id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12030v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12030v1 | SPA-VL: A Comprehensive Safety Preference Alignment Dataset for Vision Language Model | 2024-06-17T18:57:37 | 2024-06-17T18:57:37 | Yongting Zhang, Lu Chen, Guodong Zheng, Yifeng Gao, Rui Zheng, Jinlan Fu, Zhenfei Yin, Senjie Jin, Yu Qiao, Xuanjing Huang, Feng Zhao, Tao Gui, Jing Shao | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | The emergence of Vision Language Models (VLMs) has brought unprecedented
advances in understanding multimodal information. The combination of textual
and visual semantics in VLMs is highly complex and diverse, making the safety
alignment of these models challenging. Furthermore, due to the limited study on
the safety alignment of VLMs, there is a lack of large-scale, high-quality
datasets. To address these limitations, we propose a Safety Preference
Alignment dataset for Vision Language Models named SPA-VL. In terms of breadth,
SPA-VL covers 6 harmfulness domains, 13 categories, and 53 subcategories, and
contains 100,788 samples of the quadruple (question, image, chosen response,
rejected response). In terms of depth, the responses are collected from 12
open- (e.g., QwenVL) and closed-source (e.g., Gemini) VLMs to ensure diversity.
The experimental results indicate that models trained with alignment techniques
on the SPA-VL dataset exhibit substantial improvements in harmlessness and
helpfulness while maintaining core capabilities. SPA-VL, as a large-scale,
high-quality, and diverse dataset, represents a significant milestone in
ensuring that VLMs achieve both harmlessness and helpfulness. We have made our
code https://github.com/EchoseChen/SPA-VL-RLHF and SPA-VL dataset url
https://huggingface.co/datasets/sqrti/SPA-VL publicly available. | [
-0.3298496902,
-0.3434074819,
0.1790491194,
0.094726041,
-0.0961677283,
-0.1239910126,
0.1400907338,
-0.5728731155,
-0.2641246617,
0.8914022446,
-0.4294802248,
-0.6835506558,
-0.5682740211,
-0.1936921626,
-0.3935483992,
1.1609034538,
0.1768195778,
0.185285598,
0.1403510123,
-0.4073535502,
-0.5217046738,
-0.5162549615,
-0.2167626917,
0.2466293573,
0.7649841309,
0.2212286592,
0.8992367983,
0.9273993969,
0.7533000708,
0.3035569191,
-0.0603016689,
0.263177067,
-0.4759807885,
-0.0311907176,
-0.3780881763,
0.0075257267,
-0.6570958495,
-0.3275623024,
0.6793689132,
0.6542520523,
-0.1786180735,
0.0940695331,
0.0498066396,
0.7787656784,
-0.783213079,
-0.1667294055,
-0.6242470145,
0.0407811776,
-0.3114765584,
0.0951371938,
-0.5084146261,
-0.4145300984,
0.5487912893,
-0.5496702194,
-0.0387344249,
0.3799352348,
1.0416259766,
0.4244891405,
-0.5750150681,
0.2940520942,
-0.4305676818,
0.7109538317,
-0.4373720288,
0.4936649501,
-0.0672214404,
0.4117294252,
0.0504531525,
-0.2628789842,
-0.4142372608,
0.0121210422,
0.0455276333,
-0.145699963,
-0.1039514765,
0.0335796587,
0.0811511353,
-0.1506948322,
-0.9458215237,
0.1310760081,
-0.3048038781,
-0.2726374269,
0.6053248644,
0.505920589,
0.3121199608,
0.2040738463,
-0.7743950486,
-0.1405786872,
-0.8952050209,
-0.0430701487,
0.22070086,
0.4840627313,
-0.2287359834,
0.9611206055,
-0.2063427418,
1.2510033846,
-0.2307987362,
-0.0179690421,
0.8165061474,
-0.5244604349,
-0.3084655702,
0.1396380663,
0.7647298574,
0.884313345,
0.4872221053,
0.1929570585,
-0.0762571022,
0.1434116364,
0.4276215732,
-0.334702462,
0.0810744688,
0.0788984597,
-0.0190597828,
-0.5207449198,
0.0603898391,
-0.9336278439,
-0.6361662149,
-0.5649141073,
0.3293063641,
-0.414023608,
-0.359392643,
0.5704603195,
0.0444008335,
0.3372505009,
0.3388622999,
-0.6511702538,
0.0418896154,
0.5917729139,
0.5492656827,
-0.5061351657,
-0.5569158196,
-0.5663033128,
0.3308306932,
-0.3332243562,
0.6211901903,
-0.4289603531,
-0.2481291145,
0.0033739335,
0.2302527279,
-0.1299269497,
-0.3397906125,
0.32122311,
-0.264913559,
0.1452133507,
-0.234471038,
-0.2038620114,
0.0022519662,
0.1908308566,
-0.6256538033,
0.8757705688,
-0.0043904344,
-0.9599214792,
0.6029638648,
-0.4502722621,
-0.1766390949,
0.0623269305,
-0.2648107708,
-0.6089225411,
-0.2314376682,
0.0970061868,
0.2101085186,
0.0854148939,
0.3147462904,
-0.6681377292,
-0.2509149909,
0.5155656338,
-0.4941105843,
0.8025166988,
0.2383978665,
-0.3620222211,
0.4428147972,
-0.6215825677,
0.0422977507,
0.0274750944,
-0.0127675906,
-0.4539862275,
-0.2474691719,
0.2465890795,
0.4581819177,
0.4420412183,
-0.4109645188,
-0.0381197669,
-0.4753211141,
-0.12511307,
1.0206720829,
-0.314494729,
0.3236849606,
-0.1524825245,
0.1904754192,
0.3567384779,
0.832264483,
0.2435875833,
-0.4418810606,
-0.8126513362,
-0.2728191018,
0.0084539503,
0.6273238063,
-0.5910994411,
0.5853452682,
-0.4221828282,
-0.3225156963,
-0.6755049229,
-0.04668428,
0.9013559818,
0.6099666357,
0.3009541929,
-0.2002292722,
-0.4254125655,
-1.1382645369,
-0.021414496,
0.0355274081,
0.4771023989,
0.4547407031,
0.082329005,
-0.2650223672,
1.0051350594,
-0.5109968185,
-0.1782152057,
0.007366457,
-0.449980706,
0.0117667355,
0.3625296354,
0.8527374268,
-1.1778618097,
-0.4172175527,
0.2517597377,
-0.7087535262,
-0.0329407826,
0.5007891059,
-0.5586561561,
0.5102163553,
-0.0738456175,
-0.3850750625,
0.3546646833,
0.6673474908,
-0.8297126889,
0.3698812425,
0.023312619,
0.1485490352,
-1.1537578106,
0.2339468449,
0.3562109172,
-0.1901600212,
-0.8159536123,
0.0325852819,
0.0765367523,
0.1201659366,
-0.9921197891,
0.5520969033,
-0.196035713,
-0.299169153,
-0.0026325874,
-0.024100814,
-0.0888315067,
0.1893284172,
0.4225644469,
0.8247359395,
0.8073494434,
-0.4335201979,
0.296526581,
0.2609607875,
-0.0635844469,
0.4656739235,
-0.3892580867,
-0.2126400769,
-0.2282956094,
-0.2546757758,
-0.6525754929,
-0.1972588003,
0.4858051538,
-0.2260671407,
0.2449122965,
-0.185864225,
-0.0483081602,
-0.169467628,
-0.1685227752,
0.4790685773,
0.3629460335,
-0.3893668652,
0.2572543025,
0.8838956952,
-0.2407752872,
-1.3271532059,
-0.3527210057,
0.0439636409,
-0.3675810695,
-0.5810950994,
-0.1008340344,
-0.1859636456,
-0.2409101576,
0.1618362069,
-0.0411009826,
0.0575958639,
-0.2754428685,
0.3497682214,
1.0522896051,
-0.2970322967,
-0.1557699442,
-0.1759088188,
-0.5094941854,
-0.4542148113,
-0.2103766501,
0.4687822163,
-0.5612976551,
-0.4315221906,
-0.0476257429,
0.3398808241,
0.7215951085,
-0.4260834157,
0.6929053664,
0.3096155524,
-0.3289604485,
0.1075123996,
-0.4908446074,
0.3440788686,
-0.4436138868,
0.3538859189,
-0.1275280416,
-1.1504696608,
-0.1271852553,
0.256577909,
0.1876634359,
0.306215167,
0.5875563622,
-0.0123184985,
1.1140435934,
0.7631564736,
-0.2342515588,
0.390191406,
0.0875636265,
0.1403912455,
-0.4502987862,
-0.4225024879,
-0.445507586,
0.2218142599,
-0.3146277666,
-0.2801366746,
0.4563122988,
-0.4912852347,
-0.52656883,
0.4464528263,
-0.7100248337,
0.5860714316,
0.1867859811,
0.0701724961,
0.0863863006,
0.3113851249,
0.0224135276,
-0.201803118,
-0.2891501486,
-0.545147121,
1.0198742151,
0.3331261873,
0.9784436822,
0.2730855346,
0.5146846175,
0.1031900868,
-0.0534574203,
-0.3267258704,
0.6458678842,
-0.4582759142,
-0.5540992022,
-0.4572523832,
-0.2855564356,
-0.7313202024,
0.4649965167,
-0.4236709177,
-0.8407751322,
0.2016295493,
0.3202968836,
-0.4408118725,
-0.0395616665,
-0.6427993774,
1.130071044,
-0.7118350863,
-0.482439667,
0.0537020899,
-1.0372568369,
0.4089566171,
-0.1164931133,
0.213980481,
-0.2699872255,
-0.08989162,
0.3204098642,
-0.1722955108,
0.8809096813,
-0.0515027158,
-0.0958940163,
-0.0441677421,
-0.2202339768,
0.1843371838,
-0.2852427363,
0.0564324483,
0.389626354,
0.0438187905,
-0.2378805131,
-0.2119362205,
0.7969477177,
-0.8258245587,
-0.4250249565,
-0.6972398758,
-0.5021427274,
-0.2803645432,
0.4602104425,
0.284337014,
0.3998428285,
0.0283849631,
0.0814694911,
1.1360501051,
-0.2469493002,
0.1367902607,
0.6202488542,
-0.5177602768,
-0.4773415029,
1.2301126719,
0.0406572223,
0.3940703869,
0.2042089999,
-0.2552382052,
-0.587477088,
-0.4631008804,
-0.7442911863,
0.0896726176,
-0.7232379317,
-0.1124733463,
-0.696321249,
-0.6007594466,
-0.4645519257,
-0.226565361,
-0.4073677063,
-0.1367622316,
0.0263043828,
-0.1520788223,
0.2436908484,
0.585088253,
0.1317705363,
-0.1559891254,
-0.930118978,
0.3700956404,
-0.0578900054,
0.3717432022,
-0.6800821424,
-0.1250434071,
-0.071100913,
-0.0755676478,
0.0366664566,
-0.6822292209,
0.3914069831,
-0.1531024575,
0.7380205393,
0.4144544899,
0.0294815004,
0.640026629,
-0.5041045547,
0.752880156,
0.5389018655,
-0.632216692,
0.4866680801,
-0.3177468479,
-0.2906413972,
0.477725774,
0.260907501,
-0.3903876841,
-0.2091427743,
-0.3756482899,
-0.8875828385,
0.4541172683,
0.2117089182,
-0.2008522451,
0.3093370497,
-0.0483300202,
0.319049865,
0.2225585133,
-0.6908584237,
-0.2052653283,
-0.3136977553,
-0.5916883945,
-0.1350072771,
-0.2762734294,
-0.4689541161,
-0.0023189604,
0.687104404,
-0.2366310805,
-0.0521379411,
-0.1435789913,
0.1082641333,
-0.1287651211,
0.2314707339,
0.668032825,
0.482993722,
0.0431389101,
0.2844907641,
0.1957046092,
-0.4450334907,
0.2891325653,
0.0312281009,
-0.2189154476,
-0.264659971,
0.0760505274,
0.7240431905,
0.005084177,
-0.8555625081,
0.825820744,
-0.1018436104,
0.0732434317,
-0.2162679136,
0.4798263609,
-0.217623353,
0.2244036496,
-0.1502473503,
0.2731668949,
0.2995093465,
0.0156082204,
0.4250213206,
0.5218837857,
-0.4436429441,
0.133855924,
0.3836198449,
0.0741662234,
0.0549889095,
0.3921870887,
0.3276548386,
-0.2341588885,
0.5046865344,
0.2731087506,
0.7012704015,
-0.17377913,
0.2230654806,
0.1964607388,
0.3882600069,
-0.0227918401,
0.3832119405,
0.3805502951,
-0.8838645816,
-0.2433559448,
-0.8074947596,
-0.2612667084,
-0.0237352774,
-0.6179283261,
0.4121033549,
-0.2634111047,
-0.2417330593,
-0.1104989126,
-0.5226939321,
-0.4360390604,
0.3500521183,
0.3328445256,
0.8271120787,
-1.0721871853,
0.9522182345,
0.7294636965,
-0.3378657401,
-0.5815147758,
-0.1169359535,
0.4041231275,
-0.9579653144,
0.4478337169,
0.2361741215,
-0.4364073873,
-0.1544112265,
-0.6137129068,
-1.0489441156,
0.9498174787,
0.4835036397,
-0.8857530355,
-0.1176456884,
0.4811964333,
0.4880836904,
-0.3794056177,
-0.4666144252,
0.3353269994,
0.4473814368,
0.2586659193,
-0.9720595479,
-0.0473345928,
-0.3849325776,
0.2642542422,
0.292452246,
-0.6050271392,
0.3568616509,
-0.3937360644,
0.0202460606,
0.1354197264,
0.3777957261,
0.666785419,
0.3364007771,
0.5906480551,
0.642986536,
0.3949782848,
-0.166891396,
0.6077321172,
-0.213985309,
0.31859079,
1.0634012222,
-0.5341498852,
0.6529418826,
0.625259161,
0.0831649229,
-0.0979493707,
0.5195871592,
-0.0464340933,
0.7728916407,
-0.2019894123,
-0.2804696858,
-0.6648893952,
-0.2284178585,
-0.581618309,
0.2379149497,
0.375648886,
-0.2666004598,
-0.0991727784,
0.087455608,
-0.2971983552,
-0.3241250217,
-0.0996862426,
0.7782896161,
-0.0960419253,
-0.4620021582,
0.2568075359,
-0.5146424174,
0.4425650835,
-0.5728948116,
-0.1202760041,
0.1191231459,
0.2879057527,
-0.258933574,
-1.5060083866,
0.2953437567,
0.0509729385,
-0.0265688784,
0.1015299857,
0.7558776736,
-0.4274771512,
-0.379239738,
0.3492531776,
0.2310549468,
0.0706053525,
0.538801074,
-0.843968153,
0.3340548575,
0.0285022035,
-0.1627358049,
0.5311565995,
0.2896476686,
-0.255251199,
0.7668642402,
0.6032708287,
0.021603778,
0.3933169246,
-0.0269519594,
0.9623222947,
-0.4050504565,
-0.4150853753,
-0.7217658758,
1.0141997337,
-0.2535304725,
-0.4323179424,
0.6006729603,
0.6666125655,
0.7877462506,
-0.0530866012,
0.9094753861,
0.0153626762,
0.2365959734,
-0.710831821,
0.5968873501,
-0.6150690317,
0.0431465395,
-0.4758169353,
-0.7624001503,
-0.4818641245,
0.5044307113,
-0.1208532676,
-0.090751715,
0.2305577695,
1.0992825031,
-0.089493759,
-0.1329223663,
0.5440913439,
-0.0497704335,
0.1446550041,
0.5732383728,
0.7815660834,
-0.0260160025,
0.4751393199,
-0.2203597128,
-0.4981893897,
-0.3778017759,
-0.9083833694,
-0.5968381166,
-0.7713090777,
-0.3047121167,
-0.5880679488,
0.4754824042,
0.8648614287,
0.6162691116,
-0.7129608393,
0.0018945748,
0.0706066638,
-0.112007007,
-0.1488704234,
-0.1577931494,
0.2240564227,
-0.0547225475,
-0.4705653489,
0.2602501214,
0.6561065316,
0.3342552781,
-0.1295677722,
-0.3758653104,
0.1626237035,
-0.1702074409,
0.5250914693,
0.3034441769,
-0.8871598244,
-0.5397778749,
0.0626437962,
-0.558152616,
-0.0411453359,
0.3364052176,
-0.1293415874,
0.4949711561,
0.4176277816,
0.5242774487,
0.0314440057,
-0.242813006,
0.4883545637,
-0.3597336113,
0.0087286644,
-0.0694517791,
0.7955456972,
0.2893993556,
-0.5401428342,
0.5483360887,
0.1736492962,
-0.4891942143,
-0.718788743,
0.358643055,
-1.4554764032,
-0.1082867607,
1.3339574337,
-0.0145259593,
-0.2880792916,
-0.1777463257,
-0.7412773967,
0.16727525,
-0.29907161,
0.4854328334,
0.4133636057,
-0.1002403051,
-0.3357248008,
-0.0882212892,
0.3891519904,
0.2029183358,
-0.7042089701,
0.3578796685,
0.9235510826,
0.6816205978,
0.1152126715,
0.459393084,
-0.4642907977,
0.4574041069,
-0.2939742208,
0.2963531315,
-0.061347153,
-0.7634288669,
-0.5112364292,
0.2653841376,
0.0744368434,
-0.341538012
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12023v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12023v1 | LiLiuM: eBay's Large Language Models for e-commerce | 2024-06-17T18:45:41 | 2024-06-17T18:45:41 | Christian Herold, Michael Kozielski, Leonid Ekimov, Pavel Petrushkov, Pierre-Yves Vandenbussche, Shahram Khadivi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | We introduce the LiLiuM series of large language models (LLMs): 1B, 7B, and
13B parameter models developed 100% in-house to fit eBay's specific needs in
the e-commerce domain. This gives eBay full control over all aspects of the
models including license, data, vocabulary, and architecture. We expect these
models to be used as a foundation for fine-tuning and instruction-tuning,
eliminating dependencies to external models.
The LiLiuM LLMs have been trained on 3 trillion tokens of multilingual text
from general and e-commerce domain. They perform similar to the popular LLaMA-2
models on English natural language understanding (NLU) benchmarks. At the same
time, we outperform LLaMA-2 on non-English NLU tasks, machine translation and
on e-commerce specific downstream tasks.
As part of our data mixture, we utilize the newly released RedPajama-V2
dataset for training and share our insights regarding data filtering and
deduplication. We also discuss in detail how to serialize structured data for
use in autoregressive language modeling. We provide insights on the effects of
including code and parallel machine translation data in pre-training.
Furthermore, we develop our own tokenizer and model vocabulary, customized
towards e-commerce. This way, we can achieve up to 34% speed-up in text
generation on eBay-specific downstream tasks compared to LLaMA-2.
Finally, in relation to LLM pretraining, we show that checkpoint averaging
can further improve over the best individual model checkpoint. | [
-0.204658553,
-0.7289928198,
0.2584224343,
0.1643953174,
-0.4157935679,
0.0487751216,
-0.189739719,
-0.9999361038,
0.3270712793,
0.4043011963,
-0.6823720932,
-0.3455865085,
-0.3148141205,
0.2707005143,
-0.6510784626,
1.0802608728,
0.1271724999,
0.0133321593,
0.0838312209,
-0.0310570262,
-0.0834771767,
-0.4822263718,
-0.7471364737,
0.0045650927,
0.6802092195,
0.4122629464,
0.5615548491,
0.8284181952,
0.5139552951,
0.3102547824,
0.1816292703,
0.1452776492,
-0.6896100044,
0.292455703,
-0.0681989491,
-0.739269793,
-0.794712007,
-0.3161290586,
0.2291032225,
0.4873942733,
-0.4694456458,
0.3676247895,
-0.1642881632,
0.537065804,
-0.5279179811,
0.0188681725,
-0.5883342028,
-0.0696576089,
-0.1227772385,
-0.0616068654,
-0.3898542225,
-0.2358019203,
-0.0557040945,
-0.9121392965,
0.1540738791,
0.3652867079,
1.0559369326,
0.1130634546,
-0.3897642493,
-0.392839402,
-0.8843259811,
1.1429376602,
-0.6128757596,
0.5324143171,
0.3578009903,
0.0908138007,
-0.1338393241,
-1.0702445507,
-0.4475942552,
-0.1140459329,
-0.1000522897,
0.354657948,
-0.2607918978,
0.0433810726,
0.2006976455,
0.4829801023,
-0.6871517301,
0.2701048851,
-0.4081976712,
0.1201552674,
0.5909089446,
0.399802357,
0.4259741604,
0.1251867712,
-0.2948341668,
0.0605185218,
-0.8684299588,
-0.2014440149,
0.4320576489,
0.343611747,
-0.0954208821,
0.1641443223,
-0.5775416493,
0.8248484731,
-0.1192142069,
-0.5931172967,
0.028373871,
-0.4135237634,
-0.4022230208,
-0.1578793824,
0.5210614204,
0.25028947,
-0.0935337096,
-0.0759754702,
-0.3703530133,
-0.1160984784,
0.0348397195,
-0.8830093741,
-0.2475207746,
0.4154267907,
-0.6774383783,
-0.0532821082,
-0.0074263685,
-0.5706551671,
-0.0454905778,
-0.5911963582,
0.4534437358,
0.2008744776,
-0.250554949,
0.2802349329,
0.027597053,
0.1784587055,
0.3605360985,
-1.0676094294,
0.5990695953,
0.7452697754,
0.6904821396,
0.0453839898,
-0.3147303462,
-0.4523121417,
0.4900540411,
-0.1948350668,
0.6277061701,
-0.2264564484,
-0.0855746418,
0.1726277322,
0.1479328424,
0.2940674126,
-0.6533168554,
0.5037501454,
-0.8205314875,
-0.0181516912,
-0.1379728019,
-0.5901406407,
-0.2443196476,
0.4760055542,
-0.7487649918,
0.585030973,
0.017606955,
-0.3964271247,
0.3339151442,
-0.2168525308,
-0.5051509738,
0.2160716355,
-0.013418206,
-0.4278178215,
0.0784724727,
0.1655174643,
0.3880263567,
-0.5922454596,
-0.2088551372,
-0.3377966583,
-0.4648841619,
0.0516096316,
-0.218118012,
0.837520659,
0.2992801368,
-0.2918535173,
-0.1247416958,
-0.6266152263,
-0.2134279013,
0.2563750446,
-0.2428091466,
-0.314732492,
-0.0504490882,
0.3827776909,
0.0777694434,
0.5290008187,
-0.3743062019,
0.2310719341,
-0.4037773609,
0.4136368036,
0.6617109776,
-0.2901585698,
0.1367326528,
-0.3972754776,
0.8679522872,
-0.06114823,
0.4864753187,
-0.390945822,
-0.608002007,
-1.1319702864,
-0.3098471463,
0.2955665886,
0.6050371528,
-0.3637989461,
0.1597961783,
-0.2656930089,
-0.4495106637,
-0.4493741393,
0.4033289552,
0.0906555578,
0.0323128924,
0.1925177276,
-0.3264928758,
-0.3707064986,
-1.1276409626,
-0.1513074189,
-0.3637813628,
0.0812364891,
0.2202763259,
0.2135658711,
-0.4784747958,
0.6005474925,
-0.4625914395,
-0.3939167857,
-0.5072146058,
0.1782108098,
0.4909558296,
0.1596503854,
0.3832840919,
-0.6435956359,
-0.5651760697,
0.1981386095,
-0.4175667465,
-0.1584289223,
-0.2434230894,
-0.1990904063,
0.3610961139,
0.4591183066,
-0.7336027622,
0.2688206136,
0.5422233939,
0.0671806261,
0.2427557558,
-0.4025256038,
0.2278567702,
-1.2298146486,
-0.2915341556,
0.1321772486,
-0.3422101438,
-0.602360189,
0.3304721415,
0.2405514568,
0.1642054915,
-0.5299524665,
0.2559390962,
-0.5356777906,
-0.3334877789,
-0.2688129842,
0.4149459898,
0.3003725111,
0.1854546368,
-0.123050645,
0.6723709106,
0.1747414023,
-0.9537934661,
0.6557378769,
0.191038698,
-0.5797916651,
0.3467759192,
-0.7615530491,
-0.0368356891,
-0.004770604,
0.0782483593,
-0.7573622465,
-0.0852115378,
0.1333057135,
-0.2387336642,
0.4320905805,
-0.1901802123,
-0.8317781687,
-0.3627538085,
-0.153939411,
0.2414980382,
0.5671016574,
-0.7025156021,
0.481498152,
0.395889461,
-0.3095290363,
-0.5331327319,
-0.8318695426,
0.1330667436,
-0.4242608249,
-0.4887645245,
0.5166588426,
-0.3534376025,
-0.2729961872,
-0.2252200842,
0.4806318581,
-0.0122091146,
0.4999578893,
-0.2267194986,
0.2696573734,
-0.1861356497,
0.3018447161,
0.0808733553,
-0.2089594305,
0.0665166751,
-0.282928437,
0.4399902225,
0.2937175333,
-0.3235061765,
-0.6661245227,
0.1016050428,
0.3391632438,
-0.0183349214,
0.8495237827,
0.4188016951,
-0.3769270778,
-0.4657454491,
-0.3551276922,
-0.3398703337,
-0.4989161789,
0.6017274261,
-0.4241384864,
-0.8095909953,
0.4154833555,
0.1714182496,
0.3065774739,
0.3025557399,
0.8487430811,
-0.0875839293,
1.1305713654,
0.9595341086,
-0.4876482785,
0.403314501,
-0.0221186802,
0.622517705,
-0.4468984008,
-0.061701335,
-0.5330210924,
-0.3629247844,
-0.6994075775,
-0.2356644124,
-0.029283518,
0.3189202249,
-0.3436257243,
0.3359049857,
-0.0688385218,
0.5617392659,
0.5429182649,
-0.0939511284,
0.5910694003,
0.3909065425,
0.4893105626,
-0.0087060165,
-0.597741127,
-0.4946397841,
1.2640028,
0.3139742911,
0.9277489185,
0.5036967397,
0.4801749885,
0.2468152344,
0.4257483184,
-0.9592094421,
0.3961791992,
-0.258803159,
-0.64884305,
0.0870550945,
-0.3222561777,
-0.8893994093,
0.1203733981,
0.2123584449,
-0.5373237729,
-0.1480237544,
-0.0248781983,
-0.5936077833,
0.3239691257,
-0.4139139652,
0.6370491982,
-0.518155098,
-0.4687958658,
-0.4491131008,
-0.1534422487,
0.3848278224,
-0.2057773024,
0.2843165398,
-0.006147054,
-0.494115591,
0.6477338076,
-0.3111859262,
0.6927037835,
0.3161390126,
-0.3449195921,
0.0670285895,
0.0893834531,
0.5893949866,
0.0144826304,
0.1940999627,
0.1539853662,
-0.0948893428,
-0.4233009517,
-0.426215291,
0.8347979784,
-0.955354929,
-0.6605657339,
-0.2919547856,
-0.3129738867,
-0.100563854,
-0.0445399024,
0.12689659,
0.2533552945,
-0.1477213204,
0.1873734891,
0.6461236477,
-0.3619005978,
0.4411008656,
0.8199568391,
-0.5114356279,
-0.2979788482,
1.0286333561,
0.0339347422,
0.3070817888,
0.5977030396,
0.0605405159,
-0.2265540212,
-0.5694778562,
-0.7015758157,
0.4600261748,
-0.7877830863,
-0.2494344264,
-0.7090135813,
0.0239803772,
-0.3769635558,
0.1402608454,
-0.2182287872,
-0.5241237879,
-0.5848169327,
-0.2400434911,
0.4412069917,
1.1308076382,
0.0080911126,
0.5559882522,
-1.1330574751,
0.2883095145,
0.5173707008,
0.1286702752,
0.0150004057,
-0.8465060592,
-0.7996416688,
-0.0201680325,
-0.2332922071,
-0.5787406564,
0.576256156,
0.190500468,
0.4856683016,
0.8054668307,
-0.2250795662,
0.7619582415,
-0.3688313365,
0.909751296,
0.1176250279,
-0.8286668062,
0.4272580445,
-0.5376440287,
-0.0837555006,
0.2641612589,
0.6318642497,
-0.6183437109,
-0.2838226557,
-0.3750667572,
-0.9717555642,
0.775578022,
0.011947562,
0.3072859645,
-0.1266836822,
0.2905223072,
0.1613039672,
0.4292709529,
-0.828525126,
-0.4582100213,
0.334363848,
-0.4247093499,
-0.1889729202,
-0.4664320946,
0.0075326692,
-0.2137289196,
0.9189283848,
0.0550752282,
0.0313291326,
-0.2696429193,
-0.3864011765,
-0.2577055097,
0.0338547416,
0.6221182942,
0.8912755251,
-0.0447039269,
-0.4477163851,
-0.0505442023,
-0.5202437043,
0.0602285936,
0.0386274643,
-0.2825073302,
-0.0901212543,
0.1753701717,
0.4131642878,
-0.0317405276,
-0.8799524307,
0.3543711901,
-0.2354188859,
0.0549204759,
-0.5781639218,
-0.0867800266,
0.1621008366,
0.3248157501,
0.1975193173,
-0.6216979623,
0.4290565252,
-0.5714074969,
0.1287236959,
0.1955557317,
0.0594883412,
-0.3683753312,
0.6416783929,
0.193402335,
-0.0386900827,
0.7455384731,
-0.2970922589,
-0.5024450421,
0.7828765512,
0.6665545702,
0.8088294268,
-0.2663157582,
0.1776158214,
0.4761739671,
0.6852476001,
-0.204917714,
0.3457335234,
0.1124033332,
-0.7730329037,
-0.3390831351,
-0.8125082254,
-0.6141021252,
0.2416309565,
-0.6954188347,
0.3397005796,
-0.5274507403,
-0.1256727576,
-0.4642445445,
0.1868196279,
-0.6308866143,
0.29886958,
0.2836495936,
0.5918107033,
-0.7521554828,
0.8757408261,
0.5667501688,
-0.4788635075,
-0.616558075,
-0.2203247547,
-0.0664408132,
-0.5065439343,
0.9059367776,
0.1810368747,
-0.0590387993,
0.0378227159,
-0.1812769324,
-1.057107091,
1.2116863728,
0.1293044239,
-1.1449792385,
0.3784564734,
0.262840569,
0.304248929,
-0.4059740901,
0.4867712557,
0.8373277187,
0.132221669,
-0.3694693148,
-0.6216417551,
-0.3295490742,
-0.1391219497,
-0.0008733105,
0.3536238074,
-0.9194735885,
1.1440250874,
0.0396536849,
-0.1439896077,
0.5078362823,
0.6390649676,
0.3358588517,
0.1206134334,
0.3632793725,
0.9942712784,
0.9576640725,
-0.022591278,
1.110462904,
-0.5800722837,
0.2844207585,
1.1543343067,
-0.4103403687,
1.1295204163,
0.2059995681,
-0.4327396154,
0.7240846753,
0.8223534226,
0.1536853611,
0.3090291619,
0.1700149328,
-0.3624984026,
-0.1778568774,
-0.2036840916,
-0.2723101377,
0.1014950871,
0.501406014,
-0.362788409,
0.2030165344,
-0.1031195894,
-0.0796391815,
-0.2573755085,
-0.4728794098,
0.6027323604,
0.1898436248,
-0.0928341299,
0.2417949438,
0.3337384164,
0.6586048007,
-0.6115348935,
0.196234405,
-0.5856123567,
0.3638121486,
-0.1043914333,
-0.0603680424,
-0.1079972237,
-0.0676703304,
-0.1657746136,
-0.1800924242,
0.5403011441,
-0.4512526691,
-0.7247752547,
0.5116986036,
0.5023745298,
0.144011721,
0.1718121469,
-0.8714387417,
0.2418823242,
-0.0433836989,
-0.4984325469,
0.4343657792,
0.3813414574,
0.2644173503,
0.6658149362,
0.5381157398,
0.2610362172,
0.1582457125,
0.409239918,
0.5408780575,
-0.8622529507,
-0.6649776101,
-0.6266278625,
0.3564747274,
-0.1339673996,
-0.1868206561,
0.9416618347,
0.61005193,
1.196564436,
-0.0219906233,
0.7087657452,
0.4313221872,
0.5089589357,
-0.4684974253,
0.703551054,
-1.0154881477,
0.3451469243,
0.0420205034,
-1.1807545424,
-0.1445228308,
0.6178260446,
0.1023560539,
0.1755824238,
0.6524685025,
0.9118404984,
-0.045075193,
0.1193095222,
0.6007112861,
0.4457117617,
0.2595852315,
0.6497892737,
0.9707598686,
-0.7867397666,
0.5596398115,
-0.3536874354,
-0.0809342936,
-0.4222044051,
-0.6215167046,
-0.7194997072,
-0.1833516508,
-0.610393703,
-0.042347569,
-0.1733803749,
1.0420398712,
0.531377852,
-0.7157480121,
-0.7824438214,
0.0561431013,
-0.1318308264,
-0.0984238982,
-0.1135807708,
0.0851646811,
-0.4485843182,
-1.0947221518,
0.3975223303,
0.5616224408,
0.2624264956,
-0.4913307428,
-0.0962511674,
0.0257275142,
0.16254282,
0.7739371061,
0.0178224668,
-0.7068129182,
0.2524468601,
-0.0425189175,
-0.097051464,
-0.1402016133,
0.7647727132,
-0.5993812084,
0.2330573946,
0.46829018,
0.6284887195,
0.3677989244,
-0.2393472642,
0.5321464539,
-0.0950720385,
0.4488096237,
0.0186400879,
0.5465099216,
0.2653548717,
-0.1366660148,
0.2567634881,
0.1506622136,
-0.5602331161,
-0.6230728626,
0.3669579625,
-0.5872623324,
-0.4281568825,
0.960003078,
-0.1904955357,
-0.4813145101,
-0.2790881693,
0.2088147402,
0.0772055089,
-0.1081170961,
0.7618104815,
0.5623063445,
0.3553594649,
-0.3269109726,
-0.7847412229,
0.2971441746,
0.4869640768,
-0.9120877981,
-0.1364807039,
0.6173528433,
0.1213567406,
-0.1877229959,
0.608956039,
0.2515203953,
0.2483120263,
-0.2169942111,
-0.0107340934,
0.298951894,
-0.6293084025,
-0.3318500221,
0.0604961365,
0.4275821447,
0.0488843769
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12018v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12018v1 | CItruS: Chunked Instruction-aware State Eviction for Long Sequence Modeling | 2024-06-17T18:34:58 | 2024-06-17T18:34:58 | Yu Bai, Xiyuan Zou, Heyan Huang, Sanxing Chen, Marc-Antoine Rondeau, Yang Gao, Jackie Chi Kit Cheung | cs.CL | cs.CL | Long sequence modeling has gained broad interest as large language models
(LLMs) continue to advance. Recent research has identified that a large portion
of hidden states within the key-value caches of Transformer models can be
discarded (also termed evicted) without affecting the perplexity performance in
generating long sequences. However, we show that these methods, despite
preserving perplexity performance, often drop information that is important for
solving downstream tasks, a problem which we call information neglect. To
address this issue, we introduce Chunked Instruction-aware State Eviction
(CItruS), a novel modeling technique that integrates the attention preferences
useful for a downstream task into the eviction process of hidden states. In
addition, we design a method for chunked sequence processing to further improve
efficiency. Our training-free method exhibits superior performance on long
sequence comprehension and retrieval tasks over several strong baselines under
the same memory budget, while preserving language modeling perplexity. | [
-0.0448055193,
-0.5999765992,
0.6106800437,
0.2847694159,
-0.2240029275,
0.1099008918,
-0.2545138001,
-0.2821232975,
0.2867916524,
0.5551149845,
-0.4018616974,
-0.1664347053,
-0.5642663836,
-0.090449512,
-0.8300830126,
0.7968656421,
-0.0044053094,
-0.5555856824,
-0.0945677683,
0.3653846681,
-0.4319162965,
-0.2363357693,
-0.4514261782,
-0.0656465366,
0.4495784938,
0.585778296,
0.5706607699,
0.9000079632,
0.2460974604,
0.237521261,
-0.4849618375,
-0.1782079935,
-0.7597544193,
0.2390596718,
-0.2732145786,
-0.566660583,
-0.2932897806,
-0.2295696139,
0.7152069807,
0.2973668277,
-0.1796797365,
0.1102306396,
-0.0352694057,
0.8099286556,
-1.0158680677,
0.0661882013,
-0.7418009639,
0.2860884368,
-0.2563397288,
-0.1774983108,
-0.5469003916,
-0.2890630066,
0.1012832895,
-0.3763910234,
0.5818326473,
-0.0508163981,
0.8435028791,
0.3879356086,
-0.1979488283,
-0.028435614,
-0.8378482461,
0.675825417,
-0.3031765819,
0.1727875322,
0.244227916,
0.2202845663,
-0.1360401064,
-0.5204768777,
-0.430683881,
-0.1259890199,
0.1803983599,
0.1627520174,
-0.3123606741,
0.256864965,
0.3268239796,
0.5779123306,
-0.2586939037,
0.0567152649,
-0.4558130801,
-0.0916530862,
0.4121493697,
0.0754729882,
0.0922176689,
-0.2775283456,
-0.7459515333,
0.0927461237,
-1.1460493803,
0.1832651645,
0.261020869,
0.235547483,
0.2736111283,
0.6286841631,
-0.2318243682,
0.2011065483,
0.2580924928,
0.3180733323,
0.0599090606,
0.1040574014,
-0.3106454909,
0.4364542067,
0.6923058629,
-0.1108990461,
-0.0348719358,
-0.1108104736,
-0.5044374466,
-0.2925459743,
0.4707402289,
-0.7378128767,
-0.2678174078,
0.5554812551,
-0.3481979072,
-0.0715281218,
-0.038720075,
-0.7000442147,
-0.5689631104,
-0.0604483038,
0.1083854213,
-0.6161593199,
-0.5063871145,
-0.2007717043,
-0.3555669188,
0.351421535,
0.5466291308,
-0.8514130116,
0.3406811357,
0.8737561703,
0.608533442,
-0.3869432509,
0.0537650175,
-0.5780748725,
0.0625971854,
-0.351323396,
0.3465167582,
-0.6282870173,
-0.258420825,
-0.1458721161,
-0.1000669375,
-0.2567676306,
-0.9467650652,
0.057626076,
-0.8112536669,
-0.4429734647,
-0.1595992148,
-0.6536954045,
-0.2787466347,
0.2825684845,
-0.984008193,
1.2420102358,
0.1212137267,
-0.6455747485,
0.0118063502,
-0.7111558914,
-0.4034075439,
0.133993566,
-0.0119622862,
-0.4423494041,
0.4648890197,
0.0764990225,
0.4012742043,
-0.0024242632,
0.4506636262,
0.0148073472,
-0.4683178663,
0.001897105,
-0.6443800926,
0.4014252722,
0.3996338248,
-0.4879513681,
0.3551570177,
-0.6399941444,
-0.3689469993,
0.2405176312,
-0.3759209216,
-0.3929307163,
0.2982735634,
-0.1064063683,
0.1859004945,
0.4143241942,
-0.6942769289,
0.0447492152,
-0.2368447632,
0.2471512854,
0.8219608665,
-0.1543712318,
0.3483315706,
-0.1381063908,
0.8193441033,
0.6686109304,
-0.0762365982,
-0.4130682349,
-0.2147544622,
-1.0041399002,
-0.4856383801,
0.169779107,
0.7226819992,
-0.6690292954,
0.295538038,
-0.462249279,
-0.0897412077,
-0.3188134432,
-0.0967068896,
0.5194705725,
0.1475224793,
0.3746237755,
-0.3090859056,
-0.188564375,
-0.8126302361,
-0.4063971937,
0.3477046192,
0.2231580913,
0.1269002706,
0.4295732677,
0.1688782424,
1.1239460707,
-0.4380064905,
-0.0221744142,
-0.630071342,
0.0175762828,
0.1180872321,
0.5523802638,
0.1116294712,
-0.7396783829,
-0.2214894146,
-0.1431799233,
-0.1950176954,
0.3591659069,
-0.1861841828,
0.0130288322,
0.1238387972,
0.4563487172,
-0.5910538435,
1.0038200617,
0.1767977774,
-0.2010736912,
0.7482541203,
-0.0619450249,
-0.19075872,
-0.9915989041,
0.0600200519,
-0.0579893142,
-0.6632375121,
-0.5749744773,
0.1157661155,
0.4275915325,
-0.1176101938,
-0.7458949685,
0.3833091855,
-0.7229297757,
-0.0754410177,
-0.2976376712,
-0.1450575143,
-0.277713716,
0.3255284727,
0.3738978207,
0.7774090767,
0.3011836708,
-0.7421554923,
0.1411144584,
-0.0633613244,
-0.2381613255,
0.1511799395,
-0.3057084978,
0.109261781,
-0.3892941177,
0.0335652977,
-1.0072288513,
-0.1301868409,
0.0787164718,
-0.0595768504,
0.6241155267,
-0.2483908981,
-0.3066901565,
-0.424299866,
-0.2853702009,
0.5260169506,
0.3965839148,
-0.5963519812,
0.4891728461,
0.263717711,
-0.3579873443,
-0.6416823268,
-0.3207900524,
-0.0976123065,
-0.2690491378,
-0.0809703916,
0.3359811604,
0.3317376971,
0.1687828004,
0.0895419046,
-0.3886435926,
-0.370005697,
0.1925049871,
0.260335505,
0.0258488078,
-0.2899884284,
0.4366843104,
0.350620389,
-0.0007868918,
0.1849939674,
-0.2354252636,
0.6315540671,
0.0265374277,
-0.3668860197,
-0.3856871426,
0.4893592298,
0.5587469935,
-0.4790113568,
0.7281610966,
0.4001154602,
-0.4001814723,
-0.1710986942,
-0.5835747719,
0.0031982823,
-0.4544065893,
0.6994211078,
-0.3046142161,
-1.0130013227,
0.30205971,
-0.3723060787,
0.1328617334,
0.3773756921,
0.1256520599,
0.0095615778,
0.6106047034,
0.7993975878,
-0.4314979911,
0.7889170051,
-0.385019958,
0.2365983278,
-1.1036887169,
-0.0200941674,
-0.4386891723,
-0.445862323,
-0.2344689369,
-0.6609945297,
0.3045227528,
-0.065545395,
-0.3826536536,
0.2006022632,
-0.4470136464,
0.8502647877,
0.5924478769,
0.2479919195,
0.0296646226,
-0.1159709916,
-0.1177930459,
0.1667376161,
-0.6870673299,
-0.2583067119,
0.8621783853,
0.2793571651,
0.8149388433,
-0.1376657039,
1.0880476236,
0.216807425,
0.1070825681,
-0.9335534573,
0.4828986824,
-0.10533645,
-0.447676748,
-0.4660429657,
-0.5226724148,
-1.0714701414,
0.2704557478,
0.3587744534,
-1.1505980492,
0.0787560344,
0.4733712673,
-0.647669971,
0.5721356869,
-0.3128001392,
0.9509994388,
-0.1552804261,
-0.2878752649,
-0.5195510983,
-0.7848962545,
0.5751280785,
0.2002766877,
-0.0311299767,
-0.2674600184,
0.1783650219,
0.7674893141,
-0.6083212495,
0.8081761599,
-0.289803654,
-0.0149521502,
0.4372494221,
0.372641325,
0.8303188682,
-0.2976261675,
0.0413211174,
-0.2580656111,
-0.1152060255,
-0.2559247017,
-0.276943177,
0.4938167036,
-0.5533568859,
-0.7396624088,
-0.50841254,
-0.6487060785,
0.075532347,
0.2250383645,
0.2434838116,
0.2127458155,
-0.1051896289,
0.0566624291,
1.2160359621,
-0.3162993193,
0.7635844946,
0.098411873,
-0.2117720097,
-0.1013196036,
1.0573461056,
-0.1804074049,
0.3398619294,
0.7836425304,
0.3366386592,
-0.3643667698,
-0.3946911693,
-0.1672353894,
0.0462775938,
-0.4621682167,
-0.1904033571,
-0.5779600143,
-0.4680680633,
-0.1330364347,
0.1597657502,
-0.9437546134,
-0.5025445223,
-0.6016684175,
-0.1825994402,
0.2468698323,
0.8628380895,
0.2572695315,
0.3137787879,
-0.9515300989,
0.5095834136,
0.0909346491,
0.2742764056,
0.2213294059,
-0.4625920057,
-0.2744657695,
-0.0013451761,
-0.6089701056,
-1.0097277164,
0.4513861537,
0.078986004,
0.3546810746,
0.6365280747,
0.2845753133,
0.8181319833,
-0.4752900898,
0.7814127803,
0.1500041187,
-1.1456449032,
0.6410375834,
-0.1041039675,
0.546461165,
0.2728459537,
0.3025722504,
-0.5163753629,
-0.5234764814,
-0.4721492231,
-1.3533821106,
0.8060621023,
-0.0574006587,
0.0493745878,
-0.2119653523,
-0.0193027761,
-0.0544505902,
0.3820411861,
-0.5572197437,
-0.015282386,
-0.1108499914,
-0.2628528476,
0.2666040063,
-0.5350997448,
0.1380727142,
-0.2547473609,
0.603027463,
0.0833425,
0.5561016798,
0.2032050341,
-0.5117653608,
0.0955818221,
0.5817215443,
0.5416274071,
0.2838474512,
0.1120376065,
0.0570444427,
-0.1608156711,
-0.5918716192,
0.2674905658,
-0.0555308349,
-0.2024945021,
-0.2888619602,
-0.1839326322,
0.7936902642,
0.3710202277,
-0.5491640568,
0.5946515203,
0.1027880535,
0.0638915971,
-0.416215688,
0.1036197916,
0.0219948273,
0.0942947119,
0.3768777847,
0.0242779218,
0.2512955368,
-0.1855268776,
0.0563917309,
0.2842954695,
-0.6747005582,
-0.2048230469,
0.6819164157,
0.1288585514,
0.1090374738,
1.2040590048,
-0.3538180292,
-0.835288465,
0.9753736258,
0.7038750052,
1.1009863615,
-0.2630266547,
0.0305072088,
0.153908968,
0.3144719303,
-0.1089198664,
0.4695329666,
-0.3480385244,
-0.4804216325,
-0.3326514661,
-0.5070931315,
-0.1713302732,
0.2189128101,
-0.7424596548,
-0.1773448437,
-0.4100217223,
-0.00924771,
-0.536375463,
-0.4067385793,
-0.627386868,
0.0965594202,
0.430870533,
1.1371887922,
-0.7778143883,
0.8165480494,
0.4617844224,
0.0610502772,
-1.0245784521,
0.1898736805,
0.1714811623,
-0.3706782162,
0.5429018736,
0.5905356407,
-0.1442569494,
-0.055474069,
-0.3972269893,
-1.141449213,
0.8137575984,
0.2791039646,
-0.7033447027,
0.0765510499,
0.1135596111,
0.1043455824,
0.0658434555,
0.2970530391,
0.8447992802,
0.2117371857,
0.264044106,
-0.8578528166,
0.1496228874,
-0.1922419071,
0.2689482272,
0.4712838829,
-0.74871099,
0.8938683271,
-0.4433236718,
-0.2902920544,
0.2327294946,
1.0524379015,
0.0342854634,
0.0500545651,
0.5088143349,
0.6780421138,
0.9562351108,
-0.1850310415,
0.8055469394,
-0.2448693812,
0.1881555021,
1.2642220259,
-0.4196753502,
1.0583080053,
0.4144285023,
-0.1793581098,
0.3070153594,
0.4825851321,
0.4956102073,
0.537771225,
0.5196322203,
-0.3921265006,
-0.1989009678,
0.1860328168,
-0.0152844954,
0.4681348801,
0.6791161299,
-0.3920400739,
-0.2188189477,
-0.1270429045,
0.2025561035,
-0.1882154644,
-0.6322202086,
0.7400118113,
-0.1214082688,
-0.9369869828,
0.496145457,
-0.167136088,
0.4613302946,
-0.4350655675,
-0.1845464259,
-0.3092459142,
0.3146884143,
-0.1996222734,
-0.608181119,
0.2304631025,
0.160869211,
-0.420786798,
-0.2799657285,
0.4827460647,
-0.6745328903,
-0.2616568208,
-0.0015897704,
0.0671346262,
0.3326521516,
-0.5325744748,
-0.2797312438,
-0.147540763,
-0.198443383,
-0.4367631972,
0.3666289747,
0.2906486094,
-0.320132345,
0.740473628,
0.2268514782,
0.0414172746,
0.6769323945,
-0.0505613871,
0.9434508085,
-1.0045366287,
-0.7202410698,
-0.7791529298,
0.4578209221,
-0.0023983265,
0.026316708,
0.5359496474,
0.9274936318,
0.6448106766,
-0.242345199,
0.9576789141,
-0.0790993646,
0.5148355961,
-0.4630845189,
0.6696834564,
-0.364528507,
0.2782669067,
-0.1999216527,
-0.6812793612,
0.1045416743,
0.1686549634,
-0.3062984943,
0.0702633485,
0.6885719895,
0.587937057,
-0.215120852,
0.1320013553,
0.2302035242,
0.0739611462,
0.4270854592,
0.8658335209,
1.1198860407,
-0.0621186793,
0.2039915323,
-0.3864583969,
-0.0787422583,
-0.4555717111,
-0.9266541004,
-0.5206301808,
-0.2055961788,
-0.3099537194,
-0.0229652282,
0.116479218,
1.0418998003,
0.6125382185,
-0.8710918427,
-0.2697395086,
-0.0835705176,
0.4372082353,
-0.5358791351,
-0.2786997855,
0.4879499972,
-0.472668618,
-0.530438602,
0.6031374335,
0.493180722,
-0.056652125,
-0.0196532998,
0.3140877187,
-0.1924959868,
0.0026376629,
0.5231009722,
0.5772190094,
-0.7843703628,
-0.2351638973,
-0.168090716,
-0.0245334562,
0.3456303179,
0.8445849419,
-0.885763824,
0.4890991151,
0.4028462768,
0.6602184772,
0.596006453,
0.3704036474,
0.4149830043,
-1.1179326773,
0.1511690021,
0.3812815845,
0.336579144,
0.1889939904,
-0.6249523163,
0.0501468889,
0.029873047,
-0.3370135128,
-0.4284652472,
0.2317230254,
-0.817158103,
-0.1069952771,
1.054766655,
-0.4417234659,
-0.6715428829,
0.0128706424,
0.0114629446,
0.2777430415,
-0.6512463093,
0.5569846034,
0.3500047028,
-0.1541135758,
-0.4071260393,
-0.2355341315,
0.3830812275,
0.4087381959,
-0.680157721,
0.3453431427,
0.4560116529,
0.374568522,
0.0769001171,
0.5641857982,
-0.0380428992,
0.6092278361,
-0.0829722732,
0.2187518924,
-0.1800033748,
-0.845662415,
-0.4530873597,
0.2214211524,
0.0435628928,
-0.6271170378
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12009v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12009v1 | FinTruthQA: A Benchmark Dataset for Evaluating the Quality of Financial Information Disclosure | 2024-06-17T18:25:02 | 2024-06-17T18:25:02 | Ziyue Xu, Peilin Zhou, Xinyu Shi, Jiageng Wu, Yikang Jiang, Bin Ke, Jie Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Accurate and transparent financial information disclosure is crucial in the
fields of accounting and finance, ensuring market efficiency and investor
confidence. Among many information disclosure platforms, the Chinese stock
exchanges' investor interactive platform provides a novel and interactive way
for listed firms to disclose information of interest to investors through an
online question-and-answer (Q&A) format. However, it is common for listed firms
to respond to questions with limited or no substantive information, and
automatically evaluating the quality of financial information disclosure on
large amounts of Q&A pairs is challenging. This paper builds a benchmark
FinTruthQA, that can evaluate advanced natural language processing (NLP)
techniques for the automatic quality assessment of information disclosure in
financial Q&A data. FinTruthQA comprises 6,000 real-world financial Q&A entries
and each Q&A was manually annotated based on four conceptual dimensions of
accounting. We benchmarked various NLP techniques on FinTruthQA, including
statistical machine learning models, pre-trained language model and their
fine-tuned versions, as well as the large language model GPT-4. Experiments
showed that existing NLP models have strong predictive ability for real
question identification and question relevance tasks, but are suboptimal for
answer relevance and answer readability tasks. By establishing this benchmark,
we provide a robust foundation for the automatic evaluation of information
disclosure, significantly enhancing the transparency and quality of financial
reporting. FinTruthQA can be used by auditors, regulators, and financial
analysts for real-time monitoring and data-driven decision-making, as well as
by researchers for advanced studies in accounting and finance, ultimately
fostering greater trust and efficiency in the financial markets. | [
-0.2731298804,
-0.5722950101,
-0.0374803692,
0.43415609,
-0.235532105,
0.2381607592,
-0.0981555656,
-0.7527549863,
-0.1424339265,
0.387403667,
-0.5232319236,
-0.5108267665,
-0.3132976294,
-0.0559169054,
-0.4371013343,
0.7927997708,
-0.0679288954,
0.185069859,
-0.1692732573,
-0.1183855012,
-0.4321224689,
-0.2807678878,
-0.8664866686,
0.0967433006,
0.1185903624,
0.1212321296,
0.7548434734,
0.7500998974,
0.8562467098,
0.3065012395,
0.1850427091,
-0.0136897825,
-0.1207198128,
-0.0029532397,
-0.2636991143,
-0.1411729455,
-0.5026204586,
0.330139488,
0.5577584505,
0.4642394483,
-0.2858526111,
0.8385742903,
0.15509139,
0.6570438147,
-0.6661698818,
0.4058746397,
-0.1492262185,
-0.001967991,
-0.0515949801,
-0.0637281686,
-0.0899618715,
-0.804982245,
0.4778482318,
-0.6917870641,
0.0791137964,
0.3266422451,
0.9540410042,
0.1972888559,
-0.2376434058,
-0.4455060363,
-0.4645245671,
0.5940647721,
-0.8053373694,
0.4770588577,
0.4540715516,
0.6889369488,
0.3906967938,
-0.7734966278,
-0.6413597465,
0.0231166929,
-0.1805876046,
0.1224276051,
-0.4696043134,
-0.0762194619,
0.0899749026,
0.3334156275,
-0.783841908,
-0.0924992189,
-0.3327657282,
-0.4078818858,
0.5893707871,
-0.056353651,
-0.0454634316,
-0.1389555782,
-0.5360093713,
-0.770357132,
-0.1715361774,
0.2623409629,
0.5356317759,
0.3200870454,
-0.0573538728,
0.2017358989,
-0.3177980483,
0.7335719466,
0.063368775,
-0.1722325683,
0.2696602345,
-0.6595906615,
-0.2622853518,
0.0264806282,
0.6461654305,
0.5300721526,
-0.1266250312,
-0.0289795753,
-0.2568274736,
-0.3617455661,
0.1960102171,
-0.6477021575,
-0.0457077399,
0.4279813766,
-0.5007227063,
0.0695459694,
0.5305230618,
-0.741160512,
-0.0832675025,
-0.2692872882,
0.6365047097,
-0.2591895759,
-0.194540754,
0.2152631581,
-0.3666079044,
0.4020684063,
0.3661735356,
-0.5003711581,
0.5578925014,
0.8707873821,
0.4567187726,
-0.145822987,
0.0733030587,
-0.8567153215,
-0.0123201767,
-0.3202687502,
0.8034043908,
-0.2679076493,
0.3741577268,
-0.0260633286,
-0.3266392946,
-0.1991592646,
-0.7224448323,
0.5225340724,
-0.6740096211,
0.3184211552,
-0.2622459531,
-0.6201946735,
-0.519862175,
0.2080938816,
-0.6884326935,
0.7397264242,
0.3345049024,
-0.8132938147,
0.4921645522,
-0.6237113476,
0.0473110303,
0.154288888,
-0.1271877289,
-0.2639017999,
-0.6930034161,
0.35486269,
0.3686047196,
-0.5673261285,
0.5599912405,
0.1239128187,
-0.4340500832,
0.4344424307,
-0.5064429045,
0.5607799292,
0.0882279649,
-0.4633327425,
0.0117260665,
-0.5937128663,
0.2979538739,
-0.1289002448,
0.1092378497,
-0.1829687208,
-0.65170753,
0.2214764059,
0.1718677878,
0.4783878326,
-0.5492967963,
-0.3629418612,
-0.4542783201,
0.3631606996,
0.5663568377,
0.1376141906,
0.0282785706,
-0.5692787766,
0.6118471622,
-0.0946217179,
0.4822820723,
-0.0285834819,
-0.2280088514,
-0.3962056935,
-0.0500776917,
0.8740383983,
0.678293705,
-0.4354977012,
0.426122576,
0.0430049077,
-0.5997580886,
-0.8355664015,
0.2471482605,
0.5694630742,
0.7042620778,
0.3748870492,
-0.2725760639,
-0.1935908794,
-1.233746767,
-0.5381420255,
-0.4046190381,
-0.3515064418,
0.2508168221,
0.2161096185,
0.2659773231,
0.6876184344,
-0.2723699808,
-0.3094312251,
-0.0507928357,
0.549747169,
0.3672050834,
0.4514924288,
0.5362539887,
-1.0964524746,
-0.1803985238,
-0.3239659071,
-0.4451099634,
0.1484838575,
-0.428520143,
-0.2055626661,
-0.1478291303,
0.1193200499,
-0.1793815941,
0.3975246549,
0.5343686938,
-0.5318156481,
0.3872352839,
-0.1211712211,
0.4416907728,
-0.6085594296,
0.5208628774,
0.1747436523,
-0.300144136,
-0.346488297,
0.0828116238,
0.2785835266,
0.1661887318,
-0.3112365603,
0.7033516169,
-0.0703953803,
-0.4828208685,
0.0568835028,
0.5131931305,
0.2506096065,
0.4908116162,
-0.2261537015,
0.9235340357,
0.1784199625,
-0.6692995429,
0.4288100898,
0.6389533281,
-0.451287061,
0.4591042697,
-0.494538784,
-0.1316542178,
0.0805915147,
0.2070381194,
-1.1454131603,
-0.0671157911,
0.3049820065,
-0.5987495184,
-0.0528959334,
0.3294281662,
-0.6202357411,
-0.2423625141,
-0.454210043,
0.3723783493,
0.0189718176,
-0.475473702,
0.4851745963,
0.2302120477,
-0.6461863518,
-0.7252041101,
-0.8010786772,
0.1391889751,
0.155305624,
-0.6818578839,
0.4124448895,
-0.160221234,
-0.3909281492,
0.0707933381,
-0.3620052338,
-0.2281692177,
0.0238978043,
-0.0054781544,
0.5835719109,
-0.4709828198,
0.1387673169,
-0.0228010863,
-0.4023731649,
0.08728946,
-0.0143269887,
0.3351823688,
-0.4836156666,
-0.2666056752,
-0.9426711798,
-0.0200340878,
0.0098073408,
-0.3023366928,
0.5000876188,
0.5417890549,
-0.3026802242,
0.0910836235,
-0.7801043987,
0.0091950502,
-0.4960606992,
-0.0356606469,
0.1188948676,
-0.9249375463,
0.5620899796,
0.178596437,
0.4529576302,
0.8418183923,
0.1513919234,
0.1357843131,
0.537837863,
0.6390818954,
-0.0380640067,
0.1307915896,
-0.0835641995,
0.2355028838,
-0.2797580063,
-0.2868148386,
-0.6914824247,
-0.2094943076,
-0.3955358565,
-0.4333337247,
0.2461139113,
0.1225413978,
-0.4766699374,
0.5423133373,
-0.5261692405,
0.2640419006,
0.584674418,
-0.1677177101,
0.5354788303,
-0.4423135817,
-0.1290514022,
-0.0282532983,
-0.47016415,
-0.5267770886,
0.8564587831,
0.5435224771,
0.3949615359,
0.0149774682,
0.3295517266,
0.7241972685,
0.2890083194,
-0.3673745692,
0.2952711582,
-0.069592312,
-0.2714398801,
-0.5218732953,
-0.6691288352,
-0.3037953079,
-0.031894438,
-0.1699973941,
-0.3609706163,
0.4555819035,
0.0284551643,
-0.8810981512,
0.07138367,
-0.4223891795,
0.87044245,
-0.121649228,
-0.0657236204,
0.0213777516,
-0.6712224483,
0.4555426836,
-0.3682334125,
0.332909137,
-0.2011446506,
-0.3341074586,
1.1247065067,
-0.2238453478,
0.5109762549,
-0.2139377594,
-0.2220488042,
0.2810227573,
-0.0869661868,
0.3027750552,
0.4166455567,
-0.2551830411,
0.1201743111,
0.4504802227,
-0.1270094365,
-0.6654444337,
0.2456797212,
-0.5337535143,
-0.1668037474,
-0.4281279445,
-0.2329197377,
-0.4042238593,
0.0884435847,
0.0105039794,
0.310029,
-0.2201736867,
0.0924923271,
0.3922200799,
-0.2937433422,
0.3755853772,
0.5917862654,
-0.0718380436,
-0.6110982895,
0.5765500665,
0.034457799,
0.0000180469,
0.4579733312,
0.0655130148,
-0.6693333983,
-0.3425965905,
-0.3764979541,
0.2457816005,
-0.664703548,
-0.6697844863,
-0.415553838,
-0.6382018924,
-0.509606123,
0.0664562806,
-0.4274305105,
-0.6485885978,
0.001105673,
-0.349509716,
0.3997660577,
0.5381740332,
-0.2927865386,
0.0836305991,
-0.8447803855,
0.6803249121,
0.4877117276,
0.584918797,
0.1128217503,
-0.4710409939,
-0.2053254247,
0.1440796256,
0.1329675615,
-0.2347315401,
0.1715734005,
0.2041597813,
0.6027922034,
0.5837471485,
0.5277282,
0.6128235459,
0.3476047218,
0.6270378828,
-0.0087584974,
-1.0122208595,
0.3405650258,
-0.1159130558,
0.161337927,
1.0004132986,
0.3546996713,
-0.7104924321,
-0.7163699865,
-0.7382898331,
-0.9521681666,
0.581602633,
0.265360564,
-0.1273780465,
0.2582712471,
0.4975634217,
0.4505801797,
0.56611377,
-0.3776987493,
-0.2507477105,
-0.3517468274,
0.007946087,
0.0896844044,
-0.1839726716,
-0.0131932804,
-0.0991379917,
0.6347408891,
0.0261427015,
0.1410673112,
0.2896278799,
0.2563897669,
-0.1341516525,
0.1115689203,
0.1770607978,
1.09288311,
-0.4422799647,
-0.184685111,
-0.1120224968,
-0.4589010477,
-0.1261483282,
0.373544246,
-0.0771930888,
0.1167069525,
0.4140901864,
0.2857397795,
0.2789625227,
-1.0854347944,
0.810106039,
-0.4047328532,
-0.5235450864,
-0.4431114495,
0.1624915749,
-0.0707229748,
0.5233647823,
0.9061642289,
0.0336320512,
0.2980567813,
-0.45103392,
0.6988666654,
-0.0272395685,
-0.4051215351,
0.0706989318,
0.8054737449,
-0.0632884949,
0.1037972793,
0.6477679014,
0.0532093272,
-0.2848320305,
0.5261552334,
-0.0541174076,
0.8322313428,
-0.2231194377,
0.5143084526,
0.5927154422,
0.2485915273,
-0.1697703153,
0.3438267708,
-0.217584148,
-0.4960120618,
-0.3799206316,
-0.6540445089,
-0.8330543637,
0.1017677337,
-1.1541759968,
-0.1432602555,
-0.7461396456,
-0.378888309,
0.335110575,
0.2944507301,
-0.7017597556,
0.3849684894,
-0.1031881049,
1.260545373,
-0.4569010735,
0.2260120511,
0.0552148148,
-0.2205989808,
-0.4975547194,
0.0180063844,
-0.0538543686,
-0.682921946,
0.5819838047,
0.1974750459,
-0.1249255687,
-0.2828631997,
-0.6136723161,
-0.8677543998,
1.0630869865,
0.2397169173,
-0.5417243838,
0.1066668257,
0.3795056641,
0.414868623,
-0.3161553741,
0.0001385994,
0.604293704,
0.9169380665,
0.25803864,
-1.027328968,
0.0937358886,
-0.4374848604,
-0.2504757047,
-0.1581511647,
-0.7375410795,
0.7728322148,
0.0083778724,
-0.3184978664,
0.0535846204,
0.7208541036,
0.0932297856,
0.4181534946,
0.5002627969,
0.0188855603,
0.8570023775,
-0.0443557501,
0.5869492888,
-0.4463453591,
-0.0547712557,
1.122361064,
-0.1641064137,
1.3171510696,
0.1274002045,
0.0165735297,
0.1684530973,
0.5959637165,
-0.4097633064,
0.2476246357,
0.2140513211,
0.1131726503,
-0.2202468812,
-0.2453183085,
-0.1757311076,
0.4358284771,
0.2002275139,
-0.1342521906,
-0.1981003582,
-0.0681227073,
-0.2714119852,
0.2405590117,
-0.1053432226,
0.7470590472,
-0.0283323731,
-0.4422181547,
0.2529006004,
0.380843997,
0.5527688265,
-0.7614133954,
-0.0686487705,
-0.2790964842,
-0.1971584707,
-0.0497075133,
-0.8361601233,
0.3643102348,
0.2112747431,
0.1668675691,
-0.3804108202,
0.3830079734,
-0.2313144952,
-0.264577806,
0.2812111676,
0.4540383518,
-0.110264942,
-0.2116190642,
-0.8416230083,
-0.3879171312,
-0.1541644633,
-0.2425297499,
0.2063368261,
0.2692542672,
0.1470785588,
0.9272513986,
0.7275047898,
-0.0960968286,
-0.4006733596,
0.0010769755,
0.8024362326,
-1.002632618,
-0.7413378954,
-0.2783571184,
0.0957712829,
-0.2107500285,
-0.4709885418,
0.7334213257,
0.872764647,
0.8918052912,
0.3999229372,
0.5827552676,
0.3140524328,
0.9431167245,
-0.5609653592,
0.9014520049,
-0.2189384848,
0.3557744324,
-0.2488904148,
-0.736196816,
-0.1613378674,
0.5023049712,
-0.1143337265,
-0.0758412033,
0.3893352449,
0.3801546395,
0.1362802684,
0.4812767804,
0.1486155242,
0.1395804286,
-0.1322424263,
0.1651283056,
0.3278118074,
-0.748999536,
0.6324847937,
-0.5272136331,
-0.0284576789,
-0.2300182581,
-0.7489466071,
-0.4574094713,
-0.7198398709,
-0.6120749116,
-0.0736680105,
0.0077836099,
0.7471544743,
0.2597640157,
-0.8730902672,
-0.2992488444,
0.6656232476,
-0.0267825015,
-0.6222477555,
-0.2737576067,
0.7329802513,
-0.0511707701,
-0.2520897985,
0.1274615675,
0.5456578732,
0.2188660651,
-0.3023481667,
0.2119365782,
0.0124732209,
0.0236081686,
0.1896730512,
0.2619113028,
-0.1841878742,
-0.0145215625,
0.016541604,
-0.1464604586,
0.0778593719,
0.5506321192,
-0.4636892974,
0.1676017046,
0.3337809145,
0.7256651521,
0.3103870153,
0.5006511807,
0.7747207284,
-0.3625706732,
-0.0750345066,
0.5448521972,
-0.191587463,
0.0694456846,
-0.381747067,
0.3876880705,
-0.360801667,
-0.1910797805,
-0.5219191909,
-0.6206813455,
-0.9886737466,
-0.2539111674,
0.6032776833,
-0.1810302883,
-0.4990600049,
-0.328110218,
0.1598301381,
0.0759213045,
-0.651632905,
0.5944700837,
0.5844640732,
0.0036188182,
-0.0866479576,
-1.012604475,
0.7797209024,
-0.0957086086,
-0.6520512104,
0.5125558376,
0.1901655793,
0.0859906897,
0.0719158426,
0.6063105464,
-0.2041955143,
0.6281279922,
0.0265862402,
-0.1310191453,
-0.2102193236,
-0.1712999791,
-0.0607788377,
0.228126511,
-0.1939820051,
-0.0614896528
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11978v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11978v1 | Dialogue Action Tokens: Steering Language Models in Goal-Directed Dialogue with a Multi-Turn Planner | 2024-06-17T18:01:32 | 2024-06-17T18:01:32 | Kenneth Li, Yiming Wang, Fernanda Viégas, Martin Wattenberg | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | We present an approach called Dialogue Action Tokens (DAT) that adapts
language model agents to plan goal-directed dialogues. The core idea is to
treat each utterance as an action, thereby converting dialogues into games
where existing approaches such as reinforcement learning can be applied.
Specifically, we freeze a pretrained language model and train a small planner
model that predicts a continuous action vector, used for controlled generation
in each round. This design avoids the problem of language degradation under
reward optimization. When evaluated on the Sotopia platform for social
simulations, the DAT-steered LLaMA model surpasses GPT-4's performance. We also
apply DAT to steer an attacker language model in a novel multi-turn red-teaming
setting, revealing a potential new attack surface. | [
-0.1133089215,
-0.9664006829,
0.5734096766,
0.3035818338,
-0.2796799839,
0.3732936382,
-0.1170514673,
-0.0087842494,
0.5400233865,
0.7552266717,
-0.893765986,
-0.5870253444,
-0.5148807764,
-0.0508456565,
-0.3091432452,
1.0259916782,
-0.0207854174,
0.3218994439,
0.2240179628,
-0.1394126415,
-0.918317914,
-0.6555224657,
-1.1207871437,
-0.2827476263,
0.5252954364,
0.4414963424,
0.5985109806,
0.2742629945,
0.4369848073,
0.3521804512,
0.1639981419,
-0.0731052309,
-0.6176561713,
0.3602373898,
-0.1014772654,
-0.6094521284,
-0.6353082061,
-0.0267371386,
0.4526093006,
0.5417311192,
-0.3914966881,
-0.31377092,
-0.4090186656,
0.1951000839,
-0.1100848019,
0.340339452,
-0.7018264532,
-0.0834048167,
0.0501852632,
-0.1453566104,
-0.469437778,
-0.1828148216,
0.0419128276,
-0.6281244159,
-0.1197830364,
0.0883539319,
0.3783121407,
0.1696972549,
-0.1100669801,
-0.3517671227,
-0.836619854,
0.7002547383,
-0.6116735935,
0.058057908,
0.2172709703,
0.41187644,
-0.4939193428,
-0.651057601,
-0.6618942022,
-0.129943952,
0.2576518953,
0.254693687,
-0.2639113069,
0.4914270937,
0.1703651845,
-0.204064101,
-0.2210273594,
0.2189869434,
-0.3302204609,
-0.0551717244,
0.7336480021,
0.4591195583,
0.1520467401,
-0.1712967306,
-0.5764191747,
-0.1929829121,
-0.7386939526,
-0.0833137855,
0.4207201898,
0.6508635879,
-0.2492342591,
0.8067768216,
-0.2004172504,
0.4836984277,
0.1376492381,
-0.1865579039,
-0.1571943164,
-0.6253644228,
-0.2890686989,
0.1857334524,
0.7976698279,
0.4711571038,
0.1481164247,
-0.0154212853,
-0.259916544,
0.2011589259,
0.4598200619,
-0.6213670969,
-0.2613945603,
0.4121246338,
-0.3043707311,
-0.4200660884,
-0.2457480729,
-0.8549420834,
-0.3435724676,
-0.2870232165,
0.3809536397,
-0.560598731,
-0.431997478,
0.2301915437,
-0.3066690266,
0.5878096819,
0.3893031776,
-0.9199114442,
0.5890815854,
0.8818970323,
0.8709350228,
-0.3311029673,
-0.3321841061,
-0.8259428144,
0.3673644066,
-0.5313578248,
0.7312158346,
-0.8297563791,
-0.9135000706,
0.2204385996,
-0.3436655998,
-0.1766471714,
-0.1673433483,
0.4614354372,
-0.2239826918,
0.1416310668,
-0.1265820116,
-0.3293600082,
-0.1279088408,
0.3799082339,
-0.4958882332,
0.79662925,
-0.0781983733,
-0.4036255777,
0.4162189364,
-1.2150219679,
-0.4830064476,
0.0914926231,
-0.3091271222,
-0.2634720802,
0.0508523397,
0.0877804756,
0.3300406635,
-0.2040181607,
0.3575380743,
-0.0797399879,
-0.204954356,
0.1467475891,
-0.3765404522,
0.6053782105,
-0.0005389698,
-0.2281007916,
0.9364584088,
-0.3618572652,
-0.1309401542,
0.2431703061,
-0.1863203496,
-0.0850505531,
0.2009879351,
-0.3196707368,
0.2465372086,
-0.1257510781,
-0.4576660395,
0.4377577305,
-0.2154133469,
0.2531147599,
0.8039638996,
0.115351595,
0.5694627762,
-0.1482599229,
0.7858989239,
-0.0734569058,
0.3872790635,
-0.1193608195,
-0.787193954,
-0.9415628314,
-0.2927792966,
0.047475297,
0.414468199,
-1.0213136673,
0.1455622166,
-0.3100605011,
-0.4645778835,
-0.4854748249,
-0.2918075621,
0.436116457,
0.0052067763,
0.2790592611,
-0.4901595414,
-0.3743596971,
-0.5457627177,
-0.1511010528,
-0.6793097854,
0.2249105573,
0.2759777308,
0.3145763278,
-0.1170645058,
0.9657631516,
-0.4091027081,
-0.188823849,
-0.9732781649,
0.455558002,
-0.0899978653,
0.3666662872,
0.5392406583,
-0.7520307302,
-0.4463326931,
-0.1560244858,
-0.4353377223,
0.0101318369,
-0.314024508,
-0.2006905079,
0.1876321137,
0.6456101537,
-0.8762013316,
0.6083428264,
0.5178151727,
-0.3163880706,
0.6024544239,
0.0638656542,
-0.0145504354,
-1.0532910824,
-0.2055214047,
-0.3121438026,
-0.1996414214,
-1.172391057,
-0.2090489864,
-0.3868304193,
-0.3526136875,
-0.525677979,
0.7166187763,
-0.0328249112,
-0.3896022439,
-0.2643623054,
0.1341922283,
-0.3679319024,
0.9157365561,
0.3442975879,
0.7746269703,
0.4532041252,
-0.820302248,
0.4450637996,
0.5275417566,
-0.0870320052,
0.7839989662,
-0.5972976089,
0.2131055444,
0.0570264794,
0.3545375466,
-0.9343775511,
-0.1469584703,
0.4351980686,
-0.4989037514,
0.2757914364,
-0.3100654185,
-0.0306099821,
-0.2876230776,
-0.2440048754,
0.0526224971,
0.2618761361,
-0.2303356677,
0.8113905191,
0.5371130705,
-0.4451529682,
-0.3785946071,
-0.2497799397,
0.2240490466,
-0.4345908165,
-0.1878805161,
0.4350269437,
-0.0682073534,
-0.4389128685,
-0.3036253452,
0.127865836,
0.0274033416,
0.1339163482,
0.2344565988,
0.1858400851,
0.0773002282,
0.0307651758,
-0.1129687428,
-0.2988489866,
0.1014059111,
-0.3489073217,
1.0514628887,
0.3344631195,
-0.5388593674,
-0.4319081604,
0.5818494558,
0.5707566738,
-0.2087742388,
0.5870303512,
0.2930480242,
0.0143008325,
0.1358884871,
-0.1648949534,
-0.2945464849,
-0.4787421227,
0.5618349314,
-0.5478695631,
-0.5141456723,
0.4267682731,
-0.3463846445,
0.4349053502,
0.1635358036,
0.655728817,
-0.0382537618,
1.1081180573,
0.7755426168,
-0.1176715866,
0.9243332148,
-0.1916306913,
0.4048581421,
-0.6980050206,
-0.219322145,
-0.4628292024,
-0.2806138396,
-0.4535977542,
-0.5718756318,
0.159151718,
0.0173417199,
-0.3185611963,
0.4029739201,
-0.0093669444,
0.1686370969,
0.597625792,
-0.3280790448,
0.0558432341,
-0.3052983284,
-0.2906418741,
0.1943118572,
-0.9711896777,
-0.4677038789,
1.0313965082,
0.3038732409,
0.7062638998,
0.1533689648,
0.8519898057,
0.1220948622,
0.2522800267,
-0.9381121397,
0.816690743,
0.3958568573,
-0.4528037608,
-0.7264633775,
-0.2170511931,
-0.9293923974,
0.0708330572,
-0.0905881003,
-0.7835198641,
-0.0555456467,
-0.1615079194,
-0.3837543726,
0.2907786965,
-0.7441307902,
0.9418450594,
-0.4649737477,
-0.0724732876,
-0.549020946,
-0.4334535897,
0.055458121,
0.2230693549,
0.0842321813,
-0.2213561088,
0.156306535,
0.8209184408,
-0.4880487621,
1.0712252855,
-0.601247251,
-0.0857900009,
0.3642491996,
0.3030518889,
0.7606996298,
-0.0988785997,
0.0295605641,
-0.0036384466,
-0.3756238818,
-0.3523273766,
-0.5032120943,
0.2801843286,
-0.6016510725,
-0.8369035721,
-0.2371190339,
-0.3804747164,
-0.2044343948,
0.1715530306,
-0.181272611,
0.4350159168,
-0.773163259,
-0.2138624191,
0.2100228816,
-0.239470318,
0.7059218287,
0.5472803712,
-0.3021017015,
-0.3718073666,
0.8453258872,
-0.3823482692,
0.7339444757,
0.3048441708,
-0.0337467305,
-0.353695482,
-0.7727775574,
-0.4132873118,
0.1546971202,
-0.5273163319,
-0.259411782,
-0.488812685,
-0.0564187318,
-0.2030807585,
-0.193491742,
-0.4844623208,
-0.469994247,
0.0517871976,
-0.3390225768,
0.5910297036,
1.0794407129,
-0.0998469442,
0.8469353914,
-0.2915093005,
0.1540703475,
0.2680974305,
0.2937618196,
-0.3634369075,
-0.1930896342,
-0.0511395745,
0.1284640878,
-0.3661983609,
-0.9062268138,
0.5978978276,
-0.0230190735,
0.5436714292,
0.2547927797,
0.047328189,
0.6554370522,
-0.6590393782,
0.9728973508,
0.464122802,
-0.8484060764,
0.5622026324,
-0.5308571458,
0.1915756464,
0.3030669689,
0.1800994724,
-0.8087021708,
-0.4706350267,
-0.7123849988,
-0.4985882938,
0.9945244193,
0.1577128619,
0.2437672168,
-0.2097527832,
0.0857255831,
-0.0538713597,
0.3148345947,
-0.4606927633,
-0.1951823235,
-0.324894309,
-0.1334257573,
-0.044493597,
-0.2069298625,
-0.3420747817,
0.2030333877,
0.4649806619,
-0.4123211801,
0.7266044021,
-0.1198607981,
0.1533730626,
0.0546112061,
0.1417778879,
0.7699111104,
0.3787348568,
0.1132913157,
-0.3066548109,
0.2708488703,
-0.5165982246,
0.1202924699,
-0.1635801792,
-0.063046217,
-0.0712643638,
0.2228395492,
1.0650951862,
0.5305581093,
-0.2819858789,
0.4217405915,
-0.2619498372,
-0.2697658539,
-0.1877309084,
0.1576020569,
-0.0933324099,
0.3157801926,
0.0640850365,
-0.0668857172,
-0.267260462,
-0.7165679336,
-0.0059195575,
0.5349190235,
-0.7595319152,
-0.4617324769,
0.4619862139,
0.7087265849,
-0.7694024444,
0.4614593983,
-0.2017947733,
-0.8665297627,
0.417316854,
0.6487256885,
1.0528217554,
-0.3248799741,
0.5503085852,
0.124231562,
0.0595520325,
0.0947089866,
0.3891228735,
-0.0311173853,
-0.841498673,
-0.5703658462,
-0.3613638282,
-0.754365921,
-0.0375608243,
-0.4537694752,
0.4119657576,
-0.4733256996,
-0.1597606838,
-0.1047495082,
-0.0255336594,
-0.5845559835,
-0.0880731791,
-0.0636033118,
0.7593387961,
-0.5880578756,
0.9830679297,
0.3590815365,
-0.5668541789,
-0.6080768108,
-0.0008131656,
0.0297008455,
-0.7580879927,
0.6984365582,
-0.1200695038,
-0.2802044153,
0.0781820491,
-0.5204806328,
-0.7920626998,
0.9693443179,
0.1344918013,
-0.3897764981,
-0.1042386964,
0.1643614024,
0.2497935742,
-0.4649414718,
0.1471555084,
0.8098746538,
0.3879871368,
0.2902140319,
-1.0397694111,
-0.3450366557,
0.1637808979,
-0.2267456502,
0.2254693359,
-0.6717193127,
0.6588491797,
-0.206186071,
-0.3360703886,
0.2089621276,
0.7080854774,
0.2250414938,
-0.0694803447,
0.4313785434,
0.182726413,
0.7624377012,
-0.2885288298,
1.2432504892,
-0.0523223989,
-0.1109086573,
0.8961839676,
-0.5687975883,
0.8724420667,
0.3728059232,
-0.1056528166,
0.4388326108,
0.2072806507,
0.5435279608,
0.6530787945,
0.159289673,
-0.221920386,
-0.2311330289,
-0.1459733844,
0.1930046231,
0.8025114536,
0.6416595578,
0.2919289172,
0.0214239545,
-0.0639735833,
0.2056943327,
-0.0380382277,
-0.2845999599,
1.1770343781,
-0.0838424414,
-0.8075889945,
0.1803929657,
0.0786445737,
0.4582687616,
-0.8262214661,
-0.1179196313,
-0.2895922959,
0.1643586606,
0.3375851214,
-0.6973559856,
0.1957784146,
0.0531424731,
0.1783586293,
-0.3366256654,
0.4819139242,
-0.4411925375,
-0.2466686964,
0.365044415,
0.5286980867,
0.1191803217,
0.2176821381,
-0.8934157491,
0.3090415597,
0.0846898332,
0.0185797531,
0.2178854644,
0.4834397435,
-0.2930757105,
0.7875856161,
0.5632445216,
0.1633232534,
0.0391625054,
0.2813026011,
0.8849663734,
-0.7388040423,
-0.494530797,
-0.659904182,
0.4140904248,
-0.4163688123,
-0.2678235471,
0.5317056179,
0.3232668936,
0.6323621869,
0.1392921805,
0.8300223351,
0.0106414333,
0.3819350004,
-0.6574739814,
0.3071469665,
-0.0011964006,
0.0444119349,
-0.4091231823,
-0.7543824911,
-0.2149885297,
0.6788038015,
-0.4026507735,
0.0468305498,
0.5669093728,
0.6071174741,
0.2750696838,
-0.0026005635,
0.4509364367,
0.0996803045,
0.9102172852,
0.3768106997,
0.9379971027,
-0.1534520984,
0.5772830844,
0.2474140376,
-0.0697716773,
-0.3242786825,
-0.765345335,
-1.1213155985,
-0.6025398374,
-0.1480320394,
-0.0365436897,
0.2552500069,
1.0008850098,
0.7488335967,
-0.6915719509,
-0.4414806068,
-0.2977372706,
0.2410086989,
-0.1935254186,
-0.1355526745,
0.1858813167,
-0.5533335209,
-0.8980050087,
0.7146952152,
0.4538300931,
0.1805408895,
-0.4340778589,
-0.3690519929,
-0.2836478651,
0.3172518611,
0.5286812782,
0.4269459248,
-0.8040726781,
-0.4336196184,
0.057105802,
0.104278177,
-0.0136295846,
1.1184016466,
-0.6814005375,
0.4759126604,
0.0866578296,
0.3703554571,
0.5628117919,
0.002728069,
1.3669015169,
-0.6962838173,
0.5067028999,
0.3341150582,
0.216259867,
0.2959637046,
0.1106961817,
0.5231336355,
-0.0862770826,
-0.1914450228,
-0.6813163757,
0.4588417113,
-0.692374289,
-0.036595542,
1.248912096,
-0.0236960258,
-0.2001785487,
-0.292670548,
-0.6862815022,
0.1841032803,
-0.5551659465,
0.4463291466,
0.6216657758,
-0.0939139873,
-0.057740245,
-0.5248209834,
1.0347739458,
0.3250713348,
-0.796261549,
0.4252666235,
0.3926208019,
-0.3248097897,
0.1537438482,
0.9349660277,
0.0122427829,
0.175697729,
0.1880046129,
-0.0165436883,
0.2698091865,
-0.6934444904,
-0.1311096847,
-0.3198426962,
0.2183526307,
-0.2843814492
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11977v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11977v1 | Reframing linguistic bootstrapping as joint inference using visually-grounded grammar induction models | 2024-06-17T18:01:06 | 2024-06-17T18:01:06 | Eva Portelance, Siva Reddy, Timothy J. O'Donnell | cs.CL | cs.CL, I.2.7; I.2.10; I.2.6; F.4.2 | Semantic and syntactic bootstrapping posit that children use their prior
knowledge of one linguistic domain, say syntactic relations, to help later
acquire another, such as the meanings of new words. Empirical results
supporting both theories may tempt us to believe that these are different
learning strategies, where one may precede the other. Here, we argue that they
are instead both contingent on a more general learning strategy for language
acquisition: joint learning. Using a series of neural visually-grounded grammar
induction models, we demonstrate that both syntactic and semantic bootstrapping
effects are strongest when syntax and semantics are learnt simultaneously.
Joint learning results in better grammar induction, realistic lexical category
learning, and better interpretations of novel sentence and verb meanings. Joint
learning makes language acquisition easier for learners by mutually
constraining the hypotheses spaces for both syntax and semantics. Studying the
dynamics of joint inference over many input sources and modalities represents
an important new direction for language modeling and learning research in both
cognitive sciences and AI, as it may help us explain how language can be
acquired in more constrained learning settings. | [
-0.0264175385,
-0.8233875036,
0.6866919994,
0.0741858929,
-0.2308457643,
0.2119642347,
-0.3873152137,
-0.5776270032,
0.0312623568,
0.1176620796,
-0.5381903052,
-0.2133048773,
-0.6712164283,
-0.0889320076,
-0.3502328098,
0.621137917,
-0.0808120295,
0.3030213118,
-0.6397861838,
-0.071432896,
-0.6159752011,
-0.2798662782,
-0.3514074683,
-0.3515850604,
0.6374154687,
0.428262949,
0.7664027214,
0.6656139493,
0.2406241745,
0.4024718404,
0.245571062,
-0.2605080903,
-0.0887453705,
0.4525008202,
-0.3775210381,
-0.8607714772,
0.2356002927,
0.1630853117,
0.6053962708,
1.3527520895,
-0.0385308452,
0.1417592168,
-0.0482247658,
0.6348641515,
-1.0321958065,
0.4836660624,
-0.6248451471,
-0.0742644295,
0.0218539666,
-0.1952287555,
-0.506043613,
-0.045548778,
0.299862057,
-0.9339817762,
0.1744702756,
-0.0265785977,
1.0316419601,
0.2351839244,
-0.337975949,
-0.032430131,
-0.6268286705,
0.7137143612,
-0.0709682703,
0.8212617636,
0.5745649934,
0.3181083798,
-0.1430952251,
-1.0497242212,
-0.534531951,
-0.1993891895,
-0.3902727365,
0.0498150177,
0.1466078907,
0.0043884162,
0.2327248901,
0.0951565281,
-0.2751560807,
-0.0038782279,
-0.4078398645,
-0.0822485909,
0.280366689,
-0.208435908,
0.7381103635,
-0.0886122808,
-0.5897364616,
-0.2888603508,
-0.8073540926,
0.1305160522,
0.0828932896,
0.5700918436,
-0.222796157,
0.3110417724,
-0.3610727489,
0.8324936032,
0.0466452539,
-0.3915681541,
0.3815007806,
-0.4345979989,
-0.2948012054,
-0.1112110317,
0.5339989066,
0.1487877667,
0.3523230553,
-0.6118745804,
0.0075642033,
0.5919489861,
0.2066524178,
-0.1743943393,
-0.1828769147,
-0.095248431,
-0.2967392504,
-0.1827126145,
0.0857746452,
-0.9712815881,
-0.128602311,
-0.6297985315,
0.5326988697,
-0.4541553557,
-0.6331720352,
0.1511729658,
-0.4736375809,
0.3672170639,
0.2313378453,
-1.295838356,
0.6193632483,
0.8080404997,
0.2708770335,
0.051576741,
-0.8289473057,
-0.5397727489,
0.1231237724,
-0.2858448029,
0.7577842474,
-0.8713248968,
0.1400987804,
0.2108451873,
0.2087317556,
-0.3176234365,
-0.3446659148,
-0.2290644795,
-0.7229228616,
0.3860863447,
-0.3834439516,
-0.2837583721,
-0.3461622,
-0.1508677006,
-0.519693315,
0.6314912438,
0.1205396354,
-0.5968136787,
1.2967272997,
0.0522693731,
-0.558242619,
0.0670054704,
-0.6145834923,
-0.0373256877,
0.2099497169,
0.1330765486,
0.5058241487,
-0.2877965868,
0.5629651546,
-0.2135692686,
-0.0190104228,
0.0555609241,
-0.0823925287,
0.785774529,
-0.1022914499,
-0.5243381858,
0.0613607466,
-0.6068406105,
-0.0060686809,
0.3895074725,
-0.1571408361,
-0.487521112,
0.1209364906,
-0.2425126284,
0.2757825851,
-0.2272887528,
-0.30547297,
-0.0293558501,
-0.295871824,
0.1794395,
0.2950269282,
-0.0016919634,
0.8054201603,
-0.1205873862,
0.461719662,
-0.0525569282,
-0.2802465558,
-0.2658357322,
-0.2944701314,
-0.8721744418,
-0.1286972314,
0.5874189138,
0.3180041313,
-1.1415110826,
0.0815113857,
-0.0513289645,
0.1832659096,
-0.5842954516,
0.2059026957,
0.5476048589,
0.2724208236,
0.3435400426,
-0.421754837,
-0.4073454738,
-0.6946303248,
-0.3585198224,
-0.5417343974,
0.1824972779,
-0.2534214854,
0.3867507875,
0.4257535636,
0.6871134639,
0.0256781001,
0.2127725333,
-0.5351045728,
0.2706750333,
-0.4618425071,
0.4206114113,
0.6394810081,
-0.8738715649,
-0.257098645,
-0.1659611762,
-0.8031019568,
0.0641153529,
-0.4420159161,
-0.3749854863,
0.1773086041,
0.6647863388,
-0.636928916,
0.5476024747,
0.2091516852,
-0.4552324712,
0.2696315944,
0.155405432,
-0.0740388408,
-0.8222463727,
-0.2918713093,
-0.1150648966,
-0.3175587058,
-0.4418777227,
0.5486115217,
0.0663982108,
0.389895618,
-0.4390061796,
0.2225351036,
-0.9309055209,
-0.1939230263,
-0.1733978093,
0.32206586,
-0.0269817617,
0.4540174305,
0.2203049213,
0.515574038,
0.8068159819,
-0.5155316591,
0.3473035991,
-0.0996024534,
-0.4713286161,
0.2464500815,
-0.2828425765,
-0.1583698392,
-0.2231715471,
0.1237358004,
-1.1547186375,
-0.44327268,
0.3177324533,
-0.4082365632,
0.7608958483,
-0.1696941853,
-0.623916626,
0.0181799959,
0.1080970615,
0.4150420725,
0.5517755151,
-0.8656808138,
0.393424511,
0.4725260735,
0.0738988146,
-0.6386397481,
-0.6927855611,
-0.0865082368,
-0.1369617134,
-0.4009611905,
0.2087819576,
0.6609822512,
-0.6496701241,
0.2104331106,
-0.2103050202,
-0.1709887236,
0.229202345,
0.3320200741,
0.3409588933,
-0.3545000255,
0.6419091225,
-0.0005518546,
-0.354227066,
0.2284904122,
-0.449870348,
0.5251569152,
0.1329113245,
-0.4102279842,
-0.2682632506,
0.3123728931,
0.4861453474,
-0.210685432,
0.9922710657,
0.3796388507,
-0.2424004376,
-0.3362310529,
-0.4647630751,
-0.3232445419,
-0.3906491995,
0.1581267565,
-0.4177467227,
-0.6186188459,
-0.000701921,
-0.3338729143,
-0.2351733893,
0.3907001317,
0.4449994564,
0.0652912855,
0.2924339175,
0.8333393335,
0.1645065993,
0.4256885648,
-0.1398405284,
0.0513352826,
-0.3587507606,
-0.4704517424,
-0.3875986636,
-0.3096405268,
-0.5651906133,
-0.2645605206,
-0.27623564,
0.1708843857,
0.0642901659,
0.2361911386,
-0.0897572488,
0.6585142016,
0.8064835072,
0.1562480778,
0.3214994371,
0.2243965268,
-0.5298572183,
-0.0535603054,
-0.8164072633,
-0.0807531178,
0.9696974158,
0.007072181,
0.5362748504,
-0.0035602693,
0.7326140404,
-0.5442504287,
0.1625540107,
-0.7412711978,
0.5201578736,
0.3003472984,
-0.5609345436,
-0.0475171879,
-0.1524567455,
-0.90480268,
0.3808695376,
-0.5913579464,
-0.8542587161,
0.3249592781,
0.0188660882,
-0.1567528546,
0.2869267166,
-1.0704109669,
0.7600978017,
-0.1386178881,
-0.8760223985,
-0.2394617945,
-0.9829973578,
0.3744924664,
0.0746006668,
0.0842159316,
0.0022001355,
-0.1511608809,
0.5859621167,
-0.2927565575,
1.0921174288,
-0.1891869903,
0.3194721937,
0.4141202867,
0.0849057883,
-0.0407534875,
-0.1243973449,
0.4040866494,
-0.0881288499,
0.1108172908,
-0.5458601117,
-0.7164794803,
0.4684110284,
-0.6777136326,
-0.6712968946,
-0.539899528,
-0.5645563602,
-0.4604708552,
0.1191744879,
0.256048739,
0.2499708235,
-0.0110062631,
0.1349431127,
0.0922133327,
-0.0827928334,
0.4690476358,
0.4181916416,
-0.4735726416,
-0.2425301969,
0.7643629909,
-0.0768037662,
0.9274372458,
0.4362110496,
0.0106005985,
-0.1878402829,
-0.4556891024,
-0.1435837299,
0.4471929669,
-0.7530277967,
0.0059160804,
-0.3268627822,
-0.0085496735,
-0.275033921,
-0.1853615046,
-0.1337492913,
-0.7482537031,
0.2476955056,
-0.3567995429,
0.2967299521,
0.6635462046,
-0.0584178194,
0.2814993858,
-0.287171036,
0.5671444535,
0.4886693358,
0.2695784271,
0.0210902616,
-0.1463632286,
0.009444884,
0.0189138409,
-0.0689402595,
-0.9294247031,
0.0479544215,
0.1282725781,
0.5697899461,
0.1371846795,
-0.1984811425,
0.8521309495,
-0.6241538525,
0.5908313394,
0.5206890702,
-0.6889809966,
0.3864184618,
-0.1456271559,
0.3216679692,
0.8599690795,
0.4917450547,
-0.3726892173,
-0.3436482251,
-0.8240112662,
-0.7854076624,
0.5649585128,
-0.1097296402,
-0.1020258963,
-0.1608529091,
0.2885964215,
0.4464478791,
0.2686049044,
-0.7315253019,
-0.204717502,
0.1894207746,
-0.023371147,
-0.057023719,
-0.2406255752,
-0.0291003007,
-0.6525788307,
0.353666693,
0.0394442976,
0.2812407017,
-0.1425256729,
-0.441467464,
-0.3619972765,
0.1926283687,
0.010252255,
0.783808887,
0.1633866429,
0.4497446716,
-0.067061089,
-0.2072920054,
0.1205976233,
-0.10467574,
-0.033505965,
0.0535097234,
0.860871911,
0.7465267181,
0.5232971907,
-0.3891583979,
0.5166804194,
0.0119513115,
-0.3885591328,
-0.0227409564,
0.0820093974,
0.2791469097,
0.2203402668,
0.030854715,
0.1465929896,
-0.2064569741,
-0.8646686077,
0.52588588,
0.4433259666,
-0.0551155843,
-0.393129319,
0.5288252234,
-0.0304444097,
-0.0732824579,
0.5153599977,
-0.0844544321,
-0.311686784,
0.5312410593,
0.8929994702,
0.9770380855,
-0.1904409975,
0.359508872,
0.3524708152,
0.2924618125,
-0.1549320668,
0.1081036776,
-0.5071241856,
-0.7792781591,
-0.6380774379,
-0.6204805374,
-0.1721581072,
-0.0322100483,
-0.8522122502,
0.2714208364,
-0.4278565645,
0.2211335748,
0.3110643029,
-0.3450505137,
-0.7605140209,
0.1467404813,
0.3657699525,
0.6290522814,
-1.1260260344,
0.8215318322,
0.6436620355,
-0.7700092196,
-0.9524992704,
0.2954110205,
0.1344455034,
-1.0337039232,
0.9942483902,
0.2326939255,
-0.167124182,
-0.2255457789,
-0.7101515532,
-0.9464777708,
0.837295115,
0.324165076,
-0.3075542152,
-0.1971087903,
0.0867236704,
0.3931255043,
-0.4674283266,
-0.0641396344,
0.7672438622,
0.1526348442,
0.2752834857,
-0.7274542451,
0.2063043565,
-0.1174498647,
-0.2159690857,
0.4416221976,
-0.3159019351,
0.6078279614,
-0.2311413139,
-0.5377396941,
0.0359676108,
0.6637087464,
-0.0425604694,
0.4536042809,
0.5816017389,
0.5140008926,
0.4205881655,
-0.2296539843,
0.9612863064,
-0.2242222279,
0.0557838343,
1.1942746639,
0.0243157875,
0.9831209183,
0.8367681503,
-0.2733769715,
0.7644946575,
0.3551421762,
0.4945783913,
0.5953369737,
-0.0793613344,
-0.2536126375,
-0.4104549587,
-0.0821607858,
-0.29344818,
0.5915859938,
0.6679289341,
-0.4679373801,
-0.4503084719,
-0.0865801424,
0.1294137985,
0.3667875826,
0.0673297346,
0.7661694288,
0.0492264032,
-0.9189231992,
0.5993529558,
-0.4133477211,
0.1814819127,
-0.4923900068,
-0.2574451566,
0.0617729165,
-0.0594408102,
-0.1258114278,
-0.4541403949,
0.0900042057,
-0.2333058715,
0.0908693001,
-0.3845472932,
0.8220155835,
-0.7018571496,
-0.5686150789,
0.5498900414,
0.8419106603,
-0.0774775669,
0.4813072085,
-0.4126268029,
-0.027897168,
-0.2290920317,
0.0287701674,
0.5246933103,
0.5338104367,
0.1859290451,
0.3769612312,
0.484964788,
0.2710830271,
0.329133153,
0.0495521873,
0.8572918773,
-0.6176184416,
-0.3387455046,
-0.7199673057,
0.5962149501,
0.1411187202,
-0.1282539219,
0.634663403,
0.0668403581,
1.2069636583,
0.0267816987,
0.5939150453,
-0.1419532299,
0.2140054703,
-0.9091136456,
0.2776690423,
-0.5894328356,
0.0215043034,
-0.3818275332,
-0.6922192574,
-0.5858572721,
0.7000182867,
-0.6200410724,
0.108170934,
1.2188534737,
0.381868273,
-0.1156454831,
0.1177529767,
0.2799551487,
-0.0251048449,
-0.1763983816,
0.5575723052,
1.0551227331,
-0.2157725692,
-0.0288890041,
-0.6835077405,
-0.2694797814,
0.198083505,
-0.5275793672,
-0.9441533089,
-0.7687108517,
-0.3006238639,
-0.3278159201,
0.361035794,
0.9635961652,
0.6499812603,
-0.4585878551,
-0.3118602633,
-0.4778753817,
0.1790247113,
-0.374748379,
-0.2005491108,
0.1758220345,
-1.168581605,
-0.5580205917,
0.4209176302,
0.241319418,
-0.2413440496,
-0.0918751955,
0.1899032593,
-0.6525268555,
-0.367459029,
0.4352594614,
0.422798723,
-0.9701568484,
-0.3333331048,
-0.2519210577,
-0.0236342195,
0.052861657,
0.8694352508,
-1.2488870621,
0.6826167703,
0.5829657316,
0.7723175287,
0.3373597562,
-0.1250381321,
0.8083088994,
-0.6466224194,
0.7962733507,
-0.2232058793,
0.3958593011,
0.1724072695,
-0.0715014338,
0.359095633,
0.63293612,
-0.0966219828,
-0.6242069602,
0.4438616633,
-0.598025918,
-0.4244814515,
1.1638950109,
0.0626760051,
-0.4900373816,
-0.0952187032,
0.2489949018,
0.3862128556,
-0.0292419195,
0.5140241981,
0.6965520382,
0.2178276628,
-0.2654773593,
-0.6445319653,
0.5378165245,
0.7473759651,
-0.5023965836,
-0.0292836055,
0.4444116056,
0.1810985804,
0.2738735378,
0.2656797767,
0.0215210337,
0.5575638413,
0.5672892332,
-0.0229768455,
0.1572642326,
-0.8635635972,
-0.2850809097,
0.1798387021,
0.1639029235,
-0.5881845951
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11839v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11839v1 | mDPO: Conditional Preference Optimization for Multimodal Large Language Models | 2024-06-17T17:59:58 | 2024-06-17T17:59:58 | Fei Wang, Wenxuan Zhou, James Y. Huang, Nan Xu, Sheng Zhang, Hoifung Poon, Muhao Chen | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Direct preference optimization (DPO) has shown to be an effective method for
large language model (LLM) alignment. Recent works have attempted to apply DPO
to multimodal scenarios but have found it challenging to achieve consistent
improvement. Through a comparative experiment, we identify the unconditional
preference problem in multimodal preference optimization, where the model
overlooks the image condition. To address this problem, we propose mDPO, a
multimodal DPO objective that prevents the over-prioritization of language-only
preferences by also optimizing image preference. Moreover, we introduce a
reward anchor that forces the reward to be positive for chosen responses,
thereby avoiding the decrease in their likelihood -- an intrinsic problem of
relative preference optimization. Experiments on two multimodal LLMs of
different sizes and three widely used benchmarks demonstrate that mDPO
effectively addresses the unconditional preference problem in multimodal
preference optimization and significantly improves model performance,
particularly in reducing hallucination. | [
-0.4903047979,
-0.4870889187,
0.8844309449,
0.3037443459,
-0.3574803174,
-0.006051498,
-0.4072723389,
-0.2070407718,
0.229097113,
0.4327497482,
-0.6129021645,
-0.2320208699,
-0.7363587618,
0.1004857719,
0.232040152,
0.4802645147,
-0.0810311511,
0.0930886343,
-0.5377064943,
-0.1154376492,
-0.4270764589,
-0.4328339398,
-0.7460263968,
-0.3773060739,
0.7591918707,
0.6280220747,
0.7475082874,
0.7104372382,
0.6417928934,
0.3295300901,
0.1522152871,
0.5032923222,
-0.2564456165,
0.1622721553,
-0.1436074525,
-0.2839260399,
-0.4415515363,
0.0832833946,
0.6058430076,
0.5258690119,
-0.1124783009,
-0.1588160396,
-0.1829163283,
1.0250121355,
-0.9343003631,
-0.0117777744,
-0.6689040661,
0.1035327017,
0.0302572567,
-0.5758660436,
-0.4887161553,
-0.1435288042,
0.0877110958,
-0.5089974999,
-0.3455122113,
0.0752338693,
0.5596135855,
0.4423224926,
-0.9087871313,
0.0138689233,
-0.5231318474,
1.0081782341,
-0.3708240986,
0.4013230503,
0.4088315368,
0.0852628574,
-0.2209767848,
-0.1165445074,
-0.927071929,
-0.379491806,
0.13816908,
0.1154022291,
-0.0711944774,
0.3898532391,
0.1529028118,
0.3185100555,
-0.5131998062,
0.0958527103,
0.1265335232,
-0.2441372722,
0.2916291058,
-0.091188401,
0.3238004446,
-0.2235547304,
-0.5953342915,
-0.0953418091,
-0.5917640924,
0.3262556195,
0.5128836632,
0.1798944473,
-0.0328807123,
0.9843444824,
-0.3341385424,
0.7771375775,
0.3076441288,
-0.6316401958,
0.3493703902,
-0.196060732,
-0.0477458872,
0.1453706622,
0.6138645411,
0.8696801066,
0.2180404514,
0.0199140627,
-0.2531712055,
0.3655882776,
0.0907149985,
-0.7195446491,
0.1879727542,
0.4248597026,
-0.5218459368,
-0.3094928861,
-0.3134602904,
-0.7710254788,
-0.4834901989,
-0.5719679594,
0.3234756589,
-0.1854124069,
-0.3695904016,
0.230749622,
-0.2053949535,
-0.0580065511,
0.0663511381,
-1.207875371,
-0.0250785034,
0.6381762028,
0.7427182794,
-0.3084160089,
-0.4671993256,
-0.7163370848,
0.3890994191,
-0.2465961426,
0.8459539413,
-0.9335980415,
-0.309422493,
-0.1122294515,
-0.0465951152,
-0.0701845065,
-0.2420844138,
0.7598162293,
-0.2624584734,
0.1906805933,
-0.3204345405,
-0.4897973239,
0.1239082813,
0.4412631392,
-0.4076435566,
0.5425921082,
-0.243898958,
-0.7233372331,
0.6446452737,
-0.4797719419,
-0.3729651272,
-0.4632082283,
-0.3032760322,
-0.1691697687,
0.3652728498,
0.1470186561,
0.2117196023,
-0.2721435428,
0.353030771,
-0.5696828961,
-0.2454629838,
0.2630381584,
-0.2858380973,
0.2493300885,
0.1692699939,
-0.2919374704,
0.4178454876,
-0.7402738929,
-0.0621513948,
0.2675665617,
-0.3721004725,
-0.6810750365,
0.2398096025,
-0.286870867,
0.4136311114,
0.3803088069,
-0.5989643931,
0.6863051653,
-0.1025269553,
0.2258767188,
1.1738016605,
-0.3344684541,
0.6625503302,
-0.1960239708,
0.520113647,
-0.0298994556,
0.4795119166,
0.0531190336,
-0.3188738525,
-0.7714521885,
-0.8018183708,
0.0946646482,
0.2452517599,
-0.8847875595,
0.290355891,
-0.1601512879,
-0.0092421919,
-0.4018383622,
0.0663420483,
0.4784938395,
0.7091234922,
0.1749776006,
-0.2073308676,
-0.6258320212,
-1.4203377962,
0.277361095,
-0.0608107485,
0.1574158669,
0.4851047099,
-0.0177699365,
-0.3928357363,
0.634188354,
-0.7685858011,
-0.3299937248,
-0.0360673852,
-0.0925826579,
0.2357224226,
0.3876098096,
0.7324668765,
-1.0494043827,
-0.460901767,
-0.1457144171,
-0.2372799218,
-0.0737527311,
-0.0140748043,
-0.2439240664,
0.4245206416,
0.0614612848,
-0.7960419059,
-0.0899822041,
0.9520862699,
-0.224993363,
0.2898043692,
-0.4921714962,
0.672200501,
-0.9428809881,
-0.0227962453,
0.0579794943,
-0.1036679149,
-0.3550310135,
-0.199504748,
0.3072728515,
-0.3234632313,
-0.2910832465,
0.6131243706,
-0.381765455,
0.1060738936,
-0.5102466345,
0.0191526562,
0.1343167126,
0.6561846137,
0.52940166,
0.6407096982,
0.7674347758,
-0.50541538,
0.2474157512,
0.1946000606,
-0.0988951698,
0.8450783491,
-0.5218379498,
0.348167032,
-0.2139821947,
0.1250993758,
-1.2424063683,
-0.0664267465,
0.1831445694,
-0.2795708179,
0.6348118782,
-0.4788106978,
-0.4346230328,
-0.2631016374,
-0.5642216802,
0.5762949586,
0.1164378822,
-0.6972025633,
0.3812902868,
0.5426446795,
0.0535118207,
-0.9346826673,
-0.2255930603,
0.0948328376,
-0.2516779602,
-0.5399186611,
0.4394639134,
-0.3123701215,
-0.0981930271,
-0.3465030193,
-0.2681064606,
0.0481443703,
-0.2420122921,
0.1762537509,
0.3760769963,
0.1209798455,
0.18697837,
0.0502866097,
-0.4405591786,
-0.3239423335,
-0.2526125908,
0.8490787745,
0.1378487945,
-0.3351076245,
-0.3146001399,
0.6641229391,
0.7199070454,
-0.2102174312,
0.5745283961,
0.2058601528,
-0.109486334,
0.1219154447,
-0.5987890959,
-0.0001671029,
-0.5059886575,
0.1554497778,
-0.7253700495,
-0.5621988177,
-0.0162598602,
0.0664673001,
-0.2663836181,
0.0504684262,
0.4584454596,
-0.0419128947,
1.5903023481,
0.9387456179,
-0.0951753706,
0.7156486511,
0.1896796077,
0.1878316402,
-0.7796484232,
-0.1668421477,
-0.4440695047,
-0.5083612204,
-0.5767570138,
-0.2795470953,
0.2719447613,
-0.1911322325,
-0.0310454741,
0.1518603712,
-0.4723528624,
0.4289791584,
0.5764824748,
0.2183345705,
0.3228468597,
0.0528242253,
-0.2908903956,
-0.2664606571,
-0.4012181163,
-0.3907667994,
0.9526589513,
0.1331579238,
0.7746169567,
0.1646811217,
0.5855591297,
0.1256135702,
-0.0427995361,
-0.9263894558,
0.5000327229,
-0.2754856646,
-0.5675342679,
-0.1568855494,
-0.5449556112,
-0.818220675,
0.3139845729,
-0.3036144376,
-0.6544433236,
0.5960256457,
0.4566282928,
-0.0040450408,
0.1062971503,
-0.7585201859,
0.8429287672,
-0.5662593246,
-0.4271828234,
-0.3900243938,
-0.5353108048,
0.3107580841,
-0.0588753112,
0.0893852934,
-0.4504443109,
-0.3512876034,
0.2322798669,
-0.0806583762,
0.383797735,
-0.1855077595,
-0.1287452579,
-0.3102671802,
-0.0306773204,
0.4911107123,
0.0682623759,
-0.1025383621,
-0.0629542917,
-0.0715275779,
-0.3674576581,
-0.6491044164,
1.0395737886,
-0.6670302749,
-0.7209078074,
-0.4594227672,
-0.6524900794,
-0.4640206695,
0.2598575652,
0.0434955582,
0.4660301507,
0.1559168994,
0.1531386375,
0.6019893885,
-0.221565932,
0.4604811072,
0.4998983443,
-0.2735276222,
-0.5736141801,
0.7459142208,
-0.2606044412,
0.5262357593,
0.7458077073,
0.489009589,
-0.5926580429,
-0.5459830761,
-0.3634072542,
0.2444858402,
-0.6777246594,
-0.0081163822,
-0.6451265812,
0.4854468703,
-0.401006937,
-0.2002499849,
-0.6299517751,
-0.5058295131,
0.0650028139,
0.1848551482,
0.033556547,
-0.0053704656,
-0.1262583882,
-0.1492126137,
-0.4315237105,
0.762067616,
0.4936878085,
0.563436389,
-0.3989741802,
-0.3778679371,
0.3362911046,
0.1214935258,
-0.251003921,
-0.4901442528,
0.1946896166,
0.0918836892,
0.7273191214,
0.7837051749,
0.0968941152,
0.7747706771,
-0.5430010557,
0.169753328,
0.6078827381,
-0.7843008041,
0.6558035016,
-0.3723444641,
0.246067524,
0.6748690605,
0.6024240255,
-0.5643724799,
0.0638756976,
-0.102783829,
-0.6331773996,
0.3710598648,
0.0087000262,
0.2936816514,
-0.208676815,
0.2605094314,
0.1127806455,
0.4910160005,
-0.9269419312,
-0.3978207409,
-0.0527695864,
0.0613298565,
-0.3892396986,
-0.6281285286,
-0.4315354824,
-0.1776793897,
0.4615401924,
-0.290170759,
0.1832803041,
0.2178730816,
-0.0788517818,
-0.277855128,
0.2744429111,
0.9850369096,
0.875186801,
-0.5340256095,
0.2959825695,
-0.4499976039,
-0.1363254935,
0.4519118965,
-0.0396917425,
-0.1162480265,
-0.2975566089,
-0.0588579029,
0.7344284654,
0.1087710336,
-0.7266437411,
0.5858076215,
-0.2969047427,
-0.0928376615,
0.0478844531,
-0.0979799256,
-0.0400137715,
0.1590622962,
0.2194608897,
0.1640324891,
0.2001278996,
-0.8642954826,
0.0910808221,
0.7720301151,
-0.3122738004,
0.0467179753,
0.5369494557,
0.245853588,
-0.1883883774,
0.2703913152,
0.0042545083,
-0.4204777181,
0.4239391685,
0.6653017998,
0.6278955936,
-0.083071053,
0.2099810541,
0.1904945672,
0.2033637315,
-0.0196088012,
0.1979735494,
-0.1590426117,
-1.0131158829,
-0.3650609553,
-0.462310046,
-0.5285032392,
-0.0661339164,
-0.420468241,
0.4196988344,
-0.394102335,
-0.2213709652,
0.0918480605,
-0.1033170223,
-0.4622575641,
0.1981539428,
0.3546174765,
0.4483965635,
-0.6112798452,
1.0696297884,
0.7116725445,
-0.2942736745,
-0.2604346275,
-0.0422280766,
0.1527174264,
-0.9294771552,
0.5985193849,
0.2089911997,
-0.4232573211,
-0.1898693889,
-0.2522839904,
-0.8049313426,
0.6581199765,
0.636854291,
-0.6643308997,
0.3845355213,
-0.001658858,
0.2894889414,
-0.52811414,
0.0517257825,
0.3012049794,
0.7313375473,
0.334975332,
-0.8836216927,
-0.0102189425,
-0.1481844634,
-0.0525942333,
0.5088179111,
-0.853091538,
0.3906146884,
-0.3804289997,
0.030490445,
-0.0415915027,
0.1877880245,
0.4047583938,
0.1827284396,
0.9606300592,
0.5949373841,
0.6417533159,
0.016758617,
1.2699363232,
-0.2401151359,
0.2127916217,
0.9097588062,
-0.550465405,
0.6941421032,
1.1363162994,
-0.0515029654,
-0.1086261049,
0.8201816678,
0.1658972055,
1.0913000107,
0.0160879586,
-0.2070163339,
-0.4331591129,
-0.3659308851,
-0.38089028,
0.6785537601,
-0.2396107018,
-0.1293518841,
0.274979502,
0.0740112215,
-0.099345006,
0.2001320273,
-0.2581743598,
0.5419133902,
-0.1723501682,
-0.9311906695,
0.5190365314,
-0.0765560865,
0.9288442731,
-0.7404100299,
0.1622910053,
-0.4136927724,
0.3935356438,
-0.0784479678,
-0.5061120391,
0.0036836851,
-0.3396522701,
-0.5468798876,
-0.3275057375,
0.6159216166,
-0.5851092339,
-0.4892809987,
0.4173937738,
0.0118230162,
-0.3053731918,
-0.2296580523,
-0.6429847479,
0.1936530918,
0.0751325563,
-0.2771208584,
0.4879894853,
0.1822636575,
0.1501548439,
0.9624879956,
0.6964191794,
0.1015690938,
-0.335934788,
0.1600561738,
0.7502589226,
-0.4477594793,
-0.179240182,
-1.0041782856,
0.4419902265,
-0.2014641166,
-0.3633850813,
0.5935952067,
0.6148636937,
0.5950939059,
-0.1750301272,
0.4418618977,
0.0233478229,
0.0869351253,
-0.8125565648,
0.3183410764,
-1.0736047029,
0.0163502619,
-0.5842429996,
-1.2659640312,
-0.2300692499,
0.5063014627,
-0.2633616626,
-0.1381983757,
0.9042354822,
0.750828445,
-0.190222159,
-0.6016554832,
0.5875708461,
-0.3697719574,
0.178296715,
0.5691933632,
0.9728024006,
0.2095664144,
0.5700163245,
-0.6974700689,
-0.4063175321,
0.0226499718,
-1.3600071669,
-0.7986016273,
-0.6671187282,
-0.3865135908,
0.0381437317,
-0.1083407849,
1.1011551619,
0.8663196564,
-0.5876566172,
-0.1384389848,
0.4883893132,
0.4068768322,
-0.0517882407,
-0.1207079738,
0.1526731402,
-0.2160115093,
-1.0849773884,
0.5245818496,
0.7751019001,
0.13143152,
-0.089049004,
-0.1402292997,
-0.4219958484,
0.1350750327,
0.6606588364,
0.1557177305,
-0.6604071259,
-0.497759968,
0.0889193937,
-0.2318657637,
0.4322550297,
1.0303426981,
-0.1293325573,
0.7703425288,
0.5291637778,
0.5148534179,
0.5371928811,
-0.053611815,
0.8749316335,
-0.6558301449,
0.7316026092,
-0.0804359466,
0.784645617,
0.215485096,
-0.3661614358,
0.2983010113,
0.1577181816,
-0.5049418211,
-0.777441442,
0.3881989121,
-1.3852586746,
-0.3492535651,
1.256747961,
0.1821786165,
0.0881192312,
0.3135871589,
-0.5805245638,
-0.0261675827,
-0.5591289401,
0.9904173613,
0.7234802246,
-0.1558631063,
-0.3583909571,
-0.3975639045,
0.4052239656,
0.6141353846,
-0.6048691869,
-0.2056911588,
0.7142070532,
0.1340420097,
0.0823456198,
0.7277571559,
0.0841876045,
0.1467680484,
-0.3360811472,
0.3935483396,
-0.1102032661,
-0.4299066365,
-0.2492909729,
0.0285047293,
0.2823211253,
-0.5059011579
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11830v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11830v1 | Language Modeling with Editable External Knowledge | 2024-06-17T17:59:35 | 2024-06-17T17:59:35 | Belinda Z. Li, Emmy Liu, Alexis Ross, Abbas Zeitoun, Graham Neubig, Jacob Andreas | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | When the world changes, so does the text that humans write about it. How do
we build language models that can be easily updated to reflect these changes?
One popular approach is retrieval-augmented generation, in which new documents
are inserted into a knowledge base and retrieved during prediction for
downstream tasks. Most prior work on these systems have focused on improving
behavior during prediction through better retrieval or reasoning. This paper
introduces ERASE, which instead improves model behavior when new documents are
acquired, by incrementally deleting or rewriting other entries in the knowledge
base each time a document is added. In two new benchmark datasets evaluating
models' ability to answer questions about a stream of news articles or
conversations, ERASE improves accuracy relative to conventional
retrieval-augmented generation by 7-13% (Mixtral-8x7B) and 6-10% (Llama-3-8B)
absolute. Code and data are available at https://github.com/belindal/ERASE | [
-0.3598380387,
-1.0424029827,
0.5122615099,
-0.1574935019,
0.2212003171,
0.2185733616,
-0.2814507186,
-0.7326890826,
0.0692351758,
0.6177255511,
-0.3515013158,
-0.1571499407,
-0.4931360185,
-0.0962782875,
-0.7531453967,
0.9063711762,
0.0154767195,
-0.3917945027,
-0.4184556603,
0.0541860498,
-0.4031366706,
-0.352964133,
-0.8632303476,
-0.3864236176,
0.3697992861,
0.4026370049,
0.9057446718,
0.9987068176,
0.2433357388,
0.3816690445,
-0.6182199717,
0.3507122695,
-0.6515944004,
0.4280875921,
-0.1991220862,
-0.3583259881,
-0.3363111019,
-0.3942214549,
0.7493021488,
0.7880049348,
-0.3236283958,
-0.1623418331,
0.0941876322,
0.6581491828,
-0.4918282628,
0.1381344348,
-0.9495937824,
-0.3582722545,
0.1067901552,
0.0966942757,
-0.3167110682,
-0.4788549244,
0.1065044701,
-0.7413875461,
0.3034041822,
-0.0874782056,
0.8032690287,
-0.0596411414,
-0.2804660797,
-0.4880501926,
-0.7253055573,
0.4230426848,
-0.5717728734,
0.6882327199,
0.6470556259,
-0.2322352678,
-0.3510537446,
-0.7309394479,
-0.5902647376,
-0.224162221,
-0.1301135868,
-0.0316272601,
-0.1825236827,
-0.0999353752,
0.3013863862,
0.1147306785,
-0.0842578039,
-0.0468362533,
-0.6549108624,
-0.1937475652,
0.3936754465,
0.0804538801,
0.3706702888,
-0.2577956915,
-0.0128144678,
0.3195087612,
-1.0970728397,
-0.0460166894,
0.5383374691,
0.4138700068,
0.3996083736,
0.6294661164,
-0.5804128647,
0.6899058223,
0.2777580023,
-0.0877216831,
0.2400231361,
-0.2857018411,
-0.0790229887,
-0.0804093182,
0.2274750769,
0.2792059481,
0.0636400953,
-0.0445931107,
-0.3611177504,
-0.2994252443,
0.2807539403,
-0.6483384371,
-0.4459172785,
0.1875199825,
-0.4004052281,
-0.1823518276,
-0.329128027,
-0.2093500942,
-0.9447057843,
-0.612947166,
0.4612968862,
-0.7544805408,
-0.2652547657,
-0.0503492206,
-0.1895034164,
-0.2573333085,
0.8301627636,
-0.8679680824,
0.3944213986,
0.5416258574,
0.3716472685,
0.1619173884,
-0.2940897346,
-0.6210868359,
0.2210923135,
-0.347548306,
0.7517907023,
-0.5970628262,
-0.435130775,
-0.006583266,
-0.0907312557,
0.102647014,
-0.6609424949,
0.3016190827,
-0.7606870532,
0.4235112965,
-0.5133116841,
-0.8491563797,
-0.3797266185,
0.293674916,
-0.6736611724,
1.0815961361,
0.0376924686,
-0.5811712742,
0.3466912508,
-0.5069970489,
-0.3766430318,
-0.0453804284,
0.4186944962,
-0.3377212882,
0.0441843197,
0.176524505,
-0.0514998734,
-0.0287321508,
0.5557108521,
-0.1280978173,
-0.2635379136,
0.1271721125,
-0.3475385904,
0.7327493429,
0.2752131224,
0.0281990599,
-0.0182928257,
-0.919695735,
-0.1715251207,
-0.1311603338,
-0.603947401,
-0.611574173,
0.3505447507,
-0.2953378856,
0.131834358,
0.2384661138,
-0.6877456307,
0.2433803678,
-0.4397951961,
0.1468463689,
0.8234696984,
0.3464312553,
0.568379879,
-0.5777888298,
0.1577926874,
0.1314123869,
0.1955354661,
-0.5918444991,
-0.4758703709,
-1.0710799694,
-0.2493089288,
0.0772112459,
0.3154335916,
-0.6975361109,
0.0404397808,
-0.2014605105,
-0.5310407877,
-0.4239510298,
0.4717251062,
0.3334218562,
0.8614013195,
0.2901051342,
-0.0030802449,
-0.6482114196,
-0.6168299913,
-0.5614286661,
-0.184446305,
0.1721059978,
0.0713086873,
0.2935665548,
-0.1359953284,
1.0221441984,
-0.4433842897,
0.1386631727,
-0.0821009278,
0.0849887058,
-0.1777268946,
0.5339305997,
0.0699682757,
-0.7890259027,
-0.3025348783,
-0.1588589847,
-0.7489474416,
-0.338180542,
0.1095678508,
-0.1090126857,
0.3744563162,
0.6232814789,
-0.5800675154,
0.4656780064,
0.0552311949,
-0.3515809476,
0.2600159943,
-0.4328112006,
0.3206469417,
-0.8800147176,
0.1525411904,
-0.1944584399,
-0.2331070006,
-0.8278663158,
0.0679936484,
0.3075123429,
-0.1163860708,
-0.5737016201,
0.8766557574,
-0.633918643,
0.0490464121,
-0.2712746859,
0.3560561836,
0.2459648848,
0.2908160388,
0.1774007976,
0.4721471071,
0.0641740188,
-0.729739964,
0.0177747384,
0.5063370466,
-0.5489100814,
0.2401594669,
-0.2860095203,
0.1388410777,
-0.4931675196,
-0.0056893872,
-0.9121145606,
-0.1049036309,
0.0464554913,
-0.1654417962,
0.1688718349,
-0.1442197412,
-0.5733252764,
0.0503847413,
-0.2412081212,
-0.0859951526,
0.3900816143,
-0.6250324845,
0.6184524894,
0.5395790339,
-0.5683689713,
-0.4979710281,
-0.3193327487,
0.0654116943,
0.0069151218,
-0.4604921639,
0.2024271041,
-0.1932989508,
-0.4569452405,
0.3479066193,
0.0983884484,
-0.2638662159,
0.2440069318,
0.272747457,
0.2142908871,
0.0172709934,
0.6564160585,
0.1711764038,
0.0512250289,
-0.264166832,
0.0910739824,
0.4046055079,
0.2373010665,
-0.3773854971,
-0.0874512568,
0.0787858218,
0.3933900297,
-0.4203357697,
0.8079140186,
0.2341879904,
-0.6594163179,
-0.0146149127,
-0.7462820411,
-0.0773528591,
-0.5249342322,
0.514942646,
-0.4761574566,
-0.6284794807,
0.7585685849,
0.1487394273,
0.3863303363,
0.3643402755,
0.3073424697,
-0.0599286668,
0.9184250832,
0.6233360171,
0.2218958586,
0.9137145877,
-0.0347002521,
0.2136282772,
-0.9614435434,
-0.3102003932,
-0.4703715444,
-0.001674842,
-0.383742094,
-0.2550331056,
-0.0175747536,
0.4089288712,
-0.3759811521,
0.4448079467,
-0.3654484451,
0.4863616526,
0.8153514266,
0.2324259579,
0.6941176653,
-0.2036014944,
-0.010178281,
-0.0909069404,
-0.5271939635,
-0.3559480906,
1.1054993868,
0.1646339446,
0.6720536947,
-0.0251922514,
0.7753849626,
0.2335604578,
0.7144143581,
-0.2809991241,
0.4768955112,
0.0728969797,
-0.7054727674,
-0.2570352852,
-0.3648392856,
-0.683157444,
0.295625329,
-0.358577311,
-0.734402895,
0.1451292187,
0.396423161,
-0.0384838469,
0.6259263158,
-0.9249658585,
0.5986292958,
0.0094769495,
-0.4509449899,
-0.2073757499,
-0.1927918643,
0.3675167263,
-0.2935622931,
0.3743222952,
-0.1829934567,
-0.1059220135,
0.5239153504,
-0.5259471536,
0.8145419359,
-0.4104935229,
-0.1982548833,
0.5967853665,
0.4341866076,
0.8816552758,
-0.1425102949,
-0.5036451817,
-0.1575358957,
-0.0218867324,
0.0031641987,
-0.6755651832,
0.7419979572,
-0.4072169662,
-0.6203482151,
-0.1032756045,
-0.7573272586,
-0.1812327355,
0.2965953946,
-0.0636237636,
0.6512202621,
-0.3094086051,
0.0762937739,
0.5759518147,
-0.5501987338,
0.4484192431,
0.8462060094,
-0.527826786,
-0.2139229774,
0.9019629359,
0.3656454086,
0.4425928891,
0.4203619659,
0.1372179538,
-0.2726071477,
-0.6237155199,
-0.0447074659,
0.1273996234,
-0.9518018365,
-0.1243771389,
-0.9929878712,
-0.0998644903,
-0.5122286081,
-0.1401943713,
-0.261592567,
-0.6928246617,
-0.1336642653,
-0.2238365263,
0.4755702913,
0.873983562,
-0.2218320817,
0.3094663322,
-0.7478428483,
0.4330764115,
0.116028212,
0.4561730027,
0.0316068791,
-0.675023675,
-0.331635654,
0.2294943929,
-0.3825841546,
-0.5069532394,
0.3749147356,
0.272102803,
0.4944447279,
0.0534357876,
-0.0813884661,
0.8155550957,
-0.4880235195,
0.5192052722,
-0.1802883744,
-1.0697039366,
0.4942930639,
-0.4959354401,
0.4344855249,
0.4815840125,
0.0230081845,
-1.0694521666,
-0.9548217654,
-0.7240288854,
-0.8469359875,
0.6371176243,
-0.0664707124,
0.2045852095,
-0.1793063879,
0.5427871346,
0.1767888069,
0.451402247,
-0.5559486747,
-0.1193355471,
0.0958488211,
-0.3910238147,
0.1210314855,
-0.5241183043,
0.2939959168,
-0.1734386683,
1.0652827024,
0.3284745812,
0.0517841354,
-0.0732144788,
-0.4729601741,
-0.1731640995,
0.105817765,
0.4571615756,
0.7745002508,
-0.1968827844,
-0.0492539667,
0.2365571111,
-0.4365837872,
-0.0191266723,
-0.0326820612,
-0.6890650988,
-0.1602148861,
0.3814379871,
0.4193184674,
0.3590554595,
-0.8295483589,
0.1150024459,
0.08740554,
-0.1706316918,
-0.1940569431,
0.2365885228,
0.3831779957,
0.0616873689,
0.2765608728,
0.3412563205,
-0.0233413503,
-0.5686689019,
0.2841764987,
0.1127122194,
-0.3440223336,
-0.3387600183,
0.7334177494,
0.1742510349,
-0.3866179287,
0.8905370831,
-0.278916657,
-0.5439303517,
0.4077378511,
0.3567635715,
0.5158999562,
-0.3217372894,
0.0855088457,
0.346162349,
0.4471720457,
-0.0481419079,
0.3058395088,
0.2722964287,
-1.0777739286,
-0.3585541248,
-0.3871061504,
-0.4104043543,
0.1448534429,
-0.2847236991,
0.1494149417,
-0.3720711768,
0.0301890224,
0.2094510049,
0.0642338842,
-0.6242563128,
0.4586706161,
-0.0844734684,
0.742869854,
-0.7631668448,
0.9045190215,
0.445130378,
-0.5105674267,
-0.5541785955,
-0.3408945501,
0.0829795152,
-0.6210647225,
0.5564263463,
-0.0752817988,
0.0717558935,
-0.0058626463,
-0.3801252544,
-1.2633574009,
0.6332454085,
0.6123723984,
-0.1805091649,
0.0901992396,
-0.3637570143,
0.4830467701,
-0.0400511995,
0.2004444748,
0.4385375381,
0.5052465796,
-0.2322500497,
-0.6612532139,
-0.1950664818,
-0.419724375,
-0.234276861,
0.4985359609,
-0.3475858271,
1.0582823753,
-0.3254354,
-0.2200328112,
0.1781875044,
0.5513309836,
-0.0082422877,
0.0506116264,
0.4485765696,
0.5122715831,
1.1006984711,
-0.1936473995,
0.9933664799,
-0.3289296329,
0.0158415753,
1.7975196838,
-0.5140505433,
0.8843726516,
0.3898641467,
0.1174968854,
0.4837254882,
0.367100805,
0.2832459807,
0.4371210039,
0.0856337994,
-0.4483128786,
0.0093689691,
-0.1134621873,
-0.0170308836,
0.3742597401,
0.2049433589,
-0.2602190375,
0.0085648363,
0.1398093849,
0.320902884,
0.3501442373,
-0.1132585183,
0.9079049826,
-0.3726670742,
-0.9247025251,
0.2528804243,
0.1404318064,
0.1575651467,
-0.5229070783,
-0.1589491814,
-0.4441159368,
0.3367370963,
-0.129978925,
-0.7086812258,
0.3936805129,
0.0360889398,
-0.488371402,
-0.3337648809,
0.8043125272,
-0.7808747292,
-0.4249179363,
0.2353813946,
0.5518018603,
-0.0330738053,
-0.0857660174,
-0.4734170139,
0.0783820003,
0.0648648217,
-0.5070180893,
0.2846423388,
0.3630211055,
-0.2455322891,
1.1240575314,
0.7772410512,
0.2420434505,
0.305351764,
0.0713825077,
0.8032616973,
-0.5735422373,
-0.3289486766,
-0.4783796072,
0.5286641717,
-0.1837147921,
-0.0689913109,
0.6970368028,
0.8228574395,
0.7571408153,
0.1549376696,
0.9006818533,
-0.1934665591,
1.1425162554,
-0.3495076895,
0.6816210151,
-0.3385477662,
0.3283296525,
-0.3670697212,
-0.7582727075,
-0.1965043247,
0.307711333,
-0.3617632389,
0.1774644405,
0.6053450704,
1.0519756079,
-0.0000951204,
0.0294530038,
0.2157379389,
0.4091944098,
0.5584203601,
0.1695642024,
0.9546721578,
-0.5723193884,
0.4862243235,
-0.4684886038,
0.1939253658,
0.0201091655,
-0.9081134796,
-0.3760423958,
-0.6077988148,
-0.457031101,
-0.2451938093,
0.3011484444,
0.6670345664,
0.2998484075,
-0.7460826039,
-0.1653904915,
0.0397348814,
0.3942213655,
-0.2789184153,
-0.1770371348,
0.4775455594,
-0.4704051018,
-0.7811374068,
0.465934068,
0.0616563931,
0.0611134693,
0.1860854179,
0.0456439331,
-0.5419247746,
0.1391191334,
0.5312146544,
0.3710929453,
-0.5617316961,
-0.6339252591,
-0.0304593686,
-0.0453821011,
0.1134171337,
0.5063762665,
-0.8768389821,
0.8863097429,
0.5866837502,
0.4291304052,
0.5327256918,
0.3814271688,
0.7283488512,
-0.6578364968,
0.134229973,
-0.2231399864,
0.418691963,
0.6367974281,
-0.2896741033,
0.3654707372,
0.1839367151,
-0.3844378591,
-0.7134093046,
-0.0543740243,
-0.2143135667,
-0.3244017065,
0.9267380238,
-0.0320251696,
-0.1081502438,
-0.281154871,
-0.4495054483,
0.3394387662,
-0.3137710989,
0.7081770301,
0.6177259684,
0.1404326111,
-0.0573347099,
-0.42182675,
0.5847170949,
0.1592326164,
-0.9501675963,
0.4638085365,
0.9352427125,
0.5831074119,
-0.0410487577,
1.0189211369,
-0.0346238613,
0.2671798468,
0.0253287088,
0.3813174963,
-0.4042729437,
-0.3243093193,
-0.2334264815,
0.1867022514,
0.1919031441,
0.1100606173
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11827v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11827v1 | WPO: Enhancing RLHF with Weighted Preference Optimization | 2024-06-17T17:59:13 | 2024-06-17T17:59:13 | Wenxuan Zhou, Ravi Agrawal, Shujian Zhang, Sathish Reddy Indurthi, Sanqiang Zhao, Kaiqiang Song, Silei Xu, Chenguang Zhu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Reinforcement learning from human feedback (RLHF) is a promising solution to
align large language models (LLMs) more closely with human values. Off-policy
preference optimization, where the preference data is obtained from other
models, is widely adopted due to its cost efficiency and scalability. However,
off-policy preference optimization often suffers from a distributional gap
between the policy used for data collection and the target policy, leading to
suboptimal optimization. In this paper, we propose a novel strategy to mitigate
this problem by simulating on-policy learning with off-policy preference data.
Our Weighted Preference Optimization (WPO) method adapts off-policy data to
resemble on-policy data more closely by reweighting preference pairs according
to their probability under the current policy. This method not only addresses
the distributional gap problem but also enhances the optimization process
without incurring additional costs. We validate our method on instruction
following benchmarks including Alpaca Eval 2 and MT-bench. WPO not only
outperforms Direct Preference Optimization (DPO) by up to 5.6% on Alpaca Eval 2
but also establishes a remarkable length-controlled winning rate against
GPT-4-turbo of 48.6% based on Llama-3-8B-Instruct, making it the strongest 8B
model on the leaderboard. We will release the code and models at
https://github.com/wzhouad/WPO. | [
-0.4785722196,
-0.6221610904,
0.3261116445,
0.164628759,
-0.1962518543,
-0.0482906364,
-0.4273785055,
-0.2522054315,
0.299664259,
0.4578850865,
-0.7171791792,
0.0121620698,
-0.4463918209,
-0.1037673503,
0.5294745564,
0.8951499462,
0.0532910042,
-0.004684899,
-0.2696548998,
-0.2754281163,
-0.2891415656,
-0.3360714316,
-0.4984153211,
-0.9542688727,
0.4809690714,
0.5229858756,
0.716965735,
0.5432008505,
0.253788203,
0.2093190402,
0.0401096269,
0.3588807285,
-0.5862025619,
-0.1269356012,
0.0900330842,
-0.3392591476,
-0.3466509283,
-0.0329181477,
0.5136076212,
0.5867708325,
-0.8176114559,
0.0909602717,
0.0154339345,
0.8447588682,
-0.9513578415,
0.1049791202,
-0.4522054493,
0.4180957973,
0.0902522206,
-0.475543946,
-0.5136807561,
-0.4895859361,
0.3130385876,
-0.973560214,
-0.2507003248,
0.3459909856,
0.8115126491,
0.3327090442,
-0.2179683596,
-0.1038599163,
-0.4999991357,
0.9397815466,
-0.6650684476,
0.3965216279,
0.5085368752,
0.0938095078,
-0.3829549253,
-0.225202933,
-0.6052812338,
-0.54270643,
0.1938480586,
0.2900968492,
0.0440588668,
0.066430144,
0.2265379131,
-0.054870978,
-0.3429665864,
0.1742548496,
-0.1144257337,
-0.1222565994,
0.6589121222,
-0.2481841147,
-0.1747349352,
-0.0162600633,
-0.5058944225,
-0.4924843609,
-0.7047924995,
0.3027405441,
0.8266476989,
0.1870564371,
-0.0822683573,
0.4594334364,
-0.3016569316,
0.6774230599,
0.1417835951,
-0.408397764,
0.522051394,
0.386549145,
-0.1615555584,
0.0702410638,
0.7107346654,
0.4036286473,
0.3495065272,
-0.0048135263,
-0.3544839025,
-0.2569946945,
0.1147371158,
-0.811211288,
0.1942582279,
-0.0142375985,
-0.639495492,
-0.6167218089,
0.0612448081,
-0.7849552631,
-0.203057155,
-0.0929075703,
0.3854274452,
-0.0646693707,
-0.2208894789,
0.2078544647,
-0.0801804662,
0.2027478367,
0.0615921728,
-1.1763417721,
0.3055413365,
0.6003254652,
0.6561825275,
-0.2081266046,
-0.4055139422,
-0.7436294556,
0.1344216317,
-0.3944256008,
0.5842359662,
-0.4160754979,
-0.3907223344,
0.1436962783,
-0.2787471712,
0.1418479383,
-0.534419179,
0.5030221939,
-0.5675022006,
0.4113455713,
-0.4039036036,
-0.5115795732,
0.0988423303,
0.4306341708,
-0.669737339,
1.1929652691,
0.1918997914,
-0.7489829659,
0.4155170023,
-0.6861053705,
-0.3557680547,
-0.1950286627,
-0.0538850687,
-0.7281018496,
0.0145579549,
0.1528906822,
0.080451943,
-0.1445643306,
0.1937480718,
-0.6803108454,
-0.5896764994,
0.1403182149,
-0.1906191707,
0.4930490851,
0.0281960033,
-0.3655641973,
0.2145749778,
-0.8561131358,
0.0955068097,
0.2749528885,
-0.4465922415,
-0.4704204798,
0.0391730741,
-0.1792508513,
0.2355667204,
0.1587898731,
-0.6430217624,
0.443838805,
-0.6075959206,
0.2898100317,
0.9468510151,
-0.0586673655,
0.5827611089,
-0.286896944,
0.7669133544,
-0.3890189826,
0.4770511687,
0.5516982079,
-0.4732951224,
-0.291395694,
0.0205384884,
0.3056824207,
0.5501120687,
-0.7506426573,
0.605410099,
-0.1250901371,
-0.0556422994,
-0.4201698899,
0.0619390123,
0.347324729,
0.8303939104,
0.2778404653,
-0.2769885659,
-0.3963622749,
-0.710493505,
0.1342347711,
-0.2946821153,
0.046735581,
0.4936110079,
0.1481821537,
-0.012803725,
0.9981040955,
-0.9518592358,
-0.3568641543,
-0.4044753015,
-0.0658161268,
0.0171174295,
0.1724137515,
0.3513323367,
-0.5886847973,
-0.2992009223,
-0.2118199468,
-0.3364710808,
-0.2174564898,
0.2290156186,
-0.2422297895,
0.3193140328,
0.075249508,
-0.4791171849,
0.2107286602,
0.6346629858,
-0.256323576,
0.454152137,
-0.6744360924,
0.0346275903,
-0.6661071777,
-0.0515805557,
-0.0263446793,
-0.1852829158,
-0.2356165051,
-0.155053243,
-0.0313635394,
-0.0396788493,
-0.5517495871,
0.5269903541,
-0.1402622163,
-0.2864723206,
-0.4934833348,
0.0207100473,
0.1076093316,
0.934209764,
0.1347398907,
0.6778027415,
0.1877475679,
-0.4077784717,
0.337675482,
0.1489465237,
-0.1968505234,
0.3001894057,
-0.5279902816,
-0.1383833736,
-0.2002307624,
0.5611473918,
-0.463386178,
0.0370681733,
0.3131864071,
-0.1344848275,
0.1640438735,
0.0529310666,
-0.248161912,
-0.2022536397,
-0.8295866847,
0.4004064202,
0.6850364208,
-0.6262587905,
0.401917845,
0.4962221384,
0.2988097966,
-0.9549051523,
-0.2896218598,
-0.5241392851,
-0.4002890289,
-0.2692157328,
0.5222508311,
-0.0062026139,
-0.0178419463,
-0.215653047,
0.0536758862,
0.3531508446,
0.0123261465,
0.0580669045,
0.3482050002,
0.3098292351,
0.2056147158,
-0.1107527167,
-0.107047841,
-0.114386864,
-0.4108634293,
0.6879629493,
0.1917829365,
-0.1737959236,
-0.3623820245,
0.131645754,
0.1819308847,
-0.0708561838,
0.6523369551,
0.6957948208,
-0.0849935636,
-0.5382372141,
-0.2380463183,
-0.4987721741,
-0.4625799954,
0.4273647666,
-0.3167546391,
-0.6525262594,
0.1832962334,
-0.0525118373,
0.0349407494,
0.0776439086,
0.4770427048,
-0.1235610247,
1.1439521313,
0.7102546692,
-0.3663407564,
0.8165518641,
-0.2806005776,
0.0113757085,
-0.8312698603,
-0.2499847114,
-0.1403934807,
-0.424254477,
-0.6775245667,
-0.2167264819,
0.3813128471,
0.086904116,
-0.258221209,
0.080570057,
-0.4514184892,
0.2076508552,
0.5728301406,
0.2864657938,
0.1605606377,
0.1691065282,
-0.0893066451,
-0.0674574822,
-0.6902670264,
0.041368138,
1.2007027864,
0.39867571,
0.946662724,
-0.0762473941,
0.7175275683,
0.7364838719,
0.2917639315,
-0.8867654204,
0.3662786782,
-0.0252652876,
0.0977076739,
-0.5758730173,
-0.7240256667,
-0.8813794255,
0.5120762587,
-0.2059196532,
-0.3876029849,
0.2264059484,
0.5996974707,
-0.2599681616,
0.1813897043,
-0.4928203225,
0.5654855371,
-0.1808837205,
-0.3049596846,
-0.3851683736,
-0.5552031398,
0.3360018134,
0.3179459572,
0.2627691329,
-0.2317126244,
-0.2812455893,
0.880910635,
-0.7468194962,
0.4556052387,
-0.5326094031,
-0.4122443497,
0.2168013752,
-0.4192000628,
0.8980636597,
-0.0156774782,
-0.1363604814,
-0.1313257664,
-0.2599791586,
-0.4293993413,
-0.6928606629,
0.526802659,
-0.9977448583,
-0.3281759024,
-0.3925663531,
-0.4599624574,
-0.5916926265,
-0.099271208,
0.2225546986,
0.3402044475,
-0.1079462618,
-0.1501844376,
0.7024338841,
-0.0995218977,
0.519764185,
0.4231049716,
-0.2212436199,
-0.6835398674,
0.9909802079,
-0.1222996935,
0.4089394808,
0.5801789761,
0.8667662144,
-0.547183454,
-0.18555969,
-0.6378276944,
0.2312122285,
-0.4414964616,
-0.1854498237,
-0.3371287286,
0.2248216122,
-0.3993689418,
0.0783349127,
-0.3511260152,
-0.5358375907,
0.0659030899,
-0.046322301,
0.2785786688,
0.3399974108,
-0.0441266857,
0.3723675609,
-0.2413380593,
0.1430397779,
0.3362658322,
0.3482739329,
0.2420511544,
-0.5842745304,
-0.1258139908,
-0.0022583278,
-0.5243875384,
-0.763243854,
0.3110546172,
0.3294680119,
0.3995646536,
0.6032087207,
0.1270163655,
0.6229852438,
-0.4017060399,
0.2232078314,
0.2437083125,
-0.7117527127,
0.500354588,
-0.1120949164,
0.1580695212,
0.4962257743,
0.210543409,
-0.3694708049,
-0.0032230522,
-0.6413335204,
-0.6510961056,
0.7839257121,
-0.103128776,
-0.0979175121,
0.300034076,
0.4081617594,
-0.0775093362,
0.2805193365,
-0.7961981893,
-0.1496323645,
-0.164560169,
-0.1258459538,
0.2775798142,
-0.1077950075,
-0.1747752726,
0.0016370851,
0.9972746372,
-0.455217272,
-0.1426121145,
0.0586703718,
0.0950142965,
-0.2364724427,
0.1968530566,
0.7758308649,
0.6137570143,
-0.4023454785,
-0.1435468495,
0.2934411168,
-0.5625556707,
0.2984368503,
-0.0972704366,
-0.3951197565,
-0.4399235249,
0.3629997373,
0.8960773945,
0.2283274084,
-0.9758392572,
0.6479634643,
-0.0160258804,
-0.2304526567,
-0.0586181991,
0.0405941084,
-0.1256117076,
0.0085177226,
0.2815746069,
-0.1419705898,
0.0323852897,
-0.5465986729,
0.2672028244,
0.5767078996,
-0.4455153942,
-0.1424684972,
0.2794428766,
0.208900854,
-0.2068304867,
0.2137910873,
-0.3934258819,
-0.5867271423,
0.5520861149,
0.7210279703,
0.3674939275,
-0.167579934,
0.3988448977,
0.2862369716,
0.0870841518,
-0.3545095623,
0.3546636701,
-0.2856759429,
-0.8698374629,
-0.383510232,
-0.7310345173,
-0.5342251062,
-0.0471200868,
-0.8285696507,
0.2913348973,
-0.5801640153,
-0.2019558549,
-0.4942289293,
0.3430110216,
-0.2614851296,
0.0754894838,
-0.0100620249,
0.6290089488,
-0.9411309958,
1.0715544224,
0.4458602965,
-0.2394257337,
-0.8161293864,
0.200507611,
-0.2134418786,
-1.2254880667,
0.3965867162,
-0.1193994731,
-0.1582065672,
0.0188815445,
-0.1212120652,
-0.8294785023,
1.1254148483,
0.3653143644,
-0.5683615804,
0.084005855,
-0.0334131084,
0.2768830955,
-0.4035931528,
0.371049881,
0.5886340141,
0.4745344222,
0.1822781116,
-0.6412416697,
0.1039076671,
0.4348601699,
0.201978147,
0.3457584083,
-0.9973880053,
0.4487839341,
-0.457047224,
0.2550749481,
-0.3390772045,
0.7425320148,
0.8366427422,
-0.0402481556,
0.9903976917,
0.9441191554,
0.588003397,
0.265955627,
0.9438463449,
0.0906539634,
0.5376362205,
0.9082997441,
-0.6996700764,
1.0473089218,
0.6850676537,
-0.4282908738,
0.5551298857,
0.6843078732,
0.0220094789,
1.0673505068,
0.5319702029,
-0.2204265594,
-0.1097189933,
-0.3429303765,
-0.2287866026,
0.4040920138,
-0.1292142421,
0.0475051887,
-0.1053219959,
0.2975206077,
0.104191795,
0.1401045322,
-0.2420569211,
0.8124405742,
-0.1232430413,
-0.9410399199,
0.5496825576,
0.2063451856,
1.0349434614,
-0.8575654626,
-0.1527327597,
-0.2703333795,
0.3107088506,
-0.149297595,
-0.3674302399,
0.021970408,
-0.3950682878,
-0.2563807368,
-0.2103277296,
0.5828170776,
-0.6071299911,
-0.3599903286,
0.5709474087,
0.0993177369,
-0.3075005114,
0.1927118897,
-0.776388824,
0.1926746219,
0.0801073536,
-0.5336550474,
0.5338667631,
0.1064040959,
-0.2661384046,
0.7391863465,
0.7202840447,
0.5382831693,
-0.1666207612,
0.5675483942,
0.4929752052,
-0.36248523,
-0.912394464,
-0.7940474153,
-0.0698827282,
-0.1606859118,
-0.3314248919,
0.2790756822,
0.4658241272,
0.7604520321,
-0.0036763989,
0.5751861334,
-0.1370891631,
0.2572154105,
-0.5168072581,
0.6305772662,
-0.7076079845,
0.1469451487,
-0.0439710841,
-0.8987472653,
0.1973353177,
0.4611265361,
-0.0289814025,
0.1005580872,
0.5554512739,
0.8379480243,
-0.0004251579,
-0.2501653731,
0.3967575431,
-0.3326576948,
0.2398353517,
0.7051426768,
0.6219992042,
-0.2860023379,
0.6867620349,
-0.4379842579,
-0.6121556163,
-0.2075704187,
-1.0014623404,
-0.6349068284,
-0.2915469706,
-0.136322096,
-0.2612188756,
0.0897089839,
1.1534190178,
0.9929119945,
-0.5259135365,
-0.2837331891,
-0.0077912286,
0.3070391417,
-0.5130471587,
-0.2646304965,
0.4975627959,
-0.2471467257,
-0.6033086181,
0.3006364703,
0.1814343184,
-0.106585227,
-0.5225141048,
-0.5603770614,
-0.0444008,
0.1446672529,
0.5262854099,
0.3966174126,
-0.6710347533,
-0.262306571,
-0.3218572736,
-0.0013383795,
-0.042404931,
0.9986323714,
-0.7671320438,
0.0836132467,
0.5752739906,
0.6016172171,
0.4411328435,
0.2895431221,
0.5980622768,
-0.9108113647,
0.4914517701,
0.0877550915,
0.4280949831,
0.2354503572,
-0.5247745514,
0.3821027875,
0.3750549257,
-0.5085811019,
-0.8092132807,
0.220233351,
-0.9069705606,
-0.2186155468,
1.0749797821,
-0.0699450672,
-0.1933419704,
0.3460054994,
-0.0003671183,
0.0913517252,
-0.7313418984,
1.0081107616,
0.5340582728,
-0.4596790671,
-0.1823084056,
-0.5120877028,
0.7895234227,
0.6602219939,
-0.9618287086,
-0.0331055559,
0.1372535676,
0.3305829465,
-0.2204728127,
0.8854861856,
0.1563373953,
0.1627840847,
-0.3821647167,
0.2147879303,
-0.253739059,
-0.2257400751,
-0.2234605104,
0.2520728111,
0.1509893388,
-0.4339666963
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11823v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11823v1 | On Efficient Language and Vision Assistants for Visually-Situated Natural Language Understanding: What Matters in Reading and Reasoning | 2024-06-17T17:57:30 | 2024-06-17T17:57:30 | Geewook Kim, Minjoon Seo | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Recent advancements in language and vision assistants have showcased
impressive capabilities but suffer from a lack of transparency, limiting
broader research and reproducibility. While open-source models handle general
image tasks effectively, they face challenges with the high computational
demands of complex visually-situated text understanding. Such tasks often
require increased token inputs and large vision modules to harness
high-resolution information. Striking a balance between model size and data
importance remains an open question. This study aims to redefine the design of
vision-language models by identifying key components and creating efficient
models with constrained inference costs. By strategically formulating datasets,
optimizing vision modules, and enhancing supervision techniques, we achieve
significant improvements in inference throughput while maintaining high
performance. Extensive experiments across models ranging from 160M to 13B
parameters offer insights into model optimization. We will fully open-source
our codebase, models, and datasets at https://github.com/naver-ai/elva . | [
-0.3343245089,
-0.7828989625,
0.7317690849,
0.1428331435,
-0.1788650304,
-0.4217170477,
-0.1765421778,
-0.8807255626,
-0.2160582989,
0.6916503906,
-0.2531569004,
-0.4110023975,
-0.3972657323,
0.0441649072,
-0.2379053682,
0.3672687113,
-0.1019203067,
-0.0509970896,
-0.436771512,
-0.4077116251,
-0.3172824979,
-0.0208582208,
-0.4858094752,
0.0274810363,
0.5548657179,
0.3723556697,
0.7066697478,
0.9652898908,
0.6399798393,
0.3767745495,
-0.2174279988,
0.3724780381,
-0.1762095243,
0.0594407506,
-0.2585027218,
-0.4584294856,
-0.3959690034,
-0.1853867769,
0.538880229,
0.8089035749,
-0.0150760403,
0.155705899,
0.1282776296,
0.8410784006,
-1.0257273912,
0.4920834303,
-0.3534249067,
-0.1943261474,
-0.0625222549,
0.08533369,
-0.6811048985,
-0.1637932062,
0.5048045516,
-1.1828862429,
0.2384295315,
0.2089338601,
0.887341857,
0.5762749314,
-0.2932762206,
-0.1441820264,
-0.56242311,
0.7881627083,
-0.3877389431,
0.6923054457,
0.5182650685,
0.2452725172,
0.2337659597,
-0.5252656341,
-0.47815907,
0.0085256267,
-0.1894252747,
0.10102126,
-0.3311645091,
0.2555888295,
0.1328155994,
0.1358620822,
-0.6068825722,
0.0326877981,
-0.423230499,
0.1410827339,
0.3437891603,
-0.0528834574,
0.3952646255,
-0.2419868261,
0.0395180024,
-0.1658119261,
-0.3815062344,
-0.1552744806,
0.1910445839,
0.0399316922,
-0.1422517896,
0.641946137,
-0.3295091689,
1.1838899851,
-0.1729940772,
0.0320966356,
0.1477457434,
-0.6556427479,
-0.4254908562,
-0.3498620689,
0.3436794281,
0.3299486339,
0.4682920277,
-0.138868168,
-0.0222967174,
0.1035857126,
0.4690715969,
-0.5377779603,
-0.2714320719,
0.1916367114,
-0.3388309777,
-0.2030486763,
-0.0920395106,
-0.8032456636,
-0.510841608,
-0.7251161337,
0.6059315801,
-0.2772951126,
-0.039801944,
0.3010991216,
-0.2196499109,
0.265902102,
0.7279619575,
-0.9297536016,
0.1343462318,
0.402615875,
0.7656039,
-0.0059107663,
-0.0677591488,
-0.5873653293,
0.2231595516,
-0.388910681,
0.6016969085,
-0.5937260389,
-0.0689245984,
-0.1274350882,
-0.0916649774,
-0.3763167858,
-0.3052004874,
0.5216189623,
-0.4464276433,
0.2041099966,
0.0206382498,
-0.3693407774,
-0.2777867615,
0.1221434176,
-1.0255124569,
0.656450808,
-0.1487996578,
-0.7667202353,
0.4318542182,
-0.8289664984,
-0.3896482885,
0.1111903861,
-0.2097243071,
-0.2905710936,
0.301489532,
0.7445786595,
0.3186960816,
-0.1437274814,
0.1465710998,
0.0216001328,
-0.3286546767,
-0.1034092978,
-0.3607290089,
0.7097755075,
0.1316584051,
-0.2906249464,
0.2352154702,
-0.8848994374,
-0.1747790426,
0.14687033,
-0.3051427305,
-0.7800190449,
0.3005414307,
0.0311548728,
-0.4022870362,
0.2005532831,
-0.5132057667,
-0.1160361171,
-0.5316880345,
0.2555441856,
0.605815649,
-0.2794960439,
0.9123240709,
0.2936606407,
0.4760448635,
-0.1921679974,
0.5254431963,
-0.2737891972,
-0.4204646945,
-0.8996810317,
-0.6205128431,
0.0714385435,
0.4859461486,
-1.0565716028,
0.104073748,
-0.1375766397,
-0.3514074385,
-0.7927407622,
0.0476208664,
0.5018479824,
0.7121668458,
0.3769856989,
0.0019470806,
-0.2536119521,
-0.9570562243,
-0.3632994592,
-0.1974350512,
0.0260799248,
0.5360494256,
0.3602615893,
-0.1921334565,
0.8146746755,
-0.5315359831,
-0.0900354311,
-0.3195488155,
-0.1251639873,
0.0727365464,
0.2729319036,
0.5634977818,
-1.1252845526,
-0.3241065443,
0.3927991986,
-0.7896066308,
-0.3791428506,
-0.1678811759,
-0.338119179,
0.3132088184,
0.4781826735,
-0.5221956968,
0.7587396502,
0.7328038216,
-0.4610096216,
0.370665282,
-0.3617962897,
0.0458054617,
-0.7619732618,
0.1703870296,
0.336263895,
-0.1069045663,
-0.6553949714,
0.4212297797,
0.2087267786,
-0.0332935974,
-0.3089076877,
0.6919364333,
-0.764724791,
-0.1036779061,
0.0303601474,
0.3043819964,
0.4738272727,
0.5310029387,
0.2303135246,
0.8207172751,
0.5606498122,
-0.4951258898,
-0.0058612511,
0.3151766658,
-0.5309356451,
0.4836111963,
-0.868792057,
-0.1641062647,
-0.2211890221,
-0.1921719611,
-0.7522186637,
-0.3289208412,
0.291063875,
-0.1838530153,
0.220365718,
-0.1294098645,
-0.4485256076,
-0.0000636763,
-0.1271398962,
0.4418311119,
0.205551222,
-0.9243912101,
1.1109426022,
0.5272455812,
-0.0044899951,
-0.5727382302,
-0.7635466456,
-0.0799269676,
-0.0223778505,
-0.7294294238,
0.1307656616,
0.2517165244,
-0.6145446897,
0.0515210629,
-0.0918310732,
-0.1579614431,
-0.073872678,
0.1395546645,
0.3827863932,
-0.0954683051,
0.3652848601,
0.0146107096,
-0.1245397553,
-0.2222580165,
-0.3189589381,
-0.0168866348,
-0.2715914845,
-0.4615648985,
-0.4970553517,
0.4485658705,
0.6807300448,
-0.7417629957,
0.7982437015,
0.2978980839,
-0.2625560462,
-0.2330930531,
-0.440073818,
0.2124773711,
-0.4765484631,
0.5222886205,
-0.3444561064,
-0.6989855766,
0.2067521513,
0.3053133786,
0.3355942369,
0.1778887808,
0.3346544504,
-0.0133168679,
1.0113259554,
0.6103524566,
0.4257112443,
0.7760528326,
0.0676863045,
0.2668749988,
-0.6624577045,
-0.3622429073,
-0.432928592,
0.036643263,
-0.3189715445,
-0.7626487613,
0.3683734536,
-0.2048037052,
-0.00535892,
0.2733546793,
-0.6302433014,
0.7295325994,
0.7414792776,
0.2578016818,
0.4432225823,
-0.0110860132,
0.0033510646,
0.0308996513,
-0.7656912208,
-0.5629422069,
0.8939806819,
0.357719034,
0.9692723751,
0.2707298398,
0.2042488456,
-0.0658040568,
-0.170881018,
-0.8045194745,
0.5274766088,
-0.1739252061,
-0.5065498948,
-0.4261286855,
-0.3920820653,
-0.8889488578,
0.5937785506,
-0.0619764961,
-0.6503608823,
0.5761173368,
0.3704827428,
0.0343757607,
0.2040608823,
-1.2816463709,
1.0634617805,
-0.0611581132,
-0.5328193307,
-0.2902302742,
-0.6204930544,
0.2311018407,
-0.0137623884,
0.1292972118,
0.2163579762,
-0.196823433,
0.4007827044,
-0.2916553617,
0.9260874391,
-0.0176788941,
-0.0495758653,
0.3975312114,
-0.1010744646,
0.2420704216,
-0.1519771665,
-0.1437883377,
0.1249607503,
-0.0314211994,
-0.5444129109,
-0.5806829929,
0.371288687,
-0.627951026,
-0.3716413677,
-0.1267047226,
-0.5111683011,
0.0551805869,
0.1608114243,
0.0216242578,
0.8342702389,
-0.1001757979,
0.4093040228,
0.9200826287,
-0.4318569601,
0.1942099035,
0.3042227626,
-0.2216704488,
-0.1128122658,
0.8223825097,
0.0680891424,
0.5084387064,
0.63344419,
0.0085518397,
-0.3415126503,
-0.4621626139,
-0.6065796018,
0.2320691794,
-0.8774176836,
0.2424300313,
-0.5927475691,
0.1536521018,
-0.2832050622,
-0.234354645,
-0.3023752868,
-0.2790678144,
-0.4654710293,
-0.110627085,
0.3859345019,
0.5478320718,
-0.0140158646,
0.2497344762,
-0.4213121235,
0.5272149444,
0.3478529453,
0.3689569831,
0.1216393113,
-0.2302586883,
-0.3594214022,
-0.3033629954,
0.2030458301,
-0.7678593993,
0.3967184126,
0.2158915401,
0.577481389,
0.3665055335,
-0.1000489965,
0.5452390313,
-0.4764535725,
0.4154205918,
-0.0275662933,
-0.8613730073,
0.7077898979,
-0.2411230057,
0.5940940976,
0.4787881672,
-0.0407314301,
-0.163073197,
-0.3584380448,
-0.2250322104,
-0.8325363398,
0.6071455479,
0.3018190563,
-0.3367055058,
0.0820028707,
0.2556311488,
-0.0284472089,
-0.0957929865,
-0.429666698,
0.1774001867,
-0.2244426757,
-0.4708753526,
0.0326291174,
0.0100408532,
0.1295179129,
-0.5324581265,
0.4903271496,
-0.3030779362,
0.0000951009,
0.36568892,
-0.3475019634,
0.2684325278,
0.1129982471,
0.3238520026,
0.707480967,
0.0602833442,
0.1666497439,
0.0457877293,
-0.7536604404,
-0.3166882992,
0.0385840088,
-0.2586576045,
-0.0035112763,
0.4984081984,
0.9950649142,
0.1665888578,
-0.985807538,
0.3788904548,
-0.3248584867,
-0.1668372899,
-0.0007145618,
0.3264784217,
0.1050773859,
0.3557462096,
0.0625055879,
0.1678504795,
0.1134582236,
-0.315964967,
-0.1466776431,
0.1720523536,
-0.1627669781,
-0.0742765665,
0.7062046528,
0.4119167328,
-0.1194258183,
0.5681595206,
0.1780474484,
-0.1753358096,
0.6043940187,
0.0615032427,
0.630176127,
0.1496260017,
0.2804035842,
0.2376722395,
0.4260704517,
-0.0229746792,
0.132499069,
-0.3416926265,
-0.7324485779,
-0.6477282047,
-0.5967447162,
-0.6077247262,
-0.3166065216,
-0.7392068505,
0.0754370242,
-0.225019142,
0.0810288861,
0.0697189718,
-0.1780360341,
-0.6187805533,
0.2660868764,
-0.0120738298,
1.0036745071,
-0.7110795379,
0.6475576162,
0.5551944375,
-0.4357412457,
-0.6453848481,
-0.2165217102,
-0.129414618,
-0.6551501155,
0.3183794916,
0.154181242,
-0.3813738525,
0.001630759,
-0.7099258304,
-0.6114509702,
0.9197496772,
0.4597619176,
-0.6538987756,
-0.1885494888,
-0.2543743849,
0.594180584,
-0.1076038629,
0.0769939497,
0.5241811275,
0.4476656616,
0.0226460863,
-0.7391747236,
-0.3087479174,
-0.3119303584,
-0.0812195987,
0.3110482991,
-0.3723376393,
0.5629686713,
-0.3140114546,
-0.1538902074,
0.129450202,
0.5042229295,
0.2643739879,
0.2728324533,
0.4443576336,
0.5735538602,
0.7848848104,
-0.0061252974,
1.2476160526,
0.0356938168,
-0.0129119027,
1.097474575,
-0.0325868987,
0.8559758663,
0.692799747,
0.221820876,
0.3064321578,
0.4500385821,
0.0801159292,
0.4577655792,
-0.2208849937,
-0.2325164527,
-0.3579812646,
-0.1761073023,
0.1111883149,
0.4908864796,
0.3542903364,
-0.4437609613,
-0.0105294185,
-0.0748575851,
-0.4119538665,
0.2687324882,
-0.309766084,
0.6393746734,
-0.0570679046,
-0.5792239904,
0.1617457122,
-0.2376872897,
0.2586042285,
-0.441098094,
-0.082716547,
-0.0212107655,
0.3795555234,
-0.0337513536,
-0.8009755611,
0.2789713144,
0.30646649,
-0.16457057,
-0.2112246603,
0.7483958602,
-0.2773011625,
-0.5391266942,
0.3200207055,
0.5573426485,
0.1379148513,
-0.1439622939,
-0.4567489326,
0.2017961442,
-0.0499950126,
-0.3763180971,
-0.0126684308,
0.5103988647,
-0.15243949,
0.7268657088,
0.6010299921,
0.1128795445,
0.1324812323,
0.4106267989,
0.6188641787,
-0.3952171504,
-0.4496789873,
-0.6668334603,
0.5943213105,
-0.2190638036,
-0.3777470589,
0.5569909215,
0.3725384176,
0.6688061357,
-0.0711782202,
0.4640710354,
0.1298962682,
0.3655090332,
-0.5979762077,
0.7666620612,
-0.8811041713,
0.0669539571,
-0.430354178,
-0.7733944058,
-0.6419149637,
0.8448559046,
-0.4762032032,
-0.1894084364,
0.3546433449,
0.7737496495,
-0.1107402146,
0.0736993253,
0.2574437857,
0.0570762157,
0.3295850158,
0.4442548454,
0.4969176948,
-0.2096368819,
0.6037279963,
-0.0074538887,
-0.3043033481,
-0.2192796618,
-0.7431657314,
-0.9025985003,
-0.4900411367,
-0.3693102598,
0.1848371327,
0.1351868361,
0.4500630498,
0.7901315689,
-0.3407370448,
0.1660230458,
-0.5222122669,
0.1911102831,
-0.0632867068,
-0.2012626082,
0.4951627254,
-0.018889932,
-0.9669625759,
0.2976673543,
0.5099260807,
0.0770674199,
-0.3625625074,
-0.0994800627,
-0.3091141284,
0.3303436935,
0.7792131901,
0.281439513,
-0.8479425311,
-0.2497786731,
0.1149241552,
-0.2139819711,
-0.059710063,
0.2111284882,
-0.7427953482,
0.9682949781,
0.8101205826,
0.9399467707,
0.469155699,
0.1502566189,
0.7021782994,
-0.6041887999,
0.2048363239,
0.0626767874,
0.4369029999,
0.4446482956,
-0.2678478956,
0.7986005545,
0.0365661755,
-0.4219369888,
-0.7160379887,
0.1969477832,
-1.0212898254,
-0.5413253903,
0.9653656483,
0.0197097622,
-0.7048165798,
-0.083788529,
-0.5168355703,
0.1600469351,
-0.0999101251,
0.3649860322,
0.5299633741,
-0.1342497021,
-0.5321858525,
-0.6699066758,
0.1397689879,
0.4416232407,
-0.9170069695,
0.1563539356,
0.6356408,
-0.1836752594,
0.0535317212,
0.3220525384,
-0.0239137281,
0.3848130405,
0.2198996842,
0.1037272662,
0.0182523634,
-0.6917595863,
-0.3259066343,
0.0351046026,
-0.1997244805,
-0.4370802939
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11817v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11817v1 | Iterative Length-Regularized Direct Preference Optimization: A Case Study on Improving 7B Language Models to GPT-4 Level | 2024-06-17T17:55:38 | 2024-06-17T17:55:38 | Jie Liu, Zhanhui Zhou, Jiaheng Liu, Xingyuan Bu, Chao Yang, Han-Sen Zhong, Wanli Ouyang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Direct Preference Optimization (DPO), a standard method for aligning language
models with human preferences, is traditionally applied to offline preferences.
Recent studies show that DPO benefits from iterative training with online
preferences labeled by a trained reward model. In this work, we identify a
pitfall of vanilla iterative DPO - improved response quality can lead to
increased verbosity. To address this, we introduce iterative length-regularized
DPO (iLR-DPO) to penalize response length. Our empirical results show that
iLR-DPO can enhance a 7B model to perform on par with GPT-4 without increasing
verbosity. Specifically, our 7B model achieves a $50.5\%$ length-controlled win
rate against $\texttt{GPT-4 Preview}$ on AlpacaEval 2.0, and excels across
standard benchmarks including MT-Bench, Arena-Hard and OpenLLM Leaderboard.
These results demonstrate the effectiveness of iterative DPO in aligning
language models with human feedback. | [
-0.5024197102,
-0.5372958779,
0.5965969563,
0.2714615464,
-0.5068619847,
0.1008839533,
-0.5138687491,
-0.4407788217,
0.1471280605,
0.3431422114,
-0.3066658378,
-0.2738823593,
-0.6721900702,
0.3916147649,
0.1518636793,
0.7339923978,
-0.0996401012,
-0.074196443,
-0.0159733985,
0.190604642,
-0.7435845137,
-0.4232502878,
-0.7507255673,
-0.2296191007,
0.5648764968,
0.6344708204,
0.8243495226,
1.0095272064,
0.6846824288,
0.2601231039,
-0.1201493144,
0.0376445279,
-0.7474087477,
-0.0635360405,
0.0744122714,
-0.2076801807,
-0.5917586088,
0.0083813304,
0.6813440919,
0.5871738791,
-0.5215754509,
-0.1158261225,
-0.0334446803,
0.9446902275,
-0.4171880484,
0.2196517438,
-0.6723368168,
-0.0736568198,
-0.1310274154,
-0.3255755305,
-0.3454591334,
-0.5721185207,
0.334448427,
-0.6231735945,
0.2609494627,
0.0599556044,
1.0153723955,
0.4360079169,
-0.0964980349,
-0.3016365469,
-0.7756346464,
0.7025680542,
-0.9842352867,
0.393942982,
0.5400910974,
0.3164891601,
-0.1809242368,
-0.3002835214,
-0.5060277581,
-0.6290528178,
0.1005061716,
0.1547016054,
0.0244431086,
0.5274378061,
0.1787814051,
0.5114864111,
-0.4681013525,
0.3249438405,
-0.6591333151,
0.0462776087,
0.5739767551,
-0.0100762388,
-0.1994345784,
-0.0192586333,
-0.0909978375,
-0.0890391469,
-0.5491381288,
0.3454160988,
0.7798841596,
0.4001412094,
0.2776025236,
0.4765884876,
-0.5409449339,
1.0665307045,
0.4401344359,
-0.4224616587,
0.0317978263,
-0.1155962273,
0.1413341612,
0.2410560101,
0.5511585474,
0.6099728346,
0.1942523867,
-0.2460199296,
-0.2316068709,
0.349691242,
0.253757298,
-0.9112635255,
0.0612561889,
0.2594501674,
-0.3302600384,
-0.293820411,
-0.1051817238,
-0.7099722028,
-0.1804047823,
-0.3922868669,
0.3317693472,
-0.270953387,
-0.1980753988,
0.5172027349,
-0.0762522891,
0.0060452339,
0.2375565469,
-1.1343861818,
0.5148200989,
0.5266065001,
0.814514637,
-0.3812756836,
-0.1545005143,
-0.6311805844,
-0.0575429723,
-0.4389809668,
0.7072765231,
-0.7074750066,
-0.4655868113,
-0.1675362885,
-0.5483518839,
0.027341105,
-0.5216729045,
0.752823174,
-0.4682691693,
0.3342751563,
-0.25491485,
-0.5959357619,
0.0267095454,
0.3576826453,
-0.6882435679,
0.973682344,
-0.1079887226,
-0.6669845581,
0.4285092354,
-0.6745377779,
-0.1166428924,
-0.214879021,
-0.1120300293,
-0.4354890883,
0.3295888305,
0.1765310317,
0.1707750112,
-0.3941308856,
0.5059352517,
-0.3887393773,
-0.7089251876,
-0.1012973338,
-0.1571712345,
0.1157816872,
0.1674271524,
-0.6455623507,
0.2893617749,
-0.857940197,
0.0143758887,
0.083483845,
-0.6424886584,
-0.1875490248,
-0.0012673677,
-0.6005322337,
0.2027183771,
0.2137455195,
-0.660323143,
0.5995599627,
-0.700642705,
0.2156632245,
1.0581823587,
-0.3953257203,
0.6094971895,
-0.1740581542,
0.5031983256,
-0.2441778183,
0.5407099724,
0.4379354715,
-0.4709640741,
-0.7750245929,
-0.4263004363,
0.3640643358,
0.1475225687,
-0.6298123002,
0.4889518917,
-0.4195123911,
-0.369866401,
-0.5841773748,
0.0626578107,
0.1725733578,
0.688860774,
0.465634197,
-0.332769841,
-0.2173288465,
-0.9870500565,
-0.0030155729,
-0.1619294137,
0.0691386238,
0.3030359745,
-0.1215595528,
-0.1665489078,
1.0598366261,
-0.6017130613,
-0.3394670188,
-0.2885857522,
-0.1462757289,
0.2595542967,
0.1581334025,
0.6192538142,
-0.511095345,
-0.5928955078,
-0.234879747,
-0.1359249353,
-0.2853501141,
0.3527268469,
0.0407164134,
0.2585855722,
-0.334474504,
-0.3742825389,
0.4336951971,
0.6566329598,
-0.2033879757,
0.1626163423,
-0.319465518,
0.4498911798,
-0.7965340614,
-0.0715150982,
-0.1585013568,
-0.0160888284,
-0.5292950273,
-0.2910748124,
0.032684911,
-0.150451228,
-0.127617076,
0.63830024,
-0.5315874815,
-0.2083519548,
-0.5543904305,
0.1878639013,
0.1128272042,
0.5119401217,
0.2521996796,
0.5747842193,
0.3293886781,
-0.6955935359,
0.3655944765,
0.2021104842,
0.0576522239,
0.1838483512,
-0.6712027192,
0.3849955797,
-0.1752577573,
0.1699534655,
-0.9006996751,
-0.1007981449,
0.1934157014,
-0.3644449413,
0.389341265,
-0.1388255954,
-0.3732011616,
-0.4184455276,
-0.6930676103,
0.3020904958,
0.5021092296,
-0.5216910243,
0.3344567716,
-0.0637349635,
-0.2178090811,
-0.7368841767,
0.0016612693,
-0.0225602947,
-0.3487745225,
-0.7060374022,
0.428914547,
-0.4192555547,
-0.1408755481,
-0.3821364343,
-0.1710054427,
0.0002297261,
0.041344326,
-0.0683252141,
0.1644576341,
0.0995742455,
0.0025615136,
0.0529351383,
-0.0211925469,
-0.4295935035,
-0.086323157,
0.7055929303,
-0.2335194498,
-0.0726474598,
-0.4866544306,
0.4198430181,
0.0160611998,
-0.1570804417,
0.3954837918,
0.2167114168,
-0.170315817,
0.1228471175,
-0.8090612888,
-0.4243472815,
-0.4954151213,
0.1600984335,
-0.6995407939,
-0.9131245613,
0.3343628943,
0.1456036866,
-0.0780807883,
0.3329896033,
0.4111612439,
0.4453627765,
1.2608497143,
0.8997499347,
-0.0714049041,
0.6931474805,
-0.0573135354,
0.091771394,
-0.4309540391,
-0.072556667,
-0.4945507944,
-0.2423947603,
-0.5415215492,
-0.15396218,
0.1799032539,
0.194739759,
-0.1868483424,
0.1655717641,
-0.6686669588,
0.3414633274,
0.437377423,
0.2513353527,
0.5108488202,
0.0341854319,
-0.0401538648,
-0.1772780716,
-0.7035095692,
-0.3832146525,
0.8675358295,
0.4811490476,
1.0093044043,
0.3571666777,
0.7574430704,
0.1652745605,
0.2764613628,
-0.9360386729,
0.2329486459,
0.0400668792,
-0.4160589576,
-0.2770797908,
-0.5218225121,
-0.9212462902,
-0.0934422463,
0.2035724819,
-0.7853271961,
0.2623520494,
0.6349797249,
-0.3639286458,
-0.0540791973,
-0.5895009041,
0.7127366662,
-0.372393012,
-0.5864127874,
-0.1456056833,
-0.7372415066,
0.1876958013,
0.0953315347,
-0.0506443083,
-0.3824266493,
-0.0965274796,
0.5770978332,
-0.4389448464,
0.5196550488,
-0.1914785206,
-0.1405369192,
0.0129091972,
0.0047895792,
0.6600345373,
0.0800117552,
-0.2277067006,
0.0108561115,
-0.2466488332,
-0.5055346489,
-0.4806750417,
0.9678952694,
-0.8950899243,
-0.9381946325,
-0.5198156238,
-0.2926869988,
-0.4567920268,
0.0842028782,
0.3713642061,
0.4450472593,
0.0733309835,
-0.0170517545,
0.6088600159,
-0.0716831163,
0.4676183164,
0.5148459673,
-0.1454764754,
-0.508559823,
0.6396383047,
-0.0056682169,
0.5635212064,
0.4033891559,
0.6832008958,
-0.6864232421,
-0.5998740196,
-0.5879783034,
0.2845623493,
-0.7030835748,
-0.187058121,
-0.4733071327,
0.3228375316,
-0.5493471622,
-0.0795645788,
-0.669238925,
-0.3928688467,
-0.1429603696,
-0.2068081945,
0.4557997882,
0.8014612198,
-0.0821357146,
0.3333451748,
-0.6142832041,
0.1479177326,
0.0737346932,
0.7639733553,
-0.2384193242,
-0.8428607583,
-0.0410041623,
-0.041841194,
-0.226725772,
-0.9071263671,
0.3579534292,
0.2594237924,
0.5780359507,
0.3247573078,
0.0119173527,
0.7057397962,
-0.5841189623,
0.5480853319,
0.1635269225,
-0.7630755305,
0.5844218135,
-0.42675969,
0.2359101027,
0.6055045128,
0.6289506555,
-0.3410945237,
0.0625419393,
-0.5171128511,
-0.8302276134,
0.510940969,
0.1881579757,
0.1016705185,
-0.1234255061,
0.6771607995,
0.2635219097,
0.4559088647,
-0.6389611959,
-0.1471102387,
-0.5394353271,
-0.1421794891,
0.0381689779,
-0.4773159325,
-0.1862937808,
-0.0610152818,
0.7437531352,
-0.3808649182,
0.333114028,
0.188864097,
0.0631591529,
-0.0124728857,
0.3563397825,
0.8004900813,
1.0817468166,
-0.5970332623,
-0.1758852899,
-0.2171201557,
-0.2647242546,
0.3187676668,
0.4285346568,
0.0708837733,
-0.0467014387,
-0.1227837503,
1.0566864014,
-0.2786444724,
-0.4652388096,
0.4880034029,
-0.3361429274,
0.0123610785,
0.0152200963,
-0.1979553699,
-0.1990177929,
-0.1112764552,
0.2870659828,
-0.268620342,
0.5344981551,
-0.4960389733,
-0.1275703758,
0.176187247,
-0.4240064919,
-0.2546429038,
0.6001397967,
0.4465497136,
0.0205152724,
0.2314285785,
-0.2072801739,
-0.4749470651,
0.4298831522,
0.5078305602,
0.5422421098,
-0.2740502357,
0.1196188033,
0.4781931937,
0.1034825593,
-0.5125111341,
0.130976215,
-0.0153179457,
-0.6533559561,
-0.5135771036,
-0.6377472281,
-0.5291005373,
0.0864237025,
-0.5426217318,
0.4315393865,
-0.6461670399,
-0.2688753605,
-0.1856441498,
0.1038532406,
-0.5950121284,
0.2065405101,
-0.0204909239,
0.5918009281,
-0.4811099768,
0.7037277222,
0.4156672359,
-0.5079812407,
-1.1121251583,
-0.0066057476,
-0.1744401753,
-0.5889671445,
0.6611258984,
0.2981606126,
-0.1147301719,
0.3089465797,
-0.1503054053,
-1.0181976557,
0.9840216637,
0.4425269663,
-0.8465872407,
0.0136194499,
0.1793351471,
0.4067611694,
-0.1993112564,
0.3179515898,
0.6381093264,
0.3765702248,
0.1224465519,
-1.266474843,
0.0563021973,
0.0771141648,
0.3129884899,
0.2648164928,
-0.9061542153,
0.5079830289,
-0.2778518498,
0.0989740416,
0.0838778913,
0.3669194579,
0.2372667938,
-0.1660515964,
0.5002698898,
0.5609155297,
0.6155429482,
-0.1532717496,
1.1163309813,
-0.2302468419,
0.468121171,
1.0568968058,
-0.4608591199,
0.5926587582,
0.5345702767,
0.042382732,
0.1783050448,
1.1275817156,
0.3973448575,
0.8245082498,
0.5194676518,
-0.2210426629,
-0.0770394057,
-0.1377516091,
-0.4556227028,
0.4520704448,
-0.1003628075,
0.0060480395,
0.0625293106,
0.0048959861,
0.224448964,
0.1877582073,
-0.2775267363,
0.869971633,
-0.2310555577,
-0.9170389771,
0.8308577538,
0.0732780397,
0.9382104278,
-0.6922909021,
0.0487805903,
-0.6919418573,
0.5023548007,
-0.01400619,
-0.3067080379,
0.0543576628,
-0.0708299205,
-0.2110482752,
0.0503033064,
0.6790313125,
-0.430205375,
-0.1577038467,
0.4183285832,
0.1167649254,
-0.1131570563,
-0.2636303902,
-0.6035715938,
0.3429050148,
-0.0128390128,
-0.5023610592,
0.3031388521,
0.1680320352,
-0.1637605131,
0.6008989215,
0.4559796453,
0.04018059,
0.0671791658,
0.2402624041,
1.0911138058,
-0.4898454547,
-0.4822107255,
-0.9392098784,
0.3310854733,
-0.3549022377,
-0.1917440444,
0.4802561402,
0.6026970148,
0.824375689,
-0.1145012677,
0.5916361809,
-0.0368868187,
0.505967617,
-0.535194993,
0.1187404394,
-0.5015592575,
0.3904236853,
-0.1733040363,
-1.0931588411,
-0.0685644895,
0.4962524176,
-0.3922168314,
0.114539139,
0.6897966862,
0.7125448585,
0.102287136,
-0.4670777619,
0.5336547494,
-0.0202564113,
0.4922057986,
0.3385690749,
0.6302915215,
-0.1609045565,
0.7479707003,
-0.4459355474,
-0.5473145247,
-0.2580084503,
-1.0309137106,
-0.8645994067,
-0.2518255711,
-0.1713629216,
-0.3288034499,
0.3414285779,
0.9877513051,
0.4485076666,
-0.3239922523,
-0.3279039264,
0.085113056,
-0.2312516272,
-0.0227366351,
-0.2687265277,
0.1827914417,
-0.3050540984,
-0.8232497573,
0.3362745345,
0.3023502231,
0.1130290106,
-0.0660816208,
-0.2571788728,
-0.1698258817,
0.0613600276,
0.3843026757,
0.1205625981,
-0.8787205219,
-0.5205612779,
0.3228627145,
-0.021402102,
0.4021905959,
0.7460157275,
-0.4223306179,
0.6678395271,
0.5069038868,
0.6188820004,
0.5834549665,
0.1776098013,
0.9407855272,
-0.7585451007,
0.3011777103,
0.3005459309,
0.3693300784,
0.6742300391,
-0.5339428186,
0.6012716889,
0.2719514668,
-0.6349287033,
-0.5164792538,
0.2352584749,
-1.0748091936,
-0.0585567057,
1.4438611269,
-0.1028624848,
0.1179863065,
0.2107492089,
-0.5447463989,
0.1266616434,
-0.8303273916,
1.192666769,
0.6056079268,
-0.3476978242,
-0.0982238129,
-0.5520807505,
0.9993053675,
0.297044605,
-0.8697865009,
-0.1001271904,
0.6419551373,
0.3519921005,
0.0910686105,
1.047593236,
0.0584621653,
0.1727916151,
-0.3007377386,
0.1742233336,
-0.1309472471,
-0.2433876842,
-0.1930979192,
-0.2066375762,
0.6599709988,
-0.1719023883
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11813v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11813v1 | How Do Large Language Models Acquire Factual Knowledge During Pretraining? | 2024-06-17T17:54:40 | 2024-06-17T17:54:40 | Hoyeon Chang, Jinho Park, Seonghyeon Ye, Sohee Yang, Youngkyung Seo, Du-Seong Chang, Minjoon Seo | cs.CL | cs.CL, I.2.7 | Despite the recent observation that large language models (LLMs) can store
substantial factual knowledge, there is a limited understanding of the
mechanisms of how they acquire factual knowledge through pretraining. This work
addresses this gap by studying how LLMs acquire factual knowledge during
pretraining. The findings reveal several important insights into the dynamics
of factual knowledge acquisition during pretraining. First, counterintuitively,
we observe that pretraining on more data shows no significant improvement in
the model's capability to acquire and maintain factual knowledge. Next, there
is a power-law relationship between training steps and forgetting of
memorization and generalization of factual knowledge, and LLMs trained with
duplicated training data exhibit faster forgetting. Third, training LLMs with
larger batch sizes can enhance the models' robustness to forgetting. Overall,
our observations suggest that factual knowledge acquisition in LLM pretraining
occurs by progressively increasing the probability of factual knowledge
presented in the pretraining data at each step. However, this increase is
diluted by subsequent forgetting. Based on this interpretation, we demonstrate
that we can provide plausible explanations for recently observed behaviors of
LLMs, such as the poor performance of LLMs on long-tail knowledge and the
benefits of deduplicating the pretraining corpus. | [
-0.2121628076,
-0.7334625721,
1.1433297396,
-0.297403127,
-0.2683446109,
0.0709572434,
-0.4163078368,
-0.3751306236,
-0.1421407908,
0.4586906731,
-0.4657430053,
-0.2206623107,
-0.8662829399,
-0.1930393875,
-0.2766146958,
1.2256603241,
0.0375459194,
0.0291926842,
-0.4664913416,
-0.071028471,
-0.4450412393,
-0.8249195218,
-0.3112812042,
-0.4793618321,
0.6826196313,
0.2292496711,
0.3643121421,
0.6131668687,
0.254555881,
0.2850070298,
-0.0269158389,
-0.1081737652,
-0.8982308507,
-0.0064088004,
-0.2255641669,
-1.1107221842,
-0.2619225383,
0.1363942623,
1.1358340979,
0.7712013125,
-0.3979453146,
0.1708672792,
-0.1645951271,
0.6525617838,
-0.7788252234,
0.2387437373,
-0.8500082493,
0.1280645579,
-0.3178388476,
-0.4509809911,
-0.4856103361,
-0.3454993963,
0.2539232969,
-0.4969141483,
0.3575229347,
0.1950897872,
0.9268455505,
0.1819725931,
-0.4933324754,
-0.4972506762,
-0.8324224353,
0.7727941871,
-0.4417175055,
0.7083103657,
0.4781408012,
0.0022575757,
-0.0116983438,
-0.7543520927,
-0.7586948872,
-0.4504814744,
-0.1531345695,
-0.0381107405,
0.2271851301,
0.0085816449,
0.7124910951,
0.3359003365,
-0.3250828981,
0.1371666342,
-0.4241938889,
-0.1858489066,
0.3244972229,
-0.0349951647,
0.1633197069,
0.2439367771,
-0.3025654852,
0.1084912196,
-1.1076219082,
-0.0847062767,
0.0740748346,
0.0996371433,
-0.0712795556,
0.3604803979,
0.111566484,
0.5281592011,
0.0531569533,
-0.4647496045,
0.2338914722,
-0.2757763267,
-0.1817031652,
0.2995421588,
0.5328280926,
-0.2204433382,
0.5114552379,
-0.2744718492,
-0.3102003336,
-0.4422736466,
0.323823005,
-0.7464751005,
-0.2196169794,
-0.0844717473,
-0.2101381123,
-0.0364209525,
-0.0450376309,
-0.3686243594,
-0.3170114458,
-0.5712820292,
0.688229382,
-0.4342698455,
-0.279732734,
0.2164734453,
-0.0416460298,
0.2001401633,
0.3477191925,
-1.0019444227,
0.2243794799,
0.6639940739,
0.5872607827,
-0.0493038036,
-0.3990229666,
-0.5895171165,
0.1716110855,
-0.4479082823,
0.4769751132,
-0.1916823685,
-0.0533812046,
0.0927762985,
0.0328298472,
-0.4087694287,
-0.6346535087,
0.1385238767,
-1.229010582,
0.0474922806,
-0.8147511482,
-0.7605522871,
-0.0951674208,
0.350084126,
-0.415581286,
0.6149402857,
-0.4456626177,
-0.9609171748,
0.7690335512,
-0.2281003892,
-0.3979201615,
-0.1812763512,
-0.2409117967,
-0.3583722711,
0.405369401,
-0.2753354013,
0.6366581321,
-0.1635621786,
0.3251106739,
-0.3356939852,
-0.3051407635,
0.4757887125,
-0.3060349524,
0.5748690367,
-0.0273112487,
-0.1003259197,
-0.3147782385,
-0.7289791107,
-0.4563538134,
0.3354352415,
-0.6033012271,
-0.2211661637,
0.1818227768,
-0.9075827003,
0.2231761515,
0.2967578769,
-0.4172346592,
0.091181241,
-0.031802021,
-0.1169574559,
0.6909989715,
0.2598501742,
0.3159484267,
-0.2626385391,
0.2330468744,
0.368040204,
-0.3286733329,
-0.2966257036,
0.0579861663,
-1.0378204584,
-0.0181825869,
0.2790479362,
0.4600092769,
-0.4563195705,
0.115381293,
-0.4304736853,
-0.1775642037,
0.1474609077,
0.5103168488,
0.3265342712,
0.5534307957,
0.2554245889,
-0.1395584792,
-0.4104688168,
-0.5047570467,
-0.0998648927,
-0.258205086,
0.1716462225,
0.0166268442,
0.6239972711,
-0.069096081,
0.8953363895,
-0.5353819728,
0.1261136085,
-0.3567329049,
0.3308588564,
0.1636864096,
0.4583898485,
0.5803685188,
-0.6246331334,
0.0101668937,
-0.1711303443,
-0.8541506529,
0.2025472969,
-0.2482866049,
-0.008450265,
0.268189162,
0.7517048717,
-0.9040805697,
0.1994362175,
0.3801901042,
0.0244893748,
0.9316904545,
-0.3951257467,
-0.2544764876,
-0.6265855432,
-0.0415932722,
-0.3242744207,
-0.3394284546,
-0.5009803772,
-0.2856968641,
0.0327257551,
0.2748957574,
-0.2394758016,
0.2157307416,
-0.6591765285,
-0.1702349037,
-0.1334083974,
0.2466403246,
-0.0933353603,
0.4263195097,
0.2958407104,
0.6806694269,
0.5585894585,
-1.0929834843,
0.1724093258,
-0.0736730769,
-0.5511996746,
0.0377122723,
-0.3794055283,
0.2244634777,
-0.4141505361,
0.1971670538,
-0.8321784139,
-0.1842309535,
-0.1549028456,
-0.1397667676,
0.7377365232,
-0.2350217998,
-0.5906908512,
-0.2243234813,
0.2308503389,
0.2566868067,
0.5698802471,
-0.5616668463,
0.546184361,
0.2764179409,
-0.2683008909,
-0.6742874384,
-0.5234891176,
-0.2521307468,
-0.2127598971,
-0.2771705389,
-0.1184349731,
0.149308607,
-0.3447624445,
-0.1687510908,
-0.2210329473,
-0.1846066415,
0.0911813378,
0.0557225682,
0.2520529926,
-0.420378685,
0.5953467488,
-0.2047343999,
0.0262366664,
0.6401165724,
-0.5255014896,
0.5562654734,
-0.0571081676,
-0.3833959997,
-0.265635103,
-0.3263612092,
0.6773717403,
-0.2582209706,
1.355612278,
0.4797540903,
-0.1854065955,
-0.1925083548,
-0.9662564993,
-0.18481341,
-0.401557833,
0.571411252,
-0.3806923032,
-0.7865761518,
0.5073591471,
-0.3593642116,
0.0635774061,
0.2954330146,
0.5996419787,
-0.2056586593,
0.602871716,
0.7096366882,
0.043780338,
0.4565560818,
-0.321719259,
0.0479843579,
-0.4902206957,
-0.4271510243,
-0.2644089758,
0.0691782311,
-0.326888144,
-0.4290016294,
0.0461968072,
0.3171488941,
-0.4353388846,
-0.2149877399,
0.422103852,
0.5850102305,
0.4038449824,
0.0934073403,
0.3477716148,
-0.0324018337,
-0.3047264814,
0.048856657,
-0.8843226433,
-0.3737930954,
1.103775382,
0.4866908789,
0.7059666514,
-0.0390269607,
0.645719409,
-0.0866248608,
0.3923677206,
-0.6058104634,
0.4406632781,
0.1805583984,
-0.7730357647,
-0.1963827163,
-0.5407473445,
-0.6859906912,
-0.1187935844,
-0.4442081749,
-0.5693830252,
0.2024057209,
0.5332664251,
-0.5140015483,
0.4880677462,
-0.5950719714,
0.749991715,
-0.5138977766,
-0.4998498261,
-0.5583350062,
-0.741910398,
0.5639132857,
-0.5440211296,
0.273861289,
0.0215269532,
0.298668474,
0.8112568259,
-0.2806228697,
0.782895267,
-0.3947856724,
-0.2063648552,
0.2693571448,
0.0142322229,
0.5189114213,
0.0443002954,
0.0333316661,
0.0534383841,
-0.1083222479,
-0.5069093108,
-0.6385874152,
0.1345056146,
-0.9027699232,
-0.6403561831,
-0.4337618649,
-0.3349093497,
-0.4196431041,
0.1502116174,
0.4442246854,
0.4284034967,
-0.3469856381,
0.3399289846,
1.2742962837,
-0.2889695168,
0.2476420999,
0.6696916223,
-0.4287978411,
0.1420576423,
0.8208703399,
0.4234647751,
0.6425801516,
0.4594483674,
0.0510481745,
-0.3590374589,
-0.8695412278,
0.0962603316,
0.5715821385,
-0.8341539502,
0.0821336731,
-0.7038246393,
-0.2368836999,
-0.3275561333,
0.1536163241,
-0.4168165922,
-0.2739279568,
-0.0839698017,
-0.4358661771,
0.1644286811,
0.9639369249,
-0.2568935156,
0.5709953308,
-0.8028648496,
0.194328025,
0.592492044,
0.1420276463,
0.1851356775,
-0.7533919215,
-0.6900535226,
0.0260335281,
-0.1272427142,
-0.4936979413,
0.1098136753,
0.0858664215,
0.6552397609,
0.7066286206,
-0.2569130659,
0.5896622539,
-0.590698719,
0.5395044684,
0.2018580884,
-0.6053605676,
0.3022705615,
-0.2361357659,
0.1948328763,
0.493370086,
0.6957600713,
-0.2716388702,
-0.078242071,
-0.5821941495,
-0.4518398643,
0.836730063,
-0.270758599,
0.1558439583,
0.0262408797,
0.5916196108,
-0.0167746395,
0.5023536682,
-0.7232732177,
-0.1381134987,
-0.1856080443,
0.1773110479,
-0.3639973998,
-0.7685140967,
-0.2499693185,
-0.351013869,
0.6876866817,
0.145311594,
0.2813481092,
-0.127221927,
-0.6809853911,
0.2175409496,
0.1119638905,
0.6469703913,
0.9339162707,
-0.2638101578,
0.2572942376,
0.5827900767,
-0.6082274318,
0.0402373224,
-0.2082085013,
0.1107684374,
-0.1275590956,
0.7236653566,
1.1690679789,
0.2814455628,
-0.5564675927,
0.605592072,
-0.0210025795,
-0.1743213534,
-0.621191442,
0.2001949996,
0.1806316376,
0.0160113517,
0.3995003402,
0.0752820224,
-0.4325874448,
-0.8527163267,
0.2793022692,
0.2243354768,
-0.0836650133,
-0.613743484,
0.4266801775,
-0.1171183437,
0.2680003345,
0.8973964453,
-0.1385177225,
-0.7197548747,
0.365087837,
0.67169559,
0.4944429994,
-0.1920080185,
-0.0553746969,
0.4885086715,
0.1957379878,
-0.3288172483,
-0.1527810842,
-0.24724783,
-1.0596244335,
-0.6753650308,
-0.820148766,
-0.1702133715,
0.1640312076,
-0.6322411895,
0.2410852015,
-0.7270952463,
-0.0968477279,
-0.379095912,
0.0700311363,
-0.9543808103,
0.5480504036,
0.4356460571,
0.7840874791,
-0.8008249402,
0.9254510999,
0.3355185091,
-0.255222708,
-1.1883840561,
0.1935557574,
0.0401590839,
-1.077922225,
1.0979269743,
0.0290575158,
-0.0319254324,
0.0083813649,
-0.5992574692,
-1.088973403,
1.0182318687,
0.5376391411,
-0.684150219,
-0.1891480684,
0.1863372922,
0.4032512009,
-0.2676244676,
0.0990295261,
0.7874142528,
0.3934356272,
0.3954116702,
-0.6609659195,
-0.0320635028,
0.1648754776,
-0.4608301818,
0.0870344937,
-0.5483986139,
1.0427218676,
-0.4898712933,
-0.2208043635,
-0.3319149315,
0.6629587412,
0.2709876597,
0.1582611948,
0.4156609178,
0.6907294393,
1.1856765747,
0.022745749,
1.1794615984,
-0.286344856,
0.2095740139,
1.1141132116,
-0.2600251436,
0.6768329144,
0.2078708708,
-0.1349174231,
0.7103930116,
0.3560797274,
0.2695070505,
0.41909796,
0.0179692078,
-0.4039312303,
-0.6397607923,
0.1946368217,
-0.3864349127,
0.4994492233,
0.4637537599,
-0.2933674157,
-0.0667423233,
0.0121015878,
0.3036390543,
-0.3819243014,
-0.3939151764,
0.7812072635,
0.3105497956,
-0.6775545478,
0.6462218761,
-0.3291902542,
0.2472795695,
-0.8926890492,
0.2793129086,
0.019797992,
0.2289555371,
-0.0488743223,
-0.4669635594,
0.144620344,
-0.0903599337,
-0.3734897375,
-0.2448078692,
0.6264073849,
-0.4324948788,
-0.2686789334,
0.0977625549,
0.6095966101,
0.1475182623,
0.0213445034,
-0.2977946997,
0.1792043746,
-0.1191338226,
-0.3941840529,
0.4322485626,
0.8577153087,
0.0965975896,
0.65099895,
0.6338717937,
0.3527855575,
0.5138953924,
-0.0023281325,
0.7492238879,
-0.5741454363,
-0.3037983775,
-0.9826936126,
0.3242813945,
0.0363696367,
0.0007266313,
0.7822625637,
0.4277249575,
0.8215584159,
-0.0513639338,
0.6406002641,
0.1310847998,
0.555860281,
-1.0713943243,
0.8543756604,
-0.4253944159,
0.2514591515,
0.1922896355,
-0.7418020368,
-0.0366607532,
0.5485175252,
-0.7321665287,
0.1193031371,
0.9068611264,
0.5427911878,
-0.0728194937,
-0.0750702769,
0.330614388,
0.7854343057,
0.1954971403,
0.3151365817,
1.0406252146,
0.1105919555,
0.3245636225,
0.0101975081,
-0.05734374,
-0.0371428691,
-0.8831080794,
-0.9427798986,
-0.3957304358,
-0.1525256187,
-0.1879363358,
0.0614559874,
0.853708446,
0.7102847695,
-0.6885299087,
-0.1855714619,
-0.1688640863,
0.2138116062,
0.3327205181,
-0.1231688336,
0.1723556221,
-0.8272680044,
-0.1969663799,
0.1858073622,
0.0558242537,
0.1995935887,
0.0262241885,
-0.1341418475,
-0.3221149445,
0.1285841614,
0.5801643133,
0.5567068458,
-0.1989701688,
-0.2218809724,
-0.2608153522,
0.0579634123,
0.0526745692,
1.0504875183,
-0.976190269,
0.1883386672,
0.3636214137,
0.6028478146,
0.7885186672,
-0.0121967234,
0.6555185914,
-0.8110578656,
0.3764013946,
-0.0588045716,
0.4617094994,
0.2790190876,
-0.1587976217,
-0.0589645319,
0.5993079543,
-0.6451035142,
-0.8887587786,
0.1119479164,
-0.4862698913,
-0.1918345988,
0.8693748713,
-0.3372235,
-0.133308202,
-0.0396863781,
0.2040576041,
0.4870341122,
0.148573637,
0.8028410673,
0.9785627723,
0.0963155776,
-0.0929213092,
-0.7348767519,
0.6647718549,
0.4225887656,
-0.5113887787,
0.1944556534,
0.4978953004,
0.6523201466,
0.2413923591,
0.7436668277,
0.0602349415,
0.1115795299,
-0.0023083512,
-0.3045636415,
0.0876607522,
-0.7155674696,
-0.1307453215,
0.0412369743,
0.2712939978,
0.0664192215
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11811v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11811v1 | RepLiQA: A Question-Answering Dataset for Benchmarking LLMs on Unseen Reference Content | 2024-06-17T17:52:54 | 2024-06-17T17:52:54 | Joao Monteiro, Pierre-Andre Noel, Etienne Marcotte, Sai Rajeswar, Valentina Zantedeschi, David Vazquez, Nicolas Chapados, Christopher Pal, Perouz Taslakian | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs) are trained on vast amounts of data, most of
which is automatically scraped from the internet. This data includes
encyclopedic documents that harbor a vast amount of general knowledge (e.g.,
Wikipedia) but also potentially overlap with benchmark datasets used for
evaluating LLMs. Consequently, evaluating models on test splits that might have
leaked into the training set is prone to misleading conclusions. To foster
sound evaluation of language models, we introduce a new test dataset named
RepLiQA, suited for question-answering and topic retrieval tasks. RepLiQA is a
collection of five splits of test sets, four of which have not been released to
the internet or exposed to LLM APIs prior to this publication. Each sample in
RepLiQA comprises (1) a reference document crafted by a human annotator and
depicting an imaginary scenario (e.g., a news article) absent from the
internet; (2) a question about the document's topic; (3) a ground-truth answer
derived directly from the information in the document; and (4) the paragraph
extracted from the reference document containing the answer. As such, accurate
answers can only be generated if a model can find relevant content within the
provided document. We run a large-scale benchmark comprising several
state-of-the-art LLMs to uncover differences in performance across models of
various types and sizes in a context-conditional language modeling setting.
