41 | 2024-06-17T07:00:41 | Sungwon Park, Sungwon Han, Meeyoung Cha | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The spread of fake news negatively impacts individuals and is regarded as a
significant social challenge that needs to be addressed. A number of
algorithmic and insightful features have been identified for detecting fake
news. However, with the recent LLMs and their advanced generation capabilities,
many of the detectable features (e.g., style-conversion attacks) can be
altered, making it more challenging to distinguish from real news. This study
proposes adversarial style augmentation, AdStyle, to train a fake news detector
that remains robust against various style-conversion attacks. Our model's key
mechanism is the careful use of LLMs to automatically generate a diverse yet
coherent range of style-conversion attack prompts. This improves the generation
of prompts that are particularly difficult for the detector to handle.
Experiments show that our augmentation strategy improves robustness and
detection performance when tested on fake news benchmark datasets. | [
-0.4289849997,
-1.2196599245,
0.3726121783,
0.1604976356,
-0.3810634017,
0.2196333855,
-0.283249557,
-0.5046780705,
0.3439538777,
0.4170049131,
-0.5977064967,
-0.3000277579,
-0.7900104523,
0.1024328619,
-0.626745224,
0.97732234,
-0.0622566603,
0.1296053827,
0.1277979314,
-0.0871441513,
-0.2184587419,
-0.5339924097,
-0.7344022393,
0.0641693473,
0.2882120907,
0.146589905,
0.7670101523,
0.4959796369,
0.2009619772,
0.2392288446,
-0.0169856958,
0.5816213489,
-0.4469806254,
0.0030258179,
0.0261828825,
-0.5622992516,
-0.361367017,
0.1968901306,
0.4112702608,
0.1423055679,
0.1775320321,
0.0852582529,
-0.1680840701,
0.4519351721,
-0.4911611378,
-0.2794350088,
-0.8248225451,
-0.1463718414,
-0.2986595333,
-0.3078846037,
-0.4671876729,
-0.4105153978,
-0.3877503872,
-0.4777195752,
0.3251799047,
-0.0300424714,
0.8091660738,
-0.0435629487,
-0.6162615418,
-0.3392647207,
-0.6898507476,
0.4141055644,
-0.6961225271,
0.2717411816,
-0.0314210132,
0.3986433744,
-0.2987544239,
-0.5469551682,
-0.940836668,
-0.3362009823,
0.0330881365,
-0.0190234464,
-0.318441987,
-0.1794767082,
0.1235501021,
0.2406301051,
-0.5838384628,
0.0836892724,
-0.2355524153,
-0.401256144,
0.6622523069,
-0.1497588307,
0.5891622305,
-0.11720144,
-0.433570385,
-0.2616217136,
-0.7860494256,
-0.1931156367,
0.8724855781,
0.3182266355,
-0.0328026749,
0.2925699055,
-0.2854878604,
0.515539825,
0.1461789161,
-0.2796584964,
0.139303565,
-0.2773642838,
0.0373995565,
0.2438251525,
0.6481077075,
0.3559251726,
0.1964148879,
0.1104275808,
-0.4294465184,
0.4255438149,
0.5313235521,
-0.7434073687,
-0.181120187,
-0.1230831966,
-0.2379243374,
-0.8597877026,
0.1123557463,
-0.5304404497,
-0.6335608363,
-0.2225684226,
0.5520174503,
-0.4948232472,
-0.1494088322,
0.1094096377,
-0.1507172734,
0.0776217282,
0.6027041674,
-0.3065519333,
-0.0519797727,
0.4897459447,
0.7633066177,
-0.0759946927,
-0.0040537883,
-0.6908864379,
-0.085728623,
-0.7222269773,
0.8440112472,
-0.4185181856,
-0.044596415,
0.0355877466,
-0.0060112332,
0.2808902264,
-0.3549017906,
0.5763034821,
-0.8956763148,
0.3299545646,
-0.127867341,
-0.2740781009,
-0.1422945559,
0.4610607624,
-0.6974188089,
0.8526411057,
0.0948953107,
-0.5989953279,
0.3558992743,
-0.5023010969,
-0.7839331031,
0.0275049172,
0.1595469713,
-0.6615647674,
0.1207556725,
0.6199658513,
0.2152059078,
0.2743510008,
0.1962568164,
-0.6254372001,
-0.410925597,
0.460842073,
-0.8931977749,
0.6123231649,
0.3717238307,
-0.3704676926,
0.1404171735,
-0.7181569338,
-0.3560664356,
0.3413124681,
-0.3096826375,
-0.2980453074,
-0.3182507455,
0.1730727851,
0.1349942982,
0.2694271207,
-0.4288452864,
0.3583791554,
-0.3431186676,
0.2760895789,
0.8362967968,
0.0697894767,
0.4197258651,
-0.3509303331,
0.3834191263,
-0.0383679979,
0.1716201454,
-0.2968244255,
-0.2435469627,
-0.7048895359,
-0.2474238724,
0.1744044274,
0.591584146,
-1.1352330446,
0.4735243022,
-0.0397610068,
-0.3218354881,
-0.4750559032,
0.2189334035,
0.2270883024,
0.3391979039,
0.3844938576,
0.1481442004,
-0.5826969147,
-0.6868816614,
-0.7951738834,
-0.0476534031,
-0.064131856,
-0.1071374938,
0.4358590841,
-0.3431372046,
0.6307060719,
-0.2853466272,
-0.1150258854,
-0.3897350132,
0.0052438062,
0.0020149772,
0.2066638917,
0.6804802418,
-1.0938503742,
-0.3901391029,
-0.2259049565,
-0.4866535366,
-0.2802683413,
-0.4077779651,
0.0104111927,
0.2926389277,
0.6647321582,
-0.36517483,
0.4864978194,
0.5426316857,
-0.3369824588,
0.7401099205,
0.1801247597,
0.3416416943,
-1.2718961239,
-0.2742993832,
0.2880497873,
-0.6040717363,
-0.7800658941,
0.1487097889,
0.189928025,
-0.2818620205,
-0.5006210804,
0.7607485056,
-0.2502212822,
0.0905301794,
-0.4729055166,
0.0015959414,
0.3456582427,
0.1085985079,
-0.1367878467,
0.7996473312,
0.3389665186,
-0.4656888545,
0.9007927775,
-0.1712421179,
-0.2908327281,
0.6407647729,
-0.5385232568,
0.1102869883,
-0.1603647619,
0.7459677458,
-1.1776878834,
-0.4187800288,
0.3498872221,
-0.660276711,
0.5031765699,
-0.1647294462,
-0.8699299097,
-0.2838293016,
-0.5900736451,
0.0288448352,
0.2368731648,
-0.8441052437,
0.4778642654,
0.1369403005,
0.0988563821,
-0.3171184361,
-0.6359657645,
0.4845377803,
-0.409707427,
-0.9342652559,
0.4256855249,
-0.0555586293,
-0.2359657288,
-0.1028958783,
-0.0849747285,
0.253774941,
0.1785432696,
-0.3395691514,
0.3288632333,
-0.1802987009,
-0.1177282929,
0.0387090482,
0.3299121261,
-0.0002070043,
-0.2070880085,
0.5626088381,
-0.1122713983,
-0.4008039236,
-0.6919136047,
0.2358228713,
0.8950937986,
-0.0624217987,
0.8339128494,
1.0002138615,
-0.4812279642,
-0.5675222278,
-0.6797847152,
-0.462041229,
-0.5289258361,
0.4422253072,
-0.1356272101,
-0.5811039209,
0.3663105965,
-0.0179332495,
-0.1585170031,
0.1120987087,
0.3010106087,
0.1595717967,
1.3261784315,
0.4343400896,
-0.1925727278,
0.7079994082,
-0.1079094931,
0.2101578563,
-0.5278090835,
0.0497336425,
0.0307440348,
-0.3827847838,
-0.4585874677,
-0.3430183232,
0.5399594307,
0.0548449084,
0.0486127883,
0.3222806156,
-0.3602643907,
0.2756217718,
0.4961084127,
0.4681062996,
0.2593001127,
0.331183821,
0.4198051989,
-0.0009169718,
-0.4523505867,
-0.3901334107,
0.9500071406,
0.5353826284,
0.9591907859,
0.3189718127,
0.3363636732,
0.653614223,
0.3978114426,
-0.8723814487,
0.5042595267,
-0.3750861883,
-0.372130096,
-0.0857972652,
-0.3570455015,
-0.3998591602,
0.2045331746,
-0.3533337116,
-0.2026542872,
0.0328965485,
0.3357649744,
-0.083468318,
0.5784555078,
-0.5586340427,
0.3997227252,
-0.3315344155,
-0.0852646157,
-0.0709955096,
-0.2394064963,
0.5511888266,
-0.2284771055,
0.2690333724,
0.2059863955,
-0.0020906762,
0.4994991422,
-0.298530072,
1.0648745298,
0.0823752955,
-0.1274317503,
0.1241701916,
0.2463562638,
1.0642989874,
0.1238086671,
0.1287164092,
0.0261509679,
-0.6136834621,
-0.3661963344,
-0.6245901585,
0.7119002938,
-0.5817520022,
-0.8060649633,
-0.403929472,
-0.6411516666,
-0.3154381216,
0.0551216491,
0.5100836754,
0.5130565763,
-0.2389226258,
0.1779143214,
0.7597811818,
-0.2203286886,
0.1438607275,
0.5104546547,
-0.162330851,
-0.4114849567,
0.8974341154,
0.2017066628,
0.3004934192,
-0.0136778904,
0.234164536,
-0.6001121402,
-0.6470762491,
-0.7789519429,
0.1039645895,
-0.7260439992,
-0.0860657543,
-0.436283648,
-0.3259144425,
-1.0618222952,
-0.4415015876,
-0.3027299047,
-0.2236825824,
-0.4902059734,
-0.0024288343,
0.5518530607,
0.6273964643,
0.102429308,
0.4131405652,
-0.4983770847,
0.6401673555,
0.4850353599,
-0.1167152002,
-0.4908281565,
-1.0357886553,
0.0591763929,
0.2018439174,
-0.3266640902,
-1.0714693069,
0.6233549118,
0.0035326981,
0.3708627224,
0.5872472525,
0.2541318238,
0.6021084785,
-0.2714771032,
0.6670446396,
0.0516067445,
-0.756462872,
0.6946156621,
-0.6196451187,
-0.0035468799,
0.2582796812,
0.3332797885,
-0.499910146,
-0.3824352026,
-0.6766471863,
-0.6676992774,
0.6038315296,
0.022091046,
0.4140723646,
-0.0001028933,
0.2078552395,
-0.2184155583,
0.3206402361,
-0.8844949007,
-0.2507519722,
-0.4332336485,
-0.0635385215,
0.1977681667,
-0.1526999474,
-0.2682555318,
0.0252381414,
0.8988718987,
-0.2325192839,
-0.0503514446,
-0.0273104124,
-0.1909514219,
-0.0216784123,
0.2906863391,
0.8058065176,
0.3416285813,
0.1136976555,
0.1195828915,
0.1428855509,
-0.4003383219,
0.0030462823,
0.1673159152,
-0.3900427222,
0.1871178448,
0.3777122796,
0.933275938,
-0.2583110631,
-0.3931993842,
0.7347224355,
-0.0185029916,
-0.1199501902,
-0.3976040781,
0.1426321417,
-0.2236565202,
0.1596826166,
0.6620528102,
0.4017658532,
0.1428394616,
-0.9132220745,
0.2546881735,
0.7114276886,
-0.2215123922,
-0.2706733942,
0.6460098028,
0.2290744632,
-0.235891223,
0.0193772241,
-0.4558212757,
-0.943831861,
0.5944909453,
0.9544818401,
0.5042093992,
-0.3961501718,
0.2861721814,
0.0374275222,
0.6017299294,
-0.2846284211,
-0.0470923744,
0.3590862751,
-0.8286917806,
-0.214556545,
-0.6730513573,
-0.2278794497,
0.6994912624,
-0.4013871849,
0.6192968488,
-0.4277123809,
0.1183179915,
-0.2293662876,
-0.1148634553,
-0.2146174014,
0.3411045074,
0.5268836617,
0.7870114446,
-1.0858038664,
0.6259335279,
0.7964761257,
0.0894742459,
-0.4205135405,
0.4622147679,
0.5624032617,
-0.8979046941,
0.4097496569,
0.3429711759,
-0.1058820188,
-0.1273185164,
-0.6682581306,
-0.7294194102,
0.6914891601,
0.613540709,
-0.4545699656,
-0.0842547342,
-0.0330471359,
0.40953058,
-0.5095511079,
-0.1959110498,
0.2789672613,
0.5452042818,
0.1563041657,
-0.5255482793,
0.1801214665,
-0.1745190322,
0.0652678758,
0.1340672821,
-0.649448216,
0.9029226899,
0.0220489092,
-0.3727568984,
-0.1915231049,
0.8503268957,
0.3187750876,
0.416244626,
0.5942437649,
0.5821121931,
0.582649827,
-0.0264872164,
1.1170823574,
-0.2771123052,
0.0367744714,
0.7536195517,
-0.0409462154,
0.4344874322,
0.0511038788,
-0.0298952665,
0.5548879504,
0.5678995252,
-0.1280116886,
0.2916931212,
0.0730012953,
-0.5698208213,
-0.3575589061,
-0.1525258124,
-0.3777290881,
0.4638212919,
0.6679661274,
-0.478579849,
-0.1143024042,
0.3847629726,
0.567761004,
0.4206831753,
-0.5992617011,
0.4626369476,
-0.1374435425,
-0.3993105292,
0.5840036869,
0.2670568228,
1.1231769323,
-0.7039885521,
-0.0158482641,
-0.0767405182,
0.1467017084,
-0.1871999204,
-0.6550291777,
0.2056202888,
-0.0734935775,
-0.0889474079,
-0.0554934293,
1.1534582376,
-0.5453415513,
-0.6522249579,
0.1563953608,
0.1927332282,
-0.231726706,
-0.388096422,
-0.6626495123,
0.1820358336,
0.0113449898,
-0.4142815173,
0.4043727517,
0.2886067033,
-0.2709787786,
0.5864225626,
1.180328846,
0.4315397441,
0.061293114,
0.0920833871,
1.034991622,
-0.2379785329,
-0.6004647613,
-0.9062745571,
0.0012269752,
-0.3779462576,
-0.1265954673,
1.0237209797,
0.2874066532,
0.8088423014,
0.0869381949,
0.9859632254,
0.2967405915,
0.4592128098,
-0.7305301428,
0.82175529,
-0.6103631258,
0.4570005238,
-0.0879931748,
-0.6316471696,
-0.2986837924,
0.3516163826,
-0.2920693457,
0.0872215703,
0.3416661024,
0.9735977054,
-0.1434279233,
-0.2979130447,
0.4208529592,
0.1797654629,
0.4227101803,
0.1035139859,
0.6387780905,
-0.4018152654,
0.8424880505,
-0.3256836236,
-0.1760347337,
-0.5509681106,
-0.8448731899,
-1.0471299887,
-0.2335933447,
-0.2947925031,
-0.8229247928,
0.2759463787,
0.7546392679,
0.8023008704,
-0.7016096711,
0.3780283034,
0.010801008,
0.0234820731,
-0.0669862255,
-0.4004381895,
0.2602654696,
-0.2360273451,
-0.8804275393,
0.9096801877,
0.1352477968,
0.245214656,
-0.547913909,
0.2088033706,
0.0025551401,
0.4866255522,
0.6225030422,
0.1889205575,
-0.7688346505,
-0.3279466331,
0.0758878812,
-0.1907258779,
-0.1536587477,
0.698592484,
-0.762132287,
0.4946702123,
0.5070827007,
0.739331305,
0.1191183627,
0.3788720071,
0.4705451131,
-1.1784008741,
0.2224665582,
0.0898335353,
0.3676591814,
0.6380159855,
-0.8996485472,
0.0737430304,
0.6959377527,
-0.2963927984,
-1.064044714,
0.5214084387,
-0.6972965598,
-0.6442715526,
1.47674191,
0.1584756672,
-0.392329365,
-0.2279791683,
-0.228862524,
0.1962100565,
-0.5742470026,
0.759039402,
0.4869089723,
0.0796194375,
-0.0867345855,
-0.400493443,
0.6380406022,
0.1035802513,
-0.6932355165,
-0.1076385975,
0.5444998145,
0.4191250801,
0.2997518778,
0.330314219,
-0.0506647453,
0.5022004843,
-0.1458245218,
-0.2158011049,
-0.4105744958,
-0.444525063,
-0.3852294087,
0.064419426,
-0.3053230941,
-0.0225203447
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11258v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11258v1 | Enhancing Biomedical Knowledge Retrieval-Augmented Generation with Self-Rewarding Tree Search and Proximal Policy Optimization | 2024-06-17T06:48:31 | 2024-06-17T06:48:31 | Minda Hu, Licheng Zong, Hongru Wang, Jingyan Zhou, Jingjing Li, Yichen Gao, Kam-Fai Wong, Yu Li, Irwin King | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown great potential in the biomedical
domain with the advancement of retrieval-augmented generation (RAG). However,
existing retrieval-augmented approaches face challenges in addressing diverse
queries and documents, particularly for medical knowledge queries, resulting in
sub-optimal performance. To address these limitations, we propose a novel
plug-and-play LLM-based retrieval method called Self-Rewarding Tree Search
(SeRTS) based on Monte Carlo Tree Search (MCTS) and a self-rewarding paradigm.
By combining the reasoning capabilities of LLMs with the effectiveness of tree
search, SeRTS boosts the zero-shot performance of retrieving high-quality and
informative results for RAG. We further enhance retrieval performance by
fine-tuning LLMs with Proximal Policy Optimization (PPO) objectives using the
trajectories collected by SeRTS as feedback. Controlled experiments using the
BioASQ-QA dataset with GPT-3.5-Turbo and LLama2-7b demonstrate that our method
significantly improves the performance of the BM25 retriever and surpasses the
strong baseline of self-reflection in both efficiency and scalability.
Moreover, SeRTS generates higher-quality feedback for PPO training than
self-reflection. Our proposed method effectively adapts LLMs to document
retrieval tasks, enhancing their ability to retrieve highly relevant documents
for RAG in the context of medical knowledge queries. This work presents a
significant step forward in leveraging LLMs for accurate and comprehensive
biomedical question answering. | [
0.0265582986,
-0.5587247014,
0.9316715002,
-0.1061686203,
-0.3766529858,
0.3333426714,
0.1539015919,
-0.2926465273,
0.4407300353,
0.6578935385,
-0.4431968331,
-0.3876212239,
-0.3787325323,
0.2083852887,
0.1817737371,
1.0602952242,
0.1661850065,
0.0303343534,
-0.416757822,
0.0657527819,
-0.1843254119,
-0.4349497855,
-0.5808821917,
-0.2298317701,
0.8877225518,
0.2677117586,
0.3512488306,
0.5977320671,
0.7005682588,
0.2152940184,
-0.2813463807,
0.5081202984,
-0.4909305274,
0.3249649107,
-0.3620256782,
-0.3308934271,
-0.338657707,
-0.3557550013,
0.4705310762,
0.1519854665,
-0.1278163195,
0.0289453007,
-0.0119847991,
0.6840505004,
-0.6997274756,
0.1774466336,
-0.7494827509,
-0.0547909327,
-0.2675326765,
-0.9373134971,
-0.1932065785,
-0.3984008133,
0.0513423011,
-0.5900589228,
0.0253635161,
0.0372355953,
0.587980628,
0.2669730186,
-0.462323308,
-0.2706628442,
-0.2640432715,
0.5321691632,
-0.8199454546,
0.2842456698,
0.4533278048,
0.2839165628,
-0.40623945,
-0.6134918332,
-0.2556646466,
-0.2819069922,
-0.0656309873,
0.394582063,
0.058547318,
0.2817866802,
0.0460802279,
0.250108093,
-0.6032338142,
-0.0684012771,
-0.0909337848,
-0.1114382222,
0.5396890044,
0.0290351976,
-0.0181192718,
-0.4640657306,
-0.1359020919,
-0.1919105649,
-0.9168786407,
0.1735815704,
0.0053531183,
0.094209075,
0.529286921,
0.5913339257,
-0.1919502169,
0.5760602355,
-0.1039909571,
-0.435954839,
0.2038172632,
-0.3686283827,
0.0306849331,
-0.0370991826,
0.7544590831,
0.1328886747,
-0.2647197843,
-0.292493701,
-0.2959809899,
-0.4838161767,
0.2458603382,
-0.9425660968,
-0.0135158682,
0.0988393649,
-0.2893984616,
-0.565227747,
-0.45997262,
-0.6447831392,
-0.3713018596,
0.0692301169,
0.7199492455,
-0.5843123794,
-0.0406920984,
-0.0011972932,
0.0325365327,
-0.0872843415,
0.211354062,
-0.7819340229,
0.0204028934,
0.439905405,
0.7383292913,
-0.1145452484,
0.2000890523,
-0.7946500778,
0.4991700053,
-0.3357241452,
0.7524040937,
-0.5687026978,
-0.5646198988,
-0.1987308413,
0.0382073633,
0.0470578298,
-0.658454299,
0.559726119,
-0.7508018017,
0.0823996887,
-0.326939851,
-0.4419119954,
-0.0324545391,
0.294136405,
-0.1464980841,
0.822752893,
0.1634400487,
-0.7522423267,
0.2181978673,
-0.609992981,
-0.4683122337,
0.4480256736,
-0.6017548442,
-0.6122959256,
0.0533992648,
0.3417152762,
0.3949056864,
-0.2463878244,
0.4479255974,
-0.2062441856,
-0.1640269756,
0.0946200565,
-0.1284365505,
0.5216112733,
0.2807413936,
-0.2568544447,
0.0292865243,
-0.5625802875,
0.1386537105,
0.20772475,
-0.2902725637,
-0.4144880176,
0.2527030408,
-0.643620193,
0.167198047,
0.383472383,
-0.7819140553,
0.3936034739,
-0.6066695452,
0.2305089533,
0.5877763033,
0.3607054055,
0.1305432618,
-0.4062081575,
0.5483651161,
0.0668659583,
0.1246746108,
-0.1399013847,
-0.2903881073,
-0.0190299321,
-0.3449989855,
0.2530680597,
0.4473764598,
-0.8735389113,
0.3171661496,
-0.1120181531,
-0.3993687332,
-0.6762406826,
-0.136960879,
0.569737196,
0.8412684202,
0.6418371201,
-0.1641927809,
-0.4407091737,
-0.7690084577,
-0.1205490679,
-0.1792136133,
-0.0270680748,
0.8347449303,
0.3146517873,
-0.2364077717,
0.9160212278,
-0.5291317701,
-0.3334699273,
0.0692831725,
0.127940774,
0.3612155914,
0.42690593,
0.3435198963,
-0.5815957189,
-0.2025254816,
0.1128490716,
-0.5308232307,
-0.221235767,
0.0517858863,
0.0084837815,
0.1643092632,
0.2920209765,
-0.2905258238,
0.2781960666,
0.332647264,
-0.1937274635,
0.6528618932,
-0.5697650313,
0.3287938535,
-0.7821251154,
0.2799316645,
-0.446258992,
-0.3195725679,
-0.0142804021,
-0.126837492,
0.1126961187,
0.1822224706,
-0.2615867555,
0.4609421194,
-0.3785211146,
-0.1856261194,
-0.2968117297,
-0.0442955196,
0.0460897908,
0.2470289022,
-0.0087517826,
1.1086078882,
0.3166384697,
-0.5314330459,
-0.0033639038,
0.2224106044,
0.0438741893,
0.301767379,
-0.5461119413,
-0.0560096912,
-0.3685622513,
0.230638817,
-0.7303574681,
0.0076838583,
0.0506264046,
-0.399409771,
0.383487165,
-0.1155267134,
-0.5615335107,
-0.4529089034,
-0.3031041324,
0.3604388237,
0.5561216474,
-0.5372123122,
0.3251802325,
0.4407177866,
-0.231481567,
-0.5802861452,
-0.1834162474,
-0.059112519,
-0.1134309694,
-0.3733927906,
0.5947754383,
-0.0264854264,
0.3715801537,
-0.0607157163,
-0.4134968221,
0.4099521637,
0.0218625218,
-0.081668891,
0.1529527605,
0.0283664223,
0.2781305909,
0.4456858039,
-0.0687326863,
0.0413481221,
-0.4487544596,
0.2860562503,
-0.0159557797,
-0.312497884,
-0.0592626259,
0.0507849045,
0.1716634333,
-0.5407015681,
0.4237796068,
0.4533024728,
0.0031102318,
0.128722921,
-0.6345922947,
-0.5280719399,
-0.4487836063,
0.4293314219,
-0.5694821477,
-1.2829366922,
0.211673528,
-0.3782663047,
0.0363937728,
0.408362031,
0.5474733114,
-0.4351115823,
1.3329480886,
0.1602595448,
0.2614311576,
0.2825483978,
-0.2406817526,
0.0745828971,
-1.0831917524,
-0.4674825072,
-0.436429292,
-0.0715098828,
-0.7463843226,
-0.5993152261,
0.9718280435,
0.165184781,
-0.1309783161,
0.0067322967,
-0.7538754344,
0.3961509764,
0.6461572051,
0.4095830917,
0.47220397,
0.0479621962,
-0.6111947298,
0.019368019,
-1.0683090687,
-0.3077332973,
1.0916755199,
0.0954214185,
0.6038026214,
-0.0027388392,
1.1235724688,
-0.0584696643,
0.2789955437,
-0.3881702423,
0.4933718741,
-0.2774472833,
-0.381457299,
-0.3803028464,
-0.7737132311,
-1.315567255,
0.1569288373,
-0.1267974973,
-0.7578053474,
0.1720778644,
0.1706281006,
-0.4768245518,
0.2497582734,
-0.2483063489,
0.7658234835,
-0.5395595431,
-0.6849963665,
-0.2722905874,
-0.8279986978,
0.2338202894,
-0.0539289415,
0.245404914,
-0.2163662314,
-0.1081563607,
0.6764298677,
-0.2961861491,
0.3590799868,
-0.199597612,
0.0548294894,
0.2769702673,
0.3155920208,
0.6223326325,
0.2340141386,
-0.0150656141,
-0.3029105961,
0.5901139975,
-0.3083253503,
-0.5298159719,
0.6388459206,
-0.7058316469,
-0.6857587695,
-0.5508877039,
-0.7523383498,
-0.5115277767,
0.2852669954,
0.0836669654,
0.2910611331,
0.0522702597,
0.3468822539,
0.7986506224,
-0.4756812453,
0.0839506686,
0.7880294919,
-0.4973165691,
-0.4692084491,
1.1208212376,
0.24123092,
0.0292397626,
0.6537153125,
0.5988668799,
-0.6193576455,
-0.5991801023,
-0.1818073839,
0.5039115548,
-0.1125454679,
-0.7263816595,
-0.832554996,
-0.3641179502,
-0.5710667372,
0.1421773881,
-0.1499993503,
-0.363314271,
-0.1828681082,
0.108174853,
0.4547073543,
0.4852617383,
-0.4353043437,
0.3376754224,
-0.8607499599,
0.3171314597,
0.3431894481,
0.4721230268,
-0.2922358811,
-0.4823659956,
-0.2575309873,
0.0323414877,
-0.5415325165,
-0.9978243709,
0.5197873712,
-0.0254540872,
0.5666034222,
0.1353059709,
-0.0498177409,
0.5400670171,
-0.4053553641,
0.1942200065,
0.0647449642,
-0.2410032302,
0.7392115593,
-0.6013867855,
0.1989443451,
0.546338737,
0.3009842634,
-0.1891373992,
-0.3680127561,
-0.8521633744,
-0.865195334,
0.6398124695,
0.231470421,
-0.3080777824,
-0.1829715669,
0.5142973661,
-0.1491221786,
0.2157086134,
-0.2979999483,
0.1249558926,
-0.0022689954,
-0.1993249655,
0.0808196589,
-0.4556147754,
-0.247751087,
-0.25866431,
0.9850686789,
-0.3792154193,
0.1540400386,
0.5867336392,
0.2532406747,
-0.1468858421,
0.3034736812,
0.2300743014,
0.3053477407,
-0.614947319,
0.142374754,
0.0724780113,
-0.2823209465,
0.1253647804,
0.2425628006,
-0.3714620173,
-0.0859638825,
-0.1393924654,
0.4713197351,
0.1468309462,
-0.8166152239,
0.4036477804,
0.0973918289,
-0.1715924889,
0.1500430554,
0.213776961,
0.1739692539,
0.3447072804,
0.4666960835,
-0.4293572009,
0.4462106526,
-0.2489969879,
0.4092200696,
0.7859457135,
-0.1146435291,
0.1331614405,
0.7143954635,
-0.0275057741,
-0.183501929,
0.192188397,
-0.3369014859,
-0.3144935668,
0.466617614,
0.8019846082,
0.4586167037,
-0.3565416634,
0.3585114479,
0.533425808,
0.0836309716,
0.0360762514,
0.3833110929,
-0.194148168,
-0.408488065,
-0.6342650056,
-0.7852932811,
-0.369651109,
0.0384690873,
-0.1995922923,
0.0416499153,
-0.0871444717,
-0.2624444067,
-0.3079640865,
0.3243509531,
-0.3520338833,
0.2363972962,
-0.2383047044,
0.7058088183,
-0.239174664,
0.8178606629,
0.5436617136,
-0.4585974216,
-0.8628689647,
-0.2726740539,
-0.3594764769,
-0.9063790441,
0.535436511,
-0.2197443545,
-0.0524675101,
0.4001592696,
-0.4066992104,
-1.0605956316,
1.2949435711,
0.3052367568,
-0.8521030545,
-0.3271868527,
0.1008343026,
0.6459568739,
-0.2243780196,
0.552300632,
0.5854699016,
0.2399659753,
0.488717556,
-0.7870203853,
-0.0385675989,
0.1642174721,
0.0743538439,
0.0995322391,
-0.5795604587,
0.2055287659,
-0.2304018736,
0.1816207767,
-0.0876153409,
0.4528591931,
1.0020757914,
0.4047101438,
0.2863764167,
0.4715672135,
0.7225049734,
0.2096959651,
1.0747625828,
-0.5019930005,
0.2911403775,
0.9027077556,
-0.0516317897,
0.5935811996,
0.6241084337,
-0.2793160081,
0.3248898983,
0.5552050471,
0.3035669923,
0.579143703,
0.3526070118,
-0.3123645782,
-0.3144275844,
-0.4232631922,
-0.4661706686,
0.1916712523,
0.3822936118,
-0.4088690281,
-0.3257303238,
-0.1104632169,
0.1141975969,
-0.0706062242,
-0.1844781041,
1.0192993879,
0.0464091003,
-0.7506409883,
0.4774069488,
-0.1897530556,
0.4027072787,
-0.6971385479,
-0.1374080181,
-0.2696191072,
-0.0986346528,
-0.1893422157,
-0.8076190352,
0.1188811585,
-0.1710962951,
0.1469877064,
-0.1891436428,
0.8673718572,
-0.4519164562,
-0.4559299648,
0.2035628408,
0.6607304215,
0.2420763075,
-0.0390078351,
-0.7091670632,
-0.3337951601,
-0.039685145,
-0.3389850557,
0.533318162,
0.6395656466,
-0.0069761327,
0.6099795103,
0.8389671445,
0.3364341557,
-0.180486843,
-0.102805987,
0.9585521221,
-0.4457245767,
-0.3532681465,
-0.5661926866,
0.1028063223,
-0.0064980127,
0.142081663,
0.4077779949,
0.8644071221,
0.4747790396,
0.1335352808,
0.6191506982,
-0.0679680929,
1.026611805,
-0.3713976145,
0.670691967,
-0.8289076686,
0.2730418146,
-0.2049270868,
-0.6011329889,
-0.2452584058,
0.6227191091,
-0.5172419548,
-0.0109825265,
0.5316584706,
0.9745638967,
0.1749599874,
-0.29734689,
0.3934271336,
0.4374512136,
0.490739882,
0.5602757335,
0.5120536685,
-0.1868960261,
0.5687999129,
-0.1613868326,
-0.36032781,
-0.2516618371,
-0.7420341969,
-0.4485813975,
-0.4593769014,
-0.0924125835,
-0.4168975353,
0.6326811314,
0.7862678766,
0.6607393026,
-0.5758760571,
-0.185626328,
-0.2560028136,
0.1665776819,
0.0423757695,
-0.1916135401,
0.5190434456,
-0.8305222988,
-0.222524792,
0.5627972484,
0.4476816356,
-0.0597948246,
-0.0781318992,
-0.1735052913,
-0.3722685277,
-0.0138312541,
0.6171827316,
0.3689377308,
-0.3921663165,
-0.1029087678,
0.2917382717,
-0.2145721912,
0.2832387388,
0.7031571269,
-1.335829258,
0.4778575003,
0.5180691481,
0.8937222362,
0.8839482069,
0.091145739,
0.3226844966,
-0.5994007587,
-0.3750489056,
0.7153468132,
0.0740448236,
0.063047953,
-0.4780837595,
0.7225748897,
0.3846923411,
-0.9788935184,
-0.7303758264,
0.1213729456,
-0.8071431518,
-0.3046178818,
1.0389621258,
0.0881792158,
-0.323962599,
0.1524320841,
-0.5024571419,
0.3931791484,
-0.3940827549,
1.0038962364,
0.0977996066,
-0.5530645251,
-0.2257198393,
-0.4128847718,
0.7866788507,
0.7804966569,
-0.8993928432,
-0.2511498928,
0.4005844295,
0.1705555618,
-0.145662114,
0.9580424428,
-0.4812933505,
0.2889856994,
-0.5406033397,
-0.0405923203,
-0.1060857698,
-0.3091112971,
-0.0095615191,
0.0743853897,
0.1386208832,
0.0959116891
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11256v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11256v1 | Dynamic Data Mixing Maximizes Instruction Tuning for Mixture-of-Experts | 2024-06-17T06:47:03 | 2024-06-17T06:47:03 | Tong Zhu, Daize Dong, Xiaoye Qu, Jiacheng Ruan, Wenliang Chen, Yu Cheng | cs.CL | cs.CL | Mixture-of-Experts (MoE) models have shown remarkable capability in
instruction tuning, especially when the number of tasks scales. However,
previous methods simply merge all training tasks (e.g. creative writing,
coding, and mathematics) and apply fixed sampling weights, without considering
the importance of different tasks as the model training state changes. In this
way, the most helpful data cannot be effectively distinguished, leading to
suboptimal model performance. To reduce the potential redundancies of datasets,
we make the first attempt and propose a novel dynamic data mixture for MoE
instruction tuning. Specifically, inspired by MoE's token routing preference,
we build dataset-level representations and then capture the subtle differences
among datasets. Finally, we propose to dynamically adjust the sampling weight
of datasets by their inter-redundancies, thus maximizing global performance
under a limited training budget. The experimental results on two MoE models
demonstrate the effectiveness of our approach on both downstream knowledge \&
reasoning tasks and open-ended queries. Code and models are available at
https://github.com/Spico197/MoE-SFT . | [
-0.5047762394,
-0.8065623045,
0.1313487738,
0.2063978016,
-0.2664469779,
0.4207633138,
-0.2529189587,
-0.2672690749,
0.3114634454,
0.418640852,
-0.6951223016,
-0.2747269571,
-0.610947907,
-0.2056509703,
-0.4764548838,
0.7300223708,
0.0268727336,
0.1045291424,
-0.3662165999,
-0.076187849,
-0.8470359445,
-0.0638878196,
-0.501077652,
-0.2247113734,
0.496473521,
0.6938670278,
0.3927434385,
1.089640379,
0.3350058496,
0.2959870696,
0.0991508812,
0.7157868147,
-0.6225218177,
0.3868512213,
-0.1928353906,
-0.763417542,
-0.4969376624,
-0.0949635133,
0.6447584033,
0.6389049888,
-0.4476975799,
-0.0878043324,
-0.003692077,
0.5685696006,
-0.7640847564,
0.0991830379,
-0.8539456725,
0.2259920388,
-0.2404675782,
-0.5243800282,
-0.2832368612,
-0.1913922727,
0.0828336924,
-0.7765704989,
0.2928360403,
-0.0199095663,
0.5147567391,
0.6450695992,
-0.618737936,
-0.1772274971,
-0.67721802,
0.9511927962,
-0.5022002459,
0.2842870951,
0.1977575868,
0.4089151323,
-0.1755209416,
-0.3154941201,
-0.4361251891,
0.1998466253,
0.2905611396,
0.2801815867,
0.0943368375,
-0.0429650173,
-0.0365260802,
0.5311058164,
-0.0768801793,
0.1806344837,
-0.3285162151,
0.061862994,
0.7190206051,
0.3106105924,
0.1867486984,
0.3304789364,
-0.4993023574,
-0.1786588132,
-0.5421070457,
-0.0627564788,
0.5773668885,
0.0359249562,
-0.0317835063,
0.3104758859,
-0.3564216197,
0.8839532137,
0.4217334092,
0.0615528934,
0.0963672027,
-0.1799417883,
0.0113993604,
0.1280595213,
0.3559786677,
0.48276788,
0.1705722213,
-0.2483103126,
-0.3852362037,
-0.1635265499,
0.440692544,
-0.6461007595,
-0.7268239856,
-0.0082375994,
-0.0166104119,
-0.4990040362,
0.1982704401,
-0.8362720013,
-0.3829012513,
-0.6764512658,
0.4101539254,
-0.3605516851,
-0.4425334334,
0.1329037845,
-0.1360582709,
-0.2554421723,
0.3099268675,
-1.1047481298,
0.1939285994,
0.8408887386,
0.4964177012,
-0.3449037373,
-0.1208623499,
-0.7298516035,
0.1536193788,
-0.3002018631,
0.6899077892,
-0.9737023711,
-0.47577703,
-0.356503278,
-0.4984844327,
-0.295812577,
-0.8329122066,
0.0096322512,
-0.6118272543,
0.0778759047,
-0.4217067361,
-0.7871392369,
-0.1862654537,
0.0641380921,
-0.5115376115,
1.2668983936,
0.1734494418,
-0.5704725981,
0.442448765,
-0.5863758326,
-0.5335353613,
-0.1056906655,
-0.3829342723,
-0.1822912842,
0.3141142726,
0.3763746917,
0.2991368175,
0.0374362245,
0.4824227691,
-0.2106303573,
-0.6122796535,
0.0554412678,
-0.7035266161,
0.5511827469,
0.1266982555,
-0.3841331899,
0.1322770417,
-0.931253016,
0.0233475883,
-0.0775447264,
-0.6460499763,
-0.3768026531,
0.2980326116,
-0.3078475893,
-0.1410063207,
0.3059418201,
-0.2702141404,
0.4393617809,
-0.0630546361,
0.4258264899,
1.1285398006,
-0.0333879143,
0.5275821686,
-0.4657628536,
0.5578049421,
0.2889446914,
0.0747701377,
-0.2550317347,
-0.5630236268,
-0.9575701952,
-0.5103790164,
0.5900509357,
0.6964913607,
-0.8980507255,
0.68739748,
-0.3352483511,
-0.4599990249,
-0.6424068809,
0.1377468407,
0.0683398172,
0.6469547749,
0.5248995423,
-0.2041030675,
-0.3181650937,
-0.6766436696,
-0.2131742686,
0.1807986498,
0.0859538838,
0.3888167739,
0.0893401653,
0.0607048571,
1.043422699,
-0.6154801846,
0.2188445479,
-0.0048181596,
0.170219481,
0.0729737431,
0.7654516697,
0.5205525756,
-0.7984580398,
-0.5740889907,
-0.0592140332,
-0.5530804992,
-0.2741936743,
-0.1474612057,
-0.6902011633,
-0.4098700285,
0.2161847502,
-0.3716132045,
0.2141750008,
0.4339725375,
0.0323225446,
0.2693852484,
-0.2832385004,
0.1913218498,
-1.024330616,
-0.4024415314,
-0.2597245574,
-0.1727768034,
-0.2932484448,
0.2174358815,
0.1542654485,
0.022798365,
-0.0737911016,
0.4908374846,
-0.4252854884,
0.23468256,
-0.2358596176,
-0.2160920501,
-0.1484864801,
0.5730932951,
-0.2364953905,
0.8595556617,
0.8158848286,
-0.7187133431,
0.674893558,
0.0181869324,
-0.4161458015,
0.6709946394,
-0.5004228354,
0.0804163292,
0.0647304207,
0.1711236984,
-0.7597723007,
-0.5086316466,
0.2902956605,
-0.1695841253,
0.5938617587,
-0.1746608615,
-0.4978951216,
-0.1224357486,
-0.0992169157,
0.4211637378,
0.5950103998,
-0.5113435984,
0.7324866652,
0.3028718233,
-0.1570105255,
-0.5628539324,
-0.7395096421,
-0.1696152985,
-0.1880027056,
-0.4936270416,
0.5811211467,
-0.1224525347,
0.0941443443,
0.2079912275,
-0.5589526296,
-0.401404798,
0.1915716529,
-0.0891693234,
0.2211739421,
-0.3273665011,
0.0142259849,
0.8386307359,
-0.117064409,
-0.141280964,
-0.4105540216,
0.3839091957,
0.3741473854,
-0.737095952,
-0.47129035,
0.5016027689,
0.6375351548,
-0.4238077104,
0.8353942633,
0.6327366233,
-0.1290585399,
-0.3927696049,
-0.5482536554,
-0.3925457597,
-0.5218755007,
0.4095790386,
-0.0470288359,
-0.4959383607,
0.4731977284,
-0.075549759,
0.4335772991,
-0.0820109472,
0.2888613641,
-0.1516146064,
0.9592894912,
0.2551361918,
-0.1740082502,
0.8930661082,
-0.3208638728,
0.2744133472,
-0.501847744,
-0.2338908464,
-0.0312226564,
-0.8743966222,
-0.3724946976,
-0.5032745004,
0.6559010148,
0.0616066791,
-0.050413847,
-0.2122852653,
-0.5375159383,
0.7631340027,
0.9142585993,
0.4156980515,
0.0720700398,
0.3053309917,
-0.0463541076,
0.167581141,
-1.1960738897,
-0.1281519383,
1.1196289062,
-0.0266954191,
0.7066874504,
-0.2275450379,
0.7794852853,
0.2595615983,
0.0059531857,
-0.4938372076,
0.711776793,
-0.3063411415,
-0.618858695,
-0.0668197125,
-0.7341470122,
-0.7136092782,
0.2475764751,
-0.3656896353,
-0.2081756592,
0.1361619234,
0.4759810269,
-0.4113221169,
0.5983105302,
-0.8431509733,
0.4250053763,
-0.3032829762,
-0.4598224759,
-0.4179739356,
-0.4789375961,
0.2655810714,
-0.1730899513,
-0.0897372738,
-0.0648057535,
-0.0758329332,
0.576924026,
-0.5000017881,
0.7192069292,
-0.295668155,
-0.0468471497,
0.256177485,
-0.0595258139,
0.4707413614,
-0.0549953617,
-0.1578619927,
0.1128873006,
-0.4058403373,
-0.7072019577,
-0.7897222042,
0.8204146028,
-0.7075020671,
-0.5366385579,
0.0739606917,
-0.8727829456,
-0.3164458871,
0.1735704541,
0.1654443443,
0.6600427032,
0.4985814393,
0.5774539113,
1.0033882856,
0.0372503512,
0.0181341134,
0.3811028302,
0.3160044551,
-0.3419924378,
1.1742194891,
0.3316432834,
0.192430079,
0.6006418467,
0.1540884078,
0.0400172323,
-0.5064530969,
-0.5667471886,
-0.179465428,
-0.4635082781,
-0.1232050061,
-0.4132775068,
-0.0375489593,
-0.0198356546,
-0.2647372186,
-0.58972615,
-0.3106117547,
-0.5374396443,
-0.0132117458,
0.403732866,
0.4242394567,
0.0544869304,
0.568911314,
-0.8878083229,
0.1737659872,
0.4870671034,
0.3623123467,
0.3366345763,
-0.2781766653,
-0.3635945916,
0.3306373358,
-0.4855133891,
-0.7045069337,
-0.0210319478,
0.2384447753,
0.7702172399,
0.6293509007,
0.3194031715,
0.9345812798,
-0.464500159,
0.5067698359,
-0.0072306581,
-0.6781053543,
0.3871276975,
-0.5263457894,
0.0373172387,
0.521692574,
0.2686670423,
0.0055043725,
-0.4547542036,
-0.4133220613,
-1.0786948204,
0.8332160711,
0.2251360118,
0.2585949898,
0.1477531642,
0.2615723312,
0.4203568399,
0.4593610466,
0.0358454548,
-0.2068534344,
-0.0324570797,
-0.8467186093,
0.361236006,
0.0457955487,
-0.2710676491,
-0.5091311336,
0.5214509368,
0.135951966,
0.3862310052,
-0.4750976562,
0.0864440501,
-0.0422978587,
-0.2226739228,
0.4508049786,
0.7920213938,
-0.1110082567,
-0.0401151516,
0.0679254606,
-0.5810176134,
-0.0197839737,
0.1030525267,
-0.2823747694,
-0.214354828,
0.3444029391,
0.9978142977,
0.6808596849,
-0.6272695661,
0.2151379734,
0.1691878885,
-0.0785856918,
0.1754939705,
1.0809775591,
-0.0572347827,
0.3869521022,
0.5451463461,
0.5248297453,
-0.2018062919,
-0.1340698898,
0.1288862377,
0.0877933726,
0.2000688612,
-0.2123823017,
0.6668618321,
0.6080722213,
-0.234434247,
0.8518208861,
0.0098669194,
-0.3622162342,
0.7649798989,
0.1702460647,
0.5258244872,
-0.2237880081,
-0.0286279768,
-0.0173915215,
-0.0000207082,
-0.0603837483,
0.2987611294,
-0.470779717,
-0.5902533531,
-0.1520242244,
-0.2208297998,
-0.4855618477,
-0.1462357789,
-1.000420332,
0.3469463885,
-0.3710251153,
-0.0740104467,
-0.3897705674,
-0.1587973088,
-0.5600227714,
0.211513564,
-0.2221990675,
0.8307890296,
-0.7160841823,
0.6840991378,
0.8460748196,
0.0305713918,
-0.6078349948,
0.0748391747,
-0.1307848394,
-0.8353085518,
0.2091171443,
-0.0178502761,
0.0957724825,
0.1893969774,
-0.4097771645,
-0.6292713881,
1.0400247574,
0.4256941378,
-0.7128849626,
-0.1941568404,
-0.1505347937,
0.1226706654,
-0.3115199804,
0.084233135,
0.334839046,
0.3349003792,
0.1766156107,
-0.5164661407,
-0.4740343392,
-0.340117991,
-0.315685004,
0.2210728079,
-0.7366030216,
1.0189640522,
0.099566713,
0.0698391944,
-0.1997222453,
0.8142157793,
0.2802063227,
0.5172715187,
0.6750913858,
0.5077155828,
1.2179038525,
-0.1685290486,
0.8180081844,
-0.5769674182,
0.1385752559,
1.1239489317,
-0.0431569293,
0.6136335731,
0.2024540752,
-0.1253018975,
0.3593148291,
0.7873944044,
0.084170036,
0.7949882746,
-0.0696610436,
-0.3663958907,
-0.4207471311,
0.2715184093,
-0.4779909253,
0.3584477305,
0.3404756784,
-0.1166469082,
-0.1041602492,
-0.0157637335,
-0.1489761174,
-0.0826714039,
-0.2662994862,
0.5016294122,
-0.4111849964,
-0.6710823774,
0.6393140554,
-0.0739937648,
0.7293371558,
-0.6482772231,
-0.0529694781,
-0.4439747632,
0.136000827,
-0.0870822147,
-0.7964015603,
0.0270192605,
0.049631089,
-0.4049135149,
-0.2101827413,
0.3099856377,
-0.7988599539,
-0.462693423,
-0.2285449207,
0.1511678696,
-0.038400203,
0.0925790519,
-0.606123209,
0.0289151948,
0.1625945419,
-0.0919732228,
0.4009138346,
0.7122690678,
0.1266376674,
0.7574435472,
0.5522125363,
0.2489109635,
0.6395384073,
-0.3448381126,
1.0874016285,
-0.275654614,
-0.7796093225,
-0.5421061516,
0.6546328068,
-0.1747048795,
-0.345552206,
0.4568369687,
0.4311916828,
0.9753968716,
-0.1035706848,
0.6777222157,
0.226141572,
0.3429763019,
-0.681992352,
0.5440407395,
-0.8727243543,
0.3044994771,
0.0631987453,
-0.8676807284,
0.1581277996,
0.6722565889,
-0.1984926462,
0.3203718364,
0.1542156041,
0.6933860183,
-0.6611120701,
0.1748670489,
-0.0196431205,
-0.0962538719,
0.2696436644,
0.5298814774,
0.7353377342,
-0.0383752175,
0.2171945572,
-0.3428495824,
-0.3134338558,
-0.6987639666,
-0.7421264648,
-0.6841139793,
-0.2208521217,
-0.4653504491,
0.2533558309,
0.0364077725,
0.9768168926,
1.0685157776,
-0.6591432691,
0.1000124663,
-0.129862085,
0.2071967572,
-0.4430479109,
-0.2405228913,
0.0730327442,
-0.2339480966,
-0.9727166891,
0.655873239,
0.1191506982,
-0.0828054994,
-0.1277025938,
0.0576711558,
0.0573357828,
0.3522090316,
0.3606062829,
-0.1051807627,
-0.4542528093,
0.0980963707,
-0.0303740762,
0.1623061597,
-0.0697256178,
0.8561845422,
-0.4534880519,
0.8741311431,
0.6454384923,
1.0494849682,
0.1362493783,
0.2020132393,
0.5411525965,
-0.8891913891,
0.1247532293,
0.1643810123,
0.114061147,
0.1554550081,
-0.5387243629,
0.2624756694,
0.5147821903,
-0.383783102,
-0.9625058174,
-0.0767721012,
-0.8979976177,
-0.1963045895,
0.7014235854,
-0.1021942347,
0.0906635225,
0.2201241106,
-0.1624448895,
0.3795151711,
-0.5781704783,
0.9165397882,
0.8740255237,
-0.2793577611,
0.0874907374,
-0.6755369306,
-0.1776358038,
0.5679261088,
-0.5626684427,
-0.2027478218,
0.400154084,
0.316093266,
-0.3435691595,
0.2175025493,
0.3454880416,
0.1663099229,
0.1356644928,
-0.3712141514,
-0.6098834872,
-0.6946585178,
0.2142935693,
0.09054216,
-0.3708557487,
-0.7211924791
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15483v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15483v1 | Duplicate Detection with GenAI | 2024-06-17T06:42:13 | 2024-06-17T06:42:13 | Ian Ormesher | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.DB, cs.LG | Customer data is often stored as records in Customer Relations Management
systems (CRMs). Data which is manually entered into such systems by one of more
users over time leads to data replication, partial duplication or fuzzy
duplication. This in turn means that there no longer a single source of truth
for customers, contacts, accounts, etc. Downstream business processes become
increasing complex and contrived without a unique mapping between a record in a
CRM and the target customer. Current methods to detect and de-duplicate records
use traditional Natural Language Processing techniques known as Entity
Matching. In this paper we show how using the latest advancements in Large
Language Models and Generative AI can vastly improve the identification and
repair of duplicated records. On common benchmark datasets we find an
improvement in the accuracy of data de-duplication rates from 30 percent using
NLP techniques to almost 60 percent using our proposed method. | [
-0.3102625906,
-0.6432864666,
0.2499811053,
0.0566887632,
-0.136642471,
0.2608412802,
0.2035635114,
-0.5722439885,
0.0376683958,
0.9118508697,
-0.5211260915,
-0.5682019591,
-0.1776176691,
0.2569759786,
-0.5467290878,
0.8556151986,
-0.0420879871,
0.1074958965,
-0.4411004186,
-0.4096244574,
-0.6092716455,
-0.7416058779,
-0.9486166239,
-0.5801845789,
-0.0187972486,
0.6398646235,
0.6788808107,
0.5900244117,
0.5479038358,
0.4121626914,
0.0765031055,
0.35436818,
-0.2586989403,
0.3780861497,
-0.071584262,
-0.7232447863,
-0.3529313505,
-0.2706958354,
0.7720942497,
0.6793602109,
-0.3359822333,
-0.0396999381,
0.0293069091,
1.0954369307,
-0.3772468865,
-0.064194873,
-0.6443890333,
0.1743369102,
-0.2862332165,
-0.4314320087,
-0.2375019193,
-0.5192475319,
0.1056605354,
-0.6782570481,
0.818616569,
-0.1555713117,
0.7329122424,
0.2252657115,
-0.3698547184,
-0.2855433524,
-1.1375926733,
0.6838055849,
-0.5255201459,
0.2903617918,
0.270252645,
0.2738641798,
-0.4093459249,
-0.5314590335,
-0.6727182865,
-0.1214488372,
-0.2534704208,
-0.1245824844,
-0.2142359763,
-0.1915228665,
0.6992805004,
0.5922720432,
-0.7442378402,
0.2364478111,
-0.0798349231,
-0.1096620485,
0.6462740898,
0.4060679376,
0.7199545503,
0.0084510818,
-0.5587512851,
-0.2330808938,
-0.3331249952,
-0.2574782073,
0.5149291754,
0.1170704588,
0.2716644108,
0.3357370496,
-0.3940518498,
0.6291784644,
0.0437694564,
-0.1496415585,
0.5983086824,
-0.4699928761,
-0.4330382645,
0.103007935,
0.7051858902,
0.0762158632,
0.4271225631,
-0.1169563979,
-0.027128851,
0.2530122101,
-0.0276792292,
-0.2835604846,
-0.2472818792,
0.1838541329,
-0.4621821046,
0.0593510941,
0.2680497468,
-0.9143558145,
-0.4314388335,
-0.6791694164,
-0.2698704898,
-0.6733221412,
-0.3300401866,
-0.0263274275,
-0.2715720832,
0.3947275281,
0.1200783923,
-0.7777513266,
0.1346002221,
1.0900335312,
0.6000534892,
-0.1535584927,
-0.4348241389,
-0.4538924694,
0.3028740585,
-0.2961672843,
0.7640496492,
-0.5534228086,
-0.2923718691,
-0.0484939367,
-0.1396803409,
0.0394463576,
-1.2606412172,
0.6733781695,
-0.4774686098,
0.2318055481,
-0.453663826,
-0.7542037368,
-0.1868605912,
0.1753256321,
-0.8471732736,
0.7512814403,
0.2950818539,
-0.424033761,
0.6999682784,
-0.3120325804,
-0.5713745356,
0.5818983316,
0.0699727684,
-0.8420904875,
-0.0229852609,
0.2718746066,
0.1329685748,
-0.2410949767,
0.2662699223,
-0.2350209802,
-0.1579018533,
0.1113600284,
-0.4144609272,
0.74078089,
0.4388534427,
-0.17684412,
-0.225823462,
-0.7615798712,
-0.0812381655,
0.2065127194,
-0.3597305119,
-0.6113797426,
-0.0939553678,
0.0177101791,
0.0701104552,
0.1189465076,
-0.3673021495,
0.3491710424,
-0.1402299851,
0.1966539025,
0.2265400141,
0.1037523299,
0.4369976819,
-0.5543811321,
0.6910088658,
0.3494209051,
0.3089182973,
-0.1288415641,
-0.5959055424,
-0.8173511624,
-0.2238328755,
0.2086498886,
0.870947361,
-0.7719926834,
0.6346024871,
-0.3961421549,
-0.3492173254,
-0.6168409586,
0.7291706204,
0.2970207334,
0.4372726381,
0.2067095637,
-0.5048234463,
-0.8633856177,
-1.0595043898,
-0.3530791402,
0.0539585091,
-0.1818670481,
0.0862762928,
-0.0169100035,
-0.6352040768,
1.0110957623,
-0.2856897116,
-0.8680868745,
-0.2852034271,
0.2899473608,
0.0356135145,
0.6716037393,
0.5429130793,
-1.2415409088,
-0.5644752979,
-0.1348937154,
-1.236590147,
-0.1821417809,
-0.3763622642,
-0.0788673982,
0.6795526743,
0.2554168999,
-0.5360891223,
0.4918679893,
0.3332981467,
-0.170262292,
-0.1555911899,
-0.235117197,
0.5269258618,
-1.0880478621,
-0.0104538072,
0.2036247402,
-0.4130307138,
-0.9033981562,
0.0031001782,
-0.0487514436,
-0.3770665526,
0.0004454252,
-0.1751511246,
-0.6229019761,
-0.3555571437,
-0.3028174043,
-0.018010335,
-0.0355993398,
0.3343948424,
-0.1809527427,
0.6372178793,
0.3149703145,
-0.5443083644,
0.5863075256,
0.7287782431,
-0.6145766973,
0.973618269,
-0.4698707461,
0.3386037052,
-0.3123812079,
0.2173882574,
-0.8895368576,
0.0422455631,
0.4039741755,
-0.5129196048,
0.3058202267,
-0.265237391,
-0.5468251705,
-0.5431486964,
0.0447026417,
0.4078829288,
0.3890370429,
-0.7798853517,
0.7455128431,
0.2749841809,
-0.2198581249,
-0.4202023447,
-0.9002375603,
0.3096287251,
-0.0200672522,
-0.7820545435,
0.2398804426,
0.0470776111,
-0.0720937327,
0.0551752709,
0.0465709642,
-0.2519794405,
0.280938983,
0.3010590971,
0.2715095282,
-0.1751412749,
0.2558258474,
-0.2350689471,
-0.3185396492,
-0.1965737343,
-0.3390107751,
0.9124182463,
0.0280006938,
-0.3852586746,
-1.1467170715,
0.6175176501,
0.7576494813,
-0.1741355658,
0.759826839,
0.3003168404,
-0.5878854394,
-0.0780803785,
-0.8010525107,
0.3386810422,
-0.4870514274,
0.1077350602,
-0.3731344044,
-0.2903187573,
0.5688335896,
0.1313884109,
-0.234700352,
0.3812887073,
0.2083835155,
0.0645781606,
0.8845182657,
0.4871157706,
-0.8284028769,
0.5439211726,
-0.3390302658,
0.4924256802,
-0.5651170611,
-0.5803300142,
-0.791855514,
-0.3347881734,
-0.5541204214,
0.047161717,
0.0492617637,
0.301168263,
0.1539125592,
0.4910117984,
-0.6099869609,
0.4140677452,
0.7747218013,
0.0743354186,
0.7911223769,
0.054830309,
0.6183933616,
0.060085196,
-0.3925485015,
-0.3901268244,
0.899913311,
0.0429848656,
0.6304460764,
0.0383081287,
0.7944699526,
0.6283951402,
0.4915334582,
-0.4772515297,
0.5914449692,
-0.3150858879,
-0.3055277765,
-0.3860380054,
-0.8306998014,
-1.1295399666,
-0.198407203,
-0.2754578888,
-0.2483125329,
0.3125736415,
0.3946206272,
-0.1990154982,
0.5126572251,
-0.8053520918,
0.5287540555,
-0.1845420897,
0.2761610448,
-0.1277657896,
-0.0057880539,
0.3345732391,
-0.1235584766,
-0.2056582272,
-0.0765541717,
0.2071155757,
0.6249656677,
-0.5847691298,
0.2121287733,
-0.2005808949,
-0.0614942983,
0.2354763448,
0.0382541083,
0.5614230633,
-0.0213721767,
0.0338109136,
0.3182858229,
-0.2737877369,
-0.3794185817,
-0.6866232157,
0.9871948361,
-0.4919425547,
-0.4569099545,
-0.2588067949,
-0.4727751613,
0.0478297956,
-0.058088541,
0.2955057919,
0.0859563425,
-0.2115135342,
0.0543333404,
0.6264455914,
-0.2889478505,
0.2519548237,
0.6140762568,
0.0734222382,
-0.3741567433,
0.7305446267,
-0.0961166397,
0.2172101289,
0.1948098093,
-0.2548659742,
-0.0908575207,
-0.2674100697,
-0.3453825712,
0.1629895419,
-0.4295961857,
-0.4291682839,
-0.8907096982,
0.0544361174,
-0.6822135448,
0.1756247431,
-0.1880037785,
0.0522195511,
-0.2718836963,
0.2029858083,
0.1892125607,
0.6154274344,
0.0935062394,
0.1059610993,
-0.9697898626,
0.7976447344,
0.5193226933,
0.3661717474,
0.0790483654,
-0.2287442684,
0.2793432474,
0.2355410457,
-0.0173259154,
-0.6830512285,
0.6027201414,
0.0327085629,
0.5722150207,
0.3777122796,
-0.2177545875,
0.5633773208,
-0.0906346664,
0.4460929036,
0.0736491606,
-1.0284157991,
0.6811090112,
-0.1217992157,
0.0548272729,
0.6666190624,
0.4597271681,
-0.824580431,
-0.0782777444,
-0.6248161793,
-0.5431984067,
0.5474030972,
0.0140537741,
-0.1355494708,
0.0744393915,
0.5174984336,
-0.0353841335,
0.1698249578,
-0.0243017562,
-0.4035931826,
0.1988314241,
-0.3512713015,
-0.2919034064,
-0.428018719,
0.2327721268,
-0.1283271909,
0.6693274975,
0.1762198955,
0.1884236187,
0.2464982271,
-0.1464203596,
-0.3717756271,
0.2884367406,
0.3098082542,
0.7090187669,
-0.0424212292,
-0.6358047724,
-0.0067927572,
-0.3465782404,
0.0801528469,
0.2283825725,
-0.5526362658,
0.3089697361,
0.1275897622,
0.499602586,
-0.2786822319,
-0.4117804766,
0.499179244,
-0.0196387544,
-0.1287992597,
-0.9235420227,
0.0508576818,
-0.1654260904,
0.0881652161,
0.4671567976,
0.0321710482,
0.2240436673,
-0.9496216774,
0.4134973586,
0.5212221742,
-0.0779004171,
0.0950648785,
0.4764809608,
0.225546822,
-0.9855616093,
1.3291754723,
0.0634319484,
-0.6886758804,
0.8097829819,
0.3756181002,
0.9032862186,
-0.4525620341,
0.3406355977,
0.1208983362,
0.1564184278,
-0.3793027401,
0.3400783539,
0.2143182456,
-0.9247370362,
-0.1779557467,
-0.2100969702,
-0.3376743495,
0.4658218026,
-1.0190079212,
0.1724930555,
-0.4949685633,
0.01032669,
0.3655038774,
-0.0956896394,
-0.9961878657,
0.0130963372,
0.2188052684,
0.6694404483,
-0.9950893521,
0.6513576508,
0.1483529359,
-0.5987878442,
-0.5172618628,
-0.1653126329,
-0.0432073288,
-0.589656055,
0.7175338268,
0.114833653,
0.2767449021,
-0.1985228956,
-0.5049177408,
-0.5191739798,
0.9734408259,
0.1779412329,
-0.9816191196,
0.1510169357,
0.5984116197,
0.7175360918,
-0.1303516179,
-0.2186438292,
1.1587735415,
0.3800267875,
-0.2417670786,
-0.6675568223,
-0.156426847,
-0.181870833,
0.1571989059,
0.7699896693,
-0.3853717744,
0.724234581,
0.0114136655,
-0.5697669983,
0.4182841778,
0.4660776854,
-0.01744432,
0.6839615703,
0.6270872355,
1.2263776064,
1.0036000013,
-0.2222969085,
1.219671607,
0.1275714338,
0.2247324586,
1.2346067429,
-0.7415819764,
0.4408152401,
0.0973715186,
-0.0289934594,
0.7088630199,
0.0279800575,
-0.525277853,
0.102638796,
0.1458320022,
-0.3225057423,
-0.4247892797,
-0.1736240238,
-0.3220832646,
0.4763780236,
0.1256675273,
-0.5583444238,
0.0602666549,
0.2926619649,
-0.264829576,
0.3314717114,
-0.1477710605,
1.1003465652,
-0.1863237768,
-0.7734988332,
0.5459464788,
-0.3511683643,
0.6746365428,
-0.4033805728,
-0.2633591592,
-0.6589874029,
0.4592511654,
-0.2568933368,
-0.4857916534,
0.1869749427,
-0.1100159883,
-0.5188571811,
-0.1501489729,
0.7827897668,
-0.6561177969,
-0.2701999247,
0.2398735881,
0.3105824292,
-0.0323426425,
-0.2040666044,
-0.6183272004,
-0.1279367954,
0.1476067454,
0.2245599627,
0.0522817634,
0.3367978334,
0.0020372861,
1.0994567871,
0.8303411603,
0.1380447894,
-0.1340097338,
0.4802964926,
0.5116755366,
-0.8563642502,
-0.2986552715,
-0.6237969398,
-0.1368114054,
-0.5346113443,
-0.301155448,
0.5665385127,
0.8199784756,
1.1919378042,
-0.0272590425,
0.9321627617,
0.3759604692,
0.863609612,
-0.4464605451,
0.4164825976,
-0.1672798842,
0.4689075053,
-0.2626623213,
-1.0052484274,
-0.1018052846,
0.0689659119,
0.0080101844,
-0.1374459714,
0.4333270788,
0.8526733518,
0.0521735549,
0.1757099181,
0.189404279,
-0.1308127493,
0.3158341646,
0.9267967343,
0.9712355733,
-0.6763550043,
0.7065998316,
-0.187061578,
-0.1430196166,
-0.1054373458,
-0.2521285713,
-0.7322387695,
-0.5015386343,
-0.6117071509,
-0.3248782754,
-0.0229790397,
0.5910130739,
0.3866951764,
-1.1724226475,
0.1766635478,
-0.0940449312,
0.0729206428,
-0.3689351678,
-0.3252753913,
0.0349308029,
-0.293635726,
-0.8069441915,
0.1492815018,
0.2397063375,
0.4469524026,
-0.068788819,
0.1090236679,
-0.1063138992,
-0.3536547422,
0.1397811174,
0.6286174059,
-0.4327039719,
-0.1030799001,
-0.3210294545,
-0.2190302908,
0.1828728467,
1.2708148956,
-0.8216891885,
0.2346760929,
0.773080647,
0.8483431339,
0.2780503631,
0.4513756931,
0.6722131968,
-0.3673857152,
0.0259005483,
0.3556019664,
0.5138795376,
0.7201960087,
-0.6979083419,
0.5908863544,
0.4499416053,
-0.6099271178,
-0.5136774182,
0.2480040789,
-0.9854752421,
-0.1678814292,
0.9798682332,
-0.0265188664,
0.241284281,
-0.528200388,
0.0309883356,
0.3321966827,
-0.2545024157,
0.7923173308,
0.3558713794,
0.2787554264,
0.0715149492,
-0.1994582415,
0.5988836288,
0.6237663627,
-1.0154322386,
-0.0771396682,
0.4984288216,
0.4675250053,
0.378856957,
0.455282867,
-0.01755853,
0.2266017348,
-0.3062677085,
0.1223671734,
-0.0623607971,
-0.298966527,
-0.5982075334,
0.0300757363,
-0.3293717802,
-0.4803993702
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11250v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11250v1 | Can Machines Resonate with Humans? Evaluating the Emotional and Empathic Comprehension of LMs | 2024-06-17T06:22:20 | 2024-06-17T06:22:20 | Muhammad Arslan Manzoor, Yuxia Wang, Minghan Wang, Preslav Nakov | cs.CL | cs.CL | Empathy plays a pivotal role in fostering prosocial behavior, often triggered
by the sharing of personal experiences through narratives. However, modeling
empathy using NLP approaches remains challenging due to its deep
interconnection with human interaction dynamics. Previous approaches, which
involve fine-tuning language models (LMs) on human-annotated empathic datasets,
have had limited success. In our pursuit of improving empathy understanding in
LMs, we propose several strategies, including contrastive learning with masked
LMs and supervised fine-tuning with Large Language Models (LLMs). While these
methods show improvements over previous methods, the overall results remain
unsatisfactory. To better understand this trend, we performed an analysis which
reveals a low agreement among annotators. This lack of consensus hinders
training and highlights the subjective nature of the task. We also explore the
cultural impact on annotations. To study this, we meticulously collected story
pairs in Urdu language and find that subjectivity in interpreting empathy among
annotators appears to be independent of cultural background. The insights from
our systematic exploration of LMs' understanding of empathy suggest that there
is considerable room for exploration in both task formulation and modeling. | [
-0.6207950711,
-0.6616697907,
0.5411852598,
0.1631899625,
-0.2874249518,
0.1818553954,
-0.3046787083,
-0.7405416369,
0.295781523,
0.5638245344,
-0.5990374088,
-0.4434160292,
-0.8438914418,
0.5486633778,
0.1139606237,
0.6528704166,
-0.1016539857,
0.0315972976,
0.0439730212,
-0.5289496183,
-0.1821605116,
-0.7639538646,
-0.651329577,
-0.4711344838,
0.627351284,
0.5067369938,
0.7484211326,
0.3457323611,
0.5752671957,
0.3482278287,
-0.2512742877,
0.6027016044,
-0.1773252934,
-0.0083950814,
-0.1016383618,
-0.2141030133,
-0.3441828787,
0.1977429241,
0.2104433328,
0.79277879,
0.0960685238,
0.2285859734,
0.3761603534,
0.6524373889,
-0.5354498029,
-0.0495751724,
-0.1955370605,
0.3735228479,
0.4288361073,
-0.211348176,
-0.4630227387,
0.0349205732,
0.0786945224,
-0.2619830668,
0.1096156836,
0.1703386754,
0.6517055035,
0.4470295012,
-0.4289765656,
-0.3011250198,
-0.4770263731,
0.9181293249,
-0.3999583721,
0.2978762984,
0.7084021568,
-0.1953538805,
0.1135697439,
-0.4451476932,
-0.4461711049,
-0.3385846615,
-0.3972038031,
-0.0562479869,
-0.2675006092,
-0.0384487994,
0.3232218027,
0.2262248695,
-0.2583170831,
0.1409945786,
-0.2410188317,
-0.0158650149,
0.7351258397,
0.4510111213,
0.531565249,
-0.1986962408,
-0.2298030257,
0.0527772158,
-0.1276952177,
0.1037786081,
0.3127728701,
0.4158323705,
-0.4512919486,
0.4688606858,
0.0650547147,
0.7152717113,
0.162411958,
0.1402831078,
0.3021862209,
0.1855742186,
-0.2104900926,
-0.0577074923,
0.7221307158,
0.8128963709,
0.6974180341,
-0.0537043661,
0.1578542292,
0.099247545,
0.5458831191,
-0.770371139,
-0.04759413,
0.4335482121,
-0.7201490402,
-0.293672204,
-0.0968174785,
-0.5980954766,
-0.6558391452,
-0.5506507158,
0.1756002903,
-0.2466350645,
-0.5503026843,
0.2379033267,
-0.0249407291,
0.0612932071,
0.086603418,
-0.9558050036,
0.3580093086,
0.8009251356,
1.0369725227,
0.2965276539,
-0.4695053995,
-0.4146980941,
-0.2131561488,
-0.2115564942,
0.5299293995,
-0.857757628,
-0.4690281451,
-0.0583688989,
0.0065519526,
0.0900553837,
-0.5142954588,
0.7105609775,
-0.0571050979,
0.0029624447,
-0.3535234332,
-0.3447466493,
-0.2546131313,
0.3357315361,
-0.5460256934,
0.4493054748,
0.2001763135,
-0.8765060902,
0.1119209751,
-0.7480761409,
-0.402802974,
-0.3439466357,
0.0755549222,
-0.1596521139,
0.4878892899,
0.3973376453,
0.8954268694,
-0.1751986444,
0.1265600324,
-0.209121123,
-0.6853010058,
0.4305894971,
-0.151266247,
0.4920399487,
0.2888875604,
-0.1258046329,
0.0387712196,
-0.419965744,
-0.2818191648,
0.0009460784,
0.2395405769,
-0.410995543,
-0.2098715901,
0.1524248421,
0.1769943684,
-0.0536771119,
-0.4787873924,
-0.0362769887,
-0.5505122542,
0.566059351,
0.7030599117,
-0.05021099,
0.5025110841,
-0.4356453121,
0.5375035405,
0.104568854,
0.2110543549,
-0.3084698915,
-0.2542088926,
-0.4613873661,
-0.4646630883,
-0.1817859709,
0.3522079587,
-0.2497244477,
0.3296961188,
0.1442040056,
-0.6774610877,
-1.0526000261,
0.1549729556,
0.4483836293,
0.4379646182,
0.589669466,
-0.5857630968,
-0.5510962605,
-0.9664134383,
-0.8006927371,
0.0515664332,
-0.2122316509,
0.6314405799,
0.220624283,
-0.4169477522,
0.6545090675,
-0.1886323839,
-0.3399270773,
-0.3715837002,
0.3591749072,
0.2519434392,
0.4278915823,
0.2524248362,
-0.8814178109,
-0.6038573384,
0.073328346,
-0.7933508158,
-0.2473005801,
-0.080297567,
0.0679081529,
0.2415437251,
0.3856771588,
-0.3331049681,
0.3887244463,
0.6381565332,
-0.5729926825,
0.0439920053,
-0.1248487905,
0.4527261257,
-1.1103037596,
0.0345605165,
0.2226555198,
0.0329011902,
-0.7077293396,
-0.1021189094,
-0.1224648654,
0.0610336922,
-0.5594313145,
0.8858711123,
-0.4881515205,
0.0362292118,
-0.3318635821,
0.2155063301,
-0.0106067387,
0.5367161632,
0.3950507343,
0.3171738684,
0.3723331392,
-0.3101841807,
0.2744248211,
0.2647657692,
0.0299170502,
0.8080403209,
-0.654735744,
0.2639664114,
-0.1010086834,
0.0455055758,
-0.5139263868,
-0.3314937651,
0.5117025375,
-0.667853117,
0.2971561849,
-0.1589843035,
-0.3243434429,
-0.0063511385,
-0.2800536752,
0.3890016973,
0.6662461758,
-0.6089097857,
0.926404953,
0.2712806165,
-0.1868090332,
-0.4157747328,
-0.5832074285,
0.3014730513,
-0.4637913704,
-0.4969030917,
-0.1760674864,
0.1310966313,
-0.8280955553,
-0.1991904676,
0.2027497739,
0.0455885418,
0.2050122023,
0.6266518831,
-0.1910118163,
0.119155407,
0.2263878584,
0.000090117,
-0.5083627701,
0.1627982855,
0.3570107818,
0.5677755475,
-0.3471235037,
-0.3935621083,
-0.893713057,
0.4823638499,
0.4791950285,
-0.2532551587,
0.94985044,
0.9087862372,
-0.2828657627,
0.192161411,
-0.5197305083,
-0.4349669814,
-0.4140442312,
0.291357398,
-0.5365797877,
-1.081569314,
0.4145530164,
-0.1688396484,
-0.1975987107,
0.1374750733,
0.5605282187,
-0.143249318,
1.1632665396,
0.6146364212,
-0.2859871387,
0.2755425572,
-0.0036060719,
0.3296630681,
-1.1431595087,
-0.1245620772,
-0.3620471656,
-0.5650808215,
-0.8427149653,
-0.070984222,
0.1708082259,
-0.0236145314,
-0.562756896,
-0.1432170272,
-0.6190826297,
0.4277141988,
0.4041273594,
0.5225257277,
0.1180874184,
-0.0742826089,
0.3729013801,
-0.2772964537,
-0.3515509069,
-0.9437306523,
0.7823927999,
0.5039932132,
0.5900581479,
-0.0447695926,
0.8773729205,
0.397079289,
0.6437029839,
-0.5628395081,
0.3431214392,
-0.1478932798,
-0.1603314877,
-0.1636613905,
-0.0986448973,
-0.8886945844,
0.2072774172,
-0.1613030136,
-0.980223,
0.0800063238,
0.2346147001,
-0.2360011637,
0.392549634,
-0.7001519799,
0.8363887668,
-0.1042177156,
-0.5585129261,
-0.1978383958,
-0.8734552264,
0.0439642482,
0.0983763561,
0.4016108215,
-0.1677476168,
0.0176360756,
0.3691006601,
-0.1911591142,
1.2555749416,
-0.1410882324,
-0.039861083,
0.0143545736,
0.467930913,
0.1740935296,
-0.1345790327,
-0.3089366555,
0.3752579689,
-0.2464124113,
-0.6376317143,
-0.5923518538,
0.4665400684,
-0.8078691363,
-0.6507766843,
-0.2085274756,
-0.5913974643,
-0.1217685342,
-0.3411678076,
-0.0966452882,
0.0162700787,
-0.0842299685,
0.1826969981,
0.1955892593,
-0.3246519566,
0.0630215555,
0.3570478857,
0.0681208894,
-0.2057173401,
0.6661226749,
-0.3269874752,
0.1418911964,
0.2449944168,
0.3196339309,
-0.0097662406,
0.0244982094,
-0.1928000003,
0.4199796319,
-0.5483473539,
0.100921236,
-0.7874661088,
0.199900642,
-0.1722081304,
-0.6519652605,
-0.2202863842,
0.1683241427,
-0.4998053014,
-0.2564618587,
0.6495252252,
0.8490135074,
-0.5251774788,
0.1131819636,
-1.070902586,
0.2905727029,
-0.0701536611,
0.2267273962,
0.1296074241,
-0.7331959605,
-0.230344072,
0.1928245574,
-0.0298563913,
-0.7288535237,
0.6439982653,
0.0140647711,
-0.0103229266,
0.468742609,
0.247786656,
0.5665343404,
-0.2806901932,
0.7215127349,
-0.0373803228,
-1.11688447,
0.5287688971,
-0.1616298705,
0.0063612708,
0.292144388,
0.6042675376,
-0.7336708307,
-0.4897812605,
-0.7227742672,
-0.7591401339,
0.6479428411,
0.033327207,
0.5731878877,
-0.1028394923,
0.5128811002,
0.1169962883,
-0.0463039614,
-0.4294700623,
0.0474605337,
0.0064045871,
-0.5633478165,
-0.5531792641,
-0.5240820646,
-0.1693444997,
-0.1118340492,
0.0437520519,
-0.0065414668,
-0.0010463439,
0.4293263257,
0.0177385956,
-0.4111529589,
0.0560982488,
0.4624809623,
0.1576381326,
-0.1865804791,
0.2281595021,
0.3875877857,
-0.3579100072,
0.0109356325,
-0.2202592641,
0.3911558986,
-0.1875471622,
0.761085093,
0.723059833,
0.2003023922,
-0.88154459,
0.2580009997,
-0.0582988076,
-0.0245388988,
-0.1267243475,
-0.022452252,
0.2220277637,
0.7756360769,
0.0705924928,
-0.2616828382,
0.1022418141,
-0.6149792075,
-0.0432291515,
0.2422286123,
-0.5146956444,
-0.3653921783,
0.34116593,
0.2145194709,
-0.9447652698,
0.763094604,
0.1828177124,
-0.7588383555,
0.5629511476,
0.1580521315,
0.932433486,
-0.4087082148,
0.0594191961,
0.260689497,
0.420811832,
0.0730023831,
0.3135854304,
-0.4234858751,
-0.9417120218,
-0.2018276155,
-0.5745965838,
-0.8500635624,
-0.3777088821,
-1.062600255,
0.0013398227,
0.0247106906,
-0.0381585956,
-0.3204170465,
0.0603143759,
-0.7640145421,
0.3444752097,
-0.1084783599,
0.5581227541,
-1.1639318466,
0.3509304523,
0.6896647811,
-0.4345467091,
-0.7841053605,
0.0825001225,
-0.2186088711,
-0.9031476974,
0.8878877163,
0.4378962517,
-0.1888148636,
0.0253362805,
-0.4403370023,
-0.1983320862,
0.8112406135,
0.149799943,
-0.4042430222,
0.5519279242,
0.2081047297,
0.9630042315,
-0.5803607702,
0.3682126701,
0.606416285,
0.5675058365,
-0.3446534276,
-0.914832592,
0.09213496,
-0.349427253,
-0.3652497232,
0.1046988592,
-0.7158076763,
0.6544036865,
-0.4807917476,
0.0812435001,
0.0942974165,
0.3589734435,
0.2482723594,
0.8588287234,
0.4028141797,
0.3799543977,
0.401496172,
0.1053702906,
1.1729849577,
-0.3939205706,
0.1691243798,
1.0297470093,
-0.5390372276,
1.0962761641,
0.7418934107,
-0.0758829117,
0.2856439352,
0.8944921494,
0.133691296,
0.014344871,
0.2992667556,
-0.259943217,
-0.4814069569,
-0.5981100798,
-0.059571553,
0.5267798305,
0.2480954975,
-0.7600357533,
0.3351758122,
0.1130468547,
0.0200657826,
0.4770782888,
-0.4054016471,
0.8406923413,
0.3579940498,
-0.3327877223,
0.2786627114,
-0.1894825399,
0.4805622995,
-0.0023237499,
-0.2144936174,
-0.3195918798,
0.0522466525,
-0.2762466371,
-0.7828620672,
0.341085732,
0.2662521303,
-0.0841308311,
-0.3807756007,
0.6189818978,
-0.2598397434,
-0.3735611439,
0.6205483675,
0.6809185147,
0.4887216687,
-0.2311802506,
-0.4287373722,
0.4563079476,
-0.1142396852,
-0.576215148,
0.3254377246,
0.5549942255,
0.128618449,
0.7594438791,
0.5096415877,
-0.0450537056,
-0.5833224058,
0.2901252806,
0.739428699,
-0.8225487471,
0.0172212161,
-1.260441184,
0.6808111072,
0.0073037064,
-0.0755534321,
0.5457078218,
0.0941887125,
0.759406209,
-0.1033225805,
0.5029815435,
0.320502907,
0.6883460879,
-0.4534056485,
0.6013071537,
-0.7606466413,
0.0141423633,
-0.3368448615,
-0.6931807995,
-0.4875113964,
0.8338592649,
-0.2854894996,
0.2054318041,
0.2835041285,
0.7765087485,
0.0833926871,
0.2030916363,
0.6426467896,
0.4059301019,
-0.1191691086,
0.3869960308,
1.0838309526,
-0.0320892222,
-0.063279517,
-0.3354586065,
-0.1708623767,
-0.2632449567,
-0.933190167,
-1.01331985,
-0.5385010242,
-0.0852060616,
-0.2230141908,
0.0219178814,
1.3140906096,
0.3935746849,
-0.427519232,
-0.2045908272,
0.202373147,
0.0198889412,
-0.0804164559,
-0.1756016016,
0.5832082033,
-0.3317818344,
-1.014048934,
-0.0150919296,
0.4109324515,
-0.1985234916,
-0.2414510101,
-0.4388793409,
0.2714110911,
0.0457976349,
0.658798337,
0.0960172489,
-0.8691558242,
-0.4390949309,
0.0199158061,
0.1758547425,
-0.1266646981,
0.8457992673,
-0.5731253028,
0.4410386682,
-0.0497199744,
0.4223270118,
-0.0676356256,
0.2310601175,
0.5107024908,
-0.4658977687,
0.2415276021,
0.2852107286,
0.4304310083,
0.3587860465,
-0.3921897411,
0.6586951017,
-0.0931037217,
-0.5822964907,
-1.080894351,
0.3539837301,
-0.8309131265,
-0.2189144194,
1.2344169617,
-0.2067784369,
-0.1291174144,
-0.2048991323,
-0.8062371016,
0.3764363229,
-0.2010112852,
0.9971253276,
0.6622571349,
-0.4145497382,
-0.4691567421,
-0.1708117574,
0.310365051,
0.4958607554,
-0.3567288816,
0.1324168742,
0.2372646332,
-0.1062370986,
0.0990428552,
0.4423305392,
0.3270130157,
0.0936902314,
-0.0958501473,
0.350651741,
-0.0611519888,
0.0114957495,
-0.4936342537,
0.1425543427,
0.2445980161,
0.0403079577
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11243v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11243v1 | FamiCom: Further Demystifying Prompts for Language Models with Task-Agnostic Performance Estimation | 2024-06-17T06:14:55 | 2024-06-17T06:14:55 | Bangzheng Li, Ben Zhou, Xingyu Fu, Fei Wang, Dan Roth, Muhao Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Language models have shown impressive in-context-learning capabilities, which
allow them to benefit from input prompts and perform better on downstream end
tasks. Existing works investigate the mechanisms behind this observation, and
propose label-agnostic prompt metrics that can better estimate end-task
performances. One popular approach is using perplexity as a way to measure
models' familiarity with the prompt. While showing consistent improvements on
in-domain tasks, we found that familiarity metrics such as perplexity cannot
accurately estimate performance in complicated situations such as task or
domain transferring scenarios. In this work, we propose a revised measure
called FamiCom, providing a more comprehensive measure for task-agnostic
performance estimation. Specifically, FamiCom combines familiarity with
\textit{complexity} -- the inherent difficulty of end tasks, which is an
important factor missing from current metrics. Experiments show that FamiCom
strongly correlates with end-task performances, producing a 0.85 Spearman's
correlation, versus 0.43 of familiarity-only ones'. We further apply FamiCom to
automatic prompt and demonstration selection, and outperform existing methods
and baselines by more than 7.0% in accuracy. | [
-0.5756632686,
-0.7095085382,
0.8399582505,
0.0149345733,
-0.0793487281,
0.0746445358,
-0.0826915056,
-0.3042564392,
-0.043914225,
0.2081090063,
-0.7351500988,
-0.444221288,
-0.9194718003,
0.2539520264,
-0.3650006652,
0.9126999974,
-0.1525334716,
-0.4719265103,
-0.6930203438,
-0.224015668,
-0.1894632876,
-0.5681790113,
-0.3826763034,
-0.4898858964,
0.4998455644,
0.4659416378,
0.7580094337,
0.6248602867,
0.1424731463,
0.357793659,
-0.0088529931,
0.1998198479,
-0.0751752555,
0.3447043002,
-0.3074864447,
-0.4999755025,
-0.5478402972,
0.1971199661,
0.5355832577,
0.8159766197,
0.1745080352,
0.0411937982,
0.0598565713,
0.5045655966,
-0.6270358562,
-0.0187787972,
-0.4131353498,
0.2406927645,
0.0124520501,
-0.1722767949,
-0.2820829749,
-0.2285753042,
0.4443885386,
-0.8361719251,
0.3127968609,
0.2027997226,
0.7868080139,
0.4027510881,
-0.3447346687,
-0.5189179778,
-0.6685550213,
0.880728364,
-0.5026932359,
0.2731838524,
0.4151538908,
0.5797482729,
-0.1816335618,
-0.4558864534,
-0.4658616483,
-0.648629427,
0.1307838857,
0.0286092944,
-0.6796233654,
0.0308240168,
0.5454264283,
0.4390491247,
-0.4934877753,
0.0353440084,
0.21204108,
-0.2783687711,
0.3990308642,
0.4309155345,
0.3803181052,
0.2785366476,
-0.6631845832,
0.0898860544,
-0.5426555276,
0.4246220291,
0.5047522783,
-0.0313353986,
-0.0743804872,
0.2155903727,
-0.4833008051,
0.7205063701,
0.1568256617,
0.0252365563,
0.3063870668,
-0.2505696118,
-0.1929031909,
-0.4392688274,
0.6271104217,
0.1787543893,
0.2809188366,
-0.352899313,
-0.5743988156,
0.1385249645,
0.0406337269,
-0.6201915145,
-0.4297170341,
0.1973762363,
-0.1477854401,
0.0831584185,
-0.2309526056,
-0.3778674006,
-0.4641411304,
-0.3890164495,
0.5474612713,
-0.5988145471,
-0.2244746834,
-0.0875344351,
-0.0276607256,
-0.1606723815,
0.6430654526,
-0.6159052849,
0.4280068278,
0.712687552,
1.0495818853,
-0.566646874,
-0.5335999727,
-0.6631813049,
-0.1568536013,
-0.1401261687,
0.9354944825,
-0.6591413617,
-0.4747063518,
-0.3472313583,
-0.1857471317,
-0.3147004247,
-0.700165689,
0.1788227707,
-0.3705311418,
0.2711481154,
-0.221851334,
-0.84125036,
-0.2693090141,
0.2151772082,
-0.5201116204,
0.7107242942,
0.121065639,
-0.5479198098,
0.4950364828,
-0.6330157518,
-0.4407740533,
-0.1589423418,
-0.0409826972,
-0.0003346796,
0.3826711774,
-0.0385941155,
0.5126078725,
-0.3871396184,
0.1712954044,
-0.2713415623,
-0.4979612231,
0.3063385785,
-0.4883153737,
0.6686987281,
0.3862945139,
-0.2984934151,
0.2148551047,
-0.5373451114,
-0.3028269112,
-0.2197033018,
-0.0867367089,
-0.4188475609,
-0.2822211385,
-0.576739192,
0.2798089087,
0.5595555305,
-0.3729721904,
0.0045506828,
-0.4088556767,
0.0307417605,
0.7177743316,
-0.2726609707,
0.4170996249,
-0.5547221303,
0.9223219752,
0.1685865521,
0.2523880601,
-0.2720451057,
-0.5653304458,
-0.6303779483,
-0.5196372867,
0.0137724755,
0.5995863676,
-0.615327239,
0.3253358006,
-0.0699995086,
-0.5433622599,
-0.2151093334,
0.2118928134,
0.5748143196,
0.556815207,
0.3908964694,
-0.4640705884,
-0.2111600935,
-0.9801587462,
-0.5630122423,
-0.2577670813,
-0.1922010183,
0.4953370094,
0.3105208576,
-0.2110984623,
1.0021412373,
-0.4905056059,
-0.090857558,
-0.0660340339,
0.4900240898,
0.5919507146,
0.4259261787,
0.5996690392,
-0.4547814429,
-0.4856708646,
-0.0935541242,
-0.5109122992,
-0.4016101956,
0.0744419992,
0.2584457099,
0.4220893681,
0.2726561427,
-0.3283684552,
0.2105485648,
0.51672858,
-0.4958767891,
0.9186314344,
-0.3403830826,
0.3048688769,
-0.8109775782,
0.2595040798,
0.0438169762,
-0.1848511994,
-0.7910929322,
-0.1622072756,
-0.0641177148,
0.3632608056,
-0.1804261357,
0.7767250538,
-0.5217348337,
-0.0401077531,
-0.4604000449,
0.0897542015,
-0.1196781918,
0.4335469007,
-0.0805545747,
1.1898714304,
0.7669832706,
-0.6422778964,
0.1846528649,
0.029281009,
-0.2231963575,
0.715023756,
-0.5662376285,
0.1125741079,
0.0801180676,
-0.0568849519,
-1.5377864838,
-0.1359589994,
0.0776120201,
-0.8538245559,
0.2065306157,
-0.0516818464,
-0.2270995378,
-0.0387990065,
-0.0983972922,
0.4501421452,
0.5732402802,
-0.2851460874,
0.6562162638,
0.2627203166,
-0.122293748,
-0.6702576876,
-0.3888761103,
0.06417799,
-0.2139880657,
-0.3798654377,
-0.1532757729,
-0.2720310986,
-0.1284593791,
-0.5005031824,
-0.4714692235,
-0.087959446,
0.5542846918,
0.6420426369,
0.1252510548,
-0.1456503272,
-0.0045084371,
0.1973235309,
-0.2847506404,
0.3949657381,
-0.0168849211,
0.4436917901,
-0.1386940181,
-0.4727036357,
-0.307675004,
0.118131727,
0.5845472813,
0.0983478576,
0.1938311905,
0.3871057928,
-0.2137720734,
-0.1222375855,
-0.5636851788,
-0.2221555263,
-0.5074043274,
0.065351598,
-0.6765571833,
-1.0240428448,
0.7420421243,
-0.3656626046,
0.0115203969,
0.2722616494,
0.2438400388,
0.0915932804,
1.139313221,
0.5135011673,
-0.0483686998,
0.4134359658,
0.0738412961,
-0.1856144816,
-0.5458525419,
-0.138376072,
-0.5887690187,
-0.1135260463,
-0.0102656726,
-0.3762557805,
0.3620780408,
-0.0144861909,
-0.2450499535,
0.3207939565,
0.00824132,
0.1704673767,
0.6395817995,
-0.1202558577,
0.4318769276,
0.1883420646,
-0.5189320445,
0.010854275,
-0.6080559492,
-0.5940467119,
0.745059073,
0.2723205388,
0.3458292782,
0.1096188053,
0.665912509,
0.4383674562,
0.2883271277,
-0.6529692411,
0.6286337972,
-0.3042790592,
-0.4071908593,
-0.3062868118,
-0.3856932521,
-0.8924444914,
-0.0004020943,
-0.0642580166,
-0.9095242023,
0.029543763,
0.3587465882,
-0.6257596016,
0.0113794375,
-0.467831254,
0.7480621338,
0.1919783056,
-0.2135585099,
-0.1670121998,
-0.5881945491,
0.1413670927,
-0.1331115067,
0.1960960925,
-0.379065603,
-0.4630871713,
0.6935549974,
-0.2695098519,
0.742123127,
-0.3318138421,
-0.2998308241,
0.0543448217,
0.4519634843,
0.4016205072,
-0.2731589973,
-0.1332431585,
0.2440987825,
-0.2302664518,
-0.277484715,
-0.782904923,
0.8956842422,
-0.7626505494,
-0.9568648338,
-0.2154866904,
-0.8923764825,
-0.6109178662,
0.1120598391,
0.2374587208,
0.5101035833,
0.0154891387,
-0.1054283231,
0.7139484286,
-0.0669509247,
0.2486455888,
0.6227453947,
0.0017638901,
-0.4348893166,
0.8476299644,
0.0948629901,
0.3834327757,
0.4230155647,
0.237081632,
-0.5513856411,
-0.6125984788,
-0.4548923671,
-0.0176350214,
-0.6514295936,
-0.0296441019,
-0.9358459711,
0.2359884381,
-0.2772048116,
-0.3246437609,
-0.0916948095,
-0.6643345356,
-0.2685036957,
0.0857683346,
0.3903221786,
0.4311646223,
-0.1022053063,
0.4474958479,
-0.5181241632,
0.1237643212,
0.2087992877,
0.2525195777,
0.1205676943,
-0.9362809658,
-0.1776679605,
-0.0445954241,
-0.107561551,
-0.8201733232,
0.131085068,
0.2135463208,
0.782268405,
0.5132935643,
0.2928661406,
0.455526948,
-0.2104414105,
0.9108744264,
0.3693807721,
-1.2608953714,
0.5930623412,
-0.3508376777,
0.5393130779,
0.4775258005,
0.6567988396,
-0.3602188826,
-0.7156879306,
-0.5077499747,
-0.8995808959,
0.7026674747,
0.0466596559,
-0.0063522495,
0.0771378502,
0.1632913649,
0.5379616022,
0.4370174408,
-0.1230459884,
-0.4620945752,
-0.0195963122,
-0.1097283736,
-0.29846856,
-0.1216138825,
-0.1185113564,
-0.2613869011,
0.4349542856,
-0.2532393038,
0.1859255582,
0.2442771196,
-0.2552342713,
-0.09422791,
0.1266733706,
0.613604784,
0.8544594646,
-0.11760021,
0.4050824344,
0.3861856759,
-0.4773713648,
0.4395472407,
0.0553235635,
0.0253847279,
0.0702710375,
0.3792025447,
0.875251472,
0.180591464,
-0.7584376931,
0.5235196352,
0.2622688711,
-0.142391637,
-0.1712388992,
0.7091761827,
-0.2709596157,
0.3909715414,
0.5177957416,
0.2270494848,
0.6383482218,
-0.2310167402,
0.5054744482,
0.366531074,
-0.5900998116,
-0.5364129543,
0.7784520388,
0.0580944419,
-0.2404978871,
0.0428888276,
-0.0571263023,
-0.3703368306,
0.7627433538,
0.35348171,
1.143063426,
-0.6118282676,
0.1993041635,
0.1775672138,
0.1171817333,
0.0278027877,
0.2365251034,
-0.4326333702,
-0.6502950191,
-0.156716153,
-0.2946127951,
-0.6017102599,
-0.2278693169,
-0.6112436652,
0.0338827409,
-0.56065166,
-0.4706657529,
-0.020781491,
0.256285131,
-0.4918726385,
0.2332476228,
0.0798495114,
1.131911397,
-0.8658628464,
0.6818435192,
1.2448558807,
-0.1677087545,
-0.4437373579,
0.0169547461,
0.1044955254,
-0.6023606658,
0.3277250528,
0.2256751955,
-0.6180353165,
0.0348430164,
-0.2637530565,
-0.5897773504,
1.1380078793,
0.4848313928,
-0.4060008228,
0.2079052925,
0.1289547086,
0.5370640755,
-0.6952610612,
0.623352766,
0.5442371964,
0.434972316,
0.1803920865,
-0.9130199552,
0.3844379187,
-0.2060741633,
0.0157075375,
-0.0495347939,
-0.4254284799,
0.9447618127,
-0.3930196464,
-0.4244333506,
0.2870041728,
0.6940429211,
0.5013225675,
0.8937577605,
0.8871772885,
0.0761251673,
0.796798408,
0.0134872897,
0.8277036548,
-0.5185524225,
0.3190208077,
1.0058530569,
-0.1972674876,
0.5665743947,
0.4887757897,
-0.2436103523,
0.5087041259,
0.4789148271,
0.3457941413,
0.3275661469,
-0.0028740696,
-0.2794274986,
-0.6936546564,
-0.0877591074,
-0.2481280416,
0.1784864366,
0.2393536717,
-0.360530138,
-0.3011568189,
-0.0338551886,
0.3084430993,
0.1466239244,
-0.149437353,
0.7356014252,
0.0818574652,
-0.7864602208,
0.936101675,
-0.3838048279,
0.7209020853,
-0.585360229,
0.1491997838,
-0.4272937775,
0.0700783506,
0.0178943053,
-0.8609833717,
0.2155715823,
-0.1219036579,
-0.3908312917,
0.0603827871,
0.6358866692,
-0.3916228414,
-0.026311323,
0.2962267101,
0.7487488389,
0.3423403203,
-0.3398596346,
-0.6279135346,
-0.109988682,
-0.0616391115,
-0.2422835827,
0.3670614064,
0.6430045962,
0.0835087374,
0.9349904656,
0.3374111652,
-0.2701005936,
-0.1565448344,
-0.2961800098,
0.7408474684,
-0.3666602969,
-0.4217073917,
-0.9450137615,
0.2698746622,
-0.0797924101,
-0.6690306067,
0.9391358495,
0.5561587214,
0.612138927,
-0.2948799431,
0.7731981874,
0.1887971908,
0.4519026279,
-0.1426370591,
0.6369261742,
-0.8739403486,
0.2644202411,
-0.4657595158,
-0.6780262589,
-0.1469285935,
0.339872241,
-0.4305319488,
-0.094633691,
0.3674446046,
0.778074801,
-0.2420825809,
0.1676045507,
0.7391481996,
0.1741400361,
0.1090366915,
0.7257242799,
0.9340986013,
-0.0873245224,
0.2689028084,
-0.1614515036,
-0.6972497702,
-0.3507785797,
-0.8604918718,
-0.8353857994,
-0.8534227014,
-0.4552135468,
-0.1579210907,
0.2478070408,
1.0324085951,
0.4321733713,
-0.971948266,
-0.5649602413,
0.1889998913,
0.1507995725,
-0.5858005881,
-0.1365655363,
0.0465657599,
-0.5607756376,
-0.7616541386,
0.3916733861,
0.2247339785,
0.0284976941,
-0.1329452842,
-0.2014190257,
0.0054994458,
0.3397372067,
0.5897781849,
0.2502170205,
-0.8092550039,
-0.3119335771,
0.0088374922,
0.0559569336,
-0.1817443818,
0.7987982631,
-0.8722789884,
0.3628388047,
0.6321995854,
0.5328680873,
-0.1779671311,
0.0613561943,
0.7959241867,
-0.6515550613,
-0.1101974696,
0.0108516375,
0.324678421,
0.1959755719,
-0.3086524904,
0.4675097466,
0.4199334681,
-0.4323833287,
-0.8373185992,
0.4477585554,
-0.7832750678,
-0.1871330589,
1.1540738344,
-0.7392787933,
-0.1806504428,
-0.468329519,
-0.0668452159,
0.1694917083,
-0.6060826778,
0.6265751719,
0.7344001532,
-0.2727217674,
-0.0008781602,
-0.4011519253,
0.6220033169,
0.6320030093,
-0.3880696893,
0.1954259425,
0.692643702,
0.4613657296,
0.2890000343,
0.5364175439,
0.2178936303,
0.4305716455,
-0.2221863866,
-0.129869312,
-0.4113146663,
-0.5872930288,
-0.4674065411,
0.3892050385,
0.2427240014,
-0.1572034806
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15481v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15481v1 | CSRT: Evaluation and Analysis of LLMs using Code-Switching Red-Teaming Dataset | 2024-06-17T06:08:18 | 2024-06-17T06:08:18 | Haneul Yoo, Yongjin Yang, Hwaran Lee | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Recent studies in large language models (LLMs) shed light on their
multilingual ability and safety, beyond conventional tasks in language
modeling. Still, current benchmarks reveal their inability to comprehensively
evaluate them and are excessively dependent on manual annotations. In this
paper, we introduce code-switching red-teaming (CSRT), a simple yet effective
red-teaming technique that simultaneously tests multilingual understanding and
safety of LLMs. We release the CSRT dataset, which comprises 315 code-switching
queries combining up to 10 languages and eliciting a wide range of undesirable
behaviors. Through extensive experiments with ten state-of-the-art LLMs, we
demonstrate that CSRT significantly outperforms existing multilingual
red-teaming techniques, achieving 46.7% more attacks than existing methods in
English. We analyze the harmful responses toward the CSRT dataset concerning
various aspects under ablation studies with 16K samples, including but not
limited to scaling laws, unsafe behavior categories, and input conditions for
optimal data generation. Additionally, we validate the extensibility of CSRT,
by generating code-switching attack prompts with monolingual data. | [
-0.2883505821,
-0.9533351064,
-0.070771493,
0.4327894747,
-0.1418052763,
0.5910336971,
-0.5934318304,
-0.5864853263,
-0.1516908556,
0.454911232,
-0.3288187981,
-0.4364506304,
-0.5018764734,
0.2808563411,
-0.6659287214,
1.1449890137,
-0.1512731761,
0.229772836,
-0.0164713655,
-0.1539973617,
-0.5120017529,
-0.884995997,
-0.675049901,
-0.1091852412,
0.5625784397,
0.4977064133,
0.5756653547,
0.2228847891,
0.9081363678,
0.349305898,
0.0699428618,
-0.0222905967,
-0.6980516911,
0.112731047,
0.0909135863,
-0.4844945669,
-0.2821806669,
-0.2553673685,
0.5955761075,
0.5379617214,
-0.0116114393,
0.2579052746,
0.2184597701,
0.5453912616,
-0.6223750114,
-0.1744527519,
-0.8625040054,
0.0763522759,
-0.3497324884,
-0.4117837548,
-0.9212555885,
-0.2703432143,
-0.0470807813,
-0.1570712924,
0.0776287988,
0.0340942442,
0.5493395329,
0.1836122423,
-0.4995064139,
-0.1126234531,
-0.6744950414,
0.935228765,
-0.1607266366,
0.5384868383,
0.2707768381,
0.4880897999,
0.2205480039,
-0.5063692331,
-0.2748414278,
-0.3920794725,
-0.1550484449,
0.2067182809,
-0.5633984804,
-0.1169403717,
0.0877124965,
-0.1204692572,
-0.7984748483,
0.113840498,
-0.4389057159,
-0.208561942,
0.6214911342,
0.0400014482,
0.5891887546,
0.134514764,
-0.7849888802,
-0.210650146,
-0.5386880636,
-0.1258619279,
0.1390287429,
0.6785538197,
-0.3503089547,
0.3693804443,
-0.0735771582,
0.4538237154,
-0.1256561577,
0.0860605687,
0.2485574037,
-0.5551701784,
-0.3400602341,
0.0392488167,
0.7765911818,
0.4361919463,
0.2459808588,
-0.4039984047,
0.081240125,
0.4387996793,
0.1401008517,
-0.5077040792,
-0.1887702644,
0.3676352501,
-0.2625107765,
-0.4851946533,
-0.1624365002,
-0.8848260045,
-0.1570841521,
0.0436870344,
-0.0502205789,
-0.5600264072,
-0.5340052247,
0.1250924319,
0.0243250132,
0.2839105725,
0.0244343299,
-0.5405777693,
0.5343347788,
0.4390675128,
0.7474370003,
-0.7584655285,
-0.688024044,
-0.7405674458,
-0.0804316252,
-0.0919708535,
0.8316109776,
-0.3574124277,
-0.4584325552,
-0.0365581624,
-0.0256069917,
-0.161293909,
-0.3019908667,
0.1833958924,
-0.6683859825,
-0.1757194102,
-0.195887506,
-0.0527852438,
-0.002296814,
0.6190376282,
-0.5309870839,
0.977299571,
-0.3428407013,
-0.8330486417,
0.2620624006,
-0.6904144287,
-0.5378667116,
0.1215235218,
-0.0138451178,
-0.4018349648,
-0.3590813875,
-0.0867987052,
0.128659308,
-0.1129612848,
-0.1329017431,
-0.2163648605,
-0.1547928303,
0.6254315972,
-0.5117698908,
1.0260487795,
0.2355967164,
-0.2907079458,
0.0522481687,
-0.3389396966,
0.2718850374,
0.2014481872,
-0.40101704,
-0.3932831585,
-0.105970718,
0.3201215267,
0.3786863387,
0.2458356619,
-0.4857157767,
-0.0413059704,
0.0955148414,
0.1759677976,
0.4552809894,
0.0365480222,
0.3025708199,
-0.2667494118,
0.9347308278,
-0.2239686102,
0.2679308951,
0.2003546357,
-0.1510046721,
-0.6582138538,
-0.1406246871,
0.2329437584,
0.8806118965,
-0.8850525022,
-0.079672493,
-0.0546639375,
-0.4747784436,
-0.1567097902,
0.0949954838,
0.7489913106,
0.1089856625,
0.4131984711,
0.0412437171,
-0.6781783104,
-0.7970325947,
-0.3897702694,
-0.1998244077,
0.5183935761,
-0.0311789848,
0.5580755472,
-0.1717046201,
0.6793186069,
-0.2341380715,
0.141868487,
-0.6545041203,
0.0681224838,
-0.2416366935,
0.4185902774,
0.3861231208,
-0.8070812821,
-0.6766006947,
0.3258262277,
-0.6311289072,
-0.1277143955,
-0.4137236476,
-0.179686591,
0.4610127509,
0.7617499828,
-0.0554583967,
0.2361978143,
0.9393139482,
-0.3551746011,
0.7960653305,
0.0688750669,
0.3494371474,
-0.533213377,
0.2221323103,
-0.0462726988,
-0.137642473,
-0.8459118605,
0.4361820221,
0.3726624548,
0.1403105259,
-0.9528796077,
0.3773571253,
-0.5294556022,
-0.0197514798,
-0.080089353,
0.0368370228,
-0.2968628407,
0.495397836,
-0.0237678476,
0.7433267832,
0.1501028687,
-0.5017495751,
0.173896119,
0.1635038555,
-0.1393222809,
0.4112563729,
-0.4255821705,
0.272234112,
0.1424536407,
-0.0445199721,
-1.0701361895,
0.2155439109,
-0.0185528062,
-0.5334788561,
0.2692492306,
-0.3418148756,
-0.6142786145,
-0.1488568485,
-0.2659893036,
0.6125782132,
0.2380941957,
-0.4563465714,
0.266572535,
0.5371749997,
-0.2081623524,
-0.6837611198,
-1.0986700058,
0.366158247,
-0.4240548611,
-0.5011999607,
-0.0280271415,
-0.2458545864,
-0.5778512359,
-0.2324616164,
0.0928004012,
-0.3428548276,
0.3103469014,
0.039139431,
0.5257116556,
0.1002675295,
-0.1119206101,
-0.1084814295,
-0.2597596645,
0.0318553783,
0.2052944899,
0.6634477377,
-0.5343459845,
-0.4784913361,
-0.0620761737,
0.3638549447,
0.3317993581,
-0.4868820906,
0.3179214001,
0.2688601017,
-0.1992188394,
-0.2477488965,
-0.3323585689,
-0.0723479018,
-0.4694759846,
0.7048338652,
-0.1515027881,
-1.0185046196,
0.4407482147,
-0.0270749535,
0.3428432643,
0.035376396,
0.6957125068,
-0.0076798773,
0.8204883933,
0.508849144,
-0.0672839805,
0.3952570558,
0.0537191667,
0.0235805903,
-0.2497401088,
0.0029092822,
-0.5658820868,
-0.0835309029,
-0.5974727869,
-0.507774055,
0.6072779894,
-0.1208562329,
-0.2977082133,
0.5324295759,
-0.4736723006,
0.7608093619,
0.0693821087,
-0.0112006171,
0.5458413363,
-0.0546925291,
-0.2096463293,
-0.1016000956,
-0.648712337,
-0.308691442,
1.0475776196,
0.2942634523,
0.7504422665,
0.3468953371,
0.5115749836,
0.2700147629,
0.2474833131,
-0.5830622911,
0.7135868669,
-0.2342276871,
-0.6547738314,
-0.3733970225,
-0.4145024419,
-0.968934834,
0.4091852605,
-0.3150291145,
-0.3990604877,
-0.126277253,
0.1689475626,
-0.2259046137,
0.2774836123,
-0.9267880917,
0.7111939192,
-0.7780340314,
-0.4440182745,
-0.2439407259,
-0.653128922,
0.5916742086,
-0.2429326475,
0.4330613315,
0.2350132465,
-0.0370961763,
0.4683803916,
-0.1453407109,
1.0507090092,
-0.00115536,
0.0319068283,
0.0166130532,
0.4643375278,
0.3242428005,
-0.0166162346,
-0.0931971893,
0.452553153,
-0.0699739903,
-0.1729596406,
-0.3062411845,
0.5463401079,
-0.4913769066,
-0.1251130402,
-0.5790799856,
-0.4474244416,
-0.3120604157,
0.4151613116,
0.1252226233,
0.1002945304,
-0.4307206273,
0.0502587073,
0.5972033739,
-0.4466241002,
0.4391007721,
0.7798323035,
-0.3343784809,
-0.3843134642,
0.9581201673,
-0.0678256825,
0.6314781904,
0.4433887005,
-0.0200739577,
-0.1154520735,
-0.7396121621,
-0.2116566747,
0.1052859351,
-0.5118421912,
-0.2883298993,
-0.4387468994,
-0.0754662603,
-0.0925388858,
-0.3531558216,
-0.5533485413,
-0.2348366678,
0.3282762766,
-0.0830418766,
0.3421204686,
0.4117166996,
-0.0564199463,
-0.0079906909,
-0.715393424,
-0.009444233,
0.2025423646,
0.3061889112,
-0.2252742499,
-0.0090493616,
-0.3414385915,
-0.1205271855,
-0.2095329463,
-0.9361816645,
0.2570437193,
-0.266718328,
0.4668534696,
0.0419137478,
0.2484968305,
0.4998824596,
-0.4044602513,
0.5819850564,
0.3484376073,
-0.9263883233,
0.2834174037,
-0.5082448721,
0.3129581511,
0.93646878,
0.0883907154,
-0.845133841,
-0.4963912368,
-0.3477126956,
-0.955745995,
0.5151894093,
0.2405981123,
-0.3094914556,
-0.2116400898,
-0.2386299372,
-0.0980483368,
-0.0474217385,
-0.977963388,
-0.45602265,
-0.0416063182,
0.1780245304,
0.1259515882,
0.0630839467,
-0.1518662125,
-0.0361227542,
0.4983263612,
-0.1270977855,
0.2793551683,
0.0337089263,
-0.4767274261,
-0.0491666012,
0.4119472802,
0.7514781356,
0.3895898163,
-0.0004335842,
0.2465615869,
0.7408562303,
-0.439483285,
-0.0073870029,
-0.0327403322,
0.1604718864,
-0.1463622004,
0.4570119083,
0.2504298091,
0.4057290256,
-0.8281945586,
0.5060009956,
-0.262668103,
-0.3280108273,
-0.3038855493,
-0.1518296152,
0.0846345648,
-0.0324799418,
0.110700123,
0.0819830298,
-0.128608495,
-0.1765331477,
0.439121753,
0.6274061203,
-0.3611059487,
-0.117109552,
0.3380562067,
0.4341416061,
-0.0504029542,
0.3434529006,
-0.104308784,
-0.6118088365,
0.6752766371,
0.5838374496,
0.7876977921,
-0.3093031645,
0.12017598,
0.3242215514,
0.7987575531,
0.1175738499,
0.2067438215,
0.0732433796,
-0.7834568024,
-0.4987868667,
-0.1227713004,
-0.7031337619,
-0.062161684,
-0.8568803668,
0.4857116044,
-0.3105660975,
0.1275914013,
-0.2323716134,
-0.1389180273,
-0.4910096526,
-0.0939081609,
0.120189555,
1.0324889421,
-0.781440556,
0.8244880438,
0.7822644711,
-0.2187962681,
-0.3539659679,
-0.1342203915,
0.1823560745,
-1.0204367638,
0.6927501559,
-0.2488768846,
-0.3543652892,
-0.2522832155,
-0.4697285891,
-0.6745266318,
0.9254640341,
0.41490978,
-0.6345013976,
0.2427584231,
0.5288747549,
0.3942373395,
0.009132904,
0.2608440518,
0.7484047413,
0.491140753,
-0.2384997606,
-1.0109221935,
0.0277182329,
-0.3473005891,
-0.3347112536,
0.344430089,
-0.8852756619,
0.6798954606,
-0.2486732751,
-0.3374946415,
-0.2356656194,
0.2329119146,
0.4703112841,
0.1477702707,
0.8335034251,
0.1213206947,
0.594745934,
0.1121561602,
0.8795310259,
-0.4384596348,
0.4517275095,
1.1713831425,
-0.3874198198,
1.0190069675,
0.4831038713,
-0.2034071386,
0.1607689708,
0.1508833319,
-0.0026825885,
0.3952114284,
0.2780044973,
-0.2446629703,
-0.411097914,
0.2457071841,
-0.4355964065,
0.5598791242,
0.1719388664,
-0.0181399062,
-0.4102244973,
0.0787977949,
0.520545423,
0.0790733323,
0.0804919749,
0.721155405,
-0.1204092726,
-0.5316656232,
0.7345692515,
-0.1618988365,
1.0023177862,
-0.7638858557,
0.0093408599,
-0.2068710476,
0.0860454962,
-0.279694885,
-0.6337735653,
0.3620262444,
0.3880333304,
-0.0170292314,
-0.5185594559,
0.5670503378,
-0.4801310003,
-0.5444528461,
0.5732175112,
0.4622631669,
0.0657287166,
0.3234182894,
-0.8690341711,
0.4298217893,
0.2113527656,
0.1308546066,
0.6168167591,
0.0197190028,
-0.1041836515,
0.6001937985,
0.7180458903,
0.1462926269,
-0.0143875424,
-0.0846671909,
0.7308574319,
-0.6865187883,
-0.4523787796,
-0.9470348358,
0.504897356,
-0.0142008895,
-0.328099072,
1.0044101477,
0.7187131047,
0.8391739726,
0.2566186488,
1.2072092295,
0.1558206528,
0.4721772373,
-0.4668490887,
0.9992829561,
-0.1965782642,
0.3743264377,
-0.6235592961,
-0.3006510437,
-0.6171450615,
0.3648922145,
-0.1952529699,
0.0006667439,
1.0116424561,
0.6907043457,
0.187225312,
0.1295939982,
0.319701165,
0.3712154031,
0.5234386921,
0.6554695964,
0.9208432436,
-0.2621117532,
1.0670378208,
-0.2117433101,
-0.4766683877,
-0.127084747,
-1.0249433517,
-0.926746428,
-0.2819911838,
-0.5220599771,
-0.423879832,
0.3000943065,
0.7860674262,
0.4958235323,
-0.6917322874,
-0.6392604113,
-0.0260049831,
0.0794235542,
-0.4318741262,
-0.1926999539,
0.0939107388,
-0.4608388245,
-0.5442436934,
0.5597513318,
0.114093259,
-0.0188424643,
-0.2149845213,
-0.0791364312,
-0.1507123411,
-0.4102103114,
0.6973956823,
0.5818428993,
-0.3036316037,
-0.2482950985,
0.2277844697,
-0.1667414904,
-0.2265377641,
0.9197148681,
-0.4427781999,
0.2708876729,
0.347694248,
0.7633314133,
0.1887867749,
-0.2649743557,
0.4839515984,
-0.6843140721,
-0.0429942384,
0.213626653,
0.2872344851,
0.0645375401,
-0.1944938302,
0.5627960563,
-0.0223170407,
-0.6416891813,
-1.1065227985,
0.0678035393,
-1.1515148878,
-0.3528598547,
1.5912469625,
0.1100293249,
-0.0126063395,
-0.5597960949,
-0.1706259102,
0.0297340974,
-0.3328849673,
0.6215258241,
0.5458059311,
-0.3302948773,
-0.0391874686,
-0.5925785899,
0.4491921365,
0.6239039302,
-0.9816384315,
0.4985597432,
0.2388562411,
0.3519740701,
0.1293903738,
0.6800904274,
-0.1873888224,
0.6352117062,
-0.1938522309,
0.3172598183,
-0.0942033455,
-0.1233921647,
-0.5141944289,
0.2832023799,
0.0301268697,
-0.2811152935
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11239v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11239v1 | Evading AI-Generated Content Detectors using Homoglyphs | 2024-06-17T06:07:32 | 2024-06-17T06:07:32 | Aldan Creo, Shushanta Pudasaini | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The generation of text that is increasingly human-like has been enabled by
the advent of large language models (LLMs). As the detection of AI-generated
content holds significant importance in the fight against issues such as
misinformation and academic cheating, numerous studies have been conducted to
develop reliable LLM detectors. While promising results have been demonstrated
by such detectors on test data, recent research has revealed that they can be
circumvented by employing different techniques. In this article,
homoglyph-based ($a \rightarrow {\alpha}$) attacks that can be used to
circumvent existing LLM detectors are presented. The efficacy of the attacks is
illustrated by analizing how homoglyphs shift the tokenization of the text, and
thus its token loglikelihoods. A comprehensive evaluation is conducted to
assess the effectiveness of homoglyphs on state-of-the-art LLM detectors,
including Binoculars, DetectGPT, OpenAI's detector, and watermarking
techniques, on five different datasets. A significant reduction in the
efficiency of all the studied configurations of detectors and datasets, down to
an accuracy of 0.5 (random guessing), is demonstrated by the proposed approach.
The results show that homoglyph-based attacks can effectively evade existing
LLM detectors, and the implications of these findings are discussed along with
possible defenses against such attacks. | [
-0.4062648416,
-1.1926567554,
0.4136474431,
-0.4225699306,
-0.3829169273,
0.260215342,
-0.0947968215,
-0.8648331761,
0.3027124405,
0.2839211822,
-0.2058126926,
-0.4302277863,
-0.8271021247,
0.3449953198,
-0.726326406,
0.7217587233,
-0.1539295316,
-0.1035090089,
0.1100939289,
0.1629796773,
-0.2159074694,
-0.6593616009,
-0.5109903812,
-0.0713343099,
0.4101287723,
0.0875128284,
0.9522450566,
0.7922723889,
0.8170753717,
0.1544931531,
-0.1907853186,
0.0782029852,
-0.2810721993,
0.0472486168,
0.3129962087,
-0.3658231795,
-0.3113857508,
-0.006144511,
0.8345178962,
0.2498984486,
0.0973207355,
0.1032834649,
-0.1904264838,
0.4502614439,
-0.6931109428,
-0.0056021949,
-0.8483548164,
0.1504947394,
-0.7982802391,
-0.2458583713,
-0.6505628824,
-0.1334834099,
-0.2059479207,
-0.4530548155,
0.0206814464,
0.3651144803,
0.8415730596,
0.1433056444,
-0.0199037809,
-0.8956230283,
-0.7811380625,
0.8006139994,
-0.8490693569,
0.3397795558,
0.7001405358,
0.2066733241,
-0.2484676838,
-0.6984639168,
-0.6630634069,
-0.222777307,
0.0012048752,
-0.0620236807,
-0.4584870934,
0.0224018358,
0.3331139088,
0.4434685111,
-0.5258132219,
0.2082799077,
-0.1116333008,
-0.4245380759,
0.6821507215,
-0.0951032192,
0.7511495948,
-0.2984495461,
-0.337341696,
-0.2749002576,
-0.9803703427,
-0.110916324,
0.6449037194,
0.0429363176,
0.2258570343,
0.7752136588,
0.3078089654,
0.540450871,
0.038402766,
-0.2711194456,
-0.1735880226,
-0.2373985648,
-0.1757142842,
0.2469056547,
0.7610942721,
0.1305199414,
0.5403238535,
-0.287286371,
-0.4317920506,
0.3469986022,
0.3644635677,
-0.7558681965,
-0.080368422,
0.2536077797,
-0.5912348032,
-0.3665325344,
0.0794515535,
-0.6698639989,
-0.3835979104,
0.3834487498,
0.3743494749,
-0.4815267622,
0.0885424614,
0.0705954731,
-0.016371401,
0.4287559986,
0.1555663049,
-1.0722615719,
0.1509842575,
0.9292339087,
0.8469746709,
-0.1937560886,
-0.1189615205,
-0.8330251575,
0.2559982836,
-0.2605085671,
0.7779718637,
-0.5848382115,
-0.6666572094,
0.0017840815,
-0.3756904304,
0.2097468525,
-0.4591977894,
0.5233191848,
-0.7140969634,
0.0987689197,
-0.0651041195,
-0.9288190603,
-0.1336090863,
0.5304884315,
-0.8359492421,
0.6308977008,
-0.1750344038,
-1.0992634296,
0.2015157044,
-0.5916276574,
-0.618709743,
0.3449009955,
-0.3953312635,
-0.5276756883,
0.1138197929,
0.3979903758,
0.1711824983,
-0.2180007547,
-0.0810787454,
-0.1909476072,
-0.7487894893,
0.227729395,
-0.5466914177,
0.6446905136,
0.1041803136,
-0.6055621505,
0.0496294126,
-0.3060283661,
-0.2732242942,
0.3666321039,
-0.2022519112,
-0.5049523115,
0.3035600781,
-0.0111562014,
-0.285510689,
0.2563807368,
-0.6797623038,
0.1966379136,
-0.3259647191,
0.1224039868,
0.9814008474,
-0.0220124833,
0.2008989155,
-0.3094879389,
0.7333490252,
-0.2724015117,
0.4741846919,
-0.3193149865,
-0.883254528,
-0.2299928516,
-0.4612899125,
0.2988286912,
0.5175488591,
-0.9619874358,
0.2654845715,
-0.0725303665,
-0.3036682308,
-0.6620435119,
0.1712003201,
0.3000433147,
0.4105096459,
0.2641087174,
-0.6215142012,
-0.3294626474,
-0.5531235337,
-0.6246281862,
-0.6484336853,
-0.076293312,
0.2324131131,
0.4323504567,
-0.4671403468,
0.8551239371,
-0.3797037601,
-0.0435728095,
0.0703807101,
0.0504804179,
-0.0789127871,
0.3827424347,
0.7142961025,
-0.9882074594,
-0.4794922769,
-0.1809274852,
-0.7935314775,
-0.0206854418,
-0.2159563601,
0.2262669206,
0.2505695522,
0.6601011753,
-0.5351099968,
0.8781788945,
0.5853984952,
-0.4841549993,
0.7364788651,
0.1734336764,
0.1212600321,
-0.7524511218,
0.1347444057,
0.006592317,
-0.4097069204,
-0.7561958432,
0.509883225,
-0.1043752879,
0.2130919695,
-0.3740576804,
0.817589879,
-0.3188054264,
-0.0678905696,
-0.5000188947,
-0.1052231044,
-0.1963074803,
0.0959159732,
-0.2254760116,
0.8544952273,
0.5583809018,
-0.1815890968,
0.4299432039,
0.338906914,
-0.3782643378,
0.4031935036,
-0.6290507317,
0.4087677896,
-0.2327082753,
0.2652721405,
-0.9775425196,
-0.0978606269,
0.6620575786,
-0.52232939,
0.2813858092,
-0.1263985485,
-0.7752189636,
-0.1429662555,
-0.6890096068,
0.3685853481,
0.6018283963,
-0.823492229,
0.6016116738,
0.3838852048,
-0.0673150718,
-0.5976837873,
-0.8281518817,
0.5459410548,
-0.3967458606,
-0.5246634483,
0.1926077902,
-0.422585696,
-0.5218589306,
-0.1311395317,
-0.0478152521,
0.1609144211,
0.4013026059,
0.1926354617,
0.3731003106,
-0.0273108538,
-0.210916236,
-0.2923462093,
-0.0113894232,
0.1942577958,
-0.1317951679,
0.7939779758,
-0.0471966676,
-0.8467268348,
-0.7509350777,
0.3645449579,
0.5759281516,
-0.0080601098,
0.6069524884,
0.7975114584,
-0.5889644027,
0.3595007658,
-0.4281104803,
-0.3965882957,
-0.520486474,
0.1778021157,
-0.0692870542,
-0.8022934198,
0.441678077,
0.1718069166,
0.3558644056,
0.4034508169,
0.5224968195,
-0.0687035471,
1.094758153,
0.163786754,
-0.3562482297,
0.5904590487,
0.0842500404,
0.2325782031,
-0.8672982454,
-0.1027267128,
-0.465854764,
-0.3141167462,
-0.7824214697,
-0.2512227893,
0.2339862287,
-0.0340471491,
0.1193592027,
0.23935166,
-0.1387804151,
0.4295837581,
0.3210622072,
-0.0243915543,
0.4496533871,
0.2691704333,
0.1582008004,
0.1942218691,
-0.5672907829,
-0.5388326049,
1.3546749353,
0.5697089434,
0.9339601398,
0.1152266935,
0.8216899633,
0.8017855883,
0.5940339565,
-0.7377025485,
0.4298785329,
-0.1964727789,
-0.6890385151,
-0.2788347602,
-0.4400041699,
-0.9249561429,
-0.1082631275,
-0.286075592,
-0.8250482678,
-0.0354401581,
0.0227857418,
0.0406903774,
0.7453004122,
-0.5465968847,
0.3896031976,
-0.2343132049,
-0.1396238506,
-0.0624632798,
-0.3572022021,
0.2192336619,
-0.3461576998,
0.4421927333,
0.1333514303,
0.1077708304,
0.6318251491,
-0.0504848175,
0.7797439098,
-0.1228492409,
-0.4617604613,
0.4427333176,
0.3392994404,
0.6465435624,
0.1311192513,
-0.1176943853,
0.4313473105,
-0.3682079613,
-0.6563870311,
-0.3269269764,
0.4195491076,
-0.4087972641,
-0.7142378092,
-0.3146547675,
-0.5298261046,
0.1891091168,
0.1408490837,
0.4548063874,
0.3999993205,
-0.4180915356,
-0.0360232554,
0.3995568156,
-0.2156036645,
0.5879936218,
-0.1127493903,
-0.464171946,
-0.3119875193,
0.8239697814,
-0.2946191728,
0.3288277686,
0.1421025842,
0.2301184535,
-0.3136863112,
-0.7879820466,
-0.6867062449,
0.0580107197,
-0.6217273474,
-0.1690823883,
-0.3014577925,
-0.3219666183,
-0.4635609984,
-0.2014881372,
-0.1364540458,
-0.3140509725,
-0.2548736036,
0.1795817465,
0.1809702516,
0.6492878199,
0.1261590868,
0.3967638314,
-0.7740061879,
0.4635235667,
0.448789835,
0.1328307688,
0.1548950076,
-0.5211049318,
-0.1450086832,
0.1600738615,
-0.0418429524,
-0.8023906946,
0.2265977114,
0.0815924034,
0.3381716907,
0.6800416112,
-0.1616584808,
0.4809329212,
-0.4237575829,
0.6537078619,
0.0837506503,
-1.0546569824,
0.3625832796,
-0.2083809972,
0.2331709713,
0.3618524075,
0.350140512,
-0.5942682028,
-0.4991181195,
-0.6519998908,
-0.665189445,
0.3187047243,
0.6097590923,
0.0290270895,
-0.0942890942,
0.7040838003,
0.079549402,
0.1224192157,
-0.6530072689,
-0.2820661068,
-0.0741935894,
-0.1679800749,
0.1153683588,
-0.1080631241,
-0.1357579082,
-0.0265337229,
0.3964624107,
-0.1176516563,
0.225043878,
0.275983125,
-0.2608930469,
-0.163572982,
0.0490206517,
0.4657304883,
0.3179296851,
-0.204919979,
0.4041724801,
-0.1170408726,
-0.9357077479,
-0.0905081928,
0.0053256159,
-0.5793425441,
0.0208630431,
0.7201725245,
0.7268847227,
-0.3752809167,
-0.9337009788,
0.4153846502,
-0.3340502977,
0.2625161707,
-0.1403343529,
0.1192748323,
-0.240689531,
0.0304525383,
0.5020713806,
-0.2007144243,
0.0426197685,
-0.8023973703,
0.3832631111,
0.7715325356,
-0.3897633255,
-0.3864308596,
0.5194907784,
0.0384293087,
-0.6413320899,
0.6214419603,
-0.2523995638,
-0.6222763062,
0.7558019757,
0.8161589503,
0.8641055226,
-0.4937324226,
0.0718643516,
0.0041928291,
0.6581887603,
0.0403126292,
0.03096091,
-0.0522488914,
-0.8949612379,
-0.2153829634,
-0.5509288907,
-0.6282117963,
-0.0367067605,
-0.5109390616,
0.0566034876,
-0.7837113142,
-0.1138794273,
-0.031405177,
-0.1498301923,
-0.2432377487,
-0.009377392,
0.7594479322,
0.8920404315,
-0.5546486974,
0.6044585109,
0.6417766213,
0.173460871,
-0.3194369972,
0.514518559,
0.1888658702,
-1.0171604156,
0.1904625744,
0.2773223519,
-0.172030285,
-0.0285795629,
-0.7424721122,
-0.4867196083,
0.74732548,
0.2003771663,
-0.5597073436,
-0.0521354042,
0.3047421575,
0.4823463261,
-0.2770582736,
0.1145565808,
0.6840455532,
0.7611131668,
-0.0611971281,
-0.6032304168,
0.1172744036,
-0.1929212213,
-0.3041160405,
0.2094492316,
-0.4467701614,
0.7390136719,
0.0213662554,
-0.4123614728,
0.082544364,
0.5796122551,
0.5587107539,
0.3729569316,
0.7387379408,
0.3364214003,
0.7234044075,
0.1140089706,
1.2729340792,
-0.2572627664,
0.2848539054,
0.5948108435,
-0.2849786878,
0.6281126142,
0.7183753252,
0.1488257647,
0.4792208672,
0.4516273737,
-0.3419249952,
0.2303314209,
0.2981154025,
-0.2802161276,
-0.1493934691,
-0.186966747,
-0.2806763351,
0.6865141392,
0.4653679132,
0.0203728937,
-0.1284170598,
-0.0877823755,
0.281529814,
-0.0721688271,
-0.2812131643,
0.6150442958,
0.0144119896,
-0.3710463047,
0.5841115713,
0.1998413652,
1.0256707668,
-0.5634431243,
0.1548092812,
-0.2200340629,
-0.1005182862,
-0.2074826211,
-0.7322617769,
0.2484266013,
0.4814425409,
0.2927312255,
-0.1966730654,
0.9467950463,
-0.067879416,
-0.4754371345,
0.2919325531,
0.2185016721,
0.0901111811,
-0.0562825873,
-0.530900836,
0.2298762649,
0.055758439,
-0.3110010624,
0.2675420046,
-0.0394318104,
-0.0186001193,
0.5567628741,
0.8942222595,
0.3372088671,
0.0287734792,
-0.1535815448,
0.7942802906,
-0.7270837426,
-0.4843303859,
-1.1885159016,
-0.1881638318,
0.1470919102,
0.1203554943,
0.8842735291,
0.5075821877,
0.8074694276,
0.1820526123,
0.7200248241,
0.0693716556,
-0.1114740446,
-0.7133614421,
0.8284024,
-0.4592707157,
0.518956542,
-0.5497050285,
-0.9690159559,
-0.4432814717,
0.4865276515,
0.0506458059,
0.0240097512,
0.4001962245,
0.484634608,
-0.0403419435,
0.3057427406,
0.0906886309,
0.1396605819,
0.9214208722,
0.5283969045,
1.0773185492,
-0.5617831349,
0.3896334171,
-0.0121933725,
-0.2382268906,
-0.2137022465,
-0.8546996713,
-1.0775971413,
-0.3357768357,
-0.1827562153,
-0.2528062165,
0.123148419,
0.4603022337,
0.4703990221,
-0.7344325185,
-0.1130009294,
-0.0094219446,
0.1456791908,
0.1795196831,
-0.1403894573,
0.6076233983,
0.1190972254,
-0.7669584751,
0.4518738389,
0.3822619617,
0.3317122757,
-0.4245904982,
-0.1001075208,
-0.3464258313,
0.3459607065,
0.3388262987,
0.4508748353,
-0.6568930149,
-0.6914880276,
0.0888188183,
-0.084437795,
0.1880271584,
0.8431916237,
-0.6946343184,
0.4006539285,
0.4628469646,
0.6976357698,
0.3420921862,
0.1559354961,
0.1894612014,
-0.6787278056,
0.3442930877,
0.3021915257,
0.262001276,
0.468953222,
-0.6006374955,
0.3166002631,
0.3821514845,
-0.324059099,
-0.9294201136,
0.3752399385,
-0.6897147894,
-0.4328874052,
1.1436811686,
-0.2015310377,
-0.4849113226,
0.0009598574,
0.0014787052,
0.1509464085,
-0.1626450717,
1.3844556808,
0.9355797172,
-0.0623037331,
0.3744415045,
-0.2435538173,
0.4450793862,
0.4875124097,
-1.1500743628,
0.0190817863,
0.2389820665,
0.0461830571,
0.406237185,
0.4296646118,
-0.42219311,
0.342153877,
-0.194114238,
0.0103251198,
0.0424109027,
-0.4581894577,
-0.4407949746,
0.031503994,
-0.0104952035,
-0.2208100855
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11238v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11238v1 | What Kinds of Tokens Benefit from Distant Text? An Analysis on Long Context Language Modeling | 2024-06-17T06:07:29 | 2024-06-17T06:07:29 | Yutong Hu, Quzhe Huang, Kangcheng Luo, Yansong Feng | cs.CL | cs.CL | As the context length that large language models can handle continues to
increase, these models demonstrate an enhanced ability to utilize distant
information for tasks such as language modeling. This capability contrasts with
human reading and writing habits, where it is uncommon to remember and use
particularly distant information, except in cases of foreshadowing. In this
paper, we aim to explore which kinds of words benefit more from long contexts
in language models. By analyzing the changes in token probabilities with
increasing context length, we find that content words (e.g., nouns, adjectives)
and the initial tokens of words benefit the most. Frequent patterns in the
context (N-grams) also significantly impact predictions. Additionally, the
model's prior knowledge plays a crucial role in influencing predictions,
especially for rare tokens. We also observe that language models become more
confident with longer contexts, resulting in sharper probability distributions.
This overconfidence may contribute to the increasing probabilities of tokens
with distant contextual information. We hope that our analysis will help the
community better understand long-text language modeling and contribute to the
design of more reliable long-context models. | [
-0.0968826711,
-0.8987320662,
0.7759698629,
0.2138908654,
-0.4352093637,
-0.4118277431,
-0.4669578671,
-0.9015724659,
0.1735250801,
0.4572903514,
-0.09609586,
-0.3030605614,
-0.7643964291,
0.0865368173,
-0.5599778295,
1.2079998255,
0.0829205438,
-0.199405551,
-0.3531112969,
0.0298056118,
-0.5356941819,
-1.0084695816,
-0.6105906367,
-0.0724761263,
0.8262416124,
0.132313922,
0.6568074822,
0.5440173745,
0.4290277958,
0.278606534,
-0.2178659886,
-0.228167221,
-0.3930998147,
0.2533248663,
-0.395791322,
-0.5812226534,
-0.2632835805,
-0.1922916472,
0.7474674582,
0.9496896863,
0.2931207716,
-0.0924798548,
0.2066192031,
0.6654766202,
-0.5996842384,
0.3052024841,
-0.4710347652,
-0.1027548015,
-0.5928700566,
0.0436476991,
-0.2548197806,
-0.0701940209,
0.4155247808,
-0.3355319798,
-0.1395660788,
0.143796742,
0.5963125229,
-0.1950162202,
-0.7551709414,
-0.3408628702,
-0.7296224833,
1.089198947,
-0.6091041565,
0.4770559072,
0.7738342881,
0.1473209262,
-0.3239210844,
-0.9007367492,
-0.465751797,
-0.4232331216,
-0.2228484005,
-0.0562815741,
-0.1210536361,
0.1862642467,
-0.0550848432,
0.3678260148,
-0.0065286267,
0.2487318367,
-0.3827276826,
-0.1048959419,
0.2680232823,
0.0700903088,
-0.0056967111,
-0.4794357717,
-0.4117560685,
0.107804507,
-0.7221493721,
0.1710037887,
0.1801174432,
0.2981655896,
-0.0827610269,
0.6107376218,
-0.3432188928,
0.9366659522,
-0.3069197536,
-0.2064437866,
0.0174870044,
-0.6391708851,
-0.1004465967,
-0.171684593,
0.2322186083,
0.4170658886,
0.2599859834,
-0.4318754971,
-0.1883195192,
-0.3874934912,
-0.1568315327,
-0.8514646292,
0.1044026092,
0.1498692185,
-0.8134121299,
-0.0915396139,
0.3033958077,
-0.6738374233,
-0.2515733242,
-0.3383578658,
0.2223248184,
-0.4697565436,
-0.1750840247,
0.1437352449,
-0.5249557495,
-0.0481963456,
0.1297843307,
-0.9915210605,
0.3525188863,
1.0209777355,
0.8653858304,
-0.3728738427,
-0.3004369438,
-0.7298889756,
0.0491005294,
-0.3095532954,
0.6155281067,
-0.7015259862,
-0.5733857751,
0.226994276,
0.1235320717,
-0.012690803,
-0.2193306237,
0.5288661122,
-0.4491806924,
0.3334190249,
-0.5496150851,
-0.7904938459,
-0.1392383277,
0.0157529209,
-0.7145693302,
0.831135571,
0.0421245806,
-0.8830957413,
0.6922518015,
-0.5592903495,
-0.5984418392,
-0.0009964175,
-0.1395816207,
0.0093682129,
0.5305202603,
-0.2906897962,
0.7277941108,
-0.0875089094,
0.3733347356,
-0.203514263,
-0.431822747,
0.6633786559,
-0.4696318209,
0.0844402015,
0.1261098385,
-0.3168855608,
0.140618369,
-0.5700801611,
-0.3202966154,
-0.1595564038,
-0.3626050055,
-0.9248860478,
0.3064730167,
0.1283288151,
0.2775361836,
0.2184170634,
-0.5407004356,
-0.0197977833,
-0.4109634459,
0.3828665316,
0.8318332434,
0.1155635267,
0.5716767311,
-0.3358691931,
0.338778466,
0.3689659834,
-0.0323385708,
-0.4478200078,
-0.7834089994,
-0.4038439691,
-0.2985167801,
0.3600191474,
0.1187015921,
-0.4884265959,
0.2861883938,
-0.3623729646,
-0.1211830452,
0.1466001719,
-0.0372471884,
0.3059293628,
0.3429321945,
0.1325635165,
-0.2907857597,
-0.5455613136,
-0.8161928654,
-0.430460602,
-0.0658033118,
0.050144542,
0.4155829847,
0.6852048635,
-0.2102851719,
1.3509463072,
-0.6782212257,
-0.2101526707,
-0.2155311555,
-0.0774832517,
0.0930793434,
0.3863137364,
0.7646357417,
-0.9082884192,
-0.1582840085,
-0.0978629664,
-0.3142558634,
0.1909608394,
-0.1859326065,
-0.1192990467,
0.3389610946,
0.7523916364,
-0.5432469249,
0.4967894554,
0.620628655,
-0.6601355672,
0.6988037825,
-0.0898774564,
-0.071838133,
-1.2327771187,
0.2179487646,
-0.0891909748,
-0.2087588757,
-0.6263931394,
-0.1253478229,
-0.2302404791,
0.2996449471,
-0.3381542563,
1.0721926689,
-0.4632615447,
0.0015316351,
-0.3846460879,
0.2299697846,
-0.0198025536,
0.0632809773,
0.330534488,
0.7050081491,
0.3836686313,
-0.560297966,
0.1233503371,
-0.0289827604,
-0.5463566184,
0.1317636222,
-0.5052357912,
-0.1324079633,
-0.2977396548,
0.3531933129,
-0.9021639228,
-0.3572013676,
-0.0807546526,
-0.2700204253,
0.2150447816,
0.123611562,
-0.5761299729,
-0.1436399221,
-0.1784277856,
0.5229697824,
0.2927029431,
-0.387198478,
0.2561969757,
0.2201042026,
-0.2085007727,
-0.5760582089,
-0.7223737836,
0.1573234797,
-0.3591809273,
-0.2700445354,
0.3969133496,
0.0714881346,
-0.6272120476,
-0.0090374192,
0.1070245728,
-0.1164187938,
0.2761808038,
0.5779842734,
0.0135750091,
-0.1527651548,
0.7406243086,
0.0084835766,
0.0318691358,
0.0159082934,
-0.5590428114,
0.5601342916,
-0.1590251178,
-0.0535726734,
0.065284133,
0.6772150993,
0.3523346484,
-0.0564057864,
1.2579423189,
0.3369533718,
-0.4849073589,
0.1276804507,
-0.4862792194,
-0.2648689449,
-0.4409544766,
0.7170864344,
-0.3424669802,
-1.1203581095,
0.7674517035,
0.1702916622,
-0.1019920483,
0.5084058046,
0.2975075841,
0.3126209676,
0.601206243,
0.9045528769,
-0.3149067163,
1.0819267035,
0.2404818386,
0.1127613783,
-0.6925724745,
-0.2461180389,
-0.425899148,
0.1381465048,
-0.5415707827,
-0.5818116665,
-0.0593528673,
0.2861579955,
0.0334117226,
0.1692133397,
-0.0108721647,
0.3786893785,
0.6622046828,
-0.1149313673,
0.2498368174,
-0.0351032615,
-0.1531760842,
-0.1135172471,
-0.4588470459,
-0.4199228585,
1.0240676403,
0.5400905013,
0.3766357899,
0.0407609604,
0.6820614338,
0.0770934001,
0.1813160181,
-0.7581944466,
0.33995983,
-0.2472596318,
-0.7984966636,
-0.2246032655,
-0.2588620186,
-1.1827725172,
-0.2102270275,
-0.2201697528,
-0.8992418647,
0.1820230633,
-0.2193788439,
-0.3114359975,
0.2831790745,
-0.3976950943,
0.6390557885,
-0.0570937656,
-0.2595140338,
-0.1247675642,
-0.7731741071,
0.1166994348,
-0.2941155136,
0.2117068917,
0.2257037014,
-0.1786941737,
0.9165402651,
-0.167903021,
0.9736756086,
0.1996059418,
-0.2639514506,
0.3601622283,
-0.1502156705,
0.5451741219,
-0.0838618651,
-0.3597376347,
0.2240374386,
0.0221985336,
-0.3845641911,
-0.3116360605,
0.7005152702,
-0.4458042085,
-0.443453759,
-0.2701694369,
-0.3528677225,
0.0089282654,
0.4066951573,
0.4705173075,
0.6445707083,
-0.320343107,
0.5541709661,
0.173270762,
-0.415001899,
0.6445123553,
0.0683325604,
-0.3899318874,
-0.2125135958,
0.4997837842,
0.1833623499,
0.5026910305,
0.5264592171,
0.2813920677,
-0.3154623806,
-0.3303587139,
-0.0889707208,
0.1274387985,
-0.8599534035,
-0.0526387393,
-0.6073621511,
0.027220143,
-0.5329899788,
-0.1890357435,
-0.0414704755,
-0.5752266645,
-0.4046884477,
-0.338642478,
0.6493486762,
0.85615623,
0.0378004424,
0.4221161306,
-0.8127846122,
-0.1299047321,
0.220803231,
0.5826522708,
0.1199883074,
-0.21042189,
-0.6083487272,
-0.0047020004,
0.1458376795,
-0.9525409341,
0.1701218933,
0.2814297974,
0.431360513,
0.7566362619,
-0.1548420787,
0.7490813136,
-0.5333869457,
1.1128690243,
0.0975801498,
-0.8713241816,
0.0598660856,
-0.5241660476,
0.3861016035,
0.5901944637,
0.0117327133,
-0.9372454286,
-0.4511758387,
-0.4550382793,
-0.9434680343,
0.2998704314,
0.2798734307,
0.5016089082,
-0.7105658054,
0.7227372527,
0.3967797756,
0.4176845551,
-0.7618576288,
-0.1083778292,
-0.060918957,
0.0273985621,
-0.2367270887,
-0.5260102749,
0.1229782701,
-0.0450364277,
0.2290832549,
-0.1157624274,
0.3611452579,
0.1064897105,
0.1477074772,
0.0111870486,
0.3610832691,
0.828389883,
0.5998962522,
-0.0713993907,
0.1419062316,
0.2967107296,
-0.5802549124,
-0.4467055202,
-0.0383224748,
0.3051121831,
0.1636999696,
0.6142687201,
0.7919229269,
0.369902581,
-0.5726476908,
0.6627042294,
0.0513415933,
0.292678386,
-0.4194303155,
-0.1208274812,
0.1478281617,
0.0516973212,
0.5466166735,
-0.0474351719,
0.2404381931,
-0.8794445395,
0.3237573504,
0.4415130615,
-0.359838903,
-0.4078189433,
0.4875758886,
0.1712205112,
-0.125127539,
0.532697618,
-0.0324934311,
-0.5643982887,
0.7151122689,
0.8433663845,
0.6754084229,
0.1515714228,
-0.1177073568,
0.0986599997,
-0.1971443444,
-0.2151931226,
-0.0074609383,
-0.2259692103,
-0.5116540194,
-0.5090749264,
-0.8786200285,
0.0091038998,
0.0070722839,
-0.5513613224,
0.0686128885,
-0.2126071602,
-0.384673655,
-0.254458487,
0.0249075275,
-0.5829939246,
0.3612109125,
0.2021017522,
0.877352953,
-0.7066908479,
0.9579210281,
0.4727479219,
-0.1094865203,
-0.6491887569,
0.1314709485,
-0.3402193189,
-0.3764681816,
1.1539957523,
0.5542902946,
-0.2267950773,
-0.1758077443,
-0.3035700917,
-1.0697704554,
0.8891959786,
-0.2405664623,
-0.5737326741,
-0.3467658758,
0.1417544633,
0.7579962015,
-0.3781013489,
0.0595197752,
0.3724088073,
0.2941670418,
-0.0597092062,
-0.9292219877,
0.1998214722,
0.0870605037,
0.1308446229,
0.4980353713,
-0.4028879702,
0.9976280928,
-0.2465580851,
-0.2121881545,
0.4885409474,
0.9792225361,
0.0675810575,
0.3031918406,
0.3776817918,
0.0400051028,
0.5048173666,
0.1586259454,
1.2440248728,
-0.5332404971,
0.2256937623,
1.1190766096,
0.0050286688,
1.0885109901,
0.6793438196,
0.1694389433,
0.8037382364,
0.4790862501,
0.3689584136,
0.480032146,
0.1724331528,
-0.3503825963,
-0.0700584128,
-0.1446212828,
-0.4336385131,
0.5389691591,
0.3444356322,
-0.6385798454,
-0.0139974505,
0.2536637783,
0.2848994732,
-0.1752102971,
-0.1900445819,
0.7072823644,
0.4569602907,
-0.9554402232,
-0.0634371862,
0.3041028678,
0.7345350981,
-0.5188731551,
0.1100791991,
-0.0734877959,
0.3248614967,
-0.0788322389,
-0.8563346267,
0.4148540795,
-0.2659307718,
-0.1625918001,
-0.0145845339,
0.8134196401,
-0.3532162011,
-0.2926788926,
0.3880162239,
0.4632527232,
0.1330358237,
-0.25390625,
-0.2796326578,
-0.3098902702,
-0.3619058728,
-0.3844163418,
0.4346945584,
0.6265102625,
-0.4311293662,
0.4240130484,
0.7783497572,
0.227336213,
0.0169543419,
-0.1521598697,
0.7155436873,
-1.0022475719,
-0.6648913026,
-1.1515256166,
0.3431544006,
-0.187150985,
-0.5441733599,
1.0658736229,
0.5237032771,
0.43191728,
-0.0141770467,
0.4681761265,
0.0001930093,
0.2286447436,
-0.5075089931,
0.6042773724,
-0.3804964423,
0.0329380594,
-0.4813550413,
-0.654358983,
-0.3653727472,
0.4077149928,
-0.6568164229,
0.1235859767,
0.6271141768,
0.1928039491,
0.1271157712,
-0.1232209653,
0.3696793318,
0.0537112392,
0.2006042451,
0.3161757886,
0.7380267978,
-0.1239354163,
0.1324341893,
0.0086055966,
-0.0277360566,
-0.4677513838,
-1.0612021685,
-1.0049415827,
-0.9189830422,
0.0870286077,
-0.2769210339,
0.0746628568,
0.711101532,
0.6884325743,
-0.5423915386,
0.0305759721,
-0.1704112589,
0.0783195347,
-0.0317859538,
-0.2664354742,
0.4824947119,
-0.2756129801,
-0.5883367062,
0.0088976501,
0.2432166636,
0.2973922491,
0.0765929595,
0.0874478221,
0.0110065937,
0.2950284183,
1.0140647888,
0.0614929013,
-0.5529310703,
-0.6510480642,
0.1707559526,
-0.2371878922,
-0.0783597976,
0.6987150908,
-0.8532011509,
0.336884737,
0.529427588,
0.121267058,
0.147100389,
0.2817173302,
0.786457777,
-0.8675630093,
0.5283725262,
0.1104163304,
0.4489706159,
0.2095699608,
-0.5469514132,
0.0969835296,
-0.0162097719,
-0.5338904858,
-0.7386444211,
0.4756509066,
-0.7061460018,
-0.7122046947,
1.6873886585,
-0.2216781676,
-0.2992497683,
-0.2045439184,
-0.2364778817,
0.2684485316,
-0.2434211075,
0.7044724822,
0.9821317792,
0.1300113797,
0.2328080684,
-0.4260365069,
0.8502562046,
0.466606915,
-0.7178518772,
0.0658557713,
0.513287425,
0.451051265,
0.1714633852,
0.473406136,
-0.1737949699,
-0.0317993835,
-0.1500763595,
-0.5177272558,
0.1130196676,
-0.409455061,
-0.3549866378,
0.090863049,
0.2037932575,
-0.1162033826
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11234v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11234v1 | MiniConGTS: A Near Ultimate Minimalist Contrastive Grid Tagging Scheme for Aspect Sentiment Triplet Extraction | 2024-06-17T06:01:11 | 2024-06-17T06:01:11 | Qiao Sun, Liujia Yang, Minghao Ma, Nanyang Ye, Qinying Gu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Aspect Sentiment Triplet Extraction (ASTE) aims to co-extract the sentiment
triplets in a given corpus. Existing approaches within the
pretraining-finetuning paradigm tend to either meticulously craft complex
tagging schemes and classification heads, or incorporate external semantic
augmentation to enhance performance. In this study, we, for the first time,
re-evaluate the redundancy in tagging schemes and the internal enhancement in
pretrained representations. We propose a method to improve and utilize
pretrained representations by integrating a minimalist tagging scheme and a
novel token-level contrastive learning strategy. The proposed approach
demonstrates comparable or superior performance compared to state-of-the-art
techniques while featuring a more compact design and reduced computational
overhead. Additionally, we are the first to formally evaluate GPT-4's
performance in few-shot learning and Chain-of-Thought scenarios for this task.
