id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
sequencelengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13348v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13348v1 | Textual Unlearning Gives a False Sense of Unlearning | 2024-06-19T08:51:54 | 2024-06-19T08:51:54 | Jiacheng Du, Zhibo Wang, Kui Ren | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Language models (LMs) are susceptible to "memorizing" training data,
including a large amount of private or copyright-protected content. To
safeguard the right to be forgotten (RTBF), machine unlearning has emerged as a
promising method for LMs to efficiently "forget" sensitive training content and
mitigate knowledge leakage risks. However, despite its good intentions, could
the unlearning mechanism be counterproductive? In this paper, we propose the
Textual Unlearning Leakage Attack (TULA), where an adversary can infer
information about the unlearned data only by accessing the models before and
after unlearning. Furthermore, we present variants of TULA in both black-box
and white-box scenarios. Through various experimental results, we critically
demonstrate that machine unlearning amplifies the risk of knowledge leakage
from LMs. Specifically, TULA can increase an adversary's ability to infer
membership information about the unlearned data by more than 20% in black-box
scenario. Moreover, TULA can even reconstruct the unlearned data directly with
more than 60% accuracy with white-box access. Our work is the first to reveal
that machine unlearning in LMs can inversely create greater knowledge risks and
inspire the development of more secure unlearning mechanisms. | [
0.1308786273,
-0.8585812449,
0.1991975904,
-0.4531799555,
-0.3121695518,
0.3653580546,
0.083030507,
-0.1873614639,
-0.5214146972,
0.8781451583,
-0.4952700436,
-0.1740530431,
-0.642680943,
-0.5104648471,
-0.6891733408,
1.078771472,
0.2186450213,
-0.0762083456,
-0.2376409471,
-0.2384863645,
-0.6812161803,
-0.648212254,
-0.3953740299,
-0.4928005338,
0.2503720224,
0.3236254752,
0.5799800754,
0.3475451767,
0.0178222116,
0.3209204376,
-0.0314158052,
0.1381294429,
-0.7052220702,
0.3336238563,
-0.3478394747,
-0.8186887503,
0.047816325,
-0.1317203939,
0.5613939166,
0.5264613032,
-0.2565354407,
0.1871760041,
0.3594167531,
1.3539793491,
-0.8575077653,
-0.142267555,
-1.2170763016,
0.1562338769,
-0.3263679743,
-0.2981852591,
-0.9554101825,
0.115320839,
-0.0423381999,
-0.4373092055,
0.1885072291,
-0.1233127713,
0.8782345653,
0.5128192902,
-0.196047619,
-0.2742413282,
-0.744374752,
0.7657595873,
-0.4755709767,
0.3579606712,
0.6627515554,
0.3020036817,
-0.2718979418,
-0.6703061461,
-0.4855397344,
0.1971490979,
-0.0992802233,
0.049365446,
-0.5900635719,
-0.3027465045,
0.2697355747,
0.0432408415,
-0.4543854892,
0.105298169,
-0.686922431,
-0.1702363491,
0.4644109905,
-0.1844021529,
0.4955428839,
-0.1124018356,
-0.63635993,
-0.0677472278,
-1.0705667734,
0.1206947044,
0.4204431474,
0.19697164,
-0.1794818342,
0.6455577016,
0.3660147786,
0.4503512084,
-0.3083657026,
0.1344944537,
0.201553598,
0.0886318237,
-0.4780035317,
0.1630399972,
0.889918983,
0.0239868071,
0.490164876,
-0.5612382889,
-0.1047434136,
-0.0123822484,
0.5436947346,
-0.5328931212,
0.0419050157,
0.2304872572,
-0.2739810348,
-0.4332297146,
0.3880873621,
-0.9734541178,
-0.598998189,
0.0186503753,
0.628967464,
-0.6730564237,
-0.1705197245,
-0.0613306165,
-0.168147698,
-0.2850959599,
-0.1567685157,
-0.5095220208,
0.0610300861,
0.6446921825,
0.571996212,
0.137072295,
-0.351863414,
-0.7051885724,
0.3526234031,
-0.2398743778,
0.4241321683,
-0.4063448012,
-0.6848341227,
0.1289813966,
0.1341552436,
-0.1619646847,
-0.4080199301,
0.1001731902,
-0.7572399974,
0.5169317126,
0.1121296883,
-0.7329326868,
-0.2854135633,
-0.196447745,
-0.6607093811,
0.9285975099,
-0.1176558435,
-0.8621296883,
0.0939274356,
-0.4708283842,
-0.2909111977,
-0.1738866121,
-0.0580207482,
-0.7971414328,
0.0190684013,
-0.0872480199,
0.3873993158,
0.0666139871,
0.4314804673,
-0.280205816,
-0.3446155787,
0.7832708359,
-0.7118726373,
1.1327968836,
0.4052115381,
-0.5056552887,
-0.3537884653,
-0.7334724665,
0.0050915172,
0.275459826,
-0.0562595986,
-0.7167204022,
-0.089407362,
-0.6030054092,
0.0596359223,
0.1193935052,
-0.4305786788,
0.0380174629,
-0.4405952692,
0.4308769405,
0.7281450629,
0.2333250493,
0.6338716745,
-0.5352914929,
0.3932406306,
0.0764044449,
-0.1585212946,
-0.3635344803,
-0.3212376535,
-0.5800880194,
-0.0023036147,
0.3551276326,
0.6052877307,
-0.6905100346,
0.1029170752,
0.2441232055,
-0.6846953034,
-0.8681615591,
0.2644719183,
0.8931584954,
0.5448947549,
0.3845415413,
0.0663406625,
-0.487161994,
-0.4317872822,
-0.631650269,
-0.2152905315,
-0.0191843566,
-0.0935826972,
0.4711221159,
-0.3668732643,
0.727786243,
-0.3601320386,
-0.5309618115,
-0.1043910235,
0.2181235701,
-0.2220145017,
0.4816519618,
0.29505077,
-0.62868613,
-0.115443252,
-0.0502502099,
-1.0061269999,
0.0853124037,
-0.2207996994,
-0.1095016822,
0.6267340779,
0.6353888512,
-0.5104986429,
0.7238345742,
0.511896193,
-0.3967730999,
0.2264286727,
-0.5409350395,
-0.3093342185,
-1.1000407934,
0.1564908475,
-0.6423786283,
-0.0725383535,
-0.7673562765,
0.002307615,
0.2368347049,
-0.1613831967,
-0.6226927638,
0.5800050497,
-0.5447617769,
0.0417663418,
-0.3270151317,
0.1106927171,
0.188702628,
0.5369461775,
-0.2130424082,
0.6786494851,
0.3865340352,
-0.6408454776,
-0.3134453893,
0.2207080722,
-0.2671167552,
0.1696553379,
-0.4394881129,
0.555446744,
-0.4622924328,
-0.0788496956,
-0.672621727,
0.3497479558,
0.0294159334,
-0.7894178629,
0.554919064,
-0.1964026988,
-0.1881992668,
0.1551040113,
-0.3483852744,
0.0351384655,
0.4869576097,
-0.4402812123,
0.4325701296,
0.6975692511,
0.2078430206,
-1.1332665682,
-0.9027534723,
-0.0873875618,
-0.3218562603,
-0.1383229643,
0.255415678,
0.0557894818,
-0.2570877671,
0.1258040965,
0.0062378063,
-0.1998696774,
0.3809190094,
0.6756570935,
0.2781569958,
0.1708483249,
0.3501392007,
-0.151484251,
-0.2745042741,
0.2162339985,
-0.2976612747,
0.6301973462,
0.1496753693,
-0.3817032874,
-0.3705345094,
0.2111687064,
0.615015924,
-0.3325442076,
0.9661846757,
0.4180347025,
-0.781319201,
-0.4471829534,
-0.2543303072,
-0.1580456197,
-0.4724726379,
0.3590287864,
0.0146961724,
-0.5190956593,
0.2246147394,
0.0638094321,
0.2791686058,
0.2707003653,
0.3752789199,
-0.4611898959,
0.5662025213,
0.7937770486,
-0.1413306445,
0.2540532351,
-0.445414871,
-0.0029632635,
-0.6239582896,
-0.6495546103,
-0.729945302,
-0.1838573515,
-0.6045540571,
-0.1358875036,
-0.0507169291,
0.2391541451,
-0.4255943298,
0.3615919054,
-0.2921873033,
0.6573928595,
0.6586633325,
0.1770725995,
0.5285162926,
0.2556605339,
-0.4274214804,
-0.1460189521,
-0.4925262928,
-0.6740860939,
1.3074645996,
0.3714867532,
0.5965307951,
0.0783960372,
0.558391273,
0.6172173619,
0.0354367532,
-0.3244754076,
0.219841212,
-0.2645377517,
-0.6513613462,
-0.4124625325,
-0.4528276622,
-1.2157465219,
0.1418015808,
-0.280621022,
-0.9302309155,
0.1343402714,
0.1942627877,
-0.0467876084,
0.9182360768,
-0.8760973811,
0.8797943592,
-0.1205477044,
-0.2575043738,
-0.0788991377,
-0.5391204357,
0.3287986517,
-0.5736694336,
0.5505669713,
0.0606321394,
0.154947713,
0.8352251649,
-0.4059118629,
1.1600164175,
-0.267134428,
-0.0222218428,
0.2630600333,
0.6021398306,
0.4927888811,
0.1058323085,
-0.0455329232,
0.1515256017,
-0.0594379306,
-0.3987733424,
-0.596455574,
0.3164089024,
-0.9762631059,
-0.3983352184,
-0.4614266157,
-0.3967494667,
-0.2348976433,
0.2822767794,
0.6155986786,
0.3082957268,
-0.1686776131,
0.3257246315,
0.6986405849,
-0.1007910967,
0.612396419,
0.7829543352,
-0.1186527535,
-0.0068512671,
1.2125790119,
0.0936793387,
0.5129324198,
0.7237750888,
0.1672457904,
-0.318257004,
-0.4053108692,
-0.3306378126,
0.285582304,
-0.4241955876,
-0.4396584034,
-0.6436670423,
-0.3329137862,
0.0550252758,
-0.0151297823,
-0.4504832625,
-0.4177289605,
-0.2728367746,
-0.2061560303,
0.2122992426,
0.8634459972,
0.1407421529,
0.4692366719,
-0.9994661212,
0.0716033727,
0.2672135234,
0.0967885479,
0.1194980368,
-0.8676454425,
-0.0565020218,
0.3552464545,
-0.5468004346,
-0.9699598551,
0.5600666404,
-0.0092397975,
0.4072567821,
0.5713155866,
0.3287733495,
0.3539800644,
-0.47445786,
0.327737242,
0.17812334,
-0.8215857744,
0.3114286065,
-0.0181550439,
0.2513688803,
0.5199071765,
0.352306217,
-0.5361785889,
-0.5884604454,
-1.0906252861,
-0.5032402277,
0.7126389742,
0.0888859183,
0.1018800065,
0.4359600544,
0.0572219864,
0.2674656808,
0.4611576796,
-0.7988020182,
-0.4495808482,
-0.3515892625,
-0.043488346,
-0.0131567279,
-0.4559629261,
0.1313255727,
0.2368845493,
0.8211245537,
0.349119693,
0.1285272539,
-0.1715264022,
-0.6059032083,
-0.3181054294,
0.4683617353,
0.2495271862,
0.5325225592,
-0.0805962905,
0.275495261,
0.3178603053,
-0.6687276959,
0.2394686192,
-0.1566465199,
-0.5369596481,
0.0323948339,
0.423233062,
0.6257798076,
0.2090682536,
-0.7953982949,
0.3202762604,
0.0433773287,
0.0005194607,
-0.4217086732,
0.0866570696,
0.1646242738,
-0.0226660315,
0.2900091708,
0.1604393125,
-0.3845348954,
-0.7312160134,
0.5572382212,
0.4899909496,
-0.9522559643,
-0.3073609173,
0.5269478559,
-0.2844794095,
-0.4598856866,
0.4735744596,
0.1006477103,
-0.4978458285,
0.4108695686,
0.7202351689,
0.5902326703,
-0.6350579262,
0.3489424288,
0.0390901193,
0.513651967,
0.1886142492,
-0.0455789082,
0.2973796725,
-0.6552289724,
-0.0454963595,
-0.289508909,
-0.1643139273,
0.5047720671,
-0.5673678517,
0.14062047,
-0.3231167793,
0.1897374094,
-0.0673088953,
-0.0988713503,
-0.3934170604,
0.0518078431,
-0.2818526328,
0.430972904,
-0.4084947407,
0.9334794283,
0.5110638738,
-0.3083710372,
-0.6024438143,
-0.1450986564,
0.3367713094,
-1.1811854839,
0.4102112949,
0.1300799251,
-0.0435855687,
-0.2136752605,
-0.0650764927,
-0.4109595418,
0.9907335639,
0.5680348873,
-0.6274681091,
-0.0961034894,
0.6183764338,
0.1688555628,
-0.0429982841,
0.0394540541,
0.4142537415,
0.1485974789,
-0.2623648345,
-0.3810261786,
-0.0335270613,
-0.1501150876,
-0.4650480449,
0.4439477623,
-0.3112439215,
0.7236409187,
-0.4377329648,
-0.5308890343,
-0.2710255682,
0.4591534734,
-0.0373587944,
0.4565619528,
0.6128600836,
0.5383745432,
1.1449050903,
0.1386535466,
0.7056268454,
0.0071665677,
0.0694160387,
1.0730552673,
-0.0062071946,
0.8222774863,
0.2580102682,
0.0540168472,
0.3231219351,
-0.0478231721,
0.1691986769,
0.5221757889,
0.0548385009,
-0.0984158516,
0.0724584386,
-0.0484614,
-0.4710178375,
0.5768700242,
0.409607023,
-0.2692162991,
-0.3043221831,
-0.0610687807,
0.7752450705,
0.6505823135,
-0.12691091,
0.9230287671,
0.3143158853,
-0.4672323763,
0.6750738621,
-0.0755498633,
0.2907908559,
-0.6299815774,
0.100459151,
-0.2339120358,
0.4543445706,
-0.2598412633,
-0.6628400683,
0.3762039542,
0.2995655537,
-0.1072490886,
-0.0097260652,
0.7949120998,
-0.6275254488,
-0.3616037071,
0.4321351349,
0.8065810204,
-0.1298424155,
-0.1921459585,
-0.644230485,
-0.3068587184,
0.2618813515,
-0.0425074287,
0.6918922663,
0.7020286322,
-0.1729424,
0.9519592524,
0.789671123,
0.0372307114,
-0.0188363846,
-0.03315676,
0.671025753,
-0.6082661748,
-0.3688977659,
-1.155664444,
0.499989748,
-0.0220087972,
-0.0407666788,
0.6152288318,
0.4223675728,
0.9861898422,
0.1188151613,
0.7933347821,
0.5943903923,
0.5875076056,
-0.7799687982,
1.2843118906,
-0.585082829,
0.5138422847,
-0.2880615592,
-0.5121578574,
-0.0649621561,
-0.0374966823,
0.022494629,
-0.0956137106,
0.9484310746,
0.65140903,
0.0775867701,
0.1977423728,
0.480572015,
0.2472186685,
0.2279818207,
0.482832104,
0.8418266773,
-0.3202533126,
0.9391592741,
-0.294921577,
-0.0083904229,
0.18449305,
-0.7670369148,
-1.2215458155,
-0.7457017899,
-0.0265798736,
-0.4214445949,
0.4170666635,
0.3115963936,
0.1956126541,
-0.6787183881,
-0.2237360477,
0.0353662558,
0.4188352823,
-0.0445115566,
-0.1985290945,
0.5283101201,
-0.4030047059,
-0.4090182781,
0.2933264077,
-0.0079574212,
0.2524902523,
-0.1472154558,
-0.0595963076,
-0.248568967,
-0.1382484436,
0.2544321418,
0.6542770863,
-0.2848501503,
0.1664725691,
-0.0547946841,
0.1012076661,
-0.1746129841,
0.8804756403,
-1.0160205364,
0.2759287059,
0.1896695644,
0.9830439687,
0.3172233701,
-0.1785880625,
0.591414094,
-1.075910449,
0.3729434013,
-0.0971590653,
0.5720926523,
0.2461530119,
-0.3487472534,
0.3624448478,
0.2220688313,
-0.3077666461,
-1.1977823973,
0.1419432312,
-0.3145089447,
-0.7304023504,
0.8409500718,
-0.1235100776,
-0.4050471783,
-0.3522318304,
-0.066415906,
0.5255650878,
-0.4143265784,
0.9428430796,
0.3514671326,
0.7610404491,
0.1232578158,
-0.7936882973,
0.662232697,
0.5225572586,
-0.7387299538,
0.4562540352,
0.0004773289,
0.0287994239,
0.1410949081,
0.3668860793,
-0.4818516374,
0.1970188767,
-0.4288585186,
-0.1176232249,
-0.5845260024,
-0.5119401217,
-0.1781223714,
0.256511122,
-0.1985166222,
-0.3375798166
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13342v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13342v1 | ZeroDL: Zero-shot Distribution Learning for Text Clustering via Large Language Models | 2024-06-19T08:48:05 | 2024-06-19T08:48:05 | Hwiyeol Jo, Hyunwoo Lee, Taiwoo Park | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The recent advancements in large language models (LLMs) have brought
significant progress in solving NLP tasks. Notably, in-context learning (ICL)
is the key enabling mechanism for LLMs to understand specific tasks and
grasping nuances. In this paper, we propose a simple yet effective method to
contextualize a task toward a specific LLM, by (1) observing how a given LLM
describes (all or a part of) target datasets, i.e., open-ended zero-shot
inference, and (2) aggregating the open-ended inference results by the LLM, and
(3) finally incorporate the aggregated meta-information for the actual task. We
show the effectiveness of this approach in text clustering tasks, and also
highlight the importance of the contextualization through examples of the above
procedure. | [
-0.0323152132,
-0.8294947743,
0.7605637908,
-0.0188273322,
-0.5211240053,
-0.1137155294,
-0.3512728214,
-0.0413671322,
0.1021785364,
0.3120615184,
-0.4612133503,
-1.159825325,
-0.449395895,
-0.0904626027,
-0.664441824,
1.1808637381,
0.0829534158,
-0.199425295,
-0.2829062045,
-0.1858315021,
-0.4111454785,
-0.4699434936,
-0.4212233126,
-0.3267465234,
0.6346823573,
0.568146944,
0.0642999336,
0.6160244346,
0.2124919444,
0.1685733795,
-0.2349828333,
-0.1637749076,
-0.6019678116,
0.2895649672,
-0.2069451362,
-0.5937201381,
-0.1012993976,
-0.0887565836,
0.9049530029,
0.910566628,
-0.2071548849,
0.1606476605,
0.0726998225,
0.206841588,
-0.8333794475,
-0.0242137834,
-0.7776759267,
0.2724823058,
-0.1652295142,
-0.2704970539,
-0.736199677,
0.0666769668,
0.1182690784,
-0.3565980196,
0.3119136989,
-0.1410342008,
0.2749527395,
0.3656772077,
-0.6900981069,
-0.3881548345,
-0.7961109281,
1.0622285604,
-0.7027363181,
-0.0040268921,
0.0966170058,
0.3200823069,
0.1332659125,
-0.4118527472,
-0.6035504341,
0.1298428178,
-0.1838433743,
0.1462156773,
0.1596095115,
-0.0784424022,
-0.1192504391,
0.1510958821,
-0.4825387895,
0.1811371595,
0.1113516912,
0.4995746911,
0.3949728906,
0.0120622935,
0.1767565012,
0.1273563057,
-0.4487120211,
-0.0673886165,
-0.7124578357,
-0.22696729,
-0.2621844113,
0.4337743223,
-0.3638593853,
0.6387376189,
-0.1374754161,
0.825564146,
0.096423693,
-0.2554197013,
0.3053421974,
-0.1353489757,
-0.5279370546,
0.323753804,
0.5277368426,
0.1779854745,
-0.0927586332,
-0.3448957205,
-0.0222224053,
-0.3328984082,
0.0904498473,
-0.7554033399,
0.3536261022,
0.4161708653,
-0.3696839809,
-0.4475426376,
0.0654601455,
-0.6394724846,
-0.2149862498,
-0.1168777272,
0.4409519136,
-0.1254448444,
-0.1112229824,
0.0104768304,
-0.0612892658,
0.2418326885,
0.1824963093,
-0.9858679771,
0.0029693309,
0.6659505963,
1.0883835554,
-0.2746103108,
-0.2967574298,
-0.6485502124,
0.6718552709,
-0.4972103536,
0.8895478249,
-0.4476245344,
-0.3630639017,
0.1820627004,
-0.0676986873,
-0.2093775123,
-0.3976761997,
0.2954546213,
-0.2996166945,
0.174339965,
0.0953415632,
-0.6549754739,
-0.1781682521,
0.4807585776,
-0.2525851429,
0.9377085567,
0.0669790059,
-0.7722290158,
0.513437748,
-0.5937110782,
-0.4082091749,
0.1754363775,
-0.2455355674,
-0.338667959,
0.3193305433,
0.1518910974,
0.9683966637,
0.1125947833,
0.3610452116,
-0.3750234544,
-0.3965213299,
0.0588595085,
-0.3328168392,
0.6929269433,
0.0148373703,
-0.4533977509,
0.3090724349,
-0.3369131982,
-0.2716273367,
0.0265426133,
-0.1944324821,
-0.6996107101,
0.2710234523,
-0.0285020676,
0.0122048957,
0.0385528468,
-0.5525556207,
0.1829055548,
-0.6852142215,
0.0294452328,
0.493074894,
0.0305243563,
0.9457817078,
0.1140800938,
0.3475429118,
0.2261262387,
-0.0857949257,
-0.4736757576,
-0.279202491,
-0.4431805611,
-0.3663935661,
0.1547791809,
0.541064918,
-0.7722060084,
0.7058148384,
-0.0893164501,
-0.4692589343,
-0.1474674195,
0.0419401117,
0.3337918818,
0.6935822368,
0.3285186291,
0.1052280664,
-0.058420945,
-0.4786483347,
-0.0639473498,
0.1648800373,
-0.2767810524,
0.2833660543,
0.3747235239,
-0.3020605147,
1.1666328907,
-0.8340857625,
-0.5604627728,
-0.6276765466,
0.2227395028,
0.4554577768,
0.243138358,
0.7328289151,
-0.7378719449,
-0.9474509358,
0.2645829618,
-0.9240179062,
-0.1497553438,
-0.1279579699,
-0.1690714359,
0.2080928832,
0.7405891418,
-0.5167761445,
0.5106794238,
0.4991417229,
-0.5217075944,
0.2761530578,
-0.3250440657,
-0.2971693575,
-1.2304003239,
0.097676076,
0.1587170213,
-0.4351274073,
-0.9993966222,
0.1338712573,
0.0430352502,
0.0797588453,
-0.4818659723,
0.8890840411,
-0.3788622618,
-0.0971961245,
-0.3417016566,
0.310431838,
-0.3274798095,
0.3665954769,
0.2403955907,
0.4732379615,
0.7062168121,
-0.4281592071,
0.086594224,
0.1571520567,
-0.385545969,
0.76074332,
-0.4837671816,
-0.2677630484,
-0.6313123703,
0.4501561224,
-1.0152355433,
-0.1022652984,
0.1760264188,
-0.1985016912,
0.2343033701,
0.034441743,
-0.3565235138,
0.0914218426,
-0.284581393,
0.6136969924,
0.3580513895,
-0.6588242054,
0.4434145391,
0.3526777923,
0.0189840235,
-0.7143369317,
-0.6800807118,
-0.0596665777,
-0.4838242531,
0.0025572851,
0.48566401,
-0.2603357732,
-0.362985611,
-0.0261726175,
0.1676629335,
-0.2044127733,
0.0099405218,
0.1442404985,
-0.0945398435,
-0.0345516987,
0.3599064052,
0.0353823826,
-0.3093681335,
-0.3593853712,
-0.3430798948,
0.4802607298,
0.2433459014,
-0.3696196079,
-0.1234199181,
0.4171825945,
0.1905976981,
-0.0128743276,
1.0232185125,
0.5659991503,
-0.3191638589,
-0.7670337558,
-0.1821299344,
-0.1744536906,
-0.389633894,
0.1780745238,
-0.0107480278,
-0.9537363648,
0.1933352947,
-0.0970165953,
0.1687964201,
0.2602448761,
0.7140679955,
-0.2869543135,
0.9348958135,
1.02287817,
-0.3794407845,
0.5425451398,
-0.3382502496,
0.4869999886,
-0.6201126575,
-0.1163585559,
-0.4595233202,
-0.285469085,
-0.1208840013,
-0.6507044435,
0.5202006102,
0.2345943898,
-0.0922297835,
0.008597496,
-0.3187148273,
0.7527963519,
0.4693048,
0.0811527371,
0.2932394445,
0.0922281966,
-0.2169564813,
0.2564610541,
-0.6956808567,
-0.147528097,
0.9327959418,
0.1662639529,
0.4859518111,
0.0727182627,
0.7645819783,
0.1927595586,
0.5286939144,
-0.8222119212,
0.4231088161,
-0.3471185267,
-0.458860755,
-0.5662721992,
-0.2565777898,
-0.7890582085,
0.4404436052,
-0.0589168482,
-0.7534933686,
0.1744828224,
0.0077632065,
-0.1600063592,
0.3021832108,
-0.5177449584,
1.0198293924,
0.176742211,
0.1053099632,
-0.2194861025,
-0.5532491803,
0.3345845938,
-0.1692122966,
0.4206562042,
-0.0697696507,
-0.2654359043,
0.3644454777,
-0.193472147,
1.2050811052,
-0.2730089724,
-0.1455435455,
0.2065353841,
-0.1638525873,
0.3956844807,
-0.0284899604,
-0.0751153305,
0.0585961081,
-0.1601484269,
-0.424583286,
-0.5918957591,
0.7361099124,
-0.4279910624,
-0.0753083453,
-0.3861428499,
-0.6242803931,
0.0350031108,
0.1941145509,
0.1110659018,
0.5370146632,
-0.214098379,
0.4719109535,
0.7077713013,
-0.3659134209,
0.9422480464,
0.6104891896,
-0.2220592648,
-0.1120269895,
0.7166371346,
-0.0201452617,
0.1785552502,
0.7411408424,
0.2702763081,
-0.3443169594,
-0.5074170232,
-0.3442139924,
0.3952439129,
-0.7949399352,
-0.2276983708,
-0.6718741059,
-0.0141878501,
-0.2206404656,
-0.6684353352,
0.010499184,
0.0269631725,
-0.5412299037,
-0.189503476,
0.0834496692,
0.7650855184,
0.1505973041,
0.7846844792,
-0.5360338092,
0.2439540625,
0.1043290198,
0.3107516468,
0.1647173017,
-0.352840662,
-0.5218343139,
-0.1225364283,
-0.0895322785,
-0.8039650917,
0.5861034989,
0.3170326054,
0.5339560509,
0.7665059566,
0.1089082286,
0.4675889909,
-0.6934924126,
0.7968930602,
0.1978863925,
-0.9440550804,
0.4823046625,
-0.5149479508,
0.6282039285,
0.4686114788,
0.5181160569,
-0.6928367615,
-0.3573995829,
-0.3888431489,
-0.7669604421,
0.6304571033,
-0.1150365248,
0.2034198791,
-0.4084161222,
0.4781827927,
-0.0103794448,
0.3584082127,
-1.0906100273,
-0.2619160116,
0.2903523147,
-0.585015893,
-0.5561321378,
-0.4607228041,
-0.0712312832,
-0.2499716431,
0.5361689925,
-0.6068584323,
0.0571928881,
0.0923489928,
-0.34014377,
-0.0411360525,
0.1525347382,
0.639067173,
0.6737408042,
-0.268591851,
0.2796462774,
0.3056664765,
-0.1864266396,
0.2010490447,
-0.3624901772,
-0.4987634718,
0.2404450923,
0.5516868234,
0.5535268784,
0.5176189542,
-0.8325760365,
0.9484556317,
0.2076514512,
-0.1761699319,
-0.1937867999,
-0.2238390446,
0.0931854248,
0.3663495779,
0.5451004505,
-0.4539254606,
0.004147612,
-0.6099889874,
0.2469899058,
0.7107493281,
-0.5887795091,
-0.1926345378,
0.4657913148,
-0.0067215706,
-0.1255930215,
0.1242006421,
-0.2892411053,
-0.229104355,
0.5085809827,
0.8698753715,
1.0546697378,
-0.3579794168,
0.6326394677,
0.1995313913,
0.0182617288,
-0.0837311745,
-0.060213834,
-0.3389485776,
-0.7097118497,
-0.8678132892,
-0.7283350825,
-0.329233706,
-0.227795586,
-0.3880712986,
0.2937231958,
-0.189562127,
0.3480147123,
-0.2551189363,
-0.2946815193,
-0.1603632271,
0.2283541113,
0.0185995847,
0.75857687,
-0.9629198909,
1.0077269077,
0.489739418,
0.0125044966,
-0.2516078651,
0.3008197248,
-0.0682530999,
-0.557268858,
0.7034056783,
0.2262301892,
0.328006804,
0.1011193767,
-0.5970448256,
-0.9050620198,
1.1915215254,
0.1517659575,
-0.4098894298,
0.102690734,
0.1501960903,
0.5271138549,
-0.7201007009,
0.3836052418,
0.2556226552,
0.1704851389,
0.3437433243,
-0.5157129765,
-0.1765422821,
0.2883017957,
-0.0617777705,
0.3586746156,
-0.2986142337,
0.7775723338,
0.0181322042,
-0.2318415493,
-0.2754226327,
0.5753626227,
0.145795241,
0.5579029322,
0.6695439219,
0.5553495884,
0.5255524516,
0.2129599601,
0.9028162956,
-0.1709254384,
0.5689647794,
1.1021710634,
-0.4109709561,
1.0887023211,
0.3793503046,
0.1881377548,
0.3349325657,
0.327342242,
0.2296494991,
0.8774376512,
0.0192529615,
-0.7609608769,
-0.0130062075,
-0.3422161639,
0.0085645644,
0.2951674461,
0.3805141449,
-0.3082976043,
-0.8895136714,
0.3151521385,
-0.0233971532,
0.0580012202,
-0.3680247366,
1.0659943819,
0.0199588146,
-0.2600035369,
0.2547877133,
0.0615423024,
0.8301544189,
-0.4597719908,
-0.0494537503,
-0.1139035225,
0.2320927829,
-0.1327846795,
-0.7561361194,
0.6710918546,
0.099381648,
-0.3612149656,
-0.5092642307,
0.619325757,
-0.7621523738,
-0.6036524177,
0.5065139532,
0.3233164847,
0.3190000057,
-0.3587374389,
-0.3205462396,
-0.2452131957,
-0.009572749,
-0.1658285856,
0.5683238506,
0.5186859369,
-0.090404056,
0.5132777095,
0.40741539,
0.0596619137,
-0.1230413541,
0.0111833764,
0.6177791953,
-0.6888579726,
-0.5545038581,
-1.1394299269,
0.5839325786,
-0.1124872789,
-0.060651958,
0.8196784854,
0.4974445999,
0.7661371827,
-0.031689588,
0.7573511004,
0.0388839394,
0.7437265515,
-0.3422185481,
0.6084272861,
-0.6328969598,
0.0487088896,
-0.188590005,
-1.1027566195,
-0.7344992757,
0.4694495201,
-0.3143970668,
-0.2875288129,
0.7514742017,
0.58879143,
-0.2447622567,
-0.4838090837,
0.6077523828,
0.2959759235,
0.3180810213,
0.3351307213,
0.3475910127,
-0.1045972332,
0.4004662037,
-0.3183067739,
-0.436078161,
-0.2543963492,
-1.1708823442,
-1.0779794455,
-0.5005887151,
-0.1051568389,
0.223957181,
-0.2162892073,
0.7516958714,
0.7829084396,
-0.7957167625,
-0.4544217587,
-0.0743147284,
0.3630445898,
-0.216061309,
-0.1873395443,
0.3965947926,
-0.5594025254,
-0.7595200539,
0.5800445676,
0.5457959771,
-0.0966361389,
-0.1813103408,
0.1610118151,
-0.3603770435,
-0.0065939017,
1.0516455173,
-0.0032730503,
-0.593603909,
-0.150326103,
-0.2932846248,
0.0432371311,
-0.0541683286,
0.6177616119,
-0.7546262145,
0.2683306634,
0.3793224394,
0.5675470233,
0.6272104383,
0.1735558063,
0.5620366335,
-1.1992759705,
0.4714252055,
0.0620952733,
0.0930077508,
0.0716204792,
-0.3434545994,
0.5746441483,
0.0902083516,
-0.5554986596,
-0.9330447316,
-0.0181749035,
-0.8892605901,
-0.6639072299,
1.1332604885,
-0.0832388997,
-0.279260695,
-0.0235193446,
-0.0654369071,
0.0482703,
-0.1278925091,
0.5688082576,
0.4002249241,
0.0800654516,
-0.2950232923,
-0.6346597075,
0.2569655478,
0.2929064929,
-1.0090228319,
-0.0133535303,
0.2570771873,
0.1547285765,
0.052421961,
0.7020289302,
0.3660647869,
-0.2306984663,
-0.3478706181,
0.0628577247,
0.4622697532,
-0.5608314276,
-0.6473349333,
0.4189837873,
-0.1659301519,
-0.0486677401
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13340v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13340v1 | SD-Eval: A Benchmark Dataset for Spoken Dialogue Understanding Beyond Words | 2024-06-19T08:46:29 | 2024-06-19T08:46:29 | Junyi Ao, Yuancheng Wang, Xiaohai Tian, Dekun Chen, Jun Zhang, Lu Lu, Yuxuan Wang, Haizhou Li, Zhizheng Wu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS | Speech encompasses a wealth of information, including but not limited to
content, paralinguistic, and environmental information. This comprehensive
nature of speech significantly impacts communication and is crucial for
human-computer interaction. Chat-Oriented Large Language Models (LLMs), known
for their general-purpose assistance capabilities, have evolved to handle
multi-modal inputs, including speech. Although these models can be adept at
recognizing and analyzing speech, they often fall short of generating
appropriate responses. We argue that this is due to the lack of principles on
task definition and model development, which requires open-source datasets and
metrics suitable for model evaluation. To bridge the gap, we present SD-Eval, a
benchmark dataset aimed at multidimensional evaluation of spoken dialogue
understanding and generation. SD-Eval focuses on paralinguistic and
environmental information and includes 7,303 utterances, amounting to 8.76
hours of speech data. The data is aggregated from eight public datasets,
representing four perspectives: emotion, accent, age, and background sound. To
assess the SD-Eval benchmark dataset, we implement three different models and
construct a training set following a similar process as SD-Eval. The training
set contains 1,052.72 hours of speech data and 724.4k utterances. We also
conduct a comprehensive evaluation using objective evaluation methods (e.g.
BLEU and ROUGE), subjective evaluations and LLM-based metrics for the generated
responses. Models conditioned with paralinguistic and environmental information
outperform their counterparts in both objective and subjective measures.
Moreover, experiments demonstrate LLM-based metrics show a higher correlation
with human evaluation compared to traditional metrics. We open-source SD-Eval
at https://github.com/amphionspace/SD-Eval. | [
-0.3827030957,
-0.6896551847,
0.678429842,
0.125969559,
-0.1852441877,
0.1913171858,
-0.4014739096,
-0.112749815,
-0.1384409219,
0.6114341021,
-0.66513592,
-0.6554560661,
-0.3076552153,
-0.1405952573,
-0.3506334722,
0.9698012471,
0.2240156531,
0.2481651306,
-0.3686770499,
-0.2645280659,
-0.2423327863,
-0.3571239114,
-0.5317177773,
-0.0516192503,
0.3220401108,
0.2097713649,
0.3723642528,
0.3838332593,
0.2709847391,
0.2895324528,
-0.2533641458,
0.1612753421,
-0.6909521818,
0.0622846112,
-0.1517525911,
-0.437017709,
-0.3011818826,
0.022856744,
0.800696373,
0.8184977174,
-0.4470866919,
0.3469159305,
0.1720643491,
0.5413855314,
-0.6394608021,
0.5735475421,
-0.726796329,
-0.2386468202,
-0.1129373014,
-0.0342748836,
-0.3004564643,
-0.2912659347,
0.1742913872,
-0.4801925719,
0.1278379411,
-0.1465120763,
0.5117858052,
0.352953732,
-0.2962996066,
-0.3846711218,
-0.7472133636,
0.7941350937,
-0.9078765512,
0.7436235547,
0.2917116582,
0.273570776,
-0.0829870179,
-0.3443911672,
-0.7103257179,
-0.3594106138,
0.3003216386,
0.2553219795,
-0.2475138009,
0.3049897552,
0.3126218915,
0.0764517114,
-0.5016942024,
0.1793740243,
-0.5082581043,
-0.0279443804,
0.7817468047,
0.4729334116,
-0.0443730913,
-0.3177616,
-0.4071745574,
-0.2183372527,
-0.6786013842,
0.1738777161,
0.3579570651,
0.5172106028,
-0.3930241168,
0.5472500324,
-0.248421222,
0.6219390035,
-0.3350993991,
-0.2664891481,
0.4028089643,
-0.5670166016,
-0.1475439966,
-0.1435309649,
0.7043426633,
0.5182120204,
0.1247626618,
0.0950574726,
-0.2623554468,
0.1266986281,
0.2241835296,
-0.5997486115,
0.017454965,
0.3179412484,
-0.4240720272,
-0.1418928653,
-0.2457324415,
-0.8154507875,
-0.4948425293,
-0.833299458,
0.1939871609,
-0.4205430746,
-0.4129758477,
-0.1424194574,
-0.035739582,
0.1634359658,
0.3456537127,
-0.3369943798,
0.4369024634,
0.7703217268,
0.8448972106,
-0.1905071735,
-0.1866433024,
-0.6767596602,
-0.1464256048,
-0.4593748152,
0.6525192857,
-0.756262958,
-0.4795148075,
-0.1394068599,
-0.2796061039,
-0.2546224296,
-0.5989197493,
0.6796419621,
-0.1026418433,
-0.1362487674,
-0.1481889784,
-0.6861853004,
-0.1471129507,
-0.2021387964,
-0.4384437203,
0.8414678574,
0.0567189008,
-0.4225422144,
0.2622477114,
-0.8047707081,
0.0435748771,
0.3170257509,
-0.2962506115,
-0.0272542033,
0.3003898263,
0.1484622657,
0.5116973519,
-0.5335437655,
0.4015764892,
-0.3742655218,
-0.315615654,
0.3372763991,
-0.6302338243,
0.4474566281,
0.2704731524,
0.0390352271,
0.0892073214,
-0.9634327888,
0.2618102729,
-0.0619168431,
-0.2813115716,
-0.1832962483,
0.2354171872,
0.1289008558,
0.1612808704,
-0.0216587745,
-0.7648558617,
-0.400080353,
-0.3174322248,
0.510669291,
0.7976826429,
-0.0571458787,
-0.0427832976,
-0.1669759005,
0.5313235521,
0.0599007122,
-0.1031709537,
-0.4686483443,
-0.1951691955,
-0.6116873026,
-0.3737842441,
0.1364021301,
0.461987704,
-0.6723461151,
0.4856669009,
-0.4722779691,
-0.6647852659,
-0.8819360137,
0.0566434152,
0.656019628,
0.4440170825,
0.2063556761,
-0.1973716617,
-0.4606531858,
-0.874291718,
-0.0238965061,
-0.3718019426,
-0.2799786925,
0.7261315584,
0.3334773481,
-0.0430561006,
1.0092909336,
-0.5186421871,
-0.0078010084,
-0.3629541397,
0.2123693079,
0.1039793864,
0.0783471316,
0.219317168,
-0.6223521829,
-0.2830005586,
-0.12809062,
-0.4953503311,
-0.2850469947,
-0.0116141001,
0.3342481852,
0.0312805064,
0.2829187512,
-0.5390790701,
0.3084812462,
0.6560943127,
-0.0470924377,
0.7092550993,
-0.1814070344,
0.1493965089,
-0.8931158781,
0.0858330876,
0.2800305784,
-0.0692069307,
-0.8937271833,
-0.1818607002,
0.0007986405,
-0.4402252436,
-0.6818811297,
0.5607057214,
-0.0148458099,
-0.3100797534,
-0.1843645424,
0.4542931616,
-0.0772717893,
0.6124867797,
0.2439994216,
1.0175677538,
0.4455511868,
-0.4747261405,
0.4038292468,
0.2541004419,
-0.7127984166,
0.8911528587,
-0.731411159,
0.2465944439,
-0.2929714918,
0.3662703037,
-1.0248910189,
-0.1442676336,
-0.0479943305,
-0.2519318759,
-0.0286155771,
-0.0246968474,
-0.2308233827,
-0.2522675693,
-0.0398161225,
0.1435062885,
0.4382716715,
-0.5680271983,
0.4178138971,
0.4780518115,
-0.5535358787,
-0.197297886,
-0.2174356878,
0.0071245264,
-0.3604503274,
-0.603028357,
0.0393552557,
-0.273046881,
-0.5026450753,
-0.3395413756,
-0.261449188,
-0.2153978348,
-0.1599442661,
0.3301731944,
0.2995245755,
-0.2100447267,
0.1766170263,
-0.184875235,
-0.0559761375,
0.1420591325,
0.2606824338,
0.5535917282,
-0.2139333636,
-0.4461014867,
-0.6527940631,
0.3227754533,
0.6751626134,
-0.2096750438,
0.5072273612,
0.2966454625,
-0.0992340893,
-0.1949181557,
-0.543094635,
0.0897801146,
-0.441986233,
0.6066254973,
-0.3622300625,
-0.5798318386,
0.3142158985,
-0.1108666956,
0.10061156,
0.2142512351,
0.4539216459,
-0.1866534799,
0.9664254189,
0.258141011,
0.0317330509,
0.323705107,
-0.0813391879,
0.1200315729,
-1.1742651463,
-0.2406106591,
-0.516502142,
0.1108175069,
-0.2852850258,
-0.6120395064,
0.3348816335,
-0.1144510508,
-0.1425572932,
0.4287765324,
-0.1039364934,
0.3518006504,
0.1439719647,
0.1284739524,
-0.0325106904,
-0.3898049593,
0.0149018429,
-0.1334839165,
-0.4251957238,
-0.63736552,
1.119680047,
0.5113635063,
0.8999012113,
-0.1519628018,
0.5522069931,
0.3618713021,
-0.1095150262,
-0.6152208447,
0.706409812,
-0.0878174827,
-0.0827487484,
-0.3244238794,
-0.5793324709,
-0.7622397542,
0.4419418871,
0.1023469269,
-0.9396952987,
-0.0016386728,
-0.0961702615,
-0.4414837658,
-0.0460465476,
-0.9142872691,
0.5665107369,
-0.2791795135,
-0.0993275046,
-0.5208743215,
-0.5269455314,
0.2365350723,
-0.3048627377,
0.4729416072,
-0.5882703662,
0.018356353,
0.7229254246,
-0.2191821933,
0.8060632348,
-0.3693811595,
-0.2959940434,
0.114539206,
-0.254812181,
0.3608385623,
0.0539363921,
-0.190211013,
0.3484510779,
0.1806871146,
-0.0779590383,
-0.7268034816,
0.6326525807,
-0.6788512468,
-0.5117306113,
0.0055147083,
-0.5367715955,
-0.3570595384,
-0.219501853,
-0.253354758,
0.6990699768,
-0.4685791433,
0.3848391175,
0.5890450478,
-0.4773930311,
0.2218701243,
0.9248813391,
-0.035467498,
-0.3109050691,
1.0533024073,
0.061988242,
0.6012112498,
0.1101393253,
0.1521328986,
-0.5296953321,
-0.4391207099,
-0.3660154343,
-0.044213783,
-0.7520890832,
-0.0960250199,
-0.5809147954,
-0.484213084,
-0.2505202889,
0.1203668043,
-0.4741119146,
-0.1671046764,
-0.1410218477,
-0.0900457427,
0.1528406888,
0.6917647719,
-0.0436804481,
0.2375322282,
-0.7566641569,
0.4707726538,
0.0556564853,
0.3964291811,
0.0663222298,
-0.3311413527,
-0.0994199291,
0.5750896335,
-0.2125445455,
-0.6529730558,
0.3580465615,
0.4514235556,
0.771474123,
0.4270595014,
0.0785248429,
0.7328077555,
-0.6118218899,
1.0189410448,
0.1592786759,
-1.1482967138,
0.7025848031,
-0.3063072562,
0.3166228235,
0.4466212988,
0.1315729469,
-0.6945515871,
-0.5089400411,
-0.6362301707,
-0.6925846934,
0.9054000378,
0.3746779859,
0.1603920013,
-0.0149690313,
-0.0896439403,
0.2559911907,
0.2923432589,
-0.2384074181,
0.0567295216,
-0.0559121408,
-0.0282758195,
-0.3986711502,
0.0021379937,
-0.1887355894,
-0.1496043354,
0.3857088089,
-0.178506121,
0.1686798632,
-0.1572772861,
-0.0695534796,
0.1532856077,
0.4735490084,
0.6181820035,
0.7426103354,
-0.1571645737,
-0.1967595816,
0.4228264987,
-0.2089664638,
0.0724224448,
0.175826326,
0.3907455802,
-0.0599671453,
0.3433781862,
1.1997708082,
0.2976445556,
-1.1701558828,
0.4996916652,
-0.0921943635,
-0.0496500395,
-0.1484506279,
0.3581646085,
0.0817967951,
0.3408071101,
0.1809799075,
-0.138130486,
0.1672232747,
-0.4618814886,
0.0882922783,
0.42761603,
-0.2891710103,
-0.3272664845,
0.4895340502,
0.4141961932,
-0.3896014988,
0.6247337461,
0.131563589,
-0.2950068116,
0.6345030665,
0.3237131536,
0.7850077748,
-0.2998889983,
0.4252503812,
0.2684555054,
-0.0475505628,
0.2591956854,
0.343319416,
-0.4392067194,
-0.5812635422,
-0.2703174651,
-0.8169693947,
-0.6171175241,
0.3886999488,
-0.7896512151,
0.2028930783,
-0.1513385177,
0.0096294656,
0.3292151392,
-0.0404902697,
-1.0155469179,
0.1165162995,
0.2387247831,
0.8273079395,
-0.9683702588,
0.7169559002,
0.2283490151,
-0.2444943041,
-0.5000799298,
0.0165142324,
0.2564425766,
-0.8705971241,
0.6171742678,
0.2466426492,
-0.0361457877,
-0.1594146043,
-0.405298382,
-0.8984314203,
0.9217264652,
0.3648292124,
-0.8515510559,
0.1233655065,
0.3263373971,
0.7064460516,
-0.4401408434,
0.454601258,
0.8762975335,
0.3015559316,
0.2347490489,
-1.1577049494,
-0.2507908642,
-0.1834667027,
0.3522874415,
0.093080841,
-0.5944545865,
0.5377969742,
-0.1468638331,
-0.3373432159,
0.2285208255,
0.3002432883,
0.3497896791,
0.311255604,
0.5764536262,
0.4825477898,
0.8297495842,
-0.1610080898,
0.8483781219,
-0.1923893839,
0.1453226954,
1.3336658478,
-0.6702340245,
1.115634799,
0.2160105407,
-0.4242325127,
0.1151561812,
0.4439915121,
0.0438946001,
0.621009171,
0.4726781249,
-0.4559215009,
-0.0916819125,
-0.4381961823,
-0.1785625666,
0.7283984423,
0.8152990937,
-0.1769372672,
-0.3722815514,
0.2439644784,
-0.3996593058,
-0.0471405685,
-0.1845902354,
1.0393295288,
0.026077589,
-0.4983408153,
0.5144886971,
-0.3839739561,
0.3007547855,
-0.7171603441,
-0.1186498776,
0.0239686705,
0.0964795277,
-0.0292553194,
-1.0807795525,
0.2998687625,
0.1968192905,
0.1260883808,
-0.1676986665,
0.4221310616,
-0.4826623797,
-0.3156053424,
0.2558567226,
0.4438873529,
0.4525917768,
0.1009133458,
-0.6488231421,
0.4299640656,
-0.0075447345,
-0.1196942329,
0.1715133488,
0.2157001048,
0.1992959529,
0.6986710429,
0.7229478955,
0.1899041384,
-0.1787990332,
0.1762756407,
0.8446609974,
-0.3660538793,
-0.3997762799,
-0.635923028,
0.5983094573,
-0.1180997044,
-0.3656273484,
0.5642240047,
0.651853323,
0.7346149683,
0.1654001921,
1.0437140465,
0.0893147811,
0.7722758055,
-0.577044487,
0.4977211952,
-0.2927626669,
0.2675756514,
-0.404751122,
-1.0573585033,
0.3754689097,
0.5265309215,
-0.2802757025,
-0.0479538701,
0.3469947278,
0.7810547352,
0.096742183,
0.4042578638,
0.4299872816,
0.0823500305,
0.4534641206,
0.4049270451,
0.9370445013,
0.0967063308,
0.3878902197,
-0.0681026876,
-0.2126221657,
0.1489293724,
-0.6981835961,
-0.7886180878,
-0.8801108003,
-0.2246387601,
-0.1234474555,
0.2395459116,
1.1070666313,
0.782153666,
-0.6303629279,
-0.4139707088,
-0.0220065191,
-0.1878959388,
-0.1835234016,
-0.2514040172,
0.2310275882,
-0.3610862494,
-0.7675246596,
0.8595312834,
0.3431519568,
-0.1895707995,
-0.4357453883,
-0.234467119,
0.1441418976,
0.4508083165,
0.6009947062,
0.1368322819,
-0.979095757,
-0.2578524947,
-0.3005528152,
0.1470770985,
0.136249423,
0.6203127503,
-0.7488919497,
0.6880615354,
0.2694251537,
0.5486466885,
0.4376187325,
0.0247491486,
0.7503018975,
-0.798269093,
-0.1171289906,
0.2409147918,
0.2846187353,
0.3881733418,
-0.0501362421,
0.4968297482,
-0.1959978938,
-0.5385894179,
-0.946267724,
0.1369428635,
-0.8297846317,
-0.0119834514,
1.2738382816,
-0.2768319249,
0.0478572734,
-0.054148905,
-0.4142050743,
-0.003965551,
-0.6191413999,
0.5944302082,
0.900500834,
-0.2565372586,
-0.2973869145,
-0.6669564843,
0.3111135066,
0.0090101706,
-0.9806713462,
0.5452458858,
0.5213695765,
0.1900413483,
0.055527091,
0.5524089932,
0.2191206068,
0.169398576,
0.1118359268,
-0.2631422877,
0.1725931913,
-0.3132216036,
-0.4130370021,
-0.134972021,
-0.2663928568,
-0.2417291701
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13337v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13337v1 | Medical Spoken Named Entity Recognition | 2024-06-19T08:39:09 | 2024-06-19T08:39:09 | Khai Le-Duc | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD | Spoken Named Entity Recognition (NER) aims to extracting named entities from
speech and categorizing them into types like person, location, organization,
etc. In this work, we present VietMed-NER - the first spoken NER dataset in the
medical domain. To our best knowledge, our real-world dataset is the largest
spoken NER dataset in the world in terms of the number of entity types,
featuring 18 distinct types. Secondly, we present baseline results using
various state-of-the-art pre-trained models: encoder-only and
sequence-to-sequence. We found that pre-trained multilingual models XLM-R
outperformed all monolingual models on both reference text and ASR output. Also
in general, encoders perform better than sequence-to-sequence models for the
NER task. By simply translating, the transcript is applicable not just to
Vietnamese but to other languages as well. All code, data and models are made
publicly available here: https://github.com/leduckhai/MultiMed | [
-0.1449896991,
-0.5046858788,
0.5493131876,
-0.1663215011,
-0.2330766469,
0.0367902517,
-0.2262344062,
-0.5277629495,
0.4524050951,
0.8994941115,
-0.0851149336,
-0.6869450808,
-0.9080202579,
0.5096852779,
-0.5099067688,
0.9298850298,
0.1895982772,
0.5506267548,
-0.0471538492,
-0.392255187,
-0.2547991276,
-0.8960615993,
-1.0249102116,
-0.376843214,
0.628657043,
0.4242152274,
0.2143406421,
0.4652315378,
0.612288475,
0.3216536939,
0.0032689418,
0.2539173067,
-0.2031732053,
0.000295109,
0.1115355119,
-0.2675842941,
-0.6136343479,
-0.1746661961,
0.7132534981,
0.3102039099,
-0.2475407273,
0.0693871155,
-0.238063693,
0.4765991867,
-0.1546700001,
0.1294330209,
-0.4257542789,
0.0236360002,
-0.0983212888,
-0.3059971333,
-0.5314775705,
-0.3483058214,
0.5642747283,
-0.5918958783,
-0.0559265725,
-0.1057689786,
1.0944397449,
0.4496917725,
-0.7794172168,
-0.4152197838,
-0.8340973854,
0.4830887318,
-0.5542882681,
0.6558244824,
0.1861626804,
0.5512692928,
0.0387603901,
-0.904691875,
-0.5335409045,
-0.1434498131,
-0.1513701975,
0.1359550506,
-0.4053223431,
0.1025656536,
0.1419948041,
0.1923445612,
-0.6508244872,
0.1898235232,
-0.5364310145,
-0.1910886616,
0.4495586157,
-0.0524699986,
0.5278194547,
-0.3553212881,
-0.4300571084,
0.2322813421,
-0.5366146564,
-0.4884187877,
-0.1692623794,
0.3810945153,
-0.3540509343,
0.70767802,
0.0392549634,
0.8166407347,
-0.0823323354,
-0.3427533209,
0.4590028524,
-0.1469996274,
-0.3395489156,
0.44535923,
0.732758224,
0.1207791045,
0.4652142227,
-0.0962109044,
-0.1548891515,
-0.149162665,
0.0941402316,
-0.7682690024,
-0.2495364994,
0.1683745533,
-0.5690143108,
0.0990955681,
0.0689131543,
-0.5941577554,
-0.3498404324,
-0.6328088045,
0.3672304749,
-0.5000835657,
-0.451305002,
0.2306450456,
0.0359197222,
0.2037232667,
0.1512909234,
-0.275682658,
0.6449556351,
0.6130391359,
0.750831306,
-0.171761483,
-0.0072151767,
-0.7555029988,
-0.0227080099,
-0.0167588796,
0.7849023938,
-0.3019994497,
-0.3055277765,
-0.2386664897,
0.0546607077,
-0.1566070765,
-0.925324738,
0.3654495776,
-0.3690755963,
0.1858926266,
0.1452603936,
-0.6953195333,
-0.2867111266,
0.1068744287,
-0.8833087683,
0.4904925525,
0.1405365765,
-0.7766376734,
0.5625707507,
-0.6238633394,
-0.3324641883,
0.3743318319,
-0.505030334,
-0.3025889993,
0.0017624209,
0.2881986201,
0.4247244,
-0.4629835188,
0.4157316387,
0.3230445981,
0.0051957569,
0.224619925,
-0.257029891,
0.5322121978,
0.217521891,
-0.0404595882,
0.23657161,
-1.0104901791,
0.0402721204,
0.195544228,
-0.3286297619,
-0.4803600311,
-0.2106064558,
0.256023109,
0.4090231657,
-0.1079976633,
-0.671244204,
-0.0232412443,
-0.4713445306,
0.4875392616,
0.1128218323,
0.226450488,
0.1908597052,
-0.1827808917,
0.4558615685,
0.316871196,
-0.0930692926,
-0.1397176236,
-0.4498741031,
-0.6983118653,
-0.5673225522,
0.63046211,
0.8556019664,
-0.8902514577,
0.2025027722,
-0.4874208868,
-0.576843679,
-0.978762269,
-0.4100062549,
0.5269830227,
0.7933809161,
0.5111818314,
-0.1654235721,
-0.9139952064,
-0.9000537992,
-0.0577767417,
-0.2053242177,
0.062721692,
0.5917683244,
0.4421429336,
-0.7048398852,
0.6708170772,
-0.421305865,
-0.4926266968,
-0.316049397,
-0.0879096314,
0.3891751468,
0.36534971,
0.2787296176,
-0.9557648301,
-0.4618081748,
0.2116169184,
-0.7638847232,
-0.0638128668,
0.1415525824,
0.2325792462,
0.1959671527,
0.5496278405,
-0.5211176276,
0.4169355929,
0.6629086137,
-0.0757896304,
0.3162575662,
-0.3588924706,
0.1256412715,
-1.3636677265,
0.0168091431,
-0.1356091797,
-0.3520719707,
-0.81916219,
-0.4065621793,
-0.0563107692,
-0.2971780896,
-0.5222606659,
0.7805538774,
-0.6654413939,
0.1293628067,
-0.2613521814,
-0.1146781296,
-0.0997234359,
-0.130458042,
0.4483953416,
0.6202735901,
0.8432450891,
-0.8807030916,
0.3964956105,
0.4355971813,
-0.3191114962,
0.6061870456,
-0.8770107627,
0.3127675951,
-0.3730847836,
0.0116839744,
-0.3719901443,
-0.2176187485,
0.2688590884,
-0.5681399703,
0.6666159034,
-0.3645230532,
-0.3296856284,
-0.3632645607,
0.6208786964,
0.3468607366,
0.1798198819,
-0.4276802838,
0.5796660781,
0.8624963164,
-0.329734832,
-0.3790163994,
-0.6199736595,
0.1733823121,
-0.2931228876,
-0.1659789383,
0.4490119517,
0.1611610055,
-0.1775220931,
-0.1350542754,
-0.0712228715,
-0.5634322166,
-0.4330093563,
0.2472675294,
0.2554718852,
-0.5866633654,
0.3773517907,
-0.2286248058,
-0.4477044046,
-0.1445818692,
-0.2519657314,
0.5424935818,
-0.124638997,
-0.2125706971,
-0.4488658905,
0.4847850204,
0.5212965012,
-0.2935522497,
0.5426601171,
0.460959971,
-0.8851505518,
0.2944536805,
-0.5996137261,
-0.0302072391,
-0.3445458412,
0.5138821602,
-0.4269490242,
-0.8910138011,
0.1151852235,
-0.1959134191,
-0.2643292546,
0.3387818933,
0.3484057784,
0.2179117352,
0.7691237926,
0.6754148602,
-0.1347352713,
0.2124727815,
0.0032693797,
0.1784050316,
-0.698158443,
-0.3381421566,
-0.5206452012,
0.0556054674,
-0.9160097241,
-0.5034804344,
0.4280925095,
-0.2367375195,
-0.053366635,
0.5573125482,
-0.7341249585,
0.1635424495,
0.3737099469,
0.0829856843,
0.1903001815,
-0.1562004536,
-0.0558373593,
-0.2094472498,
-0.5408835411,
-0.7095833421,
0.8874585629,
0.2722945213,
0.6587345004,
-0.170141995,
1.1478939056,
-0.0728363618,
0.2830073833,
-0.8266219497,
0.4118672013,
-0.4084636569,
-0.3995154202,
-0.2295169383,
-0.5582475066,
-1.1747426987,
0.0281721223,
-0.2365208864,
-0.3554828763,
0.3303245008,
-0.1351631284,
-0.3555105329,
0.2022514939,
-0.5129839182,
0.6877432466,
-0.6815280914,
0.5554823279,
0.1497245729,
-0.7347832322,
-0.0719933063,
-0.0927606896,
0.2203157246,
-0.0482181497,
-0.1634486467,
0.7246876955,
-0.215653643,
0.2997691631,
-0.1670535207,
0.1383902729,
0.0978236347,
-0.4263983369,
0.0199606717,
0.3764219284,
-0.2069078684,
0.4989182353,
-0.047902301,
-0.1017199829,
-0.1967352182,
0.4271197617,
-0.6462416649,
-0.1781904697,
-0.6407880783,
-0.0165973492,
0.0778256655,
0.5800033212,
0.687245667,
0.6117785573,
-0.6478138566,
0.0532849915,
0.7021918297,
-0.624162674,
-0.0226183422,
0.7711372972,
-0.4102255106,
-0.8499644995,
0.9251524806,
0.251419276,
-0.0197784603,
0.8812572956,
-0.0217963681,
-0.0900043622,
-0.4442500174,
-0.5163340569,
0.4220021665,
-0.5215741992,
-0.2525336444,
-1.1504238844,
-0.7634179592,
-0.4496856034,
0.2372757941,
-0.4849428535,
-0.1496117115,
-0.537376225,
-0.2897463739,
0.4293480217,
0.9274376035,
-0.0026472383,
0.2246786505,
-1.0150274038,
0.6001089215,
0.1503112912,
0.1553817689,
-0.4356821179,
-0.3160215616,
-0.1240085363,
-0.0384976529,
0.2670766413,
-1.0317178965,
0.9063162804,
0.4585032463,
0.5662950277,
0.4144500494,
-0.0944509879,
0.6903687119,
-0.7386173606,
0.3169587851,
0.2114162892,
-0.5635802746,
0.7818973064,
0.0566320829,
0.2861596048,
0.5734502077,
0.5948219895,
-0.7424012423,
0.056339398,
-0.4811371863,
-0.903640151,
0.503167212,
-0.1022879481,
-0.0840709656,
-0.3789638877,
0.3063955307,
0.347830534,
0.2177008986,
-0.4233548343,
-0.5874671936,
-0.1003200859,
-0.1319367588,
-0.3780372739,
-0.2723646462,
0.2437050939,
-0.3609955013,
0.4670927823,
0.11332082,
0.5383680463,
0.5310255885,
-0.3412198424,
0.1280294955,
0.5270845294,
0.5674214959,
0.4185529649,
0.0275027025,
0.0798445791,
0.2223443091,
-0.648003459,
0.2042826265,
0.4286188483,
-0.1477640569,
0.6282709241,
0.1269631088,
1.0623716116,
0.3329869807,
-0.7013465762,
0.3633083105,
-0.3811641335,
0.0323264226,
-0.6447393298,
-0.222211659,
-0.0982148573,
0.0482826382,
0.2114471942,
-0.0474674143,
0.3319402635,
-0.193708539,
0.5545231104,
-0.0013232436,
-0.8436293602,
-0.3084588647,
0.4584918618,
-0.0016827891,
-0.551617682,
0.9758167267,
0.2010937184,
-0.5523962975,
0.5716643333,
0.6583499312,
0.7747354507,
-0.4588921368,
0.290891856,
0.6691089272,
0.2736699283,
0.1195610538,
0.6169600487,
0.3287701309,
-0.6030519605,
-0.2304615527,
-0.4797754288,
-0.4319736958,
0.1570655704,
-0.9579040408,
0.5865318775,
-0.0392727107,
-0.5111620426,
0.3209335208,
-0.2623352706,
-0.866388917,
0.444057107,
0.2664233446,
0.8442258835,
-0.3932640851,
0.9007561803,
1.0382111073,
-0.3487589359,
-0.7508966923,
-0.2055717111,
0.0007883123,
-0.7737107277,
0.6914405227,
0.4470635355,
0.136190474,
0.306480974,
-0.2281287462,
-1.0504646301,
0.9271549582,
0.3331491053,
-0.6919142008,
-0.2310668826,
0.1180187091,
0.5149171948,
-0.5821807384,
0.2404504269,
0.4586600661,
0.3754829168,
-0.2106885016,
-1.2336682081,
-0.3190568686,
-0.360283643,
-0.2487106323,
0.4212413728,
-0.2648777068,
0.6966245174,
-0.5192720294,
-0.3735990524,
0.0104549127,
0.691944778,
0.2912111878,
0.5128747225,
0.3053551614,
0.5408828855,
1.0404399633,
-0.1138340384,
0.9318145514,
-0.2147918195,
-0.1034664959,
1.3016963005,
-0.5222495794,
0.807559967,
0.3044671416,
0.1732099205,
0.3797186315,
0.4713319838,
0.0796272233,
0.4918837547,
0.2505542934,
-0.2933377028,
0.0892469883,
-0.3614072204,
-0.5962905288,
0.8584406376,
0.4325517118,
-0.4763093889,
0.1318288743,
0.4611635804,
-0.0491860062,
-0.1392421126,
-0.2397134006,
1.2792263031,
0.4852015376,
-0.4289482534,
0.4588624537,
-0.1539260447,
0.6699724197,
-0.5607022643,
-0.2943731546,
0.3419294357,
0.130819872,
-0.1631560773,
-0.4501668215,
0.2595645487,
-0.0465255938,
-0.2675027549,
0.0168211777,
0.9578492045,
-0.6184197664,
-0.3545250893,
0.573243618,
0.6780282855,
0.5885593295,
-0.1245049536,
-0.453568697,
-0.287887156,
-0.3826948702,
0.1087363884,
0.1111663654,
0.5173996091,
0.0585720316,
0.5959590673,
0.5170887709,
0.4105237722,
0.084114261,
0.3097423613,
0.5909348726,
-0.8194050789,
-0.3561671972,
-0.6913743615,
0.2597056627,
0.0511169694,
-0.4247194827,
0.4203341603,
0.8590928912,
0.8060780764,
-0.143704623,
0.6368907094,
0.1305333078,
0.8533610106,
-0.3679775596,
0.9834239483,
-0.4224393666,
-0.2370810658,
-0.3275799751,
-0.5080571175,
-0.3215883374,
0.4454054832,
0.049874384,
-0.0552988388,
0.5173915029,
0.5093611479,
0.206941992,
-0.1569195092,
0.5230497718,
0.2164309919,
-0.0338835418,
0.5437636375,
0.6920552254,
-0.5300024748,
0.3041255474,
-0.0554525517,
-0.0373961367,
-0.1892786771,
-0.603536725,
-0.5478843451,
-0.5431917906,
-0.4335236847,
-0.2217176706,
0.1109031513,
1.1497520208,
0.8964350224,
-0.9657856226,
-0.0235026255,
0.1957665831,
0.0581959561,
-0.2076412141,
-0.1345025599,
0.2412603498,
0.4334430993,
-0.5782564878,
0.5859324336,
0.4228864312,
0.2010640353,
0.3699652851,
-0.2891090512,
-0.2686446309,
-0.1147028506,
0.6212875247,
0.3884818852,
-0.6742966175,
0.002081248,
0.2931261063,
-0.4644709826,
0.3141783178,
0.6960632801,
-0.8904848099,
0.5949370265,
0.2385878116,
0.5835765004,
0.3280737102,
-0.2291917801,
0.4700764418,
-0.410865128,
-0.0869020447,
0.6055315137,
0.4483580887,
0.4690880477,
-0.3251748383,
0.5242682099,
-0.0678922683,
-0.5648363829,
-0.8388543725,
0.0834348053,
-1.0188033581,
0.223451525,
0.9841436744,
-0.0295758266,
0.1114014313,
-0.4920486212,
-0.4204546213,
0.7386783957,
-0.3228763938,
0.1643112749,
0.3886851072,
-0.1669989973,
-0.2947504818,
-0.6869156361,
0.2635613978,
-0.0598632321,
-1.0863177776,
-0.4934685528,
0.3807446957,
0.3719899058,
0.0700342059,
1.0549048185,
-0.2886890769,
0.3093221784,
-0.1859511286,
0.2143565565,
0.0682386234,
-0.5600857735,
-0.5564436913,
-0.0933678076,
0.0144519508,
-0.2414337993
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13332v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13332v1 | How effective is Multi-source pivoting for Translation of Low Resource Indian Languages? | 2024-06-19T08:31:52 | 2024-06-19T08:31:52 | Pranav Gaikwad, Meet Doshi, Raj Dabre, Pushpak Bhattacharyya | cs.CL | cs.CL | Machine Translation (MT) between linguistically dissimilar languages is
challenging, especially due to the scarcity of parallel corpora. Prior works
suggest that pivoting through a high-resource language can help translation
into a related low-resource language. However, existing works tend to discard
the source sentence when pivoting. Taking the case of English to Indian
language MT, this paper explores the 'multi-source translation' approach with
pivoting, using both source and pivot sentences to improve translation. We
conducted extensive experiments with various multi-source techniques for
translating English to Konkani, Manipuri, Sanskrit, and Bodo, using Hindi,
Marathi, and Bengali as pivot languages. We find that multi-source pivoting
yields marginal improvements over the state-of-the-art, contrary to previous
claims, but these improvements can be enhanced with synthetic target language
data. We believe multi-source pivoting is a promising direction for
Low-resource translation. | [
-0.2153874934,
-0.4880403876,
0.4551415741,
0.3010503352,
-0.6224439144,
0.3370029628,
-0.5309761763,
-0.2218891233,
0.1586726755,
0.2417259961,
-0.4763554037,
-0.0006580298,
-0.8224565387,
0.4437360466,
-0.5558258891,
0.7412512898,
-0.0714788809,
0.256578356,
0.1698225141,
-0.6539161801,
-0.8289750814,
-0.5813675523,
-0.1646518111,
0.0723751858,
0.4861797988,
0.6681631207,
0.8026217222,
0.5884587765,
0.8442873359,
0.2920167148,
0.1746617854,
0.5614799857,
-0.2510893345,
0.3924857378,
-0.2820646763,
-0.6103792787,
0.0325523093,
0.1495324373,
0.7921176553,
0.6710979939,
-0.1737794429,
0.2184885144,
0.1454283595,
1.0472142696,
-0.7245440483,
0.0297502447,
-0.7221779823,
-0.0565995239,
-0.8069189191,
-0.0883882269,
-0.5878940821,
-0.2238532603,
-0.4933873713,
-0.2088778615,
-0.0580842569,
0.3108431995,
0.4020843506,
0.4787585139,
-0.4186238945,
-0.2464324981,
-0.9945050478,
0.9699011445,
-0.4101755619,
0.3157492876,
0.2413276881,
0.6457422972,
0.213855803,
-0.156124115,
-0.4042468369,
0.117533803,
-0.3933907747,
-0.0324441828,
-0.001524438,
-0.7185524106,
0.063451305,
0.3451085091,
-0.2938582301,
-0.2002153844,
-0.8452097774,
0.0280168001,
0.3885786533,
-0.0086102942,
0.5837677717,
-0.3236628473,
-0.2844995856,
-0.3202134669,
-0.7775557637,
-0.1928991675,
0.1142266169,
1.0248340368,
-0.0474985018,
1.0623217821,
0.0100746043,
0.8485879302,
-0.0374191217,
-0.099252291,
0.2672702074,
-0.8407913446,
0.1537768692,
0.2792983055,
0.7163732052,
0.1373215616,
-0.0757492706,
-0.1434330642,
0.2601796985,
-0.1628649682,
0.0819062442,
-0.3908329308,
0.3039704859,
-0.0046470254,
-0.5716925263,
0.2598008513,
-0.2778030932,
-0.7158007622,
-0.3257272243,
-0.2279113382,
-0.0178153869,
-0.7964341044,
-0.5047728419,
-0.5119102597,
0.1342150271,
0.4469457567,
0.1194790006,
-0.8662909269,
-0.1433177739,
0.6453318,
1.4507842064,
-0.4440271258,
-0.5634154677,
-0.8281567693,
0.2307453901,
-0.3416243196,
1.0083340406,
-0.8084027171,
-0.4299650192,
-0.1637740135,
-0.2113033235,
-0.2304015309,
-0.3502055705,
0.4492576718,
-0.2691117525,
0.2100508064,
-0.2916289568,
0.1936668158,
-0.1270327866,
0.1606743038,
-0.5642845035,
0.6396306157,
-0.0928984135,
-0.4931721389,
0.1220159456,
-0.7006494403,
-0.7496032715,
-0.0731707737,
0.0580520034,
-0.2372140735,
0.3408911824,
0.3239311874,
0.2475645989,
-0.4010857344,
-0.0101159178,
-0.1866197586,
-0.1649086028,
0.2370397449,
-0.6022832394,
0.8047736883,
0.6175807714,
0.0366150066,
-0.0613811314,
-0.5245720148,
-0.0270052701,
0.0803417936,
-0.2268303782,
-0.647375524,
-0.0279724523,
-0.0455604531,
0.5293889642,
-0.0136020724,
-0.4577319622,
0.426951468,
-0.4786029756,
0.4655186236,
0.2177187055,
-0.191272676,
0.9548316598,
0.0366779454,
0.2280720472,
0.0888408124,
-0.0953575224,
-0.1826024503,
-0.6254940033,
-0.4128216207,
-0.2427165061,
0.3178103268,
0.5149032474,
-1.027795434,
-0.4509553313,
-0.378377527,
-0.5609332919,
-1.142937541,
0.3610746562,
0.4896278679,
0.3384214044,
0.6410010457,
-0.0778992027,
-0.186553359,
-0.9755807519,
-0.6168162823,
0.2407785356,
0.1885075271,
-0.3965753019,
-0.0633833706,
0.1032345816,
0.7460195422,
-0.4141510427,
-0.438144356,
-0.3914964199,
0.2141199708,
0.1747012585,
0.3994273841,
0.3740821779,
-1.0916465521,
-1.1289194822,
0.1291140318,
-0.4628426135,
0.06277024,
-0.1429849863,
-0.5300971866,
0.4151207209,
0.33095029,
-0.6472469568,
0.3184944093,
0.7958146334,
0.0208232161,
0.1252920628,
-0.3299879432,
0.4916673005,
-1.3131326437,
0.0566300675,
-0.2201821655,
-0.225973919,
-0.5560157895,
0.0883890688,
0.0906383023,
-0.3984234929,
-0.8342124224,
0.3158788085,
-0.7319231629,
-0.1795452535,
-0.4574216306,
0.227115199,
-0.3881712556,
0.3849435151,
-0.0595801808,
1.2054948807,
0.1609513164,
-0.3557263613,
0.2468141913,
0.3532314897,
-0.0367441662,
0.9223627448,
-0.0279925708,
0.087132059,
0.0338572338,
-0.3011588156,
-0.6350002885,
0.0475787781,
0.6430576444,
-0.4948456883,
0.3983910382,
-0.29940781,
-0.5189700127,
0.1123176813,
-0.1703159362,
0.3497663736,
0.2673299015,
-0.3158672452,
0.4848335087,
0.3942967355,
-0.480430603,
-0.4035179913,
-1.0652171373,
0.2326376736,
-0.120149672,
-0.3403817713,
0.1518633068,
-0.0047761751,
-0.4196918309,
0.2659797966,
-0.0770830289,
-0.2710134089,
-0.3442258537,
0.1105858982,
0.2314883322,
-0.0406811535,
0.1221022755,
0.1744648665,
-0.4141736925,
-0.4872834086,
-0.1520816982,
0.613269031,
-0.2700673342,
-0.7076669335,
-0.0643380806,
0.8745393157,
0.7369934916,
-0.5167069435,
0.9945797324,
0.6639752388,
-0.1233861744,
0.1518917233,
-0.3823841512,
0.0987076983,
-0.3169115782,
0.2417387068,
-0.5373566747,
-0.3228370845,
0.0481284522,
-0.4712843299,
-0.0474694744,
0.8192301989,
0.8999704719,
-0.1265760064,
0.9099308252,
0.7726919055,
-0.082060881,
0.3858596981,
-0.1246313155,
0.6409845352,
-0.8707991838,
-0.0170475394,
-0.7274990678,
-0.3401223123,
-0.8450696468,
-0.6125774384,
0.4669053555,
0.0646246821,
0.2825356126,
0.6564429998,
-0.7916105986,
0.4480380416,
0.8419153094,
-0.060902331,
0.5750297904,
0.3711279035,
-0.0372991972,
-0.33267802,
-0.7375041246,
-0.4662283957,
0.9046832323,
-0.2868656814,
0.1750373989,
0.2761909664,
0.5083590746,
0.202494204,
0.6097277403,
-0.5639728308,
0.2022890747,
-0.4072357714,
-0.7615842223,
-0.642401576,
-0.3564922512,
-0.7004259229,
0.7598956823,
-0.38561064,
0.0715202317,
0.0883155093,
-0.0255625825,
-0.0882937089,
0.4662345946,
-1.1279866695,
0.6693271399,
-0.6224160194,
-0.3689002395,
-0.6715549827,
-0.5468979478,
0.3698087931,
-0.3308846056,
0.6574920416,
-0.2222957164,
0.029881373,
0.1695736796,
-0.5863438249,
0.3007354438,
-0.1001887619,
0.3920513093,
0.26682356,
0.0383858904,
0.1688319296,
-0.1371571124,
-0.2781557441,
0.4160694778,
-0.0562760979,
-0.7588661909,
-0.5152513981,
0.5629963279,
-0.6278568506,
-0.4699193537,
-0.7132183909,
-0.5841596127,
-0.2833549678,
0.420437336,
0.230879724,
-0.1263861358,
0.2956416905,
0.2731738389,
-0.0177995861,
-0.0453816578,
0.7480879426,
0.3859195113,
0.0293705557,
-0.4238906205,
0.9901027679,
0.226131916,
0.2419416904,
0.4403354228,
0.1150286421,
-0.2414094657,
-0.5829586983,
-0.9305057526,
0.3444677293,
-0.3436901271,
-0.366871953,
-0.1198319048,
-0.0774920583,
-0.2041873038,
-0.1095033586,
-0.8023740053,
-0.4778795838,
0.2646554112,
0.3965140581,
0.2149626315,
0.4104904234,
-0.1914598197,
0.2076142877,
-1.2061522007,
0.2332319468,
0.169663474,
0.214563936,
-0.2809074223,
-0.3536034822,
-0.5326706171,
0.3376196027,
-0.2982664108,
-0.8953176141,
0.6917287707,
0.1455416977,
0.4319165945,
-0.1295342743,
0.0836571902,
0.7203348279,
-1.0252053738,
0.5874043703,
0.6219607592,
-0.748827517,
0.537209928,
0.0144419046,
0.3701533377,
0.6690007448,
0.4525559545,
-0.7043424845,
-0.3567043543,
0.1277861297,
-0.7921428084,
0.6847158074,
0.3618277609,
0.1703220159,
0.2845623791,
0.1179263517,
0.2931530476,
0.3129680157,
-0.5278047919,
-0.2702820003,
-0.3695957363,
0.0043017445,
-0.3798104227,
-0.0078561455,
0.0153725091,
-0.1137123257,
0.3664877117,
0.1239747033,
0.073757574,
-0.0122841457,
-0.4242856503,
-0.1489085257,
0.7180447578,
0.736948669,
0.5991520286,
-0.062642023,
0.128154248,
0.1612428874,
-0.4225897491,
0.260692209,
0.0013512552,
-0.1802775413,
0.1995199919,
0.2714532614,
0.5951603651,
-0.0009163438,
-0.1697901487,
0.2715019584,
0.1428074986,
0.3645327389,
0.0629459545,
-0.2800931334,
0.1306165904,
0.18963027,
0.5172184706,
0.6816760302,
-0.1738658994,
-0.7036239505,
-0.2373452336,
0.3102181256,
0.0041228416,
-0.2515925467,
0.7064820528,
0.3290834725,
-0.6987392306,
0.7036231756,
-0.2666654885,
-0.3358995318,
-0.149742946,
0.3785239458,
0.6436508894,
-0.368339479,
0.1206074581,
0.3147524595,
0.5025190115,
-0.1892534643,
-0.1472633779,
0.0059044897,
-0.2564647794,
-0.8429688215,
-0.3757270277,
-0.7607146502,
-0.479285866,
-0.4945317507,
0.3828720748,
0.1914249212,
-0.1686332971,
-0.2253234088,
-0.1449859142,
-0.5509873033,
-0.4369885027,
0.1533711702,
0.5851586461,
-0.860245645,
1.0375416279,
0.7393934131,
-0.8452233672,
-0.4939927757,
0.0531224534,
0.0599796809,
-0.7043289542,
0.8605868816,
-0.1726374924,
-0.3074726164,
-0.2654262781,
-0.3703456819,
-0.9823102355,
0.7222944498,
0.5692175627,
-0.5640883446,
0.0657247677,
0.6262125969,
0.5102487206,
-0.2796762884,
-0.0727215782,
0.1598752588,
0.5376722217,
-0.0180091299,
-0.9854452014,
-0.1878736615,
-0.2324023098,
0.0666599572,
0.3792550564,
-0.8347046971,
0.9127192497,
-0.033905521,
-0.3286223412,
-0.3783470988,
0.5042288303,
0.205105722,
0.3826189339,
0.4117881358,
0.1542516202,
0.4013971388,
-0.0539200306,
1.0156793594,
-0.6410714984,
0.1116515547,
1.0029381514,
-0.2305187136,
1.3484390974,
0.9521602988,
-0.2927258611,
0.3531248569,
0.1922312975,
0.2475318015,
0.8699105382,
-0.2690535486,
0.1303190589,
-0.215446189,
0.0131672136,
-0.4378836155,
0.6366385818,
0.2527726889,
0.1575212032,
-0.2902370691,
0.4270504713,
-0.0010075787,
0.4089924991,
-0.2048614174,
0.4004738033,
0.1580543667,
-0.6739192009,
0.6201546788,
0.1808205545,
0.6149630547,
-0.3140219748,
-0.2189609408,
-0.4095247984,
0.0401779674,
-0.0199685562,
-0.5567589998,
1.2212018967,
0.2991170585,
-0.3834947348,
-0.8223131895,
0.6809592843,
-0.549710989,
-0.6466646791,
0.1891543269,
0.9245036244,
0.2169949263,
-0.245747298,
-0.4639790952,
0.1430803388,
-0.1429013163,
0.2212697268,
0.5722193718,
0.3244814575,
-0.0768302232,
0.4841225743,
0.7961258292,
0.5639280081,
0.1991909146,
-0.5193696022,
0.5518711209,
-0.5636864901,
-0.2515966892,
-0.8320690393,
0.5630162358,
-0.235530138,
0.0775386542,
0.8544014692,
0.6383173466,
0.981216073,
-0.1426199526,
0.6565819383,
-0.0851151198,
0.8878550529,
-0.332246393,
0.7238464355,
-0.4753721058,
0.184426114,
0.0446044467,
-1.1796144247,
-0.3544560969,
0.4583776891,
-0.450599283,
-0.5551851988,
0.9624501467,
0.3890809417,
-0.2179788798,
-0.4183044434,
0.2846415937,
-0.0051320069,
0.0843469352,
0.3223541677,
0.5567464232,
-0.3082537949,
1.291041851,
-0.3437054753,
-0.2423191518,
-0.0911681503,
-0.6916388869,
-0.3069641888,
-0.7565835714,
-0.0341715328,
-0.1939635277,
-0.1832653433,
0.9030490518,
0.7169188261,
-1.0378648043,
-0.248433575,
0.4241901338,
0.3713372052,
-0.4230044186,
-0.0811961591,
0.3721891046,
-0.5632918477,
-1.0985044241,
0.5900893807,
0.7046223283,
-0.3564789295,
-0.2768334746,
-0.0060259686,
-0.5338513255,
-0.2412256151,
0.9006325603,
0.4168307483,
-0.5647629499,
0.0185898561,
0.0839382038,
-0.4047129452,
0.303530544,
0.9613733888,
-0.424773097,
0.459954679,
0.4411827624,
0.7475184798,
0.5039693117,
0.0545710288,
0.4486832917,
-0.6178275347,
0.365285933,
-0.0875205323,
0.1657212824,
0.6329212189,
-0.1440369487,
0.6253484488,
0.3941758871,
-0.2660917342,
-0.8150321841,
0.1399701983,
-0.6134613156,
-0.3341853917,
1.0220470428,
0.2189361006,
-0.2721967399,
0.0555375256,
-0.3710304499,
0.4828310609,
-0.1488380283,
0.6639089584,
0.7860043049,
-0.2910626829,
-0.2664608657,
-0.6375382543,
0.1032503918,
0.3177759051,
-0.6663074493,
0.0250388235,
0.2934376001,
-0.1185253263,
0.7611347437,
0.5338224769,
-0.2806105316,
-0.2372322232,
-0.0402968228,
-0.1455897987,
-0.1286285967,
-0.1359935552,
-0.3693657517,
0.2529985011,
0.0485931896,
-0.6246688962
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13331v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13331v1 | Improving Zero-shot LLM Re-Ranker with Risk Minimization | 2024-06-19T08:29:54 | 2024-06-19T08:29:54 | Xiaowei Yuan, Zhao Yang, Yequan Wang, Jun Zhao, Kang Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL | In the Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) system, advanced Large Language
Models (LLMs) have emerged as effective Query Likelihood Models (QLMs) in an
unsupervised way, which re-rank documents based on the probability of
generating the query given the content of a document. However, directly
prompting LLMs to approximate QLMs inherently is biased, where the estimated
distribution might diverge from the actual document-specific distribution. In
this study, we introduce a novel framework, $\mathrm{UR^3}$, which leverages
Bayesian decision theory to both quantify and mitigate this estimation bias.
Specifically, $\mathrm{UR^3}$ reformulates the problem as maximizing the
probability of document generation, thereby harmonizing the optimization of
query and document generation probabilities under a unified risk minimization
objective. Our empirical results indicate that $\mathrm{UR^3}$ significantly
enhances re-ranking, particularly in improving the Top-1 accuracy. It benefits
the QA tasks by achieving higher accuracy with fewer input documents. | [
0.0222334601,
-0.5563320518,
0.77519238,
-0.1135781631,
-0.258322835,
0.0847801715,
0.1696380973,
0.0691133961,
0.1020941436,
0.6132566929,
-0.2570564449,
-0.7869825959,
-0.5431583524,
-0.1200655475,
-0.1784563363,
1.0065574646,
0.2876755297,
-0.094884567,
-0.0968826711,
-0.0394429751,
-0.1394494623,
-0.2926159501,
-0.7111301422,
-0.2367133796,
0.8987159729,
0.4929591119,
0.8547238708,
0.4850895107,
0.6481643915,
0.1348870397,
0.0643110201,
-0.1247697547,
-0.6865603924,
0.5227435827,
-0.0358028077,
-0.7848497629,
-0.4444022775,
0.0904966816,
0.8680179119,
0.7573720813,
-0.2610900104,
0.0779341534,
-0.0399697609,
0.8853158355,
-1.1122065783,
-0.2761096358,
-0.687202692,
-0.1139780059,
-0.4099437892,
-0.4931094348,
-0.5446922183,
-0.4037721753,
-0.1803426743,
-0.5089528561,
0.4201411605,
0.0895685405,
0.7544302344,
0.1611539423,
-0.4949965477,
0.6727603674,
-0.7885040045,
0.8835773468,
-0.6110363007,
0.4492561519,
0.3028463423,
0.3208325803,
-0.5461365581,
-0.2048964202,
-0.2582577765,
0.1041600853,
0.3281732798,
0.328720212,
-0.32217291,
0.0888539627,
0.1433936059,
0.1456473917,
-0.5831065774,
0.2068273872,
-0.2022082657,
-0.0720201954,
0.7300933599,
0.0163499974,
0.0850795805,
-0.0842794925,
-0.1095581204,
-0.2002459913,
-0.9764368534,
-0.2735934258,
0.5468276143,
0.1271091849,
0.3938410878,
0.5712560415,
-0.4741963744,
0.733211875,
-0.0560195409,
-0.3243493438,
0.1036878601,
0.0476244092,
-0.3099703193,
-0.3340732455,
0.6838554144,
0.438449502,
-0.1298051476,
-0.1797722727,
-0.1204052642,
-0.2742272019,
0.6433274746,
-0.6567194462,
-0.004449001,
0.2808195353,
-0.3196718395,
-0.5848032236,
0.2314088494,
-0.6350886226,
-0.3200662732,
0.1490332037,
0.6228362918,
-0.2362617105,
0.0408611782,
0.1313978881,
-0.0484489426,
0.2157901078,
0.4207247496,
-0.5473180413,
-0.0198087972,
0.4370645583,
0.5668395162,
-0.2229519188,
-0.0878568143,
-0.696942687,
0.5967910886,
-0.6375398636,
1.1521378756,
-0.2371792942,
-0.6396437883,
0.0603695773,
-0.3235662282,
0.0826720893,
-0.4362556338,
0.7763255239,
-0.6961278915,
0.3217355311,
0.1561181396,
-0.4184123874,
0.0048632156,
0.1667418182,
-0.6382071972,
1.0053236485,
0.2014340013,
-0.6278749108,
0.6306676269,
-0.3193556964,
-0.2067944854,
0.0649960563,
-0.1625911444,
-0.6670444608,
0.3614654839,
0.3484286666,
0.2702794373,
-0.388920486,
0.0999443382,
-0.3549036086,
-0.521307826,
0.0858590081,
-0.4455744922,
0.4591677487,
0.2134890854,
-0.2109589875,
0.0949832872,
-0.6912351251,
0.1677883416,
0.0839093849,
-0.6896980405,
-0.4304681718,
-0.0537013598,
-0.2017806917,
-0.2650345564,
0.0814856067,
-0.6796144843,
0.3385113478,
-0.4213322401,
-0.3578878045,
0.5504068732,
0.4017612636,
0.7546457648,
-0.4598710239,
0.5529516339,
-0.1756532639,
0.3898574114,
0.1972134858,
-0.5571863651,
-0.8039329648,
-0.3961453736,
0.4911848903,
0.5295608044,
-0.5441209078,
0.2485712171,
-0.3624658287,
-0.4840670526,
-0.6183340549,
0.1820696741,
0.3612038791,
0.2283379138,
0.3120799065,
-0.064211227,
-0.1313223392,
-0.8887528777,
-0.4462720156,
-0.391656816,
-0.3853954673,
0.0817561969,
-0.1837457269,
-0.2012728155,
0.804567039,
-0.7011703253,
-0.4846399724,
-0.437596947,
0.3683921695,
0.3376099765,
0.442681849,
0.2795513272,
-0.6579219699,
-0.295539856,
-0.3435155749,
-0.5273045897,
-0.4002716839,
-0.0620083623,
-0.5342146158,
0.5792230964,
0.328205198,
-0.4841741621,
0.677531302,
-0.0182750598,
-0.0903920084,
0.2341389656,
-0.2893014252,
0.2015271783,
-1.0028979778,
-0.0836984888,
0.1180685982,
-0.0668812767,
-0.5502225161,
0.3271132708,
0.1312912852,
-0.0522471331,
-0.4108413756,
0.6057418585,
-0.4998594224,
-0.1563715786,
-0.4960153699,
0.3429187834,
0.0864941701,
0.2642917037,
-0.1090799496,
0.4824514985,
0.3244689703,
-0.3566135168,
-0.2672002912,
0.0885584205,
-0.1726295799,
0.6893000007,
-0.4299449325,
-0.2016773075,
-0.2965560853,
0.2431595773,
-0.944894731,
-0.0173247252,
0.0482080393,
-0.5687599182,
0.6047048569,
-0.3382160366,
-0.4467351139,
-0.3208510578,
-0.7461615205,
0.2851363122,
0.4965826869,
-0.3218181729,
0.3510378301,
0.3699057698,
-0.1652132869,
-0.7508174777,
-0.3772638738,
-0.0385115147,
-0.0414923504,
-0.3923898637,
0.4859036207,
0.0314680003,
-0.1662157178,
-0.1131951809,
-0.3639011681,
0.1409528106,
0.1077530086,
0.2208278179,
0.4049461782,
0.1066302136,
0.0447476916,
0.1833065599,
-0.4050156772,
-0.2552720308,
-0.1639497131,
0.1401285231,
0.32309407,
-0.5527015924,
-0.3569248319,
0.3117173612,
0.3960352838,
0.0904523209,
0.4824960828,
0.4893210828,
-0.1096517742,
-0.080079712,
-0.9204887152,
-0.0406647585,
-0.3565132916,
0.0944994614,
-0.3328712583,
-0.9041208625,
0.2338300347,
0.158533439,
0.1223733798,
0.5197278857,
0.3982106149,
-0.2622633874,
1.1749060154,
0.7685999274,
-0.2308676243,
0.4020794034,
-0.2991513908,
0.2848416865,
-1.1437460184,
-0.2506527305,
-0.6564731002,
-0.2228587568,
-0.8874863982,
-0.6160906553,
0.6309219003,
0.3996597826,
-0.3211293221,
0.0407809541,
-0.4117136002,
0.3399701118,
0.8267180324,
0.0098074079,
0.2924019992,
0.2842029929,
-0.3444222808,
0.0548788048,
-0.7976234555,
-0.3493871093,
1.5072346926,
0.1686582863,
1.1269074678,
0.4960907102,
1.2172490358,
0.2676083744,
0.4156304896,
-0.5260152221,
0.3622535169,
0.0730152056,
-0.4656537473,
-0.4267722368,
-0.4983416498,
-1.1379778385,
0.6020873785,
-0.3820315599,
-0.7282395959,
0.3005604148,
-0.1501533985,
-0.5978585482,
0.2595009506,
-0.156369552,
0.472194165,
0.0334298275,
-0.6960211396,
-0.0180731174,
-0.3097032011,
0.3315776885,
-0.0888515189,
0.1370928288,
-0.2409527749,
-0.394072026,
0.675480783,
-0.2533557117,
0.4484082758,
-0.10175962,
-0.1562268734,
0.2029667348,
0.3647320569,
0.5191004276,
0.3613472879,
-0.3480496109,
-0.0936110169,
-0.1010823026,
-0.6261227131,
-0.6613476872,
0.8089264035,
-0.7830304503,
-1.026866436,
-0.5349174738,
-0.5295435786,
-0.3437071145,
0.2812959552,
0.1956115067,
0.1789644808,
-0.1362727433,
0.2068751305,
0.5631292462,
-0.3066325188,
0.227279231,
0.9764039516,
-0.3306296468,
-0.4956245124,
0.7986991405,
0.0695685223,
0.0915505812,
0.672924459,
0.0226646792,
-0.4114646316,
-0.8163464665,
-0.2922377884,
0.3806940615,
-0.4766098559,
-0.5916131139,
-0.8286103606,
-0.1828160584,
-0.5472830534,
-0.2866789699,
-0.0040382706,
-0.5468909144,
-0.2890258729,
-0.2037728876,
0.1413769722,
0.5893039107,
-0.2770602405,
0.5475074649,
-0.7580093145,
0.4118968844,
0.2931760848,
0.4745025337,
-0.354397893,
-0.7315360904,
-0.0815955177,
-0.1996748894,
-0.5275065303,
-0.8323015571,
0.4634118974,
-0.0512399115,
1.0131015778,
0.2823664248,
0.0897419378,
0.280287236,
-0.3627966046,
0.6045588255,
-0.0095912311,
-0.4632130265,
0.7822606564,
-0.6395803094,
0.4134747386,
0.7481129169,
0.4098677337,
-0.041194424,
-0.6938409209,
-0.7564237714,
-0.9217669964,
0.5545855761,
0.294793874,
0.025384482,
-0.2433520854,
0.5218399167,
-0.1535255164,
0.0265665092,
-0.6375312805,
-0.2215901464,
0.1755621284,
0.000360622,
0.0979275256,
-0.7236992121,
0.0648853406,
0.0214489773,
0.9998593926,
-0.147816658,
0.2054168731,
0.14218086,
-0.086362876,
-0.3636360765,
0.4411248565,
0.4947015047,
0.4608281255,
-0.8428276181,
0.0605685115,
-0.1004672199,
-0.3696689308,
0.3946997523,
0.1107718796,
-0.5481283665,
0.020979505,
0.1416050047,
0.4231013656,
0.4394668639,
-0.2287494987,
0.4999408424,
0.0079524703,
-0.1275728345,
0.0480441228,
0.1587012112,
-0.2157960683,
0.1940559,
0.7945470214,
-0.1914786249,
0.2561625838,
-0.2908819914,
0.3577286601,
0.603898108,
-0.2934500277,
0.1873235404,
0.7082920074,
0.2025787681,
-0.1484622955,
0.3076122999,
-0.1992264539,
-0.2029571831,
0.1650818139,
0.6390874982,
0.9140570164,
-0.2433511466,
0.3861261904,
0.5146116614,
0.2970305681,
-0.1936264485,
0.3822226226,
0.1281749755,
-0.6435887814,
-0.2112438977,
-0.9289745688,
-0.4477809072,
0.0406218246,
-0.6431343555,
0.1442527473,
-0.3652977347,
-0.3058719039,
-0.2115206718,
0.1500612199,
-0.431850791,
0.108647339,
-0.0893495157,
0.6985940337,
-0.3081804514,
0.7379254103,
0.4264312685,
-0.681232214,
-0.4706476629,
0.2229860872,
0.0075420588,
-0.5969655514,
0.6364231706,
-0.2166329026,
-0.1572262794,
0.2975020111,
-0.2100276351,
-1.1935789585,
1.2607108355,
0.2888999581,
-0.4624791145,
0.1845989525,
-0.0160055421,
0.2736155391,
-0.2580868304,
0.342693001,
0.4448012412,
0.2442179024,
0.0210985746,
-0.3905128837,
-0.1034796014,
-0.0426840447,
0.3861344457,
0.448497653,
-0.287670821,
0.4904369116,
-0.4812402427,
-0.3405054212,
0.2595284879,
0.5702275634,
0.6176316738,
0.0257543847,
0.1973660439,
0.8254978061,
0.4575762749,
-0.0605911687,
1.2980263233,
-0.0777232647,
0.2292553484,
1.1356021166,
-0.4099548459,
1.0877958536,
0.3164350092,
-0.3616122007,
0.5333380103,
0.4818986356,
0.0387478247,
0.5028110743,
0.315859288,
-0.3793520629,
-0.3449831009,
-0.0953141302,
-0.1835741103,
0.2894903719,
0.0009598613,
-0.2093513906,
-0.5158350468,
-0.249397248,
0.0286721047,
-0.011619186,
-0.1740198284,
0.8813191652,
-0.1891028732,
-0.5449169278,
0.5161751509,
0.1353492588,
0.6666516066,
-0.3024300635,
0.0926926658,
-0.779316783,
-0.0280892849,
-0.047996264,
-0.7443320155,
0.0155444657,
-0.0519459732,
-0.3457469642,
-0.0604177043,
0.8335466981,
-0.2550247908,
-0.8178994656,
0.1255513281,
0.7437207699,
0.2227089852,
-0.2432606965,
-0.5537330508,
0.1226799265,
-0.1897184998,
-0.3896298707,
0.6428614855,
0.2593461573,
-0.2363636196,
0.6954999566,
0.8315102458,
0.2409644425,
-0.097146973,
0.4737280011,
0.5053736567,
-0.6950420737,
-0.1763345152,
-0.5567753911,
0.3041578829,
-0.1029405892,
0.1235023513,
0.7753979564,
0.598426044,
0.6638754606,
0.0964709371,
0.7155050635,
0.3095037639,
0.6910155416,
-0.3165964782,
0.9113255143,
-0.8148280978,
0.4032017887,
-0.2713614106,
-1.1668000221,
-0.8564292192,
0.4791068733,
-0.2438427955,
-0.005380109,
0.4815911055,
0.9256598353,
0.2872991562,
-0.6026889682,
0.7828162909,
-0.1541523933,
0.2884281278,
0.3956286311,
0.5225275755,
-0.6754634976,
0.5618185401,
-0.267991513,
-0.2737218142,
-0.4845878184,
-0.7930653691,
-0.5063149929,
-0.1585772336,
-0.319257766,
-0.1126806438,
0.2035167366,
0.4756498337,
0.52481848,
-0.4756251872,
-0.1079325005,
0.1203941628,
0.516972661,
0.0435729623,
-0.2440377623,
0.2807355821,
-0.5767117739,
-0.5663174391,
0.4242172241,
0.6199589968,
0.1159086525,
-0.2289863527,
0.0932934731,
-0.4811982512,
0.2658563554,
0.6097000241,
0.2098406106,
-0.7814648747,
-0.275795877,
-0.1042847112,
-0.2440627366,
-0.0362541415,
0.580098033,
-0.8670885563,
0.3629599214,
0.4793916047,
0.4797414839,
0.3476664126,
0.1724397093,
0.7194396853,
-0.7054564953,
-0.087290965,
0.0791887119,
0.2966246009,
0.3550488055,
-0.4621423483,
0.9502149224,
0.1875297278,
-0.5994466543,
-0.7753590345,
0.1546449065,
-0.9164012074,
-0.2845521569,
1.2989108562,
0.0901155174,
-0.1615561098,
0.0188228376,
-0.1049362421,
0.2997289002,
-0.4546024501,
0.7417205572,
0.119763419,
-0.3595565557,
-0.278927207,
-0.6827145815,
0.4477063119,
0.624960959,
-0.7015479207,
-0.1312397569,
0.6594978571,
0.4531015754,
0.173606053,
0.8031951785,
-0.3639570177,
0.4013161063,
-0.2904688716,
0.2337498963,
0.0879125595,
-0.3489264846,
-0.3410374224,
0.2727589309,
0.3884530962,
-0.1264269948
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13282v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13282v1 | Understanding the RoPE Extensions of Long-Context LLMs: An Attention Perspective | 2024-06-19T07:23:33 | 2024-06-19T07:23:33 | Meizhi Zhong, Chen Zhang, Yikun Lei, Xikai Liu, Yan Gao, Yao Hu, Kehai Chen, Min Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Enabling LLMs to handle lengthy context is currently a research hotspot. Most
LLMs are built upon rotary position embedding (RoPE), a popular position
encoding method. Therefore, a prominent path is to extrapolate the RoPE trained
on comparably short texts to far longer texts. A heavy bunch of efforts have
been dedicated to boosting the extrapolation via extending the formulations of
the RoPE, however, few of them have attempted to showcase their inner workings
comprehensively. In this paper, we are driven to offer a straightforward yet
in-depth understanding of RoPE extensions from an attention perspective and on
two benchmarking tasks. A broad array of experiments reveals several valuable
findings: 1) Maintaining attention patterns to those at the pretrained length
improves extrapolation; 2) Large attention uncertainty leads to retrieval
errors; 3) Using longer continual pretraining lengths for RoPE extensions could
reduce attention uncertainty and significantly enhance extrapolation. | [
-0.4976311326,
-0.6048641205,
0.536796689,
0.1317048222,
-0.5588381886,
0.0725781992,
-0.3638248444,
-0.8329967856,
0.3807885945,
0.4050562978,
-0.4751390219,
-0.296082288,
-0.7298557758,
0.0105239935,
-0.5958414078,
1.2456415892,
-0.1911731511,
-0.4922543168,
-0.2243159711,
-0.4353369176,
-0.3372939229,
-0.6996841431,
-0.3612523079,
-0.2562485933,
0.8504952788,
0.1592476219,
0.5551328659,
0.7066985369,
0.5971021056,
0.179382816,
-0.1797173619,
0.212801829,
-0.6687682271,
-0.0036514641,
-0.1191452593,
-0.5064889193,
-0.5926631689,
0.132160753,
0.7795664072,
0.7541313171,
0.1560166031,
0.3033489585,
0.387511909,
1.0182934999,
-0.7597412467,
-0.1176959798,
-0.3055262566,
0.2484783083,
-0.1568154246,
-0.3848184049,
-0.1856746674,
-0.1772588789,
0.6111671329,
-0.4166042507,
0.118057102,
0.1217157096,
0.6683722138,
0.3436781168,
-0.8665909171,
-0.2981003523,
-0.6715225577,
0.9262526631,
-0.2985414565,
0.462264508,
0.2506797016,
0.2608530223,
-0.0352372602,
-0.8204436898,
0.0252736397,
-0.1906020492,
-0.1436085701,
0.2793461978,
0.5283834338,
0.204074204,
0.5564880967,
0.267102927,
-0.123843506,
0.0202133134,
-0.4757637382,
0.3701057732,
0.850594461,
-0.0709796995,
-0.241475895,
0.1868331283,
-0.7543722391,
0.0168526843,
-0.9038425088,
0.3256619871,
0.1855367571,
-0.3554803431,
-0.0782057345,
0.4254544377,
-0.1216704324,
0.8618896008,
0.0114292419,
0.1616339833,
0.0536066294,
0.1551163048,
-0.1543608457,
0.176151216,
0.2064317614,
0.6598652601,
0.4610355794,
-0.1050165147,
-0.0980981141,
-0.5247029662,
0.4215924144,
-0.3432652056,
0.1156696007,
0.1540009826,
-0.2813492119,
0.0367106535,
0.1053512618,
-0.4852364659,
-0.1555055827,
-0.6241928935,
0.1864796579,
-0.233330816,
0.2435993254,
0.2613966167,
-0.0794610456,
0.5172621608,
0.4077163041,
-0.6721503735,
0.1048840657,
0.9494947195,
0.7524064183,
-0.6571055055,
-0.3191779256,
-0.7063125968,
0.6727343798,
-0.2491808087,
0.7233261466,
-0.2530176342,
-0.1370231807,
0.1070944741,
0.246321097,
0.1032429487,
-0.248508051,
0.8373280168,
-0.9201965332,
0.0787283629,
0.0352783129,
-0.7858173847,
-0.4045474827,
0.448071152,
-0.5926488638,
1.0489602089,
0.1025815383,
-0.4970004857,
0.2278952003,
-0.4502831101,
-0.4935466051,
-0.2436333448,
-0.0696427971,
-0.1362695396,
0.554194212,
0.2021072656,
0.4241528511,
-0.3032978773,
0.049311839,
-0.3461600542,
-0.5226213336,
0.5195399523,
-0.3106764555,
0.1389200538,
-0.1825275123,
-0.102507554,
-0.0349276029,
-0.4382474124,
0.2011343837,
-0.4802331924,
-0.4194613099,
-0.4691598713,
-0.1015714481,
-0.0500424653,
0.2945617139,
0.0920069516,
-0.1887144446,
0.1308245361,
-0.5532157421,
0.3194521666,
0.7002777457,
-0.1416061074,
0.3515302241,
-0.3285287023,
0.6823997498,
-0.173888132,
0.0609447509,
-0.370541513,
-0.0946441069,
-0.8490839601,
-0.0060457317,
0.3356815577,
0.179810375,
-0.4944795966,
0.3796289563,
-0.6675707102,
-0.1812408119,
-0.2525004148,
0.1659726799,
0.365317136,
0.2368079722,
0.5392495394,
-0.4994862676,
-0.4775833786,
-0.8027290702,
-0.59505862,
0.2864382267,
-0.2766616046,
0.1953468472,
0.4378989935,
0.0288430732,
1.121276021,
-0.6920118928,
-0.4107288122,
-0.0394676365,
-0.2183469236,
0.4524852931,
0.505674243,
0.2408641726,
-0.8561995625,
-0.6524919271,
-0.0690517053,
-0.7660437226,
0.4353556037,
-0.4717821777,
-0.0776228905,
-0.089364022,
0.6992555857,
-0.5606439114,
0.5411444306,
0.4960262477,
0.2531300783,
0.671428144,
-0.234131813,
-0.2766981721,
-0.6633259058,
-0.0393947214,
0.0696146414,
-0.4668392837,
-0.4695633054,
0.2588813901,
0.2895105183,
0.2035717964,
-0.4895321727,
0.435585916,
-0.9394537807,
-0.5885339379,
-0.4531224072,
0.5871373415,
0.1150491312,
0.7677035928,
0.0825511292,
0.5042639971,
0.432865411,
-0.705827117,
0.5855119228,
0.1607386768,
-0.5266029835,
0.4988654256,
-0.9968268871,
0.3770362735,
-0.0327170826,
0.4509057999,
-0.8454245925,
-0.2329302728,
-0.1018422544,
-0.4062213302,
0.5282636881,
-0.339161694,
-0.1045789197,
-0.5862603784,
-0.9579111338,
0.6168071032,
0.4955900609,
-0.6431556344,
0.384768486,
0.2762828767,
0.0410803221,
-0.8639329672,
-0.7191574574,
0.1115459874,
-0.5792167783,
-0.3359621465,
0.616307199,
0.0629596338,
-0.010472917,
-0.2024043202,
-0.4857413173,
-0.1484186053,
-0.0177920144,
0.1268514097,
-0.0035444228,
-0.228194505,
0.3145348132,
0.2079098374,
-0.1093432158,
0.2781656384,
-0.3403010666,
0.2466745377,
0.0355253182,
-0.5712581873,
-0.3003933132,
0.3530373275,
0.3414475322,
-0.163899526,
0.4242123365,
0.4053198397,
-0.0986302793,
-0.2160773277,
-0.4553045928,
-0.0825150385,
-0.5356906056,
0.5204402208,
-0.3679972291,
-0.8610042334,
0.2069251388,
-0.3380678892,
-0.0486356355,
0.1046894118,
0.0433136746,
-0.5433452129,
0.7538878918,
1.0200264454,
-0.0079240436,
0.50469625,
-0.2448751032,
-0.122236453,
-1.6756594181,
-0.0285645239,
0.0435656905,
-0.6824994683,
-0.4930472076,
-0.7628845572,
0.4029351473,
0.6879788637,
0.0788260773,
0.5268215537,
-0.3134631515,
0.6097359657,
0.1931025386,
0.2206223607,
0.1451247782,
0.0817437023,
0.0948610455,
-0.109460555,
-0.6308244467,
-0.4010394216,
1.1703846455,
0.440641135,
0.8477571011,
-0.0659725741,
0.3863520026,
0.091380626,
0.5145864487,
-1.1234841347,
0.2722176015,
0.1880027652,
-0.4148640931,
-0.3936563134,
0.2829844058,
-0.9968373179,
0.1929965913,
0.3158982694,
-0.7159281373,
-0.0190292299,
0.2704859078,
-0.3420115113,
-0.0268804897,
-0.3867439032,
0.3465584517,
-0.4414257705,
-0.7073504925,
-0.4000199437,
-1.0273406506,
0.2413085103,
-0.1705068946,
0.2099136263,
-0.0845590681,
-0.5100924969,
0.7375141978,
-0.0808530599,
0.712108314,
0.2760613561,
-0.4336984754,
0.376318872,
-0.4597737193,
0.7681543827,
0.2445555776,
-0.0174855925,
-0.1757594943,
-0.3621511459,
-0.3692266047,
-0.798833847,
0.7482306957,
-0.4843476713,
-1.0638769865,
-0.2996425033,
-0.6424541473,
-0.4067250788,
-0.1059039757,
-0.0980442315,
0.4830309749,
0.0421135239,
0.4973524511,
0.7437549829,
-0.113936469,
0.4909278452,
0.247354731,
-0.1839703023,
-0.2159015238,
0.4303145111,
0.1542128921,
0.2333730608,
0.6828889251,
-0.2453164011,
-0.5171666145,
-0.5829017162,
-0.2402216345,
0.3124161363,
-0.9664201736,
0.0647617206,
-0.7460259795,
-0.1278487295,
-0.2348948419,
-0.329777658,
-0.1233560666,
-0.6959152818,
-0.0925477445,
-0.3406412303,
0.4851722419,
0.6454703212,
-0.0267986245,
0.5136697888,
-1.0527403355,
0.1230822131,
0.492564261,
0.2744172513,
0.1083749458,
-0.703874886,
-0.7688729167,
-0.0374777652,
-0.4310957789,
-0.6039529443,
0.2795148194,
0.4638727605,
0.5999874473,
0.3908076286,
0.2070633769,
0.9107643366,
-0.7092273235,
0.5730513334,
0.2707554996,
-0.8204616308,
0.4818419814,
-0.1873376518,
0.287637651,
0.2281184942,
0.7577661276,
-0.6670868993,
-0.1612958759,
-0.4635761082,
-1.0939912796,
0.6786710024,
0.1578350067,
0.2259440422,
0.1247895434,
0.6561123729,
-0.0252077859,
0.151306957,
-0.4796414971,
-0.2879862189,
0.1863417923,
-0.0264690425,
-0.4504087269,
-0.4401159286,
-0.4629109502,
-0.2897188365,
0.2196122706,
-0.3694051206,
0.3460858762,
0.3364164531,
-0.5739876032,
0.212898463,
-0.0279941075,
0.7200679183,
0.8892606497,
-0.0265200101,
0.3244364858,
0.7370354533,
-0.2714932859,
0.2028228194,
-0.1215289161,
0.3398532271,
0.0943964347,
0.7711429596,
0.7188645601,
0.3369497061,
-0.5316812396,
0.3205395043,
0.3079191446,
0.2758156955,
-0.4911922216,
0.0581326559,
0.2694633603,
0.1629829407,
0.6481812596,
-0.1560495645,
0.2148249298,
-0.2691322267,
0.4144363105,
0.2796314955,
-0.9250564575,
-0.4759374857,
0.471288234,
0.4761196971,
-0.3787458837,
0.1027571484,
0.5205495358,
-0.6783898473,
0.9580850601,
0.2658196688,
0.659311235,
0.0232794117,
-0.2876673341,
0.3344347775,
0.0543711223,
0.0308048818,
-0.2576019168,
-0.5205725431,
-0.3267967403,
-0.6788834929,
-0.4114593267,
-0.3206117451,
-0.1293631494,
-1.1177464724,
0.4265102744,
-0.1631897837,
-0.1526180208,
-0.4023481011,
-0.0367726833,
-0.5107182264,
0.3992758393,
0.0968855694,
0.9597166777,
-0.1596284062,
1.1052292585,
0.7558199167,
0.2102624625,
-0.3690547347,
0.2394062579,
-0.3178780675,
-0.862480998,
0.780543983,
0.7426358461,
-0.4685185552,
0.0947972834,
-0.393230617,
-1.0480327606,
1.2020493746,
0.0651038736,
-0.7515509725,
-0.2377287447,
0.2597343922,
0.6069208384,
-0.3443356752,
0.3091681898,
0.4543622732,
0.0547488369,
-0.2530002892,
-0.6243208647,
0.038830325,
0.1602248251,
0.2955659926,
0.0646066144,
-0.7637710571,
0.3763928711,
-0.2492723763,
-0.127951622,
0.0614340715,
0.8535209298,
0.1477045119,
0.1747194678,
0.3636627197,
0.2070014179,
0.3593719304,
0.1906792819,
1.1942098141,
-0.6270178556,
0.7573328018,
1.5488730669,
-0.3122169673,
0.7950035334,
0.8239040375,
-0.187892139,
0.4108510315,
0.8104897738,
0.2906746268,
0.4738691151,
0.3257341981,
-0.2346882671,
-0.1622360349,
-0.1130593196,
-0.77892977,
0.0499718748,
0.6669822335,
-0.6176634431,
-0.0657488927,
0.1052869633,
-0.3969511688,
-0.1900479198,
-0.2940133214,
0.5209359527,
0.5332500935,
-0.9346361756,
0.6301516294,
-0.2346580178,
0.7073635459,
-0.51827389,
0.1340863407,
-0.16129224,
0.4901356697,
0.0985175818,
-1.0503768921,
0.3292180598,
-0.1785801351,
0.0309605915,
-0.4343069494,
0.6538658142,
-0.4879597127,
0.0026727216,
0.4850376546,
0.238212496,
0.1788239777,
-0.0234288406,
-0.5591263175,
0.0436546244,
-0.1240054294,
-0.6318491697,
0.3937423527,
0.5615996718,
-0.1037413925,
0.7997835875,
0.340097934,
-0.4022318125,
0.1290782094,
-0.366073668,
1.0163345337,
-0.7607386708,
-0.3583492637,
-0.895187974,
0.3600296676,
-0.279363513,
-0.4645748734,
0.8725786805,
0.445512414,
0.8925440907,
-0.2850751579,
0.3816096187,
0.305213958,
0.1777786463,
-0.693076849,
0.5088303685,
-0.6023495197,
0.1160195768,
-0.0216464028,
-0.9674994946,
-0.1758696884,
0.4249951541,
-0.4358348846,
-0.0759357512,
0.9344109893,
0.3457433283,
-0.154769972,
-0.2618529499,
0.3412367105,
-0.0010174409,
0.1871278286,
0.9282960296,
1.3271710873,
-0.4660538137,
0.6452732086,
-0.0853056014,
0.0079244506,
-0.3935047388,
-1.011256218,
-0.8297225237,
-0.0406326652,
-0.3095230758,
0.0727012306,
0.1159307659,
0.8643012643,
0.9301354289,
-0.4870268703,
-0.3705213666,
0.1210376099,
0.1972067207,
-0.2012439072,
-0.1360662878,
0.541895628,
-0.3322767019,
-0.8273712993,
0.2649680972,
0.509090364,
0.0539845154,
-0.0199201796,
-0.1940507293,
-0.4097073674,
-0.1143695042,
0.9582461119,
0.2298721969,
-0.539347589,
-0.4682782292,
-0.1094540805,
0.0169157758,
0.2780152261,
0.8920558095,
-0.8985176086,
0.101416789,
0.2655347586,
0.6331423521,
0.9663200378,
0.2423838675,
0.8697653413,
-1.1833428144,
0.2649796903,
0.1630476117,
0.1590829194,
0.1617155373,
-0.2708742917,
0.8167663813,
0.0162662379,
-0.5102878213,
-0.7475035191,
0.5643387437,
-0.9539756775,
-0.0358990096,
1.1333979368,
-0.7679811716,
-0.2756467164,
-0.223623246,
-0.2201025635,
0.3540708721,
0.0873511285,
0.7295920849,
0.6865670085,
-0.4089009166,
-0.0677262694,
-0.6598908305,
0.6878277659,
0.7781391144,
-0.7025619149,
0.0785292313,
0.0689191371,
0.1036548764,
0.1550704539,
0.2052039504,
0.1476990283,
0.2784219682,
-0.7222813964,
-0.5880044699,
0.1603927314,
-0.4551915526,
-0.4937859178,
0.2347945273,
-0.0588431358,
-0.1528318822
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13274v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13274v1 | In-Context Learning on a Budget: A Case Study in Named Entity Recognition | 2024-06-19T07:09:46 | 2024-06-19T07:09:46 | Uri Berger, Tal Baumel, Gabriel Stanovsky | cs.CL | cs.CL | Few shot in-context learning (ICL) typically assumes access to large
annotated training sets. However, in many real world scenarios, such as domain
adaptation, there is only a limited budget to annotate a small number of
samples, with the goal of maximizing downstream performance. We study various
methods for selecting samples to annotate within a predefined budget,
specifically focusing on the named entity recognition (NER) task, which has
real-world applications, is expensive to annotate, and is relatively less
studied in ICL setups. Across different models and datasets, we find that a
relatively small pool of annotated samples can achieve results comparable to
using the entire training set. Moreover, we discover that random selection of
samples for annotation yields surprisingly good performance. Finally, we
observe that a diverse annotation pool is correlated with improved performance.