Released splits of RepLiQA can be found here:
https://huggingface.co/datasets/ServiceNow/repliqa. | [
-0.5677736998,
-0.5149022937,
0.4572927058,
0.0364650264,
-0.1686884314,
0.0705473274,
-0.0853395686,
-0.2715080976,
-0.0932075307,
0.7341943383,
-0.8192391396,
-0.266752094,
-0.3515782952,
0.2925597727,
-0.7189853787,
0.6968785524,
-0.1230938286,
0.1505329162,
-0.6736388206,
-0.3886681497,
-0.2290189266,
-0.3965077698,
-0.3266511559,
-0.2840402424,
0.5778862238,
0.4592802525,
0.4474782348,
0.4955406189,
0.3734574616,
0.2286118567,
-0.0276138596,
0.329234153,
-0.5576496124,
0.3755709529,
-0.3493566811,
-0.4217736721,
0.0546457879,
0.2442534864,
0.8407079577,
0.4813980162,
-0.0770953447,
0.5933988094,
-0.1134581268,
0.6097329259,
-0.7850868702,
-0.2747131884,
-0.5963072777,
-0.1427995414,
-0.0831120238,
0.009243886,
-0.3850734532,
-0.6628336906,
0.1232041121,
-0.4982749224,
0.1109195501,
0.1034829766,
1.0346125364,
0.5144673586,
-0.4424772263,
-0.2005290091,
-0.4076322913,
0.7398965359,
-0.7400666475,
0.7549176812,
0.2775329649,
0.5219241381,
-0.0402811989,
-0.9338539839,
-0.7550340295,
-0.2195382863,
0.0400138721,
0.0730184466,
-0.0603166781,
-0.3066108227,
0.3374387622,
0.5133519769,
-0.725148797,
-0.1400035024,
-0.1524977535,
-0.1454156041,
0.5043401718,
0.0792325139,
0.3040300608,
-0.2077123672,
-0.2606661916,
-0.2636547387,
-1.035680294,
-0.0503653623,
0.3258094788,
0.1247997433,
0.0227446556,
0.7045266032,
-0.4189843833,
0.6684382558,
-0.0120520303,
-0.2524350882,
0.2865426242,
-0.2330859154,
-0.2310452312,
-0.2172540575,
0.5832905769,
0.2092905492,
0.4611475468,
-0.251714468,
-0.118712835,
-0.3984726369,
0.1392912418,
-1.0275489092,
-0.1904033422,
0.2269429415,
-0.2776117027,
-0.1049183458,
-0.0219630618,
-0.6957422495,
-0.5522349477,
-0.1365549862,
0.2945956588,
-0.1922088116,
-0.1386929303,
-0.2361670583,
-0.1294035465,
0.3374237418,
0.1051827669,
-0.535715282,
0.3466323018,
0.6660096049,
0.4905736744,
-0.3026863337,
-0.2179119885,
-0.7975276113,
-0.1519139409,
-0.3397773802,
0.9463829398,
-0.6596847177,
-0.2743002176,
0.1744968593,
0.2261451185,
0.0054695839,
-0.8065677881,
0.7334137559,
-0.9242123961,
0.4101908505,
-0.497007221,
-0.7873750925,
-0.231952697,
0.4819592535,
-0.9019984007,
1.3462126255,
0.2546952367,
-0.9488700032,
-0.017318612,
-0.2434393317,
-0.0217893738,
-0.0378869474,
-0.3163298965,
-0.2354549617,
-0.0769217089,
0.2330465019,
0.0855089799,
-0.788929224,
0.027461011,
-0.2912781239,
-0.4816672802,
0.6575154662,
-0.4790515602,
0.5616372228,
0.2440247238,
-0.1931621581,
-0.2282968462,
-0.6222638488,
0.418125689,
0.0025474427,
-0.4669027328,
-0.347568363,
-0.1729317904,
-0.1318375021,
0.2894430161,
0.3453772068,
-0.5895074606,
0.0178663973,
-0.3150702417,
0.1361534595,
0.5382421017,
0.3121829629,
0.1780625433,
-0.4996211827,
0.7200294137,
-0.1629358679,
0.0018822387,
-0.1443412304,
-0.2727876902,
-0.984266758,
-0.0501467288,
0.779437542,
0.4672768116,
-0.8579105735,
-0.0187984798,
-0.3079043031,
-0.4958254695,
-0.8658108115,
0.1231834218,
0.5617008209,
0.6063529849,
0.3813042641,
0.0042898152,
-0.4945564866,
-1.17291224,
-0.4479137659,
-0.2471468449,
-0.1286708415,
0.4692897499,
0.5063425303,
0.0362083167,
0.8225984573,
-0.3764526248,
0.2920676768,
0.0555787683,
0.0686050504,
0.0787663162,
0.10544274,
0.0878093541,
-1.04510355,
-0.2913440466,
-0.3062300384,
-0.6270567775,
-0.4374513924,
0.1179776862,
-0.0748437867,
0.0017886583,
0.4904438257,
-0.4011339247,
0.1521427631,
0.7814604044,
-0.1453957856,
0.6452268958,
0.1073667109,
0.2982604504,
-1.1003400087,
0.1895843446,
-0.1968002915,
-0.2037329674,
-0.4081557393,
0.3153838515,
0.2632662952,
0.0877611786,
-0.5461108685,
0.7685376406,
-0.3749385178,
-0.3340364993,
-0.2385885268,
0.302744925,
0.2658586502,
0.2897987366,
-0.074949652,
1.2461990118,
0.0210858323,
-0.3326595724,
0.2511284351,
0.3393849432,
-0.5197724104,
0.2829865813,
-0.6846914887,
0.3317936361,
0.0899279416,
0.104875572,
-1.0059192181,
-0.1190070137,
0.1447148621,
-0.4524365664,
-0.0597795136,
-0.1003814191,
-0.6781969666,
-0.1636041105,
-0.1773673445,
0.5402240157,
0.4513281584,
-0.576895535,
0.4702495039,
0.4482847452,
-0.267144084,
-0.8784793615,
-0.6407506466,
-0.1694664955,
-0.1607546657,
-0.3550157547,
0.0930662528,
-0.3960271478,
-0.3868011236,
0.1344152838,
-0.1536797583,
-0.4088607728,
0.1203240082,
0.5088866949,
0.1283271462,
-0.2754862309,
0.4758301675,
-0.1111936197,
0.1671574414,
0.1501047909,
-0.0915405005,
0.5269190073,
-0.1414136291,
-0.4929155409,
-0.1227512732,
0.1637050807,
0.5604768991,
-0.4024444222,
0.5244366527,
0.2717543244,
-0.3077103794,
-0.2095949948,
-0.7825987935,
-0.0078556221,
-0.457754463,
0.167942062,
-0.4313396215,
-0.9520885348,
0.3899923861,
-0.1314579397,
0.1105233356,
0.3224321604,
0.6467421055,
-0.0166716054,
0.6488236785,
0.3764231503,
-0.1444974691,
0.1272023469,
-0.0492688268,
-0.0112456763,
-0.8818393946,
-0.2696455717,
-0.6967551112,
-0.0786211267,
-0.6733496189,
-0.6584194899,
0.0050707329,
0.059540648,
-0.4340871274,
0.1546555609,
-0.2721557617,
0.5839630961,
0.5940586329,
0.0039699166,
0.6108611226,
-0.1401949376,
-0.3150867224,
-0.0576773547,
-0.5940685868,
-0.5899022818,
1.2286150455,
0.2900824845,
0.6120797992,
0.053337425,
0.5160855651,
0.267952323,
0.7260465622,
-0.4881278872,
0.5453551412,
0.0160815157,
-0.7894499302,
-0.3258267641,
-0.5268189311,
-0.6151307225,
0.2845632136,
-0.1850641519,
-0.3917104304,
0.2431731075,
-0.2509583533,
-0.1728767157,
0.1663853079,
-0.4123954177,
0.7183901072,
-0.1574094743,
-0.3595874012,
0.1381819844,
-0.2026310265,
0.5263351798,
-0.368137449,
0.1534251571,
-0.3056195378,
-0.1938990206,
0.8448063731,
-0.2383906692,
0.3656752706,
0.0278369635,
-0.165108338,
0.3994976282,
0.1308974922,
0.3387425542,
0.2373585999,
-0.3348338604,
-0.1082018092,
0.3673569262,
-0.354659915,
-0.7123998404,
0.7282085419,
-0.861469388,
-0.6183165908,
-0.3684388101,
-0.6266610622,
-0.4997749031,
0.2865908444,
0.2295291126,
0.4582073092,
-0.2515822351,
0.3416088223,
0.8037695289,
-0.3131434023,
0.0721006915,
0.9527598619,
-0.3727824688,
-0.3234894574,
0.6848245263,
0.0337600559,
0.1729138047,
0.3998180032,
-0.0793163404,
-0.5754055977,
-0.5104292631,
-0.2990861237,
0.3876794875,
-0.7736392021,
-0.1900357902,
-0.3437349498,
-0.4506644309,
-0.2844357491,
0.5074412227,
-0.3492932022,
-0.3615086377,
0.014361403,
-0.0273167994,
0.2302850783,
0.6405704618,
0.1956459284,
-0.1260810196,
-0.6991635561,
0.4082861543,
0.6117153168,
0.2127151936,
-0.1671677828,
-0.8164716363,
-0.0834247023,
0.227674216,
-0.0377468579,
-0.8800374269,
0.2289082706,
0.152288273,
0.5835103989,
0.0697373822,
0.314930588,
0.5800047517,
-0.5999693871,
0.6594125032,
-0.2557719648,
-0.6535033584,
0.214880839,
-0.1748458594,
0.3276921511,
0.9030587077,
0.633128345,
-0.7555798292,
-0.3997348845,
-0.5267708898,
-0.5090424418,
0.2386946529,
0.2216007859,
-0.0091691576,
-0.0014267974,
0.6020458937,
0.061978627,
0.4056538343,
-0.6237228513,
-0.3279602528,
0.029838223,
-0.1290127337,
-0.0362884924,
-0.3956772983,
-0.3434313536,
-0.0630383864,
0.6652087569,
-0.07817287,
0.0526601225,
0.255892247,
-0.1956044137,
-0.039591223,
0.2545674741,
0.2956262827,
0.787689209,
-0.2325440347,
0.1459289044,
0.3395950496,
-0.4016489685,
0.2418082505,
0.1813599169,
-0.288541019,
0.100492917,
0.4601171315,
0.3426894546,
0.2698888183,
-1.2556755543,
0.4679526389,
-0.2976022959,
-0.3273956776,
-0.5422929525,
0.0671929345,
0.350466311,
0.4853464365,
0.5622301102,
-0.5720715523,
0.0880124569,
-0.4250228703,
0.5538244843,
0.1965222508,
-0.3930472732,
-0.0353966728,
0.3980307877,
0.0198433157,
-0.2539947629,
0.7270935774,
-0.0366562754,
-0.4410721958,
0.5522100925,
0.2100425363,
0.6487516165,
-0.1094214395,
0.3887301385,
0.2098522633,
0.3135898411,
0.0548302941,
0.3743826151,
0.0785928518,
-0.8002056479,
-0.4867623746,
-0.6601905227,
-0.7765548825,
0.5023971796,
-0.795869112,
-0.0850173607,
-0.1616710722,
0.1388284862,
-0.1449454874,
0.2686901391,
-0.6277771592,
0.471854955,
0.1017228514,
1.3798135519,
-0.682649672,
0.9489628077,
0.5844685435,
-0.3604893982,
-0.8930653334,
0.3538275063,
-0.2250887454,
-0.8211647272,
0.7189466953,
0.0471302271,
0.0399402454,
-0.0348870084,
-0.4583832324,
-1.0017848015,
1.1321743727,
0.5179482698,
-0.4651787579,
0.017606359,
0.2510518432,
0.5146171451,
-0.4358992577,
0.3342243433,
0.6929594874,
0.4770880938,
0.0715484098,
-0.7241663337,
0.1625638753,
-0.4175873101,
-0.1960366219,
-0.0605956391,
-0.6522753835,
1.0053395033,
0.2192493677,
-0.2865791023,
0.3834401667,
0.6054901481,
0.592876792,
0.1134369969,
0.5681538582,
0.5890982747,
0.978856802,
-0.1198091283,
1.0662624836,
-0.3651534617,
0.2581119835,
1.4667941332,
-0.3683302999,
1.255002737,
0.4677781463,
-0.0683900565,
0.6319485307,
0.8317859173,
0.0173158962,
0.5840883851,
0.3445397913,
-0.3149208724,
-0.4135771692,
-0.3339368701,
-0.51902318,
0.3576796353,
0.0280451644,
-0.3381786644,
-0.3801099956,
-0.2012130469,
-0.2401342988,
0.2514834404,
-0.0840911865,
0.5141504407,
0.060036961,
-0.7856704593,
0.7569643259,
-0.0952688828,
0.1255520135,
-0.3768373132,
-0.1075088605,
-0.5813593268,
-0.0767541751,
0.0367769301,
-0.7576788664,
0.0346847177,
0.2721021175,
-0.1693346947,
0.0873957276,
0.6509798765,
-0.4469861388,
-0.4007057846,
0.2019763291,
0.7656265497,
0.255132705,
-0.222235769,
-0.7797816992,
0.1843401939,
-0.0423532836,
-0.4127337635,
0.3482759297,
0.4576572478,
0.0346395485,
0.9872187972,
0.5524244905,
-0.0287139174,
0.0103844292,
0.0779796913,
1.141258955,
-0.5360332131,
-0.2468493432,
-0.4533578753,
0.220553413,
-0.2082856447,
-0.4176934958,
0.9405505657,
0.7845625281,
0.6777639389,
0.2131211609,
0.8681921363,
0.2907953858,
0.9475874901,
-0.5152503252,
0.6132239699,
-0.7157371044,
0.2930250168,
0.0114053823,
-0.8807026744,
0.1812640727,
0.2574843168,
-0.4193660319,
-0.0753526613,
0.665946722,
0.8405631185,
0.1135659516,
0.0703420937,
0.329728961,
0.123688221,
-0.0349732004,
0.5774905682,
1.1945774555,
-0.6362380981,
0.7524539232,
-0.197609812,
0.1251216829,
-0.0700806156,
-0.7386330962,
-0.9533793926,
-0.6256532073,
-0.1610159129,
-0.3509093821,
0.3151623309,
0.546426475,
0.624928236,
-0.9501047134,
-0.1019959748,
0.1700796038,
0.1939802915,
0.1604464352,
-0.1904687285,
0.2913948894,
-0.0412047021,
-0.7046306729,
0.4881558418,
-0.0953199565,
-0.1354287565,
-0.485861659,
-0.1402539164,
-0.4022828937,
0.2199936509,
0.1523093134,
0.4365011752,
-0.6066352129,
-0.3719916642,
0.2334809452,
-0.2209338397,
-0.1151839569,
0.6603726745,
-0.871802628,
0.1824601293,
0.5001725554,
1.0194858313,
0.5515356064,
0.2750830352,
0.5675361156,
-0.7445963621,
0.0393561833,
0.2133633494,
0.1788837463,
0.4636712968,
-0.075037159,
0.6035792232,
-0.0337714739,
-0.5520581007,
-0.9680985212,
0.1724192351,
-0.5886825919,
-0.4351014495,
1.1623407602,
-0.4191500545,
-0.2502889037,
-0.0400804617,
0.1005813703,
0.1505229175,
-0.1057424918,
0.6838800311,
0.908051312,
0.1952130795,
-0.4561609328,
-0.7994933128,
0.4829374254,
0.4084215164,
-0.9245275259,
0.0877214372,
0.4326466322,
0.5378319025,
0.0568135343,
0.4351668954,
-0.0851547569,
0.3592368066,
-0.1655571163,
0.0065448848,
-0.0570604987,
-0.2454331815,
-0.2706034184,
0.3197230101,
0.1877620667,
-0.1449396759
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11944v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11944v1 | Transcoders Find Interpretable LLM Feature Circuits | 2024-06-17T17:49:00 | 2024-06-17T17:49:00 | Jacob Dunefsky, Philippe Chlenski, Neel Nanda | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | A key goal in mechanistic interpretability is circuit analysis: finding
sparse subgraphs of models corresponding to specific behaviors or capabilities.
However, MLP sublayers make fine-grained circuit analysis on transformer-based
language models difficult. In particular, interpretable features -- such as
those found by sparse autoencoders (SAEs) -- are typically linear combinations
of extremely many neurons, each with its own nonlinearity to account for.
Circuit analysis in this setting thus either yields intractably large circuits
or fails to disentangle local and global behavior. To address this we explore
transcoders, which seek to faithfully approximate a densely activating MLP
layer with a wider, sparsely-activating MLP layer. We successfully train
transcoders on language models with 120M, 410M, and 1.4B parameters, and find
them to perform at least on par with SAEs in terms of sparsity, faithfulness,
and human-interpretability. We then introduce a novel method for using
transcoders to perform weights-based circuit analysis through MLP sublayers.
The resulting circuits neatly factorize into input-dependent and
input-invariant terms. Finally, we apply transcoders to reverse-engineer
unknown circuits in the model, and we obtain novel insights regarding the
greater-than circuit in GPT2-small. Our results suggest that transcoders can
prove effective in decomposing model computations involving MLPs into
interpretable circuits. Code is available at
https://github.com/jacobdunefsky/transcoder_circuits. | [
-0.4046167135,
-0.4229216576,
0.5060725212,
0.2480870038,
-0.0250365417,
-0.0675597265,
-0.0510971397,
-0.4451335371,
0.2048555315,
0.5590550303,
-0.5950505733,
0.1093814149,
-0.842212081,
-0.0197724868,
-0.7357378006,
0.8316630721,
-0.2147332579,
0.0498063862,
0.1511365324,
-0.1038147882,
-0.2589643598,
-0.5783364177,
-0.284540683,
-0.5906180143,
0.4948744476,
-0.1923750192,
0.7979606986,
0.2824173868,
0.220229432,
0.2836472392,
-0.3027342856,
0.144801721,
-0.1881821752,
-0.1517134756,
-0.0512924753,
-0.2723430097,
-0.2556196749,
-0.0862112865,
0.6104275584,
0.9572951198,
0.0935279429,
0.1371575743,
0.4647937119,
0.4584426284,
-0.4112083912,
0.1821027696,
-0.6873066425,
0.3054742813,
0.1097975895,
-0.3798472285,
-0.4929675758,
0.1943743974,
-0.0953141302,
-0.1899999231,
0.3916876316,
-0.1475191414,
0.8009677529,
0.2873371243,
-0.3107511997,
-0.3914922774,
-0.9564647079,
0.614967823,
-0.4024945498,
0.6048012972,
0.1365439147,
0.1493166685,
-0.2976521552,
-0.8207219839,
-0.3988751173,
-0.2043061256,
-0.5577465296,
-0.2014509737,
-0.36768803,
0.1319529116,
0.4529543221,
0.4127125442,
-0.5859731436,
-0.0304259583,
-0.3921003342,
-0.3666139841,
0.3637862504,
0.171380654,
0.3865436316,
-0.2755687535,
-0.1835917383,
0.3001592755,
-0.6323904395,
0.0074503953,
0.1675387472,
0.0432622321,
0.0364530906,
0.6475327611,
0.18697837,
0.5995007753,
0.0733345002,
0.3324963748,
-0.0647745878,
-0.2466833293,
-0.308581382,
-0.1713270992,
0.6771813631,
-0.1111573279,
0.3975553513,
-0.3726137877,
-0.4192213118,
-0.3835507631,
0.4003720582,
-0.7889178991,
-0.4384136498,
0.0899069235,
-0.7299599648,
-0.0709320307,
0.0114619005,
-0.4529135227,
-0.3287131786,
-0.2963905931,
0.6094315648,
-0.1393226087,
-0.0418465883,
0.1883975267,
-0.0993772075,
0.3942236602,
-0.0369197503,
-1.3551235199,
0.7357768416,
0.4705955088,
1.0112606287,
0.0015268613,
-0.3439870179,
-0.3843536377,
-0.029273171,
-0.15107584,
0.4617359936,
-0.3608002365,
-0.2306873053,
-0.3998318911,
0.275875926,
-0.1529348493,
-0.6635908484,
0.4562610388,
-0.7605440021,
-0.2483272254,
-0.1890396178,
-0.2818587124,
0.1244059205,
-0.0687752813,
-0.8802267909,
0.7965674996,
0.3120381236,
-0.5807533264,
0.0923761055,
-0.6079026461,
-0.5588078499,
-0.3591752648,
-0.1073467359,
-0.296253711,
0.5735413432,
0.3944156468,
0.5247439146,
-0.0977283344,
0.0947788879,
-0.2275520265,
-0.570341289,
0.5802386999,
-0.7764105201,
0.7960470915,
0.236591652,
-0.4292213917,
0.0728219226,
-0.5670135617,
0.0142170265,
0.1967477649,
-0.1892523319,
-0.0745004714,
-0.0640107244,
0.1290832907,
0.341252923,
0.067277506,
-0.4248844683,
0.2014189959,
-0.493604809,
0.9602308273,
0.7317185998,
-0.0256310329,
0.5776630044,
0.1590482891,
0.2269986719,
-0.0865379572,
0.3445799351,
-0.0470595174,
-0.3785619438,
-0.8240283728,
-0.0574649423,
0.4007423818,
0.3575669527,
-0.6280636191,
0.5815532804,
-0.2587853372,
-0.1325870901,
-0.5489940643,
0.3639644682,
0.1606886238,
0.1989322156,
0.6838853955,
-0.3102161586,
-0.2901757956,
-1.0850259066,
-0.3741745353,
0.2029494345,
-0.3879018426,
0.1180291772,
0.4474720657,
-0.3343910277,
0.615206182,
-0.3696721196,
-0.0902494118,
-0.4575053453,
0.0930612013,
0.1187628359,
0.5514814258,
0.2688938677,
-0.5826182365,
-0.0680013746,
-0.0826669931,
-0.6285769343,
-0.1410554498,
-0.5008009672,
0.1335670054,
-0.2344017476,
0.4746247828,
-0.7043741345,
0.4376470149,
0.3433250487,
0.0397085361,
0.1782569289,
-0.419152379,
-0.1226416677,
-0.4345014691,
0.0087241512,
-0.0198702551,
-0.2625536323,
-0.5619485974,
0.0120479008,
0.0958463103,
-0.0601783097,
-0.0676895455,
0.5568262935,
-0.7040081024,
-0.7326388359,
-0.3666596413,
-0.1642422229,
0.1480338871,
0.6562453508,
-0.0023883271,
0.7288336158,
0.300783366,
-0.3098931611,
0.2306772619,
-0.0713017881,
-0.3661312759,
-0.0088503938,
-0.8798896074,
0.0374666527,
-0.0308321137,
0.0952071473,
-0.7533425689,
-0.0646798089,
0.3527709246,
-0.2059603035,
0.5279492736,
-0.3761267364,
-0.5684722662,
-0.4086429775,
-0.1850845963,
0.5895425081,
0.6276254058,
-0.6558610201,
0.739944458,
0.3974837661,
0.1033855006,
-0.3530563712,
-1.0649255514,
0.126398012,
0.265617311,
-0.3998175263,
0.0997953787,
0.1007859856,
0.0813974366,
0.1347425729,
-0.1925551891,
-0.1641113758,
0.1769267321,
0.3061330318,
-0.0501465462,
-0.1935392916,
-0.1542027593,
0.256721586,
-0.4112297595,
0.3226241171,
-0.5439580679,
0.6767634749,
-0.3423642218,
-0.6844277382,
-0.4623993933,
0.1498987675,
0.5137978792,
-0.2115286887,
0.4212968349,
0.6512032747,
-0.5019906163,
-0.369012624,
-0.2191172391,
-0.1897155046,
-0.5391495228,
0.4712554514,
-0.6012122631,
-0.7814198136,
0.4896833897,
-0.1919733435,
-0.2919528186,
0.4982338548,
0.5805937648,
-0.1518576592,
1.1516407728,
0.4850484133,
-0.0594168827,
0.3653160036,
-0.4769906402,
0.3325051367,
-1.0015501976,
-0.3654825091,
-0.0338980556,
-0.7298246622,
-0.4611223936,
-0.4998081923,
0.3956744075,
-0.0110703893,
-0.0903643519,
0.2875725627,
-0.6335784197,
0.7511911988,
0.4246322513,
0.1804733574,
0.0180303659,
0.2608505785,
-0.2151308805,
-0.1732299179,
-0.7822521329,
-0.3993351161,
0.7238289714,
0.5972735286,
0.9866107106,
-0.2982777655,
0.4192970693,
0.2956903875,
0.2038820982,
-0.7677186728,
0.3452526331,
-0.3956111372,
-0.4470764697,
-0.1282583326,
-0.491111666,
-0.8079283834,
0.1719768494,
-0.1908124983,
-0.7615622878,
0.3522874713,
0.1576844752,
-0.1625719368,
0.5534011126,
-0.680405736,
0.9078053832,
-0.564622879,
-0.1958671808,
-0.0393974707,
-0.7366036773,
0.4553447068,
0.1354845315,
0.0696090385,
0.4295399487,
0.0491025969,
0.261528492,
-0.5516394377,
0.8531215787,
-0.1222602054,
-0.243871212,
0.2995837033,
0.3556118608,
0.3186644018,
-0.0518317409,
-0.0007419025,
0.4347247481,
-0.1165076867,
-0.454855442,
-0.9403028488,
0.7597970366,
-0.7860213518,
-0.223465547,
-0.109329246,
-0.6019856334,
-0.1164793149,
0.0362506323,
0.2967578471,
0.5904331207,
0.0557652526,
-0.1848080456,
0.7563253045,
-0.1417950094,
0.164857462,
-0.0780386925,
-0.2136843055,
-0.1736273766,
1.150229454,
0.2517064512,
0.2545284331,
0.4431257844,
-0.0135344053,
-0.1398503631,
-0.6940289736,
-0.7095170617,
0.145800814,
-0.7024621964,
0.0843973681,
-0.6910970211,
-0.7256163359,
0.1676630527,
-0.0263360366,
-0.4184817076,
-0.817784667,
-0.2910261154,
-0.0303650461,
-0.2163985074,
0.9757321477,
-0.1241813749,
0.3983055651,
-0.8147243857,
0.5822302699,
0.48356089,
0.4431422651,
0.2176029235,
-0.7818135023,
-0.3076610863,
0.0702114776,
-0.1488717943,
-0.5788094997,
0.2336263061,
0.0198541004,
0.5326596498,
0.2271108776,
-0.3931775689,
0.6389837265,
-0.4630460739,
0.5803580284,
-0.0377357304,
-1.30491364,
0.4540423751,
0.2808642983,
0.1035500914,
0.2132563889,
0.2216128856,
-0.2905417383,
-0.2331360132,
-0.5096078515,
-0.6778544784,
0.5618326068,
0.5238351226,
0.4097642004,
0.2606493533,
0.8000917435,
0.0856704339,
-0.0116205318,
-1.0075012445,
-0.2875144184,
-0.3602009118,
-0.3776552081,
0.1907556802,
-0.5728304386,
0.0073977076,
-0.1146231592,
0.3175349832,
-0.0457177125,
0.5081790686,
0.1615536511,
-0.3114350438,
-0.1503561586,
0.3263776898,
0.5625665188,
0.4684502482,
-0.1633103043,
0.650118053,
0.2003376186,
-0.5348740816,
0.209995985,
0.1667998731,
-0.4488230646,
-0.0336793326,
0.7376568317,
0.6878973842,
0.1588973701,
-0.4664652646,
0.6381444335,
-0.2056083679,
-0.0562774613,
-0.0467673503,
0.2129654437,
-0.0451233536,
0.2790261209,
0.2306152731,
0.3687762022,
0.3647946417,
-0.4264316261,
0.3738316298,
0.6635026932,
-0.751429081,
-0.6217049956,
0.6687355638,
0.0665986985,
-0.0150467819,
0.6156867743,
-0.1480625272,
-0.6223731637,
0.6189107299,
0.4783959687,
1.0018151999,
0.0768613964,
-0.0812716708,
0.2264788449,
0.9761455059,
0.035541676,
-0.0149518829,
-0.0539439544,
-0.6846258044,
-0.586851716,
-0.7389758229,
-0.0401629098,
0.239095211,
-0.5482766032,
0.1236188412,
-0.7834967971,
0.1832315326,
0.1486953646,
-0.3799823523,
-0.4858783484,
0.1682428718,
0.1851253957,
0.8574777842,
-0.9684742689,
0.9005507231,
0.3289373517,
-0.2648874521,
-0.7357230186,
0.0856896713,
-0.2795600295,
-1.1014070511,
0.8331853747,
0.1058263108,
-0.2777559757,
-0.2077639848,
-0.6078186035,
-0.5970308185,
0.8776679635,
0.4408720136,
-0.5924662352,
0.0496426187,
0.3446975648,
0.647377491,
-0.1932871044,
0.4273456335,
0.6122998595,
0.3633903563,
0.011152193,
-0.8537253737,
0.2894444764,
-0.23646155,
-0.059610419,
0.3837437332,
-0.4838353395,
0.7259019017,
-0.3118286133,
-0.0502700061,
0.156433329,
0.5891302824,
-0.1122715995,
0.2773964405,
0.4373446405,
0.252764225,
0.528519392,
0.0805437863,
1.0520093441,
-0.2654413879,
0.4467914402,
0.990739882,
-0.0158148389,
0.524512589,
0.5919296741,
-0.2451797873,
0.3861969113,
0.3764260411,
-0.2548967302,
0.4726930857,
0.4557991624,
-0.0292864963,
-0.5109215975,
0.1090481952,
-0.0895424932,
0.2885915339,
0.4195871651,
-0.738894403,
-0.1082410812,
0.0215420611,
-0.3809739053,
-0.1900856048,
-0.4219118059,
0.5187067986,
0.315720588,
-0.1018499359,
0.4785456955,
0.2173119485,
0.4185113311,
-0.5742326379,
-0.2703380883,
-0.0749198049,
0.1143284217,
-0.4204700291,
-0.8569512963,
0.5858563781,
-0.1052693054,
-0.2131187022,
-0.2435731739,
1.1391385794,
-0.2405319661,
-0.7031514645,
0.4375975728,
0.5582424998,
0.0886596814,
-0.1437322348,
-0.6236876845,
0.0658873692,
-0.0660012439,
-0.2995626032,
0.4020435512,
0.5638210773,
-0.0399534069,
0.794588089,
0.4401730299,
0.1769125164,
0.1449986249,
0.1402626932,
1.107329607,
-0.7854177952,
0.0295766722,
-0.9299619794,
0.3746239245,
0.1898312718,
0.1005765125,
0.4119828939,
0.6155598164,
0.6603916883,
-0.1087203845,
0.650746882,
-0.0070064175,
0.0682215095,
-0.8212635517,
0.5908751488,
-0.5501993299,
0.6973966956,
0.0889348313,
-0.8915644288,
-0.3175700009,
0.703204155,
-0.2069037557,
0.2321577817,
0.4608561397,
0.898943305,
-0.5863132477,
0.0328631252,
0.3219262362,
0.4771103263,
0.1890740097,
0.720879972,
1.0225465298,
-0.6588203907,
0.7158518434,
-0.3204592466,
-0.0613249727,
0.0665205196,
-0.7002275586,
-0.9286190271,
-0.3368409872,
-0.0174644869,
-0.282361567,
-0.1968944818,
0.7013463974,
0.5879431367,
-0.9695459604,
-0.1090402976,
-0.2658996582,
0.4106688201,
-0.1645561606,
-0.1998830438,
0.3376516998,
-0.2219877541,
-0.417201817,
0.2313340753,
0.4549188018,
0.1640283465,
-0.5978944898,
-0.1733740121,
0.2138623148,
-0.0271551646,
0.6228892803,
0.216559127,
-0.7437463403,
-0.3092031181,
0.0695935115,
-0.1159002855,
-0.1255129576,
1.1927382946,
-0.6875783801,
0.2304601818,
0.3181904852,
0.6826524138,
0.7916802764,
-0.1930685639,
0.4174087942,
-0.8124600649,
0.0174000096,
0.0630147383,
0.5484330654,
0.2798173726,
-0.353585273,
0.5068386197,
0.2933235765,
-0.5185008049,
-0.6072458625,
0.2794745862,
-1.097102046,
-0.4289759099,
0.9868630767,
-0.0538795255,
-0.2623083591,
-0.150916934,
-0.0799694434,
-0.0809936672,
0.1221150681,
0.5779574513,
0.5246569514,
-0.5256538391,
-0.3817144632,
-0.6378338337,
0.3532044888,
0.3262828588,
-0.5600986481,
0.2392240614,
0.2967429161,
0.3272987902,
0.2571676373,
0.5085803866,
-0.0455828011,
0.1364389807,
0.0458168685,
-0.1074727327,
-0.144482553,
-0.3885932565,
-0.626506567,
0.1562986523,
0.2050181627,
0.0814165697
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11801v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11801v1 | Safety Arithmetic: A Framework for Test-time Safety Alignment of Language Models by Steering Parameters and Activations | 2024-06-17T17:48:13 | 2024-06-17T17:48:13 | Rima Hazra, Sayan Layek, Somnath Banerjee, Soujanya Poria | cs.CL | cs.CL | Ensuring the safe alignment of large language models (LLMs) with human values
is critical as they become integral to applications like translation and
question answering. Current alignment methods struggle with dynamic user
intentions and complex objectives, making models vulnerable to generating
harmful content. We propose Safety Arithmetic, a training-free framework
enhancing LLM safety across different scenarios: Base models, Supervised
fine-tuned models (SFT), and Edited models. Safety Arithmetic involves Harm
Direction Removal to avoid harmful content and Safety Alignment to promote safe
responses. Additionally, we present NoIntentEdit, a dataset highlighting edit
instances that could compromise model safety if used unintentionally. Our
experiments show that Safety Arithmetic significantly improves safety measures,
reduces over-safety, and maintains model utility, outperforming existing
methods in ensuring safe content generation. | [
0.0684423447,
-0.6568191648,
0.2552633882,
0.1931365281,
-0.125244841,
-0.0882829055,
0.1946834922,
-0.4449265599,
-0.3906112313,
0.5951806307,
-0.3734949529,
-0.5432673693,
-0.4842749834,
-0.2143238783,
-0.6918241978,
1.0463927984,
-0.0558574274,
0.0223806519,
-0.3043298721,
-0.2501309216,
-0.180307135,
-0.7197337151,
-0.8142921925,
0.0076017925,
0.5405010581,
0.365824312,
1.0588454008,
1.0422317982,
0.5561579466,
0.3585943282,
0.1264800727,
0.0251548514,
-0.4796150923,
-0.0184504874,
-0.1793667823,
-0.3273949027,
-1.0640205145,
-0.0479187407,
0.4571811259,
0.7452543378,
-0.3388423622,
-0.1865443289,
-0.1033407822,
0.7195715308,
-0.7746992111,
0.0079766195,
-0.5025705695,
-0.1174258292,
0.1124356464,
-0.2010289431,
-0.5742502809,
-0.824760437,
-0.2109573483,
-0.5443255305,
-0.1427188218,
0.1902972162,
0.6463592649,
0.4386330843,
-0.7877591252,
-0.0503133908,
-0.2958411872,
0.7928599715,
-0.8226940036,
0.4891724885,
0.2881376743,
0.0671532378,
-0.4758706093,
0.0212307088,
-0.6154797077,
0.116951324,
0.1246985346,
-0.1931729913,
0.0693174824,
0.5142042637,
0.2103236169,
0.0812990814,
-0.6423573494,
0.3411231041,
-0.2084852308,
-0.1568994671,
0.9727593064,
0.4414010048,
0.7534099221,
-0.0256346781,
-0.30214715,
-0.2407537103,
-1.2341958284,
0.0135791209,
0.5797362924,
0.2797937989,
-0.2177725583,
0.759773314,
-0.2582963407,
0.6371130943,
0.0057411809,
-0.3299813271,
0.1928425878,
-0.3052255809,
-0.2909145355,
0.4310445786,
0.9153313041,
0.6610550284,
0.5303815007,
-0.2062914222,
-0.1672658026,
0.2150688767,
0.3447344303,
-0.9616299868,
0.0097351596,
0.0964445323,
0.0721237138,
-1.041741848,
-0.1761751473,
-0.389867872,
-0.313875556,
-0.2992158532,
0.3819045126,
-0.5535436273,
-0.2532448173,
0.5631551743,
0.4244473279,
0.1300133169,
0.0679561943,
-1.2208842039,
0.142767936,
0.9954233766,
0.2758687437,
-0.1613993049,
-0.1533056498,
-0.7318021059,
0.4708597362,
-0.7235991955,
0.369710207,
-0.2202982605,
-0.4520440102,
0.0370159931,
0.1601707786,
-0.1002975181,
-0.0839536935,
0.5730464458,
-0.7050674558,
0.1839370579,
0.0966958702,
-0.649454236,
-0.2422020435,
0.1964758784,
-0.5242450833,
0.8439719677,
-0.1325007081,
-0.6832286716,
0.3080175221,
-0.6208581328,
-0.7186249495,
-0.2735450864,
-0.0505843461,
-0.4482253194,
0.0077382056,
0.1147902161,
0.2300324738,
0.1358121932,
0.4439508617,
-0.3703452349,
-0.1176316068,
0.3214179873,
-0.6829414964,
0.9341663718,
-0.0113195125,
-0.1683478057,
0.4764940739,
-0.7780325413,
0.1123814136,
-0.0464406572,
-0.6139661074,
-0.4890252948,
0.0984804705,
-0.2366636097,
0.3992592692,
0.1076449826,
-0.5003925562,
-0.1205834821,
-0.6491271257,
0.1468251944,
0.742459178,
0.2319839597,
0.6962034106,
-0.3410594165,
0.4377700686,
0.072732456,
0.2583561242,
0.0342978798,
-0.2906869948,
-0.8699258566,
0.0830348134,
0.3817909956,
0.8425965905,
-0.5078120828,
0.633444488,
-0.4984933138,
-0.2789782584,
-0.3330155909,
0.2252937257,
0.7096644044,
0.6439428926,
0.0838019997,
-0.1081732884,
-0.2789431214,
-0.6348864436,
-0.1162858754,
-0.4439505339,
-0.1191144735,
-0.1620905697,
0.0171647314,
-0.1684635282,
0.6764327884,
-0.257473886,
0.3591684401,
-0.0271471031,
0.1518743783,
-0.2685324252,
0.7835244536,
0.6180137992,
-0.7618312836,
-0.249205932,
-0.1131412312,
-0.8290640116,
-0.1492004842,
0.0592589267,
-0.4463088214,
0.5319278836,
0.3817478418,
-0.6751624346,
0.3072988987,
0.5927350521,
-0.3028205037,
0.2218034118,
0.0184427425,
0.2820564508,
-1.1226732731,
-0.1237119064,
-0.1092487946,
-0.4122137725,
-0.8111306429,
0.3142487407,
0.4723642766,
-0.1452840418,
-0.8813254237,
0.3560624421,
-0.0939424187,
0.306545347,
-0.205713287,
0.0610965453,
0.0147914756,
0.1767655313,
-0.005207316,
0.9321779609,
0.1938728839,
-0.5175639391,
-0.0484552234,
0.2760798633,
-0.2958427966,
0.5260098577,
-0.529435873,
0.2576903999,
-0.0854107514,
-0.2630726695,
-0.7747222185,
-0.4500811994,
0.123947531,
-0.3018957973,
0.4216423333,
-0.1886203885,
-0.4760137498,
0.2324656397,
-0.2914940715,
0.6349406242,
0.5398333073,
-0.1783854961,
0.3268823624,
0.6654338837,
-0.4353018403,
-0.732617259,
-0.3626469374,
-0.1333417594,
-0.4819605052,
-0.9759028554,
0.0017999584,
-0.2272402197,
-0.3816686571,
-0.1423235089,
-0.2398861498,
-0.1435500979,
0.4827016294,
0.4541256726,
0.5095182061,
-0.14901793,
0.1006929055,
0.4012686908,
-0.4224155247,
0.1666933149,
0.1182159483,
0.1986237466,
-0.0230970439,
-0.4736298621,
-0.2321050018,
0.3992224932,
0.6015958786,
-0.0432994813,
0.562780261,
-0.0324551314,
-0.5801060796,
0.193751201,
-0.3394413292,
-0.1480946541,
-0.579985261,
0.3234620392,
0.0879120156,
-0.8989723921,
-0.0681862161,
0.2692869902,
0.5292731524,
0.230808422,
0.4077935517,
-0.1236587018,
1.4329811335,
0.6786949635,
-0.0011587233,
0.2888745666,
0.3665398657,
0.3690975606,
-0.2224705666,
-0.0801706612,
-0.3686106801,
-0.1077263206,
-0.4173277617,
-0.3876109719,
0.3498339057,
0.2455206364,
-0.5700719953,
0.3572291732,
-0.1745816469,
0.7683814168,
0.2175532132,
-0.0321001224,
0.359383136,
0.0085385293,
-0.0716395453,
-0.1589360088,
-0.4363926351,
-0.631939888,
0.9489955902,
0.2825151086,
1.0435144901,
0.4119361639,
0.6898078322,
-0.0567593426,
0.5320525765,
-0.6889701486,
0.741623342,
-0.1160353348,
-0.9620251656,
-0.4775687456,
-0.4611397088,
-0.6010244489,
0.0334713608,
-0.4104070067,
-0.504542172,
-0.075288713,
0.2266807705,
-0.5944327712,
0.1926026046,
-0.7370659709,
0.7909581065,
-0.7787218094,
-0.3948926926,
-0.2635141611,
-0.6592057943,
0.5807366371,
-0.2190741897,
0.4063521028,
-0.4844955206,
-0.1588137448,
0.5081599951,
-0.4011280239,
0.90929842,
0.1315526217,
-0.2826620638,
0.0508023538,
0.5813891292,
0.5591934323,
-0.1151598319,
-0.2790106237,
0.1619030684,
-0.0117470231,
-0.2763986588,
-0.4507858455,
0.7374805808,
-0.4952061474,
-0.7921812534,
-0.3697271943,
-0.9972667694,
-0.3247552216,
0.4319112897,
-0.1360065639,
0.2090338171,
-0.0726490766,
0.2424277067,
0.8839300871,
-0.1523438841,
0.607901454,
0.6625372171,
-0.0554753803,
-0.4675790071,
0.7773448229,
-0.1482481211,
0.6375027895,
0.4282850921,
-0.1178262755,
-0.5018225312,
-0.681220293,
-0.621352613,
-0.0473559499,
-0.8221020699,
-0.2793914974,
-0.6279272437,
-0.3552341163,
-0.3430517316,
-0.396489501,
-0.237320289,
-0.9121311903,
-0.1267874986,
-0.723654449,
0.3898658454,
0.4792020917,
-0.1895005852,
0.2676004767,
-1.0589581728,
0.052783411,
0.2450432479,
0.2966810167,
-0.3146122396,
-0.126482293,
-0.0913837105,
0.0960057974,
-0.3856692612,
-0.6285269856,
0.2997303903,
0.0109745683,
0.3642088473,
0.5957311988,
0.3211072385,
0.5388527513,
-0.7091276646,
0.5186959505,
0.4819258749,
-0.852778852,
0.1568994224,
-0.5893249512,
-0.1633184105,
0.7533541322,
0.4083017409,
-0.4339036345,
-0.2523263395,
-0.3359196186,
-0.8791037798,
0.3219947517,
0.0637492388,
0.3382095993,
-0.2351631671,
0.2347916812,
0.0225456152,
0.2297363281,
-0.6272774339,
0.0769146606,
0.0663437545,
-0.6473859549,
0.158931151,
-0.4275350571,
-0.4200515747,
-0.095288083,
0.7380682826,
-0.1033218578,
-0.1719705313,
-0.3400008082,
-0.2377897352,
-0.4627710879,
0.495041728,
0.6798005104,
0.5306433439,
-0.0551154725,
0.2085340768,
0.3804991543,
-0.2562409639,
0.578101635,
-0.0919351056,
-0.3080698252,
-0.5116197467,
0.2269875854,
0.4817590714,
0.7606711984,
-0.5786299109,
0.4810069799,
0.0338417441,
-0.1406539232,
-0.0623938963,
0.8114842176,
0.2216286808,
-0.2344993204,
-0.0832434744,
-0.0357474573,
-0.031741824,
-0.1646429449,
0.3944483399,
0.352309078,
-0.4887975454,
-0.2543790936,
1.0052508116,
0.5278974771,
-0.5179534554,
0.4270604551,
0.0050795618,
-0.2766894698,
0.4852276146,
0.4175518453,
0.8987085223,
-0.452984035,
-0.0590303428,
0.2626508474,
0.5082562566,
-0.0240932386,
0.456487745,
0.4528050721,
-0.7455714345,
-0.4558236003,
-0.5981596112,
-0.4083086252,
-0.0486911349,
-0.4322387874,
0.1991990805,
-0.4726424813,
0.0858610794,
-0.1403564066,
-0.4178818762,
-0.1440902054,
0.3363629282,
-0.0051619532,
1.0088165998,
-0.8388177156,
0.8273069859,
0.5019987822,
-0.2720859349,
-0.9312705398,
-0.1283551902,
0.3408649862,
-0.6323072314,
0.2261426002,
0.2682808638,
-0.2417455316,
0.0721012875,
-0.4157442749,
-0.6956573129,
0.8920935392,
0.7199786901,
-0.7299638987,
-0.2237181664,
0.7185427547,
0.3346836865,
-0.2621034086,
-0.2565701902,
0.4866782129,
0.2345425785,
-0.0146882711,
-0.6612145305,
0.2764616609,
-0.2009835541,
-0.1643805802,
0.5006861687,
-0.299800843,
0.4826435447,
-0.4450716376,
-0.2669551373,
0.2185052484,
0.3814282119,
0.4709130526,
0.2123263776,
0.6279949546,
0.8417560458,
0.6375815272,
-0.1800927222,
1.0136752129,
-0.5703393221,
-0.027064465,
0.8811977506,
-0.1916480064,
0.7863335013,
0.3889662921,
0.0474930666,
0.2749581635,
0.5939644575,
0.6612051129,
0.6007328033,
-0.1490801126,
-0.5301182866,
-0.6333926916,
0.1001476571,
-0.3263102472,
0.0871462449,
0.3040744066,
-0.2021666318,
-0.1125334799,
-0.5068512559,
0.3903144896,
-0.140020147,
-0.0160508081,
0.8114927411,
0.1862612069,
-0.5817745328,
0.4053233862,
-0.0076350668,
0.2541348338,
-0.4187332094,
0.0318457149,
-0.2409007996,
0.2345722765,
-0.2061035335,
-0.9495418668,
0.3965768218,
-0.0151873492,
-0.0892369747,
-0.069062829,
0.5058328509,
-0.5183568597,
-0.6696428657,
0.0263569709,
0.1359283626,
-0.1321032941,
0.3000305295,
-0.6039528251,
-0.1497527063,
-0.1979983896,
-0.0663390756,
0.5621801615,
0.4438367784,
-0.4550692141,
0.6232089996,
0.8775106668,
-0.3377564549,
0.1994637549,
-0.1369694769,
0.5919384956,
-0.6930713654,
-0.5880233049,
-0.8655146956,
0.8733812571,
-0.0068003889,
0.0466537885,
0.5930225849,
0.4896200001,
0.6626223326,
0.04627854,
0.7011674643,
0.1429664195,
0.0573274232,
-0.5834050179,
1.1161789894,
-0.4405432642,
0.2412261516,
-0.1793095022,
-0.6327639222,
-0.6561381817,
0.3907728791,
-0.3755760193,
-0.2458766848,
0.4162568152,
1.0067826509,
-0.150167346,
0.1026457995,
0.3830291927,
-0.0942926705,
0.4887658954,
0.6072943807,
0.6881014705,
-0.4670106769,
0.6274057031,
-0.3271877468,
-0.2241536677,
-0.065833196,
-1.402884841,
-0.8453469276,
-0.0412664972,
-0.4381328225,
-0.3405784667,
0.2444778085,
0.8984494805,
0.8233632445,
-1.0673797131,
-0.114633292,
-0.2031013668,
0.2377124429,
0.0262226369,
-0.1447675526,
0.1670245081,
-0.1272554696,
-0.6453624368,
0.6231814623,
0.4672332704,
0.3669114411,
0.0170807559,
-0.379034549,
0.0359415896,
0.3925082982,
0.4061208367,
0.3587502241,
-0.3801036477,
-0.5720827579,
-0.0079550408,
-0.4027923942,
-0.0026961172,
0.425968796,
-0.0711641014,
0.3022495508,
0.5901922584,
0.8507524729,
-0.2149597853,
0.3104740381,
0.8398890495,
-0.8313170671,
0.3100600839,
0.0068383641,
0.4827471972,
0.5233649611,
-0.6019822955,
0.6648014784,
-0.0675358325,
-0.561640501,
-0.9209740758,
0.353304714,
-0.8246611953,
0.2271416634,
1.1799999475,
-0.1626341045,
-0.2082133591,
-0.1374695748,
0.0349145606,
0.1876404285,
-0.2715163827,
0.985691011,
0.5333635211,
0.0248936638,
-0.1305937171,
-0.4622532725,
0.5407027602,
0.4703382254,
-1.0332540274,
0.108721137,
0.6724023223,
0.6630460024,
0.0175434723,
0.2109008729,
-0.5063350201,
0.5268388987,
-0.3269658089,
0.0579757281,
-0.1899391562,
-0.3021731973,
-0.2964028716,
0.098593004,
0.172840029,
-0.170199275
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11794v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11794v3 | DataComp-LM: In search of the next generation of training sets for language models | 2024-06-17T17:42:57 | 2024-06-20T17:43:05 | Jeffrey Li, Alex Fang, Georgios Smyrnis, Maor Ivgi, Matt Jordan, Samir Gadre, Hritik Bansal, Etash Guha, Sedrick Keh, Kushal Arora, Saurabh Garg, Rui Xin, Niklas Muennighoff, Reinhard Heckel, Jean Mercat, Mayee Chen, Suchin Gururangan, Mitchell Wortsman, Alon Albalak, Yonatan Bitton, Marianna Nezhurina, Amro Abbas, Cheng-Yu Hsieh, Dhruba Ghosh, Josh Gardner, Maciej Kilian, Hanlin Zhang, Rulin Shao, Sarah Pratt, Sunny Sanyal, Gabriel Ilharco, Giannis Daras, Kalyani Marathe, Aaron Gokaslan, Jieyu Zhang, Khyathi Chandu, Thao Nguyen, Igor Vasiljevic, Sham Kakade, Shuran Song, Sujay Sanghavi, Fartash Faghri, Sewoong Oh, Luke Zettlemoyer, Kyle Lo, Alaaeldin El-Nouby, Hadi Pouransari, Alexander Toshev, Stephanie Wang, Dirk Groeneveld, Luca Soldaini, Pang Wei Koh, Jenia Jitsev, Thomas Kollar, Alexandros G. Dimakis, Yair Carmon, Achal Dave, Ludwig Schmidt, Vaishaal Shankar | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | We introduce DataComp for Language Models (DCLM), a testbed for controlled
dataset experiments with the goal of improving language models. As part of
DCLM, we provide a standardized corpus of 240T tokens extracted from Common
Crawl, effective pretraining recipes based on the OpenLM framework, and a broad
suite of 53 downstream evaluations. Participants in the DCLM benchmark can
experiment with data curation strategies such as deduplication, filtering, and
data mixing at model scales ranging from 412M to 7B parameters. As a baseline
for DCLM, we conduct extensive experiments and find that model-based filtering
is key to assembling a high-quality training set. The resulting dataset,
DCLM-Baseline enables training a 7B parameter language model from scratch to
64% 5-shot accuracy on MMLU with 2.6T training tokens. Compared to MAP-Neo, the
previous state-of-the-art in open-data language models, DCLM-Baseline
represents a 6.6 percentage point improvement on MMLU while being trained with
40% less compute. Our baseline model is also comparable to Mistral-7B-v0.3 and
Llama 3 8B on MMLU (63% & 66%), and performs similarly on an average of 53
natural language understanding tasks while being trained with 6.6x less compute
than Llama 3 8B. Our results highlight the importance of dataset design for
training language models and offer a starting point for further research on
data curation. | [
-0.3840751052,
-0.7096797228,
0.3048983514,
-0.1333581805,
-0.1820856184,
0.3032336831,
-0.3192958534,
-0.1119647473,
-0.36577034,
0.5960382819,
-0.5701571107,
-0.7432522178,
-0.573243618,
0.0755413026,
-0.6639484167,
0.8260958791,
-0.0477698371,
0.1636057645,
-0.1820099503,
-0.0967242792,
-0.523863554,
-0.7420572042,
-0.7760211825,
-0.3575238883,
0.6810721755,
0.4777920842,
0.7736290097,
0.8061109185,
0.4737691879,
0.1231749207,
-0.0855038315,
0.212383762,
-0.7875035405,
0.0353665538,
0.0419317894,
-0.4855227768,
-0.4651907384,
0.4473405182,
0.6486461759,
1.2102917433,
-0.3112699986,
0.1233582944,
-0.0486398824,
0.741083324,
-0.594369173,
0.2292714566,
-0.8580068946,
-0.0691851005,
-0.2513152957,
-0.1267428547,
-0.6542265415,
-0.2646165192,
-0.359387666,
-0.5064529777,
0.3920584023,
0.3280975223,
0.6253554821,
0.3342858553,
-0.2722680271,
-0.1178135872,
-0.4993624091,
0.8836343884,
-0.8603169322,
0.6799531579,
0.6945720911,
0.33313936,
-0.37481457,
-0.788957715,
-0.6018612981,
-0.2494147718,
-0.071125403,
-0.0697187632,
-0.2264136523,
0.0448977128,
0.5063605905,
0.4692291617,
-0.7427278161,
0.3753315508,
-0.2952548265,
-0.0291483775,
0.5861625075,
0.3835964501,
-0.00396364,
0.2562030256,
0.0210715085,
-0.2093577385,
-1.0314842463,
-0.1305688024,
0.4307506084,
0.6724638939,
-0.1378462315,
0.4741143584,
-0.4264183939,
1.148252368,
-0.2613898218,
0.0554215573,
0.1557517648,
-0.5286155939,
-0.3755273223,
-0.3003642261,
0.5783976316,
0.2947372198,
0.3673945963,
-0.2046384513,
-0.3426071405,
0.1135984063,
0.1988081783,
-0.7861788273,
-0.4753686786,
0.2816167772,
-0.4334495068,
-0.5273347497,
-0.1249481291,
-0.6044285297,
-0.4920426607,
-0.7701743841,
-0.0683421791,
-0.0528179668,
-0.3314477503,
0.3896007836,
0.0676581115,
0.0129490821,
0.2858296037,
-0.875046432,
0.6843264699,
0.7203720808,
0.6291809082,
-0.4518978298,
-0.2576570511,
-0.7945303321,
-0.3061269224,
-0.6057668924,
0.626306355,
-0.6807028055,
-0.279466182,
0.1993254274,
-0.0476731956,
-0.1610588133,
-0.7970823646,
0.5565052629,
-0.5636662245,
0.3019428253,
-0.2092663646,
-0.8514630198,
-0.0158377606,
0.194656238,
-0.8407629132,
1.2099479437,
0.2976675928,
-0.7627570033,
0.4938367307,
-0.5069285035,
-0.1875248253,
0.0614805818,
-0.171471253,
-0.2793579102,
0.0866707638,
0.2386775613,
0.3517275751,
-0.4290198386,
0.4577134252,
-0.5751796365,
-0.5261402726,
0.227261737,
-0.5391052365,
0.9461148977,
0.3261520267,
0.0742519572,
0.0474265665,
-0.9574671388,
0.0713344738,
0.0718966946,
-0.4216175973,
-0.1949645728,
-0.0391198657,
0.1404413134,
0.2631495595,
0.0155602498,
-0.4937064648,
0.1290018409,
-0.2520697713,
0.2933959067,
0.644377768,
-0.3258621693,
0.2736690342,
-0.3421721458,
0.5147996545,
0.0590376966,
0.2378908098,
-0.090668194,
-0.234028846,
-0.8772041202,
-0.3070291877,
0.3968991339,
0.2115007937,
-0.5801888108,
0.5648955703,
-0.2134245038,
-0.5769522786,
-0.7897814512,
0.2482502013,
0.1650824249,
0.6110655069,
0.3936777711,
-0.2324719578,
-0.76924932,
-0.6825191975,
0.0406637713,
-0.1645416766,
0.144838959,
0.0696701854,
0.3339892924,
-0.1118472517,
1.0995869637,
-0.4689165354,
-0.0165487379,
-0.502517581,
-0.0412330367,
0.6150658131,
0.2192552686,
0.4222787917,
-0.5707994103,
-0.4558194876,
-0.191351667,
-0.5288740396,
-0.3879712522,
0.1803750098,
-0.0009350293,
0.2771918476,
0.6008908153,
-0.427462548,
0.4274039567,
0.8146815896,
-0.1892605871,
0.4902590513,
-0.1432947069,
0.011021954,
-0.9279366136,
0.3076996803,
-0.2798973918,
-0.351842612,
-0.86877352,
-0.0385808349,
0.1715200394,
-0.1173514724,
-0.5526764393,
0.755998373,
-0.3113570511,
-0.0269859657,
-0.5451356173,
0.2060277015,
0.0956187025,
0.4524525106,
0.1305091232,
0.7543674111,
0.70403862,
-0.6095053554,
0.4311788678,
0.2107194066,
-0.4958834946,
0.281268388,
-0.5923908949,
0.2849485278,
0.0365351625,
0.3263342381,
-0.9360150099,
0.1976350695,
-0.0160427894,
-0.1720859408,
0.2880368531,
-0.0952917114,
-0.7114316225,
-0.5147022009,
-0.1368561685,
0.0947537124,
0.4511331618,
-0.6808329821,
-0.0808936059,
0.4480210543,
-0.0348047577,
-0.6588968039,
-0.4603377283,
0.1405678838,
-0.1246337295,
-0.2081717253,
0.0204916541,
-0.3430635035,
-0.4202514589,
-0.2175342441,
0.0304901656,
-0.1897782087,
0.291549623,
0.1344582587,
0.3266712725,
-0.0263097044,
0.168715775,
-0.3592259586,
-0.1559581012,
-0.0244197957,
-0.0374700278,
0.9295959473,
0.2198971361,
-0.3715600967,
-0.1461691409,
0.2107172012,
0.2683372796,
-0.1950659007,
0.7064889073,
0.3719571233,
-0.3454622328,
-0.2748321295,
-0.3350814283,
-0.2407765239,
-0.4184743762,
0.3230346441,
-0.4078605175,
-0.875613451,
0.4383500218,
0.178113699,
0.2911101282,
0.2377647012,
0.6868518591,
0.0040591867,
0.9926599264,
0.6552980542,
-0.4625980258,
0.4588997364,
-0.2989285588,
0.1066225395,
-0.6406581402,
-0.000049506,
-0.6659939885,
-0.1598137766,
-0.481933862,
-0.4551026225,
-0.2292226702,
0.040983256,
-0.2294439226,
0.472365737,
-0.12790142,
0.3254358768,
0.6083132029,
0.0203277785,
0.4977863431,
-0.0519004464,
-0.0921339989,
0.0185619816,
-0.8334922791,
-0.4097138047,
1.4332652092,
0.3498522639,
1.0801984072,
-0.3535435498,
0.4999631643,
0.3127216399,
0.3203712702,
-0.6698105931,
0.5209953785,
-0.3164249957,
-0.5738346577,
-0.2103130668,
-0.5144443512,
-1.0005565882,
0.0973143652,
0.028889494,
-0.2797790468,
0.091032654,
0.0965508446,
-0.0525405779,
0.2878119648,
-0.4114242196,
0.822830081,
0.0420214683,
-0.1238908917,
-0.2679639757,
-0.4662920237,
0.196068123,
-0.2755791843,
0.2532006204,
-0.3761763275,
0.1076519489,
0.5331939459,
-0.388288945,
0.7553961873,
-0.175795868,
-0.2049170136,
0.0891377926,
0.0003829864,
0.4145477414,
-0.1093715802,
-0.3641072214,
0.1844816208,
-0.2355998904,
-0.3184460104,
-0.5513105989,
0.5193174481,
-0.6574477553,
-0.3570582271,
-0.2711590827,
-0.9053869247,
-0.1544603556,
0.0820615888,
-0.0562999882,
0.6694793105,
-0.2612451017,
0.4277694523,
0.4890564382,
-0.1737398207,
0.3389900327,
0.7797885537,
-0.3775442839,
-0.2582382858,
0.5973958969,
-0.0293278284,
0.5299406648,
0.4789561331,
0.051652275,
-0.3470700085,
-0.8505435586,
-0.1164138019,
0.0879526511,
-0.6943475604,
-0.2838020027,
-0.5835714936,
-0.4105223119,
-0.4757665694,
0.2777336538,
-0.423805356,
-0.4176514447,
-0.1675748527,
-0.1520062089,
0.3802454174,
0.5907195807,
-0.0140638081,
0.3395150304,
-0.4093829393,
0.3247639239,
0.051690761,
0.3416727185,
-0.3268371522,
-0.8442953229,
-0.482390821,
0.2360854,
0.0048447326,
-0.3501352668,
0.4508032501,
0.1954024136,
0.759765923,
0.021612186,
0.0353691541,
0.6055377126,
-0.5845028162,
0.5967792273,
-0.0744091272,
-0.5967187881,
0.5652112365,
-0.2246603966,
0.4119433463,
0.7425513268,
0.3479291499,
-0.811214447,
-0.591843605,
-0.6236615777,
-0.4104441702,
0.7370682955,
0.1802994907,
0.0454335585,
-0.015734354,
0.2578731179,
0.3391004205,
0.4193816781,
-0.5240131617,
-0.3710355461,
0.0870745331,
-0.3617883921,
-0.3677683175,
-0.0864322856,
-0.1192914471,
-0.4219270051,
0.6318495274,
-0.1601356417,
-0.0774678141,
-0.353725642,
-0.1651189178,
-0.0969519317,
-0.0073786913,
0.3616459072,
0.9118115902,
-0.4391742647,
0.2747344375,
0.0423877127,
-0.6068032384,
-0.0017372029,
0.2654792964,
-0.0706295744,
0.0861104801,
0.4123552442,
0.9833871126,
-0.0456982553,
-0.680185914,
0.3647406399,
-0.2056952417,
-0.2052446008,
-0.0240210909,
0.214962244,
-0.0669748038,
-0.2006551772,
0.0631655604,
-0.2194721699,
0.0814356357,
-0.4721108377,
0.4848194718,
0.294254601,
-0.4234697521,
-0.2339785397,
0.5195271969,
-0.0016430428,
-0.0258313771,
0.9228357077,
0.0404948667,
-0.2255699784,
0.5192829967,
0.4924014807,
0.607413888,
-0.1215664074,
0.2238644511,
0.4527532458,
0.2709899545,
-0.1426195055,
0.4367935359,
0.1863675863,
-0.870872736,
-0.4163123667,
-0.7236428261,
-0.7100060582,
0.4945123494,
-0.58734864,
0.7252116799,
-0.2477397919,
0.1488966048,
-0.1596953869,
0.3289178908,
-0.9293583035,
0.3894442916,
0.0766775459,
1.2197072506,
-0.9888148904,
1.3095569611,
0.3738994002,
-0.3078507185,
-0.5894758701,
-0.4408958852,
-0.0518345945,
-1.0102143288,
0.6546658278,
0.1921966076,
0.3611053824,
0.1732998937,
-0.6540218592,
-0.7171080112,
0.9224953651,
0.3991520703,
-0.7554308176,
0.178909272,
0.4873420298,
0.5617507696,
-0.5748569965,
0.2281123102,
0.9536380768,
0.3443567455,
0.0355506614,
-0.7303994894,
-0.1044266,
-0.2564620674,
-0.1099255234,
0.1053312123,
-0.220810622,
0.9525936246,
-0.0164439473,
-0.0215538293,
0.0226024538,
0.4057195485,
0.4863512516,
0.0638096556,
0.6322540641,
0.7455273867,
0.7607621551,
-0.1160972267,
1.0470839739,
-0.2163285017,
0.342933774,
1.5649346113,
-0.3685288131,
0.908924818,
0.4558297098,
-0.356007576,
0.2226262391,
0.9114682078,
-0.0485379584,
0.6343058348,
0.5682524443,
-0.0899964124,
-0.1473426223,
-0.2836100459,
-0.2003529966,
0.3378433585,
0.1773821712,
-0.338478893,
-0.3141275048,
0.0457760245,
0.0450476632,
0.169923678,
-0.0362992585,
0.6363273859,
0.1239074469,
-0.4876469374,
0.7087602019,
-0.3687421083,
0.3770914674,
-0.5445635915,
-0.0082896277,
-0.6800686121,
0.2203387171,
0.0084025059,
-0.8185963035,
0.2158432305,
0.100231044,
-0.1345522553,
-0.3549611568,
0.6068076491,
-0.7821436524,
-0.4381768405,
0.338572681,
0.5942409039,
0.3716470897,
-0.1735795885,
-0.7319261432,
0.395648092,
-0.2197949737,
-0.2833975255,
0.1523863673,
0.3409448266,
0.1486909688,
0.6384795904,
0.7392802835,
0.417652458,
0.1099279225,
0.7962981462,
1.0003076792,
-0.4927513897,
-0.0618714169,
-0.7515410781,
0.4825051725,
-0.1843587905,
-0.1897748858,
0.5392614603,
0.8015158772,
1.0224692822,
0.0374500118,
0.7985326052,
-0.0505677909,
0.765933454,
-0.5060294271,
0.6081201434,
-0.4858465791,
0.1613119096,
0.0978798494,
-1.0967806578,
-0.3817411959,
0.2518300414,
-0.0915456861,
0.0037683561,
0.7627120018,
0.9751014113,
-0.0889196545,
-0.0806565434,
0.5735992193,
0.1120515168,
0.6030786633,
0.5336517692,
0.7247290015,
-0.5534023643,
0.4307224154,
-0.3729999661,
-0.1655902416,
-0.0477167964,
-0.8837866783,
-1.1775012016,
-0.5554233193,
-0.3385771215,
0.0004443375,
-0.0022486181,
0.7534132004,
0.7463772893,
-0.9560306668,
-0.5432212949,
-0.3209407628,
-0.0449891202,
-0.2436870933,
-0.1571108699,
0.2124160379,
-0.7206534743,
-0.871337235,
0.5960485935,
0.0105633,
-0.0555983372,
-0.3815015554,
-0.134602204,
-0.3201754093,
-0.1627793759,
0.4801766574,
-0.0161165725,
-0.4665569365,
-0.2554715574,
0.07535512,
-0.3597359657,
0.0642731115,
0.7725892067,
-0.7199572921,
0.5385606289,
0.4547183216,
0.629537344,
0.3906518817,
-0.3049015105,
0.9180199504,
-0.8190123439,
0.297868669,
0.0526751727,
0.4258956313,
0.5395596027,
0.0674163252,
0.9132380486,
0.2001277208,
-0.48823753,
-1.0481086969,
0.1303204149,
-0.8755517006,
-0.0892990083,
1.2401374578,
-0.0108614052,
0.0459581278,
-0.1854431778,
-0.2379599512,
0.4306617379,
-0.1482674479,
0.601762116,
0.9058263302,
0.2106766403,
-0.2577626109,
-0.9019536972,
0.6900376678,
0.0879467726,
-1.0875056982,
0.654576838,
0.4008893967,
0.0224289764,
-0.3142390847,
0.6764836907,
-0.1749097407,
0.0773972198,
0.0091152946,
0.0954294205,
-0.1452798843,
-0.4310620725,
-0.3751296401,
-0.1754336953,
0.1924236715,
-0.1470715851
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11785v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11785v1 | CELL your Model: Contrastive Explanation Methods for Large Language Models | 2024-06-17T17:39:10 | 2024-06-17T17:39:10 | Ronny Luss, Erik Miehling, Amit Dhurandhar | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | The advent of black-box deep neural network classification models has sparked
the need to explain their decisions. However, in the case of generative AI such
as large language models (LLMs), there is no class prediction to explain.
Rather, one can ask why an LLM output a particular response to a given prompt.
In this paper, we answer this question by proposing, to the best of our
knowledge, the first contrastive explanation methods requiring simply
black-box/query access. Our explanations suggest that an LLM outputs a reply to
a given prompt because if the prompt was slightly modified, the LLM would have
given a different response that is either less preferable or contradicts the
original response. The key insight is that contrastive explanations simply
require a distance function that has meaning to the user and not necessarily a
real valued representation of a specific response (viz. class label). We offer
two algorithms for finding contrastive explanations: i) A myopic algorithm,
which although effective in creating contrasts, requires many model calls and
ii) A budgeted algorithm, our main algorithmic contribution, which
intelligently creates contrasts adhering to a query budget, necessary for
longer contexts. We show the efficacy of these methods on diverse natural
language tasks such as open-text generation, automated red teaming, and
explaining conversational degradation. | [
-0.5120928884,
-0.7962343097,
0.6318552494,
0.1636485159,
-0.2309836596,
-0.0061006914,
-0.3001076877,
-0.4507491887,
0.0958796069,
0.3123490214,
-0.7391909361,
-0.4369622767,
-0.233989656,
0.0937945172,
-0.5065306425,
0.8967173696,
0.1575887501,
0.0743597373,
-0.4953229725,
-0.0318117663,
-0.4056429267,
-0.4109119177,
-0.8535635471,
-0.7748334408,
0.8760359287,
0.5311844945,
0.6323055625,
0.7253018618,
0.238289386,
0.4101360738,
-0.3739489019,
-0.0279346425,
-0.2664161921,
-0.0012408877,
-0.1684368253,
-0.6800635457,
-0.0220718645,
-0.2648614645,
0.3444415927,
0.9235981703,
0.133794114,
-0.0369252674,
0.0719806477,
0.9049071074,
-0.5794447064,
-0.00288533,
-0.6911178231,
0.3205870986,
-0.0108059142,
-0.2166752815,
-0.4446330369,
-0.1262494922,
0.162420541,
-0.3445064425,
0.4539051354,
-0.1193423495,
0.7728919387,
0.1283327937,
-0.3052796721,
-0.3549349606,
-0.8434608579,
0.7456299663,
-0.6483323574,
-0.0175498128,
0.1559941471,
0.5724003911,
0.0155024566,
-0.7488567829,
-0.7303952575,
-0.3838281631,
-0.2974341214,
0.426591903,
-0.2459783703,
0.1605262011,
0.1550717354,
0.4886955917,
-0.5061975121,
0.4275028706,
-0.3914572001,
-0.3054090738,
0.5558283925,
0.3113475442,
0.0362704583,
-0.0197790563,
-0.3771718442,
0.115418002,
-0.6809923053,
-0.0790091753,
0.3613208234,
0.0862520635,
-0.3789483607,
0.5626001358,
-0.1924484521,
0.6668866873,
-0.0381135121,
0.3370814919,
-0.1405238509,
-0.2573715448,
-0.3108549118,
0.2008382529,
0.7192401886,
0.3527151942,
0.1858998686,
-0.2538433075,
-0.0720989332,
0.1520099044,
0.2064510882,
-1.0450998545,
-0.1778700352,
0.3969117403,
-0.5865502954,
-0.3928149939,
-0.4082694948,
-1.157820344,
-0.5647834539,
-0.3884361386,
0.1783928424,
-0.0649006516,
-0.052398622,
-0.161549598,
0.078870289,
0.1379243433,
0.3825995326,
-0.990439415,
0.3817962408,
0.3949083686,
0.8615207672,
-0.069831267,
-0.0272671822,
-0.4613929987,
-0.1137509122,
-0.5058805346,
0.8081972003,
-0.5782936811,
-0.3761095107,
0.184559837,
-0.2387603968,
0.1413244307,
-0.6577315927,
0.4339945018,
-0.5088874102,
0.3827900887,
-0.2806547582,
-0.4540948868,
-0.2204110324,
-0.0435019806,
-0.4504510164,
0.5546838641,
-0.2160948068,
-0.8504399061,
0.0238044914,
-0.9400987029,
-0.288564682,
0.2713734806,
-0.2075165808,
-0.4086787403,
0.2198811918,
0.2318865806,
0.4189969003,
-0.2927175462,
0.143106252,
-0.3470989466,
-0.31197083,
0.5780658126,
-0.4684121609,
0.7073241472,
0.4611376226,
-0.3812344074,
0.3753060997,
-0.6039178371,
-0.0751847029,
0.3185397983,
-0.150972724,
-0.1302007437,
0.3168171048,
-0.065641433,
0.0097278226,
0.1136825085,
-0.3365198374,
-0.185938254,
-0.4752041399,
0.6001701951,
0.7599847317,
-0.3311235607,
0.433595717,
-0.2224092185,
0.5149920583,
0.1659285426,
-0.2784152627,
-0.472605437,
-0.2696422935,
-0.6443061233,
0.0290375669,
0.200865835,
0.2846957147,
-0.5575956106,
0.0561099052,
0.0097466018,
-0.1568127573,
-0.5271729231,
0.0464514829,
0.4945125878,
0.8399381042,
0.3894315064,
0.1499423385,
-0.5261089802,
-1.3897252083,
-0.1434939057,
-0.1661729664,
-0.0992742702,
0.602637589,
0.5024198294,
-0.180395171,
0.7807453871,
-0.6373156905,
0.1988489628,
-0.3702928722,
0.1523389816,
0.0990912318,
0.1693147719,
0.4394199848,
-1.0599942207,
-0.1095080748,
0.0639245212,
-0.5475609899,
-0.3189604878,
-0.1531297714,
0.0506310649,
0.0774280131,
0.7600780129,
-0.4203726053,
0.1738187075,
0.510189712,
-0.1235704422,
0.7581819296,
-0.2326877415,
-0.1881322116,
-1.1359659433,
-0.0158730168,
0.2127871662,
-0.2180181891,
-0.7119163275,
0.1814105958,
-0.1924554259,
-0.2370852083,
-0.2132300436,
0.7284836173,
-0.312202394,
-0.1303238422,
-0.3897052407,
0.5010371804,
-0.0596951358,
0.3460533917,
-0.0498607494,
0.7852720618,
0.4736391604,
-0.8326121569,
0.3736336529,
0.2465127259,
-0.1794146895,
0.2350975871,
-0.7941744328,
0.1469452679,
-0.4595727921,
0.2331693172,
-1.3693703413,
-0.3290397525,
0.3639069796,
-0.3960625529,
0.079887107,
-0.2714440823,
-0.1219950765,
-0.532194674,
-0.0569127314,
0.3769953251,
0.4242447317,
-1.0413367748,
0.3487720191,
-0.1014905497,
-0.2498293072,
-0.5016135573,
-0.7780591249,
0.0681994557,
-0.4149184823,
-0.4678160846,
0.6720713377,
-0.5231794119,
-0.637904942,
-0.0730292052,
-0.2828399837,
-0.2848300934,
0.4374655783,
0.2646021843,
0.2400661558,
-0.5872821808,
0.4981957972,
0.0127400532,
-0.049788788,
0.3756226897,
-0.046075765,
0.5386655331,
-0.0922521949,
-0.0097613381,
-0.2497999221,
0.3431195915,
0.3891018629,
-0.2440928817,
0.6725761294,
0.5092509389,
-0.2426213771,
-0.360850811,
-0.4603756666,
-0.1971359104,
-0.4876308739,
0.3939392269,
-0.3526372313,
-0.790594697,
0.5883097649,
-0.0376249887,
-0.0829438865,
0.4194239676,
0.8071078062,
0.0398768745,
1.0549479723,
0.4495593905,
0.0916204527,
0.5803087354,
0.0673705116,
0.1946128011,
-0.5647383928,
-0.4181708097,
-0.9113342762,
-0.3414655328,
-0.6073242426,
-0.1223454103,
0.0256708711,
0.1929621696,
-0.027560411,
-0.1647758931,
-0.5436722636,
0.7191845775,
0.3431805968,
0.0823195577,
0.0478254519,
0.1345934868,
-0.0098609114,
0.1264130175,
-0.6466977596,
-0.5836971402,
0.6089980602,
0.3284932673,
0.6298777461,
-0.0379761532,
0.8196954131,
0.0038820212,
0.4896185398,
-0.9021017551,
0.6085258722,
-0.1388446838,
-0.4583380222,
-0.2311457843,
-0.6552117467,
-1.1330732107,
0.6224645972,
-0.279936552,
-0.8189772367,
-0.1057292372,
0.3662669063,
-0.2604188621,
0.1256091744,
-0.8920865655,
0.8268144727,
-0.1817148477,
-0.5801067352,
-0.3114406466,
-0.5215602517,
0.5806487203,
0.0479746945,
0.1636645347,
0.030394746,
0.0028898434,
0.7334625125,
-0.4364679158,
0.9017789364,
-0.1024597213,
0.0369521677,
0.1310366839,
0.0422862358,
0.2402331382,
0.0839768946,
-0.2206617594,
-0.2550994158,
-0.3331417143,
-0.5388992429,
-0.687525332,
0.8456034064,
-0.4310852587,
-0.78345263,
0.1218725964,
-0.638569057,
-0.0111060617,
-0.009436572,
0.3649540842,
0.6450781226,
-0.0932928547,
0.1292167753,
0.6186971664,
-0.5796973109,
0.787458837,
0.3801896572,
-0.1309865266,
-0.0119605279,
0.7788487077,
-0.2078053504,
0.0522073954,
0.4994814098,
0.8020572662,
-0.4985125363,
-0.9453445077,
-0.5028248429,
0.0634227917,
-0.7054378986,
-0.0419932492,
-0.4414469302,
-0.049239967,
-0.0377236567,
-0.3269537091,
0.091372557,
-0.260881573,
-0.3374727964,
-0.1760797054,
0.180150643,
0.7891849279,
0.1419267803,
0.3805254996,
-0.5212813616,
0.4812658727,
0.4252029061,
0.2619412541,
0.1971493512,
-0.3293981552,
-0.2472900301,
0.2033525854,
-0.378975749,
-1.0374019146,
0.3513171971,
0.0289241765,
0.5021397471,
0.4122223258,
-0.066064015,
0.7318071127,
-0.4086253345,
0.7966936231,
0.3141101897,
-0.9611382484,
0.4976395667,
-0.0493884943,
0.2936427593,
0.1253041476,
0.3252636492,
-0.3498658836,
-0.30669415,
-0.4900817871,
-0.8658123016,
0.4907721281,
0.2797400355,
0.271014303,
-0.0614490323,
0.6378425956,
0.1229867563,
0.1415084302,
-0.9830711484,
-0.4770924747,
-0.2786422372,
-0.2299271226,
-0.3525663614,
-0.2553659379,
-0.2017863691,
0.2288390696,
0.3703136742,
-0.2960707843,
0.3056153953,
0.3915736675,
-0.114392668,
-0.141249001,
0.6456398368,
0.8702155352,
0.8958607912,
0.0808207616,
0.3090036809,
0.2046670765,
0.0868400931,
-0.1357664466,
0.2698524296,
-0.0294062421,
0.1833333671,
0.612641871,
0.6984897852,
-0.036682982,
-0.5543082952,
0.3705616295,
0.0619784221,
-0.3533244431,
-0.0520064868,
-0.0196726955,
0.2854759395,
0.3013769388,
0.1775191873,
-0.3424894512,
0.2632214129,
-0.6362290978,
-0.0603261515,
0.6366503835,
-0.4681498706,
-0.1951180995,
0.7700725198,
0.1293175519,
-0.5598675609,
0.358723104,
0.0817351937,
-0.554741025,
1.0373952389,
0.7147756219,
0.9689250588,
-0.1712408513,
0.4904673994,
0.181231454,
-0.0874072537,
0.2114674151,
-0.0819927827,
-0.1851842999,
-0.6901271939,
-0.5472714901,
-0.5295789242,
-0.5330966115,
0.4640773833,
-0.655305028,
-0.2508562505,
-0.3808178604,
0.3923627138,
0.7614181042,
-0.0203244351,
-0.4663196504,
0.5119200349,
0.2355158031,
0.894972384,
-0.6703346372,
0.4935464859,
0.5671724081,
-0.4258572757,
-0.6006795168,
0.163690418,
-0.0559310466,
-0.8764743805,
0.8835636377,
0.2272381783,
-0.2426454723,
-0.2884079218,
-0.9430155158,
-0.1235986352,
0.7307415009,
0.3440666199,
-0.8074462414,
0.1198976785,
-0.0966540873,
0.7573575377,
-0.6147599816,
0.3434482217,
0.3578016758,
0.3785919249,
0.1791275591,
-0.2671202719,
0.1941746473,
-0.0911933258,
0.0288152695,
0.3025783896,
-0.396615535,
0.6237446666,
-0.6170080304,
-0.1256374121,
0.3596790433,
0.5870293379,
-0.1180330589,
0.7026650906,
0.4223606884,
0.2116143554,
0.7854222059,
-0.1131390184,
1.4236690998,
0.0260361154,
0.062474709,
1.0447776318,
-0.1101468503,
0.569619596,
0.4639082253,
0.0128901936,
0.5383330584,
0.7770611644,
-0.1102179736,
0.3614529371,
0.8060287237,
-0.3929240406,
-0.2211757004,
-0.1018314362,
-0.2722060382,
0.0968246013,
0.2260883749,
-0.4808326066,
-0.2904880047,
-0.1153672412,
-0.2829251289,
0.3146504462,
-0.5893573761,
0.9604221582,
0.1311770678,
-0.7091785669,
0.6567812562,
-0.0026161755,
0.2164854407,
-0.3838051856,
-0.0706036314,
-0.5181612968,
0.1623173505,
-0.4246435165,
-0.6376124024,
0.2701328397,
-0.0937850699,
-0.4104482532,
-0.0731360093,
0.5280553102,
-0.5716794133,
-0.2626335323,
0.3772422671,
0.3633155823,
0.2173124254,
0.0754877254,
-0.7790966034,
-0.1396391541,
-0.0193844587,
-0.0015006271,
0.2994576991,
0.3782835007,
0.0038784172,
0.9082669616,
0.5343132019,
-0.0383127443,
-0.0978591442,
0.2289928347,
0.8264117241,
-0.7290915847,
-0.38690418,
-1.130869031,
0.4141224623,
-0.0281701628,
-0.1568483114,
0.342662394,
0.5578605533,
0.5479602814,
-0.0351630449,
0.7738277912,
0.3912718296,
0.3191525638,
-0.897567749,
0.3156478107,
-0.7416708469,
0.5130627155,
-0.0918996781,
-0.9010568261,
-0.2260659486,
0.4973123968,
-0.3601674736,
0.0166551769,
0.9077064395,
0.8972608447,
-0.0431585908,
0.0953901112,
0.4227942526,
0.5770750642,
0.2240991145,
0.3987863958,
1.0401718616,
0.0573504828,
1.0605200529,
-0.220366329,
-0.0475863554,
-0.3049173951,
-0.8894199729,
-1.1306868792,
-0.3957219124,
-0.5444176793,
-0.5267350674,
0.3141216636,
0.7211784124,
0.7308754921,
-0.7557241917,
-0.301587075,
-0.4413442016,
0.5798488259,
-0.1474870294,
-0.2169473171,
0.3033748567,
-0.5525477529,
-0.7095378041,
0.4784710407,
0.1609575897,
0.2676104605,
-0.0607585497,
-0.0739271417,
0.3201295137,
0.2067344338,
0.5564382672,
0.2979182303,
-0.928374052,
-0.1070621386,
-0.3888553977,
0.0545114987,
0.3286860883,
0.9552893043,
-0.6493282318,
0.4194900692,
0.2780357599,
0.7361540198,
0.6956740618,
-0.0081893438,
0.7217927575,
-0.5183458924,
-0.0316173509,
0.2248099744,
0.3367073834,
0.3856217265,
-0.3115787208,
0.3277710378,
-0.095465906,
-0.3584648371,
-0.7314150929,
0.6853365302,
-1.0279753208,
-0.6526315212,
1.018974185,
-0.0750982761,
-0.2197440416,
-0.0952364057,
-0.4297678173,
0.0518690236,
-0.2915004194,
0.9072004557,
0.5999084711,
0.0095961634,
-0.3896625638,
-0.3680167496,
0.4922087193,
0.5984148979,
-1.1346166134,
0.338659972,
0.5195525885,
0.0955722332,
0.1909025908,
0.1691385657,
-0.0011975643,
0.2269665301,
-0.0169413127,
-0.2149125934,
-0.0844287574,
-0.2011808157,
-0.7879462242,
0.3352213204,
0.0116763739,
-0.3022438288
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11784v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11784v1 | MDCR: A Dataset for Multi-Document Conditional Reasoning | 2024-06-17T17:38:43 | 2024-06-17T17:38:43 | Peter Baile Chen, Yi Zhang, Chunwei Liu, Sejal Gupta, Yoon Kim, Michael Cafarella | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The same real-life questions posed to different individuals may lead to
different answers based on their unique situations. For instance, whether a
student is eligible for a scholarship depends on eligibility conditions, such
as major or degree required. ConditionalQA was proposed to evaluate models'
capability of reading a document and answering eligibility questions,
considering unmentioned conditions. However, it is limited to questions on
single documents, neglecting harder cases that may require cross-document
reasoning and optimization, for example, "What is the maximum number of
scholarships attainable?" Such questions over multiple documents are not only
more challenging due to more context having to understand, but also because the
model has to (1) explore all possible combinations of unmentioned conditions
and (2) understand the relationship between conditions across documents, to
reason about the optimal outcome. To evaluate models' capability of answering
such questions, we propose a new dataset MDCR, which can reflect real-world
challenges and serve as a new test bed for complex conditional reasoning that
requires optimization. We evaluate this dataset using the most recent LLMs and
demonstrate their limitations in solving this task. We believe this dataset
will facilitate future research in answering optimization questions with
unknown conditions. | [
-0.4632113874,
-0.6092410684,
0.9120678306,
-0.1756113172,
-0.0104531012,
0.2000395656,
-0.2171052396,
-0.033086244,
-0.180063352,
0.5292788744,
-1.0661714077,
-0.2642823458,
-0.6493319869,
0.425385654,
-0.3766458929,
0.8043872118,
-0.4417660534,
0.3941149712,
-0.7294345498,
-0.270927459,
-0.6129823923,
-0.522325635,
-0.4052618742,
0.0170144551,
0.4997422695,
0.6592032909,
0.0794281065,
0.1571592987,
0.9678881168,
0.2940799594,
0.3544050157,
0.3824186623,
-0.3168728054,
0.338780731,
-0.0682660341,
-0.5431601405,
-0.1749153435,
0.3098213375,
0.5094171762,
0.6596201062,
-0.1889953017,
0.2865633965,
0.0721909776,
0.671308279,
-0.6985216141,
0.0018846191,
-0.6463816166,
0.1287304908,
0.0216850135,
-0.3042764664,
-0.377959162,
-0.316067636,
0.1385994405,
-0.7678647637,
0.3779653311,
-0.0899016857,
0.6484575868,
0.4276501834,
-0.8042916656,
-0.4851300716,
-0.4859093726,
0.6403548717,
-0.2814245224,
0.3822118938,
0.3880296946,
0.7253462076,
-0.0886107609,
-0.9288854003,
-0.7704913616,
-0.178991124,
-0.1052488163,
0.2919547856,
0.2403420806,
0.2580496371,
0.3774877787,
0.3299801648,
-0.5521415472,
-0.3420687616,
-0.6167318821,
-0.410897404,
0.2274168134,
0.5156919956,
0.1531534195,
-0.2602185011,
-0.3335316777,
-0.0628143102,
-0.1930674762,
0.3295225501,
0.3809048533,
0.3181012273,
-0.158593446,
1.0316429138,
-0.2714447677,
0.905264318,
-0.1055249646,
-0.1632585973,
-0.0195485111,
-0.6100541353,
-0.1328110397,
-0.1188523248,
0.0809817463,
0.29498294,
0.1247256398,
0.1886248738,
-0.2537787557,
0.2350396216,
0.2283469737,
-0.7126412392,
0.0665428638,
0.4587337673,
-0.5986706614,
-0.1476220042,
0.150807932,
-0.7772920132,
-0.4280593693,
-0.6404417157,
0.4307482541,
-0.1495751441,
0.2010591328,
0.3665593863,
-0.3976988494,
0.2440565228,
0.3203967512,
-0.4258759916,
0.3309893906,
0.4652594924,
0.6276091933,
-0.2118154317,
-0.3288881779,
-0.5553035736,
-0.0532852262,
0.0074457722,
0.8383386731,
-0.837998867,
-0.2776758671,
-0.1079305783,
-0.0388525724,
-0.4485105574,
-0.0634881929,
1.0770665407,
-0.4779304564,
0.4453239441,
-0.490709424,
-0.5311317444,
-0.0797288045,
0.5426037908,
-0.668322742,
0.5181191564,
0.4269354045,
-0.9605163932,
0.5010842085,
-0.5618118644,
-0.3392318487,
-0.1077120379,
-0.4411927164,
-0.203334555,
-0.1598879099,
0.1169245839,
0.1969613731,
-0.8582729101,
0.4054355919,
-0.307286799,
-0.2900415361,
0.3230648935,
-0.5112163424,
0.5011391044,
0.3773051202,
-0.1344545782,
-0.175933674,
-0.8424548507,
0.3701322675,
-0.0482829213,
-0.8271147609,
-0.0823524296,
-0.041003529,
-0.3637650907,
0.2994218767,
0.3709275723,
-0.6181969643,
0.3217508495,
0.1510509998,
0.3694243729,
0.7247058153,
0.1956996322,
0.3060126305,
-0.67633605,
0.8664270639,
-0.0392330177,
0.3884505332,
0.0469837226,
-0.3087778389,
-0.931865871,
-0.3965740204,
0.5096088648,
0.6251565814,
-0.8223469853,
-0.0651051477,
0.0634081364,
-0.0186427291,
-0.6664184332,
-0.1473011971,
0.4863764346,
0.8208035231,
0.4224939644,
0.0215492733,
-1.0463491678,
-1.1170073748,
-0.2199419141,
0.2993641198,
0.2955512106,
0.5121584535,
0.6374130845,
-0.138560161,
0.7328677773,
-0.6546775699,
-0.4357472062,
-0.4589614272,
-0.1370025128,
0.4029427171,
0.3242372274,
0.2961021662,
-1.0443890095,
-0.2950133979,
-0.3933202922,
-0.6879070997,
-0.0490864478,
-0.440459609,
-0.1525661945,
0.1111568287,
0.3364074826,
-0.754979372,
0.5740624666,
0.6183488369,
-0.308187604,
0.5714196563,
-0.4143522382,
0.6654362082,
-0.724234879,
0.0542964041,
0.0442500003,
0.1972342581,
-0.3536398709,
0.1342843473,
0.0679647177,
-0.3667485118,
-0.0806377158,
0.6536824703,
-0.6446591616,
0.0669389814,
0.0023050958,
0.0557867102,
0.258566767,
0.4571733475,
-0.1017132625,
0.7646970749,
0.5242956877,
-0.5306258798,
0.1186110228,
0.4317383468,
-0.5887595415,
0.735617578,
-0.4972209632,
0.0155221736,
-0.1778357029,
0.4717004597,
-0.9062889218,
-0.3431170881,
0.0908356011,
-0.5150151253,
0.075641796,
-0.2293367535,
-0.4208895862,
-0.5287646651,
-0.1647331119,
0.4129924476,
0.0080864495,
-0.3836548924,
0.9334859252,
0.2898532152,
0.0121571561,
-0.6373217106,
-0.5681135654,
-0.0773183927,
0.0093095498,
-0.612097919,
0.0758428797,
-0.4538173079,
-0.196202144,
-0.0734427273,
-0.2791346312,
-0.2886882126,
-0.1329872459,
0.3208937049,
0.4590021968,
-0.0195880365,
-0.1558223218,
0.3432828188,
-0.0405585356,
0.0252184812,
-0.255453974,
0.4584746659,
0.2139362693,
-0.4100282788,
-0.177038148,
0.7367671132,
0.558283627,
-0.4501636326,
0.6127918959,
0.0343535468,
-0.4202621877,
-0.2869850397,
-0.589433372,
0.0215213485,
-0.4871203005,
0.0983771831,
-1.0456410646,
-0.7970446944,
0.4454798698,
0.2698923945,
-0.0241613071,
0.3943869174,
0.6694302559,
-0.0587947555,
1.076406002,
0.4187939763,
0.3988087475,
-0.0769139081,
-0.3911660612,
0.1474990845,
-0.9087168574,
-0.6923022866,
-0.7123106718,
-0.2881828249,
-0.319142431,
-0.547234118,
0.3524046242,
-0.217032373,
-0.1947496831,
0.1482904404,
-0.6378048658,
0.4510162175,
0.5901539326,
0.3589809537,
0.2449291795,
-0.2970627546,
-0.7718413472,
0.0261934586,
-0.6024844646,
-0.3547941446,
1.2994519472,
-0.1446463317,
0.4515934289,
0.1129684299,
0.3892687857,
0.5503392816,
0.1888943911,
-0.6799639463,
0.518596828,
-0.0898184553,
-1.0089284182,
-0.0622550026,
-0.6511442065,
-0.8270573616,
0.2272715867,
-0.3934875429,
-0.3857877254,
0.4321433306,
-0.1150264144,
-0.1400767714,
0.1848068833,
-0.516330719,
0.6563184857,
-0.3666785955,
-0.0744988844,
-0.0690754056,
-0.8478958011,
0.4641639292,
-0.4745975137,
0.3101491332,
-0.0465168804,
0.0423186906,
0.699554801,
-0.3371361196,
0.4908259809,
-0.2521514297,
0.3887831271,
0.3828047514,
0.1171096414,
0.3494494855,
0.0422217585,
-0.5559850335,
-0.3398659825,
0.4650523663,
-0.4098848701,
-0.5420833826,
0.6794556975,
-0.5937842131,
-0.6873244047,
-0.6782234907,
-0.7088202834,
-0.4885797799,
0.4138099253,
0.1701286584,
0.5623559952,
-0.0373182334,
0.1286247075,
0.3863438666,
0.003570392,
-0.0734652877,
0.6945371628,
0.2155068517,
-0.3468570411,
0.6006621718,
0.0479914881,
0.064717494,
0.4723652005,
0.1494821608,
-0.4244384766,
-0.7403370738,
-0.2724668682,
0.0958370864,
-1.1399558783,
-0.324824959,
-0.6905735135,
-0.1393902302,
-0.3156548142,
-0.1534282267,
0.2039837986,
-0.6420155168,
-0.2209398448,
-0.2186885476,
-0.1318778247,
0.420835048,
-0.1105341464,
-0.241825074,
-0.598457396,
0.6849085689,
0.3378538787,
0.2172614038,
-0.1547633559,
-0.7971534133,
-0.0067157764,
0.1165457517,
-0.174484238,
-0.703327775,
-0.1205065325,
0.2958742082,
1.0749742985,
0.0341032334,
0.4057047665,
0.4268786907,
-0.4151481986,
0.2318623513,
0.1180923432,
-0.7166618705,
0.4461546838,
-0.2618918121,
-0.0525369979,
1.2018111944,
0.6069398522,
-0.2755493224,
-0.1165783182,
-0.4402821958,
-0.4763884544,
0.4900257587,
0.2278648913,
-0.0493284948,
0.1443858445,
0.605486691,
0.161705792,
0.2042701244,
-0.4966582656,
-0.194067657,
-0.0645240322,
-0.2982541919,
0.0587636642,
-0.2173306048,
-0.4499832392,
-0.4917305112,
0.3886014819,
-0.1099562868,
0.1683192849,
0.3668539822,
-0.1197972149,
0.0189170837,
0.193427667,
0.6856151223,
0.8055666089,
-0.4812312722,
-0.0267431457,
0.1085661054,
-0.3334919214,
0.3694116175,
0.2865880132,
0.0080201346,
-0.4084692299,
0.3047077358,
0.4026902616,
-0.2070712745,
-0.8674349189,
0.6509856582,
-0.5343723297,
-0.6727686524,
-0.3221139312,
0.1281843781,
-0.1378946751,
0.205400154,
0.4425532222,
0.3115889132,
0.3314751387,
-0.720369339,
0.4460715353,
0.2871748507,
-0.4614686072,
0.2789503038,
0.6620978713,
0.2223529667,
-0.1380711049,
0.8177402616,
-0.0071335435,
-0.6429633498,
0.9324832559,
0.3781337142,
0.3133376539,
0.2474966049,
0.2938647568,
0.4407109916,
0.3174246848,
0.0587582774,
0.608577013,
-0.078635484,
-0.7600332499,
-0.1660274416,
-0.6881721616,
-0.6251906157,
-0.2439040393,
-0.8383638859,
0.4108505249,
-0.5222821236,
-0.1059578434,
0.0621291138,
0.21137923,
-0.8836278319,
0.7666671872,
-0.186188221,
1.1770164967,
-0.5727857351,
0.8924406171,
0.393707037,
-0.5094203949,
-0.8156502843,
-0.2416263074,
0.1023020446,
-0.8524398208,
0.5930067301,
0.2355126441,
-0.2257103771,
-0.1153440773,
-0.3142415881,
-0.537060082,
1.0808333158,
0.2961272597,
-0.6737369895,
-0.0684647337,
0.1289864033,
0.2542902231,
-0.608502984,
0.0480539389,
0.7129430175,
0.8144352436,
0.1907483786,
-0.5248677731,
0.2205020636,
-0.3479630947,
-0.4956612885,
0.1714856625,
-0.5178487897,
0.9187477827,
-0.6746342778,
-0.1020427868,
0.2792242765,
0.2371604741,
0.5363640189,
0.5610266328,
0.6180843711,
0.6113796234,
0.9586226344,
-0.1848213673,
1.4336016178,
-0.2304894775,
0.3178606927,
1.1316306591,
-0.4752273858,
0.497192353,
0.4115498364,
-0.1169409677,
0.2997507751,
0.8574457765,
-0.1726741195,
0.8588926792,
0.6000953317,
-0.4033308029,
-0.6450312138,
0.0128599694,
-0.3914809823,
0.5874392986,
0.2446966916,
-0.1563891023,
-0.004593431,
0.1661940366,
-0.3107070625,
0.1085739583,
-0.0788234845,
0.3362997472,
0.0927498937,
-0.7528551817,
0.2319190651,
0.2317395955,
0.3690852523,
-0.6138130426,
-0.1563255936,
-0.5482450724,
0.1693226397,
-0.1681378186,
-0.7529411912,
0.1089414135,
0.0274191163,
-0.5093174577,
0.2016669959,
0.6188708544,
0.0311481971,
-0.8953502178,
0.2070795447,
0.5020186901,
0.0093798861,
0.1894777715,
-0.9486578107,
0.0765509158,
0.073523514,
-0.144040063,
0.3385018706,
0.4944721162,
0.214843601,
1.0127102137,
0.8183222413,
0.1861531287,
-0.0259036832,
0.144711569,
1.093977809,
-0.4605666101,
-0.1857703477,
-0.383520335,
0.4497329295,
-0.0481752716,
-0.499630928,
0.5435190201,
0.831349194,
0.5345335007,
0.2089391947,
1.0628728867,
-0.2036824524,
0.7519872189,
-0.8166166544,
0.4027208388,
-0.8868829012,
0.4293975234,
0.023405809,
-0.687471211,
-0.1955664009,
0.4552402794,
-0.1709073484,
0.0666118562,
1.0443778038,
0.6171934605,
-0.1860886961,
-0.0667525157,
0.2178545445,
-0.1963048577,
0.1862421036,
0.7417834401,
1.0168318748,
-0.3043312728,
0.9444360733,
-0.195726335,
-0.1492684782,
0.079869695,
-0.7261329889,
-0.9438018203,
-0.8475904465,
-0.1037442386,
-0.5091861486,
0.2365142554,
0.6510218978,
0.5174983144,
-0.7508038878,
-0.0359397009,
0.1258714795,
0.2133449763,
0.1646785587,
-0.1795295328,
0.345274508,
-0.1247511655,
-0.4318107367,
0.4338859916,
0.0062525813,
-0.1022129804,
-0.1358195096,
-0.1285600364,
-0.3029312789,
0.5119395256,
0.2493029982,
0.2164551914,
-0.2817964554,
-0.2799328268,
0.0494722724,
-0.2459596545,
0.1559174955,
1.3909415007,
-0.4972566962,
0.3904159367,
0.488784641,
0.694878459,
0.6851574183,
0.0655805543,
0.5675644875,
-0.3057608604,
0.0967051312,
0.4213533998,
0.638697207,
0.128154546,
-0.351596117,
0.421166569,
0.0559054092,
-0.6177194715,
-0.8399761319,
0.3245729208,
-1.2730253935,
-0.638671279,
0.7853369713,
-0.1526103914,
0.1996840984,
-0.3647444844,
-0.2815476954,
0.1456250995,
-0.2495535165,
0.6946423054,
0.7450668812,
-0.2821009457,
-0.4255589545,
-0.8643994927,
0.2185019404,
0.3735359609,
-1.0659792423,
-0.2376960665,
0.5260203481,
0.4066440165,
-0.4172554016,
0.8273183107,
-0.0125121959,
0.3708848357,
0.0457137749,
-0.2733485997,
-0.11650116,
-0.609918654,
0.0415835455,
0.2774575651,
0.0096890964,
-0.1497479081
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11780v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11780v1 | Split, Unlearn, Merge: Leveraging Data Attributes for More Effective Unlearning in LLMs | 2024-06-17T17:35:52 | 2024-06-17T17:35:52 | Swanand Ravindra Kadhe, Farhan Ahmed, Dennis Wei, Nathalie Baracaldo, Inkit Padhi | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have shown to pose social and ethical risks such
as generating toxic language or facilitating malicious use of hazardous
knowledge. Machine unlearning is a promising approach to improve LLM safety by
directly removing harmful behaviors and knowledge. In this paper, we propose
"SPlit, UNlearn, MerGE" (SPUNGE), a framework that can be used with any
unlearning method to amplify its effectiveness. SPUNGE leverages data
attributes during unlearning by splitting unlearning data into subsets based on
specific attribute values, unlearning each subset separately, and merging the
unlearned models. We empirically demonstrate that SPUNGE significantly improves
the performance of two recent unlearning methods on state-of-the-art LLMs while
maintaining their general capabilities on standard academic benchmarks. | [
-0.2919432223,
-0.6021078825,
0.3388310969,
-0.3637621999,
-0.2572574914,
0.6100685596,
-0.4785698056,
-0.4192431569,
-0.2355304658,
0.679728806,
-0.57822299,
-0.4869350791,
-0.6244575381,
-0.4310823381,
-0.7615880966,
1.1944384575,
0.3370776772,
0.2171418518,
-0.4530396163,
-0.0774546713,
-0.1501517743,
-0.4111780822,
-0.5342122316,
-0.7218235135,
0.7740846872,
0.8585354686,
0.6893410683,
0.5579773784,
0.3980361819,
0.2833499312,
-0.2038799226,
0.6552386284,
-0.6817129254,
0.3591559827,
-0.3031340241,
-0.3749126792,
-0.4348675609,
0.4224963784,
0.4640714824,
1.2331591845,
-0.424623847,
0.1938566566,
0.3904109001,
1.0318713188,
-0.6491618156,
-0.1581130773,
-0.5058447719,
-0.0054054535,
-0.0386221446,
-0.0324923433,
-0.4430941641,
-0.5695691109,
0.087589778,
-0.379780829,
-0.0468343981,
0.057409972,
0.4051105082,
0.1280813664,
-0.379580617,
-0.1136504188,
-0.8218912482,
1.0142936707,
-0.7178131938,
0.4731653035,
0.1613364369,
0.0360621661,
-0.3954630494,
-0.511493206,
-0.542535007,
0.0836619958,
0.0985282436,
-0.1809268594,
-0.1250777692,
0.0204534605,
0.0667110384,
0.4381183982,
-0.3983795345,
0.8060839176,
-0.6836140752,
-0.1138876304,
0.8723816276,
0.0077167707,
0.2785672843,
0.1943770647,
-0.4625912309,
-0.3319083452,
-0.9827461839,
-0.1358959973,
0.7403292656,
0.4193166792,
0.2734135389,
0.6175485253,
-0.0328341797,
0.3052784801,
0.0676145777,
-0.4680270553,
0.5005220175,
0.2671748698,
-0.168051675,
0.0903642997,
0.7059221864,
0.4499017596,
0.1640066803,
-0.5930575728,
-0.1317240149,
-0.2959090471,
0.2352979481,
-0.62320292,
-0.1093170121,
0.3616643548,
-0.5958527923,
-0.7174991369,
0.0493998565,
-0.9862676859,
-0.6437572837,
-0.5336310267,
0.2975235879,
-0.6391974688,
-0.5437654853,
0.0854544565,
-0.0816777945,
0.2015126497,
0.2277941704,
-0.4900215268,
0.1930144876,
1.0229264498,
0.5429198146,
-0.5694314837,
-0.38173154,
-0.50894171,
0.0007020019,
-0.2231980115,
0.5090453625,
-0.3884149492,
-0.5204666853,
0.1365488023,
-0.1628918499,
0.1959614456,
-0.6791794896,
0.3458374441,
-0.601778686,
0.6141763926,
-0.001008879,
-0.9250680804,
-0.581248343,
-0.0267813858,
-0.6476550102,
1.2116470337,
0.0460589454,
-0.6345828772,
0.6539534926,
-0.6838455796,
-0.5792219043,
0.0156516209,
0.204684034,
-0.6228738427,
0.2426768988,
-0.042451188,
0.5918708444,
-0.3548001349,
0.3747715056,
-0.6399694085,
-0.0857138783,
0.2939060926,
-0.5170484185,
0.8732885718,
0.4354679883,
0.0347874276,
0.1582790166,
-0.8075816035,
0.328453213,
-0.015454025,
-0.3170908988,
-0.3768104911,
0.0857588053,
0.1216801628,
0.0849146321,
0.2507404089,
-0.5075148344,
0.2903874516,
-0.1782868057,
0.1200175658,
0.7709820867,
-0.2156946957,
0.861328721,
-0.4201922119,
0.2503180504,
0.1805626303,
-0.0169210881,
0.2030376047,
-0.1019266099,
-0.9432575107,
-0.5039854646,
0.2147927284,
0.5181975961,
-0.7030089498,
0.6998588443,
0.0575897247,
-0.6046199203,
-0.7044661045,
0.4783453941,
0.5277507305,
0.4493423998,
0.3992479146,
-0.0267131738,
-0.4618169665,
-0.6127278209,
-0.3007143438,
-0.2808601558,
-0.1344592869,
-0.1025154218,
0.2471612841,
-0.3591073453,
0.8567873836,
-0.5502714515,
-0.0696927682,
-0.4838176668,
0.4863528311,
0.0210849736,
0.5047041178,
-0.03066344,
-0.6259691119,
-0.1286779046,
0.1168277785,
-0.9747866392,
0.027529249,
0.2000389844,
-0.0380220115,
0.4158197939,
0.5172291994,
-0.3215394318,
0.3393967748,
0.3065971732,
-0.0242578145,
0.4407266676,
-0.3128503263,
0.1787612289,
-1.2285963297,
-0.1407669187,
-0.3292399347,
-0.2875917852,
-0.8832223415,
-0.0243098047,
0.0236049872,
0.0159616489,
-0.6951330304,
0.2325280756,
-0.6913415194,
-0.0453252569,
-0.5499200821,
-0.0803196132,
-0.2539696395,
0.2102402598,
-0.1981974393,
0.653329432,
0.5116440654,
-0.6005271673,
0.3774967492,
0.1238912717,
-0.3703062236,
0.6325117946,
-0.2662924528,
0.3569257259,
-0.2969901264,
-0.1647839248,
-0.6095083356,
-0.0852861702,
-0.352225095,
-0.3532458842,
0.5756266713,
-0.0510697551,
-0.6267863512,
-0.0939706936,
-0.5117245913,
0.3939027786,
0.7733038664,
-0.8985153437,
0.7271615863,
0.6319362521,
0.1068699732,
-0.6510112286,
-0.366373688,
0.0126738884,
-0.7467440367,
-0.6969016194,
0.3128605187,
0.1749369949,
-0.2425790876,
0.1081833765,
-0.0108885039,
-0.0345076472,
0.1889770776,
0.4323079288,
0.4780104756,
0.0279181022,
0.2800782025,
-0.0862202123,
-0.2429817021,
-0.1431800425,
-0.407450676,
0.5599193573,
0.0641571805,
-0.375551939,
-0.0583825484,
0.4225257635,
0.725648284,
-0.2078471333,
1.0706105232,
0.5574076176,
-0.4320223331,
-0.585852325,
-0.5898858905,
-0.1584627777,
-0.5411175489,
0.3226565421,
0.3185232878,
-1.371180892,
0.2545917928,
-0.5012919903,
0.3829585314,
-0.0185687952,
0.5170544982,
-0.5295695066,
0.8516069055,
0.9602924585,
-0.4165467024,
0.3056321144,
-0.1235252172,
0.6241026521,
-0.8493433595,
-0.6128760576,
-0.3477541208,
-0.4117851555,
-0.7247868776,
-0.4609321952,
0.2850740552,
0.3281002641,
-0.4470999241,
0.1737178862,
-0.3662343025,
0.5925364494,
0.5173392296,
0.1110000387,
0.5030657649,
0.2474050373,
-0.0717058778,
0.180989936,
-0.4713734388,
-0.643914938,
1.2511539459,
0.3855197132,
1.09757936,
0.1208865419,
0.8988904953,
0.3289321363,
0.2657993734,
-0.6750392914,
0.6623548269,
-0.4505598247,
-0.4095810354,
-0.3946473002,
-0.5236218572,
-0.8263733387,
0.2749341428,
-0.4759043753,
-0.912106812,
-0.1508998871,
0.0006733326,
0.0373330303,
0.7112876773,
-0.4914777875,
0.2163570523,
-0.4688382447,
-0.2136758715,
-0.3810997903,
-0.2110091895,
0.6070560217,
-0.2934467494,
0.3215404451,
-0.2691687644,
0.1244483441,
1.0015710592,
-0.4733986557,
0.8197309971,
0.1863338351,
-0.0616536662,
0.1532882303,
0.1351763606,
0.283249706,
-0.3136850595,
0.1114305854,
0.2535684705,
-0.1357764751,
-0.0817835331,
-0.5880392194,
0.6681813002,
-0.8267783523,
-0.428817004,
-0.3999033868,
-0.8044531941,
-0.432156086,
0.1661251187,
0.1797363609,
-0.0494401678,
-0.2133404166,
0.2237857431,
0.9337301254,
-0.1451332718,
0.4865979254,
0.7980552316,
-0.4214669168,
-0.5532307625,
0.9538818002,
-0.111900717,
0.260458827,
0.0678791925,
0.127338171,
-0.3714977205,
-0.4687230289,
0.3025952876,
0.3287053704,
-0.6123699546,
-0.4358282685,
-0.4146471024,
-0.2566409707,
-0.2991687059,
-0.2637422681,
-0.4504964948,
-0.4233075976,
-0.3902071416,
-0.4120416045,
0.7256777883,
0.8215906024,
-0.3716644049,
0.5300888419,
-0.8767148256,
-0.0694372803,
0.0732518509,
0.4743059576,
0.0339751095,
-0.6099838614,
-0.1277544498,
-0.0457841232,
-0.1687180102,
-0.6750779748,
0.3295278847,
0.0243606921,
0.6378500462,
0.4521413445,
0.039370697,
0.5835669041,
-0.4055674076,
0.3701925278,
0.7057518959,
-0.728639245,
0.1939850301,
-0.1815913767,
-0.2578647435,
0.7053622603,
0.3960823715,
-0.7642549276,
-0.2955795527,
-0.6276379824,
-1.2235096693,
0.5366269946,
-0.2252322882,
-0.216187492,
0.3272595704,
0.1923750639,
0.2469049245,
0.3216252923,
-0.3103981912,
-0.3135581613,
0.3555960655,
-0.4074905217,
-0.1289452761,
-0.2405764014,
-0.3147488534,
-0.3134628534,
0.7687777281,
0.0834359229,
-0.208723709,
-0.6890215874,
-0.3894608617,
-0.0106993904,
0.4217950106,
-0.1359349787,
0.338006109,
0.0242619943,
0.3725376427,
0.3258401752,
-0.3993777931,
0.320553571,
-0.2745631337,
-0.2096923739,
-0.6098576784,
0.5179879665,
0.3324474692,
0.2396644205,
-0.5935077071,
0.2320357114,
0.2285254896,
-0.289159745,
-0.1031128019,
0.3919546008,
0.2252243906,
0.3623303473,
0.2432902157,
-0.3465258777,
-0.0288655981,
-0.4982396066,
0.6532490849,
0.5779318213,
-0.1560548395,
0.0686795637,
0.2500151396,
0.3063742816,
-0.2200760841,
0.8635830283,
0.0527662449,
-0.6549518704,
0.255687952,
0.3742490709,
0.9185518026,
-0.1359984726,
0.3154063225,
-0.0492692031,
0.3150894344,
-0.3095750213,
0.0530456975,
0.1904444993,
-0.8584631085,
-0.4413942993,
-0.5620212555,
-0.4159645438,
0.3033246696,
-0.8504759073,
0.1081159785,
-0.442222625,
0.0721621439,
-0.0404829793,
0.1259743124,
-0.5903654099,
0.0659318417,
0.1209183782,
0.7683303356,
-1.0273810625,
0.6313486695,
0.6841247082,
-0.4282594919,
-0.8928191662,
-0.1229059175,
0.3952397704,
-0.8543877006,
0.660281837,
0.1467924565,
-0.1332309842,
-0.3372204006,
-0.5973749161,
-0.8431914449,
1.0835729837,
0.2512589991,
-0.4173526466,
0.2257141769,
0.4754942954,
0.2309757769,
-0.4916564524,
0.2055330575,
0.9633084536,
0.2561142147,
0.2742775381,
-0.6440450549,
-0.1141124517,
0.0995610952,
-0.1817640066,
0.3487249315,
-0.3643876314,
0.6786628366,
-0.3648405671,
-0.1787394285,
-0.3232323229,
0.9525704384,
0.0213529598,
0.287437886,
0.7466438413,
0.7037243843,
1.3922719955,
-0.1168970987,
0.2054087371,
-0.0527418777,
0.4372362196,
1.1511771679,
-0.4902945757,
0.7888759375,
0.3779225647,
-0.2214352638,
0.3321055472,
0.2893313468,
0.1612546742,
0.4805422723,
-0.0635643229,
-0.5183695555,
-0.3253314197,
0.0220873132,
-0.0347537957,
0.6488045454,
0.1594953835,
-0.214336738,
-0.5183451772,
0.204608053,
0.6252216101,
0.0562894642,
-0.2302675992,
0.9931688309,
-0.0534012206,
-0.4761078954,
0.1819958538,
-0.0639148504,
0.8603194952,
-0.308981806,
-0.0652683228,
-0.241940245,
0.5311424732,
-0.5543984175,
-1.0148699284,
0.2024499476,
0.2836606801,
-0.2728070617,
-0.2805584669,
0.8641322255,
-0.887185514,
-0.6589281559,
0.4423800707,
0.5461825132,
0.158205539,
0.2098397911,
-0.5085714459,
-0.1413498372,
0.1095215753,
0.0242574885,
0.7749433517,
0.4593273103,
-0.0188150499,
0.9434817433,
1.0751552582,
0.1324109733,
-0.1223183647,
0.0867832676,
1.0876246691,
-0.5921680331,
-0.1038017273,
-0.7411056757,
0.6803665757,
-0.3085143268,
-0.0224509295,
0.7039042711,
0.574674964,
0.8248024583,
0.4697971046,
0.8357217908,
0.1058648229,
0.8345170617,
-0.5517235398,
1.0827742815,
-0.5658317804,
0.5124021173,
0.0238225926,
-0.8118984103,
-0.0484744422,
0.2990908027,
-0.0888440683,
0.1743836105,
0.5535933971,
0.7645892501,
0.0665002465,
-0.0166954212,
0.5234258771,
-0.1596537679,
0.5240904689,
0.2984810472,
0.8261729479,
0.0340212025,
0.1836867929,
-0.289526403,
-0.4780273438,
-0.0929688215,
-1.0738170147,
-1.1425834894,
-0.4438425004,
-0.3341761231,
-0.3999819458,
0.1553822458,
1.0415692329,
0.5340825915,
-0.6335509419,
-0.2583838403,
0.2707816958,
0.4113481343,
-0.0686869994,
-0.1631672382,
0.312987119,
-0.4738938808,
-0.4852765799,
0.4320756495,
0.2201413661,
-0.1746949852,
-0.4863394499,
-0.0234981813,
0.0579776242,
-0.0251782201,
0.6151214838,
0.293153137,
-0.2851587236,
-0.2175406218,
-0.1329132468,
0.0672704726,
-0.2989333868,
0.8664324284,
-0.6322948337,
0.0482734516,
0.4257586002,
0.6618355513,
0.215723902,
0.0128908763,
0.6430270076,
-0.703543067,
0.0313878022,
0.060765747,
0.3612008393,
0.3968096375,
-0.4086054862,
0.4794357419,
-0.0391337611,
-0.4559625089,
-1.0719577074,
0.105853267,
-0.7253465056,
-0.4685249031,
1.3159956932,
0.0417695194,
-0.1512064636,
-0.0193694942,
0.2472612858,
0.5069289804,
-0.3445346653,
0.6451279521,
0.5471214056,
-0.0628026873,
-0.1015561298,
-0.2162312269,
0.4486590922,
0.2603392899,
-1.126947999,
0.3520790339,
0.5167198777,
0.607673645,
-0.0758435354,
-0.0158021748,
-0.3640151024,
0.1006968543,
-0.4980642796,
0.3916493058,
-0.4397136867,
-0.5966338515,
-0.3794410825,
-0.0236176476,
0.0157369394,
-0.164078936
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11776v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11776v1 | Improving Multi-Agent Debate with Sparse Communication Topology | 2024-06-17T17:33:09 | 2024-06-17T17:33:09 | Yunxuan Li, Yibing Du, Jiageng Zhang, Le Hou, Peter Grabowski, Yeqing Li, Eugene Ie | cs.CL | cs.CL | Multi-agent debate has proven effective in improving large language models
quality for reasoning and factuality tasks. While various role-playing
strategies in multi-agent debates have been explored, in terms of the
communication among agents, existing approaches adopt a brute force algorithm
-- each agent can communicate with all other agents. In this paper, we
systematically investigate the effect of communication connectivity in
multi-agent systems. Our experiments on GPT and Mistral models reveal that
multi-agent debates leveraging sparse communication topology can achieve
comparable or superior performance while significantly reducing computational
costs. Furthermore, we extend the multi-agent debate framework to multimodal
reasoning and alignment labeling tasks, showcasing its broad applicability and
effectiveness. Our findings underscore the importance of communication
connectivity on enhancing the efficiency and effectiveness of the "society of
minds" approach. | [
-0.8924534917,
-1.0454614162,
0.7721531987,
-0.121754773,
-0.1174944788,
0.0540929101,
-0.2027864009,
-0.4688165188,
0.4693554342,
0.318844676,
-0.4583507776,
-0.1452849805,
-0.5896331668,
0.103903234,
-0.0490775667,
0.706037879,
0.3839853108,
-0.1470184624,
-0.3927140832,
-0.5972778797,
-0.5579217076,
-0.5642908216,
-0.7290514112,
-0.3611719608,
0.858051002,
0.2687840462,
1.0774922371,
0.5311713815,
0.4320780337,
0.5522925854,
-0.1649291515,
0.5825667977,
-0.6727488041,
0.5644309521,
-0.3038282096,
-0.2999925017,
-0.5488058925,
-0.0405872278,
0.8703401089,
0.6885994673,
-0.1583048105,
-0.2759082317,
0.1600043774,
0.5536674261,
-0.4300915599,
0.1322930455,
-0.7473415136,
-0.469592154,
-0.2205723524,
-0.431763649,
-0.3829109371,
-0.1219602451,
0.1395246983,
-0.7757070065,
0.0256179124,
-0.0090030804,
0.8923043013,
0.4992871583,
-0.5621283054,
-0.1866570115,
-0.7216483355,
0.215513885,
-0.3402577341,
0.3222379386,
0.1522762924,
0.1548224986,
-0.3939954638,
-0.5952621102,
-0.5778439641,
-0.0308389105,
0.0135005936,
0.1654304713,
-0.3041306138,
0.4758783877,
0.1995038241,
-0.2514961064,
-0.2574856877,
-0.3071137071,
-0.3477351069,
-0.1471133977,
0.508090198,
0.1622564197,
0.0265260953,
0.1901377589,
-0.1469454616,
-0.0552585237,
-0.4738041461,
-0.1354103684,
0.3025111258,
0.217176035,
0.1085254773,
0.1904734373,
-0.2430021167,
0.7422161102,
0.0127742169,
-0.1952404231,
-0.2299496979,
-0.6219604015,
-0.0810925588,
-0.3250447214,
0.522911787,
0.2895511687,
-0.0872249529,
-0.3037019074,
0.1326133162,
0.2178997695,
0.4030606449,
-0.5133431554,
-0.2947544456,
0.1421103776,
-0.2216565609,
0.244451642,
-0.2469427288,
-0.5765917897,
-0.548817873,
-0.2659898102,
0.4933072031,
-0.2467949688,
-0.5530284047,
0.0536422841,
-0.3297452331,
-0.0427165478,
0.9016894102,
-0.5608740449,
0.4923097491,
0.5891789794,
0.9089689255,
0.2673965394,
-0.4662281573,
-0.3989238739,
0.3855830431,
-0.5482071042,
1.2950636148,
-0.4613534212,
-0.1168331206,
-0.5155194402,
-0.0294062346,
-0.5047091246,
-0.2754556239,
0.1847721189,
-0.4208259881,
-0.1770952791,
-0.7461467385,
-0.4469795823,
0.066180177,
0.4783470035,
-0.9594095349,
0.3056252301,
-0.4805684984,
-0.6164046526,
0.1227337793,
-0.7286861539,
-0.314340204,
0.1384462118,
-0.127244547,
-0.2237917781,
-0.2027906477,
0.1340856403,
0.2489818484,
-0.3582056463,
0.1781248897,
-0.5510261059,
-0.4397307038,
0.3411529958,
-0.3236857355,
0.55877316,
0.2853343189,
-0.3485889733,
0.1157869324,
-0.1734047979,
-0.2191530913,
-0.0987274125,
-0.0615871884,
-0.2982361317,
0.2192390114,
-0.5185046196,
0.1456438303,
-0.289528966,
-0.3181726635,
0.3378060162,
-0.3936375678,
0.5749123096,
0.8036023378,
-0.1639717519,
0.6103138328,
-0.692496419,
0.2615312338,
-0.0452191234,
0.2123416364,
-0.0603568852,
-0.8326599002,
-0.6836012006,
-0.4397441745,
0.118433021,
0.3068779409,
-1.2011619806,
-0.177851215,
-0.3096336424,
-0.4760611057,
-0.5141988397,
-0.2971488535,
0.1500042677,
0.3061054945,
0.2094154954,
-0.2439380437,
0.0233673099,
-0.4797313213,
-0.0769101605,
-0.4272194505,
0.5292101502,
0.6544745564,
0.2544130683,
-0.012014213,
0.9307436943,
-0.3782971501,
0.0806014165,
-0.1201599464,
0.2259462029,
-0.314207375,
0.3407397568,
0.3223930895,
-0.609785974,
-0.4258421659,
0.0434629731,
-0.5501039624,
0.1890523881,
-0.3255662322,
-0.3457047641,
0.4154400527,
0.438721776,
-1.1231375933,
0.3492849767,
0.3423007727,
-0.353384614,
0.5181112289,
-0.1615898162,
0.686612606,
-0.8770037889,
-0.1165788546,
-0.0630551502,
-0.1587939113,
-0.784612298,
0.1638715118,
-0.4815598726,
-0.1455338895,
-0.1362939775,
0.4765505195,
-0.5808247328,
0.1168585345,
-0.2041440904,
0.5217095017,
0.2011456043,
0.5666521788,
-0.0407342426,
1.042797327,
0.5513637662,
-0.3796370327,
0.450997591,
0.2290169299,
0.1186146811,
0.9323182106,
-0.7238910794,
0.3017702103,
-0.4157441556,
0.5438893437,
-1.4842362404,
0.0109232021,
0.3463757932,
-0.5578981638,
0.0194841828,
-0.2373170108,
-0.389839977,
0.0927888677,
-0.2489428371,
0.5182077289,
-0.1290238649,
-0.3106476665,
0.5728753805,
0.6307394505,
-0.2303159833,
-0.6373313665,
-0.1803041846,
0.5333992243,
-0.3586147428,
-1.0411684513,
-0.0835390687,
-0.1024876162,
-0.2990016639,
-0.0660284758,
-0.001627681,
-0.3682286441,
0.1391685009,
0.0239137337,
0.0006365372,
-0.1594157517,
0.5787847638,
0.1814653426,
0.0608352199,
-0.0599483997,
-0.3231869936,
0.3600735962,
-0.2364512682,
-0.4893621206,
-0.229203999,
0.7227100134,
0.4987927973,
-0.1600437313,
1.0057829618,
0.2947382927,
-0.1398314387,
-0.2136832178,
-0.9314390421,
-0.513584435,
-0.4832665324,
0.2623997629,
-0.5061060786,
-1.2190133333,
0.3138572276,
-0.591242671,
-0.1048780084,
0.1543997675,
0.2544896603,
-0.1493782401,
0.9955124259,
0.5673463345,
0.217691794,
0.1116360575,
0.0536041893,
0.2599357069,
-0.4421445429,
-0.0997932106,
-0.7666665912,
-0.1355514079,
-0.4316577017,
-0.6508959532,
0.7995058894,
-0.1857777983,
-0.1453040987,
0.2961118817,
-0.5721460581,
0.3922127187,
0.2821506262,
0.1068076566,
0.3677215576,
0.195239529,
-0.1390089244,
0.1073603854,
-1.0480504036,
-0.3894956708,
0.6526141763,
0.1662401855,
0.6375904083,
0.4542623758,
0.3784732223,
0.2032251805,
0.1452089101,
-0.4518437684,
0.5594083071,
0.3817914426,
-0.5308477879,
-0.73855865,
-0.6167955399,
-1.3590825796,
0.8392600417,
-0.3462978899,
-0.8741487861,
0.4016014934,
-0.1247586831,
-0.2842240334,
0.3739154935,
-0.7935089469,
0.8156852126,
0.5754852891,
-0.5116127133,
-0.5672920942,
-0.7952148318,
0.2945224345,
0.3016681075,
0.2791714966,
0.0037618263,
0.1043530479,
0.5426614881,
-0.4692623615,
0.7177584171,
0.2146187425,
-0.1985330135,
0.6310210824,
-0.287914902,
0.4351130426,
0.1385782659,
0.2005079389,
0.2223004252,
0.0894814506,
-0.4161313474,
-0.6646873951,
0.5434850454,
-1.0139143467,
-0.8182076216,
-0.2221267819,
-0.7400022745,
-0.2503345311,
-0.0235785116,
-0.0828749686,
0.7402917147,
-0.19711487,
0.0458485447,
0.8351308703,
0.1606490165,
0.2388560027,
0.3268083632,
0.5624036789,
-0.4690197408,
0.9643697739,
0.4076472223,
0.612342298,
-0.04182126,
-0.1840965599,
-0.472500205,
-0.0530703813,
-0.5644863248,
0.4299458563,
-0.8735646605,
-0.2355931401,
-1.0048360825,
-0.1846535206,
-0.4718494713,
-0.0701778084,
-0.4071500003,
-0.5760543942,
0.1821088642,
0.2449656278,
-0.0029755905,
0.7290338278,
-0.2123166919,
0.4126237035,
-0.5600558519,
0.109019123,
0.6399800181,
0.2591405809,
0.2720491588,
-0.009546618,
-0.3145967126,
0.1413725466,
-0.6785575151,
-1.1804744005,
-0.193415761,
0.1115626767,
0.6421610713,
0.2468003482,
0.0626507476,
0.8171365857,
-0.3446002603,
0.4703705013,
0.1141813323,
-0.8857251406,
0.1493422687,
-0.6058948636,
0.1654519439,
0.2116811723,
0.0571258664,
-0.538198173,
-0.6341938376,
-0.6309199929,
-0.4088688791,
0.6639842391,
0.4479194283,
-0.2719897032,
-0.0535270609,
0.2173763216,
-0.295619607,
0.2547824383,
-0.3683881462,
-0.3478733599,
-0.0951969102,
0.4218675792,
0.0359542593,
0.0039028036,
-0.6511254311,
-0.3906489611,
0.2261129618,
-0.4050847292,
0.4616574347,
0.3766955435,
0.1768677235,
-0.1702965349,
0.5005477071,
0.8728289604,
0.9152743816,
0.3331531286,
0.3779835105,
0.138867408,
-0.2509325147,
0.4123198092,
0.2543109059,
0.1864128709,
-0.0487965941,
0.3040245473,
0.8115078211,
-0.3532913029,
-0.183145985,
0.3804160953,
-0.3186307549,
-0.5456985831,
0.5103379488,
0.0958262086,
0.5005124211,
0.6359626055,
0.1674423367,
0.4088673592,
0.3184262216,
-0.5226832032,
0.2631772757,
0.8784384131,
-0.1126090884,
-0.100925222,
0.4912481308,
0.3588140309,
0.013660145,
0.314155072,
-0.2233400941,
-0.3440391123,
0.8946502209,
0.4310316145,
0.4551831782,
-0.3204323649,
0.6686523557,
0.1313904524,
0.7675591707,
-0.1123455092,
-0.0078568896,
-0.2157663107,
-0.7718324065,
-0.7931777239,
0.0323565044,
-0.6389474869,
-0.2945842445,
-0.0519541837,
-0.1352962106,
-0.2742692232,
-0.4902304411,
0.0280737095,
0.2201476395,
-0.3062671423,
-0.2388923317,
0.2096032649,
0.5190223455,
-0.7400247455,
0.7376200557,
0.8772526979,
-0.0502570271,
-0.793350637,
-0.1288197786,
0.05685113,
-0.1689473987,
0.3130151629,
0.0817420408,
-0.6955822706,
0.0266931672,
-0.7396773696,
-1.0426126719,
1.0097569227,
0.6466608644,
-0.1682686657,
0.4098674655,
0.1256011873,
0.5010024309,
-0.1316768229,
0.7450194359,
0.2533073723,
0.515997529,
0.3901403248,
-1.208168745,
0.1382984519,
-0.341176182,
-0.2602795064,
0.2086087316,
-1.0615746975,
1.0125901699,
-0.1112029627,
-0.6146438122,
0.0075901337,
0.7852887511,
0.2372142971,
0.426058054,
0.6489770412,
0.4325924516,
0.9833205938,
-0.2016775906,
0.4495513737,
-0.2290799469,
0.4014205635,
0.5821802616,
-0.3484266996,
0.1882568896,
0.2380886227,
0.0398609042,
0.3896768391,
0.2355619371,
0.4548524022,
0.1280380487,
0.1228266582,
-0.3283034861,
-0.6218611598,
-0.408374846,
-0.4079526365,
0.2560322285,
0.5084645152,
0.801089108,
-0.4820990264,
-0.1553556621,
0.2192054838,
0.0880628154,
0.0268278439,
0.8680042624,
-0.2054416686,
-0.8667304516,
0.8343003392,
-0.0557900332,
0.3385535777,
-0.3579953313,
-0.4078700244,
-0.2079891413,
-0.0923539102,
-0.0173866041,
-0.4129881859,
0.2813887894,
-0.6620676517,
0.1964798123,
0.2251724005,
0.9899510145,
-0.7031962276,
0.1782616824,
0.2903727591,
0.855889976,
0.1940138638,
-0.0507803783,
-0.7445408106,
0.2703475654,
-0.6567551494,
0.0137008177,
0.3708959818,
0.7283055186,
-0.1889843494,
0.9226258993,
0.5778964162,
0.0075234268,
-0.0310258809,
-0.1649743915,
1.4761220217,
-0.2472079396,
-0.5907660723,
-0.7577495575,
0.3691025972,
-0.4665626585,
0.0299031753,
0.7083098888,
0.0824746415,
0.4900437295,
0.3885012567,
0.5418162346,
0.1237666234,
0.1012097374,
-0.169971168,
0.804718852,
-0.4801907241,
0.0270585846,
-0.4573880732,
-0.6360250115,
-0.054122258,
0.6602327228,
0.0794830769,
0.0361500718,
1.0150407553,
0.8832250834,
-0.0821491927,
0.203938067,
0.3465333581,
0.159742251,
0.3872347474,
0.6724383831,
0.9355878234,
-0.268460989,
0.4889435768,
0.0648357049,
-0.4858694971,
0.1704102904,
-0.5322554111,
-1.1749428511,
-0.826977253,
-0.2518036366,
-0.4352344573,
0.6120049357,
0.7034132481,
0.9009699225,
-0.1104258001,
-0.4345030785,
0.2656588256,
0.6460033059,
-0.4652240574,
-0.1385043114,
0.2597664297,
-0.5946135521,
-0.5435549021,
0.2786542773,
0.4724485874,
-0.4838693142,
-0.1980264485,
-0.1748252362,
-0.5077585578,
0.5951749086,
0.6373561025,
0.1696683168,
-0.5828740001,
-0.3430740535,
-0.1428428441,
-0.2434508353,
0.1346261352,
0.8411672711,
-0.6098088622,
0.4285932183,
0.4446145594,
0.7230909467,
0.0670338497,
0.4278462231,
0.4455426335,
-0.3879432082,
0.2787128091,
-0.1071790457,
0.0180235468,
0.1895147562,
-0.3405978382,
0.3005461097,
0.6824005246,
-0.9689484239,
-0.5128077269,
0.2833033204,
-0.7869731784,
-0.5400391221,
1.0555870533,
-0.0944621861,
-0.1968322545,
-0.7153031826,
-0.3872392774,
0.2235293686,
-0.5244306922,
0.605690062,
0.8536979556,
-0.1190751046,
-0.3706499934,
-0.4942538738,
0.566003561,
0.5495163202,
-0.8750718236,
-0.0178515818,
0.68323493,
-0.0559285805,
0.2561338544,
1.3359212875,
0.3369130194,
0.2128432542,
0.2705852687,
-0.2774959505,
0.1090804189,
-0.855085969,
0.0923383236,
0.3599537909,
-0.0045329984,
0.0140206236
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11768v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11768v1 | GAMA: A Large Audio-Language Model with Advanced Audio Understanding and Complex Reasoning Abilities | 2024-06-17T17:31:01 | 2024-06-17T17:31:01 | Sreyan Ghosh, Sonal Kumar, Ashish Seth, Chandra Kiran Reddy Evuru, Utkarsh Tyagi, S Sakshi, Oriol Nieto, Ramani Duraiswami, Dinesh Manocha | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.AI, cs.CL, eess.AS | Perceiving and understanding non-speech sounds and non-verbal speech is
essential to making decisions that help us interact with our surroundings. In
this paper, we propose GAMA, a novel General-purpose Large Audio-Language Model
(LALM) with Advanced Audio Understanding and Complex Reasoning Abilities. We
build GAMA by integrating an LLM with multiple types of audio representations,
including features from a custom Audio Q-Former, a multi-layer aggregator that
aggregates features from multiple layers of an audio encoder. We fine-tune GAMA
on a large-scale audio-language dataset, which augments it with audio
understanding capabilities. Next, we propose CompA-R (Instruction-Tuning for
Complex Audio Reasoning), a synthetically generated instruction-tuning (IT)
dataset with instructions that require the model to perform complex reasoning
on the input audio. We instruction-tune GAMA with CompA-R to endow it with
complex reasoning abilities, where we further add a soft prompt as input with
high-level semantic evidence by leveraging event tags of the input audio.
Finally, we also propose CompA-R-test, a human-labeled evaluation dataset for
evaluating the capabilities of LALMs on open-ended audio question-answering
that requires complex reasoning. Through automated and expert human
evaluations, we show that GAMA outperforms all other LALMs in literature on
diverse audio understanding tasks by margins of 1%-84%. Further, GAMA IT-ed on
CompA-R proves to be superior in its complex reasoning and instruction
following capabilities. | [
-0.6350906491,
-1.1902170181,
0.7881093025,
0.0534220263,
0.0391016304,
0.1405159384,
-0.4396966398,
-0.5393177867,
-0.1489755809,
0.3139323592,
-0.6280822754,
-0.6442725658,
-0.5547194481,
-0.2855234444,
-0.4805061221,
0.5184258223,
0.3589403927,
0.0934784263,
-0.1236279085,
-0.2266008705,
-0.6632499695,
-0.4260492623,
-0.6898558736,
-0.436609596,
0.1924443841,
0.6547377706,
0.8204177022,
0.406850934,
0.2800286114,
0.212806344,
-0.1354375333,
0.5855150819,
-0.083599925,
-0.0121747497,
-0.1649006307,
-0.6009784937,
-0.8682927489,
-0.0687926114,
0.3404170275,
0.6167284846,
-0.2932054698,
0.4261760116,
-0.3631610274,
0.2818505168,
-0.418636173,
0.0926368162,
-0.6566038132,
0.0033290733,
0.2997391522,
-0.5227531791,
-0.5349162817,
0.185596019,
0.0103859175,
-0.7469301224,
0.27056247,
0.2686062455,
0.8387366533,
0.4663315713,
-0.1234871224,
-0.6062167287,
-1.1131484509,
0.8485484123,
-0.5888751149,
0.4965364933,
0.5505375266,
0.7795103788,
-0.1481683105,
-0.4109908938,
-0.8143274784,
-0.2453319281,
0.4204808474,
0.0442151055,
-0.2119673043,
-0.0081669688,
0.1683786958,
0.5492278934,
-0.6827754378,
-0.175834313,
-0.1007282734,
0.2240963727,
0.6606106162,
0.2402452976,
0.83639884,
0.3878952861,
-0.2499209493,
0.067198582,
-0.6390971541,
0.1004440114,
0.2468940765,
0.1551899612,
-0.1227328777,
0.2755871117,
-0.0630203336,
0.8536812067,
-0.0155018242,
-0.2613832057,
0.2169143707,
-0.2087624073,
-0.5534825921,
0.2146861404,
0.6124286652,
-0.0474663414,
0.279424578,
-0.2637332976,
-0.087549679,
0.1190042049,
0.0905077979,
-0.291709125,
-0.1757348329,
0.3249135315,
-0.2249063849,
0.1935563236,
-0.1078672558,
-0.5122822523,
-0.2528513074,
-0.6618784666,
0.8038468957,
-0.2683271766,
-0.1970036477,
0.7960711122,
0.1810714006,
0.2284785509,
0.4213517904,
-1.0340764523,
0.3719406426,
0.7897306681,
0.7296050787,
0.2523251772,
-0.0033882463,
-0.8594250083,
0.5020602942,
-0.1195431426,
0.7617383003,
-1.033315897,
-0.3046276867,
-0.4599196613,
-0.1924495995,
-0.0355852284,
-0.5799317956,
0.9581221342,
-0.3776105642,
0.312834233,
0.0441998765,
-0.4171977341,
-0.7707876563,
0.1145072281,
-0.2632856965,
0.412124902,
-0.1741575748,
-0.0443063118,
0.2628194392,
-0.7854757905,
-0.313149929,
-0.0891857147,
-0.1550038457,
-0.4484793246,
-0.0597253516,
0.470960021,
0.345530957,
-0.6105997562,
0.5216029286,
-0.3375438452,
-0.7171778083,
0.1340738386,
-0.4595608413,
0.4926301837,
0.3421484232,
-0.4252175689,
0.2625648975,
-0.8282630444,
0.0314081423,
0.1073235422,
-0.2201876491,
-0.0412012674,
0.1543764919,
-0.0536658354,
0.2450879514,
-0.0284982454,
-0.3645374179,
0.0431027338,
-0.1048099101,
0.660633564,
0.2732747197,
-0.1198851168,
0.5037891865,
-0.362249583,
0.5581607819,
-0.1132312119,
0.1332569122,
-0.3140301108,
-0.6049726605,
-0.9267337322,
-0.4656472206,
-0.0836179033,
0.662794292,
0.1565982848,
0.4308613539,
0.0599163398,
-0.3835415244,
-0.763761282,
0.2435299754,
0.2517906129,
0.4966356158,
0.6417914629,
0.2648717463,
-0.6223288774,
-0.8168565035,
-0.1463138759,
0.022215981,
-0.3529930413,
0.6000272632,
0.1770709604,
-0.5687061548,
0.7089114785,
-0.4342186451,
-0.3937443495,
-0.2041534036,
0.2289195061,
0.4729514718,
0.3495351672,
0.2776689827,
-0.4501982629,
0.0113583989,
0.1942628026,
-0.6777184606,
-0.3084364533,
-0.3885144293,
0.0100025358,
-0.2600796223,
0.3235029578,
-0.7523658276,
-0.0574913248,
0.3755209148,
-0.4447143674,
0.4478506744,
-0.3373030722,
0.1989671588,
-0.6765386462,
-0.0457006507,
-0.0708850771,
-0.1771414429,
-0.5860698223,
0.1045027375,
-0.227342695,
-0.1531239748,
-0.1289723068,
0.5012441278,
-0.5012890697,
-0.2944374681,
-0.3374594152,
0.3319188654,
0.1709227711,
0.5704177022,
0.0772131383,
0.8615826964,
0.6526634097,
-0.6290569305,
0.3524205089,
0.2822487056,
-0.7198408246,
0.2405636907,
-0.8183338642,
0.4978899658,
-0.0201295651,
0.0766875818,
-0.8928287029,
-0.0465108156,
0.1800119132,
-0.4804765582,
0.2652181685,
-0.0226104166,
-0.391076982,
0.0156271961,
0.4854691327,
0.2794469893,
0.4025120139,
-0.5450829268,
0.9487051368,
0.6583138108,
-0.3042640686,
-0.4155406356,
-0.5189402699,
0.3157609403,
-0.3617228866,
-0.8773984909,
-0.130138889,
-0.0781060606,
-0.4537228346,
-0.271559,
-0.1321097016,
-0.1033419892,
0.2557970583,
0.2446599156,
0.2441777587,
-0.3380138278,
0.0969650149,
0.0276866294,
-0.0947187543,
0.2509560585,
-0.1699287593,
0.5278363824,
-0.577534914,
-0.5040289164,
-0.3336809278,
0.4472463131,
0.6206707358,
-0.4179483652,
0.119218342,
0.6520498991,
-0.0062650759,
-0.5209828019,
-0.3574859202,
0.1739559472,
-0.4010864198,
0.4690691233,
-0.5769351125,
-0.8568503261,
0.4707168937,
0.0106150378,
0.1255518198,
0.0766785666,
0.8828040361,
-0.2230447233,
1.5597416162,
0.0299306791,
0.2085715383,
0.1349391192,
-0.4187541306,
0.353746146,
-0.7352391481,
-0.4825698435,
-0.5004790425,
-0.4402737319,
0.0499946252,
-0.5488702059,
0.1216545776,
-0.0180239398,
-0.418500483,
-0.0109365797,
-0.362747103,
0.5593300462,
0.4908431172,
-0.0686515719,
0.5508809686,
-0.3150795698,
0.0881069675,
0.5869126916,
-0.4780820608,
-0.7101995349,
0.7273076177,
0.6377614141,
0.8329444528,
0.2638878226,
0.063369669,
0.1732085198,
-0.3139434755,
-0.9543155432,
0.4799269736,
0.0080687031,
-0.5586643815,
-0.1386544406,
-0.2086083144,
-0.5749872327,
0.384211272,
-0.3654940128,
-0.5156448483,
0.0657020882,
0.1194618344,
-0.3748519123,
0.2204068303,
-1.0170359612,
0.4480788708,
-0.3629654944,
-0.002288833,
-0.5124645233,
-0.4849081635,
0.4849746823,
0.2051352262,
0.5175021887,
-0.4039355218,
-0.0594105907,
0.2795504332,
0.0120872008,
0.2175156325,
-0.2288112938,
-0.1417718977,
0.2649554312,
0.1095652431,
0.0897044167,
0.3957017362,
0.1400926262,
0.3465188742,
-0.12833336,
-0.1914507449,
-0.8569149375,
0.6739757061,
-0.9723371863,
-0.9039478898,
-0.1347186565,
-1.0430685282,
-0.6502126455,
-0.0903925225,
-0.1293201745,
0.4608765543,
0.0583995357,
0.2368688732,
0.8909894228,
-0.3063601255,
0.0912323296,
0.4816597104,
-0.3139530718,
-0.2327418178,
0.9563300014,
-0.231677115,
0.2508511245,
0.3662662208,
0.2339060903,
-0.3695263565,
-0.7403406501,
-0.5994000435,
-0.0140670678,
-0.595346272,
0.2577499449,
-0.8634366393,
0.0416578278,
0.1396956146,
-0.0307787396,
0.0429969281,
-0.4188423157,
-0.3244176507,
-0.0837643594,
0.02524524,
0.4818535745,
0.0634169951,
0.2775474191,
-0.7413083315,
0.8021692634,
0.5508176684,
0.1403440386,
0.075776957,
-0.7416563034,
-0.2754140496,
0.1992998868,
-0.0163945388,
-0.5645714998,
0.3194960654,
0.5298364162,
0.7094435692,
0.4784764946,
-0.3972238898,
0.6460382938,
-0.4896236956,
0.440376997,
-0.0442153998,
-1.000531435,
0.4433385432,
-0.5804165006,
0.4857246876,
0.384580195,
-0.1003256738,
-0.4207574427,
-0.4616765678,
-0.3237771988,
-0.6812558174,
0.5412854552,
-0.026961023,
0.0157179404,
0.1188429296,
0.0243671257,
0.1811237782,
-0.097410515,
-0.1424300522,
-0.1773023158,
-0.2347645015,
-0.0361280479,
-0.2058853358,
-0.0915933177,
-0.1463403851,
-0.4320950806,
0.7428124547,
-0.0869786516,
0.2174457312,
0.1021720096,
-0.2542889714,
-0.0415388606,
0.7107751369,
0.9348967671,
0.5606430173,
-0.3741766214,
0.1873964816,
0.21604307,
-0.4765424728,
0.4791690707,
-0.3484405279,
0.0333508663,
-0.0949887857,
0.1759005338,
1.0726510286,
0.1300191432,
-1.0086804628,
0.1860947609,
-0.3269388676,
-0.3424068689,
-0.3490730226,
0.6094809771,
0.6516796947,
0.2339445651,
0.44771263,
0.1894707382,
0.4058862627,
-0.713091433,
0.2379178703,
0.3956103623,
-0.2932910323,
-0.2535553277,
0.8048599958,
0.1070795879,
-0.296146661,
0.315618366,
-0.0866094604,
-0.0541833639,
0.6103172898,
0.6221982241,
0.8796249628,
-0.0190215725,
-0.0282274056,
0.3276107907,
0.2013649195,
0.1130165085,
0.5380880833,
-0.3197193742,
-0.5224885941,
-0.6923449636,
-0.631383419,
-0.6967738271,
0.3392570317,
-0.4762820005,
0.3388608396,
-0.8626889586,
-0.0044227522,
0.0631998777,
-0.1604111642,
-0.4903743565,
0.4668417871,
0.38649562,
0.8919816017,
-0.7603445649,
0.7265373468,
0.7114302516,
-0.363973856,
-0.9061018825,
-0.1707590669,
-0.1152107269,
-0.8574470878,
0.4954722226,
0.0851128846,
-0.5699596405,
-0.0435558669,
-0.6034092903,
-0.6242380142,
0.943891108,
0.7359312177,
-0.902464807,
-0.0916933417,
0.0044525308,
0.4071350992,
-0.4461987615,
0.508533895,
0.762753129,
0.5416654348,
0.3903279901,
-0.7027289867,
-0.2904728651,
-0.3339127004,
-0.4836958349,
0.1782355905,
-0.4442334473,
0.7459686399,
-0.4483183026,
-0.1734914333,
-0.2088465095,
0.5858329535,
0.3542727828,
0.498434484,
0.6400685906,
0.7366973162,
0.8784028888,
-0.1745589823,
0.733728826,
0.030757295,
0.1625749916,
1.4744305611,
0.0132240448,
0.6909803748,
0.1359881461,
0.0356674641,
0.6415201426,
0.4367237687,
-0.0037659393,
0.389636308,
0.0801708773,
-0.548905611,
-0.8822618127,
-0.0849241391,
-0.3132952452,
0.9818118215,
0.4990066588,
-0.2351995558,
-0.0341517553,
-0.0105902534,
-0.098740086,
0.0897103399,
-0.5103161335,
0.8013827205,
0.306263417,
-0.2788944542,
0.5155712366,
-0.2254657,
0.4791727066,
-0.4261690378,
-0.1547609419,
0.2501887083,
0.0883023515,
-0.4418652654,
-0.8114272952,
0.4929473996,
0.0367859304,
-0.4141331315,
0.1203644574,
0.506552279,
-0.6316531301,
-0.2381663769,
0.3168042004,
0.3597494066,
0.0952062011,
0.0062287133,
-0.6574633718,
-0.008253729,
-0.3081075251,
-0.0142215379,
0.1907579154,
0.2939468026,
0.0287851859,
0.9229454398,
0.8700230122,
0.1708717644,
-0.1246531308,
0.4428857565,
0.2971795797,
-0.6414881945,
-0.7313667536,
-0.6965723038,
0.2256158292,
0.2576218843,
0.0338481851,
0.4798265696,
0.3230016828,
0.5501593947,
-0.0372140221,
0.8811739087,
0.3651490808,
0.4799933434,
-0.6136729717,
0.7462012172,
-0.5928777456,
0.3128718436,
-0.1180954576,
-0.798686862,
-0.3850547671,
0.744169116,
-0.4433046281,
-0.0581490025,
0.2670464814,
0.7702378035,
-0.2599726021,
0.5198078156,
0.5088700056,
0.1669672132,
0.5713136196,
0.8957175016,
1.0016536713,
-0.1490516365,
0.5742912889,
0.3170650601,
-0.1394514889,
-0.120514974,
-0.5961962342,
-0.8268973231,
-0.4582499862,
-0.0610316098,
0.0688590109,
-0.1114297286,
1.0457154512,
0.8022875786,
-0.8857499361,
-0.2055998892,
-0.0697126761,
0.1303329617,
-0.3285252154,
-0.1743469238,
0.1348835826,
-0.3315067291,
-0.891356051,
0.9781839848,
0.6072188616,
-0.3522520661,
-0.323433876,
-0.4206709862,
-0.3311840594,
0.3185340464,
0.5847572088,
0.3123481274,
-0.7500624061,
-0.3720724583,
0.0396042988,
0.105760105,
0.2296946347,
0.4738585651,
-0.55349195,
0.8479411602,
0.6762946844,
0.7185986042,
0.3947205544,
-0.0911285803,
0.7305362225,
-0.2094898671,
-0.005703418,
0.2596218288,
0.49300161,
0.208681643,
-0.2333057225,
0.3295454979,
-0.2259770185,
-0.7160952687,
-0.6698054671,
0.1358886063,
-1.3026899099,
-0.2202692777,
1.2545403242,
-0.1097971871,
-0.1489476413,
-0.5082891583,
-0.5664615631,
0.320086807,
-0.4409625828,
0.6538519263,
0.6844626665,
-0.2348686606,
-0.3450403214,
-0.7614468932,
0.1142019406,
0.4152649045,
-0.805647552,
-0.0567576364,
0.5516239405,
0.1618847698,
0.0854699835,
0.3531910777,
-0.1361237764,
0.7173424959,
-0.1826003641,
-0.0693795681,
-0.6998201013,
-0.6080870628,
-0.403018713,
0.3646270335,
0.1824977696,
-0.326143086
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11939v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11939v1 | From Crowdsourced Data to High-Quality Benchmarks: Arena-Hard and BenchBuilder Pipeline | 2024-06-17T17:26:10 | 2024-06-17T17:26:10 | Tianle Li, Wei-Lin Chiang, Evan Frick, Lisa Dunlap, Tianhao Wu, Banghua Zhu, Joseph E. Gonzalez, Ion Stoica | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | The rapid evolution of language models has necessitated the development of
more challenging benchmarks. Current static benchmarks often struggle to
consistently distinguish between the capabilities of different models and fail
to align with real-world user preferences. On the other hand, live
crowd-sourced platforms like the Chatbot Arena collect a wide range of natural
prompts and user feedback. However, these prompts vary in sophistication and
the feedback cannot be applied offline to new models. In order to ensure that
benchmarks keep up with the pace of LLM development, we address how one can
evaluate benchmarks on their ability to confidently separate models and their
alignment with human preference. Under these principles, we developed
BenchBuilder, a living benchmark that filters high-quality prompts from live
data sources to enable offline evaluation on fresh, challenging prompts.
BenchBuilder identifies seven indicators of a high-quality prompt, such as the
requirement for domain knowledge, and utilizes an LLM annotator to select a
high-quality subset of prompts from various topic clusters. The LLM evaluation
process employs an LLM judge to ensure a fully automated, high-quality, and
constantly updating benchmark. We apply BenchBuilder on prompts from the
Chatbot Arena to create Arena-Hard-Auto v0.1: 500 challenging user prompts from
a wide range of tasks. Arena-Hard-Auto v0.1 offers 3x tighter confidence
intervals than MT-Bench and achieves a state-of-the-art 89.1% agreement with
human preference rankings, all at a cost of only $25 and without human
labelers. The BenchBuilder pipeline enhances evaluation benchmarks and provides
a valuable tool for developers, enabling them to extract high-quality
benchmarks from extensive data with minimal effort. | [
-0.4941114187,
-0.5170242786,
0.3669779599,
0.3304568827,
0.0713718459,
0.3489997685,
-0.3770750761,
-0.3397717476,
-0.2379645854,
0.4660158455,
-0.5256636739,
-0.4216904044,
-0.3880045414,
0.1541215479,
-0.2230223119,
0.7450481057,
-0.1023896113,
-0.0578480549,
-0.6433695555,
-0.2647660971,
-0.4209257662,
-0.5654373169,
-0.4226216376,
-0.293828249,
0.4476259947,
0.4236746132,
0.8188050985,
0.9534962177,
0.4435515106,
0.3679100871,
0.0613395721,
0.0650621951,
-0.7453680038,
0.3216121495,
-0.0885607973,
-0.3136258125,
-0.2950166166,
0.127358377,
0.3797267973,
0.4681673646,
-0.3455792367,
0.3891816735,
0.1959615648,
0.58206743,
-0.5560837984,
0.321890682,
-0.5699152946,
-0.1233414635,
-0.4332886934,
0.017575087,
-0.2739735842,
-0.5254724622,
-0.2799934149,
-0.565666616,
0.2157877386,
0.2129087001,
0.9921622872,
0.5085843801,
-0.1448978633,
0.1069353744,
-0.4480068088,
0.7255426645,
-0.4341785312,
0.6206384897,
0.3711107969,
0.7817969918,
-0.3224029541,
-0.843200922,
-0.4119791389,
-0.2447264194,
0.1370960474,
0.0454429016,
-0.3497403264,
-0.2658183277,
0.1568010747,
0.1316553652,
-0.4708431661,
0.3248358369,
-0.259831816,
-0.3007234335,
0.809885323,
0.2850421071,
-0.1143777147,
-0.420301795,
-0.4384378195,
-0.3983216882,
-0.6679849625,
0.1732255816,
0.2823994756,
0.1452450007,
0.147637859,
0.360566169,
-0.5063161254,
0.5669261217,
0.1895248592,
-0.1582852453,
0.3063558042,
0.01669484,
-0.04484725,
-0.3284650147,
0.9128220081,
0.5108423233,
0.1153998151,
-0.4129783511,
-0.2597572803,
0.1769283116,
0.2352998257,
-0.7214087844,
-0.0531645007,
0.4600380063,
-0.4664450586,
-0.2694181204,
-0.1833166927,
-0.7242673635,
-0.73364079,
-0.3977017403,
0.1461648941,
-0.1113436595,
-0.1265922636,
-0.291175127,
-0.0684117675,
0.048075784,
0.4013879299,
-0.6787922978,
0.4013020396,
0.9865160584,
0.5053776503,
-0.457021594,
-0.3607003391,
-0.9546496272,
-0.1723452359,
-0.1309559196,
1.2444438934,
-0.5861922503,
-0.398149997,
0.0106248455,
-0.0433630459,
0.3285816014,
-1.002874732,
0.7280695438,
-0.3537887633,
0.1597859114,
-0.243799895,
-0.7466201186,
0.2649069428,
0.2424490452,
-0.4882427156,
1.3158031702,
0.3155954778,
-0.0948711112,
0.6396542192,
-0.426289767,
-0.0373728871,
0.5529210567,
-0.3388813436,
-0.1444763243,
0.0830512345,
0.2902461886,
0.4742625952,
-0.5736137629,
0.6019240618,
-0.4962007105,
-0.1843163967,
0.4715559185,
-0.3955288231,
0.49045524,
0.3787176311,
-0.3891118467,
0.3482007384,
-0.9041304588,
0.2483815998,
-0.2087980211,
-0.3812820315,
0.155096665,
0.1759519428,
0.2917831838,
0.3431638181,
0.049913194,
-0.3848118782,
0.0129898069,
-0.0848497823,
0.3130372763,
0.8472841978,
-0.0986075029,
0.1618778855,
-0.485075593,
0.6045783162,
-0.4567915201,
0.2377279401,
0.2414104044,
-0.4243422449,
-0.5914991498,
-0.407632947,
0.4623056948,
0.5289093256,
-0.3410690129,
0.5353603959,
-0.2267571688,
-0.8725824356,
-1.2145406008,
0.5870071054,
0.387355715,
0.5014506578,
0.2490191311,
-0.5036539435,
-0.4902576208,
-0.8020762205,
-0.2920348942,
-0.3180064857,
-0.3914153874,
0.569642365,
-0.0214357823,
-0.0464327484,
1.0945756435,
-0.3364857137,
-0.1584165096,
-0.0812363923,
0.428894639,
0.3054776788,
0.3098966181,
0.157868281,
-0.5586034656,
-0.5717362165,
-0.2297126055,
-0.7294158936,
-0.5761417747,
0.1437953115,
-0.2082849592,
-0.0273106787,
0.4894773662,
-0.6139142513,
0.1745544672,
0.4929560423,
-0.117238678,
0.3297660649,
0.0184722487,
0.1578285396,
-0.8606534004,
0.1490453035,
-0.0381590091,
-0.2938892245,
-0.1995176822,
0.1841439605,
0.0817100182,
-0.1871967763,
-0.5205469728,
0.9458289742,
-0.4127472937,
-0.0987885371,
-0.218890965,
0.3965110779,
0.0228910912,
0.3486629426,
0.0093992734,
0.6859239936,
0.3075063527,
-0.3403899968,
0.7064830065,
0.392005533,
-0.6457583904,
0.7780447006,
-0.7753993273,
0.1643674225,
0.1263903081,
0.2731416225,
-0.9834529161,
-0.3059540689,
0.1214246228,
-0.4498723745,
0.013862635,
-0.2900013328,
-0.8172537088,
-0.3186039031,
-0.1765330583,
-0.1207227111,
0.8101187944,
-0.5068896413,
0.3480229378,
0.5322530866,
-0.2739328444,
-0.3605432808,
-0.2272757739,
0.1106212586,
-0.0920278206,
-0.6725875139,
0.2258461863,
-0.2826635838,
-0.4927032292,
-0.0990064368,
0.0009446965,
-0.0994892493,
0.2136934251,
0.6301929951,
0.3201777935,
-0.0981980413,
0.1543962061,
-0.3514218926,
-0.4156965911,
0.1160888672,
0.0431865193,
0.4057650566,
-0.0517647229,
-0.37960729,
-0.2844480872,
-0.0273532178,
0.4373114407,
-0.3339858949,
0.3875495493,
0.6200005412,
-0.1787298173,
0.0649336427,
-1.081636548,
-0.0693827942,
-0.4768392742,
0.1649204195,
-0.3574695885,
-0.8573471308,
0.4854392707,
-0.2335773259,
0.174828127,
0.4283084869,
0.6867574453,
-0.0681684613,
1.0614125729,
0.1268712282,
-0.139851287,
0.178747803,
0.1699932218,
-0.3444925547,
-0.7263404727,
-0.1884300113,
-0.7516306639,
-0.4026869237,
-0.5638921261,
-0.5787416697,
0.2557258308,
0.1390034854,
-0.0615124516,
0.2832837105,
-0.5219661593,
0.6118813753,
0.5226952434,
-0.0140701886,
0.2550998628,
-0.2042495012,
-0.0383414701,
-0.168916896,
-0.5353690386,
-0.6230263114,
1.0411295891,
0.3387385011,
0.6475784779,
0.1220015138,
0.6761474609,
0.347071439,
0.8272859454,
-0.4297968447,
0.5253878832,
0.2148002386,
-1.0329329967,
-0.3474987447,
-0.4199234247,
-0.9964222908,
0.2343357652,
-0.3886331916,
-0.8006958961,
0.2692612708,
0.0029153179,
-0.3527116477,
0.0476685241,
-0.6095446944,
1.0716403723,
-0.2143972516,
-0.9137820005,
-0.0272439644,
-0.5704767108,
0.0614294037,
-0.1058772728,
0.3862863183,
-0.5219813585,
-0.052709464,
0.5230865479,
-0.7198587656,
0.7105383873,
-0.2268850803,
0.1002332568,
0.3783707023,
0.081229955,
0.6953420639,
0.2324416041,
-0.4459205866,
0.0601375625,
-0.1620848924,
-0.4693830013,
-0.5170804858,
0.8152039051,
-0.9203874469,
-0.7091048956,
-0.23467803,
-0.3292302787,
-0.5169865489,
0.0277117323,
0.1216171384,
0.3812235594,
-0.4269579649,
0.3548201621,
0.3122639954,
-0.0358159579,
0.2747829854,
0.6879807115,
-0.3132764995,
-0.5229231119,
0.7386260629,
-0.0705364943,
0.0640790239,
0.3580881953,
0.0890531167,
-0.4644256532,
-0.4009487331,
-0.6436011791,
-0.0180090275,
-0.5309258699,
-0.3732297122,
-0.5171468854,
-0.0592566207,
-0.311208874,
-0.219585374,
-0.4711169004,
-0.2922166586,
-0.0950979143,
-0.1277246326,
0.3931509256,
0.4400509,
-0.0974679515,
-0.0101591926,
-0.8991313577,
0.2221525013,
0.5589954853,
0.4744887948,
-0.144813776,
-0.4253673255,
-0.0217384081,
-0.1935391724,
-0.2501525283,
-0.5514751077,
0.4005676508,
-0.0866786316,
0.7961570621,
0.3067353964,
0.153065294,
0.7366104126,
-0.3782246113,
0.5695699453,
-0.0287663061,
-0.8363200426,
0.3671537936,
-0.3427881896,
0.4209091663,
1.0672107935,
0.3296736181,
-0.4686754942,
-0.4200693369,
-0.6028301716,
-0.7024879456,
0.5897216201,
0.1912434399,
-0.0178918708,
-0.091868028,
0.0374500379,
0.3635951579,
0.2752738595,
-0.4197297096,
-0.1688058376,
-0.2567285299,
0.0255026501,
-0.2230402529,
-0.1037047282,
-0.1793039292,
-0.0969837308,
0.4609772563,
-0.0554612502,
-0.1123303771,
-0.2498072833,
-0.1973320842,
-0.3524526358,
0.5680570602,
0.0436026454,
0.8791425824,
-0.5173637271,
-0.0894233435,
0.3169363439,
-0.040850658,
0.181348905,
0.6315846443,
-0.0104105314,
0.0280363318,
0.2496905476,
0.7617632747,
0.5347797871,
-0.8884758353,
0.4935791492,
-0.0672349632,
-0.1068102941,
-0.0381260179,
0.1608217061,
0.2640758455,
0.2733614147,
0.5215338469,
0.003727295,
-0.0280385464,
-0.4289854467,
0.1941244602,
0.1704027206,
-0.6080213189,
-0.1950802505,
0.8416452408,
0.658184886,
-0.5207306147,
0.6097496748,
-0.208957687,
-0.1241735369,
0.3649801016,
0.0860059857,
0.8979695439,
-0.1742957234,
0.2719223201,
0.2334754318,
-0.0519721955,
-0.0041335127,
0.1449646801,
-0.1579542607,
-0.4706210792,
-0.2980442345,
-0.6644411087,
-0.8158690929,
0.0143956942,
-0.6422646046,
0.4157964885,
-0.5274754167,
-0.2613225281,
0.1553208232,
0.1035949811,
-0.9119958878,
0.1421617419,
0.092254281,
0.9374101758,
-0.4419972897,
0.5411216021,
0.5594311953,
-0.4262183011,
-0.7452971935,
-0.3955232203,
0.3712272644,
-0.9728236198,
0.5627422929,
-0.0014266262,
0.3701939583,
0.0337934978,
-0.6361618042,
-0.7805354595,
1.1029911041,
0.2738020718,
-0.7597016096,
0.2591461241,
-0.0002981315,
0.7027750015,
-0.3248606324,
0.499030143,
0.2899562418,
0.5926134586,
0.1529393643,
-0.9820193648,
0.1030157134,
-0.3760105968,
-0.2069370896,
0.238038376,
-0.8927666545,
0.4953809381,
0.1559650898,
-0.1590398699,
-0.0208575558,
0.5597347617,
0.6223015785,
0.3765197992,
0.454845041,
0.4274154603,
0.7318705916,
-0.186657697,
1.0930825472,
-0.5690146089,
0.0655802786,
1.1006356478,
-0.7070310116,
1.3159453869,
0.2975248098,
-0.3997055292,
0.6221128702,
0.6344719529,
-0.3406717777,
0.2977687418,
0.4810242653,
-0.1145541742,
-0.4858162403,
-0.4122522771,
-0.4606055319,
0.3945739865,
-0.0755720362,
-0.0318763144,
-0.1247340813,
-0.3091525137,
0.0426128246,
0.2106109858,
0.0163123719,
0.8569880724,
-0.1007036269,
-1.0208234787,
0.6717781425,
-0.1032932252,
0.4970541298,
-0.5681526661,
0.2052689046,
-0.5025085807,
0.1787183881,
-0.1643868536,
-0.6113587022,
-0.1764639467,
0.2930326164,
-0.0224483833,
-0.5759069324,
0.667678237,
-0.1381502897,
-0.4209980965,
0.1251573712,
0.8156599998,
0.3851663768,
-0.2169651836,
-0.7274380326,
0.4272683561,
-0.281678915,
-0.2401448041,
0.4142047465,
0.4988539517,
0.0078400141,
0.7659742236,
0.7694664001,
-0.0441966206,
-0.2322786152,
0.2248236835,
0.9528781176,
-0.6504539251,
-0.2342604101,
-0.6203818917,
0.5709915757,
-0.2720185816,
-0.5797257423,
0.7221030593,
0.7789092064,
0.6438590288,
0.1461388469,
0.6899103522,
0.0271763969,
0.8074462414,
-0.1707623899,
0.8088242412,
-0.3948932588,
0.3617262542,
-0.2668120265,
-1.1489197016,
-0.036384061,
0.1830407381,
-0.1667397916,
-0.0097984644,
0.4563230276,
0.8381357789,
0.091185227,
-0.1646349132,
0.2226256132,
0.1393208951,
0.2194927931,
0.4136923254,
0.9799461365,
-0.2892819345,
0.9581164718,
-0.0887900963,
-0.3515532613,
-0.3743045628,
-0.9356393814,
-0.8739616871,
-0.4368851185,
-0.4786004424,
-0.4180240929,
0.1075615287,
1.0989207029,
1.0426710844,
-0.8212997913,
-0.5342495441,
0.1662210226,
0.1520370096,
-0.2899383008,
-0.2827546299,
0.0732095391,
-0.3166934848,
-0.5923793316,
0.5221213698,
0.2586607933,
-0.2669121027,
-0.4355176091,
-0.2993846834,
0.0579433441,
0.0202098284,
0.3219012916,
0.4610501528,
-0.8102055788,
-0.1715505421,
0.2199487835,
-0.3888401091,
0.2079299688,
0.3619580567,
-1.1523569822,
0.4759580791,
0.3615815043,
0.6967226863,
0.6752052903,
0.256023705,
0.7227399945,
-0.6541002989,
-0.1956668049,
0.1136243567,
0.0902127624,
0.5969563723,
-0.0364952348,
0.7777356505,
0.2036264837,
-0.6587954164,
-0.9071627855,
-0.1191850081,
-0.8470021486,
-0.0115149086,
1.0802233219,
-0.0012372732,
-0.2553731501,
-0.1607467979,
-0.2419035137,
-0.0462343805,
-0.6466097236,
1.0855354071,
0.9118800759,
-0.1528908163,
-0.2902930677,
-0.4486836791,
0.5726405382,
0.3395283222,
-1.0916385651,
0.2177812606,
0.6173870564,
0.1304971725,
0.0672141388,
0.5502074957,
-0.0263978094,
0.302455008,
0.099174507,
0.2013117671,
-0.1653537601,
0.0928934366,
0.0220009778,
0.4403134584,
0.3247997165,
0.1544246525
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11757v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11757v1 | STAR: SocioTechnical Approach to Red Teaming Language Models | 2024-06-17T17:16:45 | 2024-06-17T17:16:45 | Laura Weidinger, John Mellor, Bernat Guillen Pegueroles, Nahema Marchal, Ravin Kumar, Kristian Lum, Canfer Akbulut, Mark Diaz, Stevie Bergman, Mikel Rodriguez, Verena Rieser, William Isaac | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.HC | This research introduces STAR, a sociotechnical framework that improves on
current best practices for red teaming safety of large language models. STAR
makes two key contributions: it enhances steerability by generating
parameterised instructions for human red teamers, leading to improved coverage
of the risk surface. Parameterised instructions also provide more detailed
insights into model failures at no increased cost. Second, STAR improves signal
quality by matching demographics to assess harms for specific groups, resulting
in more sensitive annotations. STAR further employs a novel step of arbitration
to leverage diverse viewpoints and improve label reliability, treating
disagreement not as noise but as a valuable contribution to signal quality. | [
-0.2131556869,
-0.6980269551,
0.2499888539,
0.2488868088,
0.1842713058,
0.4400933981,
-0.2916768491,
-0.9504737854,
0.4221822917,
0.4850458503,
-0.3884240687,
-0.5427013636,
-0.6960834265,
-0.086245738,
-0.2022433579,
1.1402155161,
0.1906913221,
0.0853010193,
0.1689182967,
0.0113558918,
-0.4209104478,
-0.6576915979,
-0.7125550508,
-0.1446430236,
0.7031331062,
0.7692697048,
1.0646010637,
0.6696560383,
0.9074546695,
0.3210813999,
-0.2675406337,
-0.31375283,
-0.5456804633,
0.1973022223,
-0.1259417534,
-0.3290039301,
-0.5923432112,
0.1253573149,
0.3197970688,
0.9380063415,
-0.0269347709,
0.2706036866,
0.1262000352,
0.6990271807,
-0.6786901355,
0.3265123963,
-0.4283739626,
-0.2980791926,
-0.0766317695,
-0.2619584501,
-0.5380750299,
-0.196149379,
0.0063418727,
-0.5686956048,
0.0926932916,
0.1093838438,
0.8347927928,
0.2317279428,
-0.267323643,
-0.0622819886,
-0.9762621522,
0.7081003189,
-0.3935766518,
0.374504447,
0.4862338901,
0.9466786385,
0.0594210476,
-0.5698660612,
-0.2567841709,
-0.1542413235,
-0.0965382531,
0.1933730245,
0.1238221228,
0.4705079198,
-0.0665224344,
-0.2463462949,
-0.3358123302,
0.3369126618,
-0.6780830622,
-0.308044821,
1.0587946177,
-0.0241869334,
0.3817543387,
-0.2321108282,
-0.4837695062,
-0.1732984483,
-0.7240557075,
0.0051001175,
0.4976200163,
0.5775948763,
-0.5126796365,
0.2486328483,
-0.4358616769,
0.6120896935,
-0.1134412289,
0.0480363443,
0.045242548,
-0.5083414316,
-0.0185328517,
0.1404958665,
0.5381068587,
0.820030272,
0.3743287325,
-0.1971256584,
-0.2378000617,
0.4503999054,
0.2350973934,
-0.2986060679,
-0.5620189905,
0.3812568784,
-0.4370331764,
-0.6344406605,
-0.0249318369,
-0.8309541941,
-0.3948852718,
-0.4307663143,
0.3467185795,
-0.3465023935,
-0.4923204482,
0.1151248589,
-0.0809173286,
0.2376234382,
0.287147373,
-0.92788589,
0.1829186529,
0.7889268994,
0.4732617438,
0.2949320078,
-0.3995031714,
-0.8366668224,
0.2093243152,
-0.3841586411,
0.9968545437,
-0.6808336973,
-0.2166049629,
-0.0636118278,
-0.2815029025,
-0.0238428358,
-0.2877595723,
0.0621874295,
-0.5355800986,
-0.0154937701,
-0.2293098271,
-0.1216453984,
-0.2448629588,
-0.0226083994,
-0.4335252047,
0.7988886237,
0.1496548355,
-0.5590138435,
0.799330771,
-0.9912383556,
-0.3057046235,
0.5444267392,
0.038793616,
-0.1663375795,
-0.2965137362,
-0.1599900872,
0.7301748991,
0.0463793501,
0.2328615785,
-0.4409123957,
-0.2791149318,
0.0126860477,
0.3117488623,
0.6960754991,
0.3267059922,
-0.3182086647,
0.9075059295,
-0.457138747,
0.0492348187,
-0.183897838,
-0.1186374575,
-0.3841726184,
0.1860767156,
0.6652614474,
0.2807164192,
-0.114379026,
-0.5531284809,
-0.3326882124,
-0.2048150152,
0.6925345659,
0.6360730529,
0.0967358574,
0.5613493323,
-0.2805143893,
0.4640712142,
-0.3141676784,
0.7070217729,
0.1937387884,
-0.338832736,
-0.6692154408,
-0.3232348859,
0.4438995123,
0.5574699044,
-1.0050270557,
0.4082649052,
0.0122732529,
-0.7330904603,
-0.3940924406,
-0.0686292946,
0.6856666803,
0.2947035134,
0.3085374534,
0.1275005788,
-0.8559811711,
-1.1219507456,
0.0012440615,
-0.518612802,
0.4106224477,
0.1300391108,
0.6002988219,
-0.5507688522,
0.7021235228,
-0.0586645342,
-0.0802437812,
-0.6560737491,
-0.0867191032,
0.026334025,
0.505559206,
0.5414594412,
-0.9205399156,
-0.6507259607,
0.1642072946,
-0.8949917555,
-0.0155063691,
-0.0540903173,
-0.1973277479,
0.5501973629,
0.6276803017,
-0.1789685488,
0.2504189909,
0.9494395256,
-0.8541958332,
0.7112957835,
0.0921592489,
0.3768554032,
-0.9199184775,
0.0990132317,
0.4606337547,
-0.3110775948,
-0.9228197932,
0.4874584079,
-0.0469751172,
-0.1941959113,
-0.6715998054,
0.3983625472,
-0.3717854619,
-0.1255026609,
-0.2314532101,
0.2710116804,
-0.5026165247,
0.135556981,
0.1290444881,
0.8230184317,
0.6028229594,
-0.759608984,
0.1278455704,
0.0933732018,
-0.163927272,
0.5539980531,
-0.8727251291,
-0.2721604109,
-0.1350737959,
-0.0546184964,
-0.9738622308,
-0.4384616911,
0.2450359911,
-0.7267781496,
0.3000335693,
-0.088923797,
-0.5164840817,
-0.0512960255,
-0.2131815553,
0.3172343969,
0.634188652,
-0.2377094477,
0.177931115,
1.0696027279,
-0.3348360956,
-0.3753491342,
-0.2119319141,
0.3094540536,
-0.2984528542,
-0.7910118103,
0.2315095514,
0.1141757965,
-0.7089647651,
-0.0454145148,
0.1670258194,
-0.2558761239,
0.4289236069,
0.0854618475,
0.4472627044,
-0.1166745722,
0.0919735804,
-0.3008909523,
-0.5738832951,
0.0728132874,
0.200041011,
0.4593873322,
-0.3416319489,
0.1556750685,
-0.5843419433,
0.5957548618,
0.4938513935,
-0.1831713915,
0.8998626471,
0.3772960901,
-0.3367142975,
-0.2307170033,
-0.4575536847,
-0.5148915648,
-0.4994770288,
0.5297583938,
-0.0425964631,
-0.9225149155,
0.4926222563,
0.1501006782,
0.2011884898,
0.5065863729,
0.2735791802,
-0.6347127557,
0.7057573199,
1.0804686546,
0.0037592913,
0.3175182641,
0.0293186959,
0.0031540899,
-0.5172197223,
-0.2889247835,
-0.6276676655,
-0.2921285331,
-0.2735126317,
-0.3317606747,
0.5646565557,
0.2889743149,
-0.3851856589,
0.6399730444,
-0.7648568153,
0.3462660909,
0.3268827498,
0.1480838805,
0.1121858433,
-0.272271812,
0.1939487308,
-0.0788188577,
-1.1874667406,
-0.7560540438,
0.7679787278,
0.7734565735,
0.6971861124,
0.3600144684,
0.8074938655,
0.3912373185,
0.5897529125,
-0.5431720614,
0.6477110386,
0.2030933201,
-0.8401299715,
-0.492605567,
-0.3643057644,
-0.833014667,
-0.0411069356,
-0.7108209133,
-0.7098813653,
-0.018283911,
0.4559432864,
-0.3717284203,
0.0971953049,
-0.9433138967,
0.8034041524,
-0.1952019334,
-0.2934483588,
-0.2737642229,
-0.6597369909,
0.3994264901,
0.0716828853,
0.4928500354,
0.0964633599,
-0.0114226574,
1.1533939838,
-0.2824851871,
1.4641128778,
-0.2098596841,
0.1780959964,
0.1933661997,
0.1294650584,
0.4789932966,
0.0012000841,
0.0284930151,
0.3738313019,
0.0679944679,
-0.4645710588,
-0.3128991723,
0.4649692476,
-0.71363765,
-0.5939950347,
-0.3768550158,
-0.6226806641,
-0.142580688,
0.0038810952,
0.0135882394,
0.1309801936,
0.1531393528,
0.3172779083,
0.3602074981,
-0.2927951813,
0.5002220273,
0.4671087861,
-0.1482762247,
-0.4559129775,
0.6648388505,
-0.1147953495,
0.6073373556,
0.1729402095,
-0.0925383568,
-0.3725815713,
-0.658331573,
-0.2404415905,
0.4001689851,
-0.9397048354,
-0.1447845846,
-0.5513864756,
-0.3213532269,
-0.2998836339,
-0.5639148951,
-0.6484417319,
-0.4716270268,
0.1769165695,
-0.2083173841,
0.5719198585,
0.9635228515,
-0.009557711,
0.3188099265,
-0.9160754681,
-0.0829587951,
-0.0818651542,
0.5722826719,
-0.3946564794,
-0.1691642702,
-0.4525225461,
-0.1298502535,
0.1769814938,
-0.9398104548,
0.1588201523,
-0.1630299836,
1.0077762604,
-0.1206630245,
0.2702761889,
0.402304709,
-0.3562066555,
0.7214779258,
0.571844101,
-0.9732544422,
0.8316434026,
-0.7748985291,
-0.2015299797,
0.5636456609,
0.3223879039,
-0.6064519882,
-0.379116714,
-0.7576956153,
-0.8282192349,
0.396214813,
0.2229753584,
-0.3794947565,
-0.0695000663,
0.3505784869,
-0.0732655227,
-0.2377799004,
-0.6184425354,
-0.267891705,
-0.0299924035,
-0.0657660067,
-0.5404696465,
-0.4138052762,
-0.3303802013,
0.1146278679,
0.5502465367,
-0.114682883,
0.2831472158,
0.0917960852,
-0.0470481813,
-0.1968749166,
0.1288169175,
0.6881912351,
0.7727389932,
-0.0363076553,
0.0954484046,
0.1701314896,
-0.1677339375,
0.0801549405,
-0.0976957008,
-0.0565333068,
-0.1927658021,
0.8455430865,
0.3641178608,
0.6646841764,
-0.4558844268,
0.2068015486,
0.3656951785,
-0.5286281109,
-0.2258717418,
0.3841666877,
-0.0870075598,
0.3272973299,
0.1696298718,
0.3878950775,
-0.0846628547,
-0.598703444,
0.6502833962,
0.3078305125,
-0.9009758234,
-0.4633482695,
0.9104738832,
0.9297698736,
-0.6497737765,
-0.0853959993,
0.1044436097,
-0.5514361262,
0.712064743,
0.2799571455,
0.7198890448,
-0.2231284082,
0.5278641582,
0.4254437983,
0.4725546539,
0.0162186082,
0.3083798885,
0.2195770144,
-0.6299799085,
-0.7407147288,
-0.3761901259,
-0.6016407013,
-0.3456213772,
-0.5505542755,
0.1313949525,
-0.6889601946,
-0.1963294894,
0.088564612,
-0.1799034476,
-0.3198789656,
0.1844836622,
0.0349370986,
0.9041580558,
-0.9990953803,
0.69728899,
1.0143419504,
-0.4604432881,
-0.8118629456,
-0.2196059376,
0.2287617624,
-0.5120485425,
1.2955327034,
-0.0851971954,
-0.1947878003,
-0.1158927009,
-0.207252562,
-0.8357319236,
1.0346037149,
0.1327055246,
-0.4941599369,
0.2581087649,
-0.1136796325,
0.5499550104,
-0.2788896859,
0.0437919348,
0.179583028,
0.5502072573,
-0.0058147768,
-1.2237657309,
0.1315307021,
-0.2931713164,
-0.170002982,
0.1894685179,
-0.6178086996,
0.5573133826,
-0.391243875,
-0.4083360732,
-0.3575492203,
0.5671239495,
0.3174037933,
0.0993287563,
0.6693096161,
-0.2231794149,
0.5675005317,
0.0756812096,
1.322815299,
-0.5401754379,
0.3397061527,
0.6279899478,
-0.2874538302,
0.9126870632,
0.4855256379,
-0.1340269595,
0.152325213,
0.6232930422,
0.3162166476,
0.2240250111,
-0.0778613314,
-0.0404276364,
-0.5902453065,
-0.0013407685,
-0.3904735744,
0.5938816667,
0.0877780914,
-0.2585644126,
-0.1786189824,
-0.2204672098,
0.0339973867,
0.6683307886,
-0.3142779768,
0.6106664538,
-0.1387395561,
-0.6741138101,
0.5389779806,
-0.0209164061,
0.7177093625,
-0.3180610538,
-0.1528331786,
0.0531561337,
0.2189579606,
-0.403709203,
-0.9855249524,
0.6671273708,
-0.1019975245,
-0.2687702179,
-0.1987809986,
0.7438589334,
-0.18879731,
-0.5303123593,
0.5749678016,
0.3730556667,
0.0307682548,
0.2020290941,
-0.6772601604,
0.2661592066,
-0.0515236668,
0.0946541131,
0.2491447926,
-0.0354559906,
-0.1402209699,
0.9994961619,
0.5707062483,
0.3114279509,
-0.1774903387,
0.0237480439,
0.8714732528,
-1.0131115913,
-0.6201693416,
-0.5789909363,
0.8780871034,
-0.1618466675,
-0.2868036032,
0.7271522284,
0.2260201126,
0.5762604475,
-0.1372125596,
0.687911272,
-0.025351027,
0.4620609283,
-0.6550931334,
1.2617884874,
-0.0551754646,
0.5574100614,
-0.5563579798,
-0.8703433871,
-0.8689851761,
0.6691225767,
-0.3922331035,
0.1094590724,
0.6930815578,
0.8830096126,
0.2462002188,
0.0621256195,
0.5382684469,
0.048317723,
0.4686928093,
0.642789185,
0.999812603,
-0.4962571263,
0.6453691721,
-0.123829715,
-0.6331880093,
-0.2155697197,
-0.7596728802,
-1.1310228109,
-0.6471323967,
-0.68023175,
-0.3418656588,
0.5292487144,
0.7681922317,
1.2344447374,
-0.6673913598,
-0.2612555921,
0.125084728,
-0.052525159,
-0.4039452374,
-0.2586385608,
0.0438582227,
-0.792077899,
-0.3322823942,
0.2619898021,
0.2225025743,
-0.3016753793,
-0.2692141533,
-0.4402106106,
-0.2347818613,
-0.2886816859,
0.8229901791,
0.2235486507,
-0.5915187597,
-0.9190417528,
-0.1418830901,
-0.145052582,
-0.26259166,
0.422013998,
-0.5207989812,
-0.0010756979,
0.3403541446,
0.5713005066,
-0.0463930331,
-0.2464676499,
0.7492018342,
-0.3712488413,
0.1779709309,
0.3170881867,
0.2497557551,
0.1861231774,
-0.6189522743,
0.8133375049,
0.3297793269,
-0.7000789046,
-0.7328323126,
0.3811691999,
-1.211294055,
-0.3389237225,
1.6241852045,
0.0770935789,
-0.2419579774,
-0.5423423648,
-0.0428890064,
0.0526827052,
-0.4053295255,
0.9058359861,
0.4101781249,
-0.1277251542,
-0.4703858793,
-0.6942121983,
0.7071568966,
0.2978741825,
-0.8136031032,
0.2857179642,
0.408572942,
0.3639802039,
0.1711973995,
0.4829827249,
-0.1177234948,
0.7052096725,
0.2933548689,
0.3598977327,
-0.3298482299,
-0.7312676311,
-0.0253720582,
0.3161032498,
0.0838062465,
-0.1691816598
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11753v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11753v1 | A Semantic-based Layer Freezing Approach to Efficient Fine-Tuning of Language Models | 2024-06-17T17:13:08 | 2024-06-17T17:13:08 | Jian Gu, Aldeida Aleti, Chunyang Chen, Hongyu Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Finetuning language models (LMs) is crucial for adapting the models to
downstream data and tasks. However, full finetuning is usually costly. Existing
work, such as parameter-efficient finetuning (PEFT), often focuses on
\textit{how to finetune} but neglects the issue of \textit{where to finetune}.
As a pioneering work on answering where to finetune (at the layer level), we
conduct a semantic analysis of the LM inference process. We first propose a
virtual transition of the latent representation and then trace its factual
transition. Based on the deviation in transitions, we estimate the gain of
finetuning each model layer, and further, narrow down the scope for finetuning.