The results demonstrate that the pretraining-finetuning paradigm remains highly
effective even in the era of large language models. | [
-0.8249121904,
-0.1843912303,
0.2761591375,
0.0746853575,
-0.7168347239,
0.2225843072,
-0.3321349025,
-0.4000338316,
0.3109427989,
-0.020818945,
-0.4764662683,
-0.6928393841,
-0.46470204,
0.1896302551,
0.0148402285,
1.3357934952,
-0.1509744525,
-0.0587140843,
0.1173127517,
-0.1265812665,
-0.1080452055,
-0.4722728729,
-0.7711289525,
-0.3657966852,
0.417897135,
0.4966644347,
0.3458992243,
0.4126284719,
0.6451813579,
0.215433225,
-0.0137143964,
0.0790587068,
-0.3277183473,
-0.294341296,
-0.0855269432,
-0.3074122965,
-0.5327990651,
0.1001121029,
0.5469243526,
0.5126875043,
0.1710491776,
0.0714520216,
0.5430919528,
0.6314957142,
-0.6261732578,
0.3075087667,
-0.6171509624,
0.0473392196,
-0.2267511934,
-0.0399763361,
-0.0512180589,
-0.2110158503,
-0.0290871412,
-0.623560071,
0.4541686177,
0.0624604411,
1.0038216114,
0.2627491057,
0.0029036126,
-0.0461413525,
-0.4032994807,
0.6302011013,
-0.5293816924,
0.2617172599,
0.089600414,
0.0018561424,
0.3173011243,
-0.7917486429,
-0.6095240712,
-0.0599262752,
-0.4096870124,
0.3293704391,
-0.2318077236,
0.4068608284,
0.2445245981,
0.615121901,
-0.3747234344,
0.0698626712,
-0.1521196365,
-0.2960974872,
0.204426527,
-0.0425191894,
-0.1137678921,
-0.6569610238,
-0.4838317335,
0.0330758728,
-0.7797865272,
-0.1244391426,
0.3788401783,
0.4644325376,
-0.2167564183,
0.176347509,
-0.222054407,
0.2280650288,
0.1498936117,
0.2588763535,
0.4299505651,
-0.7404663563,
-0.2421030402,
-0.2790962458,
1.1132696867,
0.4162667692,
-0.3901852965,
0.1242301911,
-0.4205981195,
0.2463902086,
0.149826467,
-0.6168280244,
-0.6829614043,
-0.0824985281,
-0.30335778,
-0.2168470025,
-0.1251402795,
-0.8863466382,
-0.3187797368,
-0.3615917861,
0.4875142276,
-0.6098393202,
-0.3442297876,
-0.0728292242,
-0.0697545931,
0.3598909974,
0.2953003645,
-0.8547102213,
0.3462184966,
0.9067056775,
1.0139886141,
-0.2317548692,
-0.0285930187,
-0.2120572627,
-0.0927293003,
-0.14121373,
0.9463011622,
-0.6270816922,
-0.4257228971,
-0.1627346873,
-0.4177581072,
0.1902756393,
-0.4160128534,
0.6498741508,
-0.349545002,
0.0366516076,
-0.5464130044,
-0.2229835987,
-0.0863064528,
0.5576789379,
-0.6354912519,
0.9781313539,
-0.0462729298,
-1.0264332294,
0.5781951547,
-0.9586890936,
-0.0989953205,
0.1119622439,
-0.6050385237,
-0.4356092811,
0.1373390704,
0.3220517337,
0.4511067271,
-0.1144745871,
-0.3486244977,
-0.1853132546,
-0.278573513,
-0.3579750359,
-0.130388543,
0.1523816139,
0.131771028,
-0.373925209,
0.2127576917,
-0.5944613218,
0.0285537541,
-0.1861377507,
-0.1363009512,
-0.2604869306,
-0.379188776,
-0.1560930908,
0.3192497492,
0.2302418649,
-0.7371454835,
0.1501605064,
-0.6850686073,
0.3415548205,
0.6453384161,
-0.0562487207,
0.6734846234,
-0.1727580279,
0.4674455225,
0.3637231588,
-0.048441112,
0.0650618821,
-0.0227935202,
-1.0214494467,
-0.359559983,
0.4102858603,
0.1876945645,
-1.4144593477,
0.3082209527,
-0.5080683827,
-0.2818203568,
-0.6634062529,
0.0446439907,
0.7692323327,
0.2063273042,
0.6226612926,
-0.2964130044,
-0.7487362027,
-1.1093701124,
-0.3003363311,
-0.0231090374,
0.1028025672,
-0.1064796448,
0.54247576,
-0.1594515592,
0.7848625779,
-0.4906323254,
-0.2812026143,
-0.4725876153,
0.5361455679,
0.1161751747,
0.73573035,
0.3925418854,
-0.5227709413,
-0.6453732252,
0.1590640098,
-0.360432297,
0.1071943939,
0.1578814089,
-0.1449261606,
0.2201621681,
0.5292432904,
-0.5201798677,
0.3722123206,
0.1824274808,
0.1734122932,
0.4236836433,
0.1160817072,
-0.0211587455,
-0.9446502924,
-0.0818598792,
0.1600223631,
-0.4535999596,
-0.4952916801,
0.1140148491,
0.113646321,
0.0043407315,
-0.3499943912,
0.3563264906,
-0.5656208992,
-0.0783921853,
-0.3317445815,
0.2564632595,
0.0536586083,
0.6651344895,
0.0216784868,
0.7338493466,
0.3478194177,
-0.3406535685,
0.1449810863,
0.0112658804,
-0.0446076468,
0.6986282468,
-0.2723327279,
0.4046646953,
-0.2722088397,
0.1842649579,
-0.8742144704,
0.0412214398,
0.457284987,
-0.4389184415,
0.5796855688,
-0.151283741,
-0.4656918645,
-0.4638989568,
-0.913092196,
0.3694039881,
0.4655376077,
-0.691429615,
0.5966238976,
0.1026609242,
-0.1628533155,
-0.5867316723,
-0.4286422729,
-0.1042243317,
-0.4004981518,
-0.0782344639,
0.334422797,
0.1709293723,
0.1209734231,
-0.1061387956,
-0.5180671215,
0.1772808284,
-0.0731007829,
0.0639119595,
0.1271178573,
-0.305675298,
0.1471320689,
-0.0203695334,
-0.4517748058,
-0.1604593843,
-0.3273951411,
0.62885952,
-0.711956799,
-0.1742871851,
-0.4830001891,
0.5055336356,
-0.2371501476,
-0.0184998419,
0.2720628679,
0.9037439227,
-0.3915706277,
-0.1006960273,
-0.5097900033,
-0.0174841788,
-0.4981339872,
0.4622380137,
-0.7052872181,
-1.0370179415,
0.3637148142,
-0.1053216532,
0.0122777531,
0.6161874533,
0.280547291,
-0.3735581338,
0.8317188621,
0.8942078352,
-0.0278675314,
0.5814195871,
-0.4780345559,
0.2383321375,
-1.1291584969,
-0.0719512179,
-0.4558854699,
-0.3284718096,
-0.7320073843,
-0.2930801809,
0.3939195275,
0.3659677804,
-0.3237637281,
0.1528164446,
-0.5106330514,
0.7645280361,
0.4042916298,
0.2436102331,
0.232242167,
0.0287714209,
-0.063633129,
-0.1525797397,
-0.6440597177,
-0.5333098769,
0.9208453894,
0.2240554541,
0.6150229573,
0.0851095095,
1.1605941057,
-0.0168158133,
0.5806965828,
-0.8827209473,
0.4631605148,
-0.4149006307,
-0.0467342772,
0.031842228,
-0.3542912304,
-0.747885704,
0.5380067825,
-0.1705218405,
-0.6609571576,
0.1663974226,
0.4233037829,
-0.8950018883,
0.2839785218,
-0.8452860117,
0.8164659739,
0.1809224486,
-0.4564529061,
-0.0168239716,
-0.7570280433,
0.2835493982,
-0.081005387,
0.0651898608,
0.0163447615,
-0.4190894067,
0.9350031614,
-0.3960638046,
0.8355594277,
-0.2448941022,
0.3160243332,
0.0632157922,
-0.0762454644,
0.3183468878,
0.04098019,
0.1454456151,
0.1298387945,
0.0537821203,
-0.5097267032,
-0.5359603167,
0.8617519736,
-0.9399097562,
-0.7516681552,
-0.4080005586,
0.0523376465,
-0.5493341684,
0.3133087754,
0.5560112596,
0.35604316,
-0.2158922851,
-0.1369311213,
0.3344749808,
0.2649475634,
0.7093617916,
0.0875849426,
-0.0953307301,
-0.6060471535,
1.0019915104,
-0.2417416126,
0.1569712609,
0.2459269762,
0.1665219963,
-0.3658240736,
-0.7770510316,
-0.2123585194,
0.4648887217,
-0.9524149299,
-0.6120467782,
-0.6515657306,
-0.0696385652,
-0.3093075156,
-0.254350245,
-0.5579093695,
-0.1198785827,
-0.3610726297,
-0.1919401288,
0.0653950796,
0.9396241307,
-0.3657700419,
0.7990178466,
-0.7633865476,
0.2853270173,
0.2531987429,
0.4564499855,
-0.3126413524,
-0.2785428762,
-0.2160645574,
-0.1532114446,
-0.5105040669,
-0.6363715529,
0.1675308943,
0.2475943714,
0.2734352648,
0.2386829108,
-0.1350159943,
0.7745549083,
-0.3169214129,
0.9065846801,
0.6174570322,
-1.1979931593,
0.3570364714,
-0.2702073157,
0.2774704099,
1.0387884378,
0.5917945504,
-0.2920919955,
-0.0029068014,
-0.8879234791,
-0.8785984516,
0.8123777509,
0.2233434319,
0.0523395501,
-0.0508848764,
0.5127947927,
0.3118316233,
0.3838614523,
-0.8134685159,
-0.1339237988,
-0.4250508845,
-0.369102031,
-0.121882081,
-0.3205842972,
-0.040339753,
-0.4638338983,
0.6386355162,
-0.3199649155,
0.5048503876,
0.0474232137,
-0.1143213511,
0.3657084405,
0.2952617705,
0.2967134714,
0.1892028898,
-0.0591715388,
0.4620378017,
0.2418589741,
-0.4183776081,
-0.0341272913,
0.1441930532,
0.1638294011,
-0.0174280796,
0.3025910854,
0.9816563129,
0.2176292092,
0.2009579241,
0.8392270803,
-0.0606625341,
-0.101488255,
-0.2187227607,
-0.1293955147,
-0.1622585803,
0.2005515844,
-0.1066664979,
0.341843009,
0.2235781103,
-0.4424257874,
0.1006433144,
0.4237088561,
-0.6122148037,
-0.6106341481,
0.2029941827,
0.5064472556,
0.09614034,
0.1338632405,
-0.7727782726,
-0.7298110127,
0.1885751933,
0.2304160297,
0.9580308795,
-0.0454759076,
0.0109613826,
0.4031004608,
0.3686723113,
-0.1144611612,
0.3581891954,
-0.3404405415,
-0.7899298668,
-0.374556303,
-0.5659785271,
-0.2147120684,
0.1390714794,
-0.6867572069,
0.4229854643,
-0.6770226955,
-0.2138210684,
0.0257858392,
0.1994230598,
-0.973146379,
0.1091173664,
0.3864984214,
0.5983569622,
-0.8437167406,
0.8489803672,
0.8998600245,
-0.6536417007,
-0.7237113714,
0.246270135,
-0.0911995098,
-0.6942775249,
0.6075810194,
0.4074299634,
-0.4508880377,
0.2244162709,
-0.6374410391,
-0.6501547694,
0.7693664432,
-0.0405653082,
-0.3530117571,
-0.0931510776,
-0.0758503675,
0.5305492878,
-0.3981122673,
0.4246850312,
1.0905498266,
0.1389868259,
0.2208408862,
-0.918381691,
0.0192575436,
-0.3584463894,
0.0882933363,
0.3544305563,
-0.5997129679,
0.8541164398,
0.1560566425,
-0.570530951,
-0.0367332697,
0.9607146978,
-0.0914212689,
0.0112219388,
0.556091249,
0.6078462005,
0.6937099099,
-0.308880657,
0.9789053202,
-0.0603273883,
0.5814505219,
1.2477042675,
0.0106829442,
0.8785500526,
0.4287271798,
-0.1915567666,
0.4554030597,
0.6217286587,
0.4628598392,
0.6194552779,
0.1952898502,
-0.3306963146,
-0.3251868188,
0.0129359756,
-0.3899941444,
0.2750223875,
0.5294584036,
-0.0382218957,
-0.4033820033,
0.1525043249,
0.281683147,
-0.0799976438,
-0.6720075011,
1.0363887548,
0.2662705779,
-0.2278794944,
0.5639201999,
-0.1394506097,
1.3240636587,
-0.4129877985,
0.0434030965,
-0.3491308987,
0.0521335751,
-0.4090006053,
-0.7243583798,
0.2765460908,
0.0723020136,
0.1424135119,
-0.1869213879,
0.6731668115,
-0.4184949696,
-0.1646559238,
0.0208198,
0.3515905142,
0.0586596392,
-0.0383881927,
-0.7695949078,
0.0785567835,
0.1241791248,
0.0150873791,
0.1693384647,
0.4926742017,
0.1897716373,
0.1106864735,
0.2296573669,
0.1924700141,
-0.212476626,
0.0239673574,
1.2811418772,
-0.7913438082,
-0.7346971035,
-0.9409914613,
0.4157316387,
-0.4083290398,
-0.149001956,
0.6358597875,
0.52172333,
0.9180731773,
0.1275656223,
0.900755167,
0.1466685534,
0.5092095137,
-0.6256019473,
0.3473687768,
-0.4619491398,
0.3013680875,
-0.3679600358,
-0.9036813378,
-0.4681948423,
0.5297766924,
-0.6525583863,
0.207779184,
1.2423722744,
0.6144694686,
-0.1218215004,
0.346414119,
0.2465731949,
0.105390735,
0.3857897818,
0.6434541941,
1.1235461235,
-0.3391261399,
0.4637570083,
-0.421515584,
-0.228158161,
0.0115266666,
-0.8693185449,
-0.8196440339,
-0.5392184258,
-0.418964982,
-0.2133244574,
-0.080067426,
1.2806165218,
0.4685746729,
-0.6277808547,
0.2553954124,
0.0107431803,
-0.1378784776,
0.2965175807,
-0.1334730387,
0.500015378,
-0.6051949859,
-0.5718814731,
0.0298161209,
0.2783042192,
0.0717411786,
-0.0376705006,
0.2220160663,
0.0733177811,
-0.3025967777,
0.6087676287,
0.1699641347,
-0.4953466654,
-0.7574644685,
-0.6722870469,
-0.1793630123,
0.4883805215,
0.9686444402,
-0.6556366086,
0.2865797579,
0.4579977989,
0.4879792631,
0.5744655132,
0.2330926806,
0.0972257555,
-1.0697215796,
0.2130772471,
0.4181992412,
0.3511325717,
0.5754590631,
-0.0592687652,
0.2753078938,
0.3556758761,
-0.1569423378,
-0.4472794533,
0.3719773889,
-0.8613907099,
0.1380209923,
1.1918129921,
-0.1811024398,
-0.283282429,
-0.3032299876,
-0.3001506627,
0.2135798037,
-0.5093000531,
0.314574331,
0.5263600349,
-0.4218578637,
-0.1512958556,
-0.2953805625,
1.0285391808,
0.4219888747,
-0.8729098439,
-0.1233924404,
0.4948659837,
0.1948191524,
0.3051859736,
0.8980485797,
-0.0574273095,
0.018327821,
0.1116115153,
0.4069330394,
0.0455683693,
-0.2064880729,
-0.6626099944,
0.2219244391,
0.2961917818,
-0.4560997486
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11233v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11233v1 | Probing the Decision Boundaries of In-context Learning in Large Language Models | 2024-06-17T06:00:24 | 2024-06-17T06:00:24 | Siyan Zhao, Tung Nguyen, Aditya Grover | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | In-context learning is a key paradigm in large language models (LLMs) that
enables them to generalize to new tasks and domains by simply prompting these
models with a few exemplars without explicit parameter updates. Many attempts
have been made to understand in-context learning in LLMs as a function of model
scale, pretraining data, and other factors. In this work, we propose a new
mechanism to probe and understand in-context learning from the lens of decision
boundaries for in-context binary classification. Decision boundaries are
straightforward to visualize and provide important information about the
qualitative behavior of the inductive biases of standard classifiers. To our
surprise, we find that the decision boundaries learned by current LLMs in
simple binary classification tasks are often irregular and non-smooth,
regardless of linear separability in the underlying task. This paper
investigates the factors influencing these decision boundaries and explores
methods to enhance their generalizability. We assess various approaches,
including training-free and fine-tuning methods for LLMs, the impact of model
architecture, and the effectiveness of active prompting techniques for
smoothing decision boundaries in a data-efficient manner. Our findings provide
a deeper understanding of in-context learning dynamics and offer practical
improvements for enhancing robustness and generalizability of in-context
learning. | [
-0.6341676712,
-1.1599171162,
0.6386601925,
-0.0421511605,
-0.2317660153,
-0.1375942677,
-0.6512608528,
-0.3001610339,
-0.2830420136,
0.3228175938,
-0.6205151677,
-0.4922565818,
-0.3863255084,
-0.0283522718,
-0.1524386108,
0.8923463821,
-0.1510846019,
0.1386418492,
-0.4542533159,
-0.0338170677,
-0.5754719377,
-0.5478566289,
-0.6061626673,
-0.5406230688,
0.3185117841,
0.4695063233,
0.3670965433,
0.4583976567,
0.0894987136,
0.2139786929,
-0.3204746544,
0.224052608,
-0.4875387251,
0.3140588403,
-0.1950748861,
-0.5995426178,
-0.0802573934,
-0.0159071945,
1.04395926,
1.1772705317,
0.1560758799,
0.2076756209,
0.5401930809,
0.5646614432,
-0.545804739,
0.2847053111,
-0.6735445261,
0.1118711904,
-0.2600272,
-0.2864746153,
-0.5532218814,
-0.1777320355,
0.2578646541,
-0.3040058613,
0.2193059325,
-0.1738467216,
0.6115729213,
0.2895778418,
-0.6098888516,
-0.2311335802,
-0.6870565414,
0.768230617,
-0.3468264937,
0.7845291495,
0.3473537266,
0.3433344066,
-0.3951596022,
-0.531431675,
-0.2154713869,
0.0285018161,
0.0276404098,
-0.3266848028,
0.0032791442,
0.0446540117,
0.3603146374,
-0.0725969523,
-0.1206619069,
0.3847620785,
-0.1501521468,
-0.039752651,
0.3853401244,
0.0726258084,
-0.0033058741,
0.1692255288,
-0.3957580924,
-0.0445154794,
-0.9134891629,
0.5226793289,
0.1887002736,
0.4582166672,
-0.2356782854,
0.0154871037,
-0.1746871322,
1.0442056656,
0.3106811643,
-0.0343485139,
0.1623489857,
-0.039077282,
-0.1384590864,
0.0209214352,
0.3881134391,
0.2694719732,
0.0561414212,
-0.2299182862,
-0.3175238967,
-0.2643494904,
0.0543557741,
-0.7278051972,
0.0567599796,
0.0612158291,
-0.2415854037,
-0.0622271597,
-0.1343290508,
-0.5643309355,
-0.1697209328,
-0.6964119673,
0.5412393808,
-0.3874295652,
-0.0534398891,
0.0446371622,
0.1142982543,
0.4530561864,
0.6064889431,
-0.8625394106,
0.2203523666,
0.6215034127,
0.6543902755,
-0.1116195023,
-0.2321824431,
-0.6603463888,
-0.0452055894,
-0.3838067949,
0.6268188357,
-0.8171356916,
-0.2472099364,
0.0514094457,
-0.0419444777,
-0.1160082519,
-0.6777475476,
0.1531343013,
-0.549189508,
0.0029920079,
-0.3544174135,
-0.592102766,
-0.5056342483,
0.4181284606,
-0.3193566799,
0.9951967001,
0.1028313488,
-0.5812566876,
0.7545852065,
-0.5650272965,
-0.2427473664,
0.1383215189,
-0.4330218732,
-0.3344782889,
0.0796529874,
0.1036889255,
0.7545590401,
-0.0286095981,
0.4756563902,
-0.3029649854,
-0.4463721514,
0.3313753307,
-0.3798321187,
0.7482402921,
-0.0310199689,
-0.4997388422,
0.1496801376,
-0.4569150209,
-0.0452911481,
-0.1355574876,
-0.4505560398,
-0.5758529305,
0.0835946351,
-0.2229449302,
0.1832306534,
-0.0356347486,
-0.351462692,
0.2925315499,
-0.2578705251,
0.3074623048,
0.762172997,
0.114641808,
0.7504601479,
0.0765059963,
0.3427009583,
0.0838277936,
0.2148939967,
-0.0643626899,
-0.3851684928,
-0.6664684415,
-0.1712107807,
0.5363603234,
0.1484307647,
-0.6930080652,
0.2792919874,
-0.0136218956,
-0.2102585137,
-0.3473169506,
0.1999386698,
0.33379668,
0.6562436819,
0.3080008924,
-0.4057725966,
-0.1944780499,
-0.6626802087,
-0.1845303327,
0.2511149943,
0.0278695486,
0.4098847508,
0.5414348841,
-0.4516088963,
1.1945402622,
-0.1528998762,
-0.0607055873,
-0.205204159,
-0.0242874809,
-0.0288874488,
0.3883322775,
0.4340208173,
-0.9532555938,
-0.4013724923,
-0.0144437021,
-0.6647959352,
-0.1361046731,
-0.1905312538,
-0.2674141824,
0.1900337189,
0.8279933929,
-0.1995703578,
0.3648681641,
0.2599324882,
-0.2908314764,
0.4911746085,
-0.0154819591,
-0.2871097028,
-0.4901387691,
-0.2551329434,
0.2217390537,
-0.2216531634,
-0.8810896277,
0.2197992951,
0.4676090479,
0.251462698,
-0.5695275664,
0.6435835361,
-0.5483062267,
-0.0600908063,
-0.1745561957,
0.0982659608,
-0.1953806132,
0.5481230617,
0.137353912,
0.4097324014,
0.878011167,
-0.9928549528,
-0.1230430081,
0.0704338327,
-0.2959167361,
0.3885419369,
-0.1767093241,
0.191576004,
-0.4617212117,
0.5206125975,
-0.9696896076,
-0.1490660608,
0.1491693407,
-0.2230979353,
0.5012346506,
-0.4976330698,
-0.3402859569,
0.1641005427,
-0.2155399919,
0.7286788821,
0.2910268009,
-0.8406755328,
0.5450245142,
0.3152408302,
0.1559622288,
-0.4380926788,
-0.4147807062,
-0.2297482789,
-0.5120965838,
-0.357065767,
0.2053457052,
-0.0912002623,
-0.5889712572,
-0.3782405555,
-0.1913677901,
0.0211871713,
0.3007941544,
0.2983707786,
0.1804566532,
-0.0189284142,
0.1289911419,
0.3069694936,
0.0973401517,
0.2620354593,
-0.3572807312,
0.6091765165,
-0.231051892,
-0.2477748394,
-0.1290215999,
0.0600490347,
0.3407005966,
-0.3214488328,
0.4925322235,
0.3933959901,
-0.4438216686,
-0.7055395246,
-0.4127075374,
-0.3907651305,
-0.5003708005,
0.1747597605,
-0.4186643958,
-1.0764120817,
0.4500120282,
-0.4121094346,
0.0326410271,
0.132514894,
0.6662250161,
0.1398144215,
0.8704171181,
0.8091140985,
0.2767189145,
0.5949760675,
-0.4084088206,
0.1089328602,
-0.9838300347,
-0.535646677,
-0.3132792711,
-0.3741332889,
-0.4515958428,
-0.5186189413,
0.5824868679,
0.2003221065,
-0.2230507135,
-0.1619043052,
-0.3191920817,
0.6107007265,
0.3591535687,
0.3004384041,
0.0423319042,
-0.1394277364,
-0.3488074839,
0.0910982564,
-0.5964421034,
-0.2765714526,
0.850526154,
0.5013516545,
0.7064200044,
-0.0142647428,
0.5963713527,
-0.0688578561,
0.1761433184,
-0.9777868986,
0.47365731,
0.2472524047,
-0.4196640849,
-0.4153702855,
-0.4209039509,
-1.0193564892,
0.5753858089,
-0.3050704598,
-0.7532915473,
0.4932897389,
-0.022426622,
-0.3621508479,
0.3418603837,
-0.7313907146,
0.7636226416,
-0.3198681772,
-0.520829916,
0.1391963959,
-0.7559118867,
0.168435052,
-0.245289579,
0.3842122853,
0.1562183946,
-0.1313436627,
0.5535167456,
0.0597590096,
1.2281242609,
-0.3907444477,
-0.2648527622,
0.1392232627,
0.343719095,
0.3547739387,
0.0084909545,
0.1527538002,
0.2026256621,
-0.3691072166,
-0.2206525058,
-0.5459965467,
0.4362540841,
-0.5741401911,
-0.371347636,
-0.1445018202,
-0.4678332806,
-0.6066362858,
0.101822339,
0.2257193923,
0.7539821267,
-0.065465115,
0.2749665976,
1.0454491377,
-0.1696331352,
0.3944694996,
0.6009276509,
-0.2871949673,
0.4254512489,
0.6854185462,
0.1767616123,
0.3400112092,
0.4213548601,
0.1572537273,
-0.3534694612,
-0.7908921838,
-0.3570417166,
0.1805674136,
-0.7729580998,
-0.0718272626,
-0.4225181341,
-0.0539083704,
-0.1227152273,
-0.2861913741,
0.0473053195,
0.0138345296,
-0.2490278184,
-0.1453374028,
0.1131062657,
0.9438539147,
0.1419540197,
0.3019606173,
-0.4365649521,
-0.2415673584,
0.2872958481,
0.4916497767,
0.1827263385,
-0.6349622011,
-0.4225992262,
0.0246806871,
-0.3019044995,
-0.6588361263,
0.2044211179,
0.2638737261,
0.5974449515,
0.5727967024,
-0.0553095639,
0.472263962,
-0.5069291592,
0.6206566691,
-0.1405469775,
-0.9208095074,
0.4352260828,
-0.4304053187,
0.3183191419,
0.4005388319,
0.6294336915,
-0.5256772041,
-0.4029364884,
-0.491758734,
-0.9952714443,
0.6286822557,
-0.2758852839,
0.0795786083,
0.1005163714,
0.569157064,
0.4461468458,
0.0408082306,
-0.5185163021,
-0.1815770119,
0.1388994008,
0.1961221397,
-0.1425892413,
-0.0971700028,
-0.0138917333,
-0.4386252761,
0.3379684091,
-0.3876348734,
-0.0489946119,
0.0502622388,
-0.3616051972,
0.0340877362,
0.2624507546,
0.3938252032,
0.8023398519,
-0.186000064,
0.1930122823,
0.4973619282,
-0.2180045098,
-0.0924979374,
-0.1282984763,
-0.2182996124,
-0.1220234036,
0.1897220612,
0.9971348643,
0.4512758255,
-0.6062119007,
0.413780272,
-0.1683087349,
-0.2311553061,
-0.1913764775,
0.0365150422,
-0.2832663953,
0.364372611,
0.4277026057,
0.0203606877,
0.2498420477,
-0.6977508664,
0.2975867391,
0.5129695535,
-0.5698003173,
-0.3189046681,
0.3671869934,
0.1033314839,
-0.1035858393,
0.5371394157,
-0.2070956528,
-0.5995847583,
0.3466039896,
0.5895672441,
0.6251592636,
-0.0967415869,
0.104806304,
0.1604323536,
0.1084793285,
-0.0819033384,
-0.1166818142,
-0.4967888594,
-0.8226335049,
-0.4207349718,
-0.5017617941,
-0.6235533953,
0.0574186854,
-0.6801279783,
0.2491613179,
-0.5538364053,
0.0003956082,
-0.1157105938,
-0.1053810567,
-0.6891645193,
0.3200977743,
0.6035575271,
0.9684360623,
-0.7681459188,
0.8383022547,
0.7559371591,
0.0162658226,
-0.7943839431,
0.1515533328,
0.0111046741,
-0.6526947021,
0.667974174,
0.4506855607,
-0.269825846,
-0.14277713,
-0.8278336525,
-0.6973956823,
0.6980207562,
0.3768001497,
-0.3896977007,
-0.0233080797,
0.0169472583,
0.326438725,
-0.4229762256,
0.3202753067,
0.6334245205,
0.4100001156,
-0.2082535326,
-0.810061872,
0.1604769826,
-0.0719418675,
-0.0817662552,
0.548337996,
-0.6187056899,
0.840103507,
-0.0681761578,
-0.1271025538,
-0.5653383732,
0.5094788671,
0.0263324734,
0.2815519869,
0.6105482578,
0.2786568701,
0.8364189863,
-0.3239175379,
0.8571990728,
0.1030974835,
0.289858371,
0.781994462,
-0.0994332433,
0.817096889,
0.4854751527,
0.0853163674,
0.6188486814,
0.9975901246,
0.2239865363,
0.4492635727,
0.3569508195,
-0.3323781788,
-0.3780786693,
-0.0343053453,
-0.1730799079,
0.5893239379,
0.8067081571,
0.0750293732,
-0.409476757,
0.2504636347,
0.0479632802,
-0.1110163629,
-0.6152977943,
0.738261342,
0.018440403,
-0.5742744803,
0.7169359326,
-0.090145044,
0.9627841115,
-0.716775775,
-0.1661279947,
-0.138638109,
0.127968356,
-0.3606873751,
-0.8051221371,
-0.0775051489,
-0.1774065495,
-0.1071773618,
-0.3007305861,
0.4652061462,
-0.6111121178,
-0.0774092898,
0.5080512762,
0.3754354417,
0.2145373225,
-0.2129310369,
-0.4541999996,
0.1775992662,
0.0739740506,
-0.1489402205,
0.7124536633,
0.7206634283,
-0.3985396028,
0.6706464291,
0.4117089808,
-0.1859736592,
0.1651111245,
0.0417015031,
0.7937467098,
-0.4929342568,
-0.4898839593,
-0.8301386833,
0.3637357354,
0.2307202667,
-0.2547017634,
0.7969715595,
0.4456552565,
1.3816177845,
0.2122450173,
0.6632472873,
0.1060775816,
0.2034629583,
-0.7171200514,
0.5731570125,
-0.6821537614,
0.1746369004,
0.0679423586,
-0.8137172461,
-0.376023978,
0.4653196633,
-0.6127132773,
0.1445151567,
0.526627183,
0.6435573101,
-0.1764244884,
-0.0175124034,
0.1513860822,
0.1531229317,
0.1311070472,
0.4232481122,
0.8790658116,
0.0533585437,
0.1177052855,
-0.2286614925,
-0.6259301305,
-0.2151262313,
-0.6626344323,
-1.0453019142,
-0.774176836,
-0.0926352069,
-0.1438902915,
-0.0096253054,
1.2213485241,
0.6514166594,
-0.5196633339,
-0.4271706045,
0.242215395,
0.1971017122,
-0.2131528109,
-0.2320079952,
0.3026971221,
-0.731933713,
-0.688452065,
0.4795615375,
0.0103133386,
-0.0041981582,
-0.1135653928,
-0.0520785041,
0.0307388641,
-0.1705288142,
0.7097440362,
0.22392115,
-0.5019419193,
-0.1725255996,
-0.2829938829,
0.236082837,
0.0424976274,
0.8801996112,
-0.8294974566,
0.5105028152,
0.2033246607,
0.7546927929,
0.5324946642,
-0.0783042014,
0.5515540838,
-0.9336251616,
0.1969612986,
0.1639378518,
0.3835678697,
0.3802578747,
-0.3452594578,
0.2774119377,
-0.0340183154,
-0.5712243915,
-0.8541845083,
0.2789995968,
-0.7429481149,
-0.4736118615,
1.3127871752,
0.1995535642,
-0.3107777834,
-0.3113288581,
-0.1643665731,
0.1371445805,
-0.4276610911,
0.553330183,
0.5220668316,
-0.311919421,
0.1224316135,
-0.5970150232,
0.6846811175,
0.2623445094,
-0.3846571445,
0.1398129612,
0.4959284663,
0.363016814,
-0.1254769117,
0.267447263,
-0.0044583231,
0.1629309207,
-0.3565172553,
-0.0878588259,
0.0884098038,
-0.642524302,
-0.7185201645,
0.0298231319,
0.0781180859,
-0.0501655936
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11231v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11231v1 | Enabling robots to follow abstract instructions and complete complex dynamic tasks | 2024-06-17T05:55:35 | 2024-06-17T05:55:35 | Ruaridh Mon-Williams, Gen Li, Ran Long, Wenqian Du, Chris Lucas | cs.RO | cs.RO, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Completing complex tasks in unpredictable settings like home kitchens
challenges robotic systems. These challenges include interpreting high-level
human commands, such as "make me a hot beverage" and performing actions like
pouring a precise amount of water into a moving mug. To address these
challenges, we present a novel framework that combines Large Language Models
(LLMs), a curated Knowledge Base, and Integrated Force and Visual Feedback
(IFVF). Our approach interprets abstract instructions, performs long-horizon
tasks, and handles various uncertainties. It utilises GPT-4 to analyse the
user's query and surroundings, then generates code that accesses a curated
database of functions during execution. It translates abstract instructions
into actionable steps. Each step involves generating custom code by employing
retrieval-augmented generalisation to pull IFVF-relevant examples from the
Knowledge Base. IFVF allows the robot to respond to noise and disturbances
during execution. We use coffee making and plate decoration to demonstrate our
approach, including components ranging from pouring to drawer opening, each
benefiting from distinct feedback types and methods. This novel advancement
marks significant progress toward a scalable, efficient robotic framework for
completing complex tasks in uncertain environments. Our findings are
illustrated in an accompanying video and supported by an open-source GitHub
repository (released upon paper acceptance). | [
-0.0893544033,
-0.7637306452,
0.7835434079,
0.0732757077,
0.2533385158,
0.3297221363,
-0.2668717802,
-0.2999096513,
0.0793072656,
0.5777004957,
-0.921979785,
-0.5035629272,
-0.6790095568,
-0.0063487501,
-0.3171806335,
0.7168501616,
-0.3822456896,
-0.0573875532,
-0.1373971701,
0.092128247,
-0.2097695172,
-0.3506063521,
-0.2447589636,
-0.4364514649,
0.3685548306,
0.3710843027,
0.873973906,
0.4648825228,
0.6189828515,
0.3773465157,
0.2284948975,
0.5910712481,
-0.3372648656,
0.1007177979,
-0.4475049078,
-0.5009627342,
-0.2771356106,
-0.3509948254,
0.0998858735,
0.6793752909,
-0.0379614532,
-0.0334238298,
0.1623974741,
0.7433747053,
-0.4705046415,
0.7676078677,
-0.1039563715,
0.239248544,
0.2078582197,
-0.2550877631,
-0.2161946297,
-0.2161829621,
-0.0489329845,
-0.6296983957,
-0.3101125956,
-0.0939892083,
0.7637876868,
0.6046543717,
-0.3777219653,
-0.5328916311,
-1.239688158,
0.4566847086,
-0.5086219311,
0.2821240723,
0.3518509269,
0.3649370074,
-0.5635995269,
-0.8161677718,
-0.5603095889,
-0.4268170297,
-0.0512321517,
0.164084807,
-0.105251655,
0.2213768214,
0.1936473548,
0.0155580528,
-0.1936346143,
-0.2781839967,
-0.1689128578,
0.0076733558,
0.3606216311,
0.3462738395,
0.2965300083,
-0.0637021214,
-0.5562300682,
-0.3313524127,
-0.3827557862,
0.2884209156,
0.3638797402,
0.3991696537,
-0.2235574126,
0.7888879776,
-0.7044914961,
0.7866533399,
-0.0574273206,
-0.1597695202,
0.1287167966,
-0.3337475061,
0.1183082163,
-0.3836633861,
0.6682614088,
0.5109106302,
0.1772981286,
-0.2066132277,
-0.5376968384,
0.1965907961,
0.2643301785,
-0.6140081882,
-0.5682396293,
0.4163663387,
-0.1427152306,
-0.3434701562,
0.2824350595,
-0.5388678908,
-0.4403632879,
-0.502230525,
0.5645519495,
-0.1796399355,
-0.0912681371,
0.5285086036,
-0.0519169345,
0.071762301,
0.6920850873,
-0.6639177799,
0.5263291001,
0.521864593,
0.6480658054,
-0.0175197944,
-0.0459870957,
-0.6573117971,
0.4397991598,
-0.2889591455,
0.4896667898,
-0.5225123763,
-0.0637366176,
0.1238385811,
0.0203205403,
0.2381176949,
-0.4908924103,
0.3513539732,
-0.4609026015,
0.0501039922,
-0.1571151316,
-0.2738444805,
-0.4920854568,
0.3873428702,
-0.6053702831,
0.8577423692,
0.4727426171,
-0.4240351319,
0.2027084231,
-0.7836199999,
-0.6241043806,
0.259149909,
-0.2979151011,
-0.1142886281,
-0.3815076649,
0.2203968763,
0.7919508219,
-0.1662006527,
0.2853415012,
-0.4711652696,
-0.0767330006,
-0.0632756352,
-0.2310678363,
0.3327660561,
0.1784939468,
-0.4957684577,
0.55231148,
-0.8121102452,
-0.0177988447,
0.0444984697,
-0.5111714005,
0.1228717715,
0.1771032661,
-0.0295793843,
0.1927903742,
0.477081418,
-0.3539894819,
0.3409059644,
0.0997779518,
0.6642934084,
0.4808323383,
-0.1111976579,
0.4339803755,
-0.2839758098,
0.8056735992,
-0.3133716881,
0.1288091242,
-0.3406426907,
-0.3380579948,
-0.476821512,
-0.4096283317,
0.0897072256,
0.8859670758,
-1.288215518,
0.5236881971,
-0.1879392564,
-0.2001838833,
0.0349963009,
0.2159099579,
0.3688919246,
0.5188984871,
0.2853025496,
-0.1612610668,
-0.3261275589,
-0.5186108351,
0.2309766859,
-0.0488648489,
-0.5042583346,
0.2477411032,
0.3517831862,
-0.4197429121,
0.711258173,
-0.3629080355,
-0.386998415,
-0.0657946095,
0.1032761484,
0.295776546,
0.2785727382,
0.3267056942,
-0.6241796613,
0.0809771791,
0.4903683662,
-0.9736912251,
0.040202342,
-0.1764839441,
-0.0905071795,
-0.2473414689,
0.6943667531,
-0.9248666167,
0.4284398258,
0.3868487775,
-0.1287601292,
0.285997659,
-0.0847984031,
0.1529368758,
-0.8277845979,
-0.2536837161,
-0.0545022525,
-0.4334632754,
-0.2329462022,
0.1742908061,
-0.0688008964,
-0.0084013008,
-0.4132481515,
0.3445065022,
-0.4040675759,
0.0291310791,
-0.2683587968,
-0.1703970879,
0.0287527479,
0.7834816575,
-0.0477849133,
0.2436245084,
0.3270353377,
-0.5098657012,
0.66914922,
-0.0912433937,
-0.5195863843,
0.0868637711,
-0.5113090873,
-0.035295397,
0.2245449424,
0.2222360224,
-1.1424754858,
-0.7914222479,
0.7724686861,
-0.1674661636,
0.1852498204,
-0.0694175288,
-0.7639358044,
-0.5131426454,
0.0147936111,
-0.1383386254,
0.2183115631,
-0.3910776675,
1.1490397453,
0.3088330925,
0.04167068,
-0.4865929484,
-0.4391798079,
-0.0085422434,
0.1645585299,
-0.7174572945,
0.1134817451,
-0.0622122176,
-0.3457466662,
0.082073845,
-0.2849869132,
-0.0123675251,
0.0556361862,
0.3070061505,
0.0416867174,
0.1646249145,
-0.2394921631,
0.1896409392,
0.1887273788,
0.3746401072,
-0.41893062,
0.4285283983,
-0.4187806845,
-0.487832129,
-0.5723580718,
0.1258039773,
0.7977284789,
0.0172231682,
-0.0371399149,
0.7182649374,
-0.4144887626,
-0.4290388227,
-0.0813833252,
-0.4835310578,
-0.6253858209,
0.4631560445,
-0.4778486788,
-0.857226491,
0.5655791163,
-0.3795801997,
0.3231213093,
-0.1096571609,
0.6616103649,
-0.3338299692,
0.8427464366,
0.4370687604,
0.2495113909,
0.3864699006,
-0.2384514213,
0.2412309051,
-0.3296160698,
-0.3864576519,
-0.1842601299,
-0.5191316009,
-0.4052938819,
-0.7700037956,
0.4727835655,
-0.257024467,
-0.2146260589,
0.2413225621,
-0.6567034721,
0.311301738,
0.6014866829,
0.4512258172,
0.1934190691,
-0.1549040824,
-0.1149966717,
0.3080875278,
-0.8111982346,
-0.5149411559,
0.668989718,
0.2425761372,
1.2118835449,
0.0487978607,
0.3796609342,
0.5800136328,
-0.0052051288,
-0.9265421033,
0.6453123689,
0.0343790911,
-0.2148744017,
-0.4764923751,
-0.2208622843,
-0.957077384,
0.0770010352,
-0.1944559664,
-0.3755954206,
-0.1270172447,
0.1253866106,
-0.5140557289,
0.3293099403,
-0.7973226309,
0.4401744306,
-0.4465918243,
-0.5481764078,
0.1131746545,
-0.9570029378,
0.3512311876,
0.3578651845,
0.3432535827,
0.0126208728,
-0.0403628126,
0.1384683549,
-0.4507581294,
1.111892581,
-0.164348349,
-0.301908046,
0.3484081924,
0.5272009969,
0.6374493837,
0.119647339,
0.0365021005,
0.0355950966,
-0.0887520388,
-0.2042321712,
-1.017390132,
0.4566556215,
-0.681887269,
-0.6380264163,
-0.2763926089,
-0.9138000011,
-0.1053067967,
0.2601604164,
-0.1509867609,
0.1334444135,
0.362570256,
0.158485353,
0.653347671,
-0.0522083752,
0.2798655927,
0.3373910785,
-0.4151077569,
-0.1756399572,
0.6670897603,
0.0452533178,
0.1783872992,
0.8807436228,
0.1655149013,
0.0025811931,
-0.3928373158,
-0.8746942878,
-0.3139802217,
-0.6827039123,
-0.1955333948,
-0.5883980393,
-0.0832056627,
0.081622377,
-0.3541564345,
-0.470143348,
-0.3866590858,
-0.2676355243,
-0.3168715239,
0.5431485772,
1.1305896044,
0.0484183319,
0.1531942338,
-0.7262973785,
0.391857177,
0.3474019468,
0.2387911081,
-0.1235369071,
-0.1106004715,
-0.1381494403,
-0.0143436836,
-0.0948964581,
-0.5207586288,
0.2886336744,
-0.2411800325,
0.1925238073,
0.2389917374,
0.3032708168,
0.4260568023,
-0.537386179,
0.7282180786,
0.1987842619,
-0.7538319826,
0.5065639615,
-0.8537748456,
0.4666296244,
0.3297917247,
0.3263547719,
0.1430859268,
-0.3505649269,
-0.1755134761,
-1.1480982304,
0.4193023443,
0.0633140653,
0.1886827797,
0.2604007125,
0.3735554814,
0.0569692254,
0.2807291746,
-0.6153650284,
0.1271957755,
0.0235687457,
-0.1804216653,
0.47471416,
0.2486709505,
-0.5610494018,
-0.3046889603,
0.2596743107,
-0.3434033096,
0.2119257599,
-0.0268734042,
0.106253542,
-0.3285927773,
-0.1488583833,
0.7372744679,
0.6426175237,
-0.2010450959,
-0.1211652011,
-0.1414856762,
-0.2843649983,
-0.0504559986,
-0.0092386343,
-0.0418135449,
-0.1867094636,
0.3171633482,
0.5520920753,
0.1388719976,
-0.7473250628,
0.3807662725,
-0.1226724088,
-0.2883908451,
-0.4562810957,
0.3903113902,
0.1691374034,
0.4413956702,
0.1423105448,
0.4615677595,
0.2307652831,
-0.5446687937,
0.5621429682,
0.1189047322,
-0.5340119004,
-0.5007733107,
0.7585694194,
0.3436302245,
-0.3686607182,
0.4777709544,
-0.356503278,
-0.3862620592,
0.5812675953,
0.0275909062,
0.5347337127,
0.1472756267,
0.2144138813,
0.0870159641,
0.3616935015,
-0.07398545,
0.762783587,
-0.4664791822,
-0.7788626552,
-0.5148990154,
-0.5360880494,
-0.7350175977,
-0.1543396711,
-0.6272723675,
0.2290952802,
-0.8559725881,
0.0405603126,
-0.2685543597,
-0.47016415,
-0.7771217227,
0.2063962966,
0.0024586476,
0.3783024251,
-0.5356566906,
0.7392986417,
0.8334770799,
-0.2293833643,
-1.0259087086,
-0.0306350309,
0.0881214216,
-0.8045549393,
0.5914390683,
-0.0827030987,
-0.8450241089,
-0.488586545,
-0.7859685421,
-0.8277665377,
0.9082790613,
0.4017412066,
-0.7010604143,
0.0756121725,
0.0606382079,
0.6115715504,
-0.3636529446,
0.0691747069,
0.3345133662,
0.7028262019,
0.2570702434,
-0.7215534449,
0.0812785402,
-0.4350340664,
-0.176845789,
0.0933896899,
-0.8641927242,
0.6191648245,
-0.4501915872,
0.2354009002,
0.0621571019,
0.7666746378,
0.2023581415,
0.2781849504,
0.4785481095,
0.4895734787,
0.7367207408,
-0.1827579886,
1.2353290319,
-0.3924078643,
-0.0516725518,
1.2485945225,
-0.4813987613,
0.5671297312,
0.3347502649,
-0.2541768849,
0.6517377496,
0.5544798374,
0.0868902057,
0.7592605948,
0.4304597378,
-0.1547866017,
-0.0679061636,
-0.0232296195,
0.0901154131,
0.5217855573,
0.7255678773,
-0.1619927585,
0.1026944295,
0.1581707001,
0.0625502467,
0.2024955451,
-0.0705457851,
0.5695207119,
0.0469817072,
-0.690948844,
0.3295972347,
-0.1969195902,
0.5509702563,
-0.5875899196,
-0.4579484761,
0.2279494703,
0.3324577212,
-0.2226459235,
-1.1325758696,
0.1824835837,
-0.4261808097,
-0.2429136336,
-0.4060292542,
0.5958562493,
-0.2812104225,
-0.3323944211,
0.5302773118,
0.5060628653,
-0.0512623042,
0.1667740792,
-0.5085079074,
0.2138026506,
0.2019309253,
-0.3853327632,
0.1434159577,
0.8408560753,
-0.1066772044,
1.0599794388,
0.556742847,
-0.187524572,
0.0763608441,
0.1643280685,
0.8917892575,
-0.3187358677,
-0.2123095542,
-0.4445309639,
0.5684424639,
0.4602244496,
-0.2840425074,
0.4290915132,
0.1785170287,
1.2538300753,
-0.344515115,
0.9276770353,
-0.316062659,
0.1584818661,
-0.5118157864,
0.4209339619,
-0.5101979971,
0.4679605961,
-0.1982036382,
-0.6464733481,
-0.4771679938,
0.7285373807,
-0.051027339,
0.0992486328,
0.3007924557,
0.8236234784,
-0.0182576291,
-0.0181561168,
0.3698681891,
0.1995503902,
0.4514707327,
0.1979566067,
0.9162594676,
-0.1095882505,
0.6765581965,
-0.4181741178,
-0.1960534155,
0.051211074,
-0.7584199309,
-0.6544259191,
-0.4973199368,
-0.1856738925,
-0.4180006385,
0.1977825612,
1.1278500557,
0.9721095562,
-0.7364768386,
-0.3176474571,
-0.1115357429,
-0.0160393156,
-0.5648133159,
-0.2484028041,
0.1641277671,
-0.2296307981,
-0.8825725913,
0.4658836424,
0.6355082393,
-0.3633832335,
-0.2604878247,
-0.0687153265,
-0.0639690533,
-0.1209215,
0.9350092411,
0.2466997802,
-0.8241401315,
-0.3572965264,
0.0430354662,
-0.0051683602,
0.1407283843,
0.3960187733,
-0.6814566255,
0.7130177021,
0.5132778287,
0.895763576,
0.5116599202,
-0.1527844071,
0.773445785,
-0.6468464136,
-0.0372488908,
0.4783558249,
0.4858429134,
0.3200626075,
-0.6338658333,
0.8807098269,
0.0209505241,
-0.484965384,
-0.3939434588,
0.4334059358,
-1.2882108688,
-0.3042666018,
1.2260854244,
-0.2490560114,
-0.3555025756,
-0.120799154,
-0.1482926309,
0.1351262778,
-0.6672108173,
1.0113425255,
0.7887613773,
-0.5104624033,
-0.1611930132,
-0.7083889246,
0.1620578617,
0.2456625104,
-0.7963203788,
-0.1259790361,
0.5440058112,
0.2427094132,
0.1608476788,
0.1982170492,
-0.1691946834,
0.2937054038,
-0.1546102762,
0.3641890585,
-0.1292051971,
-0.6466702819,
0.1260897219,
0.2720696628,
-0.2035266012,
-0.2389675677
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11230v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11230v1 | Multimodal Needle in a Haystack: Benchmarking Long-Context Capability of Multimodal Large Language Models | 2024-06-17T05:54:06 | 2024-06-17T05:54:06 | Hengyi Wang, Haizhou Shi, Shiwei Tan, Weiyi Qin, Wenyuan Wang, Tunyu Zhang, Akshay Nambi, Tanuja Ganu, Hao Wang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV | Multimodal Large Language Models (MLLMs) have shown significant promise in
various applications, leading to broad interest from researchers and
practitioners alike. However, a comprehensive evaluation of their long-context
capabilities remains underexplored. To address these gaps, we introduce the
MultiModal Needle-in-a-haystack (MMNeedle) benchmark, specifically designed to
assess the long-context capabilities of MLLMs. Besides multi-image input, we
employ image stitching to further increase the input context length, and
develop a protocol to automatically generate labels for sub-image level
retrieval. Essentially, MMNeedle evaluates MLLMs by stress-testing their
capability to locate a target sub-image (needle) within a set of images
(haystack) based on textual instructions and descriptions of image contents.
This setup necessitates an advanced understanding of extensive visual contexts
and effective information retrieval within long-context image inputs. With this
benchmark, we evaluate state-of-the-art MLLMs, encompassing both API-based and
open-source models. The findings reveal that GPT-4o consistently surpasses
other models in long-context scenarios, but suffers from hallucination problems
in negative samples, i.e., when needles are not in the haystacks. Our
comprehensive long-context evaluation of MLLMs also sheds lights on the
considerable performance gap between API-based and open-source models. All the
code, data, and instructions required to reproduce the main results are
available at https://github.com/Wang-ML-Lab/multimodal-needle-in-a-haystack. | [
-0.415227294,
-0.8735310435,
0.7735009193,
0.163352713,
-0.3059830666,
-0.1359036267,
-0.3559978902,
-0.7263293266,
0.0354255959,
0.2460308224,
-0.4269370735,
-0.5644794703,
-0.4927661717,
0.2318221033,
-0.4647601843,
0.6874763966,
-0.1015317142,
-0.0898928568,
-0.4220932722,
-0.360706389,
-0.5743807554,
-0.5754246116,
-0.1443223953,
0.0396578573,
0.7997774482,
-0.0102315266,
0.4911565781,
0.3098090887,
0.7041221857,
0.3500440121,
-0.0016615165,
0.1566443145,
-0.3653300405,
0.2089822441,
-0.0205676705,
0.0724691898,
-0.2320200801,
0.0388946682,
0.7412081361,
0.3991156518,
0.0438188128,
0.2699588239,
0.0228457507,
0.4852278531,
-0.9169169068,
-0.010314784,
-0.7046089172,
-0.1072757021,
-0.4058780968,
-0.1177172139,
-0.3922881186,
-0.0815061703,
0.169955954,
-0.4392571449,
-0.0933857709,
-0.0423065014,
0.7839978337,
0.1573135108,
-0.7263371944,
-0.3764040172,
-0.3407587111,
0.8532491922,
-0.5512729883,
0.6484821439,
0.481795758,
0.5264965892,
-0.1047475487,
-0.8587237597,
-0.5320947766,
-0.5212626457,
-0.0751848221,
-0.0019153305,
0.0324661918,
-0.2005293518,
0.334439218,
0.1602371186,
-0.690654695,
-0.0390797555,
-0.3016080558,
-0.2394443452,
0.1604427099,
0.0924379826,
0.0209951177,
-0.2766672671,
-0.6289243698,
0.0644472912,
-0.3359057307,
0.1151151732,
0.0158521887,
0.1815019399,
-0.0669416338,
0.7113301158,
-0.0790951923,
0.7235090137,
-0.3551743329,
-0.1998640299,
0.5582883954,
-0.534729898,
-0.1432230771,
-0.3633565009,
0.7622436285,
0.636128962,
0.0119094457,
-0.0783557147,
-0.3694908619,
0.0093423352,
0.2249083221,
-0.8582294583,
0.0983733684,
0.2882291675,
-0.4487983882,
0.0251254551,
-0.109841302,
-0.7273792028,
-0.4454708695,
-0.2002203465,
0.6040956378,
-0.5023483634,
-0.2054884881,
-0.1318426728,
-0.371232152,
0.0776008815,
0.2434372753,
-0.6045548916,
-0.1127604544,
0.7654240131,
1.2762527466,
-0.2254763693,
-0.7341878414,
-0.6243169308,
0.1955968142,
-0.4555891156,
0.7769626379,
-0.7781011462,
-0.2149951458,
-0.0047081104,
0.1714586616,
0.0207877103,
-0.5519124866,
0.4102713466,
-0.2289000601,
0.0975795239,
-0.1455572844,
-0.4898238778,
0.0183231533,
0.4098162949,
-0.7220417857,
0.9676381946,
0.2588270009,
-0.5960899591,
0.4986027181,
-0.7351897359,
-0.2520063519,
-0.0776904747,
-0.254640907,
-0.2703361511,
0.0345439278,
0.1044101417,
0.5336495638,
-0.2711408734,
0.2481261641,
-0.746888876,
-0.6682560444,
0.4400268495,
-0.4172760546,
0.5534007549,
0.0501214378,
-0.3190876842,
0.4329829812,
-0.6094241142,
0.0095091462,
-0.0057509989,
-0.2338853329,
-0.4324961901,
-0.1917557567,
0.3637670875,
0.4377112389,
0.1914293468,
-0.5355775356,
0.1567629874,
0.2313848585,
0.6091086864,
0.8280037642,
-0.4500703216,
0.0522604659,
-0.0542978123,
0.2105083615,
0.1036477238,
0.3469195664,
-0.5999779701,
-0.4294426441,
-0.3926613927,
-0.6101932526,
0.2151699513,
0.1254908293,
-0.8242191076,
0.224902451,
-0.1432535499,
-0.4020900428,
-0.5270325541,
0.0360198095,
0.327937305,
0.4762251675,
0.5777146816,
-0.3853335679,
-0.37261343,
-1.119092226,
-0.0340038761,
0.1891939491,
-0.2405894101,
0.4928777814,
0.683568716,
-0.690972805,
0.6253172755,
-0.1322711408,
-0.4273651838,
0.3530049026,
0.1638907939,
0.2314958274,
0.2971777022,
0.4343999922,
-0.6433357,
-0.2921850383,
-0.0311281569,
-0.862154305,
0.1683436483,
0.0352573432,
-0.0677498579,
0.4901492894,
0.411870271,
-0.8775194287,
0.3350841701,
0.8678237796,
-0.4930306971,
0.8118297458,
-0.1940194219,
0.4357284904,
-0.7514051199,
0.48729375,
-0.0502184592,
-0.2022409141,
-0.3769888282,
0.1858614981,
0.6553182006,
-0.0760368183,
-0.3983640969,
0.554028213,
-0.5078389645,
-0.2564010322,
-0.1640792787,
0.0241985731,
0.0384774692,
0.4238575697,
-0.0632709935,
0.9147354364,
0.4966842532,
-0.2454481423,
0.4209579527,
-0.1953654885,
-0.6067634225,
0.6194700599,
-0.4748181701,
0.2048021853,
-0.0043028765,
0.4439277947,
-0.9141380787,
-0.1756539792,
-0.0733132288,
-0.1499095708,
0.1505808383,
-0.1763493866,
-0.5369290709,
-0.5169851184,
-0.5328823328,
0.509372592,
0.314738065,
-0.5372175574,
0.5048724413,
0.3332020044,
0.1371037066,
-0.7263675332,
-0.3642685413,
0.4464341998,
-0.3124745786,
-0.5065606833,
0.229269281,
-0.1909043938,
0.0334814973,
-0.1308042109,
0.1104692072,
-0.1381806582,
-0.0430744365,
0.2679775953,
0.1306914091,
-0.232111007,
0.4969225824,
-0.2617222667,
-0.1405780166,
-0.0437940992,
-0.0628069341,
0.5760805011,
-0.364154309,
-0.538754344,
-0.2234424502,
0.5519217253,
0.8165676594,
-0.3031466603,
0.4569364786,
0.9196459055,
-0.2003163099,
0.1025991291,
-0.7279022336,
-0.1637510955,
-0.4634304941,
0.5914608836,
-0.57540977,
-0.8372228742,
0.2595537007,
0.0596033111,
0.0433687158,
0.2479536682,
0.5564935803,
-0.1527190059,
0.8788508773,
0.4897154868,
0.0404993519,
0.3808128834,
-0.0146566369,
-0.1608667821,
-1.0236929655,
-0.0720481649,
-0.1365921497,
-0.225178048,
-0.3961932957,
-0.7773752809,
0.5350933671,
0.0082301702,
-0.1368520111,
0.091236338,
-0.3143745065,
0.5439474583,
0.6602832079,
0.0140154269,
0.236054495,
-0.2743838429,
-0.3314956129,
0.1508967578,
-0.370626986,
-0.4845988452,
1.1385378838,
0.4880186319,
0.6409124136,
0.0726463422,
0.3959540725,
-0.0230099298,
0.2333208919,
-0.7320236564,
0.4406825304,
-0.1079178378,
-0.5444966555,
-0.5064537525,
-0.2142288983,
-1.0486426353,
0.5363103747,
-0.250454396,
-0.6280819178,
-0.063371405,
0.0520407334,
-0.1189679131,
0.2108659446,
-0.7923690677,
1.0747741461,
-0.2825418413,
-0.5591766238,
-0.1476300657,
-0.5665481687,
0.4144559205,
-0.312161833,
0.2430540919,
-0.3831197321,
-0.2724179327,
0.3787869811,
-0.1029971987,
0.5357228518,
-0.1321564168,
-0.2336032838,
0.059357442,
-0.0038282839,
0.3211646974,
-0.1582752764,
0.0270465538,
0.5962956548,
0.3663682342,
-0.3616548181,
-0.3313952088,
0.8407419324,
-0.4240231216,
-0.2920143008,
-0.2094973624,
-0.5042667985,
-0.2027004808,
0.3003164828,
-0.0449061096,
0.6861411333,
-0.0470763743,
0.5743417144,
0.1086089686,
-0.3007177711,
0.5691953301,
0.3166661859,
-0.547228694,
-0.253954798,
0.8218458295,
0.1164687574,
0.0192088783,
0.0687304661,
0.2164281309,
-0.4824278057,
-0.3125366569,
-0.7004142404,
0.1234807819,
-0.8019234538,
-0.1558598578,
-0.5580003262,
0.1030737087,
-0.3506117463,
0.1266554296,
-0.4000613689,
-0.0199715514,
0.053896673,
0.3642738163,
0.1844130903,
0.6326414943,
0.1347874552,
-0.24546507,
-0.815895021,
0.2949018478,
0.3948978186,
0.8262630701,
0.1284492314,
-0.1282720268,
-0.3920245171,
-0.0420501009,
-0.2376044542,
-0.6512645483,
0.0018930204,
0.0883378088,
0.3933143914,
0.315268904,
-0.286002934,
1.0209025145,
-0.8270348907,
0.8055216074,
0.3052692115,
-0.829244554,
0.2378658801,
-0.3858803809,
0.6354120374,
0.2390681505,
0.3400912583,
-0.7180536389,
-0.388699472,
-0.0994504392,
-0.8886924386,
0.2054100484,
0.1555270255,
0.0577595904,
-0.1962231994,
-0.1616201252,
0.337652415,
0.1791215092,
-0.6405665874,
0.2352283448,
-0.2654500902,
-0.0366253257,
-0.4170209765,
-0.2832055092,
-0.2357811779,
-0.1780474335,
0.1823020726,
-0.3162356317,
0.256657809,
0.1458340138,
-0.3436934352,
-0.0435568988,
0.2385559976,
0.9126787186,
1.0429190397,
-0.39920488,
0.3452254534,
0.0408910923,
-0.3440879285,
-0.1680169255,
0.0579994321,
0.3123443723,
0.2225587219,
0.5443779826,
0.6259492636,
0.2147206515,
-1.0375401974,
0.6979299188,
-0.1828750223,
-0.1065069363,
-0.2500309348,
-0.2677059472,
0.1555256546,
0.4954382777,
0.5271324515,
-0.2888507247,
0.3137087524,
-0.6252719164,
0.304695487,
0.8256360888,
-0.2245887071,
-0.1374882311,
0.306989342,
0.1918407083,
-0.1800998598,
0.5251623392,
0.2068794817,
-0.1681607664,
0.4616318941,
0.4936178625,
0.657880187,
0.0910539776,
-0.1649044603,
0.3345475793,
0.2399703413,
0.2134474516,
0.0085239066,
-0.1499980092,
-0.2537579834,
-0.4445325732,
-0.513302505,
-0.2689571381,
0.3052334487,
-0.4489261508,
0.2480981797,
-0.1315938532,
-0.4906139076,
0.0607412197,
-0.313647449,
-0.6725901365,
-0.1416476816,
0.2439485341,
0.777135551,
-0.3591582477,
0.9310680628,
0.4041260481,
-0.041657418,
-0.2618826032,
-0.1292957067,
0.0600670725,
-0.7658212781,
0.6376873255,
0.7904656529,
-0.2440764159,
-0.3348283172,
-0.4592366815,
-0.9037667513,
1.2132278681,
0.0637007207,
-0.6979668736,
0.1432857662,
-0.0707880259,
0.4538502097,
-0.1758027375,
0.5276418924,
0.3799868226,
0.4218223691,
-0.0197767522,
-1.359102726,
0.0732428357,
-0.3036676943,
0.0168546978,
0.390463084,
-0.444285363,
1.1359238625,
-0.1824899614,
-0.2274075001,
0.2872921228,
0.2892358005,
0.3604945838,
0.4138298333,
0.5602337122,
0.3973775208,
0.6176564693,
0.0655520856,
0.9615089297,
-0.2832444608,
0.4361414015,
1.0528354645,
-0.4149470925,
1.2134770155,
0.9095281363,
-0.0266719591,
0.483787179,
0.4793286026,
-0.0011480777,
0.3887940645,
0.1154705584,
-0.06780646,
-0.0788583308,
-0.0088367881,
-0.5879662037,
0.4686717987,
0.184191063,
-0.3113090992,
-0.2599533796,
0.2306815833,
-0.4236475825,
-0.3379267454,
-0.0588020831,
0.7645125389,
-0.0553773604,
-0.563564837,
0.9334514737,
-0.2505653799,
0.9566414356,
-0.6803978086,
-0.2009541839,
-0.0164493565,
0.1972768456,
0.183432743,
-0.9193136692,
0.0282445513,
-0.0207024012,
0.0463038124,
0.0524091087,
0.4984847307,
-0.477912873,
-0.3991712034,
0.4459569454,
0.3222721815,
0.2003489286,
-0.1024600789,
-0.7523844838,
0.335968107,
-0.5320317745,
-0.3514301181,
0.4203986228,
0.4675803483,
-0.0997259691,
0.6983947754,
0.7649595737,
-0.1803431362,
0.0158415791,
0.0793630034,
0.7651023865,
-0.9362412691,
-0.2244511545,
-1.0265226364,
0.5573476553,
-0.1923282593,
-0.4694606364,
0.7903511524,
0.58490628,
0.8214708567,
-0.2069324553,
0.4499700963,
0.0895089433,
0.4336289167,
-0.6121551394,
0.7090502977,
-0.8090233207,
-0.2235097885,
-0.4709379375,
-0.7696303725,
-0.2355519831,
0.5747528076,
-0.100880906,
0.1423627436,
0.9026067257,
0.8509149551,
-0.1509918571,
-0.3252014518,
0.5755277276,
0.0725550428,
0.3393383026,
0.6162753105,
1.1781446934,
-0.1576472968,
0.4398864806,
-0.3362957239,
-0.2401546538,
-0.2733210325,
-1.0959144831,
-0.9635379314,
-0.8676818013,
0.2166948467,
-0.2087793946,
0.0081358962,
0.8212605119,
0.8397805691,
-0.4346530437,
-0.4342308939,
0.5213879347,
-0.0819640607,
-0.1502267569,
-0.1788235009,
0.3688696921,
-0.3709994853,
-0.5738095641,
0.2267829627,
0.5641140342,
0.0393780507,
-0.3445028663,
-0.0394535773,
-0.2996678054,
-0.2183849066,
1.1637682915,
-0.1348372549,
-1.0415633917,
-0.388178885,
-0.0949482694,
-0.2587174177,
0.0344052352,
0.8145822287,
-0.6804836988,
0.6145498157,
0.0817234069,
0.4892252386,
0.3729676008,
-0.1714663804,
0.3022653461,
-0.4730923176,
0.2352160513,
0.2298505157,
0.4384180307,
0.2952567041,
0.0027415578,
0.4652573764,
-0.0342755951,
-0.5727300644,
-1.0225607157,
0.0494377129,
-0.8757717609,
-0.7493333817,
1.1555739641,
-0.0249248613,
-0.222074911,
-0.0236446746,
-0.3446683884,
-0.0549639054,
-0.2373153716,
0.8775951266,
0.7228941917,
0.0086328369,
-0.1974873245,
-0.7582857609,
0.308465153,
0.2197380662,
-0.6635228992,
0.1729137897,
0.8002110124,
0.1670671552,
0.144789055,
0.6291171312,
-0.0064731617,
0.3592844009,
-0.109169513,
-0.069657281,
-0.1613418311,
-0.4802447259,
-0.3095194995,
0.2088879496,
-0.0356970541,
-0.123600468
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11228v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11228v1 | ComperDial: Commonsense Persona-grounded Dialogue Dataset and Benchmark | 2024-06-17T05:51:04 | 2024-06-17T05:51:04 | Hiromi Wakaki, Yuki Mitsufuji, Yoshinori Maeda, Yukiko Nishimura, Silin Gao, Mengjie Zhao, Keiichi Yamada, Antoine Bosselut | cs.CL | cs.CL | We propose a new benchmark, ComperDial, which facilitates the training and
evaluation of evaluation metrics for open-domain dialogue systems. ComperDial
consists of human-scored responses for 10,395 dialogue turns in 1,485
conversations collected from 99 dialogue agents submitted to the Commonsense
Persona-grounded Dialogue (CPD) challenge. As a result, for any dialogue, our
benchmark includes multiple diverse responses with variety of characteristics
to ensure more robust evaluation of learned dialogue metrics. In addition to
single-turn response scores, ComperDial also contains dialogue-level
human-annotated scores, enabling joint assessment of multi-turn model responses
throughout a dialogue. Finally, building off ComperDial, we devise a new
automatic evaluation metric to measure the general similarity of
model-generated dialogues to human conversations. Our experimental results
demonstrate that our novel metric, CPDScore is more correlated with human
judgments than existing metrics. We release both ComperDial and CPDScore to the
community to accelerate development of automatic evaluation metrics for
open-domain dialogue systems. | [
-0.5230044127,
-0.4290450215,
0.3475067019,
0.1398609579,
-0.1047949642,
0.2396782935,
-0.3126096725,
-0.0119011467,
-0.1199850664,
0.5370056033,
-0.7922329307,
-0.5074831843,
-0.3642392755,
0.0960414633,
-0.0060233958,
0.7785192728,
0.4712794721,
0.3121390045,
-0.551641047,
-0.5443034172,
-0.6226100922,
-0.5494544506,
-0.4354629815,
-0.3029018342,
0.0435461663,
0.602028966,
0.7096942663,
-0.0071602012,
0.2861334682,
0.3400130868,
0.191729486,
0.2786055803,
-0.5849519968,
0.1490207762,
-0.1497914642,
-0.21759893,
-0.6360690594,
0.4793025255,
0.5148397684,
1.0758004189,
-0.220006898,
0.3636729121,
0.0741681829,
0.395896703,
-0.6194372773,
0.3315966129,
-0.3616759479,
0.0948091447,
0.2467760444,
-0.3557005525,
-0.6121008396,
-0.5432843566,
0.4620692432,
-0.6469499469,
0.2327835411,
0.1671386659,
0.2715333104,
0.2704434693,
-0.3208931088,
0.0307492074,
-0.3609012067,
1.0119146109,
-0.4230212569,
0.3884113431,
0.1566962451,
0.6146886945,
-0.018440742,
-0.5899993181,
-0.5226891041,
-0.3080600798,
-0.1004969552,
0.2854675949,
-0.133983016,
-0.0348236635,
0.255030632,
0.2917523086,
-0.4741111696,
-0.1378872097,
0.0450709164,
-0.1339608729,
0.5717394352,
0.5670021772,
0.0638773441,
-0.21624358,
-0.4720213413,
-0.3379766047,
-0.4575864077,
0.1127105355,
0.2778305411,
0.1560223848,
-0.365334183,
0.3074109554,
-0.3778942227,
0.5198104978,
0.2099292129,
-0.1901937574,
0.3827498555,
-0.4416232705,
-0.2825590372,
-0.0148384003,
1.0236880779,
0.8955820799,
0.2987583876,
-0.1138172224,
0.1180101633,
-0.0039496319,
0.2670621574,
-0.6986303329,
-0.2909500897,
0.0963492021,
-0.7875685096,
-0.3074311614,
0.2226073295,
-0.9967766404,
-0.4784150124,
-0.6559609175,
0.1152010411,
-0.2330926508,
-0.4509279728,
0.1150230095,
-0.2924838364,
0.3201217055,
0.9084424376,
-0.5222076774,
0.9707424641,
0.9749216437,
0.5693894625,
-0.4729159474,
-0.245309785,
-0.9645996094,
-0.4811576307,
-0.1376487911,
0.7041096091,
-0.8314968944,
-0.6813552976,
-0.1007642597,
-0.0596091002,
-0.3385951817,
-0.9749124646,
0.5768063664,
-0.1451385617,
0.2984558642,
-0.148936078,
-0.395344764,
0.0585420802,
0.3269402385,
-0.3975122869,
1.0309273005,
0.3289297223,
-0.5558018684,
0.3693163693,
-0.7347634435,
0.058483988,
0.106540516,
-0.2788158357,
-0.2100248635,
0.0583038367,
0.1122962758,
0.2458442003,
-0.7543953061,
0.3504449725,
-0.4938327074,
-0.2565551698,
0.7201009393,
-0.654882431,
0.9246631861,
0.2482049763,
-0.1460012496,
0.035952244,
-0.8269876838,
0.3123444021,
-0.2847915292,
0.0626577884,
-0.05459214,
-0.182258606,
0.1772216856,
0.1563749164,
0.0136100827,
-0.770817399,
-0.1339290738,
-0.0806383044,
0.1716708839,
0.7056164145,
0.2938627303,
0.2021595985,
-0.4837428927,
0.371326983,
0.0713299215,
0.324345082,
-0.2871302366,
-0.547534585,
-0.6984274387,
-0.5053135157,
-0.0668475479,
0.3403989673,
-0.1659374833,
0.7530091405,
-0.4807567894,
-0.6802360415,
-0.5184012651,
-0.0510960892,
0.7811201215,
0.5683991313,
0.245119065,
-0.9425320625,
-0.2060548067,
-0.7455531359,
-0.3541053832,
-0.2138411552,
-0.1338889748,
0.7949071527,
0.3068932593,
0.0624189004,
1.2127846479,
-0.7125223279,
-0.2155263424,
-0.0565708987,
0.5500454903,
0.1088871807,
0.490314573,
0.3735799491,
-0.5673050284,
-0.5964516401,
-0.2111074477,
-0.6355887055,
-0.336928606,
-0.044287011,
0.0102976765,
-0.1064455584,
0.4396241903,
-0.613175571,
0.2989502847,
0.2769467235,
-0.3577098846,
0.7813968062,
0.0230343305,
0.470138818,
-0.820299387,
0.1210296005,
-0.1132802442,
-0.4489979446,
-0.3772892654,
-0.1887136847,
-0.1864739656,
-0.5359298587,
-0.6963344216,
0.6206619143,
-0.1406580508,
-0.4849821031,
0.2713451982,
0.336468339,
0.0244441777,
0.845759213,
0.1688921899,
0.9468251467,
0.3363080919,
-0.558680892,
0.5671113729,
0.8461650014,
-0.5624822378,
1.28867805,
-0.801369071,
0.4667623937,
0.3117470145,
0.5241781473,
-1.0162061453,
-0.1275517493,
0.1695158184,
-0.6250342727,
-0.2503728867,
-0.1806581467,
-0.4913593233,
-0.0293167364,
-0.2301907688,
0.4900854528,
0.4330610633,
-0.6236248612,
0.3697736561,
0.3485913575,
-0.3545666039,
-0.0956295058,
-0.0411046334,
0.1452145875,
-0.0315301493,
-0.5576083064,
0.0689927116,
-0.4081856608,
-0.4909494221,
-0.2903213501,
-0.0487746894,
-0.0767797232,
0.1167189032,
0.4601522684,
0.1668531448,
-0.0589135997,
-0.2132624537,
-0.2469642162,
-0.3461346328,
0.3702180386,
-0.0041774353,
0.6979109049,
-0.2488139719,
-0.6088927984,
-0.6209912896,
0.4199727774,
0.8561677933,
-0.2037609667,
0.3647131026,
0.2015168518,
-0.020750545,
0.1056545675,
-0.4518634081,
-0.0187303741,
-0.437053144,
0.0747366697,
-0.4919160903,
-0.6165624261,
0.3302031159,
-0.3185853362,
0.0080641489,
0.1819134951,
0.7685502768,
0.1432265937,
0.9374733567,
0.0731280968,
0.0962411538,
0.0369687676,
-0.183967039,
0.1600191742,
-1.0228284597,
-0.3726432025,
-0.6708550453,
-0.0679349676,
-0.4654324651,
-0.5922338963,
0.4979234338,
-0.3491796553,
-0.3506677449,
0.4651835263,
-0.3433659971,
0.2586555481,
0.7335914373,
0.0447459742,
0.4825063646,
-0.4299437106,
-0.2958862185,
-0.2695912421,
-0.3381672204,
-0.6258111,
1.2708480358,
0.2820368409,
0.6222648621,
0.243498072,
0.587507844,
0.4819547534,
0.3182779551,
-0.6849858761,
0.8515589833,
0.2273541987,
-0.4416435957,
-0.2175554335,
-0.3413299024,
-0.564563036,
0.298389554,
0.0075957729,
-0.8173961639,
0.1798693389,
-0.2116612792,
-0.483579278,
-0.2750761509,
-0.7682214379,
0.9443155527,
-0.0848171189,
-0.4662812352,
-0.5227808952,
-0.6883087754,
0.1299971342,
0.0585421957,
-0.110317573,
-0.225269258,
0.1646784395,
0.6892111301,
-0.70331043,
0.9706583023,
-0.4084725678,
-0.0050703385,
0.2106577158,
-0.0424723849,
0.0291401837,
0.4560225606,
-0.0678084195,
0.1463032216,
0.0904885158,
-0.1803961247,
-0.6918361187,
0.6957716942,
-0.9643633962,
-0.358412236,
-0.5344387889,
-0.224920854,
-0.5023182034,
0.0461506695,
0.007047073,
0.9268801212,
-0.9799016714,
0.2994903624,
0.5778231621,
-0.5284231901,
0.2386661917,
0.7736169696,
0.1475601345,
-0.7283515334,
0.4917880297,
-0.5198307037,
0.5212888122,
0.3390544057,
0.007201144,
-0.4241219461,
0.02618609,
-0.2537801564,
-0.1130711809,
-0.6741092801,
-0.2604530752,
-0.8059314489,
-0.0360138603,
-0.5487095714,
0.0298101362,
-0.4634769559,
-0.4657137096,
-0.0764379278,
0.1433573067,
-0.02155976,
0.3338476121,
0.1696891636,
0.2460707575,
-0.8095839024,
0.5029637218,
0.5352099538,
0.4553180337,
-0.1643151939,
-0.3861573935,
0.0588998049,
0.0957754776,
-0.6637946367,
-0.4024668634,
0.3429570496,
0.3322024643,
0.6368061304,
0.5475202799,
0.463435322,
0.506003201,
-0.5243422985,
0.9322767258,
0.4598647058,
-0.9607698321,
0.3855607808,
-0.5298499465,
0.3362883031,
0.9374513626,
0.0094758011,
-0.5337177515,
-0.354300648,
-0.8417183757,
-0.2264312804,
0.8889433146,
0.2055825889,
0.2150657475,
-0.1876810342,
-0.2472228408,
0.4785749018,
0.4646819234,
-0.2268268317,
-0.3305165172,
-0.2432744503,
-0.0202631,
-0.135058254,
-0.0288813449,
-0.4204697907,
-0.1777877212,
0.1828088909,
-0.3589245081,
0.6000156999,
0.1961954981,
-0.2404423803,
-0.1073934436,
0.4026226997,
0.4836504459,
0.4222327769,
-0.581697166,
-0.2099333256,
-0.0306280274,
-0.3230310082,
0.1581834853,
0.0355723947,
0.2994249761,
-0.022287352,
0.2947064936,
0.7935715914,
0.6708267927,
-0.8737021685,
0.8197924495,
-0.351801604,
-0.2657099962,
-0.6859868765,
0.2219759226,
-0.2521889508,
-0.0510813594,
0.2705100775,
0.4821803868,
0.3205635846,
-0.6935541034,
0.3077666461,
0.3324117959,
-0.5447233915,
-0.3553496301,
0.3968855143,
0.7723750472,
-0.5655508637,
0.6581265926,
-0.1342750639,
-0.5000158548,
0.31678316,
0.1836300194,
1.2168704271,
0.0763489902,
0.4739509821,
0.4268863797,
-0.3414514959,
0.2364333421,
-0.0843375698,
-0.5275249481,
-0.6923030615,
-0.1078943238,
-0.3979777098,
-1.0891660452,
-0.0144240223,
-1.0688281059,
0.3088956773,
-0.5896881819,
-0.0651627481,
0.0409713425,
0.2724041343,
-0.8941321969,
0.2018592656,
-0.1559720337,
1.0754910707,
-0.7192377448,
0.4833831787,
0.4701344669,
-0.2454736978,
-0.3616507947,
0.0106336065,
0.2444132715,
-0.5823035836,
0.8766325116,
0.3613251448,
-0.3443813622,
-0.0167388674,
-0.3793327212,
-0.3383879066,
1.0401988029,
0.0844290406,
-0.3583871424,
0.325766772,
0.2952064276,
0.4989605248,
-0.6613863111,
0.738958478,
0.789925456,
0.3842501342,
-0.0909184143,
-1.3076372147,
-0.0676138848,
-0.5227921009,
-0.3491965532,
-0.0543250777,
-0.9487965703,
0.5128529668,
0.0450173244,
-0.1497744024,
0.5114269853,
0.0896743611,
0.2665266097,
0.5213164091,
0.6132455468,
0.7830719352,
0.5022659898,
-0.2141167074,
0.9186748266,
-0.2160860002,
0.2474684715,
1.4415236712,
-0.7033529282,
0.6825787425,
0.1648092121,
-0.1799056083,
0.4603772461,
0.2274146676,
0.0751539469,
0.6022173762,
0.1200002432,
-0.4627669454,
-0.4230182171,
-0.261716634,
-0.0604499094,
0.7204430699,
0.2217878401,
-0.0768806934,
-0.2634781897,
-0.0702504441,
-0.1722633839,
0.4066832662,
0.0739299804,
1.0981500149,
0.0495955162,
-1.1981613636,
0.6052116156,
-0.2052722573,
0.2430658489,
-0.224150449,
-0.1074590981,
-0.2773177922,
0.4196639359,
0.0958439261,
-0.5427129865,
-0.0223694164,
0.0401051901,
0.1641157717,
-0.6042491794,
0.3820841014,
-0.1095563173,
0.0245422497,
0.1745283157,
0.6239860654,
0.1355910152,
-0.0644436851,
-0.811352253,
0.0627033636,
-0.2307310402,
0.0805142,
0.2685998678,
0.5294749737,
0.0805786103,
0.8461885452,
0.5352987051,
-0.2340363562,
-0.22880961,
0.3957619071,
0.9458255172,
-0.5964774489,
-0.4279738367,
-0.2465659976,
0.447794497,
-0.4790460467,
-0.6454966068,
0.6543040276,
0.8435535431,
0.6038419604,
-0.1901727021,
0.8784158826,
0.0288003068,
1.0318875313,
-0.3005008698,
0.4228859842,
-0.0647877753,
0.2309906036,
-0.615696609,
-1.0577373505,
0.1186962873,
0.5469456911,
-0.2745932937,
-0.0421195813,
0.8641594052,
0.8074788451,
-0.1286982149,
0.3462407291,
0.4030115008,
-0.1301832646,
0.4284748137,
0.4667311609,
1.069244504,
-0.4443286657,
0.3860345483,
0.0882334262,
-0.3694221079,
-0.4196377695,
-0.7550880313,
-1.159799099,
-0.5310366154,
-0.6279982328,
-0.1431049705,
0.0287633371,
1.2442908287,
0.7861119509,
-0.7896882892,
-0.4316157103,
-0.1582921147,
-0.3919844627,
-0.3722667992,
-0.3334223926,
0.0177400857,
-0.4408169687,
-0.925812304,
0.3852568865,
0.4742020965,
-0.2692263424,
-0.3103178442,
-0.3786633015,
0.1175923049,
0.1196601838,
0.4780944884,
0.0676551238,
-0.5321134329,
-0.3816186786,
0.1567350626,
-0.1117897928,
0.1187956482,
1.1241710186,
-1.0602353811,
0.495954752,
0.2453686446,
0.3484024107,
0.3158406913,
0.2410370559,
1.0848655701,
-0.7981820703,
0.2551656067,
0.2450426668,
0.1810697913,
0.4978806376,
0.0354801901,
0.5783436298,
0.2923880517,
-0.4506764114,
-0.7454150915,
0.3207745254,
-1.3017663956,
0.2559316158,
0.9633344412,
-0.4423192441,
0.1857476383,
-0.5107757449,
-0.399240613,
-0.0962841138,
-0.7863181233,
0.4935370684,
0.5161682963,
-0.0873104185,
-0.3351565599,
-0.2822871804,
0.5112354755,
0.5258034468,
-0.863147378,
0.4819332063,
0.7677741051,
0.205178082,
0.3196879923,
0.946865797,
-0.3597114086,
0.5273781419,
0.0795899704,
-0.3455864489,
0.067104198,
-0.2509351373,
0.0136416396,
0.0167187583,
0.0279850699,
-0.2312199622
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11218v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11218v1 | Building another Spanish dictionary, this time with GPT-4 | 2024-06-17T05:25:56 | 2024-06-17T05:25:56 | Miguel Ortega-Martín, Óscar García-Sierra, Alfonso Ardoiz, Juan Carlos Armenteros, Ignacio Garrido, Jorge Álvarez, Camilo Torrón, Iñigo Galdeano, Ignacio Arranz, Oleg Vorontsov, Adrián Alonso | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | We present the "Spanish Built Factual Freectianary 2.0" (Spanish-BFF-2) as
the second iteration of an AI-generated Spanish dictionary. Previously, we
developed the inaugural version of this unique free dictionary employing GPT-3.
In this study, we aim to improve the dictionary by using GPT-4-turbo instead.
Furthermore, we explore improvements made to the initial version and compare
the performance of both models. | [
-0.3805819154,
-0.6232151389,
0.488175869,
0.4588619471,
-0.3644262254,
0.3929308653,
-0.0218457617,
-0.8323905468,
0.4500986934,
0.2275986969,
-0.6326114535,
-0.1832365841,
-0.6855467558,
0.2993045449,
-0.2613011003,
1.2726955414,
-0.1015990078,
-0.0497794114,
0.0998854712,
-0.0284064319,
-0.3920707107,
-0.512630403,
-0.790646255,
-0.3898009956,
0.3496966064,
0.4629860222,
1.4091621637,
0.7683094144,
0.620737493,
0.3018548787,
0.3444437981,
-0.2415201366,
-0.3835259676,
-0.1661082357,
-0.3695754409,
-0.1819820404,
-0.3188673556,
0.1098428294,
0.1802463531,
0.0789475963,
-0.2487245798,
-0.0866250023,
-0.1992301941,
0.6858844161,
-0.0893725976,
0.5437989831,
-0.7701417208,
-0.0145195341,
-0.2724190652,
-0.1034695953,
0.1522613019,
-0.5650771856,
0.2943291962,
-0.6286694407,
0.7360788584,
-0.0792045221,
1.2223519087,
0.5427354574,
-0.3852303028,
-0.520527184,
-0.3316345811,
0.2640880644,
-0.3990374207,
0.8602715731,
0.3983051479,
0.2590205371,
-0.275211364,
-1.2050293684,
-0.6897373796,
-0.6244986057,
0.1245626882,
0.2583717108,
-0.1638721824,
0.1819852442,
-0.2767131627,
0.4537905157,
-0.8058492541,
0.0639099553,
-0.559718132,
-0.2745512724,
0.2874362171,
-0.3194896877,
0.2081979364,
-0.0800387189,
-0.2852637172,
0.0033290207,
-0.9621838331,
-0.4109377563,
0.4864337146,
0.1741160601,
0.0276749898,
0.7389532328,
-0.1206008792,
0.1066530123,
0.000562164,
-0.2991685271,
0.5325316787,
-0.4234168828,
-0.2432647943,
0.0350617021,
0.6508619189,
0.6380408406,
0.38006863,
-0.4523167014,
-0.1375633925,
0.1251201481,
0.1644420624,
-0.9916197658,
-0.6832581758,
0.2066940069,
-0.1736480296,
-0.5033954978,
0.2494618744,
-0.3370116949,
0.0122328866,
0.1212815344,
0.2886050642,
-0.3734580576,
-0.408220917,
0.0336512066,
-0.3277513683,
-0.0236793458,
0.1122514606,
-1.0368535519,
0.4279228747,
0.9085658193,
1.0967463255,
0.1791726053,
-0.2271369845,
-0.4368169606,
0.0713485852,
-0.5046294332,
1.0145070553,
0.1228047386,
-0.7846449614,
-0.1446349472,
0.2830840051,
0.4759675562,
-0.4489914477,
0.5607162118,
-0.4861025512,
0.3933450878,
-0.7273985744,
-0.2019537091,
-0.3034380674,
0.1251072437,
-0.8984651566,
1.4386110306,
0.5749667287,
-0.6598930359,
0.5993846655,
-0.5981515646,
-0.5277559757,
0.4757063389,
-0.2227832824,
0.0677182004,
0.1887150854,
-0.1238974109,
0.103420943,
-0.4229727685,
0.2506009638,
-0.1456747502,
-0.1294081211,
-0.3857106566,
-0.2074553221,
0.7206338644,
0.1241579652,
-0.5694547892,
-0.333760649,
-0.6239394546,
-0.1710454077,
-0.0619691797,
-0.4906843007,
-0.0949476436,
0.459382534,
-0.0987704843,
0.5010907054,
0.5265980959,
-0.7145329714,
0.0623368174,
-0.9195292592,
0.0197104998,
0.6855053902,
-0.0332532115,
0.0267731063,
-0.4274063408,
0.5178623199,
-0.4689476788,
-0.1472401023,
0.5396437645,
-1.1244663,
-0.689565897,
-0.3377252221,
-0.0804162174,
1.0676436424,
-0.8082524538,
0.0081879534,
-0.2156483233,
-0.5604746938,
-0.1476354599,
0.3751765788,
0.6010372043,
0.6042199731,
0.4475013316,
0.0564630255,
-0.945582211,
-0.9530840516,
0.0031887989,
-0.6008247137,
-0.1195899323,
0.0998845398,
0.7338678837,
-0.1949436665,
0.8986241221,
-0.325053364,
-0.2107476592,
-0.1352910101,
0.2048804611,
0.1443125755,
0.3587886989,
1.0557438135,
-0.4184190333,
-0.7738975883,
0.4019593298,
-0.4452133775,
-0.1794758141,
0.3472586572,
-0.0136986161,
0.308067441,
0.2909761071,
-0.4713104069,
0.2261635065,
0.5845798254,
-0.6993213892,
0.3457174897,
-0.2575651109,
0.0021559338,
-1.0376164913,
-0.3856091499,
-0.2362590134,
-0.2246612012,
-0.5048670173,
0.2301036716,
0.0806721747,
0.5699311495,
-0.4193738401,
0.6390686035,
-0.3375653923,
0.0082810894,
-0.3319523335,
-0.0528497286,
-0.2492521405,
0.2787555158,
0.1490543336,
1.073133111,
0.2110695541,
-0.0976446643,
0.7858020067,
0.1402417868,
-0.1875982583,
0.3308294713,
-1.0083962679,
0.1420485824,
-0.1648625731,
0.0206313692,
-1.0713419914,
-0.4131196141,
0.1609105319,
-0.4466810524,
0.1079740152,
-0.0041827457,
-0.6844552755,
-0.8708664775,
-0.4763244689,
0.0075041726,
0.5532288551,
-0.7255452275,
0.0187263396,
0.2136476338,
-0.3232756555,
-0.3130960166,
-1.0009715557,
0.0225345995,
0.1889008582,
-0.8413102031,
0.5707573295,
-0.1637863815,
-0.4462020695,
0.1965990663,
-0.1314910501,
-0.1891325861,
0.0276436247,
0.1954568774,
0.200775072,
-0.3025651574,
-0.031770397,
0.26670596,
0.171073541,
0.0942545682,
-0.1869054884,
0.3883371055,
-0.576050818,
0.0953887925,
-0.1899666041,
0.3593660295,
0.3216121495,
-0.1258911788,
0.5782489181,
0.4311892092,
-0.32828933,
0.1292711496,
-0.6911859512,
0.3095587194,
-0.5568411946,
0.3974926472,
-0.7392743826,
-1.1026390791,
0.581585288,
0.354855448,
0.0389305875,
0.7275174856,
0.867831409,
0.187239036,
0.9832714796,
0.7314063907,
0.2269997895,
0.1704820991,
-0.1158865988,
0.00961449,
-0.3547884524,
-0.5941041112,
-0.6291978955,
0.0369872041,
-0.7035222054,
-0.3376428187,
0.1681523174,
0.1175356656,
-0.2033195198,
0.4367128313,
-0.3831647336,
0.5736868382,
0.6830143332,
0.0504143201,
0.353762418,
-0.107292302,
-0.4535407722,
0.0814545304,
-0.3188251257,
-0.1820503026,
1.138736248,
0.2756632268,
0.075631611,
0.6171635389,
0.6331246495,
-0.0591225326,
0.6857113838,
-0.9044054151,
0.2113727778,
-0.3736121058,
-0.9249177575,
-0.0655524805,
0.0537044071,
-0.4582269192,
0.1798830181,
0.2363912612,
-0.6488922238,
-0.0004426353,
0.2348295748,
-0.3810238242,
0.0424138606,
-0.8196091652,
0.8987553716,
-0.36575526,
-0.2840551436,
-0.0990868583,
-0.5936262608,
0.6113026738,
-0.2953130007,
0.1495456249,
-0.0613879152,
-0.3314408362,
0.6287939548,
-1.3030855656,
0.128544718,
-0.2674909532,
-0.2528778315,
0.4715650082,
0.1944827288,
0.6046051979,
0.5131038427,
-0.1442424655,
0.0317173898,
0.2071957141,
-0.2333757579,
-0.4061729014,
0.7817209959,
-0.8221469522,
-0.4565304518,
-0.6011603475,
-0.2157833278,
-0.209610194,
0.3039488196,
0.4122391939,
0.2778934538,
-0.5486009121,
0.0715335682,
0.1915937513,
0.1630126089,
0.5288391709,
0.6090103984,
-0.224106878,
-0.6272346377,
0.7935558558,
0.0896925628,
0.0531978533,
0.3792913854,
0.302289784,
-0.8596916795,
-0.4158968627,
-0.3723270893,
0.4020587504,
-0.2280459553,
-0.1641490906,
-0.4023621976,
0.0377407856,
-0.6872431636,
-0.3919087648,
-0.4968443811,
-0.6109839678,
-0.1655047387,
-0.5069093108,
0.7110423446,
1.0174585581,
-0.5256379247,
0.6268410087,
-0.4280160367,
0.6729041338,
0.5372580886,
0.6141610742,
-0.5348594189,
-0.3206342161,
-0.2295486927,
0.0313415043,
-0.118230857,
-1.136621356,
0.3028727472,
0.5856398344,
0.3387036324,
0.3457023203,
-0.5711245537,
0.5681120157,
-0.6565162539,
0.9825211763,
0.0883162767,
-0.5705537796,
0.567453444,
-0.4502275288,
0.0114587499,
0.770678699,
0.3081145287,
-0.1108056754,
-0.2910526991,
-0.747966826,
-0.5346031785,
0.5731398463,
0.0534258783,
-0.0339850634,
-0.6684421301,
0.326130569,
0.0645261407,
0.1641638577,
-0.5453398824,
-0.174104929,
-1.0976908207,
-0.2721860111,
0.0286305267,
-0.4992809296,
0.2998665273,
-0.612737,
0.8984081149,
-0.0763853416,
0.1344762146,
0.125747934,
-0.0048414404,
0.1033307165,
-0.1117937863,
0.6209853292,
0.2398593724,
-0.5894969106,
0.0169923957,
0.0203871056,
-1.0251671076,
0.1552084386,
0.2861937284,
0.0266843475,
0.2842792869,
-0.0339468606,
0.7770899534,
0.1382343471,
-0.585293293,
0.6867502928,
0.0075838566,
-0.7802787423,
-0.4557827711,
-0.1161765456,
0.0459221452,
0.2773059011,
0.0827011093,
-0.1418325901,
0.0778047293,
-0.6618259549,
0.3783384264,
0.5960050821,
-0.0530973412,
-0.4300293922,
0.8551732302,
0.1426292658,
-0.2049214393,
0.472753197,
-0.8543615341,
-0.6585305333,
0.4966498315,
0.8525263667,
1.0598666668,
-0.5045413375,
0.4679100811,
0.5428206921,
0.5177913904,
-0.6412721276,
0.9885947704,
-0.0317801721,
-0.8482756615,
-0.3714110553,
-0.6975604892,
-0.2988398075,
0.109269321,
-0.1372169107,
0.2859865725,
-0.7433529496,
0.077990301,
-0.5010277629,
0.3043907583,
-0.6785712242,
0.3125428259,
-0.4106942415,
0.7940729856,
-0.4640173912,
1.1676571369,
0.6134694219,
-0.5373588204,
-1.0633332729,
-0.4877248704,
0.3210826516,
-0.9738668799,
0.5795627236,
-0.1684025079,
-0.4199432135,
0.1728869081,
-0.3224278688,
-1.2695176601,
1.1391464472,
0.0265427139,
-0.2730382383,
-0.1742967963,
0.0876176059,
0.640658319,
0.0597084723,
0.1696438342,
0.8674666286,
0.6198002696,
0.2338949889,
-1.096450448,
-0.0168013051,
-0.5720469356,
0.1072697565,
0.100394465,
-0.640494585,
1.0494008064,
-0.2870083153,
-0.2641338706,
0.4220615625,
1.03036201,
0.0562672243,
-0.2896318138,
0.2001202106,
0.8697654605,
0.902987361,
-0.233902052,
0.9322103262,
-0.5694012642,
0.2896140516,
1.4307593107,
-0.150720939,
0.6236078739,
0.3523984849,
-0.2284651995,
0.6733731031,
0.5754053593,
-0.2533960938,
0.7356840968,
-0.0330055021,
-0.4437014759,
0.422562331,
0.1379849762,
-0.6250895262,
0.5187373757,
0.4270176291,
-0.1624927372,
-0.4352334142,
-0.2399498224,
0.5814391971,
-0.3030892909,
-0.0686265603,
0.4040607214,
-0.3520152271,
-0.7876622677,
0.6792820692,
0.422454834,
0.7392192483,
-0.1975256205,
0.202130124,
-0.411752522,
-0.0618436784,
-0.2277015448,
-0.7302454114,
0.5294687748,
0.3085747957,
-0.0636462271,
-0.0013777534,
0.2765308619,
-0.3627127409,
-0.5277882218,
0.1016704813,
0.7616355419,
0.2677152753,
-0.2935194671,
-0.4901829064,
-0.2556492388,
0.0491241775,
-0.3610293567,
-0.2394047379,
0.3897836804,
-0.1340390742,
0.2234524637,
0.6519559622,
0.2736159265,
0.3665457666,
0.2930551469,
0.4769386351,
-0.4202541709,
-0.5535691977,
-0.896689415,
0.1386378706,
0.2240082324,
-0.5470590591,
0.5755349398,
0.9563769698,
0.9481830001,
-0.0220553074,
0.9615414739,
-0.6401512623,
0.6986609697,
-0.253797859,
0.4978845716,
-0.5509067774,
-0.0069237971,
-0.4438048899,
-0.7935768962,
-0.4149575531,
0.7404557467,
0.2820323408,
-0.0290482268,
1.0830410719,
1.1794255972,
0.0489463285,
0.175074935,
-0.0038063494,
0.4989587367,
0.5636823177,
0.563105762,
0.4546098411,
-0.451736033,
0.6413827538,
-0.7064974904,
-0.5908882618,
0.0380194113,
-0.9858425856,
-0.7705460787,
-0.5892406106,
0.2084933221,
-0.3300094604,
0.2207532972,
0.970033586,
0.2400254011,
-0.695666194,
-0.1431111991,
-0.693651855,
0.0509747379,
0.0589430109,
-0.1513963044,
0.3168816566,
-0.103857398,
-0.6639462113,
0.6969138384,
0.1963089705,
0.3973744214,
-0.0685245022,
-0.2741526961,
0.0344922468,
-0.0136407772,
0.7056077123,
0.6016899943,
-0.6894926429,
-0.8441619873,
-0.1301554888,
0.0193595793,
0.1156999469,
0.4706136584,
-0.9462085366,
0.2144138962,
0.6738333106,
0.3813709021,
0.4856691658,
0.004150928,
0.4748148918,
-0.6088501811,
0.4480421543,
-0.1173959076,
0.3243122399,
0.3224603236,
-0.3885937333,
0.7772403359,
0.6562667489,
-0.4740943313,
-0.4157449305,
0.2549674809,
-1.0887185335,
-0.0787482411,
1.0778944492,
0.5470330715,
0.0027173492,
-0.2905709743,
-0.3549166918,
0.3452675045,
-0.3721529543,
0.3909191489,
0.859072566,
-0.397293061,
0.1208676547,
-0.696526289,
0.9182762504,
0.0273317359,
-0.5991773009,
-0.5137490034,
0.6299983859,
0.5810768604,
-0.1195808649,
1.1758929491,
-0.2452178746,
0.4807571471,
0.1330888718,
-0.1112517267,
-0.3305291831,
-0.6488497257,
0.0736504793,
0.223816365,
0.1924711764,
0.0694951043
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11217v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11217v2 | WeatherQA: Can Multimodal Language Models Reason about Severe Weather? | 2024-06-17T05:23:18 | 2024-06-24T03:55:30 | Chengqian Ma, Zhanxiang Hua, Alexandra Anderson-Frey, Vikram Iyer, Xin Liu, Lianhui Qin | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, physics.ao-ph | Severe convective weather events, such as hail, tornadoes, and thunderstorms,
often occur quickly yet cause significant damage, costing billions of dollars
every year. This highlights the importance of forecasting severe weather
threats hours in advance to better prepare meteorologists and residents in
at-risk areas. Can modern large foundation models perform such forecasting?
Existing weather benchmarks typically focus only on predicting time-series
changes in certain weather parameters (e.g., temperature, moisture) with
text-only features. In this work, we introduce WeatherQA, the first multimodal
dataset designed for machines to reason about complex combinations of weather
parameters (a.k.a., ingredients) and predict severe weather in real-world
scenarios. The dataset includes over 8,000 (multi-images, text) pairs for
diverse severe weather events. Each pair contains rich information crucial for
forecasting -- the images describe the ingredients capturing environmental
instability, surface observations, and radar reflectivity, and the text
contains forecast analyses written by human experts. With WeatherQA, we
evaluate state-of-the-art vision language models, including GPT4, Claude3.5,
Gemini-1.5, and a fine-tuned Llama3-based VLM, by designing two challenging
tasks: (1) multi-choice QA for predicting affected area and (2) classification
of the development potential of severe convection. These tasks require deep
understanding of domain knowledge (e.g., atmospheric dynamics) and complex
reasoning over multimodal data (e.g., interactions between weather parameters).
We show a substantial gap between the strongest VLM, GPT4o, and human
reasoning. Our comprehensive case study with meteorologists further reveals the
weaknesses of the models, suggesting that better training and data integration
are necessary to bridge this gap. WeatherQA link:
https://github.com/chengqianma/WeatherQA. | [
-0.4931147993,
-0.6567166448,
0.6935318112,
0.4979730248,
-0.1271256804,
-0.0400698781,
-0.0785550252,
-0.6002420187,
-0.2317693084,
0.4766846895,
-0.6973767877,
-0.3570042551,
-0.2967098653,
-0.1444372833,
-0.6131014228,
0.7211982012,
-0.2253720164,
-0.0320484564,
-0.3168614507,
0.0816112459,
-0.2321404964,
-0.7274212837,
-0.2227334529,
-0.3026722372,
0.5486840606,
0.3980621696,
1.0474355221,
0.1123482212,
0.3767757118,
0.2934259474,
0.0977604911,
0.3430789709,
-0.0334263928,
0.3549192846,
-0.1684660614,
-0.0806684121,
-0.1112605333,
-0.0744062364,
0.3845435679,
0.4633592069,
-0.2855195105,
0.0214665513,
-0.0777155384,
0.3387927711,
-0.6318969727,
0.0036131386,
-0.4711320102,
-0.0823235661,
-0.2330876291,
-0.0840717331,
-0.2188674212,
0.1672468334,
0.3225378394,
-0.335942328,
0.304168731,
0.0182896201,
0.7778247595,
0.4452900589,
-0.8370133042,
0.0471761115,
-0.8365610242,
0.8069791198,
-0.6218571067,
0.8230938911,
0.2437143028,
0.5191354752,
-0.4185608923,
-0.5597138405,
-0.7950205207,
0.0581822731,
0.3580315113,
0.1863834858,
-0.136373505,
-0.0689457655,
0.0571967922,
-0.0617305525,
-0.6735190153,
-0.0746656805,
-0.18648839,
-0.3430443108,
0.4228801429,
0.4147484899,
0.2074723542,
-0.349550873,
-0.6908590198,
-0.0522682779,
-0.5403637886,
0.4431173205,
0.0552552007,
0.3111474216,
-0.3669051528,
0.5046108961,
-0.266189456,
0.701239109,
-0.5892654061,
-0.2817403376,
0.0939041451,
-0.3005431592,
-0.5269290805,
-0.1863916963,
0.7359665036,
0.3416562974,
0.0387975536,
-0.1787692457,
-0.2506219745,
0.1679909974,
0.1466067582,
-0.6862874627,
-0.4184930921,
0.2831113338,
-0.1451550424,
-0.539010942,
-0.1889789104,
-0.7602782249,
-0.7355106473,
-0.687969625,
0.4469790459,
-0.2182160169,
-0.2754560709,
0.2073974013,
-0.2437055409,
-0.1559389383,
0.4806590378,
-0.3740830421,
0.1481764466,
0.2961209714,
0.4475479126,
0.2176165134,
-0.4673726261,
-0.3396655321,
-0.224049449,
-0.1601659656,
1.0201929808,
-0.7403873205,
-0.0150527721,
-0.2774578333,
-0.1044972762,
-0.0182350837,
-0.3791166842,
0.354357779,
-0.5290445685,
0.1345261633,
0.0385743566,
0.0544253774,
-0.4573566914,
0.3066799641,
-0.5597339272,
0.9572589397,
0.0999943092,
-0.6874463558,
0.2329817265,
-0.0896830112,
-0.354103893,
-0.2436896563,
-0.1282714307,
-0.3965336382,
-0.0097167501,
0.5922041535,
0.4846725464,
-0.8071139455,
0.5889620781,
-0.5523464084,
0.2004865557,
0.5618393421,
-0.7113611698,
0.4762054086,
0.2560533583,
-0.5571836233,
0.2837738991,
-0.8415259123,
0.2007402629,
0.0864535943,
-0.3104807436,
-0.1535112858,
0.0881190449,
0.4617007971,
0.5902381539,
0.030891655,
-0.1437319368,
-0.0058656433,
-0.1891409904,
0.4986758232,
0.7756222486,
-0.1235970929,
0.278065145,
-0.4279432595,
0.6981980205,
0.4164647162,
0.4190828502,
-0.0521292277,
-0.6926246285,
-0.7157434821,
-0.2293041199,
0.094048731,
0.6726318002,
-0.9078482985,
-0.422714889,
0.0008769197,
-0.7635840178,
-0.209496811,
0.1471334547,
0.3530434668,
0.407518059,
0.568638742,
0.3301570117,
-0.9945837259,
-0.6635295749,
-0.0029320654,
0.0934488773,
0.1745289862,
0.3094742894,
0.3648202419,
-0.4211181104,
0.8529722095,
-0.1878080964,
0.1175540611,
-0.2241854668,
0.0451561958,
0.3013896346,
0.1269091815,
0.6844930053,
-1.0742173195,
0.058398135,
-0.2189406306,
-0.6633188725,
-0.1545735747,
-0.0487607755,
-0.079429768,
0.0541646369,
0.1790141016,
-0.6580640674,
0.4570646584,
0.947306335,
-0.5981497765,
0.8091762662,
0.1136870682,
0.096780479,
-0.9002068639,
-0.1789085269,
0.2808863819,
-0.3484117091,
-0.5637745857,
0.2703129947,
-0.1402505487,
-0.3441775143,
-0.5504657626,
0.6801717281,
-0.1298316717,
0.1951229125,
-0.1058133394,
-0.2316659838,
0.2654244006,
0.3844120502,
-0.0499644428,
0.3450109959,
0.7056123018,
-0.6589010358,
0.726706624,
-0.0101172859,
-0.5030630231,
-0.0144254509,
-0.4505161941,
-0.0764834061,
-0.1069785431,
0.3013844788,
-0.7408509254,
-0.3708201349,
0.3436629176,
-0.268982023,
-0.23794204,
-0.0149018466,
-0.4268507659,
-0.2782487869,
-0.0519164428,
0.4506388605,
0.0433634818,
-0.5869380832,
0.9594271779,
0.2822708189,
-0.1394438446,
-0.5402494669,
-0.5618910789,
0.2136916369,
-0.0333266407,
-0.6779238582,
0.3899641931,
-0.2139113098,
-0.5187667012,
0.0369838588,
-0.2153774798,
-0.2751166821,
0.3643209934,
0.6903751493,
0.2128925025,
-0.2247162163,
0.2264930606,
-0.144340992,
0.0168951992,
0.0970547721,
-0.3212779462,
0.5086337328,
-0.1844085455,
-0.0185745824,
-0.2976218164,
0.4522156715,
0.8797494769,
-0.2923179269,
0.6821029186,
0.4698022902,
-0.8719460964,
-0.2239664346,
-0.5085180402,
-0.0330245756,
-0.3976548612,
0.0688595548,
-0.5684660673,
-0.492179662,
0.4012709558,
0.1175425276,
-0.1208001748,
0.3756603897,
0.4647917151,
-0.1732578427,
1.3392307758,
0.4837049544,
-0.0592877567,
0.2696028948,
-0.0974100158,
0.040452458,
-0.367033869,
-0.5034439564,
-0.4058515728,
-0.1487767994,
-0.1843035966,
-0.5622858405,
0.3651968837,
0.0510361977,
-0.3517816663,
-0.003421277,
-0.2615439892,
0.169334963,
0.5016732216,
0.3548690677,
0.0523211285,
-0.1718953401,
-0.2495054901,
0.0598760657,
-0.5511874557,
-0.3201738,
0.7594869733,
0.3444619179,
0.853199482,
0.2822296619,
0.2907222509,
0.1843545437,
0.1868115366,
-0.6609365344,
0.3704114258,
-0.0116708949,
-0.6932163239,
-0.1916169971,
-0.4696186483,
-0.6190378666,
0.2786672413,
-0.589117825,
-0.2543782592,
0.2813279331,
0.113163732,
-0.2714861631,
0.0816543326,
-0.6422612667,
0.9344008565,
-0.3902894557,
-0.0465688445,
-0.1500415206,
-0.4730286896,
0.2860477865,
-0.0364376418,
0.8449835777,
-0.2341475487,
0.1692566872,
0.5030134916,
-0.4493328929,
0.9444944263,
-0.2600063682,
-0.094285883,
0.2525420785,
0.1430493742,
0.363366574,
0.2455991358,
-0.1237573698,
-0.0037704112,
0.2197090089,
-0.4956492186,
-0.5797246695,
0.696923852,
-0.9591362476,
-0.49231264,
-0.406098187,
-0.4027117789,
-0.3806795776,
0.1714173704,
0.1891566515,
0.9039342403,
0.1333908141,
0.1370010823,
0.3434690535,
0.1033712998,
0.1768513769,
0.4633333385,
-0.4034831226,
-0.4194073081,
0.9496390224,
0.0597691201,
-0.1992736608,
0.4566479325,
0.5319210291,
-0.0652875304,
-0.6787678003,
-0.4135832787,
-0.1742452085,
-0.8149655461,
-0.4901081324,
-0.5879395008,
-0.1737680137,
-0.3125169575,
0.0225417633,
-0.1098750979,
-0.2968600392,
-0.280395776,
-0.0341083482,
0.1093680337,
0.6476120949,
0.265053004,
0.0081314668,
-0.9347008467,
0.4871189594,
0.4440861642,
0.0295944903,
-0.0572701059,
-0.2752158046,
-0.1437308639,
0.3367071748,
-0.3345411122,
-0.7782326937,
0.3953915238,
0.2380944341,
0.4602704048,
0.2995889187,
0.2639836073,
0.7494888902,
-0.2802159488,
0.7420784831,
0.1191539913,
-1.0587226152,
0.5877472758,
-0.2396693975,
0.3798969984,
-0.023622036,
0.2781300247,
-0.4310541153,
-0.4708500206,
-0.4004853666,
-0.7375500798,
0.4990163147,
0.1339901835,
-0.1103773415,
0.0726848319,
0.0401872396,
0.1526722014,
0.0351618938,
-0.5501663685,
0.0758303776,
-0.7491182685,
-0.2390726358,
-0.2308254987,
-0.2213458419,
-0.1783578545,
-0.1573742777,
0.5052153468,
-0.2330588549,
-0.0630738735,
0.2478938103,
0.0023794428,
-0.0118633062,
0.433054477,
0.8419167399,
0.6335558891,
-0.0544320717,
0.4896092117,
0.243811667,
-0.2469236851,
0.0680041909,
0.2952723503,
0.1284199953,
0.0009118191,
0.5346925259,
0.7546371818,
0.5136490464,
-0.9694870114,
0.6233001947,
-0.2721507847,
-0.2298312634,
-0.3084234893,
-0.089759253,
-0.0787548125,
0.6599495411,
0.4669462144,
0.6377564669,
0.283673197,
-0.6119274497,
-0.0941534489,
0.1684388071,
-0.3577445745,
-0.605594337,
0.7768704295,
0.2366046309,
0.2557501495,
0.6044982672,
0.1359155327,
-0.7271898389,
0.8136026263,
0.3945976794,
0.3780266941,
-0.1654365659,
0.1715672165,
-0.000463344,
0.4063670337,
-0.0151396338,
0.6977440715,
0.0863800347,
-0.9907702208,
-0.2921742499,
-0.752448678,
-0.5267677903,
0.2005962282,
-0.3003981709,
0.3258207738,
-0.6281341314,
-0.3210635483,
0.3060117066,
-0.4002250731,
-1.0327233076,
0.6816490889,
0.64597404,
0.9444090724,
-0.8057525158,
0.5775252581,
0.9227764606,
-0.1553373039,
-0.8674975634,
-0.1942969412,
0.262858361,
-0.5616674423,
0.5782037973,
0.2839222252,
-0.2323144674,
-0.268689692,
-0.6248806715,
-0.7506579161,
0.7934074998,
0.4475192428,
-0.6063776016,
-0.3112523258,
-0.0350808278,
0.2678500712,
-0.1501420438,
0.0648183972,
0.1069080606,
0.6016302109,
0.0148555981,
-0.9016919136,
0.131339401,
-0.3593423963,
-0.2162170708,
0.3718263805,
-0.3389399946,
0.8390854001,
-0.5713809729,
-0.22483702,
0.0392393805,
0.4075022638,
-0.0526268706,
0.7692011595,
0.6274020672,
0.6677874327,
0.5687354207,
-0.1813702285,
0.994966507,
-0.0803670585,
0.1471640468,
0.9798582792,
-0.1449500918,
0.8571421504,
0.3439084291,
-0.1895708591,
0.6864693165,
0.6890061498,
0.2816262543,
0.7006926537,
-0.1385834962,
-0.3503980935,
-0.9490633011,
-0.2197321355,
-0.4168487787,
0.6889833808,
0.5571213365,
-0.0472874865,
-0.2012317628,
0.4692145884,
-0.1485314369,
-0.130906716,
-0.2113242596,
0.5194125772,
0.1693044007,
-0.4609541297,
0.553573072,
0.1688230783,
0.2411507964,
-0.4022336006,
0.0944271013,
0.1399693489,
0.1630623043,
-0.5018652678,
-0.8889899254,
0.1907383949,
-0.1884580702,
-0.4160209596,
-0.0712048188,
0.4095944464,
-0.1345046908,
-0.4526736736,
0.2093953192,
0.4644743502,
-0.1262354553,
-0.53558743,
-0.5401964188,
0.0315044113,
-0.2135603577,
-0.3479696512,
0.162889719,
0.4976368248,
-0.345261842,
0.8506753445,
0.8911118507,
-0.2374799103,
0.104552418,
0.4190598726,
1.1882926226,
-0.9037115574,
-0.2981171906,
-0.7048007846,
0.546225369,
0.3458071351,
-0.3225024641,
0.2642408013,
0.347579062,
0.4324760735,
0.0124011552,
0.8560031056,
0.1439977139,
0.2775559723,
-0.7172734737,
0.2061687261,
-0.6679053903,
-0.0086393058,
-0.1054117307,
-0.7756726146,
-0.376752913,
0.0494104326,
-0.2105087489,
-0.3008471727,
0.5484493971,
0.5173531175,
0.1148941293,
0.1404762119,
0.2023349255,
0.2552914619,
0.5271220207,
0.6555851102,
1.1841248274,
-0.3262080848,
0.9499530792,
-0.4084768295,
-0.3220182359,
-0.2274979949,
-0.7930768132,
-0.9043054581,
-0.8480802178,
-0.0987176448,
-0.4128486514,
-0.0001599175,
1.0257254839,
0.6947513223,
-0.7364574671,
0.3192764521,
-0.0221794732,
0.2089587897,
-0.2237361372,
-0.2326654941,
0.007513592,
-0.1204433292,
-0.3341505527,
0.6136617661,
0.19701989,
0.2262064517,
-0.1914160252,
0.0454506055,
0.273352772,
0.163010478,
0.6823489666,
0.0279901326,
-0.9245172739,
-0.2499294132,
0.0481285825,
-0.3118958771,
-0.2904832065,
0.6107128263,
-1.0658807755,
0.4874097109,
0.5210297704,
0.4274983108,
0.3143353462,
-0.2761362493,
0.4108029008,
-0.6277232766,
0.0787974969,
0.2372203618,
0.5359280109,
0.4271008372,
-0.2298704237,
0.0544270203,
0.3463132083,
-0.4448059201,
-0.7747536302,
0.1795649081,
-1.0107609034,
-0.3782539964,
1.0152720213,
0.1358282119,
-0.1497070193,
-0.2754697204,
-0.4087971151,
-0.0940101594,
-0.3556932211,
0.8198065162,
0.8274991512,
0.0703342035,
-0.5339186788,
-0.4368416965,
0.4094523787,
0.1319819689,
-0.6578409076,
-0.0127471825,
0.4035201073,
0.2498386204,
0.1202535555,
0.2086930126,
0.2934184372,
0.5317063332,
-0.1124137864,
-0.0591384917,
-0.1889051944,
-0.8746060729,
0.1101661399,
0.2214367539,
0.0420051627,
0.0395025685
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11214v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11214v1 | Global Data Constraints: Ethical and Effectiveness Challenges in Large Language Model | 2024-06-17T05:13:25 | 2024-06-17T05:13:25 | Jin Yang, Zhiqiang Wang, Yanbin Lin, Zunduo Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL | The efficacy and ethical integrity of large language models (LLMs) are
profoundly influenced by the diversity and quality of their training datasets.
However, the global landscape of data accessibility presents significant
challenges, particularly in regions with stringent data privacy laws or limited
open-source information. This paper examines the multifaceted challenges
associated with acquiring high-quality training data for LLMs, focusing on data
scarcity, bias, and low-quality content across various linguistic contexts. We
highlight the technical and ethical implications of relying on publicly
available but potentially biased or irrelevant data sources, which can lead to
the generation of biased or hallucinatory content by LLMs. Through a series of
evaluations using GPT-4 and GPT-4o, we demonstrate how these data constraints
adversely affect model performance and ethical alignment. We propose and
validate several mitigation strategies designed to enhance data quality and
model robustness, including advanced data filtering techniques and ethical data
collection practices. Our findings underscore the need for a proactive approach
in developing LLMs that considers both the effectiveness and ethical
implications of data constraints, aiming to foster the creation of more
reliable and universally applicable AI systems. | [
-0.0832760558,
-0.6069164872,
0.5693533421,
-0.2116203606,
0.0066144611,
0.0945367739,
-0.33510077,
-0.7111031413,
-0.5167658329,
0.7209991217,
-0.4468012452,
-0.3991658092,
-0.735950768,
0.0823960677,
-0.1817480922,
1.0358353853,
-0.1202839911,
0.2860052288,
-0.3187815249,
-0.3673816323,
-0.3820017576,
-1.0176877975,
-0.4429794252,
-0.2109453231,
0.2792482674,
0.4421097934,
0.9679027796,
0.8824524879,
0.5687410235,
0.2264489532,
-0.1158020943,
0.0365753025,
-0.6760479808,
0.1119291931,
-0.2418543249,
-0.4927068353,
-0.3716979325,
0.1931294948,
0.7190334797,
0.5984786749,
-0.1458458751,
0.2068384588,
0.0556288511,
0.4830822647,
-0.5754054189,
0.024370091,
-0.5787913203,
-0.0144047923,
-0.3707414269,
0.067336753,
0.005480451,
-0.6041361094,
0.1389559954,
-0.5688101053,
0.0947097912,
-0.0382165574,
0.8538614511,
0.3725112379,
-0.5328971744,
-0.6533995867,
-0.9024451971,
0.9611209631,
-0.6667721272,
0.4911909699,
0.6868507862,
0.1285052001,
-0.0841320232,
-0.3968284726,
-0.415276587,
-0.1594873369,
0.1838994622,
-0.2683876753,
0.1567958295,
-0.0571371615,
0.3458545208,
0.3474937081,
-0.2537095845,
0.4221255481,
-0.3392112255,
-0.235102728,
0.7086808681,
0.1565561891,
0.2597835362,
-0.082709454,
0.0328975022,
0.1548195183,
-1.1097639799,
-0.0672712624,
0.9424384236,
0.274007678,
-0.1092107221,
0.5629921556,
0.0473154001,
0.378828913,
-0.4496411085,
-0.1247495636,
0.1698756814,
-0.4835104048,
0.0951697379,
-0.2517439723,
0.5208944678,
0.091863893,
0.4516156912,
-0.0958281904,
-0.1964928061,
-0.2249653935,
0.1598148048,
-0.5141349435,
0.1914597154,
0.3455222547,
-0.3351591825,
-0.1817857325,
-0.0035107373,
-0.7468552589,
-0.4680419862,
-0.5678053498,
0.2824288607,
-0.1891771406,
-0.2137118876,
0.0281590465,
0.1761321425,
0.2645929158,
0.2231417,
-0.9499818087,
0.0955830663,
0.7530554533,
0.6765770316,
0.0701899827,
-0.0725736767,
-0.5507949591,
0.398565948,
-0.2112545371,
-0.0837769583,
-0.7317480445,
-0.4071555436,
-0.0278660301,
-0.012560484,
0.1894696504,
-0.6495047212,
0.6728565097,
-0.2977537811,
0.0702440143,
-0.4922634363,
-0.5222026706,
0.0943457857,
0.1813401431,
-0.6455562711,
0.7360405326,
0.0019833005,
-0.7233808041,
0.3649688661,
-0.5409455299,
-0.3877958357,
0.0755636767,
-0.583896935,
-0.4381701648,
0.1153662577,
0.3055574298,
0.4542669952,
-0.4150934517,
0.6567611694,
-0.2883363962,
-0.1789480597,
0.2235574275,
-0.7190975547,
0.9769043326,
0.1897034049,
-0.4268946946,
-0.0467552692,
-0.9204745889,
-0.1802708954,
0.329285562,
-0.3238145411,
-0.3848317266,
0.2235267162,
-0.0376948155,
0.1903505623,
0.0143609634,
-0.4507919252,
0.035968937,
0.0087996908,
0.694807291,
1.0294215679,
-0.0513549447,
0.1955877095,
-0.319704324,
0.5650587082,
-0.2830321193,
0.5409308672,
0.2433635592,
-0.2841126621,
-0.3393440545,
-0.1593806297,
0.2269866616,
0.62669909,
-0.553237915,
0.4214890003,
-0.3951359689,
-0.3116050065,
-0.7581250668,
0.2873367965,
0.249354139,
0.4572847188,
0.0815904737,
-0.0367074274,
-0.2188565433,
-1.0543987751,
-0.1396671236,
0.0194297545,
-0.0392124988,
0.5509793758,
0.7757267952,
-0.1262452602,
0.8097004294,
0.1094239578,
-0.2934211493,
-0.2003185749,
-0.2078702599,
0.0123537602,
0.8134892583,
0.2286580652,
-0.9074479342,
0.0104595898,
-0.0041246582,
-0.9848681092,
0.0570274293,
-0.0740280449,
-0.0363100097,
0.1317479759,
0.3127921522,
-0.5597498417,
0.3307002485,
0.6409195065,
0.0052412911,
0.4158751369,
-0.0968366936,
0.1282867789,
-0.8172911406,
0.2083265781,
-0.1162230894,
-0.0494646728,
-0.6306835413,
0.1986025423,
-0.0105867041,
-0.1216460317,
-0.4603806734,
0.4475546479,
-0.4392995536,
-0.099372074,
0.0724209398,
-0.0414939523,
-0.1325545609,
0.0063246451,
-0.0513021909,
0.7855476141,
0.4804552495,
-0.4832194448,
0.3612145782,
0.4304429889,
-0.5189327598,
0.6965284944,
-0.5422485471,
0.2483679205,
-0.2098996341,
0.2714816034,
-0.1526559591,
-0.4858257473,
0.2830064595,
-0.2605706155,
0.3204866946,
-0.2331920713,
-0.7221737504,
-0.0356337801,
-0.2178768814,
0.6092364788,
0.4558279514,
-0.5140239,
0.29713732,
0.5257921815,
-0.2251912802,
-0.9983716607,
-0.6961974502,
0.2921348512,
-0.4040560722,
-0.6723501682,
0.0490590371,
0.1182219908,
-0.3912123442,
-0.0698561072,
-0.078227222,
0.0938944891,
0.3935614824,
0.0200308654,
0.0782529116,
0.1013250872,
-0.0859423727,
-0.1602754146,
0.0973931253,
0.270218879,
-0.2399155945,
0.3398537338,
0.1218729168,
-0.5564540625,
-0.5374846458,
0.4168919027,
0.4639686644,
-0.1764851958,
0.708548665,
0.3837895095,
-0.5942403674,
-0.1619650424,
-0.6141619682,
-0.1573510021,
-0.4799000025,
0.4516201615,
-0.0732776523,
-1.0619257689,
0.4791535139,
0.1591080576,
0.0912977979,
0.1030274481,
0.5253736377,
0.0991957709,
0.9138128161,
0.5893152356,
-0.2645632923,
0.3186573982,
-0.1079893261,
0.2512376308,
-0.8704971075,
-0.4104357064,
-0.7000565529,
-0.0781632513,
-0.6042792797,
-0.3029319048,
0.3861876726,
0.0141293453,
-0.3844286501,
-0.337059021,
-0.3941933811,
0.6335436106,
0.6627857685,
0.0675507784,
0.5604382753,
0.0109843351,
0.1273338944,
-0.1713163555,
-0.5869827271,
-0.8220126629,
1.2233222723,
0.57992208,
0.8818839192,
0.1548534036,
0.4399746954,
0.0627027154,
0.0587047711,
-0.4112031758,
0.3239523768,
-0.025829982,
-0.9964337945,
-0.3822621405,
-0.747684896,
-0.874471426,
-0.0167355351,
-0.0737758949,
-0.9145120382,
0.166188091,
0.0311464109,
-0.1097758636,
0.4144283533,
-0.4597170353,
0.6974448562,
-0.6810988188,
-0.671820581,
-0.0555828325,
-0.9181819558,
0.3435302079,
-0.2979395092,
0.5167574286,
-0.3726163805,
0.0033861115,
0.5685997605,
-0.3492551446,
0.8799880743,
-0.1862045676,
-0.3338252902,
0.1770892292,
-0.1531042308,
0.6603087187,
0.254316777,
-0.168296665,
0.5369748473,
-0.1653250307,
-0.4959197044,
-0.1728879809,
0.6193874478,
-0.9393586516,
-0.7119112015,
-0.357396692,
-0.6858798862,
-0.6069782376,
0.1588148624,
0.3435432315,
0.313957721,
-0.1612381339,
0.2749934196,
0.6547208428,
-0.6293173432,
0.0672947764,
0.3039886951,
0.1902008355,
-0.3324040174,
1.0326434374,
0.3619782031,
0.5550318956,
-0.0994114727,
0.1161514297,
-0.3293228149,
-0.9510535002,
-0.4487294853,
0.2541361749,
-0.7490110993,
0.093170546,
-0.3217110038,
-0.3463812172,
-0.4009411037,
-0.0784383491,
-0.3403458595,
-0.1695096046,
-0.3945885003,
-0.1312831044,
0.3095483482,
0.8063228726,
-0.1583648622,
0.0832664818,
-0.6813634634,
0.0777381212,
-0.1092409194,
0.5572962761,
-0.1735708416,
-0.381788373,
-0.1868109256,
0.1398758292,
-0.1290150583,
-0.4062322974,
0.120712176,
-0.0270107873,
0.6938902736,
0.0597290955,
-0.0391641445,
0.4325125515,
-0.4203578532,
0.7473754287,
-0.2135639489,
-1.0139701366,
0.493814975,
-0.6862186193,
-0.0523531176,
0.5800817609,
0.599058032,
-0.4276746511,
-0.6155301332,
-0.5094248652,
-1.0134146214,
0.721796453,
0.5216921568,
0.2448748797,
0.3820334971,
0.6638499498,
0.3193397522,
0.3899249136,
-0.7854638696,
0.0193349142,
0.000473592,
-0.3154712915,
0.0910950154,
0.0001614009,
-0.2733375728,
-0.1636668891,
0.752268672,
0.0573582947,
-0.1772516817,
0.0099655772,
-0.0922177806,
0.0475296006,
0.3925645053,
0.464845866,
0.7859450579,
-0.0405031741,
-0.2364696264,
0.010115956,
-0.5054423213,
0.3292309344,
0.0581575036,
-0.4469490647,
-0.3280507326,
0.3337094784,
0.5614514947,
-0.1283552051,
-0.7201423049,
0.375095576,
0.0902985185,
-0.0812438577,
-0.2956227362,
0.0328165926,
-0.0201633107,
0.0837143511,
0.2327762693,
-0.3548148572,
-0.2013459951,
-0.4244611859,
0.0281267408,
0.6257460713,
0.0724300444,
-0.1169135049,
0.8757092953,
0.1807112992,
-0.0427510142,
0.9079404473,
0.2032661289,
-0.2565279305,
0.6891938448,
0.3596631587,
0.3426626921,
-0.2809212804,
0.0805940628,
0.0170504209,
0.6692350507,
-0.3633768559,
0.3192440271,
0.2947240472,
-0.7398047447,
-0.4403000474,
-0.2751365006,
-0.7695608735,
0.4498802722,
-0.6888845563,
0.1037904695,
-0.5489410758,
-0.0752844736,
-0.3663404882,
-0.0438429452,
-0.6963461637,
0.0372717045,
0.1226260066,
0.4551081061,
-0.5904785395,
0.7885922194,
0.2217812687,
-0.3662866652,
-0.6082196832,
-0.086081408,
0.3366768062,
-1.0376267433,
0.4422611296,
0.0813212469,
0.1058526859,
-0.0760640055,
-0.7498636246,
-0.9694362283,
0.8388748765,
0.8351659775,
-0.528014183,
-0.089736104,
0.6063730121,
0.3422709405,
-0.0268980898,
-0.2256394625,
0.7371670604,
0.6104839444,
-0.1538259089,
-0.869240284,
0.0715866238,
0.0379398242,
-0.1361274123,
0.1447732896,
-0.7991127372,
0.6760627031,
-0.0624743216,
-0.1709482968,
0.0246097501,
0.1961651742,
0.2017313838,
0.2165747136,
0.1623821855,
0.4015360773,
1.0644266605,
-0.0798431113,
1.0653924942,
-0.114250049,
0.2907109261,
0.9311887026,
-0.6948479414,
0.4840410352,
0.3635142446,
-0.0450542606,
-0.1733407825,
0.6377950907,
-0.302626729,
0.18079561,
0.4207176268,
-0.2436252534,
0.0607082695,
-0.5429679155,
-0.415807724,
0.4957840443,
0.5932270288,
-0.1899124682,
0.0076371063,
0.0389387235,
0.1609838903,
-0.042559769,
-0.2958157063,
0.4752296805,
-0.0040886169,
-0.3249543905,
0.2612594664,
-0.0519743823,
0.5716254711,
-0.4535839558,
0.0647173598,
-0.1668314487,
0.0263545793,
-0.3399788141,
-0.5819583535,
0.3563026786,
0.2813669443,
0.0991385356,
-0.2025306672,
0.3992217481,
-0.2622907758,
-0.4734233022,
0.2263344079,
0.6975570917,
0.1369193792,
0.0953690037,
-0.6019436121,
0.4848749936,
-0.1608713269,
-0.2690820992,
0.4843789637,
0.3889906108,
-0.1993251145,
0.8296903372,
0.6245281696,
0.3866686821,
-0.076172024,
0.0147395609,
0.5619068742,
-0.5532103181,
-0.2029298991,
-0.9920625687,
0.2022967041,
-0.0343127064,
-0.3687326908,
0.5510676503,
0.4091444314,
0.989078939,
0.4553623796,
1.1373033524,
0.1103355438,
0.3427964449,
-0.7645839453,
0.8380141258,
-0.4674953222,
0.5148179531,
-0.067657873,
-0.7992411852,
-0.3990568817,
0.5239694118,
-0.2562378049,
0.323546201,
0.3599860072,
0.6040946841,
-0.0277514607,
0.1062834635,
0.1938899159,
0.2081002593,
0.6214497685,
0.5474023819,
0.9175764918,
-0.0243253578,
0.5405473709,
-0.2703484297,
-0.0947204903,
0.1611297131,
-0.9373903871,
-0.7106689811,
-0.3967607021,
-0.2123714834,
-0.3368113935,
0.195051074,
1.0035096407,
0.7713228464,
-0.7310035229,
-0.2646752,
-0.0451355502,
0.273491323,
0.1913381517,
-0.1960978061,
0.3691715598,
-0.0160858855,
-0.7396575212,
0.2414621115,
0.0827235654,
0.2068635076,
-0.3374973834,
-0.1147394478,
0.0659542233,
-0.0045034634,
0.3116720319,
0.3633592427,
-0.6735725999,
-0.5584427118,
-0.2611704767,
-0.0582666844,
0.0447236151,
0.8816634417,
-0.2153682411,
0.1806017905,
-0.0448657759,
1.0982154608,
0.020319704,
0.0244259071,
0.7980443835,
-0.6670953035,
0.0887594074,
0.6435238123,
0.2843876183,
0.549919188,
-0.5791156292,
0.66789186,
0.194369778,
-0.8422515988,
-1.0687628984,
0.3247309625,
-0.5189029574,
-0.1967510283,
1.3392577171,
-0.0854272842,
0.1113125458,
-0.4153887928,
0.0513849892,
0.1610365361,
-0.255077064,
0.7484462857,
0.9990544915,
-0.1446465105,
-0.0661440045,
-1.2654731274,
0.4793169498,
0.3388126791,
-1.0008904934,
0.4324413538,
0.8133718371,
0.3639353812,
-0.4260200262,
0.433791846,
-0.3345800638,
-0.0252915826,
-0.2440480441,
-0.0889961347,
-0.0159485471,
-0.2529833913,
-0.5845074058,
0.0435344465,
0.0304864869,
0.1658765376
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11201v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11201v2 | Fine-Tuning or Fine-Failing? Debunking Performance Myths in Large Language Models | 2024-06-17T04:35:17 | 2024-06-30T14:42:52 | Scott Barnett, Zac Brannelly, Stefanus Kurniawan, Sheng Wong | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs) have the unique capability to understand and
generate human-like text from input queries. When fine-tuned, these models show
enhanced performance on domain-specific queries. OpenAI highlights the process
of fine-tuning, stating: "To fine-tune a model, you are required to provide at
least 10 examples. We typically see clear improvements from fine-tuning on 50
to 100 training examples, but the right number varies greatly based on the
exact use case." This study extends this concept to the integration of LLMs
within Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) pipelines, which aim to improve
accuracy and relevance by leveraging external corpus data for information
retrieval. However, RAG's promise of delivering optimal responses often falls
short in complex query scenarios. This study aims to specifically examine the
effects of fine-tuning LLMs on their ability to extract and integrate
contextual data to enhance the performance of RAG systems across multiple
domains. We evaluate the impact of fine-tuning on the LLMs' capacity for data
extraction and contextual understanding by comparing the accuracy and
completeness of fine-tuned models against baseline performances across datasets
from multiple domains. Our findings indicate that fine-tuning resulted in a
decline in performance compared to the baseline models, contrary to the
improvements observed in standalone LLM applications as suggested by OpenAI.
This study highlights the need for vigorous investigation and validation of
fine-tuned models for domain-specific tasks. | [
-0.6966617703,
-0.8438193202,
0.5010921955,
-0.0917165279,
-0.3247233629,
-0.0603707545,
-0.5009127855,
-0.6488294601,
-0.2334928513,
0.6551072598,
-0.3956486881,
-0.3996909559,
-0.574549675,
0.1362912804,
-0.3358142078,
1.0555950403,
-0.0104585486,
-0.0066786739,
-0.176996991,
-0.2109152675,
-0.8525806665,
-0.3526098728,
-0.7528057694,
-0.3981356919,
0.5472717285,
0.5322627425,
0.6173586249,
0.7270674706,
0.5801824927,
0.2160102427,
-0.275134027,
0.8513837457,
-0.9093247056,
0.2192088813,
-0.5166543722,
-0.4885619283,
-0.4884774685,
-0.0311130118,
0.6973023415,
0.7935768366,
0.0581785738,
0.3882484436,
0.4148276746,
0.7387079597,
-0.8814461827,
0.1044512689,
-0.986770153,
-0.3140719831,
-0.3101331592,
-0.544692874,
-0.2819162607,
-0.0849248022,
-0.0126355244,
-0.4817438722,
0.3495883942,
0.219549194,
0.9643337131,
0.5170229077,
-0.2716192603,
-0.3344763815,
-0.9008983374,
0.8288873434,
-0.6869602203,
0.2045656145,
0.3340035975,
0.2823930383,
-0.2895658612,
-0.4873306453,
-0.4020584822,
-0.0217248145,
-0.1811410636,
-0.1488897055,
0.017234331,
-0.0082746046,
0.4039538801,
0.4182174504,
-0.2513608634,
0.5099244714,
-0.2863466144,
0.1607370377,
0.506824553,
0.4818770289,
0.0476339832,
-0.0719997659,
0.0225407947,
0.0556973629,
-0.8750767708,
-0.0052783657,
0.1942075044,
0.8892620206,
0.0610783324,
0.6092956066,
-0.463601321,
0.8582963943,
0.1065276936,
-0.1608874202,
-0.0939775556,
-0.3851230145,
-0.4171594381,
-0.3143766224,
0.4242271781,
0.4080634713,
0.5252245069,
-0.2723613083,
-0.5539782643,
-0.0893570855,
0.2629726827,
-0.7963012457,
0.0320333764,
0.0921351165,
-0.3096294999,
-0.1560279429,
-0.0922543481,
-0.4288197756,
-0.395958662,
-0.8177579641,
0.4650853276,
-0.4009746015,
-0.0183696784,
0.1690164655,
-0.0462676361,
0.096316427,
0.42968449,
-0.8326755166,
0.3198803365,
1.0565469265,
0.7182115912,
-0.4833001792,
-0.270699501,
-0.7929869294,
0.1277490109,
-0.3846157193,
0.778167069,
-0.6083152294,
-0.251000762,
0.004252967,
0.0800057128,
-0.1984307915,
-1.0069528818,
0.7244508862,
-0.7442310452,
-0.3448289335,
-0.3044918478,
-0.6851983666,
0.0802293494,
0.1104530916,
-0.5318980217,
0.7783375382,
-0.0164654013,
-0.5182126164,
0.6211660504,
-0.477843523,
-0.4837979972,
-0.0048151198,
-0.0221513063,
-0.2953144014,
0.4087660909,
0.120795086,
0.7281415462,
-0.5875555873,
0.2638700306,
-0.3069907427,
-0.6033952832,
0.1299197674,
-0.2450524569,
0.3134545386,
0.4088789821,
-0.1368825585,
-0.0920861736,
-0.7515582442,
0.0980080068,
-0.0989713147,
-0.4825023115,
-0.5442128778,
0.0157640204,
0.166248396,
-0.0293983407,
0.1419934183,
-0.2905340493,
0.1650244296,
-0.4856756032,
0.2595498264,
0.6540727019,
-0.0492965542,
0.5501229763,
-0.4714840353,
0.3525669575,
-0.0006554172,
-0.168094933,
-0.1991793811,
-0.1604523361,
-0.7062388659,
-0.1052414253,
0.5220115781,
0.3143405914,
-0.4779640138,
0.0637853891,
-0.3378497064,
-0.3840518296,
-0.5436441898,
0.3583991528,
0.4367688298,
0.5310419202,
0.3403176963,
-0.2328543663,
-0.4860711694,
-0.9150645137,
-0.5801053047,
0.3623220921,
-0.1127076149,
0.6709823012,
0.4446748495,
-0.2685869038,
0.8807753921,
-0.4724310637,
-0.4245896041,
-0.1340845823,
0.0251297429,
0.2733108997,
0.4715820551,
0.4134147167,
-0.8356893659,
-0.5504800081,
0.315905422,
-0.4514299631,
-0.1384763718,
0.1113787591,
0.0000324705,
0.3558085561,
0.4132789075,
-0.4146283269,
0.2772729993,
0.4575380981,
-0.0800577402,
0.5532700419,
-0.290011853,
0.1691479981,
-0.8847836852,
0.2352944463,
0.0033628433,
-0.1445368677,
-0.5117996335,
0.2118130028,
0.1599636823,
0.0429381914,
-0.2770943046,
0.6772223115,
-0.4360377789,
-0.195456773,
-0.4295129478,
0.150099054,
-0.0038026413,
0.3035434783,
-0.3791590929,
1.0589780807,
0.3554955721,
-1.0236548185,
-0.1495187581,
0.0637390837,
-0.4992093146,
0.5622855425,
-0.6395195723,
0.0087068463,
-0.1220758632,
-0.141394347,
-0.7915924191,
-0.6008991599,
-0.2128338218,
-0.2051611692,
0.5842778087,
-0.2529014051,
-0.5906620622,
0.0429492034,
-0.057519298,
0.2942804992,
0.3127617836,
-0.5549977422,
0.3545728922,
0.4686101377,
0.0562715791,
-0.4509626329,
-0.5168072581,
-0.0051324246,
-0.3566407263,
-0.5854139924,
0.4506981671,
0.1649191231,
-0.2026124895,
-0.1892602146,
-0.2068267614,
-0.0592447147,
0.3003347516,
0.0930287465,
-0.0012570057,
-0.2946893573,
0.077165097,
0.067662254,
0.0023334115,
-0.2394251525,
-0.1599750668,
0.4821290374,
-0.0692964494,
-0.3321564198,
-0.3739018142,
0.1440033168,
0.6497814655,
-0.370429337,
0.8615620732,
0.4344441593,
-0.3459153771,
-0.3451210856,
-0.696810782,
-0.2192055732,
-0.4640550911,
0.192259714,
-0.609607935,
-1.0936260223,
0.6038303971,
-0.4330346286,
0.0244156178,
0.5022428632,
0.4065563381,
-0.2436567247,
1.1263229847,
0.7502882481,
0.0531748086,
0.4310017824,
-0.2336491346,
0.0650561005,
-1.1259818077,
-0.0448779538,
-0.7116031647,
-0.3861684799,
-0.8244616389,
-0.2835639119,
0.3683074713,
0.3804089427,
-0.3249938786,
0.0257343668,
-0.3072827458,
0.612962544,
0.3670540154,
0.0042441073,
0.4925871789,
0.1482493728,
0.0250978135,
0.0235246308,
-0.7179188132,
-0.6958784461,
0.9841926694,
0.2266876847,
0.9384608269,
0.1125449985,
0.3875304163,
-0.0031166533,
0.0213976689,
-0.7981000543,
0.3498645425,
-0.6635062099,
-0.5399355292,
-0.343606472,
-0.417888999,
-1.1643631458,
0.2026269436,
-0.1492594928,
-0.6898514032,
0.2527520359,
0.1980243772,
-0.4308330715,
0.2004505843,
-0.6461036205,
0.741748929,
-0.046906352,
-0.4749203324,
-0.2222195268,
-0.3251834512,
0.3345326781,
-0.3791677058,
0.1028643101,
-0.2085754722,
0.0243407022,
0.4482545257,
-0.1189455688,
0.8315720558,
-0.021040339,
-0.0695077628,
-0.0144304149,
0.1362846047,
0.5498290062,
0.0677206814,
-0.2831588387,
0.0674237609,
0.041410137,
-0.2327577919,
-0.4940316677,
0.9257277846,
-0.6526166797,
-0.6518511772,
0.0824954733,
-0.5673342347,
-0.4253263175,
0.2957829833,
0.0841252729,
0.5976681113,
-0.0360428467,
0.4816806018,
0.8550237417,
-0.1721688509,
0.1330524087,
0.5839831829,
-0.0107918484,
0.0384999476,
0.751092732,
0.3220209479,
0.3848592043,
0.2392361462,
0.0894043818,
-0.0180344135,
-0.8225657344,
-0.4392364323,
0.3029191196,
-0.4784932733,
-0.3811861873,
-0.4828386605,
-0.0533247776,
-0.3535481691,
0.0638523251,
-0.4588953853,
-0.1097749844,
-0.5695136189,
0.3351408243,
0.2687460184,
0.8091418743,
0.1319958568,
0.2765326798,
-0.7898618579,
0.3042005897,
-0.0159861688,
0.6474139094,
0.1155112535,
-0.786459744,
-0.583386004,
0.0957788825,
-0.2344179153,
-0.3541454673,
0.3407984972,
0.3891124427,
0.4940945506,
0.1115685701,
-0.084639363,
1.0328146219,
-0.6425615549,
0.5505614281,
-0.4229234755,
-0.6234481931,
0.5532513261,
-0.5512589216,
0.4580316246,
0.6706830263,
0.3013066053,
-0.3413223922,
-0.3233198524,
-0.2083905637,
-0.8677778244,
0.8120265007,
-0.0785156637,
0.1391831785,
0.1536163837,
0.8093799949,
0.1818224639,
0.080931358,
-0.0891010463,
-0.2414837927,
0.5689781904,
0.1283517927,
-0.2526320517,
-0.3226220906,
-0.175114274,
-0.300650239,
0.5425919294,
-0.342853874,
-0.1154600754,
-0.0315914415,
-0.119776465,
-0.3305718005,
0.1860625893,
0.6129060388,
0.9379044771,
-0.1748028547,
-0.1503717452,
0.3017220199,
-0.2181040496,
-0.3232377768,
-0.027803123,
-0.1718414873,
-0.1398568451,
0.2435105741,
0.9292199016,
0.3076863289,
-0.5674880147,
0.0688363761,
-0.1234818026,
0.1067651063,
-0.0198873933,
0.3668128252,
0.0260430295,
0.279048264,
0.4056074917,
0.2124947011,
0.2373351008,
-0.5473170877,
0.0898261368,
0.7066171765,
0.028207384,
-0.0619390495,
0.6181502342,
-0.0517406277,
-0.2840812802,
0.3426520526,
0.1372344643,
-0.1889268011,
0.5832127929,
0.4764472246,
0.6370527744,
0.1107234955,
-0.3016791642,
0.2912365198,
0.1466430128,
-0.2080711275,
0.0424305238,
0.0261098444,
-0.6893350482,
-0.721961081,
-1.0093766451,
-0.3948164582,
0.2916086912,
-0.7321344614,
0.4159443378,
-0.1405502856,
-0.1515188813,
0.0957618952,
0.1149026901,
-0.9877465367,
0.3034237027,
-0.0377244055,
0.989150703,
-0.558601141,
0.7773217559,
0.7511558533,
-0.1901178211,
-0.9362623692,
0.0905658007,
-0.3176000416,
-0.5885650516,
0.7759690285,
-0.0076987213,
-0.2185911685,
-0.0336812884,
-0.4623671472,
-0.9930163622,
0.9518515468,
0.4969642758,
-0.6057679653,
0.0465116128,
0.2582473755,
0.7280570269,
-0.5060443878,
0.0023161888,
0.9268260598,
0.3177221119,
-0.0039930642,
-1.3634257317,
-0.0944475383,
0.213249132,
0.2370135039,
0.264919281,
-0.5283352733,
0.8945398927,
-0.1048315987,
-0.3577265441,
0.1587236673,
0.3787974119,
0.105872646,
0.396176368,
0.3177808523,
0.5209056735,
0.8557706475,
-0.1037959084,
1.2549135685,
-0.3959963322,
0.3267000616,
1.2289389372,
-0.1218464375,
1.056012392,
0.380664885,
0.1303108931,
0.0259888824,
0.5831586719,
0.287065357,
0.4712665677,
0.0124520473,
-0.0241313837,
-0.2154080123,
-0.1667841822,
-0.2453362048,
0.6050007343,
0.5273082256,
-0.3407710791,
-0.1933713108,
0.0041437345,
-0.1931325197,
0.1128019094,
-0.4866040051,
0.8864699602,
0.1131326854,
-0.8693262339,
0.9724106789,
0.1053803042,
0.7880125642,
-0.2528930306,
0.0448117591,
-0.3278569579,
0.2943088114,
-0.3007014096,
-0.7331041694,
0.4837590158,
0.079192847,
-0.3224864006,
-0.1281154454,
0.8983212709,
-0.2749967575,
-0.0666334853,
0.2032759339,
0.6326498389,
0.1496780813,
-0.0916312933,
-0.5103410482,
0.370018065,
-0.1234975681,
-0.1830775887,
0.5859223604,
0.6962622404,
0.0119196447,
0.5303740501,
0.7000165582,
0.1728738844,
-0.2005330026,
0.1307318807,
0.941372335,
-0.436147809,
-0.0898168012,
-0.9402186871,
0.3770119846,
-0.0691557825,
-0.3411216438,
0.735789299,
0.5282336473,
1.071303606,
-0.051485464,
0.5250441432,
0.2324761599,
0.7662567496,
-0.592523396,
0.7485992312,
-0.9432600737,
0.4619358778,
-0.1024803445,
-0.8829779029,
-0.3485797048,
0.2651891112,
-0.3624477983,
0.0574817546,
0.3223128617,
0.9433494806,
-0.2906906605,
-0.1974203736,
0.4811578691,
0.3099599779,
0.2314865142,
0.1834304035,
0.5645834208,
-0.3816881478,
0.2587842643,
-0.0897889808,
-0.053047847,
-0.413289547,
-0.7452520132,
-0.7952840924,
-0.471364975,
-0.0009708101,
-0.1169747785,
0.257697165,
0.584053576,
0.6310144663,
-0.8675144315,
-0.2024463862,
0.0427881666,
0.1068349481,
0.1186142787,
-0.2259103358,
0.144881919,
-0.7741451263,
-0.9658998847,
0.3907754123,
0.2146711349,
-0.2321655154,
-0.1744193733,
0.1056462452,
-0.0601902977,
0.0427114144,
0.6787886024,
0.2100560814,
-0.7540026307,
-0.2908047438,
-0.0722290054,
-0.246229142,
-0.02122535,
0.7319881916,
-0.8036048412,
0.3439145684,
0.4082552195,
0.9464857578,
0.5006749034,
0.0567695238,
0.6261179447,
-0.7880623341,
-0.1412476748,
0.1241663769,
0.2047139555,
0.3278473914,
-0.3849895895,
0.6406268477,
-0.1893089712,
-0.9021468163,
-1.0783168077,
0.1792527437,
-0.6844633222,
-0.3658257127,
1.2588800192,
0.1611506641,
-0.1106022894,
-0.0952133164,
-0.2463296354,
0.1951497346,
-0.2438653409,
0.6658024788,
0.6209051013,
-0.3116522729,
0.2362717539,
-0.9903301001,
0.6930403709,
0.5844880342,
-0.538724184,
0.3005520403,
0.4361556768,
0.3750584424,
0.1224921867,
0.2721095085,
0.1452644318,
0.1364912242,
-0.4195826352,
-0.4942286909,
0.0567024983,
-0.2894378901,
-0.4498096108,
0.2555360794,
0.342174083,
0.1206324175
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11200v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11200v2 | AvaTaR: Optimizing LLM Agents for Tool-Assisted Knowledge Retrieval | 2024-06-17T04:20:02 | 2024-06-18T01:39:57 | Shirley Wu, Shiyu Zhao, Qian Huang, Kexin Huang, Michihiro Yasunaga, Kaidi Cao, Vassilis N. Ioannidis, Karthik Subbian, Jure Leskovec, James Zou | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Large language model (LLM) agents have demonstrated impressive capability in
utilizing external tools and knowledge to boost accuracy and reduce
hallucinations. However, developing the prompting techniques that make LLM
agents able to effectively use external tools and knowledge is a heuristic and
laborious task. Here, we introduce AvaTaR, a novel and automatic framework that
optimizes an LLM agent to effectively use the provided tools and improve its
performance on a given task/domain. During optimization, we design a comparator
module to iteratively provide insightful and holistic prompts to the LLM agent
via reasoning between positive and negative examples sampled from training
data. We demonstrate AvaTaR on four complex multimodal retrieval datasets
featuring textual, visual, and relational information. We find AvaTaR
consistently outperforms state-of-the-art approaches across all four
challenging tasks and exhibits strong generalization ability when applied to
novel cases, achieving an average relative improvement of 14% on the Hit@1
metric. Code and dataset are available at https://github.com/zou-group/avatar. | [
-0.3580720425,
-0.709143877,
0.6816587448,
-0.015876824,
-0.2519994378,
0.1996206492,
-0.1265243292,
-0.2874618769,
0.1335831583,
0.256403327,
-0.2879007757,
-0.620834589,
-0.4914110005,
0.1556918174,
-0.1585085243,
0.3625257909,
0.2656395733,
0.02433924,
-0.6125474572,
-0.237291649,
-0.5975618958,
-0.4127480388,
-0.8145176172,
-0.5505703688,
0.6586635709,
0.4521180093,
0.9389958382,
0.5459988713,
0.5781674385,
0.3838877678,
0.0999016762,
0.474550873,
-0.5317205787,
0.5038841963,
-0.2701687217,
-0.613240242,
-0.2166591883,
-0.3836233616,
0.3843373656,
0.2025406212,
-0.2376364917,
0.1296734214,
-0.2232138664,
0.4122342169,
-0.727707684,
0.3491293192,
-0.729934454,
0.091119349,
-0.0444652922,
-0.479345113,
-0.4741703868,
-0.2109567523,
-0.1335503012,
-0.8727571964,
0.0468484759,
0.3314707279,
0.6169541478,
0.5630573034,
-0.3318312764,
-0.0721410364,
-0.3925002515,
0.9112042189,
-0.3468589187,
0.5121837854,
0.3448797166,
0.4964037836,
-0.1982825249,
-0.5638331771,
-0.6820478439,
-0.5031908154,
0.074446559,
-0.1398159117,
-0.4613589942,
0.1688957959,
0.2976464927,
0.2839103937,
-0.4799129069,
0.0490787625,
-0.0011549253,
-0.4740401804,
0.5097175241,
0.2289310545,
0.3494435251,
-0.115739882,
-0.1252648085,
-0.4861631691,
-0.5765560865,
0.0579905324,
0.2501332462,
0.1631433368,
0.4005079269,
0.669978261,
-0.2742086947,
0.6873206496,
-0.057053104,
-0.3325381577,
0.43577829,
-0.1178872809,
0.0866259187,
-0.1112709343,
0.5476568341,
0.5045592785,
-0.0733745918,
-0.1915127933,
-0.6586002707,
0.1833010018,
0.4177688658,
-0.6252575517,
0.0900455788,
0.0969708487,
-0.3126434684,
-0.2325845659,
-0.2461610734,
-0.3840061128,
-0.5260574222,
-0.5138995647,
0.9427102804,
-0.3681362867,
-0.1643901914,
0.0752203241,
-0.3823505938,
0.2859576643,
0.5727216005,
-0.4787072241,
-0.0092163933,
0.6857689619,
0.6708006263,
-0.2957031727,
0.0437718928,
-1.0377036333,
0.0606432185,
-0.4328179955,
0.9312847257,
-0.80851686,
-0.2069739252,
-0.0427248403,
-0.3466700613,
0.2058165371,
-0.8157647848,
0.2111157328,
-0.7460429668,
-0.1803230196,
-0.196480751,
-0.2823067307,
-0.2658875883,
0.5113013983,
-0.6986025572,
1.0217405558,
0.169415012,
-0.2726984024,
0.3581354022,
-0.5763927102,
-0.2722074986,
0.1761828959,
-0.3846583664,
-0.1606537253,
0.0885900036,
0.5099947453,
0.4449225962,
-0.4538985491,
0.1520572901,
-0.1157326102,
-0.5907711983,
-0.2334721684,
-0.2136606574,
0.3993937075,
0.3644392192,
-0.1736202985,
0.3307493329,
-0.5004943013,
0.0089492947,
0.0900430158,
-0.4495685697,
-0.4329359829,
-0.2954467535,
-0.1295759529,
-0.1079980731,
0.32631585,
-0.3258074224,
0.4373653233,
-0.3305400312,
0.0414299853,
0.7422676682,
-0.0807411894,
0.2094528377,
-0.4760283828,
0.8260504603,
0.0745743886,
0.2483713627,
-0.1460732967,
-0.3306307793,
-0.6176524162,
-0.2834008038,
-0.0925635174,
0.4909167886,
-1.4455761909,
0.1907986253,
-0.1547680646,
-0.4613158107,
-0.664712131,
0.3438497186,
0.3521362543,
0.3683861196,
0.2602498829,
-0.4622975588,
-0.2896354198,
-0.8397755027,
-0.1739174873,
-0.3345412612,
0.0687235072,
0.572055161,
0.2832896411,
-0.4044267237,
0.8492040634,
-0.4024000466,
-0.3812958002,
-0.3516050875,
0.1035461277,
0.2898080349,
0.0395140983,
0.2888002396,
-0.8262881041,
-0.4052428007,
0.1827230304,
-0.9682308435,
-0.1268285066,
-0.147172913,
-0.223752901,
0.0108546466,
0.6321505904,
-0.7197721601,
0.3785728216,
-0.0454870686,
-0.2178067416,
0.6358036995,
-0.2166883498,
0.1139412299,
-0.8814972043,
0.135117352,
-0.1438722163,
-0.4678109884,
-0.3338949084,
0.3305228353,
-0.227285251,
0.0478462242,
-0.530267477,
0.8831381202,
-0.4279897511,
-0.0517996363,
-0.2962293923,
0.1062256172,
-0.0095249694,
0.5754778981,
-0.104588069,
1.0594496727,
0.7633914948,
-0.6132813692,
0.7448096275,
0.5348821878,
-0.4143635929,
0.7896503806,
-0.5344865322,
0.3911845982,
-0.5426371098,
-0.0658852607,
-0.5870082974,
-0.1717496365,
0.3341658413,
-0.2482384294,
0.0752375424,
0.0777138472,
-0.8172703385,
-0.1785775721,
-0.5018598437,
0.4681713581,
0.3861073852,
-0.7487663627,
1.0711340904,
0.3711553812,
0.0385097787,
-0.9958907366,
-0.0024068633,
0.3884767294,
-0.1133289561,
-0.4813644588,
0.2839668095,
-0.1586951017,
-0.541436851,
-0.1277861148,
-0.1393159777,
0.2013649791,
-0.1004498303,
0.0912797078,
0.067431733,
-0.1657494456,
0.4157934189,
0.0574931093,
-0.0100169601,
-0.0703268126,
-0.1448401511,
0.5076209903,
-0.1294841021,
-0.4923990369,
-0.2945269048,
0.1122663096,
0.3457141519,
-0.04527013,
0.4603132904,
0.6597572565,
-0.1694039553,
-0.1667474806,
-0.8639864326,
-0.3078301251,
-0.5308246017,
0.5421481729,
-0.6380791664,
-0.5537797213,
0.3354276717,
-0.1110029742,
0.0504998639,
0.0561458729,
0.5287009478,
0.413326025,
1.2660375834,
0.6243986487,
-0.2887321711,
0.6203939319,
-0.4304448068,
-0.0762602016,
-0.7124388218,
-0.2998720407,
-0.1619834304,
-0.1311527044,
-0.1254199296,
-0.6051884294,
0.7396872044,
-0.1517736912,
-0.2232023329,
0.1477395147,
-0.5606178641,
0.6549145579,
0.750682652,
0.3359894156,
0.5797083974,
0.0794703364,
-0.3577667475,
0.3210870922,
-0.7861337066,
-0.4728622735,
0.9926431179,
0.1908979267,
1.0774399042,
0.1496886313,
0.5109476447,
0.5224244595,
0.2687830329,
-1.0460540056,
0.7781947851,
0.1475331932,
-0.4681784511,
-0.3453905582,
-0.3298400342,
-1.0425310135,
0.44628793,
-0.0931353271,
-0.5192287564,
0.2403903157,
0.0728478059,
-0.3193363249,
0.0126709417,
-0.4432536364,
0.5333533287,
-0.24079597,
-0.4627877176,
-0.5571528673,
-0.5812527537,
-0.123424992,
-0.0973101556,
-0.0584309697,
-0.1025342345,
-0.239879787,
0.3807687163,
-0.2703347206,
0.5862406492,
-0.2529372275,
0.0160627607,
0.2263559699,
0.0315245539,
0.5325011015,
-0.0123689324,
-0.5159879923,
0.0296186041,
-0.0143487034,
-0.1789839119,
-0.8412889838,
0.4686974585,
-0.8751282692,
-0.9529289603,
-0.247825563,
-0.6685265899,
-0.1377651095,
0.2672842145,
0.0468710922,
0.5193710923,
-0.0894650966,
0.1928570569,
0.5589385629,
-0.4463391304,
0.0610311069,
0.4396138489,
-0.2799932063,
-0.2916036248,
1.1073828936,
-0.2133150399,
-0.0309663117,
0.6144670844,
0.0631953478,
-0.4514465928,
-0.3585950434,
-0.3587850034,
0.1979110688,
-1.2698326111,
-0.4571488202,
-0.6130980253,
-0.0236317776,
-0.3252430558,
0.0627270043,
-0.0539523251,
-0.1945790052,
-0.3659012616,
0.049348142,
0.3107881248,
0.70558393,
-0.1016200855,
0.3033789694,
-0.408990413,
0.5207563043,
0.4193660915,
0.1976942122,
0.1442140937,
-0.282188803,
-0.2771512866,
-0.3002214134,
-0.5212177634,
-0.4590895474,
0.5084481835,
0.3545739055,
0.8036540747,
0.4391154647,
0.1799180955,
0.6215538979,
-0.2474435568,
0.4699088335,
-0.0733030885,
-0.707901001,
0.6085304022,
-0.1516337693,
0.384342134,
0.5587205291,
0.2729139626,
-0.4220524132,
-0.5435467958,
-0.1817959398,
-0.9204447269,
0.6715968847,
0.2552580237,
0.2193081826,
0.0635779202,
0.494138211,
0.3950700462,
0.4644390941,
-0.5680891275,
-0.2535583675,
-0.0229540244,
-0.2428046912,
-0.0081881592,
-0.0086243954,
-0.1394991726,
-0.403979212,
0.7885599732,
-0.5342214108,
0.5306097865,
0.2044169009,
-0.4852977395,
-0.1070976853,
0.0002734048,
0.1695752591,
0.7357175946,
-0.0208794773,
0.2107929587,
0.1540122479,
-0.378067255,
0.230695948,
0.1551113874,
-0.0022001516,
-0.0182072688,
0.2552863359,
0.8245401978,
-0.1422150135,
-0.9265503883,
0.4823892117,
-0.3133883774,
0.0791184306,
-0.4400464594,
0.5465685129,
-0.2385330051,
0.6529419422,
0.6704079509,
-0.1189989448,
0.4129448831,
-0.4188455343,
0.2349236906,
0.794977963,
-0.0821562037,
-0.0642315596,
0.6566609144,
0.0640676841,
-0.5012152195,
0.6241472363,
-0.2854602635,
-0.3387373984,
0.4797462821,
0.3177961409,
0.613304019,
0.0084353834,
0.279695183,
0.1075879186,
0.0135541465,
-0.1761562675,
0.3506911695,
-0.289167881,
-0.802511394,
-0.3235146403,
-0.501773417,
-0.5812521577,
0.0660782084,
-0.3530155122,
0.5162772536,
-0.2483021319,
-0.3478600383,
0.0340116732,
0.0088462224,
-0.9762565494,
-0.0374516882,
0.074596405,
0.8358626962,
-0.2911048234,
0.5953300595,
0.8134061098,
-0.5063927174,
-0.6528714895,
-0.0960724205,
-0.0052250288,
-1.1667820215,
0.7356646061,
0.3845084906,
-0.3324436247,
0.179669112,
-0.6811049581,
-0.7964767814,
1.1600877047,
0.8308084011,
-0.5218596458,
-0.134927839,
0.1138584167,
0.5541937351,
-0.403145045,
0.632309258,
0.2933107615,
0.5716433525,
0.3383301795,
-0.858294487,
0.0689728111,
-0.5052053332,
0.1103296727,
-0.1103467867,
-0.5345718861,
0.3522608578,
-0.2908539772,
0.0537829474,
0.089169845,
0.4803343713,
0.2535970509,
0.5151397586,
0.7434895039,
0.4617856741,
0.827822268,
0.2337714434,
1.0518941879,
-0.2679925263,
-0.0476099141,
0.604622364,
-0.2093421668,
0.5897644758,
0.4585985243,
0.1787490398,
0.4926208258,
0.5627545714,
-0.0197473578,
0.4919433296,
0.0662208796,
-0.5234884024,
-0.6482400298,
-0.4506058991,
-0.0556161255,
0.4950439036,
0.2275072485,
-0.1906186789,
-0.1324881762,
0.4664002657,
-0.3519180119,
-0.1333272159,
-0.291869998,
1.0425063372,
0.1439745575,
-0.8004293442,
0.6790385246,
-0.2117681801,
0.6936241388,
-0.3297801018,
-0.3789103031,
-0.2504497766,
0.24954018,
-0.0127172917,
-0.4943394363,
-0.0262833945,
-0.3622443974,
0.0558027178,
-0.1356660575,
0.8377408981,
-0.2582951188,
-0.3438627422,
0.1913223565,
0.6699798703,
0.3558195531,
-0.3290876448,
-0.7762182355,
0.1295615882,
-0.1946576685,
-0.2666327059,
0.1674712747,
0.3380415142,
-0.2187938839,
1.2477511168,
0.5397845507,
0.0960039198,
-0.4490912557,
0.2288000286,
1.0376138687,
-0.6071789861,
-0.2685550749,
-0.7678698897,
0.2908914685,
-0.0469984226,
-0.0093236836,
0.569301188,
0.5164445639,
0.6565573812,
-0.0340097211,
0.634044826,
0.0717757791,
0.2774766982,
-0.3511987031,
0.5334765911,
-0.8923848867,
0.5582290292,
-0.0862649083,
-1.0759665966,
-0.3589443564,
0.796197772,
-0.1655520946,
0.1645622849,
0.3906308115,
1.2289267778,
0.0218516067,
-0.4210567176,
0.6194207072,
0.0739563555,
0.4865809977,
0.3219486773,
1.0420933962,
-0.1848757267,
0.629734695,
-0.0670605451,
-0.1126940995,
-0.4053227007,
-0.6670529842,
-0.9765967131,
-0.6688104272,
-0.3074057102,
-0.0993806571,
0.4377354085,
1.4221715927,
0.7676648498,
-0.390042305,
-0.2280454189,
0.2205909044,
0.4233901799,
-0.2219382524,
-0.2228570133,
0.100167416,
-0.5119386911,
-0.666696012,
0.5175385475,
0.2268747836,
-0.2528122365,
-0.3626809418,
-0.2190689445,
0.0562106073,
0.0776337609,
0.7583611012,
-0.0095977038,
-0.7484022379,
-0.3045678437,
0.1805940121,
-0.0199291762,
0.3451191783,
0.5743196011,
-1.2444634438,
0.7398860455,
0.3614059389,
0.5792273283,
0.2912288606,
0.0685226172,
0.6556672454,
-0.8520647883,
-0.0144159757,
0.4026709795,
0.145679906,
0.4679834247,
-0.7493060827,
0.5981158018,
0.0179511048,
-0.5599443913,
-0.9082947969,
0.003487041,
-0.7520330548,
-0.2065802962,
1.1974214315,
0.1879263073,
-0.2925928533,
-0.3317505717,
-0.6034232974,
0.1741293818,
-0.8906112313,
1.0083121061,
0.4192750454,
-0.3524563313,
-0.3201883435,
-0.3406693637,
0.4685148001,
0.3947513103,
-0.6959748864,
-0.1905082911,
0.6212522984,
0.1421787739,
0.1549430341,
0.6640381813,
0.167529732,
0.3802460432,
-0.1819846779,
0.1496444941,
-0.2667268217,
-0.3283038437,
-0.3009572923,
0.0508981533,
0.4304063618,
0.0865208358
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11194v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11194v1 | In-Context Editing: Learning Knowledge from Self-Induced Distributions | 2024-06-17T04:00:04 | 2024-06-17T04:00:04 | Siyuan Qi, Bangcheng Yang, Kailin Jiang, Xiaobo Wang, Jiaqi Li, Yifan Zhong, Yaodong Yang, Zilong Zheng | cs.CL | cs.CL | The existing fine-tuning paradigm for language models is brittle in knowledge
editing scenarios, where the model must incorporate new information without
extensive retraining. This brittleness often results in overfitting, reduced
performance, and unnatural language generation. To address this, we propose
Consistent In-Context Editing (ICE), a novel approach that leverages the
model's in-context learning capability to tune toward a contextual distribution
rather than a one-hot target. ICE introduces a straightforward optimization
framework that includes both a target and a procedure, enhancing the robustness
and effectiveness of gradient-based tuning methods. We provide analytical
insights into ICE across four critical aspects of knowledge editing: accuracy,
locality, generalization, and linguistic quality, showing its advantages.