We hope that future work adopts our realistic paradigm which takes annotation
budget into account. | [
-0.7876274586,
-0.1357208192,
0.3081864417,
-0.0796065032,
-0.3458629251,
-0.1259656996,
-0.2075574547,
-0.8602828383,
-0.0533362105,
0.3848168254,
-0.501149416,
-0.0853593796,
-0.3518328369,
0.3277324736,
-0.200968951,
1.1674342155,
-0.0286987908,
0.1552905142,
-0.2356358021,
-0.529669106,
-0.3974586427,
-0.3839457035,
-0.9912039042,
-0.3527402282,
0.6179607511,
0.6457621455,
-0.143771261,
0.4798419774,
0.6302498579,
0.0980590731,
0.0935053527,
0.2181466818,
-0.4089187682,
-0.0745421275,
-0.1547873169,
-0.3048571646,
0.0560898744,
0.0636804104,
0.6908640265,
0.6005612016,
0.2573570907,
0.3532541394,
0.1506527811,
0.544377625,
-1.0193446875,
0.0924942046,
-0.8889712095,
0.2372499555,
-0.3425795436,
0.0194585212,
-0.3308887482,
-0.0138967028,
0.7213340402,
-0.9805088639,
0.129680261,
0.2866786718,
0.9438497424,
0.383171469,
-0.0857147649,
-0.3586316109,
-0.7222319245,
0.7917433381,
-0.2446859926,
0.3258749247,
0.5594881177,
0.4692233801,
0.0880251154,
-0.7329261899,
-0.3380603492,
-0.0774674788,
-0.0183748603,
-0.0484976172,
-0.0418077782,
0.0101119848,
0.6443806291,
-0.0088904807,
0.0599238984,
0.1174128652,
-0.2169548571,
-0.0535187311,
0.5996987224,
-0.1221870556,
0.0390356667,
0.0327578932,
-0.7193499207,
-0.1635415703,
-0.7784206867,
0.1646253467,
-0.0754355863,
0.6426829696,
-0.0563065745,
0.2547686398,
-0.2808248997,
0.6367562413,
0.1461669654,
-0.3930935562,
0.0819616616,
-0.0958435014,
-0.4430146813,
0.4680488706,
0.0895022377,
0.0958259478,
0.4982706606,
-0.2071335614,
-0.6148559451,
-0.4577805996,
0.1622835845,
-0.9149165154,
-0.5666956902,
-0.0583358817,
-0.1579332352,
0.025940571,
-0.1280894876,
-0.6124915481,
-0.4360963404,
-0.6125615835,
0.653922677,
-0.4155529737,
0.2899477482,
-0.6213455796,
-0.2991808057,
0.0352709554,
0.5881912708,
-0.8879134059,
0.4159977436,
0.2820535004,
0.8072807789,
0.0810881481,
-0.1183313802,
-0.7063275576,
0.1566830277,
-0.3074175715,
1.1741831303,
-0.3647403717,
-0.2731753588,
-0.2008597255,
-0.3531093597,
-0.0657939389,
-0.7933697701,
0.0700053945,
-0.5405990481,
-0.3135618567,
-0.4536178112,
-0.7029880285,
-0.1190811917,
0.137195915,
-0.8578646183,
0.7424041629,
0.2533632815,
-0.9218530059,
1.387436986,
-0.6858020425,
-0.3144066632,
0.4637461603,
-0.3395648301,
-0.4078245163,
0.1280385703,
0.1450102329,
0.484428376,
-0.10338936,
-0.0342512541,
-0.2170845121,
-0.5764232874,
0.3533655405,
-0.108489275,
0.5901430845,
0.236770615,
-0.3359547555,
-0.2496260852,
-0.908665359,
-0.1323540062,
-0.1987920254,
-0.5338557959,
-0.6643553972,
-0.0372274965,
0.3966288865,
-0.0399467163,
-0.2714958787,
-0.4360131323,
0.1208017617,
-0.3956305087,
0.3232640028,
0.6319741607,
0.2231997102,
0.8818355203,
-0.11753463,
0.162531808,
0.0492713712,
-0.1949037164,
0.0207315814,
-0.0056872773,
-0.6513981819,
-0.8184247017,
0.7657328844,
0.3025559485,
-0.6703457236,
-0.216602236,
-0.0062668351,
-0.1926058084,
-0.1649671197,
0.0323429853,
0.2532572746,
0.6948911548,
0.5089695454,
-0.2551152706,
-0.7216453552,
-0.9934973717,
-0.1882980615,
-0.0510442667,
-0.0398658775,
0.8571603298,
0.7748247385,
0.2845672369,
1.2306592464,
-0.3499349654,
-0.6934720874,
-0.1533930898,
0.0776102096,
-0.1815578341,
0.4384521842,
0.6806643009,
-0.8832882643,
-0.4049835205,
-0.1747574806,
-0.3645031452,
0.1513347477,
-0.479095906,
0.0634369627,
0.0742329657,
0.53186059,
-0.1683893204,
0.4138520956,
0.0673945546,
0.1107523218,
0.1370157748,
-0.0609364472,
-0.2756248415,
-0.7999185324,
-0.0307412576,
0.2404145002,
-0.270760119,
-0.2366211116,
-0.1008303985,
0.2033226043,
-0.0081436615,
-0.6081059575,
0.8418108821,
-0.7188957334,
-0.1399430633,
-0.2840613425,
0.2335059494,
-0.1876422465,
0.2993090153,
0.2791414559,
1.0116442442,
0.3567338288,
-0.8308260441,
-0.123348251,
0.1155482233,
-0.6291173697,
0.800019145,
-0.1927320212,
0.1015319154,
-0.2383379191,
0.5037680864,
-0.5302659273,
-0.5351375937,
0.2491369396,
0.0335503034,
0.5232614875,
-0.4532937407,
-0.28300789,
0.2330995649,
0.0908569768,
0.4495703876,
0.2108295113,
-0.9193206429,
0.2941820025,
0.7585892081,
0.3083867729,
-0.3843467832,
-0.8185973763,
0.0034600899,
-0.5830045938,
0.277381748,
0.4504086673,
0.0308557618,
-0.4090572596,
0.0397238359,
-0.1467232555,
-0.3566952944,
0.4217970371,
0.3099726737,
0.0770541653,
-0.2502571642,
0.5481001735,
-0.1678153574,
-0.0170843508,
-0.1661504507,
-0.6029497385,
-0.0419077761,
0.1165433004,
-0.1075690016,
-0.0704507828,
0.1648031324,
-0.0749504566,
-0.2021010071,
0.5162346363,
0.3133760989,
-0.9687818885,
-0.6972813606,
-0.4398222566,
-0.1874199659,
-0.3436036408,
0.2895804942,
-0.61310637,
-0.6719899774,
0.2832837105,
-0.3833110929,
0.1139009893,
0.4015118182,
0.1264388859,
-0.331616044,
0.2613374293,
0.5855376124,
-0.0575233586,
0.7519691586,
-0.3632818758,
0.2866936922,
-1.0307987928,
-0.1405795217,
-0.4568772912,
-0.6721603274,
-0.3973710537,
-0.2039179504,
0.2777160406,
0.2458842397,
-0.1494588852,
0.4709567428,
-0.4066368639,
0.8477870226,
0.745200038,
0.0785580724,
-0.0934017375,
-0.0772873014,
-0.015315745,
-0.0762496144,
-0.5429640412,
-0.4874573946,
1.0251755714,
0.0396207236,
0.2981300652,
-0.1159378737,
1.0307327509,
-0.0048990375,
0.5908292532,
-0.7320181727,
0.46510005,
-0.0352206081,
-0.7828480601,
-0.4098775387,
-0.2041534334,
-0.7776790261,
0.1947394311,
-0.4150535464,
-1.0019167662,
0.5876688361,
0.2367972434,
-0.7211142182,
0.3129476309,
-0.5563636422,
0.6730856895,
-0.045373369,
-0.2123468816,
0.0167092886,
-0.4956900179,
0.0883728936,
-0.4167006314,
-0.0570449904,
-0.3497618437,
-0.1505846679,
0.6995905638,
0.022353407,
0.5799459815,
-0.3657533526,
0.5548471808,
0.4632747471,
-0.1426602304,
0.4167244136,
0.4699901342,
0.0852463096,
0.0959818214,
-0.006234685,
-0.3093583584,
-0.259724021,
0.6241952777,
-0.480630666,
-0.2371263057,
-0.5358682871,
-0.6180797815,
-0.3082751334,
0.2091845274,
0.445718497,
0.6379235387,
-0.1789702326,
0.1453268826,
0.6627107263,
-0.0291774198,
0.8661934733,
0.0112485606,
0.1665019244,
-0.3775832057,
0.7971524,
0.6868565083,
-0.0043859351,
0.6271697283,
-0.0458105877,
-0.0422680303,
-0.7241917253,
-0.7543190718,
-0.1026165783,
-0.9182559252,
-0.4072226584,
-0.5272231698,
-0.1059696674,
-0.0516420826,
-0.3101305366,
-0.3085312545,
-0.4029734433,
-0.6037560105,
-0.1298475862,
0.338950932,
0.2950264513,
0.0636391863,
0.1892323643,
-0.4016893208,
0.0508277752,
0.3641646504,
0.251435101,
-0.0044084652,
-0.3121418357,
-0.6141882539,
-0.2105068713,
0.0026489024,
-0.6434078217,
0.3044234216,
0.5944927931,
0.5499761105,
0.3155084848,
0.2080612034,
1.0068984032,
-0.5834715366,
0.438698262,
-0.2001446784,
-0.7025361657,
0.3957447708,
0.1100821793,
0.2424337864,
1.1847890615,
0.3742455542,
-0.1351491958,
0.1759647727,
-0.6495395303,
-0.9217042327,
0.7246810198,
-0.062664181,
0.1634854525,
-0.0300227348,
0.5538765788,
0.1082091406,
0.1438886225,
-0.7136010528,
-0.0921079069,
0.1937223822,
0.0010749531,
0.0552354865,
-0.14172405,
-0.1982869655,
-0.1458080262,
0.6599647999,
-0.362056911,
0.1872902066,
0.5092661381,
-0.5199266672,
-0.0007231889,
0.022792438,
0.5147935748,
0.6915953755,
-0.2662469149,
0.2681726515,
0.7466000319,
-0.238317728,
-0.0550024994,
0.1507661492,
-0.3219275773,
0.0282768775,
0.3638601303,
1.0529026985,
0.6652189493,
-0.867914319,
0.4601245224,
-0.0053914669,
-0.0528981201,
-0.61705935,
0.0096438034,
-0.0943379253,
0.6699181199,
0.4544515014,
0.2264867276,
0.3836993575,
-0.3051604629,
0.291015774,
0.4907587171,
-0.5924343467,
-0.0032767847,
0.4943017364,
-0.0465855002,
-0.2742304504,
0.7945256829,
-0.5060051084,
-0.2252443284,
0.6073625088,
0.5323815346,
1.0242952108,
0.4524688721,
-0.0627179667,
0.5891653299,
0.0720276088,
-0.1158533543,
-0.1314054728,
-0.4979353845,
-0.667536974,
-0.0462141074,
-0.5967988372,
-0.583753109,
0.0562823117,
-0.5549187064,
0.5777472258,
-0.7435632944,
-0.149913609,
0.1851046979,
0.2008262575,
-1.0004655123,
0.5229117274,
0.5359994769,
1.007375598,
-0.575317502,
0.9578572512,
0.895092845,
-0.5590833426,
-0.9063250422,
0.1324210465,
-0.0353670083,
-0.4881302416,
1.0774679184,
0.2966122925,
0.2023529261,
0.013345073,
-0.3672242165,
-1.08928442,
1.2000477314,
0.2382125556,
-0.748990953,
-0.1020648479,
-0.3024215102,
0.2915993035,
-0.7732619643,
0.1198509261,
0.359541744,
0.1786105037,
-0.0619371869,
-0.6359021068,
-0.2277471572,
0.1813832819,
-0.0181940775,
0.321467638,
-0.4452436268,
0.7967107296,
-0.3272022307,
-0.3466542661,
-0.294604063,
0.7730265856,
0.4007338285,
0.84065938,
0.6569355726,
0.4389927685,
0.885812819,
0.0349065475,
1.0757781267,
-0.1029603258,
0.3536883593,
1.297585845,
-0.2979987264,
0.94215554,
0.7120042443,
-0.1264787018,
0.0454690419,
0.9693904519,
-0.2156074047,
0.8621784449,
0.4073869586,
-0.4170792103,
-0.1900742799,
-0.3171234131,
0.1228878796,
0.3433642089,
0.1564474404,
-0.267619133,
-0.1935961992,
0.2564209998,
-0.1712251902,
-0.3527731597,
-0.3709243834,
1.0325834751,
0.4400735199,
-0.4788697064,
0.023714222,
-0.2726996541,
0.3983694315,
-0.2996256351,
-0.0721699819,
-0.1302799284,
0.2038942277,
-0.1414908022,
-0.2569049299,
0.1748675853,
0.0137130814,
-0.1222755387,
-0.0500955731,
0.7828927636,
-0.1950581223,
-0.4166616201,
0.047516007,
0.0896106809,
0.3023483455,
-0.1933348477,
-0.3981055915,
-0.2917195559,
-0.2760760784,
-0.1940888017,
0.7944692969,
0.4108923674,
-0.3604846299,
0.3948151767,
0.4308965206,
0.2452894896,
-0.073279731,
-0.0210470818,
0.5810391903,
-0.408277005,
-0.4600180387,
-0.8038238883,
0.4096630216,
-0.1538720876,
-0.7587128282,
0.4059604108,
0.5737801194,
1.5853513479,
0.0203737617,
0.7337683439,
0.1974797845,
0.4069053829,
-0.5106919408,
0.353363663,
-0.6223142147,
0.1667578369,
-0.2853674591,
-0.9868979454,
-0.5937991738,
0.9441588521,
-0.4446668327,
-0.1933500916,
0.4772419035,
0.2992593348,
-0.1610851884,
0.1761202812,
0.2802270353,
-0.4409196973,
0.059050709,
0.5160752535,
0.7645769715,
-0.3462679386,
0.1617731303,
-0.6311206818,
0.1414739192,
-0.2841392756,
-1.0451999903,
-0.7534854412,
-0.6817383766,
-0.5902590156,
-0.0235233214,
0.1376515627,
1.5517200232,
1.0008072853,
-0.8991582394,
-0.1026087403,
0.023844501,
-0.1621816754,
-0.3276717067,
-0.1404123306,
0.2597714961,
-0.3601402342,
-0.8484169841,
0.3412507176,
0.3491349518,
-0.0203614384,
0.1177433133,
0.2059146464,
-0.288472116,
0.0004496547,
0.3856466413,
0.3697761595,
-0.6866837144,
-0.5497674346,
-0.3228862286,
-0.0994396657,
0.1703656316,
0.8633898497,
-0.9900821447,
0.3387475312,
0.292999208,
1.1486378908,
0.7285239697,
-0.2102124393,
0.0144535359,
-0.7925904393,
0.083005324,
0.452655077,
0.4736928642,
0.3429504931,
-0.3646585345,
0.6185008287,
0.1746033728,
-0.591606617,
-1.0643738508,
-0.0455375835,
-0.8544162512,
-0.2547860742,
0.8277796507,
-0.2355479449,
-0.0572496057,
-0.0189180002,
-0.1852783263,
0.0981289223,
-0.3893266916,
0.5536916852,
0.6642497778,
-0.4956278205,
-0.2403647155,
-0.7387729287,
0.7051284909,
0.0429462194,
-0.638064146,
-0.2226870805,
0.4987157583,
0.3226998448,
0.065369837,
0.5867196918,
0.3728429079,
0.0896253884,
0.1169788092,
-0.062748082,
0.1120671034,
-0.5536171794,
-0.3623109162,
0.3582703173,
0.4061363637,
-0.4554523528
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13275v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13275v2 | Enhancing Automated Audio Captioning via Large Language Models with Optimized Audio Encoding | 2024-06-19T07:09:46 | 2024-06-25T08:07:36 | Jizhong Liu, Gang Li, Junbo Zhang, Heinrich Dinkel, Yongqing Wang, Zhiyong Yan, Yujun Wang, Bin Wang | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS | Automated audio captioning (AAC) is an audio-to-text task to describe audio
contents in natural language. Recently, the advancements in large language
models (LLMs), with improvements in training approaches for audio encoders,
have opened up possibilities for improving AAC. Thus, we explore enhancing AAC
from three aspects: 1) a pre-trained audio encoder via consistent ensemble
distillation (CED) is used to improve the effectivity of acoustic tokens, with
a querying transformer (Q-Former) bridging the modality gap to LLM and compress
acoustic tokens; 2) we investigate the advantages of using a Llama 2 with 7B
parameters as the decoder; 3) another pre-trained LLM corrects text errors
caused by insufficient training data and annotation ambiguities. Both the audio
encoder and text decoder are optimized by low-rank adaptation (LoRA).
Experiments show that each of these enhancements is effective. Our method
obtains a 33.0 SPIDEr-FL score, outperforming the winner of DCASE 2023 Task 6A. | [
-0.4472236633,
-0.4639536142,
0.5491535664,
0.0586657077,
-0.5747398138,
0.4450887442,
-0.1921579093,
-0.5523741841,
0.2263264805,
0.3109340668,
-0.2215197086,
-0.6239872575,
-0.8499640822,
0.5131853819,
-0.3968170583,
0.7934072018,
-0.0238248613,
0.2476734221,
-0.0842612088,
-0.2479864359,
-0.5514335632,
-0.5320185423,
-0.8247765303,
-0.0835532844,
0.2594978511,
0.4337734282,
0.6245577335,
0.733448267,
0.5290925503,
0.3192200363,
-0.0683796406,
0.3136193752,
-0.1205202192,
0.0080715846,
0.225090906,
-0.546889782,
-0.6666637063,
-0.204758808,
0.6142069101,
0.641473949,
-0.3022802472,
-0.1281850189,
0.0366722718,
0.7976946235,
-0.6449599266,
0.4532871842,
-0.6386022568,
-0.0426859707,
0.0665714145,
-0.5452981591,
-0.3827733994,
-0.0894358754,
-0.0777304992,
-0.7353999615,
-0.0985709801,
0.3977881074,
0.6024984121,
0.8199371099,
-0.2673374414,
-0.3765718341,
-0.7905147672,
0.6595998406,
-0.7756689191,
0.2522795796,
0.5935165286,
0.3901211321,
-0.0002288818,
-0.4422932565,
-0.7122291327,
-0.2747891545,
0.3185139596,
0.2506183982,
-0.2803596258,
0.3646743298,
0.1284238845,
0.6237001419,
-0.2608326674,
0.3174268305,
-0.2705766857,
-0.1971848607,
0.8569695354,
-0.0200332142,
0.2507815957,
0.2100787312,
-0.0912694931,
-0.4107381105,
-0.5491232276,
-0.1399011761,
0.425640136,
0.1584436446,
-0.2112171352,
0.4011842608,
-0.1483688056,
0.3960398138,
0.2635625601,
-0.0229748879,
0.4363232255,
-0.2599957883,
0.156702444,
0.4800679088,
0.6227095127,
0.3720306754,
0.2999564409,
-0.1097645909,
-0.3643348813,
-0.0034547017,
0.2997435331,
-0.3681114614,
-0.2199917585,
0.3498739004,
-0.3924570978,
-0.2391188145,
0.1709923595,
-0.4825458229,
-0.3822372258,
-0.628182888,
0.6367701292,
-0.1548342854,
0.1261960715,
0.3033969104,
-0.1180474088,
0.2020976543,
0.360165447,
-0.9181424379,
0.5267170668,
0.3237285316,
0.8418026567,
-0.4844611883,
0.0386668183,
-0.8899909854,
0.3403382003,
-0.3695625961,
0.8307698369,
-0.4527151585,
-0.3858434558,
0.0615206361,
-0.2323376238,
0.1080981493,
-0.6114377975,
0.5571749806,
-0.6130103469,
-0.1569404155,
0.1099581048,
-0.5824600458,
-0.0925715566,
-0.1727796942,
-0.9939157963,
0.4840479493,
-0.1192589328,
-0.3509314358,
0.2329298705,
-0.9119696021,
-0.6129969358,
-0.0647493079,
0.0465556905,
-0.3448159993,
0.0963646993,
0.8173119426,
0.290359199,
-0.1419603825,
-0.029268723,
0.0183281954,
-0.5025612116,
0.2557890415,
-0.630153954,
0.4259394407,
0.2649674714,
-0.3246320784,
0.215463385,
-0.7544802427,
-0.3243941665,
-0.0362486728,
-0.5365288854,
-0.050191395,
0.0381373242,
0.0763366297,
-0.2666181922,
0.056099955,
-0.3559446037,
0.0099178916,
-0.584530592,
0.5907327533,
0.6215180755,
0.0828434452,
0.6967158318,
-0.3289493322,
0.6223852038,
-0.1140095964,
-0.0202497989,
-0.2857876122,
-0.2246456891,
-0.6310821176,
-0.3601351082,
0.4682049751,
0.5702040195,
-0.7370698452,
0.8576998115,
-0.2630663514,
-0.3206963241,
-0.6855461001,
-0.0091230599,
0.2026999742,
0.1491485536,
0.5504636765,
-0.6389232278,
-0.4293415546,
-0.6542496085,
0.1441272944,
-0.1844501346,
-0.2381657213,
0.2268633395,
0.161761716,
-0.1245225295,
0.7470321655,
-0.3672799468,
-0.6430472136,
-0.2797100246,
0.1756153405,
0.2352627963,
0.5268612504,
0.3951640427,
-0.7845798135,
-0.4235652983,
-0.2160619497,
-0.316790849,
-0.3274106085,
-0.2697515786,
0.0720942318,
0.3111853004,
0.8007522821,
-0.6240787506,
0.3068906665,
0.6153357029,
0.0645163283,
0.6173231006,
-0.2689686418,
0.489130497,
-0.8122742176,
-0.1779996008,
-0.2279908508,
-0.3156928122,
-0.3405834734,
-0.1128852218,
-0.2459406257,
-0.0001702433,
-0.3334229887,
0.2668871582,
-0.5962725878,
-0.1890867054,
-0.6208874583,
0.22807917,
0.0107517121,
0.3884328902,
0.1986706406,
0.8573684096,
0.6903890371,
-0.3918876946,
0.444345355,
0.3465173244,
-0.3887384236,
0.2613251507,
-0.4986365438,
0.3507241905,
-0.0735531822,
0.5688218474,
-1.0543262959,
-0.1600306034,
-0.0349581353,
-0.4854491651,
0.5518921614,
0.0295680016,
-0.5825102329,
-0.155040279,
-0.2263552845,
0.4787150025,
0.5825187564,
-0.7461082339,
0.7409383655,
0.3512329459,
-0.2982642651,
-0.2123971432,
-0.5068197846,
0.4140768647,
-0.3436793983,
-0.2648722231,
0.5043732524,
-0.2613496184,
-0.2108535767,
-0.3403551877,
-0.3666979373,
-0.0935455933,
-0.0190786272,
0.0862044767,
0.2034874558,
-0.184994176,
0.1346283406,
0.2479429245,
-0.1180321425,
0.1488632411,
-0.2420884669,
0.5698574185,
-0.1219062284,
-0.3253385425,
-0.7503268719,
0.426545471,
0.5130239725,
-0.3892889619,
0.5053034425,
0.3255448937,
-0.1549508721,
-0.0762094334,
-0.4967668355,
-0.3316108882,
-0.5017431378,
0.4596604705,
-0.1910072863,
-0.8441959023,
0.4371478856,
-0.0319337957,
-0.0713831559,
0.3226670325,
0.2856306732,
-0.3667964041,
1.2153834105,
0.4520449936,
-0.3295432031,
0.4680138528,
-0.1793044358,
0.0189579148,
-0.6490648985,
0.0710783973,
-0.6088328958,
-0.1218869314,
-0.402172178,
-0.4154492319,
0.3907093704,
0.05912273,
-0.0838474259,
0.3308056593,
-0.4437315464,
0.5184392333,
0.4531723261,
0.049356468,
0.4854342639,
0.1307041198,
0.2374300808,
0.2241156995,
-0.6084532738,
-0.5970993638,
1.241465807,
0.6338019967,
0.6956331134,
0.1894522756,
0.702134192,
0.6087132096,
-0.1251179427,
-0.8364195228,
0.3018741012,
-0.2034604549,
-0.3726732135,
-0.5020294189,
-0.1794998199,
-0.7280157804,
0.0722305328,
-0.3664479554,
-0.5067775846,
0.1440976411,
0.3349838555,
-0.4673211277,
-0.0116888732,
-0.5708912015,
0.4158148766,
-0.3743217885,
-0.073114574,
-0.4507332444,
-0.7316995859,
-0.1657260358,
-0.2160988301,
0.5152379274,
0.1808736771,
-0.2168725282,
0.7341557741,
-0.3037479818,
0.5526633263,
-0.2432543486,
-0.3544223607,
0.347666204,
-0.1865336597,
0.6624677181,
-0.0261412505,
0.0027322806,
0.309068054,
0.0652252808,
-0.2270250171,
-0.4891213775,
0.2704329789,
-0.747548461,
-0.7142054439,
-0.2439058721,
-0.5848240256,
-0.4268940687,
-0.0128227295,
0.0301578548,
0.4687789083,
0.089853704,
0.3946683109,
0.6213449836,
-0.2970712781,
0.6883665323,
0.2506765425,
0.243013218,
-0.6097967029,
0.6093419194,
-0.3222380579,
0.4435743988,
0.5701293349,
0.1044508591,
-0.4089946449,
-1.0602344275,
-0.5417196155,
0.0325606316,
-0.8728423119,
-0.2404589802,
-0.4123465717,
-0.0909569189,
-0.4727114439,
-0.0992912427,
-0.5352663994,
-0.4322653711,
-0.480694741,
-0.2209818512,
0.3952133358,
0.3561729789,
-0.1790486872,
0.6929987073,
-0.9639130235,
0.5397239923,
0.1895491928,
0.0983305573,
-0.0172915068,
-0.8496661782,
-0.3426887095,
-0.044821728,
-0.0258816872,
-0.7267143726,
0.3733271062,
0.5035473704,
0.5612342358,
0.4478684366,
0.2255445272,
0.5659438968,
-0.7305904031,
0.7167419195,
0.319242686,
-0.9325936437,
0.4310331643,
-0.3313947618,
0.4921523333,
0.6398717165,
0.2257935554,
0.0498490632,
-0.4550314844,
-0.2908708751,
-1.0431470871,
0.4306528568,
0.349386096,
0.3015574813,
0.0335871615,
0.2801825404,
0.0614116937,
0.1314760596,
-0.6775678992,
-0.1371233463,
-0.3263882399,
-0.4992724657,
-0.2126328498,
-0.1282825023,
-0.0110417968,
-0.2893199623,
0.7266576886,
-0.2391617447,
0.085554041,
0.2750788629,
-0.1604463309,
-0.076616399,
0.3352635801,
0.4498102665,
0.3332383931,
-0.0929498002,
0.0398962833,
0.2968102098,
-0.647103548,
0.2009039372,
0.2557707429,
0.3525405228,
-0.1587105244,
0.7526875734,
0.7968763113,
-0.0427770652,
-0.8120761514,
0.3474395871,
0.0166459195,
-0.2169536799,
-0.5879633427,
0.1427372396,
-0.0862811357,
0.1573702246,
0.8364363909,
-0.0332976691,
0.5135487318,
-0.5144973993,
0.1374483109,
0.19330962,
-0.2920535505,
0.0371745266,
0.7271324396,
0.477899164,
-0.1574189663,
0.2369892299,
-0.015932491,
-0.3547550738,
0.6350653172,
0.4002678394,
0.7983879447,
-0.1992118508,
-0.2841015458,
0.3927485645,
0.3118262887,
-0.0273305401,
-0.0263246484,
-0.4619901478,
-0.5018207431,
-0.6736117005,
-0.768982172,
-0.3832290769,
-0.0576016866,
-0.711673677,
0.2074709237,
-0.1838206798,
-0.0184310898,
-0.0833328888,
-0.0443100668,
-0.4031836987,
0.2967883348,
0.3249685466,
0.7611928582,
-0.8564473391,
0.716765523,
0.4703502953,
-0.4176196456,
-0.9299826026,
0.0178194493,
-0.1521013528,
-0.37126863,
0.3073334098,
0.0492601655,
-0.3389684558,
0.1927428693,
-0.6552860737,
-0.9599320889,
1.0422409773,
0.136426717,
-1.2077733278,
0.125294432,
0.3108896613,
0.5346836448,
-0.6805509329,
-0.0343584865,
0.65258497,
0.4555158913,
0.0906832442,
-1.1823689938,
-0.2029984295,
-0.1286497861,
-0.1661939323,
-0.3086114824,
-0.1417567134,
0.2329479754,
-0.183099702,
-0.0256571397,
0.17796278,
0.7526227236,
0.402967453,
0.2342582941,
0.888386786,
0.275036484,
0.47729972,
0.0594444051,
1.0638725758,
-0.1466069221,
-0.2106417418,
1.1770262718,
-0.2118013948,
0.8758794069,
0.6697192192,
-0.2290575951,
0.4361554682,
0.661041379,
-0.0454002693,
0.8288630247,
0.3064909279,
-0.2241194993,
-0.3860361576,
0.0248555187,
-0.12934497,
0.7643659115,
0.1539395899,
-0.3655984104,
0.3290368021,
0.4304466248,
-0.2942730188,
0.4432810545,
-0.5237447023,
1.0995448828,
0.2469082326,
-0.4265662134,
0.5335938931,
-0.1540081054,
0.6854024529,
-0.2858299911,
-0.2076207697,
-0.1159221828,
-0.0462431833,
-0.2200616449,
-0.4215646386,
0.1505043954,
0.1169726253,
-0.1970715672,
0.0073357201,
0.3899106979,
-0.4225373268,
-0.3379557431,
0.2448210567,
0.0367325433,
0.4696741402,
-0.2109710276,
-0.3193685114,
0.3510991633,
-0.1866018027,
0.0358588323,
-0.003089183,
0.1563217342,
-0.0276187658,
0.4898308218,
0.686442256,
0.3634326458,
-0.117260918,
0.646700561,
0.6504475474,
-0.3874617219,
-0.6826238036,
-0.6275677085,
0.4441369772,
-0.0116159255,
0.2269706726,
0.5070202947,
0.5823429227,
0.6081052423,
-0.2635498941,
0.7307586074,
0.1875784397,
0.3212657571,
-0.815479517,
0.9198638797,
-0.5380394459,
0.6091858745,
-0.3922737837,
-1.2863820791,
-0.3456317186,
0.505591929,
-0.0606332347,
0.1058986858,
0.6250884533,
0.6516017914,
0.2283359766,
-0.0459514149,
0.1642913222,
0.0132794958,
0.3849259317,
0.4480895996,
0.800519228,
-0.5437015891,
0.7824835777,
-0.1456812769,
-0.2080104351,
0.0339065529,
-0.904954493,
-0.7932117581,
-0.5630005598,
-0.7071768045,
0.0342260376,
0.1432067752,
0.8811852932,
0.680464983,
-0.9237543941,
-0.1141854376,
-0.1709571034,
-0.1865341365,
-0.2262084633,
-0.1482250243,
0.5172219276,
-0.2024979442,
-0.8767185211,
0.6453469992,
0.1224590912,
0.1799462736,
-0.0721162036,
-0.438870579,
0.0248964075,
0.2000379562,
0.553306222,
0.0043787202,
-0.6685053706,
-0.5414476395,
-0.280846864,
0.2373914421,
0.2672803104,
0.2839416564,
-0.4896928668,
0.3980674148,
0.1611446887,
0.4472240806,
0.5496379137,
0.1689300537,
0.6956168413,
-0.5761223435,
0.0440525264,
0.4200244844,
0.3117140532,
0.4588788152,
-0.1334778816,
0.3292567432,
-0.2376262397,
-0.5491459966,
-0.7277169824,
-0.162672475,
-1.2692037821,
-0.2582193911,
1.3257702589,
0.1183968037,
-0.0995754823,
-0.1749636382,
-0.4572194219,
0.4180369675,
-0.533972919,
0.902670145,
0.5507178307,
-0.047246851,
-0.3365824223,
-0.5624284744,
0.5490012169,
0.3102127016,
-0.7960237861,
0.0477810092,
0.7218472362,
0.0169539601,
0.1948988885,
0.4627563059,
-0.3937901556,
0.572129488,
0.0454881117,
0.1798598319,
-0.251221925,
-0.3466686904,
-0.6352046132,
-0.0062073814,
0.3223655522,
-0.4295618832
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13269v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13269v1 | Investigating Low-Cost LLM Annotation for~Spoken Dialogue Understanding Datasets | 2024-06-19T06:59:57 | 2024-06-19T06:59:57 | Lucas Druart, Valentin Vielzeuf, Yannick Estève | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC, eess.SP | In spoken Task-Oriented Dialogue (TOD) systems, the choice of the semantic
representation describing the users' requests is key to a smooth interaction.
Indeed, the system uses this representation to reason over a database and its
domain knowledge to choose its next action. The dialogue course thus depends on
the information provided by this semantic representation. While textual
datasets provide fine-grained semantic representations, spoken dialogue
datasets fall behind. This paper provides insights into automatic enhancement
of spoken dialogue datasets' semantic representations. Our contributions are
three fold: (1) assess the relevance of Large Language Model fine-tuning, (2)
evaluate the knowledge captured by the produced annotations and (3) highlight
semi-automatic annotation implications. | [
-0.5234664083,
-0.6129392982,
0.6266495585,
-0.0950148553,
-0.2297635525,
-0.1341430098,
-0.2147417963,
-0.6312983632,
0.0045911763,
1.0264697075,
-0.8411467671,
-0.5305691957,
-0.3812724352,
0.2011485398,
-0.2766872048,
0.9263228178,
0.2042388916,
0.0468546301,
-0.1037785485,
-0.1750823557,
-0.5704707503,
-0.3531332016,
-0.6912332773,
-0.6241554618,
0.5056251287,
0.4939492047,
0.7580423951,
0.6847795844,
0.3301211894,
0.2392368466,
-0.0152855115,
0.3040326834,
-0.5718830824,
0.2915811837,
0.0298162382,
-0.6487600803,
-0.4839420319,
0.0122104511,
0.431340903,
0.9793508053,
0.2060470879,
0.0704028979,
0.0289827771,
0.4962058067,
-0.2534196377,
0.4552879632,
-0.7019639611,
-0.0094957352,
-0.20637995,
-0.1940198094,
-0.4361444116,
0.0118443249,
0.4197881222,
-0.7216905355,
-0.0965318084,
0.1824196428,
0.6281688213,
0.7453091145,
-0.3514822721,
-0.2288747728,
-0.7045567036,
0.8391337395,
-0.6748034358,
0.1664189696,
0.6290581822,
0.2761588097,
-0.4449641705,
-0.302444458,
-0.4985808432,
-0.253883034,
-0.2518025637,
-0.0966814905,
-0.1117313281,
0.6109020114,
0.5455434918,
0.4424113333,
-0.1254716218,
0.4208714962,
-0.0800025389,
-0.4504312277,
0.619725287,
0.3927545547,
0.0685169846,
-0.4584423602,
-0.1643681973,
0.1365297586,
-0.7729430795,
-0.2710122466,
0.0150854886,
0.494469732,
-0.2398016155,
0.8471660018,
-0.5495322943,
1.1202290058,
-0.1171877906,
-0.083942309,
0.0539429449,
-0.6044027209,
-0.4873501956,
0.1280602217,
0.630163312,
0.5704017878,
0.6198967695,
-0.1382905245,
-0.1782974899,
-0.2635480165,
-0.056447126,
-0.5299153924,
-0.1317504942,
0.2295078784,
-0.208231926,
-0.0865777135,
-0.3326515257,
-0.3860504925,
-0.5914344788,
-0.8136737347,
0.205623582,
-0.277583003,
0.2141465843,
0.1216148734,
-0.0851625875,
0.0477257222,
0.8558132052,
-0.8208298683,
0.1442929506,
0.6346795559,
0.791677773,
0.0389475189,
0.1508800536,
-0.5144809484,
0.2516854703,
-0.2222743332,
0.9415826797,
-0.5711806417,
-0.558815062,
-0.0443084352,
0.0038739985,
0.089364782,
-0.5855998397,
0.5096633434,
-0.1972681284,
0.0407421067,
-0.1289312094,
-0.6887822151,
-0.3322342336,
-0.0052239853,
-0.6660270095,
0.8979851604,
0.1679202467,
-0.5483266115,
0.5039108396,
-0.7768747211,
-0.033443518,
-0.0125244651,
-0.026868701,
0.0746845603,
0.1858793795,
0.4763681889,
0.6859757304,
-0.3240483403,
0.1437384039,
-0.2942381799,
-0.3015737236,
0.3400481045,
-0.5487203598,
0.4829259515,
0.1486085802,
-0.1595522165,
0.0485075451,
-0.9115074873,
-0.1429208368,
-0.1332590878,
-0.3099090755,
-0.4551199675,
-0.1136967242,
-0.1739939451,
-0.0072180983,
0.1837419271,
-0.4543711245,
0.1727336943,
-0.8297266364,
0.2350138873,
0.6921781898,
0.1430742443,
0.410310179,
-0.2736780345,
0.1233650073,
0.1160128638,
-0.0344732031,
-0.3132113814,
-0.5210228562,
-1.0436146259,
-0.4452321529,
0.4224681854,
0.453663379,
-0.814225316,
0.1836654842,
-0.2900001407,
-0.2184740305,
-0.7654455304,
0.3080805242,
0.2952232063,
0.3364034891,
0.2192455232,
-0.1712852269,
-0.5674803257,
-1.0760897398,
-0.1187669411,
-0.2695557177,
-0.2522056699,
0.5609903932,
0.2086384743,
-0.3099478781,
1.320649147,
-0.2694376707,
-0.3273242414,
-0.4147944152,
0.3526942432,
0.1775535047,
0.2519468963,
0.315944463,
-0.5251652598,
-0.2915426493,
0.036799103,
-0.5173441768,
-0.4070630372,
-0.203287676,
-0.0507919565,
0.2573856115,
0.2494401634,
-0.4313929081,
0.6222167611,
0.3724828064,
-0.0215505846,
0.2607263029,
-0.1593796313,
0.156860739,
-0.7317631841,
-0.2454162687,
0.0720504001,
-0.5665709972,
-0.7985092402,
-0.5822012424,
-0.3902732432,
-0.1713688225,
-0.3583316207,
0.5924426913,
-0.2070692629,
-0.3077290654,
-0.254535526,
0.7183634639,
-0.0531070195,
0.6532549262,
0.1524332911,
0.9447082877,
0.3999631107,
-0.6722211838,
0.383764863,
0.4303682745,
-0.3284584284,
0.4939348698,
-0.530200541,
0.3098779619,
0.0375273079,
0.2310813069,
-0.9333883524,
-0.2992610931,
0.3252183497,
-0.2170775533,
0.0154839987,
-0.5986013412,
-0.580111146,
0.0867933258,
-0.0186258741,
-0.0165709797,
0.0933404192,
-0.5531255007,
0.4878568351,
0.5146849155,
-0.3106109202,
-0.1840597242,
-0.643630147,
0.1868764013,
-0.1481844485,
-0.5642113686,
-0.0235374048,
0.2254765481,
-0.5955859423,
-0.2805880606,
0.0010514013,
0.2189175785,
0.2912663817,
0.502854228,
0.1593519896,
-0.2024030536,
0.2860860229,
0.0423875861,
-0.4425356388,
-0.1360066533,
-0.3567274511,
0.5074287057,
0.0594382808,
-0.4676921368,
-0.8026177883,
0.3081014454,
0.3943382204,
0.0223857854,
0.4449889362,
0.4273257256,
-0.1901995391,
0.013235826,
-0.4716615081,
-0.084219709,
-0.4245814085,
0.213804841,
-0.4095799327,
-1.0167046785,
0.4770705402,
-0.2436152399,
0.1247744784,
0.5755732656,
0.4907688797,
-0.3978351057,
1.0057169199,
0.2415121794,
-0.1595319659,
0.4751311541,
-0.1915215254,
0.1007621139,
-0.8466361761,
-0.1570759863,
-0.6479424238,
-0.2167685181,
-0.6807635427,
-0.6609711647,
0.2397715598,
-0.1333604008,
0.0398835577,
0.1997591108,
-0.1996833235,
0.1773749739,
0.578428328,
0.1160485223,
0.4772670269,
0.0043515889,
0.1562397778,
-0.0324120149,
-0.5745850801,
-0.7885570526,
0.9153355956,
0.4973844588,
0.9346302748,
0.0219258927,
0.6510392427,
0.5046439171,
-0.185749501,
-1.1022349596,
0.7395504117,
-0.0698484033,
-0.2427063435,
-0.5702785254,
-0.3251214921,
-0.7944716811,
0.016440101,
-0.2247134298,
-0.9625537395,
0.3152413368,
0.2131939977,
-0.3814043105,
-0.1255568713,
-0.7904987931,
0.5745117068,
-0.034234859,
-0.0549628921,
-0.4035807848,
-0.5308517814,
-0.0044815745,
0.1225652546,
-0.0191695597,
-0.36090675,
0.129452318,
0.8632782698,
-0.5302504897,
1.1826726198,
-0.4930325449,
-0.3186271787,
0.2198480517,
0.0967239961,
0.6770605445,
0.1708901078,
-0.1392683089,
0.1413013339,
-0.0881041437,
-0.289124161,
-0.6678478718,
0.4492425025,
-0.4385462701,
-0.9517678618,
-0.0572484918,
-0.6750290394,
-0.5928196907,
-0.1353912055,
-0.3057926893,
0.7127565742,
-0.0860887095,
0.0431702025,
0.7666250467,
-0.0398689434,
0.2349038273,
0.2238967717,
-0.1757262796,
-0.2336088717,
0.6536671519,
0.0092056757,
0.5212635994,
0.3084478974,
-0.0470934659,
-0.2178532034,
-0.7808790207,
-0.5894985795,
0.18099159,
-0.8864712715,
-0.1551731229,
-0.6615149379,
0.0119893709,
-0.1329653859,
0.1133749038,
-0.0520475209,
-0.9041150212,
-0.6597886682,
-0.2774041295,
0.8624538183,
0.7783138156,
0.07496351,
0.6522681117,
-0.7539543509,
0.2686897516,
0.27178666,
0.2229960561,
-0.193438068,
-0.4901396036,
-0.6253165603,
0.3510189056,
-0.0174937043,
-0.4871472716,
0.0990444645,
0.3954518735,
0.4815878272,
0.39845559,
0.0520873591,
0.8675326109,
-0.3640243709,
0.9442472458,
-0.1554591209,
-0.9601003528,
0.9146615863,
-0.3839419782,
0.2668675184,
0.6915107965,
-0.0007355972,
-0.5290477872,
-0.5911855102,
-0.3834145069,
-0.5631908178,
0.9962447286,
0.1662644297,
0.1456989944,
0.207193926,
0.3714272678,
0.2455769777,
-0.0447808132,
-0.2738806903,
-0.180434078,
-0.0951639116,
-0.349658668,
-0.1982045323,
-0.3665302098,
-0.1498824656,
-0.0483959056,
0.5908147097,
-0.3763880134,
0.4442965686,
0.151092127,
-0.3788978457,
0.1576780379,
0.3329308033,
0.6206831336,
0.3364834785,
-0.2247563004,
-0.0730462968,
0.2454111278,
-0.2039887458,
-0.1475012749,
0.1025727987,
0.075165391,
0.207591176,
0.4563401341,
1.3003656864,
0.3584065735,
-0.7342948914,
0.2107355297,
-0.0014474505,
0.1360815763,
-0.1632845104,
0.4104531109,
-0.1497061402,
0.2411445826,
0.1258890629,
-0.1099634245,
0.3129779994,
-0.4882449508,
0.1042603701,
0.4298063219,
-0.5814974904,
-0.1045274138,
0.1471888423,
0.4794264138,
-0.2376765907,
0.4399473667,
0.081740737,
-0.4446100593,
0.1727287024,
0.0959767923,
0.6595832705,
0.250035584,
0.1332937926,
0.0430457778,
0.0441973209,
0.2644428611,
0.0579509102,
-0.4688663781,
-0.5678097606,
-0.4924744368,
-0.4566601217,
-0.7103849053,
-0.2160848975,
-0.4626427293,
0.4042789042,
-0.2349353284,
-0.2619675994,
0.0008279891,
0.1302749068,
-0.8111733794,
0.3156861663,
0.2265481502,
0.9337962866,
-0.5618845224,
0.9764333963,
0.2271032631,
-0.3167770207,
-0.6307299137,
-0.0137539078,
0.0800420418,
-1.0789016485,
0.9379833937,
-0.1112875715,
-0.2340938449,
0.0220958292,
-0.2938643992,
-0.5872086883,
0.8440324068,
0.330352366,
-0.6983978748,
0.0419329628,
0.5542129278,
0.4731933773,
-0.5418281555,
0.3731174767,
0.8952800035,
0.5190656781,
0.0673232675,
-1.1111325026,
-0.1323103309,
0.0695091709,
0.062571235,
0.159809947,
-0.1834000647,
0.1764662862,
0.0088703278,
-0.1865617484,
0.170883432,
0.529874742,
-0.1358887702,
0.4522244036,
0.5825327039,
0.4056505859,
0.7157968283,
-0.5279303789,
1.0685027838,
0.0016442833,
0.1622357368,
1.2316222191,
-0.1576987654,
0.6448402405,
0.6250286698,
-0.1329863071,
0.2305894196,
0.9171417952,
0.1367942244,
0.5350301862,
0.2483788282,
-0.2395788729,
-0.3835784197,
-0.468727529,
0.0747715086,
0.6596913338,
0.7962893248,
-0.3531451821,
-0.1826080978,
0.2464290112,
-0.1464392245,
-0.2344518304,
-0.3224568963,
1.5583204031,
0.1423424333,
-0.347283572,
0.7096648812,
-0.3524252474,
0.3469879329,
-0.3065107465,
-0.0207133517,
-0.2943397462,
-0.3924065828,
-0.2904236019,
-0.7690213919,
0.2114528716,
0.1814326048,
-0.0834246203,
-0.2228209972,
0.7142204046,
-0.356444329,
-0.1794065833,
0.2574948072,
0.3230420053,
0.3501384556,
0.0737479255,
-0.4800437689,
0.100388214,
0.184314847,
-0.1219262928,
0.0471097864,
0.7572404146,
-0.0379050523,
0.7212827802,
0.4749413729,
0.2525296211,
-0.1340165734,
0.6072781086,
0.871669054,
-0.6784924269,
-0.0439434238,
-0.6614781022,
0.6907373667,
-0.2074040025,
-0.0552849732,
0.4430054128,
0.2635143101,
0.6980370283,
0.1604864299,
0.8973155618,
0.1558583677,
0.6264567375,
-0.9464697242,
0.3708598018,
-0.4049994648,
0.5470600724,
-0.0939981416,
-0.7049565911,
-0.3218270838,
0.4443072379,
-0.5904399753,
-0.1730041802,
0.2784803808,
0.9163028598,
0.0214200895,
0.3807131648,
0.4921035171,
0.2733954489,
0.2491323203,
0.2439716905,
0.9740383029,
-0.1800166965,
0.1733720899,
-0.1362659037,
-0.0440662131,
-0.4686024189,
-0.6766380072,
-1.0308747292,
-0.5971399546,
-0.4158494174,
-0.0725231171,
0.0738202706,
1.1326551437,
0.6819901466,
-0.8027257323,
-0.1070215032,
0.1557600647,
0.2025997937,
0.0787868872,
-0.164290756,
0.0939278379,
-0.5023777485,
-0.9199157357,
0.4820558131,
0.5444713831,
0.1873498112,
-0.2816382349,
-0.0691327974,
0.061155431,
0.1578082293,
0.5500209928,
-0.0643259287,
-1.0810879469,
-0.6338027716,
-0.3786477149,
0.0731102228,
0.3412730694,
0.9058969617,
-0.8716484904,
0.5885835886,
0.2445404977,
0.5821854472,
0.5151895285,
-0.1191997677,
0.7911664248,
-0.7289479971,
0.2499122918,
0.239535898,
0.4316956103,
0.4581261873,
-0.3758076727,
0.4042408168,
-0.0104950378,
-0.4220818877,
-0.7046234608,
0.3208128214,
-1.2391351461,
0.2150874883,
1.0047910213,
-0.2214121222,
-0.13542521,
-0.5948165059,
-0.5819293857,
0.1860572696,
-0.5919182301,
0.3914292157,
0.7365353107,
-0.3699373007,
-0.3212424219,
-0.6586079597,
0.7092983723,
0.2865597308,
-0.7459191084,
0.5670596957,
0.6223083735,
-0.2093839198,
0.0542254187,
0.4124031663,
0.1389600337,
0.072364457,
-0.3524825871,
-0.3046387136,
0.0377361402,
-0.0501160324,
-0.3635341525,
-0.2805652916,
0.4363278747,
-0.1789307296
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13261v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13261v2 | BeHonest: Benchmarking Honesty of Large Language Models | 2024-06-19T06:46:59 | 2024-07-01T15:18:07 | Steffi Chern, Zhulin Hu, Yuqing Yang, Ethan Chern, Yuan Guo, Jiahe Jin, Binjie Wang, Pengfei Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Previous works on Large Language Models (LLMs) have mainly focused on
evaluating their helpfulness or harmlessness. However, honesty, another crucial
alignment criterion, has received relatively less attention. Dishonest
behaviors in LLMs, such as spreading misinformation and defrauding users,
eroding user trust, and causing real-world harm, present severe risks that
intensify as these models approach superintelligence levels. Enhancing honesty
in LLMs addresses critical deficiencies and helps uncover latent capabilities
that are not readily expressed. This underscores the urgent need for reliable
methods and benchmarks to effectively ensure and evaluate the honesty of LLMs.
In this paper, we introduce BeHonest, a pioneering benchmark specifically
designed to assess honesty in LLMs comprehensively. BeHonest evaluates three
essential aspects of honesty: awareness of knowledge boundaries, avoidance of
deceit, and consistency in responses. Building on this foundation, we designed
10 scenarios to evaluate and analyze 9 popular LLMs on the market, including
both closed-source and open-source models from different model families with
varied model sizes. Our findings indicate that there is still significant room
for improvement in the honesty of LLMs. We also encourage the AI community to
prioritize honesty alignment in LLMs. Our benchmark and code can be found at:
\url{https://github.com/GAIR-NLP/BeHonest}. | [
0.1307324916,
-0.5545740724,
0.5620586276,
0.3467524052,
-0.1223295107,
0.1633704454,
-0.4884386063,
-0.5650759339,
-0.2859150171,
0.4412038326,
-0.5010533929,
-0.5729340911,
-0.7178253531,
-0.1430512518,
-0.4470469356,
0.8613021374,
-0.0025016356,
0.1738430262,
-0.2135926336,
-0.3456841409,
-0.2627547681,
-0.3962186873,
-0.602257669,
-0.5336076617,
0.3031457067,
0.2134800702,
0.7869169712,
0.611587584,
0.7648459077,
0.3193506598,
-0.1788409352,
0.072102271,
-0.6437960863,
0.5719162822,
-0.4050244391,
-0.4800727069,
-0.543674171,
0.2317851186,
0.287933737,
0.6804952025,
-0.3138714433,
0.4096487164,
0.3336392045,
0.5058258772,
-0.7550799251,
0.1072873175,
-0.6755617857,
-0.3380012512,
-0.262991637,
0.1488921493,
-0.2969046235,
-0.9494034648,
0.3241069019,
-0.3310954571,
-0.329079181,
0.1867649257,
0.8949586749,
0.4199397564,
-0.197033003,
-0.3941853344,
-0.5705915093,
1.0759826899,
-1.0129879713,
0.5296518803,
0.1965724677,
0.5182276368,
-0.217782855,
-0.6612016559,
-0.5134986043,
-0.2787410617,
0.1350794584,
0.0145510081,
-0.3055498302,
-0.1396082789,
0.2892077863,
0.4902336895,
-0.6650553346,
0.2367524058,
0.1643647254,
-0.470702827,
0.6838027835,
-0.044996392,
0.1276151538,
0.1663175821,
-0.6056813002,
-0.2005639821,
-0.7930714488,
-0.039645981,
0.773304522,
-0.002769632,
-0.26876387,
0.6898536086,
-0.2255887687,
0.3642484546,
-0.1844363213,
-0.1660017073,
0.2806194723,
-0.5722414255,
-0.1198013499,
0.1644290537,
0.8289524317,
0.5401593447,
0.6174681187,
-0.1197138354,
-0.4682169855,
0.2847004533,
0.2290934473,
-0.7604233623,
-0.0282647703,
0.2427603751,
-0.5416578054,
-0.4413462579,
0.0236008819,
-0.5810192227,
-0.4592957795,
-0.2373913825,
0.4047135115,
-0.7160910964,
-0.165479362,
0.056668479,
0.0711247921,
0.3901391923,
0.3326087594,
-0.6547856927,
0.5533154607,
1.124745965,
0.6854922771,
-0.1142678186,
-0.3942503631,
-0.691547811,
0.0678045824,
-0.4666637182,
0.4537107646,
-0.509493053,
-0.2110387087,
0.0595461689,
-0.2771497369,
0.4296486676,
-0.5391324759,
0.9880689979,
-0.2369949967,
0.0253357477,
-0.2589888275,
-0.8909068108,
-0.2037798911,
0.624530077,
-0.2385870963,
1.0334341526,
0.1369452029,
-0.5375496149,
0.1006542072,
-0.4846814573,
-0.2209990919,
-0.0105153862,
-0.3294377923,
-0.4191144407,
0.3102126122,
0.1148445457,
0.2737382054,
-0.4874877036,
0.4402353764,
-0.3396324217,
-0.3414796591,
0.7025535703,
-0.740490675,
0.9543090463,
0.0446556099,
-0.4272259772,
0.0795559362,
-0.4081805646,
0.2470088005,
-0.0614156909,
-0.0503535829,
-0.3116700649,
-0.1650159657,
-0.1006690711,
0.012785512,
0.6220563054,
-0.8128862381,
-0.0975237414,
-0.5134838223,
0.2302482426,
1.0698930025,
-0.2679826617,
0.1282464862,
-0.5670899153,
0.2800648808,
-0.0844725445,
0.5021657944,
-0.0827287212,
-0.0730960742,
-0.612580955,
-0.1444816291,
0.6727921963,
0.3511342108,
-0.3371890187,
0.6665192842,
-0.6809362173,
-0.6531325579,
-0.6664370894,
0.1012324467,
0.7520318627,
0.3587236702,
0.1192949936,
-0.4386616945,
-0.2121328115,
-1.1767066717,
-0.6504852176,
-0.3055704236,
-0.1313897222,
0.5068581104,
0.3908047974,
0.0244504623,
0.7509979606,
-0.2828916013,
-0.2655044198,
0.0251428243,
-0.0189265162,
0.2409997433,
0.5771864057,
0.2947292924,
-0.6591794491,
-0.473243922,
0.0460003056,
-0.8910357952,
-0.2557567358,
0.2512935698,
0.0598584451,
0.2574281096,
0.5504894257,
-0.656167388,
0.329711169,
0.9860265255,
-0.2220212966,
0.7589594126,
-0.1173528433,
0.0200524982,
-0.9076542854,
0.2058383971,
-0.2837617695,
-0.4729425609,
-0.3461479545,
0.1850567162,
0.0481586382,
0.1695228964,
-0.4163980782,
0.6270750165,
-0.442109406,
-0.3626152575,
0.0220276248,
0.334818989,
-0.0088960826,
0.1927643269,
-0.4859869182,
0.7961854935,
0.5613172054,
-0.2566790581,
0.5099362731,
0.2465709299,
-0.5434324741,
0.9203519821,
-0.8517163992,
0.369440645,
0.4116832316,
0.1290517747,
-0.857407093,
-0.0233020373,
0.1277104169,
-0.6771522164,
0.1718343496,
-0.262303412,
-0.7416196465,
0.0890129879,
-0.4784526229,
0.1896431297,
0.4578194618,
-0.5901934505,
0.6167368293,
0.200702399,
-0.3918320537,
-0.8093711734,
-0.6268668175,
0.1429723352,
0.0568013489,
-0.6590232849,
0.3242658973,
-0.2959733307,
-0.5251957774,
0.007192709,
-0.3947925866,
0.1535711884,
0.199168101,
0.319016397,
0.3596202433,
-0.2972311378,
-0.1432314962,
-0.0943674892,
-0.3556908965,
0.0890757963,
-0.4282041788,
0.6910023093,
-0.2754282653,
-0.5522421598,
-0.4417565167,
0.010615008,
0.6215516925,
-0.2867096364,
0.6144772172,
0.2533727884,
-0.349500984,
-0.1771782041,
-0.8868833184,
-0.3064618707,
-0.5216885805,
0.0564474016,
-0.1247290447,
-0.9463285208,
0.4388733506,
-0.3414495885,
0.3246850967,
-0.1460443586,
0.396535933,
0.0724014193,
0.6867980957,
0.6095528603,
-0.3409428895,
-0.0590424091,
0.3133736849,
0.3558469415,
-0.8030724525,
-0.0429241583,
-0.6797738075,
-0.4180165529,
-0.8018046021,
-0.3525009453,
0.2273287624,
0.0301488377,
-0.2967946827,
-0.0220727567,
-0.2775272131,
0.6804144979,
0.4528169632,
-0.0810544118,
0.4499519765,
-0.3138785958,
-0.1278015226,
-0.120787397,
-0.226342231,
-0.7997740507,
1.2244048119,
0.580698967,
0.8443149924,
0.5788937807,
0.594184339,
0.0314884074,
0.3207413554,
-0.6207389235,
0.6792708635,
-0.2344768643,
-0.5642754436,
-0.5269902945,
-0.3567880988,
-0.6203886867,
-0.0508345552,
-0.1003384665,
-0.7810582519,
0.0451888666,
0.1225685924,
-0.1655455828,
0.007048781,
-0.3658705354,
0.7659802437,
-0.2836690545,
-0.366020292,
-0.0497146994,
-0.645154953,
0.3948175907,
-0.1732189655,
-0.0017444042,
-0.3488109708,
-0.1962340623,
0.3817801476,
-0.3366914093,
0.6441999078,
0.058359541,
-0.0619579218,
-0.2108515501,
0.4249230325,
0.9268619418,
0.0238043331,
-0.4169895053,
0.529479146,
-0.0235843975,
-0.3402909935,
-0.6206758022,
0.8413076997,
-0.6155109406,
-0.3287585974,
-0.2472748756,
-0.4940106869,
-0.3000755906,
0.4497028589,
0.2547221482,
0.3733970225,
-0.5229535699,
0.3856969476,
0.9181792736,
-0.2035764754,
0.4266840518,
0.5947342515,
-0.5167869925,
-0.0273539927,
0.7204632759,
-0.0741159394,
0.3543638587,
0.0419468209,
0.267364502,
-0.5198819041,
-0.75863415,
-0.1838196963,
0.1392201483,
-0.5466859341,
-0.3964402378,
-0.3596114218,
-0.3509073257,
-0.48533988,
-0.0346122161,
-0.8260958195,
-0.2291871607,
0.331962347,
-0.0434230715,
0.2040083855,
0.4771273732,
-0.0478212126,
0.3820823431,
-0.5536940694,
-0.0225692112,
0.1883744299,
0.6654379368,
-0.3034208715,
-0.4393466115,
0.1669293195,
0.0116724716,
-0.1891790181,
-0.4367843866,
0.1289714724,
0.030750405,
0.6344465613,
0.3923899531,
0.2238796353,
0.2341685146,
-0.4166359901,
0.6683776975,
0.0790043026,
-1.3104954958,
0.3299840987,
-0.3561654985,
0.0243253931,
0.905202508,
0.2047474831,
-0.6484587789,
-0.4752153754,
-0.7370193601,
-0.6324750185,
0.467484951,
0.3717775941,
0.1527456045,
0.3843148947,
0.2752766907,
0.4257357717,
0.5417129397,
-0.6767085791,
-0.3674449325,
-0.0062580258,
-0.3896493912,
-0.2067542076,
-0.3631164134,
-0.2445678264,
0.3266025484,
0.6797059178,
-0.0506428853,
-0.1017542705,
-0.0963019356,
-0.2204621583,
0.1503345668,
0.4147744477,
0.4272178411,
0.7747781873,
-0.1104289964,
0.3875353634,
0.0860583037,
-0.4373718798,
0.0776392296,
0.1368608326,
-0.1393427849,
-0.0269270185,
0.3544859588,
0.3796292245,
0.2328690588,
-0.6737514138,
0.9652259946,
-0.1012666598,
-0.2032697946,
-0.5140131116,
0.1561761945,
0.2175813615,
0.2638666332,
-0.0425854549,
-0.0947277918,
-0.0052941651,
-0.4994934797,
0.14329198,
0.544527173,
-0.5989527106,
-0.2149467468,
0.2501571774,
0.1973537207,
-0.5012527704,
0.842244029,
-0.1700847745,
-0.5836690664,
0.1235471591,
0.3085157275,
0.7885785699,
-0.5943032503,
0.0899167955,
-0.097514309,
0.6598234177,
-0.1692856699,
0.3413720429,
0.2055599689,
-0.915943265,
-0.4178243876,
-0.6012794971,
-0.6893106103,
0.1613852084,
-0.6061781049,
0.1392300278,
-0.5686805248,
0.0646660775,
-0.0440820642,
0.2058635652,
-0.4648220539,
-0.039741151,
-0.0441169739,
1.1044363976,
-0.5017598867,
0.7356633544,
0.3783851862,
0.0019692348,
-0.7864651084,
0.1712129265,
0.2829083204,
-0.8595741391,
0.4359850585,
0.2296051383,
-0.3270764649,
0.0131090414,
-0.9025571942,
-0.6420586109,
0.9604631662,
0.6883238554,
-0.8436840177,
0.401673466,
0.2456827015,
0.4157985449,
-0.4042545557,
0.2811739445,
0.6151940227,
0.6332624555,
-0.2616151571,
-1.0785838366,
0.1337830275,
-0.0682255626,
-0.0621399134,
0.053341303,
-0.7266862392,
0.7822500467,
0.0787697732,
-0.1144545674,
0.2237686515,
0.490594089,
0.3957235515,
0.3461556733,
0.5519282222,
0.4459189773,
1.0075346231,
-0.2335507721,
0.9203385115,
-0.3144537807,
0.2020749599,
1.3404304981,
-0.6703881621,
0.7916795015,
0.4478396177,
0.0342745855,
0.3832196891,
0.3460039794,
-0.0345920585,
0.2218043357,
0.3700554669,
-0.1331139803,
-0.1913537234,
-0.4714809358,
-0.2601866722,
0.6088296175,
0.226228714,
-0.0852895156,
-0.1892917454,
-0.39153561,
0.3107112646,
0.2279643267,
0.0136465933,
0.5937737823,
0.1691715866,
-0.5245488882,
0.1794398129,
-0.1251171976,
0.6947353482,
-0.6181833744,
0.0800952166,
-0.3583000004,
0.2874210775,
-0.0277251173,
-0.8237961531,
0.0713626295,
-0.0390333124,
0.011662161,
-0.1216046214,
0.5770811439,
-0.3174673915,
-0.2174307406,
0.4404346943,
0.6919440627,
0.3090822399,
-0.1629800498,
-0.8952186704,
0.6029081941,
-0.1080539897,
-0.1055060774,
0.2174671292,
0.5266572833,
0.0760787874,
0.9209315181,
0.8106024861,
0.2457745075,
-0.2810733616,
0.0769669861,
0.7472065687,
-0.4401305616,
-0.3222251534,
-1.0948417187,
0.1273298264,
-0.4300483465,
-0.3847978115,
0.9889266491,
0.8606479168,
0.8177388906,
0.5502628684,
0.7618873119,
0.3870128393,
0.7901746035,
-0.5249521732,
0.7544324398,
-0.223448202,
0.6100298166,
-0.2842231989,
-1.2460871935,
-0.0354356691,
0.4693117142,
-0.285746634,
0.0943823382,
0.6535232067,
0.9857307673,
-0.0780404434,
0.274776876,
0.4457109272,
0.5515742898,
0.2227502316,
0.3321328163,
1.1572098732,
-0.3362647593,
0.4884114563,
-0.2345594466,
-0.3149995804,
-0.2250577211,
-1.0791778564,
-0.6804367304,
-0.1082063615,
-0.3328346014,
-0.3535258174,
0.4026484489,
0.7875861526,
0.65292871,
-0.5176482797,
-0.3119683862,
0.0448194928,
0.2609472573,
-0.2646734416,
-0.1220885664,
0.2390471548,
-0.254835397,
-0.6469147205,
0.3090412021,
0.5849100947,
0.057005059,
-0.4264084399,
-0.1066367626,
0.1617148221,
0.245075196,
0.269495815,
-0.154591918,
-0.5662874579,
-0.5504876375,
0.1025730744,
-0.2852068245,
-0.136336267,
0.6202389598,
-0.3976522684,
0.1344890147,
0.1014304459,
0.574586153,
0.1843274385,
0.0280179381,
0.7024863958,
-0.7427095771,
-0.2043002248,
0.3677493036,
0.1613880396,
0.4878233969,
-0.2268746644,
0.6637743711,
-0.2307520211,
-0.7573575377,
-1.0863908529,
0.134208709,
-0.9224645495,
-0.267822057,
1.0170838833,
-0.4218480587,
-0.2787462175,
-0.3602750599,
0.1256206781,
0.029023679,
-0.3881964087,
0.6426900625,
0.835807085,
0.1566171497,
0.1252940744,
-0.562705934,
0.4719292819,
0.5550961494,
-0.7660248876,
0.6397848725,
0.4207657278,
0.2903439403,
0.1032683253,
0.4808503687,
-0.302010715,
0.1686736494,
-0.0516275875,
-0.0649059117,
-0.0006844854,
-0.0643393248,
-0.2668569684,
-0.1068655998,
0.2806630433,
-0.058892522
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13250v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13250v1 | LangTopo: Aligning Language Descriptions of Graphs with Tokenized Topological Modeling | 2024-06-19T06:20:22 | 2024-06-19T06:20:22 | Zhong Guan, Hongke Zhao, Likang Wu, Ming He, Jianpin Fan | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Recently, large language models (LLMs) have been widely researched in the
field of graph machine learning due to their outstanding abilities in language
comprehension and learning. However, the significant gap between natural
language tasks and topological structure modeling poses a nonnegligible
challenge. Specifically, since natural language descriptions are not sufficient
for LLMs to understand and process graph-structured data, fine-tuned LLMs
perform even worse than some traditional GNN models on graph tasks, lacking
inherent modeling capabilities for graph structures. Existing research overly
emphasizes LLMs' understanding of semantic information captured by external
models, while inadequately exploring graph topological structure modeling,
thereby overlooking the genuine capabilities that LLMs lack. Consequently, in
this paper, we introduce a new framework, LangTopo, which aligns graph
structure modeling with natural language understanding at the token level.
LangTopo quantifies the graph structure modeling capabilities of GNNs and LLMs
by constructing a codebook for the graph modality and performs consistency
maximization. This process aligns the text description of LLM with the
topological modeling of GNN, allowing LLM to learn the ability of GNN to
capture graph structures, enabling LLM to handle graph-structured data
independently. We demonstrate the effectiveness of our proposed method on
multiple datasets. | [
-0.1780125201,
-0.8603224754,
0.3867532611,
-0.3483709693,
-0.2719884813,
0.3285544217,
-0.4398503006,
-0.3961233795,
0.4144662917,
0.7384839058,
-0.2044991404,
-0.844340086,
-0.6503072977,
0.1026749536,
-0.3157559931,
1.0075467825,
-0.1644732356,
-0.0500469282,
-0.3623993397,
-0.0079745641,
-0.3131001592,
-0.3574816883,
-0.6627406478,
-0.3974922001,
0.4398491383,
0.3152539134,
1.0310789347,
0.7509576678,
0.330355227,
0.4358052313,
-0.2306571603,
0.3927552104,
-0.614168942,
-0.2997936904,
0.0676283538,
-0.2321210653,
-0.7071776986,
-0.4702079594,
1.1091811657,
1.1070561409,
-0.0431431569,
-0.1708394587,
0.2154913098,
0.5731693506,
-0.0326850563,
0.4957044423,
-0.9176008701,
-0.0752379075,
0.0281070955,
0.0404168069,
-0.4371598065,
-0.313200295,
-0.1391744316,
-0.9491734505,
0.1264696717,
0.2659105659,
1.0863740444,
0.2519762218,
-0.4199274182,
-0.1564674228,
-0.3294961154,
0.3511213064,
-0.6219007373,
0.3746471107,
0.321680963,
0.4150394499,
-0.3304814696,
-0.5093151927,
-0.5436177254,
-0.0239749365,
-0.5116317868,
-0.2253727019,
0.1020517275,
0.2749551535,
-0.1175504625,
0.5906315446,
-0.7524257302,
0.4443425238,
-0.3628538847,
-0.4209713936,
0.3247250617,
0.0685014948,
0.4704794586,
-0.3199805915,
-0.4608389139,
0.116538249,
-0.6552810073,
-0.0738927051,
0.2175665051,
0.9753076434,
-0.306709826,
0.5985757113,
-0.1023820639,
0.9858509302,
-0.3567988873,
-0.191291526,
0.2191984057,
-0.3726391196,
-0.4052986801,
0.0627665073,
0.7268785238,
0.2642602921,
0.4180876911,
-0.6357989907,
-0.0321759693,
-0.2402867526,
0.1582503468,
-0.7750297189,
-0.0939630345,
0.240812704,
-0.2593863606,
-0.4345259666,
0.07013686,
-0.698400259,
-0.4655396044,
-0.4168299437,
-0.0244012009,
-0.1777404547,
-0.3391789794,
0.1741303355,
0.1782738417,
0.0507683828,
0.2131440341,
-0.7060631514,
0.7202579379,
0.9236556292,
1.077501297,
-0.3541626036,
-0.3787989318,
-0.6577702761,
0.2974779308,
-0.486307472,
0.3206703365,
-0.6107515693,
-0.1798067689,
0.0119799161,
0.3981954753,
-0.2446051091,
-0.1820918471,
0.2708396912,
-0.4035340548,
0.204003647,
-0.0831913427,
-0.6981518269,
-0.1554157287,
0.4743631184,
-0.6128965616,
0.9382001162,
0.3091462255,
-0.971963644,
0.1047130823,
-0.3353221118,
-0.3035616875,
0.1680838317,
-0.4450053871,
-0.4970198274,
-0.1769993454,
0.386005789,
0.3324455023,
-0.0790153891,
0.614490211,
-0.2368922234,
-0.338747859,
0.1173612177,
0.2342371494,
0.7603462338,
0.0436534248,
0.0082888342,
0.4629049003,
-0.3226237893,
-0.0789142251,
0.091225408,
-0.1522379071,
-0.0157541856,
0.0311762821,
-0.026169356,
-0.0255603306,
0.436979264,
-0.4958885014,
0.4618032873,
-0.5986641049,
0.5017666817,
0.8723941445,
-0.4058790207,
0.4055953026,
-0.2597874403,
0.5038214326,
-0.4404068887,
-0.1201177165,
0.0179390442,
-0.3183365762,
-0.5361645818,
-0.5121830702,
0.2724343538,
0.5431281924,
-0.6126360297,
0.5328375101,
-0.8245636821,
-0.2083758861,
0.1011409536,
0.1643056273,
0.3369743824,
0.787828207,
0.2439943105,
-0.2353076786,
-0.4910640717,
-0.6722593904,
0.1170773283,
-0.18224518,
0.1257719845,
0.6628791094,
0.1971599609,
-0.211166203,
0.9886007309,
-0.4695620537,
-0.4569246471,
-0.3859618902,
-0.0846116692,
0.3940000236,
0.3604881763,
0.4328482747,
-0.4719153941,
-0.4156350493,
0.5013187528,
-0.7302846313,
-0.0654428899,
0.1519650519,
-0.2641579807,
0.0849506333,
0.6862068176,
-0.6067137718,
-0.0056978655,
0.5748102069,
-0.2737596631,
0.3509978056,
0.0165276639,
-0.0058966135,
-1.3670963049,
0.2288513184,
-0.3390674889,
-0.5173030496,
-0.538333416,
0.2961647809,
-0.3173725307,
-0.5652957559,
-0.1352379322,
1.0694459677,
-0.514290452,
-0.3344852924,
-0.1837399453,
0.5510287285,
0.1157934815,
0.5893490314,
0.0698829889,
0.5938263535,
0.9652241468,
-0.3389676809,
0.1986937672,
0.3910662532,
-0.0629642531,
0.3211541772,
-0.6998313665,
0.1643301547,
0.0534247085,
0.3447583616,
-1.1006047726,
-0.4663658142,
0.2625301182,
-0.4020349383,
0.5179371834,
-0.7050366998,
-0.7040076852,
-0.4559713602,
-0.1051931381,
0.4374923408,
0.2013480663,
-0.50893116,
0.6757834554,
0.6739808917,
-0.2647947967,
-0.5138152242,
-0.3367742002,
0.2966808975,
-0.3116874993,
-0.5173051357,
0.4394347668,
0.1975630671,
0.0616572425,
-0.1254359931,
-0.2151398212,
-0.2140511572,
0.0781796426,
0.1490224153,
0.3132852912,
-0.1482897997,
0.5248150229,
-0.2931401432,
-0.2407339215,
-0.2097177953,
-0.7407833338,
0.6699652076,
-0.3155827224,
-0.1700383872,
-0.2164430916,
-0.0245384704,
0.4129300714,
-0.2123805732,
0.6192906499,
0.5274326205,
-0.6358882189,
-0.0642557889,
-0.0790658519,
-0.0280205794,
-0.5142955184,
0.3442580998,
-0.332457453,
-1.0529439449,
0.6635909081,
-0.0033936654,
-0.1853817701,
0.2424696535,
0.3074811697,
0.0447325446,
0.6901953816,
0.7546717525,
-0.3980572224,
0.2911285162,
-0.0751699433,
0.5018921494,
-0.5801717043,
-0.0606297702,
-0.5594203472,
-0.1435717642,
-0.6858874559,
-0.4566106498,
0.2574019134,
0.4204414487,
-0.2725421488,
0.3521381915,
-0.7672943473,
0.5273851156,
-0.0170563534,
-0.051702179,
0.2611826956,
0.3984456658,
-0.3669972718,
0.1884657145,
-0.8004125953,
-0.6452585459,
1.0592837334,
0.3546841741,
0.8248921633,
0.0345384702,
0.5858206749,
0.1725696027,
0.0904221088,
-0.6052449942,
0.4994110763,
-0.3318412602,
-0.2188592106,
-0.5055388808,
-0.6538342834,
-1.1106623411,
0.0364581347,
0.1772270352,
-1.1854115725,
-0.2159894407,
0.2615266442,
0.2676358223,
0.5807079673,
-0.281989187,
1.1878020763,
-0.2835244834,
-0.0106591797,
0.0592542402,
-0.4013751745,
0.2664998472,
0.2276497334,
0.6454069018,
-0.2221875191,
0.0400956236,
0.4220875502,
-0.6183057427,
1.0757883787,
0.0507781357,
-0.1304960549,
0.1834172457,
0.3909386098,
0.690564096,
0.1765900701,
0.0238100793,
0.2460733801,
-0.1301030368,
-0.4815940261,
-0.3485614061,
0.7476660013,
-0.6461928487,
-0.3259676397,
-0.0056685465,
-0.7203755379,
-0.2432879061,
0.3285142779,
0.0616427213,
0.6031343341,
-0.1607485563,
-0.1202260777,
0.2689014375,
-0.1148854345,
0.1428221613,
-0.028125694,
-0.6903907657,
-0.5859216452,
1.0934072733,
-0.1877635121,
0.2279269248,
0.6378747821,
0.3101667464,
-0.2888007164,
-0.602602005,
-0.5197699666,
0.3240642846,
-0.8350236416,
-0.3287297487,
-0.5800660253,
-0.2284868211,
-0.2709418833,
-0.3387759328,
-0.3031240404,
-0.5050477386,
0.0534495413,
-0.2056342661,
0.5280231833,
0.6894900799,
0.1733118743,
0.3696065545,
-0.4443262815,
0.2842481434,
0.0917568132,
0.5313171148,
-0.147285834,
-0.1921879947,
-0.4097721577,
0.0416647382,
0.1240665093,
-0.7046977878,
-0.0129077462,
0.2117313296,
0.5887782574,
0.1937026978,
-0.1603073627,
0.5897071362,
-0.4189864099,
0.5548093319,
0.0955654681,
-1.0876260996,
0.5472721457,
-0.6298666,
0.0825485364,
0.4490869045,
0.2072361559,
-0.5316341519,
-0.5730790496,
-0.399895072,
-0.8182008862,
0.4631040394,
0.1941196024,
0.0672206804,
-0.1029169261,
0.2576913834,
0.141189009,
0.2911417186,
-1.2452301979,
0.0668645352,
-0.2790538073,
-0.4947687387,
0.0240542758,
0.1488203257,
-0.5509282351,
-0.0573516376,
0.3546606302,
-0.7864163518,
0.1889672279,
-0.0539352223,
-0.3515268266,
-0.0669469237,
0.120995231,
0.2887886763,
0.9433095455,
-0.0508264638,
0.3607039452,
0.1422580481,
0.0821787864,
-0.2363806665,
0.3416772783,
-0.0857129544,
-0.0631842911,
0.7649883032,
0.6731592417,
0.2711330652,
-0.4957390726,
0.3990189433,
0.2165433764,
-0.0019347832,
0.1160838902,
-0.0582188144,
0.2494552284,
-0.1661660671,
0.0531385429,
-0.3141923249,
-0.1580162644,
-0.4177680016,
0.368108809,
0.6892917752,
-0.4229685962,
-0.1627660543,
0.5653369427,
0.0710414797,
-0.3547083139,
0.6510388851,
-0.3179813623,
-0.7616093159,
0.888792932,
0.5151854157,
0.7096336484,
0.2181113213,
0.3824228048,
0.553032279,
0.257997632,
0.3834852278,
0.040608611,
-0.0422022678,
-0.7869791985,
-0.3942350745,
-0.7561591864,
-0.2901676297,
-0.0450458042,
-0.2710989416,
0.2989713252,
-0.4758473933,
0.0946757123,
-0.3956943452,
-0.0339394324,
-0.4507001936,
0.0256343875,
0.2589453161,
0.6526350379,
-0.886097312,
0.7973226905,
0.4420006871,
-0.2746282816,
-0.7988513112,
-0.145401001,
0.0070787813,
-0.9261440039,
0.4892958701,
0.4262464643,
-0.155108273,
0.087083824,
-0.2144996226,
-1.0220643282,
1.0534389019,
0.4312383235,
-0.3597412109,
-0.0719483122,
0.2707338631,
0.4861761034,
-0.6984704733,
-0.0244457833,
-0.0003513744,
0.4555723369,
0.04653446,
-1.0982968807,
0.2492347807,
-0.1070113257,
-0.1022614911,
0.3585727513,
-0.3523732722,
0.781273663,
-0.1697929651,
-0.4741944373,
0.0835290924,
0.1861885488,
0.2578967214,
-0.1503931582,
0.4748700559,
0.6350842118,
1.0490006208,
-0.2457475215,
1.1866109371,
-0.5212071538,
0.502019763,
1.1915335655,
-0.1523319334,
0.4844301641,
0.2887056172,
-0.2351525575,
0.4557245374,
0.9713827372,
0.1324811578,
0.1662757993,
0.3955413401,
0.2949308753,
-0.1803572923,
-0.2066279203,
-0.4622525275,
0.3810417652,
0.2554289699,
-0.0294864196,
-0.4062875211,
-0.3486226499,
0.0491883159,
0.2189246714,
-0.3062085807,
0.7032858133,
-0.1024400145,
-0.3752981424,
0.8362002969,
-0.1166552976,
0.1270672679,
-0.5388408899,
0.1334091872,
-0.2762140334,
-0.1102950424,
-0.2330491543,
-0.5594153404,
0.4977110624,
-0.195247218,
0.032899864,
-0.2763501406,
0.3830190301,
-0.509986639,
-0.8481505513,
0.5810534358,
0.4074989855,
0.2987994254,
0.2614062428,
-0.7251095772,
0.1096751094,
-0.2297427058,
0.3031181097,
0.1120404303,
0.4079425633,
-0.1528587192,
0.5576218963,
0.4887673259,
0.1169309691,
-0.0555953942,
0.3761710823,
0.9035997391,
-0.4329838157,
-0.6721627712,
-0.785330236,
0.3622733653,
-0.2424698919,
-0.1566841751,
0.4923999012,
0.9219683409,
0.7950920463,
0.2654818594,
0.4349857271,
0.005463602,
0.1897385269,
-0.8895714879,
0.4713759422,
-0.6004006863,
0.2434067577,
-0.2744074464,
-0.9362974763,
-0.3098388612,
0.5207936764,
-0.1354864836,
0.023654677,
0.7272470593,
0.9431081414,
-0.2374136597,
-0.4004504383,
-0.093939729,
0.3182006776,
0.3452675641,
0.4389261305,
0.4202658832,
-0.2047822475,
0.603829205,
0.1076989844,
-0.0513526835,
-0.018242877,
-1.0455551147,
-1.1056545973,
-0.5140563846,
-0.2698167562,
-0.2518800497,
-0.0124749476,
0.4242129922,
0.8782556057,
-0.8237547874,
-0.5546686053,
-0.624186933,
0.7883055806,
-0.0670239106,
-0.3204507828,
0.5854089856,
-0.672274828,
-0.7481162548,
0.3654208481,
0.4003418982,
-0.0090223262,
-0.0665297881,
-0.2605754733,
-0.1034232229,
-0.1611728668,
0.2881835401,
0.1969498098,
-1.025344491,
-0.529684484,
0.0168729704,
-0.247454837,
0.4610597789,
0.8706806898,
-0.5657675862,
0.4529283047,
0.4906451404,
0.8196756244,
0.5524553657,
0.0838419124,
0.7199409604,
-1.0323357582,
0.0686549768,
-0.1679169536,
0.6152447462,
0.7336614728,
-0.506316483,
0.6805953979,
0.1658441126,
-0.3417530656,
-0.9317190647,
0.3886143565,
-1.0686627626,
-0.5308191776,
0.9007536173,
-0.0147145009,
-0.0493302457,
0.0836756229,
-0.0440909863,
0.4141948521,
0.0724293366,
0.5832635164,
0.7235082984,
0.0639194548,
-0.0935526565,
-0.4441018701,
0.4449310005,
0.0377580002,
-0.9374538064,
0.3569619954,
0.3261688352,
0.1685676426,
0.0661402047,
0.691819787,
-0.0201205388,
-0.1396316141,
-0.1955234855,
0.0062375832,
-0.3332537711,
-0.546382308,
-0.0932088941,
0.0392544419,
0.1264657974,
-0.0554181039
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13249v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13249v1 | R^2AG: Incorporating Retrieval Information into Retrieval Augmented Generation | 2024-06-19T06:19:48 | 2024-06-19T06:19:48 | Fuda Ye, Shuangyin Li, Yongqi Zhang, Lei Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR | Retrieval augmented generation (RAG) has been applied in many scenarios to
augment large language models (LLMs) with external documents provided by
retrievers. However, a semantic gap exists between LLMs and retrievers due to
differences in their training objectives and architectures. This misalignment
forces LLMs to passively accept the documents provided by the retrievers,
leading to incomprehension in the generation process, where the LLMs are
burdened with the task of distinguishing these documents using their inherent
knowledge. This paper proposes R$^2$AG, a novel enhanced RAG framework to fill
this gap by incorporating Retrieval information into Retrieval Augmented
Generation. Specifically, R$^2$AG utilizes the nuanced features from the
retrievers and employs a R$^2$-Former to capture retrieval information. Then, a
retrieval-aware prompting strategy is designed to integrate retrieval
information into LLMs' generation. Notably, R$^2$AG suits low-source scenarios
where LLMs and retrievers are frozen. Extensive experiments across five
datasets validate the effectiveness, robustness, and efficiency of R$^2$AG. Our
analysis reveals that retrieval information serves as an anchor to aid LLMs in
the generation process, thereby filling the semantic gap. | [
-0.4275286198,
-0.6943730712,
0.4293416142,
-0.0304700099,
-0.1878511459,
0.2551786602,
-0.1035903767,
-0.6732080579,
0.2856477201,
0.3114230931,
-0.3337857425,
0.1334563196,
-0.5993737578,
0.0688617229,
-0.1784152985,
0.6746014953,
0.0936564952,
-0.0982558131,
-0.3300859034,
-0.0591786951,
-0.6234523654,
-0.1433520913,
-0.6311985254,
-0.5923035741,
0.5719371438,
0.7152023315,
0.7129521966,
0.8043586612,
0.3942270279,
0.1492225081,
-0.0844721496,
0.6249696016,
-0.6372172236,
0.5130536556,
-0.449770391,
-0.5201064944,
-0.4195025563,
-0.0553058162,
0.7120315433,
0.335665375,
-0.1471856683,
0.3082426488,
-0.0253418256,
0.8852271438,
-0.7807338238,
-0.1795187443,
-0.9780736566,
0.0468107536,
-0.4292153716,
-0.4442734122,
-0.4460951388,
-0.0980666801,
-0.3160890937,
-0.631074369,
0.4208033085,
0.1706198454,
0.9664904475,
0.330087781,
-0.1945172548,
-0.3621919155,
-0.5145959258,
0.5058979988,
-0.3417476416,
0.5489233732,
0.6378448606,
0.2935669422,
-0.3086412549,
-0.7886378765,
-0.7217583656,
-0.0660149604,
-0.2099962234,
0.2423924208,
-0.1765612811,
-0.3512045145,
0.276196748,
0.3802538514,
-0.4104047716,
0.0156044783,
-0.1977428347,
0.1053750217,
0.4274294078,
-0.0825257227,
0.1259417832,
-0.3377169669,
-0.4693821073,
-0.1672068536,
-0.9106853604,
-0.1375141293,
0.4309043884,
0.4626826048,
0.1063638702,
0.861774087,
-0.0404819176,
0.6150614619,
0.311529398,
0.0473846421,
0.2705700397,
-0.0842089653,
0.1709688604,
-0.1962329149,
0.3906360269,
0.187081635,
-0.0062335185,
-0.1275400817,
-0.4186152518,
-0.169080317,
0.3371488452,
-0.7952340245,
0.0590661429,
-0.0523556471,
-0.3159221709,
-0.0159750879,
0.1546180099,
-0.9992086887,
-0.5326824188,
-0.20725362,
0.3645495474,
-0.2939347029,
-0.5082563758,
-0.3515422344,
-0.3248118758,
0.2741163373,
0.1594728827,
-0.910639286,
0.1480053514,
0.8666322231,
0.7273802757,
-0.0554076582,
0.0180206858,
-1.1098563671,
0.424418062,
-0.4066961408,
1.135597229,
-0.808570981,
-0.5978499055,
0.0631018281,
-0.2322033644,
0.1312904209,
-0.6767728329,
0.473274678,
-1.07987082,
0.323669672,
-0.0744051263,
-0.4941365719,
-0.1453812271,
0.2442570627,
-0.5760105252,
1.4867334366,
0.4750820696,
-0.7244099975,
0.2946174443,
-0.3373584747,
-0.3582419753,
0.4704689682,
-0.4412354529,
-0.3839724362,
0.2295772284,
-0.0136916302,
0.0807489753,
-0.4315074384,
0.0960247368,
0.0442655645,
-0.3017498851,
0.0853459165,
-0.1777362376,
0.1887786239,
0.4252651334,
-0.0245879851,
-0.3292284012,
-0.6503146887,
0.2085942775,
0.2261410952,
-0.7040581703,
-0.4776822329,
-0.1044025421,
-0.194291994,
-0.0381872244,
0.3923395276,
-0.3106526732,
0.3011081815,
-0.58179456,
-0.2748368979,
0.4434952736,
0.0886169448,
0.7476347685,
-0.2923829556,
0.828111887,
-0.267705828,
-0.367210716,
-0.2337117046,
-0.3375748694,
-0.7462234497,
-0.1479565352,
0.4240763783,
0.7369762063,
-0.9420987368,
0.1254059821,
-0.1803640723,
-0.1584589779,
-0.5404807925,
0.2533927858,
0.5368725657,
0.6689963341,
0.4473502636,
-0.008003165,
-0.6994913816,
-0.5992221832,
-0.342771709,
-0.1713275909,
-0.1480370611,
0.7008311152,
0.1092741042,
-0.3806291521,
0.9832342863,
-0.3445564806,
-0.2774550915,
-0.3486788571,
0.1336473078,
0.1154112592,
0.3479717076,
0.3146062791,
-0.9588932991,
-0.511388123,
0.1638873816,
-0.7662943602,
-0.3326616287,
0.111528337,
-0.2566538453,
0.3828946054,
0.5515853167,
-0.5552881956,
0.2819617689,
0.3311199248,
-0.393096894,
0.3159331083,
-0.4421839416,
0.0550492667,
-1.170902729,
0.2519176602,
-0.3142020404,
-0.2303193063,
-0.4561517537,
0.1607454121,
0.1769454628,
-0.0916211903,
-0.145588398,
1.0279724598,
-0.8486309052,
-0.3126464486,
-0.6924195886,
0.4428405762,
0.2016473413,
-0.0206366107,
-0.1764201671,
1.1331992149,
0.1758620888,
-0.6931408644,
0.1409510374,
0.5795504451,
0.0139490822,
0.5462103486,
-0.3955962658,
0.2702863216,
-0.4299109876,
0.2119484842,
-0.6086509824,
-0.5399685502,
0.1976722181,
-0.7924329042,
0.7787129879,
-0.2360295653,
-0.4149720073,
-0.1636360735,
-0.1745440662,
0.3491470516,
0.6163637042,
-0.6610844731,
0.9248392582,
0.5520168543,
-0.3914048672,
-0.7378568053,
-0.6997053027,
0.4314780831,
-0.1530574709,
-0.7330239415,
0.3977625668,
0.2001001388,
-0.3381370008,
0.1404217035,
0.1165099293,
0.2619470656,
-0.0851766467,
0.0569011606,
0.2617533207,
-0.1841888428,
0.2941242456,
0.0304950904,
-0.3579472899,
-0.3183258474,
0.0282509159,
0.4883582294,
0.2955293059,
-0.250436157,
-0.0338553712,
0.6848844886,
0.0680571273,
-0.4840403199,
0.5266109705,
0.6468711495,
-0.1913896203,
-0.4414525032,
-0.7758744359,
-0.2733261883,
-0.4815517962,
0.317751497,
-0.5859460831,
-1.0009824038,
0.399029851,
-0.3047055602,
-0.0951583833,
0.4408195615,
0.3908941746,
0.0480283499,
0.9929758906,
0.6330620646,
0.379046768,
0.6381441355,
-0.2808327079,
0.1523790658,
-1.4282513857,
-0.4712174833,
-0.6807519197,
-0.1198158264,
-0.3600326478,
-0.8001952171,
0.2741028666,
0.6751852632,
-0.0700690746,
0.0619712844,
-0.4497553408,
0.4628988206,
0.4609511197,
-0.0736983418,
0.194222331,
0.2820256352,
-0.1072074771,
-0.0267401226,
-0.9681363106,
-0.4664705694,
0.6967135072,
0.3276007175,
0.7431215048,
0.4199769795,
0.6645860672,
0.4334075451,
0.2901582718,
-0.7738857269,
0.5784117579,
-0.2206419706,
-0.39634341,
-0.0038775632,
-0.4488418698,
-1.0988972187,
0.2890216708,
-0.3211973608,
-0.4841313064,
0.3281029463,
0.212587133,
-0.1089923084,
-0.0715058967,
-0.5805385113,
0.393712312,
-0.0866857246,
-0.6159038544,
-0.1731502712,
-0.6127640009,
0.3031454682,
-0.0712268651,
0.381945163,
0.0020663752,
-0.2334815711,
0.5559702516,
-0.3904003203,
0.3031038642,
-0.399194777,
-0.1221521348,
0.5393152237,
0.2972195148,
1.1177014112,
0.1275156736,
-0.3500730693,
-0.4342578053,
-0.5577136874,
-0.0699264929,
-0.6386502385,
0.6471155882,
-0.3299461007,
-0.780901432,
-0.4739290178,
-0.5878388882,
-0.3994783759,
0.1716617197,
0.0974817425,
0.276614964,
0.2092527896,
0.1137974188,
0.715531826,
-0.1568976045,
0.218542397,
0.784853518,
-0.2434080839,
-0.4868091047,
1.0232203007,
-0.0945384502,
0.297942847,
0.2810792923,
0.3037772477,
-0.6073004603,
-0.345210135,
-0.6111598015,
0.3965519071,
-0.75361377,
-0.5638893247,
-0.8349543214,
-0.122663945,
-0.4870762527,
-0.1152772084,
-0.0036639895,
-0.4018908143,
-0.5277189016,
-0.0859678611,
0.6227002144,
0.7038576603,
-0.5739123821,
0.1592016518,
-0.9743266106,
0.6361138821,
0.2985312045,
0.3403154612,
0.1499177366,
-0.8367733955,
-0.2579744756,
0.0070365439,
0.010627009,
-0.6923710108,
0.2474374175,
0.3717631698,
0.771700263,
0.0885937288,
-0.1451106966,
0.7552915215,
-0.7591335177,
0.7454026341,
0.0054588062,
-0.4965610504,
0.6195311546,
-0.3263841569,
0.1702769399,
0.6349193454,
-0.0714984313,
-0.3208831251,
-0.3369204104,
-0.5674552321,
-1.1288723946,
0.8530601263,
-0.0384069607,
0.243319571,
-0.266038835,
0.5991970301,
0.0063374019,
0.0172989033,
-0.3296914399,
-0.0683122948,
0.076815255,
-0.0531870387,
0.3399557471,
-0.7681971192,
-0.0282443501,
0.2666002214,
0.9732183814,
0.0116457678,
0.221881032,
0.1534913033,
0.0019140196,
-0.4845184386,
0.2430730164,
0.3903330564,
0.472954303,
-0.0186776277,
0.300617218,
0.1259571016,
-0.4727421999,
0.1249885559,
0.1984169781,
-0.319848001,
0.1364644021,
0.1498485953,
0.6640559435,
-0.1203733757,
-0.590252161,
0.289257884,
0.09518978,
0.1225593239,
-0.3283567429,
0.151361078,
-0.0476733185,
0.5405436158,
0.7330427766,
-0.0870672688,
0.0180272888,
-0.5063170791,
0.5106493235,
0.7583329082,
-0.1364251375,
0.1419811994,
0.7235182524,
0.0908423066,
-0.531437099,
0.2753195167,
-0.4627438784,
-0.4237031937,
0.3075315356,
0.8104145527,
0.649163425,
-0.2120846361,
0.0464576595,
0.4747834504,
0.0406570137,
-0.310375154,
0.3834965825,
-0.1512389779,
-0.5677300692,
-0.5227723718,
-0.870859623,
-0.2888783813,
-0.109450832,
-0.6384160519,
0.1788751334,
-0.1033143401,
-0.1482658684,
-0.334302187,
-0.1066249162,
-0.3028461337,
0.1826434731,
0.0470416397,
0.939322114,
-0.279712677,
0.5178356767,
0.6531237364,
-0.4089510441,
-0.9167078137,
0.0084772231,
-0.215422228,
-0.9805346131,
0.8838583827,
-0.0279646944,
-0.4491446018,
0.1721902043,
-0.3275725842,
-0.9604631066,
1.2085124254,
0.1676488519,
-0.276760906,
0.053416498,
-0.0293480325,
0.3574192524,
-0.3921458721,
0.0057911249,
0.4128713608,
0.6350727677,
0.663494885,
-0.4964363575,
0.0359014869,
-0.3782525957,
0.2115605474,
0.3669762611,
-0.5219138861,
0.7540844083,
-0.3501826525,
-0.6311702728,
0.2381225526,
0.8017387986,
0.672700882,
0.3987167478,
0.3629731536,
0.7848674059,
0.7209922671,
0.0742485374,
1.0490758419,
-0.2179184109,
0.1189954951,
1.3788768053,
-0.4010034204,
1.0013666153,
0.4280925691,
-0.031201629,
0.4228751063,
0.2306625396,
-0.0700761601,
0.470652312,
-0.0326449573,
-0.5560866594,
-0.0603161566,
-0.5703416467,
-0.6647544503,
0.3131634295,
0.5496520996,
-0.3181925714,
-0.4127643108,
-0.0244035572,
0.1110967919,
0.3514772654,
-0.3079641461,
1.0454757214,
0.0596378744,
-0.8603759408,
0.499238193,
0.0691888332,
0.5256263614,
-0.6444363594,
-0.3701112866,
-0.343967557,
0.1418436766,
-0.3855978549,
-0.8517224193,
0.3757716417,
0.3197843432,
-0.3436758816,
-0.2863835394,
1.0620903969,
-0.5998096466,
-0.5211586952,
0.2876573205,
0.5837014318,
0.1953424513,
0.1358816773,
-0.4696850479,
0.1190559715,
-0.0986127704,
-0.3092319965,
0.3830283582,
0.69880265,
0.1099970192,
0.4311540723,
0.7212549448,
0.2669210434,
-0.1266617775,
0.215107128,
0.9024345279,
-0.5532562137,
-0.5031737685,
-0.5103008151,
0.5474249721,
-0.0871934593,
0.0405266844,
0.8511693478,
0.6987912655,
0.4429236948,
0.2279927135,
0.781113863,
-0.3069324493,
1.1481761932,
-0.6110373735,
0.6248155236,
-0.7896946669,
0.3413874209,
0.2108338028,
-1.0053071976,
-0.0664891601,
0.534974277,
0.0409137756,
0.1316213012,
0.3063463271,
1.0219157934,
-0.0040782937,
-0.3750736117,
0.1892101616,
-0.0058559873,
0.3094550371,
0.2142784745,
0.7460432649,
-0.3921352923,
0.4558388293,
0.3710635602,
-0.3320838213,
-0.3641569018,
-0.771478653,
-0.6201950312,
-0.3904547691,
0.1013948917,
-0.6358135939,
0.0806906,
0.7168089747,
0.270304352,
-0.4098812044,
0.0845453516,
-0.1923045963,
0.017768424,
0.28965801,
-0.3120268583,
0.1968791634,
-0.5424381495,
-0.5147764087,
0.7816391587,
0.2670515776,
0.2234665155,
-0.2536460757,
-0.2279310226,
-0.5048320889,
0.1546729207,
0.4867328703,
0.493307054,
-0.5708993077,
-0.2089983374,
0.0017121171,
-0.1137609631,
-0.001107123,
0.7583003044,
-1.0463032722,
0.5464621782,
0.6014342308,
0.9238470793,
0.4831950366,
0.4282213748,
0.453784734,
-1.0111808777,
0.330863893,
0.3888053894,
0.0468427539,
0.6324181557,
-0.5609354377,
0.672534883,
0.0570602342,
-0.6840965152,
-0.8587360978,
0.4680034816,
-0.7265504003,
-0.1791066527,
1.5116797686,
0.0858536065,
-0.0083229374,
0.0194136929,
-0.2074004263,
0.3421876431,
-0.4731877148,
0.6397710443,
0.3656841815,
-0.1050887704,
-0.1749876887,
-0.7112157345,
0.5624707341,
0.3639846742,
-0.7748583555,
0.1203687862,
0.7356925607,
-0.0544038303,
0.2851241231,
0.6384916902,
-0.1986243874,
0.2796773911,
0.0531490557,
-0.1336496323,
-0.3504333496,
-0.275056392,
-0.2315427661,
0.1460788697,
0.1064806953,
0.0862869918
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13246v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13246v1 | GSR-BENCH: A Benchmark for Grounded Spatial Reasoning Evaluation via Multimodal LLMs | 2024-06-19T06:15:26 | 2024-06-19T06:15:26 | Navid Rajabi, Jana Kosecka | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG | The ability to understand and reason about spatial relationships between
objects in images is an important component of visual reasoning. This skill
rests on the ability to recognize and localize objects of interest and
determine their spatial relation. Early vision and language models (VLMs) have
been shown to struggle to recognize spatial relations. We extend the previously
released What'sUp dataset and propose a novel comprehensive evaluation for
spatial relationship understanding that highlights the strengths and weaknesses
of 27 different models. In addition to the VLMs evaluated in What'sUp, our
extensive evaluation encompasses 3 classes of Multimodal LLMs (MLLMs) that vary
in their parameter sizes (ranging from 7B to 110B), training/instruction-tuning
methods, and visual resolution to benchmark their performances and scrutinize
the scaling laws in this task. | [
-0.646732688,
-0.5279172659,
1.0343595743,
0.0508407801,
-0.1421906501,
-0.2766562998,
-0.1355390549,
-0.3427459598,
-0.3698364794,
0.2121573538,
-0.5755441785,
-0.5861105323,
-0.6572245955,
-0.0482692532,
-0.0716576204,
0.4622137547,
-0.0940672085,
0.500362277,
-0.6730778813,
-0.5746498704,
-0.6077792645,
-0.6216595173,
-0.0179754794,
-0.268802613,
0.4126813114,
0.1939423531,
0.5480662584,
0.5356349945,
0.8798905611,
0.4371311367,
-0.1768207252,
0.0992324129,
-0.4511258304,
0.0593060888,
-0.3284000456,
-0.2408367544,
-0.1221460178,
-0.0286404993,
0.6931778789,
0.770473659,
-0.1452391446,
0.2716270387,
-0.1860271692,
0.8244910836,
-0.7134351134,
0.2415306866,
-0.5812715292,
0.2407155186,
-0.0020686344,
-0.0989328101,
-0.3076054156,
-0.315808326,
-0.1115384474,
-0.6723842025,
0.2923344672,
0.0815861523,
0.9852451682,
0.4701535702,
-0.5773568153,
0.1572097689,
-0.5614987612,
0.7904901505,
-0.4761853218,
0.7783177495,
0.3783852458,
0.792429924,
-0.1701840609,
-0.6984523535,
-0.316382885,
-0.2756540477,
-0.2384516746,
0.3328912258,
0.0972020924,
-0.199220106,
0.6780259609,
0.1258636713,
-0.7376101613,
-0.381588161,
-0.496857971,
0.1157273874,
0.5388133526,
0.2968949676,
0.0590359718,
-0.3107223511,
-0.7666107416,
-0.1103119254,
-0.5226359963,
0.0870189741,
-0.1102140546,
0.0782015994,
-0.1189960912,
0.826007843,
-0.2506670654,
0.8121089339,
-0.0308835972,
-0.3305182755,
0.2300743014,
-0.4907435775,
-0.3005549908,
-0.5304089189,
0.4460124671,
0.7398071885,
0.2911324799,
-0.0908540711,
-0.0674972162,
0.3552434742,
0.279302448,
-0.4066967964,
0.0641236603,
-0.2315803021,
-0.770639658,
0.2302822769,
0.0920073614,
-0.676491797,
-0.5367511511,
-0.7770504355,
0.1644573063,
-0.3434076011,
-0.0751060471,
0.1263413429,
-0.3319660723,
0.4043468535,
0.3343732655,
-0.6553462744,
0.4610916078,
0.6535324454,
0.5048515797,
-0.0286009777,
-0.7248386741,
-0.3126521409,
0.234884277,
-0.2712600231,
1.14118433,
-0.6304193139,
-0.4243651032,
-0.3054243028,
0.1409590244,
-0.2546841204,
-0.569720149,
0.669592917,
-0.3605026305,
-0.1288966984,
-0.8461216688,
-0.266148001,
-0.2171900719,
0.5563432574,
-0.4363146722,
1.2255293131,
0.2382001877,
-0.600982368,
0.8148179054,
-0.1645844728,
-0.0933022052,
0.1738017499,
-0.6395258904,
-0.0871908888,
0.2967288792,
0.4312902391,
0.4874214828,
-0.2626345754,
0.5085490346,
-0.8190410733,
-0.3558616936,
0.2199318558,
-0.0644816682,
0.1265803277,
0.2274464965,
-0.0092841126,
0.3555656672,
-0.9058644176,
0.3137299418,
0.1854989231,
-0.140992552,
-0.3592035174,
0.2757588327,
-0.1041050553,
0.4030216336,
0.0803242847,
-0.1140593141,
0.0076411585,
0.1802829206,
0.180434823,
0.6098303795,
-0.1618537903,
0.5445519686,
-0.1941473633,
0.3627917469,
-0.2249529362,
0.2356112301,
-0.1977339685,
-0.3528748751,
-0.5706638694,
-0.43427369,
-0.3397769034,
0.3764575422,
-0.5117214322,
0.2639594078,
-0.3668052256,
-0.5895716548,
0.0664049685,
0.0832965225,
0.4446747899,
0.5899783373,
0.3940479457,
-0.2455753088,
-0.6529105306,
-0.8939267993,
-0.1525537372,
-0.0198501628,
0.0415501073,
0.8351480961,
0.5193675756,
-0.3918568492,
0.8504077792,
-0.4127283692,
-0.3170906901,
-0.1005774587,
-0.0032418999,
0.070768781,
0.1945259124,
0.812063396,
-0.5346984863,
-0.3104269505,
0.0189039316,
-1.1420525312,
-0.1316596419,
0.2306469083,
-0.2355884314,
-0.1811338514,
0.7110550404,
-0.6550655365,
0.5555939078,
0.411085099,
-0.7006414533,
0.4736530781,
-0.3376739621,
0.3931150138,
-0.4297384322,
-0.0341891274,
0.3776678741,
-0.055225078,
-0.2726760209,
0.327580452,
0.1096303612,
-0.3085597456,
-0.3112528622,
0.5301771164,
-0.7327657938,
-0.7991533279,
0.0472749583,
0.2677130997,
0.0581121407,
0.3710450232,
0.2747831643,
0.8098505139,
0.426304251,
-0.3658363819,
0.3614392281,
0.2890205681,
-0.5633248091,
0.8592332602,
-0.684879601,
-0.0565135702,
-0.2629676759,
0.0834695399,
-1.2934756279,
-0.1454263031,
-0.0464432016,
-0.1673001647,
0.0583770089,
-0.4080833495,
-0.4307011068,
-0.3460409045,
-0.0396216474,
0.5184688568,
0.2749290764,
-0.6104141474,
0.8958703279,
0.383872211,
-0.0905950963,
-0.407903105,
-0.4985852838,
-0.1324290931,
-0.308650136,
-0.6742146611,
-0.1093684584,
0.0595845468,
-0.525069952,
0.0747932121,
-0.084240593,
-0.065031454,
-0.1316362321,
0.4577440619,
0.2638363242,
-0.3586972356,
-0.0501854569,
-0.4033658504,
-0.3848786652,
0.1885145903,
0.3363016546,
0.28573367,
-0.6459616423,
-0.8616159558,
-0.0722241402,
0.1739223003,
0.7312776446,
-0.1999532729,
0.3926883936,
0.5138828158,
-0.278568536,
0.1913509816,
-0.7141336203,
0.0628581047,
-0.4130732715,
0.5069117546,
-0.6707611084,
-0.6067464352,
0.4923909605,
-0.2188742906,
-0.522007525,
0.2680655122,
0.4214131534,
-0.1722321063,
0.9370415211,
0.2567667067,
0.0830304623,
0.2165119201,
-0.0506178252,
0.0662366301,
-0.8597386479,
-0.7035711408,
-0.405531615,
-0.3497506976,
-0.1601583511,
-0.7391405702,
0.2350620925,
0.2424708009,
-0.5853081942,
0.083660081,
-0.3234398365,
0.6379766464,
0.4071754515,
0.0581745058,
0.041368112,
0.0296876766,
-0.3639916778,
-0.6116276383,
-0.5918864608,
-0.6305205822,
0.8771861792,
0.3837051094,
0.8635851145,
0.1016389132,
0.1922064424,
0.1876168996,
0.2715597749,
-0.6858537197,
0.9122837782,
-0.0794137716,
-0.3123164177,
-0.1544106156,
-0.2125022858,
-0.6538561583,
0.8238433599,
-0.4156502485,
-0.739813447,
0.1864926368,
-0.1160720363,
-0.0660429522,
0.1765523106,
-0.8537155986,
0.9069131613,
-0.5272653699,
-0.5796861649,
-0.1199420169,
-0.6069594026,
0.5178954601,
0.4450918436,
0.3017897308,
-0.3488140702,
0.0820114166,
0.2469277531,
-0.1706148535,
0.5765357018,
-0.3282402754,
0.1680139899,
0.0889376402,
-0.0179249831,
0.2344980389,
0.0461269654,
0.2235357314,
0.3262223303,
0.1024742126,
-0.2360019386,
-0.7754211426,
0.69228971,
-0.7372653484,
-0.3949153721,
-0.5167807341,
-0.6570251584,
-0.4411540329,
0.1054619253,
-0.0920466185,
0.191705659,
-0.3104819655,
0.273219794,
0.5252682567,
-0.0562713444,
0.1139155775,
0.4637513459,
-0.6271311045,
-0.5673006177,
0.4524943829,
-0.0177780446,
-0.0448120981,
0.1209881976,
0.039851252,
-0.6099956632,
-0.4226367176,
-0.2699975967,
0.3414387107,
-1.0709391832,
-0.1238559932,
-0.3883819282,
-0.1960477531,
-0.1150960177,
-0.3519769609,
-0.1965845972,
-0.154907614,
-0.0075801932,
-0.1989598572,
0.0665346608,
0.8964720368,
-0.0346731022,
0.0088996626,
-0.8311335444,
0.4893374443,
0.4702493548,
0.3901176751,
-0.1322921216,
-0.4517210722,
0.0378828049,
-0.1663573533,
-0.0777344629,
-0.6706807613,
0.2515165806,
-0.1462017,
1.0693231821,
0.6059935093,
-0.3926781416,
1.1628979445,
-0.6542711854,
0.6781896353,
0.2685035467,
-0.7347095609,
0.643555522,
-0.3601701558,
0.265257448,
0.3874810338,
0.1513583511,
-0.180043295,
0.185244441,
-0.4570596814,
-0.5640953779,
0.426835835,
-0.100364767,
-0.2111520171,
-0.0588900708,
0.3019294739,
-0.1021528915,
0.0874643847,
-0.7723628283,
-0.0503539033,
-0.1951252818,
0.0631125569,
-0.3115426004,
-0.6401125789,
-0.4552199841,
-0.5514996052,
0.1154478192,
-0.1049410477,
0.3081303239,
0.0462507308,
-0.1726119369,
-0.0738538131,
0.2848218381,
0.8591108322,
1.0023572445,
-0.2767105699,
0.4262536168,
0.4733650982,
-0.1317123324,
0.1742964983,
0.0991612375,
0.1124147251,
-0.0781283677,
0.5115553141,
0.764323473,
0.517480135,
-0.7440952659,
0.5896933079,
-0.2547326386,
-0.3943455219,
-0.1424570233,
-0.0385056846,
-0.019384766,
0.6835346818,
0.2488538325,
0.4023058116,
0.0458156951,
-0.4005538821,
0.2317696065,
0.5615343451,
-0.4059948027,
-0.1739309877,
0.5701402426,
-0.1667634398,
0.154010132,
0.5418080091,
-0.08079198,
-0.4426853359,
0.605281353,
0.5133818984,
0.4213143289,
0.0986872688,
0.1462206542,
0.7469596863,
0.424908191,
-0.0940067545,
0.5663779974,
-0.2022960633,
-0.8892011642,
-0.3371306658,
-0.2026864439,
-0.1589852571,
0.1745191514,
-0.9858441949,
0.0252828654,
-0.6006939411,
-0.3430512547,
-0.4066487551,
-0.2566362917,
-0.7679024339,
0.3249950707,
0.2097043991,
0.7199597359,
-1.0949468613,
0.5014908314,
0.8907858133,
-0.2744213343,
-0.5544228554,
-0.3441695869,
0.0802114457,
-0.9114764333,
1.2151595354,
0.1377328932,
-0.2547408342,
-0.4803487062,
-0.6119890809,
-1.0994577408,
1.2307162285,
0.3648279309,
-0.6298291087,
0.4399387538,
-0.1126603857,
0.6511067748,
-0.2866210043,
0.3069105148,
0.4089732766,
0.609105587,
0.2828979194,
-0.5893152356,
-0.0032322817,
-0.3599369228,
0.3422126472,
-0.0126059297,
-0.5879315734,
0.7459247112,
-0.5047494173,
-0.3116248846,
0.0943176225,
0.5341324806,
0.9664279819,
0.5128584504,
0.4660491943,
0.9853074551,
0.5009519458,
-0.4601311982,
1.0270352364,
-0.1024055555,
0.3245744705,
1.2782683372,
-0.7163504362,
1.0127104521,
0.7511360645,
-0.402050674,
0.3230727017,
0.5068147779,
-0.2003107667,
0.9472745061,
0.2231215239,
-0.048711516,
-0.4850284159,
-0.01923679,
-0.8019815087,
0.3068802357,
0.3734771907,
-0.1706774682,
-0.4190257788,
-0.1297935247,
-0.4947081208,
0.4523340166,
-0.3378829658,
0.6410824656,
-0.0366686955,
-0.4820807576,
0.3495892584,
-0.1314796954,
0.1681157649,
-0.6916900277,
-0.1044848338,
-0.1460956335,
0.3880752921,
-0.1123192087,
-0.8851341009,
0.3095930219,
-0.1523123384,
-0.3835836649,
-0.2105044574,
1.0016275644,
-0.1392040402,
-0.5196455717,
0.6279498935,
0.60866189,
0.0507271774,
0.165316835,
-0.7594559193,
0.3014778495,
-0.4207849205,
-0.1501657963,
0.3664409816,
0.7347753048,
-0.0354803167,
0.8900114298,
0.7437865138,
0.0368156433,
0.2649629414,
0.4564010799,
0.9316105843,
-0.7631396055,
-0.0402987488,
-0.6025978923,
0.5130633116,
-0.1488335431,
-0.2184097469,
0.8380457759,
0.6099840999,
0.8457919359,
-0.3826904297,
0.6690841913,
0.1959857494,
0.4054250121,
-0.7535603046,
0.2656325996,
-0.6003318429,
0.2003209144,
-0.325101316,
-0.9085174203,
-0.4089002609,
1.2028411627,
-0.7509880066,
0.2540147007,
0.9177467227,
0.6179100871,
-0.2173479199,
-0.2548881471,
0.6238097548,
-0.0744987801,
-0.0650439411,
0.4563869834,
1.3843939304,
-0.3704350889,
0.2793107629,
-0.0209387951,
-0.1068370119,
0.0229114424,
-0.9846888185,
-1.0397646427,
-0.4004694223,
0.0093167601,
-0.2173210084,
-0.0606109947,
0.4764189124,
0.8665513396,
-0.5351521969,
-0.2834503055,
-0.0537937507,
-0.0602344684,
-0.3602694273,
-0.168281734,
0.207200706,
-0.2837897837,
-0.3055284321,
0.5022901297,
0.5485202074,
0.1614373773,
-0.1918650568,
-0.3395269513,
-0.1494067162,
-0.2606509924,
0.8341547251,
0.1618269533,
-1.0132101774,
-0.2180161923,
-0.0269460101,
-0.2583861053,
0.0585834049,
0.9407064319,
-0.6755131483,
0.4235354364,
0.416996628,
0.5198671818,
0.6473939419,
0.2191552669,
0.2823781967,
-0.507560432,
0.4592559636,
-0.0891231447,
0.9628823996,
0.3481504917,
-0.0622550324,
0.8533639908,
0.3517065346,
-0.6197547317,
-0.5704872608,
0.148936376,
-1.1694614887,
-0.1498232186,
1.2179862261,
-0.2671421468,
-0.0489131883,
0.0545883328,
-0.4521460831,
-0.3127865195,
0.0138590727,
0.6021190882,
0.7608184218,
-0.032760188,
-0.6565654278,
-0.4964925349,
0.108803682,
0.2886413932,
-0.8686521053,
-0.2283351421,
0.9481116533,
0.3114398718,
0.0137410723,
0.7260131836,
-0.1495794356,
0.197857812,
0.204561159,
0.010702068,
-0.0313266665,
-0.5243932009,
-0.1959168762,
0.2368248403,
0.0284884796,
-0.1721656024
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13236v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13236v1 | Data Contamination Can Cross Language Barriers | 2024-06-19T05:53:27 | 2024-06-19T05:53:27 | Feng Yao, Yufan Zhuang, Zihao Sun, Sunan Xu, Animesh Kumar, Jingbo Shang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The opacity in developing large language models (LLMs) is raising growing
concerns about the potential contamination of public benchmarks in the
pre-training data. Existing contamination detection methods are typically based
on the text overlap between training and evaluation data, which can be too
superficial to reflect deeper forms of contamination. In this paper, we first
present a cross-lingual form of contamination that inflates LLMs' performance
while evading current detection methods, deliberately injected by overfitting
LLMs on the translated versions of benchmark test sets. Then, we propose
generalization-based approaches to unmask such deeply concealed contamination.