We perform extensive experiments across well-known LMs and datasets. The
results show that our approach is effective and efficient, and outperforms the
existing baselines. Our approach is orthogonal to existing efficient
techniques, such as PEFT methods, offering practical values on LM finetuning. | [
-0.650601387,
-1.1960084438,
0.6688848138,
-0.1667728722,
-0.1237311289,
-0.1655090898,
-0.4462553561,
-0.2651974261,
-0.299051106,
0.7888857126,
-0.7373004556,
-0.5539466143,
-0.2833899856,
-0.3282865286,
-0.3615957201,
0.75956738,
0.1778634936,
-0.1460901499,
-0.1052498147,
0.1632543504,
-0.2300592512,
-0.1435125619,
-0.6750950813,
-0.5734238625,
0.5087903738,
0.7677383423,
0.7887003422,
0.8990220428,
0.1694139391,
0.2732551098,
-0.1924993992,
0.2426840365,
-0.6016241908,
0.1322534531,
-0.2895949483,
-0.5366379023,
-0.2946032584,
0.1262783557,
0.4022583365,
1.070014596,
-0.1526084244,
0.0590100661,
0.1688196361,
0.7291133404,
-0.7571943402,
0.0062428568,
-1.0954385996,
0.0981380567,
-0.2756533623,
-0.1710707843,
-0.4154856205,
0.0670780092,
0.3407870233,
-0.5788766742,
0.452940017,
-0.1555013955,
0.9794496894,
0.4464415312,
-0.1303417236,
0.2595983148,
-0.9129164219,
0.9592409134,
-0.9081721902,
0.6969630122,
0.6134728789,
0.3348297477,
-0.164421007,
-0.7502520084,
-0.4604748487,
-0.231335327,
0.1447282135,
0.0032876809,
0.0368686877,
0.2738719881,
0.0110073164,
0.3767338693,
-0.1675959826,
0.3204985857,
-0.1273682415,
-0.3397656977,
0.305542022,
0.0930887014,
0.3103901744,
0.0963702276,
-0.2488140464,
-0.0339473747,
-0.4746317863,
-0.0832981765,
0.191164881,
0.6750725508,
-0.0140270228,
0.4064292014,
-0.4495152533,
0.9290999174,
0.282823354,
0.0006414621,
-0.0147355646,
-0.170100525,
-0.4400734603,
0.1218688041,
0.4232279658,
0.5626906753,
0.2361905277,
-0.5274050236,
-0.2639673054,
0.0013173604,
0.0755149126,
-0.8062209487,
-0.5360181928,
0.4250919819,
-0.1954843849,
-0.2195257097,
-0.3071107864,
-0.3029246628,
-0.2939876616,
-0.6400424242,
0.3897351623,
-0.6552475095,
-0.4145188928,
0.2368072271,
0.0553945154,
0.4795642495,
0.2865647674,
-0.8787558675,
0.6809108853,
0.9515901208,
0.7647019625,
0.0373443626,
-0.2545430362,
-0.7491586804,
0.1535169184,
-0.5417884588,
0.8442512155,
-0.4170572758,
0.1913678795,
-0.2196858376,
-0.0528615527,
0.0220673941,
-0.6158289909,
0.7026007175,
-0.6112870574,
0.1635637134,
0.0335306115,
-0.862191081,
0.0277877059,
0.2014106214,
-0.6720032096,
0.8073428273,
-0.1568126827,
-0.6120316982,
0.2955625355,
-0.2866515517,
-0.1079180464,
-0.0341416337,
0.1308598369,
-0.2711440921,
0.2297123373,
0.3030330241,
0.8378612995,
-0.5732131004,
0.1501622051,
-0.2518586516,
0.1350786686,
0.0395164602,
-0.2468266785,
0.5349422693,
0.561409235,
-0.156808123,
0.0389986597,
-0.8922908306,
0.3945222795,
-0.0041946275,
-0.1670674682,
-0.7619552016,
0.1925702244,
0.1002188772,
-0.0404201411,
0.0302757826,
-0.5744205713,
-0.058564119,
-0.9074353576,
0.6123859286,
0.607867837,
-0.2424835861,
0.7962886095,
-0.1108464822,
0.1019704938,
0.110844031,
-0.0606290214,
0.0438139774,
-0.1679335833,
-0.9791656137,
-0.0967493132,
0.5691962838,
0.5363224745,
-0.734647572,
0.2186961025,
0.0596811026,
-0.5059635639,
-0.5996029973,
0.17934753,
0.4620222449,
0.5522514582,
0.3717793524,
-0.0155887846,
-0.0940249488,
-1.0299440622,
-0.3970472813,
0.1450134963,
-0.0310969278,
0.0806641281,
-0.0770453289,
0.1696256846,
0.993925035,
-0.4827928543,
-0.1485374719,
-0.0536691211,
0.0760757029,
0.2206262797,
0.840810895,
0.4827613831,
-0.7241466641,
-0.4128936231,
0.366084069,
-0.280176878,
-0.2646411955,
-0.1198739335,
-0.3114035726,
0.2716748714,
0.8714647293,
-0.5214646459,
-0.1356995702,
0.5486805439,
-0.4597890079,
0.2181145102,
-0.2197525203,
-0.1966422051,
-0.7333673835,
-0.1799429208,
0.0437691286,
-0.4448637366,
-1.0275914669,
0.2654394209,
0.1056832746,
-0.1209060326,
-0.3805682957,
0.4522645772,
-0.6590881348,
0.3087695837,
-0.0855777562,
0.2083867341,
-0.099557735,
0.3435047865,
-0.1102571487,
0.2831735611,
0.6821838021,
-0.7311842442,
0.067614384,
-0.3805668056,
-0.4763200581,
0.4546618462,
-0.5439121127,
0.3515771627,
-0.2647988796,
-0.2941854,
-0.8416954875,
-0.0950548574,
0.2862004936,
-0.0672773346,
0.3521186411,
-0.6883372664,
-0.391430974,
0.1932159215,
-0.0551330969,
0.2391783893,
0.3607479632,
-0.2737786174,
0.6031067967,
0.4977397323,
0.0197918024,
-0.2093647867,
-0.6728536487,
0.0700283349,
-0.4568683505,
-0.8264108896,
0.667339623,
-0.1035280451,
-0.3533094227,
-0.0095150564,
-0.2464024723,
-0.427880913,
0.4175112545,
-0.2180896997,
-0.1100698709,
-0.5959391594,
-0.0412934572,
0.2299330682,
-0.3620839715,
-0.1095189676,
-0.7337741852,
0.6165298223,
-0.1681802273,
-0.0298556183,
-0.4148532152,
0.2911429703,
0.4556442797,
-0.3011134267,
0.8896790147,
0.7294874787,
-0.6218107939,
-0.6912814975,
-0.7550125718,
-0.2062357664,
-0.4842262268,
0.1851503104,
-0.5805592537,
-0.7711192369,
0.7712751627,
-0.2404220551,
0.0447827168,
0.4425884187,
0.4199171662,
0.0302757882,
0.9392894506,
0.9494250417,
0.4001086354,
0.5374444127,
-0.3508833647,
0.1315840036,
-0.4634597003,
-0.0581814237,
-0.630087316,
-0.1554623246,
-0.566619873,
-0.5764619708,
0.1146027297,
0.658693254,
-0.2496662289,
0.2189307511,
-0.3730723858,
0.8433387876,
0.3249361813,
0.1492608488,
0.1784215122,
0.1173017621,
-0.3610257208,
-0.123016566,
-0.9120900631,
-0.3698328137,
0.4971590638,
0.4045368433,
0.6349335313,
0.1841724068,
0.6060231924,
-0.0666250885,
-0.2538284361,
-1.0254784822,
0.4624380469,
-0.4226330519,
-0.3265752494,
-0.5747633576,
-0.4067206085,
-0.7911540866,
0.1589685977,
-0.1847570091,
-0.7063378096,
0.1935506463,
0.4458416402,
-0.3640125692,
0.2635498643,
-1.0118750334,
0.9923080802,
0.0106985057,
-0.5694684982,
-0.2427425086,
-0.6253634691,
0.1641145349,
-0.0338560082,
0.2209595293,
-0.5969683528,
-0.1230951324,
0.6170336008,
-0.7137188315,
0.9215699434,
-0.4355409443,
-0.3415082395,
0.1566588879,
0.5197378397,
0.3944032788,
-0.2052263916,
-0.3523961306,
-0.0587674007,
0.3456549048,
-0.4809825718,
-0.7226885557,
1.0352869034,
-0.7282347679,
-0.5421836972,
0.034812659,
-0.6665190458,
-0.5030696988,
0.4110662341,
-0.0259909295,
0.477701813,
-0.0773988366,
0.0472561605,
0.8131986856,
-0.2007543445,
0.2176554799,
0.4842500389,
-0.047428038,
-0.0744710714,
0.9403922558,
0.3790717423,
0.5495302677,
0.5306655169,
0.6786181927,
-0.0101943035,
-0.8357014656,
-0.3914080858,
0.0776105598,
-0.6714916229,
-0.2068734169,
-0.5091457367,
-0.2802113891,
-0.1858214736,
-0.0925092846,
-0.7103426456,
-0.5718035102,
-0.1594641954,
0.0827542469,
0.5648872852,
0.2555195987,
-0.0302362312,
0.1465649754,
-0.6984828115,
0.1584469676,
0.2014192641,
0.6573873162,
0.1003742218,
-0.4073316753,
-0.2969865203,
0.0739931241,
0.0599488951,
-0.5196284652,
0.2020010352,
0.6717486382,
0.7534745932,
0.2121536732,
0.4115695059,
0.8223279715,
-0.6455659866,
0.704380095,
-0.0395546034,
-1.1198562384,
0.5145044327,
-0.3974437416,
0.4329141378,
0.4827902913,
0.115366444,
-0.4213052094,
-0.555108726,
-0.5176122785,
-1.2088142633,
0.6493790746,
0.1990976185,
0.4088671207,
0.2042315751,
0.6052005887,
0.2086212188,
-0.1645041257,
-0.3892044425,
-0.2728413045,
-0.0687064826,
-0.0304040276,
-0.0611428209,
-0.2707798481,
-0.0550296418,
-0.3462890089,
0.4716437459,
-0.24662292,
0.014043049,
0.2040479779,
-0.2263844758,
-0.095857814,
0.2489043623,
0.3478903174,
0.7133432627,
-0.2430812567,
0.6214093566,
0.3016715646,
-0.1199864522,
-0.2274039239,
0.0059868456,
-0.2296260446,
-0.1763202995,
0.3201906681,
0.8438506722,
0.186052382,
-0.4543779194,
0.1313963383,
0.1595786959,
-0.1788689643,
-0.1721967161,
0.2507072091,
0.1720887721,
0.4092040062,
0.0123306159,
-0.0607389435,
0.1015832722,
-0.4676347375,
0.3272311985,
0.3155755401,
-0.6278952956,
-0.1283963919,
0.5618716478,
-0.0017440971,
-0.1439066529,
0.5072327852,
0.2179854959,
-0.2155581117,
0.4116395116,
0.6480544209,
0.8766255379,
-0.1561874002,
0.1593769789,
0.1600020826,
0.1978428364,
-0.0967494622,
0.0739628375,
-0.1346685737,
-1.0430634022,
-0.6395719051,
-0.7395656705,
-0.104996942,
0.1940697879,
-0.6723916531,
0.3687850535,
-0.7031628489,
-0.012870281,
0.4844542146,
-0.1789234579,
-0.5883340836,
0.292345345,
0.3981868625,
1.066554904,
-0.7578636408,
0.978879869,
0.5766639113,
-0.069497779,
-0.7698200345,
0.1397905052,
-0.0264174473,
-0.7575719953,
0.4325573146,
-0.1776559651,
-0.4072322547,
0.2595327795,
-0.7685475349,
-0.7981671691,
0.7352089286,
0.7813033462,
-0.5299960375,
0.1506360769,
-0.0220861267,
0.5666543841,
-0.2554805577,
-0.1470312923,
0.911152482,
0.2273416817,
-0.0168467201,
-0.9551393986,
-0.0279416554,
-0.2712611854,
0.1656149775,
0.3738842905,
-0.3985289931,
0.8703754544,
-0.0524663106,
-0.3142712116,
0.0402888991,
0.6620205641,
-0.1757419854,
0.1813215017,
0.7762102485,
0.4584161043,
0.7259579897,
-0.0573602319,
0.9098297954,
-0.4102667868,
0.6681268215,
1.1465785503,
0.1426691264,
0.8566845059,
0.6154259443,
0.2116484046,
0.1941891462,
0.5458551049,
0.2942472398,
0.8510731459,
0.3899235725,
0.0124681322,
-0.780364275,
-0.2380587608,
-0.0736507401,
0.3241636455,
0.4860889316,
-0.1403565407,
-0.374488771,
0.0301770791,
0.2971899509,
0.2478569597,
-0.3802723587,
0.858392179,
0.2234971821,
-0.4367438555,
1.1141201258,
0.2133443803,
0.3136231899,
-0.4003732502,
0.0529746525,
-0.2361761183,
0.389138341,
-0.2782479227,
-0.8167060018,
0.4358190596,
-0.0429032482,
-0.2304890901,
-0.3685920537,
0.7287887335,
-0.5894136429,
-0.549695015,
0.3334438503,
0.6494252682,
0.2084474266,
-0.0099124303,
-0.6999585032,
0.0874267444,
-0.2420985848,
-0.1955999732,
0.2294329852,
0.7598465085,
-0.0828197673,
0.5189785957,
0.5424964428,
0.0995342806,
0.1042720377,
0.3284521699,
0.9126157165,
-0.5703761578,
-0.4590459466,
-0.858776629,
0.6727371812,
0.1206957474,
-0.1378388405,
0.4712837636,
0.3447653651,
1.1247525215,
0.0515464619,
0.456574589,
0.0153597519,
0.4344053566,
-1.2425432205,
0.8578392267,
-0.6835251451,
0.4745594859,
-0.5241017342,
-0.9482607841,
-0.6076070666,
0.5760859847,
-0.3694816232,
-0.2121973634,
0.4832131565,
0.9464886785,
-0.6596746445,
-0.2045770288,
0.5386990309,
0.6737567186,
0.1284905076,
0.3166612089,
0.7605933547,
-0.362187475,
0.2259744853,
-0.7253593802,
-0.1784967482,
0.1420300752,
-1.0970858335,
-0.7914671898,
-0.7371997237,
-0.5899917483,
-0.38492167,
0.058157675,
0.841942966,
0.9335734248,
-1.0310535431,
-0.2903707027,
-0.219067663,
0.037379209,
-0.3253414333,
-0.1936237961,
0.4657402635,
-0.4651594758,
-0.6281566024,
0.306519866,
-0.0178432968,
-0.1030147895,
-0.2193339169,
0.0671159029,
0.0192359779,
0.117593579,
0.6641857624,
0.0133440662,
-1.0040668249,
-0.5373687744,
-0.2081638575,
0.0730052739,
-0.0828280672,
0.8013363481,
-0.6941741705,
0.4528473318,
0.6126903296,
0.773136735,
0.6153278947,
-0.2618971169,
0.815043807,
-0.5606946945,
0.2889064848,
0.1220329478,
0.0497931205,
0.3405021131,
-0.1921624243,
0.1766988337,
0.0319410115,
-0.3836557865,
-0.823469162,
0.2857191265,
-1.0629366636,
-0.4336139858,
0.8869982362,
0.0204527471,
-0.3069335222,
-0.2036463022,
-0.2092048377,
0.2152469009,
-0.2093750983,
0.5124077797,
0.5102677941,
-0.0038318511,
-0.5067858696,
-0.7259392142,
0.6663064361,
0.5214468241,
-0.5653794408,
0.4232144356,
0.4021618962,
0.504378736,
0.0292679258,
0.2390168309,
0.1461839378,
-0.1209883168,
-0.1582166702,
-0.294429183,
-0.0250191893,
-0.3708174825,
-0.2212867141,
0.1843400449,
0.3467851281,
0.1465419382
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11745v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11745v1 | Multi-Layer Ranking with Large Language Models for News Source Recommendation | 2024-06-17T17:02:34 | 2024-06-17T17:02:34 | Wenjia Zhang, Lin Gui, Rob Procter, Yulan He | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | To seek reliable information sources for news events, we introduce a novel
task of expert recommendation, which aims to identify trustworthy sources based
on their previously quoted statements. To achieve this, we built a novel
dataset, called NewsQuote, consisting of 23,571 quote-speaker pairs sourced
from a collection of news articles. We formulate the recommendation task as the
retrieval of experts based on their likelihood of being associated with a given
query. We also propose a multi-layer ranking framework employing Large Language
Models to improve the recommendation performance. Our results show that
employing an in-context learning based LLM ranker and a multi-layer
ranking-based filter significantly improve both the predictive quality and
behavioural quality of the recommender system. | [
-0.3029673398,
-0.5807110667,
0.7735335827,
-0.0381612852,
-0.3826580644,
0.2817368507,
-0.1308030933,
-0.7363225222,
0.2278998941,
0.5972335339,
-0.2917089164,
-0.5894265771,
-0.6577033997,
-0.3177343309,
-0.3370819092,
1.0476256609,
0.2742449641,
0.1993652433,
-0.2138813138,
-0.0602632314,
-0.2206124812,
-0.535353303,
-0.9608319998,
-0.2779433131,
0.6254876256,
0.5363079309,
0.930015564,
0.2855368853,
0.4907630384,
0.1944534779,
-0.1729798019,
0.2094213963,
-0.3534915149,
0.1737003177,
-0.4299795628,
-0.2025734335,
-0.1772274226,
0.2494483143,
0.6827564836,
0.4589149058,
-0.2483207434,
0.0115637071,
-0.0627122968,
0.6973513961,
-0.4009254277,
0.1167135909,
-0.7606114745,
0.0055726883,
-0.0759829655,
-0.2853449881,
-0.5024543405,
-0.5857720971,
0.3340466619,
-0.4054539502,
-0.0541547872,
0.1618731022,
0.3254245222,
-0.1697857976,
-0.6309892535,
-0.0714252368,
-0.5107796192,
0.8672611713,
-0.7017551661,
0.4737907052,
0.537581861,
0.4421360791,
-0.200408861,
-0.4740944803,
-0.1203709319,
-0.6296873093,
-0.0515525751,
-0.1044263989,
0.1445080191,
-0.2513900399,
0.0132995294,
-0.0519872159,
-0.3532035947,
-0.0299789794,
-0.2589965463,
-0.1399949193,
0.6911045313,
-0.3789481521,
0.1027359813,
-0.170963183,
-0.4187402427,
0.0913555771,
-0.4279114306,
-0.0633749813,
0.4732811749,
0.4238097966,
0.2498093098,
0.4339369833,
-0.4185508192,
0.608148694,
-0.0592277125,
-0.4571190774,
0.3051033914,
-0.302311182,
0.1862121075,
0.3537498713,
0.578558743,
0.520197928,
0.2469927669,
-0.379301697,
-0.0011187393,
-0.5446816683,
0.3203580976,
-0.5678233504,
-0.3280434012,
-0.0068534054,
-0.4447165132,
-0.4756256342,
0.4282699227,
-0.7714522481,
-0.6309210658,
-0.1817211956,
0.4389509261,
-0.2613809705,
-0.3925568163,
-0.0214417018,
-0.2402240187,
-0.0117670335,
0.4667590857,
-0.3898316026,
0.0027784966,
0.3337040544,
0.7104147077,
-0.1563378721,
-0.35948506,
-0.7702379227,
0.4433685839,
-0.2427914739,
1.0097612143,
-0.820261538,
-0.1706918627,
0.0563026108,
-0.1524636149,
0.1774133593,
-0.3429034352,
0.9585154653,
-0.6210128069,
0.3229524791,
-0.3720646501,
-0.4622507691,
-0.248310864,
0.0154469628,
-0.6572739482,
1.1489309072,
0.0605391748,
-0.6547855139,
0.4155148268,
-0.4810074568,
-0.6983003616,
0.079457432,
0.0565835088,
-0.1442410499,
-0.0808022916,
0.5765839815,
0.6460425854,
-0.3173502386,
0.4000678062,
-0.4604023397,
-0.1434677839,
0.0249565691,
-0.2546034455,
0.4511656463,
0.1627884209,
-0.1723410934,
0.0614038222,
-0.803188026,
-0.0660986081,
-0.2240760177,
-0.5782274604,
-0.6182469726,
0.242571488,
0.2122321874,
0.3982561529,
0.2203679383,
-0.6023386717,
0.2318059802,
-0.0923218876,
0.685924232,
0.741371274,
0.3225679994,
0.4977456629,
-0.3834110796,
0.1766702533,
0.2073035836,
0.1099719182,
-0.0749869943,
-0.4854049683,
-0.4671071768,
-0.0205076057,
0.1117404476,
0.4637919664,
-0.8460449576,
0.4359197021,
-0.0073145512,
-0.4892237484,
-0.3505932987,
0.3202338815,
0.2877158523,
0.4580072463,
0.5286436081,
-0.0242581479,
-0.5494586825,
-0.9713514447,
-0.6067331433,
-0.213395521,
0.2153581828,
0.2614808083,
0.1465273947,
0.048701942,
0.7997245789,
-0.3649223149,
-0.2820268273,
-0.1836865246,
0.0251598135,
0.3282603323,
0.3393647373,
0.5998208523,
-0.7842903137,
-0.3132264316,
0.0055584069,
-0.4718430638,
0.1446904838,
0.0681813583,
-0.3334098458,
0.0727542341,
0.5639839172,
-0.3856166005,
-0.0927334428,
0.4121389985,
-0.4331661463,
0.2759062648,
-0.0277590379,
0.2990540266,
-1.5067330599,
-0.2208188623,
0.4179418087,
-0.5189473033,
-0.3332251012,
-0.0745817274,
-0.0536188968,
-0.0097200666,
-0.5598008633,
0.655015409,
-0.1820724159,
0.0119220894,
-0.2138181776,
0.3455080688,
0.1182652414,
0.4127135873,
-0.043620877,
0.5007453561,
0.5561147332,
-0.4725924134,
0.3875690103,
0.0715883151,
-0.8656874895,
0.7337311506,
-0.437438786,
0.1902636737,
0.0880699158,
0.4913124442,
-0.9496582747,
0.027905982,
-0.2531715631,
-0.1803658158,
-0.0842306986,
-0.3052146733,
-0.5483270288,
-0.1730674356,
-0.3574296534,
0.2703509331,
0.055153776,
-0.5690755844,
0.3808737695,
0.5789868236,
-0.4780987203,
-0.8582959175,
-0.5826485753,
0.3433592916,
0.1630348861,
-0.466099292,
0.3796080053,
-0.1908441186,
-0.1651566625,
0.2178799659,
-0.1342690885,
-0.236140132,
0.0555566922,
0.079851754,
0.1768115163,
-0.1444402784,
0.0115018319,
0.1450842172,
0.1201266348,
-0.0302613247,
-0.3811839819,
0.2541769147,
-0.0044847927,
-0.413364321,
-0.4266271889,
0.582182169,
0.9054267406,
-0.3581510484,
1.0162502527,
0.8046163917,
-0.2867384255,
-0.1382103562,
-0.9501888156,
-0.1470862925,
-0.3976818323,
0.5417536497,
-0.1468859613,
-1.0098273754,
0.3624205887,
0.2248661518,
-0.0866022334,
0.5796855092,
0.426238656,
0.0620573685,
1.1650676727,
0.3695574403,
-0.8471216559,
0.7249290943,
-0.1163075641,
0.1162295192,
-0.428060025,
-0.3875196874,
-0.5979231596,
-0.2405063361,
-0.1988318413,
-0.0594108328,
0.3360913098,
0.091534324,
-0.1501300335,
0.1458040029,
-0.3392137289,
0.6864349842,
1.0500952005,
0.3267260492,
0.5325288773,
0.0282891095,
-0.4109662175,
0.4480968714,
-0.503423512,
-0.3497881591,
0.7657337785,
0.1731218249,
0.7952335477,
0.2846566737,
0.3295380175,
0.5585662127,
-0.0960196033,
-0.6365196705,
0.4688263535,
-0.0073845428,
-0.6639344096,
-0.3298071027,
-0.3825335205,
-0.5114961267,
0.1331108958,
-0.3612361252,
-0.5701446533,
0.3637250066,
-0.5324115157,
-0.1993087679,
0.4112481773,
-0.5877378583,
0.4004659057,
-0.2746019959,
-0.24283804,
-0.5540066957,
-0.3993184268,
0.3582767844,
-0.0531723425,
0.4025354683,
-0.2028738111,
0.2218695879,
0.8100904226,
0.0750892833,
0.4918390512,
-0.323469758,
0.1109328121,
0.1329364032,
-0.0714718327,
0.819355011,
0.4636538923,
-0.6814762354,
0.136756286,
-0.011983512,
-0.4006668627,
-0.3549655378,
1.0784555674,
-1.0198974609,
-0.6574564576,
-0.2657950222,
-0.5629911423,
-0.2628326416,
0.4018908739,
-0.0497403331,
0.6628866196,
-0.0420623571,
0.7754131556,
0.2453321666,
-0.0113527663,
0.4686859846,
0.6367777586,
0.0249925703,
-0.6880353689,
0.6448696256,
0.2416814268,
-0.1757126302,
0.6127759218,
0.063966006,
-0.3877929449,
-0.828121841,
-0.1987322122,
-0.0089065246,
-0.6923940182,
-0.2444754839,
-0.6253695488,
-0.3361750543,
-0.4999424517,
-0.0560678728,
-0.3697310984,
-0.5603294373,
-0.0676340684,
-0.4148605168,
0.3913806677,
0.7839578986,
0.3471655548,
0.0712256283,
-0.6166607738,
0.3255354762,
0.2570225,
0.6984821558,
-0.1472377479,
-0.4644071162,
-0.8465998769,
-0.2112504244,
-0.3914319575,
-0.7111582756,
0.1463036388,
0.1937462538,
1.2647241354,
0.3895915151,
0.3632076383,
0.2843230367,
-0.6266716719,
0.8746849895,
0.0637120083,
-0.7391011119,
0.6924113035,
-0.4828598201,
-0.0157891791,
0.7091673613,
0.3212376237,
-0.2205842584,
-0.6501981616,
-0.3836486042,
-0.8252306581,
0.8086690903,
0.0117010744,
0.0382418185,
-0.0115256291,
0.6484730244,
0.1215734482,
0.3460404575,
-0.7391312122,
-0.2750852704,
-0.2514856458,
0.1054028794,
-0.4807609022,
-0.6294541955,
-0.232907638,
-0.3741103411,
0.8295125365,
0.0382403471,
0.1036888584,
0.2054453641,
-0.1647473127,
-0.4102080762,
0.2998989522,
0.6274777055,
0.9514347315,
-0.3345323801,
0.1343644708,
0.0102254339,
-0.1907563359,
0.1483449191,
0.2928308547,
0.0090715112,
0.0072680973,
0.2368237972,
0.7680101395,
0.4107149541,
-0.3259987235,
0.4101994336,
0.0517283008,
-0.2562412024,
-0.3324316144,
0.1074424386,
0.1236648187,
0.6102626324,
1.0242413282,
0.2490007281,
0.2727841139,
-0.7008491158,
0.4555699527,
0.5788202286,
-0.4611198604,
-0.0041499194,
0.6375060081,
0.3992895782,
-0.2665285766,
0.3894992769,
0.3121893108,
-0.3632545769,
0.2856172621,
0.2073776871,
0.6885830164,
-0.3079836369,
0.4320509732,
0.2236878425,
0.3204462528,
-0.5307317376,
0.0278424453,
0.0961371958,
-0.8442951441,
-0.4705433846,
-0.5539060235,
-0.7176951766,
0.1791983247,
-0.6405161023,
0.4602036774,
-0.317671895,
-0.1436666697,
0.1917016357,
0.4458578229,
-0.4297567308,
0.1613179445,
0.1921905875,
1.0621958971,
-0.7589675188,
1.1952997446,
0.887444675,
-0.4456349909,
-0.5599726439,
0.1805611104,
-0.2481048852,
-0.4340291321,
0.1493292451,
0.012900291,
-0.0210594404,
0.080071114,
-0.2801805437,
-1.2212386131,
1.0619004965,
0.8228551149,
-0.2901354134,
0.1063395143,
-0.3887090087,
0.3014059365,
-0.528896153,
0.594417274,
0.0907442421,
0.6388235092,
0.1445180327,
-0.9095261693,
-0.1246938035,
-0.3258222342,
-0.0683986247,
0.0468645804,
-0.8819799423,
0.7852640152,
-0.1429414451,
0.4064779878,
-0.1778812408,
0.6441405416,
0.1894730628,
0.3682923615,
0.507406354,
0.2229670286,
0.7335478663,
0.2877573371,
1.1928321123,
-0.5218664408,
0.2227850407,
1.1113232374,
-0.1654067338,
1.1780167818,
0.2314430326,
-0.031627737,
1.0338600874,
0.6305661201,
-0.0288504735,
0.8730857372,
-0.3378554285,
0.0066096317,
-0.2671114802,
-0.2196121514,
-0.4805263877,
0.2697094381,
0.0428526811,
-0.6217930913,
-0.2512120605,
0.1228289604,
-0.1852849126,
-0.039007172,
-0.418271035,
0.7819993496,
-0.028046988,
-0.6675092578,
0.1161092445,
0.1300291419,
0.4727097452,
-0.4839272797,
-0.0004599065,
-0.1292302012,
0.0964839309,
-0.2863928974,
-0.8751885295,
-0.1572809517,
-0.4706040025,
-0.6020456553,
-0.1038262174,
0.8249809742,
-0.5652138591,
-0.7982320786,
0.4035188556,
0.6196171641,
0.0104853772,
-0.3911596537,
-0.7623102665,
-0.2806444764,
-0.2058019191,
-0.6866607666,
0.5754467845,
0.2496322095,
-0.0196986813,
0.7448456883,
0.7949477434,
0.0486222245,
-0.118980743,
0.325725913,
0.8343738317,
-0.7552888393,
-0.5799372196,
-0.7070713639,
0.1805475354,
-0.2212072164,
0.0416425839,
0.918558538,
0.6487243176,
0.8550602794,
0.2109345049,
1.0015347004,
0.4268707633,
0.6901242137,
-0.4847385585,
0.7327410579,
-0.3979871869,
0.4623787999,
-0.4909730256,
-1.1338152885,
-0.2523625195,
0.4530827701,
-0.2799297571,
0.3678506017,
0.6884202361,
0.688015759,
-0.027338801,
-0.0199716389,
0.3592106104,
0.2738052607,
0.2415831536,
0.3507071137,
0.7650379539,
-0.1312779933,
0.6146634817,
-0.2497872114,
0.0461023897,
-0.5184579492,
-1.0198421478,
-0.9413282871,
-0.6257126927,
-0.3561682403,
-0.218873933,
0.2267809212,
1.1431570053,
0.9584963918,
-0.9657909274,
-0.0704213232,
0.1301566511,
0.448703289,
-0.3328517675,
-0.2396077812,
0.468747586,
-0.3088027239,
-0.720818758,
0.8510152102,
0.1830880791,
-0.4974686801,
-0.4314713776,
0.0268842038,
-0.5334266424,
-0.0328962207,
0.6903130412,
-0.3055838346,
-0.7757093906,
-0.5399557948,
-0.4581766725,
-0.1904817522,
-0.1925962269,
0.7519679666,
-0.838331461,
0.1432499588,
0.3764076233,
0.4743306339,
0.3823418617,
0.0230382737,
0.577750206,
-0.8622570634,
0.0991885141,
-0.0483866856,
0.3942931592,
0.2828359008,
-0.6825100183,
0.3842749894,
0.1213729233,
-0.6496598125,
-0.7652187347,
-0.0080614658,
-1.0837866068,
-0.3941055536,
1.434399724,
-0.0752089843,
0.1771423221,
-0.3936215043,
-0.2807651758,
-0.0312953666,
-1.0147063732,
0.7164254785,
0.8862655163,
-0.0282812882,
-0.5654225945,
-0.7435277104,
0.3385408223,
0.1598041654,
-0.3423957229,
-0.234591037,
0.3629751503,
0.3191431463,
0.034785036,
0.3826848269,
0.0163586307,
0.0400092714,
-0.5095792413,
-0.0954099596,
-0.3417235017,
-0.4643501043,
0.0591297597,
0.5990059376,
0.3289702237,
0.0967482328
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11736v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11736v1 | Interactive Evolution: A Neural-Symbolic Self-Training Framework For Large Language Models | 2024-06-17T16:52:56 | 2024-06-17T16:52:56 | Fangzhi Xu, Qiushi Sun, Kanzhi Cheng, Jun Liu, Yu Qiao, Zhiyong Wu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | One of the primary driving forces contributing to the superior performance of
Large Language Models (LLMs) is the extensive availability of human-annotated
natural language data, which is used for alignment fine-tuning. This inspired
researchers to investigate self-training methods to mitigate the extensive
reliance on human annotations. However, the current success of self-training
has been primarily observed in natural language scenarios, rather than in the
increasingly important neural-symbolic scenarios. To this end, we propose an
environment-guided neural-symbolic self-training framework named ENVISIONS. It
aims to overcome two main challenges: (1) the scarcity of symbolic data, and
(2) the limited proficiency of LLMs in processing symbolic language. Extensive
evaluations conducted on three distinct domains demonstrate the effectiveness
of our approach. Additionally, we have conducted a comprehensive analysis to
uncover the factors contributing to ENVISIONS's success, thereby offering
valuable insights for future research in this area. Code will be available at
\url{https://github.com/xufangzhi/ENVISIONS}. | [
-0.2432887256,
-0.7095466852,
0.5827829242,
0.393907398,
-0.257773906,
0.154384017,
-0.4299070239,
-0.4191028178,
0.3691155016,
0.3561253846,
-0.8121209741,
-0.2899178267,
-0.5300469995,
0.4433603883,
-0.3154861629,
0.6132524014,
-0.1651527733,
0.0072675841,
-0.3573450148,
-0.0760541186,
-0.3241452873,
-0.292838037,
-0.8866916299,
-0.2733854055,
0.324342072,
0.129544735,
0.7367164493,
1.213837266,
0.1973014623,
0.3987526894,
-0.0200472511,
0.3128345609,
-0.3039530218,
0.6287941337,
0.2039518803,
-0.3022400439,
-0.0812941268,
-0.1948898286,
0.8388698697,
0.4623730183,
-0.2233322561,
0.1849619448,
0.2468482107,
0.3621999025,
-0.5151044726,
0.2750591934,
-0.696483314,
0.350133121,
-0.0667900443,
-0.2039495707,
-0.1454901546,
-0.0689585954,
0.3240441382,
-0.7769547105,
-0.2238012105,
0.192311421,
0.5843664408,
0.5745685101,
-0.2485970408,
-0.2557790577,
-0.4183271825,
0.6340744495,
-0.7515656352,
0.5990812182,
0.0662184283,
0.2877149284,
-0.4120627642,
-0.7037983537,
-0.6685529947,
-0.2193365395,
0.0873888582,
0.1971215904,
-0.0814130902,
0.2004159689,
0.2204710841,
-0.1253098398,
-0.4802646339,
0.4140450656,
-0.2408170253,
0.0086998586,
0.6205851436,
0.1947318763,
0.4554876387,
-0.0808087885,
-0.3548620045,
-0.0964149758,
-0.7852479219,
-0.0496078581,
0.4569949806,
0.4105003178,
-0.3230392933,
0.4231128693,
-0.2182441801,
0.7842870951,
0.096336551,
0.1990390122,
0.3425786793,
0.0422697626,
-0.3223819435,
0.3479863107,
0.82530725,
-0.0836924314,
0.4158052504,
-0.2866775095,
-0.1927113533,
-0.2009714842,
0.3945773542,
-0.8036753535,
-0.1692802757,
0.1812811941,
-0.2844742835,
-0.2841582894,
-0.2988572419,
-0.8355049491,
-0.5393066406,
-0.9395856857,
0.3590717912,
-0.5601318479,
-0.2083491981,
0.1888338178,
-0.0201423671,
0.1072580814,
0.5569735169,
-1.226342082,
0.182243973,
0.6578539014,
0.9199871421,
-0.1486070901,
-0.5261514783,
-0.269605726,
0.2466130555,
-0.2419479191,
0.6573883891,
-0.7554244399,
-0.071490787,
0.068891041,
-0.3660742044,
-0.1192651913,
-0.4219911397,
0.1468977034,
-0.2549958527,
0.0015475963,
-0.1448858082,
-0.4675032496,
-0.0560725667,
0.4030941427,
-0.4719532728,
1.0765688419,
-0.058536604,
-0.5413159728,
0.2531716824,
-0.8394447565,
-0.295752883,
0.1308486164,
-0.6618885994,
-0.2876679301,
0.1233685836,
0.2419747561,
0.3575012684,
-0.3184542954,
0.230491057,
-0.5561283827,
-0.1502592415,
0.0207108743,
-0.2324650586,
0.8482472301,
0.3525424898,
-0.5854908824,
0.2871828377,
-0.637835741,
0.1858272254,
0.4174351394,
-0.0993127301,
-0.3657361567,
0.1292470098,
-0.1973819286,
0.4178721607,
0.3219848275,
-0.4939953685,
0.4163387716,
-0.6576933861,
0.5127971768,
1.0167706013,
-0.0810414627,
0.5703498721,
0.0184991211,
0.7050725818,
0.0320459194,
0.3612825871,
-0.1547857225,
-0.3226336837,
-1.0593042374,
-0.1472434849,
0.1196775064,
0.3028221428,
-0.710685432,
0.5279006362,
-0.3154260814,
-0.4116466641,
-0.6918040514,
0.3815034032,
0.2381849736,
0.1313651353,
0.3170593381,
-0.2019331753,
-0.7712076902,
-1.2159160376,
-0.3338083923,
-0.039932359,
0.1737271398,
0.0821565837,
0.5520837903,
-0.3466769755,
1.1482231617,
-0.1572866738,
-0.1871529371,
-0.2022420615,
0.0944260135,
-0.1718058884,
0.5865947008,
0.5919254422,
-0.5273709893,
-0.2894808948,
-0.0021868008,
-0.9189608693,
-0.0597173348,
-0.4763836265,
-0.3251160979,
-0.1541502774,
0.5627640486,
-0.6351047754,
0.1616428047,
0.6687035561,
-0.0802573711,
0.2305938452,
-0.2945378721,
-0.2588749528,
-1.1307564974,
-0.2714656889,
0.1583163589,
0.0378199741,
-0.5528311133,
0.0361725427,
0.0375497565,
-0.0242913235,
-0.1946045458,
0.6184914112,
-0.7525267005,
0.0082231909,
-0.1590332091,
0.2352202684,
-0.450684607,
0.5222656131,
0.1444930136,
0.5257912278,
0.7989630103,
-0.4616295993,
0.3120112121,
0.4199375212,
-0.1450079083,
0.3964290321,
-0.492076695,
0.3881074786,
-0.2838537991,
0.0406678468,
-0.5943524837,
-0.2566167712,
0.3424080312,
-0.2847804725,
0.4748930335,
0.0118615953,
-0.6648555398,
-0.198945716,
-0.2215076983,
0.3300937712,
0.4595325887,
-0.9291185737,
0.9101875424,
0.3644062281,
-0.1430859715,
-0.3927819133,
-0.562163949,
0.4655183554,
-0.4072051644,
-0.5152378678,
0.1520012766,
-0.0999148116,
-0.1616987288,
-0.2126234919,
0.0126992892,
0.1788145155,
0.2674565017,
0.3631279767,
-0.0777673051,
-0.1576031595,
0.2644600868,
0.2543216348,
0.055300232,
0.4448094666,
-0.5165316463,
0.4940515459,
-0.1743356884,
-0.5669973493,
-0.3993522823,
0.0401158929,
0.3431153297,
-0.4070141912,
0.5510893464,
0.2134327292,
-0.6864957213,
-0.6501963735,
-0.3939804435,
-0.1573257148,
-0.6182023883,
0.5205050111,
-0.1590961814,
-0.8337422609,
0.296980679,
-0.3364016712,
0.2863586545,
0.3349568546,
0.4622379243,
-0.1768526882,
1.1394673586,
0.5418198705,
0.1569990218,
0.5767152309,
-0.1293075681,
0.1664857566,
-0.907438159,
-0.4338110387,
-0.3059077263,
-0.6205072403,
-0.5241273046,
-0.1043814346,
0.3088221252,
-0.0493872613,
-0.6426185966,
0.3459320664,
-0.6264507771,
0.301772505,
0.5569426417,
0.0843134969,
0.0140940836,
-0.015443786,
-0.1093168184,
-0.31153211,
-0.818877399,
-0.4986034036,
0.8589311242,
0.4767448604,
0.7803926468,
0.0241379291,
1.0072802305,
-0.0197059624,
0.3219860792,
-0.5098598003,
0.6500129104,
0.2792217731,
-0.3998712003,
-0.3983166218,
-0.287178576,
-1.0152647495,
0.236285612,
-0.3882981241,
-0.7940084934,
0.1297947019,
0.3828706145,
-0.3385545909,
0.1899240464,
-0.5218403935,
0.9984515905,
-0.9557628036,
-0.2061548829,
-0.2066640854,
-0.6905763149,
0.0811234266,
-0.4300189614,
0.0296989512,
0.0711747631,
-0.2052052766,
0.7395499349,
-0.0631688386,
1.1065654755,
-0.1723867357,
-0.0080001689,
0.2122399956,
0.2008288354,
0.6688275337,
0.0020243251,
0.0415470712,
0.0822977126,
-0.2903784215,
-0.0664372891,
-0.7612819076,
0.7092915773,
-0.6657110453,
-0.6280167699,
-0.497620523,
-0.4322049618,
-0.396459043,
0.1769455373,
0.0413345397,
0.1712416708,
-0.0308402497,
0.1957224905,
0.4438070953,
-0.2985442877,
0.4938662946,
0.2666779459,
-0.1851214021,
-0.4904551208,
0.6380186081,
0.0342083052,
0.1894896626,
-0.0039611734,
0.1952817589,
-0.3212750256,
-0.7786030769,
-0.6348487735,
0.2074422836,
-0.770003438,
-0.2059351504,
-0.6981664896,
-0.2984570265,
-0.3106196225,
-0.1332511902,
-0.4476706982,
-0.1194010228,
-0.4197097123,
-0.1313730478,
0.4369734824,
0.9380537271,
0.0938700736,
0.3567354679,
-0.410587728,
-0.1310840398,
0.1693046242,
0.3972167373,
0.1454831809,
-0.6145436168,
-0.3059174418,
0.3796626031,
-0.4508997798,
-0.7452444434,
0.6488419771,
0.4528899789,
0.7661036849,
0.4319371283,
-0.0954988748,
1.0199280977,
-0.6172811985,
0.5813060999,
0.1950437874,
-0.8347820044,
0.7463803291,
-0.3720749319,
0.2613106966,
0.5797778964,
0.287014842,
-0.549295783,
-0.5596583486,
-0.6318629384,
-0.6919794083,
0.627892077,
0.3470802009,
0.3578635752,
-0.1234624609,
0.620889008,
0.0368181914,
0.2069254369,
-0.7950763702,
-0.201549679,
-0.1679361165,
-0.5902433991,
0.1583694518,
0.0847238973,
0.0483349673,
-0.5573507547,
0.637973249,
-0.3896291256,
0.2584432065,
0.088719964,
-0.1271990538,
-0.1384829432,
-0.0399784558,
0.4370895028,
0.4055033326,
0.193942979,
0.0951970071,
0.5067289472,
-0.3028841019,
0.0119836861,
-0.0127812205,
-0.1682263613,
-0.2583526075,
0.2796854973,
0.9618558288,
0.4573732615,
-0.6850988865,
0.2414435893,
0.1252440959,
-0.0389167592,
-0.6870684028,
0.1781282425,
0.2342821509,
0.5367117524,
0.117615059,
0.0538355894,
0.0437421426,
-0.3424583077,
0.0805838183,
0.5143874884,
-0.3214664757,
-0.5158113837,
0.8343201876,
0.1584252864,
-0.490814954,
0.8806468248,
-0.2324197292,
-0.6102846265,
0.7269089818,
0.8678315878,
1.2316002846,
-0.1698614359,
-0.032162372,
0.3718221784,
0.4085312188,
-0.2283116579,
0.1486412436,
-0.037928436,
-0.6133385301,
-0.2424765676,
-0.8694338202,
-0.3136793673,
0.0812631398,
-0.2629729509,
0.4750515819,
-0.5424494743,
0.0266723353,
-0.0887251273,
-0.4705251753,
-0.7585950494,
0.1725583822,
0.4323402643,
0.8631275296,
-0.6319986582,
0.8798134327,
0.7423836589,
-0.2429144382,
-0.5841306448,
-0.0860168412,
0.1039756984,
-0.9354056716,
0.9238249063,
0.3340699077,
-0.1904895157,
0.2897156179,
-0.6601439714,
-1.1354875565,
1.1416009665,
0.81310606,
-0.5322608352,
-0.2454258651,
0.1897573173,
0.7704484463,
-0.6391577721,
-0.0025216662,
0.3908309937,
0.5333752036,
-0.2042589486,
-0.7702254057,
0.0481105819,
-0.3891744614,
0.0674001798,
0.2400759012,
-0.5360669494,
0.505100131,
-0.2076784223,
-0.3606568277,
0.0217595398,
0.7976663113,
0.0385420322,
-0.0474861674,
0.5507162809,
0.6348661184,
0.4036443532,
-0.0969521403,
0.8627166748,
-0.4440310001,
0.2743751109,
1.1538453102,
-0.155075267,
0.8991169333,
0.5024877191,
-0.0531080291,
0.419126004,
0.9196016192,
-0.1343885362,
0.4674648941,
0.4011140168,
-0.1074407026,
-0.5054396391,
0.0749226138,
-0.2041436881,
0.7170128822,
0.3857212663,
-0.4498238564,
-0.3099882603,
-0.1053119674,
-0.2949742973,
0.0824910104,
0.0442010798,
0.7201583385,
0.1503601074,
-0.6376311779,
0.3514571786,
-0.2332052439,
0.76855129,
-0.8210228682,
-0.1782855839,
0.0018375296,
-0.0306905657,
-0.0848946646,
-0.6870942712,
0.1918663532,
-0.2118413448,
0.5494511127,
-0.6067633629,
0.4832581878,
-0.4855113029,
-0.245296821,
0.4141687453,
0.5246861577,
-0.038195543,
-0.0143452827,
-0.8413664103,
-0.168416515,
-0.1562418342,
-0.4296723604,
0.4575389922,
0.5501553416,
0.0516362078,
0.8517203927,
0.4913416207,
-0.0294827558,
0.1414848864,
-0.0691367686,
0.7644382715,
-0.6580630541,
-0.6098479629,
-1.1471606493,
0.2374805808,
-0.3343502283,
-0.6325876117,
0.7396358848,
0.6387142539,
0.8256812096,
-0.0537116751,
0.7093025446,
0.0899192691,
-0.1525050104,
-0.5047774911,
0.8160935044,
-0.5882412791,
0.0950650051,
-0.1118511036,
-1.0188289881,
-0.2849727273,
0.7984007597,
-0.158699289,
0.2348777205,
0.5235106945,
0.5384203792,
-0.0999173522,
0.1946487725,
0.0970471948,
0.1368777156,
0.188513577,
0.4182080925,
1.047228694,
0.0407789387,
0.2717911899,
-0.3006581664,
-0.1119454727,
0.0823437795,
-1.0068025589,
-0.9607710838,
-0.7072386146,
-0.3518324494,
0.0552794784,
0.2629280686,
1.5524646044,
0.7318743467,
-0.525360465,
-0.1918696016,
-0.3830886781,
-0.5144869685,
-0.0792149454,
-0.0652971417,
0.2456026226,
-0.6111895442,
-0.7147449255,
0.4262420535,
0.4977765977,
0.3861376941,
-0.5315297246,
-0.3218197525,
-0.0336810313,
0.0593827739,
0.4434654415,
0.3878630996,
-0.8400433064,
-0.55127424,
0.0616102591,
-0.0915905759,
0.1746463627,
0.5069818497,
-0.8542754054,
0.7870056629,
0.056982439,
1.0420767069,
0.2524167597,
-0.1938601285,
0.7525599599,
-0.8475258946,
0.0769444555,
0.2879941463,
0.5790359974,
0.3426500261,
-0.3965087533,
0.5540394783,
0.0277271513,
-0.3939038813,
-0.7932828069,
0.1675055027,
-0.8618434668,
-0.0108285919,
1.3395484686,
0.1979753375,
-0.2457199693,
0.0050915424,
-0.2025386542,
0.2575118542,
-0.2096954584,
1.1179512739,
0.5605777502,
-0.3162755966,
-0.0811492503,
-0.6856927872,
0.6083267927,
0.4833876491,
-1.1237169504,
0.1565451473,
0.4830305576,
0.1071720198,
0.104844518,
0.1461816877,
0.2467074543,
0.0825832039,
-0.1323111951,
0.2873670757,
-0.285264194,
-0.3047671914,
-0.6238493323,
-0.1518435776,
0.2588138282,
-0.1976348907
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11727v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11727v2 | 1000 African Voices: Advancing inclusive multi-speaker multi-accent speech synthesis | 2024-06-17T16:46:10 | 2024-06-27T08:52:54 | Sewade Ogun, Abraham T. Owodunni, Tobi Olatunji, Eniola Alese, Babatunde Oladimeji, Tejumade Afonja, Kayode Olaleye, Naome A. Etori, Tosin Adewumi | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL | Recent advances in speech synthesis have enabled many useful applications
like audio directions in Google Maps, screen readers, and automated content
generation on platforms like TikTok. However, these systems are mostly
dominated by voices sourced from data-rich geographies with personas
representative of their source data. Although 3000 of the world's languages are
domiciled in Africa, African voices and personas are under-represented in these
systems. As speech synthesis becomes increasingly democratized, it is desirable
to increase the representation of African English accents. We present Afro-TTS,
the first pan-African accented English speech synthesis system able to generate
speech in 86 African accents, with 1000 personas representing the rich
phonological diversity across the continent for downstream application in
Education, Public Health, and Automated Content Creation. Speaker interpolation
retains naturalness and accentedness, enabling the creation of new voices. | [
-1.0412346125,
-0.3221873343,
0.3177231848,
0.5631875992,
-0.1040797159,
0.5302410126,
-0.2248375714,
-0.4846705198,
0.8754921556,
0.2850693166,
-0.6740638614,
-0.3298178017,
-0.3906323314,
0.5081533194,
-0.3906896114,
0.5513996482,
0.7967854142,
0.0056531839,
0.4460238218,
-0.3105822206,
-0.1866005063,
-0.7930352092,
-0.6712309122,
0.1405522823,
0.5440974832,
0.7790591121,
0.5837191939,
-0.0121434256,
-0.458311975,
0.3294526041,
0.1412923932,
0.5429705977,
-0.1168233752,
0.2747181952,
0.166871205,
0.051210802,
-0.7114578485,
-0.2266235501,
0.2888608277,
0.7738186717,
0.173691377,
-0.0744159967,
0.2896790206,
0.2821516693,
-0.2697742879,
-0.0966428518,
-0.6013436317,
-0.36389184,
-0.2037889659,
-0.2201903164,
-0.2401246876,
-0.4819211662,
0.1631608307,
-0.523938179,
0.2390225828,
-0.1739753634,
0.2306512296,
-0.151676774,
-0.4238861203,
-0.2947708964,
-0.6775996685,
0.4805780649,
-0.7717582583,
0.537843883,
0.1441864073,
0.3405725956,
-0.2700678408,
-0.8646551371,
-0.8605203629,
-0.0939220637,
0.4131800532,
-0.098710604,
0.0506757721,
0.0912892371,
-0.1747072935,
0.1146742478,
-0.2098072618,
0.0313902274,
-0.3646895885,
-0.3519386649,
0.9008809924,
-0.133811444,
0.3395358026,
-0.2526026666,
0.0545989685,
-0.0843956321,
-0.6931170821,
-0.0849644616,
0.7039683461,
0.9678040147,
0.0040834034,
0.4183474183,
-0.0813359469,
0.3198352158,
-0.0868110433,
-0.2505505085,
0.3743008971,
-0.0485561527,
0.2126340121,
0.4616402686,
0.7817878127,
0.1784356982,
0.5330913067,
-0.155348748,
-0.0018569595,
-0.1388507336,
0.298129797,
-0.634732008,
0.2206802368,
0.3231876791,
0.0241464004,
0.2090005875,
0.0252856277,
-1.2100099325,
-0.4970652163,
-0.1768841445,
0.4057906866,
-0.4993690848,
-0.3085367084,
-0.1379278898,
-0.0158295296,
-0.0955595076,
0.1643987745,
-1.1050319672,
0.3771172762,
0.4723205566,
0.7024124861,
0.1011311859,
-0.4342939556,
-0.1954291165,
0.1227419153,
-0.2493212968,
0.3812557161,
-0.3438957334,
-0.8282772899,
0.0713785291,
0.0617710948,
0.3958030939,
-0.4715772271,
0.4520705044,
-0.0017106533,
-0.1632604748,
-0.4582251012,
-0.1393038779,
-0.0769460872,
-0.3648821115,
-0.5454877019,
1.0130375624,
0.2312469929,
0.0383458585,
0.3352273405,
-0.4908289313,
-0.7387700081,
0.2587480843,
-0.117693454,
-0.1295454204,
0.2746248543,
0.6897539496,
0.1506497264,
-0.1312063187,
-0.0714161023,
-0.0894579813,
-0.2109469324,
0.1211409196,
-0.5111375451,
0.7876340747,
0.3654809296,
-0.7414508462,
-0.2036728561,
-0.989995122,
0.1541588008,
-0.0061007319,
0.0857744291,
-0.1024954095,
-0.226411894,
0.3457814753,
0.1190670356,
-0.090392597,
-0.7277246714,
0.0725784451,
-0.424957186,
0.5758547783,
0.4788295925,
0.2608300745,
0.141256541,
-0.0913280696,
0.5755288005,
-0.26248613,
-0.1214377955,
-0.4115686119,
-1.065104723,
-0.6686110497,
-0.3366499245,
0.2968125939,
0.3896018565,
-0.5875455141,
0.5436471105,
-0.2986216545,
-0.4316460788,
-0.9393331409,
-0.162372604,
-0.124173671,
0.2547736764,
0.34308213,
-0.3224864304,
-0.8506681323,
-0.931157589,
-0.1467110813,
-0.0764978752,
-0.50149858,
0.2695018351,
0.0696595088,
0.0069947396,
0.8189117312,
0.1481358409,
-0.2604217827,
-0.1922450215,
0.0523911603,
-0.1560695618,
0.3096129,
0.8317318559,
-0.5573235154,
-0.5190520883,
-0.0290821884,
-0.1302939206,
-0.4025522768,
0.0418511704,
0.1384080052,
0.1495124996,
0.3849526942,
-0.36616081,
0.4355219603,
0.7257379293,
-0.1186844409,
0.303201884,
0.0046813688,
0.5598899126,
-1.1662551165,
-0.0583680682,
-0.3516595066,
-0.2690547705,
-0.6435537338,
-0.2867228389,
-0.3673284054,
-0.6910178661,
-0.3581219912,
0.4260822237,
-0.5143457055,
-0.4062763155,
-0.0626493543,
0.3087095618,
0.1905058324,
0.5610403419,
-0.0905463248,
1.2549155951,
0.2247179449,
-0.5451230407,
0.2025619447,
0.4660168886,
-0.3448081613,
0.7587900758,
-0.6222465038,
0.4236541986,
0.1268840283,
0.1563424617,
-1.3641666174,
-0.1019386575,
-0.3286286592,
-0.8308529854,
0.0469151475,
0.1027381644,
-0.139347136,
-0.3659365177,
-0.0482962318,
0.2596845031,
0.3773579597,
-0.6476033926,
0.6297338605,
0.8283065557,
-1.0114344358,
-0.3020874262,
-0.7215796709,
0.7178908587,
0.0547625385,
-0.6128228903,
0.3004713655,
0.0514162034,
-0.0475577489,
-0.2397148758,
0.0838808492,
-0.0816126093,
-0.1249440834,
0.1988531947,
-0.3396440148,
-0.0492785983,
-0.1201010793,
0.2351085842,
0.1353286952,
-0.1327903867,
-0.4568599761,
0.7678393126,
0.1502933949,
-0.2601203322,
-0.3156275451,
0.9951758981,
0.9625669122,
-0.3016843498,
0.6168004274,
0.2068553716,
-0.3780291378,
-0.2794158459,
-0.5644227862,
-0.2785052657,
-0.5033428073,
0.4650684297,
-0.5025669336,
-0.7130788565,
0.7231445312,
-0.0710868835,
0.1708054394,
0.2576514184,
0.4952884912,
-0.0090810778,
1.0052138567,
0.277725935,
0.1585244089,
0.3421132565,
-0.0938707069,
0.3024675846,
-0.6629163623,
-0.2919772863,
-0.8203456402,
-0.4794609249,
-0.7801886797,
-0.0031887006,
0.8189197183,
-0.5453494191,
-0.1696870029,
0.3143993616,
-0.548918128,
0.1472348869,
0.9592036009,
0.1803919673,
-0.0227473956,
0.174315393,
-0.2559980154,
-0.3061975837,
-0.4788543284,
-0.4988597035,
1.0220930576,
-0.0747096092,
0.1934500188,
0.2191221714,
0.7149997354,
0.4656005502,
0.0675965995,
-0.4835626781,
0.6023231149,
-0.3354138732,
-0.5712468028,
-0.5061517954,
-0.1302009374,
-1.0137002468,
0.158426404,
-0.2537733912,
-0.6759802103,
0.466858685,
0.0140131908,
-0.4364866018,
0.2436672896,
-0.7393146157,
0.4502837062,
-0.1181399673,
-0.1525271088,
-0.1693794131,
-0.7259361744,
-0.0619219355,
0.0115213227,
0.3577385247,
0.0662661865,
0.1521295458,
0.4764117002,
-0.6110295653,
0.4743909538,
-0.3793970942,
0.0054350849,
0.4397093654,
0.0710892156,
0.2058663666,
0.0006572647,
-0.3311658204,
0.3916067779,
-0.2686490715,
-0.2275748998,
-0.2526312768,
0.7141578794,
-0.8858237267,
-0.4964468181,
0.0334232636,
-0.5090774894,
-0.8045514822,
0.1440599561,
0.4043534398,
0.7458389997,
-0.3423694372,
0.2057754397,
0.2293226123,
-0.4771093726,
0.5068850517,
0.1445746273,
-0.0074741468,
-1.1764427423,
0.6540700197,
0.276579231,
0.3758620322,
0.0283302553,
-0.2147034556,
-0.5060327649,
-0.5094057918,
-0.5043187737,
0.2177608609,
-0.5434146523,
0.0143133057,
-0.7078554034,
-0.074545756,
-0.952221632,
-0.3342941105,
-0.3838185668,
-0.9542785287,
0.0378262438,
-0.3308888674,
0.2736449838,
0.7921594977,
-0.3151910603,
0.6162440777,
-0.6244705915,
0.6473133564,
0.6614429951,
0.203700915,
0.0128225842,
-0.4044072628,
-0.213374123,
0.2071415484,
-0.2260589004,
-1.2140690088,
0.7257676125,
0.4605415463,
0.4881939888,
0.1437710524,
0.0316677131,
0.6966657043,
-0.8245227337,
1.0434936285,
0.0426600911,
-1.1312236786,
0.3200190067,
-0.0966437086,
0.4518505931,
0.6003350019,
0.2269539386,
-0.6897956729,
-0.7325813174,
-0.502828896,
-1.164629817,
0.4832448065,
0.2452999204,
0.2048647106,
-0.1405908167,
0.0540564582,
0.4974530339,
0.3252585232,
-0.30459705,
-0.5113458633,
-0.6431298256,
-0.2237800658,
-0.2642705441,
-0.260017097,
-0.1275160909,
-0.2635970712,
0.9697203636,
-0.173697874,
0.4335266352,
0.3197126091,
0.0744248331,
0.0282291826,
0.4812723696,
0.6416406631,
0.6305839419,
-0.0855141655,
0.0435227603,
-0.0628774986,
-0.6779705882,
0.4723853171,
0.4349143505,
-0.2410948873,
0.48165676,
0.0130827362,
0.8962975144,
0.1094077975,
-0.3163223565,
0.1020520106,
-0.0573892966,
-0.0643901825,
-0.4179564416,
-0.2909535468,
0.2416158468,
-0.0983576849,
0.8710846901,
-0.15339984,
0.0783224329,
-0.5383346677,
0.2779461145,
0.3666277528,
-0.095856674,
-0.3829208016,
1.0838720798,
0.8520208597,
-0.7410722971,
0.4434841275,
-0.0146318404,
-0.367310077,
0.5130044818,
0.3760416508,
1.2157412767,
-0.772860229,
0.1442565471,
0.3426272273,
0.4954476953,
0.5274317265,
0.6081587076,
0.1563706547,
-0.3997834921,
-0.2386086136,
-0.5139927864,
-0.7251725197,
0.1234367043,
-0.4779357016,
0.3150973022,
-0.3215856254,
-0.5477246046,
0.2290319353,
-0.2475051135,
-0.5200282335,
0.2945028841,
0.4157431126,
0.6616851091,
-0.8076121211,
0.6450204849,
0.4637636542,
-0.2150043547,
-0.6783858538,
-0.1568403542,
0.0829143301,
-0.5532380939,
-0.015682077,
0.1417575926,
-0.189394623,
0.2498104721,
-0.2194666117,
-0.4845966399,
0.624707222,
0.6991947889,
-0.6454834938,
0.1752718389,
0.8227126598,
0.4275695384,
-0.4737334847,
0.3721360266,
0.3920783103,
0.5031021833,
-0.022049062,
-1.2127143145,
-0.43334952,
-0.1272495836,
-0.0632896721,
0.0100392196,
-0.5178520083,
0.848454535,
-0.1073522344,
-0.1734502614,
0.1974887848,
0.5705654621,
0.2391673476,
0.1571997255,
0.5363795757,
0.2344133258,
0.7206261158,
-0.26897493,
0.7306549549,
-0.5303636789,
-0.3209260106,
0.9157944322,
-0.3869588673,
0.4026331306,
0.3799756169,
-0.4011079073,
0.5679832101,
0.3879966438,
0.7056760192,
0.4857642055,
-0.242830351,
-0.7068448067,
0.0999720022,
-0.1742684543,
-0.4596120119,
0.553319931,
0.6999168396,
0.0578040406,
0.1332817376,
0.2342531681,
-0.1892294139,
0.1249573678,
-0.3132868409,
0.6660603285,
0.074087441,
-0.5735541582,
0.4106957614,
-0.3449244499,
0.3754708469,
-1.0219398737,
-0.1371061951,
-0.421325475,
-0.1319750994,
-0.0879610181,
-0.6348204613,
0.0426179767,
-0.1715013087,
0.0260779131,
-0.2220330089,
0.2015524954,
-0.6798792481,
-0.2896265686,
0.2989756167,
0.4265912175,
0.032891117,
-0.1855228543,
-0.1145717651,
0.0907025263,
0.1262457371,
-0.0708919168,
0.0739893615,
0.7035964131,
-0.0884303749,
0.4343794286,
0.5660853386,
0.549626112,
0.4152615666,
0.2335181534,
0.4579518735,
-0.590695858,
-1.0570816994,
-0.3922749758,
0.6599237919,
0.0243396834,
-0.3343648016,
0.8970159292,
0.4525766075,
0.6120119691,
-0.0261968058,
1.2079594135,
-0.1639925838,
0.7150653005,
0.0179588255,
0.5074023604,
-0.3652908504,
-0.0226471964,
-0.479057312,
-1.254801631,
0.0331783891,
0.2200056911,
0.4576374888,
-0.0269383807,
0.3480437398,
0.7804877758,
0.1517260075,
0.2507691681,
0.4625674784,
0.0269818716,
0.4732476771,
0.1596271843,
0.4273198843,
-0.3424854279,
0.5138193965,
-0.2439306974,
-0.1995038241,
-0.0149834445,
-0.6152822375,
-0.1818825603,
-0.7352386713,
0.0792984739,
-0.4046578705,
0.049146425,
0.9986734986,
0.880236268,
-1.2195496559,
-0.383376658,
0.3469732106,
-0.1870294511,
-0.3901849091,
-0.2373163253,
0.0985039175,
0.1851895154,
-1.1797282696,
0.8829103708,
0.3948360682,
0.1169699132,
-0.5045337081,
-0.0102037108,
-0.1467836499,
0.3947797418,
0.5524739027,
0.6489804983,
-0.6362080574,
-0.364593029,
-0.0929641128,
0.1269555837,
0.2736359537,
0.8029116392,
-0.8170641065,
0.7841094732,
0.1337266713,
0.691226542,
0.4600192606,
-0.0638620108,
0.8394955993,
-1.2798541784,
0.7292544246,
0.4355573952,
0.4307560325,
0.6693294048,
-0.068821311,
0.3073119819,
0.0834143311,
-0.5986872911,
-0.6546415091,
0.1400754452,
-0.9622200131,
0.0604674853,
1.0518569946,
0.0777430907,
0.2168757319,
-0.3142212629,
-0.3392239809,
0.25418818,
-0.739315033,
0.6761593819,
0.5313575864,
-0.0817608833,
-0.1797297299,
-0.5784993172,
0.4552948177,
0.2312576175,
-0.855273962,
-0.1395661831,
0.6782659292,
-0.1464126706,
0.275451988,
0.6339133382,
-0.0539869815,
0.1499845088,
0.1813987792,
0.5279291272,
0.0157367736,
-0.4434577823,
-0.2585440278,
0.3196390569,
-0.0275216252,
-0.378988862
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11721v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11721v1 | Zero-Shot Generalization during Instruction Tuning: Insights from Similarity and Granularity | 2024-06-17T16:40:21 | 2024-06-17T16:40:21 | Bingxiang He, Ning Ding, Cheng Qian, Jia Deng, Ganqu Cui, Lifan Yuan, Huan-ang Gao, Huimin Chen, Zhiyuan Liu, Maosong Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Understanding alignment techniques begins with comprehending zero-shot
generalization brought by instruction tuning, but little of the mechanism has
been understood. Existing work has largely been confined to the task level,
without considering that tasks are artificially defined and, to LLMs, merely
consist of tokens and representations. This line of research has been limited
to examining transfer between tasks from a task-pair perspective, with few
studies focusing on understanding zero-shot generalization from the perspective
of the data itself. To bridge this gap, we first demonstrate through multiple
metrics that zero-shot generalization during instruction tuning happens very
early. Next, we investigate the facilitation of zero-shot generalization from
both data similarity and granularity perspectives, confirming that encountering
highly similar and fine-grained training data earlier during instruction
tuning, without the constraints of defined "tasks", enables better
generalization. Finally, we propose a more grounded training data arrangement
method, Test-centric Multi-turn Arrangement, and show its effectiveness in
promoting continual learning and further loss reduction. For the first time, we
show that zero-shot generalization during instruction tuning is a form of
similarity-based generalization between training and test data at the instance
level. We hope our analysis will advance the understanding of zero-shot
generalization during instruction tuning and contribute to the development of
more aligned LLMs. Our code is released at
https://github.com/HBX-hbx/dynamics_of_zero-shot_generalization. | [
-0.2222274691,
-1.0482873917,
0.6071138978,
-0.2881088555,
-0.0838148966,
-0.1276324838,
-0.190464139,
-0.2437072992,
-0.0565525293,
0.2689108253,
-0.7150447965,
-0.7019093037,
-0.3936781585,
-0.4429862201,
-0.524645865,
1.2160630226,
-0.0953761339,
-0.0601152219,
-0.4464695156,
-0.1310135126,
-0.688906014,
-0.2489368021,
-0.2737692595,
-0.6246697903,
0.4880464375,
0.6898450255,
0.3265780509,
1.1322555542,
0.5395314693,
0.2198668122,
0.1009353325,
-0.3232225776,
-0.5904419422,
0.1384350508,
0.0300946515,
-0.7622713447,
-0.550018847,
0.1026324853,
0.6700610518,
0.9260185361,
-0.1038189307,
0.3021962047,
0.1108463109,
0.555775106,
-0.7718868852,
-0.0379334018,
-0.6510820389,
0.3498699367,
-0.2731115222,
-0.3345915675,
-0.1575756222,
-0.1965922862,
-0.1077652201,
-0.6896677613,
0.7333166003,
-0.0767032504,
0.7546785474,
0.2664962709,
-0.3537412286,
-0.0570162274,
-0.9640675187,
0.8857750893,
-0.298512429,
0.1970161051,
0.1263721287,
0.2893284857,
0.0257782396,
-0.1267762333,
-0.44707793,
-0.0071237404,
0.1737550944,
0.1280298829,
0.1922123879,
0.2882815599,
0.4254871905,
0.5506099463,
-0.7223495841,
0.2837170064,
-0.2493363619,
-0.0593829975,
0.5116063952,
0.3075474203,
-0.0841984302,
0.4105456471,
-0.4674999714,
-0.0859708786,
-0.6875867248,
0.184319973,
0.2689023018,
0.223091796,
-0.1425970644,
0.3885314763,
-0.4470018148,
0.9836865664,
0.5669216514,
-0.0082466993,
0.2362021059,
-0.3393587768,
-0.3159928918,
0.1927008033,
0.4746745825,
0.5030868053,
0.3113369942,
-0.4925272763,
0.0331384651,
0.0530791692,
0.5653588176,
-0.7475281954,
0.1286985576,
0.0800273046,
-0.1675336361,
-0.4742615223,
0.1602819562,
-0.4786266088,
-0.017118156,
-0.7277532816,
0.5728216171,
-0.3957945406,
0.2593037188,
0.0818822011,
-0.0434010178,
0.9645829797,
0.1127709001,
-1.0801138878,
0.3816198707,
1.1726588011,
0.8038727045,
-0.2181704044,
-0.5884429812,
-0.5836927891,
0.462485224,
-0.505048871,
0.7965331078,
-0.5063655376,
-0.2505847514,
0.0478045866,
0.07349585,
-0.2529439628,
-0.5400000811,
0.0106310016,
-0.4000837207,
0.1603665203,
-0.1023637056,
-0.7787468433,
-0.0287674777,
0.4228506386,
-0.0093231387,
0.8415067196,
0.044894997,
-0.2804358006,
0.610707283,
-0.4385472536,
-0.4889084697,
-0.1482622474,
-0.4849701524,
-0.6350533366,
0.5690794587,
-0.1377462596,
0.4557469487,
0.1892989427,
-0.2187329829,
-0.518129766,
-0.9344403744,
0.0136523275,
-0.0556862541,
0.2577009201,
-0.1335156858,
-0.4857901335,
-0.0035663368,
-0.448409766,
0.2308790237,
-0.0902360529,
0.0536605753,
-0.2097154707,
-0.2800790668,
-0.5645956993,
-0.0726987273,
0.2743352354,
-0.4620342851,
0.6490556002,
-0.1616472006,
-0.0584133677,
0.5717859864,
0.0127018029,
0.7815563083,
-0.3864901066,
0.6032716632,
0.240046218,
0.2796051204,
-0.3721531034,
-0.229586795,
-0.7311806083,
0.3627783358,
0.2736704648,
0.7318179011,
-0.3466785252,
0.4015034437,
-0.330219388,
-0.263112247,
-0.499843061,
0.1231638193,
0.6272623539,
0.5990345478,
0.4166954458,
-0.4904052317,
-0.084896259,
-0.7888867855,
-0.1065555811,
0.2336506993,
-0.1483651251,
0.2151612341,
0.2140866816,
-0.0377763063,
0.7555280924,
-0.7399191856,
-0.2798374593,
0.1676760018,
0.4259418249,
0.0940033793,
0.6728276014,
0.4715869427,
-0.301911056,
-0.4900188148,
0.2815573215,
-0.6652783751,
-0.0914864615,
-0.3722057045,
-0.3555756509,
0.1288924068,
0.5992621779,
-0.2348398864,
0.4992250502,
0.2648944557,
-0.1113941669,
0.4916484654,
-0.1496725529,
0.3233806491,
-0.8596296906,
-0.1593725383,
-0.2760691047,
-0.1817325652,
-0.8392711282,
0.0465609729,
0.0577295832,
0.0072932127,
-0.189284578,
0.0890702456,
-0.3930820823,
-0.31468606,
-0.4762842655,
0.0724085495,
-0.0295448359,
0.5076949,
-0.1404230595,
0.895851016,
0.7952591181,
-0.5700880885,
0.2165188044,
0.1481919289,
0.0594431013,
1.0053377151,
-0.6812912226,
0.4041395485,
-0.2027290165,
-0.0901286379,
-0.5893463492,
-0.0929626971,
0.2770040333,
-0.3983775675,
0.7564573288,
-0.3763795495,
0.145118624,
-0.0027053875,
-0.4721862376,
0.4981229901,
0.5109314322,
-0.0833728984,
0.1072636619,
-0.0266615134,
0.0912956372,
-0.6392060518,
-0.7249495983,
-0.2888860404,
-0.2751323283,
-0.2769035399,
0.6486620903,
-0.1693443209,
0.0839420035,
-0.1002735049,
-0.5759987235,
-0.320320338,
0.0479837395,
0.4052195549,
0.2051911801,
-0.3716214895,
0.1253200471,
0.3066099882,
-0.1822706759,
-0.0481765382,
-0.3798221052,
0.4069604278,
-0.0122725684,
-0.5941867232,
-0.4981565177,
0.3465490043,
0.2293258011,
0.2122818083,
0.6339346766,
0.7185262442,
0.1698092818,
-0.0983802304,
-0.4673520327,
-0.2100761235,
-0.4395696223,
0.1715858728,
-0.1971371025,
-0.8555941582,
0.3073495924,
-0.0450251177,
0.0955680013,
0.1099684238,
0.342572391,
-0.4200576246,
0.6293126941,
0.6709375978,
-0.1527580619,
0.7596148252,
-0.5001814365,
-0.0535840541,
-0.8634291291,
-0.26561445,
-0.4515261054,
-0.7927424312,
-0.4793058336,
-0.437489748,
0.1295355111,
0.2500466704,
-0.2788032889,
0.2141265124,
-0.4524278343,
0.9031642675,
0.5481461883,
0.0617460422,
0.0623953678,
0.1507395059,
0.0708358139,
0.0771536455,
-0.5443120599,
-0.1880450696,
1.153429389,
-0.0739655942,
0.6354042292,
-0.3398891985,
1.1216139793,
0.1119666025,
-0.0777446404,
-1.118314743,
0.3951752782,
-0.1553507,
-0.2568889558,
-0.2690532506,
-0.4732621908,
-1.1420190334,
-0.0801406726,
-0.0611688457,
-0.6026213169,
0.0251558684,
0.2392473072,
-0.4798060358,
0.1354840696,
-0.6476388574,
0.8457099795,
-0.246470958,
-0.4025140107,
-0.1888555735,
-0.6631436348,
0.2358058542,
0.2299175113,
-0.0356105454,
-0.0110436659,
-0.1419100612,
0.433519721,
-0.1723318547,
0.6541011333,
-0.2160541117,
-0.10326536,
0.1002633125,
0.0793429464,
0.0763912052,
-0.3324443996,
0.2145366669,
0.1537358165,
0.0465930365,
-0.8111337423,
-0.8655110598,
0.8411111832,
-0.7801580429,
-0.4307363331,
-0.2548332512,
-0.8254991174,
-0.2633919716,
0.1769511402,
0.1338862479,
0.4602146447,
-0.0955599844,
0.1510432214,
1.0053364038,
0.3415748477,
0.3859253526,
0.4533693194,
0.003708167,
0.0313381031,
1.0463209152,
0.190539062,
0.4277374446,
0.5696524382,
-0.0183564704,
0.0861842856,
-0.7144427896,
-0.3616923988,
0.0401312374,
-0.2285347283,
-0.2973633409,
0.0729744434,
-0.0877891406,
-0.429888308,
-0.4365426004,
-0.2921108902,
-0.4168606997,
-0.3662475049,
0.0490324721,
0.1144731715,
0.6536723375,
0.0603785664,
0.6365594864,
-0.7788360715,
0.2244493365,
0.443670392,
0.567381382,
-0.1518405527,
-0.6718212962,
-0.531720221,
0.1397122145,
-0.7359317541,
-0.6495740414,
-0.1933369935,
0.4350901246,
0.3723118901,
0.6980105042,
-0.3530062735,
1.0679020882,
-0.6530460715,
0.6827862859,
0.0752876103,
-0.8838816285,
0.5640880466,
-0.3624309003,
0.4090892971,
0.7641891837,
0.3482794166,
-0.4705396891,
-0.0303013716,
-0.466579318,
-0.5916725993,
0.8856762648,
-0.000310346,
0.2867379785,
0.3020904362,
0.7665557861,
0.3262642324,
0.3260371983,
-0.2121710479,
-0.3640895188,
-0.0626939833,
-0.1659269482,
0.0031196831,
0.1003391892,
-0.3642094433,
-0.2926996946,
0.4113727808,
-0.3489294648,
0.5247350335,
-0.0881908461,
-0.1888864785,
-0.2135078013,
0.3625174761,
0.7246833444,
0.3346853256,
-0.1857295781,
-0.0582210682,
0.1975373179,
-0.4066725671,
0.3237800896,
-0.0855318457,
-0.4832878113,
-0.3190764487,
0.4783345461,
0.9656091928,
0.5080960989,
0.0905496776,
0.5089471936,
0.2184374481,
-0.3903516829,
0.1082026213,
0.6060554385,
-0.3026760817,
0.2520916164,
0.0465132892,
-0.144845292,
0.073793754,
-0.5988245606,
0.2050177455,
0.7240787745,
-0.4403261542,
-0.5842248797,
0.3328130543,
-0.0316470079,
-0.344760716,
0.6288936138,
-0.2556492686,
-0.1085325554,
0.6106549501,
0.4769436419,
0.9180158973,
-0.1573219895,
0.5216624737,
0.1332729012,
-0.0150414938,
0.2374264747,
0.201749742,
-0.5342525244,
-0.6074876189,
-0.4426153898,
-0.4373660982,
-0.4415262938,
-0.1072172746,
-1.1352963448,
0.1711018831,
-0.4558255672,
0.1173114404,
-0.2059099823,
0.0600404814,
-0.6751058698,
-0.1218482926,
0.3694937527,
0.4732041359,
-0.8570373654,
0.6941903234,
0.8519104123,
-0.1897424608,
-0.5452225804,
0.3362082243,
0.0401650853,
-1.0018433332,
0.127323404,
0.2862137854,
-0.0268243868,
-0.0636771694,
-0.6151653528,
-0.5932573676,
1.5435141325,
0.2236712128,
-0.7481303811,
-0.2283883095,
0.4761783779,
0.4365031719,
-0.4541559219,
0.232447803,
0.7493466735,
0.2869751155,
0.4906916618,
-0.5967905521,
-0.2253684253,
0.2574138939,
0.0283199064,
0.486990571,
-0.6697721481,
0.5791177154,
-0.0644091368,
-0.028526973,
-0.0995462984,
0.3537183404,
-0.0578835718,
0.7244843245,
0.1690382957,
0.833876431,
0.4874102473,
-0.1462812424,
0.8502986431,
-0.2522555292,
0.4312082827,
1.1871898174,
-0.2516583502,
0.5462239981,
0.5780914426,
-0.2692649066,
0.5072835684,
0.307023555,
-0.0290617645,
0.3442822099,
0.0953856409,
-0.1800897568,
-0.1620194465,
-0.1012204215,
-0.4127652347,
0.5151600838,
0.1210052595,
-0.0734806955,
-0.3817846477,
-0.2607153654,
-0.1259089857,
-0.1986790597,
-0.5613453984,
1.1228201389,
-0.2042288035,
-0.4664693475,
0.6944204569,
-0.4737156332,
0.5557110906,
-0.6326465607,
0.0066809966,
-0.336701721,
0.0775262341,
-0.2097395957,
-0.818959713,
0.4686302543,
-0.3381045163,
-0.4294395447,
-0.269651562,
0.4262343645,
-0.612339139,
-0.2684116662,
-0.0729259625,
0.4464840293,
0.2080655545,
-0.0333813876,
-0.6719350815,
-0.016835222,
-0.0291272607,
-0.046223335,
0.822357893,
0.4919362962,
0.0240825135,
0.1433642507,
0.26730299,
0.1101586446,
0.3404189944,
0.0115594575,
0.6681919098,
-0.7240101695,
0.0298895445,
-0.6758723855,
0.2865579426,
0.0623657443,
-0.3118452132,
0.5305919051,
0.5149840117,
1.0285615921,
-0.1621921808,
0.3755894601,
0.0947548226,
0.0969332382,
-0.5746736526,
0.3629385531,
-0.5441192985,
-0.0851768479,
0.0480487086,
-1.0462218523,
-0.3129502833,
0.3513021469,
-0.4601547122,
0.0171107464,
0.5958330631,
0.8442710042,
-0.3604604304,
-0.3251469135,
0.5051555037,
-0.0376637653,
0.0749028325,
0.5437903404,
0.4909044504,
-0.390304476,
0.5373492837,
-0.494176805,
-0.332379967,
-0.1978430003,
-0.6769143343,
-0.6424767971,
-0.2604027987,
-0.4765284657,
0.3071626127,
0.0718593746,
0.5119448304,
0.7260195613,
-0.9342595935,
-0.4352117479,
-0.3872168362,
0.1413601935,
-0.4452549815,
-0.2572769225,
0.0780334845,
-0.8243593574,
-0.6796180606,
0.3584706485,
0.3000515997,
0.2665186822,
0.0403272733,
0.0443683155,
0.0565706752,
-0.0105955712,
0.4331637323,
0.4060557783,
-0.3885437846,
-0.3373664021,
0.1520513147,
0.1899536848,
0.2394299954,
1.174957037,
-0.7766455412,
0.4447049201,
0.2394677252,
0.6383255124,
0.4021072984,
0.2690713704,
0.3478062153,
-1.0441572666,
0.0964963734,
-0.0257508066,
-0.1116321161,
0.0346241109,
-0.3673991561,
0.3513614237,
0.1771331578,
-0.8165791631,
-0.5693112612,
0.4205547273,
-0.9832163453,
0.149063766,
0.8081770539,
-0.0951253846,
-0.1735725254,
0.1718834192,
-0.0908586979,
0.4278255105,
-0.3062244654,
1.0615152121,
0.7024466395,
-0.6583529115,
0.0271413829,
-0.3321665227,
0.287308991,
0.6277261972,
-0.8325368762,
-0.0503513329,
0.5022141337,
0.2680526674,
0.0531170741,
0.1758879721,
0.1245063767,
0.3463799357,
-0.1584753245,
-0.0646941587,
-0.3178684413,
-0.3994672,
-0.7391644716,
0.0528478995,
-0.1206572056,
-0.7062363625
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11717v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11717v1 | Refusal in Language Models Is Mediated by a Single Direction | 2024-06-17T16:36:12 | 2024-06-17T16:36:12 | Andy Arditi, Oscar Obeso, Aaquib Syed, Daniel Paleka, Nina Rimsky, Wes Gurnee, Neel Nanda | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL | Conversational large language models are fine-tuned for both
instruction-following and safety, resulting in models that obey benign requests
but refuse harmful ones. While this refusal behavior is widespread across chat
models, its underlying mechanisms remain poorly understood. In this work, we
show that refusal is mediated by a one-dimensional subspace, across 13 popular
open-source chat models up to 72B parameters in size. Specifically, for each
model, we find a single direction such that erasing this direction from the
model's residual stream activations prevents it from refusing harmful
instructions, while adding this direction elicits refusal on even harmless
instructions. Leveraging this insight, we propose a novel white-box jailbreak
method that surgically disables refusal with minimal effect on other
capabilities. Finally, we mechanistically analyze how adversarial suffixes
suppress propagation of the refusal-mediating direction. Our findings
underscore the brittleness of current safety fine-tuning methods. More broadly,
our work showcases how an understanding of model internals can be leveraged to
develop practical methods for controlling model behavior. | [
-0.3779267669,
-1.1690444946,
0.4894081652,
0.141884461,
-0.1186886728,
-0.0133740455,
-0.2147176266,
0.0534490608,
0.1437625289,
0.8290019631,
-1.001034379,
-0.3279141188,
-0.3973026872,
-0.3558811843,
-0.4945092499,
1.1358908415,
0.2162833959,
-0.1149510965,
-0.1997112781,
-0.1225693524,
-0.6324046254,
-0.4147826433,
-0.6995950937,
-0.2116369754,
0.7346790433,
0.7486890554,
1.2464011908,
0.5207872391,
0.1935572475,
0.3490695357,
-0.2830159068,
-0.203618899,
-0.763277173,
0.1561797708,
-0.1273665875,
-0.5988886356,
-0.4635649323,
0.2724591494,
0.445869863,
0.8308961391,
-0.1293009669,
-0.048201438,
0.2562306225,
0.8972310424,
-0.5081176162,
-0.225789398,
-1.0001684427,
-0.1089559495,
-0.1337122023,
-0.1172939762,
-0.8360652924,
-0.105252184,
0.175590232,
-0.4892384708,
0.1577457637,
-0.2001581043,
0.7785314918,
-0.1219870523,
-0.121626623,
-0.3969447315,
-0.8287370205,
0.506675601,
-0.5383895636,
0.4788815677,
0.8409073353,
0.183135584,
-0.3488391042,
-0.4120144546,
-0.3931978941,
-0.5668897629,
-0.1019206569,
-0.3666455448,
-0.4521768987,
0.4168171287,
0.1734170169,
-0.2622317672,
-0.4018664956,
0.3777009249,
-1.0002359152,
-0.0116334623,
0.2633432448,
0.1340887696,
0.5710874796,
-0.0798734874,
-0.4672194421,
-0.0553838834,
-1.0263357162,
0.0922640711,
0.5743499398,
0.4907383621,
-0.2322710603,
0.449865371,
-0.2253636122,
0.3989271522,
-0.0833237022,
0.2874943316,
-0.1912545115,
0.0466064811,
-0.3355176449,
-0.105039686,
1.0108833313,
0.179432869,
0.059990298,
-0.1545338482,
0.0758196265,
-0.1618297845,
0.6298539639,
-0.6835212708,
-0.1041515395,
0.5611464381,
-0.7434405684,
-0.5240595341,
-0.1822724491,
-0.7630888224,
-0.5443797112,
-0.1640665084,
0.4746208489,
-0.790461421,
-0.2649060786,
0.0092706149,
-0.1455094367,
0.2367244959,
0.1346542835,
-1.0169178247,
0.5400032401,
0.7256486416,
0.9035926461,
0.3108735979,
-0.4484724402,
-0.3938979805,
-0.3452225029,
-0.6029133797,
0.2533898354,
-0.4891472757,
-0.5368468165,
-0.3516504467,
-0.137917161,
-0.0063458728,
-0.4615558386,
0.4944221079,
-0.7137249112,
-0.2706921697,
-0.2687583268,
0.0179625209,
-0.4922158122,
0.0726736486,
-0.4430441856,
-0.0120300865,
-0.2774410546,
-0.4868821204,
0.217698738,
-0.4157225192,
-0.3499325812,
-0.2132926136,
-0.0939489156,
-0.5102444291,
0.3852118254,
-0.0728894249,
0.3204420805,
0.0482526943,
0.2631058693,
-0.8925962448,
-0.135279417,
0.4576147795,
-1.1452685595,
1.0393747091,
0.4590566456,
0.0276741795,
0.3851475716,
-0.8513801694,
-0.2298344374,
0.3759853244,
0.0215666443,
-0.6489257216,
0.515149653,
-0.1632503122,
0.3751131892,
-0.2730056047,
-0.5330481529,
0.0778722912,
-0.4123420119,
0.7134849429,
0.9537312984,
-0.2677734792,
0.5153666139,
-0.1327881515,
0.6417393684,
-0.248621881,
0.4583949447,
-0.0013354524,
-0.1809925437,
-0.7976256013,
-0.2010995746,
-0.0500802547,
0.2980730534,
-0.583363235,
-0.1233893111,
0.0463122167,
-0.4718616605,
-0.7920595407,
0.1428193897,
0.5332201123,
0.1857132316,
0.1076292247,
-0.0071130595,
-0.3874220252,
-1.1041806936,
-0.0352742597,
-0.4031012654,
0.1952816695,
0.0498958416,
0.101518333,
0.1587607265,
0.6668848991,
-0.1143216044,
-0.192498222,
-0.3282468617,
0.0025771973,
0.1077354923,
0.5714763403,
0.8970860243,
-0.9409711957,
-0.175490275,
-0.1076066047,
-0.6716804504,
0.2198593318,
-0.1829460859,
-0.1021498963,
0.0861240029,
0.8883965015,
-0.4222523272,
0.8570608497,
0.687205255,
-0.4906753004,
0.5529005527,
-0.1709929407,
-0.0001793014,
-0.6244687438,
-0.2060294002,
-0.2702794969,
0.0650842264,
-0.9216691256,
0.4226887226,
0.0149977906,
-0.3115630746,
-0.8100486994,
0.3269668818,
-0.2050070167,
0.5828427076,
-0.4812202752,
-0.0104693128,
-0.28431952,
0.3461430371,
-0.094033733,
0.4640393257,
0.8287657499,
-0.937602222,
0.0417156629,
0.4799357057,
0.2235722393,
0.3048247695,
-0.8640885353,
0.1620520055,
-0.3969950676,
-0.049730204,
-1.4912019968,
-0.0567102395,
0.3303527534,
-0.5232354403,
0.1189293265,
-0.6178815365,
-0.0386561453,
-0.3383737206,
-0.2315639704,
0.147976622,
0.4437265396,
-0.538310647,
0.4984283447,
0.1252613217,
-0.2145888954,
-0.3039733768,
-0.8192406893,
0.0182963423,
-0.2247558385,
-0.3458223641,
-0.034993507,
-0.2737822533,
-0.3406508863,
-0.1882617921,
0.0054155556,
-0.1281687319,
0.4124771357,
0.688649416,
0.4725163281,
0.0270261895,
-0.2348605543,
0.1813119799,
-0.1252406389,
0.2778338492,
-0.0742988884,
0.5151480436,
0.1400145441,
-0.6611007452,
-0.5915269852,
0.3545663357,
1.0464084148,
-0.2123468667,
1.046199441,
0.0017861235,
-0.1352876276,
-0.1952050328,
-0.1788611114,
-0.425046891,
-0.5983896852,
0.2258249223,
-0.5447743535,
-0.8070477247,
0.5035277605,
0.3823580444,
0.2225514054,
-0.0287298951,
0.313352108,
0.2631212175,
1.0333439112,
0.429081589,
-0.2589072585,
0.2918846309,
0.0856129378,
0.4641872346,
-0.4074114561,
-0.0334338583,
-0.938947618,
-0.1858813465,
-0.7229715586,
0.1155344695,
0.3964459896,
0.1793872267,
0.0358213633,
0.3250114322,
-0.2723493278,
0.4594372809,
0.2273384631,
0.4178745747,
0.1902443469,
0.077734299,
-0.2572308779,
-0.1815089434,
-0.7005253434,
-0.3781546056,
0.7359975576,
0.7425276637,
0.8491415977,
0.2941041887,
0.3476774395,
-0.189432472,
0.2066195905,
-0.7846277356,
0.8822713494,
-0.1014412194,
-0.8189023137,
-0.2186852992,
-0.3787241578,
-0.9484087825,
0.5755221844,
-0.222749263,
-1.076879859,
-0.078275919,
0.2054784298,
-0.4373138845,
0.443664819,
-0.8907598257,
0.7126049399,
0.0895949453,
-0.4585627913,
-0.5015230179,
-0.2825503945,
0.4267080724,
0.2203182727,
0.4385743439,
-0.2475295663,
0.4592620134,
0.3880500197,
-0.6715696454,
1.1556715965,
-0.1151968688,
-0.1756642163,
0.4792763591,
1.1361531019,
0.495216012,
0.2090666294,
-0.3068554699,
0.0099762511,
-0.0508754663,
-0.3427973986,
-0.4371278882,
0.8147053719,
-0.439881444,
-0.9161376953,
0.0399688967,
-0.5000346303,
-0.1654813141,
0.4381526113,
0.3026646376,
0.4917028546,
-0.3010309339,
0.3278822899,
0.4982873201,
-0.5243223906,
0.5195567608,
0.7167754769,
-0.5392767191,
0.1697316915,
0.8556621075,
0.0952925682,
0.9151754379,
-0.0525828898,
0.2302920371,
0.0051512574,
-0.8656266928,
-0.3261779249,
-0.15543966,
-0.5196599364,
0.1873919517,
-0.4663998783,
-0.5281707048,
-0.1627399176,
-0.2516858578,
-0.7298902273,
-0.1550215632,
-0.1688710302,
-0.3064011037,
0.2176588625,
0.7229524851,
0.0537833869,
-0.0412497409,
-0.7169929743,
0.2372539788,
0.3372663558,
0.6530476213,
0.279871136,
-0.6495440602,
0.4186372161,
0.2064584345,
-0.3600490689,
-0.7030079365,
0.1900861561,
-0.2410023808,
0.2366189063,
0.6135097146,
0.3719781041,
0.603290379,
-0.7278405428,
0.4967403412,
0.1226949468,
-0.9383680224,
0.7162222266,
-0.6906560659,
0.0208481364,
0.4503792226,
0.48154369,
-0.4205530584,
-0.8662363291,
-0.5798725486,
-0.8252151608,
0.8195641637,
0.3399334848,
0.8376970887,
-0.0107322847,
0.195617184,
0.2912193537,
0.0030482418,
-0.7246665359,
-0.4564653635,
0.0970414504,
0.3405697942,
0.2624627054,
-0.2433273345,
-0.2043284923,
-0.1650178134,
0.51812464,
0.0694724172,
0.1356800348,
0.0219518859,
0.2365694344,
-0.1179734766,
0.6425461769,
0.6199212074,
0.7345873117,
-0.1699921042,
0.0228804778,
0.0318641551,
-0.3361726999,
0.1495124549,
-0.1134009659,
-0.5895141363,
-0.0833461061,
0.0421832316,
0.9397290349,
0.1276340038,
-0.4596264064,
0.3430550098,
-0.1048046872,
-0.4188680947,
0.0756362975,
0.1897473484,
-0.2633718848,
-0.0177894831,
0.1291764081,
0.2520250976,
0.1050165892,
-0.6255383492,
0.1611888409,
0.9226423502,
-0.8566929102,
-0.4281244576,
0.9063463807,
-0.0844439715,
-0.2484775037,
0.5350899696,
-0.3118648529,
-0.317437619,
0.3990972638,
0.4947839677,
0.8018724322,
0.0065728817,
0.7443497181,
0.1770018786,
0.4482301772,
0.0878209844,
-0.0507705845,
0.2987015843,
-0.7449288964,
-0.1785831153,
-0.3058617115,
-0.2619519234,
0.402512908,
-0.7616191506,
0.2074886262,
-0.9960169792,
0.1088506207,
0.1458696276,
-0.8083073497,
-0.4360359907,
-0.2382498384,
0.2842279971,
0.9122017026,
-0.6610341072,
0.683128953,
0.4220645726,
-0.3057828844,
-0.8979480863,
0.0383541062,
0.5978919268,
-0.5508918166,
0.2806549966,
-0.032662984,
-0.1071474627,
-0.272998035,
-0.9289965034,
-0.6144722104,
0.396667093,
0.3809286058,
-0.5193217993,
0.1013559252,
-0.1822597533,
0.3136370778,
0.2096585184,
0.0701971799,
0.5307188034,
0.0830446184,
0.1571132243,
-0.9831409454,
0.2539419532,
0.1129180938,
0.0269784778,
0.1664154381,
-1.0291019678,
0.5765466094,
-0.4370233715,
-0.142049998,
0.3950514197,
0.4952918291,
0.3530253768,
0.0445486195,
0.6258689165,
0.1432536095,
0.1804311872,
-0.0048767203,
0.9726988673,
0.0885158107,
0.217806235,
0.8310682178,
-0.0911928415,
0.8839241266,
0.5413689613,
-0.0872044936,
0.3560428619,
0.0427319482,
0.4053607583,
0.6251347065,
0.0835837647,
-0.029758947,
-0.0508108214,
-0.0504190698,
0.0473743342,
0.7738749981,
0.5945463181,
-0.1977352351,
-0.321964711,
0.412599355,
0.3594254553,
0.2409944385,
-0.4670946598,
0.5016429424,
0.1164913177,
-0.8250945807,
0.8472195268,
-0.0358868688,
0.2492489368,
-0.7824826241,
0.088585712,
-0.0059465431,
0.0837476701,
-0.0677355751,
-0.7192598581,
0.3710568547,
-0.1760535538,
-0.0228645597,
-0.2064774334,
0.8142691255,
-0.1349160075,
-0.1176612452,
0.6058292389,
0.267439872,
-0.2819458842,
0.1513577402,
-0.6769599915,
0.2875111699,
0.0101479189,
-0.3664824069,
0.5539674163,
0.3284824193,
0.0334995985,
0.9186916351,
0.6969843507,
0.0313281566,
-0.2288600206,
-0.017252503,
0.9702783227,
-0.3916151226,
-0.6150255799,
-1.1414179802,
0.516448319,
0.4882097542,
0.0168921985,
0.7530263662,
-0.0657537803,
0.9048685431,
0.1543724537,
0.8002429605,
-0.3580003679,
0.1747852117,
-0.7676126957,
0.9622465968,
-0.4570322037,
0.5099706054,
-0.4835306704,
-0.2076532841,
-0.0740341842,
0.2553084493,
-0.3271777928,
-0.1009217799,
0.4655049145,
0.8543093204,
-0.0962379873,
0.209603399,
0.4954813719,
0.4195239544,
0.3462993503,
0.3465666473,
0.8738234043,
-0.2061515599,
0.6496097445,
-0.2546986341,
-0.0647065341,
-0.1946434528,
-0.4484289885,
-1.1941654682,
-0.6200658083,
-0.1391088516,
-0.8827821612,
0.1513226628,
1.0284366608,
0.9735763669,
-0.6509400606,
0.01236552,
-0.243505165,
0.3565972149,
-0.2828663588,
-0.1897736937,
-0.0296913143,
-0.3675219715,
-0.4123528004,
0.5766324997,
0.3520619571,
0.1371976137,
-0.4058339894,
0.0899958313,
-0.1102000996,
0.2070317417,
0.5720889568,
0.6377398372,
-0.7898355722,
-0.4390618503,
-0.0663440675,
-0.2054757327,
-0.037157096,
0.7598523498,
-0.4449455738,
0.6432542801,
0.3765247166,
0.2948417366,
-0.1650008857,
-0.1907608956,
0.6004497409,
-0.8470762372,
0.6499237418,
-0.0761269554,
0.0636837929,
-0.1228068247,
-0.3548956811,
0.0200972501,
0.0660638958,
-0.3073491454,
-0.570414722,
0.3139739633,
-0.4426700473,
-0.704015851,
1.0570414066,
0.1202318966,
-0.2476768196,
-0.0438010916,
-0.475492835,
-0.223507151,
-0.3963795006,
0.6633369327,
0.8663840294,
0.1957561374,
-0.3627333641,
-1.0838690996,
0.4867414832,
0.63082546,
-0.1276196241,
0.3900643289,
0.3942638338,
0.3776482046,
0.0948185846,
0.7829556465,
-0.2163466811,
0.2800242901,
-0.1026569828,
-0.3074516058,
-0.1394997984,
-0.7094262838,
-0.6025898457,
0.328494221,
0.4638999104,
-0.2427780479
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11715v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11715v1 | Measuring memorization in RLHF for code completion | 2024-06-17T16:33:35 | 2024-06-17T16:33:35 | Aneesh Pappu, Billy Porter, Ilia Shumailov, Jamie Hayes | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.SE | Reinforcement learning with human feedback (RLHF) has become the dominant
method to align large models to user preferences. Unlike fine-tuning, for which
there are many studies regarding training data memorization, it is not clear
how memorization is affected by or introduced in the RLHF alignment process.
Understanding this relationship is important as real user data may be collected
and used to align large models; if user data is memorized during RLHF and later
regurgitated, this could raise privacy concerns. In this work, we analyze how
training data memorization can surface and propagate through each phase of
RLHF. We focus our study on code completion models, as code completion is one
of the most popular use cases for large language models. We find that RLHF
significantly decreases the chance that data used for reward modeling and
reinforcement learning is memorized, in comparison to aligning via directly
fine-tuning on this data, but that examples already memorized during the
fine-tuning stage of RLHF, will, in the majority of cases, remain memorized
after RLHF. | [
-0.3668406606,
-0.5820839405,
0.3243516088,
-0.0334145948,
-0.0950456783,
0.1123621166,
-0.4199343622,
-0.4625627995,
-0.2252242714,
0.6229289174,
-0.6472937465,
-0.5663406849,
-0.1189861,
-0.086527206,
-0.3019218743,
1.4033913612,
-0.3609051108,
-0.1196922511,
-0.4991173744,
-0.2934435308,
-0.5038023591,
-0.9080783725,
-0.2892929912,
-0.8493510485,
0.7354006171,
0.5230895877,
0.6822463274,
1.1310254335,
0.4191353917,
0.2134417444,
0.0537883416,
0.0268596895,
-0.7426505089,
0.1811202914,
-0.0804663152,
-0.6117394567,
-0.3109911382,
-0.0760400295,
0.7462261319,
0.6363472342,
-0.5793656111,
0.323659569,
0.0358795188,
1.1084920168,
-0.6590735316,
0.2643351257,
-0.163801387,
0.3857837915,
0.1526088268,
-0.3675189316,
-0.3928180039,
-0.4747997224,
0.2281798124,
-0.5659692883,
0.4199888408,
0.1584509909,
0.7175968885,
0.2385301143,
-0.233083114,
-0.3079628944,
-0.8680329919,
0.6780026555,
-0.5078420639,
0.5349217653,
0.6364811063,
0.1465026289,
-0.1282374114,
-0.3789127469,
-0.3781324923,
-0.4726284444,
-0.2394147068,
0.1504805684,
0.3841508329,
0.3625999689,
0.6818063259,
0.35859254,
-0.432880044,
-0.056807179,
-0.5060665607,
-0.3880293369,
0.6162831783,
0.4118424058,
0.0562868044,
-0.0052977982,
-0.5827251077,
-0.3428863585,
-0.7680236697,
0.3386816084,
0.3439651728,
0.114802219,
-0.0686361119,
0.3753174841,
-0.072174117,
0.6398020387,
-0.0368126072,
-0.298515439,
0.1958372593,
-0.3331389725,
-0.274027735,
0.0143020302,
0.6319795847,
0.3716238439,
0.5854758024,
-0.2388471365,
-0.4534311593,
-0.2354379743,
0.5516765714,
-0.7692602277,
-0.2755678594,
0.1416174471,
-0.5128837228,
0.0446941368,
0.2411143035,
-0.271440804,
-0.3688935339,
-0.4772348404,
0.274266839,
-0.3052203357,
-0.1615990847,
-0.0140509345,
-0.0806410313,
0.0609463453,
0.1418808848,
-0.9288503528,
0.3480367064,
1.0760680437,
0.5040457249,
-0.2184621692,
-0.8135874867,
-0.506922543,
0.0062112976,
-0.4974599779,
0.3576654494,
-0.2365338057,
-0.4668784142,
0.1736441404,
0.0045023644,
-0.4450193048,
-0.8972733617,
0.2561589479,
-0.7426518202,
0.0110710682,
-0.3401924968,
-0.8686732054,
-0.4076291621,
0.3410756886,
-0.5211945176,
0.8770871758,
0.1141127273,
-0.5868524313,
0.5944547653,
-0.117983371,
-0.2570890486,
-0.2948318422,
-0.1181699634,
-1.0139518976,
0.1589124352,
-0.2339709401,
0.400331825,
0.1754869521,
0.3199217618,
-0.384611398,
-0.7096285224,
0.6815442443,
-0.0668563917,
-0.1074193865,
0.2007716745,
-0.2048734128,
0.3248607516,
-0.5225113034,
-0.0136131393,
-0.2066969723,
-0.7033069134,
-0.1143565252,
0.0446414873,
0.0982087106,
0.1814884841,
0.1442021877,
-0.1870825589,
0.1656705439,
-0.0734709576,
0.3304152787,
0.6362912655,
0.3841335177,
0.486505717,
-0.7262819409,
0.792819798,
0.1949588805,
0.0146498848,
-0.2305625975,
-0.1063613817,
-0.5571559072,
0.030490702,
0.4943188429,
0.4207130671,
0.0011569749,
0.1904766113,
-0.1061750129,
-0.2175928354,
-0.3079786599,
0.374368459,
0.9894006848,
0.4424873292,
0.1387193501,
-0.5045153499,
-0.3934836686,
-0.9311137795,
-0.2838970721,
-0.2273276448,
0.1385108232,
0.5655340552,
0.4088863134,
-0.1248472854,
0.7463663816,
-0.3029728532,
-0.3206753135,
-0.1525162905,
0.226620093,
-0.1146313176,
0.5988668799,
0.0427656807,
-0.4924007058,
-0.2570337951,
0.043538034,
-0.465016067,
0.3594572842,
-0.3575706184,
0.0241578557,
0.4851650596,
0.6543823481,
-0.1613498628,
0.4659296274,
0.3191745877,
-0.4481019974,
0.3539072871,
-0.6748824716,
0.3642302454,
-0.4130785167,
0.1276769191,
-0.2670098543,
-0.526915133,
-0.4923853576,
0.1130637527,
0.3772107065,
0.0206810012,
-0.187009722,
0.2611091137,
-0.407794416,
-0.4349413812,
-0.1819404513,
0.0411269441,
-0.2690077722,
0.8791899681,
0.2226239294,
0.8918654919,
0.031349238,
-0.7214787006,
-0.1290357262,
0.1374458671,
-0.4999842644,
0.1884329915,
-0.5874596834,
0.1933027804,
-0.0948747024,
0.2273939848,
-0.9571248293,
-0.1919716001,
0.0120115047,
-0.422994256,
0.1740020514,
-0.2000744939,
-0.3846395016,
-0.168848902,
-0.1879586726,
0.6235723495,
0.5822295547,
-0.4664708376,
0.2399620563,
0.2915535867,
0.353526026,
-0.612324357,
-0.352501601,
-0.4262923598,
-0.4510286748,
-0.2883328199,
0.0981260911,
-0.0554157197,
0.1283764839,
-0.2547880113,
-0.2748227715,
-0.0215904228,
0.2915602624,
0.6528400779,
0.2449415922,
-0.0330500752,
0.2227518857,
-0.3836638331,
-0.0767574236,
0.2652978599,
0.0072067748,
0.535199523,
-0.1032164618,
-0.4380969405,
-0.5144743919,
0.0084827067,
0.5526240468,
-0.2198691219,
0.6811648011,
0.526060462,
-0.2228085995,
-0.4270953238,
-0.4811440706,
-0.3264449239,
-0.3602422476,
0.3726707399,
-0.1889439374,
-0.8201501966,
0.9387856722,
0.1934650391,
0.0724312663,
-0.0205754638,
0.3825202584,
-0.2844176888,
1.0364279747,
0.6719024777,
-0.0506260954,
0.7029385567,
-0.2193749547,
-0.1123508289,
-0.8413691521,
-0.3440000713,
-0.3014992774,
-0.5917921066,
-0.538082242,
-0.123521015,
0.0893259346,
0.5358585119,
-0.3309569061,
0.2981328964,
-0.2494057715,
0.564666748,
0.6373224854,
0.3807991743,
0.4439311922,
-0.0541694053,
0.1063019633,
-0.0656734332,
-0.5875581503,
-0.1388541758,
1.1239577532,
0.6124671102,
0.7873577476,
-0.2080486119,
1.0569944382,
0.2217848003,
0.2232723832,
-0.6713069081,
0.3100446761,
0.1627861559,
-0.4050169587,
-0.356552124,
-0.4979951084,
-0.8270745277,
0.0386885405,
0.003389254,
-0.4867962599,
0.1075924486,
0.7845364809,
-0.4845844507,
-0.0088137835,
-0.6551481485,
1.0368088484,
0.1278006583,
-0.3065258563,
-0.5866624117,
-0.604060173,
0.4582092464,
0.0948265195,
0.2010384649,
-0.0135984616,
0.0506746136,
1.0942364931,
-0.4350117445,
0.8093608022,
-0.2899335623,
-0.1605635136,
0.1854366958,
0.0610565543,
0.584792316,
0.1181749403,
0.2993318439,
-0.2536997199,
0.1713024974,
-0.2106813788,
-0.4956883788,
0.544311285,
-0.7953427434,
-0.3180024326,
-0.3206958175,
-0.6637778878,
-0.2475935966,
-0.1379168183,
0.0741483048,
0.3345523477,
-0.0898759291,
0.0794848055,
1.0280425549,
-0.1154739261,
0.2793905735,
0.4663489461,
-0.5130345821,
-0.3923573196,
1.029740572,
0.1053715274,
0.5352426171,
0.2476497293,
0.071373269,
-0.3039371073,
-0.4983821809,
-0.3404483199,
0.3676622808,
-0.7204027176,
-0.1015462503,
-0.447232753,
-0.2673499584,
0.0322325826,
-0.0071763606,
-0.2903911471,
-0.3348067105,
-0.2138841748,
-0.2093871832,
0.3724919558,
0.7398092747,
0.0397267491,
0.185474053,
-0.7775495648,
0.3328309953,
0.2382831872,
0.7067294717,
0.2117281258,
-0.6675503254,
-0.6442263126,
-0.1210044324,
-0.006968935,
-0.5444470048,
0.1274704039,
0.0885675475,
0.3169532418,
0.2419128418,
-0.1504154652,
0.9026511312,
-0.194409579,
0.4787151217,
0.0572401173,
-0.7639219761,
0.2070862651,
-0.3999308944,
0.3868201971,
0.8258693218,
-0.1026125327,
-0.8712937832,
-0.353598237,
-0.5085895061,
-0.6361952424,
0.9437136054,
-0.418715477,
-0.0924641564,
0.1647763848,
0.4921742082,
-0.084015213,
0.273630321,
-0.5528467298,
-0.3264894187,
-0.0208296292,
0.011500041,
-0.1262613535,
-0.3518679142,
-0.2219102383,
-0.2073899508,
0.5047261119,
0.1032941341,
0.0800398514,
0.073936455,
-0.2657143772,
-0.4064041078,
0.156000331,
0.9481495023,
0.8023135662,
-0.3904536963,
-0.2208258957,
-0.0522012711,
-0.5900812149,
0.0641215444,
-0.2894175947,
-0.2078186572,
-0.3446426988,
0.4807537496,
0.857008338,
0.5850412846,
-0.8048409224,
0.463619113,
-0.0375575721,
-0.5234106779,
-0.473148644,
0.5410379171,
0.1922406256,
0.2273830771,
0.1262365878,
0.0375546627,
-0.1368516386,
-0.5331313014,
0.5312871933,
0.1983603835,
-0.7161005139,
-0.0790916607,
0.5890314579,
-0.2467364222,
-0.3782328665,
0.9545350671,
0.0794876516,
-0.6146832705,
0.866892159,
0.4304584265,
0.731605649,
-0.0970291942,
0.1592638493,
0.7181273103,
-0.0721585602,
-0.4375502765,
0.2762846947,
-0.494554311,
-0.4277596772,
-0.2512048781,
-0.5134243965,
-0.3742605746,
-0.1208343431,
-1.1670665741,
-0.0855448395,
-0.6952598095,
-0.1136583686,
-0.3838743865,
0.0294471476,
-0.6386274695,
0.1973301917,
0.1536734402,
0.7251334786,
-0.6415632367,
0.9314970374,
0.3796902001,
-0.4280135036,
-1.1264219284,
0.0574178845,
-0.0697203204,
-0.9539481997,
0.5796346664,
0.1826623082,
0.0626039803,
-0.0572961308,
-0.1641220748,
-0.6851294637,
1.1908221245,
-0.0743802711,
-0.6286554933,
-0.0043650046,
0.0903223753,
0.6335352063,
-0.2105730027,
0.0576852784,
0.9236501455,
0.406892091,
-0.1132218689,
-1.0241550207,
-0.0860528201,
0.113956973,
0.117166169,
0.4600405097,
-0.5167863965,
0.6853808761,
-0.503318727,
-0.4332042634,
-0.0507446602,
0.6261482835,
0.4065921009,
0.2883163095,
0.561452806,
0.6284862757,
0.6562758088,
-0.0100020496,
0.840474546,
-0.227470547,
0.5610915422,
1.1893706322,
0.009982504,
1.0501886606,
0.4550993741,
-0.2726347148,
0.328248471,
0.6074733138,
0.0410324484,
0.4276916981,
0.6463959813,
0.0738788471,
-0.2608010471,
0.0657536164,
-0.485191226,
0.083105363,
0.2069327682,
-0.3858130574,
-0.0443883166,
0.2125122994,
-0.0687507764,
0.4104755223,
-0.3394725025,
1.1960484982,
0.0183274467,
-1.2598809004,
0.9244028926,
-0.1899137795,
0.4061128199,
-0.6020240188,
0.0430033654,
-0.6196252704,
0.5957468748,
-0.4571680129,
-0.7687574625,
0.3198597133,
-0.2579506636,
-0.4897479713,
-0.3176275492,
0.0288919695,
-0.9547727108,
0.001869913,
0.389113605,
0.1135327369,
-0.0044503836,
0.1570292413,
-0.528013289,
0.12298958,
0.2099981606,
-0.3834924698,
0.6874527335,
-0.0029656,
0.019330591,
0.7791031599,
0.4056396186,
-0.0433338657,
0.246139437,
0.2745142579,
0.400302738,
-0.8856683969,
-0.5572628975,
-0.7104049325,
0.3000146747,
0.269480437,
-0.4480678141,
0.674990654,
0.6240958571,
1.0312293768,
-0.2052871734,
0.4783381224,
0.3840402961,
0.6790672541,
-0.6770296693,
0.6234865189,
-0.3554247916,
0.299518615,
0.0094536198,
-0.6874647141,
-0.1781267524,
0.4167316258,
-0.1516307294,
0.0107902642,
0.5706813335,
0.9488779902,
-0.104991518,
-0.0503280573,
0.3372324705,
-0.1792228222,
0.1862127781,
0.8081319332,
0.8664723635,
-0.3405733705,
0.5479640365,
-0.546387732,
-0.0831251219,
-0.2694687545,
-0.5940100551,
-1.0248713493,
-0.6475819945,
-0.3819252849,
-0.4542417824,
0.0251418334,
0.8742720485,
0.6393892169,
-1.0090810061,
-0.5599101186,
-0.2627943158,
0.3251602352,
-0.5715833902,
-0.187665984,
0.3940467536,
-0.5812252164,
-0.3432231247,
0.0170912594,
0.0311006363,
0.0287683699,
-0.3500878811,
-0.4328390658,
0.1380660534,
-0.2938885689,
0.0698757768,
0.7428805828,
-0.7165821195,
-0.2404196858,
0.027472252,
-0.3379360735,
0.2169333547,
1.3025331497,
-0.9006453156,
0.4367985725,
0.4959884584,
0.6452256441,
0.6404898167,
0.3607192039,
0.68524158,
-0.7085660696,
-0.0809035152,
-0.0481650047,
0.2722636163,
0.0455762446,
-0.4092522264,
0.2490160316,
-0.0841472968,
-0.956715405,
-0.8326490521,
0.219162792,
-0.6796717644,
-0.0940258354,
0.8463428617,
-0.164940536,
-0.1370671242,
-0.0783634558,
0.0090273526,
0.0165662654,
-0.3979347944,
0.9258694053,
0.7919301391,
-0.1440898925,
-0.1921137571,
-0.6369207501,
1.0475314856,
0.6200734973,
-0.5048609972,
0.6962385774,
0.5570584536,
0.3642204106,
0.0024642728,
0.7875159979,
0.0134492572,
0.6198515892,
-0.4012271762,
-0.1791586131,
-0.2448125184,
-0.525683701,
-0.6713631153,
0.1263672113,
0.3923416734,
-0.2561393678
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11709v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11709v2 | Instruct, Not Assist: LLM-based Multi-Turn Planning and Hierarchical Questioning for Socratic Code Debugging | 2024-06-17T16:28:21 | 2024-06-25T21:17:41 | Priyanka Kargupta, Ishika Agarwal, Dilek Hakkani-Tur, Jiawei Han | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.MA | Socratic questioning is an effective teaching strategy, encouraging critical
thinking and problem-solving. The conversational capabilities of large language
models (LLMs) show great potential for providing scalable, real-time student
guidance. However, current LLMs often give away solutions directly, making them
ineffective instructors. We tackle this issue in the code debugging domain with
TreeInstruct, an Instructor agent guided by a novel state space-based planning
algorithm. TreeInstruct asks probing questions to help students independently
identify and resolve errors. It estimates a student's conceptual and
syntactical knowledge to dynamically construct a question tree based on their
responses and current knowledge state, effectively addressing both independent
and dependent mistakes concurrently in a multi-turn interaction setting. In
addition to using an existing single-bug debugging benchmark, we construct a
more challenging multi-bug dataset of 150 coding problems, incorrect solutions,
and bug fixes -- all carefully constructed and annotated by experts. Extensive
evaluation shows TreeInstruct's state-of-the-art performance on both datasets,
proving it to be a more effective instructor than baselines. Furthermore, a
real-world case study with five students of varying skill levels further
demonstrates TreeInstruct's ability to guide students to debug their code
efficiently with minimal turns and highly Socratic questioning. | [
-0.0969098657,
-0.8766265512,
0.5131642222,
0.232657671,
0.0188883692,
0.7955908775,
-0.0320281573,
-0.3363418579,
0.106630519,
0.2777511179,
-0.5113001466,
-0.6867184043,
-0.2592860758,
-0.1693819314,
-0.4800154567,
0.9654114246,
-0.0287791416,
-0.0029635034,
-0.5118188858,
0.1442382187,
-0.386366725,
-0.4632267654,
-0.7297537923,
0.042572964,
-0.0766649246,
1.084030509,
0.7618660927,
0.0731220171,
0.1889107972,
0.2538202405,
-0.2022419274,
0.2123601437,
-0.2546437979,
0.0734149292,
0.1868793219,
-0.5891424417,
-0.2964891195,
-0.3976115882,
0.3498784006,
0.5207825899,
-0.2185098678,
0.2218096405,
0.2068044692,
0.4655478895,
-0.499316901,
0.2134298086,
-0.6994440556,
0.0187679268,
0.1451618522,
-0.2250838727,
-0.5999578238,
-0.8163695335,
-0.2722587287,
-0.4164374471,
0.1381789893,
-0.2439998537,
0.4025760889,
0.5787510872,
-0.5360351801,
-0.2011727244,
-0.6877130866,
0.4467146993,
-0.7210544944,
-0.0346456841,
0.5038332343,
0.3278007507,
-0.4211420119,
-0.3063102961,
-0.3185603619,
-0.1524928659,
0.0808973312,
0.0952905416,
0.0415988192,
0.1288809478,
0.2706754506,
0.1099109873,
-0.5630584359,
0.1619129181,
-0.3765947223,
-0.1305680573,
0.5537378788,
0.1300512105,
0.4091090858,
-0.2927272916,
-0.2176693678,
-0.0682051405,
-0.9072567821,
0.4574458599,
0.2774508297,
0.0375279225,
0.1064727157,
0.2922555804,
0.1560518593,
0.5417564511,
0.1937291473,
-0.3378561735,
-0.0992529765,
-0.1740197539,
-0.1312101334,
0.3832337856,
0.3194174469,
0.305393666,
0.366997689,
-0.1971223354,
-0.0466568395,
0.1465480477,
0.3108989298,
-0.7240616083,
-0.4212594628,
0.3792831004,
0.0992579684,
-0.3155204654,
-0.2315767109,
-0.8781505227,
-0.5047113299,
-0.1886803061,
0.3852291107,
-0.5505056977,
-0.2709620297,
0.0316801593,
0.1106509343,
0.277854681,
0.3249043226,
-0.4564262629,
0.2637290955,
0.5790616274,
0.7312781215,
0.2078933567,
-0.2359707057,
-0.6592693329,
0.21348764,
-0.5306617618,
0.7404718399,
-0.6879449487,
-0.6272583604,
-0.0693871826,
0.1873071045,
-0.0566905588,
-0.6264954209,
0.037000753,
-0.1292690188,
-0.0424998067,
-0.0082680499,
-0.310670048,
-0.1885123104,
0.3977366984,
-0.1304714084,
1.2414755821,
0.356544733,
-0.5344562531,
0.0792087689,
-0.5028547049,
-0.2944674194,
0.223021701,
-0.6220288277,
-0.4846050441,
-0.182161808,
0.309564203,
0.2610183656,
0.1726494282,
0.3450296223,
-0.0080363546,
-0.5434723496,
-0.1087705046,
0.1076740399,
1.2425519228,
-0.1740193218,
-0.7363988757,
0.3325642049,
-0.6051661372,
0.4003247619,
0.1034469381,
-0.1270083934,
-0.4006136656,
0.2164758891,
-0.3269151151,
-0.0607319213,
-0.2411653697,
-0.5407343507,
0.7628971934,
-0.2387572676,
0.285061568,
0.8614470363,
0.242252335,
0.2873522043,
-0.2706052363,
1.152815938,
-0.0818876848,
0.3343775272,
-0.0190791711,
-0.3484573364,
-0.7186419964,
-0.0633268282,
-0.1578906775,
0.6326935887,
-0.9785405397,
-0.0532248355,
0.1928491443,
-0.7202369571,
-0.3695172668,
-0.0868077725,
0.428812772,
0.351905942,
0.4360483885,
0.0673175603,
-0.3612655103,
-0.6902775168,
0.0792341381,
-0.4533932209,
0.4547557235,
-0.034083385,
0.5276672244,
-0.1810613424,
0.7922818661,
-0.677749455,
-0.0001440793,
-0.2934353352,
0.0226920489,
-0.0449198261,
0.5878536701,
0.5832881331,
-0.3936426938,
-0.7042030692,
-0.2559544742,
-0.3185072839,
0.0213268325,
-0.2943507135,
0.0243487302,
0.3091543615,
0.66175282,
-0.3699999452,
0.5643065572,
0.565897882,
-0.5804165602,
0.801777184,
-0.2725763619,
0.0961476266,
-0.9724031687,
-0.3397239745,
-0.2533111572,
-0.0614375509,
-0.2527795434,
0.1812716722,
0.2168031633,
-0.2605032325,
-0.1803663075,
-0.0956869125,
-0.5338341594,
-0.2407525629,
-0.0302710161,
0.0111303553,
-0.1114080697,
0.7149943709,
-0.4236126244,
0.9731287956,
0.6492746472,
-0.4617106915,
0.2501729429,
0.2638218105,
-0.5372259617,
0.5464034677,
-0.5785271525,
0.4961994886,
-0.3239521384,
0.1737305969,
-1.2056703568,
0.1605425179,
0.2861300111,
-0.430387795,
0.303211242,
-0.6547774076,
-0.6315372586,
-0.2272034138,
-0.4569623172,
0.2793640494,
0.3038992882,
-0.689496398,
0.2059360296,
0.2342099994,
-0.1792006642,
-0.6168355346,
-0.3169044554,
-0.0439927913,
-0.2630185485,
-0.3910453916,
0.3169938326,
-0.4283456802,
-0.3072896898,
0.086361371,
-0.502146244,
-0.3617112041,
0.4434567094,
0.5183662176,
0.2196032554,
-0.0429106914,
0.2482144386,
0.3351464868,
-0.0089866426,
0.4322488606,
0.1275804937,
0.1906164885,
-0.3352464437,
-0.6138983369,
-0.1993298829,
0.2777669728,
0.7726646066,
-0.5031181574,
0.1580607742,
-0.0159110315,
-0.1802768856,
-0.6348481774,
-0.1205756366,
-0.2676327527,
-0.4573782086,
0.4917532504,
-0.2232236117,
-0.6688597202,
0.0941112861,
-0.2217469513,
0.4263049066,
-0.1799666137,
-0.0674725771,
0.0107507417,
1.1441558599,
0.8096630573,
-0.0811154172,
0.3066738844,
-0.7003985047,
0.2493686378,
-0.5604023933,
-0.5721276402,
-0.8177915812,
-0.2524620295,
-0.2647759914,
-0.5266844034,
0.5607101917,
0.1570905447,
-0.2597067654,
0.3692137301,
-0.8680231571,
0.6499672532,
0.4446467459,
0.0217751469,
0.542016089,
-0.1532461792,
0.0634606332,
-0.0007203615,
-0.9515891671,
-0.4050311744,
0.7473342419,
0.0871597007,
0.7838950753,
0.2925590873,
0.9483237267,
-0.0018657343,
0.2152545452,
-1.1391249895,
0.7028666735,
0.2864251733,
-0.5407095551,
-0.395042181,
-0.1600684673,
-0.9296889305,
0.2316233516,
0.059165094,
-0.7050192952,
0.096293956,
0.2509376109,
-0.5083521008,
0.545022428,
-0.9078937769,
1.0235829353,
-0.5687857866,
-0.1788855046,
-0.4373000264,
-0.3282788992,
0.2149440199,
0.0850868449,
0.3050149679,
-0.0024052791,
0.1000737026,
0.6377368569,
-0.5127484202,
1.0807330608,
-0.4661286175,
-0.1121208593,
0.6277067065,
0.5841317773,
0.5475564003,
0.2672362328,
0.1637154818,
-0.4858929813,
0.744166553,
-0.4326330125,
-0.6877066493,
0.6530905962,
-0.7633125186,
-0.7011638284,
-0.5902721286,
-0.3131216168,
-0.450517416,
-0.1217891648,
-0.1335334778,
0.7343304753,
-0.0500514209,
0.1372471005,
0.4465441406,
-0.3684059083,
0.6428915858,
0.6312211156,
-0.3771788478,
-0.0182934105,
0.6894720793,
0.1543689221,
0.248671174,
-0.0069703152,
0.1401538551,
0.1444889158,
-0.5357294083,
-0.5392987728,
-0.0491723679,
-0.5714805722,
-0.6196653843,
-0.3355971873,
-0.2296263725,
-0.0896739289,
-0.3217756152,
-0.3712194562,
-0.3177996278,
0.2170989364,
-0.3422719538,
0.5189414024,
0.8377451301,
0.1948625743,
0.3634276688,
-0.6996636391,
-0.1075984165,
0.2399923056,
0.1339402795,
0.0557188056,
-0.1927702725,
-0.3332379758,
-0.0396146029,
-0.5449965,
-1.2711869478,
0.1454685479,
-0.0749714896,
0.4336353242,
0.2506133318,
0.4312478602,
0.8769194484,
-0.2218950838,
0.5734227896,
-0.0668923929,
-0.9267811179,
0.7782614231,
0.1741312444,
0.4832755029,
0.6283642054,
0.5435339808,
-0.4969108403,
-0.8580720425,
-0.7532868385,
-0.7516099215,
0.846767664,
-0.1404617727,
-0.0594731383,
0.0226890612,
0.2921331525,
0.0400070325,
-0.0895047858,
-0.5827456117,
-0.1745183766,
-0.094039768,
-0.0345772393,
0.0150585463,
-0.2019369155,
0.0189383794,
-0.541662097,
0.585144937,
-0.4095201492,
-0.0251598004,
0.2842381001,
-0.1898194402,
-0.2610087991,
0.4807631671,
0.4508823156,
0.9944520593,
-0.2051620781,
0.3895206749,
0.1907004267,
-0.2506521642,
0.2588934898,
-0.1049274206,
-0.2408120483,
0.0079810433,
0.3269679546,
0.1855233014,
0.417652458,
-0.7163951993,
0.462803632,
0.2452409863,
-0.1692054719,
-0.433523953,
0.1235980168,
0.0513504781,
0.3131298423,
0.302193284,
-0.0611193702,
-0.0312777497,
-0.643655777,
0.0135184573,
0.5183284283,
-0.3620269001,
-0.4307783246,
0.2085241973,
0.2271056026,
-0.3785665631,
0.7709477544,
-0.2625337541,
-0.811866343,
1.1855541468,
0.6504670978,
0.6667076945,
-0.3702225685,
0.8411596417,
0.6203194261,
0.5540143847,
0.2831555605,
0.4203016162,
-0.2128548324,
-0.4671243429,
-0.6862017512,
0.1020284221,
-0.5638226867,
0.1143961698,
-0.3535741568,
0.0263505373,
-0.799931705,
0.1202653646,
-0.2438604385,
0.1505073309,
-0.0242568608,
-0.1198513731,
-0.2530019879,
0.8447877765,
-0.7011781335,
0.9160099626,
1.0154464245,
-0.3709654808,
-1.045836091,
0.1544158757,
0.1845387965,
-0.5694411993,
0.5534256101,
0.1601687521,
-0.2530489564,
0.0859626904,
-0.9493447542,
-0.5845012665,
1.0166473389,
0.397179395,
-0.4072400331,
-0.1693191975,
-0.2329550683,
0.4306986332,
-0.0610531531,
0.365109086,
0.0674799159,
0.3178364336,
0.0801770762,
-0.8392708898,
0.0672736615,
0.0348512791,
-0.407861799,
0.5379756093,
-0.7742593288,
0.4671157002,
-0.6296393275,
-0.3341109455,
-0.2500268221,
0.2869089842,
0.0414249115,
0.4355627,
0.7687427402,
0.3203817606,
0.87740165,
0.1795790941,
0.6454700828,
-0.4731914699,
0.2297706753,
1.3436703682,
0.2044759095,
0.7290856242,
0.5957622528,
-0.2344722003,
0.7978672981,
0.645773232,
0.1753489077,
0.3065835536,
0.3681578636,
-0.1634005606,
-0.4128352702,
0.0541594885,
-0.4501281977,
0.463753432,
0.1397433579,
0.3314766288,
-0.4081033468,
-0.2518508732,
0.278293103,
0.2224209756,
-0.207012549,
0.4550326467,
-0.0490589216,
-0.8491363525,
0.6299708486,
-0.1224444956,
0.1818311065,
-0.4351909459,
-0.2841691375,
-0.6345483065,
0.2581492662,
-0.5988558531,
-0.7756026983,
0.5092785358,
0.0136036575,
0.2992333174,
-0.2750928402,
0.2121423632,
-0.4140205383,
-0.2576099634,
0.243902266,
0.4866793454,
0.2615341842,
-0.1467635632,
-0.5280943513,
-0.2631988525,
0.3020866513,
0.2459495962,
0.170967564,
0.4563415647,
-0.1987788379,
0.8224753737,
0.1990757585,
-0.2547945082,
-0.0274462588,
-0.1399360299,
0.9476084113,
-0.5310203433,
-0.1934049577,
-0.6243200898,
0.7180586457,
0.0420472287,
-0.2639696598,
0.8771039844,
0.7097218633,
0.9329138398,
-0.0053006336,
0.4946346879,
-0.1380523443,
0.1914273202,
-0.3331954777,
0.2060320526,
-0.4440580308,
0.4143609703,
-0.3938579261,
-0.9260702133,
0.0077184965,
0.6054480672,
-0.2369189411,
-0.2833995521,
0.8636470437,
1.0048452616,
0.1056200564,
-0.1387450397,
0.1285037994,
0.1780685037,
0.538148582,
0.9880029559,
1.1683362722,
-0.0684097707,
0.8789471984,
-0.4247843325,
-0.545935452,
-0.1285519749,
-0.4444110692,
-1.0301239491,
-0.4378848672,
-0.7450505495,
-0.3877374828,
0.0750631467,
0.9647498727,
0.7111060023,
-0.7085670829,
-0.4307274222,
-0.1202870086,
0.5661800504,
-0.3372039199,
-0.258556813,
0.4189098179,
-0.4426207542,
-0.6173060536,
0.7244473696,
0.1191239953,
0.0695033371,
-0.3941391408,
-0.0505047627,
-0.2195602357,
-0.3149288297,
0.5748147368,
0.2261182219,
-0.4570267797,
-0.4559045434,
0.2321006805,
-0.0247031841,
0.0404139683,
0.9056740999,
-0.7881679535,
0.4910796285,
0.2079058737,
0.7790722847,
0.5731316209,
-0.0299029872,
0.2706230879,
-0.5305090547,
0.0898916051,
0.4259658754,
-0.0046830969,
0.0381984785,
-0.4852436781,
0.6968128085,
0.0153854601,
-0.6698368192,
-0.7531433702,
0.2884787023,
-0.738602519,
-0.52506423,
0.983738184,
-0.0748416707,
0.0123521378,
-0.1387231499,
-0.7451338768,
-0.0541578196,
-0.1867340803,
0.9504941106,
0.5659175515,
-0.3279060423,
-0.3910420835,
-0.3731776476,
0.6799189448,
0.6199650168,
-0.9999936223,
-0.0689462423,
0.7514609694,
0.1455733031,
-0.0182652231,
0.5622928739,
0.0554958247,
0.1388198882,
0.057290189,
0.0235908087,
-0.2445407063,
-0.6989776492,
-0.2002480179,
0.1329064369,
0.4266935289,
-0.4355712533
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11706v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11706v1 | Prompts as Auto-Optimized Training Hyperparameters: Training Best-in-Class IR Models from Scratch with 10 Gold Labels | 2024-06-17T16:25:55 | 2024-06-17T16:25:55 | Jasper Xian, Saron Samuel, Faraz Khoubsirat, Ronak Pradeep, Md Arafat Sultan, Radu Florian, Salim Roukos, Avirup Sil, Christopher Potts, Omar Khattab | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL, cs.LG | We develop a method for training small-scale (under 100M parameter) neural
information retrieval models with as few as 10 gold relevance labels. The
method depends on generating synthetic queries for documents using a language
model (LM), and the key step is that we automatically optimize the LM prompt
that is used to generate these queries based on training quality. In
experiments with the BIRCO benchmark, we find that models trained with our
method outperform RankZephyr and are competitive with RankLLama, both of which
are 7B parameter models trained on over 100K labels. These findings point to
the power of automatic prompt optimization for synthetic dataset generation. | [
-0.5489569902,
-0.4867022038,
0.6049937606,
-0.0897466838,
0.0081182355,
-0.1321291476,
-0.1233734936,
-0.2336619496,
-0.0856030062,
0.4096575975,
-0.5527185798,
-0.2411682755,
-0.3990690708,
0.4885649383,
-0.201988712,
1.2090123892,
0.3260711133,
0.2853472233,
-0.1675588787,
-0.1339374185,
-0.3609595001,
-0.4857355058,
-0.7632321715,
-0.2100047767,
0.9618374705,
0.5051190257,
0.6261249185,
0.808840394,
0.5381781459,
0.3030072153,
-0.0089753335,
0.3754044473,
-0.2457975596,
0.3678610623,
-0.0428684875,
-0.4750632048,
0.1305009574,
0.2490644455,
0.5171170235,
0.7539952397,
0.1671125144,
0.3298784494,
0.0369594283,
0.6774666309,
-0.6120280027,
-0.0375542939,
-0.6947972178,
-0.0577553399,
0.1077813134,
-0.5875291824,
-0.7030729055,
-0.6223595738,
0.2419063002,
-0.5737032294,
0.4524365067,
0.5133035183,
1.150057435,
0.3552945554,
-0.2733509243,
-0.3134031892,
-0.641921103,
0.5938586593,
-0.433265835,
0.1878522784,
0.4640288949,
0.7149394751,
-0.1487385929,
-1.0813030005,
-0.3474365473,
-0.4617158771,
-0.1552166045,
-0.1481930465,
-0.153774187,
0.2274895012,
0.5703769922,
0.1620141268,
-0.8635131121,
0.0570580736,
-0.3168024719,
-0.188696444,
0.3906988502,
0.4445704222,
0.0128222359,
-0.2047543079,
-0.2547886074,
-0.3342504203,
-0.4925392568,
0.0607396364,
0.3744443953,
0.5175999403,
0.4511944354,
0.5283083916,
-0.3229965568,
1.2554959059,
0.3558024466,
0.1346850693,
-0.084498845,
-0.3597287834,
-0.0896453783,
0.0852619037,
0.8627261519,
0.2142114639,
0.1660565436,
-0.3315792084,
-0.4638188779,
-0.0360893682,
0.2667625844,
-0.8938441277,
-0.3543376029,
-0.019722335,
-0.3629528284,
-0.2597089112,
-0.189651221,
-0.5750504136,
-0.1747861654,
-0.7133380771,
0.8129314184,
-0.2379333228,
0.5000944734,
-0.0098791197,
-0.3119231462,
0.1301797926,
0.311819315,
-0.9239941835,
0.0598176643,
0.2386876345,
0.6293679476,
-0.0782656297,
-0.2008274049,
-0.83504951,
-0.1508916318,
-0.5001924038,
1.1270976067,
-0.5012732744,
-0.2988120019,
-0.0280884206,
0.0931251049,
-0.2317666262,
-0.6762150526,
0.3088372052,
-0.8076547384,
0.3910633028,
-0.4023067355,
-0.4588432908,
0.1428687572,
0.3418214023,
-0.5434112549,
1.4107578993,
0.2990185022,
-0.5013864636,
0.4635164142,
-0.5866982937,
0.048409164,
0.246105969,
0.0379725546,
-0.1072377115,
-0.04945096,
0.2051152289,
0.1407129914,
-0.7399621606,
0.2724927068,
0.0893780887,
-0.1598976701,
0.2191017717,
-0.1422940344,
0.7168396711,
0.4605436623,
-0.2538382113,
0.1632130593,
-0.8584284782,
0.3902946413,
-0.0374697074,
-0.5774959326,
-0.2816221714,
-0.5066923499,
-0.0090242289,
0.1996362656,
0.3559744358,
-0.3697066307,
0.2464903593,
-0.5150957108,
0.2463225424,
0.5800797343,
0.1855189949,
0.3268693388,
-0.2654249072,
0.5545951724,
-0.1696432382,
0.2168890983,
-0.2785440087,
-0.3333068788,
-0.958334744,
0.0122458916,
0.5571992397,
0.4800485075,
-0.5938118696,
0.6515933871,
0.1821300685,
-0.7581017017,
-0.6312618852,
0.2462495416,
0.4029979706,
0.9408116341,
0.4009748697,
0.1056405231,
-0.4587779641,
-1.0247499943,
-0.5493636131,
-0.151605159,
0.100808315,
0.2481628507,
0.5463192463,
-0.2201431841,
1.21613276,
-0.4155000746,
-0.104914397,
-0.2536343038,
0.5473060608,
0.2943521142,
0.474457413,
0.5676599741,
-0.7240763307,
-0.7649155259,
-0.3705760837,
-0.7220156193,
-0.2733044028,
-0.1499521583,
-0.4130885601,
0.0668342933,
0.7667360306,
-0.513681829,
0.2196783423,
0.0537523068,
-0.2496290058,
0.424572736,
-0.4867912233,
0.1658331901,
-1.0114076138,
0.2656183541,
0.2716229558,
0.0042889207,
-0.3952353299,
-0.2174137533,
0.2416781634,
-0.5799779296,
-0.2644800246,
0.8722539544,
-0.6393319964,
-0.0351214483,
-0.2918450832,
-0.0862374604,
0.3358239233,
0.5483391881,
0.0179700572,
1.0059286356,
0.5059197545,
-0.8288038969,
0.4018731713,
0.2360351831,
-0.3599430919,
0.4974016845,
-0.9731196165,
0.1264553219,
-0.3800635636,
-0.0330445468,
-1.4445562363,
-0.4174393117,
-0.0391538478,
-0.4501746893,
0.2596965432,
-0.2230608761,
-0.7296972275,
-0.4891424179,
-0.0530613326,
0.2934015691,
0.533839941,
-0.7976200581,
0.3505286574,
0.144703269,
-0.1667023301,
-0.3593390286,
-0.3817221224,
0.0785688087,
-0.2020794153,
-0.3990419507,
0.2602627873,
-0.3572210371,
-0.0019030856,
-0.253756851,
0.318053782,
0.0797891989,
-0.0825077817,
0.0086743217,
0.2165901661,
-0.0947616473,
0.1712384522,
-0.0018464429,
-0.3887254298,
0.036776267,
-0.3129630685,
0.5541430116,
-0.3725774288,
-0.1439956278,
-0.5909335613,
0.2526713312,
0.317661345,
-0.2964353263,
0.6516155601,
0.2620449066,
-0.1985193044,
-0.1383811235,
-0.5807126164,
-0.4615375102,
-0.5540195107,
0.0449191406,
-0.3032520115,
-0.4748538733,
0.4745445549,
-0.003454786,
-0.0354898125,
0.4710598588,
0.48934412,
-0.0029058359,
1.6495718956,
0.4503819942,
0.0776365399,
0.5458673835,
-0.3480895162,
-0.0910151526,
-0.52947855,
-0.475669533,
-1.0178905725,
-0.2139572948,
-0.5543881655,
-0.1574162841,
0.901143074,
-0.1195184067,
-0.5002281666,
0.3166391551,
-0.9142730236,
0.6780255437,
0.9989640117,
0.0002859803,
-0.0626344532,
0.1588787287,
-0.3068049848,
-0.0500660613,
-0.9381203055,
-0.4427603483,
0.9105504751,
-0.0050788573,
0.966606915,
-0.4739626348,
0.621691823,
0.3656075895,
0.1325205117,
-0.990496397,
0.5272111297,
0.283893168,
-0.7369094491,
-0.1541506499,
-0.3364284635,
-1.1573809385,
-0.0467385352,
0.0013361803,
-0.4258915782,
0.5046605468,
0.2253703773,
-0.6944369674,
-0.2269220799,
-0.691260159,
0.8753995299,
-0.4116457105,
-0.2916139662,
0.3837155998,
-0.8671459556,
-0.2560158074,
0.0805065557,
-0.2377410233,
0.0770215467,
-0.072849609,
0.9480106235,
-0.4776773453,
0.4702145159,
-0.3752031624,
0.2922863662,
0.4072441161,
0.0521333329,
0.5873368979,
-0.174375236,
-0.396710366,
-0.3752962053,
-0.1057281494,
-0.3776026964,
-0.5474337339,
0.4457118809,
-0.7917713523,
-0.4329559505,
-0.592484355,
-0.5399389863,
-0.4523103833,
0.2705485225,
0.7457674146,
0.6106899381,
0.1135240719,
0.2483776063,
0.8472488523,
-0.2425106019,
0.5078477263,
0.6224848628,
0.2949714959,
-0.5619130731,
0.8293709159,
0.1880698204,
0.1011448801,
0.2250246406,
0.3050352931,
-0.4298540056,
-0.4262839854,
-0.5922728777,
0.2275373936,
-0.872535646,
-0.5104693174,
-0.7907786965,
-0.2680109441,
-0.4297167957,
-0.073305957,
-0.1795608848,
-0.2363162041,
-0.4255436659,
0.0376238078,
0.5340035558,
0.4958935678,
-0.1036208197,
0.6017858982,
-0.8991825581,
0.285653919,
0.338344872,
-0.0194873586,
-0.2291457504,
-0.8388209343,
-0.494468838,
-0.1037168801,
-0.1507043093,
-0.6883488297,
0.7555227876,
0.266910851,
0.7882153988,
0.2271781117,
0.1638410538,
0.4875410199,
-0.4296842515,
0.7864818573,
-0.0373876244,
-0.3598009348,
1.0330319405,
-0.5405218601,
0.3533227742,
1.0381108522,
0.9431058168,
-0.2541467845,
-0.2163328826,
-0.5786587,
-0.8136883974,
0.998278439,
-0.0993548855,
0.0675469041,
-0.3261007965,
0.5484322906,
0.1699629277,
0.249752298,
-0.4103753269,
-0.4087192714,
0.0134258438,
-0.3688695431,
0.0469094887,
-0.3725027442,
-0.2066076547,
-0.4131845236,
0.7147536278,
-0.3532941341,
0.4592623413,
0.3015139997,
-0.0242391825,
-0.2449602932,
-0.2502602041,
0.2960229814,
0.6794365048,
-0.3591057956,
-0.0746092796,
-0.1985030472,
-0.131799683,
0.387224853,
0.167247057,
-0.3580926359,
0.1804417819,
-0.0978441387,
0.9403094053,
-0.07464917,
-0.6079102159,
0.1206972674,
-0.211522162,
-0.1135747135,
-0.2394482344,
0.4706842005,
-0.2857325971,
0.1640008986,
0.6011657715,
-0.0487850159,
0.321475774,
-0.4966367483,
0.2033472508,
0.4200499058,
-0.3464839458,
-0.0983342975,
0.8391355276,
0.009726217,
-0.4070381224,
0.6374827027,
-0.0936903059,
-0.4028213322,
0.7283415198,
0.345919162,
0.7047607899,
-0.2461245358,
0.2489733696,
0.6863576174,
0.0999953151,
-0.3052729368,
0.2060142308,
-0.0666135401,
-0.3200467825,
0.1493718475,
-0.7470023036,
-0.6003938317,
0.1283721179,
-0.8823205233,
0.4016749263,
-0.5397481322,
-0.3904848695,
0.3840259016,
0.1628208607,
-0.7375856042,
0.6288140416,
-0.1769675016,
1.0448725224,
-0.6306535006,
0.5788034201,
0.6762527227,
-0.58153826,
-0.8079223633,
-0.3383404016,
-0.314476192,
-0.7570494413,
1.1738250256,
0.1530930996,
0.209955886,
0.3481840491,
-0.7629067898,
-0.8955388665,
0.7680230737,
0.4645164013,
-0.3816972077,
-0.3672600389,
0.1779262424,
0.5896723866,
-0.4714932442,
0.5247454643,
0.5088293552,
0.5136680603,
-0.0411198139,
-0.5768150687,
-0.2444870174,
-0.4574468434,
0.1706758291,
0.0579765476,
-0.5632933378,
0.8953778744,
-0.0975882635,
0.1543061584,
0.3265315294,
0.6134244204,
0.2323355973,
0.3554977179,
0.3792119324,
0.3403250277,
0.8031526208,
-0.1260239482,
1.1946915388,
-0.6045023203,
0.175514251,
0.9200559258,
-0.120026134,
0.3723316789,
0.4288864732,
0.1127047986,
0.3955940008,
1.1965945959,
-0.3026797175,
0.813542366,
0.0853942633,
-0.1942381114,
-0.4392760694,
-0.2451556921,
-0.3946292102,
0.2312152088,
0.3659223616,
-0.7180530429,
-0.4364486933,
0.2864621878,
-0.3204420507,
-0.0701500773,
-0.2440712452,
0.970996201,
-0.1858922988,
-1.1228426695,
1.0159827471,
-0.0430926196,
0.3428368568,
-0.7361372709,
0.0844521597,
-0.5080794096,
0.0554371886,
0.0354741327,
-0.3200852573,
-0.2452304959,
0.0316090658,
-0.3411183059,
-0.2414062321,
0.7658472657,
-0.4242579043,
-0.5110014677,
0.0129813375,
0.4280326068,
0.2357432842,
-0.0453730971,
-0.923818171,
-0.3120774329,
-0.2421008646,
-0.6838893294,
0.5727216005,
0.7057812214,
0.0327861719,
0.7714098096,
0.726596117,
0.1116097271,
0.1495084316,
-0.0420413539,
0.9654598832,
-0.7749890089,
-0.4792307913,
-0.5405230522,
0.3081522286,
0.0183325335,
-0.3537402749,
0.6919739842,
0.7469187379,
0.6419343948,
-0.2281580418,
0.7591980696,
0.1471424997,
0.6345533133,
-0.4335173666,
0.6481588483,
-0.7053620815,
0.1184521094,
0.1577887386,
-1.1032221317,
0.0204315037,
0.5740830302,
-0.2108216435,
0.2522417903,
0.5726338625,
1.1859025955,
0.0377659388,
-0.2877767384,
0.2237994224,
-0.2841986418,
0.1105158105,
0.2839321494,
0.8553584218,
-0.6191031337,
0.6117132306,
-0.3239502609,
0.0438338444,
-0.5500332713,
-0.7035629153,
-0.9566129446,
-0.6412001252,
-0.3203530014,
-0.5260292888,
0.176844731,
1.0945901871,
0.7966384292,
-0.6631215811,
-0.2069262415,
-0.1114463955,
-0.2942749858,
0.1608794481,
-0.2925368547,
0.4051830471,
-0.9484282732,
-0.8262123466,
0.5580735803,
-0.0201784223,
0.2852929831,
-0.2307862937,
-0.1805783361,
-0.2332635522,
0.1705423146,
0.3463806212,
0.3416095972,
-0.1881462634,
-0.0607997626,
0.2919265032,
-0.584749639,
0.1396843642,
0.8478611112,
-1.0724093914,
0.5668343902,
0.7397276759,
0.7320629954,
0.3621394932,
0.1398751587,
0.5968670249,
-0.7139663696,
0.1635105461,
0.5036569834,
0.1437187642,
0.3233225346,
-0.5006231666,
0.5593203902,
0.0898121819,
-0.7957347631,
-1.136398077,
-0.1025330797,
-0.725736618,
-0.1223534271,
1.1363568306,
0.0999686643,
-0.4044550061,
-0.0428124592,
-0.3541949689,
0.3108049929,
-0.4228945076,
0.8005953431,
0.3208974302,
-0.404902041,
-0.0631422549,
-0.5975459814,
0.9084880948,
0.6287866831,
-0.8700354099,
-0.0212814063,
0.5119553804,
0.1038579866,
0.1005968377,
0.3643425703,
0.0152433002,
0.4323444366,
-0.0055195931,
-0.018413499,
-0.3121161759,
-0.6573892832,
-0.1727277488,
0.1164810136,
0.2919462621,
-0.030006364
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11704v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11704v1 | Nemotron-4 340B Technical Report | 2024-06-17T16:25:04 | 2024-06-17T16:25:04 | Nvidia, :, Bo Adler, Niket Agarwal, Ashwath Aithal, Dong H. Anh, Pallab Bhattacharya, Annika Brundyn, Jared Casper, Bryan Catanzaro, Sharon Clay, Jonathan Cohen, Sirshak Das, Ayush Dattagupta, Olivier Delalleau, Leon Derczynski, Yi Dong, Daniel Egert, Ellie Evans, Aleksander Ficek, Denys Fridman, Shaona Ghosh, Boris Ginsburg, Igor Gitman, Tomasz Grzegorzek, Robert Hero, Jining Huang, Vibhu Jawa, Joseph Jennings, Aastha Jhunjhunwala, John Kamalu, Sadaf Khan, Oleksii Kuchaiev, Patrick LeGresley, Hui Li, Jiwei Liu, Zihan Liu, Eileen Long, Ameya Sunil Mahabaleshwarkar, Somshubra Majumdar, James Maki, Miguel Martinez, Maer Rodrigues de Melo, Ivan Moshkov, Deepak Narayanan, Sean Narenthiran, Jesus Navarro, Phong Nguyen, Osvald Nitski, Vahid Noroozi, Guruprasad Nutheti, Christopher Parisien, Jupinder Parmar, Mostofa Patwary, Krzysztof Pawelec, Wei Ping, Shrimai Prabhumoye, Rajarshi Roy, Trisha Saar, Vasanth Rao Naik Sabavat, Sanjeev Satheesh, Jane Polak Scowcroft, Jason Sewall, Pavel Shamis, Gerald Shen, Mohammad Shoeybi, Dave Sizer, Misha Smelyanskiy, Felipe Soares, Makesh Narsimhan Sreedhar, Dan Su, Sandeep Subramanian, Shengyang Sun, Shubham Toshniwal, Hao Wang, Zhilin Wang, Jiaxuan You, Jiaqi Zeng, Jimmy Zhang, Jing Zhang, Vivienne Zhang, Yian Zhang, Chen Zhu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | We release the Nemotron-4 340B model family, including Nemotron-4-340B-Base,
Nemotron-4-340B-Instruct, and Nemotron-4-340B-Reward. Our models are open
access under the NVIDIA Open Model License Agreement, a permissive model
license that allows distribution, modification, and use of the models and its
outputs. These models perform competitively to open access models on a wide
range of evaluation benchmarks, and were sized to fit on a single DGX H100 with
8 GPUs when deployed in FP8 precision. We believe that the community can
benefit from these models in various research studies and commercial
applications, especially for generating synthetic data to train smaller
language models. Notably, over 98% of data used in our model alignment process
is synthetically generated, showcasing the effectiveness of these models in
generating synthetic data. To further support open research and facilitate
model development, we are also open-sourcing the synthetic data generation
pipeline used in our model alignment process. | [
-0.4830032289,
-0.2444198728,
0.4208781421,
0.1015999615,
-0.0601777136,
-0.2363303155,
0.1809290349,
-0.5366506577,
-0.1600935608,
0.8153895736,
-0.5507670641,
-0.2242526561,
-0.3337628543,
0.1451750249,
-0.2330077887,
0.93032974,
-0.2128972262,
0.1944788098,
-0.2137058079,
-0.0606167987,
-0.3103247583,
-0.7301860452,
-0.5182713866,
-0.4025165141,
0.579159081,
0.4197204709,
0.730346024,
0.8607937098,
0.8149768114,
0.200639829,
-0.0861401856,
0.0561770424,
-0.3535559177,
-0.0676493794,
-0.4066467285,
-0.0640812516,
-1.3544173241,
0.0965821072,
0.6823843718,
0.3737723529,
-0.4202919602,
0.3408660293,
-0.2883099616,
0.3896884322,
-0.4615474939,
0.2418711483,
-0.3143996298,
-0.059125077,
-0.6748233438,
0.2214821279,
-0.4386362731,
-0.5974974036,
0.0290670935,
-0.8762245774,
0.4107672572,
0.2368588746,
1.0193532705,
0.0180892684,
-0.2695223987,
-0.0682765916,
-0.5207984447,
0.644656837,
-1.0862902403,
0.4154514074,
0.1223694757,
0.8090556264,
-0.1234181225,
-0.8905717134,
-0.5590842366,
-0.1043370515,
0.2607896924,
0.0679787248,
-0.4800721705,
0.022270089,
0.2283238471,
0.7368084192,
-0.4950790405,
0.1253228188,
-0.8042861819,
-0.2035784423,
0.6057435274,
0.3856678605,
0.1520647705,
-0.1453463435,
-0.3740587831,
-0.0641142726,
-0.9427596331,
-0.6454328299,
0.805318892,
0.2092633694,
-0.2487056702,
0.7629445195,
-0.2659542859,
0.9892050624,
0.1995237172,
0.2542649209,
0.6304711699,
-0.5335912108,
-0.3286148906,
-0.077536948,
0.6004356742,
0.4346901476,
-0.1080569178,
0.039464213,
-0.485820055,
-0.1370091587,
0.5397046208,
-0.9061130881,
-0.0447860733,
0.2238768786,
-0.3791062236,
-0.24702622,
-0.0028788052,
-1.0484158993,
-0.1705268919,
-0.2310605347,
0.4172676206,
-0.3546578884,
-0.3990315199,
0.3097231388,
-0.3543699086,
0.3978269994,
0.3605893552,
-1.2938343287,
0.6819362044,
0.466242671,
0.9043226838,
-0.3154473305,
-0.0181194451,
-0.3014047444,
0.3199466169,
-0.135455966,
0.5180383325,
-0.2812100649,
-0.316115886,
-0.0264723916,
0.1651227623,
0.1603370309,
-0.8294280767,
0.5029159188,
-0.5966904163,
0.2238261402,
0.0747120157,
-0.4783166051,
-0.3448617458,
0.171096772,
-1.028640151,
0.7361772656,
0.3726780415,
-0.4589288533,
-0.050728824,
-0.823572278,
0.2332772762,
0.3080850244,
-0.0769370869,
-0.3258607984,
0.2523785233,
-0.0236586202,
0.0853359327,
-0.8102837205,
0.2439129204,
-0.3144749999,
0.0675966665,
-0.0796475038,
-0.1745666564,
0.4819632471,
0.3900583684,
-0.2595986426,
0.1111847833,
-0.4486641884,
-0.2302339673,
0.1681039184,
0.0993921012,
0.329536587,
-0.5821430683,
0.0169838034,
0.385553956,
0.3374061286,
-0.9615167379,
0.1505870968,
-0.3813212514,
0.3165142238,
0.744191587,
-0.0182710998,
0.6032209992,
-0.4874002934,
0.9499499798,
-0.0764204413,
0.3723073602,
-0.0880091712,
-0.6642406583,
-0.3180130124,
-0.2744566202,
0.2164932787,
0.0722565129,
-0.5197070241,
-0.1328195482,
-0.0497305617,
-0.7072843909,
-0.2458150387,
-0.1352539808,
0.5483880043,
0.7051830888,
0.3116374612,
-0.3118989766,
-0.4138903916,
-1.1009423733,
0.1196934208,
0.223380819,
0.1089609936,
0.3250046372,
0.6758444309,
-0.290730983,
0.6032502651,
-0.6540384293,
-0.1255843639,
-0.165380612,
0.095630154,
0.4200002551,
0.6650066972,
0.8493589163,
-0.4681846201,
-0.2201357037,
0.2293035686,
-0.5839368701,
0.0658179522,
0.5920160413,
-0.4233970046,
0.5118653178,
0.2447782755,
-0.4132759571,
0.4693076611,
0.9572002888,
0.0061730347,
0.3169133961,
-0.2976542711,
-0.0914337188,
-1.0390042067,
0.1760961413,
0.0551186465,
0.093775928,
-0.5163258314,
-0.2052385807,
0.3235245645,
-0.0654184073,
-0.5899247527,
0.6951791048,
-0.3881226182,
-0.0580330975,
-0.2693218589,
0.0614928901,
0.0335602947,
0.1893513948,
0.0957757086,
0.547467351,
0.3614066839,
-0.6076661348,
0.5960431099,
0.4539509416,
-0.0077459468,
0.2370926291,
-0.9622755051,
0.177753076,
0.0566553697,
0.2108535469,
-0.3997020423,
-0.7512315512,
0.3177554011,
-0.6313009858,
0.1541442573,
-0.2310260981,
-0.5267685652,
-0.2334729731,
0.1210579053,
0.8363948464,
0.6945522428,
-0.625241816,
0.6150731444,
0.6548835039,
-0.1421942264,
-0.201968357,
-0.7261654735,
-0.5427619219,
0.0327657908,
-0.8722913861,
0.7681438923,
0.0798711851,
-0.1904605478,
0.2029890418,
0.0044323597,
-0.2567943037,
-0.3349149823,
0.4838932455,
0.7457659841,
-0.3174352646,
0.032567326,
-0.2208292186,
-0.1640368402,
0.0255235061,
-0.3054354191,
0.5995764136,
-0.1329284459,
-0.2113205194,
-0.3172387183,
-0.0734837651,
0.4313592613,
-0.4052420557,
0.6482265592,
0.0805419162,
-0.7847313285,
-0.1340071112,
-0.1888289601,
-0.3114458025,
-0.4957636595,
0.2997418344,
-0.1578217298,
-0.4584460557,
0.223813504,
0.1631201059,
0.3355598748,
0.6310318112,
0.6437466145,
0.459807843,
0.91553092,
0.5871430635,
0.5102165937,
0.3192098439,
-0.0663385615,
0.009889733,
-0.9674401879,
-0.5875847936,
-0.4295585454,
-0.0736007467,
-0.3579536974,
-0.5875610709,
0.23198919,
-0.4479222,
-0.4045459926,
0.4568880796,
-0.4373571277,
0.1481214613,
0.5191317797,
-0.2838777304,
0.0585170053,
-0.0701882914,
-0.1270681173,
-0.0823817998,
-0.4369344115,
-0.6307220459,
1.2474076748,
0.23354882,
0.553360641,
0.469817549,
0.6830191612,
-0.1171803027,
0.6752806902,
-0.3169437647,
0.2224053591,
0.0525329225,
-1.2817190886,
-0.0901854411,
-0.3486854136,
-0.8637671471,
0.0529158637,
-0.0041521783,
-0.3856599927,
0.0287813302,
0.365832448,
-0.499972105,
0.3648970723,
-0.6030579805,
1.0848250389,
-0.1163121909,
-0.4478630424,
-0.0491451509,
-0.2382065058,
0.6250044703,
-0.3132174909,
0.1437169015,
-0.2909828722,
0.0840945989,
0.5271040797,
-0.4869321883,
0.3884102404,
-0.2327261716,
0.0108806239,
-0.0508947,
-0.1739320606,
0.1913346946,
0.1251040399,
-0.5134527683,
0.4354397953,
-0.2861142159,
-0.3696500063,
-0.4087213576,
0.7357010841,
-0.8186715245,
-0.4406508803,
-0.8603534102,
-0.6982771754,
-0.1823946834,
0.2876380384,
0.2203585505,
0.6859816909,
-0.1018959954,
0.2332454622,
0.4183837771,
-0.3785568476,
0.4263901114,
0.5380833745,
-0.5385462642,
-0.8304082155,
0.705555737,
0.1432213187,
0.7168610692,
-0.019275805,
-0.2195473015,
-0.139776811,
-0.6670531034,
-0.5648415089,
0.6279767752,
-0.2970891297,
-0.2697266638,
-0.2319550812,
-0.409560442,
-0.6950315237,
0.0011473465,
-0.70634377,
-0.5303337574,
-0.1980149448,
-0.1962357908,
0.3548863828,
1.3393973112,
-0.0976789668,
0.5218092799,
-0.8452136517,
0.3416669965,
-0.1795698851,
0.4807947278,
-0.2639822066,
-0.749085784,
-0.2842386961,
0.1925740242,
-0.8069123626,
-0.7651016712,
0.9132522345,
-0.3075221777,
0.8393230438,
-0.0919856355,
-0.144253388,
0.4498913884,
-0.5757442117,
0.7102449536,
0.2877921164,
-1.0401520729,
0.3411617577,
-0.6174622774,
0.3254952133,
0.0028112864,
0.4158198237,
-0.181983307,
-0.0836833343,
-0.8403137922,
-0.7832854986,
1.0775362253,
0.361961782,
-0.0563102327,
0.0221253838,
0.4248229861,
0.2722765505,
0.2831230164,
-0.6034888625,
-0.1431967765,
-0.4490049183,
-0.3298968971,
-0.1373934597,
-0.0760781616,
-0.2271648198,
-0.0536463931,
0.8515188098,
-0.0532463975,
0.2359294891,
0.0737857297,
0.167313695,
0.0365112685,
-0.2596499622,
0.6018036604,
0.5651694536,
-0.6194817424,
-0.1402373016,
-0.0872354284,
-0.6003396511,
-0.114126578,
0.3394228518,
0.0749325156,
-0.1217964292,
-0.1843575388,
0.590982914,
0.1310156286,
-0.4871230721,
0.392211169,
-0.1016310975,
-0.5637307763,
-0.4065380991,
-0.105985187,
0.2640957832,
0.1696079075,
-0.0903188214,
0.1134742945,
0.0840334594,
-0.199706316,
0.3196968436,
0.1314913034,
-0.2998411357,
-0.5838540196,
0.8447197676,
0.293825984,
-0.0320452601,
0.8867938519,
-0.1940020025,
0.0493272431,
0.6926259995,
0.692192018,
0.8014944792,
-0.1575129032,
0.1536172479,
0.7198711634,
0.2169999331,
-0.2367773503,
0.3375092149,
0.5258712173,
-0.7949461937,
-0.096481666,
-0.5637158751,
-0.8622672558,
-0.2315745354,
-0.9583489299,
0.3957565427,
-0.5994033217,
-0.3391910791,
0.4028522074,
-0.3451341689,
-0.4059763551,
0.1522952318,
0.3565994501,
0.9840129614,
-0.4187389016,
1.2337566614,
0.5403006077,
-0.7263355255,
-0.8798112273,
-0.1895019114,
0.1134312525,
-0.5673058033,
0.8966769576,
0.0608299561,
-0.0506800115,
-0.0203763656,
-0.5838346481,
-1.0896348953,
1.4933402538,
0.780356884,
-0.2536928356,
-0.089458257,
0.0005511573,
0.2439126819,
-0.4576352239,
0.2945677638,
0.2135475278,
0.4996184707,
0.2512619793,
-0.9750512242,
0.0396607593,
-0.4165075421,
-0.1018104032,
0.41746068,
-0.7594035864,
1.4626810551,
0.0582071282,
0.0196474046,
0.1496946067,
0.5936629176,
0.6468814015,
0.2813116908,
0.0220208336,
0.4307797849,
0.726051271,
-0.1867025644,
1.338945508,
-0.3779548705,
0.1660217643,
1.0976762772,
-0.6634999514,
0.6039664149,
0.5597534776,
0.3661869764,
0.4958204627,
0.3487657905,
-0.1280922145,
0.3132966757,
0.3060772717,
-0.1632602662,
0.1173807159,
-0.1191225648,
-0.4388202429,
0.0233698785,
0.3123495579,
-0.3311935961,
-0.2244376987,
-0.4162136614,
0.0542589091,
-0.1904228479,
-0.3701176345,
0.3017185628,
0.0209014527,
-0.8982411027,
0.4450083971,
0.193230316,
0.3001966178,
-0.6902472377,
-0.2830342352,
-0.0860963315,
0.6195223927,
-0.4099434912,
-0.5769268274,
0.5384181142,
0.0150642525,
-0.2979522645,
-0.3000864685,
0.2154243886,
0.070946008,
-0.109343186,
0.2741010189,
0.0810320377,
0.051858183,
0.1109476909,
-0.1586572081,
0.1326363087,
-0.060350664,
-0.0407783128,
0.3221516311,
0.1259926856,
-0.1691391021,
0.4511836469,
0.5386475325,
-0.097032465,
0.5684063435,
-0.2537256479,
0.8268545866,
-0.8295721412,
0.1237008348,
-0.4797224104,
0.5647502542,
-0.2808825374,
-0.7085393071,
1.1302938461,
0.8588094115,
0.8527105451,
-0.1543748975,
0.7938506603,
-0.0313949063,
0.289537847,
-0.3908010125,
0.1929608881,
-0.4463816285,
-0.0541249141,
0.0184438564,
-0.653249979,
-0.2622981668,
0.1786065251,
-0.2565010488,
-0.0090195388,
0.8457875252,
0.9054195285,
-0.1061665639,
0.4956573248,
0.2768742442,
0.0493311659,
0.5640244484,
0.553170979,
0.5719611049,
-0.3685213327,
0.3249705732,
-0.4406551123,
-0.3984804451,
-0.203198418,
-0.8770915866,
-0.583148241,
-0.3025419712,
-0.2530362606,
-0.3912243545,
-0.0367311724,
0.6832229495,
0.7835001945,
-0.7036883831,
-0.5210476518,
-0.3605107367,
-0.2117946595,
0.0608326234,
-0.1423263252,
-0.1210060567,
-0.23470667,
-1.1139041185,
0.3332342207,
0.4197914898,
0.1933623105,
-0.186473608,
-0.4613032043,
-0.20319134,
0.3418209851,
-0.0908403248,
0.3303898573,
-0.5032879114,
-0.0207458194,
0.2945764661,
-0.3540108204,
-0.0965405628,
0.4398000538,
-0.3970999122,
0.4321782589,
0.7338321805,
0.5392701626,
0.7738280296,
-0.1678258479,
1.2794311047,
-0.3365838528,
0.1813413948,
0.3554501235,
0.6632599235,
0.1209910959,
-0.0054037026,
0.5638119578,
0.0073588742,
-0.8300561309,
-1.0191164017,
0.3735737205,
-1.1219849586,
0.1639605463,
1.2399501801,
-0.1512624025,
-0.5007948875,
0.2658978999,
-0.1885962933,
0.28944242,
-0.3553889394,
-0.0986979157,
0.5322725177,
-0.2583732605,
0.2185190022,
-1.0934684277,
0.4010511637,
0.1685309559,
-0.889313817,
-0.2100732476,
0.7445736527,
0.2261728197,
0.1252931356,
0.2321106344,
-0.8816791773,
0.4364560843,
0.0137365647,
0.7717691064,
-0.1274672449,
-0.0610393509,
-0.5660102367,
0.248737514,
0.0001988195,
-0.3413416147
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11698v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11698v1 | Meta Reasoning for Large Language Models | 2024-06-17T16:14:11 | 2024-06-17T16:14:11 | Peizhong Gao, Ao Xie, Shaoguang Mao, Wenshan Wu, Yan Xia, Haipeng Mi, Furu Wei | cs.CL | cs.CL | We introduce Meta-Reasoning Prompting (MRP), a novel and efficient system
prompting method for large language models (LLMs) inspired by human
meta-reasoning. Traditional in-context learning-based reasoning techniques,
such as Tree-of-Thoughts, show promise but lack consistent state-of-the-art
performance across diverse tasks due to their specialized nature. MRP addresses
this limitation by guiding LLMs to dynamically select and apply different
reasoning methods based on the specific requirements of each task, optimizing
both performance and computational efficiency. With MRP, LLM reasoning operates
in two phases. Initially, the LLM identifies the most appropriate reasoning
method using task input cues and objective descriptions of available methods.
Subsequently, it applies the chosen method to complete the task. This dynamic
strategy mirrors human meta-reasoning, allowing the model to excel in a wide
range of problem domains. We evaluate the effectiveness of MRP through
comprehensive benchmarks. The results demonstrate that MRP achieves or
approaches state-of-the-art performance across diverse tasks. MRP represents a
significant advancement in enabling LLMs to identify cognitive challenges
across problems and leverage benefits across different reasoning approaches,
enhancing their ability to handle diverse and complex problem domains
efficiently. Every LLM deserves a Meta-Reasoning Prompting to unlock its full
potential and ensure adaptability in an ever-evolving landscape of challenges
and applications. | [
-0.4780264795,
-0.7364791036,
0.7222219706,
0.2338746786,
-0.0216486454,
0.1518512666,
-0.3850823641,
-0.2298161536,
-0.0789910033,
0.2703429461,
-0.9313655496,
-0.4314589798,
-0.2525688112,
0.419157654,
0.0867921114,
0.4853150547,
0.1444767416,
-0.1739200205,
-0.3996472359,
0.0193300005,
-0.9217331409,
-0.2401110977,
-0.8424525261,
-0.5171835423,
0.6253401041,
0.7649838328,
0.4789130986,
0.3185094893,
0.142521888,
0.2898802161,
-0.1149173379,
0.6653603315,
0.0835244134,
0.5530284643,
-0.6040505767,
-0.2692924738,
-0.4546838999,
-0.2645691335,
0.5697365403,
0.6686740518,
-0.3852337897,
0.5265832543,
0.254231602,
0.6562987566,
-1.0278161764,
0.1016884372,
-0.746999979,
0.0805877745,
-0.0080666747,
-0.4078333974,
-0.7433641553,
0.0372558609,
0.0172808096,
-0.4440879226,
-0.1076965109,
-0.0999723971,
0.3984463215,
0.4084534347,
-0.3301827312,
-0.245170936,
-0.7624791265,
0.6440176368,
-0.4993830025,
0.5449589491,
0.2826938033,
0.4588471055,
-0.1887514144,
-0.6124024391,
-0.6220169663,
-0.1817142665,
0.1065904349,
-0.0625351071,
-0.1016517356,
-0.0773801059,
0.5176164508,
-0.1650755554,
-0.728303194,
-0.1260260046,
0.1314105242,
-0.0467791781,
0.3132323325,
0.3477753699,
0.17639561,
-0.2775193453,
-0.0568189658,
0.0082104923,
-0.7670764327,
0.0505623147,
-0.0213206932,
0.4866520464,
0.2403375655,
0.3495002985,
-0.3238946199,
0.9022302628,
0.0665436685,
-0.2768123746,
-0.0311759952,
-0.0543999039,
-0.2955049574,
-0.2960677445,
0.9064866304,
0.115171656,
0.3247126639,
0.270113796,
-0.2104843855,
-0.3716827333,
0.1338974535,
-0.3723847866,
0.0524040945,
0.2602245212,
-0.4757892191,
-0.0826517344,
-0.1689865589,
-1.1142793894,
-0.2046636343,
-0.2921819985,
0.3435180187,
-0.4874951243,
-0.4450258911,
0.3011840582,
0.060379263,
0.141420573,
0.3430342376,
-1.2674888372,
-0.0402028188,
0.7551836371,
0.6254623532,
0.1299912632,
-0.2708328366,
-0.4810328484,
0.459554255,
-0.1958875209,
0.8464360833,
-0.9976351261,
-0.3684314787,
-0.003988076,
-0.2241449952,
-0.2421785593,
-0.7905397415,
0.8410579562,
-0.4803242385,
0.1975244582,
-0.6201241016,
-0.009443948,
-0.2095032334,
0.5766099095,
-0.3625579178,
1.1885153055,
-0.0971818417,
-0.6893849373,
0.3885917366,
-0.9312752485,
-0.4203501046,
0.2443077713,
-0.1622725576,
-0.0146175036,
0.0453977138,
0.5358303785,
0.3930616379,
-0.3842835128,
0.3860275149,
-0.3554926813,
-0.0879665688,
0.0861503631,
-0.5354965925,
0.7084002495,
0.5046463013,
-0.2509934902,
0.1455405653,
-0.5504034758,
0.3536092639,
0.2481191605,
-0.4503112733,
-0.2871133387,
0.2275061905,
-0.3262996078,
0.3798885047,
0.1698064804,
-0.1031398624,
0.5583377481,
-0.0758918747,
0.6460115314,
0.7260671258,
-0.1333888471,
0.1242508218,
-0.024271274,
0.7198365331,
-0.233572796,
0.0956852734,
-0.6721376181,
-0.4821520448,
-0.4693842232,
-0.3973190784,
0.3116798699,
0.9460217953,
-0.8218466043,
0.5486822724,
-0.1992265582,
-0.0317106657,
-0.2855430841,
-0.1169381142,
0.23991175,
0.5328107476,
0.4231389761,
0.2631697953,
-0.6192714572,
-0.7580554485,
-0.5143717527,
-0.1738728136,
-0.0963437259,
0.5022768378,
0.5001758337,
-0.4540908635,
1.0994626284,
-0.5505539179,
0.141125381,
-0.4355970323,
0.2470807582,
0.1750717461,
0.2941698134,
0.1864479929,
-0.5161216259,
-0.619592011,
-0.1692047119,
-0.761100769,
-0.5300272703,
-0.2062779814,
-0.0181147233,
0.2259107381,
0.5793767571,
-0.8425488472,
-0.0083407639,
0.4570568502,
-0.3102455139,
0.8072417974,
-0.1781452894,
0.2686514556,
-1.0246317387,
0.3743983209,
-0.3862086535,
-0.372564584,
-0.346491009,
0.2229811549,
0.0444289967,
-0.3566756845,
-0.1309846044,
0.6100285649,
-0.4617854655,
0.0724437237,
-0.3351687193,
-0.0719693825,
-0.0496202298,
0.365227133,
0.2683401406,
0.7504987717,
0.5890488029,
-0.7324883938,
0.5024024844,
0.07865455,
-0.0644591451,
0.7370844483,
-0.5003922582,
0.0941959321,
-0.115362525,
0.5747954845,
-0.876650095,
-0.1601810455,
0.3690977991,
-0.4403474927,
0.3537858427,
-0.1418881267,
-0.7499483824,
-0.6954900622,
0.0797203332,
0.4640956521,
0.3689534366,
-0.581276536,
0.8532980084,
-0.0451175794,
-0.2108732611,
-0.8851513267,
-0.4515859485,
0.4033375084,
-0.1814072281,
-0.6383894682,
0.0975334942,
-0.0296091847,
-0.0201519709,
-0.1700376421,
-0.0735052228,
0.0846115872,
0.0361486003,
0.039899122,
0.1006614119,
-0.1864217669,
0.3213834465,
0.1658978015,
-0.4844366908,
0.2446834594,
-0.5999162793,
0.684974134,
-0.0845028982,
-0.6544789076,
-0.5215947628,
0.5095470548,
0.6465720534,
-0.3912260532,
0.5625214577,
0.5644601583,
-0.3723343611,
-0.4716319442,
-0.5625447631,
-0.3824799657,
-0.4850814044,
0.1922898442,
-0.7995599508,
-0.7612923384,
0.3526597917,
-0.39213866,
0.14819628,
0.3601802289,
0.6857308745,
-0.0706499144,
1.2121305466,
0.4053040147,
0.1116947532,
0.4356432557,
-0.0488997474,
0.0571714565,
-0.9300941825,
-0.3279780447,
-0.5709335804,
-0.2193192691,
-0.1216557398,
-0.6471982598,
0.3515961766,
-0.0972796381,
-0.1109193638,
0.1397126913,
-0.567038238,
0.6280521154,
0.5270476937,
0.0146642104,
0.3021976352,
-0.1977097094,
-0.5777695775,
-0.0007944467,
-0.9225962758,
-0.6857042909,
0.9461467266,
0.295784235,
0.6726403236,
0.0205169711,
0.5333312154,
0.2491925955,
0.1622875333,
-0.6629567742,
0.8625371456,
0.2440541089,
-0.8188946843,
-0.3482089341,
-0.5649709702,
-0.953607738,
0.485637784,
-0.3240005672,
-0.6229329705,
-0.085862726,
0.4916744232,
-0.5519242883,
0.3923943639,
-0.4802283645,
0.9758101702,
-0.0884136632,
-0.3217428625,
-0.494905591,
-0.6700057983,
0.4955514967,
0.1897138059,
0.2788814604,
0.0580675676,
-0.1469769925,
0.398506552,
-0.0726228505,
0.8320385218,
-0.2963662446,
-0.1931897253,
0.4606651366,
0.3464567959,
0.5896181464,
0.0295199342,
-0.0658658221,
-0.1946493387,
0.0388976857,
-0.172386989,
-0.7153818011,
0.4668790996,
-0.1647569686,
-0.7685164809,
-0.3679035604,
-0.6235685945,
-0.4006415009,
0.2175910771,
0.0198797602,
0.2807471156,
-0.109403342,
0.0542555824,
0.9752904177,
-0.4786799848,
0.4150123894,
0.659027338,
-0.2930361927,
-0.5348488092,
0.7448228002,
-0.2248450518,
0.4152997434,
0.689001441,
0.4732861519,
-0.3021396697,
-0.3368405104,
-0.6210389137,
0.3602200747,
-0.8346847892,
-0.1721758246,
-0.8169568777,
0.0373239219,
-0.4371811748,
0.0445196703,
-0.1877289861,
-0.3428169191,
-0.0298858378,
0.145490706,
-0.1913457513,
0.5097980499,
-0.1982002854,
-0.0226321761,
-1.090955019,
0.4255427718,
0.7904999852,
0.2265264094,
0.1512029767,
-0.5841190815,
-0.0791890025,
-0.0795595795,
-0.6760635376,
-0.8982518315,
0.0140604088,
0.1329276711,
0.8045469522,
0.661196053,
0.0115202386,
0.6108155847,
-0.8721168041,
0.7048704028,
-0.0485208891,
-1.081371069,
0.7323858738,
-0.6038852334,
0.6586636901,
0.5233451128,
0.2312483341,
-0.8554113507,
-0.1935596168,
-0.5870521069,
-0.525262773,
0.5852704048,
-0.356743902,
0.0245625842,
-0.1630757749,
0.4796780646,
-0.0376623645,
0.1591005623,
-0.7871107459,
-0.1420690417,
0.0960893333,
-0.1560021639,
0.2303930968,
-0.4376780689,
-0.1759240627,
-0.2780575156,
0.5934284329,
-0.5074958801,
0.243781805,
0.1591954529,
-0.0056687738,
-0.354920119,
0.4573132992,
1.0362348557,
0.9401633739,
-0.0209048223,
0.2774866819,
0.6356596351,
-0.1898145676,
0.1215448603,
-0.3650176525,
-0.0992864668,
-0.1063046455,
0.5954956412,
0.4465128481,
0.0824571997,
-0.8280954361,
0.3326667547,
0.1549189985,
-0.3306480646,
0.0832168013,
0.1309846193,
0.3297227919,
0.3939590752,
0.4488296211,
-0.0420555435,
0.0578206331,
-0.6341608167,
0.047469262,
0.7866579294,
-0.1188021749,
-0.2259766757,
0.5650994778,
0.3371949196,
-0.4487015903,
0.5169122219,
-0.1894657612,
-0.7832282782,
0.2267708182,
0.6500128508,
1.0331749916,
-0.5493208766,
0.2832973599,
0.6093022227,
0.5230684876,
-0.2108969241,
0.3285435438,
-0.4215755463,
-0.5687314868,
-0.8078001738,
-0.4336859882,
-0.5728653669,
0.1079849005,
-0.3453164697,
0.3518363833,
-0.4968911707,
-0.0982480943,
-0.4102049768,
-0.3075209856,
-0.1482399404,
0.2173131406,
0.5556894541,
1.2747251987,
-1.0097856522,
0.5986864567,
0.6358350515,
0.0048227301,
-0.5751402378,
0.1883841902,
0.0866863281,
-0.7112753391,
0.7651333213,
0.1607240289,
-0.3633067608,
-0.2154208571,
-0.5595443845,
-0.7057560682,
1.0379664898,
0.4441399276,
-0.503064096,
0.0137552274,
0.0791677833,
0.3538725078,
-0.508589685,
0.2752636373,
0.3828518391,
0.8351128697,
0.5069937706,
-0.930132091,
0.3279633224,
0.1603845507,
-0.2439752966,
0.312406987,
-0.5485983491,
0.5826301575,
-0.53202492,
-0.2372409254,
-0.2742325068,
0.6056929231,
0.7583317161,
0.4189455807,
0.8224198222,
0.6971785426,
0.8598197103,
0.0743398145,
0.6749917269,
-0.1514539272,
0.090579316,
1.0023459196,
-0.3727925122,
0.9385855794,
0.4794004261,
-0.3044425249,
0.842867136,
0.7857592106,
0.2757018209,
0.2679629028,
0.0445367731,
-0.4053938389,
-0.7018849254,
0.188055709,
-0.3952611089,
0.2262178063,
0.5386881232,
-0.1994125694,
-0.2980787456,
0.0354269855,
-0.0088313809,
-0.0531623736,
-0.1045470536,
0.6489229202,
0.1524000466,
-1.0573406219,
0.619333446,
0.0847281069,
0.4500079155,
-0.7187058926,
-0.0586541444,
0.1885364205,
0.0506039485,
-0.3018611372,
-0.7620781064,
0.4596422017,
-0.0672999099,
-0.4414806664,
-0.6252399683,
0.5801161528,
-0.4431076348,
-0.2204160094,
0.1351953,
0.5950021744,
0.0028529835,
-0.2785212398,
-1.0494462252,
-0.0312658623,
0.0262054801,
-0.2968230844,
0.1387580484,
0.7885959744,
-0.1295031756,
1.1694139242,
0.7597610354,
-0.00753826,
-0.2816643417,
0.1540853381,
0.7622820139,
-0.7766590714,
-0.4671263695,
-1.1507722139,
0.596963048,
0.1356245875,
0.0074841683,
0.511475563,
0.3498613834,
0.2920964658,
-0.1624802649,
0.744538188,
-0.0998777226,
0.7347322106,
-0.5547067523,
0.2036516666,
-0.5977168679,
0.3908770382,
-0.2552275956,
-0.974522233,
-0.2814828753,
0.5563762188,
-0.3632603586,
0.2453826964,
1.0082722902,
0.6388593316,
-0.1585554481,
-0.068781063,
0.2045850456,
-0.1595858634,
0.3828951418,
0.7608543634,
0.9998531938,
0.1850696951,
0.6695775986,
0.3981176317,
-0.4316307604,
-0.3744255602,
-1.1942853928,
-0.9224345684,
-0.4737519324,
-0.1567135453,
-0.2485983372,
-0.1265729815,
1.2773947716,
0.8824239373,
-0.6688598394,
-0.1803947836,
-0.0654099956,
0.454485327,
-0.4927380979,
-0.2745757997,
-0.070667468,
-0.5964382291,
-0.5526468158,
0.5497120619,
0.4084019959,
-0.3034515977,
-0.4076845348,
0.0178033654,
-0.3901706636,
0.2781755328,
0.7204444408,
0.4385624826,
-0.7937229276,
-0.2099801302,
-0.0609345809,
-0.1184415594,
-0.1430286318,
1.1553285122,
-0.847736001,
0.2945127189,
0.8255384564,
0.5539129972,
0.196135655,
-0.0343599431,
0.6356457472,
-0.5706657767,
-0.0710242763,
0.2371165156,
0.2622441053,
0.2591871917,
-0.2442894131,
0.3805703223,
0.4178952277,
-0.7023756504,
-1.0123170614,
0.676214993,
-0.6526606083,
-0.4874775708,
1.0881516933,
0.0290372651,
0.0115224058,
-0.0934595242,
-0.2567929327,
-0.1038753539,
-0.4123798013,
0.6629501581,
0.8607512116,
-0.3027915061,
-0.5108588934,
-0.6277703643,
0.4989925921,
0.5781043768,
-0.9364195466,
0.5202142,
0.3694484234,
0.3826482892,
0.2287538201,
0.5497122407,
0.0722165406,
0.1838927567,
-0.1769051999,
0.1093364432,
-0.195870176,
-0.7355975509,
-0.2629505396,
0.2963469326,
-0.031821806,
-0.0405097008
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11695v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11695v1 | Optimizing Instructions and Demonstrations for Multi-Stage Language Model Programs | 2024-06-17T16:12:03 | 2024-06-17T16:12:03 | Krista Opsahl-Ong, Michael J Ryan, Josh Purtell, David Broman, Christopher Potts, Matei Zaharia, Omar Khattab | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Language Model Programs, i.e. sophisticated pipelines of modular language
model (LM) calls, are increasingly advancing NLP tasks, but they require
crafting prompts that are jointly effective for all modules. We study prompt
optimization for LM programs, i.e. how to update these prompts to maximize a
downstream metric without access to module-level labels or gradients. To make
this tractable, we factorize our problem into optimizing the free-form
instructions and few-shot demonstrations of every module and introduce several
strategies to craft task-grounded instructions and navigate credit assignment
across modules. Our strategies include (i) program- and data-aware techniques
for proposing effective instructions, (ii) a stochastic mini-batch evaluation
function for learning a surrogate model of our objective, and (iii) a
meta-optimization procedure in which we refine how LMs construct proposals over
time. Using these insights we develop MIPRO, a novel optimizer that outperforms
baselines on five of six diverse LM programs using a best-in-class open-source
model (Llama-3-8B), by as high as 12.9% accuracy. We will release our new
optimizers and benchmark in DSPy at https://github.com/stanfordnlp/dspy | [
-0.2284344435,
-0.7347896099,
0.6672330499,
0.4476107955,
-0.0443655737,
0.0312234946,
-0.3023971021,
0.1185886264,
-0.2054282129,
0.4028812647,
-0.9205960035,
-0.7028137445,
-0.2733157873,
-0.0007429675,
-0.1198259443,
0.9878320098,
0.0854679644,
0.0013451354,
-0.3767230213,
-0.0381827205,
-0.3699349165,
-0.0640633032,
-0.7567512989,
-0.3264383972,
0.6666272879,
0.7092115879,
0.2865180671,
0.6325880289,
0.1906357855,
0.2226736099,
-0.0594599359,
0.3397898376,
-0.0606710166,
0.2463564575,
-0.0200262237,
-0.3987861276,
-0.3184108436,
-0.1950427294,
0.6100156307,
0.647774756,
-0.1928633302,
0.3738859594,
0.0830973908,
0.5958123803,
-0.7844228745,
0.3656591475,
-0.4071240723,
-0.1354225725,
-0.0124212606,
-0.4041878283,
-0.717507422,
-0.4759559333,
-0.0653917938,
-0.4272030592,
-0.0212869141,
-0.062289726,
0.3876656294,
0.1050202996,
-0.1300572008,
-0.2882541716,
-0.5651615262,
0.9497804642,
-0.9266065955,
-0.1343212724,
0.1125839502,
0.3331932425,
-0.4081940353,
-0.5739732385,
-0.0944309607,
-0.7094619274,
0.1456323564,
0.0445132032,
-0.2728052139,
0.3922930956,
0.4501484931,
0.0381961912,
-0.5318425894,
0.3725297451,
-0.3266432285,
-0.1474360079,
0.4172031283,
0.2550136745,
0.2974284887,
-0.1043192148,
-0.3234241307,
-0.0605417565,
-0.6104277372,
0.1932112873,
0.5738601089,
0.5755949616,
0.072014384,
0.6624212861,
-0.4212576449,
0.7546887398,
-0.0835390761,
-0.0394645035,
0.0145118022,
-0.2202456445,
0.0440168455,
-0.2201986164,
0.7037833929,
0.2967767119,
-0.0624050014,
0.190016374,
-0.4969270825,
-0.0976286456,
0.2618351281,
-0.625074625,
-0.0170725007,
0.3729943335,
-0.4057221413,
-0.2599282563,
-0.2450824678,
-0.5998131633,
-0.1335807592,
-0.5248491168,
0.8322430849,
-0.336522758,
0.0541007556,
0.1332556754,
-0.0747351646,
0.119483754,
0.2729997039,
-0.970795095,
0.3173407316,
0.8310046196,
0.8314025998,
-0.0299122278,
-0.253842175,
-1.0126485825,
-0.0428632237,
-0.3786201775,
0.5755006075,
-0.4607623518,
-0.2889208794,
0.0443016924,
-0.1753239632,
-0.3507820368,
-0.3456729352,
0.5549742579,
-0.1297279447,
0.2698167861,
0.0330388322,
-0.5214120746,
-0.0012938952,
-0.0864058509,
-0.5865927935,
0.9893109798,
0.0964761302,
-0.5408223867,
-0.0879701376,
-1.078473568,
-0.0882578194,
-0.0637755245,
-0.0388786308,
-0.1302778274,
0.4213599861,
0.3657441139,
0.5013740063,
-0.0275308844,
0.1831060201,
-0.0288780872,
-0.5151382089,
-0.0042790398,
-0.2988350391,
0.718134284,
0.1191469952,
-0.4168075621,
0.5498085022,
-0.6898185015,
-0.0136281354,
-0.0538138077,
-0.443367064,
-0.1249427125,
0.0894952491,
-0.2959371805,
0.0268274639,
0.0821827725,
-0.2553379834,
0.5632908344,
-0.3362998664,
0.4469479322,
0.8347924352,
-0.249579221,
0.4703501165,
-0.3077691495,
0.8388436437,
-0.2003358901,
0.4763810635,
-0.7542567849,
-0.5931318402,
-0.9118791223,
-0.1936069131,
-0.0541404448,
0.4715344012,
-0.5938631296,
0.1552483141,
0.1483359784,
-0.4284307659,
-0.6210129857,
0.0246700551,
0.2579927146,
0.5244425535,
0.4743447006,
-0.0480808578,
-0.2651329935,
-1.216329813,
-0.2377223074,
-0.0804183334,
0.0879415572,
0.0161507819,
0.321385622,
-0.0612559617,
0.6743134856,
-0.3895739913,
0.2191528827,
-0.6429190636,
0.4733150005,
0.6565849781,
0.4930486679,
0.4057898819,
-0.1451388597,
-0.358733356,
-0.1962392926,
-0.0938407034,
-0.6355744004,
-0.4376541972,
-0.0673522428,
0.2710460424,
0.3971357644,
-0.6929879785,
0.0665389895,
0.5188115835,
0.0715237185,
0.8934818506,
-0.4366523623,
-0.0422367901,
-0.8039046526,
0.0412762165,
-0.0756517574,
-0.1547017395,
-0.672431469,
0.2501328588,
0.1595315635,
-0.2248895317,
-0.4673884511,
0.484806776,
-0.524762392,
0.0552669205,
-0.4134077728,
0.1645947695,
0.0103986003,
0.6858670115,
-0.0978938937,
0.7391871214,
0.7705515027,
-0.5360713601,
0.165476352,
-0.1947624534,
-0.4616677165,
0.2460654974,
-0.5838567019,
0.2904548943,
-0.2987613678,
0.1958549172,
-0.888120532,
0.1359792203,
0.350259304,
-0.1243528277,
0.3574070632,
-0.1977657229,
-0.1436883509,
-0.2318184227,
-0.6494153142,
0.1269174665,
0.3785403371,
-0.4448520541,
0.5212045312,
-0.1301023811,
-0.2758506835,
-0.8676382303,
-0.3276428282,
-0.0133907776,
-0.2465523481,
-0.2958465219,
0.2791206241,
-0.2513453066,
-0.0951831341,
-0.2604647577,
-0.1693908274,
0.1702384949,
0.1401821673,
0.0635023043,
0.2312233299,
-0.2954151928,
0.0198316667,
0.2961848676,
-0.4386232495,
0.1386405379,
-0.5165551305,
0.5989092588,
-0.0223573651,
-0.5940929651,
-0.7498213649,
0.595610857,
0.4190578163,
0.0206891354,
0.5596145391,
0.6038038731,
-0.1505941451,
-0.5178740621,
-0.3640478551,
-0.1939922571,
-0.4716295004,
0.3917533159,
-0.3995864689,
-0.6453337669,
0.1365010291,
-0.1388763934,
0.4720636308,
0.1638794541,
0.4595959485,
0.1519234329,
1.1555948257,
0.5810762644,
0.1025753841,
0.5999973416,
-0.2090399116,
0.1098156869,
-0.7545389533,
-0.1833226979,
-0.779659152,
-0.2131164223,
-0.2074568868,
-0.8073282242,
0.2918350697,
0.377641499,
-0.0180963352,
0.5955963731,
-0.2094980925,
0.6251815557,
1.0238066912,
-0.0384084359,
0.0387704782,
-0.1124436855,
-0.3650101125,
-0.1560204625,
-0.9448623061,
-0.7670073509,
0.8525419831,
0.410571754,
0.7105683684,
-0.211350143,
0.7998785377,
0.2720947564,
0.0972500518,
-0.7492516041,
0.6088191867,
-0.1433097422,
-0.1696261764,
-0.1138710827,
-0.3924967349,
-0.504984796,
0.1043295786,
-0.0169316065,
-0.8819604516,
-0.2067718655,
0.2973535657,
-0.4096731246,
0.082617335,
-0.5693737268,
1.0825346708,
-0.1591174304,
-0.2640111148,
-0.4822199941,
-0.6771485209,
0.2094700038,
0.1040084213,
0.1874515265,
-0.2242731601,
-0.0912392437,
0.3171496093,
-0.3341154456,
0.7148008347,
-0.3901622295,
-0.2397493571,
0.214999631,
-0.0225306153,
0.4926018417,
-0.223041296,
-0.1462640464,
-0.2346276641,
-0.0159378294,
-0.2942999899,
-0.662096262,
0.5339143872,
-0.3656309843,
-0.655397296,
0.1340082288,
-0.5459094644,
-0.0393206403,
-0.1749961972,
-0.0906320736,
0.8346164823,
-0.0087418696,
0.0804788321,
0.4656354189,
-0.8046884537,
0.7260065675,
0.1834380925,
-0.1934515536,
-0.2266727835,
0.8957881331,
-0.2842507064,
0.6467828751,
0.609313488,
0.5387839675,
-0.2863276601,
-0.6986764669,
-0.5953081846,
0.1388974637,
-0.900306344,
-0.0965614393,
-0.5539685488,
0.0360991694,
-0.285009861,
-0.0258304495,
-0.2815060616,
-0.8774271607,
-0.1440480798,
-0.0771631151,
0.0329464674,
0.4740256071,
-0.2225680649,
0.5353799462,
-0.8126447797,
0.052115418,
0.2353089899,
-0.1096728668,
-0.0304861274,
-0.3670713902,
-0.300345391,
-0.0373279192,
-0.3282933831,
-0.8058092594,
0.1967180669,
0.3262436986,
0.8473981619,
0.4134744704,
0.0164167508,
0.5671752095,
-0.5089964867,
0.804952383,
0.0648526475,
-1.1481796503,
0.9474931359,
-0.4480614066,
0.3966493011,
0.3745037615,
0.2848388553,
-0.5568581223,
-0.6797683239,
-0.2932367921,
-0.8985594511,
0.9876616597,
0.0155826705,
0.4772568345,
-0.0641758367,
0.3095641732,
0.2845193744,
0.2708621919,
-0.5393664241,
-0.188266173,
0.1911005527,
-0.3246754408,
0.1548184752,
-0.3147163093,
-0.2041726708,
-0.0278925765,
0.6741907597,
-0.459076196,
0.0674007833,
-0.1281101555,
-0.0829524547,
0.1973495483,
0.4522786736,
1.0983263254,
0.8325073123,
-0.0550320037,
-0.0266447235,
0.0302399993,
-0.2341507524,
-0.046175167,
-0.0373197682,
-0.3287392557,
0.1602695882,
0.463504225,
1.0644245148,
0.2024591714,
-0.6646597385,
0.4679020345,
0.1062951684,
-0.1132855937,
0.1054351926,
0.3238034844,
0.1633618921,
0.533839345,
0.3661552966,
-0.0584023967,
0.1123513058,
-0.3660308421,
0.0933583751,
0.2816080749,
-0.1108864993,
-0.2911081314,
0.6749667525,
0.1451368183,
-0.5302092433,
0.4130491614,
-0.013243841,
-0.4026751816,
0.573625505,
0.5605382919,
0.9722251296,
-0.2524043918,
0.6582474113,
0.4697405696,
0.2835835218,
-0.2621524036,
0.1739825308,
-0.2924684882,
-0.3832033873,
-0.667820096,
-0.6134454012,
-0.597418189,
-0.073343806,
-0.6049080491,
0.5535290837,
-0.4269792438,
-0.0777442679,
-0.290915072,
0.0075287367,
-0.2840735614,
-0.1518692523,
0.2741452456,
1.0944335461,
-0.7978377342,
0.6778839231,
0.4543520212,
-0.2545247972,
-0.7190334201,
-0.3068904281,
0.0484576114,
-0.7243523002,
0.534776926,
0.562122345,
-0.1857100129,
0.0868314952,
-0.4971503019,
-0.3299436271,
0.8227775693,
0.6020619273,
-0.7117320895,
-0.1166397631,
-0.0680319667,
0.1198434755,
-0.5664046407,
0.4947951734,
0.3530076742,
0.4135516584,
-0.1047359854,
-0.6655494571,
-0.1080120727,
-0.0587166026,
0.0150685208,
0.0501270816,
-0.385298878,
0.6545597315,
-0.418150425,
-0.1417463571,
0.3094293177,
0.5858062506,
0.5601550341,
0.2210458219,
0.6350421906,
0.3105974495,
0.5506613851,
-0.032210581,
0.8875326514,
-0.2299171686,
0.1757118702,
1.1159232855,
0.0153499339,
0.7336831689,
0.7104116082,
-0.0166798979,
0.5615670681,
0.7291371822,
0.102721408,
0.5593887568,
0.5723178387,
-0.4447554946,
-0.1844149828,
-0.1734942347,
0.05162967,
0.1368207633,
0.2931885421,
-0.261570245,
-0.2907915711,
0.0247640237,
-0.0225138217,
-0.0350887887,
-0.1712371409,
0.4849039018,
0.0355936252,
-0.6581344008,
0.2749460638,
0.1887263656,
0.5010414124,
-0.83745718,
-0.037805602,
-0.4600017667,
0.050573539,
-0.0787747353,
-0.2792951167,
0.2318705618,
0.0507998057,
0.0466229133,
-0.4821995795,
0.4603417814,
-0.5186986327,
-0.2637706697,
0.2542113066,
0.4613674879,
0.3161034584,
0.0848983824,
-0.7840320468,
0.0687263235,
-0.1466653347,
-0.4429937899,
0.0722248629,
0.1964041591,
-0.0774321333,
0.8816900253,
0.5117937922,
0.2686654925,
0.218554914,
0.6680470705,
0.7391088009,
-0.4927866459,
-0.0868545398,
-0.9479900599,
0.8135394454,
0.06346035,
-0.1638781577,
0.4825407863,
0.4677288234,
0.7029840946,
-0.2622303665,
0.4396998882,
0.1491872072,
0.121601142,
-0.86550349,
0.1648811102,
-0.5335558057,
0.3997837901,
-0.3303405344,
-1.2597022057,
-0.2889100611,
0.5603487492,
0.0899883807,
-0.0913187414,
0.7025313973,
1.0636343956,
-0.0102294041,
-0.0133751938,
0.1337742209,
-0.3292452693,
0.2949749231,
0.7754510045,
1.1787743568,
-0.1162814796,
0.4402571023,
-0.3291406333,
-0.3321747482,
-0.0882602856,
-1.1509987116,
-0.7419669628,
-0.3494106829,
-0.6042875648,
0.1269682944,
0.0946990699,
1.2654297352,
0.7163675427,
-0.63113451,
-0.5704133511,
-0.0031723932,
0.1412262022,
-0.5414649844,
-0.1924822479,
0.2494465262,
-0.913914144,
-0.957722187,
0.937857151,
0.4832728505,
-0.1317757964,
-0.3755163848,
-0.0425310321,
-0.1492451876,
0.1043046787,
0.533251524,
0.0034176349,
-0.6051228642,
-0.2803365588,
0.161728099,
-0.0852620453,
-0.0195121747,
1.1181848049,
-0.3608399928,
0.34818542,
0.5783296824,
0.7014167905,
0.2412541956,
0.1479735523,
0.8691521883,
-0.8766329885,
-0.0375367142,
0.1017749682,
0.2018209249,
0.3485531509,
0.0418111272,
0.3298445344,
-0.0554570109,
-0.5233371258,
-0.8302072287,
0.2326315045,
-0.8646551371,
-0.3648100793,
1.0223944187,
-0.3049173653,
-0.1497377157,
0.1323488206,
-0.3674892485,
0.1320385039,
-0.4064158499,
0.5444620848,
0.6709992886,
-0.4017329812,
-0.4176379442,
-0.9487887621,
0.4848371744,
0.4408465326,
-0.6525774598,
0.2676907182,
0.6190834045,
0.0371230356,
0.0137748299,
0.6945937872,
0.1123318672,
0.0020700865,
-0.1154479459,
-0.0680757016,
-0.1953942329,
-0.6661912799,
-0.5910528898,
0.1171912104,
0.1505098343,
-0.4492760003
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11687v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11687v1 | Tokenization Falling Short: The Curse of Tokenization | 2024-06-17T16:05:32 | 2024-06-17T16:05:32 | Yekun Chai, Yewei Fang, Qiwei Peng, Xuhong Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | Language models typically tokenize raw text into sequences of subword
identifiers from a predefined vocabulary, a process inherently sensitive to
typographical errors, length variations, and largely oblivious to the internal
structure of tokens-issues we term the curse of tokenization. In this study, we
delve into these drawbacks and demonstrate that large language models (LLMs)
remain susceptible to these problems. This study systematically investigates
these challenges and their impact on LLMs through three critical research
questions: (1) complex problem solving, (2) token structure probing, and (3)
resilience to typographical variation. Our findings reveal that scaling model
parameters can mitigate the issue of tokenization; however, LLMs still suffer
from biases induced by typos and other text format variations. Our experiments
show that subword regularization such as BPE-dropout can mitigate this issue.
We will release our code and data to facilitate further research. | [
-0.1215056926,
-0.8028686047,
0.5615836978,
0.0793685988,
-0.4417783618,
0.2617834806,
-0.1469078362,
-0.5108292699,
0.1278814673,
0.5038545728,
-0.3435299098,
-0.0051754736,
-0.9294210672,
0.2196789533,
-0.337248683,
1.2663476467,
-0.1093469635,
0.1056055576,
-0.3155241907,
-0.0687295645,
-0.8073373437,
-0.8688050508,
-0.7125304341,
-0.1635242254,
0.5152573586,
0.3439385891,
0.7150914073,
0.6791294813,
0.912486732,
0.1552674323,
-0.3671225905,
-0.1228037477,
-0.6150839329,
0.0481046811,
-0.1048798561,
-0.8215675354,
-0.1892194152,
0.009245907,
0.8261393309,
1.0201009512,
0.193559885,
0.2985198796,
-0.103613928,
0.6142318845,
-0.4499656856,
-0.0592751019,
-0.7653605342,
-0.0926904753,
-0.6759036183,
0.0553600639,
-0.4698975086,
-0.0728818327,
0.0432488434,
-0.1994520873,
0.2895048261,
0.3538245559,
0.923058629,
0.3571621776,
-0.3115469813,
-0.4357983172,
-0.6749465466,
0.8141056895,
-0.7975718379,
0.2356957495,
0.3681398332,
-0.0541149303,
-0.1518184692,
-0.6815630794,
-0.3493689895,
-0.3699444532,
0.1737584919,
-0.2680979669,
-0.0434399508,
0.0848910958,
0.2376568019,
0.4833555818,
-0.2000315338,
0.3678816557,
-0.5959376097,
-0.3147436976,
0.0871246979,
0.3701098859,
0.6052008867,
-0.4475590587,
-0.2063916475,
0.1852216423,
-0.8279405832,
-0.0499828495,
0.4811281264,
0.5415952206,
0.157365948,
0.6988755465,
0.5941804647,
0.3300186694,
-0.1518342793,
-0.0231611058,
-0.1449442506,
-0.3390429616,
-0.1826349348,
-0.1995943934,
0.4230388105,
0.2166683227,
0.3656485081,
-0.2299094349,
-0.2565909624,
-0.1638565361,
0.1737497151,
-0.6355763674,
0.0307142735,
0.2689701915,
-0.6178201437,
-0.2176520377,
-0.0230772924,
-0.4930076301,
-0.5369372964,
-0.0067881378,
0.2507877946,
-0.4198727012,
-0.0878744125,
0.0524640083,
-0.3980075121,
-0.107922174,
0.1209256947,
-0.9724997878,
0.3373430669,
0.7210330367,
1.0448120832,
-0.3469846547,
-0.1799747348,
-0.3621985316,
0.0759215802,
-0.3914609849,
0.3731155396,
-0.5965768695,
-0.6534805298,
-0.1604019254,
0.0090244245,
-0.1756605506,
-0.6922896504,
0.5926943421,
-0.2817578912,
-0.0000551219,
-0.2768287659,
-0.7247504592,
0.2209272236,
0.1093876064,
-0.6899796724,
0.7836011648,
0.0861087739,
-1.0155736208,
0.289511025,
-0.3616485596,
-0.3439644873,
0.0811816677,
-0.1294824481,
-0.3909745812,
0.8603671789,
-0.108445242,
0.175911963,
-0.4380781651,
0.0628442615,
-0.1416236609,
-0.4694329798,
0.2499241531,
-0.4764183462,
0.4250189662,
-0.0600742809,
-0.1595235914,
-0.1241479516,
-0.7651456594,
-0.1494124979,
0.4187469184,
-0.5086212754,
-0.6030646563,
-0.0052450579,
0.3765494227,
0.0378347374,
0.2910657227,
-0.4441754222,
0.3370997012,
-0.4380397201,
0.6600449085,
0.8902660012,
-0.1073350161,
0.351626128,
-0.2488241792,
0.680949688,
0.2472014874,
0.4087099731,
-0.0449764542,
-0.4207288325,
-0.7768363357,
-0.119136937,
0.6413447261,
0.3793628216,
-0.5721788406,
-0.0477633439,
-0.3751938343,
-0.2508606315,
-0.2782718241,
-0.1273379624,
0.5046742558,
0.273583442,
0.0577463061,
-0.4674165249,
-0.4706826508,
-0.9469213486,
-0.4152204394,
-0.2406981438,
0.0565519966,
0.2041129023,
0.7512376904,
-0.1468906701,
1.0804296732,
-0.3648181558,
-0.3823587894,
-0.3003824949,
0.1345995069,
0.0380282588,
0.6164919734,
0.5998057127,
-0.6181772947,
-0.1385768801,
-0.2959412634,
-0.0802132785,
-0.1492878199,
0.012635312,
0.4374254048,
0.4891798496,
0.585051775,
-0.6001396775,
0.4847028852,
0.5685616136,
-0.4350770116,
0.9044417143,
-0.0467884131,
-0.3215951622,
-1.1253808737,
0.1712816656,
-0.3730828166,
0.0184439737,
-0.5893323421,
-0.0421759076,
-0.0549375862,
-0.077093482,
-0.2170574665,
0.5461006761,
-0.4576430917,
-0.0862698406,
-0.239996478,
-0.165451318,
0.0423765816,
0.035084933,
-0.2202456892,
0.8593357205,
0.248298496,
-0.3654675782,
-0.0073399679,
-0.0940324441,
-0.1714730859,
0.2081745118,
-0.7788435221,
0.1312247813,
-0.298325032,
0.2056975812,
-0.9487462044,
-0.2424176782,
-0.025593916,
-0.4105080962,
0.4804671705,
-0.3439725041,
-0.7541770339,
-0.4900069833,
-0.3244028389,
0.6859601736,
0.2646294236,
-0.2466516644,
0.2960247993,
0.2263548821,
-0.0885817856,
-0.5298144817,
-0.8657548428,
0.3957049251,
-0.3076252341,
-0.495123893,
0.1692112684,
-0.1888325661,
-0.4011418223,
-0.0499111935,
-0.1975534409,
0.1384050399,
0.1398265064,
0.2290497422,
0.2040859312,
-0.129298389,
0.3968628943,
-0.241719082,
0.0866563618,
0.097366102,
-0.3660318553,
0.7719397545,
-0.1176313311,
-0.313047111,
-0.2563790679,
0.3522880077,
0.8440926075,
-0.0638523698,
0.9604151249,
0.2554762959,
-0.4727209806,
-0.131645754,
-0.7033004165,
-0.0679992214,
-0.4418054223,
0.5178343654,
-0.4247568548,
-0.9788556099,
0.8512691259,
0.0511116497,
-0.0806237459,
0.3976110816,
0.3467697203,
0.1632161736,
0.7728503346,
0.9254621267,
-0.064567782,
0.531445682,
-0.0042818296,
0.5319336057,
-0.7553572059,
-0.0912956819,
-0.4697912037,
-0.1053177789,
-0.5908151865,
-0.4956243038,
0.264434427,
0.231219992,
0.1890748441,
0.0578870326,
-0.2767079473,
0.6088446975,
0.436303705,
-0.3169373572,
0.2028654218,
-0.2487598807,
-0.2414170504,
-0.4003811181,
-0.5563308001,
-0.672719419,
0.9768960476,
0.5670905709,
0.630438149,
0.0294205621,
0.5555118322,
0.3044401109,
0.0785633698,
-0.7672132254,
0.217918396,
-0.2537008226,
-0.7187687755,
-0.3672069907,
-0.4920479655,
-0.8753235936,
0.0737971887,
0.0101035815,
-0.817348063,
0.1865039617,
0.0741457343,
-0.2494043559,
0.5574874282,
-0.7559886575,
0.825063765,
-0.1374754757,
-0.1184208691,
0.1778222173,
-0.7293511629,
0.3431420922,
-0.3421686292,
0.5183058381,
-0.2193604261,
-0.0664537102,
0.8361318111,
-0.6953309178,
0.9336544275,
0.1391033083,
-0.2908259928,
0.2005649805,
0.239350751,
0.6261936426,
0.0268330574,
0.1704443097,
0.0374859683,
0.1457174569,
-0.7559274435,
-0.3859072328,
0.4847132564,
-0.5575637817,
-0.5907181501,
-0.2665632069,
-0.4906013906,
-0.370590359,
0.1883458495,
0.6081141829,
0.5062143803,
-0.1267501414,
-0.0082463892,
0.519616127,
-0.3250117004,
0.6262081265,
0.0858060345,
-0.3014787138,
-0.3666720092,
0.9307279587,
0.4921311736,
0.5576836467,
0.0312012359,
0.3031966388,
-0.0841680169,
-0.9325512052,
-0.100789085,
0.4063313901,
-0.7637435794,
-0.0230456982,
-0.3135706782,
-0.1217030212,
-0.5842918754,
0.0316397138,
-0.4757777452,
-0.5557605624,
-0.6415051222,
-0.1520314366,
0.112273477,
1.0167438984,
0.0434453115,
0.2301261872,
-0.7824180126,
-0.0347114652,
0.1312836558,
0.471357137,
0.1404328644,
-0.8145931363,
-0.2825836241,
-0.4068586826,
0.0060118372,
-0.5355769396,
0.1143852249,
0.0581491664,
0.0735123754,
0.3796580434,
-0.1299765557,
0.5461134315,
-0.7633565068,
1.0132814646,
0.3302096128,
-1.0716081858,
0.3409001231,
-0.4228353798,
0.298011899,
0.4664690197,
0.0407122113,
-0.8358719945,
-0.5062340498,
-0.4967266321,
-1.1004670858,
0.434912771,
0.2284917533,
0.5062769651,
-0.3847972453,
0.7301399112,
0.2665231526,
0.1055574566,
-0.6868834496,
-0.2531637251,
-0.0381305665,
-0.0315197222,
0.0335240327,
-0.7873934507,
0.1084813029,
-0.0157891847,
0.4031995833,
-0.0967050046,
-0.1981431842,
0.0121976836,
-0.1797385067,
-0.0502373129,
0.285092473,
0.8292928934,
0.737701714,
0.0530871041,
0.1939403564,
0.037412975,
-0.6476918459,
-0.0880634487,
-0.2409226447,
-0.1252186894,
0.1102289706,
0.5366025567,
0.8731104136,
0.156837061,
-0.8766692281,
0.5439099073,
-0.0737244859,
0.0212276857,
-0.2668528557,
-0.4120319188,
0.0901442096,
-0.1039406732,
0.5817388296,
-0.0525981337,
-0.0444073305,
-0.6192062497,
-0.1039244086,
0.4634062648,
-0.3105413914,
-0.3870328367,
0.6628633142,
0.1072346047,
-0.397962898,
0.6301873326,
0.1878436059,
-0.5342850089,
0.8737076521,
0.6918434501,
0.7506173849,
0.1543746442,
-0.0288626458,
-0.1665277332,
0.7081461549,
-0.1290459931,
-0.01207761,
0.4712669551,
-0.5073155165,
-0.3926208913,
-0.8133388162,
-0.4537873864,
0.2549841106,
-0.4924808145,
0.0698099509,
-0.6654314995,
-0.551846087,
-0.2561562359,
-0.0985531509,
-0.3875749111,
0.1236970648,
0.2376999408,
0.8089925051,
-0.7488121986,
0.4505676329,
0.4191541076,
-0.6050359011,
-0.5848472118,
0.1832279116,
-0.1972922683,
-0.6963813305,
0.7527837157,
0.1681799591,
0.1747170687,
-0.0451248176,
-0.6774504781,
-1.0941492319,
0.5803920031,
0.4665603042,
-0.5906991363,
-0.2373186648,
0.4426366091,
0.6044102907,
-0.0509646088,
-0.1904785931,
0.7590388656,
0.5399364233,
-0.1254054159,
-1.2418340445,
0.1743202507,
0.0503640324,
0.4127781093,
0.3742188513,
-0.8639491796,
0.9901926517,
-0.330640316,
-0.2078847587,
0.1954502314,
0.336550951,
-0.0297863521,
0.0465459675,
0.225037992,
0.7661210299,
0.6070019007,
-0.0498846956,
1.0262807608,
-0.1709736586,
0.3517615795,
0.8900693655,
-0.1454880685,
0.6439269185,
0.9335306287,
-0.160403356,
0.143680349,
0.755323112,
-0.0321429782,
0.1360023022,
0.712890029,
-0.1168715656,
-0.0156114465,
-0.276273787,
-0.1757180542,
0.3684780896,
0.4128024578,
-0.3210300207,
-0.0175123531,
0.23649019,
0.1675015241,
0.0131295966,
-0.4228951931,
0.4696677625,
0.3444042504,
-0.2722886205,
0.3969519138,
0.1382695585,
0.835059762,
-0.3958115578,
0.2737771273,
-0.5180943608,
0.07292521,
-0.0453783646,
-0.2026904523,
0.3759329021,
-0.1093657315,
-0.4505937099,
0.0383690335,
0.5053445697,
-0.1477271467,
-0.5726027489,
0.1782434583,
0.4819182158,
0.2217525244,
0.0582953282,
-0.3415136039,
0.4525257945,
-0.4820677638,
-0.2458709031,
0.4783191383,
0.507391572,
-0.327575624,
0.7044618726,
0.4870835841,
0.2397179157,
0.4769417346,
0.3496728837,
0.6592060328,
-0.7171351314,
-0.2342768461,
-1.1307580471,
0.1016700342,
0.0764452219,
-0.4826332331,
0.7074750662,
0.5163531303,
0.6020742059,
-0.1786462665,
0.6837046146,
0.0265109632,
0.3973632753,
-0.3910298347,
0.818598032,
-0.5793141127,
0.2910941541,
-0.2150818557,
-0.7202743888,
-0.5792135,
-0.1349483579,
-0.2224741876,
0.0791930631,
0.9119637012,
0.3932829797,
0.2528953254,
-0.5459084511,
0.3719662726,
0.1599764675,
0.3335774839,
0.2628733516,
0.7017098069,
-0.3284830749,
0.778971374,
0.1481475532,
0.1543628275,
-0.3792577684,
-0.7570118308,
-0.9673178196,
-0.5145971775,
-0.2072443366,
-0.3743783832,
0.2014012933,
0.6838310957,
0.4066464305,
-0.7188267708,
-0.0147353625,
-0.2973897457,
0.297976613,
0.2209233493,
-0.3072050214,
0.475314796,
-0.592664957,
-0.814522624,
-0.0129551142,
0.3746154308,
0.4879546165,
-0.3538552523,
0.3563001752,
0.1521418393,
0.5412768722,
0.3831531703,
0.2451456487,
-0.9173074961,
-0.5752940178,
-0.2648971081,
-0.2822915316,
0.0209833998,
1.0946216583,
-0.3066220582,
0.1876344532,
0.3917265832,
0.7342200875,
-0.0307105351,
-0.1135006323,
0.5576061606,
-0.9582713842,
0.0326517709,
0.3075425625,
0.4175875187,
0.4395137727,
-0.368049562,
0.3158097267,
0.6168839335,
-0.3975567222,
-1.1986472607,
0.4147464931,
-0.5741994381,
-0.6354463696,
0.9863998294,
0.1103454083,
-0.3275682628,
-0.0911517963,
-0.1919316649,
0.0658891127,
-0.0009107826,
0.8962677121,
1.2216836214,
0.2284929156,
-0.2028967291,
-0.3499943018,
0.6215125322,
0.6571593881,
-0.4138832688,
0.3071402013,
0.4241214395,
0.4882041216,
0.2271578461,
0.7378157377,
-0.1516277492,
-0.0513130017,
0.058610674,
-0.0155792283,
0.0934044644,
-0.2460099757,
-0.4193332493,
0.3159665465,
0.41451177,
-0.1159702763
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11683v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11683v1 | HoLLMwood: Unleashing the Creativity of Large Language Models in Screenwriting via Role Playing | 2024-06-17T16:01:33 | 2024-06-17T16:01:33 | Jing Chen, Xinyu Zhu, Cheng Yang, Chufan Shi, Yadong Xi, Yuxiang Zhang, Junjie Wang, Jiashu Pu, Rongsheng Zhang, Yujiu Yang, Tian Feng | cs.CL | cs.CL | Generative AI has demonstrated unprecedented creativity in the field of
computer vision, yet such phenomena have not been observed in natural language
processing. In particular, large language models (LLMs) can hardly produce
written works at the level of human experts due to the extremely high
complexity of literature writing. In this paper, we present HoLLMwood, an
automated framework for unleashing the creativity of LLMs and exploring their
potential in screenwriting, which is a highly demanding task. Mimicking the
human creative process, we assign LLMs to different roles involved in the
real-world scenario. In addition to the common practice of treating LLMs as
${Writer}$, we also apply LLMs as ${Editor}$, who is responsible for providing
feedback and revision advice to ${Writer}$. Besides, to enrich the characters
and deepen the plots, we introduce a role-playing mechanism and adopt LLMs as
${Actors}$ that can communicate and interact with each other. Evaluations on
automatically generated screenplays show that HoLLMwood substantially
outperforms strong baselines in terms of coherence, relevance, interestingness
and overall quality. | [
-0.1157223135,
-0.9115809202,
0.7735998631,
0.145801574,
-0.0849960223,
0.3183170259,
-0.1453825831,
-0.1754072011,
0.0960152224,
1.0176705122,
-0.6426917315,
-0.6145902872,
-0.4408506453,
0.0046497257,
-0.2490903586,
0.8078087568,
-0.2427498102,
-0.2153097689,
-0.4125017524,
0.0725825951,
-0.3400168121,
-0.2588439882,
-0.4985630214,
-0.0765220597,
0.7084386945,
0.2010769695,
0.7050797939,
0.6049694419,
0.451694876,
0.359980166,
0.3048465848,
0.3428176045,
-0.4755033255,
0.6632559896,
-0.1383551508,
-0.3837244809,
-0.4324477613,
-0.0048598545,
0.5195226669,
0.4296164513,
-0.1580785662,
0.2094974965,
0.2264239788,
0.4479283392,
-0.3847766519,
0.2517027855,
-0.7012254,
0.2531147897,
-0.128226608,
-0.3263838887,
-0.3952659667,
-0.3195960224,
-0.0553301796,
-0.7230217457,
0.3417171538,
0.2252299339,
0.6339575648,
0.3011683822,
-0.1455671638,
-0.5270708799,
-0.9503279328,
0.6707603931,
-0.9307549,
-0.519352138,
0.2752245367,
0.255744189,
-0.1703393608,
-0.4182286859,
-0.5940868855,
-0.522939086,
0.2255443335,
0.1825758368,
0.2006047219,
0.1643905044,
0.4082171619,
0.6346270442,
-0.6104887724,
0.2771033347,
-0.1245225295,
0.0124628851,
0.9226046205,
0.3443896174,
0.5352640152,
-0.0418450274,
0.0271957535,
0.0542197488,
-0.4679647386,
0.0456410125,
0.4525190592,
-0.1869668514,
0.157947436,
0.9254925847,
0.1238771826,
0.6155099869,
0.007260954,
0.010431041,
-0.452727735,
0.2227966487,
-0.2679049373,
0.190310508,
0.7527123094,
0.6715933681,
0.1511602849,
0.2183116376,
-0.295370847,
0.1580600142,
0.2917568982,
-0.6223537922,
-0.0839341283,
0.2240357697,
-0.328466773,
-0.5366649628,
0.0191433039,
-0.6179563999,
-1.0481871367,
-0.2569361627,
0.7339112163,
-0.1651711762,
-0.2188952565,
-0.2091871798,
-0.2866864204,
0.1385831833,
0.2850821614,
-0.9905954003,
-0.0362119339,
0.3876262009,
0.516525805,
-0.1855272502,
-0.4673780203,
-0.5663248301,
0.4884770811,
-0.6384071708,
0.5880718231,
-0.2845552862,
-0.4208486378,
-0.0158420391,
-0.3785553575,
0.0551113375,
-0.6458138227,
0.2088612616,
-0.2981873453,
0.2814131379,
0.4478791952,
-0.4004465044,
0.1355593503,
0.2225886434,
-0.968010366,
0.8273194432,
0.1460893452,
-0.2308395207,
0.1959967613,
-0.6462054849,
-0.5274630189,
0.1497504115,
-0.0769074857,
-0.4412128925,
0.4254336357,
0.233354196,
0.7191302776,
-0.3794291317,
0.6977691054,
-0.1783628166,
-0.5042130947,
0.5341718197,
-0.5329796076,
0.370251298,
0.1873873621,
-0.5326682925,
0.3569969833,
-0.6415698528,
0.0115008662,
0.0622649528,
-0.4297836125,
-0.0262944084,
-0.0892560184,
0.1107731611,
0.239012152,
-0.0225732327,
-0.3663578928,
0.2449611872,
-0.5493134856,
0.6433458924,
0.5257575512,
0.0562106259,
0.4605674744,
-0.8300474882,
0.5531615615,
-0.3778164089,
0.0351672024,
-0.2440911531,
-0.349477917,
-0.6904908419,
-0.251237452,
-0.1360224932,
0.4757071733,
-0.8102584481,
0.4899866283,
0.1153740734,
-0.6434415579,
-0.9018873572,
0.4340629876,
0.2847832739,
-0.0084013585,
0.1861389577,
-0.2944645286,
-0.6398351789,
-0.6102567911,
-0.5866026282,
-0.0269457512,
-0.0082653295,
0.0504760966,
0.0378449559,
-0.2305411845,
0.9274419546,
-0.3695214391,
-0.7798596025,
-0.7183039188,
0.3204758465,
0.4502051175,
0.438464731,
-0.0308574475,
-0.5172017813,
-0.8642438054,
-0.0257083792,
-1.124499321,
-0.269163847,
-0.5386071801,
-0.116301775,
0.5254533291,
0.7185661793,
-0.8997064829,
0.618686676,
0.6986963749,
-0.2012828737,
0.5547135472,
-0.4551858902,
0.1222730875,
-1.0845206976,
0.1463255733,
-0.3398956358,
0.0442781374,
-0.2666960657,
0.1098784208,
-0.5919625163,
-0.4480299056,
-0.085500218,
0.5884776711,
-0.8171326518,
0.0554708205,
-0.2744331062,
0.3724834323,
0.2269796133,
0.6061920524,
-0.0670579523,
0.2363746911,
0.5551151037,
-0.3510253131,
0.7054466605,
-0.0065454766,
-0.6488651037,
0.3672719002,
-0.534848392,
0.025741471,
-0.4833766222,
0.2952415943,
-0.9655160308,
-0.4043180346,
-0.2544394433,
-0.069535099,
0.0336647891,
-0.125292182,
-0.3880774379,
-0.2588422894,
-0.2428658456,
-0.1630426347,
0.7749258876,
-0.205252111,
1.0021541119,
0.5544361472,
-0.4010802209,
-0.23706837,
-0.5500362515,
0.3565786183,
-0.4772768915,
-0.4895002544,
0.6293777823,
-0.2528635561,
-0.5444651842,
-0.0354747996,
0.2948298454,
0.026209252,
-0.0691540241,
0.6470860839,
0.3409009874,
-0.1124468669,
-0.2152783871,
0.0355021022,
0.0911654681,
-0.0036540837,
-0.1576851755,
0.5162038803,
0.2190196663,
-0.2552450597,
-0.3866157234,
0.5525654554,
0.8083173037,
-0.3441046178,
0.4246213734,
0.6086752415,
-0.1541547477,
-0.5775976181,
-0.5302093029,
0.1643882692,
-0.4610069096,
0.3343253136,
-0.1949429065,
-0.9547427893,
0.1129693761,
0.0433193184,
0.405508399,
0.6442634463,
0.675755918,
-0.3314032257,
1.1457943916,
0.4916822612,
0.3605216444,
0.3601532578,
-0.4370020628,
0.278062731,
-0.7751230597,
-0.1335376203,
-0.0441436917,
-0.4068593681,
-0.3191007376,
-0.5493708253,
0.3957097232,
0.2631242573,
0.0653533116,
0.3550571203,
-0.3936806619,
0.7632921934,
0.5421645641,
-0.2018731087,
0.4289958477,
-0.1184884757,
-0.353767246,
-0.0857888758,
-0.6369029284,
-0.7752040029,
0.8413153887,
0.2010074109,
1.0573883057,
0.3381140828,
0.7737787962,
0.4658475816,
0.6162051558,
-0.6631088257,
0.7608556151,
-0.2250153124,
-0.6441223025,
-0.8094770908,
0.0034697368,
-0.7007299066,
0.0578311868,
-0.4411059916,
-0.3774751425,
-0.274913609,
0.4100289345,
-0.568520546,
0.2804007232,
-0.6909614801,
0.96118325,
-0.3125448525,
-0.8676766157,
-0.5657982826,
-0.5008915663,
0.2061180174,
-0.0149019333,
0.3304582834,
-0.2245251685,
0.4827458858,
0.5164581537,
-0.2669927478,
0.9964896441,
-0.1837998033,
-0.2819220126,
0.7992225289,
0.6355606318,
0.3835714459,
0.0837443173,
-0.2449344248,
-0.2323711962,
0.0362315662,
-0.0638061091,
-0.5337145925,
0.8404330015,
-0.4985589683,
-0.7269763947,
-0.3741973639,
-0.7601928711,
-0.2161303759,
0.1403678656,
0.3016315103,
0.6589483619,
-0.8126379848,
0.1796857268,
0.2747135162,
-0.3359645605,
0.8462085724,
0.0668103695,
-0.5771611929,
-0.3257895112,
0.8862775564,
-0.0463982299,
0.1902170181,
0.4015782773,
0.0051124161,
-0.333401382,
-0.374232024,
-0.5723572969,
0.145517543,
-0.6268002987,
0.1483498067,
-0.5552579165,
-0.3010910749,
-0.2907997668,
-0.5435966849,
0.0560669899,
-0.3516588807,
-0.0949946046,
-0.0339627638,
0.0740324333,
0.9951917529,
0.0323077552,
0.2662849426,
-0.8849838376,
0.2614441216,
0.5716636181,
0.2233794332,
0.2231633365,
-0.3410939574,
-0.365067184,
-0.1341841966,
-0.4786410034,
-0.3553161919,
0.6690297723,
0.3699641526,
0.5601999164,
0.2256146669,
-0.1070858017,
0.4959621429,
-0.4252061844,
0.8186101317,
0.0531694628,
-0.906729877,
0.3840865791,
-0.4539537132,
0.4763935506,
0.5061907172,
0.1480446905,
-0.6935759187,
-0.5760247111,
-0.5002987981,
-0.7289389968,
0.4786135554,
-0.0018752818,
0.3284523487,
0.2731031477,
-0.1851322651,
0.1378691345,
0.3820447922,
-0.6958542466,
0.6484870315,
-0.2021930069,
-0.5600003004,
-0.4064606726,
-0.1932429075,
-0.0642169788,
-0.1665955186,
0.638466239,
-0.1398888826,
-0.0058315177,
0.2781676054,
-0.4421582222,
-0.3108991086,
0.2256792933,
0.4648866057,
0.4454170167,
-0.0446864404,
0.4216042161,
-0.094060801,
-0.3547481596,
0.0191563014,
-0.2429251373,
-0.0454747044,
-0.0703146458,
0.7486182451,
0.9265873432,
0.0865420029,
-1.0589950085,
0.2236997336,
0.1632155478,
-0.3830839396,
-0.4500932097,
0.4593769908,
0.2525150478,
0.1723523885,
0.2218919843,
0.1161915809,
-0.1662054509,
-0.9815856218,
0.0840305313,
0.4277228415,
-0.4981928766,
-0.0208456777,
0.7428531051,
0.3756400049,
-0.8419036865,
0.4765173197,
0.0025143134,
-0.3075901568,
0.6931535006,
0.5760669112,
0.9129955769,
-0.1891535521,
0.4270887971,
0.2109736502,
0.1068177372,
0.012544808,
0.0325358547,
0.1751095653,
-0.6290173531,
-0.4705080092,
-0.7957958579,
-0.3332583606,
0.0965476632,
-0.1056122631,
0.2312910259,
-0.7024498582,
-0.0948657021,
0.0005349634,
-0.2131124139,
-0.1747829616,
0.0194068551,
0.1629924178,
0.3182370663,
-0.3562296331,
0.6601825356,
0.4982787669,
-0.3023740053,
-0.708861053,
0.1524988711,
0.0490947627,
-0.4923467934,
0.4477929771,
0.470631361,
-0.1081978381,
0.6410422325,
-0.412597537,
-0.4770470858,
1.2107737064,
-0.0375406407,
-0.489138931,
-0.299420923,
0.1984940916,
0.7680530548,
-0.7350379229,
0.0920738503,
0.2227396071,
0.2989508808,
0.2511351109,
-0.7025262117,
-0.2274002582,
-0.3721297085,
0.1034201756,
-0.0785222873,
-0.1732407808,
0.6881117225,
-0.4349172711,
-0.1121244133,
0.2846980691,
0.4326452315,
0.3071472347,
0.1937163919,
0.4667390287,
0.156467095,
0.4490526021,
0.2008617967,
0.7794550061,
-0.1268037409,
0.0580322668,
0.874417901,
-0.7518721223,
0.7443954945,
0.4117926657,
0.0937637687,
0.7461400628,
0.1342124939,
-0.1714321673,
0.3117701113,
0.6328943968,
-0.4744930267,
-0.3257208467,
-0.1812281162,
0.3792136312,
0.4140083194,
0.1224190146,
-0.3884162009,
-0.0978958011,
0.2697689831,
-0.0959797204,
0.6915253997,
-0.3600020111,
0.8108216524,
0.2199736536,
-1.2016507387,
0.3815933168,
0.179966718,
0.5762655735,
-0.6536900997,
-0.4482466578,
-0.080477424,
0.39980793,
-0.1717288643,
-0.938685298,
0.3860393167,
0.0953622311,
-0.1495705396,
-0.5610837936,
0.5592847466,
-0.7951955795,
-0.4023730159,
-0.0124541428,
0.1453403085,
0.091044113,
-0.1615889519,
-0.463345319,
0.1548578441,
-0.1356157362,
0.1183570251,
0.0730530173,
0.3533636332,
-0.2992630899,
0.5544204712,
0.7772764564,
0.0727031231,
-0.148044914,
0.1630856097,
0.3473058939,
-0.5500738621,
-0.5445777178,
-1.0485569239,
0.8356310725,
-0.308000803,
-0.3386116624,
0.804677844,
0.5443618298,
0.3487583697,
-0.6218254566,
0.8502959609,
-0.1785420477,
0.2789047658,
-0.8183084726,
1.1128703356,
-0.1977449208,
0.2463598549,
-0.2534735203,
-1.2053771019,
-0.3243949711,
0.5365413427,
-0.0424357653,
-0.1690487415,
0.7605205178,
1.0776615143,
0.3047273457,
-0.2799197733,
0.6799666286,
0.3517715335,
0.2952440083,
0.6820225716,
1.1695437431,
-0.0090339435,
0.2583518624,
0.0967784375,
-0.3873303533,
-0.3197112083,
-0.9793280363,
-1.3527694941,
-0.6455515027,
-0.1475108415,
-0.2793110609,
-0.2235498875,
1.0186784267,
0.4417059124,
-0.4787968099,
-0.698936522,
-0.1935328543,
-0.0298921708,
-0.3106508553,
-0.2177996784,
0.1459232867,
0.1592165083,
-0.7264332771,
0.4945815504,
0.549767077,
0.0661157072,
-0.7873977423,
-0.0040112096,
-0.0597185791,
0.4366236627,
0.7964039445,
-0.000705198,
-0.6590464115,
0.2871354222,
-0.0329868942,
-0.4229560792,
-0.3299029171,
0.9908687472,
-0.5178799629,
0.3174730241,
0.3165240288,
0.4425677359,
0.5742253065,
-0.154339239,
0.8953283429,
-0.5014641285,
-0.067726396,
0.4102341235,
-0.1120262146,
0.444031775,
-0.5629595518,
0.1866712868,
0.2434203476,
-0.4966837168,
-0.6468795538,
0.2255043089,
-0.8390348554,
-0.3171783388,
1.0700275898,
0.0905054435,
-0.2349703908,
-0.1268413067,
-0.9107025266,
0.0819337741,
0.1338955611,
0.9044275284,
0.762252152,
-0.0915102661,
-0.2464499772,
-0.4080789983,
0.833795011,
0.283969909,
-0.9413931966,
0.2982050478,
0.5617339611,
-0.1272072345,
-0.0329820886,
0.8463317156,
-0.0103857461,
-0.06186511,
-0.1371810138,
0.2315988988,
-0.2224578112,
-0.4180774093,
-0.1458371282,
0.193179369,
0.482470125,
0.5704038143
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11682v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11682v1 | Knowledge-to-Jailbreak: One Knowledge Point Worth One Attack | 2024-06-17T15:59:59 | 2024-06-17T15:59:59 | Shangqing Tu, Zhuoran Pan, Wenxuan Wang, Zhexin Zhang, Yuliang Sun, Jifan Yu, Hongning Wang, Lei Hou, Juanzi Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR | Large language models (LLMs) have been increasingly applied to various
domains, which triggers increasing concerns about LLMs' safety on specialized
domains, e.g. medicine. However, testing the domain-specific safety of LLMs is
challenging due to the lack of domain knowledge-driven attacks in existing
benchmarks. To bridge this gap, we propose a new task, knowledge-to-jailbreak,
which aims to generate jailbreaks from domain knowledge to evaluate the safety
of LLMs when applied to those domains. We collect a large-scale dataset with
12,974 knowledge-jailbreak pairs and fine-tune a large language model as
jailbreak-generator, to produce domain knowledge-specific jailbreaks.