Experimental results across four datasets confirm the effectiveness of ICE and
demonstrate its potential for continual editing, ensuring that updated
information is incorporated while preserving the integrity of the model. | [
-0.1427650303,
-0.8046540618,
0.3284109235,
0.1647336483,
-0.0763475522,
-0.0535404421,
-0.6209040284,
-0.193837449,
-0.2065069675,
0.3668805659,
-0.4213014841,
-0.4644270539,
-0.3740204275,
0.0895503387,
-0.3936286569,
1.2182701826,
-0.2346985042,
-0.0965702906,
-0.2825747132,
-0.3286802769,
-0.6664431691,
-0.2870886028,
-0.6873185635,
-0.0938749537,
0.2379502505,
0.6338422298,
0.8130093813,
1.1353945732,
0.2586866021,
0.2306319326,
-0.133462891,
0.301110208,
-0.6339832544,
0.1969381422,
-0.5807217956,
-0.2393088639,
-0.3637171388,
-0.0169779416,
0.9154683352,
0.6057956815,
-0.1827645004,
0.0459561795,
0.4206706583,
0.6585311294,
-0.8942448497,
-0.2660515904,
-0.9964215755,
-0.1861665547,
-0.3206100166,
-0.0579884574,
-0.3402728438,
-0.0970063135,
0.0603107549,
-0.6776698828,
0.1976311654,
-0.1751220822,
0.6067139506,
0.6803457141,
-0.2078826576,
-0.2947542667,
-0.5373262167,
0.7303390503,
-0.6230620146,
0.5442590117,
0.3932053149,
-0.050324969,
-0.1973740608,
-0.6129332185,
-0.5032936931,
0.2317835689,
0.0589254983,
-0.0810436308,
-0.0039472892,
0.0340081304,
-0.0884262621,
-0.0333574712,
-0.1336947232,
0.0843349323,
0.0021940202,
-0.0335103534,
0.5716847777,
0.079319723,
0.4159407318,
-0.0495665446,
-0.0977385938,
0.0952797681,
-0.8641015887,
0.0088762166,
0.1851930469,
0.2915880084,
-0.0045754928,
0.3654224873,
-0.2861431241,
0.958974421,
0.5447135568,
-0.2953098714,
0.037876375,
-0.0789353028,
-0.4200692177,
0.0518100001,
0.5666132569,
0.5515559316,
-0.077256836,
-0.3433323205,
-0.340344131,
-0.3206516504,
0.1068741381,
-0.4308412969,
-0.2646122873,
0.1431289017,
-0.2074343115,
-0.4978394806,
-0.221231699,
-0.5277668834,
-0.1915568411,
-0.4531398714,
0.3635567427,
-0.6516609788,
0.0698707178,
0.1190264374,
-0.2684370577,
-0.4123457372,
0.2199342102,
-1.2440310717,
0.1195209771,
0.6710784435,
0.7760607004,
-0.133334443,
-0.6691112518,
-0.586098671,
0.6095893979,
-0.5180442929,
0.7612537146,
-0.8025817275,
-0.1924413294,
-0.0395769067,
-0.3877983093,
0.0117166284,
-0.6473689079,
0.3138854206,
-0.5027517676,
-0.0968457907,
-0.185544461,
-0.9575018287,
0.266841054,
0.0621615611,
-0.2248919755,
1.1908739805,
0.3531518281,
-0.6374818087,
0.9887279272,
-0.7174187899,
-0.5257570148,
-0.1026078686,
0.1210198626,
-0.3286011815,
0.1911557168,
0.2392280251,
0.4400615096,
0.008202537,
0.5566404462,
-0.3122792244,
-0.0008541514,
0.131496489,
-0.0856750533,
0.4686328471,
0.370796293,
-0.2925615311,
0.0484990589,
-0.7734270096,
-0.1343986094,
-0.3693619072,
-0.5492580533,
-0.5953990817,
0.1185155287,
-0.0286694206,
0.1352509707,
0.1786312163,
-0.5726683736,
0.4978276789,
-0.2977271676,
0.5167788863,
0.9207135439,
0.2001799047,
0.9376339316,
-0.1059617102,
0.3022829592,
0.0412265621,
0.3351762295,
-0.0405881442,
-0.1857096106,
-0.4721979201,
-0.3223212957,
0.4570544362,
0.5066431761,
-0.8000133634,
0.3055939972,
-0.1568593532,
-0.4716100991,
-0.5310213566,
0.6883209944,
0.3450948596,
1.024289608,
0.4450719953,
-0.0176976174,
-0.3409388363,
-0.774977684,
-0.8036894202,
0.2098434865,
0.05525022,
0.2763290405,
0.2479314357,
-0.3711285889,
1.3910895586,
-0.4633818269,
-0.3181779981,
-0.1346346736,
0.1712041497,
-0.1365042031,
0.9010255337,
0.7175598145,
-0.5958561897,
-0.8930295706,
0.0970598012,
-0.9945552349,
-0.2264393568,
-0.2184964567,
-0.334634155,
0.07709793,
0.8066626787,
-0.2688422799,
0.206901893,
0.4456374049,
-0.2450897694,
0.2931631207,
-0.2301349193,
0.0114626689,
-1.0428638458,
-0.1306077242,
0.0085249459,
-0.1309520453,
-0.8773434758,
0.1677711308,
0.4837977886,
-0.0187747739,
-0.4068917632,
0.8296641111,
-0.2236014158,
0.5233048201,
-0.1016670763,
0.0288053956,
-0.135185197,
0.2649793029,
-0.135036841,
0.6934006214,
0.6918627024,
-0.6367972493,
0.0590824485,
0.2927756011,
-0.6557906866,
0.810598135,
-0.4807600677,
0.3217094541,
-0.4402189553,
0.1298679262,
-0.4693256319,
-0.3850975037,
0.2533116341,
-0.0737979412,
0.5306226611,
-0.364620477,
-0.4674091935,
0.4257861078,
-0.1251768768,
0.6129186749,
0.2328033894,
-0.7576875091,
0.3662576377,
0.5285012126,
-0.0003269008,
-0.7333242893,
-0.5309655666,
0.1299092919,
-0.4635536969,
-0.7695910335,
0.4938223958,
-0.3463422954,
-0.3888809383,
0.0854784772,
0.0483001955,
-0.178345561,
0.0785760805,
-0.2530451417,
-0.1548925638,
0.0815078914,
0.352817893,
0.6559564471,
0.0123065347,
-0.3520335853,
-0.5400992632,
-0.0579717755,
0.2525788546,
0.0416733213,
-0.4482539892,
0.3042628765,
0.3689189553,
-0.1677557379,
0.7244781852,
0.2268340588,
-0.405590415,
-0.3901794851,
-0.5419383049,
-0.1168456599,
-0.5260283351,
0.2249768525,
-0.6060826778,
-0.8795845509,
0.4438576102,
-0.2881337702,
0.1482560188,
0.3355405331,
0.1931467503,
-0.2957715988,
0.9845214486,
0.8592890501,
-0.2393366098,
0.7965618968,
-0.0063996459,
0.0259721503,
-1.0966243744,
0.1180967242,
-0.4475099146,
-0.2549043,
-0.4065788388,
-0.0504184812,
0.6447188258,
0.49832353,
-0.2445181012,
0.126221776,
-0.28487131,
0.7684231997,
0.4259368181,
0.1654664576,
0.0438602567,
-0.1096031815,
-0.1641858816,
-0.1877214015,
-1.0521738529,
-0.276720345,
1.1646791697,
0.1966775805,
0.7848085165,
0.1484189034,
0.655353725,
0.2860307693,
0.5360830426,
-0.2473104894,
-0.0416717194,
-0.1442055553,
-0.6708884239,
-0.7598319054,
-0.3061525822,
-0.5717822313,
-0.042763412,
-0.2415076345,
-0.8750864863,
0.4140182734,
0.7379029989,
-0.1401409209,
0.3552474976,
-0.6286444664,
1.1413706541,
0.0741409659,
-0.5644768476,
-0.2214611173,
-0.5730971098,
0.2185445428,
-0.2879048884,
0.5752742887,
0.0381046161,
0.1421137899,
0.4023415446,
-0.4452491403,
0.7765268087,
-0.1205502301,
-0.0005502725,
0.2106184214,
0.4365572333,
0.7470931411,
0.431368947,
-0.2974686325,
0.0804108828,
-0.2232390344,
-0.395310998,
-1.0537111759,
0.7136240602,
-0.7316863537,
-0.4321018457,
0.0422740206,
-0.6869370937,
-0.2792200744,
0.1704785526,
0.4671526849,
0.9090954065,
-0.1839583367,
0.1931480318,
0.6426149011,
-0.0787973776,
0.3211951256,
0.3099101782,
0.1214785054,
-0.4103910625,
1.006634593,
0.1960842311,
0.5575253367,
0.4610661864,
0.3451360762,
0.0049633849,
-0.6356800199,
-0.7517419457,
0.0342988707,
-1.0229891539,
-0.2370847315,
-0.5867294073,
0.1134777516,
-0.492863059,
-0.7959107757,
-0.5181036592,
-0.194527477,
-0.3286160529,
0.001338689,
0.301892817,
0.8364244103,
-0.5565276742,
0.3715316653,
-0.5746912956,
0.0905728564,
0.2444449216,
0.6354503632,
-0.2726065814,
-0.6571537852,
-0.6752384901,
0.1508214474,
-0.215392217,
-0.7409065366,
0.3922379315,
0.7018887401,
0.4570359886,
0.4253703058,
-0.0303457379,
0.9699928164,
-0.6949949861,
0.7617005706,
-0.1817188412,
-1.4202544689,
0.7267787457,
-0.4595985711,
0.6527779102,
0.8093628287,
0.1842690408,
-0.9087424278,
-0.7716842294,
-0.5435265303,
-0.639662087,
0.5577629209,
-0.0737349316,
0.3519847095,
-0.3033263981,
0.8459771872,
0.2386580408,
0.2639451027,
-0.5158544779,
-0.3032362163,
-0.3762953877,
-0.3144599497,
-0.2160369158,
-0.3739980757,
-0.1883746684,
-0.5703893304,
0.8726451993,
-0.3750097454,
-0.2437754571,
0.2706776559,
-0.4289942384,
-0.416354239,
0.0590750575,
0.7907575965,
0.9708015323,
-0.1324800402,
0.1008066535,
0.4741746485,
-0.2646868229,
-0.092567414,
-0.4861004055,
-0.5671161413,
-0.2077601999,
0.3157799542,
0.7151904106,
0.6669618487,
-0.4009700418,
0.2105917931,
-0.05433378,
0.0076826094,
0.0539361425,
0.2416225523,
-0.2690488398,
0.0322733857,
0.1135546938,
0.46905303,
0.1875008047,
-0.4770127237,
0.3238308132,
0.4024519622,
-0.4282574058,
-0.2365016937,
0.8309580684,
0.0592027642,
-0.3096559644,
0.756391108,
-0.1275361925,
-0.354706198,
0.1526019573,
0.6052622795,
0.8134283423,
-0.2557623386,
0.1141080558,
0.3846674562,
0.193255499,
-0.0261431988,
-0.030307129,
-0.1180863231,
-1.1089878082,
-0.2246441692,
-0.4475241005,
-0.2376364768,
-0.1060270444,
-0.5811325312,
0.402778089,
-0.4646372199,
0.142352134,
-0.0773566887,
-0.6424928904,
-0.6581721306,
0.4466958046,
-0.461168319,
0.9548655748,
-0.7293170094,
1.0014511347,
0.6216601133,
-0.0412203521,
-0.6595727205,
0.0542325377,
0.1380316019,
-0.3697060347,
0.3975309134,
-0.3612919152,
0.0547946207,
0.13915883,
-0.9215759635,
-1.2383419275,
0.8585599065,
0.6507892013,
-0.3366802633,
0.4088363647,
-0.107239373,
0.4281367958,
-0.4776907563,
-0.1841967851,
0.6753540039,
0.3635742068,
-0.1766649932,
-0.9759087563,
-0.1725450307,
-0.0893074274,
-0.1206880808,
0.1825044751,
-0.691159904,
0.6692612767,
0.0328018218,
-0.1770855337,
-0.308264792,
0.7854348421,
-0.1670609713,
-0.0204929635,
0.4016776085,
0.6231292486,
0.8162387013,
0.2015538067,
1.0703750849,
-0.7199551463,
0.3533010781,
1.3597903252,
-0.0369839817,
0.6831625104,
0.5313522816,
0.4212650359,
0.4694948792,
0.6118059754,
0.3879227042,
0.948251605,
-0.1381758898,
-0.4315850139,
-0.1373046637,
-0.0870455503,
-0.0944686085,
0.4583049715,
0.3255218863,
-0.1408423483,
-0.0245077703,
0.0399162024,
0.4106609523,
0.2412081063,
-0.2506641746,
0.879155457,
-0.1148901731,
-0.8435770869,
0.513507545,
0.2476551682,
0.4822575748,
-0.3460642397,
0.0825235024,
-0.3156736493,
0.0132040158,
-0.1602529883,
-0.655807972,
0.5530087352,
-0.0044737067,
-0.2655784488,
-0.5154426694,
0.5602057576,
-0.5986744165,
-0.4013797343,
-0.0601699427,
0.2313176394,
-0.1073369533,
0.0132402554,
-0.5495611429,
0.1167714298,
-0.1469330788,
-0.226812616,
0.5282753706,
0.6584991813,
0.1425121129,
0.7533051372,
0.4971000254,
0.0103794374,
0.022055462,
-0.1332218349,
0.7402610183,
-0.3873072267,
-0.6174134612,
-0.9283547997,
0.762206018,
-0.0547351837,
-0.8692069054,
0.541955173,
0.4042989612,
1.145362854,
-0.0552271307,
1.0257732868,
-0.0560924374,
0.2209222764,
-0.6665919423,
0.7554610968,
-0.6868399382,
-0.0210152473,
-0.6142372489,
-0.7866374254,
-0.5373227596,
0.5403775573,
-0.1671281606,
-0.321352452,
0.5983176231,
0.7574537396,
-0.2458059937,
-0.2549080849,
0.4025883675,
0.2693496943,
0.2249656469,
0.0646487623,
0.4666771889,
-0.3364231586,
-0.0759765878,
-0.5615358949,
-0.3316031694,
0.079878293,
-1.0716682673,
-0.8352400661,
-0.8725090623,
-0.3332665265,
-0.1157173738,
0.2823227346,
1.1865048409,
0.8979583383,
-0.6382688284,
-0.2338300049,
-0.0141880224,
0.2420770824,
-0.4277842343,
-0.1781173348,
0.32355088,
-0.6979506612,
-0.7785539031,
0.7392609715,
0.4620035291,
-0.2348871678,
0.0796751976,
-0.1005590484,
0.0056799091,
0.1211127639,
0.5893751383,
0.271152854,
-0.47606951,
-0.7746531367,
-0.3056185842,
-0.018829504,
0.0325491726,
0.7339445353,
-0.4514283538,
0.8737744689,
0.2212338299,
0.6789860725,
0.2702332139,
0.0410988107,
0.9881069064,
-0.9799744487,
0.1015726328,
-0.0673785135,
0.2972494662,
0.3471502364,
-0.7041067481,
0.3096292913,
0.1489058286,
-0.7798166275,
-0.7839887738,
0.1821970195,
-0.5218613148,
-0.2813260555,
1.1626638174,
-0.1191665605,
-0.1719461679,
-0.167959407,
-0.156055361,
0.2555544376,
-0.4419225156,
1.160225749,
0.7598184347,
-0.2363650799,
-0.1124126092,
-0.3203422129,
1.0750536919,
0.368075639,
-0.6251505017,
0.1186924577,
0.5219969153,
0.6343337297,
-0.266584754,
0.4854909778,
0.2995702624,
0.3358355165,
-0.2911367416,
0.07465031,
0.1966948509,
-0.5961021781,
-0.4953634739,
0.1275559813,
0.2345506698,
0.3796537817
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11193v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11193v1 | MMNeuron: Discovering Neuron-Level Domain-Specific Interpretation in Multimodal Large Language Model | 2024-06-17T03:59:44 | 2024-06-17T03:59:44 | Jiahao Huo, Yibo Yan, Boren Hu, Yutao Yue, Xuming Hu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Projecting visual features into word embedding space has become a significant
fusion strategy adopted by Multimodal Large Language Models (MLLMs). However,
its internal mechanisms have yet to be explored. Inspired by multilingual
research, we identify domain-specific neurons in multimodal large language
models. Specifically, we investigate the distribution of domain-specific
neurons and the mechanism of how MLLMs process features from diverse domains.
Furthermore, we propose a three-stage framework for language model modules in
MLLMs when handling projected image features, and verify this hypothesis using
logit lens. Extensive experiments indicate that while current MLLMs exhibit
Visual Question Answering (VQA) capability, they may not fully utilize
domain-specific information. Manipulating domain-specific neurons properly will
result in a 10\% change of accuracy at most, shedding light on the development
of cross-domain, all-encompassing MLLMs in the future. Our code will be
released upon paper notification. | [
-0.5539456606,
-0.8500353694,
0.5330050588,
0.151421845,
0.0294791386,
-0.230535388,
-0.1190179884,
-0.3914310634,
0.1830598712,
0.3812574148,
-0.6519564986,
-0.4448502064,
-0.5907247066,
-0.2052993029,
-0.3803517818,
0.585131526,
0.1536367983,
0.1384623796,
-0.2919485569,
-0.266784817,
-0.3753554821,
-0.6681889892,
-0.3744012713,
-0.3825488389,
0.9089075327,
0.0537821725,
0.4418687224,
0.2882060707,
0.3723175824,
0.2718594968,
-0.1377316862,
0.2188304067,
-0.157240808,
-0.0604476221,
-0.1546962112,
-0.4341779053,
-0.4778525233,
-0.2661527395,
0.6936871409,
0.7773625851,
-0.1885124296,
-0.0217859,
0.0153703867,
0.0887192562,
-0.6022209525,
0.0704573467,
-0.8045397997,
0.1012807265,
0.0507329442,
-0.2775912881,
-0.6077147722,
0.2050343007,
0.3162586689,
-0.4187578857,
0.3710266054,
0.0264438558,
0.7307863832,
-0.1245109662,
-0.5586488843,
0.0554776788,
-0.3477684259,
0.7914318442,
-0.6876695156,
0.3174272776,
0.1870657206,
0.2532863915,
0.0400311425,
-0.8015216589,
-0.7061123252,
-0.3733966053,
-0.0517026819,
-0.1540482342,
-0.173258841,
0.0064073973,
0.292840749,
0.0699948892,
-0.7075334787,
0.1083313748,
-0.2640048563,
-0.2928529382,
0.3669205904,
0.1288339943,
0.4114069343,
-0.2362332344,
-0.370092392,
0.0481490232,
-0.6853724122,
-0.3478708565,
0.2871640921,
0.1381481886,
0.0347838998,
0.8068180084,
-0.0580801591,
0.8552596569,
-0.3216385245,
0.0713103041,
0.4015396535,
-0.2253084332,
-0.2930324972,
-0.1224799603,
0.6081530452,
0.5037496686,
0.4057169259,
0.1722976863,
-0.3007252514,
-0.0529439151,
0.3434194326,
-0.6357933879,
-0.1352952868,
0.0455408581,
-0.5513061881,
-0.2738849819,
-0.3518634737,
-0.5128834844,
-0.5244078636,
-0.064614825,
0.5533248782,
-0.3510362506,
-0.5829495192,
0.1006505787,
-0.2990530431,
0.1041824967,
0.3016735613,
-1.0791368484,
0.0293488968,
0.4538264871,
0.7801837921,
-0.2632886767,
-0.7573129535,
-0.2527210116,
0.0742661804,
-0.3374592066,
0.7579716444,
-0.6555922031,
-0.0218994804,
0.4227647483,
0.1759845912,
-0.2759017646,
-0.6789450645,
0.2920798659,
-0.6385933757,
-0.0309548844,
0.0498603955,
-0.4439507425,
-0.3176570237,
0.4291157424,
-0.6989331245,
0.5009593368,
-0.0688715354,
-0.6322259903,
0.3193444312,
-0.6848718524,
-0.225660041,
-0.0963826478,
-0.2897725105,
-0.0113082975,
0.3613172472,
0.2862137854,
0.7427731752,
-0.1202622652,
0.2104831785,
-0.3472111225,
-0.0605373383,
0.549018383,
-0.5630660653,
0.481051594,
0.0149190249,
-0.1996135414,
0.295589298,
-0.5354795456,
0.085835062,
0.1112011075,
-0.1403585821,
-0.2835313082,
-0.0016263109,
0.1985812932,
0.459317714,
0.1968186647,
-0.4529044926,
0.2892469466,
-0.0798822716,
0.5711436868,
0.76553756,
0.0406206287,
0.5956614614,
0.1120355874,
0.2977490723,
0.39548105,
0.2484888285,
-0.3077799082,
-0.781393826,
-0.6281660199,
-0.0632563531,
0.1446298212,
0.3027520776,
-0.9066618681,
-0.0638747886,
-0.0565624945,
-0.1011113897,
-0.4133358896,
0.0436618291,
0.3150646985,
0.1059561074,
0.3681229949,
-0.3300713599,
-0.1633850187,
-1.3597681522,
0.0137864687,
0.1352722794,
0.0640170276,
0.4711107612,
0.5659099221,
-0.398240447,
0.2959141135,
-0.5098972917,
-0.2706213892,
-0.3417146206,
0.1691709161,
0.0421953239,
0.4089907408,
0.5018100739,
-1.0888518095,
-0.1829685867,
0.227678284,
-0.8959310055,
0.1542504728,
-0.1970186234,
-0.1034317389,
-0.0029217906,
0.5810527802,
-0.8741779923,
0.4101596177,
0.7827197313,
-0.2573559582,
0.6028911471,
-0.2550224662,
0.1420900971,
-0.8975709677,
0.028719781,
0.0619943626,
0.0637084991,
-0.7544621825,
0.1233881935,
0.1405669153,
-0.0733717978,
-0.4623256326,
0.5005397201,
-0.5001772046,
-0.258982271,
-0.3534189165,
0.4252880514,
-0.0509609021,
0.7281870842,
0.0974374935,
0.4889171124,
0.7366043329,
-0.4830830991,
0.2419517189,
0.2426047325,
-0.6356592774,
0.3051317036,
-0.4985786378,
-0.107856065,
-0.0668713227,
-0.0788770691,
-0.9569134712,
-0.1327560246,
0.0320684761,
-0.6096726656,
0.4362549782,
-0.1536677778,
-0.3414126039,
-0.184790954,
0.1105636507,
0.447691083,
0.2503998876,
-0.4349481165,
0.6880733371,
0.4776409864,
-0.0862680748,
-0.8109394312,
-0.7122482061,
0.1903991103,
0.1540126652,
-0.6607801318,
0.3498001397,
-0.0447808765,
-0.1044088975,
0.1231778488,
0.0019040282,
-0.228251487,
-0.0902092904,
0.2241381705,
0.0373551063,
-0.4374571741,
0.2553991973,
-0.0400164872,
0.0706493631,
0.0049009798,
-0.4251826406,
0.8167144656,
0.0501339808,
-0.4750436544,
-0.1481263638,
0.60855937,
0.6500065327,
-0.4970864654,
0.7151790261,
0.69268471,
-0.4718461633,
-0.3944957852,
-0.4083686471,
-0.3177879155,
-0.4474915862,
0.7341505885,
-0.7335965037,
-0.9455920458,
0.3275020421,
-0.1326912194,
-0.1161726043,
0.4827650785,
0.7504966855,
-0.0124427415,
1.3908958435,
0.9022319317,
0.2030176967,
0.434941262,
-0.3581350744,
0.2411294281,
-0.9956131577,
-0.3257808685,
-0.079121992,
-0.3706339598,
-0.3503590524,
-0.5900148153,
0.1242804974,
-0.0896045119,
0.2045294642,
0.1843115538,
-0.3273997605,
0.4044415951,
0.5353141427,
-0.0433735512,
-0.0042326227,
0.1540378183,
-0.6383606195,
0.0073912372,
-0.8300388455,
-0.2377419472,
0.7847386599,
0.2013889849,
0.6184229851,
-0.05230904,
0.2656039298,
0.2456824183,
0.2334289551,
-0.7065166235,
0.6652504802,
-0.1942886263,
-0.7467841506,
-0.1014266014,
-0.2659336627,
-0.7530064583,
0.5005461574,
-0.2722996473,
-0.8002266288,
0.3936776519,
0.0101984646,
-0.0382147767,
0.4340492487,
-0.7493108511,
1.1810668707,
-0.1383441985,
-0.2519284189,
-0.5448582172,
-0.4183215797,
0.340293467,
-0.0601040311,
-0.0845735595,
-0.0751259252,
-0.059613917,
0.4237032533,
0.0528060347,
0.8287898302,
-0.2954918742,
-0.2978580296,
0.2900036275,
0.2250948846,
0.0593916401,
-0.1055778638,
0.0979562923,
0.2954134941,
-0.260230273,
-0.3251446486,
-0.9098870158,
1.0670574903,
-0.4785102904,
-0.5528507233,
-0.1789188534,
-0.6995052695,
-0.2671097815,
-0.0381678231,
0.1955957562,
0.589451313,
-0.0904021189,
0.1133400723,
0.6434172988,
-0.382651329,
0.5976889729,
0.1805784702,
-0.5709996819,
-0.3288577795,
1.0220766068,
0.0190030802,
0.3413382769,
0.4749430716,
-0.1566500366,
-0.1214314997,
-0.747330904,
-0.5639001727,
0.2419705391,
-0.9045013189,
0.0916406736,
-0.7454288006,
-0.2969104648,
-0.1108744517,
0.0303631984,
-0.1587649584,
-0.5250839591,
-0.0271296967,
-0.1001777798,
-0.0510489903,
0.7508737445,
0.0517369285,
0.3015483916,
-0.7166429758,
0.2832846344,
0.3924460709,
0.2140891999,
0.2276346236,
-0.4253549874,
-0.4072105587,
0.0987888426,
-0.0435818583,
-0.7555359006,
0.5424343348,
0.4093104899,
0.6993005276,
0.4910694659,
-0.7372394204,
0.507941246,
-0.8565872908,
0.9332000017,
0.3913600743,
-0.7078090906,
0.4395783246,
-0.1039560735,
0.3448370695,
-0.1861921698,
0.53920573,
-0.6020618081,
-0.209597379,
-0.5362836123,
-0.6829208136,
0.3431487679,
0.1060229614,
0.433493495,
0.0211268682,
0.2349579483,
0.0335825831,
0.3731663525,
-0.7417606115,
-0.2645939589,
-0.0548311472,
-0.03259027,
-0.3747829199,
-0.4224762321,
-0.2458064407,
-0.1614783108,
0.3118465841,
-0.362460345,
0.6620107293,
0.2420681417,
-0.3807430267,
0.1846081316,
0.0986929834,
1.0414054394,
0.8252729177,
-0.0646465272,
0.4527317584,
-0.008977918,
-0.4523279965,
-0.0279674903,
-0.1335875839,
-0.0076768114,
0.3091277778,
0.4466501772,
0.9062837362,
-0.1036707684,
-0.6005686522,
0.6975257993,
-0.0924644172,
-0.3851532936,
-0.1716580391,
-0.0750798583,
0.1705121547,
0.4767615497,
0.3889506459,
0.4237396419,
0.1471260339,
-0.564375937,
0.4314287901,
0.4451147914,
-0.5409483314,
-0.4870226681,
0.5086097121,
-0.0623980314,
-0.1663817614,
0.5455314517,
0.027938107,
-0.5931385756,
0.5818812251,
0.6347385645,
0.8713074923,
-0.1878488958,
0.3281259537,
0.2164285928,
0.3471019268,
0.1683027297,
0.3144722879,
0.2197338492,
-1.038533926,
-0.7038977742,
-0.5636151433,
0.0855766684,
0.0417389646,
-0.3073571026,
-0.0354914777,
-0.3706574142,
-0.3786201775,
0.3946821988,
-0.650221467,
-0.4155041277,
0.2483516634,
0.5824948549,
0.9472317696,
-0.6577729583,
1.1081330776,
0.6270871758,
-0.3979636729,
-0.4039501846,
-0.1404555738,
-0.0867360011,
-0.9371683002,
1.099149704,
0.1010662094,
-0.0917286277,
0.014033542,
-0.853484869,
-0.5633731484,
0.6730771661,
0.2088571489,
-0.4469533861,
-0.0403101891,
0.0425591879,
0.3605411351,
-0.7382676005,
0.1941909939,
0.1126577854,
0.2920030653,
-0.0387490578,
-0.7749233842,
-0.0570677407,
-0.4326236546,
-0.0145948539,
0.2232974023,
-0.0850403458,
0.983443737,
-0.4170509875,
0.043556422,
-0.0762762204,
0.5914573669,
-0.092944704,
0.1036146656,
0.374540776,
0.5025450587,
0.559914887,
0.0064390795,
1.0813913345,
-0.1307807714,
0.1906903833,
0.9193552732,
-0.1627103239,
1.1542834044,
0.7363067865,
0.2892403305,
0.5589523911,
0.3587161601,
-0.1795901358,
0.6651300788,
0.2786972523,
-0.511469245,
-0.2993353903,
-0.2578221858,
-0.1982703209,
0.3083054423,
0.5020182133,
-0.6066039205,
0.0701334104,
0.3498575687,
-0.3542406857,
-0.3968031704,
-0.3584683537,
0.6243463159,
0.4125946462,
-0.530226469,
0.7265154123,
-0.0462990925,
0.6283512712,
-0.6518284082,
-0.2945698798,
-0.0835244507,
0.3159960508,
-0.1867583841,
-0.9077957869,
0.1012635231,
-0.2958364189,
-0.2013924122,
-0.2123420388,
0.8278990984,
-0.5328277349,
-0.1879014671,
0.5667482615,
0.7565892935,
0.0502297133,
-0.3601568341,
-0.6412793398,
-0.1096361428,
0.0825472102,
-0.2021979243,
0.4477873445,
0.4718059599,
-0.0093361065,
0.758987546,
0.6658431292,
0.0217627008,
0.4569808543,
0.4893369377,
0.7923803926,
-0.5956866741,
0.0559019074,
-0.8579334021,
0.6912933588,
-0.2809003294,
-0.3415384591,
0.6996357441,
0.381575644,
0.7883474827,
-0.4696303904,
0.6174242496,
-0.145003736,
-0.1156930178,
-0.5138992667,
0.7515131831,
-0.9196953177,
-0.1356760561,
-0.0764926746,
-1.0409786701,
-0.5072364211,
0.5836436749,
-0.137798816,
-0.1827897429,
1.0473121405,
1.0373935699,
-0.2121632695,
-0.2165694535,
0.8633947372,
0.2273920774,
0.1252797097,
0.5032355785,
1.1641216278,
-0.283960104,
0.5581812859,
-0.1875267923,
0.0426935963,
-0.1098197177,
-0.6203683019,
-0.7479348779,
-0.8555489182,
-0.3866641223,
-0.1828988343,
-0.0706274286,
0.4159023464,
0.8284755945,
-0.64256531,
-0.2456529886,
0.126261726,
0.0655887425,
-0.2660598755,
-0.1714670211,
0.2346919477,
-0.3387079835,
-0.5451217294,
0.3437033892,
0.4796115756,
-0.0217467006,
-0.3286654651,
0.0836949423,
-0.5301280022,
-0.0269818995,
0.9087768197,
-0.0832691565,
-0.7533208132,
-0.2430129796,
0.293533951,
-0.2114548683,
0.1592319459,
0.9700590372,
-0.349737078,
0.4312701523,
0.4871034324,
0.5526384711,
0.5470510125,
-0.5446941257,
0.7020334601,
-0.7125445604,
0.1554496437,
0.1895967275,
0.670845747,
0.2806843519,
0.0629825145,
0.2526007593,
0.236176759,
-0.4550255835,
-0.6529248357,
0.434774667,
-1.0250154734,
-0.4764217138,
1.1073737144,
-0.1289057732,
-0.4971114099,
0.1439329237,
-0.4251493216,
-0.1637902111,
0.0598989166,
0.3568016887,
0.757410109,
-0.0002397593,
-0.5676999688,
-0.9357040524,
0.4464682639,
0.3923673034,
-0.55396384,
-0.1236594766,
0.5435519218,
-0.0208222829,
0.527443707,
0.3468810916,
-0.0155293336,
0.2763142288,
0.1433785409,
0.379953146,
0.2714411914,
-0.6214979291,
-0.476260066,
0.4240352213,
0.1149778292,
-0.1885096282
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11192v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11192v1 | Beyond Boundaries: Learning a Universal Entity Taxonomy across Datasets and Languages for Open Named Entity Recognition | 2024-06-17T03:57:35 | 2024-06-17T03:57:35 | Yuming Yang, Wantong Zhao, Caishuang Huang, Junjie Ye, Xiao Wang, Huiyuan Zheng, Yang Nan, Yuran Wang, Xueying Xu, Kaixin Huang, Yunke Zhang, Tao Gui, Qi Zhang, Xuanjing Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Open Named Entity Recognition (NER), which involves identifying arbitrary
types of entities from arbitrary domains, remains challenging for Large
Language Models (LLMs). Recent studies suggest that fine-tuning LLMs on
extensive NER data can boost their performance. However, training directly on
existing datasets faces issues due to inconsistent entity definitions and
redundant data, limiting LLMs to dataset-specific learning and hindering
out-of-domain generalization. To address this, we present B2NERD, a cohesive
and efficient dataset for Open NER, normalized from 54 existing English or
Chinese datasets using a two-step approach. First, we detect inconsistent
entity definitions across datasets and clarify them by distinguishable label
names to construct a universal taxonomy of 400+ entity types. Second, we
address redundancy using a data pruning strategy that selects fewer samples
with greater category and semantic diversity. Comprehensive evaluation shows
that B2NERD significantly improves LLMs' generalization on Open NER. Our B2NER
models, trained on B2NERD, outperform GPT-4 by 6.8-12.0 F1 points and surpass
previous methods in 3 out-of-domain benchmarks across 15 datasets and 6
languages. | [
-0.3864244819,
-0.3619967699,
0.0494860075,
-0.0774459392,
-0.1972242743,
-0.0412432626,
-0.6092331409,
-0.5465478301,
-0.2289302945,
0.4845788479,
-0.2249478251,
-0.5578677654,
-0.6006574035,
0.057789214,
-0.0203616749,
1.0302966833,
-0.2283023298,
0.0121837761,
-0.0368228182,
-0.3411503732,
-0.3908342123,
-0.3262668848,
-0.7668371201,
-0.4070258141,
0.433395952,
0.6281340718,
0.4659236372,
0.566796124,
0.5873471498,
0.0948682055,
0.0247672647,
0.4517596662,
-0.6524527073,
0.0959704295,
-0.5962360501,
-0.2111773789,
-0.0576263219,
-0.4211252928,
0.6804975867,
0.8996825218,
-0.191738829,
0.1458435059,
0.0413093604,
0.5732612014,
-0.6306295991,
0.2571910024,
-0.769197166,
0.0210233778,
-0.4288091063,
0.2289533466,
-0.3608470261,
-0.1904345751,
0.3363360465,
-0.5963168144,
0.3405295312,
-0.1694356203,
1.2325890064,
0.2047168016,
-0.4955039322,
-0.1942061633,
-0.9575586319,
0.5860335231,
-0.2068204731,
0.9974421859,
0.0260531176,
0.2220521122,
-0.1453196555,
-0.7960890532,
-0.450484246,
0.4137560725,
-0.0377796255,
-0.1121101454,
-0.5808469057,
-0.0625552386,
0.3386887014,
0.192829594,
-0.7519022226,
0.4277794957,
-0.4089012742,
-0.0579876266,
0.5614227057,
-0.1141484082,
0.2870141864,
0.2079586387,
-0.4208552539,
-0.1462657005,
-0.9758822322,
-0.0253940299,
0.0921465531,
0.4177763164,
0.0094532873,
0.4234481752,
-0.0416065305,
0.5120667219,
0.0546744354,
0.1693110019,
0.2828394175,
-0.0384190194,
-0.2951701283,
-0.1195803881,
0.5074255466,
0.4193991423,
0.4269173443,
-0.6143590808,
-0.2904368639,
-0.0446039401,
-0.0294264555,
-0.9014344215,
-0.4851839244,
0.0719809458,
-0.2264645994,
0.3608762026,
0.1020113304,
-0.7585353255,
-0.1566234827,
-0.5966143012,
0.2181694061,
-0.3550164998,
-0.4304489493,
0.047388792,
-0.0623727031,
0.1762070507,
0.2516943514,
-0.7919659019,
0.6104736924,
0.7576904297,
0.8410203457,
-0.1490381658,
-0.1967680454,
-0.4353898466,
0.2090928704,
-0.5291674137,
0.5995377898,
-0.4793788195,
-0.1764297336,
-0.2939157784,
0.1141037419,
-0.0083971042,
-0.940254271,
0.2145308405,
-0.7556644678,
-0.2007840574,
-0.2363765687,
-0.6453932524,
-0.3798664808,
0.1192813516,
-0.670648098,
0.8901489973,
0.360301286,
-0.6612875462,
0.7720265388,
-0.5064728856,
-0.5131162405,
0.4938845336,
-0.3414209187,
-0.4753099084,
0.2367838025,
0.0472360626,
0.3590492606,
-0.3586839139,
0.5690634251,
-0.1546431333,
-0.1066909581,
-0.254186213,
-0.021720795,
0.6923282743,
-0.0532307476,
-0.146957621,
-0.2321798503,
-0.6941766739,
0.0679839179,
0.077136606,
-0.1611124724,
-0.7784262896,
-0.1153220609,
0.1463937908,
0.1866158545,
-0.0839065313,
-0.7173116803,
0.1034291759,
-0.4349089861,
0.3520796299,
0.585021615,
0.0681845322,
0.4694076478,
-0.0155752394,
0.2002817839,
0.2186502516,
-0.3099663556,
0.1254964769,
-0.4188867211,
-0.6401857138,
-0.2578467131,
0.5915108323,
0.4752672315,
-0.5590444207,
0.645075202,
-0.555046618,
-0.6379039288,
-0.5140723586,
0.2074076086,
0.4515195191,
0.6644370556,
0.6987394691,
-0.4915370047,
-0.7622817755,
-0.7229247689,
-0.0220605321,
0.099417679,
-0.1815113872,
0.4282639921,
0.8154575229,
-0.5434072018,
1.0579277277,
-0.4181858301,
-0.4990995824,
-0.0918737501,
-0.2758443654,
0.047069665,
0.418004632,
0.0397302732,
-0.854641974,
-0.5505575538,
0.4330472648,
-0.7757887244,
0.2688092291,
0.1013689488,
-0.1906459481,
0.2540482879,
0.4488248825,
-0.5711545348,
0.3022985458,
0.3167592585,
-0.1162208766,
0.2335079163,
-0.0471238531,
-0.5241580009,
-0.9470834732,
0.1301679164,
0.225307256,
0.120360598,
-0.7555593252,
0.1676908135,
0.2356646657,
-0.1927028447,
-0.2953673601,
0.935811758,
-0.7396832108,
-0.2002425343,
0.0514389612,
0.0727045685,
-0.0881787613,
0.2730765939,
0.4301178455,
0.5970929265,
0.779168725,
-0.7778351307,
0.3210019767,
0.5069149733,
-0.4117792547,
0.55428195,
-0.5482850075,
0.2272481322,
-0.3565402925,
0.3071081638,
-0.6096454263,
-0.3432340324,
0.0913891196,
-0.2833277583,
0.5615329146,
-0.4133739173,
-0.3368875086,
-0.2848622203,
0.2205574661,
0.3823586404,
0.4429258704,
-0.9887483716,
0.6387759447,
0.470318228,
-0.0988236591,
-0.4870116711,
-0.8065869808,
0.0804190338,
-0.0635764822,
-0.6288120747,
0.4770618081,
0.2102984488,
-0.2494937181,
0.1307353824,
-0.3713306189,
-0.1153462902,
-0.0361085832,
0.1472859532,
0.0150714461,
-0.351909399,
0.4191543758,
0.1190064847,
-0.0685555786,
-0.1763000935,
-0.6660238504,
0.5127314329,
0.0200147014,
-0.0881031305,
-0.2528370917,
0.1288876683,
-0.0941140354,
-0.4839250147,
0.457254976,
0.4126485884,
-0.8505554199,
-0.4698230624,
-0.1996835768,
-0.0633543134,
-0.4038253725,
0.3949908614,
-0.6652780175,
-0.9551211596,
0.3303149045,
-0.1452876329,
0.2164208591,
0.3012473881,
0.4805458486,
0.3268291056,
0.4339892268,
0.7185958624,
0.0642513782,
0.0723522082,
-0.4254955351,
0.3910312057,
-0.9666538239,
-0.5276412964,
-0.3562331498,
-0.2743659019,
-0.6883677244,
-0.472110182,
0.0241925642,
0.2582619488,
-0.3106095493,
0.41850999,
-0.4471601546,
0.7282816768,
0.3506568372,
0.0940931439,
0.1981330514,
0.3135457039,
-0.0569808334,
-0.1823823005,
-0.3931486309,
-0.2987696528,
1.1987959146,
0.4054218829,
0.6844531298,
0.3646946847,
0.8887065053,
-0.025655359,
0.4018911421,
-0.8114798069,
0.35252738,
-0.4156212509,
-0.5713660121,
-0.406675458,
-0.5627436638,
-1.0709611177,
0.3011658192,
0.1132265329,
-0.8646171093,
0.4436787367,
-0.1131221205,
-0.1598209441,
0.5076687336,
-0.5742827654,
0.7474934459,
-0.0820942298,
-0.2620570064,
0.2276266515,
-0.594429493,
0.3289643228,
-0.2197214514,
-0.0348837711,
0.0138367703,
-0.2132930756,
0.60545367,
-0.1382814795,
0.4501372874,
-0.2309197038,
-0.2046036571,
0.2200126946,
0.0799544901,
0.4627069235,
0.2840894163,
0.0301361158,
0.560590744,
-0.5696802139,
-0.3699390888,
-0.4855894148,
0.6374567747,
-0.7355858088,
-0.26301682,
-0.2719258964,
-0.3303891718,
-0.2581917048,
0.3919737339,
0.3974433839,
0.491419524,
-0.3579230905,
0.2051494271,
0.9479619861,
-0.0979927331,
0.2262320668,
0.5444774628,
0.0464337319,
-0.5383316875,
1.0263344049,
0.309859395,
0.1202641129,
0.4998450279,
-0.2026150376,
-0.509080708,
-0.5168644786,
-0.6229987144,
0.2087275982,
-0.6011549234,
-0.3775355816,
-0.9048895836,
-0.2813000381,
-0.4535053968,
0.0644057468,
-0.2363143116,
-0.0975752473,
-0.2817513943,
-0.2609669864,
0.1823170632,
0.5876485705,
-0.1662030965,
0.1218171194,
-0.6450432539,
0.3197542131,
0.0548539832,
0.6773050427,
0.0692049339,
-0.4929640293,
-0.0905003697,
0.0818982348,
-0.0503608286,
-0.5888006687,
0.3045612574,
0.5538793802,
0.3957851827,
0.5033034086,
-0.1166893765,
0.5963231921,
-0.578702867,
0.3552945554,
0.2723014951,
-0.6817534566,
0.359509021,
-0.1294503808,
0.0162292942,
0.4302347004,
0.8810842633,
-0.7046565413,
0.0691128001,
-0.6263033748,
-0.9862872958,
0.6556592584,
-0.0456022024,
0.0500403717,
-0.030525621,
0.394618243,
0.3154068887,
0.023555154,
-0.5712288618,
-0.1804109365,
0.0542187542,
-0.2088318914,
-0.2573461831,
0.0678545982,
0.0130184246,
-0.1867716163,
0.6691555977,
-0.0939798206,
0.0437764637,
0.1093705073,
-0.397454083,
-0.1498029679,
0.2389881164,
0.1367721558,
0.6069173813,
-0.0249720961,
0.1741719097,
0.1844167411,
-0.4006575942,
0.2106331885,
0.3226608932,
-0.4988053739,
0.1337754577,
0.0804424882,
0.8197060823,
-0.1498110294,
-0.5922130942,
0.3170436919,
-0.021340929,
-0.1535493284,
-0.1476846635,
0.0143064773,
0.0409872085,
0.1836604923,
0.2088547349,
0.0880813226,
0.0718691275,
-0.344884187,
0.5446979403,
0.3092657626,
-0.518591702,
-0.3451548815,
0.4259810448,
0.0862169638,
-0.2016935796,
0.9725570083,
-0.4874967635,
-0.3276171684,
0.5869047642,
0.7029226422,
0.7287136316,
-0.1617134362,
0.057975255,
0.582490921,
0.3156377971,
-0.2499931604,
0.3197971284,
0.1405829489,
-0.9566808939,
-0.245676443,
-0.5800676942,
-0.4710568488,
0.4872803688,
-0.6998779178,
0.4352818727,
-0.6548953056,
-0.0024932381,
0.1224202365,
0.0346383303,
-0.7585433722,
0.366158098,
0.1505737603,
0.9762265086,
-0.7507539988,
0.5946909189,
0.9072215557,
-0.4421523213,
-0.857647419,
0.0059349868,
-0.1075236648,
-0.4371854365,
0.7103667855,
0.3440385759,
0.2439228147,
0.2909338176,
-0.3358884752,
-0.9452360272,
0.8971258402,
0.0896852016,
-0.998013556,
-0.2066397518,
-0.0866980255,
0.5372362137,
-0.3209946156,
0.1811966747,
0.7234717607,
0.4045229852,
-0.0287815072,
-0.7873043418,
0.0839074552,
-0.1153925583,
0.1487738937,
0.7209352255,
-0.6239935756,
0.6937783957,
-0.5986836553,
-0.5044112206,
-0.1597261876,
0.722165525,
0.1377333254,
0.3702028096,
0.1885641813,
0.9480856061,
1.1421695948,
-0.3675633967,
0.4828453064,
0.0043506315,
0.4096064866,
1.3095656633,
-0.7048703432,
0.7784637809,
0.1005419418,
-0.0582373962,
0.4452725053,
0.6405879259,
-0.6044335365,
0.4912339151,
0.3881483376,
-0.2833067775,
-0.1184463874,
-0.2703216374,
-0.3006168306,
0.4743955433,
0.5443786979,
0.0787192881,
-0.6333699822,
0.1150561571,
0.0016553444,
0.0471926108,
-0.3450719118,
0.8625485897,
0.08286044,
-0.5923295021,
0.5848653913,
0.2348628938,
0.6801748872,
-0.2425596565,
0.0087096924,
-0.2783915699,
0.4494414628,
-0.3823107779,
-0.7921423912,
0.188564226,
0.0425978191,
-0.1853721887,
0.0285875648,
0.7835373878,
-0.7093441486,
-0.1402008832,
0.5157805085,
0.3767210245,
0.17684488,
-0.0075103636,
-0.427480489,
-0.3489353955,
-0.0667007864,
0.0736375153,
0.3215073347,
0.7625343204,
-0.4532772005,
0.6324287057,
0.7222994566,
0.12883237,
-0.0523830578,
0.0620834231,
0.8129716516,
-0.6124154925,
-0.3060592711,
-0.6952087879,
0.170091331,
0.0218979642,
-0.5007613897,
0.5154941082,
1.044695735,
1.5018379688,
0.0907561257,
0.8550904989,
-0.1494905204,
0.6476628184,
-0.3940649033,
0.4244853258,
-0.4638378024,
-0.0729807541,
0.1210593507,
-0.8665615916,
-0.4857714176,
0.3604575992,
-0.1558846831,
0.0077116229,
0.3590035439,
0.7680026293,
-0.3775990903,
-0.1405334771,
0.1300492138,
0.1524565965,
0.3090235889,
0.6209900975,
0.5644241571,
-0.4565819502,
0.447045207,
-0.1748713255,
-0.0686734691,
-0.0489126742,
-0.5099964738,
-0.8896479011,
-0.3334913254,
-0.3236799538,
-0.3660573661,
0.246527046,
0.9758969545,
0.6313085556,
-0.9326575994,
-0.159277156,
-0.3327371478,
0.0312770158,
-0.0380697064,
-0.2238597125,
0.2885790467,
-0.2647868097,
-0.5397744179,
0.2377013564,
0.2502435744,
0.1377041936,
0.120110482,
-0.1892487407,
-0.0602918826,
-0.1550218165,
0.4266626835,
0.4484487176,
-0.5811257362,
-0.1384602934,
-0.0055419682,
-0.0578458644,
0.0770965219,
0.5964852571,
-0.4874485731,
0.3246038556,
0.2578887641,
0.7751184106,
0.3612997532,
-0.0050825835,
0.4295788705,
-0.8887360692,
-0.0396103896,
0.346421212,
0.1585537195,
0.483135283,
-0.1707191318,
0.7332987785,
0.2729005516,
-0.3360725045,
-0.8609663844,
0.36636585,
-0.6112904549,
-0.1638922542,
1.2370061874,
-0.2948918045,
0.0262058377,
-0.2628000379,
0.2191797048,
0.2434410602,
-0.421105206,
0.2684241831,
0.5154043436,
0.074121654,
-0.0702209696,
-0.2620146275,
0.4856340885,
-0.0168520883,
-0.6898505092,
0.2927151322,
0.4715755284,
0.6173025966,
0.0427329242,
0.5210826397,
0.0099563254,
0.2825948894,
-0.1540939361,
0.2738780975,
0.0009649453,
-0.7725828886,
-0.5452334285,
-0.095300734,
-0.0962397084,
0.1200069785
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11191v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11191v2 | A Survey on Human Preference Learning for Large Language Models | 2024-06-17T03:52:51 | 2024-06-18T08:18:33 | Ruili Jiang, Kehai Chen, Xuefeng Bai, Zhixuan He, Juntao Li, Muyun Yang, Tiejun Zhao, Liqiang Nie, Min Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | The recent surge of versatile large language models (LLMs) largely depends on
aligning increasingly capable foundation models with human intentions by
preference learning, enhancing LLMs with excellent applicability and
effectiveness in a wide range of contexts. Despite the numerous related studies
conducted, a perspective on how human preferences are introduced into LLMs
remains limited, which may prevent a deeper comprehension of the relationships
between human preferences and LLMs as well as the realization of their
limitations. In this survey, we review the progress in exploring human
preference learning for LLMs from a preference-centered perspective, covering
the sources and formats of preference feedback, the modeling and usage of
preference signals, as well as the evaluation of the aligned LLMs. We first
categorize the human feedback according to data sources and formats. We then
summarize techniques for human preferences modeling and compare the advantages
and disadvantages of different schools of models. Moreover, we present various
preference usage methods sorted by the objectives to utilize human preference
signals. Finally, we summarize some prevailing approaches to evaluate LLMs in
terms of alignment with human intentions and discuss our outlooks on the human
intention alignment for LLMs. | [
-0.493811816,
-0.4109647274,
0.7384845018,
-0.0277846102,
-0.0496680886,
-0.0776848719,
-0.8194928765,
-0.4974820018,
0.1234969348,
0.6275916696,
-0.4333171546,
-0.5178453922,
-0.4772428274,
-0.0222096499,
0.0236958768,
0.6677408814,
0.0883444324,
0.4209164977,
-0.1498170793,
-0.0396329314,
-0.333543092,
-0.8860792518,
-0.530167222,
-0.741068244,
0.6954951882,
0.6702701449,
0.6365830302,
0.3980314434,
0.2149220407,
0.288033545,
-0.0197160747,
-0.0112873763,
-0.4540714324,
-0.0014195115,
-0.154552117,
-0.3497763574,
-0.4999629557,
0.3277104199,
0.6190776229,
1.1204992533,
-0.2234111875,
0.2275662124,
0.1098353788,
0.9046341777,
-0.6502603292,
-0.1085561439,
-0.5229183435,
0.0548945926,
-0.1934449673,
-0.101309143,
-0.6554573178,
-0.369514972,
0.6352037191,
-0.0331404917,
0.0550717935,
0.1714086086,
0.3643051386,
0.0084660109,
-0.8883006573,
-0.2107457519,
-0.5904035568,
1.3192814589,
-0.4856753051,
0.6892969012,
0.5139892697,
0.4078829288,
-0.2036664635,
-0.0880478695,
-0.2874124348,
-0.3055347502,
0.125531584,
-0.2647225559,
0.2760547698,
0.0911624581,
-0.1511738896,
0.1191500649,
-0.4836212397,
0.5235409737,
-0.0408364423,
-0.1956685781,
0.8853035569,
0.2040519267,
0.0389374942,
-0.2121737152,
-0.3432928622,
-0.1877022982,
-0.8970609307,
0.3207714856,
0.4295349717,
0.2865496278,
-0.0284943003,
0.46592924,
-0.288969785,
1.0742818117,
0.0952809379,
-0.3143549263,
0.2435998768,
0.2975759804,
-0.105845131,
-0.0058064298,
0.6975120306,
0.6425110698,
0.3476108909,
-0.212882489,
-0.1969674677,
-0.1766817123,
0.2381902635,
-0.5427079201,
0.1955821812,
0.0202981979,
-0.6288093925,
-0.2430236936,
0.0946471915,
-0.538018167,
-0.623886466,
-0.7607516646,
-0.0711549148,
0.0378655866,
-0.2743960619,
0.4198265672,
0.3836487234,
0.4310298264,
0.4816178381,
-1.3880808353,
0.1394461095,
0.8167773485,
0.4286668599,
-0.5369954109,
-0.2007296085,
-0.3767290711,
-0.0703722164,
-0.1851659268,
0.6789169312,
-0.4861136079,
-0.5740586519,
0.0160283726,
-0.1769042164,
0.2548737824,
-0.5161856413,
0.5817729235,
-0.6596758962,
0.2138443291,
-0.5199193954,
-0.5231898427,
-0.2810841203,
0.3967557847,
-0.3740110695,
0.569527626,
0.0165168606,
-0.4104626179,
0.3217876554,
-0.4281086326,
-0.3310873508,
-0.1318722665,
-0.2624843717,
-0.1918757558,
0.1313336939,
-0.0932023898,
0.7732772827,
-0.3780128658,
0.6230941415,
-0.4791324735,
-0.1209057346,
0.6153386831,
-0.4079384804,
0.7232987881,
0.3568546772,
-0.1541792899,
0.3655809164,
-0.4143790007,
-0.012273022,
0.0944178253,
-0.5796143413,
-0.2318737656,
0.1972945482,
0.0802050754,
0.1718716174,
0.4208237827,
-0.4052980244,
0.3613790274,
-0.3747434914,
0.5492842197,
1.1432062387,
-0.3090395331,
0.7297526598,
-0.192749083,
0.3537487388,
-0.3144666851,
0.227787286,
0.3518805206,
-0.3137192726,
-0.6188649535,
0.1026142761,
0.2370202988,
0.0378823094,
0.1236975342,
0.6478034854,
-0.2447783649,
-0.2681935132,
-0.2481393963,
0.3505292833,
0.2700325847,
0.3773081303,
0.1641888916,
-0.3327632844,
-0.6939230561,
-1.0843064785,
-0.1820823103,
-0.3428362906,
0.1339558512,
0.6187016368,
0.0675960481,
-0.2456257343,
1.1948268414,
-0.6534698009,
0.1550146639,
-0.4610525966,
-0.2692161202,
0.1215316281,
0.1133218333,
0.5850727558,
-0.9453883171,
-0.6683655977,
-0.1113631576,
-0.2516568899,
0.1895862669,
0.6174910665,
-0.105020158,
0.3295477629,
0.1270011514,
-0.349716723,
-0.1293604672,
0.8675227165,
-0.0432412438,
0.5643909574,
0.0991753563,
-0.0010562666,
-1.0483056307,
0.0176422689,
0.1338582933,
-0.3121623695,
-0.6452630758,
-0.3453396559,
0.0772546083,
0.3883611262,
-0.6713423729,
0.938621521,
-0.5515081882,
-0.3127003908,
-0.3478677571,
0.0454800129,
-0.156718865,
0.3031815588,
0.5316889882,
0.4991211295,
0.2562180758,
-0.5953389406,
0.4028651714,
0.3622899652,
-0.375215441,
0.369463861,
-0.3148166537,
0.4150346816,
-0.1841199249,
0.3218122721,
-0.9629667997,
-0.5318666101,
0.2028132826,
-0.3731853962,
0.3920784593,
-0.2409499139,
-0.0825381204,
-0.1843369007,
-0.3452621698,
0.2022368908,
0.5909069777,
-0.7571260929,
0.3280708492,
0.6337045431,
-0.0244162027,
-0.9011595845,
-0.48130247,
-0.0795086026,
-0.3706783652,
-0.3956746757,
0.078761071,
-0.2199320942,
-0.4698364437,
-0.3539550006,
0.0237442404,
0.1522762477,
0.2048232406,
0.2487804741,
0.5062927604,
0.0240482371,
0.2009219229,
-0.4232799411,
-0.1191770881,
-0.0692241043,
-0.3100268841,
0.7354495525,
-0.2876656651,
-0.3833296597,
-0.1144480631,
0.0964944437,
0.3921495676,
-0.1618055403,
0.4989298582,
0.1882486492,
-0.1896293163,
-0.0096827261,
-0.7486733198,
-0.2896741033,
-0.4078723788,
0.3491078913,
-0.0740161315,
-1.2127370834,
-0.0340258293,
-0.0422945581,
0.0721043572,
0.2541008294,
0.8365472555,
-0.2068413943,
1.1705754995,
0.6740216613,
-0.6257315874,
0.5529315472,
-0.0909418091,
0.1966952384,
-0.9206880331,
-0.1990574449,
-0.5625528693,
-0.4563871622,
-0.2474753112,
-0.0046835425,
0.2678092718,
0.0403603129,
-0.2843494117,
-0.0102527337,
-0.2890248299,
0.3541487455,
0.0713186339,
0.0220005903,
0.336514622,
-0.0616713054,
0.0909982771,
-0.0340864994,
-0.4134043157,
-0.7653043866,
1.2450321913,
0.43610695,
0.8466442227,
0.3352589309,
0.6630982757,
-0.0763761476,
0.5989685059,
-1.025375247,
0.5026165247,
-0.1786952615,
-0.7378024459,
-0.5430806279,
-0.3312155902,
-0.9090221524,
0.2742367685,
-0.2234580666,
-0.9726573825,
0.0208265353,
0.4166616201,
-0.263061136,
0.285161078,
-0.8146620989,
0.699016273,
-0.7177076936,
-0.3531062603,
-0.218130827,
-0.7716421485,
0.5121770501,
0.1404103935,
0.1000353992,
-0.2353411764,
-0.0432955176,
0.6478898525,
-0.0234842934,
1.1022101641,
-0.0364651531,
-0.3273309767,
-0.023464404,
-0.3757544458,
0.4250612557,
-0.0730810016,
-0.2881482244,
0.0208191387,
-0.4420911372,
-0.1485882998,
-0.3630767465,
0.8335936069,
-1.0062954426,
-0.8190633059,
-0.2940671146,
-0.4735443294,
-0.6965218186,
0.2295427173,
0.1317229718,
0.2193394303,
-0.3800915182,
0.2298128754,
0.7752730846,
-0.0821479037,
0.268173337,
0.502861619,
-0.5628505945,
-0.2052450478,
0.8180601597,
-0.0823657215,
0.4573555589,
0.5073305964,
0.4965628088,
-0.7425767183,
-0.559779048,
-0.3261519969,
0.3880256414,
-0.670271039,
0.1361776292,
-0.5680631399,
0.015727926,
-0.4202200472,
-0.3176682889,
-0.4099637568,
-0.2551420033,
-0.4224546552,
-0.0507683977,
0.1310035139,
0.8183229566,
0.381840229,
0.2522590458,
-0.7063534856,
0.0416599773,
0.573453784,
0.5818414092,
0.2421590835,
-0.3398858011,
-0.1098682657,
0.1111250892,
-0.2550280988,
-0.542574048,
0.2633810341,
-0.2144212574,
0.669198215,
0.8561853766,
0.0448995233,
0.2769564092,
-0.2302113324,
0.7370305657,
0.3358892202,
-0.7334716916,
0.1897962242,
-0.310390383,
-0.0212009568,
0.5722885132,
0.6978140473,
-0.7901341915,
0.4533960819,
-0.3638924062,
-0.3925141394,
0.6848281026,
-0.5846179724,
0.1389842182,
0.1802155226,
0.4973478019,
0.1797389835,
0.3112632334,
-0.5124135017,
-0.323002249,
0.094731234,
-0.1026919186,
-0.4790186584,
-0.4351368845,
-0.0401619785,
-0.1931624562,
0.6258380413,
-0.1815871745,
-0.2386017889,
-0.3416468799,
-0.2124399841,
-0.1887952238,
0.7902889848,
0.5005717278,
0.7396909595,
-0.3491273522,
0.1975269616,
0.112195529,
-0.2494945824,
0.4002230763,
-0.4924631715,
-0.1912340224,
-0.5416280031,
-0.0271379482,
0.8368672729,
0.2420114279,
-0.7131225467,
0.5401799083,
-0.1413410604,
-0.1807515174,
-0.2183262259,
0.1692977548,
0.4982581139,
-0.1714474857,
0.0675916076,
-0.0696603879,
0.0236370955,
-0.5809831619,
-0.3623913825,
0.7883303165,
-0.7005898952,
-0.3874663711,
0.2120740414,
0.3257903755,
-0.2193641365,
0.5585568547,
0.1065772399,
-0.6396057606,
0.1065653637,
0.4998371899,
0.8621307015,
-0.4335851967,
0.0237413868,
0.2287648171,
-0.0832675323,
-0.2888396978,
-0.0242353734,
-0.2442763746,
-1.0764782429,
-0.273717016,
-0.7121889591,
-0.6606749296,
0.2022809833,
-0.5271077156,
0.4913704991,
-0.3067493141,
-0.3819870353,
-0.0500308871,
0.0530597828,
-0.4780484736,
0.0227670539,
0.2233041376,
0.7427872419,
-0.6856489182,
0.8738150001,
1.0862894058,
0.0109164044,
-0.8113595843,
-0.1309393197,
0.3103675842,
-0.6887901425,
0.637542963,
0.1037596688,
-0.3823570609,
0.0274922028,
-0.6015806198,
-0.6193184257,
0.7843922377,
0.4422744811,
-0.5936546922,
-0.0574495643,
0.0115807131,
0.3566008508,
-0.4772543311,
0.1306377202,
0.7739249468,
0.5917930007,
-0.0300671104,
-0.6591451764,
-0.3779759705,
-0.0091039287,
0.0495123342,
0.3174946308,
-1.0004353523,
0.4991747141,
-0.3186678588,
0.0191839486,
-0.0375692509,
0.472358197,
0.2668052614,
-0.0736160725,
0.8466562033,
0.2632798851,
0.5793665648,
0.1376431435,
0.9920774102,
-0.020934673,
0.2935598493,
0.9054538012,
-0.6485139132,
0.8820796013,
0.5953931212,
-0.4658742845,
0.1542363763,
0.7761083245,
0.3850340545,
0.2479355037,
0.2254930437,
-0.2452054471,
-0.638661921,
-0.2450807542,
-0.2476458251,
0.5476341844,
0.2546921074,
-0.1490768045,
-0.0310428757,
-0.1778053492,
-0.1565711945,
0.07858181,
-0.1530765891,
0.80155617,
0.1775398254,
-0.8789209127,
0.3773963451,
0.1249775589,
0.8161993623,
-0.6306246519,
0.1987323761,
0.1104623154,
0.117219381,
-0.3406596184,
-0.8209588528,
-0.1630903482,
-0.0779764131,
-0.5440621376,
-0.2664304078,
0.566775322,
-0.4314125776,
0.0352108292,
0.235765174,
0.2239008695,
0.0044782832,
0.1262898296,
-0.3663884401,
0.06301976,
0.1338646412,
-0.4087967575,
0.7069807649,
-0.2445106655,
-0.3428019583,
0.7829651237,
0.7106347084,
0.1070912108,
-0.0428464338,
0.222080037,
0.5823640823,
-0.7290791869,
-0.3927313685,
-0.747530818,
0.1875010878,
0.188528955,
-0.2464446425,
0.7285357714,
0.5440366268,
0.8728317022,
-0.1400068104,
1.0545278788,
0.3088863492,
0.5681617856,
-0.521630466,
0.5877119303,
-0.3965671957,
0.2450628728,
-0.1263621897,
-1.1105391979,
-0.2387630939,
0.4477412105,
-0.7154222131,
0.1722300351,
0.3019270301,
0.6070163846,
-0.0874920115,
0.1519681215,
0.351942271,
-0.1524977386,
0.2626996338,
0.5959925056,
1.2229771614,
0.245580256,
0.1133409217,
-0.2506432831,
-0.351105243,
-0.6059302092,
-0.9444707632,
-0.7794238925,
-0.6349257231,
0.0675023943,
0.0697682053,
-0.1027850136,
1.5700933933,
0.893745482,
-0.8395744562,
-0.6343629956,
0.2601868808,
0.2417280823,
0.2025704086,
-0.1033883542,
0.3458017409,
-0.2156144679,
-0.8783730865,
0.2707932889,
0.2067573667,
0.0956603363,
-0.5565294623,
-0.6513275504,
-0.1235182434,
-0.4019356668,
0.747842133,
0.51735425,
-0.9870646,
-0.5041943192,
0.2450550795,
-0.2816324532,
0.1258595139,
1.0135442019,
-0.4161699116,
0.3818669617,
0.5772876143,
0.6618462205,
0.3935986459,
-0.0060825991,
0.5235680342,
-0.4756741226,
0.0409008637,
0.0264030248,
0.5356500149,
0.5613004565,
-0.2605870962,
0.1821883768,
-0.161624074,
-0.6843640804,
-0.5580503345,
0.4262427092,
-1.0542434454,
-0.139309302,
1.2212259769,
0.2432873994,
-0.1227682456,
-0.1195631772,
-0.3313975632,
-0.0631655008,
-0.4648783803,
0.5616098642,
0.7357359529,
-0.3854438365,
0.0057857027,
-0.3052828908,
0.3427191377,
0.3838832378,
-0.5959550142,
0.2080397755,
0.7179778218,
0.4400066435,
-0.0974347144,
0.6651158333,
-0.1196111962,
0.0780927613,
-1.0099167824,
0.3878677189,
0.1149832532,
-0.3505017757,
-0.7587623,
-0.0068263155,
0.7976930141,
0.2371278703
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11190v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11190v1 | Aligning Large Language Models from Self-Reference AI Feedback with one General Principle | 2024-06-17T03:51:46 | 2024-06-17T03:51:46 | Rong Bao, Rui Zheng, Shihan Dou, Xiao Wang, Enyu Zhou, Bo Wang, Qi Zhang, Liang Ding, Dacheng Tao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In aligning large language models (LLMs), utilizing feedback from existing
advanced AI rather than humans is an important method to scale supervisory
signals. However, it is highly challenging for AI to understand human
intentions and societal values, and provide accurate preference feedback based
on these. Current AI feedback methods rely on powerful LLMs, carefully designed
specific principles to describe human intentions, and are easily influenced by
position bias. To address these issues, we propose a self-reference-based AI
feedback framework that enables a 13B Llama2-Chat to provide high-quality
feedback under simple and general principles such as ``best for humanity``.
Specifically, we allow the AI to first respond to the user's instructions, then
generate criticism of other answers based on its own response as a reference,
and finally determine which answer better fits human preferences according to
the criticism. Additionally, we use a self-consistency method to further reduce
the impact of position bias, and employ semantic perplexity to calculate the
preference strength differences between different answers. Experimental results
show that our method enables 13B and 70B Llama2-Chat annotators to provide
high-quality preference feedback, and the policy models trained based on these
preference data achieve significant advantages in benchmark datasets through
reinforcement learning. | [
-0.2661989033,
-0.4368439317,
0.6629231572,
0.5394522548,
-0.063100785,
-0.2400034964,
-0.4918340743,
-0.3948251009,
0.2607523799,
0.6366071105,
-0.4955472946,
-0.2640619576,
-0.4357175231,
0.1698506325,
-0.1424182504,
1.0969390869,
0.128490746,
0.0760361627,
-0.2700459063,
-0.1642127931,
-0.4765456915,
-0.6822815537,
-0.6003605723,
-0.6405643225,
0.6533093452,
0.6548988223,
0.9311916828,
0.7487495542,
0.60413903,
0.3546465337,
0.2110581398,
0.3788561523,
-0.4673597813,
-0.010774008,
-0.4629160762,
-0.2695415616,
-0.6636300683,
0.1325431764,
0.3843048215,
0.1994988769,
-0.327132076,
0.1891794801,
0.1902012527,
0.5012813807,
-0.3192133009,
0.2613457441,
-0.4569041729,
-0.185616523,
0.0283061005,
-0.17330046,
-0.5005731583,
-0.2527057827,
0.0244322736,
-0.5307161212,
-0.1610386521,
0.0512992628,
0.848305881,
0.7320392728,
-0.4613132179,
-0.0987077579,
-0.7654817104,
0.7666079402,
-0.8476896882,
-0.0198294036,
0.6479148269,
0.3180124462,
-0.1049904898,
-0.1397114545,
-0.6019823551,
-0.451481849,
-0.1079791635,
0.0687813163,
0.0695408285,
-0.0118500888,
-0.099141933,
-0.0600027777,
-0.1915842146,
0.557521224,
-0.2475102246,
-0.1726848036,
1.0584739447,
0.1422052979,
-0.0792562217,
-0.0530027188,
-0.334824115,
-0.3322288394,
-0.6880655885,
-0.1006945372,
0.3498859107,
0.3013362586,
-0.0795500055,
0.3865140975,
-0.3436528146,
0.3710279465,
0.7023425698,
-0.0901183113,
0.2893263996,
-0.1198176518,
-0.0421406589,
0.0614448823,
1.0079314709,
0.7263823748,
0.2488957494,
-0.1850905716,
-0.1319694966,
0.1434871405,
0.5660531521,
-0.6492441297,
0.0122907739,
0.1230415404,
-0.4680601954,
-0.4062286019,
-0.0672782511,
-0.5405443907,
-0.6186289787,
-0.4884473383,
0.3480574489,
0.0384624973,
-0.198322013,
-0.2236620635,
0.4011338353,
0.3833920062,
0.5955438018,
-1.2504739761,
0.1140282303,
0.5450434685,
0.3867950737,
-0.362959981,
-0.335370481,
-0.3500883579,
0.3812395036,
-0.3944823444,
0.9443263412,
-0.4767909348,
-0.2557656169,
-0.0708955675,
-0.18710877,
0.3726676702,
-0.6255397797,
0.4315770864,
-0.3116614521,
0.2110704035,
-0.2101097107,
-0.4822985828,
0.1183805987,
0.3631917536,
-0.3022478223,
0.9536571503,
-0.1521384418,
-0.4553052783,
0.2386322618,
-0.6472347975,
-0.1974715143,
-0.2000990808,
-0.3945697844,
-0.2961943746,
-0.1056399941,
0.4369422197,
0.4035038948,
-0.3661054671,
0.613755703,
-0.6017358303,
-0.0389104262,
0.2877086699,
-0.5203943253,
0.2192803174,
0.2366819233,
-0.4859469235,
0.6358073354,
-0.4547424912,
0.0563599169,
0.0042691967,
-0.342636615,
-0.0568786003,
0.1214559004,
-0.1511217803,
0.2224243581,
0.5453130603,
-0.4330797195,
0.3498082459,
-0.0829142481,
0.42322281,
1.2810937166,
-0.2370713204,
0.5237865448,
-0.3827266693,
0.2652017474,
-0.069342196,
0.272008419,
0.0208366849,
-0.0399832949,
-0.7500997186,
0.032670863,
0.0314159021,
0.3437498808,
-0.1848958582,
0.8853904009,
-0.3529577255,
-0.40588516,
-0.6360681057,
0.4186003208,
0.30653584,
0.5105543137,
0.4557134509,
-0.4137690365,
-0.4735544324,
-1.0682966709,
0.1402194947,
-0.7082131505,
-0.011937635,
0.3845895827,
0.0119575122,
-0.4022782147,
1.1043725014,
-0.1634132564,
-0.4267774522,
-0.1032454967,
-0.1173357517,
0.1242586225,
0.4784244001,
0.4085747898,
-0.4270327389,
-0.3153420687,
-0.1827850491,
-0.8445575237,
-0.322445184,
-0.1532401145,
-0.5089101195,
0.1416389048,
0.4514126778,
-0.3566527963,
0.0912742391,
0.6926095486,
-0.245405674,
0.1644836664,
-0.2722238302,
-0.0657415614,
-1.1647456884,
-0.0342089385,
0.014440787,
-0.3201801479,
-0.306440413,
-0.2827194631,
0.0900419503,
0.3942995071,
-0.1244214401,
0.7501769066,
-0.0509791933,
0.0724754184,
-0.4807778597,
0.122000739,
-0.1614136547,
0.5990657806,
0.0580010898,
0.8514168859,
0.1046165302,
-0.669988811,
0.5322859287,
0.5737949014,
-0.0122520905,
0.7871926427,
-0.6978958845,
0.4724807739,
-0.0201080777,
0.5841397047,
-0.8959383965,
-0.2193234563,
0.1281365901,
-0.4670494199,
0.1246153936,
-0.0843280181,
-0.2334844917,
-0.3025928736,
-0.2243716866,
0.058858905,
0.3433021307,
-0.6858228445,
0.607468307,
0.6162801385,
-0.1181266084,
-0.7958007455,
-0.534801662,
0.1119080111,
-0.1641425192,
-0.5150886774,
0.2411860377,
-0.2452517003,
-0.174625203,
-0.1282760799,
-0.1971227676,
0.0992332473,
0.0484031923,
0.4369904995,
0.4244478345,
0.0119230365,
0.1502154469,
-0.1554974616,
-0.258046627,
0.1050507501,
-0.3225924671,
0.5210843086,
-0.3177853525,
-0.4308770597,
-0.5993840098,
0.1030597016,
0.5615915656,
-0.1735210121,
0.4967677891,
0.3263850212,
0.1322591603,
0.0753417462,
-0.9440506697,
-0.366251111,
-0.5211277008,
0.3052909076,
-0.0194470081,
-0.9490942359,
0.2748689651,
0.09171395,
0.2782377303,
0.4921551645,
1.0142335892,
-0.3167536557,
1.1165448427,
0.6229477525,
-0.6903521419,
0.5122027993,
-0.0438784733,
0.1452969909,
-0.7849429846,
-0.1699097455,
-0.5064969063,
-0.3871511817,
-0.3571272492,
-0.0667434186,
0.1674346477,
-0.1727043092,
-0.6104490757,
0.1843772084,
-0.3968807161,
0.3789998293,
0.8015594482,
0.146548301,
0.1037212163,
-0.222009331,
0.0029102252,
0.132542789,
-0.4877805412,
-0.8902780414,
1.0518051386,
0.5195171237,
1.235906601,
0.1565103531,
0.7932337523,
0.4482409358,
0.6156696081,
-0.6406040192,
0.4770405591,
0.0870510116,
-0.5924425125,
-0.575835228,
-0.4143559337,
-0.7633094192,
0.1829772592,
-0.1830233037,
-0.6306060553,
-0.0700082928,
0.4902288318,
-0.4113969803,
0.0292075519,
-0.5951142907,
0.7344738245,
-0.4763373733,
-0.4269945323,
-0.4901345372,
-0.671828866,
0.0361716338,
0.1980770379,
0.1596646309,
-0.5436797142,
0.2507152557,
0.5763164759,
-0.443072021,
1.2249840498,
-0.2106352001,
-0.4186376631,
0.2389326245,
-0.034236297,
0.4184094369,
0.0985758528,
-0.0785271674,
0.1694214791,
-0.0005843864,
-0.2947567999,
-0.5995097756,
0.7002799511,
-1.4229136705,
-0.9776954055,
-0.2731390595,
-0.4826810658,
-0.4037776887,
0.1174839661,
-0.1379064173,
0.1062247232,
-0.1162943393,
0.1863135844,
0.2643824518,
0.0716102123,
0.3165630996,
0.6965427995,
-0.3469719291,
-0.4393888116,
0.6337946057,
-0.1355818063,
0.2151224911,
0.3722485006,
0.3457651436,
-0.5861022472,
-0.0865200907,
-0.7404087186,
0.2766386271,
-0.6314917803,
-0.4569826126,
-0.2147125751,
-0.069271937,
-0.5306592584,
-0.1227262467,
-0.4646823108,
-0.2550037205,
-0.1905347258,
-0.2020156682,
0.3086222112,
0.6394149065,
-0.3113085926,
0.4158339202,
-0.7312501669,
0.1800951511,
0.5022755861,
0.406811446,
0.1210582256,
-0.6744600534,
-0.1174697578,
0.1639830023,
-0.4642967582,
-0.5675828457,
0.1308145821,
0.0223926269,
0.5863316059,
0.6732305884,
0.244449392,
0.6540958285,
-0.3935022056,
0.6638870239,
0.1174276024,
-0.8645634651,
0.6440148354,
-0.2073770016,
0.1765897125,
0.7237992883,
0.1380418688,
-0.7860227823,
-0.2614420354,
-0.5207955241,
-0.6795060635,
0.7104219198,
0.0427956656,
0.4186944664,
-0.0274375733,
0.524140954,
-0.1043349057,
0.1245205402,
-0.7099984288,
-0.109771654,
-0.2746161222,
-0.4796610773,
-0.1308614761,
-0.2341132462,
-0.3808263242,
0.0253121853,
0.7721478343,
-0.3980298638,
0.253379792,
0.1191388816,
0.015820004,
-0.2569006979,
0.3799764216,
0.3290393353,
0.6746252179,
-0.0427249223,
0.1196736619,
0.2759913206,
-0.03601541,
0.4465557039,
-0.2473573536,
-0.2094936371,
-0.5258896351,
0.2251365781,
0.6538547873,
-0.0817258433,
-0.4929459095,
0.4480420351,
-0.0363347493,
0.1003222018,
-0.3899200857,
0.3384853899,
-0.0478250869,
0.362429291,
0.228836894,
-0.1259143651,
-0.2088298202,
-0.5772176385,
0.1606309116,
0.4592262208,
-0.3996375203,
-0.1548178792,
0.6050394177,
0.5420285463,
-0.3040905893,
0.7075496912,
0.1182211041,
-0.4089295864,
0.4168538153,
0.6326179504,
0.616002202,
-0.4008620381,
0.2813707292,
0.2086375952,
0.0071998164,
-0.2039318681,
0.0176926814,
-0.1823202819,
-1.0577654839,
-0.5088365674,
-0.3809637129,
-0.7535315156,
-0.0820726603,
-0.7499842644,
0.1540522426,
-0.7554524541,
-0.414737016,
-0.1688060462,
-0.0441069379,
-0.4920466244,
0.1349344403,
0.2482426465,
0.4734860957,
-0.6246652007,
0.9785060883,
0.5673413277,
-0.5823590755,
-1.0937125683,
-0.0151461139,
0.0576192141,
-1.1435695887,
0.530695796,
0.1543263644,
-0.3551827073,
-0.1761457175,
-0.8535395265,
-1.0600403547,
0.9165972471,
0.4123049378,
-0.6404858232,
-0.0731841996,
-0.0700638369,
0.6877371669,
-0.3743745685,
0.5128315091,
0.4967887998,
0.4729896188,
0.1204643771,
-1.1082437038,
-0.0414115861,
-0.2726811767,
0.0350203477,
0.025416201,
-1.183216691,
0.1425783336,
-0.2056809664,
0.1660079956,
0.0350605845,
0.9988940954,
0.1556008756,
-0.0231985077,
0.5552182794,
0.4281303287,
0.7083473206,
0.1542209834,
0.9780797362,
-0.4520986676,
0.2348560989,
1.4022831917,
-0.4716722667,
0.9091191888,
0.3873559535,
-0.1441074014,
0.5380954742,
0.569388032,
-0.0815035626,
0.4591541588,
0.1032410115,
0.193890065,
-0.3550073206,
-0.3393975794,
-0.2218077779,
0.4682258964,
0.1647524685,
-0.1642417312,
0.0388940684,
-0.3928539455,
0.2048295289,
0.1863218844,
-0.2185843587,
0.9809206724,
-0.0443649217,
-0.9819555879,
0.4641992748,
0.1715901345,
0.7001509666,
-0.6502171159,
0.0627072752,
-0.4014031291,
0.4270306528,
-0.1958272606,
-0.7174340487,
0.125736624,
0.1303367019,
-0.2731415927,
-0.259026736,
0.1913228929,
-0.3831633925,
-0.2140497118,
0.3121668696,
0.1562317163,
-0.0605625883,
0.1733531058,
-0.4928255379,
-0.0241322443,
-0.0264575928,
-0.0251085907,
0.3476056755,
0.1833670586,
-0.2255612612,
0.7706326246,
0.6045320034,
-0.018378295,
-0.2140357494,
0.0610678792,
0.6797152758,
-0.5743695498,
-0.5837600231,
-0.8899636865,
0.0793806538,
-0.1388394237,
-0.391061455,
0.609279573,
0.1658946127,
0.8799291253,
0.2376932353,
0.8048015833,
0.1210405678,
0.5141817331,
-0.3979898393,
0.4729999602,
-0.1961092204,
0.2493929118,
-0.1864885092,
-0.9861142635,
-0.1160712317,
1.0875860453,
-0.3816796243,
0.1062413231,
0.3269787133,
0.8365106583,
0.2115540504,
-0.2428046018,
0.1336630434,
0.3503314555,
0.6615057588,
0.3730333447,
0.9328143597,
0.0294602923,
0.5896471739,
-0.1217874065,
-0.1376174837,
-0.3378849924,
-0.860776186,
-0.7992434502,
-0.3431481123,
-0.2138050795,
-0.4501253664,
-0.0055422424,
1.5546357632,
0.941400826,
-0.8816676736,
-0.4665317237,
0.1944257468,
-0.1403681785,
-0.0062655224,
-0.1507630348,
0.4066841602,
-0.4871645868,
-0.5357208252,
0.3667590022,
0.3060694337,
-0.0300116222,
-0.6003851295,
-0.4359792173,
0.1141363606,
0.1855549216,
0.3282869458,
0.2610735595,
-1.0223324299,
-0.6960022449,
-0.1908559054,
-0.4265553653,
0.2882057726,
0.6288492084,
-0.6528048515,
0.1686412096,
0.0749756545,
0.9209820628,
0.4151861668,
0.2857138515,
0.7048338056,
-0.5067977905,
-0.0028150748,
0.1675674617,
0.2450164258,
0.4585792422,
-0.5388868451,
0.5267630219,
-0.2819788158,
-0.7918528914,
-0.3046406507,
0.1951964498,
-0.9058220983,
0.112768203,
1.2787349224,
-0.180880785,
-0.1314744204,
0.245236665,
-0.5772747993,
0.0232326854,
-0.8132817745,
1.2274413109,
0.6804816723,
-0.3036699295,
-0.1006978601,
0.0820569173,
0.3302089572,
0.7455170155,
-0.8930937052,
0.195192799,
0.6787675619,
0.1594411284,
0.1532026529,
0.8584942818,
0.0841062218,
0.0621879697,
-0.5020716786,
0.1628529578,
0.1153439283,
-0.4779020548,
-0.3680391312,
-0.0827160403,
0.5030441284,
0.016884977
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11177v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11177v1 | TIFG: Text-Informed Feature Generation with Large Language Models | 2024-06-17T03:29:14 | 2024-06-17T03:29:14 | Xinhao Zhang, Jinghan Zhang, Fengran Mo, Yuzhong Chen, Kunpeng Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Textual information of data is of vital importance for data mining and
feature engineering. However, existing methods focus on learning the data
structures and overlook the textual information along with the data.
Consequently, they waste this valuable resource and miss out on the deeper data
relationships embedded within the texts. In this paper, we introduce
Text-Informed Feature Generation (TIFG), a novel LLM-based text-informed
feature generation framework. TIFG utilizes the textual information to generate
features by retrieving possible relevant features within external knowledge
with Retrieval Augmented Generation (RAG) technology. In this approach, the
TIFG can generate new explainable features to enrich the feature space and
further mine feature relationships. We design the TIFG to be an automated
framework that continuously optimizes the feature generation process, adapts to
new data inputs, and improves downstream task performance over iterations. A
broad range of experiments in various downstream tasks showcases that our
approach can generate high-quality and meaningful features, and is
significantly superior to existing methods. | [
-0.557495892,
-0.7790256143,
0.647469461,
-0.0728807971,
-0.2278099507,
0.1662348062,
-0.3295974731,
-0.5027076602,
0.1672736555,
0.7728456855,
-0.6973465085,
-0.6587972045,
-0.4653974473,
0.0973909125,
-0.5322521925,
1.1641910076,
0.0760634542,
-0.3551256061,
-0.1254758835,
0.0395068824,
-0.3413568437,
-0.3049270511,
-0.5604081154,
-0.5549421906,
0.6645833254,
0.4375517666,
0.686596334,
1.0410488844,
0.3255438209,
0.205277577,
-0.0316614695,
0.4063415527,
-0.636138916,
0.3377326429,
-0.1241813451,
-0.424231708,
-0.334356755,
-0.2143377364,
0.4393537939,
0.5034044385,
0.3023092747,
0.4814466536,
0.1743254364,
0.6064762473,
-0.3949055076,
0.1998043805,
-0.8352357745,
0.0695969835,
-0.3920761645,
-0.2813127041,
-0.3007998168,
-0.31220752,
-0.001967791,
-0.3961572647,
0.6627089977,
-0.0228181295,
0.8370060325,
0.5650964379,
-0.328938514,
-0.3924551606,
-0.6075049043,
0.5406059623,
-0.4061875641,
0.2975944281,
0.4592128694,
0.0795582309,
-0.2896025181,
-0.7680668235,
-0.4855428934,
-0.0360223986,
-0.1864552647,
-0.1211553514,
0.4170848131,
-0.1114727333,
0.2349626124,
0.4967930317,
-0.540184319,
-0.083582364,
0.1351818889,
0.0520706438,
0.8208717108,
-0.1057193875,
0.1836383492,
-0.4397455156,
-0.3973928988,
0.0014134616,
-1.0028829575,
-0.0751532689,
0.3508118987,
0.4434435368,
0.0092713991,
0.6122277975,
0.0015385204,
0.5758182406,
0.0786516741,
-0.0996684432,
0.1906441301,
-0.0756547898,
-0.0546579659,
0.1262872815,
0.8588121533,
-0.0953187644,
0.1745804399,
-0.3618004918,
-0.4425937533,
-0.1026461124,
-0.0005386891,
-0.7552431822,
-0.0590606071,
0.1815984994,
-0.2985485792,
-0.7134252191,
0.2298993021,
-0.7745891213,
-0.6290350556,
-0.1406062841,
0.1478247941,
-0.516546011,
-0.5136107206,
-0.4120241106,
-0.0023084243,
0.0861985683,
0.079909794,
-1.0163129568,
-0.1543255448,
0.8020583391,
0.6776160598,
-0.2335387021,
-0.1533510834,
-0.9664191008,
0.4742197692,
-0.2969203889,
0.962434411,
-0.619291842,
-0.5102590919,
-0.0926610157,
-0.3198515773,
0.239915818,
-0.5300913453,
0.2864291668,
-0.3278444707,
0.2625935674,
-0.101134941,
-0.5166679025,
-0.3865717351,
0.0556098446,
-0.7419790626,
1.5651510954,
0.2325013578,
-0.996824801,
0.6644547582,
-0.6882804632,
-0.4921752214,
0.2799060941,
-0.3643380404,
-0.5474194288,
0.1852556169,
0.5128059983,
0.6739165187,
-0.4417084754,
0.731033504,
-0.5559303761,
-0.2885005176,
0.2096243948,
-0.2845408022,
0.3046819866,
0.2841757834,
-0.290864557,
0.0887788013,
-0.8703309298,
0.0895460248,
0.1709464788,
-0.4726860225,
-0.0330697708,
-0.0432923064,
0.1586445421,
0.1179762259,
0.2647681534,
-0.3485111892,
0.0256852675,
-0.4448852837,
0.3112304807,
0.5603342056,
0.2281984091,
0.6351886392,
-0.4654619992,
0.6435018182,
-0.3219516277,
-0.2921954691,
-0.4664710462,
-0.2443217486,
-0.6022732258,
-0.3176442087,
0.5212914348,
0.5666047931,
-1.010928154,
0.5871452093,
-0.2843898833,
-0.3146352768,
-0.2819524109,
0.3308762908,
0.2243691981,
0.4757080376,
-0.0878511816,
0.1943608969,
-0.4772806168,
-0.6362894773,
-0.1806937605,
-0.2192309648,
-0.2031951249,
0.3708524406,
0.1770398617,
-0.2310890108,
1.2122414112,
-0.589918673,
-0.1196061894,
-0.4869892001,
0.2548939884,
0.0891846865,
0.1244006157,
0.5717770457,
-0.9996299744,
-0.2232546508,
0.2622107565,
-0.7662107348,
-0.3552407622,
-0.2040452212,
-0.1864079684,
0.4077259004,
0.4529013932,
-0.4352680147,
0.2835912406,
0.5410664082,
-0.2285246402,
0.122335963,
-0.0867390335,
0.0515855104,
-1.3925573826,
0.2197717875,
0.1218715087,
-0.4169370234,
-0.3911243081,
-0.1586764604,
0.0095917499,
-0.3315624595,
-0.2002025545,
0.8908427358,
-0.5266206861,
-0.1272412241,
-0.3231805265,
0.0905129164,
0.0680951253,
0.4516210556,
-0.0314518027,
0.7168725729,
0.3243296444,
-0.5370451212,
0.2431528121,
0.188304022,
-0.0183400642,
0.1365151107,
-0.1086760238,
0.1919756532,
-0.0682010204,
-0.163791731,
-0.774500668,
-0.6064462662,
0.0444529019,
-0.7725263238,
0.5758961439,
-0.2648900747,
-0.6991679668,
-0.093140468,
-0.2732980549,
-0.0042234985,
0.3719855249,
-0.7676829696,
0.7524649501,
0.5202587247,
-0.5186120272,
-0.5810479522,
-0.676807344,
0.1313049942,
-0.2931053936,
-0.8842582107,
0.3849078417,
0.1597815603,
-0.0503796302,
0.15199624,
-0.0781520605,
0.0158446692,
0.1046895087,
0.428722024,
0.0256969519,
-0.1225321218,
0.6217826009,
0.0644988939,
-0.2386176288,
-0.107447736,
-0.0464556329,
0.5307120085,
0.1079961583,
-0.2019781619,
0.0931742042,
0.2974226773,
0.195624277,
-0.4548671842,
0.3049299419,
0.8946478963,
-0.427593112,
-0.694868505,
-0.4548698962,
-0.1507216096,
-0.4786848426,
0.5380437374,
-0.4974511862,
-1.0260931253,
0.4523135126,
-0.3640217483,
0.1020064428,
0.5458042622,
0.4387337267,
-0.1236496642,
0.9655031562,
1.1273483038,
0.1773661673,
0.600164175,
-0.1273803711,
0.1505142003,
-0.4893452823,
0.0028199577,
-0.4102049768,
-0.1730400324,
-0.7847057581,
-0.3089995682,
0.2793863416,
0.3060407639,
-0.0570121296,
0.0323011875,
-0.5343691707,
0.3259349167,
0.4023583233,
0.257208854,
0.2230780721,
0.1100335792,
-0.0716780871,
0.1329790503,
-0.7394329309,
-0.5856520534,
1.0650378466,
0.2786284983,
0.6739280224,
-0.2324984372,
0.9888990521,
0.2451170236,
0.4482009411,
-0.6694859266,
0.5452713966,
-0.3354762495,
-0.1524808854,
-0.2564045489,
-0.4997397661,
-0.6986907721,
-0.1694326401,
-0.7697662711,
-0.4665835798,
-0.2989917994,
0.1486290544,
-0.0648564026,
0.2763839662,
-0.8587867022,
0.5244281292,
-0.4289891422,
-0.4018260539,
0.0954488292,
-0.1558540314,
0.3772166371,
-0.4094370008,
0.0818335786,
-0.0570096672,
-0.0821604356,
0.3896812797,
-0.4836471677,
0.6412585974,
-0.1811538488,
-0.0509968735,
0.2168865055,
0.044269871,
0.6878362298,
0.3150077164,
-0.4278916121,
0.029278677,
-0.4896626174,
0.130729869,
-0.581058383,
0.6770341396,
-0.3993089199,
-0.6742745042,
-0.1502122432,
-0.6724849343,
-0.2385078222,
0.1817678958,
0.3857858777,
0.3041796088,
-0.1270833164,
0.1730964631,
0.8049003482,
-0.4165590107,
0.6044177413,
-0.0400724523,
-0.5493689775,
-0.5827270746,
0.9283006787,
-0.0155891962,
-0.0940424129,
0.6010778546,
0.0979915336,
-0.3946059644,
-0.6332902908,
-0.6588459611,
0.3377247751,
-0.453732878,
-0.3487136364,
-0.6765443087,
-0.4388616383,
-0.242435813,
-0.1961838305,
-0.0058453381,
-0.3461691737,
-0.3200943172,
-0.0899386182,
0.9270589352,
0.9916725159,
0.2773232162,
0.3028438091,
-0.9342344999,
0.3986728489,
0.0987717658,
0.5061225295,
-0.4460541904,
-0.1279514134,
-0.3340980709,
-0.1888154745,
-0.1965249032,
-0.752667129,
0.3942626417,
0.2390010804,
0.4872519374,
0.1868280023,
-0.0388395749,
0.2845028937,
-0.3288486302,
0.5795972347,
-0.1115979776,
-0.8222743869,
0.6638159752,
-0.601302743,
0.4303610027,
0.0673090592,
-0.1266020536,
-0.3218552768,
-0.563678205,
-0.6359078288,
-0.8555988669,
0.745857358,
0.2925820053,
-0.1806787401,
0.0650522783,
0.5949594975,
0.4236819744,
0.1576801538,
-0.6743608713,
-0.0122932466,
-0.0177478623,
-0.6383388042,
0.0621230341,
-0.249687776,
0.1147207096,
0.3974688649,
0.7455366254,
-0.5059819221,
0.0199652556,
0.0354214795,
-0.2584647238,
-0.0521752685,
0.117803596,
0.2842945158,
0.6505748034,
0.0219285414,
-0.033560399,
0.196894303,
-0.5107685924,
-0.1105716676,
0.4096132219,
-0.3882732987,
0.1883786172,
0.2604641616,
0.7815958261,
-0.1538305879,
-0.4228031933,
0.2584480047,
0.001173817,
-0.1506117135,
-0.2924092412,
0.3868106008,
0.2464086711,
0.4284706414,
0.4680897593,
0.0914332122,
0.0346892439,
0.0035988551,
0.4696496725,
0.4121487737,
-0.2636727393,
0.047882542,
0.6855210066,
0.2399049401,
-0.1803270876,
0.1317388862,
-0.00549092,
-0.2589908242,
0.6875811815,
0.1504411101,
1.0978155136,
-0.0081306212,
0.2522293627,
0.3578800559,
0.0962407291,
-0.0052749347,
0.2420198023,
-0.1510770023,
-0.5526302457,
-0.6504294872,
-0.8776240349,
-0.3022586405,
0.2656385303,
-0.2056524605,
0.7299178839,
-0.4286575317,
-0.3105282485,
-0.0518339276,
-0.1028362513,
-0.6380431056,
0.222531721,
0.2520193756,
0.6958755851,
-0.4833700359,
0.819850266,
0.782892406,
-0.2844288647,
-0.7524510026,
0.1566384435,
-0.0070082806,
-0.6848425865,
0.5648878813,
0.3509692252,
-0.181136772,
-0.0040553929,
-0.3236759305,
-0.8805125952,
1.1498878002,
0.6441822648,
-0.29539451,
0.0354104862,
0.422233969,
0.3422727287,
-0.5972751379,
0.0892126486,
0.246909678,
0.4255706072,
0.2917021215,
-0.6383165717,
0.1049780399,
-0.3882490396,
0.4331113398,
0.4733866751,
-0.4112412035,
0.4689366221,
-0.3132429123,
-0.3020163774,
-0.129272297,
0.6288223863,
0.3570406735,
0.2193783522,
0.554597497,
0.5573478937,
0.7561367154,
-0.2381727248,
0.8003053069,
-0.3984019756,
0.2274829149,
1.1626912355,
-0.1622676402,
0.7087012529,
0.2426995486,
0.2816609144,
0.1801492125,
0.782212317,
-0.1489136666,
0.2866124511,
-0.0041333162,
-0.3825626671,
-0.190865159,
-0.041820094,
-0.1729901582,
0.6113359928,
0.3655008078,
-0.6743896008,
-0.353202641,
0.102005139,
-0.0314894132,
0.2101519853,
-0.2720058858,
0.9781526327,
-0.1378505826,
-0.4872468114,
0.4535986185,
-0.0594408773,
0.747423768,
-0.5565047264,
-0.3052442372,
-0.3159228265,
0.1351973116,
-0.3631670773,
-1.0253863335,
0.2931082547,
0.3471125364,
-0.5403820872,
-0.5159990191,
1.0512607098,
-0.5702200532,
-0.4764223695,
0.0986370891,
0.5055966973,
-0.0739084631,
-0.2860797942,
-0.4548149705,
-0.1404734403,
0.2464545965,
-0.4695322216,
0.2531841695,
0.9957860708,
-0.2410087734,
0.812241137,
0.6974843144,
0.1968123764,
-0.0867004767,
0.0743258446,
0.7363793254,
-0.901871264,
-0.5627877712,
-0.7279000282,
0.6363375783,
-0.0944703072,
-0.0474425144,
0.2651732564,
0.6469883919,
0.7375433445,
0.1000011265,
1.1948174238,
-0.1239254177,
0.7349415421,
-0.709848702,
1.0224779844,
-0.4159753919,
0.3522726893,
-0.0016457144,
-1.1360039711,
-0.2376738191,
0.1681340933,
0.0077780355,
0.3106885552,
0.6048417091,
0.9003568292,
0.1135195047,
0.1759209633,
0.2921515107,
0.114134647,
0.4773582816,
0.3355224133,
0.5114995241,
-0.2709112167,
0.8047066331,
-0.1332490146,
-0.1794621348,
-0.0042635105,
-1.0146875381,
-0.9863964915,
-0.7356936336,
-0.1805121601,
-0.0453972295,
-0.2551474869,
0.830942452,
0.6066192389,
-0.5296057463,
0.0452083983,
-0.213971898,
0.3293234706,
0.2312861383,
-0.3049019575,
0.3822934926,
-0.5728616714,
-0.67307657,
0.1158194244,
0.4805092812,
0.0589003973,
-0.2598305643,
-0.0109141804,
-0.0192425568,
-0.3498847783,
0.5032415986,
0.0902658477,
-0.5229535699,
-0.3851872385,
-0.0467867926,
-0.0888060182,
0.1551996022,
0.7697600722,
-0.9810376763,
0.3286260366,
0.5683555603,
0.8843073845,
0.6852148175,
-0.1753509194,
0.8121961355,
-0.9264876842,
0.1826893389,
0.1203093454,
0.3185716867,
0.6306821108,
-0.8700560927,
0.7031098008,
0.0949548781,
-0.4812839925,
-0.6055749059,
0.2904450297,
-0.6789343953,
-0.2694025338,
1.2118000984,
0.0885461345,
-0.3802266419,
0.0733292848,
-0.2318163514,
0.4074563384,
-0.3527388275,
0.6807115078,
0.5915942192,
-0.1997706443,
-0.491928339,
-0.5268391371,
0.8532443643,
-0.1278891414,
-1.0275126696,
0.239594847,
0.5096085668,
0.2986466587,
-0.1486492455,
0.2858157754,
-0.17925933,
0.1176277325,
-0.0957189947,
0.442127645,
-0.2545252442,
-0.1584336907,
-0.0988997221,
0.3003408015,
0.1745860726,
0.0805962235
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11176v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11176v1 | Watch Every Step! LLM Agent Learning via Iterative Step-Level Process Refinement | 2024-06-17T03:29:13 | 2024-06-17T03:29:13 | Weimin Xiong, Yifan Song, Xiutian Zhao, Wenhao Wu, Xun Wang, Ke Wang, Cheng Li, Wei Peng, Sujian Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language model agents have exhibited exceptional performance across a
range of complex interactive tasks. Recent approaches have utilized tuning with
expert trajectories to enhance agent performance, yet they primarily
concentrate on outcome rewards, which may lead to errors or suboptimal actions
due to the absence of process supervision signals. In this paper, we introduce
the Iterative step-level Process Refinement (IPR) framework, which provides
detailed step-by-step guidance to enhance agent training. Specifically, we
adopt the Monte Carlo method to estimate step-level rewards. During each
iteration, the agent explores along the expert trajectory and generates new
actions. These actions are then evaluated against the corresponding step of
expert trajectory using step-level rewards. Such comparison helps identify
discrepancies, yielding contrastive action pairs that serve as training data
for the agent. Our experiments on three complex agent tasks demonstrate that
our framework outperforms a variety of strong baselines. Moreover, our
analytical findings highlight the effectiveness of IPR in augmenting action
efficiency and its applicability to diverse models. | [
-0.1410275698,
-0.3630303442,
0.4000888169,
-0.2265773416,
0.0055570668,
0.4737149179,
0.0366148688,
-0.0545839667,
-0.1501632929,
0.6326153278,
-0.7248690128,
-0.6847813129,
-0.6364169717,
-0.0471188724,
-0.1040739492,
1.0193818808,
-0.298597306,
0.1452726722,
-0.0401795357,
0.3392591178,
-0.07634148,
0.0422305502,
-1.3094321489,
-0.791669786,
0.7696746588,
0.7709846497,
0.2917769253,
0.7210072875,
0.5257885456,
0.4279714823,
0.0570768975,
0.5564866066,
-0.7318717241,
0.2574108839,
-0.4307412803,
-0.3202512264,
-0.4359199405,
-0.0786292478,
0.4363833368,
0.3349817693,
-0.3443158567,
0.0027712118,
0.0398399644,
0.8108682036,
-0.5795312524,
0.5536747575,
-0.6051473618,
0.118014589,
0.1037184671,
-0.7469879389,
-0.3901129067,
-0.103477858,
-0.2001330853,
-0.5967593193,
0.4826311469,
-0.0902865008,
0.6399515271,
0.510997355,
-0.5288196802,
-0.2243032455,
-0.8272822499,
0.4596908391,
-0.5255064368,
-0.0054539018,
0.104723528,
0.4647524953,
-0.4187537432,
-0.6293802857,
-0.3580355346,
-0.6134186387,
0.2164418846,
-0.0053960662,
0.0114742275,
0.4991281033,
0.5243161917,
0.1521199793,
-0.1767066419,
0.1204887405,
-0.2162460983,
-0.0343188345,
0.8055838943,
0.3994480073,
-0.0034327589,
0.6068279743,
-0.248174116,
-0.6230537295,
-0.6041947603,
0.5031810403,
0.3793928623,
0.5102926493,
0.2347958833,
0.4149210155,
-0.475432992,
0.4455084801,
0.36252141,
-0.3857418299,
0.1154935136,
-0.0136618707,
0.1513380855,
0.0267385077,
0.5373977423,
0.1760155559,
0.3433823586,
-0.2342143655,
-0.5024770498,
-0.3286803365,
0.6268156767,
-0.9187396169,
-0.2825532556,
0.2663391829,
0.2416450083,
-0.3429763615,
-0.0665326789,
-0.2461673915,
-0.6844775677,
-0.484295398,
0.6147155166,
-0.466086179,
-0.1619199961,
0.0180748291,
0.0243247133,
0.4600205421,
0.7508888841,
-0.5064948201,
0.285485059,
0.9855237007,
0.5025957823,
-0.020807052,
-0.4960015714,
-1.0410342216,
0.0636021569,
-0.6551102996,
0.9969925284,
-0.7164518237,
-0.0347725563,
-0.0034997594,
-0.1591309011,
-0.2012687176,
-0.7418959141,
0.3753441572,
-0.4863857329,
-0.3800162077,
-0.2859049439,
-0.4489688873,
-0.3505621552,
0.3743417561,
-0.5240259767,
0.8331387639,
-0.0337854475,
-0.4084727764,
0.5626461506,
-0.8774961233,
-0.4264889359,
-0.0880211443,
0.0041723871,
-0.4534011483,
-0.0202705599,
0.1973975301,
0.477889508,
-0.1392578483,
-0.0057852832,
-0.0911518857,
-0.6018586755,
-0.0181830321,
-0.0621715635,
0.1652961075,
0.1267008036,
-0.4871312082,
0.5847573876,
-0.9706887603,
0.0013000066,
-0.1633739471,
-0.3713984489,
0.2601203024,
0.088601239,
-0.5809956193,
0.2592155635,
-0.0413503647,
-0.4261805713,
0.2577395737,
-0.1692834646,
0.0824176893,
0.8600750566,
0.2528376877,
0.3961067498,
-0.4998740852,
0.6815760136,
0.3065055013,
0.0128873084,
-0.4816226065,
-0.0855926797,
-0.8895477057,
-0.5151205659,
0.0135687366,
0.5197119713,
-0.9039279222,
0.2893933356,
-0.1282879859,
-0.5047321916,
-0.7358751297,
0.1868579537,
0.308491379,
0.4230495393,
0.2256769985,
-0.2610679269,
-0.1062435508,
-0.6013838649,
-0.1823389381,
-0.1557227373,
-0.0463548042,
-0.1616037339,
0.503413558,
-0.0692515299,
0.676218152,
0.0415884517,
-0.1718755811,
-0.2814236283,
0.5900117159,
-0.0030016263,
0.5205537677,
-0.1323140562,
-0.4192064703,
-0.487945348,
0.1928079575,
-0.5225182772,
-0.0463098995,
-0.4148743749,
-0.1499698162,
-0.0681988522,
0.6333307624,
-0.3737538755,
0.4728294611,
0.0330884904,
-0.2420588732,
0.1806371957,
-0.4112331271,
0.3007712662,
-0.6530488729,
-0.0769796073,
0.1002487391,
-0.4225934446,
-0.8436193466,
0.3193868101,
-0.0965334177,
0.069398649,
-0.3497467041,
0.5317075253,
-0.5001446009,
-0.194853723,
-0.6467991471,
0.0209219716,
-0.2160545588,
0.6709496975,
-0.0254621431,
0.6784516573,
0.6860101819,
-0.7159291506,
0.4072490633,
-0.1615775228,
-0.1974226385,
0.5494050384,
-0.5170083046,
0.3184089065,
-0.4966773987,
0.229819566,
-1.0983641148,
0.0130377263,
0.4381995201,
-0.4405322969,
0.628901124,
-0.075080663,
-0.4918566644,
-0.1013487577,
-0.3155161142,
-0.0733545125,
0.2081471831,
-0.4306244254,
0.8871306777,
-0.1484282166,
0.0811379105,
-0.7718903422,
-0.1632399857,
0.0124617312,
-0.0595418401,
-0.4039172828,
0.044881247,
-0.226471141,
-0.3096159697,
-0.3414558172,
-0.3075001538,
0.0874056593,
0.2143596113,
0.3414607942,
-0.3559680581,
0.2377657145,
-0.089099966,
-0.0097476281,
-0.2828179002,
-0.0517688133,
-0.1081878617,
0.4156498015,
0.0146785062,
-0.7172700167,
-0.5925173759,
0.0731417388,
0.4005953074,
-0.2737199962,
0.4525463283,
0.8264147043,
-0.1053692251,
-0.4329888821,
-0.5267034173,
-0.3758324683,
-0.5087786317,
0.3544825315,
-0.6697112322,
-0.7741852403,
0.4984694123,
-0.2787627876,
0.3351119161,
0.0689020529,
0.3983554542,
-0.1281553954,
1.1588253975,
0.7334703803,
0.1468693018,
0.5968435407,
-0.3849622309,
0.2379648834,
-0.5217921734,
-0.4887644351,
-0.3762837946,
-0.3931669593,
-0.4926689863,
-0.7242895961,
0.35111022,
0.1847276986,
-0.5924311876,
0.0283704121,
-0.16565153,
0.617664516,
0.4577857256,
0.2132911682,
0.3480467796,
0.2158568949,
-0.0631989464,
0.2042273879,
-0.7466276884,
-0.5541170835,
0.9641584754,
0.4114466012,
0.8245503306,
-0.2796807587,
0.8699620962,
0.4786747098,
0.4889308512,
-0.7367635369,
0.7051109672,
0.2869639099,
-0.1000267267,
-0.4268355072,
-0.3418700695,
-0.8604819179,
0.3269912004,
-0.0253380947,
-0.5560391545,
0.0023991941,
0.2872798145,
-0.1091242656,
0.3251006007,
-0.2719024122,
0.5919228792,
-0.0580870323,
-0.6673282981,
-0.564686656,
-0.4047325253,
-0.0628300905,
0.0587230772,
-0.0112326425,
-0.2293684185,
-0.223049134,
0.2590571046,
-0.6398609877,
0.7740418315,
-0.3727393746,
-0.2772430182,
0.1784254462,
0.2313041687,
1.0390073061,
-0.2502726912,
-0.2689655721,
-0.2089617848,
-0.5585973263,
-0.6326810122,
-0.5860761404,
0.3888942003,
-0.5338086486,
-0.7137420177,
-0.2777227759,
-0.6060618758,
-0.2806438804,
-0.1039969474,
-0.0319804698,
0.2178283781,
0.1626390219,
-0.1516152471,
0.8186041117,
0.0789903775,
0.3052185178,
1.0711251497,
0.11418356,
-0.2499517351,
0.7148776054,
-0.1926051527,
0.2416891903,
0.7486889362,
-0.1718074083,
-0.0813838542,
-0.8165343404,
-0.2412172556,
0.1419539005,
-0.845290482,
-0.0868421495,
-0.4035796523,
-0.1137070581,
-0.1918158978,
-0.2249594778,
-0.4556536376,
0.0481023453,
-0.0635985956,
-0.4017829895,
0.3426334262,
0.7896103263,
-0.2637784779,
0.524887085,
-0.5314788818,
0.0522774495,
0.2911271453,
0.146677509,
0.0806270316,
-0.6085827947,
-0.4656932652,
-0.0449503548,
-0.3319962025,
-0.3607772887,
0.368840307,
0.2458309531,
0.7630916238,
0.5354585648,
0.0284735505,
0.7555536628,
-0.6029106975,
0.4986996651,
-0.059407983,
-0.7085420489,
0.4816813171,
-0.3166469038,
0.2794477046,
0.5887032151,
0.5134928226,
-0.2013015449,
-0.5453019142,
-0.4959736466,
-1.0891215801,
0.870441258,
0.058293853,
-0.1676406264,
0.2897639871,
0.6162416935,
0.0191740096,
0.3937229812,
-0.5310289264,
-0.1154345348,
0.1689796448,
-0.0578991361,
-0.2674731016,
0.1392084211,
-0.3803013861,
-0.1986679584,
0.7943260074,
-0.2990560234,
0.2021900713,
0.0811284184,
-0.1151500121,
-0.5051659942,
0.0634381548,
0.4862422049,
0.8525261879,
-0.1345032007,
-0.0368897393,
0.1000548378,
-0.0335577391,
0.3141748011,
0.2148866653,
0.1535231024,
-0.2554412484,
0.550232172,
1.0451153517,
0.1162270308,
-0.8295896053,
0.2941207886,
0.0245837737,
-0.3018137515,
-0.2844529152,
0.5059173703,
-0.203888461,
0.8933098912,
0.4813763201,
-0.1079987586,
0.2203136683,
-0.6135098934,
0.3617143035,
0.2322360873,
-0.5379841328,
-0.1299979091,
0.4394710362,
0.0474460907,
-0.4423892796,
0.3941161036,
-0.435018748,
-0.4854310751,
0.6248660088,
0.1850643158,
1.0292153358,
-0.3324719965,
0.5169746876,
0.3729207218,
0.3182537854,
-0.2950129509,
0.3168089986,
-0.3807724714,
-0.5834738612,
-0.6457574964,
-0.4724925458,
-0.7319154739,
-0.009997312,
-0.4053607285,
0.1717268676,
-0.4640262723,
0.1989593804,
-0.0993559584,
0.1470159292,
-0.6659838557,
0.3261686563,
0.0092795463,
0.809690237,
-0.7245287895,
0.8225206137,
0.9187007546,
-0.4698833525,
-0.7957155704,
0.186228618,
0.0280643739,
-0.9087082148,
0.7123216391,
0.0810676292,
-0.5830979347,
0.1704051644,
-0.6545737386,
-0.7770869136,
1.2328499556,
0.2060144991,
-0.6557078958,
-0.002506085,
0.2841030955,
0.8274424076,
-0.657769978,
0.6070192456,
0.5067174435,
0.2889049947,
0.6839573979,
-0.4694363773,
-0.0971839353,
-0.317897141,
0.0741693527,
-0.0046472023,
-0.6122970581,
0.751070559,
-0.5466260314,
0.0009284148,
-0.1561409533,
0.4958973825,
0.5362126231,
0.58992064,
0.6207833886,
0.4504330456,
0.7343902588,
-0.0840176418,
0.8569620252,
-0.5315122604,
0.1241064593,
1.0334764719,
-0.3590570986,
0.7162573338,
0.1160478741,
0.070959866,
0.5672786236,
0.8649848104,
0.2323089689,
0.4308532476,
0.5219759345,
-0.2914062738,
-0.5202711225,
-0.0596928783,
0.2060984522,
0.1685357243,
0.1871770173,
-0.1056793109,
-0.3625537455,
0.0837884471,
0.1694789231,
0.0861900002,
-0.7523303628,
0.8795337081,
-0.0718018785,
-0.6320548654,
0.4906791747,
-0.2058128715,
0.3092143834,
-0.7148820162,
-0.3511478603,
-0.3753905594,
0.443906486,
-0.1838751137,
-0.555116713,
-0.2371605635,
0.117620483,
0.1551950127,
-0.3217113912,
0.5283864141,
-0.5991213322,
-0.0954630971,
0.3031102121,
0.1937431842,
0.2542044222,
-0.3195237517,
-0.7055799961,
-0.2170349956,
0.0404245779,
-0.3974089622,
0.3148156404,
0.7192318439,
0.0695070848,
1.1564340591,
0.3088575006,
0.1021876931,
-0.1517276019,
0.1502179652,
0.7737551332,
-0.6499608159,
-0.189644441,
-0.5757126808,
1.0037032366,
-0.1630996466,
0.073415935,
0.4732577205,
0.3745765388,
1.0471650362,
0.1604252011,
0.6313897371,
0.4725573659,
0.5101732016,
-0.4532700479,
0.1606283039,
-0.6286821365,
0.5889569521,
-0.0977751985,
-0.8534461856,
0.0838482827,
0.5314474106,
-0.2287000567,
0.2142368853,
0.5836747885,
1.0536000729,
0.1916452646,
-0.3731070161,
0.3764554262,
0.1406403184,
0.5626504421,
0.3490769863,
0.8110010028,
-0.1821356565,
0.4285148382,
-0.2823902965,
-0.2348730117,
-0.1605512351,
-0.8855242133,
-0.7265483141,
-0.393018961,
-0.6710937619,
-0.139726758,
0.3902545869,
1.2579885721,
0.6764371395,
-0.8265516758,
-0.5476770997,
-0.156371817,
0.0366670303,
-0.5620718598,
-0.1390556097,
-0.1061385199,
-0.755414784,
-0.9143304229,
0.6267031431,
0.2863843143,
-0.2020919025,
-0.1464394778,
-0.2434855998,
0.0624633171,
0.0943301544,
0.400704056,
0.3451457322,
-0.4483422637,
-0.1192374304,
-0.3458221257,
0.0075542652,
0.2132392675,
0.9575864077,
-0.5341745019,
0.5610128045,
0.4293671548,
0.41932109,
0.819103241,
0.0784334093,
0.6973950863,
-0.6428487301,
-0.0936194584,
0.1838840246,
0.0572816953,
0.3465503156,
-0.2287179977,
0.7174034715,
-0.1398180276,
-0.6626702547,
-0.6906878352,
0.1712726951,
-0.829174161,
-0.039210286,
1.0977910757,
-0.2604213655,
-0.0529003888,
0.0747530013,
-0.2865223289,
0.4485237598,
-0.85109514,
0.9483891129,
0.441028446,
-0.5135040879,
-0.4886482358,
-0.4444825649,
0.6667810678,
0.0419157632,
-0.7871370912,
0.012825869,
0.4238195717,
0.2938087285,
-0.0367503352,
0.6738134027,
0.1734544784,
0.1297380924,
-0.0243041962,
0.3102867007,
-0.276661247,
-0.6702932715,
-0.6836898327,
0.0786749125,
0.5071289539,
-0.0652729347
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11173v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11173v2 | BSRBF-KAN: A combination of B-splines and Radial Basic Functions in Kolmogorov-Arnold Networks | 2024-06-17T03:26:02 | 2024-06-19T23:01:14 | Hoang-Thang Ta | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this paper, we introduce BSRBF-KAN, a Kolmogorov Arnold Network (KAN) that
combines Bsplines and radial basis functions (RBFs) to fit input vectors in
data training. We perform experiments with BSRBF-KAN, MLP, and other popular
KANs, including EfficientKAN, FastKAN, FasterKAN, and GottliebKAN over the
MNIST and Fashion-MNIST datasets. BSRBF-KAN shows stability in 5 training
sessions with a competitive average accuracy of 97.55% on MNIST and 89.33% on
FashionMNIST and obtains convergence better than other networks. We expect
BSRBF-KAN to open many combinations of mathematical functions to design KANs.