Specifically, we examine the LLM's performance change after modifying the
original benchmark by replacing the false answer choices with correct ones from
other questions. Contaminated models can hardly generalize to such easier
situations, where the false choices can be \emph{not even wrong}, as all
choices are correct in their memorization. Experimental results demonstrate
that cross-lingual contamination can easily fool existing detection methods,
but not ours. In addition, we discuss the potential utilization of
cross-lingual contamination in interpreting LLMs' working mechanisms and in
post-training LLMs for enhanced multilingual capabilities. The code and dataset
we use can be obtained from \url{https://github.com/ShangDataLab/Deep-Contam}. | [
-0.4301003814,
-0.9012473226,
0.5749421716,
0.0120852375,
-0.3051989377,
0.3585801423,
-0.2356123924,
-0.9952589273,
-0.1845111996,
1.0186767578,
-0.1607231647,
-0.4718319774,
-0.8551653028,
-0.1635692716,
-0.5168709159,
0.8591501117,
-0.3494229019,
-0.1125363782,
-0.1799576581,
-0.1438486129,
-0.2388939261,
-0.7205609679,
-0.3450567424,
-0.5406153798,
0.3077915013,
0.4321272373,
0.6584565639,
0.6498152018,
0.278231144,
0.3329217136,
-0.2248106301,
0.18983832,
-0.5342963338,
0.1105141118,
-0.4636078477,
-0.6903752089,
-0.1301668733,
-0.0360823497,
0.6336202621,
0.8619604707,
0.0393474624,
-0.0712108016,
0.2707546055,
0.5269267559,
-0.9040198326,
-0.005060764,
-0.8209778666,
0.0430013537,
-0.5804226995,
-0.0955437273,
-0.3254738748,
0.1342611313,
-0.1601800472,
-0.6562066674,
0.1226296574,
-0.1773767322,
0.9772897363,
0.2679545879,
-0.4340763986,
-0.0534223989,
-0.9390588999,
0.9364404082,
-0.5939714313,
0.4282680154,
0.6893674135,
0.294891417,
-0.1900534481,
-0.6716707945,
-0.3695576191,
-0.0742137581,
-0.0848257467,
-0.1832042336,
-0.2955263555,
-0.1679752916,
0.2341213524,
0.3457134068,
-0.4315748811,
0.3731955886,
-0.2872183323,
-0.3673935831,
0.5625427365,
0.0359312855,
0.6953927875,
0.0667236671,
-0.5304400325,
-0.1241898537,
-1.2766157389,
-0.1170334816,
0.528208673,
0.2270012498,
-0.110942699,
0.3556612432,
-0.2791550756,
0.5461983681,
-0.298568666,
0.1414351463,
0.3536054492,
-0.5794298649,
-0.3497952819,
-0.0228759982,
0.7277824879,
-0.0040273885,
0.6025757194,
-0.2752917707,
-0.2022805363,
-0.1325156838,
0.0149252797,
-0.663292408,
-0.2151390016,
0.1696376801,
0.0580040403,
-0.1703740209,
-0.0962292925,
-0.7677989006,
-0.5678818226,
-0.3233177662,
0.4982578456,
-0.1242596358,
-0.3756123483,
0.4417220354,
0.205028519,
-0.2605729401,
0.1079695821,
-0.8743754625,
0.2517037988,
0.9078668356,
0.432239145,
-0.0064211194,
-0.3465594947,
-0.6162241101,
0.2046808898,
-0.3288067877,
0.6409350038,
-0.6411075592,
-0.460416466,
0.1793414503,
-0.014631208,
0.0296844672,
-0.9875163436,
0.3778434396,
-0.5468990803,
0.2808912694,
-0.1770997643,
-0.4069570005,
-0.1436809748,
0.0757065192,
-0.6509849429,
1.0494076014,
-0.1031851619,
-0.8782573342,
0.4733707011,
-0.0994025394,
-0.6230748892,
0.2034527063,
-0.3749789298,
-0.2818621397,
-0.1682718694,
0.3487128913,
0.2980599403,
-0.0770222843,
0.4396595061,
-0.2532900274,
-0.6159237027,
0.2142547816,
-0.5574805737,
0.8009541631,
0.167677775,
-0.5316867232,
-0.0909025595,
-0.8288742304,
0.1239071861,
-0.1027624011,
-0.4522337914,
-0.745552063,
-0.2288811356,
-0.0961043015,
0.2432803065,
0.1557952017,
-0.4884719551,
-0.205367282,
-0.3284456134,
0.2446130216,
0.6967790127,
0.1007827818,
0.1871263385,
-0.3789556324,
0.5439748168,
0.2724449933,
0.28920874,
-0.0828083158,
-0.4944839776,
-0.8139294386,
-0.2980554402,
0.3279730976,
0.5727458,
-1.0424234867,
0.2936852872,
-0.2672773302,
-0.5300451517,
-0.511946857,
0.4232832789,
0.6487495303,
0.4361202121,
0.4657778144,
-0.2790704668,
-0.4520991147,
-0.9088866711,
-0.7286925912,
0.0180383977,
-0.1684647053,
0.4026408494,
0.6130043864,
-0.3312543631,
0.7187543511,
-0.3636859953,
-0.3203336895,
0.062147636,
0.058383517,
0.1160684824,
0.5363224745,
0.2273179889,
-0.7156819105,
-0.6139172316,
0.0683938563,
-0.7844310999,
-0.3736943603,
0.072201632,
-0.1117718816,
-0.0294646118,
0.9124715328,
-0.2270765007,
0.1634925157,
0.6521803141,
-0.1039093658,
0.5873961449,
-0.2704511881,
0.1536469311,
-0.7332295179,
0.1464524716,
-0.060775198,
-0.1359922439,
-0.7512952685,
0.2489219606,
0.1162193865,
0.1491998732,
-0.8838781118,
0.6356598139,
-0.5210900307,
0.1377695054,
-0.1767140031,
0.1890923828,
0.3256438076,
0.1740334481,
-0.0616257824,
0.7332944274,
0.6062304974,
-0.3981498182,
0.1641720533,
0.0551261529,
-0.7573574185,
0.4444739521,
-0.6674820185,
0.1188354343,
0.1511078477,
0.051947996,
-0.9517636895,
-0.0662538931,
0.3894071579,
-0.1147025675,
0.4659273922,
-0.336455375,
-0.7332582474,
0.0990696326,
-0.1326639205,
0.6807766557,
0.2671355903,
-0.8381063938,
0.1768562943,
0.3508446515,
-0.0452272706,
-0.8853645325,
-1.0596020222,
0.219007805,
-0.374479562,
-0.7109550834,
0.2386185825,
0.075143218,
-0.4414310455,
-0.0916232765,
-0.1185241789,
-0.2814472318,
0.4821801186,
0.1799331009,
0.099387452,
-0.1534834802,
0.1453600675,
0.0445290767,
0.1027751416,
0.1780160666,
0.123401098,
0.5487492681,
0.2378341109,
-0.714048326,
-0.0520446748,
0.2503052652,
0.4259928465,
-0.3243168294,
0.5925767422,
0.3109482825,
-0.5229846835,
-0.227828458,
-0.6329595447,
0.0665870309,
-0.5889648199,
0.5296088457,
-0.3317537308,
-0.5983424187,
0.5689545274,
-0.0582286976,
-0.2911135852,
0.1118918434,
0.1131300777,
0.1607895195,
0.714237988,
0.6632336378,
-0.2363983542,
0.401709199,
-0.1077667102,
0.0154065471,
-0.7637075186,
-0.2643724382,
-0.5845540166,
-0.0043670456,
-0.4983891845,
-0.622128427,
0.1595273018,
0.2055403292,
-0.2106341273,
0.1474036276,
-0.0590289645,
0.8143086433,
0.3095982671,
0.1028976291,
0.6722005606,
0.0422768556,
-0.4435281456,
-0.1539744884,
-0.4484746754,
-0.4216017425,
1.1501156092,
0.4490397573,
0.9145953655,
-0.0982246399,
0.8726561666,
0.077207543,
0.2915139794,
-0.09995424,
0.3986627758,
-0.352953732,
-0.7380732298,
-0.2939012945,
-0.6231015325,
-1.1208202839,
0.6067286134,
-0.0899188593,
-0.8862644434,
0.3675327301,
-0.2998205125,
0.0425218493,
0.5253759623,
-0.6303394437,
0.8305057883,
-0.4693893492,
-0.5652015209,
0.0000629661,
-0.4424499273,
0.657489419,
-0.5267695189,
0.589733541,
-0.0865767747,
0.0839863271,
0.6095396876,
-0.2755816281,
0.9875054955,
-0.0084019406,
-0.5434845686,
-0.1210294887,
0.1802363694,
0.4792390764,
-0.1667158455,
0.1837800294,
0.5024206638,
-0.2742991745,
-0.4997055531,
-0.3205034137,
0.5350977182,
-0.5891391635,
-0.7124650478,
-0.3559327722,
-0.5097025037,
-0.4809929729,
0.4647243917,
0.4976366162,
0.1989948601,
-0.0881405845,
0.1098208651,
0.7596862316,
-0.5606167912,
0.1996067315,
0.8290547132,
-0.2832604051,
-0.0717067793,
0.9250829816,
0.1008852497,
0.5959253311,
0.403060019,
0.0897283927,
-0.2584948838,
-0.8200934529,
-0.3119367361,
0.3659074008,
-0.7444216609,
0.1175980568,
-0.4539851248,
-0.1154519543,
-0.289321512,
0.154273808,
-0.3083710968,
0.0588672236,
-0.2832607329,
-0.0214001108,
-0.0723346397,
0.734510839,
-0.3321740329,
0.1400362551,
-0.7735590935,
0.3366266489,
0.1051725149,
0.5124202967,
-0.1584846079,
-0.558576405,
-0.3674274087,
0.3235850036,
-0.0322616883,
-0.6210365295,
0.2691440582,
0.0498813279,
0.8698727489,
0.5277256966,
-0.0141186193,
0.4565283954,
-0.3039180934,
0.5513266921,
0.0464277752,
-1.1093329191,
0.3560581207,
-0.3804912269,
0.2626613379,
0.5094371438,
0.4719753861,
-0.865162313,
-1.016595006,
-0.3865512609,
-1.1361683607,
0.5441069603,
-0.1237992421,
0.0648098886,
0.2047508359,
0.0032924528,
0.1079132706,
0.1852129847,
-0.6513329148,
-0.1079243347,
0.0295564234,
0.2237948477,
-0.4493545294,
-0.4334934652,
-0.2754804194,
0.0682958812,
0.6272422075,
0.2009549737,
-0.6241332293,
0.0041701826,
-0.6063898206,
-0.1540272981,
0.3608432412,
0.5595552325,
0.7974675298,
0.0576843955,
0.4094517231,
0.0483591184,
-0.561707139,
0.2312552482,
0.0468110703,
-0.188507542,
-0.1699930727,
0.5787558556,
0.3743405342,
0.4785948992,
-0.8223057389,
0.4856880903,
0.1374890953,
0.0513432361,
-0.0165758058,
0.120461762,
0.1926430762,
0.1035378203,
0.3357606828,
-0.1461425871,
0.0541589707,
-0.7379232645,
0.5640541315,
0.243799597,
-0.2729680836,
-0.066551961,
0.7030124068,
0.1842491329,
0.0746347606,
0.46860075,
0.0804615244,
-0.7152791023,
0.5566165447,
0.2915219367,
0.6518101692,
-0.458135128,
0.0619696006,
-0.1247748137,
0.5586280227,
0.0428344943,
0.1520251483,
0.2273329943,
-0.9547226429,
-0.6178203225,
-0.2730872929,
-0.3417862654,
0.6158792973,
-0.7362376451,
0.0927590281,
-0.2929936051,
0.2698695064,
0.0668768138,
-0.0183115751,
-0.5011112094,
0.2311776578,
0.4613313079,
0.8356341124,
-1.2735924721,
0.7874697447,
0.3309027851,
-0.3244484067,
-0.4830054641,
0.1414506882,
-0.1123154387,
-0.9734849334,
0.6607626677,
0.1311322302,
-0.0262653716,
-0.6147790551,
-0.1920022517,
-0.7152026892,
0.4713844061,
0.5363023877,
-0.5357530713,
0.2637162507,
0.777032733,
0.6176977754,
0.1526679546,
0.117981188,
0.8735836744,
0.6843556762,
-0.4284489453,
-1.039249301,
0.3155235648,
-0.205410108,
-0.2351041883,
0.2085190117,
-0.4779472351,
0.9972265363,
-0.0134478677,
-0.3699959517,
-0.0206699148,
0.074898459,
0.0449374095,
0.2709383368,
0.4934916198,
0.6037628651,
0.8495622873,
-0.1064116582,
0.9538888931,
-0.0812708586,
0.2487644553,
1.435659647,
-0.5518389344,
0.6998181939,
0.5004145503,
-0.1823678166,
0.3956424594,
0.5391501784,
-0.2217011899,
0.4698731601,
0.5232009888,
-0.2903640866,
-0.1920255423,
-0.2531284094,
-0.557790935,
0.5633019209,
0.3144893646,
-0.2843795121,
-0.6063132286,
0.1269055009,
0.2444839031,
0.3459818065,
-0.1216447577,
0.5344034433,
-0.0654081702,
-0.6582271457,
0.8665896654,
-0.0172534548,
0.7098126411,
-0.4083946049,
0.0373156443,
-0.4448497295,
0.2950589359,
-0.3744148612,
-0.9467614889,
0.1379645765,
-0.2237091064,
0.0993016958,
-0.2824624181,
0.7177348733,
-0.8009355068,
-0.1583405882,
0.8428595662,
0.7655614614,
0.4303324223,
-0.4566496909,
-0.4777926803,
0.1902208328,
-0.0376730449,
-0.0001371322,
0.6123886108,
0.3877359331,
-0.0820934474,
0.7056247592,
0.6877772808,
0.2732239664,
0.2449138165,
0.3143658936,
0.7744083405,
-0.3667961955,
-0.4649484158,
-0.851929903,
0.2610604465,
0.1206249222,
-0.0721140653,
0.7518011332,
0.7738838792,
1.1275656223,
0.1987567395,
0.8242458105,
0.6212028265,
0.3982549012,
-0.6011846066,
0.8572951555,
-0.535577178,
0.6279950738,
-0.3196865022,
-0.5539906025,
-0.114394933,
-0.006158228,
-0.3869916499,
0.0731770769,
0.7356378436,
0.7237920165,
-0.3125285208,
-0.1083198488,
0.5539596677,
0.375919342,
0.5229737163,
0.8603110313,
1.0508316755,
-0.3059006631,
0.8565075994,
-0.4789813161,
-0.2018807083,
-0.2811208367,
-0.7787127495,
-0.7551556826,
-0.3087415397,
-0.43240273,
-0.1976426691,
0.2343700528,
-0.0616554543,
0.5505290627,
-0.7501745224,
-0.1130174398,
-0.025211513,
0.3961960971,
-0.0843296498,
-0.2128375471,
0.2341632843,
-0.2706305087,
-0.908321023,
0.666000545,
-0.2452791482,
0.2244062722,
-0.30951038,
0.3207584023,
-0.1662730277,
-0.0904586315,
0.242370218,
0.3464285135,
-0.4426493943,
-0.4074764252,
-0.3795536757,
-0.1925186813,
0.08759965,
0.6595235467,
-0.5611768365,
0.53821069,
0.428943783,
0.6329889297,
0.5360739827,
-0.1145766601,
0.5728299618,
-1.1283079386,
0.2149839699,
0.1633689106,
0.5634241104,
0.5443909764,
-0.6183018088,
0.5226724744,
0.2287305444,
-0.2823073864,
-1.1889148951,
0.3284052908,
-0.4175803959,
-0.5827279687,
1.4503216743,
-0.4014824331,
-0.0224799272,
-0.5053770542,
0.2210882604,
0.1521908194,
0.0727205873,
0.8127229214,
1.0242190361,
0.2420633435,
0.2921028435,
-0.7458430529,
0.3285126686,
0.5076523423,
-0.9108213782,
0.2585737705,
0.2465043813,
0.8155457377,
0.2078247964,
0.4086557925,
-0.4734752178,
0.3041511774,
0.0661861151,
-0.0138444286,
-0.2236467153,
-0.2872526348,
-0.5428878069,
-0.0465857275,
-0.0782416835,
-0.3439714909
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13232v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13232v1 | Towards Robust Evaluation: A Comprehensive Taxonomy of Datasets and Metrics for Open Domain Question Answering in the Era of Large Language Models | 2024-06-19T05:43:02 | 2024-06-19T05:43:02 | Akchay Srivastava, Atif Memon | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, cs.LG | Open Domain Question Answering (ODQA) within natural language processing
involves building systems that answer factual questions using large-scale
knowledge corpora. Recent advances stem from the confluence of several factors,
such as large-scale training datasets, deep learning techniques, and the rise
of large language models. High-quality datasets are used to train models on
realistic scenarios and enable the evaluation of the system on potentially
unseen data. Standardized metrics facilitate comparisons between different ODQA
systems, allowing researchers to objectively track advancements in the field.
Our study presents a thorough examination of the current landscape of ODQA
benchmarking by reviewing 52 datasets and 20 evaluation techniques across
textual and multimodal modalities. We introduce a novel taxonomy for ODQA
datasets that incorporates both the modality and difficulty of the question
types. Additionally, we present a structured organization of ODQA evaluation
metrics along with a critical analysis of their inherent trade-offs. Our study
aims to empower researchers by providing a framework for the robust evaluation
of modern question-answering systems. We conclude by identifying the current
challenges and outlining promising avenues for future research and development. | [
-0.5983136892,
-0.963218689,
0.44837147,
-0.2693030834,
0.1699690223,
0.2951380014,
-0.2771156728,
-0.312148422,
-0.4686228633,
0.2327415645,
-0.4091421366,
-0.3836881518,
-0.3464719653,
0.0328985713,
-0.2279437184,
0.8587871194,
-0.2670994997,
0.1610547602,
-0.5619974136,
-0.5956081152,
-0.4160594642,
-0.439442277,
-0.3740604222,
0.196357131,
0.151740402,
0.2091053575,
0.8620519042,
0.4140686095,
0.6479390264,
0.1685608178,
-0.0594382286,
0.1970539689,
-0.6459126472,
0.2982183993,
-0.2740888298,
-0.1373129338,
-0.5371331573,
-0.0548242293,
0.7237379551,
1.1673504114,
-0.0485904999,
0.5161269903,
0.0394438654,
0.338465631,
-0.9895979762,
0.009675812,
-0.5161442757,
-0.1053764895,
-0.110812597,
-0.077208586,
-0.1035304144,
-0.6625626087,
0.1054329872,
-0.4950306118,
-0.1944486648,
0.0473089106,
0.5992608666,
0.2609727383,
-0.4726289213,
-0.3404642045,
-0.6099720597,
0.98678267,
-0.5225849748,
0.620901525,
0.1889721602,
0.5476079583,
0.0732440725,
-0.7804080844,
-0.3744826913,
-0.0591275208,
0.3261607885,
0.122605145,
-0.191487968,
-0.201862812,
0.048087094,
0.7604487538,
-0.6774030924,
0.1271074861,
-0.2162123471,
-0.170514226,
0.3296998441,
0.4255366325,
0.2847594917,
0.0896521583,
-0.4462454617,
0.0965385437,
-0.3147437274,
0.2012001276,
0.2794777751,
0.2809481919,
0.3102942407,
0.6178412437,
-0.4837263525,
0.7036975622,
-0.2445095479,
-0.1006516218,
0.1401774585,
-0.6681957245,
-0.2141917646,
-0.4141195416,
0.6872348189,
0.2819464207,
0.1411714852,
-0.4013633728,
-0.2877002358,
0.1071904525,
0.4333530962,
-0.6256099939,
0.0303342734,
0.4282318652,
-0.5025330782,
-0.2255824953,
0.1064894423,
-1.0418286324,
-0.2641551495,
-0.1957953274,
0.6151931882,
-0.3726903796,
-0.3513575494,
0.3979955614,
-0.0580342971,
0.2765816152,
0.2892772555,
-0.4172270596,
0.6849034429,
0.8405099511,
0.5066747665,
-0.3299908042,
-0.100209102,
-0.6893122196,
-0.4325539768,
-0.4623888135,
0.5289000273,
-0.5938606858,
-0.0123245455,
0.319386214,
-0.2483021319,
-0.20190458,
-0.7145392895,
1.0743618011,
-1.0083451271,
0.3300533295,
-0.2003962845,
-0.3792381287,
-0.1001042649,
0.5112674832,
-0.608592689,
1.2990618944,
0.3455593288,
-0.7953074574,
0.5605608225,
-0.6871421337,
-0.0437313244,
-0.0404117033,
0.180549711,
-0.0829468966,
0.0337842144,
0.2502259016,
0.2280146331,
-0.6131437421,
0.2181517631,
-0.4449625313,
-0.106753245,
0.3428885937,
-0.4211754799,
0.8795693517,
0.5475152135,
-0.1371470243,
0.1196935102,
-0.9168394804,
0.3928543031,
0.0152627248,
-0.3200268149,
-0.4985479116,
-0.2069919854,
-0.096179992,
0.0295760259,
0.1683070958,
-0.6571118236,
-0.1484079957,
-0.2053908408,
0.6085489392,
0.4321848452,
0.1486306638,
0.3836521506,
-0.2719736695,
0.6952323914,
-0.2339745313,
0.387750566,
-0.0412362851,
-0.380689472,
-0.3407871127,
-0.3767928183,
0.613360703,
0.4010072649,
-0.9113608599,
0.3682451546,
-0.372289151,
-0.5686886907,
-0.711360395,
-0.0025369148,
0.3341131806,
0.6161510348,
0.3799227476,
-0.7130017281,
-0.1115589514,
-0.5175979137,
-0.1587640643,
-0.2802036107,
-0.1463860571,
0.2047665715,
0.662065506,
0.2138393074,
0.991280973,
-0.4410187304,
-0.0170449167,
-0.011110927,
0.0202245284,
-0.0165291913,
0.1949537694,
0.4462439418,
-0.757281661,
-0.0705831274,
-0.1511329412,
-0.616107583,
0.0839287341,
0.3164135218,
-0.2784412503,
-0.029032303,
0.3389481604,
-0.4684651494,
0.2561815381,
0.2627666295,
-0.2813186049,
0.6641612649,
0.261426717,
0.4282769859,
-0.6454055309,
0.392830044,
-0.2447249144,
0.0119902017,
-0.5831612945,
0.5251398683,
0.0189797468,
-0.1196502075,
-0.3757678568,
0.6319662333,
-0.2367093116,
-0.0591740459,
0.3752637506,
0.3782410026,
0.2426300049,
0.227160573,
-0.1166038141,
0.5930397511,
0.6010760665,
-0.4697018266,
0.4383175075,
0.5843375921,
-0.7539843321,
0.8582674265,
-0.6258414984,
0.1613798141,
-0.0070883292,
-0.0879230127,
-1.1335173845,
-0.2189942598,
0.2040600926,
-0.6278795004,
0.1079825535,
0.0536723845,
-0.5267956853,
-0.4048652649,
-0.5367507935,
0.7453327775,
0.2484879494,
-0.5170638561,
0.1782545149,
0.3839817941,
-0.3055452108,
-0.7101433277,
-0.3866046965,
0.0160776246,
-0.2395869046,
-0.6783083081,
-0.1076060236,
-0.1897427887,
-0.61781317,
0.0710934922,
-0.1878188998,
-0.5419865847,
0.2995685339,
-0.3231502473,
0.1614008248,
-0.6392608285,
0.2058902979,
-0.2848115861,
0.2069825232,
0.2588608861,
-0.345402807,
0.3428592682,
-0.1633940637,
-0.4020448029,
0.1233306751,
0.3455804586,
0.4987128973,
-0.7169722319,
0.5457985401,
0.5858935118,
-0.5237172246,
-0.211309731,
-0.213727802,
-0.0111491038,
-0.3634505272,
0.4131316543,
-0.3933010995,
-0.8602011204,
0.3193974793,
0.0749749616,
0.2593038678,
0.4816817343,
0.5482855439,
0.2450183183,
0.8560941815,
0.4893522263,
0.1535482109,
-0.053571891,
0.050107833,
0.2249282449,
-0.6326378584,
-0.0946953893,
-0.9500546455,
0.1205337718,
-0.1632232666,
-0.5947925448,
0.4023445249,
0.1724245697,
-0.4701631665,
0.0140143326,
-0.3207383752,
0.0820211917,
0.4490056038,
-0.0589941181,
0.5214800835,
-0.198134169,
-0.2073488533,
0.0435962789,
-0.7378068566,
-0.7441607118,
1.2358373404,
0.6726325154,
0.8051134348,
0.1592063606,
0.1780256033,
0.1744425744,
0.120261088,
-1.0370012522,
0.3956195712,
0.2308601886,
-0.8389925957,
-0.5464683771,
-0.5992982388,
-0.8912758231,
-0.0567091815,
-0.116980046,
-0.6652507782,
0.2264224291,
-0.3098928034,
-0.4808968604,
0.3584611416,
-0.3513222635,
1.0538238287,
-0.196852684,
-0.3848693073,
0.2291610837,
-0.6034327745,
0.405480355,
0.0074187359,
0.1708288938,
0.1728425175,
-0.2807776034,
0.7561700344,
-0.0917519256,
0.4250248373,
-0.0554989949,
-0.4121558368,
0.5206485987,
0.0020027563,
-0.218103826,
0.1264379323,
-0.4420708418,
0.0812399611,
0.5687382221,
-0.4746646285,
-0.5821139216,
0.5666809678,
-0.5206341147,
-0.0928583369,
-0.4233280122,
-0.4060430527,
-0.830524087,
0.1066826805,
-0.0999701247,
0.8462560773,
-0.671233952,
0.2944239974,
0.8768103719,
-0.4569208026,
0.1102652177,
0.2009538859,
-0.185721755,
-0.7575104237,
0.7236931324,
0.1041188911,
0.5919661522,
0.360847801,
0.0261861272,
-0.6516623497,
-0.6427774429,
-0.768058002,
-0.1036707237,
-0.923727572,
-0.3466756344,
-0.5370067954,
-0.160110414,
-0.4700022042,
0.273271054,
-0.1487463117,
-0.4538750947,
0.0690195486,
-0.0673432797,
0.1272928119,
0.6612577438,
0.3602935672,
-0.381280154,
-0.6563278437,
0.4653510749,
0.3558510542,
0.8426998258,
0.1602448374,
-0.4896328151,
-0.2021685541,
0.0197406169,
-0.3742035925,
-0.5062486529,
-0.1180765256,
0.381449759,
0.7415340543,
0.2690352499,
0.6823193431,
0.3183188438,
-0.217253387,
0.9948605895,
-0.1030525714,
-0.7750750184,
0.2819834054,
-0.3977899551,
0.3649419546,
0.8799032569,
0.7736899257,
-0.2608528137,
-0.1721816212,
-0.2974835634,
-0.8108647466,
0.4596372545,
0.1420843899,
-0.048871249,
0.0018785562,
0.1617185473,
0.5098432302,
0.5207293034,
-0.2581856847,
-0.0630909055,
-0.1899251193,
-0.316578716,
-0.0307835639,
0.0467330888,
-0.4775473177,
0.002741978,
0.4709781706,
-0.4014448524,
0.287997514,
0.1757305264,
-0.1391881853,
-0.0188558921,
0.593793273,
0.1654083878,
0.955514133,
-0.3011548519,
-0.0097858869,
0.1043774337,
-0.4519776404,
-0.0423891321,
0.1516380757,
-0.1136958227,
-0.2152155638,
0.3175650537,
0.5011143088,
-0.0453793369,
-0.9988090992,
0.479392767,
-0.149179697,
-0.3376651704,
-0.0108723314,
-0.2136915177,
-0.2648372352,
-0.1185129136,
0.3732201457,
0.0551216342,
0.3572936356,
-0.9994435906,
0.1747731864,
0.3522794843,
-0.7912989855,
-0.2356600314,
0.716237843,
-0.0064904741,
0.0771598741,
0.3146598339,
0.0472766161,
-0.3702918291,
0.3816627562,
-0.0012854136,
0.7404475808,
0.0466219783,
0.2569252551,
0.3203009963,
0.2978740036,
0.1224561557,
0.6092064381,
-0.104206726,
-0.4630126953,
-0.3152607977,
-0.8823227286,
-0.6349409223,
0.1974132657,
-0.9455692768,
0.0367842987,
-0.3901238143,
-0.1283197254,
-0.0394580923,
0.1439743042,
-0.6949605346,
0.5171425939,
-0.1039588898,
1.346518755,
-0.4526050687,
0.3750701845,
0.9587396979,
-0.3742478788,
-0.379855305,
0.2017950267,
-0.1108912304,
-0.4363691807,
0.2262925357,
-0.0488692783,
-0.0872378424,
-0.2804156244,
-0.4156291485,
-0.6290746927,
0.7520260811,
0.2509545684,
0.2302335799,
0.227916643,
0.2350921929,
0.7325181365,
-0.3426214159,
0.4181783497,
0.7169842124,
0.5598065257,
-0.019138841,
-1.1120378971,
0.0395805202,
-0.2550134659,
-0.2578282058,
0.1616999358,
-0.4799948633,
0.6038282514,
-0.0226252414,
-0.278501749,
0.6279553175,
0.4667890966,
-0.2684744596,
0.4553742111,
0.436293751,
0.5574956536,
0.6923233271,
-0.2797171474,
0.8009704351,
-0.0129527254,
0.2306763381,
0.9387071133,
-0.505867362,
1.0277426243,
0.2895537913,
-0.2250714302,
0.198737368,
0.6969689727,
0.293651849,
0.3856785893,
0.4451997876,
-0.2064567506,
-0.2456384748,
-0.3487624228,
-0.4134480953,
0.5538392663,
0.2708883882,
0.0144363567,
-0.4109312296,
0.0616414286,
-0.2694606781,
0.5418012738,
-0.4490440786,
0.8031286001,
-0.1877420843,
-0.7158492208,
0.7701247931,
-0.159189865,
0.3421218395,
-0.627738893,
0.0783326775,
-0.0888958275,
0.0472308099,
-0.1185116917,
-1.0057829618,
0.3238633275,
0.1204844564,
0.0363758542,
-0.2010994107,
0.5528898239,
-0.1961766332,
-0.1809890419,
0.2480195016,
0.8561477661,
-0.0294067673,
-0.0292487554,
-0.5253460407,
0.1047857925,
-0.5188980103,
-0.1177975163,
0.3679445088,
0.6913272738,
-0.1429622024,
0.620829165,
0.3114539683,
-0.2399342209,
0.0061553842,
0.0496976599,
0.9696046114,
-0.3723812103,
-0.2480848432,
-0.1548006982,
0.5215964913,
0.0410342328,
-0.6384374499,
0.7221387029,
0.6585239768,
0.9076266885,
0.0226809289,
0.8483421206,
-0.3653496802,
0.9172384739,
-0.4501325488,
0.5729262829,
-0.6470494866,
0.1040176749,
-0.4278545678,
-0.9419156313,
-0.2083319277,
0.0915582478,
-0.4035559297,
0.0609206595,
0.6042630076,
0.5588864088,
-0.1509912759,
0.1083753183,
0.3663082719,
0.1232195944,
0.0204807986,
0.3543015122,
1.1643948555,
-0.5725414157,
0.8063150644,
0.0150389047,
-0.3716645241,
0.1631104201,
-0.6219534278,
-0.6903891563,
-0.6952423453,
-0.3484327197,
-0.3802726865,
0.1504502445,
0.579834044,
0.4696525633,
-0.9733758569,
-0.2016803324,
0.4708209634,
-0.0078894868,
-0.5382891297,
-0.2870813608,
0.3007133305,
-0.3562332988,
-0.666331172,
0.3244459927,
0.2511179745,
-0.4465741515,
-0.4654645324,
0.0588668101,
-0.1828135997,
0.2099027634,
0.6261816025,
0.335372448,
-0.3830341995,
-0.3704010546,
0.3521583974,
-0.0762493089,
0.0699162558,
0.5384290218,
-0.6108540297,
0.5750311613,
0.5298369527,
1.0852743387,
-0.1555261463,
0.1247288287,
0.5936998129,
-0.397608906,
-0.5491855145,
0.5173583627,
0.0513141714,
0.3214958906,
0.168938458,
0.6997400522,
-0.1392307281,
-0.5685433745,
-1.1218655109,
0.1524930149,
-1.0166817904,
-0.1552365124,
0.9376851916,
-0.4467499256,
-0.097997427,
-0.7149174213,
-0.2562062144,
-0.239465788,
-0.1477056444,
0.6048417091,
0.7282395959,
0.1478646696,
0.0603795573,
-0.8120488524,
0.4000405967,
0.2547983527,
-0.8666762114,
0.1187444776,
0.5948857665,
0.2065966427,
0.16706191,
0.4027106762,
-0.4624258876,
0.3911246657,
-0.0169389267,
-0.1708079875,
0.2322173417,
-0.3274168968,
-0.4802396297,
0.6855393648,
0.340084672,
-0.120228231
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13230v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13230v1 | Enhancing Language Model Factuality via Activation-Based Confidence Calibration and Guided Decoding | 2024-06-19T05:33:34 | 2024-06-19T05:33:34 | Xin Liu, Farima Fatahi Bayat, Lu Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Calibrating language models (LMs) aligns their generation confidence with the
actual likelihood of answer correctness, which can inform users about LMs'
reliability and mitigate hallucinated content. However, prior calibration
methods, such as self-consistency-based and logit-based approaches, are either
limited in inference-time efficiency or fall short of providing informative
signals. Moreover, simply filtering out low-confidence responses reduces the
LM's helpfulness when the answers are correct. Therefore, effectively using
calibration techniques to enhance an LM's factuality remains an unsolved
challenge. In this paper, we first propose an activation-based calibration
method, ActCab, which trains a linear layer on top of the LM's last-layer
activations that can better capture the representations of knowledge. Built on
top of ActCab, we further propose CoDec, a confidence-guided decoding strategy
to elicit truthful answers with high confidence from LMs. By evaluating on five
popular QA benchmarks, ActCab achieves superior calibration performance than
all competitive baselines, e.g., by reducing the average expected calibration
error (ECE) score by up to 39%. Further experiments on CoDec show consistent
improvements in several LMs' factuality on challenging QA datasets, such as
TruthfulQA, highlighting the value of confidence signals in enhancing
factuality. | [
-0.0883683115,
-0.7217437029,
0.6627195477,
0.057312876,
-0.0500230081,
0.1818494648,
-0.2676279247,
-0.2673324347,
0.0308375806,
0.5431267023,
-0.2100466192,
-0.6046926379,
-0.425632596,
-0.1057433113,
-0.1074680462,
0.7098481059,
0.1349974275,
0.1065683439,
-0.3492696583,
-0.1894191355,
-0.519754827,
-0.5518885851,
-0.5109913945,
-0.381506145,
0.4150387645,
0.2678184211,
1.0599507093,
0.637732923,
0.0954335257,
0.1723622531,
-0.0410902165,
0.4235588312,
-0.5445988774,
-0.0424156412,
-0.0262371581,
-0.7842417955,
-0.4728861451,
-0.0751935169,
0.4188804328,
0.6755822897,
-0.3147957623,
-0.0034279115,
-0.0643708706,
0.6068804264,
-1.0442932844,
0.4811850488,
-0.54174155,
-0.1953440905,
0.3801190555,
-0.5482316613,
-0.8309673667,
-0.7453171015,
-0.2303174585,
-0.4349097013,
0.0364178531,
-0.1138752028,
0.7776943445,
0.4822680354,
-0.5978525877,
-0.3566937149,
-0.9537245035,
0.6665648222,
-1.0921250582,
0.465628475,
0.6706965566,
0.1117541492,
-0.1450833827,
-0.4876807928,
-0.5151689053,
-0.2650903761,
-0.0153564475,
0.1296809167,
0.2125753313,
0.2092140019,
0.4003497362,
0.3344851434,
-0.3940894306,
-0.160576731,
-0.1129342541,
-0.6417707205,
0.4870783985,
-0.1123270988,
0.2481128722,
0.0105022993,
-0.2338086218,
-0.3787055314,
-0.984631598,
0.3002732992,
0.4129365087,
0.1986771077,
0.2260416448,
0.3726234436,
-0.2245165706,
0.6654555798,
0.1822792441,
-0.3591055572,
0.3904950023,
-0.2571492791,
-0.1414132714,
0.3345995843,
0.368237704,
0.2225371301,
-0.0300004296,
-0.1230621785,
-0.2359019816,
0.0521141849,
0.2309595793,
-1.0078074932,
-0.2496718168,
0.4728597105,
-0.1117497236,
-0.3256344497,
0.0682461187,
-0.2605082095,
-0.2934812009,
-0.2160524577,
0.7385371327,
-0.4552668035,
-0.4487475157,
0.4241482615,
0.3687891066,
0.5606158972,
0.4223273993,
-0.7793700099,
0.1357803345,
0.57794559,
0.4189338088,
0.1372592151,
0.2424364835,
-0.6220151782,
0.0204923563,
-0.7786223292,
0.6120435596,
-0.4295943081,
-0.2194833755,
0.2369689941,
-0.0807480365,
-0.0761001408,
-0.3877536952,
0.8840222359,
-0.9616835713,
0.1915106177,
-0.6053676009,
-0.6309584379,
-0.5077599287,
0.4297917187,
-0.8548198342,
1.213203907,
-0.1658474952,
-0.5054329634,
0.0688561648,
-0.2166988701,
-0.372672081,
0.0796865225,
-0.3411856592,
-0.0850302055,
0.0945250317,
0.3421450853,
0.2973537445,
0.0764883161,
0.3544546664,
-0.1321191639,
-0.388278842,
0.3924787343,
-0.744289279,
0.615455687,
0.2335349023,
-0.3140004575,
-0.2299808115,
-0.8215836883,
0.483240515,
-0.1906364262,
-0.570483923,
-0.1243164763,
0.0161405485,
-0.341745615,
0.2893220484,
0.3563710749,
-0.5615662932,
-0.2229083627,
-0.6818482876,
-0.1185643449,
0.4218118489,
-0.0436740555,
0.2472789139,
-0.4796925783,
0.5347848535,
-0.0419970229,
-0.1341263801,
-0.3743983507,
-0.4319587946,
-0.8023327589,
-0.1031407267,
0.5682200193,
0.6609279513,
-0.8051590919,
0.6292265654,
-0.482967943,
-0.3957526088,
-0.7739046216,
0.220131591,
0.4522583783,
0.7689259648,
0.3151071966,
-0.503798604,
-0.2355241179,
-0.750442028,
-0.2012725025,
-0.4214952588,
0.0969279781,
0.3004635572,
-0.0117112044,
0.0759089813,
1.0847115517,
-0.4264698029,
0.0194290876,
-0.0303048901,
0.2658961713,
0.2871533632,
0.3907426,
0.2133567929,
-0.9830546975,
-0.3617005348,
-0.2067504525,
-0.5715260506,
-0.1815738231,
-0.1457501501,
0.057463292,
0.2223793864,
0.3605148494,
-0.4912070632,
0.5737296343,
0.6762691736,
-0.2040017098,
0.5604963303,
-0.3735638559,
0.5974869132,
-0.9911104441,
0.1221254244,
-0.2836840451,
-0.5928364992,
-0.7926765084,
0.0474732965,
0.3320898712,
0.2457514554,
-0.3536432981,
0.3351933658,
-0.3458306789,
0.1485072076,
-0.5468084216,
0.2291490138,
0.3393242955,
0.5977846384,
0.0771070421,
0.815713644,
0.4100778401,
-0.513002038,
0.3356261253,
0.1483713239,
-0.4164477587,
0.1678484976,
-0.3591352403,
0.2820399404,
-0.13121593,
0.3517479002,
-1.1143226624,
-0.0163784884,
0.0789197907,
-0.528642118,
0.3243187964,
-0.2283675224,
-0.638584733,
0.0931225047,
-0.2366901636,
0.6472498775,
0.5735875964,
-0.5576033592,
0.8471240997,
0.1148676276,
-0.0038367172,
-0.9127124548,
-0.7496560812,
0.2109973878,
0.3110893667,
-0.630384028,
0.2868631184,
-0.3719830215,
0.062244121,
-0.1113464162,
-0.4444119334,
0.0014751055,
0.0361270234,
0.2597541213,
0.3072957098,
-0.3382892311,
0.2375922948,
0.0243962724,
-0.0507197119,
0.3395347595,
0.0275332797,
0.5507914424,
-0.2479983568,
-0.6054973602,
-0.3898436725,
-0.0363221467,
0.4362215102,
-0.403329581,
0.9435113668,
0.5583853722,
-0.449093163,
-0.1583229154,
-0.8784442544,
-0.4327670038,
-0.4654540122,
0.1934535652,
-0.3646383286,
-0.7269784212,
0.5234442949,
-0.2505607009,
0.0008287227,
0.0490738824,
0.6971305013,
0.2462296635,
1.1706721783,
0.4736727476,
0.0533288196,
0.2289422899,
-0.1258990467,
0.4841364324,
-0.6448484659,
-0.2743642032,
-0.3902180493,
0.1086687446,
-0.327118963,
-0.6881812811,
0.1674782634,
0.0935865343,
0.2787160277,
0.178885892,
-0.1340920478,
0.4419701397,
0.2696579695,
0.5147542357,
0.378475368,
-0.0744930878,
-0.3301922679,
0.0260798056,
-0.821561873,
-0.6514083147,
1.1383295059,
0.4705937207,
0.838744998,
0.1395570636,
0.3797865808,
0.3166705966,
0.3528571427,
-0.7160772681,
0.5005867481,
0.2919325233,
-0.9467160106,
-0.062617667,
-0.4523276687,
-0.376396805,
0.1207834855,
-0.3495157957,
-0.4108026028,
0.4245044887,
0.4279712737,
-0.4618938267,
0.1138332263,
-0.7704904675,
0.6459171176,
-0.1541448683,
-0.5601552129,
-0.3487758636,
-0.551668644,
0.2889612019,
-0.0474887304,
0.3964141607,
-0.1210672036,
0.1271809787,
0.3615348637,
-0.3594419956,
0.8992658854,
-0.1564868391,
-0.5174735188,
0.3765299916,
0.244376272,
0.6487660408,
0.0107719563,
-0.3003145754,
-0.2340291589,
0.1952909976,
-0.406922549,
-0.9459684491,
0.7439699769,
-0.4094707668,
-0.726110816,
-0.2692610025,
-0.6154302955,
-0.5513019562,
0.0102924397,
-0.1356256753,
0.9234260321,
-0.0409247912,
0.4744210541,
1.0812327862,
-0.0884047076,
0.1560452133,
0.6225280762,
-0.1366937757,
-0.3195325732,
0.7915341258,
-0.1716255397,
0.6251857877,
0.4757839739,
0.0092296619,
-0.5262769461,
-0.5164587498,
-0.1817520857,
0.2022681385,
-1.1295222044,
-0.3043950498,
-0.5120535493,
-0.4177236557,
-0.5858977437,
0.1550140381,
-0.4017820358,
-0.4383012354,
-0.0596589521,
-0.3446112573,
0.1578877121,
0.1775979102,
-0.1484152228,
0.2460290492,
-0.683087647,
0.3338102996,
0.3308925629,
0.2227165103,
-0.2451944947,
-0.8008653522,
-0.4708191454,
0.4116802514,
-0.0014690243,
-0.9723939896,
0.2728212774,
0.1306676418,
0.4102554321,
0.4244942367,
0.3351777792,
0.6441136003,
-0.243789196,
0.6379913688,
-0.0765339732,
-0.8011083007,
0.4210609198,
0.1314840466,
0.2590583563,
0.7188242078,
0.2250701338,
-0.2993504405,
-0.415897429,
-0.5304567218,
-0.566586256,
0.5644260645,
0.337203145,
0.4566923082,
0.0674861223,
0.5180329084,
-0.1357284486,
0.2587252557,
-0.828265667,
-0.3437758684,
-0.3416891694,
-0.5809609294,
0.1108164266,
-0.4997409284,
-0.3315056562,
0.0919526815,
1.0548290014,
-0.4187323153,
-0.016870534,
0.3890410662,
-0.3070222735,
-0.094864957,
0.4290205836,
0.3941704631,
0.717682898,
-0.5043934584,
0.2330328673,
0.2392745614,
-0.5368227363,
0.0371703096,
0.0258605108,
-0.3185070157,
-0.0262719188,
0.3196290731,
0.8443062305,
0.2615368962,
-0.6669883728,
0.7420608997,
-0.1300020218,
0.0383787416,
-0.0913779736,
0.4074805975,
0.0200855471,
0.0350525863,
0.45609653,
0.0446327366,
0.0680379719,
-0.5328394771,
0.1370220333,
0.4424695671,
-0.4905007184,
-0.2484812289,
0.428230226,
0.2294997722,
-0.1978800595,
0.1940040588,
-0.0534090772,
-0.5985022783,
0.5391269922,
0.7201699018,
0.6339950562,
-0.3839064837,
0.2381473929,
0.5591403842,
0.5068440437,
-0.2804419994,
0.2951915562,
-0.1948354393,
-1.1485892534,
-0.7333405018,
-0.5361642838,
-0.5634214282,
0.1076219156,
-0.6936102509,
0.1782728881,
-0.3548609912,
-0.1849959493,
-0.5858073831,
0.2672781646,
-0.5222356915,
0.7273631692,
0.2165528238,
1.0924009085,
-0.7970440984,
1.0196803808,
0.5108041763,
-0.2359146476,
-1.2174651623,
-0.074383907,
-0.2355875969,
-0.8371756673,
0.3161654174,
0.2824868858,
-0.4995712042,
0.2922298908,
-0.7169332504,
-0.7220982313,
1.2536761761,
0.6052778959,
-0.2843768895,
0.038761545,
0.254345119,
0.5262541175,
-0.5098925233,
0.4448192418,
0.4567956626,
0.4273284674,
0.3673325479,
-0.5742102861,
0.2793891132,
-0.1253097355,
-0.0566140525,
-0.2806948423,
-0.2855436802,
0.2186390162,
-0.2107387036,
-0.443366915,
0.0212275218,
0.7483010292,
0.346036613,
0.0410808772,
0.5854615569,
0.5602601171,
0.7615740299,
-0.0614195764,
0.8862427473,
-0.7946146131,
0.324837625,
1.1159440279,
-0.2030157149,
0.8992167711,
0.3078736961,
0.1826169491,
0.8183197379,
0.3034367561,
0.284650594,
0.4431971908,
-0.2505883574,
-0.5892592072,
-0.7552323341,
-0.0833437443,
-0.2387048006,
0.2975927889,
0.454636395,
-0.1667806208,
-0.1248046085,
-0.1785977483,
0.1371021569,
0.3058244288,
-0.0633700714,
0.5383484364,
0.0269500352,
-0.7319833636,
0.7115761638,
0.097079128,
0.2583711445,
-0.7324621677,
-0.1642069519,
-0.3199324906,
-0.013711133,
-0.3888964951,
-0.6060074568,
-0.158218205,
-0.1660752892,
-0.0460102931,
-0.1026860625,
0.8801430464,
-0.7111264467,
-0.3156589568,
0.1143280864,
0.4435831308,
-0.0942664742,
-0.0755730867,
-0.5036768913,
0.1799667776,
0.0839988515,
-0.1771641672,
-0.1256932169,
0.2586776316,
0.4656692147,
0.742072463,
0.7853227854,
0.2368683219,
0.1089117154,
0.0296490751,
0.777351737,
-0.5377130508,
-0.3438529372,
-0.5410087109,
0.522016108,
0.0053921738,
0.1987692863,
0.6375968456,
0.5614874959,
0.6587936878,
0.0382840224,
0.567271471,
0.0848371089,
0.3312726319,
-0.7228468657,
0.6344992518,
-0.3614787757,
0.5741610527,
0.1125665829,
-0.7726681828,
-0.371301353,
0.5717777014,
-0.2918288112,
0.127029568,
0.7280890942,
1.3856861591,
0.0352375656,
-0.0667488128,
0.5493463278,
0.3950299919,
0.4279079437,
0.4749785066,
0.5974421501,
-0.7520768046,
0.6954494715,
-0.2232473642,
-0.3764072657,
-0.2863036692,
-1.084829092,
-0.7376825809,
-0.3991703987,
-0.5133315921,
-0.6151897311,
-0.0325141959,
0.8420798779,
0.8338519335,
-1.0410760641,
-0.0387799442,
0.1158327907,
0.1577860564,
-0.1041145697,
-0.2377559245,
0.3139446676,
-0.4568246305,
-0.6263228059,
0.5002129674,
0.2237222046,
-0.128320545,
-0.2429496497,
-0.2617951334,
-0.1947719008,
0.5873613358,
0.4923201203,
0.502874136,
-0.6484922767,
-0.5168374181,
-0.006219605,
-0.3774963915,
0.266607523,
0.5380587578,
-1.1506317854,
0.7198132277,
0.349237442,
0.8520076871,
0.3203626275,
0.3528548479,
0.6176701188,
-0.7707253098,
-0.0403366871,
0.1978710145,
0.1997450292,
0.5336657166,
-0.3172190785,
0.2342152596,
0.0111476332,
-0.4904040396,
-0.8748164177,
0.2375883162,
-1.0118187666,
0.0161562078,
1.2302881479,
-0.2574492395,
-0.2823076546,
-0.0533412956,
-0.3444080055,
0.2802087963,
-0.2368556261,
0.8445004821,
0.8387669921,
0.216230765,
-0.1495909393,
-0.443100363,
0.7296815515,
0.6768831015,
-0.8023373485,
0.2289311886,
0.6152664423,
0.2950832546,
0.3065919876,
0.4825926423,
-0.2712293863,
0.5003122091,
-0.2479475439,
0.1214717925,
-0.1313901097,
-0.2867830992,
-0.4331228435,
0.1708641052,
0.4012318552,
0.0893393233
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13229v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13229v1 | Probing the Emergence of Cross-lingual Alignment during LLM Training | 2024-06-19T05:31:59 | 2024-06-19T05:31:59 | Hetong Wang, Pasquale Minervini, Edoardo M. Ponti | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Multilingual Large Language Models (LLMs) achieve remarkable levels of
zero-shot cross-lingual transfer performance. We speculate that this is
predicated on their ability to align languages without explicit supervision
from parallel sentences. While representations of translationally equivalent
sentences in different languages are known to be similar after convergence,
however, it remains unclear how such cross-lingual alignment emerges during
pre-training of LLMs. Our study leverages intrinsic probing techniques, which
identify which subsets of neurons encode linguistic features, to correlate the
degree of cross-lingual neuron overlap with the zero-shot cross-lingual
transfer performance for a given model. In particular, we rely on checkpoints
of BLOOM, a multilingual autoregressive LLM, across different training steps
and model scales. We observe a high correlation between neuron overlap and
downstream performance, which supports our hypothesis on the conditions leading
to effective cross-lingual transfer. Interestingly, we also detect a
degradation of both implicit alignment and multilingual abilities in certain
phases of the pre-training process, providing new insights into the
multilingual pretraining dynamics. | [
-0.4366745651,
-0.4817988276,
0.4441693127,
0.3505291939,
0.1054353639,
0.2097680271,
-0.258847177,
-0.5746831298,
0.2618680894,
-0.0834584087,
-0.8301957846,
-0.152323544,
-0.5230927467,
0.0908804089,
-0.4002976716,
0.7575144172,
-0.1767060608,
0.3448372781,
-0.1153224036,
-0.1942530125,
-0.337798059,
-0.3263133764,
-0.4009828269,
-0.5684244633,
0.6281298995,
0.1196842045,
0.2744494677,
0.4158715308,
0.3343178034,
0.2490707636,
-0.1480844766,
-0.1507449895,
-0.556312263,
-0.0165648237,
-0.201172024,
-0.5354194045,
-0.4562081397,
-0.2469174713,
0.9286631346,
0.7589803338,
0.0449102223,
-0.0242902897,
0.2836173177,
0.2894719839,
-0.5823767185,
-0.1537461281,
-0.8198773265,
0.2452529818,
-0.5003540516,
-0.2649945617,
-0.3688701093,
0.0334812254,
0.1778352708,
-0.5585770011,
0.1639943868,
-0.1720791608,
1.1883541346,
-0.0024706821,
-0.3612572253,
0.0397836193,
-0.3522551954,
0.6255952716,
-0.6469855905,
0.4306950569,
-0.1028793529,
-0.0333148204,
-0.0057819351,
-0.1903380603,
-0.6478176117,
0.0002735162,
-0.3470220566,
0.1941927522,
0.0279983785,
-0.0143082514,
0.1544527858,
0.3175389767,
-0.8906000853,
0.4640386701,
-0.1259317994,
-0.3293125927,
0.3769174814,
0.0584419034,
0.6844306588,
0.0307159126,
-0.608609736,
-0.0290518031,
-0.7330794334,
0.1144705862,
0.4355126321,
0.367174983,
-0.2656007409,
0.4998131096,
0.1581744105,
0.7184399366,
0.0412889682,
-0.0163022391,
0.3072042763,
-0.6660535932,
0.0415377878,
0.4659101665,
0.9514485002,
0.0799441412,
0.5844676495,
-0.2311227769,
-0.1967734098,
-0.128523469,
0.1901833415,
-0.5177524686,
0.0108389957,
-0.031516172,
0.0601999424,
0.0097146491,
-0.1851396114,
-0.4776818454,
0.1191485897,
-0.3912232518,
0.5417332053,
-0.4806341231,
-0.3991957903,
0.0442125537,
0.1376799494,
0.6310151815,
0.0313419476,
-1.1568479538,
0.0962359309,
0.6750112772,
0.8870062232,
-0.5019429326,
-1.146178484,
-0.3132743537,
0.3087120354,
-0.544911921,
0.563116312,
-0.2319134176,
0.06396956,
0.2668904364,
0.3045274019,
-0.5435045958,
-0.3716875911,
-0.0453389287,
-0.8011629581,
-0.0201863293,
-0.4409454763,
-0.3559686244,
-0.0115484586,
0.4552372098,
-0.4184372425,
0.9954532385,
-0.1077151448,
-0.8044563532,
0.4914619625,
-0.4186519682,
-0.553996861,
-0.0902980566,
-0.393653512,
-0.1429394782,
0.1649316251,
0.2370751351,
0.2384559959,
-0.0202629045,
0.0887854099,
-0.2805316746,
-0.3773718774,
0.1439721286,
-0.2988743186,
0.819503665,
-0.2348319739,
-0.5897060633,
0.0799149945,
-0.4194262326,
0.1183020473,
0.0217234623,
-0.1060973629,
-0.1787775308,
-0.4370777905,
-0.1884027421,
0.262296468,
0.354349494,
-0.4941694438,
0.2937130034,
-0.2174268663,
0.1869597584,
0.7520993948,
-0.1604966521,
0.5405774117,
-0.3157297969,
0.4501641095,
0.3302969635,
-0.0584807061,
-0.4865022004,
-0.17108275,
-0.9556499124,
-0.0714661554,
0.1679011583,
0.6407474279,
-0.3478288949,
0.2579816282,
-0.6765953302,
-0.299656868,
-0.4261108339,
0.2435927987,
0.5512973666,
0.3912300766,
0.2675997913,
-0.4817504883,
-0.2410501987,
-0.9578068852,
-0.2216776162,
0.1111769453,
0.3590458035,
0.1434785724,
0.3864263594,
-0.153422147,
0.8230809569,
-0.1543857157,
-0.1650388092,
-0.0224410966,
0.3883466423,
0.1703569591,
0.6311362982,
0.6646162271,
-0.3057678044,
-0.6144746542,
0.5671700239,
-0.7632015347,
-0.2901876569,
-0.3259353042,
-0.3916113377,
0.227097258,
0.6868071556,
-0.4951701164,
0.1607076973,
0.6827018261,
-0.0742421448,
0.5858826637,
-0.2137627304,
0.2793383002,
-0.8309842348,
0.1536454707,
-0.4161761999,
-0.0159735996,
-0.6523312926,
-0.1152036116,
0.344471246,
0.1468810141,
-0.5148636103,
0.5018554926,
-0.9846785665,
-0.5875179172,
-0.195170626,
0.2589148581,
0.0419032089,
0.5244452953,
0.2485675663,
0.899436295,
0.864536643,
-0.4980717897,
-0.103678897,
0.1646704376,
-0.5027626157,
0.5173496008,
-0.562717557,
0.0884447172,
0.0337661356,
-0.0996201485,
-1.0933797359,
-0.0493816137,
-0.1286180764,
-0.4430566132,
0.7056055665,
-0.3197619021,
-0.3602739871,
0.0638863146,
0.1193711609,
0.9739918113,
0.2651859224,
-0.4747725725,
0.5342640281,
0.0058517321,
-0.1505616456,
-0.7991802096,
-0.878444016,
-0.0091552567,
-0.1118773744,
-0.5912672281,
0.4721027315,
0.2299714535,
0.0330589339,
-0.2677385807,
0.0626289546,
0.0969035327,
-0.0758600384,
-0.0096601499,
0.3007941544,
-0.5989819169,
-0.0786920041,
0.0068647671,
0.2575884163,
0.1457186937,
-0.2670171559,
0.8512242436,
0.0158817209,
-0.7021345496,
-0.3782649636,
0.1948447078,
0.7427483797,
-0.3823970556,
0.7313019037,
0.6048083305,
-0.1925887167,
0.0422383025,
-0.4992056489,
-0.0778592899,
-0.4524883628,
0.424785465,
-0.434768796,
-0.6856721044,
0.9225485325,
0.1997275203,
-0.0633479878,
0.3141828775,
0.3829442859,
0.0624175966,
0.5779078603,
0.653816402,
-0.0356633738,
0.554217875,
-0.0857745931,
0.0828131288,
-1.0427677631,
-0.2153982967,
-0.090796262,
-0.4608831108,
-0.2401483655,
-0.4574358761,
0.0833642483,
0.3546567857,
-0.3312401772,
0.306725651,
-0.0710761845,
0.5719267726,
0.2574190199,
-0.3151389658,
0.0966249779,
-0.0046480447,
-0.4178717732,
-0.2416180521,
-0.6299444437,
-0.0656232163,
0.8765493035,
0.1706002951,
0.5902724266,
0.1007398292,
0.5751558542,
-0.1876101643,
0.20242697,
-0.5813726783,
0.3612080514,
0.0185869783,
-0.5814166069,
-0.2401883602,
-0.3005908728,
-0.9342978597,
0.306771487,
-0.1022564545,
-0.8582471609,
0.3143086135,
-0.0081878109,
-0.329552114,
0.3466851115,
-0.5531211495,
1.0344438553,
-0.8773391843,
-0.5728142262,
0.0696249604,
-0.5532545447,
0.4386890829,
-0.3254535794,
0.1287222356,
-0.0550977401,
-0.0652360693,
0.5291315913,
0.0409063585,
0.7889714241,
0.1831200719,
-0.5383383036,
-0.074279651,
0.2014669478,
0.1579401344,
-0.228576228,
0.4058307111,
0.4439310133,
-0.1336572766,
-0.5465721488,
-0.4937791228,
0.8707368374,
-0.838493228,
-0.5067175031,
-0.5478066802,
-0.7103934884,
-0.3922499418,
0.4069984853,
0.4846956134,
0.2050043643,
-0.2488765419,
-0.2954517901,
0.6122092009,
-0.1155021116,
0.6938958168,
0.5346797705,
-0.594758749,
-0.2760397196,
0.7626073956,
0.1923422366,
0.7629457712,
0.5490580201,
-0.1957638413,
-0.1354315728,
-0.6382539272,
-0.5715657473,
0.5191579461,
-0.5257794261,
0.061640799,
-0.5207941532,
-0.360119909,
-0.7523142099,
-0.2547733784,
-0.4982687235,
-0.0616399981,
-0.2831028402,
0.0233667679,
0.1159667075,
0.6229833961,
-0.279938817,
0.3915984631,
-1.0262187719,
-0.0910994038,
0.3028550744,
0.2213460654,
0.1716551185,
-0.7436563373,
-0.3114999831,
0.1355699301,
-0.0447858721,
-0.8142060637,
0.4150250852,
0.4985034466,
0.651342392,
0.7080910206,
-0.4605656266,
0.9831866622,
-0.8256499171,
0.7309863567,
0.3777015805,
-0.9852151871,
0.2746915817,
-0.5089811087,
0.5427536368,
0.429227978,
0.6781615615,
-0.5267028213,
-0.0990328714,
-0.1246181875,
-0.8647074699,
0.8160773516,
-0.0918179452,
0.1296842396,
-0.0420196354,
0.2725682259,
0.0762103423,
0.0563135743,
-0.8970584869,
-0.1021206155,
-0.0297082551,
0.2167416513,
-0.3260998428,
-0.0683628768,
-0.4188262224,
-0.1232693642,
0.3083238602,
-0.2887567282,
0.2054945529,
0.1203597337,
-0.4049932957,
-0.1126904711,
0.0404047705,
0.7845509052,
0.5944002867,
0.0599512681,
0.2083967924,
0.3061435521,
-0.4044728279,
0.2797557116,
-0.1013503373,
-0.0516461134,
-0.014265609,
0.6957212687,
0.8769637346,
0.5805650949,
-0.562752068,
0.5968018174,
0.0620774515,
-0.2274152488,
-0.2498003542,
-0.1448464096,
0.1631499231,
0.2206075639,
0.2175298184,
-0.1343401223,
-0.301276058,
-0.6933482885,
0.250818342,
0.5368946791,
-0.5030811429,
-0.5351058245,
0.3935992122,
-0.2310966998,
-0.151052922,
0.8579095602,
0.0095358528,
-0.8673490286,
0.4294409156,
0.5938846469,
0.8401700258,
-0.3245014548,
-0.0791104659,
0.4660071135,
0.3734207451,
0.0183673743,
0.008723516,
-0.0984700844,
-0.9479456544,
-0.6825184226,
-0.782656014,
0.1232502013,
-0.201642856,
-0.9350470901,
0.2803793848,
-0.0195440296,
0.0244058687,
-0.2134672552,
-0.4732781351,
-0.438929379,
0.0278318338,
0.5221090913,
0.8137074113,
-1.07183671,
0.8801068664,
0.4701082408,
-0.1849656105,
-0.7912043929,
0.2263249457,
-0.0073340703,
-1.0776150227,
0.9358588457,
0.374600023,
-0.283375442,
0.0221316833,
-0.0669991449,
-1.0825027227,
0.930301249,
0.611525774,
-0.7283596992,
-0.2985074222,
0.4650797248,
0.4952056408,
-0.235494867,
0.3881081045,
0.4403779507,
0.3369548917,
0.1778516173,
-1.205368638,
-0.0941403806,
-0.276604861,
-0.1619492918,
0.4621446431,
-0.613188982,
0.9533330202,
-0.125739485,
-0.2924794853,
-0.086141333,
0.5728238821,
0.0367700718,
-0.1327590793,
0.3784245849,
0.9913446307,
0.517991662,
-0.2520776093,
0.7538003922,
-0.5682175756,
0.1632730961,
1.1674674749,
-0.3761027753,
1.0079703331,
0.7197010517,
-0.0438340195,
0.4498465657,
0.7459148765,
0.0970579088,
0.5240393281,
0.2116268277,
-0.1843559295,
-0.3264761865,
-0.016190853,
-0.5011039376,
0.2898395956,
0.2635144591,
-0.1776293963,
-0.2052790523,
-0.0321149305,
-0.0547742769,
-0.2877853513,
-0.3453392088,
0.7573323846,
0.0236786623,
-1.053063035,
0.7561685443,
-0.668976903,
0.9261677265,
-0.8321734667,
0.2224333137,
-0.3024891019,
0.13267304,
-0.1781598777,
-0.909473896,
0.3866949379,
-0.3435677588,
-0.0962432101,
-0.4876258969,
0.0977036878,
-0.6929168701,
-0.0959065482,
0.8590576053,
0.4447925985,
0.331400007,
0.157442987,
-0.59783113,
0.0604952611,
-0.026559053,
-0.0499197207,
0.7762557268,
0.5806658268,
0.189176932,
0.230644688,
0.5765242577,
0.3139855266,
0.6974618435,
0.2279516608,
0.5424644947,
-0.4820629954,
-0.2219804227,
-0.9004394412,
0.4254640639,
0.1110736579,
-0.5519814491,
0.8025567532,
0.6798318624,
1.2171365023,
0.0819942206,
0.3176037073,
0.1842637509,
0.0526283197,
-0.7647094131,
0.8988915086,
-0.8960453272,
0.0241375472,
-0.1097914204,
-0.9088728428,
-0.0493326485,
0.4287312925,
-0.3694044948,
-0.0287462194,
0.8667365909,
0.9098681808,
-0.3003848195,
-0.292604059,
0.3970301747,
0.2653886974,
0.11849273,
0.6534905434,
0.901061058,
-0.2619862854,
0.5741584301,
-0.1523269415,
-0.0298689958,
0.0409987494,
-0.8369329572,
-0.7559873462,
-0.5109111667,
-0.2829770744,
-0.1250789016,
-0.0563115217,
0.3688582778,
0.6042187214,
-0.7772325277,
-0.5248011351,
-0.2850521505,
-0.3350127041,
-0.1428018361,
-0.2022393495,
0.2408281118,
-0.8173797727,
-0.720590353,
0.4425789118,
0.3592059612,
0.3699398339,
-0.3348297775,
-0.0192634147,
-0.6686444283,
-0.1862782389,
0.0897429585,
0.5198624134,
-0.5938914418,
-0.0436624587,
0.3628896177,
-0.3112352192,
0.2506472468,
0.8789668679,
-0.291749686,
0.3758565784,
0.5029230714,
0.8413729072,
0.477627933,
-0.3694135845,
0.8652944565,
-0.6863328815,
0.137793377,
0.0919091925,
0.545273304,
0.3824641109,
-0.1741764694,
0.061917223,
0.0943625122,
-0.6318808794,
-0.9289137721,
0.2285689116,
-0.9042596221,
-0.0630444437,
1.0340527296,
-0.3751313388,
-0.3762565851,
0.2109949291,
0.1365565807,
0.2316070199,
0.1690006107,
0.5411595106,
1.0228725672,
-0.2238211036,
-0.1891657561,
-0.3221722543,
0.3322193325,
0.8754931688,
-0.5387782454,
-0.0389731899,
0.1403441727,
0.3564478159,
0.4608076811,
0.3729030788,
-0.1412247717,
0.3307766318,
-0.0080417944,
0.1152675599,
0.4449999928,
-0.3153787255,
-0.6049768925,
-0.0390378945,
0.137946412,
-0.1777971536
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13219v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13219v1 | MC-MKE: A Fine-Grained Multimodal Knowledge Editing Benchmark Emphasizing Modality Consistency | 2024-06-19T05:15:21 | 2024-06-19T05:15:21 | Junzhe Zhang, Huixuan Zhang, Xunjian Yin, Baizhou Huang, Xu Zhang, Xinyu Hu, Xiaojun Wan | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.CL | Multimodal large language models (MLLMs) are prone to non-factual or outdated
knowledge issues, which can manifest as misreading and misrecognition errors
due to the complexity of multimodal knowledge. Previous benchmarks have not
systematically analyzed the performance of editing methods in correcting these
two error types. To better represent and correct these errors, we decompose
multimodal knowledge into its visual and textual components. Different error
types correspond to different editing formats, which edits distinct part of the
multimodal knowledge. We present MC-MKE, a fine-grained Multimodal Knowledge
Editing benchmark emphasizing Modality Consistency. Our benchmark facilitates
independent correction of misreading and misrecognition errors by editing the
corresponding knowledge component. We evaluate three multimodal knowledge
editing methods on MC-MKE, revealing their limitations, particularly in terms
of modality consistency. Our work highlights the challenges posed by multimodal
knowledge editing and motivates further research in developing effective
techniques for this task. | [
-0.3567700088,
-0.7731458545,
0.5750337839,
0.1680753976,
0.1426898837,
0.0873340815,
-0.3664431274,
-0.2633671165,
-0.0281574409,
0.2407883704,
-0.430277586,
-0.4154137671,
-0.6181159019,
0.2875168025,
0.2358995825,
0.5149977207,
-0.3264996111,
0.2660700679,
-0.4956073761,
-0.4897368848,
-0.6585938931,
-0.4129578173,
-0.4848153889,
0.1290691495,
0.8236495852,
0.5399779677,
0.8122372627,
0.5810343027,
0.6937364936,
0.350923866,
0.0235893335,
0.7382696271,
-0.1894542426,
0.1088868976,
-0.3962290585,
-0.2330533564,
-0.7654547095,
0.0075919861,
0.7402643561,
0.5496596098,
0.0707863048,
0.1400513053,
-0.0268859547,
0.7091341019,
-1.1231663227,
0.3014799953,
-0.5334911942,
-0.087173149,
-0.1863584965,
-0.0311814919,
-0.5349488258,
-0.2587896883,
-0.3713333309,
-0.6702084541,
-0.0045433817,
-0.009647266,
0.464351505,
0.313601613,
-0.6881427169,
-0.0622598752,
-0.5538516641,
0.7020477653,
-0.5571666956,
0.9437001348,
0.5487280488,
0.4685875475,
-0.0793788359,
-0.5553225279,
-0.7300086021,
-0.0998678058,
-0.0361101031,
0.0150835263,
-0.1173304319,
0.1384167671,
0.2620654702,
-0.0955365747,
-0.2987519503,
-0.1988530308,
-0.0404797085,
-0.5495727062,
0.3156621456,
0.0482970215,
0.1332379729,
-0.3829882741,
-0.2355370075,
-0.2727681994,
-0.3543951809,
0.0257247388,
0.0684761554,
-0.0689279661,
0.1692653894,
1.0472613573,
-0.3492371142,
0.5958890319,
-0.1236494482,
-0.6364340782,
0.3291070163,
-0.3886774182,
-0.3784441948,
-0.0871781334,
0.6293965578,
0.9394376874,
0.0509014539,
-0.2322581559,
-0.1551179588,
0.0403328203,
0.091187641,
-0.4740380943,
-0.0730678514,
-0.1166928858,
-0.4875747561,
-0.1440977752,
-0.0883837789,
-0.7697008252,
-0.5976031423,
-0.3214932382,
0.7786917686,
-0.6068424582,
0.0406931825,
-0.001070751,
-0.2729808688,
-0.4596424699,
0.6081913114,
-0.6321485639,
-0.0340889618,
0.4276409447,
0.5642609,
0.1570902616,
-0.6379811764,
-0.4155533016,
0.5152509212,
-0.1493877172,
0.7542475462,
-0.7586545348,
-0.2647248507,
-0.3298376799,
0.1016026735,
-0.4439648688,
-0.5201128125,
0.6467059255,
-0.2116764188,
-0.088367492,
-0.625833571,
-0.5825914741,
-0.2995489836,
0.6288772821,
-0.6370397806,
0.8357927799,
0.1482040882,
-0.7249934673,
0.4516328871,
-0.635063529,
0.0428983159,
-0.5701669455,
-0.0462160707,
-0.3346255124,
0.1810909212,
0.3537839055,
0.384036243,
0.089509815,
0.3052021563,
-0.4649501145,
0.0916526467,
0.4471457005,
-0.7390695214,
0.164867714,
0.0319609046,
-0.1255230308,
0.1807693094,
-1.193010807,
-0.057665132,
-0.1214860231,
-0.396216929,
-0.4432618618,
0.0831979811,
0.0398861021,
0.4660257399,
0.3192821145,
-0.5696713328,
0.4482059479,
0.4849717617,
0.1206232905,
0.8477542996,
0.0325209908,
0.2971107066,
-0.4791838825,
0.1471197754,
0.5864849687,
0.4609636664,
-0.2962664068,
-0.3580899835,
-0.7047078609,
-0.3416353166,
0.4825513363,
0.4018217623,
-1.1316702366,
-0.3168016672,
-0.1883996874,
-0.4527696967,
-0.6203016043,
0.2979622781,
0.4904281199,
0.5396994352,
0.5551741123,
-0.2390453964,
-0.5948073268,
-1.0532753468,
-0.5771282911,
0.0530335866,
0.2863775194,
0.3459976614,
0.3472792804,
-0.7114090323,
0.8995062113,
-0.2653152049,
-0.2336426079,
0.3112003505,
0.3793232739,
-0.6600031257,
0.7752909064,
0.5019622445,
-0.5959718227,
-0.3474023044,
0.2315695435,
-0.6026673913,
-0.1483030021,
-0.1370293647,
-0.0468981899,
0.3174735904,
0.5054762959,
-0.5141259432,
0.1652287543,
0.7475205064,
-0.3415629864,
0.7893304229,
-0.2159058601,
0.8331588507,
-1.025387764,
0.0072704293,
-0.1441113055,
-0.2990274727,
-0.4533978403,
-0.1243370399,
0.6108239889,
0.1492718011,
-0.3951680064,
0.450540036,
-0.4640175104,
0.0631865337,
0.1410217583,
0.1861795932,
0.2478271425,
0.5018910766,
-0.2329030186,
0.7015679479,
0.2411085069,
-0.277921468,
0.1540015787,
0.0644348934,
-0.232883051,
0.9122176766,
-0.0631836057,
0.1458808482,
-0.2961223423,
-0.0551131554,
-0.7970627546,
-0.2005160302,
0.135616824,
-0.1317372471,
0.3412899971,
-0.1868211478,
-0.7122354507,
0.0854251236,
-0.3551291525,
0.7433477044,
-0.224538669,
-0.1104529202,
0.7983688712,
-0.0246655624,
-0.1422128528,
-0.8143985868,
-0.548125267,
0.1567931771,
0.2879886627,
-0.7203937769,
0.0689542368,
-0.3539349437,
-0.2586750686,
0.0339205302,
-0.1575157046,
-0.1812625974,
-0.2472186834,
0.0925978497,
0.075950861,
-0.4256183803,
0.1775779873,
0.2085123658,
-0.1047602072,
-0.294899106,
0.2333257049,
0.2414322346,
0.0748560652,
-0.7289712429,
-0.4862225056,
0.2246159762,
1.0683659315,
-0.2820679545,
0.6394884586,
0.7489139438,
-0.3444485664,
0.4525012076,
-1.1388893127,
0.1556577981,
-0.3840350509,
0.363158077,
-0.5403844118,
-0.7647075057,
0.421872735,
-0.2492179424,
-0.1071482077,
0.4487237632,
0.1064069048,
-0.0916239768,
1.0213786364,
0.5341008902,
0.2599658966,
0.3575269878,
0.0739508793,
-0.2425606847,
-0.9702472091,
-0.4058196843,
-0.4228307605,
-0.5157207847,
-0.3775054514,
-0.8667709231,
0.382452786,
0.4132567644,
-0.0886302069,
0.086935848,
0.0782994404,
0.5647072792,
0.4029072225,
0.1847156286,
0.6452972889,
-0.3075055182,
-0.4264034927,
-0.5105202198,
-0.6239078045,
-0.4920303226,
1.0071601868,
0.2351202071,
0.5984808803,
0.3086819947,
0.1156246737,
0.2442050427,
0.372505784,
-0.56985569,
0.4165242314,
-0.1070852876,
-0.5401530862,
-0.0207142755,
-0.603115499,
-0.2979597449,
0.4253146648,
-0.5621840358,
-0.492321223,
0.6341111064,
0.3354677856,
0.1175804362,
0.6874931455,
-1.0005646944,
1.3538630009,
0.0819742829,
-0.1449885368,
-0.2442537397,
-0.5853458643,
0.4098635614,
-0.0662466958,
0.4945452511,
-0.2262077928,
-0.1519626379,
0.3758138418,
-0.2821801901,
0.6453035474,
-0.2726952136,
0.0236837622,
-0.0736739635,
0.4976759255,
0.6776409745,
0.0631908998,
0.0101918634,
-0.066066131,
0.1410488039,
-0.4001080692,
-0.7328111529,
0.4479871392,
-0.606138885,
-0.1336915791,
-0.1164489016,
-0.7692400813,
-0.6773238182,
0.2431764603,
0.0303453058,
0.8571660519,
-0.3700964451,
0.2920664251,
0.6338783503,
-0.0771286264,
0.5259922743,
0.505540669,
-0.2867754996,
-0.7631993294,
0.8064107299,
0.261965245,
0.6205979586,
0.4904864132,
0.0662034974,
-0.1368895173,
-0.450986445,
-0.7055867314,
-0.0380671807,
-0.9187750816,
-0.2478234619,
-0.9711911082,
0.0437830091,
-0.3144047558,
-0.2781679928,
-0.5851832628,
-0.5099662542,
0.0778807923,
0.2997303307,
0.1404515654,
0.5568377376,
-0.2574987411,
0.1647195667,
-1.0365458727,
0.5446132421,
0.5988672972,
0.5860173702,
-0.1151214913,
-0.0794781297,
-0.1907228529,
0.3696556985,
-0.3302066624,
-0.6590699553,
-0.2216506898,
0.118413724,
0.4219256043,
0.2680689096,
-0.2538000047,
1.0028922558,
-0.5376266837,
0.6054794192,
0.3458797634,
-1.0838905573,
0.3500751257,
-0.2187689245,
0.5654103756,
0.7765398026,
0.116334483,
-0.9665926695,
-0.3614869416,
-0.3768689036,
-0.2086547166,
0.4211040139,
0.1730084419,
-0.3999985754,
-0.1452665031,
-0.0149825988,
0.1948162019,
0.420466125,
-0.6369798779,
-0.1529848278,
-0.3875995576,
-0.1452710181,
-0.3658477962,
-0.7146363854,
-0.1155736297,
-0.31870538,
0.6668528318,
-0.1429764479,
0.0316244699,
0.438751936,
-0.6524556875,
-0.2530653775,
0.6505684257,
1.2666484118,
0.8313160539,
-0.3137241304,
0.3327205479,
0.2352831066,
-0.7079182267,
0.0968276486,
-0.1079702079,
0.0398634449,
0.0824533999,
0.2297249585,
0.6466281414,
0.5869933963,
-0.6917580366,
0.5293886662,
-0.2279522568,
-0.1703783721,
0.4469247162,
-0.2083820254,
0.0345713757,
0.3725134134,
0.0823663846,
0.9955003858,
0.0216579232,
-0.5338122845,
0.0028457155,
0.2621414661,
-0.2857752442,
-0.0698096901,
0.6488296986,
-0.0350610018,
-0.0238337684,
0.1026672721,
-0.1082365811,
-0.1845652759,
0.0940205529,
0.3527146578,
0.6414694786,
-0.1931196302,
0.2078303248,
0.1111119241,
0.5757791996,
-0.0512517728,
0.1239653602,
0.0949030742,
-0.7563242912,
-0.5109658837,
-0.4421799481,
-0.4696515799,
-0.2294282615,
-0.4482801259,
0.1358765811,
-0.4459345639,
-0.2482758611,
0.1756176054,
-0.356285125,
-0.5596567392,
0.2773982882,
-0.1968369782,
0.8375142813,
-0.5080705881,
0.6602973938,
0.8116602898,
-0.273968935,
-0.5485695601,
-0.2967093587,
0.2886297405,
-0.5375135541,
0.4266158342,
-0.104324095,
-0.2386024594,
-0.1208244413,
-0.222180143,
-0.7081372142,
1.1321254969,
0.4658277035,
-0.684912622,
0.2026492804,
0.2765386701,
0.1296286136,
-0.2129284143,
0.138988629,
0.3738896251,
0.8991188407,
-0.0997221842,
-1.2667217255,
-0.2311351001,
-0.0974422023,
0.1725362539,
0.2962878644,
-0.6332991123,
0.7770114541,
0.0839745849,
0.0975147486,
-0.0947051048,
0.2041484118,
-0.1373439878,
0.5115559101,
0.3961680233,
0.8716903329,
0.654715836,
-0.1887274235,
0.6058837175,
-0.0890474617,
0.3972047865,
1.1530913115,
-0.0543712489,
0.8545470834,
0.4950493872,
0.1347460151,
0.368832618,
0.2015274316,
0.1603575945,
0.2708440721,
-0.5198803544,
-0.3166441917,
-0.1733721793,
0.0513194352,
-0.4587804973,
0.6354946494,
0.0096562151,
-0.3139530122,
-0.2940388024,
0.3618891835,
0.231531933,
0.119482033,
-0.5185061693,
0.7947804332,
-0.3381798267,
-0.3695805669,
0.3626201153,
0.2489186972,
0.5216488242,
-0.5228710175,
0.0872615576,
-0.1160662547,
0.2801342309,
-0.1681367904,
-0.6474071145,
0.2741549313,
-0.1163458526,
-0.6294880509,
-0.1391848326,
0.7625613213,
-0.5659345388,
-0.5682426095,
-0.0609459206,
0.5828052759,
-0.2903190255,
-0.3017874062,
-0.6244251132,
0.4124760926,
-0.0511490367,
0.0335616358,
0.2389803082,
0.7092642188,
0.0241883658,
0.6257362366,
0.5423474908,
-0.3502153158,
0.2989738584,
0.1022467613,
0.5624636412,
-0.7568831444,
0.0232642088,
-0.8650665879,
0.8461075425,
-0.1494852006,
-0.3892093003,
0.8395744562,
0.7921047807,
0.7842915058,
-0.388813585,
0.4565030038,
-0.034373939,
0.2593700886,
-0.7702550888,
0.7478336692,
-0.6442986727,
-0.1826388687,
-0.629116416,
-1.1185036898,
-0.3277719617,
0.2398217022,
-0.0748109072,
0.0104944482,
1.0055743456,
0.8897868991,
-0.3344308436,
0.0300051663,
0.6745015979,
0.4569443166,
0.0285837818,
0.2187541276,
0.6659343243,
-0.5666604042,
0.3171488047,
-0.5617182255,
-0.012496043,
-0.2594953775,
-0.8976732492,
-0.777074337,
-0.6571568251,
-0.354038626,
-0.2269065082,
0.1001993716,
1.0921859741,
0.567510128,
-0.5881636143,
0.1410078704,
0.3819190562,
0.1427363008,
-0.5519371033,
-0.1810956299,
0.0326488577,
-0.319139719,
-0.5830160975,
0.4479721487,
0.6904194355,
0.1989919096,
-0.1344760209,
-0.004798912,
-0.4250318706,
0.0999812186,
1.042252779,
0.0053535849,
-0.6952276826,
-0.5228228569,
-0.1740341783,
-0.2933005393,
0.239432618,
0.8892803788,
-0.3836750686,
1.0350885391,
0.2567692101,
0.679154098,
0.2476084977,
-0.0436499082,
0.2734221816,
-0.7774612904,
0.0836803392,
-0.063470535,
0.5606796145,
0.4262911081,
-0.030969644,
0.2850721776,
0.5339409113,
-0.629214406,
-0.6727540493,
0.1078378409,
-1.401463151,
-0.2209357768,
0.9016345739,
0.0086793015,
-0.1388146281,
-0.095416829,
-0.7863952518,
0.176335603,
-0.0656766519,
0.5291842818,
1.0509263277,
0.2208512276,
-0.4075586796,
-0.7561581731,
0.4353235066,
0.2573455274,
-0.6726801395,
0.1845731586,
0.9134541154,
0.3349773586,
0.1481722295,
0.3926327825,
-0.1248486787,
0.5629054308,
0.1832941771,
0.1521772742,
-0.3554601073,
-0.4356218576,
-0.0067722667,
0.1844639182,
0.0646402836,
0.0151002109
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13217v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13217v1 | Bridging Law and Data: Augmenting Reasoning via a Semi-Structured Dataset with IRAC methodology | 2024-06-19T04:59:09 | 2024-06-19T04:59:09 | Xiaoxi Kang, Lizhen Qu, Lay-Ki Soon, Zhuang Li, Adnan Trakic | cs.CL | cs.CL | The effectiveness of Large Language Models (LLMs) in legal reasoning is often
limited due to the unique legal terminologies and the necessity for highly
specialized knowledge. These limitations highlight the need for high-quality
data tailored for complex legal reasoning tasks. This paper introduces
LEGALSEMI, a benchmark specifically curated for legal scenario analysis.
LEGALSEMI comprises 54 legal scenarios, each rigorously annotated by legal
experts, based on the comprehensive IRAC (Issue, Rule, Application, Conclusion)
framework. In addition, LEGALSEMI is accompanied by a structured knowledge
graph (SKG). A series of experiments were conducted to assess the usefulness of
LEGALSEMI for IRAC analysis. The experimental results demonstrate the
effectiveness of incorporating the SKG for issue identification, rule
retrieval, application and conclusion generation using four different LLMs.