Experiments on 13 domains and 8 target LLMs demonstrate the effectiveness of
jailbreak-generator in generating jailbreaks that are both relevant to the
given knowledge and harmful to the target LLMs. We also apply our method to an
out-of-domain knowledge base, showing that jailbreak-generator can generate
jailbreaks that are comparable in harmfulness to those crafted by human
experts. Data and code: https://github.com/THU-KEG/Knowledge-to-Jailbreak/. | [
-0.2682323158,
-0.8284702897,
0.6909354925,
0.0625394806,
-0.0558669865,
0.0844492838,
-0.3367516696,
-0.4702040553,
-0.000092302,
0.9647318721,
-0.3827127516,
-0.6926832795,
-0.7735257745,
-0.1770673543,
-0.5054125786,
1.091686368,
0.0103634065,
-0.2940903306,
-0.163612172,
0.1575657427,
-0.7219671607,
-0.7139738202,
-0.2132303566,
0.0337659419,
0.4799344838,
0.5623211265,
0.3279381692,
0.3444371819,
0.5742297769,
0.139194265,
-0.0565384738,
0.1529012918,
-0.6234234571,
0.1614533663,
-0.4842728376,
-0.3102474511,
-0.4711383879,
-0.0130013805,
-0.0929252133,
0.4886894524,
-0.0580808222,
0.1355814934,
-0.2629319429,
0.9436693192,
-0.7083417773,
-0.3093452454,
-1.1409693956,
-0.2568082809,
-0.3096326888,
0.0520066693,
-0.7169706821,
-0.5079575181,
0.0004074439,
-0.2302651107,
-0.0592844263,
0.2941715419,
0.5756380558,
0.0987358242,
-0.4194588959,
-0.1880229712,
-0.3645476699,
0.5454708338,
-0.72310853,
0.3046753109,
0.5421814919,
0.4593579173,
-0.4134891629,
-0.5827202201,
-0.4341794848,
-0.4766794145,
0.1643472016,
-0.3268258274,
-0.0668543056,
-0.1740786731,
0.2043234706,
-0.0540184155,
-0.4638911188,
-0.0212500002,
-0.4906389117,
-0.004140574,
0.7281585932,
0.0723919943,
0.5864849687,
-0.1448576599,
-0.4867580235,
0.2081072181,
-1.4077394009,
-0.4173950553,
0.3836014271,
0.2236357331,
0.1062550396,
0.641082406,
0.1079521179,
0.8835958838,
0.0151499631,
-0.4586653709,
0.0372563414,
-0.1698399037,
-0.167713657,
0.1004428864,
0.7623417377,
0.6129454374,
0.5054386854,
-0.7094925642,
-0.0292683076,
-0.230249539,
0.5743407011,
-0.8850558996,
-0.3423244655,
0.1355052441,
-0.0359467976,
-0.6495811343,
-0.1038584784,
-0.5143000484,
-0.8296058774,
0.3155197501,
0.4541675746,
-0.7831839919,
-0.1924283057,
0.1888410002,
-0.2242255211,
-0.1136870235,
-0.0197159797,
-0.9010027051,
0.2528258264,
0.5884134173,
0.6055697799,
-0.2077358812,
-0.47568959,
-0.3595089018,
0.5057332516,
-0.2313617915,
0.7076237202,
-0.0986724794,
-0.4283241332,
-0.1962003708,
-0.3643522263,
-0.0989064947,
-0.8440639973,
0.033262562,
-0.7258474827,
-0.4735328555,
-0.117266573,
-0.908719182,
0.0253298078,
0.4022225142,
-0.6815221906,
0.366292119,
0.155356884,
-0.8316179514,
0.4911687076,
-0.5287858844,
-0.7635055184,
-0.1923475266,
0.1104549542,
-0.4511005878,
-0.0526182353,
0.1452997923,
0.5185988545,
-0.436953634,
0.6410363317,
-0.4150207937,
0.0258403569,
0.4556548297,
0.0453041233,
0.7750530839,
0.155866757,
-0.4153878987,
-0.3228588104,
-0.7109401226,
-0.0475073792,
0.5035002232,
-0.3354280889,
-0.6394148469,
0.1192540824,
-0.2581578791,
0.2459014058,
0.3055035472,
-0.6868474483,
0.2781957686,
-0.3929259181,
0.5424789786,
0.5889469385,
0.4651910067,
0.1871427596,
-0.2366207391,
0.2983219624,
-0.0172909964,
0.2960893512,
0.0336127616,
-0.4347483516,
-0.2468830794,
-0.0422405973,
0.3980647922,
0.5279954076,
-0.5731473565,
0.6060475111,
-0.1203805432,
-0.621483624,
-0.1988599002,
0.4563911259,
0.5403217673,
0.6325962543,
0.430983454,
-0.2992291451,
-0.4695488811,
-0.5822633505,
-0.7403755784,
-0.2739116251,
0.1967661381,
0.2095168084,
0.5929179788,
-0.3841225207,
0.9514548182,
-0.7129531503,
-0.2474547327,
-0.3338829279,
-0.3461113572,
-0.0378549993,
0.5489593744,
0.768386364,
-0.4243479073,
-0.2537105978,
-0.2074059695,
-0.8567528725,
0.0346080512,
0.2620503008,
-0.0029288416,
-0.1301560104,
0.6250964999,
-0.6265927553,
0.2662241161,
0.4102929831,
-0.6499972343,
0.8707315326,
0.042091988,
0.0768358633,
-1.0993394852,
0.0840369761,
-0.0826946869,
-0.0496270657,
-0.8184761405,
0.4375392497,
0.2054279298,
-0.0654837564,
-0.6568621993,
0.5037556291,
-0.0393858701,
0.1975254864,
-0.1258086562,
0.1490490884,
-0.0092088366,
0.0551741756,
-0.2889460027,
0.7845419049,
0.3254477084,
-0.2821035683,
0.2999264598,
0.3503139913,
-0.8075931668,
0.0769265667,
-0.441921711,
0.4316825569,
0.326676935,
-0.1778781414,
-0.6828245521,
-0.2929091156,
-0.1018807441,
-0.4798033535,
0.2000136822,
-0.4155697823,
-0.5693753958,
-0.2285129279,
-0.1402131468,
0.3923429251,
0.5997874737,
-0.6760200262,
0.103417173,
0.8662490845,
-0.2560704648,
-0.5876819491,
-0.5929241776,
0.2899619341,
-0.4952003658,
-0.9057738781,
0.1002042666,
-0.0230094679,
-0.5827202201,
-0.1533016711,
-0.0155699095,
-0.1096521616,
0.4702575207,
0.4381989837,
0.3551487029,
0.17374596,
0.0463595502,
0.1402963847,
0.065545164,
0.5221288204,
-0.5825798512,
0.3940002918,
0.1052951291,
-0.3601202369,
0.1387985647,
0.2064300925,
0.5530544519,
-0.3253379762,
0.8602971435,
-0.1818539053,
-0.2660964727,
-0.4980948269,
-0.6053498387,
-0.1303611547,
-0.4731682837,
0.3333961666,
-0.2888244689,
-1.038345933,
0.1898005754,
-0.7191771269,
0.0702167749,
0.2057903856,
0.5477612019,
0.0375402756,
0.6505668759,
0.8034952283,
-0.448382616,
0.0860971138,
-0.1004090309,
0.5820145011,
-0.5061050057,
-0.3734250963,
-0.3887081742,
0.0468080118,
-0.0476093814,
-0.3256604671,
0.4436044395,
0.3778484464,
-0.3682389259,
0.6664301753,
-0.1336057484,
0.6626139283,
0.279655844,
0.299066484,
0.4129656851,
-0.0860430226,
-0.2711553872,
0.1353594214,
-0.5049592257,
-0.4378580749,
1.5621752739,
0.2302142829,
0.8637919426,
0.1773569137,
0.9567583203,
0.476685375,
0.452067256,
-0.7207865119,
0.5053924918,
-0.2050399482,
-0.7548629642,
-0.2240071744,
-0.4170592725,
-0.6135126352,
-0.2191877961,
0.0081565818,
-0.9265027046,
-0.2720194161,
0.2208468467,
-0.3285775483,
0.5241701603,
-0.8256287575,
1.0146412849,
-0.4775736332,
-0.1990353912,
-0.2228366137,
-0.6809996367,
0.9091837406,
-0.5887898803,
0.5521887541,
-0.1778652072,
0.5582636595,
0.8572375178,
-0.8104855418,
0.8457140326,
-0.3812383115,
-0.2164325267,
0.3264276981,
0.4556590915,
0.5042972565,
0.2371064574,
-0.1518987566,
0.0523556024,
-0.41708529,
-0.2075615823,
-0.5058149695,
0.7523255944,
-0.7607001066,
-0.9493852258,
0.1119175628,
-0.679988265,
-0.5654278398,
0.2156987637,
0.2425749302,
0.1241036057,
-0.2226523012,
-0.3141810298,
0.9007367492,
-0.3967598379,
0.0238958653,
0.5983338952,
-0.3559142947,
-0.3192758858,
1.0107320547,
-0.1823196113,
0.4217405319,
0.0878038779,
0.1570955366,
-0.042162098,
-0.9695541263,
-0.4656194746,
0.0113771176,
-0.6735727191,
-0.5517795086,
-0.4010136724,
-0.4206240773,
-0.4694262743,
-0.2966815829,
-0.4999789596,
-0.365649581,
0.1695767641,
-0.3596375585,
0.8259776831,
0.8230183721,
-0.0361741073,
0.1227007285,
-0.9597361088,
0.3516352177,
0.498260051,
0.2042780071,
-0.2996426225,
-0.5166603923,
-0.2926261723,
-0.2992044091,
-0.1586433053,
-0.997585237,
0.3559567034,
0.0512168407,
0.3321231306,
0.4364326596,
0.2636815608,
0.4765531719,
-0.9024184346,
0.6652767658,
0.5040182471,
-0.9217447639,
1.0506887436,
-0.3331874907,
-0.2331258804,
0.8417636156,
0.1915938258,
-0.3182855546,
-0.8060830235,
-0.4935686588,
-1.0137987137,
0.2385413349,
-0.0240677595,
0.061594259,
-0.1461616307,
0.4783307016,
0.3486179411,
0.1454720497,
-0.4969192147,
-0.287784636,
0.0198506378,
0.0248995703,
0.1844068468,
-0.1259686798,
-0.3759880364,
-0.1722082794,
0.6034671068,
0.1752460301,
0.023080308,
-0.1931513846,
-0.4731692076,
-0.1635527611,
0.3568743765,
0.3049523234,
0.7495649457,
-0.3083316982,
0.2622229159,
0.0725081563,
-0.717954278,
0.4090889096,
0.0160334818,
-0.1674025357,
-0.3294946253,
0.2494269907,
0.5432437062,
-0.1017523408,
-1.2277853489,
0.7601511478,
0.0288797244,
-0.2954819202,
-0.2514563501,
0.3921550214,
0.2201305777,
0.2187530398,
0.1721836776,
0.2013179213,
-0.1932516247,
-0.5157848597,
0.5821411014,
0.2903720737,
-0.0590816662,
-0.1822223216,
0.7948773503,
0.1750764102,
-0.1502779871,
0.5865806937,
-0.1726302356,
-0.560169518,
0.6100671291,
0.7758674622,
0.6194754243,
-0.1856258065,
-0.0136872409,
0.1293106675,
0.4828148186,
0.0221860036,
0.1272483766,
0.3733086288,
-0.8666551709,
-0.4561801851,
-0.4127370119,
-0.3709448278,
0.3381519318,
-0.5005586147,
0.0797007531,
-0.6134139895,
-0.2532070577,
-0.028389005,
-0.2240469158,
-0.3158608079,
0.2308448255,
-0.0296656415,
1.319404006,
-0.7469390631,
1.2346068621,
0.6088181138,
-0.0496210307,
-0.8525710702,
0.1427687407,
-0.0114243813,
-0.8146876097,
0.8070576787,
0.0829524696,
0.0045998204,
-0.1100757793,
-0.7498424649,
-0.6781500578,
0.9867551327,
0.5850614905,
-0.8881101608,
0.037396688,
0.2196049094,
0.0538234413,
-0.1972503364,
-0.5996810794,
1.0626922846,
0.5105040669,
-0.3657748401,
-0.7952734232,
0.2823269367,
-0.2187359184,
-0.393448174,
0.5521436334,
-0.3308704495,
0.5805794001,
-0.8516792655,
0.3091126978,
-0.0161884893,
0.3203122616,
0.6957276464,
0.1516290754,
0.4848739505,
0.8910656571,
0.6340286732,
0.1047390029,
0.9006074071,
-0.6190485954,
0.2076537013,
1.1388553381,
-0.440667063,
0.7567287683,
0.5961936712,
0.011152789,
0.3543599546,
0.0524010696,
-0.139164269,
0.9887732267,
0.6002346277,
-0.4034255147,
-0.1914914101,
0.3272586763,
-0.2077501863,
0.1941071153,
0.561380446,
-0.410644412,
-0.1605230868,
0.3412635624,
0.4783830047,
-0.000039556,
-0.2936362326,
0.7605237365,
0.3665055633,
-0.6068723202,
0.6632225513,
0.386582315,
0.3798003197,
-0.5861160755,
0.2316585332,
-0.0797497779,
0.1966094971,
-0.1357846558,
-0.6988829374,
0.251735121,
0.5975098014,
-0.0944795087,
0.086830467,
1.2776223421,
-0.1531801522,
-0.1348725855,
0.6367165446,
0.6399257183,
0.067124851,
-0.3311594129,
-0.2871862948,
-0.1493307054,
-0.0819300413,
-0.3685904443,
0.7700346708,
0.1636254489,
-0.0164557099,
0.6000427604,
0.4998466671,
0.2755579054,
0.2383899838,
0.0434542932,
1.2434421778,
-0.8753828406,
-0.159279719,
-1.0175987482,
0.3249732554,
0.038993787,
-0.2182666808,
0.7583761811,
0.393694371,
0.7265039086,
-0.145781979,
1.3585573435,
-0.4268935323,
0.3289811611,
-0.5624919534,
1.2417860031,
-0.3322694898,
0.5245453119,
-0.2987671196,
-0.303008467,
-0.3243383169,
0.2298682034,
-0.5316585302,
-0.3528196812,
0.7040544748,
0.6952812076,
0.2941544056,
-0.123821862,
0.4555488825,
0.2810305059,
0.1968938857,
0.8504740596,
1.0285160542,
-0.3704280257,
0.5520739555,
-0.3627272248,
-0.1922546625,
-0.0433123596,
-0.8419097662,
-1.3144487143,
-0.2446823418,
-0.1523527652,
-0.6681414247,
0.541408658,
0.6516376138,
0.6451330781,
-0.7953261733,
-0.1582228839,
-0.2063377202,
0.2422685772,
-0.1070267409,
-0.1343853623,
0.2751038671,
-0.3958848119,
-0.0729821026,
0.8983739018,
0.2450987995,
-0.2326503545,
0.027632501,
-0.0699965283,
0.1284111142,
-0.067125842,
0.7062439322,
0.1942202747,
-0.3418718576,
-0.3238510489,
-0.1061738431,
-0.0935403109,
-0.1871462911,
1.0296865702,
-0.7162755728,
0.0771388933,
0.1961933374,
0.8101735711,
0.2344694883,
-0.0783355013,
0.6487919092,
-0.9368182421,
-0.1162201464,
0.0493510552,
0.4115008712,
0.0600928031,
-0.3958873153,
0.4333994687,
0.2753415406,
-0.5439316034,
-0.7825812697,
0.3470606506,
-0.6835774183,
-0.7397636175,
1.2235540152,
-0.4638116062,
-0.2807955742,
-0.4112134278,
0.1195003912,
0.0003433416,
-0.2653309405,
1.1248995066,
0.3246174455,
0.2149514854,
0.2000919431,
-0.5884541869,
0.651561439,
0.0231787432,
-1.2055239677,
0.3637243211,
0.1436006427,
0.918092072,
0.0384096801,
0.4815211594,
-0.3788343072,
0.3303210735,
-0.1371388733,
0.2118265182,
-0.276984334,
-0.5745660663,
0.128474921,
0.4247334301,
0.480001241,
0.2621746659
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11681v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11681v1 | R-Eval: A Unified Toolkit for Evaluating Domain Knowledge of Retrieval Augmented Large Language Models | 2024-06-17T15:59:49 | 2024-06-17T15:59:49 | Shangqing Tu, Yuanchun Wang, Jifan Yu, Yuyang Xie, Yaran Shi, Xiaozhi Wang, Jing Zhang, Lei Hou, Juanzi Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models have achieved remarkable success on general NLP tasks,
but they may fall short for domain-specific problems. Recently, various
Retrieval-Augmented Large Language Models (RALLMs) are proposed to address this
shortcoming. However, existing evaluation tools only provide a few baselines
and evaluate them on various domains without mining the depth of domain
knowledge. In this paper, we address the challenges of evaluating RALLMs by
introducing the R-Eval toolkit, a Python toolkit designed to streamline the
evaluation of different RAG workflows in conjunction with LLMs. Our toolkit,
which supports popular built-in RAG workflows and allows for the incorporation
of customized testing data on the specific domain, is designed to be
user-friendly, modular, and extensible. We conduct an evaluation of 21 RALLMs
across three task levels and two representative domains, revealing significant
variations in the effectiveness of RALLMs across different tasks and domains.
Our analysis emphasizes the importance of considering both task and domain
requirements when choosing a RAG workflow and LLM combination. We are committed
to continuously maintaining our platform at https://github.com/THU-KEG/R-Eval
to facilitate both the industry and the researchers. | [
-0.4175177217,
-0.876529336,
0.3640807271,
0.2336561233,
-0.0345083885,
0.4592424631,
-0.5682424903,
-0.3405152857,
0.0854261667,
0.7360100746,
-0.3158583343,
-0.5013812184,
-0.5898496509,
0.2635681033,
-0.3076678514,
1.1292434931,
-0.1656142175,
-0.1863303483,
-0.4867765307,
-0.1414467692,
-0.5870518088,
-0.284185499,
-0.3343530595,
-0.8037785888,
0.7075244784,
0.2733661234,
0.5176878572,
0.1388512701,
0.8245990276,
0.1955494583,
-0.0725147277,
0.2970162332,
-0.3338756561,
0.6096550226,
-0.5414874554,
-0.1671138555,
-0.5507914424,
-0.1560306698,
0.4693805873,
0.6919574738,
-0.3667659461,
0.60108006,
0.16282776,
0.7380481958,
-0.9861954451,
-0.0089629367,
-0.5472096801,
-0.024952963,
-0.0926119089,
-0.3467181921,
-0.54862535,
-0.1432587504,
0.0787461624,
-0.3144589961,
-0.0584798679,
0.2586811483,
0.7116270065,
0.2429456264,
-0.1833423674,
-0.1546004415,
-0.7430505157,
1.0132017136,
-0.6493190527,
0.4492420852,
0.4790981114,
0.2750268877,
-0.2462257743,
-0.8111638427,
-0.2304252684,
-0.3253754973,
-0.2001395673,
-0.0285539404,
-0.3294765353,
0.0470139906,
0.1956311017,
0.3922019601,
-0.9348338842,
0.0264151935,
-0.2573766112,
-0.067347303,
0.526561141,
0.3671757281,
0.3223308325,
-0.104507111,
-0.4437156916,
-0.1195501909,
-0.6643447876,
-0.2886108756,
0.1186349541,
0.2589222491,
0.0691117942,
0.6688784361,
-0.0416079909,
0.8251027465,
-0.3805068731,
-0.178639695,
0.2987750471,
-0.0716645345,
-0.3224043846,
-0.4971609712,
0.7889003754,
0.0604937859,
0.1433022767,
-0.2128024846,
-0.539470315,
-0.1091545597,
0.5086800456,
-0.7044445276,
-0.0903746113,
0.2667579651,
-0.3193217218,
-0.0641494468,
-0.0221032202,
-0.9236189127,
-0.3083895743,
-0.3410630226,
0.5977371931,
-0.2752897143,
-0.4315693378,
0.1633499861,
-0.0893112943,
0.173821345,
0.3845701218,
-0.3869210482,
0.3534463942,
1.1227618456,
0.7511882782,
-0.5149410963,
-0.4011567831,
-0.7948573828,
-0.3653190434,
-0.3306141496,
0.812179327,
-0.955060184,
-0.2831303179,
0.0662893727,
-0.1841576248,
-0.2630904913,
-0.770152688,
0.5980591774,
-0.8656203151,
-0.0049594156,
0.2212652266,
-0.5327029228,
-0.1845211983,
0.3366381824,
-0.5921462774,
1.2648339272,
0.307495296,
-0.6314666867,
0.1047038659,
-0.6219856739,
-0.4746355712,
0.4733988941,
0.0544123389,
-0.3956777155,
0.0832731649,
-0.0223451257,
0.61472857,
-0.5276594162,
0.1774328947,
-0.3419944644,
-0.394446671,
0.2515288293,
-0.2620187104,
0.5964915156,
0.3546954691,
-0.0339776129,
0.1199676394,
-0.5735986829,
0.4197529256,
-0.0889674723,
-0.401458025,
-0.4572895169,
-0.2897552848,
0.3408280611,
-0.0199271347,
0.1233249605,
-0.2731364369,
0.2230298668,
-0.3286803365,
0.2132426202,
0.4918361008,
0.0261757746,
0.3585814834,
-0.2356413752,
1.1589736938,
-0.5513961315,
-0.0324451476,
-0.187608242,
-0.4558606446,
-0.5635333657,
-0.3406675458,
0.4628698826,
0.5097172856,
-0.5770573616,
0.5148302317,
-0.2252108008,
-0.5981052518,
-0.5858907104,
0.3420121074,
0.6555560827,
0.0639865324,
0.2500752509,
-0.1671401858,
-0.5458469987,
-0.7943564653,
-0.3150027692,
0.0508336313,
0.016776545,
0.4642609358,
0.8555049896,
-0.5724174976,
0.9855125546,
-0.5209384561,
-0.5181618929,
-0.6175642014,
0.2756232023,
0.2889811695,
0.1845990121,
0.2031005919,
-0.6769222617,
-0.5765478015,
0.2738954425,
-0.3347417712,
-0.3027919233,
0.3361205459,
0.0765221119,
0.3387270272,
-0.012962129,
-0.6204490066,
0.4657157063,
0.6966677904,
-0.123192139,
0.8322287202,
-0.2824496329,
0.2426172346,
-0.7661580443,
0.3756960332,
0.1074025705,
-0.2452187985,
-0.559587121,
0.3757913709,
0.3017621934,
-0.0566860028,
-0.3350548744,
1.0095331669,
-0.3982513547,
-0.2897126079,
-0.3146992326,
0.1520470679,
0.4193290472,
0.2549052835,
0.0461277887,
1.0261766911,
0.4045429528,
-0.5495253801,
0.3588497341,
0.0899629593,
-0.5189096332,
0.4025887251,
-0.4710002244,
0.3743447065,
0.2415995449,
0.208856672,
-0.5531680584,
-0.1994273216,
-0.0217181835,
-0.4436517358,
0.4065327048,
-0.3641431332,
-0.3863373101,
-0.413228035,
-0.313637048,
0.3827278614,
0.6914212704,
-0.6473987103,
0.8767132163,
0.442445606,
-0.2036069185,
-1.1179717779,
-0.2815811634,
0.3076709211,
-0.4443126917,
-0.4753875732,
0.1360921413,
-0.0630424991,
-0.5601441264,
0.0816479176,
-0.1364348382,
-0.2151231617,
0.0998053327,
0.177530691,
0.2853323519,
-0.1439740062,
-0.0695306286,
-0.3367757797,
-0.098236233,
0.0685313568,
0.0426675789,
0.5200724006,
-0.2246441543,
-0.3829865456,
-0.1773599237,
-0.0132461162,
0.3773649931,
-0.4911844134,
0.2941149175,
0.6205448508,
-0.2536726594,
-0.9956450462,
-0.6630139351,
0.0133828903,
-0.4279974401,
0.5195246935,
-0.319193989,
-0.8617115021,
0.4002508223,
-0.2303680778,
0.0204509757,
0.2421603203,
0.7333991528,
0.1081881747,
0.6873579025,
0.4868292212,
-0.0130642792,
0.0160530694,
-0.4076550901,
0.3880268633,
-1.2416731119,
-0.2074827105,
-0.6461278796,
0.0801121742,
0.0696902573,
-0.7135490179,
0.3457600176,
0.0868561938,
-0.0048088762,
0.3287521005,
-0.4215163887,
0.6226561069,
0.1371115595,
-0.2399703264,
0.331397742,
-0.0973751619,
0.0421601385,
0.028468335,
-0.6191916466,
-0.5899841785,
1.2378399372,
0.194382906,
1.2810742855,
-0.1635084301,
0.6517093778,
0.7539913058,
0.4585121274,
-0.9526478052,
0.5869663358,
0.0067923097,
-0.3367018402,
-0.1111907139,
-0.3654857576,
-1.2040451765,
0.4828883708,
-0.0978677571,
-0.5859110951,
-0.3160073161,
-0.0587892532,
-0.3596149981,
0.2839001715,
-0.442940414,
0.8097331524,
-0.1419069916,
-0.3493013978,
-0.3909082413,
-0.1754529923,
0.4485529363,
-0.2973935902,
0.4215807319,
-0.0699701309,
0.0139598139,
0.7401503325,
-0.2876543701,
0.522557497,
0.0481191725,
-0.1270147413,
0.27966851,
0.2928525805,
0.3865226507,
0.0375228301,
0.0141498055,
0.1844853461,
0.0929684266,
0.0960319489,
-0.7569137812,
0.8196959496,
-0.4388855398,
-0.5344436169,
-0.6093979478,
-0.6271547079,
-0.2062021345,
0.0867722407,
-0.3507207036,
0.5656413436,
-0.2385260016,
0.3891973495,
0.5986448526,
-0.4317212701,
0.1064656973,
0.6130087972,
-0.6978206635,
-0.3449648619,
0.8611761332,
-0.3041497469,
0.308157891,
0.3027128279,
0.3146921694,
-0.3340929151,
-0.4731032848,
-0.3514147997,
0.1250914931,
-0.7927503586,
-0.6055403948,
-0.6664494872,
-0.1907452047,
-0.2171259671,
-0.0026533685,
-0.399345845,
-0.2232199162,
-0.0262149107,
0.2277619243,
0.4590848386,
1.0201365948,
-0.081872046,
-0.2284564525,
-0.7905707955,
0.4091024101,
0.1142486855,
0.4644620121,
0.1103886068,
-0.7347719073,
-0.3354951143,
-0.1981973797,
-0.0957473814,
-0.424293071,
0.61558038,
0.2921467721,
0.5263510346,
0.0363450199,
0.1144511029,
0.5966636539,
-0.6707328558,
0.6756129861,
-0.0782281384,
-0.6904292703,
0.4012357593,
-0.0578130968,
-0.1680127084,
0.3017118573,
0.2042544186,
-0.557041347,
-0.3762745559,
-0.5007106066,
-1.0021369457,
0.6045973301,
0.0203010179,
0.0937651172,
0.1376412809,
0.2660197318,
0.2900899947,
-0.0695375651,
-0.4390701652,
-0.2734971941,
0.3700312078,
0.0014264947,
0.115379706,
-0.1617464274,
-0.2149477899,
-0.1359273791,
0.8503508568,
0.0673046112,
-0.1017603949,
-0.0206952803,
-0.3889706135,
-0.1154920459,
0.6048759818,
0.3089207709,
1.1090062857,
-0.345266968,
0.0838439912,
0.224452585,
-0.4975273013,
0.0762291774,
-0.0666672438,
0.1371712834,
0.0201286506,
0.5361625552,
0.6141580343,
0.312415123,
-1.0851137638,
0.4976274371,
-0.0281136595,
-0.1422900856,
-0.340521276,
0.3445048034,
-0.0360342413,
0.18441315,
0.5559847355,
-0.0245759357,
0.0386358015,
-0.3015094101,
0.4124583602,
0.607878983,
-0.0325034671,
-0.2000906616,
0.3659422994,
-0.0327657908,
-0.8234604001,
0.2097702026,
-0.2360955179,
-0.6186872721,
0.5431417823,
0.5170377493,
0.9525113106,
-0.2059020996,
0.2076277733,
0.3248611689,
0.1815382689,
-0.0944000557,
0.0414158143,
0.1236392334,
-0.5107597113,
-0.8816379309,
-0.9355069399,
-0.7090402246,
0.4711153805,
-0.9302650094,
0.2106672078,
-0.0558723658,
-0.018562464,
-0.1240225285,
0.1357517391,
-0.8535141945,
0.0698532239,
-0.2227783203,
0.8638063669,
-0.5924399495,
0.865044415,
0.8858928084,
-0.2099753469,
-0.5502259135,
-0.2358070612,
-0.245943591,
-0.9681135416,
0.9901664853,
-0.052414272,
-0.2621485889,
-0.0931693986,
-0.146551609,
-0.7400853038,
0.9312004447,
-0.0633114353,
-0.4285520613,
0.3615959585,
0.1292392313,
0.5514804125,
-0.4365511239,
0.3313974142,
0.6780986786,
0.6270067692,
-0.1210903674,
-1.1445465088,
-0.140659228,
-0.2272680849,
0.1003209949,
0.2136426717,
-0.0869634524,
0.5357455015,
-0.2978852391,
-0.1781401485,
0.1183345914,
0.3189117014,
0.3741087019,
0.2400911301,
0.4570417106,
0.7686609626,
0.4700596631,
0.0580352694,
1.0811929703,
-0.3540785909,
0.7264644504,
1.0529663563,
-0.6242814064,
1.0991870165,
0.2794612348,
-0.4674840868,
0.2723272443,
0.1650098562,
0.0821085796,
0.1542008668,
0.3064270616,
-0.1981612444,
-0.3554944992,
-0.0079587232,
-0.2220540345,
0.3753930926,
0.5017203689,
0.0497084372,
-0.5497379303,
0.2460736781,
-0.1418544501,
0.1977974474,
-0.2309529781,
0.6362072229,
0.2421851158,
-0.7593666315,
0.7643377185,
-0.0119909039,
0.7667902112,
-0.7136656642,
-0.2877852023,
-0.144038409,
0.3267972469,
-0.2533193529,
-1.1218867302,
0.2846269906,
0.2829515636,
0.0091168052,
-0.3538152575,
1.0555524826,
-0.3411049843,
-0.2673214674,
0.6089573503,
0.6480702758,
0.2443464249,
-0.1065824926,
-0.9916618466,
0.4605529904,
-0.1902499199,
-0.7038880587,
0.5952866077,
0.1466616392,
0.1488355547,
0.8932809234,
0.6230334044,
0.3101354539,
-0.217955038,
0.3326580226,
0.6733990908,
-0.5215831399,
0.0867124647,
-0.7969356775,
0.4542306066,
0.2458788007,
-0.148651883,
0.8580878377,
0.6564596295,
0.6311539412,
-0.0133785363,
0.9049207568,
-0.1630778015,
0.7701663375,
-0.3703612089,
0.7421060205,
-0.6839010715,
0.3479049802,
-0.1802061647,
-1.181147337,
-0.3915902674,
0.6959239841,
-0.149797827,
0.0585142896,
0.7615054846,
0.8920965195,
-0.0975443646,
-0.1779839396,
0.4010782838,
0.0543439202,
0.3259448111,
0.2728774846,
1.0103203058,
-0.1585583389,
0.4377068877,
-0.2501577735,
-0.1376412213,
-0.2306440026,
-1.0376268625,
-0.9055541158,
-0.5946555734,
-0.2837142944,
-0.5010390282,
0.1018680334,
1.0089985132,
0.4725331366,
-0.5851669908,
-0.3789521456,
0.3417882621,
0.266356051,
-0.1707151532,
-0.323192656,
0.4804093242,
-0.7125692964,
-0.6142406464,
0.6608208418,
0.526306808,
-0.6196634173,
-0.4809173346,
-0.2263606191,
-0.1017891616,
-0.0923213661,
0.6570070982,
0.2908472121,
-0.8505991697,
-0.2396281213,
-0.0884309486,
0.0526937097,
0.0232727658,
0.8179901838,
-0.8383684158,
0.3269720078,
0.3913935125,
0.9144694209,
0.2895039022,
-0.0106125651,
0.4184873402,
-0.5888774991,
-0.2689580619,
0.4990904331,
0.4152089655,
0.2294728905,
-0.0371402502,
0.7571668625,
-0.0933404416,
-0.903519094,
-1.2000428438,
-0.0116518242,
-0.9410206676,
-0.3389124572,
1.599470377,
-0.2903959155,
-0.2556779981,
-0.2417159677,
-0.115830332,
-0.3314906061,
-0.1514715999,
0.5488650203,
0.6192119122,
-0.0461641103,
0.0317000598,
-0.8843469024,
0.4614124894,
0.3122285008,
-0.7458050251,
0.4156008363,
0.3811295033,
0.6017728448,
0.102718547,
0.4905518293,
0.1137548462,
0.1884948611,
-0.4341668487,
0.2910908759,
-0.08364968,
-0.4568585455,
-0.4538979232,
0.108076632,
0.1031709239,
0.3537839949
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11678v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11678v1 | TourRank: Utilizing Large Language Models for Documents Ranking with a Tournament-Inspired Strategy | 2024-06-17T15:58:22 | 2024-06-17T15:58:22 | Yiqun Chen, Qi Liu, Yi Zhang, Weiwei Sun, Daiting Shi, Jiaxin Mao, Dawei Yin | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) are increasingly employed in zero-shot documents
ranking, yielding commendable results. However, several significant challenges
still persist in LLMs for ranking: (1) LLMs are constrained by limited input
length, precluding them from processing a large number of documents
simultaneously; (2) The output document sequence is influenced by the input
order of documents, resulting in inconsistent ranking outcomes; (3) Achieving a
balance between cost and ranking performance is quite challenging. To tackle
these issues, we introduce a novel documents ranking method called TourRank,
which is inspired by the tournament mechanism. This approach alleviates the
impact of LLM's limited input length through intelligent grouping, while the
tournament-like points system ensures robust ranking, mitigating the influence
of the document input sequence. We test TourRank with different LLMs on the
TREC DL datasets and the BEIR benchmark. Experimental results show that
TourRank achieves state-of-the-art performance at a reasonable cost. | [
-0.2549721897,
-0.804905355,
0.6593680978,
0.0505949818,
-0.198606804,
0.4810726345,
-0.3993816376,
-0.3725474775,
0.2763235867,
0.3577073812,
-0.4276483059,
-0.8365299702,
-0.9457598329,
0.1651369929,
-0.4282376468,
0.8821766973,
0.122247681,
0.0135418847,
-0.2347650081,
-0.1750467867,
-0.2717572749,
-0.5213365555,
-0.6771073937,
-0.4184958637,
0.9441997409,
0.4701032639,
0.5789045095,
0.7075893879,
0.9980021119,
0.3481937647,
-0.0689635053,
0.2764851153,
-0.9409415126,
0.4178504348,
0.0561183244,
-0.6111842394,
-0.3550644219,
0.0568075776,
0.9083650708,
0.6364720464,
-0.0897859558,
0.0257441346,
0.0749116689,
0.414765954,
-0.4280540645,
0.1985381097,
-0.726290822,
-0.1378530711,
-0.7160836458,
-0.5790177584,
-0.7631467581,
-0.5508134961,
-0.109354116,
-0.3482382894,
0.0967261046,
0.1431256831,
0.8321421146,
-0.0392567702,
-0.2869173884,
-0.2367031574,
-0.6415812373,
0.5699108243,
-0.5327811837,
0.2667793036,
0.0520715006,
0.387707442,
-0.2208067328,
-0.391377598,
-0.3487866819,
-0.0152186658,
0.3933875263,
0.1706817895,
0.0416757166,
0.1109650731,
0.1547635943,
0.2071350962,
-1.0318522453,
0.4298969209,
-0.2019064724,
0.1629375368,
0.6616120338,
0.0391654,
0.3626694977,
0.185785085,
-0.0575768277,
-0.2433513552,
-0.7751715779,
0.0897450373,
0.45959723,
0.5136293769,
0.4000783265,
0.6745753288,
-0.3631915152,
0.687985003,
-0.0307789817,
-0.2198305279,
0.0267524235,
0.0941472873,
-0.1213700771,
0.2878980935,
0.7136976719,
0.4653933942,
0.2782728076,
-0.5829336047,
-0.3299800754,
-0.0941452533,
0.0035531027,
-0.8906373978,
-0.1310250759,
-0.1086061597,
-0.2381087691,
-0.5175144672,
0.188315019,
-0.6854817867,
-0.2195734531,
0.1214364618,
0.8371756077,
-0.345954746,
0.0032207076,
-0.0627408251,
-0.1823399216,
0.3928040564,
0.5319452286,
-0.836078465,
0.2764440775,
0.8459348679,
1.2224203348,
-0.3732648492,
-0.37495175,
-0.869287312,
0.2819914818,
-0.4207148552,
1.1010104418,
-0.884716332,
-0.8436778188,
0.1389717609,
-0.3032096326,
-0.2191849798,
-0.5347511768,
0.4893198311,
-0.7792487144,
0.1577702463,
-0.1633872539,
-0.8437293172,
0.081001848,
0.3626659214,
-0.5251084566,
1.0895044804,
-0.0472159348,
-0.3824990392,
0.2500710189,
-0.649125576,
-0.5939641595,
0.4951819479,
-0.0746879652,
-0.3186226785,
0.1814240813,
0.0817877874,
0.2333769351,
-0.2451736182,
0.2240028083,
-0.5278847814,
-0.7386078835,
-0.1110847145,
-0.3777677417,
0.5828262568,
0.0729319006,
-0.0684845299,
0.1046603993,
-0.3971941769,
-0.0282612871,
0.287158072,
-0.5025084615,
-0.4550660849,
-0.0732452199,
-0.2021160424,
0.1317963898,
0.2231794447,
-0.5711321235,
0.8161051273,
-0.5197607279,
0.2844367623,
0.9051716924,
0.1393597871,
0.5548199415,
-0.4572138786,
0.5649400949,
-0.3968634605,
0.1335531622,
0.0601592846,
-0.5440490842,
-0.7883976102,
-0.0902938992,
0.6421963573,
0.2746819258,
-0.5590600967,
0.2900847793,
-0.782903254,
-0.7352672219,
-0.4739439785,
0.1462039798,
0.1069582179,
0.2052773088,
0.0669926181,
-0.2404199541,
-0.0749612525,
-0.6126026511,
-0.1102258489,
-0.2080368996,
0.0520343408,
0.3106477857,
0.2752527297,
0.1946438104,
0.5452446342,
-0.723507762,
-0.5256789327,
-0.4417956173,
0.304525286,
0.2121461332,
0.2197743058,
0.4197352529,
-0.5258451104,
-0.3562533259,
-0.2941645682,
-0.5143731833,
-0.1441709101,
0.2472635359,
-0.1863104105,
0.4561620653,
0.5645886064,
-0.4024111629,
0.2124162614,
0.4198716581,
-0.0364054777,
0.2135506123,
-0.2584380209,
0.3163715303,
-0.839384973,
-0.3091389835,
0.0562068969,
-0.2546970844,
-0.1359544396,
0.2831281126,
-0.1952119619,
-0.320514828,
-0.2252972871,
0.5683373809,
-0.1373932213,
0.0977283046,
-0.261662066,
0.4495648444,
0.0007183891,
0.4745154381,
0.0547818094,
0.6785094738,
0.4010024965,
-0.3328634202,
0.2148481756,
0.1320737004,
-0.3124871254,
0.5422014594,
-0.5207239389,
0.026728075,
0.0113762813,
0.340777874,
-1.1345206499,
0.1097901613,
-0.3163191378,
-0.4489290416,
0.6557067037,
-0.3498849273,
-0.7822535634,
-0.3467502296,
-0.5133096576,
0.3422074914,
0.3400252163,
-0.500870645,
0.3426360786,
0.463642925,
-0.3773491383,
-0.1469605118,
-0.2940922976,
0.3964587152,
-0.2320350707,
-0.7757083178,
0.4558869898,
-0.2808695436,
-0.0020171448,
-0.2075627297,
-0.078947328,
0.338658303,
0.1250859648,
0.2423291653,
0.1610676795,
-0.1720953435,
0.2292252332,
-0.104083322,
-0.0763734803,
-0.2017914504,
-0.4351932108,
0.7660931945,
-0.0262274016,
-0.3527656496,
-0.0699771717,
0.4098401964,
0.5523467064,
-0.5064660907,
0.6568549275,
0.1799866408,
-0.2037338465,
-0.4475356638,
-0.6545847654,
-0.0224115513,
-0.4717856944,
0.1912573874,
-0.4938747883,
-1.0102149248,
0.3671040535,
-0.2609218955,
0.0956967771,
0.5381797552,
0.5542864799,
-0.2632923126,
1.1013419628,
0.6750693917,
-0.3209853768,
0.4537895918,
-0.4183561206,
0.3361802101,
-0.6176580787,
-0.2890251577,
-0.9359765649,
-0.5897606015,
-0.936352551,
-0.4206656218,
0.5411408544,
-0.0834054202,
-0.1780454516,
0.1940971166,
-0.3786939383,
0.6474032998,
0.9406552315,
0.0676951781,
0.5108829737,
-0.0565544814,
-0.3447336257,
0.2349197865,
-0.7601174116,
-0.2656069696,
1.1456749439,
-0.0295502637,
0.8208459616,
0.4998477399,
1.2212314606,
0.5498182178,
0.049892243,
-0.9252977371,
0.7972384095,
-0.2439720035,
-0.1859933883,
-0.604840517,
-0.4306118488,
-0.9389083385,
0.1546922475,
-0.0907734931,
-0.7825419307,
-0.1220661551,
-0.552303195,
-0.1798029989,
0.3266217709,
-0.3502178192,
0.5746079087,
-0.1979282498,
-0.4038706422,
-0.1012270674,
-0.3738469779,
0.2364050001,
0.0002844048,
0.0569323748,
0.0707009956,
0.2564403415,
0.9540854692,
-0.4713823795,
0.2455613613,
0.0130495345,
0.058607284,
-0.033720836,
0.4297702312,
0.6289672852,
0.0577527694,
-0.3669759035,
0.1497058123,
-0.1608222127,
-0.3338958323,
-0.6173149943,
1.2836346626,
-0.823599875,
-0.9645249844,
-0.5905547142,
-0.4887630343,
-0.2365524322,
0.5419903398,
0.2492554039,
0.7001824975,
-0.1556061506,
0.3876158893,
0.8780075908,
-0.0299495943,
0.6875516772,
0.5460560918,
-0.3026952446,
-0.2250664979,
1.1377913952,
0.4865688384,
0.0758120194,
0.7750511169,
0.1467307508,
-0.4802497923,
-0.9486758113,
-0.2864356041,
0.2483638227,
-0.5131351948,
-0.2307635695,
-0.6210528016,
-0.4208256006,
-0.6625438333,
-0.3832594752,
-0.1695919186,
-0.5206423998,
0.1489271671,
-0.2409872413,
0.1137522608,
0.7807568312,
0.1685528904,
0.1005289853,
-0.5991097093,
0.0693476498,
0.1704742759,
0.7035985589,
-0.0344736241,
-0.6103378534,
-0.1997465044,
-0.4516631067,
-0.4363258779,
-0.6543062925,
0.2156927884,
0.0960027203,
0.7658095956,
0.5144706964,
0.1812452823,
0.541462183,
-0.6722455621,
0.5965399742,
-0.2130114436,
-0.6170777082,
0.6094230413,
-0.611585021,
0.3854858279,
0.7261444926,
0.1642053723,
-0.415971756,
-0.7229282856,
-0.6552023888,
-0.7147169113,
0.6573232412,
0.1395362616,
-0.0686038956,
-0.08586137,
0.0463785566,
-0.1639396846,
-0.0143988142,
-0.5791552663,
-0.1151849031,
0.2124294639,
-0.2880633771,
-0.2433187217,
-0.3240880668,
-0.001409999,
0.0986189097,
0.8886256218,
0.1162633747,
-0.0150470603,
0.0316897072,
-0.232753545,
-0.2255707979,
0.0795008838,
0.7007543445,
0.4143836498,
-0.4472901821,
-0.0044058319,
-0.1672314554,
-0.1959447563,
0.21589908,
0.0603215732,
-0.4893426597,
0.0357990041,
0.3959532678,
0.3313429058,
0.3173384666,
-0.4833236337,
0.5368811488,
-0.101674825,
-0.2425819933,
0.1436207443,
0.1373032331,
0.1149246246,
0.1882810742,
0.4437225461,
-0.300804615,
0.2015660256,
-0.3680510819,
0.1754782796,
0.6180180311,
-0.3741326332,
0.0697345361,
0.6100277901,
0.4855676889,
-0.645694077,
0.5868579149,
-0.2080786228,
-0.4668175578,
0.391767174,
0.2812148631,
0.6912197471,
-0.1280478537,
0.4715194106,
0.1661241949,
0.4198560119,
-0.2801543474,
-0.0984468758,
0.0457218662,
-0.4135788381,
-0.1596330255,
-0.8431490064,
-0.5122901797,
-0.0005122418,
-0.3594458997,
0.5047975779,
-0.2944641113,
0.0019264102,
-0.1296785176,
0.4978178442,
-0.554253161,
-0.0337256975,
0.3443320096,
1.1074699163,
-0.5333934426,
0.7999569178,
0.2883163095,
-0.527710855,
-0.6857843399,
0.0979364291,
0.1401578933,
-0.692828238,
0.5406509638,
0.222511977,
-0.2118291259,
0.3423264027,
-0.2570560575,
-0.8896411657,
1.0805733204,
0.1357136071,
-0.6116337776,
-0.3232967257,
0.1803470999,
0.3036545813,
-0.1773171276,
0.3070446849,
0.143417567,
0.4484500587,
0.4521435499,
-0.669239521,
-0.2251308113,
-0.1017517447,
0.0441452116,
0.4376628399,
-0.9135655165,
0.361676842,
-0.1444569975,
-0.1428452879,
0.0756868422,
0.5042113662,
0.298735559,
0.2679849267,
0.3333519101,
0.7703341842,
0.8396645188,
-0.3590548933,
0.9416271448,
-0.2191511691,
0.4165063798,
1.07374084,
-0.7372465134,
0.9351596236,
0.0317146555,
-0.0146247083,
0.4987395108,
0.6980734468,
-0.2101425529,
0.6300938725,
0.4781947732,
-0.1204268113,
-0.4537054896,
-0.3047352731,
-0.2364008427,
0.8519242406,
-0.009893572,
-0.1583916247,
-0.6800275445,
-0.1386760473,
-0.0381440483,
0.057873968,
-0.345395714,
0.9872956276,
-0.1591483951,
-0.6481659412,
0.2408611029,
0.1833718568,
0.5863367319,
-0.7414839864,
-0.0212788284,
-0.4516284764,
0.0772902668,
0.3678134978,
-0.7083887458,
-0.2990755141,
0.0040675816,
-0.1357480735,
-0.4269482791,
0.571668148,
-0.4629075229,
-0.9198331237,
0.2302016169,
0.3999918997,
0.1048880145,
-0.1106002033,
-0.2898756564,
0.2300709039,
-0.3936940432,
-0.2446143925,
0.6913978457,
0.5777631402,
-0.1626467705,
0.6806629896,
0.5410558581,
0.1538354903,
-0.1629867256,
0.3492702246,
0.6317683458,
-0.5151965618,
-0.4841411114,
-0.9382898211,
-0.1542773843,
-0.1560178697,
0.0105647715,
0.7116968036,
0.911801219,
0.9043710828,
0.343241632,
0.6147661805,
0.4323965013,
0.1396684051,
-0.436689049,
0.9183701873,
-0.6236974001,
0.2012555301,
-0.3223146498,
-1.0225616693,
-0.5473822355,
0.1819763035,
-0.3112869859,
-0.0556309596,
0.525871098,
0.7662806511,
0.2485141307,
-0.1872717589,
0.576033175,
0.1772135347,
0.7149977088,
0.7080055475,
0.4164676964,
-0.2115017325,
0.9286078811,
0.0424196832,
-0.2097547054,
-0.5569031835,
-0.8177233934,
-0.815797925,
-0.3959557414,
-0.3068368137,
-0.2105953842,
0.2919836342,
0.6794577241,
0.5933536887,
-0.4778284431,
-0.236853227,
0.2520525455,
0.440377295,
-0.079854615,
-0.2565090656,
0.4211626649,
-0.3249913752,
-0.957601428,
0.4448444843,
0.7741671801,
-0.1530637145,
-0.267858237,
0.0404046364,
-0.5134891868,
0.289170593,
0.5433136821,
-0.0489663184,
-0.6428662539,
-0.2563081682,
0.2627096474,
-0.295786798,
-0.0472409874,
0.6809686422,
-0.620151341,
0.3844850063,
0.5501878262,
0.6285936832,
0.4325998127,
-0.0150363455,
0.4977551997,
-0.5271157622,
-0.4490593672,
0.1421490759,
0.3514294326,
0.1835142672,
-0.2811164856,
0.6298108101,
0.2372455448,
-0.6244013906,
-0.953656435,
-0.1056357846,
-1.2183235884,
-0.2112583816,
1.1538338661,
0.0128135616,
0.0380972102,
0.2985908389,
0.0356198959,
0.1831765026,
-0.5210770965,
0.998924017,
0.9834648967,
0.0372041985,
-0.1060010195,
-0.2151802629,
0.0936055481,
0.0146898599,
-0.515052557,
-0.0640732422,
0.3105641007,
0.2066523135,
0.113911733,
0.5832887292,
-0.1898342967,
-0.1267105639,
-0.3208521307,
-0.2481460571,
-0.2693559527,
-0.6236877441,
-0.091737479,
0.6364664435,
0.3132493794,
0.0131255742
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11675v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11675v2 | BLoB: Bayesian Low-Rank Adaptation by Backpropagation for Large Language Models | 2024-06-17T15:55:38 | 2024-06-18T15:15:04 | Yibin Wang, Haizhou Shi, Ligong Han, Dimitris Metaxas, Hao Wang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, stat.ML | Large Language Models (LLMs) often suffer from overconfidence during
inference, particularly when adapted to downstream domain-specific tasks with
limited data. Previous work addresses this issue by employing approximate
Bayesian estimation after the LLMs are trained, enabling them to quantify
uncertainty. However, such post-training approaches' performance is severely
limited by the parameters learned during training. In this paper, we go beyond
post-training Bayesianization and propose Bayesian Low-Rank Adaptation by
Backpropagation (BLoB), an algorithm that continuously and jointly adjusts both
the mean and covariance of LLM parameters throughout the whole fine-tuning
process. Our empirical results verify the effectiveness of BLoB in terms of
generalization and uncertainty estimation, when evaluated on both
in-distribution and out-of-distribution data. | [
-0.2185429037,
-0.8065010905,
0.6051664352,
0.1843708754,
-0.1511816233,
0.0762489736,
-0.5461207628,
-0.13715069,
-0.1321412772,
0.4421854913,
-0.4685071409,
-0.7467122674,
-1.0091633797,
-0.4007128477,
0.0662817806,
0.9276405573,
0.2548323572,
-0.000295447,
-0.0050635012,
-0.0670989305,
-0.5272706151,
-0.3229488134,
-0.5765631795,
-0.2002792358,
0.6013023257,
0.4593662024,
0.9635843039,
0.1598495394,
0.4105621874,
0.0795892552,
0.1052719727,
0.0484130383,
-0.7382864356,
0.0893895403,
-0.6492806673,
-0.6476697326,
-0.4388832152,
-0.1062040552,
1.0406618118,
1.122974515,
-0.259375006,
0.2695377171,
0.0415766574,
0.686940372,
-1.1492789984,
0.1329341829,
-0.8816319108,
-0.2507341206,
0.1799721122,
0.0110498732,
-0.4993489087,
-0.5360660553,
-0.0464832783,
-0.4433823824,
0.0234743301,
0.1867843121,
0.6638599634,
0.6120285988,
-0.1262903512,
-0.1758341491,
-0.7228505611,
0.8621270657,
-0.8406030536,
0.644510746,
0.492416501,
0.2418414652,
-0.5918446779,
-0.1527349651,
-0.3492863178,
-0.130298391,
0.1097693443,
0.2871047258,
-0.2053461969,
0.1656492054,
0.136023581,
0.125680536,
-0.6550285816,
0.5031303763,
-0.1350352913,
0.0417148769,
0.6690658927,
-0.3067446649,
-0.1566229314,
0.3658519089,
-0.0448509492,
-0.2696011961,
-0.6496021748,
0.0197463911,
0.2394613028,
0.2967858016,
-0.1930440217,
0.3793842494,
-0.2532121837,
0.8081054091,
0.2115240395,
-0.0724788979,
0.0675431788,
0.210390076,
-0.2120072693,
0.2038496733,
0.3118477166,
0.2085635215,
0.1601375937,
-0.212710768,
-0.0924639851,
-0.2074121088,
0.1661399901,
-0.7181094289,
-0.267334342,
0.3830450177,
-0.3691704273,
0.05790646,
-0.096437946,
-0.9085142612,
-0.3420585394,
0.1218288243,
0.9157889485,
-0.065075241,
-0.0835557655,
0.0799969509,
-0.0116595393,
0.1622958779,
0.4379621148,
-1.0348709822,
0.361340344,
0.6668661237,
0.9191836119,
-0.298070997,
-0.497630924,
-0.8008170724,
0.5212619901,
-0.6880874038,
0.6128525734,
-0.5464990735,
-0.2706964612,
-0.2085316628,
0.0898635313,
-0.3825707138,
-0.5497714281,
0.1094986275,
-0.4644332826,
-0.2056135982,
0.2785816789,
-0.5974336863,
-0.1775019467,
0.021143483,
-0.2471640408,
0.8662278652,
0.2836871147,
-0.435944885,
0.5278787613,
-0.2988454103,
-0.1661121398,
-0.0908618122,
0.1920285076,
-0.6949643493,
0.5680930018,
0.2991627455,
0.6308120489,
-0.2930642664,
0.2033892423,
-0.8426656723,
-0.4454606175,
0.2208440006,
-0.1500604451,
0.4769702554,
-0.1302733272,
0.0689833015,
-0.0130861262,
-0.7714535594,
-0.0506557301,
-0.283680439,
-0.3176250756,
-0.481043905,
0.0855321437,
-0.4703872204,
0.0701151788,
0.365000695,
-0.5073278546,
0.4565288424,
-0.477697134,
0.079457663,
0.6388376355,
0.1477306038,
0.5771926641,
-0.2532492876,
0.3183557391,
-0.1902010441,
0.0158221778,
0.2354451567,
-0.5067828894,
-0.5853718519,
-0.3305474222,
0.471464932,
0.5814713836,
-0.3552818,
0.6684910059,
-0.5960807204,
-0.7182140946,
-0.5106114149,
0.2853975594,
0.2219861746,
0.1550592929,
0.5894436836,
-0.3686595559,
-0.0960966274,
-0.6126989722,
-0.0512475446,
-0.3023222387,
-0.2236724794,
0.1062146425,
0.6191890836,
-0.2443457097,
0.585347116,
-0.6402073503,
-0.0951485708,
-0.1545877159,
0.3658361733,
0.322042346,
0.5791949034,
0.3470744789,
-0.3637354672,
-0.2576853335,
-0.0023508777,
-0.3738761246,
-0.2444570661,
-0.2546215653,
-0.3008379936,
0.4336391985,
0.5420108438,
-0.3922602236,
0.4050343335,
1.2363802195,
-0.074003838,
0.3935899138,
-0.6449779272,
-0.1686129868,
-0.9272654653,
-0.0459488556,
-0.0597383603,
-0.196831882,
-0.2766393721,
0.0036347399,
0.0110780653,
-0.191462487,
0.1112845689,
0.7765799761,
-0.5075580478,
-0.5459494591,
-0.3977973163,
-0.016136311,
-0.213145256,
0.6546307206,
0.1586185694,
0.4924925864,
0.5983256698,
-0.4149129987,
0.2224345058,
0.2198022157,
-0.3301632702,
0.5154923797,
-0.3060175776,
0.0309334323,
-0.033298675,
0.3971262276,
-1.1963659525,
-0.2130597234,
0.1723348796,
-0.3277014792,
0.453214854,
-0.8124035001,
-0.3402922153,
-0.0326488875,
-0.0898647979,
0.0681003556,
0.6142635345,
-0.5494276285,
0.3382389247,
0.2807052433,
-0.5353565812,
-0.3192936182,
-0.7251684666,
0.0296159666,
0.0221878644,
-0.2753891349,
0.3450961709,
-0.1189523339,
0.0871486887,
-0.2013768405,
-0.2323624194,
-0.2637418807,
0.2033633143,
0.403729707,
-0.1081384644,
-0.3234966993,
0.1779915988,
0.6631521583,
0.0251121949,
-0.1249460876,
-0.2812908292,
0.2805278301,
0.2380797714,
-0.3824470639,
-0.2411676198,
0.2640147209,
0.3345710635,
0.1336158216,
1.0035529137,
0.5400626659,
-0.2659884989,
-0.5748557448,
-0.5332180262,
-0.1891364902,
-0.3771388233,
0.4823390543,
-0.3071130812,
-0.7041512132,
0.4484806061,
-0.225558728,
-0.2762920558,
-0.0275242589,
0.7407853007,
-0.2117739469,
0.7572832108,
0.8378489614,
-0.1450576931,
0.4155986309,
-0.0174726713,
-0.0163964015,
-0.6951674819,
0.1351318955,
-0.4183591008,
-0.3377994299,
-0.9220151305,
-0.4139570296,
0.2968637049,
0.4303756058,
-0.233667016,
0.0026079339,
-0.0401247032,
0.0786677748,
0.5229328275,
0.3817019463,
0.1535939276,
-0.028809946,
0.3244419694,
0.1145103574,
-0.7675266266,
-0.0240301806,
1.0722618103,
0.3723105788,
0.9740243554,
0.3273588717,
0.6803719401,
0.1179797053,
0.3760541379,
-0.8244706392,
0.163337633,
-0.3592983782,
-0.5585516095,
-0.6770380139,
-0.4061107337,
-0.9319968224,
0.2886054516,
-0.2669670582,
-1.1018667221,
0.5855569839,
0.3611264527,
-0.4086371958,
-0.0298042241,
-0.7598230839,
1.0068975687,
-0.0595071726,
-0.5323605537,
-0.4533622265,
-0.6729841828,
-0.0139241321,
-0.4391713738,
0.2303745747,
-0.1101329774,
-0.1738924086,
0.5919620395,
-0.1813610792,
0.8399427533,
-0.397377789,
-0.1194593981,
-0.084944047,
0.1134375334,
0.6956940293,
0.1212443411,
-0.2563139796,
0.3546731174,
0.138595134,
-0.8120472431,
-0.877976656,
0.5008512735,
-0.7266148925,
-0.6774419546,
-0.3149695098,
-0.8335953951,
-0.6489601135,
0.0629027262,
0.0984098613,
0.0427554026,
0.0269519053,
0.3596975207,
0.4476786554,
-0.5351038575,
0.4766023755,
0.373660773,
-0.0378186628,
-0.3196111321,
0.8204923868,
0.3168248236,
0.5547005534,
0.6053163409,
0.3635345995,
-0.2254945636,
-1.1783291101,
-0.398362726,
0.2800358832,
-0.4361279905,
-0.0220171865,
-0.2218118161,
-0.1770362109,
-0.3944281638,
-0.425350666,
-0.4349865913,
-0.3337880969,
-0.0137051577,
0.208232373,
0.3276843429,
0.3289003372,
-0.1477836967,
0.8521462679,
-0.7906616926,
0.1717161983,
0.2707505822,
0.3446215391,
-0.2851302624,
-1.0638891459,
-0.5773153305,
0.1680222899,
-0.0922468752,
-0.6671594381,
0.4549076259,
0.5538133383,
0.5837849379,
-0.1123943254,
-0.1135757193,
0.7486160398,
-0.2910854816,
0.4088355303,
-0.0907217786,
-0.7714803219,
0.4926732481,
-0.3807754219,
0.3966713548,
0.4322106242,
0.4863765538,
-0.1352365613,
-0.4400823712,
-0.357765168,
-0.6609728932,
0.5254313946,
0.0369169079,
0.0389111489,
0.5683115125,
0.5238675475,
0.2617764771,
0.4417354763,
-0.4211978316,
0.144522503,
-0.0616248026,
-0.245264858,
-0.5169648528,
-0.3013496697,
0.1549769789,
-0.1335107535,
0.6267957687,
-0.3998959959,
0.142711252,
-0.1830205321,
-0.5745687485,
-0.1419182867,
0.3142768145,
0.537204802,
0.9927363396,
-0.6797465682,
0.0455368795,
0.5032359362,
-0.388846755,
0.0282331929,
0.1442887187,
0.0528541356,
-0.189928934,
0.436812371,
0.7778599858,
0.4365172088,
-0.3295166194,
0.578040719,
0.4576380849,
0.0877111703,
-0.0750434697,
0.1927833706,
-0.0285932496,
0.5383327603,
0.4631254077,
-0.0105562648,
-0.1123443916,
-0.6474570036,
0.220365569,
0.2902029157,
-0.2699536085,
-0.2914430797,
0.3530177474,
-0.1345185786,
-0.0279254057,
0.0219276641,
-0.1624653488,
-0.0965949148,
0.2541315854,
0.5698276758,
0.6064947844,
-0.3981891572,
0.2201959938,
0.1503398567,
0.216627568,
-0.3997765481,
0.1703840792,
0.1437105089,
-0.9353820086,
-0.6800995469,
-0.9148526192,
-0.7839152813,
0.0711020604,
-0.7046352029,
0.1507604122,
-0.6802543402,
-0.0408563502,
-0.0423369594,
0.1101947054,
-0.2749275863,
0.3423553407,
0.1568763405,
0.6400017142,
-0.8855414987,
1.1486657858,
0.5653473139,
-0.3151080906,
-0.3306334913,
0.3150581419,
-0.371663183,
-0.8131181002,
0.6282865405,
-0.3002091944,
-0.1143611744,
0.4251303971,
-0.6260281801,
-0.9843946695,
0.7625491023,
0.6915135384,
-0.6250613332,
-0.0453505628,
-0.1240268275,
0.5767061114,
-0.3034854531,
-0.0493717939,
0.5725976825,
0.4028632641,
0.0353661403,
-0.8896613717,
0.0881811082,
0.4020517468,
0.0487280041,
0.1248237193,
-0.7379111648,
0.6524258852,
-0.146471113,
0.2895740867,
0.1176781803,
0.6388844252,
0.422363013,
0.2551791966,
0.3648427725,
0.400051713,
0.646709919,
0.0449241474,
0.84104985,
-0.1147041395,
0.5096893907,
1.3400541544,
-0.1210820451,
1.1512022018,
0.4541932642,
-0.1914146841,
0.5446053147,
0.6289228201,
-0.2484314889,
0.6877602935,
0.1546732038,
0.1116535217,
-0.3773259521,
0.1842174679,
-0.2050878108,
0.3613744676,
0.6832402945,
-0.2372840643,
-0.1874762774,
-0.0414982028,
0.00633401,
-0.1255268455,
-0.6190564036,
0.6347001195,
0.2259276509,
-0.6286590695,
0.9120371342,
-0.126613915,
0.4661138654,
-0.2892125845,
0.076810658,
-0.1725336462,
0.2696483433,
-0.2299447805,
-0.6730818152,
0.1964260638,
-0.3629532158,
-0.0621015541,
-0.0312675424,
0.4445248842,
-0.4954663515,
-0.7467147708,
0.4182636738,
0.5029317737,
0.2941429913,
-0.2702858448,
-0.6742738485,
0.0649308413,
-0.4098353982,
-0.3826906681,
0.4622569382,
0.4350761175,
-0.1817342788,
0.8159082532,
0.4787130654,
0.6777665615,
0.2938638926,
0.0307040866,
0.4969980419,
-0.5374634266,
-0.3142839968,
-0.6717620492,
0.2106881589,
0.2287006527,
-0.2073919326,
0.404437989,
0.3310038745,
0.9331530929,
-0.0013340097,
0.8043991327,
0.2219352275,
0.4548085928,
-0.837816298,
0.6646031737,
-0.6534861326,
-0.0020861095,
-0.373924017,
-1.0120176077,
-0.5470000505,
0.7291968465,
-0.7844662666,
-0.0070375502,
0.6033099294,
1.0281145573,
-0.2462798804,
-0.4851562381,
0.7475262284,
0.4521730542,
-0.0777668133,
0.7394782305,
0.425837934,
-0.3651699424,
0.3924170136,
-0.1564907432,
-0.2872520983,
-0.6679109931,
-0.8352864385,
-0.911806047,
-0.2755733132,
-0.3801029027,
-0.2013242394,
0.660605073,
0.8359681964,
0.7925035357,
-1.1055183411,
-0.3866356015,
0.047840789,
0.1798829436,
-0.2888017893,
-0.0420596972,
0.5331372023,
-0.2980159521,
-0.6596229672,
0.3285796046,
0.3027894795,
0.013292498,
-0.0728676543,
0.0162855834,
-0.3024526834,
-0.0214683246,
0.5123322606,
0.1968158484,
-0.410679251,
-0.832234025,
-0.5602532625,
-0.0184144154,
0.1578451693,
0.3296941221,
-0.3763842583,
0.2994376421,
0.3520332575,
0.7673196197,
0.7566318512,
0.230545491,
0.7393119931,
-0.7912456393,
0.4378500581,
-0.1049741581,
0.1914149672,
0.2617901266,
-0.2477069497,
0.3934862912,
0.1456715763,
-0.6209417582,
-0.9217626452,
0.2163875103,
-1.011438489,
-0.5571140647,
1.2792482376,
-0.3506237566,
-0.2037129104,
-0.1103402004,
0.1159882545,
0.4752862453,
-0.5185045004,
0.8880816102,
0.711818099,
-0.034057375,
-0.4233908653,
-0.6585611105,
0.2960451543,
0.3456475735,
-0.7143356204,
0.1579522789,
0.3089568615,
0.431463331,
-0.159150362,
0.1451696903,
0.4049630463,
0.1878641248,
0.0260102842,
0.0761967599,
0.2730089128,
-0.3874818981,
-0.4880454242,
0.1792669594,
0.4427052736,
-0.1375193298
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11674v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11674v1 | Endor: Hardware-Friendly Sparse Format for Offloaded LLM Inference | 2024-06-17T15:55:08 | 2024-06-17T15:55:08 | Donghyeon Joo, Ramyad Hadidi, Soheil Feizi, Bahar Asgari | cs.CL | cs.CL | The increasing size of large language models (LLMs) challenges their usage on
resource-constrained platforms. For example, memory on modern GPUs is
insufficient to hold LLMs that are hundreds of Gigabytes in size. Offloading is
a popular method to escape this constraint by storing weights of an LLM model
to host CPU memory and SSD, then loading each weight to GPU before every use.
In our case study of offloaded inference, we found that due to the low
bandwidth between storage devices and GPU, the latency of transferring large
model weights from its offloaded location to GPU memory becomes the critical
bottleneck with actual compute taking nearly 0% of runtime. To effectively
reduce the weight transfer latency, we propose a novel sparse format that
compresses the unstructured sparse pattern of pruned LLM weights to non-zero
values with high compression ratio and low decompression overhead. Endor
achieves this by expressing the positions of non-zero elements with a bitmap.
Compared to offloaded inference using the popular Huggingface Accelerate,
applying Endor accelerates OPT-66B by 1.70x and Llama2-70B by 1.78x. When
direct weight transfer from SSD to GPU is leveraged, Endor achieves 2.25x
speedup on OPT-66B and 2.37x speedup on Llama2-70B. | [
-0.2697323561,
-0.833057642,
0.4707916081,
0.1819898039,
-0.5766135454,
-0.1280873269,
-0.3146588802,
-0.2799058259,
0.3911189139,
0.5272156,
-0.3210826814,
0.0772747099,
-0.5190008283,
-0.1863146871,
-0.4598914087,
0.8808190227,
-0.1908307225,
-0.3195951283,
-0.5069041848,
-0.2555860281,
-0.0432573333,
-0.4446420968,
-0.7796078324,
-0.1613334864,
0.2864211798,
0.1387524009,
0.8923224807,
0.8673637509,
0.3846369386,
0.4133959413,
-0.1569142491,
-0.076103434,
-0.6642848253,
0.0961738601,
0.2896407545,
-0.3481612802,
-0.4854531586,
-0.2808690369,
0.716453433,
0.6916170716,
-0.5303000212,
0.3554219902,
-0.0104047032,
0.5224754214,
-0.8183426857,
0.0594188794,
-0.3126662374,
-0.1364485472,
-0.3224410117,
-0.2646187246,
-0.4193337858,
-0.1951567978,
-0.4106812477,
-1.0581811666,
0.2351537198,
0.4111886024,
0.7261021733,
0.8309683204,
-0.0089293318,
0.0967063904,
-0.7023340464,
0.7377756834,
-0.4656533003,
0.3782969117,
0.2353600115,
0.3896704912,
-0.2883889377,
-0.6419007778,
-0.6553707123,
0.3111790717,
0.1465608627,
0.1056600064,
-0.2989604473,
0.2451201677,
0.2735163569,
0.394376725,
-0.6106838584,
0.051946681,
-0.1759784967,
0.052472949,
0.4762815833,
-0.2405547649,
0.1242257282,
0.3079046607,
-0.3139759302,
-0.0800301507,
-0.8440846801,
-0.360004425,
0.4020785987,
0.0360810868,
-0.3390831053,
0.4185936153,
0.0988434926,
1.0819270611,
-0.0487774462,
-0.0608398505,
-0.0206994414,
-0.0122342436,
-0.4397446811,
0.3260191977,
0.551358521,
0.4892686605,
0.0571353287,
-0.3532469273,
-0.3245957196,
-0.064154759,
-0.0049267528,
-1.3463089466,
-0.1925155669,
0.1345059574,
-0.7582061291,
-0.028355116,
-0.3965625465,
-1.031137228,
-0.2505573928,
0.0490365513,
0.3796541393,
0.0362133682,
-0.1065092534,
0.2375320345,
0.0974654555,
0.1664506644,
0.4372504056,
-1.059545517,
0.7645791769,
0.4169672728,
1.1315801144,
-0.3064648509,
0.473385483,
-0.89598912,
0.2614894211,
-0.2152169496,
0.8452341557,
-0.4934079051,
-0.3449691534,
-0.3176068962,
0.058950901,
0.0897954777,
-0.6685546637,
0.4432819486,
-0.4927285612,
-0.0499544218,
-0.1845103204,
-0.4067305923,
-0.2849911451,
-0.0250380952,
-0.7707083225,
1.3397315741,
0.4555178881,
-0.5396622419,
0.3145038188,
-0.1666967273,
-0.3031052649,
0.1866652668,
-0.2991124392,
-0.6043491364,
0.3639492691,
-0.0455019623,
0.3208675385,
-0.5914112926,
0.2430237085,
-0.549511075,
-0.759337008,
0.0094133196,
-0.3061951399,
0.5180567503,
0.3617850542,
-0.1537611783,
0.1229008734,
-0.9574607611,
-0.1258597672,
0.2011446804,
-0.3020016551,
-0.3414410949,
0.008340436,
0.2276930958,
0.1805832982,
0.3515522182,
-0.9719830751,
0.1316715479,
-0.1005548686,
0.4791495502,
0.7235656381,
-0.5347002745,
0.3670848012,
-0.3698167205,
0.530218184,
-0.4002849162,
-0.0646128058,
0.081139043,
-0.4202984869,
-0.8047325015,
-0.7284104824,
0.0229816344,
0.5956368446,
-0.5437919497,
0.291513592,
-0.1578056663,
-0.2824548185,
-0.5276119709,
0.3361862004,
0.3410692513,
0.5885838866,
0.4566134512,
-0.2246000618,
-0.5533388853,
-0.5815014243,
0.3056019247,
-0.1406656653,
-0.0166095607,
0.5193160772,
0.1632265002,
0.2300004959,
0.7344933152,
-0.6034206152,
-0.2086790055,
-0.3553878665,
-0.0055559902,
0.228843689,
0.5484256148,
0.6878684163,
-0.5334421992,
-0.2948458791,
-0.0414478667,
-0.6086336374,
-0.5227848887,
-0.3438917398,
-0.3613895476,
0.2292847782,
0.6247242093,
-0.6581127048,
0.2493045628,
0.8009742498,
-0.3234774768,
0.3048456013,
-0.6487392187,
-0.1720630974,
-1.0369950533,
0.0702570528,
-0.0236420203,
-0.4236338437,
-0.3065213859,
-0.2141045183,
-0.0231406745,
0.0611722358,
-0.2281595021,
0.6395366788,
-0.5034456849,
-0.4639535844,
-0.2064447105,
-0.0970466658,
0.0647458732,
0.3417501748,
0.1910083145,
0.9955418706,
0.40881145,
-0.3730393648,
0.343378067,
0.1277976483,
-0.0233700927,
0.3966236711,
-1.0095620155,
0.0207690615,
-0.3265577555,
0.0532224774,
-1.2059322596,
0.0959931612,
0.1533126682,
-0.0782051682,
0.8415474892,
-0.3353216946,
-0.5656144023,
0.0133484332,
-0.2980347574,
0.566640079,
0.7929552197,
-0.5984969139,
0.4957213402,
0.2532257438,
-0.3162493408,
-0.4001556933,
-0.8246398568,
0.0066152341,
-0.3375992775,
-0.4855429232,
0.6116861105,
-0.3136486709,
-0.2665582895,
0.1172939166,
-0.0665944219,
-0.1394226849,
0.0768440589,
0.5042780042,
0.5501096845,
-0.433137089,
-0.3982902169,
0.1469668895,
-0.1861946285,
-0.1667717099,
-0.2719967663,
0.4351215065,
0.1136875749,
-0.3700659573,
-0.1488834471,
0.4234507382,
0.3987104595,
0.3794163764,
0.8376331925,
0.3691001534,
-0.4258361757,
-0.0699930713,
-0.5529014468,
0.0560100302,
-0.4768174887,
0.4289138317,
-0.1484212279,
-0.8105559945,
0.501986444,
-0.0842923746,
0.1209952906,
0.1335710585,
0.5682864189,
0.1563699543,
0.8103991151,
0.7835533023,
0.0840948001,
0.4598895609,
-0.1832912266,
0.1150134802,
-0.6719409823,
-0.218137309,
-0.4720194638,
-0.6146655679,
-0.2682445347,
-0.8865858316,
0.0130527774,
0.3147375882,
-0.108328782,
0.2153915763,
-0.6046164632,
0.3483750522,
0.1093385071,
-0.1932045072,
0.2878780663,
0.3041982949,
0.1200589612,
-0.1276455373,
-0.5410093665,
-0.2999556065,
0.8709076643,
0.0150946984,
1.2118797302,
0.2760495842,
0.4121380746,
0.2053330541,
0.5030249953,
-0.6226760149,
0.6264775395,
-0.3847518563,
-0.2641713023,
-0.1343270689,
-0.5329639316,
-0.5564621687,
0.2281048596,
0.0624509603,
-0.8281934857,
0.0937833637,
0.2819038332,
-0.5535536408,
0.5926006436,
-0.5871403217,
0.6567865014,
-0.3247300982,
-0.8513527513,
-0.025487043,
-0.4391490817,
0.2011275589,
-0.0832149833,
0.0262480211,
-0.1717193425,
-0.4104251564,
0.8705965281,
-0.7863024473,
0.6632137895,
-0.3414365351,
-0.0474328846,
0.4113176465,
0.3128422201,
0.6179887056,
-0.1284065396,
-0.111964561,
0.2671850324,
0.0170595758,
-0.2650066018,
-0.7179707289,
0.6791784167,
-0.8511404991,
-0.2194161862,
-0.3530166447,
-0.7712721229,
0.1578836888,
0.0773701891,
0.1579648405,
0.3894924223,
0.1054919362,
0.0345109403,
0.8834750652,
-0.2810491621,
0.7212967277,
0.5158393979,
-0.0187944043,
-0.195029512,
1.1770892143,
0.2515023053,
0.2662474811,
0.379276216,
-0.040867351,
-0.4958205223,
-0.777910471,
-1.0469181538,
0.2249515355,
-0.3159455061,
-0.3053770959,
-0.5364241004,
-0.1167485714,
0.0104113473,
-0.6310213804,
-0.6988986731,
-0.7286530137,
-0.4196495116,
0.1860519499,
0.6299394369,
0.5097586513,
-0.0913044214,
0.8072507977,
-0.3842921555,
0.332959801,
-0.2059368491,
0.450776726,
-0.1496867687,
-0.9289200902,
0.0746215954,
-0.4105927944,
-0.1280243397,
-0.4869773388,
0.6184248924,
0.5818226933,
0.4590520561,
0.7985979915,
0.0626943633,
1.0202559233,
-0.1426405758,
0.3557937443,
0.3497898579,
-0.6031329036,
0.0325266942,
0.0099859824,
-0.2250393033,
0.3319715559,
0.4714567065,
-0.3356024027,
0.1425053626,
-0.2450664937,
-0.9097210765,
0.5854100585,
-0.0551903248,
-0.0894168541,
-0.0228314176,
0.5683221221,
0.295791328,
0.2062458396,
-0.44548437,
-0.334939301,
-0.2169272155,
-0.3038632572,
-0.0667999536,
-0.4862384498,
0.0994624272,
-0.0387957245,
0.5299691558,
-0.3824767172,
0.4170802534,
0.2981596887,
-0.3534621894,
-0.2527991533,
0.1172069833,
0.4134214818,
0.3405225873,
-0.5820155144,
0.3263840675,
0.0405520201,
-0.4948278069,
0.2088868022,
0.4401242137,
-0.4810341597,
-0.1792393625,
-0.0951665342,
0.6375240088,
0.2659450769,
-0.7790150046,
0.2861125469,
-0.1907700151,
-0.0995357335,
-0.1512777209,
-0.2035771906,
-0.0075128926,
0.0103278328,
0.1252841353,
-0.0711593255,
0.0963179246,
-0.0330143571,
0.151390478,
0.5466043949,
-0.42796579,
-0.4570173919,
1.2309693098,
0.0434823222,
0.3005163968,
0.5405020118,
-0.4655424654,
0.0517804511,
0.4645849466,
1.0538657904,
0.6277557611,
-0.0124038691,
-0.096716173,
0.3713492751,
0.2736203074,
-0.1858093739,
0.568459332,
-0.4435912371,
-0.6419335008,
-0.9405382276,
-1.1981468201,
-0.1507225931,
-0.0715994164,
-0.4996220469,
0.0548062027,
-0.7737915516,
0.068216458,
-0.4012490809,
-0.0239926465,
-0.1098637879,
-0.1352760047,
0.4773123264,
0.9376493096,
-0.8293050528,
0.7276290059,
0.4810788929,
-0.128684327,
-0.3247518241,
-0.7059400678,
0.1938006431,
-0.9104757309,
0.5733303428,
0.1583265066,
-0.1282947361,
0.0904923677,
-0.2192015797,
-1.0357494354,
0.9436805844,
0.7672604322,
-0.760204196,
0.054507643,
0.0976683795,
0.0355028734,
-0.2481088042,
0.6363854408,
0.4045704305,
0.3602356315,
0.6363172531,
-0.5540800095,
0.587657094,
-0.3907192349,
0.0672835708,
0.3195235729,
-0.9031504393,
0.9802351594,
-0.4819001853,
-0.0595189705,
0.3766585886,
0.9173992276,
0.2360678315,
0.1761606932,
0.4775153995,
1.0037835836,
0.7596328855,
-0.102651991,
0.8977113366,
-0.4550069869,
0.0930730626,
0.9488551021,
-0.4909326434,
0.8342247605,
0.6794568896,
-0.2192835361,
0.2701376677,
0.8466951847,
0.0464101546,
0.44378528,
0.516902566,
-0.4003659189,
-0.3439204395,
-0.362619251,
-0.2783502936,
0.2791932225,
0.3979935348,
-0.0583335944,
-0.4347828329,
-0.295879364,
0.425427109,
-0.235072881,
-0.3930449486,
0.3347170353,
-0.0263384245,
-0.400726974,
0.5888103843,
0.0016380723,
0.9506043792,
-0.6114351153,
-0.2517224252,
-0.2200418711,
0.3534839153,
-0.3382364213,
-0.4576304555,
0.5118914247,
-0.0884276479,
-0.1831125319,
-0.4947642982,
0.7860609293,
-0.4486045241,
-0.6336631775,
0.3319232166,
0.3681617975,
0.5295200944,
-0.2344166785,
-0.4536571205,
0.3859062493,
-0.221854642,
-0.4753879309,
0.6931871772,
0.1934616268,
-0.2430932373,
0.7842374444,
0.9266571999,
0.4776878357,
0.2807702124,
-0.0123857735,
1.0488110781,
-0.4751724005,
-0.3691954911,
-0.6973585486,
-0.0014589571,
0.026767889,
-0.0891695768,
0.5271941423,
0.9103083611,
0.4791114628,
0.4945611656,
0.5540940762,
-0.4234850705,
-0.035472896,
-0.4055887461,
0.7266087532,
-0.6507663727,
0.0863866135,
0.177872777,
-0.8015172482,
-0.2198633701,
0.6233325005,
0.0563975535,
0.1749737263,
0.3157972097,
0.88278687,
-0.116452232,
-0.1673616767,
0.5009509921,
0.1309383661,
0.0785453096,
0.6284775138,
0.2451872975,
-0.2695399523,
0.7557244897,
-0.2378004938,
-0.4823889732,
-0.2406342775,
-0.9728881717,
-0.6570157409,
-0.1882451028,
-0.5029730201,
-0.2945040166,
0.0378582887,
0.5856276155,
0.9394495487,
-0.5605053902,
-0.2774163187,
-0.0631713942,
-0.1373010725,
-0.1051675752,
-0.1745618433,
0.3050698936,
-0.0293697305,
-0.5173929334,
0.2636037171,
0.5043907762,
0.1343191713,
-0.157423839,
-0.3129687607,
0.0565158948,
-0.0451810025,
0.5827004313,
0.5299494863,
-0.3212954104,
0.0013183954,
-0.0787109882,
0.2524968684,
0.1190768331,
0.8687306643,
-0.9338632226,
0.3075487614,
0.4606231749,
0.7924607396,
0.6376888752,
0.0379126891,
0.3864597082,
-0.6628832221,
0.5729080439,
-0.1095545664,
0.6580950022,
0.4085083902,
-0.4526239932,
0.3267305493,
0.5240802765,
-0.4758981764,
-0.8260678649,
-0.2453027219,
-1.3419139385,
-0.0901745111,
1.0837435722,
-0.2831843495,
-0.6979797482,
-0.1820921004,
0.0411377922,
0.3974632919,
-0.478700012,
0.5259298086,
0.3461391628,
-0.3665724099,
-0.421738714,
-0.9131761193,
0.308091104,
0.4737038016,
-0.7249180079,
0.2524066865,
0.3933199048,
0.0304669812,
-0.0970869064,
0.6224635839,
-0.1679751426,
0.008112873,
0.3432645798,
0.2762801647,
-0.409101963,
-0.10912624,
-0.1687369347,
0.0570675731,
-0.1508351117,
-0.3126492202
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11670v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11670v1 | Benchmarking of LLM Detection: Comparing Two Competing Approaches | 2024-06-17T15:51:46 | 2024-06-17T15:51:46 | Thorsten Pröhl, Erik Putzier, Rüdiger Zarnekow | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This article gives an overview of the field of LLM text recognition.
Different approaches and implemented detectors for the recognition of
LLM-generated text are presented. In addition to discussing the
implementations, the article focuses on benchmarking the detectors. Although
there are numerous software products for the recognition of LLM-generated text,
with a focus on ChatGPT-like LLMs, the quality of the recognition (recognition
rate) is not clear. Furthermore, while it can be seen that scientific
contributions presenting their novel approaches strive for some kind of
comparison with other approaches, the construction and independence of the
evaluation dataset is often not comprehensible. As a result, discrepancies in
the performance evaluation of LLM detectors are often visible due to the
different benchmarking datasets. This article describes the creation of an
evaluation dataset and uses this dataset to investigate the different
detectors. The selected detectors are benchmarked against each other. | [
-0.2017240673,
-0.3610774875,
0.6688663363,
-0.0633704588,
-0.342572242,
0.2995778024,
-0.2000527978,
-0.7039430737,
-0.0612018742,
0.2647502422,
-0.3304947615,
-0.5569500327,
-0.8222583532,
0.441506654,
-0.4115299881,
0.6615071893,
-0.2721832097,
0.2451958358,
-0.2580899298,
-0.1728061289,
-0.4001238048,
-0.5399435163,
-0.8826873302,
-0.5957235694,
0.2137980461,
0.0630865544,
0.1063481048,
0.5642017722,
0.8645781279,
0.3253279626,
-0.3231565356,
0.1469876766,
-0.477612555,
0.1410583854,
0.1176945716,
-0.5016915202,
-0.0081886034,
0.135490045,
0.8809986115,
-0.0553696342,
0.093405053,
0.0066718026,
0.0381898023,
0.5590330958,
-0.6992287636,
-0.0806289315,
-0.7853072286,
0.2645191252,
-0.6186359525,
-0.3689168394,
-0.4279719293,
-0.3834447563,
-0.1198130101,
-0.0409124084,
0.4240097106,
0.0843887255,
0.5368237495,
0.0529689975,
-0.3240932524,
-0.8876415491,
-0.6941248178,
0.855674386,
-0.648907721,
0.27543208,
0.1343389452,
0.6496081352,
-0.0941341892,
-0.6741788387,
-0.4818690121,
-0.3021839261,
0.1408223212,
0.4136493206,
-0.3790682256,
-0.3439921737,
0.2785468996,
0.6347348094,
-0.8142759204,
0.3813060224,
-0.1369988024,
-0.5067594051,
0.6220772266,
0.3831441104,
-0.0528154448,
-0.109454222,
-0.4565393627,
-0.1983168274,
-0.8050316572,
-0.1522277296,
0.5267521143,
-0.0472605713,
0.1072763801,
0.5666775107,
-0.3415329158,
0.4702609479,
-0.3459129632,
-0.326505065,
0.4520878494,
-0.2504083812,
-0.2256027013,
0.0588606112,
1.0070958138,
0.5098313093,
0.2187767923,
-0.0733619332,
-0.6638053656,
0.2946856916,
0.0941353217,
-0.8322709799,
-0.1235019788,
-0.0136142056,
-0.8286237717,
-0.6269047856,
-0.079783991,
-0.4920221865,
-0.6167016625,
0.0074380254,
0.4967687428,
-0.1509514153,
-0.1498517394,
0.1203074604,
-0.1627047062,
0.3825549483,
0.2292326242,
-0.67576015,
0.4356161058,
0.7384090424,
0.8041818142,
-0.5512429476,
-0.0115882475,
-0.2357190251,
-0.1986691952,
-0.1928182393,
1.3128561974,
-0.2342266887,
-0.5341687202,
-0.0193246994,
-0.1968124807,
0.1004492044,
-1.0197125673,
0.9312518835,
-0.4695967138,
0.0744159669,
-0.2399319708,
-0.8384675384,
-0.0087236417,
0.4486900866,
-0.7259916663,
1.3162177801,
-0.0642725527,
-0.9569631219,
0.6348499656,
-0.2023223042,
-0.2273003757,
0.2887018323,
-0.2415450215,
-0.7952218652,
0.1463375241,
0.1323830485,
0.353022635,
-0.3999356627,
-0.0851337984,
-0.1196828261,
-0.6441656351,
0.6658321619,
-0.7539801002,
0.5876380801,
0.4243019521,
-0.0723374337,
-0.1661867201,
-0.9323413372,
0.0038528235,
0.2668056786,
-0.6272934079,
-0.046604,
0.2744380832,
0.2474202216,
-0.2029183656,
0.4288140535,
-0.6346578002,
-0.0536732115,
-0.1386414468,
0.3083716035,
0.6063256264,
0.0679785162,
-0.0229746047,
-0.5013131499,
0.2537414134,
-0.0397176966,
0.0391712599,
-0.1412378699,
-0.3808283508,
-0.7193733454,
-0.1359584779,
0.3635655046,
0.6517021656,
-0.6624805927,
0.2168006897,
0.0608138405,
-0.5648790002,
-0.2391983569,
0.0970053002,
0.5793977976,
0.3988437355,
0.1068001613,
-0.4735209942,
-0.736575067,
-0.805131197,
-0.5876758695,
-0.3451429009,
-0.1957836747,
0.5402370095,
0.4854093194,
0.0185237546,
0.6183231473,
-0.5814583898,
-0.0289045162,
-0.220605731,
0.1318295449,
0.3968938291,
0.2537136972,
0.5125240684,
-0.5874834657,
-0.614584744,
-0.0387263857,
-0.9503780007,
-0.459438771,
0.165725112,
0.3002895713,
0.029452147,
0.7603796721,
-0.0815052539,
0.4394057691,
0.487616539,
0.1858893186,
0.7352522016,
-0.033649046,
0.3045985401,
-0.9736154675,
-0.2976344824,
0.076371491,
-0.428152591,
-0.5694233179,
-0.0441897288,
0.1698213518,
0.1212313771,
-0.6148120165,
0.3370163143,
-0.4644221067,
-0.5562599897,
-0.7398853302,
0.2622647583,
-0.1322725266,
0.1486933678,
0.048036091,
1.0600827932,
0.3356841505,
-0.4321035743,
0.4339284897,
0.0127095627,
-0.7212764621,
0.6762650609,
-0.7571107149,
0.210933134,
0.1935923845,
0.1577881575,
-1.0666013956,
0.1492705345,
0.5726596117,
-0.4654406011,
0.2150954455,
-0.2266356945,
-0.8479767442,
-0.3408646882,
-0.5501366854,
0.4108545482,
0.6581544876,
-0.6709855795,
0.124533236,
0.3516231179,
0.084875077,
-0.3672842085,
-0.6370731592,
0.1741349548,
-0.4195940793,
-0.2327163368,
0.4078625441,
-0.1226588264,
-0.179863587,
-0.214055717,
-0.1116155013,
0.090924412,
0.0893399864,
0.1097784564,
0.1278232485,
-0.2802804112,
0.1223576292,
-0.4077081382,
-0.4099740386,
0.1149591431,
-0.0520455614,
0.4156028032,
0.0880094394,
-0.5068532825,
-0.4514758587,
0.0506881922,
0.054311268,
0.0780804679,
0.255921483,
0.6287530661,
-0.3552042544,
0.0547697879,
-0.7228502631,
0.1048405319,
-0.4986076653,
0.0344283022,
-0.4488655925,
-0.6479591131,
0.3919964433,
-0.2812284827,
-0.2682216763,
0.4626109302,
0.9231085181,
-0.2266991585,
0.6648752689,
0.3920193017,
-0.1981888711,
0.529856205,
0.1884196252,
0.0237682611,
-0.9417680502,
-0.0852004066,
-0.7876718044,
-0.1598486751,
-0.8561295271,
-0.2520897686,
0.0988327637,
0.0191872362,
0.0483748727,
0.6222017407,
-0.6455847621,
0.6948398352,
0.3240219951,
0.3637972176,
0.5931204557,
-0.0072202072,
-0.2387069911,
-0.0021965406,
-0.4849947095,
-0.9831550121,
1.4870501757,
0.161111623,
0.8582258224,
-0.0835054889,
0.8723621964,
0.5539771318,
0.5793220401,
-0.7347053885,
0.6202668548,
-0.2746714056,
-0.3236569762,
0.2184776217,
-0.4783447981,
-1.0800489187,
0.2420410514,
-0.4218680561,
-0.8073456883,
-0.0665910169,
-0.2386149466,
0.3366034925,
0.2825879455,
-0.6584507823,
0.594796598,
-0.119370997,
-0.1019136012,
-0.0616985187,
-0.2383668274,
0.3005788326,
-0.0397634171,
-0.1282666922,
-0.540648222,
0.0874135047,
0.7702487111,
-0.0499921329,
0.5679894686,
0.112992242,
-0.0872712061,
0.4463219345,
-0.2249113023,
0.3265329301,
0.0183186997,
-0.2611998916,
0.1121854633,
-0.1804308444,
-0.1948128343,
-0.0524468534,
0.5581732392,
-0.628631711,
-0.2874236703,
-0.6220849752,
-0.4229108691,
0.0616034642,
0.1229548454,
0.6417495608,
0.545111537,
-0.7053002715,
-0.1633784324,
0.5631738305,
-0.149191916,
0.5658451319,
0.6796061397,
-0.1896664947,
-0.5034800172,
0.7850701809,
-0.1324852854,
0.064356409,
0.777344346,
-0.0061214524,
-0.3942387104,
-0.9688185453,
-0.2247914821,
-0.0450082682,
-0.9180911183,
-0.4139294028,
-0.3457738459,
-0.5314211845,
-0.1926438659,
0.0807355791,
-0.1279179901,
-0.1446311027,
-0.2275316715,
0.2237065583,
0.398627311,
0.845389545,
0.1162359193,
0.5236607194,
-0.4715308547,
0.3340118825,
0.1461490691,
0.4088498056,
-0.1245061532,
-0.3672541678,
-0.3084627092,
-0.2569226623,
-0.6144148707,
-0.6820118427,
0.1628327966,
-0.1101055443,
0.7766361833,
0.3004499078,
-0.2212500125,
0.2234043181,
-0.4747121036,
0.4283752739,
0.0499831848,
-0.9364914298,
0.5638462901,
0.1599941105,
0.2761104703,
0.5248645544,
0.2354315072,
-0.4579352736,
-0.3711781502,
-0.2768112123,
-0.3641363084,
0.4405281842,
0.5186641812,
-0.2087682039,
0.1765049249,
0.2310270369,
0.2157981098,
0.0478399061,
-0.7615751624,
-0.0177701749,
0.2351826876,
-0.2111658901,
-0.1931317896,
-0.4069629014,
-0.1408193856,
0.3233534694,
0.3381953239,
0.0911815763,
0.4549172819,
0.1167288423,
-0.4689851105,
0.2853185534,
0.0900436789,
0.4344789088,
0.335055083,
-0.2172264308,
0.191163376,
0.3006934822,
-0.7832181454,
0.2604872584,
-0.0767014325,
-0.0848463848,
0.2142177373,
0.7686727047,
0.591874063,
0.0380310267,
-0.5430811644,
0.4820534587,
-0.3361132741,
-0.3613381386,
-0.1520069838,
0.2192622572,
0.082187742,
0.4366382062,
0.355232805,
-0.0766107291,
0.4006255567,
-0.371983707,
0.20884417,
0.5402109027,
-0.0551805533,
-0.0154946139,
0.6326814294,
0.0937804878,
-0.5907559395,
0.4372955561,
-0.342097193,
-0.7254987955,
0.9339613318,
0.4514983594,
1.0788103342,
-0.0708701909,
-0.2011823356,
0.3376150131,
0.1771364212,
0.06114088,
0.3366851211,
-0.2794494927,
-1.0233092308,
-0.0362678617,
-0.4645049274,
-0.8671937585,
0.0303412843,
-0.568790257,
0.4472493231,
-0.1965555251,
-0.2523293197,
0.3527344465,
0.405689925,
-0.6005387902,
0.1158846766,
0.1632520854,
0.9066708088,
-0.8844048977,
0.697445333,
0.3816564381,
0.1004957333,
-0.1589281708,
0.2092992663,
0.2794105411,
-1.0531418324,
0.3827039599,
0.4095463753,
-0.2335859239,
-0.2299149483,
-0.3253972828,
-0.3364130557,
1.2562673092,
-0.0624157451,
-0.5287738442,
0.7422648072,
0.1987677664,
0.6779798269,
-0.3887581229,
0.4817942083,
0.5971508622,
0.2871952057,
0.0707219467,
-0.7766584754,
-0.0716604069,
-0.1156533808,
0.1705066115,
0.0947060809,
-0.5210050941,
0.787740171,
0.2551024556,
-0.6155153513,
0.4385360181,
0.2902441621,
0.5629172921,
0.8106795549,
0.2569360733,
0.5929657817,
0.4368071258,
-0.2432646751,
0.7814387083,
-0.1925623417,
0.5155618787,
0.8667708635,
-0.6524128914,
0.8742604852,
0.2686851323,
-0.7376973629,
0.1313576847,
0.8814244866,
-0.4335045815,
0.5230098963,
0.4730783701,
-0.7095751762,
0.209970206,
-0.0332803987,
-0.4507319629,
0.350092262,
0.2676567137,
-0.4342657924,
-0.4635433555,
-0.2766362727,
-0.3182869256,
0.0806526318,
-0.3605111539,
0.8714684844,
0.0683120936,
-0.3685786426,
0.5534576774,
0.1792017817,
0.9217193127,
-0.3767588437,
0.2808556557,
-0.1137811318,
0.2714293003,
-0.2559190094,
-1.053047061,
0.2802298963,
0.3461493552,
-0.1430382878,
-0.2236987799,
1.2354388237,
-0.1062376797,
-0.3104850352,
0.2126359046,
0.6488823891,
0.6026794314,
0.2480041385,
-0.6770153642,
0.4899264574,
-0.1227795109,
-0.1156313494,
0.3346828222,
0.4227083325,
0.1754557788,
0.4925682843,
0.574578464,
-0.0596031509,
-0.0359828956,
0.2386337072,
0.7612367272,
-0.6499328017,
-0.1040677577,
-1.0269212723,
-0.1654866189,
-0.1294715554,
-0.2637521029,
0.7951021791,
0.9839645624,
0.7863857746,
-0.1350157857,
0.5411549211,
0.183713004,
0.5216533542,
-0.8393337727,
0.4463941157,
-0.3545309007,
0.571318388,
-0.2772652209,
-0.9618473053,
-0.2865435779,
0.6956766248,
-0.1090641096,
0.0714794025,
0.7620749474,
0.8258318901,
0.0623481832,
0.0659879893,
0.3313490152,
-0.0626371652,
0.3508330286,
0.8659957051,
1.1679612398,
-0.7286376953,
0.6196249127,
0.0593105555,
-0.1023305058,
-0.2906919718,
-1.3060827255,
-0.7938057184,
-0.4699210227,
-0.2930568159,
-0.11732997,
0.0820688978,
0.2057367712,
0.4623663723,
-0.7272257209,
-0.3218848109,
-0.2135153562,
0.2453006208,
-0.1477542222,
-0.210813418,
0.2004270256,
-0.0837678984,
-0.8334396482,
0.4267012775,
0.4499091506,
0.3494002521,
-0.1691436023,
0.0592536516,
0.0900798962,
0.0466726124,
0.4704812467,
0.2375611216,
-0.3831457198,
-0.1742775738,
-0.3370757997,
-0.4741551876,
0.4487679899,
0.8916995525,
-0.9401980042,
0.1910578609,
0.7808766365,
0.5173363686,
0.9888851047,
-0.3196826577,
0.1736680865,
-0.573830843,
0.0306220446,
0.1305126399,
0.382792145,
0.3565486968,
-0.2279945612,
0.7944338918,
0.3544267416,
-0.9066483378,
-0.8717806339,
0.4185004532,
-1.0618107319,
-0.0929690823,
0.8794023991,
-0.1632555574,
-0.054764986,
0.0318663605,
-0.2211738229,
0.1396321803,
-0.1448023766,
0.5721009374,
0.9369375706,
-0.3751279712,
0.0082174186,
-0.5867920518,
0.2558046281,
0.0071771457,
-0.8949064612,
-0.2028435469,
0.0757523999,
0.5357429981,
-0.2048075348,
0.9081415534,
-0.2633816302,
0.15295057,
0.3317799568,
-0.0424492136,
0.2039595544,
0.1594726294,
-0.407137692,
-0.1009444296,
0.1399908662,
-0.4412538707
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11668v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11668v1 | "Not Aligned" is Not "Malicious": Being Careful about Hallucinations of Large Language Models' Jailbreak | 2024-06-17T15:51:01 | 2024-06-17T15:51:01 | Lingrui Mei, Shenghua Liu, Yiwei Wang, Baolong Bi, Jiayi Mao, Xueqi Cheng | cs.CL | cs.CL | "Jailbreak" is a major safety concern of Large Language Models (LLMs), which
occurs when malicious prompts lead LLMs to produce harmful outputs, raising
issues about the reliability and safety of LLMs. Therefore, an effective
evaluation of jailbreaks is very crucial to develop its mitigation strategies.
However, our research reveals that many jailbreaks identified by current
evaluations may actually be hallucinations-erroneous outputs that are mistaken
for genuine safety breaches. This finding suggests that some perceived
vulnerabilities might not represent actual threats, indicating a need for more
precise red teaming benchmarks. To address this problem, we propose the
$\textbf{B}$enchmark for reli$\textbf{AB}$ilit$\textbf{Y}$ and
jail$\textbf{B}$reak ha$\textbf{L}$l$\textbf{U}$cination $\textbf{E}$valuation
(BabyBLUE). BabyBLUE introduces a specialized validation framework including
various evaluators to enhance existing jailbreak benchmarks, ensuring outputs
are useful malicious instructions. Additionally, BabyBLUE presents a new
dataset as an augmentation to the existing red teaming benchmarks, specifically
addressing hallucinations in jailbreaks, aiming to evaluate the true potential
of jailbroken LLM outputs to cause harm to human society. | [
-0.092040062,
-0.5924169421,
0.2155848742,
0.4570464492,
-0.2304162085,
0.2977258563,
-0.3770633936,
-0.8188117743,
0.4062474966,
0.5742256045,
-0.4577047527,
-0.4369439781,
-0.5521326661,
-0.0445871949,
-0.5458779335,
0.9841977358,
0.1338020116,
-0.1411149055,
-0.0851119384,
-0.2142715752,
-0.8367729783,
-0.2930983007,
-0.2636972666,
-0.1424970627,
0.2814481854,
0.3372469246,
0.7591751218,
0.4763323665,
0.7468639612,
0.2631502748,
0.0074848179,
-0.0292881038,
-0.5899313688,
0.6284584403,
-0.0876898393,
-0.1457104683,
-0.2274960726,
0.0614643805,
0.1445061713,
0.3902460635,
-0.2667923868,
0.0562361404,
-0.2888736725,
0.9038847685,
-1.056040287,
-0.4026249349,
-0.8570247889,
0.1285600066,
-0.2251330167,
0.1852550358,
-0.8006120324,
-0.4607500732,
-0.0852321312,
-0.2970175445,
-0.1289658993,
0.4490437508,
1.0001437664,
0.6236789823,
-0.1150508374,
-0.0581163354,
-0.6273260713,
0.8076124787,
-0.6359085441,
0.4275830388,
0.3611249328,
0.5231977701,
-0.3827186525,
-0.2759182155,
-0.1342428029,
-0.4776363671,
0.0658908859,
0.0535949729,
-0.3499954641,
-0.0435792096,
0.3260698617,
0.0198509227,
-0.6243792772,
0.4368165135,
-0.4906637371,
-0.3936434984,
1.042075634,
0.1429729313,
0.4691778123,
0.1243786365,
-0.5262432694,
-0.0177058391,
-0.8241432905,
-0.2548340261,
0.5359268785,
0.2915319204,
-0.4854777455,
0.5952966213,
0.1823664159,
0.7379466891,
0.1380971223,
0.0908159465,
0.4449693263,
-0.0735041872,
-0.3342338204,
0.4345494807,
0.9613977671,
0.7940633297,
0.494882077,
-0.6645383835,
-0.2373478711,
0.4050407708,
0.7796449661,
-0.740391016,
-0.4426377118,
0.3086047769,
-0.3081170917,
-0.43313694,
0.1303175986,
-1.1015371084,
-0.9214136004,
0.2762764394,
0.4491842985,
-0.3705762029,
-0.2689596117,
-0.0553431548,
-0.1308803707,
0.2150384635,
0.055778984,
-0.9265078902,
0.303308785,
0.7955893874,
0.6049702168,
-0.2641057968,
-0.2812031209,
-0.3747945428,
0.0914699063,
-0.4421157241,
0.6960392594,
-0.5085684657,
-0.3941886127,
-0.0546750128,
-0.1077608317,
-0.1587247252,
-0.8591942191,
0.4255236685,
-0.3596761823,
-0.2592185736,
-0.1158719361,
-0.4063111246,
0.0702922642,
0.2826201022,
-0.6764787436,
0.7662854791,
0.0579033494,
-0.6892492175,
0.6546295881,
-0.3371139169,
-0.7099927068,
0.0766805857,
-0.1326042563,
-0.6757540703,
0.0615721531,
-0.0357046612,
-0.0016865989,
-0.2081472576,
0.4138403237,
-0.4562013745,
-0.4853134751,
0.336124599,
-0.2095108032,
0.8293743134,
0.1664864421,
-0.6148686409,
0.1754439175,
-0.7473753095,
0.2314922363,
0.0190841928,
-0.0819414631,
-0.4278785586,
-0.0056684962,
-0.0234299581,
-0.0219233539,
0.3387395442,
-0.650393486,
0.0143752713,
-0.4387439191,
0.3890828192,
0.6750271916,
-0.0704992861,
0.3222904801,
-0.4023492336,
0.5570576191,
-0.0735779405,
0.3680171967,
0.3334079981,
-0.443487972,
-0.5072304606,
-0.3249038458,
0.2345236093,
0.6046459079,
-0.357780844,
0.6426721811,
0.0200832896,
-0.7903955579,
-0.5557262301,
-0.0216224752,
0.7872367501,
0.3204729557,
0.4855481386,
-0.229058817,
-1.0080451965,
-1.1865069866,
-0.5224764943,
-0.4553474188,
0.5180689096,
0.000108982,
0.5979565382,
-0.3545313776,
0.6268609762,
-0.1032465845,
-0.1397610009,
-0.2687340081,
-0.0220786668,
0.1409282237,
0.6318082809,
0.3757631481,
-0.507889092,
-0.4447620213,
-0.1895737499,
-0.781303525,
-0.4287341535,
-0.0083761867,
-0.0384180732,
0.4260564744,
0.5336652994,
-0.5154201388,
0.3072202206,
0.8907206655,
-0.5928294063,
0.783538878,
-0.014080449,
0.1075397804,
-0.7663639188,
-0.0001239784,
0.059203051,
0.0357669182,
-0.6472929716,
0.2660211325,
0.2521646023,
0.1008671969,
-0.5047943592,
0.4843351841,
-0.3236036003,
-0.1261421591,
-0.1153194234,
0.1989617795,
-0.053832408,
-0.0433376506,
-0.4434198737,
0.9007635713,
0.3628646433,
-0.0583422855,
0.3910510838,
-0.0099620512,
-0.4966616333,
0.4377957284,
-0.46138677,
0.173637107,
0.2589032054,
-0.1245206222,
-0.6758311987,
-0.1383264661,
0.2401824296,
-0.4228293896,
0.4108614624,
-0.187080875,
-0.681938231,
-0.3456474543,
-0.4041683674,
0.5231651068,
0.5865603089,
-0.3762225509,
0.1356249899,
0.6966792941,
0.4767031968,
-0.8410500288,
-0.7758221626,
0.1815718859,
-0.5564953685,
-0.7547639012,
0.4149979055,
0.2227938622,
-0.6351243258,
0.1061319932,
-0.2891021967,
-0.1067078784,
0.4024915695,
0.5369218588,
0.5095418096,
-0.0933378115,
-0.1538627297,
-0.1393118352,
-0.1705567688,
0.26380077,
0.1567217857,
0.4430262744,
-0.1399248987,
-0.3042930961,
-0.1136860624,
0.0079096472,
0.6356161833,
-0.1608826667,
0.8693561554,
0.1299739331,
-0.5363004804,
-0.3296692669,
-0.7729572058,
-0.1521003097,
-0.4678872526,
0.2129615992,
-0.0249877404,
-0.9160994887,
0.6033902168,
0.3947946429,
0.0176894683,
0.1980800927,
0.480114013,
-0.0123256948,
0.7883386016,
0.5229768753,
-0.2806544304,
0.1690821797,
0.2234289497,
0.4900852442,
-0.8411288261,
-0.5276557207,
-0.5053352714,
-0.4557244182,
-0.757268846,
-0.0957814083,
0.0287101045,
0.1094645858,
-0.4833800197,
0.8269164562,
-0.7098914385,
0.6617124081,
0.3060458899,
-0.1493332088,
0.023129059,
-0.2524367571,
-0.1859143525,
-0.2433304638,
-0.3801736832,
-0.3287469447,
1.0868848562,
0.344455719,
1.1012203693,
0.2774219811,
0.932031095,
0.2176730782,
0.3528211117,
-0.6102185249,
0.704022944,
-0.1085313484,
-0.8807809949,
-0.1749109179,
-0.3778938353,
-1.1405433416,
0.2017220557,
-0.309084177,
-1.326405406,
-0.0024834294,
0.0666150898,
-0.4492312372,
0.132335633,
-0.8414929509,
1.0265442133,
-0.4194435775,
-0.57982409,
-0.2481898218,
-0.6186097264,
0.5346338749,
-0.1951403618,
0.2572134137,
-0.2391971797,
0.1684956551,
0.8444749117,
-0.4257961214,
0.6949919462,
-0.2472155094,
0.1285174787,
0.2404391021,
0.4356105924,
0.3419705629,
-0.1053819582,
-0.1198926866,
0.1199207455,
-0.1958664209,
-0.1143942997,
-0.3848417997,
0.9065805078,
-0.6632694006,
-0.8170760274,
-0.5451288223,
-0.6015518308,
-0.2664723396,
0.193458721,
0.2186206877,
0.0283208489,
0.0175491888,
0.2262024134,
0.4631361067,
-0.3725214303,
0.3716332614,
0.4213734865,
-0.2806023061,
-0.5412647724,
0.7252060771,
-0.0326896757,
0.2070218623,
-0.0725539327,
0.0608004071,
-0.2272691131,
-0.7922723889,
-0.419975996,
0.3900917172,
-0.5501262546,
-0.4070062339,
-0.3040851057,
-0.4330253303,
-0.3602527976,
-0.372428745,
-0.5435699224,
-0.0665983036,
0.1558379233,
-0.2106523365,
0.3444680274,
0.5149695277,
-0.089463003,
0.0539859571,
-0.7572582364,
0.082403563,
-0.1199976131,
0.439478755,
-0.1623773277,
-0.562520206,
-0.3806094825,
-0.2255029529,
-0.3834500611,
-1.083032012,
0.3168867826,
-0.3446773291,
0.7079190612,
0.3640974164,
0.400419414,
0.934908092,
-0.4489561319,
0.6394482255,
0.3582666218,
-0.9552519917,
0.6124629378,
-0.2424280345,
-0.223052159,
1.0603893995,
-0.0978838727,
-0.3045235574,
-0.7209735513,
-0.7306956053,
-0.9838529229,
0.5118669271,
0.2903248966,
-0.0525760166,
-0.091113016,
0.0626081005,
-0.0938848481,
0.3795959353,
-0.9365437627,
-0.2055566162,
0.0226250738,
-0.1640372574,
0.2588113844,
-0.2325776368,
-0.1206375584,
-0.11473988,
0.607776165,
0.4603408575,
0.003759172,
-0.0719359517,
-0.2172216326,
-0.4758509994,
0.1475498378,
0.624060154,
0.5042055845,
-0.3410445452,
0.0979895592,
0.0568372793,
-0.4669068456,
0.2493357658,
-0.1116517708,
-0.0676975399,
-0.2469150424,
0.6563313603,
0.6759046912,
0.2488657087,
-1.0040992498,
0.6316102147,
0.1667263061,
-0.081648685,
-0.4259676039,
0.3430485725,
-0.1144702807,
0.3428403735,
-0.0065345829,
0.1745708585,
-0.1014439687,
-0.5895119905,
0.2692964375,
0.6843934655,
-0.5561388731,
-0.2903171778,
0.7526190877,
0.2351963669,
-0.5355857015,
0.9287988544,
-0.2319964319,
-0.5593378544,
0.8778865933,
0.7426237464,
1.1339749098,
-0.3183228076,
-0.0377338827,
0.4972355664,
0.8103854656,
-0.1517418921,
0.1539521515,
0.308306396,
-0.8501116633,
-0.372792691,
-0.5199995637,
-0.3256818652,
0.2477669418,
-0.7740610242,
0.3487589061,
-0.6789527535,
-0.2347270101,
-0.1921458691,
-0.1818712801,
0.0264882445,
0.1053302661,
0.2755628824,
1.0173383951,
-0.9714265466,
0.8765162826,
0.5320115685,
-0.121023789,
-0.7520278692,
0.173069343,
0.0886038914,
-0.7453523278,
0.552493751,
0.7039599419,
-0.0266413987,
-0.4329075813,
-0.3770806193,
-0.5441805124,
0.7042757273,
0.4462481737,
-0.8940470219,
0.114836663,
-0.1322282255,
0.5412284136,
-0.3358442187,
-0.0749461427,
0.7822671533,
0.731143415,
-0.0929481834,
-0.980135262,
0.3252284527,
-0.311427474,
-0.3935029507,
0.7046433091,
-0.555634141,
0.6393722296,
-0.5921624303,
-0.3197419643,
0.0969262868,
0.1417187601,
0.5936172605,
0.4232984781,
0.5027933717,
0.9865153432,
0.4380310476,
-0.2464990169,
0.8245811462,
-0.3373546004,
0.2111269385,
1.2120194435,
-0.5819590688,
0.779240787,
0.8128229976,
-0.1101767793,
0.4871667922,
0.3703147173,
-0.6402463317,
0.7769441605,
0.4275077879,
-0.0078493301,
-0.2893835306,
0.154350087,
-0.2942779958,
0.2704696655,
0.3056124747,
-0.3850438595,
-0.0584162213,
-0.2861460149,
0.242798835,
0.3762393594,
-0.0186499991,
0.7535094023,
0.1302960068,
-0.93309623,
0.5957760215,
0.0155842202,
0.5823304057,
-0.2349371761,
0.1804416776,
-0.1013088673,
0.1358570904,
-0.4646661282,
-0.6630788445,
0.6184168458,
0.2669275701,
0.1011700183,
0.11200203,
0.5745209455,
-0.0335934237,
-0.3247813582,
0.8297321796,
0.1736361384,
0.050701201,
0.1455114782,
-0.740658462,
0.4043654799,
0.0112398854,
0.0653781295,
0.2659891844,
0.0498715229,
-0.135231182,
0.7903783321,
0.4551073909,
0.2632816732,
0.1531245261,
0.1438680738,
0.73904562,
-0.773706913,
-0.2410869449,
-1.3538321257,
0.5565686822,
-0.0770269036,
-0.3107325137,
0.7734047174,
0.7484084964,
0.7170994282,
0.1781821549,
0.492105633,
-0.1483398825,
0.1352228075,
-0.4069838524,
1.0380218029,
-0.4418162107,
0.4769860506,
-0.4058842659,
-1.0190393925,
-0.450173527,
0.8408926725,
-0.4314161539,
-0.0350350142,
0.8472802639,
0.9888675213,
0.3060637712,
0.0748285577,
0.4173260629,
0.3421940804,
0.1352220029,
0.7133716941,
1.1447855234,
-0.3465208709,
0.4429883659,
-0.3526781797,
-0.1331890225,
-0.3285540044,
-0.9095019698,
-1.041154027,
-0.2134446502,
-0.4820292592,
-0.7055209875,
0.4244259,
0.969303906,
0.528737843,
-0.8856756091,
-0.2921940088,
-0.1802367419,
0.095698759,
-0.1693447381,
-0.1893122494,
-0.0455946103,
-0.2301939726,
-0.3195846379,
0.5338938236,
0.4242854118,
0.0225980561,
-0.3291244507,
-0.0560617261,
0.1129712611,
-0.0680881143,
0.1946709603,
0.196867764,
-0.7693101764,
-0.575073719,
-0.1399124116,
-0.2296185791,
0.1202554405,
0.5421226025,
-0.6464034319,
0.3338335156,
0.1661287248,
0.666922152,
0.0637353733,
-0.0356848873,
0.4388130307,
-0.5786424279,
0.348810643,
0.4345045388,
0.4140891433,
0.3367466629,
-0.3234723806,
0.565361619,
0.00219503,
-0.5877265334,
-1.3143578768,
0.2431641072,
-0.8846853971,
-0.222457692,
1.2224521637,
-0.2194644213,
-0.3583293855,
-0.1449643672,
0.3142106533,
0.1246046647,
-0.5018804073,
1.1495376825,
0.6247759461,
0.0781395882,
-0.0003078419,
-0.4545223713,
0.368480742,
0.4708755314,
-0.7464145422,
0.239371419,
0.4094766974,
0.1247023121,
0.243130371,
0.1122089252,
-0.2907356322,
0.4189494252,
0.1012396291,
0.0230949372,
-0.1553648263,
-0.5360418558,
-0.1744786203,
0.0317367464,
0.1768345088,
-0.1912920773
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11665v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11665v1 | See It from My Perspective: Diagnosing the Western Cultural Bias of Large Vision-Language Models in Image Understanding | 2024-06-17T15:49:51 | 2024-06-17T15:49:51 | Amith Ananthram, Elias Stengel-Eskin, Carl Vondrick, Mohit Bansal, Kathleen McKeown | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV | Vision-language models (VLMs) can respond to queries about images in many
languages. However, beyond language, culture affects how we see things. For
example, individuals from Western cultures focus more on the central figure in
an image while individuals from Eastern cultures attend more to scene context.
In this work, we present a novel investigation that demonstrates and localizes
VLMs' Western bias in image understanding. We evaluate large VLMs across
subjective and objective visual tasks with culturally diverse images and
annotations. We find that VLMs perform better on the Western subset than the
Eastern subset of each task. Controlled experimentation tracing the source of
this bias highlights the importance of a diverse language mix in text-only
pre-training for building equitable VLMs, even when inference is performed in
English. Moreover, while prompting in the language of a target culture can lead
to reductions in bias, it is not a substitute for building AI more
representative of the world's languages. | [
-0.6093233824,
-0.4270373881,
0.4066835344,
0.1786799282,
-0.3091754615,
-0.1638989002,
-0.4238762558,
-1.0020161867,
0.0571597517,
0.5153727531,
-0.6630570889,
-0.3323202431,
-0.6290113926,
0.0142963808,
-0.099253878,
0.6522186399,
-0.1019405052,
0.6486459374,
-0.1765020639,
-0.5697665215,
-0.3223868608,
-0.5241571665,
-0.3456721008,
-0.2378109097,
0.3488768935,
0.0617495365,
0.6685768962,
0.5014207959,
0.4743016958,
0.2634460032,
-0.0793552175,
0.0499610342,
-0.4684992135,
-0.0370879881,
-0.1580293626,
-0.6842135191,
0.2209150344,
0.064139232,
0.3507671356,
0.8187076449,
0.2459145784,
0.5557855368,
0.0071292641,
0.5642391443,
-0.983651042,
0.0462423414,
-0.5617699623,
0.3863119483,
-0.0918957815,
0.0747694373,
-0.5140470862,
0.2203266919,
0.5319282413,
-0.5465948582,
0.2130018324,
0.0253154431,
1.0423846245,
0.3273472786,
-0.613702774,
0.172831893,
-0.7975168228,
0.9434899092,
-0.1339607686,
0.5372984409,
0.372482121,
0.3688463569,
0.2921726704,
-0.3855314255,
-0.4347782433,
0.0264607426,
-0.2680112123,
0.1344033778,
-0.1533742547,
-0.3352347314,
0.4370407164,
0.147971943,
-0.425015837,
-0.0033174697,
-0.5279642344,
-0.4633789062,
0.5944487453,
-0.1173891798,
0.4656811059,
0.1373429447,
-0.3221075833,
0.0264980085,
-0.6167989373,
0.1686571091,
0.0313810743,
-0.1080422476,
-0.2745085955,
0.3349463046,
-0.262491703,
1.099916935,
-0.3222259283,
-0.224874109,
0.0741924569,
-0.2040372789,
-0.3620887399,
-0.1039689928,
0.3754321337,
0.8646556139,
0.6877740026,
0.0935012773,
-0.0132980542,
0.2794075906,
0.2097723633,
-0.6178375483,
0.0096126264,
-0.3881751895,
-0.8423641324,
-0.1432581097,
-0.1304496229,
-0.3150616288,
-0.6177715063,
-0.4474036098,
0.2872174084,
-0.077138491,
-0.1900378168,
-0.2237544656,
-0.3059753478,
0.6412935257,
0.4750858247,
-0.5818228126,
-0.1041582227,
0.2287381142,
0.5777769685,
0.1475102752,
-0.4952905476,
-0.5331255198,
0.0367921777,
-0.5150653124,
0.8147730827,
-0.6680474281,
-0.2673727572,
0.2329621315,
0.1082012355,
0.3173806965,
-0.5123984218,
0.1981631964,
-0.4484060705,
0.3579956889,
-0.7251946926,
0.3242861629,
-0.3106416762,
0.3926972449,
-0.4316293895,
0.5838531256,
-0.1382268071,
-0.8432692289,
0.9924055934,
-0.2352155298,
-0.5697693229,
-0.0058367136,
-0.5294443369,
0.1664767712,
0.3774755895,
0.5758988857,
0.1740253419,
-0.1623211503,
0.0023786391,
-0.294817239,
-0.4166142642,
0.1317543536,
-0.3168041408,
0.7205476165,
0.3885928094,
-0.3248825073,
0.1204191074,
-0.6753562093,
-0.1613312066,
0.3841928244,
0.0674150214,
-0.9778507948,
0.1200971529,
0.2179847807,
0.3639270067,
0.0742156208,
-0.4096388519,
-0.09277343,
-0.0523473211,
0.1926272213,
0.7362716198,
-0.5353246927,
0.6288756132,
-0.0125845717,
0.3052521348,
0.2949911356,
0.3382556736,
-0.3232049346,
-0.3430584967,
-0.8863157034,
-0.2231066525,
-0.2229521126,
0.354799509,
-1.0725449324,
-0.3451787233,
-0.0597363114,
-0.2157742381,
-0.7037354112,
0.076165013,
0.4772405326,
0.5919665098,
0.1315791607,
-0.6120266914,
-0.5190497041,
-1.3090786934,
-0.4797894061,
-0.2089419514,
-0.1768387705,
0.3776772618,
0.2580817938,
-0.1516970694,
0.7065160275,
-0.5332987309,
-0.3761622012,
-0.2183349282,
-0.1709720045,
-0.0459261052,
0.1396394372,
0.7115155458,
-0.8824642301,
-0.5510960817,
0.1217824593,
-0.9379583001,
-0.0524635874,
0.0303276349,
-0.382417351,
0.3430020809,
0.4450637996,
0.0868006796,
0.6893912554,
0.5183769464,
-0.6742756963,
0.224863708,
-0.307633847,
0.2399741858,
-0.6222765446,
-0.1611855626,
0.5240927935,
-0.2565086484,
-0.3712726533,
0.2230498493,
0.1461449116,
0.1436956376,
-0.4981153607,
0.3702857196,
-0.6167716384,
-0.3876335323,
-0.0966040939,
0.1006045863,
0.0576271676,
0.2677085102,
0.704446435,
0.5139632225,
0.8206089139,
-0.4036999345,
-0.1438798755,
0.0745737553,
-0.6288059354,
1.014975667,
-0.3629751503,
-0.0348750576,
-0.6979852915,
0.2251992524,
-0.7718407512,
-0.0996661708,
0.1613592952,
-0.2230139375,
0.1556757838,
-0.3598482609,
-0.053330712,
-0.4168407619,
-0.011985112,
0.5994809866,
0.7652910352,
-0.7192943692,
0.5082925558,
0.3068174422,
0.2749236822,
-0.9166737199,
-1.017401576,
0.0027745208,
-0.132540077,
-0.8461740017,
-0.0905307382,
0.17094405,
-0.8416554928,
-0.0964330509,
-0.1262634695,
-0.1888157576,
0.1287422925,
0.1758706421,
0.3986393511,
-0.4523842037,
-0.1852332801,
-0.3074123859,
0.1969516724,
0.0514034666,
-0.558526516,
0.3556308448,
0.0448844135,
-0.3541559577,
-0.2312988788,
0.4641256928,
0.6890592575,
-0.7163017392,
0.8229855895,
0.715908289,
-0.1837381423,
-0.0958871394,
-0.5639694333,
-0.0687265545,
-0.3935694396,
0.5264046788,
-0.3940979242,
-0.5781183839,
0.5166484118,
0.3398970962,
0.1175483242,
0.2294364274,
0.4801377654,
-0.1461354345,
1.0230193138,
0.9898246527,
0.0002664172,
0.6370541453,
-0.2557820678,
0.2615711093,
-0.6646466255,
-0.3391959071,
-0.4062968493,
-0.4726644754,
-0.461266309,
-0.5446137786,
0.3872005939,
-0.3319253325,
-0.0809002742,
-0.3194832504,
-0.4459167421,
0.8113982677,
0.5053044558,
0.0451676995,
0.4372124076,
0.2234449238,
0.022301944,
-0.4219491184,
-0.5177893043,
-0.4525509179,
0.8842755556,
0.2794949412,
0.8177865744,
-0.1110104248,
0.3967172205,
0.0575820282,
0.591023922,
-0.8235551715,
0.3707813919,
-0.1539361775,
-0.6648331285,
0.0424527302,
-0.0089573385,
-0.6481897235,
0.8668757677,
-0.1330158263,
-0.7974904776,
0.1553339958,
0.2624818683,
0.1275496185,
0.2318376005,
-0.8399306536,
0.8379593492,
-0.205405429,
-0.460470736,
-0.2028407305,
-0.7372502685,
0.6239443421,
0.2045337707,
0.7808435559,
0.1143628135,
0.03597169,
0.4505940378,
-0.2427903265,
0.8474858999,
-0.3489740491,
-0.225593403,
0.0611383878,
0.1716071814,
0.0248205978,
-0.0479377992,
0.2778593898,
0.3402527273,
0.0561849512,
-0.7772980332,
-0.4195913374,
0.5323583484,
-0.8783257604,
-0.6625946164,
-0.3337071836,
-0.5939007401,
-0.2212601751,
0.0994031578,
0.4296573997,
0.5898025036,
-0.1325982511,
-0.1110771075,
0.4999273121,
-0.4527236819,
0.4042705297,
0.6445376873,
-0.5517215133,
0.2187537849,
0.6239068508,
0.2181199044,
0.420480907,
0.116185829,
0.056436196,
0.086838074,
-0.3618064225,
-0.6043350697,
0.0906981453,
-1.1679891348,
0.3963028789,
-0.4780398011,
0.1711942106,
-0.0557048768,
-0.3440792561,
-0.1950835884,
0.0760582909,
0.3105440736,
0.0596230067,
0.0642789677,
0.8652492166,
0.058032643,
0.2067994624,
-0.5526211262,
0.2316513509,
0.3047423065,
0.2887407541,
0.1200218573,
-0.4620865285,
-0.3963687718,
0.0803427175,
0.0327210277,
-0.7011178136,
0.4464910626,
0.0380949192,
0.59525913,
0.493994534,
-0.084826,
0.8131107092,
-0.5529450774,
1.0309699774,
0.117564708,
-0.8259320855,
0.5307025909,
-0.0927020013,
0.5445193052,
0.2533946931,
0.3204797208,
-0.7383342385,
-0.6911839843,
-0.3128118217,
-0.6952968836,
0.7499750257,
-0.2220789492,
0.2771243453,
0.1589040905,
-0.1113549843,
0.1549065709,
0.0076110908,
-1.0553497076,
-0.4353329241,
-0.2920326889,
-0.0464305878,
-0.2121146023,
-0.0943598971,
-0.3465976417,
-0.4004815817,
0.2493855953,
-0.2952349186,
0.0245061796,
0.592015624,
-0.7540854812,
-0.2975279391,
-0.0826837867,
0.5895197988,
0.9451149106,
0.213234663,
0.2684087157,
0.2617129982,
-0.5814875364,
-0.1876714677,
-0.2040078491,
-0.3620412648,
0.079610467,
0.6714838743,
0.9736016393,
-0.2427349389,
-0.7676448226,
0.4023988545,
-0.5513397455,
-0.0474511907,
-0.3249609768,
-0.2496444583,
-0.2719059885,
0.4506282806,
0.5801725388,
0.3319725692,
0.1419065744,
-0.8085988164,
-0.2461093068,
0.6263090968,
-0.7490618825,
-0.2217923552,
0.5488219857,
0.1621573865,
-0.053188242,
0.4254367054,
0.0804866403,
-0.7490891218,
0.7715460658,
0.4876934588,
0.4684737325,
0.1767744124,
0.2622522712,
0.1765758991,
0.5770943761,
0.1658855379,
0.2152592987,
-0.2725942433,
-0.9093105197,
-0.672365725,
-0.5711160302,
0.0273690987,
-0.1148372665,
-0.6624735594,
0.1721543819,
-0.2096155584,
0.1422148794,
-0.0333134457,
-0.4861615002,
-1.0637376308,
0.4692225456,
0.838409543,
0.7686647773,
-1.0713465214,
0.8463674188,
1.0061728954,
-0.2232715338,
-0.706592381,
0.3088183105,
0.0149424756,
-1.1859717369,
1.1147947311,
0.3972828388,
-0.0337031335,
-0.4353148043,
-0.6731004715,
-0.6848771572,
0.6987487674,
0.2629931569,
-0.3517315984,
0.2492775321,
-0.2216616273,
0.613722682,
-0.4583784342,
0.4009696245,
0.5636709332,
0.3464761376,
0.085275948,
-1.0414298773,
-0.1222927719,
-0.1755268425,
0.0874213725,
0.17191571,
-0.6735793948,
0.4493891895,
-0.4892736971,
0.1310846359,
-0.3136788607,
0.5590672493,
-0.0499967821,
0.4430415332,
0.5531994104,
0.0799435005,
0.524248302,
-0.1387898326,
1.3153505325,
-0.0670550242,
-0.0253756996,
0.8101395369,
-0.2021264881,
0.5250284076,
0.7682855129,
-0.0323003754,
0.4375964701,
0.6220420599,
0.2191616595,
0.6895015836,
0.2317203283,
-0.1171163172,
-0.3484713733,
-0.5007542968,
-0.3829900026,
0.6839278936,
0.1392232478,
-0.5553719997,
-0.084233582,
0.2674188614,
-0.1344376057,
0.220923543,
-0.6245798469,
0.6828077435,
0.0343081728,
-0.7796547413,
0.6222251058,
-0.3071931899,
0.8181207776,
-0.4296725392,
0.219884187,
-0.2162355185,
-0.0053279228,
-0.1885039657,
-0.6831824183,
0.2657269835,
0.0815946832,
-0.2805387676,
-0.2912691832,
0.6555639505,
-0.3735029995,
-0.5115234256,
0.4056024253,
0.5558120012,
0.0539775826,
0.0587333664,
-0.2768308818,
0.2619798183,
0.3020751774,
-0.1666846871,
0.3720009029,
0.432711035,
-0.5244559646,
0.4299630225,
0.349950254,
0.081733413,
0.0264465995,
0.2227656096,
0.4187383354,
-0.5013591051,
-0.4845192432,
-0.9342196584,
0.5330712199,
-0.2778186798,
-0.1304958612,
0.4395601451,
0.1400014758,
1.3045682907,
-0.3429442942,
0.9523644447,
-0.0307706073,
-0.1572106183,
-0.4263986349,
0.8095229864,
-0.977098465,
-0.134852916,
-0.1967661381,
-0.871630311,
-0.2459231615,
0.9084326029,
-0.6751279831,
-0.2790776193,
0.6188530922,
0.3927226365,
0.1176117733,
-0.0692331046,
0.5449818969,
0.2547468245,
0.0937343985,
0.2753893435,
1.2608042955,
0.0699116141,
0.4584583938,
-0.3696079254,
-0.2774361074,
0.1007191539,
-0.7477686405,
-0.8980758786,
-0.4940434396,
-0.1693068296,
-0.2083359212,
-0.2976707816,
0.848793149,
0.8690448999,
-0.432361573,
-0.1306094825,
0.4751830399,
0.2168612927,
-0.0646820217,
-0.1489557028,
-0.1364072561,
-0.2018992901,
-0.8602603078,
-0.1300375015,
0.3737460375,
-0.0126444446,
-0.4486453533,
0.0500023179,
0.3551667333,
-0.1150593832,
0.8200773001,
0.0651733577,
-0.9313760996,
-0.2788949907,
0.0429738387,
-0.0670846924,
0.1046807319,
0.7895823717,
-0.7666206956,
0.7639113665,
0.3633276224,
0.3641156852,
0.5174577236,
-0.4898756146,
0.973295629,
-0.4598951042,
0.8226414323,
-0.0646734387,
0.6733157635,
0.461306721,
-0.2976543009,
0.3844221234,
0.3240458965,
-0.1774637699,
-0.764333427,
0.4398965836,
-0.6571415067,
-0.5038949847,
0.922413528,
-0.0132688703,
-0.5340428352,
0.0319465362,
-0.69457829,
0.0481885821,
0.0346943475,
0.5343307853,
0.7967987657,
0.2474308163,
-0.1061991155,
-0.8418157697,
0.3108122349,
0.6944852471,
-0.3240429759,
-0.1839265972,
0.8221902251,
0.2591500878,
0.0483725108,
0.498819828,
0.0411350019,
0.2923133671,
-0.2221230865,
0.0669034347,
0.3911413252,
-0.1396031231,
-0.2841568887,
-0.0790647045,
0.4011242688,
-0.1963503361
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11661v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11661v2 | Cultural Conditioning or Placebo? On the Effectiveness of Socio-Demographic Prompting | 2024-06-17T15:43:45 | 2024-06-20T08:25:08 | Sagnik Mukherjee, Muhammad Farid Adilazuarda, Sunayana Sitaram, Kalika Bali, Alham Fikri Aji, Monojit Choudhury | cs.CL | cs.CL | Socio-demographic prompting is a commonly employed approach to study cultural
biases in LLMs as well as for aligning models to certain cultures. In this
paper, we systematically probe four LLMs (Llama 3, Mistral v0.2, GPT-3.5 Turbo
and GPT-4) with prompts that are conditioned on culturally sensitive and
non-sensitive cues, on datasets that are supposed to be culturally sensitive
(EtiCor and CALI) or neutral (MMLU and ETHICS). We observe that all models
except GPT-4 show significant variations in their responses on both kinds of
datasets for both kinds of prompts, casting doubt on the robustness of the
culturally-conditioned prompting as a method for eliciting cultural bias in
models or as an alignment strategy. The work also calls rethinking the control
experiment design to tease apart the cultural conditioning of responses from
"placebo effect", i.e., random perturbations of model responses due to
arbitrary tokens in the prompt. | [
-0.2175343484,
-0.7158933878,
0.2986465096,
0.4417141974,
-0.2562722862,
0.1839413047,
-0.151937753,
-0.1784307808,
0.4506222308,
0.0600314178,
-0.5970376134,
-0.374462992,
-0.3528716266,
0.2942381501,
0.2301656008,
0.9590942264,
-0.146751821,
0.5549110174,
-0.017644424,
-0.1607345343,
-0.615018189,
-0.7916245461,
-0.4176211357,
-0.536694169,
0.6414731741,
0.5188507438,
0.5907841325,
-0.0252228752,
0.1726309806,
0.108494781,
-0.2120249271,
-0.0663922802,
-0.7264357805,
-0.0734545887,
-0.0178929865,
-0.6778595448,
-0.2029657364,
0.295232147,
0.1316556782,
0.5813862085,
-0.229747653,
0.5269758105,
0.1913157254,
0.313883841,
-0.5579791665,
-0.4147226512,
-0.3802515864,
0.1168609709,
-0.0987015739,
-0.5155048966,
-0.3072372377,
-0.6496772766,
-0.1558264494,
-0.5362877846,
0.4969320595,
0.0730595961,
0.5742313266,
0.4784380496,
-0.8365107179,
0.0470541082,
-0.9117126465,
0.6408939362,
-0.4246477485,
-0.0169385727,
0.7284012437,
-0.02336118,
-0.2747929096,
-0.2660121918,
-0.4413991868,
-0.3044934273,
0.1577162594,
0.5974295735,
0.2664794922,
-0.3514122367,
0.594137609,
0.0718028992,
-0.4253726006,
0.221194163,
-0.7441539168,
-0.4285445809,
0.391410172,
0.3333340585,
0.1780560166,
-0.1454764307,
-0.5827290416,
0.067073904,
-1.0174976587,
0.357714057,
0.5058275461,
0.1843931675,
-0.3930416703,
0.5387792587,
-0.1279778332,
0.3226172328,
0.4465555251,
0.0583960861,
-0.0932284296,
-0.4506100118,
0.0986824557,
0.1906482875,
0.4331924021,
0.8323959708,
0.6382997036,
0.2206775248,
0.0923602805,
0.4428949654,
0.222382918,
-0.7006560564,
0.0263309143,
0.0367662534,
-0.4528814256,
-0.5561779737,
-0.0970650986,
-0.4602217674,
-0.3939842582,
-0.3038921356,
0.1389689595,
-0.1118903533,
-0.1380602121,
-0.2312405407,
-0.2589581907,
0.6542754769,
0.2437682748,
-0.8905472159,
-0.091270797,
0.4202969372,
0.7337870598,
-0.2640535235,
-0.0671754181,
-0.0993732214,
0.0859752819,
-0.6110776067,
0.8184062243,
-0.7339447141,
-0.9698868394,
-0.1370592564,
0.0939582288,
-0.0539977662,
-0.3957866728,
0.4348479807,
-0.5057868361,
0.2378730774,
-1.096065402,
-0.0954268724,
0.1426021457,
0.2546163201,
-0.429279834,
1.0180338621,
0.164362058,
-0.5509754419,
0.9782438278,
-0.0090934876,
-0.4297759533,
0.127482757,
-0.3795457184,
-0.0151656447,
0.0769371092,
0.183123216,
-0.0924723372,
-0.2588279843,
0.3336536288,
-0.8323609829,
-0.7978308201,
0.4215476513,
-0.4059043527,
0.831107378,
0.4898324907,
-0.3977009952,
-0.0380520485,
-0.1116078123,
-0.3721357882,
0.2223432958,
-0.304361999,
-0.301401794,
-0.0963595137,
-0.3442372382,
0.2318532318,
0.0896572098,
-0.477699101,
0.2687748075,
0.1501262784,
0.4700883329,
0.7745884657,
0.164552629,
0.5189635754,
-0.6967650652,
1.064599514,
0.033825431,
0.2902662158,
0.1356375366,
-0.4511429667,
-0.2850258052,
-0.0041968818,
0.2527675629,
0.6712738872,
-0.9116068482,
-0.0795800462,
0.1948336214,
-0.5476632118,
-0.4556989074,
-0.0814367756,
0.0892305598,
0.8118329644,
-0.0898103341,
-0.2038234174,
-0.1982089877,
-0.8456206918,
-0.3324832916,
-0.2075680047,
-0.054263588,
0.2310531437,
0.5422181487,
0.2452727109,
0.8151785731,
-0.2992638648,
0.0903117508,
0.0933634341,
-0.0276217833,
0.1649433821,
0.3928183317,
0.8632819653,
-0.7424158454,
-0.301656425,
-0.3941437006,
-0.5793338418,
-0.451041013,
0.2341418564,
-0.1540976316,
0.062114384,
0.3319158852,
-0.3078292012,
0.675203681,
0.4515124559,
-0.2039479911,
0.7801887989,
0.0271518137,
0.56512779,
-0.8581428528,
-0.0122154132,
0.1398434937,
0.2443874776,
-0.7553775907,
-0.3417161107,
0.3155106604,
-0.2207901925,
-0.5167363882,
0.5560802221,
-0.2386525571,
0.1283611506,
-0.060635861,
-0.0363258608,
-0.0749029964,
0.2764394581,
0.1309910715,
0.9253329039,
0.199999854,
-0.7689461112,
0.0043891198,
0.1767493933,
-0.1250990331,
1.0120192766,
-0.7072651982,
0.4375453889,
-0.4433142543,
0.96943295,
-1.0758640766,
-0.4430764318,
0.4986979961,
-0.4824337065,
-0.2632901371,
-0.1628091037,
-0.0191145074,
-0.5832765102,
-0.494746089,
0.6124668121,
0.6791330576,
-0.2572675347,
0.41598472,
-0.0484722592,
-0.1848462522,
-0.537078321,
-0.6514057517,
-0.1700869501,
-0.8832976818,
-0.4803114831,
0.2671729624,
-0.2198616713,
-0.4044140279,
-0.4462867379,
-0.2554565072,
0.4295780361,
0.2791313827,
0.1114162579,
0.3907515407,
-0.0114646396,
-0.1630663872,
-0.1099909991,
-0.0471562743,
0.0187133271,
0.0500248298,
0.4409473538,
0.3665616512,
-0.5578893423,
-0.399395436,
0.1842217743,
0.2639277279,
-0.107829608,
0.5602665544,
0.4675451517,
-0.184831053,
0.2169547379,
-0.5700745583,
-0.5392628908,
-0.4499847889,
-0.3344772756,
-0.3261177242,
-0.9949183464,
0.9220910072,
0.0619429536,
-0.1837370545,
0.1373446137,
0.8957027793,
-0.1361953467,
1.0349001884,
0.1124031916,
-0.0649666265,
0.6886297464,
0.0565512031,
0.1214393079,
-0.7814770937,
-0.3411032557,
-0.6420685053,
-0.7575950027,
-0.7026157379,
-0.2413416207,
0.3818913996,
-0.0827302113,
-0.4028269351,
-0.3661259115,
-0.3254392147,
0.4090604484,
0.5001001358,
0.2031477988,
-0.078483969,
-0.0274136346,
-0.1803091764,
-0.138808921,
-0.8566349745,
-0.3865824044,
0.7879407406,
0.1113836542,
1.1879246235,
0.1587775797,
0.4432628751,
0.2386959195,
0.7887884974,
-0.6061628461,
0.1534140855,
0.0624192879,
-0.9993489981,
0.152924031,
-0.1239272282,
-0.9286535978,
0.2935234308,
-0.0015213283,
-0.7102357745,
0.7651484013,
0.5494792461,
-0.6553345919,
-0.2046254575,
-0.8867948055,
0.3428159058,
-0.456507206,
-0.5752691627,
0.2142644376,
-0.7307466269,
0.5035072565,
-0.1311572939,
0.3484935164,
-0.3722489774,
0.1438377351,
0.5824179649,
-0.1556963027,
1.2249568701,
-0.6145085692,
-0.2372051775,
0.1709735394,
0.1448421627,
0.289218843,
0.1508656591,
-0.2933770418,
0.0510626957,
0.2111445516,
-0.597826004,
-0.352098316,
0.5065897703,
-0.8458451033,
-0.9461569786,
-0.364901036,
-0.4105790257,
-0.1214838699,
-0.2718817294,
0.5338795185,
0.4138864577,
-0.2992523909,
0.1379265189,
0.4698357582,
-0.4008876979,
-0.058172103,
0.7150309086,
-0.0318769217,
-0.393802315,
0.1589783877,
0.1870224178,
0.4821791947,
-0.2512558997,
0.2953240275,
-0.2266045958,
-0.0046311952,
-0.1778125018,
0.1862487495,
-0.6096762419,
-0.0764371008,
-0.0145610794,
0.160437122,
-0.9128888249,
-0.3101752996,
0.3702836335,
-0.1085416973,
-0.2250210494,
-0.2701968849,
0.4404222965,
0.7049347758,
-0.0095598856,
0.4408482611,
-0.2746452689,
0.1180423722,
-0.019886611,
0.011898539,
-0.0330238007,
-0.7654160261,
0.1502519101,
0.0912812799,
-0.0238187052,
-1.1052076817,
0.0718438104,
-0.1944834441,
0.5559964776,
0.5839981437,
0.3703249097,
0.8165924549,
-0.2509786189,
1.1124788523,
-0.2339525223,
-0.461594671,
0.5158129334,
-0.5287706852,
0.5783363581,
0.4864813089,
0.5777269602,
-0.6854425073,
-0.4822286367,
-0.6626957059,
-0.7619819045,
0.6948419809,
-0.1589766294,
0.2266205251,
-0.3242917955,
0.6314496398,
0.1220821515,
0.1983735263,
-0.5898656845,
-0.1296893358,
-0.2632141709,
-0.0737151429,
-0.051398281,
-0.424854666,
-0.6265413761,
0.0212862473,
0.2431854904,
-0.0436402187,
-0.0736210793,
0.4623622596,
-0.1947601736,
-0.2664141059,
0.1793291271,
0.7953315377,
0.7576930523,
-0.1744731218,
0.0780702233,
0.6320763826,
-0.3453354537,
0.5868510604,
-0.2600431442,
-0.3837383986,
-0.4851566851,
0.3845779896,
0.5609987378,
0.1491565257,
0.1433511078,
0.1677839905,
-0.2364457399,
-0.3539225161,
-0.4278512597,
0.1048692167,
-0.0622764342,
0.0273385756,
0.2212198228,
-0.3368614018,
-0.1742372811,
-0.5041897893,
-0.2799851596,
0.4367038906,
-0.3987067342,
-0.3944727182,
1.065879941,
0.3592671454,
-0.4008927047,
0.6927002668,
0.1612966061,
-0.5895194411,
0.7889493108,
0.7324739695,
0.2669704854,
-0.6548555493,
0.3927817047,
0.3053200543,
0.387581557,
0.0375877433,
0.4581410587,
-0.2024615109,
-1.2793929577,
-0.5508632064,
-0.3307938874,
-0.3361377716,
-0.0725004077,
-0.981777966,
0.0872337967,
-0.2643104196,
-0.6504936814,
-0.3300723732,
-0.1709153652,
-0.805422008,
0.0678070784,
0.202577427,
0.9778879881,
-1.3490222692,
0.6201839447,
0.8426311016,
-0.2890869677,
-0.97664994,
0.062581569,
0.5354560018,
-1.0221165419,
0.665029645,
0.0151181035,
-0.1099602282,
-0.1820839942,
-0.7132243514,
-0.9230938554,
1.0062758923,
0.2668213248,
-0.1603665203,
0.3528979421,
-0.067383267,
0.4559576809,
-0.144976899,
0.3356799483,
1.0000061989,
0.7371703982,
0.193456322,
-0.6772351861,
0.1312638968,
-0.3070786297,
0.1719897538,
-0.0933619365,
-0.9965940118,
0.5650137663,
-0.3086674809,
-0.0801094249,
-0.0780652016,
0.4792909622,
0.9319905639,
0.4390770793,
0.768114984,
0.1150779948,
0.774025321,
-0.3402664959,
1.4015853405,
-0.3560193181,
-0.0265795514,
0.537566781,
-0.8940688372,
0.2702499926,
0.6254754663,
-0.21634534,
0.2737977803,
1.5365993977,
0.1220708415,
0.4382141829,
0.2232223153,
-0.1171249151,
-0.0767170489,
-0.4316090643,
-0.4117738605,
0.3602840006,
0.3828936815,
0.1532773376,
0.1175080538,
-0.0791751891,
0.3905026317,
-0.262442559,
-0.0619348399,
0.599601984,
0.2982999086,
-0.9687339664,
0.4091337025,
-0.2162946612,
0.6838995814,
-0.7335321307,
0.3601906896,
-0.7940052748,
-0.2631093264,
-0.3426572382,
-0.3071176708,
-0.1073382795,
-0.0333695225,
-0.1241544336,
-0.2825531363,
0.7335447073,
-0.3447398543,
-0.2210956067,
0.1519462764,
0.4313177764,
0.1092199162,
0.3708608747,
-0.5238286853,
-0.1327265799,
0.1123579144,
-0.4785827398,
0.2156481594,
0.4984455705,
-0.5058817267,
0.5300351381,
0.8271436691,
0.3944733441,
-0.1585300267,
0.5951852798,
0.417865634,
-0.7030312419,
-0.6107853055,
-0.8573074937,
0.3811983168,
-0.0001427436,
-0.3183332086,
0.8890595436,
-0.1029945984,
0.5044671893,
0.0483909771,
0.6983380914,
-0.0880002305,
-0.0711931363,
-0.623457253,
0.3799533546,
-0.4217193723,
0.1181176677,
0.0037515122,
-0.8678183556,
0.0614364147,
0.4035137892,
-0.77210778,
0.6220135093,
0.728228271,
0.9540480971,
0.4304077029,
0.1366253048,
0.0436787866,
0.0219035503,
0.2436623871,
0.0449555665,
1.4126167297,
0.5718281865,
0.1306356192,
-0.0741180405,
-0.4873105884,
-0.1868322492,
-0.8303862214,
-0.517542243,
-0.2042266279,
0.0011653281,
-0.4178614616,
-0.1422961205,
0.954523921,
0.3251924813,
-0.6163332462,
-0.1953262687,
0.9077326655,
0.0129967006,
-0.2740104198,
-0.2014075965,
0.1470327973,
0.0201524086,
-0.675944984,
0.1652273238,
-0.0005178131,
0.1906152517,
-0.2439408004,
0.1325062811,
0.0930250734,
0.0521744229,
0.3826541603,
0.0050937971,
-0.6619528532,
-0.3748428822,
0.0873393118,
0.108041659,
-0.1104550362,
1.0800420046,
-0.5567573309,
0.0418319553,
0.4285615087,
0.0303815734,
0.2588021457,
0.6051957607,
0.8748924136,
-0.6996532679,
0.5008118153,
0.0517305061,
0.4829165637,
0.4029254615,
-0.6089423299,
0.5900555253,
0.2118050307,
-0.7808942795,
-0.6489295959,
0.3592758477,
-0.5453398824,
-0.1618168056,
1.4443348646,
0.2667712867,
-0.3057944477,
-0.001756695,
-0.3438648283,
0.3203447461,
-0.4990083873,
0.9861763716,
1.0012187958,
-0.1357609183,
0.2014140338,
-0.8653668761,
0.3900953233,
0.7662824988,
-0.3357867002,
-0.2741318941,
0.4884161949,
0.5392670035,
-0.1805855036,
0.9493989348,
-0.0757555291,
0.2284270376,
-0.321972698,
-0.0679440573,
0.3420610428,
0.1318400204,
-0.7143835425,
-0.2842825055,
0.1154157296,
0.2293539345
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11657v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11657v1 | Can LLM be a Personalized Judge? | 2024-06-17T15:41:30 | 2024-06-17T15:41:30 | Yijiang River Dong, Tiancheng Hu, Nigel Collier | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY | Ensuring that large language models (LLMs) reflect diverse user values and
preferences is crucial as their user bases expand globally. It is therefore
encouraging to see the growing interest in LLM personalization within the
research community. However, current works often rely on the LLM-as-a-Judge
approach for evaluation without thoroughly examining its validity. In this
paper, we investigate the reliability of LLM-as-a-Personalized-Judge, asking
LLMs to judge user preferences based on personas. Our findings suggest that
directly applying LLM-as-a-Personalized-Judge is less reliable than previously
assumed, showing low and inconsistent agreement with human ground truth. The
personas typically used are often overly simplistic, resulting in low
predictive power. To address these issues, we introduce verbal uncertainty
estimation into the LLM-as-a-Personalized-Judge pipeline, allowing the model to
express low confidence on uncertain judgments. This adjustment leads to much
higher agreement (above 80%) on high-certainty samples for binary tasks.
Through human evaluation, we find that the LLM-as-a-Personalized-Judge achieves
comparable performance to third-party humans evaluation and even surpasses
human performance on high-certainty samples. Our work indicates that
certainty-enhanced LLM-as-a-Personalized-Judge offers a promising direction for
developing more reliable and scalable methods for evaluating LLM
personalization. | [
-0.2829670012,
-0.5442960858,
1.1356011629,
0.321241349,
-0.0685188919,
0.2031005025,
-0.6568008065,
-0.4016728997,
0.211974889,
0.327113688,
-0.2260725051,
-0.7074648738,
-0.8324490786,
0.153827101,
-0.129355222,
0.6558988094,
0.2937494814,
0.2203522027,
-0.355761826,
-0.0377515331,
-0.4298121035,
-0.6993386149,
-0.4044588208,
-0.6040716767,
0.7445447445,
0.485937655,
0.8400143981,
0.2909384668,
0.3545129597,
0.3405148685,
-0.3488161266,
0.0878578424,
-0.1677696556,
0.1165063009,
-0.4442735314,
-0.69230932,
-0.6467087865,
0.1606801748,
0.2668702602,
0.8106631041,
-0.2620571256,
-0.0195652395,
-0.019139817,
0.5390066504,
-0.5749955773,
-0.0131998537,
-0.6313228607,
0.0504326001,
-0.2187193334,
-0.0185931399,
-0.6617097259,
-0.5637917519,
0.1066560298,
-0.5764383674,
-0.2107281238,
0.266392678,
0.6405269504,
0.2656823993,
-0.7137177587,
-0.2295026928,
-0.9862390757,
0.741145432,
-0.8180812597,
0.2678177655,
0.6486417055,
0.5525256991,
-0.0902216956,
-0.6127682924,
-0.4679409862,
-0.6467374563,
-0.0720731243,
0.1802413315,
-0.1396259964,
0.0933989659,
0.0890385434,
0.0443434864,
-0.1586389393,
0.5170307755,
0.2464479357,
-0.2004797161,
0.6165965796,
0.1390019059,
-0.0869388357,
-0.3021095693,
-0.3612136543,
0.2467461377,
-0.4055022001,
0.286585927,
0.6440351605,
0.1500691772,
0.0822901279,
0.6516622305,
-0.662460506,
0.6651772857,
0.4393553138,
-0.3158811629,
0.2229433358,
0.0568756573,
-0.0657767877,
-0.164129287,
0.9594694376,
0.6095243692,
0.4365035295,
-0.3494459987,
-0.2364185601,
-0.2564021349,
0.4535239935,
-0.5794828534,
0.0068170787,
0.4533413053,
-0.3436003923,
-0.3784298301,
0.314055115,
-0.4631389976,
-0.7057652473,
-0.4548217654,
0.3666021228,
-0.320946753,
0.341899395,
0.2813355923,
0.2908156812,
-0.2481737435,
0.7283507586,
-0.850897193,
0.3066045642,
0.714941442,
0.4774561524,
-0.361261636,
-0.36081025,
-0.6829928756,
0.0171929039,
-0.1743555963,
0.8442035317,
-0.6477476954,
-0.4665900171,
-0.2240561992,
-0.3793151677,
0.1524453461,
-0.6131786704,
0.6648216248,
-0.6328545213,
0.0700322837,
-0.5657278299,
-0.6027135849,
0.0536010042,
0.3443922698,
-0.1674006432,
0.4485509992,
0.0897209942,
-0.6526277065,
0.5767244101,
-0.0891517624,
-0.1885967255,
0.1385002583,
-0.3637769222,
-0.2426700741,
0.2636913657,
0.2037255019,
0.5683755279,
-0.2728070617,
0.6598184109,
-0.8251922131,
-0.707583189,
0.6538951397,
-0.4108248949,
0.2724259794,
0.2386962473,
-0.3339722753,
0.1819684058,
-0.6732885838,
0.0106900753,
-0.1359234452,
-0.7545856237,
-0.1198129579,
0.1404099315,
0.0974825174,
0.0718582273,
0.5348058343,
-0.8518545628,
0.0461367741,
-0.5351772904,
0.0365292579,
1.1660817862,
-0.1659992039,
0.4196766019,
-0.3773203492,
0.5102803707,
-0.1960053742,
-0.0094774226,
0.1452252716,
-0.5920279026,
-0.7417244911,
-0.0742720515,
0.6120920181,
0.5818305016,
-0.2011737227,
0.8943915963,
-0.5067104101,
-0.4151049852,
-0.2174698859,
0.3217038214,
0.5037063956,
0.388484925,
0.0483827516,
-0.5585998893,
-0.3330853581,
-0.999162674,
-0.5811425447,
-0.3324102461,
-0.3499390185,
0.6340433359,
0.2232989818,
-0.4874785841,
1.2018364668,
-0.4030757248,
-0.0309248008,
-0.114697881,
-0.1389642954,
0.2515047193,
0.1907941103,
0.4375682175,
-0.5917298794,
-0.6290535331,
0.2270577997,
-0.704017818,
-0.216996327,
0.0170350429,
-0.0699157566,
-0.1727124006,
-0.0522584319,
-0.536958158,
0.3335793018,
0.35764727,
-0.5742970109,
0.651915729,
-0.4285577536,
0.1926993877,
-0.7531710267,
0.1075915769,
0.1176721156,
-0.633256495,
-0.4591647387,
-0.0081631029,
-0.0125040375,
0.4143552482,
-0.2227037251,
0.8251556158,
0.1101286411,
-0.2770400345,
-0.452683419,
0.2351707369,
-0.0180033445,
0.3678102791,
-0.1733118147,
0.3881246448,
0.1965714544,
-0.4851046503,
0.3810493946,
0.3576671183,
-0.4938983023,
1.0735310316,
-0.6376180053,
0.4141865671,
-0.0246598367,
0.3467565775,
-0.6767905354,
-0.4863443375,
0.2538213134,
-0.3921453059,
0.1821988672,
-0.165168643,
-0.4932147861,
-0.149714902,
-0.2533862293,
-0.1802570224,
0.35900563,
-0.651974678,
0.6068865061,
0.2231656462,
-0.1964819133,
-0.5177602172,
-0.5935080051,
0.2930457592,
-0.0904368833,
-0.7848861217,
0.318325609,
-0.5067874193,
-0.597661078,
-0.3217804134,
-0.2069621384,
0.1956946552,
0.4479336143,
0.5763186812,
-0.048197981,
0.0772468895,
-0.0527477302,
-0.069745332,
-0.19881396,
0.027873544,
0.0077582481,
0.4714399874,
-0.3006667793,
-0.749347806,
-0.6135559082,
0.0314156562,
0.4096030891,
0.0923455805,
0.5519216657,
0.4343368709,
-0.1797509491,
0.0232002269,
-0.940710187,
-0.0050413287,
-0.4902530611,
0.0179556273,
-0.6013655066,
-1.1269441843,
0.4612675309,
-0.1626818627,
-0.0718776286,
0.1656453609,
0.7421604991,
-0.5945361853,
0.8630126715,
0.2874440253,
-0.1869026273,
0.2541217506,
0.3521602154,
-0.090445362,
-0.9139264822,
-0.4112284184,
-0.4793910384,
-0.4713740051,
-0.5076526999,
-0.1468602121,
0.2626372874,
-0.2052645683,
-0.5022408962,
-0.1186448261,
-0.0558765307,
0.2217503786,
0.6777544022,
0.4932613671,
0.5982401371,
-0.1309883893,
-0.288862139,
-0.128178373,
0.0044940962,
-0.9241917133,
1.1522650719,
0.4644771814,
0.8841318488,
0.2335323244,
0.752258122,
0.4105728865,
0.3609013855,
-0.7286683917,
0.4666570127,
-0.2588968277,
-0.4135999084,
-0.1841297597,
-0.3870352805,
-0.7062764764,
0.575393796,
-0.2731639147,
-1.1299879551,
0.276992321,
0.3881992996,
-0.6771841049,
0.2411158979,
-0.6811389327,
0.5888164043,
-0.5204916,
-0.2979531288,
-0.138657853,
-0.6961584091,
0.3458746076,
-0.4066138268,
0.3804141283,
-0.2957989872,
-0.1803554446,
0.373218298,
-0.4164501429,
0.987444222,
-0.2243648022,
0.155248791,
-0.249186337,
0.2545771301,
0.7461968064,
0.3753704429,
-0.4723035693,
0.0156152071,
-0.318020165,
-0.2288394421,
-0.7816491723,
0.9107310176,
-0.8238840699,
-1.0011228323,
-0.4141418636,
-0.2439094186,
-0.6333418489,
0.0311885606,
0.0902727917,
-0.1916964948,
-0.3221839368,
0.2975927293,
0.447378397,
-0.281603694,
-0.0211933479,
0.6566034555,
-0.303583622,
-0.3756817281,
0.6889442801,
-0.2152744085,
0.0540416464,
0.4062607288,
0.6330571175,
-0.1246293187,
-0.7836720943,
-0.3275158107,
0.0527672991,
-0.6960423589,
0.1110709235,
-0.6275867224,
0.1823931634,
-0.0172982085,
-0.2692969441,
-0.4186287522,
-0.2656936646,
-0.3506360948,
-0.1504458785,
0.0880756155,
0.666906476,
0.3146060407,
0.553407073,
-0.4545353651,
0.3798558712,
0.5975407362,
0.4652998447,
-0.3609354496,
-0.8708419204,
0.0627394617,
-0.0641162097,
-0.0471991487,
-0.5924073458,
0.2018433362,
-0.0161926635,
0.6600572467,
0.50026685,
-0.1784227341,
0.4682809114,
-0.4906624258,
0.5729935765,
0.0688101277,
-0.908223927,
0.5857691169,
-0.3448860645,
0.313360095,
0.896722436,
-0.0058412789,
-0.5523678064,
-0.3521601558,
-0.4431958795,
-0.5725244284,
0.6860132217,
0.0545175448,
0.2680706084,
0.3240176439,
0.7165783048,
0.1947192252,
0.5419376493,
-0.5701351166,
-0.246943891,
0.053036008,
0.0021798275,
-0.4006845355,
-0.5582824945,
0.0873354375,
-0.1181107834,
0.3887522817,
-0.2709982991,
-0.0514103398,
-0.0434123911,
-0.0274251308,
-0.0668235049,
0.5654731393,
0.3916374743,
0.6768840551,
-0.5904877186,
0.1615469456,
0.2248920947,
-0.2056977749,
0.2996918261,
-0.0282080639,
-0.4168335199,
-0.2590770721,
0.2022983432,
0.8086829782,
0.5039942861,
-0.7138927579,
0.800319016,
-0.2914625108,
0.0044557182,
-0.5057454705,
0.101188764,
0.34185341,
0.305003196,
0.0576987974,
0.4955333173,
0.1123203263,
-0.2616292834,
0.0979296416,
0.3943630457,
-0.3818177879,
-0.3814605772,
0.898267746,
0.1179186478,
-0.3569661677,
0.2942146063,
-0.2340620905,
-0.1885875612,
0.2377322912,
0.1231826395,
0.83078444,
-0.2118146867,
0.1520164758,
-0.0032738182,
0.1061148718,
-0.20041354,
0.112538293,
0.1029550582,
-0.9614260793,
-0.1396417171,
-0.9253008366,
-0.8359262943,
-0.2242887616,
-0.4706912935,
0.169007659,
-0.8042758703,
-0.6265487075,
-0.1158956066,
0.0371048599,
-0.6911189556,
0.4434296489,
0.1783271879,
0.6651552916,
-0.4208445847,
0.7946265936,
0.769767344,
0.1110795364,
-0.5518117547,
0.1089866981,
0.128708005,
-0.6444633603,
0.6874308586,
0.0718401149,
-0.1918296367,
-0.4350624382,
-0.286062628,
-0.6214997172,
1.258914113,
0.7843003273,
-0.8915379047,
0.1427747458,
-0.0082651153,
0.7424235344,
-0.3705149293,
0.4447695017,
0.6246573329,
0.749469161,
0.3095450103,
-0.9104343653,
-0.0707825124,
-0.0944114327,
0.2452292591,
-0.4892408848,
-0.8567244411,
0.5526067615,
-0.322008729,
0.219647035,
0.0393780097,
0.7093433142,
0.5017853379,
0.3096457422,
0.6594609022,
0.4611217082,
1.0187058449,
0.0818824172,
1.4173446894,
-0.3049015403,
0.1958151311,
1.5691930056,
-0.5096871853,
0.8371025324,
0.3500835001,
-0.3987832367,
0.5461659431,
0.6626360416,
0.0008805761,
0.1702365875,
0.1398466229,
-0.3120813072,
-0.6443019509,
-0.0665440261,
0.2470187694,
0.5527502894,
0.0516304485,
-0.4734653831,
0.1650669724,
-0.1429565251,
0.0433532819,
0.4953912497,
-0.1143005341,
0.4927579463,
0.266784519,
-0.6235953569,
-0.0180470068,
0.5979725718,
1.0102256536,
-0.5271027684,
0.5677961707,
-0.170925349,
0.0711067915,
-0.3418601453,
-0.7391412854,
-0.0296826083,
0.1338812262,
-0.0828989148,
-0.2843199372,
0.801084578,
0.1255217493,
-0.512911737,
0.3764248192,
0.6991635561,
0.0554662906,
-0.3135088086,
-0.4306015074,
0.0217685476,
0.0901220441,
-0.7277344465,
0.569942832,
-0.1422649622,
0.0231423974,
1.0885847807,
0.5572675467,
0.2259449959,
0.0021502387,
0.3824939728,
0.7259085178,
-0.5467429161,
-0.286783278,
-0.9507852793,
0.3630048633,
0.1110775396,
-0.2471281141,
0.7362139225,
0.5204117894,
0.7249535322,
-0.1169007644,
0.9332731962,
0.1426046491,
0.4443949461,
-0.395434916,
0.578071177,
-0.3900574744,
0.6931527257,
-0.1051546335,
-0.740711391,
-0.2281908244,
0.4591624141,
-0.5237419605,
0.4236210585,
0.3266812265,
0.4593476653,
-0.0197643973,
-0.1664951146,
0.7222049236,
0.2441408038,
0.3693530262,
0.4463711083,
0.7738240957,
0.0568255298,
0.2360731959,
-0.5295110941,
-0.1730923951,
-0.3548851907,
-0.5457918048,
-0.9590371251,
-0.1332953423,
-0.1474997848,
-0.2214033604,
-0.0901719779,
1.1008430719,
0.7631988525,
-0.749096036,
-0.2477415204,
0.3399762213,
0.1367368698,
0.2212347388,
-0.1195568666,
-0.008916798,
-0.1899904609,
-0.9251869917,
0.5234527588,
0.341134429,
-0.1285822242,
-0.2773665786,
-0.3529992104,
0.2762200534,
0.0190111175,
0.4747706652,
-0.0593465976,
-1.1071509123,
-0.7290926576,
-0.1767045259,
-0.3037728369,
0.335206002,
0.451197952,
-0.7314637303,
0.7381231785,
0.1522349417,
0.4410550892,
0.6628678441,
0.5120343566,
0.6365676522,
-0.6576278806,
-0.1244868115,
0.2853128314,
0.4998783469,
0.4347870052,
-0.6668950319,
0.299636066,
0.1883521676,
-0.6106093526,
-0.3977590203,
0.3593357801,
-1.280831933,
0.0624262057,
1.3650056124,
-0.5132197142,
0.0319980867,
-0.1307002455,
-0.2474634796,
-0.3061422408,
-0.6568172574,
0.71154356,
0.802164495,
-0.3117496669,
0.0143325189,
-0.5042469501,
0.1303848773,
0.3000371158,
-0.8093115687,
-0.2351967543,
0.3175959885,
0.6864728332,
0.0929067358,
0.7618148923,
0.1051391363,
0.1030799076,
-0.463655889,
0.0580009632,
0.0005628566,
-0.0013447168,
-0.5232039094,
0.255202651,
0.8447890878,
0.3573259413
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11654v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11654v1 | Ruby Teaming: Improving Quality Diversity Search with Memory for Automated Red Teaming | 2024-06-17T15:36:14 | 2024-06-17T15:36:14 | Vernon Toh Yan Han, Rishabh Bhardwaj, Soujanya Poria | cs.CL | cs.CL | We propose Ruby Teaming, a method that improves on Rainbow Teaming by
including a memory cache as its third dimension. The memory dimension provides
cues to the mutator to yield better-quality prompts, both in terms of attack
success rate (ASR) and quality diversity. The prompt archive generated by Ruby
Teaming has an ASR of 74%, which is 20% higher than the baseline. In terms of
quality diversity, Ruby Teaming outperforms Rainbow Teaming by 6% and 3% on
Shannon's Evenness Index (SEI) and Simpson's Diversity Index (SDI),
respectively. | [
-0.6583871841,
-0.2419130653,
0.3361894786,
0.5540936589,
0.0682713017,
0.7764111757,
0.1837372631,
-0.4282325506,
0.4321610332,
-0.0065113218,
-0.5359595418,
-0.1082092896,
-0.6073560715,
-0.0429838225,
-0.1878602952,
1.2386131287,
0.0900765583,
0.0878986865,
0.2112104595,
-0.5267475247,
-0.9710341692,
-0.3767496049,
-0.823803246,
-0.2030871958,
0.6387607455,
0.8668044806,
0.8082441092,
0.4196589887,
0.8918943405,
0.3853408098,
-0.0392116122,
-0.0691747218,
-0.7153929472,
0.33326599,
-0.0554000735,
-0.5592624545,
-0.39583987,
0.1688351333,
0.8078209758,
0.2750921249,
-0.3234597147,
0.0976967216,
-0.1245139465,
0.8621628284,
-0.7833484411,
-0.6035523415,
-0.7076413631,
0.1077212095,
-0.3045306504,
-0.6397718191,
-0.1065137759,
-0.4381915927,
0.1773112267,
-0.3441350758,
0.7485382557,
0.4929725528,
0.813210845,
0.0257450659,
-0.0668351129,
-0.2155911028,
-0.7326030731,
1.0911232233,
0.0438427292,
0.0599745959,
0.2947793007,
0.5994103551,
0.0646049008,
-0.2243433893,
-0.5382013917,
0.1966272444,
0.1871759742,
0.3831585944,
-0.4239926934,
-0.1488670856,
0.1792454869,
0.834534049,
-0.8970996141,
0.0003587578,
-0.716676712,
0.1093525738,
0.698000133,
0.6764333844,
0.6561523676,
0.2244169265,
-0.4936426282,
-0.3862944245,
-0.0572435781,
0.1752333343,
0.4548645318,
-0.092878662,
0.0800127909,
0.2575960457,
-0.162910983,
0.4407378733,
0.1824582666,
0.1774365008,
0.4471150935,
-0.6964715123,
-0.0442635342,
-0.2125230432,
0.5647295713,
0.6532667875,
-0.3212850392,
-0.2038148046,
-0.6416260004,
0.2834695876,
0.45242396,
-0.5696726441,
-0.7637696862,
0.3939185143,
-0.6095475554,
0.1309569031,
0.072675474,
-0.7927108407,
-0.1632512212,
0.2185102701,
0.8122667074,
-0.9796600342,
-0.2014896572,
-0.0591553524,
-1.169392705,
0.4388081133,
0.2333390564,
-0.9777985811,
0.4298346639,
0.5181211233,
0.8805025816,
-0.5088151097,
-0.7308206558,
-0.7803608179,
0.1118240878,
-0.0954073444,
1.0628064871,
-0.5512885451,
-0.3666873872,
-0.6528759003,
-0.5409679413,
0.2383683175,
-0.6180042028,
-0.2296310961,
-0.7061341405,
0.2863278687,
-0.5270210505,
-0.1072365344,
-0.0571005233,
0.2355305701,
-0.8124837279,
1.0836356878,
0.2618876398,
-0.2995098531,
0.9997708797,
-0.9803067446,
-0.335221678,
0.4938863218,
0.1623190492,
-0.458365351,
-0.1426369995,
0.1344771385,
0.0593122058,
-0.2160796523,
-0.1731919795,
-0.1831311733,
-0.3999856412,
0.3790346682,
0.0695036203,
0.7520851493,
0.4065375328,
-0.2874608934,
0.2780683935,
-0.6013892293,
0.3320939541,
-0.1288449466,
-0.4797784686,
-0.2183165103,
-0.1325678825,
-0.0076322486,
-0.042459961,
0.089809373,
-0.4600743949,
-0.1066226289,
0.0351650007,
0.1688352674,
0.7543033957,
0.0536995195,
0.7376483679,
-0.8985898495,
0.516564846,
-0.0246222094,
0.5898011327,
0.1923187077,
-0.7132713795,
-0.7145223022,
-0.5331875086,
0.0402083509,
0.622233212,
-0.6882378459,
0.388099879,
-0.1797516793,
-0.3648607135,
-0.587229073,
0.3861655593,
0.6238759756,
-0.3144958019,
0.5621635318,
-0.6583807468,
-0.8048755527,
-0.9192387462,
-0.2522145212,
-0.185710758,
-0.0605569519,
0.1282012761,
0.721090138,
-0.2797704637,
0.9220519066,
-0.2440932691,
-0.3732236922,
-0.5602680445,
0.5058266521,
0.3470261097,
0.702904284,
0.4618323445,
-0.9020311832,
-0.772770226,
-0.5077320933,
-0.3839074075,
0.2275966555,
0.0122173987,
-0.3220591843,
0.4653401077,
-0.2905525267,
-0.2479774356,
0.1840143353,
0.7035041451,
-0.5082811117,
0.1875270158,
-0.2780373394,
0.7556497455,
-0.896749258,
0.0123829935,
0.0395565592,
0.0810069963,
-0.7614638805,
0.2964502871,
0.1076375321,
-0.0260506812,
-0.1193837672,
0.1633558273,
-0.9126496911,
-0.3328496814,
-0.0026383295,
0.215478003,
-0.0357944034,
0.1413106173,
-0.3191967309,
0.9975932837,
0.3911472857,
-0.7377246022,
0.5361686945,
0.1181436628,
-0.2478487939,
0.7021314502,
-0.5219104886,
0.0000235456,
-0.1071939692,
0.1644582152,
-1.0553500652,
-0.0857105553,
-0.3510724008,
-0.8816213012,
0.2750375271,
0.1484621167,
-0.7105308175,
-0.5146375299,
-0.7671727538,
0.72091043,
0.7632188201,
-0.5567174554,
0.2642646432,
0.5954186916,
0.256375134,
-0.6433842778,
-0.8369884491,
0.0270699505,
-0.2893471718,
-0.8783085942,
0.3125206232,
-0.3809729218,
-0.3667857945,
0.0174637064,
-0.1351921856,
-0.4148103595,
0.1290452182,
-0.0158170518,
0.3892822266,
-0.3741481006,
-0.1956591159,
-0.7175519466,
-0.2610470355,
-0.3264350295,
0.0335612819,
0.7775319219,
-0.2491991669,
-0.0764241591,
-0.173210904,
0.7846356034,
0.1867121756,
-0.1856033504,
1.1330163479,
0.6412207484,
0.0154360104,
-0.2437968254,
-0.9889788628,
-0.149815321,
-0.5395421982,
0.0042181229,
-0.2495047003,
-1.076977253,
0.8102520704,
0.8393546939,
-0.1062372327,
0.3723397255,
0.1795826554,
-0.5112447739,
1.0170454979,
0.5950809717,
-0.2895583212,
0.501011312,
-0.3010461628,
-0.0302591491,
-0.8526912928,
-0.2591720223,
-0.4169122875,
-0.8423341513,
-0.3787587285,
-0.5999686122,
0.6181416512,
0.2435896993,
-0.5170968175,
0.407762289,
-0.7781210542,
0.6878638864,
1.0160948038,
0.2214658856,
-0.035228461,
-0.1780697405,
0.4337559044,
-0.2143705338,
-0.678717196,
0.1930304319,
0.7531711459,
0.2800648212,
0.6952728629,
0.78605479,
0.8794023991,
0.3082324564,
-0.0540458076,
-0.3325467408,
0.5554972291,
0.0081609497,
-0.9022656679,
-0.5231412649,
-0.6023266315,
-1.0751137733,
-0.000228348,
-0.3745698929,
-0.5869444609,
0.0633267239,
0.1852318794,
-0.7737986445,
0.3166308105,
-0.6257236004,
0.3890744746,
-0.2663082182,
-0.0940406248,
-0.5692424774,
-0.5606719255,
0.4318277836,
0.1209618822,
-0.2462854236,
0.0421124212,
-0.1348950565,
0.8547077179,
-0.3155882359,
0.4330518544,
-0.0980970711,
0.4770813584,
0.0943909585,
0.180245176,
0.3442362249,
-0.0460103713,
-0.0172719248,
-0.0807669833,
-0.4925231934,
-0.6742070913,
-0.5977978706,
0.4886755943,
-0.9481130242,
-0.6733089089,
-0.4142847955,
-0.7648693919,
0.076169692,
-0.158189863,
0.2384550124,
0.4370695353,
0.1895264983,
0.4724944234,
1.0083024502,
-0.4779066145,
0.5438183546,
0.7667691708,
0.2381934077,
-0.6454694271,
1.1949002743,
0.0409645066,
0.6440384984,
0.5338519812,
-0.0720132813,
-0.0660654455,
-0.7106733918,
-0.1803755611,
-0.0243003257,
-0.6903401613,
-0.3981727064,
-0.8880342841,
-0.2460943311,
-0.2029449344,
-0.4700381458,
-0.2443304509,
-0.2886680365,
0.0923238471,
0.3116928339,
0.7591391206,
0.5895652771,
-0.3760592043,
0.2115374357,
-0.9413845539,
0.4541403651,
0.5204339623,
0.5947979093,
-0.3530881703,
-0.4569329321,
-0.1293765008,
-0.3691280782,
-0.4123017192,
-0.8830748796,
0.4361000955,
-0.1001448035,
1.0495105982,
0.0401882865,
-0.1376822591,
1.0424861908,
-0.0006502884,
1.0033251047,
0.6244434714,
-1.0719342232,
0.9637886882,
-0.5363661647,
0.2444112748,
0.6284823418,
0.2625498176,
-0.2345732599,
-0.7319072485,
-0.8575590849,
-0.7219256759,
0.8937382102,
0.3814832568,
-0.3821434379,
-0.0517109148,
-0.1734510809,
-0.309065789,
-0.1121754944,
-0.6956332326,
-0.6024591327,
-0.0544193015,
0.1912493259,
-0.2966305017,
-0.3812078834,
-0.0745036229,
-0.0737137944,
0.4328663945,
0.2471310198,
0.508844316,
0.0484549515,
-0.0597314015,
-0.3401626945,
0.1332477033,
0.50267905,
0.5017798543,
-0.3174309731,
0.0795116127,
0.8054131269,
-0.3400896192,
0.1876392961,
-0.385843128,
0.266196996,
-0.2365384847,
0.17316401,
0.4558582008,
0.0236606076,
-0.3049685061,
0.529481411,
-0.1525567621,
-0.1155572608,
-0.0461115353,
0.6617637873,
-0.2829771042,
0.5067973137,
0.6626894474,
0.4484279752,
0.4340619743,
-1.0293152332,
0.2957863808,
0.8896671534,
-0.2448956519,
0.0134730907,
0.537229538,
0.2733419538,
-0.4644884169,
0.642794311,
-0.3612941504,
-0.8028427362,
0.6591579318,
0.6484165788,
0.6539894342,
-0.6046293974,
0.0292090755,
0.5550458431,
0.4944030643,
-0.4323135912,
0.448336035,
-0.0235415883,
-0.749327302,
-0.0893614814,
-0.3574849367,
-0.5339778066,
-0.1092143804,
-0.8236893415,
0.1849493235,
-0.5112866163,
0.0427540615,
-0.2957441211,
0.327722013,
-0.521232605,
0.2492802888,
0.0090059396,
0.837877214,
-0.5171936154,
0.7709497809,
0.6482006311,
-0.6306490898,
-0.5928714275,
-0.1012131348,
0.0504174978,
-0.8393509388,
0.9001156688,
0.0369989127,
-0.233668834,
-0.182393387,
-0.4854207337,
-1.0780342817,
1.4743140936,
-0.2084863484,
-0.1005262583,
0.3200454414,
-0.2144436389,
0.3278807402,
-0.1750653386,
0.6050361395,
0.5169974566,
0.4487818182,
0.13546139,
-0.7899883986,
0.006085597,
-0.6593822241,
0.3648145497,
0.4075914025,
-0.7198737264,
1.3592011929,
-0.3569977283,
-0.6689499021,
-0.03162219,
0.7113765478,
0.8259807825,
0.1575331688,
0.5844364166,
0.4262210429,
0.8383288383,
-0.0454230607,
1.1227655411,
-0.0615588054,
-0.0628052279,
0.7572471499,
-0.0279707052,
0.8349468112,
0.3858598471,
-0.2777307928,
0.4886036813,
0.2675956488,
-0.336496532,
0.5130012035,
0.1335498244,
-0.3484081924,
-0.2005618364,
0.6457657814,
-0.2701743841,
0.0075616078,
0.2822775841,
-0.0853349715,
0.0146294245,
-0.1565672606,
-0.4641726911,
0.0362003595,
-0.3219400942,
0.846599102,
-0.4679836929,
-0.9365321994,
0.5086295605,
-0.2965309024,
1.2474029064,
-0.2792253494,
-0.0543771833,
-0.4686080217,
0.2649891078,
-0.3456028402,
-1.4523379803,
0.3554093242,
-0.1321499944,
-0.9301356673,
-0.1426177472,
0.458896637,
-0.1869800687,
0.1119268313,
0.5043911934,
0.2251738161,
0.1688563824,
0.2151656747,
-0.7097697258,
0.1947603077,
-0.0501797013,
0.2251623869,
0.5580348969,
0.4932158589,
0.3740338981,
1.0227484703,
0.6383693814,
0.0560668372,
0.2890831828,
-0.1730837673,
0.832695365,
-0.9518722296,
-0.5480758548,
-0.8816049695,
0.5340331793,
-0.4071307182,
-0.3107560873,
1.0998663902,
0.8264881968,
0.4440416396,
0.0675846264,
0.5700252652,
-0.0950814933,
0.558593452,
-0.3033308685,
0.8229459524,
-0.4212782383,
0.240652889,
-0.3186936975,
-0.7974043489,
-0.4079492986,
0.6439849138,
0.0910551623,
0.0430661924,
0.9876689315,
0.9565185308,
-0.0604416803,
0.2435213774,
0.2874869108,
-0.1058691144,
0.2893069088,
0.8477838635,
1.2661572695,
-0.499607265,
0.8913739324,
0.1386786401,
-0.4830807745,
-0.1462671608,
-0.5350455046,
-0.9709300399,
-0.6854096651,
-0.1858971566,
-0.5756314397,
0.202677384,
0.5850612521,
0.6431456804,
-0.8356404305,
-0.3152463734,
-0.0518720187,
-0.0095808478,
-0.2355431318,
-0.2997514904,
-0.4220153093,
-0.8344340324,
-0.2940200567,
0.3981942534,
0.3591637015,
-0.2224915475,
-0.1382012814,
-0.3643256724,
-0.1747603267,
-0.1416781098,
0.44586128,
0.2183673084,
-0.4794619977,
-0.4676813185,
-0.1227160022,
-0.4011727571,
0.1753113866,
0.6783336401,
-0.6598631144,
0.1215707958,
0.7434157729,
0.3919818401,
0.3386880457,
-0.1072955579,
0.8702830076,
-0.6165733337,
-0.3275873959,
0.2740040123,
0.2102446556,
0.160210222,
-0.2263540179,
0.5889577866,
0.1562462747,
-0.8828155994,
-0.7139011621,
-0.1584669203,
-0.989557445,
-0.1771617234,
1.3633531332,
0.1634499133,
-0.2192164361,
-0.4165619016,
0.005800629,
0.0203454811,
-0.7325023413,
0.7702929378,
0.2647992969,
-0.2272080034,
-0.3971774578,
-0.3514633775,
0.5755699277,
0.4942245483,
-0.650524199,
-0.4497467577,
0.4218614995,
0.3968210816,
0.5393521786,
0.9184262753,
0.028118806,
0.7715740204,
0.394257009,
0.3727737069,
0.403546989,
-0.4171504676,
-0.2193825692,
0.3170087934,
-0.1707009524,
-0.3745949864
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11651v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11651v1 | A Two-dimensional Zero-shot Dialogue State Tracking Evaluation Method using GPT-4 | 2024-06-17T15:32:17 | 2024-06-17T15:32:17 | Ming Gu, Yan Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Dialogue state tracking (DST) is evaluated by exact matching methods, which
rely on large amounts of labeled data and ignore semantic consistency, leading
to over-evaluation. Currently, leveraging large language models (LLM) in
evaluating natural language processing tasks has achieved promising results.
However, using LLM for DST evaluation is still under explored. In this paper,
we propose a two-dimensional zero-shot evaluation method for DST using GPT-4,
which divides the evaluation into two dimensions: accuracy and completeness.
Furthermore, we also design two manual reasoning paths in prompting to further
improve the accuracy of evaluation. Experimental results show that our method
achieves better performance compared to the baselines, and is consistent with
traditional exact matching based methods. | [
-0.1455634236,
-0.9227077365,
1.2123966217,
-0.0275641456,
-0.5657895207,
0.2681461871,
-0.0696535856,
-0.2425130159,
0.0319081768,
0.4015002251,
-0.7327517867,
-0.579986155,
-0.5314173102,
0.0063790842,
-0.0385986008,
1.0889055729,
-0.3144402802,
-0.0302985869,
0.0037009437,
0.0525779985,
-0.7125311494,
-0.2952974737,
-0.6072702408,
-0.0901526585,
0.0608892553,
0.0171073843,
0.3861870468,
0.519482553,
0.3812604249,
0.2262859195,
-0.1211745292,
-0.0085818861,
-0.3612037003,
0.186823085,
-0.1161157563,
-0.2925589979,
-0.5413153768,
0.2275287062,
0.7527601719,
0.0305901133,
-0.0073866448,
0.2779679,
-0.1423845142,
0.4275619388,
-0.4896712303,
0.530842185,
-0.387955457,
0.0782779902,
-0.0443877913,
-0.4337172508,
-0.0047237873,
-0.7986635566,
0.3537668288,
-0.4301624,
0.1334713697,
-0.3081472218,
0.4777759612,
0.3031264544,
-0.7542979717,
-0.3953593373,
-0.6799544692,
0.6340279579,
-0.8854088783,
0.2197953165,
0.4936090708,
0.4740439653,
0.0623543262,
-0.3449474871,
-0.7496585846,
-0.331165731,
0.2348484695,
0.3106583655,
-0.1425023824,
0.171703741,
0.4586078227,
0.2476406842,
-0.6213779449,
-0.0352538526,
-0.1763787568,
-0.318423003,
0.4293265641,
0.3606168628,
0.4260728061,
-0.1921293437,
-0.4336417615,
0.1187351495,
-0.2313463241,
-0.0690768361,
0.2249059826,
0.3433949053,
-0.1100368574,
0.5418060422,
-0.2621676028,
0.8679436445,
0.1029115096,
-0.2536526918,
0.1500732899,
-0.9295101762,
-0.2507801056,
-0.0699544325,
0.8098320961,
0.8059993386,
-0.0367160775,
-0.1322824061,
-0.0464242026,
0.275262624,
0.2504577339,
-0.9772146344,
0.1234122366,
0.1065051854,
0.0738598257,
-0.1036860943,
-0.4906480014,
-0.9464554191,
-0.2091869265,
-0.4979025722,
0.7163447738,
-0.5051187277,
-0.3033609688,
0.1215200573,
0.0477155335,
0.4813144505,
0.6098979712,
-0.904620707,
0.3148508966,
1.019746542,
1.2794624567,
-0.0546575785,
0.1694515944,
-0.5208202004,
-0.0551223531,
-0.4882848263,
0.9677434564,
-0.4405665696,
-0.0103975991,
-0.1490798295,
-0.3772033751,
-0.2693554759,
-0.036033988,
0.7523549199,
-0.4205448925,
0.5111519098,
-0.4522554278,
-0.6872404814,
-0.3161885142,
0.6310344338,
-0.3325421214,
0.8959490657,
0.2418124527,
-0.5803402662,
0.3876896799,
-0.7357171178,
-0.1800002456,
0.2241247147,
-0.3949182034,
-0.328417182,
-0.0718515664,
0.2723220587,
-0.0129326181,
-0.2003769428,
0.0668108612,
-0.2458772659,
-0.8266720176,
-0.2889796197,
-0.7007620335,
0.7218170762,
0.0173593815,
-0.5623749495,
-0.17766954,
-0.4959928691,
0.3015122414,
0.0505454764,
-0.2647345364,
-0.0520066284,
-0.2947097123,
-0.3375920653,
0.3863004148,
0.3278865516,
-1.0047478676,
0.344407022,
-0.4216629267,
0.3087777197,
0.5647608638,
0.3103086948,
0.3658372462,
-0.0193054471,
0.7871645093,
-0.2672545314,
0.0394715331,
-0.1691734642,
-0.5728048086,
-0.4664836824,
-0.3631223142,
0.0126591539,
0.7597573996,
-0.66711694,
0.4804327786,
-0.1033789665,
-0.4248074889,
-0.4706412852,
-0.2529805005,
0.6501121521,
0.4191968143,
0.2620336115,
-0.2725773752,
-0.3069028258,
-0.6441372037,
-0.2629060149,
-0.1413447559,
-0.2315590233,
0.1582128555,
0.3000071645,
0.0000915486,
1.0619359016,
-0.6470435262,
-0.4142451584,
-0.2088847011,
0.2722107172,
0.1751582325,
0.1584767252,
0.5597753525,
-0.0461408123,
-0.6637817621,
-0.0823922381,
-0.7404138446,
-0.1783123314,
-0.0112410663,
-0.0779285654,
0.4172048271,
-0.0148437312,
-0.7771759629,
0.8656806946,
0.3762580156,
-0.4289515018,
0.3611387908,
-0.1153303906,
0.5498676896,
-0.9605639577,
-0.18856664,
0.2370000184,
-0.3719473183,
-0.8283693194,
-0.3303835094,
0.1169827431,
-0.2134428471,
-0.0769906193,
0.4417938292,
-0.3946413994,
-0.3852297366,
-0.3314491212,
0.6050866842,
0.0317726023,
0.6434772611,
-0.0558749512,
0.7418622375,
0.5127410889,
-0.0611735657,
0.6482904553,
0.3386294544,
-0.6766076088,
1.0191298723,
-0.4399763942,
0.6577194333,
-0.160150677,
0.7480182052,
-1.3744642735,
0.2856848538,
0.2983574867,
-0.286115855,
0.3019747436,
-0.3766741753,
-0.5055494905,
-0.3656361103,
-0.4821333289,
0.3084828258,
0.3886841834,
-0.250793159,
0.2040663213,
0.0135247177,
-0.3845105171,
-0.1053390726,
-0.3918783963,
0.2805865109,
-0.1253510118,
-0.5172067285,
-0.0096679498,
-0.1012961715,
0.2219205499,
-0.3621603549,
-0.6976675391,
-0.169995144,
-0.2805862427,
-0.0673115477,
0.4069594443,
-0.1114655212,
-0.3161995113,
-0.1308117509,
-0.4278138876,
-0.0777365342,
-0.3298430443,
0.4953091741,
-0.0483281985,
-0.4737969637,
-1.2752004862,
0.2005731612,
0.5844493508,
-0.0292067286,
0.1015623659,
0.6349371672,
-0.2778141797,
0.1233305931,
-0.635430038,
-0.139036119,
-0.3707656562,
0.4064778686,
-0.4933820069,
-0.8237122893,
0.0648141354,
0.1565552801,
0.1725430042,
0.1309601814,
0.4843383133,
0.0622102842,
1.3108451366,
0.33268556,
0.0507803112,
0.2508096397,
0.0200415403,
0.7492554188,
-1.0736714602,
-0.2486151755,
-0.4724902809,
-0.0964237005,
-0.1928615719,
-0.5264006257,
0.3616279066,
0.2169227451,
-0.3200265169,
0.6733702421,
-0.4961936772,
0.3675697744,
0.2951224446,
-0.0441040173,
0.5273065567,
0.0926067308,
-0.2209505886,
-0.2790580988,
-0.1256144196,
-0.6116888523,
0.8547866344,
0.5431850553,
0.442837894,
0.3894955814,
0.353107065,
0.2456617802,
-0.1044987887,
-1.0304020643,
0.5058246851,
0.0917473361,
-0.4774778187,
-0.5030605197,
-0.5138044953,
-0.4102000594,
0.4761698842,
0.2012433708,
-1.1965539455,
-0.4784695506,
-0.1138024554,
-0.6713479161,
0.1737290621,
-0.6398259997,
0.7141682506,
-0.2445245534,
0.0956692025,
-0.1814376414,
-0.3469925225,
0.3724586964,
-0.3121148944,
-0.2536156476,
-0.4117869735,
0.2069271654,
0.6851415038,
-0.4424080551,
0.6564262509,
-0.4071096778,
-0.3751771748,
0.2892041206,
0.316136688,
0.4508689344,
0.0039246823,
-0.1077912673,
0.1895366013,
0.5428686738,
-0.3997202218,
-1.0215004683,
0.6808996201,
-0.5307064652,
-0.5426076651,
-0.6896061301,
-0.5504153371,
-0.4074094892,
0.0864080489,
0.1349377483,
0.6511442065,
-0.1107399613,
-0.2365282327,
0.1556369364,
-0.1108842567,
0.4091095626,
0.9566519856,
-0.1964351088,
-0.2901696861,
0.592551887,
0.1512310058,
0.2922677696,
0.2233383954,
0.1152252406,
-0.8239915371,
-0.2695114315,
-0.8342222571,
0.1949002892,
-0.319191128,
-0.2901212573,
-0.6015405655,
-0.2666053474,
-0.5858995914,
0.0091345962,
-0.3007680774,
-0.3499759436,
0.1438831687,
-0.2429928929,
0.3468337953,
0.8925641775,
0.0713259131,
0.1263819933,
-0.4239071906,
0.4843859673,
0.4999333322,
0.8313161135,
-0.2534205019,
-0.7383137941,
0.0968677029,
0.3801288605,
-0.5391572714,
-0.767213881,
-0.1012732759,
0.0031376777,
0.4018393159,
0.1313087046,
-0.1655679494,
0.7882852554,
-0.678304553,
0.918027997,
0.4380231798,
-1.1234382391,
0.7223419547,
-0.4106248915,
0.6575444341,
0.4899559617,
-0.0284628645,
-0.5636678934,
-0.1967432052,
-0.2237516642,
-0.321570605,
1.147616148,
0.4463731647,
0.0469894297,
-0.0489640608,
0.3229150474,
-0.3166649044,
-0.1179273278,
-0.1513656676,
0.0628213137,
-0.2444594502,
-0.0253252536,
0.0904963315,
-0.4319286644,
0.0121504338,
-0.1092013121,
0.4449859858,
-0.1333880574,
0.4590882361,
0.0326992497,
0.1504407227,
-0.2337032109,
0.3954720199,
0.6370892525,
0.6666877866,
-0.570573926,
-0.2576414347,
0.2869434953,
-0.3783451617,
0.3347464204,
0.0883661211,
-0.3906300962,
0.1867587715,
0.0823729262,
1.038790226,
-0.0021585498,
-0.20622091,
1.0372579098,
-0.1762442142,
-0.3234449327,
-0.2907936573,
-0.133150816,
-0.0743827745,
0.374699831,
0.053245049,
-0.0858150572,
0.1652347445,
-0.5265548229,
0.2562125921,
0.5039466023,
-0.7686115503,
-0.4990072548,
0.4221173525,
0.0911479667,
-0.4413097501,
0.6766175628,
-0.4751317501,
-0.6138263941,
0.4584240019,
0.7606572509,
0.9978888631,
-0.4313428998,
0.5170698762,
0.5323122144,
0.1106472537,
-0.1604703218,
0.3161404133,
-0.3660229743,
-0.5251084566,
-0.8587571383,
-0.7489424944,
-0.3742091358,
0.2697032392,
-0.7635944486,
0.3355459273,
-0.5155844092,
-0.2363020927,
0.0020616334,
0.2724653184,
-0.6218613386,
0.0763094202,
0.2584038079,
0.717640996,
-0.7300516963,
0.8345547318,
0.3020907044,
-0.310336411,
-0.5615680814,
0.2221592218,
0.7295363545,
-0.7115330696,
0.3818496764,
0.4049224854,
-0.4745079279,
-0.1785174161,
-0.1786834747,
-0.9089211822,
1.0377501249,
0.302818805,
-0.7054634094,
0.1829501092,
0.0360647887,
0.864002943,
-0.0479333289,
0.6368281841,
1.2371479273,
0.4032593668,
0.4770590365,
-1.2321105003,
0.078879185,
0.0340949222,
0.2355220914,
0.403470546,
-0.5125625134,
0.2463524342,
-0.0995086282,
-0.5477349162,
0.3056833446,
0.1276324689,
0.2748947144,
0.3606657684,
0.5102844834,
0.7585056424,
0.4212342203,
-0.1021636277,
0.7588102221,
-0.009137148,
0.8343659043,
1.2805113792,
-0.7924531698,
0.638610661,
-0.0133781573,
-0.3744275868,
0.2397201061,
0.2819367945,
-0.0618621297,
0.6952489614,
0.3365817666,
-0.5092285275,
0.0805622935,
-0.0001243151,
-0.0976650417,
0.6657937765,
0.262270391,
0.2055909485,
-0.7465015054,
-0.2874712348,
0.3615334332,
-0.0485207066,
-0.013287277,
1.0128409863,
-0.137115106,
-0.7896152735,
0.5730707645,
-0.038511835,
0.3694020808,
-0.4494192004,
-0.187583372,
-0.3387162387,
-0.0215028934,
-0.0198219419,
-1.0299246311,
0.4070064127,
0.5001984835,
0.1830503494,
-0.1807116419,
0.2346496135,
-0.4598397017,
-0.3716706932,
0.4137941003,
0.1443048716,
0.4312034845,
-0.210518837,
-0.6379326582,
-0.0826948881,
0.4278731644,
-0.1475406289,
0.2548352182,
0.4337307215,
-0.1090346649,
0.2812224627,
0.5032738447,
0.0523088351,
-0.2298844308,
0.3469158709,
0.5281741023,
-0.6724662781,
-0.3447610736,
-0.919908762,
0.1952132732,
-0.171491608,
-0.3754424155,
0.6136835217,
0.6857790351,
0.3449234664,
0.392537266,
1.0116260052,
0.0001114321,
0.9211138487,
-0.4254501164,
0.2703232467,
-0.093813017,
0.3064185977,
-0.4041317105,
-1.3769543171,
-0.2382884324,
0.6747250557,
-0.4825051427,
-0.0030438886,
0.8306965232,
0.686076045,
-0.1162246093,
0.2616299093,
0.6034527421,
0.3237289488,
0.519589901,
0.6489954591,
0.7519689798,
-0.5056477189,
0.4848746061,
-0.1079124734,
-0.6971728206,
0.0358802229,
-0.8589627743,
-0.8942480087,
-0.4917002022,
-0.4586329758,
-0.2490684986,
-0.0112640625,
0.6991225481,
0.5626467466,
-0.6461039186,
0.0863741264,
0.0583918542,
-0.46739465,
-0.0727628917,
-0.2090394497,
0.4650824368,
-0.2581033409,
-0.8486273885,
0.622574091,
0.8750705123,
-0.0654348433,
-0.2718561292,
0.2447628826,
-0.1327805221,
0.0772549063,
0.7759101391,
0.0576245338,
-0.8928133249,
-0.6351038814,
-0.2558296025,
-0.1981795877,
-0.0472362377,
0.7060400248,
-0.5855164528,
0.8314684629,
0.5252330303,
0.3742093146,
0.9689734578,
0.4147035778,
0.6784935594,
-0.4412490129,
-0.0219130963,
0.1753917485,
0.0794645697,
0.3890039027,
-0.3641951382,
0.5409722328,
0.0131651033,
-0.7448679209,
-0.4166950285,
0.3381201029,
-1.0326024294,
0.0573254637,
1.1961362362,
-0.3337694407,
0.2991390228,
-0.3690087497,
-0.3380682766,
0.3683517277,
-0.4678487182,
0.7975900173,
0.7302289605,
-0.3010288179,
-0.2585939467,
-0.9676612616,
0.4853032827,
0.2102753669,
-0.6292755008,
-0.1997966915,
0.53462708,
0.6376701593,
0.0665909871,
1.0407009125,
-0.2711160481,
0.0412164666,
-0.1912760884,
-0.3311042488,
0.1697018743,
0.046225097,
-0.6665156484,
-0.3846027255,
-0.2955419123,
-0.3977713883
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00066v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00066v1 | Compress then Serve: Serving Thousands of LoRA Adapters with Little Overhead | 2024-06-17T15:21:35 | 2024-06-17T15:21:35 | Rickard Brüel-Gabrielsson, Jiacheng Zhu, Onkar Bhardwaj, Leshem Choshen, Kristjan Greenewald, Mikhail Yurochkin, Justin Solomon | cs.DC | cs.DC, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Fine-tuning large language models (LLMs) with low-rank adapters (LoRAs) has
become common practice, often yielding numerous copies of the same LLM
differing only in their LoRA updates. This paradigm presents challenges for
systems that serve real-time responses to queries that each involve a different
LoRA. Prior works optimize the design of such systems but still require
continuous loading and offloading of LoRAs, as it is infeasible to store
thousands of LoRAs in GPU memory. To mitigate this issue, we investigate the
efficacy of compression when serving LoRA adapters. We consider compressing
adapters individually via SVD and propose a method for joint compression of
LoRAs into a shared basis paired with LoRA-specific scaling matrices. Our
experiments with up to 500 LoRAs demonstrate that compressed LoRAs preserve
performance while offering major throughput gains in realistic serving
scenarios with over a thousand LoRAs, maintaining 75% of the throughput of
serving a single LoRA. | [
-0.6028857827,
-0.5765377879,
0.3924657106,
0.2169922739,
-0.3591780365,
-0.1321959049,
-0.2624221742,
-0.5414863825,
0.6435952783,
0.7618086934,
-0.3977382779,
0.0163826384,
-0.5339189172,
-0.0327239819,
-0.1611872166,
0.5220373273,
0.2462956458,
-0.24391222,
-0.1473725587,
-0.5466423035,
-0.7164930701,
-0.3899872303,
-0.832221508,
-0.1068951339,
0.6295098066,
0.7559289932,
0.8195106387,
0.6680096388,
0.6787240505,
0.3450872898,
-0.0802413449,
0.2475355268,
-0.8369128108,
0.6030272245,
0.1233768389,
-0.6948100924,
-0.4850423038,
-0.3747619987,
0.5493029356,
0.8001487851,
-0.5483718514,
0.4405171275,
0.1595652997,
0.7789909244,
-0.6796605587,
-0.263218075,
-0.6893982291,
-0.0692319945,
-0.1791826785,
-0.0911624283,
-0.600338757,
-0.658819437,
-0.2742142081,
-0.6153364182,
-0.1799031198,
0.2642453611,
0.7656428218,
0.762306869,
0.1231530979,
0.3301878572,
-0.7333238721,
0.5202305913,
-0.6052805781,
0.0769579113,
0.0479639396,
0.6890046597,
-0.3966798484,
-0.5164967775,
-0.4230686128,
0.4898675382,
0.124489069,
-0.3140328526,
-0.4714201093,
-0.1686963886,
0.4650289416,
0.4582595527,
-0.3297590911,
0.5024071336,
-0.2292910218,
0.3026696742,
0.1792140305,
0.0368777663,
0.0169741604,
0.1828223169,
-0.2146462649,
-0.0954886749,
-1.1361095905,
-0.0819332227,
0.1535318941,
0.5343945026,
0.0468520932,
0.7074674964,
-0.2674934566,
1.0321081877,
0.0553789176,
0.0516805425,
-0.1579155922,
-0.0077807461,
-0.4084696472,
-0.1220396087,
0.743399322,
0.2511624694,
0.1286450475,
-0.1882765442,
-0.1407842785,
0.4364004731,
0.3981752098,
-0.8509290814,
0.1017351747,
0.1256743968,
-0.4247744381,
-0.3414340615,
-0.2384223193,
-0.8928284645,
-0.488009572,
-0.1145894304,
0.7966543436,
0.1145913824,
0.2654229701,
0.2512362003,
-0.0696990192,
-0.0068134037,
0.2659347951,
-1.0885307789,
0.7944539785,
0.5147097707,
0.88542521,
-0.0751185492,
-0.0050027538,
-1.3607882261,
0.0896083117,
0.0812874213,
1.2739545107,
-0.3483507633,
-0.3750840127,
0.0661078542,
0.1341590881,
0.3230611682,
-0.8442228436,
0.6520142555,
-0.6433352828,
-0.3855159283,
-0.5178540349,
-0.258166343,
0.4486646652,
0.1706804335,
-0.9234027863,
0.9208684564,
0.2058737278,
-0.4113457203,
0.1038254201,
-0.489143461,
-0.4778603315,
0.0956962556,
-0.3650732338,
-0.2962096632,
0.5935974121,
0.3761286736,
0.2969516516,
-0.5490708947,
-0.5204809308,
-0.3140768707,
-0.6400856972,
-0.0583033487,
0.0010534941,
0.2529402077,
0.2144802809,
0.1224948317,
-0.0481986552,
-0.482940942,
0.1898049712,
0.161517337,
-0.9150464535,
-0.3332264721,
0.1767350584,
-0.0830600113,
0.0247752499,
0.2762908638,
-0.6175128222,
0.9693248868,
-0.3462657332,
0.6110931635,
0.7711889744,
-0.3143247366,
0.2310508341,
-0.4167018831,
0.5002686381,
-0.1797835678,
0.3973051608,
0.1461358368,
-0.3905007243,
-1.0996749401,
-0.0680318102,
0.1815738231,
0.1699106544,
-0.8801476955,
0.3614429533,
-0.7916387916,
-0.6394258142,
-0.8455478549,
0.1361199617,
0.0797762424,
0.2258709073,
0.2530751228,
-0.2262282372,
-0.4728488922,
-0.933118999,
-0.2863327563,
0.2374162972,
0.193227917,
0.3830993772,
-0.0543478094,
-0.0147694182,
0.9249721766,
-0.8727315068,
-0.4204439819,
-0.1912026703,
-0.13954328,
0.6594069004,
0.3265309334,
0.5811260939,
-0.5422890186,
-0.5665796995,
-0.0235225689,
-0.4948261678,
-0.0429355353,
0.495292753,
0.0458028018,
0.1212279201,
0.4582351148,
-0.4567526579,
0.1117861792,
1.0916403532,
-0.2891222835,
0.1291399598,
-0.7722887397,
0.1460883021,
-1.0193878412,
-0.1563947499,
-0.3857343793,
-0.4876061976,
-0.2960753739,
0.1011059582,
-0.2830598652,
-0.4276820421,
-0.43525213,
0.3569200039,
-0.3329435885,
-0.4915230274,
-0.2773893178,
0.0887300298,
0.0721191242,
0.283110112,
-0.2476176023,
0.9827837348,
0.3694829941,
-0.9002406597,
0.2941587865,
0.1110411584,
-0.4095718563,
0.5783592463,
-0.9673541188,
0.23624672,
-0.1026163027,
0.3126752079,
-0.7901195884,
-0.0931296051,
-0.0259771738,
0.0607352033,
-0.1436378807,
-0.6827070117,
-0.7196107507,
-0.2957345247,
-0.280318886,
0.4159733653,
0.6954576373,
-0.9758232236,
0.6730616093,
0.5478716493,
-0.0289667249,
-0.5178833604,
-0.8041349649,
-0.063229315,
-0.2339784652,
-0.5516366363,
0.3234061599,
-0.4807508588,
-0.1979075968,
0.0184955373,
-0.0204670746,
0.116056487,
0.1772845984,
0.627007544,
0.1198972464,
-0.334903419,
-0.2268794477,
0.1255975664,
-0.2253901511,
-0.4959489703,
-0.5359487534,
0.9388112426,
-0.0171591882,
-0.5383515954,
-0.2219403982,
0.495239526,
0.8204991221,
0.2600905597,
1.0015296936,
0.2823038101,
-0.3240578175,
-0.0437941924,
-0.6282323599,
0.1235641614,
-0.5574393868,
-0.1314817667,
-0.6200108528,
-0.7579777837,
0.5132642388,
-0.188022092,
0.2455886006,
0.3438124061,
0.3235965967,
-0.1805136502,
0.5326622128,
0.6935314536,
-0.3264425993,
0.6467465758,
-0.2440618873,
0.2435691804,
-0.7672564387,
0.2170578092,
-0.9271570444,
-0.715592742,
-0.5945405364,
-0.6959320307,
0.6486563683,
0.0269221216,
0.0660381168,
0.5335196853,
-0.7366607785,
1.0287264585,
0.2844461203,
0.0433478504,
0.5061287284,
0.2804661691,
0.2302645147,
0.0602114163,
-0.7274531722,
-0.2338560224,
0.7561737895,
-0.0449093878,
1.2457658052,
0.6259590387,
0.6708366871,
0.482637465,
-0.0062997006,
-0.8055695891,
0.5548129082,
-0.6878991723,
0.030595284,
-0.2295990288,
-0.3748035133,
-1.1321855783,
0.3915367424,
-0.1989740878,
-0.697296679,
0.3214502931,
0.1908447891,
-0.7202033401,
0.3419760168,
-0.7676888704,
0.3232742846,
0.0894727781,
-0.3178491294,
-0.4653791189,
-0.3073936105,
-0.1237533167,
0.1445207,
0.1380882561,
0.2072356492,
-0.0316789001,
0.7368681431,
-0.5347138047,
0.6036883593,
-0.1919161081,
-0.1322152764,
-0.2469953597,
0.0849329308,
0.7366682291,
0.0466729067,
-0.1980766505,
-0.1553786993,
0.2077955157,
-0.5924614072,
-0.7752537727,
1.2483744621,
-0.8843117952,
-0.4884218574,
-0.3154504597,
-0.3713837266,
-0.0986256823,
0.1719909608,
0.1996811777,
0.5373274684,
-0.1445389837,
0.1003147662,
1.0588089228,
0.0209310316,
0.4149366915,
0.4211189747,
-0.264682889,
-0.1065200642,
0.8783947825,
0.2899490893,
0.5494385362,
0.3782996237,
0.1030494049,
0.2025754303,
-0.4043340087,
-0.4730213284,
0.2682037055,
-0.7783160806,
-0.3839767575,
-0.4054066241,
0.0886485577,
-0.3939781487,
-0.2172383219,
-0.7093729973,
-0.5438995957,
-0.1833604276,
0.6130496264,
0.469702214,
0.9574716091,
0.0927709714,
0.6089648008,
-0.6884720325,
0.7015902996,
0.3026114702,
0.4885926545,
-0.1683962792,
-0.4514851868,
-0.2486586124,
-0.1618472189,
0.150872767,
-0.3297940791,
0.3512012362,
0.1955394,
0.3716519773,
0.5398145318,
0.1983947307,
0.9125310779,
-0.6462049484,
0.7429177165,
-0.1305185258,
-0.4592877626,
0.500677526,
-0.0709042624,
0.4415906668,
0.7877882123,
0.2216110528,
-0.4905632734,
0.2435021847,
-0.3301020265,
-0.725830853,
0.5125164986,
-0.3628197908,
0.1485860646,
0.1967956126,
0.5532920361,
0.2536255121,
-0.0538862795,
-0.4167059064,
-0.4451637864,
0.2642918229,
0.088963449,
0.0156820677,
-0.2460066378,
-0.4143978059,
-0.0370884202,
0.4438880384,
-0.3546553254,
0.5491037369,
-0.1483309418,
-0.0514132641,
-0.0760813579,
0.4062914848,
0.5364156365,
0.2581526339,
-0.3013912439,
0.3366886079,
0.0463032573,
-0.3321901858,
0.1512282044,
-0.0310045891,
-0.0254792571,
-0.0968423337,
-0.1594986767,
0.8655366302,
0.274174571,
-0.7010965943,
0.2285244614,
-0.6959099174,
0.3222020268,
-0.096985139,
0.2435128987,
0.0976831242,
0.1353559941,
0.0254956093,
0.3649516404,
-0.3303257227,
-0.4750023782,
-0.3759693205,
0.4316131473,
-0.158500433,
-0.0740244836,
0.3514667451,
0.1834481061,
-0.4043114483,
0.3953903913,
0.1390046328,
-0.2778357267,
0.0843094885,
0.5801776648,
0.3520469964,
0.0466584526,
-0.3811117113,
0.0280584414,
0.1540537924,
-0.442956239,
0.2802302837,
-0.0898433328,
-0.6211651564,
-0.4067099392,
-0.708835125,
-0.466989845,
-0.0537503622,
-0.820661664,
0.5221303701,
-0.3798058331,
-0.1197919622,
-0.0997017473,
-0.0274242759,
-0.6057010293,
-0.2818992138,
0.0093543259,
1.1606330872,
-0.8131457567,
1.0842117071,
0.448312223,
-0.3304244578,
-0.5064569116,
-0.3064852357,
-0.2584986091,
-0.7320902348,
0.5632140636,
-0.3905957341,
-0.440820545,
0.1039239243,
-0.2068308145,
-0.9985819459,
0.9938245416,
0.6150970459,
-0.7267600894,
-0.1889401227,
0.2342438698,
0.3171707392,
-0.2363588959,
0.0093939258,
0.4712469578,
0.332095176,
0.1094935462,
-0.8435428143,
0.0600628555,
-0.0308472179,
-0.2175019681,
0.2366065532,
-0.7141541243,
0.7201755047,
-0.1067729741,
-0.0078142518,
0.1824686974,
0.5855062604,
0.1858307719,
-0.4809060395,
0.7611246705,
0.9183489084,
0.8578565121,
0.0263394788,
1.2535024881,
-0.0483747311,
0.0949833915,
1.1473076344,
-0.2813042104,
1.2486554384,
0.9381399155,
-0.035636276,
0.3408092558,
0.3521957994,
0.195900932,
0.5939107537,
0.2646145523,
-0.3460827768,
-0.2375197113,
-0.4693415165,
-0.4437113404,
0.1631237715,
0.1848438382,
0.0455309749,
-0.2272259742,
0.015126274,
0.0596258864,
-0.012667953,
-0.2110565603,
0.6200701594,
-0.0037353449,
-0.8768253922,
0.9632380009,
-0.316185087,
0.8922139406,
-0.4733678997,
0.0644771531,
-0.3814289868,
0.2401794493,
-0.1682824492,
-0.4994391799,
0.2016980499,
-0.0545159206,
-0.6436484456,
-0.2803082764,
0.5380269289,
-0.1219659448,
-0.2201374769,
0.2344367802,
0.3641120195,
0.1551658809,
0.0719626471,
-0.0259064529,
0.8372952342,
-0.2661832273,
-0.0761272982,
0.8861954212,
0.0492155701,
0.1384657919,
0.9041883349,
0.5876894593,
0.5621231794,
0.1680654138,
0.2080151588,
1.4397792816,
-0.2748834193,
-0.4798791111,
-0.5738440156,
-0.0215089526,
-0.0437926799,
0.0836508051,
0.2692426741,
0.4669368565,
0.3398011029,
-0.0179596376,
0.7029426098,
-0.2584457994,
0.314376682,
-0.6196861267,
0.7821357846,
-0.5570642352,
0.4705609679,
0.2148790359,
-0.8796277642,
-0.1958322525,
0.4064397216,
0.0618132949,
-0.6083535552,
0.4252324104,
0.6152011752,
-0.3554240167,
-0.3551282287,
0.4191432595,
0.283400178,
0.5749613643,
0.552798152,
0.3914806545,
-0.7416731119,
0.6289730072,
-0.0024575922,
-0.0019463575,
-0.4703595936,
-0.8652911186,
-0.5508468151,
-0.3444291949,
-0.1660833955,
-0.5291189551,
0.0160715152,
0.9137275219,
0.8787611127,
-0.4473101497,
-0.1974938959,
0.3089553416,
0.0629438534,
-0.3553872705,
-0.1093096212,
0.2432626784,
-0.2332641333,
-0.7074035406,
0.7424570322,
0.1662427336,
-0.2566373348,
-0.3504861593,
0.0071231052,
-0.0504806675,
0.1990904957,
0.5701007843,
0.4630473256,
-0.5209581852,
-0.4138914645,
-0.1836461574,
-0.1809302866,
0.2131874263,
0.7819908261,
-1.373120904,
0.1553740352,
0.6661216617,
0.7900989056,
0.499456048,
-0.0859974101,
0.378516227,
-0.75739187,
0.2257234901,
-0.1323813349,
0.5546808243,
0.0747035667,
-0.3700642884,
0.5337542295,
-0.1068329439,
-0.8201674819,
-0.9618564844,
0.338620156,
-1.4988732338,
-0.0720202997,
0.9281019568,
-0.2856116891,
-0.2351151556,
0.0345089398,
-0.104849197,
-0.013574956,
-0.446733743,
0.6433054805,
0.2889356613,
-0.3223749101,
-0.0578154176,
-0.5213004947,
0.4156910479,
0.2754442394,
-0.9940499067,
0.3144876957,
0.1600946635,
0.1793841422,
0.1327503175,
0.5167860389,
0.2205412686,
-0.1534254849,
-0.2502066195,
-0.1430654377,
0.088214986,
-0.0751327053,
-0.4886336625,
0.418579042,
0.4799872041,
-0.1588182747
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11634v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11634v1 | The Base-Rate Effect on LLM Benchmark Performance: Disambiguating Test-Taking Strategies from Benchmark Performance | 2024-06-17T15:14:10 | 2024-06-17T15:14:10 | Kyle Moore, Jesse Roberts, Thao Pham, Oseremhen Ewaleifoh, Doug Fisher | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Cloze testing is a common method for measuring the behavior of large language
models on a number of benchmark tasks. Using the MMLU dataset, we show that the
base-rate probability (BRP) differences across answer tokens are significant
and affect task performance ie. guess A if uncertain. We find that
counterfactual prompting does sufficiently mitigate the BRP effect. The BRP
effect is found to have a similar effect to test taking strategies employed by
humans leading to the conflation of task performance and test-taking ability.