Our repo is publicly available at: https://github.com/hoangthangta/BSRBF-KAN. | [
-0.5003300905,
-0.6438443065,
0.1972799897,
0.7147544026,
-0.5873472691,
0.1219927371,
-0.0613529757,
-0.4184255004,
0.2690443993,
0.3532179296,
-0.5703148842,
-0.4136730731,
-0.3681482971,
0.1304617971,
-0.3513500988,
0.9982305765,
0.0344942734,
0.7732934356,
-0.0941938832,
-0.5504409075,
-0.3195292056,
-0.3871717155,
-0.4025474191,
-0.4561506808,
0.9217211008,
0.3527457714,
0.5787733793,
0.5029854774,
0.5756602883,
0.1753688604,
-0.0011391594,
0.0087067466,
-0.5111740828,
0.5715161562,
-0.1594872922,
-0.2697368562,
-0.0077371951,
-1.0732218027,
0.9121531248,
0.7283146381,
-0.4991455674,
0.1616924405,
-0.2767730057,
0.9783639312,
-0.5147558451,
0.0054822988,
-0.2846713066,
0.001076545,
0.0123230545,
0.2262794375,
-0.3164793551,
-0.7532598376,
0.3365319669,
-0.0782435834,
-0.0326294564,
0.1967537999,
1.0895400047,
0.0814315602,
-0.3150134981,
-0.1940097809,
-0.607008338,
0.5738697052,
-0.5185744762,
0.8073323369,
0.1674649566,
0.8129565716,
-0.1429776996,
-0.7203187346,
-0.2326655686,
-0.1254165769,
-0.0119977146,
-0.0336345732,
0.0055576721,
0.2644351125,
0.2287986428,
0.0982672498,
-0.5986679196,
-0.1536450088,
-0.7866684794,
-0.0213953648,
0.8098349571,
-0.0062605813,
-0.0417594947,
-0.052447293,
-0.6792668104,
-0.2824626565,
-0.6110248566,
-0.0610550828,
0.5726851821,
0.4312364161,
0.0694067627,
0.5890746117,
-0.1834922731,
1.1244909763,
-0.2730391324,
-0.0132138729,
0.163992852,
-0.0105982311,
-0.644510448,
0.3546611369,
0.6838518977,
0.0673421919,
0.1644075364,
-0.2173019946,
-0.2561146021,
-0.3368864059,
0.1122059077,
-0.9625302553,
-0.4145024717,
-0.1198958084,
-0.566087842,
-0.5900307894,
0.0985464081,
-0.7792707682,
-0.0976688415,
-0.4411844909,
0.8426628709,
-0.3766203821,
-0.2224382311,
-0.1402805299,
-0.2207143456,
0.380362004,
0.0527426265,
-0.5314275622,
0.5141958594,
0.1615507454,
0.9353832603,
0.4158587456,
-0.1189415902,
-0.3625362515,
-0.1868973374,
-0.4961654544,
0.5803329945,
-0.1281595826,
-0.5679283738,
0.02845552,
-0.02747255,
0.138146773,
-0.3290868104,
0.152072832,
-0.5511441231,
-0.407288909,
-0.486168623,
-0.1470175236,
-0.5805588365,
0.0235893931,
-0.679977715,
1.1273623705,
0.2419228852,
-0.4983377755,
0.1833910048,
-0.3454559445,
-0.6896815896,
0.0445693135,
-0.1404721141,
-0.806025207,
-0.1368345767,
-0.1525001526,
0.5896722078,
-0.1484338343,
0.2919677198,
-1.0898430347,
-0.3260188103,
0.3855093122,
-0.1249286309,
0.8453552723,
0.1980973035,
-0.102301918,
0.0797307715,
-1.1462931633,
0.2307691723,
-0.0193187762,
-0.2468638867,
-0.0497633331,
-0.2463954091,
0.4967396259,
0.0360517763,
-0.070799239,
-0.3332663476,
0.0896402448,
-0.0005122877,
0.3193156421,
0.9695474505,
0.1100388467,
-0.02477259,
-0.6117875576,
0.5482100248,
-0.4270691872,
-0.2807561159,
0.1956747472,
-0.5164984465,
-0.3461773098,
-0.6382821202,
0.5960034132,
0.2775659561,
-0.6704682112,
0.3867547214,
0.123980552,
-0.7825505137,
0.0811622739,
0.0659348369,
0.3770467043,
0.5646794438,
0.201412946,
-0.2025494725,
-0.9557232261,
-1.0684374571,
0.0590068996,
-0.0127505846,
0.3757664263,
0.5068028569,
0.3915420771,
-0.3442907333,
0.9290223718,
-0.5182228684,
-0.0026885266,
-0.2684444487,
0.1131749824,
0.2457376719,
0.3799504638,
0.8997344971,
-0.7496733665,
-0.8706706166,
0.2908638716,
-0.4789158404,
-0.0281227883,
0.2039463818,
-0.3891825974,
0.3430487514,
-0.033991646,
-0.355162859,
0.4424413145,
0.5914197564,
-0.2004899383,
0.8811278343,
-0.0809881091,
-0.1371898204,
-1.0945065022,
0.4784484208,
0.1465534866,
-0.7022808194,
-0.45039621,
-0.0321206711,
-0.0074569448,
-0.4577406645,
-0.1595704556,
0.3483079672,
-0.1014598608,
-0.4586642981,
0.198427543,
-0.347845763,
-0.3219080567,
0.847964406,
-0.1167862937,
0.509516716,
0.8323683143,
-0.4970889986,
0.5256500244,
0.3783272207,
-0.1698355973,
0.4458967745,
-0.8513867855,
0.2609760165,
-0.3352999389,
0.1174480096,
-1.2356387377,
-0.4322764874,
0.528224349,
-0.4717365503,
0.5628041029,
-0.376681298,
-0.3661530316,
-0.2899295986,
-0.1781978458,
0.2802710831,
0.3763872385,
-0.5670992732,
0.59107548,
0.28488639,
0.0155384606,
-1.0505868196,
-0.6369444132,
-0.5727462173,
0.0437180474,
-0.6787573099,
-0.1599502563,
-0.0050320998,
0.1053101569,
0.4443582296,
-0.5283629894,
-0.4383102357,
-0.1148724034,
0.233011052,
0.4561987817,
-0.5041220784,
-0.1756993681,
0.0601849891,
0.4441158772,
-0.2293486893,
-0.2371314317,
0.6738758683,
-0.4441632628,
0.1198713407,
-0.2386277169,
0.1996137351,
0.6937363148,
0.1752329171,
0.9543271065,
0.5315466523,
-0.5928405523,
-0.3955309093,
-0.1721092463,
0.0592167564,
-0.4559032023,
0.5232265592,
-0.1330347806,
-0.61543262,
0.5052508116,
0.2687619627,
-0.1103984267,
0.0562863834,
0.3520267904,
-0.2849472165,
0.9873145223,
0.4672629833,
0.1278115213,
0.6013609171,
-0.5114126801,
0.2539944649,
-0.6896622181,
-0.4024222493,
-0.4597567618,
-0.6921111941,
-0.5633234382,
-0.0618873686,
0.1013033912,
0.5672784448,
-0.5337684751,
0.8544083834,
-0.4751290083,
0.1611403078,
0.3189736009,
0.3346282244,
-0.3609666228,
0.1117167324,
-0.1274959445,
0.2749970555,
-0.9804140329,
0.1288604885,
1.3825808764,
0.4240357578,
1.0009489059,
0.2907144129,
0.6579113007,
0.0814244673,
0.4573753774,
-0.9636750817,
0.5719532371,
-0.0496603996,
-0.7792010903,
-0.4417952299,
-0.7050077915,
-0.5681343675,
0.1901249588,
-0.4138808548,
-0.6781836152,
0.5336609483,
0.6811726689,
-0.2805628181,
0.109683007,
-0.8116113544,
0.5605438948,
-0.4018605053,
-0.2673729956,
-0.1164579093,
-0.6978704333,
0.3102651834,
0.1668799669,
-0.0864848346,
0.137889713,
0.5792993307,
0.78456074,
-0.5573431849,
0.4821861982,
-0.2459728718,
0.5596246719,
0.3802908361,
-0.0558508746,
0.5104931593,
0.2428921312,
0.2004335821,
0.3045650721,
0.2970427871,
-0.3413204849,
-0.6691775322,
0.5464677811,
-0.7542179823,
0.1833065599,
-0.5865457654,
-0.1601828486,
-0.2257575244,
0.5569826961,
0.1795017123,
0.9852438569,
-0.000985124,
0.8607394099,
0.6669765115,
0.2950900197,
0.2537841499,
-0.2747047544,
-0.4709560573,
-1.1389255524,
1.1471607685,
0.251505971,
0.1738958955,
0.1864109933,
0.2146953642,
-0.4800240695,
-0.1298403293,
-0.6613753438,
0.4116777778,
-0.8868522048,
-0.5603694916,
-0.150470376,
-0.5387559533,
-0.1978701204,
-0.212417841,
-0.073228389,
-0.4688246846,
0.1631688029,
0.0770627335,
0.3076688349,
0.893045485,
-0.2701084316,
0.4114988148,
-0.4547091424,
-0.0105515933,
0.343926847,
0.4580798149,
0.1298339516,
0.1134865955,
-0.3989803791,
0.0346458331,
-0.2743373215,
-1.0031994581,
0.204997614,
0.1291718632,
0.5682677627,
0.4524048269,
-0.3765235543,
0.5324017406,
-0.5082494617,
0.0731756687,
0.7945016026,
-0.6417532563,
-0.1383848488,
-0.4990012646,
-0.2366143018,
0.3553799689,
0.6362882257,
-0.4673592448,
0.1051928475,
-0.5453608036,
-0.6115767956,
0.7935703993,
0.517121315,
-0.5041235089,
0.4661837518,
0.1367533803,
-0.1565157622,
0.7624617815,
-0.6017676592,
-0.5546573997,
-0.7502985001,
-0.6587848663,
0.2271864265,
-0.2150710821,
-0.2927283943,
-0.3396415412,
0.7330631018,
0.0094260601,
0.6549627185,
0.3712039292,
-0.0555840619,
-0.326592356,
-0.4561572969,
1.0403424501,
0.989682734,
-0.5946783423,
-0.1106065363,
0.1018221229,
-0.5949394703,
0.061650902,
0.1843236983,
-0.0196378473,
0.2174750566,
0.1566307545,
1.1194741726,
0.4750690758,
-0.3600883186,
0.1008799598,
-0.0207494926,
-0.3467947841,
-0.3020060062,
0.1667433381,
-0.0250462964,
0.1847490221,
0.2993238866,
0.6733211875,
-0.1515023708,
-0.5537619591,
0.5465142131,
0.4383350313,
-0.4019492269,
-0.3371797204,
0.3046774566,
-0.0651145279,
-0.7050314546,
0.1567128897,
-0.0682351962,
-0.7297439575,
0.7935692072,
0.6865141988,
0.6959763765,
-0.1349747628,
0.1601120234,
0.6926664114,
0.1434073448,
-0.2403825372,
0.1469737142,
-0.3700251579,
-0.6248613596,
-0.2322811484,
-0.8551937342,
-0.342654407,
0.2131727636,
-0.8602355719,
0.6410903931,
-1.0338414907,
-0.082215257,
-0.0600649863,
-0.0537708998,
-0.6151541471,
0.3176272213,
-0.0801253244,
0.9125987291,
-0.6314362288,
0.483892411,
1.0124107599,
-0.2856204212,
-0.8792510033,
-0.1588377506,
-0.4315405786,
-0.8677006364,
0.6757340431,
0.2427920401,
-0.2491636425,
0.1205113754,
-0.5260077119,
-1.0562469959,
1.2599499226,
0.2895520926,
-0.687227428,
-0.0868159458,
-0.3364464939,
0.2365303338,
-0.0616678521,
-0.1699083298,
0.1328556836,
0.2291852981,
0.508228898,
-0.3845282495,
-0.2710346282,
0.0231597405,
0.4021258354,
0.5001456738,
-0.7170058489,
0.3246812224,
0.1459483504,
0.1395302117,
0.2879939973,
0.457142055,
0.6187598109,
0.2666544914,
0.492962718,
0.8137710094,
0.4912290573,
-0.1085647494,
0.4923118949,
-0.1442437619,
0.9097642899,
0.752767086,
0.0700473413,
0.5532696247,
0.2200519443,
-0.2506369948,
0.7672858834,
0.5698375702,
-0.0207922868,
0.9414565563,
0.3486410379,
-0.1791448444,
-0.1739206165,
0.7029282451,
-0.4736451507,
-0.0325044468,
0.3605557978,
-0.0365534164,
-0.410812825,
0.0612860769,
-0.185075596,
-0.4109805822,
-0.3935480416,
0.1585696936,
0.244079262,
-0.2288925201,
0.5592175722,
-0.0559944101,
0.1490309238,
-1.0592917204,
-0.2196272016,
0.0866340622,
0.0367909968,
-0.1823153198,
-0.6915418506,
0.3118008971,
-0.4139380753,
-0.0849113315,
0.146150291,
0.9274855852,
-0.4215806127,
-0.6895507574,
0.1629995555,
-0.5432405472,
-0.1497523487,
0.6644513011,
-0.5212824941,
0.2622679472,
-0.0394105464,
-0.0444458537,
0.0431530438,
0.2739699483,
0.1117860377,
0.73537606,
0.8824995756,
0.3069724739,
0.327555567,
-0.397747308,
0.561932981,
-0.362873137,
-0.5903436542,
-0.5503599644,
0.61589849,
-0.2506958246,
-0.5506914258,
0.3008399308,
0.3720280826,
0.7992902994,
-0.0980038121,
0.6434959769,
-0.3663749993,
0.2208593935,
-0.4985801578,
1.0184284449,
-0.5820575953,
-0.30314821,
-0.1572741419,
-1.0058012009,
-0.3976972997,
1.2256377935,
0.1056945771,
0.1670226306,
0.5207766294,
0.7190542221,
-0.2195430249,
-0.0330612101,
0.3785144389,
0.0661131889,
0.0477593727,
0.1493379176,
0.4349574447,
-0.3942839503,
0.4712297022,
-0.6291435361,
-0.0821811706,
-0.76585114,
-0.7188448906,
-1.1406236887,
-0.821975708,
-0.0235990304,
-0.6364569664,
0.2092237771,
1.1346890926,
1.0034555197,
-0.829598546,
-0.3212328255,
-0.5959525108,
0.2387865335,
-0.3400136232,
-0.2171953768,
0.4046008885,
-0.3304473758,
-0.1070981175,
0.0983424038,
0.2590453625,
0.1422236115,
-0.3227133751,
-0.3438114822,
-0.1705552936,
0.2121083587,
0.4681467414,
0.6240161657,
-0.0980609283,
-0.2954223454,
0.2078833878,
0.1580210477,
-0.1731436998,
0.663425684,
-0.5985919237,
0.5682596564,
0.6088938117,
0.8976494074,
0.6233767271,
-0.0315322131,
0.7508580685,
-0.7886035442,
0.2572537661,
0.4007322788,
0.5637443662,
0.2589841485,
-0.3710089922,
0.3437573016,
0.5767410994,
-0.676297605,
-1.52087605,
0.2926743925,
-1.0741083622,
0.0018709501,
0.9255679846,
0.1832389832,
-0.6561353207,
0.2565104663,
-0.3473725021,
0.2517305017,
-0.3596520126,
0.5099253058,
0.9766004086,
-0.1713175029,
-0.1617998928,
-0.2786724567,
0.6071247458,
0.3009441495,
-0.1389261037,
-0.5098622441,
0.132680282,
0.610881865,
0.0265729129,
0.401976943,
0.2414896339,
0.7745188475,
-0.2345298231,
-0.0839903578,
-0.3612583578,
-0.7001693249,
-0.3829788566,
-0.129000932,
0.080187425,
-0.4636667967
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11172v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11172v1 | Enhancing Criminal Case Matching through Diverse Legal Factors | 2024-06-17T03:23:11 | 2024-06-17T03:23:11 | Jie Zhao, Ziyu Guan, Wei Zhao, Yue Jiang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Criminal case matching endeavors to determine the relevance between different
criminal cases. Conventional methods predict the relevance solely based on
instance-level semantic features and neglect the diverse legal factors (LFs),
which are associated with diverse court judgments. Consequently,
comprehensively representing a criminal case remains a challenge for these
approaches. Moreover, extracting and utilizing these LFs for criminal case
matching face two challenges: (1) the manual annotations of LFs rely heavily on
specialized legal knowledge; (2) overlaps among LFs may potentially harm the
model's performance. In this paper, we propose a two-stage framework named
Diverse Legal Factor-enhanced Criminal Case Matching (DLF-CCM). Firstly,
DLF-CCM employs a multi-task learning framework to pre-train an LF extraction
network on a large-scale legal judgment prediction dataset. In stage two,
DLF-CCM introduces an LF de-redundancy module to learn shared LF and exclusive
LFs. Moreover, an entropy-weighted fusion strategy is introduced to dynamically
fuse the multiple relevance generated by all LFs. Experimental results validate
the effectiveness of DLF-CCM and show its significant improvements over
competitive baselines. Code: https://github.com/jiezhao6/DLF-CCM. | [
-0.3782270849,
-0.5283512473,
0.8228861094,
0.1396917403,
-0.571916759,
0.3691032231,
-0.0658480376,
-0.6345968843,
-0.0287538469,
0.5618696809,
-0.4888629317,
-0.4368411899,
-0.3827097714,
-0.036612656,
-0.2698135078,
0.9287292957,
0.2406543493,
0.2649948597,
-0.2735038698,
-0.4579860866,
-0.7658812404,
-0.5370900631,
-0.2901313603,
-0.3669910729,
0.409394443,
0.2587471008,
0.3615910709,
0.5106390715,
0.7356204987,
0.3100968599,
0.2155175209,
0.2182939798,
-0.3928874433,
0.2614525557,
-0.4496497512,
-0.2923738062,
-0.3156006634,
-0.1335761696,
0.0971473157,
0.2496937513,
-0.323500216,
-0.1828406453,
-0.2292326242,
0.6287274361,
-0.9730955958,
-0.056510482,
-0.708566308,
0.1855990738,
-0.4372620881,
-0.364706248,
-0.2280671299,
-0.1893506199,
0.0168978255,
-0.7900162339,
0.4336042702,
0.0020327652,
0.6643466949,
0.2712945342,
-0.8348320723,
-0.0848218352,
-0.7133842707,
0.1936947852,
-0.4925836921,
0.0172136314,
0.3159986138,
0.4141816199,
-0.1965270638,
-0.3719008267,
-0.6778148413,
-0.0225031525,
-0.3120951951,
0.2983277738,
0.0988495052,
0.2858116031,
0.3565458953,
0.3479353189,
-0.4538778067,
0.1572564393,
-0.3236042261,
-0.5160406232,
0.6137388945,
0.316078186,
0.220713079,
0.3235589862,
-0.2812280059,
-0.2644563913,
-0.5475773215,
0.1424773037,
0.736056149,
0.7483274937,
-0.1383765936,
0.3729633987,
-0.3094070554,
0.5299770236,
0.388816148,
-0.35388574,
0.7739686966,
-0.8128156662,
-0.164126426,
0.1395469308,
0.7382210493,
0.4819649756,
0.0518170334,
0.0553308502,
-0.1405010372,
-0.1557428688,
0.1951691061,
-0.6747199297,
0.0983317941,
0.332192868,
-0.312106967,
-0.3178869784,
0.5192437768,
-0.7709141374,
-0.9063274264,
-0.2555958927,
0.3098951578,
-0.2934218347,
-0.3436327279,
0.0112248696,
-0.2885788381,
0.5635563731,
0.4545477927,
-0.4854745567,
-0.0838037878,
0.9099238515,
0.4843546152,
-0.1813163906,
0.2414981574,
-0.922793746,
0.1353659481,
-0.1005149037,
0.4167067111,
-0.7909849882,
0.0256573446,
0.3036758602,
0.0550016016,
0.261564374,
-0.6194725633,
0.8236322403,
-0.7105291486,
-0.1144743189,
-0.6257870793,
-0.2658422887,
-0.169019267,
0.2352050394,
-0.7627291679,
0.6767861247,
0.0088047162,
-0.6748908758,
1.0184326172,
-0.4030377269,
-0.8531872034,
0.499902308,
-0.1972483546,
-0.691269815,
0.0146239642,
0.1421433538,
0.488429755,
-0.0824320242,
0.4558759034,
-0.8436408639,
-0.3361510634,
-0.0808858871,
0.1057829335,
0.7902178764,
0.4093643427,
-0.2675839067,
0.1180899367,
-0.7834592462,
-0.5417023301,
-0.0310445223,
-0.4383744001,
-0.3013948798,
-0.0393379182,
0.1790421307,
0.3589479029,
0.1253738552,
-0.5982849598,
-0.2502624393,
-0.0802368522,
0.2734285891,
0.5239088535,
-0.024379272,
0.4516912103,
-0.3404832482,
0.5002161264,
0.3494090438,
-0.2464399636,
-0.118536368,
-0.121201314,
-0.4205918908,
-0.4365415573,
0.2057457566,
0.9823640585,
-0.6189445853,
0.5401511192,
0.0812978968,
-0.2190767676,
-0.446963191,
0.2284404039,
0.0353621878,
0.0745933056,
0.3585887849,
-0.3949953616,
-0.6319985986,
-0.7937347889,
-0.4091051519,
-0.0172192454,
0.0899068713,
0.6052876711,
0.5223847032,
-0.0211417153,
0.7593404055,
-0.0748511702,
-0.8168569207,
-0.1412691325,
-0.0685001686,
0.4311234355,
0.439662993,
0.7299599648,
-0.9192931652,
-0.5949263573,
0.2203646004,
-0.6023980975,
-0.0447955206,
-0.4268183708,
-0.176655218,
-0.4444637299,
0.5522514582,
-0.4133573174,
0.2622634172,
-0.1583363414,
-0.6843398213,
0.1766845733,
-0.1669551283,
0.5649938583,
-0.8143202066,
-0.2097945958,
0.2341257334,
-0.5233946443,
-0.7530106902,
0.5450575352,
0.0978640765,
-0.0871503726,
-0.6563609242,
0.2189428955,
-0.4047775865,
0.0127250394,
-0.1703121513,
0.3575499952,
-0.1769021302,
0.5077144504,
-0.2854976654,
0.4299108684,
0.7232262492,
-0.2497711778,
0.4432739615,
-0.197028622,
-0.4268508554,
0.99998945,
-0.3490483463,
-0.0467531607,
-0.2965529263,
0.0402715243,
-0.5941721797,
-0.1280388981,
0.3318317235,
0.2365917265,
0.5364518166,
-0.2002701014,
-0.5087050796,
-0.2400565594,
-0.3304622471,
0.7204656005,
0.0958759636,
-0.3648819625,
0.9977099895,
0.3929891884,
0.0496598706,
-0.6918131709,
-0.4009673595,
0.0498649292,
-0.5532879233,
-0.3486411572,
0.6854686141,
-0.0259221476,
-0.2367254198,
-0.0821750909,
-0.048803281,
-0.1746475995,
0.3379879892,
0.430441916,
0.223097682,
0.0097365789,
0.1809828728,
0.025723841,
0.4246635437,
-0.0242268685,
0.0328480415,
0.4370399117,
-0.1263733208,
-0.4612821341,
-0.0808817893,
0.5211023092,
0.5767073631,
-0.3258495629,
0.4868607223,
0.7461366653,
-0.3089735806,
0.0542792454,
-0.8703926802,
0.1198423952,
-0.4759510756,
0.6075922847,
-0.4355876446,
-1.1616784334,
0.596544683,
0.0765498355,
0.0764524862,
0.377050221,
0.7520259023,
0.162013337,
0.4474600255,
0.6800127625,
-0.3027309179,
0.7123808861,
0.4772443473,
0.3888896704,
-0.5327265859,
-0.5192702413,
-0.3582085371,
-0.2194634974,
-0.6192688346,
-0.3575478792,
0.1493223161,
0.188622728,
-0.2461754382,
0.3746765554,
-0.2081286162,
0.668366313,
0.5078608394,
0.5378616452,
0.328423053,
0.0347843915,
-0.3801002502,
0.4674373567,
-0.4593325853,
0.1896776706,
1.2898253202,
0.1172233522,
0.1917769313,
0.5133239031,
0.5954236388,
0.4464642406,
-0.1004387289,
-0.5761665106,
0.5322147012,
-0.4547237754,
-0.7221215367,
-0.2600837946,
-0.5699318647,
-0.7261203527,
0.5475651622,
-0.8865708709,
-0.4920438528,
0.4361546636,
-0.3017432988,
-0.7196731567,
-0.0086942781,
-0.1841991544,
0.448374629,
-0.2674922347,
-0.654153347,
-0.6279212236,
-0.4338670671,
0.6522234082,
-0.4568701386,
0.3933171332,
-0.5235162377,
0.3080265224,
0.5180917382,
-0.4668980837,
0.4936454296,
-0.1960982084,
0.0709633678,
0.2556068599,
-0.1400859654,
0.380826205,
0.3635903597,
-0.0029601797,
-0.0289238133,
0.0525431149,
-0.1924404502,
-0.3574079573,
0.5878732204,
-0.3823314607,
-0.8596387506,
-0.4750015736,
-0.9049769044,
-0.0159995183,
0.2519108653,
-0.1861852407,
0.2306680828,
-0.2028156519,
0.4758325517,
0.4215503335,
-0.0648951828,
0.4770451784,
0.6621874571,
0.4717324078,
-0.4190614522,
0.5701500773,
-0.3461033106,
-0.2765265405,
0.5052750111,
0.0514742285,
-0.0967187062,
-0.4539539218,
-0.1440905184,
0.044652883,
-0.8077982664,
-0.4736590683,
-0.5051577091,
0.2341552824,
-0.3188820779,
0.1494416893,
0.0427189879,
0.0010891078,
-0.1042611897,
0.041187346,
0.2927531898,
0.1922127157,
-0.1871908754,
-0.0215753578,
-0.5418139696,
0.4436162412,
0.4141020179,
0.4520279467,
-0.2920351624,
-0.4503396451,
-0.2036495358,
-0.0635595769,
-0.023643801,
-0.6539972425,
-0.1811106056,
0.3831151724,
0.7612112761,
0.4335557818,
0.2587538958,
0.7635887861,
-0.4081788063,
0.3802112341,
0.4827943444,
-0.7176542878,
0.4674121737,
-0.1091563255,
-0.031512361,
0.9356191158,
0.2707220912,
0.1141586006,
-0.4027524889,
-0.0434604213,
-0.8051777482,
0.7617812157,
0.3622565866,
0.0449802205,
0.298745513,
0.5855671763,
-0.0593799949,
0.1125944629,
-0.7475740314,
0.0281787254,
-0.1371724755,
-0.3747569919,
0.1275918037,
0.0814327896,
-0.4008539319,
-0.4295481443,
0.5614122748,
-0.2372952253,
-0.0495584235,
-0.0113966344,
-0.1402942538,
0.0928697288,
0.0610440746,
0.5020364523,
0.3408080935,
-0.1620910168,
-0.1781539172,
0.2822680473,
-0.3925433457,
0.3332893848,
0.123555325,
-0.0774622709,
-0.3908239007,
0.7043882012,
0.703789711,
-0.3616783917,
-0.7562845945,
0.6205013394,
-0.2372191697,
-0.4798823297,
-0.2565139234,
0.4316919148,
-0.3093889952,
0.8002846241,
0.5500436425,
0.0848595127,
0.1462568939,
-1.0425812006,
0.5368111134,
0.7302796841,
-0.5767717957,
0.3098505139,
0.5345653892,
0.3336216211,
-0.1054210737,
0.4122445881,
-0.4264443815,
-0.6938765645,
0.6590232253,
0.2315808684,
0.7074662447,
0.156866312,
-0.0773233026,
0.401491344,
0.0906640887,
-0.4271710217,
0.146277383,
-0.3873070478,
-0.842581749,
-0.318574518,
-0.4949726462,
0.1142590493,
0.0064320583,
-0.7927952409,
0.4490548968,
-0.5104241967,
-0.3450493217,
-0.260296762,
0.1376618594,
-0.9614995122,
0.020171361,
0.1089502349,
0.5158452988,
-0.8981389999,
0.7696042657,
0.3871006668,
-0.3890596926,
-0.4116440713,
-0.0760784373,
0.2757770121,
-0.5728337169,
0.4864083529,
0.1535287648,
0.1837765276,
-0.4884832203,
-0.1906160861,
-0.6105456948,
1.1584632397,
0.1777875274,
-1.000813961,
0.1254834831,
0.2581617832,
0.3729406595,
-0.8060028553,
0.0276074465,
0.8036872745,
0.336155504,
0.5004767179,
-0.553360641,
0.6004985571,
-0.3545655012,
-0.3250710964,
0.0728701949,
-0.389706552,
0.579965353,
-0.3992654681,
-0.3143056333,
0.0352071635,
0.5004699826,
0.3003045022,
0.3314462304,
0.7816095352,
0.7370589972,
0.7802892923,
-0.5057257414,
0.5462787747,
-0.3547218144,
0.3619164228,
1.2658063173,
-0.6600215435,
0.3887923956,
0.3854478896,
-0.1501131058,
0.4034644067,
0.6276663542,
-0.7176473737,
0.8354771137,
0.3049300909,
-0.1100220308,
-0.8755937219,
-0.1734646708,
-0.1873019636,
0.5167208314,
0.1280005574,
-0.2561002672,
-0.2530759275,
0.0353393666,
-0.5132197142,
0.0282835867,
-0.3584499359,
0.9106274843,
-0.2820364535,
-0.2580861449,
-0.1748222262,
0.0836339518,
0.6457523108,
-0.2470894754,
-0.2677973807,
-0.2453938723,
-0.0147211794,
-0.3589548171,
-0.745316267,
0.1626178771,
-0.3153709173,
-0.2300249785,
-0.005060703,
0.7881993055,
-0.5241442323,
-0.4083109498,
0.5906804204,
0.1826127172,
-0.3018189967,
-0.1791994274,
-0.727547586,
-0.163982287,
-0.1610558629,
0.2090443671,
0.5436972976,
0.4638753235,
0.1304695755,
0.3672685921,
0.8790630698,
0.0011860793,
-0.3695654869,
0.4333908856,
0.8206976652,
-0.4901607633,
-0.3917243481,
-0.8377401829,
0.5203318,
-0.2692144215,
-0.1235730872,
0.252227217,
0.3744466007,
0.7306392193,
0.3191820681,
0.5655199289,
-0.1911401451,
-0.015659105,
-0.5639199615,
0.4113066792,
-0.6658802629,
0.4336134791,
-0.4139052629,
-0.9300994277,
-0.1494500041,
0.4041952789,
0.3172528148,
0.0547617972,
0.4039523602,
0.9460041523,
-0.2086785734,
-0.2475548536,
0.4911383688,
-0.2571362257,
0.2367162853,
0.9439106584,
0.3663218617,
-0.4519564509,
0.670090735,
-0.0516324826,
-0.2014112175,
-0.3747164607,
-0.9517887235,
-1.2410444021,
-0.3310759366,
-0.5444149375,
-0.2682772279,
-0.1050159037,
0.7673121095,
0.7635564208,
-0.9078851342,
0.1301799268,
-0.1227765307,
0.1180340946,
-0.2962601185,
-0.2064769119,
0.0322136618,
-0.136850208,
-0.3231786788,
0.3237027526,
0.2755396962,
-0.1041664407,
0.1246058047,
0.0300401337,
-0.2644134164,
0.0282308664,
0.6326960325,
-0.0846688077,
-0.5863556266,
-0.2541858256,
-0.3310818672,
-0.032270439,
-0.0439084806,
1.1211621761,
-0.5959811211,
0.3981200457,
0.5078363419,
0.8809873462,
0.7557219863,
-0.0191449933,
0.7481220365,
-0.6206878424,
0.2186521292,
-0.0030435757,
0.7603771687,
-0.0438497849,
-0.6037421823,
0.4612565339,
0.4115867913,
-0.0520861074,
-0.6379600763,
0.4490298331,
-0.9648750424,
-0.552492857,
0.7606591582,
-0.2570810616,
0.2930504978,
-0.3298198879,
0.4397026598,
0.2361939549,
-0.4562954903,
0.6311987638,
0.8185575604,
0.251459837,
-0.3443033993,
-0.2257093936,
0.3165636063,
0.3168283403,
-0.553396821,
-0.1346554309,
0.3559145331,
0.331723094,
0.358094573,
0.2179872692,
-0.1608439237,
0.4501520097,
-0.0998041779,
-0.2212319225,
-0.5159153938,
-0.209398821,
-0.3632478118,
0.527377367,
-0.6027100682,
0.2728308737
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11171v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11171v2 | SUGARCREPE++ Dataset: Vision-Language Model Sensitivity to Semantic and Lexical Alterations | 2024-06-17T03:22:20 | 2024-06-19T00:03:42 | Sri Harsha Dumpala, Aman Jaiswal, Chandramouli Sastry, Evangelos Milios, Sageev Oore, Hassan Sajjad | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG, 68T45, 68T50, I.2.7; I.2.10 | Despite their remarkable successes, state-of-the-art large language models
(LLMs), including vision-and-language models (VLMs) and unimodal language
models (ULMs), fail to understand precise semantics. For example, semantically
equivalent sentences expressed using different lexical compositions elicit
diverging representations. The degree of this divergence and its impact on
encoded semantics is not very well understood. In this paper, we introduce the
SUGARCREPE++ dataset to analyze the sensitivity of VLMs and ULMs to lexical and
semantic alterations. Each sample in SUGARCREPE++ dataset consists of an image
and a corresponding triplet of captions: a pair of semantically equivalent but
lexically different positive captions and one hard negative caption. This poses
a 3-way semantic (in)equivalence problem to the language models. We
comprehensively evaluate VLMs and ULMs that differ in architecture,
pre-training objectives and datasets to benchmark the performance of
SUGARCREPE++ dataset. Experimental results highlight the difficulties of VLMs
in distinguishing between lexical and semantic variations, particularly in
object attributes and spatial relations. Although VLMs with larger pre-training
datasets, model sizes, and multiple pre-training objectives achieve better
performance on SUGARCREPE++, there is a significant opportunity for
improvement. We show that all the models which achieve better performance on
compositionality datasets need not perform equally well on SUGARCREPE++,
signifying that compositionality alone may not be sufficient for understanding
semantic and lexical alterations. Given the importance of the property that the
SUGARCREPE++ dataset targets, it serves as a new challenge to the
vision-and-language community. | [
-0.2556089759,
-0.333958447,
0.4648527503,
-0.0357771851,
-0.2142809927,
0.1926158071,
-0.4737638235,
-0.682411015,
0.0661519021,
0.6033177972,
-0.3659724295,
-0.4478356838,
-0.7840670347,
0.1820923537,
-0.5172110796,
0.957539022,
-0.0542466082,
0.5654807091,
-0.5317587256,
-0.04915886,
-0.8465688229,
-0.608576417,
-0.100914441,
-0.0268897489,
0.1128571779,
0.2957850397,
0.7854855657,
0.5369886756,
0.7693196535,
0.2283750623,
-0.1466911435,
-0.1237507984,
-0.3475997746,
-0.0407066233,
-0.1170825884,
-0.8316766024,
-0.2546145618,
-0.1406582594,
0.4254610538,
0.8597903252,
0.2020345181,
0.13066791,
-0.0561534613,
0.4480167031,
-0.8905499578,
0.1695510447,
-1.0091338158,
-0.0107793221,
-0.3032862544,
0.1399753243,
-0.1461949646,
0.1406452358,
0.0121789305,
-0.4721226692,
0.4805378914,
-0.1451785713,
1.0256421566,
0.3411534131,
-0.1188911423,
-0.2615733445,
-0.4407931864,
0.8000110388,
-0.5473991632,
0.5112420321,
0.1995974183,
0.098761417,
0.0876209587,
-0.4949199855,
-0.5035682321,
-0.4996399879,
-0.2696352303,
0.3981065154,
0.1047480926,
-0.2066199481,
0.1805202216,
0.1227343902,
-0.5056353211,
0.0058891922,
-0.2951540649,
-0.2456643283,
0.3658895493,
0.3947427869,
0.1376707107,
-0.5519242883,
-0.5595006347,
-0.1100703627,
-0.5769410133,
0.0240728743,
-0.0141314659,
0.4906862378,
-0.1791555583,
0.6138563752,
0.1184299141,
0.8044356704,
-0.4128694832,
0.1747663468,
0.4782983661,
-0.5391949415,
-0.3422254026,
0.0315963849,
0.3392395079,
0.4469377697,
0.5396284461,
-0.0427211933,
-0.1827692091,
0.6954099536,
0.1778673083,
-0.5758376718,
-0.2405326813,
0.1444102377,
-0.1123249829,
-0.099454172,
0.3098709583,
-0.6404003501,
-0.4398167133,
-0.5474058986,
0.4022568762,
-0.4849407673,
-0.1410328299,
0.6554860473,
-0.1318115741,
0.4165840447,
0.4368520975,
-0.7574665546,
0.6028824449,
0.8905074596,
0.7761183977,
-0.4828390181,
-0.4979310334,
-0.3521535993,
0.0845757723,
-0.2902884483,
0.8685950041,
-0.7731102705,
-0.1923268288,
-0.2408803105,
0.1675449014,
-0.4075267911,
-0.8105311394,
0.542560339,
-0.1738999039,
0.0662927106,
-0.1412316114,
-0.7123219967,
0.1100262925,
0.1457103789,
-0.5584839582,
0.6399348378,
0.3382218182,
-0.6614475846,
0.7076227665,
-0.6550212502,
-0.2434868962,
0.2863691747,
-0.2055714726,
-0.3577109873,
0.4610825777,
0.0919861123,
0.4411689937,
-0.1804721355,
0.1710650027,
-0.2713010013,
-0.228851974,
0.2608408034,
-0.2128258198,
0.6198104024,
-0.166036889,
-0.1166849807,
0.0809289888,
-0.7305638194,
-0.1378952414,
0.2651371956,
0.0824808627,
-0.6623691916,
0.0527253859,
0.1438317597,
0.1100418344,
0.2169406414,
-0.5431712866,
0.1567695439,
-0.3098893762,
0.3160225153,
0.6529391408,
-0.5871862173,
0.3587668836,
0.1147351265,
0.2816511095,
0.4722241163,
0.5144097805,
-0.1403240412,
-0.3794884086,
-0.8498690128,
-0.1283221692,
0.3894162774,
0.5117018223,
-0.6389651299,
0.1587199122,
-0.6649336219,
-0.1838551015,
-0.5327326059,
0.1033978909,
0.365311712,
0.6002146006,
0.3623210788,
-0.7511085272,
-0.3494255543,
-0.965755105,
-0.0920653418,
-0.0275965966,
-0.128341049,
0.2524566948,
0.6882363558,
-0.0732216537,
0.8069552779,
-0.5867993236,
-0.2679579556,
-0.1235747188,
-0.3884981275,
0.112537846,
0.2903055549,
0.8724565506,
-1.053044796,
-0.3447482884,
-0.099371545,
-0.3727202117,
-0.1608576924,
0.0668066666,
-0.0218745284,
0.1278131753,
0.2122147232,
-0.5720168352,
0.5949527025,
0.621085763,
-0.677821219,
0.7485182285,
0.192345351,
0.1184251085,
-0.9641833901,
-0.0146008022,
-0.1208521426,
-0.3271869421,
-0.7343782187,
0.1215734035,
0.3073491454,
0.0420514867,
-0.6986663938,
0.4235883653,
-0.3820995688,
-0.3364205956,
-0.2444531173,
0.2527415454,
0.143312797,
0.3571253419,
0.4395595491,
0.6705986857,
0.9484037161,
-0.5613396764,
0.5363827348,
0.5932945609,
-0.4068996608,
0.784175992,
-0.5510897636,
-0.3162441254,
-0.3351175189,
-0.0832223371,
-0.7721301913,
-0.3093000352,
0.2421233654,
-0.5069871545,
0.2711385787,
-0.0930273235,
-0.3434977233,
-0.3424680233,
-0.5495223403,
0.3240764141,
0.1014517769,
-0.291860044,
0.4913875759,
0.1005358174,
-0.0077882349,
-0.3613933027,
-0.8865199685,
0.4407147169,
-0.0994865149,
-0.6159083247,
0.3023457229,
-0.2290636897,
-0.3155227304,
0.1641062349,
-0.0896339193,
0.070569016,
0.0819702521,
0.3393298388,
0.3869842887,
-0.1018560529,
0.202720359,
-0.5621355176,
-0.1737696528,
-0.1040086374,
-0.1506770998,
0.7433757782,
-0.1963661015,
-0.256031841,
-0.1823531389,
0.2059225887,
0.4001492858,
-0.328831166,
0.7262918353,
0.391877979,
-0.199571386,
0.1855102926,
-0.161930263,
-0.1311701834,
-0.3393187225,
0.6313163638,
-0.4812017977,
-0.733104229,
0.5761408806,
0.2918260098,
-0.1953812093,
0.29263255,
0.5531949997,
0.0527522787,
0.7212737203,
0.6697002053,
-0.0681954101,
0.4677124321,
-0.1886932552,
-0.4285637736,
-0.9170947075,
-0.4502183199,
-0.4983189106,
-0.131565094,
-0.40751791,
-0.1714588255,
0.1630702764,
-0.3057080507,
-0.140514195,
0.6643179655,
-0.2568812668,
0.5587073565,
0.2882026136,
0.1129466966,
0.2824335694,
-0.0085071605,
0.1673293859,
-0.1151392236,
-0.642981708,
-0.2730663419,
0.9162869453,
0.0033292624,
0.8121992946,
0.061182268,
-0.0354040787,
0.2213188261,
0.1385448575,
-0.8231394291,
0.3468253314,
-0.6022104621,
-0.447807312,
0.1322673857,
-0.4885349274,
-0.9142343998,
0.179956153,
-0.2842257917,
-0.7551598549,
0.3170231879,
0.017651191,
-0.079913795,
0.1912008524,
-0.9863260388,
1.0563883781,
-0.6457518339,
-0.3738520443,
0.2745482028,
-1.033616662,
0.1674456745,
-0.2508477867,
0.2568754852,
-0.1588579565,
-0.3684106469,
0.2822802365,
-0.2896132171,
0.7200366855,
0.0160994772,
-0.1276833713,
-0.161112994,
0.2917179465,
0.2367298007,
-0.06787806,
0.162642926,
0.3628857732,
0.1026208252,
-0.5608949661,
-0.5468984842,
0.5744829178,
-0.7817863822,
-0.3690384924,
-0.183723703,
-0.3744718134,
-0.3447731733,
-0.0342364796,
0.3278100789,
0.5151700974,
0.1791342348,
0.1174701452,
0.3041360378,
-0.1349347234,
0.4044487774,
0.4222343266,
-0.251108259,
-0.3147924542,
0.5304828882,
-0.2316739559,
0.7134786248,
0.3777553737,
-0.0741935521,
-0.2428845316,
-0.5587760806,
-0.4097986817,
0.1350295842,
-0.7102963328,
-0.3616670668,
-0.2831042707,
-0.0133020263,
-0.2756690085,
-0.0603170246,
-0.5175791383,
-0.2908812165,
-0.5158929229,
0.0877965167,
0.3807932138,
0.4943538606,
0.1398702711,
0.3476794064,
-0.7279754877,
0.2780292332,
-0.1197439656,
0.7168166637,
-0.3277128935,
-0.7023153305,
-0.2021991909,
0.0783115402,
0.1701799929,
-0.7666397691,
0.2513858676,
0.4602476656,
0.143841818,
0.0744334161,
-0.497998476,
0.8550417423,
-0.3343236148,
0.8881676793,
0.0869524702,
-1.1434781551,
0.4765716195,
0.0471362211,
0.400868535,
0.8010896444,
0.1938642859,
-0.6081187725,
-0.2753668129,
-0.4461060464,
-0.7451111674,
0.6051879525,
0.4386370182,
0.3969694972,
0.2158290148,
0.5084301233,
0.368457824,
0.2930387855,
-0.7446882129,
-0.0797989145,
-0.4661031067,
-0.1377917528,
-0.2408908159,
-0.0451028645,
0.2122134864,
-0.3850919604,
0.3941109478,
-0.0720699802,
-0.0291753616,
0.0602967627,
-0.2865766585,
0.1672706306,
0.0667424574,
0.4894937575,
0.5985456705,
-0.1469776481,
0.4112696946,
0.0311968829,
-0.8348896503,
-0.0442169607,
-0.1119856909,
-0.160815686,
-0.0516627431,
0.6309657693,
1.0114158392,
0.0712431148,
-0.9381619692,
0.927613318,
-0.3389936388,
-0.116715759,
-0.2534227669,
0.142333582,
-0.1934538037,
-0.1497311592,
0.0917951763,
0.2501865327,
-0.0080932574,
-0.6022639275,
0.2782726288,
0.4028783739,
-0.513235867,
-0.3862892389,
0.6033066511,
-0.0719458833,
0.0596179925,
0.4944285452,
0.1080286428,
-0.6483546495,
0.6700609326,
0.3183398843,
0.5351835489,
-0.0913817734,
0.2070741951,
0.0173124187,
0.3701087236,
0.2828707993,
0.2561937571,
0.0378986746,
-1.0040274858,
-0.3827451468,
-0.8324140906,
-0.0577499047,
0.2352718711,
-0.5614547133,
0.4614754021,
-0.1713674068,
-0.0791481361,
0.0756111071,
-0.2454444319,
-0.6921909451,
0.2791945636,
0.1895343363,
0.810182929,
-1.1041020155,
0.3732909858,
0.8979438543,
-0.3256621361,
-0.4964868426,
0.0190535672,
-0.2081685513,
-0.7572612762,
0.4886669517,
0.0867361277,
0.0383667983,
-0.1981858313,
-0.8247532248,
-0.7508528829,
0.7522522211,
0.6864788532,
-0.5612401962,
0.3827979863,
0.6879833937,
0.5926638246,
-0.3397014141,
0.1900426894,
0.6972953677,
0.4884926677,
0.2746652663,
-0.9535236359,
-0.1590523869,
-0.1408749074,
0.0856807083,
0.3572176695,
-0.6122410297,
0.8538809419,
-0.1086383536,
-0.3832751513,
0.1617700607,
0.2399741709,
-0.0562922247,
0.0081002815,
0.3964863718,
0.5644857883,
0.1937724948,
-0.2587826252,
1.0929423571,
-0.1533465087,
0.474050343,
1.2132239342,
-0.4138092101,
0.7227172852,
0.4978579879,
-0.1613942832,
0.1962903738,
0.6274295449,
-0.3550136983,
0.3979199827,
0.212944448,
-0.1493042111,
-0.4474535286,
-0.2516342103,
-0.1392892599,
0.8407095671,
0.2575523257,
-0.2724151909,
-0.3500438929,
0.2745637596,
0.004067115,
0.1961387545,
-0.5188807845,
0.7412884235,
-0.0991969705,
-0.2031379789,
0.5484896302,
-0.2462075055,
0.7299985886,
-0.6288852096,
0.1615951508,
-0.2568686008,
0.174307093,
-0.4148753285,
-0.9517176747,
0.2821028829,
0.1102551371,
0.0839612037,
0.2545878589,
0.6519957185,
-0.3480094373,
-0.7573806047,
0.375264436,
0.406406492,
0.1331074089,
-0.1304108053,
-0.7242859006,
0.3621458411,
-0.1621534526,
-0.0371820927,
0.0478205569,
0.2403552085,
-0.0903370157,
0.6135464311,
0.3448638022,
0.4097208679,
0.1090789884,
0.3650610149,
0.8375481367,
-0.5580887794,
-0.0786349475,
-1.0268062353,
0.4000225365,
-0.0055106683,
-0.174424991,
0.5959618688,
0.836304605,
1.2453898191,
-0.379032284,
0.635063231,
-0.187816143,
0.1214465573,
-0.7797239423,
0.3161754012,
-0.8266159892,
0.2035607547,
-0.3741321564,
-0.9390162826,
-0.7765042782,
0.166405037,
-0.1891431957,
0.1574003845,
0.6721181273,
0.8044916987,
-0.2499421388,
-0.1080407277,
0.5117747784,
0.3329047859,
0.1772221625,
0.7928038836,
0.8173390627,
-0.2809919119,
0.3197225928,
0.0555980802,
-0.1204028502,
0.0572427623,
-0.8611562848,
-0.5489887595,
-0.8325513005,
-0.2178092748,
-0.0132873012,
0.2151498795,
0.6901002526,
0.5113172531,
-0.8232190013,
-0.094310239,
-0.2734172046,
-0.2791857421,
0.0584244542,
-0.2031880766,
0.4237102568,
-0.09064053,
-0.5317410231,
-0.1451639831,
0.4008699059,
0.334118098,
-0.2701166868,
0.1342721879,
0.1050334424,
-0.0929788202,
0.7600892782,
-0.1271898299,
-0.5077754259,
-0.4996158481,
-0.0532586947,
0.0807792768,
0.4597049654,
0.7082979679,
-0.8201275468,
0.3817227781,
0.2302371562,
0.3858742416,
0.3918457925,
0.0431788117,
0.1603268981,
-0.7394148111,
0.1428162009,
0.256514132,
0.460870713,
0.6928626299,
-0.1306637824,
0.5082384944,
0.544608891,
-0.1070841178,
-0.4647095799,
0.5752947927,
-1.0921227932,
-0.5244870782,
1.1777174473,
0.255160898,
-0.5548520088,
0.0228640717,
-0.3140947819,
-0.1171249673,
-0.145056814,
0.705657959,
0.6305187941,
-0.0995824337,
-0.1165560484,
-0.5753211975,
0.4939023256,
0.3451425433,
-0.9489028454,
0.471003592,
0.7390466928,
0.4461916685,
0.1339341551,
0.1249832064,
-0.28841573,
0.1224690378,
-0.131681934,
0.0783078745,
0.0318406373,
-0.591250658,
-0.3683986068,
0.0358718671,
-0.16182971,
-0.0702857673
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15480v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15480v1 | On Giant's Shoulders: Effortless Weak to Strong by Dynamic Logits Fusion | 2024-06-17T03:07:41 | 2024-06-17T03:07:41 | Chenghao Fan, Zhenyi Lu, Wei Wei, Jie Tian, Xiaoye Qu, Dangyang Chen, Yu Cheng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Efficient fine-tuning of large language models for task-specific applications
is imperative, yet the vast number of parameters in these models makes their
training increasingly challenging. Despite numerous proposals for effective
methods, a substantial memory overhead remains for gradient computations during
updates. \thm{Can we fine-tune a series of task-specific small models and
transfer their knowledge directly to a much larger model without additional
training?} In this paper, we explore weak-to-strong specialization using logit
arithmetic, facilitating a direct answer to this question. Existing
weak-to-strong methods often employ a static knowledge transfer ratio and a
single small model for transferring complex knowledge, which leads to
suboptimal performance. % To address this, To surmount these limitations, we
propose a dynamic logit fusion approach that works with a series of
task-specific small models, each specialized in a different task. This method
adaptively allocates weights among these models at each decoding step, learning
the weights through Kullback-Leibler divergence constrained optimization
problems. We conduct extensive experiments across various benchmarks in both
single-task and multi-task settings, achieving leading results. By transferring
expertise from the 7B model to the 13B model, our method closes the performance
gap by 96.4\% in single-task scenarios and by 86.3\% in multi-task scenarios
compared to full fine-tuning of the 13B model. Notably, we achieve surpassing
performance on unseen tasks. Moreover, we further demonstrate that our method
can effortlessly integrate in-context learning for single tasks and task
arithmetic for multi-task scenarios. (Our implementation is available in
https://github.com/Facico/Dynamic-Logit-Fusion.) | [
-0.2035634071,
-0.788988471,
0.208410725,
0.1017576307,
-0.3700113893,
0.26312837,
-0.3193153441,
-0.6123626232,
0.1981616765,
0.2531805038,
-0.591602087,
-0.2743020654,
-0.7344314456,
-0.0681717098,
-0.2369976491,
1.0001584291,
0.1334673613,
-0.0815226734,
0.0742561817,
-0.3986682296,
-0.6498093009,
-0.1152403653,
-0.6069734097,
-0.2467909902,
0.4662824273,
0.3621926904,
0.6938889623,
0.5749742985,
0.727411449,
0.3613190055,
-0.2884438038,
0.2841487527,
-0.817525506,
-0.0673530623,
-0.3705894053,
-0.5121601224,
-0.6530990005,
-0.5650123954,
1.0511510372,
0.7782145143,
-0.0318273902,
0.1766167134,
-0.042048689,
0.8107745051,
-0.6519309282,
-0.0063997796,
-0.9535591006,
-0.049990911,
-0.1788829118,
0.2426386029,
-0.2821965218,
-0.0350185074,
-0.0869926438,
-0.4000135362,
0.3582978845,
-0.0832457691,
0.7986735106,
0.4969355464,
-0.750053823,
0.0185387954,
-0.7723969817,
0.9757563472,
-0.5872293115,
0.4597585499,
0.1070175245,
0.3239479363,
0.0184257068,
-0.5480948091,
-0.4107858241,
-0.0201503914,
-0.1729630232,
-0.0240887385,
-0.3338778317,
0.1674013734,
0.2651368976,
0.6034203768,
-0.6051466465,
0.1858689487,
-0.5166633129,
0.0033445549,
0.7813290954,
0.364671737,
0.1954419762,
-0.1420247406,
-0.1304447651,
-0.3500036597,
-0.5664617419,
-0.1816376448,
0.2647356689,
0.383495599,
-0.1682377458,
0.4293015003,
-0.1524243504,
0.8192413449,
0.5439257026,
-0.2523198724,
0.282798171,
-0.5286279917,
-0.4130503535,
0.085612528,
0.573595047,
-0.1467822641,
-0.4719857574,
-0.2914126813,
-0.4404866993,
0.2020598948,
0.2400689572,
-0.7381055355,
-0.4644713998,
0.0488361269,
-0.2389504313,
-0.2793673575,
-0.2997914851,
-0.6510628462,
-0.492523849,
-0.1667259336,
0.7891514301,
-0.345246315,
-0.4094569683,
0.2124243528,
-0.0126251103,
-0.0515562631,
0.1852326989,
-1.1046788692,
0.4125475883,
0.5777635574,
0.6367923617,
-0.1078675836,
-0.159288168,
-0.7270277143,
0.1779719293,
-0.2326149046,
0.4378087819,
-0.2591605484,
-0.2787460983,
-0.3332075179,
-0.0362287872,
-0.4044621587,
-0.6735618711,
0.4522474408,
-0.4275988936,
-0.3001416326,
-0.0786897317,
-0.5262004137,
-0.2881737351,
0.1916276813,
-0.900921762,
0.7909838557,
0.2331266999,
-0.6034924984,
0.1633641273,
-0.5410425663,
-0.6651788354,
0.1486376524,
-0.1200136393,
-0.3253533542,
0.3865934908,
0.0018218433,
0.5482327938,
-0.4850783646,
0.1555140764,
-0.2589259148,
-0.3397179246,
-0.1798257679,
-0.1889174581,
0.8326863647,
-0.0048788213,
-0.6158807278,
0.1867800355,
-0.7173914313,
-0.1018927097,
0.0907482728,
-0.3063316047,
-0.214634791,
-0.2302210033,
-0.3134982884,
-0.048045326,
0.302716434,
-0.2650738955,
0.4014793038,
-0.5551686883,
0.1590390503,
0.7535684109,
-0.1360301673,
0.7204489112,
-0.1555854827,
0.2655778825,
-0.0603833869,
-0.059788052,
0.0492032282,
-0.1713474542,
-0.8358220458,
-0.4804536402,
0.3821721077,
0.6019120216,
-0.6972109675,
0.5383709073,
-0.5296209455,
-0.7909994125,
-0.4467554986,
0.7296362519,
0.4222120047,
0.3473103344,
0.2970506549,
-0.4299925268,
-0.3483784497,
-1.1008839607,
-0.2487762272,
-0.2175720483,
-0.0372823812,
0.251478821,
0.2562864423,
-0.1946909875,
0.319288075,
-0.5524463058,
-0.41758582,
-0.4076678753,
0.2663639188,
0.538345933,
0.7976030707,
0.4546863735,
-0.993678689,
-0.5769692659,
0.2158087343,
-0.778416872,
0.2460920364,
-0.2154624313,
-0.3564263284,
0.0272464044,
0.2401759773,
-1.0956150293,
0.0152513906,
0.7521678209,
-0.6483865976,
0.4283443987,
-0.0334578678,
0.0648679435,
-0.9225716591,
0.4316439331,
-0.0858397782,
-0.1119340807,
-0.8540715575,
0.3888299465,
0.1865097731,
-0.2112905383,
-0.3552715182,
0.6587326527,
-0.4591480196,
0.3721781373,
-0.1244703829,
-0.2436937094,
-0.2362128496,
0.6431030035,
-0.2980847359,
0.3222940266,
0.7212634087,
-0.612128377,
0.6756433249,
0.134515211,
-0.4938449264,
0.4593827426,
-0.5202504396,
0.1076764688,
0.0103586419,
0.1917519271,
-0.8709701896,
-0.2710557878,
0.1687991023,
-0.1130216643,
0.581584096,
-0.1961138994,
-0.6298331618,
-0.2373411804,
-0.1199478954,
0.843867898,
0.8644033074,
-0.4357289076,
1.0247879028,
0.3870209754,
-0.0761586428,
-0.498157829,
-0.5274665356,
-0.0287667625,
-0.286431402,
-0.8771890998,
0.522156477,
-0.1665187925,
-0.3358510137,
0.0723356232,
-0.3500020206,
-0.1028241515,
0.0409127474,
0.1399196833,
0.2909664512,
-0.2402356267,
0.1593599916,
0.2452502549,
-0.0137314685,
-0.3333227932,
-0.2667513788,
0.2080859542,
-0.295206517,
-0.2945787013,
-0.222836867,
0.1142410487,
0.7424523234,
-0.2060297281,
0.721606791,
0.9526686072,
-0.4871573448,
-0.0653315112,
-0.6768308878,
-0.3855821192,
-0.5385161042,
0.5456127524,
-0.4796238244,
-0.9691880345,
0.4180843532,
-0.0377828889,
0.2978273034,
0.5883244276,
0.6064592004,
0.237223193,
1.2214984894,
0.8306145668,
-0.2063431144,
0.4683172703,
-0.2471946925,
0.4350548387,
-0.4619678557,
-0.0594699271,
-0.1872443259,
-0.7046875358,
-0.4151134193,
-0.4396036565,
0.60084939,
0.166422829,
-0.1628724486,
0.4523692727,
-0.4312391579,
0.5334531069,
0.3644346893,
0.3723758161,
0.0704441816,
-0.0005166911,
0.2094640434,
0.1964099407,
-1.0362234116,
0.2398724258,
0.7944502234,
0.2717381418,
0.8634845614,
0.3960257173,
0.4677605033,
0.2095563412,
-0.0336695872,
-0.7360381484,
0.8335157037,
-0.5160015821,
-0.7033513188,
-0.5148463249,
-0.6934503317,
-0.8799983263,
0.2639388144,
-0.4943943024,
-0.6765801907,
0.2459704131,
0.5392789245,
-0.4024894536,
0.6223039627,
-0.9073907137,
0.9875459075,
-0.1390862614,
-0.6815587878,
-0.8161709309,
-0.6569038033,
0.638286829,
-0.3121141493,
-0.0402310081,
-0.2118579745,
0.204911828,
0.7496045828,
-0.1183904484,
0.9802441001,
-0.1252600849,
-0.104564108,
0.2114534378,
0.3579596877,
0.8250980973,
-0.0392022803,
-0.1219936907,
0.0556243211,
-0.2475491017,
-0.8020259142,
-0.6998135448,
0.8561432362,
-0.584218204,
-0.6042358875,
-0.0697281584,
-0.7411464453,
-0.2875822783,
0.3221396804,
-0.1025376543,
0.4054129422,
-0.0320653059,
0.3838245571,
0.8771460652,
0.1054541022,
0.2519867718,
0.2191092819,
0.3537145257,
-0.2902542055,
1.1538621187,
-0.0402541719,
0.2687947452,
0.6247295737,
0.2044463307,
-0.1164028347,
-0.3711099625,
-0.6633390784,
0.4646540582,
-0.7540402412,
-0.399241358,
-0.512095809,
0.0219385345,
-0.2067287266,
-0.3152038753,
-0.5846759081,
-0.5003725886,
0.1015150696,
0.0822667629,
0.1545472443,
0.372212261,
-0.036831107,
0.1576420069,
-0.9743020535,
0.3169373274,
0.6496856809,
0.1762972325,
0.2778492272,
-0.5049273372,
-0.5928794146,
-0.0948301628,
-0.2663696408,
-0.6490917206,
0.1397220343,
0.3125342727,
0.4533809125,
0.3512542844,
0.090885222,
0.703138411,
-0.2752952576,
0.6790755391,
0.5586198568,
-0.9857649803,
0.24791646,
-0.3428408504,
0.7556062341,
0.6296248436,
0.3264015019,
-0.0656943321,
-0.3544946909,
-0.7768852711,
-0.9607787728,
0.584002614,
0.1676359773,
0.1668116301,
0.4863384366,
0.1010567397,
0.0939471349,
0.215815708,
-0.4313569665,
-0.0097796097,
0.1106546819,
-0.4084738493,
-0.2273293436,
-0.1809261441,
-0.3796306551,
-0.5726043582,
0.779551506,
-0.1276015788,
0.3697275817,
-0.3759761453,
-0.2800822854,
-0.3172265589,
-0.0122411028,
0.4986602068,
0.840377748,
-0.1810091585,
0.4271098673,
0.7551724315,
-0.4646486938,
0.0909299701,
0.2192012221,
0.1181856543,
0.039327994,
0.3620658517,
1.1635553837,
0.5223657489,
-0.7840165496,
0.3572879434,
0.1656715572,
-0.287812233,
0.0787539333,
0.2905369699,
-0.0079716239,
0.4054011405,
0.4056800604,
0.2066470385,
-0.1439233273,
-0.4488689005,
0.0335401222,
0.412786454,
-0.2102216482,
-0.623683691,
0.4429553747,
0.3611672819,
-0.0946500674,
0.617007494,
-0.1515654922,
-0.3464334309,
0.4848810434,
0.4517920315,
0.8108998537,
-0.4287466109,
-0.127108559,
0.5287086368,
0.199347958,
-0.1838991493,
-0.0213246811,
-0.0284210257,
-0.5675296187,
-0.5826840401,
-0.6912771463,
-0.1327902526,
0.1580672711,
-0.3975101113,
0.441886723,
-0.4796824157,
0.0178090092,
0.1645172238,
0.1144803762,
-0.7617527246,
0.2700659931,
-0.0558566526,
0.7331803441,
-0.8633400202,
0.7234879732,
0.8962602615,
-0.1020818204,
-0.7427464724,
-0.2168638855,
0.0315459184,
-0.6893147826,
0.5441747904,
-0.1155374646,
-0.066773288,
0.182206139,
-0.2960858047,
-0.7444402575,
1.0199215412,
0.5213922262,
-0.6015889049,
-0.2661524415,
-0.2765743136,
0.3526597321,
0.0151790874,
-0.0945513919,
0.4327471256,
0.5014055371,
0.0448173545,
-1.1832660437,
0.3688236177,
-0.3159382045,
-0.3157978952,
0.6964258552,
-0.9068682194,
0.7680301666,
-0.0791150108,
-0.1474685818,
-0.1225724444,
0.5949804187,
-0.022543462,
0.0446747877,
0.8697790504,
0.5950980783,
0.7358720899,
0.2127904743,
0.7543087006,
-0.5200356245,
0.2618870139,
0.5277727246,
0.0950413123,
0.6856574416,
0.4310720861,
-0.051663965,
0.3914901018,
0.2966699302,
-0.1617260426,
0.5160130858,
-0.0460482351,
-0.7376506329,
-0.511837244,
0.0564458556,
-0.1419883966,
0.3420920968,
0.3218538463,
-0.0708786696,
-0.2062961757,
-0.0557278283,
-0.1693729162,
-0.2286296785,
-0.4595232904,
0.769485414,
0.1605050266,
-0.62121135,
1.0552889109,
0.1218175068,
0.6701036096,
-1.0104037523,
0.0840725526,
-0.0767625347,
0.4798984826,
-0.2502166629,
-0.3742475212,
0.3957872093,
-0.2169879526,
-0.2536924779,
0.0197723694,
1.1054623127,
-0.5664587617,
-0.6074845195,
-0.0767886117,
0.4950224459,
-0.0171668697,
0.0644033253,
-0.6334990859,
0.3128879964,
0.1264413893,
-0.0659198165,
0.6427474022,
0.2337949425,
0.0713556856,
0.563352108,
0.4436448216,
0.0020042425,
-0.0752862692,
-0.389502883,
0.9508904219,
-0.5526795387,
-0.5824771523,
-0.8839305043,
0.6670869589,
0.1026191935,
-0.1087106317,
0.5954648852,
0.4436897635,
0.7081797719,
-0.2555226684,
0.6186622977,
-0.3269434571,
0.1736237109,
-0.4872658253,
0.6383216977,
-0.8531450033,
-0.0107411984,
-0.1999059021,
-1.0100533962,
-0.4074565768,
0.4000703096,
-0.1510582417,
-0.1807089746,
0.7365380526,
0.7725923061,
-0.5048701167,
-0.3024733067,
0.3770939708,
0.2885850072,
0.0886020511,
0.9173266292,
0.170893386,
-0.3657022715,
0.7455262542,
-0.1413394809,
-0.3973452449,
-0.4132743478,
-0.7694361806,
-0.8594911098,
-0.4967392087,
-0.3194983006,
-0.395924747,
0.2754262388,
0.8097613454,
0.8304235339,
-0.5213987827,
-0.4979421198,
-0.0376118682,
0.1530154347,
-0.6896520853,
-0.115899004,
0.5319335461,
-0.2317389995,
-0.8202131987,
0.5105922222,
0.0563648306,
0.0177850369,
-0.1579633653,
-0.1967050731,
-0.0483701304,
-0.016745761,
0.7375611067,
0.5304952264,
-0.3331837058,
-0.0177591443,
-0.1420532614,
0.0775591955,
-0.1989079565,
0.7523089647,
-0.6845763326,
0.3779854476,
0.6711453795,
1.0277612209,
0.7219415903,
-0.0736079812,
0.5369789004,
-0.6793535352,
0.2876957655,
0.2659514546,
0.0712094903,
0.244011268,
-0.3973060548,
0.4557130337,
0.5028220415,
-0.3663502038,
-1.1498311758,
0.2913754284,
-1.1277263165,
-0.2188116014,
1.1344124079,
0.0921375453,
-0.2474093735,
0.2119318545,
0.0250190645,
0.0553330258,
-0.1499448717,
0.8981134892,
0.5025004745,
-0.1557126492,
-0.1222234964,
-0.2080435902,
0.5345306993,
0.936191082,
-0.3670368493,
0.0935798511,
0.29670012,
0.0606604256,
0.1406294554,
0.4813499153,
0.194667235,
0.3496552408,
0.3819741309,
-0.0837314203,
-0.0195547305,
-0.323998481,
-0.1824564934,
0.2701823413,
0.2165941745,
0.0609646402
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11162v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11162v2 | How Good are LLMs at Relation Extraction under Low-Resource Scenario? Comprehensive Evaluation | 2024-06-17T03:02:04 | 2024-06-26T01:43:15 | Dawulie Jinensibieke, Mieradilijiang Maimaiti, Wentao Xiao, Yuanhang Zheng, Xiaobo Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Relation Extraction (RE) serves as a crucial technology for transforming
unstructured text into structured information, especially within the framework
of Knowledge Graph development. Its importance is emphasized by its essential
role in various downstream tasks. Besides the conventional RE methods which are
based on neural networks and pre-trained language models, large language models
(LLMs) are also utilized in the research field of RE. However, on low-resource
languages (LRLs), both conventional RE methods and LLM-based methods perform
poorly on RE due to the data scarcity issues. To this end, this paper
constructs low-resource relation extraction datasets in 10 LRLs in three
regions (Central Asia, Southeast Asia and Middle East). The corpora are
constructed by translating the original publicly available English RE datasets
(NYT10, FewRel and CrossRE) using an effective multilingual machine
translation. Then, we use the language perplexity (PPL) to filter out the
low-quality data from the translated datasets. Finally, we conduct an empirical
study and validate the performance of several open-source LLMs on these
generated LRL RE datasets. | [
-0.4110281169,
-0.5026958585,
0.5453346372,
-0.0102578355,
-0.5316414237,
0.0844517797,
-0.5250028372,
-0.601759851,
-0.0290434435,
0.4735000432,
-0.5801272392,
-0.5222004652,
-0.4822663367,
0.5566551089,
-0.1173775271,
0.8670271635,
-0.1343618929,
-0.1906008422,
-0.120463796,
-0.4084722698,
-0.1521049738,
-0.6120383739,
-0.3003596067,
-0.3942696154,
0.5252630711,
0.6481672525,
0.7669268847,
0.6395561695,
0.6624476314,
0.2710129917,
-0.1732946336,
0.4252558351,
-0.6564708352,
0.2123109102,
-0.1823572814,
-0.3688868582,
-0.3917024732,
0.0574924126,
0.5203398466,
0.7195769548,
0.1043584868,
0.4769648612,
0.0508749224,
0.6116375923,
-0.6651943922,
0.1702451706,
-0.6480435729,
0.1624458581,
-0.3929434121,
0.0195922665,
-0.1968420148,
-0.3037063777,
0.4033059478,
-0.5191895366,
0.0614443198,
0.2125217915,
1.1891262531,
0.1309489012,
-0.23523058,
-0.2078631222,
-0.8668695688,
1.0237687826,
-0.7123053074,
0.5621486306,
0.4678676128,
0.411334455,
-0.2385125458,
-0.7868116498,
-0.3545720279,
0.0739526153,
-0.4276684523,
0.0010936416,
-0.2088839412,
-0.3792209625,
0.2268086672,
0.5806751251,
-0.1298956871,
0.2538807392,
-0.2060644925,
-0.0585250184,
0.3581923544,
0.2681130767,
0.0959085152,
-0.80833745,
-0.4257242084,
0.1363638937,
-0.9947050214,
-0.0174280666,
0.2662962973,
0.5519754291,
-0.2393756956,
0.6038430333,
-0.0942685157,
0.4962996542,
-0.1693920344,
-0.5709574819,
0.0908306763,
-0.7706656456,
-0.2175433487,
-0.3666716218,
1.0746062994,
-0.1008350849,
0.481154114,
-0.4780074358,
-0.3142994046,
-0.3095555305,
-0.2790929079,
-0.708008945,
-0.0763570666,
-0.0196496788,
-0.7973214388,
-0.0825777426,
-0.2459234446,
-0.8783512115,
-0.273673147,
-0.3027774096,
-0.3262735307,
-0.5689636469,
-0.4985104203,
-0.3359414339,
0.2894361317,
0.3036304116,
0.2189083397,
-0.4219720364,
0.2486582845,
0.4495978057,
0.7421862483,
-0.3376066089,
0.0289292317,
-0.5000799894,
0.0177350976,
-0.0697628036,
0.699605763,
-0.3581775725,
-0.3450193107,
-0.0622650571,
0.1344475299,
0.0828858688,
-0.9085364938,
0.6602981091,
-0.874581337,
0.1025975496,
-0.2492574453,
-0.2361093909,
0.1246263981,
0.2685336471,
-0.8737086058,
0.6248784065,
0.1655828953,
-0.7980574369,
0.1546506137,
-0.2237445116,
-0.3325755894,
0.0384822898,
-0.3293704987,
-0.3128030598,
-0.0921166539,
0.367828697,
0.3687529862,
-0.8978886604,
0.0633534044,
-0.3730536103,
-0.0945015997,
0.3940446079,
-0.4480021298,
0.6972349286,
0.6695346236,
0.1444264799,
-0.1629980057,
-0.7160080075,
-0.0019628126,
0.2088507861,
-0.4240050018,
-0.6232193708,
-0.0975776017,
-0.0089146849,
0.5234622359,
0.2691096067,
-0.4834353626,
-0.1039867625,
-0.5086492896,
0.412461102,
0.4765965343,
0.2959386706,
0.4940097928,
-0.0368593149,
0.745865941,
0.213465482,
-0.1574571878,
0.1207302287,
-0.0926602557,
-0.6147435904,
-0.3961471319,
0.5944274068,
0.5298149586,
-1.0893853903,
0.1907938868,
-0.5887231827,
-0.3655897379,
-0.7255147696,
0.546538353,
0.5709720254,
0.5751418471,
0.1916092336,
0.0682024732,
-0.5044183135,
-0.9607310891,
-0.0824773982,
0.0678291917,
-0.0113970824,
0.4027765393,
0.1829718202,
-0.0955522135,
1.1098251343,
-0.4794897735,
-0.2906503379,
-0.4524902999,
-0.2913351357,
0.4900233746,
-0.0264041312,
0.3838816881,
-0.8811767101,
-0.3857822418,
0.1112119183,
-1.0794004202,
0.0027140577,
0.2374230623,
-0.1740145981,
0.3671637475,
0.2562879622,
-0.5935192108,
0.2959338427,
0.4507997036,
0.0937214717,
0.4434929788,
0.0973922387,
-0.0243790429,
-1.1339575052,
0.3647463024,
0.1680180579,
-0.3070659935,
-0.3293544054,
-0.0528491251,
-0.082835108,
-0.2817900479,
-0.5854725242,
0.3767165542,
-0.8440224528,
-0.2980103195,
0.1093804911,
0.6624356508,
-0.1557127088,
0.3761830628,
0.0294388309,
0.7172811031,
-0.071919471,
-0.4700901806,
0.3754232824,
0.3828453124,
-0.472790271,
0.3018395305,
-0.3464116752,
0.0948857665,
0.1523897499,
-0.1591245681,
-0.6089554429,
-0.0252173599,
0.3639272451,
-0.2133615166,
0.2593793869,
-0.2734000385,
-0.6914129853,
-0.0848745629,
-0.1784956902,
0.3355381787,
0.3809057772,
-0.3896126449,
0.3391661346,
0.4823983908,
-0.2688574195,
-0.7730941176,
-0.5099720359,
0.0233877636,
-0.4138298035,
-0.4615577459,
0.077312246,
0.357465148,
-0.5169448853,
0.5058195591,
-0.2156919539,
-0.1884552538,
0.0015397675,
0.1432936639,
0.3246647716,
-0.2840886414,
0.1115618348,
-0.4010430574,
-0.114871338,
-0.0263573546,
0.3554705977,
0.4146258831,
0.0154385101,
-0.1033764854,
-0.2695232332,
0.0915413722,
0.5534907579,
-0.2222030759,
0.7193535566,
0.3367494643,
-0.437202245,
0.0252303984,
-0.4075219333,
-0.064575538,
-0.3838346601,
0.5520229936,
-0.6869320869,
-0.680814743,
0.6944442391,
-0.4672273099,
-0.1384284645,
0.4212287068,
0.1925114542,
0.1434969008,
0.180629909,
0.577958405,
-0.5316506028,
0.252764672,
-0.3345295489,
0.385387212,
-0.9540237188,
-0.1188061461,
-0.5639841557,
-0.0410461053,
-0.8267260194,
-0.0998157933,
0.218472749,
0.3727559149,
-0.0231270846,
0.4699671566,
-0.0262343865,
0.2377325445,
0.16018112,
0.0901997015,
0.7278470397,
0.397690624,
0.1122846976,
-0.4849918783,
-0.7899285555,
-0.742983222,
1.0133143663,
0.3881770074,
0.6595674753,
0.2496071607,
0.7466236353,
0.0221865587,
0.5645744205,
-0.814981997,
0.4964644313,
-0.4441753328,
-0.2781965435,
-0.4834285676,
-0.7577996254,
-1.1106032133,
0.2219909579,
-0.4201477468,
-0.4736652672,
0.2141858786,
-0.2422995865,
-0.2151065916,
0.4012461603,
-0.4446665645,
0.5307784081,
-0.2271948606,
-0.5447618365,
-0.1293218285,
-0.5694197416,
0.6977297664,
-0.2453673929,
0.4624194503,
-0.1388098449,
-0.1185687333,
0.6875609159,
-0.4594883919,
0.4652079344,
-0.0217958856,
-0.1247696728,
0.389947921,
0.0962019712,
0.4473357797,
0.060417898,
-0.3808912933,
0.2992999554,
-0.24406524,
-0.1634243131,
-0.4095720053,
0.7879508734,
-0.897377491,
-0.478888303,
-0.2323288023,
-0.4410172403,
-0.3182540834,
0.3298491538,
0.2800213695,
0.2130299211,
-0.1457453817,
0.1642414033,
0.2683718801,
-0.4676700234,
0.4372116923,
0.4141171873,
-0.151541099,
-0.715900898,
0.8249430656,
0.2541923821,
0.2537101507,
0.2086929679,
-0.0871226117,
-0.1540771425,
-0.2484168261,
-0.3824084997,
0.5141444206,
-0.5935530066,
-0.56171453,
-0.4097137451,
-0.3994305432,
-0.271160543,
0.3132317364,
-0.4028860629,
-0.1970149279,
-0.2527632415,
0.1418798566,
0.2097643614,
0.5428959131,
0.1240135282,
0.047679279,
-1.0847392082,
0.3798972368,
-0.0348170213,
-0.0260439869,
0.1289325655,
-0.4756793976,
-0.3620866835,
-0.2798387706,
-0.2044384032,
-0.7896185517,
0.5623290539,
-0.1224308684,
0.4632730782,
0.3161545098,
0.2999779284,
0.9078904986,
-0.3078770638,
0.4255999923,
0.0905877501,
-0.5566591024,
0.3038725257,
-0.1711732596,
0.0625387505,
0.5621842146,
0.5788550973,
-0.3787475228,
-0.0812371001,
-0.6164900661,
-1.054843545,
0.7938938141,
0.2419867516,
-0.2260836512,
0.2139889896,
0.6298551559,
0.0065533128,
0.2887935638,
-0.5979015827,
-0.4471764565,
0.3036497831,
-0.0232884549,
0.0407113098,
-0.5526687503,
0.1097431853,
0.1514796913,
0.411590308,
0.404275924,
0.0533495359,
0.2445095181,
-0.1517522484,
-0.3624860346,
0.453814894,
0.1914825886,
0.7142583728,
-0.3671506345,
0.168062374,
0.1646309048,
-0.2394679338,
0.1779239625,
0.2217620164,
-0.0358578004,
0.0022069919,
0.7091048956,
0.2823892236,
0.2189371437,
-0.4408290386,
0.3143034875,
-0.0819283575,
0.2345708758,
-0.3913927376,
-0.2878249586,
0.2926700115,
0.1552864015,
0.2360260785,
-0.288883239,
-0.1841132194,
-0.4539426267,
0.0816061571,
0.2748449445,
-0.003478749,
-0.31267187,
0.2398633212,
0.3168085217,
-0.2101567686,
1.0559593439,
-0.2213026583,
-0.3423722684,
0.2785927653,
0.430334717,
0.4870340824,
0.1275275052,
-0.1401517838,
0.4201363623,
0.4107872844,
0.1958835274,
-0.1279301047,
-0.0943569839,
-0.8724133372,
-0.7530026436,
-0.6626524925,
-0.4777323604,
0.5718663931,
-0.6595427394,
0.2555697858,
-0.1932519674,
-0.2054381222,
-0.3559454978,
0.4436435103,
-0.8374688625,
-0.1064956412,
-0.2353583723,
0.7358697653,
-0.7230405807,
0.9220657945,
0.7770372629,
-0.536776185,
-0.8469660282,
0.0292534493,
-0.1386567801,
-0.7122606039,
1.1496574879,
-0.3238313794,
-0.2362527847,
-0.2398799807,
-0.3705760837,
-0.8197284937,
1.0849314928,
0.5521606803,
-0.7431359291,
0.0692689791,
0.2388299555,
0.5079105496,
-0.2832422554,
-0.1113661081,
0.555318892,
0.3872320056,
-0.1388003826,
-0.768294394,
0.3171797097,
-0.0695368946,
-0.0567171089,
0.1786972433,
-0.6046632528,
0.8041591644,
-0.0612589754,
-0.6350215077,
0.1430818737,
0.7000162601,
0.5222915411,
0.3002720773,
0.4850535095,
0.4513763189,
0.5929208994,
0.1539646536,
0.9199898839,
-0.3888099194,
0.2139729857,
1.1901669502,
-0.5483494401,
0.8434664011,
0.6979472637,
-0.3815498948,
0.4214460552,
0.6053357124,
0.2331067771,
0.5249504447,
0.0869334713,
-0.0606348813,
-0.3403294981,
-0.2766418457,
-0.2228778303,
0.372941643,
0.303899616,
-0.3683550656,
-0.3687628806,
-0.3661530614,
0.3415074944,
0.1891569644,
-0.087167792,
0.6098256707,
0.5201909542,
-0.4597328603,
0.5233626366,
-0.0170815121,
0.6141982079,
-0.43730703,
-0.0559950545,
-0.5392288566,
0.2830805182,
-0.2990742922,
-0.4884332418,
0.2138727158,
0.3002634048,
-0.3391361237,
0.2180847228,
0.9782531857,
-0.3264860809,
-0.2520928085,
0.5747865438,
1.1869485378,
0.2362829894,
0.2916385233,
-0.4300494194,
0.0190408621,
0.0105786063,
-0.365790695,
0.5226652622,
0.9721546769,
-0.1270693094,
0.5394985676,
0.6510511637,
0.6706848145,
-0.5231662393,
-0.2560245693,
0.9194030762,
-0.8341776729,
0.0700071156,
-0.8882321119,
0.0733450577,
-0.2423432022,
-0.1817557961,
1.0113477707,
0.3715060353,
0.6085476875,
0.0847971886,
0.6791292429,
0.080773592,
0.5762482882,
-0.491787225,
0.6433286667,
-0.3577270508,
0.5597979426,
-0.3220021427,
-1.0377018452,
-0.2660095692,
0.4138873518,
-0.5215864182,
-0.1270746291,
0.761136651,
0.5667760968,
-0.1565695107,
-0.244253546,
0.3469781578,
0.1343127787,
0.3426679075,
0.6348716617,
0.8334121704,
-0.3338246942,
0.9335311055,
-0.4486232996,
0.0071897707,
0.1095073447,
-0.8867096305,
-0.6571159959,
-0.2319554389,
-0.0129931448,
-0.3505966365,
-0.1698131561,
0.9022015333,
0.3956001699,
-0.5642868876,
-0.4779407382,
0.2993029058,
0.4053341746,
0.244717434,
-0.2853547931,
0.7271120548,
-0.2625534534,
-0.53078866,
0.3454419076,
0.1269584596,
-0.0340114571,
-0.2768404782,
-0.2223584652,
-0.283364445,
-0.5024284124,
0.6482815742,
0.3442721665,
-0.4521385431,
-0.1864314973,
0.0050260238,
-0.2748959959,
-0.0488450192,
0.6925518513,
-0.7644928098,
0.0224526338,
0.3406334817,
0.6789424419,
0.300971061,
0.0738884881,
0.5186312795,
-0.6865380406,
0.2502507567,
0.0217948575,
0.3926014602,
0.5825674534,
-0.3227813244,
0.9665150642,
0.2934723496,
-0.591041863,
-0.9147385359,
0.2137246132,
-0.6354457736,
-0.1455525905,
1.3484437466,
-0.4956616759,
-0.341083914,
-0.3065566421,
0.128930077,
0.4389606416,
-0.3718084395,
0.617805481,
0.6273488402,
-0.359308362,
-0.1219080538,
-0.5382068157,
0.4256395996,
0.1919693947,
-0.7995460033,
0.156612739,
0.442360878,
0.3684329689,
0.3539263308,
0.5934103131,
-0.300888896,
-0.1338394135,
-0.3150371909,
-0.0242085662,
-0.0546413772,
-0.0101455804,
-0.2141508162,
0.2666125596,
0.3432935178,
-0.2073548883
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15479v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15479v1 | Twin-Merging: Dynamic Integration of Modular Expertise in Model Merging | 2024-06-17T02:31:55 | 2024-06-17T02:31:55 | Zhenyi Lu, Chenghao Fan, Wei Wei, Xiaoye Qu, Dangyang Chen, Yu Cheng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | In the era of large language models, model merging is a promising way to
combine multiple task-specific models into a single multitask model without
extra training. However, two challenges remain: (a) interference between
different models and (b) heterogeneous data during testing. Traditional model
merging methods often show significant performance gaps compared to fine-tuned
models due to these issues. Additionally, a one-size-fits-all model lacks
flexibility for diverse test data, leading to performance degradation. We show
that both shared and exclusive task-specific knowledge are crucial for merging
performance, but directly merging exclusive knowledge hinders overall
performance. In view of this, we propose Twin-Merging, a method that
encompasses two principal stages: (1) modularizing knowledge into shared and
exclusive components, with compression to reduce redundancy and enhance
efficiency; (2) dynamically merging shared and task-specific knowledge based on
the input. This approach narrows the performance gap between merged and
fine-tuned models and improves adaptability to heterogeneous data. Extensive
experiments on $12$ datasets for both discriminative and generative tasks
demonstrate the effectiveness of our method, showing an average improvement of
$28.34\%$ in absolute normalized score for discriminative tasks and even
surpassing the fine-tuned upper bound on the generative tasks. (Our
implementation is available in https://github.com/LZY-the-boys/Twin-Mergin.) | [
-0.5238727331,
-0.8980807662,
0.4142070413,
-0.0571113974,
-0.0267340783,
0.3336971104,
-0.3948140144,
-0.6088340282,
-0.0803999156,
0.3498082459,
-0.5789102316,
-0.2573850751,
-0.5591125488,
-0.3687810004,
-0.5361717939,
0.8963500261,
-0.1586076766,
-0.0370076932,
-0.5385499001,
-0.0764574111,
-0.5065924525,
-0.4121368229,
-0.3389167488,
-0.3507317305,
0.6308287382,
0.5192633867,
0.5744211674,
0.5833203197,
0.5381439924,
0.2533215284,
-0.1132254228,
0.5112560987,
-0.3343276381,
0.4105377197,
-0.1305293143,
-0.4031531811,
-0.7352516055,
0.1032513529,
0.749550581,
0.8657740951,
-0.0222701933,
0.2687094212,
0.3055270314,
0.5427765846,
-0.5785773993,
0.3017633557,
-0.3879636824,
0.1516551077,
-0.2048934847,
0.0596995205,
-0.0421238467,
-0.3851537704,
0.0779567063,
-0.3452522755,
0.2479491383,
-0.2381239533,
0.6004955769,
0.4613443017,
-0.6676388979,
0.2874215543,
-0.9763774872,
0.7548123598,
-0.6019144654,
0.223993361,
0.1334255338,
0.4215803444,
0.1795165837,
-0.3149753213,
-0.8154029846,
0.0890078172,
-0.1783300042,
0.0204563718,
-0.1517534107,
0.059778776,
0.2323641777,
0.4868008494,
-0.4977991879,
0.2956712246,
-0.6771024466,
0.0595262498,
0.8941181898,
0.2619352937,
0.3880270123,
0.1237071529,
-0.1706650257,
-0.199833706,
-0.3158898652,
0.0517001972,
0.6387726068,
0.5659323931,
-0.0784258693,
0.6438735127,
-0.2816625237,
0.6600416899,
0.3614476025,
0.056701038,
0.4339236021,
-0.7915092111,
0.0238436311,
-0.2770940363,
0.5886341929,
0.200632304,
-0.0050734924,
-0.3017529249,
-0.2094187289,
0.1416734457,
0.4264450073,
-0.3481242359,
-0.1576253772,
0.331020534,
-0.3850576282,
-0.4017810524,
-0.0841658041,
-0.7650980949,
-0.2346344739,
-0.6545924544,
0.6060378551,
-0.2576426566,
-0.6830658913,
0.1397876441,
-0.1059033647,
0.0138439881,
0.2124469131,
-0.7048590183,
0.2776489258,
0.9891363382,
0.6326042414,
-0.641073823,
-0.6195699573,
-0.534870863,
0.0395136885,
-0.0015606183,
0.6401661634,
-0.3826946914,
-0.1768847853,
-0.004108503,
-0.1805869937,
-0.4029173553,
-0.552980125,
0.147162348,
-0.395707339,
0.3901436031,
-0.3032831252,
-0.4720102847,
-0.2765107453,
0.2472893596,
-0.7289004922,
1.1148109436,
0.1853574067,
-0.6016010046,
0.3150111139,
-0.6955772638,
-0.5358136296,
0.0615501404,
-0.3093612194,
-0.3773755431,
0.1435292363,
-0.0305990186,
0.6220267415,
-0.3860402703,
0.2677482665,
-0.4353182316,
-0.2603816986,
-0.1503285766,
-0.0874195695,
0.6256405115,
-0.01862045,
-0.37772879,
0.2752718329,
-0.5480920672,
0.1237487346,
-0.1852176785,
-0.3063870072,
-0.1229755804,
-0.2137511671,
0.1200466305,
0.2853928208,
0.4547489583,
-0.3061683178,
0.6005086899,
0.0414989963,
0.0479153395,
0.5679596663,
-0.3269443214,
0.7135468721,
-0.6713631749,
0.5160825849,
0.1413584352,
0.2732574046,
0.1209064126,
-0.6482831836,
-0.8393367529,
-0.181698367,
0.4128496647,
0.57723248,
-0.6298769116,
0.676171124,
-0.3581879735,
-0.6767834425,
-0.4013097882,
0.1085786745,
0.5224437714,
0.156376794,
0.3687633276,
-0.6339834929,
-0.4294094741,
-1.0219955444,
-0.259624064,
-0.1016959324,
0.1665132791,
0.1263619959,
0.3229274452,
-0.1941625923,
0.7455883622,
-0.6152922511,
-0.287415415,
-0.2217779309,
0.4272249341,
0.1755521894,
0.9740309715,
0.423897326,
-0.9365301728,
-0.6033639908,
0.2921418548,
-0.5387024283,
0.0802579373,
0.1371988654,
-0.0304012652,
0.0411037803,
0.3264918625,
-0.6256116033,
0.3456208706,
0.7343830466,
-0.2627851367,
0.7279273272,
-0.3179437816,
0.5151767135,
-1.1679975986,
0.0189590007,
-0.3559567928,
-0.1092066988,
-0.8744269609,
0.2049015015,
0.2317239493,
-0.0170203391,
-0.1715738177,
0.3338258266,
-0.538993597,
0.0781396553,
-0.266130954,
-0.2272314876,
-0.3099764585,
0.5191805959,
-0.3861942291,
0.6889765263,
0.6301131248,
-0.5522122383,
0.5735137463,
0.1012818888,
-0.2473867238,
0.4384602606,
-0.1898249686,
0.2812207639,
-0.0015105451,
0.0108202314,
-0.8844437599,
-0.3257423341,
-0.0876833871,
-0.2803897858,
0.4704096615,
-0.0963860452,
-0.7022698522,
-0.3870271742,
-0.0510436259,
0.8033537269,
0.7473278046,
-0.4612576962,
1.1128000021,
0.2902022898,
-0.2253829241,
-0.544691503,
-0.7899920344,
-0.1699292362,
-0.1296003163,
-0.8923515677,
0.6156063676,
-0.1519025564,
0.089209497,
0.3298000097,
-0.3222822249,
-0.5144484639,
-0.0702160746,
0.37159729,
0.4049854279,
-0.270018369,
0.186915651,
0.3935085237,
-0.0599516332,
-0.3270053267,
-0.2700412869,
0.4538924098,
0.1303976923,
-0.5958358049,
-0.5948578119,
0.6461878419,
1.020637393,
-0.3631352782,
0.8724390864,
0.7240030169,
-0.4109174609,
-0.1382611096,
-1.0507699251,
-0.2360330969,
-0.3844981194,
0.3828080297,
-0.4625687599,
-1.0352036953,
0.5284153223,
-0.0316711627,
0.257483989,
0.3082468212,
0.4454820752,
-0.0198993478,
1.0712702274,
0.8509024382,
0.0426059365,
0.4514292181,
-0.2291980535,
0.6123737693,
-0.5929474235,
-0.4232741892,
-0.3518080711,
-0.6399290562,
-0.3895106316,
-0.7561647296,
0.2911640704,
-0.0982725397,
0.0586818941,
0.3391906917,
-0.3735265434,
0.5587599874,
0.5300973058,
0.1753459126,
0.4897213876,
-0.0191555303,
0.0009482916,
0.132803455,
-0.8027960062,
-0.1219755486,
1.2498835325,
-0.0129916687,
0.3725166917,
0.0818812996,
0.5888143778,
0.082673274,
-0.2341482788,
-0.616994679,
0.5660674572,
-0.6103639007,
-0.5133843422,
-0.0638636276,
-0.5311644077,
-0.6766461134,
0.2692523599,
-0.5034158826,
-0.549821496,
0.2367455065,
0.3264392018,
-0.622256279,
0.5504179597,
-0.8258889914,
0.6421640515,
-0.0654381737,
-0.3369780779,
-0.694984138,
-0.363692075,
0.7249732614,
-0.4975294173,
0.1088093817,
-0.1992854476,
0.0300767105,
0.7239430547,
0.0421533361,
0.6528170109,
0.0625221506,
0.0569403805,
-0.2912897468,
0.0674485862,
0.305485338,
-0.2945577204,
0.132376045,
0.1490402371,
0.1419086754,
-0.4725056887,
-0.8264542222,
0.7774692774,
-0.6845843196,
-0.6388042569,
-0.2457628846,
-1.1362890005,
-0.4391416609,
0.0849232078,
-0.1156925708,
0.3854829371,
0.1215162203,
0.1348793954,
0.6438425183,
0.1343750805,
0.0650531277,
0.3948734999,
-0.2240861654,
-0.249026984,
0.651435256,
0.1295156628,
0.4979082048,
0.1291166544,
0.0040982841,
0.14635019,
-0.4562049806,
0.0728830248,
0.1664240807,
-0.3156533837,
-0.1227097884,
-0.7928807735,
-0.3020952046,
-0.5138358474,
-0.002445152,
-0.631213665,
-0.5987176299,
0.0307510309,
0.1789925247,
0.122356005,
0.8909679651,
-0.3755481541,
0.1715767533,
-1.0152571201,
0.2702794969,
0.5784127116,
0.2239554524,
0.1352899373,
-0.1930389851,
-0.3124982119,
-0.1102749929,
-0.0945879519,
-0.8190641403,
-0.0525634922,
-0.1445789039,
0.6222068667,
0.2321697623,
-0.0695222765,
0.8424832225,
-0.22886163,
0.7137183547,
0.3731971681,
-0.8778074384,
0.2557182908,
-0.2735265791,
0.2755360007,
0.6333759427,
0.3217808306,
-0.4835260212,
-0.3633604646,
-0.5523328781,
-0.8273082972,
0.8832216859,
0.2026497871,
-0.0861580595,
0.6701148748,
0.2594785988,
0.2773754299,
0.2008371204,
-0.0857886299,
-0.2128167003,
0.4148158431,
-0.3006310165,
-0.1802458912,
-0.1474956125,
-0.4438985288,
-0.8530622721,
0.452753216,
0.0307480432,
0.1042378768,
-0.381998986,
-0.0782859772,
0.0475539081,
0.0209587663,
0.2627865672,
0.589933455,
-0.081123434,
0.1667350978,
0.2648693919,
-0.3751466274,
-0.0128603345,
0.2480375171,
-0.0286423974,
-0.1674807519,
0.2856021225,
0.6715613008,
0.2117507756,
-0.3630865812,
0.4701378644,
-0.1491831243,
-0.3591612279,
0.1364503354,
0.318408519,
0.0128115257,
0.6347790956,
0.1713602543,
0.4898830354,
-0.1483400613,
-0.5680590272,
0.2372832447,
0.3302074075,
-0.121133998,
-0.4469747543,
0.3088745177,
0.3290013969,
-0.0753523931,
0.5381445885,
-0.171525687,
-0.8118345737,
0.5642383099,
0.1076375619,
0.8746014237,
-0.4223152101,
-0.0027234375,
0.4496609569,
0.091043517,
-0.3634747565,
0.2746587694,
-0.4314367771,
-0.6607966423,
-0.5218778849,
-0.1493803561,
-0.2371043116,
-0.095532164,
-0.857132256,
0.2544937432,
-0.0389511958,
-0.2408403158,
-0.1080407798,
0.1723349988,
-0.828461647,
-0.0391911007,
0.0682626516,
0.6768835187,
-1.0198731422,
0.8597949743,
0.8032996655,
-0.3680802882,
-0.8138865232,
0.1333831698,
0.1640333235,
-0.5098157525,
0.6725319624,
0.0792077705,
0.1760334373,
-0.1636541188,
-0.0760338232,
-0.867397964,
1.1174008846,
0.3150664866,
-0.5270814896,
-0.5458827019,
0.0823097527,
0.1998613179,
-0.4237300456,
0.0895353034,
0.8501257896,
0.5761081576,
0.1565904021,
-1.5379189253,
0.0242479276,
-0.332248956,
-0.1864119172,
0.3815133572,
-0.4249904752,
1.1042555571,
-0.1062677875,
-0.3842496574,
0.0634787083,
0.4177047312,
-0.042331364,
0.2135070711,
0.8191224337,
0.6866553426,
0.9210364223,
-0.1963504404,
0.6698328853,
-0.5007868409,
0.6342046261,
1.186614871,
-0.0373090692,
0.7656734586,
0.4318830371,
-0.0997775272,
0.2986418903,
0.2216666639,
0.0034016981,
0.3529085219,
-0.1655956209,
-0.3394711912,
-0.6034516096,
0.0329853855,
-0.5863862038,
0.4792702198,
-0.1238266677,
0.0029592649,
-0.2223502398,
0.1002196074,
-0.1688343734,
0.0653601736,
0.0845414251,
0.7226142287,
-0.2622252107,
-0.7861238718,
0.3119809031,
-0.3583086431,
1.0022219419,
-0.6134359241,
0.1242586151,
-0.0656872988,
0.3062035739,
-0.3720093369,
-0.8066348433,
0.5978168845,
-0.1779297888,
-0.5024060607,
-0.4483774602,
0.6016142368,
-0.8435565233,
-0.1765962094,
0.4093461037,
0.78131634,
-0.1127806157,
-0.1851410568,
-0.5071853995,
0.1931768507,
0.0091728345,
0.2387882918,
0.3318167627,
0.0120315971,
0.3189852834,
0.427151382,
0.6686358452,
0.2092276961,
0.1719787717,
-0.1494445354,
0.9561020136,
-0.5001118183,
-0.4053764939,
-0.5082904696,
0.7116837502,
-0.1502574682,
-0.0887039155,
0.5599430203,
0.7052945495,
0.9159029722,
0.0065877466,
0.7726857662,
-0.1926993579,
0.3484994471,
-0.3653074205,
0.9799974561,
-1.1114066839,
-0.0230097435,
0.145019263,
-0.8851181865,
-0.223930642,
0.0056902096,
-0.297889024,
0.0195441507,
0.9395971894,
0.7899909019,
-0.4473618865,
-0.0152368108,
0.3997416496,
0.0887260437,
0.2222441137,
0.8383691311,
0.733620584,
-0.3410390317,
0.3224234581,
-0.4607819915,
-0.3619783819,
-0.1331044137,
-0.535189569,
-0.8490257859,
-1.0592609644,
-0.5585975051,
-0.3443359733,
0.1595349312,
0.7256157994,
0.9629094601,
-0.5786452293,
-0.2674116492,
0.1558670253,
0.0272786599,
-0.4776667953,
-0.1768056005,
0.199322924,
-0.4420701563,
-1.0001523495,
0.2973297238,
0.2399739623,
-0.0443552472,
-0.336278826,
0.1648170501,
-0.0783084258,
-0.0174483452,
0.2984055877,
0.1061681136,
-0.5981195569,
0.0175337736,
-0.211449191,
-0.0156953428,
-0.1486703008,
1.1676906347,
-0.6951721907,
0.605037272,
0.8935226202,
0.8364338279,
0.483174026,
-0.0350831002,
0.8362498879,
-0.4598861933,
0.0344895795,
0.187204212,
0.1824315339,
0.1309250146,
-0.3948175311,
0.326300472,
0.2788864672,
-0.4512797892,
-1.1178230047,
0.3172424138,
-1.1413656473,
-0.1522015333,
1.1001559496,
0.0115741715,
0.0377541967,
-0.0445263125,
0.1633573323,
0.5689604282,
-0.1349515617,
0.7557334304,
0.6672427654,
-0.1861966252,
0.0860865265,
-0.4161471128,
0.3266895115,
0.7293227315,
-0.944863379,
0.0781015828,
0.2071533203,
0.2522208989,
0.2786636353,
0.0920437798,
0.0776031166,
0.5009037256,
-0.0447522812,
0.2434590012,
-0.2937897146,
-0.3431085944,
-0.4717621207,
0.2962207496,
-0.3428942263,
-0.3276894093
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11149v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11149v1 | GoldCoin: Grounding Large Language Models in Privacy Laws via Contextual Integrity Theory | 2024-06-17T02:27:32 | 2024-06-17T02:27:32 | Wei Fan, Haoran Li, Zheye Deng, Weiqi Wang, Yangqiu Song | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CR | Privacy issues arise prominently during the inappropriate transmission of
information between entities. Existing research primarily studies privacy by
exploring various privacy attacks, defenses, and evaluations within narrowly
predefined patterns, while neglecting that privacy is not an isolated,
context-free concept limited to traditionally sensitive data (e.g., social
security numbers), but intertwined with intricate social contexts that
complicate the identification and analysis of potential privacy violations. The
advent of Large Language Models (LLMs) offers unprecedented opportunities for
incorporating the nuanced scenarios outlined in privacy laws to tackle these
complex privacy issues. However, the scarcity of open-source relevant case
studies restricts the efficiency of LLMs in aligning with specific legal
statutes. To address this challenge, we introduce a novel framework, GoldCoin,
designed to efficiently ground LLMs in privacy laws for judicial assessing
privacy violations. Our framework leverages the theory of contextual integrity
as a bridge, creating numerous synthetic scenarios grounded in relevant privacy
statutes (e.g., HIPAA), to assist LLMs in comprehending the complex contexts
for identifying privacy risks in the real world. Extensive experimental results
demonstrate that GoldCoin markedly enhances LLMs' capabilities in recognizing
privacy risks across real court cases, surpassing the baselines on different
judicial tasks. | [
0.0256199501,
-1.1631131172,
0.6313572526,
0.0067576799,
-0.2834094465,
-0.0557002723,
-0.3443689942,
-0.6082386374,
0.0896067992,
1.0498775244,
-0.2020771503,
-0.632617116,
-0.5278881788,
-0.0531308465,
-0.4878275096,
1.3885136843,
0.0637151822,
-0.4476488531,
-0.1617718488,
-0.243409723,
-0.322335273,
-0.830568254,
-0.2178254277,
-0.29023242,
0.4855899215,
0.239093557,
0.6689379215,
0.5030412078,
0.4608414769,
0.3220529854,
-0.1700834632,
0.0180398151,
-0.4032609761,
-0.103682749,
-0.2454286516,
-0.3273387253,
-0.5714031458,
-0.2260558307,
0.3812913299,
0.8127869964,
-0.1480019093,
0.0529771447,
0.0666700006,
0.6702527404,
-0.9987444282,
0.1464651227,
-0.7163347602,
-0.0929998904,
-0.21003218,
-0.4700954556,
-0.048724357,
-0.0721418262,
0.0262646917,
-0.3645463586,
0.0090389512,
0.0552918725,
0.7746411562,
-0.1235752925,
-0.5973259807,
-0.2508336604,
-0.5304102302,
0.3868850172,
-0.5653371811,
0.2354778498,
0.5587494969,
0.2462859005,
-0.0265826881,
-0.7385107875,
-0.5386947393,
-0.2258056253,
-0.1163870692,
-0.1954969466,
-0.0023043905,
0.1189472228,
0.3904887736,
0.6233657002,
-0.3974105716,
-0.2228643149,
-0.0876479149,
-0.0979577154,
0.4909549057,
0.0540615581,
0.2971357703,
-0.2628703415,
0.0699992776,
0.0549713448,
-0.8510697484,
0.1278015524,
0.5816132426,
0.6834942698,
-0.2514773607,
0.5342994928,
-0.0604570061,
0.5936893225,
0.0139487013,
-0.2845582962,
0.2091376483,
-0.2035321444,
-0.4010833204,
0.4828590453,
0.5916063786,
0.2647607923,
0.2083580494,
-0.22017847,
-0.1061271131,
0.0779172927,
0.2058511972,
-0.7259830832,
-0.0557097122,
0.5869829059,
-0.3667938709,
-0.5157961249,
0.2872292101,
-0.3263225853,
-0.6658056378,
-0.3713753223,
0.2614538372,
-0.0040680072,
-0.3089480102,
0.370770812,
0.2062487453,
0.0029371104,
-0.0398099832,
-1.1253112555,
0.6202029586,
1.2694692612,
0.8498760462,
0.4797188938,
-0.1575897038,
-0.7961063385,
0.5194267035,
-0.4252191782,
0.3608787954,
-0.370052129,
-0.2916201055,
0.2902519107,
0.3700286448,
0.3187806904,
-0.3194244504,
0.5702722073,
-0.6708815694,
-0.4794008434,
-0.2183261812,
-0.2358756959,
-0.1012343168,
0.6480619907,
-0.8799647093,
0.2493619621,
-0.0359451398,
-1.0902934074,
0.3516950905,
-0.6650013328,
-0.7258736491,
0.2731420696,
-0.2198359668,
-0.4960010052,
0.005473888,
-0.004164597,
0.3352235258,
-0.074721314,
0.4515280724,
-0.5114001632,
-0.5656849742,
0.5968195796,
-0.3265299201,
1.0333849192,
0.0994814187,
-0.3685227633,
0.1225243136,
-0.8166018128,
-0.2594558001,
0.1074941903,
-0.0414211676,
-0.9877591729,
-0.1120598167,
0.1629186571,
0.0038179858,
0.433154732,
-0.3368121982,
-0.1737349331,
-0.7217819691,
0.9390066862,
0.7259905934,
0.0530932024,
0.5586600304,
-0.0914779902,
0.1657646149,
-0.0861328691,
0.1780835092,
-0.245829612,
-0.082222186,
-0.2479941845,
-0.0818710029,
0.5274346471,
0.7824960947,
0.317081213,
0.687117219,
-0.5274817944,
-0.0051271506,
-0.3077601194,
0.386746347,
-0.2059131265,
0.2678447664,
-0.0889996365,
-0.2948141992,
-0.6399490237,
-0.8034026027,
-0.5758364797,
-0.1769387424,
0.241544947,
0.591501832,
0.6434829831,
-0.5979112387,
0.9803187847,
0.0387756787,
-0.1780742854,
0.1028898954,
-0.1433075815,
0.2756076753,
0.6909937263,
0.1998283118,
-1.1688171625,
-0.1155032292,
0.5904844999,
-0.8465498686,
0.1734357476,
-0.1521300226,
-0.2143764496,
-0.0205650423,
0.4129424989,
-0.7026776075,
0.5238656998,
0.6411120296,
-0.4308486283,
0.1445902288,
-0.3462335169,
0.1455051899,
-1.0871471167,
0.3367418945,
-0.1623875201,
-0.4800019264,
-0.4926711023,
-0.0019682841,
0.3743212819,
-0.1989599019,
-0.2821255028,
0.4627528489,
-0.1339347363,
-0.2859147489,
-0.4522312582,
0.1461141258,
0.0436270796,
-0.0670907274,
-0.2666396499,
0.4568834603,
0.4910297394,
-0.4460890293,
0.2985182703,
0.0660114437,
-0.2864318192,
0.6492197514,
-0.6603264213,
0.0016429493,
0.0850440562,
0.2433473021,
-0.576710701,
-0.448335886,
0.4608164132,
-0.1973730922,
0.2082203925,
-0.4837139547,
-0.7277629375,
0.0030580971,
-0.1329124719,
0.6294023991,
0.2173019648,
-0.3642328978,
0.7826699615,
0.4955069423,
-0.2337888181,
-1.0029239655,
-0.8525754809,
0.6847886443,
-0.5759780407,
-0.4842328727,
0.360560447,
-0.0028012807,
-0.7968001366,
0.0971219167,
0.0054672337,
-0.0042217928,
0.5699403286,
0.552903235,
0.1369002908,
0.3210884035,
-0.0897231773,
0.0496346988,
-0.3015656471,
0.2501751482,
-0.5575588942,
0.348282665,
-0.3119648397,
-0.2764646709,
-0.4698640406,
0.4927971959,
0.5436612964,
-0.2768338323,
0.7114518285,
0.0502772518,
-0.5985319018,
-0.0306531116,
-0.4984155893,
-0.1212316677,
-0.51965487,
0.1242740378,
-0.342952162,
-1.2065085173,
0.7872610688,
-0.2255308777,
0.3360346854,
0.1056886241,
0.589032352,
0.1913069338,
0.8267515302,
0.9241645932,
-0.2586206794,
0.5151169896,
-0.0585276596,
0.6977447271,
-0.629817307,
0.0292916633,
-0.3466662169,
0.2448577285,
-0.9342348576,
-0.039874889,
0.1569520682,
0.074459739,
-0.3621948659,
0.2251375914,
0.0477627814,
0.4914938807,
0.0641997531,
0.1613520533,
0.4698081017,
0.2311131954,
0.2039796859,
0.2814409733,
-0.3468030691,
-0.8702737093,
1.257095933,
0.4570279419,
0.7635927796,
0.1277465373,
0.7446235418,
0.477782011,
0.2902314067,
-0.6159597635,
0.2429514527,
-0.0479632542,
-0.6890538335,
-0.1362339258,
-0.4157164693,
-1.0827960968,
0.0914138332,
-0.1951565295,
-0.753537178,
0.1207403764,
0.2041670382,
-0.4973132014,
0.190165177,
-0.1684119701,
1.0957359076,
-0.2227993608,
-1.0601091385,
-0.0253932774,
-0.749979496,
0.58598423,
-0.2489906847,
0.7431822419,
0.2002495676,
0.052883625,
0.3863941133,
-0.6349579692,
0.9161357284,
0.2587319314,
-0.579425931,
0.2861984372,
0.1598575562,
0.674934864,
0.6409800649,
0.169753179,
0.2772777975,
0.0012683162,
-0.3236926496,
-0.4979045987,
1.15566957,
-0.5497382283,
-0.3477700651,
-0.4121693075,
-0.7023888826,
-0.0847714096,
0.259871006,
-0.1691858768,
0.3486655951,
-0.1346656382,
0.1412902921,
0.7822748423,
0.097176671,
0.2242952287,
0.3066261709,
0.3087254763,
-0.5611187816,
0.6615345478,
0.147765547,
-0.2448914349,
0.2038150579,
0.1202066839,
-0.2764461935,
-0.24760966,
-0.1007939354,
0.4840714633,
-0.9802173972,
0.00903745,
-0.7847567201,
0.0384870283,
-0.6121363044,
-0.3715016246,
-0.3584864736,
-0.0587953441,
-0.0225020498,
-0.2925516665,
0.3492585123,
0.1280779988,
-0.2522896826,
-0.087870039,
-0.7039501667,
0.2461904734,
0.5049776435,
0.4355600774,
-0.3358857036,
-0.2933952212,
-0.1571486592,
-0.0677756071,
0.2010076791,
-0.524533987,
0.1141357049,
-0.2048329562,
0.2476549745,
0.5984991789,
0.0940958187,
1.077062726,
-0.6447424293,
0.613758862,
0.0624806061,
-1.1777317524,
0.5910641551,
-0.2016095817,
-0.3627686501,
0.7379187942,
-0.1260630637,
-0.6640771031,
-0.272754997,
-0.9762614369,
-1.2024972439,
0.1656766385,
0.2833050191,
0.5440557003,
-0.0498485975,
0.8066371083,
0.0959002078,
0.5069941282,
-1.1266913414,
0.0389648788,
-0.120229356,
-0.2173042744,
-0.1801611781,
-0.3685429692,
-0.8031157255,
0.0299763549,
0.3594217598,
-0.1303900629,
-0.0351581648,
-0.0064732349,
-0.2766636014,
-0.1394774765,
0.3578447104,
0.6336011887,
0.8949839473,
-0.2112015933,
0.3933288455,
0.0095811905,
-0.3765636981,
0.0347559303,
0.03536091,
-0.3193281591,
-0.3489122689,
0.4146293104,
0.5468894839,
0.2724784315,
-0.9359871149,
0.6963227391,
0.0034275472,
-0.283357203,
-0.8702272773,
-0.1511521935,
-0.0795653313,
0.2596682608,
0.0892140269,
-0.12137454,
0.3436961472,
-0.8021326065,
0.300465852,
0.5150778294,
-0.4210762978,
-0.1702936739,
0.5574210286,
-0.0503764488,
-0.347982347,
0.3152673542,
0.2250173837,
-0.2872559726,
0.4214383662,
0.594578445,
0.8242456913,
0.1555909365,
-0.2176458538,
0.1760130078,
0.5425707102,
-0.3594287336,
0.1159955263,
-0.3276668489,
-0.5579707623,
-0.3144713044,
-0.2808983922,
-0.2984524369,
0.222353965,
-0.5871731639,
0.0250316318,
-0.637460649,
-0.3259760141,
-0.4405753016,
0.1195860878,
-0.2767502069,
0.1050925627,
0.2138575464,
0.426517278,
-0.9931045771,
0.5153278708,
0.7088163495,
0.0519164838,
-0.3230476081,
0.0966125801,
-0.0328122638,
-0.3658963144,
0.4887090325,
0.3821214139,
-0.1763647646,
-0.3312692344,
-0.7673838735,
-0.3986653686,
1.0463294983,
0.4674946964,
-0.8119155765,
0.3116038442,
0.1941099614,
0.3366944194,
-0.44195351,
-0.4036501646,
0.5853439569,
0.4919460714,
-0.2530082762,
-0.5744782686,
0.1387835145,
-0.2845650315,
0.0477605611,
0.1101762727,
-0.5247026682,
0.9470091462,
-0.0503541827,
0.0524941608,
-0.1615795642,
0.5797123909,
0.4789994359,
0.5190740228,
0.5801486373,
0.5311644673,
0.9323872328,
0.1255791634,
1.0836565495,
-0.6980282664,
0.4871361852,
0.7657648921,
-0.5474557877,
0.6228191853,
0.6775246859,
0.1593256593,
0.673590064,
0.4965309799,
0.1576633006,
0.5004343987,
0.2835183144,
-0.3803963363,
-0.4324999452,
-0.124420166,
-0.1214131191,
0.2973302603,
0.3850595057,
-0.4410733879,
0.141470477,
-0.015657166,
0.1244191602,
0.3043240309,
-0.4312476516,
0.5882208943,
0.1374085546,
-0.2518063486,
0.2389484942,
0.2514625788,
0.3577772677,
-0.6147298813,
-0.043532908,
0.018570466,
0.3030464351,
-0.3256392777,
-0.3241322935,
0.1189489886,
0.0607599653,
-0.0202377141,
0.0175169222,
0.6803782582,
-0.2491352558,
-0.3503966331,
0.1582123637,
-0.0929193199,
0.0381286293,
-0.1667603701,
-0.7519139051,
0.3130330145,
-0.5968506932,
-0.1528878063,
0.4531157017,
0.7177311182,
-0.2376008183,
0.5222870708,
0.7889951468,
0.0994084105,
-0.4259796143,
0.1929831058,
0.6978778243,
-0.8265405297,
-1.0627719164,
-1.2161638737,
0.5416068435,
-0.3559013307,
0.0903210342,
0.7576268911,
0.5249910355,
0.7057616711,
0.4027434886,
0.8856298923,
0.0836243778,
0.1267119497,
-0.5898046494,
0.5877537131,
-0.4964320064,
0.5206996799,
-0.4827382863,
-0.6791200638,
-0.6321982145,
1.0163521767,
-0.2714737356,
-0.0427400097,
0.4561798573,
0.6984677315,
-0.1151338443,
-0.1244937927,
0.2131272703,
-0.0276481286,
0.4207469225,
0.4632260501,
0.544942379,
-0.7043383121,
0.4029707909,
-0.3017454445,
-0.2192479819,
-0.4619769454,
-1.046826005,
-1.0566982031,
-0.2382004112,
-0.3121616244,
-0.6493554711,
-0.0178232733,
0.8255087733,
0.6425408721,
-0.6731418967,
-0.5303368568,
-0.2847453952,
-0.0840570033,
-0.3872341216,
-0.1635525376,
0.4563842714,
-0.023960717,
-0.4382911026,
0.1863173693,
0.5914650559,
0.1238178536,
-0.2119556069,
-0.1163974628,
0.0623949058,
0.0579378791,
0.6750441194,
0.4164001942,
-0.7442272902,
-0.3104898632,
-0.4019580185,
-0.2447075099,
-0.0418742523,
1.2166337967,
-0.4026154876,
0.4053103328,
0.1476447433,
0.8084501028,
0.222954765,
0.391207844,
0.2589820027,
-0.3748873174,
0.4140953124,
0.180333063,
0.4098272324,
0.4623970985,
-0.6583867669,
0.0754238665,
0.2448452562,
-0.4879113436,
-0.988139689,
0.1496188045,
-1.1146056652,
-0.3804844916,
0.8734401464,
-0.1784517467,
-0.7184063792,
-0.2238520235,
-0.003206345,
-0.0049026269,
-0.1477776617,
1.0995547771,
0.720056951,
0.5113121271,
-0.136829257,
-0.8672376871,
0.3344298899,
0.1945777535,
-0.6608688235,
0.6065365672,
0.4056289792,
0.4492427111,
0.160293296,
0.7781073451,
-0.4863677919,
0.3458033502,
-0.1456000954,
-0.2229815871,
-0.1786510795,
-0.2577999532,
-0.5562634468,
0.566352427,
-0.0438548289,
0.2147191614
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11139v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11139v1 | Breaking Boundaries: Investigating the Effects of Model Editing on Cross-linguistic Performance | 2024-06-17T01:54:27 | 2024-06-17T01:54:27 | Somnath Banerjee, Avik Halder, Rajarshi Mandal, Sayan Layek, Ian Soboroff, Rima Hazra, Animesh Mukherjee | cs.CL | cs.CL | The integration of pretrained language models (PLMs) like BERT and GPT has
revolutionized NLP, particularly for English, but it has also created
linguistic imbalances. This paper strategically identifies the need for
linguistic equity by examining several knowledge editing techniques in
multilingual contexts. We evaluate the performance of models such as Mistral,
TowerInstruct, OpenHathi, Tamil-Llama, and Kan-Llama across languages including
English, German, French, Italian, Spanish, Hindi, Tamil, and Kannada. Our
research identifies significant discrepancies in normal and merged models
concerning cross-lingual consistency. We employ strategies like 'each language
for itself' (ELFI) and 'each language for others' (ELFO) to stress-test these
models. Our findings demonstrate the potential for LLMs to overcome linguistic
barriers, laying the groundwork for future research in achieving linguistic
inclusivity in AI technologies. | [
-0.4654183984,
-0.6901239157,
0.285512656,
0.3038771152,
0.1182216555,
0.3748945296,
-0.3465191126,
-0.7415730953,
-0.051545959,
0.4716417193,
-0.3414515555,
-0.3433421254,
-0.8578800559,
0.2409490198,
-0.3395707905,
0.7849949002,
-0.4017789066,
0.2474256307,
-0.2919023633,
-0.4123809636,
-0.6356359124,
-0.6227710247,
-0.3743115664,
-0.4606384039,
0.3291783631,
0.0190471802,
1.0261881351,
0.5137807131,
0.2182682604,
0.3423059285,
-0.3156090379,
0.1797400117,
-0.2901332378,
-0.0761730075,
-0.439524442,
-0.5116917491,
-0.4513819516,
0.0091017857,
0.9992576241,
0.7324237227,
0.103742823,
-0.1666397154,
0.3235240281,
0.3904677331,
-0.4497714043,
-0.1471138746,
-0.6696864963,
0.1449147314,
-0.2861586511,
0.0906912461,
-0.173358947,
-0.1358224303,
0.0823351666,
-0.680087626,
-0.0437160432,
-0.1685966253,
1.0712434053,
0.3243908286,
-0.2927360833,
-0.1827607751,
-0.6154956222,
0.8010597825,
-0.8268289566,
0.7599226832,
0.2491220683,
-0.233440727,
0.0343236662,
-0.5415710807,
-0.5167893767,
0.0386491828,
-0.1122624651,
-0.060489215,
-0.2400132716,
0.1570089459,
0.1189232618,
0.225240618,
-0.3849951327,
0.5806185603,
-0.5282043815,
-0.0353814699,
0.5987782478,
-0.0816730931,
0.8649339676,
0.0084566623,
-0.048569005,
0.0410733782,
-0.8427087665,
0.0804688931,
0.6614257097,
0.2963747084,
-0.0056581348,
0.7807471752,
0.1752025485,
0.7309257984,
-0.2750357091,
-0.0934725478,
0.1586035937,
-0.3976983428,
-0.2474758923,
-0.0330733173,
0.679572165,
0.3450095654,
0.4861164987,
-0.2112083137,
-0.0063240402,
-0.1754549444,
0.0820287615,
-0.1605460495,
0.0223554783,
-0.0143427961,
-0.1632483155,
0.087969549,
-0.3529109657,
-0.6265544891,
-0.4162476063,
-0.4596591294,
0.4671687782,
-0.6305422783,
-0.4345929027,
0.0692021847,
-0.082622081,
0.1202667356,
0.2695808411,
-0.8973174095,
0.1309822798,
0.6833785772,
0.7670010328,
-0.0308630951,
-0.8871330619,
0.0601086654,
0.0325413197,
-0.3748437166,
0.476170361,
-0.705072701,
-0.5632687211,
0.0693130344,
-0.1572719067,
-0.3081727326,
-0.5916959643,
0.2570011318,
-0.5074586868,
0.0975032672,
-0.3135667443,
-0.6929638982,
-0.0665715784,
0.1794383526,
-0.7029426098,
1.0433624983,
-0.1251239479,
-0.6119138002,
0.4258626401,
-0.7354168296,
-0.4950826764,
-0.1747548878,
-0.0786711201,
-0.2437793463,
0.085621722,
0.4196904302,
0.109363392,
-0.0178167131,
0.4138558507,
0.0272429585,
-0.1417019069,
0.0160233844,
-0.1750348359,
0.9216068387,
0.0355784632,
-0.3559051752,
0.203943938,
-0.5876964927,
0.050315626,
-0.0203418955,
-0.1246994138,
-0.5571853518,
-0.1348236203,
-0.0126190139,
0.4578475654,
0.1753738672,
-0.4320558012,
0.0787647739,
-0.2566820681,
0.3594765663,
0.8577260375,
-0.3873299062,
0.4001119733,
-0.3284135759,
0.7205734849,
-0.026233457,
0.1452649236,
0.0485583134,
-0.7129405737,
-0.8512143493,
-0.1873706728,
0.5841633081,
0.6544753909,
-0.7726080418,
0.2391964942,
-0.1108775288,
-0.4321229756,
-1.1497373581,
0.5423368812,
0.2140578181,
0.2287580967,
0.4175711274,
-0.1706821918,
-0.5311959386,
-0.8578966856,
-0.7952001095,
-0.0281672403,
0.2795590758,
0.1444956213,
0.3482768834,
-0.2700632811,
0.9782875776,
0.1670820713,
-0.2206279784,
-0.3263396621,
0.1979586333,
-0.1770348102,
0.6248361468,
0.4646887183,
-0.6038310528,
-0.6289818287,
0.1248646528,
-0.7445918918,
-0.4835742712,
-0.1358035952,
-0.1502087265,
0.3184224963,
0.5002926588,
-0.5275889635,
0.4966633618,
0.9173019528,
-0.2050675005,
0.3728072047,
-0.2492040545,
0.3822077811,
-0.7201562524,
-0.2199455947,
-0.0813535675,
0.0496106371,
-0.6836346388,
0.1262494028,
-0.0867019519,
-0.1176881045,
-0.5604208112,
0.7887192369,
-0.574277401,
-0.1040195152,
-0.0588826574,
0.2290413082,
-0.0297500063,
0.2226622552,
0.1184831858,
0.7363715172,
0.3893656433,
-0.3430609107,
-0.1176421866,
0.2407962531,
-0.4046869278,
0.3805469275,
-0.6251841187,
0.1502422094,
-0.1159480959,
-0.1321845055,
-0.8149579763,
0.2018894106,
-0.1251857281,
-0.1843425483,
0.3223034441,
-0.1067840606,
-0.579064846,
0.1189487353,
-0.1765536517,
0.6304361224,
0.2823582292,
-0.5354017019,
0.7301678658,
0.5107352734,
-0.4346219301,
-0.8061910272,
-0.8118927479,
0.4003959894,
-0.0202694312,
-0.9241560698,
0.2237739563,
0.0231163613,
-0.6506263018,
0.0737932101,
0.2738315165,
-0.1667888165,
0.1342246234,
0.0150741534,
0.1534531713,
-0.0360359736,
0.0146580217,
0.3737376332,
0.3288975358,
-0.2233956009,
-0.1272649616,
0.4488751292,
-0.0868460834,
-0.4599358737,
-0.3294465244,
0.4493696094,
0.4258941412,
-0.5783301592,
0.837983489,
0.5656141043,
-0.3164884746,
-0.2697820067,
-0.6738390326,
0.2490060478,
-0.4167181253,
0.3971064985,
-0.5243164897,
-1.3595210314,
0.6696471572,
0.0089976927,
0.0942106918,
0.4650191665,
0.425974071,
0.0906647965,
0.942736268,
1.0240277052,
-0.0265431497,
0.4530470371,
-0.0836617425,
0.3794844449,
-0.7090749145,
-0.0982019752,
-0.4761554003,
-0.2390259504,
-0.7729253769,
-0.5769355297,
0.3804343045,
0.3165499568,
0.0338033363,
0.1652257442,
-0.2658266127,
0.5901960135,
0.583165586,
-0.1825045794,
0.5371335149,
-0.1253205389,
-0.3302504122,
-0.5590987206,
-1.0388667583,
-0.4129694104,
1.0155211687,
0.445276618,
0.6692153811,
0.0421919562,
0.5548738837,
0.2166019529,
0.4622443616,
-0.3116665781,
0.3099506199,
-0.3015539646,
-0.73672086,
-0.4284445047,
-0.1903433949,
-0.7448028326,
0.4496737123,
-0.1819585413,
-0.6165242791,
0.3775297105,
-0.0549341403,
-0.1241613403,
0.7908425927,
-0.6881629229,
0.9537362456,
-0.4874719679,
-0.4006333351,
-0.2300194502,
-0.5072179437,
0.5549440384,
-0.24544321,
0.5309588313,
-0.1139971018,
-0.0052005332,
0.7182905078,
-0.3185932338,
0.8984903693,
-0.0579674281,
-0.3574586511,
0.15292871,
0.0355539992,
0.2067340016,
-0.1513323784,
-0.0554126203,
0.7531680465,
-0.1215333864,
-0.440415144,
-0.3606660664,
0.6113473773,
-1.0617294312,
-0.5927960873,
-0.2028181404,
-0.9151631594,
-0.3911576569,
0.2252842039,
0.1611281484,
-0.0600298531,
-0.2193079144,
-0.165687263,
0.5201717615,
-0.5892875195,
0.3743699491,
0.3855755627,
-0.3427118957,
-0.3626843095,
0.5543766022,
0.503621161,
0.3692376614,
0.0948681012,
-0.0735065714,
-0.1643757373,
-0.5038993359,
-0.4019235373,
0.3490844965,
-0.6926026344,
0.2000451088,
-0.8026434779,
-0.3123867512,
-0.604896903,
-0.4643951952,
-0.4739570022,
-0.3010519147,
0.0217086338,
-0.1418857574,
0.0803656504,
1.0239830017,
-0.4855982363,
0.3215430081,
-0.7989589572,
0.1335227787,
0.0947337672,
0.4052625597,
-0.0671167001,
-0.4852741063,
-0.3428488076,
0.036510855,
-0.1565396339,
-0.6906784773,
0.4020574689,
0.1553515047,
0.734968245,
-0.2490470707,
-0.3257628381,
0.8596567512,
-0.6176688671,
0.7992082834,
0.0493238233,
-1.479170084,
0.4092761278,
-0.225530535,
0.3661165237,
0.3140540123,
0.5131285787,
-0.8036093116,
-0.827454865,
-0.5571311116,
-0.968963325,
0.562456429,
0.0194535162,
0.0924411863,
0.2877631187,
0.0900911391,
0.2651373744,
0.2562507391,
-0.9018979669,
-0.1146381497,
-0.1381504685,
-0.0127910618,
-0.1741669178,
-0.3741984367,
-0.146822691,
-0.4851097167,
0.6743491292,
0.1863324046,
-0.1881080568,
0.3168034852,
-0.4799690545,
-0.0891533419,
0.3768647909,
0.6053679585,
1.0814429522,
0.0875937417,
-0.1026177853,
0.2947985828,
-0.1326961219,
0.1207313091,
0.1399740577,
-0.1904896349,
0.1753811836,
0.6075720191,
0.8803313971,
0.0893281922,
-0.6011461616,
0.0679758191,
0.1273518056,
-0.1708967835,
0.1850035638,
-0.1320369244,
0.0292365272,
0.2212891579,
0.01468533,
0.0634572208,
-0.3189564347,
-0.5418354273,
0.2215071768,
0.3286871016,
-0.1752867401,
-0.1791446656,
0.8120446205,
0.218968913,
-0.2240517586,
0.4890798032,
0.1148879901,
-0.7020916939,
0.3994601369,
0.3982241452,
0.7093311548,
-0.5624324679,
0.1228169128,
0.0042439308,
1.0466600657,
0.0624127612,
0.1245686412,
0.1272674352,
-1.1320390701,
-0.7999500036,
-0.3960939348,
-0.5060015321,
0.0765254498,
-0.453499198,
0.236076206,
-0.377974093,
-0.151658982,
-0.0763250217,
-0.2341253757,
-0.6898006201,
0.1517852545,
0.2508040965,
0.8898837566,
-1.0379476547,
0.8946216106,
0.7571897507,
-0.2721527517,
-0.6782843471,
-0.1550920457,
0.0117661525,
-0.705360949,
0.6601827145,
-0.204270795,
0.0476812795,
-0.0213872343,
-0.3733599782,
-0.7609972954,
0.7172219157,
0.5200342536,
-0.4486941099,
-0.043700505,
0.5775014758,
0.6401491761,
-0.2380135208,
0.2001466155,
0.7811234593,
0.7020376325,
-0.5271963477,
-1.514633894,
-0.3577097058,
-0.2482877523,
0.0958464518,
0.0470784642,
-0.6361884475,
1.0836902857,
0.0385471173,
0.0994329005,
-0.0238090791,
0.5024551153,
0.0921370238,
0.047793556,
0.4044343531,
0.8249890804,
0.7163858414,
-0.1417345405,
0.9048084617,
-0.4233356714,
0.1424262822,
1.0485520363,
-0.5055941939,
0.5711461902,
0.5192815661,
-0.158882156,
0.413433969,
0.4299467504,
0.2486705184,
0.2229854017,
0.1117026284,
-0.1087152585,
-0.0103345169,
-0.4041797817,
-0.4458055496,
0.4979925752,
0.2637668252,
-0.189222917,
-0.2265778333,
0.2478000671,
0.4410308599,
0.338383615,
-0.3363729715,
0.4617969096,
0.0165156517,
-0.6207707524,
0.5521436334,
0.200831145,
0.8787099719,
-0.6495583653,
0.0718320161,
-0.2807175815,
0.0314110406,
-0.223448813,
-0.7965881228,
0.4266281128,
0.2063730657,
-0.0096492907,
-0.5402199626,
0.6853069067,
-0.8376678228,
-0.4924047887,
0.8194300532,
0.8371679783,
-0.0085257431,
0.1346973926,
-0.8447874784,
0.3976648152,
-0.0107650626,
0.0087112011,
0.3646680117,
0.3758604228,
-0.1279867887,
0.5169141293,
0.50844872,
0.3186278045,
0.5355807543,
0.0507438704,
0.5945746899,
-0.5377373099,
-0.3951324522,
-0.7594249845,
0.7460998297,
-0.026496483,
-0.5535457134,
0.9487925172,
0.4472842813,
1.3255579472,
0.161691159,
0.9319753051,
0.0020991552,
0.2403406352,
-0.5914176106,
0.7952798009,
-0.6918615103,
0.1407100111,
-0.3962371349,
-0.7721615434,
-0.4085521102,
0.2420953661,
-0.4219501913,
0.1210898831,
0.632353723,
0.6549039483,
0.1598475873,
-0.216261968,
0.5420544744,
0.4117634594,
0.291808635,
0.3456869125,
0.99840343,
-0.3813443184,
0.1670187861,
-0.4316882491,
-0.1476798654,
0.3443211019,
-0.8435654044,
-0.8730441928,
-0.3729346991,
-0.1985793263,
-0.2274976224,
0.4339745641,
0.6158428788,
0.5289426446,
-0.6302450299,
-0.6600891352,
0.2412278503,
0.4308740199,
-0.049927,
-0.2076675147,
0.1565668434,
-0.5239421725,
-1.0097893476,
0.505094409,
0.3474889994,
-0.0487139709,
-0.2951982021,
-0.0713090152,
-0.6474252939,
0.1557686478,
0.503200233,
0.2783951759,
-0.8036700487,
-0.0496795811,
-0.1401220858,
0.0111567276,
0.0585757867,
0.8350384831,
-0.3871699572,
0.6531678438,
0.4458294511,
0.8879557252,
0.1199856997,
-0.0586133972,
0.9575570822,
-0.8493266702,
0.3701318204,
0.1687203199,
0.4413920939,
0.6486285329,
-0.1713690907,
0.5554714799,
0.3688490391,
-0.5868216157,
-0.9176533818,
-0.1149608269,
-0.3285758793,
-0.3722442985,
1.004134059,
-0.1608540118,
-0.0828002244,
-0.0527384989,
0.0326678306,
0.3037753701,
0.1466540247,
0.5129023194,
1.1995126009,
-0.1708277017,
-0.1772560179,
-0.6878685951,
0.5906219482,
0.861090064,
-0.6641435623,
-0.1267422587,
0.3563682139,
0.1656287462,
0.1011935472,
0.5537930727,
-0.2620718181,
0.131695196,
-0.0747908205,
0.472949028,
0.0654019862,
-0.378475666,
-0.6090500951,
-0.1129096523,
0.1366834044,
0.2436661571
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11132v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11132v1 | RePrompt: Planning by Automatic Prompt Engineering for Large Language Models Agents | 2024-06-17T01:23:11 | 2024-06-17T01:23:11 | Weizhe Chen, Sven Koenig, Bistra Dilkina | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | In this past year, large language models (LLMs) have had remarkable success
in domains outside the traditional natural language processing, and people are
starting to explore the usage of LLMs in more general and close to application
domains like code generation, travel planning, and robot controls. Connecting
these LLMs with great capacity and external tools, people are building the
so-called LLM agents, which are supposed to help people do all kinds of work in
everyday life. In all these domains, the prompt to the LLMs has been shown to
make a big difference in what the LLM would generate and thus affect the
performance of the LLM agents. Therefore, automatic prompt engineering has
become an important question for many researchers and users of LLMs. In this
paper, we propose a novel method, \textsc{RePrompt}, which does "gradient
descent" to optimize the step-by-step instructions in the prompt of the LLM
agents based on the chat history obtained from interactions with LLM agents. By
optimizing the prompt, the LLM will learn how to plan in specific domains. We
have used experiments in PDDL generation and travel planning to show that our
method could generally improve the performance for different reasoning tasks
when using the updated prompt as the initial prompt. | [
-0.6240975857,
-0.5807256103,
0.6326478124,
0.3284931779,
-0.0875198916,
0.1515526325,
-0.3144367039,
-0.0603429973,
0.1417728662,
0.5820298195,
-1.1376523972,
-0.5493443608,
-0.0903354436,
0.2503814101,
0.1033791974,
0.5962558985,
-0.2513068914,
0.1645629704,
-0.0234390758,
0.0285843574,
-0.6067699194,
-0.4326100051,
-0.9220814109,
-0.3697583973,
0.6826020479,
0.5169646144,
0.3460502625,
0.500148952,
0.2472444624,
0.3330750465,
0.0987073109,
0.3637219071,
-0.4335498512,
0.4866670668,
-0.2877908051,
-0.4867868721,
-0.3243615031,
-0.0671957433,
0.6323441267,
0.5152899623,
-0.0284465402,
0.1315627694,
0.0321429335,
0.746966064,
-0.4402523339,
0.2169966698,
-0.3946464062,
0.0481780395,
0.343629092,
-0.7646550536,
-0.5971161127,
-0.3163384199,
-0.0240930617,
-0.4734949172,
0.1407614648,
0.2667805552,
0.4131275117,
0.301812619,
-0.1787304282,
-0.1448159218,
-0.5876190662,
0.9273064137,
-0.517472446,
0.3344890773,
0.0793298259,
0.5460518599,
-0.7319111228,
-0.7100337148,
-0.4770994186,
-0.5153137445,
0.031844005,
-0.2258178294,
-0.0122318212,
0.2657726407,
0.4697646499,
-0.258141458,
-0.7192301154,
0.3661756516,
0.0389696397,
-0.3850725889,
0.53036201,
0.4053347409,
0.3773014843,
0.0227894336,
-0.507581234,
-0.2440094054,
-0.8712584972,
0.0297436304,
0.3833479285,
0.5845674276,
0.0344227552,
0.6770145297,
-0.3643016517,
0.7801866531,
-0.0248203687,
-0.1187792495,
-0.0833017677,
-0.1965859234,
-0.1537995338,
-0.0757787004,
0.6358706951,
0.444206953,
0.6008492112,
0.1335978359,
-0.3866344988,
-0.2562895119,
0.0421943516,
-0.9349132776,
-0.1899344772,
0.26604563,
-0.3806033432,
-0.1236068457,
-0.4270463288,
-0.8797807097,
-0.6282408237,
-0.5365409255,
0.0846733823,
-0.4590995908,
0.0799281001,
-0.0339239202,
0.0160974897,
0.2508040667,
0.4518742561,
-0.7110592127,
0.0911800638,
0.7389924526,
0.75331074,
-0.0473492853,
-0.4596131444,
-0.9313765764,
-0.2133622169,
-0.2737640142,
1.0258821249,
-0.5938029289,
-0.583973825,
0.2928781807,
-0.130293712,
-0.0241099242,
-0.059546575,
0.4708969593,
-0.8216061592,
0.3646067977,
-0.2799978256,
-0.4449884892,
-0.1389615089,
0.4444216192,
-0.4991210699,
0.4975245297,
0.1465753615,
-0.6030067801,
0.1487056911,
-0.6297487617,
-0.5038312674,
0.0220769998,
-0.2185782492,
-0.0785302594,
-0.3323282003,
0.4624238014,
0.4119150043,
-0.3830311,
0.1313174367,
0.1117470339,
-0.1210564747,
0.2958494723,
-0.1380555183,
0.908878088,
0.1992217004,
-0.1847177446,
0.4244723618,
-0.6374326944,
0.0913835466,
-0.0742378831,
-0.4180617929,
-0.0578889996,
-0.0121945478,
-0.1939262748,
0.2617632449,
0.4351109862,
-0.3101816475,
0.562335372,
-0.5516257882,
0.2911881506,
0.9630889893,
0.1233067438,
0.8642314672,
-0.4835669994,
0.9900353551,
-0.5059378147,
0.0712156296,
-0.5641520619,
-0.4264324009,
-0.6005892754,
-0.282124877,
0.1562509686,
0.611387074,
-1.0020389557,
0.492022872,
-0.0273986664,
-0.3729292154,
-0.0107129775,
-0.1601532251,
0.198231101,
0.6713635921,
0.2666705847,
0.0619511828,
-0.6064277291,
-0.7407028675,
-0.3442520201,
-0.3092855215,
-0.1166148558,
0.3180350661,
0.1346741319,
-0.2462319434,
1.0689409971,
-0.6508107781,
-0.1697130054,
-0.6124318838,
0.2651715577,
0.2877848446,
0.4254743457,
0.4932678938,
-0.5237415433,
-0.4885813296,
-0.1880313754,
-0.1719262451,
-0.5528247356,
-0.4095627069,
-0.366732806,
0.4931779504,
0.5401393771,
-0.8014850616,
0.1717031896,
0.4409266114,
-0.3332470953,
0.8772173524,
-0.2799935043,
0.1402668059,
-0.9631277919,
0.06579905,
0.1213096678,
-0.2577125132,
-0.5279200673,
0.0856069624,
0.0639286041,
-0.2430730909,
-0.3543775976,
0.8867176771,
-0.6178379059,
-0.0448393077,
-0.4797109962,
0.2200580537,
-0.1149555966,
0.7629337311,
-0.1139228269,
0.8941352963,
0.409599334,
-0.7507846951,
0.4889899492,
0.2437649816,
-0.1583546698,
0.4873194993,
-0.3527562618,
0.1307503283,
-0.1213411093,
0.5370659232,
-1.3107144833,
-0.118826054,
0.4520760477,
-0.5362632275,
0.445895493,
-0.270938158,
-0.4002512991,
-0.3853241801,
-0.2822226584,
0.1859345138,
0.5128222108,
-0.6868195534,
0.9635507464,
0.296675086,
-0.4309052229,
-0.5763042569,
-0.4203024507,
0.1142300889,
-0.1784547418,
-0.6938335299,
0.2385403216,
-0.1590332985,
-0.2490001619,
-0.3814704418,
0.1377538592,
0.1089027151,
-0.0785693452,
0.1699035615,
0.3160506189,
0.0007682361,
0.1338665783,
-0.0103147151,
-0.440528214,
0.1694685072,
-0.3785699904,
1.2439332008,
0.2791783512,
-0.2496529669,
-0.7113378048,
0.1843054742,
0.4158019423,
-0.231673941,
0.5087281466,
0.1916033477,
0.0202943385,
-0.7075822949,
-0.489141494,
-0.4273995161,
-0.5517565012,
0.2845225632,
-0.3234493434,
-0.73121804,
0.6230395436,
-0.4256112278,
0.3650800586,
0.1638635695,
0.5173281431,
0.1041482016,
0.981829524,
0.7557268143,
-0.1252156794,
0.7856035233,
-0.2412067652,
0.0369837433,
-0.7571542859,
-0.0270370618,
-0.6895726919,
-0.6092838049,
-0.5937517285,
-0.608582437,
0.0788263381,
-0.3110975921,
-0.4906171858,
0.4895693362,
-0.4962979853,
0.3900104761,
0.6342672706,
-0.2335211933,
0.2595339119,
0.1317447424,
-0.336597383,
0.0199770816,
-0.6963734627,
-0.5973161459,
0.8433945775,
0.282250464,
0.9402471185,
-0.4172088504,
0.8192049265,
0.1558020562,
0.3102546334,
-0.7798496485,
1.001832366,
0.3742469549,
-0.0984815359,
-0.5435298681,
-0.5557265282,
-1.1446311474,
0.1531475186,
0.1072402373,
-0.6778624058,
0.3828362226,
0.1023122817,
-0.2605611682,
0.0882974565,
-0.5672678351,
0.5220610499,
-0.2163407356,
0.001628804,
-0.2834243774,
-0.6113954782,
0.1177068651,
0.0140784392,
0.0943417847,
-0.1438076943,
-0.2671199441,
0.6695042849,
-0.3534120619,
0.7374303937,
-0.4235397875,
-0.2236365527,
0.2807669342,
0.5220714211,
1.0327609777,
-0.0702136829,
-0.2082115412,
-0.0930618942,
-0.4419226646,
-0.0399421602,
-0.7225301862,
0.8097912669,
-0.4896753728,
-0.6872447133,
-0.1238177046,
-0.6296294928,
-0.2625266016,
0.2992977202,
0.0646399707,
0.5114891529,
-0.0886648297,
-0.4929952621,
0.198172763,
-0.6671856046,
0.7298210263,
0.7751724124,
-0.4692275524,
-0.5267046094,
0.6681485176,
-0.0131226676,
0.194524914,
0.609002471,
0.1240975782,
-0.4206750989,
-0.5104441047,
-0.26925686,
0.380645752,
-0.847668469,
-0.276827991,
-0.5124030113,
-0.097288385,
-0.3682789505,
-0.4243605733,
-0.2543161809,
-0.6033045053,
-0.2492096424,
-0.0256537553,
0.2317003161,
0.2698301673,
-0.149859041,
0.3898804784,
-0.6466964483,
0.2637614906,
0.1961132139,
0.0617807694,
-0.0875856727,
-0.4749880731,
-0.0012620592,
0.1008263454,
-0.3170176446,
-0.5717429519,
0.8155797124,
-0.2219909132,
0.7645756006,
0.1970487684,
0.3602285087,
0.400290668,
-0.7258701324,
0.6437724829,
0.0584380589,
-0.5452297926,
0.5741209984,
-0.3607162833,
0.1395450532,
0.4355758429,
0.3180224299,
-0.580642581,
-0.2815211713,
-0.4506330192,
-0.8202151656,
0.6312238574,
0.1082413271,
0.0072523355,
0.0633186102,
0.3752548695,
0.0889679417,
0.2461978495,
-0.3762831986,
-0.2445140779,
0.3020907342,
-0.0818316862,
-0.0938577205,
-0.2513550818,
-0.2406145781,
-0.0278153569,
0.5217984915,
-0.2410293818,
0.3945957124,
0.2681055963,
0.0007383823,
-0.3121066093,
0.0777044818,
0.8579381108,
0.9198954701,
0.010515688,
0.0086442381,
-0.000799465,
-0.2418361604,
0.2924396694,
0.1952946484,
-0.0792152882,
-0.1141989231,
0.351867497,
0.501781106,
-0.0635489002,
-0.7895110846,
0.2971279323,
-0.1948639452,
-0.0434180424,
-0.3310701251,
0.1747176647,
-0.1295741498,
0.5963374972,
0.3683418334,
0.014897991,
-0.1158355176,
-0.2891084552,
0.145109579,
0.3495040536,
-0.110605903,
-0.0883180946,
0.4362693429,
0.4548635185,
-0.9336489439,
0.6611873507,
-0.0755059719,
-0.6568512321,
0.6790875196,
0.4584499598,
1.1421685219,
-0.3422784507,
0.3691724241,
0.4262079,
0.2344453186,
-0.0966450945,
0.2609698474,
-0.0424758866,
-0.7916609049,
-0.8038477302,
-0.4563985765,
-0.4504186511,
-0.2162444443,
-0.1180993393,
0.3922193646,
-0.4502970874,
-0.1413547397,
-0.5218762159,
0.1369489133,
-0.5674031377,
-0.0768137276,
0.0610070713,
1.1047159433,
-0.3769440651,
0.5285525322,
0.6938890219,
-0.1477596164,
-0.7458882332,
0.1748945266,
-0.2794877887,
-1.1179633141,
0.9041532874,
0.258615911,
-0.1241284832,
0.3169315159,
-0.6762074828,
-0.7598462105,
1.0121779442,
0.4832681417,
-0.9408379197,
-0.0956789106,
0.076398246,
0.4251036942,
-0.5464786887,
0.0358881094,
0.4887548387,
0.5763831735,
0.2890787423,
-0.7271176577,
0.3381864429,
0.001046998,
-0.0080586066,
0.2896078229,
-0.5574225187,
0.811106503,
-0.4243290722,
-0.4583927393,
0.2833489776,
0.5038071275,
0.7185516357,
0.2218135744,
0.5618831515,
0.2204044014,
0.8185542822,
0.1648932248,
1.2155246735,
-0.6211580038,
0.2435916066,
1.1220532656,
-0.2843752503,
0.5774456263,
0.4669903815,
-0.1067718118,
0.4129083753,
0.7204897404,
0.1325356811,
0.6275113821,
0.4655034244,
-0.2044562548,
-0.2942631543,
0.0766774714,
-0.1199438572,
-0.0625903681,
0.2081203461,
-0.3233603835,
-0.3500063717,
0.1906253994,
-0.0345308743,
0.0334007926,
-0.3227009773,
0.5416573882,
0.1744094789,
-0.8781245947,
0.5467836857,
-0.0186170116,
0.3777088225,
-0.3817213476,
0.0488959178,
-0.4088830948,
0.0479156077,
0.1051582992,
-0.834404707,
-0.1739796847,
-0.2223646045,
0.1510865837,
-0.4560241103,
0.7778690457,
-0.2534940541,
-0.2068109959,
0.2854455411,
0.4553194344,
0.0527091138,
-0.2566869855,
-0.6267684102,
-0.0624933504,
0.0139582707,
-0.5354865789,
0.1963917613,
0.5852275491,
0.1108527109,
1.2666469812,
0.7228005528,
0.1737409532,
-0.0970947966,
0.1333685666,
1.1553993225,
-0.8920524716,
-0.7131367326,
-1.0861819983,
0.5604831576,
-0.0942963138,
-0.0712672397,
0.6250448823,
0.4152998626,
0.4202123582,
0.0294418465,
0.7304073572,
0.1880283356,
0.5824878216,
-0.6056813598,
0.4499998689,
-0.2784490287,
0.5100010633,
-0.1351906806,
-1.1484328508,
-0.3558342457,
0.7051132321,
-0.5019140244,
0.0128767667,
0.7308865786,
1.0018419027,
0.4582226276,
-0.2242925912,
0.1705542505,
0.0476992801,
0.7224687934,
0.4926766753,
1.1515306234,
0.0943805575,
0.502047658,
-0.1157749221,
-0.2441690415,
-0.367665112,
-0.8310719132,
-1.237631321,
-0.4836958647,
-0.1557327211,
-0.2125072479,
-0.0922813118,
1.2058641911,
0.3496060073,
-0.4930502176,
-0.2896116972,
-0.4655385911,
0.3393054605,
0.1083643511,
-0.2258409411,
0.3399578333,
-0.7556316853,
-0.6738609672,
0.5959586501,
0.2802059352,
0.1741184294,
-0.5392932892,
-0.2984303534,
-0.0350560248,
0.0536323152,
0.4575269818,
0.3951388001,
-0.343675971,
-0.2069110274,
-0.0596325211,
-0.2512124777,
0.1230894551,
1.1166754961,
-0.8797699809,
0.3093010783,
0.9040868282,
0.4348966181,
0.2255508006,
0.2067152411,
1.1029493809,
-0.6038524508,
0.2456933707,
0.4767663479,
0.4007892609,
0.1417182982,
-0.3137265742,
0.4440200627,
-0.0341417566,
-0.9582143426,
-0.8254195452,
0.3135584295,
-0.8956212401,
-0.3292155564,
1.4261345863,
0.0610563867,
-0.3368779421,
-0.0884878337,
-0.8456571698,
0.2085326165,
-0.6393579841,
0.7714040875,
0.3600303233,
-0.3789831996,
-0.3104147017,
-0.3984052539,
0.591317296,
0.0279946215,
-0.6774580479,
0.3837678432,
0.5430644155,
0.153339088,
0.1530429721,
0.768173337,
0.2928493023,
0.063847594,
-0.2868817747,
0.2426299453,
-0.1975448728,
-0.4188547134,
-0.1689448208,
0.2456020415,
0.0707388669,
-0.2390890867
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11131v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11131v2 | Are Large Language Models a Good Replacement of Taxonomies? | 2024-06-17T01:21:50 | 2024-06-20T08:01:14 | Yushi Sun, Hao Xin, Kai Sun, Yifan Ethan Xu, Xiao Yang, Xin Luna Dong, Nan Tang, Lei Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.DB | Large language models (LLMs) demonstrate an impressive ability to internalize
knowledge and answer natural language questions. Although previous studies
validate that LLMs perform well on general knowledge while presenting poor
performance on long-tail nuanced knowledge, the community is still doubtful
about whether the traditional knowledge graphs should be replaced by LLMs. In
this paper, we ask if the schema of knowledge graph (i.e., taxonomy) is made
obsolete by LLMs. Intuitively, LLMs should perform well on common taxonomies
and at taxonomy levels that are common to people. Unfortunately, there lacks a
comprehensive benchmark that evaluates the LLMs over a wide range of taxonomies
from common to specialized domains and at levels from root to leaf so that we
can draw a confident conclusion. To narrow the research gap, we constructed a
novel taxonomy hierarchical structure discovery benchmark named TaxoGlimpse to
evaluate the performance of LLMs over taxonomies. TaxoGlimpse covers ten
representative taxonomies from common to specialized domains with in-depth
experiments of different levels of entities in this taxonomy from root to leaf.
Our comprehensive experiments of eighteen state-of-the-art LLMs under three
prompting settings validate that LLMs can still not well capture the knowledge
of specialized taxonomies and leaf-level entities. | [
-0.3097949922,
-0.6377136707,
0.5380216241,
-0.16648148,
-0.3933236003,
0.3787720799,
-0.3736402392,
-0.6182379127,
0.2841249108,
0.4167536497,
-0.1097565517,
-0.5202380419,
-0.6486040354,
0.192293033,
-0.4239507616,
0.4879246056,
-0.0378942192,
-0.0022056217,
-0.6159538627,
-0.2403518558,
-0.2624187469,
-0.5484805703,
-0.5783136487,
-0.5700480938,
0.6509417892,
-0.0018005779,
0.5735728145,
0.790455699,
0.3841998279,
0.2661055923,
-0.5648877621,
0.1173089594,
-0.5351197124,
0.0476088002,
-0.2232611626,
-0.2949591279,
-0.5208702683,
-0.2336301357,
0.7687798142,
1.1625547409,
-0.4203154445,
0.1064313948,
0.2364860922,
0.4915492237,
-0.479256779,
0.4892611206,
-0.9274911284,
-0.3101979494,
-0.4034823477,
-0.2739019394,
-0.4862340093,
-0.4020018578,
0.2298956513,
-0.6416723728,
0.0690783337,
0.1812714487,
0.6408823729,
0.258215785,
-0.646009028,
-0.3840863109,
-0.6922478676,
0.6628144383,
-0.8849665523,
0.4494867027,
0.2071662694,
0.2314981967,
-0.2710832059,
-0.6803854704,
-0.2356322408,
0.0153828515,
-0.2456354946,
-0.1224564761,
-0.6161623001,
0.0730830878,
0.2377272099,
0.3245289922,
-0.4675936401,
0.5315941572,
-0.0788378492,
-0.2538499832,
0.2341112047,
0.3115030229,
0.4071719944,
-0.4808824062,
-0.3313348293,
0.098542504,
-1.1323696375,
-0.0634143203,
0.2547949553,
0.4207694232,
0.350209713,
0.3895510733,
-0.1232280284,
0.9136300683,
-0.5138439536,
-0.522374928,
0.4873646498,
-0.0530953482,
-0.4045898616,
-0.059563607,
0.5707461834,
0.4208502471,
0.435279429,
-0.3379177153,
-0.2751688659,
0.0207056515,
-0.0341711193,
-0.5877498388,
0.0014289945,
0.0767103061,
-0.2077697217,
0.108203508,
-0.4456622601,
-0.6356558204,
-0.3920817971,
-0.2896677256,
0.1375776231,
-0.4367876053,
-0.5034698248,
0.2862370312,
-0.1192105636,
0.1226278171,
0.6242520213,
-0.7860016227,
0.5314990282,
1.0462859869,
0.8079957962,
-0.1859216243,
-0.2716170549,
-0.0963819474,
0.2598790526,
-0.4873195589,
0.7954583168,
-0.6724315882,
-0.2755472362,
0.053177841,
-0.0686109811,
-0.0378774107,
-0.9348294139,
0.2205038667,
-0.7404517531,
0.0228898339,
-0.3265956044,
-0.9214012623,
-0.2078811824,
0.3808732629,
-0.6515516043,
0.6735583544,
0.248408094,
-0.7413861156,
0.5296235681,
-0.1730404794,
-0.3036873937,
0.4718000293,
0.0385619663,
-0.1294488162,
-0.1957215071,
-0.1247590333,
0.4091694355,
-0.607321322,
0.7199661136,
-0.38254264,
-0.4461764991,
-0.2451556027,
-0.0565818623,
0.8773123026,
0.0688034818,
0.0275140759,
-0.2595872581,
-0.6371931434,
0.0615308769,
-0.0348108485,
-0.2572646737,
-0.8117572665,
0.2398289591,
-0.3514732122,
-0.0956102982,
0.0959146395,
-0.4272271991,
0.5714822412,
-0.4733645022,
0.8106582761,
0.6942954063,
0.0949075893,
0.5432294011,
-0.164888069,
0.603045404,
-0.1833583862,
-0.0786854178,
0.1654631644,
-0.5622188449,
-0.4777309597,
-0.3759401143,
0.3872629404,
0.1861320138,
-0.6500015259,
0.2752709985,
-0.6572170854,
-0.6068108678,
-0.0489037037,
0.069118306,
0.098877959,
0.4343655705,
0.2167319953,
-0.4032143652,
-0.4599442184,
-0.8768382072,
-0.2447855622,
-0.3577236235,
-0.131270498,
0.3722174764,
0.6061612964,
-0.2243955284,
0.8832040429,
-0.488004148,
-0.1715626419,
-0.1517249048,
-0.0050371005,
0.1743209958,
0.0004007384,
0.5611473322,
-0.2893041968,
-0.1860376298,
-0.1193283573,
-0.4688002765,
-0.0871851072,
0.2961811721,
0.2175598741,
0.1387643218,
0.2872933447,
-0.8774325848,
0.0472891852,
0.4425705969,
-0.0597762726,
0.4454830587,
0.082230933,
-0.2079577148,
-0.8081974387,
0.1717755049,
-0.0414114967,
-0.119252108,
-0.6537376642,
0.2374926507,
0.1114927754,
0.1183524057,
-0.3896000087,
0.8227713108,
-0.3993586004,
-0.4349406362,
0.1321275234,
0.1902184486,
-0.0504328124,
0.2707425654,
-0.0742216036,
0.7613853216,
0.8408681154,
-0.7150238156,
0.273121655,
0.2238394022,
-0.7452273965,
0.3814325631,
-0.5112767816,
-0.1190660447,
-0.3026947677,
0.5071605444,
-0.7827574611,
-0.3682845831,
0.1757843643,
-0.180147022,
0.2858399451,
-0.2656611204,
-0.7969082594,
-0.4671034217,
-0.0737216324,
0.2498457581,
0.5555904508,
-0.4540171325,
0.5983752608,
0.4468034804,
-0.0965507105,
-0.4295705259,
-0.473857075,
0.3979844153,
-0.418677032,
-0.5338710546,
0.0779824555,
0.2063590884,
-0.435763061,
0.0302651264,
-0.1923265904,
0.1029206291,
0.3785230517,
-0.0356811769,
0.1664948314,
-0.2986958921,
0.7107017636,
-0.4219718575,
0.1238768473,
0.1479356587,
-0.1883756518,
0.8846714497,
0.067234911,
-0.1841321737,
0.0264920238,
-0.0582194477,
0.6624679565,
-0.3986372352,
0.5671847463,
-0.1134306863,
-0.6308948398,
-0.2519008815,
-0.5557224751,
0.1099358872,
-0.4118749797,
0.2988435328,
-0.3312017024,
-1.0402008295,
0.5732091069,
-0.262624979,
-0.0677577779,
0.5549529195,
0.2846737504,
0.0679232627,
0.7159252167,
0.3295217156,
-0.0847484097,
0.1482401341,
-0.3074803352,
0.4246164262,
-0.9219200611,
-0.3247095346,
-0.6544773579,
0.0194901489,
-0.6542891264,
-0.3154685199,
0.3996670544,
0.1632771194,
-0.3819234669,
0.2986538708,
-0.2726217806,
0.3221153617,
0.4163782597,
-0.1278514713,
0.5183230639,
-0.0690526739,
0.252483964,
0.1559305638,
-0.8293636441,
-0.6552903652,
0.968488574,
0.265539974,
0.900582552,
0.0906264856,
0.7851093411,
0.0060634417,
0.4955145717,
-1.0132880211,
0.6799544692,
-0.279084444,
-0.5078621507,
-0.4864763021,
-0.67344594,
-1.1157715321,
0.2889128029,
0.2186557502,
-0.9136188626,
0.0139261056,
0.0722240433,
-0.1873709857,
0.6089456081,
-0.538207531,
0.7002913952,
-0.1293249428,
-0.0200135894,
-0.1093366742,
-0.33477512,
0.6194474101,
-0.3045127392,
0.3855415285,
-0.1833776832,
-0.0378397293,
0.9675862193,
-0.5216383934,
0.8443590403,
-0.0482155457,
-0.3634916246,
0.3126761019,
0.3082955182,
0.4255670011,
-0.3732027113,
-0.1214071289,
0.0849506259,
0.0012731635,
-0.1215069741,
-0.7164804935,
0.664670825,
-0.6327221394,
-0.9972310662,
-0.4634269178,
-0.3455865979,
-0.6103082299,
0.2259191424,
-0.186481297,
0.5466919541,
-0.0972638652,
0.3746317625,
0.4503516555,
-0.078350462,
0.066799663,
0.2976103127,
-0.2612878084,
-0.1978879571,
0.7685242891,
0.2743271887,
0.5046844482,
0.2728611231,
0.3661097288,
-0.3599535823,
-0.6141750813,
-0.2967665493,
0.3477162421,
-0.8220316768,
-0.5810318589,
-0.8218090534,
-0.2398822755,
-0.3457894027,
0.1160597876,
-0.0290161557,
-0.2189480364,
-0.2958227992,
-0.0490449853,
0.3833769858,
0.8920363188,
0.2529314756,
0.2056065798,
-0.6580457687,
0.0470024943,
0.4112538993,
0.485375613,
0.4447807968,
-0.4663582742,
-0.0303013083,
0.0537884161,
0.0938648954,
-0.5138014555,
0.1966919303,
0.1469723284,
0.7375429869,
0.2300153822,
-0.1597011983,
0.7341636419,
-0.5612151027,
0.7619208694,
0.2892347872,
-1.0047156811,
0.1224187389,
-0.412401557,
0.4486744702,
0.1722812504,
0.4653216004,
-0.7890800834,
-0.5935231447,
-0.6407955885,
-0.781871736,
0.38839674,
-0.1721484065,
0.1411513686,
0.0202029049,
0.2877434194,
0.1399680227,
0.4827938378,
-0.5764558911,
-0.1918253899,
-0.0066960715,
0.1592775136,
-0.2172924727,
-0.3030611873,
-0.0065098419,
-0.2764517367,
0.4244242013,
-0.0566645451,
-0.0697961226,
-0.2407404929,
0.1382959187,
-0.3441151083,
0.4909287989,
0.1088830978,
1.2193700075,
-0.2642041445,
0.4274674952,
0.0757713839,
-0.0759710371,
0.1018687487,
-0.2465144247,
-0.3222979903,
-0.0811587125,
0.7064679265,
0.6606318355,
0.4349008203,
-0.616882205,
0.3327290416,
0.4425754249,
-0.2854140103,
-0.0909904093,
0.1416570395,
0.5545199513,
0.0851762295,
0.4086595774,
-0.0011933707,
-0.0417225733,
-1.1233435869,
0.0872390345,
0.6938998103,
0.1503966451,
-0.0684954971,
0.4422646463,
0.0036848567,
-0.3487868607,
0.4655680358,
-0.1519081742,
-0.819855392,
0.5188898444,
0.4956976771,
0.3983634412,
-0.1671873778,
0.4425456226,
0.4218221605,
0.3917849958,
-0.2709240913,
-0.1197050065,
0.2625470757,
-0.8185819983,
-0.4927532077,
-0.6791015863,
-0.413377285,
0.2640128136,
-0.4922920763,
0.1638448387,
-0.3499551117,
-0.0490651242,
0.0212821662,
-0.08409179,
-0.6653441191,
0.3430968523,
0.1246843189,
1.2569527626,
-0.650539875,
0.7822213769,
0.3924439549,
-0.2497464716,
-0.9038004875,
-0.1712420434,
-0.052187901,
-0.9488242865,
0.6826418042,
-0.059593983,
-0.2011854053,
-0.0356236622,
-0.6751151085,
-1.1607047319,
1.2370821238,
0.1876224279,
-0.7445986271,
-0.3245354593,
0.2288330793,
0.9350138307,
-0.3460715711,
0.0528980643,
0.4782165885,
0.4341928065,
0.4384280145,
-0.9271433353,
0.0893582255,
0.2400574833,
0.1224500462,
0.4342005253,
-0.6248213649,
1.0154677629,
0.0459877774,
-0.4523009956,
0.1462121904,
0.17745471,
0.1085883602,
0.1820394844,
0.6875448823,
0.7250241041,
0.9743686914,
-0.1077748761,
0.7858992219,
-0.2147163153,
0.5735808611,
1.1364225149,
-0.7115066648,
0.9320842624,
0.4403012693,
-0.3487338722,
0.3888955414,
0.6709322929,
-0.0327556394,
0.331502229,
0.595497191,
0.0076433062,
-0.5862460136,
-0.1372873485,
-0.4849206209,
0.4479646385,
0.5010264516,
-0.0518191941,
-0.6022819281,
-0.2459446341,
0.1631734967,
-0.0943179801,
-0.361484319,
0.6555056572,
0.0895475298,
-0.6348416209,
0.8996462822,
-0.186412558,
0.4237115383,
-0.8538070917,
0.0554695055,
-0.412863493,
-0.1940916479,
-0.1455340832,
-0.9405941367,
0.0666334182,
-0.0910369232,
0.3652785718,
-0.4305088222,
0.7474542856,
-0.2597140968,
-0.3135973811,
0.5205831528,
0.8853446841,
0.0944558829,
0.0330066122,
-0.2102017999,
0.0440592393,
-0.2125566155,
-0.2144182175,
0.2454280704,
0.5455171466,
0.052629184,
1.0521081686,
0.3934075534,
0.2048543394,
-0.1587904245,
0.1788047999,
1.0019183159,
-0.4913396239,
-0.1501609534,
-0.6865499616,
0.0723949075,
0.022194881,
-0.1888524145,
0.8560586572,
0.7632067204,
0.971924901,
0.1318970025,
0.6206122041,
0.0226609893,
0.6282401681,
-0.6299969554,
0.4505867362,
-0.8997498155,
0.4202813506,
-0.3921188712,
-1.1609115601,
-0.5016909838,
0.1131135002,
-0.4202010036,
-0.0219642762,
0.7996708751,
0.6702322364,
-0.1051566452,
0.0211772341,
0.5278354883,
0.4635712504,
0.3251106143,
0.4518120587,
0.9804042578,
0.0804887787,
0.520100832,
0.1142398492,
-0.1291263402,
-0.1079810858,
-0.6873235106,
-0.6332874298,
-0.6772001982,
-0.1609952599,
-0.2559481561,
0.1434346586,
0.7292513847,
0.2999846339,
-0.4982067347,
-0.3566012084,
-0.0074068126,
0.2250258923,
0.0751547366,
-0.2333627641,
0.3517946899,
-0.1497931927,
-0.4975065589,
0.1035163775,
0.3085273206,
0.0040202225,
-0.4589128494,
0.0990314111,
-0.1083689481,
-0.1352202743,
0.7221469879,
0.127905637,
-1.0369514227,
-0.632773757,
0.0248223152,
-0.0934032574,
0.2346069813,
0.9529420137,
-0.8124454021,
0.1885942817,
0.3258226812,
0.4237115979,
0.322432071,
-0.1936391443,
0.2610278428,
-0.337433964,
-0.2511280775,
0.2937208414,
0.7264883518,
0.4156065285,
0.0549560115,
0.5765396953,
0.3932931125,
-0.3908066452,
-0.8708728552,
0.2294366658,
-0.9263868332,
-0.3699268997,
1.4945880175,
-0.0274479203,
-0.4234003425,
-0.0762321427,
0.1050097048,
-0.0642481893,
-0.2607189417,
0.6706075668,
0.8568560481,
0.1359649599,
-0.137330085,
-0.3536422551,
0.4480544627,
0.0843078792,
-0.8171787858,
0.3670568466,
0.6474416852,
0.5614205003,
0.2813811302,
0.8139368296,
0.0975154489,
-0.1577734649,
-0.2234832644,
-0.0352334306,
0.2292013168,
-0.2515795231,
-0.0380032249,
0.1305191517,
0.3795348704,
0.2850136161
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11130v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11130v1 | Dynamic Order Template Prediction for Generative Aspect-Based Sentiment Analysis | 2024-06-17T01:21:28 | 2024-06-17T01:21:28 | Yonghyun Jun, Hwanhee Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL | Aspect-based sentiment analysis (ABSA) assesses sentiments towards specific
aspects within texts, resulting in detailed sentiment tuples. Previous ABSA
models often use static templates to predict all of the elements in the tuples,
and these models often fail to accurately capture dependencies between
elements. Multi-view prompting method improves the performance of ABSA by
predicting tuples with various templates and then ensembling the results.
However, this method suffers from inefficiencies and out-of-distribution
errors. In this paper, we propose a Dynamic Order Template (DOT) method for
ABSA, which dynamically generates necessary views for each instance based on
instance-level entropy. Ensuring the diverse and relevant view generation, our
proposed method improves F1-scores on ASQP and ACOS datasets while
significantly reducing inference time. | [
-0.5499736667,
-0.6795812249,
0.5886235237,
0.2694815099,
-0.6415034533,
0.2216534168,
0.3557231724,
-0.3471335769,
0.563043654,
0.0891123414,
-0.5044990182,
-0.572191298,
-0.458345443,
0.09574496,
-0.2511916757,
0.5414577723,
0.1470342129,
-0.0218426008,
-0.2656424046,
-0.1228209883,
-0.306535095,
-0.5088203549,
-0.3904115558,
0.0401881933,
0.4884976447,
0.4752995968,
0.348418951,
0.5129150748,
0.2094414383,
0.3821015656,
-0.3783423305,
0.2821675241,
-0.0033034824,
0.6759936213,
-0.052756086,
-0.4788859785,
-0.7795914412,
-0.0249842852,
0.3334728777,
0.4332777858,
-0.25441733,
0.0266754515,
0.2113573998,
0.7703988552,
-0.6923645735,
0.3684113026,
-0.6795921326,
0.1481133103,
-0.0165085439,
-0.0584516563,
-0.2877337337,
-0.4012527168,
0.3033548295,
-0.4297157228,
0.1414640397,
0.1139129549,
0.6476880908,
0.0817033127,
-0.3758590817,
-0.1083352491,
-0.4704110622,
0.785187602,
-0.6086398959,
0.2908759713,
0.0282893199,
0.0979291871,
0.10383486,
-0.5436110497,
-0.620303452,
0.2587135434,
0.1650791019,
0.513469696,
0.0352191441,
0.0160920545,
-0.1609449983,
0.7066108584,
-0.2032421827,
0.0704022944,
-0.0836871117,
0.3137698472,
0.570165813,
0.3314316571,
-0.2144295871,
-0.6882588863,
-0.2322126478,
-0.3366121948,
-0.6323367953,
0.2191570699,
0.4243620932,
0.2578716576,
-0.3201106489,
0.3247080147,
-0.2867689729,
0.602737844,
0.6153593659,
0.0362356193,
0.5807263851,
-0.0239611194,
-0.4036594033,
0.0779585913,
0.8370948434,
0.454218477,
-0.3568350673,
0.4567809701,
-0.1600804776,
-0.1456238031,
0.5426939726,
-0.7089388371,
-0.1774798632,
0.6323193908,
-0.4926009774,
-0.7300955057,
0.4296218157,
-1.3936684132,
-0.6719684601,
-0.2099806815,
-0.1295188069,
-0.714415431,
-0.2202517837,
-0.2513704598,
0.1430326253,
-0.0523891598,
0.7124763131,
-0.6755776405,
-0.3276717663,
0.601293385,
0.664085567,
-0.1065260321,
-0.068520166,
-0.6069961786,
0.0330884084,
-0.4905518591,
1.1927915812,
-0.8842735887,
-0.4516900182,
0.2113565356,
-0.4039403796,
0.0703705177,
-0.3872205615,
0.2448459566,
-0.4214395583,
0.4573228955,
-0.3035724759,
-0.4667891264,
-0.5965579748,
0.4730466008,
-0.5185321569,
0.9337833524,
0.113155663,
-0.8313655257,
0.5950721502,
-0.4368394017,
-0.4355922043,
-0.1522532701,
-0.3731280565,
-0.6561800838,
0.5815167427,
0.7008973956,
0.7991666198,
-0.1847433597,
0.1120925918,
-0.4635467529,
0.2247830331,
0.2893064022,
-0.3001515269,
0.1242613196,
0.3122894466,
-0.3118647933,
0.3567123711,
-0.8503409624,
0.0933726951,
-0.1902515441,
-0.3948878348,
-0.5318424106,
0.3690125048,
-0.147189036,
0.2638612092,
-0.0517077819,
-0.3170717955,
0.3057560623,
-0.6475394964,
0.0095613031,
1.0417137146,
0.4131570756,
0.3071657717,
0.088411577,
0.8631793857,
0.4454042912,
0.2262728661,
-0.2923267782,
-0.617359221,
-0.847617209,
-0.2714841366,
0.1404999793,
0.5075389743,
-0.9934535027,
0.7765454054,
-0.136127457,
-0.6954817772,
-0.2427740097,
-0.0279088859,
0.6051793098,
0.1716016978,
0.1920588464,
-0.7833255529,
-0.2397902757,
-0.5965163112,
-0.082954593,
-0.4442824423,
0.0171958394,
0.1654137522,
0.1201587841,
0.304156512,
0.6823316813,
-0.7058819532,
-0.3362624347,
-0.5646296144,
0.5968157649,
0.2676537931,
0.2496819049,
0.8204817772,
-0.7020132542,
-0.6187385321,
-0.0820040703,
-0.7028764486,
0.0496915542,
-0.1306127459,
0.0512492508,
0.1911771595,
0.3706716895,
-0.2215240747,
0.4826313555,
0.5952168703,
-0.4973263443,
0.3463670909,
0.0542387031,
0.1604875028,
-1.6067092419,
-0.2478687614,
0.2453405559,
-0.0351907127,
-0.4219464362,
-0.2104225159,
-0.0853456482,
-0.071581386,
-0.4968377948,
0.281753093,
-0.5948014259,
0.0953043774,
-0.0954950824,
-0.4590476453,
0.1400767267,
0.4977257252,
0.0939733163,
0.5122619867,
0.6488522887,
-0.5839972496,
0.3345782161,
0.1678489745,
-0.6195430756,
0.974226892,
-0.2824558318,
0.1404155791,
-0.1773638129,
0.0885180384,
-0.7818675637,
-0.0835729986,
0.2564099729,
-0.4112776816,
0.5036815405,
-0.2013474107,
-0.3868670762,
-0.1378938854,
-0.5948229432,
0.3531623483,
0.0719984919,
-0.2174364179,
0.9002364874,
0.2526635528,
-0.3336094916,
-0.5858899951,
-0.0308614708,
-0.1351265907,
-0.2714143395,
-0.2506752014,
0.1996263862,
0.0376523435,
-0.419798553,
-0.0896794721,
-0.0490164123,
0.126505971,
-0.10329514,
0.3673111498,
0.0539980456,
-0.1861671358,
-0.1368974596,
0.3756654561,
-0.0395414419,
-0.0623513497,
-0.0520619191,
0.7108688354,
-0.3088454902,
-0.4229339063,
-0.6397999525,
0.5347054601,
0.874258101,
-0.3465349674,
0.7244281769,
0.0314166807,
-0.1177762896,
-0.2448918372,
-0.4873311818,
-0.0396271832,
-0.5041718483,
0.3940163851,
-0.3911939263,
-0.0838164613,
0.5562770963,
0.2050292045,
0.0771894231,
0.3465513289,
0.6313970089,
-0.1636495888,
0.9330739379,
0.6901212931,
-0.1963916421,
1.0324846506,
-0.5228270888,
0.2027563155,
-0.743076086,
-0.3673016429,
-0.2967695892,
-0.285864383,
-0.3109306097,
-0.3621732593,
0.825517416,
0.0098366635,
-0.11080347,
-0.1942620277,
-0.5882233977,
0.1228409633,
0.6867008209,
-0.1006217748,
0.2347923815,
0.3743354082,
-0.2577110529,
0.0724953264,
-0.5187062025,
-0.2266697735,
0.8809834123,
0.1862786263,
0.7145496607,
0.1037764102,
0.5684554577,
0.2365970165,
0.4168506265,
-0.9718773961,
0.4406619668,
-0.2636086345,
-0.1655675918,
-0.0539245456,
-0.124995254,
-0.7599006891,
0.3200897872,
-0.3733620048,
-0.5833277106,
0.7380253077,
0.2066120952,
-0.5914911032,
0.380581975,
-0.4811737239,
0.3731237352,
-0.1208457947,
-0.2811504006,
-0.2826394737,
-0.252961874,
0.1898919791,
-0.092340447,
0.0883683562,
-0.1203519776,
0.1516741365,
0.6194986105,
-0.6999355555,
0.973841846,
-0.3269781768,
-0.0752309188,
0.316991061,
0.1959396005,
0.4226250947,
0.3346640468,
-0.5020925403,
0.0700971633,
-0.3564000428,
-0.073158823,
-0.6201872826,
0.4579757154,
-0.6571773291,
-0.5946532488,
-0.9214497209,
-0.2450191081,
-0.4008793235,
0.1551203281,
0.5846916437,
0.6325785518,
0.0694671348,
0.1844399869,
0.4695737958,
-0.3441253603,
0.5024735928,
0.4581382573,
0.0306917951,
-0.7830539942,
0.5831159353,
0.1086358801,
-0.0869070888,
0.5782875419,
0.2113455236,
-0.2724217474,
-0.8261250257,
-0.669880867,
-0.0143583706,
-0.5416564941,
-0.6914089322,
-0.3902418315,
0.0349358395,
-0.5427956581,
-0.4018003345,
-0.6834840178,
-0.2217179984,
-0.3134511113,
-0.3140759766,
0.5984903574,
0.8463355303,
0.0648120418,
0.2591921389,
-0.8530362844,
0.2577872574,
0.2642502487,
0.4442373216,
0.2028754652,
-0.1890152395,
-0.0012164064,
-0.2759720981,
-0.7011749148,
-1.0126791,
0.7879189253,
0.0818797946,
0.3672375083,
0.9982365966,
0.3678691387,
0.7459917665,
-0.360421598,
0.8937565088,
0.5559866428,
-0.9558410645,
0.8085947633,
-0.3201687336,
0.0662048981,
0.3981185555,
-0.0724946037,
-0.3280748427,
-0.7154245973,
-0.5404785872,
-1.2642468214,
0.7739921808,
0.1781959385,
0.1077005789,
-0.017317865,
0.4461791813,
0.350209415,
0.3868637979,
-0.2709788084,
-0.4199955165,
-0.6318839788,
-0.3065883815,
0.1705193073,
-0.5052137971,
0.0734395012,
-0.3066930175,
0.6539927721,
-0.2982411981,
0.4459113181,
0.1381696761,
0.4394992292,
-0.1922229528,
0.2438124716,
0.3470582366,
0.8134883642,
-0.2662618458,
-0.1269616485,
-0.0607276373,
-0.4820807576,
0.0775124058,
0.0469186716,
-0.2450820655,
0.0217570141,
0.1960769743,
0.8155844212,
-0.21449624,
-0.2450020015,
0.5070952773,
-0.0936156064,
0.1042903811,
-0.7099706531,
-0.0348787121,
-0.2940092981,
0.3148934543,
0.4529233277,
0.0248575136,
-0.0021597878,
-0.6366278529,
0.0861238167,
0.2478047609,
-0.6136199236,
-0.5274067521,
0.6884881854,
0.4139217734,
0.0449524969,
0.6513029337,
-0.2249758542,
-0.4696572721,
0.6283724308,
-0.0917476192,
1.1608730555,
-0.5696025491,
0.2828229666,
0.1138638407,
-0.0721820593,
0.1313110292,
0.6026697755,
0.3028604984,
-0.7759450078,
-0.2337284088,
-0.8181384802,
-0.4869123399,
0.249447152,
-0.9767776132,
0.2590829134,
-0.5996598005,
-0.0860236436,
0.0537631102,
-0.0538952127,
-0.484539777,
0.4999456108,
0.1055427045,
0.6382249594,
-0.7887265682,
0.9378401041,
1.0914958715,
-0.5685530901,
-0.707455337,
0.4177874327,
0.3431018889,
-0.5822370648,
0.2141261101,
0.1979114264,
-0.1862451285,
-0.494810313,
-0.2336348593,
-0.7802764773,
0.8743420243,
0.0167684797,
-0.12961559,
0.2215377539,
-0.0980893001,
0.6109548211,
-0.548797667,
0.0345483758,
-0.0384093113,
0.2682622373,
0.1773603708,
-0.5118145943,
-0.0225166436,
-0.5189141035,
0.0520597994,
0.0189013816,
-0.730858922,
0.8637453318,
0.0213143378,
0.1256310493,
-0.0386253931,
1.2608891726,
0.2582772374,
0.3964542747,
0.8136842251,
0.3992803693,
0.5921699405,
0.0290177017,
1.0233783722,
-0.4240356982,
0.2355877459,
0.8740876913,
-0.2801586986,
0.9678577781,
0.4065862,
-0.0777074993,
1.0130368471,
0.804739058,
0.0147132212,
0.6755178571,
-0.2543795705,
-0.1299349815,
-0.1935843229,
0.1836732775,
-0.4227432609,
0.6872791052,
0.6724934578,
-0.4960787296,
0.1680587679,
-0.2092678994,
0.1024900004,
0.0416176282,
-0.3775496185,
0.8649020195,
0.1521560252,
-0.7434463501,
0.3621963859,
0.0330371968,
0.6872801781,
-0.3217658103,
0.1698045284,
-0.6505111456,
0.3012495935,
-0.0117721362,
-0.7621377707,
0.4050694704,
-0.0522390194,
-0.4011282623,
-0.3852839768,
0.1757247299,
-0.115114443,
-0.9607215524,
0.1438179016,
0.6635069847,
-0.18739447,
-0.3409689069,
-0.7593178153,
-0.2832562327,
-0.0040923487,
-0.7540480494,
0.4124942422,
0.6308872104,
-0.0859624222,
0.5467060208,
0.3610872328,
0.0345115624,
-0.2368477732,
-0.1353274882,
0.9313722849,
-0.7050776482,
-0.9238643646,
-0.6111291051,
0.5176471472,
-0.3296273351,
-0.2438716441,
0.4873353839,
0.5541724563,
0.3732193708,
-0.1228093505,
0.8865731359,
-0.2592979372,
0.6861413121,
-0.6847803593,
0.8052548766,
-0.9036007524,
0.5066346526,
-0.496268183,
-0.9072998762,
-0.3306382298,
0.4900932014,
-0.2547211349,
-0.0997579098,
0.8510209918,
0.5310660601,
-0.2492047995,
-0.0036761204,
0.1048817188,
0.3247050941,
0.4621780515,
0.1858134866,
0.6509040594,
-0.0586766377,
0.3347068727,
-0.5560894608,
-0.1100962907,
-0.2245821953,
-1.0122219324,
-0.6790814996,
-0.7125968933,
-0.474293679,
-0.526194036,
-0.216764465,
0.7169455886,
0.616407752,
-1.0065498352,
-0.0284677017,
0.0743501037,
0.3577056527,
-0.7503303885,
-0.3246689737,
0.7351955175,
-0.2071875632,
-1.1464869976,
0.34147048,
0.3327376246,
-0.0430571102,
-0.1748990119,
0.439152211,
0.1508466005,
0.2342483103,
0.8727762103,
-0.0354271755,
-0.6991469264,
-0.4762064517,
-0.2888143659,
0.3339646459,
0.4025414586,
0.7804703116,
-0.7499468327,
0.4861316681,
0.8389226794,
0.0869834945,
0.1359892488,
0.2915103436,
1.0292857885,
-0.9674900174,
0.2180587947,
0.2059699148,
0.5393913388,
0.2434091717,
-0.4221056104,
0.1635812819,
0.3491613269,
0.0301615149,
-0.6481579542,
0.4096462429,
-1.1210606098,
-0.4728180468,
1.208204031,
-0.3394365013,
-0.0979658514,
-0.3399306536,
0.072772786,
0.040682625,
-0.9747234583,
1.201240778,
0.2713189423,
-0.4601965249,
-0.2443369925,
-0.0026990157,
0.524828434,
0.354142487,
-0.9329886436,
0.0231360849,
0.6512161493,
0.2106276155,
0.2218191177,
0.482278049,
-0.0937382057,
-0.0890584216,
-0.2132439017,
0.057916671,
-0.0554968417,
-0.4001685381,
-0.2098627687,
0.7425507307,
-0.0924487188,
-0.4154856205
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11116v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11116v1 | Grammaticality Representation in ChatGPT as Compared to Linguists and Laypeople | 2024-06-17T00:23:16 | 2024-06-17T00:23:16 | Zhuang Qiu, Xufeng Duan, Zhenguang G. Cai | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated exceptional performance across
various linguistic tasks. However, it remains uncertain whether LLMs have
developed human-like fine-grained grammatical intuition. This preregistered
study (https://osf.io/t5nes) presents the first large-scale investigation of
ChatGPT's grammatical intuition, building upon a previous study that collected
laypeople's grammatical judgments on 148 linguistic phenomena that linguists
judged to be grammatical, ungrammatical, or marginally grammatical (Sprouse,
Schutze, & Almeida, 2013). Our primary focus was to compare ChatGPT with both
laypeople and linguists in the judgement of these linguistic constructions. In
Experiment 1, ChatGPT assigned ratings to sentences based on a given reference
sentence. Experiment 2 involved rating sentences on a 7-point scale, and
Experiment 3 asked ChatGPT to choose the more grammatical sentence from a pair.
Overall, our findings demonstrate convergence rates ranging from 73% to 95%
between ChatGPT and linguists, with an overall point-estimate of 89%.
Significant correlations were also found between ChatGPT and laypeople across
all tasks, though the correlation strength varied by task. We attribute these
results to the psychometric nature of the judgment tasks and the differences in
language processing styles between humans and LLMs. | [
-0.2648616731,
-0.7067267895,
0.7785112262,
0.5225029588,
-0.247794047,
-0.1477435529,
-0.7435858846,
-0.3475809097,
0.2715749443,
0.0078742029,
-0.3025262356,
-0.4745597839,
-0.7638944387,
0.0910246894,
-0.2540620565,
0.8860140443,
0.4202919006,
0.2293099761,
-0.3367243409,
0.1952601522,
-0.1978974938,
-1.0357480049,
-0.4554910958,
-0.426940918,
0.4580785036,
0.1952126473,
0.831944108,
0.1729547977,
0.6028085947,
0.2842920423,
-0.2116208375,
-0.1173849627,
-0.5035966635,
-0.0326016732,
-0.2667163312,
-0.6434921026,
-0.3200311065,
0.1436690241,
0.443569541,
1.0217829943,
-0.3377735913,
0.052337449,
0.1880902648,
0.6709012389,
-0.4864484072,
0.5095989108,
-0.5300064683,
0.2215061933,
-0.3879362345,
-0.2107921243,
-0.6684831381,
-0.1834492087,
0.2329788655,
-0.4127226174,
0.2073963135,
0.0452182405,
0.839566648,
-0.0282924604,
-0.6303537488,
-0.1712827384,
-0.5903546214,
0.4278153181,
-0.6790114045,
0.5541171432,
0.3847423792,
-0.0498110019,
-0.3506066203,
-0.5848247409,
-0.5252128243,
-0.6810165048,
-0.1574371606,
0.3080273271,
-0.1799981147,
0.3069298863,
0.3275326788,
0.5074661374,
-0.7117821574,
0.2051639259,
-0.2382500172,
0.0483994856,
0.5112394691,
-0.0691959783,
0.0638208389,
-0.6147340536,
-0.3152271211,
0.0318646915,
-0.5478965044,
0.0332731567,
0.3144369423,
0.193531096,
-0.057946451,
0.9136318564,
-0.2882691026,
0.4226139784,
-0.0354484543,
0.1904694289,
0.1505452693,
-0.1660966724,
-0.2774023712,
-0.303942889,
1.2118077278,
0.5118938088,
0.7943116426,
-0.1029600054,
-0.0215083845,
0.3914996386,
0.3099830151,
-0.5278213024,
-0.4381371737,
-0.2668849528,
-0.4409360588,
-0.1126564071,
0.2427822351,
-0.4864776433,
-0.614354372,
-0.3979792595,
0.040757075,
-0.4626752138,
-0.3016816974,
0.2678828537,
0.0977303386,
0.4044090211,
0.3386864066,
-1.0213172436,
0.4064331949,
0.9262202382,
0.561626792,
-0.1567424238,
-0.5274284482,
-0.1233146712,
-0.3798615038,
-0.3754640818,
0.9828816056,
-0.428817898,
-0.2980258167,
-0.022155432,
-0.1531486064,
-0.3804850578,
-0.3900249898,
0.6401696801,
-0.2828500569,
0.3059601188,
-0.2468996942,
-0.6736038327,
-0.170048058,
0.202232793,
-0.305350095,
0.9810549617,
-0.0655519068,
-0.6146149635,
0.6668426991,
-0.3985781074,
-0.290366441,
0.2479721159,
-0.4896076918,
-0.0969281346,
0.399294585,
-0.0061931345,
0.7024821043,
-0.2889462709,
0.5229862332,
-0.209257111,
-0.3013735712,
0.5628042221,
-0.4220094085,
0.5025716424,
-0.0160864592,
-0.2341813892,
-0.030118037,
-0.5244812369,
0.0921911746,
0.0355018452,
-0.5209083557,
-0.1071262956,
0.2680437565,
0.1713434011,
0.227917701,
0.0680333227,
-0.4085500836,
0.2605396211,
-0.4663997293,
0.5080954432,
0.6060160398,
-0.2111758292,
0.2886109352,
-0.2303109765,
0.4373743832,
-0.2710403502,
-0.0406717248,
0.0691705793,
-0.68010813,
-0.8141858578,
-0.1267847568,
0.0873205215,
0.4666871428,
-0.0458675697,
0.4846382439,
-0.5685977936,
-0.4126563668,
-0.1093012244,
0.188340053,
0.5587692857,
-0.1314983368,
0.0324421413,
-0.3884771764,
-0.513371706,
-1.0049271584,
-0.4830782115,
-0.5595570803,
-0.1381047666,
0.2967360616,
0.4282899201,
0.0473373123,
0.9307435155,
-0.3657441437,
-0.0846669003,
-0.4196971953,
0.116416879,
0.3319898248,
0.2984984815,
0.5276733041,
-0.6343061924,
-0.3865239918,
0.1876550764,
-0.6328272223,
-0.1653921604,
0.0915542021,
-0.0343290381,
0.2323246449,
0.7151654363,
-0.9361880422,
0.4113563001,
0.5100883842,
-0.8027439117,
0.6414082646,
-0.1129690632,
0.066451706,
-1.0358507633,
0.0267106108,
-0.0068291677,
-0.2518615127,
-0.4957832694,
0.1554200649,
-0.1524510533,
0.0683818236,
-0.1790289134,
0.1923847347,
-0.3624242842,
-0.2365752012,
0.2266629338,
0.2306326181,
-0.2768654227,
0.6059493423,
0.0679415315,
0.6768610477,
0.2999810576,
-0.2860419452,
0.2744521797,
0.0766484812,
-0.3730101883,
0.560110569,
-0.7402175665,
0.139141798,
-0.2910594046,
0.1294007003,
-1.2572697401,
-0.4827011526,
0.1371694952,
-0.5905987024,
0.0092849936,
-0.3094947934,
-0.6385384202,
-0.1876327991,
0.0440321192,
0.2942590714,
0.595276475,
-0.0610382147,
0.4815790951,
0.1439856291,
-0.3237750232,
-0.1108176261,
-0.7021122575,
0.2296421081,
-0.1434358954,
-0.7173990011,
-0.0985182822,
0.1670733839,
-0.6828261018,
-0.3658643961,
-0.0104879886,
0.0553670675,
0.0467457436,
0.4165051281,
0.2561241388,
-0.3765929937,
0.3237356246,
-0.5514944792,
0.0997016877,
0.2830826938,
-0.2247592956,
0.7889387608,
-0.377183497,
-0.5653063655,
-0.2793937624,
0.0922975168,
0.5267473459,
-0.1258125007,
0.6703126431,
0.3634134531,
-0.1098828539,
0.1652985066,
-0.8386695385,
0.1345709562,
-0.3616485596,
0.3889659941,
-0.3540880382,
-0.8275465965,
0.509295404,
0.2374672443,
-0.2232101411,
0.453759253,
0.6180368662,
-0.2290748507,
0.635714829,
0.3285078704,
0.0209671818,
0.5876254439,
-0.0288182721,
0.2053437382,
-0.6168062687,
-0.3176511824,
-0.4879163802,
-0.1750429273,
-0.8228601813,
-0.4262832999,
0.1509726197,
0.0551641621,
-0.2619830966,
0.1207810193,
-0.0602768734,
0.4682962298,
0.4774696529,
0.2528198063,
0.3161326647,
-0.0619457401,
-0.2135428339,
-0.1834429353,
-0.5716202259,
-0.6742898822,
1.0184246302,
0.2179880589,
0.6808636189,
0.3274992108,
0.5360258222,
0.2189158946,
-0.0807618648,
-1.1552706957,
0.7945480347,
-0.327483803,
-0.2610465288,
-0.0796352178,
-0.3998429477,
-1.1028302908,
0.4384455383,
-0.2577864528,
-0.9930533171,
0.1105683967,
-0.0404108651,
-0.3141918778,
-0.118434839,
-1.0677046776,
0.851285398,
0.0715756416,
-0.253733784,
-0.1427611113,
-0.6031021476,
0.1703967452,
0.2216930687,
0.1878044903,
-0.2323531806,
0.1157027185,
0.6722752452,
-0.3670699894,
1.0339061022,
0.0798081756,
-0.1681464016,
0.0837096497,
0.2414057255,
0.3133626878,
0.1395821422,
0.0564260967,
0.0822638795,
-0.1095385179,
-0.4354836941,
-0.6273400784,
0.5268468261,
-0.6447402835,
-0.6622666121,
-0.5737783313,
-0.4262544215,
-0.2983430326,
0.1713516861,
0.3374479115,
0.4500624537,
-0.527050972,
0.1761689186,
0.2893925905,
0.0291893706,
0.3012105525,
0.4711489677,
-0.3924675286,
-0.09395504,
0.3723592758,
-0.0802972615,
0.5864602923,
0.4047227502,
0.2086418718,
-0.1393799335,
-0.4028097689,
-0.0452982709,
0.3593536019,
-0.6997979879,
0.2215528339,
-0.502278626,
-0.1438687444,
-0.2398430854,
-0.0272473618,
-0.3262093663,
-0.4894968271,
-0.0147822918,
-0.0932940096,
0.3152216673,
0.9711697102,
0.2121022344,
0.4538966119,
-0.4473766983,
-0.0295726769,
0.236424461,
0.1986554712,
-0.2563222647,
-0.5354593992,
0.1231107339,
0.1280500293,
-0.1025691032,
-0.5327059031,
0.1849366874,
0.3298074901,
0.2989174128,
0.5141502023,
-0.3948121369,
0.728182435,
-0.4018112719,
1.0487772226,
0.103571184,
-0.8798918724,
0.3537536561,
-0.6406335235,
0.2596491575,
0.4500769377,
0.0922672674,
-0.8796092868,
-0.4836665094,
-0.6246749163,
-0.7351300716,
0.5492640138,
0.4260806441,
0.2217042148,
-0.2443478256,
0.3674959242,
0.0015498669,
0.1000335217,
-0.8492186069,
0.0316193178,
0.0491513088,
-0.0233934261,
-0.4881325662,
-0.4301759601,
0.0826497376,
-0.1619805545,
0.0868792906,
-0.0926197916,
0.5928929448,
0.1582351774,
-0.1457975358,
0.1890129,
0.6210018396,
0.6658554077,
0.8317925334,
-0.0850781798,
0.3923614919,
-0.0365810022,
-0.5882202387,
-0.091256775,
0.1290259212,
0.1864166409,
-0.0591308512,
0.8465417027,
0.8633190393,
0.6036256552,
-0.5230941772,
0.9000353217,
-0.0264355671,
-0.1562754512,
-0.4918182492,
-0.0831884891,
0.1391891986,
0.2548960149,
0.1849480867,
0.3794547915,
0.0269144159,
-0.7570180297,
-0.1156176403,
0.4820230305,
-0.1451675445,
-0.5225090981,
0.3456498981,
-0.0144195026,
-0.225727886,
0.6996234655,
-0.3370682001,
-0.6771278381,
0.3996279836,
0.363819629,
0.8048449755,
-0.0886370614,
0.1403826028,
0.2964096069,
0.2239889354,
-0.3121373951,
0.318726778,
-0.0317652784,
-0.9126958847,
-0.5303769112,
-0.5653286576,
-0.1754543036,
-0.2070120871,
-0.7187075615,
0.2732451558,
-0.3139952123,
-0.2975187898,
-0.0351283774,
-0.2490396798,
-0.6442109942,
0.0111307949,
0.3150442541,
0.622074604,
-0.8365793228,
0.4329281151,
0.8898531199,
-0.3187486529,
-0.8492359519,
0.1881365925,
-0.0021165034,
-0.9365653396,
0.7884961367,
0.0525626317,
-0.0044315057,
-0.0941807106,
-0.2439044267,
-0.6708714366,
0.6797859669,
0.470941931,
-0.6431690454,
-0.335955888,
0.399304539,
0.7803992033,
0.0325021334,
0.471696347,
0.6146308184,
0.2302609533,
0.0876487419,
-1.5462782383,
-0.0846433714,
-0.3631761968,
0.1471626461,
0.3570821881,
-0.5748713613,
0.9198688269,
-0.1807959825,
-0.2783109546,
0.0533334166,
0.3566789329,
0.1008972228,
0.0032253121,
0.3014199734,
0.4982008636,
0.7320799828,
-0.2530636489,
1.120111227,
-0.12313921,
0.5120614171,
1.0754686594,
0.0090742121,
0.9781544209,
0.5876320601,
-0.6550859213,
0.4920813143,
0.4445611238,
0.2114565969,
0.2180934101,
0.3145581782,
-0.3326343,
-0.4120791554,
-0.0231047086,
-0.2274626642,
0.8342151046,
0.4433057308,
-0.5427670479,
-0.0868808106,
-0.0878822207,
0.3831375539,
0.1396025717,
-0.277123034,
0.8510465622,
0.2787102759,
-0.90554142,
0.6139150262,
-0.3050388992,
0.6586794853,
-0.6065939665,
0.1365835071,
-0.1758506596,
0.2306271195,
-0.4271607101,
-1.06379354,
0.0422054268,
0.0179145914,
0.0220113713,
-0.1829629391,
0.5072333813,
-0.2218372524,
-0.358379364,
0.1771971732,
0.7463914156,
0.381847024,
-0.2289152294,
-0.1306810528,
-0.0890048742,
-0.0885949209,
-0.2674227357,
0.172772333,
0.684525013,
-0.1698410809,
0.6595364213,
0.5163265467,
0.2108911276,
0.3282679319,
0.2800083756,
0.7757493854,
-0.7365992665,
-0.439391166,
-1.1333979368,
0.2805877626,
0.0575364493,
-0.5380850434,
0.7637870312,
0.5480260849,
0.8168757558,
-0.1676887423,
0.5816204548,
-0.3036745489,
0.0954038575,
-0.7135196924,
0.5092291832,
-0.0723295212,
0.136929214,
-0.4527204037,
-0.8471608162,
-0.3258168101,
0.8836918473,
-0.6411070824,
0.1720981151,
0.9862964749,
0.6240758896,
-0.1043886989,
0.1451576948,
0.2967772782,
0.315756917,
0.2026271075,
0.596169889,
1.0671511889,
-0.1226358637,
0.2999501824,
0.0097659295,
-0.147243768,
-0.1834216416,
-0.803042531,
-1.0423129797,
-0.5364536047,
-0.0073473612,
-0.1867233217,
-0.0657429546,
1.2617727518,
0.6217306852,
-0.4916523099,
-0.4308952689,
-0.4041330814,
-0.4760045409,
-0.0883561373,
-0.2703274786,
0.2110445201,
-0.441741854,
-0.5402326584,
0.2579974532,
0.1002783328,
-0.1319781542,
-0.1611585766,
0.0589823723,
-0.1603421569,
-0.1223961189,
0.8563453555,
0.013478904,
-0.9365614653,
-0.3254446983,
-0.0556168333,
-0.2194168866,
0.2405306101,
0.8600591421,
-0.6282835603,
0.2319516242,
0.4833156765,
0.2512654066,
0.3915390968,
0.1134656295,
0.7289443016,
-0.6950265169,
0.2560821772,
0.1091188341,
0.5601599813,
0.2744588554,
-0.2924723923,
0.5924970508,
0.4022229314,
-0.7231270671,
-0.4491707087,
0.2202781588,
-1.2333641052,
0.2748161256,
1.4891731739,
-0.2368067205,
0.0281523671,
0.0467384048,
-0.4963071644,
-0.0788875446,
-0.5963698626,
0.683870852,
1.0369231701,
-0.2890756428,
-0.1146283373,
-0.6803365946,
0.3246375322,
0.6134414077,
-0.734957397,
0.1288309395,
0.5543707013,
0.2480503619,
0.1245626062,
0.7174925208,
0.0103004538,
0.1954774261,
-0.1544596553,
-0.0131685901,
0.316801995,
0.1690377146,
-0.2125775218,
0.0151311168,
0.4998339117,
0.0480485857
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11115v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11115v1 | Text Grafting: Near-Distribution Weak Supervision for Minority Classes in Text Classification | 2024-06-17T00:23:08 | 2024-06-17T00:23:08 | Letian Peng, Yi Gu, Chengyu Dong, Zihan Wang, Jingbo Shang | cs.CL | cs.CL | For extremely weak-supervised text classification, pioneer research generates
pseudo labels by mining texts similar to the class names from the raw corpus,
which may end up with very limited or even no samples for the minority classes.
Recent works have started to generate the relevant texts by prompting LLMs
using the class names or definitions; however, there is a high risk that LLMs
cannot generate in-distribution (i.e., similar to the corpus where the text
classifier will be applied) data, leading to ungeneralizable classifiers. In
this paper, we combine the advantages of these two approaches and propose to
bridge the gap via a novel framework, \emph{text grafting}, which aims to
obtain clean and near-distribution weak supervision for minority classes.