LEGALSEMI will be publicly available upon acceptance of this paper. | [
-0.2101056725,
-0.6975775957,
0.6889957786,
0.1046581417,
-0.2578460276,
0.1628296971,
-0.1292335093,
-0.3787648976,
-0.0962440223,
0.7053619623,
-0.2805283368,
-1.0680216551,
-0.2738617957,
0.0057034274,
-0.3864619434,
0.7464946508,
-0.1236140579,
0.123272799,
-0.468419373,
-0.4902136028,
-0.4950641096,
-0.3424116075,
-0.3093690276,
-0.2081161141,
0.1950822473,
0.5588994622,
0.4381650686,
0.7377115488,
0.4473083615,
0.327498436,
0.1298571676,
-0.0522540808,
-0.3994634151,
0.2155158669,
-0.1402876973,
-0.7175458074,
-0.4782387316,
0.0928288996,
0.5724101663,
0.7533321977,
-0.6600580215,
-0.0736489818,
-0.4607560933,
0.4524591863,
-0.7215250134,
0.146069631,
-0.474572897,
0.2487030774,
-0.3217170835,
-0.2416191697,
-0.3847527802,
-0.1886509657,
-0.1386218071,
-0.4879618585,
-0.0882745907,
0.4868265986,
0.71491009,
0.3351700604,
-0.5666796565,
-0.4874082208,
-0.7011834383,
0.5865003467,
-0.9608688951,
0.5325624943,
0.1504434347,
0.4848421514,
-0.3517069817,
-0.8455610871,
-0.5699498057,
-0.529291153,
0.0170053486,
0.525496304,
-0.1660281867,
0.0723004416,
0.5517594218,
-0.0402983166,
-0.5130521655,
0.3252098262,
-0.5182206631,
-0.1619279087,
0.8198675513,
0.3336006701,
0.3381778896,
-0.2535452247,
-0.5263196826,
0.1054647192,
-0.8093183637,
0.1259988695,
0.817748189,
-0.0060412409,
-0.1196136549,
0.8299834728,
-0.2658283412,
0.6538075805,
-0.360561043,
-0.1749301106,
0.3918135464,
-0.3667102456,
-0.1189274117,
0.4853617549,
0.6825819016,
0.4294991791,
0.1564282477,
-0.1397748291,
-0.2095181793,
-0.0806662589,
0.0963519141,
-0.5508455634,
-0.0429079831,
0.3178600669,
-0.541998148,
-0.0313821845,
0.2980108857,
-0.7802309394,
-0.3217720687,
-0.5720200539,
-0.173596561,
-0.3412596285,
0.0120527521,
0.2794651389,
-0.2120147943,
0.3809882104,
0.2046233714,
-0.055617094,
0.1628733128,
0.8028034568,
0.6234302521,
0.10687536,
0.1773480177,
-0.7188283205,
0.5556008816,
-0.3856550753,
0.9528748393,
-0.8845207691,
-0.2805113196,
-0.0138832033,
-0.2277532071,
0.0683676898,
-0.6053116918,
0.9961498976,
-0.5198128819,
-0.1623890251,
0.0185454674,
-0.7074911594,
0.0898618773,
0.3039631546,
-0.6786825657,
0.8378990889,
-0.0952755287,
-0.7088583112,
0.7845748067,
-0.750767827,
-0.6971864104,
0.5645033121,
-0.5267069936,
-0.4057123065,
-0.2244904637,
-0.0195875894,
0.5013478994,
-0.2393316925,
0.657897234,
-0.6595503688,
-0.0382267199,
0.1479721665,
0.2017107755,
0.8773498535,
0.7624613047,
-0.0171389226,
0.0112512726,
-0.7120248079,
-0.1158744693,
-0.1971550882,
-0.3851134777,
-0.5244858265,
0.1507404447,
-0.3972847164,
0.4112068117,
0.0060377363,
-0.5191619992,
-0.1575627774,
-0.1302991956,
0.6822172403,
0.5096248984,
-0.0013987465,
0.3401125371,
-0.1540219784,
0.5867733359,
0.2404202968,
-0.1144328117,
0.1212654263,
-0.2835645378,
-0.5472127795,
-0.3423449993,
0.6171866655,
0.7678333521,
-0.4882144928,
0.3541482985,
-0.3444617987,
-0.3127137721,
-0.5091164112,
0.2435419559,
-0.0167622305,
0.5058661103,
0.0300525986,
0.0981163383,
-0.8748958707,
-1.1560676098,
-0.4637588263,
-0.3889903724,
-0.0066652345,
0.4965806305,
0.6536750793,
-0.124715969,
0.8749870658,
0.0584172606,
-0.1970928311,
-0.5944061875,
0.4900488555,
0.144057408,
0.0975179002,
0.380513519,
-0.8047617674,
-0.2573380172,
0.0968164578,
-0.8986782432,
-0.4406219423,
-0.4063322544,
-0.3162274659,
-0.1834862828,
0.9080176353,
-0.3460614383,
0.6146529913,
-0.088274233,
-0.4133298695,
0.3569650352,
-0.305292815,
0.3652957082,
-1.0023466349,
-0.0028611666,
0.5000765324,
-0.3181604445,
-0.558372438,
0.0180986971,
0.1551522166,
0.0590815805,
-0.4526604116,
0.3527669013,
-0.2679147124,
-0.2390024662,
0.0871852487,
0.2317277491,
-0.18694067,
0.1059860587,
-0.020456573,
0.7288117409,
0.297645092,
-0.3952276111,
0.4012311697,
0.1734488308,
-0.654179275,
0.7733857036,
-0.5550118089,
-0.4206841886,
-0.1855987906,
0.1747262031,
-0.3456978798,
-0.2499068081,
0.1282224357,
-0.0795442909,
0.0633254051,
-0.4033401012,
-0.7879964709,
-0.215330705,
-0.1192929223,
0.2670403719,
0.4285667241,
-0.2898879945,
0.8948403001,
0.6616914868,
-0.0041613597,
-0.2307770848,
-0.5372119546,
0.4802108705,
-0.6832598448,
-0.6525723934,
0.1761797071,
0.1265006959,
-0.8145924807,
0.1881075352,
0.068271257,
0.1227702796,
0.0434536822,
0.4846513569,
0.129837811,
-0.1727578938,
-0.1402694583,
0.0254019275,
0.0018353555,
0.4838325977,
0.0842061639,
0.1208171919,
-0.0774733871,
-0.4396844506,
-0.2331984788,
0.4231478572,
0.2828111053,
-0.2931526303,
0.409144789,
-0.1226503104,
-0.4035545588,
-0.4525190294,
-0.5044752955,
0.3903162777,
-0.408370167,
0.0600040331,
-0.5143414736,
-0.8792048097,
0.6897580624,
-0.5223971009,
0.1075914279,
0.4094338119,
0.7328638434,
-0.4615900815,
0.8977572322,
0.1773738265,
0.0657198057,
0.2016481012,
-0.0795852393,
0.5509059429,
-0.6553649902,
-0.6736911535,
-0.7425406575,
-0.3245233297,
-0.5001405478,
-0.2759953141,
0.4212427735,
0.1202149093,
-0.1993502527,
0.3040846288,
0.2640368342,
0.5114904046,
0.5266161561,
0.0537858643,
0.4151086509,
-0.1808716208,
-0.377147615,
0.2993932664,
-0.9498988986,
-0.7065697908,
1.0828751326,
0.196673885,
0.7727074623,
0.0522766113,
0.5381721258,
0.5486963987,
-0.055224739,
-0.5934112668,
0.8341453075,
-0.0913512409,
-0.6231908798,
0.0128138456,
-0.7831730247,
-0.7170832157,
-0.1560567468,
-0.2235017419,
-0.6623920798,
0.2033133656,
-0.2736054957,
-0.5432987213,
0.3112705946,
-0.5288340449,
0.6064289212,
-0.2654253244,
-0.4834102392,
-0.2093941867,
-0.7307752371,
0.5581529737,
0.0513947606,
0.4671112001,
-0.43161726,
0.0410044417,
0.8138801455,
-0.6623510122,
0.4224973321,
-0.048625499,
0.1730600297,
0.663500011,
-0.0151808131,
0.363059938,
0.3325306177,
-0.1077477038,
-0.0605923906,
0.1093086973,
-0.2690994442,
-0.6287457943,
0.831759274,
-0.3840421438,
-0.5648249984,
-0.5723254681,
-0.811248064,
-0.323129952,
-0.0101383114,
-0.3164902031,
0.3412345946,
0.0615883693,
0.4253442287,
0.7306674719,
0.0294751339,
0.1499814093,
0.6060435772,
0.4331726432,
-0.0771967843,
0.4414632618,
0.1494101584,
-0.2535228431,
0.0516451672,
0.0709301904,
-0.4438763261,
-0.7196319103,
-0.2494566441,
0.0880091339,
-0.8339395523,
-0.3381786346,
-0.6890522242,
-0.1996160001,
-0.2759590447,
-0.0279120151,
-0.0493399315,
-0.1688090861,
0.2071643174,
-0.2519408166,
0.4085768461,
0.4241574109,
-0.1810236722,
-0.1030237526,
-0.5228669643,
0.3605261743,
0.0390520804,
0.4346546829,
-0.4802467823,
-0.3697939217,
0.0552974828,
-0.0678561404,
0.3154356778,
-0.6280604005,
0.0512644611,
0.0099277515,
0.8486329317,
0.5439302921,
0.3022806048,
0.9598535895,
-0.5640294552,
0.3307282329,
0.1200149059,
-0.5219503045,
0.8698641658,
-0.1472327411,
-0.1855274737,
0.7764732838,
0.2300975174,
-0.2366993278,
-0.5405564904,
-0.5693730116,
-0.8168839812,
0.5280131102,
0.4119338989,
-0.1654182822,
0.2026354671,
0.6665520668,
0.0354164541,
-0.0312509052,
-0.2216231972,
0.2398981601,
0.1400753111,
-0.4676987827,
0.2889208496,
-0.067618303,
-0.4145449996,
-0.47435987,
0.6713078022,
0.133987233,
-0.14858374,
-0.0877714604,
-0.3142778277,
0.1439714432,
0.3548223972,
0.4623818099,
0.8126837015,
-0.0954747796,
0.2373024374,
0.2351112515,
-0.1631110162,
0.0951595008,
0.0271708798,
-0.2501761019,
-0.1858727634,
0.6118123531,
0.7162699103,
0.1489320397,
-1.1655430794,
0.3927047253,
-0.0835067183,
-0.5959639549,
-0.3050334156,
0.3619348705,
0.0692871064,
0.5107952356,
0.2269098461,
-0.3040474057,
0.3002487123,
-0.7638319135,
0.4248778522,
0.3412014544,
-0.1231460422,
0.1647979617,
0.7199057937,
0.2458428144,
0.0358008146,
0.6244814396,
-0.0783027112,
-0.3344931304,
0.7553899884,
0.1890335083,
0.2385780215,
0.299402684,
0.1404258609,
0.3729979098,
0.2985857129,
-0.1540686637,
0.3600666225,
-0.1610820442,
-0.4811333716,
-0.410987854,
-0.3503549993,
-0.230894208,
0.0836195499,
-0.6638075113,
0.3906193674,
-0.3982662261,
0.1161159202,
0.056361828,
0.2152149826,
-0.7986380458,
0.0559636354,
-0.1165688783,
1.195089221,
-0.9807063341,
0.7293050885,
0.7333729863,
-0.3719603717,
-0.8504049182,
-0.3226039112,
0.1044531465,
-0.6814137697,
0.4756744504,
-0.0656349882,
0.0237774588,
-0.3274379969,
-0.7800505161,
-0.1174077094,
1.2486768961,
0.273191005,
-0.8372484446,
0.3066788316,
0.6151564717,
0.467422694,
-0.578791678,
0.0631195456,
1.0602310896,
0.6385294795,
0.4946731925,
-0.2147200555,
-0.0827205926,
-0.4464782476,
-0.0545293204,
0.1729147434,
-0.2048168629,
0.2203315049,
-0.1890605688,
-0.2902426124,
-0.1442154497,
0.7067158222,
0.6214289069,
0.6946293712,
0.5864792466,
1.0993643999,
0.7287447453,
-0.2378214151,
0.8558368087,
-0.3605717421,
0.0586107522,
1.2418156862,
-0.8120234013,
0.5256080627,
0.6650481224,
-0.1193629205,
0.5239337683,
0.7656213045,
-0.2424009442,
0.4076759517,
0.3648810387,
-0.2393768281,
-0.8271529675,
-0.2625451684,
-0.1080253571,
0.374373138,
0.2783896625,
-0.1016559154,
-0.4073539972,
0.0067145303,
-0.0156479552,
0.2676060498,
-0.3466359675,
0.856382072,
-0.0200693961,
-0.2979561687,
-0.3902744055,
0.183419466,
0.0221357215,
-0.423176527,
-0.2762801349,
-0.5463816524,
-0.1334600747,
-0.3041057587,
-1.1174935102,
0.1867978722,
0.4124324024,
0.2128065974,
-0.1996271461,
0.7406283617,
-0.1940195262,
-0.7741638422,
0.2151443064,
0.4956865013,
0.3385299742,
0.4770859182,
-0.7867904902,
0.0420462117,
-0.3935456872,
-0.0614534132,
0.1578151733,
1.0031690598,
-0.4024736285,
0.8496177793,
0.6010930538,
0.2421536744,
0.2372097075,
0.3274121583,
0.9160647392,
-0.5065662265,
-0.5248071551,
-0.6575520039,
0.6023283601,
-0.4743489027,
-0.1262868792,
0.6464534402,
0.9598170519,
0.8073982,
0.4525712132,
0.702809453,
-0.2759348452,
0.3523139358,
-0.8983324766,
0.4791939855,
-0.3761617541,
0.7078233957,
0.1717398912,
-0.7100937963,
-0.4505006671,
0.4831661284,
-0.4053447545,
0.0094765881,
0.4148501158,
0.8472426534,
-0.4260726869,
0.065646179,
0.2961100042,
-0.0130640585,
0.176815033,
0.5033069849,
0.9831787348,
-0.1141093671,
0.5519786477,
-0.159206599,
-0.1272038072,
-0.1330703497,
-0.9410113692,
-1.1310353279,
-0.3722226024,
-0.553473711,
-0.2453878671,
0.1196356267,
0.7275403738,
0.7009167075,
-0.8687310815,
-0.3251844049,
-0.1644277275,
0.0256501529,
0.157791242,
-0.1532224566,
0.0977159366,
-0.2487571388,
-0.3452237844,
0.4084861875,
0.3902888,
-0.3346443772,
-0.0317797586,
-0.4463488758,
-0.5014426112,
0.251013875,
0.283293277,
0.2488383651,
-0.5522863865,
-0.1986855417,
-0.3313856125,
0.0210333895,
0.1461535543,
1.3383178711,
-0.6288623214,
0.4173453748,
0.4618275464,
0.6107733846,
0.3447704315,
0.1264061332,
0.5129342675,
-0.4840808511,
0.1301977038,
0.3804613054,
0.791256547,
-0.1972111762,
-0.0972787216,
0.6774955988,
0.0435524993,
-0.1006501913,
-0.8352612853,
0.0069024749,
-0.9444974661,
-0.4770832956,
1.0373573303,
-0.2745934427,
-0.3798197806,
-0.2143987268,
0.2099060863,
0.1920414865,
-0.4165839255,
0.6023054123,
0.9005299807,
-0.063810505,
-0.3112108707,
-1.1684951782,
0.145584166,
0.1338437051,
-1.2793393135,
-0.1578636765,
0.6549524665,
0.2079093903,
-0.3051776886,
0.1783776581,
-0.3137960434,
0.0679317415,
-0.1110071018,
-0.1266349554,
-0.2765000463,
-0.5145851374,
-0.0519183166,
0.2545888126,
-0.3310441077,
0.1655326784
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13213v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13213v1 | Multi-Meta-RAG: Improving RAG for Multi-Hop Queries using Database Filtering with LLM-Extracted Metadata | 2024-06-19T04:53:48 | 2024-06-19T04:53:48 | Mykhailo Poliakov, Nadiya Shvai | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.DB | The retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) enables retrieval of relevant
information from an external knowledge source and allows large language models
(LLMs) to answer queries over previously unseen document collections. However,
it was demonstrated that traditional RAG applications perform poorly in
answering multi-hop questions, which require retrieving and reasoning over
multiple elements of supporting evidence. We introduce a new method called
Multi-Meta-RAG, which uses database filtering with LLM-extracted metadata to
improve the RAG selection of the relevant documents from various sources,
relevant to the question. While database filtering is specific to a set of
questions from a particular domain and format, we found out that Multi-Meta-RAG
greatly improves the results on the MultiHop-RAG benchmark. The code is
available at https://github.com/mxpoliakov/Multi-Meta-RAG. | [
-0.8187135458,
-0.7668697834,
0.6107102036,
-0.0502204411,
-0.2496156693,
0.422449708,
0.0585370548,
-0.6624428034,
0.649887383,
0.9268302917,
-0.5890192389,
-0.3566537797,
-0.4901219904,
0.2005129606,
-0.2815147042,
1.0243108273,
0.3113197386,
0.0378348343,
-0.3332919776,
-0.3114631176,
-0.3750181198,
-0.368799597,
-0.66729182,
-0.2613400817,
0.7066073418,
0.5874155164,
0.44145751,
0.4681220353,
0.7955915928,
0.248375088,
-0.1609039903,
0.7616050839,
-0.2424988598,
0.6319004297,
-0.2607381046,
-0.3912436664,
-0.7504718304,
-0.1018141061,
0.6174960136,
0.3457648158,
-0.088160038,
0.5668332577,
-0.0491229631,
0.9517144561,
-0.9926062226,
-0.2383007854,
-0.8160760403,
-0.2775551081,
-0.5078557134,
-0.7082639337,
-0.4710308015,
-0.2445663065,
-0.308947444,
-0.5643563867,
0.3229528069,
0.1710133553,
0.6628717184,
0.2881074548,
-0.6565699577,
-0.3546475172,
-0.8226584792,
0.6177850962,
-0.2964425981,
0.4751673639,
0.6000068784,
0.6058908105,
-0.1433524638,
-1.0328270197,
-0.4360646307,
-0.0613521002,
-0.3343685567,
0.2016154826,
0.3424948156,
-0.1365860105,
0.4649983644,
0.2706865072,
-0.4842975736,
-0.4099606574,
-0.1954774857,
-0.142842561,
0.5017327666,
0.1840399206,
0.0417934544,
-0.3854511678,
-0.2996456027,
-0.0465459339,
-0.6462773085,
-0.0726005062,
0.370085746,
0.2820210755,
0.6191542745,
0.6325641274,
-0.2873716354,
0.9528719187,
-0.0111294296,
-0.4731836021,
0.2121413052,
-0.4190826118,
0.0482036173,
-0.4131378829,
0.4514149129,
0.2935020328,
-0.2175903767,
-0.0768894702,
-0.1563317925,
-0.2806132138,
0.2975552976,
-0.6725024581,
0.0856255069,
0.2431622446,
-0.6137523055,
-0.223219946,
0.1737242192,
-1.2227216959,
-0.69020468,
-0.1982819885,
0.3979408741,
-0.2965642214,
-0.4557167888,
-0.0788961798,
-0.3852162957,
0.4810351431,
0.2762361765,
-0.4780702293,
0.4295284152,
0.77856493,
0.6518663168,
-0.0145319141,
-0.1574337929,
-0.9859967232,
0.3619719744,
-0.1657370776,
1.2198919058,
-0.7667797804,
-0.3973384798,
-0.3255721927,
-0.0384643301,
-0.0006953767,
-0.5734331012,
0.8972982168,
-1.0149978399,
0.1568178982,
-0.3720303774,
-0.2870756984,
-0.1650203913,
0.4897731841,
-0.9958279133,
1.2843313217,
-0.0915067121,
-1.0119864941,
0.3063509762,
-0.71645087,
-0.3915972114,
-0.0330602266,
0.0896620452,
-0.3950878978,
0.021265734,
0.3648689985,
0.0826008618,
-0.6895309687,
0.176983282,
-0.3494817317,
-0.2823061645,
0.1226627752,
-0.1139113605,
0.8111460805,
0.3579937816,
0.0705627128,
-0.1387977898,
-0.9210803509,
0.1894816607,
0.1315875798,
-0.6636747718,
-0.5765711069,
0.0750743076,
-0.137133196,
0.3050260544,
0.07481087,
-0.3984595537,
0.3047207892,
-0.1617574543,
-0.3802670538,
0.4644471705,
0.2672686875,
0.4489126205,
-0.617898941,
0.6327669024,
-0.2226991206,
-0.0166487563,
-0.4380551875,
-0.5625830889,
-0.5177966356,
-0.3646696508,
0.4928279519,
0.5263563395,
-1.0068049431,
-0.0861399397,
-0.1390139461,
-0.3789280057,
-0.6304445863,
0.0768734366,
0.1850842983,
0.5904161334,
0.5681192875,
-0.1610026211,
-0.8614336252,
-0.488027662,
-0.7232771516,
0.1554254889,
0.0344019048,
0.7451847196,
0.3297631741,
-0.3673963845,
0.9790853858,
-0.6715129018,
-0.2323496193,
0.0463749133,
0.2918250859,
0.2981088758,
0.0416724011,
0.4396961331,
-0.9848800898,
-0.8944073319,
-0.0469762422,
-0.3766281903,
-0.4398714304,
0.1963883787,
-0.3286308348,
0.2470704317,
0.5556228757,
-0.646155715,
0.1747311652,
0.4702001214,
-0.3543375134,
0.7147238851,
-0.0613686591,
0.4130506814,
-1.2811926603,
0.3633017838,
-0.5021355152,
-0.5085772872,
-0.6035234332,
0.2678623497,
0.1593882889,
0.004719391,
-0.1950775981,
0.6111044288,
-0.7069017887,
-0.4039807916,
-0.6533095837,
0.2487089932,
0.3723120093,
0.1170928776,
-0.0765528381,
0.7367572188,
0.4783328176,
-0.7222274542,
0.4673693776,
0.0354321636,
0.0378394425,
0.6566328406,
-0.1450868845,
0.3193892539,
-0.3392200172,
0.4985966384,
-0.9513176084,
-0.2388530672,
0.1118048131,
-0.5719880462,
0.5316019654,
-0.6488503218,
-0.5595282912,
-0.2609142363,
-0.5503447652,
0.1304909736,
0.1206400096,
-0.5962472558,
1.1176377535,
0.4353674352,
0.0475820936,
-1.0286666155,
-0.3655519783,
0.1648975909,
-0.3218546212,
-0.5657336712,
0.4960074127,
-0.0946094617,
-0.1922020018,
0.2219055891,
-0.1718484908,
-0.2534044981,
0.0801565573,
-0.1025608182,
0.1987689584,
-0.1639111936,
0.2750438452,
-0.0246266201,
-0.3255367577,
-0.0624304637,
-0.2023471594,
0.6961781383,
0.1424735934,
-0.315358758,
0.3788456321,
0.4282675087,
0.6305993795,
-0.6630982161,
0.8710237741,
0.9666600227,
-0.1180784255,
-0.1996499598,
-0.7076640129,
-0.1786079854,
-0.4705817103,
-0.0405225083,
-0.6181817055,
-0.7115334272,
0.3769964576,
-0.5576899648,
0.0357408412,
0.6655483246,
0.2850296497,
-0.2494884282,
0.7321690917,
0.4654183984,
0.2123415917,
0.3323622942,
-0.2887409329,
-0.2046571374,
-1.2653223276,
-0.0974326059,
-0.8323963881,
-0.2437485904,
-0.8532349467,
-0.6083276868,
0.5383683443,
0.0466938168,
-0.0415303707,
0.10861063,
-0.3985072374,
0.6296117902,
0.7514484525,
0.1098332331,
0.7122026086,
-0.137831986,
-0.1606496423,
0.1626054943,
-0.4328998625,
-0.2738941908,
1.2912460566,
-0.0933087841,
0.8109019399,
0.3453588784,
0.847638309,
0.0339471735,
0.3054039776,
-0.5255375504,
0.4652147591,
-0.159215495,
-1.0536301136,
-0.1670186967,
-0.5741155148,
-0.9275329113,
0.6614344716,
-0.5835584998,
-0.3714745641,
0.1072983518,
0.0292302985,
-0.0972914994,
0.4248134494,
-0.428515017,
0.3784690797,
-0.368825227,
-0.3012681305,
-0.020558143,
-0.7206813097,
0.5863108039,
-0.4630054533,
0.4544425309,
-0.0945163518,
-0.2042862922,
0.4869939089,
-0.2443255782,
0.447496146,
-0.3669737875,
0.1901060492,
0.531472683,
0.1296685934,
0.7079219222,
0.0741579831,
-0.0972936526,
-0.1848942935,
-0.0436766148,
-0.0529012866,
-0.5803447962,
0.3564445376,
-0.3318369985,
-0.5152347088,
-0.4764004648,
-0.507617414,
-0.3445254266,
0.4838283658,
0.129734993,
0.2599127293,
0.1219743788,
0.359010309,
0.7352228761,
-0.3214973807,
0.3667436838,
0.8137176633,
-0.6052767634,
-0.5532189012,
0.6912564039,
0.1351673901,
0.0343475826,
0.7081050873,
0.3815786839,
-0.3314624727,
-0.2626165748,
-0.3331950307,
0.2476173192,
-0.6714237928,
-0.6394892335,
-0.9564750791,
-0.1829260588,
-0.5055275559,
0.4146799147,
-0.3159817457,
-0.6661965847,
0.0045758579,
0.2210767865,
0.4597837031,
0.5587429404,
-0.2944916785,
0.2934723198,
-1.1234232187,
0.8494159579,
0.2976906598,
0.5984986424,
-0.2812963426,
-0.5525235534,
-0.3072193563,
-0.2532477677,
-0.3870993555,
-1.1335434914,
0.0933983251,
0.3569612205,
0.6914696693,
0.0284803938,
0.1644882709,
0.7233412266,
-0.8182384968,
0.2927921414,
-0.2862105072,
-0.5669112802,
0.6295067668,
-0.3443329334,
0.1790881157,
0.5392540693,
0.3976335227,
-0.4482682049,
-0.2515752912,
-0.5004936457,
-0.9361419678,
0.7899572849,
-0.0924461186,
-0.2227087021,
0.1705960482,
0.4558723569,
-0.030574929,
0.0801668912,
-0.6790499687,
-0.503056407,
0.0749113858,
0.3520665765,
0.0828828514,
-0.5831597447,
-0.1235723421,
-0.0179832727,
0.7284780741,
-0.2094509155,
0.219248116,
0.0775952637,
-0.157090649,
-0.2601982057,
0.2327951044,
0.5013308525,
0.636200428,
-0.3374512792,
0.1994921863,
0.2153735012,
-0.6199849844,
0.0436554998,
0.1688256115,
-0.046582412,
0.2169210762,
0.3049209416,
0.3156227767,
-0.1970283836,
-0.2611452043,
0.2653582394,
-0.2877748609,
-0.0477264039,
-0.0810199007,
0.0072662788,
0.1980325133,
0.2770334184,
0.6046432853,
0.102920033,
0.5218751431,
-0.4251631796,
0.4707194567,
0.6260877848,
0.3656765819,
0.1735560745,
0.5986074209,
-0.0500525758,
-0.3231130242,
0.2909180522,
-0.1081473753,
-0.416814208,
0.2955402732,
0.6211590767,
0.7791503072,
-0.4764779806,
0.146200493,
0.5371629,
0.5107697248,
0.0835128129,
0.4851113856,
-0.1582322568,
-0.6934041381,
-0.7526536584,
-0.8251223564,
-0.6673411727,
-0.0634416118,
-0.5536852479,
0.3914042413,
0.0765455067,
-0.419624567,
-0.0488544665,
0.2437499166,
-0.4402635098,
0.1661704183,
-0.2095039189,
0.8610123396,
-0.5633565187,
0.7571888566,
0.8286702037,
-0.261682868,
-0.5795637369,
0.1231369004,
-0.0486713089,
-0.4576302767,
0.4725640416,
-0.0427300371,
-0.3675047755,
-0.1437194198,
-0.2157658786,
-1.3370606899,
1.1196093559,
0.3091667891,
-0.2623900473,
0.1274484098,
0.0950165838,
0.4260474443,
-0.0851234794,
0.4350411296,
0.4861360192,
0.7669170499,
0.3419604897,
-0.8059588671,
-0.3398644924,
-0.1228900924,
-0.2808843553,
0.5366595984,
-0.4669439197,
0.8792779446,
0.0025034475,
-0.040381413,
-0.3091106117,
0.3129370213,
0.4098711312,
0.5818120837,
0.5453302264,
0.6509570479,
0.9464896321,
-0.086255312,
1.0693119764,
-0.3884913921,
0.3925057352,
1.4574038982,
-0.3015064001,
0.7556764483,
0.3324086368,
-0.1130824834,
0.5516964793,
0.4452166855,
0.3122877181,
0.4293014407,
-0.0819528103,
-0.3435587287,
0.0955386609,
0.0911798701,
-0.3270594776,
0.6898251176,
0.4120994508,
-0.1968608797,
-0.3255016804,
-0.1381480992,
-0.1440722793,
-0.2555581629,
-0.2049117088,
1.0555653572,
-0.136797145,
-0.6776252985,
0.2729750574,
0.1808302253,
0.4781839252,
-0.4902365208,
-0.0894119442,
-0.3594815731,
-0.0385935083,
-0.398853302,
-0.6855258346,
0.796069324,
0.102712214,
-0.3774428666,
-0.1556278914,
1.3792901039,
-0.364381671,
-0.321426928,
0.4301241636,
0.9700108171,
0.3126424253,
-0.2392187566,
-0.6411343217,
-0.0666618124,
-0.3611362875,
-0.4746472538,
0.1739857644,
0.6624667645,
0.0186880995,
0.519464016,
0.8675267696,
0.216512531,
0.3126851022,
0.0719528496,
0.9240389466,
-0.7320008874,
-0.2819837928,
-0.8150322437,
0.4605039358,
-0.2322598398,
0.2923921645,
0.7505115271,
0.7660844922,
0.5398327708,
0.0310918037,
0.479901582,
-0.335103035,
1.1516051292,
-0.4303942919,
0.6486952305,
-0.7881066203,
0.3934862614,
-0.4110431969,
-1.196331501,
-0.374075532,
0.298546195,
0.2045516223,
0.2994345725,
0.7147009373,
0.8472865224,
-0.0850194469,
-0.3607986569,
0.2783477902,
-0.0429234393,
0.326269567,
0.0292470939,
0.7785930037,
-0.3971754909,
0.8341787457,
-0.135032326,
-0.1917547733,
-0.1344381869,
-1.0596039295,
-0.597758472,
-0.4826108217,
0.159609735,
-0.4536836147,
-0.1552952677,
0.567994833,
0.5657514334,
-0.522436738,
-0.1261654943,
0.2417604625,
0.4958497584,
-0.1684785485,
-0.2318163663,
0.3059157431,
-0.6525838971,
-0.5699283481,
0.5189586878,
0.2165018916,
-0.3659909368,
-0.0107794292,
0.0771470293,
-0.7235252261,
0.0592233948,
0.7469052672,
0.015640432,
-0.232667014,
-0.0187427644,
0.1031027064,
-0.010639851,
0.1935270727,
0.9083827138,
-0.8266055584,
0.5021228194,
0.6752114892,
0.8129217625,
0.7941545248,
0.3029949665,
0.0609323643,
-1.0476070642,
-0.2730972469,
0.2637609541,
0.3062534928,
0.1701529622,
-0.3936338127,
0.9335536957,
0.2858403027,
-0.8018618822,
-0.7812295556,
0.2773101032,
-0.5725398064,
-0.3622045219,
1.1083655357,
0.3441939652,
-0.1146182418,
-0.1825993657,
-0.3070924282,
0.1550110132,
-0.0180607922,
0.4270700216,
0.6095104814,
-0.3268613517,
-0.3805067539,
-0.7891287208,
0.5014939904,
0.0394234695,
-0.9550119042,
-0.0213856623,
0.5644571781,
0.3288328648,
0.3572044373,
1.0213879347,
-0.1670673937,
0.3188054562,
-0.1143941805,
-0.0955497921,
0.0390774831,
-0.6527912617,
-0.0523905754,
0.2512961328,
0.0676244572,
-0.1378622055
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13195v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13195v1 | Learning Translations via Matrix Completion | 2024-06-19T04:03:19 | 2024-06-19T04:03:19 | Derry Wijaya, Brendan Callahan, John Hewitt, Jie Gao, Xiao Ling, Marianna Apidianaki, Chris Callison-Burch | cs.CL | cs.CL, I.2.7 | Bilingual Lexicon Induction is the task of learning word translations without
bilingual parallel corpora. We model this task as a matrix completion problem,
and present an effective and extendable framework for completing the matrix.
This method harnesses diverse bilingual and monolingual signals, each of which
may be incomplete or noisy. Our model achieves state-of-the-art performance for
both high and low resource languages. | [
-0.4389293492,
-0.1139294058,
0.539329946,
0.2101540565,
-0.2364275157,
0.5554884672,
-0.4116367102,
-0.3313618302,
0.4985563159,
0.4223003685,
-0.8063939214,
-0.5233070254,
-0.7942460179,
0.3869890273,
-0.5155490637,
1.1589305401,
-0.4462237358,
0.3066178858,
-0.3208609223,
-0.0624759011,
-0.3443259001,
-0.0815661177,
-0.4413583279,
-0.7424303293,
0.5015106797,
0.6663934588,
0.7099736929,
0.7594109178,
0.304310143,
0.3540997803,
-0.1991078705,
0.3197013736,
-0.6307881474,
0.0224053077,
-0.2964429855,
-0.7440444231,
-0.3778102398,
0.0703451261,
0.8214203119,
1.5676478148,
-0.1802375466,
0.1433314383,
0.2268283665,
0.8257590532,
-0.7546918392,
0.3982575238,
-0.6019399166,
0.4763836861,
-0.0868658572,
-0.2404603362,
-0.3048312664,
-0.5435292721,
0.0669715852,
-0.6595515609,
0.2609977126,
-0.0841535181,
0.5972873569,
-0.066800192,
-0.6640247107,
-0.4032857716,
-1.0298612118,
0.7511087656,
-0.0152244382,
0.538607955,
0.7436252832,
0.0854060948,
-0.1900239587,
-0.47106269,
-0.6937604547,
-0.1998351067,
-0.1989902556,
0.446479708,
0.1735313237,
0.2864693701,
0.4065888226,
0.5741893649,
-0.4892548919,
-0.1899660081,
-0.9126442671,
0.0994522199,
0.0844310299,
0.2350035459,
0.5797175765,
-0.1620810628,
-0.3062421083,
0.0602051914,
-0.6930977702,
0.1391576529,
0.4904316366,
0.2978544831,
-0.3271071911,
0.8004431725,
-0.2147678435,
0.7049534917,
-0.0664710924,
-0.2745393515,
0.477181077,
-0.6206351519,
0.0614492856,
0.2316243947,
0.5646361113,
-0.2410596758,
0.2995443344,
-0.6143662333,
-0.3997347057,
0.1322279125,
0.2319426835,
-0.2339343131,
0.3306919336,
0.2361996621,
-0.1315139979,
0.0078544272,
-0.1716266572,
-0.560573101,
0.0827941969,
-0.7727217078,
0.3860776126,
-0.4211414754,
-0.4384215176,
0.1510851085,
-0.3795618713,
0.0557459593,
-0.0298061315,
-1.2134578228,
0.42591995,
0.552687645,
0.9015453458,
-0.16335693,
-0.7934963703,
-0.5460639,
0.2227026224,
-0.7640981674,
0.6952516437,
-0.3651438057,
-0.6425739527,
0.1372130662,
0.0093175033,
-0.3641812503,
-0.5827257037,
0.3333610296,
-0.5865892768,
0.1328986883,
-0.5467357039,
-0.2810330689,
-0.221446842,
0.1309696585,
-0.7718725204,
0.9774840474,
0.3977837861,
-0.8400180936,
0.3388344049,
-0.5210283399,
-0.6781162024,
0.0605184138,
0.0376221985,
0.2075760663,
0.1593663096,
0.0269411877,
0.1270433068,
-0.1841527075,
-0.0467094406,
0.0255717915,
-0.4040310085,
-0.1280630678,
0.2704674304,
0.9396559596,
0.1317286342,
-0.3679290116,
-0.0129424036,
-0.747097373,
-0.3890208006,
-0.0083310688,
-0.6305981874,
-0.1464650929,
0.1050206497,
-0.174661532,
0.3177392483,
0.4143702388,
-0.6922821403,
0.072034277,
-0.6731084585,
-0.1144816279,
0.3456837833,
-0.3573284447,
0.9447084665,
-0.4815437198,
0.7567809224,
0.2383658588,
-0.0949319899,
0.1031493694,
-0.5735713243,
-1.1710205078,
-0.3066562116,
0.4151410758,
1.0627372265,
-1.2192714214,
0.2576557398,
-0.5147439241,
-0.4020675421,
-0.604896903,
0.858658433,
0.531709671,
0.4172935188,
0.5403130651,
-0.4315828383,
-0.8995949626,
-0.9753386974,
0.1785171628,
-0.0285435952,
0.1231549308,
-0.3495455086,
0.5610125065,
-0.2602463961,
0.4661739171,
0.0103205862,
-0.4938652813,
-0.7013694644,
0.1524178088,
0.4422285855,
0.3751952052,
0.1957618147,
-0.5658457279,
-0.6036044955,
0.4122084379,
-1.0716643333,
0.0793887079,
0.1023511142,
-0.0401787907,
0.072392121,
0.6467750072,
-0.5440482497,
0.4594594836,
0.6592722535,
0.1314243823,
0.3499952257,
-0.4573017061,
0.0038202265,
-1.2026336193,
-0.0165860206,
-0.4537450671,
-0.4736286998,
-0.806394577,
0.0534151867,
0.1962241232,
-0.0299764369,
-0.5488372445,
0.1655986458,
-0.6765466332,
-0.0688353479,
-0.4644734263,
0.1176765934,
-0.1617166996,
0.542778194,
0.1097402796,
0.5447283387,
0.5835666656,
-0.6193059087,
0.4618925452,
0.2982039154,
-0.4036600292,
0.3526339233,
-0.2987441123,
-0.3071085513,
-0.6444248557,
-0.0660856441,
-0.9334509373,
-0.1274852604,
0.0574360006,
-0.3289174139,
0.4884357154,
-0.0660282597,
-0.5666094422,
-0.3509596586,
0.0016051451,
0.6673697829,
0.5795525312,
-0.6684000492,
0.517326951,
0.2743369937,
-0.0893261433,
-0.9026606083,
-0.6956852078,
-0.0414430164,
0.3139104843,
-0.214269191,
0.1977109164,
0.2047120035,
-0.1114229783,
0.0344474204,
0.1958205551,
-0.043855831,
-0.0254243221,
0.212712422,
0.1562910676,
-0.1189102754,
-0.1070795953,
0.3035446703,
-0.1774396002,
-0.1440283507,
-0.1095849127,
0.4875949621,
0.0644005835,
-0.2241577357,
-0.4399683774,
0.9625733495,
0.6510342956,
-0.4127938449,
0.8092224598,
0.6044629812,
-0.5949094296,
-0.3116683066,
-0.3911565244,
0.0146531444,
-0.4398442805,
0.2379298657,
-0.5284076929,
-0.7269498706,
0.7393859029,
0.1957253814,
-0.1037573218,
0.2736221552,
0.7453702688,
0.1351658255,
1.2022496462,
0.8514298201,
0.1158587858,
0.3984773755,
-0.4903123081,
0.2069831192,
-0.8330137134,
-0.4326477945,
-0.3017065227,
-0.304759413,
-0.471255362,
-0.3836770952,
0.3288223147,
0.2343431711,
-0.0146936327,
0.7421566248,
-0.1406066716,
0.5063372254,
0.8349809051,
0.0007216502,
0.5682716966,
0.2826045156,
-0.8410571814,
0.0204083044,
-0.675542891,
-0.1120341942,
1.1741583347,
0.0820359364,
0.4064974785,
0.3110158145,
0.9981639981,
-0.1470508277,
0.3574483097,
-0.8478451967,
0.4418298602,
0.1034485474,
-0.7059537768,
0.0523307398,
-0.4518322051,
-1.1357438564,
0.2126217932,
-0.5582903624,
-0.7357993722,
0.3483975828,
-0.2071436942,
-0.1800230592,
0.2721158266,
-0.5401735902,
0.688575685,
0.113741219,
-0.1054729074,
-0.4961541295,
-0.2403221577,
0.6178007722,
-0.2959244549,
0.3406763077,
-0.0114997011,
-0.2443836927,
0.5542973876,
-0.496070683,
0.5595005155,
0.041487392,
0.158181861,
0.1475529522,
0.2894182801,
0.3090567887,
-0.0512175821,
0.179258585,
0.0551730692,
0.1702865213,
-0.6310164928,
-0.4943523705,
0.4956499934,
-0.8819029927,
-0.4566688836,
-0.4964458942,
-0.7643796206,
-0.1833552718,
0.3123882413,
0.4756723344,
0.2418444753,
-0.1189165413,
-0.325753808,
0.5208669305,
0.0320564657,
0.3754981458,
0.3923191428,
-0.5572327375,
-0.4403139055,
0.9729866385,
0.3235074282,
0.2136173099,
0.3849593699,
-0.3150891662,
-0.2545140088,
-0.5573505759,
-0.4306591749,
0.4950027466,
-0.8906449676,
0.0577486604,
-0.7420943975,
-0.4569841921,
-0.3221055269,
-0.1717551351,
-0.4513404369,
-0.4095483124,
-0.1386969686,
-0.3012696207,
-0.2088528275,
1.0331742764,
-0.5629270673,
0.2641533613,
-0.7722138762,
0.6915307045,
0.5895313025,
0.2525449097,
0.0412220843,
-0.2457891703,
-0.5433359146,
0.1104488373,
-0.2179982066,
-1.0785909891,
0.3723002374,
0.187916398,
0.6831949949,
0.3977643251,
-0.2866260111,
0.4917412102,
-0.9192647338,
0.5357750654,
0.434835583,
-1.0868546963,
0.457316637,
-0.419527173,
0.3416647315,
0.6307532787,
0.8498689532,
-0.6044261456,
-0.5174722075,
-0.3636998832,
-0.7422859073,
0.6294983625,
0.2505950928,
-0.0677022859,
-0.5099859834,
0.1636834145,
-0.0122982049,
0.0874950662,
-0.5427189469,
-0.2085183412,
-0.0847350582,
-0.11113666,
-0.4637245536,
-0.272438854,
-0.2085452527,
-0.6451079249,
0.7596153617,
0.0342367142,
0.2641189098,
0.1818618327,
-0.5926896334,
-0.4187956452,
0.1586556584,
0.7527733445,
0.9826914072,
-0.2585506141,
0.0581203848,
0.484493047,
-0.4121470153,
0.2783835828,
-0.0860504955,
0.0660661235,
0.3614358902,
0.3901141882,
0.6678572893,
0.3399852216,
-0.5864220262,
0.6983562112,
-0.1251831353,
-0.4267546535,
-0.6358509064,
-0.243263036,
0.2996972203,
0.031855084,
0.3582371175,
-0.0282116309,
0.0683440715,
-0.527186811,
0.0771888793,
0.3806089759,
-0.6337587833,
-0.3363660276,
0.7173274755,
-0.1009348556,
-0.1059852317,
0.6395995021,
-0.4805333316,
-0.6901172996,
0.5429368019,
0.692735076,
0.7074564099,
-0.2161236852,
0.235069409,
0.5733433962,
0.5245229602,
-0.4339420795,
0.6308885813,
-0.375171572,
-0.9004436135,
-0.8406821489,
-0.7855088115,
-0.5180079937,
-0.2009563297,
-0.8589010239,
0.2825020552,
-0.4631181359,
-0.2163626403,
-0.0244798213,
-0.2501841784,
-0.8428174853,
-0.198325038,
0.563432157,
0.8731303811,
-0.9222531915,
1.0577093363,
0.7825953364,
-0.4584440887,
-0.6850060225,
-0.6962674856,
-0.0203346517,
-0.7842168808,
0.966491878,
0.0322352797,
-0.0343643837,
-0.0841169283,
0.0691112429,
-1.0390367508,
0.708812058,
0.6289414763,
-0.1624231189,
-0.1795782,
0.5967363715,
0.4265676737,
-0.2131931484,
0.1097278818,
0.723141849,
0.4223668277,
0.0212428272,
-1.3086982965,
-0.2202314883,
-0.3037513494,
0.1530310959,
0.3203950822,
-0.07650242,
0.8570695519,
-0.0670740008,
-0.2158926129,
0.104598023,
0.8041818738,
-0.1177293509,
-0.122430183,
0.4900960028,
0.7877627611,
0.7135515809,
0.0323805138,
1.0868407488,
-0.6307899952,
0.3397855461,
1.0156354904,
-0.1055494472,
0.8247464895,
0.4816430807,
-0.1472443193,
0.6802874207,
0.606269896,
0.3833267689,
0.3613564074,
0.0685574785,
-0.6168045998,
-0.5060161352,
-0.3368694782,
-0.3653512597,
0.6446772814,
0.5956758261,
-0.3800650239,
-0.6253624558,
0.3054562807,
-0.1486642957,
0.281565547,
-0.6176963449,
0.7251777053,
0.2734294832,
-0.9808958173,
0.9071727395,
0.0699542612,
0.5456294417,
-0.5879993439,
0.0159601662,
-0.3852419853,
0.2653872371,
-0.4053320587,
-0.3759561479,
0.6976783276,
-0.2843432128,
-0.5181699395,
-0.3000781834,
0.2025031149,
-0.9156722426,
-0.7141238451,
0.8096376657,
0.8775416017,
0.1411079615,
0.2407649159,
-0.4415275455,
-0.4778121412,
-0.1736664325,
0.0848924369,
0.2017355114,
0.0418591499,
0.1779918522,
0.6104812622,
0.5474749207,
0.3525924385,
0.427624166,
-0.2278145552,
0.5627176762,
-0.4751452208,
-0.3514448404,
-0.6827087402,
0.2015190274,
0.2673713267,
0.0166213699,
0.661113441,
0.7588170171,
1.1465249062,
-0.2077740431,
0.6641277671,
0.2448475808,
0.5846890807,
-0.2554199696,
0.7023476362,
-0.6378468871,
-0.1288752407,
0.0227928609,
-1.0662189722,
-0.2857181728,
0.482021153,
-0.3327599764,
-0.3966805041,
1.2345439196,
0.9014101624,
-0.2864668071,
-0.0389023535,
0.5167844892,
-0.176145643,
-0.3149950504,
0.9777293801,
0.9480417371,
-0.5057188272,
0.6554942727,
-0.4643156826,
-0.2646799088,
0.3512774408,
-0.4629543126,
-1.09179914,
-0.8766911626,
-0.1863504052,
-0.7783464789,
-0.1624433398,
1.1920987368,
0.5830004215,
-0.8548606038,
-0.7552010417,
0.0206316113,
0.6860129833,
-0.4169676602,
-0.1056907326,
0.2122512758,
-0.9394697547,
-1.1562182903,
0.5927323103,
0.2884678245,
-0.113644287,
-0.1724539697,
0.041159045,
-0.5273513794,
0.0687647834,
0.4740765989,
0.6446731091,
-0.3451417983,
0.0753857493,
-0.2137774378,
-0.246397078,
0.2187964171,
0.7444747686,
-0.7801886797,
0.6835241914,
0.7614002228,
0.6597487926,
0.6726031303,
-0.6735931635,
0.7179116011,
-0.7441038489,
0.5499224067,
-0.0772215798,
0.7433749437,
0.4109521806,
-0.0737482086,
0.2544236779,
0.4885866046,
-0.0688349977,
-0.6372132301,
0.3017282486,
-0.9941550493,
0.0305956062,
1.2035964727,
-0.0219960231,
-0.577996254,
-0.4763543308,
0.2116931081,
0.5380504727,
0.1649151742,
0.4269881546,
0.6794273257,
0.4448587298,
-0.022153303,
-0.8141348958,
0.6083515286,
0.5360790491,
-0.1534090936,
-0.5216228366,
0.0004797839,
0.3575284779,
0.4218874276,
0.679246366,
-0.1009221449,
0.6682087183,
-0.0140075926,
0.5256334543,
0.1695576757,
-0.3963056803,
-0.3049983382,
0.2788754404,
0.2366345823,
-0.0383636393
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13193v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13193v1 | PRESTO: Progressive Pretraining Enhances Synthetic Chemistry Outcomes | 2024-06-19T03:59:46 | 2024-06-19T03:59:46 | He Cao, Yanjun Shao, Zhiyuan Liu, Zijing Liu, Xiangru Tang, Yuan Yao, Yu Li | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, physics.chem-ph | Multimodal Large Language Models (MLLMs) have seen growing adoption across
various scientific disciplines. These advancements encourage the investigation
of molecule-text modeling within synthetic chemistry, a field dedicated to
designing and conducting chemical reactions to synthesize new compounds with
desired properties and applications. Current approaches, however, often neglect
the critical role of multiple molecule graph interaction in understanding
chemical reactions, leading to suboptimal performance in synthetic chemistry
tasks. This study introduces PRESTO(Progressive Pretraining Enhances Synthetic
Chemistry Outcomes), a new framework that bridges the molecule-text modality
gap by integrating a comprehensive benchmark of pretraining strategies and
dataset configurations. It progressively improves multimodal LLMs through
cross-modal alignment and multi-graph understanding. Our extensive experiments
demonstrate that PRESTO offers competitive results in downstream synthetic
chemistry tasks. The code can be found at https://github.com/IDEA-XL/PRESTO. | [
-0.3371497989,
-0.8547224402,
0.8973849416,
0.1580500603,
-0.1338986903,
0.5290108323,
-0.313308686,
-0.1911549419,
0.1691804528,
0.3421804011,
-0.7275289893,
-0.6025963426,
-0.4133895636,
0.389252156,
-0.2111769915,
0.9629550576,
-0.378962785,
0.116646193,
-0.430998683,
0.2632461488,
-0.084442988,
-0.6156263351,
-0.4291143119,
-0.2384645045,
0.9599952698,
-0.0152427498,
0.3371222317,
0.1499356627,
0.6330623031,
0.4583962262,
0.1798200756,
0.1051982939,
-0.5996971726,
0.4454313219,
0.1608251184,
-0.2573432922,
-0.9632970095,
0.3094086349,
0.7184950709,
0.5812107921,
0.0497360975,
-0.1835666597,
0.1150729358,
0.7029911876,
-0.7121605873,
0.1424890161,
-0.314239502,
0.009936464,
-0.4371991754,
0.0521255881,
-0.4143538773,
-0.2133459896,
0.2449420393,
-1.1211618185,
0.0921013653,
-0.2263000757,
0.5240963697,
0.2152093947,
-0.6577083468,
-0.1639004052,
-0.5989464521,
0.4831782579,
-0.4918108582,
0.8052091002,
-0.181955114,
0.4793688357,
-0.3203168809,
-1.5008593798,
-0.8949419856,
-0.3223390579,
0.0090616783,
0.298247993,
0.2049758434,
0.5203255415,
-0.0617555454,
0.2154217809,
-0.7392213345,
-0.2511763573,
-0.1006842628,
-0.3820417523,
0.1537457705,
0.1822079122,
0.0351289101,
0.2817513943,
-0.5497744083,
-0.2310227156,
-0.6344168782,
-0.0085048443,
0.2544201016,
0.5160734057,
0.1158216745,
0.6980810761,
0.0410558358,
0.8521068692,
-0.3503287435,
0.1401348263,
0.5001146793,
-1.0947757959,
-0.2413443923,
-0.0081191938,
0.9272831678,
-0.0923828334,
0.3410041928,
0.0031961116,
-0.1471011192,
0.1043908,
0.4078575075,
-1.1650931835,
-0.2741612494,
0.0607192628,
-0.0955819041,
-0.1435998529,
0.1557903141,
-0.896243453,
-0.0056399838,
-0.6109175086,
0.7283986211,
-0.3988849521,
-0.201613754,
-0.0403634049,
-0.2897236049,
-0.3339078128,
0.3333409727,
-0.6371368766,
0.0731029212,
0.5762808919,
0.8630956411,
-0.2415525168,
-0.516577065,
-0.4092087448,
0.0677599087,
-0.2235182673,
0.7402800322,
-0.8806528449,
-0.5866573453,
-0.2976162434,
0.0014259827,
-0.2693679631,
-0.4202844501,
0.0830545127,
-0.5492996573,
0.2653109133,
0.0704253316,
-0.4085792899,
0.1846192181,
0.2956958711,
-0.6368594766,
0.8783971071,
0.127648592,
-0.3593507409,
0.3246288896,
-0.7833619714,
-0.4520705938,
-0.2655396461,
-0.1578365415,
-0.4823493063,
0.1672291756,
-0.1833547503,
0.080032438,
-0.0122463843,
0.0331081524,
-0.3626132607,
-0.171350807,
0.496912688,
-0.2103631645,
0.2358340919,
0.173680529,
0.0269973781,
0.8242240548,
-0.7666400671,
0.1780131757,
-0.3751724958,
-0.4865551591,
-0.0690156519,
-0.3750856519,
0.15178442,
0.4163522124,
0.2697354257,
-0.2946310043,
0.2995300293,
-0.0196637027,
0.5276696682,
0.8863014579,
-0.1141085327,
0.5459902287,
0.1284844428,
0.6543370485,
-0.1364607364,
0.3293061852,
-0.3011799455,
-0.2679460943,
-0.4902421236,
-0.5895659924,
0.4396477342,
0.2280233204,
-0.8473024368,
0.3340625763,
-0.2786026299,
-0.5328562856,
-0.0706980824,
0.3179608285,
0.5260519981,
0.7299655676,
0.5890935063,
-0.3679575026,
-0.6784691811,
-0.6214932799,
-0.3763934076,
-0.0583645999,
-0.0658450499,
-0.1235122159,
0.5244012475,
-0.6516916156,
1.1241749525,
-0.3288122118,
-0.3105835021,
-0.2909423709,
0.2522104383,
0.164644286,
0.4101677537,
0.2506250143,
-0.8894349337,
-0.7088772655,
-0.2539756298,
-0.4613175094,
-0.0936900154,
0.1792835891,
-0.6313800812,
-0.0127801392,
0.5832235217,
-0.7349944711,
0.0669666827,
0.7766831517,
-0.4311795831,
0.6233233809,
-0.0338162743,
0.1187781766,
-0.917049408,
0.1375151426,
-0.218475312,
-0.2775983214,
-0.7391554713,
-0.3590035439,
-0.0880316421,
-0.2673889399,
-0.8021454215,
0.5560516119,
-0.2921001315,
0.0644316748,
-0.1448592544,
0.048452124,
0.3423896432,
0.1401698142,
0.2365527004,
1.0054968596,
0.3258601129,
-0.5579650998,
0.0201709718,
0.1492932886,
-0.1079735607,
0.198794201,
-0.647877872,
0.2035747319,
0.1310182959,
0.5644435287,
-1.0059422255,
-0.2483178824,
0.019829236,
-0.3549641073,
0.5448536277,
0.0698939785,
-0.1602284908,
-0.1987804025,
-0.2799117267,
0.6523032784,
0.2723301351,
-0.0013814416,
1.2338173389,
0.0737697855,
-0.0964932442,
-0.4651941061,
-0.3558431864,
-0.2835667431,
-0.1438253522,
-0.3689098656,
0.5822374821,
-0.2230955064,
-0.0244605578,
-0.1387176365,
-0.2919973731,
-0.1041393206,
-0.195211038,
0.0092816381,
0.3233557045,
-0.0891605169,
0.2696867585,
-0.1847990602,
-0.369610846,
-0.0592623614,
-0.4233312905,
0.857229054,
-0.0810944811,
0.0842832848,
-0.4845595658,
0.1475373656,
0.8311547041,
-0.5053078532,
0.8293036819,
0.7394518256,
0.0741823241,
0.1236719489,
-0.0863605961,
-0.3748350143,
-0.5650465488,
0.5642113686,
-0.5235322118,
-0.5905181766,
0.1526487619,
-0.4445744753,
-0.3509577215,
0.1044176593,
0.5603755713,
-0.2806451321,
0.8353580236,
0.5951293111,
0.6602436304,
0.8615149856,
-0.1710514873,
0.3312861621,
-0.8833039999,
-0.4815301597,
-0.2357984036,
-0.2434715927,
-0.4704496562,
-0.7042930722,
0.7776206136,
0.3704525828,
-0.5971359015,
0.2778915465,
-0.2783923447,
0.3708446622,
0.346496731,
0.2246686369,
0.252997905,
0.0103487577,
-0.2869873643,
-0.128581956,
-0.524731636,
-0.4220475554,
1.3300082684,
0.0275423732,
0.766074717,
0.1552625597,
0.7018597126,
0.0522654392,
0.5190346241,
-0.5387361646,
0.5586489439,
-0.1704780161,
-0.7462769151,
-0.4485889971,
-0.6191318035,
-0.9250708222,
0.2010696381,
-0.5613787174,
-0.2453300208,
-0.0667967349,
0.3946475685,
-0.1664944142,
-0.2282463163,
-0.6604918838,
1.3664120436,
-0.6059077382,
-0.6523751616,
-0.1127391756,
-0.6815206409,
0.0279503744,
-0.4729081392,
0.2329406142,
-0.0800255835,
-0.2503766716,
0.4853024781,
-0.5015283227,
0.5426422358,
-0.1001575738,
0.0729317069,
0.1718834341,
0.0068433355,
0.3532226086,
-0.0339515507,
0.0717693418,
0.0902633965,
-0.1521143764,
-0.4109167457,
-0.7125857472,
0.4594252706,
-0.4664214551,
-0.4160461724,
-0.1852515936,
-0.4169901013,
-0.3978508711,
0.6689608097,
0.4637854993,
0.2081372291,
-0.3386128843,
0.0427520722,
0.3974528313,
-0.1076146588,
0.3080718219,
0.4081989229,
-0.6357443929,
-0.6250067353,
0.7460722327,
-0.0110426424,
0.4863353372,
0.539069891,
-0.0230857395,
-0.6621322036,
-0.5182684064,
-0.1546603739,
0.0500180051,
-0.642275095,
0.0521542095,
-0.547242105,
0.0788412616,
-0.4529049695,
-0.0848919377,
-0.6956270337,
-0.3824403286,
-0.0892487392,
-0.0726642907,
0.0310024228,
0.4478756487,
0.0503111929,
0.3226184547,
-0.917529285,
0.3287838697,
0.4789212346,
0.2065471262,
-0.3497915268,
-0.038131088,
-0.1454503387,
0.0093828449,
-0.3664822876,
-0.8049813509,
0.11565198,
0.4555598795,
0.6143838167,
0.0502096042,
-0.2285741568,
0.6735413074,
-0.6870114207,
0.5772250891,
0.3716934025,
-1.1227160692,
0.602635324,
-0.3219106793,
0.2245489657,
0.708809793,
0.6660913229,
-0.222787112,
-0.0587034747,
0.0394307487,
-1.139934063,
0.0206290074,
0.414721489,
0.021678431,
-0.1076576412,
0.1780792475,
0.1483291984,
0.5772163272,
-0.8002814651,
-0.0214855447,
-0.5392733812,
-0.492972523,
-0.4883906543,
0.1662930101,
-0.1190762445,
-0.4283570349,
0.596363008,
-0.1285410374,
0.2645670474,
0.1297442615,
-0.3511216938,
0.3335345984,
0.1970625222,
0.6266217232,
0.8343166113,
-0.157724753,
0.2275744826,
-0.1588811427,
-0.6332057118,
0.4487534761,
0.286537528,
0.3867723048,
-0.1601653844,
0.7148016095,
0.6585437655,
0.0678002015,
-0.730733335,
0.2502164841,
-0.1057347357,
0.0182288047,
-0.0684843957,
0.1048803255,
-0.0202374719,
0.3172821105,
0.3519538939,
0.0733160526,
-0.0269544385,
-0.7765564919,
0.2424448878,
0.2913940847,
-0.3875921965,
-0.4307825863,
0.7870200276,
0.4657172859,
-0.1346784979,
0.7987278104,
0.1844887435,
-0.6400668621,
0.3871970177,
0.4137669206,
0.6407040954,
-0.354310751,
0.0703205168,
0.145620212,
-0.1544142962,
0.1519136876,
0.2564769685,
-0.2264566869,
-0.6414885521,
-0.4561339915,
-0.6862546802,
-0.167422235,
-0.2972586155,
-0.2922216952,
0.2540631592,
-0.3502791524,
-0.6376936436,
0.0077163735,
-0.2215240598,
-0.6868057847,
0.0834513605,
0.0588418059,
0.6892558932,
-0.7275933027,
0.920009613,
0.7211732864,
-0.4873260558,
-0.3487821519,
0.0220601428,
0.1186079234,
-0.3081659973,
0.9630710483,
0.4302035272,
-0.4159702659,
0.1852049828,
-0.0390459783,
-0.7530107498,
1.0225096941,
0.4018137455,
-0.9031609297,
-0.1962278485,
0.3500936329,
0.6805427074,
-0.3679990768,
0.3262907267,
0.5171146393,
0.8352579474,
0.0484192334,
-0.9314752221,
-0.0781978369,
-0.2154534757,
-0.1610000879,
0.323305279,
-0.4804914594,
1.1685267687,
-0.017364921,
-0.116808109,
0.0140512763,
0.3366620839,
0.5500827432,
0.3888368607,
0.336907655,
0.578443706,
0.5954990387,
-0.3602819741,
0.9437485933,
-0.2756180465,
0.2337156087,
0.9831978083,
-0.4576557577,
0.7233535647,
0.6452065706,
-0.4873993397,
0.7680256963,
0.7690024376,
0.4053069055,
0.7253829241,
0.2619046867,
-0.5410327911,
-0.5462017655,
0.0746317953,
-0.5734834671,
0.3708074391,
0.3364728093,
-0.3290774822,
-0.0334908105,
0.3206262887,
-0.1909913123,
-0.0064197527,
-0.1959079206,
0.4952478111,
-0.0335484184,
-0.5318474174,
0.4836909473,
-0.5412440896,
0.500287056,
-0.9324241877,
-0.1152240708,
-0.0428587794,
0.4207413495,
0.0259685386,
-0.6377964616,
0.1671921313,
-0.2759208977,
-0.2256109864,
-0.3746169508,
0.3650497198,
-0.5097129941,
-0.4116228521,
0.4398434162,
0.5138055086,
-0.1828358173,
-0.2108125389,
-0.606488049,
0.3451791704,
-0.3018575609,
-0.5612857938,
0.262198329,
0.2860135436,
-0.0164111611,
0.4269624352,
0.9216833711,
-0.2592769861,
0.1966372281,
0.1265213937,
1.1745926142,
-0.5859973431,
-0.3254728913,
-0.9171830416,
0.719842732,
0.0745185241,
-0.2189554423,
0.7182101011,
0.9446282983,
0.8651074171,
-0.2296122909,
0.5871657133,
0.2063888162,
0.1065083444,
-0.8873530626,
0.3918303847,
-0.498490721,
0.1004741192,
-0.2778429687,
-1.3098118305,
-0.3558507264,
0.5161415935,
-0.2753666937,
0.3937692344,
0.8885700107,
0.7019454241,
-0.0464665145,
-0.3831582069,
0.0007837832,
0.3002470434,
0.6202754974,
0.4989266992,
1.0249695778,
-0.0408281162,
0.5723826885,
0.1183438078,
0.0259030573,
0.1261807382,
-0.8809147477,
-0.9748228788,
-0.4826464057,
0.1224355474,
-0.3410425484,
0.1304466575,
0.7901929021,
0.9402729869,
-0.4794367552,
-0.1443821043,
-0.6258431673,
-0.1898646355,
0.1230453253,
-0.2425213456,
0.1782077998,
-0.499966681,
-0.8500089049,
0.7573696375,
0.3560766578,
0.4839751124,
-0.1799771637,
-0.3224172592,
-0.1960206479,
0.0071331547,
0.7193776965,
0.1435263008,
-0.3911491036,
0.2703611851,
0.1164895594,
0.1321413815,
0.2124208808,
1.2350611687,
-0.9738205671,
0.7389423251,
0.6879346967,
0.3660618067,
1.0598418713,
-0.0058177956,
0.8980364799,
-0.7988151312,
0.3143294752,
0.2446123064,
0.071854189,
0.2023792714,
0.1233564541,
0.4836014509,
0.3675187826,
-0.4445433021,
-0.816962719,
0.3350088894,
-0.8175488114,
-0.6440131664,
0.6446903348,
-0.16732274,
-0.1808742136,
0.043392349,
-0.0078202737,
0.509537816,
-0.3167123199,
0.4019068182,
0.7428594232,
-0.6235828996,
0.0083712172,
-0.3753690124,
0.6383910179,
0.4042554498,
-0.9391601682,
-0.1248818934,
0.5752423406,
0.2065555751,
0.2650265098,
0.6624124646,
-0.0336787514,
0.045078624,
-0.0789618567,
-0.075293906,
-0.488791585,
-0.8667359352,
0.037121404,
-0.0421359837,
-0.2498893142,
0.0619663522
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13188v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13188v1 | Synthetic Context Generation for Question Generation | 2024-06-19T03:37:52 | 2024-06-19T03:37:52 | Naiming Liu, Zichao Wang, Richard Baraniuk | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | Despite rapid advancements in large language models (LLMs), QG remains a
challenging problem due to its complicated process, open-ended nature, and the
diverse settings in which question generation occurs. A common approach to
address these challenges involves fine-tuning smaller, custom models using
datasets containing background context, question, and answer. However,
obtaining suitable domain-specific datasets with appropriate context is often
more difficult than acquiring question-answer pairs. In this paper, we
investigate training QG models using synthetic contexts generated by LLMs from
readily available question-answer pairs. We conduct a comprehensive study to
answer critical research questions related to the performance of models trained
on synthetic contexts and their potential impact on QG research and
applications. Our empirical results reveal: 1) contexts are essential for QG
tasks, even if they are synthetic; 2) fine-tuning smaller language models has
the capability of achieving better performances as compared to prompting larger
language models; and 3) synthetic context and real context could achieve
comparable performances. These findings highlight the effectiveness of
synthetic contexts in QG and paves the way for future advancements in the
field. | [
-0.6023193002,
-1.1255791187,
0.7019549608,
-0.1474743634,
-0.2342503667,
-0.1207640544,
-0.3216225803,
-0.4966432452,
-0.3060725927,
0.4549946785,
-0.8368009925,
-0.1831401885,
-0.1452434063,
0.3980029523,
-0.3239863217,
0.8547973633,
0.0469978862,
0.137717694,
-0.4313186407,
-0.213062346,
-0.6227601171,
-0.5473697186,
-0.7285989523,
-0.2435181439,
0.4126127362,
0.3402865231,
0.326579392,
0.257919848,
-0.1017081216,
0.2709463537,
0.007298199,
0.512693882,
-0.5935299397,
0.4672640562,
-0.1599298716,
-0.4323531687,
-0.0764955506,
0.1194719523,
0.7664062977,
0.5673009753,
-0.0172394477,
0.3894864321,
0.0547714904,
0.4029991031,
-0.361635983,
-0.1074626371,
-0.9761097431,
0.0431503169,
0.1528645009,
-0.4513154328,
-0.2256040871,
-0.3923002481,
0.3167868555,
-0.6683782935,
0.5300513506,
0.156857267,
0.533875227,
0.0510011241,
-0.6589894295,
-0.2989861965,
-0.8182299137,
0.6456027627,
-0.6713532805,
0.3019505441,
0.135991931,
0.4759573936,
-0.3364191651,
-0.9248259068,
-0.7542926073,
-0.0259945933,
-0.1014936566,
0.1244614273,
0.2752209902,
0.006925778,
0.4381499588,
0.23595801,
-0.5619055629,
-0.1864919215,
-0.4729254842,
0.0453536958,
0.6248810291,
0.4786049426,
0.2654291093,
-0.1868428141,
-0.1511157751,
-0.1314376742,
-1.0238977671,
0.1497905999,
0.1369818896,
0.4249745905,
0.0431796797,
0.4363768697,
-0.4104220867,
0.8719265461,
0.2243189961,
-0.020300962,
-0.2989054024,
-0.5551033616,
-0.1328251809,
-0.1436897218,
0.4709255099,
0.2721762359,
0.3513489366,
-0.1411314309,
-0.1407884061,
-0.2234844565,
0.4040684402,
-0.8629560471,
-0.1049792096,
0.2887825072,
0.15763551,
-0.1897837073,
-0.1662133783,
-0.3069140613,
-0.0747713968,
-0.7226424217,
0.4184967577,
-0.2936417758,
-0.1550330669,
-0.0313705839,
-0.1463427991,
0.5220437646,
0.3851093948,
-0.9570295811,
0.0226727072,
0.5734915733,
0.4699197114,
-0.1853409708,
-0.0748283342,
-0.4783808887,
0.2366551608,
-0.4059357345,
0.7333928943,
-0.5266248584,
-0.5484617949,
0.1724728346,
0.1747245044,
-0.2214868963,
-0.7414449453,
0.2012276053,
-0.7337954044,
0.4796083272,
-0.446596086,
-0.6306806207,
0.0546520054,
0.6309067607,
-0.4397545755,
1.0814838409,
0.2894076109,
-0.6422397494,
0.3190009296,
-0.2777240276,
-0.4241233766,
0.2981575131,
-0.496560365,
-0.230594039,
0.1797018349,
0.244839102,
0.3425308466,
-0.4814745486,
0.3282634616,
0.0754933059,
-0.4019649625,
0.4422966838,
-0.1368659586,
0.371059984,
0.0479295813,
-0.20080477,
0.1136822104,
-0.7791671157,
0.6124308705,
0.1402072161,
-0.4971957207,
-0.2918697894,
-0.0974942893,
-0.0060015484,
0.3322973251,
0.0832436532,
-0.3995028436,
0.0896888375,
-0.4134737253,
0.5596005917,
0.5617675781,
0.3732392788,
0.387553364,
-0.4032489657,
0.830173254,
-0.0743562952,
-0.1545499861,
-0.0416558497,
-0.4794265926,
-0.4760995507,
0.2553628683,
0.5242865682,
0.3323263526,
-0.9130618572,
0.0726570711,
0.0304880347,
-0.429556936,
-0.3492722809,
0.0089397114,
0.2802442908,
0.7587084174,
0.2493005842,
0.2020843029,
-0.7372461557,
-0.8836454153,
-0.3410768807,
-0.0140364617,
-0.0491084903,
0.7917771935,
0.4622772038,
-0.073689431,
1.2964528799,
-0.6568827033,
0.2386260331,
-0.4300162196,
0.0164297502,
-0.1128145978,
0.6263561249,
0.4753926694,
-0.9471470714,
-0.452666223,
-0.1648773253,
-0.6024301648,
-0.0625064075,
-0.1073046103,
-0.2688880265,
-0.0281211101,
0.615138948,
-0.5790573955,
-0.2376444787,
0.6554066539,
-0.0059839338,
0.8041024208,
-0.1382791102,
0.129985109,
-1.3709021807,
0.1918431818,
-0.1134537533,
-0.3020015657,
-0.9327439666,
0.2438264042,
0.0604305454,
-0.3377931118,
-0.5926583409,
0.8471188545,
-0.1613890976,
0.1593156308,
-0.1055186465,
0.2245570868,
0.0965661108,
0.4095179141,
0.0690991804,
1.0942630768,
0.2781144381,
-0.859166503,
0.2080589235,
0.2844054997,
-0.4615446329,
0.3115955591,
-0.9155615568,
0.4223848879,
-0.1201310977,
0.3163507283,
-0.8299611807,
-0.5284469128,
0.0099323057,
-0.2843826711,
0.1131698564,
-0.1680795997,
-0.505012393,
-0.1596619636,
0.0309959725,
0.7345717549,
0.7210312486,
-0.6068629026,
0.2324969918,
0.3477239311,
-0.0955870524,
-0.1525290012,
-0.4075114727,
-0.2375038713,
-0.3696949184,
-0.724812448,
0.3645108044,
-0.0381943397,
-0.1890855581,
-0.2578160167,
-0.1491232812,
0.012548144,
0.1532455832,
0.1156188995,
-0.1820815951,
-0.2903638482,
0.3473406136,
0.2570421994,
0.3229779899,
0.1241370961,
-0.4236162901,
0.5834694505,
-0.0145269819,
0.0031645459,
0.1114447191,
0.5117670894,
0.1962235272,
-0.283324182,
0.7603559494,
0.320982635,
-0.4273798466,
-0.6939808726,
-0.3509021401,
-0.4727137685,
-0.5501083732,
0.2567911148,
-0.3808602095,
-1.3101587296,
0.4458507895,
-0.2754612267,
-0.0781501457,
0.0705769286,
0.6881186366,
-0.0942011476,
1.3288172483,
0.4308000505,
0.4933666885,
0.437052995,
-0.2272507101,
0.1506621689,
-0.9057372212,
-0.2231755555,
-0.2340970486,
-0.224183172,
-0.7670707107,
-0.4036918581,
0.8088618517,
0.293268919,
0.0432655439,
0.1788659543,
-0.2126625478,
0.6042206883,
0.5464100838,
0.0582883134,
0.1557552218,
0.0198460687,
-0.1806691587,
0.1802219301,
-0.9956995845,
-0.7471824884,
1.0747152567,
-0.0439399742,
0.3893199861,
-0.1418409199,
0.6462829709,
-0.0465088338,
0.1369886249,
-0.497656554,
0.6014814377,
0.2660584748,
-0.8809110522,
-0.409263283,
-0.3874334097,
-1.0596159697,
0.3913463354,
-0.2771274447,
-0.3868791461,
-0.0796921253,
0.3966973126,
-0.7014973164,
-0.188869983,
-0.6657027602,
0.9287074804,
0.014071852,
-0.4372881651,
-0.0090115312,
-0.487005502,
0.4862790406,
-0.0342668742,
-0.0899244547,
0.0878854915,
0.3730849326,
0.6066004634,
-0.2437138855,
0.6529200077,
-0.1215101406,
-0.3409780562,
0.7438751459,
0.0496240966,
0.4726658463,
0.5622711182,
0.0320877507,
-0.3091978729,
0.2560355663,
-0.3485449851,
-0.6509689093,
0.7209533453,
-0.6188024879,
-0.9273750782,
-0.1128489822,
-0.7176315188,
-0.7518595457,
0.0508290604,
0.3633466363,
0.5878424644,
-0.2918243408,
0.0469013713,
0.7034350634,
-0.403803885,
0.1007303819,
0.4025209546,
0.0354771726,
-0.2548583746,
0.7268430591,
0.053696081,
0.4375236332,
-0.0841074586,
0.068638213,
-0.4194529057,
-0.4467457831,
-0.627353549,
0.1338137686,
-0.5353407264,
-0.2079240531,
-0.5758733153,
-0.4015926421,
-0.4795873165,
-0.020187797,
-0.1016802266,
-0.4748878777,
-0.2979826629,
-0.0110777356,
0.1365380138,
0.4716880918,
0.3349430263,
0.256640166,
-0.8767264485,
0.2578216791,
0.8569394946,
0.0927052349,
-0.0983318835,
-0.3479296267,
-0.387757659,
0.395627588,
-0.3655368984,
-0.778732419,
0.3006844521,
0.2778490186,
0.3460637033,
-0.0312927887,
0.1494770795,
0.6476868987,
-0.7349503636,
1.0101130009,
-0.3905094564,
-0.5280035734,
0.6914628148,
-0.6676939726,
0.4166000783,
0.6028043628,
0.3468022645,
-0.6122233272,
-0.3100564182,
-0.561720252,
-0.7233024836,
0.7744933963,
0.1694135517,
0.3776419163,
-0.2860909402,
0.7415280342,
0.12585105,
0.3629940152,
-0.5369590521,
0.1303739697,
0.1034173742,
-0.0060798926,
-0.0257162135,
-0.0701830089,
-0.332485348,
-0.305105269,
0.5152773261,
-0.3854741752,
0.0763923079,
0.2938320637,
-0.1120340079,
-0.3163443804,
0.3178619444,
0.756976366,
0.6833207607,
-0.0334346332,
0.0105385501,
0.4548190832,
-0.0446389131,
0.2332186699,
-0.33871454,
-0.3724649847,
-0.2397734672,
0.0680350661,
0.6422063708,
-0.0613936186,
-1.0371943712,
0.1237436682,
-0.0781697482,
-0.294878155,
-0.5310953259,
0.5171447992,
0.1733357757,
0.366820842,
0.2213997096,
-0.3740990758,
0.0369938351,
-0.739956975,
0.0201272182,
0.6083772182,
-0.1344919801,
-0.401445359,
0.5881825089,
0.1212859079,
-0.2266788036,
0.5498815775,
-0.1974610239,
-0.6488676667,
0.7697193027,
0.8735950589,
0.6634797454,
-0.0160877984,
0.2001353651,
0.4970049262,
-0.0746080205,
-0.1881505996,
0.4581088722,
-0.1997950375,
-0.7829726934,
-0.3242200315,
-0.7254000306,
-0.5448597074,
0.5150366426,
-0.3900584579,
0.0436531417,
-0.3278947175,
-0.090905413,
-0.4182291329,
-0.0936818868,
-0.5749663711,
0.6143060923,
0.0217252392,
0.5419837236,
-0.6195152998,
0.7809099555,
1.0110046864,
-0.0392825492,
-0.8654898405,
0.141277343,
-0.464726299,
-0.4378534853,
0.6794795394,
0.1545409858,
-0.0059589827,
0.3289927542,
-0.7213628292,
-0.7595022321,
1.1393120289,
0.1345754713,
-0.3430305421,
-0.3085836172,
0.5669361949,
0.8316172361,
-0.5099032521,
-0.1618094146,
0.7145361304,
0.2360583842,
-0.0384571478,
-0.5656748414,
0.2276342064,
-0.2302286476,
0.2161471546,
0.0262093768,
-0.6583544016,
0.8828991055,
-0.0220860187,
-0.4280901849,
0.1450497806,
0.4979489446,
0.682615459,
0.1635663062,
0.3707203269,
0.2266362458,
0.4890680611,
-0.1817382425,
0.9922724962,
-0.5101076365,
0.0778634474,
0.9666175246,
-0.2345105112,
0.6632503271,
0.4698448479,
0.0956672058,
0.2541176975,
0.6464924812,
0.1303354353,
0.5451880693,
0.395068258,
-0.4465519786,
-0.5083242059,
0.0117848758,
-0.4069569409,
0.414079994,
0.3491840065,
-0.1747528464,
-0.0496378131,
-0.0221063755,
-0.4619207382,
0.1225992218,
-0.1409608573,
0.7840417027,
0.0779902562,
-1.0958211422,
0.7665130496,
0.1864804626,
0.3703282475,
-0.4512448311,
-0.0455214679,
-0.410376817,
-0.0330002941,
0.0325639918,
-0.3707890809,
0.2339610904,
0.0469644777,
-0.134696126,
-0.1896966547,
0.5849425197,
-0.6711586714,
-0.2248724252,
-0.3121607304,
0.7628572583,
-0.2397395819,
-0.1516451091,
-0.3019663393,
-0.4631015658,
-0.2250690758,
-0.3382440805,
0.4965368509,
0.5674685836,
-0.1126499325,
0.4839787781,
0.6674807072,
0.0072466824,
0.3358142078,
-0.2148696333,
0.8968699574,
-0.7163841724,
-0.4342038333,
-0.5410034657,
0.4646920562,
0.0533841066,
-0.4459286332,
0.761875689,
0.4581380188,
1.0333182812,
-0.2442103773,
0.9370021224,
0.0289884321,
0.4447935522,
-0.7857553959,
0.613201499,
-0.611482203,
0.2062303722,
-0.0306302551,
-0.8844578266,
0.0586135723,
0.374597311,
-0.2613924742,
0.1975983083,
0.4283931851,
0.8692083359,
-0.0777229145,
0.0720092952,
0.2733493447,
-0.1009491012,
0.4067084193,
0.5505194664,
1.1279131174,
-0.5316755176,
0.2872635424,
-0.1395001113,
0.2558823228,
-0.1141203716,
-0.584097445,
-1.0512875319,
-0.6921961904,
-0.2286046147,
-0.2494648844,
0.055740945,
1.0463501215,
0.6479438543,
-0.8448936343,
-0.1877979487,
-0.3677255213,
-0.2037609071,
0.1769358963,
-0.2359330356,
0.1562006921,
-0.5004197955,
-0.8153787851,
0.6157703996,
-0.1520645767,
0.2749208808,
-0.2118768096,
-0.0387234688,
-0.0658037066,
0.3685332239,
0.7758786678,
0.3073694706,
-0.5223271251,
-0.4818319678,
0.1635076255,
-0.1701706648,
-0.0915665403,
1.0324426889,
-1.0287659168,
0.1385726929,
0.5675534606,
0.6690935493,
0.4733389914,
0.3976453543,
0.9424946308,
-1.3043166399,
-0.0124402139,
0.3116134405,
0.1050039157,
0.2238359898,
-0.2168180496,
0.3833097219,
0.0728723854,
-0.5306511521,
-0.9842239618,
0.4712946415,
-0.6088657379,
-0.394502908,
1.4136213064,
0.1468732804,
-0.0412742235,
0.0587320402,
-0.3929894269,
0.3555470407,
0.0797096267,
0.885594368,
0.5638566017,
-0.2190702856,
-0.158982113,
-0.61828053,
0.9160744548,
0.6510004401,
-0.8444314599,
0.0559888072,
0.5627785325,
0.4048643112,
-0.1690036654,
0.2940813005,
0.0682128295,
0.2768616378,
-0.1916483492,
-0.2891988754,
-0.0675529614,
-0.1380311549,
-0.2383160144,
0.358777523,
0.0986080468,
0.1593275964
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13185v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13185v1 | Learnable In-Context Vector for Visual Question Answering | 2024-06-19T03:33:45 | 2024-06-19T03:33:45 | Yingzhe Peng, Chenduo Hao, Xu Yang, Jiawei Peng, Xinting Hu, Xin Geng | cs.CL | cs.CL | As language models continue to scale, Large Language Models (LLMs) have
exhibited emerging capabilities in In-Context Learning (ICL), enabling them to
solve language tasks by prefixing a few in-context demonstrations (ICDs) as
context. Inspired by these advancements, researchers have extended these
techniques to develop Large Multimodal Models (LMMs) with ICL capabilities.
However, applying ICL usually faces two major challenges: 1) using more ICDs
will largely increase the inference time and 2) the performance is sensitive to
the selection of ICDs. These challenges are further exacerbated in LMMs due to
the integration of multiple data types and the combinational complexity of
multimodal ICDs. Recently, to address these challenges, some NLP studies
introduce non-learnable In-Context Vectors (ICVs) which extract useful task
information from ICDs into a single vector and then insert it into the LLM to
help solve the corresponding task. However, although useful in simple NLP
tasks, these non-learnable methods fail to handle complex multimodal tasks like
Visual Question Answering (VQA). In this study, we propose \textbf{Learnable
ICV} (L-ICV) to distill essential task information from demonstrations,
improving ICL performance in LMMs. Experiments show that L-ICV can
significantly reduce computational costs while enhancing accuracy in VQA tasks
compared to traditional ICL and other non-learnable ICV methods. | [
-0.5149953961,
-0.8327402472,
0.3839928508,
0.1863906682,
-0.4792056382,
0.2459648699,
-0.0947065875,
-0.3900110424,
-0.1797683388,
0.1721577644,
-0.5585845709,
-0.4461408854,
-0.3630961776,
-0.0507509671,
-0.3877971768,
0.6943984032,
-0.1520939469,
0.2123759985,
-0.9510225654,
-0.4208122194,
-0.546631217,
-0.3482811749,
-0.4430499673,
0.0193591788,
0.3830736876,
0.6807199121,
0.2135292143,
0.4250634015,
0.4080526531,
0.2918539345,
-0.0258926265,
0.4502070248,
-0.3861844838,
0.1464117765,
-0.1011911705,
-0.4752032161,
-0.1910789162,
-0.2572128475,
0.6663548946,
0.6359752417,
-0.0195056982,
0.2418920696,
0.1211755276,
0.4284303188,
-0.561195612,
0.3015450537,
-0.5990689993,
-0.0490745939,
-0.0158775076,
-0.4136219025,
-0.3986361921,
0.0804341659,
0.469132483,
-0.6359354854,
0.0192605574,
0.0525229536,
0.6246367693,
0.3450699449,
-0.3729361594,
0.0330726653,
-0.6756591201,
0.901796639,
-0.5738145709,
0.4013108909,
0.0644104034,
0.53698349,
-0.0755166486,
-0.8960071206,
-0.6597778797,
-0.2113371491,
0.2332532108,
0.1916583627,
-0.2290608883,
0.0585082024,
0.5302443504,
0.0237786882,
-0.4348753095,
0.025122121,
-0.2796971798,
-0.0302529335,
0.0556832664,
0.2773635089,
0.5177689791,
-0.3561679423,
-0.7193785906,
-0.2097230852,
-0.6109621525,
0.7712418437,
-0.1749835759,
0.1293855906,
-0.1905737817,
0.675481379,
-0.3051029742,
0.7500188947,
-0.0886089504,
-0.5024865866,
0.2676155865,
-0.2370093018,
-0.3406722248,
-0.3149691522,
0.3357024789,
0.4068048,
0.0536595285,
-0.0399084166,
-0.0919498354,
-0.2014169246,
0.2727909684,
-0.8825079799,
-0.1252089441,
0.2877462804,
-0.5382993817,
0.120042406,
-0.1079029366,
-0.7953669429,
-0.0904549509,
-0.4584197104,
0.7061938643,
-0.6301555634,
-0.080648616,
-0.2157385945,
-0.3958856463,
0.6530977488,
0.7323099971,
-0.4151230454,
-0.0281984843,
0.3431971371,
0.6928987503,
-0.2454136312,
-0.2455199659,
-0.9269528985,
0.091224663,
-0.2916846275,
0.6423894167,
-0.6250470281,
-0.263587147,
-0.0709621236,
-0.0314984955,
-0.069229573,
-0.5468330383,
0.1736027747,
-0.6071283221,
-0.1345189959,
-0.4769654572,
-0.4300794899,
-0.4111168385,
0.4344766438,
-0.5070344806,
0.8596361279,
0.0620371997,
-0.8682938218,
0.4047411978,
-0.4387717545,
-0.2919428051,
0.2905704379,
-0.4373438954,
-0.3251130581,
0.0486748219,
0.6323407292,
0.767760396,
-0.1668938249,
-0.0193568561,
-0.4141446352,
-0.5094023943,
0.3116855025,
-0.5147275925,
0.5001809597,
-0.0058274455,
-0.4161705077,
0.2781694829,
-0.7925909162,
0.0166978016,
-0.0475712903,
-0.2788618803,
-0.4653238654,
0.0637548789,
0.0144610805,
0.3889528513,
-0.0114331022,
-0.5397046208,
0.0294867735,
-0.2160177678,
0.4053798616,
0.7455762029,
-0.0709798411,
0.3698042333,
-0.1921068877,
0.8347110152,
0.3627393842,
0.1137807369,
-0.1594922841,
-0.4725211263,
-0.912743926,
-0.7798894644,
0.0276179798,
0.5662409663,
-1.8711909056,
-0.4106226563,
-0.1602886617,
-0.5605336428,
-0.3481478393,
0.2601650059,
0.5840658545,
0.9283930063,
0.5059731603,
-0.0382534079,
-0.2409658879,
-1.0361453295,
0.086341776,
-0.1372044235,
0.0129159745,
0.6020582914,
0.5371818542,
0.0601552501,
0.8756284118,
-0.3389508128,
-0.1832007319,
-0.4149776995,
0.1282594055,
-0.1633980274,
0.2885657847,
0.6311787367,
-1.0158938169,
-0.406267792,
-0.1500878483,
-0.7415545583,
0.1546299011,
-0.0888344869,
-0.025608873,
0.0308720563,
0.9046360254,
-0.3610752225,
0.5328659415,
0.4368717968,
-0.0746734068,
0.2890517414,
-0.390537262,
0.1379962564,
-0.8941134214,
-0.0612468645,
0.097783953,
-0.3790451884,
-0.5654153824,
0.000276621,
0.4641880989,
-0.0935358182,
-1.0441763401,
0.5311208963,
-0.3976347446,
0.010099858,
-0.0281572882,
-0.0053893263,
-0.0350592025,
0.745821476,
0.0504476987,
0.9452309012,
0.8583995104,
-0.7906904817,
0.2070459872,
0.3342740536,
-0.5798648,
0.7881568074,
-0.6898418665,
-0.166528061,
-0.7882184982,
0.1113520414,
-1.2586308718,
-0.1537883878,
0.1028616428,
-0.2860789299,
0.3697603345,
-0.096108295,
-0.2439145297,
-0.0919528902,
-0.2487306893,
0.7827606797,
0.3619163334,
-0.91974473,
0.6977544427,
0.228945747,
-0.0778483152,
-0.8787525296,
-0.5404518247,
-0.0442954712,
-0.3280248642,
-0.4808470905,
0.1762236655,
-0.2849936187,
-0.0697038844,
-0.1039013565,
0.085502781,
-0.0060509858,
-0.0819632336,
0.3641681075,
0.4587135613,
-0.2196872383,
0.4101148546,
-0.0430827513,
0.0590057746,
-0.1054702103,
0.0318738632,
0.2443123162,
-0.178539589,
-0.505571723,
-0.4465583563,
0.6126898527,
0.8942673206,
-0.6079441309,
0.5913637877,
0.5984306335,
-0.350332886,
-0.4701579809,
-0.4117732048,
0.118649371,
-0.4219525456,
0.5675034523,
-0.4485192597,
-0.9121078253,
0.2645659745,
-0.0898565874,
0.0176868737,
0.1354229301,
0.4270257056,
-0.3843458295,
1.0868788958,
0.654188931,
0.2929126024,
0.6699758768,
-0.3157250583,
0.0346024521,
-0.9963720441,
-0.4718891978,
-0.1692390144,
-0.4229494631,
-0.3882193863,
-0.7689183354,
0.7731413245,
0.0391789749,
0.0746239498,
0.0487539507,
-0.2425787151,
0.2901217043,
0.671077013,
0.3672648072,
0.095699586,
0.041390352,
-0.1447655112,
-0.1513931751,
-0.8983367085,
-0.1292481124,
0.9565823078,
0.1815280318,
0.8373881578,
0.1537939161,
0.1255130172,
-0.2329027206,
0.2045460343,
-0.6366349459,
0.672395885,
-0.1938237846,
-0.323810041,
-0.3013215363,
-0.2488758415,
-0.5984552503,
0.3676821291,
-0.4599809051,
-0.6021218896,
0.3780844808,
0.3078689575,
-0.3858557642,
0.3653086424,
-0.6654795408,
0.8429496288,
-0.1346698254,
-0.3899097443,
0.0443314575,
-0.69063133,
0.3391244411,
0.1996131688,
0.0648761243,
0.0817133486,
-0.2186480612,
0.4875550568,
-0.2934925258,
0.9051871896,
-0.286442101,
0.137484476,
0.3908628523,
-0.0708554462,
0.5181298852,
0.2219317704,
0.3986028135,
-0.0543311127,
0.0511910245,
-0.3754528761,
-0.7425302863,
0.7431934476,
-0.5912181735,
-0.427161783,
-0.2181439251,
-0.645749867,
-0.3164046705,
-0.100949496,
0.2200857252,
1.0275195837,
0.0796622187,
0.5791912675,
0.9971663952,
-0.5477190018,
0.688678503,
0.2043912411,
0.0130471047,
-0.4207084179,
1.023103714,
0.1296942085,
0.4681248069,
0.6535028219,
-0.0824013203,
-0.3292885423,
-0.6527898312,
-0.5608651638,
-0.0073471041,
-1.0208323002,
-0.1539580375,
-0.8052222133,
-0.1232628524,
0.0556892417,
-0.1150514111,
-0.2619582117,
-0.2957355082,
-0.5038334727,
-0.0457625724,
0.3188973665,
0.2454295307,
0.2125668824,
-0.0394902565,
-0.5840727687,
0.7499597073,
0.820204258,
0.2811985314,
0.0927489474,
-0.4445309043,
0.0267056432,
0.0185343307,
-0.0328205414,
-0.5350033045,
0.297031045,
0.2226448804,
0.5327336788,
0.318772763,
0.1892458946,
1.1699624062,
-0.5479778647,
0.7540152669,
0.1599459797,
-0.800303936,
0.3278482258,
-0.2116003186,
0.4511772394,
0.4176590741,
0.3894166648,
-0.385119319,
-0.2642008364,
-0.176349625,
-1.0589331388,
0.4778624773,
0.0722143203,
0.1687227041,
-0.0347595066,
0.3516819775,
0.0721394196,
0.3203490973,
-0.6458779573,
-0.2494094968,
-0.2807283103,
-0.1309386045,
-0.2284607291,
-0.2915614545,
0.030487271,
-0.5613036752,
0.4609161019,
-0.3488717377,
0.1785248518,
0.5026723742,
-0.3363682628,
0.1252515763,
0.1429148912,
0.6907090545,
0.9557848573,
-0.1684873551,
0.3119450808,
0.3582662046,
-0.192735076,
-0.0188303571,
-0.1250833422,
-0.0816160217,
-0.1386024356,
0.4032810628,
0.7932396531,
0.298193574,
-1.2432261705,
0.9413977265,
-0.3600485027,
-0.101320602,
-0.6170253158,
-0.0216069575,
0.1203185841,
0.6024522185,
0.3095512986,
0.1009057611,
0.0246618167,
-0.4256628752,
0.1870150715,
0.8389940858,
-0.639911294,
0.009592169,
0.9277459979,
0.133173123,
-0.1077066809,
0.6706395745,
0.0189436059,
-0.3309592009,
0.7353711128,
0.3364246786,
0.5330335498,
0.1104400903,
0.2709410191,
0.2612091303,
0.1087435335,
0.2550436556,
0.5023828745,
-0.1635241061,
-0.4643690884,
-0.6176065803,
-0.301458627,
-0.420050025,
0.269195497,
-0.6670885682,
0.3268443644,
-0.267264694,
0.1806331426,
-0.0272140447,
-0.5881130695,
-0.8345039487,
0.3316425979,
0.1391582936,
0.8432834744,
-0.5754705667,
0.7230675817,
0.7662452459,
-0.3119629622,
-0.649546802,
-0.235966906,
-0.2595489919,
-0.6884377599,
0.8375322819,
0.1575601995,
-0.1467791498,
-0.0715427548,
-0.7637738585,
-0.7067005634,
1.2499297857,
0.3891010284,
-0.2404838949,
0.0445450433,
0.0107372599,
0.381077975,
-0.3130806983,
0.3143438697,
-0.0553658381,
0.1800082177,
0.4434734881,
-0.6193803549,
-0.0857634619,
-0.3202283084,
0.2242351919,
0.0004258308,
-0.6121987104,
0.9264252186,
-0.2888682485,
-0.1109409928,
0.0539658517,
0.7928586006,
0.1752831042,
0.2867712975,
0.6880415082,
0.2820435464,
0.4835555255,
0.0919453576,
1.0975496769,
0.0082290517,
-0.040382687,
0.9579322934,
0.1026759967,
1.0531313419,
0.8871884346,
0.2207069099,
0.2201467603,
0.4430452287,
0.1847988069,
0.5004598498,
0.0770142972,
-0.3167389631,
-0.7071996927,
-0.0786955282,
-0.1237022504,
0.754083097,
0.2754859328,
-0.0912830159,
-0.2797534168,
0.4310660064,
-0.3043964803,
-0.0059394236,
-0.4705009758,
0.6567528248,
0.0011299399,
-0.6729229689,
0.4970719516,
-0.2474677414,
0.5778969526,
-0.5994400978,
-0.5054442286,
0.0069531975,
0.1555003375,
0.0458904319,
-0.577768743,
-0.0308300108,
-0.1234688684,
-0.1781876683,
-0.2462144792,
0.4965775311,
-0.6407437921,
-0.554710269,
0.1793463379,
0.6512732506,
-0.0611327961,
-0.0287869014,
-0.304400444,
-0.2509777248,
-0.0531541966,
-0.1830017269,
0.5105282068,
0.3956995606,
-0.2058122754,
1.1363470554,
0.5734975934,
-0.2883814573,
0.1013972312,
-0.2068689167,
1.0267060995,
-0.5390427113,
-0.3841737807,
-0.6683651209,
0.8149612546,
0.0746774599,
-0.2878758907,
0.7215028405,
0.2882779539,
0.9315879345,
-0.2251365036,
0.7249738574,
0.0639041811,
0.5240111947,
-0.6921685934,
0.4992654622,
-0.9845865965,
0.1415825337,
-0.4594117701,
-0.6023519039,
-0.3327673376,
0.3797419667,
0.138055101,
-0.1307954341,
0.6574181914,
0.6512838602,
-0.1706965417,
-0.280384928,
0.5502770543,
0.0813576207,
0.4675834179,
0.6791958809,
1.0209661722,
-0.1152136326,
0.7642911673,
-0.5370407104,
-0.2603839636,
-0.1783120483,
-1.0044740438,
-1.1553707123,
-0.8394979835,
-0.4470514357,
-0.0091275806,
-0.2986319661,
0.9382519722,
0.6651819348,
-0.5233103633,
0.0380351841,
0.2982015908,
0.0791076422,
-0.4431262314,
-0.1888450682,
0.4709892571,
-0.1500650942,
-0.9312751889,
0.4100905061,
0.4430704117,
0.1156833544,
-0.1079600975,
0.1947264522,
-0.2219324708,
0.0548447855,
0.9646678567,
0.3145619035,
-0.6624219418,
-0.53622365,
0.0463870727,
0.1506263167,
0.1872258931,
0.6323050261,
-0.9275193214,
0.8694945574,
0.5648399591,
0.902831912,
0.5250982046,
0.0461550839,
0.3370708525,
-0.8344476819,
0.314181298,
0.1152075008,
0.4558048844,
0.2529506981,
-0.1179250777,
-0.0082323207,
0.0189745445,
-0.2582408488,
-0.6989429593,
0.2605033517,
-1.2403466702,
-0.4274701774,
1.1039733887,
-0.0779084638,
-0.3744437695,
-0.2434326708,
-0.4146211147,
0.0159094799,
-0.1817696989,
0.3351161182,
0.4794074595,
-0.3133729994,
-0.4563999772,
-0.9140669107,
0.4984681606,
0.3512356281,
-0.7686648369,
-0.2536137998,
0.4330118895,
0.3527021706,
-0.17205064,
0.4428440332,
-0.0259739496,
0.5016536117,
-0.2733344436,
0.171886459,
-0.2858869433,
-0.52075845,
-0.3213658035,
0.4608808458,
0.0603823103,
-0.5613045096
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13184v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13184v1 | Locating and Extracting Relational Concepts in Large Language Models | 2024-06-19T03:29:51 | 2024-06-19T03:29:51 | Zijian Wang, Britney White, Chang Xu | cs.CL | cs.CL | Relational concepts are indeed foundational to the structure of knowledge
representation, as they facilitate the association between various entity
concepts, allowing us to express and comprehend complex world knowledge. By
expressing relational concepts in natural language prompts, people can
effortlessly interact with large language models (LLMs) and recall desired
factual knowledge. However, the process of knowledge recall lacks
interpretability, and representations of relational concepts within LLMs remain
unknown to us. In this paper, we identify hidden states that can express entity
and relational concepts through causal mediation analysis in fact recall
processes. Our finding reveals that at the last token position of the input
prompt, there are hidden states that solely express the causal effects of
relational concepts. Based on this finding, we assume that these hidden states
can be treated as relational representations and we can successfully extract
them from LLMs. The experimental results demonstrate high credibility of the
relational representations: they can be flexibly transplanted into other fact
recall processes, and can also be used as robust entity connectors. Moreover,
we also show that the relational representations exhibit significant potential
for controllable fact recall through relation rewriting. | [
-0.3273397684,
-1.0020363331,
1.1020869017,
0.1286050826,
-0.0583689511,
-0.1116902605,
-0.164758727,
-0.4001210332,
0.3801854551,
0.4150441587,
-0.4400572479,
-0.2890368402,
-0.5793824792,
0.0729026124,
-0.3006101549,
0.5721443295,
-0.151429981,
-0.1969888955,
-0.3978669643,
-0.0056019579,
-0.6270909309,
-0.572874248,
-0.4237417579,
-0.4174339771,
0.7412230372,
0.1823228896,
0.7331781387,
0.6366326809,
0.3703091145,
0.3144499362,
-0.2279181778,
0.0172593314,
-0.4446679354,
0.3257499635,
-0.7120323181,
-0.5810910463,
-0.0546227247,
0.2174721062,
1.1310806274,
0.9280799627,
-0.1796450019,
0.1224922612,
-0.314249754,
0.4355288148,
-0.9031466246,
0.8039392233,
-0.6183633208,
-0.1219907701,
0.0090697268,
-0.2637618184,
-0.5491974354,
-0.2852479517,
0.1666818857,
-0.562533021,
-0.0648465604,
0.264950037,
1.0649877787,
0.1029831171,
-0.9079885483,
-0.2704311907,
-0.9753251672,
0.4348491728,
-0.318508625,
0.5786978602,
0.192605719,
0.2303657383,
-0.4284193218,
-0.5961434841,
-0.8027290702,
-0.3399413228,
-0.5123513937,
-0.0545563959,
-0.2261205614,
-0.1464615613,
0.6395300627,
0.182482481,
-0.0927219018,
-0.0389106199,
0.1056112498,
-0.4040494859,
0.3685842454,
0.2871051133,
0.5377673507,
-0.4076933563,
-0.3587472439,
0.1432499439,
-1.0326586962,
-0.1444466412,
-0.2139137685,
0.2368293256,
-0.0062442436,
0.6205800176,
0.0201007985,
0.4512179494,
-0.075284645,
-0.3005697727,
-0.0234929975,
-0.3482182324,
-0.2170571387,
-0.0916583389,
0.7825649381,
-0.1948617846,
-0.1721791625,
-0.3745053411,
-0.0359955318,
0.0516195856,
-0.0280160867,
-0.6194397807,
0.0621803738,
-0.263964951,
-0.415088892,
0.0364161693,
0.1508535445,
-0.4385724068,
-0.3856101036,
-0.4009051919,
0.3539782763,
-0.1833669096,
-0.6746526361,
-0.1590456218,
-0.2113990784,
0.2711049616,
0.25000301,
-0.8307320476,
0.3891741931,
0.7616358995,
0.5650683045,
-0.0182013493,
0.0081630312,
-0.3587938249,
0.6029726863,
-0.5467168093,
0.4473898709,
-0.680318296,
-0.2104928493,
0.1847780943,
0.3315347731,
-0.203348428,
-0.4055314362,
0.410794884,
-1.0423184633,
0.1177721471,
-0.7971115708,
-0.8536180854,
-0.2334880084,
0.1409466416,
-1.1143351793,
0.6643669009,
-0.1539138407,
-1.0320678949,
0.1663156897,
-0.3711546659,
-0.2883141637,
-0.1966642886,
-0.4573101401,
-0.2345472276,
0.2131651044,
-0.0261027943,
0.5239548087,
-0.6083853245,
0.5142387748,
-0.3661074936,
-0.1454523355,
0.6439328194,
-0.2649729252,
0.7971069217,
-0.0103448462,
-0.2320667058,
-0.142350018,
-0.8347741365,
-0.5403887033,
0.2768820524,
-0.3208411038,
-0.7312863469,
0.0243372284,
-0.6825973392,
0.3451381028,
0.1478147954,
-0.5057826042,
0.1551905274,
-0.1963936538,
0.2035035342,
0.4007165134,
0.5056605935,
0.8526348472,
0.1799302101,
0.2273898572,
0.3744541109,
-0.3416987062,
0.0136039611,
-0.2966634035,
-0.7147059441,
-0.1878545433,
0.1412404478,
0.3689913452,
-1.0660889149,
0.31327793,
-0.4382627308,
-0.0748233423,
-0.0872061551,
-0.0891651884,
0.3050265014,
0.757037282,
0.1105480194,
0.0608660206,
-0.2563501596,
-1.1531569958,
-0.3482735753,
-0.4133485258,
0.1029531062,
0.1358252466,
0.6435094476,
0.0183480829,
0.9909616113,
-0.6489165425,
-0.1898170561,
-0.1463818997,
0.1250083148,
0.3005585372,
0.1533431709,
0.1933988929,
-0.9831496477,
0.0428043082,
-0.2287113219,
-1.2119812965,
0.2595808506,
-0.3827822506,
-0.1702277362,
0.0058075134,
0.7392628193,
-1.2629573345,
0.3071638048,
-0.1201557592,
-0.4654225707,
0.519133985,
-0.0395211875,
-0.1729191542,
-0.9318285584,
0.1926466972,
-0.20448865,
-0.2535773516,
-0.3372215033,
0.3549201787,
0.2473854274,
0.0210840907,
-0.2215363681,
0.4992062747,
-0.9171078801,
-0.1355402917,
0.0107019786,
0.4345512986,
0.0331570879,
0.3805655539,
0.2709306479,
0.4595840275,
0.5645122528,
-0.6739500761,
0.299401015,
0.3000424504,
-0.3054935932,
0.3736048341,
-0.3145094812,
-0.225028798,
-0.4110594392,
0.3021415472,
-0.6336715817,
-0.1708724648,
0.4472844005,
-0.1562412977,
0.6142119765,
-0.2051277906,
-0.7434658408,
-0.2013141811,
0.1894145459,
-0.1168082431,
0.3310470879,
-0.2622717023,
0.6834352016,
0.6705927253,
-0.078669332,
-0.6684213877,
-0.3563008308,
-0.0301726889,
-0.2770258188,
-0.1657764167,
0.0673129782,
0.4044321775,
-0.3656781018,
0.3665129244,
-0.1676482111,
0.047765065,
0.2665941417,
0.4901337922,
0.2842221856,
-0.2043693215,
0.6636288762,
0.0712426156,
-0.2462470233,
0.7297782898,
-0.2491929084,
0.1178981885,
-0.0538095459,
-0.2619988918,
-0.3009102643,
0.3742058277,
0.4919106364,
-0.1936412454,
1.2993394136,
0.5502830744,
-0.6143713593,
0.1307705045,
-0.4274869263,
-0.2481830865,
-0.3527756631,
0.3476079404,
-0.4314683974,
-1.1442226171,
0.5549088717,
-0.4955789745,
-0.1989402175,
0.4070480168,
0.4349474907,
-0.0142890448,
0.7121116519,
0.7007451653,
-0.1504530758,
0.2720913589,
-0.1671419144,
0.3508503139,
-0.809564054,
-0.3991184235,
-0.5346073508,
0.0031387797,
-0.6231216788,
-0.3185420036,
0.3479996026,
0.5395490527,
-0.3611702323,
0.1925906539,
0.2985702157,
0.3738709688,
0.4790481329,
0.1679850519,
0.5137565136,
-0.0735205337,
-0.4945335984,
-0.1197022423,
-0.5932921171,
-0.3936287165,
0.5171065331,
0.2731766403,
0.5862640738,
0.446048826,
0.7343713641,
-0.1906527877,
0.4205018282,
-0.7788814306,
0.6564298868,
0.4834654331,
-0.7786964178,
-0.3827340305,
-0.6567862034,
-0.8605558276,
0.2209174633,
-0.4826998711,
-0.9073006511,
0.3752872944,
-0.0062669106,
-0.1573925912,
0.2860646546,
-0.415302366,
0.7163466215,
0.4393712878,
-0.5288318992,
-0.3752762377,
-0.7747009993,
0.6248996258,
0.0026637772,
0.27204597,
-0.1130745113,
0.0500931665,
0.5928962231,
-0.3125186265,
0.9199503064,
-0.1917068511,
-0.2662958205,
0.4325416684,
0.5521484613,
0.588006258,
0.2440380603,
0.1880859435,
-0.2143857032,
-0.1862473637,
-0.1649158299,
-1.0152388811,
0.8112069368,
-0.6131917834,
-1.0147507191,
-0.3425936401,
-0.3650634587,
-0.1841120571,
0.4202485383,
-0.2704648972,
0.3952821195,
-0.3392311931,
0.0061446708,
0.9010073543,
-0.3017355204,
0.4584953487,
0.7319079638,
-0.3968254626,
0.0821231678,
0.9208687544,
0.021800058,
0.1443172842,
0.9153302908,
0.1547862291,
-0.506164968,
-0.1235897616,
-0.0615846589,
0.752910316,
-0.808904469,
-0.2833026052,
-0.725378871,
-0.1040666476,
-0.1610979289,
0.4348369241,
-0.3408370614,
-0.6176983714,
-0.367364943,
-0.482670635,
0.1497444063,
0.6711691618,
-0.2752310932,
0.0343318395,
-0.9068193436,
0.4554265738,
0.5285205245,
0.1247579977,
0.1513642669,
-0.0891766474,
-0.26069507,
-0.1573438942,
-0.0483939126,
-1.0628368855,
0.2574445307,
-0.0055669439,
0.5499592423,
0.5337349176,
0.1898908913,
0.598567307,
-0.5636379123,
0.6450635791,
0.1685379297,
-0.8257915378,
0.44113639,
-0.2001268715,
0.0495605953,
0.1222304627,
0.9586593509,
-0.5262902379,
-0.1714253575,
-0.6212728024,
-0.5060546994,
0.3655058444,
0.17339091,
0.0597292297,
-0.4366902411,
0.5609302521,
-0.2434418797,
0.1300914139,
-0.7224590182,
-0.450668335,
0.243658483,
0.1619742215,
0.228215903,
-0.6116099358,
-0.2948938906,
-0.0424343906,
0.4220886827,
0.270691365,
0.515273869,
0.230539009,
-0.2948103845,
-0.2363143116,
0.3717004061,
0.2221584916,
0.7689320445,
-0.0237006526,
0.7356494665,
-0.2688840926,
-0.1148654073,
0.2249976695,
-0.0532875955,
-0.3215455711,
0.0383799374,
0.706626296,
0.6317982674,
0.5758473873,
-0.2529591024,
0.5771089196,
-0.1290067136,
0.4122565687,
-0.3740368783,
-0.0371384025,
0.740021944,
0.3561117649,
0.1403846294,
-0.0121316975,
0.1752698272,
-0.9381002188,
0.2611991167,
0.5058010221,
-0.4045725465,
-0.5721891522,
0.6676442027,
-0.0910752788,
0.0631122366,
0.8773977757,
-0.3161771595,
-0.4036991894,
0.1867799759,
0.8126727343,
0.4995450974,
-0.1456583887,
0.4050596952,
0.5708301067,
0.1290614307,
0.0003870193,
0.134562701,
0.0848484188,
-1.1025444269,
-0.5700466037,
-0.4536653757,
-0.013746283,
-0.0674949437,
-0.9640473127,
0.0158063099,
-0.2471411526,
-0.1430134773,
0.0631691888,
-0.0866603553,
-0.7235965133,
-0.1406408101,
0.1995650381,
0.8445522785,
-1.1006320715,
0.9640367627,
0.3775557578,
-0.7395043969,
-1.2729027271,
-0.3554617465,
0.1977302134,
-0.6550684571,
1.0049543381,
-0.3043238223,
-0.0536323898,
-0.0604504682,
-0.7020204067,
-1.0617090464,
1.0335390568,
0.4765151143,
-0.4819492996,
-0.2552636862,
0.0605950393,
0.4217829406,
-0.3280061781,
0.1305907816,
0.6556915641,
0.4148178995,
0.2723391354,
-0.6531678438,
0.6943247318,
-0.0148598086,
-0.0221600085,
0.1736823916,
-0.3291337788,
0.6868544817,
-0.2544615269,
-0.655606389,
-0.1417099833,
0.8170579672,
0.1980389506,
-0.0099076023,
0.306425631,
0.5009072423,
0.7658964396,
0.0051479535,
1.1019123793,
0.0978822559,
0.4169255793,
1.1864036322,
-0.2741524577,
0.8016272783,
0.5389213562,
0.0368883312,
0.82283324,
0.4060911238,
0.4047778547,
0.5415264964,
0.0010465272,
-0.1991088092,
-0.5513489842,
-0.3973701,
-0.2165915817,
0.33725214,
0.7969446182,
-0.409055233,
-0.2028561085,
-0.218708545,
0.3372947276,
-0.0611050315,
-0.2402417511,
0.8838364482,
0.4111725688,
-0.5805118084,
0.5198053122,
-0.2156691551,
-0.1978835315,
-0.431145072,
-0.5426011682,
-0.2962052226,
-0.1601265967,
0.0325637832,
-0.5740407109,
0.1124062687,
-0.5428685546,
-0.2759383321,
-0.1940744221,
0.9735958576,
-0.577870369,
-0.2645274103,
0.375346601,
0.6736403704,
0.0361316912,
-0.1483377963,
-0.3465971053,
-0.1418195367,
-0.1898025125,
-0.1900208145,
0.1968865246,
0.9954458475,
-0.4106496572,
0.7525404096,
0.4324336946,
0.2969566286,
0.0336136669,
0.122312896,
1.0818229914,
-1.0299664736,
-0.2721952498,
-0.8704363108,
0.1536451578,
-0.1172452718,
0.2991938293,
0.8468130827,
0.2375651598,
0.5384029746,
-0.1738837361,
0.3927576542,
-0.0102428952,
0.549620688,
-0.5605601072,
0.7312780023,
-0.103407532,
0.2917843759,
-0.4912389219,
-0.9315173626,
-0.3294055462,
0.3840932548,
-0.246271506,
-0.4256472588,
0.9347539544,
0.5928652287,
0.076543875,
-0.0479057357,
0.2583522201,
0.6981198192,
0.3803490698,
0.4278439879,
1.1911239624,
-0.1831847429,
0.1861249059,
0.063425824,
-0.1275872141,
-0.0582607612,
-0.8784844875,
-0.7969419956,
-0.7172428966,
-0.331641078,
-0.2352403253,
-0.2488612086,
0.6789252758,
0.4006487131,
-0.5491015315,
0.0434918441,
0.0502141416,
0.8292820454,
-0.1552370638,
-0.273426652,
0.6035352349,
-0.1377020329,
-0.2663142681,
0.3821744323,
0.3319289982,
-0.0244023893,
-0.3005061746,
0.1392444521,
-0.4713572264,
-0.1983253658,
0.7527150512,
0.3259333968,
-0.7162557244,
-0.7261527777,
0.0432254337,
-0.021653574,
-0.2736424804,
1.2002187967,
-1.0046092272,
0.2833127081,
0.3504433632,
0.4966376126,
0.5373459458,
-0.147160247,
0.671215117,
-0.7993270755,
0.09755788,
0.0033747733,
0.4918370247,
0.2405249476,
-0.2525187731,
0.2964444458,
0.4478595555,
-0.1011134014,
-0.5178120732,
0.5240505934,
-0.7658170462,
-0.395807147,
1.0712021589,
-0.3749596179,
-0.3023251295,
-0.3064790666,
0.2203944325,
0.5472883582,
-0.108756125,
0.6702197194,
0.6913679838,
-0.1004180312,
-0.3055815995,
-0.3214043677,
0.5333944559,
0.0065807202,
-0.6129181981,
0.0892949849,
0.7062467337,
0.3878911138,
0.4093259871,
0.5353308916,
-0.2355407923,
-0.1124130189,
0.0109682735,
-0.2115574032,
0.148705855,
-0.3416073322,
0.0856802538,
0.2248073071,
0.0678478777,
0.1247756481
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13173v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13173v2 | Biomedical Visual Instruction Tuning with Clinician Preference Alignment | 2024-06-19T03:07:33 | 2024-06-30T01:22:09 | Hejie Cui, Lingjun Mao, Xin Liang, Jieyu Zhang, Hui Ren, Quanzheng Li, Xiang Li, Carl Yang | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, 68T50, 68T45, 68T37, 68T05, 68T07, 68T09,, I.2.7; I.2.6; I.2.10 | Recent advancements in multimodal foundation models have showcased impressive
capabilities in understanding and reasoning with visual and textual
information. Adapting these foundation models trained for general usage to
specialized domains like biomedicine requires large-scale domain-specific
instruction datasets. While existing works have explored curating such datasets
automatically, the resultant datasets are not explicitly aligned with domain
expertise. In this work, we propose a data-centric framework, Biomedical Visual
Instruction Tuning with Clinician Preference Alignment (BioMed-VITAL), that
incorporates clinician preferences into both stages of generating and selecting
instruction data for tuning biomedical multimodal foundation models. First,
during the generation stage, we prompt the GPT-4V generator with a diverse set
of clinician-selected demonstrations for preference-aligned data candidate
generation. Then, during the selection phase, we train a separate selection
model, which explicitly distills clinician and policy-guided model preferences
into a rating function to select high-quality data for medical instruction
tuning. Results show that the model tuned with the instruction-following data
from our method demonstrates a significant improvement in open visual chat
(18.5% relatively) and medical VQA (win rate up to 81.73%). Our
instruction-following data and models are available at BioMed-VITAL.github.io. | [
-0.1609116644,
-0.7012556195,
0.6656112075,
-0.1553027481,
-0.300222069,
-0.1412600577,
-0.2051730007,
-0.0945084244,
0.0919748992,
0.5237555504,
-0.528401494,
-0.8760365248,
-0.540410161,
-0.3356310725,
0.3922457993,
1.1332455873,
0.0000216986,
0.4021522403,
-0.6808047295,
-0.3176512718,
-0.9761829972,
-0.1542837173,
-0.4257299304,
-0.2469213307,
0.5064756274,
0.5882174969,
0.7901868224,
1.0009511709,
0.6221649051,
0.2681855857,
0.3461248577,
0.3691248596,
-0.7120379806,
0.0681251287,
-0.331074506,
-0.3369857073,
-0.7135877609,
-0.0739701018,
0.3162438571,
0.6208632588,
0.0272944625,
0.2382438332,
-0.2011234909,
0.8087784052,
-0.497089088,
0.2768274248,
-0.5633362532,
0.056938123,
-0.1051956415,
-0.7765309215,
-0.5103390813,
-0.4600815475,
0.3060920238,
-0.6559448242,
0.3470555544,
-0.2098176479,
0.7130977511,
0.4511502981,
-0.63492769,
0.1831766665,
-0.2432710826,
0.7249955535,
-0.314178586,
0.4458063245,
0.2978643477,
0.4547693431,
-0.0230719857,
-0.4839328229,
-0.0690617487,
0.0921146423,
0.1758520752,
0.4530993402,
-0.0195793305,
0.3661365807,
0.1507465988,
0.0948569179,
-0.5980793238,
0.0522142686,
-0.4577171803,
-0.1287576854,
0.4738877416,
0.2754829824,
0.295362711,
0.0537715964,
-0.3869999945,
-0.2809209824,
-0.6695486903,
0.1672903299,
0.0043445965,
0.1330976933,
-0.2722777724,
0.6791039705,
-0.2458941936,
1.091075182,
0.3029156327,
-0.3428815007,
0.5685356855,
-0.4421159327,
-0.4156583548,
0.1360136867,
0.4886033535,
0.7468422651,
0.2023436874,
0.001601038,
0.1527629048,
0.2469928563,
0.8120702505,
-0.8748981953,
-0.4970721602,
0.3111782968,
-0.4198728204,
-0.5756636262,
-0.3503591716,
-0.6682704687,
-0.2689608634,
-0.7008900642,
0.4666130543,
-0.6450322866,
0.1360564232,
0.2753742337,
0.1038870662,
-0.0414874479,
0.5628014803,
-1.0508230925,
-0.2737241685,
0.3558411598,
0.6401261687,
-0.2290726453,
0.1514474154,
-0.6202325821,
0.3302055895,
-0.2729406953,
0.6818058491,
-0.7284874916,
-0.4324059784,
-0.068269603,
0.2370325327,
-0.2493778169,
-0.2587377131,
0.2287044674,
-0.3793679774,
0.1232623458,
-0.2168818265,
-0.5581509471,
-0.0668065101,
0.1998967081,
-0.3126513064,
0.3465364575,
0.1974976659,
-0.6807069182,
0.6618523598,
-0.6216910481,
-0.2693527937,
0.1289331764,
-0.6293216944,
-0.6398756504,
-0.1455592662,
0.3658835888,
0.6360864043,
0.0953305811,
0.2734924257,
-0.6411371827,
-0.1588311046,
0.1367541254,
-0.3194656968,
0.5686304569,
-0.1796169728,
-0.551892221,
0.5060484409,
-0.8247123957,
0.2640426755,
-0.1777073443,
0.0164205693,
-0.2416598648,
0.0114538204,
-0.3248593509,
0.113937974,
0.0477493666,
-0.5121249557,
0.3844839633,
-0.2235971689,
0.2987326682,
0.8908496499,
0.1043033004,
0.4389609694,
-0.3119269609,
0.6381665468,
0.1218589842,
0.4758288264,
0.0558691621,
-0.6843799353,
-0.5603768229,
-0.636069715,
0.1004085988,
0.4060132205,
-0.7826400995,
0.0952886567,
-0.3556477427,
-0.2900421321,
-0.7378140092,
0.0552293472,
0.4849953949,
0.942422688,
0.6943038106,
-0.1873813868,
-0.2115540057,
-1.0453544855,
0.3688946962,
0.1538855582,
0.3265419602,
0.8548917174,
0.10566625,
-0.4265692532,
0.7569149733,
-0.5753868818,
-0.2095302194,
0.2189311981,
-0.0584167242,
0.0457563214,
0.5204856396,
0.7930312157,
-0.8044131994,
-0.4612367451,
0.3146327734,
-0.7702540159,
-0.0341402255,
0.0346152633,
-0.735711813,
-0.1120638624,
-0.0166387931,
-0.3120355606,
0.6776324511,
0.3951563239,
-0.2882115543,
0.3531829417,
-0.2164237052,
0.6558795571,
-1.0907969475,
0.0233781729,
-0.0167139247,
-0.3001792133,
-0.3677549362,
-0.1610141844,
0.2623499632,
-0.0042717443,
-0.2956134379,
0.4636933506,
-0.2841256261,
0.2960669696,
-0.1982635707,
-0.1887145787,
0.0699498579,
0.3285673559,
0.335845232,
0.6832176447,
0.6678450704,
-0.5102316737,
0.2460383773,
0.650069356,
-0.019483583,
0.7305722833,
-0.5256130099,
0.0254000723,
-0.0332272537,
0.0188096259,
-0.784248054,
-0.480492264,
0.1689063907,
-0.3346904218,
0.6363218427,
-0.4395039678,
0.1245352775,
-0.2056172341,
-0.2092368603,
0.2312161326,
0.3263065517,
-0.5638378263,
0.1941071302,
0.4028252065,
-0.06824141,
-0.8675484061,
-0.3975402415,
-0.3459320068,
-0.0861231312,
-0.6128511429,
0.4264716506,
-0.1147902012,
0.2223813832,
-0.1999930143,
-0.1177335382,
0.1054632291,
-0.2447338551,
0.6056637168,
0.7957256436,
-0.353333205,
0.1810883433,
0.522305727,
-0.0545251817,
-0.1050812602,
-0.428188473,
0.0134547995,
0.1150760427,
-0.4996466339,
-0.316295892,
0.2756255567,
0.5616244078,
-0.3700495958,
0.6878350377,
0.6706332564,
-0.0459327511,
0.0795853958,
-0.4815855026,
-0.2580113709,
-0.4497053623,
0.3136066794,
-0.0992081463,
-0.8943009377,
-0.1078609005,
0.0937201157,
0.2008218169,
0.0982446969,
0.830068469,
-0.2393922359,
1.2809374332,
0.5329691172,
0.3430854976,
0.4496438205,
-0.2562068105,
-0.1602174789,
-0.6214420795,
-0.245214805,
0.0144655239,
-0.3182563484,
-0.372736752,
-0.5006639957,
0.892924726,
-0.2667767704,
-0.191501528,
-0.0869981349,
-0.7227299213,
0.3258884251,
0.3914979398,
0.6960163713,
-0.1540640444,
0.2233055979,
-0.2899415493,
-0.2104611844,
-0.7166546583,
-0.430383116,
1.4408684969,
0.131425783,
0.7446547747,
0.10761749,
0.6351140141,
-0.0127347549,
0.5098901391,
-0.5702899098,
0.1415013373,
-0.3491004407,
-0.4982921481,
-0.107920222,
-0.4694894254,
-0.7671387196,
-0.0224644318,
-0.5733928084,
-0.6245775223,
0.4077497721,
0.6796262264,
-0.5693989396,
-0.005949643,
-0.8220097423,
1.2089699507,
-0.3265715539,
-0.8877500296,
-0.2054736614,
-0.8854832649,
0.4203645885,
0.042204801,
-0.1259031743,
0.0302670486,
0.1902127713,
0.161771208,
-0.3078900576,
0.9519930482,
-0.2151794732,
0.1979795098,
-0.0850403458,
-0.2367013395,
0.0253661387,
0.3835938871,
0.2322519273,
-0.0675646961,
0.0984144434,
-0.4992461801,
-0.4710727334,
0.7900316119,
-0.7946842313,
-0.4634288251,
0.00700462,
-0.4315883219,
-0.7159038782,
0.0613705516,
0.4411281943,
0.8292429447,
-0.214548111,
0.5089954734,
1.1104331017,
-0.253783524,
-0.2360932529,
0.4743389189,
-0.0496414639,
-0.5642537475,
1.0711554289,
-0.1488227695,
0.4708064198,
0.5974891186,
0.0733941868,
-0.2298676223,
-0.4555394053,
-1.0062514544,
0.0102362446,
-0.6032901406,
-0.4213023484,
-0.7323413491,
-0.1044711694,
-0.402923435,
-0.3604964614,
-0.2247224599,
-0.1439521462,
-0.5981249213,
-0.0008111396,
0.5773467422,
0.119101949,
0.1976410896,
0.2660035491,
-0.8764328361,
0.4522652626,
0.4079413116,
0.4006891847,
-0.4180853069,
-0.4597703516,
-0.3880562782,
0.1824818552,
-0.5240568519,
-0.8820407987,
0.1581715494,
0.2459170073,
0.538313508,
0.6113000512,
-0.3996719718,
0.8395133018,
-0.6883921027,
0.3555806577,
0.3309440613,
-0.3259447813,
0.8776875734,
-0.4009210765,
0.1361829191,
0.7697871923,
0.4889695048,
0.1820919812,
-0.0494164191,
-0.4803534746,
-0.5324723125,
0.5947672129,
-0.0187912732,
-0.0707897022,
-0.0099818381,
0.3429434001,
0.4463121891,
0.3473944366,
-0.2445522398,
-0.2257823348,
-0.6396247149,
-0.5948874354,
-0.0267043058,
0.0732061043,
-0.523111403,
-0.3831276596,
0.670717895,
-0.53946805,
0.2203518003,
-0.0715945587,
-0.0040133782,
-0.0537307337,
0.1771151274,
0.5363348722,
0.6862946153,
-0.3301126063,
-0.2850755155,
-0.3246018291,
-0.5964241624,
0.133461073,
0.109897919,
-0.0960770696,
-0.1710245013,
0.2024047226,
1.2416635752,
0.3339607716,
-0.6088144779,
0.7404747605,
-0.1509787887,
-0.3513399959,
0.334548533,
0.5663727522,
-0.0400432758,
0.1400099248,
-0.2736880481,
0.3868856728,
0.3022058308,
-0.1526774764,
0.3098711967,
0.4954901934,
-0.5235081911,
-0.2747552693,
0.9344086647,
0.2748174369,
0.3561780751,
0.4843728542,
0.3674887419,
0.0196963232,
0.4171237648,
0.4632421732,
0.5185556412,
-0.1457737684,
0.5798110366,
0.2649410963,
-0.1378371716,
0.1667413116,
0.3955903351,
-0.204100281,
-0.7224999666,
-0.3581094444,
-0.5654060841,
-0.4039194882,
0.0366435759,
-0.8629565835,
0.413372308,
-0.3425522745,
-0.5412783027,
0.3516462743,
-0.2671454251,
-0.9260748029,
0.476226151,
0.0858086273,
0.5536768436,
-0.6794781685,
0.8498396873,
0.928638339,
-0.4193657041,
-0.6619220376,
-0.4425334632,
0.2785199583,
-0.9061285853,
0.3898158073,
0.1101064682,
-0.0322802924,
-0.0227948241,
-0.5465804338,
-0.4916627109,
1.137938261,
0.4850921035,
-0.7344875336,
0.0832665116,
-0.21903193,
0.5904478431,
-0.5657621622,
0.2505913675,
0.3024797142,
0.1647857577,
0.0939197168,
-0.539517045,
-0.3321508467,
-0.3520745933,
-0.1791360229,
0.2020194381,
-0.6234166622,
0.3589987159,
-0.5214973688,
0.1739940345,
-0.1744771153,
0.3621299863,
0.4480787218,
0.3950481117,
0.3106632829,
0.428820014,
0.5558971167,
0.0116532221,
0.8677108884,
-0.5502893925,
-0.1071535647,
1.0263808966,
-0.237779811,
0.3494166136,
0.431830734,
0.0404139869,
0.2407525331,
0.6314935088,
0.1242663488,
0.6391465664,
-0.3920973241,
-0.2123883367,
-0.4381604493,
0.0016236482,
-0.6561354995,
0.5543337464,
0.4191360474,
-0.6974463463,
0.1845922768,
0.148401618,
-0.3234944046,
-0.1532868892,
-0.1778993011,
0.7984508872,
-0.1616230309,
-0.4566321373,
0.5754498243,
-0.369348526,
0.0574575849,
-0.5640267134,
-0.3629758358,
-0.0159251746,
0.0922634676,
-0.2151928395,
-0.6936311126,
-0.1905421913,
-0.1079256162,
-0.479636699,
-0.2163841575,
0.4828277826,
-0.6069846153,
-0.2860995829,
-0.0487890728,
0.4759014547,
-0.0452986583,
0.4552439749,
-0.7359347343,
-0.1516597271,
0.3354473412,
-0.079016991,
0.4796222448,
0.4222532511,
-0.1604863107,
0.4669083655,
0.704621315,
0.1096142381,
-0.1409398913,
0.3679890335,
0.9106577039,
-0.3434195817,
-0.3638329804,
-0.4937287867,
0.4879103899,
-0.1385164559,
-0.5044107437,
0.3687528074,
0.4706936479,
0.4842119515,
-0.3161741197,
0.6848118305,
0.2729253173,
0.4043740928,
-0.7063655257,
0.654325366,
-0.5647630095,
0.0104272384,
-0.1891112477,
-0.581513226,
-0.1146198288,
0.6015493274,
-0.3461181819,
0.0691441298,
0.4033097327,
0.8666447401,
-0.3252207637,
0.0726554766,
0.3641600013,
0.0539623685,
0.1830162853,
0.4483641684,
0.2611926198,
0.0361213386,
-0.0093543706,
-0.3286639154,
-0.755886972,
-0.3978421986,
-0.6273757815,
-1.0540997982,
-0.2347881198,
-0.4496495724,
-0.3055591285,
0.2803230286,
0.9402834773,
0.9465922713,
-0.7632319331,
0.2587333024,
0.2325947881,
-0.2541750669,
-0.2356198877,
-0.1752483249,
0.4025206566,
-0.3487168252,
-0.4232738018,
0.4618724287,
0.6266255975,
0.0825125873,
0.0843881741,
0.1112193316,
0.043134097,
-0.0158220474,
0.5800577402,
0.082536757,
-0.4386134446,
-0.2645465732,
0.1799848378,
-0.2873332798,
0.295889616,
0.6059194207,
-0.7623158097,
1.0276194811,
0.1789243519,
0.7291078568,
0.4076177776,
0.1545546353,
0.6909611821,
-0.6321052909,
-0.129138127,
0.1216201782,
0.2266263366,
0.4007514417,
-0.6050560474,
0.4016655684,
0.2880017459,
-0.67643255,
-0.5616022348,
-0.1021038666,
-1.2382087708,
0.0322096199,
0.8623719215,
0.0654930919,
-0.3074448705,
0.1402621865,
-0.4282690287,
0.3025767207,
-0.3537411988,
0.7418854237,
0.3025513887,
-0.475104779,
0.0752192959,
-0.7152664661,
0.6105301976,
0.3266704679,
-0.7833691239,
-0.2962037325,
0.7684827447,
0.3565482497,
-0.2727769911,
0.6349542141,
-0.2033149302,
0.654476881,
-0.2589918971,
0.1497375965,
-0.1332998574,
-0.4305726886,
-0.0164313316,
-0.0699811876,
-0.4163671732,
-0.4361463487
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13170v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13170v1 | Amphista: Accelerate LLM Inference with Bi-directional Multiple Drafting Heads in a Non-autoregressive Style | 2024-06-19T02:53:39 | 2024-06-19T02:53:39 | Zeping Li, Xinlong Yang, Ziheng Gao, Ji Liu, Zhuang Liu, Dong Li, Jinzhang Peng, Lu Tian, Emad Barsoum | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) inherently use autoregressive decoding, which
lacks parallelism in inference and results in significantly slow inference
speeds, especially when hardware parallel accelerators and memory bandwidth are
not fully utilized. In this work, we propose Amphista, a speculative decoding
algorithm that adheres to a non-autoregressive decoding paradigm. Owing to the
increased parallelism, our method demonstrates higher efficiency in inference
compared to autoregressive methods. Specifically, Amphista models an
Auto-embedding Block capable of parallel inference, incorporating
bi-directional attention to enable interaction between different drafting
heads. Additionally, Amphista implements Staged Adaptation Layers to facilitate
the transition of semantic information from the base model's autoregressive
inference to the drafting heads' non-autoregressive speculation, thereby
achieving paradigm transformation and feature fusion. We conduct a series of
experiments on a suite of Vicuna models using MT-Bench and Spec-Bench. For the
Vicuna 33B model, Amphista achieves up to 2.75$\times$ and 1.40$\times$
wall-clock acceleration compared to vanilla autoregressive decoding and Medusa,
respectively, while preserving lossless generation quality. | [
-0.2986777425,
-0.877245903,
0.6405568123,
0.5636073947,
-0.5130910873,
0.0516612679,
-0.1261836737,
-0.6656312346,
0.5354393125,
0.5955484509,
-0.7167974114,
-0.3273463845,
-0.6092799306,
0.3057260811,
-0.6155521274,
0.279650867,
-0.0990279838,
-0.1359741241,
0.0301649049,
-0.0164172053,
-0.336558938,
-0.2114556581,
-0.4085530043,
-0.0413461886,
0.4487520158,
0.4398348927,
0.4865091145,
1.0268435478,
0.363003552,
0.3400294483,
0.2727414966,
0.451962769,
-0.266177237,
0.5388765335,
-0.1046377942,
-0.627771914,
-0.5112351775,
-0.1675750911,
0.6013373733,
0.4045181572,
-0.1107245907,
0.1063483953,
-0.3479202092,
0.5773091912,
-0.6228769422,
0.1584070623,
-0.6357160807,
-0.1562508941,
-0.4150396883,
-0.7896341085,
-0.6244569421,
-0.3077608049,
-0.0668757483,
-0.4635149539,
0.2499145567,
0.3338774443,
0.6289112568,
0.4105314016,
-0.3115432262,
0.0006718253,
-0.738550961,
0.555771172,
-0.7053562999,
0.6923639178,
0.2311054766,
0.3321850002,
-0.1322355568,
-0.8199013472,
-0.8622984886,
0.1456412077,
0.32405442,
0.1347517967,
-0.0842876658,
-0.0195085406,
0.0823894069,
0.3844659925,
-0.5250595808,
0.330991745,
-0.0075008571,
-0.1417478472,
0.7631297112,
0.4299402237,
0.008344491,
0.0581327416,
-0.1487011462,
-0.4844666719,
-0.6868003011,
-0.2423967123,
0.4629416168,
0.2976765335,
-0.3795582354,
0.6961145997,
-0.357342571,
0.693084538,
0.1857817322,
-0.082995452,
0.2738475204,
-0.3260225058,
-0.2595356703,
-0.0554464236,
0.6337337494,
0.1633415371,
-0.2876268923,
-0.4044532776,
-0.0016307503,
0.3312740028,
0.0691160113,
-0.8447548151,
-0.4760197699,
0.3583215475,
-0.5039458275,
-0.023658298,
-0.2281994373,
-1.0478016138,
-0.4559309781,
-0.166698128,
0.2333141714,
-0.3379799128,
-0.2563851476,
0.4365754426,
-0.2111062557,
0.7199488878,
0.4546187222,
-0.9709454775,
0.0162737817,
0.3689054847,
0.7788282633,
-0.1830629706,
-0.4821168482,
-0.5073270798,
0.1334883422,
-0.4503767192,
1.3646986485,
-0.642986238,
-0.3723012805,
-0.4406057894,
-0.0233830586,
-0.1528810561,
-0.1094009802,
0.4526601136,
-0.5716620684,
-0.0067052352,
-0.2621736825,
-0.3475897014,
-0.2240040749,
0.0387695432,
-0.5657944679,
0.5230904222,
-0.0818590596,
-0.8881444931,
0.2536469102,
-0.4033614397,
-0.5440739989,
-0.2559782565,
-0.2250911146,
-0.425332576,
0.2283461243,
0.4345593154,
0.2940984964,
-0.7051910758,
0.017623648,
-0.4052684605,
-0.3819960952,
-0.1051953807,
-0.5791707039,
0.7418501377,
0.1052813455,
-0.4727086723,
0.2204767615,
-0.5149111748,
-0.2152463049,
0.2172759622,
-0.0972252265,
-0.2107114941,
-0.0684694797,
-0.254668653,
0.2118826658,
-0.0118549773,
-0.4907382429,
0.2924262881,
-0.4190864265,
0.0688753128,
0.5885207653,
0.1983989477,
0.2552407682,
-0.2512536943,
0.4217190742,
0.1445629597,
-0.1287816465,
-0.1597894579,
-0.5311377048,
-0.9703873992,
-0.3377797604,
0.3016395569,
0.3897974193,
-1.12969625,
0.2564604878,
-0.2567430437,
-0.5269246101,
-0.6948157549,
-0.0286015328,
0.3514598906,
0.4330769479,
0.4153803289,
-0.48157233,
-0.7588563561,
-0.8921678662,
-0.4272426665,
-0.2307625413,
0.1557848603,
0.0378877372,
0.0332371667,
-0.1812121123,
0.5826104283,
-0.3171726465,
0.1691220254,
-0.2572079897,
0.4615154862,
0.186362803,
0.2333231866,
0.3722150922,
-0.4294017255,
-0.4419049919,
0.0074710604,
-0.7152216434,
-0.2013366669,
-0.334318608,
-0.4194104671,
0.2560236454,
0.4142077267,
-0.9235172868,
0.3322213292,
0.6651744246,
-0.5815294385,
0.6829352975,
-0.1381186545,
0.1150276884,
-1.0624227524,
0.0113555929,
-0.0989881083,
0.0021153926,
-0.5758656263,
0.1063238904,
0.204586342,
0.3403502703,
-0.0258379169,
0.5783832669,
-0.8765211701,
-0.2454620749,
-0.6012660265,
0.0318852104,
0.1229730025,
0.4322681129,
0.4312981665,
1.1310451031,
0.6235851645,
-0.5041581392,
0.1842977256,
0.3120993674,
-0.0613379665,
0.2636954188,
-0.2781015933,
0.2947852314,
-0.2596304119,
0.2923715413,
-0.6995533705,
-0.166915074,
0.037356209,
-0.3228352368,
0.2797561586,
0.1259632111,
-0.6959488392,
-0.4782988727,
-0.3366777897,
0.2573836446,
0.4090904295,
-0.5185228586,
0.8293753862,
0.4047484398,
-0.0987677351,
-0.5814532042,
-0.7912176847,
0.2051188201,
-0.1419698447,
-0.2719415426,
0.2458794415,
0.0966674164,
-0.2752675116,
-0.078347154,
-0.0275114607,
0.1908273399,
-0.2019272894,
0.0568103641,
0.3826166391,
-0.3942103386,
-0.1170235053,
0.337772131,
-0.1083799824,
0.158606559,
-0.4849900305,
0.734394908,
-0.0868522674,
-0.3412946761,
-0.5995776653,
0.1187198758,
0.7972636223,
-0.2676386237,
0.6486060619,
0.4996070564,
0.0480828583,
-0.3357261717,
-0.8304045796,
-0.4318428338,
-0.4778524339,
0.2447426617,
-0.534424305,
-0.4023013711,
0.5756768584,
0.0338399224,
0.2156275064,
0.4989745319,
0.9063048959,
0.197987482,
0.542075038,
0.6335507631,
0.0235369876,
0.2582074702,
-0.3492338657,
0.1300446242,
-0.9512037635,
-0.364010036,
-0.4011352956,
-0.2723212242,
-0.3516364098,
-0.9252749085,
-0.035317529,
-0.3278230429,
0.1355483532,
0.6314884424,
-0.2702467442,
0.2088126987,
0.3967590928,
0.1432778984,
0.5974225998,
0.0037297863,
-0.2410104424,
0.2127971202,
-0.7107716799,
0.0729969814,
1.1453585625,
0.3188668489,
0.8584029078,
0.140356794,
0.5277093053,
0.0836264193,
0.3975028992,
-0.6547657251,
0.5508313775,
0.0288566556,
-0.3878386617,
-0.3303456008,
-0.3758155107,
-0.7608319521,
0.5515232086,
-0.1387052685,
-0.4554218054,
0.7313482165,
0.048731219,
-0.1879773289,
0.5801787972,
-0.6023729444,
0.4487515092,
-0.0470351167,
-0.6473002434,
-0.3737323284,
-0.5042520165,
0.6154182553,
-0.1918088794,
-0.0796047449,
-0.2229952067,
-0.1262007356,
0.4599812329,
-0.1962600797,
0.8529089093,
-0.2380670905,
-0.203981787,
0.2532107234,
0.2681233287,
0.8092457056,
0.0775200427,
-0.3298425972,
0.0718351901,
-0.2631445825,
-0.4647572935,
-0.4587312639,
0.5994093418,
-0.6422637105,
-0.6222216487,
-0.177711457,
-1.015889287,
-0.7325324416,
0.2383455038,
0.2422154695,
0.3527828455,
0.0961501598,
-0.1681446582,
0.5384343863,
0.0501915738,
0.473823458,
0.5496630669,
0.0054377588,
-0.08730416,
0.7231795192,
-0.1821147501,
0.0961523578,
0.4860780239,
-0.0946607664,
-0.6239706874,
-1.0321083069,
-0.6201779246,
0.5424745083,
-0.610871315,
-0.3161144555,
-0.9460793734,
-0.0759342313,
-0.2543422878,
0.0305482149,
-0.5047594905,
-0.5369424224,
0.0122421524,
0.0220889598,
0.5689473152,
0.4078234136,
0.0347033329,
0.1790150553,
-0.5039818287,
0.4870630503,
0.2467958629,
0.1681752056,
0.1598564237,
-0.6411716938,
-0.1813272089,
-0.2641405761,
-0.0260798689,
-0.811920464,
0.6386882663,
-0.1731458455,
0.6233927608,
0.2266592681,
0.1032261923,
1.0350607634,
-0.2486795336,
0.1562689841,
0.0467047989,
-0.7086670995,
0.0392529182,
-0.4626584947,
0.5670517087,
0.6576260328,
0.041614566,
-0.2399805039,
-0.6394642591,
-0.4725334346,
-0.6765950322,
0.5442316532,
0.1278750747,
0.0157446712,
-0.0766758695,
0.2210728377,
0.3521638811,
0.2262749821,
-0.1500226855,
-0.129948929,
-0.2731815577,
-0.0389837883,
0.042311091,
-0.2458094656,
0.1835827678,
-0.3381041288,
0.5661821365,
-0.1723562032,
0.6455032229,
0.3346326053,
-0.0994583368,
-0.1882477105,
-0.00940271,
0.4614459872,
0.5060488582,
-0.1184846833,
0.2525901794,
0.1824389696,
-0.5725788474,
0.0311889611,
0.2167837769,
0.0486702472,
0.0606242716,
0.5447030067,
0.9715676904,
0.0875188187,
-0.4860728085,
0.147886306,
-0.3103857338,
-0.2442878187,
0.0409588963,
-0.1340109259,
0.246336937,
0.4932560921,
0.4068109989,
0.1663731635,
0.219808057,
-0.4834581316,
0.2015546709,
0.4196932018,
0.2210598141,
-0.4457743466,
0.6830783486,
0.2647953331,
0.1068235412,
0.5506350398,
-0.0783481896,
0.0830261037,
0.5441862345,
0.6030772328,
1.2062329054,
-0.3265000582,
-0.0197243318,
0.2120353431,
0.3334929645,
-0.1235692725,
0.5692710876,
-0.2376652956,
-0.5774903893,
-0.6060453653,
-0.8812531829,
-0.585549593,
-0.2041048259,
-0.4534615576,
0.0169962645,
-0.4211411476,
-0.050967861,
-0.0106021119,
-0.1184561625,
-0.5158706307,
-0.212791577,
0.1003553122,
1.2522661686,
-0.7873707414,
1.3707786798,
0.2815261483,
-0.0728455111,
-0.7167428136,
0.5892034173,
0.0290459953,
-0.8284108639,
0.3777205348,
0.0615049675,
-0.6228847504,
0.3654087484,
0.0182031803,
-0.954506278,
1.2378293276,
0.4546466172,
-0.5746885538,
-0.292787075,
-0.3050659001,
0.4530400336,
-0.3884439766,
0.1173158139,
0.7434698343,
0.5454689264,
0.0931338817,
-0.9790278077,
0.174872905,
-0.2046161592,
0.1839555949,
0.0938845649,
-0.6797984838,
0.942953825,
-0.2362695336,
-0.4408238828,
0.2376549691,
0.9231034517,
0.3885580599,
-0.0494411141,
0.1878552288,
0.5331658125,
0.6354520321,
0.1218093336,
1.1972734928,
-0.5566733479,
0.1244758144,
0.9173343778,
-0.3367658854,
0.9608792067,
0.7532103062,
-0.0732300356,
0.8923993707,
0.4642494619,
0.1346961558,
0.5685138702,
-0.3191006184,
-0.236114338,
-0.3183860183,
0.1890729815,
-0.3018892109,
0.6186327934,
0.527608335,
-0.3259167373,
-0.3735087812,
0.0267947651,
-0.1847120523,
-0.0448094197,
-0.1004565284,
0.5339354277,
0.0639534891,
-0.6454722881,
0.7923489213,
0.3134334981,
0.6584028602,
-0.5419968367,
0.0706550106,
-0.3984925747,
0.1793676466,
0.1217932329,
-0.6613357663,
0.4445309639,
-0.3790022135,
0.0133506311,
0.0244629756,
0.4400162995,
-0.3301306069,
-0.5074129105,
0.4238986671,
0.7054055333,
-0.0040877354,
0.0972404182,
-0.5176876187,
0.5103796721,
-0.2008384913,
-0.4068306088,
0.0822839066,
0.4390027523,
-0.2085368633,
0.7301166654,
0.8112071753,
0.1419463754,
0.1584895402,
-0.1619431823,
1.0295437574,
-0.7319532037,
-0.6380745173,
-0.9111889601,
0.116007179,
0.0042888233,
-0.0409922861,
1.1728037596,
0.4826781452,
0.3905692697,
-0.1122207344,
0.5873938203,
-0.0247849487,
0.3420914114,
-0.904083252,
0.5519891381,
-0.2516941726,
0.3058576882,
0.054237958,
-0.86154598,
-0.2445744425,
0.3231820166,
-0.4514414966,
-0.0613170043,
0.7964190841,
0.6828430295,
-0.1596501917,
0.1850073487,
0.218488127,
0.5214720368,
-0.0768700689,
0.4860464633,
0.3950951099,
-0.2647143602,
0.1788536608,
-0.4494969249,
-0.0601968542,
-0.2981877029,
-0.6077612638,
-1.023055315,
-0.4615829289,
0.0207613073,
-0.2661539614,
0.2599497736,
0.6184116006,
0.7916508317,
-0.6969774961,
-0.4096855521,
-0.2831393182,
-0.1598234028,
-0.3035946488,
-0.1970760524,
0.4764177799,
-0.2998790145,
-0.747223556,
0.7903562784,
0.5609413981,
0.0120648118,
-0.5243839622,
-0.0830449685,
-0.3363323808,
0.4409764111,
0.5985817909,
0.5623182654,
-0.6812264323,
0.1563725173,
-0.1052345112,
0.0136945732,
0.0672660396,
0.9262855053,
-0.9144527316,
0.3979037702,
0.6448143721,
0.6620802283,
0.9030647874,
0.1406751126,
0.6579138041,
-0.2815241218,
0.6891973615,
0.2517388165,
0.3479888141,
0.1853628457,
-0.4426651299,
0.1562102884,
0.3151395619,
-0.1886217594,
-0.864332974,
0.2573854625,
-0.7414752841,
-0.4059194028,
0.8813434839,
0.2354319543,
-0.6084048152,
-0.346127063,
0.2003858685,
0.2206014097,
-0.2045656443,
0.8309788704,
0.2577081919,
-0.5441940427,
-0.6527097225,
-0.5060663819,
0.3027426302,
0.3628844023,
-0.9504728317,
0.4788830578,
0.336822927,
0.0153627545,
-0.0675976202,
0.7039299607,
-0.3291627467,
0.5160555243,
0.7099644542,
0.0654224753,
-0.343573004,
-0.608530283,
-0.2384693027,
-0.0185311455,
0.2870385945,
0.0174424294
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13167v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13167v1 | QRMeM: Unleash the Length Limitation through Question then Reflection Memory Mechanism | 2024-06-19T02:46:18 | 2024-06-19T02:46:18 | Bo Wang, Heyan Huang, Yixin Cao, Jiahao Ying, Wei Tang, Chong Feng | cs.CL | cs.CL | While large language models (LLMs) have made notable advancements in natural
language processing, they continue to struggle with processing extensive text.