We propose the Nvr-X-MMLU task, a variation of MMLU, which helps to
disambiguate test-taking ability from task performance and reports the latter. | [
-0.6196225286,
-0.9650720954,
0.0802708715,
0.0552128814,
-0.1345521808,
-0.1853721738,
-0.1275800914,
-0.5165287852,
-0.0119376536,
0.047147084,
-0.5957124233,
-0.0484943241,
-0.5942299962,
0.127844736,
-0.1255630702,
0.6052129865,
0.0064499076,
0.0845456347,
-0.2845385373,
-0.1534358412,
-0.8717767,
-0.5792223811,
-0.5501925945,
-0.5833996534,
0.6395725608,
0.5122586489,
0.5320158601,
0.3520081639,
0.3716044426,
0.1293161809,
-0.0719759613,
-0.2536281943,
-0.5873592496,
0.1983324289,
-0.2133184969,
-1.2981626987,
-0.3929052949,
0.2672227323,
0.6048833132,
0.6294912696,
-0.2310130596,
0.4228174388,
0.1642406434,
0.7044689655,
-0.701239109,
-0.0389807858,
-0.7042165399,
-0.1506979913,
-0.2155581266,
-0.4168019593,
-0.5990973115,
-0.1016502157,
-0.0009706492,
-0.1954109222,
0.5716860294,
0.1987385005,
0.5164183974,
0.2205145508,
-0.1308967918,
-0.2622425556,
-0.2678715289,
0.8321210146,
-0.643075943,
0.6057986021,
0.28438133,
0.0031698695,
-0.2301144749,
-0.230915308,
-0.6105347276,
-0.5400936604,
-0.099179402,
-0.0017946804,
-0.2039051801,
-0.1048387885,
0.938305676,
0.4619898796,
-0.8375213146,
0.1131624579,
-0.4248882234,
-0.0629803538,
0.4817096293,
0.2318550199,
0.1737584621,
0.1397779286,
-0.2801225781,
-0.1698433757,
-1.0739513636,
0.568533361,
0.2706020474,
0.2083551288,
0.2627546191,
0.6581913829,
-0.5546018481,
0.7512332201,
0.1274362653,
-0.148884356,
0.4696162045,
-0.3546587527,
-0.5201998949,
0.1213779524,
0.1698697656,
0.4651405513,
0.3120659292,
-0.0390815698,
0.0147927674,
0.452090174,
-0.0198495593,
-0.8986610174,
0.0848223343,
0.1881396174,
-0.2461383045,
-0.0648578852,
-0.2605373859,
-0.8394685984,
-0.2363481224,
-0.2059379816,
0.4609231949,
-0.3391502202,
-0.0394396596,
0.1188082695,
-0.4352670312,
0.3253555298,
-0.1076242924,
-0.7901237011,
0.534521997,
0.4233134687,
0.7595983744,
-0.3430456519,
-0.4074482024,
-0.9765909314,
-0.2287432402,
-0.1606660187,
0.5867338181,
-0.36883986,
-0.8666959405,
-0.2513410151,
-0.0839118958,
-0.3631642759,
-0.9506096244,
0.3444751501,
-0.4874237478,
-0.0077164448,
-0.6982721686,
-0.6601437926,
-0.1962139606,
0.3047691286,
-0.6503578424,
1.1256312132,
0.0421632417,
-0.5864604115,
0.7420418262,
-0.6090885997,
-0.5998285413,
-0.0342028923,
-0.1372616887,
-0.1475098133,
0.0842369124,
0.033981882,
0.3134411275,
-0.076078333,
-0.3418221772,
-0.2173379958,
-0.6568949223,
0.3626045287,
-0.3660004139,
0.7241012454,
-0.0690050572,
-0.812487781,
-0.306073755,
-0.6809338331,
0.2265141755,
0.1508274823,
-0.4065158367,
-0.4707034826,
-0.062893413,
-0.3651658297,
0.2467020303,
0.0893300101,
-0.6027010679,
0.2815873623,
-0.3143649101,
-0.0269982535,
0.541221559,
0.0676855817,
0.1857931763,
-0.7003657818,
0.4807956219,
-0.0749405921,
0.1457870901,
0.0491225794,
-0.7654650807,
-0.5714913011,
-0.0709776431,
0.1310754269,
0.7678179741,
-0.2082545757,
-0.1602262557,
0.1113639623,
-0.475966841,
-0.4872145057,
0.5232509375,
0.5763241053,
0.6444463134,
0.3635047078,
-0.5952726603,
-0.3623651266,
-0.8189883232,
-0.289316982,
-0.2024341375,
0.0032297855,
0.254675597,
0.4557748437,
0.0712557137,
0.8592629433,
-0.7001376152,
-0.0524136908,
-0.2938681543,
0.4415909052,
0.2571270466,
0.3815546036,
0.5450882912,
-0.7893006206,
-0.4479083419,
-0.3833832741,
-0.2353633344,
-0.6386346221,
0.135588333,
0.0621533468,
0.4249979556,
0.4392569065,
-0.7482715249,
0.6288801432,
0.3132362068,
-0.0958585814,
0.9925635457,
-0.1265558153,
0.3812337816,
-0.4938555658,
0.1806738973,
-0.0143773276,
-0.0077027413,
-0.6305833459,
0.2505651712,
0.2229198366,
0.3625024557,
-0.6704206467,
0.4808810055,
-0.3022045195,
-0.193477869,
-0.2816949785,
0.1272003949,
-0.016844878,
0.3625860214,
-0.1300836056,
1.2086038589,
0.3372143209,
-0.8606569767,
-0.032691922,
0.1497750729,
-0.2272478938,
0.6402605772,
-0.5771909356,
0.0816183686,
0.0112005491,
0.0064493166,
-1.1789638996,
0.3167217672,
-0.0276361257,
-0.4471789896,
0.2139386088,
-0.009918116,
-0.6198083162,
-0.3539343476,
-0.3002175093,
0.3419953585,
0.7536385059,
-0.2910145223,
0.1392459273,
-0.2478434443,
-0.155144304,
-1.0159451962,
-0.7452203035,
-0.3379519284,
-0.3319049776,
-0.3997039795,
0.2785338163,
-0.4401185513,
-0.4868988097,
-0.488743186,
-0.2239313573,
-0.1103222072,
0.3768044114,
0.6331877112,
0.2747613192,
-0.1772676408,
-0.0237717684,
-0.3222129941,
-0.0016681744,
0.2828920782,
0.3434812129,
0.7274965048,
-0.0246149972,
-0.3259705007,
-0.2572824657,
0.206885621,
0.4746101499,
-0.272520721,
0.5555369258,
0.4080382884,
-0.0432834402,
-0.3213682771,
-0.5970175266,
-0.3538267612,
-0.4487898648,
0.1393229216,
-0.4857766628,
-0.714168489,
0.5277037024,
0.0517756529,
0.1610663235,
0.1082169786,
0.9089646935,
-0.1865573227,
0.7422640324,
0.2922247052,
-0.1272708476,
0.4751750231,
-0.2596210241,
0.0225272141,
-0.8666757941,
0.2816171944,
-0.4089765251,
-0.3832394779,
-0.3075029254,
-0.3810016215,
0.06251885,
0.0883889794,
0.0597440489,
0.3023875058,
-0.0793684646,
0.406922847,
0.6806177497,
0.1842262298,
0.4110248387,
-0.4012401998,
-0.2760964632,
-0.0190111306,
-0.4543963373,
-0.0787578598,
1.3345892429,
-0.0746356323,
0.5101773143,
0.0545332618,
0.508585155,
0.5848097205,
0.5642568469,
-0.5290271044,
0.6513414383,
0.2446391582,
-0.9873690009,
-0.2648091018,
-0.2841903269,
-1.0219188929,
0.4324213266,
-0.0827725604,
-0.8867504001,
0.0223814864,
0.2661413848,
-0.3559432924,
0.0807856247,
-0.7714857459,
0.6462646127,
-0.1494148523,
-0.423807621,
-0.4090348482,
-0.383189559,
0.3931124508,
0.0260437466,
0.0667985529,
-0.3240245581,
0.2089441866,
0.4545431137,
0.124867186,
0.8812041879,
-0.4697372615,
0.3369924724,
0.3059560955,
0.4130668342,
0.5139291883,
-0.1409862787,
-0.1050396413,
-0.0648087859,
-0.0238645151,
-0.5296393633,
-0.5348933339,
0.5330446959,
-0.3423604667,
-0.7943559885,
-0.1707196385,
-0.873097837,
-0.2924701869,
0.0860690773,
0.3631868958,
0.5128824115,
-0.2948286533,
0.0815823153,
0.6580167413,
0.1357632279,
0.3438876271,
0.7504274845,
-0.1128966734,
0.1580442637,
0.4225356877,
0.3979626596,
0.7279475927,
0.3357369006,
0.3200902939,
-0.4365624785,
-0.6577115655,
-0.2071761042,
0.1167915016,
-0.7673652768,
0.2053908408,
-0.319021672,
0.2920791209,
-0.2069872022,
-0.273707509,
0.0278479122,
-0.2844580114,
0.016387077,
-0.2794521153,
0.1231791526,
0.4191015065,
-0.1129787713,
0.4508011937,
-0.2663243711,
0.1880879849,
0.336850822,
-0.0176037047,
0.1012117639,
-0.3535446823,
0.0250487085,
0.0159187987,
-0.2913362086,
-0.7088287473,
0.0468168892,
-0.0269393362,
1.0054376125,
0.1629939377,
0.0808558241,
0.7183488011,
-0.3749233484,
0.8624822497,
0.2308007181,
-0.854524076,
0.3501284122,
-0.067697145,
0.1942729801,
0.6961044669,
0.3160604835,
-0.524918437,
-0.2907628417,
-0.4301213324,
-0.5018689632,
0.1452673078,
0.3003310859,
-0.1824418604,
-0.0856164768,
0.2470831573,
0.2599583864,
0.412578851,
-0.6581538916,
-0.5275602341,
0.2928151786,
0.2111258656,
-0.1920234114,
-0.2279880345,
-0.1587274671,
-0.2242282033,
0.5094006062,
0.0383381657,
0.0680566058,
0.622564137,
-0.5230361819,
-0.080508396,
0.5032992363,
0.8743283749,
0.7969365716,
-0.6681448817,
-0.07994923,
0.5343854427,
-0.5341803432,
0.2822823226,
-0.0871033072,
-0.1392748058,
0.021813821,
0.2340224981,
0.3665841222,
0.2096761018,
-0.8126094937,
0.4003308713,
0.119692713,
-0.4254608154,
0.0142968614,
0.5851699114,
-0.0274726003,
0.0061249658,
0.4680514634,
-0.1460099369,
0.2383349538,
-0.6216979623,
0.7187597156,
0.3758645356,
-0.3658245504,
-0.1338036507,
0.7447932363,
0.0132072847,
-0.4963352978,
0.3910965919,
-0.2550727427,
-0.4583229423,
0.8390309811,
0.6490269899,
0.3205560446,
-0.4111006558,
0.069525823,
0.2331065834,
0.3154082596,
0.1297800243,
0.4776652753,
-0.0172382239,
-0.6068211794,
-0.6125353575,
-0.1007876396,
-0.5234259367,
0.2131809294,
-0.7596994042,
-0.0879937857,
-0.2203361839,
-0.3686983883,
0.0979216397,
0.1452186108,
-1.0369153023,
0.377199322,
0.3864946663,
1.17773664,
-0.7893877029,
0.7123448849,
0.3984534442,
-0.2903256416,
-0.5340034962,
-0.1486963034,
-0.0272679869,
-0.9758206606,
0.9258218408,
0.4328536689,
0.0671312064,
-0.1962206364,
-0.2566349506,
-0.7129921913,
1.0888510942,
0.1432919055,
-0.4945971072,
0.2250064462,
0.5513694882,
0.4096128941,
-0.3539774418,
0.3722113371,
0.8910470605,
0.4481578767,
-0.3360549212,
-1.1254255772,
0.1852429062,
-0.114470616,
-0.3377584815,
0.2229261696,
-0.593031466,
0.8748955131,
-0.2764693797,
-0.1607479304,
-0.1111244187,
0.0891336352,
0.6327409744,
0.8283011913,
0.7183358669,
0.6375490427,
0.7490265369,
0.1037695259,
1.0565373898,
-0.1877085865,
0.290899545,
1.1042797565,
-0.6755173802,
1.1158727407,
0.8746984601,
-0.3561422825,
0.5348980427,
0.3758935034,
0.1021464467,
0.4510216117,
0.5657637119,
-0.1354448497,
0.0478957817,
0.0003913513,
-0.2554062605,
0.285699755,
0.2467881143,
-0.2722222507,
-0.3582768738,
-0.0827064142,
0.0544297025,
-0.1377409846,
-0.3902131915,
0.1525666416,
0.024387015,
-0.7952817082,
0.708063066,
-0.4244235754,
0.5943192244,
-0.5152474046,
-0.043062672,
-0.1926504225,
0.1363203228,
-0.0676319674,
-0.8131858706,
0.1666105837,
-0.3005812168,
-0.3853981197,
0.1021091864,
0.5833261013,
-0.2082748413,
-0.1000890583,
0.6012812853,
0.834414959,
0.061965432,
-0.2436778247,
-0.7451840639,
-0.2527577877,
0.025796352,
-0.4206603169,
0.5097451806,
-0.2073270679,
-0.0763505325,
0.7820365429,
1.0192569494,
-0.0931788981,
0.4822527468,
-0.0511584133,
0.4618887603,
-0.5293613076,
-0.522592783,
-1.0379412174,
0.3631070256,
-0.0539704189,
-0.3816157579,
0.720173955,
0.7514361143,
0.8898755312,
-0.0919460133,
0.8069276214,
-0.1650300175,
0.5303280354,
-0.3639152944,
0.3208883405,
-0.4994847476,
-0.051692225,
0.0799825937,
-0.6736630201,
0.1402314454,
0.0838597119,
-0.3961838186,
-0.4174462855,
0.9474390745,
0.9213998318,
0.074986279,
-0.1024430469,
0.5617927313,
0.078427732,
0.2533834279,
0.7809313536,
0.6460154057,
-0.3195194006,
0.4262737632,
-0.3859762549,
-0.1217309758,
-0.3976907134,
-0.7308316231,
-1.0308750868,
-0.4383206964,
-0.2630811334,
-0.2988016009,
0.0471180454,
0.6549178958,
0.4689925909,
-0.6726105213,
-0.3539870083,
0.0275433436,
0.0191443376,
-0.7480356693,
-0.2559395432,
0.136821121,
-0.2585765123,
-0.5121427774,
0.4369862974,
-0.0695272535,
0.0076605277,
-0.0876929462,
0.0196180288,
-0.15888457,
0.2486631274,
0.4660126865,
0.3233233392,
-0.6761988997,
-0.2437661439,
0.2200239301,
-0.0972226858,
0.4770118594,
0.8325591683,
-0.7911137938,
0.4062899947,
0.5408783555,
0.459176302,
0.4375761151,
0.1467839032,
0.585558176,
-0.6486300826,
0.1746533513,
-0.1859605014,
0.6289725304,
0.0334962532,
-0.5959456563,
0.6412510872,
0.4807378352,
-0.5448168516,
-0.9132640362,
0.2962732315,
-1.0202578306,
-0.1963271648,
1.3130697012,
-0.1196734682,
-0.3406878412,
-0.1969085485,
-0.276920855,
0.1036238819,
-0.4261878133,
0.707420826,
1.0632743835,
-0.3564687371,
-0.140447095,
-1.1408398151,
0.3167434037,
0.6880680919,
-0.4957765341,
0.082161501,
0.2272886783,
0.6425283551,
0.2311800122,
0.6342324018,
0.273652494,
0.6298391819,
0.1300258785,
0.1864079982,
-0.1629173309,
0.1698890179,
-0.1090894118,
0.2318872958,
0.057551939,
-0.3554551005
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11632v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11632v1 | Unveiling the Power of Source: Source-based Minimum Bayes Risk Decoding for Neural Machine Translation | 2024-06-17T15:13:52 | 2024-06-17T15:13:52 | Boxuan Lyu, Hidetaka Kamigaito, Kotaro Funakoshi, Manabu Okumura | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Maximum a posteriori decoding, a commonly used method for neural machine
translation (NMT), aims to maximize the estimated posterior probability.
However, high estimated probability does not always lead to high translation
quality. Minimum Bayes Risk (MBR) decoding offers an alternative by seeking
hypotheses with the highest expected utility.
In this work, we show that Quality Estimation (QE) reranking, which uses a QE
model as a reranker, can be viewed as a variant of MBR. Inspired by this, we
propose source-based MBR (sMBR) decoding, a novel approach that utilizes
synthetic sources generated by backward translation as ``support hypotheses''
and a reference-free quality estimation metric as the utility function, marking
the first work to solely use sources in MBR decoding. Experiments show that
sMBR significantly outperforms QE reranking and is competitive with standard
MBR decoding. Furthermore, sMBR calls the utility function fewer times compared
to MBR. Our findings suggest that sMBR is a promising approach for high-quality
NMT decoding. | [
0.0475654975,
-0.1211725101,
0.5434350371,
0.1490917802,
-0.5427630544,
0.1536628604,
0.088136822,
0.0855650753,
0.1157869026,
0.5760336518,
-0.4842779338,
-0.4250338078,
-0.8890365362,
0.0527513623,
-0.224026531,
0.9594026208,
0.2298986763,
0.2994706631,
0.0138461702,
0.0448878482,
-0.4624272883,
-0.6561987996,
-0.7158784866,
-0.0587963238,
0.7989003658,
0.2456265241,
0.9302877188,
0.791970253,
0.8047164679,
0.2408850193,
-0.0643828288,
0.0232687164,
-0.4282233119,
0.069416292,
-0.3000285625,
-0.5747154355,
-0.2323702425,
0.1017032415,
0.8065766692,
0.5373128653,
-0.2720037699,
0.3165642917,
-0.0066108,
0.866153419,
-0.8269824386,
0.1948426217,
-0.7900384665,
0.0143696219,
0.0394922979,
-0.5085427761,
-0.8993244171,
-0.4838289022,
-0.20673953,
-0.0690031275,
0.2221613973,
0.0162885413,
0.7209731936,
0.4151592553,
-0.6843037009,
0.259237349,
-0.4586205184,
0.7794135213,
-0.6424266696,
0.5676432848,
0.2509152889,
0.6674530506,
-0.2529254854,
-0.5010097027,
-0.3858190179,
-0.0519800112,
-0.0764972046,
-0.0472908542,
-0.612580061,
-0.05375297,
0.1025657877,
0.2599903345,
-0.3139020205,
-0.2569135129,
-0.4587979615,
-0.360109359,
0.6928369999,
-0.1435533762,
0.1320481151,
-0.5306132436,
-0.0741776749,
-0.3674478531,
-0.8821860552,
0.0435203649,
0.1983269751,
0.1810456216,
0.4311355352,
0.7090038061,
0.0397875234,
0.5945404768,
-0.078014046,
-0.0999032259,
0.1763411313,
-0.2609078586,
-0.3181518912,
0.1152156293,
0.8873823881,
0.4720302224,
-0.1427676529,
-0.4616075456,
-0.13809596,
-0.4572944939,
0.477165401,
-0.7107790112,
-0.1976216882,
-0.1344011873,
-0.7558858991,
-0.3739127815,
-0.0443606488,
-0.653940618,
-0.1552956998,
-0.0721962079,
0.8316937089,
-0.5250252485,
-0.1996026635,
-0.1173723862,
-0.3614189327,
0.3249658942,
-0.2111437917,
-0.692291379,
0.0002155201,
0.3581063151,
1.1242437363,
0.0439782105,
-0.0182900541,
-0.6991713643,
0.1602116227,
-0.4574016929,
0.664591372,
0.0638236776,
-0.5019907951,
-0.2355949879,
0.0532363392,
0.0951875225,
-0.3483793736,
0.7073902488,
-0.6507356763,
-0.2122469991,
-0.4603654146,
-0.2751474977,
-0.1975579113,
-0.3075572252,
-0.6946111321,
0.3779237568,
0.3518596888,
-0.6873751879,
0.3392072916,
-0.3792238832,
-0.5604474545,
-0.2403761595,
0.026534427,
-0.3586297333,
0.5927843451,
0.3982057571,
0.483084619,
-0.1057987511,
0.4215326309,
-0.1054349914,
-0.1812772453,
0.4764299691,
-0.9160494804,
0.7682397962,
0.4694462121,
-0.1588997692,
0.0031990111,
-0.829453826,
0.0670532882,
0.2777052522,
-0.2322503924,
-0.3664126694,
0.3544043303,
-0.2458392084,
0.2581564188,
-0.0307670962,
-0.7336443067,
-0.0327473283,
-0.4567902982,
0.7340388894,
0.874147892,
0.1989042014,
0.4832897484,
-0.3148546517,
0.2846729457,
0.0358351767,
0.0741231292,
0.0163540617,
-0.5511402488,
-0.3685385883,
-0.2240884602,
0.5090317726,
0.5053565502,
-0.982373476,
0.3075590432,
-0.5626733899,
-0.5122743249,
-1.1056929827,
-0.1087630093,
0.4432571828,
0.5026404262,
0.539732933,
-0.0263563544,
-0.4102580845,
-1.2117543221,
-0.4913698435,
-0.0867212564,
-0.1751071662,
-0.099143438,
-0.0727233291,
-0.0267317742,
0.880224824,
-0.4677316546,
-0.0898863003,
-0.4066223204,
-0.0089065339,
0.6003192663,
0.7647835016,
0.295314014,
-0.699691236,
-0.3383097053,
-0.2784335613,
-0.4847297668,
-0.0105571747,
-0.25579831,
-0.6441944838,
0.1642739177,
0.4131874144,
-0.3865370452,
0.2135091573,
0.8968836665,
-0.1435178667,
0.1948426217,
-0.2906971574,
0.2381462008,
-1.311517477,
0.1947920471,
-0.0581351966,
-0.1249169558,
-0.4542036057,
0.2748154402,
0.2767847478,
-0.1727516949,
-0.3773848116,
0.083089754,
-0.4728997946,
0.0247905497,
-0.4397387505,
-0.2931493819,
-0.0160104651,
0.2514562607,
0.0855870917,
0.8587693572,
0.1231649816,
-0.4227802455,
-0.0424065478,
0.2068019509,
-0.282276094,
0.2905644774,
-0.7023525834,
0.0879418328,
-0.2230036557,
-0.0036710361,
-0.9040859938,
0.1663570255,
0.2208384722,
-0.7212843895,
0.5491414666,
-0.484092772,
-0.4979229867,
-0.1863822937,
-0.083890073,
0.2800064385,
0.7694151998,
-0.6702153087,
0.4346815646,
0.4254671037,
-0.2718049288,
-0.7270538211,
-1.0412515402,
0.2384993434,
0.2356271297,
-0.6606302261,
0.4477959573,
-0.1303388923,
0.2289303392,
0.1245805919,
-0.5238141418,
-0.2981249094,
-0.1193971783,
0.2903426588,
0.3006118536,
-0.3749623597,
-0.246315062,
0.6831483245,
-0.4960587621,
0.2510329187,
-0.4550535083,
0.0227195118,
0.1759783775,
-0.3307077587,
-0.1749840677,
0.5949087739,
0.4555158615,
-0.134364903,
1.0340117216,
0.5167255402,
-0.2688076496,
0.0126510719,
-0.558003962,
-0.1274211258,
-0.5370823145,
0.1515984684,
-0.4940347075,
-0.7771257758,
0.1691274196,
0.1520004869,
-0.117993094,
0.5589514971,
0.2691733241,
-0.1543436646,
1.3361809254,
0.7220495939,
-0.1893477291,
0.3995003402,
-0.3297213316,
0.3911297321,
-0.7457391024,
-0.3822055161,
-0.4276372194,
-0.4213453233,
-0.8361201286,
-0.3904439509,
0.5342917442,
0.0692244694,
-0.0727062449,
0.5916712284,
-0.6014581323,
0.6741710305,
1.0755975246,
0.3995661139,
0.4176966846,
0.2737992406,
-0.1537759751,
-0.2407156676,
-0.9862287641,
-0.2704264224,
1.2111662626,
0.3681541383,
0.4913179278,
0.3423963785,
0.7991779447,
0.1414965838,
0.517973125,
-0.7959829569,
0.4486207664,
-0.0877760351,
-0.6920545697,
-0.2219331414,
-0.9699984789,
-0.9336741567,
0.489985317,
-0.1912993938,
-0.2866739035,
0.5447267294,
0.1213199571,
-0.314974457,
0.3727763593,
-0.49948892,
0.9065212607,
0.116465278,
-0.1050058082,
-0.1547715217,
-0.7208788991,
0.4835937321,
0.1584304422,
0.2337084115,
0.1554074585,
0.001662688,
0.5328252316,
-0.2756474316,
0.3376608193,
-0.1790495813,
0.0045966199,
0.1974107027,
0.4621237516,
0.4638724923,
0.2948220968,
-0.1633871198,
0.4595682621,
0.2387723774,
-0.6849461198,
-0.546225965,
0.5394484401,
-0.6427007914,
-0.5577389002,
-0.6969773173,
-0.3000710309,
-0.1869772375,
0.366091609,
0.674662292,
0.0515455268,
-0.071498841,
0.4398745894,
0.6155394912,
-0.1986718923,
0.3600314558,
0.6158736348,
0.2628254294,
-0.8477441072,
1.2856205702,
-0.0734448507,
0.2503280342,
0.7816153765,
0.2167992145,
-0.3865386546,
-0.9278162122,
-0.4379395247,
0.2496609688,
-0.6400911808,
-0.6165680289,
-0.5557146668,
-0.567728579,
-0.3313083947,
-0.2078548223,
-0.5200840831,
-0.1641394347,
0.0263303109,
-0.2714763284,
-0.1133641377,
0.1602030545,
-0.5445102453,
0.4944103062,
-1.3241659403,
0.3173936903,
0.1454211026,
0.2741497159,
-0.3798944056,
-0.5372367501,
-0.390179038,
0.1561715156,
-0.3364228904,
-1.2841804028,
0.8926483989,
-0.0934919417,
0.8234090209,
0.0667791888,
0.0567624643,
0.232793197,
-0.8827432394,
0.519092977,
0.3032076657,
-0.9875665903,
0.5904198289,
-0.0471960343,
-0.0496652238,
0.6303503513,
0.4875132143,
-0.4953094125,
-0.1902062744,
-0.6099127531,
-0.7277582288,
0.444762826,
0.3186178803,
0.1082332209,
-0.2070963979,
0.2807362974,
-0.0064713587,
0.3195420504,
-0.638448,
-0.1172037795,
-0.444508642,
-0.2316473722,
-0.5695411563,
-0.2534030378,
0.1467228383,
-0.1901084036,
0.6280102134,
0.0314601697,
0.5962033868,
0.4255824685,
-0.2901673913,
-0.3391750157,
0.3528936207,
0.2631332278,
0.103285566,
-0.6016290784,
0.1922174394,
-0.1543274075,
-0.35596928,
0.4161195159,
-0.0359913521,
-0.402359426,
0.3672656715,
0.1348039508,
0.5886260867,
0.3511299789,
-0.4612183571,
0.6005084515,
0.0997124463,
-0.102454327,
0.1239459664,
-0.088827312,
-0.0432559364,
0.2540884316,
0.4203176498,
0.4189575315,
0.3973641992,
-0.3773063123,
0.3482503295,
0.3192941546,
-0.2737556696,
-0.2119896561,
0.5890267491,
-0.0280782562,
-0.0639676005,
0.6943522692,
-0.2309764028,
-0.0666706711,
0.3120207489,
0.6663401127,
0.9026346207,
-0.3821111321,
0.2965683341,
0.5371561646,
0.7874438763,
-0.1141409129,
0.3351973891,
0.3055919111,
-0.4810162187,
-0.8878291249,
-0.617153883,
-0.3642438054,
-0.0768987834,
-0.8094879985,
-0.1600589305,
-0.3526967168,
-0.2714573443,
-0.1511189044,
-0.3181528449,
-0.3475215137,
-0.0031925114,
-0.1844400764,
0.9586706758,
-0.4471556842,
0.9045202732,
0.2199036181,
-0.548994422,
-0.6441500783,
0.0021240513,
-0.0377019383,
-0.6686311364,
0.6825432181,
-0.224541828,
-0.0392701291,
0.3974919319,
-0.4975084662,
-1.226875186,
1.2036774158,
0.8469929695,
-0.4118326008,
-0.1420448571,
-0.150216952,
0.1198379621,
-0.0846921504,
-0.1862792373,
0.3459428847,
0.2958509922,
-0.0031981657,
-0.4540357888,
0.2782110274,
-0.1942373216,
0.3172409236,
0.2965332568,
-0.3213286996,
0.5334830284,
-0.4212370217,
-0.3943577707,
-0.0906325802,
0.7256912589,
0.0642273501,
0.3996223211,
-0.0960506871,
0.1441604197,
0.2351956517,
0.0386977084,
1.1955763102,
-0.2120865881,
0.1020045429,
0.8850793242,
0.4909619987,
1.3167273998,
0.5646361709,
-0.2094591558,
0.3643511534,
0.4772846997,
0.0012074404,
1.0124486685,
0.3029454052,
0.0639948547,
-0.1042430475,
0.238627851,
-0.3965333402,
0.0978380665,
0.1351167262,
-0.784517765,
-0.1573668718,
-0.0879247487,
-0.2851326466,
0.0334395133,
-0.2918106914,
0.6517276168,
0.3405101001,
-0.4321379662,
0.6619436145,
0.301220268,
0.5656264424,
-0.5026333928,
0.0587240644,
-0.2939833999,
-0.0000440511,
0.0871104151,
-0.6241802573,
0.6420146227,
-0.2652355731,
-0.3849423528,
-0.2536506355,
0.5707727671,
-0.2990181744,
-0.5569498539,
-0.0060920818,
0.5729133487,
0.1319559366,
-0.6007768512,
-0.4426206946,
-0.2298080474,
-0.1485833228,
-0.1356005818,
0.6244764924,
0.4131403267,
0.4913685918,
0.6583254337,
1.0495451689,
0.1642436534,
0.2324102968,
-0.3762551844,
0.5470422506,
-0.8671995401,
-0.3619737625,
-0.9149744511,
0.3982729912,
0.0540511571,
0.0279342402,
0.6307429075,
0.3474363983,
0.7313800454,
-0.3987434506,
0.6755171418,
0.3359771669,
0.1517602503,
-0.6653425694,
0.9941341281,
-0.3294405937,
-0.0917715207,
-0.1191930249,
-0.8957335949,
-0.3274137378,
0.7770159841,
0.0556030869,
-0.4279431999,
0.8569852114,
0.6991339922,
-0.0568696484,
-0.1280331165,
0.6269881129,
0.0999825895,
0.1993476748,
0.7758802772,
0.4713975787,
-0.630053997,
0.8092357516,
-0.3110415339,
-0.3037965298,
-0.2776648402,
-1.0703834295,
-0.5246458054,
-0.488781184,
-0.148055315,
-0.6148443818,
0.1519703269,
0.8724291921,
0.6027427912,
-0.8371036649,
0.000103025,
-0.1057245582,
0.2579053044,
-0.6550973654,
-0.1205902845,
0.2814084888,
-0.3742775321,
-0.4403348267,
0.7887912989,
0.2039794922,
0.0243087709,
0.03050231,
-0.1402269751,
0.0802773461,
0.2485683113,
0.7556852698,
0.1277952343,
-0.4398236275,
-0.0355595537,
0.1312113255,
-0.2598547935,
0.0057553193,
0.9141736627,
-0.4538672864,
0.0933444574,
0.6760281324,
1.0353368521,
0.3162336946,
-0.2984834611,
0.7781493664,
-0.6125148535,
-0.2785311043,
0.2786337137,
0.4431252778,
0.0336241163,
-0.4799079001,
0.4723369479,
0.4147061408,
-0.5100929141,
-0.8560299873,
0.2305015177,
-1.1461749077,
-0.3914406896,
0.9528982639,
-0.2022870034,
-0.3393460214,
0.3375249207,
-0.2167803347,
0.460001111,
-0.5059277415,
0.6415048242,
0.5037637949,
0.2160435021,
-0.3071794212,
-0.7275182605,
0.316729635,
0.3341953456,
-0.263425678,
-0.1496547759,
0.4939984381,
0.4180043638,
0.1734607071,
0.5209795237,
-0.2973976135,
0.2349132001,
0.2123818547,
-0.078248933,
-0.4114837945,
-0.3456510305,
-0.5167155266,
0.4082186818,
0.0880528018,
-0.2889445722
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11629v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11629v3 | Can Many-Shot In-Context Learning Help Long-Context LLM Judges? See More, Judge Better! | 2024-06-17T15:11:58 | 2024-06-30T13:31:24 | Mingyang Song, Mao Zheng, Xuan Luo | cs.CL | cs.CL | Leveraging Large Language Models (LLMs) as judges for judging the performance
of LLMs has recently garnered attention. However, this type of approach is
affected by the potential biases in LLMs, raising concerns about the
reliability of the evaluation results. To mitigate this issue, we propose and
study two versions of many-shot in-context prompts, which rely on two existing
settings of many-shot ICL for helping GPT-4o-as-a-Judge in single answer
grading to mitigate the potential biases in LLMs, Reinforced ICL and
Unsupervised ICL. Concretely, the former utilizes in-context examples with
model-generated rationales, and the latter without. Based on the designed
prompts, we investigate the impact of scaling the number of in-context examples
on the consistency and quality of the judgment results. Furthermore, we reveal
the symbol bias hidden in the pairwise comparison of GPT-4o-as-a-Judge and
propose a simple yet effective approach to mitigate it. Experimental results
show that advanced long-context LLMs, such as GPT-4o, perform better in the
many-shot regime than in the zero-shot regime. Meanwhile, the experimental
results further verify the effectiveness of the symbol bias mitigation
approach. | [
-0.4334945679,
-0.5147017241,
0.9025990367,
0.2708021998,
-0.4459919631,
-0.1979373842,
-0.4177382886,
-0.4866036177,
-0.2804800272,
0.2979904711,
-0.2535875738,
-0.4541969895,
-0.6544121504,
0.2194494605,
0.0508781485,
1.2470611334,
-0.1689638346,
0.4930133522,
-0.2047013491,
-0.3829636276,
-0.6733656526,
-0.5883702636,
-0.8289912939,
-0.5175802112,
0.5073529482,
0.4327241182,
0.3315258622,
0.0920913443,
0.410523355,
0.1910332888,
-0.2388142347,
0.0375177898,
-0.2971003056,
0.1153194755,
-0.099909544,
-0.4273101091,
-0.3997558057,
0.2076777071,
0.7821356654,
0.4333785474,
0.031712763,
-0.0602748245,
0.3241977692,
0.5621843934,
-0.6889889836,
0.232578367,
-0.4344250262,
0.0958584175,
-0.1170852482,
-0.1570351422,
-0.7457488179,
-0.2108000219,
0.0119327968,
-0.6460876465,
-0.2374863774,
0.0657128915,
0.427618742,
0.1738645881,
-0.9024037123,
-0.2069117427,
-0.436124146,
0.984823823,
-0.8445510268,
-0.0683468431,
0.4002908468,
0.7409355044,
-0.1303058565,
-0.3905502856,
-0.3642103076,
-0.3024825156,
-0.0658943877,
0.3168772757,
0.1638703495,
0.1967023164,
0.6235018373,
-0.1625484973,
-0.3122128844,
0.4008369744,
-0.0150380051,
-0.3379912078,
0.3045773208,
0.0208558477,
-0.1925063878,
-0.1762848645,
-0.4905149043,
-0.0733297765,
-1.1767076254,
0.2919255197,
0.3168444932,
0.3400466442,
-0.0899708569,
0.248324573,
-0.2319096774,
0.737067759,
0.1148468256,
-0.3739089668,
0.1350237131,
-0.2511431873,
-0.1385670751,
0.0745849386,
0.5920770168,
0.8438410163,
0.4454813898,
0.067154929,
-0.2318085879,
-0.1708334386,
-0.0830782577,
-0.9253910184,
0.2451317906,
-0.0601858534,
-0.296338439,
-0.0789118409,
0.1376431584,
-0.7782417536,
-0.3239684999,
-0.4638893008,
0.6247870326,
-0.1648385972,
0.2114184648,
-0.0772621855,
-0.2349985093,
0.3303351402,
0.7194169164,
-0.6009227633,
0.1023708507,
0.568128109,
0.6705652475,
-0.1240234375,
-0.3825737536,
-1.0319279432,
0.1417274922,
-0.296823293,
0.7505996823,
-0.6672847867,
-0.2759297788,
0.1115341187,
-0.3386568725,
0.295753181,
-0.6062395573,
0.5926663876,
-0.4677198529,
0.1989807785,
-0.5961163044,
-0.5077970028,
0.0968213528,
0.611458838,
-0.4540809989,
0.7592475414,
0.0638022944,
-0.6238949299,
1.0463728905,
-0.5230759978,
-0.3613458872,
-0.110148333,
-0.5461830497,
-0.4754356444,
0.0186116006,
0.5890569091,
0.3731786907,
-0.1926921904,
0.2355797887,
-0.4980805516,
-0.7228460908,
0.1008796021,
-0.685231328,
0.4414560497,
0.1338097155,
-0.4613763988,
0.1920566559,
-0.5374910235,
0.0074080266,
-0.2825537026,
-0.534489274,
-0.2283641398,
-0.2028560787,
-0.0348551013,
0.555562377,
-0.4347730279,
-0.5867753029,
0.2554601431,
-0.3157201409,
0.3410443068,
1.0600661039,
0.0299774054,
0.4209418595,
-0.335730046,
0.5266132951,
0.2272118181,
0.0910915881,
-0.5297288299,
-0.4034336209,
-0.541411221,
-0.5378762484,
0.004579186,
0.0575959235,
-0.91046381,
0.1351816803,
-0.1075180918,
-0.0506288968,
-0.1792425513,
0.2117726207,
0.6328197122,
0.6867759824,
0.4416057169,
-0.2097641677,
-0.1105648428,
-0.6948645711,
-0.5410221219,
-0.0311059877,
-0.135319978,
0.4871207476,
0.4824873805,
0.2420844436,
1.0518125296,
-0.1502227038,
-0.2270206809,
-0.0945631266,
0.0502016991,
0.2597303987,
0.2485883236,
0.7517451048,
-0.3600049019,
-0.5251013041,
-0.2974252999,
-0.8398649096,
-0.2149661332,
-0.0962132961,
-0.0527073704,
0.0794988647,
0.5376017094,
-0.5721871853,
0.3892257512,
0.1450152546,
-0.4576373994,
0.7152963281,
-0.0168808438,
0.3158251643,
-0.8483107686,
-0.2129972279,
0.2354773581,
-0.4180862308,
-0.3444910049,
0.1690215468,
0.2854726613,
0.1820966601,
-0.8790197968,
0.8254120946,
-0.307867527,
-0.0888155624,
-0.4302927256,
0.1334006488,
0.1774728298,
0.3867259324,
-0.1258979887,
0.7687935233,
0.6453812718,
-0.6944995522,
0.2124257684,
-0.0500446856,
-0.4922641218,
1.1583532095,
-0.3957268298,
0.1358491033,
-0.241273284,
0.9642034173,
-0.7696164846,
-0.045562204,
0.1462375969,
-0.0812164098,
0.6124736071,
-0.5193277001,
-0.5103563666,
-0.3166872561,
-0.6962940097,
0.6361399889,
0.0570662059,
-1.0604200363,
0.18761383,
-0.2517829835,
0.0791348144,
-0.8275933862,
-0.5875831246,
0.1610021442,
-0.5669952035,
-0.3701860905,
0.1368470341,
-0.371722281,
-0.4171568751,
-0.5748024583,
-0.1409352571,
0.2912589312,
0.0989250392,
0.1507237107,
0.1975582689,
-0.1174632311,
0.4608701169,
0.011457637,
-0.1704995185,
0.096919477,
-0.2009883523,
0.2475377172,
-0.2256250829,
-0.7309089303,
-0.3272038996,
0.328217268,
0.7027605772,
-0.0333889909,
0.4166086614,
0.1638124883,
-0.1210824624,
-0.3111814559,
-0.6202069521,
-0.3048041165,
-0.4616564512,
0.2125563323,
-0.5013677478,
-1.059124589,
0.2532055974,
-0.2073642313,
0.1915718168,
0.3156570494,
0.669991076,
-0.1901317984,
0.822717607,
0.2840105891,
-0.3541252911,
0.6355617642,
-0.0873210207,
0.110222809,
-1.1280472279,
0.0632189587,
-0.3034429848,
-0.4219355285,
-0.3479165137,
-0.2867594659,
0.6613907814,
0.1879421622,
-0.5788320303,
-0.2382665128,
-0.1700113416,
0.7631418109,
0.432429105,
0.1930754185,
0.3524653316,
-0.0208011046,
-0.4634146094,
0.1929485947,
-0.4580735266,
-0.6163825989,
1.3457247019,
0.3594665527,
0.7187725902,
0.1845687926,
0.7013569474,
-0.0501733273,
0.6297333837,
-0.8717222214,
0.2671463788,
0.2651055157,
-0.5965391994,
-0.3157557547,
-0.3174402118,
-0.5720934868,
0.5928578377,
0.0039975517,
-0.6399270892,
-0.1000003368,
0.1467508227,
-0.4835976958,
0.1463561505,
-0.7155536413,
0.7108914852,
-0.2616664171,
-0.6512758732,
-0.0643742979,
-0.6970635653,
0.2913044691,
-0.2094371915,
0.3343990743,
-0.0631594062,
0.2164050788,
0.4465557635,
-0.4142893255,
1.0214884281,
-0.3690529764,
-0.0005749066,
0.4438276887,
-0.1332307309,
0.583812356,
0.3999558091,
-0.4117671251,
-0.0512098931,
-0.2497113347,
-0.3967551589,
-0.5675772429,
0.8309306502,
-0.6086289287,
-0.5855919719,
-0.462245822,
-0.3717709482,
-0.4188616872,
-0.0523128621,
0.3593461215,
0.5380036235,
0.0260529853,
0.2027212232,
0.2648674548,
-0.153614834,
0.7947521806,
0.6042771935,
0.0198623314,
-0.1817864776,
0.243206799,
0.0104466323,
0.4162766933,
0.2071343362,
0.3621776104,
-0.2062630206,
-0.4598552287,
-0.6571672559,
0.1674764901,
-1.1354696751,
-0.5140407085,
-0.080455333,
0.2278787345,
-0.2220708281,
-0.2802850902,
-0.0707824677,
-0.2137121558,
-0.2040100843,
-0.367811799,
0.2965411842,
0.5587367415,
0.2556515634,
0.427950561,
-0.4635616541,
0.029652888,
0.4369212091,
0.5921506286,
0.0715840012,
-0.8860894442,
-0.1415378898,
-0.1491743624,
-0.4116206765,
-0.5326732993,
0.0362680517,
0.2203106433,
0.6188365221,
0.5566759706,
-0.0903906599,
0.8295325637,
-0.6998165846,
0.8728578687,
0.3588901162,
-0.7769479156,
0.6672888398,
-0.2979032397,
0.583525002,
0.6680250764,
0.1471445858,
-0.4620493054,
-0.5612488985,
-0.0745262727,
-0.6599742174,
0.8940601945,
-0.1980523169,
0.2499702722,
-0.2827817202,
0.5746316314,
0.1626630425,
0.1521436572,
-1.0089608431,
-0.0109220268,
-0.1776266396,
0.0424531773,
-0.1401489377,
-0.350094527,
-0.2859114707,
-0.2115814239,
0.4264617264,
-0.5174963474,
-0.1970650703,
0.2063408047,
-0.3148681521,
-0.045037698,
0.6520251036,
0.5950024724,
0.7748494744,
-0.0798403174,
0.3433560431,
0.3991098702,
0.0261695087,
0.079357028,
-0.3558546901,
-0.1432355791,
-0.3017724156,
0.5800945759,
0.7979312539,
0.3533218205,
-0.5916681886,
0.8250233531,
0.1176577806,
-0.1419328004,
-0.1083309352,
-0.2393777817,
-0.2099387199,
0.3458473682,
0.3295091391,
-0.145328477,
0.1016405076,
-0.758670032,
0.2932086289,
0.521497786,
-0.4113678634,
-0.0383678377,
0.4741862118,
0.2027734816,
0.1064648181,
0.6585888267,
-0.3029505014,
-0.4620787501,
0.5552746654,
0.7798121572,
0.615991056,
0.0322068222,
-0.1110802591,
0.3498718739,
-0.0039799968,
-0.3116488755,
-0.1495839208,
-0.2013520449,
-0.6608332992,
-0.4404415488,
-0.5818780661,
-0.4429716766,
-0.0546922795,
-0.4508089721,
0.4695652127,
-0.5638316274,
-0.3259230852,
-0.2389145195,
-0.1945395321,
-0.7025592923,
0.0451298058,
0.3764544725,
0.7166574597,
-0.973651886,
0.8891677856,
0.4831232429,
-0.4089336097,
-0.7417280674,
0.0543420203,
0.3525844514,
-0.545825839,
0.8747795224,
0.5755614042,
-0.2297479659,
-0.3934013247,
-0.488868475,
-0.5968401432,
1.1820909977,
0.4460055828,
-0.5802512169,
0.2195307165,
-0.184503302,
0.5916461945,
-0.3414402604,
0.8944200873,
0.5470026135,
0.623278141,
0.3018727601,
-1.1822417974,
-0.0110766208,
0.049438864,
-0.188738212,
0.0071233851,
-0.6720919609,
0.558932066,
-0.1975088269,
0.0917981192,
-0.2651143968,
0.3563838303,
0.5813534856,
0.5729256868,
0.4645166099,
0.5070750713,
0.5516495705,
-0.0586568043,
1.1990044117,
0.0070205014,
0.3202050626,
1.4436546564,
-0.5537484884,
0.688970685,
0.7566974163,
-0.1166187823,
0.2934510708,
0.4496110082,
-0.007430919,
0.3599309027,
0.3805319667,
-0.4906624556,
-0.2386762947,
-0.0471202508,
-0.1156100407,
0.3821881413,
0.093145743,
-0.272808224,
-0.539419353,
0.2347830832,
0.1457191557,
0.1183546558,
-0.4540051222,
0.6579614878,
0.3838524222,
-0.8324173093,
0.3026746511,
0.064509429,
1.0444142818,
-0.4540970922,
-0.1136044338,
-0.3373934329,
0.1576482207,
-0.2195623517,
-0.8277938962,
-0.0444648452,
0.110369049,
-0.1665724665,
-0.2707921267,
0.3641624749,
-0.1699246317,
-0.3541739881,
0.4129112661,
0.3112350404,
0.226499632,
-0.3475347459,
-0.4790391326,
-0.1547033936,
-0.3080290854,
-0.3053222001,
0.6855263114,
0.4242813587,
-0.506457746,
0.6552730203,
0.376570642,
-0.0596549697,
0.0602413006,
0.615001142,
0.8966815472,
-0.5717867017,
-0.3293893039,
-1.159271121,
0.2691965401,
-0.1263202429,
-0.3376173973,
0.7378337383,
0.598972261,
0.9343878627,
0.1343155354,
0.5696891546,
0.4548940659,
0.1988361776,
-0.7349591255,
0.5441459417,
-0.407743901,
0.5149745345,
-0.3179550171,
-0.8398500681,
-0.6066195965,
0.5917302966,
-0.3652505875,
0.3891449571,
0.84188205,
0.6209101081,
0.1239515096,
-0.4044907987,
0.5026475787,
-0.1626283228,
0.7496304512,
0.7320680618,
0.926830411,
-0.2261840999,
0.5249015093,
0.0944067389,
-0.2772006691,
-0.3732071817,
-1.0063899755,
-1.0195707083,
0.0557813235,
-0.1923649907,
-0.1395402998,
-0.0265386347,
1.0393213034,
0.7345238328,
-0.7028696537,
-0.1369449943,
0.2844207287,
0.2125683278,
-0.1031427905,
-0.1707472205,
0.3740000427,
-0.5878457427,
-0.6605546474,
0.5095342994,
0.4714173377,
-0.1861068159,
0.1639677286,
-0.2483018488,
0.1573424786,
-0.2258077711,
1.0454288721,
-0.0370729119,
-0.9659531713,
-0.6983270049,
-0.401450485,
-0.1408637911,
0.4337905049,
0.7908902764,
-0.9355357289,
0.7274576426,
0.1803425848,
0.3286855519,
0.5565706491,
0.0602390245,
0.5200694203,
-0.9913074374,
0.1272342652,
0.2949984372,
0.6475152373,
0.1913586855,
-0.1701136529,
0.2470349669,
-0.0079665706,
-0.5007011294,
-0.4745463431,
0.3428136408,
-1.0112295151,
-0.3784193993,
1.4834603071,
-0.2449747175,
0.2057208866,
0.0217519961,
-0.3403423727,
0.1126296595,
-0.5338907242,
0.7210350633,
1.1296466589,
-0.162241146,
-0.1570848078,
-0.6201496124,
0.3242744803,
0.5160936117,
-0.7393218875,
0.0405234247,
0.7830681801,
0.4564207792,
-0.2454871237,
0.6574242711,
-0.3932283819,
0.3330913484,
-0.5257358551,
-0.1359351724,
-0.0040361979,
-0.4160323441,
-0.8349041343,
0.0091898888,
0.4814041555,
0.1716088355
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11624v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11624v1 | Words in Motion: Representation Engineering for Motion Forecasting | 2024-06-17T15:07:55 | 2024-06-17T15:07:55 | Omer Sahin Tas, Royden Wagner | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CV | Motion forecasting transforms sequences of past movements and environment
context into future motion. Recent methods rely on learned representations,
resulting in hidden states that are difficult to interpret. In this work, we
use natural language to quantize motion features in a human-interpretable way,
and measure the degree to which they are embedded in hidden states. Our
experiments reveal that hidden states of motion sequences are arranged with
respect to our discrete sets of motion features. Following these insights, we
fit control vectors to motion features, which allow for controlling motion
forecasts at inference. Consequently, our method enables controlling
transformer-based motion forecasting models with textual inputs, providing a
unique interface to interact with and understand these models. Our
implementation is available at https://github.com/kit-mrt/future-motion | [
-0.1947691292,
-0.102528505,
0.7402237058,
0.2272914946,
-0.3119919598,
0.3732307553,
0.4144607782,
-0.4719523489,
0.5097542405,
0.6090308428,
-0.9274902344,
-0.1201421097,
-0.7283940911,
-0.3116663992,
-0.8249877691,
0.5824939609,
-0.3513482809,
0.1850768477,
-0.1028150618,
-0.089650102,
-0.8681375384,
-0.392473042,
-0.0268953033,
-0.7713688016,
0.0230230857,
0.0072462438,
1.0134536028,
0.6155780554,
0.493155092,
0.3411067128,
-0.0372624546,
-0.0812519938,
-0.0383972488,
0.3051607311,
-0.1528425813,
-0.4310422242,
-0.1872789264,
0.0982900411,
0.5291761756,
0.482537955,
-0.1043273434,
0.0265331585,
0.0309458915,
0.5935865641,
-0.5689758658,
0.5297990441,
-0.0949907377,
0.4696478546,
0.1183692962,
-0.1472148299,
-0.0905872285,
-0.456430912,
0.0349647254,
-0.5438939929,
0.1847038865,
0.2765838802,
0.9006891251,
0.5784212351,
-0.2309204489,
-0.2699986398,
-1.0758641958,
0.7693683505,
-0.3711797595,
0.8226848841,
0.3746593595,
0.6917482615,
-0.1018127725,
-0.8648466468,
-0.5503925681,
-0.11994908,
-0.3832770288,
0.3573752642,
-0.0606855489,
0.0089714136,
0.3193069696,
0.2045879364,
-0.5760373473,
-0.2568089068,
-0.0060250266,
-0.317772001,
0.7751905918,
0.4883233011,
0.0018551953,
-0.1090966985,
-0.3874145746,
-0.4181847572,
-0.3269323111,
0.0747875646,
0.0616806857,
0.0456753485,
-0.3461589813,
0.76286906,
-0.0292483196,
0.2846014798,
0.1029279903,
0.027405642,
0.1284165233,
0.2754917145,
-0.3594330251,
0.0524805784,
0.7168930769,
0.3142640889,
0.0020779476,
-0.2713184357,
-0.4533265233,
0.0658009425,
0.2617610991,
-0.5114580393,
-0.2203225642,
-0.0453242287,
-0.2995670736,
-0.1772367209,
0.4519853592,
-1.0444355011,
-0.7865434885,
-0.6181001663,
0.562879622,
-0.5176234841,
-0.0092761153,
0.1274331063,
-0.5092990994,
0.3437558115,
0.0540353209,
-1.0553555489,
0.3227375746,
0.7406324744,
0.7671955228,
0.1821559072,
-0.1159512028,
-0.1566518247,
0.3259446323,
-0.4502178431,
0.7278614044,
-0.8045999408,
-0.7656402588,
-0.0426225066,
0.1545900404,
0.0478444807,
-0.244948566,
0.2819694877,
-0.5482997298,
0.4341597557,
0.0329702124,
-0.4618307948,
-0.5917482376,
-0.1594231725,
-0.6974208355,
0.9075039029,
0.0017195232,
-0.4724960327,
0.4634912312,
-1.126401782,
-0.5148796439,
0.0241450425,
-0.1418975443,
-0.2952378988,
0.3550032377,
0.3606217504,
0.5396988392,
0.2377930582,
0.2861063778,
0.1542981267,
-0.2691206038,
0.2376490533,
-0.6377230883,
0.0847886577,
0.2703852355,
-0.3308743536,
0.3828355074,
-0.726883471,
-0.1198298931,
0.1466080546,
0.0078486204,
0.0093499683,
0.5567004085,
-0.2649374604,
0.0238836128,
0.2257307172,
-0.2551074922,
-0.0395825952,
-0.5646428466,
0.4889227152,
0.5935357809,
-0.0187791884,
0.93565768,
-0.1954369992,
1.0573644638,
0.0040823338,
0.1546930224,
-0.4772931933,
-0.6695153713,
-0.6595169306,
0.3217171729,
-0.0354478918,
0.7048757076,
-0.9275089502,
0.1872297227,
-0.6111113429,
-0.4063049555,
-0.2133352757,
-0.4893171191,
0.0447528027,
0.1705036461,
0.4722604454,
0.1717477143,
-0.5708249807,
-0.3510857522,
-0.3395503163,
0.0311719365,
-0.4817845523,
-0.1965769827,
0.4106636941,
-0.1953616142,
1.1805210114,
-0.7780596018,
0.2340155244,
-0.2137285173,
0.5408605933,
0.1463926584,
0.2891503572,
0.1833589971,
-1.0433348417,
-0.1842477471,
-0.0973705053,
-0.5751199126,
0.2492946237,
-0.2875025272,
-0.0544809215,
-0.2956451178,
0.5248506069,
-0.4463610947,
0.6714727879,
0.783618331,
-0.6722091436,
0.2684132755,
-0.0976804495,
-0.1121153608,
-0.8905103803,
-0.2526032627,
0.0197877157,
-0.3909198642,
-0.2225175798,
-0.1140410975,
0.1737182736,
-0.5498696566,
-0.4079036713,
0.4837653339,
-0.5021677017,
-0.1554227918,
-0.2237365097,
-0.0041450872,
0.1088665202,
0.2772438824,
0.1500203013,
0.8435447216,
0.315644443,
-0.6857404113,
0.3379619122,
0.2390041947,
-0.3808128238,
0.1571803987,
-0.3080020547,
0.0944453403,
-0.2890401185,
-0.2345333695,
-0.4067097604,
-0.5116547942,
0.2793112993,
-0.4770126045,
0.5973839164,
0.0024914884,
-0.174951449,
-0.6476070881,
0.0033411561,
-0.2152710408,
0.6427415013,
-0.3521344066,
1.0386021137,
0.4444427192,
0.1724882126,
-0.3314602077,
-0.944601953,
0.0941951275,
-0.2988764346,
-0.2258403152,
0.5654780865,
0.0017484515,
-0.1490421742,
-0.0707939342,
-0.0619558953,
-0.088135168,
0.0204415135,
0.7601417303,
0.1024022326,
-0.0440087765,
0.2041880488,
0.1464029402,
-0.3800829053,
0.1934282184,
-0.4015032947,
0.54529953,
0.0132506648,
-0.4737375081,
-0.3435968459,
0.3162390888,
0.8676591516,
-0.2917559147,
0.4641164541,
0.5434598327,
-0.4297858477,
-0.036779128,
0.076786764,
-0.2457665056,
-0.5773794651,
0.3892217577,
-0.2188770175,
-0.7384414673,
0.3695034683,
-0.2731663287,
-0.0342769139,
0.4420487583,
0.2206167281,
-0.4902987182,
1.1916842461,
1.194342494,
-0.023078436,
0.6838354468,
-0.4101379514,
0.3423457444,
-0.703908205,
-0.4319224656,
-0.2651034594,
-0.7256320715,
-0.6502472162,
-0.5016713142,
0.1736028045,
0.1049164534,
-0.4797821343,
0.7440903187,
-0.6547771096,
0.5330904126,
0.529191196,
0.1105711684,
-0.0854288414,
-0.3953412771,
-0.1353599429,
-0.1992166638,
-0.4669379294,
-0.7090984583,
0.5662565231,
0.5105986595,
0.8721479177,
-0.1866898537,
0.4499007165,
0.1769413352,
0.3526317775,
-1.0970253944,
0.5839626193,
-0.1535622478,
-0.3379802406,
-0.3771885931,
-0.0215964317,
-0.7938057184,
-0.0342025757,
-0.2788241506,
-0.7920525074,
0.3545868695,
0.2512740791,
-0.5367228389,
0.4457235336,
-0.5892834067,
0.5753777027,
-0.4642195702,
0.2090432793,
-0.0890955999,
-0.6604686379,
0.0389249735,
0.1200745776,
0.1974275708,
-0.1884054542,
0.0353948101,
0.673432827,
-0.3144011199,
0.8381002545,
-0.1683693677,
0.1645120233,
0.3558836877,
0.110622175,
0.4849640131,
-0.2465046495,
-0.08137732,
0.1460949779,
-0.0041829837,
-0.0429618396,
-0.699700892,
0.2401765436,
-0.2757221758,
-0.2915482223,
-0.4623807669,
-0.4450129569,
-0.1648734808,
0.0585079752,
0.4537225962,
0.3847130835,
-0.1190366969,
-0.2710283995,
0.4230892956,
-0.1305842698,
1.1228108406,
0.234874472,
-0.4927071631,
-0.4685453176,
0.9404756427,
0.0111285206,
-0.1177137792,
1.0269912481,
0.4593806565,
-0.4744614661,
-0.4185954034,
-0.322983712,
-0.008293841,
-0.5275425315,
-0.3031264246,
-0.2476951033,
-0.1101591811,
-0.3397913277,
-0.12035238,
-0.1847258955,
-0.5235906243,
-0.4797222912,
-0.387460798,
0.2251705527,
1.3253692389,
0.1226057112,
0.8275290132,
-0.9896230102,
0.2575434148,
0.4972933829,
0.4690694511,
-0.4054617584,
-0.3213395178,
-0.6068153977,
0.0881143138,
-0.9812354445,
-0.8607119918,
0.8922502398,
0.1686323732,
0.4303148389,
0.5603684783,
-0.1490710974,
0.8341988921,
-0.7216513157,
1.1809436083,
0.3616820574,
-1.0812802315,
0.7558603287,
-0.0540452339,
0.5064110756,
-0.1270355582,
0.448497951,
-0.5210446715,
-0.1530193388,
-0.561909318,
-0.4466954172,
0.318519026,
-0.0111050755,
0.4409148097,
0.1555423737,
0.1414867789,
-0.144677788,
0.4131453335,
-0.5233052373,
-0.2396161407,
-0.6385201812,
-0.2830410898,
-0.1382083446,
-0.5387715101,
0.1763900369,
-0.10260766,
0.3098359406,
-0.1142763644,
0.8045104742,
-0.1274400353,
0.1019009054,
-0.2463745028,
0.0066889212,
0.9165136218,
0.4439053833,
-0.0012705915,
-0.0444278941,
0.0996657163,
-0.8893802166,
0.0809460804,
-0.0075876671,
-0.1137839481,
0.4178189337,
0.4292939305,
0.8950292468,
0.4708450437,
-0.3576184213,
0.2627365887,
0.1090288088,
0.0647215322,
-0.4239697158,
0.0265364274,
-0.0371105336,
0.518856585,
0.3188596964,
0.5546739101,
0.1266192347,
-0.28163293,
-0.0512700081,
0.1388419569,
-0.9463268518,
-0.6813753247,
1.2060278654,
-0.0329463445,
-0.3958094418,
0.3688140213,
-0.1843810976,
-0.7333719134,
0.4359391928,
0.2804422975,
1.3837918043,
-0.3645795584,
0.1271149963,
0.2580609024,
0.2655659616,
-0.2730220556,
0.5374065042,
0.2301600873,
-0.8137267828,
-0.6533382535,
-0.7816086411,
-0.4429530203,
-0.2120707184,
-0.5916953087,
0.4051153064,
-0.3681496382,
-0.4157642126,
-0.2587919235,
-0.4169872105,
-0.6231445074,
0.4578476846,
0.4564638138,
0.9545622468,
-0.8492388129,
0.657342732,
0.790707767,
-0.2071374059,
-0.7251170278,
0.1868506521,
-0.0695805848,
-0.630640626,
0.4953977764,
0.158712253,
-0.2458462566,
-0.1859986186,
-0.7327594161,
-1.0512697697,
1.3461008072,
0.5491425991,
-0.5468602777,
-0.1820061654,
0.2057539821,
0.307885617,
0.001279074,
-0.031727735,
0.3347256482,
0.6423584223,
0.305930227,
-0.6175817847,
-0.4297128618,
0.1568659842,
0.0906274989,
0.6729072332,
-0.1795043498,
0.5640124679,
-0.048725415,
-0.5427398682,
0.0189085379,
1.0484074354,
-0.2452859879,
0.6113488674,
0.1431968659,
0.4782619476,
0.8498405814,
-0.5290713906,
1.1803129911,
-0.4416555166,
0.2861316502,
1.261469245,
0.0379459858,
0.8029367924,
0.35844329,
-0.5170418024,
0.8391275406,
0.4052528143,
0.0986002386,
0.862704277,
-0.2121159434,
-0.2483914942,
-0.0897102654,
0.3124583066,
0.0033672249,
0.609685421,
0.5173301101,
-0.3044439554,
-0.0108860759,
0.3916074634,
-0.2303000391,
0.2051656842,
-0.5328832269,
0.6228792667,
0.2058500648,
-0.2296727747,
-0.0969032347,
-0.0786907449,
0.5066438913,
-0.6906964779,
-0.3839933276,
-0.1181917191,
-0.1350910813,
-0.0082752872,
-1.08129704,
0.8098592162,
-0.3038842678,
-0.1919122636,
-0.7001777291,
0.3902345002,
0.0193966161,
-0.6725432873,
0.0625129715,
0.1339900047,
-0.009746368,
-0.3226482272,
-0.4947212338,
-0.3263483942,
-0.1592527479,
-0.0779532343,
0.0063689426,
0.5937213302,
-0.3427672386,
1.1808232069,
0.1051195115,
0.0852182806,
0.2191171646,
-0.1531878412,
0.7078724504,
-1.0306073427,
-0.6035514474,
-0.6815845966,
0.7657763958,
0.1875317544,
-0.0068505215,
0.4492380917,
0.3070640862,
0.5737380981,
-0.3237050772,
0.4688450098,
0.0471307375,
0.542460382,
-0.659278214,
0.8009285331,
-0.1060005128,
0.1340828985,
0.0018259863,
-0.6219272017,
-0.2796367407,
0.4001721442,
-0.397184819,
-0.067103222,
0.6915867329,
0.4116735458,
0.0992592499,
0.2897012234,
0.7221782804,
-0.0707834437,
0.2365843654,
0.1600834727,
0.9056108594,
-0.4325221181,
0.1978747398,
-0.5579767227,
0.1100419462,
0.0645588711,
-1.2563021183,
-0.4299148619,
-0.6707391143,
-0.2212672085,
-0.0144460239,
-0.2376309335,
0.8588503003,
0.8677765131,
-1.2022565603,
-0.1333488375,
-0.2376875877,
0.1630651504,
-0.4949771762,
-0.2422039956,
0.2005689293,
0.0313012153,
-0.7067635655,
0.8481105566,
0.2308459729,
0.6183858514,
-0.3831793964,
-0.1346572042,
0.4338441193,
-0.1360853761,
0.789270401,
0.1213440001,
-0.5355481505,
-0.4240236282,
0.0039146137,
0.3459999263,
0.0829261318,
0.9604038,
-1.1972655058,
0.4318339229,
0.3770053983,
0.0466211289,
0.5136345029,
0.0851827189,
0.9296869636,
-0.7360244989,
0.2652930021,
0.4496054649,
0.5369893312,
0.2581294179,
-0.477977097,
0.4564692676,
0.1358884424,
-0.4043827057,
-0.1921533644,
0.2245938927,
-0.697589457,
-0.0753647536,
0.4450608194,
0.1082173362,
-0.1094964668,
0.0937730744,
-0.0460641719,
0.3030878007,
-0.2168942541,
0.60683465,
0.3880512118,
-0.3352436125,
-0.5494533181,
-0.7810424566,
0.4029320776,
-0.3001461327,
-0.3389261365,
-0.2985828817,
0.2315720618,
-0.2830724418,
0.3799223602,
-0.2837745845,
-0.0948976576,
-0.2072435915,
-0.0938971266,
0.0554357208,
-0.0154004162,
-0.3845044971,
-0.5778889656,
-0.0213999823,
-0.2086008191,
-0.5465530753
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11622v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11622v1 | Building Knowledge-Guided Lexica to Model Cultural Variation | 2024-06-17T15:05:43 | 2024-06-17T15:05:43 | Shreya Havaldar, Salvatore Giorgi, Sunny Rai, Thomas Talhelm, Sharath Chandra Guntuku, Lyle Ungar | cs.CL | cs.CL | Cultural variation exists between nations (e.g., the United States vs.
China), but also within regions (e.g., California vs. Texas, Los Angeles vs.
San Francisco). Measuring this regional cultural variation can illuminate how
and why people think and behave differently. Historically, it has been
difficult to computationally model cultural variation due to a lack of training
data and scalability constraints. In this work, we introduce a new research
problem for the NLP community: How do we measure variation in cultural
constructs across regions using language? We then provide a scalable solution:
building knowledge-guided lexica to model cultural variation, encouraging
future work at the intersection of NLP and cultural understanding. We also
highlight modern LLMs' failure to measure cultural variation or generate
culturally varied language. | [
-0.5290727615,
-0.6963902116,
0.4662665725,
0.283741802,
-0.0567021035,
0.4442743957,
-0.2130133808,
-0.6687021852,
0.6827261448,
0.2856693268,
-0.6853265166,
-0.5094477534,
-0.7128884792,
0.0850993246,
-0.0696589202,
0.6975137591,
-0.0832709298,
0.1973866969,
-0.1344456375,
-0.5355117917,
-0.4304461181,
-0.5842838883,
-0.4848415554,
-0.4861632586,
0.4107507467,
0.5469167233,
0.8724506497,
0.5055055618,
0.544223547,
0.1674388796,
-0.6910871267,
0.4392473102,
-0.3123173714,
-0.1373784095,
-0.2882722616,
-0.8294936419,
-0.1124930307,
-0.1250565648,
0.515791893,
1.219191432,
-0.2471115589,
0.2348657846,
-0.2297909856,
0.6757031679,
-0.5332620144,
-0.1778289229,
-0.6523640752,
0.4985843003,
-0.2655873597,
-0.1439128965,
0.220318839,
-0.3672947288,
0.320487231,
-0.4526780248,
0.4173295498,
-0.0724616945,
0.767005682,
0.3498359621,
-0.662691772,
-0.3349908888,
-0.938369751,
0.8064115047,
-0.6327079535,
0.17515935,
0.5109701157,
0.0511843376,
-0.2257591337,
-0.6616256833,
-0.328561157,
-0.1198652685,
0.266623795,
0.0714335814,
0.1041165143,
-0.5540705323,
0.2966491878,
0.689399004,
-0.283149302,
0.1860470921,
-0.3706072271,
-0.2617121637,
0.5016325116,
0.4874236882,
0.7319620252,
0.0315895304,
-0.230660364,
-0.120792143,
-0.8023644686,
0.2851783037,
0.2832081616,
0.2327373922,
-0.1855944842,
0.3392435312,
-0.2094410658,
0.5047661662,
-0.3091098666,
-0.1954887509,
0.2511204183,
-0.2750840485,
0.0206522346,
-0.3867994845,
0.3348126411,
0.3872509897,
-0.1676039994,
-0.1463869661,
0.0508107208,
0.034040872,
-0.0044491789,
-0.4628253281,
-0.0973364413,
-0.1334943473,
-0.3190726936,
0.0199552588,
-0.1928211004,
-0.7573913932,
-0.7347914577,
-0.1832592636,
0.0053893747,
-0.2128526866,
-0.5489934683,
0.2705642581,
-0.3029416502,
0.5070902705,
0.0728203654,
-1.2434062958,
0.3377830088,
0.6044564843,
1.0326875448,
-0.3035453856,
-0.3745122254,
0.1913580149,
-0.1851352304,
-0.6959118843,
0.6603115797,
-0.4764043987,
-0.6480398178,
0.0944912806,
-0.1654468179,
0.3425998688,
-0.6509722471,
0.2673102319,
-0.3206793666,
0.1334589869,
-0.9277119637,
-0.5233339071,
-0.2880616188,
0.3837217391,
-0.7360158563,
0.965459764,
0.2726208866,
-0.9885653257,
0.7083719373,
-0.4128809273,
-0.2181522399,
0.2978512049,
-0.456666708,
-0.0956475884,
0.3327049315,
0.3290743232,
0.1305421442,
-0.578315258,
0.1851606816,
-0.306889236,
-0.3150741458,
0.1865262836,
-0.184164077,
1.1240452528,
0.3500430286,
-0.3024479151,
-0.2186949551,
-0.6598679423,
-0.1430937052,
0.206563741,
-0.4412517548,
-0.5105578899,
0.361115396,
-0.1295634508,
0.0927546769,
0.5847079754,
-0.43871665,
0.2809809148,
-0.4061141312,
0.3302800953,
0.2849150002,
-0.1192338839,
0.6128896475,
-0.5113947988,
0.8341537118,
-0.0143091744,
0.0505667701,
0.3271743059,
-0.6070272923,
-0.865188539,
0.1483993977,
0.1072503552,
0.4047067165,
-1.0248823166,
0.1253574491,
-0.1593161374,
-0.8277464509,
-0.4821017981,
0.0570977256,
-0.0688797235,
0.5113325715,
0.1603874415,
-0.6576468945,
-0.4720903933,
-0.7522735,
-0.0225947592,
-0.050895907,
-0.2080933303,
0.221717447,
0.3103806973,
-0.0888346657,
1.0244899988,
-0.6283718944,
-0.267503202,
-0.538738966,
0.1478253007,
0.146407634,
0.2744448185,
0.5472208858,
-0.6976571083,
-0.3920466602,
0.0992325172,
-0.5915253162,
-0.0374998748,
-0.0377405286,
-0.1458463222,
0.0643533915,
0.4523289204,
0.1998467594,
0.3938586116,
0.6863521934,
-0.4569303095,
0.4606513679,
-0.2056933641,
0.0647455901,
-1.4861898422,
-0.2296099514,
0.0137232114,
0.1689535826,
-0.6330059171,
0.2342025787,
0.081954293,
0.0569598787,
-0.4031140506,
0.3793188334,
-0.2969155908,
-0.1700681001,
-0.1351980716,
-0.0222142152,
-0.1940738857,
0.3540115058,
0.398093015,
0.7152606249,
0.6942277551,
-0.5797066689,
0.1650703251,
0.0692673028,
-0.7784475684,
0.5298544168,
-0.4156018198,
-0.0757991225,
-0.1076784506,
0.3377461731,
-0.4920485318,
-0.2427683324,
-0.2215434313,
-0.2394053638,
-0.1510774642,
-0.1252267063,
-0.509986937,
-0.2180238217,
-0.0178349186,
0.4690672755,
0.5150860548,
-0.4523319006,
0.5787927508,
0.460583359,
-0.0442729853,
-0.7590410709,
-0.9971576333,
0.1225001663,
-0.5632041097,
-0.7791929245,
0.3453815579,
-0.3226397336,
-0.4490942359,
-0.3286369145,
-0.140343532,
-0.2956480682,
0.4363930821,
-0.0026575341,
-0.0998444632,
-0.2954660952,
0.3182160258,
-0.0591967404,
0.3685187101,
0.2352694124,
-0.1905034184,
0.7286705971,
-0.2472814322,
-0.4764533937,
-0.077800259,
0.5282899141,
0.3319645822,
-0.3187445402,
0.861953795,
0.6351106167,
-0.3202746212,
-0.4102884829,
-0.542929709,
-0.0268193986,
-0.4615150988,
0.5206445456,
-0.1014425978,
-1.0686926842,
1.0446903706,
-0.2080753148,
0.1416306794,
0.3554381132,
0.8128684759,
-0.0292002037,
0.4882702231,
1.1386196613,
-0.0329170488,
0.4748420119,
-0.1304612011,
0.0764477402,
-0.5070682764,
-0.2283942401,
-0.5018037558,
-0.5936670303,
-0.970708549,
-0.5908865333,
0.4319579899,
-0.0608658642,
-0.2281534225,
0.0280384943,
-0.1902439594,
0.764419198,
0.740359664,
0.03775841,
0.3036925793,
0.0365056768,
-0.3422548473,
-0.300177902,
-0.8713448048,
-0.307290554,
1.098811388,
0.42483145,
0.7987293601,
0.4157290757,
0.8735541105,
0.1286719292,
0.1723140627,
-0.8323816657,
0.2409499884,
-0.3130770028,
-0.6043284535,
-0.3394068778,
-0.372240454,
-0.8206502795,
0.2574053705,
-0.2260849774,
-0.5667179227,
0.2524674535,
0.0134429364,
-0.1149709746,
0.672796905,
-0.470973134,
0.4399707913,
-0.0995692536,
0.0795888752,
0.0508811772,
-0.6816236377,
0.3132760823,
-0.0590732582,
0.3032053709,
-0.2265584469,
0.0685008988,
0.6334249973,
-0.3741629124,
1.0599625111,
0.1823508888,
-0.3786732256,
0.3357612193,
0.4223365486,
-0.0732533857,
0.1764139384,
-0.012479689,
0.2323224843,
0.0226483755,
-0.5503104925,
-0.4728815556,
0.5171834826,
-1.010425806,
-0.5204856396,
-0.1882996261,
-0.9896419644,
-0.3438563943,
-0.2921584547,
0.4521995485,
0.1831956208,
-0.260122925,
0.2715783417,
0.8089630604,
-0.3457303643,
0.5826419592,
0.6564708352,
0.0039881435,
-0.1755499393,
0.7125717998,
0.2915122509,
0.237100333,
0.3948538005,
0.4807013273,
-0.0031306273,
-0.3375775218,
-0.1369223893,
0.0787471384,
-0.9210053086,
0.219898507,
-0.2241389006,
-0.0437401496,
-0.2382997423,
-0.352891922,
-0.2942247093,
-0.328278631,
-0.2733818889,
-0.124016583,
0.2269578874,
0.9288105369,
-0.3595102131,
0.3713851273,
-0.5114537477,
-0.1679544002,
0.4590124488,
0.3161831498,
0.0734895691,
-0.6004830003,
-0.3044084311,
-0.0554460846,
-0.1675207317,
-1.0292134285,
0.5527175665,
-0.0742620304,
0.4532338083,
0.1718806624,
0.0426624008,
0.6868599653,
-0.2882649004,
1.1143064499,
0.0763466433,
-0.9016682506,
0.4765296578,
-0.1503221691,
0.6959002018,
0.403329134,
0.5624284744,
-1.0553135872,
-0.5503441095,
-0.588922739,
-0.9786109924,
0.3051050007,
-0.1098329872,
0.3532635868,
-0.1195897013,
0.1922952831,
0.0796062946,
-0.1525025517,
-0.9973601699,
-0.3752168119,
-0.001095862,
0.1005200073,
-0.0990676954,
-0.2394329011,
-0.4836304188,
-0.1283789873,
0.3293929994,
-0.0942941681,
-0.1498274952,
0.204924345,
-0.0792222321,
-0.0299187899,
0.1519140899,
0.6076617241,
0.8554120064,
0.1266645491,
0.1274564862,
0.5578788519,
-0.4367817044,
-0.0991608128,
-0.2459964454,
-0.1971003413,
-0.1155913696,
0.473449707,
0.670014143,
-0.2288701087,
-0.4854703546,
0.1653846502,
-0.2749835849,
-0.3471269011,
-0.4622350931,
0.0442969501,
0.4864186347,
0.3915109634,
0.3171960115,
-0.3127914369,
-0.0863276199,
-0.5184943676,
0.0382889397,
0.3330475688,
-0.2687599659,
0.0409771912,
0.4307081699,
0.1556397825,
-0.3286517859,
0.7061869502,
-0.2199157476,
-0.3873206675,
1.136947751,
0.571148634,
0.4934331477,
-0.0425547808,
0.3604273796,
0.1965163499,
0.51976794,
-0.1567728966,
0.513479054,
-0.1421603709,
-1.0177688599,
-0.4853999615,
-0.6361089945,
-0.7883614302,
0.0174277853,
-0.7351379395,
0.1997894943,
-0.3827175796,
-0.2130225599,
-0.3552393019,
0.0976848304,
-0.9083449244,
0.3000980616,
0.3089021146,
0.9135379195,
-1.2632493973,
0.6756794453,
0.7567355633,
-0.2776185274,
-0.993792057,
0.1967253238,
-0.0155864796,
-0.8036172986,
0.6018010378,
-0.1543454677,
-0.0856919438,
-0.3661415279,
-0.820980072,
-1.2348541021,
1.2015399933,
0.0492793247,
-0.2478627414,
0.2615348995,
0.301525712,
0.9296404123,
-0.3957664073,
-0.0374595821,
0.5973290205,
-0.0378222801,
0.2840459049,
-0.7326076627,
-0.2976571321,
0.0274476223,
0.2457806468,
0.0995824337,
-0.6294376254,
0.9702631235,
-0.1277955025,
-0.0843852162,
-0.2053328902,
0.8875439167,
0.229157567,
0.2173845321,
0.4601996541,
0.5694528222,
1.0379029512,
-0.1696884632,
0.819621563,
-0.2628649175,
0.3630014956,
1.2249382734,
-0.1018347666,
0.6030625105,
0.3479623795,
-0.3113226891,
0.6852124929,
0.9825487733,
-0.0899874717,
0.1117787585,
0.5800384879,
-0.4980400503,
-0.196493268,
-0.3436951637,
-0.4139207602,
0.8366946578,
0.7456975579,
-0.2692649066,
-0.1918301135,
-0.2983734012,
0.2450196892,
0.1198399439,
-0.3232282996,
0.5894966125,
-0.0968719125,
-0.5987930894,
0.581866622,
0.0549775101,
0.9516013861,
-0.7221330404,
0.2780164778,
-0.8816866279,
-0.5235410929,
-0.2230526358,
-0.6220381856,
0.4578890502,
-0.0571826175,
-0.2127532512,
-0.0132688442,
0.2181473672,
-0.4477077723,
-0.5333274603,
0.205274716,
0.882486701,
0.2317401022,
0.4093279243,
-0.3685726821,
-0.1899176985,
0.1820308417,
-0.1216253191,
0.4811380208,
0.6515568495,
-0.3058137298,
0.8426643014,
0.4445207715,
0.2286161482,
0.2449183464,
0.2700037062,
0.4200110137,
-0.5564460754,
-0.6332865357,
-0.6658867598,
0.1624132097,
-0.1008832827,
-0.6197037697,
0.415680021,
0.0388750955,
1.0120111704,
0.0619650707,
0.6021307111,
-0.447245419,
0.3103843033,
-0.3866717815,
0.6631703973,
-0.8752141595,
0.2962836325,
0.1034900621,
-0.809589684,
-0.4816085398,
0.4701000154,
-0.0653096139,
-0.100511305,
0.8788512349,
0.7459990978,
0.3128147125,
0.0003095778,
0.4837968349,
0.084402211,
0.3714640141,
0.4482810199,
0.6481149793,
0.3082865775,
0.4659626782,
-0.6623384356,
-0.2636784613,
0.2638941109,
-1.1268957853,
-0.5843477249,
-0.75010252,
-0.2211006731,
-0.2796187699,
-0.4631789923,
0.9395790696,
0.462230891,
-0.5374251008,
-0.5933964849,
0.0785005242,
0.2974425554,
-0.3849344254,
-0.2278446704,
0.2540934086,
-0.3994012475,
-0.9519017339,
0.3125378489,
0.0218117014,
0.2769549191,
-0.6751247048,
0.4207467139,
-0.0033352645,
0.1656011641,
0.4232029319,
0.4291689694,
-0.8041359186,
-0.1802786887,
-0.1585296094,
-0.0056400299,
0.0132282572,
0.9414369464,
-0.4961580932,
0.5229692459,
0.5877974629,
0.846128583,
0.2983908653,
-0.4053123295,
0.7889912128,
-1.0519970655,
0.0880163461,
0.1846161038,
0.5362962484,
0.5602199435,
-0.2479798496,
0.7400739193,
0.2431146652,
-0.686804533,
-0.201146856,
0.6879963875,
-0.8532302976,
-0.4158675671,
1.2104393244,
-0.1105558649,
0.092012845,
-0.168364048,
0.1275300235,
0.1193944067,
0.0093925605,
1.3036204576,
1.074493289,
-0.0803707391,
0.2316890061,
-0.6002708673,
0.5979205966,
0.6459999681,
-0.7605440021,
-0.2602843046,
0.4395526648,
0.5761094689,
0.2332871407,
0.5614758134,
0.0859462172,
0.0703902841,
0.0380057953,
0.2518805861,
0.4743531346,
-0.0506793186,
-0.2979224324,
0.1921511441,
0.0814104378,
0.1513566971
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11617v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11617v1 | DELLA-Merging: Reducing Interference in Model Merging through Magnitude-Based Sampling | 2024-06-17T15:02:45 | 2024-06-17T15:02:45 | Pala Tej Deep, Rishabh Bhardwaj, Soujanya Poria | cs.CL | cs.CL | With the proliferation of domain-specific models, model merging has emerged
as a set of techniques that combine the capabilities of multiple models into
one that can multitask without the cost of additional training. In this paper,
we propose a new model merging technique, Drop and rEscaLe via sampLing with
mAgnitude (DELLA-Merging), that employs a novel pruning technique, MAGPRUNE,
which shows significant advantages over DARE and TIES. MAGPRUNE first ranks the
parameters in order of their magnitude and assigns higher dropout probabilities
(p) to parameters with lower ranks corresponding to lower magnitudes. To
approximate the original embeddings, MAGPRUNE employs a rescaling operation on
the parameters that survive the random dropping by 1/(1 - p). On three
different expert models considered for merging (LM, Math, Code) and
corresponding benchmark datasets (AlpacaEval, GSM8K, MBPP), DELLA shows an
average improvement of 2.4 points over baseline methods employing delta
parameter pruning (an improvement of 3.6 points over TIES, 1.2 points over
DARE), and 11.1 points over the no-pruning baseline (TA). We release the source
code at: https://github.com/declare-lab/della. | [
-0.9630795121,
-0.4060118198,
0.1776594818,
-0.0622741766,
-0.100717023,
-0.2945750654,
-0.037167944,
-0.4046082497,
0.078352958,
0.4084367752,
-0.93583709,
-0.1776173711,
-0.338830471,
-0.0843434185,
-0.7211485505,
1.04738307,
0.2315305024,
0.1788438261,
-0.321359247,
0.1307233125,
-0.2390990704,
-0.5391916633,
-0.5553888083,
-0.0719948336,
0.6712419391,
0.3469360769,
0.5464803576,
0.2826986313,
1.0035282373,
0.2643079162,
-0.2956953347,
0.8441408277,
-0.6931126118,
-0.1291027963,
-0.1733248979,
-0.5384177566,
-0.7019144893,
0.5481805205,
0.7996413708,
0.7846125364,
-0.1501422375,
0.2640849948,
0.1495907903,
0.6597054601,
-0.9035989642,
-0.2677973211,
-0.3821133971,
0.2652057111,
0.0398077145,
-0.1656560451,
-0.6384502053,
-0.6272732019,
0.0413715579,
-0.3797610402,
0.591047287,
-0.1805393398,
1.0379480124,
0.5009694695,
-0.5854914188,
0.5485365391,
-0.9485993385,
1.0578912497,
-0.6815450788,
0.3615131378,
0.3648964465,
0.2466764301,
-0.1505248249,
-0.4313887954,
-0.3183635771,
0.0256944001,
0.0809364691,
-0.01297013,
0.0391827896,
-0.1625576168,
0.0124849835,
0.5493121147,
0.1069027334,
0.1064245552,
-0.8258682489,
-0.1535508484,
0.9551150799,
0.1362355798,
-0.1411423534,
0.0945945606,
-0.3468743861,
-0.1700077355,
-0.9047387242,
-0.1633164585,
0.4428253174,
0.3607962728,
0.1308691502,
0.6802967191,
-0.1650454849,
0.8478317261,
0.5091987252,
-0.1342082322,
0.3791984916,
-0.6188285351,
-0.2742248476,
-0.5687708259,
0.5987715721,
0.8586762547,
0.0434041843,
0.0978552327,
0.0795088187,
-0.6961807609,
0.4685601592,
-0.9535232186,
-0.5754887462,
0.1955349892,
-0.5410889983,
-0.6388322115,
0.1308073103,
-0.6265027523,
-0.3555538356,
-0.4182921648,
0.4739974439,
-0.312749356,
-0.3859660029,
-0.125905484,
-0.0567644201,
0.0309707634,
0.5201559067,
-0.4026063681,
0.0177453998,
0.7127119303,
0.7773208618,
-0.1160684377,
-0.3137332797,
-0.9016400576,
-0.1474091858,
-0.4425542355,
0.4973556101,
-0.251619786,
-1.0123543739,
-0.2646858096,
-0.0930681527,
-0.150325194,
-0.6253884435,
0.7266353369,
-0.4312445223,
0.3843495846,
-0.3633043468,
-0.5564491153,
-0.7122988701,
0.1140411347,
-0.8256984353,
0.8325179815,
0.0571158119,
-0.6445198655,
0.5733559728,
-0.1677874625,
-0.0337272026,
-0.1731696725,
-0.0187394544,
-0.7158865333,
0.390594691,
0.222284779,
0.4069679379,
-0.4689637423,
0.0409747139,
-0.3945504427,
-0.3262878358,
0.1376634091,
-0.4079350531,
0.5632026196,
0.2836088538,
0.225386709,
0.1390209794,
-0.628947556,
0.3556186557,
-0.3888301849,
-0.1287763119,
-0.0656313598,
-0.0707035884,
0.0508925542,
0.1585012227,
0.2209991962,
-0.1664678603,
0.5773358941,
-0.3206744492,
0.1843465716,
0.3101133108,
0.2382722497,
0.8852561116,
-0.8448214531,
0.3068770766,
0.0672430322,
0.5124278069,
0.2409664243,
-0.5286875963,
-0.6528226733,
-0.8445575237,
0.8859883547,
0.2742801011,
-0.4311704636,
0.7101191282,
-0.3688752353,
-0.8883917332,
-0.6539142728,
-0.2092466056,
0.2404973805,
0.5570976138,
0.3627336025,
-0.4352560639,
-0.156299904,
-1.150359869,
0.0598871149,
-0.0445906296,
-0.4575937092,
0.2889273763,
0.0842671543,
0.2876545489,
1.2951434851,
-0.7416271567,
-0.5808274746,
0.0061697089,
0.3704092205,
0.185038805,
0.7829388976,
0.6846615076,
-1.0103749037,
-0.3875670433,
-0.0661980808,
-0.3982078433,
-0.0936255902,
0.1150107309,
0.0624255873,
-0.1426211596,
-0.0326565057,
-0.6536717415,
0.678040266,
0.5118548274,
0.0362882838,
0.7790449858,
-0.1727545112,
0.8819410801,
-1.3987746239,
-0.0120504219,
0.0264293738,
0.1141660511,
-0.9473116994,
0.2351307571,
0.3788062036,
-0.0942306146,
-0.7806124091,
0.2078127414,
-0.5561485887,
0.0830334499,
-0.2259650677,
-0.2652179003,
0.1871316284,
0.2662660778,
-0.0835036933,
0.8138788342,
0.3227445483,
-0.6076762676,
0.131258294,
0.2144187987,
-0.0711835697,
0.3977263868,
-0.3041446507,
-0.0626979545,
0.0687592775,
0.1406001151,
-0.7182314992,
-0.0579995327,
0.116723083,
-0.5110659599,
0.2111324072,
-0.5267130136,
-0.3700356781,
-0.2048199624,
-0.6886425018,
0.4589818418,
0.5830569267,
-0.4381426573,
0.8403764367,
0.2724338472,
-0.1038763449,
-0.4930808246,
-0.6329007745,
-0.3333339691,
-0.5253163576,
-0.7552120686,
0.5733655095,
-0.1621762961,
-0.030748466,
0.0730058104,
-0.1683612317,
-0.632217288,
-0.2005486488,
0.2455365956,
0.7523325682,
0.324277252,
0.3990795314,
0.2539308071,
-0.001771395,
-0.2223933786,
0.107355535,
0.3644770682,
0.290384233,
-0.3769363463,
-0.8439545631,
0.2743956149,
0.9161248803,
-0.3736815453,
0.9695520997,
0.619776845,
-0.1015853211,
-0.1335191727,
-0.7715178132,
-0.6658491492,
-0.4081420004,
0.2938901186,
-0.6727679372,
-0.630926609,
0.669480741,
-0.4122965336,
0.5875811577,
0.2939099669,
0.2415486276,
0.1606741697,
0.8924770951,
0.9489766359,
-0.1825005561,
0.4392187297,
-0.5464645624,
0.6563534737,
-0.8629395962,
-0.288903296,
-0.6098700762,
-0.5728749633,
-0.2084483951,
-0.9043357968,
0.2733095586,
0.2954612374,
0.175163433,
0.3063752651,
-0.7795732021,
0.4152227044,
0.5157395601,
0.1043216959,
0.3867110312,
0.3166172802,
0.1814590245,
-0.338647604,
-0.7625735402,
0.172906965,
1.1010454893,
0.0924492404,
0.5390495658,
-0.0985993296,
1.0014110804,
-0.0432442427,
0.3309318423,
-1.0483791828,
0.717099309,
-0.0992449895,
-0.4153093398,
-0.2404618412,
-0.7910935879,
-0.4737304151,
0.6372014284,
-0.5991185308,
-0.365514487,
0.7059027553,
0.1202571094,
-0.6974388957,
0.4436213672,
-0.7859102488,
0.1988020539,
0.5460980535,
-0.2591528296,
-0.4586952329,
-0.1064422205,
0.5700370073,
-0.5397165418,
0.2929136455,
-0.3723501563,
-0.2608069777,
0.5257077813,
-0.773480773,
0.5602225661,
0.0801360086,
-0.1879051924,
0.203741774,
0.3947557807,
0.6078573465,
-0.1791294813,
-0.2113898396,
0.3716975451,
-0.1414090842,
0.0050047655,
-0.7775580287,
0.8132363558,
-0.58175385,
-0.4037281573,
0.0461041182,
-1.013201952,
-0.1510656178,
-0.1553730518,
0.3894344568,
0.6981453896,
0.2619485557,
0.3308882117,
0.1854032576,
0.3790540993,
0.1402597725,
0.6185119748,
-0.3982129097,
-0.6703985333,
0.6983444691,
0.4152899384,
0.216980502,
-0.0151862148,
-0.0608185269,
-0.2500093579,
-0.5412015915,
0.0906446278,
0.3271577954,
-0.2983237505,
-0.5302119851,
-0.3323269188,
-0.4825927615,
-0.2013378441,
-0.234306857,
-0.4967515469,
-0.6025027633,
-0.1597260088,
0.157760039,
0.4884086847,
0.2863512635,
-0.4415948391,
0.2867775261,
-1.3419049978,
-0.1680138409,
0.1312189102,
-0.1609291881,
-0.0174319521,
-0.7239687443,
-0.1739032865,
0.0993237793,
-0.0906265676,
-0.9824552536,
0.7517651916,
0.1794174165,
0.3820619881,
0.3777704239,
0.4150136709,
0.9655814171,
-0.2720276117,
0.5863256454,
0.5374167562,
-0.7319267988,
0.4284986854,
-0.2456689775,
0.0091169141,
0.6594100595,
0.5367432237,
-0.1374447048,
-0.532289803,
-0.608851552,
-0.8639596105,
0.6542981267,
0.4055474699,
-0.373385191,
0.136152029,
0.3532039225,
-0.276491046,
0.2775338888,
-0.0234240275,
-0.1808452308,
0.6256518364,
-0.1512816101,
0.0200692341,
-0.116024211,
-0.6500858665,
-0.6035972834,
0.4299114347,
0.1446748078,
-0.1906565577,
0.0822019652,
0.1033982188,
0.0479734279,
-0.1347411275,
0.2207881212,
0.6432616115,
-0.0507248119,
-0.173305735,
0.3284110129,
-0.4948375225,
-0.0015751309,
-0.0074758925,
-0.4826100171,
-0.0230930764,
-0.0088439221,
0.1412348449,
0.4967814982,
-0.2104740888,
0.2913696468,
-0.0634605438,
-0.8366670609,
0.1935442388,
0.1229454949,
-0.1008506268,
0.3099615276,
0.4960605502,
0.5808581114,
0.3824027777,
0.0318909436,
0.3468058705,
0.2844923437,
-0.1447747797,
-0.1609359831,
0.4165306687,
0.5939122438,
-0.1656394005,
1.0643098354,
-0.0859661624,
-0.206465587,
0.737899065,
-0.0795253515,
0.7720533013,
-0.2651762068,
0.0845647454,
0.6799026728,
-0.0318859741,
-0.2109593302,
-0.043785166,
-0.1679569185,
-0.7035204768,
-0.8987161517,
-0.3472953141,
-0.3918727338,
0.0245461296,
-1.022887826,
0.3074377775,
-0.2144354582,
-0.7926861048,
-0.103324078,
0.3607958853,
-0.3179742396,
-0.1191363633,
-0.3641325831,
0.9000065327,
-0.8480088711,
0.7920303345,
0.517472446,
-0.3611873388,
-1.0508041382,
0.0458954275,
0.4372445941,
0.0360039957,
0.7417253256,
0.1881719679,
-0.0547274612,
0.2742236555,
-0.2370243967,
-0.8779805303,
1.0947737694,
0.1882490814,
-0.6396700144,
0.1321213841,
-0.6009064317,
-0.0413834043,
-0.257027626,
0.0396695361,
0.7144704461,
0.3679663837,
0.6750961542,
-1.2930628061,
-0.2426173836,
-0.188218981,
-0.2257637829,
0.8264729381,
-0.4871369004,
1.1159328222,
-0.437851131,
-0.3551032245,
0.3534107506,
0.6217566133,
0.3502168357,
0.0011918496,
0.5396163464,
0.8747153282,
0.9085233212,
-0.1638816148,
0.5144923925,
-0.7125717402,
0.8742822409,
1.0993452072,
-0.2714733183,
1.0857101679,
0.3886680007,
-0.3963983953,
-0.1768024117,
0.5563666821,
-0.3984661698,
0.4291257262,
-0.2964690328,
-0.5607796907,
-0.4246338308,
-0.0402699001,
-0.5176196694,
0.1160253957,
-0.063782081,
0.0239047371,
-0.3864264786,
-0.1276208013,
0.0115362993,
-0.1426497847,
-0.2915094197,
0.587844491,
-0.1471620351,
-0.5514931679,
0.4976903498,
-0.2700596154,
0.7982409596,
-0.3557483852,
-0.0440437831,
-0.2098687738,
0.2643381953,
-0.4099158645,
-0.5921828747,
0.4172146916,
-0.3428702354,
-0.4099894166,
0.0621552356,
0.5571019053,
-0.6181969047,
-0.520355463,
0.010252703,
0.5832054019,
0.3430821896,
-0.2166769952,
-0.4544758201,
0.1504632831,
0.1085992455,
-0.0026941448,
0.3348528445,
-0.0041162688,
0.1211399883,
0.794274807,
0.8680968285,
0.330842495,
-0.0225759558,
0.338765204,
1.0418182611,
-0.250849396,
-0.204216525,
-0.5035393238,
0.4858572483,
-0.4227059186,
-0.0483358316,
0.826558888,
0.5879305005,
0.4918881655,
-0.1845280379,
0.1784945726,
-0.104119584,
0.4630064368,
-0.1728953868,
0.901024878,
-0.7810126543,
0.126514405,
0.3444165885,
-1.0441024303,
-0.2736727297,
0.4658430815,
-0.5087964535,
0.0745346472,
0.4556442797,
1.0868279934,
0.1662087142,
-0.4000433683,
0.4986818433,
-0.2287662327,
0.3118350804,
0.412907213,
0.4025141895,
-0.325855583,
0.5308554769,
-0.4937854111,
-0.2751893699,
-0.3850484788,
-0.4964804947,
-0.7033424973,
-0.6011024714,
-0.4418691695,
0.0522054769,
-0.2813037336,
0.6194602251,
1.222115159,
-0.2586645186,
0.0992947891,
0.1430007666,
-0.017472947,
-0.42283687,
-0.2529436946,
0.3382708728,
-0.4460973144,
-1.2954862118,
0.348222822,
0.1858905256,
0.0580380596,
-0.1911391616,
0.1577200741,
0.0061086612,
0.1725135148,
0.4017707705,
0.0552499183,
-0.5181910992,
0.0212814044,
-0.2287870795,
0.174278453,
-0.2432139963,
0.7234566808,
-0.7719302177,
0.3044978976,
0.9188867807,
0.2968287468,
0.2754475474,
0.433280319,
0.8550832272,
-0.7653846145,
0.4060780704,
0.0991714746,
0.0617554747,
0.1164373979,
-0.3314411044,
0.7375979424,
0.1339229345,
-0.5214680433,
-1.112765193,
0.2656137347,
-0.8412168026,
-0.1950988024,
0.68003124,
-0.139284417,
-0.1697687805,
0.2900972068,
-0.195876807,
0.0933194235,
-0.1905604154,
0.8826776743,
0.606482029,
0.067672953,
-0.2814638615,
-0.2794103324,
0.5637916327,
0.4929010272,
-0.4882481098,
-0.0293827653,
0.662597239,
0.2710666955,
0.3845113814,
0.2026458234,
-0.3577896655,
0.6285104752,
0.0573872738,
0.4268734753,
-0.4292145967,
-0.6337646246,
-0.4171606004,
0.4807310998,
-0.0743067265,
-0.441541791
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11614v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11614v1 | Intrinsic Evaluation of Unlearning Using Parametric Knowledge Traces | 2024-06-17T15:00:35 | 2024-06-17T15:00:35 | Yihuai Hong, Lei Yu, Shauli Ravfogel, Haiqin Yang, Mor Geva | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The task of "unlearning" certain concepts in large language models (LLMs) has
attracted immense attention recently, due to its importance for mitigating
undesirable model behaviours, such as the generation of harmful, private, or
incorrect information. Current protocols to evaluate unlearning methods largely
rely on behavioral tests, without monitoring the presence of unlearned
knowledge within the model's parameters. This residual knowledge can be
adversarially exploited to recover the erased information post-unlearning. We
argue that unlearning should also be evaluated internally, by considering
changes in the parametric knowledge traces of the unlearned concepts. To this
end, we propose a general methodology for eliciting directions in the parameter
space (termed "concept vectors") that encode concrete concepts, and construct
ConceptVectors, a benchmark dataset containing hundreds of common concepts and
their parametric knowledge traces within two open-source LLMs. Evaluation on
ConceptVectors shows that existing unlearning methods minimally impact concept
vectors, while directly ablating these vectors demonstrably removes the
associated knowledge from the LLMs and significantly reduces their
susceptibility to adversarial manipulation. Our results highlight limitations
in behavioral-based unlearning evaluations and call for future work to include
parametric-based evaluations. To support this, we release our code and
benchmark at https://github.com/yihuaihong/ConceptVectors. | [
-0.0910927802,
-0.690094769,
0.5067806244,
-0.1336738318,
-0.375623703,
0.3568072319,
-0.4437276125,
0.0555107109,
-0.3416559994,
0.4486307204,
-0.3696798384,
-0.6842948198,
-0.4281766415,
-0.4415553212,
-0.7768285275,
0.9671630859,
-0.071594663,
0.0530712828,
-0.6884361506,
-0.1784865558,
-0.2414214313,
-0.358418256,
-0.4960588813,
-0.4980441332,
0.3720666766,
0.2739828825,
0.2220417708,
0.3536734581,
0.3206292987,
0.3580444455,
-0.305036515,
0.2346156836,
-0.7596315145,
0.1827960014,
-0.2381828278,
-0.3718616664,
0.049278684,
0.0880552754,
0.80433321,
0.91255337,
-0.3909673393,
0.4059995115,
0.4871469736,
0.7617099285,
-0.7826120257,
0.233696267,
-0.6642966866,
-0.0792222619,
-0.0600867309,
-0.417129904,
-0.3305548728,
-0.4307015538,
0.0958912447,
-0.493263483,
0.196405232,
-0.2698685825,
0.6721304059,
0.197153151,
-0.2163445652,
-0.3902415037,
-0.9845584631,
0.785340786,
-0.3892083168,
0.601373136,
0.4185013473,
0.2202498466,
-0.310403049,
-0.7811208963,
-0.3064424098,
-0.2815590799,
0.1669332385,
0.1712083369,
-0.4125114679,
-0.1275727004,
0.0879544318,
0.1538214833,
-0.3122135699,
0.0963656381,
-0.7322284579,
-0.1562772244,
0.3589137495,
0.1246100739,
0.1069372222,
-0.0373408832,
-0.4419588745,
-0.0798488781,
-0.9506075978,
0.2262069285,
0.5561735034,
0.0940056294,
-0.0184264444,
0.6279174685,
-0.2951345146,
0.4590917528,
-0.0661315024,
-0.0184769519,
0.3249956071,
-0.1140457541,
0.0440516621,
-0.1701805741,
0.7263996005,
0.2277052999,
0.1674954444,
-0.7130557299,
-0.1599507034,
0.1726621985,
0.3811752498,
-0.6109244227,
-0.2515332699,
0.1001530513,
-0.4343868196,
-0.2654110789,
0.1257208139,
-0.789511621,
-0.5247950554,
-0.4066975713,
0.4414006174,
-0.7493959069,
-0.0467874631,
-0.0057162484,
-0.2898333967,
0.3477635682,
0.327398926,
-0.3239557147,
0.1153733656,
0.7854733467,
0.7207018733,
-0.1809257865,
-0.3249798119,
-0.3829700649,
0.1024903506,
-0.4605019987,
0.7079741955,
-0.7160155773,
-0.5610784292,
0.0194959342,
-0.2889364958,
0.1848466247,
-0.6583144665,
0.5340675712,
-0.4647852182,
-0.0345634893,
-0.4899777174,
-0.8090279102,
-0.2919202745,
0.020428285,
-0.156891942,
1.0153876543,
0.1107850894,
-0.6738584638,
0.3065529466,
-0.2668532729,
-0.2377824485,
0.2374344319,
-0.4309335947,
-0.3006192446,
0.2510787249,
-0.1834058166,
0.4473426342,
-0.4966136813,
0.3056395948,
-0.4862538278,
-0.4144997895,
0.3918797672,
-0.4721128643,
0.91965729,
0.0293854699,
-0.2764770687,
0.1093902588,
-0.9768257141,
-0.0946823359,
0.0918417722,
-0.2763725221,
-0.7080008984,
0.2645257115,
-0.5479406118,
0.2096868306,
0.2199117988,
-0.7145504355,
-0.1364113241,
-0.1380446255,
0.3547241986,
1.0526763201,
0.291145891,
0.4009352922,
-0.2651436329,
0.4261623323,
0.0198151227,
0.0979130939,
0.1593660116,
-0.2741403282,
-0.9230104089,
-0.1353754401,
0.0285815783,
-0.0205870438,
-0.8544976711,
0.339541316,
-0.1529548764,
-0.7315760255,
-0.3961622417,
0.4975437522,
0.8051028252,
0.7776970863,
0.292778641,
-0.0052844821,
-0.3511157036,
-0.6430129409,
-0.2140627801,
-0.4627968967,
-0.1652324796,
-0.1283358634,
0.5535166264,
-0.0781798884,
0.7669386864,
-0.4932520092,
-0.1189454794,
-0.0657877922,
0.3350641131,
-0.2796939015,
0.2928610146,
0.1699811071,
-0.4145832062,
0.0780313611,
-0.0865199268,
-0.9554696679,
0.1178677231,
0.0754507333,
-0.165598914,
-0.1031885818,
0.7886993289,
-0.582883358,
0.4080823362,
0.1710949838,
-0.2426692396,
0.545331955,
-0.3479225934,
-0.149437502,
-0.5347078443,
0.1784661263,
-0.0035182245,
0.130196169,
-0.4870252311,
0.3057560325,
0.1914869845,
0.0812884942,
-0.6712015271,
0.4513532221,
-0.4822161794,
-0.0690413639,
-0.0750819147,
0.1950630695,
-0.0469826832,
0.6399000287,
-0.1320723146,
0.5429499149,
0.4769325852,
-0.8980808854,
0.4286326468,
0.2497661114,
-0.5312212706,
0.5266498923,
-0.4909968972,
0.2415681481,
-0.3571098149,
-0.0383147784,
-0.9958060384,
0.3584016263,
0.2668375671,
-0.5494799018,
0.2219276726,
-0.1090256721,
-0.3634368181,
-0.2174948007,
-0.5658399463,
0.1090414152,
0.7674905658,
-0.6285824776,
0.3732053936,
0.3949908018,
0.1233615428,
-0.4480984211,
-0.2961899936,
-0.2134674042,
-0.4700980783,
-0.1722823679,
0.1509125084,
-0.0446231551,
-0.2335985303,
0.1944301426,
-0.3885118961,
0.0837539732,
0.12133912,
0.4091778398,
0.1796584427,
0.0703151599,
0.2292337418,
-0.0766351372,
-0.0617457815,
0.541605413,
-0.4034909904,
0.4873305559,
-0.1236197874,
-0.5835499167,
-0.0171971414,
-0.1960429549,
0.455714345,
-0.4190225601,
0.6391400099,
0.6428492069,
-0.5314574838,
-0.4667782187,
-0.3134450316,
0.025074875,
-0.501624465,
0.4698577821,
-0.0751944259,
-0.6992321014,
0.568102181,
-0.2396778315,
0.0057694674,
0.2379330993,
0.5618017912,
-0.2303749025,
0.7154178619,
0.4414767027,
0.0287033692,
0.1867416054,
-0.5443845987,
0.1499267071,
-1.1391823292,
-0.6963837743,
-0.5414239168,
-0.0946651697,
-0.4814935625,
-0.5242735147,
0.3514919579,
0.2478495985,
-0.3387742043,
0.0748200119,
-0.0865157992,
0.3963249624,
0.5877394676,
0.4017386138,
0.3243969381,
-0.0005417314,
-0.4125577509,
0.1257215291,
-0.4408958852,
-0.4125004113,
1.5591192245,
0.2974846363,
0.8078409433,
0.0518413745,
0.6039566994,
0.0941440091,
0.2802169025,
-0.6899747849,
0.6775199771,
-0.206876725,
-0.1225295216,
-0.4219328165,
-0.6230658293,
-0.762408793,
0.1946669817,
0.0311562996,
-0.8619673848,
0.1253574491,
0.0318432599,
-0.320207119,
0.4621948302,
-0.3492055833,
0.6012568474,
-0.2482341677,
-0.4949847758,
-0.3446714282,
-0.2236492336,
0.5328143835,
-0.4399394095,
-0.0494636856,
-0.0483054295,
0.0719669387,
0.9849514365,
-0.4316575825,
0.9414317608,
-0.3861542344,
-0.2580884993,
0.42514503,
0.1496184468,
0.3908372521,
0.0593599603,
0.1249000579,
0.1470367014,
-0.1521250755,
-0.1917959601,
-0.8154073358,
0.6875306368,
-0.7744386196,
-0.5266561508,
-0.1664472222,
-0.3302473128,
-0.4784235954,
0.0954295397,
0.2408850491,
0.4321087301,
-0.4451179206,
0.3665541112,
0.7828171253,
-0.4552089572,
0.3833727837,
0.8702835441,
-0.1337083578,
-0.0088120271,
1.3134388924,
-0.0293502565,
0.0584160835,
0.4403239191,
0.40021047,
-0.5292267203,
-0.740437746,
-0.0954240933,
0.1691204607,
-0.8644739985,
-0.2343553752,
-0.3350642323,
-0.2308772355,
-0.1046176553,
0.110061042,
-0.4628967941,
-0.1984242797,
-0.1616863757,
-0.2180688083,
0.2317260355,
0.8165379763,
-0.0963821784,
0.1026849896,
-0.5527965426,
0.3651977479,
0.3801788092,
0.3114270866,
0.2361483574,
-0.811075747,
-0.2682024539,
0.176018849,
-0.3477530181,
-0.6110362411,
0.3115442395,
0.0377473049,
0.7981779575,
0.7110557556,
0.1755584031,
0.7499860525,
-0.4335824847,
0.3982324004,
0.1213625818,
-0.9813659191,
0.3987602592,
-0.3884148896,
0.0630826131,
0.4322900772,
0.3611709774,
-0.5248049498,
-0.6654818654,
-0.6130361557,
-0.835232079,
0.5992664695,
0.1045195311,
-0.0325112268,
0.0397969522,
0.4693666101,
0.0508258045,
0.4507019818,
-0.1400612742,
-0.3213802278,
-0.0564049892,
-0.0604743585,
-0.3561300337,
-0.2532590926,
-0.1720473319,
-0.409593761,
0.4757692814,
0.1614765078,
0.2542918324,
-0.2111000419,
-0.3273994029,
-0.1325013936,
0.0948173478,
0.3327804506,
0.9506819844,
-0.3307553828,
0.1846847236,
0.1018756106,
-0.3337209821,
0.3343153894,
-0.0784580782,
-0.48379004,
-0.1772984266,
0.4130529165,
0.5924827456,
0.4562406242,
-0.7011401653,
0.5177794099,
-0.0486225151,
-0.0389104337,
-0.4054492414,
-0.0918837935,
0.1858013868,
0.0788611099,
0.1950302124,
-0.0815736502,
0.1039537787,
-0.5127533674,
0.4803513587,
0.5705233216,
-0.4818719923,
-0.6066723466,
0.4921400249,
0.1813091189,
0.0607105084,
0.6378458738,
-0.2854010761,
-0.3864317834,
0.4889668524,
0.3905480504,
0.977635622,
-0.3719747663,
0.6247936487,
0.0057050604,
0.3411102295,
0.0612304658,
0.0045982399,
-0.10069713,
-0.7667877078,
-0.2173910141,
-0.7320644855,
-0.3379395902,
0.5037767291,
-0.9343505502,
0.1323106885,
-0.5806221366,
0.3881969154,
-0.0306594092,
-0.1814629287,
-0.7117204666,
0.0370223112,
0.0198297203,
0.6541659236,
-0.8673913479,
0.8060234785,
0.8448160291,
-0.4562889636,
-0.5195304751,
0.2339791209,
0.1903404295,
-1.0608431101,
0.8705722094,
-0.1598375887,
-0.2194251269,
-0.1774181426,
-0.2048724443,
-0.8088303804,
0.8633593321,
0.5120875239,
-0.4211903512,
0.0276043024,
0.2482454777,
0.6220191121,
0.1667772084,
0.2467149049,
0.6406928301,
0.1674460471,
0.1061513796,
-0.2169099003,
0.1255535632,
-0.1769917458,
-0.0501695015,
0.2672139406,
-0.5467369556,
0.8309535384,
-0.0441076383,
-0.3286861777,
-0.1144762486,
0.6398915648,
0.0513751693,
0.021235317,
0.3308168948,
0.6179075837,
0.8299841285,
0.1091869175,
0.7173964381,
-0.3329494298,
0.262689352,
1.0623133183,
-0.0983555913,
0.8465704918,
0.3905493617,
-0.2686425745,
0.2666942179,
0.3163990378,
0.1810847819,
0.6291083694,
0.4163645804,
-0.2292021215,
-0.0926354453,
0.0332220681,
-0.1303758621,
0.7098549604,
0.4750470519,
-0.0147854574,
-0.5415094495,
-0.078000471,
0.0383791998,
0.1191230938,
-0.2942897677,
0.6980155706,
0.0797242746,
-0.5134668946,
0.7429305911,
0.1273335814,
0.3433333933,
-0.7051152587,
-0.0508000553,
-0.4623701572,
0.407997191,
-0.0425019898,
-0.6109772325,
0.2314082086,
0.1932460517,
0.240242213,
-0.2081604898,
0.592305243,
-0.545231998,
-0.4817279279,
0.5856819749,
0.5721777678,
-0.047416646,
-0.1255479753,
-0.6476391554,
-0.1250870675,
0.110917367,
-0.1925067306,
0.5721330643,
0.4970834851,
-0.0445506759,
0.8809581995,
0.667663753,
0.2061560005,
-0.0519963242,
0.1273437887,
1.1397402287,
-0.5482153296,
-0.2795213759,
-0.9093716741,
0.3527631462,
0.2586821616,
-0.3923644423,
1.0410943031,
0.5255908966,
1.0799164772,
0.2255785912,
0.8460206985,
0.3044924736,
0.5892674327,
-0.6410865784,
0.6883483529,
-0.4618308544,
0.5337705016,
-0.3891117573,
-0.8378999233,
0.1462023407,
0.3253083527,
-0.1723799556,
-0.0679315478,
0.7191623449,
0.5052053928,
-0.041656442,
-0.1450807154,
0.417596668,
0.1507447213,
0.2270738184,
0.341532141,
1.2591539621,
-0.0642671883,
0.6369903088,
-0.5800235271,
-0.2727510035,
0.1977731735,
-0.6428348422,
-1.0159198046,
-0.7772060633,
-0.4089935422,
-0.2828044891,
0.378411144,
0.4265068471,
0.1206914261,
-0.6771622896,
-0.389198035,
-0.283710748,
0.108613342,
-0.1433908045,
-0.1799498647,
0.5552446246,
-0.4031526446,
-0.4061362743,
0.543977499,
0.2301773131,
-0.1195038408,
-0.5757912397,
-0.2243144512,
-0.0273362659,
-0.1338858455,
0.5491800904,
0.3995550871,
-0.6181588769,
-0.266710937,
-0.1696080714,
0.2986394167,
-0.2357321382,
0.8730301857,
-0.8425731063,
0.319596678,
0.439747721,
0.612303555,
0.3581734896,
0.0792913064,
0.5305764675,
-1.030287981,
0.1524441391,
-0.0121641066,
0.4190073311,
0.2771565318,
-0.1206554621,
0.2873140275,
0.2775012553,
-0.1163739711,
-1.0283230543,
0.0245253351,
-0.3611737192,
-0.4718815684,
1.3094259501,
-0.4476457536,
-0.2117567062,
-0.0540975146,
0.3085164726,
0.4330474138,
-0.2623171508,
0.708466053,
0.5175911188,
0.0547326729,
0.0799320936,
-0.4050633311,
0.4979072809,
0.3002608418,
-0.6503812671,
0.3189727068,
0.3250111043,
0.3950535655,
-0.0640964881,
0.3507967293,
-0.2783282995,
0.0057259635,
-0.1765221655,
0.1860681921,
-0.1653700918,
-0.481823802,
-0.6062543392,
-0.0919315144,
0.0668188408,
-0.4972781539
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11598v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11598v1 | Understanding "Democratization" in NLP and ML Research | 2024-06-17T14:47:06 | 2024-06-17T14:47:06 | Arjun Subramonian, Vagrant Gautam, Dietrich Klakow, Zeerak Talat | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY | Recent improvements in natural language processing (NLP) and machine learning
(ML) and increased mainstream adoption have led to researchers frequently
discussing the "democratization" of artificial intelligence. In this paper, we
seek to clarify how democratization is understood in NLP and ML publications,
through large-scale mixed-methods analyses of papers using the keyword
"democra*" published in NLP and adjacent venues. We find that democratization
is most frequently used to convey (ease of) access to or use of technologies,
without meaningfully engaging with theories of democratization, while research
using other invocations of "democra*" tends to be grounded in theories of
deliberation and debate. Based on our findings, we call for researchers to
enrich their use of the term democratization with appropriate theory, towards
democratic technologies beyond superficial access. | [
-0.4600512683,
-0.850840807,
0.2872650027,
-0.0227151141,
-0.3595323861,
0.1407749802,
-0.5067493916,
-0.42389974,
0.3874883354,
0.4515589178,
-0.1927797645,
-0.2246664762,
-0.5927467942,
0.2449893355,
-0.3193496764,
1.0363175869,
0.0223093163,
0.2415689379,
-0.1687109321,
0.0130183958,
0.0463545956,
-0.8255994916,
0.005195498,
-0.5700824857,
0.7828285694,
-0.0446483083,
0.9396719337,
0.5843589306,
0.882820189,
0.3448952436,
-0.2820373178,
0.0820439085,
-0.0674605742,
0.0923343152,
0.0527788736,
-0.9105741382,
-0.2160720825,
0.4159992039,
0.600803256,
0.7167190909,
-0.1248535216,
0.268038094,
0.0515251532,
1.0937663317,
-0.9566696882,
0.1993772089,
-0.625459969,
0.1780305952,
-0.1511904746,
-0.3125953376,
-0.4293828607,
-0.5190151334,
-0.0826754421,
-0.5510433912,
0.2817652822,
-0.469142586,
0.6264462471,
0.1124236509,
-0.385196507,
-0.4761993289,
-1.1168069839,
0.5981081128,
-0.5037631989,
0.3188241124,
0.5081146359,
0.3521532416,
-0.06386365,
-0.8904494643,
-0.9301738143,
-0.1360974908,
0.0938929468,
0.0297574867,
-0.337249428,
0.2240653485,
0.2656572759,
0.0173190273,
-0.2705856264,
-0.0951260105,
-0.7442091107,
-0.195852384,
0.5157381892,
-0.2223344147,
0.2526939809,
-0.2600435913,
-0.2958571315,
0.0222243425,
-0.3851806819,
0.2092598081,
0.5821591616,
0.6332162023,
0.0990974233,
0.9814102054,
0.0045836228,
0.8699875474,
-0.2879565954,
0.1897037476,
0.2787032127,
-0.8840999603,
-0.5205947161,
-0.1171786413,
0.5202078819,
0.1023942903,
0.2386158407,
-0.2663179934,
-0.0481703244,
0.2638728321,
0.6505493522,
-0.6420152187,
-0.0781015232,
0.3463124931,
-0.8268851638,
-0.0495560467,
0.5038971305,
-0.5337795019,
-0.6070873141,
-0.7219807506,
0.0256385654,
0.0026005283,
-0.3704783916,
0.2334806323,
-0.4720064402,
0.0811433867,
0.4059237838,
-0.596765995,
0.1840347648,
1.2099661827,
0.9228855371,
-0.0271050241,
0.0562369227,
-0.0685894489,
-0.205553934,
-0.4687411487,
0.7669456005,
-0.6755639911,
-0.3272258639,
0.3523840606,
-0.2064227462,
-0.2872138917,
-0.6920832992,
0.3555942774,
-0.765907228,
0.4780686498,
-0.2277819663,
-0.3019162118,
-0.6488534212,
0.3225246668,
-0.6961452365,
0.5616376996,
-0.2236500829,
-1.03000772,
0.7698438764,
-0.7051280737,
-0.1473124772,
-0.1607539654,
-0.0341388471,
-0.0817789435,
0.3020322919,
-0.2516355515,
0.3965318203,
0.2376108468,
0.5243068933,
-0.256149143,
-0.2741814554,
0.444619447,
-0.0884907395,
1.1240413189,
0.1741111875,
-0.2914706767,
0.3842898011,
-0.5807449818,
-0.181314528,
-0.2707862556,
-0.1526066512,
-0.484675169,
0.2482885122,
0.0969882682,
0.2245820612,
0.3278626502,
-0.5420219302,
0.282302618,
-0.5014784336,
0.4918486774,
0.7163033485,
-0.3328647017,
1.0276917219,
-0.3545733988,
0.5031634569,
-0.0629187375,
0.3542891145,
0.1557150632,
-0.6181221604,
-0.7061181068,
-0.4145863056,
0.4800598919,
0.5996431112,
-0.4596480429,
0.5502363443,
0.0133998943,
-0.508633256,
-0.6613037586,
-0.0774097219,
-0.5294987559,
0.0951398611,
0.3158639967,
-0.1540526897,
-0.7309003472,
-1.1036683321,
-0.3525670469,
-0.4611999393,
0.1114746854,
0.2675354183,
0.711817205,
-0.4949381053,
1.0875432491,
0.2490070164,
-0.3798566163,
-0.1705643386,
0.2390083224,
0.2312686443,
0.1141795665,
-0.1067818701,
-1.0685987473,
-0.002905994,
0.224142462,
-0.6210571527,
0.251478821,
-0.3743900955,
0.2054318637,
0.0382047109,
0.2430592626,
-0.4827126265,
0.5047081113,
0.4362786412,
-0.2608400583,
0.3688007593,
-0.188025564,
0.2649351656,
-1.0162022114,
0.189126417,
0.0633699223,
-0.1167295948,
-0.7338043451,
0.2921892703,
-0.2155500501,
-0.0009999953,
-0.2789750099,
0.2669124305,
-0.3573924303,
0.0925904885,
-0.6416438222,
0.5030179024,
-0.287633419,
-0.305344671,
-0.0615529902,
0.8100589514,
0.138790071,
-0.3866634667,
0.1563539058,
-0.175007686,
-0.1811543107,
-0.0111144986,
-0.5845526457,
0.1430935264,
-0.2471980006,
0.4817620218,
-0.6919706464,
0.1520036161,
0.3243926764,
-0.3910105824,
-0.3181741238,
0.0897514001,
-0.487225771,
-0.0206009038,
-0.4893532097,
0.2665663958,
0.344103694,
-0.2250689864,
0.7942229509,
0.7852471471,
-0.0509232916,
-0.756269455,
-0.3824726343,
0.3174217641,
-0.2017828822,
-0.7023496628,
0.1728968918,
0.2446811646,
-1.0343295336,
-0.1732603163,
0.3114977777,
-0.4363243878,
0.2362566888,
0.3061419129,
0.1723614186,
-0.1303917617,
0.2017053515,
-0.1661810875,
-0.0571176969,
0.1776250601,
0.2207034081,
0.4578484893,
0.2125238031,
-0.0514811836,
-0.8479642868,
0.278619945,
0.1598862559,
-0.0706052557,
0.7197889686,
0.6689372063,
-0.0858281776,
-0.3014068305,
-0.3872952163,
-0.5439243913,
-0.3781802356,
0.2022894919,
0.0257830638,
-0.9000808597,
0.6704967022,
-0.2945843339,
0.2984861434,
0.4245152175,
0.6144856215,
-0.241774708,
0.6642744541,
0.8175765872,
0.0548075289,
0.5424339771,
-0.3091163933,
0.5459232926,
-0.6175602674,
-0.4237504303,
-1.2665038109,
-0.3882874548,
-1.0311291218,
-0.8086704016,
-0.2304136157,
-0.1223086417,
-0.1567746848,
0.1956357658,
-0.7151455879,
0.1801751107,
0.6976610422,
0.032992471,
0.5067164302,
0.0176970083,
0.7576435208,
-0.1420385092,
-0.6494576931,
-0.7666196227,
0.9572067857,
0.2537350953,
0.4754320085,
-0.2403588295,
1.0657600164,
0.6212108135,
0.1418549269,
-0.8835857511,
0.501688242,
-0.0582519546,
-0.6236972213,
-0.0203499589,
-0.3028365076,
-1.1408582926,
0.3085765541,
-0.4781271815,
-0.4513403773,
0.6634994745,
-0.2387159169,
0.1339814812,
0.4553917646,
-0.4561378658,
0.4295645356,
0.3107152879,
0.1286772788,
-0.6789956093,
-0.4688141644,
0.2565611601,
0.2784084678,
0.5643085837,
0.0682299957,
-0.3693323433,
1.1449707747,
0.1926469356,
0.8998641968,
-0.2830307782,
0.0356026888,
0.3606756926,
-0.1513735801,
0.3622507453,
-0.286510855,
-0.0686377287,
0.455696404,
-0.0858723298,
-0.421115011,
-0.6940591335,
0.3640058339,
-0.7539941072,
-0.4323486686,
-0.633464992,
-0.5541024804,
0.2645813227,
-0.0182566065,
-0.0939147472,
-0.1175121292,
-0.3763599098,
0.4246495962,
0.4400676191,
0.2338187099,
0.4248880446,
-0.0883449242,
-0.2151651233,
-0.162065044,
0.8485737443,
0.5654993653,
-0.2433109879,
-0.0620089509,
0.0667844191,
-0.2385454923,
-0.6168633699,
-0.1846189648,
0.2732456923,
-0.4904000163,
0.2482559383,
-0.6752461195,
0.0126081035,
-0.1157378703,
-0.1890182495,
-0.2756212652,
-0.8167005181,
-0.7789885998,
-0.0785970762,
-0.2936100066,
0.9240618348,
-0.1160157546,
0.067534402,
-0.3805797994,
0.4680150449,
0.0618868321,
-0.1350635886,
-0.1167172492,
-0.4611755013,
-0.2528972626,
0.1920558214,
-0.2177886367,
-0.9198867083,
-0.0127778081,
-0.0399222337,
0.3868798614,
0.2357478142,
0.0977108032,
0.4054922163,
-0.4378209412,
1.2666665316,
0.1780104041,
-0.7427175641,
0.3536824882,
-0.1519565731,
-0.3394365311,
0.6455894113,
0.3271054626,
-0.3538348973,
-0.5199135542,
-0.852393508,
-0.9561598301,
0.0409589335,
-0.0171349607,
0.8084814548,
0.1449440718,
-0.0056046839,
0.5744603276,
0.459847331,
-0.7051076293,
-0.1408657432,
-0.1472014487,
0.0944564193,
0.0322667807,
-0.2340953648,
-0.57261163,
-0.1062117666,
0.700025022,
-0.1143186092,
0.1655933559,
0.2456925064,
0.0236317776,
0.0974176675,
0.473202616,
0.4861625731,
1.2042382956,
-0.0243533179,
0.1032104492,
-0.7527135015,
-0.4206517637,
0.1259836853,
0.1804249287,
-0.7353478074,
0.1576084495,
0.4935073853,
0.4484898448,
-0.5540436506,
-0.2613641024,
0.3312165737,
0.178205505,
-0.2732610703,
-0.1150025502,
0.2238156945,
-0.2685003579,
0.3856767118,
0.716680944,
0.3571572304,
0.4313740134,
-0.6903020144,
0.2469360232,
0.8057281375,
-0.43932724,
-0.4225266576,
0.1797207296,
0.4113114178,
-0.7033773661,
0.4323062301,
0.1165226325,
-0.2121454477,
0.6478264332,
0.3528199494,
1.1186462641,
0.2606241703,
0.8389391303,
0.1950359493,
0.7658554316,
0.0596378595,
0.3106350303,
-0.3403732777,
-0.8100078702,
-0.6768141985,
-0.1913260967,
-0.4734635353,
-0.3746849,
-0.8211457729,
-0.1184456944,
-0.2488421798,
-0.8701629043,
0.0885520577,
0.2582258284,
-0.3436059654,
-0.1254386753,
0.0047371876,
1.0374655724,
-1.0711753368,
0.4306734204,
0.6684029698,
-0.1411866248,
-0.1924596429,
0.1211375669,
-0.167579338,
-0.3930386305,
0.6534822583,
0.0406222343,
0.0052674492,
-0.5154314637,
-0.503662765,
-0.0255154949,
0.6156756282,
0.3411251903,
-0.2206706405,
0.0432160795,
-0.1079130247,
0.5941719413,
-0.1680247933,
0.19044967,
0.4036195278,
0.8449683785,
-0.713988781,
-0.8367525935,
-0.3052967489,
-0.0598327182,
-0.175544098,
0.0981099904,
-0.4854048789,
0.6123543382,
-0.3889948428,
-0.2790460885,
-0.2611459196,
1.1040908098,
-0.1054742858,
0.9112843871,
0.312936604,
0.0383102223,
0.7830638289,
-0.1751290858,
0.8182327747,
0.1211611256,
0.3211421669,
0.7595295906,
0.0205130465,
0.7325125933,
0.9889320731,
-0.5379370451,
0.6798129082,
0.6948892474,
0.2489110827,
0.2700342834,
0.3104485869,
-0.3216593564,
-0.0810248852,
-0.4659808278,
-0.2950735986,
0.6513963342,
-0.1320794672,
-0.4586157799,
-0.2016465962,
0.1985584944,
-0.1301985532,
0.6134852171,
-0.2221402824,
1.2119652033,
-0.0997705162,
-0.2893950939,
0.2123427093,
-0.1398709565,
0.6739308238,
-0.4859936535,
-0.2298822105,
0.086775586,
-0.410836786,
-0.33145836,
-0.6912599802,
0.5176146626,
0.0322036594,
-0.5946685076,
-0.1458498538,
0.5173420906,
-0.0403575674,
-0.5484814048,
0.4423398972,
0.8688514233,
-0.0208035428,
-0.0048458185,
-0.928445816,
0.1762587875,
0.1000295132,
-0.4057662189,
0.4549480975,
0.2031292319,
0.0952956676,
0.6000510454,
0.7363450527,
0.6811187863,
-0.0277440064,
0.018755801,
0.929728508,
-0.4338611066,
-0.2825420201,
-0.9166873693,
0.5398837924,
-0.1232474819,
-0.1730184108,
0.8194522858,
0.5738618374,
0.7251207232,
0.3199782968,
0.851973474,
-0.2304354012,
0.1212314293,
-0.2620923519,
0.6101462841,
-0.400980711,
-0.0183638893,
0.0015482826,
-0.9484907389,
-0.4969652593,
0.8053374887,
-0.2952750325,
0.0705694705,
0.2918443978,
0.5685399175,
-0.0494996756,
0.3386783004,
-0.1354528815,
0.149721086,
0.1721713096,
-0.385406822,
0.778976202,
-0.1675343513,
-0.0091469176,
-0.6545552611,
-0.326025635,
-0.0217810292,
-0.6121993661,
-0.7443773746,
-1.1209020615,
-0.1250307709,
-0.6383285522,
0.2859913707,
0.7572793365,
0.6238661408,
-0.5884831548,
-0.5213273168,
0.2835594118,
0.5059463382,
-0.3226170242,
-0.2382199615,
0.4128177464,
-0.5078451633,
-0.8249861002,
0.2494555265,
0.2278614044,
-0.5707735419,
-0.7147958279,
0.3706155717,
-0.1939709932,
0.3151006401,
0.4813987017,
0.0441275463,
-0.6698778868,
-0.1262685657,
0.0743391663,
0.024186749,
0.2110692263,
1.2489335537,
-0.9002456069,
0.9094971418,
0.8053364754,
0.5522404313,
-0.0655996054,
0.3394270539,
0.4093157947,
0.056321431,
0.3953374922,
0.7743614912,
-0.1592530757,
0.4397290051,
-0.1197402999,
0.5741634369,
0.1463885903,
-0.6482557654,
-1.1941150427,
0.2542670965,
-0.929926455,
-0.3557050824,
1.0084882975,
0.1217171028,
-0.3721452057,
-0.4373788834,
-0.2363249213,
0.2008254826,
-0.4028323293,
1.2363426685,
0.5550980568,
-0.1316972077,
0.1349022537,
-0.608728826,
0.3789896071,
-0.1424771547,
-0.661690414,
0.1648454368,
0.32491377,
-0.3513462543,
0.5337889194,
0.6782529354,
-0.0387439281,
0.3529107571,
-0.2241784185,
-0.0911024138,
-0.0249746721,
-0.5232188702,
-0.314355135,
0.5723795891,
-0.1377354562,
-0.0745766312
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11581v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11581v1 | Style Transfer with Multi-iteration Preference Optimization | 2024-06-17T14:20:53 | 2024-06-17T14:20:53 | Shuai Liu, Jonathan May | cs.CL | cs.CL | Numerous recent techniques for text style transfer characterize their
approaches as variants of reinforcement learning and preference optimization.
In this work, we consider the relationship between these approaches and a class
of optimization approaches developed primarily for (non-neural) statistical
machine translation, formerly known as 'tuning'. Inspired by these techniques
from the past, we improve upon established preference optimization approaches,
incorporating multiple iterations of exploration and optimization, and choosing
contrastive examples by following a 'hope' vs 'fear' sampling strategy.
Cognizant of the difference between machine translation and style transfer,
however, we further tailor our framework with a new pseudo-parallel generation
method and a dynamic weighted reward aggregation method to tackle the lack of
parallel data and the need for a multi-objective reward. We evaluate our model
on two commonly used text style transfer datasets. Through automatic and human
evaluation results we show the effectiveness and the superiority of our model
compared to state-of-the-art baselines. | [
-0.3414550424,
-0.5233111978,
0.5413922668,
0.3303768933,
-0.2431985587,
0.1748520881,
-0.6515756249,
-0.1634177417,
0.384719342,
0.2905421853,
-0.7071108818,
-0.1036071405,
-0.7383217216,
0.3640197515,
-0.2580571175,
1.2762415409,
-0.3731769025,
-0.0676994026,
-0.0361668728,
-0.1525061131,
-0.5961505175,
-0.482144475,
-0.758056879,
-0.3593730032,
0.6254406571,
0.6933359504,
0.5087888241,
0.5075079203,
0.6750701666,
0.3122108579,
0.2573671341,
0.3942488134,
-0.7199810743,
0.1314194798,
-0.2358489782,
-0.4506423771,
-0.2713740766,
0.1656783372,
0.4110408127,
0.207298249,
-0.0259578954,
0.1952125281,
-0.1284995079,
1.0815389156,
-0.5910022855,
0.0156700313,
-0.6847659945,
0.0916177481,
-0.2121148407,
-0.6041063666,
-0.4560826123,
-0.5667244792,
0.2021826953,
-0.6645824909,
-0.0833722353,
0.2555901706,
0.6084638834,
0.2334649563,
-0.4167452753,
-0.3933217227,
-0.6489272714,
1.2879986763,
-0.2371557802,
0.112788707,
0.2875268459,
0.366065383,
0.20174779,
-0.6388620138,
-0.5129765868,
-0.2708224058,
-0.0218701586,
0.1410669535,
-0.0407774895,
-0.2813453674,
-0.2078304142,
0.2765790522,
-0.4475365877,
-0.1278837025,
-0.2591052353,
-0.0256163422,
0.7412938476,
0.0410736054,
0.1873739809,
-0.0893401057,
-0.5240655541,
-0.6387044787,
-0.2410871983,
0.176173836,
0.3130934238,
0.3050967753,
-0.125275135,
0.3369111121,
-0.2018363327,
0.6210254431,
0.1845977008,
-0.323036015,
0.4907489419,
-0.6655569077,
0.2080978155,
0.067634277,
0.8300136924,
0.7957989573,
0.5944252014,
-0.3472156823,
-0.3083495796,
-0.0712637529,
0.6499795914,
-0.6185230017,
-0.2242256701,
-0.1251033843,
-0.8574898839,
-0.8237406015,
-0.0222885814,
-1.1607837677,
0.020301722,
-0.7978388071,
0.512755096,
-0.3743360937,
-0.061397139,
0.2043022215,
-0.2757849693,
0.0060190563,
0.1371354461,
-1.1936922073,
0.1336058527,
0.1218881682,
1.0032229424,
-0.8228356242,
-0.2066367418,
-0.3161741495,
-0.0039074891,
-0.4796230793,
0.8780850172,
-0.6182220578,
-0.5067743063,
-0.1638210565,
-0.1145336777,
-0.2613630891,
-0.3253162801,
0.5900402665,
-0.3203261793,
0.1964073181,
-0.3835811913,
-0.1761228144,
0.0904958621,
-0.0294641294,
-0.4350377023,
1.0584020615,
0.290348947,
-0.489113152,
0.3588714302,
-0.8774423599,
-0.6371679306,
-0.3842164576,
0.2946808934,
-0.667634964,
0.2150617838,
0.2782390416,
0.0895537585,
-0.2105426639,
0.0325371884,
-0.5022161007,
-0.4612766802,
0.3210328519,
-0.0375678651,
0.1714894921,
0.6412153244,
-0.3913901746,
0.4378123581,
-0.4405067563,
0.0915309936,
0.2878563404,
-0.0966237113,
-0.4933162928,
-0.0966119692,
0.1490969062,
0.2094088048,
0.3781037629,
-0.1281068921,
0.4851985574,
0.001698693,
0.4806289077,
0.9593896866,
-0.0526392944,
0.8388341665,
-0.682561636,
0.5231115818,
-0.3407593369,
0.2804249525,
0.0859889612,
-0.0591305569,
-0.807806015,
0.0350009575,
0.2249538153,
0.5821250677,
-0.927102685,
0.1828220487,
-0.2009246647,
-0.4973066151,
-0.5165224075,
-0.0749519244,
0.3173705637,
0.4155543447,
0.7938604951,
-0.2904854417,
-0.3730079532,
-0.8718997836,
-0.6074529886,
0.0072536618,
0.2312778383,
0.493878901,
0.1473368704,
-0.0292651299,
0.4717617929,
-0.5620933175,
-0.0532336831,
-0.3115950525,
0.5419645309,
0.1452645957,
0.5062471628,
1.0599814653,
-0.8067730069,
-0.7338942885,
0.0450265706,
-0.4795481265,
-0.1353653818,
-0.4181877375,
-0.5070124269,
0.0824574754,
0.4406908154,
0.0495584235,
0.1001646891,
0.5342456698,
0.2080201507,
0.6040385962,
-0.0668128282,
0.591752708,
-1.1831247807,
0.0402758531,
0.1036522165,
-0.1500115842,
-0.5823823214,
-0.2247891128,
0.1182038486,
0.1568512768,
-0.2968262434,
0.6590157151,
-0.2633112967,
0.1032600328,
-0.502630651,
-0.268163681,
-0.0048401658,
0.6845139265,
0.0368281752,
1.0100791454,
0.4564097822,
-0.5081966519,
0.4030664563,
0.1952843964,
-0.1451780498,
0.8841484785,
-0.4000949264,
0.688578248,
-0.1433097571,
-0.0049790293,
-0.9575604796,
0.1613835096,
0.2271524817,
-0.2388015091,
0.4305733144,
-0.0743730888,
-0.2583479285,
-0.3165405393,
-0.4570309818,
0.3027469814,
0.5479845405,
-0.4362304807,
0.0168737974,
0.0994250104,
-0.4652231038,
-0.4248237908,
-0.4233721793,
0.0832345635,
-0.7332225442,
-0.2492411733,
0.7798472047,
-0.3219194412,
-0.1336897761,
-0.2020466477,
-0.2163141519,
0.0770914406,
0.0724690109,
-0.4769046009,
0.4022350013,
-0.1238669604,
-0.0991706997,
0.3522906005,
-0.090198569,
-0.2780628502,
-0.6152195334,
0.4681997597,
-0.116120711,
-0.023919614,
-0.2938865125,
0.3749780655,
0.4070400894,
-0.2752289772,
0.7008086443,
0.7691757083,
0.250846982,
-0.2460892498,
-0.3117754161,
-0.2847373188,
-0.5141015053,
0.3452350199,
-0.5485453606,
-0.6605175734,
0.0053259954,
-0.2837315798,
-0.0082181124,
0.3090793192,
0.5615830421,
-0.2162285596,
0.9982507825,
0.8307291865,
-0.2275811136,
1.081130147,
0.0559925251,
0.0378553383,
-0.4975133836,
-0.0628011078,
-0.7278394699,
-0.7457832694,
-0.890820086,
-0.111752905,
0.5100455284,
0.0407176241,
-0.0723772272,
0.5388897061,
-0.5291034579,
0.3835349083,
0.7193401456,
0.1274570376,
0.1417924166,
0.3662388325,
-0.0622158498,
-0.133398369,
-0.4848846197,
-0.3054890633,
1.321949482,
-0.1629862338,
0.6774632931,
0.1259510964,
0.7481275201,
0.3312089741,
0.2354494482,
-0.9297974706,
0.1616694778,
-0.5331439972,
0.1546519399,
-0.4080085754,
-0.6175720692,
-0.9714201689,
0.1153583154,
-0.3080016673,
-0.5889855623,
0.2772926688,
0.2340202332,
0.1738356054,
0.0771138594,
-0.5660763383,
0.7820365429,
-0.4583646059,
-0.4305694103,
-0.3138974309,
-0.7412984967,
0.2173071504,
-0.3840723932,
0.129058376,
0.1657923013,
0.1137655154,
0.5675804615,
0.037565235,
0.0693427026,
0.2755947709,
0.1575267613,
-0.0759878233,
0.0587874204,
0.6415551305,
-0.2919053137,
-0.4201690853,
0.0061000595,
-0.0252266154,
-0.2651098967,
-0.7343446016,
0.4581932127,
-0.7771499753,
-0.1661149859,
-0.1192607507,
-0.757984221,
-0.4233151078,
0.39330706,
0.2495728284,
0.1529264301,
-0.0358388238,
0.1779520512,
0.3799531162,
-0.2304644585,
0.465313524,
0.1445320994,
-0.0727061853,
-0.5006998181,
1.1711078882,
-0.0842443705,
0.4239969254,
0.4806622267,
0.4533816576,
-0.5449176431,
-0.5798014402,
-0.7315090299,
0.0569633432,
-0.2133460492,
0.0622411519,
-0.395606339,
0.0797000974,
-0.5613655448,
-0.4617114663,
-0.2625575066,
-0.3867855668,
-0.2442823052,
0.174427852,
0.5454214811,
0.5517011285,
0.0774915591,
0.3415613174,
-0.585819602,
0.5010980368,
0.1687340736,
0.1926549673,
-0.3158878982,
-0.5767239332,
-0.2381365448,
-0.2147933245,
-0.4978958368,
-1.0099022388,
0.6721462011,
0.0964202881,
0.4789735675,
0.1210358292,
0.2389395982,
0.5957448483,
-0.5592359304,
0.4018376172,
0.3119233251,
-0.6677225828,
0.4357307851,
-0.2706347704,
0.0483905822,
1.0021623373,
0.4881264865,
-0.714246273,
-0.0171884485,
-0.4480015337,
-0.8236085176,
0.7451208234,
0.2722894549,
0.0963822082,
0.1346139461,
0.4137153924,
0.1051931456,
0.6842522621,
-0.382829845,
-0.3911994696,
-0.5613104701,
-0.2860477269,
-0.3801766038,
0.1594410837,
-0.0723536015,
-0.1405973583,
0.4854891598,
-0.3882261813,
0.4425300062,
-0.1557366103,
-0.1496117115,
0.070321016,
0.3707353175,
0.7014119625,
0.3936053514,
-0.1836248934,
-0.0743830949,
-0.0112733562,
-0.1927601546,
0.1830324382,
0.0187726486,
-0.126429677,
-0.1001170799,
-0.2410069555,
1.2719978094,
0.007667847,
-0.1216018647,
0.3293531239,
0.0042052339,
-0.2479700595,
0.0518024042,
0.0261671003,
-0.2607888281,
0.0117731206,
0.0410452634,
0.4045538902,
0.4180999994,
-0.5222667456,
0.2789877951,
0.3601979613,
-0.3472666442,
-0.0344093628,
0.4921452105,
-0.0557987168,
-0.3689539731,
0.3608012497,
-0.1516966969,
-0.3468471766,
0.5121657848,
0.6204277277,
0.8957898617,
-0.1172199771,
0.3468147814,
0.3762844801,
0.174301967,
-0.3400114477,
0.2093933672,
-0.2217107266,
-0.6660827398,
-0.3905121982,
-0.8274847269,
-0.5696614981,
-0.0861714929,
-0.8425622582,
0.5761116743,
-0.0723334551,
-0.1076331809,
-0.2217715979,
-0.2276287228,
-0.5580745935,
-0.0062278127,
-0.1164564118,
0.5010550618,
-0.8635900021,
0.8346462846,
0.8236965537,
-0.4143773913,
-0.7012286782,
0.2759179771,
-0.0126452586,
-0.8494439125,
0.3642137349,
0.0204328224,
-0.2940408289,
0.2598544657,
-0.1968002617,
-0.9730423093,
0.6903554797,
0.321266681,
-0.4729038775,
-0.0695778504,
-0.1914293617,
0.4589484036,
-0.2292834967,
0.2042467445,
0.7154090405,
0.7594004273,
0.1418044269,
-0.9385694265,
-0.2098323703,
-0.2807851136,
0.1651410162,
0.220001623,
-0.9090968966,
0.6148350835,
0.0753656328,
0.1846160591,
0.2563642561,
0.5192062855,
0.2606209815,
0.2360395342,
0.5513870716,
0.185179919,
0.5449305177,
-0.0075418716,
1.2552771568,
-0.4306356311,
0.3882986903,
0.8002933264,
-0.0431338362,
0.5433277488,
0.6486271024,
-0.2919717133,
0.5467448831,
0.759617269,
-0.0298279002,
0.8862726092,
0.2902326286,
0.1554153562,
-0.0456051119,
-0.2189390361,
-0.3474694788,
0.4124615788,
-0.060636811,
-0.4330334961,
0.1630832702,
-0.0412943289,
0.1580389887,
0.1879630387,
-0.1495825499,
0.9700884819,
0.041790273,
-1.0214290619,
0.7163435817,
0.2601605356,
0.9176958203,
-0.6020524502,
-0.0514731482,
-0.3590303957,
-0.0878610685,
0.1303869486,
-0.4628784359,
0.2885932624,
-0.1964864582,
-0.2143906355,
-0.9041290283,
0.638818562,
-0.5193778872,
-0.504935205,
0.1026112363,
0.3438073993,
0.2865452766,
0.1073175073,
-0.9082219601,
-0.1193295941,
0.0778136924,
-0.259575367,
0.6441496611,
0.2835364342,
-0.2413413376,
0.2852408886,
0.840107739,
0.3642359674,
-0.0661441609,
0.1153184548,
0.5151143074,
-0.4612960815,
-0.6156423092,
-0.8440265656,
0.1578231901,
-0.1014948413,
-0.3336581588,
0.560828805,
0.272547394,
0.7445887327,
-0.1442425996,
0.8310991526,
0.2596797347,
0.261742413,
-0.8365477324,
0.5085220337,
-0.8751705289,
-0.1811665595,
-0.8529306054,
-1.0288958549,
0.0080948509,
0.7661653757,
-0.3767848313,
0.1917800754,
0.9699370265,
0.5497723818,
-0.0375200622,
-0.0823943689,
0.0858968273,
-0.4158771038,
-0.0889112204,
0.5589205623,
0.5376794338,
0.02468355,
0.5153734088,
-0.3820538223,
-0.4575189352,
-0.3039371073,
-0.940402627,
-0.4121171534,
-0.5346351266,
-0.0780675039,
-0.2951749861,
0.2328524739,
0.9115181565,
0.8308505416,
-0.715688169,
-0.4332078397,
0.0476843081,
0.0167114343,
-0.5419929028,
-0.17000857,
0.3566740453,
-0.7932681441,
-1.1539947987,
0.5827503204,
0.2384840995,
0.0479617715,
0.025265703,
0.0279715098,
0.0782839879,
0.1822678447,
0.6340954304,
0.0764059126,
-0.1705283374,
-0.1347130388,
0.2730989158,
-0.0276071616,
0.2355959117,
1.0809673071,
-0.3528825343,
0.4870099127,
0.5034698844,
0.9143192172,
0.7573267221,
0.1984101981,
0.5931537747,
-0.6592098475,
0.0941443369,
-0.1554974467,
0.1999376863,
0.1273111403,
-0.3442118764,
0.4181689918,
0.4387070239,
-0.4411984682,
-0.5753211379,
0.32380566,
-0.9206596017,
-0.3386416435,
1.2147824764,
0.1607173383,
-0.0292004663,
0.1458339393,
-0.3425378203,
0.3321399987,
-0.6118472219,
0.9523428082,
0.7403188348,
-0.5339571834,
-0.1072783992,
-0.5121849775,
0.6009337902,
0.8464642167,
-0.8896429539,
-0.3908705711,
0.334412545,
0.1655968279,
-0.0937012732,
0.6473323703,
-0.176670596,
0.106376186,
-0.5152925849,
0.105919756,
0.1462100893,
-0.635013938,
-0.1867769063,
0.0290153213,
0.0774377882,
-0.3071289062
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11580v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11580v1 | Error Span Annotation: A Balanced Approach for Human Evaluation of Machine Translation | 2024-06-17T14:20:47 | 2024-06-17T14:20:47 | Tom Kocmi, Vilém Zouhar, Eleftherios Avramidis, Roman Grundkiewicz, Marzena Karpinska, Maja Popović, Mrinmaya Sachan, Mariya Shmatova | cs.CL | cs.CL | High-quality Machine Translation (MT) evaluation relies heavily on human
judgments. Comprehensive error classification methods, such as Multidimensional
Quality Metrics (MQM), are expensive as they are time-consuming and can only be
done by experts, whose availability may be limited especially for low-resource
languages. On the other hand, just assigning overall scores, like Direct
Assessment (DA), is simpler and faster and can be done by translators of any
level, but are less reliable. In this paper, we introduce Error Span Annotation
(ESA), a human evaluation protocol which combines the continuous rating of DA
with the high-level error severity span marking of MQM. We validate ESA by
comparing it to MQM and DA for 12 MT systems and one human reference
translation (English to German) from WMT23. The results show that ESA offers
faster and cheaper annotations than MQM at the same quality level, without the
requirement of expensive MQM experts. | [
-0.4072700441,
-0.4137945175,
0.2376358509,
0.9181700945,
-0.0883535594,
0.4570495784,
-0.0521946065,
-0.7407557964,
0.2580669522,
0.3522780836,
-0.5262190104,
-0.2622376978,
-0.815798223,
0.4753565192,
-0.3139889836,
0.654120326,
-0.5688638687,
0.0183755513,
0.0411105938,
-0.4215632379,
-0.4983529449,
-0.5455081463,
-0.7526252866,
-0.1649370641,
0.5292579532,
0.2971484959,
0.8705378771,
0.9720668793,
0.8648448586,
0.3096116185,
0.1923115999,
0.5586473942,
0.1136676744,
-0.2731225193,
0.1112458333,
-0.2157627493,
-0.9479110241,
0.2504869103,
0.5925669074,
0.9210800529,
0.0880304724,
0.2184359282,
-0.0034795625,
0.8754661679,
-0.5313316584,
0.015979955,
-0.1043834537,
0.3097659945,
-0.222077921,
-0.2193462849,
-0.7002663016,
-0.3477113843,
0.01657602,
-0.5908008218,
-0.203936398,
0.3575330079,
1.045511961,
0.6971901655,
-0.4599941373,
0.0312108826,
-0.5822759271,
0.932215631,
-0.4148674309,
0.2497252524,
0.4882825017,
0.5283877254,
-0.0826020986,
-0.3211021423,
-0.4974324703,
-0.0271469429,
-0.1843110621,
0.3602976501,
-0.3527955413,
0.1395663768,
0.0284400843,
0.2642828822,
-0.2434416562,
0.360052228,
-0.3032421172,
-0.3678838313,
0.7815941572,
0.2178475559,
0.3630133867,
-0.3094489276,
-0.6773494482,
-0.1887627691,
-0.3964753747,
-0.148074165,
0.3531852365,
0.13946715,
-0.0339961424,
0.5292337537,
-0.2604893744,
0.5865533352,
0.0649586618,
0.0678505599,
0.6484109163,
-0.1692647487,
-0.2750265002,
-0.1923769414,
0.9147824645,
0.623968184,
0.071500279,
-0.4239902794,
-0.3443912864,
0.3072824776,
0.3530635238,
-0.5894169807,
0.150864616,
0.19652915,
-0.4339859486,
-0.2442094982,
0.3140242398,
-0.8493330479,
-0.3225118816,
-0.0992367119,
0.4949736595,
-0.2292713821,
0.1023978442,
0.2354998589,
0.0687473714,
-0.0442510545,
0.5966246128,
-0.3651621342,
0.3591420352,
0.2713222802,
0.8107974529,
-0.2712756097,
-0.7130478621,
-0.9928037524,
-0.1708894968,
-0.4528771341,
0.6781673431,
-0.0214357935,
-0.0502724275,
-0.270155102,
-0.0411028005,
-0.2172542214,
-0.3492541015,
1.190880537,
-0.4291372895,
0.2089440674,
-0.2812959254,
-0.3791742027,
-0.3634356856,
-0.0357730314,
-0.7302879691,
1.2030490637,
0.2894693315,
-0.8417928815,
0.696308732,
-1.1447405815,
-0.5695098042,
0.1777813882,
0.2713651657,
-0.272205174,
-0.0947795883,
0.3471575677,
0.5140882134,
-0.0879363492,
0.1023810804,
0.1180900633,
-0.5093758106,
0.2209034413,
-0.3836687803,
0.5361364484,
0.2767467201,
-0.6049737334,
0.1505128294,
-0.7982623577,
0.1010497808,
-0.1862524599,
-0.7912418246,
-0.3083617389,
0.2194025815,
0.0553766377,
0.5523663759,
-0.0566247702,
-0.4991050363,
0.1492628157,
-0.2873106301,
0.0470689572,
0.6849811077,
-0.2401783168,
0.2776516974,
-0.2124415338,
0.516336143,
-0.1327265203,
0.0874488279,
-0.0230295416,
-0.4620226622,
-0.9659606814,
-0.6232246161,
0.5915777683,
0.7350146174,
-0.5055894852,
1.1063257456,
-0.3843509853,
-0.4460445046,
-1.357558012,
0.1352430582,
0.6051671505,
0.3920559585,
0.7722247243,
-0.4087455571,
-0.7326028943,
-0.8037301898,
-0.2319557667,
-0.4160145819,
-0.0761133134,
-0.0665545836,
0.4866449535,
-0.7048137784,
0.7132868171,
-0.107230261,
-0.4955646098,
-0.0367921889,
0.7233583331,
-0.251814425,
0.5063024163,
0.4946488738,
-0.3888679743,
-0.3715863824,
0.0094142305,
-0.585940659,
-0.6704024673,
-0.2409685552,
-0.4212008715,
0.4069950581,
0.1212892085,
-0.4650519192,
0.3658791482,
0.7947670817,
-0.5770056248,
0.5272179842,
-0.2314230502,
0.6839317679,
-0.780318141,
0.2432203889,
0.0774139538,
-0.3354682028,
-0.1162536368,
-0.0399161838,
0.2607881427,
0.3409118652,
-0.2707640827,
0.4111200869,
-0.1965430528,
-0.2048093826,
-0.2604257762,
0.2376313359,
0.1385158449,
0.3343264163,
-0.2034077793,
0.6453632116,
-0.0511088111,
-0.29846403,
0.3993904293,
0.3484611809,
-0.0971391872,
0.9666824341,
-0.4500936866,
0.0732978433,
-0.0900931284,
0.3383338153,
-0.9803086519,
-0.3574777544,
0.2033218741,
-0.5325071216,
0.2167084962,
0.056361001,
-0.6801998615,
-0.5946825147,
-0.3298223615,
-0.0214925203,
0.4550430775,
-0.6921781898,
0.2912171781,
0.1211766303,
0.1043286398,
-0.7494910955,
-0.9489881992,
0.3095727265,
-0.2436252832,
-0.8476225138,
0.2020801902,
0.1365607232,
-0.1597881168,
0.0296195298,
-0.2009734064,
0.1108721644,
0.5855223536,
0.3256903887,
0.0391546786,
-0.0149207935,
0.0514364801,
0.1425490528,
-0.5081541538,
-0.095912151,
-0.0549845323,
0.1430169493,
-0.324069351,
-0.5947062373,
-0.7359381318,
0.5662518144,
0.7502598166,
-0.4088278115,
0.4305734336,
0.6667206883,
-0.5670180321,
-0.0001353358,
-0.5853566527,
0.1509720683,
-0.2868632674,
0.4744345546,
-0.4249647558,
-0.5314120054,
0.2934603691,
-0.091912277,
0.1373668164,
1.00385952,
0.308706671,
-0.4923039377,
1.2598757744,
0.4639852643,
-0.3087869883,
-0.1094552353,
0.0858068243,
-0.1901388764,
-0.7776435018,
-0.007650007,
-0.953671813,
-0.5739107132,
-0.1124321371,
-0.4061864316,
0.1339805722,
0.3442084193,
-0.3182996213,
0.4470300376,
-0.2762829661,
0.2722347379,
0.4511080682,
-0.1478113383,
0.4129799902,
-0.0740892515,
-0.0994682238,
-0.3146974742,
-0.3082256913,
-0.990388453,
0.7388368249,
0.782881856,
0.5512855649,
0.0128478678,
0.6043351889,
0.6372421384,
0.6429110765,
-0.7511457801,
0.3517913818,
-0.1580467522,
-0.3849051595,
-0.2340751141,
-0.7492546439,
-0.7574130297,
0.3900188208,
-0.3231032193,
-0.5329452157,
-0.1035105065,
0.1589741409,
-0.3464012146,
0.218483761,
-1.0820405483,
1.0477832556,
-0.519400537,
0.1193324327,
-0.0092756525,
-0.9627375007,
0.0468789525,
-0.315749079,
0.3741545677,
-0.0650678128,
-0.1174169108,
1.0984493494,
-0.415055573,
0.7928888798,
-0.392388761,
0.3063706756,
0.0853853822,
0.2768596411,
0.6214811206,
-0.5687760115,
-0.1011930779,
-0.0247738082,
-0.1771359891,
-0.5234040618,
-0.3134768605,
0.126288712,
-1.0049756765,
-0.0992584899,
-0.4098789692,
-0.3711788654,
-0.2918844223,
0.1265498698,
0.0221561827,
-0.2648226023,
0.0358131826,
-0.0258191656,
0.0772025511,
-0.1442720294,
0.2913705707,
0.4333054721,
-0.0315308832,
-0.5375825167,
0.5753615499,
0.1495958418,
0.2549476624,
0.1819579899,
0.1419213712,
-0.1829086095,
-0.3810848892,
-1.012676239,
0.0685651004,
-0.7609133124,
-0.4817848206,
-0.7520623207,
0.2246382087,
0.3143169284,
-0.2554967105,
-0.6069296002,
-0.4467350841,
0.1298262477,
-0.4397569299,
0.2090279907,
0.3436746597,
0.1064813733,
0.6123725772,
-0.9747385979,
0.0218221564,
-0.0725650191,
0.3259327412,
-0.2964195013,
-0.413631618,
-0.4738522768,
0.0593363158,
-0.4700124264,
-0.9170848131,
0.1453086883,
0.0848712027,
0.569896996,
0.189570114,
0.0814056769,
0.9647608995,
-0.3872173727,
0.684669137,
0.2635149658,
-1.3881186247,
0.2703130543,
0.1139785647,
-0.1054741964,
0.6868715882,
0.2774117291,
-0.8287691474,
-0.4236559272,
-0.4468363822,
-1.0253429413,
0.6571701765,
0.0831129402,
-0.160152331,
-0.0181364752,
0.1835550517,
0.1149084568,
0.1423518062,
-0.7356643081,
-0.0659035444,
-0.1171204075,
-0.3609503806,
0.0340109803,
-0.0960560739,
-0.0016030256,
-0.0246491265,
0.7696375251,
-0.2076326162,
0.2183320224,
0.2937592864,
-0.4011292458,
-0.8596068621,
0.383878082,
0.3790788352,
0.5115633607,
-0.377769649,
0.3781639934,
0.3555811346,
-0.1545883715,
0.2765319645,
0.0753904134,
-0.0025659208,
0.071504496,
0.5883635283,
0.7081725597,
0.0157083049,
-0.494330287,
0.7245092392,
0.3616506755,
-0.123429507,
0.251398474,
-0.5374750495,
0.0377420299,
0.0665132403,
0.4732100964,
0.5603858829,
0.0904667452,
-0.0723357722,
0.3110436797,
-0.0344368294,
-0.5153871775,
-0.4157442451,
0.7408112288,
0.5678864121,
-0.0467920899,
0.5150578022,
-0.5010740757,
-0.7888081074,
0.2641319335,
0.2995433211,
1.1024916172,
-0.4990023077,
0.1618520021,
0.2022843212,
0.9316088557,
-0.3309207559,
0.2308014184,
0.3148763776,
-0.3300176263,
-1.1305931807,
-0.7315755486,
-0.5308329463,
-0.4626215994,
-0.4508553445,
0.2711538076,
0.015512513,
-0.1136591509,
0.0300742276,
0.1523332,
-0.4875427186,
0.4966990948,
0.0508705415,
1.0379532576,
-1.1650557518,
0.5581843257,
0.9206211567,
-0.6266703606,
-0.7297833562,
-0.0848771632,
-0.1412001997,
-0.6059653759,
0.9827295542,
0.2189589292,
-0.307464093,
-0.3096381724,
-0.0412662625,
-0.3222567439,
0.9945311546,
0.318174541,
-0.3011952341,
0.0625262633,
0.166605711,
0.6997466087,
-0.1957609802,
0.0818005726,
0.557074666,
0.9391577244,
-0.1815300733,
-1.1749404669,
0.1966462135,
-0.2090748996,
-0.2192602009,
0.3507946432,
-0.5485621691,
0.5865124464,
-0.0612062849,
-0.297375679,
0.0008222434,
0.5242345333,
-0.232635051,
0.2906339467,
0.6309577227,
0.7267252207,
0.8939366341,
-0.434291333,
1.0914885998,
0.1711105108,
0.4017704427,
0.7002937794,
-0.1769205183,
0.9745533466,
0.740678966,
-0.4857027531,
0.1158330366,
0.6602905393,
-0.1183076128,
0.1313967705,
0.4890065491,
0.1614173651,
-0.1086053103,
0.2586512268,
-0.1772605479,
0.1293054074,
0.1753709465,
-0.2678393126,
-0.1700906903,
-0.0335268527,
0.3541249335,
0.2183803916,
-0.113583073,
0.5847939253,
-0.199012965,
-0.5598480701,
0.4689772725,
0.5963027477,
0.797002852,
-0.2345869094,
0.1579812318,
-0.3050519824,
0.1650280654,
-0.6690863967,
-0.6379225254,
0.7535865307,
0.3876302242,
-0.0653789937,
-0.2586927712,
0.2864103019,
-0.1086808443,
-0.3775831461,
0.4319444895,
0.6016913056,
0.2535573542,
-0.2280010879,
-0.5115014911,
0.0839135796,
-0.3186344206,
-0.2929770648,
-0.08459609,
0.4201013744,
-0.5069276094,
0.5702035427,
0.3488981128,
0.0329378322,
0.3093373179,
-0.174866274,
0.3676164746,
-0.605558157,
-0.4209499061,
-0.8547978401,
0.8182271123,
-0.0344743952,
-0.2254642844,
0.7123429775,
0.4202768207,
0.6968768239,
-0.1543205678,
0.905962646,
-0.0014749073,
0.5380992293,
-0.2508217692,
0.6917371154,
-0.5542902946,
0.2221943289,
-0.7506653666,
-0.8577267528,
-0.819742918,
0.8095242381,
-0.1492305547,
-0.0176478643,
0.7402213216,
0.1606502682,
0.0433346853,
-0.1549812704,
0.1045988798,
-0.005841685,
0.2724365294,
0.5394539833,
1.0830414295,
-0.6986541152,
0.5914105773,
0.0010251483,
-0.6146315336,
-0.485625267,
-0.9943214059,
-0.5477718115,
-0.2142218202,
-0.63690418,
-0.5672224164,
-0.1274201721,
1.3618233204,
0.741235137,
-0.5749108195,
-0.1684532464,
0.1306489408,
-0.0183849148,
-0.7059963942,
-0.1593429297,
0.7058447003,
-0.4915694594,
-0.8020142317,
0.2610222101,
0.3551139534,
0.0104831858,
-0.0847262368,
-0.5290400386,
0.0583438277,
0.0168438684,
0.577233851,
0.0562270992,
-0.7913129926,
-0.6150551438,
0.0136731183,
-0.3972935677,
0.1982240826,
0.1644557863,
-0.2934188843,
0.5020329356,
0.313878268,
1.2027257681,
0.1195159927,
0.1388838589,
0.4203580022,
-1.0274391174,
-0.0866917297,
0.0709431916,
0.5048196912,
0.5083229542,
-0.0564416833,
0.7379886508,
0.3903636634,
-0.4188541472,
-0.9524184465,
0.0411166959,
-1.2212963104,
0.33396101,
0.8604812026,
-0.557215929,
-0.0532546639,
0.048409529,
-0.7245042324,
0.1205333918,
-0.1914913356,
0.8969318867,
0.945082128,
0.001014499,
0.1834944636,
-0.5169295669,
0.3406755924,
0.5565254092,
-1.1195468903,
-0.0189898107,
0.4688200951,
-0.1183511838,
0.582989037,
0.3896841109,
-0.3992670178,
0.4366801381,
-0.2683570087,
0.6296330094,
-0.1122449636,
-0.2032768279,
-0.1311197728,
0.042601224,
0.3712431192,
-0.6394924521
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11577v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11577v1 | Mathematical Entities: Corpora and Benchmarks | 2024-06-17T14:11:00 | 2024-06-17T14:11:00 | Jacob Collard, Valeria de Paiva, Eswaran Subrahmanian | cs.CL | cs.CL, math.HO | Mathematics is a highly specialized domain with its own unique set of
challenges. Despite this, there has been relatively little research on natural
language processing for mathematical texts, and there are few mathematical
language resources aimed at NLP. In this paper, we aim to provide annotated
corpora that can be used to study the language of mathematics in different
contexts, ranging from fundamental concepts found in textbooks to advanced
research mathematics. We preprocess the corpora with a neural parsing model and
some manual intervention to provide part-of-speech tags, lemmas, and dependency
trees. In total, we provide 182397 sentences across three corpora. We then aim
to test and evaluate several noteworthy natural language processing models
using these corpora, to show how well they can adapt to the domain of
mathematics and provide useful tools for exploring mathematical language. We
evaluate several neural and symbolic models against benchmarks that we extract
from the corpus metadata to show that terminology extraction and definition
extraction do not easily generalize to mathematics, and that additional work is
needed to achieve good performance on these metrics. Finally, we provide a
learning assistant that grants access to the content of these corpora in a
context-sensitive manner, utilizing text search and entity linking. Though our
corpora and benchmarks provide useful metrics for evaluating mathematical
language processing, further work is necessary to adapt models to mathematics
in order to provide more effective learning assistants and apply NLP methods to
different mathematical domains. | [
-0.5396437645,
-0.862547636,
0.3628872931,
0.4781813323,
-0.2107977122,
-0.0201751497,
-0.3380116522,
-0.5879837871,
0.0804819539,
0.3500729501,
-0.5232229233,
-0.5302665234,
-0.5033720732,
0.4774923921,
-0.2576631308,
0.8532853127,
-0.1673171818,
0.378892988,
-0.6538137197,
-0.2669573724,
-0.5085261464,
-0.7389588952,
-0.573749423,
-0.1292086393,
0.1652979106,
-0.0434593074,
0.701248467,
0.4178156555,
0.7931486964,
0.3875497878,
0.1120678633,
0.0770773441,
0.0231207069,
0.0983216688,
-0.2687618434,
-0.5034533739,
-0.5192611217,
-0.0938547179,
0.6045313478,
1.1967338324,
-0.0396373086,
0.3891918659,
-0.1263296753,
0.4296830297,
-0.4164957106,
0.7363879085,
-0.4599577188,
0.0236263126,
-0.238107875,
-0.0374951623,
-0.1474614739,
-0.5404718518,
0.3554464281,
-1.0508317947,
0.1781346351,
-0.0707523599,
0.6132702827,
0.2475536019,
0.0453159623,
-0.8450134397,
-0.3320019841,
0.9230430126,
-0.3491129875,
0.4371111393,
0.4693388641,
0.4177553356,
0.368144393,
-0.7866110802,
-0.0888136029,
-0.1603498012,
-0.2022498399,
-0.1580509096,
-0.27871117,
-0.3310973346,
0.4781102538,
0.2019503266,
-0.3227588832,
-0.287032634,
-0.4643951356,
-0.2003727555,
0.4634660482,
0.0831118748,
0.3686356843,
-0.2787807286,
-0.0591043718,
-0.3494025171,
-0.7112054229,
-0.0607810281,
0.4878178239,
0.2514477074,
-0.0040070745,
0.6807004809,
0.1336920857,
0.6687445045,
-0.6207131743,
-0.0707630515,
0.2529327869,
-0.2009206712,
-0.2084049731,
0.0981532186,
0.5032078624,
-0.2252140045,
0.5773089528,
-0.3416993022,
-0.1961899996,
0.5574371219,
0.2168399394,
-0.8621045351,
-0.3808729351,
-0.248094365,
-0.0290129185,
-0.0191125274,
-0.0694592744,
-0.7326782346,
0.361777246,
-0.9424135089,
0.2855857313,
-0.6896983981,
0.0218324717,
0.0157469958,
0.0142549984,
-0.4055222869,
0.1836371869,
-1.0811855793,
0.9344456196,
1.0713591576,
0.7770740986,
-0.0640030131,
-0.1102649644,
-0.5382499695,
-0.2717155516,
-0.3662971854,
0.7617101073,
-0.77480793,
-0.3346967697,
0.2458814383,
-0.2401179224,
-0.0985536426,
-0.8205569983,
0.8892065287,
-0.5904925466,
0.1932846308,
-0.2642080188,
-0.6587453485,
-0.3265553117,
0.0820088014,
-0.7990210652,
0.9841281772,
0.3482707739,
-0.497463733,
0.0644261315,
-1.1262229681,
-0.4237689972,
0.212185353,
-0.3656477034,
-0.1771925688,
0.3804344833,
0.1968132555,
0.0329949111,
-0.5561466813,
0.4323863089,
-0.2162424326,
-0.0881503224,
0.3541109264,
-0.1945265681,
0.9512648582,
0.2053166032,
-0.1330589056,
-0.0975126997,
-0.8658896089,
0.0873613581,
0.0196904726,
0.1202308908,
-0.6766709685,
-0.0163751524,
0.3165822923,
-0.0081051989,
0.3609379828,
-0.2303824127,
0.0006663917,
-0.3750314713,
0.3957365453,
0.5402814746,
-0.309740454,
0.3524746001,
0.0136876823,
0.4806598723,
-0.0845677331,
-0.2636300027,
-0.0524161607,
-0.4717190266,
-0.5398033261,
-0.2010911107,
0.7971792817,
0.4572187662,
-0.6395335197,
0.1486568749,
-0.2055875808,
-0.1300459653,
-0.5160108209,
0.2834428847,
0.551507175,
0.7477308512,
0.4575197697,
-0.2746436,
-0.5888953209,
-0.9650807381,
-0.2888121009,
0.0527040511,
-0.3610695899,
0.2964880764,
0.5088136196,
0.0850978047,
0.9034032226,
-0.7504253387,
-0.3063777387,
0.3810774088,
0.3224070072,
0.0490199924,
0.2345568687,
0.5575698018,
-0.9492448568,
-0.3166339695,
-0.2006530315,
-1.024020195,
-0.2683371902,
0.3481444418,
-0.2048412114,
-0.0258420166,
0.2649192214,
-0.2968433201,
0.3596772254,
0.2653527558,
-0.1811436564,
0.2987792492,
-0.0540091991,
-0.1970295459,
-0.927092731,
0.1926226169,
0.3311842978,
-0.1170354635,
-0.3377741873,
0.2324066609,
0.1503828019,
-0.056974221,
-0.2918893397,
0.4636628032,
-0.1969247162,
-0.4734584987,
-0.0744930729,
0.3802624047,
-0.0967191234,
0.4351240098,
0.3939785659,
0.917591393,
0.6416954994,
-0.6530086994,
0.1971714646,
0.3883186281,
-0.3071906865,
0.7956016064,
-0.8004904985,
-0.1575635523,
0.1663834006,
-0.2715486586,
-0.4791096151,
0.1379277259,
0.1201399267,
-0.3057770729,
0.0858734325,
-0.0506784208,
-0.8028180003,
0.2434441894,
0.0031941338,
0.5665180087,
0.3756407201,
-0.410998553,
0.5831670761,
0.5305370688,
-0.4362316728,
-0.407697022,
-0.3582994938,
-0.0090067368,
-0.2758896053,
-0.5913801789,
0.6681392193,
-0.2714176774,
-0.7080278993,
0.3546933234,
0.0506315157,
-0.298110038,
0.2688747048,
0.2870118618,
0.6115326881,
-0.568446815,
0.2878322899,
-0.1329060644,
-0.3228292465,
0.4919952452,
-0.3015542924,
0.4805327952,
-0.3867592216,
-0.118425943,
0.0408586971,
0.2489284724,
0.0200553723,
-0.2195563763,
0.3937270641,
0.3991148472,
-0.939856708,
-0.0360767096,
-0.2028903961,
-0.1529755741,
-0.4317459166,
0.2067814618,
-0.6654039621,
-0.6689376831,
0.3127253056,
-0.1476276219,
0.2277342081,
0.7927172184,
0.4250331819,
0.3896090388,
0.6185904145,
0.5878252983,
0.111097537,
0.2528343201,
-0.2067696154,
0.1175262779,
-0.908724308,
-0.0651431084,
-0.8329023123,
-0.0307614952,
-0.5979064703,
-0.2680887878,
0.1883042306,
0.1502417773,
0.0110205133,
0.8895379901,
-0.4289535284,
0.4771487713,
0.3722363412,
-0.375493288,
0.3746440411,
0.2209050059,
-0.373269856,
-0.535708189,
-0.3359019458,
-0.7750849128,
1.1215196848,
0.1610610038,
0.4283280075,
0.3532899022,
0.4708085954,
-0.0318543427,
0.7995530963,
-0.5241859555,
0.362364471,
-0.2646316588,
-0.7009530663,
-0.1955209672,
-0.7361313701,
-0.8485381603,
0.1954008341,
-0.0160291139,
-0.6354438066,
-0.0989700109,
-0.3432356715,
-0.3104439676,
-0.1297724098,
-0.6616466045,
0.959415853,
-0.1661047488,
-0.440277189,
-0.061153926,
-0.1148507223,
0.4405171871,
-0.3198804855,
0.4640206397,
-0.1122392341,
-0.1987632513,
0.6735534668,
-0.3783800602,
0.6249575615,
0.2991677225,
-0.1513455063,
0.3303266764,
0.3399253786,
-0.2390466928,
0.6575357318,
-0.1367496699,
0.3488094807,
0.3883771896,
-0.3225854933,
-0.509419322,
0.8825554252,
-0.8292799592,
-0.3350472152,
-0.563873589,
-0.6765364408,
-0.2296544611,
0.1082707047,
-0.1530790031,
0.6024906039,
-0.1696131676,
0.1182887182,
0.6178337932,
0.0044266777,
0.6093164682,
0.2214452624,
-0.2401568294,
-0.5598400235,
0.893433094,
0.2158958465,
-0.0441126414,
0.5887265205,
0.0109060984,
-0.71405828,
0.0133405859,
-0.4782265127,
0.1756463796,
-0.893004775,
-0.295327872,
-0.4008735716,
-0.2405473739,
-0.562646389,
-0.0922637731,
-0.1933033019,
-0.6553753018,
-0.3821864426,
0.0993173644,
0.3386094868,
0.4531827271,
-0.0285067838,
-0.0251259655,
-0.536801517,
0.3272501826,
0.3205524385,
0.3158117235,
-0.2131802887,
-0.1786721647,
0.001405556,
-0.1416049302,
-0.2897904515,
-0.4088287354,
0.4695723653,
0.1456478983,
0.4144700766,
0.153298825,
-0.146726042,
0.7352306843,
-0.8042300344,
0.4456702769,
0.2307697833,
-1.2768191099,
0.1681307703,
0.0817244947,
0.031028986,
0.5043632984,
0.5444975495,
-0.2398418635,
0.2538413107,
-0.8396407962,
-0.4259761572,
0.3457717896,
0.4755580425,
0.110721387,
-0.1257550716,
0.3610413074,
0.1047995985,
0.4366802275,
-0.4977810383,
-0.287075758,
-0.1175536141,
-0.4131898284,
-0.2921314836,
0.0522209071,
-0.3939345479,
-0.01987914,
0.3488973677,
-0.2254766375,
0.1152548417,
0.0618788712,
-0.3985551894,
-0.0701966658,
-0.0089767165,
0.8642259836,
1.3062858582,
-0.1369933337,
0.3591226339,
0.2609786093,
-0.5191721916,
-0.2502291203,
0.6536152363,
-0.0572885387,
0.5219615698,
0.3557389677,
0.3439236879,
0.9526292086,
-0.848903358,
0.0370711647,
-0.2724045813,
-0.199938342,
-0.6624614596,
-0.0920866206,
0.3975967467,
-0.1027759612,
0.3509533405,
0.1644600332,
0.2710770667,
-0.5424551964,
0.4173884392,
0.2702336013,
-0.103647083,
-0.5223668218,
0.756139338,
-0.1610961407,
-0.6546244621,
0.3835714161,
-0.3033952713,
-0.5254420042,
0.6247549653,
0.5707745552,
0.6305937767,
0.0294836946,
0.0981082544,
0.5397049785,
0.0556064136,
0.0111442739,
0.0455187932,
-0.094324708,
-0.2597803175,
-0.4145997763,
-0.83944875,
-0.5145308375,
-0.200402528,
-0.6671517491,
0.4716479778,
-0.5928457379,
-0.0146531854,
0.7039623857,
0.3710843623,
-1.0046796799,
0.1344580203,
0.0765039995,
0.7297132015,
-0.5082796216,
0.6031307578,
0.7244561911,
-0.6111151576,
-0.4492171407,
-0.6532546878,
-0.185409531,
-0.773224175,
0.9383930564,
-0.0547278635,
0.1879034489,
-0.1670099199,
-0.2749072611,
-0.730202198,
0.7948463559,
0.4070626795,
-0.509475708,
-0.0621209145,
0.3938194215,
0.7010679245,
-0.5856575966,
0.4125348628,
0.1658661216,
0.1386271268,
0.0671990067,
-0.6328063011,
-0.0356186256,
-0.2706147432,
0.068880178,
0.1923884898,
-0.2331943512,
1.111546278,
0.4107588828,
-0.0493214056,
0.1089076996,
0.7725052834,
0.4261152744,
0.6186748743,
0.26053074,
0.6831200123,
0.6265979409,
-0.1610925496,
0.7402197123,
-0.4551231861,
0.3964202106,
1.0206581354,
-0.2613461614,
1.0180953741,
0.3061898351,
-0.2988566756,
0.5655970573,
0.5819070935,
0.0451903045,
0.1800950468,
0.654879868,
-0.3777298033,
-0.1690705121,
-0.1666816175,
-0.6259573102,
0.0213594884,
0.6123004556,
-0.2919068336,
-0.4820381403,
-0.2702594101,
0.0308435,
0.4796379507,
-0.1836616248,
0.3551646769,
0.403921634,
-0.8261401653,
0.2426202446,
0.202807039,
0.3048074841,
-0.5090146065,
-0.32388556,
0.0054248446,
0.1728605777,
-0.0214856043,
-0.2553900182,
0.4984396994,
0.2344212532,
0.0303787179,
-0.1430318058,
0.368396461,
-0.3050795794,
-1.0682625771,
0.1319564581,
0.601046443,
0.3189623952,
0.0596603416,
-0.7139394879,
0.1556010246,
-0.5206456184,
0.1190363467,
0.4179458022,
0.7740761638,
-0.1962486655,
0.2071585208,
0.8947928548,
-0.1518056989,
0.0563603938,
0.2392000407,
0.783551991,
-0.6061702371,
-0.1433984786,
-0.786658287,
0.0279399883,
-0.2089423686,
-0.7673916221,
0.7130625844,
0.8705044985,
1.1197578907,
-0.0929833353,
0.4383980632,
0.0804875493,
0.4088445008,
-0.4972015321,
0.3364830017,
-0.1516194493,
0.3257642984,
-0.425036937,
-1.2830342054,
-0.6218751073,
0.8731443286,
-0.5016872883,
-0.1168293431,
0.8539240956,
0.2524315119,
-0.2858271301,
0.3366792202,
0.2751373053,
-0.3777711987,
0.1804915518,
0.5153791308,
0.5098198056,
-0.7034571767,
0.5105147362,
-0.4865559638,
0.0490114987,
-0.0497182757,
-0.7824140787,
-1.0830658674,
-0.6562124491,
-0.6377691031,
-0.2997812033,
-0.1638177633,
0.8842895627,
0.5506028533,
-0.78120327,
-0.4586932659,
-0.2571569979,
0.1559646577,
-0.17511262,
-0.2207584828,
0.6156255007,
-0.6957806945,
-1.0708106756,
0.148458004,
0.2288860083,
-0.1590199023,
-0.4274569154,
0.0836686641,
0.0401784889,
0.0085489042,
0.5513278246,
0.1928674728,
-0.4926343262,
-0.0014826193,
0.4273677766,
-0.0863457173,
-0.0347530469,
0.9647570252,
-0.6332329512,
0.1865698993,
0.0915454403,
0.8487930298,
0.3426983356,
-0.0976701379,
0.3856317699,
-0.4428185821,
0.0838120878,
0.3991548717,
0.4734660089,
0.3563295603,
-0.0831529126,
0.8999506235,
0.4322145879,
-0.1944262832,
-0.9081932902,
0.0578739159,
-0.640291214,
-0.2842234969,
0.6880400181,
-0.299908638,
-0.5218307972,
0.1134886742,
-0.0154311592,
0.0832596943,
-0.0829424262,
0.8790152669,
1.121971488,
0.0701417923,
0.0000977297,
-0.9250808358,
0.5289440155,
0.5142134428,
-0.959459424,
-0.3601447046,
0.2566525638,
0.1670833081,
0.7841666341,
0.0456153676,
-0.2535677552,
0.1616514921,
0.1475401372,
-0.0856142044,
0.1777166873,
-0.3414658606,
-0.1913684756,
0.3640868068,
-0.1758069694,
0.0857101381
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11568v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11568v1 | Towards an End-to-End Framework for Invasive Brain Signal Decoding with Large Language Models | 2024-06-17T14:04:18 | 2024-06-17T14:04:18 | Sheng Feng, Heyang Liu, Yu Wang, Yanfeng Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS, q-bio.NC | In this paper, we introduce a groundbreaking end-to-end (E2E) framework for
decoding invasive brain signals, marking a significant advancement in the field
of speech neuroprosthesis. Our methodology leverages the comprehensive
reasoning abilities of large language models (LLMs) to facilitate direct
decoding. By fully integrating LLMs, we achieve results comparable to the
state-of-the-art cascade models. Our findings underscore the immense potential
of E2E frameworks in speech neuroprosthesis, particularly as the technology
behind brain-computer interfaces (BCIs) and the availability of relevant
datasets continue to evolve. This work not only showcases the efficacy of
combining LLMs with E2E decoding for enhancing speech neuroprosthesis but also
sets a new direction for future research in BCI applications, underscoring the
impact of LLMs in decoding complex neural signals for communication
restoration. Code will be made available at
https://github.com/FsFrancis15/BrainLLM. | [
-0.2326728255,
-0.977920115,
0.6159125566,
0.3085099757,
-0.241776824,
-0.1352833062,
-0.3126493692,
-0.7116631866,
0.3634477854,
0.3706111014,
-0.4676351845,
-0.5671674013,
-0.8060294986,
-0.0319950432,
-0.5298659205,
0.5773952007,
0.0573694035,
0.1552831233,
-0.0856654942,
0.11232692,
-0.3580955267,
-0.324102819,
-0.8300503492,
-0.3156035244,
0.4983479083,
-0.1001026332,
0.3444375098,
0.4876906872,
0.086229533,
0.1597662419,
-0.5921022892,
0.1526897401,
-0.3109306097,
-0.0388884805,
-0.4997929633,
-0.3411030769,
-0.6758067608,
-0.5881490707,
0.4927251041,
0.9615892172,
-0.3670419157,
-0.0828733444,
0.1309853047,
0.3505931795,
-0.6590737104,
0.0606682338,
-0.2541115582,
-0.2049974948,
-0.0566709414,
-0.0370386988,
-0.8525072336,
0.0681975931,
0.0492692105,
-0.2117050141,
-0.5377671719,
-0.1771505326,
0.4413042665,
-0.0211497322,
-0.462875247,
-0.2122864276,
-0.6127186418,
0.5243157148,
-0.8160536289,
0.8641012907,
0.2254054546,
0.0712156296,
-0.5034334064,
-0.9236935377,
-0.4714713991,
0.0584599413,
0.2927654088,
0.1167986766,
-0.5793297887,
0.4466907084,
0.137518838,
-0.1075772941,
-0.5986491442,
0.6634472609,
-0.2071291655,
-0.4399056137,
0.1947626919,
-0.0911278948,
0.6011239886,
0.1736275405,
-0.1003202125,
0.3322328031,
-0.7635676265,
-0.1129385978,
0.2915426493,
0.0011487128,
-0.3103903234,
0.3944713175,
-0.0474132933,
0.9996353388,
-0.34547773,
0.264947921,
0.0262759291,
-0.0873850733,
-0.2103116363,
0.1795888841,
0.4971822202,
0.3073658347,
0.219789207,
-0.4982468486,
-0.0442192256,
0.0031743136,
-0.2209171951,
-0.7001851201,
0.0726572722,
0.4844518006,
-0.5066799521,
0.1113564149,
-0.4974716604,
-0.5821939111,
-0.3873964846,
-0.4347449541,
0.4176864624,
-0.3698044717,
-0.6938639283,
0.7207823992,
-0.1743308455,
0.6845594049,
0.138244018,
-1.0727983713,
0.4386512637,
0.8965319395,
0.8839331269,
-0.0004365202,
-0.1262091696,
-0.3565518558,
0.320446074,
-0.4809360206,
0.7742746472,
-0.3321404159,
-0.1972387284,
0.1383102536,
0.0981107652,
0.3537513614,
-0.4765820205,
0.7811642885,
-0.7341973782,
-0.0236683264,
-0.1475875676,
-0.4510369301,
-0.3767434359,
-0.1332825422,
-0.5174689889,
0.2485629469,
0.0477979369,
-0.3553721607,
-0.118670918,
-0.7030690908,
-0.6608451605,
0.032082364,
-0.1287232786,
-0.1216838807,
0.2754871249,
0.1487569511,
0.3947212994,
-0.6300551891,
0.3526753485,
-0.5480023623,
-0.3682730198,
0.163808763,
-0.7814874649,
1.1732829809,
0.1587139219,
-0.2459987998,
-0.108745724,
-0.6661631465,
0.1271348298,
0.0046344497,
-0.2465408444,
-0.1956970692,
0.1576203853,
0.1669139266,
0.2322858125,
0.4332143068,
-0.8553335667,
-0.1562574655,
-0.5742667317,
0.9631253481,
0.6345626116,
-0.043630641,
0.3155380487,
0.0565233231,
0.1674673855,
0.0231837127,
0.1190868169,
-0.4029468894,
-0.4858324528,
-0.3902218044,
-0.4057076573,
0.1595826745,
0.6755421758,
-0.3230824172,
0.7509000301,
-0.5181120634,
-0.1228486001,
-0.3534699678,
-0.3263421357,
-0.0127189895,
0.4996494353,
0.4300822914,
-0.0587471463,
-0.8925833106,
-1.0869351625,
-0.0111230854,
-0.1468041092,
-0.4099699855,
-0.0565045662,
0.185052231,
-0.3639233112,
0.9571927786,
-0.2116013169,
-0.118493408,
-0.1479546428,
-0.2529008389,
0.4610972404,
0.4925259352,
0.056829311,
-0.3644232154,
-0.0852274224,
0.2630251646,
-0.951597333,
-0.238936305,
-0.1958154887,
-0.1356185377,
0.1814500839,
0.5131655931,
-0.6662576795,
0.2890771627,
0.6201071143,
-0.2879152,
0.3026064634,
-0.2427652329,
-0.0280219577,
-1.0377877951,
0.2366866022,
0.0641138628,
-0.0332345665,
-1.0040394068,
-0.0943375602,
0.1126813143,
0.0807222202,
-0.1975561529,
0.2914823294,
-0.7219132781,
-0.1155909002,
-0.515566349,
0.1004908457,
0.0139733339,
0.2643356323,
0.2990897298,
0.4304038584,
0.9008589983,
-0.2446631789,
0.1830601543,
0.4251369238,
-0.1444507241,
0.6781502962,
-0.9115130901,
0.2453604937,
-0.3491007388,
0.4076539576,
-1.000996232,
-0.0424880236,
-0.0291666258,
-0.7890885472,
0.5548825264,
-0.0718393475,
-0.3382132947,
-0.1537176818,
-0.0950109661,
0.4121690094,
0.7950760126,
-0.9062954783,
0.7965646386,
0.5681576133,
-0.2783539891,
-0.5194637775,
-1.0641664267,
0.7297083735,
-0.0318127461,
-0.9561079144,
0.3334950805,
-0.051830858,
-0.028951969,
-0.3082835674,
0.0666029677,
-0.1747093946,
-0.1164188236,
-0.0986118913,
0.0963227302,
-0.0500929318,
-0.2812716067,
0.5305863023,
-0.060660556,
0.5126924515,
-0.6807932258,
0.6392828822,
0.2673145831,
-0.3552120328,
-0.6576849222,
0.5909088254,
0.7037058473,
-0.1542598903,
0.5132907629,
0.5030487776,
-0.9408596754,
-0.1721302122,
-0.5013999343,
-0.1911805868,
-0.4899156988,
1.0500730276,
-0.5396202803,
-0.7925031781,
0.6241365671,
-0.4151735902,
0.0615977645,
-0.0602976903,
0.4725331068,
-0.0956434831,
1.1732022762,
0.4154101908,
-0.0175316129,
0.1011743695,
-0.0612953827,
0.3722906411,
-1.3634659052,
-0.5228379965,
-0.1690668911,
-0.131068334,
-0.0444086008,
-0.4389258623,
0.2800671756,
0.3742325306,
-0.1920797676,
0.246049732,
-0.5338670611,
0.331444025,
-0.0605419502,
0.359644413,
0.0542368293,
0.3332667649,
0.224930957,
-0.0792048201,
-0.5700968504,
-0.3311577439,
1.0182754993,
0.7526509166,
0.5416718721,
0.4159995914,
0.2835813165,
0.2235623449,
0.1536854506,
-0.8425477743,
0.6313478947,
-0.138671279,
-0.3383015394,
-0.3245256841,
-0.1642463803,
-0.8817456961,
0.1369277835,
0.0425634682,
-1.1429479122,
0.5811548829,
-0.0471258201,
-0.2879991829,
0.4360398054,
-0.5288597345,
0.4426430762,
-0.0821011439,
-0.7469301224,
-0.4624587893,
-0.6819723248,
0.417614311,
-0.1243689954,
0.2903134227,
0.339559257,
-0.4484777749,
0.8761655688,
-0.0279024169,
0.8426718116,
-0.2385670245,
-0.5699259639,
0.336263746,
-0.0064298324,
0.6650506854,
-0.0756779388,
-0.221185267,
0.4933539927,
-0.1138390675,
-0.3059482276,
-0.6616849303,
0.7943887115,
-0.5977759957,
-0.367135942,
-0.0205824953,
-0.3488112092,
-0.3621026576,
0.0277492963,
-0.0310977791,
0.6427118182,
-0.0789414123,
0.2741805911,
1.1173866987,
-0.3893992007,
0.6871337891,
0.5430375934,
0.1136722267,
-0.8206956387,
0.9784949422,
0.0729748905,
0.2821353972,
0.5531987548,
-0.2467414439,
-0.6769705415,
-1.0612419844,
-0.5637876987,
0.4224968553,
-0.8326275349,
-0.0310531463,
-0.7077603936,
-0.1781122833,
-0.3845570982,
-0.091681838,
-0.2304439545,
-0.0857103467,
-0.3869045079,
-0.3087522984,
0.0874678567,
0.6355519891,
-0.4158321321,
0.4788010716,
-0.6241545677,
0.1036946326,
-0.014908432,
0.5644906759,
0.1077883095,
-0.8595838547,
-0.3931076527,
0.1815414727,
0.1348257363,
-1.2468761206,
0.3727956414,
0.0293718409,
0.5490595698,
0.3795092702,
-0.3119255304,
0.5717715621,
-0.6550638676,
0.7548356056,
0.6547673345,
-1.0611298084,
0.1362316459,
-0.4514785707,
0.3890181482,
0.0424367413,
0.2070942968,
-0.7531041503,
0.1831506342,
-0.1832576841,
-1.1010652781,
0.5011839867,
-0.1840268821,
0.0549074933,
-0.1903749257,
0.5946793556,
-0.1210175678,
-0.1009312421,
-0.5960976481,
-0.0703778341,
0.2252576202,
-0.5015913248,
0.2192216069,
-0.5588285923,
-0.1389154047,
-0.1558455825,
0.4056530297,
-0.1343251914,
0.638371408,
0.1738773435,
-0.1295765042,
0.0923973322,
0.278421998,
0.4481116533,
0.5081753731,
0.1223136783,
-0.0423049442,
0.5076489449,
-0.3122246861,
0.1178973392,
0.0405839458,
0.0399457626,
-0.1406538337,
0.3078432381,
0.8821427822,
0.0015833939,
-0.646958828,
0.6017225981,
0.2059300095,
-0.3306575119,
-0.5065045357,
-0.4981414378,
0.4627129436,
0.2147420049,
0.3809452951,
-0.1018484533,
0.3889166713,
-0.3590878248,
0.4359696507,
0.659261167,
-0.2496415228,
-0.5754832625,
0.8081929684,
0.2949497402,
-0.4116346836,
0.6039017439,
0.1801066995,
-0.1405842006,
0.5310590863,
0.9178104997,
0.9564239383,
-0.200512737,
-0.2106652558,
0.3762732744,
0.4167197347,
-0.0138103981,
0.4683295786,
0.1053175852,
-0.4449742734,
-1.0698952675,
-0.6659954786,
0.0153630422,
0.1698958278,
-0.4632941484,
0.4987611175,
-0.4961217344,
0.0000723909,
-0.2445704788,
-0.7270858288,
-0.090065375,
0.305457294,
0.6281292439,
1.1731790304,
-0.6149511933,
0.7960808873,
0.2623430789,
0.0507141463,
-0.454295814,
-0.329560101,
-0.1830316484,
-0.6036881804,
0.3192131817,
-0.0032763905,
-0.3436301947,
0.3761354983,
-0.4048219025,
-0.9037803411,
1.0323591232,
0.5871129632,
-0.8124548793,
-0.2398122996,
0.2562001646,
0.4563579857,
-0.2212087959,
0.8359534144,
0.7816703916,
0.5016499162,
-0.1144929603,
-0.7916930318,
0.2088638693,
-0.1538546979,
0.0511952005,
0.1365353912,
-0.3745559156,
0.1683967412,
-0.2292708009,
-0.271830827,
0.1377177089,
0.9302703142,
-0.0408872738,
0.0433824025,
0.3136523664,
0.4611465931,
0.4501995742,
-0.0543843247,
0.581105113,
-0.511344254,
-0.0741168186,
0.8875356317,
-0.0488532111,
1.027017355,
0.5488212705,
-0.1797997355,
0.4073192477,
0.6208674312,
0.3118275702,
0.3667491972,
0.3835345805,
-0.5129020214,
-0.2347300798,
-0.1827284545,
-0.2518442869,
0.3202423155,
0.8301592469,
-0.2514114082,
-0.2007041126,
0.2750088871,
-0.0353849567,
0.1755052358,
-0.2846146822,
0.7204456925,
0.2382262647,
-0.511998713,
0.737247169,
0.0843070596,
0.8669823408,
-0.853266418,
-0.0929317102,
-0.0609637052,
0.0449156761,
-0.4501683712,
-0.7015686035,
0.4362136722,
-0.3953206837,
-0.2050561309,
0.0828092843,
0.4423997104,
-0.6172292829,
0.0986422151,
0.761693418,
0.3514660895,
0.1882212013,
0.0575065129,
-0.309417516,
0.4605521858,
0.1547608525,
-0.2560349703,
0.3647626638,
-0.0278419424,
-0.0032808881,
0.5867248774,
0.7661809325,
0.1473637968,
0.0989901647,
0.2271800637,
0.6627548933,
-0.5683328509,
-0.5178948045,
-0.9710389376,
0.6468610764,
-0.076453425,
0.0416554101,
0.3033974767,
0.6637694836,
0.2772974372,
0.1170233861,
0.7826691866,
-0.0364624709,
0.3520877063,
-0.3751929402,
0.5823270679,
-0.3564464152,
0.2989871204,
0.0154322144,
-0.6845094562,
-0.395661056,
0.3173841238,
-0.0280810744,
-0.0080764219,
0.6056020856,
1.0822069645,
0.1548429579,
0.2550570965,
0.5612358451,
0.5088441372,
0.5054056048,
1.036819458,
0.6504678726,
-0.2582799196,
0.5255774856,
0.3746462166,
-0.8650233746,
0.2283048481,
-0.5457150936,
-0.4187884927,
-0.3224725127,
-0.3329775333,
-0.3234543204,
0.3443537056,
0.7701805234,
0.5803880095,
-0.55054456,
-0.3354821205,
-0.4681550264,
-0.3119986057,
-0.2228581309,
-0.1106137037,
0.4127884507,
-0.1009155363,
-0.9812873006,
0.7342230082,
0.482404083,
0.0236426741,
-0.4122973084,
-0.2706473172,
-0.1262955815,
0.1740558296,
0.9433069229,
0.4963600039,
-0.69449687,
-0.1180629134,
0.1392182261,
0.2087508738,
-0.1920147091,
0.3613567054,
-0.7238965034,
0.346926719,
0.5720614791,
0.9016851783,
0.3378687799,
-0.3498291373,
0.8771902323,
-0.1483748853,
0.0404778756,
0.1047802791,
0.5579519868,
0.3236415088,
-0.4398667216,
0.214334622,
0.0892666578,
-0.4989328682,
-0.9005284905,
0.4558627009,
-1.179766655,
-0.4135198891,
1.3122217655,
-0.1579738259,
-0.5121439099,
-0.3207327127,
-0.2193230838,
0.2856049538,
-0.0498068035,
0.3930022717,
0.6410253644,
-0.1821669191,
-0.3583295643,
-0.3442662656,
0.0743889287,
0.6119395494,
-0.7929463387,
0.3028623164,
0.7022900581,
0.3408272564,
-0.0486462079,
0.4972725213,
-0.3398367167,
0.4850244224,
0.0779985636,
0.2934546769,
-0.2966122925,
-0.232072711,
-0.8291292191,
0.274409622,
-0.0102855871,
-0.1701066941
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11566v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11566v1 | MEMLA: Enhancing Multilingual Knowledge Editing with Neuron-Masked Low-Rank Adaptation | 2024-06-17T14:03:50 | 2024-06-17T14:03:50 | Jiakuan Xie, Pengfei Cao, Yuheng Chen, Yubo Chen, Kang Liu, Jun Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL | Knowledge editing aims to adjust the knowledge within large language models
(LLMs) to prevent their responses from becoming obsolete or inaccurate.
However, existing works on knowledge editing are primarily conducted in a
single language, which is inadequate for multilingual language models. In this
paper, we focus on multilingual knowledge editing (MKE), which requires
propagating updates across multiple languages. This necessity poses a
significant challenge for the task. Furthermore, the limited availability of a
comprehensive dataset for MKE exacerbates this challenge, hindering progress in
this area. Hence, we introduce the Multilingual Knowledge Editing Benchmark
(MKEB), a novel dataset comprising 12 languages and providing a complete
evaluation framework. Additionally, we propose a method that enhances
Multilingual knowledge Editing with neuron-Masked Low-Rank Adaptation (MEMLA).