Specifically, we first use LLM-based logits to mine masked templates from the
raw corpus, which have a high potential for data synthesis into the target
minority class. Then, the templates are filled by state-of-the-art LLMs to
synthesize near-distribution texts falling into minority classes. Text grafting
shows significant improvement over direct mining or synthesis on minority
classes. We also use analysis and case studies to comprehend the property of
text grafting. | [
-0.0490863174,
-0.5882824659,
0.3081720471,
0.1251894236,
-0.347410202,
0.3743441701,
-0.0804014057,
-0.618183434,
0.3345660567,
0.5878233314,
-0.3324762285,
-0.5917807817,
-0.4037582278,
0.1025559232,
-0.6698814034,
1.4034692049,
-0.1018700153,
-0.2072249055,
-0.2030838728,
0.006581387,
-0.2179826945,
-0.8305239677,
-0.2000882328,
-0.0524412096,
0.280312866,
0.4944848716,
0.3873393536,
0.6300547123,
0.4638166726,
0.264508456,
-0.1838857085,
-0.0963490903,
-0.5451881289,
-0.0295945462,
-0.0970642343,
-0.7221731544,
-0.5009202361,
0.0255073532,
0.7057795525,
0.7675270438,
0.2113235146,
0.0130710211,
0.2723249495,
0.4677624106,
-0.7961691022,
-0.2386391163,
-0.8580274582,
0.2982133925,
-0.7544902563,
-0.169309333,
-0.4555473328,
-0.446882993,
0.0143596195,
-0.2038545609,
0.6076796055,
-0.0020136603,
0.6217468977,
-0.0553040132,
-0.5096628666,
-0.1619924158,
-0.7138585448,
0.8839440346,
-0.5733760595,
0.1145897359,
0.4453344643,
0.1541585922,
0.1458570361,
-0.9617987871,
-0.2669316828,
0.1683546752,
-0.1732959896,
0.1970013231,
0.0210267343,
0.0519818701,
0.0437641516,
0.7543246746,
-0.1526379287,
0.2066596746,
-0.5873547196,
-0.3445727825,
0.4671401083,
0.1698511839,
0.1959144175,
-0.048915226,
-0.7569112778,
-0.0673587471,
-0.6638160944,
-0.3309441209,
0.6366981864,
0.4308381677,
0.0365319736,
0.6741926074,
0.1395173967,
0.7392712831,
-0.1251222342,
-0.2682735622,
0.4047043324,
-0.5076662898,
-0.2810938954,
0.2031890154,
0.6924685836,
0.3754917383,
0.0031764125,
-0.1012503952,
-0.3656265736,
0.0613328442,
0.1864620894,
-0.8571882248,
-0.1976030767,
-0.1957999021,
-0.7223644853,
-0.7952852845,
0.0931243226,
-1.0301839113,
-0.3460879922,
0.0165428445,
0.1779868305,
-0.0475264937,
-0.1930892766,
-0.1118443161,
-0.2147732973,
-0.0215676073,
0.2007590681,
-1.1629223824,
0.2607298791,
0.3262179792,
0.9995384812,
-0.5223526955,
0.0369470678,
-0.2362803072,
0.4991365373,
-0.2294703722,
0.786378324,
-0.3711581826,
-0.274608016,
0.2141959071,
-0.1385078281,
0.0626931489,
-0.6839493513,
0.7054183483,
-0.2383768857,
0.215640679,
0.2565184236,
-0.6457080245,
0.2145367116,
0.1957353801,
-0.4855574667,
1.1331968307,
0.3781661093,
-1.1124455929,
0.4677734971,
-0.2065396309,
-0.5540019274,
0.084103398,
0.0930300504,
-0.8275455236,
-0.0949369371,
-0.0761750713,
0.7398712039,
0.1110306755,
0.2483483106,
-0.6562401056,
-0.5253649354,
0.1186074242,
-0.4083832204,
0.7321920395,
0.1755942553,
-0.3248175979,
-0.1306817532,
-0.5193750858,
-0.2642658353,
-0.0595454387,
-0.2823964655,
-0.6445649266,
-0.1842162162,
0.4896464944,
0.0394187979,
0.1371394843,
-0.4553899467,
0.3588047624,
-0.5216460228,
0.2212796062,
1.0018668175,
-0.1246123165,
0.864548564,
-0.4046610892,
0.4147261083,
-0.1521967053,
0.0982300341,
-0.2160223573,
-0.4297426641,
-0.7012571692,
-0.4808139205,
0.4859102368,
0.7169218659,
-0.7032293677,
0.4770236611,
0.0553297661,
-0.5108222365,
-0.4392724335,
0.4764254689,
0.422216028,
0.4305213392,
0.4062716067,
-0.3424941003,
-0.6634278893,
-0.8198087215,
-0.378994137,
-0.2331059426,
0.0305235554,
-0.0379020385,
0.3435152769,
-0.3901939392,
0.8088217974,
-0.6514309645,
-1.0497034788,
-0.3377902806,
-0.1312665939,
-0.0395281948,
0.5052536726,
0.6613141298,
-0.8945951462,
-0.6606113315,
-0.2215207368,
-0.7335101962,
-0.1840666234,
-0.1846920997,
-0.0841597542,
0.0987628773,
1.0834481716,
-0.120489724,
0.4903667569,
0.3789219856,
-0.1587398201,
0.4300081432,
0.1177321076,
-0.1871636212,
-1.201669693,
-0.0973187238,
-0.078544274,
-0.3401810229,
-0.6378620267,
-0.2051324248,
-0.0069628898,
-0.0692976192,
-0.6143060327,
0.6812892556,
-0.5375172496,
0.2039454579,
-0.391495645,
-0.0737536103,
-0.3718784153,
0.3120884001,
-0.1646632701,
0.3167498708,
0.5786926746,
-0.4691719115,
0.2898284495,
0.2146040946,
-0.2423071265,
0.6211513281,
-0.286180675,
-0.0297963805,
-0.0723523051,
0.5305982232,
-0.6881712675,
-0.0929095075,
0.3415899873,
-0.1743815094,
0.4886902273,
-0.467759937,
-0.5554603338,
-0.2604163885,
-0.5214434862,
0.6681925058,
0.6575824022,
-0.6018525362,
0.3696814477,
0.4831008613,
-0.2106176913,
-0.5493462682,
-1.0253946781,
0.0818441063,
-0.4629172981,
-0.1840016842,
0.5722556114,
-0.1047578976,
-0.1616719216,
0.2317231894,
-0.0534795411,
-0.1546407938,
0.1315013319,
0.2330628932,
0.3117092252,
0.0090372851,
0.2026553303,
0.481311202,
-0.0338675417,
-0.2293139845,
-0.4113505781,
0.0933081284,
0.1342018694,
-0.3948927522,
-0.2540464997,
0.2599265277,
0.1172951236,
0.192936182,
0.6625978947,
0.5157735348,
-0.2869166732,
-0.5708764195,
-0.3270338476,
-0.2827421427,
-0.486169368,
0.2160663456,
-0.1490272284,
-0.9739951491,
0.0096895583,
-0.2414965928,
0.285094142,
0.3538325429,
0.6817923784,
-0.3699649572,
0.6546920538,
0.8987060189,
-0.2130912542,
0.7851226926,
-0.0912067443,
-0.0939355716,
-0.3502898812,
-0.2600953579,
-0.5163550377,
-0.390324384,
-0.5514020324,
-0.533387661,
0.092307508,
0.0616963618,
0.4426387548,
0.1932582557,
-0.5934472084,
0.5357449055,
0.5733351111,
0.0815484151,
0.3381473422,
0.3733339012,
-0.0815154985,
-0.1232043728,
-0.5058771372,
-0.6894696951,
1.346987009,
0.1886104941,
0.7348751426,
-0.0710582212,
1.1112416983,
0.5345720053,
0.8847485185,
-0.6836045384,
0.4774143696,
-0.3981867135,
-0.7425389886,
-0.013737889,
-0.5874142647,
-0.9110370874,
0.3543046415,
-0.5661860704,
-0.5377724767,
0.1124749184,
0.4156507552,
0.4565232992,
0.8460347056,
-0.8752704859,
0.6553717256,
0.177515462,
-0.1930126548,
0.1346949041,
-0.6389034986,
0.5853518844,
-0.4747125506,
0.3117371202,
0.1044149101,
-0.0565870553,
0.8854436874,
-0.3387509584,
1.281632185,
-0.1012345403,
-0.1610400379,
0.4118923545,
-0.0505963936,
0.4134313166,
-0.1514844894,
0.0101341922,
-0.056439843,
-0.326213181,
-0.6763646007,
-0.3658361733,
0.6438708901,
-0.3996633589,
-0.4035233855,
-0.4801648259,
-0.2198787034,
-0.1584828794,
0.3881161511,
0.4507107735,
0.2482243627,
-0.4180697799,
-0.0002490171,
0.7240920663,
0.1118675545,
0.4085384905,
0.1076270863,
-0.054683648,
-0.3560855091,
1.2298340797,
-0.1244652644,
0.2648923695,
0.6409896016,
-0.0131803192,
-0.2460151613,
-0.7860226631,
-0.3644087315,
0.1674279273,
-0.7442792654,
-0.4027402401,
-0.6932395697,
-0.1905835867,
-0.2347336411,
-0.5239771605,
-0.2004906684,
-0.4800597727,
-0.6490362883,
-0.3018268347,
0.0421572849,
0.7149916291,
-0.0439359061,
0.33823964,
-0.8077872396,
0.3344344795,
0.3285729587,
0.4029510915,
0.0058495863,
-0.3790102899,
-0.2404520512,
-0.1724202633,
-0.4888004363,
-1.0619785786,
0.1861169189,
-0.0013795343,
0.4040620625,
0.3703809977,
0.3015640974,
0.3543148339,
-0.4457171559,
0.4431899488,
0.4948506951,
-0.9206274748,
0.4151389599,
-0.1561625749,
-0.1524368078,
0.7480406761,
0.2144795805,
-0.2464423776,
-1.137319088,
-0.6950101852,
-1.0291149616,
0.7820001841,
0.4946901202,
0.3713041544,
0.1160195097,
0.1652356684,
0.2073881775,
0.026548868,
-1.0344783068,
-0.4222659767,
-0.4031708837,
-0.6154777408,
-0.160819456,
-0.2899648547,
-0.0681005195,
-0.0420173369,
0.660610795,
-0.1411542445,
0.0740215033,
0.0576730184,
-0.3560263216,
0.0786265284,
0.3014728427,
0.3588635325,
0.1963760555,
-0.2720185518,
0.4974889457,
0.2494342327,
-0.6254895329,
0.2810330689,
0.0503403619,
-0.5140286684,
0.0952044874,
0.5093116164,
0.503590405,
-0.0291103553,
-0.5108480453,
0.7483357787,
0.0955364257,
-0.3495972455,
-0.0825027302,
0.028865356,
-0.0240797959,
-0.010688425,
0.5203088522,
0.3368632197,
0.1243057102,
-0.5530023575,
0.262960434,
0.3696440756,
-0.7340907454,
-0.3953972459,
0.5983140469,
0.3752559423,
-0.0897940919,
0.3863877654,
-0.1910370886,
-0.4445290267,
0.5104193091,
0.6991809607,
0.73242414,
-0.0341685191,
0.1952842176,
0.1395898163,
0.3815165758,
-0.1695019901,
-0.1797474325,
-0.1407394409,
-0.4513601959,
-0.3102582097,
-0.6205250621,
-0.3307020366,
-0.1202888042,
-0.4207518101,
0.4824812114,
-0.4142332971,
-0.0841827914,
-0.239390552,
-0.3511838913,
-0.2073894739,
0.2402363569,
-0.0149099361,
0.6403779387,
-1.185869813,
0.6421732306,
0.9119481444,
-0.0919529349,
-0.3077199757,
0.216424942,
-0.0635855943,
-0.4913721383,
0.3652591705,
0.2286481112,
0.2187850624,
-0.1093798131,
-0.5125306845,
-0.2653106153,
0.8072667122,
0.4064018428,
-0.4878182113,
0.0621347092,
0.0615354478,
0.5660125613,
0.0322748236,
0.0836420059,
0.0504361987,
0.3311923444,
0.0775382444,
-0.6243366003,
0.1870897412,
-0.1726334542,
-0.2189995795,
0.4749733806,
-0.6272422075,
0.5238180757,
-0.2043190449,
-0.2737122774,
0.0804046169,
0.8167097569,
0.1569565833,
0.6799160838,
0.5519199371,
0.5354598165,
0.7465581894,
0.0575142801,
0.825338006,
0.3133898377,
0.3289425969,
0.8783352375,
0.0120466473,
0.5157582164,
0.4408895075,
-0.2728768885,
0.614195168,
0.5449524522,
-0.2359375656,
0.5641235709,
0.3276919723,
-0.500695765,
-0.0129132122,
-0.1971012354,
-0.485776931,
0.1449316442,
0.0922125578,
-0.4582624733,
-0.1390246451,
0.0210614651,
0.0121754836,
0.2564102709,
-0.3368028998,
0.7783334255,
0.3905139863,
-0.1324892491,
0.2956238389,
0.3014473617,
1.0956394672,
-0.4081829786,
0.0007756288,
-0.3616954088,
0.2482229471,
-0.472124666,
-0.6620928049,
0.4462637305,
0.0877590925,
-0.3480580747,
-0.6645047069,
1.0517698526,
-0.4906829,
-0.5452898145,
0.2548037171,
0.4687004685,
0.2730361521,
0.2555879354,
-0.5126234889,
-0.3083778322,
0.1646499485,
0.0127240978,
0.7640696168,
0.4605531991,
-0.3876729608,
0.4675917327,
0.7218925357,
0.2471607924,
0.1175709963,
-0.0952970535,
0.9293369651,
-0.757979691,
-0.4628516436,
-1.0145331621,
0.1187511981,
-0.0743817613,
-0.2217801809,
0.7709466219,
0.7614356875,
0.8863614202,
-0.111012049,
0.8878480196,
-0.0023212209,
0.3597952724,
-0.4437704682,
0.6772940755,
-0.6403861642,
0.1460504085,
-0.7662735581,
-1.1511421204,
-0.4386719167,
0.2808021009,
0.22636123,
-0.1119286045,
0.6245679855,
0.5130302906,
-0.4195341766,
-0.2518899441,
0.1431049854,
0.0210556295,
0.1738749444,
0.5448440313,
0.887181282,
-0.1817483753,
1.0948991776,
-0.2307227403,
-0.2647486627,
-0.1985370666,
-0.8226392269,
-1.2733083963,
-0.4293396771,
-0.2576237023,
-0.3630633056,
-0.0696204305,
0.3090394735,
0.687656343,
-0.6505346894,
-0.0566439852,
-0.2116533369,
0.5758367777,
-0.0104697058,
-0.3396711946,
0.4826547801,
-0.2229586393,
-0.9392925501,
0.1948761195,
0.1321794093,
0.6471168399,
-0.0756983384,
0.1929762065,
0.0698818415,
-0.210808292,
0.4153852463,
0.1683939546,
-0.1170773357,
0.3296585977,
-0.3959493041,
-0.3200933039,
-0.1253215373,
1.0397225618,
-0.7296812534,
0.2770294845,
0.3619159758,
0.6544060111,
0.8128687143,
-0.0303151235,
0.4021781385,
-1.1592772007,
0.3966409266,
0.5172509551,
0.0577524006,
0.5260921717,
-0.1741289198,
0.3455221653,
0.8179349899,
-0.01015714,
-1.2799130678,
0.2872489989,
-0.8616829515,
-0.5029414892,
1.1070915461,
-0.1056608483,
-0.0326713882,
-0.4334179759,
-0.2630529702,
0.3092395067,
-0.3436438143,
0.5746174455,
0.3564252555,
0.2725524604,
0.1159396768,
-0.2100777328,
0.5694557428,
0.5538961291,
-0.9470586777,
-0.0855418071,
0.2130094618,
0.2541670501,
-0.0373838991,
0.957930088,
-0.2027422339,
-0.145175457,
-0.227448076,
-0.0283635613,
0.1316694319,
-0.1273907572,
0.0202670526,
0.4201997519,
-0.1599667966,
0.0514906719
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11109v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11109v2 | Investigating Annotator Bias in Large Language Models for Hate Speech Detection | 2024-06-17T00:18:31 | 2024-06-18T06:21:16 | Amit Das, Zheng Zhang, Fatemeh Jamshidi, Vinija Jain, Aman Chadha, Nilanjana Raychawdhary, Mary Sandage, Lauramarie Pope, Gerry Dozier, Cheryl Seals | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Data annotation, the practice of assigning descriptive labels to raw data, is
pivotal in optimizing the performance of machine learning models. However, it
is a resource-intensive process susceptible to biases introduced by annotators.
The emergence of sophisticated Large Language Models (LLMs), like ChatGPT
presents a unique opportunity to modernize and streamline this complex
procedure. While existing research extensively evaluates the efficacy of LLMs,
as annotators, this paper delves into the biases present in LLMs, specifically
GPT 3.5 and GPT 4o when annotating hate speech data. Our research contributes
to understanding biases in four key categories: gender, race, religion, and
disability. Specifically targeting highly vulnerable groups within these
categories, we analyze annotator biases. Furthermore, we conduct a
comprehensive examination of potential factors contributing to these biases by
scrutinizing the annotated data. We introduce our custom hate speech detection
dataset, HateSpeechCorpus, to conduct this research. Additionally, we perform
the same experiments on the ETHOS (Mollas et al., 2022) dataset also for
comparative analysis. This paper serves as a crucial resource, guiding
researchers and practitioners in harnessing the potential of LLMs for
dataannotation, thereby fostering advancements in this critical field. The
HateSpeechCorpus dataset is available here:
https://github.com/AmitDasRup123/HateSpeechCorpus | [
-0.5684790015,
-0.8388489485,
0.1359138191,
-0.0675861761,
-0.1634345204,
0.1562730074,
-0.2925709784,
-0.6949970722,
0.14402996,
0.5964358449,
-0.3343835771,
-0.3324960172,
-0.9046738744,
0.0032263284,
-0.3398251534,
1.5414181948,
0.0823260248,
0.0913453996,
0.1400823444,
-0.2893303335,
-0.3145509064,
-0.8934129477,
-0.6795822978,
-0.3346280456,
0.6680653691,
-0.0148200244,
0.793859005,
0.4847685993,
0.2859808803,
0.1873128116,
-0.3284517825,
-0.2002966255,
-0.593947053,
0.3271918595,
0.0746633783,
-0.3188263178,
-0.189738974,
0.0957120731,
0.3518722951,
0.3696875572,
0.1511800587,
0.256488651,
-0.0435226113,
0.0966987163,
-0.570602417,
0.2358107269,
-0.9849829078,
0.2201328427,
-0.6422454119,
-0.0244209357,
-0.2506488264,
-0.4643109441,
0.1414087415,
-0.4676378071,
0.4366740584,
0.0974700674,
0.4773187041,
0.3953303099,
-0.2648434639,
-0.3568577468,
-0.6119616628,
0.6949661374,
-0.5573328733,
0.3408343792,
0.4601424038,
0.1909582168,
-0.0464766547,
-0.1700575352,
-0.7136488557,
-0.3337084055,
0.105895564,
-0.1585321426,
-0.3123173118,
0.0679164603,
0.6250859499,
0.326793313,
-0.3511711955,
0.6097806096,
-0.4381157756,
-0.4367990196,
0.6063238978,
-0.0483656712,
0.3005832136,
-0.2060890943,
-0.2728502154,
0.1991436332,
-0.6424345374,
-0.4234886467,
0.7217475772,
0.4427167773,
0.0142172528,
0.5669855475,
0.00873088,
0.5031383634,
-0.2596357763,
0.1259897202,
0.4704442322,
0.1931876838,
-0.0412667878,
0.1975440532,
0.8701145649,
0.4285096228,
0.7923567295,
-0.1581305265,
-0.160106495,
0.2138605863,
0.3004135787,
-0.634693563,
-0.2724870443,
0.0342788212,
-0.0995544568,
-0.4615793526,
-0.599221468,
-0.9227647185,
-0.9742069244,
-0.2411609441,
0.1874188632,
-0.3735111356,
-0.2936861813,
-0.4562251568,
-0.091872327,
0.0713337809,
0.2435679287,
-0.9576398134,
0.1835805029,
0.6662623882,
0.8164511919,
-0.4009463191,
-0.1630251855,
-0.6421614289,
0.0354275666,
-0.1505532861,
0.6792365909,
-0.7516862154,
-0.2611157596,
0.2164468169,
-0.3813816011,
0.1234788522,
-0.7094681859,
0.7937259674,
-0.5704394579,
0.0188896526,
-0.2324568182,
-0.5322323442,
-0.1427917928,
0.27614972,
-0.6272815466,
1.0179666281,
0.090992026,
-1.0312379599,
0.6275189519,
-0.8208061457,
-0.2258899957,
0.2524682581,
-0.3688859046,
-0.7111432552,
-0.0375339538,
0.2264706641,
0.3722750843,
-0.1526851952,
0.2722264826,
-0.5776091218,
-0.1939824224,
0.3652498722,
-0.374206692,
0.719579339,
0.2387087792,
-0.5412276387,
0.2412083149,
-0.5735065937,
-0.5780982971,
0.311447233,
-0.0090399804,
-0.4330648482,
-0.051030919,
0.3891895413,
0.3054410219,
-0.2757983804,
-0.7910035253,
-0.0953980759,
-0.0518230088,
0.4096887112,
1.0756223202,
-0.2176336348,
0.0627670214,
-0.1092956141,
0.6753525734,
0.0268276129,
0.1807388067,
0.0911597908,
-0.4869515896,
-0.4978743494,
-0.3693049252,
0.1340717375,
0.3814219832,
-0.4569586217,
-0.0897052661,
-0.0514756069,
-0.4055197835,
-0.513289094,
-0.0157754086,
0.2140320092,
0.4686656594,
0.4192385077,
-0.0666551292,
-0.7739496231,
-1.1924904585,
-0.4212345183,
-0.1173791364,
0.02510597,
0.2731241584,
0.5803151727,
-0.0772320405,
0.8825047016,
-0.286665231,
-0.4382287562,
-0.2355041951,
0.1173110828,
-0.1907084435,
0.2389958799,
0.5326621532,
-0.8986060023,
-0.3901345134,
-0.2135562599,
-0.3301868737,
-0.5206380486,
0.1351605505,
0.0866440088,
0.3372645974,
0.313323915,
-0.2813081443,
0.4284357131,
0.6314221621,
-0.2538308799,
0.67091465,
0.6181582808,
0.0726698041,
-0.7360936999,
-0.1341548711,
0.224420324,
-0.1260215193,
-0.7763779759,
-0.225610435,
-0.4051328301,
0.0605713204,
-0.4279997647,
0.2694950402,
-0.0842423663,
-0.0071066157,
-0.2860593498,
0.233623296,
-0.5515944362,
0.2760104239,
0.0811598226,
0.7451905012,
0.2404294163,
-0.2862355113,
0.2290506959,
0.283392489,
-0.1826831549,
0.5497893095,
-0.4463194907,
0.1815499514,
-0.0867212713,
0.3660133183,
-0.9635214806,
-0.1480776817,
0.5813257694,
-0.4458562136,
0.0040197861,
-0.5810784698,
-0.6807152033,
-0.3520936072,
-0.2885048091,
0.4213357568,
0.2752481401,
-0.450027287,
0.3518382311,
0.9244558811,
-0.1823189408,
-0.4720387757,
-0.8441560864,
0.0852175951,
-0.6227728128,
-0.2121447176,
0.0050489991,
0.0780751407,
-0.4224766791,
-0.308137536,
0.0838980377,
-0.1142054573,
0.0445083901,
0.5104192495,
0.2491026819,
0.0860356838,
0.1190297678,
-0.292981565,
-0.0384955071,
0.3022971451,
-0.0248849615,
0.6617296338,
0.1704376787,
-0.2258411646,
-0.0490981266,
0.1099152267,
0.429307431,
-0.128211394,
0.6615733504,
0.8567145467,
-0.3317792714,
-0.0370182134,
-0.8344406486,
0.0465443805,
-0.3627691567,
0.5110124946,
-0.1278679669,
-1.3325442076,
0.6504528522,
0.4121808112,
0.1588619649,
0.3974805474,
0.7756946087,
0.321842581,
0.8291931152,
0.2590580583,
-0.3648132682,
0.549985528,
0.0386344306,
0.2941641212,
-0.8990021944,
-0.1138683185,
-0.5852178335,
-0.0642092302,
-0.8344743252,
-0.5099349022,
0.2801630199,
-0.4498019516,
-0.2998839915,
-0.0435927361,
-0.5919088125,
0.4572505355,
0.3432645798,
-0.2283360958,
0.1354001313,
0.1453890949,
0.2231710404,
-0.3982231319,
-0.4757927358,
-0.5551116467,
1.2201954126,
0.6472712159,
0.3394117355,
0.0013636117,
0.4722912014,
0.3872953057,
0.6595168114,
-0.7355804443,
0.363653034,
0.0326388963,
-0.9659634233,
-0.1203031391,
-0.4173136652,
-0.6238334775,
0.4620791972,
-0.1018852517,
-1.020160079,
0.0992722511,
0.3358680308,
-0.233173117,
0.6868293881,
-0.5927858949,
0.8246615529,
0.0226437226,
-0.4122941792,
0.0181129631,
-0.2057599425,
0.5398201942,
-0.3642209172,
0.4058504701,
-0.4561865032,
0.0213200133,
1.0786173344,
-0.2369581312,
1.0730253458,
-0.4291230142,
-0.3245534599,
0.1837540418,
0.060050182,
0.5338870287,
-0.2565074861,
-0.2691788375,
0.5173808336,
-0.3554653227,
-0.2397037297,
-0.1267907321,
0.6249637008,
-0.6270517111,
-0.4036970437,
-0.5525128245,
-0.6197252274,
-0.2906302512,
0.0432274677,
0.1572354734,
0.0854767859,
-0.1464007646,
-0.170637235,
0.5538153648,
-0.3463508189,
0.1847354919,
0.4166447818,
-0.3514336646,
-0.2938188612,
0.8625288606,
0.5007554293,
0.2635704875,
-0.081242092,
0.1060979068,
-0.1316340566,
-0.8096794486,
-0.3777315021,
0.0776592642,
-0.5125663877,
-0.085210152,
-0.8612477779,
-0.2342021018,
-0.3882855475,
0.0981294438,
-0.34526366,
-0.3051442802,
-0.0626112595,
-0.2073875815,
0.5820381641,
0.7571754456,
-0.0723447651,
0.4819460511,
-0.0675663948,
0.2392477542,
0.0525366478,
0.4386641085,
-0.0042204438,
-0.7257500291,
-0.231699869,
-0.0602918267,
-0.3015794456,
-0.8033025861,
0.2564541698,
-0.3254293799,
0.3234910667,
0.1202730015,
0.0211844556,
0.4717618823,
-0.5244769454,
0.8408927917,
-0.0930300504,
-0.7637777925,
0.4072158337,
-0.5900235176,
-0.0770824775,
0.4221403003,
0.5503976345,
-0.7334560156,
-0.6308720708,
-0.6102978587,
-0.9296955466,
0.784543097,
0.3942900002,
0.1282579452,
-0.1222064868,
0.1251502484,
0.3035883009,
0.1411569118,
-0.8961061835,
-0.5451164246,
-0.1476664841,
0.0312073063,
0.020094322,
-0.6286712885,
-0.1642338485,
-0.0537445098,
0.8063436747,
0.0300981551,
0.0871676058,
-0.1291249245,
-0.1809192896,
0.0382938199,
0.3784606159,
0.5090684295,
0.5725471377,
-0.0931056291,
0.0528124943,
0.3815318346,
-0.6142882109,
-0.0646245107,
0.4516142905,
-0.3333435655,
0.0630322471,
0.308547467,
0.9240309596,
-0.0790580884,
-0.5297120214,
0.516284287,
0.1754245162,
-0.0872676373,
-0.6534757614,
-0.0213327613,
-0.2665365636,
0.2074515224,
0.3395194709,
-0.1923502982,
0.2351693511,
-0.0555885099,
0.1367263347,
0.4318297207,
-0.4689044654,
-0.309063673,
0.6890982985,
0.1312589794,
-0.1720068604,
0.3592996597,
-0.0295424145,
-0.8252648711,
0.341951102,
0.4391752779,
0.8677102327,
-0.454652667,
0.2015465796,
0.2271890938,
0.4425913393,
0.3862485886,
-0.1545910984,
-0.0894058421,
-0.7433320284,
-0.5171123147,
-0.6807821393,
-0.514685154,
0.5422240496,
-0.457521975,
0.1298392117,
-0.3900468647,
-0.103179723,
0.3359849453,
-0.1476622522,
-0.6063572168,
0.0779747143,
0.7489661574,
0.6073272824,
-1.0454003811,
0.5222159624,
0.3785432577,
-0.3380221128,
-0.488393575,
0.0917873532,
0.4571302831,
-1.0491501093,
0.7983737588,
0.1845444739,
0.0824485272,
-0.2527189553,
-0.4279235601,
-0.5351362228,
0.3350528777,
0.3277700841,
-0.7104638219,
0.3225323856,
0.6414422989,
0.6306552291,
-0.2597454786,
0.4417888522,
0.7667341232,
0.4183535874,
-0.1270834506,
-0.9525797963,
0.0318925567,
0.0206240062,
0.0388040021,
0.2721349001,
-0.5877482295,
0.5490045547,
0.057929121,
0.1971115619,
-0.4704240561,
0.3365443647,
0.2632662356,
0.2585170865,
0.6422089934,
0.520268023,
0.6002351046,
-0.0786982253,
0.9411085844,
0.2239524722,
0.2233301103,
1.3133393526,
-0.245007515,
0.5325651765,
0.4676371515,
-0.2811254263,
0.1481163353,
0.5479412675,
-0.1339868009,
0.0343546383,
0.716530025,
-0.4422556758,
0.0093124583,
-0.4636113942,
-0.217848137,
0.5255711675,
0.381914854,
-0.5811193585,
-0.1658483446,
0.1524818242,
0.4789293408,
-0.1269059479,
-0.2261096537,
0.6909359694,
-0.1046826318,
-0.2289672047,
0.4320494235,
-0.2876904309,
0.8315987587,
-0.4676299691,
0.1453935653,
-0.0719212219,
-0.0313591994,
-0.3390796483,
-0.831728816,
0.4334203899,
0.4871688485,
-0.0992776603,
-0.0275951345,
0.4059635401,
-0.353608489,
-0.2270208299,
0.3396709561,
0.0636232197,
0.2886070907,
-0.414060533,
-0.7428768277,
0.6893863082,
0.2374732345,
-0.3574717343,
0.3097915649,
0.3545853794,
-0.2154061049,
0.6144484282,
0.5819538236,
0.3198151886,
0.2373993099,
0.3048859537,
0.9144942164,
-0.5527693033,
-0.2452313304,
-1.1525599957,
0.1840936095,
-0.1540586501,
-0.4234905541,
0.8657369018,
0.8761849403,
1.0226634741,
0.2770702243,
1.1840068102,
0.024752751,
0.8237736225,
-0.17318286,
0.6311673522,
-0.0664889067,
0.2406011522,
-0.5386221409,
-0.8267200589,
-0.5385681391,
0.4798112214,
-0.845212996,
0.1149336919,
0.1974174231,
0.8112381101,
-0.0714669377,
0.3193512261,
0.2462095022,
0.551605165,
0.7112337947,
0.1450807005,
0.9098376036,
-0.2511207163,
0.6244153976,
-0.2914455533,
-0.1270181537,
-0.190578267,
-0.6696107984,
-0.9178747535,
-0.4437380433,
-0.5907003284,
-0.3856759965,
0.1781000197,
0.9969899654,
0.5417196155,
-0.9125864506,
-0.0661331788,
0.2158689648,
0.0335511491,
0.3642884791,
-0.2867596745,
0.2902732193,
-0.1970365494,
-0.7761403322,
-0.1256109774,
0.0942609012,
-0.086428687,
-0.227324456,
0.0660295635,
-0.0672564283,
-0.1687278301,
0.6519212127,
0.2516810596,
-0.8655098677,
-0.4261161089,
-0.7354570031,
0.1729834676,
0.0455652438,
0.8131213784,
-0.6815226078,
0.3386779428,
-0.0598831289,
0.7159644961,
0.4932465255,
-0.2591961026,
0.3308598399,
-0.5160166621,
0.1637960076,
0.387581706,
0.2321020663,
0.6070402265,
-0.2327337414,
0.5682550669,
0.2855099738,
-0.6646252275,
-1.0708340406,
0.2171671987,
-0.7228024602,
0.1040795892,
1.3456372023,
0.154009074,
-0.1027113199,
-0.2785108984,
-0.4632737339,
0.3306716681,
-0.6394548416,
0.8036445379,
0.7558563948,
-0.1713797152,
-0.1970002353,
-0.915889442,
0.750095427,
0.3279541433,
-0.5392926335,
0.5798492432,
0.6853826046,
0.3800994456,
0.0675687119,
0.5449777842,
-0.1224335507,
-0.0267704129,
-0.1399564892,
0.2732138634,
-0.0558329634,
0.2355226576,
-0.4278006852,
0.1113819852,
0.0701322928,
-0.1364199668
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11107v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11107v1 | Exploring Safety-Utility Trade-Offs in Personalized Language Models | 2024-06-17T00:17:11 | 2024-06-17T00:17:11 | Anvesh Rao Vijjini, Somnath Basu Roy Chowdhury, Snigdha Chaturvedi | cs.CL | cs.CL | As large language models (LLMs) become increasingly integrated into daily
applications, it is essential to ensure they operate fairly across diverse user
demographics. In this work, we show that LLMs suffer from personalization bias,
where their performance is impacted when they are personalized to a user's
identity. We quantify personalization bias by evaluating the performance of
LLMs along two axes - safety and utility. We measure safety by examining how
benign LLM responses are to unsafe prompts with and without personalization. We
measure utility by evaluating the LLM's performance on various tasks, including
general knowledge, mathematical abilities, programming, and reasoning skills.
We find that various LLMs, ranging from open-source models like Llama (Touvron
et al., 2023) and Mistral (Jiang et al., 2023) to API-based ones like GPT-3.5
and GPT-4o (Ouyang et al., 2022), exhibit significant variance in performance
in terms of safety-utility trade-offs depending on the user's identity.
Finally, we discuss several strategies to mitigate personalization bias using
preference tuning and prompt-based defenses. | [
-0.2061573714,
-0.6045250893,
0.7141955495,
0.0816085711,
0.0628938377,
0.1498121023,
-0.1885012239,
-0.4438951313,
-0.2125659883,
0.750020802,
-0.3118105233,
-0.5732616186,
-0.5827792883,
0.0037582298,
-0.0359124988,
1.0739235878,
0.2387208939,
-0.1675741822,
-0.1893662661,
0.1301753223,
-0.6492264271,
-0.8582800627,
-0.6358002424,
-0.2480732799,
0.6119165421,
0.2341125309,
0.8752424717,
0.6372779608,
0.2971740663,
0.3188045323,
-0.2459774464,
-0.4678580165,
-0.3757480681,
0.3389523327,
-0.2297389209,
-0.3766739368,
-0.6009910107,
0.0101034418,
0.3965044022,
0.6364310384,
0.1335493326,
0.07314457,
0.1263360977,
0.4667222202,
-0.6585639715,
0.1004250869,
-0.7112731934,
-0.1314721107,
-0.3100160658,
-0.1819380373,
-0.540022254,
-0.7018504143,
0.2787062526,
-0.4441532791,
-0.0544198342,
0.1166819707,
0.4765738547,
0.2591199279,
-0.6289356947,
-0.2255891114,
-0.6772012711,
0.9732329845,
-0.7129976749,
0.2377063632,
0.5799105167,
0.3121673167,
-0.1489908099,
-0.2880604863,
-0.1836148202,
-0.4936599135,
0.0381193794,
-0.1701393723,
-0.2062822878,
0.2556263208,
0.3262482882,
0.0237443615,
-0.5161874294,
0.5209626555,
-0.0632660091,
-0.3949278593,
0.6772815585,
0.3156788051,
0.3637877405,
0.0193436816,
-0.2954625487,
-0.0552924648,
-0.8872287273,
0.5137934685,
0.8220221996,
0.2390759885,
-0.2218470573,
0.4635422528,
-0.2130095065,
0.6459081769,
-0.0565809906,
-0.3280464709,
0.2387574613,
-0.1210934073,
-0.1239341199,
-0.0050269533,
0.8205228448,
0.4696086049,
0.6242392063,
-0.3429759145,
-0.0445389524,
-0.2054917216,
0.0607984364,
-0.6497536898,
-0.0995924994,
0.1887088567,
-0.4948667288,
-0.5670064688,
-0.3511835039,
-0.6246747971,
-0.6669422388,
-0.1858566552,
0.2012498081,
-0.228657335,
-0.0114637166,
0.0573515631,
0.1514811516,
-0.1701047719,
0.2131723464,
-1.1508562565,
0.2753841877,
0.5902586579,
0.6393663883,
-0.4425526261,
-0.1347872764,
-0.6040796638,
0.3269694448,
-0.0822000057,
0.6138282418,
-0.6194173098,
-0.656411767,
0.1923959553,
-0.2562730312,
0.0658879951,
-0.4460297823,
0.6819866896,
-0.5611556768,
-0.003387535,
-0.5888106823,
-0.3694744706,
0.0178721156,
-0.0413335226,
-0.4752570987,
0.449233532,
-0.2122607678,
-0.9861091375,
0.4254038334,
-0.5484924912,
-0.5220779181,
-0.0231058989,
-0.0462481976,
-0.189293474,
0.0857904553,
-0.1143431067,
0.5316765308,
-0.2701718211,
0.2343099862,
-0.7150783539,
-0.355676353,
0.6240050197,
-0.5373791456,
0.7340073586,
0.3665708303,
-0.2682742476,
0.2701114416,
-0.7832955122,
-0.0551277138,
0.0836805627,
-0.5669474602,
-0.7721194029,
0.0537665226,
0.1710615456,
0.2072710097,
0.4917891622,
-0.5298438072,
-0.0488485731,
-0.5012290478,
0.1938939542,
1.2387740612,
-0.282130897,
0.4557678699,
-0.2358894348,
0.4796303809,
-0.050634928,
0.1895155013,
-0.0379615165,
-0.5690783262,
-0.4831239283,
-0.170950368,
0.0954045355,
0.6930977702,
-0.3868322372,
0.5175470114,
-0.0333931595,
-0.0267489702,
-0.0617384017,
0.2230660766,
0.5128773451,
0.4544171691,
0.0256775767,
-0.1756784022,
-0.2136421204,
-1.0978187323,
-0.8135809898,
-0.3222081065,
-0.2542520165,
0.4544788599,
-0.0030673724,
-0.3282661736,
1.0645782948,
-0.6675146818,
0.0339761898,
-0.233592689,
-0.2066369355,
0.077770181,
0.3017282188,
0.6923670769,
-0.50810498,
-0.5289844275,
0.1638205647,
-0.5216493607,
-0.5120540261,
-0.0693788826,
-0.0553149581,
0.2433625609,
0.1686320901,
-0.4718654156,
0.1900593638,
0.5904332995,
-0.6324016452,
0.4194377065,
-0.1702902317,
-0.1136783436,
-1.0545477867,
0.1119898111,
0.2549865246,
-0.1874241233,
-0.9411981106,
-0.0559862405,
-0.083579585,
0.2522587776,
-0.5463974476,
0.788787961,
-0.1346184164,
-0.0011972375,
-0.2827055156,
-0.0925794244,
-0.3386470377,
0.1606592238,
-0.1053935736,
0.9536179304,
0.4630739689,
-0.5456299782,
-0.1656266302,
0.0704985559,
-0.1568876654,
0.2984107137,
-0.8183783293,
0.3130661845,
0.0653549358,
-0.0576140694,
-0.7424170971,
-0.3847902417,
0.3525834084,
-0.1397628188,
0.1776230931,
-0.2224797308,
-0.3435079455,
0.0169431418,
-0.5589085817,
0.3253587186,
0.5808051825,
-0.4143541753,
0.4138042033,
0.6129052043,
-0.5846480131,
-0.6172227263,
-0.3791592121,
0.1205089986,
-0.4960116744,
-0.6352965832,
0.0983527005,
-0.4586915374,
-0.5683332682,
-0.2637031376,
0.0623681992,
0.0232776403,
0.4942524135,
0.4410998821,
0.3131115437,
0.2746575475,
-0.0307362676,
0.3192314506,
-0.2393833697,
0.2636328936,
0.0491439849,
0.538089335,
-0.233164072,
-0.3470516801,
-0.2336132675,
0.2798119187,
0.4776971042,
-0.029753102,
0.7623012662,
0.2392864078,
-0.1657085717,
0.1949124336,
-0.6949443817,
0.0245081224,
-0.5871611834,
0.1655513048,
-0.3020674288,
-1.2736856937,
0.618416369,
0.0049682036,
0.3194330931,
0.0558176041,
0.8764546514,
-0.0423840284,
1.1490352154,
0.5645099878,
-0.1918928921,
0.5269340277,
0.2775680423,
0.2938557863,
-0.5953440666,
-0.2172475159,
-0.5414795876,
0.0262643453,
-0.7692796588,
-0.0006500441,
0.3902021348,
-0.2561454773,
-0.5090887547,
0.087842606,
-0.1976448447,
0.5256761312,
0.555303812,
-0.1059009358,
0.4890186191,
0.0109175798,
-0.0708804801,
-0.1298520565,
-0.3634957075,
-0.7947387695,
1.3571479321,
0.7310676575,
1.1529176235,
0.2755190432,
0.7287511826,
0.2958036661,
0.3081899285,
-0.4716321826,
0.5224358439,
-0.1795725673,
-0.5443042517,
-0.2176759541,
-0.5782358646,
-1.0821906328,
0.297436744,
-0.1170850098,
-1.0438593626,
-0.0693841577,
0.4666321278,
-0.4856370986,
0.1461696178,
-0.9389704466,
0.6179195642,
-0.5469928384,
-0.4516187608,
-0.056149371,
-0.5750286579,
0.6958072186,
-0.2799254656,
0.385850966,
-0.2683575749,
-0.0987374783,
0.4798203707,
0.0261815544,
1.0767323971,
-0.1340779662,
-0.1744580567,
-0.1895112991,
0.1885783076,
0.5656409264,
0.1499982774,
-0.0340991318,
0.3590223789,
0.008276497,
-0.2540465891,
-0.2610942125,
1.1860971451,
-0.8198760748,
-0.9292402267,
-0.4570969939,
-0.6387947798,
-0.4252961278,
0.2876766026,
0.3080149293,
-0.0151628079,
-0.3396106362,
0.0566916429,
0.8404551744,
-0.6676315665,
0.5480322838,
0.4486479759,
-0.1056049392,
-0.2422110587,
0.7416415215,
0.0213513542,
0.3755586147,
0.1984927356,
0.5026233196,
-0.4231999516,
-0.6035062075,
-0.2779618502,
0.0793062076,
-0.7428398132,
-0.0117871519,
-0.9080345035,
0.0463983603,
-0.3391180336,
-0.1880311966,
-0.161296621,
-0.2773254216,
-0.3144358397,
-0.1012412459,
0.2086339891,
0.6509380937,
0.1667696983,
0.1925313622,
-0.7543625236,
0.0401157103,
0.4160183072,
0.5553592443,
-0.0584249683,
-0.3050366938,
-0.149245739,
-0.2720394135,
-0.2862328887,
-0.7537919283,
0.2102265805,
-0.2466386557,
0.7836658955,
0.463496685,
0.1734533608,
-0.029437976,
-0.5509724617,
0.7206118107,
0.3337765038,
-1.016366601,
0.3575816154,
-0.4747425318,
0.1444090605,
0.4685297608,
0.2384847999,
-0.5134007931,
-0.305675298,
-0.1790295243,
-0.8229334354,
0.4901604354,
0.2736948133,
0.3980384171,
0.0629994646,
0.1698299646,
0.3600402772,
0.2071579993,
-0.9195170403,
-0.3089970946,
0.043829985,
-0.0446340516,
-0.03194125,
-0.4716956019,
-0.2571406662,
0.0234929901,
0.3257448971,
-0.2272768915,
-0.0502114072,
-0.4077917933,
0.0062784301,
0.034647692,
0.7262595296,
0.7499426603,
0.4230290055,
-0.2159294188,
0.1856884062,
0.2201135159,
-0.4097829163,
0.3265089393,
-0.0154990545,
-0.4339111745,
-0.294662714,
0.1973008811,
0.7675927877,
0.3108974993,
-0.7654825449,
0.3903289437,
-0.2062055022,
0.2256509513,
-0.1474823207,
0.3697379827,
0.0991054401,
0.0791653097,
0.0729933456,
0.2105091214,
0.36258322,
-0.3011465371,
-0.1974927485,
0.6296772957,
0.0250487961,
-0.4736056924,
0.7969082594,
0.3935621977,
-0.440823555,
-0.1025458127,
0.1448803097,
-0.2278849185,
0.3936243057,
0.3810801506,
1.2136451006,
-0.3356384933,
0.0471556857,
0.0187491514,
0.3132665157,
0.1341103613,
0.0244632363,
0.164384976,
-0.6492295265,
-0.214432165,
-0.4111311138,
-0.4464524984,
0.2219017744,
-0.4219501019,
0.0994359553,
-0.7030871511,
-0.4780383706,
-0.249292925,
-0.3006781042,
-0.7445034385,
-0.0892051905,
0.1659401059,
0.7181875706,
-0.7228075266,
0.7381817102,
0.6736882925,
-0.0494549833,
-0.4101136029,
0.3284233809,
0.1499205679,
-0.576300621,
0.6996306777,
-0.0121737365,
-0.2641276717,
-0.3943154812,
-0.1876975596,
-0.8470656872,
0.8957774639,
0.6983183622,
-0.7724038363,
0.0173158366,
0.3518328667,
0.502438426,
-0.1488469243,
0.1717131436,
0.722311914,
0.3710902333,
-0.278003335,
-0.9917718172,
0.0749356374,
-0.0295380596,
0.3917672336,
-0.1696520001,
-0.6623382568,
0.7374933958,
-0.2601667047,
-0.057416968,
-0.0464624017,
0.1748287678,
0.465939194,
0.5400151014,
0.5735895038,
0.2417951077,
0.6036063433,
0.1041652039,
1.3798923492,
-0.4088662863,
0.1409434676,
0.9070289135,
-0.5305648446,
0.5773783922,
0.4485155344,
-0.2038796693,
0.1615821719,
0.5384640098,
0.5494945049,
0.7045849562,
0.1163367927,
-0.3995193839,
-0.3732880354,
-0.0504619181,
-0.4673902988,
0.1640075445,
0.0206791684,
-0.4293532968,
-0.0264097527,
-0.0865991414,
0.3598859906,
-0.0174631868,
-0.0007172818,
0.765057683,
0.2030722499,
-0.5237102509,
0.3645007312,
0.1685477048,
0.8615329266,
-0.5660799742,
0.3115759492,
-0.2831236124,
0.1007793248,
-0.0833249837,
-0.9822856188,
0.0887194872,
0.2303250879,
-0.2492052019,
-0.3111009896,
0.9122695327,
-0.0703538507,
-0.2600767612,
0.419115901,
0.3366590738,
-0.1137462109,
0.1273605227,
-0.4936215281,
0.3020174205,
-0.0300774612,
-0.5241025686,
0.9249830246,
-0.0596255772,
-0.2076230347,
0.9816978574,
0.8929089308,
-0.0237938929,
0.1285842955,
0.0943891108,
0.9379347563,
-0.4059531987,
-0.6375981569,
-1.05831182,
0.4283758402,
-0.0570167378,
-0.3560607135,
0.8286930323,
0.4686665535,
0.7906877398,
-0.2644942403,
1.1805711985,
0.3149420321,
0.4991301298,
-0.6128773689,
0.9644828439,
-0.2410706878,
0.6992037296,
-0.4279153049,
-0.7769018412,
-0.212479949,
0.3461301625,
-0.6062383652,
0.2464364022,
0.1858667135,
0.6288120747,
0.1542716622,
-0.232604146,
0.5678731799,
0.0373605117,
0.6497551203,
0.5559690595,
0.8431787491,
0.0989212394,
0.3310631812,
-0.1824078858,
-0.4288808703,
-0.2677363753,
-1.01113832,
-1.2513201237,
-0.291154623,
-0.1131276041,
-0.2486689985,
0.0796954781,
1.0767029524,
0.6488891244,
-0.8651063442,
-0.2974005938,
0.2181124687,
0.2673790455,
0.2782939672,
-0.1758797318,
0.0266329274,
-0.238037616,
-0.6080104113,
0.3250887692,
0.3526314795,
0.1065552384,
-0.228913337,
-0.3806659877,
0.3811832368,
0.3040362,
0.7499189973,
0.3226562142,
-0.9789866209,
-0.4881951213,
0.0977815911,
-0.0827712566,
-0.1198245585,
0.959741354,
-0.4275124073,
0.3631007373,
0.5236766338,
0.6665472984,
-0.0252843648,
-0.0120326709,
0.6693861485,
-0.5485166907,
0.0693472922,
0.0721552595,
0.3500651419,
0.311717242,
-0.7606418133,
0.1751755476,
0.0399276838,
-0.7263007164,
-0.8254956007,
0.4461216331,
-0.9366177917,
-0.1953735352,
1.336920023,
-0.2766258121,
0.324598968,
-0.3987390399,
-0.318310082,
-0.1819092035,
-0.6907218695,
0.9591460228,
0.5803864598,
-0.2079553604,
-0.2006621659,
-0.5756021738,
0.6907733679,
0.3324717581,
-1.0097119808,
0.1529574245,
0.4653052092,
0.7432512045,
-0.0580565929,
0.5923132896,
0.0504403971,
0.1745337993,
-0.5473191142,
-0.0556225292,
-0.1201764047,
-0.1542510092,
-0.541929841,
0.1634668112,
0.4523694515,
-0.0025131903
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11106v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11106v1 | From Intentions to Techniques: A Comprehensive Taxonomy and Challenges in Text Watermarking for Large Language Models | 2024-06-17T00:09:31 | 2024-06-17T00:09:31 | Harsh Nishant Lalai, Aashish Anantha Ramakrishnan, Raj Sanjay Shah, Dongwon Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | With the rapid growth of Large Language Models (LLMs), safeguarding textual
content against unauthorized use is crucial. Text watermarking offers a vital
solution, protecting both - LLM-generated and plain text sources. This paper
presents a unified overview of different perspectives behind designing
watermarking techniques, through a comprehensive survey of the research
literature. Our work has two key advantages, (1) we analyze research based on
the specific intentions behind different watermarking techniques, evaluation
datasets used, watermarking addition, and removal methods to construct a
cohesive taxonomy. (2) We highlight the gaps and open challenges in text
watermarking to promote research in protecting text authorship. This extensive
coverage and detailed analysis sets our work apart, offering valuable insights
into the evolving landscape of text watermarking in language models. | [
-0.0241802596,
-0.7426496744,
0.7868234515,
0.030228829,
-0.4943702519,
0.1622652709,
-0.0117213288,
-0.5226586461,
0.0608669631,
1.0943946838,
-0.3641218245,
-0.3844343722,
-0.9670155048,
0.1772072166,
-0.6465368271,
0.9696795344,
-0.2716116309,
-0.1812199056,
-0.3392719626,
-0.1232040524,
-0.2988570631,
-0.7560020685,
-0.546769917,
-0.1521816105,
0.5901215076,
0.1269188374,
0.4932885766,
0.7110156417,
0.672144115,
0.2480424345,
-0.3534210622,
0.0753799304,
-0.3779308796,
0.5312792659,
-0.1134892851,
-0.3267142177,
-0.1554163992,
0.0280785263,
0.5621199608,
0.2827211618,
0.1041531563,
0.0588141344,
0.2832794189,
0.3382691443,
-0.9300602674,
-0.1302746087,
-0.5927980542,
-0.0741430447,
-0.5774347782,
-0.3081988692,
-0.6512093544,
-0.0953247324,
-0.0158049669,
-0.5203744769,
-0.2559223175,
0.128146559,
0.7375939488,
0.0145610319,
-0.3959618211,
-0.6928720474,
-0.7946409583,
1.1253304482,
-0.729184866,
0.0787134916,
0.2624089718,
-0.0803927481,
-0.0596888587,
-0.8816241026,
-0.2421845794,
0.3199142516,
0.0174886733,
-0.000496232,
-0.3123078048,
-0.0211869739,
0.2287828326,
0.4097707272,
-0.2974966168,
0.1142827198,
0.1191334203,
-0.1977577209,
0.9071789384,
0.0820275098,
0.6558452845,
-0.069977656,
-0.572827816,
0.016244147,
-1.0112273693,
-0.0312201194,
0.5081241131,
0.2871942818,
0.1023901254,
0.5720967054,
0.1138834506,
0.5193037391,
-0.5133094788,
-0.1477359384,
-0.377092123,
-0.1668775678,
-0.1315191984,
-0.0863217264,
1.0181043148,
0.0647257715,
0.4593747854,
-0.258166343,
-0.3318469226,
-0.3748372793,
0.3273429573,
-0.7073974609,
0.0958095714,
0.109195374,
-0.4785684049,
-0.3222477138,
0.2429620326,
-0.655161798,
-0.6326532364,
-0.4715763032,
0.4858805537,
-0.2111471891,
-0.4520938993,
0.0900700986,
-0.4489709437,
0.3330051899,
0.2804775238,
-0.8659126163,
0.3407393694,
1.0187270641,
0.6610739231,
-0.5528076291,
-0.0593906119,
-0.2066002935,
0.4832575321,
-0.3865050077,
0.6247879863,
-0.715780139,
-0.3370073438,
0.1701517403,
-0.105064027,
0.1991284788,
-0.1378082484,
0.4035356343,
-0.821562469,
0.232302174,
-0.5051572919,
-0.8882623911,
-0.1081768274,
0.0471118875,
-0.6161826849,
0.8376290202,
-0.3017266691,
-0.8062233329,
0.3229513168,
-0.4193404913,
-0.3572626412,
0.262511909,
-0.0546623729,
-0.5084403753,
0.2507182658,
-0.0800553113,
0.5410951376,
-0.2848646343,
0.5221678615,
-0.0673471242,
0.0034351279,
0.4419007301,
-0.4354022145,
0.8426225781,
0.1130076349,
-0.3365437686,
0.1039305404,
-0.5227681398,
0.0221639834,
0.2434984893,
-0.0834863558,
-0.9046148062,
0.1317111552,
0.1999272853,
-0.2330991924,
0.4879704416,
-0.363437891,
-0.0304167736,
0.071335569,
0.5038027167,
0.7605243325,
0.3617444634,
0.4541426003,
-0.2870762348,
0.6644279957,
-0.4031426609,
0.3603114188,
-0.4173855782,
-0.7278744578,
-0.3342188597,
-0.4834063947,
0.3324065506,
0.1797038615,
-0.5214968324,
0.3914825022,
-0.204734534,
-0.4754577577,
-0.259765327,
0.4001297951,
0.6824241877,
-0.0642484874,
0.2030258924,
-0.3170149028,
-0.2389022559,
-0.9924624562,
-0.7602415681,
-0.0926355347,
0.1117576584,
0.2702409923,
0.6434134245,
0.0198513195,
1.0884540081,
-0.553401351,
-0.1787546277,
-0.3791113794,
0.2098781317,
-0.2147621065,
0.4689671695,
0.6177635193,
-1.1102039814,
-0.6369882822,
-0.1093957499,
-0.7003749013,
-0.3596622348,
0.0030497657,
-0.1395334899,
0.2651978731,
0.6851181388,
-0.522017777,
0.5525785089,
0.7115232348,
-0.3325420618,
0.3955427408,
0.1823849976,
0.1628754884,
-1.0986181498,
0.1503147334,
-0.0622864291,
0.0821463764,
-0.8619995117,
0.5237925649,
-0.0289603155,
0.0654908568,
-0.3090440929,
0.7458928823,
-0.6649005413,
0.3586449325,
-0.4589481056,
-0.2938950062,
0.2755663395,
0.0238057375,
0.2031584978,
0.5007637739,
0.4499652088,
-0.5127732158,
0.0759419501,
0.2457436919,
-0.3101480305,
0.5383376479,
-0.7580096126,
0.3362496793,
-0.1574676782,
-0.1690310538,
-1.0633026361,
-0.0622687116,
0.375222683,
-0.2761952579,
0.5477491021,
-0.4658353627,
-0.6505393982,
0.2836497128,
-0.4330480099,
0.2733959556,
0.3645867407,
-0.3947070539,
0.7154819965,
0.5614967346,
-0.5113958716,
-0.5172778368,
-0.709461391,
0.6515684128,
-0.4887852073,
-0.367772609,
0.679384172,
-0.0116403215,
-0.572650373,
-0.030224422,
-0.0053723068,
-0.4402376115,
0.391490221,
0.1479135603,
0.1874774247,
0.2177063674,
0.0352941751,
0.0682992414,
-0.2333664149,
0.0982265994,
-0.0687608868,
0.2811513543,
0.5185071826,
-0.2820721269,
-0.3211473227,
0.7051499486,
0.2304402292,
-0.2521559596,
0.7315735817,
0.1957362443,
-0.346780777,
-0.2032176554,
-0.5802485943,
-0.0912782401,
-0.4756970704,
0.0423287153,
-0.0123548172,
-1.0266958475,
0.305611819,
0.1227335483,
0.4135249853,
0.2671148479,
0.2271919399,
-0.0100427018,
0.4377523363,
0.8730106354,
-0.1629530489,
0.5862955451,
0.099838607,
0.3070932627,
-0.823770225,
-0.188203454,
-0.7101937532,
0.0381600112,
-0.3685801327,
-0.2640567422,
-0.0804679915,
0.0040828469,
-0.0033472949,
0.4550368488,
-0.805465281,
0.4279334247,
0.4226538241,
-0.1068516895,
0.4177142084,
0.1254795343,
0.2645289898,
-0.2510997653,
-0.2854621112,
-0.9624043703,
1.0746012926,
0.0688026026,
0.6908246279,
0.1276295036,
0.8276638389,
0.2810739577,
0.3746450543,
-0.6520383954,
0.699000895,
0.1469546258,
-1.0499471426,
-0.4570594132,
-0.3901004493,
-1.140381813,
0.2782071233,
-0.0832946524,
-0.8053507209,
-0.1256043762,
-0.0683224946,
0.0446222574,
0.4729936123,
-0.3715731502,
0.7394840121,
-0.3126824796,
-0.6520293355,
-0.0192716792,
-0.4831143916,
0.0465171933,
-0.3343646526,
0.4747524261,
-0.1059321538,
-0.4292947352,
0.9646722078,
-0.1637103111,
0.8524755836,
-0.2227872014,
-0.6760482192,
0.4289592505,
0.1931272745,
0.4869972765,
-0.169749558,
-0.0706749111,
0.1479605138,
0.0132678673,
-0.1785286814,
-0.1792215407,
0.4183074534,
-0.2234587669,
-0.6607531905,
-0.4931639731,
-0.255002737,
-0.1036435589,
0.5020487309,
0.1946711838,
0.46338588,
-0.3710063994,
0.4169293642,
0.8086977005,
-0.3816096783,
0.6854959726,
0.2998408675,
-0.150311023,
-0.4200703502,
0.7247363329,
0.0186756626,
0.2894560993,
0.6514766216,
0.2885656655,
-0.1970266253,
-0.9298115373,
0.0087053971,
0.1892744005,
-0.6999062896,
-0.182115078,
-0.6488547921,
-0.1066937894,
-0.2716759145,
-0.2494977713,
-0.1857745945,
-0.1565370858,
-0.3565210402,
0.197400704,
0.4742685556,
0.8236483932,
0.384057194,
0.4165074825,
-0.663520515,
0.3429994285,
0.3328580856,
0.2525925338,
0.1198382974,
-0.3871637881,
-0.0932428911,
-0.0421200246,
-0.2715969682,
-0.6196653247,
0.3071717322,
-0.0161465071,
0.514674902,
0.365047425,
0.1288873851,
0.2649821639,
-0.4481977522,
0.9242633581,
0.2087499797,
-0.9912474155,
0.4565061629,
-0.4208641648,
0.0299511496,
0.3788735569,
0.4294924438,
-0.6567826867,
-0.4158426523,
-0.4815890789,
-1.0882291794,
0.4440705478,
0.487003386,
0.4765879512,
0.2243611962,
0.4920711517,
0.2899646461,
0.3306802809,
-0.92996943,
-0.0965217724,
0.259047389,
-0.2398692071,
-0.0798191354,
-0.5501564741,
-0.314991802,
-0.030313028,
0.7627463937,
-0.0628502145,
0.0610525683,
0.1305239499,
-0.19285734,
0.2372416705,
0.4873982668,
0.3778482676,
0.3605627418,
0.3147311211,
0.0483237244,
-0.3003613353,
-0.4279565513,
0.2617804706,
-0.3187657595,
-0.4675890207,
-0.0287499763,
0.8025335073,
0.5349653363,
0.2946840823,
-0.4251481295,
0.6367109418,
0.0397006273,
-0.332798928,
-0.2201945186,
0.0643946528,
0.3034207225,
-0.214060083,
0.4757790267,
-0.3080747426,
0.0648116693,
-0.411236763,
-0.1860785037,
0.692920804,
-0.2800789177,
-0.4989076555,
0.5842853785,
0.0069701737,
-0.2284032255,
0.0724029317,
0.2841976285,
-0.4679042399,
0.5307183266,
0.2389031053,
1.0996804237,
-0.2157971859,
0.0899502933,
-0.0130000766,
0.3504197299,
-0.2711678445,
0.2337315679,
-0.1881284863,
-0.8095175028,
-0.1949588209,
-0.541878283,
-0.6977034807,
0.0672726929,
-0.6664786339,
0.0083558839,
-0.3879567385,
-0.1629819274,
0.3324391842,
-0.1949779093,
-0.208897531,
-0.0145833585,
0.0607955344,
0.557608068,
-0.6697970033,
0.4890432954,
0.6574019194,
0.1717009693,
-0.4274553061,
0.0753198564,
0.3277034163,
-0.5638971925,
0.2434781492,
0.0524214283,
-0.1617822647,
0.0716048628,
-0.9774823785,
-0.7568708658,
0.7233853936,
0.2925527096,
-0.3363430202,
0.2133713961,
0.3350573778,
0.4433918595,
-0.3063161373,
-0.3468643427,
0.3528337479,
0.6582787037,
-0.1895858049,
-0.2988871634,
0.186103195,
-0.2407686412,
0.0867584944,
0.3726826906,
-0.5253005028,
0.5539342165,
0.3017643094,
-0.3233045042,
0.2967252731,
0.0674768239,
0.2068894804,
0.2965040505,
0.2672500312,
0.3552840054,
0.3304430246,
-0.2200332284,
1.0012139082,
-0.15140073,
0.2766063511,
0.6881424785,
-0.453186959,
0.5906179547,
0.7877100706,
-0.1374141872,
0.2387287319,
0.2410909534,
-0.0777684897,
0.537379086,
0.2716876864,
-0.3906718493,
-0.2387209386,
-0.3065286279,
-0.2884999514,
0.2979462445,
0.3344526589,
-0.4370065033,
0.1032956913,
-0.1281666011,
0.2950221598,
0.2631266415,
-0.0967919976,
1.046200037,
0.4694642127,
-0.5354748964,
-0.1523723304,
-0.0605839752,
0.812341392,
-0.7347631454,
0.1994627267,
0.0706751272,
-0.0564183816,
-0.1632758826,
-0.9112834334,
0.2315223813,
0.1251876503,
-0.0480676852,
-0.9691073895,
0.9728543758,
-0.2343224734,
-0.1612708569,
0.4896808267,
0.4140097797,
0.0736009702,
-0.1548183411,
-0.3616086543,
0.3870203495,
-0.1717673391,
-0.4213793278,
0.286477834,
0.6138910055,
-0.0026569858,
0.5819535851,
0.5990437269,
0.1958936751,
-0.2160839587,
0.0578368381,
0.4277525842,
-0.725974977,
-0.3257579207,
-1.328570962,
0.303111732,
-0.2367858738,
-0.3248926401,
0.9994865656,
0.5087223053,
0.4903785586,
-0.0310230609,
0.9281392694,
-0.0593544878,
0.2162622809,
-0.5457777381,
1.0003385544,
-0.6044616103,
0.1274834275,
-0.9089779854,
-0.8290717602,
-0.5367410779,
0.1738114357,
-0.0234625507,
0.0923415795,
0.5337864757,
0.5440622568,
0.1756897122,
0.1410869211,
0.3107324243,
-0.2731109858,
0.6562789679,
0.1239776909,
1.0153530836,
-0.3723692894,
0.4099995792,
-0.1234539673,
-0.0820420533,
-0.0919832438,
-1.1592806578,
-0.836808145,
-0.8188750744,
-0.6583791375,
-0.0221767426,
-0.0284933057,
0.4475233555,
0.6207771301,
-0.7828160524,
-0.1981619,
-0.1126571894,
0.2042552382,
-0.1640497595,
-0.2045480013,
0.2832288742,
-0.0244790874,
-0.5651361942,
-0.0167826973,
0.5313063264,
0.5015497208,
-0.1729736328,
-0.000676307,
-0.0219418127,
0.3929476738,
0.5683213472,
0.1427715868,
-0.4510202706,
-0.2349870205,
-0.1353145689,
-0.2750257254,
-0.1742460281,
1.0573848486,
-0.067778483,
0.2418989688,
0.4736855924,
0.6173374057,
0.2606446445,
-0.1557853073,
0.521086812,
-0.6073620915,
-0.056127727,
0.3101373911,
0.3588142693,
0.4300083518,
-0.3893159628,
0.4327946901,
0.1984834522,
-0.3839003742,
-1.046906352,
0.2438175827,
-0.8918716311,
-0.4382353723,
1.3052403927,
-0.2703785896,
-0.1417166591,
-0.3830700219,
-0.1951677799,
0.0092805736,
-0.1892676055,
0.669936657,
1.1257212162,
0.4356510639,
-0.2202512324,
-0.4864890277,
0.5761002898,
0.1805101335,
-0.9306936264,
0.4542410076,
0.2322886735,
0.279361099,
0.0731991678,
0.5809453726,
-0.5269386768,
-0.0147571331,
-0.2941761613,
0.3664088845,
0.120276466,
-0.351392895,
-0.1987392455,
0.2690842748,
0.1965555251,
0.2256868333
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11102v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11102v1 | Grading Massive Open Online Courses Using Large Language Models | 2024-06-16T23:42:11 | 2024-06-16T23:42:11 | Shahriar Golchin, Nikhil Garuda, Christopher Impey, Matthew Wenger | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Massive open online courses (MOOCs) offer free education globally to anyone
with a computer and internet access. Despite this democratization of learning,
the massive enrollment in these courses makes it impractical for one instructor
to assess every student's writing assignment. As a result, peer grading, often
guided by a straightforward rubric, is the method of choice. While convenient,
peer grading often falls short in terms of reliability and validity. In this
study, we explore the feasibility of using large language models (LLMs) to
replace peer grading in MOOCs. Specifically, we use two LLMs, GPT-4 and
GPT-3.5, across three MOOCs: Introductory Astronomy, Astrobiology, and the
History and Philosophy of Astronomy. To instruct LLMs, we use three different
prompts based on the zero-shot chain-of-thought (ZCoT) prompting technique: (1)
ZCoT with instructor-provided correct answers, (2) ZCoT with both
instructor-provided correct answers and rubrics, and (3) ZCoT with
instructor-provided correct answers and LLM-generated rubrics. Tested on 18
settings, our results show that ZCoT, when augmented with instructor-provided
correct answers and rubrics, produces grades that are more aligned with those
assigned by instructors compared to peer grading. Finally, our findings
indicate a promising potential for automated grading systems in MOOCs,
especially in subjects with well-defined rubrics, to improve the learning
experience for millions of online learners worldwide. | [
-0.1864946187,
-0.895410955,
0.8903315663,
-0.1547543406,
-0.1555587351,
0.1246795878,
-0.6258291602,
-0.446692884,
0.0624291301,
0.3944585621,
-0.3452810049,
-0.6838048697,
-0.4271476865,
-0.0278366022,
-0.2164437771,
1.509860158,
-0.2743259072,
0.3518278599,
-0.3690691292,
0.024798559,
-0.2499555051,
-0.5437138677,
-0.5311847925,
-0.4168277383,
0.6454777718,
0.5336741209,
0.6344240308,
0.5643808842,
0.6896663904,
0.2446403652,
-0.1914376318,
0.2219662964,
-0.5084005594,
-0.0840656236,
-0.3257138729,
-0.2887171805,
-0.7201115489,
0.1912671924,
0.6447839737,
0.826536417,
-0.2325166911,
0.3955428898,
0.0344453529,
0.3720048666,
-0.4803380966,
0.1508100033,
-0.5133391619,
0.123621434,
-0.0813465565,
-0.0632497072,
-0.6779945493,
-0.5993813872,
0.1145593002,
-0.6916347742,
0.0977428854,
-0.1631156802,
0.7813148499,
-0.1071343645,
-0.2698342204,
-0.6198888421,
-0.7139468193,
0.7999302745,
-0.5428631902,
0.0797393396,
0.4740547836,
0.3722661436,
0.135422945,
-0.596077621,
-0.5827932358,
-0.487164557,
0.1858732402,
0.2527031302,
0.4590359926,
0.254335165,
0.3716665804,
0.8609367013,
-0.3459509313,
0.5007977486,
-0.3706817031,
-0.2038282603,
0.2898409069,
0.3584569395,
0.1074460447,
0.0679937974,
-0.3513115942,
-0.1220649481,
-0.8821474314,
-0.0177315157,
0.7151707411,
0.4975370765,
0.0625586063,
0.6293362379,
-0.1237229258,
0.5629606843,
0.0028708864,
-0.2759415209,
0.0073280684,
-0.2667341232,
-0.0836887062,
-0.2133139968,
0.7656334639,
0.5668651462,
0.3789753914,
0.1142600253,
-0.1216512099,
-0.0063122734,
0.1508253068,
-0.7937537432,
-0.2048884928,
0.2061454505,
-0.1431560218,
-0.3495430052,
0.0109404856,
-0.776578784,
-0.3380861878,
-0.2546969056,
0.7606599927,
-0.1173857003,
0.2915552855,
0.0057844939,
0.0932081416,
0.0660512,
0.9870539904,
-0.6713876724,
0.2663241923,
0.6142729521,
1.2226746082,
-0.016020827,
-0.2492232919,
-0.6024374366,
0.0023153673,
-0.2993182838,
0.5631765127,
-0.5644745827,
-0.1493944377,
0.2132224441,
-0.3456961811,
0.2679337859,
-0.2440503389,
0.4187182486,
-0.4842817187,
0.7969152331,
-0.198617056,
-0.8461788893,
-0.1550873667,
0.5181735158,
-0.3908257782,
0.8967555165,
0.0470242985,
-0.3112047017,
0.1302529126,
-0.7304307818,
-0.0573941804,
0.2743575573,
0.079996258,
-0.2328510284,
-0.1983530074,
0.0735117719,
0.5978461504,
-0.3424274325,
0.298715353,
-0.1787153035,
-0.4485836625,
0.1982425898,
-0.1430557966,
0.5323001742,
0.1263352633,
-0.471280992,
0.1086402237,
-0.5215978622,
0.2509761751,
-0.0761048719,
-0.4305568337,
-0.2942307889,
0.0241109524,
-0.1533768475,
0.2513596416,
0.147903949,
-0.7406522036,
0.561308682,
-0.0831836164,
0.3364136815,
1.2198694944,
-0.1385552883,
0.2835852802,
-0.3632842302,
0.473815918,
-0.277340889,
0.1983110607,
-0.2336084247,
-0.7122612596,
-0.9867393374,
-0.2330932617,
0.1632217765,
0.2875624299,
-0.6458535194,
0.2329666615,
-0.3432911932,
-0.7539904118,
-0.2685889304,
0.388918668,
0.6201341748,
0.3178913891,
0.4410340786,
-0.3359174728,
0.0410279632,
-0.2782235444,
-0.1061277911,
-0.266779542,
-0.2640953362,
0.3176153004,
0.519626677,
-0.0219194889,
0.5627670288,
-0.7018416524,
-0.4995208681,
-0.0955532193,
0.1286849082,
0.1603922546,
0.3087716401,
0.1388286799,
-0.1451409757,
-0.5755496025,
0.241238609,
-0.5313951969,
-0.2930797637,
0.0281428322,
-0.1177598089,
0.0124471588,
0.2678649127,
-0.2867026925,
0.0801113099,
0.5888261795,
-0.2834386826,
0.6639835238,
-0.2086244673,
0.2184451073,
-0.7557014823,
-0.0627076179,
0.0260355193,
-0.2984609306,
-0.6184957623,
0.5438485146,
0.1620649844,
-0.2006628811,
-0.4756156504,
0.576228559,
-0.4054979682,
0.1029444486,
-0.2400627732,
0.3651321232,
-0.0308315493,
0.5553282499,
-0.0568551272,
0.6027260423,
0.4689629674,
-0.5483097434,
0.2665433884,
0.1263334453,
-0.5920671225,
0.6264213324,
-0.4466607273,
0.2787619829,
-0.1236472651,
0.6108042598,
-0.9637078047,
-0.1536849588,
0.1393550634,
-0.2954592407,
-0.003359484,
-0.2064498961,
-0.3416311145,
-0.2245772034,
-0.3138651848,
0.3397962451,
0.4811295867,
-0.6400886774,
0.3754430115,
-0.1299857348,
-0.0697496161,
-0.4031212032,
-0.469830513,
-0.089813821,
0.1033041477,
-0.3190285265,
0.0369458981,
-0.3080111742,
-0.2411294878,
-0.1980540901,
0.1840513051,
-0.0182830859,
-0.0491237454,
0.4325349629,
0.4991290271,
-0.2400841713,
0.2557790577,
-0.2156959623,
0.0619011149,
-0.0428824089,
-0.6488758922,
0.5595732331,
-0.1883705854,
-0.5246047378,
-0.329624474,
0.2418580651,
0.9640115499,
-0.2641151249,
0.8061023355,
0.3726790249,
-0.2768303454,
-0.2466069758,
-0.7540187836,
-0.1152844205,
-0.4700574875,
0.0859538987,
0.1181285977,
-1.1720273495,
0.5491087437,
0.2170378864,
0.4380536079,
0.1003689766,
0.8091027737,
0.0380013101,
0.7192650437,
0.3983772099,
0.2864764333,
0.4970071912,
-0.2499156296,
0.3162299395,
-0.798679173,
-0.3193829656,
-0.5998786092,
-0.2020702958,
-0.3875237405,
-0.7353550196,
0.3024659455,
-0.1520527154,
-0.2253340036,
0.1202683374,
-0.1419961452,
0.8712568879,
0.504624486,
0.2556317151,
0.5168120861,
0.2025664449,
-0.2363439947,
0.1054205671,
-0.2234568894,
-0.7027665377,
1.2282568216,
0.2618439496,
0.7659803629,
0.1969721615,
0.3748905659,
0.2305910587,
0.7398843765,
-0.9495257139,
0.7093160748,
-0.0229494143,
-0.7414055467,
-0.3592661321,
-0.7728572488,
-0.2879109085,
0.2922372222,
-0.2153699398,
-0.6235020757,
-0.3704201281,
0.2020104975,
-0.3368139565,
0.7793952823,
-0.6342419982,
0.7323207259,
-0.1307593286,
-0.6166726351,
-0.2616173029,
-0.3336666822,
0.3238751292,
-0.2880290449,
0.3248697817,
-0.0864711478,
-0.0251637138,
0.7215658426,
-0.6052752137,
0.6732150316,
-0.024641078,
-0.3476672173,
0.4924856424,
0.256999433,
0.4306642413,
-0.2052908093,
-0.2132564187,
0.2844999731,
-0.340483129,
-0.4091896713,
-0.6243472099,
0.972217977,
-0.964677453,
-0.5725717545,
-0.5185520053,
-0.4219673872,
-0.0359721854,
0.074366264,
0.111575909,
0.5921671391,
0.08322341,
0.0467083566,
0.3903916776,
-0.3352003694,
0.2311753184,
0.7038203478,
-0.492967099,
-0.5730749369,
0.9565030336,
0.2820585668,
0.906871736,
0.4009122252,
0.4782769978,
-0.1660980731,
-0.393871069,
-0.5102750063,
0.2763908505,
-1.0663603544,
-0.25829193,
-0.6382396221,
0.0546472408,
-0.3096789122,
-0.4814713597,
-0.0725144744,
-0.4952919781,
-0.0878058299,
-0.2920036614,
0.2641243339,
0.9527853131,
0.1095591336,
0.4991844296,
-0.6557356715,
-0.1566948444,
0.4776798785,
0.6192031503,
0.2046681494,
-0.808803916,
-0.1690222174,
0.0681397691,
-0.5147331953,
-0.4987032712,
-0.0792240724,
0.3315458894,
0.1157757342,
0.5162356496,
-0.1111077815,
0.7721480727,
-0.6743344069,
1.0244662762,
0.3664574921,
-1.1832716465,
0.3582368493,
-0.5027589202,
0.1377796531,
0.4256078899,
0.5602262616,
-0.7928498387,
-0.8794154525,
-0.2127289623,
-0.6677126884,
0.7752048373,
0.0949576348,
0.3247352242,
-0.0896042883,
0.2948448956,
0.3129169345,
0.0981852934,
-1.1313903332,
-0.1188268661,
-0.072002247,
-0.1183431819,
-0.303755641,
-0.230291456,
0.0647559538,
-0.1603770554,
0.7853748202,
-0.1509917229,
-0.0791336223,
0.0729449466,
-0.0286476873,
-0.4332583249,
0.5108634233,
0.8789880276,
0.8387008905,
-0.2937806249,
-0.0016893958,
0.1711046845,
-0.5717189908,
0.2948154211,
-0.5952977538,
-0.3278567493,
-0.1122829393,
0.2924152017,
0.446459204,
-0.0500508994,
-0.8338779807,
0.6394400597,
-0.0038850172,
-0.2433713377,
-0.1608951688,
0.013739557,
-0.2261187881,
-0.0980656222,
0.2792991698,
-0.1707656533,
-0.1699137837,
-0.6371381283,
-0.2964304984,
0.2999829948,
-0.3869141638,
-0.1449124664,
0.4073896408,
0.5020751357,
-0.2478727251,
0.6395116448,
0.0458703116,
-0.6382786632,
0.3115401864,
0.4723474383,
0.7912161946,
-0.1603793651,
0.4682378769,
0.5129909515,
0.3365307152,
-0.3019529581,
-0.1613807529,
-0.1703949273,
-0.3250524104,
-0.6970320344,
-0.8219546676,
-1.1024274826,
0.0017949587,
-0.5015038252,
0.3442302346,
-0.9705625772,
-0.114270106,
-0.2226895243,
-0.0170862414,
-0.4394432306,
0.1495788693,
0.2764024138,
0.5012763143,
-0.8998448253,
0.519130528,
0.9380728602,
-0.3619854152,
-0.8409869671,
-0.1883908212,
0.1826941818,
-0.5260391235,
0.4414279163,
0.4167060554,
-0.0712755322,
-0.1189951971,
-0.4670618176,
-0.6213479638,
0.9480460286,
0.0413542874,
-0.5360158682,
-0.1015215889,
0.0631724373,
0.6668412685,
-0.0201125201,
0.8623936176,
-0.1914691776,
0.3344163895,
0.047844585,
-1.0893726349,
-0.1470877081,
-0.1053817272,
-0.220918119,
0.5007932782,
-0.6934093833,
1.0355927944,
-0.2693962455,
-0.1219328418,
0.1585355997,
0.4619207382,
-0.0600988641,
0.2177603692,
0.2926194668,
0.7917173505,
0.7897275686,
-0.2882837355,
0.906711936,
-0.0698100328,
0.6876641512,
0.829328537,
-0.3984047472,
0.8785521984,
0.3454600275,
-0.2977962792,
0.9140235186,
0.2640638351,
0.081456244,
-0.0670545772,
0.2908062339,
-0.290579319,
-0.4492045641,
-0.2227270603,
-0.4185317755,
0.3527952731,
0.2579010129,
-0.2164605111,
-0.3604636192,
0.2376635671,
0.0977830887,
0.2747451663,
-0.8285281658,
0.5328090787,
-0.0614179634,
-0.860868752,
0.2419102788,
0.1661101431,
0.6115990281,
-0.7457494736,
0.0020358877,
-0.3942278326,
0.4557065368,
-0.2624499202,
-0.8899086118,
-0.3580394685,
0.6146692634,
-0.0485277921,
-0.5875493288,
0.051030606,
-0.4616887867,
-0.6218594909,
0.0866945386,
0.2241324335,
0.2342677265,
0.0987446606,
-0.0740590766,
-0.1092880443,
-0.158731699,
0.0618012585,
0.4342105985,
0.3053591847,
0.0107466206,
0.8882420063,
0.856751442,
0.0777792409,
0.1505757123,
0.0386786684,
0.7201891541,
-0.4955351055,
-0.5746252537,
-0.8544920683,
0.2766506076,
0.0613800436,
-0.3817086518,
1.0650039911,
0.3065005541,
1.2563678026,
-0.0862492397,
0.4314783812,
-0.0918491632,
0.4255216718,
-0.7004801631,
0.5077894926,
-0.4688691795,
0.1828009039,
-0.6000604033,
-1.1190135479,
-0.3700554073,
0.534999907,
-0.5265461206,
0.0785773844,
0.9459571242,
0.5550025702,
0.2635593712,
-0.0648785159,
0.3620209694,
-0.1349142492,
0.5816870928,
0.7041579485,
1.1061438322,
-0.2560530305,
0.7931716442,
-0.3046984076,
-0.247353211,
-0.2933593094,
-0.7742086649,
-1.1747291088,
-0.2087053508,
-0.5023550391,
-0.5030055642,
0.087424688,
1.224796772,
0.2255481333,
-0.7441655993,
-0.3717358112,
0.199450478,
0.0724886134,
-0.0623535961,
-0.2413666546,
0.1236432493,
-0.1570151448,
-0.767627418,
-0.1013593152,
0.3589264154,
0.1186599284,
-0.3584576547,
-0.0702070147,
-0.051886905,
-0.1407485157,
0.6929883957,
0.0733811185,
-0.9424039125,
-0.5243902802,
0.0004571377,
-0.342600286,
-0.0222269949,
0.9491829276,
-0.5023130178,
0.5071482062,
0.4917693138,
0.3955230117,
0.1046692729,
0.1607279778,
0.3130350709,
-0.4668618441,
-0.1659737676,
0.2618896663,
0.2246049494,
0.432145834,
-0.1096468121,
0.2448707819,
0.2154371887,
-0.7880598307,
-0.8398769498,
0.0414883047,
-0.9060353637,
-0.0229461659,
1.207357645,
-0.4434177876,
-0.0250004325,
0.1002257839,
-0.1998649836,
-0.0862087309,
-0.170134306,
0.7963920236,
1.1843173504,
0.3511859179,
0.1473230422,
-0.370629698,
-0.0622838698,
0.4186978936,
-0.8059484363,
0.1175658405,
0.7196166515,
0.2379020005,
0.3290430605,
0.4907811284,
-0.0170026459,
0.3337831795,
-0.3572038412,
0.1179329306,
-0.2095430046,
-0.5541968942,
-0.3285994828,
0.2520158291,
0.1261541545,
0.107466042
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15477v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15477v1 | CrisisSense-LLM: Instruction Fine-Tuned Large Language Model for Multi-label Social Media Text Classification in Disaster Informatics | 2024-06-16T23:01:10 | 2024-06-16T23:01:10 | Kai Yin, Chengkai Liu, Ali Mostafavi, Xia Hu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | In the field of crisis/disaster informatics, social media is increasingly
being used for improving situational awareness to inform response and relief
efforts. Efficient and accurate text classification tools have been a focal
area of investigation in crisis informatics. However, current methods mostly
rely on single-label text classification models, which fails to capture
different insights embedded in dynamic and multifaceted disaster-related social
media data. This study introduces a novel approach to disaster text
classification by enhancing a pre-trained Large Language Model (LLM) through
instruction fine-tuning targeted for multi-label classification of
disaster-related tweets. Our methodology involves creating a comprehensive
instruction dataset from disaster-related tweets, which is then used to
fine-tune an open-source LLM, thereby embedding it with disaster-specific
knowledge. This fine-tuned model can classify multiple aspects of
disaster-related information simultaneously, such as the type of event,
informativeness, and involvement of human aid, significantly improving the
utility of social media data for situational awareness in disasters. The
results demonstrate that this approach enhances the categorization of critical
information from social media posts, thereby facilitating a more effective
deployment for situational awareness during emergencies. This research paves
the way for more advanced, adaptable, and robust disaster management tools,
leveraging the capabilities of LLMs to improve real-time situational awareness
and response strategies in disaster scenarios. | [
-0.2391689569,
-0.7201589942,
0.3630447686,
0.5491187572,
-0.2329220325,
0.6581006646,
-0.3530855179,
-0.2276452184,
0.2650880814,
0.330788523,
-0.5671025515,
-0.8747933507,
-0.6567043662,
0.0280126929,
-0.4437769055,
1.087443471,
0.005850337,
-0.069843024,
0.3502022326,
0.1112752035,
-0.191236347,
-0.3067513108,
-0.7367060781,
0.1389452219,
0.6585671902,
0.8219152689,
0.3667095006,
0.2811208665,
0.708317697,
0.2989194989,
0.0657215714,
0.2721943557,
-0.8679651022,
-0.0611518435,
-0.1791216582,
-0.1126725152,
-0.2590307891,
-0.2030940652,
0.4415072799,
0.1313459277,
-0.3821053207,
0.3602052927,
0.3412576616,
0.237853229,
-0.8089535832,
0.1516686231,
-0.5651367903,
-0.1413025856,
0.0604129992,
-0.6311686039,
-0.382224977,
-0.6648879051,
0.1619777977,
-0.3937602043,
0.4062095284,
-0.0737469718,
0.4318743348,
0.387778461,
-0.4289714098,
-0.2478103638,
-0.9282825589,
0.6509058475,
-0.3585814536,
0.3140217364,
0.1324171424,
0.4086968005,
0.0169735234,
-0.7463091612,
-0.3362700045,
0.3980383277,
0.4693314731,
0.1103843227,
0.2258808315,
0.3107106984,
-0.0505516715,
0.0630088672,
-0.4147891402,
0.3655398786,
-0.2899573743,
-0.1851055026,
0.7338303924,
0.3234080672,
0.3513804078,
-0.4465244114,
-0.4660801888,
-0.1165031716,
-0.6124805212,
-0.1998420358,
-0.2287051976,
0.5597409606,
-0.5080868602,
0.2623826563,
-0.1147929057,
0.2683256269,
-0.2370370328,
-0.5297951102,
0.138518244,
-0.098313719,
-0.2838692665,
0.5616800189,
0.9128986597,
0.6404911876,
0.129898876,
0.0870017186,
-0.13902165,
-0.1640673876,
0.4357833266,
-1.0778936148,
-0.1489336342,
-0.0635160133,
-0.4006673098,
-0.5828012228,
0.0094859283,
-0.9129486084,
-0.9906569719,
-0.1482630074,
0.4447313249,
-0.2940660417,
-0.1853112429,
0.2699017227,
0.2581405044,
-0.0665445477,
0.6290022135,
-0.5097558498,
-0.1665186286,
0.6515176296,
1.0417208672,
0.3377415538,
-0.0652544796,
-0.2826198041,
0.3205985129,
-0.0310857873,
0.9287470579,
-0.5300780535,
-0.2671763301,
0.4479156733,
0.0770800784,
-0.1009008288,
-0.1420610696,
0.8779082298,
-0.4951209128,
-0.2177441716,
-0.1508394331,
-0.4844588339,
-0.2564776838,
0.3866398036,
-0.487675339,
0.7695126534,
-0.0819070339,
-1.0110046864,
0.2194525301,
-0.4810667932,
-0.4893967807,
0.0632290021,
0.0132764243,
-0.5536228418,
0.0707019866,
0.1686317623,
0.9919393063,
-0.5513358712,
0.4082828462,
-0.7401912808,
-0.2660033405,
0.0836158246,
-0.5583122969,
0.374969244,
0.0448634848,
-0.0268993564,
0.121117264,
-0.8274101615,
0.0017920978,
0.1672101319,
-0.6823263764,
-0.512268126,
0.2093367726,
0.3231214285,
0.201763019,
0.2564385831,
-0.3765208423,
0.1818801761,
-0.2459921092,
0.2164964825,
0.6276734471,
0.3492980599,
0.3350957036,
-0.2671978176,
0.168134138,
-0.0345264636,
0.4257417023,
-0.1859757602,
-0.2714424431,
-0.7718134522,
-0.1020365953,
0.0523959287,
1.0743246078,
-0.7727962732,
0.3551858962,
-0.337156415,
-0.5775085688,
-0.6453701258,
0.0923912823,
0.1069930941,
0.5006670356,
0.6138930321,
0.4093915224,
-0.9540982842,
-0.6723034382,
0.002144373,
-0.0190699771,
0.0663404837,
0.1893866211,
0.2019626647,
-0.425693661,
0.4181547463,
-0.689766407,
-0.0752212927,
-0.5619417429,
0.337090224,
-0.005110879,
0.0733854771,
0.3419987559,
-0.8578050733,
-0.4475444853,
0.0576274917,
-0.7324255705,
-0.2498522848,
-0.2131922096,
0.0638460964,
-0.0755028203,
0.5115924478,
-0.2126633376,
0.3653919101,
0.1920072287,
-0.1460753381,
0.4011022747,
-0.0527944565,
0.4466325641,
-1.5995993614,
-0.4202413857,
0.1838359088,
0.0195786376,
-0.8225283027,
-0.2315461189,
0.3889282644,
-0.0785595998,
-0.5225663185,
0.4437226951,
-0.3859242499,
0.3566383123,
-0.3380194902,
0.1653640866,
-0.2802537978,
-0.0650651455,
-0.1095532551,
0.3760963082,
0.7163898945,
-0.6447988749,
0.4439079165,
0.1584180444,
-0.4233803451,
0.534096241,
-0.2133418471,
-0.0452744886,
-0.3288578093,
0.1665787995,
-1.0292414427,
-0.5881320834,
0.2357624173,
-0.1536699682,
0.535128653,
-0.174068734,
-0.60329777,
-0.5604442954,
-0.3671703041,
0.0072517018,
0.1799558997,
-0.480242461,
0.5310397148,
0.411814183,
-0.3310661912,
-0.4973915815,
-0.5293135643,
0.1632803231,
-0.5951669216,
-0.3645464182,
0.1477395445,
-0.1320562512,
0.0435437635,
-0.1414546221,
-0.1716113091,
-0.2708030045,
0.3664610088,
0.323420763,
0.1754347831,
-0.2375011742,
0.4698713422,
0.3220151961,
0.0735387355,
-0.0950700939,
0.0539010577,
0.5785636902,
-0.0253968537,
-0.090485774,
-0.6720909476,
0.2889772654,
0.5631346107,
-0.0374336727,
1.0839424133,
0.76358217,
-0.5493623018,
-0.209848091,
-0.7352378964,
-0.1919177026,
-0.4828575253,
0.4282784164,
0.0600983687,
-1.0960284472,
0.374394089,
-0.5683894157,
0.0663462356,
0.2713064849,
0.3019938767,
-0.265863359,
0.7232542634,
0.6900725961,
-0.5422557592,
0.5269531012,
-0.3168247342,
0.2162176669,
-0.4094492197,
-0.2676078081,
-0.5530139804,
-0.3081054389,
-0.3532001078,
-0.4318746328,
0.4110413492,
0.175451979,
-0.4651830196,
-0.0019144249,
-0.4139876664,
0.5651805997,
-0.0219448693,
0.3881120682,
0.0809278861,
0.0638854429,
0.5988646746,
0.0496139154,
-0.6786355972,
-0.6503096819,
0.7797750831,
0.3760668635,
0.9572825432,
0.0998493955,
1.1497118473,
0.3279375136,
0.7809572816,
-0.7018263936,
0.4543403387,
-0.1286996305,
-0.3882987797,
-0.3081029952,
-0.4143047929,
-0.6827502847,
-0.0938265249,
-0.4989108443,
-0.676210165,
0.0164017864,
0.0753749609,
-0.6580882072,
0.2331517637,
-0.8706236482,
0.7358983159,
-0.2962908149,
0.1909259111,
-0.4071683288,
-0.5389528871,
0.3387280703,
-0.4017893672,
0.5773810744,
-0.1131067872,
-0.3291848898,
0.6327940822,
-0.0647558868,
1.412411809,
-0.0349465869,
-0.2508356571,
0.4794076383,
-0.0273577049,
0.5250888467,
0.293640554,
0.1362267286,
-0.119732976,
-0.3495496809,
0.0009474543,
-0.4782499373,
0.8255655766,
-0.7420722842,
-0.4629704058,
0.102822639,
-0.420188576,
-0.1751694679,
0.2532832026,
0.3166439533,
0.5120908618,
-0.3451928794,
0.2028540373,
0.9829559326,
-0.448096931,
0.5026398897,
0.6578909159,
0.116336748,
-0.5318061709,
1.0335446596,
0.2891262472,
-0.0384927206,
0.8293350935,
0.2712349892,
-0.0564642139,
-0.482940197,
-0.0590539537,
0.2227992713,
-0.7872847319,
-0.7943245769,
-0.8709522486,
-0.461253345,
-0.2620874941,
-0.3772545755,
-0.3031022251,
-0.1985972971,
-0.6289360523,
-0.2324460149,
0.4879391789,
0.6553212404,
0.0223603547,
0.553042233,
-1.1708546877,
0.3198654652,
-0.0290753879,
0.4375607371,
-0.05549578,
-0.534530282,
-0.3741880953,
0.0675453991,
-0.3665429354,
-1.2184948921,
0.0582276173,
0.5032152534,
0.2562277615,
0.7696278095,
0.4775814712,
0.6330108643,
-0.6447392702,
0.3255542219,
0.2749364078,
-0.5700067878,
0.8012929559,
-0.4667650163,
0.1164972559,
0.5624353886,
0.7169826031,
-0.5340514183,
-0.4375025928,
-0.4945381284,
-0.7995009422,
0.7635219097,
-0.0514779165,
0.2121324688,
-0.0680631697,
0.1646467745,
-0.2741730213,
0.0895932987,
-0.4006637335,
-0.2058421969,
-0.2310193628,
-0.4940930009,
-0.1424450427,
-0.7057429552,
-0.0642457753,
-0.1786454469,
0.5592224598,
0.035131909,
-0.0397215001,
-0.1593575478,
0.0247365218,
0.0842641965,
0.4191116095,
0.6673398614,
0.1971153766,
-0.1146278977,
0.2842565179,
0.4851169288,
-0.7407674789,
0.313075453,
0.3201531172,
0.0187153965,
-0.1559986919,
0.5643128753,
0.7254075408,
0.8161723614,
-0.5391041636,
0.4538086653,
-0.1995436549,
-0.0151604759,
-0.1532825083,
0.1908183992,
0.3178387284,
0.6125331521,
0.4102780819,
-0.119274959,
0.3959857225,
-0.2840532362,
0.0724523365,
-0.0499114431,
0.0071141766,
-0.3509393334,
0.23043558,
0.3247171044,
-0.4812847674,
0.174482733,
-0.2195039541,
-0.4423290193,
0.4610195756,
0.4440117478,
1.0388966799,
-1.2222551107,
0.5151675344,
0.5465531945,
0.4983105659,
-0.3866048157,
0.5957725644,
0.0841675922,
-0.8184041977,
-0.2374605834,
-0.8412730694,
-0.0263831504,
0.5766788721,
-0.4500800073,
0.4072740376,
-0.7040325403,
-0.1821787208,
0.0046376949,
-0.481898725,
-0.6102485061,
0.2891121805,
0.2173502296,
0.9284999967,
-0.9446403384,
0.3592457473,
0.9038624763,
0.0826023445,
-0.8383165002,
0.3028672636,
0.0346294567,
-0.3956638277,
0.3013247252,
0.4792905748,
0.1208619922,
0.1029026285,
-0.7283605933,
-1.0869511366,
0.7856020331,
0.3919590116,
-0.755307138,
0.0124252103,
0.2947016954,
0.5544554591,
-0.2767893672,
-0.1026565582,
0.298799634,
0.4103844464,
0.0865909308,
-0.8501688242,
-0.0187307708,
0.0632871464,
-0.0577827394,
0.491112709,
-0.5799190402,
0.0340838358,
-0.4351508319,
-0.4538196027,
-0.4595279098,
0.7897789478,
0.0353020504,
0.65073663,
0.370328486,
0.411149025,
0.8561505675,
-0.0789130703,
0.8039798141,
-0.2877689302,
0.5259132981,
1.1099183559,
0.080958724,
0.8009377718,
-0.067511104,
0.0818419233,
0.2028721124,
0.8219351172,
0.2685295045,
0.6151985526,
-0.0144668594,
-0.5513280034,
-0.4728989303,
-0.179013446,
-0.1438677162,
0.4091289341,
0.8864703774,
-0.4347145557,
-0.5286073089,
0.3608380854,
0.0129068624,
-0.2569085658,
-0.555500567,
0.7743296623,
0.2569336295,
0.0494567826,
0.7777843475,
0.0036596332,
0.399905324,
-0.1912428588,
0.1435074359,
0.0645547882,
0.1075127125,
-0.3632872701,
-0.9279499054,
0.455160886,
0.1948859245,
-0.2986810803,
0.1161674336,
0.7880890369,
-0.4411471486,
-0.6935663223,
0.2657043636,
0.1973284334,
-0.016249327,
-0.1062677503,
-0.6637149453,
0.2831665576,
-0.1048892513,
-0.3244506419,
0.0722176656,
0.8813855052,
-0.0877991319,
0.9064253569,
0.1640745699,
-0.1435351819,
-0.0378169864,
0.4631535113,
0.9692311287,
-0.6472213268,
-0.5125073791,
-0.9802817702,
0.5062111616,
-0.327269882,
-0.1126045138,
0.5453563929,
0.4861870408,
0.4245932996,
-0.1289065927,
0.9681508541,
0.0040818453,
0.6515966654,
-0.3485332429,
0.6763801575,
-0.5588873625,
0.2091961652,
-0.4935503602,
-0.7893164754,
-0.4767233431,
0.3224157393,
-0.2953312993,
-0.1441152543,
0.3821844757,
0.6565535069,
-0.215940401,
0.0452521257,
0.053847421,
0.3614341617,
0.2108385116,
0.3976360857,
0.8939977884,
-0.1111919582,
0.6489970088,
-0.0677734911,
-0.4978243709,
-0.5138110518,
-0.7478048801,
-1.2159707546,
-0.7395301461,
-0.2874518931,
-0.2086880654,
0.0138098616,
0.9329158664,
0.2893682122,
-0.674179554,
0.1841037422,
0.1936199814,
0.2070637047,
0.3146326244,
-0.2470245808,
0.4032056928,
-0.2417583168,
-0.2854763269,
0.4946602881,
0.5134318471,
0.2608661354,
-0.0523035079,
0.1215429902,
0.0013477696,
0.1293339282,
0.7882733941,
0.0506892912,
-0.4248003364,
-0.3132228255,
-0.190987289,
-0.1836037487,
-0.2503767908,
0.6343841553,
-0.2391690165,
0.0383037664,
0.4079998434,
0.8983605504,
-0.0107136499,
0.0771102533,
-0.0158771798,
-0.8689797521,
0.0252444781,
0.0872039571,
0.1851653308,
0.6407199502,
-0.7675727606,
0.3005389273,
0.1147387773,
-0.4544019997,
-0.946505785,
0.1772004664,
-0.7950835824,
-0.2171677649,
1.3407980204,
0.1836878657,
-0.0344267786,
-0.2204038203,
-0.3156889379,
0.6212947965,
-0.5777912736,
1.2454140186,
0.4566325843,
0.3728247285,
-0.5183614492,
-0.4980728924,
0.384124577,
-0.3266515136,
-1.0035779476,
0.0876321718,
0.2717805803,
0.3078704774,
0.2564543188,
0.3899666965,
0.4321452379,
0.1176273823,
-0.5920125842,
0.0834222212,
0.1235280856,
-0.6984020472,
-0.0777994469,
0.3013901412,
-0.4222897291,
-0.0659884587
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11097v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11097v2 | InstructCMP: Length Control in Sentence Compression through Instruction-based Large Language Models | 2024-06-16T23:00:47 | 2024-06-18T18:35:52 | Juseon-Do, Jingun Kwon, Hidetaka Kamigaito, Manabu Okumura | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7 | Extractive summarization can produce faithful summaries but often requires
additional constraints such as a desired summary length. Traditional sentence
compression models do not typically consider the constraints because of their
restricted model abilities, which require model modifications for coping with
them. To bridge this gap, we propose Instruction-based Compression
(InstructCMP), an approach to the sentence compression task that can consider
the length constraint through instructions by leveraging the zero-shot
task-solving abilities of Large Language Models (LLMs). For this purpose, we
created new evaluation datasets by transforming traditional sentence
compression datasets into an instruction format. By using the datasets, we
first reveal that the current LLMs still face challenges in accurately
controlling the length for a compressed text. To address this issue, we propose
an approach named "length priming," that incorporates additional length
information into the instructions without external resources. While the length
priming effectively works in a zero-shot setting, a training dataset with the
instructions would further improve the ability of length control. Thus, we
additionally created a training dataset in an instruction format to fine-tune
the model on it. Experimental results and analysis show that applying the
length priming significantly improves performances of InstructCMP in both
zero-shot and fine-tuning settings without the need of any model modifications. | [
-0.1360982507,
-0.625854075,
0.6078840494,
0.1989514828,
-0.4630026221,
0.0119442856,
-0.5567320585,
-0.2312566787,
0.117528148,
0.6530662775,
-0.544940412,
-0.4312418401,
-0.9285263419,
0.1717293262,
-0.2726252675,
0.9967310429,
-0.1078281105,
-0.041980844,
-0.4716852009,
0.3445091248,
-0.8022921681,
-0.4174386561,
-0.0571561195,
-0.1343443245,
0.0855958089,
1.0307924747,
0.6446779966,
0.9979295135,
0.5196508169,
0.1863065958,
-0.0526562147,
0.3684356213,
-0.4247234166,
0.1311418116,
0.1771155,
-0.5778999925,
-0.1485395133,
-0.0632958487,
0.7350050807,
0.7515134215,
-0.0768044591,
0.2605287135,
0.3249200284,
0.7535485029,
-1.0014891624,
0.3803955019,
-0.3455714285,
0.1543146521,
0.1382389069,
-0.7088181376,
-0.654661119,
-0.1386492252,
-0.2476831824,
-0.1087988392,
0.0847327337,
0.1045014486,
0.6875207424,
0.2757769227,
-0.2887094021,
-0.2470435202,
-0.8253580928,
0.7655370831,
-1.0410739183,
0.0221269671,
0.2653555274,
-0.0003263254,
-0.0626234338,
-0.363702178,
-0.3408619463,
-0.2057136297,
-0.1227305532,
0.1415468007,
0.0452257879,
0.3613571525,
0.4537417889,
0.4635168612,
-0.765001297,
0.342864573,
-0.6121631861,
0.0983818397,
0.5361225605,
0.371674329,
0.296133101,
-0.2621591985,
-0.2944174111,
-0.0244840942,
-0.8607617617,
0.0050582173,
0.447037518,
0.2947726548,
-0.1240057796,
1.0195037127,
-0.4681876898,
0.8806084394,
-0.0565811023,
-0.1665519327,
-0.0248693656,
0.0607328974,
-0.4828631878,
0.4424658716,
0.671562016,
0.5756342411,
0.1837749183,
-0.3158072531,
-0.2676186562,
-0.1088622808,
0.0962100774,
-1.2637209892,
0.1005340517,
0.307020098,
-0.5528662205,
-0.2668815553,
0.2566467524,
-0.6142119765,
0.0785066113,
-0.5537211299,
0.518789649,
-0.4795321524,
0.4161977172,
0.6157206297,
-0.2093310356,
0.1981867403,
-0.1850178242,
-1.2280336618,
0.5891259313,
0.7981238365,
1.1488252878,
-0.0435299352,
-0.1112114042,
-0.7288459539,
0.3706906438,
-0.1609920859,
0.5704175234,
-0.6860565543,
-0.5186828375,
-0.0614133142,
0.0887070745,
-0.0169262998,
-0.3692554533,
0.4037457108,
-0.176970154,
0.3827697635,
0.2369730622,
-1.1184023619,
0.0043150159,
0.1919136196,
-0.3214254975,
0.4434784949,
0.0560105629,
-0.6105421185,
-0.0868943036,
-0.5999065042,
-0.6225854158,
0.1204118356,
-0.0464345142,
-0.3389839232,
0.3298691213,
0.6502295732,
0.7846791148,
-0.1795278788,
0.0730186254,
0.0159617811,
-0.6603077054,
0.0050237854,
-0.5560991168,
0.5734878778,
-0.0002147967,
-0.0432703085,
0.1939175278,
-0.6976195574,
0.3256765604,
-0.0310894027,
-0.3334374726,
-0.0376236252,
-0.0857071057,
-0.4844609797,
0.0178289991,
0.3261791468,
-0.5963189006,
0.5616061687,
-0.6748197675,
0.4107809961,
0.5691813231,
0.4390065372,
0.6060611606,
-0.544172585,
0.7755514979,
-0.4371675551,
0.3870526552,
-0.6432119012,
-0.0874013454,
-0.708122015,
-0.1333554834,
0.418420434,
0.8339852095,
-0.7949510217,
0.6699599624,
-0.5986284018,
-0.3993080258,
-0.2414050549,
-0.0313145816,
0.4650912583,
0.5051907301,
0.5951941609,
-0.3536905646,
-0.3618107736,
-0.8137366176,
0.0068552271,
0.1466889232,
-0.4664182961,
0.0941832364,
0.3671337962,
0.4253584146,
0.710149169,
-0.958107233,
-0.2466038167,
-0.5680509806,
0.3883207142,
0.2110255212,
0.6215623021,
0.1947841793,
-0.4320438802,
-0.347687304,
-0.5597815514,
-0.5552443862,
-0.2950489819,
-0.2068013698,
0.2411839068,
-0.1103487313,
0.4235163927,
-0.6072873473,
0.525673449,
0.6430148482,
-0.0968228728,
0.885861516,
-0.5369767547,
0.1871411502,
-0.9191204309,
-0.3418903351,
-0.2307567298,
-0.2133792043,
-0.2620602846,
-0.0378199033,
0.2127026469,
-0.378810674,
-0.5140478611,
0.0077761333,
-0.721087873,
0.0567858964,
-0.604534924,
-0.2234892398,
0.1891189516,
0.7341629267,
0.0961027592,
0.7188005447,
0.3072862029,
-0.6465855837,
0.3154167533,
0.3709466159,
-0.5900259614,
0.2428988665,
-0.777284205,
0.1546693295,
-0.2532752156,
0.1351928115,
-0.4466435313,
-0.3232870996,
0.2278035432,
-0.3695028722,
0.6545597911,
-0.3359062076,
-0.7354932427,
-0.1278048307,
-0.4006669521,
-0.0089458926,
0.7176507115,
-0.2625103593,
0.1859698743,
0.0597102754,
-0.3965910375,
-0.6470316052,
-0.6896214485,
0.3465467095,
-0.1918169111,
-0.4003723264,
0.7488104701,
-0.3483145237,
0.0995149538,
-0.0400638394,
-0.0976682827,
-0.130000636,
-0.1224786788,
0.3460979462,
0.3074429035,
-0.035417188,
0.2517954111,
0.4413561225,
-0.028892871,
0.1384942383,
-0.2775904834,
0.6179605126,
0.3153550327,
-0.1151039153,
-0.714766264,
0.589414537,
0.3175403476,
-0.354411155,
0.8591643572,
-0.028535584,
-0.1314319968,
-0.4403264821,
-0.2762935758,
-0.4581663907,
-0.4044618905,
0.2548230886,
0.0086836861,
-0.9081133604,
-0.1158745512,
-0.1997377723,
0.0139752338,
0.0428821221,
0.2938840091,
0.0675022155,
0.8872748613,
1.0178511143,
-0.0744934604,
0.5451050997,
-0.3245384395,
-0.0110213375,
-0.7832333446,
-0.1390786469,
-0.4839933217,
-0.4109287858,
0.0839555413,
-0.4000715315,
0.3398195207,
0.1225021109,
-0.0967412218,
0.4639206827,
-0.7031242251,
0.9572319984,
0.3694375753,
0.3733939528,
0.0909006819,
-0.1853121221,
0.3674199581,
-0.0818670318,
-0.842327714,
-0.5213917494,
0.9721893668,
0.1260706335,
0.7406483889,
-0.1600646973,
0.6263902187,
0.2559435666,
-0.1057005674,
-0.9934232235,
0.6208318472,
-0.2412787378,
0.0871372819,
-0.3847318292,
-0.6182085276,
-0.7749530077,
-0.1402640492,
-0.1525204182,
-0.7051967382,
-0.0786475614,
0.0441176929,
-0.4608722031,
0.2347467691,
-0.6640586257,
0.6634235978,
-0.4705070257,
-0.023478426,
-0.1028015539,
-0.7645459771,
0.2913832068,
0.4357481599,
-0.0727236271,
-0.0459834114,
-0.1039116308,
0.8047370911,
-0.7553725839,
0.9478046894,
0.0713162646,
0.1846454889,
0.2757185698,
0.0961067751,
0.5218775868,
-0.2262456119,
0.2567423582,
-0.0701280832,
0.0345835462,
-0.3003033996,
-1.0002506971,
0.4899553657,
-0.2671980858,
-0.6048282981,
-0.0923886374,
-0.8284114599,
-0.3047201037,
0.0424413159,
0.3887964189,
0.7398856282,
-0.0437925197,
0.5103327036,
0.6832438707,
-0.2602929473,
0.7046854496,
0.5013669133,
0.1376318336,
-0.3513657749,
0.6359316707,
0.2776801884,
0.4671224058,
0.9087163806,
0.2173327506,
-0.0997009873,
-0.6529427171,
-0.46423015,
-0.0571091771,
-0.4858210087,
-0.5545905232,
-0.4079821706,
-0.3388544917,
-0.4757870734,
-0.260034591,
-0.1610981822,
-0.6398070455,
-0.3416152894,
-0.2207061648,
0.1155539453,
0.4852575958,
0.0918657258,
0.592414856,
-1.0830980539,
0.182319507,
0.0498838834,
0.2236995697,
-0.1733006239,
-0.8613231182,
-0.5009848475,
-0.1568636,
-0.325303942,
-1.0626980066,
0.5857009888,
0.282437712,
-0.0886579752,
0.4763289392,
0.2715203762,
0.6493051052,
-0.7377001643,
0.8046861291,
0.091916576,
-0.9946403503,
0.5952398777,
0.0880378261,
0.7407672405,
0.2261032164,
0.460006237,
-0.4402890503,
-0.3908475339,
-0.4627380371,
-0.8832637668,
0.5321635604,
0.2296008915,
0.4083835483,
-0.0029467,
0.4362286031,
0.0794148669,
0.2431289256,
-0.3667656183,
0.0304841828,
0.1113381386,
-0.3477924466,
0.0013546301,
-0.7251759768,
-0.0000734878,
0.0514967777,
0.7691155672,
-0.1340855062,
0.0905259848,
0.1346582025,
-0.2189301103,
0.1255419254,
0.7251942754,
0.5349392295,
0.6561952829,
-0.2795699835,
0.090701811,
0.0528112575,
-0.3604505062,
0.144868359,
0.1533350945,
-0.2081857324,
-0.034943901,
0.6225065589,
0.6598100662,
0.3414173424,
-0.946613729,
0.7716493607,
0.0248901024,
-0.0366729088,
-0.2545381784,
0.2858220637,
-0.3076255918,
-0.0688977689,
-0.0265626479,
-0.1905212849,
0.2439888269,
-0.2651219964,
0.0848350525,
0.2303144336,
-0.4231474996,
-0.0370477885,
0.522103548,
-0.0090500256,
-0.2126883268,
0.9037746191,
-0.0449333936,
-0.2513380945,
0.7299782634,
0.5821621418,
0.6619896293,
-0.1086471826,
0.1742717177,
0.314298898,
0.4875798225,
-0.2170108557,
0.2010624707,
-0.1653634012,
-0.4376143813,
-0.901655376,
-0.3851735294,
-0.4172469079,
0.2376979589,
-0.8376435637,
0.355404526,
-0.5000690818,
0.3415480256,
-0.2423589379,
-0.0866101161,
-0.2529539764,
0.1687796116,
0.1214335859,
1.1267791986,
-0.7000021935,
0.5494295359,
-0.0891347378,
-0.4955455959,
-0.8114172816,
-0.0523571707,
-0.1415565461,
-0.2283732146,
0.403528899,
0.6456982493,
0.0031513171,
-0.1412305236,
-0.9766685367,
-0.4029946923,
1.0499895811,
0.5856690407,
-0.7189826965,
-0.1457431167,
0.1879455,
0.2521215677,
-0.5243250728,
-0.1339969933,
0.3506416678,
0.1613110751,
-0.0062991418,
-0.7480689883,
-0.0250537209,
0.0237175636,
-0.0385343023,
0.3054579496,
-0.3704010844,
0.5301761031,
-0.3858878016,
-0.310413152,
0.2958941758,
0.8967580795,
-0.2453106791,
-0.022452008,
0.2442680448,
0.5734890699,
0.455830574,
0.2023358643,
1.1535054445,
-0.5533643365,
0.1669314355,
1.5786529779,
-0.1534247547,
0.897560358,
0.296010375,
0.1779892594,
0.4793128669,
0.2030071616,
-0.2374501377,
0.3844649494,
0.3074518144,
-0.2434523255,
-0.122377038,
-0.2168172002,
-0.0527845919,
0.6170130968,
0.3094973564,
-0.5754252672,
0.0199565683,
0.1089507788,
0.3081953228,
0.2176388204,
-0.4851421416,
0.6341511607,
-0.0319380984,
-0.6636296511,
0.3808548748,
0.2774973512,
0.5513628721,
-0.9169336557,
-0.2168410718,
0.108913064,
-0.1110567153,
-0.0610914975,
-0.8284260631,
0.4033128321,
0.1329940259,
-0.3838475943,
-0.4866524935,
0.6064459682,
-0.6073235869,
-0.4607493579,
-0.2353104055,
0.2574628592,
0.3161924183,
-0.2549031079,
-0.2773970366,
-0.1631409228,
-0.1322057992,
-0.1100401208,
0.2843785882,
0.2249274999,
0.1600536704,
0.6306203008,
0.4542292953,
0.3001348674,
-0.2794629931,
-0.1206202582,
0.7388694286,
-0.5131092668,
-0.4949966967,
-1.0193169117,
0.2560203373,
-0.1852370352,
-0.0657820925,
0.5388166904,
0.8262931108,
0.7272982001,
-0.3247939348,
0.6485990882,
-0.1296150088,
0.2849440575,
-1.018148303,
0.4289160073,
-0.2786861658,
0.2844190598,
0.0928835496,
-0.6606539488,
-0.3656895161,
0.033520367,
-0.3646021485,
-0.2296497524,
0.712767601,
0.7388780713,
-0.0025340961,
-0.1776290387,
0.4470746517,
0.1439105719,
0.1343393326,
0.7725219131,
0.5325459838,
-0.0365927294,
0.7994858027,
-0.7072983384,
-0.3480822146,
0.0495359562,
-1.1001708508,
-0.92259413,
-0.3508707285,
-0.3263508976,
-0.0609037541,
0.0455882438,
0.9616138935,
0.7722963095,
-0.4539619684,
-0.1741905361,
0.0492928624,
-0.1453990042,
-0.4708777964,
-0.2723555267,
0.5034968853,
-0.4193996489,
-0.7654533982,
0.6654466987,
0.6587259769,
0.2515058517,
-0.1528197527,
0.1749504805,
0.0972485393,
0.2080231905,
0.5854519606,
0.30125615,
-0.2507123649,
-0.248242408,
-0.1772215366,
0.2155824453,
0.0521734506,
1.0869027376,
-0.6782000065,
0.3383842111,
0.4796859324,
0.5380539894,
0.2918249369,
0.0987997577,
0.7272142768,
-1.1982966661,
0.3778018653,
0.3715304434,
0.5001229048,
0.3638054729,
-0.6833654642,
0.4566833377,
-0.1148037612,
-0.7279632688,
-0.5851256847,
0.3392229676,
-0.9122256637,
-0.614934206,
0.9857362509,
-0.2735542655,
-0.2226704359,
0.3604096174,
-0.3863773942,
0.2778196633,
-0.2361921072,
0.9642713666,
0.6268535852,
-0.228490904,
-0.4422627389,
-0.4628105164,
0.2869721651,
0.2968753278,
-0.9701823592,
0.1754641384,
0.615924716,
0.0517626218,
-0.1253653169,
0.1972503364,
-0.0459033474,
0.1501609236,
-0.2272513956,
0.1319223791,
-0.5898718834,
-0.5879166126,
-0.3680773675,
0.3873140812,
-0.2797617912,
-0.3449191451
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11096v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11096v2 | The Potential and Challenges of Evaluating Attitudes, Opinions, and Values in Large Language Models | 2024-06-16T22:59:18 | 2024-07-01T10:04:09 | Bolei Ma, Xinpeng Wang, Tiancheng Hu, Anna-Carolina Haensch, Michael A. Hedderich, Barbara Plank, Frauke Kreuter | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent advances in Large Language Models (LLMs) have sparked wide interest in
validating and comprehending the human-like cognitive-behavioral traits LLMs
may have. These cognitive-behavioral traits include typically Attitudes,
Opinions, Values (AOV). However, measuring AOV embedded within LLMs remains
opaque, and different evaluation methods may yield different results. This has
led to a lack of clarity on how different studies are related to each other and
how they can be interpreted. This paper aims to bridge this gap by providing an
overview of recent works on the evaluation of AOV in LLMs. Moreover, we survey
related approaches in different stages of the evaluation pipeline in these
works. By doing so, we address the potential and challenges with respect to
understanding the model, human-AI alignment, and downstream application in
social sciences. Finally, we provide practical insights into evaluation
methods, model enhancement, and interdisciplinary collaboration, thereby
contributing to the evolving landscape of evaluating AOV in LLMs. | [
-0.3942783177,
-0.7712155581,
0.8691872358,
0.0755765885,
-0.0259840526,
0.2397295982,
-0.5205266476,
-0.4224661291,
-0.1197477281,
0.329760462,
-0.4970727861,
-0.3761198223,
-0.7822669744,
-0.0879188925,
-0.101928845,
0.8568719029,
-0.0650395527,
0.3083543181,
-0.4497328699,
-0.4461170733,
-0.3538025022,
-0.7124175429,
-0.720512867,
-0.6190828681,
0.3684405684,
0.1519830972,
0.8072194457,
0.3131968379,
0.4869372845,
0.3175121248,
-0.3733719885,
-0.0360338353,
-0.5247864723,
0.0827572644,
-0.1939717531,
-0.3595300019,
-0.626239717,
0.2993995845,
0.826241076,
0.88192451,
-0.1611147076,
0.3260792196,
0.2024965137,
0.9631250501,
-0.6737558842,
0.3769156933,
-0.3653721213,
-0.1524227113,
-0.0929608569,
0.2469506562,
-0.2600122392,
-0.487778306,
0.3916918039,
-0.1642173082,
-0.4376236796,
0.0132187391,
0.6711678505,
-0.0048382482,
-0.7286961079,
-0.5612376332,
-0.6418070793,
1.143175602,
-0.7715370059,
0.3492281437,
0.0895797461,
0.1303762347,
-0.1442407817,
-0.2393279821,
-0.7422895432,
-0.1823568493,
0.2393293828,
0.0129568269,
-0.1957037449,
0.0297679696,
-0.2548288703,
0.4967886209,
-0.1169580668,
0.2663017511,
-0.1366578639,
0.0480570607,
0.9257879257,
0.4347827435,
0.1647061706,
-0.3575384915,
-0.193073988,
-0.0830321535,
-0.6385636926,
0.3704430163,
0.642180264,
-0.0124833006,
-0.1710069925,
0.622938931,
-0.150603205,
0.5668138862,
0.0262328815,
0.0759810284,
0.4577976763,
-0.2229167074,
-0.1375120878,
-0.3269982934,
0.9652314186,
0.3641446531,
0.3869681656,
0.0235912949,
-0.1864137053,
0.1153502166,
0.235371232,
-0.4153271616,
0.1833665371,
0.4405345917,
-0.6345460415,
-0.5556405783,
-0.0105691487,
-0.6598648429,
-0.6925669312,
-0.5806578994,
0.3001626432,
-0.2383823544,
-0.4773622751,
0.0484550372,
-0.0112758009,
0.5500224829,
0.6207770109,
-0.6798030138,
0.263035804,
1.0663357973,
0.7193666101,
-0.5295569301,
-0.3089099824,
-0.1337421834,
-0.1856748164,
-0.4787106812,
0.6770159602,
-0.8039323688,
-0.412145704,
-0.0005922567,
-0.192095682,
0.1670611352,
-0.3779371977,
0.4816581607,
-0.5347536206,
-0.0263312012,
-0.5768921375,
-0.5518675447,
-0.1226641387,
0.5208849311,
-0.4732768536,
0.9846830964,
-0.0378863253,
-0.6202517748,
0.1933894306,
-0.752969265,
-0.2725113332,
-0.2201117575,
-0.2047738433,
-0.2171978205,
0.3559319675,
-0.0050074537,
0.4324677885,
-0.580144763,
0.2577824295,
-0.5192461014,
-0.1080887169,
0.639261663,
-0.4133295715,
1.0149995089,
0.2519852817,
-0.0068206689,
0.4233948588,
-0.5191296935,
0.011014672,
0.131742239,
-0.2285402864,
-0.4886372089,
0.2050274163,
-0.1408286691,
0.1799447685,
0.4652405977,
-0.5699451566,
0.2063304484,
-0.3712645769,
0.7421408296,
1.0693328381,
0.0691076592,
0.6130658984,
-0.1048056334,
0.6244360209,
-0.1798154116,
0.4410558939,
0.155389145,
-0.3908409774,
-0.6802607775,
-0.1630654931,
0.0508603528,
0.2121264786,
-0.3290786147,
0.3570515513,
-0.2859822214,
-0.8749917746,
-0.8683025837,
0.1532365978,
0.3744129241,
0.23525998,
0.1044864058,
-0.4679701626,
-0.1834830046,
-0.8299428821,
-0.5006850362,
-0.5837577581,
0.1191999912,
0.5257399082,
0.5597321987,
-0.0965521336,
0.9925579429,
-0.3718615174,
0.0188650265,
-0.1369082928,
0.3207812011,
0.1671319455,
0.1387293041,
0.2023162842,
-0.597957015,
-0.2407389581,
0.0825292915,
-0.7239488363,
-0.1576110423,
0.4432646036,
0.0613691546,
0.0876136273,
0.3146071434,
-0.5518484712,
0.2145380378,
0.8798747659,
-0.2520746887,
0.5833063722,
0.1054611579,
0.5215965509,
-0.6288996339,
-0.183597073,
0.2363498807,
-0.026448492,
-0.5267559886,
0.1576140225,
-0.1882389188,
0.1277973503,
-0.6127699614,
0.6874192357,
-0.5615013242,
-0.2868882716,
-0.1493098438,
0.2342674583,
0.0581498966,
0.1903522909,
0.0884744599,
0.4620689154,
0.4721591473,
-0.4089922309,
0.6405124664,
0.1111950874,
-0.6644436717,
0.7467730641,
-0.7347247601,
0.416557461,
-0.3193463385,
0.264188081,
-0.9266349077,
0.1366119832,
0.1008870006,
-0.4250822663,
0.0218894891,
-0.2584906518,
-0.3154789805,
-0.0608756915,
-0.5202156305,
0.4714686573,
0.4687974155,
-0.1886603385,
0.6681618094,
0.8234586716,
-0.3867487013,
-0.5394147038,
-0.2848983109,
0.1003252268,
-0.3300633132,
-0.5757712722,
0.0484315343,
0.0215466451,
-0.9445986152,
0.0647507533,
0.0285612699,
0.0936192647,
0.0755138695,
0.2012644857,
0.3770710826,
-0.2277663946,
0.080835022,
-0.2110999823,
0.12844266,
0.2117329687,
-0.1102957278,
0.3184517026,
-0.7064583898,
-0.5619323254,
-0.0210991018,
0.2030326277,
0.7170321941,
-0.4251703918,
0.6748600602,
0.2979088128,
-0.2683424056,
0.0355283879,
-0.6002274156,
0.023878295,
-0.3787855208,
0.6119025946,
-0.0991057083,
-0.9294939041,
0.3375688493,
-0.0316829868,
0.1149448454,
0.3819003701,
0.9356299639,
-0.2532193661,
0.9066615105,
0.502854228,
-0.0145636825,
0.3373750448,
0.0020222219,
0.4045479,
-1.3881077766,
-0.2749490142,
-0.4864508212,
-0.0801968127,
-0.3351077139,
-0.5014039874,
0.4859614074,
-0.028994251,
-0.248573944,
-0.1428594887,
-0.1637201905,
0.254624933,
-0.1772886068,
-0.0182437822,
0.4720275998,
-0.4294742942,
0.2483173162,
-0.1371544451,
-0.3387166262,
-1.0122224092,
1.1815828085,
0.8037276268,
0.6941456795,
0.2582481503,
0.1971908957,
0.4302060604,
0.7493726611,
-1.2223558426,
0.562643826,
0.0521829389,
-0.8036637902,
-0.7631064057,
-0.2062910497,
-0.826241374,
0.4996057451,
-0.3861347735,
-1.0901908875,
0.1770318002,
0.0299150422,
-0.1009749845,
0.2011366785,
-0.6745389104,
0.8795012236,
-0.4283117652,
-0.3542902768,
-0.4813010395,
-0.3781379759,
0.4360768199,
-0.1169400513,
0.4980474412,
-0.3920828402,
0.0069293878,
0.7525715828,
-0.3262656033,
0.7304668427,
-0.0579914674,
-0.4870529473,
0.4507071674,
-0.1327196062,
0.3452820778,
-0.0892687216,
-0.4905858338,
0.5423303246,
0.1030162871,
-0.2894239426,
-0.6953601837,
0.8191097975,
-0.9153426886,
-0.8187013268,
-0.5403411984,
-0.486461401,
-0.506319046,
-0.1224194169,
-0.2796828151,
0.1190563813,
-0.6693127751,
0.1738906503,
0.6599583626,
-0.4393402934,
0.3052870035,
0.4652378559,
-0.3212535083,
-0.0569272116,
0.6768006682,
-0.0165963676,
0.4736358523,
0.1695137322,
0.3052177131,
-0.3093603849,
-0.5874910355,
-0.2987582684,
0.2668965161,
-0.9541083574,
0.2547540069,
-0.5136823654,
0.0480110534,
-0.4290901721,
-0.0861024186,
-0.6956333518,
-0.0094827311,
-0.0467944294,
0.0409877151,
0.3672036231,
1.1844534874,
0.3176103532,
0.0594080687,
-0.5850078464,
0.0648740977,
0.3239604235,
0.4123846591,
0.4963183999,
-0.4156966209,
-0.0732759982,
0.1572020054,
-0.1725412905,
-0.9311261773,
0.1920109242,
-0.2343670577,
0.4759509563,
0.33309412,
-0.0327668525,
0.6199954748,
-0.4311573207,
0.9613577127,
0.0628273189,
-1.2334865332,
0.2240041047,
-0.2019325793,
0.00756648,
0.4524058104,
0.3772821128,
-0.6233721972,
-0.1617054641,
-0.3942197561,
-0.9380760193,
0.564434588,
0.1429910064,
0.175658375,
0.1636478156,
0.1861007214,
0.0373426117,
0.3468616903,
-0.637730062,
-0.2578829527,
-0.0115657514,
-0.2063623071,
-0.1822463125,
-0.1412571222,
-0.0703127533,
-0.2170861065,
0.6388623714,
0.0495846681,
-0.0086848484,
-0.0428525396,
-0.2203479558,
0.0109192124,
0.7375908494,
0.1432898939,
0.7734349966,
-0.1669412255,
-0.0281193666,
0.3254141212,
-0.2220400423,
0.2795836627,
-0.3387880921,
0.1555922776,
-0.4269032776,
0.3357695937,
0.7228140831,
0.0594951659,
-0.6783592701,
0.7687131166,
-0.0031711413,
0.203521803,
-0.4638476074,
-0.1913038343,
0.2453276664,
0.190845266,
0.2088733763,
-0.1366633773,
0.0016203797,
-1.1284402609,
-0.4042654037,
0.6390786767,
-0.8332431316,
-0.3661350608,
0.1689250469,
0.3226664662,
-0.1808868796,
0.5455933213,
0.0039473702,
-0.4382943809,
0.6404887438,
0.0406680517,
0.8288688064,
-0.1844584942,
0.0075628855,
-0.166687876,
0.4269261062,
0.123743847,
0.0946274698,
0.1799694449,
-0.9930288792,
-0.5444544554,
-0.7268512249,
-0.5248621106,
0.2231600583,
-0.8221306205,
0.3427585959,
-0.1856711656,
-0.337657541,
0.1806718409,
-0.0793615133,
-0.7526915669,
0.0894025788,
0.2458693981,
0.5393115878,
-1.0179282427,
0.7966983318,
1.1341536045,
-0.112474151,
-0.4757689834,
0.1437886059,
0.2883234918,
-0.9398507476,
0.7011013031,
-0.254437685,
-0.3855609894,
-0.2365325391,
-0.4023185968,
-0.7673107982,
0.8459866643,
0.1278904378,
-0.3845297098,
0.0418904163,
-0.0749895871,
0.6786532998,
-0.5066722631,
0.4889724255,
0.8154556155,
0.7857406139,
-0.1878734976,
-0.8310922384,
-0.1313261539,
-0.3060891926,
0.188076362,
0.0600798391,
-0.9390106797,
0.7043192983,
-0.1287598312,
0.0271313172,
-0.2237531841,
0.8553047776,
0.3165478408,
0.1430687308,
0.648735702,
0.2403743118,
0.5892822742,
-0.0305695776,
1.104460001,
-0.034108445,
0.3688434064,
0.7824606299,
-0.6139383912,
0.9150148034,
0.5561187267,
-0.4988981783,
0.4575030804,
0.5593903661,
0.1553276926,
0.1408741027,
0.436653018,
-0.123238273,
-0.1906036437,
-0.273021996,
-0.0370960422,
0.5824546814,
0.6318779588,
-0.0935049728,
0.1569494605,
-0.2460863143,
0.085072279,
0.1703944057,
-0.5593546033,
0.6915388107,
0.2342103273,
-0.8330256939,
0.1388281733,
0.1489968598,
0.6653397083,
-0.4871281683,
-0.0552689694,
0.1920300871,
-0.0582782291,
-0.2845132053,
-1.2576617002,
0.3033589125,
0.2799575329,
-0.125090614,
-0.1790181249,
0.5120532513,
-0.0596265122,
-0.2622533441,
0.2835961282,
0.4740442932,
0.1850150526,
0.0416613296,
-0.5839259624,
0.4678604603,
-0.1335799247,
-0.5674487352,
0.3089431524,
0.482219547,
-0.1915349066,
0.7472566962,
0.4349682927,
0.267138809,
-0.2283662558,
0.0502928197,
0.6050001979,
-0.6723432541,
-0.1237356588,
-1.0761418343,
0.4292511642,
0.1145500094,
-0.4688397646,
0.7539353371,
0.2671575248,
0.6866223216,
0.1156314313,
1.0923806429,
-0.0579728819,
0.1573640555,
-0.5385068655,
0.6222397685,
-0.3554388583,
0.4682624042,
-0.6763216257,
-0.7994697094,
0.1963654608,
0.617990315,
-0.647816062,
0.2100337893,
0.6187904477,
0.3350384235,
0.3424884975,
-0.0603338964,
0.1037179828,
0.3470620215,
0.283443898,
0.436237067,
1.2754434347,
-0.2463262677,
0.2360838801,
0.0777658224,
-0.4659154713,
-0.1299932897,
-1.230194211,
-0.7953317761,
-0.5734019279,
-0.4645329714,
-0.3958876431,
0.0789659023,
1.0817352533,
0.5030888915,
-0.6534417868,
-0.5529172421,
0.2461587042,
0.3222302794,
-0.1112915576,
-0.2428483665,
0.3343857527,
0.1005926952,
-0.8378051519,
0.092299141,
0.5913814306,
-0.1666697711,
-0.8663794398,
-0.2586013675,
-0.1019811034,
0.4331580698,
0.7940063477,
0.2031393647,
-0.9188381433,
-0.3338762224,
-0.1230615824,
-0.0793271959,
0.0775557756,
0.7090418339,
-0.5790194273,
0.3878312707,
0.4426118433,
0.5350761414,
0.2566912174,
-0.0111919036,
0.8360189199,
-0.2890748084,
-0.1245019138,
0.3809756935,
0.4732483923,
0.5315964222,
-0.1592193246,
0.2556173205,
-0.2110579014,
-0.5718485713,
-0.8882321119,
0.4595255256,
-0.8878772855,
-0.2339071184,
1.4005727768,
-0.2381551117,
-0.2845916152,
-0.2010451257,
-0.0246967003,
0.1277340353,
-0.3806208074,
0.8037318587,
1.1410540342,
-0.2906498313,
-0.0658671856,
-0.6820651889,
0.2730048001,
0.3907325566,
-0.8636257648,
0.3110972941,
0.4245154858,
0.2028615922,
0.0410109721,
0.6001727581,
-0.6159097552,
-0.1551208645,
-0.5004284978,
0.2502694726,
0.2936363816,
0.0769558325,
-0.6546337008,
-0.0278302394,
0.6040219069,
0.2601623237
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11093v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11093v1 | RAEmoLLM: Retrieval Augmented LLMs for Cross-Domain Misinformation Detection Using In-Context Learning based on Emotional Information | 2024-06-16T22:49:11 | 2024-06-16T22:49:11 | Zhiwei Liu, Kailai Yang, Qianqian Xie, Christine de Kock, Sophia Ananiadou, Eduard Hovy | cs.CL | cs.CL | Misinformation is prevalent in various fields such as education, politics,
health, etc., causing significant harm to society. However, current methods for
cross-domain misinformation detection rely on time and resources consuming
fine-tuning and complex model structures. With the outstanding performance of
LLMs, many studies have employed them for misinformation detection.
Unfortunately, they focus on in-domain tasks and do not incorporate significant
sentiment and emotion features (which we jointly call affect). In this paper,
we propose RAEmoLLM, the first retrieval augmented (RAG) LLMs framework to
address cross-domain misinformation detection using in-context learning based
on affective information. It accomplishes this by applying an emotion-aware LLM
to construct a retrieval database of affective embeddings. This database is
used by our retrieval module to obtain source-domain samples, which are
subsequently used for the inference module's in-context few-shot learning to
detect target domain misinformation. We evaluate our framework on three
misinformation benchmarks. Results show that RAEmoLLM achieves significant
improvements compared to the zero-shot method on three datasets, with the
highest increases of 20.69%, 23.94%, and 39.11% respectively. This work will be
released on https://github.com/lzw108/RAEmoLLM. | [
-0.3247259259,
-0.8317123652,
0.3420359194,
0.3238455951,
-0.1391255707,
0.1821706444,
-0.0745328814,
-0.6905113459,
0.5959322453,
0.1690750569,
-0.495552808,
-0.6642531753,
-0.8015477061,
0.2113454193,
-0.2516948581,
0.7652196884,
-0.1424520612,
-0.0209378842,
-0.4202396572,
-0.2507832944,
-0.241100058,
-0.3163374364,
-0.2299805433,
-0.4375854135,
0.4385978878,
0.7676534057,
0.3752339482,
0.0505647101,
0.5283643603,
0.0848724917,
-0.13121517,
0.4333383739,
-0.6576352715,
0.4613625705,
-0.2990326285,
-0.5652374029,
-0.1547378898,
0.0702418834,
0.4429736137,
-0.0537147895,
0.028771298,
0.031418208,
-0.1872329265,
0.8388438225,
-0.9556387663,
-0.1128397137,
-0.6596162915,
0.2469875067,
-0.2256276011,
-0.6216036081,
-0.4362549186,
-0.3384577632,
-0.0729612783,
-0.3916388452,
-0.0814025924,
0.4997252524,
0.7368738651,
0.2123396546,
-0.4920619428,
-0.448722899,
-0.1271942854,
1.0249198675,
-0.6603340507,
0.5625292063,
0.4631379843,
-0.0606675558,
-0.0168552063,
-0.3369115889,
-0.5487862825,
0.1908631623,
0.0284681991,
0.4002104104,
-0.5083971024,
-0.1990464926,
0.0904219449,
0.2986440659,
-0.6603053212,
-0.0423976704,
0.0546713434,
-0.0276565496,
0.4995853603,
0.0274903085,
0.3699080646,
-0.5490210652,
-0.7277947068,
0.0203220639,
-0.7864536643,
-0.3966419697,
0.1961504221,
0.1844299883,
-0.1756920666,
0.6765418053,
-0.1600452513,
0.4208385348,
0.3478066623,
-0.1893207282,
0.4473103285,
0.2155399323,
-0.3476571441,
0.3562203348,
0.5271522403,
0.4393664896,
-0.0222629327,
-0.0752888545,
-0.2669312656,
0.1754739732,
0.1102326959,
-0.8815336227,
0.2674562931,
0.1991231143,
-0.4903612137,
-0.113580592,
-0.0784438103,
-0.9576212764,
-0.6599118114,
-0.2539263368,
0.525883615,
-0.7000822425,
-0.2707252204,
0.1626380533,
0.100545451,
-0.0027431173,
0.4660261869,
-0.4143766463,
-0.056964118,
0.6169059873,
0.7932112813,
-0.5495871902,
0.0868223682,
-0.5387793183,
0.0041136337,
0.0031476265,
1.0285929441,
-0.7458399534,
-0.4470688105,
0.0792017132,
-0.1163338721,
-0.0981416926,
-0.8567943573,
0.6586585045,
-0.7456692457,
0.219858855,
-0.1639047563,
-0.7635893226,
-0.3393362761,
0.6983318329,
-0.4922241569,
1.1571029425,
0.1841724962,
-1.0950884819,
0.1028971821,
-0.4474479854,
-0.4920696914,
-0.0971804783,
0.0474786274,
-0.5266088843,
0.0525287315,
0.1106877774,
0.5737167001,
-0.4150237441,
-0.0176973883,
-0.3010755181,
-0.2924747169,
0.3203810751,
-0.3172471225,
0.3184601068,
0.2088560015,
-0.3703598678,
-0.1111337319,
-0.3846032619,
0.014977606,
-0.2246304154,
-0.3633722365,
-0.663769722,
-0.4470126033,
0.060386546,
0.4011690617,
0.0088441912,
-0.651376009,
-0.0779444575,
-0.1052226052,
-0.5218696594,
0.4563256204,
0.2374640852,
0.5091705918,
-0.4603753686,
0.7825309634,
0.479447633,
0.0817364231,
-0.0657146648,
-0.3833407462,
-0.5726847649,
-0.2279674411,
-0.0535206497,
0.7139413357,
-0.926233232,
-0.0052269227,
0.0952385142,
-0.2457359731,
-0.6008766294,
0.2205923051,
0.5698766708,
0.6725662351,
0.6409870386,
-0.066429235,
-0.6463943124,
-0.6540188193,
-0.9097564816,
0.0451924466,
0.3597922921,
0.5261971951,
0.4147697985,
-0.7282081842,
0.8924282789,
-0.2492681444,
-0.5789003372,
-0.1862934679,
0.4674376547,
0.1074084714,
0.1206814423,
0.5000130534,
-1.0344207287,
-0.6913689375,
-0.0284709223,
-0.8076145649,
-0.3884660006,
0.1936677992,
-0.2013307512,
0.5065863132,
-0.047760807,
-0.5957245827,
0.5574126244,
0.4811764061,
-0.2639271021,
0.4739005864,
0.3303453326,
0.5549467802,
-1.217946291,
-0.266161859,
0.4578716755,
-0.3859243095,
-0.4337632358,
-0.4146645963,
0.3427173793,
0.2792895138,
-0.6913881898,
0.7774778008,
-0.6127154827,
0.0752711296,
-0.3852820992,
0.5655676723,
0.0488889106,
0.1892664135,
-0.0520437844,
0.4949553311,
0.314512521,
-0.4802513421,
0.2837249339,
0.3059636056,
-0.1251032054,
1.2334417105,
0.0020925135,
0.0241675805,
-0.3352409899,
0.1249129474,
-0.4053556323,
-0.2912458777,
0.5350160599,
-0.634706974,
0.4028677344,
-0.3018199205,
-0.3815892339,
0.1041845754,
-0.4260402322,
0.2235813737,
0.1834190786,
-0.736566782,
0.908850491,
0.5295179486,
0.0483502969,
-0.6915111542,
-0.8471640944,
0.0141203292,
-0.3631245196,
-0.5313250422,
0.2431584448,
-0.1234866008,
-0.4747689664,
0.1998556703,
-0.4673834145,
-0.0174637996,
-0.2600722909,
0.5371821523,
0.1534474194,
-0.0485728681,
0.5213143229,
0.109895803,
-0.0135460701,
0.0300020147,
-0.0131909959,
0.0701064244,
-0.1856755614,
-0.3912905753,
-0.3224101365,
0.407132268,
0.1918230802,
-0.0511091352,
0.6927944422,
0.650182128,
-0.5882319808,
-0.6450873613,
-0.647302568,
-0.1862854511,
-0.3695709705,
0.2427275628,
-0.0439569838,
-1.0585665703,
0.2567131519,
-0.5214746594,
-0.5265145898,
0.4196689129,
0.3337991834,
-0.1860500723,
0.6063178182,
0.4623584151,
-0.3107529879,
0.5678107738,
-0.3300111294,
0.1223613173,
-0.8032371402,
-0.4711426497,
-0.2500232756,
-0.4680311382,
0.008941236,
-0.7098751664,
0.3836482763,
0.1285414249,
0.0480201989,
-0.1987416893,
-0.1904485524,
0.4976682961,
0.1426322162,
0.2931157649,
0.3610704243,
0.1731503606,
0.1060799137,
-0.2519676685,
-0.6747662425,
-0.1800613105,
0.7688602209,
0.149623096,
1.2598372698,
0.2085973769,
0.7415162921,
0.6511734724,
0.874622941,
-1.0003443956,
0.2990191281,
0.0146024032,
-0.4663545489,
0.2508513629,
-0.5985187888,
-0.542727232,
0.2642674446,
-0.5267593861,
-0.427011162,
0.4150326252,
0.0343461186,
0.0726582706,
0.5461871624,
-0.3724572062,
0.508672595,
-0.4446612298,
-0.4444175661,
-0.3939333558,
-0.6250293851,
0.4162208438,
-0.1941969395,
0.2669193149,
-0.2931545079,
-0.0228983294,
0.6132315397,
-0.0124173416,
0.8385033607,
-0.2929078937,
0.0678984374,
0.2382568717,
0.2922306061,
0.5569996238,
0.2726412416,
-0.3385945261,
0.0248182584,
-0.3676450849,
0.0568732433,
-0.5779814124,
0.8709153533,
-0.4791543782,
-0.1970851868,
-0.7043893337,
-0.6660873294,
-0.3758514822,
0.0835610032,
0.1642739922,
0.2373590916,
-0.179476127,
0.3266003728,
1.1664464474,
-0.1888665855,
0.128095001,
0.8338288665,
-0.403327316,
-0.2730896175,
0.6923190355,
-0.2087616324,
0.0943728909,
0.5011143684,
-0.0244541839,
-0.2922458351,
-0.0851161331,
-0.0458601564,
0.4556740224,
-0.9261209965,
-0.9141384363,
-0.762791872,
-0.0111953486,
-0.138013646,
0.0046818811,
-0.3017198443,
-0.0944538191,
-0.778909862,
-0.0880930647,
0.7823546529,
0.7747007608,
-0.2341241539,
0.2277352959,
-0.8692592978,
0.5991406441,
-0.0945715085,
0.42966488,
-0.2291784585,
-0.7586942911,
-0.5666294694,
0.2163063288,
-0.3953687251,
-0.9778671265,
0.7995737791,
0.4091641903,
0.4079293609,
0.4334436059,
0.3092063963,
0.6310732365,
-0.0022618223,
0.3456251323,
0.1208565086,
-0.8979825974,
0.4925127029,
0.1974886954,
0.0328773595,
0.4260449409,
0.897145927,
-0.8903932571,
-0.2088785022,
-0.5472403169,
-0.8021455407,
0.8343885541,
-0.1606924981,
-0.0781498179,
-0.2497827858,
0.3674018681,
0.1714842469,
0.1039043665,
-0.4938486814,
-0.4173778594,
0.1056921482,
-0.3813551068,
0.2853518128,
-0.5624622703,
-0.0268257391,
0.0857837275,
0.9896485806,
-0.1384977996,
0.1779402941,
0.4235662222,
-0.7187306285,
-0.4356609285,
0.3153151572,
0.2304779589,
0.3150414228,
-0.3603273332,
0.203045398,
0.0938434675,
-0.4723462462,
0.0630974993,
0.0582869202,
0.0512516871,
0.3749819696,
0.096518971,
0.786116302,
0.5594997406,
-0.5820553303,
0.6231111288,
-0.0336816125,
-0.0515262038,
-0.1927216947,
-0.1991087198,
-0.0025665325,
0.6969602704,
0.5617924333,
0.1583408862,
0.2040471882,
-0.3960061669,
0.3409113586,
0.4348914623,
-0.4653877318,
-0.2764964104,
0.4997441471,
0.1300364584,
-0.0484243147,
0.2513836026,
-0.1357027292,
-0.6290926337,
0.2797029912,
0.6526752114,
0.9711290598,
-0.4286670089,
0.3910565078,
0.071417667,
0.2048653215,
-0.1926566511,
0.617097199,
0.0046818973,
-0.7880575657,
-0.0234545637,
-0.5035558939,
-0.6991651654,
-0.3611854315,
-0.545763135,
0.134490937,
-0.1299688816,
-0.3670410812,
-0.5126617551,
-0.0008669549,
-0.5181161165,
0.4497045875,
0.0096607273,
1.0392947197,
-0.7415690422,
0.5769079924,
0.7273364663,
-0.2052239776,
-0.4411067367,
0.1273538023,
0.4373414218,
-0.43383497,
0.9503609538,
0.1961777359,
-0.4739504457,
-0.0817381889,
-0.555033803,
-0.764863193,
1.1857880354,
0.4365922213,
-0.4842749536,
0.4912326634,
0.0241935607,
0.2867378592,
-0.7132285237,
0.3307922781,
0.1086366698,
0.486287117,
0.2210422605,
-0.3488059938,
-0.191248104,
-0.2702294588,
-0.1877375394,
0.0712323636,
-0.5425263643,
0.643633008,
-0.0267705265,
-0.3339366913,
-0.47823596,
0.7175962925,
0.2610322833,
0.708846271,
0.3776671886,
0.7896795273,
0.8216871023,
-0.0301274508,
1.060957551,
-0.337623924,
0.5208254457,
1.0482393503,
-0.3990407586,
0.9563606381,
0.4822519422,
0.1318870485,
0.5192831159,
0.6470557451,
0.5111063123,
0.3886575699,
0.0234463792,
-0.6953940392,
-0.1501935422,
-0.2557881176,
-0.3638526797,
0.036832355,
0.6244465113,
-0.3476329148,
-0.1493731588,
0.2793679535,
0.137584269,
-0.0292373728,
-0.4550521076,
0.5378649831,
0.4521436095,
-0.0133767175,
0.5540575981,
-0.017389169,
1.1781361103,
-0.5112508535,
-0.0333215035,
-0.5707662702,
0.1620705575,
-0.7110353112,
-0.7844290137,
0.3015236855,
0.2048144937,
-0.4517073929,
-0.2913473845,
1.2056703568,
-0.7955464721,
-0.185513705,
0.6692992449,
0.5119709969,
0.1249783263,
-0.2954461575,
-0.6808213592,
0.298960954,
-0.1166836321,
-0.4982258677,
0.2988940179,
0.6884351969,
0.0075756018,
0.7807859182,
0.3263456821,
0.0199841745,
0.1268023849,
0.0699474439,
0.9084451795,
-0.6732828617,
-0.1735760272,
-0.5994119048,
0.4450220764,
-0.0267982073,
-0.1160053909,
0.9441197515,
0.6066063643,
0.6466561556,
-0.0955913737,
0.8066132069,
0.0626471639,
0.8653848767,
-0.5207858086,
0.7590212226,
-0.9013216496,
0.2740802765,
-0.5211299062,
-0.9360566735,
-0.641282618,
0.4497904181,
-0.2449686676,
0.0166200846,
0.6311097741,
0.9462664723,
-0.2124610841,
0.104574129,
0.3823975921,
0.4404337406,
-0.0902628005,
0.4602044523,
0.7438405752,
-0.3999043405,
0.0944696665,
-0.1263450831,
-0.1670395434,
-0.7222226858,
-0.9157469273,
-0.6284389496,
-0.2715677917,
-0.3177523911,
-0.4546021223,
0.2240386307,
1.0497143269,
0.3912521601,
-0.6486709714,
0.0582086444,
0.5808312297,
0.3673150837,
0.2921395302,
-0.3124512136,
0.1958118379,
-0.2473968118,
-0.4994854629,
0.6371199489,
0.6296755672,
-0.1578867733,
0.1023601592,
-0.3873149455,
-0.5955256224,
0.2669505179,
0.6690734029,
0.4064367414,
-0.4206093252,
-0.132894367,
-0.1075471938,
-0.2606505156,
0.238141939,
0.5543227792,
-0.921549201,
0.6182374358,
0.3079837859,
0.9531889558,
0.542075038,
0.2438952774,
0.0149774961,
-0.9039904475,
0.0495425016,
0.4010320604,
0.3164251745,
0.6064246893,
-0.5896161199,
0.3194770813,
0.3824663758,
-0.5645007491,
-0.5471507311,
0.0400779434,
-1.0053225756,
0.0201232284,
1.1870337725,
-0.1038688719,
-0.4139384925,
0.1139427125,
-0.3417050242,
0.2557773888,
-0.5533760786,
0.8297542334,
0.2916868329,
-0.2486994565,
-0.3281592131,
-0.2945474982,
0.4607572258,
0.4506207705,
-1.0500223637,
-0.2346150726,
0.6109545231,
0.3070624769,
-0.1156119257,
0.3626514971,
-0.2187246382,
0.2486539185,
-0.4471839964,
0.3407413065,
-0.0352279544,
-0.2539379895,
-0.4547696412,
-0.1048653573,
-0.3860663176,
0.1183464602
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11087v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11087v2 | MemDPT: Differential Privacy for Memory Efficient Language Models | 2024-06-16T22:11:41 | 2024-06-20T05:43:50 | Yanming Liu, Xinyue Peng, Jiannan Cao, Yuwei Zhang, Chen Ma, Songhang Deng, Mengchen Fu, Xuhong Zhang, Sheng Cheng, Xun Wang, Jianwei Yin, Tianyu Du | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Large language models have consistently demonstrated remarkable performance
across a wide spectrum of applications. Nonetheless, the deployment of these
models can inadvertently expose user privacy to potential risks. The
substantial memory demands of these models during training represent a
significant resource consumption challenge. The sheer size of these models
imposes a considerable burden on memory resources, which is a matter of
significant concern in practice. In this paper, we present an innovative
training framework MemDPT that not only reduces the memory cost of large
language models but also places a strong emphasis on safeguarding user data
privacy. MemDPT provides edge network and reverse network designs to
accommodate various differential privacy memory-efficient fine-tuning schemes.