Memory mechanism offers a flexible solution for managing long contexts,
utilizing techniques such as compression, summarization, and structuring to
facilitate nuanced and efficient handling of large volumes of text. However,
existing techniques face challenges with static knowledge integration, leading
to insufficient adaptation to task-specific needs and missing
multi-segmentation relationships, which hinders the dynamic reorganization and
logical combination of relevant segments during the response process. To
address these issues, we introduce a novel strategy, Question then Reflection
Memory Mechanism (QRMeM), incorporating a dual-structured memory pool. This
pool synergizes static textual content with structured graph guidance,
fostering a reflective trial-and-error approach for navigating and identifying
relevant segments. Our evaluation across multiple-choice questions (MCQ) and
multi-document question answering (Multi-doc QA) benchmarks showcases QRMeM
enhanced performance compared to existing approaches. | [
-0.4681452811,
-0.9817902446,
0.9137724638,
0.1164663211,
-0.6102540493,
0.2277051806,
-0.2103895396,
-0.2755127549,
0.0051932964,
0.6457838416,
-0.5026786923,
-0.3256453872,
-0.2748392522,
0.0351423845,
-0.2007620484,
0.9205696583,
-0.2604107857,
-0.1173386425,
-0.6067008376,
-0.4586440325,
-0.6046898961,
-0.4494202435,
-0.7290158868,
-0.1788154542,
0.685241878,
0.4780475795,
0.601593554,
0.4923928976,
0.4987360537,
0.2544103265,
0.0062397178,
0.6685170531,
-0.4786528647,
0.4281161129,
-0.1254896373,
-0.4867424071,
-0.4044662416,
-0.2202562392,
1.0324414968,
0.3884720504,
-0.2045515478,
0.2932702899,
0.1491569579,
0.7467162609,
-0.611549437,
-0.0318170749,
-0.3611286879,
-0.1102660149,
-0.074322924,
-0.5373547673,
-0.3969052732,
-0.2474372536,
0.1667862236,
-0.3234775364,
-0.1276218742,
0.2500936687,
0.5306535363,
0.2037337273,
-0.673840344,
-0.3193489015,
-0.716234386,
0.8326115012,
-0.5119501352,
0.2931320071,
0.1398685127,
0.3869425952,
0.0051392117,
-0.7216743827,
-0.5119208097,
0.0417544916,
-0.0509372726,
0.162759468,
0.211555481,
0.1683955044,
0.1094123349,
0.2518016696,
-0.8747833371,
-0.3111792803,
-0.3706179559,
-0.1447264254,
0.4757098556,
0.3722132444,
0.5318552852,
-0.0537843332,
-0.6720002294,
-0.1237494722,
-0.1036452353,
-0.143881157,
0.1885122806,
0.1534778476,
0.293666482,
0.4897581935,
-0.0251857974,
0.5398866534,
-0.4367691576,
-0.0893552899,
-0.1262211502,
-0.4253401458,
-0.0284307506,
0.039825622,
0.6758083105,
0.4553508461,
-0.0506251715,
-0.195226416,
-0.2282362133,
-0.248343274,
0.4744495749,
-0.9343066216,
0.1238751262,
0.4053117037,
-0.1971103549,
0.3822879195,
0.0396703631,
-0.9472407699,
-0.0325437412,
-0.04366697,
0.4892061651,
-0.613974154,
-0.1268862486,
0.3926475942,
-0.4047003984,
0.2389915735,
0.2942771912,
-0.4856255651,
0.5789667368,
0.5471549034,
0.9394898415,
-0.0535763353,
-0.1456184089,
-0.6081038713,
0.4374582469,
0.0613675937,
0.8157472014,
-0.6873079538,
-0.3686104119,
-0.073458232,
-0.2643623054,
-0.288957417,
-0.5844417214,
0.4708163142,
-0.986376822,
0.7321041822,
-0.2425710261,
-0.5032721162,
-0.4597017467,
0.4576622248,
-0.5541353822,
1.2524966002,
0.4159261286,
-0.861266017,
-0.1740048677,
-0.6558008194,
-0.3618475199,
-0.0648545921,
0.0471153669,
-0.3577397764,
0.0759598762,
0.0443243906,
0.2010698617,
-0.3386429846,
0.2590546608,
-0.1081630737,
-0.3956186771,
0.0487911552,
-0.2312890291,
0.3917840123,
-0.0059082611,
0.000789372,
0.2611038089,
-0.7166185379,
0.2833644748,
0.2749421299,
-0.6159262061,
-0.6191554666,
0.0218960866,
-0.2479127347,
0.4843801856,
0.3911720216,
-0.3099972308,
0.1735616922,
-0.1056843698,
0.45388183,
0.5289712548,
0.3250467181,
0.5129011869,
-0.4196635783,
0.7343325019,
-0.0028254208,
0.0793573186,
-0.327221185,
-0.1371228099,
-0.6999989152,
-0.0676309466,
-0.0223728325,
0.6337084174,
-0.9605844021,
-0.0711571872,
-0.2275000364,
-0.028870495,
-0.4856691062,
0.3307033181,
0.5458875299,
0.613981545,
0.8012449741,
-0.3910959363,
-0.6813382506,
-0.9288308024,
-0.1862342805,
-0.3008984327,
-0.1039076075,
0.2840777934,
0.2877444625,
-0.2215442806,
0.9316330552,
-0.7200914621,
-0.1509895921,
-0.4161145389,
0.2182776034,
-0.1404822022,
0.1180635616,
0.1086262614,
-0.9291765094,
-0.2384173572,
-0.5956780314,
-0.544642508,
-0.082604818,
-0.2640353143,
-0.2928873897,
0.0046775383,
0.4953527749,
-0.7382842302,
0.0181737691,
0.3991130888,
-0.2220921069,
0.6176407337,
-0.3460598588,
-0.0280349683,
-1.0577588081,
-0.1118139178,
-0.1493492424,
-0.353318125,
-0.5249193907,
0.2824469507,
0.2956215143,
0.0556545034,
-0.443418026,
0.7159709334,
-0.8093724847,
0.1553097814,
-0.4172789156,
0.5472002029,
0.4650742114,
0.4996928573,
-0.1725776345,
0.8833023906,
-0.0780946165,
-0.785623014,
0.1621003598,
0.3494411409,
-0.1462363154,
0.4312676489,
-0.3494794667,
0.4551895261,
-0.4368577302,
0.223278001,
-1.1598799229,
0.0542240217,
0.2047688067,
-0.1952436566,
0.5058666468,
0.3618364334,
-0.6615099907,
-0.6166821122,
-0.6429492235,
0.6455641389,
0.4573304951,
-0.1703641117,
0.6798952818,
0.2560908198,
-0.216277808,
-0.3667469919,
-0.4628589749,
0.1691638082,
-0.2451297939,
-0.8485668302,
0.2161622047,
-0.2210136205,
-0.303065896,
-0.0649175942,
-0.2663020194,
-0.1038639918,
-0.0005686314,
0.0232008155,
0.1227249578,
-0.5111948848,
0.3917095065,
0.3153971136,
0.0333228037,
0.1174628139,
-0.2332847565,
0.748519659,
0.0110867629,
-0.1272317171,
-0.2207897455,
0.6405587792,
0.6344345808,
-0.4128886759,
0.9370746613,
0.4011817873,
-0.0244608168,
-0.3361866176,
-0.7144622207,
-0.3314115703,
-0.4513712227,
0.4823804498,
-0.3057659268,
-1.2489955425,
0.50455302,
-0.0802196264,
-0.036352247,
0.1620303988,
0.3639982045,
-0.001075048,
0.9457729459,
0.5007172227,
0.0745985135,
0.2951027155,
0.0905559063,
0.3695181608,
-1.2662541866,
-0.1904068291,
-0.2361475378,
-0.4002479613,
0.0001758959,
-0.8682169318,
0.3729190528,
0.2019566596,
-0.0529420935,
0.1697913408,
-0.2524141669,
0.2378935665,
0.4827182293,
0.195550859,
0.3696298897,
-0.3719141781,
-0.2707864344,
0.1212505177,
-0.7329405546,
-0.7906813622,
0.7195081711,
0.4036613107,
0.359643966,
0.0166447237,
0.6475830674,
-0.0449291579,
0.1806947738,
-0.5930383801,
1.0373530388,
0.2824188769,
-0.5262457728,
-0.5851747394,
-0.4623728096,
-0.7061513066,
0.7328807712,
0.2071805894,
-0.3849114478,
-0.254206717,
-0.0786795169,
-0.5528259873,
0.4917450249,
-0.5524972081,
0.5428119302,
-0.2073550075,
-0.5015597939,
-0.0824272037,
-0.8577648401,
0.3442595005,
-0.0681149662,
0.2724712789,
-0.1953446716,
-0.3543196619,
0.7361530066,
-0.3373068571,
0.5060390234,
-0.089576669,
-0.0485387817,
0.7660428882,
0.0501045547,
0.3779428005,
0.1235237643,
0.0094199013,
-0.2214567065,
0.0153794931,
-0.4652300179,
-0.7111395001,
0.2378837317,
-0.2411057353,
-0.8593762517,
-0.284303993,
-0.8003245592,
-0.4830261767,
0.3188921809,
-0.0500129871,
0.2941386998,
-0.2512232363,
0.0948392302,
0.7800999284,
-0.2561250925,
0.6366719007,
0.7358407974,
-0.2118602246,
-0.367949456,
0.565900743,
0.0005586554,
0.3068392873,
0.6297027469,
0.1198458448,
-0.4171213508,
-0.6446564794,
-0.3112642765,
0.4156505167,
-0.3357224762,
-0.2305549681,
-0.9519264102,
-0.2704024315,
-0.1974882334,
0.1684961021,
-0.2036103606,
-0.2547667921,
-0.3085958064,
-0.1641971469,
-0.0527294092,
0.1752171367,
0.3641646802,
0.2182168365,
-1.1587065458,
0.4265025854,
0.6215636134,
0.209670499,
0.1112749204,
-0.466421634,
-0.2345715016,
0.0532369949,
-0.2955301404,
-0.8633721471,
0.3349219263,
0.147935912,
0.3089734018,
0.4014976025,
0.2004389912,
0.7018613815,
-0.8064679503,
0.5084312558,
0.036072731,
-0.577562809,
0.4602779448,
-0.3673256338,
0.5931822658,
0.7961966395,
0.3590402305,
-0.7128617167,
-0.6335291862,
-0.2460425496,
-0.9996005893,
0.3468693197,
0.0350648649,
0.3954944313,
-0.3164857626,
0.555924654,
0.0015162914,
0.387162447,
-0.2624444962,
0.1150950864,
0.247359246,
-0.0999776572,
0.0655760542,
-0.9003290534,
-0.1378351897,
-0.0065001058,
0.4871172905,
-0.1979505569,
0.2097817063,
0.3882366419,
-0.2703654766,
-0.0636946857,
0.7118957043,
0.8386041522,
0.9084441066,
-0.3876290023,
0.428327173,
0.1482504457,
-0.5105357766,
0.0874654874,
-0.1095916405,
-0.0327597558,
-0.0837905556,
0.2600978911,
0.5022849441,
0.3880026639,
-0.9426417351,
0.2792881131,
-0.1674097776,
-0.3615673184,
-0.0115684327,
0.2070004642,
0.2640902102,
0.3761901259,
0.420049578,
-0.5884894133,
0.1819082201,
-0.7846366763,
0.3891977668,
0.3221606612,
-0.5291644335,
-0.2224500626,
0.6391338706,
-0.0410717539,
-0.1963624358,
0.8197188377,
-0.3033341467,
-0.6531941295,
0.4708354175,
0.5976951122,
0.6582150459,
-0.4043388069,
0.4047942162,
0.1991945654,
0.2365293056,
-0.4008416831,
0.5752105713,
0.0058575165,
-0.7373637557,
-0.3652904928,
-0.7183402777,
-0.2512525916,
-0.1828814149,
-0.9527710676,
-0.2186616361,
-0.4743149281,
-0.1883062273,
-0.5644361973,
0.0583067536,
-0.163628459,
0.2076416314,
0.0952181295,
1.0450769663,
-0.4558810294,
0.7808006406,
0.6710937023,
-0.2796803415,
-0.6463470459,
-0.058931116,
-0.0435251147,
-0.8359205127,
0.2693612278,
0.3057321012,
-0.1877774447,
-0.0233805142,
-0.3712124228,
-0.5011211634,
1.123913765,
0.0981950536,
-0.5914506912,
-0.1986783445,
0.0622066744,
0.6399174333,
-0.2077008188,
0.0896004438,
0.4472794235,
0.5196120739,
0.1440719962,
-0.5254630446,
0.4048610628,
-0.1506035477,
0.1286462992,
0.6393520832,
-1.1572871208,
0.7626235485,
-0.3664406836,
-0.4321073592,
-0.1364324093,
0.7902399302,
0.3236798942,
0.5289517045,
0.4089693427,
0.6251897216,
0.9136853814,
0.2400479913,
0.9320331812,
-0.3104399443,
0.1723023802,
1.3934067488,
-0.5782636404,
0.909858048,
0.7200669646,
-0.009613323,
0.7936074734,
0.2812233865,
0.2243801355,
0.4015891552,
0.2612135708,
-0.4759214222,
-0.3485881984,
-0.1315301955,
-0.3150912821,
0.2847067714,
0.1948595941,
-0.1897921413,
-0.3045747578,
0.0001282827,
0.106121406,
0.2213396579,
-0.202952072,
0.7371184826,
0.3658357561,
-0.6250652671,
0.1350059807,
0.0776014775,
0.3113106787,
-0.7192543149,
-0.0239284728,
-0.256578356,
-0.0893925056,
0.1594380587,
-0.7019293308,
0.4054248929,
-0.428041935,
-0.3629378676,
-0.4317148924,
0.7686862946,
-0.6400287151,
-0.0989673436,
0.4812897444,
0.6683424115,
-0.2081784606,
-0.4507090151,
-0.4613926709,
-0.1474151611,
-0.2751287222,
-0.4724033177,
0.5255125761,
0.5829603076,
-0.071709834,
0.8652562499,
0.4364340007,
-0.2590723932,
0.0973149985,
-0.0451701991,
1.0283387899,
-0.8585958481,
-0.5170201063,
-1.0470182896,
0.4784988463,
-0.1951846629,
-0.0100595597,
1.0017220974,
0.9154354334,
0.5381566286,
0.256033659,
0.4134116173,
0.4941394627,
0.5819575191,
-0.6801755428,
0.4099546969,
-0.6618831754,
0.2798419595,
0.0869503841,
-0.9312381744,
-0.3312661946,
0.167428717,
-0.3910162151,
0.0263269711,
1.1770621538,
0.5575811267,
0.1333521008,
0.0397552252,
0.2153657973,
0.1433029771,
0.1138308421,
0.895953238,
0.8673044443,
-0.2091072053,
0.7754716873,
0.1159893721,
-0.035394758,
-0.288818866,
-0.5597404242,
-1.0057835579,
-0.3865902424,
-0.3068362176,
-0.3498807251,
0.0245877746,
0.4454498887,
0.5461973548,
-0.4230830669,
-0.1006784141,
0.2629479468,
0.3081685305,
-0.0120219663,
-0.2677084804,
0.3275569975,
-0.4440506697,
-0.2214380354,
0.3047320843,
0.993789494,
-0.0105293272,
-0.1447959542,
0.0867889374,
-0.3758757114,
0.4229046702,
0.6870161891,
0.2917581201,
-0.2215168178,
-0.326031357,
0.0262991861,
-0.3420975804,
0.357835263,
1.0040496588,
-0.4679912925,
0.3852107525,
0.5831132531,
0.7089741826,
0.3694243133,
0.2566166222,
0.4847747684,
-0.64304775,
-0.0365350433,
0.5508401394,
0.0993141159,
0.020590717,
-0.3531686664,
0.3059547842,
-0.1121329963,
-0.5298107862,
-0.7853031754,
0.1800968498,
-1.0131440163,
-0.6350805759,
1.1545499563,
0.0667497814,
-0.4238886535,
-0.2751819491,
-0.3871478736,
0.2700225115,
-0.2981183529,
0.7843450308,
0.850017488,
-0.132234171,
-0.5719696879,
-0.805496335,
0.1204110086,
0.4047251642,
-0.8657729626,
-0.2011010945,
0.5125884414,
0.1372172385,
0.0861008838,
0.9574413896,
-0.1693843305,
0.0207870025,
-0.170579657,
-0.1472114772,
-0.2345654666,
-0.361638844,
-0.1714473963,
0.6950855851,
-0.1955748647,
-0.1956157088
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13163v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13163v1 | LLMatDesign: Autonomous Materials Discovery with Large Language Models | 2024-06-19T02:35:02 | 2024-06-19T02:35:02 | Shuyi Jia, Chao Zhang, Victor Fung | cond-mat.mtrl-sci | cond-mat.mtrl-sci, cs.AI, cs.CL | Discovering new materials can have significant scientific and technological
implications but remains a challenging problem today due to the enormity of the
chemical space. Recent advances in machine learning have enabled data-driven
methods to rapidly screen or generate promising materials, but these methods
still depend heavily on very large quantities of training data and often lack
the flexibility and chemical understanding often desired in materials
discovery. We introduce LLMatDesign, a novel language-based framework for
interpretable materials design powered by large language models (LLMs).
LLMatDesign utilizes LLM agents to translate human instructions, apply
modifications to materials, and evaluate outcomes using provided tools. By
incorporating self-reflection on its previous decisions, LLMatDesign adapts
rapidly to new tasks and conditions in a zero-shot manner. A systematic
evaluation of LLMatDesign on several materials design tasks, in silico,
validates LLMatDesign's effectiveness in developing new materials with
user-defined target properties in the small data regime. Our framework
demonstrates the remarkable potential of autonomous LLM-guided materials
discovery in the computational setting and towards self-driving laboratories in
the future. | [
-0.0732015595,
-0.5163856745,
1.1820201874,
0.143126592,
0.016567599,
0.4490367174,
-0.1131974161,
-0.2380364835,
0.3177720308,
0.278727442,
-0.8178800344,
-0.6412581205,
-0.281144321,
0.3196629882,
-0.2093406171,
0.4082119465,
-0.5106779933,
0.0490913577,
-0.3054581285,
0.1278601587,
-0.2357072979,
-0.0496603027,
-0.2109089494,
-0.5075592995,
0.5353988409,
0.413492173,
0.5007839799,
0.7485206127,
0.3268480599,
0.4110430777,
0.0534295328,
0.2715547383,
-0.1843462884,
0.0630735904,
-0.3872936666,
-0.5581251383,
-0.3792539239,
0.0988930017,
0.4522923529,
0.7669141293,
-0.0892224088,
0.3501808643,
0.0391920358,
0.6161329746,
-0.3341697454,
0.4255352318,
-0.5204806328,
0.4089596272,
-0.2953273058,
-0.4481891692,
-0.4928616583,
0.1087695956,
-0.2208729237,
-0.7108349204,
0.3790115118,
0.1076990291,
0.3293232024,
0.3608085811,
-0.2960233092,
-0.4472470582,
-0.7581189275,
0.8369957805,
-0.4900889695,
0.5552629232,
0.0567374304,
0.4707393944,
-0.5267819762,
-0.5315999389,
-0.390616864,
-0.3389198482,
-0.0273355376,
0.0246807728,
0.3860636353,
-0.0041000727,
-0.0594332293,
0.4103751779,
-0.7902846932,
0.3826128244,
-0.1611005366,
-0.3541606963,
0.6660739779,
0.3746025264,
0.312531054,
0.0846811309,
-0.4739161432,
0.01983607,
-0.8003934026,
-0.5198250413,
0.221916914,
0.605216682,
-0.0356462114,
0.6311659217,
-0.4149911106,
0.2698884308,
-0.2698996663,
0.0094294073,
0.247566998,
-0.2380166501,
-0.2314317822,
0.0891751051,
0.7757030129,
0.0626046956,
-0.0443889387,
-0.1981424689,
-0.4369633198,
-0.0634660199,
0.0802894086,
-0.9466816187,
-0.3645215929,
0.2689558864,
-0.493139714,
-0.4786054194,
-0.2381337732,
-0.5203021765,
-0.9950338602,
-0.6052575707,
0.3971740901,
0.1857280582,
-0.3638093174,
0.3326141238,
-0.0087171858,
-0.0922443792,
0.6208471656,
-1.0570970774,
0.228772819,
0.3671946824,
0.8645534515,
-0.44707793,
-0.3531490266,
-0.2444652915,
-0.0000399459,
-0.5446624756,
0.9818635583,
-0.1827578247,
-0.696205318,
-0.5306378007,
0.1393520832,
0.3719980121,
-0.7453586459,
0.2340107858,
-0.2285658419,
-0.0421295688,
-0.2006875724,
-0.1740015149,
0.1071457565,
-0.1005728692,
-0.719304502,
0.6287819743,
0.2627573013,
-0.3255848289,
0.1613175273,
-0.674882412,
-0.3773630857,
0.27767995,
-0.7071954608,
-0.5683534741,
0.4921019375,
-0.1315386146,
0.4550108612,
-0.6510674357,
0.2236121744,
-0.397815913,
-0.2311814725,
0.3317825794,
-0.3921429515,
0.4519052505,
0.3751291633,
-0.3112166822,
0.2407269478,
-0.8222234845,
-0.1017625332,
0.3967187703,
-0.4538319111,
0.0136991767,
0.0883727148,
0.230566442,
0.2588172853,
0.371825546,
-0.75301373,
0.1373582631,
-0.264285177,
0.3005774021,
1.2798413038,
-0.2188325673,
0.819069922,
-0.2359562069,
0.5375546813,
-0.4168337286,
0.0856945887,
-0.0849342123,
-0.0672531575,
-0.67504251,
-0.0198682602,
0.0341456383,
0.1729543656,
-0.6259827614,
0.0231591705,
-0.0895686075,
-0.4780853391,
-0.1690074354,
0.541932404,
-0.0434383117,
0.2519804239,
0.178740114,
-0.2935566604,
-0.5348397493,
-0.9359390736,
-0.0766680613,
0.1389457285,
-0.2396409512,
0.533559382,
0.510977149,
-0.6651170254,
0.9580360651,
-0.6861635447,
-0.4443313777,
-0.1193118021,
0.158732608,
0.3892309666,
0.2691297531,
0.3261070549,
-0.5199588537,
-0.4457469285,
0.3704198599,
-1.0908622742,
-0.2008326501,
-0.4942876399,
-0.0581242815,
0.0402127802,
0.7713553905,
-0.4925232828,
-0.0328381471,
0.3974515498,
-0.1093147025,
0.5136578083,
-0.2265790552,
-0.362070471,
-0.816100657,
-0.060663566,
0.0115325237,
0.01072683,
-0.2972462773,
0.0435800739,
0.032823503,
-0.3123914599,
-0.6985118985,
1.0377603769,
-0.7503022552,
-0.2122575939,
-0.5395647287,
-0.1800380945,
0.0038276417,
0.400016278,
0.0578291304,
0.8214654326,
0.3787198961,
-0.5138313174,
0.3269312084,
0.1401293874,
-0.3677968383,
0.5612685084,
-0.5848068595,
0.1521143317,
-0.2052308619,
0.216133669,
-0.7548003197,
-0.3555750847,
0.0873605534,
-0.1820252091,
0.2216905653,
0.1236937493,
-0.7673406601,
-0.3629850149,
-0.1869203746,
0.439927429,
-0.0584162399,
-0.8321797848,
1.1863765717,
0.3009468317,
-0.2894844413,
-0.0616665594,
-0.5014076829,
0.1173209175,
-0.0793897137,
-0.4726239741,
0.6031560898,
-0.8015476465,
-0.3152934015,
-0.4086028934,
-0.3753499985,
0.1108057052,
0.4525845349,
0.439050734,
0.1554107964,
-0.0047860579,
0.2471974641,
-0.0879179165,
-0.3507383168,
0.1929762661,
-0.2324850261,
0.8607746363,
-0.0447570533,
-0.3594355285,
-0.3245593309,
0.3007978201,
0.6937624216,
-0.1265488267,
0.1419249624,
0.3314112127,
-0.2300963998,
-0.7981258035,
-0.080446057,
-0.2804844379,
-0.7208890319,
0.34871611,
-0.6386060715,
-0.5611706972,
0.5106249452,
-0.4622376263,
0.1099369451,
0.3581592739,
0.8124005198,
-0.2607041299,
1.0133532286,
0.8883519173,
0.0835021436,
0.441875428,
-0.126091823,
0.0638352707,
-0.5503388643,
-0.2327987552,
-0.0624750108,
-0.3058722913,
-0.5189396143,
-0.3354340494,
0.5083658099,
-0.6986574531,
-0.2771393955,
0.1854101866,
-0.643499434,
0.7599866986,
0.1716402173,
0.1825725585,
0.3959629238,
-0.0232957583,
-0.1670526266,
0.0770132244,
-0.4787875116,
-0.3679868281,
1.2004303932,
0.4721106589,
1.2699053288,
-0.0477955714,
0.8011804819,
0.4486513436,
0.2787386179,
-0.7940891981,
0.6395642161,
0.1791487485,
-0.60310781,
-0.1539066136,
-0.4387530386,
-0.9538161755,
0.1236532629,
-0.1892755777,
-0.1528013349,
0.1806374788,
-0.1833002418,
-0.209042266,
0.1742465347,
-0.492326349,
0.5802597404,
-1.0101051331,
-0.376075387,
-0.1543613523,
-0.1943592727,
0.1005265117,
-0.5273606777,
0.4554890692,
-0.3832757175,
0.000234331,
0.5466039777,
-0.0648551956,
0.9107600451,
0.0012980077,
-0.6304168701,
0.0732119381,
0.5547140837,
0.4474896193,
0.0051021972,
-0.2484469414,
-0.1435553133,
-0.3722698689,
-0.1846993566,
-0.6534612775,
0.8929467201,
-0.4557181597,
-0.5198207498,
-0.3725358546,
-0.7089491487,
0.1709775627,
0.4751868844,
0.0600127578,
0.0251840129,
-0.3915490508,
-0.0128342388,
0.5798324347,
-0.4067425132,
0.2479176968,
0.867654562,
-0.2861848772,
-0.1209572554,
1.4844536781,
0.0930802375,
0.0914420262,
0.2704905868,
0.2771356106,
-0.3062585294,
-0.6251440048,
-0.5645170808,
0.3278526962,
-0.8134986758,
-0.0716419816,
-0.1731222272,
-0.2345588058,
-0.0742706805,
-0.3561542034,
-0.6292780042,
-0.2016523033,
-0.4764941931,
-0.2405721545,
0.16225411,
1.034737587,
-0.022218626,
0.130532518,
-0.3031436801,
0.4499506056,
0.3049295545,
0.7259138227,
-0.223636061,
-0.1942076683,
-0.3702704012,
-0.2665305734,
-0.12864016,
-0.4700782895,
0.3720887005,
-0.1459853053,
0.7489361763,
0.0993162915,
0.1050820947,
-0.1362829953,
-0.6704068184,
0.1831834018,
-0.0044806344,
-0.6055604219,
0.5920851231,
-0.5193499923,
0.3132807314,
0.3276754916,
0.3350777626,
-0.3125997484,
0.199396655,
-0.5274851322,
-0.8674955964,
0.3104084134,
-0.019170383,
-0.0268407818,
0.2685032487,
0.1407483369,
0.3390763402,
0.0506544411,
-0.9711019993,
-0.1909061521,
0.1122808531,
-0.3855850101,
-0.1536984146,
-0.0146005945,
-0.2473787516,
0.0867538974,
0.4274841249,
-0.4427444339,
0.3899784684,
-0.0988213047,
-0.1645377278,
-0.1334149539,
0.0911980793,
0.6111220717,
0.2913195491,
-0.2589336932,
0.1401958615,
0.1168325469,
-0.1454369426,
0.3419616818,
0.1229236126,
-0.0026312701,
-0.0432353057,
-0.1223146915,
0.4223579466,
-0.091774419,
-0.7903555036,
0.1879846156,
-0.0736192912,
-0.4250380397,
-0.5946686268,
0.077352345,
-0.1527414024,
0.4393762052,
0.3638886511,
0.0065109078,
0.2224907428,
-0.61546278,
0.326420486,
0.5548960567,
-0.0712965354,
-0.1913852245,
0.8539478779,
0.3537406027,
-0.4313524067,
0.3447740972,
-0.1719644666,
-0.2137405872,
0.689222753,
0.4187344611,
0.8658956885,
-0.1299981475,
0.3299420178,
0.0414729975,
0.149631843,
-0.0253288783,
0.0745327994,
-0.4356116354,
-0.6442238688,
0.0469932593,
-0.6918512583,
-0.7138284445,
0.0094506219,
-0.0309179015,
0.422544986,
-0.8342801929,
0.209537819,
0.0552809052,
0.1447435766,
-0.4542593956,
0.3340792656,
0.3080895841,
0.625706017,
-1.012004137,
0.4907267988,
0.1274745017,
-0.1975412518,
-0.2185614705,
-0.4466055334,
0.510825932,
-0.9065296054,
0.7114281654,
0.1889327466,
-0.4548172653,
0.0244774614,
-0.5512102246,
-1.1763150692,
1.4169535637,
0.380807668,
-0.3587536216,
0.0799636692,
0.3990583718,
0.3500594497,
-0.2733751833,
0.1471646577,
0.37564376,
0.4040400982,
0.0957772359,
-0.7415866256,
0.1939316988,
-0.4841512144,
-0.2229313552,
0.0545934662,
-0.5082809329,
0.8696827292,
-0.1264658272,
-0.4856310189,
0.2950032055,
0.6244582534,
0.4698479176,
0.3206285238,
0.2305418998,
0.2648993134,
0.7533823848,
0.1472495049,
0.9042837024,
-0.012370469,
0.1691392064,
1.0982830524,
-0.4170003831,
0.5042937994,
0.2345140278,
-0.141290769,
0.4169372618,
0.7673183084,
-0.2622576952,
0.5075755715,
0.5259435773,
-0.4099697173,
-0.2095226645,
-0.2755959332,
-0.0929316282,
0.3637035787,
0.5370871425,
-0.4149700701,
-0.3925802112,
0.1192462221,
-0.3365404606,
0.2632013559,
-0.1383731365,
0.3926572204,
0.0193572883,
0.0007607543,
0.4336575568,
0.0942322686,
0.6657951474,
-0.3151522577,
-0.1195004284,
-0.3284149766,
0.2972813249,
-0.2848612964,
-0.8643177152,
0.1032132655,
-0.5439415574,
-0.1871804148,
-0.6860758662,
0.4719013572,
-0.0467182472,
-0.5670625567,
0.2125326544,
0.6222898364,
-0.0061861463,
-0.1162576303,
-0.4819785953,
0.2305305898,
-0.0675105006,
0.044054158,
0.3682380319,
0.4330683947,
-0.1455592513,
0.9984767437,
0.8002119064,
-0.1459667385,
-0.3386721015,
0.0480436794,
0.8628639579,
-0.6620456576,
-0.1976851821,
-0.613237381,
0.2494702637,
0.1353990585,
0.1580747962,
0.7047525048,
0.9049124122,
0.7769776583,
-0.2499139011,
0.7803394198,
0.3976616859,
0.539683044,
-0.6709313393,
0.7400769591,
-0.6810567379,
0.5738297105,
-0.0876486525,
-0.688321054,
-0.5038748384,
0.8041838408,
-0.0681941435,
-0.0290241558,
0.4572710991,
1.0633050203,
-0.1681576073,
-0.3177777827,
0.1066761464,
0.34928599,
0.6786378026,
0.3571261466,
0.8091742396,
-0.0376972258,
0.3108840585,
-0.096383594,
-0.1028138772,
-0.1163021177,
-0.7976791859,
-0.8249312639,
-0.5884592533,
-0.095229879,
-0.0571053326,
-0.4207405448,
0.9841920137,
0.6400361061,
-0.4621459842,
-0.5048183203,
-0.6599279642,
0.1870989203,
0.3542561233,
-0.179197371,
0.2513765991,
-0.1469199508,
-0.7997767925,
0.9669944644,
0.474590987,
0.4041159153,
-0.6510267258,
-0.2307694852,
0.2892073393,
0.1011776477,
0.6611523032,
0.6058620811,
-0.4424738884,
0.209272489,
0.3676381409,
-0.2279883772,
0.2127344161,
0.5976136923,
-0.8929975629,
0.5875536799,
0.4308637679,
0.6709616184,
0.6435117722,
-0.4946689904,
0.8004164696,
-0.4600687623,
0.0260331817,
0.1050461233,
0.4421955347,
0.259562403,
-0.4071317911,
0.6679785848,
0.175685823,
-0.5244345665,
-0.6469747424,
0.5601284504,
-1.0794019699,
-0.6546314359,
1.0293774605,
0.5511161685,
-0.4540274143,
0.1094035804,
-0.376306206,
-0.1936865598,
-0.1663537323,
0.9944250584,
0.2219250202,
-0.2547444403,
-0.1860635132,
-0.64749825,
0.3913096189,
0.4421538711,
-0.9025946856,
0.2106680274,
0.4479973614,
0.3838119507,
0.1374010444,
0.6329672337,
-0.0110422149,
0.2624374628,
-0.1783771813,
0.0365329869,
-0.1039950624,
-0.6616855264,
-0.1915971935,
-0.1797942817,
0.1885791719,
0.125846073
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13161v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13161v1 | APPL: A Prompt Programming Language for Harmonious Integration of Programs and Large Language Model Prompts | 2024-06-19T02:29:59 | 2024-06-19T02:29:59 | Honghua Dong, Qidong Su, Yubo Gao, Zhaoyu Li, Yangjun Ruan, Gennady Pekhimenko, Chris J. Maddison, Xujie Si | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.PL | Large Language Models (LLMs) have become increasingly capable of handling
diverse tasks with the aid of well-crafted prompts and integration of external
tools, but as task complexity rises, the workflow involving LLMs can be
complicated and thus challenging to implement and maintain. To address this
challenge, we propose APPL, A Prompt Programming Language that acts as a bridge
between computer programs and LLMs, allowing seamless embedding of prompts into
Python functions, and vice versa. APPL provides an intuitive and Python-native
syntax, an efficient parallelized runtime with asynchronous semantics, and a
tracing module supporting effective failure diagnosis and replaying without
extra costs. We demonstrate that APPL programs are intuitive, concise, and
efficient through three representative scenarios: Chain-of-Thought with
self-consistency (CoT-SC), ReAct tool use agent, and multi-agent chat.
Experiments on three parallelizable workflows further show that APPL can
effectively parallelize independent LLM calls, with a significant speedup ratio
that almost matches the estimation. | [
-0.2589963377,
-0.8121128678,
0.7173924446,
0.4748726785,
0.138201341,
0.4535152018,
-0.2659577727,
-0.1794410199,
-0.1469253451,
0.269807905,
-0.4398142695,
-0.4409996569,
-0.0855532885,
0.289293766,
-0.2738811672,
0.6816808581,
-0.2809167802,
-0.0899085328,
-0.2606997192,
-0.2319499999,
-0.7937830091,
-0.3219286203,
-0.7179849744,
-0.5101108551,
0.5731480122,
0.4577649534,
0.948146522,
0.6909598708,
0.3556218445,
0.3167150915,
0.2157530338,
-0.0019026736,
-0.0623258129,
0.3665757477,
-0.3657410443,
-0.5524298549,
-0.1553837806,
-0.2145816386,
0.4179239869,
0.8614459634,
-0.205777213,
0.1128470302,
-0.0022421458,
0.6155541539,
-0.34063977,
0.3637301028,
-0.2735607028,
-0.056732811,
-0.057083115,
-0.1028148383,
-0.3836719394,
-0.4922916293,
-0.1238532886,
-0.30055058,
-0.3322193325,
0.2148189992,
0.2739997804,
0.1851248592,
-0.031269487,
-0.4331496358,
-0.4628183246,
0.7977838516,
-0.5926202536,
0.198577404,
-0.0857127458,
0.5218824148,
-0.2399553955,
-0.7829297781,
-0.793761313,
-0.4424631596,
0.0321095511,
-0.2293640673,
-0.0163263865,
0.0203562267,
0.2829680145,
0.1889303476,
-0.6643093228,
0.166986987,
-0.0355773494,
-0.2551338077,
0.4246870279,
0.8005048037,
0.7882376313,
0.3185424507,
-0.3436642885,
0.0483845845,
-0.7645451427,
0.3301613927,
0.1377970278,
0.7797983885,
-0.3631953895,
0.5055052042,
-0.1820904762,
1.1135084629,
-0.5521094203,
0.0855171233,
-0.0386702046,
-0.4006132185,
0.0276815742,
0.1050219163,
0.9957863688,
0.1950148344,
0.3189093471,
0.0788781792,
-0.3009347022,
0.3985628486,
-0.1085250825,
-0.5553463101,
-0.1632597297,
0.6070729494,
-0.2767157853,
-0.1109222621,
-0.2576541007,
-0.1165069267,
-0.701960206,
-0.5300151706,
0.2009590566,
-0.3680680394,
0.0294166822,
0.0246407706,
0.05051158,
0.1744923592,
0.7114078403,
-0.5784268379,
0.0908714607,
0.7987778187,
0.9365708828,
-0.2329793721,
-0.5457311273,
-0.8829285502,
-0.1753541231,
-0.5265760422,
0.6306755543,
-0.5431678295,
-0.1834060699,
0.0259417091,
-0.196022585,
-0.1248024553,
-0.4642007649,
0.2297846973,
-0.4379343987,
0.0036759721,
-0.1123016402,
-0.4967876375,
-0.0103295222,
0.3646830618,
-0.3607559204,
0.925049305,
0.2314217836,
-0.5229684711,
-0.044670403,
-0.6263027787,
-0.537134707,
0.3210813403,
-0.3203756213,
0.1530686319,
-0.1197606251,
-0.1836676449,
0.3403020799,
-0.4845678508,
0.3420868814,
-0.4830696285,
-0.4288932085,
0.0590648428,
-0.2753533125,
0.9151861072,
0.5330335498,
-0.121529676,
0.3860614002,
-0.3683320284,
0.0195540767,
-0.0365874432,
-0.4736542404,
-0.2667626143,
-0.1568552256,
0.0359666795,
0.1976307034,
0.6005228162,
-0.446295917,
0.6541082263,
-0.2785561681,
0.5090679526,
0.5865487456,
-0.5748596191,
0.3102521002,
-0.2753055692,
0.567293942,
-0.1571172178,
0.1973509341,
-0.8970820308,
-0.5538507104,
-0.4550653696,
-0.2088783532,
-0.1402021945,
0.6836631894,
-0.7500346899,
0.2293265462,
0.2784396112,
-0.1912869066,
-0.4971734583,
0.288246572,
0.2162901908,
0.7080495954,
0.1036450118,
0.0160278846,
-0.5253431201,
-0.6340565681,
-0.2657121718,
-0.4517287612,
0.1688584089,
0.4294784367,
0.0742258206,
-0.3560953736,
1.0721701384,
-0.25219661,
-0.0126811005,
-0.573592782,
0.1089473441,
0.7893773913,
0.234687537,
0.1752352417,
-0.4913634658,
-1.1407630444,
0.2370471805,
-0.9323465824,
-0.544182837,
-0.1184915975,
0.0370560102,
0.12543796,
0.4055634141,
-0.7062782049,
0.0575229675,
0.4485725462,
-0.7162775397,
0.8144154549,
-0.5545520782,
0.0876124129,
-0.8453482985,
0.0544603691,
-0.4544967711,
-0.3943967521,
-0.7183683515,
0.0197954327,
0.2349219918,
-0.3408796787,
-0.4737980664,
0.8502590656,
-0.4924248159,
-0.1449347436,
-0.4188410938,
0.0911945105,
0.0554867312,
-0.0737997964,
-0.0975383148,
1.0468264818,
0.9919698834,
-0.366982162,
0.8629274964,
0.1613298506,
0.1831780672,
0.7016054392,
-0.5625505447,
-0.01284297,
0.1172479615,
0.0272657964,
-0.9027338028,
-0.0785889328,
0.0511814952,
-0.0426175259,
0.0936939567,
0.3260473311,
-0.4470560551,
-0.5139743686,
-0.4463721514,
0.3427290916,
0.4926196635,
-0.8173724413,
0.5303164721,
-0.0653774142,
-0.1976871938,
-0.4911916256,
-0.3669425249,
0.3258824646,
-0.1432297379,
-0.7192155123,
-0.0653524846,
-0.3232194185,
-0.5016627312,
-0.115582332,
0.2961061001,
-0.0411693864,
0.0314480886,
0.0036500075,
0.4457874596,
-0.279404074,
-0.0602581277,
-0.4638983607,
-0.1693693548,
-0.2059173733,
-0.4074663818,
0.6530989408,
-0.6309440136,
-0.5729881525,
-0.6285325885,
0.5053317547,
1.0220205784,
0.0089156348,
0.4348453283,
0.3221232295,
0.0503234752,
-0.2789774537,
-0.4299868643,
0.0086267898,
-0.479909569,
-0.0888462067,
-0.3235455155,
-0.7671534419,
0.8377145529,
-0.0900017545,
0.0471283719,
-0.156118229,
0.7143846154,
-0.0595673658,
1.1094070673,
0.4366896152,
-0.2665439844,
0.511946559,
0.1876737475,
0.1774024069,
-0.5006393194,
-0.107629925,
-0.3668437004,
-0.0735662356,
0.0216588415,
-0.5081750154,
0.2284844369,
0.1727727056,
-0.5176846385,
0.2582428157,
-0.3711900115,
0.4465750158,
0.6562550068,
-0.2916325033,
0.2713229358,
-0.5041921735,
-0.1935209334,
0.1059260443,
-0.7820845246,
-0.4670774341,
0.6391319036,
0.2330830097,
1.2954368591,
-0.0364620276,
0.7643490434,
0.6710551381,
0.2539327741,
-0.779180944,
0.5367119312,
-0.0878178552,
0.0363107659,
-0.2049050778,
-0.1408437341,
-0.8410537243,
0.0514399037,
0.3250882328,
-0.9399290085,
-0.0904042348,
0.3455388546,
-0.6336160898,
0.0357812941,
-0.8633615971,
1.0633244514,
-0.2792508304,
-0.5214420557,
0.0371133499,
-0.5548914671,
0.3152355254,
-0.0575421192,
0.4495913684,
-0.2784182727,
-0.0399800539,
0.0790809095,
-0.8938148618,
0.6755746603,
-0.0665614083,
-0.1630068272,
0.5978518128,
0.2627522945,
0.9506394863,
-0.0193385426,
0.1140639856,
-0.01371466,
-0.020442728,
-0.0841171369,
-0.7080024481,
0.8912220001,
-0.32390365,
-0.4696444869,
-0.249018997,
-0.9349201918,
-0.020320924,
0.1437274069,
-0.3872326016,
0.6533093452,
0.338213414,
-0.1531649381,
0.2830961347,
-0.4986447692,
0.9210870862,
0.8108541369,
-0.3990478516,
-0.0988388509,
1.0576250553,
-0.2979735136,
0.1979389191,
0.0300765093,
0.3708588481,
-0.5348445773,
-0.0493568368,
-0.6353064775,
0.1020119265,
-0.6434493661,
-0.2770465612,
-0.511851728,
0.0044673169,
0.0325229727,
-0.5836247206,
-0.6446252465,
-0.2619956434,
-0.2065301389,
0.4040057063,
0.3440431654,
0.611245811,
-0.0567501411,
0.0331033729,
-0.8227027655,
0.2421765327,
0.0357906222,
0.328920126,
-0.0299633536,
-0.0098978151,
-0.0740144402,
-0.4978760779,
-0.0261367578,
-0.8369303346,
0.2067459822,
0.2434210032,
0.5964462161,
0.3615898788,
0.4144957066,
0.3557877839,
-0.6800966859,
0.985742867,
0.533752203,
-0.9571099877,
0.6462960839,
-0.3480463028,
0.4341706336,
0.1892503053,
0.0692121685,
-0.7766264081,
-0.6926221251,
-0.272208333,
-0.7296999693,
0.7479872108,
-0.1141062155,
0.1284871846,
-0.2389377058,
0.010660057,
0.199579373,
0.311585784,
-0.4189341664,
-0.3064800203,
0.1022094414,
-0.4869037271,
-0.0003141956,
-0.1380802989,
-0.1461843699,
-0.2286489159,
0.1109314933,
-0.3456607461,
-0.037125621,
0.0712168589,
0.016094178,
0.3271685541,
0.3190357387,
0.4578551948,
0.554526329,
0.1898534745,
0.5531259775,
-0.0259180311,
-0.1382566839,
0.309214741,
-0.100908041,
-0.0872158185,
-0.1210956722,
0.4569678307,
0.5234590173,
-0.0378114246,
-1.1798326969,
0.5271337032,
-0.1525362432,
0.2505337894,
0.099726446,
0.1599017829,
0.0877427459,
0.7216608524,
0.1204920858,
-0.1311596632,
0.175426349,
-0.697499752,
0.3624107242,
0.5348656774,
-0.3774300814,
-0.3689264059,
0.9018774033,
0.2215102166,
-0.6533367038,
0.3946441114,
-0.2030732334,
-0.5791896582,
0.4571134746,
0.7147521973,
0.901237309,
-0.2501122653,
0.1813729852,
0.1884927452,
0.1341694146,
-0.2052420229,
0.7569195032,
-0.1222070679,
-0.5302333832,
-0.4414628148,
-0.6110671759,
-0.5527632833,
-0.3182300329,
-0.0982952118,
0.3660281003,
-0.3544095755,
0.099342905,
-0.3987313509,
-0.4019931257,
-0.4213134944,
-0.1878616661,
0.2901461124,
1.0665287971,
-0.8823623657,
0.7453497052,
1.0628693104,
-0.3055936098,
-1.1050816774,
-0.4285869002,
0.0535270274,
-0.8341299295,
0.8896642327,
0.3397837281,
0.0977570862,
0.0762860328,
-0.1796102077,
-0.4170950055,
0.8533380628,
0.659609735,
-0.419564724,
0.4421004653,
0.2862516642,
0.3998481333,
-0.6846295595,
0.6155949235,
0.6792371869,
0.404542625,
0.1573890746,
-1.2072027922,
0.2762680948,
-0.11033196,
0.188265264,
-0.0240441673,
-0.5903272033,
1.3120677471,
-0.5599066019,
-0.1424317509,
0.0153230559,
0.2505239248,
0.2302993685,
0.4334130287,
0.3866672814,
0.1133802906,
0.8537706733,
-0.0481579714,
1.1482505798,
-0.8106983304,
0.2774370313,
0.7962255478,
-0.3796306551,
0.558652699,
0.5618305206,
-0.3286089897,
0.4606247544,
0.5593556166,
0.4024391174,
0.4459207356,
0.1432937086,
-0.688069582,
-0.3258277178,
-0.4493953586,
-0.2923050523,
0.1138504222,
0.2336578965,
-0.1038455963,
-0.5661614537,
0.0720303133,
-0.2045261413,
0.1430718452,
-0.2701228559,
0.4943213463,
0.2373504341,
-0.7373774052,
0.6328157187,
-0.3389437795,
0.4926025271,
-0.5657770038,
-0.2091618776,
-0.5034846663,
0.4028078318,
-0.0689582378,
-1.0157266855,
0.3484152257,
-0.0823755413,
-0.1402183622,
-0.3591398895,
0.7863033414,
-0.5081019402,
0.0883094892,
0.2972533405,
0.4804617763,
0.2846059501,
-0.0937332958,
-0.8522277474,
0.5261327028,
-0.1381527781,
-0.275121212,
0.1296683103,
0.3569764197,
-0.2773787379,
1.1650052071,
0.6578218341,
0.0329946652,
0.0294875056,
0.2373511642,
0.8681420684,
-0.633220017,
-0.818315804,
-1.2604721785,
0.6355084777,
0.0024503004,
0.2120613903,
0.835745275,
0.4758916199,
0.1919907331,
-0.0601245575,
0.845235765,
-0.1977202743,
0.2110159993,
-0.2933448255,
0.5782985091,
-0.4462432265,
0.6412082911,
-0.0051601692,
-0.818284452,
-0.221389994,
0.4481920004,
0.1109835654,
-0.2496827841,
0.5901041627,
0.6396178007,
0.1376402378,
-0.0156271234,
0.3919970393,
-0.0760364532,
0.5459322333,
0.7705866694,
1.2446850538,
0.155660972,
0.3383706212,
0.0407809392,
-0.54274863,
-0.2593916357,
-1.03711164,
-0.8735103011,
-0.1623402238,
-0.2573027313,
-0.2781104147,
-0.0716150701,
0.9543508291,
0.3873612285,
-0.7869692445,
-0.5584811568,
-0.3438132107,
0.3587449789,
-0.2416587919,
-0.2352806181,
0.0548613481,
-0.9351738691,
-0.6210492849,
0.6411022544,
0.6806010604,
-0.234750092,
-0.4540794492,
-0.4764069319,
0.192811951,
-0.0142755434,
0.5878605843,
0.8051309586,
-0.6955699325,
-0.3146278262,
-0.09522558,
-0.2734001875,
-0.1102824956,
0.7943067551,
-0.6246367097,
0.9332632422,
0.5648958683,
0.7880002856,
-0.2818856835,
0.0628640875,
0.9723209143,
-0.7397865057,
0.1772333384,
0.0025859266,
0.448510319,
0.4311190546,
-0.3030436933,
0.3589112759,
0.3743371964,
-0.5193514824,
-1.0026516914,
0.3365971446,
-0.7688177824,
-0.176152274,
1.0011667013,
-0.3329336047,
-0.0861507356,
-0.3411034346,
-0.5516254902,
-0.1473381668,
-0.3908577263,
0.402628988,
0.6082071066,
-0.7881088853,
-0.0721856803,
-0.6212237477,
0.360658139,
0.1123960316,
-0.6435679197,
0.4743357301,
0.4595697224,
0.0362790637,
0.1828515083,
0.9268417358,
0.2745088935,
0.1989296824,
0.1551741958,
0.1275569201,
-0.3961697221,
-0.297267586,
-0.3675364256,
0.0616106577,
0.2420421392,
-0.1680386811
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13152v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13152v1 | Analyzing Diversity in Healthcare LLM Research: A Scientometric Perspective | 2024-06-19T02:00:51 | 2024-06-19T02:00:51 | David Restrepo, Chenwei Wu, Constanza Vásquez-Venegas, João Matos, Jack Gallifant, Luis Filipe | cs.CL | cs.CL | The deployment of large language models (LLMs) in healthcare has demonstrated
substantial potential for enhancing clinical decision-making, administrative
efficiency, and patient outcomes. However, the underrepresentation of diverse
groups in the development and application of these models can perpetuate
biases, leading to inequitable healthcare delivery. This paper presents a
comprehensive scientometric analysis of LLM research for healthcare, including
data from January 1, 2021, to June 16, 2024. By analyzing metadata from PubMed
and Dimensions, including author affiliations, countries, and funding sources,
we assess the diversity of contributors to LLM research. Our findings highlight
significant gender and geographic disparities, with a predominance of male
authors and contributions primarily from high-income countries (HICs). We
introduce a novel journal diversity index based on Gini impurity to measure the
inclusiveness of scientific publications. Our results underscore the necessity
for greater representation in order to ensure the equitable application of LLMs
in healthcare. We propose actionable strategies to enhance diversity and
inclusivity in artificial intelligence research, with the ultimate goal of
fostering a more inclusive and equitable future in healthcare innovation. | [
0.0544251464,
-0.2050069273,
0.5639145374,
0.3579420149,
0.1068819687,
0.411025703,
-0.1017634943,
-0.7859651446,
0.4259164631,
0.097699374,
-0.4533018768,
-0.4619775712,
-0.8215379119,
0.2619272768,
-0.2296064943,
0.8895866871,
0.2394968569,
0.7449121475,
-0.4237110913,
-0.1817152947,
-0.075495638,
-0.4889194667,
-0.1092387438,
-0.4444834888,
0.6366616488,
0.1408040673,
0.5534175038,
0.6715852618,
0.8704479933,
0.296121031,
-0.2283333987,
-0.0348092094,
-0.3902085423,
0.0803943947,
-0.0197595377,
-0.6522658467,
-0.4477123618,
-0.2596487403,
0.9120793939,
1.157194972,
-0.0231186785,
0.0827446282,
0.0102064079,
0.4442349076,
-0.3719935417,
-0.1055548117,
-0.1667644233,
0.2792781591,
-0.3552626669,
-0.2539283931,
0.1018918827,
-0.6008965969,
0.3190923631,
-0.3181815743,
0.2268067896,
0.3362481296,
0.3950604498,
0.1808206588,
-0.4748559594,
-0.3693980277,
-0.7667405009,
0.886726141,
-0.7184432149,
0.4445250034,
-0.1014655009,
0.0429805405,
-0.4280051291,
-0.5469993949,
-0.1173809618,
-0.3058142364,
-0.0622588694,
0.0298044402,
-0.331779629,
-0.1746654361,
0.0265991725,
0.3858239353,
-0.6128606796,
0.5770059228,
-0.6618368626,
0.0361307487,
0.8680896759,
0.2737739682,
0.79801929,
0.1403962374,
-0.2376381606,
0.2352590263,
-0.5864140391,
-0.029096121,
0.2926058173,
0.22478351,
-0.2904591858,
0.7401778698,
0.0415342823,
-0.0603179112,
-0.4661891162,
-0.3532362878,
0.5030875802,
-0.6319974065,
-0.0783848315,
0.4329972267,
0.8065292239,
0.1853097379,
-0.2861905098,
-0.2694198489,
0.1315208524,
-0.1301646233,
0.1320958883,
-0.7184721231,
0.2478920668,
0.1543660313,
-0.6414855719,
-0.1148321703,
0.0299813654,
-0.7321764231,
-0.7529000044,
-0.0097258352,
-0.3490832746,
-0.1862586588,
-0.1553769112,
-0.0875196382,
-0.2878352702,
0.1054833233,
0.2315048277,
-0.637050271,
0.3585587442,
0.817134738,
0.761379838,
-0.4102892578,
-0.2962524593,
0.1163928732,
0.0998241156,
-0.1476715356,
0.5335521698,
-0.4115564823,
-0.6638528705,
-0.0111768236,
-0.1887781173,
-0.0113285156,
-0.5140937567,
0.5089327097,
-0.1127531603,
0.0499220043,
-0.385204047,
-0.5033448339,
0.0561936311,
0.1093107685,
-0.6281123161,
0.3824691474,
0.4378730953,
-0.6959820986,
0.6543644667,
-0.7097914815,
-0.3064736128,
0.4786558747,
-0.5055172443,
-0.6279222369,
0.3271973729,
0.1745583564,
-0.0293663554,
-0.5598009229,
0.6497713923,
-0.5143812895,
-0.2709642053,
0.499219507,
-0.3729380071,
1.0288401842,
0.2880132794,
-0.1762297451,
0.4181439877,
-0.538479805,
-0.3202051222,
0.0138008213,
0.0148489578,
-0.356880337,
0.144648701,
0.0545912646,
-0.0315929167,
0.0974226221,
-0.5589663982,
0.0880718082,
-0.610880971,
0.4186858237,
0.4638866782,
-0.0510968603,
0.6588440537,
-0.528252542,
0.7662186027,
-0.1914593279,
0.5236452818,
0.157135874,
-0.6184872985,
-0.2147607952,
-0.6268000603,
0.1966614574,
0.3460072875,
-0.1550066471,
0.1687377393,
-0.2447264791,
-0.4599922299,
-0.7527433634,
-0.0221832916,
-0.0387664139,
0.426930964,
0.1279050559,
-0.3097297549,
-0.6638912559,
-0.8907706141,
-0.3069573641,
-0.3257144094,
-0.102325812,
0.3322279453,
0.7282432914,
-0.5598112345,
0.8176605701,
-0.1773387194,
-0.164248839,
-0.1512369215,
-0.0399269424,
0.2383174747,
0.5056882501,
0.4693313241,
-0.6675466299,
0.0594666675,
-0.0483070612,
-1.0309357643,
-0.1616778225,
0.314941138,
-0.1155792177,
-0.2016612291,
0.1765896678,
-0.30708009,
0.4161806107,
0.4387281835,
-0.3618290722,
0.3220886886,
0.053795781,
0.2501671612,
-0.7589501739,
0.0565398112,
0.2286599874,
0.3603160083,
-0.6091185212,
-0.0796173513,
-0.11149358,
-0.115655221,
-0.0719411522,
0.6002185345,
-0.397636205,
-0.0215098895,
-0.0228109546,
-0.4525638223,
-0.2006270885,
-0.4150993228,
-0.3750395477,
0.4563027322,
0.286760211,
-0.192207709,
0.0087928008,
0.1186613813,
-0.3797372282,
0.3684177101,
-0.8635733128,
-0.4824621379,
-0.1394339651,
0.3004674017,
-0.7541952729,
-0.2868191004,
0.2591225505,
-0.463773042,
0.0024291486,
0.2692733705,
-0.258772403,
-0.7654111385,
-0.2911590338,
0.744525373,
0.4191405475,
-0.0746860281,
0.4319004714,
0.7115211487,
-0.5997639894,
-0.5948355198,
-0.7640833259,
0.0071252822,
-0.2601771951,
-0.7387017012,
0.539714098,
-0.1139035225,
-0.8238412738,
0.0723804682,
-0.0550153628,
-0.0185558852,
0.3606068194,
0.2199572027,
0.5016717911,
-0.2677293718,
0.0335295275,
-0.0103290705,
0.1841751635,
0.3367683291,
-0.346937716,
0.3226457238,
-0.0552841723,
-0.8244667053,
-0.146260187,
0.7177646756,
0.3462848961,
-0.149590224,
0.4724764824,
0.5209701657,
-0.3136689365,
0.0159485918,
-0.3724545836,
-0.2181225717,
-0.3766111434,
0.6577323079,
0.476102531,
-1.3117182255,
0.6284845471,
0.1121500507,
0.3648059964,
0.3907079399,
0.7278963923,
-0.2297587395,
0.8351022005,
0.7813614011,
-0.0642374381,
0.1412530094,
0.0758271664,
0.4077180028,
-0.5969402194,
-0.7387527227,
-0.8800551295,
-0.4709717333,
-1.0571118593,
-0.5002760887,
0.6794237494,
-0.1682455689,
-0.2587231696,
-0.5572718978,
-0.6776993275,
0.0873681605,
0.7149775624,
0.0489854328,
0.4377544522,
-0.0794714615,
0.2218189836,
-0.2129343152,
-0.7087571025,
-0.1585265249,
1.152766943,
0.6748284698,
0.8801795244,
0.1528864503,
0.8365589976,
0.5348268747,
0.5841854215,
-0.7353684306,
0.0909019932,
-0.1204293519,
-0.5424090028,
-0.3286163807,
-0.5975868106,
-0.9991562366,
0.1309898794,
-0.0451122113,
-0.4093748629,
0.6395889521,
-0.271445781,
-0.2167350948,
0.2314001024,
-0.2778998613,
0.2574649453,
-0.6750522852,
-0.1194310486,
0.0709925815,
-0.5452660918,
0.5023862123,
0.0804177895,
0.486558944,
-0.4657432139,
-0.1605824828,
0.6132157445,
-0.0570609756,
0.624546051,
0.1250609905,
-0.1207309067,
-0.2224596441,
-0.3018013835,
-0.1061534211,
0.1746746302,
-0.2758743465,
0.7016972899,
-0.2902288735,
-0.5096709728,
-0.4276668727,
0.6548247933,
-0.9907716513,
-0.5634931922,
-0.8265555501,
-0.8366647959,
-0.0758909062,
0.0387283675,
0.222007066,
-0.0395166725,
-0.387396723,
0.0444669239,
0.5250477791,
-0.3220326602,
0.2073359489,
0.4387207925,
0.0350742638,
-0.4090184271,
0.6150039434,
0.3369390666,
-0.1788771451,
0.1860346347,
0.3309533596,
-0.2749392092,
-0.9853113294,
-0.1741139442,
0.4388442636,
-0.3385592997,
0.0351388901,
-0.6727080941,
-0.3951328397,
-0.6008692384,
-0.3539667428,
0.0270835627,
-0.0791540071,
-0.4430499077,
0.1316037327,
0.1636157781,
0.868473649,
0.1409312487,
0.157887876,
-0.4203869998,
0.0416942909,
-0.0400704518,
0.2887277603,
-0.0861968249,
-0.3887213171,
-0.2066586018,
-0.0589258261,
-0.0486934185,
-0.7200543284,
0.6138160229,
-0.1110372022,
1.1037477255,
0.2842033207,
-0.1264851242,
0.5426281691,
-0.6160177588,
0.7563486099,
0.590767324,
-0.5374714136,
0.4087139666,
-0.2343803495,
0.1979500502,
0.487811476,
0.6007065773,
-0.4586301446,
-0.527187705,
-0.5061243176,
-1.1109992266,
0.4449233711,
-0.0972355232,
0.0554789864,
0.262516886,
-0.0324478932,
0.1674634218,
0.1871519685,
-0.6162962914,
-0.1821359992,
0.0237548109,
-0.4507249892,
0.206105262,
-0.250984937,
-0.5523331165,
-0.3148157001,
0.3709281683,
-0.1152483076,
0.4165247679,
0.3412787616,
0.0459794812,
-0.060692206,
0.6210276484,
0.5710190535,
0.9938941598,
-0.0622811355,
0.0428150073,
0.0068269074,
-0.4763795137,
0.2271976769,
0.5305685997,
-0.3593058884,
0.0351031795,
0.6581077576,
0.5126567483,
0.0287276469,
-0.6756495833,
0.1858804226,
-0.0422354825,
-0.084926106,
-0.1833353043,
0.123063013,
-0.0516674854,
0.4578769505,
0.5365244746,
-0.0125157116,
0.4361644089,
-0.5030326247,
0.1947562993,
0.3677749336,
-0.4569734633,
-0.0688656196,
0.6643090844,
0.3206100166,
-0.3175860345,
0.4847235084,
0.2717276812,
-0.1630413234,
0.8578721881,
0.5510427356,
0.7434315085,
-0.2971849144,
0.1368144602,
0.1170890182,
0.4040305316,
0.079532221,
0.0591551811,
0.355630815,
-0.40243572,
-0.2190447599,
-0.6582612991,
-0.5336995721,
-0.279004097,
-0.4251689017,
-0.0281005148,
-0.2652491629,
-0.195822984,
0.1928609163,
0.0834899172,
-0.6530377269,
-0.0187535416,
0.3666019142,
0.6014603376,
-0.5684462786,
0.3604485691,
0.5128059983,
-0.3356863558,
-0.4543765187,
-0.0896043032,
0.3877456486,
-1.0194618702,
0.6450862288,
-0.0804322585,
0.0591910891,
-0.4493704438,
-0.5989550948,
-0.8410438299,
1.2040714025,
0.4187921286,
-0.7934035659,
-0.251164943,
0.3676835895,
0.6448326111,
-0.6615518928,
0.5654072762,
0.5166483521,
0.3781307042,
-0.0632659346,
-0.8512269258,
-0.1160306558,
-0.406062156,
0.1729405671,
-0.1332567483,
-0.5606843829,
0.9910060763,
-0.3433026969,
-0.0109283486,
0.0662410483,
0.6121894121,
0.6409483552,
0.7580618262,
0.1385873258,
0.2233648896,
1.1338270903,
-0.2343329191,
1.1557714939,
0.0116190994,
0.0737863854,
0.7832837701,
-0.6151862741,
0.010312181,
0.4709888101,
-0.4349562824,
0.4436224401,
0.5071370006,
-0.4215106666,
0.1367575228,
0.3695808649,
-0.4758759141,
0.3233699799,
-0.7888187766,
-0.7454013228,
0.4663804471,
0.4758868217,
-0.7868742347,
-0.0847344846,
0.1297263503,
0.1357865781,
-0.0329538435,
-0.462980926,
0.7076787949,
0.2459338307,
-0.2545121908,
-0.0342784598,
-0.0449900217,
0.8813185692,
-0.8498551846,
0.0617010146,
-0.3208956718,
-0.0749321282,
-0.3501316905,
-0.727411449,
0.2149566263,
0.1108355969,
-0.5358479619,
-0.1049069986,
0.6584445238,
-0.3622832,
-0.9284741879,
0.3513067365,
0.6927933693,
0.0086339237,
0.5168239474,
-0.6047084332,
0.2622502148,
0.0192905907,
0.1927881241,
0.4211668074,
0.2986047566,
-0.3161495328,
0.691935122,
0.6570168138,
0.6358655095,
-0.0495383218,
0.2517144978,
0.7590170503,
-0.6214967966,
-0.417486161,
-1.2093372345,
0.2916145623,
-0.2055142522,
-0.4197334349,
0.9941372871,
0.4840173423,
0.3528411984,
0.3460715711,
0.9731561542,
0.0384179316,
0.2607863247,
-0.0218930896,
0.934905529,
-0.7304580808,
0.3617067337,
-0.1452922374,
-0.3341302574,
-0.5400494933,
0.0610786229,
-0.2465827763,
0.0772927403,
0.1361630261,
0.4668274522,
0.1800217628,
0.2875355184,
0.0783786476,
0.1012302637,
0.4305006862,
0.1848030984,
0.9733198285,
0.0151619734,
0.1318226457,
-0.0835795552,
-0.3401613533,
-0.4089680314,
-0.6040678024,
-0.4018601477,
0.0736336485,
-0.1806644201,
-0.3135781586,
0.1046308801,
0.9789128304,
0.6848831773,
-0.8778448105,
-0.4306489527,
0.2280102074,
0.5596371889,
-0.0786436945,
-0.1892725974,
0.2108864486,
-0.1370503157,
-0.5363575816,
0.150665462,
0.6404885054,
-0.0906502232,
-0.537476182,
-0.1008617207,
-0.0205742754,
-0.0290915743,
0.4078725874,
0.1902385503,
-0.6592194438,
0.4321291447,
0.3293347657,
-0.3178568482,
0.219268173,
0.9309670925,
-0.2215608954,
0.3498436809,
0.4676299095,
0.7357942462,
-0.0980855152,
-0.2553542256,
0.5265029073,
-0.3680706322,
0.0664810389,
0.9403722286,
0.3978288174,
0.3216148913,
-0.5226061344,
0.4822252095,
0.4242374897,
-0.7058619857,
-1.0461976528,
-0.1412335038,
-0.7267894149,
-0.3639268279,
0.8090189695,
0.1083986536,
-0.3756763935,
-0.2324319631,
0.17793791,
0.2351580411,
-0.4924182892,
0.830509901,
0.465261668,
-0.5314378142,
-0.1169517115,
-0.5397266746,
0.3297640085,
0.4510785341,
-1.1027796268,
-0.4032776356,
0.5109215975,
0.0830258206,
0.0858836621,
0.7149830461,
-0.4186847508,
0.2248981595,
-0.1975092888,
0.2018337101,
0.118595086,
-0.2118070275,
-0.3523672223,
0.163172707,
-0.0533697084,
0.3126127124
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13144v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13144v1 | DialSim: A Real-Time Simulator for Evaluating Long-Term Dialogue Understanding of Conversational Agents | 2024-06-19T01:37:10 | 2024-06-19T01:37:10 | Jiho Kim, Woosog Chay, Hyeonji Hwang, Daeun Kyung, Hyunseung Chung, Eunbyeol Cho, Yohan Jo, Edward Choi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Recent advancements in Large Language Models (LLMs) have significantly
enhanced the capabilities of conversational agents, making them applicable to
various fields (e.g., education). Despite their progress, the evaluation of the
agents often overlooks the complexities of real-world conversations, such as
real-time interactions, multi-party dialogues, and extended contextual
dependencies. To bridge this gap, we introduce DialSim, a real-time dialogue
simulator. In this simulator, an agent is assigned the role of a character from
popular TV shows, requiring it to respond to spontaneous questions using past
dialogue information and to distinguish between known and unknown information.
Key features of DialSim include evaluating the agent's ability to respond
within a reasonable time limit, handling long-term multi-party dialogues, and
managing adversarial settings (e.g., swap character names) to challenge the
agent's reliance on pre-trained knowledge. We utilized this simulator to
evaluate the latest conversational agents and analyze their limitations. Our
experiments highlight both the strengths and weaknesses of these agents,
providing valuable insights for future improvements in the field of
conversational AI. DialSim is available at
https://github.com/jiho283/Simulator. | [
-0.4214900434,
-0.9850693941,
0.4788479507,
0.4181965888,
-0.190078944,
0.4962474406,
-0.2912555039,
-0.3861027956,
0.0980907604,
0.7068821788,
-0.8128674626,
-0.074579373,
-0.2492538393,
0.0115962299,
-0.0911237076,
0.681429565,
0.1809664965,
0.2695392072,
-0.6032789946,
-0.0122335916,
-0.5098471045,
-0.6776379943,
-0.7835823894,
-0.425873518,
0.2433335185,
0.268342495,
0.8108028769,
0.2890867591,
0.3559500873,
0.386842519,
-0.0495902523,
0.138799265,
-0.5604729652,
0.6055001616,
0.0258791298,
-0.622046411,
-0.4891227186,
0.1370324343,
0.8468415737,
0.5151235461,
-0.028199885,
0.0306203775,
-0.1751909554,
0.2501162887,
-0.2009640336,
0.4192385972,
-0.3508261442,
0.2448943555,
0.3747284114,
-0.5230234265,
-0.4866903126,
-0.4448558986,
0.5430632234,
-0.6662584543,
-0.0370153412,
-0.0595827512,
0.8108996749,
0.3995140493,
-0.6036480665,
-0.2656505704,
-1.0832289457,
0.6344573498,
-0.6278151274,
0.2922401428,
0.1112553179,
0.720290184,
-0.3397898078,
-0.5716254115,
-0.5405821204,
-0.7729702592,
0.2146284282,
0.2713647485,
0.1231213734,
0.2606281638,
0.5042131543,
0.0094065117,
-0.4642026126,
-0.0476048142,
-0.0277078096,
-0.3085694015,
0.1582249999,
0.4908569753,
0.4109012485,
0.0199771672,
-0.5279597044,
-0.0321782194,
-0.5156920552,
-0.0035740375,
0.2714802921,
-0.007416972,
-0.0633067414,
0.3193425834,
-0.020033747,
0.3918632269,
-0.1974478513,
-0.1257721633,
-0.0349163935,
-0.2858650386,
-0.1205146089,
0.0642360002,
0.5640403628,
0.351061523,
0.3610583246,
-0.0446723066,
0.2291935831,
0.0572136119,
0.2461804003,
-1.1726306677,
0.0314896256,
0.1369927824,
-0.2660441995,
-0.4585759938,
-0.3092510104,
-0.7147373557,
-0.5018638968,
-0.2140447646,
0.2764138281,
-0.3564337194,
-0.2645204961,
-0.1171299219,
-0.1063040867,
0.4713092148,
0.5553243756,
-0.1333707571,
0.3934156299,
0.5761473775,
0.7469770312,
0.057952486,
-0.2602068186,
-0.9002742171,
-0.055951111,
-0.2591072321,
0.5503825545,
-0.7143188715,
-0.6467929482,
-0.1460154802,
-0.0319378115,
-0.2029889226,
-0.5032528639,
0.143135339,
-0.5215090513,
0.1466411054,
0.0657703727,
-0.5492652059,
0.0734386966,
0.5165919065,
-0.4390829802,
0.5473943949,
-0.0549951047,
-0.2489722073,
-0.11463698,
-0.8200159073,
-0.1929042786,
0.1472812444,
-0.1680088788,
-0.3558051884,
-0.2307792902,
0.058943551,
0.2948954403,
-0.3683703244,
0.470944643,
-0.2946637869,
-0.5782650113,
0.9079872966,
-0.7762772441,
0.6186071038,
0.2993676066,
-0.2542716861,
0.1203560978,
-0.3251273036,
0.0016611883,
0.1178978086,
0.1221303567,
-0.0168369506,
0.2026954889,
-0.2277687043,
0.2953393161,
0.056892138,
-0.3738030791,
0.2142640948,
-0.3849721849,
0.5655505657,
0.7292914391,
0.1426972896,
0.3661309481,
-0.5012087226,
0.9815835357,
0.1580501348,
0.3736053705,
-0.6288814545,
-0.2971148193,
-1.1774302721,
-0.207953319,
0.2859425247,
0.8556438684,
-0.9253906012,
0.2545660436,
-0.41469419,
-0.4689070582,
-0.2571571767,
-0.0957107544,
0.3791432381,
0.1976013482,
-0.1440514177,
-0.3709010482,
-0.3085088432,
-0.6404897571,
-0.1221863478,
-0.3523913622,
0.1043047979,
0.5788850784,
0.5421779156,
-0.4293402135,
1.0963840485,
-0.5096227527,
-0.1482956558,
-0.4751286209,
0.2211001366,
-0.3456720114,
0.3469522893,
0.3588310778,
-0.6298165321,
-0.2347782999,
-0.2433892339,
-0.7082226276,
-0.0332795158,
-0.5473566651,
0.160521701,
-0.1684273481,
0.7187144756,
-0.6447966099,
0.2961203456,
0.4403527677,
-0.3222918212,
0.7237404585,
-0.1120654494,
0.2461085171,
-1.0799231529,
-0.0984664485,
-0.1013543978,
-0.6503350139,
-0.6400443912,
-0.220517084,
-0.2888683081,
-0.6802799702,
-0.7124394774,
0.8932083249,
-0.3594691753,
-0.151879698,
0.0790554434,
0.5289362669,
-0.0315547585,
0.5463995934,
-0.0899609998,
1.2408800125,
0.2511563003,
-0.5802233815,
0.6076955795,
0.0552008711,
-0.570514977,
0.5548150539,
-0.5818805695,
0.3394664228,
-0.1094392613,
0.6789830923,
-0.8251491189,
-0.2351552695,
0.3757956922,
-0.4176591039,
0.0298712756,
-0.2502996027,
-0.3108288944,
-0.1328464001,
-0.1430947185,
0.5505139828,
0.4138279855,
-0.409904778,
0.8505767584,
0.3316941857,
-0.4827985466,
-0.3522953689,
-0.1181068793,
0.333673209,
-0.2686241567,
-0.476148665,
-0.115076378,
-0.5219889879,
-0.4561993182,
-0.1978833824,
0.0349880569,
-0.1581741571,
0.4013657272,
0.556507349,
0.3624926209,
-0.1434258074,
0.0346799456,
-0.0921154395,
-0.2032138854,
0.1284711808,
0.0287628137,
0.7129295468,
-0.320395261,
-0.4304682314,
-0.7407416701,
0.0979081392,
0.8638228178,
-0.1459767371,
0.2676390111,
0.3507981002,
-0.2235580087,
-0.1052598432,
-0.6170923114,
-0.3047714829,
-0.4522064924,
0.5174549818,
-0.2993842661,
-0.7998728156,
0.5358569622,
-0.5141300559,
-0.0106427548,
-0.2154656351,
0.3680974245,
-0.0044515496,
1.3353013992,
0.1407083273,
-0.0631267428,
0.8034772873,
-0.2616400719,
0.2498443127,
-0.7418607473,
-0.2814892232,
-0.3343524933,
0.0183276925,
-0.1746713966,
-0.8851264715,
0.3433821797,
-0.3523752689,
-0.0388947986,
0.0409547649,
0.1848660856,
0.6375881433,
0.2103004903,
-0.0538462512,
0.2569221854,
-0.2718312144,
0.1466617435,
0.0258773696,
-0.5154892802,
-0.7290344834,
0.6657415032,
0.7166307569,
0.8585604429,
-0.1155336276,
0.3482539654,
0.576238513,
0.2816096246,
-1.0986331701,
0.943790555,
0.3820906579,
-0.4562642574,
-0.2217108607,
-0.537574172,
-0.8076460958,
0.3607732952,
-0.1192419901,
-0.4309245944,
-0.2163101286,
0.0877041668,
-0.4213165939,
0.0570025928,
-0.6578543186,
0.7512254119,
-0.4087199271,
-0.2080102414,
-0.4664103985,
-0.6698034406,
0.0570836328,
0.2198064327,
0.1712587178,
-0.4547194242,
0.2085507512,
0.6451745033,
-0.4002411366,
0.9681761861,
-0.133510828,
0.0654206276,
0.3488861918,
0.2855839729,
0.3065869808,
0.3616961241,
0.1432640105,
0.0308462344,
0.2752204835,
-0.4004424214,
-0.77048558,
0.7202335,
-0.8439225554,
-0.5533607602,
-0.709680438,
-0.5383653045,
-0.3938456476,
0.0101176249,
-0.208477214,
0.717836678,
-0.8691611886,
0.0715145394,
0.6449351907,
-0.2917814255,
0.1600860506,
0.5305909514,
-0.4475513101,
-0.3372609615,
1.0351797342,
-0.1457969993,
0.4651773274,
0.0963114351,
-0.029828677,
-0.0239598379,
-0.0620020404,
-0.5621050596,
0.1819958538,
-0.4633493125,
-0.0475295372,
-0.4791893065,
-0.4221239388,
-0.2006435394,
-0.1170715168,
-0.3023700416,
-0.4007408023,
-0.2134283185,
0.1337737292,
-0.0897912979,
0.6187395453,
0.3616959453,
0.5224600434,
-0.7515160441,
0.2699364424,
0.6667330861,
0.2179587483,
-0.1662692279,
-0.2253928035,
-0.2308006287,
0.4487656951,
-0.3504453003,
-0.8087326288,
0.3095853627,
0.2290839106,
0.4500442445,
0.4641419053,
-0.0484749451,
0.6926024556,
-0.2508204877,
0.9300658107,
0.0790240392,
-0.8843642473,
0.3688209057,
-0.2120285034,
0.3880820274,
0.4048009515,
-0.1465702802,
-0.7999292612,
-0.5660667419,
-0.414219439,
-0.4685886502,
0.8092230558,
0.3263887167,
0.2085943371,
0.0631319433,
0.1436179876,
0.0230578873,
0.2371102124,
-0.3772372305,
-0.0635463893,
-0.0802764595,
0.0491992123,
-0.1804866046,
-0.3216361403,
-0.1170224026,
-0.0423371121,
0.6539347172,
-0.100582011,
0.5304932594,
0.1184773818,
-0.4809584618,
0.0959545895,
0.4014570117,
0.684512794,
0.5407030582,
-0.3583157063,
-0.1119070202,
0.3725953698,
-0.3898859918,
0.1281042099,
0.0751870796,
0.149893567,
-0.0078544272,
0.1458673477,
0.9923679829,
0.3103968501,
-1.0533794165,
0.5778439045,
-0.577711463,
-0.0869695097,
-0.6689326763,
0.173595354,
-0.08955843,
0.5294415355,
0.2188013196,
-0.0706773698,
0.0043082186,
-0.8577560186,
0.0934711844,
0.4588060677,
-0.6635665894,
-0.2306041718,
0.4068683088,
0.7050625682,
-0.6531884074,
0.6989923716,
-0.2109577954,
-0.8139850497,
1.0557537079,
0.5550526381,
0.9363985062,
-0.2599377632,
0.5283646584,
-0.1916767955,
0.0323632136,
0.0866682157,
-0.0149796214,
-0.1580705047,
-0.6663433909,
-0.3460698128,
-0.3337842524,
-0.9927129745,
0.1991576701,
-0.4498953819,
0.1086795777,
-0.4338991344,
-0.4017224312,
-0.2051323801,
0.0447798185,
-0.602332294,
0.1127641648,
0.0813743174,
0.7880446911,
-0.6072724462,
0.7042883039,
0.5463173985,
-0.0083192708,
-0.2523975968,
0.2592693567,
-0.0266938228,
-0.6925538182,
0.5340762138,
0.3621501625,
-0.4423687458,
0.1384326965,
-0.453473568,
-0.3725501001,
0.9712715149,
0.4538747966,
-0.5073425174,
-0.3490446806,
0.2583940923,
0.5821100473,
-0.5388391614,
0.7127084136,
0.4322304428,
0.2330686897,
0.0277086999,
-0.8497551084,
-0.2089944035,
-0.3463238776,
-0.0886035636,
0.1701811999,
-0.7833696008,
0.289932847,
-0.2316831052,
-0.2202003896,
0.3738779128,
0.5996363759,
0.0062572206,
0.5251373053,
0.8049117327,
-0.0054182699,
0.5054479241,
-0.0897030607,
0.6157009006,
-0.4714750051,
0.3202033937,
1.0771046877,
-0.4305769503,
0.4472671449,
0.2479506284,
0.108538352,
0.3699806631,
0.4061899185,
0.2203083038,
0.2047199458,
0.2611842453,
-0.5299222469,
-0.5907269716,
-0.3483096361,
-0.3367379308,
0.417403698,
0.6175087094,
0.1098551676,
-0.0386381336,
0.2836288512,
0.1248453856,
-0.1654943675,
0.0543693006,
0.866519928,
0.1942007542,
-0.6626237035,
0.2882514596,
-0.3986331522,
0.2089191675,
-0.6763875484,
-0.2414918691,
-0.1560316384,
0.1963932961,
0.2810920179,
-0.5266723633,
-0.1955924928,
-0.150237903,
0.2359543443,
-0.2465741336,
0.6221387982,
-0.4888091981,
-0.2101676464,
0.2232411206,
0.3881202936,
0.2384186536,
0.100775376,
-0.8153509498,
0.2481112927,
-0.1396000385,
-0.1412227154,
0.250778228,
0.1233439744,
0.0042917291,
1.1967149973,
0.6006997228,
0.1272986233,
-0.1759783179,
0.1969313174,
0.8707920909,
-0.6628655791,
-0.4574193656,
-0.5983134508,
0.120997712,
-0.2965299785,
-0.1503682882,
0.452931881,
0.6014080644,
0.4726859927,
0.011692266,
0.8512026072,
0.3323650956,
0.283013165,
-0.3820039034,
0.5239769816,
-0.3573329449,
0.3155803978,
-0.0787682012,
-0.9026364088,
0.0172769912,
0.6834543347,
-0.2001071125,
-0.0659993514,
0.543995738,
0.7188127637,
0.076915957,
0.1597090065,
0.4017558992,
0.3285162151,
0.7641353607,
0.4275636673,
1.3978385925,
-0.0262125805,
0.6734318137,
-0.1869135052,
-0.1444198489,
-0.576587379,
-0.7187577486,
-1.2379847765,
-0.5011239648,
-0.243895039,
-0.3104115725,
0.3935103714,
1.2875748873,
0.6392954588,
-0.4101144373,
-0.4952447116,
0.2970145643,
0.1919414997,
-0.0804707929,
-0.2466198206,
-0.303809315,
-0.2629199326,
-0.9490934014,
0.6153286695,
0.4079919159,
0.0949452296,
-0.3466410339,
-0.2262358218,
0.0919576809,
0.5357281566,
0.6510962248,
0.3461712599,
-0.5430033207,
-0.3599633873,
0.0084461616,
-0.220495984,
-0.0408717915,
0.9632570744,
-0.8561167121,
0.8199754953,
0.3433127701,
0.3649216294,
0.5415135026,
0.1913145632,
0.7637507915,
-0.208111003,
0.263258636,
0.3726534843,
0.0634913966,
0.1551403105,
-0.098220624,
0.2125504911,
0.1885172427,
-0.6559533477,
-0.9504166842,
0.4717630744,
-0.9984979033,
-0.1263715178,
1.0661289692,
-0.1648406684,
-0.0325646326,
-0.2875558734,
-0.7128026485,
0.3620437384,
-0.5198221207,
0.6505815983,
0.599016428,
-0.0071870107,
0.047812026,
-0.6971781254,
0.4313593209,
0.4972743392,
-0.8698901534,
0.1067602634,
0.550639987,
0.2709524333,
0.0420827307,
0.7596915364,
0.1394082159,
0.2362823486,
-0.3013180196,
-0.290040344,
-0.1494389623,
-0.526260376,
-0.1261696368,
-0.1496381015,
0.1579082459,
-0.1407487392
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13138v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13138v1 | Large Language Models are Biased Because They Are Large Language Models | 2024-06-19T01:08:03 | 2024-06-19T01:08:03 | Philip Resnik | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | This paper's primary goal is to provoke thoughtful discussion about the
relationship between bias and fundamental properties of large language models.