Specifically, we identify two categories of knowledge neurons to improve
editing precision. Moreover, we perform LoRA-based editing with neuron masks to
efficiently modify parameters and facilitate the propagation of updates across
multiple languages. Experiments demonstrate that our method outperforms
existing baselines and significantly enhances the multi-hop reasoning
capability of the edited model, with minimal impact on its downstream task
performance. The dataset and code will be made publicly available. | [
-0.2557899952,
-0.6897227168,
0.2606095076,
0.312250942,
-0.0447542071,
0.2697972655,
-0.4950047135,
-0.43188411,
0.4228584766,
0.2662759721,
-0.3006095886,
-0.672172606,
-0.7317180037,
0.0969043225,
0.1792617887,
0.6767058969,
-0.0111471266,
0.2105629146,
-0.1821484715,
-0.4973761439,
-0.7939157486,
-0.5090163946,
-0.7049924135,
-0.310765326,
0.7762749791,
0.4619479179,
0.5632215738,
0.2176754028,
0.1219009012,
0.2839349508,
-0.3851418495,
0.5528861284,
-0.1308438182,
0.0714422017,
-0.3294785619,
-0.3702916801,
-0.9611204863,
-0.2334093302,
0.67990762,
0.6745358706,
-0.1136914566,
0.1641319245,
0.0597785152,
0.6390524507,
-0.8810355663,
0.0196677223,
-0.6812713146,
-0.0744488165,
-0.1098719165,
0.1118060946,
-0.4904629886,
-0.2176642567,
-0.3043784797,
-0.8344584107,
-0.2742046416,
-0.2327647358,
0.3667550385,
0.2346617132,
-0.1874499619,
0.1861417592,
-0.2924161851,
0.4632869661,
-0.9296575189,
0.4364686012,
0.3788149059,
0.2246491909,
-0.0713169351,
-0.41370821,
-0.6023565531,
0.032794252,
-0.0111265974,
-0.0468666628,
-0.2841918766,
-0.0879242867,
0.4223813713,
-0.223214969,
-0.3860132396,
0.1387230605,
-0.1565519422,
-0.3141977489,
0.2938189805,
-0.167697683,
0.2670615017,
-0.2566130459,
-0.040151827,
-0.1993068457,
-0.7297872305,
-0.0607803538,
0.4533387423,
0.0930591598,
0.0498135015,
0.4020107388,
-0.4776214361,
0.8394615054,
-0.2094703466,
-0.2710648477,
0.359280318,
-0.1321077347,
-0.1981780529,
0.1390114725,
0.5253712535,
0.4166603386,
0.0974087566,
-0.2420061678,
-0.0846594274,
-0.2845104337,
0.0844191834,
-0.778806746,
-0.1591107249,
-0.1126417518,
-0.3300485015,
-0.2116360813,
-0.5124127865,
-0.9084130526,
-0.6586695313,
-0.1964706033,
0.6016759276,
-0.4304257333,
-0.1165933236,
0.3002876937,
-0.0543312319,
-0.2011483163,
0.628156364,
-0.8997338414,
0.1014976129,
0.2980356216,
0.6254405975,
0.1114052683,
-0.863571465,
-0.4224219322,
0.351052165,
-0.4160471559,
0.8096169233,
-0.4859772921,
0.085192956,
-0.2526896298,
-0.0970240906,
-0.2375971377,
-0.5432143211,
0.2139322609,
-0.8310866356,
-0.1435661465,
-0.2066347599,
-0.3330861628,
-0.3817414343,
0.5083735585,
-0.5369439721,
0.8762040734,
-0.0606778748,
-0.4305435717,
0.3310114443,
-0.929166317,
-0.5436144471,
-0.3504248261,
0.0837565139,
-0.2196146548,
-0.0536318384,
0.73881495,
0.329349637,
-0.0975459814,
0.3891662359,
-0.1600167304,
-0.0724046156,
0.3279396892,
-0.4575943053,
0.6404163241,
-0.1238105819,
-0.1498235464,
0.1916177571,
-0.8307074308,
0.0202732291,
-0.1974575371,
-0.3156878054,
-0.3923894167,
-0.2053089738,
-0.0589458421,
0.3559569716,
0.2741716206,
-0.4841291308,
0.5779691935,
0.0333847068,
0.4593884349,
0.9670431614,
0.1767115742,
0.529509306,
-0.1256309301,
0.3276877999,
0.2791825831,
0.3761407435,
0.0197186694,
-0.6293387413,
-0.595128715,
-0.1739217043,
0.7594347596,
0.5532926321,
-1.1623117924,
0.0224663597,
-0.522579968,
-0.5155252814,
-0.7485354543,
0.5374403,
0.2670174837,
0.4432168305,
0.6592034698,
-0.1413559318,
-0.185648188,
-0.9416756034,
-0.4533300102,
0.16146788,
0.1201350316,
0.1846564263,
0.3011173904,
-0.2272844911,
0.603623867,
-0.432564199,
-0.4203859568,
-0.0471196808,
0.2062831074,
0.3493580818,
0.765325129,
0.5055713654,
-0.4873532057,
-0.4062153399,
0.172575742,
-0.8299608231,
-0.0798798352,
-0.2528826594,
-0.2920036316,
0.1067092717,
0.6594178081,
-0.5113526583,
0.2788291574,
0.6915901899,
-0.2159295827,
0.3667888939,
-0.4566266537,
0.5062158108,
-1.17965734,
-0.0343770348,
-0.4031935036,
-0.0110658435,
-0.692669332,
-0.0513660759,
0.5271997452,
-0.1362276673,
-0.4251519144,
0.6629981995,
-0.4060389996,
0.0371650457,
-0.1395568848,
0.1708921492,
0.1584471613,
0.8772365451,
-0.1107920185,
0.6955739856,
0.4272252619,
-0.3432726562,
0.0485170707,
0.4455367625,
-0.656994462,
0.5158933997,
-0.2650189698,
0.3319437802,
0.0370752551,
-0.0420036055,
-0.3992564976,
-0.0476725288,
0.1922524124,
-0.4321386218,
0.4909797311,
-0.1920528561,
-0.7670143247,
0.2597274184,
-0.2079900801,
0.632941246,
0.0904066265,
-0.580298245,
0.6998818517,
0.3016621172,
-0.2543355525,
-1.0007042885,
-0.7108219266,
0.5780524015,
0.1538849175,
-0.718988955,
0.4396221042,
-0.1478581578,
-0.229256615,
-0.0412131883,
-0.1535280645,
-0.0918375701,
-0.0081251841,
-0.2538531125,
0.1092819646,
-0.2520479262,
0.2126355618,
0.5159866214,
-0.1721570194,
-0.2695193291,
-0.1096652225,
0.2604296505,
0.2022095621,
-0.3605603874,
-0.2380321473,
0.1218510121,
0.4972240329,
-0.4647310674,
0.7381514311,
0.514171958,
-0.5252268314,
-0.3572946191,
-0.6776329279,
-0.2423132956,
-0.3850264847,
0.5165814757,
-0.591006875,
-0.8068577051,
0.5687926412,
-0.2481286973,
-0.2148442864,
0.3156967759,
0.2206175178,
0.1222004294,
0.5987863541,
0.5083095431,
-0.2384306788,
0.2909549773,
-0.0181324501,
0.163077876,
-1.1529377699,
-0.1688758582,
-0.4428039789,
-0.6659686565,
-0.4168745279,
-0.8174974322,
0.5641516447,
0.448484838,
0.1013451889,
0.3380037844,
-0.3438336253,
0.7127717733,
0.5462910533,
0.3862920702,
0.5480061173,
-0.0943060592,
-0.2297199667,
-0.2162234634,
-0.9021359086,
-0.2111528963,
1.0799583197,
0.0577596389,
0.647379458,
0.3245666921,
0.2357136756,
0.4219102263,
0.4040008485,
-0.3786760867,
0.431669414,
-0.2608520091,
-0.537124753,
-0.2966147363,
-0.2451198846,
-0.3888993859,
0.5308825374,
-0.4151431322,
-0.6773612499,
0.6031326056,
0.0084188618,
-0.1878297329,
0.7108219266,
-0.8174085617,
1.1560497284,
-0.079292208,
-0.4633513987,
-0.460782975,
-0.5470855236,
0.1734889001,
-0.2316596359,
0.306920439,
-0.1869584769,
0.0239990782,
0.7069242597,
-0.1856660396,
0.8144139647,
-0.3302237689,
0.0466786623,
-0.1133090481,
0.1116220355,
0.6238027811,
0.2843408883,
-0.3351040483,
0.5070638657,
-0.2776152194,
-0.4500437379,
-0.7924389243,
0.6884356141,
-0.6699870825,
-0.4205653071,
-0.2330237031,
-0.8218480945,
-0.5498078465,
0.257992208,
-0.0734011754,
0.4904387891,
-0.1506999731,
0.0584109537,
0.5704923868,
-0.5471538901,
0.4721530974,
0.5342800021,
-0.2426672131,
-0.734054029,
0.7904497981,
0.3018949926,
0.3102038503,
0.488283664,
-0.0852265805,
-0.0036024323,
-0.7748368979,
-0.9571338892,
0.102663517,
-1.1881356239,
-0.2915837765,
-0.7718575001,
-0.0699080825,
-0.4309995174,
-0.2884881794,
-0.2396777868,
-0.621506989,
0.1148505434,
0.0776409805,
0.4703418612,
0.668014586,
-0.3380567431,
0.2884519994,
-0.6138454676,
0.5988094807,
0.4308786988,
0.520362854,
0.0521845333,
-0.4807550609,
-0.4100399017,
0.0552332178,
-0.0642598346,
-0.8550319076,
0.1443660408,
0.208651647,
0.6106294394,
-0.1113265529,
-0.2211860269,
0.8787702322,
-0.6232093573,
0.4405458272,
0.0800817758,
-1.1834617853,
0.3872736394,
-0.152652517,
0.4653938115,
0.5980125666,
-0.0209286641,
-0.9045411348,
-0.210624069,
-0.3266449869,
-0.5058657527,
0.7747209668,
0.0388559587,
0.1153405011,
0.2022843957,
0.3120339811,
0.0890217945,
0.3435057104,
-0.7754887342,
-0.3051970601,
-0.2713599205,
0.1790609956,
-0.2790901959,
-0.3656829298,
0.0147958361,
-0.5430284739,
0.9833254218,
-0.4013004601,
0.0634877682,
0.2066825926,
-0.6633986831,
0.0811367482,
0.5399538875,
0.9541898966,
0.8218553066,
-0.2259624153,
0.1533768773,
0.635201931,
-0.4901761413,
0.1029416397,
0.076999329,
-0.2966665924,
0.0523841567,
0.2333438396,
0.8047170639,
0.469501406,
-0.363358736,
0.339550972,
0.0086975098,
-0.1365655065,
0.2949124575,
-0.2187112868,
0.2945749462,
0.22025235,
0.1350193024,
0.7219346166,
-0.1079000905,
-0.0078430781,
0.0445015505,
0.1099203378,
-0.179096058,
-0.1298304349,
0.6254152656,
0.008895495,
-0.1293275356,
0.4339419901,
-0.2086949944,
-0.2744014859,
0.4244196117,
0.437915504,
0.7502143979,
-0.3647759259,
0.1788626462,
0.5006771088,
0.8335658908,
0.2189809084,
0.0433368422,
0.1636061966,
-0.8886658549,
-0.7614118457,
-0.5547910929,
-0.5002889037,
0.1494873911,
-0.3203744292,
0.3625041544,
-0.3827427328,
0.1765396297,
0.2568660676,
-0.5233657956,
-0.3285961449,
0.0422162525,
-0.0558911934,
1.1125233173,
-0.5517730117,
1.2368290424,
0.7072531581,
-0.2437771708,
-0.3900470436,
-0.2253063917,
-0.1877162606,
-0.6889890432,
0.2992634177,
-0.0122893518,
-0.0268699601,
-0.0203485452,
-0.29800421,
-0.6766495705,
0.989436388,
0.7047443986,
-0.3064451814,
0.202972725,
0.2273127139,
0.427211076,
-0.2042437643,
0.0467106849,
0.3244484365,
0.7371467352,
-0.2799596786,
-0.7951554656,
-0.12873514,
-0.3791389763,
-0.1092086062,
0.1774412543,
-0.453087002,
0.7947113514,
-0.0630315095,
0.5205976367,
-0.1638388783,
0.2980895042,
-0.1389079839,
0.0369519368,
0.2894996107,
0.7597501278,
0.7582333088,
0.0524415746,
0.6922700405,
-0.3015922904,
0.0565377437,
1.4542015791,
-0.2582396865,
0.9398121238,
0.5550749302,
0.164386645,
0.5269191861,
0.4182820022,
0.0262015704,
0.5061230063,
-0.0245124865,
-0.3656941056,
-0.2847383916,
-0.0593840927,
-0.3179373443,
0.5658953786,
0.2066533864,
-0.145124346,
-0.3048422635,
0.254393518,
0.3244440854,
0.0906945318,
-0.4615006149,
0.8766246438,
-0.0885975957,
-0.5972443819,
0.5551940203,
0.3066896796,
0.5987167358,
-0.580018878,
-0.1690804362,
-0.2676557004,
0.2292934954,
-0.1256703138,
-0.5071194172,
0.2290994227,
-0.0328010991,
-0.3860475123,
-0.2755636573,
0.9046401978,
-0.4976240396,
-0.50195086,
0.5540231466,
0.8002429605,
-0.1017534211,
-0.3758799434,
-0.7833247781,
-0.0675468817,
-0.0629647449,
-0.1610788405,
0.5464169979,
0.2770324945,
-0.2044916004,
0.4742521048,
0.7671052217,
0.188090086,
0.2227381766,
0.2216028571,
0.7817680836,
-0.692850709,
-0.2753215432,
-0.7533662319,
0.5272830129,
-0.2040214539,
-0.3526737392,
0.6055138707,
0.5266724825,
0.8305092454,
-0.3337421417,
0.6999108195,
-0.1214739829,
0.2105751485,
-0.741684258,
1.2613557577,
-0.5482640862,
0.0376000665,
-0.2528571188,
-0.9818701744,
-0.5586071014,
0.327580601,
-0.3093640506,
-0.1582054198,
0.8147139549,
1.0868856907,
-0.1502507627,
-0.1383594275,
0.6524014473,
0.479860872,
0.0393345803,
0.57421422,
0.6529676914,
-0.6854526401,
0.2451591343,
-0.7022292018,
0.0131322425,
0.0524566844,
-1.0124300718,
-0.8741589785,
-0.393080622,
-0.3133381307,
-0.1773094684,
0.2496632785,
0.8669621348,
0.6908023953,
-0.8502745628,
-0.1690289229,
0.2615858912,
0.525272429,
-0.6246696711,
-0.0454842672,
0.5148934126,
-0.419914335,
-0.7012721896,
0.7956156135,
0.4784177542,
-0.3166207969,
0.1477921754,
-0.1437063515,
-0.6478483677,
-0.1769169271,
0.713829577,
0.0221127793,
-0.4419929683,
-0.2343489528,
0.0139491251,
0.0277757365,
0.3107162714,
0.6016619205,
-0.556682229,
0.8852042556,
0.2734365165,
0.8378349543,
0.3504951298,
-0.4399996996,
0.2674159408,
-0.9646738172,
0.2331751138,
-0.0519287512,
0.5482917428,
0.4605624378,
-0.0998630598,
0.48874107,
0.2735582292,
-0.4286053479,
-0.5762912035,
-0.2340707928,
-0.9416068196,
-0.3261816204,
0.9967327714,
-0.0738445446,
-0.1883546859,
-0.0822352096,
-0.2814166844,
0.2141246647,
-0.1839342415,
0.7080065012,
0.8869801164,
0.1556231827,
-0.2248638719,
-0.8249313831,
0.4989369512,
0.5534814596,
-1.1198072433,
0.0458014533,
0.5497264266,
0.2101188898,
0.2224832922,
0.450352937,
-0.1008788273,
0.717926383,
-0.0597461797,
0.6439788342,
-0.1852737367,
-0.4356009662,
-0.5821700096,
0.1649511158,
0.2673939466,
-0.0176897105
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11565v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11565v2 | Extrinsic Evaluation of Cultural Competence in Large Language Models | 2024-06-17T14:03:27 | 2024-06-19T05:18:56 | Shaily Bhatt, Fernando Diaz | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CY | Productive interactions between diverse users and language technologies
require outputs from the latter to be culturally relevant and sensitive. Prior
works have evaluated models' knowledge of cultural norms, values, and
artifacts, without considering how this knowledge manifests in downstream
applications. In this work, we focus on extrinsic evaluation of cultural
competence in two text generation tasks, open-ended question answering and
story generation. We quantitatively and qualitatively evaluate model outputs
when an explicit cue of culture, specifically nationality, is perturbed in the
prompts. Although we find that model outputs do vary when varying nationalities
and feature culturally relevant words, we also find weak correlations between
text similarity of outputs for different countries and the cultural values of
these countries. Finally, we discuss important considerations in designing
comprehensive evaluation of cultural competence in user-facing tasks. | [
-0.2968377769,
-0.581612885,
0.2712458074,
0.042359449,
-0.1797108501,
0.0406009108,
-0.7561398149,
-0.5124329925,
-0.0304351021,
0.4094307721,
-0.4837550223,
-0.2512561679,
-0.2312271148,
0.1513921022,
-0.2932722867,
1.2373911142,
-0.2990559638,
-0.3189746439,
-0.4485955238,
-0.3407194316,
-0.4944081306,
-0.6841112971,
-0.6496458054,
-0.1796375662,
0.2674072981,
0.5218244791,
0.6730161309,
0.1834948659,
0.3445889354,
0.2531660199,
-0.1380724609,
-0.0167170055,
-0.6359100342,
0.6441255212,
-0.3858291209,
-0.2280017436,
0.0320946202,
0.0813713148,
0.3426378369,
0.5226610899,
0.2692895234,
0.6845322251,
0.1151195765,
0.390009135,
-0.4406514168,
0.0435404293,
-0.3223479688,
0.1164145991,
0.0690760687,
-0.4334501624,
-0.4617253542,
-0.5320906639,
0.2902901471,
-0.3020006716,
0.0966924056,
-0.4135218263,
0.7414138913,
-0.0555150025,
-0.9188081622,
-0.686242938,
-1.0322993994,
0.7387003303,
-0.5005366206,
0.1874324977,
0.2426495403,
0.3126596808,
0.2235772461,
-0.7568572164,
-0.5941368341,
-0.4885471761,
0.0556934997,
0.3849240541,
-0.0025504727,
-0.4201520383,
0.4543478191,
0.4378549457,
-0.5841004252,
0.2437291741,
-0.4606951475,
-0.0481411405,
0.6734471917,
0.2972721457,
0.6004544497,
-0.1646685451,
-0.1997326314,
-0.2208778113,
-0.5654048324,
0.6122828126,
0.8340579271,
0.3314875662,
-0.3498446643,
0.5963802934,
-0.4023292661,
0.6200660467,
-0.2315890789,
0.0272508301,
0.1772648543,
-0.6896187067,
0.2751578987,
-0.2463580817,
0.5788800716,
0.6302186847,
0.65251863,
-0.0060854806,
0.052105628,
-0.1590145677,
0.1742932647,
-0.8072471023,
0.1303123683,
0.3352173567,
-0.4790004194,
-0.1002468318,
0.2395864278,
-0.5382563472,
-0.4372474551,
-0.1725742072,
0.2318489552,
-0.2493738383,
-0.3981609643,
-0.2446184307,
-0.2895657122,
0.1066762283,
0.1706066281,
-1.0082440376,
-0.0527578667,
0.3897553384,
0.5170589685,
-0.2177634984,
-0.1783285588,
-0.3591236472,
-0.1962724924,
-0.4205701053,
0.3380536735,
-0.5782731175,
-0.3856751621,
0.2298483104,
-0.0498828478,
0.0781364292,
-0.4215886295,
0.8076928258,
-0.5725924373,
0.3696618676,
-0.5730057359,
-0.0317461714,
-0.2907078564,
0.1100085229,
-0.752168715,
0.8146362901,
0.4178783,
-0.7892647386,
0.6712613702,
-0.4126764834,
-0.5584638119,
0.265275836,
-0.0498899035,
0.1888037622,
0.2874034345,
-0.1271562129,
0.3026535809,
-0.3451713026,
0.2454729229,
0.0505849198,
-0.2779634595,
0.6015715003,
-0.3382032514,
0.8388910294,
0.3045192659,
-0.2576317787,
0.1804723591,
-0.7532565594,
0.250559181,
0.0947579518,
-0.5189027786,
-0.4919476807,
-0.0882755667,
0.0173765495,
0.5744858384,
0.3310525715,
-0.6473456025,
-0.279872179,
-0.2404911816,
0.5516104698,
0.3876082003,
0.0832764879,
0.3214614391,
-0.2882056534,
0.7702614069,
-0.0561935753,
-0.1361258328,
-0.4833654761,
-0.4792587757,
-0.4836670458,
0.1524659693,
0.0440989435,
0.5062192082,
-1.1340098381,
0.0461438075,
-0.1012104973,
-0.8095321655,
-0.1175971478,
0.0465036184,
0.3537759185,
0.5331996083,
-0.1179835945,
-0.6050574183,
-0.3931522369,
-0.689324677,
-0.5263459086,
-0.461309135,
-0.0768819898,
0.508292377,
0.5001877546,
0.4444248974,
0.8793307543,
-0.167879805,
0.1593727171,
-0.2186017334,
0.3812566996,
0.2205804139,
0.41465801,
0.4815911651,
-0.8646201491,
-0.7016601562,
0.3807088137,
-0.7733008265,
-0.1906037033,
-0.1451685727,
0.0159352496,
0.5634302497,
0.2993083596,
-0.3206999004,
0.1789942384,
0.7433831096,
-0.6011142135,
0.6386271119,
-0.2282989025,
0.6713136435,
-0.9492096901,
0.3564741313,
-0.0843783095,
0.181394875,
-0.9300140142,
0.2755818367,
0.0998356491,
-0.3111226261,
-0.4123064578,
0.7840730548,
-0.2090173513,
0.0849753469,
0.0228327643,
0.1813802719,
0.0921119303,
0.1381364316,
0.4295056164,
0.6812785864,
-0.0312551297,
-0.3409206569,
0.4724514484,
0.1863073558,
-0.7700386643,
0.7561820149,
-0.5604419112,
0.2873163521,
-0.0287215263,
-0.0055293697,
-1.2309231758,
-0.2716590762,
-0.0942627788,
-0.7026198506,
-0.0760793984,
0.0528016128,
-0.5139075518,
-0.6453544497,
-0.1097525284,
0.6482198834,
0.525416553,
-0.1638988107,
0.2083691955,
-0.0361517966,
-0.5640949607,
-0.4267715514,
-0.6763846278,
-0.1337536275,
-0.4010640383,
-0.8654954433,
-0.1119366363,
-0.1809247732,
-0.3748549521,
-0.1863187999,
0.1808307618,
-0.1309929937,
0.1925679594,
0.0727864355,
-0.0591005124,
-0.3293438852,
0.158085078,
0.2095970511,
0.2456395924,
0.1803697795,
-0.1874411851,
0.5232092142,
0.0148539757,
-0.3936225176,
0.0673064068,
0.5262182951,
0.6502579451,
-0.6892994046,
0.8033354282,
0.619281888,
-0.290086627,
0.0867805704,
-0.4112937152,
-0.1215798482,
-0.4132202268,
0.5827338696,
-0.4383308887,
-1.0975557566,
0.9548610449,
0.6026758552,
0.1231435984,
0.4874015749,
0.8913335204,
0.1519680172,
0.8160386682,
0.5657855868,
0.7172827721,
0.0757542849,
0.151570484,
0.3156687915,
-0.656159699,
-0.3604680896,
-0.6972937584,
-0.1633550823,
-0.6605497003,
-0.2516320944,
0.3832193911,
-0.227455005,
-0.4268669188,
0.2939960659,
-0.0704470947,
0.1818102449,
0.6781154871,
-0.1789047867,
0.4421718121,
0.022156518,
-0.1742162257,
-0.2212721556,
-0.6166746616,
-0.7055696845,
0.8529848456,
0.3917736411,
0.5849398971,
0.3104985654,
0.3165267706,
0.0819359049,
0.3303869367,
-0.624712646,
0.2479190677,
-0.3362774849,
-0.8406471014,
-0.4401881695,
-0.4014990926,
-0.5738334656,
-0.0222439785,
-0.2182055563,
-0.866977036,
-0.0074834758,
0.0723692179,
-0.5926971436,
0.1042241305,
-0.7717844844,
0.8429248333,
-0.2581499219,
-0.3415257037,
0.1104200482,
-0.5492823124,
0.4957481325,
-0.3123493791,
0.045272354,
0.1923176944,
0.0321943015,
0.8196794987,
0.2141799033,
0.7171795964,
-0.0689163506,
-0.3331134021,
0.5701247454,
0.4476165473,
-0.014479368,
-0.0777251348,
-0.4653768837,
-0.038755931,
0.3306694925,
-0.0504937805,
-0.5808504224,
0.5775026679,
-0.7689777017,
-0.6603891253,
0.0042004376,
-0.9348734617,
-0.2199031413,
0.0401335806,
0.4786942303,
0.4263091087,
-0.3285080492,
0.3308103979,
0.3493581712,
-0.7166320086,
0.3052821159,
0.4997528195,
-0.0892619863,
-0.0721610412,
0.6972270608,
0.4304684103,
0.5454137325,
0.0973786265,
0.1393097639,
-0.2830731869,
-0.2182402462,
-0.7767855525,
-0.0487035066,
-0.9918689132,
0.0664971918,
-0.4856564403,
-0.1985842437,
-0.2385106832,
-0.2050192952,
0.1256366074,
-0.3940593004,
-0.2400598377,
-0.100636825,
0.1205919087,
0.7597432733,
0.108504124,
0.1962458789,
-0.8208808303,
-0.0925601423,
0.1898972839,
0.1939348876,
0.1589515507,
-0.7275123,
-0.4293995798,
0.1185405552,
-0.1508813649,
-0.8892091513,
0.1496474445,
0.1062910631,
0.6283423305,
0.5241757035,
0.2779968381,
0.0808518976,
-0.2052090168,
1.2083399296,
0.0412186719,
-0.9769811034,
0.3011907935,
-0.4719229937,
0.5789983273,
0.5167298317,
0.643032074,
-1.1243544817,
-0.4892636538,
-0.3258607984,
-0.8968307376,
0.6905714869,
0.0120383818,
0.8504140377,
-0.2362962514,
0.0085097384,
0.5069965124,
0.3269274533,
-0.7004320621,
0.2471885234,
-0.1728846431,
-0.0520850196,
-0.0427693091,
-0.4511453509,
-0.1581038088,
0.1613793522,
0.4177776873,
-0.2070304304,
-0.0415551439,
0.0569254458,
-0.2335965931,
-0.2574346364,
0.3295403719,
0.636184454,
0.9922450781,
0.0891444981,
0.0107240872,
0.2922506928,
-0.2644359171,
0.2569677234,
-0.2025645971,
-0.2550840676,
-0.3065907657,
0.4056469798,
0.6361461878,
-0.2731432021,
-0.806204915,
0.3879460096,
-0.1760616601,
0.0930732489,
-0.2872174978,
-0.0141959405,
0.0072814003,
0.1283811182,
0.3947342634,
-0.2763647735,
-0.0868957862,
-0.7743201256,
0.0420650207,
0.4070957899,
-0.636652112,
-0.3523494601,
0.5781415701,
0.5116245747,
-0.2299474478,
0.886000514,
-0.1332952231,
-0.6000706553,
0.9063066244,
0.6139807701,
0.6842682958,
-0.4856059551,
0.3888168335,
0.5610487461,
0.4841009378,
0.4949711263,
0.5673827529,
0.0110329306,
-0.7385876179,
-0.7513400316,
-0.5411348939,
-0.2835631371,
-0.0835242495,
-0.843393445,
0.3028046191,
-0.1452465653,
-0.1579467505,
-0.4212759137,
-0.1665213406,
-0.7441389561,
0.5327769518,
0.2723433971,
0.9828144312,
-1.301431179,
0.2977036238,
0.8984145522,
-0.4118866324,
-0.6148700118,
-0.0093638739,
-0.1729274988,
-0.4681922197,
0.9308953285,
0.1476373374,
0.1886904389,
-0.1802177429,
-0.104528673,
-0.7042443752,
0.8683702946,
0.2610200346,
0.0790248141,
0.2078205347,
0.3081355095,
0.9000021815,
-0.4660791159,
0.748339653,
0.4934433699,
0.2630136609,
0.0455618575,
-1.0613055229,
0.2501132786,
-0.4285428822,
0.0723481625,
-0.1648941189,
-0.5599706173,
0.8795686364,
-0.3010284305,
-0.3872541785,
0.3789105415,
0.7730455399,
0.091640301,
0.1123135388,
0.4574908912,
0.1995649338,
0.6535422802,
-0.1942798197,
1.0117629766,
-0.3936687112,
0.039194759,
0.9931311011,
-0.4251742065,
0.6418418288,
0.2687980235,
0.1243153438,
0.6584452987,
0.7214127183,
0.1408687532,
0.090512529,
0.2854480743,
-0.2078804821,
0.0691205859,
-0.5344051123,
-0.3320549428,
0.7798258662,
0.0358810835,
-0.5920396447,
-0.1600686461,
0.1840887219,
0.1661662012,
0.3165869117,
-0.1729165018,
0.547503233,
-0.1522025913,
-1.1898342371,
0.3595059812,
0.0700165182,
0.2557005286,
-0.661614418,
0.0426620804,
-0.3543134034,
-0.3144942522,
-0.2801688612,
-1.226036787,
0.3834180534,
0.3428820074,
-0.2768152356,
-0.1375913769,
0.5800601244,
-0.5126786232,
-0.2205224782,
0.1206081584,
0.6699781418,
0.1256287247,
-0.0185951293,
-0.0679745823,
0.0588938072,
0.0197623484,
-0.422403872,
0.0677182525,
0.403398335,
-0.5186390281,
0.4652299285,
0.5114398003,
-0.0565544777,
-0.0820367262,
0.1284110248,
0.4707005918,
-0.3783369362,
-0.6290593743,
-0.5791988969,
0.8334028721,
0.0380166806,
-0.6133583188,
0.7068400979,
0.4109415412,
1.0468562841,
-0.2209865153,
1.0179134607,
-0.4432170093,
0.2476403564,
-0.3739415407,
0.8159808517,
-0.4103180766,
-0.1191262901,
-0.2483981699,
-1.0020982027,
0.1028027236,
0.2102446407,
-0.5824092031,
0.3924663961,
0.7996392846,
0.4512405396,
0.1345843673,
0.317435056,
0.4975688457,
0.115752168,
0.0778251439,
0.5513843894,
1.2181060314,
0.1134924963,
0.5041831136,
-0.3104645908,
-0.462880373,
0.2601152956,
-1.0230039358,
-0.6848002672,
-1.0477029085,
-0.2040755004,
-0.5272638798,
-0.239318952,
0.8109058142,
0.4204539955,
-0.7132502198,
-0.472002238,
0.7988085151,
-0.1711853445,
-0.2252149433,
-0.2510479093,
0.1679279804,
-0.0179947,
-0.7651445866,
-0.1750085652,
0.0522927493,
-0.0826031491,
-0.4479586184,
0.1594469398,
0.2451713383,
0.2116249949,
0.8447954655,
0.2809664905,
-0.3801583052,
-0.461430788,
0.1139445379,
-0.0241813548,
-0.3157114685,
0.9708641768,
-0.6007344723,
0.6513803005,
0.721095264,
0.3711680174,
0.1839805543,
0.1601894647,
0.7168751955,
-0.7026979923,
0.0654230192,
0.2170635164,
0.1313578784,
0.6561937332,
-0.3994190097,
0.3715403974,
-0.204801172,
-0.4985470176,
-0.6230831742,
0.4946481586,
-0.6289108992,
-0.0144592896,
1.3857465982,
-0.6761248112,
0.1147355288,
-0.1114930883,
-0.2413293868,
0.3811717927,
-0.0321546085,
0.5208048224,
1.0168945789,
0.1185430512,
-0.1136859059,
-0.768070817,
0.2290697992,
0.3977703154,
-0.6347732544,
0.0905593634,
0.3772923648,
0.1155873686,
0.2434330583,
0.4221456349,
-0.176831454,
0.3822533488,
-0.3043146431,
0.0166481268,
-0.0528937168,
-0.1678967625,
-0.3485894203,
0.1753388196,
0.4299380779,
0.4356697798
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11555v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11555v1 | Input Conditioned Graph Generation for Language Agents | 2024-06-17T13:53:15 | 2024-06-17T13:53:15 | Lukas Vierling, Jie Fu, Kai Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recent progress in Large Language Models (LLMs) and language agents has
demonstrated significant promise for various future applications across
multiple disciplines. While traditional approaches to language agents often
rely on fixed, handcrafted designs, our research aims to develop both learnable
and dynamic agents. Our method uses an existing framework that abstracts
language agents as graphs. Within this graph framework, we aim to learn a model
that can generate edges for every given input to the language agent. This
allows us to generate edges that represent the flow of communication within the
graph based on the given input, thereby adjusting the internal communication of
a language agent. We learn to generate these edges using a pretrained LLM that
is fine-tuned with reinforcement learning. This LLM can be fine-tuned on
several datasets simultaneously, and we hypothesize that the model learns to
adapt to these different domains during training, achieving good overall
performance when encountering data from different domains during deployment. We
demonstrate that our approach surpasses the previous static approach by nearly
6% accuracy on a combined dataset of MMLU and CMMLU, and by more than 10% when
trained with a sparsity-inducing loss. It also performs superior in additional
experiments conducted with the MMLU and Mini Crossword Puzzles datasets. The
code is available at https://github.com/lukasVierling/DynamicGPTSwarm. | [
-0.3377414644,
-1.0778068304,
0.5995106697,
0.0578847453,
-0.0833089799,
0.558447957,
-0.4715802073,
-0.2626728117,
0.211289227,
0.3686525226,
-0.7137770653,
-0.6329760551,
-0.5905055404,
0.1730796248,
-0.0322045013,
0.9587727189,
-0.1284141093,
-0.1890686154,
-0.2044687867,
-0.2465373874,
-0.2643229961,
-0.3185616434,
-0.9578147531,
-0.8042984605,
0.6462658048,
0.4617694318,
0.8890154362,
0.4964897633,
0.0662990212,
0.4608120024,
0.1582465023,
0.52876091,
-0.7768747807,
0.3943239748,
-0.1812712401,
-0.1765394062,
-0.4592242837,
-0.1531177908,
0.7515582442,
0.6316241026,
-0.2016073018,
-0.0710490346,
-0.0476084873,
0.3841633201,
-0.2488090396,
0.4888145328,
-0.8500078917,
0.0748913884,
-0.1683924645,
-0.4193340242,
-0.6047877669,
-0.2401700765,
-0.111713618,
-0.8284132481,
-0.0342133343,
-0.1968344152,
0.8284323812,
0.2735726535,
-0.5436152816,
-0.3999063671,
-0.7301589251,
0.3083936274,
-0.5398102999,
0.608944118,
0.0695695803,
0.4212564826,
-0.6261586547,
-1.0046957731,
-0.5398463607,
-0.4154931009,
0.0493101254,
-0.0064719901,
-0.1498114169,
0.1759920269,
0.2048459798,
-0.203665033,
-0.5861600041,
0.4136331975,
0.0003690073,
-0.1821705997,
0.504688561,
0.2587353587,
0.518384397,
0.3443575203,
0.0536829196,
-0.2872475386,
-0.8245363832,
0.1154309511,
0.5792859197,
0.6321510077,
-0.0680919811,
0.306427896,
-0.3430602551,
0.952111721,
0.2821679413,
-0.3043776751,
0.4221816361,
-0.0880438313,
0.1181820109,
-0.1708960086,
0.7442185283,
0.1023134217,
0.5693181157,
-0.2707212567,
-0.493242383,
-0.1122275144,
0.2218872309,
-0.8966967463,
-0.3499214947,
-0.0553688966,
0.0293646958,
-0.4193188548,
-0.3992356658,
-0.3600568473,
-0.4278197587,
-0.2506053746,
0.1705347449,
-0.4047287405,
-0.2555837035,
-0.0414198861,
0.0571933798,
0.0655725151,
0.2158177197,
-0.8026328087,
0.44345963,
0.2797686458,
0.5545070767,
-0.1704946756,
-0.4881745279,
-0.9031405449,
0.0249172729,
-0.385101527,
0.6781209707,
-0.7047543526,
-0.2874506712,
0.2231332511,
0.020852264,
-0.211618945,
-0.4091173112,
0.0039837612,
-0.868581593,
-0.0705159754,
0.1705633402,
-0.3186322749,
0.1721484661,
0.2628332973,
-0.561999321,
0.8596899509,
0.3313431442,
-0.5661951303,
0.2787869275,
-0.4901752472,
-0.6389473677,
0.2707285881,
-0.1804695725,
-0.4928283691,
-0.101141192,
0.2187812924,
0.2264626771,
0.0960393324,
0.2571868002,
-0.4783761203,
-0.1631989926,
0.4179742336,
-0.1017953008,
0.4489374161,
0.2092758119,
-0.2359508127,
0.3884088695,
-0.8921045065,
0.261972934,
0.3474294245,
-0.6178019047,
0.0548402891,
0.309585005,
-0.1339230537,
0.2723759115,
0.0619238392,
-0.4713816047,
0.2035452574,
-0.4941420853,
0.4085796475,
0.7691859603,
0.09339232,
0.2712362409,
0.0071902308,
0.7623022795,
-0.244504407,
-0.1776437312,
0.193938911,
-0.0642050803,
-0.7035682201,
-0.2223450691,
0.3048360944,
0.4910538495,
-1.4618558884,
0.3507246077,
-0.3164028525,
-0.4274810255,
-0.0557922758,
0.1690239161,
0.3678176999,
0.4126587212,
0.0712554157,
-0.1877925843,
-0.3963662386,
-0.5299058557,
-0.0314854234,
-0.0847423598,
0.1574109644,
0.4274747074,
0.2671192288,
-0.2916110158,
0.7957044244,
-0.6155193448,
0.0734435022,
-0.6113484502,
-0.0244361982,
0.0441122167,
0.2800842822,
0.5966967344,
-0.4152450562,
-0.6546054482,
0.008766057,
-0.6011919975,
-0.2271193415,
-0.0348322392,
-0.1701943278,
0.0515277199,
0.6957765818,
-0.4859669209,
0.1303405166,
0.6938019395,
-0.3626650572,
0.3204059005,
-0.3237946928,
-0.291572392,
-0.9604202509,
-0.1232454851,
-0.0530843325,
-0.6358990073,
-0.804345727,
0.0459968708,
-0.2458937317,
-0.4985002875,
-0.4602296352,
0.6048805118,
-0.5107622147,
0.0786079168,
-0.409802556,
0.312164247,
-0.1313423812,
0.7017452121,
0.1069469601,
0.6199166179,
0.5664462447,
-0.656645596,
0.5534094572,
0.1708497852,
-0.1199440658,
0.286044687,
-0.7889973521,
0.5160387754,
-0.0552056916,
0.5438786149,
-0.7446455359,
-0.0744080245,
0.3420040011,
-0.4834216535,
0.5555818081,
-0.0867662877,
-0.416354686,
-0.2991372347,
-0.0553274304,
0.3929600418,
0.4446948171,
-0.5258614421,
0.476526916,
0.5011293292,
-0.2588273883,
-0.4584746659,
-0.2880674899,
-0.0167943295,
0.086443603,
-0.582203269,
0.1874079406,
-0.1221581697,
-0.1172221303,
0.1307030916,
0.1993361413,
0.1283178777,
0.2979300618,
0.2460424453,
-0.1744439304,
-0.1932953596,
0.2554383278,
0.0563873276,
-0.2223941088,
-0.0114429379,
-0.4947481453,
0.7398300171,
-0.0525904968,
-0.3245425522,
-0.0901681185,
0.0744073987,
0.3943405449,
-0.3504567146,
0.6331033707,
0.5068875551,
-0.3054216206,
-0.7790884376,
0.0773897916,
-0.0479830652,
-0.555883348,
0.6547925472,
-0.6594526768,
-0.8496209383,
0.5320165753,
-0.1695878953,
-0.0929246396,
0.1806967705,
0.738812983,
0.1715945452,
1.1042833328,
0.8356485367,
0.1033260897,
0.7045614719,
-0.2386439443,
0.1770748943,
-0.3742805123,
-0.0636621118,
-0.2473161668,
-0.1861818731,
-0.7516032457,
-0.2428639084,
0.3433465958,
-0.2911436856,
-0.062834084,
0.0629827008,
-0.3254871368,
0.4416522384,
0.4754737914,
0.1630073786,
-0.0973504409,
0.0220586527,
-0.4465891123,
0.3719307482,
-0.8049557209,
-0.2754410505,
0.9338569045,
0.357075274,
0.8920227885,
0.0568352453,
0.6572213173,
0.2941239476,
0.339931488,
-0.7359778285,
0.5528898835,
0.0422946662,
-0.1726233214,
-0.6218767762,
-0.5732678175,
-1.2615922689,
0.1984688789,
-0.2735295296,
-0.7005887032,
-0.1199237108,
0.274078548,
-0.151520133,
0.1715814918,
-0.4739255607,
0.718824625,
-0.2986406088,
-0.2805968821,
-0.0964165479,
-0.4028486311,
0.2110458463,
-0.0757022873,
0.0278356224,
-0.2196253091,
0.2184610665,
0.5666068196,
-0.6934710741,
0.8738340139,
-0.3995386064,
-0.1470242143,
0.3752801418,
0.132463634,
0.7739729285,
0.0903385356,
-0.0355566069,
-0.3052652776,
-0.2604846954,
-0.274672538,
-0.7304611802,
0.7081507444,
-0.9945762753,
-0.5041775703,
-0.2373672277,
-0.8246745467,
-0.5348073244,
0.4117409587,
0.0674521327,
0.6732711196,
-0.2734491825,
-0.1208352447,
0.4562087357,
-0.3734157383,
0.2506965101,
0.7018746734,
-0.2566003203,
-0.508694768,
1.1584527493,
0.1748171598,
0.3750928938,
0.1887577325,
-0.0654866919,
-0.2437133789,
-0.7618595958,
-0.6080902815,
0.3720147908,
-0.7798364162,
-0.0943506956,
-0.3330416977,
-0.4449249804,
-0.3968892694,
-0.0497540906,
-0.2511594296,
-0.1628999859,
-0.1266354769,
-0.303625077,
0.2895403802,
0.9604552984,
0.1067134142,
0.5332981348,
-0.4590523541,
0.2453632951,
0.2929506302,
0.4543714225,
-0.2348554134,
-0.3457815349,
-0.4041772187,
0.0193354432,
-0.2387821525,
-0.7438753247,
0.3614767194,
0.428219825,
0.7695016861,
0.1840715259,
0.0693370998,
0.2937058806,
-0.7466232777,
0.4340463281,
-0.0751483366,
-0.7333165407,
0.3796824217,
-0.4461286664,
0.4959437549,
0.4845392704,
0.2050349563,
-0.4655695558,
-0.6775113344,
-0.6761677265,
-0.7346379161,
0.6873496771,
0.0724264756,
0.1976322979,
0.1737991124,
0.383115828,
0.0174419302,
0.1537477374,
-0.6253950596,
-0.138145119,
-0.083149761,
-0.3799200952,
-0.347222507,
-0.1062345952,
-0.1181674525,
-0.1657397151,
0.6724382043,
-0.4436717331,
0.1725534499,
-0.2194299251,
-0.4568506181,
-0.1660368592,
-0.1165192649,
0.6315339804,
0.9583751559,
-0.0872228965,
0.311924845,
0.2270750403,
-0.3037392497,
0.310454309,
0.2871898711,
-0.2687237263,
0.0035687382,
0.4173985124,
1.2263094187,
-0.1112472564,
-0.6335158944,
0.3123701811,
-0.253511399,
-0.348076731,
-0.2673822343,
0.0772286132,
0.1409008801,
0.2382815033,
-0.022726303,
-0.3087229133,
-0.2509064376,
-0.5235352516,
0.4531107843,
0.4585818648,
-0.3234578371,
-0.5534980893,
0.4215073884,
0.5041311979,
-0.5533735752,
0.8130555153,
-0.4766357839,
-0.650277257,
0.4786286056,
0.7705846429,
0.7539812326,
-0.0902204067,
0.3652228713,
0.1014682725,
0.1346117258,
0.4716905355,
0.1142748818,
-0.0584272593,
-1.0791966915,
-0.3167939782,
-0.5786747336,
-0.4096340835,
0.1622036397,
-0.1919522285,
0.2156115323,
-0.4456585348,
-0.1996293664,
-0.1191092804,
0.1836522818,
-0.753177762,
0.2102078944,
0.4361109734,
0.703212738,
-1.0331442356,
1.0662118196,
0.6931510568,
-0.3061241508,
-0.9402426481,
-0.0894021466,
-0.2395161837,
-1.0081100464,
0.5408681035,
-0.1175836846,
-0.3935509026,
0.2263959497,
-0.482831955,
-1.015432477,
0.7806399465,
0.5473382473,
-0.1889053285,
0.0292025227,
0.2609668076,
0.6033599377,
-0.4538490474,
0.2937388718,
0.5173214674,
0.2795037031,
0.0997728705,
-0.7046154141,
0.1672623754,
-0.4628472924,
-0.0899724066,
0.1690669358,
-0.6185897589,
0.6702005267,
-0.1252740622,
-0.3229024112,
-0.2434491664,
0.6574708819,
0.3527360559,
0.1770064533,
0.6625487208,
0.3216144741,
0.8678824902,
-0.0601150133,
0.9479278922,
-0.4778469205,
0.0822931081,
1.0923513174,
-0.3153429031,
0.4059738815,
0.0958708972,
0.0305475108,
0.6772029996,
0.8243667483,
0.3193405867,
0.5142992139,
0.7477376461,
-0.073866792,
-0.1828882694,
-0.1736791879,
-0.1048915088,
0.3402253091,
0.5303804278,
-0.1388463974,
-0.3988854885,
0.1343884319,
0.1869852543,
0.1198886782,
-0.0629382804,
0.8094430566,
0.0136223938,
-0.6328052282,
0.9230479002,
0.081467405,
0.294950217,
-0.8357666731,
-0.0342901349,
-0.2625118494,
0.2468505651,
-0.1207981408,
-0.5420854092,
-0.0715494677,
-0.1032733098,
0.1434650272,
-0.3618439734,
0.7581197619,
-0.6577572823,
-0.465249896,
0.2137040943,
0.5866525173,
0.082049109,
0.3603650033,
-0.6166360974,
0.253492415,
-0.0558691509,
-0.5142559409,
0.3453215063,
0.6614561081,
-0.1979161352,
0.7707576156,
0.45910272,
0.3306169808,
0.1147393212,
0.3571912944,
1.0661623478,
-0.2960968912,
-0.3655053675,
-0.6559115052,
0.4270138443,
-0.0527762324,
-0.2251905501,
0.4547120035,
0.3230164647,
0.6852356195,
0.0347737782,
0.8397673368,
0.0997076929,
0.1331974864,
-0.6528112888,
0.6845923662,
-0.4076308906,
-0.0970287994,
-0.0378030352,
-0.747628808,
-0.1707158685,
0.2388074994,
-0.1597649306,
0.1331850141,
0.6565077901,
0.9303386211,
-0.0000753023,
-0.6901220083,
0.2773987353,
0.1314714402,
0.7090702653,
0.6677330136,
0.9487924576,
0.0696157664,
0.5111606121,
-0.1461214274,
-0.1313105375,
-0.0815945417,
-0.6953570247,
-0.8959153891,
-0.5412745476,
-0.3813467324,
-0.5418928266,
0.2885022759,
0.8337728977,
0.6997163296,
-0.5766057968,
-0.2791056037,
-0.08549086,
0.3435375094,
-0.0640432015,
-0.1338114887,
0.2117764056,
-0.7076398134,
-0.779661417,
0.7911379337,
-0.0721616,
0.0915633515,
-0.2344913334,
-0.3730318248,
-0.0537324212,
0.26644665,
0.5617702007,
0.476166904,
-0.298666656,
-0.5929157734,
-0.2068145871,
-0.2137187272,
-0.0130938711,
0.8290867209,
-0.8195433617,
0.4581933022,
0.5115996003,
0.7633572817,
0.6623665094,
-0.0355913565,
0.8697326779,
-0.9721320868,
0.3115747571,
0.1504545212,
0.284303993,
0.3452540934,
-0.3170982897,
0.4067029953,
0.1325045973,
-0.5003808737,
-0.903070569,
0.440381676,
-0.7515419126,
-0.1510163546,
1.2043372393,
-0.1070752218,
-0.2633868456,
0.0748132765,
-0.028406037,
0.5096363425,
-0.3867869377,
0.2882300913,
0.4679360688,
-0.2898149788,
0.0306875203,
-0.1481695324,
0.695528388,
0.0033944517,
-0.8355323672,
-0.0342450999,
0.530970037,
0.431461215,
-0.0922916979,
0.8970511556,
0.332950443,
0.0142336963,
0.0892179161,
0.3335653543,
-0.3604192138,
-0.467233628,
-0.2396754324,
0.1114045233,
0.622363925,
-0.2453259528
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11547v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11547v1 | GECOBench: A Gender-Controlled Text Dataset and Benchmark for Quantifying Biases in Explanations | 2024-06-17T13:44:37 | 2024-06-17T13:44:37 | Rick Wilming, Artur Dox, Hjalmar Schulz, Marta Oliveira, Benedict Clark, Stefan Haufe | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY | Large pre-trained language models have become popular for many applications
and form an important backbone of many downstream tasks in natural language
processing (NLP). Applying 'explainable artificial intelligence' (XAI)
techniques to enrich such models' outputs is considered crucial for assuring
their quality and shedding light on their inner workings. However, large
language models are trained on a plethora of data containing a variety of
biases, such as gender biases, affecting model weights and, potentially,
behavior. Currently, it is unclear to what extent such biases also impact model
explanations in possibly unfavorable ways. We create a gender-controlled text
dataset, GECO, in which otherwise identical sentences appear in male and female
forms. This gives rise to ground-truth 'world explanations' for gender
classification tasks, enabling the objective evaluation of the correctness of
XAI methods. We also provide GECOBench, a rigorous quantitative evaluation
framework benchmarking popular XAI methods, applying them to pre-trained
language models fine-tuned to different degrees. This allows us to investigate
how pre-training induces undesirable bias in model explanations and to what
extent fine-tuning can mitigate such explanation bias. We show a clear
dependency between explanation performance and the number of fine-tuned layers,
where XAI methods are observed to particularly benefit from fine-tuning or
complete retraining of embedding layers. Remarkably, this relationship holds
for models achieving similar classification performance on the same task. With
that, we highlight the utility of the proposed gender-controlled dataset and
novel benchmarking approach for research and development of novel XAI methods.
All code including dataset generation, model training, evaluation and
visualization is available at: https://github.com/braindatalab/gecobench | [
-0.5523385406,
-0.6331787705,
0.3187616765,
-0.0105868895,
0.0131059187,
-0.1549619585,
-0.2124829739,
-0.3818437755,
-0.3329335153,
0.296518743,
-0.8236143589,
-0.4921721518,
-0.4724543393,
-0.1023834348,
-0.6415278912,
1.1036164761,
-0.0611326881,
0.1846593767,
-0.4356866777,
-0.2216541171,
-0.5453421474,
-0.3445788324,
-0.7071005702,
-0.597720027,
0.5231360197,
0.434933126,
0.8485808969,
0.7287222743,
0.0360003263,
0.2331753671,
-0.0853775144,
0.1455755085,
-0.31796965,
-0.1767015904,
-0.4287448525,
-0.6070462465,
-0.3165706694,
0.0626913086,
0.4573998451,
0.8546046019,
-0.2349456549,
0.0413350426,
0.2184011191,
0.5647847056,
-0.812574327,
0.125055939,
-0.5098479986,
0.1071003377,
-0.0618596748,
-0.1098764837,
-0.2174165994,
-0.1454643458,
0.2727756798,
-0.5025076866,
0.6393425465,
0.3537527025,
0.8543409109,
0.1657880098,
-0.3399780691,
-0.4507961869,
-0.5458087325,
0.8410268426,
-0.5930783749,
0.2195476592,
0.2680213451,
0.4109336436,
-0.0758554786,
-0.4769924283,
-0.5771722198,
-0.2502603531,
-0.2544465363,
0.0338880606,
-0.2908032835,
-0.0022425782,
0.3270966113,
0.4040739834,
-0.7311239243,
0.2821086943,
0.0714248493,
-0.1068197861,
0.592474997,
0.0345370919,
0.5478163958,
-0.1418316513,
-0.1110876203,
-0.2841085792,
-0.5276919007,
0.0719636902,
0.818849802,
0.2479578108,
-0.1209826767,
0.2598131597,
-0.1705393642,
0.5700470209,
-0.1336214095,
0.4461740553,
0.1861827672,
-0.220071286,
-0.2640525103,
0.2539341748,
0.7852150798,
0.2246244848,
0.4936948717,
-0.2638934255,
0.1583676189,
0.3625064492,
0.349686563,
-0.7960841656,
-0.1008177102,
0.2017678916,
-0.2722831368,
-0.6077430844,
0.0541834645,
-0.9581725001,
-0.3100596368,
-0.2474641949,
0.092426464,
-0.1117932498,
-0.1392753869,
0.1285167634,
-0.398027122,
0.1506849229,
0.0171047375,
-1.2319926023,
0.6446344852,
0.7086073756,
0.544778347,
-0.0265617985,
-0.2900276482,
-0.4426173866,
0.0799254999,
-0.4336163998,
0.3945735395,
-0.7122825384,
-0.193004638,
-0.0114567606,
0.0939062685,
0.1407786459,
-0.3401028514,
0.7552802563,
-0.1276704371,
0.4796662629,
-0.4051582813,
-0.3918290436,
-0.2312044352,
0.0771835074,
-0.5452398062,
0.8991321921,
-0.0985128656,
-0.8604289889,
0.47354424,
-0.7716769576,
-0.3773709238,
-0.3744203448,
-0.4714688659,
-0.4133155346,
0.0699667409,
0.542817831,
0.3160330951,
-0.7192929387,
0.5132611394,
-0.3298231363,
-0.3179157972,
0.2360756546,
-0.4789954126,
0.8707486987,
-0.0084121432,
-0.6821666956,
0.1818506718,
-0.7215705514,
0.2819301188,
0.1967967749,
0.3863064945,
-0.4172424376,
0.078356117,
-0.2919352353,
0.2684643865,
-0.1859306246,
-0.3232543468,
-0.2098454386,
-0.3658143282,
0.6799998879,
0.7309988141,
-0.4436211884,
0.4887452722,
-0.1304765642,
0.6682873964,
-0.1005335376,
0.0822972059,
-0.1984124035,
-0.1787239611,
-0.5589478612,
0.0712026283,
0.3863661885,
0.3025425971,
-0.5229665041,
0.2170191854,
-0.2434252352,
-0.450067699,
-0.4308488965,
0.1536311656,
0.6983980536,
0.6272326708,
0.1769884974,
-0.2520734072,
-0.5031817555,
-1.1182208061,
-0.6243531704,
0.0533391424,
-0.4153664112,
0.5190598965,
0.6712095737,
-0.2138489038,
0.8272081017,
-0.2673549652,
0.0080854585,
-0.1630256921,
0.5419593453,
0.036327865,
0.4753204584,
0.7372174859,
-0.8321322799,
0.0690015331,
0.1396360993,
-0.7893762589,
-0.3308666945,
-0.0549933054,
-0.3512556553,
0.0194949694,
0.5420572758,
-0.365808636,
0.4126425385,
0.6974166036,
-0.3183637261,
0.6113711596,
-0.3352698684,
0.0908834711,
-0.5792129636,
0.2514573038,
0.0452907532,
-0.3794195056,
-0.4543561041,
0.1977221221,
-0.005363076,
-0.1334371865,
-0.1963813454,
0.5496786237,
-0.5488957167,
-0.1875214875,
-0.3462920189,
0.2799620032,
0.1306281239,
0.606746912,
-0.1940128654,
0.6321583986,
0.4058796465,
-0.5027809143,
0.0168073289,
0.1771614254,
-0.2365819961,
0.3303613365,
-1.0707073212,
0.3116402626,
-0.2518715262,
0.181591332,
-0.8395122886,
-0.2783473134,
0.2995474935,
-0.5185836554,
0.078819856,
-0.0567228757,
-0.2939240932,
-0.4206535816,
-0.2402494401,
0.2078887075,
0.3099732995,
-0.570880115,
0.7037931681,
0.2244482785,
-0.1150040776,
-0.8131951094,
-0.7835234404,
-0.1203362569,
-0.1481210142,
-0.4913463295,
0.5517272353,
-0.1336328089,
-0.1881466061,
-0.0847321004,
-0.2814764082,
-0.0411024131,
0.2583532929,
0.4554103315,
0.1851068139,
0.0633484423,
0.1943276376,
0.3428955972,
-0.3661843836,
0.4067159593,
-0.2559736967,
0.6556212306,
-0.1386197358,
-0.2015615255,
-0.3182377219,
0.3821063936,
0.3352505863,
-0.1916584224,
0.7927424908,
0.4497111738,
-0.3112376034,
-0.4384679496,
-0.0425247811,
-0.1393957138,
-0.4290371835,
0.32994017,
-0.4575143158,
-0.8348326087,
0.5742143393,
0.1125701666,
0.0531842671,
0.4653557539,
0.4886631072,
0.0241373982,
1.595076561,
0.6659712791,
-0.2398195416,
0.4099012613,
-0.0264801271,
0.0879112855,
-0.5407021046,
0.057360407,
-0.8561069965,
-0.3081081212,
-0.6766819358,
-0.1745051742,
-0.1663645953,
-0.0895203799,
-0.3286956549,
-0.0501591228,
-0.5221198797,
0.7005856633,
0.555632174,
-0.0209972598,
0.1449229121,
0.0025953273,
-0.0618232638,
0.1044165641,
-0.6798654795,
-0.6033859253,
0.95470047,
0.2472702861,
0.6693189144,
-0.2058774382,
0.1081685722,
0.490362823,
0.0712831616,
-0.3595789373,
0.3044471443,
-0.4107589424,
-0.8557997942,
-0.2655744851,
-0.5553835034,
-0.8777227402,
0.349619627,
-0.0591431819,
-0.7636451125,
0.227302283,
0.3952005804,
-0.092872411,
0.0883546993,
-0.7832944393,
1.1277959347,
-0.2995221317,
-0.450604707,
-0.3357874453,
-0.5967355967,
0.3771663308,
0.081597887,
0.163951546,
-0.107387431,
0.2256928831,
0.7213258743,
-0.4733099043,
0.7446829081,
-0.2211955339,
-0.1385458857,
-0.1376340985,
-0.1125590205,
0.327731967,
0.1719309092,
-0.1951379776,
0.4438253343,
-0.1058477685,
-0.4571738839,
-0.9149695635,
0.7203188539,
-0.8528912067,
-0.5629871488,
-0.1461589485,
-0.6517985463,
-0.0264299344,
0.1519635469,
0.3591827154,
0.5388787985,
-0.3103008866,
0.1057653949,
0.5881655216,
-0.3666095734,
-0.0172609165,
0.3056651056,
-0.3425515294,
-0.0574336201,
0.7264653444,
0.118135497,
0.2328955084,
0.3050150573,
0.2617338896,
-0.0161154866,
-0.4324541986,
-0.4255637527,
-0.0328613557,
-0.5801801682,
0.2327838838,
-0.5620344281,
0.0067898841,
-0.1924532205,
-0.235453859,
-0.1497680545,
-0.178397119,
-0.0270839389,
-0.1843963116,
-0.0400246456,
0.2902345955,
0.2311231196,
0.5175442696,
-0.1521301568,
0.6525009274,
0.3875183165,
0.3192269802,
0.1400422305,
-0.3290078342,
-0.0396096818,
0.4318945706,
0.0750113651,
-0.7932518721,
0.3508279324,
0.1900901347,
0.5663157105,
0.4164762497,
-0.1144767702,
0.5999687314,
-0.3467975557,
0.4650589526,
-0.0351671278,
-1.3544462919,
0.8751294017,
-0.3711009026,
0.3891333938,
0.505018115,
0.4180003405,
-0.6415569186,
-0.4034171402,
-0.6686590314,
-0.8076479435,
0.8746964931,
0.2900313139,
0.1184214056,
0.1261229962,
0.5566259027,
0.4747515619,
0.3098916113,
-0.4917176664,
-0.2832164764,
-0.1426692605,
-0.252738297,
-0.2920050025,
-0.2397381365,
-0.238002345,
-0.2380802631,
0.8592610359,
-0.491494149,
0.2728557289,
0.0723418966,
-0.3588790596,
0.1029675528,
0.3367888927,
0.4064494967,
0.7828406096,
-0.1012521312,
0.1024086326,
0.1777088791,
-0.2741838396,
0.0896039382,
0.2271983474,
-0.3011132777,
0.0916499496,
0.3980849683,
0.9666475654,
0.1447817087,
-0.6959403753,
0.3704133034,
-0.4434662163,
-0.2528341115,
-0.2529524565,
0.4720780849,
-0.0305411723,
-0.0088931303,
0.0987050533,
0.0363680571,
0.2141143233,
-0.6018657684,
-0.0970656499,
0.3390519023,
-0.6133584976,
-0.3182143867,
0.9122859836,
0.0562494881,
-0.0387228802,
0.694768548,
-0.0492581278,
-0.3419365287,
0.9100954533,
0.2615740001,
0.8577159643,
-0.0375590324,
0.4098043442,
0.2364515215,
0.3800816834,
0.045151636,
0.1642163694,
-0.1728480309,
-0.934197247,
-0.2914758325,
-0.1511467248,
-0.4751192331,
-0.0906781256,
-0.9418162107,
0.2188907862,
-0.5484538674,
0.071999751,
0.5224658251,
-0.0768508166,
-0.8334864378,
0.3478900194,
0.2240870893,
0.8552196622,
-1.060721755,
0.6220226288,
0.4867473543,
-0.3309466243,
-0.6688601375,
-0.0369404741,
0.1392043233,
-0.8081997037,
0.3369012773,
0.4258384705,
-0.3561397493,
-0.1704023033,
-0.8707255721,
-0.3779309392,
0.8174257874,
0.7036178708,
-0.8201773763,
-0.0033582959,
0.2048832774,
0.6248978972,
-0.3510594964,
0.7282568812,
0.9153268933,
0.5777646303,
-0.3622381389,
-0.4680044353,
0.1362677962,
-0.5518787503,
0.1384180784,
0.050765913,
-0.4882414341,
0.614769578,
-0.0884060785,
-0.0976351202,
-0.0188663863,
0.6672791839,
0.1110011637,
0.344584018,
0.8326864839,
0.4227479994,
1.2013010979,
-0.3312673867,
1.3753609657,
0.0459295623,
0.1566380858,
1.3703455925,
-0.2245482504,
0.3646851778,
0.3237698972,
0.0088968985,
0.8989210129,
0.4163723588,
0.0026317437,
0.2748876214,
0.391235739,
0.0704530105,
-0.1311352998,
-0.2969202101,
-0.2403295189,
0.4827278256,
0.1493282467,
-0.638479352,
-0.0686926916,
0.1561812907,
0.2219310552,
-0.0079111932,
-0.2171661705,
0.4901624918,
-0.1251523942,
-0.6300321817,
0.3853243589,
-0.0248001888,
0.4800280333,
-0.8117530346,
0.126241073,
-0.2659261525,
0.3406129479,
-0.2728590667,
-0.6185294986,
0.1351693571,
0.1359464973,
-0.6545259356,
-0.1330951601,
0.6494785547,
-0.4320288599,
-0.4305487871,
0.3975562453,
0.3699004948,
0.0873960182,
-0.2117791772,
-0.7338997126,
-0.0048493017,
0.2052931786,
-0.1041656509,
0.1844280064,
0.4701302648,
-0.5600732565,
0.8733511567,
0.5414853096,
-0.2038457543,
-0.255512476,
0.5749772191,
0.7262257934,
-0.699426949,
-0.6316357255,
-1.0301750898,
0.4158551693,
-0.254561305,
-0.4752475917,
0.6869159341,
0.3196077645,
0.8527244329,
0.0958241373,
0.8120814562,
-0.0367493108,
0.3569004238,
-0.4002234936,
0.6838113666,
-0.617538929,
0.0920659527,
-0.4347405434,
-0.8046811223,
-0.1593671143,
0.3900441229,
-0.3534194529,
0.3606330156,
0.6479417086,
0.8775451183,
-0.0201858412,
0.4745205641,
0.0599522777,
0.3655005395,
0.4117023945,
0.3062479198,
0.7699611783,
-0.3772914112,
0.5611991286,
-0.2156419158,
-0.2274221927,
-0.0014068602,
-1.0118991137,
-0.8593914509,
-0.2622183561,
-0.4798252285,
0.2234409302,
0.3789630532,
0.4827916026,
0.9187860489,
-0.8228444457,
-0.0725257322,
-0.4719610512,
0.2605736852,
-0.5346133709,
-0.2278804481,
0.199370265,
-0.2377753407,
-0.8400068283,
0.0632062927,
-0.0888423473,
-0.2792146802,
-0.3832280934,
-0.1223676801,
0.1184493452,
-0.0896926075,
0.2680467069,
0.148108989,
-0.5531696677,
-0.2353502363,
-0.2397727519,
0.1963385046,
-0.0093013812,
0.9571979642,
-0.8085475564,
0.5903321505,
0.5649496913,
0.5607010126,
0.4592651427,
-0.0857644528,
1.0337126255,
-0.7894189358,
0.1392102093,
-0.0901859254,
0.3802621365,
0.2306582481,
-0.358037889,
0.6373112202,
-0.2550459504,
-0.521979928,
-0.7334638834,
-0.1629595309,
-0.7447214723,
-0.485009551,
0.6411808133,
-0.1237533912,
-0.4827851057,
0.0969712883,
-0.3445367515,
0.3378733397,
-0.3571975827,
0.6915178895,
0.9811050892,
0.169029519,
-0.3196776807,
-0.8205224276,
0.2365170121,
0.8197513223,
-1.0359009504,
0.4087060988,
0.3840664029,
0.1116482317,
-0.1060755104,
0.1106556132,
-0.1633044928,
0.4028386176,
-0.0100855147,
0.3990385234,
-0.0345994681,
-0.3939088881,
-0.5422903895,
0.0642354861,
-0.2179555446,
-0.0908388197
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11546v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11546v1 | GigaSpeech 2: An Evolving, Large-Scale and Multi-domain ASR Corpus for Low-Resource Languages with Automated Crawling, Transcription and Refinement | 2024-06-17T13:44:20 | 2024-06-17T13:44:20 | Yifan Yang, Zheshu Song, Jianheng Zhuo, Mingyu Cui, Jinpeng Li, Bo Yang, Yexing Du, Ziyang Ma, Xunying Liu, Ziyuan Wang, Ke Li, Shuai Fan, Kai Yu, Wei-Qiang Zhang, Guoguo Chen, Xie Chen | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.SD | The evolution of speech technology has been spurred by the rapid increase in
dataset sizes. Traditional speech models generally depend on a large amount of
labeled training data, which is scarce for low-resource languages. This paper
presents GigaSpeech 2, a large-scale, multi-domain, multilingual speech
recognition corpus. It is designed for low-resource languages and does not rely
on paired speech and text data. GigaSpeech 2 comprises about 30,000 hours of
automatically transcribed speech, including Thai, Indonesian, and Vietnamese,
gathered from unlabeled YouTube videos. We also introduce an automated pipeline
for data crawling, transcription, and label refinement. Specifically, this
pipeline uses Whisper for initial transcription and TorchAudio for forced
alignment, combined with multi-dimensional filtering for data quality
assurance. A modified Noisy Student Training is developed to further refine
flawed pseudo labels iteratively, thus enhancing model performance.
Experimental results on our manually transcribed evaluation set and two public
test sets from Common Voice and FLEURS confirm our corpus's high quality and
broad applicability. Notably, ASR models trained on GigaSpeech 2 can reduce the
word error rate for Thai, Indonesian, and Vietnamese on our challenging and
realistic YouTube test set by 25% to 40% compared to the Whisper large-v3
model, with merely 10% model parameters. Furthermore, our ASR models trained on
Gigaspeech 2 yield superior performance compared to commercial services. We
believe that our newly introduced corpus and pipeline will open a new avenue
for low-resource speech recognition and significantly facilitate research in
this area. | [
-0.2690244019,
-0.6898062229,
0.0245715436,
0.1526323408,
-0.2016155869,
0.4682419896,
-0.3680915236,
-0.5703746676,
0.409103781,
0.4682913423,
-0.194315806,
0.0784209818,
-0.7138504386,
-0.0928481594,
-0.4436509907,
0.8181720376,
0.1498843879,
0.1790440828,
-0.0773979425,
-0.0507566147,
-0.1459497362,
-0.5383855104,
-0.7882280946,
-0.2044336051,
0.4385528564,
0.5325419307,
0.6508071423,
0.5343405008,
0.2022035718,
0.2710587382,
-0.1915078163,
0.2752577066,
-0.4814026356,
-0.0767043605,
-0.0226962212,
-0.1106433421,
-0.3313010335,
-0.0259501804,
0.8649764061,
0.5504158735,
-0.2703086138,
0.4591493607,
0.0957670286,
0.3997529149,
-0.4294509292,
0.1489101052,
-0.6685951948,
-0.3118702769,
-0.4548187554,
0.0400418267,
-0.2684576213,
-0.1885915846,
0.009700072,
-0.3814216554,
0.3336021602,
-0.2066485286,
0.6851008534,
0.3810104728,
-0.2806532383,
-0.3174110353,
-0.7028594613,
0.757704854,
-0.3876699805,
0.7824863195,
0.6382963061,
0.5322936177,
0.2374189347,
-0.8973699212,
-0.6829128265,
-0.154105857,
0.2820243835,
0.0279482044,
-0.2623070478,
-0.312492609,
0.1250298321,
0.2698981762,
-0.6522593498,
0.3321689665,
-0.8773661852,
-0.4320205152,
0.5330548882,
-0.2428414226,
0.0934035778,
-0.0985645652,
-0.3708281815,
-0.1890343726,
-0.7075462937,
0.1639292538,
0.5864872932,
0.6576659083,
-0.209480539,
0.5432919264,
-0.0307761617,
0.5733786821,
-0.1120930761,
-0.3099551797,
0.5028036833,
-0.0248411354,
0.0136001427,
0.3311650157,
0.7548951507,
0.0633217469,
0.155256182,
-0.075805001,
-0.2035724521,
0.2545475066,
0.3800174594,
-0.7217915654,
-0.3683149219,
0.2024625987,
-0.2772425413,
0.0381118394,
-0.2371856719,
-0.7876916528,
-0.3266833723,
-0.6312434673,
0.3652404845,
-0.3224480152,
-0.5212395787,
0.0518656,
-0.0248323996,
0.1249829158,
0.350376457,
-0.8543187976,
0.3670937419,
0.8192178011,
1.0685939789,
-0.2728554606,
-0.4497096539,
-1.0142939091,
0.0456769504,
-0.3712540865,
0.9162102938,
-0.594907701,
-0.6297483444,
0.0567252301,
-0.013500317,
0.0404985435,
-0.7757067084,
0.474112004,
-0.5898163319,
-0.016258033,
-0.118889235,
-0.2718143463,
-0.1682680845,
-0.0546549968,
-0.7030459642,
1.0571124554,
0.260456115,
-0.3387107253,
0.1042075828,
-0.6846856475,
-0.545320034,
0.2311272621,
-0.0604967959,
-0.3815476,
0.029596841,
0.0602311678,
0.0149312271,
-0.5879203677,
0.0701528937,
-0.0965359807,
-0.3824664056,
0.2020797879,
-0.4658442736,
0.8207024932,
0.3723269403,
-0.1858986914,
0.0051736441,
-0.7508975267,
0.3009777069,
-0.1618944556,
-0.5305138826,
0.1972095221,
-0.1308680922,
0.6628152728,
0.3337467015,
0.1003039703,
-0.6326041222,
0.0664028078,
-0.1951220781,
0.7843984365,
0.4357585907,
-0.2011321336,
0.2156116813,
-0.0841907859,
0.5820245743,
-0.2119121552,
0.013741985,
0.1207488552,
-0.5625574589,
-0.7048287392,
-0.466288954,
0.4928637445,
0.4754999578,
-0.8275479674,
0.0888454169,
-0.5882447362,
-0.592887342,
-0.9505867958,
0.2280520797,
0.4503909051,
0.4564420283,
0.6038802862,
-0.3681766093,
-0.6239129901,
-0.8161607385,
-0.0321081094,
-0.2410639226,
-0.2316988707,
0.449382484,
0.0900316238,
-0.6512492895,
0.6721292138,
-0.2956446707,
-0.3293917477,
-0.2533777654,
0.1725185663,
0.0551241301,
0.3792831004,
0.2716963887,
-0.8013084531,
-0.6633791924,
-0.1084784046,
-0.0990608037,
-0.0089198099,
0.2261627465,
0.1523332745,
0.3009822965,
0.385599643,
-0.5067508221,
-0.2325288504,
0.7751335502,
-0.0572227985,
0.7059366703,
-0.0783794448,
-0.0302953795,
-0.8394610286,
0.163084954,
-0.2818258107,
-0.1450392157,
-0.696465075,
-0.0184562281,
0.002749058,
-0.4277876616,
-0.4721853137,
0.5127254725,
-0.1494843066,
-0.2351337373,
-0.3282469511,
0.130150184,
-0.2796301544,
0.2365064919,
0.2082668245,
1.3165293932,
0.6094357967,
-0.5239870548,
0.4307901561,
0.4923030138,
-0.4115869999,
0.4104281962,
-0.5458378196,
0.6289173961,
0.1669656187,
0.2513848543,
-1.0531512499,
-0.2158394456,
-0.2741434276,
-0.778644383,
0.3637389839,
-0.4440678656,
-0.7310015559,
-0.4175342321,
-0.0956392661,
0.2167159021,
0.6234424114,
-0.817994535,
0.5127085447,
0.9003028274,
-0.5141573548,
-0.3103263378,
-0.7100768089,
0.3687506914,
-0.1096697599,
-0.5513851047,
0.0342147574,
0.0297305603,
0.0272091627,
-0.4063766599,
-0.0782610551,
-0.4635329247,
-0.4158093035,
0.2717220485,
0.2877073288,
-0.2270655036,
0.232194379,
-0.1648075134,
-0.3097228706,
-0.0449762195,
-0.5628771782,
0.8244761229,
-0.1367743611,
-0.0312914662,
-0.3128661811,
0.3455986977,
0.535764575,
-0.4750611782,
0.2158474773,
0.9594585299,
-0.2445781529,
-0.015313277,
-0.8466553688,
0.1061705872,
-0.5252978206,
0.3244769275,
-0.3819427788,
-1.0407533646,
0.17923747,
-0.112559475,
-0.191884622,
0.4895518124,
0.7342810035,
-0.0174616463,
0.6981827617,
0.4375097752,
-0.2709537745,
0.2348868251,
-0.3802632093,
0.1318427324,
-0.9017321467,
-0.1023944765,
-0.5968338251,
-0.2701827288,
-0.6859766841,
-0.7796746492,
0.3798753321,
-0.2073302269,
-0.1886653006,
0.3790847361,
-0.4764618576,
0.412250489,
0.6418462992,
-0.2104354203,
0.0355718918,
0.4102603793,
0.1721999347,
-0.0504354462,
-0.5400292873,
-0.4459381104,
1.0855866671,
0.2536765933,
0.5149452686,
0.4729991555,
0.2578118145,
0.3682574332,
-0.0077024624,
-0.8726136088,
0.2200208157,
-0.4663373828,
-0.5946559906,
-0.3770719767,
-0.3474286795,
-0.8655124903,
0.2716781795,
0.0759631395,
-0.7042608857,
0.0970208645,
0.2313671261,
-0.5522859693,
0.1869135201,
-0.7703464627,
0.479311049,
-0.1111868843,
-0.5554171801,
-0.2817128003,
-0.616369307,
0.1377648562,
-0.2507061958,
0.2182715535,
0.0921836346,
-0.0288341381,
0.854387641,
-0.3095934689,
0.5693536401,
-0.3656675816,
-0.0915469751,
0.7223699689,
0.0376089476,
0.5799037218,
0.0423186272,
-0.0240951367,
0.4484439194,
-0.0062846486,
-0.2370436788,
-0.1693782955,
0.7354049683,
-0.9204448462,
-0.1914669424,
-0.1486004442,
-0.2018519342,
-0.5530079007,
0.1358571351,
0.2140657008,
0.3866048455,
0.0493810177,
0.2807636857,
0.5597143769,
-0.1947655678,
0.1840051562,
0.7204017043,
-0.1208268777,
-0.5788807273,
1.4316452742,
0.2211144716,
0.1794610769,
0.0774196386,
0.1972630769,
-0.6701568365,
-0.3357273638,
-0.7016643882,
0.1378962994,
-0.3866741955,
-0.348911047,
-0.8813046217,
-0.3419402838,
-0.5798096061,
-0.0599134602,
-0.784776926,
-0.5877819657,
-0.2344912887,
-0.0329256579,
0.4382784069,
0.3787977695,
-0.478515029,
0.5536741018,
-0.6940952539,
0.6625542045,
0.5310562253,
0.4152546525,
-0.1690620929,
-0.8384215832,
-0.1231656,
0.0430541821,
-0.0609804578,
-0.386937052,
0.4490330219,
0.4791586697,
0.0007270545,
0.4263882041,
-0.3534835279,
0.8384507298,
-0.7691500783,
0.8464452624,
0.2826055586,
-0.8547277451,
0.2949727476,
-0.3288994133,
0.2044439763,
0.5876886249,
0.1668964028,
-0.7379754186,
0.0907675847,
-0.5929760337,
-0.7984668612,
0.6723840237,
-0.1467210352,
0.1946368665,
0.2482931763,
0.0851105005,
0.3140288889,
0.245590806,
-0.0900584534,
0.004083016,
-0.3753052652,
0.1677034646,
-0.5626052618,
-0.3973913193,
-0.0162862763,
-0.255000174,
0.6316798925,
-0.2392915636,
0.3396042287,
-0.1725887358,
-0.2358517051,
-0.1963718385,
0.2198283225,
0.4636618197,
0.3955480754,
0.1193922013,
0.2415619791,
0.1724624634,
-0.9533455372,
0.2006957531,
0.4388967454,
-0.0551868379,
0.060796164,
0.228399843,
0.7543079853,
0.2859253883,
-0.9087709785,
0.4740459621,
0.2424055636,
-0.0948944762,
-0.6242749095,
-0.0055291206,
0.222621277,
0.139653191,
0.2272980511,
-0.0530849509,
0.3649570942,
-0.4407620728,
0.3179779053,
0.2965859771,
-0.4660456181,
-0.3137555122,
0.7070708871,
0.0696552545,
-0.5107312202,
0.778737843,
-0.3923236132,
-0.4401989281,
0.2845743001,
0.4769836366,
0.6842494011,
-0.634770453,
0.3253944814,
0.4927091002,
0.2398691028,
-0.1899145842,
0.391114682,
-0.0931322947,
-0.3931826055,
-0.497998327,
-0.8552724719,
-0.5765817165,
0.3605079651,
-0.6072527766,
0.3111133277,
-0.365116179,
-0.0511288568,
0.2305118889,
0.1201131195,
-0.6750825047,
0.1542519629,
0.2351057827,
0.7388759851,
-0.6352479458,
0.9574074745,
0.6287644506,
-0.1350225061,
-0.6350744367,
-0.2970023751,
0.3939259052,
-0.9799107909,
0.5912245512,
0.0615935698,
-0.3914481997,
0.1789578348,
-0.3954640627,
-1.2197304964,
0.7404800653,
0.1648831666,
-0.6317667365,
0.1217662618,
0.3521102071,
0.6141255498,
-0.0544675775,
0.0688873306,
0.6909607053,
0.3519893289,
0.3501132727,
-1.1765170097,
-0.4548107684,
-0.237068072,
-0.0729172453,
0.0083809141,
-0.9634381533,
0.8927195668,
-0.2675774097,
-0.2176629305,
-0.0852856711,
0.3963963091,
0.0760928839,
-0.0235022623,
0.5187108517,
0.5089207292,
0.7988123298,
0.0169443041,
0.675275743,
-0.0637874082,
0.1511223316,
1.382735014,
-0.3872527778,
1.2337853909,
0.3852384388,
-0.5193741918,
0.2595054805,
0.4444451332,
-0.1830161512,
0.4489036202,
0.1670589745,
-0.1993505806,
-0.1508432925,
-0.2765714228,
-0.2449569255,
0.9999409318,
0.4780834615,
0.0650772899,
-0.0458429642,
-0.0668949708,
-0.1321720779,
-0.2542605996,
-0.1954767406,
0.8194490075,
-0.080616504,
-0.3496786654,
0.7978311777,
-0.1080286652,
0.5376752615,
-0.6319251657,
0.1312574595,
0.0616675988,
0.2455227524,
-0.0853628144,
-0.5109810829,
0.2410614491,
0.2694720328,
-0.0356601477,
-0.1373457909,
0.5108724833,
-0.507317245,
-0.4954150617,
0.1840774417,
0.4690950811,
0.345892787,
-0.2805539668,
-0.478885293,
0.3616947532,
-0.0614021644,
0.0830752403,
0.2967588007,
0.112959668,
0.2724941671,
0.4998839796,
0.9023678899,
0.3743778467,
-0.0129952347,
0.1820523143,
0.7599307299,
-0.3340573013,
-0.7195928693,
-0.3022409379,
0.4253491163,
-0.0711343065,
-0.2796730399,
0.445548296,
1.0029172897,
0.7534530163,
-0.0596797056,
0.8315572739,
0.2207148969,
0.9876095057,
-0.351138562,
0.8223260641,
-0.4470798969,
-0.1742282361,
0.0394482613,
-0.804418385,
-0.0440472066,
0.5831232667,
0.0419118926,
-0.1746010631,
0.4412584305,
0.6956843138,
-0.1988627613,
-0.0255992636,
0.1664615571,
0.2732101083,
0.3890069723,
0.3451377451,
0.625295043,
-0.3316141963,
0.6621755362,
-0.0250124838,
-0.3357135653,
-0.2771823108,
-0.2469239682,
-0.4902878404,
-0.8878605962,
-0.3444252014,
-0.2542600632,
-0.0367640369,
0.8338489532,
0.6927547455,
-0.7927612662,
-0.4262777865,
0.3395270705,
-0.4534094036,
-0.1972704083,
-0.2069756091,
0.4593883157,
-0.360735029,
-0.7868977189,
0.720335722,
0.3675149381,
-0.0236006547,
-0.2659258544,
0.000555407,
-0.0375921577,
-0.0128153227,
0.74442029,
0.5169783831,
-0.7133204341,
-0.2487199455,
-0.1774047315,
0.045396816,
0.1118923426,
0.8170476556,
-0.7600136995,
0.677790761,
0.0556885302,
0.8220969439,
0.6542841792,
-0.1223609522,
0.1191482097,
-0.6801322699,
0.2061232179,
0.3265936375,
0.1803642213,
0.6301648021,
-0.1059344634,
0.6077185273,
0.0458184369,
-0.465248853,
-0.9118388891,
0.1481252015,
-0.9008607268,
0.0987479091,
1.4848231077,
0.2158526629,
0.1828800738,
-0.1990323663,
-0.2695503235,
0.2893340886,
-0.429007113,
1.0164955854,
0.5596176386,
-0.0400000699,
-0.1082126349,
-0.8351380825,
0.5980127454,
0.087613292,
-0.650763154,
0.4595275819,
0.6087568998,
0.2896612585,
0.3600950241,
0.562097311,
-0.1110129282,
0.3915163875,
0.3196870387,
-0.0292888228,
-0.1068225726,
-0.3553225398,
-0.4380914271,
0.1427513063,
0.0058983918,
-0.1403344423
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11514v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11514v1 | Counterfactual Debating with Preset Stances for Hallucination Elimination of LLMs | 2024-06-17T13:21:23 | 2024-06-17T13:21:23 | Yi Fang, Moxin Li, Wenjie Wang, Hui Lin, Fuli Feng | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) excel in various natural language processing
tasks but struggle with hallucination issues. Existing solutions have
considered utilizing LLMs' inherent reasoning abilities to alleviate
hallucination, such as self-correction and diverse sampling methods. However,
these methods often overtrust LLMs' initial answers due to inherent biases. The
key to alleviating this issue lies in overriding LLMs' inherent biases for
answer inspection. To this end, we propose a CounterFactual Multi-Agent Debate
(CFMAD) framework. CFMAD presets the stances of LLMs to override their inherent
biases by compelling LLMs to generate justifications for a predetermined
answer's correctness. The LLMs with different predetermined stances are engaged
with a skeptical critic for counterfactual debate on the rationality of
generated justifications. Finally, the debate process is evaluated by a
third-party judge to determine the final answer. Extensive experiments on four
datasets of three tasks demonstrate the superiority of CFMAD over existing
methods. | [
-0.9296091795,
-1.1326850653,
0.9298967719,
0.0071798046,
-0.2969979048,
-0.0641022176,
-0.3225282729,
-0.4090614617,
0.4895499647,
0.8302232027,
-0.62950629,
-0.2811619937,
-0.502707243,
0.2787111104,
-0.3215264678,
0.9316028357,
-0.1673825681,
0.1755815148,
-0.5433676243,
-0.3640379012,
-0.3906072676,
-0.7610496283,
-0.4716043174,
-0.651534915,
0.6162007451,
0.4278010726,
0.9244681001,
0.2554348409,
0.1992966384,
0.4270604253,
0.1928498,
0.3031550646,
-0.4438339174,
0.4014404416,
-0.5404781699,
-0.315133661,
-0.3255728185,
0.1725895256,
0.1635554582,
0.5424785614,
-0.2312018126,
-0.071918264,
-0.221969828,
0.3479160368,
-0.5452124476,
-0.3517681658,
-0.8226171136,
0.0708488002,
0.0235182736,
-0.3786207736,
-0.4071584642,
-0.3256077468,
0.2309516966,
-0.4515067041,
0.3807697296,
0.0031022797,
0.6646350026,
0.4984285235,
-0.4403551221,
-0.3928974271,
-0.7320184112,
0.6012384892,
-0.5975850224,
0.3458861113,
0.519349575,
-0.0313186124,
-0.2185387164,
-0.5138340592,
-0.8938707709,
-0.2132026106,
-0.2397208214,
0.0601397976,
-0.284332782,
0.143051073,
0.2030069232,
0.0044975211,
-0.7477181554,
0.2169988453,
-0.1094655022,
-0.2298651338,
0.4981000125,
0.1841861457,
0.0117282132,
-0.0890114456,
-0.3121147156,
0.2243869454,
-0.7341662645,
-0.3474849164,
0.2682528794,
0.0485466011,
0.406131804,
0.6334465742,
-0.2897806168,
0.3288663328,
0.3950970769,
0.2409233898,
0.2041344643,
-0.1399676651,
-0.456158191,
0.2253536582,
0.6578918695,
0.4595359266,
0.2186281532,
-0.2728764415,
-0.3106528521,
0.310431838,
0.6096181273,
-0.7753466368,
-0.0358101688,
0.6945246458,
-0.4044065475,
-0.122344479,
-0.2754029036,
-0.8469975591,
-0.6511890292,
-0.5151930451,
0.5759012103,
0.0303504765,
-0.3030613065,
0.1741217077,
0.0421577506,
0.3012158573,
0.4755268693,
-0.5475724339,
0.3296580017,
0.6023482084,
0.6446244717,
-0.1080063805,
-0.3637829423,
-0.7287301421,
-0.0061728032,
-0.5056641102,
1.1061737537,
-0.7087278962,
-0.5327022076,
-0.2123622596,
0.128797248,
-0.1316712648,
-0.687222302,
0.306824863,
-0.5323488116,
0.4002569318,
-0.763348043,
-0.6589227319,
-0.16549851,
0.7502192259,
-0.6075721979,
0.726703763,
-0.314774394,
-0.6980342865,
0.317124933,
-0.6710253358,
-0.3384815156,
-0.0192486215,
-0.5920603275,
-0.4362019897,
-0.0360607281,
0.2966247201,
0.2076776177,
-0.2127911448,
0.617922008,
-0.4695263505,
-0.4260396957,
0.2825134993,
-0.4163892865,
0.7152894139,
0.2771122158,
-0.7241741419,
0.5397566557,
-0.5107720494,
-0.3337263465,
0.0917545781,
0.1299148351,
-0.2310609221,
-0.0071955561,
-0.3274147809,
0.3818341494,
-0.0463682264,
-0.5025399923,
0.0648133457,
-0.4087720215,
0.1910832673,
0.9853214025,
-0.0196635369,
0.301212728,
-0.6796877384,
0.6991059184,
0.0124521535,
0.2089894861,
0.2291361541,
-0.2090190947,
-0.8918501735,
-0.2121161968,
-0.2720195055,
0.4655634463,
-1.1120018959,
0.2408483475,
0.1204584762,
-0.426602751,
-0.4307819903,
0.1776259094,
0.3962953687,
0.4932483733,
0.5809730291,
-0.1210113242,
-0.5824744105,
-0.841648221,
0.0217545256,
-0.2353101373,
0.3386775255,
0.1885859519,
0.5505695939,
-0.3643990755,
0.9304303527,
-0.442468375,
-0.2764851153,
-0.2694092393,
0.4549063742,
-0.0661013871,
0.2799871564,
0.5626010895,
-0.698399961,
-0.1249940395,
-0.311645627,
-0.8473423719,
-0.2288300842,
-0.4123730361,
-0.2823776305,
0.7075630426,
0.7992678881,
-1.0410177708,
0.5105774403,
0.2168722451,
-0.3802735507,
0.8225619197,
-0.0711767897,
0.1805405021,
-0.7513111234,
0.0596545115,
-0.2188177407,
-0.1226336509,
-0.681022048,
0.1624630988,
-0.5627098083,
0.4173560143,
-0.3282416165,
0.7170056105,
-0.2536298931,
0.0476733111,
-0.5710734129,
0.3036668897,
0.0001039237,
0.4665619433,
0.5317179561,
0.4689851403,
0.2890695632,
-0.4293398559,
0.5349069238,
0.2410986274,
-0.0356172547,
0.7989257574,
-0.6151525974,
0.3800434768,
-0.3573214114,
0.5602027774,
-1.0572184324,
0.175571382,
0.6546460986,
-0.3178431094,
-0.2692495883,
0.2464369386,
-0.367045939,
-0.2824502885,
-0.5214173198,
0.3311136365,
-0.0416822471,
-0.7008440495,
0.6381542087,
0.1502881348,
-0.1574649513,
-0.8960520625,
-0.294911325,
0.3393003643,
-0.358420372,
-0.2152893096,
0.0624892749,
-0.4957939684,
-0.6045554876,
-0.0937156603,
-0.2261532843,
0.1271963865,
-0.0455522276,
0.2557415664,
0.2926561236,
-0.1943994462,
0.3988671601,
0.0170296263,
0.0349137783,
0.3501813114,
-0.0833023041,
0.7951885462,
-0.0605540089,
-0.465506047,
-0.0331714563,
0.4838214219,
0.5689327121,
-0.0937790424,
0.6696197391,
0.5133101344,
-0.4011895359,
-0.1942441463,
-1.0422137976,
-0.3786441684,
-0.4849230051,
0.2022266984,
-0.6144662499,
-0.7751052976,
0.6487242579,
0.1930861473,
0.2143280953,
0.2027769983,
0.8524093032,
-0.0779564455,
0.7335777283,
0.0857981965,
0.200688526,
0.0845977962,
-0.0514291041,
0.1853471696,
-0.3462510407,
-0.3668143451,
-0.6492803693,
-0.2110912055,
-0.3202489913,
-0.3733286262,
0.0415547453,
-0.384013623,
-0.1867174357,
0.0604489408,
-0.3046226501,
0.5449228883,
0.2753610611,
0.2047739923,
0.3146753013,
-0.3104241192,
-0.3285664916,
0.043166656,
-0.342494905,
-0.6193977594,
0.8663659692,
0.1370927393,
0.5595015883,
0.2567299902,
0.69824332,
0.3337174654,
0.6924434304,
-0.7280244231,
0.7621204257,
0.2105091661,
-0.884442091,
-0.5954357982,
-0.3304054439,
-0.8695088029,
0.8385416269,
-0.3215411007,
-0.5514758825,
0.416241914,
0.1748429984,
-0.3617926538,
0.2807863355,
-0.2884422243,
0.8430274725,
-0.1099632904,
-0.5141190886,
-0.342890352,
-0.7076089382,
0.4480377734,
-0.1657709777,
0.1826823801,
0.1910766214,
0.2848851085,
0.6158995032,
-0.6272697449,
0.9426138401,
-0.2280170768,
-0.5575444698,
0.3065356612,
0.167220518,
0.5562607646,
0.2435408235,
-0.010119576,
-0.0756872669,
-0.017496543,
-0.2267056108,
-0.6699427962,
0.6587854028,
-0.7551601529,
-1.1691676378,
-0.4877769351,
-0.3579531312,
-0.2629960179,
0.1285255104,
0.2935698926,
0.3777865767,
-0.5322983265,
0.0160649493,
0.675337553,
-0.217010662,
0.4379196763,
0.7193786502,
-0.4195733368,
-0.3015123904,
0.6913668513,
0.1016117409,
0.1853020787,
0.1121961847,
0.1766740829,
-0.6540224552,
-0.5299842954,
-0.4257571995,
0.1943782419,
-0.9470083714,
-0.1025374904,
-1.0454515219,
-0.1779094785,
-0.5062299371,
-0.2606838346,
-0.4105072021,
-0.135477826,
-0.317427367,
-0.3454059362,
-0.0841722116,
0.6599597931,
-0.2743372619,
0.2636297941,
-0.4448572099,
0.7779248357,
0.5768548846,
0.0477489308,
0.0711308643,
-0.4639354646,
0.1762448698,
0.0010232647,
-0.4898347855,
-0.9028719664,
0.2713394761,
-0.3759200275,
0.8467398286,
0.5521549582,
0.3625925779,
0.7438870072,
-0.3151910901,
0.6085720062,
0.0650582239,
-1.1427006721,
0.2792688906,
-0.1088106856,
0.0570999496,
0.5698477626,
0.4854131937,
-0.3960888684,
-0.7328614593,
-0.5086797476,
-0.6004213691,
0.4916149676,
0.1321516186,
-0.0691052154,
-0.2740177214,
0.1424831748,
0.3244855106,
0.2700468004,
-0.894718051,
-0.0346244425,
-0.5365990996,
0.1942521781,
-0.2059228867,
-0.2173418701,
-0.4313521683,
-0.2830319703,
0.598795712,
-0.1263501793,
-0.1284289062,
0.5808018446,
-0.4618934095,
-0.361705035,
0.3841751218,
0.9374246001,
0.9207366705,
-0.2470618933,
0.6307832003,
0.3255685866,
-0.1538729966,
0.3932422101,
0.0209184177,
-0.0972341746,
0.0414309725,
0.4163552523,
0.6164168715,
-0.2689611316,
-0.6179969907,
0.3383367658,
-0.130759716,
-0.5758021474,
-0.3192394972,
-0.1364620328,
0.155767411,
0.4291463196,
0.2574820817,
0.0492061414,
0.210997805,
-0.5802406073,
0.4749376178,
0.7036909461,
-0.3275344968,
-0.1088010147,
0.5071886778,
0.1630992889,
-0.1489236504,
0.5237987638,
-0.3035153449,
-0.5958217382,
0.8149515986,
0.4641377032,
0.9062042236,
-0.414741993,
0.5300980806,
0.0559414141,
0.6092363,
-0.0902428925,
0.336019367,
0.0096686566,
-1.0805084705,
-0.3666664064,
-0.2757242024,
-0.5851871967,
0.5171265602,
-0.4416030347,
0.1784959733,
-0.4073908627,
-0.1115608215,
-0.0329897553,
0.010399892,
-0.4883273244,
0.2950325012,
0.1883916855,
0.5736004114,
-0.9040586352,
0.7737482786,
0.5907341242,
-0.3023391664,
-0.1433921456,
0.2976678908,
0.1552072018,
-0.4930445552,
0.4747736752,
0.227857843,
-0.7384596467,
-0.3835574985,
-0.8067990541,
-0.389667958,
0.6522731781,
0.4705236256,
-0.5072640181,
0.2627946734,
0.0575657748,
0.6285803914,
-0.362059921,
0.3699889779,
0.5235193968,
0.7122352719,
0.3646354079,
-0.822259903,
0.4065092802,
-0.1310615689,
-0.5596055388,
-0.1992305219,
-0.6893327236,
0.7871354222,
-0.4112732708,
-0.0107949376,
0.016105907,
0.5459495783,
0.4668717682,
0.5543993115,
0.9304574728,
0.3615591824,
0.5991643071,
0.2688603997,
0.492630899,
0.1233176515,
0.1551674157,
1.4393002987,
-0.7917730212,
0.5986198783,
0.7007765174,
0.1446179003,
0.2698056996,
0.6146765351,
0.1019218341,
0.3086181581,
0.514555037,
-0.1034860238,
-0.6562967896,
-0.2859787643,
-0.3164079487,
0.7212902308,
0.265429765,
-0.0161713883,
-0.2953083813,
-0.000096864,
0.2156904191,
0.3931271732,
0.1019456238,
0.7021153569,
-0.0325343795,
-0.9703199863,
0.6196622252,
-0.0260901358,
0.5380433202,
-0.279778868,
-0.1301730573,
-0.5582019687,
0.0076491288,
-0.1582935154,
-0.4138046503,
0.4168036282,
-0.1673404425,
-0.0626278594,
-0.2491051406,
0.4122921228,
-0.459510237,
-0.3224101961,
0.5701210499,
0.7487033606,
0.1546947509,
-0.1109635681,
-0.6082246304,
0.0379892513,
-0.2052661926,
-0.4584608674,
0.0876597241,
0.3531646132,
-0.2125888467,
0.6331728697,
0.5108500123,
-0.0105255302,
-0.1818360388,
0.3493346274,
1.1087607145,
-0.6668865085,
-0.4849952757,
-1.1184304953,
-0.0247559939,
-0.1133590564,
-0.0459009036,
0.6147457361,
0.4446009398,
0.7807444334,
0.0652889386,
0.6860694885,
0.3027155697,
0.2797807753,
-0.539434135,
0.6985695362,
-0.5839552283,
0.309107393,
-0.47202003,
-0.8959101439,
-0.1823330224,
0.8345327377,
-0.2912103236,
0.0499870591,
0.9041315913,
0.9317674637,
0.1019436046,
0.213473022,
0.3653923869,
0.3602104485,
0.4544796944,
0.5841040015,
1.26504004,
0.0943180695,
0.5487571955,
-0.0052555311,
-0.0283805467,
-0.0897726789,
-0.7616271377,
-1.289259553,
-0.3982122242,
-0.3721116781,
-0.3557660282,
0.091723226,
1.2909007072,
0.3976897597,
-0.8442943096,
-0.2419695556,
0.1357746869,
0.4802393615,
-0.1321549565,
-0.2018096745,
0.2885154188,
-0.2558306456,
-0.5974435806,
0.2881638706,
0.0959895626,
-0.1501389146,
-0.4796247482,
-0.2848811448,
-0.4409276247,
0.5740099549,
0.581566453,
0.1032979935,
-1.0765558481,
-0.5078251958,
0.011312684,
-0.0463333279,
0.1115215644,
0.894281745,
-0.8107023835,
0.4117076993,
0.4552668333,
0.4545169771,
0.2610546947,
0.1050678045,
0.4543258846,
-0.5298424959,
0.1398325861,
0.094310075,
0.2534612119,
0.0766416937,
-0.3740083575,
0.3794412911,
0.3557805717,
-0.4224211574,
-1.0000181198,
0.1842048019,
-0.7470276952,
-0.783184588,
1.0730662346,
0.0610454232,
0.2735547721,
-0.5522155762,
-0.3704257905,
0.2521512806,
-0.198126927,
1.1071884632,
1.0694373846,
-0.1708007306,
-0.2188513577,
-0.2908289731,
0.4633534849,
0.7001650333,
-1.0163296461,
0.1815700531,
0.6910859942,
0.0894891024,
0.2046650797,
1.1535159349,
0.0724187344,
0.113057524,
-0.1088378057,
0.0355069228,
0.0388206728,
-0.698281467,
-0.2556635737,
0.2748051286,
-0.0943061635,
-0.0686059371
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11930v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11930v1 | A Critical Study of What Code-LLMs (Do Not) Learn | 2024-06-17T13:11:17 | 2024-06-17T13:11:17 | Abhinav Anand, Shweta Verma, Krishna Narasimhan, Mira Mezini | cs.SE | cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL | Large Language Models trained on code corpora (code-LLMs) have demonstrated
impressive performance in various coding assistance tasks. However, despite
their increased size and training dataset, code-LLMs still have limitations
such as suggesting codes with syntactic errors, variable misuse etc. Some
studies argue that code-LLMs perform well on coding tasks because they use
self-attention and hidden representations to encode relations among input
tokens. However, previous works have not studied what code properties are not
encoded by code-LLMs. In this paper, we conduct a fine-grained analysis of
attention maps and hidden representations of code-LLMs. Our study indicates
that code-LLMs only encode relations among specific subsets of input tokens.
Specifically, by categorizing input tokens into syntactic tokens and
identifiers, we found that models encode relations among syntactic tokens and
among identifiers, but they fail to encode relations between syntactic tokens
and identifiers. We also found that fine-tuned models encode these relations
poorly compared to their pre-trained counterparts. Additionally, larger models
with billions of parameters encode significantly less information about code
than models with only a few hundred million parameters. | [
-0.335169971,
-0.3903206587,
0.6453811526,
0.1109566614,
-0.0273584239,
0.335305512,
-0.5037770271,
-0.5940003395,
0.0913344324,
0.4470082521,
-0.4236028492,
-0.6582064629,
-0.7687453628,
0.3706440032,
-0.3382028341,
1.112459898,
-0.0433920883,
0.171125114,
-0.3694879413,
-0.1131908968,
-0.1535762548,
-0.9347836375,
0.0013279064,
-0.0920321569,
0.4868431091,
0.3389048278,
0.4669183791,
0.659299612,
0.7241073251,
0.2453700155,
-0.2489980608,
0.2108434588,
-0.6562392712,
-0.2655301392,
-0.0283342768,
-0.8738021851,
-0.2581092417,
-0.0103229377,
0.4183982909,
0.7946464419,
0.420160532,
0.5715523958,
0.0815466568,
0.5626846552,
-0.685090661,
0.6709276438,
-0.7136303186,
0.1627946645,
-0.014984211,
-0.2426548451,
-0.503238976,
-0.305024296,
-0.3105958402,
-0.2319045514,
0.2101394832,
0.1312960684,
0.8182713985,
0.5377884507,
-0.1606958359,
-0.6499470472,
-0.6566427946,
0.6644629836,
-0.6804971695,
0.1409327239,
0.6644172668,
-0.1155026108,
0.0040395916,
-0.2888049483,
-0.2030645013,
-0.3105238676,
-0.4370096028,
-0.1912477612,
-0.0478911437,
0.2618353367,
0.446593821,
0.4832400382,
-0.3841764033,
0.2490138561,
-0.4744515419,
-0.1550007612,
0.3344402611,
0.1808030605,
0.0683434159,
-0.290915668,
-0.6870773435,
0.1386803389,
-0.6120949388,
0.0694291815,
0.0712539777,
0.1383747905,
-0.4078764915,
0.6765722632,
0.1897060722,
0.6116017699,
0.2439349741,
-0.3628714383,
0.3036634326,
-0.2998050451,
-0.5098705888,
-0.2904429436,
0.8010906577,
-0.1030123383,
0.6360574365,
-0.5493617654,
-0.2580620646,
0.3734134734,
0.1397915781,
-0.4209308028,
0.029012192,
0.1973243356,
-0.5856614709,
-0.2405682802,
0.0208633896,
-0.4739139676,
-0.1868927777,
-0.2543560565,
0.2414680123,
-0.1935910285,
0.00363006,
0.0157229938,
-0.0262105297,
0.2770796418,
0.0004395631,
-0.8239790797,
0.2506597042,
0.5241525173,
0.5115600228,
-0.2848627269,
-0.2450611889,
-0.2617541552,
0.0474107787,
-0.4563682973,
0.4444455504,
-1.0197284222,
-0.1735166907,
0.0352115706,
0.2776464224,
-0.2504915595,
-0.853012383,
-0.0063257148,
-0.7271276116,
-0.4812436998,
-0.2743976712,
-0.6447805166,
-0.063857168,
0.0650004521,
-0.5328478217,
0.5741653442,
0.2028833479,
-0.6264716387,
0.1435041875,
-0.2882445753,
-0.3600196838,
-0.1615006179,
-0.5920585394,
-0.2424595058,
0.5101857185,
0.0759634674,
0.7048075199,
-0.0403894931,
0.4123226702,
-0.4588937759,
-0.7590025663,
0.5409442186,
-0.2222506106,
0.4732297063,
0.1917375326,
-0.2288663834,
-0.0233674515,
-0.8086773753,
-0.1437589079,
0.2234509438,
-0.6869770885,
-0.0910047591,
-0.261990279,
-0.1536116004,
0.3485071659,
0.4120822549,
-0.3367518485,
0.4241088331,
-0.2260786593,
0.4900111854,
0.6014302969,
-0.1578344554,
0.7271081805,
-0.2299059331,
0.7970232368,
0.2929190993,
-0.2407303154,
-0.1874661595,
-0.1183119118,
-1.0270041227,
-0.0205696039,
0.4280632436,
0.3101069331,
-0.7369702458,
0.2096888721,
-0.2004033029,
-0.1367473304,
-0.4894604683,
0.3579506278,
0.8109078407,
0.0217281356,
0.2624418736,
-0.3141762316,
-0.4352106154,
-0.908146143,
-0.2872453332,
-0.1338508874,
0.136710003,
0.2353332043,
0.5106487274,
-0.2447422296,
0.5563047528,
-0.3313739896,
-0.397762984,
-0.3567172885,
-0.1040618643,
-0.0813548192,
0.2941223681,
0.5789812803,
-0.3280512989,
-0.1888996214,
-0.1479728669,
-0.8129646778,
0.0396347344,
-0.1732336134,
0.3551488817,
0.177269876,
0.7104821801,
-0.370796442,
0.5381991863,
0.7531148195,
-0.2701997757,
0.3188755512,
-0.3442344666,
-0.3705701232,
-0.4328047037,
-0.0490424708,
-0.0914344341,
-0.2247145325,
-0.3837366402,
0.357957989,
0.469989419,
-0.26125741,
-0.3687309027,
0.4541456401,
-0.9000220299,
-0.5666306019,
-0.1780097336,
0.0602545552,
-0.0801071748,
1.3015670776,
0.1678598672,
0.7550829053,
0.5389534831,
-0.8276078701,
-0.0508834198,
0.0984171927,
-0.0183426682,
0.0997341424,
-0.3521945775,
0.411911726,
-0.1496044546,
-0.1930740178,
-0.7482612729,
-0.1355585307,
0.1917896271,
-0.4842831194,
0.6323727369,
-0.314293474,
-0.7768854499,
-0.1594991386,
-0.2620387971,
0.4301795959,
0.5537680984,
-0.4911226332,
0.2006250769,
0.4340175986,
0.3250572085,
-0.3402262032,
-0.893693924,
-0.1190558076,
-0.0197033361,
-0.1091047004,
0.1261600554,
-0.0608398952,
-0.1888155788,
0.0901616812,
-0.2773300409,
-0.2468327731,
0.0738829896,
0.6128414869,
0.062512286,
-0.1953600794,
0.4532304108,
-0.2919902503,
-0.0228171498,
0.2410562485,
0.0391292349,
0.4742711186,
-0.2146905959,
-0.3488915265,
-0.1862725914,
0.1526972204,
0.7008205056,
-0.4317212701,
0.8365032077,
0.3901732862,
-0.2031547278,
-0.3131559491,
-0.3621016145,
0.0791982114,
-0.4670164287,
0.5526769161,
-0.3371628225,
-1.0299761295,
0.6378287673,
-0.1149047464,
-0.2269441336,
0.2752007544,
0.4388745129,
-0.0894797072,
0.5569418669,
0.8438389301,
-0.1790763438,
0.2833871841,
-0.4230137765,
0.1020338535,
-1.0033228397,
-0.3849066794,
-0.552978456,
-0.3304714262,
-0.7116658092,
-0.478861779,
0.0933559313,
0.0555246547,
-0.1199121848,
0.4405182898,
-0.4284617603,
0.3153260052,
0.3813425004,
0.0212858114,
0.2382154316,
-0.068055138,
0.092203021,
-0.0555919744,
-0.9122374654,
-0.4537595212,
1.0856729746,
0.4461588264,
1.1825004816,
-0.1476517916,
0.780112803,
0.0739469677,
-0.1331496537,
-0.866228044,
0.5303385258,
-0.2335656881,
-0.3591893315,
0.0339916721,
-0.5177592039,
-0.9567236304,
-0.0241331775,
-0.0356842093,
-0.4286279082,
0.5635555387,
0.0104380604,
-0.3543354571,
0.3428735137,
-0.96952492,
0.6985833049,
-0.2505627871,
-0.2785845697,
0.1282559931,
-0.4406363666,
0.2277584821,
-0.3025634587,
0.3704071343,
0.1003171653,
-0.1311528385,
0.6539247036,
-0.1995967329,
1.1330884695,
0.061540246,
-0.2280037701,
0.1888493001,
0.2436903268,
0.5074180365,
0.0167053733,
0.1070118025,
0.3725935817,
-0.0666297749,
-0.3672602177,
-0.3774656653,
0.7025649548,
-0.8241491914,
-0.5090616941,
-0.2278174609,
-0.4343504906,
-0.331830889,
0.0787017196,
0.2262655199,
0.5594668984,
0.2246714234,
0.104481183,
0.6456993222,
-0.4691610336,
0.6569935083,
0.3715615571,
-0.0877999216,
0.0510658287,
0.8892310262,
0.3201282322,
0.4511137307,
0.3335624337,
-0.3536401987,
0.1571994573,
-0.4913817346,
-0.1565828174,
0.4276717603,
-0.9326446652,
-0.3507825136,
-0.5698889494,
-0.3934755325,
-0.2758284211,
0.0862281099,
-0.2020037621,
-0.222357288,
-0.7388831377,
-0.1482239664,
0.252192229,
1.0974575281,
0.1885145903,
0.0832943693,
-0.876068294,
0.5703037977,
0.1558681577,
0.4809829593,
0.2131458521,
-0.5658839345,
-0.7018786669,
-0.2252309918,
-0.0973286778,
-0.9052032232,
0.3539641201,
0.0980245396,
0.3605186045,
0.3224461377,
0.1242036074,
0.7517862916,
-0.5077841282,
0.5920908451,
-0.1485457271,
-0.925118804,
0.3082286119,
-0.0235539395,
0.5298649669,
0.4101430774,
0.1231032684,
0.0063100262,
-0.7408614159,
-0.614649713,
-0.3580685854,
0.9154553413,
0.0876780525,
0.4669377208,
-0.2915112972,
0.5650359988,
0.1127653867,
0.3049396276,
-0.9979630113,
-0.4267640412,
0.1756661236,
-0.2080188394,
0.0734577775,
-0.5765160918,
0.1070565656,
-0.0863957778,
0.0145170167,
-0.0143865012,
0.6307222247,
0.1482958943,
-0.3681812882,
-0.1666739732,
0.2950947881,
0.6609542966,
0.5778533816,
-0.0876818746,
0.5177419782,
0.0917110294,
-0.4176284075,
-0.0091891242,
-0.2480371445,
0.19475393,
0.096954979,
0.7545694709,
0.8728561401,
0.560849607,
-0.6622341871,
0.6106953025,
0.0742174387,
-0.0392167792,
-0.3327261806,
0.4024974704,
0.2251417786,
0.1676203161,
0.1063933671,
0.2960400283,
-0.1361951977,
-0.7165991664,
-0.1926546991,
0.4800150096,
-0.5214354992,
-0.5861726999,
0.5559638143,
0.0849435031,
-0.3370283246,
0.2507494092,
-0.2661197186,
-0.3317911327,
0.8838258386,
0.4815906286,
0.6794547439,
0.2436400503,
-0.0642747059,
0.2749527991,
0.5284813046,
0.179198578,
-0.0294214953,
-0.2101640552,
-0.4777521193,
-0.3076074123,
-0.6203662753,
-0.1208444238,
0.3455285132,
-0.7977886796,
0.102656655,
-0.7133879662,
-0.1340803951,
-0.2689647079,
-0.0991088003,
-1.1622955799,
0.1826757044,
0.0303400587,
0.6496690512,
-0.5479491353,
0.9074639678,
0.4796745181,
-0.6047888398,
-1.0627923012,
0.135962829,
-0.4435015023,
-1.0455766916,
0.9457258582,
0.2293278724,
0.0483308397,
-0.1162698492,
-0.7174292207,
-1.0032185316,
0.671975255,
0.6247182488,
-0.852388382,
-0.3767113984,
0.2337493896,
0.58288306,
-0.3289277256,
0.039432358,
0.1954215765,
0.2353191674,
-0.2736178041,
-1.0750265121,
0.016378995,
0.0161485411,
0.1160911247,
0.0278599262,
-0.8786292672,
0.8001868725,
-0.4544477165,
-0.4161271155,
-0.1706852168,
0.2071766257,
-0.0788359791,
0.0513997041,
-0.1466267109,
0.3218784034,
0.4150652885,
0.0125237694,
1.1148766279,
-0.4026894867,
0.6025511622,
1.122510314,
-0.1902558059,
0.7608385682,
0.513959527,
-0.2234718651,
0.3732427061,
0.5932535529,
-0.2153821886,
0.5432108641,
0.301014483,
0.4284614921,
-0.3038297892,
0.1845189631,
-0.3209899366,
0.4723097086,
0.3017450273,
-0.8452618122,
-0.0243879408,
-0.0320007093,
-0.0230644699,
0.1662910283,
-0.4690008461,
1.1293985844,
0.3747085631,
-0.4684509635,
0.9614423513,
0.0294186305,
0.747335732,
-0.3420683146,
-0.0430922508,
-0.3315080106,
0.0768855959,
-0.3756626546,
-0.4446340501,
0.2934617698,
0.1904966831,
-0.2865345776,
0.0862042457,
0.5916594267,
-0.3503464162,
-0.487522006,
0.587998271,
0.4733816385,
0.1949534714,
0.2095216811,
-0.255692929,
0.3660880327,
-0.0460324697,
-0.08644858,
0.5097624063,
0.5834354162,
0.1440809071,
0.6336809993,
0.3022677004,
0.3247727752,
0.1686009318,
-0.0095664011,
0.7863152623,
-0.7940430045,
-0.1367575824,
-0.9201646447,
0.1556580812,
0.4075080752,
-0.0796624571,
0.7076200843,
0.4109988511,
1.0613356829,
-0.5097626448,
0.6073447466,
0.4742473066,
0.0310693961,
-0.7372621298,
0.3652442694,
-0.43577528,
0.5665037632,
-0.1192862093,
-0.8619384766,
-0.1906050295,
0.5428122878,
-0.3937989473,
0.1384767741,
0.7234295607,
0.6119986773,
0.034552779,
-0.4353620708,
0.678011775,
0.2331589013,
-0.2165257037,
0.9761835337,
0.8636433482,
-0.3075166345,
0.55776757,
0.0780906528,
0.0333156176,
-0.2990234792,
-0.35769853,
-1.4351359606,
-0.3973233402,
-0.2027282417,
-0.0816300809,
0.0086658252,
0.7873879671,
0.6938323379,
-0.6441805959,
-0.0565797426,
-0.1868697852,
0.0990379006,
0.067544736,
-0.1791542172,
0.4391399026,
-0.6033874154,
-0.6119892597,
0.1567620933,
0.4796203971,
-0.0271002594,
-0.633243084,
-0.0531664155,
0.281167388,
0.0430480465,
0.2807122469,
0.0925617144,
-0.9428081512,
-0.1585724652,
0.2889549732,
-0.3631151021,
0.3725849688,
0.6453649402,
-0.9652180076,
0.2601458132,
0.1881643385,
0.6622146964,
0.2732591033,
-0.2487464249,
0.209181264,
-0.9498550296,
0.2433018088,
0.139003858,
0.3891007602,
0.2483588159,
-0.583329618,
0.3342417479,
-0.0414290801,
-0.3902103603,
-0.6604364514,
0.2454429865,
-0.7487735152,
-0.394467473,
1.4089314938,
-0.3701936007,
-0.3351173699,
-0.1149071008,
-0.1108973101,
0.1987242997,
-0.2460004091,
0.5905897021,
0.5893085003,
-0.1595860124,
-0.1703445613,
-0.5143443942,
0.5746639967,
0.2185926139,
-0.5513538122,
0.2638822198,
0.2599582374,
0.4258083105,
0.3001807928,
0.5698299408,
-0.3147053719,
0.238547191,
-0.1138843894,
-0.0362827368,
-0.2220221758,
-0.2923939526,
-0.7138893008,
0.4531780183,
0.4562242925,
-0.3263624907
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11503v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11503v1 | GeoGPT4V: Towards Geometric Multi-modal Large Language Models with Geometric Image Generation | 2024-06-17T13:04:27 | 2024-06-17T13:04:27 | Shihao Cai, Keqin Bao, Hangyu Guo, Jizhi Zhang, Jun Song, Bo Zheng | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Large language models have seen widespread adoption in math problem-solving.
However, in geometry problems that usually require visual aids for better
understanding, even the most advanced multi-modal models currently still face
challenges in effectively using image information. High-quality data is crucial
for enhancing the geometric capabilities of multi-modal models, yet existing
open-source datasets and related efforts are either too challenging for direct
model learning or suffer from misalignment between text and images. To overcome
this issue, we introduce a novel pipeline that leverages GPT-4 and GPT-4V to
generate relatively basic geometry problems with aligned text and images,
facilitating model learning. We have produced a dataset of 4.9K geometry
problems and combined it with 19K open-source data to form our GeoGPT4V
dataset. Experimental results demonstrate that the GeoGPT4V dataset
significantly improves the geometry performance of various models on the
MathVista and MathVision benchmarks. The code is available at
https://github.com/Lanyu0303/GeoGPT4V_Project | [
-0.3143827617,
-0.761783123,
0.9057804942,
0.0064995387,
-0.182836026,
-0.269993782,
-0.2213329971,
-0.2402905524,
-0.2792509198,
0.3507853448,
-0.4257518351,
-0.7628563046,
-0.4897366166,
-0.0335407481,
-0.1206712797,
0.92228055,
-0.1641528606,
0.2130566537,
-0.1385926157,
-0.1535492837,
-0.5359097719,
-0.4046126604,
-0.3620426059,
0.0144176278,
0.388556689,
0.177054584,
0.8663690686,
0.6872655749,
0.6484444141,
0.3382386267,
0.4210410416,
0.0866066515,
-0.4721385837,
0.0525398292,
0.137333259,
-0.2152268887,
-0.1838555187,
0.120387055,
0.802919209,
0.4063340425,
-0.2353186905,
0.037299376,
-0.0703770965,
0.4384170175,
-0.2703898549,
0.6241058111,
-0.5085350275,
-0.0413312167,
-0.4808469117,
-0.0419587605,
0.0625743195,
-0.4888034165,
0.2541216314,
-1.1796299219,
0.328423053,
-0.0252621714,
0.8121327758,
0.352645278,
-0.4260539412,
-0.2935041785,
-0.5040200353,
0.6444559693,
-0.5382254124,
0.7174500227,
0.3269085884,
0.4664160907,
-0.0387542136,
-0.6262427568,
-0.4100531638,
0.1839680225,
0.2366885543,
0.2592006624,
-0.0993551686,
-0.1925094128,
0.4907330871,
0.3300978541,
-0.7391756177,
-0.1963973641,
-0.6090703011,
-0.3738107383,
0.0773017853,
0.0884214789,
0.3275131881,
-0.4839100242,
-0.2523462474,
-0.1270125955,
-0.9367662072,
0.0072453856,
0.7201094627,
0.1708208621,
-0.1446080357,
0.7555195093,
0.1426361203,
0.8457036018,
-0.3637478352,
-0.0866858214,
0.3722304106,
-0.5556247234,
-0.2067633122,
-0.3718772829,
0.7617135048,
0.1518753469,
0.040258538,
0.2172707319,
-0.2348153144,
0.0980053917,
-0.0073620193,
-0.8939625621,
-0.6585714221,
-0.2135245949,
-0.1651013792,
-0.1326818466,
-0.0344792791,
-0.9480463862,
-0.1985470653,
-0.5709986687,
0.5177349448,
-0.6236772537,
-0.280803889,
0.2466805726,
0.066909045,
0.2748482525,
0.4753370881,
-0.6217569709,
-0.1806454509,
0.5719256401,
0.9773176908,
0.2105070204,
-0.2141833752,
-0.706835866,
0.2657680511,
-0.3543622792,
0.6367688775,
-0.7489459515,
-0.2351505905,
-0.0404347107,
-0.0354793295,
0.214704752,
-0.1031456813,
0.6054535508,
-0.1701209098,
0.7778332829,
-0.4817561209,
-0.0823587999,
-0.3456688225,
0.38978827,
-0.9484493732,
1.1588177681,
0.0918368921,
-0.7586817145,
0.258466512,
-0.6544075608,
-0.0954181999,
0.3159440458,
-0.5868905187,
-0.6269475818,
0.1466962844,
0.7058522701,
0.3012435436,
-0.4369734228,
0.2369369715,
-0.2925968468,
0.0618996844,
-0.1692928672,
-0.525157392,
0.2468500435,
0.1267685294,
-0.1944496334,
0.1315817833,
-0.4791787267,
-0.0107820909,
0.360820353,
-0.3712711036,
-0.4049293101,
-0.1453512758,
0.0981338099,
0.3660355806,
0.203783676,
-0.5613799691,
0.2789000869,
-0.1261247844,
0.4836865067,
0.7679567337,
-0.232932955,
0.3493048549,
-0.1102400571,
0.5593296289,
-0.0774867237,
0.1313637644,
-0.382355839,
-0.845979929,
-0.3744859695,
-0.4501743615,
0.0839290395,
0.3215824664,
-1.2963271141,
-0.2417983413,
-0.4561662674,
-0.3005038202,
-0.1164320186,
0.0827848613,
0.3539109528,
0.7083011866,
0.3489817977,
-0.2098015845,
-0.2031752169,
-0.7236804962,
-0.0197659787,
0.1660144925,
-0.210343942,
0.5739077926,
0.3599703908,
0.0550575256,
0.6667243838,
-0.7756127119,
-0.3786775172,
-0.0256696176,
0.2864794135,
0.1437916011,
0.2725755274,
0.7352743745,
-0.7126469612,
-0.2269271463,
0.1868023276,
-0.8240551353,
-0.0888375565,
0.2121710926,
-0.2183966935,
0.1616102308,
0.2028116137,
-0.5433126092,
0.2975893319,
0.8665335178,
-0.3465922177,
0.5527966619,
-0.2970987856,
0.3044244945,
-1.3234118223,
-0.0499102697,
0.5461367369,
-0.4171116948,
-0.3590340018,
-0.0733544976,
0.0625004023,
-0.7448644638,
-0.3221282959,
0.0867375135,
-0.6629000306,
-0.3439683318,
0.1088351831,
-0.043455217,
0.0683412328,
0.4176827073,
0.0115639661,
0.8368685842,
0.852039814,
-0.0994728431,
0.7062912583,
0.3648337722,
-0.2947966754,
0.6872835755,
-0.661428988,
0.1095084921,
-0.1858410835,
0.2561944425,
-0.7427766323,
-0.5739402175,
0.3026658595,
-0.1495651901,
0.0416324772,
-0.4575281143,
-0.4238599241,
-0.2787228525,
-0.2437776476,
0.8492152095,
0.2140679657,
-0.6351145506,
0.6430844069,
0.3736202717,
-0.3676940501,
-0.3450055122,
-0.4164861441,
0.0973851234,
-0.186234355,
-0.7100266814,
0.0043975837,
0.0225694887,
0.3304189742,
0.3054735959,
0.0326476172,
-0.175903514,
-0.4634754658,
0.1498003006,
0.3768800795,
-0.2836640775,
0.2124424726,
-0.2899353206,
-0.1263370365,
-0.0117476592,
-0.7149006128,
0.5426948071,
-0.4718878269,
-0.5915108323,
-0.4353529811,
0.3922251761,
0.6283769011,
-0.5887445807,
0.1421081126,
0.7016035318,
-0.5743050575,
0.1328842044,
-0.4160465896,
0.0418415144,
-0.4663695991,
0.4916062951,
-0.5701755285,
-0.7072591186,
0.2638688982,
-0.2002804875,
0.0349966809,
0.1969303936,
0.5471225381,
0.1774590462,
0.9973826408,
0.5695562363,
0.081675142,
0.5527168512,
-0.2286032289,
0.3614044785,
-0.5421079993,
-0.3494947255,
-0.3965860903,
-0.2266377658,
-0.448242873,
-0.7499558926,
0.7650929689,
-0.2184575349,
-0.2216314226,
0.13614963,
-0.5395770669,
0.6517013311,
0.4982597828,
0.2188966721,
0.347412467,
0.3461428583,
-0.1487233788,
-0.4279648066,
-0.592854917,
-0.2470250577,
1.1746585369,
0.1974145472,
1.0309634209,
0.3443420529,
0.2238467783,
-0.292467773,
-0.122891821,
-0.6547169685,
0.2602116764,
-0.0140547697,
-0.3162161112,
-0.2646935284,
-0.8199028373,
-0.823810637,
0.2263445854,
-0.3463182449,
-0.187456578,
-0.1639517397,
0.2724336982,
-0.2221511751,
0.4941364825,
-0.7547953129,
1.064032197,
-0.4563791454,
-0.3421418071,
0.0708684698,
-0.2870820463,
0.4608027339,
-0.1605160236,
0.2484797239,
-0.0701727644,
0.1079547703,
0.2883127332,
-0.3519729972,
0.5891458988,
-0.3460511267,
-0.2772661448,
0.1026800275,
0.1741485745,
0.3321740329,
0.2967608273,
0.3592205346,
0.3363577724,
-0.1238274798,
-0.3723641634,
-0.6116497517,
0.9084823132,
-0.8272438049,
-0.2864134908,
-0.4113951921,
-0.8350905776,
0.0134033058,
0.3980340362,
0.2358626425,
1.0397905111,
0.0677295029,
0.1807730049,
0.5379021764,
-0.3950106204,
0.399097383,
-0.1092355922,
-0.3498550057,
-0.645539701,
1.0029886961,
0.0846773311,
0.0431876965,
-0.0986496583,
0.1517761946,
-0.5398883224,
-0.4474623203,
-0.6919723749,
0.3570694625,
-0.5915637016,
-0.4951143861,
-0.22702685,
-0.0615890138,
-0.2433601916,
0.0276368409,
-0.5035144091,
-0.3025390208,
-0.0545074306,
0.1272878647,
0.3634036779,
1.1519573927,
0.0387193933,
0.251519233,
-0.7027982473,
0.2995710969,
0.3773091137,
0.5673370957,
-0.4923467636,
-0.0264303666,
-0.0561428368,
-0.0775850266,
-0.5034475327,
-0.6395821571,
0.4156903028,
0.1622785181,
0.2569127381,
0.1577326059,
-0.4677525461,
0.6932233572,
-0.8199689388,
0.7252597213,
0.5264441967,
-1.0494378805,
0.4763633311,
-0.8155522346,
0.4447806478,
-0.0224697869,
0.3850838542,
-0.4868190885,
-0.0049105641,
-0.2676948607,
-0.6142696738,
0.4516295791,
0.3705217838,
-0.1043742523,
0.3906258345,
0.410269022,
0.1514105797,
0.0764394701,
-0.9309798479,
0.3629465997,
-0.7990170121,
-0.5344477296,
0.0566595346,
0.0900160521,
-0.3301336467,
-0.1635582,
0.4403506219,
-0.4668452144,
0.3476307094,
0.1337791979,
-0.2099315226,
0.091618143,
-0.0246067513,
0.664065659,
0.8136941195,
0.2059684694,
0.1291724145,
-0.1873618811,
-0.5222546458,
-0.0598894209,
0.3077275455,
0.1410489678,
-0.2008522898,
0.0186036751,
0.816272676,
0.092712447,
-0.2395113111,
0.7884174585,
-0.3414232731,
-0.4724759161,
-0.2937117517,
-0.4378356934,
0.0088395309,
0.3403019607,
0.2850491107,
0.0817419142,
0.0283832382,
-0.1047643274,
0.0948638618,
0.5346278548,
-0.0380824432,
-0.672927022,
0.8098284602,
0.2813037038,
0.1081932709,
0.773655951,
-0.046903573,
-0.5890586376,
0.1784839034,
0.5183539391,
0.3721960783,
-0.0905070081,
0.1994442195,
0.5188866258,
0.3271511197,
-0.1470135301,
0.3758639395,
0.2602515221,
-0.5178788304,
-0.8512265086,
-0.3700532615,
-0.2753174007,
0.3452223837,
-0.2823422551,
0.506277144,
-0.409881115,
0.0120643973,
-0.4063746929,
-0.2829291523,
-0.8979821801,
-0.0857310146,
0.3451972604,
0.3475570977,
-0.8822331429,
0.6938966513,
0.7592735291,
-0.3922704458,
-0.9979147911,
-0.0959207341,
0.1262413412,
-0.7051277757,
0.3700693846,
0.3684474528,
-0.1625726521,
0.2369087487,
-0.6968055964,
-1.0611482859,
1.1101094484,
0.664557755,
-0.425709486,
-0.324950695,
0.3124571145,
0.1571083069,
-0.0887134299,
0.072932817,
0.070705384,
0.4962479174,
0.3014921546,
-0.8666164875,
-0.0109208347,
-0.0814856812,
0.149746716,
0.5867090821,
-0.3101700544,
0.9024452567,
0.0173729882,
-0.1676564664,
-0.0695842728,
0.5035299659,
0.1728063673,
-0.0159139689,
0.4690898359,
1.0986773968,
0.7432732582,
-0.6058111787,
0.9468287826,
-0.0953244567,
0.6248069406,
0.7356161475,
-0.0490783826,
0.3540480733,
0.1812772602,
0.2451839596,
0.3545080721,
0.5609004498,
-0.0528727323,
0.4890829623,
-0.024661094,
-0.2031033337,
-0.3859102726,
0.1518630832,
-0.529633522,
0.6856583953,
0.4517835081,
0.1585803628,
-0.728422761,
0.08230111,
-0.0838821083,
-0.0838538632,
-0.2960811853,
0.3560042977,
-0.1547223181,
-0.2136030048,
0.2985304296,
-0.158462882,
0.4578513205,
-0.5651660562,
-0.349362582,
0.0562928431,
-0.0125435414,
-0.1327944249,
-0.9444824457,
0.2074728906,
-0.0420295112,
-0.0698765665,
-0.1847696602,
0.4902715087,
-0.6183059216,
-0.699074924,
-0.2045777291,
0.6432796717,
0.0868408307,
-0.1915211231,
-0.6947486997,
0.1662009954,
-0.1573362797,
-0.0574488826,
-0.0104054501,
0.789557755,
-0.2011695653,
0.3962670267,
1.0429024696,
0.0527810007,
0.3157167733,
-0.0565147549,
0.9546399713,
-0.5050686002,
-0.5234565139,
-0.6505823135,
0.3752473593,
-0.0925828144,
-0.3014377356,
0.5695767403,
0.7446109056,
0.8170263767,
-0.0300245844,
0.8753390312,
-0.0469176769,
0.124841027,
-0.7830740809,
0.443544358,
-0.5155643225,
-0.1003841832,
-0.3179792762,
-1.0604262352,
-0.7405647635,
0.696418345,
-0.4837999344,
0.0147475284,
0.8031501174,
0.6241803169,
-0.5628131628,
-0.0344768427,
0.3047007918,
0.0124747884,
0.8759847879,
0.7967574596,
0.8713323474,
-0.3190416098,
0.9494105577,
0.040259257,
-0.293454349,
0.3269926608,
-1.078691721,
-0.6976421475,
-0.7375003099,
0.026013026,
-0.1448301375,
-0.2036958635,
0.5611132383,
0.840210557,
-0.2856421471,
0.1841601878,
-0.2350050211,
-0.1978344321,
0.2874247134,
-0.1609525234,
0.2835391164,
-0.3117829561,
-1.0347707272,
0.2885689437,
0.4020766914,
0.1438948214,
-0.297906965,
0.0268257521,
0.0614635907,
-0.3067997992,
0.5350525975,
0.1723283231,
-0.4980401099,
-0.4194306135,
-0.0814777762,
0.0406520739,
0.2946974635,
1.0421088934,
-0.6945159435,
0.5314225554,
0.442192167,
0.898260653,
0.5934291482,
0.1426984817,
0.7672851086,
-0.7505467534,
0.2918583453,
0.0629445761,
0.6517810822,
0.6772326231,
-0.3278920949,
0.3447120488,
0.4701175094,
-0.7886825204,
-0.4111715555,
0.5447610021,
-0.8061439991,
0.0079733115,
1.024744153,
-0.0737916902,
-0.2159966528,
0.1503050029,
-0.3389097452,
0.1225172877,
-0.3690146208,
0.3472287059,
0.8514659405,
0.0032545112,
-0.302682519,
-1.0150047541,
0.3397090733,
0.1803568602,
-0.9546909332,
-0.1954919547,
1.2541712523,
0.5056990385,
-0.0354255848,
0.1830885708,
-0.3212499022,
0.1654799283,
-0.3496608436,
0.1589940637,
-0.2909400165,
-0.5217142105,
-0.4038106203,
0.2369609624,
-0.2577274144,
-0.2105935067
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11497v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11497v2 | CrAM: Credibility-Aware Attention Modification in LLMs for Combating Misinformation in RAG | 2024-06-17T13:01:12 | 2024-06-27T10:18:53 | Boyi Deng, Wenjie Wang, Fengbin Zhu, Qifan Wang, Fuli Feng | cs.CL | cs.CL | Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) can alleviate hallucinations of Large
Language Models (LLMs) by referencing external documents. However, the
misinformation in external documents may mislead LLMs' generation. To address
this issue, we explore the task of "credibility-aware RAG", in which LLMs
automatically adjust the influence of retrieved documents based on their
credibility scores to counteract misinformation. To this end, we introduce a
plug-and-play method named $\textbf{Cr}$edibility-aware $\textbf{A}$ttention
$\textbf{M}$odification (CrAM). CrAM identifies influential attention heads in
LLMs and adjusts their attention weights based on the credibility of the
documents, thereby reducing the impact of low-credibility documents.
Experiments on Natual Questions and TriviaQA using Llama2-13B, Llama3-8B, and
Qwen-7B show that CrAM improves the RAG performance of LLMs against
misinformation pollution by over 20%, even surpassing supervised fine-tuning
methods. | [
-0.2762804627,
-0.8806919456,
0.439162612,
0.3230041265,
-0.2483255714,
0.34065938,
-0.3888999224,
-0.6165131927,
0.3491581678,
0.7380799651,
-0.2235133052,
-0.3314894736,
-0.7444900274,
-0.0556659847,
-0.377504766,
1.0294904709,
0.0837560967,
-0.0173587669,
-0.433893621,
-0.1051894799,
-0.5442970395,
-0.2906435132,
-0.6919307709,
-0.2020935714,
0.7407321334,
0.556999743,
0.6308491826,
0.7816884518,
0.8385008574,
0.2145273089,
-0.299987942,
0.4806452394,
-0.925093472,
0.3149813712,
-0.5941249728,
-0.774585247,
-0.4965857565,
-0.0036701078,
0.6501925588,
0.2218788713,
-0.1161351427,
0.5798110366,
0.2444795817,
0.6594537497,
-0.9000985026,
-0.1112790555,
-1.0075981617,
-0.2279712558,
-0.4780736268,
-0.7940240502,
-0.63707304,
-0.2205361575,
-0.1403255165,
-0.5396948457,
0.5568007827,
0.4175050259,
0.9200991988,
0.5695215464,
-0.1931597739,
-0.2852675021,
-0.9726933241,
0.9128752351,
-0.4526274204,
0.4798475206,
0.588322401,
0.0483626872,
-0.1951653957,
-0.7141445279,
-0.474874258,
-0.0603040978,
-0.1931260973,
0.2838688791,
0.0832669288,
-0.0112786237,
0.4381544292,
0.4210825562,
-0.5011457801,
-0.1701135039,
-0.3892603815,
-0.4103837311,
0.4232224822,
-0.1129482388,
0.1190833524,
0.0723050982,
-0.4073182642,
-0.0371627882,
-0.8785226941,
-0.3752206266,
0.2700388432,
0.0632521734,
0.2054889798,
0.6732792258,
-0.1003880575,
0.7064480186,
0.567943573,
-0.5653079748,
0.0241536722,
-0.1541462243,
-0.2813159823,
0.2739910483,
0.103161186,
0.3626072407,
0.1809325963,
0.0901014283,
-0.1880971491,
0.1713707,
0.4816849232,
-0.5990534425,
-0.0238746218,
0.2427541763,
-0.326268971,
-0.3568043411,
-0.2404522151,
-0.8721843362,
-0.6433637142,
-0.3677224517,
0.5955236554,
-0.3099348843,
0.0535222851,
-0.0490176342,
-0.0778210163,
0.0945507884,
0.4786803126,
-0.3632206321,
-0.0384730026,
0.5218749642,
0.530305326,
-0.246344313,
-0.1348366141,
-0.8159119487,
0.7009840608,
-0.2834166884,
1.2116100788,
-0.6522501707,
-0.308424592,
-0.0719128251,
-0.198445484,
-0.1276516765,
-0.7592241764,
0.8974102139,
-0.7814500332,
0.4297415316,
-0.1278645247,
-0.4536794126,
-0.1643252522,
0.5163417459,
-0.5015077591,
1.0668151379,
0.1340905279,
-0.9572489262,
0.0986073241,
-0.3033201694,
-0.3850894868,
-0.0212205257,
0.1800352186,
-0.3950762153,
0.1782364547,
0.2271456569,
-0.066882439,
-0.2539956272,
-0.0477792248,
0.0749575049,
-0.3477507234,
0.2117743045,
-0.4954640865,
0.4919376373,
0.085867919,
-0.1831585169,
0.0368446931,
-0.6450728774,
-0.0485847034,
-0.0247398987,
-0.4822327197,
-0.5281876326,
-0.1684453785,
-0.2247311473,
0.0101522384,
0.398673296,
-0.2715741694,
0.0091850786,
-0.508259654,
-0.3338879049,
0.6239128113,
0.4466203451,
0.3980790675,
-0.8231631517,
0.4235496223,
0.2083790749,
0.2539080381,
-0.1842575371,
-0.4459284544,
-1.0706837177,
-0.1782012582,
0.5228931308,
0.6455261111,
-0.7899488211,
-0.0804256126,
-0.1033811867,
-0.5102825761,
-0.6731753349,
0.355956465,
0.5751241446,
0.7677906752,
0.5395011306,
-0.193930909,
-0.6412976384,
-0.8640777469,
-0.940125227,
-0.1232732981,
0.0741778985,
0.3145007789,
0.0038557693,
-0.2625048459,
0.8233235478,
-0.500479877,
-0.6151638031,
-0.0681261718,
0.275377959,
-0.1872325391,
0.2811734676,
0.3426549733,
-0.9203135967,
-0.7234660387,
-0.3622089326,
-0.2218023539,
-0.4305719137,
-0.318208158,
-0.1154136956,
0.4924449027,
0.4603632689,
-0.6101867557,
0.4339150488,
0.4999090135,
-0.3214764595,
0.6388659477,
-0.1753214598,
0.4435936809,
-0.8458553553,
-0.1120461226,
-0.0245525036,
-0.3716516197,
-0.5964702368,
0.0459561497,
0.1570414603,
0.3671681285,
-0.4599291086,
0.6741588116,
-0.6044320464,
-0.0035694088,
-0.5696764588,
0.5402809978,
0.3839741647,
0.355535984,
-0.2400186211,
0.7825846672,
0.3516987562,
-0.8102912903,
-0.1307357103,
0.2020479292,
-0.0890064389,
0.8756631017,
-0.2722430825,
0.2563748658,
-0.3429065943,
0.2501792908,
-0.8602429032,
-0.3487727344,
0.4704849422,
-0.6732975245,
0.5636137724,
-0.2447724193,
-0.4266071618,
0.0142484941,
-0.262029171,
0.3464364707,
0.2747782171,
-0.5899625421,
0.9857148528,
0.4786968529,
-0.068301551,
-0.6637711525,
-0.7563422918,
0.2095365822,
-0.259753257,
-0.2897261679,
0.5083293915,
-0.3689412475,
-0.5711761117,
-0.0489328727,
-0.3148117363,
-0.0238632597,
-0.1414436549,
0.1152350977,
0.327441901,
0.0404301956,
0.1981659383,
-0.0199793838,
-0.0523401238,
-0.0656640008,
-0.1059474051,
0.4233774245,
0.2523700893,
-0.3380820453,
-0.0491658375,
0.0911681056,
0.3707529306,
-0.4286801815,
0.6697171926,
0.7035403252,
-0.3856006265,
-0.3980872929,
-1.0860631466,
-0.2538694441,
-0.4843781888,
0.0874705836,
-0.0546877198,
-0.7886611819,
0.2792318165,
-0.1618237048,
0.108357735,
0.5216440558,
0.6012680531,
-0.0765603706,
0.6270700097,
0.4972675145,
0.0543081425,
0.4741723239,
0.1452471912,
0.0771367997,
-0.8569040298,
-0.0581087992,
-0.5735396147,
-0.3308570087,
-0.3211731911,
-0.9784449935,
0.2308195829,
0.0754513443,
0.1825466454,
0.0789694786,
-0.6437876821,
0.6227958798,
0.5084825754,
0.1554677039,
0.6765550375,
0.0225029252,
0.2282489985,
-0.2459369451,
-0.7627657056,
-0.3230696619,
1.0505752563,
0.2574961185,
0.8579427004,
-0.023105301,
0.4914132059,
0.5026813745,
0.7058928013,
-0.6070486903,
0.5505978465,
0.1939098686,
-0.7482959628,
0.0381568559,
-0.462754786,
-0.641260922,
0.0667743757,
-0.3050465584,
-0.4522189498,
0.3145616353,
0.4017947316,
-0.1905194968,
0.2130284607,
-0.6120467186,
0.1314440966,
-0.1870486289,
-0.5544149876,
-0.7249752283,
-0.3053666055,
0.4191340208,
-0.3453288376,
0.3319652081,
0.0685566664,
-0.1337885708,
0.6003113985,
0.3307951093,
0.8999205232,
-0.1100380048,
-0.2360642552,
0.5348470211,
0.3580085039,
0.8660361767,
0.1163773686,
0.1392152458,
0.2457716614,
-0.3155799806,
-0.0735879093,
-0.5427682996,
0.8451014161,
-0.2283270061,
-0.8540855646,
-0.4078899026,
-0.8665049076,
-0.3741149008,
0.2674913704,
0.2070456892,
0.3148370385,
-0.1635729223,
0.1922473162,
1.2305617332,
-0.2325591743,
0.1099345684,
0.7620067596,
-0.2639856935,
-0.5736002922,
0.8387898207,
0.3006813228,
0.3750721216,
0.4492314458,
0.1818708628,
-0.1341063827,
-0.3998455703,
-0.1159506813,
0.3890654743,
-0.7293023467,
-0.481769979,
-0.7706041932,
-0.3027518988,
-0.3770534396,
-0.0458053723,
-0.3042641282,
-0.56511271,
-0.2287822217,
0.1212300509,
0.4166973829,
0.5264630318,
-0.0704414621,
0.4555768967,
-0.6973897219,
0.6864435077,
0.1771175265,
0.4610069096,
-0.2462039143,
-1.0650564432,
-0.524785459,
-0.000324941,
-0.4033910334,
-0.8194292784,
0.2199935913,
0.2138743401,
0.5116429925,
0.5035718083,
0.1469447315,
0.6741241217,
-0.3458592892,
0.5320641994,
-0.2604574859,
-0.7175599337,
0.3593734503,
-0.2971309423,
0.2163853347,
0.4583126903,
0.082365796,
-0.3707214594,
-0.8484238982,
-0.8639724851,
-0.6619273424,
0.469648093,
0.1980412304,
-0.144203648,
0.0767176896,
0.3303534985,
-0.2127672881,
0.2360835671,
-0.4866986573,
-0.2917881012,
0.0362223201,
-0.2287777513,
0.0179127213,
-0.7478541136,
-0.3653473854,
0.0759571195,
1.0191172361,
0.0065871798,
0.054704491,
0.4798869193,
-0.3218517005,
-0.3423510194,
0.1761339456,
0.7938945293,
0.5944507718,
-0.0763436556,
0.1318264604,
0.3441140354,
-0.7146702409,
-0.1789432168,
-0.1721772999,
-0.3964385986,
0.244398281,
0.1588436663,
0.3598220944,
0.2291470021,
-0.5073404908,
0.1187950671,
0.0211832467,
-0.1314651668,
-0.2876093686,
0.2486529946,
0.1375913024,
0.3394812047,
0.3159220219,
0.2694984972,
0.006677344,
-0.2986173928,
0.2117075026,
0.3550614417,
-0.2345976382,
0.0213900935,
0.5768119693,
0.0591450185,
-0.5579455495,
-0.0485131107,
-0.0046492312,
-0.4989122152,
0.4051967859,
0.7209200263,
0.7674657702,
-0.5965269804,
0.0288164411,
0.5291762352,
0.676309824,
-0.2658557892,
0.0990420282,
0.2229379267,
-0.717451036,
-0.4867455959,
-0.4807592034,
-0.6083728671,
0.1386864632,
-0.4491173029,
0.218665868,
-0.3829428256,
-0.3098834753,
-0.431964308,
-0.0701350793,
-0.4275993407,
0.3830809295,
0.0369154923,
0.9801388383,
-0.4165251851,
0.5605509877,
0.624381125,
-0.0755204558,
-0.4757420719,
0.6262032986,
-0.0424275137,
-0.5458765626,
0.2438415438,
-0.011815167,
-0.3677812815,
0.2731676996,
-0.6640849113,
-1.1405318975,
0.8928365111,
0.2946689427,
-0.6038311124,
0.2611247301,
0.1267830133,
0.4365716577,
-0.3848705292,
0.0985402465,
0.4334025681,
0.8166623712,
-0.0006187414,
-0.6651559472,
-0.2216471285,
0.1123610511,
-0.200886637,
-0.0171894785,
-0.9064724445,
0.5045935512,
-0.2637338638,
-0.3870714903,
-0.294160068,
0.7625498772,
0.5008562207,
0.4920680821,
0.7206709385,
0.6078181267,
0.9815097451,
0.0472572893,
0.7575796843,
-0.6992186904,
0.1597648114,
1.6072837114,
-0.2580454946,
0.6500232816,
0.6346675754,
0.3127236366,
0.4842266738,
0.2871806324,
0.0263779759,
0.285818398,
0.0153531255,
-0.2527352571,
-0.2384044826,
-0.3769279718,
-0.2099567503,
0.4313975871,
0.6489323974,
-0.3727587759,
-0.1803003103,
0.0585559048,
0.0920894071,
0.3331589997,
-0.4644685388,
0.7338061333,
0.0942717493,
-0.7778401375,
0.5948303342,
0.0402124971,
0.4633443356,
-0.4928235412,
-0.2251639962,
-0.2602318525,
0.4092297554,
-0.2901362181,
-0.6352927089,
0.3660707176,
0.0426149443,
-0.5383457541,
-0.1477740109,
1.2952306271,
-0.746450603,
-0.4202325344,
0.22074233,
0.5635453463,
-0.0284700729,
-0.2315645218,
-0.6552736759,
0.1530635357,
0.1234764308,
-0.3841488063,
0.3451227546,
0.4874359667,
-0.0012871885,
0.8400292397,
0.6795553565,
0.2764292061,
-0.1405516565,
0.0653409138,
0.9047726393,
-0.4858520925,
-0.3453713357,
-0.5760762095,
0.3549913764,
-0.1583553851,
-0.0313716121,
1.1115704775,
0.6212599874,
0.8404690623,
-0.0597476773,
0.6778222919,
0.080940865,
1.1399973631,
-0.2794865668,
0.8347163796,
-0.4984332919,
0.3094044626,
-0.1333458275,
-1.0343617201,
-0.2652554214,
0.2875649333,
-0.1680023074,
-0.0806227699,
0.7190704942,
1.272372365,
-0.0323832855,
-0.2641405761,
0.2553190589,
0.6132867932,
0.014358581,
0.0785875022,
0.6230186224,
-0.3042268157,
0.7719131708,
-0.1947639287,
-0.2521034777,
-0.3164592087,
-0.8657285571,
-0.9321385622,
-0.2152335793,
-0.3753935695,
-0.6730843186,
0.2333267927,
0.5748772621,
0.2505526245,
-0.6451029778,
0.2004367709,
0.3160908818,
0.3338209987,
-0.2130829841,
-0.2970716655,
0.2357424796,
-0.4700543582,
-0.7209932208,
0.5278254151,
0.2914713025,
0.0141368685,
-0.3853152692,
0.1051140651,
-0.3003998995,
0.6899238229,
0.4668850005,
0.0973604023,
-0.4657301605,
-0.3567954898,
-0.0887295082,
-0.3012759686,
0.2021370232,
0.7244341373,
-0.8963949084,
0.3916998804,
0.4290561676,
0.5102309585,
0.2600213587,
0.536190331,
0.3160116971,
-0.789249599,
0.1015042514,
0.2989545465,
0.1044837162,
0.437958926,
-0.8240636587,
0.4897668064,
0.3917289972,
-0.7843151093,
-0.9351220131,
0.1735188663,
-0.9316980243,
-0.0805596337,
1.4137842655,
0.2074305713,
-0.3781297803,
-0.3557011187,
-0.508104682,
0.2203570306,
-0.2280187309,
1.2020838261,
0.5559267998,
0.3250598013,
-0.1264078021,
-0.5943263173,
0.683345437,
0.4916544259,
-0.7320392728,
0.2775119841,
0.4473473728,
0.2880011499,
0.4009527266,
0.5668346882,
-0.1398893744,
0.2412678748,
-0.1567010731,
0.1244912669,
-0.1032828391,
-0.6222652793,
0.0154329706,
0.0210780259,
-0.0056710555,
0.1265720129
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11486v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11486v1 | Analysing zero-shot temporal relation extraction on clinical notes using temporal consistency | 2024-06-17T12:53:21 | 2024-06-17T12:53:21 | Vasiliki Kougia, Anastasiia Sedova, Andreas Stephan, Klim Zaporojets, Benjamin Roth | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | This paper presents the first study for temporal relation extraction in a
zero-shot setting focusing on biomedical text. We employ two types of prompts
and five LLMs (GPT-3.5, Mixtral, Llama 2, Gemma, and PMC-LLaMA) to obtain
responses about the temporal relations between two events. Our experiments
demonstrate that LLMs struggle in the zero-shot setting performing worse than
fine-tuned specialized models in terms of F1 score, showing that this is a
challenging task for LLMs. We further contribute a novel comprehensive temporal
analysis by calculating consistency scores for each LLM. Our findings reveal
that LLMs face challenges in providing responses consistent to the temporal
properties of uniqueness and transitivity. Moreover, we study the relation
between the temporal consistency of an LLM and its accuracy and whether the
latter can be improved by solving temporal inconsistencies. Our analysis shows
that even when temporal consistency is achieved, the predictions can remain
inaccurate. | [
0.3055554628,
-1.0359712839,
1.3408093452,
0.5003384352,
-0.4200738966,
-0.0028859051,
0.1102001071,
-0.8284427524,
0.3650806248,
0.1606672406,
-0.7158549428,
-0.5465666652,
-0.7093679309,
0.3090463579,
-0.1798206866,
1.1004303694,
-0.1813438237,
0.1222575754,
-0.1537903547,
-0.5131888986,
-0.5178551078,
-0.4728738368,
-0.4946048558,
-0.5871621966,
0.9077786207,
0.1321480423,
0.3602562547,
0.9348823428,
0.8123927712,
0.109377183,
-0.2666159868,
-0.1758931726,
-0.1567438096,
0.3575614393,
-0.1509378105,
-0.2281585932,
-0.8745347261,
0.038176015,
0.5885785222,
0.8974428177,
-0.0394126065,
0.2218482047,
-0.2757956684,
0.1673671454,
-0.4426800013,
0.2600468993,
-0.6033626795,
0.3664062023,
-0.3368564844,
-0.8360485435,
-0.3841086626,
-0.1573132873,
0.0299754255,
-0.6605162621,
0.417922318,
-0.3285090029,
1.2256162167,
0.1228674427,
-0.4966976345,
-0.1652712971,
-0.8132193685,
0.5687118173,
-0.689981997,
-0.0121963788,
0.0876381025,
0.1907161474,
-0.1335522085,
-0.6093968153,
-0.5290540457,
-0.3488416374,
-0.1602350324,
0.3608437181,
0.1736828834,
-0.0717923939,
0.3666774929,
0.1803956628,
-0.6076840162,
0.1262480021,
-0.0999531448,
-0.097026594,
0.2528855205,
0.75283885,
0.2416499853,
-0.1348329633,
-0.3572786748,
0.5072607398,
-0.6869406104,
-0.1001113951,
-0.134489432,
0.1361223161,
-0.1710681021,
0.7057936788,
0.0342832021,
0.5272646546,
0.1885875463,
-0.4717988372,
0.0089380918,
-0.4406089187,
-0.220136568,
0.0715224817,
1.0568555593,
0.4107669592,
0.3118652105,
-0.3824944794,
0.3649636507,
0.1389655173,
0.0389270075,
-0.7321690917,
0.2181397527,
0.4551237226,
-0.4057204425,
-0.4577280581,
-0.252389878,
-0.5253895521,
-0.0551559627,
-0.2522405684,
0.3819378614,
-0.5475859046,
0.1810863465,
0.0294627901,
-0.1045027822,
0.2889701128,
0.6274226904,
-0.7854268551,
0.0721144751,
0.6263230443,
0.976919353,
-0.1449150443,
-0.137114808,
-0.564460814,
0.5466947556,
-0.335013777,
0.9537533522,
-0.3153917789,
-0.6730856299,
-0.2113624066,
0.2443441749,
-0.1684239954,
-0.3848564327,
0.4661064744,
-0.121131368,
0.255905658,
-0.1224764735,
-0.6588917971,
0.4209491909,
0.2826094031,
-0.3476373255,
0.7372305393,
0.0839736685,
-0.4951447248,
0.4782881737,
-0.2266952246,
-0.4245166481,
0.0541940741,
-0.6138809323,
-0.4690063,
-0.0207619481,
0.1032024026,
0.4589343071,
0.1091660261,
0.414190501,
-0.5626380444,
-0.312663734,
0.4215540588,
-0.2121384889,
0.7326322794,
-0.0139658516,
-0.1155772582,
-0.2232140601,
-0.7666602731,
-0.080177106,
0.3132499456,
-0.1244689077,
0.0164670702,
-0.1005694196,
-0.2380461097,
0.2823653817,
0.4103868306,
-1.0758355856,
0.4812088609,
-0.0515702777,
0.2801448107,
0.7159590125,
0.6449388266,
0.1871278584,
-0.5460914969,
0.3847635388,
0.3870993555,
0.189770937,
-0.553376019,
-0.3441694975,
-0.3365558088,
-0.0207721554,
0.101163052,
0.5977030993,
-0.2409232557,
0.1001057103,
-0.4334070086,
-0.3571665883,
-0.4033973217,
-0.167676419,
0.5040701628,
1.0232355595,
0.4733376801,
-0.3131467104,
-0.4142160714,
-0.5734503269,
-0.2419297397,
-0.4168561101,
-0.1310621053,
0.3728714585,
0.3717966676,
-0.0717066675,
0.8950560689,
-0.6137112379,
-0.3856161535,
0.1941355765,
0.3599661291,
0.3979968727,
0.3284779787,
0.6488164067,
-0.0188503899,
-0.4777382314,
0.0110412994,
-1.2360508442,
-0.3132126927,
-0.367367357,
0.2044502646,
0.2455574125,
0.4509769082,
-0.5614855289,
0.5509309173,
0.0932028145,
-0.3452248573,
0.6265091896,
-0.1064075232,
0.2105490863,
-0.7152665854,
0.3055613041,
0.0051322854,
-0.3709740937,
-0.6109594703,
-0.4197021127,
0.0117072966,
0.0736355782,
-0.4900901318,
1.0072271824,
-0.2669611871,
0.2287146896,
0.0227046441,
0.2919273674,
0.0963142142,
0.4433474243,
0.2127945125,
0.3162756264,
0.0811281502,
-0.3149748743,
-0.1211640686,
0.4543471932,
0.3253369927,
0.7767241597,
-0.9375942945,
0.2871917188,
-0.2785736024,
0.0842008442,
-0.8511948586,
-0.0644373149,
0.3839611411,
-0.6755339503,
0.5845119357,
-0.2736854851,
-0.4331850708,
0.1078162268,
-0.2611133158,
0.2486715466,
0.4330501258,
0.0653349534,
0.1505047083,
-0.0067433515,
-0.4650996923,
-0.6198357344,
-0.6467745304,
0.0095807202,
0.0783842951,
-0.333119601,
0.6055269241,
-0.2098768055,
-0.2574827671,
0.1331489384,
-0.4968157709,
-0.1175391003,
-0.1596774757,
0.3911629319,
0.4814741015,
-0.2804066539,
-0.0601455383,
0.0309401955,
-0.1497442573,
-0.0144313974,
0.3061767519,
0.0385842584,
0.3002209067,
-0.3340723217,
-0.7112225294,
0.3992842138,
0.5079426169,
0.4360277653,
0.6599074602,
0.4277921021,
-0.4350377917,
0.4180449843,
-0.4778494239,
0.0053612771,
-0.31128034,
-0.1246340945,
-0.3067515492,
-0.7612423897,
0.7020238638,
0.3068098426,
0.092358321,
0.5352858305,
0.5677185059,
-0.5977973342,
0.6953023076,
0.6238244772,
0.0529213361,
0.5222750902,
0.0925747156,
-0.2261467874,
-0.8337492943,
-0.531855762,
-0.4078795016,
-0.0115757277,
-0.3168160021,
0.0759944394,
0.5421346426,
0.2404829115,
-0.2350116223,
0.0855224282,
-0.2981883585,
0.1970996112,
-0.1598598957,
0.3273966014,
0.4657512903,
-0.222361058,
-0.2506034374,
-0.3074624538,
-0.4439245164,
-0.557980001,
1.0601086617,
0.2851510346,
0.3433339596,
0.1018268913,
0.5860096812,
0.049245514,
0.4986511469,
-0.6211751699,
0.4674580991,
-0.0197475906,
-0.6027312875,
-0.1817985624,
-0.29799366,
-1.0959979296,
-0.0828051269,
-0.1462812126,
-0.9914640784,
-0.017710764,
-0.1559522003,
-0.6273147464,
-0.0635152534,
-0.1899962276,
0.7268943787,
-0.2094404846,
-0.6014810801,
0.4603317678,
-1.0897010565,
0.1647101194,
0.107257545,
-0.140164122,
-0.6576861739,
-0.1893300265,
0.6015785933,
-0.4191880226,
0.7997853756,
-0.024809802,
0.1042496786,
0.0430804305,
0.2945733666,
0.0346688554,
0.3307221532,
0.1187460348,
0.3623899817,
0.6543488503,
-0.6237055659,
-0.7343227267,
0.5155646205,
-0.6802221537,
-0.2918209434,
-0.8553186655,
-0.6354554296,
-0.2032248676,
0.2040468305,
0.2710755765,
0.6015406251,
-0.3986947536,
-0.2981030345,
0.4941473901,
-0.1426314116,
0.7811867595,
1.1847109795,
0.0982600823,
-0.3484819829,
0.264911741,
0.1630606055,
0.1485770643,
0.7867652774,
0.0552865788,
-0.2391698658,
-0.5360697508,
-0.1933766007,
0.6506305933,
-0.4184964001,
-0.1149988025,
-0.6917276978,
-0.396509409,
-0.6805585623,
-0.0490262732,
-0.099566564,
-0.6368221045,
-0.5750675797,
-0.0590744391,
0.2368512601,
0.5988655686,
-0.0961935669,
0.24967058,
-1.2327874899,
0.3382251561,
-0.2043463141,
0.1000894904,
-0.3588355184,
-0.5772108436,
0.0789572224,
-0.4261013865,
-0.4876459241,
-1.1190328598,
0.3402907252,
0.1506220251,
0.6062224507,
0.4593102932,
-0.3521503806,
1.0824323893,
-0.7463899255,
0.8044018745,
0.1427298933,
-0.6617687941,
0.7038345337,
-0.6897964478,
0.3301016688,
0.4495829046,
0.4569712877,
-0.6619768143,
-0.4416442811,
-1.0775225163,
-0.5645648837,
0.4845162034,
0.1878198534,
-0.389198184,
-0.3040759861,
1.0805864334,
0.1302051544,
0.1291956902,
-0.6006532907,
-0.4317182899,
0.2979336083,
-0.177349031,
-0.1397957355,
-0.5854805708,
-0.2290360779,
-0.070792757,
0.0780329257,
0.0289125107,
0.5118097067,
0.6511470675,
0.0164416023,
-0.3700354099,
0.3838993907,
0.8930116892,
0.8366681337,
-0.6763857007,
-0.0065441257,
-0.0013443816,
-0.540400207,
0.3459677696,
0.0113498736,
-0.1533474773,
0.47390154,
1.0453364849,
0.3026431799,
0.2501425743,
-0.3479582667,
0.5084845424,
-0.0203696266,
-0.0592604354,
-0.4603568316,
-0.1225582436,
-0.1621821821,
0.0483991504,
0.1698199809,
-0.2574324906,
-0.1693627685,
-0.6766989827,
0.3937681913,
0.3215845525,
-0.6298044324,
-0.5617471337,
0.9389023781,
-0.2508568764,
-0.1911472678,
0.4849261642,
-0.0603783391,
0.0222891103,
0.7201064229,
0.5416066051,
0.820971489,
-0.1742165834,
0.1570623815,
0.4260936677,
0.0184661951,
0.1638347358,
0.3023270965,
-0.0597362593,
-0.5239292979,
-0.6039284468,
-0.5482575297,
-0.7101301551,
0.1582382321,
-0.9095782042,
0.2066969573,
-0.5648688674,
-0.3883403242,
0.3078111708,
0.3066003919,
-0.46493119,
0.0560872704,
-0.285091579,
0.6756179929,
-0.6562154293,
0.9091716409,
0.4068200588,
-0.6755784154,
-0.6295996904,
-0.2593162358,
0.3144640028,
-0.7825504541,
0.5641652942,
-0.2239030451,
0.1758203357,
-0.3861605227,
-0.3239199221,
-0.2516645789,
1.3764965534,
0.4251029789,
-0.6790484786,
-0.2517875135,
0.2077988386,
0.8948442936,
-0.1237471029,
0.5363857746,
0.5207738876,
0.1466172636,
0.3697000146,
-0.9940277934,
0.066412054,
-0.1687845886,
-0.4188797772,
0.2074733526,
-0.5120556951,
0.8106231689,
-0.3579526842,
-0.4471241832,
0.4473612905,
0.31303671,
0.5590688586,
0.8839482665,
-0.2200105488,
0.5418357849,
0.5760923624,
-0.1823489368,
0.9950394034,
-0.3158405125,
0.3450926542,
1.3653563261,
-0.664037466,
0.6098380685,
0.7410027981,
-0.2819547951,
0.4599033594,
0.6099450588,
0.135694176,
0.3035675287,
-0.2865593731,
-0.5074632764,
0.0675840601,
-0.2069154084,
-0.4720447361,
0.0458865389,
0.2273896784,
-0.347076416,
-0.3555464745,
-0.5066574812,
0.5372754335,
-0.2704966962,
-0.0736073926,
0.8876307607,
0.3875340521,
-0.4650810659,
0.12199191,
-0.2006690055,
0.028760517,
-0.72012043,
-0.1198612899,
-0.4942314327,
0.1563346237,
-0.1314574331,
-0.8241214156,
0.4340545237,
0.0099819629,
-0.3466858268,
-0.121543102,
0.4605408907,
-0.444421798,
-0.3271281421,
0.1885997802,
0.7341040969,
0.1535566151,
0.3170074522,
-0.534235239,
-0.007295738,
-0.3390577734,
0.0211861711,
0.4871905446,
0.8210495114,
0.0928326398,
0.3587063253,
0.495867759,
0.608263433,
-0.1001314521,
0.0084786359,
0.2970840931,
-1.0747387409,
-0.0550430939,
-1.2387129068,
0.2680028975,
-0.0728974864,
-0.4789193273,
0.6009554863,
0.3582654297,
0.3225022852,
0.0733927116,
0.3701340258,
0.2527173162,
0.6769756079,
-0.601821661,
0.4323643744,
-0.3834883571,
0.3057972193,
-0.3254483044,
-0.5061772466,
-0.652962029,
0.04516498,
-0.0996590555,
-0.2557335496,
1.117312789,
0.485185802,
0.2442543209,
-0.2006025314,
0.3100627065,
0.2286792248,
0.5250506997,
0.9309847355,
0.7684862614,
-0.4463791251,
0.4530538917,
-0.2741898596,
-0.0875196457,
-0.0089119151,
-1.278924346,
-0.8011894226,
-0.1822483838,
-0.6127839088,
-0.4376661181,
0.323285073,
0.5133336186,
0.3315689564,
-0.6141173244,
0.0472198538,
0.2278977931,
-0.012844326,
-0.3037172854,
-0.2540917397,
0.3906572759,
-0.2633478642,
-0.4404037893,
0.2518430352,
0.8044675589,
0.3474131525,
0.1628295928,
0.2554998994,
-0.0688443929,
0.0124944132,
0.4949614108,
0.6413470507,
-0.477432251,
-0.4471924305,
0.288277775,
-0.4163677394,
0.4021092653,
1.0083470345,
-0.7315208912,
0.3728424609,
0.2487273514,
0.1896028817,
0.7388703823,
-0.0049583968,
0.2810322046,
-0.8846294284,
0.1200554594,
0.4087073207,
0.3234426379,
0.0951562375,
-0.4324934185,
0.7344158888,
0.7190260887,
-0.7910510302,
-0.7511901855,
0.0795204788,
-1.6707389355,
-0.1539567858,
1.0752727985,
-0.2547717988,
-0.2730418444,
-0.224680379,
0.0871894509,
0.4392971098,
-0.1245373636,
0.7917897701,
0.6891003847,
-0.7943020463,
-0.0910443887,
-0.6709903479,
0.2098225057,
0.2617359459,
-0.5603986382,
-0.4141801,
0.3502389491,
0.6640205979,
0.2223155349,
1.3299158812,
-0.6410238743,
0.2850691378,
0.0687860921,
-0.3492631614,
-0.1652081162,
-0.277665168,
-0.5729147196,
0.1275807023,
-0.2013580352,
-0.2176050097
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11477v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11477v1 | Vocabulary Expansion for Low-resource Cross-lingual Transfer | 2024-06-17T12:42:34 | 2024-06-17T12:42:34 | Atsuki Yamaguchi, Aline Villavicencio, Nikolaos Aletras | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) have shown remarkable capabilities in many
languages beyond English. Yet, LLMs require more inference steps when
generating non-English text due to their reliance on English-centric
tokenizers, vocabulary, and pre-training data, resulting in higher usage costs
to non-English speakers. Vocabulary expansion with target language tokens is a
widely used cross-lingual vocabulary adaptation approach to remedy this issue.
Despite its effectiveness in inference speedup, the majority of previous work
has focused on high-resource settings assuming access to a substantial amount
of target language data to effectively initialize the embeddings of the new
tokens and adapt the LLM to the target language. However, vocabulary expansion
for LLMs in low-resource settings (i.e. languages and compute) has yet to be
explored. In this paper, we investigate sample-efficient adaptation strategies
from different angles, including target vocabulary size and initialization
methods, and the amount of target data available for adaptation. Extensive
experiments across typologically diverse languages, tasks and models show that
simpler heuristic-based embedding initialization is more efficient and robust
to changes in target vocabulary size and adaptation data in low-resource
settings, outperforming a popular random initialization and a more
sophisticated state-of-the-art approach that relies on external data and model. | [
-0.2031074166,
-0.5517482162,
0.1853072345,
0.2484728098,
-0.292614013,
0.3005230725,
-0.7209798098,
-0.5221427679,
0.1408534199,
0.1474533379,
-0.207274884,
-0.2633166909,
-0.7200277448,
0.0940435454,
-0.0573201291,
0.797480762,
-0.0662193224,
0.0172170028,
-0.0864634663,
-0.1048699841,
-0.5749502778,
-0.4540335238,
-0.7394897342,
-0.1013070345,
0.5149398446,
0.5848130584,
0.592078805,
0.601077199,
0.4128371775,
0.2812748849,
-0.0542322621,
0.2937157452,
-0.797444284,
-0.2807229459,
-0.5379846096,
-0.5129833221,
-0.1561394483,
-0.2724814713,
0.7522450686,
0.9293400049,
-0.0076843197,
0.2752640545,
0.1942219287,
0.3387591541,
-0.9018514752,
0.1628297865,
-0.8499248624,
0.13811858,
-0.2467993349,
-0.2723243833,
-0.4979270101,
0.2162271738,
0.3485149443,
-0.8901131749,
-0.016064398,
0.3281057477,
0.574051857,
-0.0471375175,
-0.1442757249,
-0.2479183078,
-0.6032493711,
1.1289409399,
-0.4224247932,
0.5916548371,
0.2350228727,
0.0219385158,
-0.0805930123,
-0.5369609594,
-0.1527951509,
-0.1784925461,
0.0053953286,
-0.0543822236,
-0.272562474,
-0.1559037417,
0.1502785385,
0.0244831685,
-0.1181518286,
0.6614245176,
-0.540314436,
-0.2161492705,
0.4105197489,
-0.1380734742,
0.2185710818,
-0.2593302429,
-0.5398172736,
-0.2269051671,
-0.5531483889,
-0.0979406908,
0.180027917,
0.903650105,
-0.6318725348,
0.6099651456,
0.0066135274,
0.6408694983,
0.1060972363,
-0.1499336809,
0.2025843412,
-0.7412771583,
-0.0301827062,
0.1144796982,
0.4983530641,
0.2100358456,
0.3107817173,
-0.3125299811,
-0.0717744604,
-0.3088760674,
0.073588565,
-0.7853309512,
0.0927613601,
0.0169867221,
-0.4104931653,
0.0745593533,
-0.4608643055,
-0.7232484221,
-0.4970108569,
-0.0458873212,
0.4473906457,
-0.6046520472,
-0.0834201202,
0.0090905437,
-0.022603102,
0.2953685224,
0.3444514871,
-0.9567879438,
0.2950835824,
0.6232123971,
1.1047916412,
-0.6994903684,
-0.2468692958,
-0.8464320898,
0.1289961487,
-0.5862865448,
0.5931633115,
-0.4490682781,
-0.4761555493,
0.0782959163,
0.1189255267,
-0.2557607293,
-0.35222435,
0.2902514935,
-0.6094917059,
0.2474029064,
-0.3371362984,
-0.334317863,
0.0143413348,
0.1433028132,
-0.675989151,
0.9555094838,
0.3080440164,
-0.5997005701,
0.5211234093,
-0.8490614295,
-0.5756013989,
0.033533819,
0.0249090306,
0.1751505435,
0.3974302709,
0.2971700132,
0.4891145825,
-0.5746010542,
-0.3123125732,
-0.0944201276,
-0.4681268036,
0.1079324633,
-0.4274631441,
0.6641258597,
0.2066761404,
-0.0654681996,
-0.2014858127,
-0.3660232425,
-0.0615905486,
0.089728415,
-0.5174070597,
-0.7287043929,
-0.2243946493,
0.0557699911,
0.0119777909,
0.3970119953,
-0.5154027939,
0.1436552256,
-0.4530196488,
0.1716141552,
0.7234341502,
-0.1639083922,
0.9881711602,
-0.4017723799,
0.6160978079,
0.2911330163,
-0.2304243743,
-0.0859565586,
-0.2417130619,
-0.5601064563,
-0.4606697857,
0.7469034195,
0.5904152989,
-1.0466005802,
0.0184297897,
-0.7259940505,
-0.3730339408,
-0.5228551626,
0.4784769118,
0.349090308,
0.32376194,
0.410102576,
-0.4159113467,
-0.3976183832,
-0.732504487,
-0.2408156246,
-0.1002011746,
-0.0269388724,
0.4694259763,
0.2610999942,
0.2125554532,
0.5608826876,
-0.2735306025,
-0.0785490125,
-0.6052738428,
-0.1368911415,
0.1331634223,
0.4179762006,
0.6730903387,
-0.4248678386,
-0.706641674,
0.2342257798,
-0.3313598335,
-0.0371719375,
-0.4377841055,
-0.431971848,
0.2946870327,
0.4692109227,
-0.3082821965,
0.0292670913,
0.923645556,
-0.1786149591,
0.1396508813,
-0.3409405649,
0.0000102417,
-1.4024471045,
-0.1826963425,
-0.0258244704,
-0.0796155781,
-0.6825437546,
-0.0231602266,
-0.0570487119,
0.0533264838,
-0.6818651557,
1.0467213392,
-0.8761805892,
-0.3942769468,
-0.1093213633,
0.2758086026,
-0.1599461585,
0.4250596166,
0.1224332079,
0.8745141625,
0.5663238764,
-0.5125947595,
-0.0005284441,
0.1359447837,
-0.2066161036,
0.4284664989,
-0.1757860929,
-0.0216561612,
-0.003432015,
0.0002428655,
-0.7975158095,
0.1220922172,
0.209826231,
-0.0437208191,
0.3369826078,
-0.3119354844,
-0.4148661196,
0.0664335489,
-0.1274495721,
0.5448781252,
0.6131448746,
-0.8710620403,
0.7730494142,
0.2100599259,
-0.1523653269,
-0.6369800568,
-0.7346448898,
0.1813606918,
-0.2455021888,
-0.2920898497,
0.5426033735,
0.1698317677,
-0.3619366884,
0.0781677142,
0.117853649,
-0.0065511242,
0.0737377256,
-0.1741040796,
0.2410955429,
-0.3706356287,
0.2921895385,
0.0096393963,
0.2357536107,
-0.2000508308,
-0.4394310117,
0.5908679366,
0.1077108085,
-0.3208627403,
-0.0669358149,
0.2770145237,
0.4369205534,
0.0246776249,
0.8441746235,
0.6785796881,
-0.3629133105,
-0.4716232717,
-0.3318974674,
-0.249590382,
-0.453222543,
0.7964714766,
-0.5987504721,
-0.5660279989,
0.5118777752,
-0.13387236,
0.2640788257,
0.3236071467,
0.5896410942,
0.1114998236,
0.3319234848,
0.7778512239,
-0.141066432,
0.7104785442,
-0.1501256675,
0.0789711773,
-0.9320751429,
0.1709822267,
-0.2742137611,
-0.4284054339,
-0.9461691976,
-1.2116856575,
0.0618254617,
0.0236800816,
0.1620834023,
0.4092375636,
-0.1146815196,
0.2743169963,
0.5262975693,
0.0629037768,
0.2794169486,
0.4301812649,
-0.2092888206,
-0.1674607992,
-1.3029267788,
0.1018781886,
1.3388707638,
0.2769533694,
0.6946386695,
0.3087250888,
0.6589075923,
0.1637918949,
0.4965318441,
-1.0809555054,
0.3909932077,
-0.6767665744,
-0.2535686195,
-0.4801193774,
-0.351736635,
-1.0672420263,
0.3890669644,
-0.4163109064,
-0.6188607812,
0.458173126,
-0.0172688458,
-0.3205987811,
0.5297150016,
-0.8134592175,
0.5015714169,
-0.4316165149,
-0.6253089905,
-0.3663831651,
-0.028835671,
0.1588317901,
-0.6487200856,
0.3918271959,
-0.0394717902,
-0.5433695912,
0.926082015,
-0.1683423519,
1.0092949867,
-0.2202042192,
-0.18471241,
0.3007287383,
-0.0635482967,
0.6327512264,
-0.2238503844,
-0.1749701202,
0.5121161342,
-0.0666867346,
-0.6322339773,
-0.5531180501,
0.5557485819,
-0.7491008639,
-0.5581326485,
-0.2368946522,
-0.8621966243,
-0.458668679,
-0.0417848378,
0.0455455929,
0.128901273,
-0.1282713264,
0.3129480779,
0.3576207459,
-0.4748830795,
0.4556641579,
0.6220672727,
-0.0149337752,
-0.1109651402,
0.9477888346,
0.2490114719,
0.5457012057,
0.393755734,
0.4305397868,
-0.2209948897,
-0.6367202997,
-0.6429676414,
0.2944815755,
-0.5340636969,
-0.0112600597,
-0.3525860012,
-0.0705579817,
-0.2418464124,
-0.3561556637,
-0.4586471617,
-0.3532035947,
-0.4262197912,
0.1844860464,
0.7416426539,
0.0475080684,
-0.2571719289,
0.4910136759,
-0.7601282001,
0.0917410254,
-0.099479042,
0.1559470594,
-0.033398021,
-1.0273637772,
-0.5928099751,
-0.0918380469,
0.3425095677,
-0.6205976009,
0.3388539851,
0.3497021794,
0.492824465,
0.1839392185,
-0.0409658104,
0.9850537777,
-0.5269774199,
0.5432983637,
0.3145058453,
-0.6806928515,
-0.1032793373,
-0.1107672974,
0.3217433393,
0.3639191687,
0.4086568356,
-0.5879722238,
0.1769906878,
-0.3567698896,
-0.7325228453,
0.6100541949,
-0.2765884995,
0.5252198577,
0.1100336835,
0.352791816,
0.1210435033,
-0.0883233845,
-0.2858546376,
0.1224883869,
0.091723606,
-0.0621142611,
-0.3524442017,
0.0100897728,
-0.1686804146,
-0.1282912195,
0.4078722298,
-0.6599244475,
0.2003897727,
-0.0888756812,
-0.3658758402,
0.0574649535,
0.3782322407,
0.1749492288,
0.284116298,
0.1954375952,
0.0321023203,
0.7843046784,
-0.4140836298,
0.115143925,
0.1580939591,
0.0123843802,
-0.0613197386,
0.5218096972,
0.7079452276,
0.6453863978,
-0.7351965904,
0.4292834997,
0.1605269611,
-0.1160623208,
0.000810818,
-0.0508154929,
0.2236543298,
0.3075497448,
0.2586618662,
-0.2574009299,
-0.219874531,
-0.6187804341,
-0.0356768779,
0.6446480751,
-0.1217041537,
-0.2578440607,
0.2265730798,
0.1505671591,
-0.0747563094,
0.3716933429,
-0.1979510784,
-0.1449836195,
0.4035463929,
0.705051899,
0.7403426766,
0.0216163304,
0.0915261656,
0.263431102,
0.3930226564,
-0.0154159712,
0.4006002843,
-0.0127317691,
-1.0995389223,
-0.7964444757,
-0.6629486084,
-0.4040551186,
-0.0524770655,
-0.4418230653,
0.2266969383,
-0.5167354345,
-0.1087943316,
-0.2809063494,
0.1639142334,
-0.9427978396,
-0.1125499308,
0.0781954527,
1.2258019447,
-0.9483733177,
0.7415981889,
0.6249421835,
0.0438266695,
-0.6503553987,
-0.0549553894,
-0.2442761064,
-1.0992848873,
0.7872668505,
-0.427015543,
-0.013112234,
0.1133660525,
-0.0086954096,
-1.3162305355,
0.984672308,
0.3248209655,
-0.6682845354,
-0.1882961988,
0.119320415,
0.5444941521,
-0.5446459651,
0.0444003567,
0.4073915184,
0.4299962819,
0.1308426708,
-0.9191371799,
0.297296375,
0.1915159523,
0.2482611537,
0.0032331471,
-0.5134025812,
0.8778648376,
-0.3803477287,
-0.1849697679,
-0.0338613689,
0.8249585629,
0.0404135659,
-0.256557405,
0.8338749409,
0.192568481,
0.7475514412,
0.1091416329,
0.9899849892,
-0.6403135061,
-0.1463224441,
1.2291451693,
-0.3453480601,
1.0152897835,
0.7620874047,
-0.0082035735,
0.5207029581,
0.5978206396,
-0.1801141202,
0.3952495754,
0.3702174127,
-0.1026695222,
-0.1770596802,
-0.5087278485,
-0.060201738,
0.8075946569,
0.5594248772,
-0.4444046617,
-0.2081759721,
0.0502821617,
-0.0462681279,
-0.2055123001,
-0.4435468912,
0.7147661448,
-0.0456401519,
-0.5176658034,
0.6609449983,
0.227064833,
0.8932062387,
-0.3950306475,
0.225989297,
-0.2169439048,
-0.0719448328,
-0.003470453,
-0.362728864,
-0.0003357953,
0.123215273,
0.106850639,
-0.180531621,
0.6266795993,
-0.4133608639,
-0.6112892032,
0.4978478253,
1.1305282116,
0.1483908892,
0.5222117305,
-0.6156850457,
-0.0446314327,
-0.2280771732,
-0.1922875345,
0.5898913145,
0.3816667199,
-0.529437542,
0.3612895608,
0.9220719934,
0.6902252436,
0.2031033188,
0.0362875648,
0.6885498166,
-0.3447300494,
-0.432534039,
-0.5867861509,
0.1583659202,
-0.056139525,
-0.2248398364,
0.680267334,
0.4507879913,
0.8596217036,
0.082870312,
0.8255594969,
0.0663393587,
0.277677834,
-0.6632146239,
0.4133095145,
-0.6798654199,
0.1821168512,
-0.0821179003,
-0.7100302577,
0.0455563255,
0.2564823925,
-0.4796945453,
0.0178438835,
0.661578536,
0.7105770707,
-0.2542104125,
-0.5259834528,
0.4588361979,
0.2203038037,
-0.0385545231,
0.5388041735,
0.4962434471,
-0.1603835523,
0.6184342504,
-0.3100918233,
-0.2699150443,
-0.2603240609,
-1.0400999784,
-0.7362025976,
-0.3020172417,
-0.2199482918,
-0.3823227286,
0.1523701549,
1.129950285,
0.7294147611,
-0.674605906,
-0.38731426,
0.2932111323,
0.1104419157,
-0.3137376308,
-0.1950778663,
0.436739862,
-0.4569144845,
-1.027726531,
0.5153625607,
0.0162683725,
-0.0088021737,
-0.3756788969,
-0.0536544658,
-0.1659450382,
0.3355866671,
0.6526707411,
0.4479582608,
-0.5157430172,
-0.3450081646,
0.2033940405,
-0.1238431185,
0.0447288193,
0.7049319148,
-0.6682407856,
0.3437533677,
0.4782473445,
1.1337599754,
0.3489705622,
-0.1341299415,
0.7202528119,
-0.8595666289,
0.3394272029,
-0.13180089,
0.399071008,
0.392110616,
-0.3518960178,
0.3701023161,
0.2011772692,
0.1547752768,
-0.8886318803,
0.0165210497,
-0.6844427586,
-0.4034196138,
1.3305050135,
-0.0834908485,
-0.4128743708,
0.0628327355,
0.1351392418,
0.2810086906,
-0.3287535608,
0.7207478881,
0.6373935938,
-0.1253553927,
-0.0796650425,
-0.4458208382,
0.4410323501,
0.5903490782,
-0.9075613022,
0.0715004504,
0.2031739354,
0.3677513003,
0.2777241766,
0.5464882851,
0.0796985924,
0.1411887258,
0.0648089871,
-0.0987441987,
0.1301617324,
-0.0855776593,
-0.3832017481,
0.1186937243,
0.1237905324,
-0.3448390663
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11474v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11474v1 | How Far Can In-Context Alignment Go? Exploring the State of In-Context Alignment | 2024-06-17T12:38:48 | 2024-06-17T12:38:48 | Heyan Huang, Yinghao Li, Huashan Sun, Yu Bai, Yang Gao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recent studies have demonstrated that In-Context Learning (ICL), through the
use of specific demonstrations, can align Large Language Models (LLMs) with
human preferences known as In-Context Alignment (ICA), indicating that models
can comprehend human instructions without requiring parameter adjustments.
However, the exploration of the mechanism and applicability of ICA remains
limited. In this paper, we begin by dividing the context text used in ICA into
three categories: format, system prompt, and example. Through ablation
experiments, we investigate the effectiveness of each part in enabling ICA to
function effectively. We then examine how variants in these parts impact the
model's alignment performance. Our findings indicate that the example part is
crucial for enhancing the model's alignment capabilities, with changes in
examples significantly affecting alignment performance. We also conduct a
comprehensive evaluation of ICA's zero-shot capabilities in various alignment
tasks. The results indicate that compared to parameter fine-tuning methods, ICA
demonstrates superior performance in knowledge-based tasks and tool-use tasks.