Our approach not only achieves $2 \sim 3 \times$ memory optimization but also
provides robust privacy protection, ensuring that user data remains secure and
confidential. Extensive experiments have demonstrated that MemDPT can
effectively provide differential privacy efficient fine-tuning across various
task scenarios. | [
-0.4388596714,
-0.5826792717,
0.2035086602,
0.0548379533,
-0.2324981093,
0.0614452474,
-0.0620787814,
-0.1963827461,
-0.0827162042,
0.5419732928,
-0.7084451318,
-0.4213849902,
-0.4126570225,
-0.1807582527,
-0.0654341429,
0.5243942142,
0.0082900422,
0.093176648,
0.2696002126,
-0.0900183693,
-0.1463301927,
-0.8526573181,
-0.7346705794,
-0.1710526049,
0.3465998173,
0.4091684818,
0.6861643791,
0.9378892779,
0.1558598578,
0.3059310913,
0.1241375953,
0.0748829246,
-0.6196672916,
0.2184393704,
-0.4742245376,
-0.1060276777,
-0.5790277719,
-0.0160215646,
0.5801151991,
0.6464759707,
-0.1068515554,
0.1431480199,
0.036594525,
0.841753006,
-1.0212626457,
-0.2105525136,
-0.6135758162,
0.037964493,
-0.2774604857,
-0.2814130187,
-0.2321503758,
-0.2227794081,
0.1451404691,
-0.0900596455,
0.0346995033,
-0.1515393406,
0.431224823,
0.1428637654,
-0.3816567361,
0.3878937662,
-0.6135846972,
0.863773644,
-0.5652601719,
0.7257624865,
0.5979534388,
0.3618328869,
-0.0479357541,
-0.425289005,
-0.481729269,
0.1251778603,
0.4325850606,
-0.0612590201,
-0.3268900216,
0.3272640109,
0.232390359,
0.3515589237,
-0.6706461906,
0.5187258124,
-0.1457776874,
-0.4507772923,
0.3922286332,
0.3605545163,
0.1857198924,
0.3686003387,
-0.3759024441,
-0.2257562131,
-0.767319262,
-0.0962444022,
0.9083458781,
0.2414836138,
-0.1686214954,
0.5381385684,
-0.5691926479,
0.7165576816,
-0.3329203129,
-0.2550180554,
0.0564400069,
0.0629360899,
-0.1577464938,
0.0043081543,
0.5584759116,
0.5596807599,
0.3176447749,
-0.2161813229,
-0.091521509,
0.0878731757,
0.1173290461,
-1.1734477282,
-0.4341810644,
0.2028214633,
-0.4956947267,
-0.3310576975,
-0.1496895552,
-0.8336573839,
-0.293636173,
-0.3372950852,
0.2105451524,
-0.4871256948,
-0.677935183,
0.3121177256,
-0.0530564226,
-0.0899827927,
0.0076840986,
-1.4557806253,
0.8229911327,
0.9330371022,
0.7971942425,
-0.1597358584,
-0.399497956,
-0.5154334903,
0.4938748181,
0.0144654587,
0.2664594948,
-0.7380939722,
-0.3156117201,
-0.2084249556,
-0.1946199983,
-0.176952064,
-0.3224535882,
-0.0393860899,
-0.4805423617,
0.0329838693,
0.0165489446,
-0.4288398623,
-0.2555209398,
0.3698351979,
-0.4647185802,
0.4234484434,
0.2457091659,
-0.8940222859,
0.0516248606,
-0.5024827123,
-0.357440412,
-0.2611749768,
-0.2440767139,
-0.5247168541,
0.1712995917,
0.1873752922,
0.7085282803,
-0.1785122752,
-0.0282229334,
-0.4309889078,
-0.3332747221,
0.1756562442,
-0.5530933142,
0.8318274021,
0.4197855294,
-0.3739354014,
-0.1643948406,
-0.9858987331,
0.0153140211,
0.057210803,
-0.3579183221,
-0.7824195027,
-0.4101242423,
-0.0894086137,
0.0722811893,
0.3619467616,
-0.7066950798,
0.1001408026,
-0.4348207414,
0.5129052997,
0.9519428015,
-0.1239341348,
0.6376130581,
-0.0086526247,
0.5720185637,
0.0939911678,
0.4175571799,
0.1543052346,
-0.399510473,
-0.0211836472,
-0.4378953576,
0.3773258924,
0.4708765149,
-0.4887959659,
0.3312171996,
-0.2510315776,
-0.3096772432,
-0.0980567634,
0.0036753856,
0.4782682061,
0.6651968956,
0.2287756205,
-0.2883016467,
-0.2800491452,
-1.1082123518,
-0.4176853895,
0.0245072134,
-0.1024920493,
0.6759576201,
0.0638221577,
-0.4489738941,
0.6290876269,
-0.5607858896,
-0.2450879663,
-0.1826656908,
-0.1477222443,
-0.0018694663,
0.9723992944,
0.4905402362,
-0.7542206049,
-0.2529809475,
-0.3198083043,
-0.1738156825,
-0.1000817791,
-0.0378620289,
-0.0712662041,
0.3412145376,
0.3612134457,
-0.3179470003,
0.2137280852,
1.0566295385,
-0.3540939987,
0.3428192139,
-0.5303481817,
-0.0697902665,
-1.1736366749,
0.0393608585,
-0.3601123095,
-0.4137626588,
-0.4788792431,
-0.1600383967,
0.3660803139,
-0.3390425146,
-0.5809752941,
0.6029245257,
-0.5205075145,
0.1301623583,
-0.2451979816,
-0.3708664775,
-0.1902591735,
0.4029862285,
-0.0520740077,
0.7633067966,
0.801469326,
-0.8623515964,
0.0745891035,
-0.0225259736,
0.2135397196,
0.5795961618,
-0.2098780125,
0.4286823273,
0.2049369365,
-0.1776827276,
-0.8531080484,
-0.1490491331,
0.2352166772,
-0.2086619884,
0.7214146256,
-0.3096504807,
-0.6350422502,
-0.1759350151,
-0.6772488356,
0.5119024515,
0.4763867855,
-0.757420361,
0.5576807261,
0.8864375353,
0.1008604243,
-0.9129837155,
-0.6828094721,
0.1868675202,
-0.3758423626,
-0.4997727871,
0.2859424949,
0.162446484,
-0.0888084993,
-0.1792352349,
-0.3978847563,
-0.3602294922,
0.4335945845,
0.3132351339,
-0.3005747497,
0.004041539,
-0.0584607273,
0.5320085883,
-0.6335569024,
-0.1214355305,
-0.5380721092,
0.9655060768,
0.0242391732,
-0.1482840925,
-0.5446937084,
0.4244319201,
0.134834215,
-0.2066859454,
0.7707387805,
0.3391990364,
-0.4299978018,
-0.3302032948,
-0.6537820697,
-0.4892526865,
-0.5861207247,
0.464517206,
-0.5578305721,
-1.0167535543,
0.3814301193,
-0.5652811527,
0.0247531887,
0.0028531188,
0.6263440847,
0.2640618384,
1.0629709959,
0.8268683553,
-0.3240121603,
0.6434092522,
-0.147887215,
0.0804531574,
-0.8964073062,
0.1318298429,
-0.213925764,
-0.5390862823,
-0.7108044624,
-0.1394852251,
0.0978938863,
-0.1932548732,
-0.3388855755,
0.5335797071,
-0.6078498363,
0.7149405479,
0.6845132709,
0.2596665621,
0.1718770564,
0.0072703315,
-0.1885019094,
-0.1182423905,
-0.330573082,
-0.496094197,
1.3564419746,
0.5497613549,
1.1417822838,
0.1636502892,
0.9398025274,
-0.1645631194,
-0.363797754,
-0.1993523836,
0.7536982894,
-0.3503950536,
-0.6387136579,
-0.3305915892,
-0.7995330691,
-0.9333392978,
0.0494952947,
0.1470966786,
-1.1311461926,
0.1800337583,
0.2704337239,
-0.2193279713,
0.5276466608,
-0.6910708547,
0.8548467159,
-0.1698979884,
-0.6330031753,
-0.6014273763,
-0.8750526309,
0.2822893858,
0.0477982238,
-0.2394757122,
-0.3341349661,
-0.257386446,
0.7296462059,
-0.373223424,
0.8878849745,
-0.6598469019,
0.1128658131,
-0.2413882762,
0.4752656817,
0.3824633062,
0.4380866289,
-0.0866467878,
0.3778928816,
-0.026544895,
-0.1737544686,
-0.2065412402,
0.9710175991,
-0.6767180562,
-0.5120021701,
-0.1160824001,
-0.8166648746,
-0.2422321141,
0.4780055881,
0.0760449693,
0.515393436,
-0.1551550031,
0.0764327645,
0.7978749275,
-0.5262812972,
0.3604064882,
0.685721159,
0.0980190635,
-0.2330140322,
0.980296731,
0.1514668018,
0.2936465442,
0.5980747342,
0.4149822593,
-0.6291007996,
-0.7058743834,
-0.3473128378,
0.1860962659,
-0.5118137598,
-0.214417398,
-0.96547544,
-0.0586727001,
-0.3877615631,
0.0350714028,
-0.9162458181,
-1.0858855247,
-0.2154189944,
-0.2083814591,
0.4066281021,
0.0513259694,
-0.5414226651,
0.5635264516,
-0.4192236364,
0.3691286445,
0.3809515238,
0.8224307299,
-0.2449464202,
-0.3340898156,
0.0967627987,
-0.0133763608,
-0.4210669696,
-0.4877815247,
0.3201445043,
0.2396383286,
0.427099824,
0.5411078334,
0.2192865014,
0.4376798272,
-0.6803992987,
0.4843554795,
0.1161122769,
-0.8445903063,
0.3171152174,
-0.2833400071,
0.0116097247,
0.8719747066,
0.26529634,
-0.1664333344,
-0.3770954609,
-0.730895102,
-0.8238939047,
0.451020956,
-0.0295460802,
0.6368731856,
0.2159837782,
0.5579716563,
0.4349544644,
0.2067933977,
-0.4645622671,
-0.2939166725,
-0.1311719567,
-0.077684544,
0.0925336182,
-0.4687065184,
-0.1709548533,
-0.3360615969,
0.4713983834,
-0.0382035859,
0.1128573418,
-0.1557050347,
0.0682019442,
0.1796815097,
0.1565126032,
0.6415091157,
0.7291516662,
-0.3612724245,
0.6561009288,
0.1103513837,
-0.7886604071,
0.338627845,
0.1718481034,
-0.1192190573,
-0.2130271196,
-0.4674719274,
0.2882394493,
0.0506384932,
-0.4026944637,
0.5200739503,
-0.3762551248,
-0.30101493,
-0.1228780821,
0.37694031,
0.1953966916,
0.3276607394,
-0.1665428132,
0.0212292783,
0.3714590371,
-0.097678721,
0.4683410227,
0.440702796,
-0.3411294818,
-0.4217813909,
1.0152478218,
0.022120975,
-0.2138934731,
0.4966773093,
-0.0037383318,
-0.414781332,
0.1373015642,
0.7166401744,
1.0082426071,
-0.6447707415,
-0.0461629853,
0.0974285305,
0.1423473358,
-0.2057067454,
0.5265778303,
-0.1915658116,
-0.4827127159,
0.092317827,
-0.364289552,
-0.6548492908,
0.2947039902,
-0.3635385036,
0.2092690319,
-0.858633399,
-0.1134763137,
-0.3389928341,
-0.0905077755,
-0.4057439566,
0.2486415803,
0.2642917633,
0.818320632,
-0.5409141779,
1.2317063808,
0.4586399496,
0.1029178873,
-0.5809381604,
-0.1683450639,
0.1348834485,
-0.9333319068,
0.2430079877,
0.5121165514,
-0.2760983407,
0.2466863245,
-0.3548188806,
-0.5250008106,
0.9135833979,
0.7620012164,
-0.6534092426,
0.4260255098,
0.3665760159,
0.3362174332,
-0.1245690137,
-0.2866261005,
0.4356540442,
0.1180406213,
-0.183376804,
-0.697165966,
0.3533613682,
0.0442327447,
0.038177155,
0.0784798265,
-0.6217864752,
1.0426476002,
-0.0498772413,
-0.2991679609,
-0.2428909093,
0.3091784716,
0.2441316992,
0.1279112995,
0.5697882771,
0.5224927664,
0.8266320825,
0.2071682364,
0.9660093784,
-0.4939823151,
0.0420000926,
1.0278730392,
-0.1045948491,
0.6254837513,
0.579455018,
0.1516299844,
-0.1217758581,
0.6183809042,
0.2209041268,
1.0056371689,
0.5742854476,
-0.2336034924,
-0.037612807,
-0.0148551296,
-0.5571421981,
0.2760483921,
0.0831221193,
-0.370487988,
-0.3563779593,
-0.0945249274,
0.2991693616,
0.0408390388,
-0.2453320622,
0.7735871673,
0.3191214502,
-0.0242510214,
0.5559713244,
0.1565548927,
0.6665809751,
-0.4591847956,
0.2387107611,
-0.1461327374,
0.8049847484,
-0.0044750953,
-0.5218904614,
0.4895111322,
-0.186262995,
0.1077394709,
-0.3181603253,
0.5896865726,
-0.2507772446,
-0.0539306179,
0.4254217446,
0.3801737726,
0.2617401481,
-0.4287908077,
-0.8075240254,
-0.1085964739,
-0.2279514372,
-0.4835447073,
0.745375514,
0.4701195061,
0.0941141099,
0.646558404,
0.5619104505,
0.2316014171,
-0.0062050326,
0.3524654508,
1.1559470892,
-0.5856096148,
-0.9108500481,
-1.4758943319,
0.2144006193,
-0.1464644372,
-0.2756967247,
0.7477057576,
0.8436207771,
0.6853125095,
-0.0342404656,
0.6858760715,
0.295111835,
0.6992681623,
-0.5180592537,
0.9524370432,
-0.3637654185,
0.3990640938,
-0.2870559394,
-0.9479418993,
-0.5223776102,
0.6057927608,
-0.287814796,
-0.2754999995,
0.2397918552,
0.8295658231,
-0.5655834675,
-0.0674428642,
0.3775954545,
-0.040967606,
0.5807552934,
0.7103773355,
0.8036830425,
-0.2991984487,
0.2151066959,
-0.706099093,
-0.5289537311,
-0.0448838957,
-0.9602334499,
-1.2738875151,
-0.4794797003,
-0.2730685771,
-0.1317703873,
0.0336103365,
0.7173147798,
0.8685188293,
-0.7519021034,
-0.2154249996,
-0.2580842078,
0.0137226461,
-0.1729885489,
-0.0989970192,
0.5021502972,
0.0393177085,
-0.5447419882,
0.3464801908,
0.5591172576,
0.3871050775,
-0.2438968271,
-0.012947714,
0.0943977609,
-0.0121174529,
0.1521515101,
0.3547656238,
-0.1222506464,
-0.1901833415,
-0.1967284828,
-0.1341277659,
-0.0252525806,
0.680470705,
-0.4519665837,
0.5334980488,
0.4063475132,
0.8200146556,
0.6224719286,
0.1585478336,
0.9269062281,
-0.8481819034,
0.6811717153,
0.3633515239,
0.1554412991,
0.2990877926,
-0.5508554578,
0.5989367962,
0.0241366699,
-0.470243752,
-1.0425871611,
0.3237100244,
-0.9186745286,
-0.3470207155,
0.9129189849,
-0.2090035677,
-0.2491606474,
-0.3864343762,
-0.1045713872,
0.1212438941,
-0.4500522912,
0.963947475,
0.1052045822,
-0.013728328,
-0.1938836128,
-0.5760212541,
0.6686637998,
0.2802429199,
-0.3980568051,
0.5709133148,
-0.0061921747,
0.3511331975,
-0.198267445,
0.7773832083,
-0.2815330923,
-0.0137105957,
0.0152925812,
-0.1530668885,
-0.5162963867,
-0.4083724916,
-0.3478844464,
0.0142113082,
-0.1460015178,
-0.6353865266
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11085v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11085v1 | Multiple Sources are Better Than One: Incorporating External Knowledge in Low-Resource Glossing | 2024-06-16T22:01:15 | 2024-06-16T22:01:15 | Changbing Yang, Garrett Nicolai, Miikka Silfverberg | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this paper, we address the data scarcity problem in automatic data-driven
glossing for low-resource languages by coordinating multiple sources of
linguistic expertise. We supplement models with translations at both the token
and sentence level as well as leverage the extensive linguistic capability of
modern LLMs. Our enhancements lead to an average absolute improvement of
5%-points in word-level accuracy over the previous state of the art on a
typologically diverse dataset spanning six low-resource languages. The
improvements are particularly noticeable for the lowest-resourced language
Gitksan, where we achieve a 10%-point improvement. Furthermore, in a simulated
ultra-low resource setting for the same six languages, training on fewer than
100 glossed sentences, we establish an average 10%-point improvement in
word-level accuracy over the previous state-of-the-art system. | [
-0.3775053322,
-0.4170348346,
0.6922374368,
0.1854874194,
-0.0752539486,
0.2620881796,
-0.6509305239,
-0.5729327202,
0.2780018449,
0.3853574991,
-0.259211272,
-0.3936476111,
-0.7568491101,
0.1958700866,
-0.1698152572,
0.8078330159,
-0.1527145803,
0.2208266556,
-0.0696164742,
-0.4459508359,
-0.1483206153,
-0.3836476505,
-0.6505408883,
-0.0744559243,
0.5822514296,
0.8454514742,
1.0097032785,
0.5417604446,
0.6774399281,
0.3103733659,
-0.0418998785,
0.6869378686,
-0.5252321959,
0.1310248971,
-0.3388853371,
-0.4576133192,
-0.434527427,
-0.054597728,
0.4632158279,
0.6413431168,
-0.2714277208,
0.0016749285,
0.1114208996,
1.002887249,
-0.8292928338,
0.1968991011,
-0.7779875398,
-0.2968043089,
-0.3072846234,
0.1084064767,
-0.0888699293,
-0.3387200832,
0.1611981094,
-1.0136710405,
0.1108898297,
-0.1198539138,
0.8801869154,
0.5653187037,
-0.2099908292,
-0.5536109209,
-0.7121178508,
0.7916134,
-0.7288618684,
0.3425257802,
0.6265933514,
0.2200391293,
0.3043779433,
-0.4248268604,
-0.4588469565,
-0.1808500886,
-0.1793571413,
0.1223630458,
0.072083354,
0.0967648849,
0.1346076429,
0.3542654514,
0.0268565249,
0.0987706631,
-0.4229878783,
-0.0649184808,
0.6035887599,
-0.0059274966,
0.0506088249,
-0.2281593978,
-0.0614061393,
-0.1008244082,
-0.5549756289,
-0.2609822452,
0.0975769535,
0.7968659401,
-0.1802790165,
0.6144497395,
-0.4972031713,
0.556019187,
-0.0000823747,
-0.4218064547,
0.3117044866,
-0.9500066638,
-0.1494570971,
-0.3735536933,
0.7427122593,
0.2334271371,
0.2730696797,
-0.3253068626,
-0.1918515265,
-0.3548133671,
0.0805443376,
-0.2669758797,
-0.2777613401,
-0.0116526382,
-0.067979157,
-0.0198675226,
0.0042516207,
-0.7030656338,
-0.5819391608,
-0.4814578295,
0.0941452608,
-0.5619805455,
-0.0288671497,
-0.2248246372,
-0.0028802981,
-0.2029971778,
0.3345061839,
-0.9448503256,
0.2556740344,
0.2704307139,
1.2724670172,
-0.1845020801,
-0.2218926698,
-0.6637201309,
0.4355641603,
-0.5088908076,
0.8850497007,
-0.4007943273,
-0.2272332758,
0.0766141415,
-0.2528485954,
0.0938472077,
-0.8399122953,
0.3999219537,
-0.4249535501,
0.075474456,
-0.4772806466,
-0.4260993302,
0.0090321396,
-0.14158611,
-0.7462927699,
1.2199953794,
0.4002078772,
-0.3577822149,
0.6877362132,
-0.726334393,
-0.3341856003,
0.2405810356,
-0.0874548778,
-0.0753635019,
0.3748597801,
0.4433616698,
0.1308324635,
-0.3265604973,
0.4044544697,
-0.2339907736,
-0.0382026881,
0.1324039996,
-0.1794763356,
0.4504319429,
0.3156113029,
-0.0455458239,
0.172963798,
-0.8963513374,
0.1488753706,
-0.1527933031,
-0.7090422511,
-0.5252327323,
-0.2419184297,
0.0587047562,
0.4391924441,
0.3616111875,
-0.2266311049,
0.281462729,
-0.6878610253,
0.1220471635,
0.7812319994,
-0.1711939424,
0.8708308339,
-0.4860359728,
0.4362127483,
0.0154314553,
0.1169358492,
0.1623112857,
-0.4534436464,
-1.1339167356,
-0.2763626277,
0.2141669989,
0.6490371823,
-1.3765884638,
0.2363371402,
-0.491230458,
-0.3031857312,
-0.8279328346,
0.7500671148,
0.3589050174,
0.2960970998,
0.6601765752,
-0.2179570645,
-0.3038973808,
-1.0594934225,
-0.0646496043,
-0.0666733459,
-0.0030961935,
0.3365801573,
0.1995036602,
0.0019955537,
0.928573668,
-0.3851885796,
-0.5220452547,
-0.2245941907,
-0.0038067924,
0.2297556549,
0.3196607232,
0.4228261411,
-0.4216302335,
-0.9845058322,
0.0059465496,
-0.6485716701,
-0.2592297196,
0.00879928,
-0.4033876359,
0.5707756877,
0.2666150928,
-0.4048710763,
0.0422166586,
0.5493320823,
0.0299079642,
0.2584030032,
-0.5270573497,
-0.0398680717,
-0.9848784804,
0.0023959973,
0.2207375169,
0.0514129065,
-0.8728044033,
0.0806498826,
0.0864147395,
0.1910776794,
-0.4410493374,
0.6270927787,
-0.6693245173,
0.0003001076,
-0.4054655135,
0.4609844387,
-0.1932256073,
0.4641980827,
-0.0742288902,
1.0717556477,
0.7424244285,
-0.6976600885,
0.6091464162,
0.315153569,
-0.4766200185,
0.6441031694,
-0.1499840021,
0.0833707973,
-0.1069720909,
-0.2238725275,
-0.7103024125,
-0.4612615407,
0.3029712439,
0.0138490358,
0.2948638797,
-0.205930233,
-0.7699649334,
-0.1955390275,
-0.3408771753,
-0.0185899362,
0.32671839,
-0.6388096213,
0.3866013288,
0.5958022475,
-0.4190652668,
-0.5546760559,
-0.8750259876,
0.25938344,
-0.1087457687,
-0.7391680479,
0.211920321,
-0.1408672184,
-0.5356667638,
-0.0999448225,
-0.1559131891,
-0.2511748075,
-0.0061848005,
-0.106940493,
0.0829318836,
-0.059875384,
0.4926459789,
-0.1996062994,
-0.1649505943,
-0.3784889281,
-0.5312756896,
0.1365731508,
0.0135189574,
-0.1982865483,
-0.3052440882,
0.4461950362,
0.3255583644,
0.2205226421,
0.901061058,
0.4335601926,
-0.2286682874,
-0.3179357052,
-0.5891253948,
0.0981897414,
-0.5349898934,
0.098214142,
-0.5347464681,
-0.6030784249,
0.5166328549,
0.0997996628,
-0.116750665,
0.5356113315,
0.3330484331,
-0.1118326411,
0.7391160727,
1.0538134575,
-0.321444273,
0.6053483486,
-0.2530262172,
-0.1539178938,
-0.5814040899,
-0.0047733001,
-0.1849392205,
-0.1006112918,
-0.7858929038,
-0.6689988375,
0.4402089715,
0.3153111339,
-0.0868234709,
0.1328128427,
-0.4324540496,
0.4792979658,
0.9334295988,
0.2420098335,
0.6367536783,
0.3680013716,
-0.0381649062,
0.0106301578,
-0.9782855511,
-0.4436335564,
1.1565287113,
0.0206998456,
0.9398393631,
0.3661169708,
0.5375970006,
0.0691927969,
0.4980069697,
-0.8807507753,
0.3655571043,
-0.5222585797,
-0.5148372054,
-0.5791952014,
-0.6094231009,
-0.4821905792,
0.2879016101,
-0.245685786,
-0.4489509761,
0.239806965,
0.072340861,
-0.4261585772,
0.2768748999,
-0.8177255392,
0.4152472615,
-0.3937488794,
-0.4299263954,
-0.2119353116,
-0.4335427284,
0.2480732799,
-0.4041000903,
0.5082451701,
-0.2728609443,
-0.5602932572,
0.7315376401,
-0.6395488977,
0.6159138083,
-0.1336931735,
-0.4849317372,
0.2369598001,
-0.294798851,
0.6886962056,
0.0079067554,
-0.2735604346,
0.1546969265,
-0.4450912774,
-0.5976550579,
-0.5496808887,
0.7026693225,
-0.7025046349,
-0.6198733449,
-0.3670700192,
-0.6611421108,
-0.5541715026,
0.0948713049,
0.1714095324,
0.2097084373,
0.1574795842,
-0.2595692575,
0.3242050111,
-0.188590616,
0.4494103491,
0.7101512551,
0.0380579941,
-0.6595064402,
1.0389215946,
0.3729484677,
0.5979169011,
0.1725480109,
0.0219502766,
-0.2325399518,
-0.8306830525,
-0.5337514877,
0.5349155664,
-1.0611107349,
-0.3021856844,
-0.4253695011,
-0.084533155,
-0.3689296246,
-0.1765034348,
-0.4218185842,
-0.5195118785,
-0.1876437515,
-0.0162342079,
0.5191805959,
0.9101779461,
-0.4437705278,
0.6156075597,
-0.8242976069,
0.4697471559,
0.1392455995,
0.7084273696,
-0.3143044114,
-0.5820019245,
-0.7426312566,
0.0664573312,
-0.0093160626,
-0.69183743,
0.5196272731,
0.489007771,
0.6387304068,
0.1306010932,
-0.1506335884,
0.7788168788,
-0.3242351115,
0.6186881661,
0.1564515531,
-0.9048601985,
0.5066910982,
-0.1971625239,
0.6635434031,
1.0225930214,
0.4322550595,
-0.6091248989,
-0.9397827387,
-0.5372753143,
-1.0508718491,
1.163449645,
0.1894135475,
-0.1411890835,
0.1619505435,
0.312068969,
0.1420805156,
0.1017353907,
-0.5854083896,
-0.5447103381,
0.0504852571,
-0.3026008308,
-0.3069430888,
-0.2169192582,
-0.1910673529,
-0.0787663087,
1.0735617876,
-0.3992818296,
-0.0402286239,
-0.1529444903,
-0.3462899923,
-0.2036398649,
0.3254573345,
0.438077122,
0.911760211,
-0.0314400569,
0.2806889713,
0.5120553374,
-0.4563751519,
0.0964418352,
0.1714698821,
-0.2875109613,
0.1962140948,
0.3533923924,
0.6788352132,
0.069450438,
-0.3712972701,
0.186362043,
0.2486667782,
0.063408792,
-0.0713505596,
-0.0292983707,
0.0512988418,
0.1038310677,
0.5925924182,
0.3347821236,
-0.1001755148,
-0.2949726284,
0.2405100912,
0.3398288488,
-0.1249604747,
0.0231473949,
0.4032282233,
0.37584427,
0.1835094541,
0.4535432458,
-0.4461292326,
-0.2198191583,
0.3391885161,
-0.0779900849,
0.4424187243,
-0.1199226081,
0.2475629598,
0.5843366981,
0.3560628295,
-0.3748075068,
0.3107256889,
0.0298529752,
-0.7275149822,
-0.6785228252,
-0.487626493,
-0.5970084071,
0.2607860267,
-0.3782037199,
0.3367113173,
-0.278588295,
-0.223725006,
0.0796330646,
0.1408095509,
-0.6085957885,
-0.056706287,
0.2475779802,
0.7208034992,
-0.5653944612,
0.9228668809,
0.5726742148,
-0.7603937984,
-0.4638984203,
0.184312582,
0.0296321288,
-0.8498458266,
0.8692541718,
-0.2238788754,
-0.1612346172,
-0.0815232843,
-0.4916286469,
-1.6145404577,
0.8695536256,
0.4415158033,
-0.5951901674,
-0.0687610358,
0.2548848093,
0.5828078985,
-0.1916957498,
0.2300091088,
0.6367982626,
0.6520661116,
-0.1171313822,
-1.3593389988,
0.0651185662,
-0.0247649346,
0.1246842444,
0.1788031906,
-0.5034505129,
0.5729589462,
-0.2401091009,
-0.7843050361,
-0.028182447,
0.7209467888,
-0.0457002595,
-0.0058816932,
0.4054791927,
0.3873790205,
1.0075637102,
-0.0346442685,
0.9572108984,
-0.6918964982,
0.1753590256,
1.352170229,
-0.0290436484,
0.6132118702,
0.4824405015,
-0.2962273061,
0.300176084,
0.3914151788,
0.0992385894,
0.7447116375,
0.1257037967,
-0.4505936503,
-0.1407012194,
-0.3054317236,
-0.1559540033,
0.2155166864,
0.4755778313,
-0.082429111,
-0.3057352602,
0.2889165878,
-0.1582555771,
0.1256906986,
-0.3382086456,
1.0697842836,
0.0980649889,
-0.5655856133,
0.8302074075,
0.0878341645,
1.1486195326,
-0.5248522758,
0.2919309437,
-0.5150088072,
0.0600159392,
-0.2865132987,
-0.7388421297,
0.3495368361,
0.0921867788,
-0.1820665449,
-0.4126294553,
0.5699937344,
-0.7468361855,
-0.4907246232,
0.4539457262,
1.0911153555,
0.151234746,
0.0104026366,
-0.6451020837,
-0.2413978726,
-0.2622714639,
0.0448033586,
0.1477493346,
0.5023804307,
0.1151088998,
0.8811373115,
0.5166400075,
0.5013635159,
0.1731478572,
0.435005784,
0.9903503656,
-0.6491803527,
-0.4182762206,
-0.599701643,
0.1336887032,
-0.321385473,
-0.2170295566,
0.8239248395,
0.609572947,
1.0272780657,
-0.0070144832,
1.106600523,
-0.1063658968,
0.4990809858,
-0.6566235423,
0.4448546171,
-0.5187378526,
0.4307411313,
0.0130377337,
-0.8693976998,
-0.2969686389,
0.4085061848,
-0.3191932738,
-0.058648251,
0.9182369709,
0.7824751139,
-0.0706944913,
-0.415805161,
0.3203704357,
0.1162199154,
0.0605057627,
0.6087093353,
0.853710711,
-0.1918873787,
0.8534241319,
-0.6293166876,
-0.1788561493,
0.0293001477,
-0.5106165409,
-0.5485471487,
-0.6797297597,
-0.3167773783,
-0.1697382629,
0.0756611004,
0.9259676933,
0.7717297077,
-1.041382432,
-0.3088970482,
-0.1037909314,
0.2341752201,
-0.1787816882,
-0.2243703753,
0.1796952039,
-0.9080010653,
-0.7301978469,
0.7059929967,
0.1991901696,
0.0541840494,
-0.2942005992,
-0.106968008,
-0.3051466644,
0.0380428135,
0.5967311859,
0.05344202,
-0.7653471828,
-0.3213042915,
-0.1759821177,
-0.5963401198,
0.3657433093,
0.7475495338,
-0.5886737108,
0.3501102924,
0.4164195955,
0.328809768,
0.4317522347,
0.0829690918,
0.4945598841,
-0.9931820631,
0.0973331183,
-0.0659799501,
0.2882632017,
0.6658470631,
-0.2498929501,
0.8795141578,
0.3739804327,
-0.2549585104,
-0.4053658545,
0.1742626876,
-0.857760489,
-0.3658810258,
1.3556865454,
-0.0256856363,
0.044585295,
-0.386759311,
-0.0631662458,
0.310608238,
-0.7143242359,
0.8718819022,
0.9972929955,
-0.194955796,
-0.0586404912,
-0.7657334805,
0.9401942492,
0.2785535753,
-1.1631686687,
0.2495190799,
0.7376298904,
0.093539156,
0.4732976258,
0.9376888871,
0.3138290942,
-0.1147252619,
-0.1035618708,
-0.0480955057,
0.0506920554,
-0.3025031984,
-0.4855686724,
0.0537958257,
0.1931469589,
0.2218869179
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15476v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15476v1 | Self-Regulated Data-Free Knowledge Amalgamation for Text Classification | 2024-06-16T21:13:30 | 2024-06-16T21:13:30 | Prashanth Vijayaraghavan, Hongzhi Wang, Luyao Shi, Tyler Baldwin, David Beymer, Ehsan Degan | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recently, there has been a growing availability of pre-trained text models on
various model repositories. These models greatly reduce the cost of training
new models from scratch as they can be fine-tuned for specific tasks or trained
on large datasets. However, these datasets may not be publicly accessible due
to the privacy, security, or intellectual property issues. In this paper, we
aim to develop a lightweight student network that can learn from multiple
teacher models without accessing their original training data. Hence, we
investigate Data-Free Knowledge Amalgamation (DFKA), a knowledge-transfer task
that combines insights from multiple pre-trained teacher models and transfers
them effectively to a compact student network. To accomplish this, we propose
STRATANET, a modeling framework comprising: (a) a steerable data generator that
produces text data tailored to each teacher and (b) an amalgamation module that
implements a self-regulative strategy using confidence estimates from the
teachers' different layers to selectively integrate their knowledge and train a
versatile student. We evaluate our method on three benchmark text
classification datasets with varying labels or domains. Empirically, we
demonstrate that the student model learned using our STRATANET outperforms
several baselines significantly under data-driven and data-free constraints. | [
0.0645011961,
-0.0184809379,
0.4512146413,
-0.0328536592,
-0.2568601668,
0.0078183776,
0.0287320893,
-0.4234845638,
0.1320532113,
0.7645108104,
-0.2844776511,
-0.5546978116,
-0.598317802,
0.0528337881,
-0.8638300896,
1.0487239361,
-0.1308723837,
-0.2405442446,
-0.4693556428,
0.0058632647,
-0.3477430046,
-0.5779705644,
-0.2341448367,
-0.3106252849,
0.5345099568,
0.5626072884,
0.3127563596,
0.7387760282,
0.4342508018,
0.3663421869,
0.1918590814,
0.0979296342,
-0.3083908856,
-0.0130412141,
-0.4081773162,
-0.4753963947,
-0.2078844011,
0.2067097574,
0.7538619637,
0.5225596428,
-0.1657646447,
0.1884197891,
0.3179914355,
0.6379519701,
-0.8422253728,
0.1896601319,
-0.5456987023,
0.0913797542,
-0.1962663084,
0.1503089517,
-0.4775035679,
-0.3090070784,
0.1659580916,
-0.7743403912,
0.2436570376,
-0.3672605455,
0.5549798012,
0.4806805849,
-0.759175837,
-0.3573098481,
-0.7597679496,
0.5606374741,
-0.2894983292,
0.3107375205,
0.3304366469,
0.3551470041,
0.1358619034,
-1.1188470125,
-0.6562816501,
0.3623683751,
-0.3608910441,
0.4643783271,
-0.1252855957,
0.0284461025,
-0.3208558559,
0.2416836768,
-0.265429467,
0.2921257019,
-0.6100704074,
0.0440535545,
0.6504431367,
0.1658552736,
0.2392899543,
-0.7353457212,
-0.9166514874,
-0.15197815,
-0.1228034645,
0.0683159009,
0.4359994829,
0.5844904184,
-0.017603308,
0.4498275816,
-0.2404848933,
0.7140299678,
-0.16046682,
-0.0503397472,
0.0665211231,
-0.2617101073,
-0.2441956848,
0.290392071,
1.0397629738,
-0.0470191687,
-0.0220480859,
-0.3490000963,
-0.148703143,
0.048117131,
0.3301488459,
-0.8061638474,
-0.5718896985,
0.2175201178,
-0.3778237104,
-0.5340607762,
-0.0183870159,
-0.5646155477,
-0.2563726604,
-0.3763208687,
0.7052058578,
-0.3047270775,
-0.2767671049,
0.221748665,
-0.203538686,
-0.4829602242,
0.2664366663,
-0.8568567038,
0.5276151299,
0.6039568186,
0.8069924116,
-0.2171097994,
-0.4951049387,
0.1015305296,
0.3758722544,
-0.1859956533,
0.4527089894,
-0.3287528455,
-0.2957997918,
-0.1583980769,
-0.1906805784,
-0.3886831701,
-0.2066297233,
0.3277590275,
-0.5624268651,
0.3904386163,
0.0967382789,
-0.9232667089,
-0.3009829819,
0.0190854352,
-0.8116205335,
1.1147483587,
0.1949703842,
-1.0775895119,
0.4436026812,
-0.2708933055,
-0.166783005,
0.3490873873,
-0.3172061443,
-0.1882438213,
-0.3774237037,
0.0797667503,
0.8270027637,
0.0093593588,
0.6219929457,
-0.1740246713,
-0.3019881248,
0.0200936142,
-0.1963470727,
1.0571843386,
0.2285356373,
-0.2215710133,
-0.0598112047,
-0.9303274751,
0.0443244502,
-0.1947554201,
-0.36961326,
-0.9409327507,
-0.1838539094,
-0.1125944331,
0.23098737,
0.1832252145,
-0.4779964983,
0.4677207172,
-0.0895155445,
0.3855928481,
0.7896969914,
0.077749148,
0.709210515,
-0.4148639739,
0.1813509613,
0.2994399965,
0.121525161,
0.0881965756,
-0.2613840699,
-0.6245232821,
-0.5253721476,
0.6132139564,
0.481122911,
-1.0687552691,
0.3728129864,
-0.6892527938,
-0.8582940102,
-0.5071102381,
0.4704966545,
0.0827694163,
0.6091864109,
0.4368515909,
-0.2471328527,
-0.3319549263,
-0.6042129397,
-0.1124726608,
-0.2391985655,
0.0587959699,
0.3284958005,
0.5086933374,
-0.1552897096,
1.1012011766,
-0.4514759183,
-0.7236423492,
-0.0827271864,
0.0753938556,
-0.1429031491,
0.7736003399,
0.5115529895,
-0.7397161126,
-0.4604095221,
-0.1978243887,
-0.8108870387,
0.2037338763,
-0.4420471787,
-0.3018299639,
-0.2952015102,
0.2490971535,
-0.5395249128,
0.400262475,
0.5782058239,
-0.2032965273,
0.323910892,
-0.0271737967,
-0.2101816386,
-1.4779577255,
-0.0058029983,
-0.279453367,
-0.1633344293,
-0.626496017,
-0.0050123483,
0.3504295945,
-0.1994806379,
-0.3170629442,
0.6854686737,
-0.210719049,
0.1661993116,
-0.1069160029,
0.3082088828,
-0.0030381216,
0.3374413848,
0.1208369508,
0.4647285044,
0.6790326834,
-0.8421216011,
0.2417860478,
0.5936319828,
-0.4209747314,
0.1952214241,
-0.2421367466,
0.1074796841,
-0.1223701537,
0.3597677648,
-0.9997885227,
-0.2369195521,
0.3471734524,
-0.1321233511,
0.0762557387,
-0.3516375721,
-0.2464068681,
-0.3328305185,
0.1358998865,
0.3896284699,
0.2215571404,
-0.9377249479,
0.9613242745,
0.0229884945,
0.0259708222,
-0.82207793,
-0.7932872772,
-0.09054593,
-0.052317474,
-0.3837586641,
0.4588041604,
0.085026741,
0.183440879,
0.4922222197,
-0.0931533948,
-0.5951200724,
0.1644285172,
0.4103537202,
0.1262046546,
0.0906028897,
0.4820190072,
0.387560755,
0.121813789,
-0.1721989363,
-0.6163792014,
0.0641496405,
0.4183934331,
-0.1767688543,
-0.5982607603,
0.0224282388,
0.4795600474,
-0.2146577984,
0.7700610161,
0.4744437635,
-0.2821194828,
-0.7676961422,
-0.2809302807,
-0.2498956174,
-0.5155885816,
-0.0631312728,
-0.2179233879,
-0.9386152625,
0.3948510289,
-0.1170131564,
0.1178420931,
0.2993494272,
-0.0574797019,
0.0590635464,
0.2678776085,
0.8092198968,
-0.0292187426,
0.5422760248,
-0.3470975161,
-0.1861778051,
-0.5173485875,
-0.3967266083,
-0.5371715426,
-0.3709158599,
-0.4408148527,
-0.1866114736,
-0.0035707226,
0.0299454369,
-0.1073045507,
0.3602180481,
-0.6070771813,
0.5145291686,
0.6825504303,
0.3456431031,
0.3989486992,
-0.0096123144,
-0.101840876,
0.2288640141,
-0.9606605172,
-0.2653062344,
1.2211686373,
0.0892866775,
0.6777686477,
0.1515276879,
1.2388893366,
0.2438004613,
0.4844213426,
-0.7410538197,
0.5760315657,
-0.6037074924,
-0.7949566245,
-0.3120735586,
-1.1497173309,
-0.8611568809,
0.2923743725,
-0.3553276658,
-0.5560180545,
0.5011852384,
-0.0006695972,
-0.3867651224,
0.657907784,
-0.737259984,
0.5128541589,
-0.2278637737,
-0.2894989252,
0.160911724,
-0.5105777979,
0.5491907597,
-0.4829769433,
0.1753604859,
0.0143526709,
0.0913453847,
1.0752621889,
-0.3826730549,
1.1524648666,
-0.1952862144,
0.0904101133,
0.5793616772,
0.2317572236,
0.2081521749,
-0.133412227,
0.0023522435,
0.2275360972,
0.0898552239,
-0.3420982361,
-0.5602145195,
0.3958734274,
-1.2209014893,
-0.3251793385,
-0.2479213923,
-0.4020358622,
-0.1123431846,
0.647878468,
0.1355955005,
0.4479493499,
0.1523329318,
0.3835450411,
0.3012489676,
0.2781701684,
0.5067852139,
0.5500378609,
-0.107126534,
-0.4036980867,
0.9399310946,
0.5908212066,
0.1326828003,
0.4301916063,
0.3776291013,
-0.3775799274,
-0.384306252,
-0.3817480206,
-0.1094354317,
-0.8516330123,
-0.4389791489,
-0.7607684731,
-0.3330530524,
-0.620367527,
-0.0317280181,
-0.4181453288,
-0.7251909375,
-0.5669836998,
-0.3500264585,
0.2063207626,
1.0661360025,
0.0168242622,
0.8374143243,
-0.9986384511,
-0.0433594473,
0.6188703775,
0.6302011013,
0.2479780465,
-0.3821091354,
-0.1496091336,
-0.3316917419,
-0.0780847147,
-0.8641747236,
0.2224893868,
0.2323508561,
0.4255226552,
0.4169706702,
0.4619636536,
0.2414395362,
-0.2243238389,
0.6175717115,
0.3200597167,
-1.0152690411,
0.173748672,
-0.2841215432,
-0.1069460884,
0.749371767,
0.7993662357,
-0.389647603,
-0.2011484206,
-0.6632667184,
-0.7548370957,
0.6778971553,
0.0937047303,
0.2885505855,
0.4031847715,
0.8265066743,
0.2009705603,
0.2806989551,
-0.7256829143,
-0.1760670245,
-0.5602988005,
-0.6611357331,
-0.1065238789,
-0.1260369569,
-0.2204177082,
-0.1667187065,
0.523542285,
-0.1376833171,
-0.1994519979,
0.2412688136,
-0.042727761,
0.2655145526,
0.159584403,
-0.1056193709,
0.3923539817,
-0.0266978387,
0.439335525,
-0.0561608039,
-0.8183007836,
0.4293965697,
0.1886508614,
-0.5948050618,
-0.1160126999,
0.2673156857,
0.4925402999,
0.3804639876,
-0.0378364399,
0.6048099995,
-0.2720803618,
-0.5990049243,
-0.004970389,
0.2496311069,
-0.0868031457,
0.1358683556,
0.3467819691,
0.269346863,
0.1682133079,
0.0644650757,
0.5377810001,
-0.196838364,
-0.4334634244,
-0.1752444208,
0.5570574999,
0.2909812033,
0.2629015148,
0.7462297082,
0.1102311835,
-0.4510827959,
0.3249046206,
0.5258614421,
0.6847575307,
-0.4424595833,
0.6815689802,
0.2744309306,
0.3757031262,
-0.2081997395,
0.0639207587,
-0.1200000495,
-0.9777876735,
-0.1819726378,
-0.4314459264,
-0.3908952177,
-0.1172982529,
-0.7633176446,
0.0705680326,
-0.711745739,
-0.1940573901,
-0.063664332,
0.1120424196,
-0.667840302,
0.5254303813,
-0.1415850222,
0.9632799625,
-1.1109006405,
0.8557691574,
0.692902565,
-0.3384838104,
-1.2766973972,
-0.3119909167,
-0.2539816499,
-0.4089594483,
0.6090810895,
0.0874747261,
0.046166528,
0.2091698349,
-0.5472642779,
-0.7665213346,
1.2158290148,
0.2532957792,
-0.3917498589,
-0.1206254512,
0.1550780833,
0.333789587,
-0.2134386301,
-0.0463357642,
-0.0214612447,
0.1171498075,
0.2043002993,
-0.5352498293,
0.0262293071,
0.0157833025,
-0.3281103671,
-0.0571678206,
-0.9998130798,
1.0821129084,
0.2415119261,
-0.3811699748,
-0.2985921502,
0.8553311229,
-0.3723146021,
0.3216809332,
0.5675157309,
0.6950253844,
1.2461057901,
0.1094073728,
0.6913788915,
-0.4067794681,
0.4508206248,
1.3349642754,
-0.1284902245,
0.8791658282,
0.0844794959,
0.0992266461,
0.7025374174,
0.5231195688,
0.1032953635,
0.5019869208,
-0.0897642747,
-0.3475718498,
-0.4990964234,
-0.0325204842,
-0.2185180634,
0.8581922054,
0.0224605035,
-0.2611252367,
-0.1944317967,
-0.0904500335,
-0.1411687881,
0.0380687863,
-0.445496738,
0.8394978642,
0.0658700466,
-0.2715487778,
0.0053934325,
-0.0473931618,
0.5294295549,
-0.6505814791,
0.2807776928,
-0.1728292853,
0.2984206975,
-0.4849976003,
-0.5765078664,
-0.0318225734,
-0.2530942261,
-0.1574252695,
-0.1691084057,
1.0768588781,
-0.6473817825,
-0.531771481,
0.1784990579,
0.6449729204,
0.0595884025,
0.1902575642,
-0.4956068099,
-0.4058045149,
-0.1557139158,
-0.0338787474,
0.3305920362,
0.5862113833,
0.0761449859,
0.7798963785,
0.6042277217,
0.0522463135,
0.1647038162,
-0.1916809082,
1.0343102217,
-0.3469322026,
-0.8247920871,
-0.5340770483,
0.2922176719,
0.0437708981,
-0.305188179,
0.9013098478,
0.5231162906,
0.987795651,
0.1638813615,
0.9372967482,
0.2004276067,
0.5031946898,
-0.3402346373,
1.0575720072,
-0.579590559,
-0.1017524526,
-0.2605221272,
-0.5616108179,
-0.0736018643,
0.3173675835,
-0.19252716,
0.0576036908,
0.3489251435,
0.2204202116,
-0.2208859921,
0.3969085813,
0.0614111051,
-0.1185683534,
0.2278750092,
0.2721973956,
0.6591004133,
-0.3806696534,
0.5959134102,
-0.6653159857,
-0.2372272164,
0.0867604017,
-0.7392112613,
-0.9796975255,
-0.6874549389,
-0.2209225595,
-0.1751852185,
-0.2098394483,
0.6424573064,
0.8805063367,
-0.5007732511,
-0.1652276516,
0.0786722228,
0.3088642657,
-0.2488454729,
-0.2101691663,
0.5855259299,
-0.2044314444,
-0.4292331934,
0.3164625466,
-0.3435857594,
0.4434654117,
-0.2044331729,
0.3774294257,
-0.0485737622,
0.0623067282,
0.1793607622,
-0.0290400255,
0.060453549,
-0.2373321652,
-0.1484199911,
-0.2452416569,
-0.3708400428,
0.8404211402,
-0.7313238382,
0.5994616747,
0.3586538434,
0.9528300166,
0.3905566633,
0.2578902543,
0.11829108,
-1.1651105881,
0.0754131898,
0.1847129464,
0.0477426723,
0.2658079267,
-0.6423180103,
0.3759024143,
0.3218368888,
-0.5211844444,
-0.6596875191,
0.0430536158,
-0.7333699465,
-0.4827896953,
0.7304846644,
-0.4037267566,
-0.3754898608,
-0.0871750861,
0.2817292511,
0.3335643411,
-0.2747226357,
0.8758622408,
0.5495816469,
0.0982124135,
0.009203596,
-0.2869704664,
0.5489293337,
0.256138742,
-0.7664772868,
0.0993630514,
0.3471539319,
0.4208516181,
0.2428809106,
0.7144947648,
0.1447890848,
-0.204717353,
0.2446000725,
0.1458685249,
-0.3769319952,
-0.9159049392,
-0.0743660256,
0.4678515196,
-0.5216344595,
-0.2226501107
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11073v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11073v1 | Exploring the Limitations of Detecting Machine-Generated Text | 2024-06-16T21:02:02 | 2024-06-16T21:02:02 | Jad Doughman, Osama Mohammed Afzal, Hawau Olamide Toyin, Shady Shehata, Preslav Nakov, Zeerak Talat | cs.CL | cs.CL | Recent improvements in the quality of the generations by large language
models have spurred research into identifying machine-generated text. Systems
proposed for the task often achieve high performance. However, humans and
machines can produce text in different styles and in different domains, and it
remains unclear whether machine generated-text detection models favour
particular styles or domains. In this paper, we critically examine the
classification performance for detecting machine-generated text by evaluating
on texts with varying writing styles. We find that classifiers are highly
sensitive to stylistic changes and differences in text complexity, and in some
cases degrade entirely to random classifiers. We further find that detection
systems are particularly susceptible to misclassify easy-to-read texts while
they have high performance for complex texts. | [
-0.3277284205,
-0.7192645073,
0.6610377431,
0.1004896462,
-0.0148455808,
0.1725183576,
-0.3293474317,
-0.9330388904,
-0.3348592222,
0.6485029459,
-0.4112384319,
-0.3901267946,
-0.9795871973,
0.7104824185,
-0.3531577587,
1.0527017117,
-0.2600163519,
-0.3901310563,
-0.2169965357,
-0.0904241651,
-0.4493775666,
-0.9357329607,
-0.3660644889,
-0.3424504697,
0.3543713987,
0.3002433181,
0.5486065149,
0.4511296451,
0.6911108494,
0.3764486611,
0.0437765643,
0.5050094724,
-0.4412398934,
0.5295351148,
-0.0345243886,
-0.5907714367,
-0.0466887765,
0.0113720261,
0.6207793355,
0.1670936793,
0.5348430872,
-0.0083480729,
0.1839084327,
0.5838615894,
-0.8519705534,
-0.1433218718,
-0.8029062748,
0.0409251712,
-0.4946761131,
-0.451048553,
-0.982950449,
-0.0891108066,
0.062933661,
-0.4701917171,
0.5256328583,
0.2984732687,
0.7823197246,
0.1194799542,
-0.3031442761,
-0.8348299265,
-1.0178968906,
0.8962314129,
-0.2771732211,
0.1534119099,
0.2357114851,
0.3375311792,
0.0287165381,
-0.5734742284,
-0.6902117133,
-0.1261961758,
-0.1380190402,
0.0345840454,
-0.3186524212,
-0.1986630559,
0.4567775726,
0.1924948245,
-0.7072539926,
0.276571691,
-0.0524879806,
-0.4231316447,
0.6930518746,
0.323133111,
0.5242426395,
-0.4204888642,
-0.1337909102,
-0.1484131664,
-0.2790062129,
0.0724574402,
0.7471935153,
0.330249846,
0.3174207509,
0.5887926221,
-0.1942528039,
0.6341962218,
-0.1760316789,
-0.2950623631,
0.0617343672,
-0.2222630233,
-0.2149693668,
-0.0646855757,
0.9265372753,
0.3045862913,
0.3880719543,
0.009824153,
-0.6043916345,
0.0909611508,
0.3978511989,
-0.6866519451,
-0.2251003236,
-0.1866514981,
-0.593716383,
-0.537968576,
0.0931953117,
-0.2480454296,
-0.5893681645,
-0.0098313233,
0.5955995917,
-0.4185977578,
-0.0204103347,
0.1850610822,
-0.6159758568,
-0.0231756568,
0.436742723,
-0.7963293195,
-0.0642752722,
0.5646954775,
0.56232512,
-0.3167572916,
-0.3430639505,
-0.3579164445,
-0.1584558338,
-0.2839994133,
0.9588928223,
-0.5359002948,
-0.3211649656,
-0.1552270651,
0.0603600219,
-0.1491553187,
-0.7096663117,
0.7878459692,
-0.428978771,
0.2374813855,
-0.0500311889,
-0.4332491755,
0.1181837469,
-0.0803012922,
-0.6714164615,
0.8310542107,
0.2512356341,
-1.0462379456,
0.8751420379,
-0.286474824,
-0.7668672204,
0.0604473315,
0.1375935227,
-0.8824418783,
0.1109632552,
-0.2302179635,
0.7025799155,
-0.0650265515,
0.1888546795,
-0.2434351146,
-0.5930775404,
0.6057300568,
-0.6529608965,
0.5356165767,
0.5506612062,
-0.4499022365,
-0.0289813057,
-1.0192043781,
-0.0887409821,
0.2011435628,
-0.6742633581,
-0.5399739742,
0.1157811731,
0.5009693503,
0.0322817788,
0.1992141604,
-0.3873878419,
0.0796899348,
0.1515723914,
0.3798447549,
0.7361719608,
-0.2920053899,
0.2366824597,
-0.6086614728,
0.4851363897,
-0.0432089642,
-0.2950500548,
-0.2228891104,
-0.507226944,
-0.7959480286,
-0.2666589022,
0.3148191273,
0.6439429522,
-0.8292626739,
0.470353812,
0.1014569476,
-0.5083226562,
-0.3275929689,
0.0528911389,
0.4898866713,
-0.0806548744,
0.1775291562,
-0.2468309402,
-0.5136739612,
-0.7824808955,
-0.8059193492,
-0.0822739154,
-0.1912732124,
0.3860384524,
0.5498982668,
-0.3945459723,
0.593028605,
-0.5045320392,
0.1396549195,
-0.3312356472,
0.4730383456,
-0.3820874691,
0.4473683238,
0.6960167289,
-0.6148623824,
-0.4707046747,
0.0905155763,
-0.7657102346,
-0.372281909,
-0.3717166483,
0.076342687,
0.4207321703,
0.4601902366,
-0.235495612,
0.4730281234,
0.3102045953,
-0.3457691967,
0.6554492712,
-0.130293712,
0.2340191305,
-0.644128561,
0.0629543662,
0.2718349695,
-0.2121032327,
-0.7676600814,
-0.0116964513,
0.1721100658,
-0.1302028894,
-0.1725483984,
0.2072534412,
-0.279081583,
0.0874309093,
-0.3843699396,
-0.0517195202,
0.2199406624,
0.2000132352,
-0.0382629968,
0.6540340781,
0.0493046269,
-0.7180268764,
-0.0242321268,
-0.1960592717,
-0.5410575867,
0.7971407771,
-0.5170050263,
0.2038986683,
-0.326865226,
0.2236937582,
-1.0661365986,
-0.5298826694,
0.0625696778,
-0.4964627922,
0.5449194908,
0.1055290923,
-0.5798456669,
-0.3126042783,
-0.2583459318,
0.3085013926,
0.1931555718,
-0.4402706623,
0.3546707928,
0.0399855487,
0.0861672089,
-0.482894659,
-0.6068198681,
-0.0157456752,
-0.2969301343,
-0.6168287992,
0.2199037224,
0.053348992,
-0.2946130335,
-0.1478667557,
0.0726621523,
-0.1199726611,
0.5694460869,
0.2540827394,
0.0149331046,
-0.2793954313,
0.2872771025,
0.2375270724,
0.1091519743,
-0.0841808021,
-0.0374363102,
0.5007768273,
0.1163865551,
-0.2576712966,
-0.5885264277,
0.3784019053,
0.9305875897,
-0.135146603,
0.6028020978,
0.8273386359,
-0.315926671,
-0.5634260178,
-0.3752885163,
0.1226754785,
-0.4776417613,
0.3261351585,
-0.6828845739,
-1.0007272959,
0.2352686971,
0.2504467666,
-0.2569271326,
0.9222432375,
0.3954131305,
-0.0594346374,
1.1563141346,
0.7333909273,
0.1706031412,
0.3637219965,
0.2017216682,
0.2619365752,
-0.584074378,
-0.2365622371,
-1.1370764971,
-0.1654350907,
-1.1259268522,
0.0458031558,
-0.0543325394,
0.0138564706,
-0.2080960572,
0.4764935076,
-1.0363332033,
0.5529997945,
0.6555493474,
0.1231306195,
0.5078164339,
-0.1025607288,
0.1624309272,
0.0181039181,
-0.3668327332,
-0.9598234892,
1.2619924545,
0.365151763,
0.6024867892,
0.0139362914,
0.6263527274,
0.6631786227,
0.3016841114,
-0.6694718599,
0.2214449495,
-0.5442299247,
-0.5915944576,
-0.1528732479,
-0.5119782686,
-0.9864938855,
0.1235602722,
-0.4625639617,
-0.5026326776,
0.0775968507,
-0.1469323635,
-0.0177167226,
0.4198040664,
-0.9332700372,
0.7639200687,
-0.0400442667,
-0.0933365673,
0.1686406434,
-0.3182606995,
0.2714443803,
-0.3338224292,
0.0146918567,
-0.1025779396,
0.2740507722,
0.7722955942,
-0.127146095,
0.6993308067,
0.1053542346,
-0.1258574724,
0.5892626643,
0.3314867914,
0.2623147368,
-0.2680553198,
-0.0919066891,
-0.0829523429,
-0.2121646106,
-0.4115017056,
-0.3223320544,
0.4769569337,
-0.7985581756,
-0.4476127923,
-0.4581385255,
-0.3871008158,
0.004973161,
0.3216330111,
0.9113827348,
0.3713789284,
-0.2494737804,
0.0951768458,
0.5904254317,
-0.4616033733,
0.2912847996,
0.145027563,
-0.225051105,
0.034276668,
1.2101721764,
0.2615496516,
0.3507188261,
0.328514725,
0.1078736782,
-0.0776117593,
-0.7013908029,
-0.7651554346,
-0.1294333488,
-0.6424330473,
0.0094413422,
-0.7741363049,
-0.2201482952,
-0.2143660188,
-0.3108759224,
0.1404211372,
-0.4994892478,
-0.6566975117,
0.2006924748,
0.132559821,
1.0999501944,
0.2526573837,
0.2439457625,
-0.4553898275,
0.1373475343,
0.3693824112,
0.2873164415,
-0.122695826,
-0.47243765,
0.1134628654,
-0.4115067124,
-0.5717051625,
-0.6502181888,
0.2058253735,
-0.0610060468,
0.2084715068,
0.2983528376,
0.0554703064,
-0.0492156819,
-0.2681749165,
0.7058181167,
0.0232037045,
-1.0166735649,
0.4928101301,
-0.3941489458,
0.3470460474,
0.4372522235,
0.5090187192,
-0.4884634018,
-0.6948005557,
-0.4034983814,
-0.3631922305,
0.6770790815,
0.2810317278,
0.1707025468,
0.0568225533,
0.330383718,
0.4419680536,
0.1300853491,
-0.6954239607,
-0.0119066723,
-0.2997636199,
-0.2226427495,
-0.0333317816,
-0.2177492529,
0.2913470864,
0.1778099537,
0.356711179,
0.0229099058,
0.4231505096,
0.1748863608,
-0.2015359998,
-0.0810094923,
0.4154761434,
0.8789039254,
0.2296866179,
-0.0063255015,
0.2503309548,
-0.103161335,
-0.4934126139,
0.1617789567,
-0.1874895692,
-0.422077477,
0.1760895103,
0.7833912969,
0.8189457059,
-0.2061798573,
-0.6371706724,
0.4244149625,
-0.1828841716,
-0.1983251572,
0.1183488965,
0.5434905291,
-0.4007148147,
-0.0539734811,
0.2636936903,
0.5724773407,
0.3171020746,
-0.7934120893,
0.0648702681,
0.4029357135,
-0.4076693952,
-0.2310775667,
0.5266416073,
0.1709170341,
-0.6015211344,
0.3329161704,
-0.5478575826,
-0.8757558465,
0.7823235989,
0.6980574727,
0.9565809965,
-0.0004745564,
0.0719129592,
0.1482019424,
0.3323012888,
0.0364798643,
0.1538757384,
-0.1099732444,
-0.8029121161,
-0.1927386075,
-0.6916537881,
-0.4372432828,
0.223060891,
-0.3699405193,
0.2718715668,
-0.595654726,
-0.4555532634,
0.4099660516,
-0.1486281455,
-0.6222622991,
0.2362866253,
0.0064129964,
0.3450396657,
-0.8804551363,
0.2174756974,
0.6351453662,
-0.0676170513,
-0.350787431,
0.3179727495,
0.1035112068,
-0.5327284932,
0.7120136023,
0.6051413417,
-0.4840933979,
-0.2699912786,
-0.5971818566,
-0.2114890963,
0.5779051185,
-0.1373229772,
-0.4327965379,
0.1240544021,
0.1284606904,
0.795979023,
-0.200113833,
0.1247419193,
0.5464459062,
0.4360251725,
-0.4625850618,
-1.101636529,
0.0109739006,
-0.1557049304,
0.0399001502,
0.2976757884,
-0.6115137935,
0.9902021289,
0.0238859877,
-0.598184526,
0.1668287516,
0.3223741055,
-0.0624636747,
0.9182927608,
0.2885203362,
0.4389347136,
0.9281594157,
-0.3482224643,
1.0194154978,
0.1098028496,
0.3460178971,
0.539740622,
-0.2642649114,
0.6132620573,
-0.2016023099,
-0.1624553055,
0.6230673194,
0.4918422699,
0.0044362582,
0.1071969122,
0.4638927579,
-0.4475603402,
-0.296133548,
-0.1453460306,
-0.2331773788,
0.7522441745,
0.1267338842,
-0.5637131929,
0.3058686554,
0.1661672145,
0.1124128401,
0.399312973,
-0.1084442511,
0.6538821459,
-0.2089183033,
-0.7729272246,
0.5451648831,
0.3585447371,
1.0536102057,
-0.0752143264,
0.2934597135,
0.2652461827,
0.2077108175,
-0.4116399884,
-0.8542079329,
0.2754426599,
0.2557154596,
-0.4228629768,
-0.0372792557,
1.2382795811,
0.0539502688,
-0.3623629212,
-0.0027023982,
0.4427827597,
0.042116303,
-0.0643253475,
-0.2445089966,
0.385392338,
-0.078367494,
-0.2261360437,
0.3394741416,
0.9293659329,
-0.0439634323,
0.6251356006,
0.5978606343,
-0.4803738296,
-0.0462796688,
-0.0845820233,
0.4166873991,
-0.5551197529,
-0.1132099479,
-0.901673317,
0.0883402973,
-0.0412589572,
-0.6581942439,
0.6715655923,
0.5663672686,
1.008749485,
-0.2678631544,
1.0674850941,
0.0655129403,
0.4062913954,
-0.5612146854,
0.8917616606,
-0.5233157277,
0.1148946285,
-0.5621637106,
-0.6556753516,
-0.3733025789,
0.4928648472,
-0.1198264882,
0.1387506276,
0.7170315385,
0.4218837917,
0.1433146447,
0.2288957536,
0.3816534579,
-0.1869153231,
0.2810549438,
0.5504541993,
1.1259894371,
-0.3245715797,
0.573580265,
-0.1569504887,
-0.1297753602,
-0.510648489,
-0.6780138016,
-1.0674055815,
-0.7291822433,
-0.1794766039,
-0.5516867042,
-0.1199702471,
0.3421183527,
0.446798116,
-0.6666491628,
0.0402770787,
0.0079618609,
0.2966413796,
0.0232043471,
-0.3280249238,
0.0956134796,
-0.3608521521,
-0.8218454719,
0.0835832804,
0.3553949296,
0.2412943989,
-0.2150315642,
0.1486474574,
0.4367408454,
0.2900737226,
0.8883222938,
0.1620507389,
-0.4932918847,
-0.5965963006,
0.1467009485,
-0.6254192591,
-0.0157996248,
1.0956950188,
-0.4244640172,
0.4444514811,
0.7795374393,
0.6723051667,
0.3740798533,
-0.1106925607,
0.1472045779,
-0.5017235279,
-0.3371033072,
0.2673011124,
0.156893611,
0.342651993,
-0.5874070525,
0.2388364375,
0.5516684055,
-0.7689628005,
-0.835673511,
0.4619017243,
-0.6837777495,
-0.6440078616,
0.9652488232,
0.0379333608,
0.0616341718,
-0.3692857027,
-0.3912726045,
0.239729628,
-0.2739571631,
0.6685097218,
0.960404098,
-0.234709084,
0.4021678567,
-0.4702217579,
0.5189883709,
0.2312485278,
-0.7241061926,
-0.0016603814,
0.5185763836,
0.2737293839,
0.4166764617,
0.4446223974,
0.0652752966,
0.398519963,
0.0131153427,
-0.161534071,
0.2646131814,
-0.5654497147,
-0.2083039731,
0.4807980657,
0.2920908928,
0.1819053292
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11069v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11069v1 | WildVision: Evaluating Vision-Language Models in the Wild with Human Preferences | 2024-06-16T20:53:25 | 2024-06-16T20:53:25 | Yujie Lu, Dongfu Jiang, Wenhu Chen, William Yang Wang, Yejin Choi, Bill Yuchen Lin | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | Recent breakthroughs in vision-language models (VLMs) emphasize the necessity
of benchmarking human preferences in real-world multimodal interactions. To
address this gap, we launched WildVision-Arena (WV-Arena), an online platform
that collects human preferences to evaluate VLMs. We curated WV-Bench by
selecting 500 high-quality samples from 8,000 user submissions in WV-Arena.
WV-Bench uses GPT-4 as the judge to compare each VLM with Claude-3-Sonnet,
achieving a Spearman correlation of 0.94 with the WV-Arena Elo. This
significantly outperforms other benchmarks like MMVet, MMMU, and MMStar.
Our comprehensive analysis of 20K real-world interactions reveals important
insights into the failure cases of top-performing VLMs. For example, we find
that although GPT-4V surpasses many other models like Reka-Flash, Opus, and
Yi-VL-Plus in simple visual recognition and reasoning tasks, it still faces
challenges with subtle contextual cues, spatial reasoning, visual imagination,
and expert domain knowledge. Additionally, current VLMs exhibit issues with
hallucinations and safety when intentionally provoked. We are releasing our
chat and feedback data to further advance research in the field of VLMs. | [
-0.4689777195,
-0.4557703733,
0.6050419211,
0.244851917,
-0.2967833579,
-0.2012158334,
-0.1797201186,
-0.8574142456,
-0.0445239879,
0.5911564231,
-0.3964504004,
-0.4608893096,
-0.3162148297,
-0.10799402,
-0.3228135407,
0.6212417483,
-0.0022890461,
0.1292525828,
-0.2275558412,
-0.3344324529,
-0.5170146227,
-0.6375502348,
-0.2061355114,
-0.1020119414,
0.6218118072,
0.0790103376,
0.5925833583,
0.4155274034,
0.5685958862,
0.3513727486,
0.0629526675,
0.1958520561,
-0.5767441392,
0.1151649207,
-0.0315950736,
-0.2403147817,
-0.5478994846,
0.2305055559,
0.2105692923,
0.5830407143,
-0.2586860359,
-0.0237358976,
-0.0765781179,
0.4887573719,
-0.7045975327,
0.1400965005,
-0.7173921466,
0.3856743574,
-0.2856502235,
-0.143332243,
-0.4467598796,
-0.1132107601,
0.6117594838,
-0.6520867944,
0.2721887231,
0.2685004175,
1.0872510672,
0.1446572244,
-0.4449558854,
0.420391649,
-0.8641861677,
0.7633270621,
-0.3901801407,
0.591227293,
0.2954508662,
0.6698079705,
0.0419560261,
-0.7350379825,
-0.7270773649,
-0.1814955026,
0.1891172677,
0.2876525521,
-0.4800091982,
0.17016159,
0.2668373585,
0.0063323956,
-0.6955769658,
0.0740576908,
-0.5802578926,
-0.2713756859,
0.6334586143,
0.3926059604,
-0.0868341997,
-0.0265690833,
-0.4577857554,
-0.3714222014,
-0.4281220138,
-0.0795363486,
0.1593242288,
-0.0342106819,
0.1669000834,
0.5544853806,
-0.3198847771,
1.0955088139,
-0.2873321772,
0.1250002831,
0.4695955217,
-0.2601892054,
-0.53667593,
-0.5727465749,
0.7435799837,
1.0659613609,
0.2717666328,
-0.1990277469,
-0.2425465733,
0.3327278197,
0.5982915759,
-0.4445496798,
-0.140443027,
-0.0267943125,
-0.4546960294,
-0.3716781437,
-0.1333055347,
-0.8451859355,
-0.7346204519,
-0.4105783999,
0.5821500421,
-0.1494480669,
-0.1226040274,
0.0567280874,
-0.3108584583,
0.436493665,
0.7386171818,
-0.9011977315,
0.2586103678,
0.4787180126,
0.6229173541,
-0.5285167098,
-0.6259223223,
-0.5074412823,
-0.1981055439,
-0.3345674574,
0.940212369,
-0.4203390479,
-0.2857587337,
0.0895380229,
-0.1796581596,
-0.0093037402,
-0.7196127772,
0.5432474017,
-0.3576622307,
-0.0183670614,
-0.3484195173,
-0.2226226628,
-0.0810893774,
0.5608603358,
-0.626573205,
0.6497558951,
-0.2647272646,
-0.5548279285,
0.9422594905,
-0.3782162368,
0.0169681441,
0.4501048028,
-0.3875646889,
-0.2221176326,
0.2657586932,
0.1097461805,
0.4720441103,
-0.099549748,
0.2346886247,
-0.4686106145,
-0.3348164558,
0.2688237429,
-0.5883963108,
0.2607881725,
0.2768066823,
-0.3037773073,
0.510722518,
-0.8351966739,
0.0846122727,
0.1380750239,
-0.0420124233,
-0.4606594741,
0.1909027696,
0.3856592476,
0.2761234045,
-0.0299861562,
-0.4550076425,
0.1208131015,
-0.3417754769,
0.2958033681,
0.8722807169,
-0.2281336337,
0.2549187839,
-0.0845107064,
0.2870756984,
0.095886521,
0.8664662242,
0.2320912182,
-0.7370603085,
-0.7776609063,
-0.0970717669,
-0.2717240453,
0.3457788527,
-0.7649515271,
-0.0771672502,
-0.1018998176,
-0.4912880063,
-0.4132276475,
-0.0514814071,
0.3341688514,
0.3580645323,
0.2569010556,
-0.4950321317,
-0.5376212001,
-1.1461595297,
-0.3106803,
-0.2133543491,
-0.0241623465,
0.8158336282,
0.3781778514,
-0.5143530369,
1.074207902,
-0.5264738202,
-0.3937627971,
-0.2109800577,
0.0248348955,
0.0753275678,
0.07963714,
0.7553508282,
-1.2777791023,
-0.4681503475,
-0.050422512,
-0.8935153484,
0.0746503845,
0.3560754359,
-0.0308945179,
0.1978464872,
-0.02048463,
-0.4277293384,
0.6453350186,
0.7250933647,
-0.4446950257,
0.4942184389,
-0.2407597303,
0.2856385112,
-0.5497691035,
0.0795846656,
-0.0217565671,
-0.0153863421,
-0.7591099143,
0.0766693503,
-0.0322056413,
0.0875691026,
-0.7135651112,
0.4672885239,
-0.169914633,
-0.2777380645,
0.0280723311,
0.3506005108,
0.0363821574,
0.5388761163,
0.2310974598,
0.5336405635,
0.6646228433,
-0.3043893874,
0.7560074329,
0.355810225,
-0.2645460963,
0.3651203811,
-0.5786495209,
0.1712837368,
-0.0560874008,
0.1327711642,
-0.7422605157,
-0.2773059309,
0.1408313513,
-0.2650385201,
0.0247244779,
-0.2263742536,
-0.3144839406,
-0.4852390885,
-0.4232104719,
0.2194038779,
0.362387985,
-0.4198197424,
0.5278275609,
0.5457098484,
0.3181716502,
-0.7159551978,
-0.675314784,
0.5522975922,
-0.1277424097,
-0.5679271221,
0.0446799025,
-0.2123347819,
-0.5635103583,
-0.10059008,
0.021867007,
0.0258193202,
-0.004524719,
0.4443325698,
0.5555806756,
0.0005348728,
-0.2808568478,
-0.4935427606,
-0.156930849,
-0.1376090497,
-0.572412312,
0.2867260575,
-0.5777878165,
-0.293518275,
0.0544350185,
0.2349812686,
0.6910418272,
-0.3788519204,
0.5814965367,
0.3785112202,
-0.3582539558,
-0.1110014766,
-0.6638914347,
-0.0981790498,
-0.4097938538,
0.219357118,
-0.3471919596,
-0.8560350537,
0.2656697929,
0.1999973357,
0.1084481105,
0.2820520401,
0.6037011147,
-0.0551117435,
1.1571894884,
0.7116703391,
0.3009280562,
0.4214781523,
-0.2701061666,
0.0650661886,
-0.6391382217,
-0.4703555703,
-0.1285865009,
-0.2234572321,
-0.4971287847,
-0.4255759716,
0.5069489479,
-0.3720422089,
0.3009045124,
0.3047658801,
-0.4701398015,
0.436026454,
0.3765917122,
-0.03882806,
0.325271666,
-0.1685434133,
-0.4462876022,
-0.4397788048,
-0.4917164743,
-0.5310786366,
1.0919638872,
0.1561187804,
0.7097562551,
0.1366090328,
0.4281763732,
0.2723783255,
0.3889306188,
-0.6878631711,
0.6464887857,
-0.0257290415,
-0.7759406567,
-0.3459388614,
-0.2606169581,
-0.8647206426,
0.7232830524,
-0.5324705839,
-1.0086779594,
0.2779204547,
0.3651597202,
-0.3890128136,
0.1964715868,
-0.6602253318,
1.1792781353,
-0.2901949286,
-0.7935954332,
-0.1597328633,
-0.7537751198,
0.5402384996,
-0.0879207477,
0.2176151127,
0.0288158692,
0.1413294524,
0.6007429361,
-0.2378191352,
0.7762820721,
-0.1221804172,
0.0602148734,
0.0490701757,
-0.0759771168,
0.2502017319,
-0.0795244798,
0.283446908,
0.2727318108,
-0.1502448916,
-0.1200013012,
-0.4357216358,
0.762104094,
-0.8914971352,
-0.4364263415,
-0.7080039382,
-0.2789209485,
-0.4935729504,
0.1846223623,
0.3138104379,
0.6253015399,
-0.4314019978,
0.1503626704,
0.7409249544,
-0.3271803856,
0.3234185576,
0.6591140628,
-0.5990862846,
-0.3535192311,
0.7407462597,
0.0461714901,
0.2019758821,
0.32290712,
0.1569859833,
-0.170119077,
-0.7599676251,
-0.6177316904,
-0.0702852234,
-0.7794294357,
0.0781682879,
-0.8735280633,
-0.0160076991,
-0.1931595653,
-0.0589796454,
-0.4676671922,
-0.0645079166,
0.2107410729,
-0.1227007061,
0.1871369183,
0.8384850621,
-0.0913727656,
-0.1722657531,
-0.6613886952,
0.3152779937,
0.8326480985,
0.4978362024,
-0.1237455308,
-0.2515040636,
-0.0888114497,
-0.2418186218,
-0.1502627283,
-0.6923507452,
0.6169102192,
-0.0127019314,
0.5892370939,
0.4584696591,
0.0030533809,
0.7398373485,
-0.7079880834,
0.8813103437,
0.1461693943,
-0.6849097013,
0.5169607401,
-0.2937537134,
-0.0150216911,
0.5077559948,
0.0606458075,
-0.5356731415,
-0.3575247824,
-0.5116010308,
-0.8778879642,
0.712323308,
0.297028482,
0.0308505781,
0.2577822506,
-0.0283480808,
0.1149894744,
0.2589045167,
-0.5877279639,
-0.1601220369,
-0.4763250053,
0.2122607082,
-0.1975279003,
-0.0871131718,
-0.2440107167,
-0.2579695284,
0.093786858,
-0.2608135939,
0.1747237295,
0.0380020291,
0.0282517392,
-0.2683903575,
0.2067437917,
0.8747153878,
0.8444917798,
-0.4629702866,
0.3363703489,
0.4047678411,
-0.7077579498,
-0.2696312368,
0.0790464059,
-0.1382193714,
-0.1556387395,
0.4141548276,
1.0845038891,
0.2213161737,
-0.9815915227,
0.8700819612,
-0.6661792397,
-0.2953087389,
-0.2466489375,
0.1021102816,
-0.2251405418,
0.2460072637,
0.4913592339,
0.6054580808,
0.3926508129,
-0.5926320553,
0.175071463,
0.2604579926,
-0.6509839296,
-0.3639569879,
0.9202039838,
0.2915062606,
0.0097448453,
0.3921581209,
0.0467835255,
-0.6582801938,
0.3016663194,
0.1266235709,
0.9923964143,
0.272280246,
0.1501035988,
0.1070044115,
0.2786039412,
-0.0143225854,
0.1128285304,
-0.1417488605,
-0.7972790599,
-0.3343424499,
-0.7329272628,
-0.7221965194,
0.0934368819,
-0.5966520309,
0.1498883218,
-0.2337237,
-0.220436275,
0.1151039675,
-0.0678776056,
-0.8872708082,
0.2481926531,
0.412617892,
0.6788607836,
-0.8401710391,
0.9098738432,
0.8041909933,
-0.2930938005,
-0.6086253524,
-0.1419623941,
0.3191657066,
-0.7555271983,
0.6400191784,
0.0827389657,
-0.1566443741,
-0.1680177301,
-0.8478733301,
-0.4245996773,
1.0993251801,
0.0471219607,
-0.7568436861,
0.2457001656,
-0.2060096413,
0.7218335271,
-0.1539828628,
0.152228862,
0.3487603068,
0.5608204603,
0.3651343882,
-1.1046876907,
-0.3194492459,
-0.3401691914,
-0.0211383197,
0.0439802632,
-0.6558121443,
0.5960595012,
-0.3025962114,
-0.0075229337,
-0.1909425408,
0.4191054404,
0.3727765083,
0.558714509,
0.6481676102,
0.4167898595,
0.4300129712,
-0.1653994769,
1.0808528662,
0.0625983328,
0.2268643975,
0.6084378958,
-0.6348068118,
1.0260858536,
0.5052381158,
-0.1274701357,
-0.0408724546,
0.3357584476,
-0.1626650691,
0.723012507,
0.0600921661,
-0.0605876185,
-0.4976768792,
-0.0961852223,
-0.1382273287,
0.5400777459,
0.1681046039,
0.1413959861,
0.0843384042,
0.3262088299,
-0.2542535961,
-0.0524031371,
0.0429189354,
0.7612469792,
0.1163592264,
-0.8424890637,
0.5047222376,
-0.1734949201,
0.6258744001,
-0.6872464418,
-0.0756439716,
-0.349604547,
0.4202269912,
-0.0831678435,
-0.7824211121,
0.1185753942,
0.2477163225,
0.0255623478,
-0.3526751995,
0.6562155485,
-0.2178334594,
-0.0239423383,
0.4576638937,
0.4423803389,
0.2129175812,
-0.0597844385,
-0.4358053207,
0.5165666342,
-0.1529664248,
-0.3205946684,
0.4397263527,
0.326742202,
-0.2285194993,
0.7497739792,
0.6383682489,
0.0746826604,
0.1255077869,
0.3849080801,
0.9799561501,
-0.6549830437,
-0.29502967,
-0.7913510799,
0.3550256193,
-0.3240188062,
-0.6592210531,
0.8008463979,
0.4985344112,
0.7252806425,
-0.1049915254,
0.7932906151,
-0.044280421,
0.0269524399,
-0.2106826901,
0.7826963067,
-0.7566131949,
0.1207807213,
-0.5448084474,
-0.9158383012,
-0.5988906026,
0.5887772441,
-0.2112297565,
-0.2156298906,
0.4910586774,
0.5535063148,
0.0257122312,
-0.1360026151,
0.9568015933,
0.3403336704,
0.3889277577,
0.6128338575,
1.0849733353,
-0.2549778819,
0.73627913,
-0.0480460078,
-0.5732713342,
-0.4901976585,
-0.8206906319,
-0.9084254503,
-0.6691589355,
-0.0724349618,
-0.0568467043,
0.1527605653,
0.8151250482,
0.845939219,
-0.5947329402,
-0.0668127462,
0.0515297763,
-0.2424827367,
-0.2752909064,
-0.1426979899,
0.0400437079,
0.099207662,
-0.5155338645,
0.4567985833,
0.6941897273,
0.0780497417,
-0.5761864781,
-0.3444759846,
0.1408880651,
0.0656405315,
0.818177104,
0.136156112,
-0.9961209893,
-0.3239967525,
0.3479265571,
-0.3770636022,
-0.1799015999,
0.4864963293,
-0.8569224477,
0.8035552502,
0.44704476,
0.2074376792,
0.8675631881,
-0.4051299095,
0.7765696049,
-0.38265872,
0.0064493129,
0.279060483,
0.4053271711,
0.3651058078,
0.1738046855,
0.5638659,
0.6846136451,
-0.4662358761,
-0.8450422287,
0.1293703914,
-1.2051460743,
0.0414592028,
1.0536215305,
0.0742838457,
-0.2498589009,
-0.174823612,
-0.4846553206,
-0.297460407,
-0.2179125845,
0.7266320586,
0.4747246206,
-0.1729371101,
-0.1787266135,
-1.0537782907,
0.6465457678,
0.0780464187,
-0.5476309061,
0.101713866,
0.6321119666,
-0.0156765208,
0.1129952893,
0.4954015315,
0.0456745699,
0.3258016407,
0.1675758511,
0.1731427312,
-0.0510558933,
-0.3488657773,
-0.2114845812,
0.1837829649,
0.0731337219,
-0.1389385164
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11065v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11065v1 | Can LLMs Understand the Implication of Emphasized Sentences in Dialogue? | 2024-06-16T20:41:44 | 2024-06-16T20:41:44 | Guan-Ting Lin, Hung-yi Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL | Emphasis is a crucial component in human communication, which indicates the
speaker's intention and implication beyond pure text in dialogue. While Large
Language Models (LLMs) have revolutionized natural language processing, their
ability to understand emphasis in dialogue remains unclear. This paper
introduces Emphasized-Talk, a benchmark with emphasis-annotated dialogue
samples capturing the implications of emphasis. We evaluate various LLMs, both
open-source and commercial, to measure their performance in understanding
emphasis. Additionally, we propose an automatic evaluation pipeline using
GPT-4, which achieves a high correlation with human rating. Our findings reveal
that although commercial LLMs generally perform better, there is still
significant room for improvement in comprehending emphasized sentences. | [
-0.3796223104,
-0.9975184202,
0.9999467134,
0.3681863248,
-0.508656919,
-0.1762265563,
-0.5543020964,
-0.7991424799,
-0.007312438,
0.4252296686,
-0.4218037426,
-0.4441881776,
-0.7611021996,
0.3322784305,
-0.3276628554,
0.7308626175,
0.0621479973,
0.0066649029,
-0.0518628247,
-0.0675511435,
-0.4310689569,
-0.3029277623,
-0.4097407758,
-0.5190504789,
0.1640665531,
0.2699803114,
0.781768918,
0.5768550634,
0.6154770255,
0.3362380266,
-0.4070699215,
0.0996168628,
-0.401607573,
0.1161030009,
-0.1259452552,
-0.4718432724,
-0.5371319652,
0.0950203687,
0.8249809146,
0.9150210023,
0.1862283796,
-0.0679820329,
0.2484910935,
0.3462703526,
-0.5045332909,
0.3238816559,
-0.7434963584,
-0.1819690764,
0.0973494574,
-0.2907982767,
-0.4877118468,
-0.1713000536,
0.4857529402,
-0.4396992922,
-0.1986448318,
0.2338992208,
1.0340462923,
0.5591825247,
-0.4838958085,
-0.1598036587,
-0.6186291575,
0.9255884886,
-0.6636698246,
0.1861786693,
0.1965882927,
0.0578794107,
-0.359242022,
-0.6751173735,
-0.2845145166,
-0.2660696507,
-0.1841604859,
0.1045030728,
-0.0132731218,
0.6800180078,
0.4302773774,
0.7848312855,
-0.2119343877,
0.0544893034,
-0.0578856692,
0.0579087585,
0.4601322114,
0.0214056764,
0.2468478829,
-0.2677609324,
-0.4791674018,
0.3246039748,
-0.5950448513,
-0.0031671268,
0.225771606,
0.0883791,
0.0960448906,
0.3594402969,
-0.3861082196,
0.588290453,
0.0692247227,
-0.0439558476,
0.0654320344,
-0.2965119779,
-0.5192950368,
-0.01395017,
0.6238481998,
0.6144906282,
0.5231840611,
-0.0008468575,
0.1023381874,
-0.1481368691,
0.1336326897,
-0.8519120812,
0.0284573045,
0.2689674497,
-0.3501695693,
-0.0417803712,
-0.1521687657,
-0.3460406661,
-0.3497755826,
-0.3665980697,
0.0997878984,
-0.0555496328,
-0.0235956889,
0.1830824614,
-0.207943663,
0.3559730649,
0.5066157579,
-0.7848374844,
0.5611454248,
0.885453999,
0.5992735028,
-0.3457464278,
0.0187396072,
-0.3738587201,
-0.0005424687,
-0.1731657982,
0.8858512044,
-0.6444768906,
-0.4787705839,
0.0108799217,
-0.055334188,
-0.0541484579,
-0.507712841,
1.4696443081,
-0.125077948,
-0.148099035,
-0.0530275702,
-0.8888680339,
-0.2553678453,
0.2687725723,
-0.3470185101,
0.9979791045,
-0.0376665294,
-0.7103536725,
0.3194890916,
-0.48259601,
-0.366383642,
0.2754294574,
-0.3056074977,
-0.2586894631,
0.3190543354,
0.2928088605,
0.3118102551,
-0.4653368592,
0.4664734602,
-0.3036721051,
-0.6272044182,
0.7213944793,
-0.4869728684,
0.3918481171,
-0.1595162004,
-0.5741063952,
-0.0427047722,
-0.5799129605,
0.2343186438,
-0.2735937238,
-0.2068687081,
-0.1967421621,
0.181828022,
-0.1182177961,
0.0197820049,
0.2039661407,
-0.3664215803,
0.0361407511,
-0.4244896472,
0.5435600281,
0.6605341434,
0.1202976853,
0.3206126392,
0.0900447071,
0.438854754,
-0.3672143817,
0.0151669281,
-0.6071729064,
-0.7044424415,
-0.9121283293,
-0.4454193115,
0.0584828705,
0.402739346,
0.2125864178,
0.5241585374,
-0.2745946646,
-0.0960586816,
-0.4932049513,
0.1113217771,
0.4400461912,
0.4386190176,
0.3087413013,
-0.3499761522,
-0.5138319731,
-1.305804491,
-0.6270692945,
-0.1942348182,
-0.0946075469,
0.6683514714,
0.1854031235,
-0.1045162231,
0.9578135014,
-0.709536612,
-0.0030640492,
-0.4421918988,
0.4284162819,
0.2740529478,
0.1314338446,
-0.0068914089,
-0.8023471832,
-0.4713989496,
-0.1812683791,
-0.3213947713,
-0.5360675454,
-0.0406635031,
-0.1998898238,
-0.3562778831,
0.5071095228,
-0.7388061881,
0.506103754,
0.3455462754,
-0.0612987019,
0.5749103427,
-0.0326944925,
0.1769549698,
-0.6152008772,
-0.031492427,
0.2001658976,
-0.2718103826,
-0.6673959494,
-0.2400263548,
0.0266943648,
0.0764857903,
-0.2482363731,
0.5049629807,
-0.4178762436,
-0.4589385092,
-0.3419743776,
0.4168525338,
0.2206073701,
0.4256803393,
0.267472297,
0.8238635659,
0.2461108863,
-0.35062626,
-0.0662132725,
0.2003223747,
-0.5400013328,
0.4992342591,
-0.7963049412,
0.2320962995,
0.1051721945,
0.538654089,
-1.187739253,
-0.3367517292,
0.0492253713,
-0.2209618539,
0.2935269177,
-0.5057684779,
-0.3545269072,
-0.3354386687,
-0.0532843508,
0.0888927653,
0.3846747875,
-0.1972122192,
0.4549562335,
0.3249050379,
-0.2819785178,
-0.6283820271,
-0.5181536078,
0.1554208249,
-0.3108124137,
-0.6552501321,
0.2893162966,
-0.0275016185,
-0.5408085585,
-0.3780048192,
-0.0337852463,
-0.3068160415,
0.4378082752,
0.5532657504,
0.1400002539,
-0.2165713757,
0.205386892,
-0.2232137769,
-0.0908074826,
0.11229112,
-0.3460194468,
0.2190592736,
-0.3736048937,
-0.3915513158,
-0.5490253568,
0.1258789301,
0.5373216867,
0.0461615436,
0.3028024137,
0.3296282887,
-0.0719132721,
0.0233611055,
-0.6554145217,
-0.2805397809,
-0.4869405031,
0.4088888168,
-0.2233558893,
-0.8609101772,
0.1176886261,
-0.3535424173,
-0.0039509656,
0.3480867743,
0.471665591,
-0.1037460044,
1.1564249992,
0.4763942659,
-0.0705607086,
0.347944051,
0.1861686409,
0.3508130908,
-0.9427658319,
0.3768059015,
-0.3559708893,
-0.2983023226,
-0.5078642964,
-0.4628489912,
0.2621639967,
0.1188111156,
0.1513133049,
0.1400109082,
-0.4525639415,
0.6184679866,
0.1770276129,
-0.1359808445,
0.505369246,
-0.2137940377,
0.0035031242,
-0.1646883339,
0.051105015,
-0.9366836548,
0.8818287849,
0.6906836033,
0.622980237,
-0.2863535881,
0.2896324694,
0.0741927922,
0.4070545137,
-0.9755213261,
0.64026016,
0.1076918617,
-0.8037365675,
-0.3042884469,
-0.0506451838,
-0.7095845342,
0.5215991139,
0.1554347426,
-1.1024460793,
-0.1302565038,
0.2314792275,
-0.3088734448,
-0.1462557316,
-0.8886888027,
0.8390289545,
-0.2880335152,
-0.3411373496,
-0.3566426039,
-0.6004115343,
0.410381645,
0.2405297458,
0.2080991268,
-0.5871165991,
-0.067171365,
0.4173844755,
-0.0892452076,
0.8870105743,
0.0357758179,
-0.0211223979,
0.3958155513,
-0.4065094888,
0.5601451993,
0.0259571802,
-0.1462554038,
-0.1344119757,
-0.6815344691,
-0.2481253147,
-0.6695913672,
0.4048105478,
-0.4627814889,
-0.8707159758,
-0.0473060608,
-0.6197633147,
-0.3011936843,
-0.0699157864,
-0.0370266177,
0.4568402767,
-0.5721927881,
0.1113432869,
0.6306200624,
0.0041498933,
0.0963791683,
0.5393483639,
0.0174549744,
-0.081531778,
0.2845722735,
-0.1067253575,
0.4731926322,
0.4155868292,
0.2149414122,
-0.3269552886,
-0.7301918268,
-0.3275703192,
0.2192846835,
-0.9291526675,
0.3399524093,
-1.1032156944,
0.0204737149,
-0.1579941064,
-0.322481066,
-0.1116332263,
-0.5357619524,
-0.0240095817,
-0.4235810041,
0.298246026,
0.6250678897,
0.2735569775,
0.4584721923,
-0.4524364173,
0.0461444259,
0.3945566714,
0.1013592854,
-0.3204331398,
-0.5309197307,
-0.1984538883,
-0.1798163354,
-0.482129246,
-0.7118776441,
0.2022221237,
0.2296776772,
0.5680952668,
0.8004637361,
-0.1231177002,
0.5138157606,
-0.5315836668,
0.8342725635,
-0.1264613122,
-1.0244088173,
0.4374630153,
-0.3618839979,
0.4112673402,
0.7209396362,
0.2108737677,
-0.5603935122,
-0.7653183937,
-0.7218959332,
-0.8692466617,
0.5918439031,
0.3993055224,
-0.00456258,
-0.1505093426,
0.1185045019,
-0.133073315,
0.317227751,
-0.5625995994,
-0.1673974544,
0.2538595498,
-0.1593351662,
-0.1556574702,
-0.50934273,
-0.12159729,
0.0079408782,
0.3705935776,
-0.1347569823,
0.2601204515,
0.2320189178,
-0.420568198,
-0.1111861095,
0.8076086044,
0.5931528211,
0.6381776929,
-0.4674831927,
0.2095929384,
0.4208876789,
-0.3931942582,
-0.0325620584,
0.2780900896,
-0.0548628308,
0.1200143248,
0.307521522,
0.8417429924,
0.8335641026,
-0.765093267,
0.60484308,
0.0228795893,
0.0419677645,
-0.2503012121,
-0.046158053,
0.2514578402,
0.0083349477,
0.439781338,
-0.3471809924,
0.6594008207,
-0.5900830626,
0.1728318185,
0.288043499,
-0.6112966537,
-0.3606702089,
0.3797011971,
0.6340544224,
-0.0358834974,
0.3243239224,
-0.0058676018,
-1.0505610704,
0.7678385973,
0.3160694838,
1.2267711163,
-0.0497445501,
-0.1298555434,
0.3933975101,
0.3233168423,
0.0062571364,
0.2019160539,
-0.3562306762,
-0.6058369875,
-0.6744235158,
-0.4160992205,
-0.9539852738,
-0.0607606024,
-0.5809883475,
0.3212501705,
-0.2091353238,
-0.3663865924,
0.16728957,
0.0985579118,
-0.5993955731,
0.1491770148,
0.4029542506,
0.7218006253,
-0.8780629635,
0.5519969463,
0.5514394045,
-0.0910866484,
-0.767772913,
0.1739798933,
0.0623089559,
-0.7381607294,
0.8583939075,
0.7495201826,
-0.2966682315,
-0.0628379285,
-0.5266405344,
-0.5655895472,
0.6756187081,
0.0743155777,
-0.3495297432,
0.0184797905,
0.1946146786,
0.5373254418,
-0.4457014203,
1.0009361506,
0.9283874035,
0.7662264705,
-0.195626393,
-1.0407403708,
-0.1184136122,
0.019658234,
-0.1604955643,
0.2567850053,
-0.5909788609,
0.7109349966,
0.0472957455,
-0.3302334547,
0.0311878119,
0.6147419214,
-0.0001913124,
0.2097153962,
0.5188043118,
0.441231221,
0.7160496712,
-0.2605955899,
1.1624560356,
-0.428933531,
0.0518876091,
1.2416086197,
-0.347979337,
0.6993350387,
0.2784757912,
-0.1992404014,
0.3659459949,
0.4649557769,
0.3341538608,
0.1115654111,
0.3783920705,
-0.4047788382,
-0.3855260909,
-0.4426244497,
-0.1158914566,
0.3526151776,
0.8874240518,
-0.6405546665,
-0.0728714466,
-0.4390200973,
0.0069919359,
-0.0267326441,
-0.2338680327,
0.7681083679,
0.5091976523,
-0.9813844562,
0.495760411,
-0.2510772049,
0.4109645784,
-0.3865379989,
0.0647553578,
0.0260895472,
0.2853765786,
-0.1483657509,
-0.9010726213,
-0.0592564493,
0.0278075431,
-0.0191195346,
-0.2760994434,
0.8503497243,
-0.463031292,
0.0250910632,
0.3486209214,
0.1936244667,
0.4778257012,
-0.1548485756,
-0.5274360776,
0.2103510797,
-0.089991875,
-0.2345038801,
0.0733274147,
0.4523348808,
0.0298393108,
0.5972586274,
0.2597810924,
-0.1417872161,
0.0150273964,
0.2306877822,
0.6849662066,
-0.4709785581,
-0.3473600447,
-0.8277614713,
0.4201132953,
-0.4372227788,
-0.4655387104,
0.6835511327,
0.431581825,
0.2969531715,
0.3478938341,
0.8484075069,
0.3205528259,
0.6450732946,
-0.3543921411,
0.1045382321,
-0.1207923442,
0.0599171259,
-0.4428564012,
-0.9379994869,
-0.0958395079,
0.5405654311,
-0.7891320586,
-0.2469969094,
0.8025033474,
0.5698352456,
0.0297371354,
0.3266475499,
0.3728493452,
0.2716007829,
0.2590574026,
0.3532541394,
1.1929516792,
-0.0754039288,
0.7556041479,
0.0325980708,
-0.1505612284,
-0.6237011552,
-0.9780681133,
-0.9351266026,
0.0048859706,
-0.3503876626,
0.0588576272,
0.1293986589,
0.9535275102,
0.6452747583,
-0.5635973215,
-0.19659096,
-0.1392769217,
0.1510424316,
-0.102544181,
-0.178435728,
0.2049836963,
-0.5943594575,
-1.0870847702,
0.5502294898,
0.6511331797,
0.0317081809,
-0.0629266948,
0.0861387998,
0.0026745163,
0.2670353055,
0.3524863422,
0.1962002367,
-0.9792699814,
-0.3530005515,
-0.1425684094,
-0.2724266946,
0.3993366659,
1.0134003162,
-0.370395124,
0.5467039347,
0.3381884098,
0.6223063469,
0.4912160039,
0.4141670763,
0.9329251647,
-0.6460387111,
0.2997458875,
0.2215442955,
0.5416492224,
0.4435248971,
-0.2736546397,
0.5908011794,
-0.1455717236,
-0.8666159511,
-0.5851840973,
0.2724084556,
-1.0316115618,
0.0643358603,
1.409153223,
-0.4131965041,
-0.0785998851,
-0.4857538939,
-0.4216299951,
0.0827736333,
-0.5946418643,
0.4111517072,
0.9902516603,
0.0288885459,
-0.1436506957,
-0.8470787406,
0.6099362969,
0.7876602411,
-0.7620360851,
0.2441479713,
0.4208803773,
-0.1662809104,
0.078493163,
0.717623651,
0.0419293009,
0.1717073917,
-0.3780187666,
-0.0719017312,
0.6153866053,
0.0941820964,
-0.3160695434,
-0.1010721922,
0.5175258517,
-0.0081292307
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11050v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11050v1 | A Peek into Token Bias: Large Language Models Are Not Yet Genuine Reasoners | 2024-06-16T19:22:53 | 2024-06-16T19:22:53 | Bowen Jiang, Yangxinyu Xie, Zhuoqun Hao, Xiaomeng Wang, Tanwi Mallick, Weijie J. Su, Camillo J. Taylor, Dan Roth | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This study introduces a hypothesis-testing framework to assess whether large
language models (LLMs) possess genuine reasoning abilities or primarily depend
on token bias. We go beyond evaluating LLMs on accuracy; rather, we aim to
investigate their token bias in solving logical reasoning tasks. Specifically,
we develop carefully controlled synthetic datasets, featuring conjunction
fallacy and syllogistic problems. Our framework outlines a list of hypotheses
where token biases are readily identifiable, with all null hypotheses assuming
genuine reasoning capabilities of LLMs. The findings in this study suggest,
with statistical guarantee, that most LLMs still struggle with logical
reasoning. While they may perform well on classic problems, their success
largely depends on recognizing superficial patterns with strong token bias,
thereby raising concerns about their actual reasoning and generalization
abilities. | [
-0.2189116329,
-0.8572227359,
1.0043822527,
0.18308267,
-0.1310603172,
0.0560876429,
-0.1300462484,
-0.1584148705,
0.1919850707,
0.5241861343,
-0.5823005438,
-0.2188230306,
-0.6717125773,
0.2370414883,
-0.5674058795,
0.7065299153,
0.0794890895,
0.4392490387,
-0.3736979067,
-0.1646977365,
-0.6713782549,
-0.7081077695,
-0.6760289073,
-0.442045778,
0.3755141497,
0.2135304362,
0.5680167079,
0.3820812106,
0.3063870966,
0.2645903826,
-0.274748385,
0.0172989573,
-0.2954950631,
0.0310608093,
-0.5479102135,
-0.8938029408,
-0.1734846383,
0.2272987515,
0.4397862852,
0.808134973,
0.0984902531,
0.2330488414,
-0.3332671225,
0.4065039158,
-0.5025293827,
0.1211905405,
-0.9615100622,
0.0185403787,
-0.3135683537,
0.0242429152,
-0.8117666245,
-0.1611526608,
0.0485355631,
-0.3594159782,
0.3151552677,
0.5017107129,
0.6288001537,
0.3380345404,
-0.6407614946,
-0.1654152274,
-0.2899680436,
1.0251477957,
-1.0426490307,
0.4400396049,
0.374108851,
0.1996673197,
-0.4303831756,
-0.4989478886,
-0.8793570995,
-0.4195671678,
-0.0924830809,
-0.2320470065,
-0.0111129591,
0.0873067975,
0.7226701379,
0.2796042562,
-0.3881603181,
0.0853412375,
-0.2111454308,
-0.6013725996,
0.2187484354,
0.1363147348,
0.3498985767,
-0.3124723434,
-0.3901821971,
0.2077301145,
-0.7762216926,
-0.0643677264,
0.3614547551,
0.1696487367,
-0.0427273363,
0.8811506629,
0.1512584537,
0.7883177996,
0.0163140688,
-0.3140846789,
0.0542148203,
-0.3692188859,
-0.287386477,
0.1155260801,
0.51973629,
0.2569310665,
0.3669328094,
-0.0199221727,
-0.417984128,
0.3507157564,
-0.0403466448,
-0.5368680358,
-0.048644565,
0.3520253599,
-0.5945666432,
-0.1312389672,
0.1284673512,
-0.5300181508,
-0.4888940156,
-0.4853796065,
0.3227132857,
-0.2602626681,
-0.2823599577,
0.2254564762,
-0.5952088833,
0.331466347,
0.2054168582,
-0.7164638638,
0.1695841551,
1.0482927561,
0.7817775607,
-0.4652279317,
-0.1241502464,
-0.7344477773,
-0.2299730778,
-0.5872479677,
0.8088636994,
-0.5963816643,
-0.2773765624,
-0.0190475266,
0.0802628919,
-0.2178587765,
-0.5980275869,
0.8217974305,
-0.4061494768,
0.2737084031,
-0.7445572615,
-0.6526776552,
0.193519339,
0.4518654346,
-0.6124756336,
0.7529299259,
0.1693044752,
-1.1304273605,
0.7555916309,
-0.4117408097,
-0.4675763845,
-0.2725000978,
-0.5030385256,
-0.0749112666,
0.2375519276,
0.1099727303,
0.1161230206,
-0.5340590477,
0.4886381924,
-0.520131588,
-0.4504987597,
0.6503320336,
-0.5063689351,
0.9608487487,
0.0307549424,
-0.6381859779,
0.1890160292,
-0.639723897,
-0.2425631881,
0.0920771956,
-0.2107362747,
-0.272158891,
0.2253974378,
-0.0873744786,
0.3839073777,
0.0592241436,
-0.6622012854,
0.359977752,
-0.4274678826,
0.5649884343,
1.1985501051,
-0.2918927073,
0.2548571229,
-0.2563378215,
0.5085110068,
0.3511484563,
0.0850961432,
-0.0294539444,
-0.5632064342,
-1.1746901274,
-0.3750036955,
0.4100109935,
0.2789368629,
-0.7901566029,
0.4444572031,
-0.1240470409,
-0.0607488528,
-0.2544078529,
0.048711881,
0.4051184356,
0.6618711948,
0.0700466111,
-0.1958154291,
-0.5063608885,
-1.2025153637,
-0.4629617631,
-0.3736403584,
0.0261767786,
0.1799743772,
0.740449369,
-0.2666757405,
1.0995069742,
-0.2082973868,
-0.0834229887,
-0.389731437,
-0.2322169989,
0.4816067815,
0.2753025889,
0.4207520783,
-0.713472724,
0.1180814654,
-0.2687466741,
-0.6760042906,
-0.1965243369,
-0.0163896512,
0.0158445705,
0.4569166899,
0.548207581,
-1.0309818983,
0.4298572838,
0.4325009882,
-0.8549950719,
0.8432582021,
0.1982923448,
-0.1922750175,
-0.7675654888,
0.0984671712,
0.0961405262,
-0.0170083232,
-0.3212441802,
-0.1493827403,
-0.0950503349,
0.2362788916,
-0.2448547333,
0.9086529613,
-0.2723255157,
-0.1980375051,
-0.1836831123,
-0.0661432073,
0.0854779109,
0.0936460942,
-0.0993018597,
0.7750801444,
0.5382723808,
-0.3999908566,
0.3051710725,
0.0548581406,
-0.3464612067,
0.6194163561,
-0.71550107,
0.0833966807,
-0.151090309,
0.4611259997,
-1.025377512,
-0.3181140423,
0.1892961562,
-0.3674875796,
0.0516555496,
-0.1994032115,
-0.7020477653,
-0.5789092183,
-0.157603249,
0.3228266239,
0.483784616,
-0.6379801035,
0.6162654161,
0.2162728012,
0.1659143716,
-0.7806971669,
-0.7826922536,
-0.0238271188,
-0.3610025942,
-0.4940773845,
-0.0862368941,
0.0696154237,
-0.767716229,
-0.1981108636,
-0.4040041864,
0.150673002,
-0.0420753956,
0.0960554928,
0.4088928103,
-0.2102772146,
0.208433494,
-0.1606991887,
-0.1803070456,
0.4676336348,
-0.6722308993,
0.5839827061,
0.1152776107,
-0.7503346801,
-0.2233463079,
-0.0666950047,
0.7735565305,
-0.1295618564,
0.7008838058,
0.3110662997,
-0.2642971873,
-0.4037801325,
-0.9929823875,
-0.4063344002,
-0.4360443354,
0.170795247,
-0.4659065902,
-1.0259847641,
0.7079585195,
0.1811011285,
-0.1268680245,
0.4213887453,
0.6352285147,
0.3491278589,
1.1770927906,
0.2650751472,
-0.1805406064,
0.0486669689,
0.0115563227,
0.5100050569,
-0.5983178616,
-0.2750477791,
-0.5395129919,
-0.0742244422,
-0.5867316127,
-0.5807771087,
0.0786011219,
-0.1584984511,
-0.3485679328,
-0.0737323985,
-0.2393913865,
0.5119363666,
0.513779521,
-0.1216381043,
0.2257456034,
-0.2607023418,
-0.3972351253,
0.0182866808,
-0.7326508164,
-0.5350757241,
1.1219376326,
0.3971862793,
0.5805071592,
-0.0694627464,
0.0964976475,
0.2201474011,
0.2750582397,
-0.8619639277,
0.6068953872,
0.1538823992,
-0.9881642461,
-0.1693129092,
-0.5638827085,
-0.6800475717,
0.2970809639,
0.0705412328,
-0.7351725698,
0.2355230302,
0.270888865,
0.1758032292,
0.4346311688,
-0.6476565003,
0.8563492894,
-0.1748518497,
-0.3195506036,
0.0573448353,
-0.5881623626,
0.6727707982,
-0.1795847416,
0.4179371297,
-0.1991962343,
0.0562373511,
0.7946655154,
-0.5671117306,
0.8231711984,
-0.2005478442,
-0.2268435657,
0.3354640305,
0.2594565153,
0.3815462589,
0.1083133742,
-0.3315129578,
0.1085892767,
0.1073355898,
-0.8424074054,
-0.6402776837,
0.6054243445,
-0.518586278,
-0.9068882465,
-0.5807659626,
-0.322041899,
-0.4408083856,
0.3414025903,
0.1086646244,
0.3669922054,
-0.0426230133,
0.1092615947,
0.5782570839,
-0.0656698048,
0.1580011696,
0.2749185264,
-0.4493229389,
-0.1711304337,
0.6909357309,
0.0369924307,
0.401989758,
0.0396047495,
0.4486962557,
-0.4345134199,
-0.6249501109,
-0.4260365963,
0.2956747413,
-0.8817276955,
0.0237371642,
-0.2445955426,
-0.04642592,
-0.3694224358,
0.0824424028,
-0.1597037762,
-0.3471583128,
0.0259256177,
-0.2942552567,
0.0198419616,
0.6524145603,
0.2093695998,
0.017578125,
-0.2517978847,
0.2103878409,
0.3371604085,
0.163046971,
0.0190312658,
-0.645765245,
0.1734332144,
-0.1753449738,
0.0908084884,
-0.6707684994,
0.1237519383,
-0.2838635743,
0.5783805847,
0.6757795811,
-0.0998254865,
0.3620651066,
-0.4296322763,
0.9245836735,
0.2290010452,
-1.1166324615,
0.4392724633,
-0.4835463166,
0.0321244262,
0.4320801497,
0.2016812712,
-0.2548654079,
-0.2251359224,
-0.631106317,
-0.4303770959,
0.5038759112,
0.0789500177,
0.177147463,
-0.3887571394,
0.4564891756,
0.1323588938,
0.3304823041,
-0.7067187428,
-0.217074573,
-0.0970181003,
-0.1185705066,
-0.0803462863,
-0.3647908568,
-0.2123416066,
-0.3738772571,
0.3562664092,
-0.3882858455,
0.0250581186,
0.2661280036,
0.0728105679,
-0.0271192696,
0.2915615737,
0.5105349422,
1.1073594093,
-0.0120230867,
0.5176507831,
0.1591730863,
-0.3067069054,
0.2429584414,
-0.1626044214,
-0.224007532,
0.0522114411,
0.7207852602,
0.776458919,
0.0237392671,
-1.055867672,
0.8156868219,
0.0276992749,
-0.2606754601,
-0.4342703521,
0.0123964092,
0.1027102843,
0.0054690773,
0.4334480762,
0.0667660087,
0.0646908581,
-0.8382344246,
0.0595564023,
0.7217217684,
-0.3324644864,
-0.3840966821,
0.5191278458,
0.0466413461,
-0.2458501309,
0.7025076151,
-0.1300275475,
-0.7547631264,
0.6893566251,
0.7736460567,
0.4854598045,
0.1767182052,
-0.0436565503,
0.0390033051,
0.4756676555,
-0.2265227288,
0.1665987819,
0.259686619,
-0.9842839241,
-0.6913899779,
-0.55480057,
-0.3872909844,
0.1467837095,
-0.374928683,
0.3743679821,
-0.5405365229,
-0.3709768355,
-0.080463089,
-0.2150007486,
-0.5584507585,
0.2798252404,
-0.0012318179,
1.2231391668,
-0.8798713684,
0.6499714851,
0.5558327436,
-0.2919647098,
-0.7466180325,
0.1190127358,
0.1108474135,
-0.9022487998,
0.9562696815,
0.3648932576,
0.0995290801,
-0.3248405159,
-0.6770339608,
-0.6686353087,
0.7414918542,
0.6975677013,
-0.5141125321,
-0.2384359837,
0.1861752272,
0.3313078582,
-0.2276573777,
0.2898797393,
0.8444895744,
0.6972358823,
0.206354484,
-1.017424345,
0.1145634502,
-0.1177426949,
-0.2118789703,
0.0978503376,
-0.760415256,
0.9340295792,
-0.1548284143,
0.1325912625,
-0.2038062662,
0.4427517951,
0.6529644132,
0.4933814704,
0.7330563664,
0.7976678014,
0.7273846269,
-0.2504042685,
1.0474984646,
-0.153158322,
0.1328442544,
0.7822575569,
-0.5772515535,
0.6573148966,
0.9302427173,
-0.1861548424,
0.4995279908,
0.5538304448,
0.0804590359,
0.0832096115,
0.6393271685,
-0.1291247457,
-0.6849260926,
-0.2092672288,
-0.0962450132,
0.5186617374,
0.3336559236,
-0.3730450571,
0.2315485477,
-0.097114183,
0.1708062589,
-0.0668111369,
-0.2217220068,
0.3781552315,
0.3104529977,
-0.8625563383,
0.2179593742,
-0.0079927826,
0.7361642122,
-0.3530293405,
-0.0083496645,
-0.2741766274,
0.181270957,
-0.2127782553,
-0.4793373346,
0.1315202862,
-0.1000101417,
-0.0587441213,
0.1518298686,
0.9191889763,
0.175519824,
-0.5584181547,
0.1898825169,
0.6768459678,
0.0167830884,
0.0308103859,
-0.5530340075,
0.3657377362,
0.0379777439,
-0.331397146,
0.2786216438,
0.5832775235,
-0.2590601146,
0.8410615921,
0.9127323627,
0.2346175164,
0.0855443925,
0.2242961526,
0.9024173617,
-0.6251546741,
-0.2492149323,
-1.2444396019,
0.3518343568,
-0.2357511371,
-0.3150002956,
0.9374222755,
0.7189019322,
0.6594130397,
-0.0347765833,
0.7706099749,
0.1883852184,
0.4705815613,
-0.7579860091,
0.4744263589,
-0.36182037,
0.2096373439,
-0.1240173057,
-0.9041721225,
-0.1985900849,
0.7113060951,
-0.5865132213,
0.1436224431,
0.8044976592,
0.7083111405,
-0.1658366919,
-0.043597009,
0.2183523476,
0.3358649313,
0.3804992437,
0.4076908529,
1.1789318323,
-0.1327437609,
0.0982493013,
0.2111898214,
-0.1661575139,
-0.140267849,
-0.9582588077,
-1.4982640743,
-0.2695141733,
-0.0732310265,
-0.6236293316,
0.0446555242,
0.9640317559,
0.6597941518,
-0.8861958385,
0.0246771351,
-0.33520028,
0.4670490324,
0.3776110113,
-0.273645252,
0.3436767459,
-0.4354501069,
-0.5761732459,
0.2799187899,
0.1589749753,
-0.1625328809,
-0.5422100425,
0.0922180414,
0.1558277011,
0.4347079694,
0.5405578017,
-0.0509915538,
-1.1157355309,
-0.5205414295,
0.212663874,
0.0241485462,
-0.1038005054,
1.0862157345,
-0.7235424519,
0.3165471256,
0.49636361,
0.5612710118,
0.1321068853,
-0.0849924535,
0.5484461784,
-0.3083975315,
0.4078993499,
0.210310936,
0.6805251837,
0.2584334016,
0.034782026,
0.3831472695,
0.6509142518,
-0.516793251,
-1.1385588646,
0.3169363141,
-0.9555003047,
-0.2894493639,
1.3598085642,
-0.026287498,
-0.3169257641,
-0.1382495165,
-0.3620715141,
-0.0887836218,
-0.0841909349,
0.6789517999,
0.9311185479,
-0.0317252763,
0.1120795384,
-0.6420350671,
0.4656783044,
0.6762521863,
-0.5498588085,
0.0191126578,
0.5935109258,
0.4770507812,
0.1025511399,
0.663176477,
-0.1126858443,
0.1330809444,
0.1287302226,
-0.3879231811,
0.1971298605,
-0.1479067206,
-0.1626318693,
-0.0574171357,
0.4777178764,
0.3467432857
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11049v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11049v1 | Reconsidering Sentence-Level Sign Language Translation | 2024-06-16T19:19:54 | 2024-06-16T19:19:54 | Garrett Tanzer, Maximus Shengelia, Ken Harrenstien, David Uthus | cs.CL | cs.CL | Historically, sign language machine translation has been posed as a
sentence-level task: datasets consisting of continuous narratives are chopped
up and presented to the model as isolated clips. In this work, we explore the
limitations of this task framing. First, we survey a number of linguistic
phenomena in sign languages that depend on discourse-level context. Then as a
case study, we perform the first human baseline for sign language translation
that actually substitutes a human into the machine learning task framing,
rather than provide the human with the entire document as context. This human
baseline -- for ASL to English translation on the How2Sign dataset -- shows
that for 33% of sentences in our sample, our fluent Deaf signer annotators were
only able to understand key parts of the clip in light of additional
discourse-level context. These results underscore the importance of
understanding and sanity checking examples when adapting machine learning to
new domains. | [
0.1263560355,
-0.3493473232,
0.4067889154,
0.1110915914,
-0.3569330573,
-0.0288630631,
0.0864279643,
-0.5110616088,
-0.2716988921,
0.7049850821,
-0.5581213236,
-0.5769225955,
-1.0795475245,
0.4227745533,
-0.4375248253,
1.1103476286,
-0.326167345,
-0.1438663751,
0.0167730246,
-0.2712308168,
-0.6296243668,
-0.4141360521,
-0.707742691,
-0.1537509561,
-0.2286390215,
0.4162561893,
0.7498468161,
0.5834575891,
0.346300602,
0.2226762772,
-0.0153952669,
-0.1022849753,
-0.2645587921,
0.0815926939,
0.1505547017,
-0.3909848332,
-0.447562784,
0.2569831014,
0.7010490298,
1.0552322865,
0.479116112,
0.0528658777,
0.0660430118,
0.4248700142,
-0.36624071,
0.3452927172,
-0.5110453367,
0.3090867698,
-0.2459089905,
0.1017546207,
-0.598888576,
0.1008469909,
0.0587704517,
-0.6292605996,
0.2907478809,
0.2281129062,
0.8759221435,
0.6407026052,
-1.0066312551,
-0.2947784066,
-0.5299457312,
0.6434165835,
-0.8042151332,
0.2759155035,
0.4967364073,
0.077773951,
-0.0521886833,
-0.497711271,
-0.3276502192,
-0.1324292719,
-0.3393722475,
-0.0683310702,
-0.3008046746,
0.1363606006,
0.5795254111,
0.1262207627,
-0.4806398749,
0.0754750818,
-0.6466885209,
-0.3553716242,
0.530867517,
0.1844065338,
0.5205228329,
-0.5651220083,
-0.5793628693,
-0.0124873016,
-0.5378029943,
0.2187267095,
-0.0789456218,
0.4377427101,
-0.0487465896,
0.5906433463,
-0.0188924819,
0.913847208,
0.0044370349,
-0.0621087663,
0.1979036927,
-0.3635326028,
-0.0816890597,
-0.06980443,
0.7102825642,
0.385725975,
0.2329890728,
0.1160468832,
-0.2666796744,
-0.0974454358,
0.1093785688,
-0.5501956344,
0.0106415041,
0.0986017287,
-0.1944158971,
0.2451869398,
-0.0017962598,
0.0311684813,
-0.2991267443,
-0.198815763,
0.2529093027,
-0.4040463567,
-0.0044854367,
0.2165634334,
-0.0954498649,
0.1522129327,
0.2731992304,
-0.551908493,
0.3792244196,
0.7215542793,
0.7309808731,
-0.2559202909,
-0.3459226191,
-0.6494515538,
0.0428384803,
-0.2676724494,
0.3556272089,
-0.3278942108,
-0.3579961658,
-0.1071992591,
0.1034206748,
-0.1802028269,
-0.3655869067,
0.5424816012,
-0.3171177208,
0.4644780755,
-0.1135883033,
-0.627098918,
0.0324945748,
-0.1716336906,
-0.3829631805,
0.6626798511,
0.2444309145,
-0.3488385081,
0.6898160577,
-0.5034654737,
-1.0966104269,
0.0235380139,
-0.0854685605,
-0.464020431,
0.0938009769,
0.2687816322,
0.4906729758,
0.1327204108,
0.2033286095,
0.2440446764,
-0.3256544769,
0.3444420397,
-0.1002675518,
1.1195971966,
0.3086413443,
-0.5260224342,
-0.0220935028,
-0.5810836554,
-0.2817824185,
-0.2262975276,
-0.1540084928,
-0.2576463223,
-0.171279639,
0.1369847208,
0.4339250326,
-0.0534072816,
-0.6032956839,
-0.1567145437,
-0.2893201113,
0.7173457146,
0.385958612,
0.0872678682,
0.3897044957,
0.0506935492,
0.6842990518,
0.1025884077,
-0.0490721501,
-0.4314166009,
-0.6931249499,
-0.6125689745,
-0.219292596,
0.1024823263,
0.521550715,
-0.5288385153,
0.4086242914,
-0.1553607136,
0.280515939,
-0.777363956,
0.0089427,
0.8237628937,
0.5877081752,
0.4574309289,
-0.4475310743,
-0.5464993715,
-0.8407999873,
-0.4309176207,
-0.325697422,
-0.2491494119,
-0.1201335862,
0.5609150529,
0.3263120055,
0.856000483,
-0.3040045798,
-0.6089152098,
-0.1489110589,
0.1569288969,
0.1065149456,
0.6556560993,
0.2330908775,
-0.860306561,
-0.4248664081,
-0.1476719677,
-0.787894547,
-0.1522812396,
-0.6513025165,
0.2854154408,
0.1176289394,
0.8414204121,
-0.5846591592,
0.6017146111,
0.628424108,
-0.817717135,
0.195160836,
-0.2073855102,
0.3283191025,
-1.1045850515,
0.1318869293,
-0.0166789368,
-0.5997033715,
-0.7018985152,
0.0282559488,
0.1198261008,
-0.5465174317,
-0.4684404135,
0.4159729481,
-0.7538627982,
-0.5148878098,
-0.4970094264,
0.4702550769,
0.1096576825,
0.3615519106,
-0.1134025529,
0.7640962601,
0.3713794947,
-0.4199467301,
-0.1498282552,
0.746740818,
-0.2829171419,
0.8531746864,
-0.6345723271,
0.1969773024,
-0.1345978677,
0.4263768494,
-1.00736022,
-0.3889589012,
0.5252150893,
-0.585187912,
0.3666030467,
-0.090294987,
-0.1988397092,
-0.3135255575,
0.1309598088,
0.4093016088,
0.6895777583,
-0.0832274109,
0.215097487,
0.5031625032,
0.1361921728,
-0.2638239264,
-0.9467043877,
0.6241490841,
-0.1979960501,
-0.5632817745,
0.1332062632,
0.2919778526,
-0.2836324871,
-0.0902595297,
-0.3398660421,
-0.1113571599,
0.4150372446,
0.3656955957,
-0.0111403679,
-0.2921421826,
-0.1420444697,
0.2092595249,
-0.3986644745,
0.0203242302,
-0.4524011314,
-0.2171028107,
-0.032289993,
-0.5925446749,
-0.8640072942,
0.4196351171,
0.4709658027,
0.0198833086,
0.6220128536,
0.2920203209,
-0.4525515437,
0.04961586,
-0.0042712227,
0.0067350082,
-0.3826693296,
0.3816180527,
-0.6880847216,
-1.1953619719,
0.2230422497,
0.2208685428,
0.3078806996,
0.4752217829,
0.3114136159,
-0.3025234044,
0.8139153719,
0.4164064229,
0.1784426868,
0.3090749085,
0.185407877,
0.3483217657,
-0.930318892,
0.0230925586,
-0.4200036228,
-0.4478442073,
-0.2345345169,
-0.500502944,
0.5468786955,
0.3412311673,
0.10170497,
1.1261491776,
-0.3370994329,
0.2933818102,
0.1233128607,
0.1055173129,
0.6078585982,
-0.3891627789,
0.3292420506,
-0.2393914908,
-0.5140137672,
-0.6457561851,
0.8637790084,
0.3026787043,
0.1210343018,
-0.0461956896,
0.4949818254,
0.4587462246,
0.2311245352,
-0.5205937624,
0.6776877642,
-0.2134070843,
-0.781529367,
-0.5909492373,
-0.2969689369,
-1.1878336668,
0.4647597075,
0.0426036082,
-0.6419672966,
-0.0056275614,
0.3632026911,
-0.1422672719,
0.051100865,
-0.8445467949,
1.200145483,
-0.2507738471,
0.1630469561,
0.0310170725,
-0.9980974197,
0.2751840353,
-0.0485615619,
0.4263800383,
-0.306879431,
-0.2312704772,
0.5740988851,
-0.4811222851,
1.2731971741,
-0.0882577822,
-0.2185310125,
0.1982320845,
0.1342695206,
0.397200048,
-0.1948878765,
-0.1266768277,
-0.0813340619,
-0.0801982284,
-0.8648761511,
-0.4109136462,
0.0426803045,
-0.5619294047,
-0.8751462698,
-0.2847722173,
-0.6369697452,
-0.3578853607,
0.1472436935,
0.3419238031,
0.3255192339,
-0.2214079499,
-0.0122194989,
0.3275257945,
0.130329296,
0.1721559167,
0.3696670234,
-0.0046633324,
-0.0276543088,
0.7140383124,
-0.1861298233,
0.5806515813,
0.3618791401,
-0.0133587625,
-0.049292583,
-0.8542920947,
-0.8079401255,
0.0639132187,
-0.773029983,
0.1767862439,
-0.4733968079,
0.075203523,
-0.534933269,
-0.2239358574,
-0.0785672292,
-0.584613502,
-0.5166270733,
-0.2216328233,
0.0952269211,
0.5940387249,
0.0770988092,
0.1048129052,
-0.5928926468,
0.2915691733,
-0.0299323928,
-0.2297089547,
-0.4138582051,
-0.843274951,
-0.1605650038,
-0.0565401018,
0.0146200713,
-0.7559100389,
-0.1411923766,
0.4183490872,
0.2132326216,
0.3116698265,
0.3400859237,
0.670756042,
-0.5842514634,
0.9948388934,
0.4649028778,
-1.1166462898,
0.5052669048,
-0.3228490949,
0.6707205176,
0.4642467499,
0.4007534981,
-0.9129058719,
-0.8661743402,
-0.3308550417,
-0.812117219,
0.7098882198,
0.519841969,
0.3040291965,
0.0171384793,
0.3592342138,
0.2685056329,
0.1488060951,
-0.7749242187,
-0.1131726354,
-0.1770676374,
-0.2162126005,
-0.2450038642,
0.0753157511,
-0.0106910756,
-0.1745224446,
0.3359186649,
-0.234786287,
-0.0582116246,
0.043503426,
-0.6542727351,
-0.0749197751,
0.2877963185,
0.6249026656,
0.5378554463,
0.3260591924,
0.2177635878,
0.2966476083,
-0.1828222722,
0.1694871634,
-0.0861570984,
-0.5916776657,
0.1081568524,
0.8696331382,
1.2452446222,
0.7107189894,
-0.657143712,
0.5272859931,
0.4720213711,
-0.2991901934,
-0.0532053635,
-0.0641799644,
0.0310763791,
0.0713267177,
0.209322691,
0.2083477229,
0.0054813283,
-0.666344285,
0.4701440036,
0.2087829113,
-0.7565280199,
-0.4948543608,
0.913941741,
0.289291501,
-0.6788557172,
0.4241375029,
-0.0944922492,
-0.7060756683,
0.4002944827,
0.5329794288,
0.8488040566,
0.0189142078,
0.4040311873,
0.2338527441,
0.4343432486,
-0.023753712,
-0.10617356,
-0.2590369284,
-0.4235934317,
-0.5702751279,
-0.273404479,
-0.4291490316,
-0.2862418294,
-0.6645169258,
0.1126381382,
-0.1720273644,
-0.2498211116,
-0.1054963842,
-0.442361623,
-0.4616553187,
0.1952595562,
0.282258004,
0.709733665,
-1.0869913101,
0.6589375138,
0.6279307604,
-0.4300428033,
-0.4123079777,
0.2839570045,
0.090279758,
-0.691493094,
0.591740489,
0.054630816,
-0.1841204464,
0.0842435658,
-0.1976763755,
-0.7394333482,
0.6849126816,
0.344484657,
-0.0691376105,
-0.1344354749,
0.4083947241,
0.7169322371,
-0.4236173034,
-0.3925084472,
0.6547195911,
0.4008950889,
0.0270636827,
-1.0649396181,
0.3631948233,
0.0369021147,
0.1830879897,
0.0998033956,
-0.4369259775,
0.6395885944,
-0.2651868463,
-0.5728530288,
0.0521376356,
0.955466032,
-0.1614194512,
0.3925742209,
0.4917813838,
0.1882634312,
0.6093607545,
0.0759124979,
0.9952988029,
-0.0111552421,
0.153420791,
1.1164987087,
-0.3184371591,
0.7694962025,
0.5968413353,
-0.2459540367,
0.3309960961,
0.4905809164,
0.1116328537,
0.0910313949,
0.1557155699,
-0.081928432,
-0.3659696877,
0.1078414321,
-0.0157633144,
0.3378049433,
0.090803571,
-0.2421704531,
-0.2094716877,
0.4249380827,
0.2257368565,
0.5152235627,
-0.0587333366,
0.5630702972,
0.4614952803,
-0.8037935495,
0.6095596552,
0.0616045035,
0.3121230006,
-0.271558553,
0.2359323204,
-0.1491299272,
0.0338082723,
-0.1480499208,
-0.8635931015,
0.6277395487,
0.1788969487,
0.0230743047,
-0.9179699421,
0.4517017901,
-0.4096227884,
-0.3799062073,
-0.0739897564,
0.433195591,
0.5387742519,
0.1536889076,
-0.7509536147,
0.1397491097,
0.0621869639,
-0.2371289134,
0.3418082297,
0.6248344779,
-0.1907594204,
0.6027860045,
0.3171506524,
-0.3054632545,
0.0807650015,
-0.199773699,
0.4632844031,
-0.6338990331,
-0.613150239,
-0.5448719263,
0.657766819,
-0.0456732288,
-0.8130365014,
0.9267261028,
0.5114785433,
0.9497503042,
-0.0786542669,
0.6684148908,
-0.1392533779,
0.2018382251,
-0.6690933704,
0.5169185996,
-0.5462327003,
0.0611950494,
-0.2631749511,
-0.4376963079,
-0.5058167577,
0.502184689,
-0.3281247318,
-0.293858856,
1.009296298,
0.3927268684,
0.0780409798,
0.0244242959,
0.5906378031,
0.0277602226,
0.0852476656,
0.7800519466,
0.4392895997,
-0.7731486559,
0.7947600484,
0.3602694869,
-0.14658916,
-0.1655734628,
-0.7743523717,
-0.9899873734,
-1.059202075,
-0.7684288025,
-0.4578497708,
-0.0339863226,
0.6967983246,
0.7115215659,
-1.1244477034,
-0.3667823076,
0.0609276108,
0.2051828653,
-0.3961020708,
-0.1216779947,
0.2836832404,
-0.3607284129,
-0.6839824915,
0.6588029861,
0.2671686709,
-0.0254848041,
-0.1187738627,
-0.1312370151,
0.0169687904,
-0.2873161137,
0.5556710958,
0.5822349787,
-0.8931512833,
-0.6474454403,
-0.1117429882,
-0.3932729065,
0.2424735129,
1.2101242542,
-0.5994639397,
0.2230996788,
0.0589607283,
0.6983808279,
0.6038327217,
-0.0603118241,
0.7504518628,
-0.8802681565,
0.1872553974,
0.2236310542,
0.2679394484,
0.4824540317,
-0.2193332165,
0.3333324194,
0.4108141363,
-0.0305358358,
-0.7613509297,
0.7030442357,
-0.9318143725,
-0.413302213,
0.9774631262,
-0.397405833,
-0.3176510036,
-0.5995879173,
-0.1672777832,
0.2713347375,
-0.134374395,
0.6358097792,
0.6703416109,
-0.2986465096,
-0.2696975768,
-0.5393348336,
0.5982935429,
0.5696602464,
-0.5239634514,
0.1810219586,
0.6235487461,
0.1693601906,
0.0339515284,
0.8394283652,
0.1070928648,
0.338786006,
0.0501958169,
-0.1993967146,
-0.2320070863,
-0.0722349882,
-0.305339694,
0.2728957236,
0.0849966556,
-0.3295342624
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11044v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11044v1 | Evaluating the Performance of Large Language Models via Debates | 2024-06-16T19:02:31 | 2024-06-16T19:02:31 | Behrad Moniri, Hamed Hassani, Edgar Dobriban | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large Language Models (LLMs) are rapidly evolving and impacting various
fields, necessitating the development of effective methods to evaluate and
compare their performance. Most current approaches for performance evaluation
are either based on fixed, domain-specific questions that lack the flexibility
required in many real-world applications where tasks are not always from a
single domain, or rely on human input, making them unscalable. We propose an
automated benchmarking framework based on debates between LLMs, judged by
another LLM. This method assesses not only domain knowledge, but also skills
such as problem definition and inconsistency recognition. We evaluate the
performance of various state-of-the-art LLMs using the debate framework and
achieve rankings that align closely with popular rankings based on human input,
eliminating the need for costly human crowdsourcing. | [
-0.5943880081,
-0.9035658836,
0.5185980201,
0.1503967643,
0.0310453363,
0.2518402934,
-0.5878498554,
-0.4755961895,
-0.0360631719,
0.6141065955,
-0.2799179256,
-0.3739552796,
-0.757901907,
0.1650623232,
-0.3670042157,
0.4135926068,
-0.0844330788,
0.1080625728,
-0.5394943953,
-0.4247949719,
-0.2499638647,
-0.5747053027,
-0.5850689411,
-0.5487868786,
0.3936804831,
0.2710361183,
0.725680232,
0.4934177101,
0.581859529,
0.5423221588,
-0.2531120777,
0.3166203499,
-0.5071463585,
0.3500854373,
-0.5838566422,
-0.1892441809,
-0.3523015678,
0.0453515016,
0.7992955446,
0.702339828,
-0.2449288964,
0.2008252442,
0.0301530529,
0.4812229574,
-0.5186185837,
0.0241782088,
-1.042363286,
0.0094984621,
-0.3582339883,
-0.2213335484,
-0.3370514214,
-0.6590013504,
0.2635410726,
-0.1681925505,
-0.0047304723,
0.1167824194,
0.9054071903,
0.2057142705,
-0.2802985907,
-0.3593553305,
-0.5268275142,
0.5626252294,
-0.9166888595,
0.3963986337,
0.0514413826,
0.3877161741,
-0.3502111733,
-0.5774126649,
-0.5782161951,
-0.4681371152,
0.121759668,
-0.1589530259,
-0.2895770967,
-0.0973958671,
0.252564013,
0.3469613492,
-0.5928806067,
0.4967660308,
-0.0178381577,
-0.0455102175,
0.8146015406,
0.3139924407,
0.0024469839,
0.030092584,
-0.1758109033,
-0.1177561209,
-0.6202396154,
-0.2463420928,
0.504339695,
0.2116671205,
0.2173383534,
0.5472848415,
-0.3296380639,
0.7091171145,
0.0671791583,
-0.0362787917,
0.2505100965,
0.0362172872,
-0.2908654213,
-0.4566450417,
1.0308730602,
0.3734054565,
0.1468537897,
-0.2853237987,
-0.3563320041,
-0.1088219956,
0.2591056526,
-0.7733759284,
-0.1044463292,
0.1545508951,
-0.1827015281,
-0.1309296042,
-0.2606610954,
-0.9226459861,
-0.6838991046,
-0.3821964562,
0.6405283213,
0.1491446197,
-0.2733272016,
0.0427395999,
0.0203438066,
-0.074877888,
0.4706485271,
-0.7340521216,
0.4641979635,
0.982111454,
0.5949804783,
-0.5539144278,
-0.264483422,
-0.4133243263,
-0.0773028955,
-0.3586173952,
1.0473507643,
-0.6750239134,
-0.3699521422,
0.1654208302,
-0.0814238787,
-0.2328095585,
-1.2238328457,
0.5517080426,
-0.7533705235,
0.0458737575,
-0.1586366743,
-1.0255234241,
0.1533521563,
0.6000468135,
-0.7302883863,
1.1542551517,
-0.1240701005,
-0.7176337242,
0.3365035653,
-0.6117278934,
-0.25022614,
0.3864089847,
-0.3132566214,
-0.3774383664,
-0.1561659873,
0.1190468222,
0.4335464835,
-0.6809358597,
0.4557620585,
-0.4078140259,
-0.2496481538,
0.3333429098,
-0.4456095695,
0.502912581,
0.0958944336,
-0.5211343765,
0.3470595181,
-0.7348134518,
0.2161988616,
0.1256967485,
-0.483066231,
-0.1736259013,
0.1583405584,
-0.0893174931,
0.1055766195,
0.1524371803,
-0.4219821393,
0.33092466,
-0.460878849,
0.4700778425,
0.7153023481,
-0.1104136556,
0.1213804632,
-0.2898665667,
0.5524092913,
-0.2119086534,
-0.0327450074,
0.246392563,
-0.3860390484,
-0.9313649535,
0.0151608549,
0.5190982223,
0.4278787374,
-0.5608556867,
0.3312683403,
-0.3988685906,
-0.6133152246,
-0.5809127688,
0.3764007092,
0.3851558566,
0.2853885293,
0.2319441885,
-0.4043960571,
-0.2814937532,
-0.9681806564,
-0.4509418905,
-0.2934473753,
-0.0150860287,
0.6475788355,
0.3926837444,
-0.0546936393,
0.8262981772,
-0.4036793113,
0.0924502686,
-0.2033728212,
0.5618206263,
-0.1147206649,
0.2830203176,
0.0872683078,
-0.4573765099,
-0.2776986659,
0.1531125158,
-0.6835799217,
-0.3567720652,
0.2285440266,
-0.1592159122,
0.4649515748,
0.5192679167,
-0.5430575609,
0.08589302,
0.5645083189,
-0.2045615315,
0.5532929301,
-0.0511941537,
0.4623123109,
-0.644082129,
0.1966009736,
-0.0120860208,
-0.2591526806,
-0.3109570742,
0.2763045728,
0.0578801222,
-0.0339685716,
-0.3466466367,
0.9141165614,
-0.3268972933,
-0.2373855114,
-0.1817075908,
0.4859639406,
-0.0074759005,
0.2843532264,
0.1873344034,
0.8238970637,
0.1706744283,
-0.3844279945,
0.4847421348,
-0.0370494202,
-0.8455452919,
0.6140387654,
-0.6391732097,
0.3793540001,
0.2831176817,
0.1592090428,
-1.0963383913,
0.0016036524,
-0.1424674094,
-0.1750220209,
0.205679208,
-0.3342508972,
-0.641649127,
-0.445507586,
-0.1237819269,
0.3967062533,
0.1477944851,
-0.4482351542,
0.2968605161,
0.7473375201,
-0.5142990351,
-0.5152865648,
-0.1244088933,
0.3988449574,
-0.3185509741,
-0.7386186123,
0.1114911959,
-0.1332668513,
-0.6400791407,
-0.1779816896,
0.1635301858,
-0.192189455,
0.1588872522,
0.0154063459,
0.0860968605,
-0.4121570289,
0.2528520226,
-0.1888564676,
0.0858439356,
0.129480049,
-0.0453232117,
0.4457219839,
-0.127409026,
-0.5865945816,
-0.1508123577,
0.196135208,
0.628493309,
-0.2865510583,
0.4380577207,
0.2106592357,
-0.3136971295,
-0.3943814635,
-1.2206628323,
0.0226869844,
-0.5047904849,
0.4944114387,
-0.3156511188,
-1.2067294121,
0.3248832226,
-0.5261983871,
0.1630129218,
0.4413040578,
0.9649324417,
0.1705119908,
0.9401211143,
0.3773486614,
-0.1421326101,
0.1386078149,
0.0181778241,
0.0239384342,
-0.5966228843,
-0.2555891573,
-0.7645767927,
-0.2650819421,
-0.2969184518,
-0.720893681,
0.2343918234,
-0.0584868751,
-0.3476103842,
0.332005769,
-0.3123945892,
0.6423277259,
0.1061889082,
-0.4592760801,
0.5202860832,
-0.0767982453,
-0.4332652688,
-0.0827496871,
-0.5625187159,
-0.7985298038,
0.9252160788,
0.3868921101,
0.680898428,
0.1913900375,
0.3526037931,
0.446680963,
0.6969528794,
-0.7317137122,
0.6798373461,
0.077764906,
-0.6379635334,
-0.556411922,
-0.6597867608,
-0.9128332138,
0.8261933327,
-0.2559149563,
-0.8508515954,
-0.0984537974,
-0.0361126773,
-0.2180174142,
0.5431420803,
-0.567679286,
1.0616714954,
-0.191980496,
-0.5328322649,
-0.3568044901,
-0.2273389995,
0.3410027325,
-0.0293798503,
0.2975049317,
-0.2829304636,
0.0382810421,
0.8622940183,
-0.4127987325,
0.4318684936,
-0.0387609266,
-0.3790576458,
0.1811973006,
0.1280935556,
0.309782505,
0.0560675785,
-0.3880655169,
0.1721576452,
0.066050224,
-0.0446844511,
-0.5938987732,
0.8882938027,
-0.778614819,
-0.8580530882,
-0.254553467,
-0.4572104216,
-0.6869113445,
0.0579450913,
-0.0831567645,
0.3205698729,
-0.6310561299,
0.0354901589,
0.5903810859,
-0.2962630689,
0.2867304087,
0.8135403395,
-0.3226955831,
-0.3313877881,
0.6686336994,
0.1825674921,
0.2500632405,
0.3513400257,
0.2568434775,
-0.4966591001,
-0.5338243246,
-0.6716868281,
0.1753350198,
-0.7273919582,
-0.2343746126,
-0.7043217421,
-0.1461930871,
-0.2232395113,
0.1118658707,
-0.6199125648,
-0.3782469034,
0.2273972183,
0.1045592427,
0.1634393781,
0.9895750284,
0.2549118102,
-0.0801841915,
-0.5559597611,
0.0271876026,
0.5363851786,
0.4759307802,
0.3445134759,
-0.7582420111,
-0.1310195029,
-0.3105127215,
-0.6109567285,
-0.3900237978,
0.2072770894,
-0.0639099777,
0.686455369,
0.2669366598,
-0.1013472006,
0.773119092,
-0.650819838,
0.63244313,
-0.0937944427,
-1.1100928783,
0.2034923136,
-0.1760944128,
0.0771240965,
0.7119547725,
0.2720741928,
-0.5243917108,
-0.4308848977,
-0.4444877207,
-0.8132137656,
0.5523197651,
0.0901254565,
-0.0348918252,
-0.0347495191,
0.069769688,
-0.0095602442,
0.296595186,
-0.4284922183,
-0.0502630398,
0.4140971601,
0.1876065433,
0.0212000795,
-0.1199458539,
-0.3209234476,
-0.4204776883,
0.5793672204,
-0.0346989185,
-0.0881880745,
-0.1364670694,
-0.2129786164,
-0.2883349657,
0.4348308444,
0.5631448627,
1.080512166,
0.0212071259,
0.135801062,
0.4958678484,
0.0058976589,
0.2428380549,
0.123741053,
-0.008100694,
0.0026055137,
0.3723606467,
0.6879975796,
0.4836392701,
-1.0306810141,
0.5239970088,
-0.1081539243,
-0.4068801105,
0.0441648327,
0.0031232052,
0.5956006646,
0.3979589641,
0.1239759326,
-0.2934791446,
0.0415842682,
-0.531001091,
0.2250995636,
0.5376255512,
-0.1603928357,
0.0480473414,
0.453689754,
0.3209041655,
-0.4844532013,
0.2776979208,
-0.0926134139,
-0.5713862777,
0.7246339321,
0.2350645661,
0.5949157476,
-0.2349518239,
0.1070562601,
0.2111493051,
0.2273946553,
-0.2326832712,
0.063111864,
0.1438320428,
-0.7086276412,
-0.3597861528,
-0.5014342666,
-0.9137211442,
0.4629812539,
-0.4701854289,
0.1371354461,
-0.4884752631,
-0.3147203326,
0.2743862569,
0.3197327554,
-0.6419850588,
0.0832850859,
0.2164366841,
1.0005905628,
-0.6131004095,
0.7097676396,
0.7573248148,
0.0463144295,
-0.5172119737,
0.0080454918,
-0.0045493841,
-0.6696279049,
0.6142368913,
-0.0556140058,
-0.3682096601,
-0.3412385583,
-0.4104409516,
-0.8093406558,
0.808347404,
0.5413628221,
-0.6945617795,
0.4515381157,
0.1750858575,
0.720692277,
-0.2820869088,
0.6140682697,
0.5700060725,
0.5544108748,
0.1697768569,
-1.2546408176,
-0.1678984463,
-0.4123276472,
-0.0628130138,
0.1117737889,
-0.9129542708,
0.7565167546,
0.1144190356,
-0.2078847885,
0.1553044915,
0.5606619716,
0.1972692758,
0.2527595162,
0.5380305052,
0.5562810302,
0.9329888225,
-0.0651541799,
0.6894182563,
-0.3380050957,
0.4497361779,
1.106662631,
-0.9633679986,
1.2573692799,
0.1547514796,
-0.5307735801,
0.2400565296,
0.4690681994,
-0.0388861932,
0.0812896118,
0.8509401679,
-0.2024203241,
-0.487803489,
-0.0298114512,
-0.2988145947,
0.4557755291,
0.2913433611,
-0.0283679757,
-0.3572464883,
-0.3567145467,
0.0887742713,
0.3459901214,
-0.0593182035,
0.8750788569,
-0.0521267094,
-1.0035604239,
0.8119822145,
0.4105207622,
0.7112379074,
-0.4692772031,
0.0098367548,
-0.2580191195,
0.3410991728,
-0.0034298403,
-0.7945793271,
0.1169717163,
0.3203782737,
0.0396661237,
0.0324790068,
0.4209388196,
-0.4806700051,
-0.4801695943,
0.5508464575,
0.5699450374,
0.2675818503,
0.1293358952,
-0.9308740497,
0.5142344236,
-0.4969296455,
-0.3077692688,
0.6166944504,
0.442148298,
-0.1657358557,
0.8859608769,
0.2606921792,
0.007959255,
-0.1499978155,
0.3578940928,
1.0462622643,
-0.3749524951,
-0.2366070896,
-0.8988741636,
-0.0077184374,
-0.2841120958,
-0.4678488076,
0.6815432906,
0.6965575218,
0.8424926996,
0.2135743052,
0.6988861561,
0.2450407594,
0.7303780317,
-0.3953876495,
0.9582167864,
-0.5658345819,
0.4522041678,
-0.4656680524,
-0.8083965778,
-0.1204037219,
0.6668627262,
-0.4581432343,
0.0574805103,
0.5234371424,
0.8734492064,
-0.0125562958,
0.1360084265,
0.3859625161,
0.2964540124,
0.3296248615,
0.5279651284,
0.9911828041,
-0.0502135903,
0.2743603885,
0.1709749401,
-0.2264626324,
-0.1862798035,
-1.0784281492,
-1.0746412277,
-0.3669533134,
-0.4142175317,
-0.1328176558,
0.2910195589,
1.1307945251,
0.6783331037,
-0.9365414381,
-0.7793729305,
0.4860032797,
0.3428652585,
0.0666575804,
-0.1896906793,
0.3994314373,
-0.1194466501,
-0.8149323463,
0.5691948533,
0.2776987255,
-0.4641753435,
-0.5386580229,
-0.0095923208,
-0.2594905496,
0.4219445586,
0.6955986023,
0.324237138,
-0.924685657,
-0.1679474413,
-0.3735662997,
-0.219293043,
0.0544306859,
0.8517407179,
-0.7110279799,
0.3516832888,
0.384537518,
0.9807064533,
0.3019297719,
0.105131045,
0.4793670774,
-0.450759083,
-0.143018961,
0.1585731357,
0.2448596358,
0.4964989126,
0.0858615488,
0.4561814964,
0.1949802041,
-0.7806236148,
-0.998182416,
-0.0080211563,
-0.6684195399,
-0.2053025067,
1.1883381605,
-0.3869668841,
0.2477839589,
-0.2602879703,
-0.0468159616,
-0.0708789453,
-0.2463922054,
0.8312042952,
0.9639860392,
0.0949285328,
0.165639773,
-0.6309553385,
0.4154169858,
0.4118084013,
-0.858489573,
0.4629305601,
0.2645221651,
0.4702333808,
-0.1008313745,
0.6515724063,
-0.2162039876,
-0.165773645,
-0.2707102597,
-0.0203405432,
0.173100248,
-0.207145825,
-0.249470219,
0.4446053803,
0.3080014288,
0.4427855313
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11036v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11036v1 | garak: A Framework for Security Probing Large Language Models | 2024-06-16T18:18:43 | 2024-06-16T18:18:43 | Leon Derczynski, Erick Galinkin, Jeffrey Martin, Subho Majumdar, Nanna Inie | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CR | As Large Language Models (LLMs) are deployed and integrated into thousands of
applications, the need for scalable evaluation of how models respond to
adversarial attacks grows rapidly. However, LLM security is a moving target:
models produce unpredictable output, are constantly updated, and the potential
adversary is highly diverse: anyone with access to the internet and a decent
command of natural language. Further, what constitutes a security weak in one
context may not be an issue in a different context; one-fits-all guardrails
remain theoretical. In this paper, we argue that it is time to rethink what
constitutes ``LLM security'', and pursue a holistic approach to LLM security
evaluation, where exploration and discovery of issues are central. To this end,
this paper introduces garak (Generative AI Red-teaming and Assessment Kit), a
framework which can be used to discover and identify vulnerabilities in a
target LLM or dialog system. garak probes an LLM in a structured fashion to
discover potential vulnerabilities. The outputs of the framework describe a
target model's weaknesses, contribute to an informed discussion of what
composes vulnerabilities in unique contexts, and can inform alignment and
policy discussions for LLM deployment. | [
-0.6145964265,
-1.2226730585,
0.3891807795,
-0.0677163526,
-0.0141691584,
0.4089111388,
-0.110050723,
-0.4433082044,
0.1378272772,
0.7057034969,
-0.5244705677,
-0.5187655091,
-0.7245429754,
-0.2366915643,
-0.5393665433,
1.2842915058,
-0.0279583484,
-0.3640417755,
-0.0227732398,
-0.3304054439,
-0.7485323548,
-0.7636537552,
-0.7599841952,
-0.315895766,
0.531940639,
0.2055281997,
0.774184227,
0.258081466,
0.709790647,
0.3613816202,
-0.2268767953,
-0.0117080519,
-0.5236331224,
0.4884597659,
-0.2583209574,
-0.6441128254,
-0.5591564775,
-0.1339055598,
0.3844372034,
0.2923216522,
-0.062561363,
0.4171974361,
-0.0486565977,
0.4877367318,
-0.533624351,
-0.1922459304,
-0.6834105253,
0.1190382019,
-0.4084413946,
-0.2170936614,
-0.3863578439,
0.174314335,
0.1970290244,
-0.3886119723,
0.1766337454,
0.3599019647,
0.7579616308,
0.1697015464,
-0.5264933109,
-0.3500457704,
-0.7202544212,
0.7933799624,
-0.5013116002,
0.1296873987,
0.3127254248,
0.7548370957,
-0.4406584501,
-0.6083033681,
-0.4153264761,
-0.4699840546,
0.1063031554,
-0.2580819726,
-0.5369004607,
0.0377087519,
-0.0996800363,
0.3890506625,
-0.7837301493,
0.1194086298,
-0.2338728905,
-0.3763629198,
0.6821069121,
0.3844894767,
0.6891465783,
0.3050525486,
-0.3610508442,
-0.1893026829,
-0.7963142395,
-0.1942954659,
0.71377635,
0.3906066716,
-0.4534679949,
0.4215925038,
0.2251550257,
0.5704425573,
-0.1356302351,
0.058600869,
-0.1233963445,
-0.3371899128,
-0.3172457516,
-0.0532953776,
0.7875494957,
0.2196668386,
-0.1113426685,
-0.0636349842,
-0.2303694487,
0.0971045047,
0.7799984813,
-0.385849297,
-0.2986537516,
0.3931848705,
-0.1831497252,
-0.8284257054,
-0.1047617197,
-1.1798555851,
-0.7033294439,
0.2349502444,
0.1564481854,
0.001307194,
-0.2443494648,
-0.0329606421,
-0.0340693183,
0.2456810325,
0.1455498785,
-1.0271612406,
0.3597248495,
0.9585350156,
0.8259533048,
0.0976611003,
-0.1672836691,
-0.6204735637,
0.1440475285,
-0.4795949161,
0.5702141523,
-0.5118570328,
-0.4558955729,
0.0588623509,
-0.1901786625,
0.2080230713,
-0.1018052325,
0.4635045528,
-0.7675943375,
0.0561059788,
-0.0734097883,
-0.2057070881,
-0.2752038836,
0.8839691281,
-0.7574615479,
0.8791777492,
-0.0958886892,
-0.8733200431,
0.2267117053,
-0.8871127963,
-0.2136778533,
0.317381084,
-0.3071621656,
-0.5002866387,
-0.0428441726,
0.3473986387,
0.3780958056,
-0.4878431559,
0.1366830915,
-0.4368719161,
-0.2629360855,
0.2506453991,
-0.4155180156,
0.5977755189,
0.2398211509,
-0.4291879833,
0.3516421914,
-0.2112746239,
-0.0119074024,
0.2736997306,
-0.3214456141,
-0.3445212543,
0.1282039136,
-0.1775116473,
-0.2034686655,
0.2346283048,
-0.4016695023,
0.1883137673,
-0.6902816892,
0.642190814,
0.9259757996,
0.1823048294,
0.638176322,
-0.2294393331,
0.9693440199,
-0.2657129169,
0.3964384794,
0.0396025926,
-0.4071998596,
-0.6672121882,
-0.3014292717,
0.0435437188,
0.5060936213,
-0.3790957332,
0.056863308,
-0.1683959365,
-0.6125847697,
-0.4335617125,
0.2471785247,
0.3303026557,
0.1902332604,
0.1440183073,
-0.1533424854,
-0.6419636607,
-0.8417246938,
-0.2734743953,
-0.5457719564,
0.2364054769,
0.3893410265,
0.803658843,
-0.6469686031,
0.6866884232,
-0.235500738,
-0.1820420921,
-0.5955707431,
0.0484190434,
0.1074777842,
0.2422117293,
0.6035768986,
-0.8574743867,
-0.3506868184,
0.5995590687,
-0.8048446774,
0.092835322,
0.0610456504,
-0.1325772554,
-0.0588263124,
0.6454359293,
-0.4433771074,
0.3631435931,
0.7959253788,
-0.237358436,
0.5762950778,
-0.1615881473,
-0.1557564437,
-0.8618747592,
0.1735616624,
-0.2268962413,
-0.1184931025,
-0.9865972996,
0.6795496941,
-0.1759845763,
-0.2845202386,
-0.2124188095,
0.9997314811,
-0.3009709418,
-0.2630590498,
-0.2106227726,
-0.0293543823,
0.067404449,
0.1787178367,
-0.8411417603,
0.937201798,
0.4244194627,
-0.5396994352,
0.5097382665,
0.1125051901,
-0.4460096061,
0.4667366743,
-0.7639128566,
0.4515852034,
0.0924239233,
0.3136000335,
-0.9875848293,
-0.2816544473,
0.5507051945,
-0.4439026415,
0.3647019863,
-0.3542633653,
-0.3152755797,
-0.315767169,
-0.3353914618,
0.6274161935,
0.0826118514,
-0.4217953384,
0.8037118912,
0.7276064754,
-0.442738682,
-0.9764677882,
-0.4805922806,
0.5553566217,
-0.5963977575,
-0.6766260862,
0.0178890675,
0.1956638396,
-0.6988689899,
-0.2568891346,
-0.002724665,
-0.0049286936,
0.7590352893,
0.3619490266,
0.3407469988,
-0.085570462,
-0.0167117156,
-0.3701752126,
-0.1190881804,
0.1855528057,
-0.3158961833,
0.6948247552,
-0.4500055611,
-0.6207000017,
0.0194446165,
0.4867314398,
0.6747983098,
-0.460477978,
0.3657469153,
0.4945260584,
-0.0912459493,
-0.439157486,
-0.4776765704,
0.0151563026,
-0.5247775912,
0.5650418997,
-0.180306673,
-1.1700283289,
0.7339330912,
0.085131757,
0.2626107931,
0.3035936058,
0.8468087316,
-0.1244877651,
0.9023827314,
1.0972946882,
-0.562597394,
0.2836421728,
-0.1355588138,
0.6017209888,
-0.7691674829,
-0.1586663872,
-0.3176480234,
-0.363484323,
-0.344170332,
-0.2438345551,
0.4538707733,
-0.2186172158,
-0.2143980861,
0.169144243,
-0.4603735209,
0.4123428762,
0.1569923162,
-0.3434731364,
-0.0098465616,
-0.144793421,
-0.4438685179,
0.4248509109,
-0.4725401103,
-0.789219141,
1.306653142,
0.7225099206,
0.7392622232,
0.3652761877,
0.5918965936,
0.6650748849,
0.496434927,
-0.6097365618,
0.6558067203,
0.3422199786,
-0.9895415306,
-0.3828121722,
-0.2427488267,
-1.0244414806,
0.3847971857,
0.0430215113,
-0.8677117825,
-0.0932307243,
0.0536757708,
-0.407776773,
0.3980979919,
-0.3328194618,
0.8276782632,
-0.3530555665,
-0.0801370665,
-0.1992366165,
-0.5043694973,
0.4867326319,
-0.1092551649,
0.3586052954,
-0.1094055027,
0.1444883645,
0.6210544705,
-0.3485750854,
1.0768684149,
-0.0490923785,
-0.343304038,
0.2580933571,
0.2488368452,
0.5478078723,
0.0845874622,
0.2015718073,
0.1167050451,
-0.2091967463,
-0.3728967309,
-0.6301095486,
0.6403089762,
-0.6933418512,
-0.7564593554,
-0.4695597887,
-0.6208922863,
-0.1027551815,
-0.0246857181,
0.0472813509,
0.2814577818,
-0.6675838828,
-0.0693990514,
0.6615909934,
-0.3286105394,
0.1159545928,
0.2866821885,
-0.3841544986,
-0.4631210566,
0.7721346617,
-0.1233682632,
0.2996937037,
0.2541876435,
-0.0607960895,
-0.0894759297,
-0.7025436163,
-0.4733529091,
0.065475449,
-0.7946462035,
-0.2364272773,
-0.3151345253,
-0.0778741166,
-0.0691358373,
-0.3866501153,
-0.1693739891,
0.1094911173,
0.0587461777,
-0.393139571,
0.3983483613,
0.8899654746,
0.1297846735,
0.2702124119,
-0.5445973873,
-0.0245229341,
0.4058459997,
-0.1337635964,
0.1658354849,
-0.4884402752,
-0.2842473686,
0.0645316839,
-0.283896476,
-0.7364859581,
0.5625262856,
0.0202271808,
0.7509837747,
0.3725126088,
-0.1357058287,
0.3324970603,
-0.479021132,
0.7886220813,
-0.0332746916,
-0.7237237096,
0.4770784974,
-0.4320452213,
-0.1053760871,
0.5129817128,
0.081974715,
-0.5988101959,
-0.5838414431,
-0.4711306393,
-0.9065732956,
0.134171769,
0.0015190449,
0.4099218249,
-0.06111845,
0.2403747737,
-0.1222600937,
0.2529475391,
-0.5911931992,
-0.1818839312,
-0.0319671072,
0.0881403685,
-0.2498761415,
-0.4348506033,
-0.7093122005,
0.1539358348,
0.3875719607,
-0.1882843524,
0.4455854893,
-0.0396194793,
-0.1392605603,
0.0253715869,
0.551433742,
0.7350370884,
0.2568526864,
-0.0247034431,
0.339101702,
0.4628287554,
-0.4576961696,
0.5408208966,
-0.2401847988,
-0.0491805971,
-0.1930481195,
0.6214268804,
0.6896770597,
0.1896922588,
-0.6189666986,
0.651291132,
0.0148137864,
-0.2970071435,
-0.2981349528,
0.0722974315,
-0.1010989547,
0.4913284183,
0.2843179107,
-0.1871300638,
-0.1416973174,
-0.6901845336,
0.1485126168,
0.7633115053,
-0.4025123417,
-0.4159012139,
0.5244290233,
0.0830143988,
-0.3952039182,
0.4152554274,
-0.1790112853,
-0.9538510442,
0.6937171817,
0.3792570531,
1.0152733326,
-0.196959123,
0.2404794097,
-0.1958049238,
0.7487562895,
0.116065681,
0.1176719517,
0.0268078335,
-0.8039255738,
-0.3925330639,
-0.449041158,
-0.6795386672,
0.2124886811,
-0.6143963337,
-0.0808109865,
-0.842926085,
-0.4236657619,
-0.2340630293,
0.1315699965,
-0.5196455121,
-0.1589713395,
0.257494092,
0.6669273973,
-0.8550733328,
0.5025444627,
0.6873212457,
-0.1611086726,
-0.5294579864,
-0.1649027765,
0.3096582294,
-0.8675417304,
0.8649396896,
0.1079892293,
-0.0998754427,
-0.4430547059,
-0.6312915087,
-0.7021555901,
1.109659791,
0.4153047502,
-0.4088725746,
-0.0158387944,
0.2679243982,
0.5368098617,
-0.3000729978,
0.0269317534,
0.4915881455,
0.5724371076,
-0.3286914825,
-0.824711144,
0.0436950177,
-0.3871096075,
-0.0783561841,
0.4324370027,
-0.54798311,
0.8376414776,
-0.1195896938,
-0.4066546559,
0.0059823971,
0.52253443,
0.1559433788,
0.2192505002,
0.3480907083,
0.6776927114,
0.9591138363,
0.1865310371,
1.2835723162,
-0.0878877044,
0.1981506348,
0.9431163669,
-0.445638746,
0.7818475962,
0.4793564379,
-0.1327688098,
0.4247559309,
0.2502173781,
-0.2020794302,
0.5317267179,
0.4420957863,
-0.4335917234,
-0.0142987063,
0.1631534249,
-0.1820595711,
0.4573044777,
0.5013016462,
-0.2293399423,
-0.4970309734,
0.0838044435,
0.1898739487,
-0.1858741492,
-0.2793158889,
0.6826922894,
0.2108012438,
-0.3021123707,
0.4313566983,
0.3386058211,
0.4297235012,
-0.6915755272,
0.1411881447,
-0.1480068862,
0.1025784835,
0.0263473764,
-0.5585095286,
0.3257858157,
0.1397165656,
0.0096491976,
-0.001525161,
0.8214113712,
0.0913531408,
-0.2305487394,
0.4316025674,
0.3084191978,
-0.0010353863,
0.0610911548,
-0.7372650504,
0.3895029426,
-0.0403762944,
-0.2229819149,
0.7302864194,
0.2756486237,
-0.1768392175,
1.134557128,
0.9462381005,
0.0379163735,
-0.0056579835,
-0.116116114,
0.9627759457,
-0.304710865,
-0.5566034913,
-1.27526021,
0.3521054387,
-0.104300335,
-0.3550588787,
0.8977072239,
0.1102128476,
0.5315431356,
0.4436561167,
1.002622366,
0.3368735909,
0.1741887331,
-0.3766903877,
0.9657821059,
-0.2031776458,
0.6147084832,
-0.2058082223,
-0.7238740325,
-0.3237181008,
0.7532661557,
-0.5903961062,
-0.3098424077,
0.2422357351,
1.0455636978,
0.0228121802,
-0.0782832578,
0.2825879455,
0.1751755029,
0.8512932062,
0.3775914907,
1.0699881315,
-0.3679207563,
0.514077425,
0.2615401149,
0.0425408743,
-0.4780783057,
-0.8470729589,
-1.1019202471,
-0.3330691755,
-0.0463921688,
-0.0632813573,
0.3648922145,
0.5258564353,
0.441972822,
-0.6224780083,
-0.2035351396,
-0.117710717,
0.0845854506,
-0.1144527271,
-0.1820987016,
0.0520973206,
-0.2689628303,
-0.07004302,
0.8293902874,
0.5075163245,
-0.0201736707,
-0.7261431217,
-0.14469257,
0.0171811059,
0.2417318076,
0.2176181376,
0.5600895286,
-0.7054232359,
-0.5913280249,
-0.1810944378,
-0.2218250036,
-0.2913461328,
0.5441781878,
-0.3680492938,
0.4387586117,
0.1680455804,
1.0861691236,
0.1763131917,
-0.2901357114,
1.0107542276,
-0.6924590468,
0.0929674506,
0.3086702824,
0.3527795374,
0.161097452,
-0.3739008009,
0.4090598226,
-0.3052218258,
-0.6972490549,
-1.2929508686,
0.4206568599,
-0.6076098084,
-0.0728814006,
0.9338834882,
-0.2336406708,
-0.1767473817,
-0.4449030757,
-0.1909476966,
-0.2933188081,
-0.0449784398,
0.6697707176,
0.8040777445,
0.5177080035,
0.0834612846,
-0.9458135366,
0.3435773253,
0.4826333821,
-0.5822957158,
0.185421586,
0.0671163648,
0.2072563767,
0.2402824461,
0.5266548991,
-0.0798524544,
0.199465692,
0.0613453425,
-0.1178662106,
-0.2021482736,
-0.4578544497,
-0.4951892793,
0.3566765487,
0.1402503103,
-0.020393651
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11035v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11035v1 | Scaling Synthetic Logical Reasoning Datasets with Context-Sensitive Declarative Grammars | 2024-06-16T18:10:49 | 2024-06-16T18:10:49 | Damien Sileo | cs.CL | cs.CL, I.2.7 | Logical reasoning remains a challenge for natural language processing, but it
can be improved by training language models to mimic theorem provers on
procedurally generated problems. Previous work used domain-specific proof
generation algorithms, which biases reasoning toward specific proof traces and
limits auditability and extensibility. We present a simpler and more general
declarative framework with flexible context-sensitive rules binding multiple
languages (specifically, simplified English and the TPTP theorem-proving
language). We construct first-order logic problems by selecting up to 32
premises and one hypothesis. We demonstrate that using semantic constraints
during generation and careful English verbalization of predicates enhances
logical reasoning without hurting natural English tasks. We use relatively
small DeBERTa-v3 models to achieve state-of-the-art accuracy on the FOLIO
human-authored logic dataset, surpassing GPT-4 in accuracy with or without an
external solver by 12%. | [
-0.0959851891,
-0.7009065747,
0.7707433701,
0.0883640721,
-0.1221675202,
-0.2983560562,
-0.3945187628,
-0.3610893786,
-0.2547345757,
0.4269829094,
-0.6068210006,
-0.4518432617,
-0.4798328578,
0.4294717908,
-0.0657846108,
0.5673804879,
0.0237917211,
0.0203611255,
-0.2059227526,
-0.2848237753,
-0.479301095,
-0.6989398003,
-0.3549434245,
-0.0963182002,
-0.0834169313,
0.269718051,
0.5565940142,
0.5975853801,
0.4439296424,
0.3283914328,
0.1638054848,
0.4403450191,
-0.1060341597,
0.2642591596,
-0.7061892748,
-0.4732519984,
-0.2588625848,
-0.2272025794,
0.4184692502,
0.7476793528,
0.0227200426,
-0.040150702,
-0.3790651262,
0.4771703184,
-0.4853060842,
0.5846920013,
-0.9354412556,
-0.1464286,
-0.035508845,
-0.0919425339,
-0.6108760834,
-0.3861486912,
0.1412707269,
-0.9002672434,
0.1816996634,
-0.1674484015,
0.7752243876,
0.3700653613,
-0.5843425989,
-0.1989261061,
-0.6363154054,
0.9773552418,
-0.5618789792,
0.5472150445,
0.1876553595,
0.4745176136,
-0.1258361638,
-0.7681142092,
-0.4077876508,
0.0922933519,
-0.0869865939,
-0.3913854957,
-0.2354959249,
-0.061834719,
0.4751365483,
0.0153169977,
-0.4530704021,
-0.2564280331,
-0.3657169044,
-0.2895134091,
0.5862955451,
-0.0130998213,
0.1960406303,
0.0610805452,
0.0416924134,
-0.0486593507,
-0.7800159454,
-0.0326904356,
-0.1014413312,
0.5580035448,
0.327295661,
0.526083231,
-0.2305374444,
0.9820144773,
0.1843815893,
-0.1405404061,
0.1442571431,
-0.6625225544,
-0.1617974043,
-0.0711804628,
0.3203489482,
0.2824089229,
0.5242310166,
0.0498407334,
-0.1042897925,
0.5356439352,
0.1185183451,
-1.0351881981,
-0.1332753748,
0.1982280016,
0.0302102286,
-0.1554498523,
-0.0301049128,
-0.1603673846,
-0.1860781908,
-0.7467035055,
0.308227092,
-0.6184681058,
-0.1064721569,
0.6857995987,
0.0069456403,
0.2509536743,
0.3782534599,
-0.8990850449,
0.4815129638,
0.8620461226,
0.2757475376,
0.1300022155,
-0.0579137839,
-0.6449193954,
0.2169758528,
-0.3294422328,
0.6383926868,
-0.6769672036,
0.1702971458,
0.0632801577,
-0.0802395195,
-0.1765419841,
-0.5966539383,
0.8042303324,
-0.4902654886,
0.3682917356,
-0.4343888462,
-0.6083878279,
-0.0141156483,
0.4978349805,
-0.3061603904,
0.4283114672,
0.0800166801,
-0.6719834208,
0.7202154994,
-0.4082572758,
-0.8057739139,
0.0636262596,
-0.4239834249,
-0.0036685097,
0.0082745403,
0.5042102933,
0.2917336822,
-0.2670223713,
0.4505747855,
0.0272033699,
0.1396654248,
-0.1247168258,
-0.1311129481,
0.9310482144,
0.0435728692,
-0.3987456262,
0.1028132737,
-1.0091353655,
0.4552180171,
0.1614766717,
-0.304377079,
-0.2321633697,
0.0952214003,
-0.403709352,
0.359490037,
0.0896869749,
-0.6451958418,
0.1635240465,
-0.5018704534,
0.7693198323,
0.4292755127,
0.0924415067,
0.2839169502,
-0.3118287921,
0.2940577567,
0.1499947459,
-0.0697525144,
-0.1530119628,
-0.4742839634,
-0.6215447783,
-0.4673353434,
0.1238320917,
0.555473268,
-0.6160253882,
0.5567758679,
-0.4941550195,
-0.1975177228,
-0.1355496049,
0.0746222585,
0.1840046793,
0.764500618,
0.5552244782,
0.1316971779,
-0.5877816677,
-0.9217889905,
-0.3262873292,
-0.1966123432,
-0.4064511061,
0.1052890867,
0.328309685,
-0.2646881044,
1.2181344032,
-0.4719370902,
-0.3290437162,
-0.3561668694,
-0.1203417182,
0.2311472446,
0.4041820168,
0.3727656305,
-0.7452214956,
-0.2596130073,
-0.1187775135,
-0.6564771533,
-0.4348829091,
-0.1777619272,
-0.1510237604,
0.337248683,
0.2379428744,
-0.7863088846,
0.1559697092,
-0.0183919445,
-0.586651504,
0.4039067328,
-0.2217940986,
-0.1395182461,
-0.8583399057,
-0.3673868775,
-0.0535440445,
-0.5004892349,
-0.8391286135,
0.1168333068,
0.14731507,
-0.0557774529,
-0.3014241457,
0.3043347299,
-0.0823878497,
0.4544476867,
-0.0065157153,
0.1791771948,
0.4378498793,
0.2503681779,
0.4179258943,
0.2586588562,
0.4145536721,
-0.5717745423,
0.1667394787,
0.3018510044,
-0.0657475069,
0.7565373778,
-0.7088896632,
-0.0640017018,
-0.143069908,
0.3463322818,
-0.5230835676,
-0.2566604018,
-0.1216111481,
-0.1022632569,
0.1200972274,
-0.0894443169,
-0.4392056465,
-0.0437861308,
-0.1924519986,
0.5201212764,
0.4991028011,
-0.7456663847,
0.5664322972,
0.1363387406,
0.0953330696,
-0.1538315862,
-0.6710811257,
-0.0594061837,
-0.157211557,
-1.098169446,
0.4233193696,
0.0866554752,
-0.783231616,
-0.1840956956,
-0.3940284848,
-0.251283586,
-0.0326760598,
-0.0490349457,
-0.029864613,
-0.1454800516,
0.150936082,
0.0382743999,
0.0488972813,
0.3279091418,
-0.7075042725,
0.2222739309,
-0.5776974559,
-0.3372491598,
-0.2406294197,
0.2455867976,
0.4936758876,
-0.2734172344,
0.4738149941,
-0.0713702515,
-0.6384174228,
-0.7102470994,
-0.2575281262,
-0.370346576,
-0.4635480046,
-0.0059609874,
-0.7681981325,
-0.7180621028,
0.2301940918,
0.0607939586,
0.1817782819,
0.5622572899,
0.5856091976,
0.5332946777,
0.8846380115,
0.2458745837,
0.4218464792,
-0.1660280079,
0.0276082903,
0.3476870656,
-0.0589168966,
-0.0045148018,
-0.3300663531,
0.2233402282,
-0.679908514,
-0.6195723414,
0.1567294598,
-0.0263231471,
-0.3886092603,
0.5718250275,
-0.5286588073,
0.768617928,
0.517670691,
-0.0161097012,
0.4752266109,
-0.074882634,
-0.2462330759,
-0.1993859261,
-0.6090088487,
-0.5186081529,
0.9586057663,
0.1285119355,
0.4446859956,
0.389401406,
0.5569339395,
0.0742389634,
0.0027040278,
-0.624709487,
0.6262637973,
-0.1683084816,
-0.8137977123,
-0.273476243,
-0.4878739715,
-0.6317517757,
0.4211063981,
-0.0077029318,
-0.5630363822,
0.0766064525,
0.0249988958,
-0.2481630147,
0.0565994419,
-0.8575277328,
0.7910954952,
-0.1071753725,
-0.6227729321,
-0.0497466214,
-0.5687958598,
0.3623489141,
-0.1507467479,
0.2439275533,
-0.1742735803,
0.1895738691,
0.2536784112,
-0.9903143048,
0.7735401392,
-0.3003181219,
-0.277215451,
0.5131622553,
0.4235772192,
0.4505322278,
0.2341971844,
-0.0527710393,
-0.1926737279,
0.2804660499,
-0.4071467817,
-0.7237449288,
0.5095568895,
-0.3391345739,
-0.8803061843,
-0.4256868958,
-0.5925862789,
-0.5123654604,
0.4018296599,
0.0405832864,
0.4982782006,
-0.0954256356,
0.12188752,
0.5230103731,
0.2194259614,
0.0550542884,
0.4206779897,
-0.0063451268,
-0.1904629022,
0.8815185428,
0.0711322725,
0.3558655381,
0.4755062461,
0.3530986309,
-0.4164814651,
-0.2860742211,
-0.3829184175,
0.1628812999,
-0.8882703781,
-0.1276784241,
-0.3971804976,
-0.0052684755,
-0.5720033646,
-0.4149429798,
-0.2569183409,
-1.1437561512,
0.0885506496,
-0.2589546442,
0.0971355587,
0.3938909769,
-0.0671487525,
-0.3189399242,
-0.558398068,
0.4773414135,
0.6207732558,
0.088117063,
-0.7024130225,
-0.5457562208,
0.3181289732,
-0.0095153153,
-0.1448557675,
-0.5356468558,
0.3417901695,
0.3985509872,
0.1736435145,
0.4453377724,
0.318055898,
0.4319004714,
-0.6748057008,
0.5591701865,
-0.0853296518,
-1.0263441801,
0.808218956,
-0.4886256754,
0.3293798566,
0.8187454939,
0.1655216962,
-0.0958800018,
-0.2547067106,
-0.5713416338,
-0.6364257336,
0.4460217059,
0.3856241405,
-0.1101547629,
-0.1679921597,
0.2656817436,
0.0888995379,
0.0661140159,
-0.6499660611,
0.3011505008,
-0.3615929782,
-0.4415977001,
0.3365806341,
-0.0031610248,
-0.3497259617,
-0.5159252286,
0.6172249317,
-0.3796482384,
-0.1860021204,
0.3428811431,
-0.3529165983,
0.251496762,
0.5214548111,
0.5638772249,
0.9012463689,
-0.1914515048,
0.5330325961,
0.0259369947,
-0.2446779162,
0.4081236422,
0.3486903906,
-0.4634608328,
-0.1502648294,
0.5033078194,
0.3845498562,
-0.1627897918,
-0.93984586,
0.4492505193,
-0.187123403,
-0.495225668,
-0.2404773086,
0.1406790614,
0.0064786049,
0.1784987003,
0.0342933834,
-0.0589846298,
-0.0741994381,
-0.2971916199,
0.3311226964,
0.2953148484,
0.1164224297,
-0.423440218,
0.8351657987,
0.3010970056,
-0.003921906,
0.5127965808,
-0.4823436439,
-0.5661898255,
0.5404251814,
0.8393661976,
0.7404250503,
0.087532647,
0.0864305869,
0.5082837939,
0.4326750636,
-0.0690691024,
0.4263049364,
-0.2690269649,
-1.0580064058,
-0.4343414605,
-0.5028621554,
-0.5965561271,
-0.0555152707,
-0.2621706724,
0.2734366059,
-0.8126809597,
0.0566140227,
0.164017573,
0.1347956508,
-0.5626134276,
0.2929354012,
0.0064976262,
0.8646466136,
-0.7876169682,
0.7586163282,
0.6904119849,
-0.1912815273,
-0.6388531923,
-0.1267211139,
0.0618305765,
-0.4376701415,
0.6895157695,
0.5170682669,
-0.2121779472,
-0.196240738,
-0.2785720229,
-0.6259200573,
0.8335492015,
0.5637766123,
-0.4622576833,
0.2086729556,
0.5468183756,
0.6679035425,
-0.5096277595,
-0.1483073533,
0.9299971461,
0.5367905498,
0.1258708239,
-0.5735514164,
0.4195187092,
-0.1853619367,
-0.2043114454,
0.012515788,
-0.3525907993,
0.5711625814,
-0.2988273203,
-0.3009459078,
-0.3926287293,
0.544719398,
0.6243376732,
0.1743751764,
0.6283541322,
0.7501580715,
1.045363307,
-0.229064092,
0.979529202,
-0.295987308,
-0.1859104931,
1.2354379892,
-0.623200357,
0.5299409032,
0.4418857098,
-0.0751188993,
0.5818994045,
0.2647969127,
0.1482986361,
0.3440359831,
0.5526810884,
-0.509439826,
-0.5672690272,
-0.4182881713,
-0.0649519637,
0.4021807313,
0.3685671985,
-0.1786500067,
-0.2084785253,
-0.2318355739,
0.1428236365,
0.3772011399,
-0.0530343577,
0.4236912429,
-0.0716645569,
-0.7458347082,
0.8076863885,
0.0883952826,
0.2781229615,
-0.460850358,
-0.0024179383,
-0.1391476393,
0.4828685224,
-0.2326776385,
-0.377717793,
0.4265405834,
0.2273248881,
-0.2899034321,
-0.5368936062,
0.8410929441,
-0.313675642,
-0.6724650264,
-0.0336019099,
0.4834046662,
-0.2556843758,
-0.0552927777,
-0.1201838031,
-0.1513495147,
0.0028949466,
-0.3831190169,
0.0461526699,
0.7077153921,
-0.4360354841,
0.5657519698,
0.513891995,
-0.0851748735,
0.1095740199,
0.2676745951,
0.9154686332,
-0.5155788064,
-0.3043230772,
-0.6733115315,
0.2866584659,
-0.1167938113,
0.0093537765,
0.627545476,
0.4339018762,
0.882805109,
0.0379245393,
0.7592214942,
-0.1967012882,
0.3699650764,
-0.3103005886,
0.017363308,
-0.1177547053,
0.3419566751,
0.2807660401,
-0.7061306238,
-0.8254616261,
0.7031835318,
-0.3834501505,
-0.2107611001,
0.7710788846,
0.6568643451,
-0.1406835914,
0.0156786665,
0.1741460711,
0.2073713094,
0.6454623342,
0.8198410273,
0.490955919,
-0.2077362239,
0.4275549054,
-0.4103849828,
-0.1403850615,
0.2999270558,
-1.0441660881,
-0.9596369267,
-0.303542614,
-0.459652245,
-0.3906917274,
-0.2212348729,
1.0572565794,
0.6981222034,
-0.9461191297,
0.1747158766,
-0.6660381556,
0.1672708392,
-0.1981434524,
-0.2440414727,
0.3388749659,
-0.6676704884,
-0.6346102357,
0.8243975639,
0.0729235411,
-0.1655533016,
-0.0236825105,
0.0116043109,
-0.0554964282,
0.512364924,
0.8016625643,
0.3933209181,
-0.4730297327,
-0.5882173777,
-0.0728162453,
-0.0000600271,
-0.0222439207,
0.7005530596,
-0.8218765855,
0.4160746634,
0.7765612602,
0.5988355279,
0.2988218665,
0.2907023728,
0.6887158155,
-0.8644657135,
0.2893217206,
0.2903040051,
0.4276823699,
0.3608594835,
-0.1202653646,
0.7124862671,
0.4447087646,
-0.372004807,
-0.7245160937,
0.4811862111,
-0.7957061529,
-0.3726791143,
1.1484513283,
-0.0690223053,
-0.0652593002,
-0.0422772914,
-0.0026503108,
-0.2278539389,
-0.0784589723,
0.4806779623,
0.6439707279,
-0.2667083442,
0.2474403232,
-0.2830106914,
0.6344394684,
0.5363199115,
-0.9510228634,
0.2494874299,
0.9076948166,
0.3384281695,
0.2420105785,
0.5225020051,
-0.1543487906,
0.080858089,
-0.0035022649,
-0.3150130212,
-0.2291679382,
-0.4787828624,
-0.3206668496,
0.3945538104,
0.0339778773,
0.0224716775
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11030v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11030v1 | FoodieQA: A Multimodal Dataset for Fine-Grained Understanding of Chinese Food Culture | 2024-06-16T17:59:32 | 2024-06-16T17:59:32 | Wenyan Li, Xinyu Zhang, Jiaang Li, Qiwei Peng, Raphael Tang, Li Zhou, Weijia Zhang, Guimin Hu, Yifei Yuan, Anders Søgaard, Daniel Hershcovich, Desmond Elliott | cs.CL | cs.CL | Food is a rich and varied dimension of cultural heritage, crucial to both
individuals and social groups. To bridge the gap in the literature on the
often-overlooked regional diversity in this domain, we introduce FoodieQA, a
manually curated, fine-grained image-text dataset capturing the intricate
features of food cultures across various regions in China. We evaluate
vision-language Models (VLMs) and large language models (LLMs) on newly
collected, unseen food images and corresponding questions. FoodieQA comprises
three multiple-choice question-answering tasks where models need to answer
questions based on multiple images, a single image, and text-only descriptions,
respectively. While LLMs excel at text-based question answering, surpassing
human accuracy, the open-sourced VLMs still fall short by 41\% on multi-image
and 21\% on single-image VQA tasks, although closed-weights models perform
closer to human levels (within 10\%). Our findings highlight that understanding
food and its cultural implications remains a challenging and under-explored
direction. | [
-0.3632334769,
-0.5674921274,
0.3247353435,
-0.1287643909,
0.1304505765,
0.000447425,
-0.2125263065,
-0.6502767801,
0.0878715068,
0.4928760827,
-0.6175938845,
-0.3590791821,
-0.4962178171,
-0.0629544705,
-0.2130785882,
0.7208910584,
-0.158101663,
0.3609746695,
0.024211375,
-0.4413432181,
-0.3261788189,
-0.2029563636,
-0.393024981,
-0.092382513,
0.5347744226,
0.4774097502,
0.7662824392,
0.6857836843,
0.4391389787,
0.1980016083,
-0.2192263156,
0.5072010756,
-0.3047654033,
-0.1239479631,
-0.1647001654,
-0.5845469236,
-0.0870860368,
-0.0157160573,
0.2109943628,
0.7092715502,
0.0450304635,
0.6355658174,
0.0258578397,
0.6189709902,
-0.6693494916,
0.0840871185,
-0.5344169736,
0.221685335,
-0.2670799494,
-0.0404766165,
-0.1413926035,
-0.2417797744,
0.0073836683,
-0.7605497241,
-0.0451947786,
-0.088511683,
1.1440832615,
0.3127919137,
-0.9165182114,
-0.2348965406,
-0.8802105784,
0.7905766964,
-0.2358277291,
0.195498392,
0.5215200782,
0.4484643936,
-0.1292991936,
-0.8071891665,
-0.7558244467,
0.1675287187,
-0.0706821755,
0.2938651145,
0.0010750915,
-0.3288844824,
-0.1282106489,
0.7899034023,
-0.7086175084,
-0.174165383,
-0.2521172166,
-0.0794073567,
0.5105814338,
0.4485917389,
0.8368448615,
-0.3409280777,
-0.667581439,
-0.3030295372,
-0.3443178535,
0.7099887133,
-0.2167613208,
0.262878567,
0.0235908385,
0.5866587162,
-0.4566810727,
0.6426310539,
-0.2749441862,
-0.2141082883,
0.2925533056,
-0.7945325375,
-0.1216877475,
-0.5148285627,
0.5086995959,
0.8772118688,
0.2665815353,
0.3871011734,
-0.2436991483,
-0.1567445695,
-0.1802126616,
-0.5678754449,
-0.5334830284,
0.3351396322,
-0.6001622081,
0.2066195011,
0.2849470973,
-0.4564394951,
-0.5484518409,
0.0581227541,
0.3774251342,
-0.2167639583,
-0.3013100922,
0.1197743267,
-0.6556081176,
0.7015002966,
0.4235984087,
-0.922772944,
0.0348946974,
0.4721672237,
0.6125815511,
0.1225088239,
-0.3162565529,
-0.2566578984,
0.2926036417,
-0.510576427,
0.7098802924,
-0.7760340571,
0.0118478993,
-0.3856758177,
0.5499922037,
0.1729807109,
-0.7898253202,
0.5790313482,
-0.3111123443,
-0.1337447464,
-1.0534597635,
-0.1556007266,
-0.5017599463,
0.6114366651,
-0.7325849533,
0.8263135552,
0.1994780749,
-0.5704225302,
0.7569538951,
-0.1357089728,
-0.4018835127,
0.5508010983,
-0.4059079289,
0.3368344307,
-0.1613868773,
0.6241711378,
0.4614821374,
-0.3316223919,
0.2376737893,
-0.3796550632,
-0.4619830251,
0.2378633022,
-0.6919101477,
0.4769387841,
0.450837642,
-0.0747620314,
0.0739088282,
-0.3870164156,
-0.0029059388,
0.4053301811,
-0.4153452516,
-0.6661088467,
0.133406505,
0.5245136023,
-0.0276128426,
0.3226850629,
-0.3457110822,
0.2941646278,
-0.1310942024,
0.6238918304,
0.5953955054,
-0.3408792615,
0.4020224214,
-0.5050615072,
0.1663996279,
0.2005348057,
0.516335845,
-0.6070155501,
-0.5256388783,
-0.4424908757,
-0.1948886216,
0.2494188249,
0.7213679552,
-1.2595722675,
-0.1490222961,
-0.1294780821,
-0.6332107782,
-0.530959487,
-0.0047163987,
-0.0515600666,
0.266372025,
0.3657824695,
-0.5437240005,
0.0531683043,
-1.0766429901,
-0.0981259197,
-0.1149664968,
-0.3647519946,
0.5711456537,
0.3493056595,
-0.0867104083,
0.4915114939,
-0.6829000711,
-0.2578397989,
-0.4323606491,
-0.0154395876,
0.1361410767,
0.4539759755,
0.7360424399,
-1.2179734707,
-0.5016723275,
0.4575328529,
-0.589258492,
0.3846262991,
-0.1347627193,
-0.2609999776,
-0.1241054311,
-0.1815517396,
-0.330296874,
0.3862671554,
0.606243372,
-0.4026565552,
0.3275514543,
0.2367496639,
0.6296969056,
-1.2414021492,
-0.1355531216,
0.2297043055,
0.2334065735,
-0.5583408475,
0.4214653075,
0.2358315587,
-0.0442713648,
-0.5919891,
0.8872047067,
-0.2811501622,
-0.0152948545,
-0.1124886572,
-0.2492941916,
0.3640274704,
0.5831342936,
0.3035491407,
0.7371418476,
0.5009035468,
-0.3719538748,
0.4742006063,
0.1388648897,
-0.5556785464,
0.3915045559,
-0.335960269,
-0.320889771,
-0.2467013299,
0.3846621811,
-1.0902224779,
-0.6202691197,
0.6027491093,
-0.2912541926,
-0.220352605,
-0.167064324,
-0.4644824862,
-0.5193350315,
-0.1717291176,
0.7785636187,
0.0096227303,
-0.6074590087,
0.8963540792,
0.466352433,
0.0849998519,
-0.5887793303,
-0.9950341582,
0.0591886677,
-0.0195964687,
-0.6713818312,
-0.1006712466,
-0.2008373588,
-0.1732612848,
-0.0044478839,
-0.3065851629,
-0.5714518428,
0.2014820129,
0.1491521001,
0.1690748185,
-0.3553818166,
0.1744721979,
-0.1925057769,
0.6924153566,
-0.178969875,
-0.3476158082,
0.5337352753,
-0.3258788288,
0.0016074481,
-0.3989330232,
0.398543179,
0.4630625844,
-0.3816770017,
0.4009898901,
1.0306327343,
-0.4915243089,
0.0370893106,
-0.1221667677,
-0.0605725385,
-0.4411491454,
0.3573133349,
-0.4508039355,
-0.627574265,
0.5990434885,
0.2178456336,
0.1175995693,
0.2815208733,
0.2813640833,
-0.3027377129,
0.511815846,
0.398714453,
-0.0389296897,
0.314084053,
-0.0981838554,
-0.326115638,
-0.3203014135,
-0.4997826815,
-0.3819375634,
-0.2382933795,
-0.6723182797,
-0.817982614,
0.2870468795,
-0.4674082398,
-0.1929813027,
-0.0598425791,
-0.456809938,
0.8417485952,
0.4953744709,
0.502227962,
0.2729327083,
-0.2336349189,
0.125491187,
0.1678956896,
-0.7466661334,
-0.4765786529,
0.5007261038,
0.3573446274,
1.1321858168,
0.1257201135,
0.3420373499,
0.1280558556,
-0.0489723459,
-0.9486297965,
0.2770447433,
-0.9044647217,
-0.736011982,
-0.4232076406,
-0.4484465718,
-0.5235772133,
0.3083227873,
-0.0577439144,
-0.4783589244,
0.0892791823,
0.2952212393,
-0.5632598996,
0.5158258677,
-1.0255823135,
0.971813798,
-0.5166582465,
-0.3714009225,
0.582341969,
-0.5784615278,
0.528729856,
0.2701214254,
0.4712187946,
-0.1245113835,
0.286416471,
0.4757043421,
0.0914941803,
0.7919741273,
-0.0495409779,
-0.1319309324,
0.3204595149,
0.2564626038,
0.0484070815,
0.1509565115,
0.2249948829,
0.1804572046,
0.5484830141,
-0.6077851653,
-0.7516470551,
0.6073335409,
-0.6031147242,
-0.45652771,
-0.1998108029,
-0.6672554612,
0.0206698403,
0.1994514465,
-0.1251912564,
0.3562342525,
0.1147674248,
0.2031258941,
0.6762900352,
-0.570343256,
0.1801075041,
0.1190977842,
-0.3221040666,
-0.1949293464,
0.992013216,
0.1814224124,
0.0557138696,
0.4799337983,
0.2910394371,
-0.0573852137,
0.1047651768,
-0.5132644176,
-0.181306988,
-0.9037868977,
0.0983612612,
-0.5084789395,
-0.2555110455,
-0.1184958592,
-0.0128207617,
-0.455865562,
-0.1388728321,
-0.2403778434,
0.0804004818,
-0.0259328298,
0.8069105148,
0.029507162,
-0.089548476,
-0.953279376,
0.5261529684,
0.5265079141,
0.2249207944,
0.2887948155,
-0.2790994644,
-0.2013041228,
0.1427488178,
-0.1186971813,
-0.7939853072,
0.3660371602,
0.1617353708,
0.4670478106,
0.5178860426,
0.1195090264,
0.767958045,
-0.1328480095,
1.219722867,
0.0398401506,
-0.7200528979,
0.4638352096,
-0.2050549537,
0.8291069269,
0.4390262067,
0.6261940598,
-1.0125409365,
-0.3276184499,
0.2050682455,
-1.0250968933,
0.3727277815,
-0.1916722506,
0.2711541951,
0.0195542425,
0.073818028,
0.5178745985,
0.008806535,
-1.1000925303,
-0.193873331,
-0.6087815762,
-0.0519464947,
0.1299177259,
-0.0407345258,
-0.2420164943,
-0.4779471755,
0.2036609501,
-0.2182567716,
-0.2875570953,
0.0929267853,
0.1850526631,
-0.0982007757,
0.4875429273,
0.275002867,
0.5380923748,
-0.1022835448,
0.2364818603,
0.02643192,
-0.5542298555,
-0.1213324443,
-0.3098228872,
-0.06331487,
-0.3776327968,
0.2839110494,
0.611096561,
-0.3312955499,
-0.7094320655,
0.283798933,
-0.5862345695,
-0.1832462698,
-0.3356113136,
0.066195555,
0.0045093228,
0.573159039,
0.6955650449,
-0.0648537353,
0.4246383905,
-0.8618254066,
0.2585088611,
0.3228019476,
-0.2683479488,
-0.1473051757,
0.4448178709,
0.2575853169,
0.4673689306,
0.7468932271,
-0.0767283514,
-0.4652443826,
0.8347826004,
0.1323872507,
0.3891386092,
0.1119966879,
0.5034567118,
0.3647423387,
0.5800008774,
-0.0077693723,
0.6596908569,
-0.1378853768,
-0.9423124194,
-0.202118203,
-0.7034375668,
-0.2783112228,
0.354868412,
-0.7061772943,
-0.0887552649,
-0.2398560494,
-0.049161613,
0.0461111069,
-0.2894436717,
-0.7630195022,
0.5243635774,
0.5235007405,
1.0659890175,
-1.0122004747,
0.6706522703,
0.9919846654,
-0.2968762219,
-1.147972703,
0.5733652711,
-0.0305587109,
-0.7491239905,
0.7829825878,
0.1329033375,
0.0564629547,
-0.5622136593,
-0.9539404511,
-0.7901292443,
1.0136581659,
-0.1222466677,
-0.3160697818,
-0.0029659462,
0.060100168,
0.3868968785,
-0.077133134,
0.3041223884,
0.3430066109,
0.5808581114,
0.3526411057,
-0.7543027401,
-0.1806569397,
-0.2698309124,
0.0445566252,
0.0197661705,
-1.0353939533,
1.074049592,
-0.2643299401,
-0.4579558671,
0.0902870074,
0.5836646557,
0.0299758036,
0.5861341953,
0.4173509479,
0.2098164856,
0.6811833978,
-0.3448911011,
0.8749290705,
-0.1017254367,
0.2499027997,
1.1125164032,
-0.3082273602,
0.6981204152,
0.4876277149,
0.1047345847,
0.1199493408,
1.4174108505,
-0.2897019088,
0.6079169512,
0.0611980446,
-0.0996254086,
-0.6264742017,
-0.7852617502,
-0.2766880691,
0.9965093732,
0.13652955,
-0.2872512341,
-0.2124907821,
-0.0315424725,
-0.3468225896,
0.0102851,
-0.4302954674,
0.6608005166,
-0.0367084667,
-0.330316484,
0.3224107623,
-0.132373631,
0.5675151348,
-0.3461026251,
-0.4191880822,
-0.4410869777,
-0.3972750604,
-0.0956295282,
-1.2625237703,
-0.1125837862,
-0.3321049809,
-0.3222222924,
0.1361439526,
0.4850690067,
-0.393360734,
-0.3139908016,
0.1612771302,
0.451584965,
0.0022807322,
0.1891678274,
-0.562251091,
0.0277358983,
0.0569596477,
-0.0556280799,
-0.0018110856,
0.6906036735,
-0.0501928329,
0.6575535536,
0.2842908502,
-0.2760972679,
-0.1080402732,
-0.1089259237,
0.8773085475,
-0.6527735591,
-0.5534330606,
-0.6990559697,
0.3442497551,
0.373731792,
-0.1991974711,
0.4657086432,
0.2403192222,
1.3769549131,
-0.2867583036,
0.8707735538,
-0.1669901013,
-0.0823369995,
-0.7339661717,
0.6922092438,
-1.3013521433,
-0.0135337263,
-0.0244790241,
-0.3404994607,
0.0742164403,
0.2345211506,
-0.1913150996,
-0.0276850648,
0.4217453599,
0.7082350254,
-0.0428610072,
0.0774131566,
0.5289384723,
0.0899353623,
-0.105790779,
0.7032116055,
1.3194798231,
-0.2027178854,
0.4705506563,
-0.1882021129,
-0.3211665452,
0.2818585932,
-0.347340852,
-0.499802649,
-0.9150297046,
0.1544793546,
0.1456343234,
0.0042124214,
0.926943779,
0.7807496786,
-0.6476545334,
-0.2422394902,
0.8091638684,
0.0920127481,
-0.3270449042,
-0.2041882426,
0.0614096522,
0.0823524073,
-0.8692026734,
0.2114042044,
0.2835683227,
0.0680657849,
-0.2270622998,
0.1308560371,
-0.1524406224,
0.14214845,
0.664811492,
0.3303925991,
-0.9635538459,
-0.1748977304,
0.0885204673,
-0.1154362336,
0.1853739023,
0.4459771514,
-0.2076864839,
0.5293962955,
0.239802137,
0.7904067039,
0.0779145211,
0.1060027406,
0.2798676193,
-0.7287220955,
-0.0593029298,
-0.0966662541,
0.3818463385,
0.383176893,
-0.5287147164,
0.2708801031,
0.1050241366,
-0.4550167322,
-0.3713508844,
0.3770167828,
-1.041323781,
-0.8480057716,
1.1732815504,
-0.1837960929,
-0.7586314678,
0.1145707816,
-0.1795648187,
0.2244446129,
-0.3113981485,
0.714251101,
0.7105184793,
0.2114225179,
-0.4001195431,
-0.6510879993,
0.3006748259,
0.2438568175,
-0.8312732577,
0.0910547897,
0.67155689,
0.3875606656,
0.1783967912,
0.4282999039,
0.197080493,
0.322262913,
-0.1140217334,
0.2679691017,
0.3234169185,
-0.6698766947,
0.0619811043,
0.4101090133,
0.0482918546,
-0.4224436879
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11029v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11029v1 | Curating Stopwords in Marathi: A TF-IDF Approach for Improved Text Analysis and Information Retrieval | 2024-06-16T17:59:05 | 2024-06-16T17:59:05 | Rohan Chavan, Gaurav Patil, Vishal Madle, Raviraj Joshi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Stopwords are commonly used words in a language that are often considered to
be of little value in determining the meaning or significance of a document.