We do this by seeking to convince the reader that harmful biases are an
inevitable consequence arising from the design of any large language model as
LLMs are currently formulated. To the extent that this is true, it suggests
that the problem of harmful bias cannot be properly addressed without a serious
reconsideration of AI driven by LLMs, going back to the foundational
assumptions underlying their design. | [
-0.3228486478,
-0.8969804049,
0.677805841,
0.3196083009,
-0.0880879387,
-0.3244434297,
-0.4304005802,
-0.5717631578,
-0.00592389,
0.9753312469,
-0.3302936554,
-0.0815340206,
-0.6798105836,
-0.2170664668,
-0.533827424,
1.0926146507,
0.1560637057,
0.3439198732,
-0.2411016077,
-0.0133847091,
-0.3282885849,
-0.6746526361,
-0.7118885517,
-0.6057041883,
0.5978706479,
0.0271811318,
1.0216773748,
0.509951055,
0.3817397356,
0.325057596,
-0.2783288062,
-0.4174572527,
-0.6334171295,
0.4982423484,
-0.3494136631,
-0.791444242,
-0.3903371692,
0.0785144642,
0.8535519838,
0.9158818722,
0.2933700383,
0.0995109156,
0.226079911,
0.8539062738,
-0.252543211,
0.0797939599,
-0.6367504597,
-0.0116908755,
-0.3099037707,
0.053426832,
-0.6197187304,
-0.2246994823,
0.2349564433,
-0.1506218314,
0.0709753856,
0.1114752814,
0.6243938208,
0.2100037336,
-0.723500073,
-0.427064389,
-1.0065735579,
1.1225361824,
-0.7472108603,
0.2944864333,
0.2621109486,
0.0816384479,
-0.1201752275,
-0.1455488205,
-0.5111012459,
-0.4727310836,
0.2752230167,
-0.2904313505,
-0.0529014952,
0.1558320224,
0.5200231075,
0.3801758885,
-0.2876971662,
0.3698927164,
-0.309741348,
0.0048204465,
0.8041493893,
0.3545855284,
0.3725684583,
0.1819936931,
-0.1002061814,
0.2715671062,
-1.0595532656,
-0.3430936337,
0.7047845125,
0.2555447519,
-0.0108879227,
0.5600327849,
0.1681824625,
0.4901506901,
0.0485329144,
-0.2705340087,
0.2047100365,
-0.1025691107,
-0.1942537725,
-0.0037152839,
0.7203419209,
0.5163257718,
0.8024052382,
-0.1432018727,
-0.0496739782,
0.0444595329,
0.3632579148,
-0.6967480779,
0.3256881535,
0.3630276918,
-0.4051120281,
-0.4244886339,
-0.0403967053,
-0.8723469377,
-0.5375598073,
-0.4066113532,
0.1802119315,
0.1507124454,
-0.369926393,
0.0690295175,
0.1228921264,
0.3611983061,
0.2860209942,
-0.7374843359,
0.2199893147,
0.9684910178,
0.4166580141,
-0.0933396593,
-0.2731497586,
-0.1722389609,
0.2218591422,
-0.4727364182,
0.5775374174,
-0.553794086,
-0.6243241429,
0.2662039995,
0.0459850654,
0.5643783808,
-0.644215405,
0.8107670546,
-0.4632835984,
0.2573099732,
-0.76434201,
-0.4061097205,
-0.2474099845,
0.137828663,
-0.5771693587,
0.4209573567,
-0.2734543681,
-1.0085456371,
0.364851594,
-0.4213000238,
-0.7302895784,
-0.2712233067,
-0.1804288924,
-0.3482459784,
0.2191247642,
-0.1436627805,
0.2994714379,
-0.6660010815,
0.8047414422,
-0.5873900652,
-0.1240606755,
0.4788405299,
-0.7514966726,
0.9685565829,
0.3015397787,
-0.5445682406,
0.2104222178,
-0.3312023282,
-0.2261457145,
0.1928463578,
-0.589305222,
-0.5340713859,
0.3721008897,
0.0049863798,
0.4133978486,
0.1467223614,
-0.3423541188,
0.1436941326,
-0.4030386209,
0.3975719213,
1.0869436264,
-0.2856081724,
0.8009842038,
-0.4385003746,
0.4571162462,
0.1077273116,
0.3012304604,
0.0408574902,
-0.3198571503,
-0.834967196,
0.0422197282,
0.0741924569,
0.3388028741,
-0.2829991281,
0.3746140301,
-0.1945481896,
-0.2523440123,
-0.2862663269,
0.2576438785,
0.468429178,
0.3207393289,
-0.1307979971,
-0.1643301696,
-0.5495738983,
-1.306547761,
-0.4212119877,
-0.1285864711,
0.1362231225,
0.472050786,
0.5133048892,
-0.4104117751,
0.6151614785,
-0.2919100523,
-0.1494875252,
-0.2221713215,
-0.2922909856,
0.0861444399,
0.4484160841,
0.7197457552,
-0.6056787968,
-0.3458526433,
-0.3121475279,
-0.8322275877,
-0.4032345414,
0.0931398124,
-0.1640373766,
0.1455789506,
0.5298124552,
-0.9070783257,
0.0801771209,
0.4598476291,
-0.3660639822,
0.6959370375,
0.2203173488,
-0.3281773627,
-1.083026886,
-0.0329378098,
0.2920757532,
0.0317288674,
-0.5570566654,
0.1592610776,
-0.4775038064,
-0.0525562838,
-0.5180683732,
0.8039373159,
-0.4466932118,
-0.1019678265,
-0.5575416684,
0.0575897954,
0.1344302446,
-0.0239869691,
-0.1307494342,
0.5808377862,
0.7065099478,
-0.7626971006,
0.395642072,
-0.0159880109,
-0.2207441777,
0.4982512295,
-0.6872560978,
-0.0842391178,
-0.3157350421,
0.455594033,
-0.6525694728,
0.0183860231,
0.0759492218,
-0.240639165,
0.4657612741,
0.0462109149,
-0.380307883,
-0.6559275985,
-0.2867388129,
0.489672035,
0.5402598381,
-0.3993567824,
0.4196320474,
0.8242417574,
-0.0313199684,
-0.7442346811,
-0.9010851383,
-0.0801902935,
-0.4053145349,
-0.8046232462,
-0.2111670673,
0.056189578,
-1.0468585491,
-0.090543054,
0.0264261607,
0.2371958643,
0.0400698856,
0.3992814124,
0.3260152638,
-0.3340962231,
0.2543152869,
-0.1602466851,
-0.0285823885,
0.564352572,
-0.2606664002,
0.6764907241,
0.1318428367,
-0.2926199138,
-0.1131137311,
0.4920617044,
0.9329887629,
0.0395288952,
0.6622666717,
0.0763843209,
-0.1729455888,
-0.2436911762,
-0.7853260636,
-0.0554585084,
-0.4826703668,
0.6769388318,
-0.1255980134,
-1.0304088593,
0.5955883265,
0.199734658,
0.0858732238,
0.4991911054,
0.9526814222,
0.1006873399,
1.2540125847,
0.4997213483,
-0.7128232718,
0.3884298503,
-0.1092492864,
0.219978556,
-1.0224123001,
-0.1259003878,
-0.702660799,
-0.2056515962,
-0.7066088915,
-0.1489840448,
-0.0010858804,
-0.2989210784,
-0.6970847845,
-0.305660814,
-0.3317368031,
0.4537188709,
0.6216537952,
-0.0219591241,
-0.0638139024,
0.0160608552,
-0.0501481518,
-0.0157782156,
-0.4696497321,
-0.8498558402,
1.2581379414,
0.730448842,
1.3052254915,
0.0046444153,
0.1082443967,
0.1669452339,
0.3954085112,
-0.9081948996,
0.5365796685,
0.0403360352,
-1.392403841,
-0.2418274432,
-0.3495637178,
-0.7882302403,
0.4250434339,
-0.023675045,
-0.6890526414,
-0.0172204319,
0.2366261184,
-0.014899645,
0.5203192234,
-0.6196502447,
0.4347619712,
-0.4654468298,
-0.8895910978,
-0.3442153633,
-0.5154254436,
0.8360995054,
-0.0656183809,
0.5061970353,
-0.0725166872,
0.2022954971,
0.8741878867,
-0.3571410775,
1.0233597755,
-0.0920759887,
-0.4405362606,
0.438102752,
0.3415113389,
0.2617120743,
-0.0452322811,
-0.1805351824,
0.1369486153,
-0.2962864935,
-0.4522171021,
-0.0879146308,
0.9852669835,
-0.9444878101,
-1.1806339025,
-0.5857704282,
-0.6249750257,
-0.26793015,
0.2260859907,
0.1768865585,
0.2433819622,
-0.3491819501,
0.1219120026,
0.7498808503,
-0.5837913752,
0.2862030268,
0.3645219505,
-0.7124329805,
0.1591426283,
0.6399694085,
0.1503564864,
0.5657424331,
-0.0417751372,
0.1943365037,
-0.0406169258,
-0.5312862396,
-0.0932462439,
0.4641597867,
-0.6649733186,
0.1853820533,
-0.5502986908,
-0.204471916,
-0.3213273883,
-0.193994984,
-0.3863598704,
-0.0669497475,
-0.3463124335,
-0.1287078857,
-0.0842853561,
1.0594636202,
-0.0304835197,
0.3653369844,
-0.5522150993,
0.0911050439,
0.4432424605,
0.2725554109,
0.319726944,
-0.7477463484,
-0.0440877564,
-0.0475273021,
-0.5629268289,
-0.5698139668,
0.209908545,
-0.3180664182,
0.6109799147,
0.9033877254,
-0.1797521859,
-0.0170254428,
-0.6548703313,
0.7713218927,
0.1928105205,
-0.8770824671,
0.3136522472,
-0.5137894154,
0.1572440267,
0.2033191621,
0.4274455011,
-0.4234824479,
-0.4603628516,
-0.6595731378,
-0.6889311075,
0.5858288407,
-0.2898874581,
0.6434892416,
-0.2160792798,
0.2181467116,
0.2058461308,
0.287976265,
-0.9182063937,
-0.2613545358,
0.1716612428,
0.0662204698,
-0.1600795835,
-0.9760488868,
-0.2033343911,
-0.0754579902,
0.8204148412,
0.0204546656,
0.2176363766,
-0.1002568677,
0.0495931692,
-0.4760778248,
0.359477669,
0.6981639266,
0.8805169463,
0.0708623901,
0.3117977977,
0.0205839016,
-0.3143663108,
0.1683212221,
-0.3663910031,
-0.4810428619,
-0.3600760102,
0.5969156623,
0.903958559,
-0.0867701098,
-0.5015650392,
0.5446839333,
0.2918275595,
-0.1119714007,
-0.4367303252,
0.0395057872,
0.2403295487,
0.2145425826,
0.2639816701,
-0.0225587804,
-0.1375032812,
-0.9225662351,
0.0924498215,
0.919378221,
-0.3305554092,
-0.4238998592,
0.7218248844,
0.4008263648,
-0.2753760815,
0.6242984533,
0.2303587645,
-0.8277172446,
0.7205833793,
0.543066442,
0.71302706,
-0.3555828035,
-0.0457809418,
0.2893592715,
0.5655252337,
-0.0802842155,
0.0513357706,
0.4600664973,
-0.9328994751,
-0.5551304221,
-0.6379154325,
-0.1298748255,
0.332246542,
-0.3047477007,
0.2470904887,
-0.5880217552,
-0.3100272119,
-0.0695844293,
-0.2606411576,
-0.3135460913,
0.2040196508,
0.4667233825,
0.798735559,
-1.0085891485,
0.7266631126,
0.222149685,
-0.4307101667,
-0.485021323,
0.1221629307,
-0.0087687783,
-0.8521485329,
1.0880194902,
-0.0019254478,
0.1382276267,
-0.4349314868,
-0.8303852677,
-0.9230943322,
0.4046778083,
0.5714618564,
-0.7324447036,
-0.3794386685,
0.2083699405,
0.3282774091,
-0.3740797937,
0.1344576329,
0.3370436728,
0.5443266034,
-0.0693598762,
-1.0385359526,
0.1366039366,
0.1596232504,
0.162108779,
0.1639977843,
-0.8900589943,
0.9181574583,
-0.2383464426,
0.1042500958,
-0.2547225952,
0.3927702308,
0.0149996094,
-0.0297200065,
0.1287395507,
0.4941138029,
0.3763385117,
-0.1396124661,
1.298120141,
-0.1205610782,
0.144394666,
0.9181272388,
-0.5960993171,
0.3333996832,
0.5561202765,
-0.4452712536,
0.1497888416,
0.3014743924,
0.0923541114,
0.2701207101,
0.6684400439,
-0.3330307603,
-0.1952015162,
-0.112345174,
-0.5014194846,
0.4055664539,
0.417770803,
-0.7950552702,
-0.0293291882,
-0.0177279655,
0.3934441805,
0.1245214865,
-0.4903030694,
0.5816114545,
0.409440726,
-0.6996864676,
0.2150270194,
0.0246713106,
0.8210340738,
-0.3314034939,
0.3598978221,
0.0517702959,
0.3296136558,
-0.2186886668,
-0.9081232548,
0.5365689993,
-0.2586907446,
-0.4372682571,
0.029765347,
0.830031991,
-0.0944625735,
-0.5139386654,
0.4639619291,
0.5616117716,
-0.1288366467,
-0.0455961712,
-0.8112449646,
0.6083189249,
0.1382869035,
-0.5257294774,
0.4194265008,
0.3848924339,
-0.1254602969,
0.9499334097,
0.4450347722,
0.179233551,
0.1137152389,
-0.0355428904,
0.8737231493,
-0.5968973637,
-0.2332657427,
-1.2227144241,
0.1597517878,
0.0559740551,
-0.1216473356,
0.6512497067,
0.5040177703,
0.4984327257,
0.013834836,
1.1238059998,
0.2280698121,
0.5074554086,
-0.5664729476,
0.8129954338,
-0.2964296937,
0.3265374303,
-0.2655574977,
-1.2777088881,
-0.2826132476,
0.6504137516,
-0.7977962494,
0.6358662248,
0.5999875069,
0.6261153221,
0.1675840616,
-0.0496223345,
0.3520071507,
0.7917030454,
0.3597605228,
0.4500489831,
1.1165755987,
0.0049285139,
0.1463549733,
-0.0087081371,
-0.2932579517,
-0.2214332968,
-0.7813373208,
-1.1590064764,
-0.3620342314,
-0.1986298114,
-0.6712752581,
-0.06538672,
0.7620073557,
0.5128813386,
-0.8065619469,
-0.3989356458,
0.0159520432,
0.3880276382,
0.5132636428,
-0.2708723843,
0.1714618653,
-0.0807459503,
-0.7960656285,
-0.2606072724,
0.1498709768,
-0.1076422036,
-0.9227500558,
-0.0157757439,
0.000728269,
0.2375717461,
0.8017046452,
0.2994857132,
-0.881388545,
-0.5053103566,
-0.3617981076,
-0.4129347205,
-0.0603770688,
0.8045881987,
-0.4231012464,
0.1084524542,
0.426258862,
0.5337651372,
0.0458568446,
-0.3556707203,
0.8759675026,
-0.2376418561,
0.2598620653,
0.2147418261,
0.5663331151,
0.370819211,
-0.4149971604,
0.2129575759,
0.2490343451,
-0.752882123,
-0.9516875148,
0.536642611,
-0.7516386509,
-0.4577617347,
1.6680408716,
0.2515971363,
-0.3452453911,
-0.0049292855,
-0.4649500251,
0.1353146285,
-0.195131436,
0.6904015541,
0.9879028201,
0.1663774401,
0.0630361587,
-0.7676827908,
0.2954353392,
0.3635956943,
-0.4555067718,
0.2866472602,
0.595471561,
0.4356813431,
0.0983860269,
0.4907825589,
-0.312191397,
-0.1057580262,
-0.0306939371,
0.1337697506,
0.3396634161,
-0.142096296,
-0.333422333,
0.1276882142,
0.6245270967,
0.3792085946
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13133v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13133v1 | PathoLM: Identifying pathogenicity from the DNA sequence through the Genome Foundation Model | 2024-06-19T00:53:48 | 2024-06-19T00:53:48 | Sajib Acharjee Dip, Uddip Acharjee Shuvo, Tran Chau, Haoqiu Song, Petra Choi, Xuan Wang, Liqing Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG, q-bio.GN | Pathogen identification is pivotal in diagnosing, treating, and preventing
diseases, crucial for controlling infections and safeguarding public health.
Traditional alignment-based methods, though widely used, are computationally
intense and reliant on extensive reference databases, often failing to detect
novel pathogens due to their low sensitivity and specificity. Similarly,
conventional machine learning techniques, while promising, require large
annotated datasets and extensive feature engineering and are prone to
overfitting. Addressing these challenges, we introduce PathoLM, a cutting-edge
pathogen language model optimized for the identification of pathogenicity in
bacterial and viral sequences. Leveraging the strengths of pre-trained DNA
models such as the Nucleotide Transformer, PathoLM requires minimal data for
fine-tuning, thereby enhancing pathogen detection capabilities. It effectively
captures a broader genomic context, significantly improving the identification
of novel and divergent pathogens. We developed a comprehensive data set
comprising approximately 30 species of viruses and bacteria, including ESKAPEE
pathogens, seven notably virulent bacterial strains resistant to antibiotics.
Additionally, we curated a species classification dataset centered specifically
on the ESKAPEE group. In comparative assessments, PathoLM dramatically
outperforms existing models like DciPatho, demonstrating robust zero-shot and
few-shot capabilities. Furthermore, we expanded PathoLM-Sp for ESKAPEE species
classification, where it showed superior performance compared to other advanced
deep learning methods, despite the complexities of the task. | [
-0.1129891053,
-1.0177028179,
0.430532217,
-0.2413973063,
-0.4460289478,
0.1929396838,
0.0197977927,
-0.2926064134,
0.2350900024,
0.5377191901,
-0.4116646051,
-0.5825084448,
-0.9184706807,
0.2031926215,
-0.2989578247,
0.9079711437,
0.3553864658,
-0.0450843014,
-0.2928966284,
-0.2100957781,
-0.2160546035,
-0.4184394479,
-0.2284436971,
-0.2225488275,
0.4492489696,
0.5286346674,
0.6105091572,
0.7640290856,
0.9629670978,
0.1771628708,
-0.2503218949,
0.2151156813,
-0.3321445286,
0.2594614327,
-0.0266138334,
-0.2469663471,
-0.2184336185,
-0.0446169078,
0.2375007719,
0.9940031767,
-0.0853156671,
0.4458656013,
-0.3746086657,
0.6737501025,
-0.5865935087,
-0.1253973246,
-0.1790967137,
0.4453577697,
-0.4947417974,
-0.2154220641,
-0.7168316841,
-0.3024216592,
0.2163750082,
-0.6172127128,
-0.1232568249,
-0.3630459309,
0.5026319027,
0.3203727007,
-0.6890614033,
-0.1168587729,
-0.9624962807,
0.3413081765,
-0.5442265868,
0.5019683242,
-0.0705346018,
0.3490968049,
-0.404723078,
-0.5444117785,
-0.0818634331,
-0.137616396,
0.2529037893,
0.035632696,
-0.3642014265,
-0.0659540221,
0.2908431292,
0.2639512122,
-0.9846758246,
-0.1545643508,
-0.5584791303,
-0.1862607747,
0.4431506693,
0.0687486976,
0.502012372,
-0.2786106765,
-0.5750980377,
-0.1847257614,
-0.6114981771,
0.3104501665,
0.3780810833,
0.3892904818,
0.1194258481,
0.3230572939,
-0.0148227056,
0.9020451903,
-0.038635768,
-0.3537400663,
0.37001127,
-0.1184053123,
-0.4468281567,
0.124736689,
0.5694480538,
0.0151846632,
-0.3137768507,
-0.0516132452,
0.2723658681,
-0.1828344464,
0.4954555333,
-0.8526230454,
-0.4181810021,
0.2727163434,
-0.4438706934,
-0.5017727613,
-0.0306012258,
-0.8547144532,
-0.6223338842,
-0.1023213863,
0.1880765706,
-0.5844843388,
-0.3657488525,
-0.0139377601,
-0.202857241,
0.3732101619,
0.2096470892,
-0.5730116367,
0.2532912195,
0.7849776149,
0.9744246602,
-0.4133099914,
0.1329943389,
-0.5451065898,
0.1683918387,
-0.354377687,
0.4828767478,
-0.7392892838,
-0.5578383803,
-0.4279341102,
-0.1017775461,
0.0456942916,
-0.6148468852,
0.5630108118,
-0.2663491666,
-0.5603604317,
-0.0971076116,
-0.5657802224,
-0.3175046444,
0.1147049963,
-0.6581306458,
0.7671205997,
-0.0338283516,
-0.7767679691,
0.2843766212,
-0.2451901585,
-0.7139590383,
0.3629765809,
0.1257556826,
-0.7616369724,
0.1206601337,
0.001388658,
0.5555542111,
-0.2145411372,
0.5831208825,
-0.584379077,
-0.098189868,
-0.0800060779,
-0.215634644,
0.8960055709,
0.3989546299,
0.0816721022,
0.196423769,
-0.8128719926,
-0.3489598632,
0.1788755655,
0.0603145882,
-0.4212569594,
-0.0124163898,
-0.1146439016,
-0.1239423305,
-0.2212642133,
-0.5233377814,
0.4941080213,
-0.5475751758,
0.4310306907,
0.65939641,
0.1120265201,
0.4290286601,
-0.247682184,
0.8021634221,
0.2083335966,
0.6953615546,
-0.2157651484,
-0.8664126396,
-0.1546193212,
-0.2777163684,
0.115560919,
0.7581022382,
-0.2566993535,
0.1617626846,
-0.3732993901,
-1.0208725929,
0.0502119176,
0.0290517416,
0.2031171322,
0.8018659353,
0.457334727,
-0.5407012701,
-0.5872900486,
-0.6267183423,
-0.022700239,
-0.271515131,
0.2141877115,
0.3824594617,
0.486130327,
-0.3008680046,
0.7903733253,
-0.6469080448,
0.0684746131,
-0.3185459971,
-0.0390473232,
0.5312675238,
0.3665359318,
0.2223636359,
-1.044066906,
-0.3143450022,
0.3612144291,
-0.7102077007,
-0.0219762214,
0.3746604323,
0.0224663336,
-0.2780702114,
0.3583469987,
-0.4938340187,
0.3118668497,
0.3806170821,
-0.1703195721,
0.3122667968,
0.0999722928,
-0.0061098929,
-1.0862236023,
0.3802261055,
-0.0886446461,
-0.263621062,
-1.0343042612,
0.4050055444,
0.1022903249,
-0.5149103999,
-0.5911753178,
0.2673571706,
-0.0557529964,
0.2015707344,
0.3125817478,
-0.5957636833,
0.0157325249,
0.1453579068,
0.1215038151,
0.3208189309,
0.695763886,
-0.4066651165,
0.4586387277,
0.1177415997,
0.1835315526,
0.1686396897,
-0.4906570613,
0.3118039072,
0.0242641326,
0.3237244785,
-0.6399454474,
-0.2158489078,
0.6409041286,
-0.3931954801,
0.5103751421,
-0.4948986471,
-0.1455625892,
-0.5674581528,
-0.2761569917,
0.7264067531,
0.5996285081,
-0.3933550417,
1.1244468689,
0.4548598528,
-0.1100160107,
-0.7531755567,
-0.2515423596,
-0.1037922278,
-0.5376722217,
-0.5341562033,
0.1116978526,
-0.0232914183,
-0.1098040715,
-0.3738361597,
-0.3780168891,
-0.1646324843,
0.3845356107,
0.6551628113,
0.3716985583,
-0.2554817796,
0.3078693151,
-0.1221290529,
-0.1553983092,
-0.1329094023,
-0.5635325909,
0.2969032824,
0.0033239392,
-0.5093021989,
-0.0300089195,
0.3228884041,
0.6034496427,
-0.3541883528,
0.2312027365,
0.4145182669,
-0.5665612817,
-0.1490053087,
-0.0792137384,
-0.0613589063,
-0.404437989,
0.3471960723,
-0.2863221765,
-0.4273564517,
0.3238440156,
-0.5072112679,
-0.2677852213,
0.129106313,
0.2931794524,
0.0569548979,
0.3079597652,
0.6022207141,
-0.3375582695,
-0.2365527153,
-0.1223959848,
0.606259644,
-0.4927157164,
-0.4316668808,
-0.4656206071,
0.1833754182,
-0.3248302639,
-0.6414711475,
0.3109706938,
0.2770300806,
-0.1694414318,
0.4419422448,
-0.6477476358,
0.2365042865,
0.4206638634,
0.2383871078,
0.1079271436,
-0.4697242975,
-0.2327046543,
0.3880663514,
-0.7195545435,
-0.535202682,
1.3619554043,
0.4863519967,
0.5800614357,
0.4909166694,
0.9456394911,
0.546970427,
0.1327200532,
-0.8381964564,
0.3194261193,
-0.3877043128,
-0.4275147915,
-0.2856086195,
-0.2905841172,
-0.8273946643,
-0.2983918786,
-0.0859268159,
-0.7058125138,
0.3233715594,
0.2802792788,
-0.6768580079,
0.3883311152,
-0.6267693639,
1.0196089745,
-0.1559285522,
-0.0403251648,
0.3248530924,
-1.0590771437,
0.4558496773,
-0.1559109092,
0.2873123884,
-0.1571616381,
0.307710886,
0.5474011302,
-0.5869067907,
0.8936154246,
0.0489187017,
-0.0072464175,
0.0559918433,
0.3037872314,
0.2619619071,
0.2719751596,
0.0763552636,
0.3497034311,
-0.2821885049,
-0.3525777757,
-0.3123064637,
0.2958458364,
-0.4526182711,
-0.7930266261,
-0.473629117,
-0.2898698449,
-0.0661840588,
0.3307254016,
0.2986994088,
0.5867568254,
-0.3021369278,
0.0096818861,
1.1299750805,
-0.4229920208,
0.2934584618,
0.2355597168,
-0.0759271383,
-0.1684022099,
1.0498691797,
-0.2545226812,
0.3248503804,
0.7243905663,
0.3557037413,
-0.175319761,
-0.640650332,
-0.7035350204,
-0.4784552455,
-0.7538927197,
-0.5667318106,
-0.6603305936,
-0.2335900068,
-0.5742960572,
-0.0994606465,
-0.2556461692,
-0.1617918313,
-0.2927216589,
-0.4086413085,
0.7501547337,
0.7217059135,
-0.1388008296,
0.0036129893,
-0.8425631523,
0.2915089726,
0.1713396162,
-0.0921950117,
-0.2903137505,
-0.3922054768,
0.1316820979,
-0.1284864843,
-0.3526026905,
-1.2856057882,
0.6527497768,
0.4395168126,
0.3299670517,
0.7167854309,
-0.0739540681,
0.2943283319,
-0.6172955632,
0.6914101839,
0.1372713149,
-0.8181778789,
1.1404081583,
-0.2506485879,
0.0286641717,
0.3180506825,
0.6453380585,
-0.506084919,
-0.4080792069,
-0.4119708538,
-0.9997243285,
0.3940602541,
0.0882891864,
-0.2736627162,
-0.0329373293,
0.1609164178,
0.3417042196,
-0.2570089102,
-0.4548048377,
-0.5881922841,
-0.367167443,
-0.2673088312,
-0.0897008553,
-0.0037788227,
-0.1692485511,
-0.3254873157,
0.5419026613,
-0.0038621218,
0.1074528396,
0.3451569378,
-0.3739101291,
-0.2623713911,
0.1097716838,
0.6466822028,
0.4651589692,
-0.2812148929,
0.337516129,
-0.0188095719,
-0.8752381802,
0.5035266876,
0.5813788176,
-0.3262790442,
0.0251226611,
0.7021457553,
0.5228322148,
-0.2857968211,
-0.7590708733,
0.6197968721,
0.2006906718,
0.1628057361,
-0.1330999583,
0.1545582712,
0.0066983826,
0.2938834727,
0.6558546424,
0.5404160619,
0.5812265277,
-0.2084317952,
0.4432270825,
0.3546008468,
-0.4692150652,
-0.3814077377,
0.4954350591,
0.1691755503,
-0.384234786,
0.6204741001,
0.0122475242,
-0.5838651061,
1.1634750366,
0.4688143432,
0.6445435882,
-0.7546310425,
0.4038255513,
0.3507504165,
0.2552134097,
0.2982979119,
-0.1366626173,
-0.0684683695,
-0.7428783178,
-0.0852647722,
-0.8658723831,
-0.1893644929,
0.0951731503,
-0.6758579016,
0.2917170227,
-0.446852535,
-0.0942685679,
0.4291310608,
-0.1416184902,
-0.1925481707,
0.1799930036,
0.3391907811,
0.9857611656,
-1.4729892015,
0.8223293424,
0.4565388858,
-0.3897628784,
-0.8310938478,
-0.2322102487,
0.3493354023,
-0.6753142476,
0.6242406368,
0.4958822131,
0.0078613395,
-0.0981152579,
-0.0681894422,
-0.7973700762,
1.1283613443,
0.3353526294,
-0.7810816765,
0.2815187275,
0.1489540935,
0.3118124604,
-0.1718238145,
0.0569426566,
0.2807849348,
0.3327166736,
0.1319744289,
-0.7202794552,
0.1295954585,
-0.4782367051,
0.045078516,
0.6066862941,
-0.2394784689,
0.5461087227,
-0.5648462772,
-0.0734265521,
-0.046388302,
0.3287504613,
0.3271415532,
0.3758631051,
0.1642982364,
0.9787914157,
0.8992961645,
-0.1700983644,
1.0065205097,
-0.059039969,
0.0504748896,
1.0125851631,
-0.3478651047,
0.5552966595,
0.5155242682,
-0.2153470814,
0.2137758881,
1.0423510075,
-0.2217503935,
0.5592438579,
0.4102592766,
-0.1871577501,
-0.1920593381,
-0.1189414114,
-0.475825727,
0.2446231693,
0.3664070368,
-0.382122457,
0.2227814198,
0.3383367956,
-0.3912856579,
-0.187743336,
-0.390188694,
0.659933269,
0.0814803019,
-0.0791623518,
0.1182468757,
-0.2867422998,
0.2664201558,
-0.5033432841,
-0.2487645149,
-0.18337363,
0.0068429122,
-0.071822457,
-0.4021358192,
0.3177133203,
-0.4109098911,
-0.2646198273,
-0.0318134129,
0.7528821826,
-0.1476960331,
-0.6756330132,
0.2958807051,
0.2995794415,
0.0158080645,
0.3086965382,
-0.298481971,
-0.2188453376,
-0.2550912201,
-0.1375185251,
-0.3230660558,
0.2935243249,
-0.0157948807,
0.7782998681,
0.7407938242,
0.2344535738,
-0.1134851724,
0.0704105198,
0.5846181512,
-0.3243122101,
-0.2215714306,
-1.1450830698,
0.2429446131,
-0.0401853994,
-0.2517387569,
0.5915470719,
0.6838200688,
0.8808442354,
-0.1984028071,
0.5925135612,
0.0885067433,
0.2584384978,
-0.1583152711,
0.4799466431,
-0.261523217,
0.1766440123,
-0.3530368209,
-0.3663368523,
-0.5185201168,
0.2229745984,
0.0294800047,
-0.2138711661,
0.5461627841,
0.5508024096,
-0.1502764523,
-0.0861728713,
0.0568876565,
0.3133146465,
0.2176932096,
0.7022792101,
0.785923183,
-0.2385499179,
0.2651045918,
-0.4039503634,
-0.2688000202,
-0.2172646672,
-1.0155309439,
-0.6612374187,
-0.4612796903,
-0.2916488051,
-0.1685537547,
0.620922029,
0.8890890479,
0.9534068704,
-0.8895644546,
0.1314592361,
-0.3777759969,
0.1389937848,
-0.3352332115,
-0.1238583624,
0.3135222793,
0.1378320754,
-0.1318218708,
0.4180235267,
0.6482443213,
0.12633726,
0.0349549018,
-0.1185478792,
-0.130913496,
-0.1499656588,
0.4226188064,
0.5338073969,
-0.7413108945,
-0.0605939291,
0.2025225312,
-0.0841624215,
0.0780127496,
0.5385340452,
-0.5694928169,
0.601226449,
0.3172669709,
0.8781422973,
0.1882676035,
-0.1180751175,
0.7882696986,
-0.4776274264,
0.1158445626,
0.6069889069,
0.2353789508,
0.3338611126,
-0.8133757114,
0.6591183543,
0.4605233371,
-0.100013487,
-0.8781531453,
0.4591485262,
-0.9843433499,
-0.3860537112,
0.9737361073,
-0.2416150868,
-0.2612263262,
-0.2071817517,
0.2806656361,
0.2831688821,
-0.1911972463,
0.2074264884,
0.3524616361,
-0.1064173281,
-0.0702420473,
-0.0821240172,
0.5031929016,
0.178986758,
-0.6863405108,
-0.1572508067,
0.1639227718,
0.2199928761,
0.3206898868,
0.5516844392,
0.0057460773,
0.2864804864,
-0.2962674499,
-0.0409425944,
-0.0785453692,
-0.7134329081,
-0.5129299164,
0.2267140001,
0.0974828079,
-0.0149428099
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13131v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13131v2 | When Parts are Greater Than Sums: Individual LLM Components Can Outperform Full Models | 2024-06-19T00:48:44 | 2024-06-24T15:13:13 | Ting-Yun Chang, Jesse Thomason, Robin Jia | cs.CL | cs.CL | This paper studies in-context learning (ICL) by decomposing the output of
large language models into the individual contributions of attention heads and
MLPs (components). We observe curious components: good-performing ones that
individually do well on a classification task, even when the model performs
poorly; bad-performing ones that do much worse than chance; and label-biased
components that always predict the same label. We find that component
accuracies are well-correlated across different demonstration sets and
perturbations of prompt templates, even when the full-model accuracy varies
greatly. Based on our findings, we propose component reweighting, which learns
to linearly re-scale the component activations from a few labeled examples.
Given 24 labeled examples, our method improves by an average of 6.0% accuracy
points over 24-shot ICL across 8 tasks on Llama-2-7B. Overall, this paper both
enriches our understanding of ICL and provides a practical method for
improvement by examining model internals. | [
-0.1814564615,
-0.3853815794,
0.5331460834,
0.1774830669,
-0.4062541425,
0.087821275,
-0.3399288654,
-0.3566958308,
-0.1446103603,
0.3429383934,
-0.4735248089,
-0.342455864,
-0.6151165366,
-0.0134808002,
-0.460347265,
1.1598594189,
0.0520902425,
0.133323878,
-0.5859152079,
-0.4219333231,
-0.5696339607,
-0.5342540741,
-0.6343916059,
-0.7496400476,
0.6034702063,
0.726751864,
0.0910897106,
0.4347095788,
0.3385434449,
0.2518214881,
-0.0493445657,
0.2149803638,
-0.6549201608,
0.0968874097,
-0.1044516861,
-0.6302314997,
-0.2656798065,
0.0418984368,
0.7527706027,
0.7446283698,
0.0337394364,
0.3228488564,
0.6188839078,
0.5414580703,
-0.6371203661,
0.5219198465,
-0.6857057214,
0.0019546577,
0.031024063,
-0.1882023215,
-0.9367673397,
0.1719723642,
0.0845809579,
-0.3877369463,
0.000367544,
0.0348101147,
0.597507596,
0.5326961875,
-0.5948927999,
-0.1795466542,
-0.4687235057,
1.1704512835,
-0.7867565751,
0.3867395222,
0.3422897458,
0.1524953395,
-0.2549044788,
-0.695679903,
-0.2513575554,
-0.1609633416,
-0.0262081847,
0.0202622786,
-0.1318150014,
0.0270440374,
0.0938850567,
0.2543382049,
-0.1144265682,
0.370385468,
-0.1509471089,
-0.0210857559,
0.4594177902,
0.0270186812,
0.2558507025,
0.2325583696,
-0.4262084067,
-0.2343744189,
-1.0986834764,
0.2328353673,
-0.1010148227,
0.4665102959,
-0.2280539423,
0.5101032853,
-0.1001361087,
0.7324571609,
0.4978393614,
-0.5103285313,
0.2072601467,
-0.2903968394,
-0.4727870822,
0.2345598638,
0.2681139112,
0.2265039831,
0.1417000443,
-0.2534694374,
-0.2173360735,
-0.2705681324,
0.1333292574,
-0.739300549,
-0.2720301151,
0.1023386717,
-0.3557861447,
-0.1004886776,
-0.0070654526,
-0.011792127,
-0.248277247,
-0.8888433576,
0.5020027757,
-0.2242091149,
0.2168277502,
-0.0114784772,
0.2369739711,
0.2172398418,
0.4252820313,
-0.7542232275,
0.2719739377,
0.7748360634,
0.6116868854,
-0.3583939672,
-0.3885178566,
-0.7814516425,
0.0493688174,
-0.425445646,
0.9579166174,
-0.2798052728,
-0.1291366071,
-0.2062870562,
-0.0193330646,
0.227755934,
-0.8309788108,
0.2109366059,
-0.3542783558,
-0.0150060942,
-0.6345744133,
-0.742539227,
-0.2079289407,
0.1613518596,
-0.4146303236,
0.9104556441,
0.157797873,
-0.7619083524,
0.7800533772,
-0.0386160053,
-0.3637011349,
-0.0601260439,
-0.3818696141,
-0.4486978352,
0.508962214,
0.2094162852,
0.8102273941,
-0.2725685537,
0.2530585229,
-0.2169208974,
-0.4954083562,
0.5030496716,
-0.2946982682,
0.7853323221,
-0.193331033,
-0.2980343103,
0.4223707914,
-0.7018901706,
-0.090096198,
-0.2433068007,
-0.6304883957,
-0.4331488013,
0.0184292737,
-0.1013362855,
0.2616885006,
-0.1099245846,
-0.5677083135,
0.1236737594,
-0.5448276997,
0.2411314547,
0.977966845,
-0.0371819921,
0.5599375367,
-0.3149698377,
0.2624715865,
0.3499807715,
-0.113571316,
-0.4001817405,
-0.4134061038,
-0.9752047062,
-0.3373642266,
0.1729872972,
0.1155923381,
-0.7994266748,
0.4174365103,
-0.182196781,
-0.327151984,
-0.3602180779,
0.2682938874,
0.5976352692,
1.0058504343,
0.3714547753,
-0.3860577345,
-0.1599752307,
-1.0680218935,
-0.0202224515,
-0.2213417292,
-0.2488016039,
0.1615175605,
0.3455056846,
0.0827790126,
0.9237692952,
-0.3040406406,
-0.2543674707,
-0.3442348242,
0.0894993693,
0.037792746,
0.3249458075,
0.4045277536,
-0.5471103787,
-0.7325842977,
0.0023404651,
-0.6607728004,
-0.2070606351,
0.0379299596,
0.1379556358,
0.1651897579,
0.7030876279,
-0.2658574283,
0.3131650984,
0.3573427498,
-0.3927970529,
0.4468751252,
-0.3153446019,
-0.2407471091,
-1.0536851883,
-0.2386966944,
0.2533534467,
-0.3478677869,
-0.5524293184,
0.3424211442,
0.3211891055,
0.236862272,
-0.7353784442,
0.5300481319,
-0.4445971251,
-0.3507418036,
-0.5678390265,
0.150424242,
0.0041106087,
0.6183641553,
-0.4309818149,
0.843711257,
0.3400861323,
-0.6308282018,
0.2094077766,
-0.2637911439,
-0.9026632309,
0.5261350274,
-0.4919032753,
0.0356226079,
-0.5389725566,
0.523347199,
-1.2529101372,
-0.2327014804,
-0.0033681309,
-0.081804812,
0.7649335861,
0.1985338777,
-0.4254950583,
0.0899754092,
-0.1964662671,
0.5886812806,
0.3128922582,
-0.7713216543,
0.4894396961,
0.4693033099,
0.0277801789,
-0.8208832741,
-0.860906899,
-0.0964566469,
-0.3910018802,
-0.0815877691,
0.5360335112,
-0.2004603148,
-0.38980335,
-0.0117250681,
-0.0841903016,
-0.0639758036,
0.1850714684,
0.1241370067,
-0.1486035287,
-0.215115577,
0.4916020334,
-0.0876696035,
-0.2472232282,
-0.1235058159,
-0.3123829067,
0.3647222221,
-0.062696889,
-0.4445359409,
-0.4908559322,
0.1815364212,
0.5751530528,
-0.0639108792,
0.5195187926,
0.2899035811,
-0.3875197768,
-0.4687346518,
-0.4240322709,
-0.3197607994,
-0.4030169845,
0.7356754541,
-0.3865871131,
-0.7900440097,
0.532114923,
0.2527293265,
0.2812255919,
0.3233797848,
0.6134773493,
-0.019346023,
0.9242892265,
1.0424870253,
-0.5239087343,
0.4506281316,
-0.235538587,
0.2055674642,
-1.0149151087,
-0.3284147084,
-0.264955461,
-0.520696938,
-0.169794634,
-0.6543177962,
0.4159086049,
0.0528679639,
-0.3110808432,
0.2106357068,
-0.3738356233,
0.6881500483,
0.5305826068,
0.4340529442,
0.3327685297,
0.0966121331,
-0.0425648428,
-0.2010151446,
-0.7312246561,
-0.1943794489,
1.1633379459,
0.3444826305,
0.9095554352,
0.057269346,
0.3360926807,
0.1311287582,
0.8121396303,
-1.0302166939,
0.3208826184,
-0.3093756735,
-0.2566319704,
-0.2997524738,
-0.1182856485,
-0.6192369461,
0.4379467964,
0.0571687184,
-0.8153324127,
0.2909519672,
0.2431401908,
-0.41164729,
0.2933598757,
-0.5247616768,
0.4963705242,
-0.2246532142,
-0.2643435597,
-0.2786465883,
-0.4909004867,
0.4667102695,
-0.1147372425,
-0.0847758427,
-0.0328790136,
-0.088799417,
0.4350534976,
-0.2002216727,
1.183068037,
0.0975363851,
-0.3024784923,
0.3694863915,
-0.1452568024,
0.3206857741,
-0.1373304427,
0.0864677727,
-0.0637465566,
-0.5066570044,
-0.4799292386,
-0.8242687583,
0.7610334158,
-0.7854076624,
-0.4709570706,
-0.0873351395,
-0.6432124972,
-0.2531679273,
-0.1101660207,
0.4085609913,
0.8971367478,
0.2348437905,
0.6649240255,
0.9772716761,
-0.2583331466,
0.4882941246,
0.3694019914,
-0.1646646708,
-0.1430983692,
0.9018799067,
0.3531885445,
0.4023090005,
0.8221309781,
0.1821754724,
-0.1204044074,
-0.3536202013,
-0.3906668723,
0.235736534,
-1.1713774204,
-0.4313580692,
-0.5687406659,
-0.0143332575,
-0.1683342904,
-0.1931018978,
-0.4552471638,
-0.2066036612,
-0.3607328534,
-0.3365199864,
-0.2959791124,
0.8843532801,
0.3376181424,
0.3192282617,
-0.2095150352,
-0.1977464408,
0.6584112644,
0.0675995126,
0.5334357619,
-0.7206189632,
-0.5535355806,
-0.0958582833,
-0.4047256708,
-0.5730337501,
0.2349176556,
0.2690719664,
0.6633759141,
0.6407676339,
-0.0750778168,
0.8155210018,
-0.513525486,
0.7936644554,
0.067542851,
-0.8821598291,
0.0362749361,
-0.0325782746,
0.8157609105,
0.4927878678,
0.1737858355,
-0.3483467996,
-0.5080062747,
-0.4789450467,
-0.9277539849,
0.6294780374,
-0.1806652248,
0.0501548983,
0.1264915019,
0.5475932956,
0.0539146215,
0.0750963613,
-1.0164107084,
-0.2716087401,
0.1532663107,
-0.4800355434,
-0.3599901199,
-0.5898401737,
0.0893785655,
-0.31103158,
0.7747188807,
-0.428737551,
0.2078299671,
0.1449989676,
-0.268849194,
-0.0575259887,
0.0532185584,
0.8439817429,
1.0571137667,
-0.0152357416,
0.4102606177,
0.327223748,
-0.0057045389,
0.3046835065,
-0.4440453351,
-0.0523917936,
-0.2569931448,
0.7824069262,
0.7723813653,
0.81712538,
-0.7197257876,
0.5416268706,
-0.1176955998,
0.1591727585,
-0.1776964664,
-0.1207857132,
0.0642604083,
0.2043893635,
0.5019301176,
-0.1885665208,
0.0712577477,
-0.7807272673,
0.4535970688,
0.3173136115,
-0.688162148,
-0.556523025,
0.5152786374,
0.0309247263,
-0.1090566069,
0.5851232409,
0.0132660959,
-0.4740301073,
0.7906329632,
0.8681665659,
0.9594828486,
-0.2714338005,
0.0165188368,
0.1799432635,
0.2855471373,
-0.0276986342,
-0.2274680585,
-0.3493506312,
-0.8317127824,
-0.8714308739,
-0.3953056633,
-0.363947928,
0.2540034056,
-0.5419179797,
0.1591618359,
-0.3292928636,
0.073689267,
-0.0176947899,
-0.1198463589,
-0.5788960457,
0.2283172905,
0.1755202562,
0.6604149342,
-1.0862725973,
0.9625503421,
0.7467322946,
-0.2588400245,
-0.7929515243,
0.2589627504,
0.0130237155,
-0.5324593782,
1.1915768385,
0.3264276981,
-0.0516320094,
-0.2214184701,
-0.6266073585,
-1.2409607172,
0.9566636086,
0.4020825028,
-0.3409397006,
-0.0286529418,
-0.1301219761,
0.4156105816,
-0.6877033114,
0.1353241205,
0.1845171452,
0.008320624,
-0.2234116793,
-0.7604233027,
-0.0892659277,
0.1625802368,
-0.0824664235,
0.0269944984,
-0.8786649704,
1.1191062927,
0.0172281973,
-0.232877031,
-0.149502337,
0.9518178701,
0.3736153841,
0.2372842431,
0.5902375579,
0.4810306132,
0.6915975213,
0.0599912405,
1.1933699846,
-0.1799239665,
0.2410065681,
1.4679424763,
-0.2103933096,
0.803550303,
0.6433157921,
-0.119004935,
0.4257600307,
0.6313484907,
0.5586776137,
0.6298171282,
0.2355435938,
-0.3003390133,
-0.4145903587,
-0.1269383878,
0.1277738214,
0.4881940782,
0.3611023426,
-0.3031598926,
-0.3111960888,
0.4345706105,
-0.0138250496,
0.0259100795,
-0.3326518238,
0.7546980977,
0.4092873633,
-0.7494837046,
0.2015319765,
0.046205543,
0.5902664661,
-0.328867346,
-0.0718038455,
-0.3519078791,
0.5258248448,
0.0520239621,
-0.5146295428,
0.1248701736,
-0.3064372241,
-0.5058772564,
-0.2330029011,
0.718306303,
-0.6063824296,
-0.5632621646,
0.2258189321,
-0.0261552632,
-0.011930868,
0.0554756261,
-0.436912477,
-0.0475571081,
0.1507541537,
-0.2116687298,
0.6317415237,
0.3047364652,
-0.1315544397,
0.9942485094,
0.1417079568,
-0.1136432514,
-0.0015880481,
-0.0955535695,
0.830264926,
-0.262286067,
-0.4339204133,
-0.9072149992,
0.6949423552,
-0.103728503,
-0.3953737915,
0.9600149989,
0.4728038013,
1.3586544991,
-0.00815152,
0.3942474723,
0.4557589889,
0.49697119,
-0.5557416677,
0.3901318014,
-0.6784853339,
0.2224816084,
-0.1714621037,
-1.0271691084,
-0.5126038194,
0.5183131695,
-0.0008511937,
-0.1232161373,
0.5582716465,
0.4607745111,
-0.1367057562,
-0.3531139195,
0.6019850373,
0.2391330749,
0.5234247446,
0.5304341912,
0.6474134326,
-0.4124389589,
0.0257238597,
-0.4634480774,
-0.281375289,
-0.2879580259,
-0.885748744,
-0.8771089911,
-0.6463324428,
-0.4255411625,
-0.0378887914,
-0.2159083188,
1.042714715,
0.9441353083,
-0.8460291028,
-0.5247898102,
0.1888935566,
0.2438223958,
-0.3754151762,
-0.1961963177,
0.4265264571,
-0.6494043469,
-0.8003387451,
0.6232139468,
0.5237630606,
-0.1185988039,
-0.518682003,
0.1477164328,
-0.0223054141,
-0.0155229485,
1.1123861074,
0.0377526581,
-0.9667505026,
-0.424874872,
-0.3245905042,
-0.089690268,
0.0204860643,
0.9189216495,
-0.8586032987,
0.4991485476,
0.4866916239,
0.8650661707,
0.407519877,
0.170626834,
0.5255394578,
-1.0912554264,
0.3651962876,
0.0187467206,
0.5187543631,
0.4284387231,
-0.3063504398,
0.3302209675,
-0.0186861325,
-0.8397433162,
-0.8316342831,
0.3095069528,
-0.7045204043,
-0.5270509124,
0.9690681696,
-0.2716915011,
-0.3732755184,
0.0290102772,
-0.064040944,
0.1415197253,
-0.2020619363,
0.8982797265,
0.7486109138,
-0.2967931032,
-0.1172797158,
-0.3935760558,
0.3559922576,
0.4483571053,
-0.4498869777,
0.122430481,
0.4416084886,
0.3274989128,
0.0938241556,
0.6092437506,
0.0558501296,
-0.1556264311,
-0.3980492055,
0.0128549235,
0.177767247,
-0.6928572655,
-0.5226741433,
0.1935236901,
0.2763230801,
-0.0518439002
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13124v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13124v1 | Learning to Generate Answers with Citations via Factual Consistency Models | 2024-06-19T00:40:19 | 2024-06-19T00:40:19 | Rami Aly, Zhiqiang Tang, Samson Tan, George Karypis | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) frequently hallucinate, impeding their
reliability in mission-critical situations. One approach to address this issue
is to provide citations to relevant sources alongside generated content,
enhancing the verifiability of generations. However, citing passages accurately
in answers remains a substantial challenge. This paper proposes a
weakly-supervised fine-tuning method leveraging factual consistency models
(FCMs). Our approach alternates between generating texts with citations and
supervised fine-tuning with FCM-filtered citation data. Focused learning is
integrated into the objective, directing the fine-tuning process to emphasise
the factual unit tokens, as measured by an FCM. Results on the ALCE few-shot
citation benchmark with various instruction-tuned LLMs demonstrate superior
performance compared to in-context learning, vanilla supervised fine-tuning,
and state-of-the-art methods, with an average improvement of $34.1$, $15.5$,
and $10.5$ citation F$_1$ points, respectively. Moreover, in a domain transfer
setting we show that the obtained citation generation ability robustly
transfers to unseen datasets. Notably, our citation improvements contribute to
the lowest factual error rate across baselines. | [
-0.3150745928,
-0.8766093254,
1.0542107821,
-0.0659198686,
-0.0464711189,
-0.012921785,
-0.5778851509,
-0.3432776332,
-0.168643713,
0.4907342494,
-0.5537336469,
-0.5398399234,
-0.5921881795,
0.3350843489,
-0.1237515658,
1.1009796858,
0.1655029953,
-0.140013814,
-0.5688394904,
-0.0799345523,
-0.2583197355,
-0.2166310847,
-0.3231084943,
-0.2091285139,
0.7489170432,
0.7820764184,
0.6789499521,
0.8317939043,
0.5484560728,
0.2458077222,
-0.1376805454,
0.9504424334,
-0.6147866845,
0.1666809022,
-0.7977335453,
-0.2145702839,
-0.0870928168,
-0.1168820634,
0.4858127236,
0.8969023228,
0.2894239426,
0.4254354537,
0.1854462624,
0.4973017573,
-0.7747685313,
0.1887584329,
-1.2762283087,
-0.4316001236,
-0.1159135103,
-0.4777187109,
-0.8027070165,
-0.5751709342,
0.0033525315,
-0.6534602046,
0.6024787426,
0.143011421,
1.035676837,
0.4527503252,
-0.4322546124,
-0.2382464707,
-0.6175330281,
0.8680430651,
-0.551669538,
0.0985785797,
0.3878574371,
-0.1709510237,
-0.3236278892,
-0.7837292552,
-0.2145748287,
-0.090300791,
-0.3506151736,
-0.1752491742,
0.1090542078,
-0.16693452,
0.275990814,
0.0051953187,
-0.3785519898,
-0.127990067,
-0.3731693625,
-0.202395305,
0.5527980924,
-0.0134295886,
-0.301892221,
-0.2882823348,
-0.2914845645,
-0.0023608974,
-0.7782773972,
-0.1779176295,
0.1152549386,
1.0316866636,
0.0995272547,
0.6958298087,
-0.4284740984,
0.5150603056,
0.4555998743,
-0.3478859663,
0.1335174888,
-0.5898706317,
-0.2427757829,
0.0481038466,
0.3703705072,
0.0573853999,
0.2456590831,
-0.5715182424,
0.0856921226,
-0.2363283932,
0.3903503418,
-0.9562450051,
-0.2740939856,
0.0417036526,
-0.2013721019,
-0.3787736893,
0.1848711371,
-0.4492135346,
-0.3772251606,
-0.786262393,
0.4778262079,
-0.4908405542,
0.1381057948,
-0.3234327435,
0.1221984774,
0.0366144441,
0.4480424821,
-0.7533886433,
-0.0650575906,
0.6430010796,
0.8249570727,
-0.0843417346,
-0.0352051593,
-1.0862250328,
0.2665405273,
-0.3896182775,
1.0714988708,
-0.4061156809,
-0.3763340116,
0.2925213277,
0.2389523536,
-0.0999951139,
-0.7297512889,
0.8484331369,
-0.5092545152,
-0.3934372365,
-0.7301571369,
-0.6292629838,
0.1525742561,
0.2494159341,
-0.171751067,
1.0650678873,
-0.0663116723,
-0.6107794642,
0.4920011461,
-0.168444097,
-0.5779581666,
-0.0170431677,
-0.0753812641,
-0.5886865258,
0.2140466422,
0.1607457399,
0.5054224133,
-0.1348454803,
0.6129353642,
-0.443554014,
-0.2916280329,
0.0644598529,
-0.2326495796,
0.4722782373,
0.3860023022,
-0.2378635406,
0.0861010104,
-1.0811929703,
0.0897726044,
-0.1008392423,
-0.5393534899,
-0.2614367604,
0.1445463598,
-0.0603075996,
-0.0084854802,
0.348890394,
-0.4981857836,
0.0944862515,
-0.0185018945,
-0.1334450394,
0.6763124466,
0.3193708062,
0.4055497646,
-0.46528548,
-0.0399327204,
0.0857490972,
-0.2352268547,
-0.2503249645,
-0.1546592861,
-0.8280963898,
-0.278719008,
0.2065279931,
0.2380164266,
-0.7577196956,
0.2946855724,
-0.5803391933,
-0.4026615322,
-0.2302252203,
0.7873386741,
0.1376116574,
0.978309989,
0.7601856589,
0.4508115351,
-0.6066896915,
-0.8248186707,
-0.3471549749,
-0.3899823725,
0.0110915964,
0.397808075,
0.484056294,
-0.1802778691,
0.9521427751,
-0.4291531444,
-0.1157758385,
0.0997272357,
0.5670717359,
0.0779122636,
0.6463615894,
0.5038548708,
-0.6935889125,
-0.503585279,
0.0039631794,
-0.9486202002,
-0.1367020011,
-0.204740718,
-0.3110530674,
0.1360928267,
0.6969690323,
-0.3547517359,
0.087979652,
-0.0063507967,
-0.2782436013,
0.3239763677,
-0.0718153864,
0.1172927171,
-0.8655941486,
0.2243382782,
0.082737036,
-0.4434507191,
-0.1336746365,
0.0839291885,
0.1894757003,
0.0485437065,
-0.3371002376,
0.1850106269,
-0.3571668267,
0.2499080449,
-0.4380446672,
0.1255983859,
0.0933623537,
0.2418735921,
0.0639552847,
0.5873731375,
0.2669215798,
-0.5565537214,
0.0096990652,
0.1949887276,
-0.1872020662,
0.8139690161,
-0.6100804806,
0.1185021624,
-0.1859541088,
0.0360945389,
-0.8386671543,
-0.2739035487,
-0.2416387647,
-0.1755522192,
0.4707318544,
-0.6787803173,
-0.6639795303,
0.1373113841,
-0.1523249447,
0.0655624494,
0.3114371002,
-0.8479958773,
0.3792206049,
-0.0304844528,
-0.299084276,
-0.3941940665,
-0.4031098783,
-0.0733095556,
-0.0124182217,
-0.7408261895,
0.4180663824,
-0.1914848238,
-0.2637211978,
0.0549784303,
-0.2524596453,
0.0979088321,
0.2249995917,
0.293217957,
0.3473121226,
-0.5993556976,
0.2221349776,
0.2443564534,
0.1845154315,
-0.0457358621,
-0.2286204845,
-0.0777061135,
-0.3241847456,
-0.1621798724,
-0.0566053018,
0.2617203593,
0.3797618449,
-0.0137897404,
0.9802271724,
0.6434261203,
-0.2393422723,
-0.2458713353,
-0.5218336582,
-0.2629262805,
-0.4472694993,
-0.0405346267,
-0.3280514777,
-0.8742548227,
0.3038988709,
-0.4122313559,
0.2626972795,
0.3917580247,
0.5146297812,
-0.1626864076,
0.6447729468,
0.5621579289,
0.2372321337,
0.2388854474,
0.0713577867,
-0.0965317264,
-0.3928352296,
-0.2460544109,
-0.8449338675,
-0.1167564541,
-0.5731604099,
-0.4097595811,
0.3118607104,
0.1838788986,
-0.4262036383,
0.0640714318,
-0.2106080502,
0.5028970838,
0.5342141986,
0.0914931521,
0.5608811378,
0.2313853353,
-0.1626500487,
-0.0114580728,
-0.5543136597,
-0.7128372192,
1.1981967688,
0.1348193735,
0.7377266884,
0.1987396181,
0.7030590773,
0.3130008876,
0.4792837203,
-0.5116279721,
0.4121956229,
0.0164314862,
-0.6700111032,
-0.1106931642,
-0.4554236233,
-0.5261323452,
0.1776722372,
-0.5063241124,
-0.5690507889,
0.4671047926,
0.1693995148,
-0.3590924144,
-0.0419850945,
-0.6935152411,
0.6115819812,
0.130115822,
-1.0419306755,
-0.0280355848,
-0.6489182115,
0.3697558939,
-0.125929594,
0.1531143486,
-0.1608407795,
0.3482188582,
0.3309900463,
-0.5235725641,
0.7646902204,
-0.2373324484,
-0.0192134343,
0.3947074413,
-0.0606714673,
0.8580301404,
0.5767512918,
-0.3056824207,
-0.1244981289,
-0.1650834978,
-0.5943598747,
-0.4306000173,
1.1503813267,
-0.5538999438,
-0.5883793831,
-0.3130594492,
-0.5416762829,
-0.6353613734,
0.2320747226,
0.2161989063,
0.2820815146,
-0.0987165645,
0.6596450806,
1.0380469561,
0.1044556797,
0.2081913799,
0.7200614214,
0.1431130022,
-0.2734409273,
0.7833496928,
0.0396636873,
0.0989225581,
0.2469730973,
-0.092612274,
-0.2522325814,
-0.6929489374,
-0.6104445457,
0.3197188079,
-0.7746970654,
-0.6283182502,
-0.5283889174,
-0.2198760659,
-0.449334681,
-0.1900848895,
-0.4841456413,
-0.1125202477,
-0.4985961318,
-0.3528792262,
0.4717290699,
0.2084243,
-0.1624571085,
0.1044807732,
-0.5008550286,
0.4438077807,
0.2550251782,
0.1014447957,
-0.2848899961,
-0.750441432,
-0.4715000093,
0.1887163073,
-0.356331706,
-0.3766697049,
-0.2077141106,
0.4623596668,
0.3386471868,
0.2165584415,
0.4403984249,
0.9930663705,
-0.5954999328,
0.6448242664,
-0.2918926179,
-0.6951567531,
0.6777306795,
-0.317964673,
0.0994671136,
1.2291160822,
0.2748776972,
0.3718385994,
-0.383559376,
-0.6117501259,
-0.8775731921,
0.5583401918,
0.1625622511,
0.0703849047,
-0.289576441,
0.4028075039,
0.0487606525,
0.0103133107,
-0.461840719,
-0.3494622409,
-0.2056584805,
-0.3647167683,
-0.0067686937,
-0.0855634138,
-0.2972693443,
-0.2276021987,
1.1043556929,
-0.6800201535,
-0.2477412075,
0.4184784889,
-0.3297806084,
-0.4067257047,
0.3177935183,
0.724784255,
0.799377203,
-0.4401870668,
0.5927817225,
0.0831348523,
-0.0836723372,
0.0509036183,
0.2207076848,
-0.5804129839,
0.3429174423,
0.1461582631,
0.4411317408,
0.3935038745,
-0.6386826634,
0.3828375638,
0.1619735062,
-0.2924367487,
-0.1478928775,
0.0922101438,
0.1696751267,
0.2285661995,
0.7275455594,
0.355756402,
-0.1127253994,
-0.5047029853,
0.2326739281,
0.452911824,
-0.1877097487,
-0.1536042094,
0.6736302376,
0.0637117103,
0.3559175432,
0.3472580612,
-0.1210942715,
0.1024582833,
0.252625972,
0.6456674337,
0.4616909921,
0.371787101,
0.3331944048,
0.7278186083,
0.2682314813,
-0.2116720676,
0.0689486563,
-0.2224410474,
-0.5298637152,
-0.3894616663,
-0.9080578685,
-0.4800769389,
0.2301974744,
-0.6784992814,
0.2780883014,
-0.4879471362,
-0.1327625215,
0.2404489517,
0.1979020536,
-0.7561742067,
0.3644858897,
0.1929840147,
0.7557495832,
-0.8312986493,
0.7756053209,
0.7221928239,
-0.5904610753,
-0.7967814803,
0.0423419327,
-0.1471035779,
-0.2476263642,
0.5802514553,
-0.2539060712,
-0.3620647192,
0.0673445314,
-0.8582949042,
-0.9315129519,
1.036180377,
0.7248842716,
-0.4437839687,
0.2449576408,
-0.025989797,
0.4282213748,
-0.2724129558,
-0.0865018368,
0.3545158207,
0.540963769,
0.2842390835,
-0.3723753691,
0.2574529052,
-0.0589757748,
-0.105386056,
-0.3083631992,
-0.5983446836,
0.3758496642,
-0.3778107166,
-0.1044432223,
0.3349984288,
1.2360631227,
0.6309561729,
0.4803592563,
0.2043047249,
0.2386801243,
1.1926914454,
-0.0688895136,
0.7345238924,
-0.2506659925,
0.3845002949,
1.4061363935,
-0.3439877331,
0.8484916091,
0.7782511711,
0.0964282528,
0.6773275733,
0.2883554101,
-0.1581236422,
0.5779677629,
-0.1635439694,
-0.2223638892,
-0.6051265597,
-0.4195567071,
-0.2304754704,
0.0744588301,
0.0149460835,
-0.6915323734,
-0.3116892874,
-0.2915129364,
0.1879795939,
0.4907499254,
-0.3417186737,
0.7081591487,
0.0790444314,
-0.8281051517,
0.8014286757,
0.1069346517,
0.5135623813,
-0.3963417113,
0.1114448756,
-0.358913362,
0.1597289443,
-0.4612360001,
-0.2967040837,
0.3575274646,
0.462257117,
-0.7570092678,
-0.2114426643,
0.798205018,
-0.4455913901,
-0.7034339309,
-0.2184989601,
0.4546796381,
-0.1314876825,
0.1292801499,
-0.157358557,
-0.0222935081,
-0.0041097482,
-0.1511166096,
0.4359647334,
0.5361146927,
0.038339261,
0.2797241509,
0.8847441077,
-0.1041794121,
0.1256392151,
0.0305218138,
0.5867836475,
-0.3429809213,
0.0079373196,
-0.7898749113,
0.4552285671,
-0.2441445142,
-0.254919976,
0.8816772103,
0.7536658645,
0.7437365651,
-0.1911476701,
0.8182176948,
-0.0289093088,
0.6209955215,
-0.5993757248,
0.4886640608,
-0.5104894638,
0.3215871453,
-0.3349432349,
-0.6568457484,
-0.207008183,
0.4781984091,
-0.1970288306,
-0.2217956781,
0.4633547068,
0.8059777021,
-0.3203827441,
-0.1593454778,
0.1887595057,
0.2306013554,
0.1810899973,
0.1766913384,
0.5667334199,
-0.4741437733,
0.6107980609,
-0.2538942397,
0.2211194038,
-0.3763334155,
-1.0312789679,
-0.7450948954,
-0.1538106799,
-0.7558013797,
-0.4787741601,
0.0748645365,
0.9588885903,
0.7745878696,
-0.9934188724,
0.3495485187,
-0.1425697058,
0.2941794395,
-0.1327361614,
-0.2410488129,
0.3034795523,
-0.8883703351,
-0.7221949697,
0.6910683513,
0.0515232645,
-0.1794082075,
0.1872027665,
-0.0359336995,
-0.263762027,
0.2748201191,
0.4589485824,
0.3395271301,
-0.5361468792,
-0.7052772641,
0.1332527548,
-0.243678391,
0.0324836038,
0.5397095084,
-0.820902288,
0.1101803333,
0.304015398,
0.9226032495,
0.5471585393,
0.5682932138,
0.233795017,
-1.0843253136,
-0.1634273976,
0.0396201201,
0.3462560475,
0.6746284366,
-0.2774815261,
0.5202276707,
0.4694132209,
-0.6253228188,
-1.0005757809,
-0.0748694539,
-1.1636322737,
-0.2704202533,
1.200794816,
-0.3299728632,
-0.0101771699,
-0.1858888417,
0.0297943912,
0.1627013832,
-0.1645569652,
0.7345528603,
0.5730375051,
-0.0461330488,
0.1674871147,
-0.0835750476,
0.4368284345,
0.4533503354,
-0.6661054492,
0.1182899922,
0.6629790068,
0.6060655117,
0.4248529077,
0.154851079,
0.0163924545,
0.2286134362,
-0.0832809806,
-0.4403756261,
-0.1964281052,
-0.4750199914,
0.1887963116,
0.4889541566,
0.3704479635,
0.2314276844
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13121v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13121v1 | Can Long-Context Language Models Subsume Retrieval, RAG, SQL, and More? | 2024-06-19T00:28:58 | 2024-06-19T00:28:58 | Jinhyuk Lee, Anthony Chen, Zhuyun Dai, Dheeru Dua, Devendra Singh Sachan, Michael Boratko, Yi Luan, Sébastien M. R. Arnold, Vincent Perot, Siddharth Dalmia, Hexiang Hu, Xudong Lin, Panupong Pasupat, Aida Amini, Jeremy R. Cole, Sebastian Riedel, Iftekhar Naim, Ming-Wei Chang, Kelvin Guu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR | Long-context language models (LCLMs) have the potential to revolutionize our
approach to tasks traditionally reliant on external tools like retrieval
systems or databases. Leveraging LCLMs' ability to natively ingest and process
entire corpora of information offers numerous advantages. It enhances
user-friendliness by eliminating the need for specialized knowledge of tools,
provides robust end-to-end modeling that minimizes cascading errors in complex
pipelines, and allows for the application of sophisticated prompting techniques
across the entire system. To assess this paradigm shift, we introduce LOFT, a
benchmark of real-world tasks requiring context up to millions of tokens
designed to evaluate LCLMs' performance on in-context retrieval and reasoning.
Our findings reveal LCLMs' surprising ability to rival state-of-the-art
retrieval and RAG systems, despite never having been explicitly trained for
these tasks. However, LCLMs still face challenges in areas like compositional
reasoning that are required in SQL-like tasks. Notably, prompting strategies
significantly influence performance, emphasizing the need for continued
research as context lengths grow. Overall, LOFT provides a rigorous testing
ground for LCLMs, showcasing their potential to supplant existing paradigms and
tackle novel tasks as model capabilities scale. | [
-0.3030155897,
-0.7842031121,
0.4515253305,
0.4132763743,
-0.0515771247,
0.1786974519,
-0.4418520033,
-0.7133530974,
-0.3486898243,
0.4713553488,
-0.4874424636,
-0.3469132781,
-0.1685352474,
0.1866261661,
-0.7416415811,
0.8877741694,
0.3563619852,
-0.1199108362,
-0.4142382443,
-0.1288687885,
-0.9264194965,
-0.7880772352,
-0.5862405896,
-0.0237252489,
0.6766132116,
0.0510883555,
0.578461051,
0.225908488,
0.2066306323,
0.1561636478,
-0.3309837282,
-0.0580979995,
-0.6214236021,
0.3076604009,
-0.2680791914,
-0.4050782621,
-0.3991393745,
-0.2349662334,
0.5061966777,
1.0244992971,
-0.1086634323,
0.0846248418,
0.2295987308,
1.0153003931,
-0.5484766364,
-0.2177980393,
-0.8768942952,
-0.1676721126,
-0.1895518154,
-0.1367491931,
-0.6904815435,
0.0862615034,
0.1216731817,
-0.4983717799,
0.0309167542,
0.463624686,
0.4494284689,
0.1282144785,
-0.4550751448,
-0.5460102558,
-0.5500648022,
1.0687687397,
-0.5410246849,
0.7630189061,
0.3377313614,
0.3931424022,
-0.3596332073,
-0.7713782787,
-0.2526028156,
-0.6374232769,
-0.3604022861,
-0.0553860031,
0.1101699397,
-0.0314192437,
0.4128049016,
0.0545352772,
-0.4904975891,
0.194288224,
-0.4841172397,
0.0647139847,
0.3865140975,
0.1603601277,
0.1944614202,
-0.3988159299,
-0.5440650582,
0.2338499278,
-1.020209074,
0.3938728869,
-0.0108475499,
0.5692991018,
0.2189019471,
0.3524540365,
-0.2743308246,
1.0474137068,
-0.279533565,
0.0536661781,
-0.2201937139,
-0.3787469566,
-0.4071570635,
-0.1242970899,
0.3246747851,
0.2445955724,
-0.0406497717,
-0.4074044526,
-0.4151737392,
-0.2690784037,
0.2614469528,
-0.4822548628,
0.1274128556,
0.4613288045,
-0.28026402,
-0.0560450926,
-0.159585014,
-0.5446004868,
-0.3693063855,
-0.6500642896,
0.1940372884,
-0.3419190645,
-0.2089125961,
0.0496534705,
-0.0861901715,
0.3950089514,
0.2954720855,
-0.5816719532,
0.3955512047,
1.0811411142,
0.840901494,
-0.5355535746,
-0.0959406719,
-0.4879791737,
0.0749607161,
-0.613272965,
0.5950976014,
-0.5593260527,
-0.6454558969,
0.0792959481,
0.0321365185,
0.1202859432,
-0.7006690502,
0.6604043841,
-0.6070433259,
0.1371690482,
-0.7250069976,
-0.5228736401,
0.177394554,
0.3405733705,
-0.6111840606,
1.487573266,
0.2055853009,
-0.6361761093,
0.5128273964,
-0.7649525404,
-0.4820590913,
0.1724271625,
0.0011483994,
0.1138157919,
0.1567462683,
-0.0185381472,
0.4871707261,
-0.4063643515,
0.4126219451,
-0.1127650663,
-0.6552466154,
0.1411613226,
-0.2309978753,
0.9812210202,
0.2131344825,
-0.1438883394,
0.1588659734,
-0.5609996915,
0.0477855243,
-0.1810719967,
-0.2794919908,
-0.5518144965,
0.1002375185,
0.2131841481,
0.3041887581,
0.3583858609,
-0.4395597875,
0.1139213368,
-0.3400639296,
0.5780575871,
0.5889356732,
-0.5092878938,
0.5452151299,
-0.2800118923,
0.3597878218,
-0.085973911,
0.1689318717,
-0.3114575446,
-0.0473720804,
-0.673209548,
-0.3354363441,
0.0021359494,
0.3675242364,
-0.2982412279,
0.2788363993,
-0.2345143706,
-0.389313668,
-0.1392426044,
0.0459674262,
0.3082541227,
0.7021287084,
0.5787915587,
0.0543259643,
-0.6819235682,
-0.7347141504,
-0.3544733822,
0.1577338725,
-0.1335407495,
0.5280668139,
0.3609380126,
0.0376223847,
1.3108745813,
-0.1516553164,
-0.232148543,
-0.2965509892,
-0.1054174602,
0.4153574109,
0.4393473268,
0.412537396,
-0.895316422,
-0.4398426414,
-0.0712478608,
-0.7250003815,
-0.193452552,
-0.1188284233,
-0.0173761621,
0.5928722024,
1.0527039766,
-0.5757836103,
0.3604857624,
0.3137339354,
-0.145800367,
1.0002641678,
-0.1134263352,
-0.1802000403,
-0.6824774146,
0.4674188495,
-0.5639688969,
-0.3223134875,
-0.6311344504,
0.2235923707,
0.1944857538,
-0.100894779,
-0.5654255152,
0.9611125588,
-0.7548170686,
-0.5295152068,
-0.2064168304,
0.1969192475,
0.1741305739,
0.2854074836,
0.0679662526,
0.8604570031,
0.5164341927,
-0.7421556115,
0.1880819649,
-0.1650993824,
-0.5188385844,
0.6980740428,
-0.8012291193,
0.1871007681,
-0.2740962207,
0.7012410164,
-0.9286060333,
-0.0667531788,
-0.3809672296,
-0.0229575448,
0.1460829377,
-0.1445330679,
-0.46632424,
-0.4978765547,
-0.1095694602,
0.2918890715,
0.4689184427,
-0.5451574922,
0.5084635615,
-0.0649934635,
-0.015330852,
-0.9360392094,
-0.4110450745,
0.3770483136,
-0.2561737597,
-0.2238391191,
0.4936277866,
0.0088457875,
-0.2566474378,
-0.1337931305,
-0.0466317832,
0.0630628839,
0.2103620023,
0.2546610534,
0.2999182343,
-0.146697551,
0.5438645482,
-0.0386760049,
0.019427767,
-0.0863663405,
-0.4504233301,
0.55780375,
-0.3119000196,
-0.3767418563,
-0.1556741893,
0.5572229028,
0.6071475148,
-0.2628638148,
0.7531933188,
0.3288308084,
-0.3498424888,
-0.3019431829,
-0.6396428347,
-0.2244305313,
-0.4686916173,
0.4453548193,
-0.5336820483,
-0.959598124,
0.4514516294,
-0.0800447538,
0.3124541044,
0.1440935433,
0.1572131664,
-0.2439989448,
0.8443704844,
0.6305477619,
0.1276826113,
0.4476915598,
-0.1239893809,
0.3257445097,
-1.212500453,
-0.1290367395,
-0.4752818048,
-0.1765452921,
-0.2125302404,
-0.5025947094,
0.4954180121,
0.4385526776,
-0.2597837448,
0.4653784633,
-0.562073648,
0.7038873434,
0.2106008679,
-0.1915029287,
0.3435713649,
-0.4841992259,
-0.176750198,
0.0882755965,
-0.6415123343,
-0.5758625269,
0.8929112554,
0.1193721071,
0.4481801391,
-0.0134708891,
0.44631356,
0.1732923985,
0.596321702,
-0.8819281459,
0.6842794418,
-0.0924693197,
-0.867321372,
-0.6024041176,
0.0711477697,
-0.9477779269,
0.3229086995,
0.0698275864,
-0.7391129136,
-0.0333135016,
-0.0110751512,
-0.3346636295,
0.1616808325,
-0.37883237,
0.7987928987,
-0.2645830512,
-0.5406627655,
-0.1438425183,
-0.6366499662,
0.2516120672,
-0.1351499707,
0.4783284366,
-0.2109722942,
-0.1917919666,
0.4098517895,
-0.1161767542,
0.8244190812,
-0.2245512009,
-0.1498389691,
0.2613039315,
0.332857579,
0.5029289126,
-0.0559078231,
-0.4057332277,
-0.0755716488,
0.3931345344,
-0.4176567495,
-0.6390098333,
0.7631419301,
-0.1499959826,
-0.6854444146,
-0.1479365826,
-0.5517258048,
-0.3461363316,
0.2439917326,
0.0361344926,
0.6739475131,
-0.3919764459,
0.5723280907,
0.2468332499,
-0.1491707414,
0.6652673483,
0.3535540104,
-0.5122873187,
0.2805749178,
0.5536088347,
0.1043750271,
0.2769372463,
0.4098263383,
0.2347376794,
-0.6166042686,
-0.3724450767,
-0.3148866594,
-0.0870954841,
-0.8305135965,
-0.1898839772,
-0.7346935272,
0.0440805703,
-0.2935861051,
-0.6239030957,
-0.2819349468,
-0.2679561973,
-0.2188052237,
-0.0015289043,
0.0430926643,
0.7532753944,
0.2468209416,
-0.0740722418,
-0.6599018574,
-0.1863127053,
0.3366657197,
0.3009459078,
0.2947134376,
-0.4475797117,
-0.1542920917,
-0.0870711952,
0.0427850597,
-0.6457170248,
0.3074896038,
0.1416310072,
0.4447432756,
-0.0137720574,
0.1846434921,
0.8330283165,
-0.6844212413,
0.9872528911,
-0.1581346095,
-0.9487292767,
0.2702136338,
-0.4729754031,
0.2948037684,
0.5128298402,
0.3840456009,
-0.7441791296,
-0.1420457214,
-0.346511066,
-0.8807092905,
0.4463472068,
-0.2075043917,
0.3487815261,
-0.192364499,
0.3789534867,
0.2001136541,
0.2204779536,
-0.6360000372,
0.3990128934,
-0.1545973718,
0.1056824252,
0.1234090924,
-0.1151149869,
0.0079478957,
-0.2939781547,
0.3036516011,
-0.3412446976,
0.0487507023,
0.3079343736,
-0.200871706,
0.2173824608,
0.5474949479,
0.6566992998,
1.0846985579,
-0.1444653124,
-0.0377342291,
0.5078415275,
0.1875925213,
-0.2583050728,
-0.4140206575,
0.0438081622,
-0.109206304,
0.2304553539,
0.4166729748,
0.6092097759,
-0.9867608547,
0.4661317766,
0.2398786247,
0.2074917406,
-0.530451715,
-0.0861977637,
0.2987748981,
-0.0533810146,
0.7164084315,
-0.2229419053,
0.2248405218,
-0.7963955402,
0.1982798725,
0.8020247817,
-0.4863025546,
-0.2385285348,
0.363252461,
0.1340822875,
-0.3576543927,
0.3481408954,
-0.0278741755,
-0.4396907985,
0.5320194364,
0.7623240352,
0.4854574502,
0.0783792064,
-0.1161643341,
0.4524182677,
0.0159095675,
-0.2130032182,
-0.0583509468,
-0.3624873161,
-0.3740794361,
-0.4447540641,
-0.7896593213,
-0.4594752491,
0.1359222233,
-0.6705080867,
0.3957401216,
-0.4427344799,
-0.0545880571,
-0.2497501373,
-0.1762621105,
-0.6126327515,
0.1946628988,
-0.1484617591,
1.1468387842,
-0.2793273926,
0.8312773108,
0.40119344,
0.0211170428,
-0.404715687,
-0.2358311117,
-0.1646845341,
-0.5368584991,
1.1445125341,
0.5067768693,
-0.3232980371,
-0.1613914967,
-0.615388751,
-0.7828770876,
0.9568743706,
0.0767162517,
-0.6977815628,
-0.4351961911,
-0.095638603,
0.7197049856,
-0.5234087706,
0.1232335716,
0.6293751001,
0.3432448208,
0.0594183318,
-1.1169046164,
0.0667633191,
0.149087131,
0.1519855857,
0.202696234,
-0.38238585,
0.9596973062,
-0.2073237896,
-0.3216763735,
0.1997200102,
0.6589041948,
0.2706539929,
0.1356742233,
0.6119421124,
0.0669558868,
0.76821208,
0.0292515401,
1.0897096395,
-0.394797802,
0.1297551841,
1.2329672575,
-0.6109470129,
1.3247913122,
0.5901128054,
-0.1459793448,
0.7027472258,
0.265367806,
0.5449396968,
0.2069283724,
0.380502373,
-0.1764496118,
-0.2706682682,
-0.2748509943,
-0.2475307435,
0.3864150643,
0.6626832485,
0.0084000258,
-0.1447127014,
0.1327004582,
-0.0500824377,
0.2106664181,
-0.0411225967,
0.5665482879,
0.1728065312,
-0.9897845387,
0.8270255327,
-0.2692542374,
0.9029937387,
-0.5200462937,
0.082486771,
-0.1113157794,
-0.0759225413,
-0.125245139,
-0.6114403605,
0.5153386593,
-0.046064239,
0.011997533,
-0.4137749374,
0.7254556417,
-0.3123554587,
-0.2926189005,
0.5334884524,
0.4913909435,
0.0755808577,
-0.1226288453,
-0.6301922202,
0.0550982319,
-0.5079650879,
-0.2992048562,
0.3165819049,
0.3075448275,
-0.3283695579,
0.7754961848,
0.9546719193,
-0.0796383172,
0.0588115789,
0.0446745902,
0.7926806211,
-0.8449928164,
-0.4454983175,
-0.6029602289,
0.3992493749,
-0.2323157787,
-0.1969501227,
0.5426515341,
0.5493331552,
0.7447634339,
0.0701754317,
0.5333070755,
-0.1926421225,
0.8203269839,
-0.4900710881,
0.6075659394,
-0.7184098363,
0.2805767357,
-0.0225482322,
-0.8663079739,
-0.2946673334,
0.3452280164,
-0.3202722967,
0.1639954299,
0.7815766335,
0.7992369533,
0.0054366151,
-0.0151146604,
0.58395648,
0.1077491641,
0.4977844357,
0.4636301994,
0.8743570447,
-0.0747266263,
0.3569396138,
0.0510432385,
-0.0758324116,
-0.4374736249,
-1.2671716213,
-0.9608610272,
-0.7007840872,
0.2862459719,
-0.0101455143,
0.2069178075,
0.9828539491,
0.8336737752,
-0.6632831693,
-0.3475702703,
-0.183761701,
0.0601413138,
-0.317628324,
-0.2618625462,
0.3874303401,
-0.8064092994,
-0.7065160275,
0.7487731576,
0.3973496556,
-0.1258678287,
-0.4666220844,
0.1849372387,
-0.060977459,
0.1176229641,
1.0266978741,
0.3821949959,
-1.0453869104,
-0.3487896025,
0.4673267007,
-0.3305925727,
-0.0820654705,
0.9130656123,
-1.193523407,
0.2250133604,
0.5397008657,
0.4744623005,
0.179734543,
-0.0283259433,
0.4628024995,
-0.817199409,
0.2532774806,
0.4475412965,
0.3194437325,
0.5033361912,
-0.3316762745,
0.5311250687,
-0.1136412621,
-0.5179613829,
-1.2031471729,
0.2871015072,
-0.9086255431,
-0.521115303,
1.0930638313,
0.0825033635,
-0.2944733202,
-0.4616164863,
-0.4500968456,
-0.1419288069,
-0.1825132072,
0.6519197822,
0.7170466185,
-0.1149820313,
0.0033607157,
-0.7439931035,
0.8369008303,
0.724525094,
-0.7247418761,
0.5545185804,
0.4369420707,
0.2677873969,
0.1040233672,
0.7787978053,
-0.2323419452,
0.2345223874,
-0.4288009405,
-0.4045291245,
-0.0898033753,
-0.5638436675,
-0.1175474152,
0.2439088225,
-0.0023518512,
0.4357105494
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13114v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13114v1 | Multi-Stage Balanced Distillation: Addressing Long-Tail Challenges in Sequence-Level Knowledge Distillation | 2024-06-19T00:01:14 | 2024-06-19T00:01:14 | Yuhang Zhou, Jing Zhu, Paiheng Xu, Xiaoyu Liu, Xiyao Wang, Danai Koutra, Wei Ai, Furong Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models (LLMs) have significantly advanced various natural
language processing tasks, but deploying them remains computationally
expensive. Knowledge distillation (KD) is a promising solution, enabling the
transfer of capabilities from larger teacher LLMs to more compact student
models. Particularly, sequence-level KD, which distills rationale-based
reasoning processes instead of merely final outcomes, shows great potential in
enhancing students' reasoning capabilities. However, current methods struggle
with sequence level KD under long-tailed data distributions, adversely
affecting generalization on sparsely represented domains. We introduce the
Multi-Stage Balanced Distillation (BalDistill) framework, which iteratively
balances training data within a fixed computational budget. By dynamically
selecting representative head domain examples and synthesizing tail domain
examples, BalDistill achieves state-of-the-art performance across diverse
long-tailed datasets, enhancing both the efficiency and efficacy of the
distilled models. | [
-0.3490498364,
-0.6569213867,
0.7384345531,
0.5770304203,
-0.2496789396,
0.5660043359,
-0.3244397044,
-0.1137542054,
-0.2303368598,
0.4380708039,
-0.5808683634,
-0.3907411993,
-0.75014925,
0.1184782386,
-0.4988828003,
1.0931463242,
-0.0221226662,
-0.088289924,
-0.2252180725,
-0.0954314172,
-0.6619769335,
-0.5658096671,
-0.8444770575,
-0.8157203197,
0.5470129251,
0.6120465994,
0.3993787467,
0.4570083916,
0.2183626592,
0.2474938929,
-0.1044721305,
0.0135364467,
-0.5806745291,
0.4069570005,
-0.2460019141,
-0.3318701386,
-0.228708148,
-0.2291292101,
0.5635660887,
1.2064856291,
-0.649830699,
-0.1379887015,
0.4226242006,
1.0216213465,
-0.6919826865,
0.1505137384,
-0.7268695831,
-0.1209759265,
-0.0943412259,
0.1965550929,
-0.3321672082,
-0.1894121766,
0.4123323858,
-0.5767009258,
0.2524630725,
-0.2282398343,
0.6135742664,
0.3890062869,
-0.5319452286,
-0.324506104,
-0.8104147315,
1.1906098127,
-0.9039101601,
0.2975867689,
0.2695929706,
0.5067670941,
-0.2945570648,
-0.703175962,
-0.6769226193,
0.3151404858,
0.1232015193,
-0.0817556605,
-0.2050872594,
0.0777727738,
0.2105886489,
0.399590373,
-0.3924384713,
0.0445106663,
-0.4181676805,
0.1854577512,
0.49174878,
-0.073765561,
-0.2624052763,
-0.0198123138,
-0.3523647487,
-0.3905990422,
-0.282376349,
-0.2384134382,
0.3508092165,
0.5700924993,
0.2864803076,
0.6079181433,
-0.4445740283,
0.6860332489,
0.4372418523,
-0.4798404872,
0.1396704316,
-0.2863026857,
-0.4044134915,
0.2463747561,
0.5764804482,
0.0909924582,
0.3831029832,
0.0334162898,
-0.1545502543,
-0.0408966616,
0.2298493236,
-1.0417716503,
-0.2901120782,
0.4650028348,
-0.0218204129,
-0.3240377903,
-0.3704375625,
-1.013258934,
-0.4740452468,
-0.6434527636,
0.4081861377,
-0.4653831124,
-0.3135719895,
0.4568446875,
-0.4459104538,
-0.132169202,
0.2991440296,
-0.9416183829,
0.3844303489,
0.752789855,
0.7579449415,
-0.4267370999,
-0.297960639,
-0.0122673241,
0.3444901407,
-0.1408640444,
0.4161986709,
-0.327257365,
-0.3042118549,
-0.0716536343,
-0.3006975353,
0.0470625497,
-0.8206306696,
0.6990381479,
-0.4473983943,
0.0055536414,
-0.2870518565,
-0.5695505738,
-0.0951521546,
0.065196231,
-0.5093849301,
0.9096527696,
0.0736384764,
-0.7360892296,
0.5549325943,
-0.2648783028,
-0.8099595904,
-0.1995426714,
-0.0390792415,
-0.4787056744,
-0.0522274077,
0.2524810433,
0.5475020409,
-0.2486562878,
0.7482270598,
-0.3529485762,
0.0911940858,
-0.1885151565,
-0.4531140327,
0.7933921218,
0.3970129788,
-0.2130744159,
-0.0892368481,
-1.1693977118,
-0.2514594495,
0.0210681204,
-0.3103832304,
-0.7611789703,
0.1329294145,
-0.2097314,
0.1253843904,
0.0454791673,
-0.3818499148,
0.3465210795,
-0.0747422427,
0.6064084172,
0.6752252579,
0.0455815569,
0.4979712069,
-0.2365333736,
0.2169059366,
0.3633117378,
-0.0618199408,
-0.0962536931,
-0.4141609669,
-0.8329318166,
-0.6029658318,
0.0548867583,
0.4487614632,
-0.8549094796,
0.3949607015,
-0.1921612322,
-0.3970938623,
-0.1809253991,
0.3241510987,
0.0900651515,
0.6742871404,
0.5631496906,
0.028948091,
-0.4163894951,
-0.8509691358,
-0.0100494428,
-0.1282262951,
0.0909217522,
-0.1343872696,
0.2763333619,
-0.1696792841,
0.9673198462,
-0.7978358269,
-0.41914469,
-0.251992166,
0.6436663866,
0.6752606034,
0.3903529644,
0.4677553773,
-0.6031194329,
-0.5161207318,
-0.0709151626,
-0.6062474251,
-0.303953141,
-0.3273810446,
-0.3813979328,
-0.0519469045,
0.3095755577,
-0.8457844853,
0.0088812299,
0.4107579589,
-0.1070874035,
0.407484889,
-0.041286733,
0.2497165799,
-1.0413544178,
0.0078477934,
0.1483978927,
-0.1323013008,
-0.6924717426,
-0.0712953284,
0.0851107985,
-0.0075595714,
-0.1040233746,
0.1997841597,
-0.3517597616,
0.2543919981,
-0.4192324281,
-0.020849565,
0.188599512,
0.4294813275,
0.0575469136,
0.4844240248,
0.3663458228,
-0.588532865,
0.3190768957,
0.098169677,
-0.1925013661,
0.8966343999,
-0.5678880215,
-0.1677481532,
-0.0696233884,
0.1776719242,
-1.1486855745,
-0.1433656961,
-0.1531051397,
-0.0705931485,
0.4726319611,
-0.3070938289,
-0.2623421848,
-0.5102856159,
-0.1676413715,
0.4956911504,
0.4880966246,
-0.5168911219,
0.677698493,
0.1258078218,
-0.4865152836,
-0.9175941348,
-0.5993380547,
0.1274589449,
-0.4512141943,
-0.68232584,
0.3252487481,
-0.0485761575,
-0.2803440392,
-0.1432289779,
-0.4284900725,
-0.3992527723,
-0.0129728792,
0.0161715075,
0.1641750038,
0.0085943108,
-0.1312670708,
0.5062086582,
0.2209784091,
0.0396109931,
-0.6336925626,
0.4544623494,
0.3541022837,
-0.3012128472,
-0.1183297113,
0.2979091704,
0.8123489022,
0.1772713661,
0.7135416269,
0.2639111578,
-0.5586463213,
-0.687196672,
-0.6446707249,
-0.0857964605,
-0.4535119236,
0.2776963711,
-0.3323564529,
-0.840416193,
0.485783428,
-0.1997040063,
0.3264738321,
0.379160583,
0.5158604383,
0.0222256929,
0.8059717417,
0.4582775831,
-0.0757151842,
0.0714729726,
-0.2562331855,
0.3819930255,
-0.3776517212,
-0.1108304039,
-0.5415788293,
-0.2906058431,
-0.0104611646,
-0.5322469473,
0.2215874344,
0.4988261759,
-0.2711311579,
0.176375106,
-0.3473605216,
0.4663198888,
0.6204380989,
-0.1011223421,
0.6387556791,
-0.0024666991,
-0.2485725433,
0.0470674336,
-0.5800357461,
-0.1910810322,
1.2469540834,
0.2920867205,
0.9322130084,
-0.0516813323,
1.0282583237,
0.3294685781,
-0.0459206514,
-0.7687417865,
0.3483214974,
-0.3182799816,
-0.488422513,
-0.4249877632,
-0.5475077033,
-0.6842852235,
0.4428727031,
-0.1496500671,
-0.2291582823,
0.381269902,
0.2472273856,
-0.4786011577,
0.2511562407,
-0.7441109419,
0.7635492682,
-0.2582173645,
-0.5046259761,
-0.4456965923,
-0.5206560493,
0.8454372883,
-0.6705883145,
0.3765030205,
-0.0761192143,
0.4610182345,
0.6251806021,
-0.6292135119,
0.6824635863,
-0.3308929205,
-0.3472937644,
0.2837124169,
-0.0374624059,
0.437933296,
-0.0183831938,
0.0822702125,
0.1807918698,
0.2434426099,
-0.3633278906,
-0.5483990908,
0.7336707711,
-0.6954519749,
-0.6320919394,
-0.6581654549,
-0.5308405161,
-0.489561677,
0.2975773215,
-0.2451930046,
-0.0861896127,
-0.0051368265,
0.2287679464,
0.8047158122,
-0.1422228366,
0.35759601,
0.2736831009,
-0.2783647478,
-0.5731030703,
0.6814046502,
0.0766604617,
0.6815543175,
0.1680732667,
0.2478123605,
-0.279216975,
-0.6845237017,
-0.4247777462,
0.0149985831,
-0.7478685379,
-0.4054866433,
-0.7470957637,
-0.2499512136,
-0.3101582229,
-0.0631703883,
-0.5760354996,
-0.5651664734,
-0.3088657856,
-0.0447964482,
0.2699193954,
0.479281038,
-0.2148341835,
0.4932626784,
-0.5455018878,
0.803345263,
0.6415084004,
0.1655156463,
0.3132508993,
-0.3710869253,
-0.1995742917,
0.3342098594,
-0.4877709448,
-0.5847173333,
0.4004173577,
0.4735379219,
0.4703795016,
0.5301067233,
0.2391142398,
1.0856925249,
-0.7675662041,
0.6357782483,
0.4898733497,
-0.8904192448,
0.3760840893,
-0.2858937979,
0.2843092978,
0.7247357368,
0.5693397522,
-0.5033733249,
-0.6093572974,
-0.2447487116,
-1.1091054678,
0.4836642146,
0.109338671,
-0.0599980503,
-0.0074116853,
0.3139464855,
0.3280915916,
0.4778262377,
-0.3525057435,
-0.2693342268,
-0.2713126242,
-0.5272736549,
0.0242480859,
-0.1178325489,
-0.1083797812,
-0.4801389575,
0.8122304678,
-0.0969091356,
-0.3495867848,
0.0637849718,
-0.0515348166,
-0.1173066348,
0.3682628572,
0.382730335,
0.9196830988,
-0.3932633698,
0.2862356305,
-0.0540707335,
-0.5910862684,
0.3799411058,
0.279294163,
-0.0683578625,
-0.173015669,
0.1927035898,
0.5573303699,
0.2590228319,
-0.5215147734,
0.350617826,
0.0707625896,
-0.5688285828,
-0.0969732106,
0.0367484689,
0.2548833489,
0.5087547898,
0.8877047896,
-0.0103705283,
0.1863378882,
-0.5615837574,
0.4366696775,
0.3378673494,
0.2396140248,
0.0321651697,
0.7030808926,
0.0738868788,
0.3801623285,
0.7161179185,
0.0422230773,
-0.3615321517,
0.3132543862,
0.4807902575,
0.83883816,
-0.1154553145,
0.1285115778,
0.3989637196,
0.0309792124,
-0.5442028046,
0.1815907359,
-0.0164945349,
-0.7329686284,
-0.7022459507,
-1.1203030348,
-0.3310257792,
0.2224550247,
-0.8104766011,
0.2504912019,
-0.5330981612,
-0.4063857794,
0.3385620713,
-0.2165464312,
-0.425850302,
-0.0789479539,
0.213227123,
0.7659606934,
-0.9261043668,
0.9331331849,
0.1714766175,
-0.1871234328,
-0.6172044277,
-0.1162009239,
0.0697442293,
-0.5517470837,
0.8160553575,
-0.1073770672,
-0.1030327603,
-0.0150807081,
-0.3991474807,
-0.5577805042,
1.1170958281,
0.3720194995,
-1.0504579544,
-0.2252418399,
0.4209519327,
0.4170538485,
-0.0861667991,
-0.1926424205,
0.8287745714,
0.4493278265,
0.8073836565,
-0.9085354805,
-0.2913668454,
0.1574008316,
-0.1627627313,
0.1930296123,
-0.2728215158,
0.9809487462,
-0.0607591532,
-0.2212675512,
-0.1882082224,
0.8361487985,
0.4730460048,
0.391497165,
0.5349422097,
1.0752843618,
0.7815178633,
-0.1278120577,
0.3918475807,
-0.1714384556,
0.3328046799,
1.284304738,
-0.6321091056,
0.7946956754,
0.8189772367,
-0.4820725024,
0.4421034455,
0.3547348678,
0.0764349028,
0.7822893262,
0.442895472,
-0.3672744632,
-0.2730030119,
0.206441164,
-0.17223005,
0.0618423559,
0.2254396379,
-0.0409301482,
-0.47920385,
0.2333139628,
-0.012680633,
0.1060587391,
-0.2678734958,
0.8028190136,
0.2380344272,
-0.8542747498,
0.8733726144,
-0.05944217,
0.8096144199,
-0.6626017094,
-0.2414803356,
-0.1862882376,
0.5254994631,
-0.1255785525,
-0.9197896123,
0.2908135951,
0.0044331267,
-0.3744467497,
-0.5118013024,
0.6091931462,
-0.8146229982,
-0.6767222285,
0.2853695154,
0.5006398559,
-0.2205390781,
-0.236035794,
-0.4568166733,
-0.0347655267,
-0.0947351307,
0.0880746096,
0.4064522386,
0.7120867968,
-0.0808415487,
0.5968320966,
0.6499910951,
0.1955419034,
0.2989677191,
0.3680566251,
1.0233616829,
-0.3211461008,
-0.2487140298,
-0.9576852322,
0.510279119,
-0.1710101962,
0.0899416581,
0.7166224718,
0.5433992743,
0.9628782868,
-0.0699197277,
0.8606436253,
-0.0106164701,
0.6006055474,
-0.352311641,
0.653683722,
-0.4385286272,
0.2021256834,
-0.3646523952,
-0.9460043311,
-0.1622480154,
0.6126126647,
0.1248406321,
-0.0841734335,
0.6010516286,
0.2950816154,
-0.1712806672,
0.0384396575,
0.101785019,
0.2028521001,
0.4279327989,
0.6204523444,
0.7931846976,
-0.1547297537,
0.1578986794,
-0.4417960644,
-0.3005016446,
0.1019029245,
-1.076228857,
-1.0320210457,
-0.4838394821,
-0.4160508513,
-0.2474723756,
0.2606340051,
0.8431615233,
0.5767983198,
-0.8771884441,
-0.5075592995,
-0.3030934334,
0.1152955145,
-0.2335634828,
-0.2460852563,
0.1101221293,
-0.5398448706,
-0.6363061666,
0.2369382679,
0.1420398057,
-0.0371137448,
-0.2887746692,
0.138878718,
-0.446197927,
0.1553078145,
0.817871809,
0.1513657272,
-0.5722141266,
-0.1877955943,
-0.108045049,
0.0327870958,
-0.0346410461,
0.7416463494,
-0.68218261,
0.2603702843,
0.3756502569,
0.693305254,
0.6655431986,
0.1590762585,
0.7061027884,
-0.9419764876,
0.0324410833,
0.1404955834,
0.2077406049,
0.1719711125,
-0.1041169316,
0.3302667141,
0.4151970446,
-0.4908503294,
-0.9139150381,
-0.1463341713,
-1.1470382214,
-0.5647443533,
1.1090607643,
-0.0857092589,
0.093332544,
-0.0241897721,
-0.0674275607,
0.3861085773,
-0.4138965905,
0.705850184,
1.1006580591,
-0.0178771354,
-0.0524314865,
-0.5984511971,
0.5533064604,
0.267400533,
-0.7463829517,
0.3863141537,
0.7486506104,
0.2953784764,
0.2289266437,
0.3630377054,
0.0680357888,
-0.3110861182,
-0.2800927162,
0.0052595525,
0.028984258,
-0.6182617545,
-0.1206977814,
0.2316166759,
0.1144372746,
0.1550064832
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13106v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13106v3 | Accelerating Complex Disease Treatment through Network Medicine and GenAI: A Case Study on Drug Repurposing for Breast Cancer | 2024-06-18T23:40:00 | 2024-06-27T08:28:51 | Ahmed Abdeen Hamed, Tamer E. Fandy | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.IR, I.2; I.2.6 | The objective of this research is to introduce a network specialized in
predicting drugs that can be repurposed by investigating real-world evidence
sources, such as clinical trials and biomedical literature. Specifically, it
aims to generate drug combination therapies for complex diseases (e.g., cancer,
Alzheimer's). We present a multilayered network medicine approach, empowered by
a highly configured ChatGPT prompt engineering system, which is constructed on
the fly to extract drug mentions in clinical trials. Additionally, we introduce
a novel algorithm that connects real-world evidence with disease-specific
signaling pathways (e.g., KEGG database). This sheds light on the
repurposability of drugs if they are found to bind with one or more protein
constituents of a signaling pathway. To demonstrate, we instantiated the
framework for breast cancer and found that, out of 46 breast cancer signaling
pathways, the framework identified 38 pathways that were covered by at least
two drugs. This evidence signals the potential for combining those drugs.