However, it still exhibits certain limitations in areas such as multi-turn
dialogues and instruction following. | [
-0.3671786487,
-0.6637089849,
0.7449594736,
-0.1049135104,
-0.393155694,
-0.0155038023,
-0.2702059448,
-0.6807284951,
-0.3340452313,
0.144732058,
-0.407117188,
-0.3100544512,
-0.250598222,
0.0975318328,
-0.5429810882,
0.9697497487,
-0.2865896523,
0.0209535174,
-0.5020660162,
-0.4308391213,
-0.8906804323,
-0.4819772542,
-0.278179884,
-0.413748771,
0.3355154693,
0.9781421423,
0.6143121123,
0.9784365892,
0.4466666281,
0.2151956111,
-0.1373472512,
0.0411314778,
-0.2724623084,
0.0552523248,
-0.2795504332,
-0.3728883564,
-0.2218796015,
-0.031058738,
0.9157581329,
0.7487806678,
0.0437404811,
-0.0394418091,
0.2520673573,
0.517889142,
-0.5401849151,
-0.3619907796,
-0.692909956,
-0.4057008922,
-0.2800616622,
0.0945428535,
-0.3044010699,
-0.1361683607,
0.5786998272,
-0.4056262672,
-0.2449500859,
0.0583898537,
0.9161812067,
0.2966824472,
-0.6982837319,
-0.5367633104,
-0.8634803295,
0.86759758,
-0.9424640536,
0.3870514929,
0.0680228546,
0.2179029882,
-0.1862502545,
-0.2755478919,
-0.7097647786,
-0.0661875606,
-0.0936787128,
-0.246970132,
0.0172509607,
0.1159468591,
0.4304668605,
0.0981738567,
-0.3653253317,
0.5180021524,
-0.1311724037,
0.0563852303,
0.2633654773,
0.1443304718,
0.5329105258,
0.0473428257,
-0.5208801627,
-0.1249632239,
-0.973026216,
0.3259691596,
0.1243466288,
0.4097992778,
-0.1495047063,
0.7044218779,
-0.1784771085,
1.0681632757,
0.2644738853,
-0.1959014088,
-0.2102214694,
-0.2576258481,
-0.3846575916,
0.3391186297,
0.3561319709,
0.4122993648,
-0.2379054576,
-0.2378511131,
-0.1186146662,
-0.0484238602,
0.2275693715,
-0.7650048733,
0.3824108541,
0.1882965416,
-0.2326223105,
0.1639825851,
0.0058664051,
-0.3996509314,
-0.3322590888,
-0.7867014408,
0.5549674034,
-0.6162213087,
0.2684230208,
-0.0087679308,
0.1612686217,
0.7275432348,
0.2946437895,
-1.0549558401,
0.2168551385,
0.8427741528,
0.7470667958,
-0.3348085582,
-0.4692524672,
-0.404474169,
0.2334365249,
-0.2615064681,
0.7839223742,
-0.6505014896,
0.051176738,
-0.0316513926,
-0.2008152902,
-0.0984515995,
-0.5100531578,
0.0283609275,
-0.4941307902,
0.271861583,
-0.4485529661,
-0.9914095402,
-0.3300419152,
0.1233479604,
-0.2840916216,
0.6570953131,
0.0166497901,
-0.4753981531,
0.7231330276,
-0.59551543,
-0.4393443763,
-0.1689581275,
-0.3182015121,
-0.2424808592,
0.2332656831,
0.0928435102,
0.4107581675,
-0.1865155995,
0.2326819599,
-0.2814637125,
-0.800380826,
0.5580006838,
-0.3401780725,
0.6194697022,
0.034129452,
-0.5837673545,
0.1169154048,
-0.4804216325,
-0.4061745107,
-0.277566582,
-0.2216902673,
-0.431075722,
0.0121170003,
-0.2094709873,
0.4470281303,
0.2481096089,
-0.497780323,
0.4457288086,
-0.5289775133,
0.3906439245,
0.6851392388,
-0.1700627804,
0.8938142657,
-0.2734110355,
0.4427445531,
0.0078133894,
0.0669308454,
-0.2814621031,
-0.2723022997,
-0.5768312216,
-0.1507606953,
0.3583933115,
0.4196973145,
-0.3461437523,
0.3167085946,
-0.1578031629,
-0.4216419756,
-0.3996710181,
0.0894756243,
0.621404469,
0.9706678987,
0.2869508564,
-0.2599570155,
-0.3201234043,
-0.9515911937,
-0.2634208798,
-0.0872205347,
0.036571946,
0.285862118,
0.2982806563,
0.0341761857,
1.2271491289,
-0.102250278,
-0.0917271972,
-0.0727898553,
-0.105536446,
0.0120047685,
0.529651463,
0.4567072093,
-0.5530512929,
-0.6437044144,
0.2583130896,
-0.6172707677,
-0.0537201837,
-0.2301447242,
-0.1746027023,
0.3500291407,
0.6720578074,
-0.2627961338,
0.4824311137,
0.4936845303,
-0.3169410229,
0.1670498252,
-0.0999950096,
0.0820342526,
-1.1033229828,
0.0992329046,
0.0412485749,
-0.0681057125,
-0.8452621698,
0.0532326624,
0.4579359889,
0.0569074713,
-0.6842939258,
0.7654799819,
-0.356179595,
-0.2161845118,
-0.430924207,
0.3153669536,
-0.1764256358,
0.381321311,
-0.0612558685,
0.9510670304,
0.3254007101,
-0.6700107455,
-0.2725239396,
0.3238865733,
-0.4882478416,
0.7199223638,
-0.2890638411,
0.3180992305,
-0.0762178525,
0.2377710938,
-1.028378129,
-0.35760957,
0.1130880713,
-0.0107893953,
0.5498008132,
0.0224805828,
-0.3457127213,
0.391033262,
0.0376891196,
0.6823703647,
0.4200849533,
-0.7416455746,
0.5334143639,
0.1324854195,
0.1517955214,
-0.8430632949,
-0.3589081764,
0.1096164733,
-0.6743237376,
-0.5029996634,
0.7079754472,
-0.2528339028,
-0.4044238329,
-0.3119696677,
-0.2246452719,
0.1546816677,
0.2939269841,
0.1665305793,
0.2774804831,
-0.1652475297,
0.1585365534,
0.2507304549,
0.2352283895,
-0.426168263,
-0.119479388,
0.4297638834,
-0.1622675508,
-0.5094597936,
-0.8759378791,
0.295509249,
0.5642539263,
0.0352838635,
0.6806451678,
-0.0706241578,
-0.4049401879,
0.0452671051,
-0.4733149111,
-0.2398494333,
-0.4178328812,
0.1861924082,
-0.1826484799,
-0.9081798196,
0.477566272,
0.0255300216,
0.2724677622,
0.0922076479,
0.2569382787,
-0.3005944788,
1.2149597406,
0.741324842,
-0.2127314359,
0.755564332,
0.0863615498,
0.2342544198,
-1.1194448471,
-0.0712156445,
-0.6528241634,
-0.6202019453,
-0.3886162639,
0.0932018459,
0.2721713483,
0.455904752,
-0.3826152384,
0.5697534084,
-0.2885076702,
0.6340290308,
0.431612581,
0.021320153,
0.1786592007,
-0.131908536,
-0.0971540362,
0.000410491,
-0.5517647266,
-0.7838855982,
0.8342226744,
0.3684932888,
0.5180435777,
0.1538963616,
0.57776016,
-0.2972988188,
0.6459503174,
-0.8953225613,
0.3900693655,
-0.1171644256,
-0.5275031328,
-0.4666369557,
0.196884647,
-0.6046304703,
0.1863464266,
-0.0724795535,
-0.9784591198,
0.1814003289,
0.2462247312,
-0.4711509943,
0.1845386028,
-0.7271856666,
0.8927408457,
-0.2885880768,
-0.226624608,
0.0964805335,
-0.7992233634,
0.1519476622,
-0.0390087031,
0.0699907988,
0.0371522643,
-0.091123797,
0.3712586761,
-0.0647131801,
0.9455679655,
-0.0776607767,
-0.4079250395,
-0.0115741175,
-0.0010298748,
0.3894889057,
-0.2068878561,
-0.047552079,
-0.009076097,
-0.02542492,
-0.3035450876,
-0.7440845966,
0.5982339382,
-0.5802896619,
-0.6435735226,
-0.21595788,
-0.7341682315,
-0.4251762927,
0.1311435252,
0.1843026727,
0.6807714701,
-0.2083461285,
0.4214300513,
0.6913377047,
-0.0480895117,
0.5627745986,
0.5070289969,
-0.027478287,
-0.0385573581,
0.771907866,
0.0812451914,
0.4416072965,
0.6395373344,
0.1487838179,
-0.3881652951,
-0.8037080765,
-0.7615334392,
0.271209687,
-0.851278007,
-0.1787462831,
-0.3760618269,
0.1848927885,
-0.2354995161,
-0.6106483936,
-0.0710783079,
-0.1930955499,
-0.7095552087,
0.0657459572,
-0.1217251122,
0.7836000919,
0.3989779949,
0.4740363359,
-0.5586233139,
-0.2647154629,
0.2737279534,
0.4022266865,
-0.0274255835,
-0.6638049483,
-0.3620738089,
0.0011813135,
-0.4011883736,
-0.8281907439,
0.0269523375,
0.0936347544,
0.3248427808,
0.6846017838,
-0.1881356537,
1.0665677786,
-0.4460954964,
0.8755882382,
-0.0886717439,
-1.1856341362,
0.2583129406,
-0.2964456677,
0.5557402372,
0.583614707,
0.1917034984,
-0.6582251191,
-0.4339154363,
-0.2620590031,
-0.5947108269,
0.8581736088,
-0.1670818776,
0.1081323773,
0.0908883065,
0.7951683998,
0.1867665052,
-0.1564501226,
-0.4073178172,
-0.0022076892,
0.1346900314,
-0.4484936595,
-0.1176932231,
-0.158466801,
-0.3048657775,
-0.1603763103,
0.6498633027,
-0.5006409287,
-0.026899524,
0.1251212209,
-0.2841525376,
-0.1552630514,
0.382391423,
1.1489099264,
0.9978598356,
-0.0927329957,
-0.1067855507,
0.3661620915,
0.0187228397,
0.1918362826,
-0.048660554,
-0.2366358936,
-0.5695042014,
0.2989807129,
0.6540340185,
0.4458792806,
-0.7134734988,
0.4903609753,
-0.1695176661,
-0.0386250801,
0.0301077832,
0.1159536242,
-0.0127309728,
0.3665177524,
0.2753341198,
-0.1178265288,
0.0668663159,
-0.6061999798,
0.0948721021,
0.8203050494,
-0.6544755697,
-0.3295968771,
0.5143504143,
-0.2053516954,
-0.3565269113,
0.6208228469,
0.1257962137,
-0.3383313119,
0.6338741183,
0.7857343554,
0.6968257427,
-0.0653291196,
-0.1363266706,
0.048305694,
0.0567814931,
-0.0304315723,
-0.0128625389,
-0.216899842,
-0.7721421719,
-0.5239267349,
-0.36001724,
-0.6380296946,
-0.0604037642,
-0.6341894269,
0.3700111508,
-0.1580925286,
0.2283721864,
-0.0392449163,
-0.1280871034,
-0.659442246,
0.1110399216,
0.1177780256,
0.9160859585,
-0.7279702425,
0.8378378749,
0.861671865,
-0.2381036133,
-0.9377874732,
0.2659534216,
0.1413079202,
-0.4102466404,
0.4315264821,
0.4344961643,
-0.1478847116,
-0.2242995948,
-0.765684545,
-1.0492702723,
1.2565720081,
0.5389214158,
-0.4613467455,
-0.0780096427,
-0.0056369039,
0.5401619673,
-0.7112253308,
0.1359450072,
0.6522320509,
0.210428074,
-0.0300220419,
-1.0079424381,
0.0910367891,
0.2973617911,
0.0566420518,
0.1377514005,
-0.7009266019,
0.6042001843,
0.0390256345,
-0.3979178965,
0.305929333,
0.8313596249,
0.1757433265,
0.4040469825,
0.5419843793,
0.4282609224,
0.5360037088,
0.0373195969,
1.0069864988,
-0.2680040002,
-0.0431751572,
1.1887769699,
-0.5574882627,
0.8130723238,
0.8500801921,
0.2299903482,
0.7076863647,
0.6584838629,
0.5949872732,
0.3281183839,
-0.128947407,
-0.2603872418,
-0.0722641796,
-0.2327934802,
-0.0252642203,
0.7861733437,
0.4126164019,
-0.1844787747,
0.0014460594,
0.101944305,
-0.0262343828,
0.1046922281,
-0.0373778008,
1.0685174465,
-0.1427086741,
-1.1329180002,
0.3770838082,
-0.1257750094,
0.5835155845,
-0.4221349955,
-0.2359671146,
-0.1794263273,
0.0333555602,
-0.1522163004,
-0.6905551553,
0.2541014552,
-0.1931300759,
-0.15915595,
-0.1103639156,
0.4673964679,
-0.4645150006,
0.204011336,
0.0801117793,
0.1327191442,
0.0688747689,
0.1639426649,
-0.3595738113,
0.0300930906,
0.0202505346,
0.0800437927,
0.8082168698,
0.2253915668,
-0.2326356769,
0.4517624378,
0.2693682909,
-0.3117669225,
-0.1242117509,
-0.1708692014,
0.7349291444,
-0.6108427644,
-0.0927890912,
-0.911115706,
0.5820763111,
0.0259914957,
-0.4296256006,
0.7198722959,
0.4380482137,
1.2117624283,
0.306245774,
0.545830369,
0.0456440151,
0.2625766695,
-0.639097333,
0.3259857297,
-0.7430567741,
0.2440448552,
-0.2855043709,
-0.842751205,
-0.4737332165,
0.3088026941,
-0.2174734175,
-0.1778278798,
0.6517345905,
0.7770505548,
-0.1750710309,
0.0904174969,
0.3897718787,
-0.1827841252,
0.5505694747,
0.2065804154,
0.8717904091,
-0.2373539507,
0.3431169391,
-0.4978401959,
-0.3357730806,
-0.2727309167,
-1.172326088,
-0.7129980326,
-0.8183930516,
-0.1337862611,
-0.1333299428,
-0.2371177226,
1.1798686981,
0.7522690296,
-0.6751477122,
-0.4618073106,
0.0584378727,
0.1515376568,
-0.4569045901,
-0.1639851034,
0.3406175673,
-0.4616149366,
-0.9323453307,
0.7389638424,
0.3993753791,
0.1800082922,
-0.1157839969,
0.0990204439,
-0.2335362136,
0.0722872242,
0.5046067238,
0.5276307464,
-0.8988186121,
-0.6465841532,
0.1895219684,
-0.065398179,
0.1271226853,
0.9303377867,
-0.4720982015,
0.6304088235,
0.3407465816,
0.8082858324,
0.0843321756,
0.3570673168,
0.7786218524,
-0.6793446541,
-0.1880096048,
0.0212401617,
0.3827688396,
0.4015970826,
-0.503960371,
0.0957653746,
-0.4701720476,
-0.9432932734,
-0.7841633558,
0.2941682041,
-0.8458617926,
-0.3159198463,
1.1128174067,
0.1846482903,
-0.2531155944,
-0.1511329114,
-0.3476453722,
0.4521681666,
-0.4249725938,
0.9136703014,
0.8327507377,
-0.5799828172,
0.1252109855,
-0.2919478118,
0.5903104544,
0.6400918365,
-0.6375843883,
0.0735489354,
0.5735734701,
0.3307231069,
0.0388857834,
0.4249649644,
-0.0934157968,
0.2579736114,
-0.7248110175,
-0.119625777,
0.2748039663,
-0.4286538661,
-1.0877122879,
-0.0379436426,
0.3137535453,
0.0141158234
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11473v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11473v1 | Promises, Outlooks and Challenges of Diffusion Language Modeling | 2024-06-17T12:38:38 | 2024-06-17T12:38:38 | Justin Deschenaux, Caglar Gulcehre | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The modern autoregressive Large Language Models (LLMs) have achieved
outstanding performance on NLP benchmarks, and they are deployed in the real
world. However, they still suffer from limitations of the autoregressive
training paradigm. For example, autoregressive token generation is notably slow
and can be prone to \textit{exposure bias}. The diffusion-based language models
were proposed as an alternative to autoregressive generation to address some of
these limitations. We evaluate the recently proposed Score Entropy Discrete
Diffusion (SEDD) approach and show it is a promising alternative to
autoregressive generation but it has some short-comings too. We empirically
demonstrate the advantages and challenges of SEDD, and observe that SEDD
generally matches autoregressive models in perplexity and on benchmarks such as
HellaSwag, Arc or WinoGrande. Additionally, we show that in terms of inference
latency, SEDD can be up to 4.5$\times$ more efficient than GPT-2. While SEDD
allows conditioning on tokens at abitrary positions, SEDD appears slightly
weaker than GPT-2 for conditional generation given short prompts. Finally, we
reproduced the main results from the original SEDD paper. | [
-0.225575909,
-0.8924486637,
0.7269482613,
0.3740199506,
-0.0638608634,
-0.1064719334,
-0.0908959433,
-0.21959804,
-0.0969728827,
0.2671681643,
-0.4512805641,
-0.3554141819,
-0.8633602262,
-0.0821042806,
-0.6373192072,
0.7376908064,
-0.102255024,
-0.1283573955,
-0.2043954134,
0.1628037393,
0.0088031972,
-0.5518338084,
-1.0412648916,
-0.3745840192,
0.3690608442,
-0.0743807182,
0.6573133469,
0.5243021846,
0.3394860029,
0.2696849406,
-0.2405998707,
-0.3206951916,
-0.2099034786,
0.50328511,
0.0387212634,
-0.0931746587,
-0.3543956578,
0.1968470514,
0.6585634351,
0.7712495327,
-0.6233016253,
-0.1543602049,
-0.0179453082,
0.6465431452,
-0.4932300746,
-0.1341082901,
-0.5252776146,
0.1366546899,
-0.3479932249,
0.2666718364,
-0.3168182373,
-0.2401651889,
0.2269507498,
-0.0167922396,
0.141551137,
-0.1182353497,
0.4528363347,
0.5006403327,
-0.5544256568,
-0.3421428204,
-0.7649416924,
0.6029534936,
-1.058711648,
0.3290532529,
0.2532071769,
0.155276835,
-0.0322925076,
-0.6224935651,
-0.406370312,
-0.0982434303,
0.29491961,
0.0769481584,
-0.1181375384,
0.0077208201,
0.1577983201,
0.4162881672,
-0.7478839159,
0.4489043951,
0.0038423943,
0.0280487407,
0.6817671657,
0.4211941957,
-0.0808746591,
0.0372030474,
-0.4232301116,
0.0653391927,
-0.6584690213,
-0.2439122647,
0.5406326652,
0.0067272442,
-0.1688158065,
0.4196952283,
-0.21542418,
0.5891089439,
-0.0462182723,
0.1053548902,
0.2983911335,
0.0287787728,
-0.2494358122,
-0.3728981018,
0.8462783694,
-0.0083740093,
-0.1013783216,
-0.2303930521,
-0.3290653527,
0.02508655,
-0.1947689056,
-0.7126132846,
-0.2862740159,
0.3029649258,
-0.5137324929,
-0.2505714595,
-0.4084700048,
-0.8324514627,
-0.445395261,
0.0630345941,
0.2007436454,
-0.4463819563,
-0.6229429245,
0.2528759241,
-0.2273065895,
0.3203177452,
0.5935863853,
-0.866230011,
0.3404833078,
0.6128965616,
1.0311858654,
-0.742141366,
-0.1772230715,
-0.2159880996,
-0.0254855417,
-0.2210068852,
0.8536370993,
-0.6204437017,
-0.5308989286,
-0.2079244703,
-0.4319437146,
-0.2050991207,
-0.5105834603,
0.2557308376,
-0.3992983699,
0.1575816125,
-0.0782350525,
-0.6163026094,
0.1844426095,
0.03155756,
-0.4751131237,
0.9819095135,
0.249203071,
-0.6805383563,
0.257914722,
-0.535120368,
-0.5351866484,
-0.0097459741,
0.0434121788,
-0.2247979194,
0.1561289728,
-0.1821635514,
0.3935382664,
-0.3449463546,
0.4373306632,
-0.5313389301,
0.1099890992,
0.0330490097,
-0.9715380669,
0.9254496098,
0.6026674509,
-0.3964928985,
-0.3176431358,
-0.8029574156,
-0.0926990435,
0.1435557902,
-0.4575597346,
-0.2720864117,
0.1693800986,
-0.1220963895,
0.3056356907,
0.174216181,
-0.2861810327,
0.0905504152,
-0.4044520259,
0.3878759742,
1.1340442896,
0.018992221,
0.6728896499,
-0.0142853446,
0.8748301268,
0.2445526719,
0.1231325492,
-0.1282487065,
-0.6071817279,
-0.6227305532,
-0.2307356149,
0.5468990803,
0.5196902752,
-0.4938295484,
0.3481814265,
0.1740640551,
-0.4499676526,
-0.4679424465,
0.0046347682,
0.152104035,
0.4808759391,
0.1289535761,
-0.4188208878,
-0.3017250597,
-0.6159794331,
-0.0017026949,
-0.307761848,
0.2115816772,
0.2296121269,
0.379835397,
-0.2812356055,
0.8174224496,
-0.4185237288,
0.2439146936,
-0.0040195524,
0.2719598711,
0.1337691545,
0.5245661736,
0.2592802346,
-0.5909273028,
-0.7042759061,
-0.2173817903,
-0.4530616701,
-0.4210239649,
0.0617740303,
0.2278421819,
0.6429889202,
0.5484060645,
-0.6636028886,
0.4545347989,
0.7865850925,
-0.3524290323,
0.6356980801,
-0.1686888188,
-0.1304532439,
-0.8059478998,
-0.1370855421,
0.0770609006,
-0.2824122906,
-0.639975965,
-0.1127300039,
-0.2583682239,
-0.1163640469,
-0.5475993156,
0.8622657061,
-0.3467689157,
-0.1738891751,
-0.1785700023,
-0.0019281619,
-0.2571334541,
0.0697822869,
0.353292644,
0.8042625785,
0.8083074093,
-0.8887156248,
0.2228837162,
-0.1133693755,
-0.3870868683,
0.4386969507,
-0.6697869897,
0.0764196664,
-0.1235886589,
0.2696413994,
-0.9299744964,
0.247621268,
0.0645986795,
-0.2904432118,
0.3128421605,
0.0766297206,
-0.4898999929,
-0.3054634035,
-0.0789897442,
0.3449198902,
0.8275257349,
-0.4610652626,
0.3356967866,
0.3670276403,
-0.2418124527,
-0.4534541368,
-0.5493274927,
0.1872337908,
-0.5878919363,
-0.606122613,
0.3302176893,
-0.4479351342,
-0.4558414817,
-0.0788675696,
0.0608669147,
0.30524683,
0.3812041581,
0.023263881,
-0.1814000756,
-0.2109951377,
0.0415123291,
0.0441428348,
-0.268607527,
0.0465700105,
-0.2924848497,
0.6638929844,
0.012611201,
-0.4792798758,
-0.0343843699,
0.4663591683,
0.2479141951,
0.1502006352,
0.7510761023,
0.6304028034,
-0.1774883717,
-0.3665406406,
-0.6013532281,
0.0596452989,
-0.4888650179,
0.194144249,
-0.3763263524,
-0.8796602488,
0.5823350549,
-0.3038034141,
-0.040813379,
0.5318573713,
0.8032577634,
-0.0576921068,
1.1433589458,
0.4936393797,
0.0627225637,
0.4246082902,
-0.1010434926,
0.1917365491,
-0.9399982691,
-0.0005681344,
-0.5411758423,
-0.0175898671,
-0.3234785199,
-0.4261735976,
0.1633263826,
0.1089163199,
-0.2375966311,
0.1038338467,
-0.1828718185,
0.2565633357,
0.5444655418,
-0.4010691345,
0.1234665439,
-0.1994985342,
-0.251624167,
-0.045680806,
-0.8569687009,
-0.3763113618,
0.8299424052,
0.5125561953,
1.0092016459,
0.2580099702,
0.9726822972,
0.4743073285,
0.0702870935,
-0.3533162773,
0.5783362389,
-0.1633910239,
-0.4019143879,
-0.4062435329,
-0.5016483665,
-0.8189622164,
0.2632425129,
0.2133983225,
-0.6783550382,
0.2295997888,
0.0204091538,
-0.2304396033,
0.1519770771,
-0.8143324256,
0.6905480623,
-0.2232567817,
-0.2661827207,
0.0138413412,
-0.4763587117,
0.4769753516,
-0.1349344552,
0.298761636,
-0.2062167078,
-0.040697109,
0.6589099765,
-0.5709498525,
0.8377255797,
-0.3535190225,
-0.5673949718,
0.1372575909,
0.0754565746,
0.690523088,
0.097643882,
-0.4742636085,
-0.005103712,
-0.1135501787,
-0.1681414396,
-0.3085656464,
0.8598549962,
-0.5120437145,
-0.9136155248,
-0.6480558515,
-0.2825878859,
-0.3130499125,
0.0458174571,
0.3156076372,
0.0859979093,
-0.3034608662,
-0.1811514646,
0.7883251309,
-0.4867408276,
0.7639677525,
0.5831257105,
-0.1743454188,
-0.237709403,
0.6837764978,
0.0695077777,
0.5483385921,
-0.027337892,
0.1866630167,
-0.4594340324,
-0.6588667631,
-0.1773681939,
0.2429545969,
-0.6774970293,
-0.1370123327,
-0.8860548735,
-0.3882029057,
-0.8133943081,
-0.1499488652,
-0.3342849016,
-0.6657010317,
-0.5896677375,
-0.0859341249,
0.2171837538,
0.7215496302,
-0.5686063766,
0.1725283265,
-0.3561418355,
0.2261760235,
0.2996197939,
0.4138924181,
0.1605158448,
-0.6401387453,
-0.1782340109,
-0.1986073405,
-0.1130800694,
-0.7448282242,
0.4653274417,
0.1719591171,
0.6000661254,
0.3494288325,
-0.0463943072,
0.6862490773,
-0.813718915,
0.9839101434,
0.1935434341,
-0.8154976964,
0.4957775176,
-0.0745359361,
0.2924956679,
0.2220373303,
0.2714790404,
-0.5598923564,
-0.6823077202,
-0.9646437168,
-0.9092911482,
0.4562258422,
-0.1017261967,
0.2287056595,
-0.4711833596,
0.4309176207,
0.2847721279,
0.1374263167,
-0.6322289705,
-0.3148693144,
0.0570232905,
-0.0669849142,
-0.0502538569,
-0.3749776185,
0.3701360524,
0.0108756656,
0.856387794,
0.2403682619,
0.2872922122,
0.0770446509,
0.0160227027,
-0.0342199057,
0.2047374398,
0.6844382882,
0.3336611986,
-0.0619074628,
0.1364821941,
0.059016183,
-0.2281475812,
0.3781259954,
0.1415627897,
-0.4203121662,
0.1054849699,
0.1262165159,
0.8001028299,
-0.273696512,
-0.4662784636,
0.4250258505,
0.0035988286,
-0.3805275559,
-0.4465132356,
0.1840932518,
0.190748319,
0.4887118936,
0.2419255823,
0.0434559993,
0.2594105303,
-0.3101534843,
0.110097222,
0.8522090912,
-0.3501709998,
-0.3014275432,
0.958293736,
0.1158853099,
-0.3486504853,
0.5274515152,
-0.4704153538,
-0.3147167563,
0.5072082281,
0.7504372001,
0.8863275051,
-0.5351375341,
0.4794925153,
0.0200858675,
0.1745039672,
-0.4147556424,
0.0420204364,
-0.1262513697,
-0.6546230316,
-0.4022325873,
-0.8908658624,
-0.4147353768,
0.1686069518,
-0.4041248858,
0.1230908707,
-0.3426586986,
-0.2820940316,
-0.2621351182,
-0.2202625126,
-0.4076336622,
0.0956710279,
0.3506332338,
0.9784644246,
-0.9528329372,
0.9754559994,
0.2601431608,
-0.1273671687,
-0.2374313474,
-0.023849858,
0.0135051953,
-0.7999393344,
0.7039083838,
-0.2711657286,
-0.0485675633,
0.2713426948,
-0.3342829645,
-1.0048527718,
0.9906659126,
0.2652146816,
-0.3560419977,
-0.3376134634,
-0.250227958,
0.5457608104,
-0.3785903752,
0.0750385821,
0.7088310122,
0.3731449246,
0.2187943012,
-0.6108999252,
-0.1236288846,
-0.1136196405,
0.2776210904,
0.197865963,
-0.6711248755,
0.9261518121,
-0.2448235303,
-0.3685645163,
0.0715135708,
0.7759401798,
0.2312589586,
0.2244858295,
0.4653761089,
0.9717669487,
0.6135601997,
0.0451857187,
0.9979746938,
-0.0503135584,
0.3907444179,
1.0402342081,
-0.7754129171,
0.7772153616,
0.453681767,
-0.555942297,
0.5536988974,
0.7748904824,
0.1143262163,
0.7532935739,
0.3087796867,
-0.5053741336,
-0.084181048,
0.1930573732,
-0.4682900608,
-0.0354377776,
0.5645102262,
-0.2066413015,
-0.3011426926,
0.1179401428,
-0.1235627756,
-0.0870607868,
-0.006405164,
0.7763423324,
0.3517456651,
-0.5242166519,
0.3524270952,
0.1482205987,
0.8830333948,
-0.4254828095,
0.0518227927,
-0.4183164239,
-0.0808474943,
0.0589218773,
-0.6212853789,
0.4724149108,
-0.0075876908,
0.0382762365,
-0.5408456922,
0.6223919988,
-0.4980531037,
-0.3026070297,
0.1822547615,
0.5589390397,
0.2360001951,
0.2132830024,
-0.9015207887,
-0.0175221264,
-0.1347584277,
-0.4984783232,
0.5114954114,
0.7365788221,
0.2813014984,
0.7782831192,
0.3402487338,
0.4408766925,
0.2155944556,
0.1170250922,
0.4854238629,
-0.5224254727,
-0.4805954099,
-0.9649253488,
0.3138076067,
0.1578816772,
-0.1530655622,
0.739236474,
0.4222788215,
0.4743953049,
0.1658761203,
0.9256057143,
-0.169444561,
0.5991814733,
-0.807489872,
0.4016394913,
-0.4889325202,
0.5504823327,
-0.3130073547,
-0.8271678686,
-0.267970413,
0.6355170608,
-0.4018782079,
0.2617768943,
0.9441686869,
0.5765549541,
0.0908397809,
-0.324760139,
0.386387527,
0.1575013101,
0.4101881981,
0.5367057323,
0.8256041408,
-0.2993458807,
0.2379130125,
-0.0406603403,
-0.0650798529,
-0.0930177271,
-0.9810827374,
-0.6588666439,
-0.8157415986,
-0.6735367775,
-0.4816641808,
-0.075489603,
0.45447281,
0.3604040146,
-0.5903277993,
-0.1064320058,
-0.3530961871,
0.2210798562,
-0.058537554,
-0.2788849175,
0.2436780781,
-0.562284708,
-0.6828384399,
0.3094083667,
0.4788304269,
0.5666259527,
-0.6230356097,
-0.3232106268,
-0.1060369462,
0.2104514837,
0.5549780726,
0.2757956386,
-0.6599655151,
-0.0962888673,
-0.1215610281,
-0.1324393749,
-0.1114519462,
0.626740694,
-0.7864458561,
0.0417932756,
0.4305717945,
0.5596824288,
0.6704490185,
-0.0601550266,
0.6844778657,
-0.517909348,
0.0097146938,
0.3214099407,
0.2750779092,
0.2751673162,
-0.1951725334,
0.5963231921,
0.1644403338,
-0.653808713,
-0.9516988993,
0.4644321501,
-0.478086859,
-0.3286492229,
1.5196695328,
-0.0125397509,
-0.116982162,
-0.316481024,
0.2809773684,
-0.0984862298,
-0.3701432049,
0.662902832,
0.8617078066,
-0.1620467901,
-0.4214771986,
-0.4715079069,
0.6867349744,
0.4810865521,
-0.6900584698,
0.2666713893,
0.4554882646,
0.1763600707,
-0.1425064057,
1.283572197,
-0.1625801027,
0.0839797929,
0.0671555698,
-0.2260766178,
0.2880167067,
-0.176824674,
-0.7474195957,
0.015373541,
0.2961379588,
0.3501079381
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11464v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11464v1 | Automating Easy Read Text Segmentation | 2024-06-17T12:25:25 | 2024-06-17T12:25:25 | Jesús Calleja, Thierry Etchegoyhen, David Ponce | cs.CL | cs.CL | Easy Read text is one of the main forms of access to information for people
with reading difficulties. One of the key characteristics of this type of text
is the requirement to split sentences into smaller grammatical segments, to
facilitate reading. Automated segmentation methods could foster the creation of
Easy Read content, but their viability has yet to be addressed. In this work,
we study novel methods for the task, leveraging masked and generative language
models, along with constituent parsing. We conduct comprehensive automatic and
human evaluations in three languages, analysing the strengths and weaknesses of
the proposed alternatives, under scarce resource limitations. Our results
highlight the viability of automated ER segmentation and remaining deficiencies
compared to expert-driven human segmentation. | [
-0.2616394758,
-0.9446883202,
0.8282876611,
0.2368771285,
-0.4829999804,
0.0427080803,
-0.0079039717,
-0.7507221103,
-0.0324604474,
0.5241882205,
-0.6105026007,
-0.4166692495,
-0.3047909439,
0.8750691414,
-0.4837317169,
0.5677019954,
-0.0972087979,
-0.15777421,
-0.0686659887,
-0.1799531728,
-0.5697334409,
-0.5508980751,
-0.5078157783,
-0.0815508515,
0.2225756049,
0.6109258533,
0.5895223022,
1.3912539482,
0.5646485686,
0.3704036176,
-0.2050269842,
0.3490738571,
0.3170576096,
0.5302944183,
0.035952054,
-0.4013215899,
-0.1201675981,
-0.2728139758,
0.6200951934,
0.8878995776,
-0.0726657212,
-0.2982257903,
0.105416216,
0.9066356421,
-0.4066778123,
-0.0091414237,
-0.3201070428,
0.0997034535,
-0.3211943209,
0.3550028801,
-0.5090347528,
-0.2404668331,
0.2503252923,
-0.4969663024,
0.420429945,
0.4262830615,
0.9735554457,
0.4321458936,
-0.37571913,
-0.8755446672,
-0.4806152582,
0.7485561371,
-0.3321252763,
0.4287309349,
0.4850149155,
0.1884653568,
0.2955836654,
-0.4874775708,
-0.5567175746,
-0.2444020063,
-0.4202470481,
-0.1822437942,
-0.2095605135,
-0.0107357278,
0.0939641297,
0.4562987387,
-0.4176515937,
0.1362253278,
-0.2037663013,
-0.2453688085,
0.5019008517,
0.2181683332,
0.7992175221,
-0.8612331152,
-0.1835550666,
-0.049963098,
-0.2942734957,
-0.1773852259,
0.4768762589,
0.14807567,
0.0267121214,
0.7271002531,
-0.2076400518,
0.981318593,
-0.0978536382,
-0.0071007479,
0.1024962068,
-0.3868472278,
-0.3928319812,
-0.1923770756,
0.5524283051,
-0.0472010076,
0.1346294582,
-0.1214425787,
-0.2566746175,
-0.3183944225,
0.0753104016,
-0.3803412914,
-0.3527699113,
0.2370501906,
-0.5391705632,
-0.0513043515,
-0.0023134125,
-0.899654448,
-0.3708242476,
-0.3184143901,
0.1575410366,
-0.7203725576,
0.3815511763,
0.3749064803,
-0.1819999367,
0.1458486766,
0.7081795335,
-1.0344717503,
0.3306580186,
0.4441367388,
1.0626724958,
-0.287337184,
0.0441101119,
-0.3942067027,
0.074563846,
0.2579577863,
1.266597271,
-0.3013316393,
-0.111429818,
-0.1870383769,
0.1188254058,
-0.5323330164,
-0.4928519428,
0.5959662795,
-0.3445780873,
0.1623864025,
0.0849593058,
-0.3064983785,
-0.1551797837,
0.3135911822,
-1.2621371746,
0.6220109463,
0.0235006306,
-0.5808528662,
0.2351690829,
-0.5721524954,
-0.7147499919,
-0.0072227567,
0.0924892202,
-0.5976211429,
0.039501898,
0.8162273169,
0.2481591851,
-0.0260743257,
-0.2986752987,
0.131814152,
0.3591555953,
0.1833468378,
-0.5594171286,
0.7830405831,
0.4237539172,
-0.490332067,
0.2361774445,
-0.8669978976,
0.0155664189,
-0.042743247,
-0.3357741237,
-0.528093338,
0.3368920088,
0.3079394996,
-0.1251559854,
-0.0629391819,
-0.4188883305,
0.2606229186,
-0.4885891676,
0.3801652789,
0.5652749538,
0.0495012365,
0.5521906614,
0.0065161684,
0.6308409572,
-0.1182232127,
0.0937739909,
-0.6134855747,
-0.3583650291,
-1.2544988394,
-0.8407487273,
0.6451444626,
0.7781373858,
-0.9283887744,
0.5003109574,
0.2443162501,
-0.1332009882,
-0.5741016269,
0.3400771618,
0.505450666,
0.281683892,
0.2431706041,
-0.2646605968,
-0.3348829448,
-0.9939115644,
-0.2611915469,
-0.0833999664,
-0.1254554838,
0.1154741719,
0.2555350661,
-0.2533251643,
0.8750873208,
-0.764896512,
-0.4496844709,
-0.7329817414,
0.1042081863,
-0.2183302939,
0.4153071642,
0.1488903612,
-0.6516932845,
-0.6331143975,
0.0601436868,
-0.6714661121,
-0.3305329978,
-0.1919604093,
-0.0086467043,
0.1433541775,
0.637657702,
-0.2744610012,
0.4145003259,
0.0268295743,
-0.4878782332,
0.2776331007,
-0.291215688,
-0.0074074855,
-0.677077353,
-0.1126254946,
0.2770651281,
-0.713123858,
-0.531198442,
0.4031157494,
0.080046922,
-0.1125078946,
-0.3792164624,
0.3955763578,
-1.098654151,
0.0558662787,
-0.1095100939,
-0.0648128018,
0.1639493853,
0.0204784498,
0.3175947666,
0.4325413704,
0.0005973804,
-0.3673408031,
0.014533828,
0.4883391857,
-0.5139176846,
0.4819262624,
-0.6179257631,
0.2457819134,
-0.242209658,
0.0027823742,
-0.9271112084,
-0.6081827283,
0.5195115805,
0.1801359653,
0.0949823037,
-0.0546705984,
-0.5380718112,
0.0478795506,
-0.1168514416,
0.5476918221,
0.1566898674,
-0.4009634554,
0.5560964942,
0.4849031568,
-0.596211195,
0.0071648229,
-0.5639797449,
0.1327988505,
-0.2079437375,
-0.8204410672,
0.1719653159,
0.1156892627,
-0.4758982658,
-0.0688567087,
0.1971975863,
-0.4677880108,
0.0306040421,
0.0594421886,
0.1981663853,
-0.0192068964,
0.0456651449,
0.0847265422,
-0.2632691264,
-0.5309107304,
0.1032828838,
0.4426836967,
-0.2311681658,
-0.4013426602,
-0.4268008471,
0.7921301723,
0.2559122145,
-0.3613299131,
0.3915313184,
0.250303328,
-0.3881966174,
-0.4102318585,
-0.5329697728,
0.2496762276,
-0.4601993859,
0.1332541108,
-0.2975735068,
-0.901460886,
0.4166632891,
0.2592022121,
-0.1319048405,
0.7157967687,
0.3338955045,
-0.1832336783,
1.0169450045,
0.7612984776,
0.3210597038,
0.3782664835,
0.1953903884,
0.1810936928,
-0.5049005151,
-0.3127668202,
-0.8857321143,
-0.0335554518,
-0.1141508818,
-0.4435167909,
0.2854000032,
0.0880801529,
0.3971010447,
0.2451002896,
-0.82633394,
0.7825692892,
0.4345654845,
0.1653814614,
0.6130903959,
0.2678622603,
-0.2016233951,
-0.0809686929,
-0.5298236609,
-0.8756352663,
0.5198944807,
0.6598486304,
0.7933934331,
-0.081835255,
0.5904498696,
0.6151090264,
0.2945039868,
-1.2426639795,
0.5215336084,
-0.2585549057,
-0.6367263794,
-0.718460083,
-0.2305183411,
-0.9029642344,
0.4561897516,
0.0886699781,
-0.5675286651,
0.5257148147,
0.0214524753,
-0.681276083,
0.1169580892,
-1.2370920181,
0.866428256,
-0.1377341896,
0.0849475861,
0.3291131556,
-0.6960024834,
0.0529791676,
-0.1201226413,
0.4526858628,
0.010327409,
-0.117394492,
0.8834518194,
-0.7935174108,
0.6986215115,
0.2070665061,
-0.0098323394,
0.5129227638,
-0.0061116889,
0.224086538,
-0.1378753036,
-0.0963719934,
-0.1100844145,
0.0161164049,
-0.3521617055,
-0.326529175,
0.0729866177,
-0.5528467298,
-0.3253281116,
-0.6790886521,
-0.1467407942,
-0.1425561011,
0.400228709,
0.1781051308,
0.31037274,
-0.3210821748,
-0.0834563226,
0.4354338944,
-0.0782718435,
0.7191895247,
0.4402722716,
0.1340809613,
-0.6660020947,
0.7839149833,
-0.0865270942,
0.0693111271,
0.2267622948,
0.0201780759,
-0.4426862597,
-0.750457406,
-0.8600141406,
0.1782042384,
-0.6342995763,
-0.062855795,
-0.7791740298,
-0.0438885279,
-0.0629593581,
-0.337972194,
-0.0597382933,
-0.5409402847,
-0.467153728,
-0.2055574954,
-0.2265810966,
0.9027772546,
-0.0143353157,
0.6072412729,
-0.8249307275,
0.4484246075,
0.3822295368,
0.0936496258,
-0.2584456801,
0.007438466,
-0.2856035233,
-0.4808735847,
-0.4434267879,
-1.068633914,
0.6179689765,
0.256729871,
0.163790077,
0.3273537457,
0.0616192743,
0.5440075994,
-0.7630608678,
0.5731680393,
0.2510485053,
-1.1962018013,
0.5198337436,
-0.2146070153,
0.2721636891,
0.9699963927,
0.1538343728,
-0.5369767547,
-0.2790112495,
-0.148235634,
-1.022846818,
0.8331003189,
0.3885959089,
-0.1338655949,
-0.249485597,
0.2056546807,
0.4684821963,
-0.1057196781,
-0.803311348,
-0.0328873619,
-0.0419274047,
-0.4077908099,
0.0015186208,
-0.4086368382,
0.2210076898,
-0.1350094378,
0.3800500929,
0.0761789754,
0.1771495491,
0.5007737875,
-0.6263046265,
-0.0208283458,
0.6330002546,
0.447512567,
0.4613207579,
-0.1274093688,
0.2397630364,
-0.3097262681,
-0.7167543769,
0.6338427067,
0.3425089717,
-0.4759124517,
0.2155971527,
0.4726185799,
0.6198169589,
-0.097333774,
-0.6775826812,
0.2168657631,
-0.1399351507,
-0.1569324136,
-0.098195903,
-0.0191339571,
-0.2829554379,
0.0781060457,
0.4032119513,
0.0133333476,
0.2050064206,
-0.4587435722,
0.3157086372,
0.0236270558,
-0.4197063148,
-0.1455498934,
0.4187197983,
0.6895222664,
-0.5494403839,
0.7865657806,
-0.4000636637,
-0.58668226,
0.6706821322,
0.3235110939,
1.0608040094,
-0.1057365015,
0.4635864794,
-0.0888273641,
0.7004458308,
-0.0063370708,
-0.041193001,
-0.0392229892,
-0.5791844726,
-0.4985704422,
-0.7545083761,
-0.4720062912,
-0.0595653132,
-0.5452466607,
0.1130484566,
-0.3340239227,
-0.0406412072,
0.3683185875,
-0.287535429,
-0.7080677152,
0.5006710291,
-0.0175277684,
0.7015792727,
-0.8782971501,
0.4025356472,
0.7840442061,
-0.3921566308,
-0.5665791035,
0.3202962875,
-0.1122743413,
-0.6049544215,
0.4985610247,
0.4184024632,
0.0636014268,
0.0495587848,
-0.1987501085,
-0.43438676,
0.537925601,
0.1503804028,
-0.6560995579,
-0.4988887608,
0.2697353661,
0.4538350105,
-0.1940680891,
0.2916197777,
0.6575865149,
0.6336025596,
-0.1403927654,
-0.7848843932,
0.024602728,
-0.2354483306,
-0.2636809051,
0.2255724669,
-0.4909768403,
0.5740744472,
-0.003212651,
-0.4627766609,
0.2032840401,
0.6150230765,
-0.2203189731,
0.565076828,
1.0753241777,
0.5986042023,
0.6629344225,
-0.0257673021,
0.9838086963,
0.1810923517,
0.2395008951,
0.7147302628,
-0.2154354602,
0.6940549016,
0.2990130186,
-0.3114151657,
0.679844141,
0.6239984035,
0.021795081,
0.4762886167,
0.1317166388,
-0.4154995382,
-0.5162225962,
0.0668468103,
-0.0124945585,
0.5487420559,
0.1778074354,
-0.4389575124,
-0.3528063297,
0.2461616397,
-0.037696749,
0.1103407219,
-0.1565030515,
0.9354042411,
0.0466457754,
-0.6950333714,
0.0399947576,
0.5149092674,
0.4362565875,
-0.4086755812,
0.040966738,
-0.0760029033,
-0.0915800333,
-0.2373631597,
-0.5478873849,
0.6557790041,
0.4785731733,
-0.2982027531,
-0.3282091618,
1.0402215719,
-0.1439210176,
-0.6466726661,
-0.1896748841,
0.8327220678,
0.1271989942,
-0.162294656,
-0.5642758012,
0.1048699841,
0.2899242043,
-0.2200632691,
0.0402578562,
0.4757666886,
-0.0341521315,
0.6000504494,
0.4645597339,
-0.1033079773,
0.0678681731,
-0.0901004896,
0.5437247157,
-0.8906924129,
-0.7862628102,
-1.0871376991,
0.6318221092,
-0.1203935593,
-0.1594052911,
0.8769663572,
0.6573707461,
0.2907299995,
-0.1488318145,
0.8871119022,
-0.0726151541,
0.5366399288,
-0.5726348162,
0.8587372899,
-0.3362775445,
0.2423918098,
-0.3590858579,
-0.8800352812,
-0.5238274932,
0.711542964,
-0.4193440676,
-0.2988801301,
0.8580186963,
0.3011547625,
-0.168197155,
-0.1539360732,
0.1974775642,
-0.2904701829,
0.24565579,
0.1360153556,
0.8718118668,
-0.0199661497,
0.6318307519,
-0.2175988853,
-0.3856820166,
-0.332202971,
-0.8694889545,
-0.9691903591,
-0.3946199715,
-0.4074943066,
-0.3088221252,
0.1958450973,
0.6794655919,
0.603289485,
-0.7242022157,
-0.066548638,
-0.1953902245,
0.4653114676,
0.0998236835,
-0.206848681,
0.6125867963,
-0.3997255266,
-0.8721562624,
0.3630747497,
0.4971761703,
0.0848974735,
-0.2075936794,
0.3169623315,
-0.0321657844,
0.2623974085,
0.5856074691,
0.5452725291,
-0.3972182274,
-0.1876309216,
0.0627602413,
-0.2924352288,
0.1202361658,
0.8796772957,
-0.4500293136,
0.6623231769,
0.5125677586,
0.6778760552,
0.2712243497,
0.4719893038,
0.5152382851,
-0.4533587098,
0.015476062,
0.3012416661,
0.3290004432,
0.486654073,
-0.2321679294,
0.4024400711,
0.3223875165,
-0.4399068356,
-0.7634254694,
0.1897763908,
-1.0430747271,
-0.2636673748,
1.0634871721,
-0.1987850815,
-0.5125263333,
-0.6200885773,
-0.6509723067,
0.0768077746,
-0.1671289653,
0.6673304439,
0.8885183334,
-0.265086025,
-0.1867768168,
-0.2616238892,
0.4853802323,
0.5792801976,
-1.1759127378,
-0.2189381272,
0.8805723786,
0.2932861745,
0.0295546092,
0.7031419873,
0.0769338161,
0.0264095534,
-0.0417125747,
-0.0902024433,
-0.1377348751,
-0.3662081063,
-0.4983475208,
0.5078573227,
-0.0952859148,
-0.224585712
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11460v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11460v1 | TRACE the Evidence: Constructing Knowledge-Grounded Reasoning Chains for Retrieval-Augmented Generation | 2024-06-17T12:23:32 | 2024-06-17T12:23:32 | Jinyuan Fang, Zaiqiao Meng, Craig Macdonald | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) offers an effective approach for
addressing question answering (QA) tasks. However, the imperfections of the
retrievers in RAG models often result in the retrieval of irrelevant
information, which could introduce noises and degrade the performance,
especially when handling multi-hop questions that require multiple steps of
reasoning. To enhance the multi-hop reasoning ability of RAG models, we propose
TRACE. TRACE constructs knowledge-grounded reasoning chains, which are a series
of logically connected knowledge triples, to identify and integrate supporting
evidence from the retrieved documents for answering questions. Specifically,
TRACE employs a KG Generator to create a knowledge graph (KG) from the
retrieved documents, and then uses an Autoregressive Reasoning Chain
Constructor to build reasoning chains. Experimental results on three multi-hop
QA datasets show that TRACE achieves an average performance improvement of up
to 14.03% compared to using all the retrieved documents. Moreover, the results
indicate that using reasoning chains as context, rather than the entire
documents, is often sufficient to correctly answer questions. | [
-0.3350487351,
-0.6732981801,
0.9724636674,
-0.3514387608,
-0.1848705262,
0.4814016223,
0.5672011375,
-0.4207196832,
0.3832799792,
0.5000368953,
-0.2500114143,
-0.1540820301,
-0.4766192734,
-0.166760698,
-0.4962939322,
0.9547717571,
0.023340974,
-0.1615970135,
-0.2510224283,
-0.3059729934,
-0.6026737094,
-0.3613634109,
-0.5299244523,
-0.2007459104,
0.6105126739,
0.379159987,
0.462657243,
0.943202734,
0.2264430225,
0.1698309034,
-0.1537119746,
0.5719704032,
-0.5268540978,
0.4670614004,
-0.3718170822,
-0.3390814066,
-0.5294578671,
-0.1208365411,
0.6140127182,
0.5089866519,
0.1160510778,
0.6270585656,
-0.1547139287,
0.8271173835,
-0.9431500435,
-0.2097302973,
-0.6225879192,
-0.4530334473,
-0.0460835956,
-0.5741408467,
-0.5846655369,
-0.4986383319,
0.0308996122,
-0.8521596193,
0.168297559,
0.2897320688,
0.9271279573,
0.0906817988,
-0.8177638054,
-0.5092520714,
-0.7280796766,
0.4661772251,
-0.4784479737,
0.3058176339,
0.4310422242,
0.4444257319,
-0.1935649365,
-0.9623841643,
-0.337582469,
0.1384801865,
-0.2510757744,
0.1181416139,
0.2384686768,
-0.133831948,
0.6423919201,
0.4514492154,
-0.2975824475,
-0.7141571641,
-0.2733899951,
-0.1980151385,
0.4522177577,
0.1008209586,
0.3149846494,
-0.2448945045,
-0.199567467,
-0.0609270744,
-0.6575795412,
0.1088279709,
0.3440126479,
0.1276410222,
0.4314005673,
0.5572126508,
-0.3261623979,
1.0211051702,
0.1764440835,
-0.3158585429,
0.0061590923,
-0.3108466566,
0.1055014282,
0.0400593765,
0.2051693797,
0.1513493061,
-0.0924382284,
-0.0551150888,
0.0995782539,
-0.0712015927,
0.3177825809,
-0.8668558598,
-0.4295166731,
0.0960159451,
-0.5259869099,
-0.3107699156,
-0.0555109866,
-0.7721316218,
-0.6655952334,
-0.2089854181,
0.7185787559,
-0.5530700684,
-0.5101103187,
0.0069530508,
-0.670545876,
0.3930359483,
0.3246819675,
-0.3541378081,
0.4044287801,
0.5764223933,
0.5550777912,
0.3653935194,
-0.0342464931,
-1.0728102922,
0.5151299238,
-0.4664269388,
0.9251474142,
-0.4783253074,
-0.1034808233,
-0.2355216146,
0.0093846312,
-0.1326942295,
-0.28831321,
0.5662686229,
-0.8457794785,
0.307651937,
-0.6735110879,
-0.7834002376,
-0.5397976041,
0.5387992859,
-0.7802219987,
1.1476405859,
0.0494031534,
-1.1342256069,
0.206421569,
-0.3225451112,
-0.5108000636,
-0.0374231711,
-0.1010774523,
-0.161217317,
-0.018344773,
0.305378288,
0.0101878913,
-0.2973519862,
0.2750512958,
-0.2789868414,
-0.3844410479,
-0.0546461865,
0.0437382385,
0.9587560892,
0.1805177331,
-0.3738499284,
-0.1523317993,
-1.2264357805,
0.2860416472,
0.0221596174,
-0.3224171698,
-0.815505445,
0.4703528583,
-0.5605236292,
0.2819147706,
-0.2551294267,
-0.4096210599,
0.072448343,
-0.1278863549,
-0.1212503612,
0.7136963606,
0.4686027169,
0.1375378519,
-0.5993738174,
0.5729098916,
-0.1040896773,
-0.1787890494,
-0.531447649,
-0.739182055,
-0.9260997176,
-0.0900633931,
0.2713989913,
0.3975882232,
-0.8210359216,
0.0198990125,
-0.2905599773,
-0.3421607912,
-0.4700706303,
-0.0871239305,
0.4242655039,
1.0942310095,
0.5080777407,
0.0805868581,
-0.7918240428,
-0.4531553984,
-0.674167335,
-0.4342889488,
-0.1245031804,
0.4358994365,
0.4602788985,
0.0473402403,
1.034932375,
-0.5753247738,
0.2293451577,
0.1109426767,
0.2075968683,
0.1648333967,
0.3993589282,
0.2230259031,
-0.737423718,
-0.407171756,
-0.0288142562,
-0.74206388,
-0.0111539336,
-0.0175149571,
-0.5663613081,
-0.1787979305,
0.3449291289,
-0.3958839774,
0.3981923461,
0.2192980349,
-0.9122871757,
0.6289280653,
0.1267155111,
0.4098907411,
-1.0935305357,
0.5224426389,
-0.619887352,
-0.4106245339,
-0.5243784785,
0.1325769424,
0.0306746643,
-0.1085800752,
0.0294048265,
0.6018231511,
-0.6157495975,
-0.2219815552,
-0.2155343294,
0.2011882961,
0.6089820862,
0.1685590446,
-0.1455017775,
0.7634114623,
0.3267284632,
-0.8020420671,
0.0429804027,
0.1633344144,
0.0006240885,
0.7326869369,
-0.3681966066,
0.3827518523,
-0.2409930229,
0.2092436403,
-1.0143860579,
-0.2172727287,
0.065341197,
-0.6458333731,
0.3129485548,
-0.3497846127,
-0.2290008068,
-0.3228463233,
-0.2401861697,
0.4522721767,
0.5584435463,
-0.6976722479,
1.3139519691,
0.2395108491,
0.4073719382,
-0.6508206725,
-0.1536127925,
-0.0938898548,
-0.2584971189,
-0.6985747814,
-0.0430243723,
-0.095339641,
-0.2275590152,
0.2287499309,
-0.37463063,
-0.0308913365,
0.2417930216,
0.0856446624,
0.0398378372,
-0.2980381846,
0.3603209257,
-0.0292848907,
-0.1373794526,
0.2618412077,
-0.4306975007,
0.2203228027,
-0.0188100692,
-0.3365808427,
0.0879781693,
0.3164075017,
0.6709403992,
-0.3586893082,
0.5577346087,
0.3969058096,
-0.2523779571,
-0.2127671838,
-0.7719169259,
-0.1381207854,
-0.3856541216,
-0.1316884905,
-0.7108237147,
-0.6679089069,
0.7159712315,
-0.4841865599,
-0.0803806707,
0.6709687114,
0.0117209479,
-0.1281395108,
1.1089529991,
0.2289991081,
0.1879566014,
0.0269926097,
-0.1597329676,
0.1520656198,
-1.1047103405,
-0.2354910374,
-0.6718919873,
-0.0412458219,
-0.3284915388,
-0.4967924058,
0.3424035609,
0.6045911312,
-0.5097917318,
0.0558522455,
-0.4751464427,
0.3572068214,
0.7040292025,
0.141185075,
0.5430304408,
-0.117935963,
-0.2428944558,
0.3287644982,
-0.9023577571,
-0.3651582003,
1.179790616,
0.2117552459,
0.5233429074,
0.0498993471,
0.5530826449,
0.1184732467,
0.2298287898,
-0.5536901355,
0.4625302255,
0.2630923688,
-0.9996571541,
0.0562365241,
-0.4306545258,
-0.6085996032,
0.3408651352,
-0.1826223284,
-0.4792201221,
0.1577581167,
0.3735766411,
-0.1763738692,
0.566192627,
-0.6138924956,
0.5971984863,
-0.0858142078,
-0.4275760651,
-0.0241310932,
-0.8133596182,
0.6109709144,
0.1233364344,
0.2651636302,
0.1460392773,
0.3597552478,
0.9089212418,
-0.545593679,
0.374319464,
-0.3750464916,
0.040643692,
0.8996149302,
0.3714229465,
0.9175186753,
-0.0071698809,
0.0250751264,
-0.4009358585,
0.0873080119,
-0.3766737878,
-0.7835171223,
0.3888117373,
-0.3106430173,
-0.5558709502,
-0.4515526891,
-0.6173235178,
-0.3360370398,
0.5728946924,
-0.0260814,
0.6131183505,
0.1875007898,
0.1125616729,
0.9776646495,
-0.1246657223,
0.1124605536,
0.5225995779,
-0.3777532279,
-0.6255487204,
0.9540833831,
0.0466468893,
0.3818930089,
0.3264598548,
0.4151180983,
-0.3278778195,
-0.2221337557,
-0.6346849203,
0.2140219212,
-0.8534711003,
-0.3520184457,
-0.9222572446,
-0.1648838967,
-0.3431617022,
-0.0260202363,
-0.2089088261,
-0.5557357073,
-0.0229489468,
-0.2461036146,
0.5930517316,
0.584203124,
0.0124713331,
0.0572463647,
-0.8249331117,
0.8335266113,
0.6126249433,
0.4580264986,
0.1070073694,
-0.4830550849,
-0.21062693,
-0.0570940897,
-0.1790959984,
-1.1199350357,
-0.0862577483,
-0.0691853315,
0.447118938,
0.373272568,
0.1860009879,
1.1422512531,
-0.4760780632,
0.528514266,
-0.1157620847,
-0.8903818727,
0.7719458938,
-0.7128499746,
0.1166469976,
0.5408955812,
0.3012851179,
-0.2203691155,
-0.4344627857,
-0.8170855641,
-0.740976572,
0.5118485093,
0.1476071924,
-0.5680849552,
-0.1399148107,
0.4018788338,
-0.2149491459,
0.1479542702,
-0.505219996,
-0.3427526951,
-0.1685267985,
-0.011172683,
0.5085179806,
-0.7116450071,
-0.306797266,
-0.2116995305,
0.7771488428,
-0.2436140031,
0.1738850474,
0.3775218427,
-0.051575277,
-0.1484509706,
0.0815606788,
0.2467617542,
1.0269546509,
-0.5693019032,
0.5154099464,
-0.0742403269,
-0.4891829193,
0.3264087737,
0.0201830585,
-0.5684713721,
0.0842587724,
0.4710901082,
0.4852073193,
-0.2294598818,
-0.5288981199,
0.3267385364,
0.0791467726,
-0.1195131093,
-0.2144635767,
-0.0264923386,
0.0979467705,
0.184576422,
0.5174234509,
0.0749991313,
0.480224669,
-0.4629039466,
0.3562709093,
0.2847616374,
-0.1310114115,
-0.0870603099,
0.6888085008,
0.0220350958,
-0.1548596323,
0.613961935,
-0.2233047187,
-0.6477680802,
0.6939544082,
0.6546934843,
0.8027817607,
-0.2301983386,
0.0989496782,
0.8020370007,
0.3209136426,
-0.228339389,
0.4857995808,
-0.0935724154,
-0.4168519676,
-0.6288794875,
-0.4542905092,
-0.0956413299,
-0.1777455956,
-0.852769196,
0.0630120188,
-0.1928480268,
0.0550712943,
-0.3676730394,
-0.0571097545,
-0.3911012411,
0.4091815352,
-0.2216945291,
0.8186255693,
-0.7785567045,
0.4862285256,
0.5852245688,
-0.4438273013,
-1.2283895016,
-0.1210444495,
-0.0696548,
-0.5070454478,
0.6300100088,
0.1752143353,
-0.4029912055,
0.2047626227,
-0.3549686372,
-1.2220134735,
1.2194020748,
0.1254678667,
-0.0445694402,
0.0602903478,
-0.4180673659,
0.3426994085,
-0.2390836477,
0.5721134543,
0.3972693384,
0.3902363181,
0.3784074485,
-0.4126655459,
0.3662262857,
-0.3329538107,
-0.1865658015,
0.3680576086,
-0.3890074193,
0.7968902588,
-0.2105534822,
-0.4975410998,
-0.0983882844,
0.4961666167,
0.7664428353,
0.6452821493,
0.5952978134,
0.8934355974,
1.1059497595,
0.0720240101,
1.0609866381,
-0.3791579902,
0.0376850255,
1.493249774,
-0.1841233969,
0.5852110982,
0.5204761028,
0.0050239949,
1.1098207235,
0.313629806,
0.3837999701,
0.3412325084,
0.223534435,
-0.1828859746,
-0.3345339596,
-0.2041830719,
-0.5182009339,
0.1150658652,
0.3672757447,
-0.3236197233,
-0.1906094104,
-0.3606506288,
0.0945461094,
0.0631199181,
-0.3201792538,
0.5927055478,
-0.2738023996,
-0.8624936342,
0.5508841276,
-0.3390830159,
-0.0538115986,
-0.5895879865,
-0.5753627419,
-0.3518761098,
-0.0334869847,
-0.3243772686,
-0.4853005409,
0.2960366011,
-0.1007536575,
-0.4551794827,
-0.1369428039,
1.1304556131,
-0.1086198837,
-0.4742977023,
0.3263537288,
0.5837615132,
0.0910736471,
-0.083332248,
-0.2876721919,
-0.2684547603,
-0.13025105,
-0.3908088803,
0.0792994648,
0.7444963455,
-0.166490078,
0.7145692706,
0.8384324312,
-0.0598519146,
0.392552346,
-0.1387556046,
1.1221534014,
-0.8232560754,
-0.4959607124,
-0.508236289,
0.8266676664,
-0.3519374728,
0.0532561429,
1.1019282341,
0.8493182063,
0.4322310388,
0.1423183829,
0.5117780566,
-0.4116988182,
1.255854845,
-0.4257099032,
0.3873567283,
-0.5012752414,
0.266939491,
-0.3338572979,
-0.6185254455,
-0.0075571393,
0.4184122682,
0.1717349738,
-0.0435970686,
0.9508965015,
0.5280174613,
-0.0364292897,
-0.1329492927,
-0.0954990461,
0.1085225865,
0.5498476624,
0.4987511933,
0.9270380139,
-0.9314512014,
0.6148608923,
-0.0873617679,
-0.1516202837,
0.2399528921,
-1.0222965479,
-0.8311751485,
-0.3085999787,
-0.1876357496,
-0.8951083422,
0.0322300494,
0.0691062361,
0.5009096861,
-0.5881580114,
-0.1060054228,
-0.3829684556,
0.5019788742,
-0.4273441434,
-0.2745294571,
0.6627530456,
-0.4316781461,
-0.0824816152,
0.5489647985,
0.0776399001,
-0.245252952,
0.066463016,
-0.0845020786,
-0.8972639441,
-0.1025522053,
0.6485580802,
0.4440791905,
-0.4219411612,
-0.4590138793,
0.2353253365,
0.3616481721,
-0.1175541356,
1.0408388376,
-1.116289854,
0.9603356719,
0.8420877457,
0.9665135741,
0.7159228921,
0.5900837779,
0.5629110932,
-0.6238015294,
-0.1578259319,
0.2307345122,
0.1321974099,
0.0528273061,
-0.3629504144,
0.842901051,
0.4573255181,
-0.7077342868,
-0.9302997589,
0.2237526476,
-0.8262920976,
-0.260779649,
1.1685237885,
-0.1465521753,
-0.1343827546,
-0.4184073508,
-0.0867807418,
0.2764935493,
0.0075038434,
0.5646688342,
0.6161497831,
-0.187662974,
-0.0900307968,
-0.6887446642,
0.5252695084,
0.3516574204,
-0.831117034,
0.0140604051,
0.9109458923,
0.4650518596,
0.3726631403,
1.045314312,
-0.1351266354,
0.2457401007,
0.2851845324,
-0.1140546277,
-0.2591740489,
-0.4946956336,
-0.0192464441,
0.3701420426,
0.1307135224,
-0.2988861799
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11455v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11455v1 | Adaptive Reinforcement Learning Planning: Harnessing Large Language Models for Complex Information Extraction | 2024-06-17T12:11:01 | 2024-06-17T12:11:01 | Zepeng Ding, Ruiyang Ke, Wenhao Huang, Guochao Jiang, Yanda Li, Deqing Yang, Yanghua Xiao, Jiaqing Liang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Existing research on large language models (LLMs) shows that they can solve
information extraction tasks through multi-step planning. However, their
extraction behavior on complex sentences and tasks is unstable, emerging issues
such as false positives and missing elements. We observe that decomposing
complex extraction tasks and extracting them step by step can effectively
improve LLMs' performance, and the extraction orders of entities significantly
affect the final results of LLMs. This paper proposes a two-stage multi-step
method for LLM-based information extraction and adopts the RL framework to
execute the multi-step planning. We regard sequential extraction as a Markov
decision process, build an LLM-based extraction environment, design a decision
module to adaptively provide the optimal order for sequential entity extraction
on different sentences, and utilize the DDQN algorithm to train the decision
model. We also design the rewards and evaluation metrics suitable for the
extraction results of LLMs. We conduct extensive experiments on multiple public
datasets to demonstrate the effectiveness of our method in improving the
information extraction capabilities of LLMs. | [
-0.3360436559,
-0.9947474599,
0.6316131353,
0.4074186981,
-0.139329195,
0.2386306077,
-0.4397925436,
-0.3593798876,
-0.1738738865,
0.5743027329,
-0.5895362496,
-0.3620339334,
-0.7679358721,
0.107495755,
-0.1486984193,
0.8030699492,
-0.201289922,
0.0660538003,
0.3496298492,
0.1804760545,
-0.4098120928,
-0.0415616482,
-1.1462179422,
-0.2640306056,
0.7872621417,
0.6723448038,
0.3966952562,
0.6953520775,
0.234160915,
0.2813773751,
0.0370516479,
0.4174974859,
-0.2710449398,
0.4436559677,
-0.4939106405,
-0.2734247148,
-0.4039095342,
-0.1366981268,
0.6384329796,
0.092188552,
-0.6090249419,
0.1382946223,
-0.2704406381,
0.6548409462,
-0.54229635,
0.5460159183,
-0.6583632827,
0.0744536221,
0.1350247413,
-0.4208400548,
-0.5460183024,
-0.2361618429,
0.2532539368,
-0.5367488861,
-0.2501720786,
0.1319431663,
0.418156594,
0.0644424558,
-0.2756826282,
-0.5983723402,
-0.9977172017,
0.8368739486,
-0.6858641505,
0.3360536098,
-0.0034827392,
0.2938666046,
-0.5608415604,
-0.6703789234,
-0.6169133782,
0.0432440154,
0.2464838326,
0.019278409,
0.0232082307,
-0.0366248786,
0.5282474756,
-0.1620571613,
-0.4612566829,
0.4585033357,
-0.3200945258,
0.1789964885,
0.646238029,
0.1098043472,
0.2696424723,
-0.2842340171,
-0.5518632531,
-0.2747553289,
-0.609739244,
0.1065689623,
0.0439365432,
0.5405188799,
0.3281666338,
0.5843052268,
-0.248813957,
0.3910932541,
0.0323244743,
-0.5258790255,
0.1045556739,
-0.0761674494,
-0.3628003895,
0.2082724571,
0.784553349,
-0.2746265531,
0.3211995363,
-0.2197099328,
-0.6098700166,
-0.4606975019,
0.31049788,
-0.693831861,
-0.240200758,
0.5107973814,
-0.4048036933,
-0.2642979622,
0.0285050347,
-1.0891805887,
-0.3582142889,
-0.3072814345,
0.4409718215,
-0.4996870756,
-0.538816154,
0.0234675333,
0.0406597815,
0.2782542706,
0.6003616452,
-0.7914471626,
0.284119904,
0.6337291598,
0.6228209734,
-0.6061908603,
-0.2507325411,
-1.0434422493,
0.2935914993,
-0.1832547486,
0.7816634774,
-0.540804863,
-0.0730832964,
0.1488003135,
0.0137754753,
-0.1845021695,
-0.7250094414,
0.4634285569,
-1.0876215696,
0.1018275917,
-0.0090804836,
-0.3425629437,
-0.3235453963,
0.3873870671,
-0.9144698977,
0.9617493749,
-0.2361205071,
-0.4094135165,
0.2556989193,
-0.7783971429,
-0.4829989076,
-0.0485354811,
-0.2363278568,
-0.4877732694,
-0.2514531314,
0.4641627073,
0.6412937641,
-0.151884228,
0.4332784712,
-0.0908036157,
0.0524589494,
0.0985404477,
-0.2505968809,
0.7317764163,
0.2936718464,
-0.382802248,
0.4185075462,
-0.9472298622,
0.0551721714,
0.3065969944,
-1.1692988873,
-0.0177008677,
0.4506054223,
-0.1212676764,
0.710975945,
0.0879477635,
-0.2737877667,
0.5009760261,
-0.3383823037,
0.3101197481,
0.8460540771,
0.3150106072,
0.5503123403,
-0.059153568,
0.6681879759,
0.2453365773,
-0.07381998,
0.0109374877,
-0.0450635962,
-0.7803516388,
-0.3276661336,
0.3676686883,
0.8231207728,
-1.0945034027,
0.3457561433,
-0.3098069429,
-0.1818990111,
-0.2215071768,
0.1464658082,
0.3244144022,
0.2070289254,
0.4417939782,
-0.1699314564,
-0.5622130632,
-0.5283725262,
-0.3092783689,
-0.230243355,
0.1783400625,
-0.0937037617,
0.4310721457,
0.1223545,
0.6972860098,
-0.4658918977,
-0.1098838672,
-0.5359843969,
0.531242609,
0.1772519499,
0.2971010208,
-0.1704454869,
-1.0664368868,
-0.153132543,
-0.0482291766,
-0.5502269864,
0.3179779649,
-0.3757140934,
-0.0288398117,
0.152498886,
0.4412890077,
-0.6983324289,
0.1193720922,
0.2781858444,
0.0899057537,
0.6476778984,
-0.2053569555,
-0.1685453206,
-0.9057701826,
-0.0834593549,
0.2219029963,
-0.4938221574,
-0.5243943334,
0.0375435017,
0.2269603014,
0.1980273277,
-0.4737919569,
0.3646458685,
-0.6652683616,
-0.5341441035,
-0.4308791757,
0.3932397664,
-0.1560109556,
0.7693469524,
0.2801945806,
0.5508592129,
0.1910749376,
-0.8717576861,
0.5604583621,
0.1314584762,
-0.5671510696,
-0.0041307458,
-0.1350676417,
0.0612414367,
-0.2422981858,
0.2313157469,
-0.6806241274,
0.0768685639,
0.6070880294,
-0.0920005813,
0.6030017734,
-0.0282120202,
-0.4738600254,
-0.1719778031,
-0.1044459119,
-0.0847260207,
0.1026810557,
-0.6008799076,
0.8742749095,
0.4641477764,
-0.8198732734,
-0.6788470745,
-0.1734799147,
-0.0119148772,
-0.3078816831,
-0.1555080563,
0.1972782463,
-0.005985003,
-0.3090984225,
-0.0503045097,
-0.11998716,
-0.0956669077,
0.2038824111,
0.0247900784,
0.2444436699,
-0.1357828379,
0.1368623376,
-0.1551814079,
-0.0763359442,
0.237198621,
-0.3867403269,
0.5060586333,
0.4946006238,
-0.0822657794,
-0.2455821931,
0.169165507,
0.3706724942,
-0.3225043416,
0.4553804398,
0.6060253978,
-0.4520122707,
-0.3414913118,
-0.4217667282,
0.074246347,
-0.385366261,
0.7015216351,
-0.3587423563,
-0.4452724755,
0.050969962,
-0.6614899635,
0.6172608733,
0.3603274822,
0.6057674885,
0.0780718848,
1.1395308971,
0.7238880396,
-0.0991415307,
0.8310889602,
-0.1785482466,
0.0506480522,
-0.8362293243,
-0.5328484178,
-0.4777717888,
-0.2192836553,
-0.2423480153,
-0.3570917547,
0.0690891296,
0.3035574257,
-0.1232798323,
0.0681234822,
0.0290657636,
0.160973087,
0.365858227,
0.1642402261,
0.4582546055,
0.1193389595,
-0.070798479,
0.2196449637,
-0.5705013275,
-0.4819136262,
0.8483874202,
0.4424622953,
0.5106646419,
0.2966909707,
0.5421227813,
0.1942621022,
0.1325652897,
-0.8826144338,
0.3655216098,
0.0921587348,
-0.2726383805,
-0.7154576182,
-0.4543859959,
-0.8687598705,
0.5361620784,
-0.4693509638,
-0.6924775243,
0.2552090287,
-0.2924858034,
-0.3815346062,
0.1728415489,
-0.3300021589,
0.4009295106,
-0.4763373435,
-0.1358613819,
-0.3267800212,
-0.5751855373,
0.4309443235,
-0.3560620546,
0.5670593381,
-0.1764532179,
-0.1768297404,
1.0250257254,
0.0287076961,
0.4747101963,
-0.3521115482,
-0.1804877669,
0.0271856971,
0.2014368325,
1.1302883625,
-0.0081792604,
-0.206370607,
-0.3458593786,
-0.1971979439,
-0.2868065834,
-0.7254527211,
0.3543435335,
-0.5224100947,
-0.4740699828,
-0.429859966,
-0.4817082882,
-0.2563895881,
0.3688447177,
-0.3955616653,
0.2422839403,
-0.0844461843,
-0.2507299185,
0.7146453857,
-0.3958542943,
0.826779604,
0.6874016523,
-0.3668626845,
-0.5633628964,
0.8638347983,
-0.1218674183,
0.1953557283,
0.5742063522,
0.1656131595,
-0.3164551258,
-0.9305006862,
-0.4671069384,
0.0196879338,
-0.7897804379,
-0.1565437019,
-0.7165747285,
-0.2954272926,
-0.4099049568,
0.6148423553,
-0.1912617981,
-0.4088012874,
-0.1122241393,
-0.1623366475,
0.0094567435,
0.8964124322,
-0.0103399921,
0.1945448071,
-0.8309851885,
0.5464712381,
0.2603021264,
-0.187874496,
0.1086999178,
-0.3241774142,
-0.2212929726,
-0.2484030426,
-0.277761519,
-0.6634726524,
0.5876815915,
0.1471233219,
0.6611686945,
0.3725011349,
-0.056351155,
0.6763982773,
-0.5959071517,
0.4677900076,
0.0775101781,
-0.338186413,
0.4759503007,
-0.1026329026,
0.0174294598,
0.2364403456,
0.5104613304,
-0.3387905061,
-0.1236864105,
-0.5596715808,
-0.9545718431,
1.0119658709,
-0.0894930661,
-0.4601964355,
0.1851897985,
0.5496681333,
0.0585558452,
0.187286377,
-0.9201380014,
-0.1449799389,
0.4171201289,
-0.1121663675,
-0.109968394,
-0.46582219,
0.0390754789,
0.0815220401,
0.8570179343,
0.0247464273,
-0.0819320157,
0.0674754232,
-0.4021492302,
-0.1712127328,
0.4265189469,
0.5270674825,
0.8528837562,
0.0253506768,
0.1042556465,
0.1318965107,
-0.258470118,
0.0446590446,
0.1036413983,
-0.0030478269,
-0.4583124518,
0.3726458549,
0.5644451976,
0.4201571345,
-0.8211482167,
0.3578044176,
-0.3000297248,
-0.0108262636,
-0.4571763277,
0.1766964346,
0.009609879,
0.8083434701,
0.3492662907,
-0.1526888013,
-0.0123339472,
-0.6174128652,
0.4634441137,
0.1256791353,
-0.1921540499,
-0.0332837477,
0.1421884,
-0.0541154556,
-0.4318577349,
0.73839432,
-0.1314236224,
-0.4945594668,
0.4043797553,
0.7073894143,
0.5943801999,
-0.249512136,
0.3504009545,
0.4607375264,
0.1199760735,
-0.3794063032,
0.4650968313,
0.1144585535,
-0.7836470604,
-0.6539077163,
-0.7976877689,
-0.131561175,
0.1649623811,
-0.5510140061,
0.3798046708,
-0.600903213,
0.3752212524,
-0.0116460864,
0.2572287619,
-0.4895321429,
0.3427332938,
-0.0142560117,
0.8528608084,
-0.4928745627,
1.0990937948,
0.3774871826,
-0.4505455196,
-1.0423096418,
-0.0421271846,
0.0423193909,
-0.9681712389,
0.8187639117,
-0.1707053185,
0.1071175933,
0.1419140399,
-0.3313477933,
-0.9784867167,
1.2831501961,
0.0323842503,
-0.8513253927,
-0.3727921844,
-0.3207932711,
0.0790878981,
-0.5574944615,
0.0533967055,
0.665492177,
0.5576431155,
0.3484787643,
-0.3896768391,
0.1814558506,
0.2269023955,
-0.0910510197,
0.2890802324,
-0.1455993056,
0.8774493337,
-0.2123995721,
-0.4476045668,
0.0096530076,
0.7064717412,
0.3373375833,
-0.0750537589,
0.7921470404,
0.3162095845,
0.9047451019,
0.36786744,
0.6582132578,
0.1241559759,
0.1804653853,
1.378806591,
-0.2360580713,
1.2608370781,
0.3724249303,
-0.0168625265,
0.5601192117,
0.7968354821,
0.1205879897,
0.6649661064,
0.1742137074,
-0.1962806284,
-0.2249160856,
0.2093075514,
0.2087835073,
0.4028656185,
0.490601629,
-0.3174225986,
-0.345091939,
-0.0432759374,
0.0935488418,
-0.2424610406,
-0.3214802742,
1.1412369013,
0.0117252264,
-0.8051172495,
0.0769735873,
0.3900035322,
0.288830936,
-0.3890275657,
-0.3195987344,
0.2037672997,
0.0797116831,
-0.2105524838,
-0.6426532269,
-0.0560543425,
-0.0218425039,
-0.1615869254,
-0.3159568012,
0.8378509283,
-0.5768325925,
-0.226290226,
0.5072963834,
0.5132954121,
0.2807786167,
-0.1296215802,
-1.0174049139,
0.0531158783,
0.0307370704,
-0.5535042286,
0.4581284225,
0.5343368053,
0.086743556,
0.6781365871,
0.7335348129,
0.5876369476,
0.2079970837,
-0.0766878352,
0.8043218255,
-0.8846510649,
-0.2925663292,
-0.9525706172,
0.5145874619,
-0.1322850734,
0.1433778554,
0.2339146584,
0.5109378099,
0.7467434406,
0.4001271725,
0.8184851408,
-0.0449166149,
0.4639382064,
-1.0482355356,
0.0593570471,
-0.415851444,
0.4584338665,
-0.1201794446,
-1.1582164764,
-0.1020055264,
0.4618444741,
-0.2263016999,
-0.2450686395,
0.7194512486,
0.608541429,
0.1070184037,
-0.0592381991,
0.1140660867,
0.3229222,
0.7823442817,
0.5098905563,
0.7943370938,
-0.1798447222,
0.6632653475,
-0.060914468,
-0.2798308134,
-0.1172274351,
-0.9093677998,
-0.4489240646,
-0.4749558866,
-0.1912629008,
-0.3517825902,
0.0013594261,
1.1455477476,
0.4776516557,
-0.6984252334,
-0.2095906138,
-0.0077834334,
0.4339292347,
-0.2202878743,
-0.2391272336,
0.3428252041,
-0.5128393769,
-0.6620454788,
0.7603354454,
0.403752625,
-0.2534883022,
-0.2765210271,
-0.1431140155,
-0.744443059,
-0.2268727273,
0.6225364208,
0.4763126671,
-0.7206494212,
-0.4992617071,
-0.4673682749,
-0.1417429,
0.258405149,
0.8678803444,
-0.5965540409,
0.3654288352,
0.4023224413,
0.7569621205,
0.6801126599,
0.1275224984,
0.648352921,
-0.6115145087,
-0.0988952145,
0.1037408561,
0.1876738966,
-0.0580619499,
-0.2592674196,
0.3472588956,
-0.1280316263,
-0.5601519942,
-0.4763479531,
0.3312605619,
-0.9050844908,
-0.5504332781,
1.3701196909,
-0.2672576308,
-0.3736602962,
-0.2049167305,
-0.1999725401,
0.4789676964,
-0.4853881299,
0.7179192305,
0.642082274,
-0.3243601918,
-0.3635780215,
-0.7163814306,
0.3361445367,
-0.0393793508,
-0.9223076105,
0.1896479428,
0.4627297521,
0.5088777542,
0.093049556,
0.6496147513,
-0.2320313603,
-0.0384287015,
-0.4682452977,
0.0440512002,
0.1271273494,
-0.7213612199,
-0.5988449454,
0.3627966344,
0.3999355435,
-0.0597040057
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11431v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11431v1 | Super(ficial)-alignment: Strong Models May Deceive Weak Models in Weak-to-Strong Generalization | 2024-06-17T11:36:39 | 2024-06-17T11:36:39 | Wenkai Yang, Shiqi Shen, Guangyao Shen, Zhi Gong, Yankai Lin | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Superalignment, where humans are weak supervisors of superhuman models, has
become an important and widely discussed issue in the current era of rapid
development of Large Language Models (LLMs). The recent work preliminarily
studies this problem by using weak models to supervise strong models. It
discovers that weakly supervised strong students can consistently outperform
weak teachers towards the alignment target, leading to a weak-to-strong
generalization phenomenon. However, we are concerned that behind such a
promising phenomenon, whether there exists an issue of weak-to-strong
deception, where strong models may deceive weak models by exhibiting
well-aligned in areas known to weak models but producing misaligned behaviors
in cases weak models do not know. We then take an initial step towards
exploring this security issue in a specific but realistic multi-objective
alignment case, where there may be some alignment targets conflicting with each
other (e.g., helpfulness v.s. harmlessness). Such a conflict is likely to cause
strong models to deceive weak models in one alignment dimension to gain high
reward in other alignment dimension. Our experiments on both the reward
modeling task and the preference optimization scenario indicate: (1) the
weak-to-strong deception exists; (2) the deception phenomenon may intensify as
the capability gap between weak and strong models increases. We also discuss
potential solutions and find bootstrapping with an intermediate model can
mitigate the deception to some extent. Our work highlights the urgent need to
pay more attention to the true reliability of superalignment. | [
-0.1685256511,
-0.5567597747,
0.5626088381,
-0.2095549554,
-0.0681880414,
0.0427406207,
0.08939749,
-0.5875198841,
0.0973967314,
0.3672705889,
-0.6127628684,
-0.0667272657,
-0.7315508723,
-0.2491014749,
-0.4830227792,
1.1786948442,
0.0830885544,
0.3213231862,
-0.3072544038,
-0.2345556021,
-0.6640498042,
-0.59650141,
-0.238416031,
-0.5852412581,
0.3502679169,
0.3935350478,
1.3188031912,
0.8243826032,
0.7992892861,
0.3286546767,
-0.1118493974,
-0.0147917159,
-0.5768967867,
0.3489233851,
-0.5677567124,
-0.6801080704,
-0.4943959713,
0.0482754447,
0.5316190124,
0.6589313745,
-0.2852730453,
-0.0495944843,
0.0810695365,
0.6388269663,
-0.6185299158,
-0.3624103963,
-0.5305309296,
-0.3860763609,
-0.3065085709,
0.3940134346,
-0.1220476776,
-0.0581488684,
0.1558542252,
-0.541300118,
0.3470797241,
0.1298162639,
1.4018864632,
0.3861787915,
-0.4997193217,
0.0491594449,
-0.8806125522,
0.909193635,
-0.4606734514,
0.391133666,
0.2896409035,
0.3239949942,
-0.1704999357,
-0.3439632058,
-0.4452704191,
-0.1025949419,
0.0042047841,
0.0853677988,
0.0147116091,
0.035703592,
0.1537968814,
0.3712013066,
-0.5090932846,
0.4206563532,
-0.2394600064,
-0.2796807885,
0.7084203362,
0.3022782207,
0.3397912979,
0.2056608647,
-0.6672417521,
-0.252509594,
-0.8444391489,
-0.0638580397,
0.5667265058,
0.4851594567,
-0.2990422845,
0.5028215647,
0.1166079342,
0.5689091086,
0.4266250432,
-0.189495936,
-0.2105413079,
-0.5996001363,
-0.1179612502,
0.1368158162,
0.6149693727,
0.5620925426,
0.3000710905,
-0.0927340165,
-0.2996234894,
0.4764115214,
0.3333351612,
-0.4562769532,
0.1218738332,
0.1982381791,
-0.4713376164,
-0.4208835363,
0.2663220465,
-0.3443220854,
-0.56293118,
-0.5294112563,
0.350138694,
-0.2833620608,
-0.3913209736,
0.1286278367,
0.195941776,
0.4091491699,
0.0856229961,
-1.2328721285,
0.3230504394,
1.0034247637,
0.5297147632,
0.1191855073,
-0.5086893439,
-0.1404222846,
0.4490949512,
-0.3639477491,
0.5346637964,
-0.6021898389,
-0.1717261672,
-0.1700401604,
0.0094013568,
-0.2399417162,
-0.418745786,
0.574349463,
-0.3539661765,
0.1793954074,
-0.3069651723,
-0.5560986996,
0.0855385959,
0.2356091738,
-0.4714938104,
0.6480625868,
0.0911990777,
-0.6219528317,
0.3272190094,
-0.0199959688,
-0.1400297582,
-0.2551563084,
-0.303332895,
-0.6606140733,
0.2796050906,
0.0465577394,
0.473773092,
-0.4465928078,
0.6894046068,
-0.439555645,
-0.5969819427,
0.4456342161,
-0.3136853874,
0.6979733706,
0.0398589522,
-0.4522271752,
0.0428687073,
-0.1726699024,
-0.3295150101,
0.1995910704,
0.1252076626,
-0.5275846124,
-0.0341999754,
-0.2967568636,
0.1084093824,
0.4522057176,
-0.4199334383,
0.5882906318,
-0.4543450773,
0.1396775991,
1.0693360567,
-0.2698749602,
0.6214354634,
-0.3922719657,
0.4943908751,
-0.0001131052,
0.3983612061,
0.2382932305,
-0.2415440828,
-0.4407567382,
0.0355580747,
0.7592226267,
0.5320068002,
-0.3432863653,
0.2227476239,
-0.1642652899,
-0.3889417052,
-0.6876289845,
0.3292616308,
0.9122080803,
0.4037898481,
0.2847329974,
-0.3435463607,
-0.2760068774,
-1.2293310165,
-0.3170124888,
-0.3614948988,
0.174751997,
-0.0726449117,
0.4185765088,
-0.316054374,
0.6627876163,
-0.3845571876,
-0.4325914085,
-0.1895047873,
-0.0701820999,
0.0959537998,
0.8302730322,
0.620059073,
-1.2072085142,
-0.1406765282,
-0.1314749718,
-0.8037028313,
0.0962986872,
-0.2685695589,
-0.3076609671,
0.2340415865,
0.6350982785,
-0.7816205025,
0.1776777357,
0.5192359686,
-0.3839429319,
0.7663254738,
-0.0214701686,
-0.1993391216,
-1.0931754112,
-0.1065360829,
0.2033363283,
0.053069856,
-0.7105964422,
0.4462057948,
0.0819704682,
0.0828087926,
-0.3196352124,
0.2369439453,
-0.3985835612,
0.1395240426,
-0.1995939314,
-0.0944490954,
-0.1569364667,
0.1706404388,
-0.0390792638,
0.496522516,
0.8112662435,
-0.4411987066,
0.2082627565,
0.1940091699,
-0.0073756529,
1.071764946,
-0.6324766278,
0.0444257781,
-0.1278567612,
0.2745630741,
-1.0492782593,
-0.6181721687,
0.2441866249,
-0.3225637972,
0.7576454282,
-0.2829743624,
-0.2911434472,
-0.0932334065,
-0.2298256308,
0.5279718041,
0.0887408927,
-0.4074417949,
0.4232636392,
0.3364605308,
-0.0982615277,
-0.8700156212,
-0.653730154,
0.0187652577,
-0.5321324468,
-0.751542747,
0.5903211236,
0.1809546649,
-0.2140086889,
-0.1571662128,
-0.5423737168,
0.2528375387,
0.2586222291,
0.327377677,
0.5986250639,
-0.2331648469,
0.0863192379,
-0.1117255092,
-0.4496119618,
-0.0546589009,
-0.1778891683,
0.3213102221,
-0.3018706143,
-0.6123178601,
-0.5856746435,
0.3150708973,
0.6646815538,
0.0336176492,
0.9393678308,
0.5021263957,
-0.5145854354,
0.3835857809,
-0.6479555368,
-0.2691563964,
-0.514138937,
0.0832368806,
-0.2507966757,
-0.837033987,
0.5072168708,
0.0097017819,
-0.0250565149,
0.3411448598,
0.1755603999,
-0.2157041281,
1.7213170528,
0.9295002222,
-0.2690324485,
0.3752394617,
-0.1970040351,
0.2766553462,
-0.8162108064,
-0.3120796382,
-0.5274293423,
-0.6965811849,
-0.6751641035,
0.2317286879,
0.0719973519,
0.5149052739,
-0.3465058208,
0.6159902811,
-0.5491288304,
0.6676031351,
0.450101167,
-0.0424071625,
-0.0831144154,
-0.1869837642,
-0.1654065251,
-0.1915520132,
-0.581022501,
-0.5554734468,
1.0167154074,
0.4261417091,
1.1132377386,
0.4608812928,
0.7793588042,
-0.091908507,
0.3028711379,
-0.500585258,
0.6714769006,
-0.2218710035,
-0.7451312542,
-0.214691177,
-0.3398729861,
-0.8445503116,
0.1892728955,
-0.3383477926,
-0.9453294277,
0.511493504,
0.2763540447,
-0.475145936,
0.1308967471,
-0.8474787474,
1.0416779518,
-0.6106231809,
-0.7227700949,
0.0355509669,
-1.1038869619,
0.5917442441,
0.0826078281,
0.0563161261,
-0.0196238402,
0.1308212131,
0.56204772,
-0.4151520431,
0.9817413092,
-0.2757873833,
-0.3218789697,
-0.0867402181,
0.2638323307,
0.5254250765,
-0.0295809526,
0.1030374616,
0.0111990198,
-0.035217341,
-0.621135354,
-0.532360971,
0.6866579652,
-0.7525557876,
-1.0064126253,
-0.5007812977,
-0.6607977152,
-0.3134744763,
0.161047861,
0.3295491934,
0.3023833036,
-0.0775591955,
0.1192959473,
0.7578776479,
0.2872774303,
0.0678478256,
0.3381084204,
0.0131724281,
-0.1956713945,
1.2145121098,
0.169736132,
0.5503564477,
0.1680294126,
0.2842316926,
-0.311639607,
-0.6476834416,
-0.3478349745,
0.48786515,
-0.2374223024,
-0.4638397098,
0.1501454711,
-0.0269539487,
-0.6285768151,
-0.5222557783,
-0.5451132059,
-0.5351356268,
-0.2134743333,
-0.167119056,
-0.3331894875,
0.6225616932,
-0.1376980841,
0.5477055907,
-0.6086137295,
0.2707757354,
0.3470627964,
0.1606285125,
-0.2044530958,
-0.5657210946,
-0.3199971914,
0.2382304966,
-0.6157328486,
-0.6130629778,
0.0175113678,
-0.053318575,
0.5115922093,
1.0046571493,
0.0220007282,
0.806738615,
0.0684066042,
0.7295252085,
0.5038397908,
-0.7679208517,
0.3498991728,
-0.4733790755,
0.2213597149,
0.6683402061,
0.5251841545,
-0.279671371,
-0.6290120482,
-0.9906184077,
-0.8926955462,
0.7110024691,
0.0328166708,
0.1591710448,
0.2486827075,
0.482952863,
0.0117820874,
0.1270409822,
-0.7775361538,
-0.2235432267,
-0.0513306931,
-0.2925177813,
0.0435840376,
-0.3066129982,
-0.496876508,
0.1293290257,
0.7581176162,
-0.1746440679,
0.1757886559,
0.0311628468,
-0.0580466427,
-0.3601337969,
0.2351587266,
0.8787917495,
0.6406957507,
-0.1901857853,
0.347750932,
-0.0680138245,
-0.358330667,
0.4298839569,
0.206185773,
-0.0848301128,
-0.5866363645,
0.4968008399,
0.4472736418,
0.2360819578,
-0.2057291865,
0.7399610281,
0.0996269062,
-0.3364834785,
0.1490865946,
0.2376142591,
0.159819752,
0.4302693903,
0.3003107905,
0.3188356161,
-0.2185026258,
-0.5703324676,
-0.0367769301,
0.7953496575,
-0.588898778,
-0.5310499072,
0.9239530563,
-0.0148642492,
-0.2944340408,
0.6346117258,
-0.0278981309,
-0.7186518312,
0.7037373781,
0.729837954,
0.6150445938,
-0.7002658248,
0.1694162786,
-0.08302854,
0.3863421977,
-0.5588601828,
-0.0364365652,
0.1267269254,
-0.9566802382,
-0.3230879605,
-0.3123722374,
-0.5365440845,
0.1740924269,
-0.8108431101,
0.0728342384,
-0.2914172411,
-0.3716526926,
-0.10596513,
-0.1884932965,
-0.2370166928,
0.1765544564,
0.2547338307,
0.5321558714,
-1.1122756004,
0.5587645769,
0.7036979198,
-0.381505549,
-0.8684529066,
0.2273898721,
0.2843487561,
-0.7402002215,
0.4356740415,
0.3410824239,
-0.2052381039,
-0.3002823889,
-0.9612662196,
-0.9390677214,
1.0277358294,
0.8746352196,
-0.5274162889,
-0.3072868586,
0.2531386316,
0.5438241959,
-0.3792204261,
-0.1221975163,
0.5924355984,
0.4255821705,
-0.1158131361,
-0.9279212356,
0.2277577221,
0.0462044403,
-0.0389921442,
0.4025913179,
-1.175157547,
0.6879248023,
-0.3000499904,
-0.254676491,
0.2066384405,
0.5483908653,
0.366501689,
0.3795748651,
0.5230895877,
0.8377994299,
0.6281623244,
-0.1679442972,
0.8262388706,
-0.1923763901,
0.2491206974,
0.9524332881,
-0.492187798,
0.4129112661,
0.6562414169,
-0.0176818017,
0.5124103427,
0.5929368138,
0.0959181786,
0.418299973,
0.0372141227,
-0.016575072,
-0.6053540707,
-0.4118494391,
-0.4857578874,
0.452684015,
0.4272989631,
-0.1753231138,
-0.003072602,
-0.2695757151,
-0.1418718547,
0.0386317708,
-0.2914746702,
0.5322114825,
0.1787450612,
-0.7579532266,
0.4416316152,
-0.0328680985,
0.4965483546,
-0.69370085,
0.1217321232,
-0.2060682029,
0.3290401995,
-0.3612599373,
-0.5615493059,
0.1237949207,
-0.4250771105,
-0.075023748,
-0.4464036226,
0.930839479,
-0.3339149058,
-0.2822188139,
0.1614400893,
0.3761302531,
-0.0644041821,
0.2503220141,
-0.883841455,
0.0299533382,
-0.2189349085,
-0.2461236417,
0.7295299172,
0.1416272372,
-0.3458188176,
0.5772843957,
0.6811670661,
-0.0021731192,
-0.3939218819,
0.1478369236,
0.777800262,
-0.4847235978,
-0.4636155367,
-1.0370163918,
0.435164243,
-0.0153723601,
-0.2606439888,
0.7562298775,
0.4389616847,
0.9109249115,
0.2640056312,
0.2991428375,
0.1737781018,
0.1636591405,
-0.5544351339,
0.378991276,
-0.5823698044,
0.3120619953,
-0.4828535914,
-1.0708417892,
-0.3401291072,
0.5373277068,
-0.3706781566,
-0.0856977105,
0.4877664149,
1.0235613585,
-0.3380484879,
-0.021488348,
0.1857205629,
0.0411835052,
0.0031130926,
0.5447745919,
1.0664167404,
-0.3861510158,
0.6133466363,
-0.1386503577,
-0.0768455938,
-0.3849928975,
-0.7213783264,
-0.4393745959,
-0.4441141188,
-0.4190967977,
-0.3607378304,
0.0659410954,
0.5404945612,
0.7553111911,
-0.7099099159,
-0.3447764516,
-0.1794294566,
0.4639023542,
-0.5676617026,
-0.2088362277,
0.2830979526,
0.0348320939,
-0.5878841877,
0.3471621573,
0.0921301544,
0.518199265,
-0.4268000722,
-0.163735345,
-0.2672283351,
0.0729511231,
-0.1124435812,
0.457226485,
-0.5229242444,
-0.4330049157,
-0.0444026701,
-0.3294061124,
-0.2276078761,
0.6922874451,
-0.42813012,
0.1679666936,
0.1327013522,
0.5576229692,
0.113876842,
0.5278192759,
0.8202471137,
-0.763630271,
-0.1187007204,
0.0171125904,
0.4163634479,
0.3460540473,
-0.5230416656,
0.5121524334,
0.2940255404,
-0.7014076114,
-1.2785128355,
0.5672596693,
-0.6860177517,
-0.2395806611,
0.8082627058,
0.0545623973,
-0.108994849,
-0.0243504085,
-0.1967308521,
0.2095324844,
-0.120918408,
0.9545187354,
0.9345841408,
-0.4320586324,
0.2299613804,
-0.2295672297,
0.2725198567,
1.0167642832,
-0.2968444824,
0.1320558935,
0.3513694406,
0.061511714,
0.5631629229,
0.1634305865,
0.0789917186,
0.3989757597,
-0.0590335056,
-0.336897403,
-0.0524096861,
-0.5315513611,
-0.5501427054,
0.2111493349,
0.1272782385,
0.0054590083
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11430v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11430v1 | A Simple and Effective $L_2$ Norm-Based Strategy for KV Cache Compression | 2024-06-17T11:35:16 | 2024-06-17T11:35:16 | Alessio Devoto, Yu Zhao, Simone Scardapane, Pasquale Minervini | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The deployment of large language models (LLMs) is often hindered by the
extensive memory requirements of the Key-Value (KV) cache, especially as
context lengths increase. Existing approaches to reduce the KV cache size
involve either fine-tuning the model to learn a compression strategy or
leveraging attention scores to reduce the sequence length. We analyse the
attention distributions in decoder-only Transformers-based models and observe
that attention allocation patterns stay consistent across most layers.
Surprisingly, we find a clear correlation between the $L_2$ and the attention
scores over cached KV pairs, where a low $L_2$ of a key embedding usually leads
to a high attention score during decoding. This finding indicates that the
influence of a KV pair is potentially determined by the key embedding itself
before being queried. Based on this observation, we compress the KV cache based
on the $L_2$ of key embeddings. Our experimental results show that this simple
strategy can reduce the KV cache size by 50% on language modelling and
needle-in-a-haystack tasks and 90% on passkey retrieval tasks without losing
accuracy. | [
-0.2999854088,
-0.33488065,
0.4761122167,
0.2925587893,
-0.5643543005,
-0.2589292526,
-0.5191634893,
-0.2969220877,
0.0478479229,
0.3468830884,
-0.3339496851,
-0.4186713398,
-0.5902537704,
-0.2494220138,
-0.1812486649,
0.4336492419,
0.2259036303,
-0.1145666391,
-0.3285272121,
-0.0032524117,
-0.6396003366,
-0.310765028,
-0.4977257252,
-0.0042762272,
0.4901737571,
0.5583438873,
0.5350134969,
0.9020028114,
0.5749232769,
0.0392441303,
-0.3372769654,
0.2023195773,
-0.8900691867,
0.5330871344,
0.2712640464,
-0.8135713339,
-0.2392415404,
-0.0758080781,
0.6776729226,
0.1482686102,
-0.0662464723,
0.2555008233,
-0.0225693583,
0.8657305241,
-1.0335429907,
0.2925059199,
-0.75235641,
0.1525458246,
-0.0389994755,
-0.2897806168,
-0.8535989523,
0.0390538014,
-0.1484768689,
-0.3079586029,
0.086457327,
-0.0810146779,
0.8120727539,
0.6141946912,
-0.2101006508,
0.1483843029,
-0.5969356298,
0.9008889198,
-0.568197906,
0.597769022,
0.5458182096,
0.0934443697,
0.1819829941,
-0.5040472746,
-0.3764461279,
0.2388904393,
-0.0190403052,
0.1141487658,
0.0061089764,
0.0500830375,
0.207919836,
0.1886267811,
-0.3426330686,
0.2626028359,
-0.4013842344,
-0.1485936791,
0.415066421,
0.1121638566,
-0.0524747893,
-0.1238284707,
-0.2842564285,
-0.4400633574,
-1.0697162151,
0.178610757,
0.2468284667,
0.3210445046,
0.0107507547,
0.4493241608,
-0.0325919278,
0.4391553104,
0.2482916415,
-0.1446579695,
-0.0519100092,
-0.1987011135,
-0.2681179643,
0.0104515282,
0.4653481841,
0.6567854285,
0.3614801466,
-0.3417245746,
-0.1899270713,
0.1228379235,
0.5437480211,
-0.8854353428,
-0.2315848619,
0.0661877096,
-0.5406674147,
-0.4227508903,
-0.2258570194,
-0.785474658,
-0.0072273137,
-0.043115899,
0.4041664302,
0.0245089717,
0.0819278061,
0.1935255229,
-0.0315973535,
0.5407249331,
0.2258313894,
-1.0171639919,
0.4106931984,
0.5346717834,
0.9806890488,
-0.2638548613,
0.312099576,
-0.5460605621,
0.1088845134,
-0.2218491584,
0.5781084299,
-0.5050749779,
-0.5106868148,
0.1346901208,
-0.1312009394,
0.2329296172,
-0.5321213007,
0.5556046963,
-0.9116117358,
-0.42879498,
-0.5655728579,
-0.4471514821,
0.0253118463,
0.201403752,
-0.9561419487,
1.2191518545,
0.290836513,
-0.4662002921,
0.0392526612,
-0.1639227271,
-0.4250911176,
-0.2258894444,
-0.1244530752,
-0.5103598833,
0.3927066922,
0.4289802015,
0.6354215145,
-0.474182725,
-0.2449072897,
-0.1194643825,
-0.4890390038,
-0.0263648294,
-0.3021252751,
0.3770559132,
0.2622228265,
-0.223812446,
-0.4276704788,
-0.2765854597,
0.2155023515,
0.2584999204,
-0.5711808205,
-0.287977159,
-0.0717018098,
0.1812003255,
0.2816180289,
0.136167109,
-0.2729391456,
0.5902945995,
-0.5339212418,
0.3685279787,
0.7622039914,
0.0273237713,
0.6846945286,
-0.2420650125,
0.3240964711,
0.1352526844,
0.2017272115,
-0.1089213341,
-0.3425937295,
-1.0919547081,
-0.2275853157,
0.2601613402,
0.4048649669,
-0.1114346087,
0.331405431,
-0.6829652786,
-0.2969713211,
-0.9106406569,
0.3105516434,
0.3967293501,
0.18459782,
0.4993923903,
-0.3544784188,
-0.3840542734,
-1.119017601,
-0.1697970033,
-0.0523551628,
0.1702826023,
0.6867299676,
0.0834788978,
0.0274472479,
0.9613825679,
-0.567587316,
-0.3309592605,
-0.218729198,
-0.1866564155,
-0.0210953914,
0.4335677028,
0.1909958124,
-0.7567000985,
-0.6449048519,
-0.3726089895,
-0.2461920977,
-0.0236636084,
-0.0593881607,
0.0428601839,
0.2583633363,
0.5460665822,
-0.8354784846,
0.4511299729,
0.370401144,
0.084848851,
0.3028275967,
-0.0842223465,
-0.1708566099,
-0.9132525921,
0.0372847766,
-0.2512444258,
-0.4597309828,
-0.5185298324,
0.3160970211,
0.4352354705,
0.2105493844,
-0.5893021226,
0.4640249908,
-0.5652230978,
-0.1370647997,
-0.0368332751,
0.0438637771,
0.0346098989,
0.6988931894,
-0.0969306529,
0.8979635239,
0.1543261409,
-0.6169637442,
0.0265649315,
0.3064070046,
-0.5543524027,
0.1882800758,
-0.7146478891,
0.5352965593,
-0.1703720838,
0.3131942749,
-1.1701122522,
0.1673635244,
-0.2319412529,
-0.3746089339,
0.7744531631,
-0.2341348082,
-0.8071427941,
-0.1482063979,
-0.5433217287,
0.6669588089,
1.0462192297,
-0.5222600698,
0.1849591583,
0.4005125165,
0.1324412525,
-0.5963419676,
-0.8736081123,
0.108189106,
-0.2102794945,
-0.6105883718,
0.5322319269,
-0.1597496867,
-0.0266666636,
-0.0677103102,
-0.3214794993,
0.1134898812,
0.0630555227,
0.1557097733,
-0.0004963409,
-0.1784288883,
0.4026697278,
0.1517132223,
-0.108555682,
-0.0612558499,
-0.3193279505,
0.648265481,
0.1198030785,
-0.093147032,
-0.3917525113,
0.3783723414,
0.7748637795,
-0.0958426148,
0.7593463063,
0.4515945911,
-0.193400532,
-0.3702680469,
-0.8077943921,
-0.4929673374,
-0.4616823196,
0.3145991564,
-0.3482066691,
-1.0736424923,
0.4864041805,
-0.2137571424,
-0.0550621413,
0.3181533515,
0.871242702,
0.0070325253,
0.9899817705,
0.4622366726,
-0.4738203585,
0.1801269203,
-0.4720135927,
0.4102443159,
-1.2702236176,
-0.1367709041,
-0.3941773772,
-0.6614000797,
-0.2833828926,
-0.8539159298,
0.3720211983,
0.3014242947,
-0.0756293833,
0.148662895,
-0.654315412,
0.6681523323,
0.1812405884,
0.2175688446,
-0.0257245302,
0.1577261388,
-0.0943897367,
-0.1664013863,
-0.755197823,
-0.0766803175,
1.140556097,
0.4179854989,
0.8007935286,
0.312510103,
0.4680998325,
0.3594168723,
-0.0410424508,
-1.0220607519,
0.3889820278,
0.0730082393,
-0.3890675008,
-0.1690064073,
-0.1367222369,
-0.7356321216,
-0.0040558232,
0.0825891048,
-0.7985807657,
0.0845284611,
0.0258816667,
-0.3592093289,
0.1264002025,
-0.3956046999,
0.5399852395,
0.225454405,
-0.3919863105,
-0.4002442956,
-0.8375054002,
0.2848089933,
0.0067960862,
0.0256195366,
0.1547370702,
-0.1784190238,
0.7240529656,
-0.2846927345,
0.8686884642,
-0.1092825383,
-0.0939216539,
0.2540147901,
0.2387506962,
1.1705880165,
0.1947269142,
0.1042394191,
-0.149624601,
-0.3475660086,
-0.4837430418,
-0.8415292501,
0.9407497644,
-1.0239923,
-0.6599217653,
0.1965360343,
-0.7050001025,
-0.180098325,
-0.1953618824,
0.2474825978,
0.2624299526,
0.0863687992,
0.4733754396,
1.1898090839,
-0.068439424,
0.4488816559,
0.2594364285,
0.3256919384,
-0.1306473613,
0.5104910731,
0.1667268127,
0.597204268,
0.6156338453,
0.0863417685,
-0.3378815353,
-0.2863067091,
-0.1098101661,
0.2075973749,
-1.0476796627,
-0.4906978011,
-0.8568060398,
-0.3040643632,
-0.5401732922,
-0.349116236,
-0.7328337431,
-0.4716105163,
-0.3819671869,
0.0156082753,
0.5661370754,
0.2438088357,
0.0095251212,
0.3437727094,
-0.6164817214,
0.0842663944,
0.4739439785,
0.2930103838,
0.3095479012,
-0.7503541708,
-0.4790087938,
-0.1228703558,
-0.0906617418,
-0.7556037307,
0.4850105047,
0.2435923219,
0.2638122141,
0.4338197112,
0.1990808398,
0.6738711596,
-0.549874723,
0.8795009255,
-0.0251914319,
-0.790038228,
0.3221074343,
-0.032497175,
0.4584932625,
0.522238493,
-0.0047168303,
-0.5002654791,
-0.247438699,
-0.5889282227,
-0.9920283556,
0.5521696806,
0.2296710759,
0.4060419202,
-0.1262959838,
0.5920472145,
-0.2606268525,
-0.0898320079,
-0.5461224318,
-0.3532575965,
0.0926154852,
-0.2793952525,
-0.0332825072,
-0.6978930235,
0.1101098061,
-0.2732902765,
0.3846340775,
0.0817397013,
0.7426425219,
0.2229877561,
-0.4088483453,
-0.1660244763,
0.1997593939,
0.7540816069,
-0.0916662812,
-0.3239952326,
0.5023680925,
0.2217896283,
-0.5488655567,
0.2388920784,
-0.5806860328,
-0.07996279,
-0.0354226604,
0.0245281793,
0.7388012409,
0.4576380849,
-0.5063075423,
0.703720808,
-0.00304671,
0.0448850952,
-0.0385995582,
0.0090508033,
0.3355844617,
0.2212505192,
0.0823763758,
-0.264074713,
-0.0390734673,
-0.1022147089,
0.1632192731,
0.4032870233,
-0.6186867952,
-0.274230957,
0.4271603525,
0.05087208,
-0.2763730884,
0.8743525743,
-0.0966847986,
-0.5856525898,
0.5692731142,
0.727632761,
0.789019227,
-0.2374285161,
-0.312856555,
0.5274273753,
0.5370589495,
-0.4430554211,
0.1728269458,
-0.3885961175,
-0.6035708189,
-0.4124828875,
-0.5522496104,
0.2037683427,
0.4369907081,
-0.8339435458,
0.3517340422,
-0.312939167,
0.0193255581,
-0.3888446987,
0.0174692962,
-0.9979226589,
0.0018420706,
0.0707531422,
0.9908004999,
-0.6615025997,
1.1111835241,
-0.0423221029,
-0.2064256966,
-0.8284824491,
-0.1295412183,
0.0361723751,
-0.9271168709,
0.8928743601,
0.2714831233,
0.1469893456,
0.3171569705,
-0.5348699689,
-1.1302677393,
1.0682159662,
0.0966591686,
-0.7294641137,
-0.0607023761,
-0.0578135327,
0.2995671332,
-0.2863114178,
-0.0608693361,
0.5984306931,
0.558206737,
-0.1020126119,
-0.7375192642,
0.192860961,
-0.3141978979,
0.1745635271,
0.4370020926,
-0.7463309169,
0.6200648546,
-0.2135007083,
-0.403072536,
0.0765150487,
0.4588108063,
-0.163417533,
-0.3735236228,
0.4559449852,
0.9886274338,
0.3641738892,
0.3079085946,
1.0605944395,
-0.4678768814,
0.5721487403,
0.8447047472,
-0.1019555107,
1.0859339237,
0.8522965908,
-0.1191674843,
0.1725593805,
0.4845814109,
-0.0997638851,
1.0148751736,
0.3828969896,
-0.0978043973,
-0.4590962231,
-0.1149490625,
-0.2151193023,
0.3756775856,
0.5273843408,
-0.4734449685,
-0.1582305729,
-0.2564511001,
0.1774093956,
-0.3636957407,
-0.0711552277,
0.7162138224,
0.2369755208,
-0.6893672943,
0.8512080908,
0.073774077,
0.4144204855,
-0.2849078178,
0.1176797375,
-0.1745377332,
0.1265543848,
0.1301301271,
-0.5107852221,
0.0342842117,
-0.1495557874,
-0.602283895,
-0.1579996347,
0.6236155033,
-0.5141099095,
-0.1550541818,
0.1321419477,
0.2666723728,
0.1114324629,
0.0218526721,
-0.2509011328,
0.3143695891,
-0.2414739728,
-0.4636400938,
0.5973780751,
-0.033641275,
0.0920335352,
0.4242975116,
0.647046864,
0.0838097706,
0.0333601907,
-0.0636683255,
1.0804648399,
-0.3474232554,
-0.5945909619,
-0.8678153753,
0.4299780726,
0.0506064594,
-0.0073326938,
0.5953779221,
0.4583985806,
0.4616507292,
-0.0625558719,
0.6321550608,
0.3925008476,
-0.0443649739,
-0.6263105869,
0.6317493916,
-0.6478270888,
0.325004071,
-0.0205330979,
-0.9885103703,
-0.4817911386,
0.6962572336,
0.1788465679,
-0.1210471988,
0.602805078,
0.9828802943,
-0.1732293963,
-0.5034240484,
0.3938235044,
0.2888396382,
0.3630189002,
0.9099422693,
0.3761632442,
-0.5648150444,
0.5089184046,
-0.0390834436,
0.0306330323,
-0.7303239107,
-0.7551968098,
-0.9147375226,
-0.5349968672,
-0.0193804502,
-0.4201462865,
0.0933402553,
0.7497723103,
0.9026709795,
-0.3386153877,
0.0897660106,
-0.088985227,
-0.1346016824,
-0.176848501,
-0.1875682473,
0.71326828,
-0.5757718086,
-0.4148960114,
0.3645811379,
0.6323487759,
-0.1182109118,
-0.4582427144,
-0.2018453181,
-0.0196316596,
0.3757938743,
0.5426540971,
0.0183902867,
-1.0452487469,
-0.4380282462,
0.406226486,
-0.4520847201,
0.1929723471,
0.9118803144,
-0.9536949396,
0.7198291421,
0.5845541954,
0.83066535,
0.7147402763,
-0.2968975306,
0.4443129301,
-1.1541416645,
0.3350009918,
0.2260112762,
0.1362085044,
0.1526762247,
-0.654873848,
0.3244604468,
0.1175261289,
-0.6070255041,
-0.8794003129,
0.2765208483,
-1.2546329498,
-0.2330130041,
1.6012043953,
-0.0351584032,
-0.2415173948,
0.0179368537,
-0.0729465634,
0.294844538,
-0.4628506899,
1.0868569613,
0.7562353015,
0.4602742791,
-0.5320334435,
-0.5720629096,
0.7345021367,
0.5802302361,
-0.3723474741,
0.271543473,
0.0231176522,
0.0192488786,
0.1091578901,
0.3945032954,
-0.0884849057,
0.4398611188,
-0.0964529142,
-0.0767502859,
-0.0701013058,
-0.3572059274,
-0.4117739797,
0.0712134391,
0.104409948,
0.0050920118
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11429v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11429v1 | Fusion Makes Perfection: An Efficient Multi-Grained Matching Approach for Zero-Shot Relation Extraction | 2024-06-17T11:31:48 | 2024-06-17T11:31:48 | Shilong Li, Ge Bai, Zhang Zhang, Ying Liu, Chenji Lu, Daichi Guo, Ruifang Liu, Yong Sun | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Predicting unseen relations that cannot be observed during the training phase
is a challenging task in relation extraction. Previous works have made progress
by matching the semantics between input instances and label descriptions.
However, fine-grained matching often requires laborious manual annotation, and
rich interactions between instances and label descriptions come with
significant computational overhead. In this work, we propose an efficient
multi-grained matching approach that uses virtual entity matching to reduce
manual annotation cost, and fuses coarse-grained recall and fine-grained
classification for rich interactions with guaranteed inference speed.
Experimental results show that our approach outperforms the previous State Of
The Art (SOTA) methods, and achieves a balance between inference efficiency and
prediction accuracy in zero-shot relation extraction tasks. Our code is
available at https://github.com/longls777/EMMA. | [
-0.4828926921,
-0.7297818661,
0.8186739683,
0.0598873757,
-0.111728102,
-0.2240861505,
0.2116674781,
-0.949072957,
0.1717515439,
0.5958604217,
-0.4951059222,
-0.261064738,
-0.3230672777,
-0.0877820253,
-0.4048099816,
0.9361911416,
0.0303479582,
-0.1726830751,
-0.5158692002,
-0.1564662904,
-0.2717246711,
-0.2196004391,
-0.1902066171,
-0.6001886725,
0.4658363461,
0.3707493544,
0.6302109361,
1.3043032885,
0.4374537468,
0.299949199,
0.1347546279,
0.3408690989,
-0.5501832962,
0.4069505036,
-0.2160952538,
-0.0385148153,
-0.5386246443,
-0.0734559968,
0.3031007648,
0.2890033722,
0.2599626482,
0.4100024998,
-0.1889622957,
0.0950015262,
-1.2081676722,
0.2873157859,
-1.0293935537,
0.0976177827,
-0.4034825265,
-0.3587674201,
-0.2749988437,
0.037803676,
-0.0635411888,
-0.7152434587,
0.2712195516,
-0.0325715803,
1.6147581339,
0.0887124017,
-0.302421689,
0.219228819,
-1.0315653086,
0.4924909174,
-0.2606135607,
0.3016917109,
0.3386974633,
0.5544282794,
-0.2265332341,
-0.5237257481,
-0.7794659734,
0.1848908812,
-0.2274125069,
0.2601152956,
0.0319887251,
0.2454264164,
0.1709365845,
0.6663751602,
-0.3779342473,
-0.1082574651,
-0.0417827256,
-0.1006562784,
0.4662574232,
0.1583643705,
0.1120938212,
-0.169868812,
-0.4679704905,
-0.1425365508,
-0.2505228817,
-0.3502242267,
-0.1406807899,
0.3910291791,
0.0783315748,
0.6598168612,
-0.4090168476,
0.8872383833,
-0.030947743,
-0.3098368645,
0.1383566111,
-0.5857109427,
-0.4288578331,
0.1603650898,
0.8733490705,
0.5379618406,
0.3868154585,
-0.3600318134,
0.246513918,
0.6079959869,
0.0670422465,
-0.8649881482,
-0.2314679325,
0.1700036377,
0.1315431446,
-0.2817344964,
0.1502344012,
-0.9011049867,
-0.0983817726,
-0.2672530413,
0.7015658021,
-0.5092781782,
-0.1782697439,
-0.129137218,
-0.3679340184,
0.8416637182,
0.1365306228,
-0.8562005758,
0.0559195988,
1.0561472178,
0.777906239,
0.3377203941,
-0.3013727367,
-0.7380220294,
0.4988646805,
-0.2225822508,
1.110257864,
-0.652841866,
-0.2030843943,
-0.1021776497,
-0.1693508327,
0.0008412828,
-0.4094893336,
0.5196655393,
-0.3468978703,
-0.1909135431,
-0.0259160846,
-0.6103638411,
0.0032424107,
0.4609107673,
-0.4016509056,
0.9604496956,
0.1595086902,
-0.5422673225,
0.229671672,
-0.0520658344,
-0.363094449,
0.2340240479,
-0.2607752085,
-0.4816127419,
-0.0093552656,
0.1800464243,
0.6143938303,
-0.222300753,
0.1727893203,
-0.9828004241,
-0.295430392,
-0.2302499264,
0.0603865795,
0.2430167794,
0.160800308,
-0.1821410507,
0.085722886,
-1.0280793905,
0.0358088203,
0.221470654,
0.2672918141,
-0.6192931533,
-0.4402484298,
-0.0551626496,
0.5047820807,
0.0522185639,
-0.7937571406,
0.2107346654,
-0.4764521718,
0.0000763722,
0.5032529831,
-0.0744286031,
0.7280860543,
-0.0587989055,
0.0152685316,
0.0887645483,
0.133411482,
-0.7088946104,
-0.1763712168,
-0.7440491319,
-0.2031027228,
0.4906691611,
0.5050603151,
-1.0366051197,
0.4878763855,
-0.4756092131,
-0.8759004474,
-0.8156769276,
0.0330833681,
0.9016845226,
0.7533541322,
0.4608932734,
-0.5210595131,
-0.4456231594,
-0.8730373383,
-0.1196267456,
0.0750712305,
-0.1678028107,
0.4485659301,
0.1679029316,
-0.2124524564,
1.1230633259,
-0.7835194468,
-0.6899279952,
0.0410038047,
-0.0117457956,
-0.1437946409,
0.4417192936,
0.6833614111,
-0.583496511,
-0.6465671659,
0.5668050647,
-1.278958559,
0.0630298406,
-0.0408248305,
-0.6266428828,
-0.2578653395,
0.1765540987,
-0.6502490044,
0.3520206213,
0.3169374466,
-0.3578209877,
0.2049821615,
0.0626246557,
0.1569575667,
-1.1705106497,
-0.0435211882,
0.3471410871,
-0.5333600044,
-0.7590190768,
0.3750482798,
0.2295071185,
-0.0527035557,
-0.6645062566,
0.8043917418,
-0.4639763236,
-0.2736259997,
-0.2090692967,
0.4279369712,
0.168878004,
0.3808434606,
-0.042663902,
0.4454826713,
0.8070222735,
-0.5793910623,
0.2380364984,
0.4472816586,
0.3148960471,
0.8122243285,
-0.1927956492,
-0.0685948059,
-0.217490539,
0.1756985933,
-0.5332101583,
-0.4975172579,
0.2097327113,
-0.3835972548,
0.470589608,
-0.0683429539,
-0.2504865527,
-0.1273417175,
-0.6506651044,
0.1760489792,
0.1244157925,
-0.543847084,
0.8975303173,
0.4598965049,
0.2815135121,
-0.4561850727,
-0.3838273883,
0.0014467697,
0.1867693067,
-0.4367974102,
0.6627383828,
0.1665747315,
0.0902363732,
0.2309168279,
-0.4995408952,
-0.5662907958,
0.0286843851,
0.4928635955,
0.4079388082,
-0.2684117258,
-0.1267125458,
0.0006344391,
-0.4156730771,
-0.5795837045,
0.2103482634,
0.5350123644,
0.0868511423,
0.0733895525,
-0.5199041367,
0.2639737725,
0.8018406034,
-0.1428120136,
0.7938566208,
0.8083001375,
-0.4324823618,
0.2900820971,
-0.7919467092,
-0.122509487,
-0.4572436512,
0.2009915859,
-0.7345501184,
-0.7752958536,
0.275413394,
-0.0348448865,
0.1765408814,
0.4690786302,
0.0196648166,
0.0795632601,
0.5189800858,
0.6187634468,
-0.1941463649,
0.3229469359,
-0.1146012992,
0.1941608489,
-0.843090117,
-0.4209223688,
-0.6261423826,
0.0554558635,
-0.5305101275,
-0.2449348122,
0.0368268974,
0.3116143644,
0.009174943,
0.9572604895,
-0.534483254,
0.748405695,
0.5653030872,
0.0205159709,
0.4015060663,
-0.1604644209,
0.3612274826,
0.0124664018,
-0.4930687845,
-0.1769447923,
0.6609276533,
-0.113379389,
0.3143106401,
-0.195977062,
0.9874930382,
-0.3375621736,
0.2859615088,
-0.961745739,
0.585801661,
-0.1006624848,
-0.4956016839,
-0.1388035268,
-0.7417889237,
-1.1637535095,
0.374863863,
-0.8471987844,
-0.7954724431,
-0.0370141231,
0.3795987964,
-0.618549943,
0.2534706891,
-0.762740314,
0.9771050215,
0.0698764846,
-0.524638474,
0.1513890177,
-0.6880244017,
0.7116124034,
-0.2785983086,
0.0913596973,
-0.4919289351,
0.4576100707,
0.2327151448,
-0.2519859672,
-0.0159231108,
0.1899992824,
0.3416776955,
0.0125821875,
0.2989591658,
0.101923421,
-0.2160809636,
-0.090420559,
0.3758839071,
0.1915862411,
-0.4205879569,
-0.5974819064,
0.9904868603,
-0.4356097877,
-0.1655038446,
-0.5997390151,
-0.4699205756,
-0.0666180402,
0.2993224263,
0.0445821211,
0.2868213356,
-0.1919073313,
-0.0684338808,
0.4573708773,
0.0889909565,
0.6604088545,
0.4101887643,
-0.2425153255,
-0.3509452641,
1.1093071699,
0.1921502054,
0.0772877485,
0.4559454918,
0.0346812904,
-0.1495357156,
0.1120196134,
-0.6620338559,
0.3062601089,
-0.1161855236,
-0.7531785965,
-0.9733985066,
-0.3713112772,
-0.5910428166,
-0.216512695,
-0.6184054017,
0.0276935529,
-0.2631457448,
0.0880006701,
0.3526294231,
0.3864473701,
-0.0031604455,
0.4532701075,
-1.3597944975,
0.7008146048,
0.5680274963,
0.3744913042,
0.0006503794,
-0.0932151824,
0.0977171883,
-0.2494786531,
-0.6400249004,
-0.863494575,
0.2124048471,
0.6215151548,
0.2027098984,
0.569221437,
0.1574099362,
1.4120292664,
-0.5300614834,
0.576012671,
0.3457895219,
-0.8619199991,
0.4471542537,
-0.0578586198,
0.203179121,
0.7886142135,
0.3826173842,
-0.1055518612,
-0.178621769,
-0.9157496095,
-1.0360566378,
0.7836880088,
0.4202566147,
0.0612166338,
0.0052163936,
0.5590903759,
-0.0431816988,
0.0052880011,
-0.5333111882,
-0.4553826749,
0.3003148139,
-0.126734674,
0.0887142941,
-0.2977783978,
0.1909741163,
-0.2715199888,
0.8394180536,
0.0339207053,
0.1423709691,
0.1398714334,
0.0140153877,
-0.2227519602,
-0.0447407365,
0.1057098359,
0.2769662142,
-0.3075557649,
0.3025676906,
0.1165647507,
0.0278649088,
0.1167511493,
0.3477050662,
-0.2879592478,
0.2860396802,
0.2985392213,
0.7479500771,
0.5299004316,
-0.3510688245,
0.5949953198,
-0.1163964719,
-0.1822249442,
0.0779211223,
0.2461060733,
0.0023128504,
0.2735006213,
-0.1435684115,
0.0460225493,
0.1708080918,
-0.9055725932,
0.5969054699,
0.6141856909,
-0.553943336,
-0.3539766371,
0.649169147,
0.1695604026,
-0.4385148287,
0.422980845,
-0.4023534358,
-0.2248572707,
0.1396507919,
0.396520704,
0.7432290316,
-0.4245885611,
0.2932033837,
0.5070661306,
-0.2809740603,
-0.2558476925,
-0.231256023,
-0.3262639642,
-0.7493238449,
-0.5791988969,
-1.1415845156,
-0.3177531064,
0.0626607314,
-0.7404924035,
0.4064965546,
-0.2636274397,
0.0452087969,
0.6719856858,
-0.3096341193,
-0.5723533034,
0.0500928834,
0.2156102657,
0.5177385211,
-0.9547805786,
0.8826867342,
0.2265759408,
-0.4711368382,
-0.9005402923,
-0.2676327229,
0.0241698492,
-0.5801778436,
-0.0742846802,
0.5578347445,
0.073131755,
0.0825318843,
-0.2124698907,
-0.7003907561,
0.8217208385,
0.7888869643,
-0.6646367311,
0.1116834134,
-0.0887035429,
0.3600909412,
-0.1016048267,
0.5668789744,
1.0456043482,
0.2702024877,
0.7092707753,
-1.1112462282,
-0.2286961824,
-0.0363922082,
-0.0578640364,
0.7577599287,
-0.4455262423,
0.5751555562,
0.2836328447,
-0.4060554206,
0.006683934,
0.6347483993,
0.1880264282,
0.7615272403,
0.134542644,
0.9218559861,
0.2207131833,
-0.1772167832,
0.8660778403,
-0.27107054,
0.6634076834,
1.4775674343,
-0.5983305573,
0.8388513923,
0.3494904339,
0.0213577766,
0.101230517,
0.528183341,
-0.0436086841,
0.3897789121,
-0.2832513154,
-0.3048374951,
-0.5294658542,
-0.614872694,
-0.2649976611,
0.6178913116,
-0.0704368949,
-0.2261213511,
-0.7802924514,
-0.3181522787,
0.1723759323,
0.2530001104,
-0.2939828038,
1.2570843697,
0.1293370575,
-0.519110024,
0.3498656452,
-0.3445349932,
0.6272062659,
-0.5178740621,
-0.3222751915,
0.0231397171,
0.1878801584,
-0.2390255332,
-0.7264451981,
0.4307741821,
-0.2024691105,
-0.1301988661,
0.1505382359,
0.8883150816,
-0.7083902359,
-0.3090361059,
0.5764607191,
0.4394071996,
0.1525208801,
-0.3805679083,
-0.3665571511,
0.023281863,
-0.1718115211,
0.0989028662,
0.6304089427,
0.4918348491,
0.1438526064,
0.224967286,
0.7446082234,
-0.0012926923,
-0.1659865677,
-0.3998574913,
0.8197520971,
-0.6461687684,
0.0948456302,
-1.2667450905,
0.3203498721,
-0.4742845595,
-0.2290717661,
0.5692804456,
0.6574289203,
0.9842099547,
-0.1646548212,
0.3863608539,
-0.0149965826,
-0.0419062264,
-0.0190994572,
0.2637488544,
-0.4077173173,
-0.46551615,
-0.5992255211,
-1.4922796488,
-0.6375991702,
0.5142046809,
0.1853917092,
-0.4564044476,
0.3703312874,
0.8384346366,
-0.4397099316,
-0.2315639555,
0.727651298,
-0.0167403314,
0.3712266088,
0.6329348087,
0.1890548319,
-0.8840500116,
0.5316464305,
-0.5106468201,
-0.3673745394,
-0.1913288981,
-0.8605456352,
-0.4911189079,
-0.3274672627,
-0.4525177181,
-0.3649593592,
-0.0814726278,
0.9697259665,
0.8067948222,
-0.4962964952,
0.0688997805,
0.0086294049,
-0.0560877509,
-0.1152078435,
-0.2121654153,
0.1330108345,
-0.0654373318,
-0.7801375985,
0.1936278343,
0.8222801685,
0.1440304667,
0.2518679202,
0.1955436319,
-0.3630502224,
0.0855882317,
0.9277550578,
0.5493035913,
-0.5883841515,
-0.3685277402,
-0.3396447003,
0.0048308638,
0.1268711984,
0.309492141,
-0.6905314326,
0.7692121863,
0.2659152448,
0.8724486828,
0.8962471485,
0.1452462226,
0.3287907541,
-0.6796686053,
0.2160547078,
-0.005392048,
0.1197972745,
0.287891686,
-0.2376411557,
0.7028735876,
0.2664736211,
-0.3749784529,
-0.8529376388,
0.2604673505,
-1.3776830435,
-0.0508242771,
1.026466012,
-0.2450114489,
-0.5935607553,
-0.0666708574,
-0.2299676538,
0.566606164,
-0.2276857793,
0.8261731267,
0.1936264783,
-0.1139955893,
-0.2192916423,
-0.1501493603,
0.3022066057,
0.07399147,
-0.8761899471,
0.014924461,
0.3127684295,
-0.0028200457,
0.5085775852,
0.5252248645,
0.1185399517,
0.0660471693,
0.0856629983,
0.2806207836,
-0.2544161975,
-0.4270742834,
0.0571788922,
0.3589106202,
-0.2080965489,
-0.4175751805
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11427v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11427v1 | DiTTo-TTS: Efficient and Scalable Zero-Shot Text-to-Speech with Diffusion Transformer | 2024-06-17T11:25:57 | 2024-06-17T11:25:57 | Keon Lee, Dong Won Kim, Jaehyeon Kim, Jaewoong Cho | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD | Large-scale diffusion models have shown outstanding generative abilities
across multiple modalities including images, videos, and audio. However,
text-to-speech (TTS) systems typically involve domain-specific modeling factors
(e.g., phonemes and phoneme-level durations) to ensure precise temporal
alignments between text and speech, which hinders the efficiency and
scalability of diffusion models for TTS. In this work, we present an efficient
and scalable Diffusion Transformer (DiT) that utilizes off-the-shelf
pre-trained text and speech encoders. Our approach addresses the challenge of
text-speech alignment via cross-attention mechanisms with the prediction of the
total length of speech representations. To achieve this, we enhance the DiT
architecture to suit TTS and improve the alignment by incorporating semantic
guidance into the latent space of speech. We scale the training dataset and the
model size to 82K hours and 790M parameters, respectively. Our extensive
experiments demonstrate that the large-scale diffusion model for TTS without
domain-specific modeling not only simplifies the training pipeline but also
yields superior or comparable zero-shot performance to state-of-the-art TTS
models in terms of naturalness, intelligibility, and speaker similarity. Our
speech samples are available at https://ditto-tts.github.io. | [
-0.2393502593,
-0.8938125968,
0.6404997706,
0.1344396472,
-0.5048782825,
0.1653131992,
-0.0377781838,
0.0559263118,
0.3055133522,
-0.0471840724,
-0.4650459886,
-0.2792056799,
-1.1049081087,
0.052298829,
-0.8904564381,
0.9050649405,
0.211904183,
-0.0776196048,
0.1667806953,
0.1119071916,
-0.3523364961,
-0.0077406433,
-0.7146884203,
-0.1672938019,
0.505258441,
0.1806968749,
0.5379131436,
0.5930560231,
0.2238797843,
0.2717526257,
-0.3608487248,
-0.2622353137,
-0.4390771687,
0.166896522,
-0.2127606273,
-0.0779171139,
-0.4317512512,
-0.436874032,
0.7396724224,
0.513917625,
-0.4078022838,
0.142599538,
0.0554438084,
0.5681486726,
-0.5114142895,
-0.3402003944,
-0.7239189148,
0.096405074,
-0.3206297755,
0.097055532,
-0.4009543061,
-0.1057593599,
0.5460033417,
-0.5460639596,
0.181083411,
-0.3347475529,
0.5466396809,
0.7584437728,
-0.351067543,
0.0447598323,
-0.9038484097,
0.6648521423,
-0.4900333881,
0.6362581849,
-0.1277618855,
0.5246319771,
0.1779789925,
-0.758009553,
-0.8295114636,
0.1270658076,
0.0508850627,
0.3416315913,
-0.5510237217,
-0.1974146217,
0.0592672043,
0.2024106681,
-0.8241910338,
0.0702941641,
0.1158322766,
0.0725510493,
0.086249724,
-0.1021990702,
0.167161122,
0.0947719663,
-0.3354945183,
0.0375787318,
-0.0986408368,
-0.499235332,
0.0996970236,
0.2387093902,
-0.3389894366,
0.5153785944,
-0.0002866821,
0.9087053537,
0.5064528584,
-0.1856952012,
0.2731022835,
-0.3279390633,
-0.228013739,
0.3337028921,
0.9630131125,
-0.0300701745,
0.0691176355,
-0.4575400352,
0.095968172,
0.1044023186,
0.3585236073,
-0.9522086978,
0.2430691421,
0.2255612165,
-0.0345612802,
-0.0903708562,
-0.3705095947,
-1.0799657106,
-0.0929135904,
-0.1235586777,
0.7046020031,
-0.4993223846,
-0.4823077321,
0.3816257715,
-0.4922283292,
0.1449502409,
0.3350726068,
-0.8927120566,
0.0416938774,
0.3409946859,
1.3680715561,
-0.3745031059,
-0.1135819927,
-0.6180716753,
0.4541208744,
-0.2297860235,
0.6020416021,
-0.5305832028,
-0.5013666749,
-0.0754808858,
-0.1626287252,
-0.1604705453,
-0.1308545172,
0.5801941752,
-0.3303684592,
0.2300228775,
0.2994220257,
-0.5618326664,
0.3617946208,
0.0773486495,
-0.4173952639,
0.7970665097,
0.0866568536,
-0.804731369,
0.1374321282,
-0.9248510599,
-0.6131048799,
0.1596914828,
-0.022837488,
-0.6741687655,
0.0396061987,
0.1124621555,
0.5513214469,
-0.3493955135,
0.2729479671,
-0.1308570653,
-0.3657534122,
0.0220259596,
-0.8477644324,
0.4539553225,
0.2287523299,
-0.6896202564,
-0.0839905292,
-0.8579645753,
-0.3943144679,
0.2267055213,
0.118119441,
-0.3039854467,
-0.1995730102,
0.1077940315,
0.0328366235,
0.2271450609,
-0.8055759072,
-0.027053168,
-0.3520866632,
0.7747035027,
0.4505518675,
-0.2427334934,
0.9246120453,
-0.014503736,
0.3652494848,
0.1428332627,
0.1973126084,
-0.3801477849,
-0.5015301108,
-0.5131456256,
-0.6912233233,
0.2930815816,
0.4841675162,
-0.8542608023,
0.560836494,
-0.7389835715,
-0.8323500752,
-0.5071512461,
-0.3830995858,
0.1746549904,
0.9234361649,
0.4547615647,
0.1049695686,
-0.2204586565,
-0.6179355979,
0.008939418,
0.1445486844,
-0.2170592248,
-0.1532823145,
0.299265027,
-0.3847914338,
1.1717841625,
-0.5662421584,
-0.3352880478,
0.0075581353,
0.1854861528,
-0.0029521063,
0.3392834365,
0.6304160953,
-0.770971477,
-0.8042799234,
0.1383662075,
-0.2207726836,
-0.1268710047,
0.1390399486,
-0.1304654181,
-0.0093065193,
0.3379581869,
-0.5926887393,
0.488737613,
0.6677531004,
-0.327483356,
0.0552720465,
-0.2005491555,
0.1632714272,
-1.5073355436,
0.176133126,
0.2222691029,
-0.4496203959,
-0.8775163293,
-0.7300187349,
-0.0266113561,
-0.2307678312,
-0.5537674427,
0.5067976713,
-0.0907691494,
0.1021403298,
-0.2839792669,
0.3740068972,
0.0261045378,
0.2626633048,
0.3877255917,
0.999869585,
0.8256385326,
-0.5641072989,
0.1456207633,
0.3680168688,
-0.0102134403,
1.1370669603,
-0.8443009853,
0.1522904783,
-0.2361078411,
0.3297176957,
-1.1706790924,
0.1710848063,
0.1293285191,
-0.4898766279,
0.4150691926,
-0.3261580169,
-0.4722011983,
-0.1680628061,
-0.218396917,
0.3968484998,
0.8292033076,
-0.5611089468,
0.6912221313,
0.3630070984,
-0.3508765399,
-0.6606960297,
-0.8121793866,
0.0591284782,
-0.4190243781,
-0.3902788162,
0.8557503223,
-0.1206772029,
0.2285625637,
-0.0796385333,
-0.040143244,
-0.3448821604,
-0.3249545395,
0.0501901209,
0.0563066714,
-0.0475313291,
0.1448967606,
0.3902045786,
-0.2536783814,
-0.4209131002,
-0.5940036178,
0.5094195008,
0.3744677901,
-0.2309028804,
-0.6566705108,
0.3552037179,
0.9404059052,
-0.1047510207,
0.7209940553,
0.7341136932,
-0.151548937,
-0.0216013789,
-0.4319894612,
0.1137017608,
-0.4231642783,
0.485701561,
-0.2064038813,
-0.969815135,
0.1329026669,
-0.2805697322,
0.0355588309,
0.4408907294,
0.4705647528,
-0.0588028021,
0.816704154,
0.738265276,
-0.1748673767,
0.9210633039,
-0.203620255,
0.1790994704,
-0.6915212274,
0.0511525273,
-0.4871717691,
-0.2384324521,
-0.2567976117,
-0.7375963926,
0.3866185248,
-0.3266381025,
-0.3813479245,
0.4462983906,
-0.861189723,
0.322119385,
0.1397755593,
-0.1883821338,
0.2482474744,
0.1928304583,
0.1356134266,
0.0341723263,
-0.6226998568,
-0.3689804971,
0.9673016071,
0.3346857727,
0.7076852918,
0.1683920026,
0.6106469631,
0.2632717192,
-0.1246317923,
-0.7103997469,
0.242840603,
-0.486582607,
-0.2457478791,
-0.7815038562,
-0.3735744059,
-0.7882882357,
0.0548579842,
-0.0195632484,
-0.507245481,
0.127454713,
-0.0343863927,
-0.4329881072,
0.3696812093,
-0.7332783341,
0.7132214904,
-0.0075674197,
-0.3521590233,
-0.0619182326,
-0.6465461254,
-0.1399620622,
-0.3789333403,
0.0408163816,
0.1438156664,
-0.2258475125,
0.8000738025,
-0.3270978928,
0.7655420899,
-0.3143516183,
-0.3569380641,
0.1982622296,
-0.1840717196,
0.2474752218,
-0.059729144,
0.0550334416,
0.4511121809,
-0.0422249958,
-0.1628213078,
-0.6280776858,
0.5741552114,
-0.647203207,
-0.1866176724,
-0.2754170895,
-0.2162162662,
-0.1585405767,
0.3087154329,
0.5302276611,
0.3782289326,
-0.4054246247,
0.141727671,
1.0300639868,
-0.0340891145,
0.7595850825,
0.6414862871,
0.0306961313,
-0.5152121186,
0.7977532744,
0.194171831,
0.3340975344,
0.6977326274,
0.1388813704,
-0.6878552437,
-0.3833877146,
-0.734950304,
0.308778733,
-0.1782357395,
-0.2839982212,
-0.7445719838,
-0.2829393148,
-0.4580886066,
-0.2288181782,
-0.7661392689,
-0.4274286926,
-0.5863561034,
-0.0028442505,
0.6081694365,
0.5911775231,
0.0848231837,
0.7953416109,
-0.6160500646,
0.5770222545,
0.441396147,
0.544578433,
0.053503111,
-1.0512909889,
-0.114477925,
0.1287847459,
-0.2708343267,
-0.7605246305,
0.2346106172,
0.2339344323,
0.2475484908,
0.2983037829,
-0.0932115316,
1.0119315386,
-1.1283082962,
0.759744823,
0.5923557281,
-1.2089724541,
0.6600418091,
-0.227813378,
0.5191652179,
0.2719944417,
0.4082399309,
-0.4815792143,
-0.2569532394,
-0.3221201599,
-0.6491202116,
0.6936826706,
0.4532854259,
0.2347641438,
-0.0245506018,
0.4001302421,
0.1761746556,
0.0232966021,
-0.4482651651,
-0.4000068903,
-0.5013507009,
-0.5300992727,
-0.2612142563,
-0.1590186954,
0.0623130687,
-0.1847792566,
0.5299209356,
-0.0348526984,
0.2217125893,
0.3325378001,
-0.0895978287,
-0.0065156515,
0.4342995286,
0.6411724091,
0.2136138529,
0.0518675484,
-0.0125641981,
0.1005748957,
-0.7014121413,
0.5370681286,
0.3794905245,
0.0168649368,
0.396623373,
-0.036296092,
0.784942627,
0.1537832469,
-0.4260071218,
0.8438309431,
-0.3014630973,
-0.3415304124,
-0.2146986425,
-0.3608659506,
0.1657072008,
0.2211559117,
0.3809207678,
-0.1100602448,
0.1503472477,
-0.015470136,
0.2667488754,
0.3914830089,
-0.3979754448,
-0.359536469,
0.8850408792,
0.4242857993,
-0.491946876,
0.1634107083,
0.0888354778,
-0.0514578596,
0.1170547307,
0.5349306464,
1.120387435,
-0.5243256092,
0.5527198315,
0.0579109378,
0.010543379,
-0.1882767975,
-0.2355125546,
-0.4208098948,
-0.3713196814,
-0.4922533035,
-0.7100805044,
-0.3210192919,
-0.105140999,
-0.4208919406,
0.3195490837,
-0.1181289852,
-0.4645780027,
0.1852050871,
-0.5263044238,
-0.3845288157,
0.2018709183,
0.1723662913,
0.6795968413,
-0.7466700077,
0.9564307928,
0.3385380208,
-0.1485207975,
-0.3493665159,
0.1632686704,
-0.340988338,
-0.4693261683,
0.5602453947,
0.0283543169,
-0.5268111229,
0.2896389663,
-0.0037208563,
-0.8682032824,
1.2121143341,
0.7548527718,
-1.1887357235,
-0.1240210086,
0.4819582701,
0.6375468373,
-0.0601253137,
0.421969533,
0.4391051531,
0.1302147955,
0.6619052291,
-1.0422497988,
-0.3872245848,
0.2022924572,
0.2050940692,
0.3101018965,
-0.6172460318,
0.5025803447,
0.2124307305,
-0.1803217977,
-0.1149990261,
0.4870635271,
-0.1908551008,
0.2765969932,
0.6065535545,
0.8552882075,
0.4065643549,
-0.074604094,
0.4997451603,
-0.1247865781,
0.2157295495,
1.0007624626,
-0.4517768621,
0.8280948997,
0.5138301849,
-0.1678121835,
0.4514531195,
0.119921647,
0.4085784853,
0.9146360755,
-0.1401341259,
-0.2849360704,
0.084147349,
0.0095034763,
-0.4300240278,
0.3664397299,
0.139572978,
-0.1826993972,
-0.3233587146,
0.2120245844,
-0.1520177424,
0.059610609,
-0.1439120322,
0.9747522473,
-0.1714171171,
-0.3715532124,
0.4417679012,
-0.3366954923,
1.150460124,
-0.7773565054,
-0.0194567218,
-0.0797960311,
0.0655387565,
-0.0079191411,
-0.7868326902,
0.5314117074,
0.4656985402,
-0.3351616263,
-0.4998818934,
0.3924483359,
-0.4975812733,
-0.4450646341,
0.3820828497,
0.3516937494,
-0.1097854748,
-0.1545182467,
-0.6095193028,
0.0445000231,
-0.2110091895,
-0.0763447359,
0.3287250996,
0.8076589704,
0.446531713,
0.418384999,
0.2977527976,
-0.0717863068,
0.1236118227,
0.2534469068,
0.658180654,
-0.3843891621,
-0.5040211082,
-1.2088829279,
0.6872537136,
-0.1772532612,
-0.1313400418,
0.5273341537,
0.681723237,
0.4312871397,
0.00697773,
0.6930190325,
0.1261500865,
0.7642630339,
-0.1515681893,
0.8367249966,
-0.5781967044,
-0.1076189354,
-0.6078829169,
-0.8708757758,
-0.1587013453,
0.5515337586,
-0.1443178654,
-0.1094305366,
0.4809129536,
0.47640118,
-0.0791995898,
-0.22862342,
0.609496057,
0.0051063346,
0.3800916672,
0.358497113,
0.5779244304,
-0.525775671,
0.8055647016,
-0.0467178822,
-0.457690686,
0.0827339366,
-0.8613736033,
-0.7282442451,
-0.8351935744,
-0.5940926671,
0.1527085602,
0.0737527385,
0.1998551786,
0.8083159924,
-0.2790225744,
-0.0071623842,
-0.3367144763,
-0.1038808301,
0.060694918,
-0.1941599846,
0.2457081228,
-0.1565194875,
-1.0266481638,
0.2527990937,
0.7463416457,
0.5068231821,
-0.106230773,
0.0604301319,
-0.1892459691,
0.2562162578,
0.7375336885,
-0.0071386602,
-0.5239124298,
-0.1005224735,
0.0138623416,
-0.0128472149,
0.0745173246,
0.4651934505,
-0.7737037539,
0.5010660887,
0.1692347527,
0.7607519627,
0.6834014058,
-0.2184913754,
0.4053191841,
-0.7612691522,
0.3887750208,
0.2645469308,
0.1978878975,
0.2798900902,
-0.300947696,
0.2576551437,
0.0103721498,
-0.5485064387,
-0.7331869006,
0.0884973854,
-1.1116276979,
-0.160210073,
1.0028260946,
-0.0063663661,
-0.1165563688,
0.0869720355,
-0.3493880332,
0.6146443486,
-0.451539278,
0.6096871495,
0.3928709626,
0.1290768236,
-0.1199868917,
-0.0532072224,
0.3308391273,
0.3321288526,
-0.6430289745,
0.1424705833,
0.2736567557,
0.4576936066,
0.3195642829,
0.7384624481,
-0.1651410162,
-0.0127260499,
0.0084716519,
-0.2521867156,
0.261361599,
-0.2077302784,
-0.5755265951,
0.0510773547,
-0.3767821193,
-0.6236053109
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11424v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11424v1 | Evaluating the Efficacy of Open-Source LLMs in Enterprise-Specific RAG Systems: A Comparative Study of Performance and Scalability | 2024-06-17T11:22:25 | 2024-06-17T11:22:25 | Gautam B, Anupam Purwar | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.CL | This paper presents an analysis of open-source large language models (LLMs)
and their application in Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) tasks, specific
for enterprise-specific data sets scraped from their websites. With the
increasing reliance on LLMs in natural language processing, it is crucial to
evaluate their performance, accessibility, and integration within specific
organizational contexts. This study examines various open-source LLMs, explores
their integration into RAG frameworks using enterprise-specific data, and
assesses the performance of different open-source embeddings in enhancing the
retrieval and generation process. Our findings indicate that open-source LLMs,
combined with effective embedding techniques, can significantly improve the
accuracy and efficiency of RAG systems, offering a viable alternative to
proprietary solutions for enterprises. | [
-0.3777153194,
-0.8025490642,
0.6513960361,
0.3224267066,
-0.0599937811,
0.0970916301,
-0.405113101,
-0.6957304478,
0.405403614,
0.7197762728,
-0.0391803011,
-0.5043756366,
-0.2625706792,
0.2124225199,
-0.4784934223,
0.6262708306,
-0.0036255247,
0.184269771,
-0.3335846961,
-0.3197463751,
-0.1421707869,
-0.5023348927,
-0.6676594615,
-0.0912187472,
0.3742988408,
0.3012257516,
0.6392743587,
0.6236605644,
0.8988297582,
0.270273149,
-0.1059410125,
0.0186859332,
-0.5236724615,
0.3804460466,
-0.6156069636,
-0.3855039477,
-0.6784211397,
-0.1086772233,
0.8501878381,
0.5272585154,
-0.3785382807,
0.5324287415,
0.107807979,
0.6151931286,
-0.8467043042,
-0.0500249192,
-0.7551733851,
-0.037922401,
-0.3715966046,
0.0030264696,
-0.5456145406,
-0.622753799,
-0.0991159007,
-0.3130660951,
0.0709977373,
0.3113209009,
0.5906774998,
0.1333343983,
0.0223553982,
-0.5727829337,
-0.867434144,
0.991527915,
-0.7916404605,
0.5683076382,
0.1695034057,
0.2782146931,
-0.0843025297,
-0.9268473387,
-0.1504762918,
-0.2347700596,
-0.0556279495,
0.0216391664,
-0.3839273155,
-0.1027852446,
0.0864748955,
0.6600310802,
-0.5775220394,
0.617960453,
-0.299908042,
0.2849295437,
0.334628284,
0.3414870799,
0.136992082,
-0.0114304489,
-0.2868172228,
0.1062146276,
-0.6686796546,
-0.3150126636,
0.2171730101,
0.5203787684,
0.2355575114,
1.076665163,
-0.0491868556,
0.5662471652,
-0.1656626612,
-0.107763283,
0.2887411714,
-0.0927193388,
-0.6738946438,
-0.0957256332,
0.6848396659,
0.0118693952,
0.0534940995,
-0.5157242417,
-0.4133508503,
-0.191599831,
0.4284747243,
-0.5501951575,
0.3356798589,
0.3637722731,
-0.6199426651,
-0.2529310584,
0.1794426888,
-0.7777577043,
-0.4586998224,
-0.2111734599,
0.29202649,
-0.2147943079,
-0.3215388954,
-0.0728111044,
-0.3672929108,
0.2695816755,
0.1850988865,
-0.3487267494,
0.4640538394,
0.8731654882,
1.1143044233,
-0.2377624512,
0.0433820896,
-0.6643486023,
0.4666749835,
-0.4270856977,
0.555891037,
-0.5066819191,
-0.328561008,
0.1913288832,
-0.1783791184,
0.2074270695,
-0.9663463831,
0.7810532451,
-0.8671167493,
-0.0503485836,
0.052634161,
-0.7152042389,
0.1049646437,
0.1292084754,
-1.0510425568,
0.9199782014,
0.111111477,
-0.7056800723,
0.2216705382,
-0.8511524796,
-0.2163447738,
0.363569051,
-0.1290508658,
-0.2979398668,
0.3896655142,
-0.0876544639,
0.4787842929,
-0.534463644,
-0.1652914435,
-0.4336746037,
-0.1682719439,
0.0203475002,
0.1379819661,
0.7936986685,
0.4752948284,
-0.1055481657,
-0.0814543813,
-0.7823211551,
0.2655124664,
0.3398682773,
-0.4878397882,
-0.8410258293,
0.12345355,
-0.0369455218,
-0.2236064672,
0.4446205497,
-0.5547601581,
0.053548798,
-0.2936324775,
-0.1474557519,
0.6194776893,
-0.1678403914,
0.5664186478,
-0.1495451927,
0.4974034429,
-0.1484627575,
-0.1054456532,
-0.0769654289,
-0.3714884222,
-0.5683427453,
-0.5549238324,
0.3102198541,
0.5683760047,
-0.4578659832,
0.2457757145,
-0.2338196784,
-0.608079493,
-0.4721913934,
0.1067411751,
0.2986831665,
0.3090307713,
0.3643203378,
-0.3677526712,
-0.6548935771,
-0.9786219597,
-0.5532489419,
0.1512654275,
-0.3658269346,
0.4349958003,
0.3209325373,
-0.2174349427,
1.0666987896,
-0.5003159642,
-0.2364310622,
-0.2821608782,
0.1580814272,
0.3304985464,
0.1510605961,
0.5145143867,
-0.5016875863,
-0.5555474162,
0.1995761544,
-0.7025330067,
-0.2331968248,
0.4804346561,
0.1747011244,
0.592438519,
0.4096371233,
-0.3819532096,
0.4306662083,
0.6676191688,
-0.2409541309,
0.7517077923,
-0.2838998735,
0.0779779181,
-0.9681551456,
0.3836597502,
0.0956015214,
-0.4029483199,
-0.5831259489,
0.2815300226,
0.1603639722,
-0.0540037826,
-0.485070169,
0.5221081376,
-0.7414292693,
-0.6892706752,
-0.157665208,
0.5221045613,
-0.1613081843,
-0.0469824895,
-0.1073927879,
0.9408168793,
0.1706329286,
-0.7460163832,
0.2306018472,
0.1547000855,
-0.6205865741,
0.7674567103,
-0.662766695,
0.0960554481,
-0.1429847628,
0.0044018701,
-0.4906771183,
-0.1510532796,
-0.0271195415,
-0.2705800235,
0.2430902719,
-0.0578151308,
-0.6157509089,
-0.1407282948,
-0.2104127556,
-0.1428836733,
0.6413139105,
-0.5453870296,
0.472360462,
0.4795162976,
-0.2924252748,
-0.5867675543,
-0.8059202433,
0.2005848289,
-0.2363887131,
-0.7127327919,
0.3092442751,
0.1597850174,
-0.7724466324,
0.3581255376,
0.006835612,
-0.148822546,
0.1072028801,
-0.130369857,
0.0823458284,
-0.5038753748,
-0.0316868424,
-0.2759074569,
0.298401624,
-0.069097124,
-0.2310468704,
0.3795933723,
-0.2007633895,
-0.4489409029,
0.0772099495,
0.2932921648,
0.4527259171,
-0.4309850037,
1.2090890408,
0.403765589,
-0.3247851729,
-0.5042620897,
-0.6035853624,
0.2021313012,
-0.4576645195,
0.3074149787,
-0.1296791583,
-0.8784815073,
0.3558439314,
-0.360868603,
0.2234882712,
0.4657335281,
0.5761358142,
-0.1700638831,
0.6731894612,
0.7761576176,
-0.0687198415,
0.4415400028,
-0.1481156796,
0.159174636,
-0.9207436442,
-0.1340233535,
-0.9820162654,
-0.2801376581,
-0.6170043945,
-0.6500224471,
0.269190371,
0.3010839522,
-0.3888951838,
0.0839230642,
-0.2156202793,
0.5012012124,
0.3838265836,
-0.2124331146,
0.593742013,
0.1187493354,
-0.1860071868,
0.1313842088,
-0.4398868084,
-0.8568361998,
0.9572387934,
0.5052061081,
0.9246126413,
0.4479667842,
0.5595461726,
0.3469493389,
0.378085047,
-0.5773938298,
0.5034615397,
-0.5916518569,
-0.5753415823,
-0.4662279189,
-0.5428230166,
-0.9897233248,
0.1257539988,
-0.0456092693,
-0.9242901206,
-0.026208885,
-0.1861548275,
0.2179639041,
0.7092937827,
-0.4931088984,
0.4813252687,
-0.2759691477,
-0.3745844364,
-0.2517926693,
-0.0887742862,
0.3327830732,
-0.2886280119,
0.2999795377,
0.1060888395,
-0.4897284806,
0.6700391173,
-0.1982939988,
0.468126595,
-0.2258649766,
-0.1090105921,
0.2204921544,
0.0940760598,
0.6482611299,
-0.3384738266,
-0.3533371091,
0.3598379791,
-0.4265445769,
-0.1311515719,
-0.4620100558,
0.8316408992,
-0.3819634914,
-0.4716766179,
-0.2302898765,
-0.2336587608,
-0.3526836932,
0.3826536834,
-0.1393932253,
0.2428176701,
-0.5459184051,
0.7086126804,
0.8305158019,
-0.3798294365,
0.4280407727,
0.7395426035,
-0.5836589932,
-0.4808928072,
0.6524883509,
0.1232725754,
0.3102118075,
0.2853019536,
0.0926155671,
-0.2299175411,
-0.5595251918,
-0.3254364729,
0.3514600694,
-0.5634689927,
-0.2016781718,
-0.4459275007,
-0.0224627387,
-0.3104030192,
-0.2137258947,
-0.4931459725,
-0.5521317124,
-0.3007234633,
0.1165404171,
0.2326493263,
1.2325624228,
0.0060824612,
-0.0127646551,
-0.8444567919,
0.2683392465,
-0.221337676,
1.0466871262,
0.1029965505,
-0.139674589,
-0.6346735954,
-0.0649213195,
-0.2803591192,
-0.9982397556,
0.3500267863,
-0.1322189718,
0.8472800851,
0.1003853902,
-0.0825128928,
0.4380954802,
-0.6389582753,
0.968763411,
0.0869059488,
-0.7820351124,
0.3123341799,
-0.3575311303,
0.0577533245,
0.2403625101,
0.6929064989,
-0.2574042082,
-0.5112000704,
-0.4007743597,
-1.0614032745,
0.8216531873,
0.1248341575,
-0.2742250562,
0.1411049366,
0.1165793091,
-0.0898854584,
0.2102281749,
-0.2932586372,
-0.450978905,
0.3070416749,
-0.149282217,
-0.1183453649,
-0.305513531,
0.0747242793,
0.3085752726,
0.7721726298,
0.1712213606,
0.2737715542,
0.0519999713,
-0.1779353321,
-0.176145643,
0.3939290345,
0.3152587712,
0.7868180871,
-0.2805249989,
-0.2604510784,
0.2229139805,
-0.4923546314,
-0.0254145134,
-0.2507362664,
-0.0931896791,
0.3317856193,
-0.0928174555,
0.5219093561,
0.1302586049,
-0.692617774,
0.2314064503,
0.0533256121,
0.0785702541,
-0.3184179664,
-0.1376952678,
0.3661141098,
0.4864464104,
0.4396164119,
-0.421621412,
0.1758650839,
-0.4078235924,
0.0305761136,
0.7096205354,
0.1108624339,
0.0869551897,
0.5464918613,
-0.0018904143,
-0.6554434299,
0.4941280782,
0.1839853376,
-0.056845881,
0.4100916684,
0.6974726319,
1.2034363747,
-0.3718081713,
-0.1061001569,
0.3088635206,
0.4186780751,
-0.0556263067,
0.1965330541,
0.2541790009,
-0.3802111745,
-0.5461447835,
-0.8392521739,
-0.876126349,
0.2790972888,
-0.8242458701,
0.376660794,
-0.2964969575,
-0.3091373444,
-0.1946332753,
-0.2031043023,
-0.6821160316,
-0.0294982959,
-0.0940484926,
1.3973113298,
-0.307294637,
0.4825748801,
0.9551811218,
-0.4868342876,
-0.5991322398,
0.0251860823,
-0.3577915132,
-0.4802050591,
0.7604256868,
-0.3197877109,
-0.2311598063,
-0.227832526,
-0.3165867925,
-0.9999381304,
1.1562650204,
0.3382787108,
-0.5061690807,
-0.1252480745,
0.3601851463,
0.5832098722,
-0.2017893344,
0.3080838621,
0.4205575883,
0.5161101818,
-0.2008071393,
-1.2075431347,
-0.1896393895,
0.1713223606,
0.0815536305,
0.4152927697,
-0.5225695968,
0.7167403698,
0.1587921083,
-0.2765261531,
0.041302409,
0.5903918743,
0.1945925951,
0.3885138929,
0.2571875453,
0.8133954406,
0.6895102262,
0.2022458762,
1.0602720976,
-0.2590083778,
0.4182062745,
1.2261337042,
-0.4156794548,
1.3543883562,
0.401984781,
-0.2690845132,
0.6279685497,
-0.1812250912,
0.1077781618,
0.2706301212,
0.1942195594,
-0.2067030668,
0.3909022212,
0.020403672,
-0.2507757246,
0.3124468625,
0.4305737019,
-0.6533645988,
-0.3901564479,
-0.2353594005,
0.0294686891,
0.0425517783,
-0.4918810129,
0.9483367801,
0.1675709635,
-0.4507375956,
0.3099398613,
0.3511829376,
0.6751331091,
-0.7017170787,
0.157288298,
-0.1285928041,
0.2767961025,
-0.4095050991,
-0.9141395688,
0.7520697713,
0.6018198133,
-0.1843779981,
-0.3363172412,
0.843821466,
-0.0885801762,
-0.0497187972,
0.3881557882,
0.6765118837,
0.2802565694,
0.0691387802,
-0.3810667098,
0.2665657997,
-0.3375853896,
-0.595731616,
0.5123397112,
0.4317047298,
0.0840616301,
0.5291634798,
0.447748512,
0.4058155119,
0.1692385972,
-0.1478366256,
0.6910141706,
-0.6520967484,
-0.2883366942,
-0.6300906539,
0.5316896439,
-0.1880927682,
0.2835793793,
1.0510823727,
0.8249821067,
0.884745121,
-0.22963579,
0.8029321432,
-0.1798903793,
1.0118159056,
-0.4249156713,
0.7850738764,
-0.6670203805,
0.3699333966,
-0.4122668803,
-1.0609494448,
-0.1264442354,
0.3237484992,
-0.2631178796,
-0.0291889887,
0.6284483075,
0.7457059622,
-0.1328199655,
0.000468239,
0.3917461932,
0.2771327496,
0.2589380741,
-0.1293772012,
0.718087554,
0.0267055333,
0.3977445364,
-0.0293761082,
-0.2263840288,
-0.2985280454,
-1.1708375216,
-0.3658305109,
-0.4899727106,
0.0125674699,
-0.3216408193,
0.0135405529,
0.6547345519,
0.1347926408,
-0.6214522719,
-0.45873788,
0.1085239202,
0.0654869154,
0.05350288,
-0.2926670015,
0.0813946202,
-0.6290569305,
-0.7808789611,
0.5452615023,
0.3093767464,
-0.2289260775,
-0.5682829022,
-0.1253941357,
-0.1556016207,
0.3328139782,
0.7307227254,
0.1643311679,
-0.5753757358,
0.0659322813,
0.2102903724,
-0.2496377528,
-0.0748320222,
0.8798282743,
-0.7376496792,
0.1499772817,
0.6263199449,
0.8118060827,
0.2676938772,
0.0960138887,
0.3678582907,
-0.6827045083,
-0.2020599544,
0.4234479964,
0.3910981417,
0.206082806,
-0.2165057808,
0.7561055422,
-0.141549319,
-0.8493516445,
-1.0049341917,
0.07060536,
-0.6303150058,
-0.3759443164,
1.2646160126,
-0.1716908067,
-0.2315312177,
-0.0210008249,
0.0082678972,
0.0829614028,
-0.2158539444,
0.2021245807,
0.4748454094,
-0.1750942022,
0.2222791016,
-0.5737128258,
0.1649829,
-0.0655604601,
-0.8469609022,
0.0042085373,
0.6159812212,
0.3164582551,
0.2527304292,
0.5603803992,
-0.3239457905,
-0.0450252146,
-0.1329344511,
0.1252267808,
-0.1096161678,
-0.1677485257,
-0.4710509181,
0.371747613,
0.3565797806,
-0.0271649547
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11423v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11423v1 | Dredge Word, Social Media, and Webgraph Networks for Unreliable Website Classification and Identification | 2024-06-17T11:22:04 | 2024-06-17T11:22:04 | Evan M. Williams, Peter Carragher, Kathleen M. Carley | cs.SI | cs.SI, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG | In an attempt to mimic the complex paths through which unreliable content
spreads between search engines and social media, we explore the impact of
incorporating both webgraph and large-scale social media contexts into website
credibility classification and discovery systems. We further explore the usage
of what we define as \textit{dredge words} on social media -- terms or phrases
for which unreliable domains rank highly. Through comprehensive graph neural
network ablations, we demonstrate that curriculum-based heterogeneous graph
models that leverage context from both webgraphs and social media data
outperform homogeneous and single-mode approaches. We further demonstrate that
the incorporation of dredge words into our model strongly associates unreliable
websites with social media and online commerce platforms. Finally, we show our
heterogeneous model greatly outperforms competing systems in the top-k
identification of unlabeled unreliable websites. We demonstrate the strong
unreliability signals present in the diverse paths that users follow to uncover
unreliable content, and we release a novel dataset of dredge words. | [
-0.1641031206,
-1.3201146126,
0.4464049041,
0.2036241293,
-0.2873100936,
0.7271360159,
0.0213905219,
-0.6370175481,
0.4912280738,
0.0593529008,
-0.5084827542,
-0.3524248004,
-0.8893897533,
-0.1987059712,
-0.6184718013,
0.7227891088,
-0.0895106345,
-0.0425983779,
-0.0880464837,
-0.1958255172,
-0.2535759211,
-0.2203359455,
-0.7447094321,
-0.2998446524,
0.8063877821,
0.1264769435,
1.1203272343,
0.841435194,
0.6154767871,
0.423769474,
0.107552208,
0.3184131086,
-0.8269814849,
0.1142312288,
-0.6935327053,
0.1356107742,
-0.214470759,
0.2834819257,
0.3966664672,
0.9936752915,
-0.2672773004,
0.3084262908,
0.2743692398,
0.1837873012,
-0.7551785707,
0.2693126202,
-0.7544196844,
-0.1560980529,
-0.3151854873,
-0.376409471,
-0.3169022799,
-0.4189954996,
-0.0126804803,
-0.6875701547,
0.2565762699,
0.0105479881,
1.1065833569,
0.1176071689,
-0.341612041,
-0.448669225,
-0.761074245,
0.6879416108,
-0.2557581663,
0.2963718176,
0.4492202699,
0.3480882347,
-0.355337441,
-1.5065295696,
-0.4189240932,
0.2303560376,
-0.1183901727,
0.2047368437,
-0.2699078619,
-0.0232209526,
-0.0821110085,
0.1262011081,
-0.2295057774,
0.3132997453,
-0.5133853555,
-0.6945540905,
0.6593755484,
0.1601915807,
0.4490127563,
-0.2997585535,
-0.3544304967,
-0.0024579188,
-0.3227775991,
-0.1561508775,
0.7039845586,
0.7487385273,
0.117624335,
0.3956589997,
0.0271744933,
0.628882587,
0.0332840309,
-0.3425842524,
0.2729363441,
0.0136593292,
-0.0332792066,
0.2247890383,
0.7762107253,
0.4316130877,
-0.094556801,
-0.3520000577,
-0.2354699224,
0.3295443654,
0.5779802799,
-0.3343482912,
-0.4222297072,
0.2097118795,
-0.6430792809,
-0.4565024078,
0.3506017923,
-0.7912767529,
-0.6359803081,
-0.0951049402,
0.6917816997,
-0.3029562533,
-0.4751380086,
-0.3197026253,
-0.8147928715,
-0.509275794,
0.259377718,
-0.2027359307,
0.2551265955,
0.5935407877,
1.0743538141,
0.0371421166,
-0.5239005685,
-0.4931561053,
-0.0776036605,
-0.3342039287,
0.64743644,
-0.5912280083,
-0.0248773731,
0.5462667346,
0.3702991009,
0.0593613833,
-0.1688945144,
0.5555599928,
-0.9564929008,
-0.1202324033,
-0.086789012,
-0.5436493754,
-0.3719629645,
0.0837482139,
-0.9887858629,
0.7213493586,
0.3631080389,
-0.9447521567,
0.2700401843,
-0.2966744304,
-0.7393148541,
0.4132356346,
0.0523983426,
-0.2470718473,
0.131366685,
-0.6295412183,
0.5003826618,
0.0342968926,
0.0184226185,
-0.8624894023,
-0.5990662575,
0.209151119,
-0.6289783716,
0.9933784008,
0.3424310386,
-0.4917337298,
-0.3634180427,
-0.6878836155,
0.1024708301,
0.5569363832,
-0.3132393956,
-0.6751252413,
0.2474128008,
0.1235397235,
0.1232329607,
0.3509694934,
-0.4280988872,
-0.0862997621,
0.1839858294,
0.7227558494,
0.9872247577,
0.2303594947,
0.0313440338,
-0.3294791579,
0.2500846684,
0.0038508009,
-0.0861818194,
0.3354786038,
-0.4874788225,
-0.4180721343,
-0.095959574,
0.3845982552,
0.3613309264,
-0.9086762667,
-0.0509741604,
-0.611299932,
-0.7135161161,
-0.3758204877,
0.0170266535,
0.2034865618,
0.5920744538,
0.5332484245,
-0.478815794,
-0.2819183171,
-0.6438959837,
-0.3225350678,
-0.2096233219,
0.2088901103,
0.4665776193,
0.2336588055,
-0.4044881165,
0.6213448644,
-0.3370306492,
-0.285056591,
-0.0725365877,
0.5487781167,
0.0669764876,
-0.0628491417,
0.3243964314,
-1.0377552509,
-0.534717977,
-0.3553769588,
-0.7919527292,
0.1305229217,
0.0733695179,
0.1325035095,
-0.0594542623,
0.2887153625,
-0.1833108366,
0.2957834005,
0.5032162666,
-0.239207387,
0.4285285771,
-0.1063000932,
0.0983807445,
-0.708224237,
-0.2590081692,
0.3277830184,
-0.2319350392,
-0.4907066524,
0.1360678077,
-0.018400332,
0.1306461543,
-0.3487323225,
0.2496516556,
-0.5633190274,
0.0008802853,
-0.3733979166,
0.6748799682,
0.0057199411,
0.0776310191,
-0.1957772225,
0.4657119513,
0.6646095514,
-0.693667233,
0.614444077,
0.1940151155,
-0.0972925648,
0.5483742356,
-0.5125066638,
0.1616805494,
-0.1809400916,
0.2534090579,
-1.1324117184,
-0.5050994754,
0.2223539799,
-0.384649992,
0.4304294288,
-0.4361768663,
-0.4950453639,
-0.6867725253,
-0.2420305014,
0.0304234065,
0.3345162272,
-0.4937767684,
0.5680269003,
0.8770682216,
-0.008748645,
-0.8536621928,
-0.5650346875,
0.2119397223,
-0.0946270004,
-0.5626180172,
0.4556409717,
0.224941954,
-0.4928429723,
0.2987007797,
-0.1342232525,
-0.4570013285,
0.3947958052,
0.5809025168,
0.1304547489,
0.0420804285,
0.238878265,
0.0448463932,
0.219179973,
0.0949628428,
-0.3550044894,
0.625282526,
-0.0013957651,
-0.2757692933,
-0.4168341756,
0.137594074,
0.5953021049,
0.1684700698,
0.7887291312,
0.7715120912,
-0.5282164812,
-0.2599896491,
-0.4141641259,
-0.2247856259,
-0.5574108362,
0.2072813511,
-0.1112698689,
-0.6218257546,
0.4897067845,
-0.3058416247,
-0.0471342094,
0.7190287113,
0.2165849656,
-0.1795237064,
1.0573667288,
0.6707856059,
-0.3108697832,
0.1417220384,
-0.1546022147,
0.3046849966,
-0.2997336686,
0.1017282531,
-0.4022296965,
-0.521671474,
-1.0336393118,
0.0567997284,
-0.0533019863,
0.1504282355,
-0.2615263164,
0.4650530517,
-0.656644702,
0.0595821217,
0.5699903369,
0.4131806493,
0.2866207063,
0.4221843779,
-0.3940447569,
0.1073211953,
-0.8778262138,
-0.682880342,
0.8242276907,
0.4755995274,
0.6958581805,
0.1563044488,
0.4085405469,
0.8551835418,
0.546841085,
-0.6937929392,
0.3573782444,
-0.3193604946,
-0.8018396497,
-0.4173494875,
-0.4674789608,
-0.9492818713,
-0.2888864577,
-0.2763997018,
-0.7533780336,
0.1323025823,
0.1319748759,
-0.3083941936,
0.5577473044,
-0.4194077849,
0.5497846007,
-0.251816839,
-0.9438080788,
-0.1539025009,
-0.7759751678,
0.0844964758,
-0.0363051444,
0.6892390847,
-0.027571436,
0.1866025031,
0.727039516,
-0.4065453708,
1.0372972488,
-0.1370783299,
0.1720442921,
0.7375121713,
0.159426406,
0.6961293817,
-0.0442757159,
0.0577381626,
0.6013187766,
-0.2017177492,
-0.4184879959,
-0.1381747872,
0.8645874858,
-0.9109618664,
-0.1265123039,
-0.5385713577,
-0.0782502294,
-0.1805365384,
0.628847599,
0.4551910162,
0.5836504698,
-0.1110831127,
0.0152517706,
0.4438409209,
0.1548815221,
0.578058362,
0.2349470407,
0.1774403602,
-0.2725582719,
1.2561146021,
0.458286792,
0.1501625478,
-0.1303950399,
0.0153398141,
-0.251922965,
-0.5894316435,
-0.4358550608,
0.2817836106,
-0.9713375568,
-0.272305429,
-0.7564992905,
-0.4847648144,
-0.3510924876,
-0.0616882145,
-0.400180608,
-0.3493041396,
-0.3471778631,
-0.3151169419,
0.1927585602,
0.9477235079,
-0.3032110035,
0.288056761,
-0.8300547004,
0.1479118466,
0.2253611684,
0.6048571467,
0.0156621505,
-0.3963600099,
-0.1075299755,
0.3412013054,
-0.2471984327,
-1.0411285162,
0.0484924465,
-0.0180677287,
0.7142296433,
0.6944491863,
0.134366408,
0.5901756287,
-0.5120208263,
0.6730127335,
0.2597976327,
-0.5922986865,
-0.0241380297,
-0.4961424172,
-0.4851002693,
0.6403079033,
1.1289926767,
-0.5075888038,
-0.327205956,
-0.8458154202,
-1.1447066069,
0.2787075341,
-0.0497202165,
0.3716359138,
-0.2654747069,
0.434145093,
-0.1457382143,
0.4405885339,
-0.5782630444,
-0.6220521331,
-0.6937943101,
-0.1142399907,
0.1292350739,
-0.4303434491,
-0.2901057303,
0.2739755213,
0.7467936277,
-0.0939270556,
0.2324976623,
-0.0200963877,
-0.2946096659,
-0.3878669143,
-0.2182595879,
0.114068225,
0.9980184436,
-0.1651484221,
0.5449315906,
-0.1707589477,
-0.7064703107,
0.0681059733,
0.3232347369,
-0.0383631252,
0.2441621125,
0.4491359293,
0.3555028439,
0.1192169785,
-0.3687437773,
0.4015147686,
-0.0222427957,
-0.1036465093,
-0.5736258626,
-0.0855709687,
0.1167298108,
0.0637708008,
0.6185284853,
-0.2610741854,
0.3484618068,
-0.8127309084,
0.4467451572,
0.489475131,
-0.9800472856,
-0.1500477642,
0.5656624436,
0.0764363408,
-0.5660479069,
0.8646397591,
-0.4568501115,
-0.6888120174,
0.3319606483,
0.3877012432,
0.6756051183,
-0.1439714581,
0.4976273179,
0.4334768951,
0.2646842897,
-0.2862532139,
-0.0016406806,
0.5161190629,
-0.8991917968,
0.0316490345,
-0.6718197465,
-0.2331247777,
0.2667887509,
-0.489692688,
0.1815749258,
-0.6595740914,
-0.4748672247,
0.2860444784,
-0.0011520606,
-0.4228719473,
0.4301588833,
-0.0731840953,
0.5163066387,
-0.9870478511,
0.1790572852,
0.8446855545,
-0.7166596651,
-1.00960958,
-0.0572099201,
0.3777079284,
-0.6009145975,
0.4058072269,
0.1034981757,
-0.3925866783,
0.1848377138,
-0.6920987964,
-0.7371075749,
1.1623075008,
-0.4045102596,
-0.4065665007,
0.0690196976,
-0.0460596122,
0.4339977205,
-0.1964092255,
0.2332529426,
0.0783193335,
0.5723938942,
0.1392830312,
-0.7833611369,
0.2526198924,
-0.104479447,
-0.327013582,
0.0732557252,
-0.7365834713,
0.7838790417,
0.1344712079,
-0.5578003526,
-0.2227436304,
0.5260014534,
-0.1206963435,
0.5921552181,
0.7393583059,
0.4845403433,
0.8654331565,
-0.1676325053,
0.6704902053,
-0.3767414987,
0.6379557848,
1.0227421522,
-0.1003405079,
0.6663607359,
0.1428343654,
-0.0410220884,
0.8729557395,
0.7707213759,
-0.1798710078,
0.4429009855,
0.1479535699,
-0.0612169206,
-0.2317509502,
-0.1976023763,
-0.1317066103,
0.5812612176,
0.4380172491,
-0.515331924,
-0.44451648,
-0.2601129711,
0.1617320329,
0.0857462958,
-0.3915077448,
0.4733169377,
0.0522168912,
-0.2717696428,
0.3609932959,
0.2495792359,
0.3828362525,
-0.422598511,
-0.0879431441,
0.0576345585,
0.2727080584,
-0.3198651075,
-0.538336277,
0.1561502218,
-0.5018765926,
0.1141314954,
-0.0676952153,
1.2344536781,
-0.0120314695,
-0.5118504167,
0.4646545649,
0.6280800104,
0.0535696894,
-0.011537686,
-0.7659285665,
-0.0600422807,
-0.3529557884,
-0.1781726629,
0.2947444618,
0.3863478005,
0.0559475049,
0.7361498475,
0.6630619764,
-0.1081236228,
-0.005837061,
-0.0302152,
0.7896056771,
-0.4192958772,
-0.2808222771,
-0.6389248371,
0.4072857201,
-0.6583403349,
0.0259696469,
1.1496146917,
0.3822704852,
0.6920208931,
0.4692023098,
1.0722373724,
-0.284717679,
0.620565176,
-0.0029016251,
1.1187438965,
-0.7428020835,
0.0097738029,
-0.5896812677,
-0.6918532252,
-0.0624485239,
0.5412891507,
0.1090547293,
0.2227930427,
0.7597898245,
0.3630419075,
-0.3802906573,
-0.0709357709,
-0.0428760014,
0.3451003432,
0.0140287625,
-0.1442022175,
0.751380682,
-0.3525574803,
0.5141570568,
-0.5163750052,
-0.397562623,
-0.5551765561,
-0.8978149891,
-0.6225155592,
-0.4910286367,
-0.4894988537,
-1.2247256041,
0.1448973566,
0.5387226343,
0.3705205619,
-0.4650573432,
-0.0035633873,
-0.035056863,
0.563144207,
-0.32431373,
-0.3048501909,
0.3963208795,
-0.2488210648,
-0.4739493132,
0.1700342447,
0.3776126802,
0.027840903,
-0.4620830119,
0.28730762,
-0.355573982,
0.2598918974,
0.2945728302,
0.225778684,
-0.2307171226,
-0.5801770687,
0.1390284598,
-0.2544195354,
-0.1654602736,
0.4666356444,
-0.4248047769,
0.2615722716,
0.4843521714,
0.4170557559,
0.1255913377,
0.2451724857,
0.1269354373,
-0.2957425117,
-0.1400554627,
0.2073804885,
0.4594605565,
0.382817924,
-0.3676792383,
0.5420911312,
0.7567639351,
-0.4001586735,
-0.7820051908,
0.275085479,
-0.689817071,
-0.6340279579,
1.1722884178,
-0.3252809644,
-0.2524858415,
-0.6844314337,
0.5447255373,
0.3995747864,
-0.1477094293,
1.1960319281,
0.7741969824,
0.3660145104,
0.2852175236,
-0.5355140567,
0.2151373476,
-0.288475126,
-0.2604208291,
-0.2695288658,
0.8413877487,
0.5811537504,
0.8174025416,
0.4739288986,
0.093626298,
0.1042654291,
0.3400280476,
-0.4181413352,
-0.125343293,
-0.4381962717,
0.2724227607,
0.6926210523,
-0.0040914975,
0.135530889
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11418v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11418v1 | BAMBINO-LM: (Bilingual-)Human-Inspired Continual Pretraining of BabyLM | 2024-06-17T11:08:08 | 2024-06-17T11:08:08 | Zhewen Shen, Aditya Joshi, Ruey-Cheng Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Children from bilingual backgrounds benefit from interactions with parents
and teachers to re-acquire their heritage language. In this paper, we
investigate how this insight from behavioral study can be incorporated into the
learning of small-scale language models. We introduce BAMBINO-LM, a continual
pretraining strategy for BabyLM that uses a novel combination of alternation
and PPO-based perplexity reward induced from a parent Italian model. Upon
evaluation on zero-shot classification tasks for English and Italian,
BAMBINO-LM improves the Italian language capability of a BabyLM baseline. Our
ablation analysis demonstrates that employing both the alternation strategy and
PPO-based modeling is key to this effectiveness gain. We also show that, as a
side effect, the proposed method leads to similar degradation in L1
effectiveness as human children would have had in an equivalent learning
scenario. | [
-0.2162090242,
-0.7568712831,
-0.0058476627,
0.0996571779,
-0.4579376876,
0.3965837657,
-0.1864264607,
-0.4719753861,
0.1200968847,
0.3097792566,
-0.580286324,
-0.0958262905,
-0.5211409926,
0.0280309971,
0.098910749,
1.2290837765,
0.0866039172,
0.3071939945,
0.4029137492,
0.0780625641,
-0.2485805005,
-0.602357626,
-0.822820127,
-0.4818144143,
1.1672006845,
0.7625186443,
0.494689852,
0.4726160169,
0.1020832136,
0.1986639351,
-0.1542113572,
0.1070365906,
-0.8642801642,
-0.1454306841,
-0.1950361133,
-0.6703915596,
-0.4768746495,
0.1270540059,
0.7762656212,
1.0171138048,
-0.4631912708,
0.0035551139,
0.1642876267,
0.5734729767,
-0.6592465043,
-0.1640624106,
-0.7736338377,
0.1805831939,
-0.2417651266,
-0.0843554735,
-0.4321497083,
-0.3200198114,
-0.0515389256,
-0.1970055252,
0.093299672,
-0.1213746667,
0.9369602203,
-0.0156352445,
-0.3302494586,
-0.2517569065,
-0.8735281229,
0.6866954565,
-0.6860517263,
0.4134371579,
0.4478959739,
-0.0651593804,
-0.3636268675,
-0.2563431561,
-0.7566043139,
-0.526230216,
-0.2763459682,
-0.0131189199,
0.3306251764,
-0.0724321157,
0.0511563309,
0.2155873477,
-0.4946911633,
0.4616546631,
-0.4738874137,
-0.1249622852,
0.471000582,
0.1128550991,
0.2757969797,
0.0777622014,
-0.0338497497,
0.1338018775,
-1.0907703638,
0.3230237961,
0.6122565269,
0.4781266451,
-0.1190573275,
0.4125793576,
0.0679334924,
0.7965630889,
0.2278539091,
-0.4356624186,
0.213136211,
-0.1223216429,
0.0215514302,
-0.0348293707,
0.5782439113,
-0.3620687723,
0.0456973724,
-0.5703977942,
-0.2719880044,
-0.1579979658,
0.2275731564,
-0.7967532277,
0.1214535087,
-0.1683567166,
-0.1176849529,
-0.3108313084,
0.0310040843,
-0.7559390068,
-0.0133672515,
-0.3609197438,
0.5351212025,
-0.6061217785,
-0.3224789202,
0.0752032623,
0.3317008018,
0.4142501354,
0.0440649651,
-1.4328057766,
-0.0934074223,
0.6969432235,
0.7355414033,
-0.1483582854,
-0.4723435342,
-0.3807585239,
0.2559298575,
-0.4634764791,
0.8075431585,
-0.4712955654,
-0.9108248949,
-0.1274358332,
0.0179827809,
-0.2850867808,
-0.7704671025,
0.1908164024,
-0.4901569784,
0.2283123285,
-0.0566767454,
-0.1841618866,
0.0541897304,
0.3697693646,
-0.4616639614,
0.5611712337,
0.2401641011,
-0.6030490398,
0.7721582651,
-0.5276143551,
-0.6847193241,
0.0906296,
0.0196766593,
-0.6023818851,
0.416572541,
-0.2984439433,
-0.030356152,
-0.0403862186,
0.0863327309,
-0.0962366611,
-0.424062103,
0.0074593029,
-0.3246562183,
1.116841197,
0.0580579229,
-0.4376387894,
-0.0530409627,
-0.7514492869,
-0.2459845543,
0.3075361252,
-0.6410690546,
-0.1297139525,
-0.1008635685,
-0.4505682588,
0.2322795987,
0.2148507982,
-0.4429795444,
0.4374332428,
-0.5442617536,
-0.0038098947,
0.5172975659,
0.0176484268,
0.297977984,
-0.4723055363,
0.7925480604,
0.1179322824,
0.3191588223,
-0.3394541144,
-0.1796477437,
-1.0378553867,
-0.5768370628,
0.467356354,
0.6121165752,
-0.7208236456,
0.6200405955,
-0.1624741256,
-0.4437811077,
-0.5329672098,
0.4292117357,
0.5473509431,
0.6021945477,
0.2393073291,
-0.7596557736,
-0.4373084307,
-0.7724406123,
0.141376853,
-0.2225042135,
0.0363300331,
0.0176789258,
0.5304725766,
-0.5047982335,
0.7341151834,
0.1104852706,
-0.0854545683,
-0.3609367311,
0.6064704061,
0.3324125707,
0.7151930332,
0.6239446998,
-0.4712985754,
-0.6041944623,
0.104692705,
-0.3739250898,
0.155714646,
-0.0819649324,
-0.3206324577,
0.3873486221,
0.1424835473,
-0.4072143137,
0.3714674413,
0.4731716514,
-0.2941316962,
0.9047371745,
-0.422142446,
0.0620423742,
-0.4838924706,
0.0682731271,
-0.6047073007,
-0.092782259,
-0.8453682065,
-0.0133790458,
-0.0959989503,
0.0326554663,
-0.6933623552,
0.6400458813,
-0.3749232888,
0.1316157579,
-0.3061619401,
-0.2423091233,
-0.2828961909,
0.5908205509,
0.1329049319,
0.6247597933,
0.5028344393,
-0.5666292906,
0.1496926993,
-0.1416607946,
-0.1570820808,
0.6524722576,
-0.5278713703,
0.4506515563,
-0.1867201924,
0.0477437451,
-0.7036222816,
0.0505799465,
0.4307898879,
-0.4198961258,
0.8123649955,
0.0021963683,
-0.7155692577,
-0.2704491615,
0.0036401376,
0.3298882842,
0.5338262916,
-0.4789389968,
0.4835574329,
0.1476570517,
-0.2625062466,
-0.2534377575,
-0.4980479181,
0.0085595157,
-0.3336699009,
-0.1435084045,
0.1297995001,
-0.16120103,
-0.0016078157,
-0.1540000141,
0.0478797965,
-0.097000204,
0.253349185,
-0.2597351074,
0.4374912679,
-0.1675160378,
0.1484161019,
-0.007266134,
-0.1911222637,
-0.2543767393,
-0.3439452052,
0.7891277075,
-0.0919767544,
-0.1241749525,
-0.2896113098,
0.290840894,
0.2777039409,
-0.2252586931,
1.1958171129,
0.4159756303,
-0.1158244535,
-0.0460987501,
-0.3716961145,
-0.2068196088,
-0.417719692,
0.0688547567,
-0.4211841226,
-0.6055250764,
0.2823624015,
0.0585154444,
-0.0143991541,
-0.0550389215,
0.7931870818,
-0.4978453517,
0.7093747854,
0.8835213184,
-0.1157421991,
0.7951399088,
-0.4242763519,
0.0526454225,
-0.7433927059,
-0.405433923,
-0.4214849174,
-0.3466280401,
-0.4275097847,
-0.3735687137,
0.1787740439,
0.4212514162,
-0.5006375313,
0.2709318399,
-0.0073103188,
0.2639684379,
0.4452976584,
0.4748876393,
0.4388516545,
0.0386514403,
-0.3584957123,
-0.0198145676,
-0.8818125129,
-0.4237061441,
1.12854743,
0.0065774973,
0.604922235,
0.206619218,
0.9841193557,
-0.188360393,
1.0884437561,
-0.745608449,
0.4138250351,
-0.0587468892,
-0.9620761275,
-0.4740658998,
-0.4157118499,
-1.2853919268,
0.4344341457,
-0.3153273761,
-0.9568543434,
0.2569318414,
0.4595994949,
-0.341226697,
0.0445969552,
-0.5560926795,
0.936894834,
-1.0388364792,
-0.8221758604,
-0.3298933804,
-0.5134968758,
0.2109789699,
-0.4564005435,
0.2543596029,
0.0648678243,
-0.1323316097,
0.3791414201,
-0.342870146,
0.7874280214,
-0.1732801199,
-0.234872669,
0.124983862,
0.2712460756,
0.229684338,
-0.012478957,
-0.1915988624,
0.2575038373,
-0.4071215987,
-0.8959117532,
-0.5801786184,
0.3209320605,
-0.5627359152,
-0.8603428602,
-0.3312420845,
-0.4295608401,
-0.545576334,
0.3611481786,
0.3515266478,
0.0215894673,
-0.1511688679,
0.3028634787,
0.5608227849,
-0.1953549683,
0.1876232475,
0.9915569425,
-0.3373910487,
-0.1758372337,
0.7235891223,
-0.0237836745,
0.4942638278,
0.3085383177,
0.2790979743,
-0.0049991719,
-0.5245615244,
-0.2556193769,
0.7647647262,
-0.1765105426,
0.1512420028,
-0.2093015164,
0.0315679945,
-0.2003216743,
-0.3565152586,
-0.4248419702,
0.1090949401,
-0.2328650504,
-0.2209630758,
-0.4221602082,
0.3730761111,
-0.4051161408,
0.464160949,
-0.6402249932,
0.2332283258,
0.5428804755,
0.2702625096,
0.039743796,
-0.9385610819,
-0.5927401781,
0.3434261978,
-0.4450531006,
-0.8450340033,
0.4152285457,
0.0736927241,
0.8055164814,
0.755802393,
-0.3796491325,
0.8834673762,
-0.6717458367,
0.5175719261,
0.5141493678,
-0.8365986943,
0.5617681742,
-0.3168430626,
0.2725257576,
0.6666125059,
0.7297968864,
-0.2792393863,
-0.2320635617,
-0.658631146,
-0.6763980389,
0.7498518229,
0.0184894837,
0.2094953358,
0.0720142871,
0.2268902063,
0.2123246789,
0.4286590517,
-0.8724877238,
0.0137511585,
-0.1022531465,
-0.0412231162,
-0.3530902863,
-0.3668832779,
-0.1210742965,
-0.6169329286,
0.7074223161,
0.1210101172,
0.0602031462,
-0.1058315858,
-0.381170541,
-0.1588958353,
0.1287946999,
0.3771685362,
0.7548694611,
-0.129463017,
-0.2332200855,
0.2432605475,
-0.1911784112,
0.4506459534,
-0.1008674726,
-0.2968794107,
-0.0444791839,
0.6405471563,
0.8302205205,
0.6228274107,
-0.6295791864,
0.0121384421,
0.2192031443,
0.0448187217,
-0.1180801615,
0.1371208727,
0.115295589,
-0.0182287749,
0.2614496946,
-0.5651894808,
-0.1289974004,
-1.2844092846,
0.146169275,
0.4884824753,
-0.3084222674,
-0.5668138266,
0.3426644206,
0.2469463795,
-0.6402148604,
0.5746164322,
-0.3704518676,
-0.6911844611,
0.6187597513,
0.5744277239,
0.6079415679,
-0.6858298182,
0.376971513,
0.3862458169,
0.2876809835,
0.1232250333,
-0.0668480471,
-0.4621497393,
-1.0600612164,
-0.1611539721,
-0.7135154009,
-0.4696699083,
0.0901035443,
-0.6231966019,
0.422078222,
-0.3374416232,
0.0645091608,
-0.2305623889,
0.0023013763,
-0.7520344853,
0.2037539333,
0.3822358847,
0.3633008897,
-0.6792894602,
1.219837904,
0.668466866,
-0.5847175121,
-0.8503843546,
0.2033895701,
-0.178309083,
-0.657592237,
0.9623880386,
0.0174033679,
-0.3182509542,
0.1914589852,
-0.3086213768,
-0.5522492528,
0.7394255996,
0.3642039001,
-0.734038651,
-0.1276411861,
0.10052903,
0.7857758403,
-0.3890237808,
0.2194242477,
0.9685488343,
0.4126934409,
0.3595743775,
-0.8716964126,
-0.5949606299,
0.1354589164,
0.1047521532,
-0.1001468748,
-0.6502088308,
0.6108947992,
-0.5145848393,
-0.2457841784,
0.1150810942,
0.5189524293,
0.3550969064,
0.1657354534,
0.6853202581,
0.2807064354,
0.5685853362,
0.0448762104,
0.8651418686,
-0.3351899087,
0.4347567558,
1.0945023298,
-0.1988736689,
0.6919255853,
0.6136607528,
-0.330848664,
0.8749929667,
0.6788675785,
0.4085653424,
0.5487565398,
0.2486078739,
-0.4040914178,
-0.0712098852,
0.0805168748,
-0.097744517,
0.4123871624,
0.5142738223,
0.024451524,
-0.0954207703,
0.3536353111,
0.4757634103,
-0.0559488311,
-0.3663566411,
0.8139573336,
0.0417496413,
-0.7856833935,
0.8782643676,
-0.2998259068,
0.8044509292,
-0.8833028674,
0.2585071027,
-0.6933043599,
0.0516216755,
-0.0666179061,
-0.0016076394,
0.2840285599,
0.0995146334,
-0.0472707488,
-0.2462588549,
0.0310029108,
-0.7730857134,
-0.7434877157,
0.435164988,
0.349378705,
-0.0441314392,
0.5685412884,
-0.7323774099,
-0.184756279,
0.0058151302,
-0.413805753,
0.4001262188,
0.4641886353,
0.2107415646,
0.5077997446,
0.750831306,
0.7078752518,
0.1973802298,
-0.0730841607,
0.6858515143,
-0.5703475475,
-0.5260598063,
-0.6712779999,
0.6134889126,
0.2249134481,
-0.0939069912,
0.5531077385,
0.3695093393,
1.0448479652,
-0.2731905878,
0.4614707828,
-0.1751111597,
0.6085005403,
-0.4178503454,
0.6077671647,
-0.7735332251,
0.1868956536,
0.078399457,
-0.8154336214,
-0.2973689437,
0.8083978891,
-0.5730013251,
0.0477198362,
0.7826302052,
0.8152127266,
0.147406742,
-0.5356562734,
0.6608803868,
0.3931375742,
0.2519681454,
0.5193887353,
0.8675100207,
0.2586230934,
0.4461742043,
-0.3363954127,
-0.4617529809,
-0.3414955437,
-0.7732480764,
-0.7537788749,
-0.2433123887,
-0.0587299839,
-0.0268663019,
0.3559978008,
0.7795809507,
0.827850759,
-0.8863094449,
-0.46013394,
-0.0839753151,
0.1210944578,
-0.061112877,
-0.1412514895,
-0.0692370385,
-0.7161407471,
-0.9261502028,
0.2695311606,
0.3312602937,
0.0040145512,
-0.4772545397,
-0.1626999527,
-0.3698831797,
0.1953984946,
0.5176378489,
0.7129505873,
-0.3718987405,
-0.168468684,
-0.4814615846,
-0.1450032443,
0.0765382424,
1.1129835844,
-0.7023557425,
0.6001858711,
0.1093828827,
0.3976527154,
0.6941975951,
0.0064164479,
0.5069667101,
-0.3488830626,
0.9404502511,
0.4319515824,
0.3141155243,
0.2643993199,
-0.2751343548,
0.3490141332,
0.4394691288,
-0.2325300127,
-0.6631902456,
0.4329132736,
-0.3270668089,
-0.2668519914,
1.0547953844,
-0.4615749121,
-0.2428688854,
-0.0844567344,
-0.253537178,
0.2607344687,
-0.0287592672,
1.2277930975,
0.6747910976,
-0.1681017429,
-0.2949754,
-0.1399586052,
0.1396072358,
0.6855141521,
-0.8163310289,
-0.5497279763,
0.2720349431,
0.3314504027,
0.0627641007,
0.6444266438,
-0.2769312859,
0.3210417032,
-0.0218172465,
0.1757297665,
-0.0387312733,
-0.5270058513,
-0.4717015326,
-0.2426280826,
0.192171365,
-0.0055458434
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15486v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15486v2 | SampleAttention: Near-Lossless Acceleration of Long Context LLM Inference with Adaptive Structured Sparse Attention | 2024-06-17T11:05:15 | 2024-06-28T08:55:17 | Qianchao Zhu, Jiangfei Duan, Chang Chen, Siran Liu, Xiuhong Li, Guanyu Feng, Xin Lv, Huanqi Cao, Xiao Chuanfu, Xingcheng Zhang, Dahua Lin, Chao Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) now support extremely long context windows, but
the quadratic complexity of vanilla attention results in significantly long
Time-to-First-Token (TTFT) latency. Existing approaches to address this
complexity require additional pretraining or finetuning, and often sacrifice
model accuracy. In this paper, we first provide both theoretical and empirical
foundations for near-lossless sparse attention. We find dynamically capturing
head-specific sparse patterns at runtime with low overhead is crucial. To
address this, we propose SampleAttention, an adaptive structured and
near-lossless sparse attention. Leveraging observed significant sparse
patterns, SampleAttention attends to a fixed percentage of adjacent tokens to
capture local window patterns, and employs a two-stage query-guided key-value
filtering approach, which adaptively select a minimum set of key-values with
low overhead, to capture column stripe patterns. Comprehensive evaluations show
that SampleAttention can seamlessly replace vanilla attention in off-the-shelf
LLMs with nearly no accuracy loss, and reduces TTFT by up to $2.42\times$
compared with FlashAttention. | [
-0.0625510514,
-0.6973700523,
0.653595686,
0.4622285366,
-0.2596859038,
0.2126564234,
-0.3857572675,
-0.5223087072,
0.2084517926,
0.335577637,
-0.803876996,
-0.3686660826,
-0.3289674222,
-0.0548922084,
-0.4509217441,
0.8121398687,
-0.0019778092,
-0.3176536858,
-0.2253673971,
-0.3194769919,
-0.363846004,
-0.2378631383,
-0.6417094469,
0.1538192034,
0.6934461594,
0.4363221228,
0.1873396635,
0.6709573269,
0.0695789754,
0.3216115236,
-0.199059397,
0.2114746571,
-0.7955645323,
0.043474324,
-0.0729219466,
-0.4890926778,
-0.6182002425,
0.1594352871,
0.6897117496,
0.8543848395,
0.0024716679,
0.2621534169,
0.4019291401,
0.6132692099,
-0.7910314202,
-0.0481473841,
-0.6623052359,
-0.0291351303,
-0.2378571033,
-0.2199224532,
-0.3218487799,
-0.1189435571,
0.1404621452,
-0.7221006155,
0.5077773333,
0.3081753254,
0.5175613165,
0.3178370595,
-0.0425628461,
0.1380042881,
-0.5985831022,
1.1855642796,
-0.6149771214,
0.3792646825,
0.3307355344,
0.0544392988,
-0.4709676504,
-0.9174224138,
-0.4526196122,
-0.1469064057,
0.101663813,
0.0152074993,
-0.0993581265,
0.2520875037,
0.2631421685,
0.2435093671,
-0.5008218288,
0.1168463603,
-0.2527239323,
-0.2092516571,
0.2175212801,
-0.0031573533,
-0.2099990845,
0.2904995382,
-0.3087943494,
-0.0303896852,
-0.7492874861,
0.0100107035,
-0.0384221599,
0.396813333,
-0.2995963395,
0.0873196796,
-0.2611666918,
0.8790587187,
0.3528366685,
-0.2191449404,
-0.0271652862,
-0.3542589247,
-0.3991805315,
0.0519460812,
0.5531241298,
0.0878859386,
0.1412421018,
-0.4461335838,
-0.125250563,
-0.3485951424,
0.0952151269,
-1.028834939,
-0.1740597785,
0.5474371314,
-0.3220763803,
-0.2505162358,
-0.2697170675,
-0.8063630462,
-0.1892117709,
-0.1929743737,
0.0950814039,
-0.2564094067,
0.0962114409,
-0.1031748503,
0.0359927192,
0.3070613444,
0.4720439315,
-0.7915875912,
0.3693911731,
0.6283602118,
1.1214858294,
-0.6255390644,
-0.1914501339,
-0.8932765126,
0.0850851908,
-0.3203957081,
1.0671099424,
-0.3872810304,
-0.0297283735,
-0.223264575,
0.0423729718,
0.0490463302,
-0.5791561604,
0.3123701513,
-0.6349563599,
0.0692925155,
0.0446492806,
-0.50208354,
0.0636802912,
0.2290523499,
-0.5526736975,
1.20614779,
0.555254221,
-0.4082974195,
0.6077868342,
-0.5719077587,
-0.3359542191,
0.2007514983,
0.0083879596,
-0.2896212339,
0.3224361241,
0.1277655214,
0.5000770688,
-0.0560305305,
-0.1421021372,
-0.7114318013,
-0.7675617933,
0.1820251048,
-0.3703586757,
0.4734113514,
0.01514233,
-0.2642053962,
0.3120764196,
-1.1632225513,
-0.0065390114,
0.0408499204,
-0.2643117309,
-0.4574731886,
0.2662502825,
0.3370061219,
0.0540955588,
-0.0056465198,
-0.649872005,
-0.0390111841,
-0.6666611433,
0.5591042042,
0.9121851325,
-0.050886929,
0.6100190878,
-0.1311353892,
0.4316649139,
0.1042686626,
-0.2350785285,
-0.2314198166,
0.0444334894,
-0.6187717915,
-0.602778852,
0.3525804877,
0.1974384487,
-0.3297799528,
0.234347403,
-0.4175150394,
0.0137002245,
-0.4769327343,
0.3601571918,
0.2101078629,
0.4551387429,
0.2839893997,
-0.1303646564,
-0.5161736012,
-0.6780803204,
-0.1028777957,
0.0791197196,
-0.3333266079,
0.2243055403,
0.0703673139,
0.1638537645,
0.9802612662,
-0.5279321671,
-0.3859459758,
-0.1674158126,
0.0314434469,
0.2277345955,
0.4506076574,
0.6345044971,
-0.5347113609,
-0.2615312636,
-0.1861332357,
-0.0687372386,
-0.2565131783,
-0.137430355,
-0.1437400728,
0.2075149119,
0.7095974088,
-0.4172434509,
0.2272195667,
0.5135675073,
-0.0993764997,
0.1499888003,
-0.0845612958,
-0.2272524387,
-1.030821085,
0.0662450641,
-0.0695891082,
-0.6722267866,
-0.5879077911,
0.0248773955,
0.1291302741,
-0.0014919038,
-0.5730404258,
0.8062019348,
-0.5436402559,
-0.1126798689,
-0.6468093395,
0.3315496147,
0.1204344481,
0.7728888392,
0.0598367378,
1.0443682671,
0.0434363745,
-0.6823341846,
0.1715989858,
-0.1040103137,
-0.3685269654,
0.6499373317,
-0.6049434543,
0.4369878471,
-0.2612917721,
0.2181477547,
-1.370980382,
-0.2271334976,
0.0659995377,
-0.3376912475,
0.5098614097,
-0.0772985965,
-0.1577162445,
-0.1437101066,
-0.5585337877,
0.6193327904,
0.3984052241,
-0.4534654021,
0.5122992992,
0.1071345806,
-0.2026947141,
-0.4470542371,
-0.6669692993,
0.0399608985,
-0.1401761323,
-0.1692589968,
0.4174257815,
-0.08999715,
-0.0355071314,
-0.0857590139,
-0.3074930608,
-0.2371608466,
0.3141923249,
0.0986323208,
0.0515300781,
-0.4351621568,
0.104378283,
-0.0282505788,
-0.0296547692,
-0.1035721749,
-0.6262614131,
0.436317265,
0.2806370854,
-0.0936053321,
-0.2954211235,
0.3964232206,
0.5834025145,
0.0166187622,
0.5222228169,
0.4436917007,
-0.4144956768,
-0.5608081222,
-0.6332432628,
-0.1383379251,
-0.4790542722,
0.838211,
-0.1082331464,
-1.1682603359,
0.3991551101,
0.0756373927,
0.0853913054,
-0.0154960426,
0.532405436,
-0.3318549693,
0.6491458416,
0.7120778561,
-0.3003095686,
0.7473890185,
0.1214150488,
0.0932956636,
-0.7337445617,
0.0869092569,
-0.4212148488,
-0.4787788987,
-0.4972851872,
-0.647002697,
0.2397946119,
-0.211421743,
-0.0523028374,
0.0432509147,
-0.3401070833,
0.6158068776,
0.4214126766,
0.1467511058,
-0.0094763227,
0.0469354317,
0.2651648521,
-0.167711556,
-0.5173549652,
-0.0732437521,
0.8351357579,
0.182946071,
0.8110689521,
-0.1195438951,
0.2762988806,
0.3101075888,
0.4392784536,
-1.0256688595,
0.4804119468,
-0.083485879,
-0.2935800254,
-0.3052690923,
-0.1629693806,
-0.797775805,
0.1533086747,
0.0979740694,
-0.8795595765,
0.2637768984,
0.6008048654,
-0.7100488544,
0.0421178564,
-0.4171842039,
0.7551836371,
0.0993210301,
-0.7431594133,
-0.1147741824,
-0.5651963949,
0.3979472816,
-0.4209300876,
-0.0015695362,
-0.1828612089,
-0.3388548493,
0.6183801889,
-0.2108017653,
0.9722172022,
-0.252525419,
-0.1075176969,
0.1200508252,
-0.051150877,
0.6162030101,
-0.218173027,
0.2059135586,
-0.2755817771,
0.1107044592,
-0.6899601221,
-0.6571959257,
0.7035139203,
-0.2962327898,
-0.4047880173,
-0.3290264308,
-0.7187952995,
-0.468485564,
0.1936227232,
-0.04052338,
0.233172223,
-0.2022149712,
0.2948598862,
0.8715650439,
0.0577333607,
0.5516765118,
0.419831723,
0.127484709,
-0.2614498436,
0.8823649883,
-0.0289102979,
0.3366822302,
0.5173277259,
-0.008579772,
-0.2221127599,
-0.8959066868,
-0.3306778073,
0.1884038746,
-0.3187687099,
-0.2684463561,
-0.6110268235,
0.1376818866,
-0.3829720318,
-0.004587499,
-0.4211089015,
-0.285007447,
-0.3427651227,
-0.0276733022,
0.4017153084,
0.1633517593,
0.2971101403,
0.6086874008,
-0.7402424216,
0.2924527824,
0.2175298631,
0.3064681888,
0.1125081629,
-0.7201678753,
-0.4124414325,
-0.1227789745,
-0.1428306252,
-0.6626597643,
0.2540929019,
0.5468627214,
0.2902206481,
0.4914579988,
0.0883563682,
1.1724761724,
-0.6402222514,
0.7028157711,
-0.2872478366,
-0.8374963999,
0.2530142069,
-0.1147315577,
0.4847154617,
0.7423437238,
-0.0164771136,
-0.48566553,
-0.6032135487,
-0.1638173908,
-0.8513393402,
0.9152815342,
-0.1130778566,
0.2148269862,
0.0890110284,
0.5879067183,
-0.1876295954,
0.1241799593,
-0.732257545,
0.1692158133,
-0.007059963,
-0.3756066859,
-0.0354325585,
-0.4080863595,
-0.002098036,
-0.0683898479,
0.4245640337,
-0.4986812174,
0.3592329025,
0.3024170697,
-0.338639915,
-0.1384281963,
0.0975686237,
0.9559463859,
0.5037807822,
-0.4400635362,
0.0714000538,
0.3318389654,
-0.6177399158,
0.2837213278,
0.2072280794,
-0.178309992,
-0.1499674022,
0.5198997259,
0.8600133657,
0.5466211438,
-0.7955266237,
0.6402764916,
0.005657563,
-0.0733446255,
-0.2940919995,
0.0960587338,
-0.0217573512,
0.168265298,
0.489041388,
-0.3226292431,
0.1366099119,
-0.3499943316,
0.2374749184,
0.4802496731,
-0.5653264523,
-0.3896223307,
0.7632145882,
-0.0945281461,
-0.0596438982,
0.3159644604,
-0.0258687548,
-0.1154413149,
0.556412518,
0.502620995,
0.9681151509,
-0.29197824,
-0.3383994699,
0.1500085145,
0.0913357586,
0.194805041,
0.1177373305,
-0.577429831,
-0.4828558564,
-0.9148619175,
-0.8327592015,
-0.2987852395,
0.5235620737,
-0.4964082241,
0.0064771208,
-0.5809004307,
0.2227691412,
-0.1577231437,
-0.162507847,
-0.2368397564,
0.2491440326,
-0.0035741772,
1.08129251,
-0.679366529,
0.8261325359,
0.4350244999,
0.1589421183,
-0.5311748385,
0.3658955991,
-0.1611337215,
-0.7183187604,
0.4732852876,
0.2633146048,
-0.223115325,
0.077819787,
-0.7432258725,
-0.9817895889,
0.9294133782,
0.369410336,
-0.5529440045,
-0.3367786705,
-0.0441576019,
0.3845044672,
-0.1437217146,
0.0940459147,
0.8037676215,
0.1665055305,
0.2822631598,
-0.4231007993,
0.0680710524,
0.0429658033,
0.1499158293,
0.090802297,
-0.7734287381,
0.5473597646,
0.0348311365,
-0.3045360744,
0.3439185023,
1.2458233833,
0.3314652145,
0.259537518,
0.5512005687,
0.3339563012,
0.531724453,
-0.0462849624,
0.8130493164,
-0.4294990301,
0.1735835671,
1.2701934576,
-0.3863041103,
0.8259497881,
0.8010042906,
-0.4456904531,
0.157465905,
0.8165162802,
0.2870246172,
0.7040510178,
0.3248665035,
-0.397459656,
-0.0487398878,
0.0107743973,
0.0448271185,
0.4633640051,
0.3351421654,
-0.107492961,
-0.1974600106,
0.1628006995,
-0.0678210035,
-0.0861039609,
-0.4012369812,
0.8041465282,
0.1746442914,
-0.6986157894,
0.6510831118,
-0.0104652634,
0.6994213462,
-0.6604755521,
-0.1573854983,
-0.4657108784,
0.3127011061,
0.0259102806,
-0.2246291637,
0.21942918,
0.0052104522,
-0.3319975436,
-0.2474993616,
0.5584176183,
-0.5348094702,
-0.4173721373,
0.1767266542,
0.1487915516,
0.0371239707,
-0.1318896115,
-0.3764795065,
-0.0234087463,
-0.2427966744,
-0.4615150094,
0.5815499425,
0.4310528934,
-0.1617893875,
0.3718565702,
0.6693222523,
0.3751369715,
0.09675093,
-0.1485840231,
0.8034682274,
-0.5610414147,
-0.5861065984,
-0.8112226129,
0.2001581788,
-0.020757271,
-0.0853804648,
0.4014215767,
0.4722679555,
0.7101281881,
-0.0212148651,
0.4347013235,
0.2205777913,
0.7721179128,
-0.6962675452,
0.5197892785,
-0.6654348373,
0.0783396959,
-0.1253976971,
-1.0274151564,
-0.4300157726,
0.4805622995,
0.0420560837,
0.2344726324,
0.5966471434,
0.799216032,
-0.4534923434,
-0.4868555665,
0.4515720308,
0.4324920475,
0.275308013,
0.715328753,
0.5294893384,
-0.0928521007,
0.4598957598,
-0.1218554825,
-0.262989819,
-0.1371058822,
-1.0968109369,
-0.7247734666,
-0.2241169065,
-0.1209604368,
-0.429122746,
0.0684251413,
1.0706145763,
0.9262114167,
-1.0711323023,
-0.13174887,
-0.09765286,
-0.1079571396,
-0.2015647441,
-0.2342759073,
0.6084048152,
-0.5241647363,
-1.0862326622,
0.5539788604,
0.5265185833,
0.1102839932,
-0.2104055583,
0.2095160484,
0.0236933678,
0.0875273049,
0.7044765949,
0.4634461999,
-0.6774204373,
-0.4409753084,
0.0070341239,
-0.1065853536,
0.3512544036,
0.7990484834,
-0.871070981,
0.1724628061,
0.3317249417,
0.8862981796,
0.5703034401,
0.1991606057,
0.4147101939,
-1.1927748919,
0.7774871588,
0.2855300605,
0.2735938132,
0.2095104754,
-0.3437002897,
0.1927833706,
0.5838406682,
-0.3175229728,
-1.0709174871,
-0.00780593,
-1.198012948,
-0.0975987017,
0.942222476,
-0.2646251619,
-0.8367111683,
-0.1696120948,
-0.2255260348,
0.0262358021,
-0.3612441123,
0.6144502163,
0.6627076268,
-0.0486319773,
-0.4603395164,
-0.4670338333,
0.680880487,
0.574401319,
-0.7165700793,
0.2605280876,
0.5401719809,
0.3165776432,
-0.0985018313,
0.8122795224,
0.1028230861,
0.422270596,
-0.3045004606,
-0.209304139,
-0.048138231,
-0.2970301211,
-0.4948816597,
0.32037884,
0.1663138419,
-0.3843090534
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15485v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15485v2 | SegHist: A General Segmentation-based Framework for Chinese Historical Document Text Line Detection | 2024-06-17T11:00:04 | 2024-06-25T07:37:22 | Xingjian Hu, Baole Wei, Liangcai Gao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV | Text line detection is a key task in historical document analysis facing many
challenges of arbitrary-shaped text lines, dense texts, and text lines with
high aspect ratios, etc. In this paper, we propose a general framework for
historical document text detection (SegHist), enabling existing
segmentation-based text detection methods to effectively address the
challenges, especially text lines with high aspect ratios. Integrating the
SegHist framework with the commonly used method DB++, we develop DB-SegHist.
This approach achieves SOTA on the CHDAC, MTHv2, and competitive results on
HDRC datasets, with a significant improvement of 1.19% on the most challenging
CHDAC dataset which features more text lines with high aspect ratios. Moreover,
our method attains SOTA on rotated MTHv2 and rotated HDRC, demonstrating its
rotational robustness. The code is available at
https://github.com/LumionHXJ/SegHist. | [
-0.3641759455,
-1.0428197384,
0.5051228404,
0.0738660023,
-0.6080548167,
-0.4408370256,
0.2055089623,
-0.4684963524,
0.4831526279,
0.7651533484,
-0.7609000802,
-0.6635122299,
0.1139775068,
0.134304598,
-0.4064905047,
1.0100598335,
-0.087421082,
0.045901686,
0.123042278,
-0.2258117199,
-0.1801647395,
-0.5894933939,
-0.2914817929,
0.1113904566,
0.0191000737,
0.6074947119,
0.504314065,
1.2484227419,
0.7624571919,
0.0931356177,
-0.0122805648,
0.2640587986,
-0.1484939158,
0.5766292214,
0.1359811127,
-0.0365049243,
-0.5012048483,
-0.4873185456,
0.6517249346,
0.1318396777,
0.0258762222,
-0.2660256922,
0.129071638,
0.7464219332,
-0.5667987466,
-0.2379954904,
-0.1822726279,
0.0545102395,
-0.8348472118,
-0.6635003686,
-0.1379645616,
-0.3705438972,
0.1376675814,
-0.7527185678,
0.4004005492,
0.1427146494,
1.1252945662,
-0.0755075067,
-0.4227178395,
-0.5192543268,
-0.2573507726,
0.5531271696,
-0.7384284139,
0.3671438694,
0.410720408,
0.4324918985,
-0.0298346039,
-0.7435524464,
-0.4181383848,
0.0136752026,
0.0723784193,
0.1467200816,
0.2819600403,
-0.2235154212,
0.1964868903,
0.6375296116,
-0.9329761267,
0.202994734,
-0.1421744823,
-0.3399766982,
0.2996830344,
0.2761643231,
0.6709535122,
-0.4663339257,
-0.5268492103,
-0.0655670017,
-0.658829689,
0.1293652058,
0.4254628122,
-0.0206286479,
-0.0810037628,
0.1585671753,
-0.1452771276,
0.541759491,
0.033630915,
0.1341532916,
0.0073070088,
-0.2023381293,
-0.3429318666,
0.1350500584,
0.6807767153,
0.2779871523,
-0.0954060405,
0.3212127686,
-0.0638087913,
-0.1281835884,
0.0047224835,
-1.116253376,
-0.275883168,
-0.2592404187,
-0.5323927402,
-0.2520011663,
0.2062554061,
-0.9992729425,
-0.8901746273,
0.0239975564,
0.0027068849,
-0.6514951587,
-0.0714529678,
-0.0327156261,
-0.0908960328,
0.7577251196,
0.5875107646,
-1.191506505,
-0.0884303302,
0.7253025174,
0.9496130347,
-0.3010827899,
-0.17194511,
-0.7080899477,
0.1947147846,
-0.3042528331,
1.3083549738,
-0.1769754291,
-0.431779176,
0.0718197152,
0.1736214906,
0.4310984015,
-0.3475617468,
1.2101165056,
-0.3620682061,
0.3478345275,
-0.4468232095,
-0.3648376465,
-0.148189798,
0.5396704078,
-0.8558802605,
1.0961916447,
0.0984499678,
-1.1697586775,
0.527302742,
-0.1293795705,
-0.945240736,
0.3099586964,
-0.3474439979,
-0.764226675,
-0.411251545,
0.5259400606,
0.406080544,
-0.5815136433,
0.1665587276,
-0.3715131283,
-0.5473663807,
-0.180327937,
-0.4592052102,
1.0566065311,
0.2461040616,
-0.4248915911,
0.183085084,
-0.7231468558,
0.0398381092,
-0.0689154193,
-0.5108526349,
-0.5838874578,
0.0446422584,
0.5783600807,
-0.0875270367,
0.3098313808,
-0.182438612,
0.2883168459,
-0.3898568749,
0.2076392472,
0.7548831701,
0.0359270573,
0.31611076,
-0.1897509098,
0.4561194181,
-0.0568657368,
0.010888245,
-0.457174629,
0.0216273461,
-1.0253081322,
-0.3216384053,
-0.0432252511,
0.469787389,
-0.9627201557,
0.8867487311,
-0.083746545,
-0.3813272119,
0.1894634813,
-0.1165405288,
-0.0814636648,
0.2675485015,
0.4708530903,
-0.0837052539,
-0.9081680179,
-0.9452522993,
-0.198655352,
-0.2882650495,
-0.1948098987,
0.0163422115,
0.5281180739,
-0.3604159057,
0.7200431824,
-0.5316116214,
-0.630659461,
-0.182806313,
0.0199197996,
0.1525414735,
0.5125014782,
0.5805997849,
-0.9915208817,
-0.7456489205,
0.6340762377,
-0.7971128821,
-0.4668365717,
-0.3378970027,
-0.3291136324,
0.5154905915,
0.5839539766,
0.0945002437,
0.5567398667,
0.4089624286,
-0.6179475784,
0.7186985016,
-0.2111875564,
0.4211676419,
-1.0613191128,
0.2855430245,
0.1790726781,
-0.3032146096,
-0.8841832876,
0.0940702185,
0.584045887,
0.0817803517,
-0.0582823269,
0.2353694737,
-0.516664505,
0.0340609178,
-0.1440419406,
0.0038262326,
0.135332793,
0.5045358539,
0.2349845767,
0.5310447812,
-0.0099643283,
-0.2110102028,
0.426504612,
0.0304247197,
-0.5967666507,
1.0247217417,
-0.4491554201,
0.1603246331,
0.0202576984,
-0.0276913848,
-0.7384378314,
-0.1974681616,
0.3010287583,
-0.2722833157,
0.2397719026,
0.323549509,
-0.1451839656,
-0.1832271665,
-0.8345230818,
0.191769585,
-0.113770403,
-0.5774638057,
0.6172719002,
0.3151672781,
-0.3151521385,
-0.3804239631,
-0.6949843168,
0.0121787759,
-0.1676770896,
-1.0199906826,
0.2541518807,
-0.0329189897,
0.2556164563,
-0.2272708565,
-0.4485183358,
-0.6475268006,
0.0818818063,
0.1191528141,
0.4548232257,
-0.6066157222,
-0.3299019635,
0.3648914695,
-0.2547803223,
-0.3566664755,
-0.1946279705,
0.7285451889,
-0.0432491302,
-0.3630006909,
-0.5599819422,
0.2809846103,
0.6876588464,
-0.2079300433,
0.1950532645,
0.5418262482,
-0.4674120247,
-0.1366035938,
-0.6600814462,
0.1097438484,
-0.4232156277,
0.4286241531,
-0.1708721071,
-0.9890267253,
0.3611865044,
0.3841707408,
0.0396507829,
0.7246983647,
0.3148796856,
-0.1411405057,
0.7340340018,
0.4587727785,
-0.1809576303,
0.505274415,
-0.1075300723,
-0.0599438213,
-0.7052598596,
-0.0791771337,
-0.7630915642,
-0.1432662308,
-0.237816602,
-0.2833663225,
0.0798805654,
0.2908953726,
-0.3985140622,
0.4892283082,
-0.5895733237,
0.4450436831,
0.2692044973,
-0.0240058266,
0.4836728275,
-0.2601408064,
-0.0280060507,
-0.3266402483,
0.0276473165,
-0.5511030555,
0.3367783427,
0.3140033484,
0.7989359498,
-0.0595395938,
0.5208591223,
0.50578475,
-0.0112081729,
-0.8350872397,
0.4807528853,
-0.2364245653,
-0.6911816001,
-0.6065915823,
-0.3340186477,
-0.4843575954,
0.343654871,
-0.1629638523,
-0.4674194157,
0.4631442428,
-0.1022087634,
-0.2872880399,
0.263037324,
-0.4012884796,
1.062518239,
-0.3721615374,
-0.1659682542,
0.1942355186,
-0.4411026239,
0.0821113437,
-0.3467472792,
-0.0639263541,
-0.053112831,
0.2088625133,
0.9296450019,
-0.5888647437,
0.2669962645,
-0.1065715849,
-0.0518383421,
0.315579325,
0.1944712102,
0.7250883579,
-0.1592278481,
-0.0017552568,
-0.1507522613,
0.3731140196,
-0.2086796761,
-0.360286057,
0.5301004052,
-0.4337828457,
-0.4803106487,
-0.4460865855,
-0.1864872426,
0.4205567837,
0.5463816524,
0.5602744222,
0.3597946167,
-0.639734745,
0.7053150535,
0.3079344034,
-0.1601546854,
0.238792628,
0.4325658977,
-0.2797198892,
-0.4378983378,
0.558766067,
0.1375181824,
-0.1586999744,
0.5139821768,
0.1414285004,
-0.2537907958,
-0.490505904,
-0.6685052514,
-0.1808724552,
-0.6422150731,
-0.1971482337,
-0.5395340919,
-0.4345117211,
-0.4265652895,
-0.5332919359,
0.068955712,
-0.2161567956,
-0.5044557452,
0.0035550394,
0.0083349012,
0.3792699277,
0.0572098084,
0.5415142775,
-0.4593092203,
0.3491415679,
0.1534455717,
-0.2052746117,
-0.0998381153,
-0.3650151193,
-0.4687466025,
-0.0950927064,
-0.6532700062,
-0.914458096,
0.6739386916,
-0.0662071928,
0.2966274321,
0.8865207434,
0.2907532156,
0.4149087965,
-0.4131115377,
0.4692979753,
0.3401282132,
-1.0413035154,
0.398445338,
-0.5869195461,
0.2528729141,
0.5615838766,
-0.0389040634,
-1.0888785124,
-0.1502897441,
-0.0095743015,
-0.7825120687,
0.8144426942,
0.0517927743,
-0.4896086156,
0.4791002274,
0.1233706698,
0.2070771605,
-0.3873276711,
-0.7897872329,
-0.0370554775,
-0.3712053299,
-0.2850099206,
0.3783490956,
-0.4522613585,
0.3996551931,
0.1431970745,
0.6271029711,
-0.1634589732,
-0.1808792651,
0.4248082936,
-0.3354313672,
-0.0047164825,
0.6016386151,
0.4656330943,
0.4200813174,
-0.1881045699,
0.146429494,
0.1911955774,
-0.8709791899,
0.2260928452,
0.3184345365,
-0.5613713861,
-0.1744954437,
0.4544317424,
0.6896893382,
-0.1099989414,
-0.2891153991,
0.6152657866,
-0.0123918969,
-0.2362916321,
-0.2724621594,
-0.1157798097,
-0.0721659213,
0.2497849315,
0.8196510077,
-0.1368281543,
0.40305686,
-0.283570677,
0.2930934429,
0.2030287683,
-0.6835047603,
-0.1209742427,
0.4777366817,
0.4144729972,
-0.2348941565,
0.3385932148,
0.060199298,
-0.9126256108,
0.7946944833,
0.3988779187,
0.8291842341,
-0.4117885232,
0.203993693,
0.0894156098,
0.2714331448,
-0.1127022579,
0.0627828315,
-0.270632416,
-0.771705389,
-0.0890463069,
-0.4716508389,
-0.1887603253,
0.119874455,
-0.7038148046,
0.614613533,
-0.7245274782,
0.0945668146,
0.0503552742,
0.1560796201,
-0.1354481727,
-0.0042750943,
-0.1699726731,
0.8398963213,
-0.5390634537,
1.0192649364,
0.4418433011,
-0.1564641297,
-0.4363899529,
0.2422586977,
0.2978484631,
-0.619754076,
0.5009551048,
0.7622481585,
-0.2112923115,
-0.0629076734,
-0.2188034058,
-0.2437586486,
1.1557424068,
0.073187314,
-0.4657632113,
-0.3413296342,
-0.2003358305,
0.4823622406,
-0.0847767666,
0.0146582043,
0.8480188251,
0.6165249944,
-0.0081215128,
-0.4809037149,
-0.0591320097,
-0.246597603,
-0.1164848283,
0.4858313203,
-0.3974784613,
0.8855486512,
0.2466381937,
-0.8033530712,
0.6334773898,
0.652810812,
0.2193414569,
0.4804923534,
0.4513973296,
0.4957044721,
0.651024878,
-0.1592787206,
0.5145927072,
0.2622482479,
0.4881207943,
0.6593652368,
-0.509950459,
0.6128718853,
0.2797040939,
0.046761062,
0.6303623319,
0.615455389,
-0.2074763626,
0.5356632471,
-0.0575982183,
-0.1289725602,
-0.2572276294,
-0.1777134687,
-0.7522456646,
0.1893573403,
0.2796390057,
-0.093727611,
-0.1824672222,
-0.1061037034,
0.1645466834,
0.1963573545,
-0.2697168589,
0.3444047272,
-0.1132232845,
-0.2165829092,
0.2926737368,
0.1671706885,
1.0154247284,
-0.6884052157,
0.070633173,
-0.3127967119,
0.4252793789,
-0.2122545689,
-0.7406458259,
0.1837665439,
-0.0567722656,
-0.1548024863,
0.1800620407,
0.9484689832,
-0.4147338867,
-0.2147831619,
0.1686921716,
0.1232625172,
-0.1843955815,
-0.0500163846,
-0.2096238732,
-0.017408574,
0.4702076614,
-0.2272179872,
0.0254235752,
0.8133716583,
-0.1918601692,
0.1666071564,
0.7546414733,
-0.0330743715,
-0.3521938026,
-0.2606563866,
0.767523706,
-0.9311748147,
-1.1624925137,
-0.980325222,
0.1434503347,
-0.3775259256,
-0.2663601935,
0.8190732598,
0.8188199401,
0.5962615609,
0.1205703467,
0.6265417337,
0.0064213509,
0.6883704662,
-0.6923779249,
1.1784381866,
-0.5265290737,
0.1467708647,
-0.3983954489,
-0.8514031768,
-0.5115787983,
0.9468562603,
-0.3567354977,
-0.3395185173,
0.9569527507,
0.720248878,
0.1032205671,
0.4281754494,
0.324023217,
-0.132852897,
0.6164159179,
0.619940877,
1.1356947422,
-0.3527784944,
0.8384196162,
0.1650346369,
-0.2346670181,
-0.4911278784,
-0.7755756378,
-0.9744873643,
-0.7202785611,
0.2069343477,
-0.1855372339,
-0.0202490818,
0.5831648111,
0.5468412638,
-0.9113262892,
-0.3387484848,
0.1190000996,
0.0355685055,
0.1210210547,
-0.2624767125,
0.8712177873,
0.2394220978,
-0.3631269038,
0.1156975403,
0.7411229014,
0.2447793335,
-0.1324060261,
-0.3787842393,
-0.271310091,
-0.4018975496,
0.1571096182,
0.5043560266,
-0.3123932183,
-0.321375072,
0.1672804356,
-0.4928935766,
0.287948668,
1.190072298,
-0.2129511088,
0.3022417128,
1.0155534744,
0.8126879334,
0.7350523472,
0.0809310228,
0.3609677553,
-0.4356795549,
0.3319436312,
0.2575239539,
0.5847300291,
0.3802405,
-0.5030936599,
0.6157806516,
0.3293006122,
-0.7168530822,
-0.5943289995,
0.0192578901,
-0.9818116426,
-0.4070520699,
0.8290988207,
-0.2137836069,
-0.3568488657,
-0.390673846,
-0.7774314284,
0.1342072189,
-0.48189798,
0.3593809009,
0.7091033459,
0.1396674961,
-0.1222140864,
-0.3547852039,
0.4072772563,
0.0895371512,
-1.0469555855,
0.1504954547,
0.9423707128,
-0.1936608702,
0.1944225878,
0.8538820148,
0.0162671134,
0.5107983947,
-0.2073388398,
0.0527209863,
-0.0346322171,
-0.2734229565,
-0.2834064662,
0.0247791559,
-0.3309981525,
0.0549913906
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11410v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11410v2 | HARE: HumAn pRiors, a key to small language model Efficiency | 2024-06-17T10:56:03 | 2024-06-18T11:59:03 | Lingyun Zhang, Bin jin, Gaojian Ge, Lunhui Liu, Xuewen Shen, Mingyong Wu, Houqian Zhang, Yongneng Jiang, Shiqi Chen, Shi Pu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Human priors play a crucial role in efficiently utilizing data in deep
learning. However, with the development of large language models (LLMs), there
is an increasing emphasis on scaling both model size and data volume, which
often diminishes the importance of human priors in data construction.