These words occur frequently in most texts and don't provide much useful
information for tasks like sentiment analysis and text classification. English,
which is a high-resource language, takes advantage of the availability of
stopwords, whereas low-resource Indian languages like Marathi are very limited,
standardized, and can be used in available packages, but the number of
available words in those packages is low. Our work targets the curation of
stopwords in the Marathi language using the MahaCorpus, with 24.8 million
sentences. We make use of the TF-IDF approach coupled with human evaluation to
curate a strong stopword list of 400 words. We apply the stop word removal to
the text classification task and show its efficacy. The work also presents a
simple recipe for stopword curation in a low-resource language. The stopwords
are integrated into the mahaNLP library and publicly available on
https://github.com/l3cube-pune/MarathiNLP . | [
-0.5963807106,
-1.0155158043,
0.2468867302,
0.3682014346,
-0.7325467467,
0.3362228274,
-0.2950864434,
-0.4882336855,
0.4129756987,
0.7536655068,
-0.3268662989,
-0.4955720305,
-0.8700171113,
0.385738641,
-0.449770689,
0.8982642889,
-0.1655506045,
-0.24937509,
-0.049603913,
-0.609819591,
-0.6824147701,
-0.3564456105,
-0.8619378805,
-0.1835472882,
0.2541357279,
0.5455656648,
0.5929003954,
0.2545878589,
0.6484802961,
0.2534888685,
-0.2067150772,
0.3473242819,
-0.4970602393,
0.4624582231,
-0.55485636,
-0.2589870691,
-0.0554401316,
-0.0504752137,
0.3716553748,
0.5733459592,
-0.2267797887,
-0.0059956932,
-0.1388096958,
0.8243486881,
-1.0780255795,
0.2062866837,
-0.3138101101,
0.2770567834,
-0.8431518674,
-0.1578516811,
-0.3757919967,
-0.479444176,
-0.2703128159,
-0.3432845473,
0.0175521579,
0.200538516,
0.8555853367,
0.3353002965,
0.0164569113,
-0.6091069579,
-0.9608454108,
0.972587049,
-0.4134486914,
0.2518602908,
0.6417093277,
0.1850892007,
0.0175415501,
-0.618912816,
-0.533154726,
-0.1257560402,
-0.0070817126,
0.209168762,
-0.2393146753,
0.0085590864,
0.4008999467,
0.6087753773,
-0.280960381,
-0.070192717,
-0.4520682395,
-0.2271487415,
0.4430091083,
0.2628270984,
0.5478465557,
-0.4477884769,
-0.3914097846,
0.0919641778,
-0.5270525217,
-0.1325713545,
0.0362968519,
-0.0052834959,
0.1974519491,
0.8629792929,
-0.4312466383,
0.7347621322,
-0.1437829882,
-0.109657459,
0.1789627075,
-0.7969278097,
-0.2196927071,
0.2135876417,
0.8454050422,
0.0513155423,
0.3033954501,
-0.2445120215,
-0.3080642223,
0.4250323474,
0.3745754659,
-0.8912994862,
0.016073253,
0.1810695082,
-0.4157453477,
-0.4994023144,
-0.0313278176,
-0.9777110815,
-0.0755250081,
0.0958296061,
0.2671372592,
-0.5667108297,
-0.2022946179,
0.1026744694,
-0.4057269394,
0.4842456579,
-0.1861609519,
-0.6775633693,
0.4099574983,
0.4458982646,
0.9060589075,
-0.3560854197,
0.0844009668,
-0.7541094422,
0.0906453803,
-0.575977087,
0.7501392961,
-1.019310236,
-0.9504460692,
0.1658664942,
-0.1564327329,
0.0225030165,
-0.7499118447,
1.0389238596,
-0.6905125976,
0.1678664684,
-0.1213409305,
-0.575306654,
-0.1727725267,
0.2909058034,
-0.7634559274,
1.400701642,
0.0929557383,
-0.7934986949,
0.402723372,
-1.0037400723,
-0.7887010574,
0.5572846532,
-0.1772997975,
-0.2629271746,
0.312037915,
0.2426531166,
0.3328955472,
-0.1353076547,
0.1528067738,
0.1040089205,
-0.2510075569,
0.2634841502,
-0.146111235,
0.8273804784,
0.6004303694,
-0.2909964025,
0.0090895249,
-0.5668273568,
-0.0833746195,
-0.0049246605,
-0.3108066916,
-0.7029640079,
0.1389053762,
0.440426141,
0.2075303346,
0.1271677464,
-0.9651270509,
0.0706898123,
-0.6034216285,
0.4961043,
0.3360823989,
0.3756966591,
0.3110108078,
-0.3388350904,
0.9081855416,
0.116403304,
0.1790757626,
0.0677349269,
-0.7574633956,
-0.6047078371,
-0.2425047606,
0.2782127559,
0.5500002503,
-1.1257650852,
0.1608075649,
-0.187217325,
-0.6372899413,
-0.5729053617,
0.336518079,
0.4086197317,
0.3942235112,
0.5165436864,
-0.5601551533,
-0.4869530499,
-0.7584158778,
-0.1553542614,
0.2503619492,
0.272895813,
0.0754315257,
0.5695326924,
-0.2877798975,
1.1595896482,
-0.8339343071,
-0.634128511,
-0.3050496876,
0.3608450294,
-0.1331243366,
0.0836580843,
0.3765698969,
-1.118427515,
-0.3405436575,
-0.4884123504,
-0.6104099154,
-0.1556551456,
0.3692805171,
-0.4249467254,
0.3835163414,
0.6091073155,
-0.5832442641,
0.4500162601,
0.3017950058,
-0.2694120407,
0.4594092965,
-0.0418520905,
0.0842180029,
-1.3637831211,
0.0543253571,
-0.128308773,
-0.1366802603,
-0.351205796,
0.2239605039,
-0.187397182,
-0.327260673,
-0.3885459006,
0.7191166282,
-0.2520731091,
0.211040765,
-0.4596564472,
0.521787405,
0.0118838297,
0.0658191666,
0.1204013303,
0.9374725223,
0.089074783,
-0.6567909718,
0.4634694159,
0.4985216558,
-0.3734134436,
0.6766808033,
-0.4704120755,
-0.1439896822,
-0.0006330471,
-0.0645347014,
-0.8132659793,
-0.0994133055,
0.4772373736,
-0.3895811737,
0.2872790992,
0.1678508222,
-0.6283564568,
-0.0928330719,
-0.442758888,
0.3415290415,
0.4767564833,
-0.2524466217,
0.3266841769,
0.8075649738,
-0.1758635342,
-0.4908263087,
-0.850217402,
0.4346168935,
-0.069995746,
-0.3074925542,
0.4717131257,
-0.0970465764,
-0.4947426915,
0.4225666225,
0.0861478075,
-0.2083275765,
-0.0213497356,
0.2732779682,
0.151349768,
0.1531917006,
0.4250755906,
-0.0319839753,
-0.252632916,
-0.1454397589,
-0.2704881728,
0.4995143712,
0.0153923305,
0.0284680016,
0.1222992539,
0.4734777212,
0.4472233057,
-0.6987386942,
0.7627224326,
0.9990383983,
-0.5684669018,
-0.2369505465,
-0.5160282254,
0.1566415429,
-0.3930110335,
-0.0008717336,
-0.2461960167,
-0.7202154994,
0.011415923,
-0.0007117901,
0.0244817026,
0.7295499444,
0.5905430913,
0.0829202756,
0.5742117167,
0.6970152855,
-0.2545796931,
0.4233968556,
-0.091564402,
0.5881963372,
-0.7539105415,
-0.2034582645,
-0.8271493912,
0.0757254437,
-0.8404229879,
-0.5154733658,
-0.0207822639,
-0.0218317453,
0.3654035926,
0.3976125419,
-0.7890019417,
0.0524753816,
0.2707498074,
-0.0050250073,
0.4338428378,
0.1149254069,
-0.2112842947,
-0.1985011399,
-0.3958769143,
-0.5589548349,
0.7499269843,
-0.3438194096,
0.5959151387,
0.1556054205,
0.8584330082,
0.731528461,
0.3156018853,
-1.132371068,
0.7426040173,
-0.3223352134,
-0.7486338019,
-0.3060043752,
-0.1796218008,
-0.9618515372,
-0.1177264377,
-0.3264962733,
-0.2485254407,
-0.2122025341,
-0.3686575592,
-0.1049233079,
0.2253621817,
-0.4720984697,
0.6607324481,
-0.0411529168,
-0.279501617,
-0.5725530982,
-0.0051877708,
0.169074297,
-0.2723100483,
0.527253747,
-0.1050660238,
-0.4310007989,
1.1147518158,
-0.7240656614,
0.3639237285,
0.0550822541,
0.1918831319,
0.5008457899,
-0.0605257116,
0.1752626002,
-0.3352122605,
-0.1838558167,
0.185146451,
0.0005671571,
-0.58712852,
-0.2067306787,
0.6100257039,
-0.2807964683,
-0.115577817,
-0.493221432,
-0.0180901438,
-0.0551603474,
0.3539588749,
0.4624842405,
0.6332994103,
-0.3306861222,
0.2747142315,
0.6704355478,
-0.2799808979,
0.6150913239,
0.2055892795,
-0.2543899715,
-0.2131492347,
0.9740534425,
0.3311730921,
-0.2044925839,
0.6226465106,
0.1557976305,
-0.3467202187,
-0.4972378016,
-0.4492609799,
0.1404202878,
-0.5453835726,
0.0228807908,
-0.5618084073,
-0.2566532493,
0.0084303841,
-0.2514478266,
-0.0351666212,
-0.3490370512,
0.0792357773,
0.0212596096,
0.5609942675,
0.7821674347,
0.1364551336,
-0.019562684,
-1.038223505,
0.3955476582,
-0.0695883185,
0.5454208851,
-0.2515655458,
-0.2999427319,
-0.3499923646,
-0.3609394431,
-0.282920897,
-0.9175205231,
0.3256559968,
0.1443894506,
0.4119132459,
0.4665225744,
0.3696378767,
0.3883756399,
-0.2406843305,
0.9020116925,
0.0697065145,
-0.8614323139,
0.8605691791,
-0.099443242,
0.4334707558,
0.7865671515,
0.5427734256,
-0.5568967462,
-0.7436769009,
-0.682921648,
-0.9515195489,
0.3501411974,
0.4049305022,
0.2691164613,
-0.6079340577,
0.202339232,
-0.1560663432,
0.3730868399,
-0.1313844025,
-0.0788004026,
0.1061558202,
-0.4257151484,
0.0045048362,
-0.6368184686,
0.0769110546,
0.1285725683,
0.8408670425,
0.3656153679,
-0.0430705659,
0.0683389455,
-0.4719297588,
0.0329053625,
0.5819907784,
0.447329402,
0.5763583779,
-0.168243289,
-0.0785219595,
0.1265893579,
-1.0363068581,
0.0675915554,
-0.0945700482,
-0.4540707171,
0.395737648,
0.2468241006,
0.3666711748,
0.528296411,
-0.7853767276,
0.36722821,
-0.1105453819,
0.1310715377,
-0.6472555995,
-0.0094727417,
0.0877365172,
-0.2240630537,
0.1704096049,
0.0269770101,
0.1083127782,
-0.5374299288,
0.2221338153,
0.2604564726,
-0.6358772516,
0.167998597,
0.5352169871,
0.3712559938,
-0.5158010721,
0.8726024032,
-0.5223513246,
-0.3786691427,
0.3092316985,
0.0165617298,
0.9995568991,
-0.041835919,
0.2117096484,
0.4454097152,
0.351939857,
-0.0841023102,
0.222615093,
-0.3381394744,
-0.7904568911,
-0.6381098628,
-1.2182376385,
-0.5624211431,
0.0370760299,
-0.6687805057,
0.2772839367,
-0.4684877992,
-0.439648211,
0.1211704016,
0.3735579848,
-0.5387159586,
0.2132812142,
0.021087626,
0.9519097805,
-0.7808697224,
0.7640493512,
0.8842206001,
-0.9551708102,
-0.5641304851,
-0.076609239,
-0.1881989837,
-0.2987869382,
0.7196189761,
0.284278065,
-0.3445935547,
-0.0381632186,
-0.381148994,
-0.3875296712,
0.7527887821,
-0.5039286613,
-0.495678097,
0.1437595785,
0.0374887809,
0.5584416389,
-0.2135397047,
0.0860739872,
0.5510353446,
0.5176261067,
0.1558299661,
-0.4857854843,
0.1848078072,
-0.2453441173,
0.2174061239,
0.6296490431,
-0.322919488,
0.3032085598,
0.0652267486,
-0.3030433953,
-0.1445938498,
0.3125781417,
0.0902151167,
0.2912885249,
0.467030406,
0.8063020706,
0.535785377,
-0.1223136783,
1.0457817316,
-0.4533849359,
0.3715100288,
0.6955239773,
-0.1053641886,
1.120423317,
0.3651615083,
-0.2548838258,
0.4940873384,
0.5197255611,
-0.0098066432,
0.3333348036,
0.033873681,
-0.5026466846,
-0.1954259127,
-0.436399281,
0.2530680895,
0.7370951772,
0.5889388323,
-0.150415808,
-0.4471051693,
0.4585969746,
0.2083142251,
0.2102563232,
-0.3304118514,
0.6582180858,
0.4078959227,
-0.8751319647,
0.2136656791,
0.270968318,
0.6841627955,
-0.5038204193,
-0.0926749557,
-0.2460447401,
0.1633877605,
-0.2959868908,
-0.875336051,
1.0349599123,
0.2564267516,
-0.2576492429,
-0.219655484,
1.0573662519,
-0.2911099792,
-0.4289948642,
0.5289133787,
0.416713506,
0.4010457993,
-0.1150462851,
-0.6025937796,
0.0906896293,
-0.2303596288,
-0.1634142697,
0.1391715109,
0.1592807919,
-0.2146636397,
0.4982129633,
0.5649166107,
0.35522753,
-0.1547633111,
-0.0329284817,
0.4831999242,
-0.8726362586,
-0.450579524,
-0.888867557,
0.0231667943,
-0.2246532589,
-0.1767387092,
0.6836779118,
0.5234616995,
0.92415452,
0.1446918249,
0.8573045731,
-0.3656626642,
0.360160768,
-0.5579003096,
0.7463623881,
-0.5788088441,
0.0867067873,
-0.1892015934,
-1.022507906,
-0.1034346893,
0.4687525034,
-0.3995883167,
-0.0921240672,
0.7589340806,
0.7399911284,
0.1298863888,
0.115626879,
0.4763543606,
0.2105387747,
0.1052560136,
0.1391526014,
0.5010882616,
-0.365165323,
0.915923059,
-0.1638968438,
-0.2421161383,
-0.5538520217,
-0.6587116718,
-0.5131404996,
-0.6656981111,
-0.2819297314,
-0.4464800358,
-0.1403584629,
0.6990090609,
0.3638377786,
-0.8148630261,
0.0203640331,
0.0742152259,
0.2494126558,
-0.1154482141,
-0.29958722,
0.2681046426,
-0.5727269053,
-0.6700603962,
0.1391976178,
0.6145111322,
-0.5675337911,
-0.2669543028,
0.1858374625,
-0.3988655806,
0.3750469089,
1.0249191523,
0.2358096689,
-0.2967804074,
-0.1233195886,
-0.1632387936,
-0.4184027016,
-0.0011178312,
0.6607033014,
-0.7214527726,
0.8388213515,
0.6073094606,
0.6949128509,
0.6703635454,
-0.006843348,
0.1412181854,
-0.5776184797,
0.1742083877,
0.2784288824,
0.2339693904,
0.5329223871,
-0.1325027943,
0.7336544394,
0.4493360519,
-0.2534630895,
-0.3642322719,
0.3690436482,
-0.9405357838,
-0.1866877675,
1.0831269026,
0.0709527731,
-0.3213932812,
-0.4594865143,
-0.2728289068,
0.3649872839,
-0.3799773157,
0.7525249124,
1.1196113825,
0.0958201587,
0.0488815643,
-0.9534819126,
0.5271367431,
0.3140930533,
-0.6893585324,
-0.5093838573,
0.3347541392,
0.4254504144,
0.4447502494,
1.1331549883,
-0.4168348908,
-0.0185435954,
-0.0457345359,
-0.017111551,
-0.1338039339,
0.0534535646,
-0.2630195916,
0.3352039158,
0.2030109018,
-0.4820213616
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11028v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11028v1 | Universal Cross-Lingual Text Classification | 2024-06-16T17:58:29 | 2024-06-16T17:58:29 | Riya Savant, Anushka Shelke, Sakshi Todmal, Sanskruti Kanphade, Ananya Joshi, Raviraj Joshi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Text classification, an integral task in natural language processing,
involves the automatic categorization of text into predefined classes. Creating
supervised labeled datasets for low-resource languages poses a considerable
challenge. Unlocking the language potential of low-resource languages requires
robust datasets with supervised labels. However, such datasets are scarce, and
the label space is often limited. In our pursuit to address this gap, we aim to
optimize existing labels/datasets in different languages. This research
proposes a novel perspective on Universal Cross-Lingual Text Classification,
leveraging a unified model across languages. Our approach involves blending
supervised data from different languages during training to create a universal
model. The supervised data for a target classification task might come from
different languages covering different labels. The primary goal is to enhance
label and language coverage, aiming for a label set that represents a union of
labels from various languages. We propose the usage of a strong multilingual
SBERT as our base model, making our novel training strategy feasible. This
strategy contributes to the adaptability and effectiveness of the model in
cross-lingual language transfer scenarios, where it can categorize text in
languages not encountered during training. Thus, the paper delves into the
intricacies of cross-lingual text classification, with a particular focus on
its application for low-resource languages, exploring methodologies and
implications for the development of a robust and adaptable universal
cross-lingual model. | [
-0.2671378553,
-0.3211482167,
0.0099817878,
0.2182938755,
-0.1786604226,
0.1713946909,
-0.2700284123,
-0.8708398938,
-0.06636516,
0.6096051335,
-0.3039418757,
-0.4664341807,
-0.5027256012,
0.2203520685,
-0.2063309401,
1.3534913063,
-0.166786015,
0.1652677506,
0.1130776927,
-0.4346829355,
-0.4930574,
-0.7243503332,
-0.2739878893,
-0.6045827866,
0.4030557573,
0.4947759211,
0.3974339962,
0.2488307953,
0.1412343383,
0.2752494812,
-0.0652431399,
0.0918115228,
-0.3942509294,
-0.0322653614,
-0.383348316,
-0.3581374586,
-0.0480947196,
-0.1001029611,
0.65201509,
0.9316126108,
0.1044386178,
-0.0181588568,
0.1368335783,
0.2352075428,
-0.4891052246,
-0.0587848127,
-0.6321861148,
0.3572388589,
-0.3276105821,
0.0346324481,
-0.5246692896,
0.0064833313,
0.1802794337,
-0.5764200091,
0.1890849024,
0.1625648588,
0.655803144,
-0.0758348554,
-0.6668801308,
-0.2529945374,
-0.6946970224,
0.8457786441,
-0.2524511516,
0.7985434532,
0.1483344883,
0.3450931609,
0.3549761176,
-0.4746030271,
-0.2884973884,
0.079423219,
-0.0895391852,
-0.0175810382,
-0.1089226156,
-0.2086287737,
-0.2287541181,
0.3200942278,
-0.7013661861,
0.4410830438,
-0.2157247365,
-0.3368033171,
0.5410850048,
-0.0107721258,
0.7618466616,
-0.1051610485,
-0.7112234831,
-0.0213429462,
-0.5562163591,
0.1176096275,
0.1225900054,
0.6612532735,
-0.0778081045,
0.3118971586,
-0.0945159793,
0.7914555669,
-0.1616264433,
-0.1633079052,
0.0510038845,
-0.532379806,
-0.3245253563,
0.3619906604,
0.8077656627,
-0.0295417923,
0.2951847911,
-0.4720033407,
-0.0776079446,
-0.0854250416,
0.1023627818,
-0.7619717121,
-0.1322320551,
-0.3520722985,
-0.1875475198,
-0.2804345787,
-0.0385748334,
-0.6089011431,
-0.1531366408,
-0.2329698056,
0.2663002908,
-0.1964631528,
-0.2386308163,
0.1046590805,
0.2010387778,
-0.0966874361,
0.1884598136,
-1.1396456957,
0.2638517916,
0.4189127684,
0.5135620236,
-0.2681926489,
-0.5337998271,
-0.3994617164,
0.4107230008,
-0.2989815772,
0.7976064086,
-0.4953425527,
-0.3991915286,
0.0059935125,
0.2234108448,
-0.0972840339,
-0.1737985462,
0.520825088,
-0.3795540333,
0.5455231667,
0.0320900828,
-0.2969124317,
-0.4562180042,
0.3024313748,
-0.6544523239,
1.1265131235,
0.1259856224,
-0.955542028,
0.4592631459,
-0.3560963869,
-0.7066962719,
0.2662743628,
-0.0389708802,
-0.1900089085,
-0.1193438321,
0.2261078656,
0.6063876748,
-0.593936801,
0.2003326118,
0.0029053402,
-0.2844617069,
0.2792162001,
-0.5114049315,
1.1019951105,
0.0418594517,
-0.2007981092,
-0.1184176952,
-0.6515163779,
0.2230076492,
-0.1981665343,
-0.4416524172,
-0.9180293679,
-0.5840958357,
0.7153097391,
0.2265741527,
0.1964416504,
-0.5368267894,
0.1306842417,
-0.3126770258,
-0.0112979775,
0.3717404306,
-0.2514064014,
0.8562375307,
0.0030663298,
0.5866075158,
-0.1357219964,
-0.0383051448,
-0.1412028968,
-0.4704288542,
-0.4406272173,
-0.3684624434,
0.7983077168,
0.9617644548,
-0.8118957877,
0.3796521425,
-0.3564100862,
-0.45226717,
-0.5693836808,
0.5013985634,
0.7069525719,
0.3856969476,
0.313039273,
-0.2623981833,
-0.4576963782,
-0.770896852,
-0.1799546927,
0.0004864547,
0.0479232334,
0.0416098982,
0.2279080749,
-0.7167556286,
0.6456554532,
-0.2497718632,
-0.3787076473,
-0.6573987603,
0.2724354863,
-0.0732146874,
0.4035227895,
0.5714442134,
-1.0968452692,
-0.9386233091,
0.7268636823,
-0.8141403794,
-0.3470694125,
-0.1688916385,
-0.2420190573,
0.4672931135,
0.4896459281,
-0.1570526958,
0.2897128165,
0.5906533599,
-0.2677675486,
0.2969154119,
-0.2404074371,
0.1122307032,
-0.9651791453,
-0.012128545,
0.1748241782,
-0.1449037045,
-0.9005052447,
0.0476337038,
0.0688522086,
-0.0870551541,
-0.5360292792,
1.0181279182,
-0.4736286402,
0.1014811918,
-0.2426057458,
-0.0737760812,
0.0313641429,
0.5013247728,
0.2415797859,
0.4820061624,
0.6192445755,
-0.5256463289,
0.2536441088,
0.3044634759,
-0.1619845182,
0.9116431475,
-0.2510723174,
-0.2163797617,
-0.0759315267,
0.1328696758,
-0.9611255527,
-0.062140014,
0.3560402989,
-0.2567943931,
0.5545521379,
-0.0831554458,
-0.3650930822,
-0.0453450158,
0.0645489395,
0.5952594876,
0.1953171045,
-0.7745297551,
0.5803008676,
0.5723891854,
-0.2739773691,
-0.4849278927,
-0.989959836,
-0.015814472,
-0.1705692559,
-0.4790032208,
0.3574868739,
-0.0467017666,
-0.0287844576,
0.0822327584,
-0.1622957885,
-0.4756836593,
-0.129965052,
0.0568646602,
0.2858033478,
-0.1408175528,
0.2496556342,
0.3488184512,
-0.1856886595,
-0.4902264178,
-0.4251269996,
0.1823507547,
-0.1778718084,
-0.1468922347,
-0.2142179906,
0.6805035472,
0.3535835743,
-0.1537842751,
0.4401775002,
0.8100387454,
-0.352986604,
-0.4544225037,
-0.2072838843,
0.3883160651,
-0.3998227715,
0.3149852455,
-0.5411322713,
-0.9359481931,
0.3086654842,
0.0767806098,
0.006174596,
0.2626084685,
0.5219196081,
0.1071069166,
0.7712128758,
1.1500277519,
-0.422554493,
0.3359240294,
0.0955334008,
0.0717245862,
-0.4719157815,
-0.2100781351,
-0.6352530718,
-0.027003713,
-0.6228682995,
-0.4335344434,
0.0829801038,
-0.012191182,
-0.0785995126,
0.5555444956,
-0.6258469224,
0.5885240436,
0.4463801682,
-0.1848661005,
0.4103862345,
0.2582941353,
-0.2882093489,
-0.2279429436,
-0.9520784616,
-0.3120767176,
0.8347805142,
0.1159674823,
0.809106946,
-0.1752342135,
0.5576888919,
0.2955892384,
0.5574522614,
-0.5661273599,
0.4025789797,
-0.547020793,
-0.749706924,
-0.4083065689,
-0.6303248405,
-1.0192890167,
0.7526165843,
-0.1528037935,
-0.6992621422,
0.0184797999,
-0.2583236396,
0.2330088466,
0.4654071331,
-0.6656332016,
1.2006576061,
-0.6697802544,
0.0223981757,
0.1992186904,
-0.7230699658,
0.3249799907,
-0.4451276064,
0.4194319546,
0.0669504702,
0.01079043,
0.6210172176,
0.0251486767,
0.944588244,
0.2391050011,
-0.3751061261,
0.235712707,
0.0163995195,
-0.0305783115,
-0.1000430956,
0.258125037,
0.4226373434,
-0.1158355474,
-0.3795086145,
-0.231688112,
0.5240018368,
-0.5766643882,
0.0460791774,
-0.5246109962,
-0.6762025356,
-0.3419668972,
0.4073647261,
0.427409023,
0.3264020383,
-0.5198880434,
-0.0705362856,
0.7167838216,
-0.3328946531,
0.2077183127,
0.6626529098,
-0.3273185194,
-0.3750641942,
1.1747089624,
0.0444661751,
0.1674130857,
0.8391366005,
0.1392024606,
-0.3163458705,
-0.1626906395,
-0.6150965095,
0.1660541445,
-0.7578554153,
-0.2118589133,
-0.4674993157,
-0.1930868626,
-0.4238846004,
-0.3967318833,
-0.1389701664,
-0.3233859241,
-0.2670620084,
0.0559296757,
0.1516751051,
0.6147822738,
-0.2215813547,
0.3821404278,
-0.9579595923,
0.4282868803,
0.3469734788,
0.3796001375,
-0.1837455779,
-0.373250246,
-0.4235595167,
0.0262775179,
-0.0907506943,
-0.8535585403,
0.5269917846,
0.3259487152,
0.9988324642,
0.1310837716,
0.0148915751,
0.2427899241,
-0.5099743009,
0.277856946,
0.431763947,
-0.8816096187,
0.287039578,
-0.2437101752,
0.4081665277,
0.5327860117,
0.7654525042,
-0.99294734,
-0.3685476482,
-0.3886835575,
-0.7593863606,
0.8269356489,
-0.0484352298,
-0.0831176713,
0.426658541,
-0.1186698899,
0.41134727,
0.0064241132,
-1.0849751234,
0.0470513925,
-0.1672657728,
-0.4351584911,
-0.2064691633,
0.0701554641,
0.019022245,
-0.2513922155,
0.6111448407,
-0.2184693217,
-0.1363460124,
-0.1641552895,
-0.499473691,
-0.062928848,
0.5121816397,
0.081824027,
0.1885020435,
0.0758242384,
0.1278010756,
0.3206194043,
-0.4510827661,
0.3643841445,
0.2740751803,
-0.441047281,
0.1844555438,
0.2171936482,
0.7456398606,
0.5852485299,
-0.7054693103,
0.2093329877,
-0.0209576767,
-0.0375935547,
0.3329471648,
-0.1973873526,
-0.0617717914,
0.1629113257,
0.2578572631,
-0.0488383584,
0.1877943128,
-0.599660635,
0.1682848781,
0.3237479627,
-0.5273959041,
-0.3366723657,
0.4886392951,
0.2365242243,
-0.2061770856,
0.3667321205,
-0.1854080409,
-0.9071301222,
0.3771937788,
0.6870783567,
0.8322674632,
-0.4151204824,
0.5499500036,
0.0831951648,
0.3928355873,
-0.1618736833,
-0.2212249339,
-0.2391083091,
-0.7591937184,
-0.2982015014,
-0.7445556521,
-0.6115810871,
-0.2084074467,
-0.5408120155,
0.0821011066,
-0.1248667464,
0.1983101368,
-0.0362431966,
-0.0289923511,
-0.5678679347,
0.4694452882,
0.4109642208,
0.715693295,
-1.218808651,
0.9172583818,
0.9764367342,
-0.1580635011,
-0.3848040998,
-0.0892583132,
-0.094942227,
-0.5392333865,
0.8563296199,
0.3329476416,
-0.1350522339,
-0.3285625875,
-0.2628672719,
-0.6406199336,
0.4885260463,
0.1219635904,
-0.2162504941,
0.0184639078,
0.4596748948,
0.8270133734,
-0.385763973,
-0.2564817071,
0.2840299308,
0.4897210896,
0.0408102758,
-1.0472513437,
-0.0398753285,
-0.3725573719,
0.1906595826,
0.349144429,
-0.3902758062,
0.7326173186,
0.0121778082,
-0.1549380273,
-0.0686020479,
0.610414207,
0.1191404536,
0.3833678365,
0.3975905478,
0.5216640234,
0.6789164543,
-0.0083744535,
0.8649908304,
0.0319654867,
0.183123678,
0.8237631321,
-0.406385988,
0.6038188934,
0.1625016034,
-0.0086383,
0.3231748044,
0.5907549262,
0.0158780031,
0.5680368543,
0.0261759683,
-0.3230065107,
-0.3028527796,
-0.2387757897,
-0.3086752892,
0.4841369689,
0.2468997091,
0.0862188488,
-0.43311432,
0.4431039095,
0.00138581,
0.0780697539,
-0.4381480217,
0.5352509022,
0.0160347708,
-0.3870844245,
0.5277357101,
0.101853855,
0.960496366,
-0.5361438394,
0.2832474113,
-0.1196069494,
0.3750503659,
0.0734670907,
-0.7446204424,
0.1288658381,
0.119838357,
-0.2035322338,
-0.5201859474,
0.8979458213,
-0.8959288001,
-0.7866892815,
0.5499711633,
0.39965415,
0.0977621526,
0.1737558246,
-0.6744866967,
-0.0873638466,
0.1376758218,
0.0074637393,
0.62073946,
0.9600255489,
-0.3696700931,
0.5730569959,
0.5114175677,
0.0938756093,
0.069053717,
-0.1328022927,
0.5328885317,
-0.6574889421,
-0.820386529,
-0.3710624576,
0.3060988784,
0.1159438193,
-0.5114575028,
0.8419622779,
0.5529082417,
1.1786956787,
-0.0763428658,
0.9917690158,
0.0656889081,
0.6159579754,
-0.2962753773,
0.8148772717,
-0.9458341002,
-0.0426333062,
-0.3427774608,
-0.8177982569,
-0.4627038836,
0.4562945664,
0.0769111663,
-0.1643666327,
0.500051856,
0.298594147,
-0.2549312413,
0.0201457366,
0.2801424265,
-0.1342998147,
0.0127879921,
0.7136590481,
0.6164211035,
-0.367982626,
0.953599751,
-0.2038901895,
-0.1436326355,
-0.2723287642,
-0.7086729407,
-1.0470824242,
-0.6281599402,
-0.1352137476,
-0.0334512219,
0.0436089672,
0.5003985167,
0.6331433654,
-0.9193693995,
-0.4805173576,
0.1592234671,
0.2346268892,
-0.1369441301,
-0.1901298016,
0.1066513807,
-0.3470748067,
-0.8009624481,
0.2089563459,
0.1974288374,
0.4226412773,
-0.1668398529,
-0.0916080251,
-0.3178715706,
-0.162930131,
0.633559525,
0.6848624945,
-0.3733436763,
0.0970478281,
0.0491873212,
-0.521191299,
-0.1342535168,
0.7054044008,
-0.5766275525,
0.4018945992,
0.5372149348,
1.0435285568,
0.4846457839,
-0.3446587324,
0.4952910841,
-0.9589062333,
0.3673557341,
0.1986864805,
0.2434147596,
0.5240833163,
-0.2974402905,
0.6626132727,
0.1812591106,
-0.3869287372,
-0.9514712691,
0.2149121612,
-1.0213271379,
-0.7014078498,
1.0682728291,
-0.0047831177,
-0.093926616,
-0.1800445616,
-0.3505717814,
0.2858826518,
-0.0583478697,
0.5195478201,
0.6905902028,
0.1043030322,
-0.0706140846,
-0.2350170165,
0.1803324968,
0.2197717428,
-1.0227183104,
0.056357827,
0.3767589331,
0.2236830145,
0.3627938032,
0.6180576086,
0.1205447093,
0.1503306776,
-0.0583335198,
0.2179952562,
0.2526990175,
-0.6886280179,
-0.2663091421,
0.1580668837,
-0.5728256106,
0.0061026015
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11025v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11025v1 | Large Language Models for Dysfluency Detection in Stuttered Speech | 2024-06-16T17:51:22 | 2024-06-16T17:51:22 | Dominik Wagner, Sebastian P. Bayerl, Ilja Baumann, Korbinian Riedhammer, Elmar Nöth, Tobias Bocklet | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS | Accurately detecting dysfluencies in spoken language can help to improve the
performance of automatic speech and language processing components and support
the development of more inclusive speech and language technologies. Inspired by
the recent trend towards the deployment of large language models (LLMs) as
universal learners and processors of non-lexical inputs, such as audio and
video, we approach the task of multi-label dysfluency detection as a language
modeling problem. We present hypotheses candidates generated with an automatic
speech recognition system and acoustic representations extracted from an audio
encoder model to an LLM, and finetune the system to predict dysfluency labels
on three datasets containing English and German stuttered speech. The
experimental results show that our system effectively combines acoustic and
lexical information and achieves competitive results on the multi-label
stuttering detection task. | [
-0.3555168211,
-1.0059794188,
0.5284237266,
0.2409139872,
0.0191010702,
0.2399532199,
-0.1550815254,
-0.6672909856,
0.2145408392,
0.512494266,
-0.270319134,
-0.1091423258,
-0.7793136239,
0.2740668654,
-0.6951096058,
0.742412746,
0.0990942493,
0.212676689,
-0.0092549128,
0.0781716481,
-0.5045098066,
-0.6987703443,
-0.7024887204,
-0.5071381927,
0.4777828157,
0.3888086379,
0.8376318812,
0.311907053,
0.2026461512,
0.4279839098,
-0.2974155545,
-0.0165864956,
-0.2750853896,
0.5882017612,
0.2822754681,
-0.1550436616,
-0.5701634288,
-0.3673219979,
1.0363537073,
0.7369764447,
-0.1043008566,
-0.1647133082,
0.1419974715,
0.3222062886,
-0.2934132814,
0.1889045686,
-0.4755618572,
-0.0280335266,
-0.4187176228,
0.0311634988,
-0.4333329201,
0.0720292106,
-0.335791707,
-0.2498293519,
0.1419461817,
-0.0686465055,
0.3971144259,
0.3583126962,
-0.3703316152,
-0.5139188766,
-0.7721381783,
0.4682449102,
-0.5792657733,
1.0885320902,
0.4891271889,
0.0442146249,
-0.4796354771,
-0.5800268054,
-0.6934422851,
-0.5183257461,
0.1479064375,
-0.2558682859,
-0.3270242512,
0.1369045973,
0.3089843094,
0.2630538046,
-0.8328220844,
0.7679300308,
-0.1133417562,
-0.5366791487,
0.6579898,
-0.1381380558,
0.2912662327,
0.1163304374,
-0.065665938,
0.0585064888,
-0.1697873473,
-0.276568234,
0.4461646974,
0.45139727,
-0.0066685802,
0.3363776207,
-0.1921186894,
0.8366398811,
-0.3069419563,
-0.5467352271,
0.3629453182,
0.15366216,
0.0288665537,
0.4433402121,
0.4660640657,
-0.1977940798,
0.4966746867,
-0.0810435936,
-0.632686615,
0.0221792813,
-0.332709074,
-0.5667123199,
-0.3965190351,
0.1621452421,
0.0120555302,
-0.0315205492,
-0.1667320728,
-0.7493109703,
-0.5678187013,
-0.2006441355,
0.3320329487,
-0.2816372812,
-0.4795924723,
0.1137656942,
-0.141119644,
-0.422012955,
0.0511999428,
-0.8778250813,
0.0491151847,
0.5630239248,
0.7222197652,
0.0660547838,
-0.2946286201,
-0.957742393,
0.1755239218,
-0.2228563279,
0.6736992002,
-0.6252855062,
-0.1844610721,
0.1918379515,
0.0741198137,
0.0961729661,
-0.4404523075,
0.6651331782,
-0.4911112487,
-0.2985115945,
0.1627660245,
-0.6517983675,
0.0417656936,
-0.0787914842,
-0.9310310483,
0.9462056756,
-0.0668174326,
-0.4713771343,
0.5199059844,
-0.4163073003,
-0.4926655591,
0.5684736371,
0.1328225881,
-0.5213151574,
0.2662564218,
0.2584132254,
0.6759936213,
0.0586140156,
0.7072274089,
-0.4372567236,
-0.3578321934,
0.6657294631,
-0.992575407,
0.5322577953,
0.1358535141,
-0.0485804081,
-0.1328302175,
-0.8318920135,
-0.1190163866,
0.1231915727,
-0.583959341,
-0.4328554571,
-0.1324833333,
0.3804562986,
0.0445955992,
0.0548511036,
-0.5326849818,
0.1613525301,
-0.1399730593,
0.5696573257,
0.3959422112,
-0.1749954224,
-0.0957925916,
0.039653793,
0.3654710352,
0.1942687184,
-0.1980019808,
-0.2575584054,
-0.5294926167,
-0.6123360991,
-0.5578973293,
0.5437717438,
0.363121897,
-0.8365834355,
0.374900341,
-0.143535316,
-0.2112982422,
-0.4342550933,
0.3083781004,
0.3070638776,
0.5243721008,
0.3127519786,
0.0628386214,
-0.4750286639,
-0.8992543221,
-0.1759646982,
-0.2114868909,
-0.1261481643,
-0.1256068796,
0.5130329728,
-0.3192672431,
0.5313650966,
-0.4057833254,
-0.4860963821,
-0.2192590684,
0.1535072774,
-0.1987133026,
0.2939310968,
0.4345239699,
-0.9555074573,
-0.3163372576,
-0.1810770035,
-0.354445219,
-0.3660970628,
0.2070835233,
0.5643535256,
0.5042234063,
0.7351207733,
-0.070274055,
0.1591761261,
0.8832532763,
-0.3830839694,
0.4631861746,
-0.2088335752,
0.1617837995,
-0.6506502032,
-0.2935492694,
0.3745259047,
-0.4147079885,
-0.9840836525,
-0.3378201425,
0.1143714115,
-0.1676402539,
-0.3052074015,
0.4193093777,
-0.3169817626,
-0.040485803,
-0.2246052027,
0.2640562952,
0.0220065489,
0.0223763045,
0.1088749394,
0.6234858632,
0.776011467,
-0.5071690679,
0.6400031447,
-0.0699686632,
-0.3351198137,
0.6332092285,
-0.4355618954,
-0.0154800937,
-0.230400309,
0.2535394728,
-1.4183334112,
-0.6749157906,
-0.0523716845,
-0.3122128546,
0.6485797763,
-0.1078117713,
-0.7288481593,
-0.6932332516,
0.3927993774,
0.3189828396,
0.2843574584,
-0.665627718,
0.176060155,
0.7352327704,
-0.3628557622,
-0.2822109461,
-0.8815381527,
0.2568032742,
-0.1920083761,
-0.6240884662,
0.1807335466,
0.1416854411,
-0.1335894465,
-0.1008971706,
0.0560304523,
-0.4741326571,
0.1322601587,
0.0374934375,
0.0648180917,
-0.1218028739,
0.6838971972,
-0.1124720871,
0.046729207,
-0.1363273412,
-0.201938197,
0.5824136138,
-0.2418572754,
-0.4293986261,
-0.5322523713,
0.5172621608,
0.6077589393,
-0.0400342755,
0.464731425,
0.6907282472,
-0.6649984717,
-0.2341281176,
-0.8745667338,
-0.261928618,
-0.4757897854,
0.7754189372,
-0.4581478536,
-0.9371826053,
0.4461707175,
0.1033990905,
-0.3052611351,
0.1198615953,
0.4831208885,
-0.0216961708,
1.2131319046,
0.7107796669,
-0.240065515,
0.4479518831,
0.2208628654,
0.0900240615,
-0.3315143287,
-0.3282652795,
-0.6758032441,
-0.2063397616,
-0.3557342589,
-0.3157710135,
0.3659448624,
0.0101625063,
0.0085355071,
0.0086086085,
-0.4287470877,
0.5049459338,
0.2799706459,
-0.1262639612,
0.5673479438,
0.2994832098,
-0.1268812865,
-0.1751939058,
-0.877614975,
-0.3765304089,
0.4569397271,
0.6816144586,
0.5719633698,
0.0316544212,
0.6418218017,
0.3998609483,
0.2410418987,
-0.8915750384,
0.2979836762,
-0.3298513889,
-0.6361116767,
-0.5452738404,
-0.4574884474,
-0.8400170207,
0.0664759353,
-0.2818475664,
-0.7260901332,
0.2327580452,
0.2647029161,
-0.1383140087,
0.3769249916,
-0.6356056333,
0.5431258678,
-0.3882838488,
-0.2634139955,
-0.0095531242,
-0.0160270873,
0.4738880098,
-0.4345320165,
0.6133682132,
-0.1146863997,
0.1142876744,
0.9029197693,
-0.0685289577,
0.8609008193,
-0.2556302547,
-0.4622626603,
0.255729109,
0.0217918847,
0.2384921312,
-0.0444695093,
-0.2866604626,
0.4718515873,
-0.1006545648,
-0.1382469088,
-0.2940908372,
0.8434681296,
-0.3816484511,
-0.5613516569,
-0.4969238043,
-0.5876769423,
-0.3674302101,
0.1117034927,
-0.0061604846,
0.5428596139,
-0.3049497008,
0.2488374114,
0.5870991349,
-0.0242261738,
0.6692282557,
0.5223891139,
-0.2311673313,
-0.3360494673,
0.8630002141,
0.4733963907,
0.1469524056,
-0.0494614951,
0.1178653836,
-0.5849206448,
-0.4641172588,
-0.4199366868,
0.3175278604,
-0.7594100833,
-0.2447820157,
-0.5541494489,
-0.2847337425,
-0.600086689,
0.1274292022,
-0.3484186828,
-0.1777750403,
-0.3500020802,
0.0932555497,
0.5208653808,
0.8798858523,
-0.2353209257,
0.4108193815,
-0.8518416286,
0.3111158907,
0.3550961912,
0.5977426171,
0.0281641204,
-0.7923186421,
-0.2831361294,
0.0973044336,
-0.2755701542,
-1.1027525663,
0.6399453282,
0.4502412379,
0.6346835494,
0.3732585907,
-0.1154863536,
0.8034217954,
-0.325358659,
0.4768134058,
0.3062908947,
-0.9990021586,
0.3857651651,
-0.1014077738,
0.1516766399,
0.0969030634,
0.6451134682,
-0.7308652997,
-0.4325495958,
-0.3607845306,
-0.7621000409,
0.5159025788,
0.0410900153,
-0.0450804234,
0.0093751298,
0.2287888527,
-0.0704370067,
0.0329546034,
-0.7902088165,
0.048664432,
0.0068909214,
-0.0854998007,
-0.3529780805,
-0.4593541324,
-0.1059818491,
-0.1539953202,
0.6088576913,
-0.0969544426,
-0.1328359842,
0.2639918029,
-0.1860510856,
-0.1402146965,
0.4427472651,
0.4193647206,
0.1884203404,
0.1559398919,
0.2177555114,
0.1968183517,
-0.619137466,
0.4904150963,
0.3745819628,
0.097073935,
0.1138783321,
0.5109329224,
0.8601737022,
0.3084439933,
-0.8026978374,
0.270521313,
0.1086217836,
-0.3596710861,
-0.3883053958,
0.0031721184,
0.1918816715,
0.3829061091,
0.5349643826,
-0.3346152008,
0.1401881427,
-0.5616317391,
0.4309411347,
0.4715403616,
-0.4677453339,
-0.0767765343,
0.656722486,
0.2067077607,
-0.5943527818,
0.6098032594,
-0.2877429724,
-0.5786883831,
0.6035437584,
0.7589591146,
0.5719540119,
-0.679330349,
0.0831275582,
0.012091673,
0.2358578444,
-0.3206619322,
0.1138229966,
0.2713821232,
-0.7491862178,
-0.4723912477,
-0.7190463543,
-0.1561483741,
0.4940122664,
-0.4870153964,
0.4242132604,
0.0074386988,
-0.3207504749,
0.3465477228,
-0.2076129168,
-0.5728680491,
0.0421812646,
0.7843942046,
0.4563535154,
-1.2499703169,
0.9968536496,
0.4939053059,
-0.1169868112,
-0.7037754655,
0.0861727372,
0.073638618,
-0.6394744515,
0.8190253377,
0.2350710034,
-0.0253148135,
0.0442527495,
-0.1754472256,
-0.9954252839,
0.6015446782,
0.4541032016,
-1.1125198603,
0.2432879657,
0.2259276062,
0.5943672657,
-0.2661647201,
0.01928504,
0.8043570518,
0.6664967537,
0.2206907868,
-1.2365734577,
-0.2276200205,
0.255392164,
-0.2544808686,
0.1658629775,
-0.4471108019,
0.7237890363,
-0.0759115741,
-0.1767249852,
-0.2699177861,
0.5662341714,
0.4320099354,
0.4885411263,
0.7789285183,
0.3863539994,
1.0874958038,
-0.2569449246,
0.585264802,
-0.1538363844,
0.0032832238,
0.719206512,
-0.3082245886,
0.834215939,
0.3015260696,
-0.0281026214,
0.1652136296,
0.4790910184,
-0.1174607277,
0.0740712285,
0.2448194474,
-0.3307147324,
-0.450710535,
-0.2112149,
-0.3613708317,
0.8252783418,
0.7731747627,
-0.1832856387,
-0.1250775009,
0.4651199877,
-0.0521310754,
0.0334174894,
-0.5233516097,
0.6594154835,
0.035603404,
-0.5741419792,
1.0107914209,
-0.0712104067,
0.8157535195,
-0.3011480868,
0.0164660662,
0.005615761,
0.2286467999,
-0.2553942204,
-0.6959967017,
0.2195535898,
-0.025028022,
0.0197143406,
-0.2323944122,
0.8866403699,
-0.8698313832,
-0.7581567168,
0.4409961402,
0.3413142264,
0.402980417,
-0.0838314816,
-0.5368046761,
0.4961678982,
-0.0924752727,
-0.2011440545,
0.3184928,
0.4459111691,
-0.1115519181,
0.7753433585,
0.4149715006,
0.2668187916,
0.0216195378,
0.336699605,
0.8251616955,
-0.3409507275,
-0.5098485351,
-0.7527839541,
0.3121494055,
-0.0568840802,
-0.0066565573,
0.5318589211,
0.3480582237,
0.6019929051,
0.0442799293,
0.7622388005,
0.222652927,
0.2818704844,
-0.5197893381,
0.6895641685,
-0.7228873372,
0.1359973401,
-0.3914086819,
-0.8380996585,
-0.5270692706,
0.5399788022,
-0.0304559562,
0.0767484158,
0.3013593853,
0.8719587326,
0.0013284764,
-0.0189151522,
0.7159032822,
0.3767852783,
0.3702428639,
0.3849481642,
0.7565550208,
-0.1852568388,
0.6535460353,
-0.0750547126,
-0.4688676596,
-0.5119917393,
-0.964762032,
-0.7286556363,
-0.8055102825,
-0.5018178225,
-0.3123238683,
0.1203098297,
0.6525302529,
0.6582452655,
-0.6800580025,
-0.2224425524,
0.2267707586,
0.2892771065,
-0.1651579887,
-0.2272568941,
-0.0534590892,
-0.2359157801,
-0.9826245308,
0.7569215894,
0.179925397,
0.5495226383,
-0.5591859221,
0.0817351565,
-0.0187727343,
-0.0936053991,
0.6028014421,
0.2350437045,
-0.7083815932,
-0.2148913592,
-0.2115852833,
0.1483601928,
-0.1880591065,
0.6414318681,
-0.649967134,
0.3908666074,
0.3300077617,
0.3106491268,
0.3701075613,
-0.2947244644,
0.2472956181,
-0.9369427562,
0.6019954681,
0.4620909393,
0.4824266732,
0.4901432991,
-0.4181083739,
-0.0204498563,
0.185504958,
-0.6821771264,
-1.2950003147,
0.3292151392,
-0.5079562664,
-0.3792405128,
1.1709414721,
0.0402553119,
0.0652036294,
-0.5580940843,
0.0768554881,
0.3344563246,
-0.5763471127,
0.6382702589,
0.9371951222,
-0.1443762779,
-0.1454706639,
-0.7116677165,
0.4317448139,
0.260021925,
-0.2125632912,
0.3006978035,
0.7984595895,
0.3078815043,
0.2298183441,
0.3777567446,
0.1346459836,
-0.0418135524,
0.2339773774,
0.0145594133,
-0.3572981358,
-0.5895375609,
-0.6914927363,
0.3768416345,
0.053691607,
0.138955459
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11020v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11020v1 | RUPBench: Benchmarking Reasoning Under Perturbations for Robustness Evaluation in Large Language Models | 2024-06-16T17:26:44 | 2024-06-16T17:26:44 | Yuqing Wang, Yun Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL | With the increasing use of large language models (LLMs), ensuring reliable
performance in diverse, real-world environments is essential. Despite their
remarkable achievements, LLMs often struggle with adversarial inputs,
significantly impacting their effectiveness in practical applications. To
systematically understand the robustness of LLMs, we present RUPBench, a
comprehensive benchmark designed to evaluate LLM robustness across diverse
reasoning tasks. Our benchmark incorporates 15 reasoning datasets, categorized
into commonsense, arithmetic, logical, and knowledge-intensive reasoning, and
introduces nine types of textual perturbations at lexical, syntactic, and
semantic levels. By examining the performance of state-of-the-art LLMs such as
GPT-4o, Llama3, Phi-3, and Gemma on both original and perturbed datasets, we
provide a detailed analysis of their robustness and error patterns. Our
findings highlight that larger models tend to exhibit greater robustness to
perturbations. Additionally, common error types are identified through manual
inspection, revealing specific challenges faced by LLMs in different reasoning
contexts. This work provides insights into areas where LLMs need further
improvement to handle diverse and noisy inputs effectively. | [
-0.2397341281,
-1.0102756023,
0.6822835207,
0.2241910994,
-0.0185008161,
-0.0636541769,
-0.3100273907,
-0.2006951421,
-0.4072684944,
0.4406892359,
-0.4311669171,
-0.627509892,
-0.7996467352,
0.1229179278,
-0.4404576123,
0.6568223238,
-0.0127156312,
0.2812670171,
-0.3937658668,
-0.2612270117,
-0.4424393177,
-0.5754164457,
-0.0609099977,
-0.5408809781,
0.5003277063,
0.3515779078,
0.8107815981,
0.5115749836,
0.6682676673,
0.3421832025,
-0.1568832397,
-0.0149977421,
-0.4382932186,
0.6642514467,
-0.3359870911,
-0.5360936522,
-0.3001049459,
-0.1720934659,
0.7929589152,
0.6934424639,
-0.23902376,
0.1468466073,
0.1612944305,
0.3487335742,
-0.8894541264,
0.0361397155,
-0.8474293947,
-0.0938489512,
-0.4096526206,
0.0561997481,
-0.4778817892,
-0.1720969081,
-0.1489292532,
-0.3443055749,
-0.0349765345,
-0.1757948548,
0.969553411,
0.6528235078,
-0.1854052991,
0.021661235,
-0.54565835,
0.9588093162,
-0.789544642,
0.5448082685,
0.3013084233,
0.4083436728,
-0.670509994,
-0.9086746573,
-0.3800585866,
-0.3689483106,
-0.0408859327,
-0.0306752976,
-0.3455404937,
-0.0543439239,
0.5746304393,
0.1967622787,
-0.6503999233,
0.2419350296,
0.3929927349,
-0.2344850302,
0.2653941512,
0.258728534,
0.2210766375,
-0.0409066789,
-0.2058299631,
-0.4569937587,
-0.6930395365,
-0.1181603298,
0.5238552094,
0.1158789769,
0.0320394821,
0.5269731879,
-0.2428273559,
0.8509491086,
-0.2696857452,
-0.2424983233,
-0.0129324878,
-0.2510145903,
-0.2177909315,
-0.5181075335,
0.7877568603,
0.1540769786,
0.2114907503,
-0.0870224759,
-0.2923026085,
0.1868065894,
0.0323081501,
-0.6112263799,
-0.3080362678,
0.1350344121,
-0.183440432,
-0.3170659542,
-0.0738193095,
-1.0707895756,
-0.6464275122,
-0.0229422338,
0.1646315008,
-0.2924945951,
-0.0310077742,
0.2072673738,
0.0498823561,
0.135326609,
0.3681305051,
-0.7141648531,
0.3673163354,
0.7980113029,
0.3507477343,
-0.1388344616,
-0.4725409448,
-0.8680122495,
-0.0085793398,
-0.1526048928,
0.9814741611,
-0.7923768163,
-0.2104521543,
-0.1334902793,
-0.2784435451,
-0.1114736572,
-0.6027849913,
0.9075067043,
-0.4377906024,
0.0033395076,
-0.2993915677,
-0.3751093149,
0.034326449,
0.5230724812,
-0.6627613902,
1.081682682,
0.0314474441,
-0.9412041306,
0.4124785066,
-0.2554914653,
-0.4642845988,
-0.029788537,
-0.3364583552,
-0.4230188131,
0.1059014946,
0.3246113062,
0.2914453447,
-0.6331599355,
0.2077679634,
-0.7753549218,
-0.3244405985,
0.6752640009,
-0.5877749324,
0.786011517,
0.0997094959,
-0.3593703508,
0.3626574278,
-0.8965418339,
0.1829512119,
0.1825224459,
-0.3604564667,
-0.1225939468,
0.2380442321,
-0.1184320524,
0.0831309855,
0.0371718332,
-0.2032983005,
0.073428914,
-0.1346372515,
0.5113970041,
0.731395483,
-0.1556791365,
-0.0794950947,
-0.2381352037,
0.6869236231,
-0.1657422036,
-0.0698686838,
-0.1171865612,
-0.2446879297,
-0.7025021911,
-0.3467351794,
0.6003835201,
0.7186036706,
-0.2556413114,
0.3896340132,
-0.2757510841,
-0.3968242109,
-0.1644593477,
0.2784357369,
0.2539332807,
0.4796686471,
0.2504475415,
-0.0367951617,
-0.4336078465,
-0.869668901,
-0.6406953931,
-0.1396760792,
-0.0362156853,
0.12889494,
0.5192489028,
-0.2582440972,
0.4790655673,
-0.1599446982,
0.0555025451,
-0.3302561343,
0.1202962995,
0.0705811232,
0.2282622606,
0.267632544,
-0.3992967308,
-0.1791928262,
-0.0857609957,
-0.6010404825,
-0.4284427166,
-0.1221679151,
0.0168197565,
0.3354532421,
0.4843335152,
-0.6084742546,
0.4302482605,
0.7732294798,
-0.295476824,
0.6772920489,
0.0125747286,
-0.0163487066,
-0.6601352096,
0.1645973474,
-0.0673548356,
-0.260972023,
-0.1419326663,
0.3945442438,
-0.0770465285,
0.0493050329,
-0.0370180793,
0.2592509985,
-0.359115541,
-0.1905435622,
-0.0062350756,
0.2932550907,
0.0088132778,
0.0520564765,
-0.165762797,
0.6737003326,
0.5655853748,
-0.2967130244,
0.5684283376,
0.0149867889,
-0.4378140569,
0.4041375816,
-0.6618041992,
0.2183237225,
0.1542682201,
0.429754287,
-0.9323232174,
-0.3965332806,
0.0035517684,
-0.4009904265,
0.1975792944,
-0.2852220237,
-0.8545899987,
0.0311943721,
-0.1731397659,
0.2397714704,
0.2543305755,
-0.5329481363,
0.8118805885,
0.2568381727,
-0.0964780152,
-0.837677002,
-0.6409202814,
0.2016103268,
-0.3656021357,
-0.7989700437,
-0.1239119619,
0.070415847,
-0.5847181678,
-0.0889646485,
-0.2811442614,
0.0776431486,
0.3806807399,
0.1463770568,
0.1680032015,
-0.0974807292,
-0.1341216415,
-0.2623082995,
-0.2233702838,
0.1634883136,
0.0213022754,
0.7044882178,
-0.419826895,
-0.6264454126,
-0.1803381741,
0.0866649225,
0.6485438347,
-0.2809164822,
0.4779214859,
0.498066783,
-0.3089629114,
-0.5351939201,
-0.6669892669,
-0.2571815252,
-0.4405993223,
0.4271788597,
-0.5569811463,
-0.8225948811,
0.7076648474,
-0.1079660058,
-0.0223479681,
0.2685241699,
0.6381917,
0.0383062288,
0.8908031583,
0.203556031,
-0.0142320953,
0.1939599216,
0.1538772881,
0.050147526,
-0.440859288,
-0.0558732189,
-0.7872219682,
-0.1981941164,
-0.5741906166,
-0.5533242822,
0.1585616767,
0.1194949299,
-0.2400591224,
0.2054695189,
-0.1346527487,
0.5270696282,
0.421813637,
-0.3273713887,
0.4891058505,
0.0536204539,
-0.4639620483,
-0.1496320218,
-0.7393203974,
-0.7100462317,
1.0223478079,
0.4013745189,
1.1048105955,
0.1746117324,
0.3700152338,
-0.0691405758,
0.2019280493,
-0.5645514727,
0.6978273392,
-0.1393226534,
-0.5817649364,
-0.1499637961,
-0.6396323442,
-0.8615548015,
0.4719863236,
-0.3986565471,
-0.9906862974,
0.0939404517,
0.1337327063,
-0.0609719828,
0.3634311557,
-0.4623790085,
1.0251480341,
-0.3619966805,
-0.6571295857,
-0.3275120556,
-0.5161843896,
0.3710741103,
0.0698587224,
0.1610880196,
-0.1052302048,
-0.0702050626,
0.1813264936,
-0.2044133991,
0.6503760815,
0.1769164503,
-0.1537799537,
0.1048725843,
0.450437516,
0.6726720333,
0.1770960987,
-0.1371371299,
0.2891295552,
0.1499470621,
-0.3773335218,
-0.5947637558,
0.8836077452,
-0.603566587,
-0.6175433397,
-0.6258816719,
-0.6883208156,
-0.6702163219,
0.2730615139,
0.3277598321,
0.4207176268,
-0.1809943616,
0.4281032085,
0.6921830773,
-0.2491132021,
0.2141513973,
0.4656466544,
-0.2173330337,
-0.4038639069,
0.58894068,
0.0146017885,
0.3282214105,
0.34099406,
0.2183086127,
-0.2390627414,
-0.8192313313,
-0.3653817177,
0.0163560901,
-0.9630349278,
-0.1376480311,
-0.3726193607,
0.1316074431,
-0.2918492258,
0.18537651,
-0.3412999511,
-0.3770709336,
0.0019926012,
-0.0105612008,
-0.0562608875,
0.6238083839,
0.0549311191,
-0.0549900159,
-0.6287113428,
0.1784577072,
0.2860492766,
0.6419565082,
-0.2005293071,
-0.4541567564,
0.1723646969,
-0.292650342,
-0.2654411793,
-0.8083353043,
-0.070134148,
-0.0551833138,
0.7695773244,
0.2630233765,
0.0345029235,
0.6028282642,
-0.1504549235,
0.5470494032,
-0.1418917328,
-0.9346678853,
0.4230405092,
-0.6063039303,
0.3860318065,
0.6096086502,
-0.0131193902,
-0.2627593875,
-0.3435449302,
-0.5355603099,
-0.8618891239,
0.4189946949,
0.0259733722,
-0.19275181,
0.2004349083,
0.1679950058,
0.0415343679,
-0.0955409631,
-0.8767594099,
0.0045561749,
-0.1051806509,
-0.0460397676,
0.1926637888,
-0.3102888763,
-0.3378745914,
-0.0777641162,
0.6054822206,
-0.120809406,
-0.2391106784,
-0.0564066358,
-0.227733627,
-0.1724404395,
0.4944465756,
0.5273397565,
0.8479973078,
0.007211356,
0.2772632241,
0.4851713777,
-0.2540077567,
-0.0752315745,
0.3241893351,
-0.160114333,
-0.2958387434,
0.6231490374,
0.5735298991,
0.2013899684,
-1.069819808,
0.3481514752,
-0.2736570239,
-0.0443053208,
-0.2640090585,
0.1830411106,
0.1305349767,
0.1120762974,
0.0001798862,
0.0331043974,
0.0463618971,
-0.4340508878,
0.0794417188,
0.5552155375,
-0.0699639916,
-0.0985413715,
0.5442230701,
-0.0175261851,
0.0065099946,
0.5921517611,
0.0674613118,
-0.3935094774,
0.2746316493,
0.4866279364,
0.7196187973,
0.0198220927,
-0.243443504,
0.2359449714,
0.5396262407,
-0.1256522089,
0.1518803984,
0.1581047773,
-0.78420192,
-0.7289057374,
-0.4652462304,
-0.67156142,
0.4633238614,
-0.63276124,
0.2518386543,
-0.7525008917,
-0.2040352523,
-0.0591171384,
-0.0829945952,
-0.4244453907,
0.0384601206,
0.0903901979,
0.9379347563,
-0.6316483021,
0.6833924055,
1.0118155479,
-0.1744285822,
-0.8595948815,
0.2241122127,
0.2906140387,
-0.5695854425,
0.3250049055,
-0.0698423386,
-0.4337583184,
-0.3927390873,
-0.5409716964,
-0.8018716574,
0.7980356812,
0.8309784532,
-0.7154480815,
0.4239044785,
0.1878232658,
0.5111906528,
-0.0526394546,
0.2062105387,
0.8826126456,
0.7275770903,
0.014677532,
-0.7482287288,
0.128721714,
-0.1858232617,
-0.1568811387,
0.1474706382,
-0.6366826296,
0.5957792401,
-0.0484929495,
-0.1863407195,
0.2747346759,
0.462962687,
0.5582429171,
-0.1033939719,
0.5758835673,
0.9792708755,
0.7699638605,
-0.5011681318,
1.1475288868,
-0.2705522478,
0.1476981491,
1.2706817389,
-0.4545915723,
0.9184243083,
0.3071330488,
-0.3277820349,
0.631916225,
0.3865807056,
-0.1393990219,
-0.0145734986,
0.4005689025,
-0.1533883959,
-0.6725290418,
0.1929763705,
-0.2305994481,
0.5206598639,
0.3833390474,
0.0134179639,
-0.3478959501,
-0.482711792,
0.0499697961,
0.3258469701,
0.1574393809,
0.5969772339,
-0.0165860448,
-0.7737622261,
0.5933977962,
0.0511545539,
0.4233635366,
-0.7057554722,
-0.0543817244,
-0.2032728642,
0.5962190628,
-0.3200564682,
-0.7983899713,
0.117532976,
0.071385406,
0.0340237617,
-0.0745554194,
0.8923876286,
-0.0619243011,
-0.4217265844,
0.4804222584,
0.3567398787,
-0.005028212,
0.1067181677,
-0.7293127775,
0.6366741061,
-0.101177603,
-0.3143910468,
0.5591425896,
0.4695231616,
-0.0688228011,
0.934787631,
0.5654610991,
0.1983967721,
-0.0031958779,
0.3024570346,
0.8367338181,
-0.5555649996,
-0.0963089094,
-0.9077418447,
0.4291675687,
-0.0335814804,
-0.4784473777,
0.9731371403,
0.3396644592,
0.7334976792,
0.2260443121,
0.7424868345,
0.1191455424,
0.4951560199,
-0.4275370538,
0.4319672585,
-0.2804118395,
0.6674140692,
-0.4247375429,
-1.0058676004,
-0.5530300736,
0.8422468305,
-0.3568110764,
0.1367781311,
0.6389371157,
0.7951816916,
0.0391641483,
0.1011413857,
0.2816416919,
0.4098086953,
0.3185790777,
0.3219601214,
1.0803979635,
-0.0787590072,
0.8340593576,
-0.1751468331,
-0.2213749886,
-0.0317519009,
-1.2300871611,
-0.8464692235,
-0.1704460084,
-0.2811986804,
-0.6478398442,
0.1235152557,
0.5741479397,
0.5552231669,
-0.9204159975,
-0.2894707918,
-0.2419794947,
0.2886633873,
-0.1859458238,
-0.2106058598,
0.1008430421,
-0.4741411507,
-0.5321806073,
0.5952996612,
0.1704232097,
-0.234121725,
-0.4353356659,
0.1565963179,
-0.0162628442,
0.0552701317,
0.2948467135,
0.1957242489,
-0.7761570215,
-0.3074311316,
-0.1701489538,
-0.0095711173,
-0.0555792041,
0.7519104481,
-0.6782209277,
0.3142362833,
0.7020900846,
0.7079508305,
0.4070270658,
0.0765342489,
0.5744280219,
-0.4114536345,
0.0772477239,
0.3303470314,
0.6337141395,
0.4787958264,
0.0609673299,
0.5668040514,
0.1615368575,
-0.7414190769,
-1.0843676329,
0.4023710787,
-0.9163438678,
-0.3336697519,
1.2626372576,
-0.31965819,
0.0001388076,
-0.0797004104,
0.0573419482,
-0.189789623,
-0.2128973901,
0.6182668805,
1.1109575033,
-0.0735614598,
-0.2864494324,
-0.5545440912,
0.1906567514,
0.761600256,
-0.7772965431,
0.4175984561,
0.8113524318,
0.6359314919,
-0.0309160035,
0.088038981,
-0.4128103852,
0.2626708448,
0.2691341043,
-0.2304935008,
-0.0156373661,
-0.2482393086,
-0.4397397935,
0.3765490651,
0.4522869885,
0.323767364
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11016v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11016v1 | Optimized Speculative Sampling for GPU Hardware Accelerators | 2024-06-16T17:19:23 | 2024-06-16T17:19:23 | Dominik Wagner, Seanie Lee, Ilja Baumann, Philipp Seeberger, Korbinian Riedhammer, Tobias Bocklet | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | In this work, we optimize speculative sampling for parallel hardware
accelerators to improve sampling speed. We notice that substantial portions of
the intermediate matrices necessary for speculative sampling can be computed
concurrently. This allows us to distribute the workload across multiple GPU
threads, enabling simultaneous operations on matrix segments within thread
blocks. Additionally, we use fast on-chip memory to store intermediate results,
thereby minimizing the frequency of slow read and write operations across
different types of memory. This results in profiling time improvements ranging
from 6% to 13% relative to the baseline implementation, without compromising
accuracy. To further accelerate speculative sampling, probability distributions
parameterized by softmax are approximated by sigmoid. This approximation
approach results in significantly greater relative improvements in profiling
time, ranging from 37% to 94%, with a slight decline in accuracy. We conduct
extensive experiments on both automatic speech recognition and summarization
tasks to validate the effectiveness of our optimization methods. | [
-0.6984532475,
-1.0324518681,
0.7315135598,
0.1198373139,
-0.2630893588,
0.3857552409,
-0.2118841708,
-0.3859548569,
0.2840053439,
-0.0719060227,
-0.374065727,
-0.1279894114,
-0.4245093763,
-0.2480850518,
-0.2211512178,
0.7299087644,
-0.0439277403,
-0.2669922113,
-0.1503127664,
-0.0022293979,
-0.1589922011,
-0.2316530794,
-0.7467433214,
-0.0521440245,
0.3157089949,
0.3887561262,
0.3958325982,
0.7703949809,
0.4816859066,
0.31207183,
-0.1114172265,
0.0888697505,
-0.56474334,
0.0846929699,
0.3293374777,
-0.3275202215,
-0.5419874787,
0.0922516882,
0.9378506541,
0.4583638906,
-0.4594312906,
0.6766466498,
-0.048656214,
0.2064366043,
-0.9842653275,
0.0658319369,
-0.3489708602,
0.2720914185,
-0.6954120994,
-0.6014495492,
-0.368290484,
-0.5671001077,
-0.2755691111,
-0.8481423259,
0.8277949095,
0.1866409034,
0.2407680601,
0.3041197658,
0.2919766307,
0.3285696507,
-1.0411318541,
0.7856476903,
-0.3929248154,
0.0226036496,
0.2010314465,
0.4332089722,
0.1095259637,
-0.816670537,
-0.3931843042,
-0.0727496669,
0.2197238505,
0.1125582829,
-0.204632923,
0.2055072486,
0.6395120621,
0.3510411978,
-0.7072069645,
0.0128027936,
-0.7268194556,
-0.3559212685,
0.5250509381,
0.3353406787,
-0.0793034285,
0.4353621006,
-0.2824624777,
-0.2346802056,
-0.672922492,
0.0289234407,
0.6314371228,
0.0661526844,
0.0110640815,
0.2573046088,
-0.1051766798,
0.6079841852,
0.1015040204,
-0.110763289,
0.3224821985,
-0.4350961745,
-0.2179842889,
0.1969886422,
0.6956223249,
0.1834308058,
-0.2132944316,
-0.1319035292,
-0.1209337413,
0.1531044394,
0.4154385328,
-1.1107026339,
-0.1097324789,
0.437917769,
-0.3606489003,
-0.0427798405,
-0.1843725592,
-1.1859002113,
-0.0987924784,
-0.1083303839,
0.0257616639,
-0.1759487689,
0.0057799825,
-0.030326305,
-0.5277340412,
-0.1485439837,
0.096159488,
-1.0720601082,
0.7640548348,
0.7760258913,
0.8148983121,
-0.3574627936,
-0.0098720556,
-0.9348227382,
0.2444304675,
-0.3411901593,
0.9802642465,
-0.7749958038,
-0.7914981842,
-0.3686652184,
-0.3886155188,
-0.1129771173,
-0.5580224395,
0.7466180921,
-0.1787558049,
-0.3819953203,
-0.3103384972,
-0.3625323474,
0.1298385561,
-0.0961346775,
-0.6138527393,
1.2597367764,
-0.0517871864,
-0.6963560581,
0.4187036455,
-0.393081665,
-0.3892124593,
0.2112702429,
-0.4181104898,
-0.3030135036,
0.5620344877,
0.3642449081,
0.3027591109,
-0.2553068399,
-0.0485267006,
-0.421384573,
-1.110999465,
0.0493627451,
-0.3284907937,
0.2981202006,
0.4822687805,
-0.353402555,
0.3030073345,
-0.3981083035,
0.0082800984,
-0.1661496609,
-0.0600844137,
-0.0350635648,
-0.0830357522,
0.1047927737,
-0.2589662671,
0.083373338,
-0.828174293,
0.1453251988,
-0.1400168389,
0.2860886157,
1.0112247467,
-0.1995862275,
0.2726267278,
-0.2473649085,
0.780410707,
-0.2526049018,
0.4243687391,
0.084349297,
-0.7208898664,
-0.2720423341,
-0.2956252098,
0.1323305219,
0.6572300792,
-0.7648742199,
-0.1668052077,
0.0802334026,
-0.5182564855,
-0.5482876301,
0.1442199349,
0.631573379,
0.6693279743,
0.3191510737,
-0.4053997099,
-0.4314241409,
-0.9077733755,
-0.2186511606,
-0.1963536292,
0.0598457716,
0.5940233469,
-0.0179660171,
0.1106843054,
0.5076999664,
-0.8706535101,
0.1549688876,
-0.1453600526,
0.3849077225,
0.4987078607,
0.5730646849,
0.7281208634,
-0.4560933411,
-0.3035595119,
-0.2731715739,
-0.4335721433,
0.0960921869,
0.1564266533,
-0.0998802334,
-0.1860847473,
0.723775506,
-0.5731617212,
0.4883328378,
0.1831752807,
0.1911579818,
0.5892956257,
-0.548830688,
0.331205219,
-0.796749711,
0.1808816791,
0.1696053594,
-0.0521456636,
-0.5608472824,
0.1669492871,
-0.098003976,
-0.0406579599,
-0.4839929044,
0.3790783584,
-0.2804555595,
-0.1985450089,
-0.4796513021,
-0.0649715811,
-0.3302689195,
0.289242357,
-0.1938575357,
1.4010583162,
0.6606914401,
-0.5860797167,
0.2400044054,
-0.2279188037,
-0.1816849858,
0.2052033246,
-0.7895281315,
0.517237246,
-0.4551662207,
0.2556378543,
-0.9271733165,
0.0731060207,
0.1570943892,
-0.3729581237,
0.4832520485,
-0.0916977227,
-0.6039574146,
-0.5847349167,
-0.5304266214,
0.8311521411,
0.7460635304,
-0.253993094,
0.7171815038,
0.8853260279,
-0.4587662816,
-0.8802161217,
-0.671548903,
-0.3773132563,
-0.0650337264,
-0.2959645689,
0.5623832941,
-0.2144614756,
-0.339800626,
-0.1352514029,
0.1749509722,
0.0639576912,
0.0180506669,
0.2718791366,
0.5779727697,
-0.3400013447,
-0.2016382962,
0.264886409,
-0.3362645209,
-0.135319218,
-0.4545786381,
0.7471721768,
-0.1665174365,
-0.0115141058,
-0.4005479217,
0.3443768024,
0.0633585081,
0.2278580666,
0.1750265509,
1.2270709276,
-0.4382919371,
-0.0095457891,
-0.7168610096,
-0.3813571036,
-0.5609553456,
0.2430634797,
-0.4177210629,
-0.78209728,
0.484541744,
0.2941347063,
0.3013503253,
0.4290394485,
0.781583786,
0.0360917263,
1.0239177942,
0.5130481124,
-0.5031657815,
0.2951798439,
-0.145855397,
0.0369605981,
-0.8257446289,
0.0108839413,
-0.5690174103,
-0.6543818712,
-0.5294071436,
-0.8389089108,
0.3737994432,
-0.4140270948,
0.3221241534,
0.0564742908,
-0.5573833585,
0.5596053004,
0.7252457738,
0.0786793455,
-0.0690294504,
0.2932625413,
-0.3138084114,
-0.0642732456,
-0.6330689788,
-0.0512184948,
1.1537920237,
-0.0889214203,
0.8075826764,
-0.4541834593,
0.4618825018,
0.2130396813,
0.504966557,
-0.2746730447,
0.6701769233,
-0.2457037121,
-0.6635326147,
0.0036440587,
-0.4459925592,
-0.5671440363,
0.1091955602,
0.1177378818,
-0.9151423573,
0.3088026345,
0.4970386624,
-0.9080674648,
0.6028248072,
-0.6129686236,
0.4553415179,
0.3128939271,
-0.5825692415,
-0.5915023685,
-0.3503397703,
0.3742506206,
0.0860594884,
-0.1490569115,
-0.1581653953,
0.0200383682,
0.7810135484,
-0.2406445891,
0.4571790397,
-0.2939009666,
0.4194557965,
0.5031096339,
-0.171242848,
0.2725691497,
0.278029561,
-0.1959725767,
-0.0964252651,
-0.233042717,
-0.6155988574,
-0.1742366105,
0.8274080753,
-0.6259818077,
-0.4720311463,
-0.4688757956,
-0.8487504721,
-0.3948704898,
-0.2649042904,
0.2887254357,
0.5525372624,
-0.154031232,
-0.026546672,
0.6167342067,
-0.088541992,
0.6910708547,
0.0966093168,
0.1301092952,
-0.1180313602,
1.0363694429,
-0.221193254,
0.0615601577,
0.0848612785,
-0.00882472,
-0.2291792184,
-0.8077694774,
-0.5702943206,
0.2569676936,
-0.2655791044,
0.0962294713,
-0.7040336132,
0.0200535506,
-0.6432434916,
-0.0534420647,
-0.4422616959,
-0.5136979818,
-0.2912636399,
-0.1454722732,
0.2848034799,
0.1289515793,
-0.2424961627,
0.5101044178,
-0.6068868637,
0.4757184684,
0.0235021189,
0.054659646,
-0.1433984935,
-0.6060106158,
0.0077619115,
-0.2949644029,
-0.2823906243,
-0.2503117919,
0.3969767392,
0.1843914837,
0.859752357,
0.5931341052,
-0.3798918426,
1.1330897808,
-0.4880109429,
0.460700959,
-0.1269191653,
-0.5593165755,
0.4858229756,
-0.0867055431,
0.2993043959,
1.0523780584,
0.5635082722,
-0.1443194449,
-0.4886493683,
-0.6596134305,
-0.7200974822,
0.721137166,
0.2441225797,
0.0243622828,
0.2097129077,
0.4927063584,
0.0512208231,
0.1913477927,
0.4255823791,
-0.5607630014,
0.262396723,
-0.01613947,
-0.4745145142,
-0.3009421229,
-0.4269404709,
-0.4368415177,
0.6380268931,
-0.2059116811,
0.6176915169,
0.0235551614,
0.1224750653,
-0.0472184643,
0.0308182091,
0.7577003837,
0.8329796791,
-0.6525015235,
0.0913458541,
0.1334003359,
-1.2236720324,
-0.2403761297,
0.720893085,
-0.3276439309,
0.0706854761,
-0.4902494848,
0.8827320337,
-0.0182117019,
-0.7544229627,
0.1910713911,
-0.6644396186,
-0.0963682309,
-0.1665498465,
0.1862419546,
-0.0521228351,
0.1569260657,
0.5081045628,
0.442238003,
0.5993331075,
-0.3394000232,
0.3332924843,
0.3537528813,
-0.2173274457,
-0.3604057729,
0.9481342435,
-0.317009747,
0.0531076156,
0.8861899972,
-0.3048544526,
-0.1024070233,
0.6988820434,
0.4251209199,
0.8611927629,
-0.3493356407,
-0.0175088122,
0.5688994527,
0.2150104493,
-0.1028652266,
0.6227260828,
-0.4361651838,
-0.5029976368,
-0.5104517937,
-0.8380396962,
-0.7467566133,
-0.3077366352,
-0.7154347897,
0.0447914898,
-0.7955365181,
-0.5007821918,
0.1197010055,
-0.0480585881,
-0.5467717052,
-0.0249179062,
0.3387889266,
0.7688750625,
-0.6767752171,
0.9800083041,
0.1970961392,
0.0640179589,
-0.7726268172,
-0.5168612599,
0.131521523,
-0.7256163359,
0.2844892442,
0.0259868726,
-0.0084448606,
-0.0672994182,
-0.1049902067,
-0.6423698068,
1.0422773361,
0.3983701169,
-0.6299752593,
0.2126133293,
-0.0980263129,
0.2351671606,
-0.0260681696,
0.6985507607,
0.9072206616,
0.3357912898,
0.305262059,
-0.6865392327,
0.0598867387,
-0.682592988,
-0.1069734767,
0.278865695,
-0.5043895841,
1.1064442396,
-0.333874464,
-0.022478424,
0.1415885836,
0.8614043593,
0.8069633245,
0.3578840494,
0.5381342769,
0.6243134737,
0.9637491107,
-0.2370983213,
1.4363236427,
-0.6243688464,
0.0609233677,
0.952175498,
-0.2397737354,
0.7646960616,
0.5057398081,
-0.2144377828,
-0.0160755347,
0.6668762565,
-0.1103744209,
0.2452486306,
0.1751177907,
-0.6844439507,
0.0420135371,
-0.1023206487,
-0.5129790902,
0.0964779407,
0.4996012449,
-0.317345798,
-0.0412200615,
-0.0835646018,
0.0066610719,
-0.650054276,
-0.5435647368,
0.1902272701,
-0.0312208571,
-0.8068271279,
0.2837645411,
0.0921987444,
0.8298161626,
-0.3255809247,
0.1767522544,
-0.1331828982,
0.4557337761,
-0.0131734665,
-0.498457402,
0.2642045021,
-0.0820224285,
0.0855657756,
-0.3131999373,
0.9031495452,
-0.0746932104,
-0.8053559661,
-0.1709662527,
0.2010030746,
0.466773957,
-0.1500934213,
-0.4113138318,
0.3559986651,
-0.4167721868,
-0.0860549361,
0.4289439917,
-0.2589295208,
0.0948233604,
0.2916672826,
0.8461621404,
0.3777894974,
0.5010612607,
0.2146283388,
1.0015671253,
-0.4575822651,
-0.5691013932,
-0.7753570676,
-0.0382302776,
-0.2847155035,
-0.5474001169,
0.7503387928,
1.1439857483,
0.5614157915,
-0.0434993692,
0.5498042107,
0.0834344849,
0.3197326958,
-0.424380064,
0.5019539595,
-0.2342547178,
0.0304359496,
-0.2769222856,
-0.8390654922,
-0.1073931083,
0.2656076849,
-0.2574365735,
0.0585743971,
0.5578420758,
0.9684585333,
-0.2729178667,
0.367958039,
0.057407286,
0.1835076511,
0.2821466029,
0.6582202315,
0.4575555027,
-0.3942914605,
0.3683356047,
-0.5973732471,
-0.3428389728,
-0.1593386531,
-0.5432604551,
-0.4176821113,
-0.184301421,
-0.3709486127,
-0.3126577437,
0.2633780837,
0.3736431599,
0.9169800282,
-0.6952655315,
-0.4936654568,
0.1182395071,
-0.3829317093,
-0.3512859344,
-0.179134056,
0.2811627984,
-0.3450119197,
-0.9712744355,
0.6502313018,
0.5232697129,
-0.2038593739,
-0.212533623,
0.1499156356,
0.0972175077,
0.1538467109,
0.3064617813,
0.6608741283,
-0.217539832,
0.0609414205,
0.062618427,
0.0642737299,
0.1962565929,
1.3288161755,
-1.1129741669,
0.4244507253,
0.8639137149,
0.749104023,
1.3408999443,
0.2238755822,
0.4450381994,
-0.5982759595,
0.6243991852,
0.4561508894,
0.4289849699,
-0.0251067448,
-0.3587915897,
0.2520956099,
0.4411340952,
-0.4655370414,
-0.8326529264,
-0.3684749901,
-1.3866223097,
-0.0522539616,
0.8777915239,
-0.0229700748,
-0.6317157745,
-0.0282336585,
0.0365833677,
0.1848021001,
-0.5530589223,
0.586314559,
0.1424739808,
-0.5147337317,
0.0267082434,
-0.9446383119,
0.562646687,
0.4121814668,
-0.8065325618,
-0.2400079966,
0.3397021592,
0.1420608163,
0.1334845275,
1.0887573957,
-0.2132116705,
0.6402705908,
0.2425714731,
-0.1595445275,
0.066373162,
-0.3060980439,
-0.0168009959,
0.6083108187,
-0.4136812985,
-0.2302073985
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11012v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11012v3 | Connecting the Dots: Evaluating Abstract Reasoning Capabilities of LLMs Using the New York Times Connections Word Game | 2024-06-16T17:10:32 | 2024-06-22T15:40:14 | Prisha Samadarshi, Mariam Mustafa, Anushka Kulkarni, Raven Rothkopf, Tuhin Chakrabarty, Smaranda Muresan | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The New York Times Connections game has emerged as a popular and challenging
pursuit for word puzzle enthusiasts. We collect 200 Connections games to
evaluate the performance of state-of-the-art large language models (LLMs)
against expert and novice human players. Our results show that even the
best-performing LLM, GPT-4o, which has otherwise shown impressive reasoning
abilities on a wide variety of benchmarks, can only fully solve 8% of the
games. Compared to GPT-4o, novice and expert players perform better, with
expert human players significantly outperforming GPT-4o. To deepen our
understanding we create a taxonomy of the knowledge types required to
successfully categorize words in the Connections game, revealing that LLMs
struggle with associative, encyclopedic, and linguistic knowledge. Our findings
establish the New York Times Connections game as a challenging benchmark for
evaluating abstract reasoning capabilities in humans and AI systems. | [
-0.3957364559,
-0.9535313845,
1.0459669828,
0.0145747997,
-0.2152581364,
0.4644643068,
-0.0364094116,
-0.7716236711,
0.0427584462,
0.3504739702,
-0.4365972579,
-0.4895687103,
-0.6086264849,
0.4937179089,
-0.3355938494,
0.6229938865,
-0.0533108041,
-0.1995043606,
-0.740868628,
0.0163633302,
-0.51202631,
-0.339600414,
-0.9014164209,
-0.5492669344,
0.5357795358,
0.3357785046,
0.6400682926,
0.6727738976,
0.6208729148,
0.4650016427,
-0.3302234411,
0.4190514982,
-0.5537087917,
-0.0217808001,
-0.3569536209,
-0.7179890275,
-0.3466474712,
0.0161817819,
0.2086249292,
0.8396491408,
0.1814894825,
0.3027890623,
-0.2767972648,
0.9076477885,
-0.2775554657,
0.2029190361,
-0.8316568732,
0.0225072168,
-0.2391712517,
-0.4283140004,
-0.3019708097,
-0.5929583907,
0.5290752649,
-1.0479179621,
0.1535298079,
0.2182314098,
0.9805854559,
0.1888395101,
-0.7232589126,
-0.4589917958,
-0.698278904,
0.2677393556,
-0.4672291279,
-0.0737625957,
0.4376329184,
0.5287459493,
-0.3692936301,
-0.5459901094,
-0.6738234758,
-0.3151186109,
0.3313754797,
0.0025008623,
-0.4252641201,
0.1110028625,
0.3921284974,
0.2550254166,
-0.3538756669,
-0.0709046274,
-0.6078629494,
-0.0734068751,
0.8004204035,
0.3141673803,
0.1765820533,
0.1522192806,
-0.3281770051,
0.334228009,
-0.7945088744,
0.4589300454,
0.4395954609,
-0.2154383063,
-0.0632433891,
0.8029783964,
-0.1511633098,
0.9357357025,
0.2367184013,
-0.12402457,
-0.0253824461,
-0.2157388777,
0.22332865,
-0.1143753082,
0.5800606608,
0.578448236,
0.5107482672,
-0.4207921922,
0.0177063141,
0.1804603785,
0.0777049437,
-0.2848610282,
-0.4305657744,
0.0134422611,
-0.3255530596,
0.1229999438,
-0.387031883,
-0.3911251724,
-0.6648440361,
-0.2957315445,
0.7407208085,
-0.6263322234,
-0.0903442353,
0.3093418777,
-0.2632828951,
0.1259503514,
0.361530304,
-0.8690487742,
0.237872377,
0.6550371647,
0.7826641202,
-0.2214963287,
-0.2230696827,
-0.1660909951,
0.1350072175,
-0.4834589064,
1.2276190519,
-0.5068135858,
-0.2831601501,
-0.088200748,
-0.3491701782,
0.0215891805,
-0.3450636566,
0.5080643892,
-0.7918727994,
-0.0184383392,
-0.544916749,
-1.126024127,
-0.154622674,
0.5361881852,
-0.5571235418,
0.5159247518,
-0.1574758887,
-0.7368210554,
0.1688699424,
-0.5910331607,
-0.3928783834,
0.1718738377,
-0.2075193226,
0.2542172074,
0.2327083647,
-0.0036411148,
0.1471867263,
-0.3767706454,
-0.1431004852,
-0.3718679249,
-0.5627583861,
0.477842927,
-0.0090731159,
0.6366784573,
0.0201495159,
-0.0441007279,
0.0981888846,
-0.5954898,
-0.1562316716,
0.0948943049,
-0.3784776032,
-0.4272892475,
0.288857013,
-0.8114808202,
0.2865573168,
0.1968363822,
-0.5981074572,
0.1255736351,
-0.3913509846,
0.6850582957,
0.7787429094,
-0.014264809,
0.2402733415,
-0.2322606295,
0.4919961989,
-0.0026747463,
0.0754139125,
-0.2657041848,
-0.8677521348,
-0.8077609539,
0.223015368,
0.3110370934,
0.6107285619,
-1.3353455067,
0.5066950917,
-0.4768984318,
-0.6359894872,
-0.3749400377,
-0.2450699061,
0.2606277764,
0.7130802274,
0.2614122033,
-0.0706714243,
-0.0312390644,
-0.90145576,
-0.5384427309,
-0.4017448425,
-0.0783799067,
0.6977789402,
0.5359141827,
0.1389345974,
1.0987149477,
-0.475936383,
-0.0717866868,
0.1177561209,
0.1100311652,
0.06589064,
0.0088489782,
0.261410296,
-0.2913078964,
-0.3583539426,
-0.0070144054,
-0.9127738476,
0.0184710417,
0.1993533969,
0.064136602,
0.0015537816,
0.6822524667,
-0.7206747532,
0.0906242803,
0.6600627899,
-1.0930281878,
0.6652715206,
-0.3563250303,
0.3318725824,
-0.8355110288,
0.070995979,
0.1269800365,
0.08402206,
-0.4278125763,
-0.1169526204,
-0.2444764376,
-0.1702525914,
-0.2055801153,
0.3653002083,
-0.7890191674,
-0.2518722713,
-0.0201926995,
0.5396437049,
0.0840931609,
0.1779548824,
-0.2391331643,
0.9037255049,
0.6695449352,
-0.5579814911,
0.6515138149,
0.2513706088,
-0.745606184,
0.3058304191,
-0.825906992,
0.1728625447,
0.0014383195,
0.1695863605,
-1.1810647249,
0.080739215,
-0.3227575421,
-0.4751011133,
-0.157784,
0.1677598059,
-0.4619141817,
-0.3926551938,
0.0324039049,
0.6471865773,
0.3055145741,
-0.2286175638,
0.4453829229,
0.5724042058,
-0.0412986912,
-0.3370223641,
-0.6142448783,
0.4804782271,
-0.1766314358,
-0.8846087456,
0.2477443814,
-0.0358607247,
-0.1998384148,
0.0887795761,
-0.0419438109,
-0.1071137711,
0.1284568906,
-0.2142584026,
0.0919917598,
-0.1500380486,
0.1085279286,
-0.1307597458,
-0.2528100014,
0.4275892973,
0.0689458027,
0.2109057307,
-0.1047420502,
-0.6183149815,
-0.1692617238,
0.2701389492,
0.4705148041,
-0.1471660435,
0.3094803989,
0.1891202629,
-0.1364420354,
-0.0209858268,
-0.7962108254,
-0.1779471785,
-0.4568678141,
0.4245996773,
-0.6115631461,
-1.4337793589,
0.7103981376,
-0.3018009663,
-0.1364961416,
0.2842928469,
-0.0152358394,
0.0116710924,
1.0617229939,
0.5002112985,
-0.0442150272,
-0.1060919389,
0.1521050781,
0.3855865002,
-0.5425385237,
-0.3383964002,
-0.4040398002,
-0.3951322734,
-0.5081998706,
-0.6061257124,
0.5164846182,
0.2374180853,
-0.2684566081,
0.2580678761,
-0.4101029038,
0.8239073157,
0.4581369758,
0.1098526493,
0.7721459866,
0.0009562257,
-0.242086485,
-0.1060089469,
-0.7217903137,
-0.4103820324,
1.0622774363,
0.3639413416,
0.3952337205,
0.3242481649,
0.2671259344,
0.3449729681,
0.0030782488,
-0.8095531464,
0.8667930961,
0.0227480549,
-0.5877737403,
-0.2529136837,
-0.6892358065,
-1.1013200283,
-0.1622553915,
-0.5418384671,
-0.7208571434,
0.0030065819,
-0.095590502,
-0.4582927823,
0.4860857427,
-0.7584041357,
0.5484148264,
0.0103463335,
-0.177072078,
-0.4238391519,
-0.5067751408,
0.7903251052,
0.1270166487,
0.1296736449,
-0.3279058635,
-0.3534861207,
0.6059232354,
-0.0989333019,
0.4695997536,
0.2238769829,
-0.1823791862,
0.3790945113,
0.2132806033,
0.2566072345,
-0.0978863537,
0.0644317716,
0.4690350294,
-0.1367923766,
-0.3191108108,
-0.6085086465,
0.5947694182,
-0.7493174076,
-0.7671467662,
-0.4711236656,
-0.5875782371,
-0.5056768656,
0.2563932836,
0.2403324246,
0.3020147085,
-0.154407531,
-0.0011746726,
0.6921958923,
-0.2305656672,
0.4435097873,
0.6654807329,
0.0211522914,
-0.3609572947,
0.871163547,
0.1310396045,
0.1797153652,
0.3233709037,
0.0475196652,
-0.463606149,
-0.8677976131,
-0.3228557408,
0.2738327086,
-0.6173938513,
-0.1545160413,
-0.3182743788,
-0.1740106195,
-0.0062029297,
0.1608196944,
-0.099532783,
-0.3297071457,
0.1283154488,
-0.0499602146,
0.3510454595,
0.9742347002,
0.1640227884,
0.0442855097,
-0.8819941878,
0.08974085,
0.7698786855,
0.6755139232,
-0.097746931,
-0.2400334328,
-0.3369998634,
-0.271358937,
-0.2291671634,
-1.0014874935,
-0.2432506531,
-0.0361901596,
0.5162215829,
0.63737005,
-0.0168465897,
0.7387875319,
-0.7656048536,
1.061447382,
0.3136896491,
-1.0458558798,
0.2436359376,
-0.683409512,
0.2368712574,
0.4554649591,
0.2371788621,
-0.3851304352,
-0.2331917435,
-0.5966681838,
-0.5558165312,
0.6323478818,
0.3137474656,
-0.2575208545,
-0.3625148535,
0.540128231,
-0.1902767569,
0.2308949083,
-0.528935194,
-0.5435581803,
0.3533071578,
0.1322461516,
-0.1255358458,
-0.4241300523,
-0.1465821415,
-0.3428558707,
0.2811212838,
0.0144074159,
0.3375775516,
0.1715690792,
0.1725576669,
-0.0629501268,
-0.0649878383,
0.7613761425,
1.0959254503,
0.1614471674,
0.3414482474,
0.1499090493,
-0.4326536655,
0.1816824079,
0.2285985202,
-0.2249217331,
-0.013703688,
0.7144507766,
0.6416996121,
0.1755501777,
-0.7071340084,
0.3957906961,
-0.2023421675,
-0.4548819065,
-0.1161264703,
0.1940216124,
0.5099452138,
0.4025613368,
0.504984796,
0.1850473285,
0.1202823296,
-0.4030729234,
0.0506815016,
0.4869305193,
-0.2169014961,
-0.41603297,
0.4939729273,
0.6082106233,
-0.5374431014,
0.3129479587,
-0.4019004107,
-0.3165929615,
0.5300909281,
0.4408343136,
0.5454176068,
-0.1031129211,
0.0833279639,
0.3547746241,
0.4212308824,
-0.0965215638,
0.0959956273,
-0.006742409,
-0.9446908236,
-0.9139729142,
-0.0814600959,
-0.3565230072,
0.1452618837,
-0.2124668062,
0.0309637077,
-0.3035227358,
-0.3832064271,
-0.1348744333,
0.3137442172,
-0.4689230323,
-0.3057408929,
0.2054823786,
1.2974870205,
-0.9489985108,
0.4429322481,
0.9807097912,
-0.3444240093,
-0.7095986605,
-0.1539874822,
0.0149952536,
-0.6724358797,
0.4856667817,
-0.0109727383,
-0.048574321,
0.2053329647,
-0.3576815128,
-1.0575829744,
1.2689887285,
0.5254240632,
-0.4169601798,
-0.0356854722,
0.2620846927,
0.4767239988,
-0.2959913015,
0.5316258669,
0.6638874412,
0.3416873813,
0.1184299886,
-0.9267857671,
-0.0315533914,
-0.3119024336,
-0.0685688034,
0.0419419445,
-0.5163844824,
0.8201031089,
-0.2133066058,
-0.404576838,
-0.0940210223,
0.8105300665,
0.6706697941,
0.3444952667,
0.8176068664,
0.7634308338,
0.7683656216,
-0.2195317,
0.6771315336,
-0.4537325203,
0.0185594168,
0.8042385578,
-0.2409600466,
0.6862339377,
0.4328187704,
-0.4973876476,
0.5925742388,
0.7447624803,
0.1339043975,
0.2710172534,
0.4990117252,
-0.3924461007,
-0.3939628899,
-0.0611296669,
-0.35027197,
0.4001171589,
0.3843022883,
0.2005198598,
-0.5055584311,
-0.4156052768,
-0.0964786112,
0.4101905227,
-0.312500149,
0.7923392057,
0.0578121617,
-0.8592261076,
0.3433007896,
-0.2130239457,
0.6335452199,
-0.5291776061,
-0.2528879642,
-0.2753129601,
0.1180629879,
-0.04056428,
-1.0167738199,
0.1383800954,
-0.0043351599,
-0.1577619612,
0.3587865531,
0.6548279524,
-0.4347115159,
-0.3594098389,
0.3517178297,
0.7247238159,
0.3702491224,
0.0174589083,
-0.8099734187,
-0.0752877668,
-0.1068579555,
-0.1430847496,
0.3169668317,
1.0919767618,
0.0465496108,
1.0320373774,
0.7176473141,
0.3656185567,
0.0578038953,
-0.1355511099,
0.7947415113,
-0.7409865856,
-0.5762008429,
-0.8490945101,
0.4482034445,
-0.4365921021,
-0.6499614716,
1.0972642899,
0.6116207242,
0.5136486888,
0.0587704256,
0.5475742817,
0.2313916534,
0.4888291061,
-0.3435685933,
0.6102238894,
-0.228577435,
0.4400883019,
-0.0996420309,
-0.7545005083,
-0.0570275448,
0.2229763716,
-0.3184814453,
-0.1477980763,
0.8627510667,
0.5255467892,
-0.048795905,
0.0781278312,
0.3447231948,
0.2349080294,
0.2760117352,
0.8943713307,
1.0150923729,
-0.2713646889,
0.7297534347,
0.1391727179,
-0.4465794861,
0.0449633375,
-1.0184065104,
-1.2817713022,
-0.5942012072,
-0.183387816,
-0.2690527439,
0.063014701,
0.5489019752,
0.4165109396,
-0.3142065704,
-0.3307342529,
-0.3877902627,
0.3007113039,
-0.2090823501,
-0.2584514618,
0.4036166668,
-0.4228363335,
-0.4343793094,
0.5748129487,
0.107907109,
-0.3355575204,
-0.4086541831,
0.0374622159,
-0.349696517,
0.1688611954,
0.978056848,
0.1794278473,
-0.7425777316,
-0.3345714808,
0.1014828235,
0.0372559875,
-0.3350966871,
0.8954794407,
-0.8811724782,
0.5431895852,
0.731918633,
0.8037891984,
0.3550460339,
0.0617612451,
0.6831418276,
-0.304657191,
-0.1476369053,
0.1646156609,
0.3250374198,
0.2629220784,
-0.0360580646,
0.513838172,
0.4122601151,
-0.7915655971,
-0.546844244,
0.244668901,
-0.7564681768,
-0.3380472958,
1.126480937,
-0.280171454,
-0.2393994182,
-0.6009959579,
0.1871702075,
0.0800407752,
-0.3024417758,
1.1274052858,
0.8254641891,
-0.5046255589,
-0.1385950297,
-0.5995604992,
0.7897888422,
0.2050231248,
-0.6758816242,
-0.1921026111,
0.6535874605,
0.1270524263,
0.4460624456,
0.7355991006,
0.0182267576,
0.0822418556,
-0.0275352318,
0.0168400481,
-0.4428955317,
-0.0620510317,
-0.1418575197,
0.1688723862,
0.0636812374,
-0.1601331532
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11011v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11011v2 | Data Shapley in One Training Run | 2024-06-16T17:09:24 | 2024-06-29T23:05:32 | Jiachen T. Wang, Prateek Mittal, Dawn Song, Ruoxi Jia | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, stat.ML | Data Shapley provides a principled framework for attributing data's
contribution within machine learning contexts. However, existing approaches
require re-training models on different data subsets, which is computationally
intensive, foreclosing their application to large-scale models. Furthermore,
they produce the same attribution score for any models produced by running the
learning algorithm, meaning they cannot perform targeted attribution towards a
specific model obtained from a single run of the algorithm. This paper
introduces In-Run Data Shapley, which addresses these limitations by offering
scalable data attribution for a target model of interest. In its most efficient
implementation, our technique incurs negligible additional runtime compared to
standard model training. This dramatic efficiency improvement makes it possible
to perform data attribution for the foundation model pretraining stage for the
first time. We present several case studies that offer fresh insights into
pretraining data's contribution and discuss their implications for copyright in
generative AI and pretraining data curation. | [
0.0789565891,
-0.4574116766,
0.3813570142,
0.1536251605,
-0.2095779777,
-0.1027419642,
0.1399288476,
-0.1320853531,
0.1453692615,
0.8305829167,
-0.6032734513,
0.0689253435,
-0.5019671321,
-0.3752999008,
-0.8100118637,
1.0774029493,
-0.102489382,
0.0520289205,
-0.948138237,
-0.0753365979,
-0.1316959709,
-0.936331749,
-0.6113089919,
-0.546128571,
0.3592448831,
0.4616920352,
0.4953584075,
0.955034554,
0.5269373655,
0.2587577105,
0.5844711065,
-0.1626416743,
-0.65470469,
0.1908194423,
0.0111450497,
-0.7236270308,
-0.0470386297,
0.4108298421,
0.7519263625,
0.7646403909,
-0.1400271803,
0.2826925814,
-0.072183378,
0.8016758561,
-0.9572052956,
-0.1506609172,
-0.4968482256,
0.1155631468,
-0.4238878489,
-0.1356981248,
-0.2397528142,
-0.4085421562,
0.0476749316,
-0.810102284,
0.4479600489,
-0.0304477122,
0.8037100434,
0.6012665033,
-0.1637199372,
-0.1689352393,
-0.5227255225,
1.1353107691,
-0.3324365914,
0.3561946452,
0.4538821578,
0.2408603281,
0.2194795161,
-0.9615675211,
-0.3531702459,
-0.209063381,
0.2215408534,
-0.1171690151,
-0.067630887,
-0.3513122201,
0.2709283233,
0.5630275607,
-0.115284659,
0.0675434098,
-0.4025271535,
-0.0292159095,
0.7371423841,
0.2198810726,
-0.3370471001,
0.0692390427,
-0.5220961571,
-0.3038845956,
-0.6462882161,
0.088353008,
0.5211648345,
0.3575999439,
-0.1190677434,
0.1733900309,
-0.1192215309,
0.6628491282,
0.1598811001,
0.2669442594,
0.2278609574,
-0.186157316,
-0.0827052668,
0.1238802299,
0.7172628641,
-0.240371719,
0.3136182129,
-0.3761651218,
-0.1273953021,
-0.3464517891,
0.5867097974,
-1.1442757845,
-0.7651952505,
0.2194813788,
-0.4051443338,
-0.8474988341,
0.3500411212,
-0.194557786,
-0.6325858235,
-0.4845485985,
0.4572808743,
-0.4828395545,
-0.0650750697,
-0.0007784922,
0.0943988562,
0.1977188438,
0.0508532859,
-0.7970101237,
0.2247915715,
0.7078989148,
0.826801002,
-0.3445136547,
-0.4483795762,
-0.7051771879,
0.3595186472,
-0.4940161407,
0.5461288691,
-0.5740421414,
-0.0319434814,
-0.2377362698,
-0.2887246609,
-0.0519934781,
-0.6177030802,
0.31168437,
-0.4335316718,
0.0772725567,
-0.5000718832,
-0.6557542682,
-0.091057241,
0.0109901903,
-0.7654223442,
0.7450352311,
0.3429198265,
-0.737508893,
0.8534400463,
-0.7883390188,
-0.7198033333,
-0.0019765203,
-0.1181378439,
-0.8994023204,
0.3349211216,
0.1655250788,
0.6777667403,
-0.1449008137,
0.2108482122,
-0.5001111031,
-0.3191450536,
0.2881535888,
-0.3365280032,
1.0582019091,
0.1244387478,
-0.1261501014,
0.0191570148,
-0.9769087434,
0.4125849903,
0.3527090251,
-0.1930706203,
-0.2279415131,
-0.0662212074,
0.214547351,
-0.000958006,
0.1730631441,
-0.3831236064,
0.1253499836,
0.035517551,
0.4958594441,
0.7902336121,
-0.1444830149,
0.2317246348,
-0.4830552638,
0.707025826,
0.0043021804,
0.1600808352,
-0.1589644402,
0.0008834449,
-0.4715913832,
-0.4435300529,
0.4616436958,
0.3940997124,
-0.3906702995,
0.0974118486,
-0.2780613899,
-0.5005936623,
-0.43727386,
0.208447367,
0.4201000631,
0.3364731967,
0.2611962855,
-0.4487080574,
-0.631647706,
-0.8447683454,
-0.1386675239,
0.0328186676,
-0.1082030386,
0.534329474,
0.5889739394,
0.1460105479,
1.0030390024,
-0.4731371701,
-0.1625895053,
-0.0124737667,
0.1274614036,
-0.0487425774,
0.8922499418,
0.5382071733,
-0.8505724669,
-0.4276667237,
-0.2984823883,
-0.8642922044,
-0.0264197197,
-0.1179569736,
-0.2197002918,
-0.4393520951,
0.4224896729,
-0.0872332603,
0.2869414985,
0.5263836384,
0.0070458325,
0.560129106,
-0.1080641523,
0.4983367026,
-1.1247084141,
0.2176157832,
-0.5915648937,
-0.3441425562,
-0.4620913863,
-0.053215839,
-0.1525983959,
-0.4469408989,
-0.4532076716,
0.2383933812,
-0.0353950188,
-0.2851791978,
-0.1393917501,
-0.4584081471,
0.0750425309,
0.1728804559,
-0.079298608,
0.681887567,
0.7591267228,
-0.75453794,
0.75588727,
0.4887419939,
-0.4032857418,
0.8011734486,
-0.8323702812,
0.4513523579,
-0.0351628363,
0.2625381351,
-0.5508246422,
-0.4144952297,
0.0605465025,
-0.3521862626,
0.2371083498,
-0.3196511269,
-0.3496418893,
-0.0505742058,
-0.3455420136,
0.8771236539,
0.1710441113,
-0.7406757474,
0.4659681916,
0.2710111439,
0.2386929244,
-0.4099994898,
-0.9156836867,
-0.1339010298,
-0.6981857419,
-0.6940253973,
0.487953335,
0.2850232422,
-0.0874355286,
-0.1379325688,
0.2045389563,
-0.4525778294,
0.3727894723,
0.4537675083,
-0.0633449182,
-0.047984194,
0.0124645382,
-0.3684406281,
-0.3090637326,
0.2811096311,
-0.3577978313,
0.5106875896,
0.2523033917,
-0.6405908465,
-0.4946730733,
0.3576131761,
0.1765670627,
-0.3087278306,
0.7692095637,
0.5073694587,
-0.4100291431,
-0.2519370615,
-0.3111406565,
-0.1641944647,
-0.4240440428,
0.4001444876,
-0.2634570301,
-0.3275021315,
0.4081379771,
0.1085271835,
0.2170962989,
0.3449936807,
0.2920342386,
-0.3420091569,
0.5578967929,
0.7355691791,
-0.4656776786,
0.8997387886,
-0.51290977,
0.0135569395,
-0.4986959398,
-0.1838350743,
-0.5321351886,
-0.2358164638,
-0.0299588386,
-0.0939233452,
0.2225515544,
0.2860488296,
-0.3333275616,
0.15287368,
-0.3899949491,
0.5013448596,
0.6864810586,
0.4164918959,
0.1065909937,
0.2114934921,
0.8262966275,
0.1093254983,
-0.8924714327,
-0.2263205498,
1.7287187576,
0.0623168163,
0.704357326,
-0.1594917923,
1.0735992193,
0.5519332886,
0.4366076589,
-0.4410096705,
0.0994295925,
-0.3937119246,
-0.6719872355,
-0.3678872585,
-0.5126440525,
-0.8319177032,
-0.341278851,
-0.1908474714,
-0.4515776932,
-0.1703918278,
0.5757741928,
-0.4352309406,
0.3673206568,
-0.6427206993,
1.0839183331,
-0.4350711703,
-0.5641105771,
-0.3626761138,
-0.3835777938,
0.4303902984,
-0.3076962531,
-0.104578808,
0.1513786763,
0.1903854609,
1.3950738907,
-0.7294244766,
0.5981560349,
-0.4995346665,
0.2010355294,
0.4359663129,
-0.1732105464,
0.5610806942,
-0.1650370508,
0.1428780407,
0.1193426549,
0.0702006668,
-0.80737257,
-0.4887277782,
0.4916409552,
-0.5235350132,
-0.0766174942,
-0.2249457389,
-0.5813169479,
-0.3620763719,
0.0548562557,
0.4768356383,
0.5487537384,
-0.1884534955,
0.5259943008,
0.8236922026,
0.1975403279,
0.0462239496,
-0.0295158755,
-0.0408638678,
-0.2225302309,
1.1267660856,
-0.2061460018,
0.3007532358,
0.0849848539,
0.2637219131,
-0.1878452599,
-0.7865593433,
-0.4421331286,
-0.1420728713,
-0.5749847889,
-0.1955957264,
-0.3338001668,
0.0111168334,
-0.2216722369,
-0.6089434624,
-0.7605113387,
-0.2488012165,
-0.2429398745,
0.2218767703,
0.3791628182,
0.5377355814,
-0.0297087878,
0.5794603229,
-0.4510124922,
0.1392385066,
0.4688752592,
0.3473388553,
-0.0710326731,
-0.6751289964,
-0.5826203823,
0.2603013217,
-0.2961813509,
-0.3749341667,
-0.2017792165,
0.4523898065,
0.4495921731,
0.4780451953,
-0.2130595595,
0.8013784885,
-0.0412633717,
0.6984626055,
0.1011420712,
-0.9375377893,
0.6551321745,
-0.2123650461,
-0.0519195423,
0.960208714,
0.4889754951,
0.048289977,
0.2693638504,
-0.7556526065,
-0.561601162,
0.7194179296,
0.009803134,
0.1236604899,
0.5762364268,
0.6119953394,
0.2279936075,
0.3413295448,
-0.4462780952,
-0.1576017737,
-0.4542981088,
-0.1042775586,
-0.2078489065,
0.0867433697,
-0.1665923744,
-0.2720310092,
0.9491557479,
-0.1327114403,
0.0280890446,
-0.3601477742,
-0.3924044669,
0.0445756838,
-0.2668591142,
-0.0763072968,
0.772975862,
-0.0546069033,
-0.2928948402,
-0.0842627957,
-0.5531865954,
0.1583037972,
0.341978997,
-0.2690592706,
-0.4318387508,
0.6604180932,
0.6371654272,
0.3358968496,
-0.5019065738,
0.7844176292,
0.4401581585,
-0.3649224639,
-0.2882595062,
0.2011172622,
-0.244430244,
0.3798952997,
0.2137129754,
-0.1549081951,
0.0955123007,
-0.5363022089,
0.6028932333,
0.5498597622,
-0.3702258766,
-0.177764371,
0.928786695,
-0.1979793608,
0.1459678262,
0.8917515874,
0.0523940101,
-0.5784909129,
0.6326084733,
0.273008734,
0.9085129499,
-0.3047961295,
0.1968605518,
0.1546476185,
-0.3587569594,
-0.1137006953,
0.0764690936,
-0.3064438701,
-0.853068769,
-0.2407111377,
-0.645802319,
-0.3340081275,
0.1014029831,
-0.8366709352,
0.1303468943,
-0.627555728,
0.0799906999,
0.2788758278,
0.0994653702,
-0.820930779,
0.3624508381,
0.1185230464,
0.242449224,
-1.0308400393,
0.7372928262,
0.6866824627,
-0.4462363422,
-0.6526066065,
-0.2319685519,
-0.2387875021,
-0.9514963031,
0.3730480969,
0.1050000638,
0.1044779941,
0.0678239092,
-1.0186195374,
-0.7764402032,
1.0724272728,
0.5670769215,
-0.0563313141,
0.2716145813,
0.2499581873,
-0.0471682549,
-0.5128136873,
-0.2439192981,
0.6428626776,
0.1936108321,
0.2195124328,
-0.4638364613,
-0.1071616933,
0.1943789572,
-0.3602977693,
0.0523527414,
-0.4339891672,
1.0722111464,
-0.3017266095,
-0.0082191201,
-0.3043789864,
0.6841815114,
0.4087766707,
0.2820894122,
0.5616462827,
0.5503948331,
0.9079192877,
-0.0193494558,
1.1172726154,
-0.1917014271,
0.3072376847,
1.0322856903,
0.1568629146,
0.424752146,
0.3625714779,
-0.7770575881,
0.4185124338,
0.5481314063,
-0.1766988635,
0.6632173061,
0.4957776964,
-0.1864192635,
-0.257709384,
-0.1691271067,
-0.2396437526,
0.5027483106,
-0.1722390801,
-0.4528115094,
0.0438447967,
0.0106316367,
-0.0245676227,
-0.0214813761,
-0.5370399952,
0.4011149406,
-0.0946272612,
-0.140890196,
0.4451669157,
-0.2118768841,
0.5877366662,
-0.8576586843,
0.013709547,
-0.065196082,
0.204819873,
-0.6397892237,
-0.2949213982,
0.3785752356,
-0.1033707187,
-0.4833492637,
-0.3757070005,
0.5607690811,
-0.217518881,
-0.5202671885,
-0.55203408,
0.2922028899,
0.4829228222,
-0.7356677055,
-0.6877807379,
-0.1542377621,
0.1706823409,
-0.4529096484,
0.2743394077,
0.3718468845,
-0.2318615019,
0.8028769493,
0.7081319094,
-0.0977063403,
0.2731215358,
-0.115372397,
0.8761063814,
-0.5701355934,
-0.7328419089,
-0.5321162939,
0.3286031485,
-0.0391907766,
-0.4209121764,
0.5458725095,
0.9516135454,
0.7571914792,
0.1709931493,
0.9802590013,
-0.3111875653,
0.139242202,
-0.5673004389,
0.6216546297,
-0.4494703412,
-0.1141685843,
-0.1672336459,
-0.8531107903,
0.1019500196,
0.6828965545,
-0.2272064239,
0.2800872326,
0.4325628877,
0.3735304773,
-0.3365550339,
0.1462678611,
0.0110521708,
-0.3058068454,
0.4572747648,
0.7880083919,
0.5648946762,
-0.5137666464,
0.1728791445,
-0.5469847322,
-0.3087017536,
0.0788711011,
-0.9041535258,
-0.6073436141,
-0.7967860699,
-0.3583753109,
-0.2527267933,
-0.1377735436,
0.5038694143,
1.0569509268,
-0.954238832,
0.1106813401,
-0.0897600725,
-0.2658744454,
-0.4032424986,
-0.2380525917,
0.6196867228,
-0.1775632352,
-0.2971099913,
0.3230423629,
-0.3525882363,
-0.0392606221,
-0.5055831671,
-0.0888030082,
0.0750460103,
-0.1529851854,
0.2076017261,
0.3468050063,
0.0399198048,
-0.3144708872,
-0.6936378479,
0.1279376,
0.0346239991,
1.3875625134,
-0.9844870567,
0.1491691172,
0.1215079948,
0.9886598587,
1.0664401054,
0.4037860632,
0.4809975922,
-0.7748035789,
0.199334994,
0.3860724568,
-0.0434809849,
0.5582525134,
-0.4508140981,
0.4489175975,
0.3711160123,
-0.4051972032,
-0.7476032376,
0.2197308689,
-0.765065968,
0.0042532524,
0.7354074717,
-0.2591278553,
-0.0348994955,
-0.003092767,
0.4733380079,
0.0904448479,
-0.0483841412,
0.7192612886,
0.7459254861,
-0.3006699979,
0.1777392924,
-0.6028828621,
0.6552145481,
0.4694631398,
-0.9350823164,
0.3919262886,
0.5632055998,
0.480014205,
-0.1617635489,
0.6970698833,
0.0908170342,
0.0834484771,
0.4789497852,
-0.0573090985,
-0.8179472685,
-0.407984376,
-0.2350937426,
0.236896202,
-0.229158923,
-0.5415128469
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11911v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11911v1 | A Notion of Complexity for Theory of Mind via Discrete World Models | 2024-06-16T16:46:55 | 2024-06-16T16:46:55 | X. Angelo Huang, Emanuele La Malfa, Samuele Marro, Andrea Asperti, Anthony Cohn, Michael Wooldridge | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Theory of Mind (ToM) can be used to assess the capabilities of Large Language
Models (LLMs) in complex scenarios where social reasoning is required. While
the research community has proposed many ToM benchmarks, their hardness varies
greatly, and their complexity is not well defined. This work proposes a
framework to measure the complexity of ToM tasks. We quantify a problem's
complexity as the number of states necessary to solve it correctly. Our
complexity measure also accounts for spurious states of a ToM problem designed
to make it apparently harder. We use our method to assess the complexity of
five widely adopted ToM benchmarks. On top of this framework, we design a
prompting technique that augments the information available to a model with a
description of how the environment changes with the agents' interactions. We
name this technique Discrete World Models (DWM) and show how it elicits
superior performance on ToM tasks. | [
-0.6688780785,
-0.9313619733,
1.1467983723,
0.227149263,
-0.1986577958,
0.0262198746,
-0.387123704,
-0.4795284569,
-0.1647303402,
0.0064972891,
-0.7680091262,
0.0347476453,
-0.6415761709,
0.1293286234,
-0.0956869647,
0.6072156429,
-0.0786194205,
-0.0550468713,
-0.3464925289,
-0.069640696,
-0.2687575817,
-0.1230671778,
-0.7565714121,
-0.8196001649,
0.6761986613,
0.000923619,
0.6583177447,
0.3966488838,
0.7468444109,
0.403236419,
-0.3676109016,
0.3423462808,
-0.4918387234,
0.2159465104,
-0.5272554159,
-0.6898931265,
-0.6537113786,
0.0167268887,
0.2896553874,
0.8963841796,
-0.0665985271,
0.084173277,
0.0892190337,
0.4622375965,
-0.3458416462,
0.3789924979,
-0.5928236246,
-0.0168890655,
-0.0404409692,
-0.3125396669,
-0.2517062128,
-0.2585770488,
0.5215486884,
-0.5016718507,
0.065763697,
0.1789695323,
0.3116136193,
0.3058395684,
-0.5634137392,
-0.1746415645,
-1.1530309916,
0.9576542974,
-0.3614466488,
0.0037364778,
0.3903771937,
0.3785733581,
-0.5405926108,
-0.3584718406,
-0.9593971372,
-0.1828274578,
0.2094341516,
-0.1560117453,
-0.1295238584,
0.429179281,
0.592787087,
0.6810312867,
-0.3264252841,
-0.3755472004,
0.0154275531,
0.2561893761,
0.7596076131,
0.5795173645,
0.3034627736,
-0.0774894655,
-0.2588561773,
-0.2752741575,
-0.2535867393,
-0.1037726477,
0.0572830029,
0.0650655702,
-0.0961555913,
0.1207018644,
-0.2438504547,
0.7438810468,
0.122659862,
-0.4144112766,
-0.3004867136,
0.1610371321,
-0.3462151587,
-0.5023996234,
0.314914912,
0.190299809,
0.350499332,
0.0329045355,
-0.2783195078,
0.0709948763,
0.3787010312,
-0.4179359674,
-0.1654914767,
0.5209410787,
-0.2408474535,
-0.0319724903,
-0.0868432969,
-0.4284202456,
-0.6433988214,
-0.1627808362,
0.5415107012,
-0.6764819026,
-0.6600893736,
0.2889072001,
-0.2110895365,
0.1771885753,
0.481487304,
-0.6596992016,
0.5183733702,
0.7853907943,
0.7997100353,
-0.0923323333,
-0.3669059277,
0.2918761075,
0.2622224391,
-0.4768365324,
0.7970888019,
-0.4000941813,
-0.4653649628,
-0.2469717115,
-0.312507838,
0.1722257435,
-0.2256563157,
0.1218814105,
-0.4104627967,
0.0750758797,
-0.7593353987,
-0.8001027703,
-0.556096077,
0.5046627522,
-0.554908514,
0.9076516032,
0.2143649906,
-0.6053205729,
0.2615360618,
-0.7996537089,
-0.3810963631,
0.5743983388,
-0.2647233605,
0.1344837397,
0.4752217829,
-0.1209485307,
0.6184559464,
-0.7018808126,
0.7370634079,
-0.5672264695,
-0.4433440268,
0.4028440118,
-0.3668462336,
0.7414505482,
0.2661773562,
-0.4028116465,
-0.0597683601,
-0.804926753,
0.2143350095,
0.4121648967,
-0.1981676072,
-0.6032806039,
0.2437253296,
-0.229448244,
-0.0475304388,
0.2020085752,
-0.3264849186,
0.2301047444,
-0.3092763722,
0.545422256,
0.9442124367,
0.0964148641,
0.2417182326,
-0.9409391284,
0.4415701926,
-0.2844306529,
0.1629910767,
0.0703723505,
-0.5669332147,
-0.8072729111,
-0.2766334713,
0.0192671288,
0.2626912594,
-0.710596025,
0.3960988224,
-0.5247015357,
-0.7570055127,
-0.029541105,
-0.2799169719,
0.4967952967,
-0.0103687206,
0.1188407987,
-0.3993264139,
-0.2112018764,
-0.7146008611,
-0.2110004425,
-0.4478077888,
-0.1461542547,
0.3966680169,
0.7092897296,
0.0267994013,
0.8148344159,
-0.5084230304,
0.187694788,
-0.2163779587,
0.1885058284,
0.148865208,
0.4090141058,
0.2007300705,
-0.7811996937,
-0.0561785996,
-0.1084173918,
-0.9002316594,
0.2403344512,
0.0606022328,
0.0033064294,
-0.1704964787,
0.1005768105,
-0.8701817989,
0.3391985595,
0.1014239267,
0.0199887287,
0.1850317419,
-0.3051104248,
0.2898814082,
-0.6969937682,
0.0805357546,
0.0766584948,
-0.0054172934,
-0.6345440745,
0.4927099943,
-0.2008315921,
0.0407297723,
-0.2597936392,
0.5958775282,
-0.5110318661,
-0.0902379081,
-0.1093358994,
0.0156310499,
-0.2057930529,
0.8898386955,
-0.2042842358,
0.3948532343,
0.1591658741,
-1.0849394798,
0.6956397891,
-0.1047236994,
-0.496968925,
1.1423854828,
-0.6029523015,
0.3623080254,
-0.17226924,
0.3891735375,
-1.3707515001,
-0.3631707728,
-0.0507219955,
-0.1333164424,
-0.0785961002,
0.2247385085,
-0.4636574686,
-0.5631634593,
-0.0957273841,
0.399464637,
0.3988347054,
-0.3063330054,
0.7060295939,
0.2506947815,
0.0797401369,
0.0241861288,
-0.653142035,
0.0003358783,
-0.3665473461,
-0.6834604144,
0.6246973276,
-0.5327749252,
-0.7227689624,
-0.1768340617,
-0.2401575297,
-0.2464432269,
0.225552544,
0.3705332577,
-0.1938701868,
0.0997698754,
0.3747113347,
-0.1024480909,
0.0705545023,
0.4102424979,
-0.2913103402,
0.4942561686,
-0.0797233582,
-0.3742997348,
-0.1894804537,
0.2725188732,
0.7823729515,
0.0057892092,
0.2922313213,
-0.0230056997,
-0.8492116928,
-0.5993433595,
-0.5129480362,
-0.2053070068,
-0.4914952219,
0.2193998247,
-0.8383273482,
-0.6408440471,
0.6110127568,
-0.3033735454,
-0.017706465,
0.1193068549,
0.5607218742,
0.06449081,
1.0268186331,
0.7325683832,
0.1049062982,
0.2709842026,
-0.2355803251,
0.1994464695,
-0.5627942085,
-0.1560630798,
-0.1351715773,
-0.5363519192,
-0.3513162136,
-0.5648799539,
0.4144316018,
-0.1199098602,
-0.3909181952,
0.1442034543,
-0.4085564017,
0.4637084603,
0.4079194367,
0.3800421059,
0.4373125434,
-0.0788863078,
-0.2774357498,
0.0771401376,
-0.6041509509,
-0.473926425,
0.873203814,
0.2641689777,
0.7039527297,
0.4485782683,
0.5004398823,
0.4242243469,
0.0415697135,
-0.7546338439,
1.0141209364,
0.3315090537,
-0.9403678179,
-0.7024928331,
-0.2237593234,
-0.9129171371,
0.133811906,
-0.0753617361,
-0.6981773973,
0.0311964974,
-0.01565524,
-0.5622177124,
0.3117694557,
-0.1236295924,
0.1677496433,
0.0217198506,
-0.302331239,
-0.6625392437,
-0.4180907309,
0.4938897192,
0.1153527647,
0.061935991,
-0.1957519501,
0.0184157565,
0.6548011899,
-0.4142076075,
0.6961468458,
-0.0660848245,
-0.5563154221,
0.2991600037,
0.3616253734,
0.491815716,
-0.0708332807,
-0.0017431031,
-0.2267241925,
-0.0274396036,
-0.4044189453,
-0.9037017822,
0.5868566036,
-0.4993848205,
-0.7823598981,
-0.5276323557,
-0.8109163642,
-0.468391031,
0.0742339566,
0.1956488937,
0.3600108922,
-0.2628392279,
-0.072500512,
0.9760351181,
-0.079264611,
0.3561498225,
0.6262694597,
-0.0972305834,
-0.0412012227,
0.7737099528,
0.5513397455,
0.1791787595,
0.3424075842,
0.19381769,
-0.0645279884,
-0.4740615487,
-0.03983327,
-0.0632520095,
-0.7775678039,
0.0275770556,
-0.3994223177,
-0.0914216042,
0.0004288417,
-0.0101181753,
-0.094248496,
-0.203771472,
0.2543075681,
-0.1641028225,
0.5877104998,
1.1369645596,
-0.0019475489,
0.1676772386,
-0.1622806042,
0.322760433,
0.8384164572,
0.6211440563,
0.4764424562,
-0.218305409,
-0.1460301131,
-0.0227865558,
-0.2283782214,
-0.9154174328,
-0.0053101117,
-0.1690965444,
0.5504741669,
0.3036565483,
0.1830612421,
0.84755373,
-0.2973249257,
0.5774800777,
-0.1012503281,
-1.1141574383,
0.6046748757,
-0.7073914409,
0.2820546031,
0.1282427609,
0.3931650519,
-0.3237533271,
-0.398773998,
-0.89791435,
-0.4744530022,
0.3290524483,
-0.0421347283,
0.0833698586,
-0.2521007955,
0.5971675515,
-0.179733023,
0.1484429091,
-0.5460628271,
-0.2316799313,
0.4801866114,
-0.242160812,
-0.0214883946,
-0.341969043,
-0.3110387623,
-0.1813885868,
0.4207148254,
-0.0705330223,
0.4006865025,
0.4716626406,
-0.0119993938,
-0.4340325296,
0.2146999538,
0.5232249498,
1.0364757776,
-0.2482730001,
0.2717837989,
0.354108572,
-0.1577223688,
0.5332522988,
-0.2827913463,
0.0668855235,
-0.4288303852,
0.5351768136,
0.4693170786,
0.140425384,
-0.5402251482,
0.3244972527,
-0.0504135638,
-0.3750473261,
-0.3232600689,
0.4684698284,
-0.0711849108,
0.4333557487,
0.5633969903,
-0.2375704348,
0.2424302548,
-0.5227891207,
-0.0339180902,
0.3993896246,
-0.4522033632,
-0.2652840018,
0.4019607902,
0.3236269951,
-0.5313185453,
0.3285775483,
-0.4784545004,
-0.3693567514,
0.8419400454,
0.3880363405,
0.7591412663,
-0.2238408923,
0.0003973379,
0.1278035641,
0.5046711564,
-0.4875535071,
0.6931379437,
-0.0947154313,
-0.7562661171,
-0.4552596807,
-0.2954419851,
-0.6790744066,
0.5112378001,
-0.7673611641,
-0.0549303964,
-0.8988157511,
-0.4448393881,
0.0138877993,
0.3760291636,
-0.7575161457,
0.5691403151,
0.103074953,
0.6853469014,
-0.5727902055,
0.6150271893,
0.826888442,
0.007146515,
-0.6349563003,
0.022648707,
0.2128712386,
-0.6597447991,
0.4884282053,
0.0599165931,
-0.3339613974,
0.0923215523,
-0.6859390736,
-0.7372731566,
1.0688322783,
0.2911142111,
-0.5430346727,
0.2078946978,
-0.2814520895,
0.6894184947,
-0.3105997741,
0.2107933611,
0.530110836,
0.5973325968,
-0.2921546698,
-0.8568845987,
0.4019409418,
-0.3175069988,
0.4607304037,
0.1193685159,
-0.7665934563,
1.1095716953,
-0.2753227353,
-0.4826020598,
0.0651199594,
0.6706779599,
0.295032382,
0.3293099701,
0.9050527811,
0.4487074316,
1.0465831757,
-0.0163167492,
0.9609097242,
-0.2293713391,
0.3938118219,
0.8980202675,
-0.4309644401,
0.5586376786,
0.273163408,
-0.8171725869,
0.5236213803,
0.6109759808,
0.2387980223,
0.2116229385,
0.9022690058,
-0.273149699,
-0.4292237759,
-0.0490865856,
-0.1704422235,
0.4327357113,
0.5265318155,
0.1314924359,
0.1698548645,
0.073321484,
-0.1167566925,
0.3836432099,
-0.1948473603,
0.6738682389,
0.1431781799,
-0.8672864437,
0.5909002423,
0.0176762287,
0.5317178369,
-0.5024781227,
-0.1087710708,
-0.2827906013,
0.2040086836,
0.1657945812,
-0.6766170859,
0.1020185128,
-0.3281531334,
-0.5139841437,
-0.0061087506,
0.488602072,
-0.2392112166,
-0.384943217,
0.5157484412,
0.7917153239,
0.2370205373,
-0.0744625106,
-0.5059816837,
0.0942583978,
-0.23822321,
-0.454678297,
0.2087407559,
0.7809832096,
-0.2015050799,
1.2112147808,
0.3169721365,
0.030248398,
-0.2575098276,
-0.2085662186,
0.4625483155,
-0.9783657789,
-0.6132453084,
-1.1167410612,
0.0370665379,
-0.0779630393,
-0.3201963603,
0.5838590264,
-0.1599266827,
0.7128999829,
0.1257910132,
0.9603524208,
-0.3100827038,
0.4557275474,
-0.3022675514,
0.4396046996,
-0.5922118425,
0.447704792,
-0.4892780483,
-0.8473225832,
-0.0689044222,
0.7231878042,
-0.1439280063,
0.2237950861,
0.8428425789,
0.5946964025,
0.153360948,
0.2499943227,
0.4746699333,
0.2060056478,
0.2190278918,
1.0233902931,
0.9558573961,
-0.1150218397,
0.3962679505,
-0.22960262,
-0.4529652596,
-0.0052905446,
-0.9191881418,
-1.0708975792,
-0.8735758066,
-0.3214908242,
-0.2410867661,
0.0769782439,
0.9228227735,
0.8586958051,
-0.3572135568,
-0.4411725402,
-0.2030106932,
0.4007226527,
-0.6716153026,
-0.1592754871,
-0.0283985939,
-0.0647181123,
-0.8277333975,
0.2701325715,
0.4513100684,
0.2694375813,
-0.8109713197,
0.0996543318,
-0.0406191535,
0.5508470535,
0.6287614703,
-0.0588128902,
-1.0377582312,
-0.6741576195,
-0.3590219915,
-0.1840963215,
-0.3093220294,
0.9183855653,
-0.504157722,
0.4460991919,
0.493560791,
0.3672088981,
0.3306271434,
-0.3379251063,
0.857376039,
-0.5124747753,
0.0054043652,
0.0472977012,
0.2337472886,
0.2747657895,
-0.3942660093,
0.7414619327,
0.2134873122,
-0.3921622038,
-0.8760821819,
0.464014709,
-0.7759785652,
-0.5549774766,
0.8209183216,
-0.269074589,
-0.3547068536,
-0.3288904428,
-0.0047210613,
0.038786158,
-0.1637028158,
1.0015956163,
1.1840372086,
-0.1189753637,
-0.1172476336,
-0.4116211236,
0.6955644488,
0.3853917122,
-0.535887599,
0.0197461955,
0.1918958575,
0.1457042843,
0.4235220551,
1.037756443,
0.2245619893,
0.0209431555,
0.1250822991,
0.0333379433,
0.1990402043,
-0.3547904491,
-0.3050341606,
0.2125805765,
0.1716590226,
0.3032883704
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10999v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10999v1 | Not All Bias is Bad: Balancing Rational Deviations and Cognitive Biases in Large Language Model Reasoning | 2024-06-16T16:25:22 | 2024-06-16T16:25:22 | Liman Wang, Hanyang Zhong | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This paper investigates the nuanced role of biases in the decision-making
processes of large language models (LLMs). While conventional research
typically aims to eliminate all biases, our study reveals that not all biases
are detrimental. By examining rational deviations, involving heuristic
shortcuts that enhance decision-making efficiency, we highlight their potential
benefits when properly balanced. We introduce the concepts of heuristic
moderation and an abstention option, allowing LLMs to abstain from answering
when uncertain, thereby reducing error rates and improving decision accuracy.
Using our newly developed BRD (Balance Rational Deviations) dataset, our
findings demonstrate that appropriately scaled bias inspection enhances model
performance and aligns LLM decision-making more closely with human reasoning.