Specifically, the most covered signaling pathway, ID hsa:2064, was covered by
108 drugs, some of which can be combined. Conversely, the signaling pathway ID
hsa:1499 was covered by only two drugs, indicating a significant gap for
further research. Our network medicine framework, empowered by GenAI, shows
promise in identifying drug combinations with a high degree of specificity,
knowing the exact signaling pathways and proteins that serve as targets. It is
noteworthy that ChatGPT successfully accelerated the process of identifying
drug mentions in clinical trials, though further investigations are required to
determine the relationships among the drug mentions. | [
-0.1911755204,
-0.8296259046,
0.522331655,
0.0828404278,
0.0606818274,
0.412148118,
0.4121456742,
-0.3892377913,
0.6696144342,
0.9922252297,
-0.7430918813,
-0.3457072675,
-0.7982765436,
-0.1325509697,
-0.1975754499,
0.7605031133,
0.0036893538,
0.4820230305,
0.1598815322,
-0.2172831744,
-0.55154109,
-0.2520335913,
-1.0605527163,
-0.9003566504,
0.9877195358,
0.2970455289,
0.3891274929,
0.5559862852,
0.7496449351,
0.2481423318,
-0.0501636788,
0.3167981803,
-0.4817787111,
0.5465611815,
-0.0488838628,
-0.3940222263,
-0.6151731014,
-0.2072243541,
0.2504376471,
0.9797706604,
-0.3351776302,
-0.0093943616,
0.1199240088,
0.8039129376,
-0.5085881352,
-0.1328174472,
-0.2381196171,
0.438927114,
-0.2135088593,
-0.4543778896,
0.1660435498,
-0.3084278405,
0.2242219746,
-0.6507201195,
0.1028378084,
0.1325170249,
0.7906576991,
0.0782106742,
-0.4953970611,
-0.4318471849,
-0.4676379561,
0.3646372259,
-0.7563700676,
-0.1923248768,
0.0630170107,
0.8702759147,
-0.9573211074,
-1.0748740435,
-0.0430731587,
-0.1923971623,
-0.0368630253,
0.1880750209,
-0.0240580328,
0.3818065524,
0.2354190201,
0.4803213477,
-0.5331788063,
0.1836934984,
-0.4646824598,
-0.4331246614,
0.0536143743,
0.3348652124,
0.905251205,
-0.0478591807,
-0.359141469,
0.2303920686,
-1.0227247477,
0.1140283495,
-0.1355862319,
0.3828713298,
0.0519479699,
0.7338359356,
-0.4381445646,
0.7181940675,
-0.0800585374,
0.3251458704,
0.170203194,
-0.4807056785,
-0.4138759971,
0.3957394958,
0.8571413755,
0.3908706903,
-0.3078050911,
-0.0307009686,
0.4354790747,
-0.1136736497,
0.0895534083,
-1.0741597414,
-0.5076447725,
0.5794549584,
-0.6002465487,
-0.3921008706,
0.0173094105,
-0.952872932,
-0.4414702058,
0.2100675404,
0.6810464859,
-0.2887017727,
-0.4723008871,
0.4522539675,
-0.5110117793,
-0.0327827968,
0.0213719793,
-0.6901744008,
0.1501833498,
0.9089258909,
0.9791322947,
0.161015898,
-0.2557653189,
-0.9812446237,
0.5812789798,
-0.1827076226,
1.0292674303,
-0.4949654639,
-0.3598783314,
0.0127846384,
0.092730917,
-0.1748303622,
-0.3821624815,
0.5778041482,
-0.4451036155,
0.2645741999,
-0.7781255841,
-0.5097882748,
-0.1647727937,
0.4249811172,
-0.9096032381,
0.2404953092,
-0.0578383803,
-0.7091827989,
0.3190463483,
-0.9435583353,
-0.4965243042,
0.1909510046,
-0.1147796214,
-0.2273935378,
-0.1075272337,
0.3409594297,
0.5090674162,
-0.1283888519,
0.4428623021,
-0.3700790107,
-0.428627044,
0.127989009,
-0.1548849791,
0.7917084098,
0.4573709667,
-0.1929675341,
0.2775959074,
-0.6899920702,
-0.0232020132,
-0.0621754006,
-0.2515479326,
-0.4671577513,
-0.396210283,
-0.1989168525,
0.3122327626,
0.1898469031,
-0.5654034019,
0.5856102705,
-0.466345787,
0.8096954823,
0.6789614558,
0.4400612414,
0.1896043122,
-0.4893939495,
0.4059937894,
-0.0465406701,
0.2805379629,
-0.0930707231,
-0.9422055483,
-0.3216859698,
-0.330952704,
0.2991035879,
0.4310401976,
-0.6256225705,
-0.1608203351,
-0.2077050954,
-0.1491546035,
-0.594913125,
-0.3014989495,
0.4094085991,
0.3421961069,
0.3945103884,
-0.5318220854,
-0.5269715786,
-0.8358271718,
-0.1278007925,
0.1107857898,
0.0472154357,
0.3044064939,
0.0839414671,
-0.3828481138,
0.5286791921,
-0.57930094,
-0.3189482689,
-0.0803719312,
0.2967511415,
0.4109387696,
0.3745838702,
0.0765464306,
-0.5837791562,
-0.1698699892,
0.2465739697,
-0.8006883264,
-0.3759927154,
-0.049225267,
-0.4059729278,
-1.04601264,
0.525583148,
-0.4425646663,
0.190291062,
0.4468664527,
-0.3218753338,
0.2955901921,
-0.6660984755,
0.5713149309,
-1.3031821251,
0.0035254629,
-0.0606223829,
-0.3699327111,
-0.7028651834,
-0.1388937235,
-0.5388760567,
-0.2416531891,
-0.1061064079,
0.3690616488,
-0.3760688901,
-0.0903249756,
-0.2765619159,
-0.2471149415,
0.0532807671,
0.1897221804,
-0.3352018595,
0.3935312331,
0.3839316368,
-0.4287932515,
0.4439959228,
0.1334375143,
-0.1385426968,
0.5565295219,
-0.6817322373,
-0.3248551488,
0.0286012404,
0.3809966743,
-1.0529341698,
-0.2319158167,
0.8798707724,
-0.3579535186,
0.1833840758,
-0.5016806126,
-0.3168219924,
-0.3356028497,
-0.0088422857,
0.1574844122,
0.0137585718,
-0.2470121235,
0.584985137,
0.4806859195,
-0.2505628169,
-0.454708606,
-1.0343548059,
0.4883315563,
-0.0694136843,
-0.6057949662,
0.4072566032,
0.0439317375,
0.0411853269,
0.128254205,
0.2823713422,
0.0718785748,
-0.0978858247,
0.4973838925,
-0.1814488173,
-0.206749782,
0.0194706507,
0.6470295787,
-0.4616969824,
-0.087525785,
-0.2800694704,
0.483769387,
0.2871233821,
-0.6872121096,
-0.4701479375,
1.0114177465,
0.7155468464,
-0.1229278669,
0.3814868033,
0.7866711617,
-0.4148614705,
0.0363311432,
-0.0987984613,
-0.3888368011,
-0.4317819178,
0.2045394182,
-0.4843598306,
-0.8750110269,
0.6559223533,
-0.7459116578,
-0.0139636481,
0.1533926576,
0.627720356,
0.347109735,
0.7551427484,
0.2343874723,
0.0395615213,
0.2285825163,
-0.3574979603,
0.2960481942,
-0.8717759252,
-0.4012084007,
-0.1748714596,
-0.6306373477,
-0.6586261988,
-0.3698511124,
0.4659959078,
0.0452525429,
-0.4831094742,
0.3651091456,
-0.7925661802,
0.022189362,
0.6123310924,
0.4475851059,
0.5237686038,
0.0842389762,
-0.0989525244,
0.2297365814,
-1.2317656279,
0.0570779666,
1.3824568987,
0.2353942096,
0.085166052,
0.0250221435,
0.630831182,
0.2369392514,
0.5224152207,
-0.5524091721,
0.423140049,
-0.0538261235,
-0.638997972,
0.0440542214,
-0.5756803751,
-1.1915938854,
0.0013582747,
-0.345780462,
-0.6101213098,
0.6451538205,
-0.1462249607,
-0.7565479875,
0.4339117706,
-0.548563838,
0.7299167514,
-0.1248548701,
-0.2188370973,
-0.1601936668,
-0.8145667315,
0.3129607141,
0.145355612,
0.2942597866,
-0.1442920268,
0.2047319412,
0.609084487,
-0.6375567913,
0.5459796786,
0.1086288914,
0.2101807445,
-0.0364983678,
0.0683358759,
0.2384050488,
-0.0694115981,
0.1998772919,
0.2520868778,
0.0871054456,
-0.6276738048,
-0.5206097364,
1.1109089851,
-0.4557415247,
-0.1613409519,
-0.3823100328,
-0.3997758329,
-0.0866441205,
0.2384787053,
0.4889113307,
0.6882929802,
0.0068966132,
-0.3064910471,
0.4292616248,
-0.2116801143,
0.0607564747,
0.3614537716,
-0.3865950406,
-0.4933372438,
0.9892140031,
0.359901011,
0.2142417431,
0.5473772883,
0.1336428374,
0.1335894018,
-0.4642429352,
-0.2616101801,
-0.0290112309,
-0.281465292,
-0.0136312414,
-0.6004991531,
-0.1257953048,
-0.2456959486,
-0.0352459475,
-0.4635573924,
-0.2393142134,
-0.0127263609,
-0.0530152731,
0.2926813364,
0.6240879893,
-0.2558755577,
0.4642379582,
-0.8518976569,
0.382183224,
0.1914183199,
0.3568258584,
0.1837766469,
-0.084352158,
-0.0907157958,
0.4862679839,
-0.0890728012,
-1.0221425295,
0.2397701442,
0.1398670226,
0.5672212839,
0.5363298059,
-0.3904787004,
0.5159632564,
-0.346673429,
0.3489891887,
0.4774751961,
-0.3137548268,
0.6271143556,
-0.4992975295,
-0.107242927,
0.1790017486,
0.1514326632,
-0.6579025388,
0.0198208205,
-0.5750044584,
-0.9116116166,
0.2297452092,
0.4336271584,
-0.3068896532,
0.2574469447,
0.5885367393,
-0.0489756428,
0.1519545019,
0.0298846588,
-0.5058938861,
-0.0876956061,
-0.1145063043,
0.2895164788,
-0.2270628512,
-0.76864779,
0.0406741761,
0.4883857667,
0.0205550566,
0.4960316718,
0.3794334829,
0.2821782529,
0.0173111856,
0.3032732308,
0.1266553998,
0.3392201364,
-0.4251253307,
-0.0725004748,
-0.5533301234,
-0.6435269117,
-0.138032034,
0.4907118082,
-0.1191911101,
-0.2322166115,
0.5610326529,
0.4601995647,
0.1283537149,
-0.4726699591,
0.0773148462,
-0.1303184032,
-0.0210722685,
0.2503048778,
-0.05373317,
0.0239769556,
0.7268363237,
0.3291517496,
0.2908837199,
0.7098406553,
-0.7323322892,
0.5330882072,
0.2589536905,
-0.844935596,
-0.1233393326,
0.5855435133,
0.1343565732,
-0.3112281561,
0.5400118232,
0.056947656,
-0.2439921945,
0.7461080551,
0.4072944224,
0.7017179728,
-0.1854698658,
0.590882659,
0.4025020301,
0.0615732372,
-0.3331431448,
0.0366383344,
0.3063851595,
-0.8976823092,
-0.339887321,
-0.2535148263,
-0.3200548589,
-0.1872489005,
-0.1838103086,
0.0376882888,
-0.411560446,
-0.462511301,
0.5076507926,
0.2055920064,
-0.0701402873,
-0.0248807818,
-0.1681772918,
0.4298703969,
-0.9670817256,
0.7164251804,
0.722212255,
-0.6131539941,
-0.8304101825,
-0.2967743576,
-0.0134708891,
-0.6968463063,
0.2205792814,
0.1562274843,
0.1152843982,
0.1062775329,
-0.3484097123,
-0.7164179683,
1.463865757,
0.1301737726,
-0.6978788376,
0.196190998,
0.1405768991,
0.5256304741,
-0.6430305243,
0.2550671995,
0.3026546836,
0.4744895399,
0.6896713376,
-0.6720364094,
0.2896204889,
-0.2789489925,
-0.1842911243,
0.0640260577,
-0.3833008111,
0.7134834528,
-0.441208154,
-0.1099793166,
0.4816508293,
0.0357825942,
0.412822783,
0.6086426377,
0.0339747407,
0.8705963492,
0.9218230844,
-0.2975776494,
0.8327188492,
-0.1973952204,
0.2409304529,
0.6684772968,
-0.0633975118,
0.3460308909,
0.4298732877,
-0.3263728321,
0.3551778495,
0.7656827569,
0.0883703306,
0.5226008296,
0.3176531494,
-0.391936481,
-0.382345289,
-0.3619255126,
-0.5716478825,
-0.2582389414,
0.4132433534,
-0.3398993909,
-0.379109472,
0.3716808558,
0.1448207349,
-0.2214546055,
-0.385032475,
0.6441988349,
0.4385654926,
-0.3833800852,
0.1291626692,
-0.1457846463,
0.1732183099,
-0.7432109714,
-0.4565192759,
-0.3364185691,
0.1873250157,
-0.2947733104,
-0.7742244005,
0.0678843334,
-0.7400933504,
-0.0915187225,
0.3806765676,
0.8472417593,
-0.393729955,
-0.4722491801,
0.3784967661,
0.5630702376,
0.0963216051,
-0.0400404222,
-0.8384625316,
0.156581074,
-0.0470125787,
-0.0095668836,
0.5028830767,
0.5280877352,
0.0730892718,
0.9827695489,
1.0132851601,
0.4081439972,
-0.2741304934,
0.0319002159,
0.9809222221,
-0.3782293499,
-0.1433897018,
-0.6780865192,
0.1588158458,
-0.2992770076,
-0.2830842435,
0.510396719,
0.3480783999,
-0.3065226078,
0.4640222788,
0.6526008248,
0.2565062046,
0.2742909491,
-0.5206611156,
0.8583089709,
-0.4058836997,
0.4646090865,
-0.022546187,
-0.741194725,
-0.5668762326,
0.0003174112,
-0.2896521091,
-0.1271250397,
0.4401914179,
0.7887814641,
0.1704098284,
0.2128775269,
-0.0921394899,
0.4544619918,
0.8559007645,
1.0676516294,
0.2575730085,
-0.7336474061,
0.2142998576,
0.1235499829,
-0.6955115795,
-0.2983544469,
-0.7078606486,
-0.428191632,
-0.461489141,
-0.1207508594,
-0.7558159232,
0.5956367254,
0.7961701751,
0.7511108518,
-0.6362977624,
-0.0319452547,
-0.2235995382,
0.3636060059,
-0.6747341156,
-0.1111647934,
0.6167996526,
0.228653729,
-0.3034981191,
0.5173140168,
0.716290772,
-0.2299950421,
-0.2189598233,
-0.0203036182,
-0.6271917224,
-0.1679872274,
0.4803029597,
0.6401848793,
-0.1091892347,
0.1532478482,
-0.0431529097,
-0.0820008144,
-0.0973747373,
0.9455968142,
-0.7954086661,
0.7122392058,
0.8643153906,
0.5750944614,
0.5555320382,
-0.0616310947,
1.0660319328,
0.190072298,
-0.2140896469,
0.054121621,
0.3077886701,
0.2426997423,
-0.350977242,
0.187487334,
0.4760046899,
-0.6180006862,
-0.4910481274,
0.2875699401,
-1.3388952017,
-0.5185168386,
1.090765357,
-0.2972181141,
-0.2750971019,
-0.3844769001,
-0.3342781663,
0.1974126101,
-0.4843177497,
0.8426449895,
0.3880476356,
-0.1926528215,
-0.1784939021,
-0.5014594197,
0.3655821681,
-0.0442274548,
-0.5823070407,
-0.1840345263,
0.3326809108,
0.3465698063,
0.0242083538,
1.0268868208,
-0.2500719726,
-0.0702648163,
-0.0137105174,
-0.2710551023,
-0.3185994327,
0.0476571433,
-0.07733161,
0.4837405086,
-0.4856712222,
-0.382620424
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13094v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13094v1 | Exploring and Benchmarking the Planning Capabilities of Large Language Models | 2024-06-18T22:57:06 | 2024-06-18T22:57:06 | Bernd Bohnet, Azade Nova, Aaron T Parisi, Kevin Swersky, Katayoon Goshvadi, Hanjun Dai, Dale Schuurmans, Noah Fiedel, Hanie Sedghi | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | We seek to elevate the planning capabilities of Large Language Models
(LLMs)investigating four main directions. First, we construct a comprehensive
benchmark suite encompassing both classical planning domains and natural
language scenarios. This suite includes algorithms to generate instances with
varying levels of difficulty, allowing for rigorous and systematic evaluation
of LLM performance. Second, we investigate the use of in-context learning (ICL)
to enhance LLM planning, exploring the direct relationship between increased
context length and improved planning performance. Third, we demonstrate the
positive impact of fine-tuning LLMs on optimal planning paths, as well as the
effectiveness of incorporating model-driven search procedures. Finally, we
investigate the performance of the proposed methods in out-of-distribution
scenarios, assessing the ability to generalize to novel and unseen planning
challenges. | [
-0.5581745505,
-0.6133156419,
0.7504740357,
0.22697106,
0.0669133738,
-0.0249978025,
-0.5928328633,
-0.5223317742,
-0.2751504183,
0.5500198007,
-0.7004289031,
-0.4927599728,
-0.2375276983,
0.1264376044,
-0.2362384349,
0.3719060123,
-0.2840551138,
0.0863392428,
-0.1019885615,
-0.0607152134,
-0.6283546686,
-0.5466291904,
-0.825720787,
-0.5232790112,
0.1995642781,
0.7382671237,
0.6131215096,
0.5119901896,
0.4414571524,
0.1937219054,
-0.2540777922,
0.2724373937,
-0.5944957733,
0.191982612,
-0.345851779,
-0.0597181953,
-0.4043996036,
-0.3104325533,
0.9878206253,
0.8352785707,
-0.1958327293,
0.1585811675,
-0.085277766,
0.5746206045,
-0.7553830743,
0.2762743533,
-0.8721935153,
0.0502508432,
-0.0854251906,
-0.2058338225,
-0.3004162014,
-0.1572908014,
0.3328256607,
-0.2468083501,
-0.0320887379,
0.1085693166,
0.4000584781,
0.0388101041,
-0.471262753,
-0.4928999841,
-0.9894818664,
0.8818203211,
-0.847253561,
0.4201746285,
0.3508181274,
0.5505029559,
-0.4594932795,
-0.6966050863,
-0.3034726977,
-0.2563442588,
0.0692268908,
-0.1615638882,
0.0173205435,
0.1398740858,
0.5413461924,
0.2055259794,
-0.5119041204,
0.5270695686,
-0.1444716901,
0.1936448663,
0.9454523325,
0.4135942161,
-0.0298290085,
0.1379383057,
-0.1757678837,
-0.1984674782,
-0.9980629086,
0.1632216573,
0.311457932,
0.4094569385,
-0.0199109446,
0.5636644959,
-0.6526448727,
0.6642234921,
-0.4947493374,
-0.1860569119,
-0.0998727307,
-0.4284784496,
-0.300052464,
-0.1494790018,
0.2825632989,
0.3180905581,
0.1891911477,
-0.1745001674,
-0.4877981842,
-0.3993006051,
0.0527804755,
-0.8836248517,
-0.0347234607,
0.019668011,
-0.2445459366,
0.0359607749,
-0.3856942058,
-0.782281816,
-0.2527609169,
-0.5289106369,
0.2481296211,
-0.5807799697,
-0.0922072232,
0.3429381251,
0.0136745386,
0.4186789691,
0.1530173868,
-1.1345146894,
0.5831415653,
0.7815309167,
0.5038384795,
-0.0585684665,
-0.3357625008,
-0.442944169,
0.3928255737,
-0.5270107985,
0.8449137211,
-0.4842312634,
-0.5738903284,
0.4859550595,
-0.3171774745,
0.1788314581,
-0.8020336628,
0.7252851129,
-0.3455223143,
-0.1576621383,
-0.4771206975,
-0.6825857759,
-0.2748838663,
0.6336729527,
-0.4297466278,
1.1504983902,
0.1829144061,
-0.2803966701,
0.5747024417,
-0.7488717437,
-0.5789746642,
0.1630282551,
-0.1610609144,
-0.199192524,
0.0804044679,
0.25352332,
0.762419641,
-0.6348785162,
0.4508054852,
-0.1589937359,
-0.2619699836,
0.0507893339,
-0.235969916,
0.3865195513,
0.1470599025,
-0.3469409943,
0.3226934671,
-0.7076095343,
0.1274011135,
0.1173728183,
-0.5004455447,
-0.1376146376,
0.4593346417,
0.1247339919,
0.240827471,
0.2804938555,
-0.2456743717,
0.4722637236,
-0.4475768805,
0.4580731094,
0.5409619808,
-0.060107626,
0.640203774,
-0.2138227075,
0.5277232528,
-0.4286343753,
0.2548591793,
-0.2378700376,
-0.1589408219,
-0.6697093844,
0.1377714127,
0.0212561041,
0.2433655113,
-0.6595110297,
0.1940687299,
-0.348780632,
-0.4808498621,
0.212662518,
0.0745294988,
0.3267264664,
0.3719305694,
0.3676374555,
-0.2169464678,
-0.4384587407,
-0.8245994449,
-0.2234584242,
-0.1099391207,
0.1473822147,
0.3783831894,
0.4362728,
-0.2374026328,
0.7627568841,
-0.4427092373,
-0.1102239415,
-0.6601274014,
-0.1424655765,
0.1836938709,
0.1674679965,
0.534041822,
-0.8591999412,
-0.4832136333,
0.0494635105,
-0.5993549824,
-0.1312068403,
0.0484735109,
-0.0137528889,
0.1081225798,
0.6363672614,
-0.3770218194,
0.4207722843,
0.4283942282,
-0.1105488464,
0.6736289859,
-0.457465142,
-0.2544587851,
-0.9087408185,
-0.0892134756,
0.0971108153,
-0.0204741489,
-0.6955569983,
0.3205159903,
0.2929051518,
-0.1410011202,
-0.4765641391,
0.7000340819,
-0.6267943978,
-0.4891822934,
-0.1212904453,
0.004758874,
-0.2699302733,
0.3741882145,
0.0489590913,
0.8788564205,
0.5148706436,
-0.7816833854,
0.0998750404,
0.168072179,
-0.6128076911,
0.2660100162,
-0.3096773922,
-0.1529610306,
0.0152351884,
0.3550220728,
-0.6941758394,
-0.2763117552,
-0.2439290136,
0.1950109899,
0.3810972273,
-0.0918802246,
-0.8325996399,
-0.3732993305,
-0.1856424809,
0.3353767097,
0.3882932961,
-0.626975596,
0.6052267551,
0.4177050889,
-0.1703176796,
-0.2455862612,
-0.348420769,
0.1973126382,
-0.5109676123,
-0.5324283838,
0.6162221432,
-0.2438599467,
-0.5819961429,
-0.3691036105,
0.073997505,
0.0203692988,
0.0854464248,
-0.0360424519,
-0.0606060289,
-0.1461278349,
0.0490799583,
-0.2161295563,
-0.03320897,
0.1585918516,
-0.1671780944,
0.8643266559,
0.0630340129,
-0.2563524544,
0.0043786168,
0.3766064942,
0.3137917519,
-0.3451669514,
0.4474645853,
-0.0428086072,
-0.5298038721,
-0.4291029871,
-0.6486855149,
0.0461388119,
-0.4913291931,
0.4756341279,
-0.5010966659,
-0.7009287477,
0.531231463,
-0.5772094131,
0.277808845,
0.1592628509,
0.5540241003,
0.1699540168,
1.123903513,
1.0292415619,
-0.1060690582,
0.3707013428,
-0.4842631221,
0.2664126456,
-0.9595520496,
-0.1809576601,
-0.5220654607,
-0.2470447868,
-0.5497183204,
-0.5185053349,
0.458417207,
0.2120639235,
-0.2645539045,
0.4170311987,
-0.0054553896,
0.6544715166,
0.3528428376,
-0.3397716582,
0.2244636863,
-0.0946270004,
-0.2014545947,
0.0758280456,
-0.7359728217,
-0.7020015121,
1.0946846008,
0.3700639606,
0.550653398,
0.1472551227,
0.5286569595,
-0.3424015939,
0.2791114151,
-0.6501336694,
0.7906495929,
-0.0353548639,
-0.5711289048,
-0.5915704966,
-0.2607839704,
-0.7375549078,
0.2293311507,
-0.2799374759,
-0.9349181652,
0.0008344881,
-0.1253708899,
-0.1570040137,
0.5110643506,
-0.5418043137,
0.6348654032,
-0.4662432373,
-0.3499621749,
-0.4655611813,
-0.2710701227,
0.199823916,
-0.1746644974,
0.1010370702,
-0.3659710586,
-0.0389205441,
0.3479717374,
0.0998439118,
0.4276469946,
0.0315169133,
-0.1018956825,
-0.0377147757,
0.1281255335,
0.6737243533,
0.0322425142,
-0.5862407088,
0.0690289363,
-0.2198070139,
-0.2743868828,
-0.2855148315,
0.8072019219,
-0.3680467606,
-0.3625534177,
-0.054184135,
-0.9822873473,
-0.6262551546,
0.2685030699,
0.1875357181,
0.5979427099,
-0.6860591769,
0.1151858121,
0.5440116525,
-0.4940225482,
0.9676524997,
0.6451848745,
-0.3827593625,
-0.0469286889,
0.415363133,
0.3101936877,
0.375885278,
0.5637919903,
0.2510896027,
-0.5231719017,
-1.1219825745,
-0.2532994747,
0.0417245366,
-0.8465120196,
-0.0001637148,
-0.3997285962,
-0.1881940365,
-0.4790809751,
-0.3440519571,
-0.2753082812,
-0.029030025,
0.151341483,
-0.0137853594,
-0.008756496,
1.0065003633,
0.082310006,
0.331387639,
-0.3714854419,
-0.0665550753,
0.1069636419,
0.3864419758,
0.0574109927,
-0.0365571193,
-0.3325413465,
-0.0811845735,
-0.4883146584,
-0.4527632892,
0.7019532919,
-0.0000932664,
0.7472140789,
0.3274013102,
0.0371465683,
0.8990374207,
-0.6814150214,
0.674087882,
-0.1848920733,
-0.5781738162,
0.5393199325,
-0.5144178271,
0.4383687079,
0.6066527367,
0.5635032058,
-0.3450466096,
0.0137469824,
-0.643142879,
-1.1398993731,
0.5164759159,
0.1660652161,
0.0384152792,
0.0836473107,
0.3695523441,
0.0820380598,
0.0825831741,
-0.5714244246,
0.0169169586,
0.6131470799,
0.2652194202,
-0.5576002002,
-0.553432405,
-0.0819191188,
-0.3987013996,
0.6832376719,
-0.2363234609,
-0.0402479991,
-0.149644509,
0.0285594221,
-0.1709164083,
0.2437577397,
0.8199619651,
1.3111274242,
-0.2532055676,
-0.0134639889,
0.656272471,
0.0033837927,
-0.2436296344,
0.2420876473,
-0.0399140082,
-0.2800111771,
0.3867417276,
0.6461357474,
0.5793334246,
-0.978060782,
0.1992232651,
-0.2081793845,
-0.2580511272,
-0.6375558376,
-0.0504286624,
0.2283049971,
0.3670703769,
0.366759181,
-0.4806132615,
0.1346601397,
-0.6805078387,
-0.0372952372,
0.4898017645,
-0.2900122702,
-0.0983024314,
0.2932040393,
-0.042326998,
-0.5161277056,
0.5447536111,
-0.1688278764,
-0.5020042658,
0.5289755464,
0.7195260525,
0.7256007791,
0.0149896052,
-0.0575344563,
0.3428892791,
0.3534611464,
-0.1390695572,
0.439525038,
-0.0365159661,
-0.6539728642,
-0.4340763092,
-0.6171802878,
-0.4804012179,
0.2726251781,
-0.4101077914,
0.5395694971,
-0.3603807688,
0.1763813198,
-0.2254073471,
0.3490658402,
-0.8883569837,
0.065507561,
0.0725009888,
1.3208565712,
-0.5199918151,
0.8319971561,
0.7560924292,
-0.0979140028,
-0.9695342779,
0.2392633408,
-0.1325049996,
-0.743983686,
0.6551160216,
0.2677846253,
-0.1092890203,
-0.0624445453,
-0.3655268848,
-0.9515503049,
1.297514081,
0.1817557067,
-0.6920089722,
-0.0462215431,
0.3773522079,
0.4953204989,
-0.5530431867,
0.166025579,
0.7893177271,
0.3402504623,
-0.0088420995,
-1.0496792793,
-0.2350997925,
0.2560266554,
0.2959816158,
0.4424817264,
-0.4486004114,
0.769300282,
0.0130574433,
-0.2326167673,
0.1637512147,
0.5292316675,
0.3064421713,
0.3993845284,
0.4660153389,
0.5623773932,
0.5777897239,
0.0612584241,
1.1734046936,
-0.3832575679,
0.0996675044,
1.0577251911,
-0.7749288678,
1.1572247744,
0.4317001402,
-0.0582951903,
0.3204635084,
0.6769373417,
0.3940267861,
0.5627410412,
0.3657732904,
-0.4352469444,
-0.1057800725,
-0.1575233489,
-0.178665936,
0.4464315176,
0.5100624561,
0.0007711744,
-0.5611320734,
-0.0258442592,
-0.0916240737,
0.3278868496,
-0.4399926364,
0.7004420757,
0.0130535848,
-0.7904182673,
0.3268622458,
0.1552708745,
0.5912077427,
-0.6319667697,
0.0310647599,
-0.1251621097,
0.376975745,
0.2161781937,
-0.942660749,
0.2845592797,
-0.2010811418,
0.0334961861,
-0.5073308349,
0.7741548419,
-0.2004923224,
-0.3201552331,
0.6119215488,
0.4042014182,
-0.0391305685,
-0.0511086024,
-0.5369981527,
0.0895214081,
-0.2784262002,
-0.1415747404,
0.5694603324,
0.5968277454,
-0.3139389455,
0.9465709329,
0.6378080249,
0.1400210857,
0.0666173622,
0.0421376266,
0.8022417426,
-0.7618839741,
-0.4865466058,
-0.799387157,
0.2948208451,
-0.2173920125,
-0.4809122086,
0.6783406138,
0.8299487829,
1.2109345198,
0.0623681769,
0.4036429524,
0.1638218015,
0.4395807385,
-0.6893023849,
0.2406918406,
-0.4438239038,
0.4336168468,
-0.1357368082,
-1.1314389706,
-0.2819976807,
0.4170004725,
-0.6719488502,
-0.2111437917,
0.5633884072,
0.8548237085,
-0.1040457189,
-0.0679312274,
0.582259953,
-0.2091601044,
0.6139726043,
0.7223575115,
1.049430728,
-0.1376713812,
0.2004562765,
-0.4335003793,
-0.0950506926,
-0.2282077372,
-1.1771900654,
-0.9372249842,
-0.6625056863,
0.0499322861,
0.203362599,
-0.0161076672,
0.9584164023,
0.9209735394,
-0.3893562555,
-0.8646659851,
-0.2111812234,
-0.0641549304,
-0.1053684875,
-0.1733917594,
0.023431493,
-0.386652112,
-0.5462230444,
0.8114047647,
0.4416292012,
0.0025216015,
-0.4242824614,
-0.2932029665,
-0.3185313642,
0.0081207864,
0.879365027,
0.3159423769,
-0.6550059319,
-0.1222197115,
-0.1693593115,
0.0611991026,
-0.1916776597,
1.0001369715,
-0.5290190578,
0.2940070033,
0.3814620674,
0.5662928224,
0.8061769009,
-0.3476485908,
0.8427099586,
-0.8429653645,
0.2950766683,
0.3833646476,
0.5004378557,
0.268679738,
-0.2430352271,
0.7990962863,
-0.551584959,
-0.7836967707,
-0.8077095151,
0.4297368824,
-0.7653446794,
-0.3997914195,
1.3097629547,
0.1834696382,
0.194633618,
-0.0582302436,
-0.2026051134,
-0.0316055678,
-0.039239414,
0.5666327477,
0.6393188238,
-0.4211776555,
-0.0173150469,
-1.002122879,
0.6327523589,
0.1039996371,
-0.8356825113,
0.2784898579,
0.5001884103,
0.2110926509,
-0.0539435036,
0.8498413563,
0.0498088822,
-0.1358440965,
-0.4800495803,
-0.0383315198,
0.3210327625,
-0.4901740253,
-0.3820031881,
0.0911608711,
0.4947617352,
0.4222372174
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13092v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13092v1 | Multilingual Synopses of Movie Narratives: A Dataset for Story Understanding | 2024-06-18T22:44:50 | 2024-06-18T22:44:50 | Yidan Sun, Jianfei Yu, Boyang Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | Story video-text alignment, a core task in computational story understanding,
aims to align video clips with corresponding sentences in their descriptions.
However, progress on the task has been held back by the scarcity of manually
annotated video-text correspondence and the heavy concentration on English
narrations of Hollywood movies. To address these issues, in this paper, we
construct a large-scale multilingual video story dataset named Multilingual
Synopses of Movie Narratives (M-SYMON), containing 13,166 movie summary videos
from 7 languages, as well as manual annotation of fine-grained video-text
correspondences for 101.5 hours of video. Training on the human annotated data
from SyMoN outperforms the SOTA methods by 15.7 and 16.2 percentage points on
Clip Accuracy and Sentence IoU scores, respectively, demonstrating the
effectiveness of the annotations. As benchmarks for future research, we create
6 baseline approaches with different multilingual training strategies, compare
their performance in both intra-lingual and cross-lingual setups, exemplifying
the challenges of multilingual video-text alignment. | [
-0.2898439765,
-0.3657028079,
0.3239991069,
0.014101496,
-0.2588741183,
0.3003783226,
-0.3616134226,
-0.3968448341,
0.5186254382,
0.1921296418,
-0.8325922489,
-0.3853601515,
-0.5433793664,
0.4097563624,
-0.166996181,
1.3282754421,
-0.4317684472,
0.2227527201,
-0.0749510974,
-0.5729650259,
-0.3286954761,
-0.4556038678,
-0.2051573396,
0.2523048222,
0.5065277219,
0.3501648009,
0.8465107083,
0.9627546668,
0.4673781991,
0.2177744806,
0.3134309053,
0.4409461617,
-0.1557939798,
0.17051287,
-0.0329133309,
-0.1956067085,
-0.2142632753,
-0.1972313225,
0.8315436244,
0.4366867244,
-0.0155662084,
0.6633828282,
-0.127219677,
0.3077294528,
-0.7679696679,
0.0358330347,
-0.1593167037,
0.2317848057,
-0.4378938079,
-0.0539892539,
-0.1639343649,
-0.0004488945,
0.1162162945,
-0.9258572459,
0.2588722408,
-0.0867081955,
0.7069032192,
0.2797325253,
-0.2305718809,
-0.0259272363,
-0.5152246952,
0.5884388685,
-0.393748492,
0.4189954996,
0.3664830327,
0.4327195883,
0.4955613315,
-0.0888138637,
-0.6640646458,
0.2401143461,
-0.1227275357,
-0.0096458355,
0.0830788836,
-0.0848566592,
0.3956208527,
0.1675737351,
-0.8397986293,
0.1981419772,
-0.4014558494,
-0.4425029755,
0.6955156922,
0.3743341863,
0.3969271481,
-0.4088606536,
-0.4031622708,
-0.4423692822,
-0.24061656,
0.1304097474,
0.4647528827,
0.1632959098,
-0.3532227278,
0.651013732,
-0.017131988,
0.7392277718,
-0.3695454895,
-0.6908072829,
0.4346913099,
-0.6615718603,
-0.2230876833,
0.4649202228,
0.8793013096,
0.8307173252,
0.4440304637,
0.0043145278,
0.2750723064,
0.3645946383,
-0.0731858537,
-0.5549319386,
0.0223166998,
-0.039293807,
-0.1853271276,
0.2752084136,
0.1366380006,
-0.8240118027,
-0.5229634047,
-0.2816099226,
0.4322198927,
-0.3404529095,
0.1063458771,
-0.0937922373,
-0.3089047074,
0.0068457127,
0.1727274507,
-1.1110179424,
0.0656054914,
0.3935005963,
0.9128690958,
0.0353371799,
-0.9456231594,
-0.6853777766,
0.682798624,
-0.3043062091,
0.6304885745,
-0.2393277436,
0.3344687521,
0.188296929,
0.0051530558,
-0.2113834471,
-0.0817164704,
0.4467388093,
0.0462242328,
0.4377962053,
-0.0576084442,
-0.2067256272,
-0.2932580113,
0.4412650168,
-0.6712450385,
0.6743367314,
-0.2301276624,
-0.6397826076,
0.2942768633,
-0.14626275,
-0.4243920445,
-0.3938967288,
-0.4457592666,
-0.0775249377,
0.0386301242,
0.693053484,
0.3562211096,
-0.1651428342,
0.4804854691,
0.0353408344,
-0.3880115151,
0.206625253,
-0.5108501315,
0.482011795,
0.147261858,
-0.2205736339,
-0.1263421923,
-0.6469714642,
-0.208498314,
-0.2359686494,
0.214587912,
-0.2101321369,
-0.2680705488,
0.0915890634,
0.4340618551,
0.0398536287,
-0.4095117748,
0.0790389702,
-0.2853045166,
0.3263863921,
0.581092,
-0.298858583,
0.3670753241,
-0.2266159356,
0.7440848351,
-0.1059518978,
0.1833086461,
-0.8678770661,
-0.0850803182,
-0.4273263514,
-0.1630889773,
-0.024832163,
0.5941642523,
-0.725864768,
-0.1328409612,
-0.4624828398,
-0.3155798316,
-0.7712666988,
0.3669808507,
0.6600194573,
0.3556967378,
0.424683392,
-0.2198626995,
-0.6417455077,
-0.8221834302,
-0.2505476773,
-0.1693613082,
0.0666776896,
-0.064653039,
0.1642200798,
0.1074857041,
0.6314101219,
-0.4615553916,
-0.5050244927,
-0.271239996,
-0.1280967444,
0.2978437543,
0.1758154482,
0.3487070203,
-0.6860455275,
-0.5377402902,
0.1852161139,
-1.0864104033,
0.131434828,
-0.2193916887,
0.1221300438,
0.1640795171,
0.6318674088,
-0.6254114509,
0.1384303421,
0.8038259745,
-0.2272412777,
0.7449659109,
-0.3207208514,
0.5612008572,
-1.1571294069,
-0.0588430911,
0.1669870466,
0.0363104902,
-0.4741292894,
-0.2224098295,
-0.075215213,
-0.2378188968,
-0.5560973287,
0.576317966,
-0.3223459423,
-0.2350300252,
0.207830742,
0.5915580988,
0.1205428466,
0.6382020116,
0.116543211,
0.6318252683,
0.3969077766,
-0.2488301843,
0.4323055446,
0.60594064,
-0.4012326002,
0.6667141318,
-0.170416683,
-0.2324190587,
-0.3091278076,
0.2449157685,
-0.912907362,
-0.5363599658,
0.0411492065,
-0.2938140929,
0.038763348,
-0.1454295814,
-0.5621550679,
-0.0593387149,
-0.3890631795,
0.6041170359,
-0.0837320909,
-0.3900725842,
0.4521923065,
0.47717309,
-0.4079807401,
-0.9868583679,
-0.5885700583,
0.3331986368,
-0.5991275907,
-0.6688386798,
0.4003266692,
0.0452194363,
-0.1704288274,
-0.3905009031,
-0.300908953,
-0.1617614478,
-0.336492449,
0.0683664232,
0.2871176004,
-0.2187150866,
0.2064512521,
0.1169348732,
-0.206274718,
-0.1992565542,
-0.1014863253,
0.2997282147,
0.2848147452,
0.0129053295,
-0.5424231291,
0.5724080205,
0.529687047,
-0.2831385732,
0.372852087,
0.9370902777,
-0.2397864163,
0.3153063655,
-0.4717776775,
0.0325018354,
-0.3183507323,
0.6973033547,
-0.3623932004,
-0.8723468781,
0.3132887185,
0.33434847,
0.2631361783,
0.3526674211,
0.2598883808,
-0.4472339451,
0.9836714268,
0.6163362265,
-0.1468274593,
0.5167498589,
-0.057998307,
0.0975778326,
-0.4451713264,
-0.1514865011,
-0.3112239838,
-0.4419403076,
-0.4358700514,
-0.2883962989,
0.4479868114,
0.2249738127,
-0.2607331574,
0.5970201492,
0.0554457195,
0.838439703,
0.1869054884,
-0.2444341034,
0.4765022993,
0.321831882,
-0.0245360583,
-0.4279610515,
-0.7251647115,
-0.5462827086,
0.6995817423,
0.2970452309,
0.5766739845,
0.4427767098,
0.4226693511,
0.0104133142,
-0.2427549809,
-0.3268577456,
0.3728743196,
-0.5533778667,
-0.4709065855,
-0.3204216957,
-0.2122873813,
-0.6691351533,
0.192188397,
-0.3706685305,
-1.0260201693,
-0.1339990348,
0.1664314419,
-0.5296853781,
0.1434144527,
-0.8478265405,
1.2651032209,
-0.3959903419,
-0.3733198643,
-0.1804125458,
-1.1651259661,
0.1351446062,
-0.0706668571,
0.6048466563,
-0.0902578384,
0.0833685622,
0.8825064898,
-0.3339470923,
0.6686162949,
0.0713884681,
-0.0646613911,
0.1719154269,
0.0666325539,
0.1779396683,
0.1920229495,
0.2997958362,
0.1155142933,
0.2636259794,
-0.2555412054,
-0.6250289679,
0.363764286,
-0.6723888516,
-0.3112928271,
-0.4569817185,
-0.840759635,
-0.2626428306,
0.0442251526,
0.2649740279,
0.6120878458,
-0.160092786,
-0.2310603261,
0.2753632665,
-0.2439986616,
0.7598849535,
0.1529894322,
-0.2832063138,
-1.0529515743,
0.7936971784,
0.1106040925,
0.2165812254,
0.5298553109,
-0.1630511731,
-0.3192430437,
-0.1195843443,
-0.97282058,
0.2562116981,
-0.530531168,
-0.202158168,
-0.5404880047,
0.0878792331,
-0.2500471473,
-0.2614756227,
-0.2385563552,
-0.3955473602,
0.2133925408,
-0.4685783088,
0.3938970268,
0.3099660575,
-0.0022755922,
0.4971371889,
-1.0335441828,
0.2793241739,
-0.0136590078,
0.1053821221,
-0.306383431,
-0.460031718,
-0.8490744829,
-0.1510640383,
-0.2929024994,
-0.7247216105,
0.2708264291,
0.510771513,
0.3288257122,
0.339583993,
-0.333864361,
1.3320987225,
-0.5117064118,
0.7666311264,
0.5215755701,
-0.8143108487,
0.4255577028,
-0.4284048676,
0.5216631889,
0.7444814444,
0.4847717881,
-0.8638397455,
-0.2414017618,
-0.4234682024,
-0.6237697005,
0.7403829694,
0.1220680103,
0.2152516693,
0.2533894181,
0.0225510281,
0.4435759187,
0.2563694715,
-0.6146115661,
-0.1856057644,
-0.0613360107,
-0.4591282904,
-0.8801674843,
0.0452348739,
-0.2251960039,
-0.1498136073,
0.3738504052,
-0.2914815247,
-0.2755943835,
0.1380210221,
-0.5013967752,
-0.0747605786,
0.1393568963,
0.5200836062,
0.5333339572,
-0.1207636148,
0.3659241796,
0.1558009982,
-0.6017569304,
0.4235228598,
0.2632889748,
-0.0335427076,
0.2096827179,
0.6969674826,
0.8732640743,
0.1853689104,
-1.1469792128,
0.3314526379,
0.1669405699,
-0.1394738704,
-0.1100036502,
-0.3187417984,
-0.2463799566,
0.3538302481,
0.2606727779,
-0.0395789295,
-0.0959650204,
-0.6535277367,
0.1689439565,
0.080603309,
-0.3267570436,
-0.3305723369,
0.4036091566,
-0.1055940688,
-0.1382326633,
0.5316597819,
0.0595246404,
-0.3669045568,
0.3590896726,
0.4377234578,
0.5380861759,
-0.1659846902,
0.436144799,
0.5550093055,
0.3857341409,
-0.2778392732,
-0.0352675021,
-0.0259508248,
-0.5701132417,
-0.9169225097,
-0.5478623509,
-0.2315712571,
-0.2289236933,
-0.4930413961,
0.4361124337,
-0.089969039,
0.0262614395,
0.1264957488,
-0.1615998894,
-0.3761401474,
0.1188178584,
0.3912198544,
0.6698493361,
-1.2914842367,
0.6663264632,
0.8343766928,
-0.4803549349,
-0.7641999125,
-0.1207550541,
0.1029888988,
-0.4139364362,
0.4692316353,
0.4957820773,
0.1201552376,
-0.2246728241,
0.0782382786,
-0.792973876,
1.0310325623,
0.8039553165,
-0.5100247264,
-0.214638561,
0.2139252275,
0.6501516104,
-0.3335951269,
0.1747893989,
0.4831198156,
0.2619128823,
-0.2241895497,
-1.1923961639,
-0.4578995109,
-0.2792339325,
-0.4569504559,
0.4634342492,
-0.507160008,
0.5033445954,
-0.2867034972,
-0.1296940893,
0.0208313353,
0.5019835234,
0.4676790833,
0.707469523,
0.3033822775,
0.6766136289,
0.4637329876,
0.1279510558,
0.7654919028,
0.0417058878,
0.0754442364,
1.4088577032,
0.0372335017,
0.7496014833,
0.7438154817,
-0.1570023447,
0.490747124,
0.6142328978,
-0.042615626,
0.3300952613,
-0.1272139847,
-0.0412717685,
-0.2815772593,
-0.4324957728,
-0.0612891838,
0.5926312804,
0.030593453,
-0.2179001868,
-0.3035138249,
0.3190240264,
0.0166026428,
0.3823982477,
-0.3969617486,
0.8156579137,
-0.0353212021,
-0.7529206872,
0.2704167962,
-0.3626477122,
0.4781516194,
-0.6732265353,
-0.0060827737,
-0.1513884068,
0.1116224974,
-0.2572546005,
-0.6485356092,
0.1656272709,
0.459474802,
-0.3917255402,
-0.2507769465,
-0.1074631438,
-0.8267459869,
-0.4694678187,
0.0970683992,
0.3517219722,
0.3572301567,
0.2141727358,
-0.4606142044,
0.2589711547,
0.0172697119,
0.3895184994,
0.4024192691,
0.3818424344,
-0.3706528246,
0.2064494491,
0.24038966,
-0.1462880522,
-0.1299192011,
0.1830672324,
0.1847578138,
-0.5120809078,
-0.6227636933,
-1.0812369585,
0.5488747954,
0.0205322877,
-0.574249804,
0.9711205959,
0.7923855186,
1.2306450605,
-0.1959858984,
0.5890541077,
0.0199269988,
0.0091743432,
-0.7941185832,
0.1137832478,
-0.3867478669,
0.0651933849,
-0.5700156093,
-1.1800639629,
-0.4084325731,
0.5892964602,
0.0287774689,
-0.2897022367,
0.9037415385,
0.5866135955,
-0.085500665,
-0.0555505529,
0.0090886839,
0.0434016846,
0.0755794123,
0.6282328367,
0.8299241662,
-0.6254097819,
0.7724069357,
-0.3560789227,
-0.0500839725,
0.0858057514,
-0.8487922549,
-0.7676062584,
-0.7494743466,
-0.3688018024,
-0.0884814858,
0.1390446275,
0.991294086,
0.5322520137,
-0.5900107026,
-0.7592898011,
0.3697138727,
-0.0839448273,
-0.5362457633,
-0.0728224516,
0.548548162,
-0.0983681753,
-0.7377135754,
0.4386618137,
0.4266164005,
-0.0231086109,
-0.108668685,
-0.1944928318,
-0.3258062601,
-0.4742555916,
0.4016932249,
0.2211227417,
-0.5811103582,
-0.0710885972,
0.0882956982,
0.024959445,
0.0476723611,
0.8367636204,
-0.3756445944,
0.7453702092,
0.3671340942,
0.571277082,
0.6448013783,
0.1210905537,
0.8245010972,
-1.1325774193,
0.3170631826,
-0.1789387763,
0.4833864868,
0.3558455408,
-0.1960176378,
0.5523916483,
0.1385395974,
-0.2068050951,
-0.8279783726,
0.0882443935,
-1.2297116518,
-0.158106491,
0.9601936936,
-0.0718797669,
-0.0805315971,
0.0818094462,
-0.4304820299,
0.3054782152,
-0.1642063111,
0.5813706517,
0.8880921006,
0.0020647391,
-0.3104551435,
-0.6837558746,
0.5886136889,
0.3958712518,
-0.6808114648,
0.4003866017,
0.6403170824,
-0.1231047213,
0.4346785843,
0.3671008646,
-0.0130456416,
0.4501268864,
-0.1409755051,
0.0164386705,
-0.110117428,
-0.6642453074,
-0.521188736,
0.0637336597,
-0.3567816615,
-0.2112973481
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13069v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13069v2 | Evaluating $n$-Gram Novelty of Language Models Using Rusty-DAWG | 2024-06-18T21:31:19 | 2024-06-25T15:02:40 | William Merrill, Noah A. Smith, Yanai Elazar | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | How novel are texts generated by language models (LMs) relative to their
training corpora? In this work, we investigate the extent to which modern LMs
generate $n$-grams from their training data, evaluating both (i) the
probability LMs assign to complete training $n$-grams and (ii) $n$-novelty, the
proportion of $n$-grams generated by an LM that did not appear in the training
data (for arbitrarily large $n$). To enable arbitrary-length $n$-gram search
over a corpus in constant time, we develop Rusty-DAWG, a novel search tool
inspired by indexing of genomic data. We compare the novelty of LM-generated
text to human-written text and explore factors that affect generation novelty,
focusing on the Pythia models. We find that, for $n > 4$, LM-generated text is
less novel than human-written text, though it is more novel for smaller $n$.
Larger LMs and more constrained decoding strategies both decrease novelty.
Finally, we show that LMs complete $n$-grams with lower loss if they are more
frequent in the training data. Overall, our results reveal factors influencing
the novelty of LM-generated text, and we release Rusty-DAWG to facilitate
further pretraining data research. | [
-0.2778188586,
-0.9599656463,
0.7400894761,
-0.2396139801,
-0.3829073906,
0.1542434245,
-0.2253535241,
-0.2811064124,
0.1993981451,
0.1526605189,
-0.4166451991,
-0.6868810058,
-0.4853468537,
0.4103597105,
-0.7763810158,
1.0755039454,
0.3037993014,
-0.0831603855,
-0.3080231845,
0.2795675695,
0.0354145728,
-0.5461791158,
-0.0937493891,
-0.3068873584,
0.7559453845,
0.4540537298,
0.6626905799,
0.7289745212,
0.4136478901,
0.2432725579,
-0.3944760561,
0.0959478021,
-0.6241861582,
-0.0188715924,
0.1883714348,
-0.3723299801,
-0.2599412501,
0.0778709874,
0.8788690567,
0.8514630198,
0.0256130416,
-0.0136974109,
-0.2098537385,
0.7066222429,
-0.6312750578,
-0.1261413097,
-0.8258110881,
-0.0283218417,
-0.500013113,
-0.3816795051,
-0.5349951386,
-0.551081121,
0.3039675355,
-0.3899669647,
0.6829235554,
-0.090522036,
0.8954545856,
-0.2685967684,
-0.3370196521,
-0.5691428185,
-0.681260705,
0.7342271209,
-0.9504750967,
-0.1091217175,
0.1579678208,
0.0366625451,
-0.618657589,
-0.6971290112,
-0.749014616,
-0.5842491984,
0.1218736544,
-0.2004138231,
-0.149883762,
-0.0144077418,
0.0763822719,
0.8372793198,
-0.6971597075,
0.1931869388,
-0.1223709285,
-0.0394781791,
0.7558461428,
0.3462267518,
0.5497070551,
-0.0585260205,
-0.2019151002,
-0.2542556226,
-0.6569468975,
-0.3335644901,
0.9066928029,
0.2387845367,
0.020426536,
0.3971937299,
-0.3092652857,
0.7534490824,
-0.1710420251,
-0.2132343799,
0.6058470011,
-0.1950887293,
0.0166009478,
0.078186214,
1.0106698275,
0.1437683403,
0.4832544625,
-0.5778993964,
-0.2100679576,
-0.029965939,
0.2091601938,
-0.8031068444,
-0.362108767,
0.0100043798,
-0.5647448897,
-0.7289507985,
0.2008253783,
-0.4797836542,
-0.3298193514,
0.2079326659,
0.4098678231,
-0.6209644079,
-0.3504885137,
0.2721804678,
-0.7307155132,
0.0006385377,
0.1472268701,
-0.9533361793,
0.1671703011,
0.4191554189,
0.7989566326,
-0.1460959613,
-0.3548103571,
-0.3886576295,
-0.192789495,
-0.6022878289,
0.5916513801,
-0.4705829024,
-0.4667344689,
-0.0312710293,
-0.1260140687,
0.0830038935,
-0.5270799398,
0.4501317143,
-0.5017522573,
0.0730010197,
-0.0464092791,
-0.5670075417,
-0.0910267308,
0.063296698,
-0.5263361335,
1.130438447,
0.2253314853,
-1.1187000275,
0.5974359512,
-0.3326763809,
-0.3630633354,
0.3008651137,
-0.2091263235,
-0.3708740771,
0.5188809633,
-0.3221985102,
0.2518180013,
-0.4741733074,
0.1876602918,
-0.5817880034,
-0.7390118241,
0.6700227857,
-0.6073437929,
0.5096744895,
0.1923169941,
-0.2910735309,
-0.0983828977,
-1.1436499357,
0.2832957804,
0.545096457,
-0.6072565317,
-0.5738435388,
0.0222764537,
0.1596994847,
-0.0791370794,
0.3438737988,
-0.8074099422,
0.3247629702,
-0.5400594473,
0.4352608025,
0.3965773582,
0.0535419509,
0.3122702539,
-0.448641181,
0.327832371,
-0.0024080868,
-0.0997403264,
-0.1801563948,
-0.5810409188,
-0.4927506447,
-0.0845642462,
0.4776199758,
0.1041643173,
-0.6434546113,
0.2100686133,
-0.4985355735,
-0.7871117592,
-0.2364479452,
0.0757695213,
0.2900658548,
-0.0025665027,
0.0469675846,
-0.4516819715,
-0.3714591563,
-0.952801168,
-0.3799201846,
-0.0302929971,
-0.1742155105,
0.1718246192,
0.3942042589,
-0.2915681601,
1.1342128515,
-0.4758241475,
0.2252876163,
-0.4026540518,
0.6333718896,
0.21014373,
0.2505161464,
0.819465816,
-0.5271140933,
-0.5256127715,
-0.029444525,
-0.5628519058,
-0.2448845953,
0.0981459841,
0.4119825661,
0.4294498563,
0.3459581733,
-0.4395143688,
0.475607276,
0.5452871323,
-0.0236126147,
0.6662083864,
-0.569632113,
-0.2248728126,
-0.8216522336,
0.1626847535,
-0.2833856642,
-0.0278439689,
-0.6650948524,
0.2812222838,
0.1162720248,
0.0843439028,
-0.2897210419,
0.5679160357,
-0.7933588624,
0.0350289233,
-0.656747818,
0.435747236,
-0.2269269675,
0.3041622043,
-0.2034470737,
0.6894818544,
0.3779802918,
-0.6906502843,
-0.0100763822,
-0.0006298643,
-0.418284893,
-0.1661659926,
-0.5092271566,
0.4853295386,
-0.238452062,
0.022129098,
-0.7973816395,
-0.2169621587,
0.0508249588,
-0.6027222872,
0.252435416,
-0.3036141396,
-0.6755228639,
-0.4913734496,
-0.4092639089,
0.2449329793,
0.5230771899,
-0.2592701614,
0.1784308255,
0.2963351607,
-0.1867289692,
-0.4104132354,
-0.7654772997,
0.2731611133,
-0.1618478596,
-0.4648421109,
0.4372120798,
-0.1315999627,
-0.1588032842,
0.1067648008,
-0.0954573601,
-0.0227147564,
0.3529894352,
0.0979188606,
0.0005731822,
-0.0895776823,
0.163810879,
-0.0997075289,
0.0556816831,
0.1124866903,
-0.3896408975,
0.9126096368,
-0.2280945182,
-0.1366975009,
0.0854642242,
0.3357014954,
0.3091781437,
0.0020625112,
0.8106009364,
0.8249088526,
-0.1417581588,
-0.241577968,
-0.2831661701,
-0.085377343,
-0.4564515054,
0.5418916941,
-0.2884047031,
-0.5412570238,
0.3147679865,
0.1872241944,
-0.1071159169,
0.4889397323,
0.7722069621,
0.1884582192,
0.8859656453,
0.7309470177,
0.1345914304,
0.5430221558,
-0.198204726,
0.2965831757,
-0.4539399743,
-0.0539394878,
-0.5262135863,
-0.2391791642,
-0.9643044472,
-0.2474563867,
0.2944127619,
0.1400739849,
0.0876960754,
0.0738498643,
-0.3317150772,
0.437301904,
0.8228314519,
-0.1553011239,
0.2745151818,
0.0455069542,
-0.4284710586,
0.0921768844,
-0.9902201295,
-0.7788179517,
1.4353464842,
0.3066202104,
0.8209581971,
0.2386437207,
1.1659520864,
0.1481970996,
0.2863009274,
-0.7622191906,
0.5885965228,
-0.3821964264,
-0.5358318686,
-0.2321379036,
-0.8643481135,
-1.085734129,
-0.0852773041,
-0.3342549801,
-0.7053874731,
-0.0685872287,
0.0025256327,
0.0129383374,
0.3123682141,
-0.6620212197,
0.5921686292,
-0.2249447554,
-0.2566742301,
-0.082663469,
-0.505566895,
0.3922981322,
-0.078254737,
0.157008782,
-0.1966368705,
0.2028454989,
0.6054283977,
-0.4414140284,
0.5900669694,
0.0327680446,
-0.37214306,
0.3757260144,
0.0347800367,
0.4247226119,
0.1134423241,
0.0622239709,
0.0512788892,
0.0134854745,
-0.3548270762,
-0.3080158234,
0.7450712323,
-0.5756947994,
-0.5888893604,
-0.6542901397,
-0.8492242098,
0.0340816379,
0.4547190964,
0.4647141993,
0.5172156692,
-0.4201636612,
0.4171150625,
0.5522550941,
-0.5234054327,
0.5676072836,
0.561445415,
-0.2464250326,
-0.1636739373,
1.1083060503,
0.2056469023,
0.4816417694,
0.3285548687,
0.494692564,
-0.0974765122,
-0.875199616,
-0.6530727148,
0.1149505675,
-0.634119451,
0.1421655715,
-0.7768455744,
-0.3491779864,
-0.2654685974,
0.2927203774,
-0.0838074088,
-0.4669782519,
-0.2420206219,
0.2591035664,
0.5190796256,
0.9329544902,
-0.0527598895,
0.3223411739,
-0.9847916961,
0.1729592085,
0.1027168557,
0.3364467025,
0.1179841831,
-0.5035329461,
-0.4665006995,
0.2435582876,
-0.278105706,
-1.1082470417,
0.3835197687,
0.2826682031,
0.6203664541,
0.4264684618,
0.1634158641,
0.0296827871,
-0.5545361638,
0.692931354,
-0.0861297101,
-0.6813956499,
-0.0270035192,
-0.7788348198,
0.4279401004,
0.3764362335,
0.2444594502,
-0.4099150598,
-0.6632344127,
-0.8119080663,
-1.0524069071,
0.588085115,
0.2530197501,
0.4888644218,
-0.4488671422,
0.2395795286,
0.0830881521,
0.3103299141,
-0.6502581239,
-0.4868717492,
0.0760658458,
-0.3251653016,
-0.0033345199,
-0.5588119626,
0.1240288168,
0.1861028969,
0.4998438358,
-0.1380968988,
0.2028826326,
0.0342312865,
-0.1757910103,
0.111400798,
0.4056953192,
0.6705584526,
0.2619072199,
-0.5087431073,
0.1475908458,
0.0409637392,
-0.8477712274,
0.1134508774,
-0.0195090175,
-0.3626803458,
0.4969816804,
0.1937416941,
0.7542899847,
0.3544508517,
-0.74803406,
0.3357640207,
-0.1529202908,
-0.4619817436,
-0.3203350902,
0.2758325636,
0.2752692103,
-0.2191318572,
0.5853008032,
-0.2308642268,
0.2647057176,
-0.7073113322,
0.0257347673,
0.4999126494,
0.30442819,
-0.1297467053,
0.4073266983,
-0.0371078923,
-0.2836648226,
0.4281277061,
-0.8183722496,
-0.3537235558,
0.5671281219,
0.6975458264,
0.8881481886,
0.2837519944,
0.2787318528,
0.2924727499,
0.2577900589,
-0.0147656705,
0.2540625334,
0.2046494335,
-0.5360085964,
-0.0779719353,
-0.7280845642,
-0.30387339,
0.312508136,
-0.6259486079,
0.3766733408,
-0.299772948,
-0.2134458423,
-0.1481550783,
0.0686129704,
-0.4627276063,
0.1738544255,
0.160226047,
0.8177226782,
-0.6070492268,
0.8289462924,
0.5860839486,
-0.4774805307,
-0.6708527803,
0.3358076215,
-0.1768648028,
-0.542193532,
0.5734677315,
0.1817228198,
-0.165923208,
0.1415332407,
-0.2433538735,
-0.9187003374,
0.860676825,
0.2458630204,
-0.6718956828,
-0.2727238238,
0.2032424361,
0.698066175,
-0.0497325547,
0.2138852179,
0.4987393618,
0.2401008606,
-0.0337420553,
-0.7687161565,
-0.3192872405,
-0.5959272385,
0.104415521,
0.3526845276,
-0.3677175045,
1.3503712416,
-0.4013751745,
-0.5309281349,
0.4140816331,
0.2270077467,
0.3292258382,
0.3168981075,
0.2341016531,
0.5503718257,
0.7360075116,
-0.0037527292,
1.0828948021,
-0.4184713066,
0.3669892848,
1.0878030062,
-0.0753244907,
0.7380348444,
0.373380661,
-0.0175022259,
0.6879501343,
0.4895307422,
-0.0309656896,
0.3701250851,
0.6496856213,
-0.3251425326,
0.02858961,
0.2300340235,
-0.5580084324,
0.5591610074,
0.0579760894,
-0.4661802649,
-0.3871742785,
-0.2748524845,
0.1169310063,
0.1064523831,
-0.0863620192,
0.7780361176,
0.0189906936,
-0.2473296076,
0.900277853,
0.387421608,
0.7118979096,
-0.5633912683,
0.1922624856,
-0.3344754577,
0.2311056256,
-0.0693467259,
-0.4117947221,
0.1126309112,
0.2330503017,
-0.4007022977,
0.1491953731,
0.5824823976,
-0.5793787241,
-0.4495779872,
0.0033324717,
0.4292910397,
0.4091886878,
0.0558235198,
-0.1672295183,
-0.1044039726,
-0.2919601798,
-0.2894215882,
0.6178753972,
0.709849596,
-0.1057322174,
0.6845868826,
0.7369507551,
0.1955525428,
0.2515848279,
0.0599944033,
0.7291612029,
-0.7045828104,
-0.5896821618,
-0.8167163134,
0.0912079513,
-0.0155462818,
-0.325396508,
1.0660840273,
0.4810001552,
0.8234533668,
-0.3847554922,
1.0665379763,
-0.2356616855,
0.4642964303,
-0.7025514841,
0.9148141742,
-0.6581726074,
0.1387274861,
-0.4564694464,
-0.6866672039,
0.1065759063,
0.458853811,
-0.4476073682,
0.2312050313,
0.7346180081,
0.6697570086,
0.1444315761,
-0.0543830805,
0.2869692743,
0.1644501537,
0.2199328095,
0.5814243555,
0.9003642797,
-0.4293229282,
0.6149265766,
0.1065888405,
-0.0117399851,
-0.491941005,
-1.0704865456,
-0.7967764735,
-0.4382620156,
-0.0359403752,
-0.1725704819,
-0.1540594101,
0.7542624474,
0.2239086032,
-0.5500516295,
-0.0506722629,
-0.4916938841,
-0.1359202266,
-0.0340806916,
-0.2234075665,
0.0848054215,
-0.527038455,
-0.7571678162,
0.465821594,
0.0697163567,
0.2839247882,
-0.3133161366,
-0.1043008491,
-0.2124683112,
0.0108482093,
0.21922943,
0.0969038233,
-0.5511955619,
-0.1983397901,
0.193640694,
-0.3094131052,
-0.0855953023,
0.8437578678,
-0.7838645577,
0.4037109613,
0.5388228893,
0.5467368364,
0.3365884423,
-0.3575965166,
0.7525604963,
-0.8199549913,
0.3006583154,
0.1506443322,
0.1671750098,
0.3745948672,
-0.0864234939,
0.2129744142,
0.3772997856,
-0.4768953323,
-1.0582985878,
0.1918203682,
-0.5181290507,
-0.3352635801,
1.2899247408,
-0.1781542003,
-0.1718639135,
-0.1016437486,
-0.1538744271,
0.3021843135,
-0.0860996321,
0.9341721535,
0.7335345149,
0.3800704479,
0.0614877082,
-0.5703742504,
0.6011973023,
0.335067302,
-0.6041849852,
0.0380410329,
0.3477297425,
0.6355172992,
0.194271788,
0.524787426,
-0.128625378,
0.429630667,
0.4347470701,
0.2460568547,
-0.2912434936,
-0.3686448634,
-0.1791404337,
0.1296877563,
0.5002666712,
-0.0828886703
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13050v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13050v1 | Think-then-Act: A Dual-Angle Evaluated Retrieval-Augmented Generation | 2024-06-18T20:51:34 | 2024-06-18T20:51:34 | Yige Shen, Hao Jiang, Hua Qu, Jihong Zhao | cs.CL | cs.CL | Despite their impressive capabilities, large language models (LLMs) often
face challenges such as temporal misalignment and generating hallucinatory
content. Enhancing LLMs with retrieval mechanisms to fetch relevant information
from external sources offers a promising solution. Inspired by the proverb
"Think twice before you act," we propose a dual-angle evaluated
retrieval-augmented generation framework \textit{Think-then-Act}. Unlike
previous approaches that indiscriminately rewrite queries or perform retrieval
regardless of necessity, or generate temporary responses before deciding on
additional retrieval, which increases model generation costs, our framework
employs a two-phase process: (i) assessing the input query for clarity and
completeness to determine if rewriting is necessary; and (ii) evaluating the
model's capability to answer the query and deciding if additional retrieval is
needed. Experimental results on five datasets show that the
\textit{Think-then-Act} framework significantly improves performance. Our
framework demonstrates notable improvements in accuracy and efficiency compared
to existing baselines and performs well in both English and non-English
contexts. Ablation studies validate the optimal model confidence threshold,
highlighting the resource optimization benefits of our approach. | [
-0.2753271759,
-0.8059589267,
0.5276864171,
0.0932748765,
-0.2174767703,
0.2165714055,
-0.0682156011,
-0.5232151151,
0.248075515,
0.585916996,
-0.6496876478,
0.2198494077,
-0.211626038,
-0.0564613789,
-0.3982127309,
0.5694482923,
-0.0182751995,
0.3894173503,
-0.051276844,
0.0347164981,
-0.4668194354,
-0.140205875,
-1.1430313587,
-0.3400869071,
0.3018509448,
0.3230885565,
0.7788841724,
0.1090798751,
0.5280290842,
0.3256277144,
0.2462046146,
0.4137799442,
-0.4269938767,
0.254234761,
-0.3497471809,
-0.7727755308,
-0.3138343096,
-0.0084201265,
0.636023283,
0.4598741531,
-0.2484118491,
0.3502415419,
-0.0632140338,
0.853758812,
-0.5666701794,
-0.1043536589,
-0.6174600124,
0.0234973785,
-0.037608631,
-0.3005359471,
-0.4231082201,
-0.4987466633,
0.060511142,
-0.3494818211,
0.1342588812,
0.3958066702,
0.5154616237,
0.0272940993,
-0.4247224331,
-0.0056039202,
-0.6903895736,
0.6017127037,
-0.5561988354,
0.5385805964,
0.027131943,
0.2229865491,
-0.3629291952,
-1.1358716488,
-0.9719595313,
-0.3366588354,
0.045628652,
-0.1275088787,
-0.1060131639,
-0.0742825121,
0.2369627208,
0.3598488271,
-0.6447506547,
-0.2509509623,
-0.2249232084,
-0.2056245059,
0.7124977112,
-0.0968038887,
0.2570540309,
-0.1830123961,
-0.6015658975,
-0.2692868114,
-0.7804214358,
0.0505256392,
0.3544360697,
0.4167333245,
0.3438867033,
0.9307348132,
0.0523424,
0.2734512091,
0.378051579,
0.2816335261,
0.0175178126,
-0.58516258,
-0.2182171196,
-0.1052430347,
0.7699301243,
0.1697289944,
0.2437402904,
0.0330266282,
-0.4030154347,
0.0602639802,
0.6466830969,
-0.6796207428,
-0.03899692,
0.4015355706,
-0.3067479134,
-0.177587539,
-0.1294635683,
-0.7256126404,
-0.3327477276,
-0.4944791794,
0.8513925672,
-0.4171323478,
-0.7400849462,
-0.0286984295,
0.1184101403,
0.0605864301,
-0.1894845366,
-0.5374852419,
0.2875108421,
0.8949729204,
0.6508034468,
0.0631094798,
-0.1647515297,
-0.6990681291,
-0.1526026726,
-0.5805326104,
0.9354832768,
-0.5737729669,
-0.491070956,
0.2423924655,
-0.2765910625,
0.172737062,
-0.4898928106,
0.4832618833,
-0.9918419719,
0.3750198483,
-0.5008878708,
-0.3364723325,
-0.0434961021,
0.170203656,
-0.655185163,
1.463239789,
0.0508247726,
-0.6525298953,
0.7921966314,
-0.617922008,
-0.6144158244,
0.2293082029,
-0.3253865242,
-0.2922739983,
0.3285485506,
-0.0274309982,
0.0383134261,
-0.2961005569,
0.3088642359,
-0.2812525928,
-0.0236596465,
0.3189525902,
-0.1889349967,
0.5878617764,
-0.037757162,
-0.5247211456,
0.0810215846,
-0.5290622711,
0.7030380368,
0.2878933847,
-0.3231827915,
-0.3333650827,
0.0440006517,
-0.1908955574,
0.4497030973,
0.241286248,
-0.5665714145,
0.1456525922,
-0.6668521762,
0.0466674231,
0.6718905568,
0.0193076003,
0.4182170033,
-0.3492335975,
0.5872613788,
-0.2316474319,
0.0154250218,
0.1786539257,
-0.282261014,
-0.8659064174,
0.2593735158,
-0.0932057127,
0.5142053366,
-1.278783679,
0.1124076545,
-0.2774029076,
-0.2232119292,
-0.6636090875,
0.2682109475,
0.8234607577,
0.5218518376,
0.4000129104,
-0.3014596105,
-0.8036918044,
-0.8540978432,
-0.6152536273,
-0.6847428679,
0.3680562973,
0.1448329091,
0.4332917929,
0.1695469618,
0.8320544362,
-0.5353682637,
-0.0706184357,
-0.461817801,
0.510623455,
-0.1986825764,
0.1255570948,
0.13278386,
-1.2439930439,
-0.310431838,
-0.3330357075,
-0.349690944,
-0.2072308511,
-0.0831299499,
-0.5164999366,
0.4485627413,
0.4457387626,
-0.7592962384,
0.1083638445,
0.1462936103,
-0.4626840651,
0.4874107242,
-0.318666786,
0.2702152729,
-1.0458590984,
0.0728454441,
-0.3458343744,
-0.2093747407,
-0.5183856487,
0.2254924029,
0.2122736275,
0.056254793,
-0.4538348317,
0.6810467839,
-0.5225827098,
-0.1281471848,
-0.5793064237,
0.1663175672,
0.2174271792,
0.2901115417,
0.0633665323,
1.2008035183,
0.1874968261,
-0.817042172,
0.0321177132,
0.040508043,
-0.5873436332,
0.7387802005,
-0.3119309545,
0.421582967,
-0.2070237845,
0.1274120063,
-0.8985791206,
-0.135741204,
0.074631691,
-0.2623587251,
0.7257336378,
0.226484701,
-0.5303020477,
-0.8034162521,
-0.3919819593,
0.3476186991,
0.2482247353,
-0.6406894326,
0.7501730323,
0.6360177994,
-0.2247993797,
-0.9456264377,
-0.6842269897,
0.0474445038,
0.00582725,
-0.7532262802,
0.3778088987,
-0.3056535721,
-0.4462804794,
-0.0552861094,
-0.1042284891,
0.1440704316,
-0.0654560402,
-0.0419349708,
0.0775370896,
-0.1570057869,
0.1705911309,
0.1678061038,
-0.0608799122,
0.1345497668,
-0.5480561256,
0.6886959076,
-0.0322922207,
-0.2915418446,
-0.3159223199,
0.5824137926,
0.3915826678,
-0.4589262009,
0.4849023819,
0.5024996996,
-0.3281388283,
-0.3691523671,
-0.7895923853,
-0.2464057356,
-0.517280221,
0.5292123556,
-0.468773216,
-0.5275970697,
-0.0439100191,
0.0979373455,
0.4007049799,
0.1492750049,
0.6892282367,
-0.3037069738,
1.0254836082,
0.7144969106,
0.4528656006,
0.6645960808,
-0.2381456345,
0.6005012989,
-0.8414481878,
-0.5217422843,
-0.1306701899,
-0.3763148785,
-0.2915783525,
-0.6745624542,
0.3956981301,
0.0833285227,
-0.1717664748,
0.3238988817,
-0.1029296145,
0.217524305,
0.4533131719,
0.1496538669,
0.1636890769,
-0.042724058,
-0.141796872,
-0.0196353458,
-0.3732937276,
-0.478079766,
1.3507630825,
-0.1377126276,
0.3055858314,
0.5318386555,
0.6509271264,
0.4212026298,
0.5384911299,
-0.8606729507,
0.8607642055,
0.0493831933,
-0.844047308,
-0.234062776,
-0.3616494834,
-0.8849475384,
0.5398461223,
-0.2604645491,
-0.375156492,
0.1001974419,
0.2721360624,
-0.6006256342,
0.284252882,
-0.7989407778,
0.2285075188,
-0.6313570738,
-0.7474115491,
-0.4724482,
-0.3371810317,
0.4687220156,
-0.3254814744,
0.2681790292,
0.0119848661,
-0.3834452033,
0.6583072543,
-0.3146396875,
0.4237891138,
-0.328856051,
-0.0317114107,
0.6642452478,
0.4569559693,
0.644539237,
0.036810562,
-0.2424174845,
-0.3150461912,
-0.0417281091,
-0.0334696844,
-0.7749336958,
0.5549585223,
-0.3083569407,
-0.911560297,
-0.3264782131,
-0.3970666826,
-0.3363530338,
0.5888420939,
0.1761260629,
0.3962084353,
-0.4421421885,
-0.1036383659,
0.3710926473,
0.3469397724,
0.5064802766,
0.8545079231,
-0.5262622833,
-0.4490441382,
0.4940723181,
0.184698984,
0.4315778315,
0.4717207551,
0.1205353066,
-0.6928679347,
-0.364641279,
-0.2620586157,
0.3178227246,
-0.3282440603,
-0.2920387983,
-0.7429167628,
0.0824952796,
-0.5559366345,
0.2597850561,
-0.5049195886,
-0.4731855989,
0.1499695182,
-0.1740032732,
-0.0096207811,
0.4152353108,
-0.3436644673,
0.1134146154,
-0.3840713501,
0.5190394521,
0.3652199507,
0.1618185788,
-0.1446235031,
-0.5083458424,
-0.0622320622,
0.1553490311,
-0.3530406654,
-0.6518884301,
0.2619470656,
0.3019526601,
0.4746656716,
0.2350882888,
-0.0014377392,
0.6138775349,
-0.7326760292,
0.681856811,
0.1065421328,
-0.7539155483,
0.4237592518,
0.1242352724,
-0.0953011215,
0.7214275599,
0.1166432425,
-0.1869757771,
-0.0697153807,
-0.6306887269,
-0.8780587912,
0.7032933235,
0.2292731404,
0.3623166382,
-0.056041196,
0.4425199032,
-0.0119631309,
0.4450428188,
-0.6178252101,
-0.1492958367,
0.2089370191,
0.1189561859,
0.0231803451,
-0.6662400365,
-0.1364879757,
0.1666900218,
0.8798170686,
-0.1703261286,
0.3393690288,
0.1511737406,
-0.1467606425,
-0.4752278328,
0.3456918299,
0.3900551796,
0.6414467692,
-0.0761449784,
0.1660716087,
0.0415062644,
-0.4331485331,
0.2366387248,
-0.1005432829,
-0.1318805069,
-0.305062294,
0.2020836473,
0.5535300374,
0.3498781621,
-0.6331208348,
0.5416102409,
-0.014812178,
0.0788823813,
-0.6108974814,
0.2953149676,
-0.0890550837,
0.615901649,
0.1948074549,
0.139770478,
0.1997466236,
-0.7000818253,
0.3448527157,
0.5314019918,
-0.0978026241,
-0.337985754,
0.5829859972,
0.0410887673,
-0.7355796695,
0.4853735268,
-0.3441542387,
-0.5560389161,
0.3628747463,
0.7474275827,
1.0556635857,
-0.4339115322,
0.3442442119,
0.4279782176,
0.3250016868,
-0.4233609438,
1.0873810053,
-0.0650793239,
-0.7551314831,
-0.3679790199,
-0.5120073557,
-0.1497753859,
0.063237302,
-0.868799746,
0.4291499257,
-0.288040936,
-0.7091505527,
-0.2920368016,
0.3266061842,
-0.7636228204,
0.311218977,
0.2598038018,
0.9479444623,
-0.6154147983,
0.6244276166,
0.7019116282,
-0.331381768,
-0.7272262573,
0.2141351998,
0.1162853464,
-0.9388259649,
0.4771002829,
0.074678801,
-0.6902236938,
-0.0279589947,
-0.2517540455,
-1.2093672752,
1.0695589781,
0.3104682863,
-0.571606338,
-0.1055855602,
-0.0139454277,
0.649815321,
-0.4569404721,
0.2705553174,
0.7893707156,
0.4153873026,
0.133015573,
-0.6102535725,
0.0684673786,
-0.2378340065,
-0.0631687045,
0.4084571302,
-0.8182456493,
0.8172080517,
-0.6929328442,
-0.5595802069,
0.1041818485,
0.9514246583,
0.2812079489,
0.2981101274,
0.6932886839,
0.4335325956,
1.0382977724,
0.1850999296,
1.1954963207,
-0.2946634591,
0.0142259095,
1.4085712433,
-0.404148519,
1.3523052931,
0.6066607237,
-0.2664493918,
0.6228767633,
0.272182405,
0.45643875,
0.6045716405,
0.0056727282,
-0.2919047475,
-0.3802236021,
-0.2450063825,
-0.365187645,
0.4535508752,
0.4088835418,
-0.1979433745,
0.0354347564,
-0.1058799475,
0.2238425314,
0.1470986158,
-0.2460025847,
0.5592435002,
0.3288625181,
-1.1078760624,
0.2192175686,
-0.1104142219,
0.2486069947,
-0.5801053643,
0.1084713414,
-0.1710408032,
0.2346250117,
-0.1075455919,
-0.9604653716,
0.2244028896,
0.0046490887,
-0.3955696821,
-0.3756815493,
0.4217401147,
-0.5750851631,
-0.7828131318,
0.5688850284,
0.5020403862,
-0.0121561205,
0.0121266842,
-0.946336627,
-0.1917727739,
0.1643477529,
-0.4896960855,
0.0159422848,
0.2383477241,
-0.1126942039,
0.7178867459,
0.6864836812,
0.2407083213,
0.0751681253,
0.2370810509,
0.7609164715,
-0.3392203152,
-0.4544193149,
-0.5772723556,
0.653439939,
-0.1598691493,
-0.1125394925,
0.2963963747,
0.5555177927,
0.8683848977,
0.4137274325,
0.6934223175,
-0.1588640362,
0.7054234147,
-0.7428384423,
0.5776477456,
-0.9262072444,
0.2442739904,
-0.0201632679,
-0.948254168,
-0.1234727129,
0.1989712119,
-0.5990542173,
0.4215243161,
0.9251136184,
1.1211041212,
0.0543231107,
0.0653077066,
0.1698328406,
0.3352459967,
0.3362208307,
0.4666464925,
0.7485330105,
-0.4228610098,
0.6288503408,
-0.2528896928,
-0.1234395802,
-0.1074765176,
-0.6527144313,
-0.6749977469,
-0.5840274692,
-0.3538811803,
-0.6498079896,
-0.3214694858,
1.0596755743,
0.571873188,
-0.8035780787,
-0.0199675336,
0.0831195265,
-0.1008764505,
-0.1967391372,
-0.1885274798,
0.4253167808,
-0.460226059,
-0.6251359582,
0.7494348288,
0.2207091451,
-0.1650480777,
-0.425933063,
0.1085513756,
-0.3812010884,
0.5124363899,
0.4913809001,
0.4084222019,
-0.665884614,
-0.242668584,
-0.0036795423,
-0.2007074207,
0.0512256622,
1.198156476,
-0.8163185716,
1.0042709112,
0.5071360469,
0.3985055089,
0.2472943217,
0.1359937787,
0.7813410759,
-0.3871793747,
0.0681594238,
0.3523414731,
0.3453429937,
0.3620327711,
-0.5866105556,
0.2684803307,
-0.072559081,
-0.201484099,
-0.8157249093,
0.4762048125,
-0.4937095642,
-0.0905411392,
1.0313444138,
0.0358417444,
-0.0896328241,
-0.0201706178,
-0.2552456856,
0.3513879776,
-0.2250188887,
0.8216304779,
0.4610882699,
-0.2872824371,
0.0404180922,
-0.3416961133,
0.5468391776,
0.7984033227,
-0.640730679,
-0.0451053679,
0.3220136166,
0.0999981463,
0.2206719071,
0.8082426786,
-0.2363640964,
0.1534147412,
0.0339728594,
0.0271776617,
-0.1398452818,
-0.5856291056,
-0.1384736001,
0.2650727034,
0.080474183,
-0.0022107528
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13035v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13035v2 | D2O: Dynamic Discriminative Operations for Efficient Generative Inference of Large Language Models | 2024-06-18T20:01:51 | 2024-06-23T08:27:48 | Zhongwei Wan, Xinjian Wu, Yu Zhang, Yi Xin, Chaofan Tao, Zhihong Zhu, Xin Wang, Siqi Luo, Jing Xiong, Mi Zhang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Efficient inference in Large Language Models (LLMs) is impeded by the growing
memory demands of key-value (KV) caching, especially for longer sequences.
Traditional KV cache eviction strategies, which prioritize less critical
KV-pairs based on attention scores, often degrade generation quality, leading
to issues such as context loss or hallucinations. To address this, we introduce
Dynamic Discriminative Operations (D2O), a novel method that utilizes two-level
discriminative strategies to optimize KV cache size without fine-tuning, while
preserving essential context. Initially, by observing varying densities of
attention weights between shallow and deep layers, we use this insight to
determine which layers should avoid excessive eviction to minimize information
loss. Subsequently, for the eviction strategy in each layer, D2O innovatively
incorporates a compensation mechanism that maintains a similarity threshold to
re-discriminate the importance of previously discarded tokens, determining
whether they should be recalled and merged with similar tokens. Our approach
not only achieves significant memory savings and enhances inference throughput
by more than 3 times but also maintains high-quality long-text generation.
Extensive experiments across various benchmarks and LLM architectures have
demonstrated that D2O significantly enhances performance with a constrained KV
cache budget. | [
-0.0615679249,
-0.7676959634,
0.6128836274,
0.2234187871,
-0.3617526591,
0.2747589648,
-0.1708547026,
-0.2762142718,
-0.2362031639,
0.4279533029,
-0.4158338904,
-0.4713312387,
-0.4559259117,
-0.3193099797,
-0.3333663046,
0.4387403727,
0.0261016879,
-0.1835139394,
-0.3403371572,
0.0334268957,
-0.4741940498,
-0.1721119583,
-0.8354974985,
-0.2412336618,
0.5033987164,
0.4807088375,
0.5553882718,
0.980294466,
0.3576276898,
0.2998587787,
-0.2970918417,
0.4552746415,
-0.7728145719,
0.4391322136,
0.0530967116,
-0.6945083141,
-0.3938415051,
-0.0918994993,
0.7625511289,
0.5307897925,
-0.4513994753,
-0.0701113045,
-0.1920973063,
0.9411713481,
-0.9298759103,
0.2467736751,
-1.0161738396,
0.2782652676,
-0.1503132433,
-0.1043472886,
-0.5808449984,
-0.2157670707,
-0.056283731,
-0.5859106183,
0.2276467234,
-0.149547264,
0.6331858635,
0.7166293859,
-0.4176217318,
-0.2012997419,
-0.8469920158,
0.7814597487,
-0.474539727,
0.3500795662,
0.2599938512,
0.1797590852,
-0.2968609035,
-0.6251547337,
-0.8236086369,
-0.0585709885,
0.1353879422,
0.2894364893,
-0.0531838648,
0.1285878718,
0.3289623559,
0.4350176156,
-0.10151048,
0.5220997334,
0.0084127765,
0.0165158827,
0.5217100382,
0.09870895,
0.0901747867,
0.2675452828,
-0.3945759237,
-0.2826249301,
-0.8548577428,
-0.2233388871,
0.4632432759,
-0.0015768905,
-0.0501930453,
0.213614285,
-0.0621423684,
0.3724037111,
0.360773176,
-0.1231397167,
0.2342860848,
0.037233334,
-0.0672738776,
0.2971726656,
0.5222788453,
0.3987445235,
0.0421392843,
-0.2688167691,
-0.2677381039,
0.0569787249,
0.1749960482,
-0.9152202606,
-0.2244142741,
0.3225202262,
-0.3161526322,
-0.5230785012,
-0.2133219093,
-1.183160305,
-0.460896343,
-0.1703149676,
0.0121404473,
-0.1081161723,
-0.3712284863,
0.1467737108,
-0.1834163815,
0.0007509728,
0.5427888632,
-1.0354709625,
0.3837005198,
0.6033264399,
0.6636474133,
-0.3925111294,
0.1377913505,
-0.8178434968,
0.4069217145,
-0.4656985998,
0.360306859,
-0.6245395541,
-0.1563216299,
0.0727359876,
-0.401902467,
0.0885909423,
-0.9809110761,
0.3095304668,
-0.9610770345,
-0.1610853374,
-0.1236075684,
-0.4359883666,
0.1997835487,
-0.129607141,
-0.8622477055,
1.4183071852,
0.2268803567,
-0.490958184,
0.4701528549,
-0.3331424296,
-0.527661562,
0.0906164348,
-0.1092646495,
-0.6443107724,
0.3472386897,
0.1085591167,
0.2840892375,
-0.3110424876,
0.239444375,
-0.2911483645,
-0.3185458481,
-0.0401613936,
-0.4676088393,
0.4420438707,
0.2109561563,
-0.6890995502,
-0.0051097893,
-0.9559698105,
-0.2377920896,
0.3932108879,
-0.4392829835,
-0.5654542446,
0.4608599842,
-0.3754933178,
0.1583454311,
0.2581340373,
-0.5506443381,
0.3523618877,
-0.4861963689,
0.6002811193,
0.6516646147,
-0.206489116,
0.5386512876,
0.2722265124,
0.3085124195,
0.1887166649,
0.0152040776,
0.0874076858,
-0.0983745977,
-1.0074386597,
-0.5704955459,
0.1244178563,
0.5660425425,
-0.6872260571,
0.516669631,
-0.3328413367,
-0.2503566742,
-0.5438354611,
0.1814646423,
0.4559555352,
0.3926168978,
0.1423352659,
0.032538183,
-0.3021906316,
-0.8456709981,
0.204627648,
-0.2425028831,
0.1861654073,
0.3548412025,
0.2286141664,
-0.1696838886,
0.6945397854,
-0.6556375623,
-0.0610998198,
0.0330833308,
0.1674789339,
-0.1689493507,
0.3453562558,
0.4894554913,
-0.7514434457,
-0.388140142,
0.0161995068,
-0.5592947006,
-0.2163069248,
-0.221967712,
-0.2372513562,
0.3523412943,
0.6257290244,
-0.8363502622,
0.2406621277,
0.5122138858,
0.1366873085,
0.1768166572,
-0.3318317235,
-0.1225083545,
-0.7253004313,
-0.0656852573,
-0.499117285,
-0.1362066716,
-0.4884473383,
0.231801793,
0.1359895915,
-0.0022200611,
-0.3520129323,
0.7525334358,
-0.7045977712,
-0.1292171776,
-0.3045007885,
0.2940089107,
-0.0307308752,
0.2528255284,
-0.051753372,
0.8996667266,
0.2630595565,
-0.5574828982,
0.4992226958,
0.114404209,
-0.4265443981,
0.2043498307,
-0.330537498,
0.5058119297,
-0.2403871715,
0.2942613959,
-1.2673629522,
0.0264084022,
0.0436355583,
-0.1022347212,
0.5787080526,
-0.0833527893,
-0.7923254371,
-0.370138824,
-0.3928382695,
0.5737902522,
0.5445466042,
-0.8832857609,
0.4082291424,
0.4861063659,
-0.0083125001,
-0.5700770617,
-0.5269693136,
0.1910800487,
-0.4014242291,
-0.4551919103,
0.6440418959,
0.135954693,
-0.289909929,
-0.0820941627,
-0.296487093,
-0.0422981642,
0.3203938007,
0.0699480325,
-0.0462482758,
0.0061846147,
0.3134564161,
0.5328423381,
-0.1214264557,
-0.0322103836,
-0.1389455795,
0.8052499294,
0.3979302347,
-0.1899353415,
-0.5310383439,
0.3656613827,
0.848813653,
-0.3413484097,
0.6666490436,
0.4820750058,
-0.2995360494,
-0.6054999828,
-0.7743724585,
-0.2377375662,
-0.4998883903,
0.4860569835,
-0.4897036552,
-0.8512120843,
0.554276228,
-0.2642261386,
-0.0025548756,
0.3912380338,
0.7533338666,
-0.0080232006,
1.1374241114,
0.0919851363,
-0.0930674225,
0.6185469627,
-0.1918750405,
0.2867133319,
-0.729146421,
-0.2792143226,
-0.2482384294,
-0.2879949212,
-0.4479243457,
-0.6457526684,
0.1488505304,
0.2484730631,
-0.0600078478,
-0.0677078143,
-0.5384224653,
0.2918170094,
0.5096219182,
0.2022918612,
0.0711134374,
0.304521203,
-0.1271887869,
0.0593438484,
-0.5660686493,
-0.1945332438,
0.8016768098,
0.3691516817,
0.7943971753,
0.1799570471,
0.6434400082,
0.4314929247,
-0.0232957341,
-0.811891675,
0.7028319836,
-0.302503258,
-0.3882490396,
-0.2654705942,
-0.5060871243,
-0.95908463,
0.2093732357,
0.0774857625,
-0.6006190181,
0.2309111804,
0.4726367295,
-0.321675688,
0.2587448955,
-0.5319085121,
0.5805686116,
-0.2429579347,
-0.7195791006,
-0.7491010427,
-0.5227191448,
0.2599008679,
-0.1356428713,
-0.122462444,
-0.1673175693,
-0.2546236813,
0.4225168526,
-0.3923259079,
0.8065505028,
-0.3958615065,
-0.4991270006,
0.3443295062,
0.1600643992,
0.8899948597,
0.0878647342,
-0.2464113683,
0.1175031662,
-0.3449284732,
-0.10294687,
-0.7441965342,
0.8826556802,
-0.6747531295,
-0.6015312672,
-0.2028915137,
-0.5130319595,
0.10666693,
0.114080213,
-0.154167816,
0.1554138362,
0.0825636461,
0.2120798826,
0.8151832819,
-0.3897480965,
0.3248568475,
0.4774283767,
0.2226629704,
-0.455034107,
0.8106461763,
-0.1442876756,
0.490624398,
0.8335664868,
0.2748325467,
-0.3955160975,
-0.7775595188,
-0.4377964139,
0.1539552957,
-0.5907856226,
-0.1283373982,
-0.614764452,
0.0027371466,
-0.1837575883,
0.0452439412,
-0.6302297711,
-0.3148666024,
-0.2388338298,
-0.2065714449,
0.2932960093,
0.2902195156,
0.0629438311,
0.3829387724,
-0.6093233824,
0.4726643264,
0.3777894974,
0.2526187897,
0.1658739597,
-0.2025677115,
-0.1412239522,
-0.0097356346,
-0.2041815221,
-0.6085789204,
0.2751366496,
0.2315535098,
0.524771452,
0.4719558358,
0.1865207106,
0.8689008355,
-0.5673786402,
0.5216992497,
0.0571393818,
-0.861795485,
0.5596261621,
-0.266184479,
0.1012148857,
0.4935919344,
-0.1446273476,
-0.3068836927,
-0.251449883,
-0.2518975139,
-1.2439696789,
0.8119551539,
0.1084536538,
0.2596336603,
-0.3925839961,
0.7480239868,
-0.0740467459,
0.3617631197,
-0.2478728294,
-0.1794164926,
0.0907136053,
-0.3487147987,
0.2806672752,
-0.5639217496,
-0.0277193356,
-0.2857469022,
0.3865428865,
-0.0727678612,
0.4053941667,
-0.0601206385,
-0.1325813532,
-0.1541791111,
-0.0942016542,
0.72176373,
0.3813104928,
-0.2351367772,
0.2475171238,
0.2336114198,
-0.5012360215,
0.163779363,
0.0646737963,
-0.237906158,
-0.2395480424,
0.1715661287,
1.0344129801,
0.1891435534,
-0.7975902557,
0.3494195044,
-0.0246955063,
-0.1434523463,
-0.3136341572,
0.1333623528,
0.0320662819,
0.1962762326,
0.1979742199,
-0.4287921786,
0.0730802491,
-0.4630481005,
0.1828842014,
0.4284918904,
-0.1991349608,
-0.1991443634,
0.7485869527,
0.4768697023,
-0.0368992649,
0.9923455119,
-0.1734045744,
-0.4336238801,
0.7884370089,
0.5116311908,
0.9311896563,
-0.2832003534,
0.0445392095,
0.4155564308,
0.0124586821,
-0.1267610937,
0.07383506,
-0.2660418153,
-0.8298994899,
-0.3688240051,
-0.6531856656,
-0.0467414781,
0.4054571688,
-0.6064937115,
0.0625938475,
-0.5736696124,
-0.0324228071,
-0.0379786193,
-0.090817824,
-0.3983834088,
0.2230817974,
0.2703091502,
0.6346336603,
-0.5799354315,
0.9032849073,
0.2518300414,
-0.0208268389,
-0.3002437353,
0.0570053682,
0.1372786164,
-0.9696697593,
1.120002389,
0.1972610801,
-0.3059259355,
0.1664319783,
-0.1844598651,
-0.8742160797,
0.9569525719,
0.5821336508,
-0.8811990023,
-0.1280891299,
0.2098584324,
0.4457776845,
-0.1550244987,
0.073482506,
0.6948342323,
0.448679328,
0.2126242816,
-0.5346052051,
0.1832832843,
-0.1044886261,
0.2440823615,
0.5007416606,
-0.8268638253,
0.5496533513,
-0.2059786022,
-0.4598321617,
0.2313623726,
0.5028093457,
0.0937729552,
0.0196700431,
0.8421911001,
0.9240654707,
0.7463624477,
-0.2801356912,
0.8840900064,
-0.4683268964,
0.2767696977,
1.1304455996,
-0.6137079,
0.7736734748,
0.5035669208,
-0.2211110592,
0.2579856217,
0.5306210518,
-0.0013445457,
0.8648689389,
0.5436630249,
-0.572399497,
-0.269051373,
-0.0195882581,
-0.1001996994,
0.5524870157,
0.3911429048,
-0.3124580383,
-0.0037505827,
-0.3102974892,
0.1058618203,
0.0684129149,
0.0396505669,
0.9646139741,
-0.1391527206,
-0.8240090609,
0.6699423194,
-0.1061312184,
0.3644239902,
-0.4890624881,
-0.3245542645,
-0.3432969153,
0.5947341323,
-0.0559587777,
-0.531090498,
0.1105095372,
-0.1993397921,
-0.5137307048,
-0.3388842046,
0.3129031062,
-0.5919064879,
-0.352263391,
0.6152771115,
-0.1371814907,
-0.1140921041,
-0.0681462735,
-0.4781793356,
0.3052873909,
-0.1627727598,
-0.1757035702,
0.30401057,
0.5478391051,
-0.0926080644,
0.6055595875,
0.6286302209,
0.0963806957,
0.129235521,
0.3794436157,
0.9034463167,
-0.385304004,
-0.1909011602,
-0.947722435,
0.3991140425,
-0.3365051448,
-0.1492952853,
0.5332456827,
0.78251791,
0.7388031483,
-0.0127059687,
0.6156695485,
0.1734455973,
0.1816293299,
-0.7435513139,
0.5018439889,
-0.7191174626,
0.3236577809,
-0.1194694862,
-0.8583314419,
-0.2461638302,
0.5363518596,
-0.1573974192,
-0.0601109378,
0.5250335336,
0.786141634,
0.09878961,
-0.6646745205,
0.2164383531,
0.2534452677,
0.5890843868,
0.5229589343,
0.6812269688,
-0.2493557483,
0.4323918223,
-0.2288845479,
-0.2840269804,
-0.3692899644,
-0.9023990631,
-0.696179986,
-0.3360338807,
-0.5004917979,
-0.1137916222,
0.2811427116,
0.4217656255,
0.7849124074,
-0.6279096603,
-0.0326758511,
-0.3829241395,
0.066103667,
-0.2592557967,
-0.2855917513,
0.583296597,
-0.3703290522,
-1.060285449,
0.4047619104,
0.5052822828,
-0.1944991499,
-0.2731620371,
-0.0184982978,
0.0098329075,
-0.0038427247,
0.8791364431,
0.0649946705,
-0.9297149181,
-0.3003945947,
-0.239458248,
-0.147592634,
0.0322333723,
0.6482269168,
-0.5157452226,
0.6987353563,
0.6749210358,
0.8296222687,
0.862727046,
-0.0519471839,
0.550540328,
-0.7187606096,
0.4424456954,
0.1339936256,
0.1634188294,
0.2477009147,
-0.4646725655,
0.3514416516,
0.3907549679,
-0.2947417796,
-0.8746497035,
0.3530087471,
-1.0696508884,
-0.2121158093,
1.2703931332,
-0.1228240952,
0.0138166612,
0.2173220813,
-0.1973241121,
0.3785626888,
-0.5633803606,
1.0230094194,
0.4775177836,
0.2274376154,
-0.3978403807,
-0.4653840363,
0.5306144953,
0.3906756043,
-0.7859838605,
0.5064173937,
0.5596567392,
0.0677811652,
0.0078189177,
0.357245326,
-0.104881689,
0.0566787645,
0.1191372648,
0.1223098263,
-0.0184721556,
-0.3789504468,
0.0026898666,
0.0909529105,
-0.0624117889,
-0.2990776896
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.13009v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.13009v1 | Detecting Errors through Ensembling Prompts (DEEP): An End-to-End LLM Framework for Detecting Factual Errors | 2024-06-18T18:59:37 | 2024-06-18T18:59:37 | Alex Chandler, Devesh Surve, Hui Su | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Accurate text summarization is one of the most common and important tasks
performed by Large Language Models, where the costs of human review for an
entire document may be high, but the costs of errors in summarization may be
even greater. We propose Detecting Errors through Ensembling Prompts (DEEP) -
an end-to-end large language model framework for detecting factual errors in
text summarization. Our framework uses a diverse set of LLM prompts to identify
factual inconsistencies, treating their outputs as binary features, which are
then fed into ensembling models. We then calibrate the ensembled models to
produce empirically accurate probabilities that a text is factually consistent
or free of hallucination. We demonstrate that prior models for detecting
factual errors in summaries perform significantly worse without optimizing the
thresholds on subsets of the evaluated dataset. Our framework achieves
state-of-the-art (SOTA) balanced accuracy on the AggreFact-XSUM FTSOTA,
TofuEval Summary-Level, and HaluEval Summarization benchmarks in detecting
factual errors within transformer-generated text summaries. It does so without
any fine-tuning of the language model or reliance on thresholding techniques
not available in practical settings. | [
0.0589411482,
-0.8615122437,
0.7984182239,
0.3141326904,
-0.0722908378,
0.2073643506,
-0.0665863678,
-0.1855858266,
0.0351319872,
0.5754306316,
-0.6164998412,
-0.5150480866,
-0.5945241451,
0.4631489813,
-0.5109578967,
1.0180208683,
-0.1832405627,
-0.0778888166,
-0.6544541717,
-0.1684253961,
-0.5222767591,
-0.2496041059,
-0.5379160643,
-0.0130074238,
0.2266922295,
0.612793982,
0.3920322359,
0.2540234029,
0.4191271067,
0.3270404339,
-0.1471550018,
0.7091878653,
-0.5133993626,
0.4260211885,
-0.068253845,
-0.591448307,
-0.3741978109,
-0.2481232733,
0.7003344893,
0.4775285721,
-0.0428063981,
-0.0093247974,
0.1430878937,
0.7474484444,
-0.5425053835,
0.0617933087,
-0.431078285,
-0.0612562597,
-0.0475694872,
-0.3205423057,
-0.6055793762,
-0.7380234599,
-0.0848484188,
-0.2196381241,
0.3658469319,
0.137082696,
0.8498476744,
0.7004388571,
-0.3742878437,
-0.6164463758,
-0.42643255,
0.5619940758,
-1.075958848,
0.299233377,
0.2979294658,
0.1491541713,
-0.0689705312,
-0.4700654745,
-0.6583861113,
-0.1750072837,
-0.3481418192,
0.4228910208,
-0.2745218575,
0.0482207239,
0.3056015372,
0.1377573013,
-0.6739934683,
0.2032237798,
-0.2285635024,
-0.2449050993,
0.5029398799,
0.3061575294,
0.3720559478,
-0.0514193848,
-0.164134413,
-0.0125425886,
-0.8498094678,
0.2031466216,
0.4264422059,
0.189435333,
-0.493881315,
0.7099456787,
-0.2706957459,
0.5118257403,
0.3093547225,
-0.1704976261,
0.005181761,
-0.4780917466,
-0.3389040232,
0.499633491,
0.5513696671,
0.6756947041,
0.2965811491,
-0.1962951571,
-0.3984524906,
0.101018697,
0.00773715,
-0.8391474485,
-0.0320992395,
0.520876646,
-0.1381138116,
-0.4278535247,
-0.0877055153,
-0.5692776442,
-0.8011239171,
-0.3263670802,
0.212212503,
-0.3815208972,
0.1502348185,
0.2233101726,
0.0024765236,
0.0343614444,
0.5965530276,
-0.777646184,
0.1219432205,
0.6596972942,
1.0258209705,
-0.1041192785,
-0.2389720976,
-0.6803843379,
0.0545047596,
-0.5917079449,
1.1747870445,
-0.2320715934,
-0.1924247295,
-0.0443899669,
-0.0459961854,
0.0099736396,
-0.5290489197,
0.6658381224,
-0.3062411249,
0.2136153728,
-0.4539853036,
-0.799079299,
-0.2459096313,
0.5840291977,
-0.528842926,
0.7117765546,
-0.0848156959,
-0.7332179546,
0.3164964616,
-0.3660090268,
-0.5379782319,
-0.1925836056,
-0.1314858198,
-0.4799673855,
0.1524052471,
0.427483201,
0.5515825152,
-0.2514579296,
0.7088000178,
0.0283500291,
-0.3544409275,
0.3193103373,
-0.6685611606,
0.7412641048,
-0.155120492,
-0.3071135879,
0.3005445898,
-0.8382072449,
-0.5474068522,
-0.1687592119,
-0.4103032947,
-0.0822813883,
0.010367672,
-0.3779211044,
-0.1615038961,
0.1906349808,
-0.4616183341,
-0.1167085618,
-0.4373543561,
-0.1234831288,
0.651435256,
0.1252084225,
0.4605317414,
-0.4805078804,
0.406162113,
0.1735689789,
-0.3099816442,
-0.7863727212,
-0.337743789,
-0.8189976215,
-0.2623235583,
0.1258282363,
0.8290409446,
-0.6535284519,
0.8602257967,
-0.2919006944,
-0.3132686615,
-0.2990107238,
-0.0550443307,
0.3100749552,
0.953248322,
0.2812345326,
0.2973204255,
-0.6079049706,
-0.6353601813,
-0.3786987066,
-0.2672420144,
-0.0444106683,
-0.1126322746,
0.432113409,
-0.3975864947,
1.0704280138,
-0.3011086881,
-0.2379247397,
-0.1050567254,
0.3372821212,
0.486025244,
0.3664224744,
0.3353541791,
-0.4862136245,
-0.4525154829,
-0.103549473,
-1.0757446289,
-0.3921294212,
-0.4577001333,
0.2202848047,
0.450329572,
0.6390829086,
-0.6237421632,
0.2555540204,
0.2571774423,
-0.4842794538,
0.77490592,
-0.2188597172,
0.4081932008,
-0.7749423385,
-0.1197569445,
0.0766610727,
-0.3852556646,
-0.4566861093,
-0.0158637948,
0.2349381745,
0.2663447559,
-0.0670145601,
0.2900334597,
-0.2264131755,
0.1719819009,
-0.2007415295,
0.1885619015,
0.2933808863,
0.2330951244,
-0.0753361508,
0.76557374,
0.2702026665,
-0.5002807975,
0.6379228234,
0.2349017113,
-0.3301254511,
0.8276417255,
-0.6649496555,
-0.3031601012,
-0.4711953402,
0.3132937551,
-1.3163248301,
-0.5178694725,
0.2550885677,
-0.6395520568,
0.401809603,
0.0253582951,
-0.4671393037,
0.1290249974,
-0.5554189086,
0.0579748936,
0.3973054886,
-0.6328184009,
0.6973933578,
0.1814049929,
-0.4510854483,
-0.8359197378,
-0.690036118,
0.2275558263,
0.0584687553,
-0.8657597899,
-0.0052606119,
0.0652949437,
-0.3784198463,
0.0276757982,
-0.2866645455,
0.1846250743,
0.1372539997,
0.0011165268,
0.2842395008,
-0.4248716831,
0.1605655849,
0.2391638756,
-0.2225648016,
0.2630586028,
-0.1161667556,
0.2414102405,
-0.2991441488,
-0.5423354506,
-0.2218980789,
0.1760128886,
0.6450278163,
-0.001532999,
0.4780527651,
0.2940927148,
-0.6572749615,
-0.0840906948,
-0.8003579974,
-0.1682139039,
-0.4393514097,
0.4329836965,
0.0233778898,
-0.8023052216,
0.6544524431,
0.1322702169,
0.3558155894,
0.390216738,
0.3673410714,
-0.4781471193,
0.8335539103,
0.4703100324,
0.1200062633,
-0.1095690429,
0.1284350455,
0.3583305478,
-0.4446944296,
-0.1932636648,
-0.5452981591,
-0.2062656581,
-0.3254267871,
-0.3726226389,
0.5041553974,
0.0780595466,
-0.2994069159,
-0.1602304727,
-0.2418108881,
0.7731878757,
0.373003006,
0.0002716496,
0.4705114067,
0.0423937701,
-0.0371221863,
-0.1050151512,
-0.4274527729,
-0.5791519284,
0.7227829695,
0.3485068381,
0.8963012695,
0.2173658907,
0.5746100545,
0.375185132,
0.3075065017,
-0.7583760619,
0.3749367893,
-0.0664794892,
-0.2198638469,
-0.5691514611,
-0.5262899399,
-0.4286419749,
0.0736580789,
-0.1958394796,
-0.5302224159,
0.3036087453,
0.2938798964,
-0.7001779675,
0.4761846066,
-0.4725408852,
0.6973323822,
-0.2072912902,
-0.2571469843,
0.0379673019,
-0.6515738964,
0.6893083453,
-0.1440897286,
0.2660664022,
-0.115970999,
-0.1720445156,
0.5631111264,
-0.2724764049,
1.123742938,
-0.0548077784,
-0.3922478557,
0.261274308,
0.3180803359,
1.0071088076,
0.0557255335,
0.075068295,
-0.0895003453,
-0.3465639949,
0.0006706966,
-0.7292885184,
0.4076510966,
-0.4383478463,
-0.4833621085,
-0.4871323109,
-0.3994056582,
-0.1281422526,
0.0644419342,
0.5745671988,
0.7375911474,
-0.0543081574,
0.270026803,
1.0734885931,
-0.3550737202,
0.3464746773,
0.5408787727,
-0.1133150607,
-0.2985456288,
0.9677600265,
0.1244728714,
-0.0004271082,
0.5138972998,
0.1781851649,
-0.571154356,
-0.7252508998,
-0.7553578019,
0.207551986,
-0.9300897121,
-0.4834465384,
-0.8988643289,
-0.0896484256,
-0.462805599,
-0.4334842861,
-0.2388308197,
-0.3122267425,
-0.3659315705,
-0.5024639368,
0.2726428509,
0.5188271403,
-0.0749864727,
0.3655892611,
-1.0867323875,
0.2526017129,
0.106739752,
0.1203633398,
-0.1101385877,
-0.8822680712,
-0.1461850107,
0.0228533708,
-0.0926488265,
-0.9146761894,
0.363273114,
0.0119198598,
0.2865878046,
0.4452877939,
0.2393958122,
0.4289277792,
-0.3908617198,
0.9014148116,
0.3515381515,
-1.0032497644,
0.3970889151,
-0.3330440521,
0.3416438401,
0.6168273687,
0.2284114808,
-0.93246907,
-0.5302436352,
-0.4360068142,
-0.8181712627,
0.6182143092,
-0.0947941989,
-0.0458756909,
-0.0472575352,
0.1056241989,
0.0844398141,
0.2096434683,
-0.6477428675,
-0.0776397437,
-0.0157788154,
-0.6784028411,
-0.0187493246,
-0.5777411461,
-0.0432268046,
0.0791625604,
0.9675630331,
-0.3838356733,
-0.1460762769,
0.3271580338,
-0.499032259,
-0.2637427151,
0.2597332001,
0.871085465,
0.7332356572,
-0.2378761917,
0.2760954797,
0.5335021019,
-0.209548384,
0.2647795379,
-0.1423788518,
-0.4306128025,
0.3096814454,
0.7355442643,
0.5561829805,
0.5266298056,
-0.9989691377,
0.6825644374,
0.0578851253,
0.0685550049,
-0.2197712511,
-0.1664243937,
0.1372087896,
0.1718631089,
0.3990751505,
0.3303283751,
0.3773956299,
-0.360902369,
0.3250430524,
0.1824709624,
-0.3109721243,
-0.2066129595,
0.4951474965,
0.3612912893,
-0.0131512647,
0.5320184231,
-0.3378235102,
-0.5509069562,
0.7796925306,
0.3547786772,
1.100184679,
-0.1293870062,
0.3308309019,
0.3461307883,
0.6950128078,
-0.2154805064,
-0.0087106377,
0.0903348401,
-0.9563345313,
-0.652948916,
-0.464830935,
-0.6914503574,
-0.1933396012,
-0.2737890482,
0.366235286,
-0.3237783015,
0.2771020234,
-0.164903596,
-0.4435027838,
-0.1671447456,
0.2088813037,
0.2056999654,
0.8375503421,
-0.8686655164,
0.0228762943,
0.4467209876,
-0.2930282652,
-0.4948679209,
-0.0621854812,
0.2829894423,
-0.6098892093,
0.4333634973,
0.2620155215,
-0.3240263164,
-0.2031285763,
-0.6383544803,
-0.7562887073,
0.9186831117,
0.4772633612,
-0.7618895173,
-0.0623973459,
0.0138419531,
0.2539956272,
-0.1369823217,
0.4537910819,
0.7616809607,
0.5438007116,
0.1030150056,
-0.4959233999,
0.2549649477,
-0.0307464823,
-0.6225933433,
0.1215498,
-0.517301023,
0.8325225115,
-0.4478684962,
-0.4525611103,
-0.1678751111,
0.7715833187,
0.3754238188,
0.5961931944,
0.369549185,
0.4854169488,
1.333570838,
-0.2662702799,
0.8762058616,
-0.0575568154,
0.1749212295,
1.275464654,
-0.5009244084,
0.3746950328,
0.1396462619,
-0.0857694596,
0.2542211711,
0.6625846028,
-0.0324651487,
0.2675209939,
-0.1931449175,
-0.2544271648,
-0.2052120864,
0.1246297285,
-0.252620399,
0.0010204857,
0.4632621706,
-0.03388514,
-0.5416660309,
-0.1661893874,
0.0716133788,
0.1832936108,
-0.179572776,
0.8111433387,
0.1064802334,
-0.7326923013,
0.4371694922,
-0.0113501903,
1.0670531988,
-0.4460601807,
-0.046459429,
-0.4972111583,
0.0388269797,
-0.4095462263,
-0.7544024587,
0.4440945387,
0.3087903559,
-0.3072477877,
-0.0633037016,
0.9315425158,
-0.5305152535,
-0.6022946239,
-0.0953373611,
0.4422521293,
0.0940868109,
-0.1551566571,
-0.2020812482,
-0.1226356402,
0.0857172459,
-0.0173541475,
-0.125090003,
0.6547443867,
0.0852673054,
0.5666534305,
0.6642730832,
-0.1099271476,
-0.0722883344,
0.1121391729,
0.4943522811,
-0.5216479897,
-0.7726461291,
-1.2625479698,
0.7396258712,
-0.345169723,
-0.1753179133,
0.7333287597,
0.6071605086,
0.6281340122,
-0.1242331043,
0.9453126788,
0.3132180274,
0.4943826795,
-0.7869045138,
0.7819008231,
-0.2938680351,
0.5162893534,
-0.0089527089,
-0.6702029705,
-0.3731921017,
0.4881528616,
-0.0941979289,
-0.2667661309,
0.633474946,
0.9088528156,
0.1430326253,
0.3026438653,
0.4689697027,
0.4485860765,
0.2708741128,
0.1537391096,
1.1192935705,
-0.2411708683,
0.2307187319,
0.1292272061,
-0.3640189767,
-0.4502743483,
-0.9204912186,
-0.8456969857,
-0.2934354842,
-0.4806903601,
-0.4404521585,
0.1074845716,
0.9452587366,
0.1192970499,
-1.0596895218,
-0.0635458007,
-0.0829146579,
0.5497065783,
-0.1011054665,
-0.214135319,
0.3095033169,
-0.749843955,
-0.5323700905,
0.4905903041,
0.5775622129,
0.1984482855,
0.007132676,
-0.1212332174,
0.0418811627,
0.2518476546,
0.6275604367,
0.0445606411,
-0.5483471751,
-0.3255722523,
0.0478275307,
-0.1531645209,
-0.0030870154,
0.7661749721,
-0.5754146576,
0.3105764985,
0.6811672449,
0.9771803021,
0.1300908327,
0.0103456723,
0.5639500022,
-0.9569189548,
-0.2238771915,
0.2716965973,
0.5641426444,
0.5597819686,
-0.7183953524,
0.5267882943,
0.3455860913,
-0.414550215,
-1.0247119665,
-0.0271376297,
-0.7611302733,
-0.1765139252,
0.9205098152,
-0.2369046658,
-0.2640728354,
-0.1953473836,
-0.16048792,
0.2354052216,
-0.273794204,
0.6293714643,
0.7469594479,
0.0571127124,
-0.1064014062,
-0.2270514518,
0.4797490537,
0.3614192605,
-0.9531607032,
0.3354315162,
0.7340774536,
0.1830783337,
0.2567213476,
0.4252847433,
0.1109701917,
0.5603660345,
0.0550229661,
-0.0820089653,
-0.1142825186,
-0.4056652784,
-0.4892736375,
-0.0073341778,
-0.4463684559,
0.0448576361
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12998v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12998v1 | Articulatory Encodec: Vocal Tract Kinematics as a Codec for Speech | 2024-06-18T18:38:17 | 2024-06-18T18:38:17 | Cheol Jun Cho, Peter Wu, Tejas S. Prabhune, Dhruv Agarwal, Gopala K. Anumanchipalli | eess.AS | eess.AS, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.SD | Vocal tract articulation is a natural, grounded control space of speech
production. The spatiotemporal coordination of articulators combined with the
vocal source shapes intelligible speech sounds to enable effective spoken
communication. Based on this physiological grounding of speech, we propose a
new framework of neural encoding-decoding of speech -- articulatory encodec.
The articulatory encodec comprises an articulatory analysis model that infers
articulatory features from speech audio, and an articulatory synthesis model
that synthesizes speech audio from articulatory features. The articulatory
features are kinematic traces of vocal tract articulators and source features,
which are intuitively interpretable and controllable, being the actual physical
interface of speech production. An additional speaker identity encoder is
jointly trained with the articulatory synthesizer to inform the voice texture
of individual speakers. By training on large-scale speech data, we achieve a
fully intelligible, high-quality articulatory synthesizer that generalizes to
unseen speakers. Furthermore, the speaker embedding is effectively disentangled
from articulations, which enables accent-perserving zero-shot voice conversion.