Influenced by these trends, existing Small Language Models (SLMs) mainly rely
on web-scraped large-scale training data, neglecting the proper incorporation
of human priors. This oversight limits the training efficiency of language
models in resource-constrained settings. In this paper, we propose a principle
to leverage human priors for data construction. This principle emphasizes
achieving high-performance SLMs by training on a concise dataset that
accommodates both semantic diversity and data quality consistency, while
avoiding benchmark data leakage. Following this principle, we train an SLM
named HARE-1.1B. Extensive experiments on large-scale benchmark datasets
demonstrate that HARE-1.1B performs favorably against state-of-the-art SLMs,
validating the effectiveness of the proposed principle. Additionally, this
provides new insights into efficient language model training in
resource-constrained environments from the view of human priors. | [
-0.3895145655,
-0.261826098,
0.581032455,
0.0434864461,
-0.1051052287,
-0.1808000654,
-0.5719495416,
-0.1630218327,
-0.1505675465,
0.7599827647,
-0.6193315983,
-0.5565809011,
-0.4052472413,
0.0062564961,
-0.0864369795,
0.672059238,
0.1729308814,
0.1404989958,
-0.2220348716,
-0.2136267126,
-0.564321816,
-0.6076902747,
-0.642103672,
-0.1925654709,
0.4382291734,
0.5910371542,
0.8644172549,
0.8494420052,
0.3784102201,
0.233765617,
0.1997817159,
0.3049158752,
-0.4547647238,
0.085293524,
-0.3720138967,
-0.8132222295,
-0.3180517256,
-0.089322038,
0.7484310865,
1.0661739111,
-0.3275742531,
0.3482598662,
0.0281323455,
0.9604577422,
-0.9932531118,
-0.0098425886,
-0.9880920053,
0.1268368214,
-0.5730444193,
0.3813542128,
-0.5301238298,
-0.1099293157,
0.0743621141,
-0.7898551822,
0.4371564388,
0.1049432382,
0.8603057861,
0.3418658972,
0.0338573717,
0.0736684278,
-0.6859809756,
0.962331593,
-0.8627244234,
0.8338238597,
1.0886327028,
0.3070341051,
-0.1946969181,
-0.6405991912,
-0.5492342114,
0.0822368413,
-0.2399026155,
-0.4214106798,
0.0833473653,
-0.2128316909,
0.3726642132,
-0.00018775,
-0.4804725945,
0.2714400291,
-0.3088811636,
-0.1517433077,
0.6731140018,
0.4959083498,
-0.0516398735,
0.0969481468,
0.1101290956,
-0.3162685037,
-0.9707615376,
0.0764995217,
0.2754963636,
0.673535347,
-0.0154115316,
0.2756148279,
-0.2996528745,
0.5929678679,
-0.2225301862,
-0.2482328713,
0.0720952526,
-0.4813302457,
-0.1694223583,
-0.2238933593,
0.6992536187,
-0.057206437,
0.4411192834,
-0.3172566593,
-0.1333650947,
0.0318491496,
0.4001727104,
-0.9375755787,
-0.4618198276,
-0.3222115636,
-0.4937500358,
0.0748862624,
0.1515851915,
-0.6867649555,
-0.1964606345,
-0.3010300696,
0.0102982,
-0.4206144214,
-0.40879336,
0.4605273902,
0.2584806085,
0.117580846,
0.1839847118,
-1.0956517458,
0.8174490333,
0.770254612,
0.5763432384,
0.142486155,
-0.4063105583,
-0.5941017866,
0.3309080005,
-0.6252984405,
0.3140358031,
-0.6640864611,
-0.3002345562,
-0.0266920459,
-0.1804137379,
0.1673838645,
-0.6710826159,
0.749004066,
-0.5485092998,
-0.1044226289,
-0.4039763212,
-0.6507429481,
-0.0966536328,
-0.3081378341,
-0.5577515364,
0.7255474329,
0.0428547226,
-0.590862751,
0.6961112022,
-0.4126307666,
-0.6907374263,
-0.0560628064,
-0.3371614218,
-0.5176483989,
0.3736966252,
0.4169688225,
0.5648649335,
-0.1727664471,
-0.0659707263,
-0.5190112591,
-0.149126932,
0.1183741018,
-0.0488086939,
0.5146352053,
0.4555117488,
0.015035498,
-0.4920192957,
-0.3578017354,
0.1248902157,
0.360153079,
-0.1755910218,
-0.7396888733,
0.3261310756,
-0.289986968,
0.0588795245,
-0.0821237937,
-0.2637004554,
0.3198840618,
-0.3980656266,
0.0990727991,
0.6213133335,
-0.3205077946,
0.7662412524,
-0.3661141694,
0.2169007361,
-0.156540975,
-0.0371357389,
-0.2105021775,
-0.2076380402,
-0.8424628973,
-0.3077575266,
0.3662787378,
0.2603553236,
-0.0265393462,
0.6329344511,
-0.4897386432,
-0.35426265,
-0.7800650001,
0.7057344913,
0.2155503035,
0.3212400973,
0.1537940651,
-0.1483099312,
-0.8223413229,
-1.0796262026,
-0.1303519309,
-0.0076423706,
-0.1011842713,
0.3058914244,
0.2152912617,
-0.219322741,
1.3316290379,
-0.680827558,
-0.3919730783,
-0.1894782186,
-0.0387148187,
0.1657192111,
0.7421320081,
0.3595966101,
-0.6671763062,
-0.4206824005,
-0.4314374924,
-0.7072148919,
-0.0021287969,
-0.0648431629,
-0.4184252918,
-0.040348161,
0.469943136,
-0.7530506849,
0.2835412323,
0.2419254482,
-0.0033399323,
0.2631468475,
-0.2021920681,
-0.247368753,
-0.7355316281,
-0.2705816329,
0.1323627979,
-0.4396373928,
-0.4876775742,
0.0508722849,
0.2336488962,
-0.1586280912,
-0.3497520387,
0.5453742146,
-0.4472737908,
0.0022043979,
-0.1664436162,
-0.1724036187,
-0.0653369725,
0.3965746462,
0.2655126154,
0.7661886215,
0.3832491636,
-0.7866185308,
-0.3445708454,
0.3242615461,
-0.3893871009,
0.46660164,
-0.5300574303,
0.3947840929,
0.0229921751,
0.0969139934,
-0.525339067,
-0.0698240399,
-0.0580166578,
-0.2237567604,
0.5999366641,
-0.0630011708,
-0.8084331155,
-0.204236418,
-0.1906561553,
0.3603391349,
0.9190589786,
-0.3794602454,
0.2663609982,
0.6097786427,
-0.1348108649,
-0.2419930995,
-0.6379585266,
-0.0007288696,
-0.1770359129,
-0.8345065117,
-0.0599729344,
0.0030871786,
-0.3516539931,
-0.0313268118,
-0.1851747185,
-0.2071941346,
0.2786793113,
0.0714711174,
-0.0168313049,
-0.3449606597,
0.2204003185,
-0.0882027,
-0.1642273515,
-0.0983834639,
-0.3495329618,
0.4980404973,
-0.0957994014,
-0.4074532688,
-0.6009905934,
0.2903069556,
0.2554073036,
-0.3157547414,
0.5704138875,
0.3425632119,
-0.6750506759,
-0.2729893327,
-0.6652501225,
-0.3820187449,
-0.473205328,
0.5529098511,
-0.3387705088,
-0.5181446075,
0.2667695582,
-0.1096256375,
0.1373604387,
0.3334295452,
0.3091383576,
-0.2690849006,
1.0235648155,
0.7647960782,
-0.3730894029,
0.3934486806,
-0.3030432463,
-0.2671920955,
-0.8944264054,
0.1449815929,
-0.6484932899,
-0.2538796663,
-0.066817522,
-0.4522031546,
-0.1617255062,
0.4982881248,
-0.5108107924,
0.3067699969,
-0.2162146568,
0.4805582166,
0.4612400234,
0.1098388731,
0.2225787193,
0.0211849194,
0.0034052632,
-0.5524098277,
-0.7012835741,
-0.7709803581,
1.3049902916,
0.4264057875,
1.2399104834,
0.0695080683,
0.7553970218,
0.2661029994,
0.2557346225,
-0.3377899826,
0.4971958697,
-0.2492410541,
-0.7411352396,
-0.414203167,
-0.3523792028,
-1.0761517286,
0.3031849563,
-0.2390057743,
-0.721303761,
0.0121729644,
0.2111929059,
-0.2082989663,
0.2856276333,
-0.9476698637,
0.801187396,
-0.3174019754,
-0.4968389571,
-0.3695595264,
-0.6017305851,
0.1541812718,
-0.2813312709,
0.3479145169,
-0.3116901219,
-0.4079189599,
0.8491967916,
-0.7363162041,
0.9820488095,
-0.2808105052,
0.2229272872,
-0.0278507769,
0.283868432,
0.8329355121,
0.2087985128,
0.134467259,
0.2116829455,
-0.4587140381,
-0.5182623863,
-0.5551033616,
0.465821147,
-0.8216745257,
-0.522992909,
-0.1201674789,
-0.3182613254,
-0.3754050732,
0.1976730824,
0.2092641741,
0.3254680634,
0.0866376162,
0.3302081525,
0.7324800491,
0.1685058177,
0.1497306824,
0.651568234,
-0.1725004315,
-0.1596371382,
0.6919643283,
0.0424142405,
0.1955073327,
0.3351880312,
0.3061323464,
-0.297886163,
-0.8337931633,
-0.3222576976,
0.3041266501,
-0.5371738672,
-0.3613780439,
-0.6607730985,
0.095361948,
-0.2534382045,
-0.2812319696,
-0.7504946589,
-0.0632333979,
-0.2461444885,
0.1087526903,
0.2183213681,
0.6030560136,
0.0427071787,
0.4149548113,
-0.8012587428,
0.2171257138,
0.3902917206,
0.4511477947,
0.149419263,
-0.3337546289,
-0.4756013751,
0.3803302944,
-0.1174360812,
-0.4649686813,
0.2501446903,
0.3673597872,
0.9094316959,
0.3595820069,
0.0951406658,
0.8558123708,
-0.7098721266,
0.5688604116,
0.0949007794,
-0.8092923164,
0.5973068476,
-0.2741871476,
0.1960370839,
0.9845741391,
0.2293624282,
-0.4113805294,
-0.5069558024,
-0.5830183625,
-0.6757934093,
0.8440751433,
0.199772507,
0.1883691996,
0.228540197,
0.3976487219,
0.4627177417,
0.2630752325,
-0.4464811981,
-0.2164845169,
-0.1183400974,
-0.2298738658,
-0.2521775067,
-0.0849740654,
0.1168416291,
-0.3889048994,
0.5775055289,
0.1260141134,
-0.3294602931,
0.080658704,
-0.6484596133,
-0.0877472311,
0.087185204,
0.4197693467,
0.8062165976,
-0.2974009216,
0.1915128231,
0.4391185641,
-0.477001518,
0.3197859824,
-0.2320587337,
-0.1975588799,
-0.1102170423,
0.4748948514,
0.6276117563,
0.198807627,
-0.4551562667,
0.3756984472,
-0.1653437614,
0.0589481853,
-0.2180090249,
0.1799083054,
0.1592363119,
0.0359548777,
0.5534597039,
0.1806101203,
-0.1895845979,
-0.1187088788,
0.4849297702,
0.3323121071,
0.0173668396,
-0.390403986,
0.5856342316,
0.0974957719,
-0.4480218291,
0.7550677061,
-0.2971000373,
-0.2698281705,
0.1324536204,
0.4910392761,
0.8018798828,
-0.0425681621,
-0.2647332251,
0.3474479318,
0.3543683887,
-0.3776554465,
-0.1667026579,
-0.0949675217,
-0.8087088466,
-0.4403724372,
-0.6295984387,
-0.1437677145,
0.3188359141,
-0.5869569778,
0.3936094046,
-0.5419206023,
-0.2074638456,
-0.0510636345,
0.1441595703,
-1.2224435806,
0.0322853252,
0.2593207061,
1.0295637846,
-0.7853595614,
1.0129226446,
0.650971055,
-0.3364204764,
-0.8387969732,
0.0488990508,
-0.194393307,
-0.7329887152,
0.8656910658,
-0.0462442897,
0.0745704696,
-0.1840537041,
-0.5112438202,
-0.8233884573,
0.7852054238,
0.6190569401,
-0.7156998515,
-0.0301613864,
0.0318520404,
0.321239382,
-0.3902685046,
-0.1705655456,
0.3918304443,
0.2845097482,
-0.1950057894,
-0.6833102107,
0.1298853308,
-0.0285994727,
0.2286447883,
0.3008203804,
-0.3531468213,
0.7374516726,
-0.2989596128,
-0.304682672,
0.1563320607,
0.9344326258,
0.1767033935,
-0.1610433012,
0.7552438974,
0.7478125691,
0.8949412107,
0.1436384916,
1.0804594755,
0.0541379116,
0.3745343685,
1.2411342859,
-0.5171571374,
0.9477455616,
0.2368241102,
-0.6388136744,
0.2722822428,
0.6208660603,
0.2821809649,
0.9164803624,
0.3441894948,
0.0390124768,
-0.6572912931,
0.1551848352,
-0.4112511277,
0.4523480237,
0.4141730368,
0.0580038093,
-0.3390796781,
-0.0989689603,
0.1996026784,
0.3636994958,
-0.2456273586,
0.7804526687,
0.0685192198,
-0.3791416585,
0.6369183064,
-0.1688375771,
0.8442863226,
-0.9507920742,
0.2071371824,
-0.2099352479,
0.3417893648,
-0.0011503955,
-0.5780577064,
0.2726148665,
-0.0698975548,
-0.4366740882,
0.0025676924,
0.6558204889,
-0.3154112399,
-0.6263632178,
-0.0017923274,
0.5036183,
-0.0057177595,
0.0143867172,
-0.4506604671,
0.029471945,
-0.2840049267,
-0.0990060046,
0.4740724862,
0.391386658,
-0.112309888,
0.7220625281,
0.769728303,
0.5189355612,
-0.0894500166,
-0.0931020379,
0.7226402164,
-0.6375918388,
-0.6655108929,
-1.0193858147,
0.331096828,
-0.2777465582,
-0.1004150733,
0.6962461472,
0.8163676858,
1.0981360674,
0.1157451943,
0.8169714808,
0.3503589034,
0.7121085525,
-0.4808589518,
0.8280081749,
-0.5721874237,
0.2093875855,
-0.2665933073,
-0.6230928898,
-0.1859719902,
0.8767379522,
-0.1435607523,
0.0013548995,
0.4558190405,
0.7232108116,
-0.2507093251,
-0.1057954505,
0.2158744782,
-0.1698655486,
0.4194273353,
0.3735516667,
0.7416431308,
-0.10818737,
0.4291365147,
-0.5228562951,
0.0095421672,
-0.2024437785,
-0.9147664309,
-0.9043831229,
-0.6892891526,
-0.051653605,
0.0071928096,
-0.0365525112,
1.1141006947,
1.3884322643,
-0.7057783604,
-0.3046824038,
0.0352874473,
0.1018404588,
-0.1436005831,
-0.1654918194,
0.3766940832,
-0.6096349955,
-0.5053700209,
0.1029961631,
0.0595657863,
-0.0085405624,
-0.258843869,
-0.4819263816,
-0.1696527153,
-0.1513865888,
0.3886498213,
0.2765734494,
-0.7316609025,
-0.3783252537,
-0.0539031737,
-0.4684934914,
-0.0203568581,
1.0427796841,
-0.9256205559,
0.3604226112,
0.2344245911,
0.9495731592,
0.6163791418,
-0.1723977327,
0.7915167809,
-1.1079969406,
0.554915905,
0.3503759801,
0.6199561954,
0.5053138137,
-0.2407548428,
0.5536351204,
0.1587719321,
-0.3700019717,
-0.9043233991,
0.1355204582,
-0.6321738958,
-0.2180340439,
1.1185337305,
-0.0001050225,
-0.0352469683,
-0.0911724567,
-0.1578485072,
0.0320110396,
-0.5908309817,
0.3087503612,
0.6359626651,
0.1613949984,
0.072782293,
-0.6736696959,
0.5886711478,
0.4242725968,
-0.7285661101,
0.3222597837,
0.228669107,
0.2417486608,
-0.0720922053,
0.8760499954,
0.2542113066,
0.1018225923,
0.0546364821,
-0.0053689987,
-0.2612955272,
-0.1889586151,
-0.0751485229,
-0.2055757493,
0.3264645934,
-0.3957827687
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11409v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11409v2 | CodeGemma: Open Code Models Based on Gemma | 2024-06-17T10:54:35 | 2024-06-19T02:37:50 | CodeGemma Team, Heri Zhao, Jeffrey Hui, Joshua Howland, Nam Nguyen, Siqi Zuo, Andrea Hu, Christopher A. Choquette-Choo, Jingyue Shen, Joe Kelley, Kshitij Bansal, Luke Vilnis, Mateo Wirth, Paul Michel, Peter Choy, Pratik Joshi, Ravin Kumar, Sarmad Hashmi, Shubham Agrawal, Zhitao Gong, Jane Fine, Tris Warkentin, Ale Jakse Hartman, Bin Ni, Kathy Korevec, Kelly Schaefer, Scott Huffman | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This paper introduces CodeGemma, a collection of specialized open code models
built on top of Gemma, capable of a variety of code and natural language
generation tasks. We release three model variants. CodeGemma 7B pretrained (PT)
and instruction-tuned (IT) variants have remarkably resilient natural language
understanding, excel in mathematical reasoning, and match code capabilities of
other open models. CodeGemma 2B is a state-of-the-art code completion model
designed for fast code infilling and open-ended generation in latency-sensitive
settings. | [
-0.2621902823,
-0.7796074152,
0.125722453,
0.2589769661,
-0.1207758337,
0.1451675445,
-0.0184201784,
-0.6472434998,
-0.0431002676,
0.8111636043,
-0.4082774222,
-0.4622402191,
-0.5780015588,
-0.0441153497,
-0.1753126532,
0.8406169415,
-0.0314788148,
0.3694941998,
-0.1184848025,
-0.0565037765,
-0.6256421208,
-0.6550838351,
-0.3354064226,
-0.4922479391,
0.0782039464,
0.5862192512,
0.9814624786,
0.4039806724,
0.7295147181,
0.11727608,
0.0654804111,
0.2244681716,
-0.5990658402,
-0.2862547636,
-0.0464130454,
-0.871016264,
-0.6829471588,
-0.0008511964,
0.2744480073,
0.5241347551,
-0.0463373289,
0.4841112196,
0.0201878585,
0.545866251,
-0.7336989045,
0.4905401766,
-0.767807126,
0.1212309301,
-0.0702792779,
-0.0044987351,
-0.6622762084,
-0.7059582472,
-0.1110202596,
-0.3518311381,
0.251083374,
-0.132953465,
0.8561610579,
0.2307325304,
-0.2633382976,
-0.6625258923,
-0.4515738785,
0.7083743811,
-0.7715592384,
-0.0544767268,
0.67677176,
0.4864552617,
-0.477443099,
-1.0349349976,
-0.1387203783,
-0.3329341412,
-0.0898316279,
-0.0511730462,
-0.3451851606,
0.1081187427,
0.2039449364,
0.8407734036,
-0.5506048203,
-0.0312177557,
-0.7056823373,
0.0012960619,
0.1460567415,
0.096934922,
0.4803561866,
0.1506760716,
-0.1815179884,
0.3170039058,
-1.2191978693,
-0.0885574967,
0.3960860372,
0.3148871064,
-0.2545632124,
0.844403863,
0.0419467948,
1.1006020308,
0.0505637415,
0.0014615465,
0.0352549553,
0.0094544664,
-0.5307903886,
0.2091985047,
0.3452666402,
-0.0808129013,
0.568400085,
-0.1053386331,
0.0016245898,
0.4066968262,
0.5674521327,
-0.9627258778,
-0.4600054026,
0.0303775594,
-0.647700727,
-0.4232572317,
0.1498363316,
-0.5357385278,
0.0589730367,
-0.1069133803,
0.5919763446,
-0.4267864823,
-0.375492841,
0.7618983984,
0.3354707062,
0.0564935766,
0.0674546957,
-0.9066577554,
0.2557826638,
0.7108442783,
0.8469982147,
0.1703778356,
-0.0920359716,
-0.7214938402,
0.1908136606,
-0.6828072071,
0.527898252,
-0.811861515,
-0.5602382421,
0.158986643,
-0.0434081107,
-0.134817645,
-0.624789834,
0.361350596,
-0.8197293878,
0.4280117154,
-0.0372737385,
-0.5845422149,
-0.4758941531,
0.0638608113,
-0.8095527887,
1.2389487028,
0.3415602446,
-0.8256337047,
0.3969151676,
-0.8462474942,
-0.2156864107,
0.1496155262,
-0.0597697161,
-0.4403483272,
0.3505664766,
-0.0743627623,
0.2337174714,
-0.4827809334,
0.4557045102,
-0.2299312949,
-0.4820951223,
0.0176006239,
-0.0119973896,
0.8389210105,
0.5579401255,
-0.4575285912,
0.1341029257,
-0.8911286592,
0.1561959088,
0.2395845801,
-0.5263716578,
0.0273230113,
0.0354166329,
-0.2902954221,
0.1555305421,
0.4114823937,
-0.3061087132,
0.2707033157,
-0.3306345642,
0.3685417771,
0.1423260272,
-0.1389811337,
0.2490301132,
-0.6788637042,
0.8099156022,
-0.1569848061,
0.0145383738,
-0.4292764962,
-0.9289142489,
-0.7447881699,
-0.5359426141,
0.16200611,
0.3601773381,
-0.5568357706,
0.3271971047,
0.1145125404,
-0.6302432418,
-0.5565216541,
0.0301448628,
0.9788926244,
0.3632089198,
0.3843934238,
-0.2819918096,
-0.5146650672,
-0.6611854434,
-0.1938276887,
-0.3741184175,
0.0535543635,
-0.0289688408,
0.2659897506,
-0.1981186122,
1.0758004189,
-0.6492543817,
-0.0738470778,
-0.4259454906,
0.2556629479,
0.1704415977,
0.5282329917,
0.8782898188,
-0.5552544594,
-0.2217656821,
-0.2287634462,
-0.7099401355,
-0.3004445732,
0.3248336613,
-0.2230851501,
0.2969016135,
0.3187750876,
-0.3785722554,
0.6255132556,
0.7143221498,
-0.3584976792,
0.6261258125,
-0.3181766272,
0.1207277179,
-1.4109369516,
-0.0678386986,
-0.4129596353,
-0.2851748168,
-0.4942285717,
0.7749611139,
0.2285737395,
-0.3036921918,
-0.5574829578,
0.4155236483,
-0.7907996774,
-0.4221395552,
-0.2640596032,
-0.1813365668,
0.0825967416,
0.4160906076,
0.0012191599,
1.0806324482,
0.7068735957,
-0.7086049318,
0.0192541815,
0.3306015134,
-0.5159948468,
-0.1462254226,
-0.7958262563,
0.230154261,
0.0631375983,
-0.2039624602,
-0.8225089908,
-0.4049703181,
0.0084139323,
-0.461743325,
0.300614059,
-0.4613419175,
-0.76741606,
-0.4368159771,
0.0652433187,
0.4348575771,
0.7342792749,
-0.831017673,
0.3920652866,
0.3758162856,
0.0500243269,
-0.3270434141,
-0.6799034476,
-0.0662042201,
-0.0126151051,
-0.7504960895,
0.1858094633,
-0.1207624152,
-0.3285361528,
0.0036351783,
0.0476615354,
-0.3425574005,
-0.0080151707,
0.3195776045,
0.4554724097,
-0.5918800831,
0.0933859274,
-0.027702406,
-0.0354254246,
0.0151264705,
-0.1445851922,
0.7794910073,
-0.3679186404,
-0.5432774425,
0.2839671075,
0.2610999048,
0.5330232978,
-0.6625784039,
0.6399720907,
0.3598495126,
-0.6463019848,
-0.2191789895,
-0.2302102447,
0.2092331052,
-0.511950016,
0.2767526209,
-0.6950460672,
-1.1963894367,
0.5024595857,
0.1226543784,
0.1828884333,
0.2135714591,
0.9435607791,
0.7044039965,
0.9632304907,
0.8495854735,
0.1819061786,
0.1583488286,
-0.0498154052,
0.3655473292,
-0.1989102364,
-0.3472069502,
-0.7654921412,
0.2939163744,
-0.2644639611,
-0.6356274486,
-0.0559360273,
0.6672232747,
-0.3611560464,
0.7879926562,
-0.5718032718,
0.4578222036,
0.60875386,
-0.0378226675,
0.4331010878,
-0.0560644083,
-0.3569871783,
0.1203830838,
-0.9062831998,
-0.8757682443,
1.0634301901,
0.3738005757,
1.0542228222,
0.4620367289,
0.577227056,
0.1870886981,
0.2934004366,
-0.5537649989,
0.4728002548,
-0.0796396434,
-0.84895432,
0.3665608764,
-0.3380862772,
-0.7186778188,
-0.2258200645,
-0.0462046117,
-0.8146846294,
-0.198206082,
0.193237409,
-0.2424165308,
0.4740905166,
-0.9088215828,
0.7548430562,
0.1994779408,
-0.2756153345,
-0.369549185,
-0.2810602486,
0.8188436031,
-0.2586016357,
-0.1343299448,
-0.1302856803,
0.3080075979,
0.3944010735,
-0.7011657357,
0.7680054903,
0.0816707313,
-0.331152916,
0.7265509367,
0.6632806063,
0.3089655936,
0.1860720515,
-0.0987500474,
0.1820232719,
-0.1332584918,
-0.5603669882,
-0.2369918376,
0.6078990102,
-0.6018494964,
-0.4253085256,
-0.0781788081,
-0.4283975959,
-0.144985497,
0.1631654501,
0.5605934858,
1.0436216593,
-0.0828982964,
0.0357373133,
0.7854514122,
-0.3543560505,
0.5912495852,
0.5422282815,
-0.6908502579,
-0.1920271367,
0.464648962,
-0.2606922388,
0.4011972249,
0.3932240903,
-0.1769108921,
-0.0348941125,
-0.3585417867,
-0.3915991783,
-0.0880524218,
-0.6778038144,
-0.4413998425,
-0.6695123911,
-0.359531939,
-0.2837569714,
-0.3982003331,
-0.4902250171,
-0.442110002,
-0.5103405118,
-0.0086038942,
0.5168417096,
1.2044939995,
0.0602221824,
0.4169232547,
-1.1570081711,
0.5112367272,
0.2082951814,
0.5724010468,
-0.3623708785,
-0.3179795146,
-0.4331885576,
0.1083825007,
-0.304487288,
-0.9455186725,
0.3358211219,
0.0997005776,
0.4509946704,
0.5774723291,
-0.1395650804,
0.4548908472,
-0.4465048611,
0.8898823857,
0.4087914228,
-0.9681013823,
0.5248131752,
-0.408769697,
0.2930772007,
0.3126258254,
0.2940540314,
0.2295071781,
-0.3307263851,
-0.4017292261,
-0.1889931709,
0.5270344019,
0.2388876975,
0.0459317863,
-0.4915804565,
0.1610984802,
0.3670256138,
0.2038842887,
-0.5270878673,
0.013824123,
-0.3050621748,
-0.2302259803,
0.1314210743,
-0.5390277505,
0.0625398979,
0.1477109045,
0.5968946218,
-0.2523778379,
0.5213089585,
-0.1010660902,
-0.2786238194,
-0.2271609902,
0.0326618254,
0.7439777255,
0.9824332595,
-0.3780098259,
-0.1177265868,
-0.2954086065,
-0.7745242715,
0.0328358486,
-0.0211733356,
0.0373957977,
0.0847783312,
0.4276505709,
0.6649580598,
0.4571396708,
-0.7221796513,
0.4420880377,
-0.0922708884,
-0.2736874819,
-0.3115659654,
0.4547103047,
0.0451840498,
0.1184061021,
0.1291932464,
0.1526284963,
-0.0899710283,
-0.6818273067,
0.3751010895,
0.2090940624,
-0.4427929521,
-0.2726487815,
1.1414840221,
-0.0662760437,
-0.5631987453,
0.2315027863,
-0.3491953909,
-0.3510617912,
0.8109551668,
1.0107495785,
1.0319042206,
-0.1011281982,
0.3092886508,
0.2998661399,
0.2541207075,
-0.2271330953,
0.6810485721,
0.2524764836,
-0.6757378578,
-0.6555979252,
-0.6828825474,
-0.422521323,
-0.0660950318,
-1.0119518042,
0.5509734154,
-0.5797360539,
-0.2015850395,
-0.4303829372,
0.0099987928,
-0.4465039372,
0.1395335197,
-0.2202186733,
1.5141363144,
-0.4019202292,
1.1054126024,
0.9078000784,
-0.4848479033,
-0.8772429824,
-0.0821551234,
-0.1859661341,
-1.0344293118,
0.592993319,
0.2372099161,
-0.2271503359,
0.1392398924,
-0.4875172973,
-0.7925177813,
1.0233622789,
0.6010811925,
-0.2399485111,
-0.288025856,
0.0435379446,
0.3120689392,
-0.7832090855,
0.2073671669,
0.3759007752,
0.0519624799,
0.0835851058,
-0.7961350083,
-0.2620004714,
-0.4214061201,
-0.0003635534,
0.3869656026,
-0.682967782,
1.032823205,
-0.4303008914,
0.0033858859,
0.5218907595,
0.3668987453,
0.4566950202,
0.0944169462,
-0.0208324455,
0.8077862859,
0.4892002344,
-0.15633367,
0.8810687661,
-0.8511661291,
0.3586529791,
1.3402805328,
-0.3508011699,
0.5938594341,
-0.2723512053,
-0.0622121692,
0.5366582274,
0.7436751723,
0.1451148987,
0.5522768497,
0.2073014081,
-0.3861200809,
-0.2007425427,
0.1992681623,
-0.7081950903,
0.5509823561,
0.2639037669,
-0.182817325,
-0.4028464556,
-0.2474012077,
0.2083600014,
0.1966501027,
-0.5898569822,
0.5613851547,
0.071226269,
-0.8082283735,
0.6708806753,
0.2902519107,
0.3393703699,
-0.7367640734,
-0.285903126,
-0.1622163057,
0.1082146093,
-0.1938141137,
-0.4053869545,
0.4460104406,
0.1918440312,
-0.1811029762,
0.0686145648,
1.0217703581,
-0.4079034626,
-0.5476561785,
0.4362608492,
0.3968272507,
0.0721908435,
0.089345552,
-0.534868598,
-0.1016474292,
-0.0517492369,
-0.1153388694,
0.2141107321,
0.3511318266,
0.0780155286,
0.7319070101,
0.4259894788,
-0.0562129132,
0.63859725,
0.0274513382,
0.8669232726,
-0.4875886142,
-0.6215068102,
-0.5603196025,
0.3313257396,
0.2819181383,
-0.362018466,
0.6724835038,
0.801862359,
0.7223712802,
-0.3188335896,
0.6330112219,
0.0174806677,
0.4921642542,
-0.7969732881,
0.6336910129,
-0.2767528892,
0.2183192819,
-0.2774990201,
-1.0582549572,
-0.3399654031,
0.4048428237,
-0.0860527381,
0.0184753183,
0.7280982137,
1.0632469654,
-0.2258661538,
0.2629771531,
0.5818066001,
-0.179571569,
0.1479735523,
0.7753763795,
0.6556093693,
-0.3087595105,
0.4306010604,
0.2401165366,
-0.3953542113,
-0.3215852976,
-0.8171892166,
-1.3343183994,
-0.3060420752,
-0.2107614875,
-0.5080996156,
0.0641011894,
0.8941032887,
0.7283434272,
-0.6859798431,
-0.0899952278,
-0.4573071003,
-0.1513918191,
0.2341320962,
-0.2695118189,
0.115447551,
-0.7366229892,
-0.6426979303,
0.4849384427,
0.4341020882,
0.127538994,
-0.1924740523,
-0.3469575346,
-0.0091858394,
0.5467574596,
0.3942121863,
0.3331348598,
-0.3797918856,
-0.1176842749,
0.0640147626,
-0.2723971903,
0.1374865323,
1.038436532,
-0.7497318387,
0.5380033851,
0.4148424566,
0.6762880683,
0.421698153,
-0.1157990247,
0.7444037199,
-0.5462561846,
0.3947278261,
-0.0596640818,
0.6963127255,
0.0592530146,
-0.2602889836,
0.7565902472,
-0.0423937365,
-0.5031135082,
-0.6284556985,
0.6275416017,
-0.6462670565,
-0.4012235105,
0.956410408,
-0.5354880095,
0.0055903038,
-0.1102921218,
-0.1404459476,
0.2365652472,
0.0048426548,
0.6767898202,
0.5986173153,
0.2333093137,
0.0297073834,
-0.7005815506,
0.5293576717,
0.3271526098,
-0.8558251858,
-0.3810888529,
0.5718458891,
0.1031330451,
0.0445631072,
0.805976212,
-0.6171018481,
0.5165764689,
0.22007671,
0.3205312788,
-0.3475375772,
-0.5996736288,
-0.2388589531,
0.4403710067,
0.4113196135,
-0.3561211228
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11403v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11403v1 | Multimodal Structured Generation: CVPR's 2nd MMFM Challenge Technical Report | 2024-06-17T10:45:47 | 2024-06-17T10:45:47 | Franz Louis Cesista | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Multimodal Foundation Models (MMFMs) have shown remarkable performance on
various computer vision and natural language processing tasks. However, their
performance on particular tasks such as document understanding is still
limited. They also require more compute, time, and engineering resources to
finetune and deploy compared to traditional, unimodal models. In this report,
we present Multimodal Structured Generation, a general framework which
constrains the output logits of frozen MMFMs to force them to reason before
responding with structured outputs that downstream APIs can parse and use. We
provide a detailed account of our approach, including the technical details,
theoretical discussions, and final evaluation results in the 2nd Multimodal
Foundation Models Challenge hosted by the Computer Vision and Pattern
Recognition (CVPR) conference. Our approach achieved the second highest score
in the hidden test set for Phase 2 and third highest overall. This shows the
method's ability to generalize to unseen tasks. And that simple engineering can
beat expensive & complicated modelling steps as we first discussed in our
paper, Retrieval Augmented Structured Generation: Business Document Information
Extraction as Tool Use. All of our scripts, deployment steps, and evaluation
results can be accessed in https://github.com/leloykun/MMFM-Challenge | [
-0.2875674665,
-0.6642866135,
0.502068758,
0.5679712892,
-0.1878162026,
0.0439340733,
-0.1088487953,
-0.4452781379,
-0.3352380693,
0.6187465191,
-0.8913857341,
-0.2440723479,
-0.5553573966,
0.1918512732,
-0.3480587602,
0.7483828068,
-0.2125046253,
-0.1605410874,
-0.5958526731,
-0.054594364,
-0.5290948749,
-0.5984248519,
-0.2922281921,
-0.2683155239,
0.2578527927,
0.4270344377,
0.348980546,
0.5826072693,
0.7152484655,
0.390090555,
0.1974281073,
0.4376498163,
-0.1746441871,
0.2117524594,
0.0109613771,
-0.192007035,
-0.3776374459,
-0.0067850212,
0.4591682553,
0.5735352039,
-0.186463505,
0.2242759466,
0.102451086,
0.7303106785,
-0.6428874135,
0.4284388721,
-0.6560739875,
0.1874442846,
-0.1440629065,
-0.3915558159,
-0.7896900773,
0.3515432477,
-0.1702938974,
-0.555796206,
0.4899665713,
-0.0336724706,
0.8794786334,
0.2989992499,
-0.6719262004,
-0.4659341872,
-0.8042224646,
0.6103337407,
-0.1708022654,
0.2827207148,
0.400311619,
0.4126404822,
-0.1555595994,
-0.9756814837,
-0.5296518207,
-0.2159563452,
-0.0275555942,
0.2141593993,
-0.0404653735,
0.1071110219,
0.3085229993,
0.202671349,
-0.6255297661,
-0.1816629916,
-0.4732194543,
-0.32570225,
0.2692987621,
0.2235438824,
-0.1800196469,
-0.3397628963,
-0.4718717933,
-0.3565663695,
-0.2724043131,
0.1628286391,
0.335991621,
0.2563439608,
-0.1881082207,
0.9254351258,
-0.3032425344,
0.630361855,
-0.0936246887,
-0.3283570409,
0.3323243558,
-0.7438338995,
-0.334649384,
-0.4377411604,
0.5246027112,
0.3092814684,
-0.071815379,
0.2208397985,
-0.4430850744,
0.2140092552,
0.207832396,
-0.86252141,
-0.2625548244,
0.2012774646,
-0.5230125189,
-0.334418565,
-0.0770763829,
-0.6919772625,
-0.2099214345,
-0.2374547273,
0.1811876744,
-0.2394045144,
-0.3809224367,
-0.0715149567,
-0.426134795,
0.1473168135,
0.3956855237,
-0.9787098169,
0.178156063,
0.6701363921,
0.8358942866,
0.3616689444,
0.0619003661,
-0.6546912193,
0.1482833922,
-0.1571947485,
0.8428744674,
-0.5571584105,
-0.4582359791,
-0.0310459137,
-0.2817069888,
-0.035557963,
-0.4732830226,
0.4931325614,
-0.2829222679,
0.245190829,
-0.0012277244,
0.0002422324,
0.0896497071,
0.4936239123,
-0.6008884311,
0.9643038511,
0.3285565078,
-0.478584677,
0.3948010504,
-0.5903142095,
-0.3012953997,
0.0967035592,
-0.3969987929,
-0.2953413427,
0.1487659216,
0.0863752887,
0.3950340748,
-0.3012134731,
0.3032346964,
-0.3307085037,
0.29427284,
0.2129616588,
-0.5502650142,
0.2436506003,
0.3503783941,
-0.2336281985,
0.1830911785,
-1.3033480644,
0.0495455973,
0.238837257,
-0.7580787539,
0.0737466216,
0.2069846988,
0.3640471697,
0.6425203085,
0.0500861928,
-0.4646417499,
0.1612657756,
-0.2238629311,
0.5877358913,
0.7996931076,
-0.1993082017,
0.3253950477,
-0.2222085595,
0.3344021738,
0.1477528512,
0.3100958467,
-0.6275039911,
-0.4495295584,
-0.4873064458,
-0.3707404137,
0.1284874678,
0.4227132201,
-1.075158596,
-0.3123951852,
-0.021093905,
-0.227943182,
-0.2017179877,
0.3637196124,
0.6692221761,
0.7192382812,
0.268968761,
-0.4373611212,
-0.5486257076,
-1.0408457518,
0.1628228426,
-0.1669751108,
-0.1511898339,
0.3542305231,
0.42258358,
-0.2396432608,
0.8690648675,
-0.4767283499,
-0.2803648114,
-0.0435070023,
0.6127911806,
0.0850334316,
0.6207071543,
0.5537583828,
-1.3779164553,
-0.1574860662,
-0.1955061257,
-0.5807157159,
-0.1313873827,
-0.1550849378,
0.1023415253,
0.47793293,
0.4361996353,
-0.7253477573,
0.15125449,
0.6841381788,
-0.3644171953,
0.6766472459,
-0.2564435005,
-0.1719684005,
-0.8710051179,
0.1055151224,
0.084038347,
-0.3024534583,
-0.4006094038,
0.2001916021,
0.1362772882,
-0.4978090823,
-0.3496389091,
0.1537268013,
-0.6460555792,
-0.1388503015,
-0.2000726014,
0.0198758487,
0.2516472638,
0.7469109893,
-0.0892076492,
0.3726404309,
0.0434173979,
-0.5509456992,
0.3156466782,
0.231065467,
-0.2665491998,
0.5372161269,
-0.5286437273,
0.2900936902,
-0.2070484906,
0.2284295112,
-1.1096862555,
-0.5844257474,
0.2550471127,
-0.4874611497,
0.5199347138,
-0.1266292483,
-0.6550744772,
-0.3453157842,
-0.1945339441,
0.2645977437,
0.148387149,
-0.2889246047,
0.8294178247,
0.2135096639,
-0.2114242017,
-0.5292755365,
-0.6628063321,
0.0689593852,
0.1628674567,
-0.9380476475,
0.3759176135,
-0.4190282226,
-0.2878926098,
-0.0945712551,
-0.2747439444,
-0.2116026282,
0.2298980653,
0.4382368028,
0.0922833011,
-0.3166978955,
0.0183841586,
0.0274569113,
-0.1771221161,
0.0757649466,
-0.1047488749,
0.4760069847,
-0.0974332765,
-0.3373716772,
0.0235347431,
0.5871018171,
0.6954529285,
-0.4603765607,
0.5031879544,
0.7757288814,
-0.4632716477,
-0.176184088,
-0.4998630583,
0.1911558062,
-0.5132380724,
0.3748320937,
-0.6894928217,
-0.8151622415,
0.1280041486,
-0.2756533325,
0.3377809823,
0.6305273175,
0.7572618723,
-0.0190188047,
1.3317104578,
1.0549249649,
0.6073614955,
0.3279859126,
-0.1768969595,
-0.1583383828,
-0.4566661716,
-0.7312734723,
-0.7127579451,
-0.1249620765,
-0.3892263472,
-0.4453198016,
0.3897193074,
0.1621036232,
0.3712140918,
0.0417025536,
-0.4369195998,
0.1325997561,
0.3148981035,
0.0016739058,
0.181852594,
-0.0152591411,
-0.4915349185,
0.091139324,
-0.5864879489,
-0.4440488815,
0.8243188858,
0.3036803603,
0.2733775675,
0.3277159333,
0.2875401974,
0.3177602887,
0.3980230689,
-0.658412993,
0.5109379888,
-0.0873295739,
-0.522583127,
-0.0207334757,
-0.4006108344,
-0.4963445663,
0.413839817,
-0.4262550473,
-0.3266398013,
0.1273699552,
0.269415617,
-0.2047042251,
-0.2205675095,
-0.8566762209,
0.7229809761,
-0.0824365094,
-0.4036383629,
-0.0925853699,
-0.818225503,
0.5680588484,
-0.2512486279,
0.4836732745,
-0.196993798,
0.0760932043,
0.46479249,
-0.5664617419,
0.5927221179,
-0.3368430138,
0.0974227116,
0.2883686721,
-0.0540165491,
0.3179865181,
0.0262031909,
-0.0433211103,
-0.3047996163,
0.0312381964,
-0.3533943295,
-0.5819034576,
0.4096285403,
-0.4015513957,
-0.4261493981,
-0.2787743807,
-0.6638839245,
-0.1117099002,
0.4298370481,
0.2682947218,
0.8454851508,
-0.1401544213,
0.4356283545,
0.4786957502,
0.0389394946,
0.7263995409,
0.4840547442,
-0.0717003718,
-0.4522888064,
0.7434710264,
0.1028746888,
0.1458954513,
0.5674186349,
0.0563767329,
-0.2566533983,
-0.610330224,
-0.6208451986,
-0.1742432564,
-0.8503515124,
-0.2289571315,
-0.7916205525,
0.0267810859,
-0.577768743,
0.0078777429,
-0.3525232077,
-0.6281710267,
-0.4098117054,
0.0419426449,
-0.1746262014,
0.7215158343,
-0.192935586,
0.1338562816,
-0.7670087814,
0.5634667277,
0.2559931576,
0.2098218501,
-0.3369317949,
0.0253367256,
-0.1933071166,
-0.0459490269,
-0.6557092071,
-0.6099233031,
0.3252809942,
0.3264124691,
0.4064108729,
0.3949868679,
0.0704867169,
0.6334597468,
-0.4658838212,
0.6927862763,
0.2462475598,
-0.7523095012,
0.5822930932,
-0.2888410389,
0.2509765923,
0.4689874947,
0.1019144505,
0.0027721454,
-0.1436521858,
-0.4716572464,
-1.0449908972,
0.4645067751,
0.2390843332,
0.1502358168,
0.0189756453,
0.316373378,
-0.0017375795,
0.3829168677,
-0.683005929,
0.0987942293,
-0.4061738849,
-0.1833715737,
-0.1352028996,
-0.6933692098,
-0.1523609012,
0.1215332448,
0.3956928849,
-0.3538807929,
0.2739973068,
0.4373893738,
-0.3848955333,
-0.1614708006,
0.2704807222,
1.2103391886,
0.7991538644,
-0.2927930951,
0.2418711782,
-0.3894889653,
-0.4438326955,
0.0233328417,
0.2385798991,
0.0971049219,
0.1470106691,
0.4082280993,
0.5796905756,
0.2820279896,
-0.7494454384,
0.4382138848,
-0.165819034,
-0.6358402371,
-0.4582308233,
0.0100078331,
-0.2532970607,
0.3653457761,
0.5772371292,
0.4221529663,
-0.0190964472,
-0.532969296,
0.2488289773,
0.3692636788,
-0.2700803876,
-0.2528892756,
0.8131771684,
0.272639662,
-0.3858592212,
0.703166008,
-0.2300676554,
-0.3605852723,
0.6513305902,
0.681447804,
0.612377882,
0.0633472055,
0.1238743588,
0.11986655,
0.5588408709,
-0.0269271713,
0.3071937263,
-0.3913395107,
-0.6316862106,
-0.3933291137,
-0.7826033831,
-0.4487800896,
0.1032279879,
-0.6065746546,
0.1802131087,
-0.7505833507,
-0.2945800424,
0.3336545527,
-0.0952812582,
-0.5180529356,
0.1624846011,
0.1594517678,
1.1650668383,
-0.5674699545,
0.5488221049,
0.5560799241,
-0.2909183204,
-0.5403057337,
-0.4010108709,
0.2969720364,
-0.4640634656,
0.6194126606,
0.3845004141,
-0.2320897728,
-0.161649406,
-0.6497508883,
-0.4956111014,
1.0848892927,
0.2638190687,
-0.3378870487,
-0.0128627447,
0.1226277575,
0.3916153014,
-0.4558420479,
0.098482646,
0.2110467851,
0.524962604,
0.350081116,
-0.7664890289,
-0.1502962261,
-0.792728126,
-0.0055699158,
0.0399013795,
-0.6079746485,
0.943400085,
-0.2279910743,
-0.2430945635,
0.2730883658,
0.6776425838,
0.3767080009,
0.7458342314,
0.4838469028,
0.4536867142,
0.4406588972,
-0.0939247608,
1.0419443846,
-0.0377083234,
0.2335461676,
1.0078235865,
-0.3442289233,
0.7806245685,
0.5387388468,
0.1762056202,
0.3648423553,
0.4852376878,
-0.2083155364,
0.7142614722,
0.0751129389,
-0.0551392734,
-0.1523343772,
-0.3047733307,
-0.2718759179,
0.7875586152,
0.2932858765,
-0.2561543286,
-0.0595251732,
0.1998669058,
-0.1139891222,
0.1528612822,
-0.2755121887,
0.5993618369,
0.0017290141,
-0.6232787967,
0.3553998172,
0.6745806336,
0.4065602124,
-0.6937817931,
-0.3241586089,
0.0046539758,
0.3435343802,
-0.1481842995,
-0.3730330169,
0.5635870099,
0.1074614376,
-0.667912662,
-0.7559400797,
0.895285964,
-0.2506587505,
-0.5053437948,
0.063821733,
0.2380264401,
-0.2431701124,
-0.1621529758,
-0.5428639054,
0.0902821869,
-0.1959544718,
-0.351868093,
0.3629477918,
0.4906262457,
-0.1059359238,
0.5942425728,
0.9578357935,
-0.4548377991,
0.1440624148,
0.0046686311,
0.9452403784,
-0.3063127398,
-0.5255920291,
-0.758056879,
0.6977615356,
0.0857135206,
-0.2854674459,
0.4941398501,
0.7136662006,
0.8475158215,
-0.1200713292,
0.5269492269,
-0.0666993037,
0.1316317618,
-0.7854091525,
0.5242242217,
-0.6501491666,
-0.0269160122,
-0.4181562364,
-0.605533421,
-0.2301973999,
0.2535930574,
0.2848820686,
-0.0891506001,
0.6719435453,
0.6569101214,
-0.0140157994,
-0.1055673957,
0.2600573599,
0.1798800528,
0.4484241903,
0.5650061369,
0.7127107382,
-0.2568948865,
0.8488224149,
-0.4229358733,
-0.3458654284,
-0.1210284829,
-0.9970247746,
-0.6218864322,
-0.8597812057,
-0.1372185349,
-0.4154296219,
-0.3490746021,
0.6528362036,
0.7428905964,
-0.4161422849,
-0.0329827666,
-0.0240900517,
0.0424912721,
-0.1482462436,
-0.2226656973,
-0.1134664863,
-0.1016430929,
-0.4590548277,
0.6082935333,
0.5603978038,
0.0700352639,
-0.1811913699,
0.0082283141,
-0.2986799181,
-0.0110003278,
0.9955154657,
0.2207855433,
-0.4630828202,
-0.1609178036,
0.0236391444,
-0.1091922522,
0.0238347761,
1.0510866642,
-0.5906267762,
0.5042838454,
0.4628332257,
0.3893679082,
0.681109786,
-0.0042186305,
0.4520503581,
-1.1350640059,
0.3804103434,
0.0420253798,
0.3759335279,
0.2851194441,
-0.3825152814,
0.508831203,
0.6096709967,
-0.1697363257,
-0.9717997909,
0.4197724462,
-1.1706167459,
-0.3025279939,
0.697381258,
0.0984891802,
-0.1106036752,
-0.1334753931,
-0.088774249,
0.278885901,
-0.1279112101,
0.6005504727,
0.7361448407,
-0.1001417413,
-0.4601942003,
-0.6746366024,
0.1768757701,
0.2074252069,
-0.6495896578,
-0.1517481357,
0.7823228836,
0.1051190719,
0.4778869152,
0.9021561146,
-0.2163886428,
0.2593877912,
0.1871770322,
-0.1116061583,
-0.7486316562,
-0.7390213013,
-0.3034859896,
0.8280668855,
-0.0939325839,
-0.1093676463
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11402v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11402v1 | Evaluating Open Language Models Across Task Types, Application Domains, and Reasoning Types: An In-Depth Experimental Analysis | 2024-06-17T10:45:36 | 2024-06-17T10:45:36 | Neelabh Sinha, Vinija Jain, Aman Chadha | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | The rapid rise of Language Models (LMs) has expanded their use in several
applications. Yet, due to constraints of model size, associated cost, or
proprietary restrictions, utilizing state-of-the-art (SOTA) LLMs is not always
feasible. With open, smaller LMs emerging, more applications can leverage their
capabilities, but selecting the right LM can be challenging. This work conducts
an in-depth experimental analysis of the semantic correctness of outputs of 10
smaller, open LMs across three aspects: task types, application domains and
reasoning types, using diverse prompt styles. We demonstrate that most
effective models and prompt styles vary depending on the specific requirements.
Our analysis provides a comparative assessment of LMs and prompt styles using a
proposed three-tier schema of aspects for their strategic selection based on
use-case and other constraints. We also show that if utilized appropriately,
these LMs can compete with, and sometimes outperform, SOTA LLMs like
DeepSeek-v2, GPT-3.5-Turbo, and GPT-4o. | [
-0.3359995186,
-0.9298601747,
0.8371314406,
0.2446705103,
0.0900508836,
-0.1272850782,
-0.5508303642,
-0.4108676016,
-0.302408278,
0.5286473632,
-0.5135082006,
-0.4267272353,
-0.4628139436,
0.3239447773,
-0.280857265,
0.7424131036,
-0.3255318105,
0.0920166969,
-0.2973071337,
-0.2446356267,
-0.7511781454,
-0.5013831258,
-0.5631103516,
-0.2184192687,
0.3891767561,
0.6693862677,
0.8834522367,
0.2062124312,
0.5793341398,
0.2255876511,
-0.0840323493,
0.0281153116,
-0.2970903218,
0.2193444818,
-0.265945226,
-0.2436567247,
-0.4975696504,
0.0815694332,
0.4544740021,
0.7155973315,
0.0626438484,
0.1498712599,
-0.0307982806,
0.5012620091,
-0.6284400225,
0.1940319538,
-0.5482792854,
-0.1226150915,
-0.3497048914,
0.1268169582,
-0.4977212846,
-0.5180613399,
0.4472735226,
-0.4968908131,
-0.1040935591,
0.3193520308,
0.878516376,
0.0055856402,
-0.2136689872,
-0.5020903945,
-0.8612473607,
0.7220685482,
-1.0702270269,
0.5108965039,
0.2330575585,
0.5955631137,
-0.2021062672,
-0.6320000887,
-0.5072814822,
-0.6320074797,
-0.1232989877,
-0.1018150002,
-0.2573738694,
0.0496653914,
0.2700264752,
0.4315329492,
-0.6766449213,
0.5437099338,
-0.245329693,
-0.1513295174,
0.1974090785,
0.2841466665,
0.4757767022,
-0.0377375521,
-0.2477423847,
0.126330018,
-0.9021975398,
0.0885621011,
0.2857384682,
0.8147732615,
-0.0397611484,
0.8506259918,
-0.350964129,
0.7773985863,
-0.2086481601,
-0.1043528244,
-0.024078263,
-0.6324857473,
-0.3695433736,
-0.2462918609,
0.7425176501,
0.2806068063,
0.2707403302,
-0.1543356478,
-0.3959594965,
-0.0018065153,
0.0892635584,
-0.5453600287,
0.2775765955,
0.3843271434,
-0.4454435408,
0.0842978284,
-0.3542685509,
-0.4466844201,
-0.3631166816,
-0.2934747338,
0.5633388162,
-0.5583127141,
-0.3339961469,
0.3120743036,
0.0375691466,
0.0185054615,
0.4346289635,
-0.6606563926,
0.4336315691,
0.5672687888,
0.7814719677,
-0.416480571,
-0.1577529907,
-0.4120274782,
-0.2514586449,
-0.3756952584,
0.5779139996,
-0.5676571131,
-0.4097864628,
0.2743195593,
-0.1632549167,
-0.0717949569,
-0.6163372993,
0.7947949171,
-0.6978226304,
0.3853160143,
-0.370955795,
-0.6720571518,
0.1082986817,
0.1374191046,
-0.7231710553,
1.131180644,
0.2760309875,
-0.6152521968,
0.5351999402,
-0.7113221884,
-0.1962308586,
0.1749324352,
-0.2079246789,
-0.0315824002,
0.1226857007,
-0.171858117,
0.4553447962,
-0.4615749717,
0.2264744937,
-0.2244894058,
-0.2588311136,
0.3049270511,
0.0786990523,
0.6130333543,
0.4977661073,
-0.2491426021,
0.4875134528,
-0.8141536117,
-0.124111861,
0.2541556656,
-0.243126139,
-0.5711535811,
-0.1119627431,
-0.2884011269,
0.2186976373,
0.1251680404,
-0.6310604215,
0.1493247747,
-0.3754847944,
0.524864614,
0.4805115461,
-0.3133265674,
0.6126223207,
0.0336737595,
0.5608435273,
-0.0794194341,
0.1666634679,
0.0277497005,
-0.4316375554,
-0.8197200894,
-0.4080394208,
0.3028959632,
0.4041603804,
-0.7481759787,
0.1003119722,
-0.0077852006,
-0.5001477003,
-0.2828347087,
-0.2116312385,
0.3407015502,
0.4068185091,
0.1385697126,
-0.1403711587,
-0.3372405171,
-1.0052938461,
-0.4845170677,
-0.1996394247,
0.1154229417,
0.4469903409,
0.5591337681,
-0.0710278898,
1.1757858992,
-0.2837053239,
0.1211458966,
-0.4758807719,
-0.0504409038,
0.2857111692,
0.188272357,
0.4732182026,
-0.381683439,
-0.3059659004,
0.0272724908,
-0.4883163869,
-0.1812523305,
0.1624048799,
-0.0932260826,
0.2717027664,
0.2911660671,
-0.897223711,
0.3363952935,
0.4073363245,
-0.4197058678,
0.7093920112,
-0.1156220734,
0.0354172103,
-0.5705673695,
0.0245347992,
0.0435229726,
-0.0512960218,
-0.868942678,
0.220770672,
0.3020076752,
-0.2398697287,
-0.4675503671,
0.8251805305,
-0.4045114815,
-0.2024465948,
-0.1546559185,
0.285404712,
-0.0098475236,
0.2181218117,
0.1795975715,
0.8940169811,
0.5322059393,
-0.7409997582,
0.1897148788,
-0.0282014012,
-0.6569696665,
0.2041076571,
-0.7102681398,
0.0459671021,
-0.039527107,
0.0306371581,
-0.8966817856,
-0.1961046159,
0.1490703672,
-0.1567612439,
0.0810069144,
0.2348490655,
-0.7036516666,
-0.2714759111,
-0.1156393066,
0.2561202049,
0.4218178093,
-0.2856251597,
0.4891013205,
0.0062937671,
-0.362498045,
-0.2932983637,
-0.3257222772,
-0.050396461,
-0.2618210614,
-0.6247729659,
-0.0051625394,
0.0360621326,
-0.5695593953,
0.0535029955,
-0.2251159549,
0.1119180769,
0.2673729062,
0.0119546922,
0.3186056018,
-0.49022156,
0.0108111305,
-0.0943569168,
0.0558305271,
-0.1892799139,
-0.1937942952,
0.4628707767,
-0.4180645645,
-0.4653891027,
-0.0754797459,
0.3567035198,
0.4256717563,
-0.3124153614,
0.671138823,
0.2273473889,
-0.4327122569,
-0.3571813405,
-0.409176439,
-0.130504176,
-0.4222156107,
0.2078908533,
-0.5461096168,
-1.2063685656,
0.3886768818,
0.1265809983,
0.1565981209,
0.4030081034,
0.7509874105,
0.1963465661,
0.8352157474,
0.5123029947,
0.448251009,
0.2974655032,
0.0191878378,
0.4177237451,
-0.4967979789,
-0.3240271807,
-0.8508422971,
0.1421964467,
-0.3894581199,
-0.3066078126,
0.3042784035,
0.2043421566,
-0.2701737583,
0.526158154,
-0.0162503943,
0.2064644396,
0.6806060672,
-0.2349214852,
0.3821989596,
-0.1253957301,
-0.2903418541,
0.0162703935,
-0.6764304042,
-0.96294415,
0.7845296264,
0.6283831596,
0.7742772698,
0.3224132657,
0.2675689161,
0.0525015183,
0.1982076168,
-0.8704021573,
0.6816151142,
-0.1428138763,
-0.8096883893,
-0.5018629432,
-0.1608123481,
-0.7728436589,
0.2896465957,
-0.0718051717,
-0.8715005517,
0.1246224791,
0.1255857497,
-0.5897467732,
0.1025391445,
-0.7372851372,
1.0538779497,
-0.0901594013,
-0.1571494341,
0.0406705923,
-0.61429739,
0.3600738943,
-0.0191502366,
0.200086087,
-0.3328791559,
-0.0980616882,
0.3777725697,
-0.4576039612,
0.7082547545,
0.0203349106,
-0.4394751787,
0.5185247064,
0.347311765,
0.4267822504,
-0.3148810267,
-0.1067464724,
0.1580505073,
0.0371561274,
-0.1840229481,
-0.7372533083,
0.5541668534,
-0.6659644246,
-0.7815015316,
-0.2932862341,
-0.4606017768,
-0.7149677873,
0.3640680015,
0.1982139796,
0.6738455296,
-0.3325465322,
0.119750455,
0.5693401694,
-0.2769897282,
0.3913656473,
0.8066605926,
-0.3159268796,
0.0627924576,
0.8017266393,
0.1493853331,
0.6268138885,
0.2554836869,
0.390663296,
-0.2850763798,
-0.8143563867,
-0.6662909389,
0.0461123995,
-0.7723092437,
0.0926429555,
-0.6546720862,
0.01112122,
-0.5675153732,
0.1539063156,
-0.3405575156,
-0.5220033526,
-0.2365651131,
-0.0408717431,
0.2152850926,
0.7339277864,
0.2795886993,
0.2758559883,
-0.7326768637,
0.0086556682,
0.1445870697,
0.4275501072,
-0.049835097,
-0.4010120928,
-0.1082769632,
-0.181328088,
-0.0270653553,
-0.8775924444,
0.062655881,
-0.0065411869,
0.7192802429,
0.1272835433,
-0.098136045,
0.2164159119,
-0.6597805023,
1.1394188404,
0.0115571972,
-0.788782239,
0.5234487057,
-0.4611265659,
0.1274148524,
0.4425887465,
0.4695016444,
-0.4159215093,
-0.4010749757,
-0.4539834261,
-0.6552111506,
0.7816035151,
0.4007647932,
-0.096394904,
-0.0985577181,
0.2379897982,
0.5899637341,
0.2407156229,
-0.453704834,
-0.2031763643,
-0.1395478547,
-0.2195501477,
-0.0239979234,
-0.1895268112,
0.0009856543,
0.2307643443,
0.6747310758,
-0.0503845997,
-0.0198147353,
0.0005315037,
-0.0828693658,
0.1912423968,
0.7224351168,
0.645753324,
0.7056649923,
-0.2588298917,
0.1349225491,
0.0546709113,
-0.1846004277,
0.023952648,
-0.1970528811,
-0.3450737596,
0.0492115133,
0.3041226864,
1.1360197067,
0.0924973488,
-0.8464752436,
0.469250232,
-0.1368261278,
0.1665277034,
0.1779815555,
0.1237760186,
-0.0220141932,
0.2333179265,
-0.1254497916,
-0.0713910088,
0.2772090137,
-0.7319937348,
-0.3563295305,
0.5193650126,
-0.2165737003,
-0.3069700301,
0.336461395,
0.3709494174,
-0.3555628657,
0.2016820461,
-0.1522704363,
-0.0604012348,
0.3909742534,
0.6448463202,
0.8581238985,
0.0574344806,
0.1247130781,
0.1258868128,
0.4053486884,
-0.217621848,
0.5002589822,
0.1963231713,
-0.805749476,
-0.4516168237,
-0.4592749774,
-0.7297343016,
0.3368110061,
-0.5589177608,
0.2670457661,
-0.2682208419,
-0.3590545356,
-0.1696913987,
-0.1572610736,
-0.8338857889,
0.2382220626,
0.0722497106,
1.2710707188,
-0.746632874,
0.6751702428,
0.9388686419,
-0.4106649458,
-0.9832255244,
-0.2270165533,
0.0330501013,
-0.8195977807,
0.8235452771,
-0.1481262445,
-0.1656765342,
-0.2998726368,
-0.400298208,
-0.9782301188,
0.7769104242,
0.2969211638,
-0.48631832,
-0.0852152184,
0.1093929037,
0.5070394874,
-0.5235362053,
0.4042392373,
0.8540393114,
0.3444836438,
-0.0061244327,
-1.2825068235,
0.1069329083,
0.0643468499,
0.3389011025,
0.0809056982,
-0.5167645812,
0.9749180079,
-0.1750922501,
-0.4041280746,
0.3722156882,
0.7532750368,
0.52611655,
0.2381785959,
0.4750089943,
0.2433001101,
0.5394262671,
-0.1524289399,
1.1004319191,
-0.0880836025,
0.1710532159,
1.1546894312,
-0.6658469439,
0.808781743,
0.3933151662,
-0.1872771233,
0.4110169709,
0.7715510726,
0.5080122352,
0.4440557361,
0.2480275482,
0.0563302822,
-0.065538682,
-0.2884310782,
-0.3632020056,
0.28403759,
0.3479145169,
-0.0301126596,
-0.2883759439,
0.0077237003,
0.1506401002,
0.0732073635,
-0.2841414511,
0.5596290231,
0.0636275709,
-0.7931248546,
0.2794724405,
0.17748487,
0.5142204165,
-0.5752958059,
0.1746189743,
-0.2934398651,
0.0000344196,
-0.0649553835,
-0.8648280501,
-0.0114227869,
0.2528351545,
0.0574103706,
-0.2430396974,
1.085060358,
-0.317558229,
-0.1484508812,
0.1219575331,
0.8235144019,
0.1435218751,
0.0966642722,
-0.3429709971,
0.4396108687,
-0.454603225,
-0.32102862,
0.2504015267,
0.5661598444,
-0.3555233777,
0.5941314101,
0.2826585174,
0.240035668,
0.1508208811,
0.3635219932,
0.749974966,
-0.5465109348,
-0.3634798527,
-0.7888580561,
0.4463162422,
0.0179408714,
-0.5179168582,
1.139051795,
0.3566883206,
0.9056009054,
-0.1332657039,
0.7778345942,
-0.0132551175,
0.6793234348,
-0.7366133332,
0.1396841258,
-0.4460937083,
0.2078153491,
-0.3453221023,
-0.9244915843,
-0.0570856035,
0.2953384519,
-0.4783089161,
0.1000579745,
0.7821854949,
0.6259547472,
0.0947785676,
0.490413785,
0.2960009277,
0.217901662,
0.1979018003,
0.258993715,
1.3152118921,
0.0065347659,
0.1374462694,
-0.0975336134,
-0.4861531556,
-0.3114666939,
-1.0677448511,
-0.887108326,
-0.4185109735,
-0.3075432181,
-0.3747823536,
-0.046413146,
0.9256461263,
0.5570087433,
-0.9039306641,
-0.388597846,
0.2425428033,
-0.0151986871,
-0.0467586033,
-0.1863013059,
0.1092421412,
-0.4565735161,
-0.5605818033,
0.5640097857,
0.3512656689,
-0.0174726993,
-0.432741493,
-0.1453224421,
0.0111359162,
0.3584545553,
0.8922452331,
0.2750613391,
-1.0590367317,
-0.5125542879,
0.3323690295,
-0.3822517991,
-0.2834173739,
1.1373845339,
-0.5197483897,
0.2511945069,
0.6830176115,
0.5328271389,
-0.0028614891,
-0.2854567766,
0.59252882,
-0.4956149161,
-0.1413483173,
0.3014473617,
0.5549777746,
0.2507219017,
-0.0069710738,
0.5092369914,
-0.0403206311,
-0.4849564731,
-0.9790361524,
0.3668404818,
-0.7958229184,
-0.5448574424,
1.5239295959,
-0.0812974796,
-0.0201052129,
-0.0826620162,
-0.4148893654,
-0.0363510586,
-0.3568864465,
0.1313958019,
0.9747042656,
-0.383525461,
0.1682836562,
-0.7591459155,
0.6594332457,
0.4125565886,
-0.659219265,
0.067609556,
0.4992235005,
0.2370695621,
0.1586482674,
0.8030616641,
-0.145467788,
0.0256045163,
-0.2174773365,
-0.0048692189,
-0.0215864684,
-0.4681814313,
-0.3920934498,
0.1777923405,
0.5019394755,
-0.0471552536
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11400v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11400v1 | Large Language Models and Knowledge Graphs for Astronomical Entity Disambiguation | 2024-06-17T10:38:03 | 2024-06-17T10:38:03 | Golnaz Shapurian | cs.CL | cs.CL, astro-ph.IM | This paper presents an experiment conducted during a hackathon, focusing on
using large language models (LLMs) and knowledge graph clustering to extract
entities and relationships from astronomical text. The study demonstrates an
approach to disambiguate entities that can appear in various contexts within
the astronomical domain. By collecting excerpts around specific entities and
leveraging the GPT-4 language model, relevant entities and relationships are
extracted. The extracted information is then used to construct a knowledge
graph, which is clustered using the Leiden algorithm. The resulting Leiden
communities are utilized to identify the percentage of association of unknown
excerpts to each community, thereby enabling disambiguation. The experiment
showcases the potential of combining LLMs and knowledge graph clustering
techniques for information extraction in astronomical research. The results
highlight the effectiveness of the approach in identifying and disambiguating
entities, as well as grouping them into meaningful clusters based on their
relationships. | [
-0.4941679239,
-0.9939715862,
0.9747510552,
-0.038558498,
-0.1034264266,
0.2909644842,
-0.3732157946,
-0.8507663608,
0.5850892663,
0.5449876189,
-0.4064941406,
-0.5293229818,
-0.6632636189,
0.2435121983,
-0.7049206495,
0.7288595438,
0.0673739985,
0.0518813357,
-0.3028632402,
0.1883531958,
-0.1470416188,
-0.2586872578,
-0.5313892961,
-0.0376016051,
0.7531593442,
0.1779947281,
0.5471071601,
0.7333436608,
0.9965074658,
0.3779832125,
-0.3692416847,
0.1255091429,
-0.3005945683,
-0.0526431762,
-0.3494614363,
-0.3850344121,
-0.2772039473,
-0.0749802813,
0.6366000175,
1.0712224245,
-0.0336783901,
0.2052235007,
-0.2368312776,
0.3963518441,
-0.2163003981,
0.4803076088,
-0.7997189164,
-0.1956703514,
-0.6532182097,
0.0112429168,
-0.1458672881,
-0.3337425292,
0.1179479286,
-0.951323092,
0.2467959523,
0.5151650906,
0.8001747131,
0.2893261313,
-0.2318889499,
-0.5572080016,
-0.7866049409,
0.9011526704,
-0.5108168125,
0.3996893764,
0.3113889396,
0.2671240568,
-0.1522180438,
-0.7979435921,
-0.8270133138,
-0.2151228487,
-0.1174854487,
-0.0028083315,
-0.079257682,
-0.1391884834,
0.1860768497,
0.2398737669,
-0.5156977177,
0.4081952572,
-0.614248991,
-0.1545209736,
0.3661329746,
-0.0151603399,
0.2921231389,
-0.5183417797,
-0.1860687286,
0.0828175768,
-0.8210163713,
-0.6075555682,
0.4167335927,
0.1692907661,
0.4193781316,
0.92628932,
0.0662894025,
0.5896962881,
-0.1343634576,
-0.3836291432,
0.194232285,
-0.4564626813,
-0.0100808358,
-0.1067456156,
0.641051352,
0.097599335,
0.1294751018,
-0.4800466895,
-0.0015875387,
0.1774743199,
-0.0049430733,
-0.5365421176,
-0.3083633482,
0.047025308,
-0.456748575,
-0.292882055,
0.070856832,
-1.154476881,
-0.4490817189,
-0.3095517457,
0.1919761598,
-0.3142516315,
-0.5027546883,
-0.2151901275,
-0.2721108198,
-0.1777704209,
0.3834956288,
-0.8409596086,
0.3295500278,
0.8256697059,
0.6524995565,
-0.3929397464,
-0.3679546714,
0.2176106274,
0.5140656829,
0.0034363407,
0.5927640796,
-0.7821938992,
-0.5381007195,
-0.3277679384,
-0.1539934278,
0.1329229921,
-0.5125542283,
0.2539933324,
-0.9396326542,
0.1286558211,
-0.1645894498,
-1.1226011515,
-0.3387161195,
-0.0387105644,
-0.960963428,
0.9686093926,
0.1527139246,
-0.7303569317,
0.5309047103,
-0.8541369438,
-0.0218872931,
0.3006118834,
-0.5316961408,
-0.1388670951,
-0.2136859745,
0.2942196727,
0.3398520947,
-0.280076921,
0.2645168602,
-0.4609463513,
-0.0303184893,
0.10144867,
0.1007010639,
0.6160051823,
0.3803064823,
-0.210455969,
-0.2513281703,
-0.6559311748,
-0.4660915434,
0.2402826101,
-0.248595193,
-0.7829616666,
0.1769387424,
-0.046215415,
-0.1965448558,
0.4924970269,
-0.7800181508,
0.5707495809,
-0.3292736709,
0.2501021624,
0.4858552516,
0.2830079794,
0.6759383678,
0.2805345654,
0.2808231413,
0.1762736887,
-0.0333562456,
0.0630920604,
-0.6284244061,
-0.5693547726,
-0.1466396898,
0.1513492018,
0.2112553269,
-0.9625401497,
0.5073898435,
-0.3083912134,
-0.7999176979,
-0.3070398569,
0.1300448328,
0.1876948923,
0.8604747057,
0.3796497583,
-0.0006330997,
-0.5606621504,
-0.7063530087,
-0.1012548432,
-0.3395113349,
-0.0405893773,
0.3357439041,
0.7322931886,
-0.4155222178,
1.0841633081,
-0.8352891803,
-0.0232524928,
0.0392397344,
-0.0613622442,
0.2715336084,
0.2057453096,
0.7238715887,
-0.9646093845,
-0.183272928,
0.2484479547,
-0.7534840107,
0.0397438742,
0.3171390891,
-0.0990158245,
-0.0131762028,
0.6055066586,
-0.5839447975,
0.3714174032,
0.3625752926,
-0.375736922,
0.533074677,
0.0830932781,
0.2867442966,
-1.2425199747,
0.1626140624,
0.1215049848,
-0.3111781776,
-0.354001224,
-0.0248840507,
0.0066007995,
0.1784156412,
-0.2781917155,
0.535107255,
-0.6232725978,
-0.4779220521,
-0.3375177085,
0.5425895452,
-0.0845374092,
0.0956654176,
0.3760256469,
0.5640572309,
0.6647022963,
-0.5414018035,
0.5234357715,
0.4482671618,
-0.6571167111,
0.1528447121,
-0.3279898167,
-0.0597963706,
-0.1002356559,
0.2423580587,
-0.7968742847,
-0.2843305171,
-0.0193159152,
-0.2148898691,
0.0690328106,
-0.2026855797,
-0.5968987942,
-0.6136701703,
0.3149924576,
0.4172548652,
0.4682813883,
-0.5073161125,
0.2641948462,
0.8256106377,
-0.5189270377,
-0.4279375076,
-0.3905717731,
0.0299180504,
-0.6366027594,
-0.5539395213,
0.2612574399,
0.1377043575,
-0.56637609,
0.2019779235,
0.1419669688,
-0.2017706633,
0.1836464703,
0.2720274627,
0.5925045609,
-0.1440818608,
0.3666405082,
-0.1553141922,
0.0412599333,
0.0467796624,
-0.5547010899,
0.4335613251,
-0.0135599002,
-0.3825025856,
-0.021334365,
0.1454538554,
0.3016144931,
-0.0390279517,
0.9176707268,
0.5582895279,
-0.5847540498,
0.1002025604,
-0.6376505494,
-0.4233216941,
-0.4325128496,
0.6403445601,
-0.129985854,
-1.1847609282,
0.6999934316,
-0.5136626363,
0.0626980141,
0.625420928,
0.6039486527,
-0.1572933942,
0.4241661727,
0.6281865835,
-0.3803167641,
0.3837593794,
-0.1514495611,
0.1781392843,
-0.8558061123,
-0.1104076952,
-0.8113059998,
-0.1797491461,
-0.3702774942,
-0.646599412,
0.5028697252,
0.296518594,
-0.0823422819,
0.4571121931,
-0.4094073474,
0.7615087032,
0.2689759135,
-0.2301638722,
0.588950634,
0.015059296,
0.1390829235,
-0.0429798514,
-0.3423021734,
-0.7156217694,
1.1963382959,
0.1680252403,
0.7078811526,
0.3737770915,
0.79693681,
-0.0144344429,
0.5578331351,
-0.4492154717,
0.4025841653,
0.0637580901,
-0.7741972208,
-0.5600349903,
-0.8357268572,
-1.1314889193,
0.1251755506,
-0.0848070309,
-1.1706548929,
0.0454536192,
-0.1127040684,
-0.0269056484,
0.3226442635,
-0.6496892571,
0.5867276192,
-0.011974778,
0.1712728441,
-0.1694706678,
-0.5686353445,
0.4764437079,
-0.5634454489,
0.6091274023,
-0.0465060323,
0.0205891225,
0.9365724921,
-0.0622324646,
0.6930183172,
-0.2345069051,
-0.0911245719,
0.3829081059,
0.1888705045,
0.495977819,
0.1878208369,
-0.2568844855,
0.3777706921,
-0.0180880148,
-0.2570055723,
-0.3280600607,
0.9665771723,
-1.0306261778,
-0.5090624094,
-0.0534892194,
-0.4733971059,
-0.1054578424,
0.4529620409,
-0.0729095638,
0.1229134724,
-0.2239919156,
0.0339244902,
0.3610141277,
-0.1707960963,
0.4433832467,
0.6170303822,
-0.8376542926,
-0.0573066697,
0.8095496893,
0.044622764,
0.170259729,
0.3302001059,
0.0258000176,
-0.4712444246,
-0.7314277887,
-0.199042201,
0.4932561517,
-0.6787178516,
-0.1777779013,
-0.5690211058,
0.0158678312,
-0.5271259546,
-0.021232767,
-0.249391973,
-0.6561146379,
-0.3249382377,
-0.2923192084,
0.4564548433,
1.1785081625,
0.2616046071,
0.3418224454,
-0.779651463,
0.0188585538,
-0.210943982,
-0.1265850514,
-0.0852751508,
-0.0543612763,
-0.3986839652,
-0.2003669888,
-0.1880017221,
-1.0698325634,
0.3581015766,
0.0735642165,
0.5772910118,
0.2775840163,
-0.3534370661,
0.7199954391,
-0.5294695497,
0.9109802246,
0.3605853915,
-0.7122069001,
0.4876739085,
-0.5855626464,
-0.1910399944,
0.3615530729,
0.3761137724,
-0.4972151816,
-0.6184414029,
-0.6230515838,
-0.9299390316,
0.377161026,
0.2864521444,
-0.3955456018,
-0.0943227559,
0.8276218176,
0.2690256536,
0.3803804815,
-0.7475835681,
-0.2889610529,
0.261531949,
-0.1755007207,
-0.2078340501,
0.2129428834,
-0.2377882451,
-0.0007015312,
0.4939747751,
0.021806445,
0.0668577403,
0.1266808957,
-0.3058741987,
-0.1760968566,
-0.1560980827,
0.1606705636,
1.1025907993,
0.072856687,
0.1337750405,
0.0605138242,
-0.6426112652,
-0.3420809805,
0.1748400629,
-0.0950605944,
-0.0683021843,
0.4360502958,
0.4784183502,
0.0665117949,
-0.4174233675,
0.2840878963,
0.0561377704,
0.040723037,
-0.4387733936,
0.0269553885,
0.5853082538,
0.3517436981,
0.4725448489,
-0.0446118303,
0.2506819963,
-0.2388248593,
0.1869221181,
0.2147129476,
0.0841096342,
-0.2629099786,
0.6549580097,
0.2176435292,
0.0899326131,
0.5040470362,
-0.1694247574,
-0.2827182412,
0.8356680274,
0.3183556795,
0.3099306226,
-0.0015180713,
0.1848420501,
0.2972780466,
0.2748893797,
0.1350971162,
-0.0877464563,
0.1741582155,
-0.7492642403,
-0.7045585513,
-1.0273922682,
-0.4838398099,
-0.125982821,
-0.3962354958,
0.170857355,
0.0504843853,
-0.0138956448,
0.5134621263,
0.1178634763,
-0.7894430757,
-0.0723494217,
0.2538550198,
0.8807117939,
-0.6933929324,
0.9704747796,
0.7568135858,
-0.5029892325,
-1.0925389528,
-0.3392228782,
0.1711269766,
-0.823848784,
0.8438073993,
-0.2381328642,
0.1981298327,
0.1999201626,
-0.477666676,
-1.1870158911,
1.3523751497,
0.1262339354,
-0.9757351875,
0.0176025406,
0.1735780686,
0.5596089959,
-0.2996045351,
0.2869239748,
0.6267387271,
0.8653380871,
0.1514419764,
-1.0143494606,
-0.1925952137,
0.0316123515,
-0.1730738431,
0.5738084912,
-0.5668019652,
0.84897089,
0.1174031273,
-0.1135771871,
0.2232822627,
0.9257668257,
0.2355049253,
0.306412071,
0.436604768,
0.5115022063,
1.1213380098,
-0.2132418752,
0.8958489299,
-0.337159425,
0.8840449452,
0.7169195414,
-0.5673792958,
0.5208542943,
0.9550387859,
-0.4639017582,
0.4429083169,
0.7315674424,
0.0161118973,
0.2829934061,
0.1973246336,
-0.2259921134,
0.1962222606,
0.1111268252,
-0.2829008996,
0.3673381805,
0.6634532213,
-0.2812533975,
-0.3572892845,
-0.0276987702,
0.2882612646,
-0.1690368205,
-0.3252140284,
0.8342795372,
0.1308161318,
-0.7322112918,
-0.1466271132,
-0.0167244673,
0.405110091,
-0.5899323225,
-0.0397023857,
0.0193623081,
0.0836414024,
-0.2978144884,
-0.7874352932,
0.3246490359,
0.1911484748,
-0.1712028086,
0.0987490267,
0.7614539862,
-0.5222878456,
-0.6883054972,
0.2548769116,
0.7323385477,
0.5537644029,
0.1226551533,
-0.3716862798,
-0.1575224698,
0.0929500759,
-0.5063816905,
0.258944869,
0.5109616518,
-0.0447068512,
0.3992357552,
0.7571021318,
0.3910076022,
0.2416754216,
0.006783322,
1.0706927776,
-0.7332412601,
-0.3582630455,
-0.8325053453,
0.1907502562,
-0.2965171933,
-0.2354754806,
1.0811327696,
0.5976599455,
0.590013206,
-0.1061217487,
0.8215874434,
-0.3782704175,
0.7059372067,
-0.4075525701,
0.6599172354,
-0.4127606153,
0.4411287606,
-0.5311710835,
-1.3764492273,
-0.2541511953,
0.4400793016,
-0.3846059442,
0.0073890211,
0.7490867376,
0.7639949322,
-0.0899922773,
0.1481349021,
0.1414892226,
0.4401032329,
0.6854958534,
0.3615586162,
0.8824473023,
0.0803523362,
0.387172848,
-0.0840488747,
-0.4210094512,
-0.0978484526,
-0.8559756279,
-0.6352923512,
-0.6787365675,
-0.1843791604,
-0.132006228,
-0.2752036154,
0.5094836354,
0.4734288454,
-0.5095832944,
0.017273007,
-0.0912865251,
0.0970380604,
0.1676895916,
-0.2781625688,
0.5835171938,
-0.0680621639,
-0.9441800117,
0.6557805538,
0.3327872157,
-0.072472401,
-0.5705882907,
0.0269587561,
-0.0217414815,
-0.1438395083,
0.1926994324,
0.0625016466,
-0.5344535708,
-0.5226556063,
-0.0259571299,
0.004877978,
-0.3350305259,
0.5588582754,
-0.5746538043,
0.2286481857,
0.1462253779,
0.5495857,
0.6893531084,
-0.0002920982,
0.1368605047,
-0.7929974198,
0.3046477437,
0.205534175,
0.6254068613,
0.1301652789,
-0.4351571798,
0.6470876932,
0.4460678101,
-1.0153890848,
-0.6627066135,
0.3063635528,
-1.1423566341,
-0.3830372989,
1.3894690275,
-0.1318005025,
-0.410746485,
-0.1134558693,
-0.2126173973,
0.134029448,
-0.2745373249,
1.0474017859,
0.9885215759,
-0.3180667758,
0.1846588254,
-0.4204446375,
0.304923296,
0.1023003981,
-1.0593960285,
-0.2210832983,
0.6772440076,
0.2900343835,
0.7102559805,
0.3668593466,
-0.2771224976,
-0.1363050789,
-0.05110972,
0.2949962914,
0.0165252779,
-0.2442686409,
0.3000833094,
0.112850152,
0.0176231749,
0.1930578202
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11385v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11385v2 | MetaGPT: Merging Large Language Models Using Model Exclusive Task Arithmetic | 2024-06-17T10:12:45 | 2024-06-27T16:01:28 | Yuyan Zhou, Liang Song, Bingning Wang, Weipeng Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | The advent of large language models (LLMs) like GPT-4 has catalyzed the
exploration of multi-task learning (MTL), in which a single model demonstrates
proficiency across diverse tasks. Task arithmetic has emerged as a
cost-effective approach for MTL. It enables performance enhancement across
multiple tasks by adding their corresponding task vectors to a pre-trained
model. However, the current lack of a method that can simultaneously achieve
optimal performance, computational efficiency, and data privacy limits their
application to LLMs. In this paper, we propose \textbf{M}odel
\textbf{E}xclusive \textbf{T}ask \textbf{A}rithmetic for merging
\textbf{GPT}-scale models, which formalizes the objective of model merging into
a multi-task learning framework, aiming to minimize the average loss difference
between the merged model and each individual task model. Since data privacy
limits the use of multi-task training data, we leverage LLMs' local linearity
and task vectors' orthogonality to separate the data term and scaling
coefficients term and derive a model-exclusive task arithmetic method. Our
proposed MetaGPT is data-agnostic and bypasses the heavy search process, making
it cost-effective and easy to implement for LLMs.Extensive experiments
demonstrate that MetaGPT leads to improvements in task arithmetic and achieves
state-of-the-art performance on multiple tasks. | [
-0.4233603179,
-0.7466591001,
0.5198654532,
0.1210557148,
-0.2336613983,
-0.0407345891,
-0.2030740082,
-0.2350788414,
0.1235526055,
0.5189220905,
-0.5715069175,
-0.4286080599,
-0.7998579144,
-0.1547599882,
-0.2943928242,
1.077914834,
-0.2641661763,
0.0243369602,
-0.1851503104,
-0.3319629729,
-0.1030003577,
-0.8491934538,
-0.560405612,
-0.0796189085,
0.3440593779,
0.2120372355,
0.4912240207,
0.9126102328,
0.5486187935,
0.3591353297,
0.422241509,
0.437753886,
-0.2401695549,
0.121442534,
-0.0490741096,
-0.2269764543,
-1.1090714931,
0.1919733286,
0.7582662106,
0.5589087605,
-0.262444824,
0.5146163702,
0.2241510749,
0.4880731404,
-0.7316951752,
0.5338913202,
-0.3936902583,
0.093242377,
-0.3252266049,
-0.1474799514,
-0.2557783127,
-0.3258303702,
-0.2260047942,
-0.4367051721,
0.0515116677,
-0.1043347865,
0.2945659161,
0.3978079557,
-0.6023511291,
-0.0016259847,
-0.5627655983,
0.8236846924,
-0.7577576637,
0.6012814641,
0.2007288188,
0.1322910041,
0.2433307469,
-0.5610283017,
-0.463046968,
-0.0795374364,
0.0651328266,
-0.0757338852,
-0.3830234408,
0.1814645827,
0.3126444519,
0.3142193556,
-0.877387464,
-0.2382542789,
-0.2890646458,
0.0058086333,
0.311652869,
0.2830876112,
0.2745542526,
0.1650610715,
-0.3630923629,
0.166848883,
-0.7666244507,
-0.1244321391,
0.4005703926,
0.2175644487,
-0.0434579104,
0.7506395578,
-0.1726702005,
0.6152229309,
0.0084868278,
-0.1382693946,
0.435944885,
-0.3027533889,
-0.269203037,
-0.2997550368,
1.0077617168,
0.1613020152,
0.1286392212,
-0.2538709939,
-0.2432126403,
0.0993106663,
0.0817558691,
-0.9194139242,
-0.0233011767,
0.0207246412,
-0.2224522233,
-0.2618728578,
-0.2289918959,
-0.6193662286,
-0.0021679432,
-0.5591577291,
0.6618272066,
-0.1720633954,
-0.4704409838,
0.144407019,
0.4439505339,
-0.1445719004,
0.0897258073,
-0.9284329414,
0.3877845407,
0.943520844,
0.7025231123,
-0.127218008,
-0.481944263,
-0.8386913538,
0.1831341535,
-0.1033329889,
0.2610070407,
-0.5266947746,
-0.2532555163,
-0.1498703212,
-0.1710164398,
-0.4148974121,
-0.2316613495,
0.5987308025,
-0.5405333638,
0.2148699909,
-0.1797821224,
-0.505623281,
-0.3328329921,
0.3876595199,
-0.5878680944,
0.9996672869,
0.0219206493,
-0.7727250457,
0.085331127,
-0.9692197442,
-0.3675990999,
-0.0053832098,
-0.276486069,
-0.4337520599,
0.0802614912,
0.3532360792,
0.5682989955,
-0.3750653565,
0.3683441579,
-0.4448557198,
-0.1346722096,
-0.0385682993,
-0.5966522098,
0.7033022642,
0.1487069428,
-0.500944078,
0.1164946258,
-0.3925564289,
0.2778893709,
-0.0566423722,
-0.3093005717,
-0.2655815482,
-0.1479512304,
-0.1386291683,
0.2873337865,
0.6218676567,
-0.4430184066,
0.3713679016,
-0.1256078482,
0.4562493563,
0.6900022626,
-0.4312354922,
0.4959870875,
-0.3109894395,
0.6011351347,
-0.2764756978,
0.1910923868,
-0.0883752331,
-0.4958490729,
-0.5453047156,
-0.4550398886,
0.2437411398,
0.7819061279,
-0.6286824942,
0.3507635891,
-0.6652023792,
-0.4284696579,
-0.4369856715,
0.2100218534,
0.5140027404,
0.3289550245,
0.3619003892,
-0.0999593064,
-0.2968170047,
-0.7318664789,
-0.4534193575,
0.093531996,
-0.1089614034,
0.4492421746,
0.2359501272,
-0.1009319946,
0.8284961581,
-0.6000733972,
-0.3177247345,
-0.1678757668,
0.380325526,
0.2810839713,
0.6539765596,
0.3852522671,
-0.775256753,
-0.6427866817,
-0.0060765287,
-0.8137348294,
-0.1437032074,
0.3456026018,
0.0198265463,
-0.0066029858,
0.3035880625,
-0.9460691214,
0.2808722258,
0.8167310953,
-0.1552367359,
0.3217582405,
-0.4945994318,
0.4773055613,
-1.1520321369,
-0.0053630997,
-0.1467840225,
-0.4169458151,
-0.7514553666,
0.3291399479,
0.3503122628,
-0.4214872718,
-0.339692682,
0.3295785785,
-0.5229372382,
-0.1078158617,
-0.4010814726,
-0.1654871851,
-0.3253810108,
0.7360188365,
-0.1641745567,
0.8427649736,
0.7632947564,
-0.3951615691,
0.2118408978,
-0.0836858898,
0.2988809347,
0.5586363673,
-0.4437496066,
0.4015410244,
-0.025269771,
0.1519289911,
-0.8458927274,
0.0585060008,
0.2741927207,
-0.4751083851,
0.3219085336,
-0.3643238544,
-0.5195412636,
-0.031313587,
-0.2552731037,
0.9710167646,
0.3843118548,
-0.4662518799,
1.1527293921,
0.414635092,
-0.3912885189,
-0.7697896361,
-0.5023868084,
0.0870318934,
-0.2422726303,
-0.7464147806,
0.2203664929,
-0.1861274391,
0.1402081996,
0.1874171644,
-0.2695563138,
-0.2843416333,
-0.3492350876,
0.1409949213,
0.3569225073,
-0.2683998942,
-0.1796706617,
0.0152032422,
-0.3388874531,
0.0771848783,
-0.6307070255,
0.4770747125,
-0.1039249077,
-0.6115325689,
-0.0797734931,
0.4352535605,
0.888291657,
-0.6609782577,
0.6047898531,
0.7503496408,
-0.4271991253,
0.0058120759,
-0.7281524539,
0.0706613883,
-0.477986306,
0.3496025205,
-0.4918479621,
-1.0965147018,
0.4023628533,
-0.0019255361,
0.4063867331,
0.3155310154,
0.5314817429,
0.36332497,
1.0274338722,
0.5768262148,
-0.1891696453,
0.3561842442,
-0.1560440361,
0.3395293355,
-0.8560304642,
0.1031107754,
-0.3391142488,
-0.1563115865,
-0.6479951143,
-0.7669529319,
0.6293110251,
-0.4105753601,
-0.3891477883,
0.3725682795,
-0.3381159902,
0.5996579528,
0.5302756429,
0.3304333091,
0.3718520701,
-0.0889731348,
0.0881621093,
-0.1198713481,
-0.4530778527,
-0.0936860219,
1.497651577,
0.0831347331,
0.6159686446,
0.2480963916,
0.8419662118,
0.1965236068,
0.3024409413,
-0.5149342418,
0.7037601471,
-0.5189148188,
-0.5877656937,
-0.3886051178,
-0.9060328603,
-0.6607757211,
0.7123600245,
-0.0873132646,
-0.5751588345,
-0.1046851352,
0.1774378121,
-0.0675241873,
0.5014171004,
-0.4516154528,
0.9765716791,
-0.158896029,
-0.449729085,
-0.332024008,
-0.414865911,
0.6752232909,
-0.4037029743,
0.5015426874,
-0.103241384,
-0.2450232506,
0.729329288,
-0.3663396537,
0.7015562654,
-0.2026040405,
-0.0096871993,
-0.0983816311,
0.3018793762,
0.9383538961,
-0.1964289695,
0.3367759585,
0.3094021082,
-0.3071947694,
-0.3461228907,
-0.5177947879,
0.7668201327,
-0.4339508414,
-0.586491406,
-0.3049474955,
-0.9266378284,
-0.3845018148,
0.4105779231,
0.0030307993,
0.7385783792,
0.1960055977,
0.153285563,
0.6221800447,
0.1398301572,
0.3085401058,
0.7002496719,
-0.1187225431,
-0.6207415462,
1.0299785137,
0.1732845902,
0.23030065,
0.5537400842,
0.2107414752,
-0.4038527608,
-0.3954983056,
-0.421938777,
0.1172278523,
-0.5846431255,
-0.1648316532,
-0.80893749,
-0.0459925495,
-0.3510224223,
0.0665397421,
-0.4739783406,
-0.5176003575,
0.1681713909,
-0.0444540717,
0.0409167036,
0.5924854875,
-0.3430874348,
0.2617305219,
-0.9804393053,
0.5140960813,
0.4807113707,
0.2920464575,
0.0059981486,
-0.3659032881,
-0.1418453604,
0.0667972937,
-0.3106737733,
-0.7727597356,
0.4009425044,
0.1379039586,
0.5801995993,
0.3109184802,
-0.0380932763,
0.5442219377,
-0.8411923051,
0.4398716688,
0.302710861,
-1.1910457611,
-0.092895031,
-0.5664590001,
0.0697234645,
0.2653867006,
0.2771344483,
-0.3209173381,
-0.4469025731,
-0.5835387111,
-0.9098868966,
0.6379309893,
0.2844740152,
0.0311935768,
0.3297204971,
0.1236895025,
-0.1563959867,
0.4499732852,
-0.879864037,
-0.5219822526,
0.0065608947,
-0.4831441045,
-0.1067776084,
-0.0869093388,
-0.2156739086,
-0.2752735019,
0.4133006036,
-0.0036883831,
0.2407007515,
-0.3987793326,
-0.1212474331,
0.0114882626,
0.300644666,
0.5281308293,
0.6689750552,
-0.0829015151,
0.3550603092,
0.3494820297,
-0.6220679283,
0.314661473,
0.3870722651,
0.0202076081,
-0.117836751,
0.2138528377,
0.4995217025,
0.4399453998,
-0.2629702687,
0.7106018662,
0.0893660709,
-0.4717207849,
0.0165058486,
-0.0574764982,
0.1382183731,
0.3767132759,
0.2801517844,
0.1197260246,
0.2630988955,
-0.1705139875,
0.4266503155,
0.5839319229,
0.0141510991,
-0.2739417851,
0.9180300832,
0.1326038539,
-0.0661099553,
0.3063679338,
-0.2248054296,
-0.7208210826,
0.3277308047,
0.38242203,
1.1052401066,
-0.5943195224,
-0.0823465809,
0.2224615216,
0.5397987366,
-0.1074397415,
0.2688489854,
-0.2251608074,
-0.4159805775,
-0.8336174488,
-0.3656874001,
-0.41007182,
0.0021784613,
-0.516734004,
0.0286076516,
-0.1412848234,
-0.0738989562,
-0.2166403532,
-0.1694250554,
-0.6725394726,
0.0924547389,
-0.0607366264,
0.4242466986,
-0.8340898156,
0.8764469028,
0.59557271,
-0.1609376669,
-0.8809280992,
-0.1103906706,
0.0589962266,
-0.9498513341,
0.6172475219,
0.1264900863,
-0.1909538209,
0.0778840557,
-0.0879820883,
-0.8988058567,
0.9330550432,
0.7181259394,
-0.4743458331,
-0.1203507185,
0.4996971786,
-0.041459322,
-0.3093665838,
0.2102216929,
0.3150001466,
0.5425783992,
0.1130142212,
-1.1419012547,
0.3079889417,
-0.0751161426,
-0.4878610373,
0.666790843,
-0.415537864,
1.3147488832,
-0.1050677747,
-0.0483180098,
-0.2979409397,
0.4297647774,
0.1379255652,
0.246635586,
0.6508709192,
0.8168312311,
0.6682869792,
-0.0504980199,
0.5520845056,
-0.5582068563,
0.8264274597,
0.933506608,
-0.080318056,
0.6261273623,
0.1174330413,
-0.2716597021,
-0.1767727584,
0.2198898792,
0.2352889329,
0.4068649411,
-0.0012203001,
-0.5960376263,
-0.3949697316,
0.3240142465,
-0.4810582697,
0.1838287562,
0.0458880737,
-0.192071721,
-0.5201733112,
-0.0876115113,
0.2446941286,
-0.3916182518,
-0.2800325453,
0.6936439872,
0.0050037121,
-0.3842172325,
0.4028796554,
0.1049248129,
0.7056638598,
-0.744951725,
0.0443915427,
-0.0908025205,
0.2594693601,
-0.2054721713,
-0.5052076578,
0.2635008395,
0.0154886488,
-0.1767062694,
-0.2432046235,
0.394854784,
-0.8271850348,
-0.5552054644,
0.0699261725,
0.7238153219,
0.1400699615,
-0.4579998255,
-0.7545981407,
-0.0510822535,
-0.0332708284,
-0.2077306211,
0.4860764146,
0.5556146502,
0.2133631259,
0.5964509249,
0.7760266662,
0.0721015185,
0.1921227425,
-0.3163096607,
0.8268651962,
-0.4405680001,
-0.6624600291,
-1.1532958746,
0.3862750828,
0.2463789433,
0.0286798533,
0.7025498152,
0.7731818557,
0.5255777836,
-0.0477092974,
0.9010780454,
-0.0355225094,
0.4166768193,
-0.4948992729,
0.5681996942,
-0.675372839,
0.0748480856,
-0.2014684379,
-1.0704777241,
-0.093017973,
0.4039238095,
-0.2380123734,
0.2315386385,
0.7992888093,
0.6639864445,
-0.52641505,
-0.1124381498,
0.425247401,
-0.1104428917,
0.4252204299,
0.9317156672,
0.3453997374,
-0.3136335313,
0.6541422009,
-0.0949178785,
-0.5398100615,
-0.00567309,
-0.9403142929,
-0.7671678066,
-0.477723062,
-0.1883288026,
-0.0451109856,
-0.0803224668,
0.9571617842,
0.767803371,
-0.4381914735,
-0.312435478,
-0.0652415752,
-0.0980743691,
-0.2258721143,
-0.1398127973,
0.6485882401,
-0.3404487967,
-0.9621971846,
0.3346343637,
0.2596458197,
-0.1216199845,
-0.2404487878,
-0.060105335,
0.2560740411,
0.0836245418,
0.4769138396,
0.1550890207,
-0.4442423582,
0.1779113561,
-0.0253541972,
-0.0206044335,
-0.0523748882,
1.0698586702,
-0.2552971244,
0.321762532,
0.4018176496,
0.8354895115,
0.6384789944,
0.0362231918,
0.6500704288,
-0.7026777864,
0.0075129294,
0.0106333559,
0.4773477316,
0.1229429394,
-0.360622257,
0.5792379975,
0.2555528581,
-0.6671645641,
-0.7675592303,
0.180324778,
-0.9078717828,
0.1049453989,
1.0199991465,
-0.2937777638,
0.0942351222,
0.0891762227,
-0.0146960178,
0.1770782769,
-0.3132943511,
0.3616721034,
0.5899249315,
-0.2311118543,
-0.1707502306,
-0.8759809732,
0.3291478753,
0.3025746644,
-0.8387506008,
0.4453433752,
0.3308941126,
0.3653153777,
0.0020493353,
0.6361514926,
-0.0948961899,
0.17280972,
-0.211006552,
0.0873142034,
-0.6296257973,
-0.2427049279,
-0.1641300172,
0.4105787873,
-0.1629535556,
-0.556332171
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11380v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11380v1 | A Realistic Evaluation of LLMs for Quotation Attribution in Literary Texts: A Case Study of LLaMa3 | 2024-06-17T09:56:46 | 2024-06-17T09:56:46 | Gaspard Michel, Elena V. Epure, Romain Hennequin, Christophe Cerisara | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) zero-shot and few-shot performance are subject
to memorization and data contamination, complicating the assessment of their
validity. In literary tasks, the performance of LLMs is often correlated to the
degree of book memorization. In this work, we carry out a realistic evaluation
of LLMs for quotation attribution in novels, taking the instruction fined-tuned
version of Llama3 as an example. We design a task-specific memorization measure
and use it to show that Llama3's ability to perform quotation attribution is
positively correlated to the novel degree of memorization. However, Llama3
still performs impressively well on books it has not memorized nor seen. Data
and code will be made publicly available. | [
0.3161111772,
-0.6065596342,
0.7357573509,
0.195651263,
-0.4357189238,
-0.0372563004,
-0.0826365799,
-0.4251646399,
0.0773991495,
0.726549983,
-0.3180386424,
-0.4534293413,
-0.3498649895,
0.2280374914,
-0.5147622824,
0.9863772988,
-0.3402824402,
-0.2860901356,
-0.5623339415,
0.017257018,
-0.3028808534,
-0.6539347768,
-0.4584854245,
-0.5336312652,
0.9201858044,
0.4457380474,
0.3763714731,
0.7656466365,
0.773416698,
0.267978698,
0.0246510729,
-0.1320668161,
-0.5408509374,
0.2731838226,
-0.0805518776,
-1.0536946058,
-0.193961516,
0.189686209,
0.9517478943,
0.033909291,
-0.039373152,
0.1626157165,
0.0448557064,
0.4834386408,
-0.7419605851,
0.1258892566,
-0.7452039719,
0.0046934783,
-0.4038515389,
-0.4285439849,
-0.3418143094,
-0.8241252303,
-0.1585092694,
-0.5945870876,
0.1066622436,
0.1695383936,
0.8277282119,
0.3210361898,
-0.3386214375,
-0.4440032244,
-0.672776103,
1.2564575672,
-0.7337539196,
-0.4230249822,
0.7023195028,
0.1716533154,
0.0660195053,
-0.4155566692,
-0.6030972004,
-0.5562632084,
0.0353920534,
0.1541818827,
0.0551433787,
-0.1616227031,
0.1140260845,
0.4181811213,
-0.1990592778,
0.0615796484,
-0.1800783277,
-0.049640961,
0.6588861346,
0.3054614365,
-0.0696653351,
-0.3509388268,
-0.6185382605,
-0.015544449,
-0.9069225192,
-0.1905955821,
0.5916649699,
0.1789752841,
0.1265382618,
0.6285287142,
0.243293643,
0.439222008,
-0.4449613094,
-0.4433120787,
0.1678006798,
-0.2471143603,
-0.1113178357,
0.1500868648,
0.7066020966,
0.5405026674,
0.7844178677,
-0.1575229764,
-0.2909350693,
0.0082826102,
0.4217507839,
-0.7571015954,
0.0395694189,
-0.0570266582,
-0.1749744713,
-0.4577031732,
-0.396399796,
-0.2916925251,
-0.6834528446,
-0.0612463467,
0.6253083944,
-0.407766968,
0.2011111081,
0.0448063314,
-0.3112972975,
0.2241432816,
0.3598846793,
-0.6253279448,
0.2651467323,
0.4465070963,
1.0158619881,
-0.337254554,
-0.378831476,
-0.1540226042,
0.6612532139,
-0.4583053291,
0.9724942446,
-0.4571239054,
-0.1910507977,
0.1553780288,
-0.2134213448,
-0.3597771227,
-0.6051674485,
0.8223609924,
-0.3296337724,
-0.2221267074,
-0.2619693577,
-0.9271762967,
-0.2861692309,
0.4629538059,
-0.8322882652,
0.6699031591,
-0.0728072524,
-0.4763191044,
0.1642487794,
-0.275337249,
-0.5015128255,
0.0229715686,
-0.2580222785,
-0.4086283147,
-0.0710787103,
-0.2695418,
0.66122365,
-0.4798588157,
-0.0922984183,
-0.2897550464,
-0.9809263349,
0.7155873775,
-0.5739545822,
0.5018939972,
0.0981843248,
-0.0110380715,
-0.2659529448,
-0.6768449545,
-0.0665462539,
0.170086652,
-0.4326858819,
-0.3824731708,
0.1076030657,
0.1191873327,
-0.3987703025,
0.3330411017,
-0.5869890451,
0.2158031166,
-0.2096522748,
0.2149329931,
0.5412275791,
0.3173241615,
0.0654122978,
-0.890122354,
0.5978236198,
-0.2349527776,
-0.1645452976,
-0.0825821608,
-0.1835127771,
-0.6100655794,
-0.6391949058,
0.2816155851,
0.8043595552,
-0.6003460288,
0.1650332808,
-0.1231532842,
-0.5782919526,
-0.1459712386,
0.2371410131,
0.7024738789,
0.1961067766,
0.0507219099,
-0.0121288095,
-0.1495697796,
-0.8190894723,
-0.7293531299,
-0.3542647958,
-0.0951740816,
0.2945130765,
0.5899415612,
0.2614533603,
0.6617342234,
-0.5874457359,
-0.7286249399,
-0.2619440854,
0.1640141904,
0.1452690363,
0.3733019829,
0.6474009156,
-0.1516141295,
-0.3762674332,
-0.1603988409,
-0.8688908815,
-0.0803866908,
-0.1886924505,
-0.0386005268,
-0.0759025812,
0.7060673833,
-0.391236335,
0.1847033948,
0.0998949856,
-0.1187976599,
0.6510497928,
-0.0430691354,
0.3759676218,
-0.9163006544,
0.0670895204,
0.0209980961,
-0.1930102408,
-0.3811766803,
-0.0445853174,
0.0665126517,
0.3709795475,
-0.6299335361,
0.4963700473,
-0.3222619593,
0.1907493621,
-0.0584230982,
0.2890251279,
0.1026499569,
0.4262285829,
-0.0679683685,
0.7071851492,
0.0258334186,
-0.4410326183,
0.5502878428,
0.1346389949,
-0.9713301659,
0.5074684024,
-0.5266239643,
0.0384052657,
0.1164776757,
0.079617478,
-0.9744228125,
-0.2712157071,
-0.0078001488,
-0.0260676518,
0.0733307377,
-0.0835915506,
-0.6932147145,
0.039619267,
-0.6154071093,
0.568713069,
0.2105935961,
-0.2483396977,
0.2274137139,
-0.0314058773,
-0.2330488414,
-0.5722849965,
-0.8645908833,
0.1234011054,
-0.7521471381,
-0.0045518256,
0.3593432903,
-0.0743307397,
-0.4052778184,
-0.2832317948,
0.0907250717,
-0.2263235301,
0.1327143759,
0.1821222901,
0.2952954769,
-0.0532234795,
0.2371580601,
-0.0538991205,
0.2633597851,
0.0226386748,
0.4609229565,
0.109610498,
-0.0836709961,
-0.4684793949,
-0.4498298466,
0.1258921623,
0.3343513906,
0.3046293557,
0.671477735,
0.251514703,
-0.4258898497,
-0.1599440128,
-0.6393142939,
0.1768685281,
-0.4587850273,
0.3163517714,
-0.387023747,
-0.519485414,
0.5742461085,
0.1605086476,
-0.0649952888,
0.3822880983,
0.5376377702,
-0.2789604068,
0.2434661835,
0.4134050012,
-0.0474233888,
0.551047802,
-0.0755108446,
-0.0602817312,
-0.7288498282,
-0.2320349216,
-0.6605003476,
-0.3170803487,
-0.1531151682,
-0.2780060768,
0.1282837391,
0.427210778,
-0.2383698076,
0.4225623906,
-0.0264877342,
1.0218491554,
0.3751160502,
-0.0540694557,
0.6432636976,
0.1041003019,
-0.0578029528,
-0.1553562284,
-0.2265428305,
-1.0758626461,
1.0856199265,
0.3839663863,
0.89153862,
0.3703915179,
0.6488809586,
0.6362820268,
0.3294860423,
-1.0021151304,
0.557207942,
-0.0566051081,
-0.7477281094,
-0.2990837693,
-0.3160213232,
-0.7823143005,
0.0961285904,
0.0962627754,
-0.8213101625,
0.0462752692,
0.0539131537,
-0.5233646631,
0.1320089996,
-0.6240906715,
0.7244186997,
-0.0810363218,
-0.3349780738,
-0.0907070562,
-0.2099416405,
0.4409378767,
-0.3941918314,
0.0397555642,
-0.3918040395,
-0.4801693559,
1.0094243288,
-0.0416876674,
0.9881933331,
0.1919716299,
-0.41508165,
0.4941643775,
0.3804507554,
0.4022222459,
-0.1918643862,
-0.5846138,
-0.0795830861,
0.3651400506,
-0.2458843738,
-0.4588702917,
0.7752908468,
-0.6980001926,
-0.3886679113,
-0.541341424,
-0.7328157425,
-0.3154257238,
0.0050170659,
0.3048573434,
0.3070974052,
-0.3641898036,
0.2502885461,
0.2739171684,
0.0155301197,
0.5750799775,
0.5347405076,
-0.0885810554,
-0.3800793588,
1.0850087404,
0.1648493558,
0.2611742616,
0.2581959963,
-0.0098932637,
-0.2250772417,
-0.6267579198,
-0.318474412,
0.4021178484,
-0.893930614,
-0.3328996301,
-0.0502366126,
-0.1998076588,
0.0461497121,
-0.3726228476,
-0.2370211184,
-0.4813291728,
-0.6184006929,
-0.0720452592,
0.596496582,
1.0496869087,
0.3163962364,
0.5835676193,
-0.4842512012,
0.0560609922,
-0.0473112725,
0.3928709626,
-0.0816799924,
-0.8908615708,
-0.5441944003,
-0.4575625062,
-0.5761434436,
-0.812081635,
0.3641879559,
0.3665754199,
0.3494431078,
0.4760858417,
0.2087745816,
0.5124036074,
-0.4857728183,
0.8750973344,
0.261341989,
-0.8181122541,
0.2088343799,
-0.537117064,
0.1001597345,
0.6623021364,
0.3700192571,
-0.3095757663,
-0.6293510795,
-0.3112930059,
-0.5042077303,
0.7977601886,
0.3055815101,
0.3498175442,
-0.0681275204,
0.5810748935,
0.0282243788,
0.2724448442,
-0.912659049,
-0.038970843,
0.0760806799,
-0.4019908309,
-0.5288715363,
-0.42417714,
-0.2510593235,
-0.2034978271,
0.4687673151,
0.1411736161,
0.2042957544,
-0.0019716462,
-0.2956087291,
0.0099455044,
0.230272159,
0.7355196476,
0.3824530542,
-0.3570854068,
0.0843998268,
0.1817371249,
-0.576561749,
0.2631034553,
-0.2800986171,
-0.0859784409,
-0.166001007,
0.8659320474,
0.7228451967,
0.0976351127,
-0.6088055968,
0.6396051645,
0.175502345,
-0.3424206674,
-0.4748849273,
0.2986269295,
0.1434319764,
0.4766247272,
0.3243778348,
-0.1623379439,
0.0748126209,
-0.6673924923,
-0.0589705184,
0.3230629861,
-0.2609710991,
0.0575729385,
0.3097065985,
0.0511584915,
-0.1753959656,
0.2835740745,
-0.0433893241,
-0.4248507917,
0.7482545376,
0.7590143681,
0.6907021999,
-0.1068339795,
0.0615719147,
0.1753074825,
0.4033180177,
0.0583646968,
0.0546146035,
-0.0220873635,
-0.6500207186,
-0.3821214139,
-0.7035191655,
-0.5857918262,
0.2854119241,
-0.5194006562,
0.1393986642,
-0.4725698531,
-0.2060042918,
-0.2272903472,
0.1088931635,
-0.184676677,
0.083079353,
0.1005461216,
0.5108154416,
-0.8086668253,
0.864354074,
0.3616333008,
-0.5109592676,
-0.6146098971,
0.2314920723,
-0.175215885,
-0.7623432875,
0.5896945596,
0.1828717142,
-0.5030891895,
0.1089064181,
-0.4861887693,
-0.6585847735,
1.173174262,
0.8501484394,
-0.3511429727,
0.0793762431,
0.174079448,
0.4504919052,
-0.2015496343,
0.3836670816,
0.7728509307,
0.3265687823,
0.2467568517,
-0.8479059935,
-0.0564533845,
-0.0501540937,
-0.0023917218,
-0.1430049837,
-0.654047966,
0.7661641836,
-0.119138144,
-0.1143727452,
0.514544189,
0.5228316784,
0.302832514,
0.1409001052,
0.2050494701,
0.2015453875,
0.7780945897,
-0.0150421672,
1.2061970234,
0.1828507334,
0.3603549302,
0.9543693066,
-0.535421133,
1.173212409,
0.5135568976,
-0.3807240129,
0.5416750312,
0.4299735725,
-0.0726166368,
0.5237700343,
0.6522297263,
-0.6312589049,
-0.13762483,
-0.2449896783,
-0.189515233,
0.3748671114,
0.143799752,
-0.3786804676,
0.1153873205,
0.007380323,
0.1626597196,
0.2964709699,
-0.3029637635,
0.7613633275,
0.327542454,
-0.5689014792,
0.8928295374,
0.1437424719,
0.5620215535,
-0.4919543266,
0.0162047707,
-0.2461615503,
0.4973742068,
-0.2344238758,
-0.8945561051,
0.2968018949,
0.3887538612,
-0.2355300933,
-0.0135909673,
0.5030647516,
-0.3571237028,
-0.6678598523,
0.2331963629,
0.1598756909,
0.7712693214,
0.0178054497,
-0.3071182966,
0.2523198426,
0.0172217377,
-0.529837966,
0.2295263708,
0.4249812067,
0.0857379064,
0.7088019252,
0.1676512659,
0.2313356549,
0.0646870062,
0.282975018,
0.3844121993,
-0.8066541553,
-0.0492284559,
-0.9707209468,
0.0087317033,
0.0162223298,
-0.3193362355,
0.9174153805,
0.5226510763,
0.3430336714,
-0.2456372678,
0.7178636789,
0.3562961519,
0.5619365573,
-0.6260405779,
0.8127602935,
-0.6348398924,
0.4294110537,
-0.4501031935,
-1.0231468678,
-0.4569699168,
0.8469451666,
-0.4433917999,
0.0223352201,
0.8703514338,
0.7354903817,
0.1740489602,
0.0272620451,
0.5842391849,
0.0619302131,
0.0894187614,
0.5264074802,
1.0495694876,
-0.4582009315,
0.7377764583,
0.1524686515,
-0.1267195344,
-0.1988855749,
-1.1834193468,
-0.9661121368,
-0.3032613993,
-0.3949431479,
0.0248520337,
0.1304424256,
0.5124157071,
0.0064937817,
-0.5754512548,
-0.6038048863,
0.0701908767,
0.083482556,
-0.0510886535,
-0.1852047443,
0.2568519711,
-0.3654212058,
-0.7036441565,
0.4320400059,
-0.1374038458,
0.0525787659,
-0.1907295585,
0.02062908,
-0.2654311657,
0.6063452363,
0.5842576027,
0.0334116258,
-0.6600518823,
-0.2632753253,
-0.5396357775,
-0.3776537776,
-0.0445309207,
0.7555112839,
-0.5660791993,
-0.0231168121,
0.108489044,
0.3327653408,
0.6010729671,
0.0755363181,
0.5026906729,
-0.8613218665,
-0.1308330595,
0.2722018957,
0.2751237154,
0.4092326462,
-0.3254578114,
0.3532780111,
0.2817481458,
-0.7300922871,
-0.8719373345,
0.067128554,
-0.9391849637,
-0.2435673475,
1.4499254227,
-0.4206598103,
-0.1674206704,
-0.1164496168,
-0.1613057256,
0.272358954,
-0.2694491744,
0.4313670695,
1.2151097059,
0.0164775029,
0.1813675761,
-0.7634607553,
0.5788128972,
0.6211413145,
-0.6584300399,
0.3667327166,
0.5734316111,
0.2968441248,
0.062233083,
0.5598578453,
-0.0879932493,
-0.1092744842,
0.0085087493,
0.110955447,
-0.0547360256,
-0.3625838459,
-0.2916224003,
0.1307456493,
0.4436649978,
-0.2013401687
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11375v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11375v1 | Boosting Scientific Concepts Understanding: Can Analogy from Teacher Models Empower Student Models? | 2024-06-17T09:51:38 | 2024-06-17T09:51:38 | Siyu Yuan, Cheng Jiayang, Lin Qiu, Deqing Yang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Analogical reasoning plays a critical role in human cognition, enabling us to
understand new concepts by associating them with familiar ones. Previous
research in the AI community has mainly focused on identifying and generating
analogies and then examining their quality under human evaluation, which
overlooks the practical application of these analogies in real-world settings.
Inspired by the human education process, in this paper, we propose to
investigate how analogies created by teacher language models (LMs) can assist
student LMs in understanding scientific concepts, thereby aligning more closely
with practical scenarios. Our results suggest that free-form analogies can
indeed aid LMs in understanding concepts. Additionally, analogies generated by
student LMs can improve their own performance on scientific question answering,
demonstrating their capability to use analogies for self-learning new
knowledge. Resources are available at https://github.com/siyuyuan/SCUA. | [
-0.1332406551,
-0.4702912271,
0.8407065868,
-0.1583049744,
-0.3647483587,
0.224188298,
-0.0199651774,
-0.5649657249,
0.2825648487,
0.2081820816,
-0.0229107775,
0.0905913338,
-0.1716414839,
0.2680171728,
-0.418732971,
0.6650267243,
0.0130686928,
0.5329704285,
-0.9336262345,
0.0446617976,
-0.4163027108,
-0.1769640744,
-0.4715328515,
-0.6564532518,
0.3777135909,
0.4746023118,
0.7782207131,
0.9237728715,
0.4498991668,
0.3368416429,
0.0418384336,
-0.0581377484,
-0.0254113749,
0.1797078252,
-0.4996812642,
-0.7038149238,
-0.1161357462,
0.269264251,
0.6707077622,
0.9985349774,
-0.086721614,
0.2598493099,
0.0169608891,
0.3718772829,
-0.282990098,
0.3332846463,
-0.7692772746,
-0.0284852087,
0.338126123,
-0.1642318517,
-0.2391565889,
-0.3795894384,
0.2041843086,
-1.1494044065,
0.3024809659,
-0.1993260831,
0.9441131949,
0.0650763959,
-0.2179771513,
-0.3878633976,
-0.5553984046,
0.5302489996,
-0.7498742938,
0.2606462836,
0.186072275,
0.4995308816,
-0.2323709428,
-0.854414165,
-1.0253522396,
-0.1326124519,
-0.0202623419,
0.2703686953,
0.0348722041,
-0.0537989326,
0.0692448989,
0.1361916959,
-0.208138302,
0.013118295,
-0.9367030859,
0.0234112479,
0.4711204469,
0.2010176778,
0.52666682,
-0.3481731415,
-0.5145010948,
-0.3686413765,
-0.7536810637,
0.2563793063,
0.1021827757,
0.3861694336,
0.0379763953,
0.326258719,
0.0990235731,
0.72841537,
-0.1822827905,
-0.1199843585,
-0.0419996195,
-0.1860174388,
-0.006565148,
0.0180456936,
0.4359094501,
0.4598582685,
0.3905147016,
-0.3506234586,
0.1571488976,
0.4855820537,
-0.005572624,
-1.1638139486,
-0.3146052957,
-0.0295350589,
-0.2009041458,
-0.3462642431,
0.2045444399,
-0.6914787889,
-0.3233622909,
-0.5572332144,
0.6826859117,
-0.198211506,
-0.3910449445,
0.1516464502,
-0.4447898567,
-0.113885738,
0.335988313,
-0.959289372,
0.5181741118,
0.6490023732,
0.6944634914,
0.0842320323,
-0.4419347942,
0.0444727167,
0.1895896345,
-0.3487403691,
0.7927900553,
-0.7390444875,
-0.562635839,
-0.5270645022,
-0.2326580435,
-0.1285632402,
-0.6511324644,
0.2310422659,
-0.2335352004,
0.329580456,
-0.1953424215,
-0.6324722767,
-0.1955604553,
-0.1552208066,
-0.393763423,
0.8753172159,
-0.1470339596,
-0.4236792326,
0.0310440529,
-0.7273787856,
0.0045389589,
0.0718402267,
-0.4301595092,
0.1177151203,
0.2697581947,
0.0273971613,
0.3843638897,
-0.4999952614,
0.3393405378,
-0.331083715,
-0.2585065365,
0.5483982563,
-0.0986981913,
0.6128762364,
0.5229954123,
0.1050403193,
0.1949306875,
-0.493876338,
0.0950480998,
0.3156628609,
0.3776857853,
-0.8866834044,
0.0232888106,
-0.4684158862,
0.2388584465,
-0.1447416991,
-0.4526562989,
0.2209863514,
-0.5638501644,
0.8886644244,
0.5907511711,
0.0395811871,
0.5688809752,
-0.3592322171,
0.4146308601,
-0.0587967448,
-0.2356088161,
-0.5028618574,
-0.4446219504,
-0.6065095067,
-0.3000662625,
0.3902474344,
0.2607436776,
-0.6418291926,
-0.1768087745,
-0.454487443,
-0.7788293958,
-0.8424047232,
0.0529663675,
0.1737269908,
1.1043666601,
0.2642758489,
-0.2839209437,
-0.5206312537,
-0.6969357729,
-0.4741688967,
-0.2030018717,
-0.3860030174,
0.2327172011,
0.7630761862,
0.1996640563,
1.2421760559,
-0.5410682559,
0.2895216346,
0.2155271322,
-0.0323949344,
0.0818803906,
0.3486408591,
0.5428866148,
-0.6717502475,
-0.2076328993,
-0.2267896086,
-1.0770763159,
0.0558239706,
-0.1416223496,
-0.155275479,
-0.4158623517,
0.4204498827,
-0.7409481406,
0.2321941257,
-0.0042270711,
-0.4670977294,
0.6211701035,
-0.2954739928,
0.1241379827,
-1.0824424028,
0.0375740975,
0.1580660045,
-0.0886020735,
-0.6889970303,
0.4367533624,
0.1550211757,
-0.5055727363,
-0.7351295352,
0.9400935173,
-0.3198985457,
-0.1381173581,
-0.3098468482,
0.630055964,
0.2553094625,
-0.1116005406,
0.2968739569,
0.9812772274,
0.4897928536,
-0.5993631482,
0.1550972909,
0.0832774341,
-0.4215141237,
0.3737450838,
-1.0301849842,
-0.0194322839,
-0.2197916955,
0.4298082888,
-0.583345294,
-0.1884707361,
0.1735138148,
-0.4995647371,
-0.2424012721,
0.2323065251,
-0.4920567572,
-0.3968681097,
-0.279606998,
0.494487673,
0.4588124752,
-0.6509874463,
0.451434046,
0.1769306064,
-0.0785746351,
-0.3478405476,
-0.5124682188,
0.0209440738,
-0.4022152424,
-0.2949253619,
0.1794717908,
-0.0998818129,
-0.5110286474,
0.309843123,
-0.2348699719,
-0.0505300537,
0.3971305788,
0.1296469718,
0.5442561507,
-0.2420572788,
0.4046041667,
0.1737075895,
0.0215701368,
0.377928853,
-0.1931000948,
0.1717233658,
-0.2271287888,
-0.2246525437,
-0.5236718059,
0.1341072023,
0.6811335683,
0.172672227,
0.6249107122,
0.061275579,
-0.5386631489,
-0.052030094,
-0.1030971929,
-0.985676527,
-0.4588268995,
0.3726768792,
-0.5410045981,
-0.378552705,
0.3767620623,
-0.074927479,
-0.3543096185,
0.2426650822,
0.2669196725,
-0.4420109391,
0.5921251774,
0.2859078646,
0.1976363063,
0.1603742838,
-0.2309416085,
0.3295302391,
-0.6316151023,
-0.2596561015,
-0.5390330553,
0.0810861513,
-0.3120378554,
-0.5532419682,
0.336481601,
0.455306679,
-0.2807402611,
0.3339984417,
-0.6589844823,
0.7845901251,
0.3625248969,
0.2001493871,
0.2967896163,
0.1657159925,
-0.2424867749,
-0.1406294852,
-0.8324400783,
-0.9143242836,
1.0444582701,
0.3493454754,
0.5015016198,
-0.1321654171,
0.5743282437,
0.0145779364,
0.6314883828,
-0.7246824503,
0.8175559044,
0.1984558105,
-0.5571974516,
-0.1273252368,
-0.3723894954,
-0.847686708,
0.7191764116,
-0.4915015996,
-0.6786032915,
-0.0790197551,
0.1598798782,
-0.0674610659,
0.4230028987,
-0.8502162099,
0.736353457,
-0.1970095336,
-0.2330392301,
-0.5100728869,
-0.6546596289,
0.1787275076,
-0.0078560645,
0.4168294966,
-0.143338412,
0.1116975769,
0.7776190042,
-0.2965005636,
1.1110070944,
-0.0895925164,
0.0638417751,
0.6351229548,
0.2070747763,
-0.0562955737,
-0.074268423,
-0.23668468,
0.034618184,
0.4549322128,
-0.6494991779,
-1.1223863363,
0.7154891491,
-0.8286227584,
-1.0444488525,
-0.5049744248,
-0.9326117635,
0.0524782725,
0.0242772624,
-0.3888276815,
-0.1133614779,
0.0568591841,
0.0152985109,
0.3444366157,
0.2547885776,
0.2699793875,
0.5398731828,
-0.264695853,
-0.2583127618,
1.1457988024,
-0.0900779963,
0.6715179086,
0.0832021162,
0.6095132232,
-0.3397199214,
0.0471975468,
-0.6242550015,
0.3874521852,
-1.0114132166,
-0.3946177661,
-0.4546994269,
-0.0458426401,
-0.5842451453,
-0.2088273168,
0.0370295905,
-1.082275033,
-0.4039635956,
-0.2484913021,
0.3521632552,
0.6421281695,
-0.0237099454,
0.1707207859,
-0.4383676052,
0.3767186403,
0.4590658545,
-0.2675928175,
0.4025188386,
-0.5407170057,
-0.131238386,
0.4287894964,
-0.6549046636,
-1.1082049608,
0.2819674313,
0.2489460558,
0.6625940204,
0.5746977329,
-0.1998983324,
0.7280336618,
-0.4212295413,
0.8084818125,
0.3834789395,
-1.1669328213,
0.5703548789,
-0.1763294339,
-0.0885934681,
0.1692674607,
0.5456960797,
-0.5352313519,
-0.3042614162,
-0.6399664879,
-0.6297550201,
0.2059899271,
0.0369660296,
0.3826859295,
0.0761753917,
0.8004907966,
0.2440302819,
0.3692457974,
-0.7925714254,
-0.2731016278,
-0.6415032744,
-0.5557142496,
-0.0741391256,
0.1268870533,
-0.1620091051,
-0.6002416015,
0.5595986247,
-0.2417413443,
0.1017913744,
0.1122517362,
0.1007999182,
-0.157765314,
0.3775333762,
0.5100893974,
0.7722930908,
0.0465729348,
0.4953719378,
0.4030539095,
-0.2381504625,
0.1088594794,
0.0852804855,
-0.2825186253,
-0.276461482,
0.2184399068,
0.4739764333,
0.2748148441,
-0.8081207275,
0.0874925405,
0.2340593189,
0.0823116675,
0.0491044335,
0.3673727214,
0.4278787076,
0.1047092229,
0.5896968246,
0.1150191203,
-0.0263740085,
-0.8586024642,
0.0587562323,
0.4587340653,
-0.0007949568,
-0.6009625196,
0.882437706,
0.1057019904,
-0.3898395002,
0.312422365,
0.1647113413,
-0.5728734732,
1.0349470377,
1.2485561371,
0.4258054495,
-0.3794695437,
0.3713845611,
0.4486470819,
0.0094170375,
-0.0560515821,
0.1291157454,
-0.330396384,
-0.9098582864,
-0.1084636077,
-0.3650747538,
-0.7631193995,
-0.0793713704,
-0.6259434223,
0.3346320987,
-0.405646652,
0.2322863936,
0.3316479623,
-0.172285676,
-0.506065309,
0.2748810053,
-0.0745120496,
0.9013844728,
-1.4471085072,
1.0153832436,
0.9371323586,
-0.6787849069,
-0.9650107622,
-0.3451308906,
-0.2952425778,
-0.6341077685,
1.0117172003,
0.0463856943,
-0.1593813896,
-0.0743240416,
-0.5533123612,
-0.7237467766,
1.291229248,
0.4100090861,
-0.1465442479,
-0.0927364528,
0.2600168586,
0.906462729,
-0.7196785808,
0.5403673053,
0.1515846401,
0.2717214823,
0.1555744857,
-0.6864185333,
0.2562746704,
-0.2692804933,
-0.2639181614,
-0.2657959759,
-0.3120256364,
0.6895589828,
-0.6485028863,
-0.2253755778,
0.2581313252,
1.0270252228,
0.5793426037,
0.8352130651,
0.4295428395,
0.4195650518,
0.6835114956,
0.1443496346,
0.6735907197,
-0.3239348531,
0.2180284709,
0.9798688293,
-0.0654221624,
0.8366920352,
0.9227957726,
-0.1026253551,
0.6095442176,
0.6029264927,
-0.0063348496,
0.4265504181,
0.4862679839,
-0.2893714607,
-0.4014406204,
-0.3055013418,
-0.6003940701,
0.2619271874,
0.6713168025,
-0.1607963741,
-0.2353115231,
-0.0251554996,
0.0285480395,
0.6999245882,
-0.2947719693,
0.1888525039,
0.2933655381,
-0.5530925393,
0.5396494865,
-0.3452958465,
0.2793347836,
-0.3593522608,
-0.3430787027,
-0.012466738,
-0.085974969,
-0.0449582525,
-0.7398967147,
-0.0499124825,
-0.2448111475,
-0.1297238171,
-0.0813629106,
0.5949021578,
-0.5374700427,
-0.4922250211,
-0.1092933863,
0.5398940444,
0.4149695635,
0.5152310729,
-0.551520586,
-0.3056787848,
-0.2409071177,
0.27845487,
0.2492740005,
0.1408821195,
-0.3074513972,
1.0826443434,
0.6800215244,
0.3450960815,
-0.2321516275,
-0.2416687906,
0.982059598,
-0.5380896926,
-0.3582993746,
-0.5020805001,
0.1723895669,
0.0969458893,
0.0037579229,
0.6909970641,
0.4338032007,
0.953961432,
-0.3717469871,
0.5957020521,
0.3413639069,
0.4180689752,
-0.3156575859,
0.7391895056,
-0.4598326385,
0.3534293473,
-0.312967062,
-0.7950819135,
-0.3185487092,
0.8338279724,
-0.3615868986,
-0.1820588857,
0.5617410541,
0.601151526,
-0.3158786595,
0.1717499942,
0.3005785048,
0.1427930295,
0.3385888338,
0.2410317063,
1.0274962187,
-0.4260637164,
0.081120193,
-0.266887337,
0.059355136,
0.0482738242,
-0.9462938905,
-1.0094362497,
-0.6508567929,
-0.2776982486,
-0.1856574416,
0.2235269845,
1.0763814449,
0.6369268298,
-0.6244319081,
-0.3112273216,
-0.1987440735,
0.2319336534,
-0.213708654,
-0.2166267335,
0.5895255804,
-0.1951317489,
-0.745274663,
0.526374042,
-0.3238768876,
0.4369101822,
-0.2328475267,
-0.0901060253,
0.1645365059,
0.5886140466,
0.3030157089,
0.5019621253,
-1.0142691135,
-0.3462900221,
0.1529775709,
0.0182038359,
-0.1097896993,
0.9441120028,
-1.2714112997,
0.6661074162,
0.3596445322,
0.3879167438,
0.3506761789,
0.0719679892,
0.3734544218,
-0.2754586935,
0.4759846926,
0.1839203089,
0.3227303922,
0.3728865087,
-0.1200025305,
0.4417604804,
0.3708687723,
-0.314070195,
-1.1185199022,
0.1920390427,
-0.746019125,
-0.5089389086,
0.7664895654,
-0.2256820798,
-0.2038620859,
0.31931144,
0.0294654574,
0.2246249169,
-0.2571942508,
1.0795813799,
0.632913053,
-0.0711577013,
-0.0438158661,
-0.5288167,
0.3291727901,
0.7491901517,
-0.8360548615,
-0.3013136089,
0.0922238231,
0.4675911665,
0.2608622313,
-0.0024769576,
0.0236434918,
0.3036389053,
-0.1816580594,
0.2083591819,
-0.3253547847,
-0.2222664356,
0.0004218007,
-0.1258646399,
0.0270736013,
-0.1346693337
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11370v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11370v1 | Fairer Preferences Elicit Improved Human-Aligned Large Language Model Judgments | 2024-06-17T09:48:53 | 2024-06-17T09:48:53 | Han Zhou, Xingchen Wan, Yinhong Liu, Nigel Collier, Ivan Vulić, Anna Korhonen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG | Large language models (LLMs) have shown promising abilities as cost-effective
and reference-free evaluators for assessing language generation quality. In
particular, pairwise LLM evaluators, which compare two generated texts and
determine the preferred one, have been employed in a wide range of
applications. However, LLMs exhibit preference biases and worrying sensitivity
to prompt designs. In this work, we first reveal that the predictive preference
of LLMs can be highly brittle and skewed, even with semantically equivalent
instructions. We find that fairer predictive preferences from LLMs consistently
lead to judgments that are better aligned with humans. Motivated by this
phenomenon, we propose an automatic Zero-shot Evaluation-oriented Prompt
Optimization framework, ZEPO, which aims to produce fairer preference decisions
and improve the alignment of LLM evaluators with human judgments. To this end,
we propose a zero-shot learning objective based on the preference decision
fairness. ZEPO demonstrates substantial performance improvements over
state-of-the-art LLM evaluators, without requiring labeled data, on
representative meta-evaluation benchmarks. Our findings underscore the critical
correlation between preference fairness and human alignment, positioning ZEPO
as an efficient prompt optimizer for bridging the gap between LLM evaluators
and human judgments. | [
-0.2180299163,
-0.3722297549,
0.7904200554,
0.0413498729,
-0.1725285798,
-0.2081760019,
-0.452577889,
-0.3551403284,
-0.139137581,
0.3079318702,
-0.358907342,
-0.3642595708,
-0.4745280445,
0.2146821469,
0.2715183794,
0.8800243735,
0.3282963932,
0.1490300745,
-0.206515789,
-0.0734986514,
-0.6529457569,
-0.1876792461,
-0.590130806,
-0.5651230812,
0.5657637715,
0.6113400459,
1.0264881849,
0.5681009889,
0.0262584612,
0.2411362976,
0.0060804491,
-0.1112157255,
-0.3932676017,
0.255764842,
-0.2474064976,
-0.5050637722,
-0.5205712318,
0.0756340697,
0.397271663,
0.7272090316,
-0.0436606109,
0.1670839339,
0.1369081885,
0.6687284112,
-0.7742866874,
-0.0539478622,
-0.8142405152,
0.1005062908,
-0.082960695,
-0.2456035614,
-0.554861784,
-0.4973146021,
0.1772416383,
-0.5128136873,
0.1330382675,
0.22263363,
0.7891879082,
0.1477296799,
-0.385522306,
0.02883677,
-0.3068923652,
1.1950095892,
-0.8663638234,
0.31042853,
0.0412279256,
0.4532179534,
-0.3854256868,
-0.1519380659,
-0.704761982,
-0.2277031243,
0.2817258537,
0.0534014553,
-0.1532999873,
0.2456336468,
0.0995609462,
0.1104823202,
-0.7038850188,
0.4191517532,
0.0591389649,
-0.4700541198,
0.6068294644,
0.1792700589,
0.3371272087,
-0.5672043562,
-0.3468889594,
0.0082898205,
-0.7122552395,
0.3849610686,
0.7472733259,
0.4286126494,
0.1646964252,
0.5575520992,
-0.4687849581,
0.9379703403,
0.2763420045,
-0.2668505311,
0.5742890835,
-0.044652462,
-0.187623769,
0.1546743512,
1.0040216446,
1.0307276249,
0.3770374358,
-0.1483204365,
-0.4514944851,
0.2668098509,
0.0996331051,
-0.9161335826,
0.2977461219,
0.1990419477,
-0.4527075589,
-0.5842055082,
-0.0769054592,
-0.7994442582,
-0.2965492308,
-0.4467819333,
0.4955641031,
-0.1942313761,
0.0936120972,
0.409735024,
-0.0899151042,
0.2773041129,
0.4507194459,
-1.0758376122,
-0.0799058154,
0.7918877006,
0.5973162055,
-0.0657488555,
-0.1769593507,
-1.0243324041,
-0.0241695493,
-0.4276976883,
0.779643774,
-0.5584382415,
-0.2161248326,
-0.1018770039,
-0.186660707,
0.244143039,
-0.3663928211,
0.8834731579,
-0.3519565165,
0.6474911571,
-0.3898566961,
-0.4222278595,
0.0487418883,
0.1944461018,
-0.3355031908,
0.5999493003,
0.2196917236,
-0.6160979271,
0.8013402224,
-0.3768436015,
-0.2671941221,
0.1755995899,
-0.4198410809,
-0.294190377,
0.2509557605,
0.2333180159,
0.3965070844,
-0.6027271152,
0.6875904799,
-0.5410733819,
-0.358836472,
0.127930969,
-0.4784811437,
0.78283602,
0.3460777402,
-0.517152071,
0.3998887539,
-0.5602884889,
0.1393901855,
0.12558496,
-0.2282221764,
-0.1276550591,
0.0114861932,
-0.2259393632,
0.3360497952,
0.2115332931,
-0.6137771606,
0.0784630105,
-0.7175104618,
0.2198087275,
1.1923180819,
-0.3726119697,
0.791768074,
-0.54702425,
0.5477918386,
-0.3475075066,
0.4933236539,
0.0157670975,
-0.4913404882,
-0.599830687,
0.018445665,
0.0871540606,
0.348831445,
-0.5068506002,
0.7386795282,
-0.2498193681,
-0.2371295691,
-0.6155328155,
0.2378394455,
0.3946006596,
0.9804744124,
0.014487558,
-0.1429973394,
-0.3089846373,
-0.9947081804,
-0.3143948019,
-0.190908134,
-0.1806840748,
0.4193347991,
-0.146567136,
0.0368828811,
1.1603912115,
-0.4395662844,
0.0133725274,
-0.3163032532,
-0.056547191,
0.3519234955,
0.1302790791,
0.9614332914,
-0.542062223,
-0.7048763037,
-0.1912340224,
-0.4523668289,
-0.6448771358,
0.1435533464,
-0.2956468165,
0.3785694838,
-0.0536962636,
-0.4300159812,
0.014935948,
0.5098956823,
-0.5167168379,
0.5517324805,
0.0801784322,
0.3105344772,
-0.884648025,
0.021671176,
-0.1212047711,
-0.2500605583,
-0.5302852988,
-0.2525111437,
0.0946002677,
-0.0838198215,
-0.5669599175,
0.9018470645,
-0.324971348,
-0.1433425099,
-0.3443530798,
0.3227241635,
0.3715206683,
0.3033480942,
-0.0652146712,
0.7555914521,
0.5078781843,
-0.3670727015,
0.1328162104,
-0.0142412698,
-0.4016444087,
0.5994387269,
-0.7494227886,
0.2917273343,
-0.3840984106,
0.048948586,
-0.8882131577,
-0.1324710995,
0.2698030174,
-0.5672751069,
0.1987473965,
-0.1246073693,
-0.3029011488,
-0.1611628085,
-0.7307450771,
0.2182536274,
0.7211422324,
-0.5734010339,
0.2625471354,
0.2974610925,
-0.1750048101,
-0.9840896726,
-0.3227797747,
-0.0172769465,
-0.2189700305,
-0.8364034295,
0.2084969431,
-0.2353459895,
-0.2817553878,
-0.1604153961,
-0.0912687927,
0.4638381898,
0.1972100288,
0.2757098377,
0.5765795708,
-0.1002941281,
0.1640662104,
0.0710600168,
-0.3640805185,
-0.1839163899,
-0.2964987457,
0.6957387328,
-0.0839731917,
-0.1968661249,
-0.3756912351,
0.1118000448,
0.3985392749,
0.0646589398,
0.4021937549,
0.3296332657,
-0.0647880733,
-0.1791458577,
-0.7099169493,
-0.0160728879,
-0.4607625306,
0.0193017013,
-0.2557824254,
-0.9523653984,
0.154322207,
0.3458779156,
0.2517387867,
0.4287301898,
0.4051669538,
0.1285343319,
1.2707391977,
0.5881995559,
-0.2790519297,
0.4804851413,
0.3083856702,
0.1907888651,
-0.7000966072,
-0.0182394143,
-0.6725335121,
-0.3939592838,
-0.1582175195,
-0.2394587547,
0.2241464555,
0.33098647,
-0.3397646844,
0.0780017748,
-0.4758823216,
0.5235247016,
0.3692401052,
-0.1041659713,
0.2250224352,
-0.05221707,
-0.1838902086,
-0.2189431787,
-0.613155067,
-0.9368588328,
1.1805906296,
0.2194475085,
0.5467223525,
0.0607190505,
0.7128287554,
0.1355717182,
0.3095100522,
-0.8449488878,
0.473672837,
-0.0885831043,
-0.3420614898,
-0.3361259103,
-0.5871289968,
-0.9108513594,
0.2810518742,
-0.3311657608,
-0.6392536163,
0.1775594354,
0.3741581142,
-0.6536842585,
0.0248938072,
-0.7985476851,
0.9354971051,
-0.502183795,
-0.4756445289,
-0.13574332,
-0.629959166,
0.2908025384,
-0.0836017951,
0.2101504803,
-0.6677353382,
-0.1901268959,
0.417152822,
-0.4043551087,
0.6217213273,
-0.3592850566,
-0.091807358,
0.1645393223,
0.1302320063,
0.2917319238,
-0.0092661865,
-0.6729493141,
0.1443608254,
-0.5128806829,
-0.3700911105,
-0.6914909482,
0.7728950381,
-0.7725663781,
-0.7923836708,
-0.2189258486,
-0.3694804907,
-0.2302494198,
0.2854052186,
0.396461904,
0.2997564971,
-0.2097839564,
0.0010835454,
0.3073404133,
-0.5434945822,
0.4638368189,
0.5712925196,
-0.3283188939,
-0.4363821149,
0.721630156,
-0.1349335462,
0.559561193,
0.3676430583,
0.632014811,
-0.3484259248,
-0.4007533193,
-0.6471773386,
-0.0146576753,
-0.4485975504,
-0.4984026551,
-0.557310164,
0.2140595466,
-0.6967098117,
-0.5443769097,
-0.1516173333,
-0.4644065201,
-0.1825934649,
-0.0796562433,
0.1072470471,
0.19872953,
-0.0424562283,
0.2097089291,
-0.6756901741,
0.3317142129,
0.4076767862,
0.3037890792,
0.0036191621,
-0.7409178019,
0.2550484836,
0.0494790338,
-0.2631821632,
-0.6375057697,
0.3889707923,
0.0302992724,
0.6406497359,
0.5903159976,
0.2530316114,
0.4370098114,
-0.5634617805,
0.7007437348,
0.5657419562,
-1.0356514454,
0.6941964626,
-0.3421163261,
0.2917841375,
0.7031898499,
0.1336253583,
-0.5409296751,
-0.1239979416,
-0.3387812674,
-0.6522833705,
0.888091445,
-0.1878785342,
0.2963888347,
-0.1891323328,
0.3175398409,
0.5079543591,
0.2840432823,
-0.7186517119,
0.0032903869,
-0.1823476404,
-0.1653774232,
-0.178208217,
-0.3577031493,
0.0822347701,
0.1334342062,
0.5554113984,
-0.3412330747,
-0.2519590855,
-0.0253002122,
-0.1780388504,
-0.500028193,
0.6513753533,
0.3750034869,
0.5256717205,
-0.3082952499,
0.0625955611,
-0.0624121614,
-0.0081220521,
0.3531356156,
-0.1962216944,
-0.7180353999,
-0.0640775338,
0.0553649291,
0.9398255348,
0.2024509162,
-0.8124734163,
1.0336784124,
-0.0602820255,
-0.0946074054,
0.1197523326,
0.38156569,
-0.1023521945,
0.1727203429,
0.1402620971,
0.0920850113,
0.2489560694,
-0.4853372276,
0.0465967432,
0.6126352549,
-0.2337425947,
-0.3354490697,
0.6531256437,
0.5019498467,
-0.4360040426,
0.5204694271,
-0.4330306947,
-0.5137739778,
0.3482201993,
0.4782013297,
1.0170972347,
-0.259642601,
0.2766453326,
0.3917181194,
0.0854828879,
-0.0376898237,
0.2019045204,
-0.1372997314,
-1.0607587099,
-0.4107538462,
-0.7740619183,
-0.2681229413,
-0.1817594469,
-0.4250136316,
0.6813115478,
-0.4716438949,
-0.3874595463,
-0.1316567808,
0.1177673638,
-0.6868917942,
-0.048753161,
0.2943442166,
0.5846428871,
-0.8054177165,
0.6914194822,
0.3135368526,
-0.2722938955,
-0.7187590003,
-0.0735922828,
0.1663222462,
-0.9089209437,
0.6372352839,
0.4031842351,
-0.1928280294,
-0.2544079125,
-0.3854194582,
-0.5380281806,
0.975677371,
0.9350852966,
-1.0311059952,
0.0639198646,
-0.0438385457,
0.2616707683,
-0.2795263231,
0.4565343857,
0.3738541901,
0.5055304766,
-0.0821360871,
-0.9026041031,
0.0165941194,
-0.0670550242,
-0.0396557413,
0.3475156128,
-0.773537457,
0.6273132563,
-0.5189999342,
-0.24525626,
-0.0365514755,
0.4609724283,
0.4167761207,
0.3269720078,
0.8411974907,
0.5149515271,
0.7554169297,
0.0686228201,
0.9858283401,
-0.3112487495,
0.0869234577,
1.2306960821,
-0.6708086133,
0.6772834659,
0.5112163424,
0.0162011031,
0.2654229999,
0.4216330051,
0.1137163863,
0.3570822775,
0.1381725371,
-0.3122157753,
-0.4062971473,
-0.3491749465,
-0.1907888651,
0.3480256498,
-0.2276811302,
-0.208302483,
-0.2457749993,
-0.2487360239,
0.0215775073,
0.2382648438,
-0.1903128326,
0.6495419741,
-0.0008206028,
-0.9103702903,
0.2865008712,
0.0994062722,
1.0300912857,
-0.4287988544,
0.1682675928,
-0.2500117719,
-0.1241636574,
-0.2598929703,
-0.8810074329,
-0.0602525994,
0.1929455996,
-0.3935160935,
-0.3611060083,
0.7863510251,
-0.2794258296,
-0.1891083121,
0.4678922892,
0.3659978211,
0.0685182586,
-0.0208441839,
-0.6833925247,
0.0352231041,
0.2004670203,
-0.3809901476,
0.4977335632,
0.3897005618,
-0.0932032168,
0.4228846729,
0.7036197186,
0.0968007967,
-0.0980723128,
0.5349726677,
0.5124385953,
-0.6729015112,
-0.291590929,
-0.9574352503,
0.3925016224,
-0.027062729,
-0.3399995565,
0.5685011148,
0.5403897166,
0.7596523762,
0.133500129,
0.7567135692,
0.0902889743,
0.4205006957,
-0.423558861,
0.603941083,
-0.4908550382,
0.2011222243,
-0.322779119,
-1.2371973991,
-0.2275682241,
0.5236041546,
-0.3600214422,
0.0398174077,
0.2386533022,
0.8198894262,
0.2161322534,
-0.2448387593,
0.6461949348,
-0.2604091465,
0.4376534522,
0.8176059723,
0.8660494089,
-0.1734513044,
0.4477004409,
-0.2307481617,
-0.3802596331,
-0.2686590254,
-1.1958853006,
-0.7477329373,
-0.1041337028,
-0.0234628953,
-0.0498721711,
-0.0102087352,
1.3633030653,
0.5503869057,
-0.5093012452,
-0.212852478,
0.0475920923,
0.1897711754,
0.3119252026,
-0.2798738778,
0.1589025855,
-0.7203287482,
-0.935082376,
0.3183637559,
0.5847262144,
-0.0217540003,
-0.0065528727,
-0.4878481925,
0.3375831544,
-0.0075981356,
0.6238767505,
-0.0080637988,
-0.8033508062,
-0.5843559504,
0.107414566,
-0.3132028282,
0.2449421734,
0.6088626385,
-0.8233535886,
0.7137147188,
0.8066698313,
0.5371487141,
-0.2170551866,
-0.0344165899,
0.9914290309,
-0.3418495059,
0.161097616,
0.3588349223,
0.4561359882,
0.3991414011,
-0.3694386184,
0.3009221554,
-0.0072161499,
-0.6589223742,
-0.7843658328,
0.1365251392,
-0.9175115228,
-0.2262757123,
1.133018136,
0.0784385502,
-0.2300544828,
0.1967974454,
-0.2638534307,
0.1704506129,
-0.8767643571,
0.7699164748,
0.5752728581,
-0.1275089532,
0.0862474516,
-0.460808754,
0.3563271761,
0.8452923894,
-0.6448135972,
-0.0258509647,
0.7743772864,
0.3977104127,
-0.1006683856,
0.7248807549,
-0.1818961352,
0.3916503787,
-0.4231251478,
0.3790264726,
0.0300892461,
-0.2147037387,
-0.6301030517,
0.0679437816,
0.4395936131,
-0.0391211361
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11368v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11368v1 | Improving Quotation Attribution with Fictional Character Embeddings | 2024-06-17T09:46:35 | 2024-06-17T09:46:35 | Gaspard Michel, Elena V. Epure, Romain Hennequin, Christophe Cerisara | cs.CL | cs.CL | Humans naturally attribute utterances of direct speech to their speaker in
literary works. When attributing quotes, we process contextual information but
also access mental representations of characters that we build and revise
throughout the narrative. Recent methods to automatically attribute such
utterances have explored simulating human logic with deterministic rules or
learning new implicit rules with neural networks when processing contextual
information. However, these systems inherently lack \textit{character}
representations, which often leads to errors on more challenging examples of
attribution: anaphoric and implicit quotes. In this work, we propose to augment
a popular quotation attribution system, BookNLP, with character embeddings that
encode global information of characters. To build these embeddings, we create
DramaCV, a corpus of English drama plays from the 15th to 20th century focused
on Character Verification (CV), a task similar to Authorship Verification (AV),
that aims at analyzing fictional characters. We train a model similar to the
recently proposed AV model, Universal Authorship Representation (UAR), on this
dataset, showing that it outperforms concurrent methods of characters
embeddings on the CV task and generalizes better to literary novels. Then,
through an extensive evaluation on 22 novels, we show that combining BookNLP's
contextual information with our proposed global character embeddings improves
the identification of speakers for anaphoric and implicit quotes, reaching
state-of-the-art performance. Code and data will be made publicly available. | [
-0.0064671258,
-0.2699562311,
0.4937215447,
-0.0441385619,
-0.281858176,
0.0863357857,
-0.1919971257,
-0.58940804,
0.2310193926,
0.7171458602,
-0.4174774587,
-0.2521808147,
-0.1993855536,
0.2066488117,
-0.0345088392,
0.842944324,
0.1134339795,
0.0776882246,
-0.5655412078,
-0.1548509151,
-0.4610869288,
-0.6752210855,
-0.6389468312,
-0.3081169128,
0.7516809702,
0.063802056,
0.6568374634,
0.551530838,
0.1957975328,
0.3333292007,
0.0740172789,
0.484801501,
-0.135840863,
0.5480151176,
-0.3319739401,
-0.5153990388,
0.0306451563,
-0.0777849704,
0.8249949813,
0.3356251717,
-0.1458603591,
-0.0990036353,
0.1433322579,
0.3023309708,
-0.6696681976,
0.5372332931,
-0.5177761912,
0.2245759815,
-0.0523304939,
-0.3059697151,
-0.5743278265,
-0.8054682612,
-0.1088241562,
-0.7198368311,
0.0626886785,
0.3067571819,
0.7446089387,
0.0745378584,
-0.436584115,
-0.3817005157,
-0.6923717856,
0.8161340952,
-0.589504838,
-0.1102269888,
0.3696422279,
0.1321989,
0.0253978334,
-0.2179563642,
-0.4455131292,
-0.5627241135,
-0.2411078811,
0.0799355581,
-0.1573933959,
0.0007326183,
0.1464765519,
0.1632291526,
-0.1975517422,
-0.1103783473,
0.1066399291,
-0.3956786394,
0.6450843811,
-0.0058493046,
0.3343820274,
-0.417570591,
-0.2673136294,
-0.3675859571,
-0.5657773614,
0.0642806813,
0.5551118851,
0.2744226754,
0.3098436296,
0.4843505919,
0.3129799664,
0.1667939425,
-0.0968782976,
0.4574029446,
0.0678503215,
-0.1760294884,
0.1164158881,
0.4541632533,
0.6754524112,
0.4337677658,
0.8029548526,
-0.1675042212,
0.0666235238,
-0.0404821634,
0.2875300944,
-0.4552723467,
-0.1722860634,
-0.1004620716,
-0.0301184226,
-0.3502461314,
0.1070590243,
-0.3733350635,
-0.9603219628,
-0.1707329601,
0.3493282497,
-0.7426165342,
-0.041261632,
-0.2338455766,
-0.4356853664,
0.2373836935,
0.4475762844,
-0.8674618602,
0.1534767449,
0.3884654343,
0.7543655634,
0.0905298293,
-0.1203663349,
-0.5619410276,
0.6785306334,
-0.6654809713,
0.8477399945,
-0.5193104744,
-0.0392559245,
0.2680855989,
-0.0668950453,
-0.0739090443,
-0.3813239336,
0.7019179463,
-0.1958184987,
0.1712170839,
-0.7227031589,
-0.653213799,
0.0545067936,
0.0250250511,
-0.8551559448,
0.5846272707,
-0.2228699178,
-0.5495917201,
0.2474280894,
-0.6078068018,
-0.3819111586,
0.1294052452,
-0.4558256269,
-0.1413571835,
0.2307972014,
0.4963656366,
0.6175807714,
-0.2914597392,
0.0072496566,
-0.1348273903,
-0.3040519357,
0.6364834905,
-0.5075436831,
0.7056943178,
0.1543132663,
0.0185136274,
-0.3145573139,
-0.4541879296,
-0.0005685044,
0.021360537,
-0.1821962148,
-0.6970116496,
0.1815006733,
0.2237649411,
-0.3145030439,
0.0429729745,
-0.7205909491,
0.2902413011,
-0.5172840953,
0.2758192122,
0.7763510346,
0.1869556606,
0.3388063014,
-0.515403688,
0.4614474773,
-0.4146180451,
-0.1668531746,
-0.20591335,
-0.4421017468,
-0.3156092167,
-0.4903604388,
0.4030794501,
0.764585793,
-0.8500136137,
0.6069228649,
-0.1998617947,
-0.2319612652,
-0.3168961704,
-0.1139594987,
0.54642272,
0.2435521632,
0.3086902797,
-0.1744238138,
-0.5220439434,
-0.7327296734,
-0.6840801239,
-0.6212344766,
-0.4367643297,
0.3622020185,
0.2064133435,
0.3586280942,
0.9417862892,
-0.5279269218,
-0.5126926899,
-0.2756914496,
0.2236154824,
-0.1275272816,
0.5709198713,
0.4814356565,
-0.467259407,
-0.4613733292,
0.1043901965,
-0.8670094013,
-0.0673586503,
-0.2947248518,
-0.0823256671,
-0.0292331669,
0.6247446537,
-0.4787682891,
0.1989678442,
0.0121064847,
-0.4944966733,
0.611703217,
-0.2321259975,
0.592350781,
-1.0296081305,
-0.0053652371,
-0.1591944546,
-0.4300130904,
-0.1906825304,
0.0560115725,
0.026881285,
0.0142339747,
-0.4060102105,
0.5647569299,
-0.5970395803,
0.2597343326,
0.1650714576,
0.1409312785,
0.2119760215,
0.5092464685,
-0.0600201264,
0.6144339442,
0.2298403531,
-0.3242988586,
0.5985046029,
0.3372345567,
-0.5977367759,
0.7485662103,
-0.5393579602,
-0.0268164836,
-0.1516183466,
0.5449755192,
-1.1868464947,
-0.3390506506,
0.1589383036,
-0.2569399774,
0.4065769315,
-0.3482833803,
-0.5930474401,
0.0709903762,
-0.3605964482,
0.3546814322,
0.5323458314,
-0.4248209298,
0.7789004445,
0.1434478462,
-0.3622000515,
-0.6600568891,
-0.9173739552,
0.2954731882,
-0.2459588796,
-0.4885257483,
0.5474979281,
-0.0059642009,
-0.1269870102,
-0.1396851987,
0.0316856392,
-0.1692998707,
-0.2475262731,
-0.0032353727,
0.1198273748,
-0.1630904377,
0.2980649471,
0.2187817246,
0.0364437439,
0.1388345808,
-0.0004727442,
0.0978043824,
0.0126022557,
-0.2640958428,
-0.4962036312,
0.5652395487,
0.3972604275,
-0.0273056496,
0.6903984547,
0.5093621016,
-0.3123556972,
-0.358694762,
-0.5338041186,
-0.0615704991,
-0.4614798725,
0.2544029951,
-0.0961047113,
-0.6397345066,
0.7355633378,
0.052271951,
-0.117454648,
0.5118796825,
0.2537992597,
-0.2820770442,
0.7558268309,
0.3331035376,
-0.069607608,
0.6569998264,
-0.0542171374,
-0.2143951952,
-0.7454467416,
-0.1536925286,
-0.5602458119,
-0.210019514,
-0.3361604214,
-0.5777576566,
0.1936400831,
-0.1493889987,
-0.0943933427,
0.4965826869,
-0.3216748536,
0.9692551494,
0.3628948927,
0.1731818467,
0.3064601123,
0.2351467311,
-0.5963147283,
-0.268505156,
-0.4688081741,
-0.5252488852,
0.9728448987,
0.2179632187,
0.7418406606,
0.4456337094,
0.4949055016,
0.9043903947,
0.0063322969,
-0.4867012799,
0.4814609885,
-0.2441711426,
-0.7685935497,
-0.3263459206,
-0.2725736797,
-0.7201962471,
0.0668523759,
-0.1595644206,
-0.978758812,
0.6228740215,
0.2737848461,
-0.5904379487,
0.2576651573,
-0.5752748251,
0.6594013572,
0.2249940485,
-0.3331159949,
-0.0993320942,
-0.500287056,
0.1438825279,
0.1290338933,
-0.0185393021,
0.0601460189,
-0.0579090714,
0.6820650101,
-0.491337657,
0.9282773733,
-0.1814849675,
-0.3173822761,
0.4297721088,
0.1415075213,
0.7217956185,
0.08066082,
-0.4590269029,
0.0470569842,
0.1102207005,
-0.1615267098,
-0.7134481072,
0.6499117613,
-0.6915618777,
-0.1120651364,
-0.7327091694,
-0.4848051667,
-0.2732057571,
-0.3479607403,
0.3422805369,
0.6077635288,
-0.580550611,
0.4874773622,
0.6455047727,
-0.1768017113,
0.4417668879,
0.1075959578,
0.0495867878,
-0.6863148212,
0.8219727874,
0.0497417152,
0.1984817833,
0.5441237092,
0.1810835749,
-0.4873590469,
-0.1481921524,
-0.3048714995,
0.2721742988,
-0.9963055849,
-0.2206506282,
-0.4659953415,
-0.2982749939,
-0.4526322782,
-0.2947753668,
-0.3441483676,
-0.6373842955,
-0.307495147,
-0.0201437436,
0.4927274585,
0.5856745839,
-0.1656306088,
0.3777316809,
-0.3772274554,
0.1238162145,
0.2699593306,
0.1246071458,
-0.0232660864,
-0.6908509731,
-0.4993627369,
-0.1673400253,
-0.3166832626,
-0.8193314672,
0.3048590422,
0.5739477277,
0.4588991404,
0.3626919091,
0.3186692894,
0.5592668653,
-0.9234347343,
0.8646227121,
0.1973403245,
-0.9148190618,
0.390535295,
-0.4406540096,
0.0829849914,
0.6471671462,
0.2274801582,
-0.640450716,
-0.5114332438,
-0.4700434208,
-0.6551395059,
0.7223885059,
0.5319823623,
0.4222196937,
0.0914046541,
0.4349902272,
0.0494259186,
0.2345393151,
-0.7143077254,
-0.1182328165,
-0.1279875487,
-0.3753842711,
-0.317261219,
-0.1637440771,
-0.1378296167,
-0.3744773269,
0.5295825005,
-0.1024288386,
0.4776340425,
0.3961227238,
-0.1957644224,
-0.0044055558,
0.2098842263,
0.3991911709,
0.3042679131,
-0.3495634496,
-0.0807006955,
-0.0939901471,
-0.3827448785,
0.1297718436,
0.1333047748,
0.0331793018,
0.1388595104,
0.7114342451,
0.5607716441,
0.1326908618,
-0.3419874609,
0.5882411599,
-0.0856545269,
-0.0777452663,
-0.6650457382,
0.3035692573,
-0.0444205143,
0.5697548389,
0.5824600458,
0.1967010051,
0.0780478045,
-0.6822912693,
0.2751364112,
0.3797396421,
-0.4273887575,
-0.0458379649,
0.5361564755,
0.2571789622,
-0.3203630447,
0.3455560505,
-0.0399416648,
-0.4116659462,
0.4755179584,
0.4616541564,
1.0988386869,
-0.3568943143,
0.4836524129,
0.1463568658,
0.4032696187,
0.0130612496,
0.0064429953,
-0.1014733091,
-0.7174075842,
-0.460577786,
-0.5414136648,
-0.6630592346,
-0.1389628798,
-0.3321102858,
0.1474148184,
-0.5912849307,
0.014305396,
-0.1838117838,
-0.0430647954,
-0.5090607405,
0.0020570818,
0.4568116963,
0.252483815,
-0.9399567842,
0.6854658723,
0.5083420277,
-0.6586859226,
-0.5196408033,
0.143234387,
-0.086569339,
-0.5450260043,
0.4516301155,
0.1076883227,
0.0162510574,
0.1287215352,
-0.6592153311,
-0.7725337744,
1.0875223875,
0.9201435447,
-0.2879645526,
-0.2935135365,
0.0353993252,
0.4268691242,
-0.7757808566,
0.6153580546,
0.0227053873,
0.3648764193,
0.2023353875,
-0.570843339,
0.2029299289,
-0.2205776721,
0.0672787651,
-0.2425494641,
-0.2259268016,
0.633118391,
0.0827743635,
-0.0403967239,
0.2932215035,
0.8720782995,
0.2108706683,
0.0163290519,
0.5336697698,
0.0249858554,
0.9898020029,
-0.0328515507,
1.2521473169,
0.2502459586,
0.1159224138,
1.1509767771,
-0.1359712631,
0.8056809306,
0.345846355,
-0.1535785496,
1.0968208313,
0.3290096223,
-0.1379514039,
0.5080345273,
0.3965694308,
-0.4473940134,
-0.4022879601,
-0.3576246202,
-0.3002718389,
0.2820838988,
0.2432794571,
-0.5740619898,
0.0287119038,
0.1702923924,
0.011349638,
0.3354178667,
-0.0666706339,
0.6480007172,
0.1812695712,
-0.4348019361,
0.4382266104,
-0.0659722313,
0.4999056756,
-0.914893806,
-0.2251707464,
-0.1189985871,
0.3368839025,
-0.0135913342,
-0.4450334013,
0.0105805183,
-0.0068112891,
-0.267516315,
-0.2631313205,
0.6590538025,
-0.6114183068,
-0.7204089761,
0.1051535308,
-0.0242041927,
0.3758244514,
-0.3524028957,
-0.5861318111,
-0.1194240153,
0.0526319705,
-0.2101023048,
-0.0230550598,
0.6678996682,
0.066769436,
0.4847138524,
0.5117566586,
0.3246833682,
-0.2550679445,
0.2352632582,
0.5856932998,
-0.7173410058,
-0.5653110743,
-0.8119131923,
0.7534148693,
-0.4639272094,
-0.3147250414,
0.7645930648,
0.2063192278,
0.399907589,
-0.2276381105,
0.875003159,
0.0517748222,
0.2511472702,
-0.6343739033,
1.0258288383,
-0.5843909383,
0.3930568993,
-0.6672773957,
-1.0913358927,
-0.2629117966,
0.8100040555,
-0.0105780065,
0.0173692089,
0.8424787521,
0.6588501334,
0.0188256055,
0.041087836,
0.5082452297,
0.128975004,
0.3659749031,
0.3486563861,
0.8122289777,
-0.7052550912,
0.5531261563,
0.1709530652,
-0.1256893575,
-0.3000529408,
-1.3196150064,
-0.8364087343,
-0.5276051164,
-0.6461607218,
-0.2665908635,
0.3384056091,
1.0386513472,
0.3233699501,
-0.7811729908,
-0.2917596102,
0.002645968,
0.067762889,
-0.4663157463,
-0.203598693,
0.3368097246,
-0.3040560484,
-0.6238448024,
0.5152187943,
-0.1310078651,
-0.2335200608,
-0.2636703551,
-0.0914770514,
-0.4110044241,
0.6086059809,
0.393559128,
0.2599133551,
-0.7464085221,
-0.5482881069,
-0.4103868604,
0.0579067208,
-0.033898972,
0.8399010897,
-0.644204855,
0.4411153197,
0.2221105993,
0.582916975,
0.1484673321,
0.1589041948,
1.0175577402,
-1.1520135403,
-0.1784921438,
0.3530340791,
0.3963822424,
0.5616292953,
-0.617510736,
0.3021597564,
0.3961226046,
-0.6430297494,
-0.7515605688,
0.147546038,
-0.9275413156,
-0.2154435962,
1.0949984789,
-0.3133124411,
-0.2948575914,
-0.1492161155,
-0.2089397758,
0.3401996791,
-0.7017430663,
0.3447340727,
1.070928216,
0.0396779031,
0.1257877648,
-0.2870073318,
0.7191902995,
0.5582727194,
-0.4853587151,
0.5886577964,
0.7253984809,
-0.0611130558,
0.3791058064,
0.378757,
-0.0096995011,
0.0919444039,
0.0017712703,
0.4330325723,
-0.1168637052,
-0.4144972563,
-0.1524109095,
0.2022394538,
-0.1742597967,
-0.0354641452
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16937v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16937v1 | A Complete Survey on LLM-based AI Chatbots | 2024-06-17T09:39:34 | 2024-06-17T09:39:34 | Sumit Kumar Dam, Choong Seon Hong, Yu Qiao, Chaoning Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The past few decades have witnessed an upsurge in data, forming the
foundation for data-hungry, learning-based AI technology. Conversational
agents, often referred to as AI chatbots, rely heavily on such data to train
large language models (LLMs) and generate new content (knowledge) in response
to user prompts. With the advent of OpenAI's ChatGPT, LLM-based chatbots have
set new standards in the AI community. This paper presents a complete survey of
the evolution and deployment of LLM-based chatbots in various sectors. We first
summarize the development of foundational chatbots, followed by the evolution
of LLMs, and then provide an overview of LLM-based chatbots currently in use
and those in the development phase. Recognizing AI chatbots as tools for
generating new knowledge, we explore their diverse applications across various
industries. We then discuss the open challenges, considering how the data used
to train the LLMs and the misuse of the generated knowledge can cause several
issues. Finally, we explore the future outlook to augment their efficiency and
reliability in numerous applications. By addressing key milestones and the
present-day context of LLM-based chatbots, our survey invites readers to delve
deeper into this realm, reflecting on how their next generation will reshape
conversational AI. | [
-0.1753767133,
-0.940328002,
0.4141190052,
-0.0856213719,
0.3761297464,
0.3745245039,
-0.1882995218,
-0.4975502789,
0.1072712615,
0.7165611386,
-0.5456522703,
-0.3591910899,
-0.5601229668,
-0.2139276862,
-0.4633349478,
0.8343150616,
0.2696006894,
-0.1808709651,
-0.6627143621,
-0.0454636961,
-0.4685204923,
-0.6712990403,
-0.6771603227,
-0.628914535,
0.3852342069,
0.4696009755,
0.730581224,
0.3201256096,
0.4079352319,
0.368011862,
-0.2018606812,
0.2868152857,
-0.6946391463,
0.3010207117,
0.3391076326,
-0.9233101606,
-0.3572046757,
0.0581632107,
0.3760111332,
0.5398375392,
-0.1847884506,
-0.0252996571,
-0.041683659,
0.4373909235,
-0.2840291262,
0.4178858399,
-1.0014563799,
0.0201839712,
-0.0480815694,
-0.2868572176,
-0.3164822757,
-0.3441948593,
0.1231825352,
-0.3628326058,
-0.0975793749,
-0.0105768265,
0.4941558242,
0.3944961429,
-0.5230872035,
-0.5564036369,
-1.062466979,
0.7663143277,
-0.5062201619,
0.3097599745,
0.1166168153,
0.6120688915,
-0.4737347662,
-0.704143405,
-0.3931239247,
-0.5123080611,
0.2408680469,
0.1685367078,
-0.1505324841,
-0.1403468698,
-0.1014236137,
0.4060803354,
-0.3289108872,
0.4293016493,
-0.3223632574,
-0.0539117903,
0.6316449642,
0.3002898097,
0.490488559,
0.3356659412,
-0.2984981537,
-0.0945898369,
-0.995141089,
-0.2005560249,
0.2706457675,
-0.0096485019,
-0.2422274947,
0.6856590509,
-0.2089812607,
0.5298622251,
-0.2745814323,
-0.2401886582,
0.1778659374,
-0.2825253606,
-0.2127904594,
-0.0448234603,
0.917360425,
0.2314010262,
0.399690032,
-0.1076555848,
-0.0262859147,
-0.2804599106,
0.1978773624,
-0.3491163552,
-0.0012404935,
0.192943722,
-0.1109240353,
-0.5020608902,
-0.4690789282,
-0.4217046797,
-0.772823751,
-0.0377412327,
-0.1120170876,
-0.1722639054,
-0.1951122135,
-0.1699782461,
-0.0247894544,
0.7941541672,
0.60016644,
-0.8242304921,
-0.0628817454,
0.7323983908,
0.7135824561,
0.0163073875,
-0.2058125436,
0.0572951585,
-0.0706948712,
-0.4268558919,
0.9214824438,
-0.4406150281,
-0.4636971951,
0.3556033671,
-0.3185249269,
0.0291651003,
-0.7152191997,
0.1065593809,
-0.5210379362,
0.3273261487,
0.2917577326,
-0.5807349086,
-0.1486269236,
0.8013910651,
-0.3735580742,
0.701720655,
-0.0235826448,
-0.358936429,
0.1465346217,
-0.7665305138,
-0.3219884038,
0.2608233392,
-0.3340959251,
-0.2156990916,
-0.2373203486,
0.2662108839,
0.5081387758,
-0.6262428164,
0.0696739927,
-0.1855370253,
-0.2695404887,
0.6473169327,
-0.7144030333,
0.6909416318,
0.1882688254,
0.0100007141,
0.1122143865,
-0.411907196,
-0.0583907589,
0.0690541565,
-0.2142508626,
0.2369818836,
0.3408483565,
-0.3023421764,
0.0996651649,
0.4696009755,
-0.464543283,
0.1591816396,
-0.4177348912,
0.6498559117,
0.6673372984,
0.1276637018,
0.3547782004,
-0.5530350208,
0.6018027663,
-0.046038378,
0.3468983173,
-0.4355825186,
-0.6460884213,
-0.91348809,
0.007028454,
-0.0927628726,
0.7014219165,
-0.6186971068,
0.4711616337,
-0.3706319332,
-0.8694494367,
-0.5460226536,
0.0985917076,
-0.1024171636,
0.3119853735,
-0.0113551896,
0.1110060215,
-0.1955555528,
-0.6088761091,
0.0608152226,
-0.5803578496,
-0.0607535876,
0.6910924315,
0.1444223523,
-0.5046513677,
0.8588848114,
-0.3503248096,
-0.1792897582,
-0.6949049234,
-0.2887696922,
0.0199791174,
0.2039010674,
0.2573030293,
-0.62007761,
-0.3792435229,
0.1945339888,
-0.8372350335,
0.0732393786,
-0.3265445828,
0.0048215124,
0.1644831002,
0.565901041,
-0.7090247869,
0.1776989996,
0.545918107,
0.1923517585,
0.2315392345,
0.0337790251,
-0.0783056021,
-1.049374938,
-0.0184741765,
-0.250708729,
-0.1596788764,
-0.5926504135,
-0.2232728451,
-0.4106697142,
-0.1395948082,
-0.6118741632,
0.7458044887,
-0.3607497513,
-0.0478649698,
-0.311968863,
0.4166032076,
-0.586260736,
0.4332973063,
-0.0962214842,
0.6512038112,
0.5720379949,
-0.5931409597,
0.64245224,
0.5308821201,
-0.1641716212,
0.3636859953,
-0.6165037155,
0.4068725705,
-0.009998682,
0.2508237362,
-0.8777649999,
-0.1687104851,
0.5024403334,
-0.6919159889,
-0.1094646603,
-0.1690033674,
-0.5649696589,
-0.2079736143,
-0.0673442036,
0.0447505563,
0.8422284126,
-0.3547699451,
0.3827086091,
0.5292586088,
-0.2137592882,
-0.5811060667,
-0.6643372774,
0.3669919372,
-0.1318480521,
-0.630205512,
-0.1638534069,
-0.1433788985,
-0.377250731,
-0.2742917836,
0.0410045907,
-0.0693797767,
0.271427989,
0.3641315401,
0.092697911,
-0.1209413484,
-0.0619557239,
-0.3323574066,
-0.0284571089,
0.1099692509,
-0.0797311813,
0.9266123772,
-0.012398107,
-0.710310638,
-0.3910773098,
-0.1085848138,
0.474730283,
-0.0267901123,
0.5612231493,
0.388323009,
0.0541739017,
-0.0687413141,
-0.6342114806,
-0.064423278,
-0.4773001373,
0.4099481702,
0.1095219627,
-1.1732040644,
0.4526956081,
-0.185123831,
0.4922687113,
0.3254017234,
0.8446977139,
-0.2101638466,
0.6734624505,
0.7189369202,
-0.3548773825,
0.6916051507,
-0.0836176872,
0.2338076532,
-0.4068515003,
-0.4607700408,
-0.433797121,
-0.2703915834,
-0.6754229665,
-0.3382306397,
0.3063848317,
-0.4322076738,
-0.131268993,
0.0462468527,
-0.1617702693,
0.429967165,
0.6190982461,
-0.0553487167,
0.3316530883,
-0.2013290823,
0.6279150248,
0.4755167961,
-0.6324990988,
-0.6237254739,
1.2674789429,
0.3968033791,
0.6920709014,
-0.0520938672,
0.4973074198,
0.51960361,
0.3481794894,
-0.9205292463,
0.5907317996,
0.2908301353,
-0.5327808857,
-0.3791431189,
-0.4794141948,
-1.0383070707,
-0.1479445994,
0.0783490837,
-0.4080252051,
-0.4542936385,
0.0051525068,
0.0392581411,
0.2601728439,
-0.4197541475,
0.5738897324,
-0.5017378926,
0.2433408201,
-0.2806268334,
-0.6865082383,
0.3669386506,
0.0339683853,
-0.0725950226,
-0.3440101445,
-0.0248862486,
0.4652763307,
-0.4169827402,
0.9116789103,
-0.0779311135,
-0.3624534309,
0.7713956237,
-0.2406375259,
0.3613517284,
-0.0857538804,
0.1630638838,
0.3817744255,
-0.2436335087,
-0.3021686375,
-0.6186745167,
0.3700190783,
-0.9062540531,
-0.5633359551,
-0.255628258,
-0.4603060782,
-0.3855252266,
-0.0042182147,
-0.0523389988,
0.1484756172,
-0.5784009695,
0.2933287323,
0.515322566,
-0.4356272519,
0.3650289774,
0.4760604501,
-0.17200239,
-0.2268884778,
0.8581953645,
-0.174816668,
0.2823269069,
0.575941503,
-0.0887115598,
-0.1839531511,
-0.6319370866,
-0.4011358917,
0.0721705407,
-0.459949404,
-0.1364013851,
-0.4465515316,
-0.6323052049,
-0.3984862566,
-0.1362318248,
-0.4055104256,
-0.0791689903,
-0.2842444479,
0.1253059953,
0.5206887722,
0.8824592233,
0.3406941295,
0.6211972237,
-0.6991548538,
-0.0259434506,
0.4240445793,
0.1760131121,
-0.0707087517,
-0.2476105541,
-0.1146060303,
0.3640917838,
-0.3823572099,
-0.4745154679,
0.1820393652,
0.1752251238,
0.7264368534,
0.3987229764,
-0.0724343807,
0.2037452459,
-0.1943435222,
1.1114360094,
0.0675829798,
-0.2626028657,
0.4536899924,
-0.3967863023,
0.1012095958,
0.2423727363,
0.185564667,
-1.0216583014,
-0.4241697788,
-0.4968160987,
-0.6173628569,
0.696336627,
0.2208400518,
0.597430706,
0.1855190843,
0.2431405336,
0.1545243263,
0.3182881474,
-0.4363926947,
-0.3149239719,
0.0618110187,
-0.3300976157,
-0.110426195,
0.0432477035,
-0.0609336533,
0.2677049041,
0.5298013091,
-0.0782371834,
0.5528163314,
-0.3516174555,
-0.2904326022,
0.4162106216,
0.3907283843,
0.4051623344,
0.480371654,
0.0405700803,
-0.277692318,
0.0632776693,
-0.3462420106,
0.164873749,
-0.19098261,
-0.135133341,
-0.3375124931,
0.2700959444,
0.662781775,
-0.0557459332,
-1.0811783075,
0.5399606228,
-0.032144729,
-0.1956502199,
-0.7524453402,
0.4644129872,
0.0877499506,
0.4721465111,
0.1393003911,
-0.0163811129,
-0.3591302931,
-0.7267848849,
0.0884656608,
0.5808443427,
-0.5146075487,
-0.1682492942,
0.4562386572,
0.4491271973,
-0.4402400553,
0.9451268315,
-0.0220007505,
-0.2510571182,
0.5710612535,
0.2979697883,
0.8781222105,
0.2047439814,
0.1782087237,
-0.3119125962,
0.144795239,
0.1494700015,
0.1751377434,
-0.2458316088,
-1.094817996,
-0.0812636539,
-0.2619308233,
-0.9490312934,
0.1873054504,
0.0349301994,
0.1672809869,
-0.5574170351,
0.0208141189,
-0.3691202402,
-0.0677312687,
-0.7451556921,
-0.1086825803,
0.3630803227,
0.6946546435,
-0.3462301493,
0.5838922858,
0.7586384416,
-0.4006031752,
-0.1393174529,
-0.0727259517,
0.0732796267,
-1.3629015684,
0.2544956803,
0.0220192429,
-0.0171373207,
0.0072070076,
-0.8819177747,
-0.6227549911,
1.1119081974,
0.1452551931,
-0.3723677397,
-0.105910182,
0.7241508365,
0.6815547943,
-0.2470317185,
0.5821581483,
0.5604883432,
0.1969037652,
0.2614301741,
-0.7986226678,
-0.5090465546,
-0.2714412808,
-0.1597239673,
-0.0456986651,
-0.952861011,
0.4472009838,
0.0441957898,
-0.098842673,
0.243458569,
0.6558474302,
0.0946057141,
0.4641421735,
0.3045541644,
0.1714800596,
0.6440186501,
-0.1023598686,
0.5609855652,
-0.3928983212,
-0.0581488125,
0.8217175007,
-0.3577596247,
0.6200461984,
0.0547062494,
-0.2347009331,
0.3670826554,
0.5462988615,
-0.3026177585,
0.0388534591,
0.34766078,
-0.2517555058,
-0.0741536617,
-0.279315114,
-0.1467918456,
0.74389714,
0.4844524562,
-0.1731846184,
-0.1027899235,
-0.033778131,
0.2450468093,
-0.2978976667,
-0.2312234193,
1.1091934443,
-0.0065148361,
-0.5365792513,
0.3381494284,
-0.210122779,
0.7929171324,
-0.6614816189,
0.0499007627,
-0.4933762848,
0.0740252957,
0.1260643303,
-0.9527295232,
0.0389356464,
0.2117685825,
0.1209949553,
-0.3322824538,
0.8510698676,
-0.2835315764,
-0.0811837837,
-0.0269740243,
1.0477657318,
0.5764127374,
-0.2330195606,
-0.5213893652,
-0.0851729214,
-0.0135671692,
-0.0133770406,
0.2732480466,
0.3845414519,
0.100363791,
1.0820052624,
0.4350799918,
-0.0038981088,
0.1832296848,
0.0028746556,
0.7674372792,
-0.7716211677,
-0.1182328835,
-0.6927019358,
0.3358743191,
-0.0319095813,
-0.3421983123,
0.7196739316,
0.4178094268,
0.7519487739,
0.2363902032,
1.0843297243,
-0.0705203488,
0.4367040992,
-0.3489228785,
1.0125621557,
-0.4214741588,
0.200213775,
0.1308620572,
-0.7457256913,
-0.0007197757,
-0.0251061879,
-0.1666765213,
0.2762380838,
0.0366798677,
0.7283713818,
0.2724149525,
0.2229150832,
0.4204907119,
0.1435226947,
0.5874865055,
0.4643135369,
1.3223668337,
-0.1923419386,
0.8202469349,
0.1029657274,
0.0268479716,
-0.4557495117,
-0.3369916081,
-0.8126962185,
-0.4920991361,
-0.3474478424,
0.1307468265,
0.1081669331,
0.7904080749,
0.477553159,
-0.5146819353,
-0.3372808993,
-0.1562664062,
0.2736926079,
0.0563162901,
-0.1791269481,
-0.1657113582,
-0.5519509912,
-0.8345277309,
0.6249001026,
0.055718977,
0.2859006226,
-0.4686961174,
-0.0495629907,
0.0877561867,
0.0712089911,
0.6668540835,
0.5556798577,
-0.4859547615,
-0.1409092396,
0.0823292956,
-0.1318031251,
0.3053288162,
0.6504617929,
-0.7742502093,
0.133341223,
0.4243424833,
0.852719903,
0.3215571344,
-0.162035808,
0.6664006114,
-0.6557248235,
-0.0301861633,
0.3455534279,
0.0234631244,
0.454783082,
-0.0723108426,
0.5697771311,
0.2301790714,
-0.7734616995,
-0.6904423833,
0.1433944106,
-0.820730865,
-0.0634812862,
1.0418530703,
0.1200706363,
-0.0005327768,
-0.1219868138,
-0.1624658555,
0.2620182633,
-0.5044803023,
0.6364911199,
0.5299367309,
-0.4469612539,
-0.2578456402,
-0.4773071408,
0.3612252176,
0.1123684198,
-1.0923352242,
0.180246979,
0.5802970529,
0.0941653773,
-0.0900551602,
0.7209874392,
-0.0000864159,
-0.1284973621,
0.1520892084,
0.1604358405,
0.0688389316,
-0.3483057618,
-0.1665193737,
0.0384579599,
0.2635204196,
-0.1899008006
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11357v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11357v2 | Refiner: Restructure Retrieval Content Efficiently to Advance Question-Answering Capabilities | 2024-06-17T09:25:10 | 2024-06-18T02:44:27 | Zhonghao Li, Xuming Hu, Aiwei Liu, Kening Zheng, Sirui Huang, Hui Xiong | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs) are limited by their parametric knowledge,
leading to hallucinations in knowledge-extensive tasks. To address this,
Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) incorporates external document chunks to
expand LLM knowledge. Furthermore, compressing information from document chunks
through extraction or summarization can improve LLM performance. Nonetheless,
LLMs still struggle to notice and utilize scattered key information, a problem
known as the "lost-in-the-middle" syndrome. Therefore, we typically need to
restructure the content for LLM to recognize the key information. We propose
$\textit{Refiner}$, an end-to-end extract-and-restructure paradigm that
operates in the post-retrieval process of RAG. $\textit{Refiner}$ leverages a
single decoder-only LLM to adaptively extract query-relevant contents verbatim
along with the necessary context, and section them based on their
interconnectedness, thereby highlights information distinction, and aligns
downstream LLMs with the original context effectively. Experiments show that a
trained $\textit{Refiner}$ (with 7B parameters) exhibits significant gain to
downstream LLM in improving answer accuracy, and outperforms other
state-of-the-art advanced RAG and concurrent compressing approaches in various
single-hop and multi-hop QA tasks. Notably, $\textit{Refiner}$ achieves a 80.5%
tokens reduction and a 1.6-7.0% improvement margin in multi-hop tasks compared
to the next best solution. $\textit{Refiner}$ is a plug-and-play solution that
can be seamlessly integrated with RAG systems, facilitating its application
across diverse open-source frameworks. | [
-0.4701681435,
-0.5624716282,
0.6312999725,
-0.2306368798,
-0.2557623982,
0.3254016042,
-0.3261211812,
-0.2792277038,
0.4398730099,
0.6638667583,
-0.522126615,
-0.0251041185,
-0.3636477888,
0.2088047415,
-0.6127242446,
1.0130938292,
-0.0149004795,
-0.2091554105,
-0.4199654162,
-0.0718472078,
-0.6144925952,
-0.2784951329,
-0.8532423973,
-0.2042909414,
0.8170196414,
0.5569577217,
0.3087947369,
0.2851467431,
0.352655828,
0.3589108884,
-0.1229149476,
0.3832894266,
-0.9144324064,
0.7600545287,
-0.5255460739,
-0.573380053,
-0.0196558237,
-0.2992631495,
0.5585784912,
0.338475883,
-0.496918112,
0.5139489174,
-0.1653041542,
0.8290726542,
-0.7829195261,
-0.2370432168,
-0.9227285385,
-0.4331290424,
-0.1605830044,
-0.4099752307,
-0.5222613811,
-0.299865216,
-0.1481745541,
-0.6322453022,
0.4586993456,
0.2769084275,
1.0443937778,
0.5638098717,
-0.2809466124,
-0.0020585512,
-0.7904666066,
0.6945931911,
-0.610839963,
0.6913855076,
-0.0581334494,
0.6089456081,
-0.2909124494,
-1.2502381802,
-0.6056941152,
0.4660830796,
-0.1753825694,
0.3217029572,
0.0303405039,
-0.2472354025,
0.0953806117,
0.6180368066,
-0.5110488534,
-0.1992207021,
-0.6311131716,
-0.0124746272,
0.3903106451,
0.0827143788,
0.0751432851,
-0.0531003475,
-0.3046691716,
-0.0024037536,
-0.5405243635,
-0.0161615424,
0.1119310185,
0.2050963789,
0.5878911614,
0.4328260124,
-0.3872447312,
0.5022825599,
0.2184129506,
0.0280339327,
0.1201199517,
-0.1873524487,
-0.4786086679,
-0.2278979272,
0.3424233496,
0.0918141678,
-0.0108952913,
-0.2215815485,
-0.4070331454,
-0.524749279,
0.7625246048,
-0.9482361674,
-0.0241986196,
0.2705157697,
-0.4768165946,
-0.0865974203,
0.0662579387,
-0.7484431267,
-0.2351545095,
-0.427595377,
0.2949194014,
-0.1842695475,
-0.3998734951,
0.1487185955,
-0.4769929349,
0.5110353827,
0.4793705642,
-0.6134333611,
0.2954022586,
0.7830687761,
0.5924599767,
0.0762456357,
0.0421110541,
-0.8086465597,
0.2619669139,
-0.0248511452,
1.1631724834,
-0.6462686658,
-0.298650533,
-0.0427157506,
0.1953231692,
0.0245540421,
-0.7581109405,
0.6782266498,
-1.1761395931,
0.4566970766,
-0.3400363326,
-0.3985039592,
-0.4660198689,
0.4239632487,
-0.7487931848,
1.1888198853,
0.3860088885,
-0.7242859006,
0.0939430147,
-0.2481830865,
-0.1387423426,
0.0606928505,
-0.064959757,
-0.2661017776,
0.5521429777,
0.1282551289,
-0.0378762893,
-0.5897738934,
0.300650686,
-0.022834057,
-0.5548036695,
0.177350685,
-0.2356495708,
0.3385604024,
0.2604822218,
0.1558205783,
0.2807711065,
-0.5405248404,
0.2534248233,
-0.0371781215,
-0.6485291719,
-0.2097673714,
-0.1195324436,
0.1461815089,
0.1476875395,
0.4290953577,
-0.475782752,
0.1990123987,
-0.3689264357,
0.1370470226,
0.8278000355,
0.2120306343,
0.2970120907,
-0.5783033371,
0.6767955422,
-0.4295325279,
0.1194861457,
-0.2627186477,
-0.1439511627,
-1.0304050446,
-0.2145038843,
0.3582543135,
0.5137636662,
-0.7527996302,
0.0283710063,
-0.4609864056,
-0.4599376023,
-0.6934217811,
0.1783464849,
0.3254981637,
0.5880964398,
0.4807987809,
-0.2428963482,
-0.725335896,
-0.8604497313,
-0.4236242473,
-0.0467902273,
-0.2175320536,
0.1476007998,
0.1562959105,
-0.1643695384,
0.8609961867,
-0.7219897509,
-0.084291175,
-0.2393932641,
0.0227395184,
0.3755753934,
0.1930229664,
-0.0061867177,
-0.8897061348,
-0.5166116357,
-0.1423972696,
-0.3645880818,
-0.2697917223,
0.0219843797,
-0.4196470082,
0.1172490269,
0.7447263002,
-0.4948903024,
0.241487354,
0.176072672,
-0.2514684498,
0.5985476375,
-0.1889425367,
0.1297895312,
-1.1185611486,
0.2993917465,
-0.5542336702,
-0.2383319438,
-0.5959770679,
0.3636695147,
-0.0945369154,
-0.0555326454,
-0.2054644227,
0.6002677679,
-0.4185042381,
-0.1956656873,
-0.5626171231,
0.2459010035,
0.3982436061,
0.5341487527,
0.0342132971,
0.7562502623,
-0.0982248411,
-0.2957846224,
0.2463680059,
0.2011848241,
-0.1617092043,
0.495978117,
-0.6214332581,
0.3287476599,
-0.5551102161,
0.3156192899,
-1.3321999311,
-0.1624173522,
-0.1480723023,
-0.5635777116,
0.5190221071,
-0.2171250582,
-0.4050024152,
-0.0340681002,
-0.3777258098,
0.4212138057,
0.6497362256,
-0.4914752841,
0.877128005,
0.0834357366,
-0.3725472391,
-0.6051464081,
-0.347420007,
-0.0902687982,
-0.1229593158,
-0.5471469164,
0.2996617258,
-0.1103374735,
0.0313561819,
-0.0190098099,
-0.4321581125,
-0.0705077201,
-0.0053581884,
0.0998945758,
0.2439482659,
-0.1177076548,
0.3146464825,
0.116191715,
-0.2677615881,
-0.0887375101,
-0.2167414278,
0.6935025454,
0.1187460646,
-0.2497161329,
0.1222064868,
0.4445713758,
0.8169701099,
-0.6234881282,
0.6369451284,
0.7712904215,
-0.2832460105,
-0.126012668,
-0.8958538175,
-0.2509429753,
-0.5049396753,
0.213871941,
-0.428604126,
-0.9767118692,
0.504031837,
-0.2668376267,
0.4033542275,
0.2969371378,
0.3521229625,
0.0260271933,
0.5522041321,
0.6002209187,
0.2353067398,
0.5481489897,
-0.1085046679,
0.4169115126,
-1.3046500683,
-0.45793432,
-0.6538327336,
-0.515137136,
-0.3463360965,
-0.6229090095,
0.2823168635,
0.3183701932,
-0.3525491655,
0.0044106874,
-0.6208940148,
0.4916858077,
0.5411440134,
0.0658425987,
0.457070142,
0.0458713658,
0.0631001741,
0.071004115,
-0.638302207,
-0.2944035232,
1.0336937904,
0.156635657,
0.697332263,
0.1875966787,
0.8115846515,
-0.0698301122,
0.6213949323,
-0.6774764061,
0.441712141,
-0.0609322488,
-0.5595501065,
-0.3043402135,
-0.2495640218,
-0.8398897648,
0.4541027248,
-0.1532705873,
-0.3875992894,
0.2993766963,
-0.2133006603,
-0.3357190788,
0.3571616411,
-0.6463955641,
0.6398397088,
-0.0895123631,
-0.4837253392,
-0.2479903549,
-0.4434566796,
0.3138449788,
-0.1831054688,
0.2872051299,
-0.0050318628,
-0.3316852152,
0.5856321454,
-0.4238284528,
0.4456203878,
-0.2240408808,
-0.1721845269,
0.2166934758,
0.1795261204,
0.6159914136,
0.02786934,
-0.0713041797,
-0.2757799327,
0.0134447711,
-0.2909264565,
-0.9640899301,
0.6579030752,
-0.4436717033,
-0.8598672152,
-0.2716169655,
-0.5193536878,
-0.0733923018,
0.4273398519,
-0.0237686355,
0.4120543301,
0.0843577087,
0.1383365542,
0.7966073751,
-0.2209640443,
0.1808443964,
0.7740857005,
-0.5282825828,
-0.5581774712,
0.8555386662,
-0.1811001748,
0.2779757679,
0.6469150782,
0.0542014241,
-0.5730049014,
-0.5488171577,
-0.2218778878,
0.3396367431,
-0.7855607271,
-0.514672637,
-0.6139864922,
-0.2380080521,
-0.3039032221,
-0.1488632858,
-0.263179034,
-0.3785956502,
-0.1118186042,
0.0241560005,
0.4756026268,
0.4407293499,
0.217772156,
0.2182941288,
-0.8901843429,
0.5258103013,
0.3928768635,
0.5469045043,
0.1196239665,
-0.7888351083,
-0.3176098466,
-0.1584753394,
-0.0428501591,
-0.6847351789,
0.2681051791,
0.043118652,
0.4398243427,
0.2621206641,
0.1110543236,
0.9702490568,
-0.5155621171,
0.5163666606,
-0.1368188858,
-0.5001226664,
0.2372549921,
-0.1385899633,
0.4262493849,
0.9622424245,
0.1593813449,
-0.8684772849,
-0.4276751876,
-0.5238461494,
-1.1635285616,
0.460478127,
-0.0848452002,
-0.1494547129,
-0.0616084151,
0.5437671542,
0.1348238587,
0.3356107473,
-0.3193190396,
0.0310596172,
-0.0456570536,
-0.1588406265,
0.1552711278,
-0.4547920525,
0.0066126436,
-0.1028477624,
0.799985528,
-0.0058396431,
0.1631789654,
0.3106638193,
-0.0004141805,
-0.1452776194,
0.5350623131,
0.1913456917,
0.650321126,
-0.3852955997,
0.1231377721,
0.0858688354,
-0.3821898103,
0.087675564,
0.129229635,
-0.157055825,
0.0188244022,
0.1712709218,
0.3447984755,
0.2166139334,
-1.0237016678,
0.119407855,
-0.3303981125,
0.0681528151,
-0.5050884485,
0.0007990143,
0.1029530391,
0.3960061967,
0.5135189891,
-0.0156727098,
0.2534663975,
-0.4638055563,
0.2776257098,
0.3518255651,
-0.1193155423,
0.1118500829,
0.6120699048,
0.1649101228,
-0.1814331114,
0.8718233705,
-0.1723106354,
-0.5293490887,
0.2097559869,
0.4712335765,
1.0387032032,
-0.2017406374,
-0.0722023994,
0.5387985706,
0.2025600672,
-0.1446457952,
0.4366714358,
-0.0395881906,
-0.5331705213,
-0.7597209811,
-0.9279257655,
-0.197708413,
0.0951224491,
-0.7484551072,
0.2607053816,
-0.2960014641,
0.16074422,
-0.3918332458,
-0.0327016897,
-0.4117967188,
0.1004469022,
-0.1920187622,
1.0827168226,
-0.4895923138,
0.5088178515,
0.7764033675,
-0.4889601469,
-0.7835510373,
-0.1736881584,
-0.3294630647,
-0.6117115021,
0.4736820161,
0.1210887954,
-0.1732968241,
0.0486453995,
-0.2178074569,
-1.1198545694,
1.1753188372,
0.1252055615,
-0.6759611368,
-0.2436201721,
-0.241373077,
0.4656419158,
-0.1506097168,
0.5769380927,
0.5788141489,
0.5099708438,
0.4349730611,
-0.7803611755,
0.402554661,
-0.4062818289,
0.0858355984,
0.5936987996,
-0.7871655226,
0.7640010118,
0.0259213019,
-0.4461561143,
0.1318881512,
0.5223069787,
0.2714027762,
0.2054100633,
0.5466392636,
0.8578740358,
0.8030645847,
-0.0136971204,
0.834048748,
-0.268463403,
0.1313591748,
1.4009954929,
-0.1750476658,
1.0967196226,
0.6712065935,
0.0502376407,
0.8617781997,
0.462802738,
0.2831270397,
0.5133726001,
0.3141274452,
-0.3313544691,
-0.3224042058,
-0.2001124471,
-0.2116830498,
0.1980112642,
0.2533007264,
-0.1112394109,
-0.4623168707,
-0.1801585257,
-0.0766857788,
0.2020348907,
-0.1785438657,
0.8801886439,
-0.1836354882,
-0.9169583321,
0.8640861511,
-0.0568390079,
0.5477812886,
-0.6758336425,
-0.2291785628,
-0.4576946497,
0.0921473056,
-0.4261630774,
-0.6225677729,
0.5017854571,
-0.0411078818,
-0.4467740953,
-0.3518841267,
0.8697676063,
-0.6478681564,
-0.3118071258,
0.0701541081,
0.5303862691,
0.2572214007,
-0.3984175324,
-0.3184177876,
0.2266437709,
0.2026703656,
-0.2551105917,
0.2259594649,
0.5306643844,
-0.0293263998,
0.625251174,
0.8498626351,
-0.0067158537,
-0.0325230472,
0.1447672993,
1.1176366806,
-0.6639897823,
-0.2186124325,
-0.4487406909,
0.6244524717,
-0.1467868388,
0.1286689937,
0.6139532924,
0.964499414,
0.9412896037,
0.0332501307,
0.667316854,
-0.1341269761,
0.8862544298,
-0.3451113105,
0.4308563173,
-0.8101033568,
0.3230257332,
0.0825210661,
-0.8849172592,
0.1171588898,
0.2353880703,
-0.1022846997,
-0.1269842833,
0.6104177833,
0.7869526148,
-0.0346623883,
-0.1915354878,
0.0124574965,
0.0538366027,
0.4931217134,
0.6358551383,
0.6722877622,
-0.4160323143,
0.8986453414,
0.1450376809,
-0.0558926202,
-0.2344703525,
-0.4549565613,
-0.6826415658,
-0.4536037743,
0.0466789082,
-0.333453089,
-0.2692490518,
0.4321076274,
0.3233549297,
-0.4556401372,
-0.190183267,
-0.0158768669,
0.2380722165,
-0.1330761313,
-0.2649633884,
0.2376698256,
-0.7547516227,
-0.7000488043,
0.3157016337,
0.3320916295,
-0.2869558632,
-0.2726058066,
0.1456823349,
-0.395249784,
0.0979895145,
0.6006790996,
0.3211724758,
-0.5782207251,
-0.2470584661,
0.3367639482,
0.3477472067,
-0.0260985531,
0.9215035439,
-0.9567788839,
0.5363264084,
0.777654171,
0.9376992583,
0.7709763646,
0.3413490653,
0.5386900306,
-0.727391243,
-0.0508411899,
0.2265153527,
0.3354761302,
0.2654926777,
-0.3319151402,
0.5747474432,
0.0736775026,
-0.7045748234,
-0.8142613769,
0.3881277442,
-0.7818229795,
-0.5433383584,
0.8503095508,
0.0833251551,
-0.2988061905,
-0.1584071815,
-0.4288206398,
0.322029531,
-0.4862917066,
0.8511450291,
0.5782961845,
-0.0881973356,
-0.3334978223,
-0.6037907004,
0.3307571113,
0.4672988057,
-0.7655393481,
0.3222859204,
0.637383163,
0.5261954665,
0.2769657671,
0.6913006306,
-0.1851336509,
0.1782970876,
-0.2808313966,
0.0525385812,
-0.2561933696,
-0.2227616161,
-0.1575373262,
0.1796673685,
0.1699587852,
-0.0720502809
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12937v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12937v1 | Self-Train Before You Transcribe | 2024-06-17T09:21:00 | 2024-06-17T09:21:00 | Robert Flynn, Anton Ragni | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD | When there is a mismatch between the training and test domains, current
speech recognition systems show significant performance degradation.
Self-training methods, such as noisy student teacher training, can help address
this and enable the adaptation of models under such domain shifts. However,
self-training typically requires a collection of unlabelled target domain data.
For settings where this is not practical, we investigate the benefit of
performing noisy student teacher training on recordings in the test set as a
test-time adaptation approach. Similarly to the dynamic evaluation approach in
language modelling, this enables the transfer of information across utterance
boundaries and functions as a method of domain adaptation. A range of in-domain
and out-of-domain datasets are used for experiments demonstrating large
relative gains of up to 32.2%. Interestingly, our method showed larger gains
than the typical self-training setup that utilises separate adaptation data. | [
-0.1663073599,
-0.2181674987,
0.0152003542,
0.0608216897,
-0.1241909191,
0.2752830982,
-0.2111667544,
-0.3964638114,
-0.2763815224,
0.3844079077,
-0.54006809,
0.0422842577,
-0.5637415051,
-0.030517891,
-0.6663116813,
0.8043296933,
0.0483174808,
0.373023659,
-0.0822514221,
-0.0901460871,
-0.7728259563,
-0.8575729728,
-0.5190649033,
-0.2868682742,
0.0621685497,
0.3029965758,
0.1784707755,
0.5324655771,
0.246985659,
0.2337865084,
0.4262738526,
-0.0040514693,
-0.6018204093,
0.3791381419,
-0.3628069758,
-0.3589607477,
0.0256710183,
0.3460810483,
0.8849020004,
0.7071789503,
-0.1349023879,
0.2994511724,
0.4036073685,
0.3384022415,
-0.6720510125,
0.1693218797,
-0.6621171832,
0.383633852,
-0.2341614366,
-0.3103691936,
-0.5206782818,
-0.0759720579,
0.3022012413,
-0.5157034993,
0.3050721884,
-0.3222896457,
0.3936984539,
0.3466306031,
-0.1167171076,
-0.1410737634,
-1.1634719372,
0.8403256536,
-0.6296194792,
0.9741796255,
0.5546070337,
0.3824452162,
-0.1097883508,
-0.703361094,
-0.4143503606,
0.027009584,
0.0488488227,
0.2875051796,
-0.0777436569,
-0.2371815145,
0.176785171,
0.22686252,
-0.5235261321,
0.0286600087,
-0.5643748045,
-0.3056550026,
0.5751996636,
-0.1276858598,
0.2400663644,
0.3541321158,
-0.2223243862,
-0.4895005226,
-0.2837879658,
-0.0049028713,
0.2561912537,
0.6661579609,
-0.0222546477,
0.0713928118,
0.1989242733,
0.638201952,
0.3213250041,
-0.3453273773,
0.355202049,
-0.1209251732,
-0.1513017267,
0.3733612597,
0.3708334863,
-0.2066879123,
0.5929960608,
-0.456109792,
-0.1421652883,
0.0684610084,
0.3799304366,
-0.8480033278,
-0.3782937527,
-0.0847238526,
-0.2943497002,
-0.1473155767,
-0.2889338732,
-0.746878922,
-0.2123669833,
-0.5359582901,
0.8206853271,
-0.3321037889,
-0.3330794275,
0.2501098216,
-0.0803160518,
0.0741892606,
0.2305147648,
-0.8751593828,
0.7367251515,
0.2004668862,
0.6893482804,
-0.4749456346,
-0.4957916439,
-0.741871357,
0.1687229127,
-0.35308972,
0.61421597,
-0.3194249868,
-0.6870436072,
-0.1469224691,
-0.0049148882,
-0.5788693428,
-0.7476348281,
0.3075376749,
-0.408254087,
0.3341553807,
0.2616495788,
-0.5343410373,
0.1328576207,
-0.3122996092,
-0.4587446749,
1.3011798859,
0.3560626507,
-0.2524683177,
0.428214103,
-0.519649148,
-0.7583560348,
-0.0737122446,
-0.0508870594,
-0.5719047189,
-0.004975534,
0.0623139478,
0.4515026808,
0.2571826577,
-0.2144004703,
-0.080697313,
-0.3275196254,
0.5661796331,
-0.4422233105,
0.6264476776,
0.3203815222,
-0.5575600863,
-0.5263382196,
-0.8218922019,
0.3404634297,
0.0158962924,
-0.5283654332,
-0.5537141562,
-0.0900028795,
-0.2943328023,
0.061859943,
-0.3301111758,
-0.4040305912,
0.117067419,
-0.4170971513,
0.3831442893,
0.8030173182,
0.0029650291,
0.3709262311,
-0.2642211616,
0.6169787645,
0.2785633504,
0.0860879496,
0.2330400944,
-0.090500243,
-0.6194987893,
0.0227513257,
0.8604398966,
0.3342745602,
-0.459880501,
0.1421399713,
-0.345867008,
-0.3727217317,
-0.7662416697,
0.2257128656,
0.3745319843,
0.5674142241,
0.5150643587,
-0.7436279655,
-0.5599610209,
-0.3578596413,
-0.5005046725,
-0.1749185026,
0.078050077,
0.2373095453,
0.3099478781,
-0.02315793,
0.6365540624,
-0.2631795704,
-0.5850497484,
-0.0645061582,
0.0689985529,
-0.28090626,
0.6252430081,
0.4961509109,
-0.6662614942,
-0.5709800124,
-0.4740898907,
-0.1753387451,
-0.085574314,
-0.4969705343,
-0.1256411672,
0.016921157,
0.3265040219,
-0.0335580185,
0.4281406701,
0.7245536447,
-0.0966115743,
0.3374848068,
-0.0555142201,
0.0980182141,
-0.775029242,
-0.1941008121,
-0.3605036736,
-0.5264548063,
-0.8904234171,
-0.5531366467,
-0.0940226242,
-0.3116863966,
-0.467355758,
0.5867179036,
-0.6243424416,
-0.1898742467,
-0.2921739817,
0.0331238993,
-0.0620799698,
0.4564018548,
0.1186371669,
1.3732199669,
0.6188534498,
-0.9091687799,
-0.151331231,
0.5454361439,
-0.361324966,
0.3365799487,
-0.2079830319,
0.5684281588,
0.1755769551,
-0.1466826051,
-0.8603519797,
0.0643738136,
0.2934382856,
-0.5914816856,
0.7243255973,
-0.1410477459,
0.1822126657,
-0.4295705557,
0.0948849022,
0.4322767854,
0.601259172,
-0.850236237,
0.5808159113,
0.5142785907,
0.0747230053,
-0.535687685,
-0.9876583815,
-0.1193466559,
-0.2249456942,
0.0171065778,
0.3435790837,
-0.3267417252,
0.1606529355,
-0.2415084094,
-0.401725173,
-0.512455225,
0.3005317748,
0.5123022795,
-0.2581178546,
-0.1564528495,
0.4571250677,
-0.1635618657,
0.1161440089,
0.1996203065,
-0.4444360733,
0.3503856659,
0.2273442149,
-0.1163816676,
-0.5180415511,
0.1757029444,
0.1881213337,
-0.1591819823,
0.3439988494,
0.2614701688,
-0.2779871523,
-0.9959535003,
-0.3330313861,
-0.3659434617,
-0.4912058711,
0.2986623049,
-0.6347153187,
-0.46102494,
0.0072509698,
-0.3801829815,
-0.3219041526,
0.1399041265,
0.4353426099,
-0.3166772723,
0.5111529231,
0.6680260897,
-0.1983837932,
0.8007631302,
-0.201724872,
0.2318223566,
-0.727132082,
-0.0635012761,
-0.5707215071,
-0.2333379537,
-0.2182822376,
-0.3497149348,
0.2440171242,
-0.3018152118,
-0.0403783917,
0.4605949819,
-0.5934429169,
0.3074085116,
0.6582767963,
0.3154088557,
0.0844502226,
0.2912560999,
0.1841824204,
-0.5321820378,
-0.7160198092,
-0.0006117882,
1.3235538006,
0.1587965041,
0.989512682,
-0.0885433927,
0.6568787694,
0.6337872148,
0.2580322027,
-0.6768186092,
0.2723233998,
-0.2470342368,
-0.6368199587,
-0.7277069092,
-0.3658882976,
-1.159942627,
0.1380562782,
-0.042761378,
-0.1991914809,
0.5238044858,
0.1325378269,
-0.4937160015,
0.2496612966,
-0.7615174651,
0.6490857005,
-0.3595055044,
-0.0414067917,
-0.0293387752,
-0.4315542877,
-0.189362675,
-0.6906018853,
0.1008917764,
-0.0046545989,
0.3772672415,
1.2120941877,
-0.242421478,
1.0474905968,
-0.3451527059,
0.0995277762,
0.5386489034,
0.3569753766,
0.2415660769,
-0.4993146062,
-0.1891899705,
0.1338026077,
0.2401176542,
-0.2056981772,
-0.8882207274,
0.2549470961,
-1.238792181,
-0.6094948649,
-0.5165082216,
-0.5550495386,
-0.6149124503,
0.1114017144,
0.0793995038,
0.5530027747,
-0.2842834294,
-0.0158949345,
0.6312862635,
0.181078732,
0.4416596889,
0.7230237126,
0.1410231143,
-0.2216280252,
1.0636813641,
0.4268094003,
0.6138560176,
0.0216047857,
0.3400485218,
-0.4947333038,
-0.6856720448,
-0.283108145,
0.1317988634,
-0.8650856018,
-0.2525896132,
-0.4977238774,
-0.5138659477,
-0.8785903454,
0.239682138,
-0.4767323136,
-0.5339539051,
-0.5284382701,
-0.0245160349,
0.212901473,
0.6404209733,
-0.4239364266,
0.5310621262,
-0.4528619349,
0.1080800593,
0.5999242067,
0.2276634723,
-0.2498433441,
-1.344209075,
-0.4857549369,
0.0249562617,
-0.3536927998,
-0.6695021391,
0.6807941794,
0.9520263672,
0.6053609848,
-0.1260638237,
0.2300634086,
0.8684561849,
-0.5599435568,
0.6170613766,
-0.0642419308,
-1.1628973484,
0.6803326607,
0.2825417221,
0.1241287738,
0.7064855695,
0.5747298598,
-0.432013154,
-0.1392994672,
-0.5994101167,
-0.1746430844,
0.5908818245,
0.0823494941,
0.3323991299,
0.5576661825,
0.6727200747,
0.3274590373,
0.0660530627,
-0.6689966917,
-0.1698478758,
-0.5355986357,
-0.1433065981,
-0.2370198369,
-0.0682861209,
-0.2501707971,
-0.4771754146,
0.7424940467,
-0.3380274773,
0.4647838175,
0.3667432666,
-0.2526978254,
-0.274954915,
0.1090515181,
0.3227570951,
0.5406767726,
0.029680524,
0.3060621619,
0.5847811699,
-0.8700371981,
0.5634351969,
-0.0364956595,
0.1476830691,
0.1322947741,
0.3980421126,
0.6006923318,
0.2234238982,
-0.3567611575,
0.7816029787,
-0.0441850014,
-0.364348352,
-0.1563508213,
0.3360742033,
-0.4195112586,
0.2059346288,
0.0704462826,
0.091957204,
0.2439913601,
-0.6161531806,
0.4617055655,
-0.0620510206,
-0.4837757647,
-0.5026939511,
0.711002171,
0.0364238359,
-0.3891626894,
0.6386019588,
0.1854325384,
-0.5952709913,
0.2395582497,
0.9545302987,
0.9429668188,
-0.9048665166,
0.2388786525,
0.2525360286,
-0.0027088514,
-0.0244953204,
0.3876747489,
-0.3013171256,
-0.7212927341,
-0.3321831524,
-0.475908041,
-0.5280119181,
0.179251194,
-0.6819015145,
0.1187798306,
-0.2958009243,
-0.1043257415,
0.1629501134,
-0.0419517644,
-0.7254815698,
0.6366637349,
0.2413796186,
0.5457172394,
-0.839628458,
1.1701431274,
0.3970656395,
-0.0023288454,
-0.9697822928,
0.0922843292,
-0.4094384611,
-1.0386760235,
0.9086485505,
-0.1681084484,
-0.1970272213,
0.0733853802,
-0.3086222708,
-0.9512149692,
0.7931632996,
0.4435996413,
-0.7896658778,
0.1795889139,
0.5075802803,
0.6177150607,
-0.4042887986,
-0.0967565179,
0.6911776066,
0.2277601957,
-0.0736143216,
-0.9567657709,
-0.045864135,
0.1643908471,
-0.1586681753,
-0.1397339851,
-0.648409605,
0.4940925539,
-0.1270603389,
-0.4862428308,
-0.2764220536,
0.6021900773,
-0.5111961961,
0.0827020705,
0.8297590613,
0.1363309175,
1.0096355677,
-0.0032565736,
0.6972058415,
-0.2416992635,
0.1794725358,
1.474486351,
-0.2090753317,
0.6893556714,
0.3508595824,
-0.3915365636,
0.1523029506,
0.6321994662,
-0.1106298342,
0.9031972289,
0.3694927692,
-0.1843145639,
-0.5324879289,
-0.0216125548,
-0.4910126626,
0.5276808739,
0.0449778847,
-0.2654182613,
-0.01858739,
0.346655935,
-0.4517450929,
0.0099092899,
-0.0949614346,
0.7552980185,
0.3289344609,
-0.2949232161,
0.7933295965,
-0.6258170009,
0.0969104096,
-0.50179106,
0.0792512223,
-0.0413571969,
0.4427159727,
-0.0439177006,
-0.5354620814,
0.3407225907,
-0.3401417732,
-0.0012634838,
-0.5978921056,
0.8506245017,
-0.6235671043,
-0.2008076459,
0.4520829618,
0.690081656,
0.5840379,
-0.0389626399,
-0.8273165226,
-0.007333844,
-0.0798033103,
-0.1927934587,
0.4145072103,
0.4670668244,
0.150402844,
0.5971830487,
0.4938227534,
0.3268461525,
0.266150564,
0.3107248247,
1.0066466331,
-0.5821153522,
-0.4373879731,
-0.4132385254,
0.0224528145,
0.2941405475,
-0.4904844463,
0.7204675078,
0.6209948659,
1.083434701,
-0.1240401119,
0.8951515555,
0.5389595032,
0.9935176969,
-0.4107268453,
0.5219517946,
-0.4291387498,
-0.0333193243,
-0.0445086733,
-0.5161911249,
-0.1151796058,
0.5376223326,
-0.2835122049,
0.0892070606,
0.5425825119,
0.5572604537,
-0.2080187052,
0.1632772684,
0.7738731503,
0.2677752376,
0.1919306815,
0.4135211408,
0.9982308745,
-0.7199367285,
0.666760385,
-0.4094517827,
-0.1146632954,
0.0876667127,
-0.3418478668,
-1.123192668,
-0.6482205391,
-0.6117422581,
-0.5284838676,
0.4964317679,
0.5499638319,
1.1377260685,
-0.9175056219,
-0.4815126359,
0.4432697594,
-0.3896167278,
-0.4376527369,
-0.1339686513,
0.3604363501,
-0.4622243643,
-0.6839832067,
0.7916437387,
-0.2424584478,
0.6450356841,
-0.1739034653,
-0.0453163907,
0.1416570693,
0.171225965,
0.3306415975,
0.4050236344,
-0.0114443107,
-0.4151850939,
-0.1499722898,
0.0688946098,
0.4952553511,
0.8546420932,
-0.9367974401,
0.6086491942,
-0.0303219259,
0.8578544259,
0.8546069264,
0.0428219773,
0.6075001955,
-0.646832943,
0.1586797088,
0.3082123995,
-0.2041044533,
0.2691776454,
-0.6529804468,
0.8065863252,
0.4291658401,
-0.5774800777,
-0.9706300497,
-0.1864665598,
-0.8090496063,
-0.1972541809,
0.9616619945,
-0.2721916437,
-0.2982214093,
-0.2878248394,
-0.0010497404,
0.4019045234,
-0.3630237877,
0.9680877924,
0.5408940911,
-0.1815982461,
0.0592064336,
-0.4254167378,
0.8808099627,
0.6528974771,
-0.6931096315,
0.131336078,
-0.1029446647,
0.6193515658,
0.0537819751,
0.6094902158,
-0.0071037742,
0.1416614801,
0.0670504421,
0.1692616194,
0.1279826015,
-0.53871876,
-0.6448948383,
-0.0335650481,
-0.0276747793,
-0.6867851019
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.