This balance improves the reliability and trustworthiness of LLMs and suggests
new strategies for future enhancements. Our work offers a fresh perspective on
leveraging biases constructively to enhance the practical applications of LLMs,
from conversational agents to decision support systems and beyond. | [
-0.5140390396,
-0.7370125651,
0.760427773,
0.1371153444,
-0.1296262443,
-0.0583610125,
-0.5258209705,
-0.3876025379,
-0.0825936422,
0.6565509439,
-0.4380590022,
-0.2248435766,
-0.5842162371,
-0.1183157936,
-0.035389591,
0.8679662943,
-0.0208577644,
0.3191327453,
-0.3463336229,
-0.254758507,
-0.5523573756,
-0.3469839096,
-0.716755271,
-0.8524674773,
0.3547286093,
0.2937041819,
1.0166553259,
0.6406058669,
0.2570221722,
0.2018778026,
-0.1680290103,
0.2954840958,
-0.4241818488,
0.2741572261,
-0.5600430965,
-0.5989390612,
-0.2944912314,
0.1169696301,
0.5362897515,
0.8893263936,
-0.1468195766,
-0.0376318581,
0.0631397143,
0.7987974882,
-0.7321299911,
0.1638333201,
-0.599998951,
-0.1214618534,
-0.2995893359,
-0.0235256571,
-0.5051512718,
-0.3487204611,
0.3255007565,
-0.3650107682,
-0.1655544788,
0.1603941768,
0.7006206512,
0.524232626,
-0.4726818502,
-0.1034854427,
-0.702973187,
1.201215148,
-0.8234456182,
0.5012016892,
0.4301849008,
0.2762290537,
-0.1884325296,
-0.0159295034,
-0.3663859963,
0.0644585192,
0.0592827462,
-0.2095943242,
-0.1460941881,
0.1908016056,
0.3077033162,
0.0588224418,
-0.0633071363,
0.2754780352,
-0.2550136447,
-0.3764712512,
0.6559054255,
0.1395982653,
0.1991787404,
-0.0224266499,
-0.1005197018,
0.0044269795,
-0.7190955877,
-0.0637443662,
0.2885188758,
0.2322699577,
0.0197194088,
0.6430233121,
-0.2244952917,
0.5850610137,
0.0633534119,
-0.1529674381,
0.0232994352,
-0.2577757239,
-0.3796184659,
-0.0230261851,
0.6167981029,
0.6501207352,
0.7118350863,
-0.1281585544,
-0.3220042586,
0.2433857173,
0.224301368,
-0.5434380174,
-0.0462782197,
0.1828620881,
-0.3594486415,
-0.3175939918,
-0.1926230341,
-0.7598695755,
-0.5435786843,
-0.5361446738,
0.1148492247,
-0.2703000307,
-0.1985175908,
0.4593599737,
-0.1640664041,
0.1248097494,
0.614092648,
-0.6885954142,
0.1699418277,
0.7002462149,
0.4088125527,
-0.2003630549,
-0.088918373,
-0.369350493,
0.1118482128,
-0.5519233346,
0.6197121143,
-0.4356966913,
-0.4184865654,
-0.0672812909,
-0.245701462,
0.173035562,
-0.8055701256,
1.0432025194,
-0.4267700613,
0.1482194811,
-0.7272160649,
-0.5481457114,
-0.2992534935,
0.2760635614,
-0.584548533,
0.6623463035,
-0.0224236213,
-0.6416111588,
0.6169658899,
-0.3377937973,
-0.544647038,
-0.1882494986,
-0.2950621247,
-0.4601913393,
0.0766640976,
0.3050069213,
0.1178334057,
-0.5701292157,
0.3166202605,
-0.575463891,
0.0176745746,
0.469283253,
-0.681191206,
0.9310590625,
0.361223489,
-0.3755588233,
0.319847703,
-0.1703130007,
0.2592539489,
-0.0829851404,
-0.4214941263,
-0.5130089521,
0.3001351655,
-0.1068863124,
0.2213071734,
-0.0693495795,
-0.1592185646,
0.126942873,
-0.3333952129,
0.3737798333,
1.0190796852,
-0.2123075873,
0.9079135656,
-0.7306298614,
0.2549650371,
0.117530033,
0.2677693665,
0.084780477,
-0.3342213035,
-0.8889535069,
-0.443382591,
0.2859538794,
0.5762007833,
-0.52096349,
0.5338584781,
-0.0436284281,
-0.2429575771,
-0.5863022804,
0.4008223116,
0.2682096362,
0.4273400903,
0.1651534438,
-0.1578785926,
-0.6251266003,
-0.9717330337,
-0.4925114214,
-0.18630144,
0.0741227493,
0.1733750999,
0.2269931883,
-0.3058157265,
0.9356098771,
-0.3440177143,
-0.17013596,
-0.1862272918,
-0.2021865547,
-0.0848753378,
0.3388544917,
0.4617002308,
-0.4331707954,
-0.2456882745,
-0.1779601574,
-0.6864445806,
-0.4995510876,
-0.2132528126,
-0.5326570272,
0.4265028834,
0.4146390557,
-1.0120044947,
0.1583307981,
0.2144930363,
-0.4302688241,
0.4518151283,
0.1496286541,
-0.0228201877,
-0.5933840275,
-0.3206417859,
0.3798264563,
-0.3291549981,
-0.3427394331,
-0.0060444162,
0.0387648046,
0.7507362962,
-0.2297655642,
0.5761871338,
-0.3843404353,
-0.0835442618,
-0.2571468651,
0.1581047475,
0.1714508384,
-0.0880269334,
-0.0276856478,
0.6524652839,
0.3324899077,
-0.5043828487,
0.1284822226,
0.0228302162,
-0.3914772272,
0.7083079815,
-0.3417775631,
-0.2982900143,
-0.209199518,
0.2744748592,
-0.645240128,
0.016631607,
0.1081403568,
-0.3503516614,
0.1503847986,
0.1045617238,
-0.3458542824,
-0.2518741786,
-0.5217077732,
0.2539868355,
0.5311372876,
-0.469943434,
0.5440499187,
0.4364337921,
-0.0771119893,
-0.6208921075,
-0.6426848769,
-0.0814521164,
-0.3544460237,
-0.6835182309,
0.0219716243,
-0.1118857637,
-1.0477471352,
-0.2052185535,
-0.2918329835,
0.1881104857,
0.2111786753,
-0.0222957861,
0.5572884679,
-0.1165617555,
-0.0608054213,
-0.0263450667,
0.077728644,
0.2268334329,
-0.3975638449,
0.5985049009,
0.0221702904,
-0.4618206918,
-0.3447723985,
0.0770084485,
0.9062242508,
-0.1195529923,
0.5112367868,
0.1868537515,
-0.3750305176,
-0.2723636627,
-0.9650931954,
-0.3466916382,
-0.4571053684,
0.0901157111,
0.0013120783,
-0.8150915504,
0.4599689543,
0.0687731877,
0.2493946999,
0.2001568079,
0.6837909818,
-0.1024269536,
1.2117606401,
0.3363890648,
-0.3883322775,
0.4997795522,
0.0908842906,
0.3978947997,
-0.7764129043,
0.0192195587,
-0.553394556,
-0.1594238728,
-0.5130571723,
-0.6365421414,
0.2132410258,
0.1919034868,
-0.4397431016,
-0.4719271958,
-0.3105508387,
0.5729150176,
0.4019705057,
0.0577525757,
0.295394361,
-0.1506485045,
0.0360967591,
-0.241975069,
-0.4735566974,
-0.7957591414,
0.997764349,
0.4721902013,
1.0361804962,
0.0992445871,
0.3200393021,
0.2876753509,
0.3462048173,
-0.8341302276,
0.3736375272,
0.2483542711,
-0.7945881486,
-0.5051327944,
-0.4625006914,
-0.5267480612,
0.6249261498,
-0.2738944292,
-0.5225575566,
0.119759798,
0.1052357629,
-0.3261677921,
0.4114221632,
-0.8099989295,
0.4930336773,
-0.4856863022,
-0.7544171214,
-0.2330459356,
-0.3757393062,
0.5704029799,
-0.0301581807,
0.3552517891,
-0.0816741064,
0.0217705574,
0.5621198416,
-0.2213617563,
0.8462864161,
0.0174670108,
-0.2678878009,
0.3564378619,
0.2838509381,
0.5533623099,
0.1560026109,
-0.3304824829,
0.1777258217,
-0.0130488183,
-0.498565048,
-0.3823489249,
0.5671349168,
-0.7894598842,
-0.8562840819,
-0.3669163883,
-0.6539255381,
-0.3387348056,
0.3555374742,
0.0011423026,
-0.2488529086,
-0.1512264609,
0.1472785324,
0.937946558,
-0.1623832732,
0.3553310335,
0.4293302596,
-0.2937819958,
-0.3310194016,
0.3842564821,
0.124802798,
0.6634486914,
0.0029833452,
0.1963160485,
-0.2957111895,
-0.5151047111,
-0.5023537874,
0.2306691259,
-0.8163391352,
-0.0833448097,
-0.5127751827,
0.0195160806,
-0.4445966482,
-0.3911796212,
-0.4898125231,
-0.2269396037,
-0.0992069989,
-0.4059647322,
0.0808624476,
0.3700602949,
-0.013772279,
0.2299226969,
-0.4277623892,
-0.0000471222,
0.2661356926,
0.1810892671,
0.1040910035,
-0.2625337839,
-0.0293942802,
0.2563881874,
-0.5057295561,
-0.5185833573,
0.3681260347,
-0.3812400997,
0.8530703187,
0.5302150846,
0.1504145712,
0.4050113261,
-0.2590538859,
0.6746723652,
0.1649008393,
-1.0008460283,
0.1548577994,
-0.6368489861,
0.3222085238,
0.5646585822,
0.0584011078,
-0.5131500363,
-0.2743380666,
-0.262835294,
-0.6758882403,
0.6693444252,
0.022968309,
-0.0749446675,
0.0244158804,
0.2162798047,
-0.0454874672,
0.2901799679,
-0.6905055046,
-0.051763054,
0.0366242304,
-0.1868997812,
-0.0573191531,
-0.343811661,
-0.4467201531,
-0.3948010802,
0.821541369,
-0.1915716082,
-0.1746096164,
-0.0395721085,
-0.1794999689,
-0.3900548816,
0.5354107022,
0.6204920411,
0.6510698199,
0.0244613215,
0.1821196079,
0.3988196254,
-0.1185132936,
-0.0893879905,
-0.3505006731,
-0.359667182,
-0.3380945921,
0.3343499303,
0.6351056695,
-0.1002327651,
-0.8049274683,
0.3804145455,
0.1438201517,
-0.099039875,
-0.0879639611,
0.0123470509,
0.2096082568,
0.3642133176,
0.0410349146,
0.2148840725,
-0.0985790491,
-0.6095143557,
0.0946725234,
0.8090108633,
-0.2282661498,
-0.0063415007,
0.4510791004,
0.2331888378,
-0.1241200119,
0.7044402957,
-0.0189682059,
-0.5663189292,
0.6078922153,
0.3598856628,
0.6526591182,
-0.1741717309,
0.0640623048,
-0.1002261192,
0.7863295674,
-0.4753651917,
0.1228700057,
0.1058374196,
-1.1489503384,
-0.4676238,
-0.4650504887,
-0.4302999675,
-0.0525360815,
-0.5084429979,
0.4674563408,
-0.6342968941,
-0.2438350916,
-0.0198569614,
-0.172445029,
-0.4657892585,
0.1230439842,
0.2242984325,
0.839612186,
-0.8249214888,
0.6352533698,
0.3307187855,
-0.2820736468,
-0.6372852921,
0.0208344143,
0.3587779999,
-0.6363614202,
0.5437914729,
-0.0399126858,
-0.0970674306,
-0.4198085964,
-0.5458030105,
-0.7213807106,
0.7321900129,
0.461071521,
-0.5445269346,
0.0259877536,
0.0152762607,
0.4076119363,
-0.1912547946,
0.3752497435,
0.8962746263,
0.7928574085,
-0.053220965,
-1.0294498205,
0.0519174598,
0.2402333617,
-0.1785148531,
0.3536143303,
-0.7037644982,
0.9223498106,
-0.2333448231,
0.0759965405,
-0.2938128114,
0.2610274851,
0.4103762209,
0.3079285324,
0.6033228636,
0.6784875989,
0.856110692,
-0.265735954,
0.8916473985,
-0.0248747226,
0.0201971382,
0.9442564249,
-0.800065577,
0.3772552609,
0.7178944349,
-0.161729455,
0.1871878952,
0.5506204963,
0.238933906,
0.4447362423,
0.1970610619,
-0.394649595,
-0.6461612582,
-0.1652048677,
0.0571061708,
0.2972939312,
0.5728822947,
-0.3035535514,
-0.2694999278,
-0.1412962079,
0.3276656568,
0.3153038621,
-0.1632642597,
0.6414152384,
0.1847027242,
-0.9279236794,
0.3885739744,
0.0790051222,
0.9398347735,
-0.3082596362,
0.1822726429,
0.0184328891,
0.4017859697,
-0.3769443333,
-0.8488008976,
0.4000823498,
-0.1968576014,
-0.5824155211,
-0.456164211,
0.6290935874,
-0.1804930419,
-0.2881479561,
0.4201775789,
0.6757840514,
-0.2892224193,
-0.0645784065,
-0.6294053197,
0.3867952228,
0.3329726756,
-0.1396288425,
0.2529447377,
0.4770610332,
-0.6528381109,
0.8269318342,
0.6311012506,
0.191727668,
-0.0506002009,
0.2769946754,
0.7108534575,
-0.5877430439,
-0.350045234,
-1.1000326872,
0.3018874228,
-0.2762719393,
0.0264203232,
0.7320171595,
0.5212092996,
0.9182844758,
0.2937906682,
1.2252595425,
0.4261263311,
0.4694270492,
-0.5032486916,
0.5391936898,
-0.1705604047,
0.6667494774,
-0.2090180516,
-0.7574413419,
-0.234010756,
0.8434233069,
-0.766374588,
0.2577829361,
0.5341627002,
0.7847902775,
0.1324423254,
0.2753834724,
0.2452337891,
0.1775646806,
0.6555791497,
0.2629002631,
0.9244717956,
-0.0152358375,
0.139552623,
-0.0904141814,
-0.2262641639,
-0.2650664449,
-0.75699085,
-1.017693162,
0.0211409591,
-0.1957286745,
-0.4234124124,
0.0512914881,
1.1573964357,
0.7121695876,
-0.6274285913,
-0.3502055109,
0.0311514903,
0.6736039519,
-0.0594914518,
-0.2550415397,
-0.1678176969,
-0.4653691649,
-0.6459254026,
0.0694199353,
0.2699737549,
0.0125975581,
-0.385170877,
-0.1742285192,
-0.2247988582,
0.5683386326,
0.681532681,
0.0275399275,
-0.8416115046,
-0.3461124897,
0.0234220065,
-0.2995637357,
-0.0355207697,
0.7580057383,
-0.4355157912,
0.2209176719,
0.6766780615,
0.6312773824,
0.149622649,
-0.0575699545,
0.8358412385,
-0.2653208673,
0.1268234998,
0.2375165969,
0.5612827539,
0.5198731422,
-0.3095944822,
0.4104958773,
0.057820227,
-0.6027065516,
-0.9005504847,
0.3284954727,
-0.880354166,
-0.4589635432,
1.3946268559,
0.3910812438,
-0.2161119133,
-0.200210169,
-0.4238215983,
0.1536144912,
-0.4686438739,
0.7901895642,
1.1550985575,
-0.1577212065,
-0.1532815546,
-0.7865989804,
0.4730805755,
0.8333314657,
-0.8042626977,
0.3742120266,
0.9115644693,
0.4657433629,
0.0822376534,
0.5178704262,
-0.2352042943,
0.03514193,
-0.3521170914,
0.1424459815,
0.3188057542,
-0.0034284333,
-0.3008619845,
-0.2178459018,
0.437177062,
0.2050463557
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10996v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10996v1 | THEANINE: Revisiting Memory Management in Long-term Conversations with Timeline-augmented Response Generation | 2024-06-16T16:17:46 | 2024-06-16T16:17:46 | Seo Hyun Kim, Kai Tzu-iunn Ong, Taeyoon Kwon, Namyoung Kim, Keummin Ka, SeongHyeon Bae, Yohan Jo, Seung-won Hwang, Dongha Lee, Jinyoung Yeo | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) are capable of processing lengthy dialogue
histories during prolonged interaction with users without additional memory
modules; however, their responses tend to overlook or incorrectly recall
information from the past. In this paper, we revisit memory-augmented response
generation in the era of LLMs. While prior work focuses on getting rid of
outdated memories, we argue that such memories can provide contextual cues that
help dialogue systems understand the development of past events and, therefore,
benefit response generation. We present Theanine, a framework that augments
LLMs' response generation with memory timelines -- series of memories that
demonstrate the development and causality of relevant past events. Along with
Theanine, we introduce TeaFarm, a counterfactual-driven question-answering
pipeline addressing the limitation of G-Eval in long-term conversations.
Supplementary videos of our methods and the TeaBag dataset for TeaFarm
evaluation are in https://theanine-693b0.web.app/. | [
-0.3484933078,
-1.1728732586,
0.5873211622,
-0.2838815451,
-0.109388873,
0.0834346339,
-0.1195364445,
-0.3436455727,
0.519159615,
0.7483797669,
-0.8087123632,
0.0090108039,
-0.1843334585,
-0.298502475,
-0.3996779025,
0.9334490895,
0.0317929313,
-0.1300593317,
-0.3081113398,
-0.2023453712,
-0.7154823542,
-0.8481799364,
-1.1086438894,
-0.6677299738,
0.9274006486,
0.3436472118,
0.5296176672,
0.4223091304,
0.1657869816,
0.3007695675,
-0.1647756398,
-0.0458641537,
-0.6725631356,
0.4233177006,
-0.3313198388,
-0.4402319491,
-0.5336749554,
-0.4203465581,
0.3570426702,
0.7169837952,
-0.2373150289,
0.1241017878,
-0.0523230731,
0.5119289756,
-0.5812987089,
-0.0372480266,
-0.6476172209,
0.1288744658,
-0.0061688907,
-0.4861323237,
-0.3379772305,
-0.0567292534,
0.3007106781,
-0.3165026307,
0.051155962,
0.0350428484,
0.5379425883,
0.1251537055,
-0.4012066424,
-0.3408806324,
-0.9764857888,
0.8746427298,
-0.5774425268,
0.0239789337,
0.4237828553,
0.2450490147,
-0.3052602112,
-0.8327400088,
-0.5316722393,
-0.0703665689,
-0.0531993136,
0.111756146,
-0.1960638016,
0.0882990137,
0.2882983685,
0.3705770969,
-0.648658514,
0.0541437827,
-0.3526153266,
-0.4437493086,
0.1745919734,
0.3301873207,
0.2274614573,
-0.2137587219,
-0.5584568977,
0.1949048042,
-0.7180067301,
-0.2141681314,
-0.0259477776,
-0.0537172779,
0.2513382137,
0.4657033682,
0.0476754867,
0.5244822502,
-0.0995788425,
0.0600159913,
-0.3076125383,
-0.2437206507,
-0.4351553917,
0.3720332086,
0.5335483551,
0.2877301276,
0.5902451873,
-0.235409528,
0.453874588,
-0.0235284083,
0.3448480368,
-1.0150333643,
-0.3065434992,
0.4039281309,
-0.2801382542,
0.0088677956,
-0.5642747879,
-0.8796584606,
-0.3139380515,
0.0830917507,
0.2841039896,
-0.1635921746,
-0.4767490029,
-0.0366276018,
-0.1782178283,
0.2502072155,
0.218182385,
-0.7074363828,
0.3623125851,
0.5123620629,
0.5097973943,
-0.0104597677,
-0.0944079459,
-0.7626581788,
0.523213923,
-0.2000341117,
0.813416183,
-0.5653609633,
-0.7443708181,
-0.01620364,
-0.1796188653,
0.0963265672,
-0.5833805203,
0.1970202923,
-0.7151890993,
0.3363634944,
-0.2597123384,
-0.5987321734,
-0.1178693548,
0.5201998353,
-0.5703953505,
0.7090222836,
0.0609709173,
-0.4093249142,
0.0575846545,
-0.4971170425,
-0.3681280613,
-0.1436260045,
-0.202765137,
-0.4413948357,
-0.0123179853,
0.0884703323,
0.0979098231,
-0.4908115864,
0.6280708909,
-0.3979953825,
-0.2258260548,
0.3871197701,
-0.8222968578,
0.616655767,
0.1127475724,
-0.0812318102,
0.0654011145,
-0.6675012112,
0.0430527739,
0.1264957339,
-0.0582226813,
-0.1050540879,
0.0902522877,
-0.529876709,
0.1987270862,
-0.072881192,
-0.281449914,
-0.1529713422,
-0.2757124901,
0.658561945,
0.7652474046,
0.4086529016,
0.4787806273,
-0.3729449213,
0.2762951851,
0.3051502705,
-0.0013735256,
-0.9092229009,
-0.1353794038,
-1.1228227615,
0.2254023403,
-0.0806784332,
0.605253756,
-0.7625800967,
0.2502565384,
-0.291957736,
-0.039899867,
0.1240444928,
0.3039502501,
0.1147707999,
0.8864759803,
0.5766503215,
-0.3367739916,
-0.7079243064,
-0.8849841356,
-0.2403387725,
-0.7961236835,
-0.071482189,
0.6261066198,
0.2174783796,
0.0267509334,
0.9854715466,
-0.4383248687,
0.1129430309,
-0.1094528809,
0.2391081601,
-0.0972723886,
0.4572048783,
0.2432656586,
-0.650251627,
0.1241073906,
-0.3380537033,
-0.4611102045,
-0.1278787702,
-0.4808703959,
-0.1818121374,
0.355237782,
0.4963384569,
-0.874601841,
0.5068265796,
0.2663626969,
-0.152455166,
0.2918044925,
0.0184859224,
0.1445209831,
-1.1472074986,
0.1499882489,
-0.4134339392,
-0.287668854,
-0.5526692867,
-0.6016917229,
-0.2793445885,
-0.2797338068,
-0.5587565899,
0.8221557736,
-0.4064095914,
0.0671911463,
-0.2999860346,
0.2203522772,
0.0420177616,
0.6800494194,
0.2374639511,
0.7593255043,
0.1131967008,
-0.5826368332,
0.5925188661,
0.1515512764,
-0.0701787621,
0.6910054088,
-0.4440757036,
0.3616125584,
-0.0746209621,
0.3774742484,
-1.3411650658,
-0.2605981827,
0.5283577442,
-0.2072575837,
0.4137828946,
0.0172275882,
-0.2062486559,
-0.691170156,
-0.1970135123,
0.408864677,
0.4549948275,
-0.6105606556,
0.8183336258,
0.0532471389,
-0.398894608,
-0.4022615254,
-0.7268489003,
0.5602600574,
-0.5206496119,
-0.4063530266,
0.0065154023,
-0.3666813076,
-0.2591435015,
-0.0625996441,
-0.4126465321,
-0.0094965864,
0.1011452973,
-0.0009555566,
0.1619402021,
-0.1089011431,
0.4285258651,
-0.1946564913,
-0.0640975684,
0.2473328561,
-0.1691017151,
0.8335605264,
0.4412586689,
-0.1730569005,
-0.0796639323,
0.5366453528,
0.2634624243,
-0.1053152233,
0.6865046024,
0.3473730981,
-0.2543024421,
-0.0965006426,
-0.6740833521,
-0.3264427483,
-0.4683019817,
0.3638674915,
-0.2664742172,
-1.0035640001,
0.5948742628,
-0.3157426119,
-0.2606525421,
0.2721264362,
0.5699961185,
-0.2389066666,
0.6483252048,
0.1529144645,
-0.1345819533,
0.7809097767,
0.0888038427,
0.2855228484,
-0.7838602662,
-0.1217744499,
-0.2190539092,
-0.3588510454,
-0.2319378555,
-0.2554962337,
0.2262499034,
0.1512788832,
-0.6492497325,
0.0078053083,
0.2015990168,
0.470736444,
0.1313593537,
0.2465649098,
0.1293657422,
-0.0130067123,
0.2556609809,
0.1257345378,
-0.7343125343,
-0.3552552462,
0.7865062356,
0.255800277,
0.6897716522,
0.0644077808,
0.3152846992,
0.1171718761,
0.3962232471,
-0.6689119935,
0.8455521464,
0.218455106,
-0.5813450217,
0.0126568396,
-0.504748702,
-0.9157193303,
0.0025618731,
-0.0200803392,
-1.0363628864,
-0.0830763802,
0.3478628397,
-0.6556373239,
0.4448847771,
-0.5978549719,
0.7230350375,
-0.4989538789,
-0.7267366648,
-0.3021602929,
-0.7657367587,
0.3305518031,
0.0956468955,
-0.1791837662,
0.0295440443,
0.0884693339,
0.4819485843,
-0.6352143884,
1.1060363054,
0.0743959174,
-0.1033632159,
0.6523486376,
0.2029353678,
0.418990612,
0.2962738276,
0.0383547992,
-0.0687684044,
-0.184241116,
-0.4325536489,
-0.6207572818,
0.978268981,
-0.2840400934,
-1.0341701508,
-0.2682380378,
-0.6077227592,
-0.2329896241,
0.1138995886,
-0.1464123726,
0.6213299632,
-0.5711036325,
0.0827546939,
0.9242842793,
-0.4785616398,
0.8269952536,
0.2852832675,
-0.4225506783,
-0.3732646704,
0.4513608813,
0.1336462349,
0.4317085445,
0.2928178906,
0.0941016674,
-0.1114355549,
-0.1571325213,
-0.5883518457,
-0.0835795552,
-0.4375037253,
-0.3779202998,
-0.6202040911,
-0.2106019109,
-0.1086279452,
0.1322540045,
-0.1652348489,
-0.5189489722,
-0.4189696014,
-0.140425995,
0.4768014848,
0.2297736108,
0.0351985507,
0.5636903048,
-0.7877168655,
0.3048397005,
0.4499332011,
0.3683055639,
0.3278245926,
-0.1709373742,
-0.2989556789,
0.2702820897,
-0.4032169878,
-0.9357708097,
0.2658804059,
0.096863687,
0.3461904526,
0.2636098266,
-0.2699687779,
0.824513495,
-0.6178296208,
1.2574080229,
0.1065469831,
-0.6354486942,
0.5115305781,
-0.4042293429,
0.5623933673,
0.1041932404,
0.0962332338,
-0.7052075863,
-0.1080788448,
-0.709153533,
-1.0038068295,
0.3086507916,
-0.0122150695,
0.3209436834,
-0.2599996626,
0.5549644828,
-0.162866801,
0.3847956061,
-0.2824135721,
-0.1731005013,
-0.0601247661,
0.0450960025,
-0.1193099841,
-0.4116877019,
-0.2386510819,
0.030381253,
0.367385149,
0.1131345555,
0.448402226,
0.1878909022,
-0.2401874661,
-0.2101333141,
0.6001534462,
0.4731006324,
0.7968249917,
-0.2625632584,
0.1802879721,
0.3394050896,
-0.1366304308,
-0.0486178547,
-0.1368815452,
0.1242042109,
-0.1897523254,
0.2012090832,
0.745182693,
0.2203148752,
-0.6976662874,
0.0825494528,
-0.1054352075,
0.1454648077,
-0.7058448792,
0.3208978474,
0.132393226,
0.2298596799,
0.4614643157,
-0.1786822379,
0.1475969851,
-0.8879970312,
0.2653231919,
0.4041460454,
-0.2139482796,
-0.1981237531,
0.6484649181,
0.1568824351,
-0.4778519571,
0.6750451326,
0.347387284,
-0.4898812771,
0.6189035773,
0.7707737088,
0.95959723,
-0.3316796422,
0.1508493423,
0.3840320408,
-0.1488804519,
-0.0363330729,
0.1366829872,
-0.3682486117,
-0.6365846395,
-0.5479825139,
-0.2379685789,
-0.3919476271,
0.3825300038,
-0.6599735618,
-0.3018281758,
-0.5418497324,
-0.3952075839,
-0.3202974498,
-0.1165504381,
-0.6433544159,
0.3200969994,
0.1960123628,
0.8864517808,
-0.4408556521,
0.7237797976,
0.2363165319,
-0.3006310761,
-0.418061614,
-0.0110346191,
0.083261244,
-0.5449404716,
0.3657567501,
-0.0023589619,
-0.1856238097,
-0.0013064626,
-0.6941584349,
-0.6312140822,
1.1093056202,
0.254262507,
-0.5394609571,
0.0020056118,
0.2484730631,
0.6498522758,
-0.2696756721,
0.4864952564,
0.8154347539,
0.2770602703,
0.389626652,
-0.6933832169,
-0.1738809347,
-0.167713359,
0.1728669256,
0.4664833844,
-0.8555229902,
0.4656251371,
-0.0776319355,
-0.3381690383,
0.6153444052,
0.7102499008,
-0.028625872,
0.2299563885,
0.1503258646,
0.4887214303,
0.769584775,
-0.207000792,
1.0578186512,
0.0575240292,
-0.1634391546,
1.4261758327,
-0.2685125172,
0.8954664469,
0.9529476166,
0.1290819496,
0.5216199756,
0.5018841028,
0.3739235103,
0.3019731343,
0.3566479087,
-0.53008008,
-0.3354228437,
-0.2955182195,
-0.2035844326,
0.2452763766,
0.5815290809,
-0.2833205163,
-0.3856264651,
-0.0903130919,
0.1432246119,
-0.0836200416,
-0.5945739746,
0.9426927567,
0.3325277269,
-0.6253236532,
0.5246019959,
-0.501725316,
0.3195737004,
-0.5790341496,
-0.0574314855,
-0.576279819,
0.2332535386,
0.1646272391,
-0.765806675,
0.443382293,
-0.0857372209,
-0.3656958044,
-0.1816239059,
0.8312843442,
-0.7727008462,
-0.1831794977,
0.382389307,
0.6721271276,
-0.0558199324,
0.3221304715,
-0.4716862142,
0.2020106316,
-0.3047646582,
-0.4783866704,
0.1644827724,
0.2932426929,
-0.1872163415,
0.6733793616,
0.3147473633,
0.0299912374,
-0.2214426845,
0.003501639,
0.8506470919,
-0.7528114915,
-0.2457080632,
-1.1756863594,
0.4049084187,
-0.2410465032,
-0.1089830697,
0.6351074576,
0.431011945,
0.6763338447,
0.2178483605,
0.5770375729,
0.277803719,
0.6314147711,
-0.5866414905,
0.3885089159,
-0.3564600945,
0.512927711,
-0.0710845888,
-0.7818666101,
-0.2843839824,
0.2989234626,
-0.4133147299,
0.3008361459,
0.4906584322,
0.8065237999,
0.0621058159,
0.1396074444,
0.1757339835,
0.5469649434,
0.5118150115,
1.0452917814,
0.9991694093,
-0.426430434,
0.7297395468,
0.4019804001,
0.209103182,
0.1664917618,
-0.9893629551,
-0.9529466033,
-0.1491232961,
-0.1170250848,
-0.483561486,
0.4574500322,
0.8419067264,
0.2038714886,
-0.8686432242,
-0.3323963284,
0.0695061535,
0.0416876227,
0.2123554647,
-0.1660365313,
0.2561783493,
-0.1592648327,
-0.486749351,
0.2792761326,
0.5874598026,
0.1601696312,
-0.282587558,
-0.0068461522,
-0.215563789,
0.461054951,
0.6185313463,
0.6302690506,
-0.3930837214,
-0.52954638,
-0.1060930416,
0.1099463627,
0.3405126333,
0.9050874114,
-1.0218318701,
0.4997687638,
0.3432438076,
0.7172631025,
0.7524510026,
-0.0445956476,
0.9440319538,
-0.5375084877,
0.1434041262,
-0.0077253357,
0.1934766769,
0.3785348833,
-0.1592018157,
0.2750153244,
-0.0361563265,
-0.5639093518,
-0.6832419634,
0.4810876846,
-0.7418920994,
-0.301610142,
1.0608991385,
0.135025233,
-0.4053242207,
-0.0749927536,
-0.3485028148,
0.1866627336,
-0.2498672605,
0.6329105496,
0.8685258627,
-0.1890391111,
-0.5322161913,
-0.5053744912,
0.5200727582,
0.6671323776,
-0.8014531732,
0.1004808098,
0.8705614209,
0.1606523991,
0.1415532976,
0.8698061109,
-0.0039834878,
0.2732711136,
-0.1989902854,
-0.3771074414,
0.1046540365,
-0.3695821762,
-0.1865154952,
0.0703531057,
-0.0869277194,
0.1249235421
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10993v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10993v1 | CoSTA: Code-Switched Speech Translation using Aligned Speech-Text Interleaving | 2024-06-16T16:10:51 | 2024-06-16T16:10:51 | Bhavani Shankar, Preethi Jyothi, Pushpak Bhattacharyya | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS | Code-switching is a widely prevalent linguistic phenomenon in multilingual
societies like India. Building speech-to-text models for code-switched speech
is challenging due to limited availability of datasets. In this work, we focus
on the problem of spoken translation (ST) of code-switched speech in Indian
languages to English text. We present a new end-to-end model architecture COSTA
that scaffolds on pretrained automatic speech recognition (ASR) and machine
translation (MT) modules (that are more widely available for many languages).
Speech and ASR text representations are fused using an aligned interleaving
scheme and are fed further as input to a pretrained MT module; the whole
pipeline is then trained end-to-end for spoken translation using synthetically
created ST data. We also release a new evaluation benchmark for code-switched
Bengali-English, Hindi-English, Marathi-English and Telugu- English speech to
English text. COSTA significantly outperforms many competitive cascaded and
end-to-end multimodal baselines by up to 3.5 BLEU points. | [
-0.0106454557,
-0.5246779919,
0.0177461375,
0.7263356447,
-0.604208529,
0.5082615614,
-0.4544942677,
-0.5145124197,
-0.0300999489,
0.3637061715,
-0.3402118087,
-0.2342381179,
-0.5898008347,
0.1847209483,
-0.6641738415,
1.1021988392,
-0.1799039692,
0.5190832615,
-0.0984183475,
-0.0771750137,
-0.6578915119,
-0.4420956969,
-0.4699639678,
-0.2672881484,
0.2739344537,
0.3543603122,
0.6079429388,
0.4660544395,
0.3559337556,
0.2349217534,
0.1022232994,
0.1837830842,
-0.2380621284,
-0.1440109462,
-0.2923491597,
-0.4870194793,
-0.4255021811,
-0.2118552625,
0.6718411446,
0.4184114635,
-0.1899154186,
0.1544757038,
0.2596159875,
0.4662135839,
-0.3250726163,
0.3863356113,
-0.8994591236,
-0.2836958766,
-0.553047061,
-0.2906633317,
-0.6608299017,
-0.3509516418,
-0.143340528,
-0.2998278141,
-0.0806864649,
-0.1898148656,
0.8697081804,
0.4030323327,
-0.3509663939,
-0.5352101922,
-0.8386811018,
0.5414188504,
-0.7062497139,
0.6971698999,
0.3175567985,
0.4313287437,
0.3263213634,
-0.6121339202,
-0.6827990413,
0.0074182823,
0.0687024519,
0.323302567,
-0.1339764148,
-0.0939558521,
-0.183114171,
0.1924946606,
-0.5215422511,
-0.0120841675,
-0.6390481591,
-0.0171358045,
0.7307505012,
-0.1346441805,
0.3804710209,
0.0233642403,
-0.5032668114,
-0.1270267367,
-0.6637598872,
0.0927215666,
0.646243751,
0.5543953776,
-0.3968654871,
0.3162503839,
0.0296059549,
0.9395431876,
-0.0831181109,
-0.0564891584,
0.308087945,
-0.2163882107,
-0.2186630368,
0.4113468826,
0.5835910439,
0.188703686,
0.2238347381,
-0.0132933594,
-0.1872843951,
0.4542844594,
0.1769202203,
-0.2155305743,
0.0375691801,
-0.0206468105,
-0.2953476012,
-0.0288756248,
-0.312367022,
-0.7195549607,
0.1947073787,
-0.3265730441,
0.3702541292,
-0.4383963048,
-0.3530926406,
0.2388275117,
0.3202814162,
0.7513384223,
0.2119682431,
-0.6937686205,
0.3544470966,
0.5278936625,
0.8504282236,
-0.4651063085,
-0.2754554152,
-0.3301756978,
0.2919305861,
-0.2934271991,
0.781511426,
-0.7558935285,
-0.5352836847,
0.3540408015,
-0.1016680449,
-0.285951525,
-0.2221520543,
0.7551330924,
-0.6359913945,
0.1757951379,
0.1692528278,
-0.1763359159,
0.05992781,
0.0416731127,
-0.304297328,
0.8722201586,
-0.3034318388,
-0.3604435325,
0.0633668825,
-0.3474857211,
-0.8239114881,
0.1535544842,
-0.3120378554,
-0.3807410002,
-0.0450382419,
0.1753624529,
0.096662268,
-0.4413666725,
0.3604959548,
0.1422265172,
-0.3045653105,
0.3170516193,
-0.6304609179,
0.7110314369,
0.6435776949,
-0.0618219823,
0.0710977763,
-0.7013272643,
0.183891207,
-0.1513481736,
-0.3668635488,
-0.2297300845,
0.050098069,
0.3635396063,
0.4487511814,
0.4175840616,
-0.6645638347,
0.1041433588,
-0.1564307511,
0.6028100848,
0.4401243627,
-0.3609869778,
0.327452302,
-0.2580420375,
0.5771992207,
0.0824953318,
0.099201031,
-0.1842219979,
-0.6725016236,
-0.7060644031,
-0.1313436925,
0.2559141219,
0.8116806746,
-0.7858783007,
0.0977033451,
-0.4503880441,
-0.3832035661,
-1.0566766262,
-0.2494746,
0.9386727214,
0.3758555949,
0.4964964986,
-0.0781532973,
-0.4059516788,
-0.9986507297,
-0.5094016194,
-0.0456283949,
0.3084112406,
-0.078259699,
0.0972727984,
-0.3407660723,
0.7418717146,
-0.354772985,
-0.3566533327,
-0.3593181968,
-0.0113798808,
0.2928000987,
0.6755869985,
-0.0560071915,
-0.9278694391,
-0.8160582781,
0.2224256098,
-0.0789260119,
-0.467772305,
-0.3359612823,
0.0058870413,
0.401823163,
0.8481048942,
-0.1574351937,
0.4929742515,
0.9848761559,
0.0955577493,
0.2870999277,
-0.4020140469,
0.4114663005,
-1.2602975368,
0.1580676585,
-0.3561658263,
-0.2515904605,
-0.6349462867,
0.0126550971,
0.4305419922,
-0.3463206589,
-0.7139894366,
0.2284129411,
-0.5148851275,
-0.3170489371,
-0.1862057745,
0.1648088396,
-0.1561148614,
0.702698648,
0.1174190119,
1.135607481,
0.2356614619,
-0.5985095501,
-0.0969791487,
0.6754754782,
-0.2774693966,
0.6725772619,
-0.5645770431,
0.2433725744,
0.0346753486,
0.1878017336,
-1.3326349258,
0.1597027481,
-0.0545727946,
-0.745480895,
0.4101211429,
-0.322106421,
-0.2492423207,
-0.0347857624,
0.2019862384,
0.7569534779,
0.3924559057,
-0.5898906589,
0.0966014937,
0.6914951801,
-0.3128586709,
-0.3393009007,
-0.9226105213,
0.2448662817,
0.0899018794,
-0.5198554397,
0.497431159,
-0.1165133119,
0.1396804005,
-0.1568839848,
-0.1365650743,
-0.3958435953,
-0.5440055132,
0.0684613287,
0.3197684884,
-0.0612161383,
-0.1055076197,
0.3711129427,
-0.368399322,
-0.2121843696,
-0.2950641513,
0.8678403497,
-0.1259137839,
-0.5225657821,
-0.2418280244,
0.5999693274,
0.3965314329,
-0.6682918072,
0.3148126304,
0.2399044931,
-0.4080189466,
-0.0753088966,
-0.2601986527,
0.5296342373,
-0.418456465,
0.4355477989,
-0.7009187937,
-0.537432611,
0.5642219782,
-0.1002249345,
0.2346692383,
0.2436579168,
0.6457585096,
-0.0621035993,
1.1090523005,
0.5058528185,
0.0651314333,
0.5299662948,
-0.005453439,
0.5698791742,
-0.7999814153,
-0.2688528001,
-0.674597919,
-0.1436387002,
-0.5897415876,
-0.7401985526,
0.4682282507,
-0.0771850795,
0.2816035748,
0.7115377188,
-0.5400769114,
0.4330430627,
0.1695896536,
0.0431706272,
0.5049518347,
-0.1959766001,
0.0679446235,
-0.1798577905,
-0.5455591679,
-0.3436622024,
0.8916982412,
0.0790383518,
0.8742467165,
0.1772061288,
0.3479947448,
0.4947037697,
0.0967477188,
-0.4074124694,
0.5994567871,
-0.543648541,
-0.4437532127,
0.0548285171,
-0.1034329832,
-0.847571075,
0.2942653298,
-0.1096902862,
-0.2194389552,
0.098340705,
0.1386089623,
-0.0037196553,
0.1926392764,
-0.7470110059,
0.5058037043,
-0.418147862,
-0.2763729393,
-0.5780332685,
-0.8451285362,
0.2672203779,
-0.0632922724,
0.2844508886,
0.0879723355,
-0.0340945497,
0.52526474,
-0.3497478962,
0.5180882812,
0.1349059492,
-0.2654437125,
0.1343825907,
-0.1377474368,
0.3518504202,
-0.0805730969,
-0.1021759287,
0.5536829233,
0.0284259636,
-0.386141479,
-0.2002984434,
0.6276189685,
-0.788723886,
-0.2991317809,
-0.5970545411,
-0.6127895713,
-0.4400994182,
0.1569066346,
0.4796446562,
0.6293594241,
-0.1673283875,
-0.0710490718,
0.6556261182,
-0.3852154911,
0.5354059935,
0.6365221739,
-0.238079384,
-0.6604588628,
0.9337924719,
0.1470064819,
0.6892994046,
0.6669294238,
-0.29272753,
-0.4985230565,
-0.5657777786,
-0.8394831419,
0.2222414464,
-0.4163684547,
-0.2762258947,
-0.6125135422,
-0.456886977,
-0.4905471802,
-0.594517827,
-0.5298321843,
-0.1624065787,
0.1450821459,
0.170673877,
0.0900110751,
0.61026299,
0.0109418631,
0.6229593158,
-0.7239819169,
0.2045420855,
0.1018277407,
0.4488157928,
-0.5222912431,
-0.7456163764,
-0.458132863,
0.1611389518,
0.1192818359,
-1.0163543224,
0.6317228079,
0.2246795148,
0.3735702932,
0.128995508,
-0.0917543173,
1.1013486385,
-0.7843136787,
0.3945583701,
0.2448315024,
-1.1615555286,
0.478649497,
-0.5431939363,
0.3992693424,
0.7427006364,
0.125244692,
-0.7658810019,
-0.3085156977,
-0.2847568989,
-0.8584038019,
0.6469917893,
0.0562155358,
-0.0194539595,
0.034123484,
-0.028640151,
0.2123476565,
0.3299116194,
-0.6494925022,
0.0261648763,
-0.0587571487,
-0.3106776476,
-0.1883512437,
0.1262397617,
0.1003595516,
-0.3489631414,
0.6618070602,
0.0001466108,
0.3235017955,
0.2266544998,
-0.5792982578,
-0.0683083683,
0.399219811,
0.6909068823,
0.4133978188,
0.0054962086,
-0.090143092,
0.2001233995,
-0.4438477159,
-0.0566686802,
0.2069274187,
-0.1756891608,
0.1157552227,
0.1332196295,
0.7957432866,
0.5857957602,
-0.6309022903,
0.3985463083,
0.026321169,
0.1882972121,
-0.3779179454,
-0.2633798718,
0.0119597623,
-0.0312067457,
0.097631909,
0.4119957983,
-0.101455614,
-0.5618139505,
0.2934187651,
0.2767081261,
-0.5535074472,
-0.3585546911,
0.9177142978,
0.651946485,
-0.7536794543,
0.2710227966,
0.0021706428,
-0.4754998386,
0.2070889026,
1.042375803,
0.9053634405,
-0.5433394909,
0.1241097078,
0.1724751741,
0.3860024214,
0.0470319092,
0.3674867451,
-0.1730103046,
-0.4375366271,
-0.3109681308,
-0.6007866859,
-0.5134177208,
-0.2166379392,
-0.866525352,
0.6870199442,
-0.1631326377,
0.1596209109,
-0.5339454412,
-0.2480392158,
-0.4602102339,
0.2152134329,
0.1286434382,
0.8993291259,
-1.042262435,
1.3241550922,
0.7218156457,
-0.4516924024,
-0.4620396495,
0.002177211,
-0.2278718799,
-1.134937048,
0.1965008974,
-0.0326420516,
-0.3497697115,
0.2969343662,
-0.3558429778,
-0.8827165961,
0.8462927341,
0.3012559116,
-0.6218528748,
0.1815079749,
0.5482324958,
0.5205016732,
-0.4119561017,
0.1919609308,
0.4963975549,
-0.0289722066,
0.0849898234,
-1.1275669336,
-0.5005247593,
-0.5463070273,
0.0804019496,
0.4316108525,
-0.9126349092,
0.9422837496,
0.083618544,
-0.2835002542,
-0.123233825,
0.6619744301,
0.1283741444,
0.2780296504,
0.6030730605,
0.4642455876,
0.314224869,
0.0339112617,
0.6173596978,
-0.5605506301,
-0.0425946601,
1.2093185186,
-0.5107852817,
1.24041152,
0.4675816894,
-0.2165882736,
0.406350255,
0.4370987713,
0.5870099068,
0.7083910108,
0.0370202363,
-0.3059454858,
-0.0541996397,
-0.0183538441,
-0.6784722805,
0.6586059928,
0.586791873,
0.0299107358,
-0.2899372578,
0.0828470811,
0.1610409021,
0.4461436868,
-0.222357288,
0.6405814886,
-0.0239703543,
-0.8826603889,
0.5236455798,
0.019305883,
0.8950712681,
-1.054700017,
-0.0866434127,
-0.1805508435,
0.2393955588,
-0.1131462008,
-0.6940689683,
0.5724921227,
0.3101335466,
-0.0128599778,
-0.8343700767,
0.5869352221,
-0.9401165247,
-0.3105877042,
0.336286068,
0.1826371402,
0.2362610996,
0.3051727712,
-0.6239129901,
0.3639590442,
0.2365378737,
0.4521010518,
0.3232885897,
0.0425086729,
-0.3356993496,
0.4689216614,
0.8980031013,
0.266734153,
0.4035198987,
0.0677705482,
0.6221059561,
-0.4223641455,
-1.019056797,
-0.5597596765,
0.6567386389,
-0.0953062102,
-0.6993455887,
0.6356286407,
0.8228325844,
0.9874538779,
-0.1098349541,
0.7893952131,
-0.0526635386,
0.4985044003,
-0.4487624764,
0.8568642139,
-0.2749861479,
0.2501266599,
-0.3133590519,
-0.7125324011,
-0.1319575161,
0.5487826467,
-0.2904215455,
-0.5202853084,
0.5444573164,
0.7881838679,
-0.1162768975,
-0.0126253823,
0.403626889,
0.1099333018,
0.4457627535,
0.6081988215,
0.5372849107,
-0.6997374892,
0.8001822829,
0.2381673306,
-0.4528797269,
-0.2243724763,
-0.7076949477,
-0.3811938763,
-1.1013065577,
-0.2149453461,
-0.3830727637,
0.2449533045,
0.7783762217,
0.4772914052,
-0.7598500252,
-0.6656761765,
-0.0242572967,
-0.051687412,
-0.1734451801,
-0.1099122539,
0.0678553656,
-0.376113385,
-0.9600850344,
0.568932116,
0.5411568284,
-0.3432036936,
-0.1371452361,
-0.1740732491,
-0.620649159,
0.3614116609,
0.5613010526,
0.4972699285,
-0.4745350778,
-0.0823535174,
-0.134097442,
-0.3246728778,
0.1124587357,
0.8966118693,
-0.6398738027,
0.5476450324,
0.6349239945,
0.9557516575,
0.5435010791,
-0.0984760374,
0.7693598866,
-0.7067850828,
0.3918999135,
0.1268282533,
0.3001339436,
0.2904508114,
-0.0349764787,
0.4145498574,
0.0923678651,
-0.5915361643,
-0.9486663342,
0.3562369347,
-1.1560493708,
0.1494900137,
1.1826183796,
0.0812335536,
-0.1490179896,
-0.2593817413,
-0.4300374687,
0.5457851887,
-0.2798148692,
0.5664269924,
0.3687755167,
-0.0944919214,
0.0594813488,
-0.4192708135,
0.4270234108,
0.6591488719,
-0.9528368711,
-0.0064327852,
0.2404575348,
0.0744681358,
0.0297414884,
0.9480131269,
-0.3893446326,
0.1440240294,
-0.118250303,
0.1987556517,
0.1065432951,
-0.2950201333,
-0.5913093686,
-0.3436784446,
-0.3361895084,
-0.8257127404
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10991v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10991v1 | Adaptive Query Rewriting: Aligning Rewriters through Marginal Probability of Conversational Answers | 2024-06-16T16:09:05 | 2024-06-16T16:09:05 | Tianhua Zhang, Kun Li, Hongyin Luo, Xixin Wu, James Glass, Helen Meng | cs.CL | cs.CL | Query rewriting is a crucial technique for passage retrieval in open-domain
conversational question answering (CQA). It decontexualizes conversational
queries into self-contained questions suitable for off-the-shelf retrievers.
Existing methods attempt to incorporate retriever's preference during the
training of rewriting models. However, these approaches typically rely on
extensive annotations such as in-domain rewrites and/or relevant passage
labels, limiting the models' generalization and adaptation capabilities. In
this paper, we introduce AdaQR ($\textbf{Ada}$ptive $\textbf{Q}$uery
$\textbf{R}$ewriting), a framework for training query rewriting models with
limited rewrite annotations from seed datasets and completely no passage label.
Our approach begins by fine-tuning compact large language models using only
~$10\%$ of rewrite annotations from the seed dataset training split. The models
are then utilized to generate rewrite candidates for each query instance. A
novel approach is then proposed to assess retriever's preference for these
candidates by the probability of answers conditioned on the conversational
query by marginalizing the Top-$K$ passages. This serves as the reward for
optimizing the rewriter further using Direct Preference Optimization (DPO), a
process free of rewrite and retrieval annotations. Experimental results on four
open-domain CQA datasets demonstrate that AdaQR not only enhances the in-domain
capabilities of the rewriter with limited annotation requirement, but also
adapts effectively to out-of-domain datasets. | [
-0.0458992384,
-0.9910895228,
0.4111124873,
-0.1682384908,
-0.2313692868,
-0.0470604077,
-0.0161274169,
0.0012027618,
0.1875000894,
0.8518298268,
-0.6178565025,
-0.4077302217,
-0.0616750978,
0.038064979,
-0.0700391456,
0.9399646521,
-0.0731150508,
-0.0432850569,
-0.5030109286,
-0.3048928976,
-0.4414707422,
-0.6801496744,
-0.8940023184,
0.1003332809,
0.6306282878,
0.3921581209,
0.7636403441,
0.7767558098,
0.4256134927,
0.2216031402,
-0.0152222542,
0.0967707336,
-0.4901916683,
0.5346061587,
-0.1325979233,
-0.762185812,
-0.4087186456,
-0.3280763328,
0.8198055029,
0.848398447,
-0.6608986855,
0.0188938826,
-0.0430578329,
0.9228878021,
-0.6929291487,
-0.2521685958,
-1.2097511292,
-0.0688000023,
0.1137608886,
-0.4962260127,
-0.5038274527,
-0.7317078114,
0.1934880167,
-0.8541520834,
0.6249408722,
0.4972240329,
0.5452102423,
0.4298360348,
-0.7106480002,
-0.310870856,
-0.4970577955,
0.7729905248,
-0.4619944394,
0.4659341276,
0.2579221129,
0.5634484291,
-0.4423186481,
-0.6061151624,
-0.5046898723,
0.0190760251,
0.1265761852,
0.0857734382,
-0.2393982112,
0.0751065388,
-0.0961646587,
0.4886944294,
-0.3667564988,
-0.1096097231,
-0.3817827702,
-0.2106125057,
0.6671842337,
0.382181406,
0.1080809087,
0.1728722304,
-0.2743454874,
-0.1133460999,
-0.7814307213,
0.1649496108,
0.2586301863,
0.2854723334,
0.5542484522,
0.4203284681,
-0.3709897101,
0.7440173626,
0.5080507994,
0.1489084959,
0.0035211197,
-0.3246304989,
-0.3369957805,
0.0635660365,
0.5395265222,
0.331490159,
0.0697504133,
-0.0620350502,
-0.0131705692,
-0.5135111213,
0.4198589325,
-0.7617000937,
-0.2954796553,
0.2591612339,
-0.3621420562,
-0.1906820685,
-0.4766075313,
-0.5284320712,
-0.2641049027,
-0.1702653766,
0.4086014926,
-0.482011497,
-0.0169805735,
0.2015355974,
-0.0331011675,
0.45538342,
0.3603620529,
-0.8485946059,
0.3813375533,
0.7268868685,
0.4583599865,
-0.1189962775,
-0.0806034431,
-0.6718885899,
0.15350236,
-0.3162803948,
0.7875627279,
-0.7469713688,
-0.4304143488,
0.162282452,
0.2204949409,
-0.5485231876,
-0.5394307971,
0.9207566381,
-1.1714920998,
0.0855605379,
-0.2111891657,
-0.6615585685,
-0.1782257557,
0.1009175107,
-0.6605041623,
0.6444058418,
-0.1407887191,
-0.5874511003,
0.4261928201,
-0.3347392082,
-0.3946986198,
-0.2783231735,
0.0463892147,
-0.646240294,
0.2760089934,
0.4508066773,
-0.1926580667,
-0.0969375521,
0.1932606548,
-0.122936815,
-0.256498903,
0.5707901716,
-0.4895496368,
0.6351674199,
0.1074273884,
0.0286198724,
0.2338576764,
-0.6116713285,
0.2283863425,
-0.0503571294,
-0.5204349756,
-0.4145928025,
0.1807847768,
-0.3003168702,
-0.1140449345,
0.0221854262,
-0.6431308389,
0.3020651042,
-0.659622252,
0.3094927371,
0.769589901,
0.4531369209,
0.6249053478,
-0.4848363101,
0.7927241325,
-0.1088365391,
0.1213061735,
-0.0772885159,
-0.3118899465,
-1.011417985,
-0.104901433,
0.41591084,
0.3997988105,
-0.7655041218,
-0.0185302999,
-0.3217930794,
-0.3409159184,
-1.0337947607,
0.0564693436,
0.6258338094,
0.5690761805,
0.4219614863,
-0.1645414084,
-0.295835644,
-0.9699611664,
-0.5415343642,
-0.1110224724,
0.1442583799,
0.5573414564,
0.1078938842,
0.3790633082,
0.733420372,
-0.829680562,
-0.3227308989,
0.0742226839,
-0.2277974039,
0.2090673745,
0.4264958799,
0.1725153625,
-0.9762856364,
-0.6092262268,
-0.2410253435,
-0.4138662517,
-0.0446070246,
-0.1497112364,
-0.5665573478,
0.2396962494,
0.5733231902,
-0.3030466437,
0.3988649249,
0.0215340275,
-0.2140331119,
0.3424800336,
-0.3224608302,
0.2440392077,
-0.890458405,
-0.1531147063,
-0.3102821112,
-0.0298095569,
-0.503882885,
0.1707077175,
-0.0048713298,
0.000565845,
-0.398224622,
0.4885772765,
-0.6573169827,
0.1970272958,
-0.3387913704,
0.0829225853,
0.2060914487,
0.5732132196,
0.1405647844,
0.7626527548,
0.412714541,
-0.7425059676,
0.1806378514,
0.7193452716,
0.0062053045,
0.6220185757,
-0.7386705875,
0.5691118836,
-0.2552886903,
0.4253762662,
-1.120424509,
-0.0957678035,
0.2802791595,
-0.5579349399,
0.1331834048,
-0.6213237047,
0.0316403024,
0.036552459,
-0.3515716791,
0.5578307509,
0.2516746223,
-0.4599404633,
0.7090014815,
0.1805583537,
-0.297763437,
-0.6792172194,
-0.3425112963,
-0.0663519204,
-0.2503526211,
-0.5915330648,
0.4728663266,
-0.0828181505,
0.0234317929,
-0.1112627909,
-0.2505418956,
-0.1623970568,
-0.0498156063,
0.1926568747,
0.1032844633,
-0.4074089825,
0.1132662892,
0.4427630305,
0.0695372075,
0.1346400082,
-0.3562321663,
0.1663683206,
0.1403357834,
-0.489461571,
-0.3603228927,
0.5360324383,
0.2339161038,
-0.3788069487,
0.8548983335,
0.1426554471,
-0.0516038239,
-0.1284466386,
-0.4951974154,
-0.0792990848,
-0.4793431759,
0.2364097983,
-0.7858677506,
-0.9382145405,
0.3660777509,
0.3619531095,
0.2592781782,
0.3817935288,
0.5504850745,
0.1490749717,
0.9048814178,
0.5908330679,
0.2057707161,
0.5432155728,
0.1177283302,
0.0991662294,
-1.0982209444,
-0.1752107292,
-0.4998579621,
-0.1561034322,
-0.712341547,
-0.4190786779,
0.3780308366,
-0.0198906157,
-0.2943435907,
-0.0300746784,
-0.5924305916,
0.5003574491,
0.832985878,
0.2199112475,
0.460221827,
0.1558472812,
-0.1192329973,
-0.0788042694,
-0.6314482093,
-0.4093329608,
1.5014088154,
0.01241263,
0.8137776852,
0.4195361137,
0.6533235908,
0.1917805076,
0.2146354169,
-0.7403851151,
0.4083884656,
0.0675917491,
-0.7719862461,
-0.5032714605,
-0.361813575,
-1.167131424,
0.5518490076,
-0.104633145,
-0.4166918993,
0.5499529839,
0.3292254508,
-0.5613515973,
0.0104990415,
-0.6918554306,
0.7778100967,
-0.0982178226,
-0.4788525701,
-0.1063409448,
-0.6152692437,
0.0960443392,
-0.0214646924,
-0.1171213463,
0.0196620896,
-0.1825576276,
0.6827453971,
-0.2907818556,
0.6892789602,
-0.3986251652,
-0.0520365685,
0.4915846586,
0.3473893702,
0.41337502,
0.0560033508,
-0.4679836333,
-0.5189847946,
0.2790754139,
-0.5011516809,
-0.641063869,
0.5085238218,
-0.5244182944,
-1.0732091665,
-0.4479945898,
-0.3353667855,
-0.3861415386,
0.1618444473,
-0.0361045413,
0.3521968424,
-0.5320514441,
0.2371281534,
0.6497291923,
-0.2996474206,
0.0334284045,
0.7630144954,
-0.0249697808,
-0.5098963976,
0.6839827895,
-0.2414451689,
0.439647615,
0.5988408923,
0.0227543786,
-0.5715970397,
-0.8796704412,
-0.5805206895,
0.0586090721,
-0.8155856729,
-0.2765134275,
-0.8580143452,
-0.1168450639,
-0.4840518236,
-0.0581107549,
0.1491867602,
-0.6018487215,
-0.0389849134,
0.0770999044,
0.3973882794,
0.0703608617,
0.2463329136,
0.3484843671,
-0.5181074739,
0.2678997815,
0.3791097105,
0.1584582925,
0.0610908344,
-0.9096136689,
-0.0572213642,
0.1744042635,
-0.551217556,
-0.580691874,
0.3725918829,
0.7195478678,
0.5294952989,
0.0181900859,
0.5546940565,
0.6289834976,
-0.7057885528,
0.4354760051,
-0.2694036067,
-0.4872407317,
0.6728697419,
-0.3390325606,
-0.1335378587,
0.9519218206,
0.3383153081,
-0.4193531573,
-0.2446099818,
-0.4721422493,
-0.9564860463,
0.5691351891,
0.1396945715,
0.27707991,
-0.0992779285,
0.6304479837,
0.1263802052,
0.1878499687,
-0.26786533,
-0.0689112023,
-0.1457787156,
-0.2193938196,
0.0917493626,
-0.3417892158,
-0.1517775804,
-0.0101467259,
0.7547490001,
-0.24257572,
0.1422448307,
0.3657355011,
-0.1301535219,
-0.0753585994,
0.5398911834,
0.0819913521,
0.4891590178,
-0.5056447387,
-0.1616548151,
0.0183377471,
-0.4360161126,
0.3014833331,
0.1551846415,
-0.3189941049,
-0.2420473695,
0.0291551128,
0.5043725371,
0.0236804895,
-0.4829096794,
0.4392421246,
-0.3699165881,
-0.1787113398,
-0.2791906297,
0.3278463483,
0.0427080579,
0.0642074347,
0.390402019,
-0.3409614563,
0.3797509074,
-0.4894402921,
0.2762007713,
0.4855276644,
-0.5118457079,
-0.2088330984,
0.9130721688,
0.2764292657,
-0.2731730342,
0.6713673472,
0.0475010164,
-0.2632061839,
0.3291110098,
0.7461996078,
0.8389750719,
-0.2703811824,
0.0047394866,
0.3915966451,
0.0332447216,
0.2497684807,
0.1640780717,
-0.0624210984,
-0.7035602927,
-0.1727579087,
-0.8107177019,
-0.6681006551,
-0.2900002003,
-0.8573970795,
-0.0584897399,
-0.2065211833,
0.0702147633,
0.4028224945,
0.0053916583,
-0.3895655572,
0.3059749305,
-0.4816316664,
0.7808907628,
-0.5616443753,
0.6548412442,
0.8087126017,
-0.5592976213,
-0.5196807384,
0.2078224719,
-0.0527055636,
-0.9484680295,
0.3176239729,
-0.3249016404,
-0.150153622,
0.188855499,
-0.2877942026,
-0.8396520615,
1.0080686808,
0.3666913807,
-0.355165422,
-0.0580829792,
0.0593239069,
0.544813633,
-0.5279020667,
0.1337645948,
0.4784778655,
-0.0283138584,
0.3395723701,
-0.7212185264,
0.3320724368,
-0.1548481435,
-0.027651133,
0.2120117694,
-0.7148551941,
0.523627162,
-0.2193149924,
-0.2022136897,
0.3020604253,
0.6563301086,
0.2172760665,
0.373054117,
0.4615195394,
0.2672924101,
0.6833145618,
0.0634209663,
0.9225931168,
-0.04858578,
0.0194413755,
1.3232556581,
-0.3271322846,
1.0407197475,
0.4775982499,
-0.2098922282,
0.4977450371,
0.5208116174,
0.3477263451,
0.6268618107,
0.5068280697,
-0.365729481,
-0.3545697927,
-0.1734792888,
-0.2104441673,
0.4518176317,
0.1032036543,
-0.3137861788,
0.0604839101,
-0.2719418705,
0.0244925432,
0.3195660412,
-0.1807921231,
1.0366322994,
0.061798986,
-1.0291882753,
0.959875226,
-0.0594426058,
0.3135284781,
-0.1617889255,
0.0023973431,
-0.4994371831,
0.4347406924,
-0.0767289922,
-0.7019726038,
0.332914412,
-0.1690707803,
-0.2649240792,
0.016529562,
0.6055550575,
-0.3943544626,
-0.5111967325,
-0.2326208353,
0.5003433824,
0.0761864856,
-0.3808725178,
-0.6469809413,
-0.3320552409,
0.2929114103,
-0.1850129366,
0.4660722017,
0.705488503,
-0.2277312577,
0.7723673582,
0.6913734674,
-0.2204157412,
0.0416126586,
0.1565096527,
0.9986960888,
-0.8054101467,
-0.4510222673,
-0.5381641984,
0.2213465869,
0.0297492966,
-0.1718485653,
0.8010646701,
0.8689662814,
0.5541120768,
0.1395266354,
0.6748410463,
0.220323801,
0.7240146995,
-0.5618470311,
0.4654616416,
-0.5325210094,
0.2430395335,
-0.0939790681,
-0.8583117723,
-0.1371362507,
0.2542575896,
-0.4877888858,
-0.1362025887,
0.3675757647,
1.038700223,
0.0278058667,
-0.0757107735,
0.1244415864,
-0.0792640969,
0.33057639,
0.8936130404,
0.9082116485,
-0.4943202734,
0.9434677958,
0.1674812287,
-0.2419735342,
-0.3355924785,
-0.6097189784,
-0.7531903386,
-0.473325491,
-0.4663867354,
-0.4853496253,
0.3747305572,
0.5460215807,
0.2607138753,
-0.755439043,
-0.0020851747,
0.1369370669,
0.2603450716,
-0.2186638415,
-0.2044322789,
0.7216522098,
-0.3061412275,
-0.6062943935,
0.3466590643,
-0.0531467609,
-0.1414301395,
0.260692358,
0.1164644957,
-0.2509394288,
0.2899059653,
0.2075338662,
0.3478528559,
-0.6046037078,
-0.1913280189,
0.3949280977,
0.1871216297,
0.3106181622,
0.7324261069,
-0.6976693869,
0.569596827,
0.1953454763,
0.7550863028,
0.4964819551,
0.4297946393,
0.7157301903,
-0.7031068206,
-0.217738539,
0.3128715754,
0.0339004025,
0.3846264482,
-0.3761433959,
0.3554342687,
-0.0581408665,
-0.7652593851,
-0.7745910883,
0.2677998245,
-0.9001242518,
-0.0616570041,
1.1833429337,
-0.1577849686,
-0.4150570929,
-0.2452415377,
-0.430908531,
0.1562010497,
-0.4653179646,
0.6704323888,
0.2926048636,
-0.2587173283,
-0.0338385031,
-0.3726660907,
0.5160025358,
0.4626858532,
-0.3741789758,
0.5132873058,
0.6516649723,
0.5916826725,
-0.2283541411,
1.1027761698,
-0.0448494181,
0.3398436308,
0.0694297552,
-0.1986497939,
0.0214278754,
0.1307097822,
-0.4100036323,
0.1044723168,
0.3826458752,
-0.5317466259
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15474v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15474v1 | WundtGPT: Shaping Large Language Models To Be An Empathetic, Proactive Psychologist | 2024-06-16T16:06:38 | 2024-06-16T16:06:38 | Chenyu Ren, Yazhou Zhang, Daihai He, Jing Qin | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC | Large language models (LLMs) are raging over the medical domain, and their
momentum has carried over into the mental health domain, leading to the
emergence of few mental health LLMs. Although such mental health LLMs could
provide reasonable suggestions for psychological counseling, how to develop an
authentic and effective doctor-patient relationship (DPR) through LLMs is still
an important problem. To fill this gap, we dissect DPR into two key attributes,
i.e., the psychologist's empathy and proactive guidance. We thus present
WundtGPT, an empathetic and proactive mental health large language model that
is acquired by fine-tuning it with instruction and real conversation between
psychologists and patients. It is designed to assist psychologists in diagnosis
and help patients who are reluctant to communicate face-to-face understand
their psychological conditions. Its uniqueness lies in that it could not only
pose purposeful questions to guide patients in detailing their symptoms but
also offer warm emotional reassurance. In particular, WundtGPT incorporates
Collection of Questions, Chain of Psychodiagnosis, and Empathy Constraints into
a comprehensive prompt for eliciting LLMs' questions and diagnoses.
Additionally, WundtGPT proposes a reward model to promote alignment with
empathetic mental health professionals, which encompasses two key factors:
cognitive empathy and emotional empathy. We offer a comprehensive evaluation of
our proposed model. Based on these outcomes, we further conduct the manual
evaluation based on proactivity, effectiveness, professionalism and coherence.
We notice that WundtGPT can offer professional and effective consultation. The
model is available at huggingface. | [
-0.496288389,
-0.7555292249,
1.0282956362,
0.3104133606,
-0.2860238254,
-0.1351680905,
-0.5478987098,
-0.3629230559,
0.1838756502,
0.3229125738,
-0.6377249956,
-0.1386853755,
-0.7978479266,
-0.1546566337,
-0.0385373123,
0.8402399421,
0.0054159891,
0.2790870965,
0.1844886392,
0.0133937458,
-0.1247012615,
-0.4341871142,
-0.9766485095,
-0.6912884116,
0.7013844848,
0.1921847016,
0.9296707511,
0.2997698486,
0.5074372888,
0.2175936252,
-0.1929111481,
-0.1117126718,
-0.3234175444,
0.1191516817,
-0.2884411812,
0.0825809017,
-0.7421547174,
0.0856311619,
0.3291504383,
0.8697418571,
-0.7919080853,
0.025529759,
0.1733820289,
0.4469056427,
-0.0400737524,
0.1428747624,
-0.0376338586,
0.1235759035,
0.0479959846,
0.1520751864,
-0.2491530776,
-0.2950303555,
0.0390599556,
-0.402787894,
-0.1314683706,
-0.1976337284,
0.5041747689,
0.1105781272,
-0.6970430017,
-0.0486612692,
-0.6600378752,
0.4255937636,
-0.6465987563,
0.4059633017,
0.4622645676,
0.2040513456,
-0.302595675,
-0.8994356394,
-0.5980432034,
-0.3657536507,
-0.0210846104,
0.1725700051,
-0.4460813403,
0.2301619947,
0.2697294354,
0.355914712,
-0.3761833906,
0.2301569879,
0.0477815308,
0.023020763,
0.5685097575,
0.4080741704,
0.1895182729,
0.0611767881,
-0.0896225199,
0.1697028428,
-0.4034231305,
-0.0728597865,
0.0002752922,
0.0086668953,
-0.185076341,
0.4599865079,
0.2182405591,
0.6004223228,
0.4065060318,
-0.2491364032,
-0.4305882752,
0.3303586841,
-0.0543610193,
0.0270932782,
0.8223611712,
0.556299746,
0.6079921722,
-0.220913887,
0.0537062883,
0.15056777,
0.6738271117,
-1.0625178814,
-0.5597637892,
0.4385275841,
-0.6002301574,
-0.3278172314,
-0.1721855998,
-0.6410445571,
-0.6246109605,
-0.6270186901,
0.1125252023,
-0.5042841434,
-0.8312950134,
0.0313227437,
0.209317863,
0.1054920256,
0.2239108086,
-0.9934702516,
0.428856492,
0.6750380993,
0.5967873931,
0.2050381303,
-0.2709625959,
-0.5861038566,
0.2311087996,
-0.3047432601,
0.5856003761,
-0.7265257239,
-0.4045765698,
-0.0807058588,
-0.0222322196,
0.2728108168,
-0.0932003185,
0.4797844589,
-0.079197526,
0.2159137577,
-0.6372458935,
-0.6477212906,
0.1107162982,
0.5306211114,
-0.2486190647,
0.6841931939,
0.735225141,
-0.7846019864,
0.1539011002,
-0.8392782807,
-0.276248455,
0.3217284381,
-0.0670515671,
0.0983906239,
0.4051918685,
0.0952600986,
0.5587320924,
-0.4324734509,
0.371100992,
-0.3653945923,
-0.1719966531,
0.1992925107,
-0.0164423175,
0.6484971642,
-0.0372652821,
-0.129415974,
0.1966693997,
-0.5833604336,
0.216031462,
0.2525469661,
-0.2026515007,
-0.3173360825,
-0.260986656,
0.4594316781,
0.3572840691,
-0.1103524044,
-0.5345906615,
0.2947356999,
-0.2214661241,
0.4675821066,
0.8348889947,
0.1730083227,
0.2332625389,
-0.1684473455,
0.7412821054,
-0.1752335429,
0.4508990347,
0.1426217258,
-0.5791402459,
-0.125299111,
-0.6325643063,
-0.0047890488,
0.3822245896,
-0.2422193587,
0.513748765,
-0.0076717809,
-0.8989581466,
-0.5346925855,
0.0459293835,
0.2395921797,
0.7624223828,
0.2457184792,
-0.5554899573,
-0.2611777782,
-0.693844974,
-0.4050982296,
0.0743212625,
0.0706481189,
0.1770491153,
0.0695667788,
-0.5774927139,
0.543084085,
-0.4707255661,
-0.3392132521,
-0.4281585813,
-0.0134166237,
0.1500467658,
0.2354830652,
0.3161776364,
-0.6064147353,
-0.8018139005,
-0.0521946698,
-0.7205492258,
-0.042705141,
0.213727057,
-0.0998530388,
-0.3189322054,
0.2644261122,
-0.8595724106,
0.1546996981,
0.6768912673,
-0.8346996903,
0.4975123405,
-0.4130690396,
0.0249548797,
-1.1483124495,
0.0416381732,
0.1898374707,
-0.1884888262,
-0.7207408547,
0.0566427931,
-0.0352190174,
-0.119849354,
-0.2153312564,
0.6204180717,
-0.3767624795,
0.4139228165,
-0.2225917876,
0.0984063596,
-0.3554744422,
0.2493235171,
0.1313707978,
0.2829907238,
0.7053014636,
-0.3693307042,
0.7145028114,
0.3923735917,
-0.0253417008,
1.3492115736,
-0.5900140405,
0.2540607452,
0.0932584032,
0.2591940165,
-0.431627661,
-0.4437874854,
0.1234484166,
-0.1547172964,
0.528636992,
-0.1939034462,
-0.5955138803,
-0.3710151911,
0.1457185894,
0.2493947148,
0.8445588946,
-0.4572533369,
0.5820969343,
0.2749185264,
-0.5223119855,
-0.1166566387,
-0.342425704,
0.40226385,
-0.1831321567,
-0.5015621185,
0.2237738669,
-0.0431733578,
-0.5382665992,
-0.0134103894,
0.2229947597,
-0.0911056101,
-0.0184847955,
0.2231599241,
0.007886623,
0.0382788628,
0.229254812,
0.063147366,
-0.4683435559,
0.2556409538,
-0.0586227179,
0.7090352774,
-0.3916975856,
-0.4078969657,
-0.4932582974,
0.588117063,
0.6085432172,
-0.2492302954,
0.8640455604,
1.0545529127,
-0.4489205182,
0.0865338072,
-0.5062590241,
-0.6919849515,
-0.4283459485,
0.3892814815,
-0.3244711161,
-0.7962915301,
0.2647362947,
-0.2661060393,
-0.2627083659,
-0.0160409398,
0.8079235554,
-0.2894306481,
1.2031661272,
0.7792497277,
0.0844161585,
0.2164937407,
0.0637928024,
0.5468827486,
-1.0131434202,
-0.0920162424,
0.1573340744,
-0.1890850514,
-0.6484117508,
0.0631897748,
0.424810499,
0.0333179533,
-0.6429850459,
0.0332159773,
-0.7460134625,
0.1043884084,
0.3228965402,
0.4376540482,
0.0521812551,
-0.2320405394,
-0.0953905806,
-0.6807053089,
-0.3775271177,
-0.6125314832,
0.8431777954,
0.5257019401,
0.8386067748,
0.4603054821,
0.7030840516,
0.2638364136,
0.6504259706,
-0.881241858,
0.4203927815,
0.2422180772,
-0.2830881476,
-0.1469299793,
-0.3197641969,
-0.9091671109,
0.1647073179,
0.0983981565,
-1.0888994932,
-0.0195878372,
0.3735785782,
-0.0955988914,
0.3115941584,
-0.693905592,
0.9589588642,
-0.3980640471,
-0.4712952673,
-0.2817295194,
-0.6444886923,
0.3850628138,
-0.1627839208,
-0.0168425571,
-0.0955313444,
0.0100445291,
0.5400877595,
-0.245745644,
0.8630611897,
-0.4923920631,
-0.3495748341,
-0.2643293738,
0.5479177237,
0.5701885223,
0.1241343543,
0.006179254,
-0.2330446243,
0.3084481061,
-0.4467467964,
-0.651624918,
0.5563364625,
-0.5253617764,
-0.6842906475,
-0.3708702922,
-0.6465129256,
-0.7644160986,
0.3988416791,
0.0143453144,
0.4179750383,
-0.626930058,
-0.2149706781,
0.5679496527,
-0.0829871222,
0.0267988853,
0.7224474549,
-0.3672698736,
-0.0561399832,
0.4753491282,
-0.2559689283,
0.2067701668,
-0.0939635113,
0.6412649751,
-0.347427398,
-0.0240266081,
-0.0475014709,
0.6691257358,
-0.6686242223,
0.0528485626,
-0.5699520111,
-0.080743961,
-0.4094579518,
-0.378315717,
-0.4081658125,
-0.0360427834,
0.0093638012,
-0.182132706,
0.7516507506,
0.9218469262,
-0.3845190704,
0.339694798,
-0.8446223736,
0.1723237187,
0.3099806011,
0.4479502738,
0.2745006382,
-0.5617676377,
-0.1178127006,
-0.0720036626,
-0.4851300418,
-1.0151534081,
0.5018663406,
-0.0310986508,
0.3922218978,
0.8502992988,
0.0665744245,
0.3567321897,
-0.5037244558,
0.4951339662,
0.5423859954,
-0.9189197421,
0.4499732256,
-0.6410896778,
0.0932107866,
0.1531701088,
0.4569453001,
-0.9768862128,
-0.2690922022,
-0.8666012287,
-0.4569099545,
0.4422154725,
-0.1648756117,
0.340397805,
-0.0768876374,
0.382671833,
-0.1650951058,
0.0008095903,
-0.5792973638,
0.0528902747,
-0.0824724212,
-0.5430597067,
-0.1779413223,
-0.4603024423,
-0.7793733478,
-0.4475686252,
0.2285794318,
-0.1268502623,
0.6098786592,
0.3244292438,
0.2466802597,
-0.3199947476,
0.4908423722,
0.2845826447,
0.6691994071,
-0.1468179226,
0.1817016751,
-0.1058424413,
-0.578245461,
0.2721871138,
0.316019088,
0.5693430305,
-0.3181053102,
0.3460802734,
0.3861369193,
0.0302813705,
-0.5308943391,
0.6488962173,
0.0117853172,
-0.1262533814,
-0.183390677,
-0.0759653524,
0.5657730699,
0.5124104023,
-0.0029664962,
-0.3888637424,
-0.1313492358,
-0.6493023038,
0.1440934241,
0.3108083606,
-0.6169416308,
-0.5018753409,
0.5192069411,
0.0596342944,
-0.7691957951,
0.9321985245,
-0.2594536543,
-0.777125597,
0.2336972654,
0.7558904886,
0.7011098266,
-0.4366084933,
0.3143250048,
0.0440746099,
0.2468331307,
-0.2984866202,
0.4274185896,
-0.0581361204,
-0.6494915485,
-0.1457258165,
-0.2687647045,
-0.7051236033,
-0.06265793,
-1.1060366631,
-0.1484486908,
-0.4985335171,
-0.4551573992,
-0.3079008758,
0.0566524491,
-0.8474190235,
0.2397331297,
-0.0989424735,
0.8925238252,
-0.7708429098,
0.9661607742,
0.8482784033,
-0.4270848334,
-1.0360478163,
0.123362422,
0.0044334307,
-0.8971403241,
0.4069781303,
-0.0213458259,
0.1702050567,
0.3116321564,
-0.2405531257,
-0.3683789968,
1.0030859709,
0.5136243105,
-0.569858551,
-0.0895350277,
-0.1906137913,
0.7788608074,
-0.264141053,
0.2095451951,
0.6839625239,
0.7552028894,
-0.3975967169,
-1.1262181997,
0.4373675585,
-0.1581226289,
-0.1519847363,
0.233187452,
-0.6717890501,
0.561350584,
-0.6355602741,
0.2651956677,
0.0677136704,
-0.0253948197,
0.1963438094,
0.0023625954,
0.4074708819,
0.6441146731,
0.8949983716,
-0.0834531859,
1.3086972237,
-0.2320697159,
0.2301635593,
0.9951152802,
-0.5565456748,
0.821187377,
0.7688696384,
-0.2560455501,
0.4504648447,
0.672462523,
-0.2440662831,
0.5240962505,
0.1015596464,
-0.5563561916,
-0.2943803966,
-0.2474379689,
-0.394246608,
0.4444137812,
0.3878396749,
-0.4930149317,
-0.0507150441,
0.0886294544,
0.3260500729,
0.2050195336,
-0.2281619161,
0.564193666,
0.4906319678,
-0.557207942,
0.184297815,
0.0213578474,
0.2157445848,
-0.7666078806,
0.1202303469,
-0.2479742467,
0.4764237106,
-0.1889796704,
-0.959634006,
0.1154639944,
0.1235972419,
-0.2281526625,
-0.3264968991,
0.6234651208,
-0.357775867,
-0.5557544231,
0.4594752192,
0.7304574847,
0.1479575783,
-0.3682194054,
-0.7407457829,
-0.0970165953,
-0.2917884588,
-0.5128204226,
0.6503041387,
0.5395302773,
0.0233250074,
0.7595701218,
0.5383636951,
0.4167809188,
-0.5982857347,
0.359236747,
0.8094230294,
-0.7295217514,
-0.4262492955,
-0.7360765934,
0.5061628222,
-0.1177503169,
-0.080806978,
0.5898949504,
-0.0876213536,
0.0621025339,
-0.0538644306,
0.6156585813,
-0.1199964806,
0.4595805407,
-0.146331504,
0.8459316492,
-0.474612534,
-0.1723924726,
-0.3367244899,
-0.8315442801,
-0.1893006712,
0.8549253345,
-0.2143425494,
0.3422516584,
0.6823228598,
0.6278555393,
-0.0256839171,
-0.0289774854,
0.4337782562,
0.3263500035,
0.5758157969,
0.6353616118,
0.9377983212,
-0.0274424683,
0.1884496361,
-0.2778722644,
-0.516929388,
0.1618039906,
-0.999135077,
-0.8477576971,
-0.3100033104,
-0.2750851512,
-0.4509001672,
-0.2399843633,
1.0721716881,
0.7683146,
-0.2536948323,
0.0363080166,
-0.0406860635,
-0.3686447144,
-0.4809979498,
-0.2383850962,
0.4595103264,
0.076440461,
-0.3528969884,
0.0712821186,
0.4081983268,
0.0917782113,
-0.4041641057,
-0.2711336017,
0.3353605866,
0.0003284528,
0.7429814935,
0.1745772958,
-0.6891199946,
-0.0621843003,
0.0074581285,
-0.0807082951,
-0.1038205177,
0.9023119211,
-0.3422290981,
0.3535142243,
-0.446446985,
0.4367746115,
0.3726797104,
-0.0098659433,
0.80610919,
-0.1419793963,
0.2205820978,
0.4579903781,
0.3680579364,
0.4060732126,
-0.6488485932,
0.4612177014,
0.0480651595,
-0.6815316081,
-0.9476855993,
0.3965067565,
-1.0490422249,
-0.1036551893,
1.296639204,
-0.2785520256,
0.2528823018,
-0.187161833,
-0.6243288517,
0.1418457031,
-0.2802560627,
0.9552260041,
0.5836470723,
-0.527104795,
-0.6689110398,
-0.2606573403,
0.5420200229,
0.2913202047,
-0.6421009302,
0.1917389482,
0.1758432388,
0.5652129054,
-0.3488919139,
0.8726935983,
-0.0957682207,
0.3282445073,
0.086950101,
0.2697197795,
-0.159493506,
0.2723879218,
-0.0113249468,
-0.0738310888,
0.5958801508,
0.2921701968
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10985v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10985v1 | Taking a Deep Breath: Enhancing Language Modeling of Large Language Models with Sentinel Tokens | 2024-06-16T15:50:10 | 2024-06-16T15:50:10 | Weiyao Luo, Suncong Zheng, Heming Xia, Weikang Wang, Yan Lei, Tianyu Liu, Shuang Chen, Zhifang Sui | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have shown promising efficacy across various
tasks, becoming powerful tools in numerous aspects of human life. However,
Transformer-based LLMs suffer a performance degradation when modeling long-term
contexts due to they discard some information to reduce computational overhead.
In this work, we propose a simple yet effective method to enable LLMs to take a
deep breath, encouraging them to summarize information contained within
discrete text chunks. Specifically, we segment the text into multiple chunks
and insert special token <SR> at the end of each chunk. We then modify the
attention mask to integrate the chunk's information into the corresponding <SR>
token. This facilitates LLMs to interpret information not only from historical
individual tokens but also from the <SR> token, aggregating the chunk's
semantic information. Experiments on language modeling and out-of-domain
downstream tasks validate the superiority of our approach. | [
-0.1114068404,
-0.7211717367,
0.7123089433,
0.0590618663,
-0.7570325136,
0.4331852496,
-0.4402517974,
-0.2602036595,
0.3418976665,
0.6327492595,
-0.3013278246,
-0.5079062581,
-0.8046868443,
-0.1759651303,
-0.6531374454,
0.8145049214,
0.1817948818,
-0.3254671395,
-0.0269467384,
0.0727667958,
-0.4275331497,
-0.4395247996,
-0.724542141,
-0.2452977747,
0.5128668547,
0.1613025069,
0.6221086979,
0.5657740831,
0.5335270762,
0.2689034641,
-0.5663622618,
0.0949879438,
-0.472063154,
0.3077952266,
-0.2978086174,
-0.3888890743,
-0.2126326412,
-0.3539563417,
0.9470989108,
0.7769786716,
0.0214399137,
0.0645465702,
0.0525227338,
0.4575555623,
-0.5343261361,
0.1846957654,
-0.8073623776,
-0.064529039,
-0.3426524401,
-0.0150851831,
-0.5441527367,
0.1668471247,
0.253351897,
-0.2151032239,
0.0214086603,
-0.1100741252,
0.5536372662,
0.4835453629,
-0.384588182,
-0.0814076364,
-0.6580971479,
0.7094147205,
-0.990950048,
0.3357509673,
0.0733847171,
0.1125289723,
0.0790273324,
-1.0245990753,
-0.6706112623,
0.0926777795,
-0.1283525527,
0.0654734895,
-0.3579977751,
0.1205853522,
-0.1632327139,
0.4990786612,
-0.3861100376,
0.2784987688,
-0.3088162541,
-0.1249371395,
0.3734002113,
0.352262944,
0.2021072358,
-0.1219800636,
-0.4677112997,
0.0608559474,
-0.5580397844,
-0.1874863207,
-0.2690733969,
0.5926921964,
-0.1976341754,
0.5848132372,
-0.1280344576,
0.6206015348,
-0.2996072769,
-0.2082047462,
0.1619597077,
-0.1433795393,
-0.6054540277,
-0.1620543301,
0.6536704302,
0.1547680199,
-0.0152442968,
-0.1643145233,
-0.1916936338,
0.0491329432,
0.3562597632,
-1.0093721151,
0.1291905344,
0.514179647,
-0.5051677823,
-0.2639685273,
-0.2339098305,
-0.7220039368,
-0.572378695,
-0.4503639042,
0.2425716817,
-0.3403536975,
-0.2909975052,
0.4073092639,
-0.2479072809,
0.0988343954,
0.2506259382,
-0.6579551101,
0.4242635667,
1.0297554731,
1.0545284748,
-0.36449489,
-0.1825407594,
-0.5640470982,
0.1342618763,
-0.2413329035,
0.7432064414,
-0.7491132021,
-0.4730852842,
0.1459952891,
-0.2180999517,
-0.2027308047,
-0.6349167228,
0.416233927,
-0.6687152386,
0.0971327126,
0.2611771226,
-0.8677513599,
-0.1577593386,
0.2010295242,
-0.5457551479,
0.981213212,
0.0536276549,
-0.683611691,
-0.0443419851,
-0.6865058541,
-0.5544239283,
0.2590681016,
-0.164487198,
-0.2961835265,
0.5579408407,
0.2985880375,
0.6855088472,
-0.2412273139,
0.2829193175,
-0.0538276397,
-0.2586993277,
0.5004930496,
-0.4029394686,
0.5375447273,
0.3027970195,
-0.2680476904,
0.3262401819,
-0.3547420502,
-0.2496507615,
-0.0549756661,
-0.2033089399,
-0.3112459779,
0.0032810094,
0.0740728825,
0.1661361009,
0.0135204634,
-0.3144008219,
0.2129431516,
-0.4018970728,
0.6954074502,
0.690639019,
0.1630091667,
0.3666202426,
-0.2337624729,
0.6694198251,
0.1989629269,
0.1277069896,
-0.6635071635,
-0.3743020892,
-0.8744623065,
-0.8414251804,
0.2695380747,
0.145310089,
-0.5136272907,
0.5313848257,
-0.7250145078,
-0.5138109922,
-0.5645879507,
0.0078590717,
0.1968616694,
0.4582903087,
0.4195739031,
-0.3535339236,
-0.3600008786,
-0.5901570916,
-0.3873874545,
-0.1682281792,
-0.0919478312,
0.2026201189,
0.478965044,
-0.5089042187,
1.0604374409,
-0.7422391772,
-0.473308593,
-0.4759608805,
0.1250067502,
0.1163101345,
0.2507785857,
0.105018042,
-0.6503424644,
-0.1112673879,
-0.1554344743,
-0.4209692478,
0.0837431103,
-0.3221981823,
-0.1392743886,
0.0471208468,
0.8222723007,
-0.8475052714,
0.4322953522,
0.5467532873,
-0.4331105351,
0.3544718027,
0.121665962,
-0.4072881937,
-1.2325483561,
0.2003545314,
-0.3231782615,
-0.3225336671,
-0.7095828056,
0.3696836829,
0.0224883109,
-0.2506176233,
-0.7720261812,
1.0890097618,
-0.3109711707,
-0.0074060345,
-0.5366691947,
0.1935618669,
0.1617239863,
0.3299711347,
0.1970930099,
0.527551651,
0.5833733082,
-0.527910769,
-0.0067913667,
0.1606102735,
-0.5401290655,
0.2272892594,
-0.5858274698,
0.2393302321,
-0.2857097983,
0.6271787882,
-1.0499811172,
-0.3154825866,
-0.0992073715,
-0.4466584027,
0.4111922085,
-0.0639310628,
-0.5007320642,
-0.1443522424,
-0.2296889722,
0.4491648674,
0.5516213775,
-0.440048486,
1.0452437401,
0.6357265711,
-0.4224018455,
-0.2586770356,
-0.8739609718,
0.5213564038,
-0.5112572908,
-0.3952108622,
0.6128693223,
0.1430724114,
-0.3165574372,
0.0551814288,
-0.086119011,
-0.0440620705,
0.1804694533,
0.1490738392,
0.1060012802,
-0.1041141227,
0.5740072727,
0.0323412493,
-0.1342409402,
-0.0942273512,
-0.5985761285,
0.7394701242,
-0.0397725031,
-0.227419585,
-0.539239943,
0.4908308387,
0.903819263,
-0.5844113231,
0.8708170056,
0.506783247,
-0.6824185848,
-0.1534586996,
-0.668207705,
-0.2398464084,
-0.4275767207,
0.309535712,
-0.2460649014,
-1.3018685579,
0.5602309108,
-0.2753998637,
0.0003186011,
0.3257804811,
0.7314751744,
-0.0441770405,
0.5172655582,
0.7400344014,
-0.5474469662,
0.6652140617,
-0.3143591881,
0.3425598443,
-1.1044965982,
-0.0912750587,
-0.5018917322,
-0.304810226,
-0.087910831,
-0.9946149588,
0.329774946,
0.0218260363,
-0.1378449798,
0.0424221009,
-0.2799791992,
0.4791598022,
0.2311225086,
0.0963660255,
0.2416836321,
-0.1159470752,
-0.181207642,
0.0912310705,
-0.4691681564,
-0.5060181618,
0.7389761806,
0.5751795173,
0.8644788861,
0.0568425953,
0.7695916295,
0.0149017796,
0.3829676211,
-0.9182893038,
0.4280761778,
-0.2332270145,
-0.599598527,
-0.4096898139,
-0.260363549,
-0.9322126508,
0.454367131,
0.342353344,
-0.7703775764,
-0.0866649747,
-0.0739833862,
-0.5568902493,
0.1901989132,
-0.4892734289,
0.8177594543,
-0.0172835831,
-0.0531758703,
-0.4494531453,
-0.7176778913,
0.2735692859,
-0.1923178583,
0.4612533152,
-0.1094528735,
-0.3651219308,
0.6809698343,
-0.5105035305,
1.2816400528,
-0.088165842,
-0.1149091497,
0.5691028237,
0.0685749874,
0.5897838473,
-0.0902060941,
0.000290766,
0.047039222,
-0.5569464564,
-0.3297017813,
-0.6474004984,
0.458357662,
-0.4817576408,
-0.2903088033,
-0.2417389303,
-0.4066071808,
-0.1127950028,
0.3065584004,
-0.0376909338,
0.5351379514,
0.1179128662,
0.3848090172,
0.5688216686,
-0.2045537829,
0.6040117741,
0.5208064318,
-0.3237242103,
-0.4999077916,
0.6302571893,
-0.065682888,
0.2774016857,
0.6869994998,
0.4750733972,
-0.6893880963,
-0.502122581,
-0.1388095021,
0.3764617145,
-0.7303162813,
-0.3717721999,
-0.8081799746,
-0.2049355805,
-0.3945919275,
-0.1049106866,
-0.3275580406,
-0.3849107623,
-0.4093181193,
-0.317553848,
0.4086951911,
0.4714547396,
0.2342444211,
0.5718815327,
-0.9905411601,
0.2327129841,
0.2438517511,
0.2597025335,
0.1959480792,
-0.8817421794,
-0.3828982115,
-0.2211114764,
-0.0419846699,
-0.5350648165,
0.45746997,
0.2152391821,
0.252068758,
0.306853205,
0.0164613631,
0.9603254199,
-0.5166226029,
0.9971852899,
0.0041220351,
-1.2969857454,
0.4275304973,
-0.3460041285,
0.7178415656,
0.4420678616,
0.0447383784,
-0.8587599397,
-0.6986593008,
-0.5221477747,
-1.1176435947,
0.2874175012,
0.2014994174,
0.4794647992,
-0.2012853324,
0.193871662,
-0.0663627684,
0.1792305559,
-0.4655749202,
0.1726146787,
0.1616407931,
-0.4262702763,
-0.1215992272,
-0.3267531097,
0.0666960776,
-0.1081216186,
0.4867278337,
-0.3609587252,
0.2385994494,
0.1804305911,
-0.2964532077,
0.2710562646,
0.2149422616,
0.7562471032,
0.4441245198,
0.1911765337,
0.5922549367,
0.2014854252,
-0.4162195325,
-0.0853362307,
-0.0676566213,
0.1144765615,
0.1013671309,
0.5824642777,
0.7500218749,
0.4539428949,
-0.8681497574,
0.4159056246,
-0.1496592313,
0.2377139181,
-0.1023900732,
-0.2620259225,
0.5187065601,
0.2368122041,
0.4180950522,
-0.2465331256,
0.0083564278,
-0.4995018244,
0.2589512169,
0.3012813032,
-0.4068552554,
-0.1308143735,
0.5771841407,
0.3168683946,
-0.1720865071,
0.6058531404,
0.1717263162,
-0.6740039587,
0.2238922864,
0.484621346,
1.1459743977,
-0.1673076898,
-0.0849064887,
-0.0269460082,
0.1619923115,
0.0906734765,
0.0349510573,
-0.1822014749,
-0.5289978981,
-0.8638096452,
-0.770698905,
-0.3336293399,
0.3122830391,
-0.5405340791,
0.0195796695,
-0.1280409545,
-0.2597892284,
0.0418256,
-0.2304365933,
-0.6821343899,
0.4178960919,
0.3467936516,
1.1054311991,
-0.7926044464,
0.8039578199,
0.3801386356,
-0.1649173945,
-0.5992332697,
0.1883297861,
-0.004776781,
-0.7813396454,
0.5304005742,
0.3548452258,
-0.159558624,
-0.0344057642,
-0.2017190456,
-0.9323237538,
0.8682166934,
0.2025539428,
-0.5918779373,
0.0361737348,
0.2739897668,
0.6762847304,
-0.294577837,
0.1824065745,
0.6456688046,
0.2818646729,
0.1201145053,
-0.7132534385,
0.065860875,
-0.0747158527,
0.1650878787,
0.1556656957,
-0.8125337958,
0.6648989916,
-0.0390821025,
-0.2544076741,
-0.0379526429,
0.750487864,
-0.0166835822,
0.003992212,
0.4739724398,
0.6489194036,
0.9797548056,
0.1725191027,
1.1052718163,
-0.4159842134,
0.2944617271,
1.3844875097,
-0.4563710392,
1.1628371477,
0.5654521585,
0.002009386,
0.3852868676,
0.4204899073,
0.4590740204,
0.4718825817,
0.3403379917,
-0.6554029584,
-0.1368752122,
-0.3157251775,
-0.0238292627,
0.6035014987,
0.5908287168,
-0.4667247832,
-0.1282838136,
0.0901898444,
0.323728472,
-0.1354435533,
-0.1720962226,
0.980528295,
0.3193776906,
-0.7784423232,
0.3930832148,
0.1273064762,
0.4911564589,
-0.3456154466,
0.3274315298,
-0.3867123425,
0.348105818,
-0.0340443552,
-0.6905164719,
0.674998939,
0.3334362507,
-0.0201604776,
-0.3875786662,
0.7661443353,
-0.4648540616,
-0.5664001703,
0.215775758,
0.3732893169,
0.2749440372,
-0.4949945211,
-0.3591777384,
0.650262475,
-0.2411410511,
-0.2894633412,
0.2811866403,
0.4601393938,
0.0894272029,
0.7665877342,
0.6083056927,
-0.0622873865,
0.1144176424,
0.256396234,
1.1142119169,
-0.8338332772,
-0.5504574776,
-1.2295612097,
0.8961785436,
-0.0318813063,
-0.3111039102,
0.5843161345,
0.7540246844,
0.5311993361,
0.0003867475,
0.9011560082,
0.3135859668,
0.5664932728,
-0.6108263135,
0.7542945743,
-0.3648535609,
0.0338125788,
-0.0888896659,
-0.5680331588,
-0.6421654224,
0.3973884881,
0.0131974518,
-0.2588130534,
0.7670165896,
0.6495495439,
0.0694546178,
-0.1482411325,
0.1712818742,
0.3085000217,
0.7251464725,
0.315975666,
0.7952333689,
-0.2123825848,
0.3406784534,
-0.0087663783,
-0.1000326574,
-0.46870628,
-0.9784269929,
-1.010923028,
-0.4776538312,
-0.3775911629,
-0.0628063083,
-0.2688188851,
0.7049229145,
0.9325181842,
-0.5200981498,
-0.0360726118,
-0.1677592248,
0.0659768805,
-0.0873578265,
-0.2208447158,
0.4883008301,
-0.6219494343,
-0.6425527334,
0.5801559687,
0.4584404826,
0.1631867439,
-0.3503392339,
0.1790543646,
0.2190504074,
0.3459119797,
0.8838033676,
-0.1366885602,
-0.9238981605,
-0.3111788929,
0.0167363603,
-0.0756812692,
-0.124406971,
0.9416955709,
-1.0362173319,
0.5158079863,
0.4100669324,
0.970736742,
0.6808596849,
0.0004783281,
0.3891215026,
-0.9258224368,
0.1116230637,
0.548725903,
0.372163862,
0.3830226362,
-0.0833011791,
0.3819127381,
-0.0648455247,
-0.3132141531,
-0.9954224825,
0.15916875,
-0.9681636095,
-0.4095753729,
1.2131102085,
-0.2033848017,
-0.2755318284,
0.0586306825,
-0.2757028341,
0.2239919007,
-0.2408220172,
0.6877003908,
0.6246453524,
0.0666880906,
-0.0005286252,
-0.1657911688,
0.2169321626,
0.4097170234,
-1.0180363655,
0.4147033691,
0.1728036702,
0.2326153815,
0.1210268363,
0.7489134073,
-0.2030227482,
-0.1902103573,
-0.0703729391,
-0.1505670249,
0.1294705719,
-0.42129457,
-0.7030565143,
-0.0375819728,
-0.0193955824,
-0.2065132707
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10984v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10984v1 | Revisiting Cosine Similarity via Normalized ICA-transformed Embeddings | 2024-06-16T15:44:37 | 2024-06-16T15:44:37 | Hiroaki Yamagiwa, Momose Oyama, Hidetoshi Shimodaira | cs.CL | cs.CL | Cosine similarity is widely used to measure the similarity between two
embeddings, while interpretations based on angle and correlation coefficient
are common. In this study, we focus on the interpretable axes of embeddings
transformed by Independent Component Analysis (ICA), and propose a novel
interpretation of cosine similarity as the sum of semantic similarities over
axes. To investigate this, we first show experimentally that unnormalized
embeddings contain norm-derived artifacts. We then demonstrate that normalized
ICA-transformed embeddings exhibit sparsity, with a few large values in each
axis and across embeddings, thereby enhancing interpretability by delineating
clear semantic contributions. Finally, to validate our interpretation, we
perform retrieval experiments using ideal embeddings with and without specific
semantic components. | [
-0.6836594343,
-0.6076108217,
0.4706057012,
-0.0782828778,
-0.5745902658,
-0.4223728478,
0.0001284976,
-0.4182975292,
0.7759128213,
0.5189374685,
-0.5275756121,
-0.713762939,
-0.5795174241,
0.1203378364,
-0.652769804,
0.7906796336,
0.0668306276,
0.2062381208,
-0.3190580904,
-0.5912507176,
-0.6661464572,
-0.1215031371,
-0.1569286883,
-0.0835757032,
0.2579158545,
0.3903578222,
1.0935930014,
0.622425735,
0.7045586705,
0.2209639698,
0.291280508,
-0.2240740657,
-0.7256194353,
-0.2262496203,
-0.1751319319,
-0.4850204587,
-0.3720499575,
0.1158573851,
0.4413657784,
0.9743834138,
0.2407696396,
0.1712873429,
0.4183665514,
0.6346786618,
-0.5110794902,
0.3826890588,
-0.7576735616,
0.0007194955,
0.035881225,
-0.3147543371,
-0.2453187108,
-0.1990278512,
0.382894367,
-0.9652538896,
0.5658581853,
0.142268002,
1.0039209127,
0.1836517006,
-0.2432691604,
-0.645172298,
-0.3316377103,
0.959459424,
-0.5688525438,
0.6327602863,
0.0375446714,
0.2800445557,
-0.3827745616,
-0.6599596739,
-0.7122524977,
-0.207426399,
-0.2962639928,
-0.0754037127,
-0.4989403188,
-0.2531315386,
-0.2663221657,
0.34619838,
-0.3698826134,
-0.0473741181,
-0.2526613474,
-0.2320770621,
0.6952209473,
-0.0149547514,
0.7267861366,
-0.1076795906,
-0.8700425029,
-0.4115096927,
-0.8152546287,
0.2268220931,
0.2506479621,
0.2462715805,
-0.304189533,
0.7645295858,
-0.2075717598,
0.3574332893,
-0.0356891118,
0.0585416295,
0.1139139608,
-0.0273741316,
-0.1491785794,
0.0640430972,
0.3026749194,
0.7544031143,
0.242984578,
-0.5653637648,
0.143163234,
0.0811952204,
0.2936421037,
-0.4929576814,
-0.164382726,
-0.3383363485,
-0.7731631398,
-0.0240347181,
0.4032429755,
-0.8258051872,
0.0827309787,
-0.8290137053,
0.4964559376,
-0.6126414537,
0.0970070958,
0.3278468549,
-0.2735099494,
0.6119479537,
0.263838321,
-0.4141090512,
0.6987066865,
1.2026543617,
0.7040477395,
-0.5569520593,
-0.2893883586,
-0.2352087796,
-0.1139614135,
-0.487837553,
0.83409971,
-0.5069511533,
-0.1647560745,
-0.2091667205,
0.1942357123,
0.2384898067,
-0.5712493658,
0.4060631096,
-0.8468781114,
-0.1632602364,
-0.2549468279,
-0.5056291819,
-0.6751397252,
0.1996036321,
-0.9066162109,
0.7316790819,
0.0209329631,
-0.6281007528,
0.5813353658,
-0.2135692388,
0.1956103891,
-0.0814279765,
-0.5060572028,
-0.5569357872,
0.394698292,
0.1619065106,
0.5189756751,
-0.3399261534,
0.0907644108,
-0.8720744252,
-0.3886215985,
0.5215280652,
-0.4384939969,
0.7744290233,
-0.0582765788,
-0.3519588411,
-0.2904318571,
-0.9289864898,
-0.048650872,
-0.3054833114,
0.3422406912,
-1.0145368576,
-0.2237417102,
-0.0999419838,
-0.0519086793,
0.1397120804,
-0.6881921291,
-0.0566637889,
-0.2886454165,
-0.1949598193,
0.617171824,
0.2575626671,
0.6839310527,
-0.2273222208,
-0.0274794959,
0.1753989607,
-0.2157406509,
0.5932524204,
-0.4910361767,
-0.523144722,
-0.6439469457,
-0.0858184546,
0.0451757126,
-0.5640276074,
0.4658731818,
-0.7922899723,
-0.4696081877,
-0.6789742708,
-0.0550058447,
0.168729946,
0.276873529,
0.7866132855,
-0.8776859641,
-0.3200910985,
-1.2187855244,
-0.4900273383,
0.16655761,
-0.2514673173,
0.1723664105,
0.3502231836,
-0.1488084644,
0.9645214081,
-0.634124577,
-0.5469593406,
0.3308418989,
0.210419327,
0.0058276802,
0.5593681931,
0.7104039192,
-0.5274454355,
-0.6310270429,
0.0581994541,
-0.6409061551,
0.0268136207,
-0.38047719,
-0.4654067159,
-0.4070735276,
0.6131696701,
-0.3715213835,
1.1077498198,
0.263288945,
-0.6533349156,
0.114314422,
-0.1025897861,
0.2378136516,
-0.9987392426,
-0.0529104881,
-0.1835695803,
0.0029747044,
-0.4137766659,
0.1240335554,
-0.1543844193,
0.0148023758,
-0.2055856735,
0.364951998,
-0.4951990545,
-0.5894933939,
-0.3241323829,
0.4856766462,
0.170237124,
0.404183954,
-0.2385053188,
0.6170536876,
0.3855067194,
-0.689450562,
0.1061442494,
0.2952324748,
-0.2990776002,
0.9475166202,
-0.495074302,
0.1037025526,
-0.3398808837,
0.1006489396,
-0.9315149188,
0.234204337,
0.0414852537,
-0.5448189974,
0.1017357856,
0.0784988478,
0.0242577344,
0.5283384919,
-0.6603710055,
0.5972130299,
0.2054297179,
-0.6715765595,
0.4982853532,
0.2177122086,
-0.035728503,
-0.5893226862,
-0.4016028941,
0.006314599,
-0.2163083553,
-0.535266459,
0.6449041367,
0.1334126592,
-0.6335257292,
0.5925130248,
0.0750325322,
-0.1211676747,
0.1100438386,
0.3067893088,
0.322481811,
-0.5455749035,
0.0664767772,
0.3268320262,
-0.2687906623,
0.0636395589,
0.0834092125,
0.4632347524,
-0.1250605881,
-0.5338788033,
-0.7877804637,
0.4736952484,
0.5115994811,
0.0063821264,
0.6403177381,
0.6461364627,
-0.466401726,
0.1507899165,
-0.467353344,
-0.3031721115,
-0.3162935078,
0.4808808863,
-0.585244,
-0.6485853195,
0.6028441191,
0.2599959671,
-0.1517858654,
0.864638865,
0.3315728903,
-0.1294405013,
0.619566977,
0.7319391966,
-0.0796809494,
0.1392032355,
-0.4424291849,
0.1956718415,
-0.8521474004,
-0.5037975907,
-0.6810829639,
-0.494514823,
-0.9312049747,
-0.6016766429,
0.4033618867,
0.0435034409,
-0.1338184476,
0.1698634773,
-0.185028553,
0.4430961311,
0.1468162984,
0.1096227765,
0.3616911173,
0.3157648742,
0.1975402385,
-0.3345195055,
-0.1831421256,
-0.5116679668,
0.8564998507,
0.2997656465,
0.8652163744,
0.0683226138,
0.5799673796,
0.196002394,
0.3570546508,
-0.8932879567,
0.2901852727,
-0.4327787757,
-0.2613694072,
-0.3053645194,
-0.1191728115,
-1.1275434494,
0.4894990921,
-0.2805925608,
-0.6194418073,
0.8671275973,
-0.4656285048,
0.0065181055,
0.4162766635,
-0.5195149779,
0.5464640856,
0.1415571868,
0.1467778087,
-0.7976866364,
-0.3171759844,
-0.0298482589,
0.3563965559,
0.2139145732,
-0.3010804951,
-0.2801493406,
0.790106535,
-0.3403350711,
0.9125929475,
-0.052819062,
0.2332983315,
0.5882242322,
0.3893630207,
0.1481113583,
0.4139663577,
0.0280102976,
0.5449879169,
0.3421144187,
-0.8213459849,
-0.9588108063,
1.0015892982,
-1.1691937447,
-0.4467050731,
-0.3932797909,
-0.7643749118,
0.1128240004,
0.279613167,
-0.0170810744,
0.6232494712,
-0.535629034,
0.574236095,
0.4607512951,
-0.0631166846,
0.0582466237,
0.3334139884,
0.1070543379,
-0.1977912635,
0.697596848,
0.1787464768,
0.1198853776,
0.4397519827,
0.0159028657,
-0.142567426,
-0.4564626217,
-0.1997357011,
0.301445514,
-0.767886281,
-0.2104972452,
-0.4023284912,
0.1141509935,
-0.4508889914,
-0.4334825873,
-0.614970386,
-0.5000896454,
-0.5890108943,
0.0066671208,
0.2984858155,
0.9491064548,
-0.0540550388,
-0.1177505925,
-0.7087572813,
0.1690167487,
0.2107343972,
0.3290853798,
0.1744799912,
-0.5150042772,
-0.204294607,
0.1647897065,
-0.124396421,
-0.7179815769,
0.5441573858,
0.2519461513,
0.477278471,
0.2744032741,
0.1692692786,
0.963624835,
-0.2289143801,
0.5788673759,
0.1848002225,
-0.919698,
-0.2586766183,
0.4137592912,
-0.0164492596,
0.645316422,
0.6362010837,
-0.3824564815,
-0.0835908502,
-0.6918084621,
-0.5927553177,
0.2397018969,
0.1140530929,
0.3771355748,
0.1239943281,
0.5823360085,
0.7500244379,
-0.45789814,
-0.2647241652,
-0.1770076901,
-0.1863903999,
-0.4342948794,
-0.0503172018,
-0.2866733372,
-0.1889473349,
0.214593038,
0.4510611296,
-0.1687893122,
0.6285334229,
0.4380712509,
-0.3044333458,
0.1348861456,
0.4077361226,
0.087746121,
0.4748294652,
-0.0552523322,
0.5978825092,
0.3770233691,
-0.6410970688,
-0.0238168165,
-0.1170186624,
-0.2007186115,
0.1911051273,
0.6394919753,
0.5720738173,
0.4691618383,
-0.1753444523,
0.6202363372,
-0.4411702156,
0.3107240796,
-0.3214349747,
-0.4293293059,
-0.1327947825,
0.2843901813,
0.2897498012,
0.21641922,
0.4299428165,
-0.5703956485,
0.5397327542,
0.5583623648,
-0.9918524623,
-0.8488336802,
-0.206994772,
-0.3056881726,
0.0000896002,
0.5543777347,
-0.1249695197,
-0.1412952393,
0.485140115,
0.4066281319,
0.9592269659,
0.2232295424,
0.0973135307,
0.281353116,
0.1030906513,
0.3921979666,
0.0128346998,
-0.0379540175,
-0.6953678131,
-0.1656345278,
-0.2497933656,
-0.0949462876,
-0.2305408865,
-1.3176662922,
0.5023755431,
0.0270569567,
0.2802762985,
0.0006416797,
-0.2458943427,
-1.06323874,
0.2154332995,
-0.2645793855,
0.675157547,
-0.9344590306,
0.6383286119,
0.6073812842,
-0.3771111071,
-0.9397895336,
0.1753353775,
-0.1955039948,
-0.9274987578,
0.5096520782,
-0.0303341355,
-0.2552886605,
-0.2841671109,
-0.4721950293,
-1.13651824,
1.3858600855,
0.18568483,
-0.1391164362,
0.1034481078,
0.5129278302,
0.7851204276,
-0.6866332889,
0.1020995677,
0.4570148289,
-0.2325448096,
-0.1238084584,
-0.7653024793,
0.2676673532,
0.1718746722,
0.1607366055,
-0.1510936171,
-0.4189376831,
0.8161415458,
0.1689773798,
-0.4657361507,
0.0480534695,
1.0132164955,
-0.2577147186,
0.6691845655,
0.3587502837,
0.6555598378,
0.3762342334,
0.2429800332,
0.809478581,
-0.2999242246,
0.7020252347,
0.886230886,
0.1333260536,
0.9766153693,
0.8828853965,
-0.0998624191,
0.6655024886,
0.0802172646,
0.4753065109,
0.5986912251,
-0.1046697944,
-0.0287717301,
-0.0890183523,
-0.2010457665,
-0.3485923409,
0.6867319942,
0.3950693607,
-0.1765595526,
-0.6791398525,
-0.0281194244,
0.078928791,
0.279296279,
-0.3053724468,
0.884819746,
0.4597955346,
-0.5029190183,
0.5441220999,
-0.0995131657,
0.5190368891,
-0.2116187066,
-0.375271678,
-0.0782926828,
0.448823154,
-0.1567559242,
-0.7962974906,
0.8609757423,
-0.3870086968,
0.0813683122,
0.2375100255,
0.7991480827,
-0.3296767771,
-0.306653738,
0.4895166457,
0.2849734128,
0.1180388927,
0.1652860343,
-0.5113084912,
-0.0832525939,
0.0862694383,
0.0105560487,
0.5362086296,
0.8342978954,
-0.3986955285,
0.4186955988,
0.4829311967,
-0.1880267859,
0.2874477506,
-0.4712443352,
0.9586253762,
-0.5252643228,
-0.4702077508,
-0.5987944603,
0.2099185288,
0.1423731297,
-0.305098474,
0.7518273592,
0.6103694439,
1.0782365799,
-0.2425295711,
0.2320216149,
0.0484415069,
0.4303224385,
-0.6223850846,
0.6045506001,
-0.3773289621,
0.1930882931,
-0.1209823415,
-0.979519546,
-0.474044919,
0.6332386732,
-0.4395499527,
-0.5172688961,
0.7264145613,
1.0317497253,
-0.3694846034,
0.1770558059,
0.4445702136,
0.1483313292,
0.4823768139,
0.1081201285,
0.4654176533,
-0.6548480988,
0.3470768631,
-0.3682899475,
-0.3198305666,
-0.1540635079,
-0.6394110322,
-0.6135935187,
-0.8372378945,
-0.1805992126,
-0.4695326686,
-0.1697619855,
1.0725778341,
0.0937224329,
-1.0256376266,
-0.3169331253,
0.1140909269,
0.0234559868,
-0.331851393,
-0.2253743261,
0.901296258,
-0.2245397419,
-0.6445149183,
0.0560019836,
0.3351465464,
0.0863748863,
-0.4031633139,
-0.0042367326,
-0.0350940973,
0.1397965848,
0.5102943182,
0.0027662416,
-0.6718915701,
-0.9163150787,
-0.0246472508,
-0.0772506893,
0.2596022487,
1.0379359722,
-0.5284119248,
0.6255590916,
0.9208096266,
0.7710956931,
0.447686702,
-0.1259688139,
0.4024621248,
-0.4114649594,
0.3019298315,
0.2240016758,
0.2299211174,
0.2417850047,
-0.3098224699,
0.2017338574,
0.2271727324,
-0.2918362021,
-0.5357953906,
0.2154294997,
-1.3312643766,
0.1030052975,
0.8652722836,
-0.5881813169,
-0.5137632489,
-0.3604089022,
-0.1537570208,
0.4427891672,
-0.1653015316,
1.0612990856,
0.5398421288,
-0.2651415765,
0.3194620907,
0.016914092,
0.254832387,
0.3640313745,
-0.4840368927,
-0.3603020012,
0.1439296156,
0.5792537332,
0.4573093951,
0.1645664275,
-0.5856652856,
0.3177904487,
0.0983456895,
0.1299912632,
0.2369842529,
-0.0534774736,
-0.2640757859,
0.1046256796,
0.204144001,
-0.3230143785
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10977v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10977v1 | Toward Optimal LLM Alignments Using Two-Player Games | 2024-06-16T15:24:50 | 2024-06-16T15:24:50 | Rui Zheng, Hongyi Guo, Zhihan Liu, Xiaoying Zhang, Yuanshun Yao, Xiaojun Xu, Zhaoran Wang, Zhiheng Xi, Tao Gui, Qi Zhang, Xuanjing Huang, Hang Li, Yang Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, 68 | The standard Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF) framework
primarily focuses on optimizing the performance of large language models using
pre-collected prompts. However, collecting prompts that provide comprehensive
coverage is both tedious and challenging, and often fails to include scenarios
that LLMs need to improve on the most. In this paper, we investigate alignment
through the lens of two-agent games, involving iterative interactions between
an adversarial and a defensive agent. The adversarial agent's task at each step
is to generate prompts that expose the weakness of the defensive agent. In
return, the defensive agent seeks to improve its responses to these newly
identified prompts it struggled with, based on feedback from the reward model.
We theoretically demonstrate that this iterative reinforcement learning
optimization converges to a Nash Equilibrium for the game induced by the
agents. Experimental results in safety scenarios demonstrate that learning in
such a competitive environment not only fully trains agents but also leads to
policies with enhanced generalization capabilities for both adversarial and
defensive agents. | [
-0.1134684384,
-0.5881931186,
0.6380167007,
-0.0851929635,
0.0106358863,
0.3512018919,
-0.367905736,
-0.1719598025,
-0.1664133668,
0.4454015195,
-0.8587935567,
-0.5022444725,
-0.4554437995,
-0.1442704797,
0.2944786251,
1.237760067,
-0.0944894329,
0.0831610039,
-0.2823777199,
-0.1584181637,
-0.4387975931,
-0.0215987172,
-0.8624163866,
-0.7461473942,
0.6417880058,
0.47512272,
0.8524022102,
0.8723257184,
0.4613474607,
0.3537732959,
0.1722747087,
0.3203935325,
-0.8057898283,
0.5581895113,
-0.3636774123,
-0.4333128929,
0.0943615586,
0.1367305517,
0.6572397351,
0.2208561599,
-0.4081530869,
-0.2953040898,
0.0522445068,
0.6974452138,
-0.4877931178,
-0.037335325,
-0.3569093347,
0.2900671959,
0.1141922399,
-0.4233492315,
-0.3796115518,
-0.2888935208,
0.3544534445,
-0.9397391677,
-0.2071672827,
-0.0274836905,
1.1414520741,
0.5953104496,
-0.4742548168,
-0.326423049,
-0.701010704,
0.7068791986,
-0.2964411676,
0.025219664,
0.0789554939,
0.5531840324,
-0.5355790257,
-0.1806027293,
-0.2288439274,
-0.2765789032,
0.0907597318,
0.4312964678,
-0.2777116895,
0.2080856711,
0.0208841059,
-0.3252317309,
-0.5853732824,
0.5147485733,
-0.0843017846,
-0.0865483508,
0.9118163586,
0.4167835414,
0.3228228688,
0.4314376414,
-0.8603518605,
-0.4089532197,
-0.7295598388,
0.6034550667,
0.5782064795,
0.3408788741,
-0.111180827,
0.4375774264,
0.2830080092,
0.5423277617,
0.2614128888,
-0.4250748754,
-0.1655545384,
-0.218849048,
0.2568540871,
0.0733027235,
0.7663604617,
0.5962506533,
0.3558829427,
-0.4978685975,
-0.4312668145,
0.2525062263,
0.6651115417,
-0.4001170397,
-0.0394960605,
0.1827869862,
-0.0148428129,
-0.5088495016,
0.1240999699,
-0.6498712897,
-0.7591715455,
-0.3567542732,
0.4772431552,
-0.0814665705,
-0.060293138,
-0.1944896579,
-0.2198133767,
0.5065168142,
0.2596868575,
-0.9500188231,
0.2461699545,
0.8748446107,
0.4566140473,
-0.3325092494,
-0.4075140059,
-0.7568897605,
0.1431062669,
-0.6613606811,
0.7612945437,
-0.055564899,
-0.4087637067,
0.177204445,
-0.2264489383,
-0.0360509492,
-0.4707389176,
0.2710481584,
-0.6778381467,
0.1956258267,
-0.4594134688,
-0.6212724447,
0.1048757061,
0.6340740919,
-0.40626508,
0.7624974251,
0.0150524778,
-0.5316195488,
0.3808020949,
-0.3918143809,
-0.4930313528,
-0.0864940286,
-0.4477257729,
-0.7053201199,
-0.167385444,
0.0497623719,
-0.01349576,
-0.4042527378,
0.1692369431,
-0.2750433087,
-0.5803658366,
0.4226480424,
0.0763851479,
0.535081327,
0.1518848389,
-0.4738391042,
0.6124835014,
-0.2065262049,
-0.0171312578,
0.2375694364,
-0.6748329401,
0.0482424609,
0.1935150176,
-0.4312503934,
0.140243873,
0.0357966498,
-0.1571172774,
0.3078133464,
-0.4309794009,
0.1484288275,
1.1040055752,
-0.0241043624,
0.8359568715,
-0.6686564684,
0.8404188752,
-0.1059756652,
0.0920270532,
0.2364691496,
-0.0886968374,
-0.3846301138,
-0.2495132089,
0.1292757541,
0.6657036543,
-0.9110412598,
0.3210906386,
-0.1550308019,
-0.0349393412,
-0.6356705427,
0.1569241434,
0.635266006,
0.5958957076,
0.1867949963,
-0.1813053191,
-0.454495877,
-0.6799030304,
-0.1973579228,
-0.3620663285,
0.2837978005,
0.4664161205,
0.1343351603,
-0.1912486255,
0.7332144976,
-0.1252749115,
-0.3395971358,
-0.3160202503,
0.0923527703,
-0.1408678293,
0.3084917068,
0.3769271076,
-0.4172978103,
-0.5209059715,
0.0221259333,
-0.7530278563,
-0.0580487102,
-0.274708271,
-0.2772191167,
0.4117269218,
0.3065471947,
-0.3585983217,
0.2015466392,
0.3155418038,
-0.364055872,
0.4295423627,
-0.3400422931,
0.0702659637,
-0.7772530317,
-0.1526347548,
-0.2478217781,
-0.4610338509,
-0.5915822387,
0.2623859048,
-0.1401450485,
0.2017963827,
-0.1493010223,
0.6217870712,
-0.5160603523,
-0.42779091,
-0.509028554,
0.677084744,
-0.1884306669,
0.6201989651,
0.1316064149,
0.8915640712,
0.4363814592,
-0.6002893448,
0.4451958835,
0.1594064534,
-0.0354941227,
0.6782938838,
-0.4757184684,
0.2068192065,
-0.2737645805,
0.2165575773,
-0.9864665866,
-0.0908845291,
0.4902328849,
-0.4237467349,
0.5148541927,
0.2335873097,
0.037657734,
-0.1982429475,
-0.6161658168,
0.2830220461,
0.6604739428,
-0.724767983,
0.5105659962,
0.6006373167,
0.2475991547,
-1.1120954752,
-0.3479408622,
-0.0654806495,
-0.3370632231,
-0.5077328086,
0.2775486112,
0.0740030408,
-0.3632172048,
0.0615819693,
-0.0517050698,
0.2354695946,
0.3760200143,
0.2539635301,
0.4521171749,
-0.1107912883,
0.0464644805,
-0.2475610077,
-0.256192863,
0.0624676123,
-0.4182783365,
0.3349185288,
0.0174609497,
-0.2075476944,
-0.4389618337,
0.2722238004,
0.0203282032,
0.1098890901,
0.4907842577,
0.4388175607,
-0.0166192725,
-0.2603071332,
-0.2489884496,
-0.2558251023,
-0.4201391339,
0.4508002996,
-0.3032737374,
-0.9428903461,
0.4066631496,
0.0420169421,
0.2966530323,
0.2627777457,
0.5856378078,
-0.3246330917,
1.2020577192,
0.4734659493,
-0.0967311114,
0.2790542245,
-0.1057476774,
-0.2016524523,
-0.532550633,
-0.4444026053,
-0.3638171852,
-0.5221598148,
-0.5479224324,
-0.2347656786,
0.244968012,
0.0527077951,
-0.5468185544,
0.2653247416,
-0.3588834107,
0.7513929009,
0.6569775343,
0.4273594618,
-0.0612085946,
-0.0276751965,
-0.379281193,
-0.1223354489,
-0.7349048257,
-0.2508766353,
0.9438204765,
0.503684938,
0.7424663901,
0.5337610245,
1.0491051674,
0.1938537806,
0.2655970454,
-0.8953846693,
0.2692369521,
0.1850221306,
-0.2973214984,
-0.4849291146,
-0.4729013741,
-1.1633714437,
0.1230471954,
-0.3878632486,
-0.6539567709,
-0.0561731383,
0.2473667711,
-0.5805225968,
0.0017008217,
-0.1231313497,
0.8418505192,
-0.4400964081,
-0.6183829308,
-0.2599053383,
-1.0016312599,
0.4421521127,
0.3258433044,
0.1026110351,
0.0521566272,
-0.257897675,
0.5845326185,
-0.2891634703,
0.5952195525,
-0.2921589017,
-0.3546578884,
0.3337600529,
-0.0608429387,
0.7535693645,
-0.0738543123,
0.333450675,
-0.5418012738,
-0.3025479615,
-0.5655771494,
-0.5814640522,
0.4437570572,
-1.2351077795,
-0.6997010112,
-0.6371608973,
-0.7621455789,
-0.2749521434,
-0.1277867109,
0.2374299169,
-0.0692879409,
-0.4448592663,
-0.3231524527,
0.8481450677,
-0.2049929202,
0.3224033713,
0.5785421729,
-0.0560892336,
-0.4733718634,
0.8455651999,
-0.3054300845,
0.3140684664,
0.3514325023,
0.134494558,
-0.5616702437,
-0.48701033,
-0.4731393456,
0.2131180018,
-0.7090156078,
-0.2833621204,
-0.1228372008,
-0.0270779319,
-0.2918331325,
-0.2296659499,
-0.0996791571,
-0.0791467354,
-0.2913722992,
-0.0859842822,
-0.1322578341,
0.8729330301,
-0.4827938378,
0.3771428466,
-0.4787726402,
0.0558792949,
0.4449569285,
-0.1663943678,
-0.168408528,
-0.5476483703,
-0.0712335557,
-0.0437610969,
-0.43677634,
-1.0343476534,
-0.009557277,
0.0277870968,
0.6101567745,
0.5676549077,
0.033078257,
0.5584005117,
-0.3440852463,
0.4925894141,
0.4193411469,
-0.510986805,
0.1914797276,
-0.3306817114,
0.1222342774,
0.6684040427,
0.2025934011,
-0.5007770658,
-0.0596264452,
-0.3516992331,
-0.6518998742,
0.9973029494,
-0.1787544638,
-0.2463402003,
-0.0101768691,
0.3848206699,
-0.1907176375,
-0.0552936643,
-0.4909779429,
-0.1569634974,
0.1844014525,
-0.3283570111,
-0.1265102476,
-0.1741014719,
-0.7275227308,
0.2274640948,
0.8928948641,
-0.1671802104,
0.1668587923,
-0.0965985656,
-0.2551686168,
-0.5494275093,
0.149192974,
0.8889334202,
0.2662968636,
0.1067293584,
0.2419568002,
0.0723689273,
0.0678494424,
0.5937284827,
0.1462576538,
-0.188682586,
-0.5686501265,
0.5023860931,
0.9035409093,
0.2563889921,
-0.7968341708,
0.7292175293,
-0.1391092539,
-0.384832114,
-0.0507581756,
0.2460515052,
0.0474706739,
0.8272914886,
-0.0233796537,
-0.1707404852,
-0.1598205417,
-0.6039619446,
0.4491574466,
0.8792405128,
-0.5637774467,
-0.0948041901,
0.6024266481,
0.050780572,
-0.6000452042,
0.5320073962,
-0.4028228521,
-0.8592043519,
0.6956840158,
0.651278615,
0.6886232495,
-0.0936037377,
0.4639876187,
0.3519205153,
0.0851185098,
-0.3341626823,
0.1741975248,
-0.1653455198,
-0.8541311026,
-0.1736426502,
-0.2231103033,
-0.4411968887,
-0.3967750669,
-0.5949620605,
0.0506437123,
-0.588562429,
-0.1081768349,
-0.2983755469,
0.3063333333,
-0.4257214963,
-0.2016329467,
0.1164174974,
0.2312720716,
-0.4890752435,
0.471861124,
0.612231493,
-0.5305422544,
-1.0086476803,
-0.1247606874,
0.4600707293,
-1.1929643154,
0.5155789256,
0.023122225,
-0.1862553656,
-0.0076518226,
-0.5440473557,
-0.6044354439,
1.2689127922,
0.3828095496,
-0.6848255992,
-0.1228266358,
-0.016316941,
0.435777843,
-0.4665781856,
0.1351588517,
0.7478749156,
0.4657656252,
0.1752158403,
-0.5031639934,
0.0511914827,
0.0922160372,
-0.1590572149,
0.3469833136,
-0.5907841325,
0.6001140475,
-0.6923287511,
-0.4078886807,
0.2363142967,
0.6552145481,
0.5888615251,
0.1753086746,
0.6217240095,
0.8378446698,
0.7676640153,
-0.1164643541,
0.8738278151,
-0.0825547725,
0.3351544738,
1.162360549,
-0.332821995,
0.4058261812,
0.4224149585,
-0.2469051182,
0.3952952623,
0.8833339214,
0.0432472564,
0.6517265439,
0.5718079805,
-0.326752454,
-0.3508483469,
-0.2551024258,
-0.0884083211,
0.1623314172,
-0.0235725082,
-0.0600455999,
-0.4477371573,
-0.3449888825,
0.0688895583,
0.5320175886,
-0.0499086268,
1.2552324533,
-0.0695065185,
-1.1720600128,
0.3608570397,
-0.1264854521,
0.5765265226,
-0.4910895526,
0.0644299909,
-0.2262097001,
0.3905381858,
-0.0114199789,
-0.5738205314,
-0.0951222628,
-0.155843854,
0.0537335873,
-0.0320278779,
0.4858654439,
-0.7833048701,
0.2270846814,
0.5221574306,
0.3349894285,
-0.0086959209,
0.37624982,
-0.8871300817,
-0.1433390379,
0.0028940591,
-0.1239865422,
0.6194529533,
0.1024322435,
0.0441030748,
0.5054906607,
0.3632138669,
0.1233012155,
-0.0992431268,
-0.0310935788,
0.5842662454,
-0.4924033284,
-0.5921748877,
-0.9433167577,
0.3321276307,
-0.0520374477,
-0.1996926516,
0.3210548162,
0.1708904058,
0.5973588228,
0.3543280959,
0.6222262383,
0.3305494189,
0.191977933,
-0.5311242938,
0.3226805627,
-0.573255837,
0.3277984858,
0.1488350481,
-0.6686481833,
-0.1602740288,
0.6196733117,
-0.032182917,
-0.1643250585,
0.4912466407,
0.8063164949,
0.4159086347,
-0.272811085,
0.2439402491,
-0.1828383207,
0.3463243544,
1.0651553869,
1.050409317,
-0.258563906,
0.6263555288,
-0.1167785823,
-0.3180043101,
-0.075484626,
-0.7201360464,
-1.0328162909,
-0.2733011246,
-0.1551898271,
-0.7461073399,
0.555124104,
1.3922911882,
0.310181886,
-0.6707701683,
-0.4190696776,
-0.1685384214,
0.4092077315,
-0.3441308737,
-0.2064930946,
0.2542848289,
-0.7766456008,
-0.4273664057,
0.5138463378,
0.141288653,
0.164987877,
-0.2540050149,
-0.8758672476,
-0.2874796391,
0.1289222836,
0.0447626822,
0.6689615846,
-0.7453271747,
-0.2611303329,
0.084506236,
-0.484597832,
0.0336886309,
0.781814754,
-0.512532413,
0.3965958357,
0.3300947547,
1.1481267214,
0.2449341863,
0.3721079528,
0.8296559453,
-0.7643659115,
0.0055574644,
0.2032532245,
0.076264292,
0.2485627681,
-0.4142130017,
0.6007580161,
0.1128031686,
-0.8118408322,
-0.8406905532,
0.3673708737,
-0.6401596665,
-0.3474676311,
1.1118475199,
-0.4087842107,
-0.1678578407,
0.1711613685,
-0.1271673739,
0.4927532971,
-0.4938478172,
0.8596829772,
0.5988887548,
-0.2301383168,
-0.117429845,
0.068580471,
0.8648854494,
0.6464230418,
-0.7185469866,
-0.0819464698,
0.4476393163,
0.0535492152,
0.0257832576,
0.7161037326,
0.2147520632,
0.5707646012,
-0.0973523334,
-0.1957836747,
-0.0073640211,
-0.604724288,
-0.7037575245,
-0.0031250368,
0.2436781228,
-0.1921938211
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10976v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10976v1 | Promoting Data and Model Privacy in Federated Learning through Quantized LoRA | 2024-06-16T15:23:07 | 2024-06-16T15:23:07 | JianHao Zhu, Changze Lv, Xiaohua Wang, Muling Wu, Wenhao Liu, Tianlong Li, Zixuan Ling, Cenyuan Zhang, Xiaoqing Zheng, Xuanjing Huang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CR | Conventional federated learning primarily aims to secure the privacy of data
distributed across multiple edge devices, with the global model dispatched to
edge devices for parameter updates during the learning process. However, the
development of large language models (LLMs) requires substantial data and
computational resources, rendering them valuable intellectual properties for
their developers and owners. To establish a mechanism that protects both data
and model privacy in a federated learning context, we introduce a method that
just needs to distribute a quantized version of the model's parameters during
training. This method enables accurate gradient estimations for parameter
updates while preventing clients from accessing a model whose performance is
comparable to the centrally hosted one. Moreover, we combine this quantization
strategy with LoRA, a popular and parameter-efficient fine-tuning method, to
significantly reduce communication costs in federated learning. The proposed
framework, named \textsc{FedLPP}, successfully ensures both data and model
privacy in the federated learning context. Additionally, the learned central
model exhibits good generalization and can be trained in a resource-efficient
manner. | [
-0.3130512238,
-0.7702240348,
0.1491867006,
0.1636668146,
-0.1423775852,
-0.0475562327,
-0.0969914421,
-0.4574140012,
-0.0319493078,
0.7054268122,
-0.5473936796,
-0.8849936724,
-0.1368733048,
-0.3190152347,
-0.4413782656,
1.1149523258,
0.1851973087,
-0.0208406691,
-0.3666676581,
-0.2751631737,
0.3038717508,
-0.6420164704,
-0.677090764,
-0.4721245468,
0.7231491804,
0.1559928358,
0.6680970192,
0.788286984,
0.4741633534,
0.2571306825,
-0.0181621239,
0.0747471154,
-0.4744108915,
0.1831471324,
-0.1811714023,
-0.8331813216,
-0.7738800049,
0.0370374955,
0.771627605,
0.7181165218,
-0.4931626618,
0.249404937,
0.0148291551,
0.9940811396,
-1.0562263727,
0.2749311328,
-0.1184444949,
0.4404846728,
-0.085515283,
-0.0537968017,
-0.4624436796,
-0.5681896806,
0.0996683389,
-0.5347788334,
0.0989792272,
-0.2640813887,
0.6176105142,
0.2760031521,
-0.2918452621,
0.264344424,
-0.7464159131,
0.5773285627,
-0.3956553042,
0.5136077404,
0.591827333,
0.3870909512,
0.0783077925,
-0.8281518221,
-0.1245510057,
0.2174737602,
0.0151208118,
-0.3522179127,
-0.5334322453,
0.2036560625,
0.2990985215,
0.5214839578,
-0.3410179615,
0.531737864,
-0.0576674528,
-0.1570630372,
0.8003474474,
0.0682299286,
-0.2480423003,
0.3937801421,
-0.494335264,
-0.3251250386,
-0.8363672495,
0.1303025484,
0.5461540222,
0.535602808,
-0.2718271017,
0.3064503074,
-0.738812685,
0.6011635065,
0.2326968014,
-0.2208387405,
0.2009169757,
-0.0184777062,
-0.5777868629,
-0.2199422568,
0.8746364117,
-0.0374745019,
-0.1083721071,
-0.3553525805,
-0.3584834039,
-0.1513854414,
-0.1306902319,
-1.056445241,
0.069920145,
0.1761318594,
-0.3061008453,
-0.4345627725,
-0.087721318,
-0.7130901217,
-0.2377325296,
-0.1723757982,
0.3893125355,
-0.0348308533,
-0.1002104208,
0.2009292841,
0.351439774,
0.0972972587,
0.0879363939,
-1.3687409163,
0.6395492554,
1.0556969643,
0.7148711085,
0.3019713759,
-0.1703156084,
-0.8615521193,
0.1847880483,
0.0182958525,
0.4267948866,
-0.3287199736,
-0.2276342511,
0.2384245247,
-0.148153767,
0.0903080553,
-0.2057271153,
0.0153940488,
-0.8107152581,
0.4035166502,
-0.1359451413,
-0.5981550813,
-0.1166527793,
0.0926131681,
-0.678316474,
0.4229581356,
0.1706694663,
-0.9201473594,
0.0482452884,
-0.7376052737,
-0.1913309097,
0.0315109454,
-0.2220804989,
-0.7775127292,
-0.0153639149,
0.4011666477,
0.7213253379,
-0.0869663358,
0.2600346804,
-0.3689008951,
-0.3453119993,
0.2341118455,
-0.3164538741,
0.9610753059,
0.2152513415,
-0.2763605714,
0.1396034062,
-0.6676441431,
0.2301419973,
0.0464594923,
-0.4793913364,
-0.4996851683,
-0.2330399603,
-0.3110567927,
-0.1647749096,
0.4590271115,
-0.4097649455,
0.2521282434,
-0.5401284099,
0.4875632226,
0.8399120569,
-0.1370216608,
0.8446363211,
-0.309615463,
0.559884131,
-0.0817003548,
0.5989206433,
0.0168625247,
-0.1397379488,
-0.5199429989,
-0.4550723732,
0.4939392209,
0.1556421816,
-0.5085207224,
0.3056662381,
-0.307854414,
-0.4564337134,
-0.4374661148,
0.1246849373,
0.4668601751,
0.346106112,
-0.061251916,
0.0725069195,
-0.0980203822,
-0.7643744946,
0.0826802254,
0.0348363593,
-0.129560262,
0.2957744598,
0.3025263548,
-0.3861868978,
1.097499609,
-0.629016459,
-0.4732775092,
0.1292331219,
-0.0268440489,
-0.1288823783,
0.6653058529,
0.6020282507,
-0.9164758921,
-0.3668278456,
0.1082667187,
-0.7396386266,
0.0791797489,
0.3861651719,
-0.2900651097,
0.3697783053,
0.2538436055,
-0.4137131274,
0.389485091,
0.9022417665,
-0.3641144335,
0.1100310683,
-0.1903185695,
-0.3216050863,
-1.0879007578,
0.0885168537,
-0.1749528944,
-0.5968580842,
-0.3842532635,
0.6662515402,
-0.0627442524,
-0.4418670535,
-0.3696013689,
0.4764835536,
-0.1141868755,
-0.1828999519,
-0.182667464,
0.0589825623,
0.0994090214,
0.5621990561,
0.0191124715,
0.6656816602,
0.770742774,
-0.3561076522,
0.3657837808,
0.406036675,
-0.0357137471,
0.8245407343,
-0.5197844505,
0.2609548867,
0.1816011518,
0.3341066837,
-0.109667711,
-0.3819185197,
0.2576910257,
-0.2285318077,
-0.015517192,
-0.1181797832,
-0.7144640684,
0.0896369442,
-0.2166604996,
0.2582786679,
0.4464193583,
-0.8443527222,
0.6384244561,
0.4820460081,
0.181277737,
-0.8028377891,
-0.6627216339,
-0.3980931342,
-0.348521024,
-0.7170895338,
0.216354534,
-0.0515890829,
-0.2517556548,
-0.169271633,
-0.0661183596,
-0.4488511682,
0.4997243285,
0.5158773661,
-0.0952416956,
-0.2830098271,
0.1832821816,
0.1829570681,
-0.2405489534,
0.3240714371,
-0.5264289975,
0.5003605485,
-0.3544787169,
-0.3467732072,
-0.5591908097,
0.3534287214,
0.1799491048,
-0.3824268281,
1.0688347816,
0.6551982164,
-0.5062689781,
-0.629478991,
-0.2688235343,
-0.4784201384,
-0.551474452,
-0.1149425358,
-0.0193567164,
-1.229875803,
0.6840274334,
-0.0315038338,
0.2308177799,
-0.0974006504,
0.3183022738,
0.0118932389,
0.7998967767,
1.3101942539,
-0.279317975,
0.7345812321,
-0.3854350746,
0.076690644,
-0.5238024592,
-0.2093693614,
-0.4072633982,
-0.319083184,
-0.7672618628,
-0.18106547,
0.3216799498,
0.0261435658,
-0.400505513,
0.0677360222,
-0.3517226577,
0.6516963243,
0.9310218096,
0.5742774606,
0.5767025948,
0.2885838747,
0.1219520345,
0.2096640319,
-0.6165254116,
-0.0936200693,
1.2018948793,
0.585529089,
0.9075737,
0.1447295547,
1.0976940393,
0.2754474878,
0.1172464788,
-0.5081584454,
0.6811081171,
-0.0530482829,
-0.4218820333,
-0.3325529099,
-0.8270182014,
-0.7075459957,
0.2840444446,
-0.1418002993,
-0.7536580563,
0.3996381164,
0.1186255068,
-0.6443566084,
0.3493257761,
-0.3149950802,
0.547929287,
0.1551792324,
-0.5813127756,
-0.2746104002,
-0.7038062811,
0.3567689061,
-0.2350481451,
-0.0942871869,
0.0247895513,
0.0381482355,
0.7938358784,
-0.7074485421,
1.0416381359,
-0.3250878453,
-0.3329947591,
0.0460766256,
-0.092921719,
0.5306184888,
0.4036459029,
0.0716351122,
0.2855816782,
-0.2941602468,
-0.4812228084,
-0.4814397097,
0.8209894896,
-0.7544591427,
-0.6076740623,
-0.2497873306,
-0.628477633,
-0.241062358,
0.1954421401,
0.0580927506,
0.2378364801,
-0.0270507783,
0.4133107066,
0.9414996505,
-0.0167926345,
0.4720763564,
0.8667793274,
-0.2929088473,
-0.3513471782,
0.7286688685,
-0.1625811756,
0.5070027113,
0.4969164133,
0.3329909742,
-0.0713444725,
-0.3595331311,
0.1802511811,
0.3879168332,
-0.8206977844,
-0.4753231704,
-0.473493576,
-0.3916704953,
-0.2105297446,
-0.3108240664,
-0.5933088064,
-0.4402347207,
-0.5093327761,
-0.2614530921,
0.5818874836,
0.0923544466,
-0.584471941,
0.8153746128,
-0.5226762891,
-0.0298397336,
0.5122218132,
0.5979636908,
-0.1132392138,
-0.1010826528,
-0.4509798288,
0.3587452769,
-0.092100434,
-0.0535977148,
0.2605873644,
0.2754668891,
0.032375779,
0.7166264057,
0.3123030066,
0.3778877854,
-0.2256277204,
0.3659322262,
-0.0501395911,
-1.0032001734,
0.5386134982,
-0.4247626066,
0.1132893637,
0.4170155227,
0.1886008531,
-0.2170979828,
-0.3295470178,
-0.7743717432,
-0.5393662453,
0.668161273,
-0.0569822714,
0.3038240671,
0.450094223,
0.2325832993,
0.0068631978,
0.3818913698,
-0.9083073139,
-0.247896418,
0.0235199891,
0.0663037151,
0.2659757733,
-0.0025697201,
-0.6510791183,
0.0879672468,
0.4880678356,
-0.3063956499,
0.2114511877,
-0.2735192776,
0.2885878682,
-0.2017448097,
0.0915459841,
0.3753584921,
0.5403195024,
-0.1801375747,
-0.1415372342,
-0.3163416982,
-0.4693856835,
0.0704727918,
0.5275815725,
-0.4901519716,
-0.1556964964,
0.1362450868,
0.7998610735,
0.2904317975,
-0.4537967145,
0.6415182948,
-0.1441271603,
-0.308560282,
-0.2116039842,
0.3902150095,
0.0118881091,
0.6835611463,
0.1872155815,
-0.0997029468,
-0.0959752649,
-0.1555050761,
0.2157702893,
0.5284353495,
-0.2074708641,
-0.4427239597,
0.8261470795,
0.3490081131,
-0.2102847695,
0.6049427986,
0.1536790282,
-0.1173116714,
0.3034799695,
0.3449531794,
0.7680948377,
-0.459387362,
0.6484792233,
-0.0506901219,
-0.0323020853,
-0.2708558738,
0.2007372826,
-0.4940519035,
-0.5156577229,
-0.0612341501,
-0.5913277268,
-0.5338411927,
0.0041632387,
-1.0819613934,
-0.0592139699,
-0.8841193914,
-0.1844897866,
-0.1793268621,
0.1565408558,
-0.4835742414,
-0.0230468269,
0.3024367392,
0.7773171663,
-0.8246031404,
1.0164593458,
0.1094915941,
-0.3745185733,
-0.6132110357,
-0.2900555134,
-0.2845909595,
-0.6920282841,
0.6396265626,
-0.1287698895,
0.0484909341,
0.1612626165,
-0.7642861605,
-0.6774727106,
1.262524128,
0.6142166257,
-0.784439683,
-0.189131856,
0.5040828586,
0.6230430603,
-0.2461532354,
-0.4014497697,
0.2366986424,
0.0658665821,
-0.0990122631,
-0.5915161371,
-0.0939728394,
0.3744748235,
-0.3544639647,
0.2814415991,
-0.8076050878,
0.9841346145,
-0.2384474576,
-0.4041367769,
-0.1399509758,
0.8820541501,
0.1282084882,
0.4471747279,
0.2309120744,
0.5478559732,
1.1113017797,
-0.0179929603,
0.8528177738,
-0.1655976921,
0.6801235676,
1.1739484072,
-0.3039857745,
0.9673596621,
0.4570371509,
-0.0402914658,
0.2488444746,
0.4328151643,
0.0885628387,
0.8501403928,
0.0430544764,
-0.6906911731,
0.0135148643,
-0.2017934024,
-0.3357918262,
0.4055344164,
0.2301986367,
-0.6020622253,
-0.3907894194,
0.3017090559,
0.2920009792,
0.1342452019,
-0.4704552293,
0.7621721625,
0.2384257168,
-0.0019041632,
0.6241503954,
0.0468968861,
0.4142723083,
-0.6893728971,
0.3042336702,
-0.5821729898,
0.3718068302,
-0.2737065256,
-0.3111558557,
0.2258194834,
0.074826926,
-0.2013193071,
-0.2204619497,
0.1357128471,
-0.460947156,
-0.3095852733,
0.2889460921,
0.4269463718,
-0.3152942657,
-0.1096334159,
-0.5455839634,
-0.0043285848,
-0.2109751999,
-0.2647100687,
0.7551265359,
0.3152729571,
-0.0811108053,
0.946380794,
0.6079031825,
-0.124441959,
-0.2178467363,
0.0201364141,
1.1126300097,
-0.1545582414,
-0.8129134178,
-0.8670497537,
0.1414463222,
0.0733608752,
-0.0774926841,
0.7553189397,
0.2859948575,
0.9955588579,
0.1052524,
0.4768559039,
0.2330383062,
0.2072275728,
-0.6129524708,
1.0183962584,
-0.2813081741,
0.4083386362,
0.0579181649,
-0.8752731681,
-0.3544027209,
0.5622142553,
-0.2207866907,
-0.319219619,
0.4010323584,
0.6753589511,
-0.1713630706,
0.1670011133,
0.3139972389,
0.0768572018,
0.3066166937,
0.6011893153,
0.3523951769,
-0.5461964607,
0.081795387,
-0.7567481995,
-0.0735281631,
-0.1392051131,
-0.773245573,
-1.0946497917,
-0.5138908625,
-0.5444795489,
-0.113465935,
0.1823837608,
0.7011711001,
0.8861401081,
-0.5039610863,
-0.1468373239,
-0.1000338495,
0.2121471465,
-0.2865207195,
-0.1638872027,
0.4464867711,
0.0663323104,
-0.651699841,
0.2764801681,
0.0500028133,
0.1780565381,
-0.734775424,
0.0388544686,
0.0781968385,
-0.1270934939,
0.2858311236,
0.4031848907,
-0.3599748015,
-0.0514270924,
-0.2004473805,
-0.19452703,
0.0115213804,
0.5752995014,
-0.891508162,
0.1576033235,
0.2537914217,
0.7493368983,
0.2814788818,
0.2029172629,
0.5805114508,
-1.0539326668,
0.414054364,
0.2316058278,
0.1221577153,
0.3829605579,
-0.6414788365,
0.6498837471,
-0.0530028678,
-0.7322309017,
-1.1227439642,
0.0423364565,
-0.69665277,
0.020958079,
0.7680766582,
-0.684202373,
-0.4297562838,
0.503906846,
0.3917549253,
-0.0233036168,
-0.4131795764,
0.8099367023,
0.1912415773,
0.2643118799,
-0.0644504502,
-0.326662302,
0.6314603686,
-0.0493529998,
-0.9534965754,
0.3201974034,
0.4149052203,
0.145810619,
-0.0773326084,
0.3993679881,
0.1588357389,
0.1948426068,
-0.1327690035,
-0.1141771749,
-0.2869516611,
-0.3425321579,
-0.7023098469,
0.2721237838,
-0.2915101349,
-0.4080389738
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10974v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10974v1 | Towards Supporting Legal Argumentation with NLP: Is More Data Really All You Need? | 2024-06-16T15:15:44 | 2024-06-16T15:15:44 | T. Y. S. S Santosh, Kevin D. Ashley, Katie Atkinson, Matthias Grabmair | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Modeling legal reasoning and argumentation justifying decisions in cases has
always been central to AI & Law, yet contemporary developments in legal NLP
have increasingly focused on statistically classifying legal conclusions from
text. While conceptually simpler, these approaches often fall short in
providing usable justifications connecting to appropriate legal concepts. This
paper reviews both traditional symbolic works in AI & Law and recent advances
in legal NLP, and distills possibilities of integrating expert-informed
knowledge to strike a balance between scalability and explanation in symbolic
vs. data-driven approaches. We identify open challenges and discuss the
potential of modern NLP models and methods that integrate | [
-0.2031703144,
-0.6967307925,
0.7899125218,
0.125442341,
-0.3067464828,
-0.3232832551,
-0.0434289165,
-0.6915352941,
0.0280604362,
0.4289036989,
-0.2245147973,
-0.1997670233,
-0.6186042428,
-0.0248242989,
-0.3908699751,
1.007121563,
0.1450657248,
0.5101787448,
-0.7568950653,
-0.6058239937,
-0.7673165202,
-0.9971219301,
-0.9922568202,
-0.2903723121,
0.4512138963,
0.1360605508,
0.8624520302,
0.8255676627,
0.3707684875,
0.2701829076,
-0.0929858536,
-0.0885741636,
0.1334891319,
0.4121802151,
-0.2110930383,
-0.6262362003,
-0.2298568785,
-0.0699181557,
0.3062015176,
0.5631423593,
-0.2867190838,
0.0271477904,
-0.6546759009,
0.6319404244,
-0.4798112214,
0.1439531893,
-0.5441319942,
0.3931115866,
-0.0292445607,
0.0674492046,
-0.5224366784,
-0.2298413664,
0.2295496911,
-0.5741127133,
-0.2367823422,
0.1478699744,
0.8331177831,
0.6604497433,
-0.5557227731,
-0.5426362753,
-0.7063195705,
0.6007213593,
-0.9982272387,
0.3825879991,
0.1310018003,
0.5779158473,
0.0719134882,
-0.9518361688,
-0.607894659,
-0.5586280227,
0.0194321852,
0.1770521402,
-0.5027948022,
-0.0079078842,
0.5076346993,
-0.2437780648,
-0.3193625808,
0.3487409353,
-0.1594582945,
0.0216356255,
0.9471438527,
-0.0442239307,
0.248194322,
-0.1272442639,
0.0293926857,
-0.0635228902,
-0.5537161827,
-0.0655239448,
0.4189867079,
0.108792223,
0.0109609747,
0.7579312325,
0.2871402204,
0.6228449345,
0.0982374549,
0.261492312,
-0.2079915851,
-0.1623047888,
-0.1984583586,
0.4658216238,
0.9753196239,
0.1976325661,
0.4811614454,
0.1191775203,
0.0349538475,
-0.1402428001,
0.5081958175,
-0.4378824234,
0.0465246178,
0.6554402709,
-0.6679002047,
-0.0503255315,
0.0869669467,
-0.6705205441,
-0.8088923693,
-0.6306445003,
-0.1982100457,
-0.3080638945,
-0.2352821082,
0.5873385668,
-0.5828590989,
0.3153178692,
0.5346224308,
-0.778010726,
0.2652703822,
0.9160049558,
0.6647145748,
0.3061363697,
0.178888917,
-0.4194072485,
0.2748343647,
-0.6400010586,
1.0375458002,
-0.5931257606,
0.0259419475,
0.0877895206,
-0.2538452148,
0.08655148,
-0.5286970735,
1.056750536,
-0.4801405668,
0.0987711772,
-0.3477707505,
-0.5815650225,
-0.5143441558,
0.0960043296,
-0.868309319,
0.6694562435,
-0.2197143137,
-0.5881491899,
1.0411180258,
-1.0235034227,
-0.687671423,
0.414773047,
-0.5943793654,
-0.6030678749,
0.2913011312,
0.1875960678,
0.4919513166,
-0.2898598313,
0.8279153705,
-0.5765324235,
0.2763551474,
0.0097658196,
-0.3266133964,
1.2770401239,
0.4132315814,
-0.3486815989,
0.1617193669,
-0.6080127954,
-0.1732272953,
0.1132595912,
-0.1054026559,
-0.2593025565,
0.7036502361,
-0.1217855141,
0.3282196224,
0.0473567434,
-0.3301562965,
0.0760321096,
-0.2938334942,
0.4870812297,
0.4866820574,
-0.3455236554,
0.3894956112,
-0.2351245582,
0.6382808685,
-0.1750619113,
-0.0603966378,
0.2777673304,
-0.7439661026,
-0.5096895695,
-0.0241925195,
0.4404374659,
0.5782566667,
-0.3105365932,
0.4462223947,
-0.2414592057,
-0.2164401412,
-0.6234759092,
-0.1853401959,
-0.2316700667,
0.2512848675,
0.3344181478,
0.1937465519,
-0.9959771037,
-0.8607282043,
-0.4277560115,
-0.6131843328,
-0.1417026371,
0.5009006262,
0.5175743699,
0.0542097725,
1.2769830227,
0.0817325115,
-0.0891974717,
-0.7170250416,
0.0705911443,
0.3106928766,
0.3203020394,
0.8958665133,
-0.8906019926,
-0.2839123905,
0.4815595448,
-1.1503002644,
-0.3220741153,
-0.6821262836,
-0.0360542834,
-0.0029241843,
0.548468709,
-1.0334678888,
0.30737409,
-0.252371639,
-0.5254842639,
0.5898599029,
-0.1376926601,
-0.2416559309,
-0.856210053,
-0.1785531193,
0.4740709662,
-0.4998526275,
-0.7068009973,
0.2969922125,
-0.2579825819,
0.1122996435,
-0.4119659066,
0.4477528632,
-0.1393398494,
0.149585411,
-0.2831596434,
0.0183231235,
-0.0570647344,
-0.1214357018,
0.2117312998,
0.1538158506,
0.5323086977,
-0.3681162,
0.7856822014,
0.0090519516,
0.0843621045,
0.8941059709,
-0.8000971079,
-0.2659671307,
-0.2300245464,
0.4694380462,
-0.3338707089,
-0.317530483,
0.3575845957,
-0.1737903506,
0.1696365625,
-0.737550199,
-0.5048878789,
-0.4572808146,
-0.1291422844,
0.2948414087,
0.2557450235,
-0.3566069305,
0.9289206862,
0.5946004391,
-0.1478462964,
-0.5873656273,
-0.5931139588,
0.5403810143,
-0.7106223702,
-0.5365940332,
0.1199408397,
0.3554618359,
-0.9718121886,
-0.0210636575,
0.1176704243,
-0.2321512401,
0.1432229429,
0.222029537,
-0.1216439307,
-0.4810743928,
0.4405415058,
0.1898104548,
-0.2350970805,
0.7060857415,
-0.411246866,
0.1985722184,
-0.1297921687,
-0.6141545177,
-0.5638890862,
0.7504307032,
0.4517085552,
0.1920068562,
0.4373105168,
0.131005913,
-0.4728995562,
-0.0451859869,
-0.5975509286,
0.1370895207,
-0.3766782582,
0.3138126731,
-0.111507386,
-0.6350006461,
0.1934362799,
-0.1010175496,
0.7225083709,
0.8286855221,
0.6794837117,
-0.2974670529,
1.1829371452,
0.3887803853,
-0.0917173028,
0.175729543,
0.130994454,
0.5591448545,
-0.1267749667,
-0.0814022347,
-0.8135359287,
-0.0406277589,
-0.4462425411,
-0.0968744308,
-0.1961885393,
0.1250613928,
-0.277151227,
0.267047137,
-0.4699258208,
0.4891367257,
0.3913415074,
-0.1584651321,
0.2277777493,
-0.2669615149,
0.176469326,
0.1377544254,
-0.9017871022,
-0.7666428685,
0.8752585053,
0.6108240485,
0.3510493338,
0.107471481,
0.3305522799,
0.4342238605,
0.0336021446,
-1.0208854675,
0.5796973109,
-0.2433462292,
-0.7609507442,
-0.1667975783,
-0.2675559223,
-0.853862524,
0.2854006588,
-0.4426223636,
-0.522349298,
0.1057670265,
-0.0241835285,
-0.6292972565,
0.2120307833,
-0.6043067575,
0.7380260229,
-0.3671044707,
-0.117823258,
-0.2527189255,
-0.5991694331,
0.1882497966,
0.0576320738,
0.3425625563,
-0.1858851761,
0.1897088885,
1.1164232492,
-0.8716558218,
0.6556475163,
-0.1815078855,
-0.1260942072,
0.5406053066,
-0.4368774593,
0.2571032643,
0.2519564629,
-0.2199160457,
-0.0489615798,
0.4041138887,
-0.2756869197,
-0.7693693638,
0.2941713929,
-0.3560463488,
-0.8564521074,
-0.353831917,
-0.5654378533,
0.0465883762,
0.0237705931,
-0.198079586,
-0.0250069275,
0.3716373146,
0.3212219775,
0.4451438189,
0.1354914159,
0.4883699715,
0.2082416266,
0.2033281624,
-0.2551071048,
0.7648437619,
0.205099836,
-0.476337105,
-0.0233245622,
0.5843273997,
-0.6947867274,
-0.6940456629,
-0.5743118525,
0.2483671457,
-1.0238925219,
-0.0299648549,
-0.7264758348,
0.0322770216,
-0.3825142086,
-0.3034064472,
-0.2538096905,
-0.7883589268,
-0.1719639599,
-0.3628658652,
0.6447115541,
0.8971610069,
-0.0616268925,
0.0351504944,
-0.5913976431,
0.1694423407,
0.2517892122,
0.1597076207,
-0.2060498893,
-0.3507381976,
0.0223692507,
0.0070768921,
-0.0952395722,
-0.9639297724,
0.0459770486,
-0.0254795179,
0.6603657603,
0.5697251558,
-0.012558396,
0.8318294287,
-0.6306264997,
0.9295894504,
0.2090364993,
-0.7013604641,
0.5748577714,
-0.0836337656,
-0.246084705,
0.5563855171,
0.4339219332,
-0.3811793327,
-0.1692326218,
-0.5531833172,
-0.7630079985,
0.3720899224,
-0.0649744272,
0.2792603076,
0.0978394225,
0.6833800077,
0.1077445,
-0.0476174876,
-1.038589716,
0.1571492255,
-0.1675485373,
-0.4576246738,
0.4130735397,
0.0916838124,
-0.3113200665,
-0.5772942305,
0.3749643564,
-0.1696447581,
-0.0144188125,
-0.1152637824,
-0.0386422984,
0.3123069704,
0.1228538677,
0.4423402846,
0.6504102945,
0.3201210201,
-0.0533109121,
0.2433589846,
-0.2269810736,
0.1488414705,
0.0781796202,
-0.0699479356,
0.3780632615,
0.7223394513,
0.6986375451,
-0.3243312836,
-0.7392619252,
0.5299477577,
-0.0697026849,
-0.6987800598,
-0.5055371523,
0.0403496623,
0.1979488432,
0.5923998356,
0.1849360764,
-0.1219047904,
0.0358959846,
-0.4551442862,
0.3377106488,
0.6169130802,
-0.2835688591,
0.1768481135,
0.9130971432,
-0.0555449128,
-0.2263210565,
0.3386369348,
0.2609451115,
-0.257942766,
0.8703773022,
0.2383514792,
0.8458414674,
0.3379899561,
0.099518761,
0.187078476,
0.0338762738,
-0.382864058,
0.1855887324,
-0.349611789,
-0.5067207813,
-0.59251827,
-0.2448237389,
-0.4861843288,
-0.0314481184,
-0.3721060157,
0.2768992484,
-0.584769547,
-0.2386919558,
0.1900386065,
-0.1731583625,
-0.3177043796,
0.1148878261,
0.0190811045,
0.8884875178,
-0.85525769,
0.5701937675,
0.755500257,
-0.5811968446,
-0.4803745747,
-0.2044963539,
0.0333838053,
-0.3352882564,
0.5926221013,
0.0112374695,
-0.0260541569,
-0.3492263854,
-0.8975608349,
-0.3172438741,
0.6453902721,
0.5711224675,
-0.276261121,
-0.05900025,
0.3326536119,
0.777056396,
-0.4000659287,
0.4734813273,
0.5914965272,
0.7987205982,
0.207477361,
-0.217402935,
0.014933751,
-0.4138885438,
-0.2414459884,
-0.1711759269,
0.0413308628,
0.4202347994,
-0.1986936927,
-0.3292072117,
-0.3093196452,
0.7517927289,
0.161543414,
0.5106642246,
0.457606703,
0.7298050523,
0.6790481806,
-0.2227420807,
1.1544055939,
-0.0344258398,
-0.0593557097,
1.0720187426,
-0.3828010559,
0.6944181919,
0.530259192,
-0.2889325023,
0.4834485948,
0.8210553527,
-0.3441421092,
-0.1392217427,
0.3633477688,
-0.1386760324,
-0.5264686942,
-0.3025316596,
-0.0688834637,
0.3070673347,
0.3757711053,
-0.1450809836,
-0.224426955,
-0.3124910891,
0.1699687541,
0.1515798569,
-0.0562993065,
1.0686779022,
0.0872257426,
-0.6794003844,
0.1998038292,
0.0014332043,
0.2317764014,
-0.3331103921,
-0.1666529477,
0.141324088,
-0.3336023688,
-0.4838367999,
-1.0707511902,
0.5916165709,
0.3561285734,
-0.104963772,
-0.3592302203,
0.5093232989,
0.1038124934,
-0.3720984757,
0.1886157244,
0.4049939215,
0.2711905241,
0.0302626304,
-0.9382092357,
-0.3011271358,
-0.2876441479,
-0.2366421074,
0.1377342194,
0.6499194503,
-0.4005532563,
0.8068276048,
0.7537460327,
0.2330790013,
0.2479692698,
0.4564392865,
0.5906241536,
-0.6185584068,
-0.330062747,
-1.2006092072,
0.5717951059,
-0.5065416098,
-0.0913252607,
0.3971817791,
0.2956930697,
0.4048480392,
0.1972564757,
0.8783165812,
-0.2464495599,
0.1152158529,
-0.671010673,
0.6163150072,
-0.4183907807,
0.1408852935,
-0.0311908368,
-0.4965572655,
-0.6897189021,
0.8201679587,
-0.2069700807,
-0.057948634,
0.4480674863,
0.1221534237,
-0.0404901728,
0.331241399,
0.1854747385,
-0.1305953264,
0.643004179,
0.4199083447,
0.9202151299,
-0.1832834482,
0.4244322181,
0.1187109202,
0.0539016277,
-0.1599313915,
-1.0849503279,
-0.7176316977,
-0.3054417968,
-0.4451712072,
-0.0006202459,
-0.2075217962,
0.8327198625,
0.8031760454,
-0.8475627899,
-0.301322341,
-0.6705752015,
0.3448781967,
-0.3085207641,
-0.1986872703,
0.1821909547,
-0.6507045031,
-0.4478331208,
0.335190326,
0.2366274148,
-0.0556128137,
0.0398339219,
-0.0320481583,
-0.3471881449,
0.4373182654,
0.714466691,
0.542319715,
-0.8237290978,
-0.1533094496,
-0.7176066041,
0.2162784189,
0.3316407502,
0.9995297194,
-0.4755274057,
0.3068833053,
0.5854232907,
0.9258815646,
0.0425478704,
0.072913833,
0.896371901,
-0.2813916206,
0.1115210578,
0.5442147255,
0.8348867297,
-0.1787335426,
-0.2752886415,
0.5803170204,
0.0641251281,
-0.3142020404,
-0.7689498663,
0.3043157458,
-0.8513255715,
-0.5038489103,
0.937265873,
-0.251368314,
-0.0489559285,
-0.5280884504,
-0.1765802503,
0.073880747,
-0.3273369372,
0.732827723,
1.0089640617,
-0.2524744868,
-0.341378808,
-0.9680493474,
0.5820510387,
0.5082135797,
-1.2133129835,
0.236370191,
0.6759495735,
-0.3419441283,
0.3643626273,
0.2290596068,
-0.1384957135,
0.4079475999,
0.1177908257,
-0.2865563929,
0.1842059046,
-0.3230064213,
-0.4602734745,
0.4074267745,
0.0263549909,
0.2993885279
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.