To the best of our knowledge, this is the first demonstration of universal,
high-performance articulatory inference and synthesis, suggesting the proposed
framework as a powerful coding system of speech. | [
-0.315702796,
-0.6624045372,
0.310582608,
0.0377868824,
-0.125592038,
0.0650405511,
-0.0228175353,
-0.1120529175,
0.8457300663,
0.4588387311,
-0.5358470678,
-0.6365063787,
-0.3238357306,
-0.2761698365,
-0.5356056094,
0.7607138157,
0.2609642744,
0.2009714842,
0.0656719357,
-0.1417256445,
-0.1884237826,
-0.9317778349,
-0.472602576,
-0.4038891196,
0.1934213191,
0.0927118137,
0.5346959829,
0.6663261652,
0.1756114364,
0.2442364544,
-0.2468407154,
-0.1242764965,
-0.2976377606,
0.4313954115,
0.3984753489,
-0.4421574473,
-0.8797677755,
-0.0848180056,
0.6927265525,
1.0152235031,
-0.4989448786,
-0.138508603,
-0.0644378439,
0.4331254065,
-0.6279606223,
0.2321896702,
-0.2643921971,
0.2667063177,
-0.1237715259,
-0.4725202322,
-0.3665137887,
-0.3969928324,
-0.2899585664,
-0.3408809006,
-0.0635635406,
-0.4028506875,
0.3086315095,
0.3709899783,
-0.2260015309,
-0.3293989301,
-0.8564254642,
-0.0900484025,
-0.6648953557,
0.7656182647,
0.3648641109,
0.1490704715,
-0.173908338,
-0.6195766926,
-0.4402194321,
-0.1285540909,
0.4769415259,
0.3343892097,
-0.1120390072,
0.5887427926,
-0.0981638357,
0.3401781619,
-0.5256960988,
0.0489845797,
-0.2488992214,
-0.1161369756,
0.4585522115,
-0.0503776073,
0.3317023516,
0.0706378594,
0.0879101232,
-0.0426568612,
-0.4863006473,
0.0786203817,
0.68735677,
0.0882910788,
-0.3025521338,
0.4382537901,
-0.1973435134,
0.4288915396,
0.1577326804,
-0.153315112,
0.3264988661,
0.1701887548,
-0.2941532433,
0.5535413623,
0.7123157978,
0.0704653934,
0.1678376496,
-0.3689374328,
0.0015220114,
0.1039485484,
0.1355681419,
-0.4861115217,
-0.2420410663,
0.2873513699,
-0.5589524508,
-0.2994193137,
0.1479739547,
-0.2723477781,
-0.1677705199,
-0.4850609601,
0.0693964139,
-0.4207168221,
-0.5940426588,
0.0882643461,
-0.0907612815,
0.1306651682,
-0.2077723294,
-1.209613204,
0.4139060974,
0.5056146383,
0.8367187977,
0.04351338,
-0.3855470717,
-0.4851900339,
0.1279637963,
-0.7866755128,
0.4254915714,
-0.665713191,
-0.0715923831,
0.121467039,
-0.0045396853,
-0.0715039447,
-0.3902840018,
0.3013578057,
-0.3293435872,
-0.2195573002,
0.1965007186,
-0.5417313576,
-0.2188286483,
-0.3818295002,
-0.7575939894,
0.4043681026,
0.0564429089,
-0.3038627803,
-0.0349603966,
-0.6549084783,
-0.4134271741,
0.0815397054,
-0.0891781747,
0.1452423781,
0.2788401246,
-0.1257977933,
0.3491882384,
0.0544944368,
0.3099368513,
-0.1791567653,
-0.3241618276,
0.4742115736,
-0.5581876636,
0.5997071862,
0.5316085815,
-0.3770380616,
0.0455849729,
-0.9911878109,
0.0601731017,
-0.1197118163,
-0.3889229,
0.1532660127,
-0.2662378848,
0.0244401675,
-0.2275101393,
-0.0321360752,
-0.5702230334,
-0.1838793457,
-0.6389194727,
0.9082945585,
0.2487087846,
0.1529122293,
0.8279153109,
0.1014289036,
0.4753468037,
-0.1790399402,
0.0081927171,
-0.1225748658,
-0.4948808551,
-0.7484413385,
0.0875359774,
0.2625977397,
0.5383123755,
-0.5634548068,
0.6612668037,
-0.2150319517,
-0.2883524001,
-0.7524845004,
-0.2166318744,
0.2663514912,
0.1057773679,
0.0523080751,
-0.5066244006,
-0.4742025733,
-0.7241163254,
-0.0396152958,
-0.3440977335,
-0.2542928159,
-0.0811352059,
0.0671956688,
0.121271871,
0.4685395658,
0.03395731,
-0.0668362528,
-0.1658331007,
0.1102472022,
0.1958536506,
0.7647829056,
0.4515540302,
-0.2251578718,
-0.0310870297,
0.0541868135,
-0.6238021851,
-0.2320806533,
0.0755315274,
-0.3865091205,
0.1387832165,
0.5535356998,
-0.8794239759,
0.5633657575,
0.6410276294,
-0.307997793,
0.1022232026,
-0.3108507991,
0.4073819518,
-0.6310485601,
0.0681196302,
-0.5638698339,
-0.0039808918,
-0.9439138174,
-0.0416911617,
-0.02172927,
-0.5365735292,
-0.3383227885,
-0.1902094781,
-0.3604251742,
-0.0390976854,
-0.2875150144,
-0.0856224597,
0.0313727073,
0.8138916492,
0.0833862349,
0.2273673713,
0.7774096131,
-0.5182964206,
0.8004088998,
0.2210659236,
0.0921464413,
0.7571336031,
-0.4264142215,
0.5010198355,
-0.3317991793,
0.3564227819,
-0.7831034064,
-0.345197171,
0.2444687784,
-0.8034223914,
0.480520159,
-0.3472366929,
-0.0724691153,
-0.1501248032,
0.17301552,
0.4958522022,
0.8063132167,
-0.528129518,
0.5958365798,
0.6744147539,
-0.0065745083,
-0.0376859643,
-0.9930492043,
0.2428787649,
0.0047471025,
-0.5340910554,
0.0973107815,
0.1800827831,
0.0608770512,
-0.0539738685,
0.040407069,
-0.148840636,
-0.1766161919,
0.4560527503,
-0.1604855955,
-0.1931984127,
0.1153916195,
0.1080751643,
-0.2393942326,
0.2418409586,
-0.7368760705,
0.4952697158,
0.2871451974,
-0.635193944,
-0.9067769647,
0.5861487985,
0.8197460771,
-0.1863300502,
0.2715059817,
0.6055388451,
-0.4160625935,
0.1776026487,
-0.4390462041,
-0.226447463,
-0.3795879185,
0.2704971135,
-0.28777349,
-0.5925306678,
0.437551558,
-0.021825688,
-0.3688297272,
0.0312717259,
0.4324803054,
-0.0385136381,
1.1545532942,
0.2922217846,
-0.1544116586,
0.4385177195,
-0.4113965034,
0.2312926799,
-0.6292793155,
-0.4214191735,
-0.586789906,
-0.4441055655,
-0.3650580645,
-0.4891157746,
0.2676716447,
-0.1707885265,
-0.3327976465,
0.0690017268,
-0.6454278231,
0.2194743901,
0.6535024643,
0.0924985558,
-0.155543223,
0.2293867171,
-0.1547594219,
-0.0991575122,
-0.6809168458,
-0.3050401211,
0.853260994,
0.5826804042,
0.7954878211,
0.0417589508,
0.6040863395,
0.1138586998,
-0.3118162751,
-0.8484175801,
0.2794539034,
-0.3407994807,
-0.1934584379,
-0.0660210773,
-0.0885977075,
-0.6149485707,
-0.0718880892,
-0.1057035774,
-0.7650741339,
0.4837199748,
0.1768438816,
-0.3889193237,
0.5316165686,
-0.6465651989,
0.5708212852,
-0.1470572352,
-0.1711625606,
-0.0916172117,
-0.6826803684,
-0.0233101808,
0.6345558763,
0.1139793396,
0.0016578643,
0.0831088126,
0.7484552264,
-0.2505355477,
0.9104117751,
-0.53361094,
-0.1696618199,
0.3397968709,
0.3208175898,
0.1572952569,
-0.3228312135,
-0.0532052442,
0.4613877535,
-0.0164454766,
-0.0856515393,
-0.7699463964,
0.6103545427,
-0.5442066193,
-0.2116237581,
0.1287883371,
-0.2048228383,
-0.1981442273,
-0.2924818397,
0.2702741027,
0.7752662897,
-0.4323258698,
0.4308153987,
0.5049654245,
0.0861931741,
0.4079144001,
0.2476559877,
0.1624237001,
-0.7585888505,
0.9407057762,
-0.0392821208,
0.2544358671,
0.4884757996,
-0.1136025265,
-0.3079063892,
-0.7731184363,
-0.4705035985,
0.1612054408,
-0.8057600856,
-0.1855851412,
-0.5571392775,
-0.515853405,
-0.5953765512,
0.0122431824,
-0.5440137982,
-0.4974185824,
-0.3934372663,
-0.2599966824,
0.1805735379,
0.9688226581,
-0.4464557171,
0.250490725,
-0.5897629857,
0.3904034495,
0.3790083528,
0.4399857521,
-0.0636821464,
-0.4406132698,
-0.2810273468,
0.3295681477,
-0.0833484605,
-1.0284280777,
0.6850996017,
0.4801334441,
0.4390247762,
0.3824693561,
-0.1741311103,
0.5762137771,
-0.5960732102,
0.9094945192,
0.4107183814,
-1.2331732512,
0.6983051896,
-0.0176894367,
0.375438571,
0.2368904799,
0.0497625098,
-0.7098919749,
-0.6255512238,
-0.6352055669,
-0.7584916353,
0.6143811345,
0.3803321123,
0.1105731502,
-0.0393540189,
0.3792828023,
0.1310424507,
0.2723297179,
-0.1888953894,
-0.1804327071,
-0.687292695,
-0.4843354225,
0.1097543761,
-0.3189490736,
-0.5415501595,
-0.2824765742,
0.3653012514,
-0.3381037712,
0.6569603682,
0.4309383929,
0.2098835409,
-0.2524694204,
0.3418763876,
0.5786064267,
0.2976225615,
-0.1896004379,
0.3640740216,
0.0287116859,
-0.732231915,
0.3964262903,
-0.1292713732,
0.076781325,
0.1693864912,
0.3340309262,
1.4342131615,
0.1208274588,
-0.3365553319,
0.4976412952,
-0.1139454618,
-0.3984628618,
-0.4208424091,
0.1018836796,
0.0876566842,
0.258421272,
0.3712013662,
0.2102799267,
0.3890543282,
-0.4978776276,
-0.0202820059,
0.301764369,
-0.4677739739,
-0.5383604765,
0.9619517326,
0.3770744205,
-0.5243958831,
0.1813376993,
-0.0024001945,
-0.3593510687,
0.6635733247,
0.4263091981,
1.2615247965,
-0.4011326134,
0.0454539098,
0.2881179452,
0.1055100039,
0.2736606896,
0.3526985049,
-0.3374389708,
-0.4087031484,
-0.2892445922,
-0.7204087377,
-0.3030935228,
-0.0184849557,
-0.8085148931,
-0.1207675859,
-0.3728044331,
-0.1650308818,
-0.1409499049,
-0.6459769607,
-0.5275168419,
0.0993645489,
0.6850264668,
0.6134062409,
-0.6778560877,
0.8568009138,
0.6256480217,
-0.0560212247,
-0.8377366066,
-0.1353185177,
-0.0736300796,
-0.7619804144,
0.6530982256,
-0.1037530005,
-0.3242192268,
0.2535273731,
-0.5621315837,
-0.8098502755,
0.9024640918,
0.7790868878,
-0.6796717048,
0.1965266615,
0.3348748386,
0.5770366788,
-0.8255596757,
0.358229965,
1.0254961252,
0.1605865508,
0.3467209637,
-1.1685209274,
-0.1122889444,
-0.4236420393,
0.1550184637,
-0.1793421507,
-0.149051398,
0.5924316049,
0.0636538416,
-0.32884112,
0.3259408176,
0.4017000496,
0.0293410029,
0.1561264098,
0.2888115644,
0.5869570971,
0.6674876213,
-0.267727524,
0.5218350291,
-0.6011899114,
0.0002058643,
0.5168609023,
0.0699481443,
0.8478892446,
0.3715056181,
-0.1676447839,
0.4199945629,
0.2052201927,
0.5737357736,
0.6414079666,
0.1835006177,
-0.4063316286,
-0.1409407854,
-0.1111755148,
-0.5734118819,
1.05542171,
0.5272007585,
-0.3914933205,
0.2238807082,
0.4450650811,
-0.2029846311,
0.0010725849,
-0.2264942378,
1.1283026934,
-0.0506621636,
-0.4925458133,
1.1307376623,
-0.480250746,
0.4330534339,
-0.7517496347,
-0.2590849996,
-0.2190223783,
-0.0667759404,
-0.3536530137,
-0.6399174929,
0.1502922922,
-0.2662937045,
0.1887712926,
-0.2758173347,
0.5877720714,
-0.9018964767,
0.1466331929,
0.2875531912,
0.2632696927,
0.5883067846,
-0.1168452874,
-0.2238963097,
0.4280796051,
-0.0283697899,
0.0280418061,
0.0579009801,
0.6305607557,
0.5595105886,
0.368948549,
0.562220633,
0.5713999867,
0.058918789,
0.6585941911,
0.7604193091,
-0.7113071084,
-0.9724941254,
-0.343678534,
0.3842017949,
0.1876085997,
0.1204638332,
0.1354991794,
0.1750891209,
0.3987188637,
-0.1286147833,
0.8446235657,
0.056037847,
0.2026203722,
-0.8334361911,
0.9315838218,
-0.2922276556,
-0.1576841027,
0.195980534,
-0.750500083,
-0.2314646095,
0.673252821,
0.2546410561,
-0.0015368853,
0.8021586537,
0.7166632414,
0.198217079,
0.4566760957,
0.5746885538,
0.1402018666,
0.1571906507,
0.6847322583,
0.8085606098,
-0.3618577123,
0.4903479815,
-0.340454787,
-0.2976178825,
-0.2013988793,
-0.562445879,
-0.5799344182,
-0.6881718636,
-0.3520645201,
-0.2881840765,
0.2568000257,
0.8023785353,
0.9534923434,
-0.8726983666,
-0.5208889246,
-0.4279695749,
-0.1328359693,
-0.2931734324,
-0.2607750297,
0.1234046295,
-0.1957719326,
-0.8832291365,
0.7566713095,
0.4152979851,
0.2932384014,
-0.5072506666,
-0.4132887721,
0.2973308265,
-0.2808411121,
0.3831459284,
0.4354333282,
-0.7580806613,
-0.1872774214,
-0.0055673607,
0.0418766513,
0.1433655471,
1.1452149153,
-0.5135659575,
0.5976129174,
0.6278636456,
0.3799898624,
0.2826136053,
-0.2125271559,
0.5996625423,
-0.721853137,
0.5576111078,
0.573005259,
0.2910420299,
0.4444019794,
-0.3331823051,
0.1566710174,
0.2976133823,
-0.4564123452,
-0.6387165189,
0.1447230577,
-1.0553041697,
0.0968928263,
1.0153543949,
-0.0189395249,
-0.510436058,
-0.1491283178,
-0.2893663645,
0.5084473491,
-0.5682575107,
0.2321676761,
0.4305762649,
-0.3912706375,
-0.3292553723,
-0.5124331713,
0.5066531897,
0.1820326895,
-0.4810597897,
0.0856281519,
0.6081994772,
-0.0501223169,
0.2501099706,
0.5967615843,
-0.1323854923,
0.3354306817,
0.5363808274,
0.5550888777,
-0.1248551607,
-0.4611036479,
-0.5557174683,
0.478775084,
0.0571697205,
-0.6400012374
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12997v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12997v1 | Suitability of CCA for Generating Latent State/ Variables in Multi-View Textual Data | 2024-06-18T18:37:24 | 2024-06-18T18:37:24 | Akanksha Mehndiratta, Krishna Asawa | cs.CL | cs.CL | The probabilistic interpretation of Canonical Correlation Analysis (CCA) for
learning low-dimensional real vectors, called as latent variables, has been
exploited immensely in various fields. This study takes a step further by
demonstrating the potential of CCA in discovering a latent state that captures
the contextual information within the textual data under a two-view setting.
The interpretation of CCA discussed in this study utilizes the multi-view
nature of textual data, i.e. the consecutive sentences in a document or turns
in a dyadic conversation, and has a strong theoretical foundation. Furthermore,
this study proposes a model using CCA to perform the Automatic Short Answer
Grading (ASAG) task. The empirical analysis confirms that the proposed model
delivers competitive results and can even beat various sophisticated supervised
techniques. The model is simple, linear, and adaptable and should be used as
the baseline especially when labeled training data is scarce or nonexistent. | [
-0.0050493032,
-1.0203288794,
0.9554581046,
0.1462588608,
-0.4151577353,
0.0031084979,
0.1342080235,
-0.1964479834,
0.5345875621,
0.2258487791,
-0.3177340627,
-0.6180227399,
-0.4092802107,
-0.190821901,
-0.2918176055,
0.9832625389,
-0.0505616702,
0.2122288048,
-0.5346719027,
-0.1618496329,
-0.8313282132,
-0.9051158428,
-0.4914380908,
0.0092046056,
0.4976449907,
0.5082308054,
0.5807490945,
0.2185769081,
0.6528585553,
0.2967360914,
-0.0352564976,
0.1571996212,
-0.4124375582,
0.1120821312,
-0.1465792507,
-0.6705614328,
-0.7244068384,
0.4494536817,
0.7038373351,
0.8249884844,
0.0634507015,
0.1648311019,
0.1054532751,
0.8052615523,
-0.7366390824,
0.445545584,
-0.3723046184,
-0.0828085095,
-0.1706928015,
-0.3170509636,
-0.4125860631,
-0.4002684355,
0.5054392815,
-0.8391204476,
0.2575813532,
-0.0879647657,
0.7709035277,
0.0429068282,
-0.5658205152,
-0.500584662,
-0.7369554639,
0.8784556389,
-0.2366127521,
0.025042383,
0.4965713918,
0.1714636236,
-0.0219473951,
-0.7300031781,
-0.7487898469,
-0.23336564,
-0.297208935,
0.4302642345,
0.1234346703,
-0.1419598013,
-0.1562713683,
0.5082710385,
-0.4603621364,
-0.0446891412,
-0.2493471503,
-0.0093921255,
0.4652124345,
0.346350044,
0.2605457902,
-0.4731918275,
-0.416084677,
-0.0773720518,
-0.5075883269,
0.3088304996,
0.5909041166,
0.5203641057,
-0.2685033679,
0.475933522,
-0.0435754396,
0.6619802117,
0.0418777652,
0.1328142881,
0.0679073036,
-0.5162811875,
-0.0255450066,
-0.146048218,
0.7874746919,
0.1415759325,
-0.2620117068,
-0.0164507218,
0.1810222417,
0.2784073353,
0.4936830103,
-0.7184264064,
-0.5836893916,
-0.0011213933,
-0.5588669181,
-0.5173600912,
0.1354516,
-0.8965278268,
-0.065176256,
-0.716942668,
0.2601045072,
-0.1407185644,
0.0427942127,
-0.3068424165,
0.3174808025,
0.203333199,
0.5096623302,
-0.5676825047,
0.3030735552,
0.494473815,
0.9244664907,
-0.4796567559,
0.0721355155,
-0.6257306337,
-0.2756220102,
-0.6815710664,
0.749902606,
-0.692728579,
-0.2404598892,
-0.0428000912,
-0.0805814639,
-0.246340245,
-0.2119107693,
0.469201982,
-0.7569902539,
0.2877747118,
-0.3692809045,
-0.5357275605,
-0.0903790891,
0.2991191149,
-0.9110212326,
0.7902842164,
-0.0378531851,
-0.8475430608,
0.366088748,
-0.1486603022,
-0.0839745775,
-0.0584132373,
-0.4048516154,
-0.7610341907,
-0.1503555924,
0.046247445,
0.5714454651,
-0.3097230196,
0.4167488515,
-0.3895449638,
-0.1611450464,
0.4781835377,
-0.4419189095,
0.3038842082,
0.2329202741,
0.1125890687,
-0.1327577531,
-0.7977921963,
-0.0639155954,
-0.1796689183,
-0.3031211197,
-0.7218616605,
0.4141533673,
0.0487691462,
0.2938129604,
0.2816585302,
-0.2721868455,
0.2124108374,
-0.2076694816,
-0.0786805749,
0.711012125,
0.3896389306,
0.6102699637,
-0.1220993102,
0.5480490327,
0.3905608654,
-0.1626788974,
0.0427673124,
-0.4817440808,
-0.6071845293,
-0.2678021491,
0.477610141,
0.534884572,
-1.0022259951,
0.4707285762,
-0.042437505,
-0.4602265954,
-0.195823431,
0.1333444118,
0.6707018614,
0.3866311014,
0.4448579252,
-0.6817266941,
-0.3489325643,
-0.7853684425,
-0.0981108174,
-0.3317013681,
0.2245451212,
0.2649710178,
0.4241544306,
0.1976084411,
1.0952260494,
-0.8858302832,
-0.762316823,
-0.2009361535,
0.5120502114,
-0.0751455575,
0.5056229234,
0.6301517487,
-0.8459303975,
-0.4315351248,
-0.3222561479,
-1.0487642288,
0.2403290719,
-0.3595450222,
-0.2991661429,
-0.1259852797,
0.534234941,
0.0086422507,
0.6985138059,
0.4619391561,
-0.349080354,
0.461941123,
-0.2383876294,
0.1858243495,
-1.3169817924,
0.0241878089,
0.2807219028,
-0.0029148178,
-0.7083768249,
-0.113586247,
-0.09586519,
-0.0039593372,
-0.4171613753,
0.3237887919,
-0.3032039702,
0.0499938242,
-0.384231925,
0.3695822358,
-0.2199356705,
0.7250558734,
0.3698307276,
0.759033978,
0.2217682898,
-0.7556385994,
-0.0096137058,
0.4198519886,
-0.124443084,
0.6267211437,
-0.3913611174,
-0.0000758747,
-0.1961820722,
0.4059308767,
-1.0494077206,
0.0448196419,
0.0058742724,
-0.5911699533,
-0.0070923646,
0.1150380895,
-0.4875986874,
0.0271169022,
-0.2596711516,
0.7012864351,
-0.0407913774,
-0.5705015063,
0.3847866356,
0.3584060073,
-0.0798322409,
-0.5172508359,
-0.2971298397,
-0.2265330702,
-0.0747491345,
-0.2483170182,
0.2525292039,
-0.1689976007,
-0.2229215801,
-0.1033250615,
-0.0279584583,
-0.3613076508,
0.0973482206,
0.2220541984,
0.492988348,
-0.1381376386,
0.3287519217,
0.0853955969,
-0.095312275,
0.1147309467,
0.043603465,
0.1779143959,
-0.256066829,
-0.108647041,
-0.610237062,
0.1759676039,
0.1306494027,
-0.1027286574,
0.8403527141,
0.2868970931,
-0.3858220875,
-0.0169795696,
0.0699051619,
-0.0140632531,
-0.3683585227,
0.2401721328,
-0.3195160329,
-0.4321633875,
0.5615024567,
0.0187020861,
-0.1960808933,
0.5956973433,
0.5939759016,
-0.065266192,
0.6581912637,
0.8493666053,
0.0085717607,
0.5747920871,
-0.3557782769,
0.3367045522,
-0.7909967303,
-0.3530503809,
-0.5420585275,
-0.0972122699,
-0.8774304986,
-0.4750122428,
0.423542887,
0.1336164922,
0.1769216955,
0.149893865,
-0.362794131,
0.3256871998,
0.4282806516,
0.3139052689,
0.285061866,
-0.3437021375,
-0.3001380861,
-0.304997474,
-0.3676047027,
-0.7894847989,
1.1858413219,
0.1447279751,
0.7012908459,
0.2621759474,
0.5073153377,
0.3486332893,
0.307749927,
-0.9319227934,
0.3706650436,
-0.447581023,
-0.4190497398,
-0.1460965574,
-0.1750672013,
-0.8978064656,
0.4275790751,
-0.5949265957,
-0.6716265082,
0.4354690313,
0.2320192009,
-0.3708139658,
0.1272327602,
-0.6298537254,
0.8087716699,
-0.0345637687,
-0.6123643517,
-0.0320564695,
-0.6802780628,
0.5697383285,
-0.4568239152,
0.0762459189,
0.1385063529,
0.2164956331,
1.0600699186,
-0.4564844072,
1.0226103067,
-0.0941626728,
-0.0519554578,
0.6730791926,
-0.0072230534,
0.2597779036,
0.3326919377,
0.2005455792,
-0.2134853154,
0.1449055076,
-0.445410192,
-0.5578576922,
0.7017588019,
-1.0802175999,
-0.2336212844,
-0.9010593891,
-0.406211853,
-0.3595806062,
-0.0577481166,
-0.0468017794,
0.3966510594,
-0.4736942053,
0.298345238,
0.6709509492,
-0.3194964826,
0.2658402026,
0.5577812791,
0.232862249,
-0.1075821072,
1.0887001753,
0.1348564029,
0.139804706,
0.7335215211,
0.1175902858,
-0.0938086361,
-0.2768498957,
0.0026951383,
0.0984670594,
-0.665745914,
-0.1809989214,
-0.5491963625,
-0.1978908777,
-0.1792209148,
-0.2134647816,
-0.4052904248,
-0.4798617959,
-0.7555453777,
-0.0906833112,
-0.1789609045,
0.6638040543,
0.1827566326,
0.6149895191,
-0.5399032235,
0.5002202988,
0.4508258998,
0.1127518713,
0.0151263494,
-0.3495783508,
-0.2686271966,
-0.2075184137,
-0.7773963809,
-0.8313059807,
0.4729995728,
0.0249667875,
0.553550601,
0.2656290829,
0.1609871238,
0.5857102275,
-0.3477354944,
1.0124742985,
0.2666734159,
-0.9238602519,
0.5574617982,
-0.2381675392,
0.0953042209,
0.638009727,
0.5018877387,
-0.233529985,
-0.5482475162,
-0.7225559354,
-1.0043458939,
0.7206380367,
0.4483069181,
-0.0246447921,
0.0181280281,
0.4745143652,
0.0992568806,
0.0702976957,
-0.5627662539,
-0.3365136385,
-0.1910893172,
-0.3949959576,
-0.2214215547,
-0.2876431942,
0.0058789607,
0.1584960371,
0.5817741752,
-0.4193147719,
0.5011172295,
0.1060165316,
-0.2727038562,
0.2499590367,
0.3500116467,
0.5712805986,
0.7296135426,
-0.2442606091,
0.1328184754,
-0.0868568346,
-0.8384023309,
0.202739656,
0.0434521101,
-0.0420759916,
-0.2210038602,
0.4714134932,
0.5006344318,
0.0577486418,
-0.2900609672,
0.8433735371,
-0.4289545715,
-0.1518719792,
-0.621430099,
-0.2988361418,
-0.3104782403,
-0.0539026931,
0.4168220162,
0.1458233297,
0.2085152268,
-0.5737732053,
0.4064179659,
0.2389412075,
-0.5099667311,
-0.4750772715,
0.7366266251,
0.1252062768,
0.2143444419,
0.624574244,
-0.1448724419,
-0.2454361469,
0.7395555377,
0.2086372524,
0.6030084491,
-0.0654138699,
0.3042600751,
0.5485243797,
0.0511342548,
-0.001125364,
0.0769444257,
0.0552662686,
-0.6932713389,
-0.2188934088,
-0.6855620146,
-0.5971232653,
0.1535790265,
-1.0987130404,
0.3289630711,
-0.4358763099,
0.0100080818,
0.3487035334,
0.2453355044,
-0.7531168461,
0.5544432998,
0.0096769901,
0.2353374809,
-1.2916978598,
0.9847833514,
0.6734082699,
-0.763807714,
-0.8427941203,
0.2531345487,
0.0925997123,
-0.5638616681,
0.7299721241,
-0.0258510131,
-0.1180257872,
-0.5676682591,
-0.5281324983,
-0.8105882406,
1.1020396948,
-0.082010366,
-0.3756698072,
-0.0846281946,
-0.0518095456,
0.9389588237,
-0.4367284775,
0.2530569136,
0.4375634193,
-0.0867680758,
0.2688096464,
-0.5718405247,
0.0256769881,
-0.1570041776,
0.1448937356,
-0.0580843203,
-0.7686475515,
0.8895419836,
-0.0912692696,
0.0215714891,
0.2092319578,
1.1813637018,
0.4580407143,
0.473898083,
0.3915739954,
0.2484765053,
0.6228327751,
-0.0922003835,
0.7777703404,
-0.1825974584,
0.4634488225,
1.2275191545,
-0.0598737709,
1.052883029,
0.3597468734,
-0.1343503445,
0.8398078084,
0.6667264104,
0.3204267025,
0.6472306848,
0.2426867038,
-0.1104846224,
-0.3011963069,
0.0971746221,
-0.0084699206,
0.738088429,
0.6144685149,
-0.3041726649,
0.0399913415,
-0.0754112452,
-0.0546608828,
0.5391783714,
-0.26715675,
0.7888367176,
0.2375197262,
-0.7473971844,
0.1162827313,
0.0832429752,
0.4804918766,
-0.3569539785,
-0.3592681885,
-0.1606419086,
0.3659158945,
-0.2217404544,
-0.5679460764,
0.2919295132,
-0.101481922,
-0.3610552847,
-0.1048315838,
0.4927022457,
-0.4815792143,
-0.5055137873,
0.0995412171,
0.5912014842,
0.2152798921,
0.3143651783,
-0.502073586,
-0.3602949381,
-0.2989093065,
0.0818409473,
0.4067765772,
0.2995254099,
-0.3796866238,
0.2968370616,
0.4349676073,
-0.1585315019,
-0.0644744337,
-0.0740070343,
0.83125633,
-0.643830955,
-0.8757682443,
-0.3321484029,
0.4090423882,
0.1404507309,
-0.1994706392,
0.6155466437,
0.661806643,
0.6564228535,
0.1309314519,
0.658410728,
-0.0582401194,
0.701890111,
-0.7469449639,
0.5183697939,
-0.5170149803,
0.3368078172,
-0.5733482838,
-0.6228342652,
-0.2387394309,
0.6045535803,
-0.5225367546,
-0.0633921847,
1.3071429729,
0.3760418594,
0.0722489208,
0.166879952,
0.1799983829,
-0.1465762854,
0.5599181652,
0.4485607445,
0.5077212453,
-0.6283317208,
0.5124129653,
-0.2045565099,
-0.3641755283,
0.0131400749,
-0.6387471557,
-0.9917625785,
-0.9853383899,
-0.3594838381,
-0.3384568393,
-0.1614814848,
0.5784758925,
0.4031044245,
-0.7586145401,
-0.1082533896,
0.0708198845,
0.0292127524,
-0.3800695837,
-0.2777769566,
0.8397060037,
-0.5280786157,
-0.8649088144,
0.1909978837,
-0.1918981075,
0.0672979206,
-0.2430397868,
0.1996413022,
-0.5591678023,
0.1610897481,
0.7513404489,
0.052159559,
-0.4790475368,
-0.2520325184,
-0.1548556983,
-0.3112911284,
0.0842442736,
1.020835638,
-0.8449618816,
0.7263312936,
0.4512012303,
0.4616082311,
0.4531169236,
0.3284870982,
0.6204836965,
-1.0393544436,
0.1405794472,
0.0368342139,
0.158877328,
0.0993931666,
-0.5936099887,
0.3236590326,
0.3764731884,
-0.5891194344,
-0.3820948303,
0.122404851,
-1.2801493406,
-0.2914351821,
1.0474789143,
-0.3557557464,
-0.236521095,
-0.144074142,
-0.0182547811,
0.3432322145,
-0.4562696517,
0.7755997777,
0.7379313707,
-0.2917433083,
0.2234681696,
-0.6177585721,
0.489441812,
0.3518251777,
-1.1872314215,
-0.216718778,
0.5568084717,
0.1616361886,
0.3742875457,
0.8892316222,
-0.1985681951,
0.2630176544,
-0.1108226329,
-0.2253728509,
0.4378989637,
-0.5026453137,
-0.3407130539,
0.3164457083,
0.0713920742,
-0.5673827529
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12975v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12975v1 | SHIELD: Evaluation and Defense Strategies for Copyright Compliance in LLM Text Generation | 2024-06-18T18:00:03 | 2024-06-18T18:00:03 | Xiaoze Liu, Ting Sun, Tianyang Xu, Feijie Wu, Cunxiang Wang, Xiaoqian Wang, Jing Gao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY | Large Language Models (LLMs) have transformed machine learning but raised
significant legal concerns due to their potential to produce text that
infringes on copyrights, resulting in several high-profile lawsuits. The legal
landscape is struggling to keep pace with these rapid advancements, with
ongoing debates about whether generated text might plagiarize copyrighted
materials. Current LLMs may infringe on copyrights or overly restrict
non-copyrighted texts, leading to these challenges: (i) the need for a
comprehensive evaluation benchmark to assess copyright compliance from multiple
aspects; (ii) evaluating robustness against safeguard bypassing attacks; and
(iii) developing effective defenses targeted against the generation of
copyrighted text. To tackle these challenges, we introduce a curated dataset to
evaluate methods, test attack strategies, and propose lightweight, real-time
defenses to prevent the generation of copyrighted text, ensuring the safe and
lawful use of LLMs. Our experiments demonstrate that current LLMs frequently
output copyrighted text, and that jailbreaking attacks can significantly
increase the volume of copyrighted output. Our proposed defense mechanisms
significantly reduce the volume of copyrighted text generated by LLMs by
effectively refusing malicious requests. Code is publicly available at
https://github.com/xz-liu/SHIELD | [
-0.3518446088,
-0.8294555545,
0.3286593556,
0.1510789245,
-0.2671835423,
0.4274407625,
-0.0805088952,
-0.4867414832,
-0.0861678943,
1.1279051304,
-0.5304871798,
-0.4029420614,
-0.7667841315,
0.2430064976,
-0.6233785748,
1.1506569386,
-0.1763970852,
-0.0444084816,
-0.3189309835,
0.0338038653,
-0.3999433517,
-0.5756458044,
-0.4752764404,
-0.0957352743,
0.2653593123,
0.2416584194,
0.3447545469,
0.775149107,
0.5989106894,
0.2706450224,
-0.006056583,
-0.0316105448,
-0.5648621321,
0.656724453,
-0.226446867,
-0.250926435,
-0.2986790836,
0.0889334828,
0.6657025814,
0.1715862453,
0.2607750893,
0.1630823463,
0.1848915219,
0.6411697865,
-0.8959819674,
-0.3152205646,
-0.9049619436,
0.1472138166,
-0.3269453943,
-0.2286436111,
-0.7164134383,
-0.1944858134,
-0.066443786,
-0.3144952059,
0.1569835842,
0.2841441631,
0.6955935359,
0.2965453267,
-0.4489916265,
-0.4147468507,
-0.4217386246,
0.8180732131,
-0.5450564027,
0.1396571696,
0.3689123094,
0.0851318315,
-0.3642047346,
-1.0384030342,
-0.4894095659,
-0.4054529071,
0.3905260563,
0.288420707,
-0.605022192,
0.0700844154,
0.4236079752,
0.1411919296,
-0.5428455472,
0.3507552445,
-0.1872621924,
-0.3913055956,
0.9088717699,
0.2082954943,
0.6225847006,
-0.1702322811,
-0.5793436766,
-0.141628772,
-1.1147691011,
-0.2005506307,
0.8373227119,
-0.0098059485,
-0.0711486489,
0.768251121,
0.0959676653,
0.4049879909,
-0.0203773528,
0.105870299,
-0.0541826561,
-0.1619067788,
-0.1917788535,
0.3246904314,
0.9314769506,
0.4147362411,
0.0458987989,
-0.12627922,
-0.2310290635,
-0.0756594166,
0.4099403322,
-1.0124366283,
0.0177459884,
0.2628237307,
-0.5870062709,
-0.7837117314,
0.2381936461,
-0.8836805224,
-0.9088432193,
-0.1557696313,
0.2982977033,
-0.175124079,
-0.0261589717,
0.1444929838,
-0.2444195896,
0.150260672,
-0.1849876195,
-0.5418453217,
0.3375867903,
0.7467766404,
0.6563913822,
-0.2973251343,
-0.2133794576,
-1.0303231478,
0.2144391686,
-0.25471735,
0.604041636,
-0.1429828405,
-0.6238275766,
0.0982794687,
0.0718974099,
-0.0594286583,
-0.6854342222,
0.6792408228,
-0.6356496811,
-0.0557284057,
0.1093892083,
-0.6925690174,
0.1326878667,
0.1493989974,
-1.0121589899,
0.5839741826,
-0.0570336357,
-0.9956459403,
0.1403593272,
-0.4556839466,
-0.7543324828,
0.1403707713,
0.0018971597,
-0.8359298706,
0.0603253469,
0.05036439,
0.5267580748,
-0.3828956485,
0.1132121161,
-0.3981458247,
-0.0897909775,
0.6190770268,
-0.3939751983,
0.919628799,
0.5621089339,
-0.64697963,
0.3258954883,
-0.5903047323,
-0.0563846305,
0.4226930737,
-0.2269858718,
-0.1693461388,
0.3036921918,
-0.0153132454,
-0.037944939,
0.2171550989,
-0.6357882023,
0.0474857241,
-0.331666708,
0.6121106744,
0.7333135009,
0.1693337411,
0.2759705186,
-0.6715052724,
0.7692577839,
-0.2179583907,
0.2358269393,
-0.1888297945,
-0.4188696444,
-0.4144337475,
-0.3697041869,
0.1692792475,
0.7077814937,
-0.8448020816,
0.3980363905,
-0.1260931045,
-0.422429502,
-0.4803448021,
0.5140247941,
0.6276242733,
0.3105960786,
0.2585824728,
-0.2664254904,
-0.728546977,
-0.6289756894,
-0.3881746233,
0.0623128302,
0.0071364134,
0.1524566114,
0.6041741967,
-0.3564524949,
0.878944993,
-0.3572778106,
-0.0236693919,
-0.5779387355,
0.073238112,
-0.1451250166,
0.4766444862,
0.4613643587,
-0.6640470028,
-0.2911201417,
-0.2022307366,
-0.7098567486,
-0.6077566743,
-0.2119267732,
-0.0794026852,
0.2366257757,
0.7255094051,
-0.3232425451,
0.3367601335,
0.5765987039,
-0.4424139261,
0.8057463169,
0.064945288,
0.0019366004,
-1.2016410828,
0.0084824581,
-0.115831092,
-0.2820639908,
-0.6729307175,
0.4440279901,
0.0284155309,
-0.1923956126,
-0.6167477369,
0.6483495831,
-0.2010954916,
0.197617501,
-0.4298995137,
0.1277136803,
0.1589125097,
-0.1995585412,
-0.1494548619,
0.7025392056,
0.3066843152,
-0.4821339548,
0.507390976,
0.0489976816,
-0.4697073102,
0.655341506,
-0.7054035068,
0.1968463063,
-0.0761536285,
0.3493900299,
-0.5169078112,
-0.1271413416,
0.2974526882,
-0.3063779771,
0.3568741679,
-0.268435955,
-0.4996319711,
-0.2280030698,
-0.7952078581,
0.2742763758,
0.4427852333,
-0.6114428043,
0.4827736616,
0.4420427978,
-0.1209442839,
-0.830994308,
-0.8202970028,
0.3570314348,
-0.480969429,
-0.6995880604,
0.6667304039,
-0.3438088894,
-0.5196237564,
-0.0716566071,
0.1258561164,
0.1939510852,
0.4932184219,
0.4170651138,
0.1765460819,
0.1181994453,
-0.2936169207,
0.0916409343,
-0.0398309007,
0.3735866845,
-0.3958302736,
0.5852878094,
0.1699662358,
-0.5023214221,
-0.1773956418,
0.2245499194,
0.4677958786,
-0.1311068535,
0.4243899286,
0.5470882058,
-0.1826703101,
-0.5829170346,
-0.4660653472,
-0.1398810446,
-0.486577034,
0.3318648934,
-0.2508186102,
-1.0394268036,
0.4545454383,
-0.105214335,
0.116371125,
0.4662880898,
0.7008332014,
0.0746847242,
0.6913388371,
0.3726477027,
-0.2526667118,
0.481590271,
-0.1844783425,
0.1477901787,
-0.8075094223,
-0.1104544178,
-0.6091627479,
-0.1265200675,
-0.7074453831,
-0.2448697537,
-0.0416522883,
0.134058103,
-0.3179625273,
0.5378701091,
-0.5653296709,
0.533600688,
0.5675586462,
0.0615494214,
0.3499286473,
-0.0225436836,
-0.1275875568,
0.1164400801,
-0.4911742806,
-0.5717208385,
1.2988904715,
0.5606636405,
0.8643838167,
0.1935225129,
0.9524022937,
0.7647229433,
0.3593851924,
-0.7041555643,
0.5969082117,
-0.1806574017,
-0.6431716084,
0.1441918015,
-0.7125711441,
-1.1485008001,
0.045930732,
-0.3573496044,
-0.6227794886,
-0.2888906598,
-0.1681965888,
0.0207668319,
0.4682400525,
-0.4382254779,
0.6777585745,
-0.4262662232,
-0.8594690561,
-0.0593488663,
-0.5112068057,
0.4896365106,
-0.3941881359,
0.3174192011,
0.0546183251,
-0.0308961757,
0.816352427,
-0.3605716825,
0.9067828655,
-0.0188006032,
-0.1162783056,
0.5883684158,
0.3452406526,
0.4499597549,
-0.0338172764,
0.0925730988,
-0.0627846792,
0.1127645299,
-0.3019966483,
-0.2238200307,
0.6687336564,
-0.5228232145,
-0.5441482067,
-0.2449291646,
-0.4852747023,
0.1712721139,
0.4181096554,
0.5922961235,
0.2028001696,
-0.2473903298,
0.26973629,
0.8703764081,
-0.4863421619,
0.4795535505,
0.3432962596,
-0.2602445483,
-0.7194217443,
1.162446022,
-0.1282155961,
0.2223325223,
0.2676223218,
0.3154602051,
-0.3630043268,
-0.8011724353,
-0.4533126354,
0.0286623351,
-0.6478523612,
-0.4701116383,
-0.3708424866,
-0.4246776402,
-0.4642464519,
-0.2789634168,
-0.0714754313,
-0.2123401761,
-0.1276711524,
-0.0272108577,
0.3252488971,
0.8653759956,
0.2555283308,
0.1408332586,
-0.8710349202,
-0.0430402048,
0.0036824432,
0.2791879475,
-0.1796101332,
-0.5871999264,
-0.0598930568,
-0.2736501992,
-0.6100542545,
-0.8836334348,
0.3212434947,
-0.2206266075,
0.6075490117,
0.2793018818,
0.448464781,
-0.0405895896,
-0.4689235985,
0.687920928,
0.2031563371,
-1.2073731422,
0.3501894176,
-0.3214681745,
-0.0667341724,
0.2502271533,
0.0856873617,
-0.0763365179,
-0.4869892299,
-0.5799274445,
-0.7926855683,
0.1387697011,
0.3871767819,
0.2690139711,
0.1095126867,
0.1517382562,
-0.2291907221,
0.2296060771,
-0.8086596727,
0.1287798882,
-0.2058117241,
-0.4617256522,
0.2676268816,
-0.2593713403,
-0.364869535,
0.2112691551,
0.6991913915,
0.0017838029,
-0.0625545084,
0.0425768308,
-0.3465117216,
0.1521321982,
0.4201900661,
0.7511727214,
0.0287891701,
0.0647416934,
0.2526930571,
0.1501125097,
-0.7898212671,
0.2059460282,
0.235000357,
-0.3128920197,
-0.3112498224,
0.5419704318,
0.4910577834,
0.0560597181,
-0.9131957293,
0.5992900133,
0.1021474749,
-0.5010139346,
-0.1860025972,
0.0213466454,
-0.1348981708,
0.232309863,
0.0777328238,
-0.36512357,
0.027981963,
-0.2241599411,
0.3310064375,
0.5516724586,
-0.2364089042,
0.0401161611,
0.8080019951,
0.0762652755,
-0.0873479471,
0.2192261666,
-0.0120273149,
-0.7289417982,
0.6848530173,
0.8126763701,
1.1286779642,
-0.0828246102,
-0.1542782187,
0.0256430171,
0.5337472558,
-0.0175881889,
-0.0149697391,
-0.0095536066,
-0.6949676871,
-0.3468621969,
-0.5139524937,
-0.5703235865,
0.1368309557,
-0.3612320423,
0.2333249599,
-0.7658164501,
-0.3400749266,
-0.2748308182,
0.1807080507,
-0.1976635456,
-0.0428039916,
0.191884473,
0.8690681458,
-0.5089480877,
0.7111180425,
0.403886646,
-0.4553123415,
-0.4363530278,
-0.158774808,
0.2848905623,
-0.4203394651,
0.389252156,
0.1815955639,
-0.4002061784,
-0.0394126438,
-0.7865037918,
-0.3396315873,
0.9981406331,
0.4037649035,
-0.5021511316,
0.5176967382,
0.1804508716,
0.1966051161,
-0.4036169052,
-0.1528001875,
0.551940918,
0.3249233961,
-0.1458864659,
-0.3537892997,
0.2241116464,
-0.2995326221,
-0.0109742703,
0.1114399061,
-0.3287726939,
0.5575209856,
0.045786202,
-0.1076675877,
0.2469330877,
0.3490726054,
0.5915015936,
0.654107213,
0.2800085247,
0.716614306,
0.5771859288,
-0.1052841619,
1.1561377048,
-0.3899129331,
0.0428787321,
1.0500328541,
-0.6169994473,
0.7995980978,
0.3294244409,
0.1227770001,
0.4092960656,
0.3238815367,
-0.5753257275,
0.1961468905,
0.8350592852,
-0.6566691995,
0.114300862,
-0.1314726025,
-0.1451960504,
0.1730935127,
0.150909856,
-0.525496006,
0.099902235,
0.1649085432,
0.4917606413,
0.4944700301,
-0.2505097091,
0.8326465487,
0.0923590213,
-0.4855759144,
0.3089623451,
0.3203279376,
0.6945926547,
-0.571282208,
0.2832295001,
-0.1065422818,
0.3567429185,
-0.3989521563,
-0.7756195068,
0.1677266657,
0.5299859047,
-0.2023662925,
-0.2139108032,
1.0092004538,
-0.1129300147,
-0.1724250168,
0.535261035,
0.1438513249,
0.0866481513,
0.1557482779,
-0.76348418,
0.527523756,
-0.0921946838,
-0.2956327498,
0.6829876304,
-0.0987152979,
-0.1722343862,
0.6692513824,
0.8228487968,
0.0897623301,
0.1527697146,
0.1631470323,
0.7829273343,
-0.3335487247,
-0.1380044818,
-1.1663051844,
0.3666022718,
-0.2944677472,
0.0716385171,
0.754016459,
0.6974583864,
0.8193773031,
0.0513780564,
1.1012802124,
-0.0069768117,
0.1320168972,
-0.8112063408,
1.0507817268,
-0.3181442916,
0.4959513247,
-0.3908844292,
-0.8401861787,
-0.4816528559,
0.2996904254,
-0.2357121408,
-0.1707444042,
0.5359653234,
0.6620274186,
0.2001045495,
-0.0124351652,
0.1483002603,
-0.1049053743,
0.8209587336,
0.4815840721,
0.9334990978,
-0.4205405414,
0.7045163512,
-0.1894492358,
-0.2408363521,
0.0161453225,
-1.3386849165,
-0.9567596912,
-0.2923954427,
-0.2061792165,
-0.9378496408,
0.0068044313,
0.8960976601,
0.4909953773,
-0.7624480724,
-0.4582820833,
-0.2327817827,
0.2793664336,
0.0300843064,
-0.2257459313,
0.3018591702,
-0.3626928329,
-0.5622437,
0.5259237885,
0.0565086529,
0.1788089573,
-0.2643471062,
-0.1996563673,
0.1625916213,
0.2915374935,
0.6564544439,
0.4128282368,
-0.5397174954,
0.0640011281,
-0.2014804482,
-0.3568231463,
-0.4409976304,
0.951667428,
-0.4232229292,
0.5298879147,
0.5617616773,
1.1601018906,
0.3249348998,
-0.0858363211,
0.5567222238,
-0.5936851501,
0.0582861565,
0.1852863431,
0.3817498982,
0.2442615926,
-0.2173450738,
0.4700006545,
0.4013692737,
-0.6222658753,
-0.9968914986,
0.3890167475,
-0.891928494,
-0.5119817853,
1.0273313522,
-0.3078396618,
-0.1321400851,
-0.0187160801,
-0.2206143886,
0.1869717985,
-0.1151368693,
0.5974770188,
0.5040239096,
0.3181393445,
-0.1092790365,
-0.6844509244,
0.5073177218,
0.3296067119,
-0.9344195127,
0.2361165434,
0.4335201383,
0.4115086198,
-0.0921378508,
0.2687604427,
-0.3103941679,
0.171406284,
-0.0921862647,
0.0931386054,
-0.2716725767,
-0.2650224268,
-0.4353285432,
0.2353974283,
0.1047589257,
-0.032569062
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12845v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12845v1 | Interpretable Preferences via Multi-Objective Reward Modeling and Mixture-of-Experts | 2024-06-18T17:58:28 | 2024-06-18T17:58:28 | Haoxiang Wang, Wei Xiong, Tengyang Xie, Han Zhao, Tong Zhang | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL | Reinforcement learning from human feedback (RLHF) has emerged as the primary
method for aligning large language models (LLMs) with human preferences. The
RLHF process typically starts by training a reward model (RM) using human
preference data. Conventional RMs are trained on pairwise responses to the same
user request, with relative ratings indicating which response humans prefer.
The trained RM serves as a proxy for human preferences. However, due to the
black-box nature of RMs, their outputs lack interpretability, as humans cannot
intuitively understand why an RM thinks a response is good or not. As RMs act
as human preference proxies, we believe they should be human-interpretable to
ensure that their internal decision processes are consistent with human
preferences and to prevent reward hacking in LLM alignment. To build RMs with
interpretable preferences, we propose a two-stage approach: i) train an
Absolute-Rating Multi-Objective Reward Model (ArmoRM) with multi-dimensional
absolute-rating data, each dimension corresponding to a human-interpretable
objective (e.g., honesty, verbosity, safety); ii) employ a Mixture-of-Experts
(MoE) strategy with a gating network that automatically selects the most
suitable reward objectives based on the context. We efficiently trained an
ArmoRM with Llama-3 8B and a gating network consisting of a shallow MLP on top
of the ArmoRM. Our trained model, ArmoRM-Llama3-8B, obtains state-of-the-art
performance on RewardBench, a benchmark evaluating RMs for language modeling.
Notably, the performance of our model surpasses the LLM-as-a-judge method with
GPT-4 judges by a margin, and approaches the performance of the much larger
Nemotron-4 340B reward model. | [
-0.4742850065,
-0.3387283385,
0.4888270795,
0.1263673156,
-0.2304513603,
0.1233774424,
-0.425347954,
-0.593172431,
0.1492993832,
0.6052300334,
-0.6091064215,
-0.3080288172,
-0.6947807074,
-0.0395773053,
0.1392645091,
1.1342562437,
-0.0587643832,
-0.0941063389,
-0.0965203792,
-0.2142861634,
-0.4978063703,
-0.7240859866,
-0.6012409329,
-0.7866836786,
0.4639735818,
0.6414300203,
0.7062328458,
0.6589186192,
0.2017976791,
0.2656214237,
0.0607616156,
0.3703759611,
-0.5034174919,
0.0419313014,
-0.2973823249,
-0.3745491505,
-0.4412791431,
0.20478037,
0.1614715308,
0.1348691881,
-0.5133084655,
-0.158321321,
0.0136971325,
0.5395325422,
-0.4969073236,
0.4434280097,
-0.643081367,
0.0897791907,
0.0075575025,
-0.4216176271,
-0.6224482656,
-0.1141849235,
0.2185005397,
-0.5838539004,
-0.1787338108,
0.3564141095,
0.8395437598,
0.2938338518,
-0.3742274642,
-0.1477559656,
-0.3232489824,
1.1444057226,
-0.6303603649,
0.4254003167,
0.5893448591,
0.2716853619,
-0.2254654765,
-0.1145000085,
-0.448346585,
-0.3688882291,
-0.1469593793,
0.2235148996,
0.178020373,
0.1818431169,
-0.2310716659,
0.1764707267,
-0.4411077499,
0.3299192488,
0.0641088039,
-0.2632333934,
0.7119016647,
0.1508814842,
0.1470182091,
-0.3287574351,
-0.6577524543,
-0.295999676,
-0.7301180959,
0.2490217686,
0.44068259,
0.3159391582,
-0.0708131269,
0.4542310834,
-0.4030485153,
0.6704139113,
0.2115112841,
-0.2761896253,
0.2421804368,
0.1039403081,
0.0176232271,
0.1158716902,
0.7969985604,
0.5635732412,
0.1807968169,
-0.4112792611,
-0.4381589293,
0.04223492,
0.4912357032,
-0.7305776477,
-0.2613551319,
0.1647087485,
-0.4996370971,
-0.5050824881,
-0.0127336988,
-0.6303508282,
-0.6551780701,
-0.548941493,
0.5609961152,
-0.2858176529,
-0.3587827384,
0.4729251862,
-0.0469238348,
0.1082399264,
0.2844619453,
-1.2191767693,
0.3041008711,
0.7574152946,
0.6088732481,
-0.3722789586,
-0.4973255098,
-0.6551377177,
0.12170735,
-0.0185472965,
0.9402555227,
-0.6131760478,
-0.2540797293,
-0.2104052603,
-0.2434549183,
0.0496951677,
-0.5375456214,
0.7941593528,
-0.6904242635,
0.1388540864,
-0.1910773516,
-0.4836795032,
-0.2019601613,
0.4042354524,
-0.4051215351,
0.7318515778,
0.0781809986,
-0.6147404313,
0.5831923485,
-0.6339989305,
-0.1465314776,
-0.0339150019,
-0.1704771072,
-0.2842731476,
-0.0096782502,
0.5038266778,
0.5067598224,
-0.1627158374,
0.4534064233,
-0.3651804924,
-0.3058751523,
0.393784821,
-0.3957318366,
0.0455130413,
0.1593093276,
-0.4944433272,
0.355252564,
-0.5774482489,
0.0164988451,
0.0145797944,
-0.6334697008,
-0.2470283806,
0.4008618295,
0.0486497283,
0.3827510774,
0.214339003,
-0.4313779175,
0.0778392404,
-0.4740577638,
0.447481811,
1.2269288301,
-0.1737177819,
0.536601305,
-0.3121788204,
0.5512843728,
0.0166816041,
0.0790688917,
0.19975999,
-0.408233732,
-0.6123759151,
-0.2699836195,
0.1276320219,
0.4257519841,
-0.5820513368,
0.4840457439,
-0.229581967,
-0.319494009,
-0.639142096,
0.0136829773,
0.4796019495,
0.4923807085,
0.54389745,
-0.4637736678,
-0.3829704523,
-1.1273394823,
-0.4514430463,
-0.430840075,
0.0098025845,
0.6104871631,
0.2545376122,
-0.178186506,
0.8563179374,
-0.6351940632,
-0.2091094702,
-0.3662714958,
0.3611501157,
0.2025588006,
0.3692218363,
0.1696244627,
-0.6740160584,
-0.3519794643,
0.0981535986,
-0.5177252889,
-0.0110920165,
-0.0154687986,
-0.2667108178,
-0.0709099099,
0.0072575673,
-0.3504196703,
0.0755101517,
0.543633759,
-0.3356150091,
0.5846906304,
-0.1581052989,
0.3294017613,
-0.7283553481,
-0.0972677246,
0.228402555,
-0.3805331588,
-0.4826345742,
0.124030225,
0.1049517021,
0.3111457527,
-0.4105102718,
0.9044912457,
-0.1977256089,
-0.0754070207,
-0.4675410986,
-0.0911276042,
0.0678390339,
0.8505008221,
0.5023533702,
0.7363389134,
0.2550600469,
-0.5504114032,
0.2878725827,
0.3412046432,
-0.4780308008,
0.8335333467,
-0.5877575874,
0.1940175742,
-0.0584486611,
0.3030313849,
-0.6150359511,
-0.4059397876,
0.4518388808,
-0.4541139007,
0.16454193,
-0.1660690159,
-0.180622831,
-0.0074515911,
-0.2554467618,
0.3441120088,
0.2503954768,
-0.7775759101,
0.5949668288,
0.4881524146,
-0.217158705,
-1.0156929493,
-0.5273013711,
0.132769078,
-0.3292466104,
-0.4392233491,
0.4694053233,
-0.0964597836,
-0.0831474438,
-0.0928326771,
-0.1117063612,
0.0335728414,
0.2131744921,
0.3711155951,
0.403652519,
0.1579608619,
0.0243786424,
-0.0498272255,
-0.4066784084,
0.1010328606,
-0.3162783682,
0.4979582727,
-0.4016211629,
-0.3542211652,
-0.3831409812,
0.1864937395,
0.3607805967,
-0.2896678448,
0.89608711,
0.5395380855,
-0.0681297332,
-0.1497521102,
-0.5709167719,
-0.4546757936,
-0.447280407,
0.4641913772,
-0.4124251604,
-0.9296247363,
0.3084596694,
0.2088183463,
0.1441657245,
0.1897544116,
0.6583785415,
0.1015223265,
1.3551926613,
0.3798293769,
-0.3927286863,
0.5323203802,
0.133173123,
0.0663304999,
-0.8133366108,
-0.5087704659,
-0.3463045359,
-0.361209929,
-0.2276503444,
-0.0876379609,
0.4538932145,
-0.0518762954,
-0.2857446969,
0.0633186623,
-0.3878197372,
0.5110120177,
0.4930949509,
0.4511130154,
0.1670027077,
0.0801097155,
-0.1018117443,
0.0151525335,
-0.4679275155,
-0.4873056114,
1.0750499964,
0.5170951486,
0.9771152139,
0.0647834316,
0.6057683229,
0.3498091698,
0.3659001589,
-0.9246080518,
0.2403590083,
0.0637657046,
-0.5065795183,
-0.3131211102,
-0.5599791408,
-0.7908255458,
0.594788909,
-0.4150958657,
-0.6756852865,
0.1497327834,
0.3336105943,
-0.2935821414,
0.2693710625,
-0.6785447598,
0.8443194032,
-0.4870673418,
-0.4128527343,
-0.510365963,
-0.7362546921,
0.3631685078,
0.2332148999,
0.4216787815,
-0.0689903349,
0.1241743192,
0.7322311401,
-0.0873156637,
0.6944581866,
-0.2055072486,
0.0615849011,
-0.3020832837,
0.0436606482,
0.6711838245,
0.1834484041,
-0.2983312011,
0.0671760961,
-0.3362619579,
-0.4336027205,
-0.5750329494,
0.6783256531,
-1.235925436,
-0.5526118875,
-0.487215668,
-0.6770370603,
-0.3632584512,
0.0043787723,
-0.0365019515,
0.4679709077,
-0.0204217546,
0.0256125759,
0.6576228738,
-0.2210794538,
-0.0683908761,
0.5041040182,
-0.1753687263,
-0.4278430939,
1.006849885,
-0.430836767,
0.3695560396,
0.5718485713,
0.3380180597,
-0.5939258337,
-0.5385002494,
-0.6648878455,
0.1117466912,
-0.7263619304,
0.0025381222,
-0.5885739923,
0.0756399408,
-0.0405374132,
-0.1111265197,
-0.3144117892,
-0.2125690579,
-0.3082746267,
-0.1780324876,
0.2141760141,
0.9155984521,
-0.1484947503,
0.3297929168,
-0.616035223,
0.3220654726,
0.534989357,
0.5237973928,
0.1021570563,
-0.6095361114,
-0.3956051171,
0.1353411227,
-0.162973091,
-0.7187590599,
0.5011755228,
-0.0702626631,
0.7506855726,
0.5697742701,
-0.0100893015,
0.5641865134,
-0.3017267585,
0.5094038248,
0.1741429418,
-0.9021058083,
0.2251513004,
-0.2627388239,
-0.1590154767,
0.6289905906,
0.2140513659,
-0.7288843393,
-0.1542476267,
-0.2828308046,
-0.7782631516,
1.1418405771,
-0.1748790741,
-0.1409752518,
0.0878628641,
0.3798629045,
0.3350605667,
0.4134475291,
-0.8861849904,
-0.1203621328,
-0.4552161098,
-0.137600854,
-0.3292547762,
-0.2365804911,
-0.1825770736,
0.0373474136,
0.7527366281,
-0.2135132104,
0.1367689371,
-0.1932023168,
-0.3087303638,
-0.1010422632,
0.6701104641,
0.5891894698,
0.6775557995,
-0.5882470608,
0.3355075717,
-0.0472598188,
-0.0323476084,
0.3463382423,
-0.1337628514,
0.1379211992,
-0.5759984851,
0.0197542235,
1.1460382938,
0.3357988894,
-0.6919706464,
0.5066054463,
-0.1991526484,
-0.1703577042,
0.0652571246,
0.1126755998,
0.0679336712,
0.1347678602,
0.1578682214,
0.2862199247,
0.082524538,
-0.5135617852,
0.0387346223,
0.4200341105,
-0.6695840955,
-0.2677089274,
0.5504838228,
0.1869127452,
-0.0104791606,
0.5376963615,
-0.2512755394,
-0.7646719813,
0.3056005538,
0.3681712151,
0.6125125289,
-0.1519166827,
0.4470174909,
0.1688445508,
0.2174553722,
-0.3789892495,
0.0032217605,
-0.0642427355,
-0.9289476275,
-0.3608576357,
-0.6504101157,
-0.6450558901,
0.017919844,
-0.8700201511,
0.0485716276,
-0.1910048276,
0.0532220416,
-0.1053279787,
-0.2433958352,
-0.6173808575,
0.1950513572,
-0.0466999784,
0.5253347754,
-0.9426562786,
0.6460354328,
0.7985081673,
-0.3756449521,
-0.8748964071,
-0.1930320263,
0.0957088992,
-1.153473258,
0.6133882999,
0.0655003712,
-0.1645348966,
-0.1520447731,
-0.4572121501,
-0.5441014767,
0.8351843357,
0.1936882585,
-0.2687810957,
0.1477274597,
-0.0310009234,
0.3731188476,
-0.4028370082,
0.6250693202,
0.6987293959,
0.6645234227,
-0.0884587541,
-0.7808095813,
-0.0362612344,
-0.1566953659,
-0.2991418839,
0.194462046,
-0.5570762753,
0.7755218744,
0.0113586178,
0.1646249741,
-0.1640823781,
0.5361557007,
0.7034119964,
0.0344783776,
0.7967998385,
0.6036453247,
0.5918303728,
0.0703456774,
1.1578687429,
-0.2246497124,
0.2825321257,
0.9260028601,
-0.2415087372,
1.0156487226,
0.4494520128,
-0.1222255602,
0.6139583588,
0.8382611871,
0.361552,
0.8074106574,
0.1396094412,
-0.1286223084,
-0.7549241781,
-0.2006898671,
-0.287922442,
0.3471801579,
0.181671679,
-0.0582217798,
-0.0328472704,
-0.1576036811,
-0.0322098471,
0.0304589979,
-0.2721537948,
0.7887554765,
0.0762509853,
-0.9059642553,
0.335051626,
0.4064334035,
1.0175807476,
-0.6147207618,
0.001602528,
0.0075807013,
0.1667536795,
-0.3275848329,
-0.8514276147,
-0.1726262867,
-0.1202647537,
-0.2748330235,
-0.3408167362,
0.5844987035,
-0.4836629629,
-0.1427622139,
0.2453674972,
0.3620790243,
0.0958048403,
-0.2133062184,
-0.7457318902,
-0.1826866269,
0.0157376621,
-0.3224610686,
0.6331381202,
-0.0372919552,
-0.0452451259,
0.8551291823,
0.6389993429,
0.1524402797,
-0.2404109538,
0.0282815583,
0.8082191348,
-0.5279299617,
-0.7759688497,
-0.8094285131,
0.4452868402,
0.1400355548,
-0.1312051564,
0.3748487234,
0.3556610048,
0.6958338618,
0.0124400603,
0.8900321722,
0.2268145084,
0.3785158098,
-0.552439034,
0.5619642735,
-0.6774945855,
0.3610849082,
-0.1728278548,
-0.7624457479,
-0.0172439814,
0.6842797399,
-0.3626536131,
0.0788989067,
0.4703556001,
0.739177227,
-0.0648702458,
0.0505606085,
0.1494963914,
-0.0044257557,
0.5032209754,
0.6943051815,
1.1432561874,
0.1792134643,
0.4539656043,
-0.1424824744,
-0.2855898738,
-0.4169124663,
-0.8487440348,
-0.7397996783,
-0.279283762,
0.0473994762,
-0.2543089688,
0.0560976453,
1.324585557,
0.8695947528,
-0.8599381447,
-0.401692003,
0.1012170017,
0.3419007659,
-0.3690287173,
-0.2179002464,
0.2865585387,
-0.2244019061,
-0.5488037467,
0.5074663758,
0.3301487565,
-0.3075858355,
-0.4643986821,
-0.7178832293,
0.067153044,
-0.004683991,
0.5043732524,
0.0971677974,
-0.9000220895,
-0.5129916668,
-0.0409798361,
0.0248971246,
0.2060600072,
0.5748429894,
-0.7639139891,
0.5008363128,
0.3907369077,
0.6602066755,
0.4743227661,
0.1608838886,
0.7150092125,
-0.6058764458,
-0.0410766229,
0.0836418122,
0.3770626783,
0.2495068014,
-0.2578831911,
0.2865230143,
-0.0608268715,
-0.840688467,
-0.6463222504,
0.2975911498,
-0.9949478507,
-0.2050316483,
1.1857923269,
-0.1618047655,
0.0422874615,
-0.2524956167,
-0.2808552086,
-0.0312732607,
-0.9153875709,
0.9742100239,
0.7776461244,
-0.2195065469,
-0.2085830122,
-0.3740389049,
0.4901520312,
0.5732645392,
-0.8462134004,
-0.0382114723,
0.4650866091,
0.2451337278,
-0.2102286816,
0.5618742108,
0.0775351077,
0.2928470671,
-0.4127552211,
0.3251413107,
-0.2774411738,
-0.3609035909,
-0.4064678848,
0.1476421952,
0.5668383837,
-0.0161017384
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12832v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12832v1 | LaMDA: Large Model Fine-Tuning via Spectrally Decomposed Low-Dimensional Adaptation | 2024-06-18T17:52:59 | 2024-06-18T17:52:59 | Seyedarmin Azizi, Souvik Kundu, Massoud Pedram | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG | Low-rank adaptation (LoRA) has become the default approach to fine-tune large
language models (LLMs) due to its significant reduction in trainable
parameters. However, trainable parameter demand for LoRA increases with
increasing model embedding dimensions, leading to high compute costs.
Additionally, its backward updates require storing high-dimensional
intermediate activations and optimizer states, demanding high peak GPU memory.
In this paper, we introduce large model fine-tuning via spectrally decomposed
low-dimensional adaptation (LaMDA), a novel approach to fine-tuning large
language models, which leverages low-dimensional adaptation to achieve
significant reductions in trainable parameters and peak GPU memory footprint.
LaMDA freezes a first projection matrix (PMA) in the adaptation path while
introducing a low-dimensional trainable square matrix, resulting in substantial
reductions in trainable parameters and peak GPU memory usage. LaMDA gradually
freezes a second projection matrix (PMB) during the early fine-tuning stages,
reducing the compute cost associated with weight updates to enhance parameter
efficiency further. We also present an enhancement, LaMDA++, incorporating a
``lite-weight" adaptive rank allocation for the LoRA path via normalized
spectrum analysis of pre-trained model weights. We evaluate LaMDA/LaMDA++
across various tasks, including natural language understanding with the GLUE
benchmark, text summarization, natural language generation, and complex
reasoning on different LLMs. Results show that LaMDA matches or surpasses the
performance of existing alternatives while requiring up to 17.7x fewer
parameter updates and up to 1.32x lower peak GPU memory usage during
fine-tuning. Code will be publicly available. | [
-0.6814360619,
-0.8504337668,
0.2876108587,
0.0030407312,
-0.5717936158,
-0.0885734037,
-0.527949512,
-0.38648054,
0.1756724268,
0.6900543571,
-0.3676815927,
-0.5758179426,
-0.4335961342,
-0.4396010339,
-0.0103873732,
0.8046544194,
0.0959328935,
-0.1982876211,
0.058994092,
-0.2521483302,
-0.6703488827,
-0.2226962745,
-0.9734774232,
-0.1668287963,
0.704396069,
0.492846638,
0.4714351296,
0.5454872251,
0.2947209775,
0.2819710374,
-0.1548565179,
0.6192432642,
-0.7952645421,
-0.0746157393,
-0.1451565921,
-0.454777807,
-0.7173319459,
-0.1635711938,
0.6767224669,
0.580847919,
-0.2749674618,
0.4155523479,
0.0618728921,
0.7956427932,
-1.0063010454,
0.2756989598,
-0.9043808579,
-0.1021489277,
-0.3261393309,
-0.1878085434,
-0.4486448765,
-0.2859203815,
-0.3610007763,
-0.573030293,
-0.153756246,
-0.0990987793,
0.6854575872,
0.6807348132,
-0.2548555434,
0.0148352263,
-0.6822747588,
0.5629491806,
-0.8294932842,
0.3967130482,
0.3667957187,
0.3115908802,
0.0456150807,
-0.5452982783,
-0.482611388,
-0.0205672942,
0.4359106123,
-0.0448744781,
-0.2688072622,
0.1757839918,
0.2533591688,
0.1870396584,
-0.2837106287,
0.6872320175,
-0.4484168887,
0.0273421481,
0.4976272285,
0.1854845285,
0.1379379034,
-0.0012375286,
-0.1708070636,
-0.1986480504,
-0.7573694587,
0.0719131753,
0.2787976861,
0.5776902437,
-0.3031166792,
0.21386531,
0.0256491732,
0.8442341685,
0.1554350108,
-0.0374352373,
0.0214427803,
-0.0372603908,
-0.5306145549,
0.2008416951,
0.4714319706,
0.3158180118,
0.1493910104,
0.0349485204,
0.0111521231,
0.0573996454,
0.151914075,
-1.0866811275,
-0.3440220952,
0.0475963466,
-0.4858887196,
-0.0284018274,
-0.5309199095,
-0.746111989,
-0.6060989499,
-0.4943154156,
0.4159136117,
-0.368021518,
0.175763458,
0.4021618068,
0.3667936623,
0.3439625502,
0.4680210054,
-1.1281235218,
0.3919692039,
0.7412800193,
0.6780669093,
-0.1386633366,
-0.2103096545,
-0.8687419295,
0.114058964,
-0.4222789705,
0.6684530973,
-0.5288687944,
-0.0512032732,
-0.3060410023,
-0.1869121939,
-0.1589419991,
-0.6224998832,
0.7867933512,
-0.5775353312,
0.0374022424,
-0.1381189525,
-0.2655777931,
-0.2022417933,
-0.0233144332,
-0.577460587,
0.8168672323,
0.0155871166,
-0.4486179054,
0.2538722456,
-0.8137485981,
-0.2956643105,
-0.1308926642,
0.3582415283,
-0.4940326214,
0.3261786699,
0.4025056362,
0.5070188642,
-0.6030368209,
-0.0780139938,
-0.3444295526,
-0.6056520343,
-0.0175905861,
-0.2492366135,
0.6777814627,
0.3157569766,
0.0794626102,
0.2437659353,
-0.9479598999,
0.0386853218,
-0.0057205278,
-0.4375044405,
-0.5182854533,
-0.0220018551,
0.0233815461,
-0.0222898573,
0.3464327455,
-0.3379298747,
0.4322912693,
-0.4953647554,
0.6223343015,
0.845661521,
-0.0489783436,
0.4638872445,
-0.0411979221,
0.1713142693,
-0.0330488309,
0.1718102396,
0.0041752881,
-0.2091467083,
-1.010833621,
-0.3884058893,
0.4129931927,
0.2812788785,
-0.5611733198,
0.3230634928,
-0.326738745,
-0.5092830658,
-0.6583654881,
0.451934725,
0.2765199244,
0.4057065248,
0.3812756836,
-0.3087143302,
-0.6179290414,
-0.8074210286,
-0.0385734923,
0.0409635305,
-0.0053796601,
0.3442875445,
0.3512690067,
-0.2374012917,
0.5824804902,
-0.8042619228,
-0.6008841395,
0.0649675652,
-0.0163172577,
0.3392251432,
0.348949492,
0.6131697297,
-0.4670871496,
-0.4985285699,
0.0701123476,
-0.244554013,
-0.0337956809,
0.0292311572,
-0.0637965351,
0.1986562312,
0.5264260173,
-0.5009106994,
-0.1244827509,
0.8411628604,
-0.3411639929,
0.2324265391,
-0.6650214195,
-0.2860456705,
-1.1136003733,
0.1567055881,
-0.1431965232,
-0.1261584759,
-0.6104400754,
0.1441681385,
0.0420716852,
-0.2839616239,
-0.2277260274,
0.4928148687,
-0.3489619195,
-0.0612203889,
-0.4055796862,
0.271222353,
-0.1064440385,
0.6517165303,
-0.3385412395,
0.7983331084,
0.4630398452,
-0.5664086342,
0.1539130062,
0.1948747486,
-0.6012752652,
0.4446431398,
-0.4373224974,
0.3552055955,
-0.250720799,
0.2001638263,
-0.6702417135,
-0.0387548991,
-0.0382401608,
0.0133243576,
0.257053256,
-0.1922400892,
-0.2841716707,
-0.0725864843,
-0.3615939021,
0.2680855095,
0.648568511,
-0.7212718725,
0.5722846985,
0.565679729,
-0.1097066328,
-0.3175218701,
-0.5699930787,
0.2693905532,
-0.1899828017,
-0.5024514794,
0.331335485,
-0.2688795626,
-0.1884036213,
-0.2980577052,
0.1618502289,
-0.1115675345,
0.336117506,
0.2036575377,
0.1210943684,
-0.4508221447,
0.0428238697,
0.1582168043,
-0.1452079266,
-0.1589516997,
-0.1804309785,
0.7889413238,
-0.1506429613,
-0.0983415693,
-0.3848882616,
-0.1104632691,
0.7740843892,
-0.4699307978,
0.8527880311,
0.8878390789,
-0.3255069554,
-0.6513802409,
-0.373716861,
-0.0876764134,
-0.5025493503,
0.4741621017,
-0.3984489441,
-0.8049084544,
0.6749061942,
-0.1546896398,
-0.1975501478,
0.1924009025,
0.7005775571,
-0.0000438658,
0.7869595885,
0.6420734525,
-0.2542886138,
0.5551934838,
-0.3076950014,
0.2499281019,
-1.0780917406,
-0.0100754686,
-0.4623821974,
-0.6817474365,
-0.511009872,
-0.6981934905,
0.3466359973,
0.2680496275,
-0.5629531741,
0.1719043702,
-0.5078116059,
0.6897889972,
0.3128195405,
0.2340264469,
0.3147398531,
-0.059737578,
0.300899595,
-0.0163344964,
-0.5016447306,
0.0036964689,
0.8071753979,
0.4033995569,
0.7040803432,
0.1522320211,
0.4412502944,
0.194264099,
0.0030197199,
-0.639877677,
0.5694320798,
-0.8159421682,
-0.136705935,
-0.3811135888,
-0.2952846289,
-0.83575207,
0.2689113915,
-0.2583152056,
-0.7868576646,
0.4516352415,
0.0109738484,
-0.5230473876,
0.4278022051,
-0.7970057726,
0.6718202829,
-0.0165845379,
-0.390216887,
-0.4849478304,
-0.2701079249,
0.5103235245,
-0.3400549889,
0.0082521364,
-0.3062328696,
-0.1177992821,
0.6700624824,
-0.1583988816,
0.9003894925,
-0.4811474979,
-0.5792803764,
-0.0764464512,
0.1200916469,
0.7945138812,
-0.0532401651,
-0.2713764906,
0.0118531054,
-0.0948468819,
-0.4006538987,
-0.5429504514,
1.0028847456,
-0.897739768,
-0.4092595875,
0.0977798179,
-0.8443408012,
-0.45477736,
0.1274230629,
-0.155970186,
0.3456829786,
-0.1116575748,
0.2674719989,
0.6825885773,
-0.4203840792,
0.4036438763,
0.5274493694,
-0.0986328349,
-0.3789410591,
1.0912406445,
-0.0204945672,
0.140280813,
0.328068465,
0.1013978943,
0.0260800794,
-0.9589458704,
-0.2617674172,
0.1946303993,
-0.6453055143,
-0.2464885265,
-0.1485680491,
-0.1986603439,
-0.0704271272,
-0.1681261063,
-0.5811170936,
-0.3286145627,
-0.3217634559,
0.1868400872,
0.3263424635,
0.3870654702,
0.0443156324,
0.3061029017,
-0.4308140278,
0.5659844279,
0.4484529197,
0.5956352353,
0.075883545,
-0.5486232042,
-0.3445669711,
0.0953451619,
0.0575041361,
-0.1991253644,
0.4064970315,
0.5541272163,
0.1380137056,
0.3742485046,
0.0880647823,
0.9301629663,
-0.4214857221,
0.5403226614,
0.0362603702,
-1.0743592978,
0.3577544093,
-0.4612115026,
0.4924150109,
0.5320051908,
-0.1024723649,
-0.3033258915,
0.0452085845,
0.0357313901,
-0.5790811777,
0.6996618509,
-0.1464897394,
0.2661829889,
0.5056567788,
0.4462485015,
-0.0577237643,
-0.1708213985,
-0.5138708353,
-0.1700754017,
-0.1112419292,
-0.0970963761,
-0.4225457311,
-0.3477559388,
-0.2092490196,
-0.5208153129,
0.5578150749,
-0.499422729,
0.1062621251,
-0.3076429367,
-0.1653890312,
-0.0850346014,
0.3782635331,
0.8553600311,
0.6093319058,
-0.4834365249,
0.1421840638,
0.6380301118,
-0.4207020104,
-0.0773963183,
0.1177903041,
-0.0195261165,
-0.4922918975,
0.108629331,
1.3002827168,
0.4313093722,
-0.5700991154,
0.0805136859,
-0.024135001,
-0.1063864678,
0.1073675677,
0.2681099474,
0.2750363052,
0.3810524046,
0.273473829,
0.1859507412,
-0.2558799684,
-0.5371717811,
-0.1176718548,
0.4103081524,
-0.3313731849,
-0.351126045,
0.7213948369,
0.0908888131,
-0.078171052,
0.3797565997,
-0.1373565942,
-0.1061204746,
0.442992419,
0.6806900501,
0.7479277849,
-0.2397402376,
0.235969156,
0.2987084389,
0.1472944915,
0.1423721164,
0.2608934939,
0.105056636,
-0.7563710809,
-0.6143776774,
-0.8888692856,
-0.2444051504,
0.1774701029,
-0.3998833299,
0.3285270631,
-0.6731896996,
0.1031313613,
0.1188163012,
0.308647722,
-0.2763914466,
0.0029714634,
0.5231350064,
0.9238787889,
-0.5799056888,
1.3944499493,
0.3336278498,
-0.1942382306,
-0.5899803638,
-0.1655096859,
-0.306389153,
-0.7976359725,
0.6411734223,
-0.3065130115,
-0.247461319,
0.1834333092,
-0.3434592187,
-0.9025849104,
1.1953142881,
1.0935051441,
-0.5174917579,
-0.0764822662,
0.1471510977,
0.6770070791,
-0.2604436278,
-0.1460053772,
0.6224409342,
0.6223929524,
-0.0239905156,
-0.9312519431,
0.2320678383,
-0.0703995079,
0.0849470273,
0.3366200626,
-0.8688045144,
1.1836878061,
-0.202721253,
-0.1692850739,
0.0689857602,
0.4550255537,
0.0089265062,
0.0264554713,
0.4891256392,
0.6716710329,
1.0912464857,
0.0109973997,
0.8273727298,
-0.452747643,
0.3577812612,
1.0510724783,
-0.4361250997,
1.1547967196,
0.2857023478,
-0.0500521585,
0.6323999763,
0.3557220101,
-0.0896917805,
0.5778167248,
0.1020641476,
0.0057659112,
-0.3402049839,
-0.1776401848,
-0.3419306576,
0.7829840779,
0.4724757671,
-0.1270785928,
-0.2842788398,
0.2797943056,
-0.0867916644,
-0.0002698525,
-0.689394176,
0.6276566982,
0.1367783099,
-0.4767407477,
1.2763909101,
0.1449731141,
0.5561109781,
-0.5594938397,
0.1066902727,
-0.2783426344,
0.6122175455,
-0.1774588376,
-0.318069905,
0.1916092187,
-0.1835767627,
-0.167838484,
-0.0902857184,
0.7234632969,
-0.3899520934,
-0.3211291134,
0.2975228727,
0.1779468805,
-0.3514086902,
-0.1114828959,
-0.5909278393,
0.4346612394,
-0.0951695517,
0.0882730931,
0.5464091897,
0.1058964878,
0.0736845359,
0.7860285044,
0.7559756637,
0.2606157959,
-0.0447456725,
0.0742441639,
0.9853169918,
-0.5110273957,
-0.436129421,
-0.6162365079,
0.0972466767,
0.125988394,
-0.2481879443,
0.606574595,
0.531488657,
0.4134255052,
-0.04620713,
0.3366912603,
0.2384711802,
0.2144595683,
-0.9466522932,
0.9003179073,
-0.5809627771,
0.4429108202,
-0.1382312924,
-1.1173826456,
-0.3526319265,
0.2720722258,
-0.2980741858,
-0.205629617,
0.4710431695,
0.7754921317,
-0.3268907964,
-0.2135213763,
0.3297352791,
0.7206645608,
0.2710887194,
0.8587644696,
0.3545501828,
-0.4648796916,
0.3378455639,
-0.0346827172,
0.1623774171,
-0.2637898624,
-0.6732519269,
-0.920930326,
-0.7444700003,
-0.1927716881,
-0.1389618069,
0.2351407707,
0.7346228957,
0.7913716435,
-0.8289859891,
-0.2510152459,
0.1546790004,
0.0731023997,
-0.0591686107,
-0.1637283862,
0.7248734236,
-0.2595103979,
-0.831289947,
0.5956708193,
0.2859219015,
-0.2354586571,
-0.427518189,
-0.207914412,
-0.1570553035,
0.2257530987,
0.7829265594,
0.3776904941,
-0.4944758117,
-0.3978429437,
-0.3620398045,
-0.0363354757,
0.2720503807,
0.5052119493,
-0.833553195,
0.3569028974,
0.5037127733,
0.6367000341,
0.9941157699,
-0.1641750932,
0.4029031694,
-0.6519753933,
0.2934222221,
-0.0404691771,
0.286750555,
0.0720086545,
-0.05763622,
0.3510509431,
-0.2349034995,
-0.3844641447,
-0.9818353653,
0.0521181077,
-1.3395860195,
-0.4929392636,
0.9069944024,
0.2659510374,
-0.329554826,
0.1151470765,
-0.4169701338,
0.0170500427,
-0.2288859934,
0.8690078855,
0.3232131004,
0.1250138581,
-0.3972197473,
-0.3985505998,
0.5913150311,
0.226678744,
-0.9179765582,
0.4040665925,
0.2242330015,
0.0075920387,
0.06602671,
0.3143604696,
0.2525528669,
0.1085135788,
-0.190268591,
-0.0506856777,
-0.3469462991,
-0.0870245472,
-0.4526549876,
0.3943134248,
0.2259638011,
0.0364508629
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12830v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12830v1 | What Are the Odds? Language Models Are Capable of Probabilistic Reasoning | 2024-06-18T17:51:24 | 2024-06-18T17:51:24 | Akshay Paruchuri, Jake Garrison, Shun Liao, John Hernandez, Jacob Sunshine, Tim Althoff, Xin Liu, Daniel McDuff | cs.CL | cs.CL | Language models (LM) are capable of remarkably complex linguistic tasks;
however, numerical reasoning is an area in which they frequently struggle. An
important but rarely evaluated form of reasoning is understanding probability
distributions. In this paper, we focus on evaluating the probabilistic
reasoning capabilities of LMs using idealized and real-world statistical
distributions. We perform a systematic evaluation of state-of-the-art LMs on
three tasks: estimating percentiles, drawing samples, and calculating
probabilities. We evaluate three ways to provide context to LMs 1) anchoring
examples from within a distribution or family of distributions, 2) real-world
context, 3) summary statistics on which to base a Normal approximation. Models
can make inferences about distributions, and can be further aided by the
incorporation of real-world context, example shots and simplified assumptions,
even if these assumptions are incorrect or misspecified. To conduct this work,
we developed a comprehensive benchmark distribution dataset with associated
question-answer pairs that we will release publicly. | [
-0.3403833508,
-0.7543029785,
1.022244215,
0.2774446011,
-0.2661717832,
-0.3947249055,
-0.2583685815,
-0.1006497368,
-0.3328454196,
0.7042657733,
-0.4396134317,
-0.6084209681,
-0.212174505,
-0.2133410573,
-0.3372918665,
0.6854724884,
0.0759521127,
0.0711470172,
-0.273848176,
0.1392920166,
-0.1630917788,
-0.5213055611,
-0.4064915478,
-0.2884089649,
0.0853847042,
0.176926896,
0.9937226176,
0.3707943261,
0.8196491003,
0.1697203815,
0.0146778449,
-0.1244297028,
-0.1368854642,
0.0765276775,
-0.3050048947,
-0.6990472674,
-0.1483435333,
0.043947231,
0.5888164043,
1.1569401026,
-0.2801830173,
0.180059731,
-0.2041484416,
0.4670624137,
-0.7539345026,
0.261123389,
-0.4479981363,
0.0965947285,
-0.1125805452,
-0.1608958244,
-0.7175361514,
-0.7325743437,
0.1964790672,
-0.4261378646,
0.101648353,
0.0349068679,
0.3677684665,
0.069400765,
-0.3203041852,
-0.287411809,
-0.8399648666,
0.7635312676,
-0.5619049668,
0.3494715989,
0.7482509017,
0.6931462884,
-0.3109299541,
-0.4822126031,
-0.5479373932,
-0.2849714756,
0.2386827022,
-0.0828543901,
-0.1963775605,
0.0470831916,
0.0225795563,
0.1171613634,
-0.5531898737,
-0.1371795684,
-0.0397584252,
0.0914565474,
0.7631758451,
0.0820774734,
0.3363111317,
-0.1804935485,
-0.0167308785,
-0.4015524387,
-0.5682827234,
-0.0157878995,
0.5259653926,
0.1993946284,
-0.1888878793,
0.5758115649,
-0.204121381,
0.9867300391,
-0.5944123268,
-0.0891109705,
0.0843657777,
-0.3689802289,
-0.2732078135,
-0.2981330156,
0.6755312681,
0.4928372502,
0.9085946083,
-0.1671479344,
-0.204178527,
-0.2244450897,
0.1155942529,
-0.263789624,
-0.3500225544,
0.4759732485,
-0.4411438107,
-0.3811249733,
0.0150923459,
-0.3049588799,
-0.3361153305,
-0.1014620513,
0.4358291924,
-0.6530438066,
-0.4411569238,
0.4352396429,
-0.4792629182,
-0.2276236862,
0.2439544201,
-0.6652293205,
0.1903697848,
0.8852737546,
0.4107988477,
0.0903249606,
-0.0046920297,
-0.0729181692,
0.0725493282,
-0.5579055548,
1.0228362083,
-0.4991385639,
-0.1058192477,
0.0553655587,
-0.2150845528,
-0.0997979343,
-0.6835715175,
0.805657804,
-0.3744490147,
-0.1498902887,
-0.0906079561,
-0.8016596437,
-0.1923786849,
0.0669725165,
-0.6378727555,
0.5819157958,
0.0081783198,
-0.8392891288,
0.4462268054,
-0.222656846,
-0.1315300465,
0.3068445921,
-0.106770508,
-0.0171004049,
0.2011414021,
-0.0101814894,
0.5739629865,
-0.2888454795,
0.496717453,
-0.7449195385,
-0.2692255378,
0.7611030936,
-0.8616136909,
0.777327776,
0.4411290884,
-0.1253087074,
-0.4061355591,
-0.5999838114,
0.1874278188,
-0.0604074523,
0.134410724,
-0.5295149684,
0.3941825032,
-0.0433511585,
0.0143848779,
-0.1998922825,
-0.2220347375,
0.1093702018,
-0.4321133196,
0.2259962261,
0.3931487501,
0.2783609927,
0.5800926685,
-0.2078195065,
0.5628402829,
-0.0507295094,
0.2954590023,
0.1008545905,
-0.6305367351,
-0.2018001229,
-0.3001757562,
0.3606368899,
0.7434648275,
-0.6280544996,
0.3085162044,
-0.0957254469,
-0.7157370448,
-0.3656283617,
-0.2269007415,
0.3022108972,
0.3829977512,
0.0517814681,
-0.0033884298,
-0.2802266181,
-1.0000399351,
-0.4494643509,
-0.3647409678,
-0.1276957542,
0.055014234,
0.3967885375,
0.2569676638,
1.2207690477,
-0.5928201079,
0.2486139089,
-0.5383985639,
0.0891031548,
0.3275219202,
0.269035399,
0.6031847,
-0.8258478045,
-0.0661759749,
-0.1821397245,
-1.1029118299,
-0.1953157932,
0.0218318161,
-0.2310859412,
-0.0864918157,
0.0896038562,
-0.7012526393,
0.6141005158,
0.3927309811,
-0.3268595934,
0.7165070176,
-0.3342519104,
0.0623481572,
-0.6725966334,
-0.1737606525,
0.4098542035,
-0.0349613205,
-0.7867897153,
0.25052315,
-0.0251330771,
-0.0069487239,
-0.4253876507,
0.7120449543,
-0.2069181204,
-0.2574927211,
0.0204930734,
0.1137396693,
-0.1732660383,
-0.209464401,
0.45974347,
0.4751040637,
0.5399466753,
-0.462557584,
0.1745565683,
-0.2587472796,
-0.9596072435,
0.3879707754,
-0.5177221298,
-0.5542446375,
-0.3198666275,
0.4251539707,
-1.0768049955,
-0.2499330938,
0.2757225931,
-0.3052907884,
-0.2788964212,
-0.2579880059,
-0.6685367227,
-0.3636174202,
-0.136102438,
0.1967131495,
0.610000968,
-0.1708363593,
0.1371869445,
0.4996527135,
-0.1285934597,
-0.5326527357,
-0.741684854,
-0.0950145945,
-0.280361563,
-0.6157109141,
-0.1447193176,
0.0483372435,
-1.2621132135,
0.1719819456,
0.1590524465,
-0.2385747582,
0.2548385262,
0.097529456,
0.0591790155,
-0.2304349542,
0.2916682661,
-0.0683121979,
-0.0595288165,
0.1298707873,
-0.2879379094,
0.3461888731,
0.1187484413,
-0.6832490563,
-0.3541721404,
0.120861955,
0.0479764268,
-0.0559904091,
0.8793485165,
0.1461885273,
-0.5500032902,
-0.3899750113,
-0.5594350696,
-0.1642795205,
-0.3744772077,
0.176588878,
-0.7076979876,
-0.2551092505,
0.4244254231,
0.2503828406,
0.0806020945,
0.2012009323,
0.5016901493,
-0.4192338288,
1.1256375313,
0.2217246145,
0.45857355,
0.2011834085,
-0.2467309535,
0.6088069081,
-0.2831165791,
-0.1021003872,
-0.3577796221,
0.2567403316,
-0.4937815368,
-0.8724559546,
0.277294606,
0.5117140412,
0.006958039,
0.2679878771,
-0.2234248519,
0.6449612975,
0.5700956583,
-0.0466165394,
0.1730990708,
0.0958328694,
-0.2561262846,
0.072437793,
-0.5480061769,
-1.1242169142,
1.1156693697,
0.415502876,
0.8185036778,
0.1692027897,
0.7619960904,
0.4203202128,
0.5865868926,
-0.5686867833,
0.588460505,
-0.2348940372,
-0.6153616309,
-0.3835273683,
-0.511033237,
-0.6987652779,
0.4217336178,
-0.1629813313,
-0.8852468729,
0.2000242621,
0.094813101,
-0.2735032439,
0.3290140033,
-0.9508106112,
0.9235733151,
0.0250023007,
0.0546939634,
-0.0934683084,
-0.3885391653,
0.6651182175,
-0.0277973581,
0.8885656595,
-0.4084011614,
0.1319743097,
0.4036316872,
-0.322296679,
0.5613875985,
-0.1379127353,
-0.2286885083,
0.795816958,
0.3659705818,
0.1122571602,
0.09902706,
-0.7962331772,
-0.0809389278,
0.3940021992,
-0.1978731006,
-0.8227458,
0.2952012122,
-0.6416791677,
-0.4583519101,
-0.2201188654,
-0.6641772389,
-0.3763446808,
-0.3015139401,
0.132508412,
0.6525138021,
-0.2409052998,
0.0942863896,
0.3977483809,
-0.2106838375,
0.3242141604,
0.4304068089,
-0.094115369,
-0.2028001696,
0.8963971138,
0.1582300663,
0.5173168182,
0.4073952138,
0.2690844834,
-0.7340381145,
-0.3879930377,
-0.4915313125,
0.273789078,
-1.2446688414,
0.1996500492,
-0.6679403186,
0.0171685349,
-0.4412432909,
-0.1434207261,
0.0759779438,
-0.6434937119,
0.1668346375,
-0.1896394938,
0.1432680488,
0.7247617245,
-0.0450979248,
0.3003126383,
-0.615873456,
0.2393898517,
0.1608835459,
0.0795743018,
0.0192638692,
-0.4738437831,
0.1697513312,
0.1939981878,
-0.0432683043,
-1.2668734789,
0.3974770308,
0.0249310732,
0.783428669,
0.2598375976,
0.1658660024,
0.308889389,
-0.5415382981,
0.7197007537,
-0.0246322285,
-0.5651543736,
0.4778485596,
-0.2644723654,
-0.1292505562,
0.4500803649,
0.5233702064,
-0.3838111162,
-0.7106623054,
-0.7665224075,
-0.5112679601,
0.5993804336,
0.3468801379,
-0.0080419201,
-0.4637876749,
0.3418107927,
-0.0543786958,
0.0019635858,
-0.4838936627,
-0.2573772669,
0.1326164454,
-0.5942891836,
-0.3131822348,
-0.0797142759,
-0.0288825557,
-0.1160828099,
0.3611749113,
-0.0384558216,
-0.0166344009,
-0.0685921013,
-0.1771734208,
0.1457902044,
0.3924188316,
0.5969158411,
1.0914767981,
-0.4695810378,
0.5420612097,
0.0416367091,
-0.1769465506,
0.2880855799,
0.1217821464,
-0.1993367821,
0.1782513708,
0.5516140461,
0.7376884222,
0.1468999088,
-1.050339222,
0.494645685,
-0.2184624523,
-0.1394820362,
-0.3729968369,
0.1440138817,
0.6092140079,
0.0875568986,
0.5657512546,
-0.1772371382,
0.3333846629,
-0.8237602115,
0.3790082037,
0.362165302,
-0.1415491849,
-0.3212853968,
0.4980071485,
-0.1163296327,
-0.4423106313,
0.2703174949,
-0.4650403261,
-0.3176168203,
0.9494884014,
0.5042721033,
0.6566669941,
-0.0310506988,
0.5295437574,
0.2015349269,
0.3365639746,
-0.4247074723,
0.5419996977,
0.0916594863,
-0.8980619311,
-0.4973977804,
-0.8877843618,
-0.64602983,
-0.2371178716,
-0.4719551504,
0.2791853249,
-0.0082608592,
-0.1987033337,
0.2555175126,
-0.2995607555,
-0.5537164807,
0.454456836,
0.2669002712,
1.1413205862,
-1.1501959562,
0.6972587109,
0.6669875979,
-0.4831029475,
-0.7539823651,
0.0004626018,
-0.1144105494,
-0.8347225189,
0.9969931245,
-0.0961281881,
0.2150315195,
-0.1627719402,
-0.2696803808,
-0.5939173102,
0.4131984115,
0.4501149058,
-0.4894960225,
0.4965705276,
0.3717138171,
0.6346058846,
-0.3953967392,
0.7299247384,
0.6268850565,
0.4015132487,
-0.1394264847,
-0.8362441659,
-0.233885482,
0.0538677424,
0.0936610922,
0.0784427226,
0.0327619761,
0.7646476626,
-0.415951252,
-0.043335136,
-0.2127535641,
0.4822253883,
0.801805377,
0.3475616574,
0.7150609493,
0.609913826,
0.5419198275,
-0.0531510934,
1.522662878,
-0.3748828173,
0.3210986257,
0.8448023796,
-0.2909743488,
1.2502286434,
0.2343357652,
-0.6196347475,
0.397356391,
0.7487745285,
0.5093650222,
0.5420323014,
0.5135228038,
-0.6467890739,
-0.5751138926,
-0.1548716724,
-0.1764010638,
0.2207874805,
0.5241159201,
-0.2574337423,
-0.3225308359,
0.0032691965,
-0.2861014307,
0.236211881,
0.0952315703,
0.4914835989,
0.2901902795,
-0.8190929294,
0.288973093,
0.0482016318,
0.2677056789,
-0.3463768661,
-0.1245960891,
-0.2010115087,
0.3597680032,
-0.0580157563,
-1.6667634249,
0.3871961832,
0.1335413903,
-0.0150241656,
-0.1156360582,
0.6083757877,
-0.3632009625,
-0.6738387942,
-0.0665369779,
0.5351196527,
0.7661844492,
-0.1367511153,
-0.5748345852,
0.0634078681,
-0.2230262607,
-0.3406794965,
0.2586092353,
0.6252490282,
-0.3987202942,
1.0147658587,
0.4298386872,
0.3469853401,
0.0164651535,
0.5871405602,
0.1841862649,
-0.4794552028,
-0.4390672445,
-0.9587225318,
0.2432255298,
-0.0058405651,
-0.1421924084,
0.7189314961,
0.2266436964,
0.5621328354,
-0.1624433994,
0.8997662067,
0.0234329067,
0.3926073909,
-0.3075542748,
0.3615269959,
-0.3117551804,
0.1752046943,
-0.1644120514,
-0.8742342591,
-0.4485972822,
0.9120455384,
-0.8148739338,
-0.217410937,
0.4261212051,
0.5475034118,
-0.0752809197,
0.1416543424,
0.3496248424,
-0.3928199112,
0.1831537783,
0.3883832693,
0.9894413948,
-0.2490472198,
0.4632066488,
-0.5629150271,
-0.2636854351,
-0.1526388377,
-0.9095683694,
-0.5577941537,
-0.2599590719,
-0.236966297,
-0.0360463746,
0.2009205669,
0.8434023261,
0.6366950274,
-0.7472227216,
-0.4523301423,
-0.16074422,
0.3398177624,
-0.1840933561,
-0.3009067178,
0.3047332764,
-0.3707966506,
-0.5386262536,
0.1210692152,
0.2815324962,
0.0033747745,
-0.2497000545,
0.0986885205,
0.0923566371,
0.1775365174,
0.6192139983,
-0.0523476079,
-0.9291960001,
-0.4631624222,
-0.0142610949,
-0.1994471103,
-0.4817554951,
0.3773415685,
-0.5253636241,
0.3229531944,
0.8890765905,
0.3612277508,
-0.030939525,
0.2412088662,
0.825795114,
-0.456816107,
0.2731787264,
0.3008486927,
0.3950030804,
0.2001258135,
0.05110652,
0.7812743783,
0.1644456834,
-0.4286129773,
-1.1661417484,
0.1772613227,
-0.5653610826,
-0.4368038177,
1.2488222122,
-0.2278435528,
-0.1662126929,
-0.2713846564,
0.1085452288,
-0.035601303,
0.0868669376,
0.1706300378,
0.9016333818,
-0.2391773909,
-0.3151301742,
-1.0470502377,
0.4558398724,
0.457028091,
-0.7980980277,
0.1653202176,
0.2351982594,
0.4851670861,
-0.0257590022,
0.7844503522,
0.1654135287,
0.213073343,
0.105902262,
0.1531330794,
0.6558372378,
-0.0981092975,
-0.2212038189,
0.2216959447,
0.233090803,
0.1110867113
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12824v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12824v1 | From RAGs to rich parameters: Probing how language models utilize external knowledge over parametric information for factual queries | 2024-06-18T17:46:08 | 2024-06-18T17:46:08 | Hitesh Wadhwa, Rahul Seetharaman, Somyaa Aggarwal, Reshmi Ghosh, Samyadeep Basu, Soundararajan Srinivasan, Wenlong Zhao, Shreyas Chaudhari, Ehsan Aghazadeh | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Retrieval Augmented Generation (RAG) enriches the ability of language models
to reason using external context to augment responses for a given user prompt.
This approach has risen in popularity due to practical applications in various
applications of language models in search, question/answering, and chat-bots.
However, the exact nature of how this approach works isn't clearly understood.
In this paper, we mechanistically examine the RAG pipeline to highlight that
language models take shortcut and have a strong bias towards utilizing only the
context information to answer the question, while relying minimally on their
parametric memory. We probe this mechanistic behavior in language models with:
(i) Causal Mediation Analysis to show that the parametric memory is minimally
utilized when answering a question and (ii) Attention Contributions and
Knockouts to show that the last token residual stream do not get enriched from
the subject token in the question, but gets enriched from other informative
tokens in the context. We find this pronounced shortcut behaviour true across
both LLaMa and Phi family of models. | [
-0.4662450254,
-0.963978529,
0.7728066444,
-0.1255215257,
-0.1963133961,
-0.2015936375,
-0.060631223,
-0.2520051599,
0.1724565476,
0.7700517774,
-0.4264701605,
0.1323728412,
-0.5846115351,
-0.0267072357,
-0.4087224007,
1.3168268204,
0.1395659894,
-0.0917904973,
-0.2889223993,
-0.4321312606,
-0.2266313732,
-0.4945662618,
-0.5890141129,
0.057119675,
0.8779460192,
0.4121420383,
0.9657126069,
0.7655836344,
0.250318706,
0.3399913311,
-0.1742601097,
0.0446983911,
-0.6880215406,
0.4824625254,
-0.4083372951,
-0.6213773489,
0.0201743469,
-0.0007218628,
0.5014119744,
0.8487710953,
0.3071553111,
0.6889948249,
0.3053877354,
0.583548665,
-0.963945806,
-0.2095924467,
-0.8336963654,
-0.6204984784,
-0.4150361121,
-0.5577312708,
-0.2811400592,
0.0061285715,
0.0801688433,
-0.1184135154,
0.4478991032,
-0.0045397864,
0.9008948207,
0.3667346537,
-0.5908398032,
-0.5989566445,
-0.8357340097,
0.8393322229,
-0.5002709031,
0.4332042038,
0.6653111577,
0.4337424934,
0.1113655791,
-0.7172788382,
-0.2884300351,
-0.3750810325,
-0.2656849325,
-0.2881750166,
0.0513236038,
-0.0056083836,
0.3376325667,
0.1752151698,
-0.3631372154,
-0.2989095449,
-0.6042426825,
-0.1342851073,
0.3540899158,
0.32361871,
0.2199097127,
-0.3933098316,
-0.2450291067,
0.0176545028,
-0.7210236192,
0.2728683054,
0.4497616589,
0.3464011848,
-0.060229525,
0.9459103346,
-0.1415487975,
1.0164461136,
-0.0943168476,
-0.2791514397,
-0.475892216,
-0.3947707415,
-0.0896103308,
-0.2869556248,
0.5029707551,
-0.157738626,
0.0308163259,
-0.2135462761,
-0.2156323195,
-0.3939039111,
0.1035781205,
-0.7529938817,
0.0082213217,
0.0816642046,
-0.436612159,
-0.1440462768,
-0.2085103542,
-0.7276720405,
-0.27641204,
-0.4124177694,
0.4597791135,
-0.0591011457,
-0.0138358045,
-0.1822792143,
-0.359501183,
0.2745251656,
0.0181313325,
-0.6839161515,
0.2654263079,
0.7020737529,
0.550370276,
0.148802653,
-0.1912826747,
-0.8448251486,
0.4129399955,
-0.2881960869,
0.8184064627,
-0.838067472,
-0.1989857852,
-0.2447543591,
-0.1561692506,
0.0066111847,
-0.405624032,
0.5411102772,
-0.8353715539,
0.2860336304,
-0.8461233377,
-0.3457250297,
-0.2628026307,
-0.0065144566,
-0.7032176256,
0.8503056169,
0.1080264598,
-1.0205792189,
0.3532202542,
-0.184497267,
-0.1115381718,
-0.2515543103,
-0.1463255733,
-0.0732055008,
0.3812307417,
0.0453495905,
0.3135076463,
-0.8734056354,
0.4710557759,
-0.5566542149,
-0.3253116012,
0.3953539431,
-0.6090385318,
0.7683727741,
0.3264830709,
-0.1842828244,
-0.1518983692,
-0.8043983579,
-0.2524760962,
0.2325633764,
-0.3208731115,
-0.7321823239,
0.0131788105,
-0.1376016736,
0.3391425014,
0.1756231189,
-0.2346430868,
-0.0803531483,
-0.4029958844,
0.1930132508,
0.5647059083,
0.3238131702,
0.5757977366,
-0.3377251625,
0.3220421672,
-0.1726565361,
0.0110248532,
-0.091455169,
-0.4404532909,
-0.983166635,
-0.1437805295,
0.2744992673,
0.1681843102,
-0.624715209,
-0.1847239286,
-0.1260496378,
-0.360016644,
-0.59783566,
0.3043285608,
0.3247646987,
0.9361393452,
0.1711202115,
0.1908180565,
-0.3440062404,
-1.0545555353,
-0.6810395122,
-0.3251105845,
-0.1033869684,
0.6373056173,
0.2496407181,
-0.0619024709,
0.9883684516,
-0.323651731,
0.1653458774,
-0.4305247366,
0.1636931598,
0.1399771422,
0.1474727839,
0.6204506755,
-0.7347142696,
-0.4669404924,
-0.4627644718,
-0.4046031535,
-0.223932758,
-0.0888590068,
-0.3112046123,
0.0063506346,
0.4314635396,
-0.6141009927,
0.4141475558,
0.4198976755,
-0.4111314714,
0.3539043963,
-0.01814829,
0.0577597097,
-0.8962589502,
0.3574108183,
-0.2000201046,
-0.0675493702,
-0.540035069,
0.2146155238,
-0.0133299595,
-0.2895994484,
-0.3313572407,
0.9563422203,
-0.5689284205,
-0.3657617569,
-0.4971452653,
0.0614886731,
0.2453966588,
0.6105056405,
-0.2267529517,
0.9162378311,
0.335378617,
-0.9608867764,
-0.0320481583,
-0.075780198,
-0.0011165764,
0.1358844489,
-0.7457112074,
0.1703673303,
-0.4095441699,
-0.0627259165,
-1.0987246037,
-0.2757120132,
0.0808701888,
-0.4137271345,
0.4273721278,
-0.2649245262,
-0.5424278975,
0.0758052543,
-0.245501712,
0.6530737281,
0.5026257634,
-0.3440857828,
0.5666460395,
0.4948679805,
-0.175147593,
-0.4239778519,
-0.4241178632,
-0.0831263885,
-0.4309589267,
-0.6261299849,
-0.0301760305,
0.0656242147,
-0.5391817093,
0.0639480948,
-0.0660310239,
-0.2458400875,
0.0133417938,
-0.1702570617,
0.0952562764,
-0.3378359973,
0.0706892833,
0.1106900796,
-0.0469453149,
0.0117225265,
0.3496511877,
0.5259839296,
0.1134392396,
-0.3670795858,
0.0074117701,
0.5201308131,
0.5839765668,
-0.3210778832,
0.8867032528,
0.318665266,
-0.0412791483,
-0.0201162342,
-0.7248362899,
-0.441439271,
-0.5199186802,
0.209848538,
-0.4905394018,
-0.7725714445,
0.6931926608,
0.0894772783,
-0.1544748843,
0.4466176927,
0.6217707992,
0.0567789152,
1.0725476742,
0.4470913112,
0.081752941,
0.1662973613,
-0.1140276715,
0.239284113,
-1.0168318748,
0.0704116672,
-0.8091585636,
-0.3261674643,
-0.6920037866,
-0.5955674648,
0.5747097135,
0.3744213581,
-0.3383130729,
0.1576414406,
-0.1625858247,
0.4139997363,
0.5618246198,
-0.0293939132,
-0.0367308632,
-0.3301941156,
-0.0003075249,
-0.1444643736,
-0.7701319456,
-0.3291309178,
1.0179089308,
0.2948006094,
0.8387237191,
-0.0549568199,
0.549865067,
-0.2864157856,
0.183030054,
-0.5411866307,
0.5602163076,
0.2737563848,
-0.939678669,
-0.3038365245,
-0.2482755929,
-0.891245544,
0.2145370692,
0.1364820153,
-0.5560989976,
0.3803918064,
0.1331884265,
-0.2248807698,
0.2287076712,
-0.4874283075,
0.586564064,
-0.3739565015,
-0.8851068616,
-0.1002573445,
-0.7366637588,
0.5519765615,
-0.039483048,
0.2109958678,
-0.0351817943,
-0.3401077986,
0.7053536177,
-0.3726888001,
0.7456361055,
-0.1857940704,
0.1196465343,
0.5751203299,
0.4099849463,
0.7675964832,
0.1258777678,
-0.0586878434,
-0.198275134,
-0.173148334,
-0.5336783528,
-0.7949229479,
0.616533041,
-0.4800745547,
-0.9351247549,
-0.1880595237,
-0.6735858917,
-0.565042913,
-0.0342772864,
0.1876347661,
0.5483451486,
0.2717256844,
0.3972004354,
0.5573229194,
-0.4282101989,
0.3064087331,
0.5243219733,
0.0312509127,
-0.0660724193,
0.7670226097,
0.2506555617,
0.367865324,
0.4082501829,
0.5174457431,
-0.3132311404,
-0.2300388813,
-0.3520978987,
0.66261518,
-0.892808497,
-0.1571260989,
-0.7595775723,
-0.110694252,
-0.3891675472,
-0.0000992533,
-0.3967900872,
-0.4393565059,
-0.2594968379,
0.011714139,
0.2852362096,
0.5213472247,
0.0280974023,
0.0349081494,
-0.9042851925,
0.4889377654,
0.5459045172,
0.0893447772,
0.1214218587,
-0.7027078867,
-0.2033930123,
0.1315985471,
-0.2176236361,
-1.2453868389,
0.2905972302,
0.2012442648,
0.6482023001,
0.4397977293,
0.1431831121,
0.8919507265,
-0.5864388347,
0.8054769635,
-0.4208973348,
-0.6656151414,
0.4390398264,
-0.4507513344,
0.1369743496,
0.6522649527,
0.4203339219,
-0.2932704985,
-0.5961145759,
-0.6564374566,
-0.7945387363,
0.4828028381,
-0.0948802084,
0.4348369241,
-0.0879602358,
0.4419565201,
0.1978114843,
0.1916868389,
-0.564068079,
-0.2517442703,
0.2111919671,
0.0767182484,
-0.018170068,
-0.832504034,
-0.1360619217,
-0.1453842521,
0.4381764531,
-0.0435566939,
0.264074266,
0.0207157042,
-0.0882972106,
-0.098390922,
0.1529721469,
0.6862823963,
0.7765496969,
0.0295294989,
0.1461107284,
-0.029674761,
-0.0305133425,
-0.0837970376,
-0.1866665035,
-0.2382016033,
0.1690217704,
0.422029227,
0.8409221768,
0.5429067612,
-0.6369842291,
0.4137063026,
0.0844965577,
0.2368444204,
0.1877990812,
-0.0298016183,
0.0313187614,
0.2865656316,
0.2866421938,
0.0429687984,
0.5958455801,
-0.5600414276,
0.2276746035,
0.7342391014,
-0.213015452,
-0.4437123239,
0.7759645581,
-0.1089185178,
-0.1893385202,
0.229317084,
0.0452774502,
-0.3901735842,
0.2430548221,
0.4262317121,
0.8996061683,
-0.0664939359,
0.19785963,
0.3168741465,
0.1301934123,
0.3172107935,
-0.016949553,
-0.499255985,
-0.2989248633,
-0.5008265972,
-0.8239710927,
-0.1465645283,
0.3128428161,
-0.5719586015,
0.3749124408,
-0.1015821993,
0.0956154019,
-0.1406991184,
-0.1809505224,
-0.7993478179,
0.1922673136,
-0.2416004241,
0.6164890528,
-0.7535361052,
0.7554649711,
0.2876493633,
-0.5751654506,
-1.0196969509,
0.3287364542,
-0.2149347961,
-1.0055445433,
0.9471262693,
-0.1602725536,
0.0741454512,
-0.2241130173,
-0.5414370894,
-1.3102325201,
0.6071109176,
0.6353132725,
-0.0130192488,
-0.3504759073,
0.2533757985,
0.4469784796,
0.0775332302,
0.151033625,
0.4941342175,
0.2519390881,
0.303162396,
-0.8020734191,
0.0250194091,
-0.1000835523,
0.0906355381,
0.2113741934,
-0.5565423965,
1.0708481073,
-0.1301758885,
-0.1120399237,
-0.0176050719,
0.591021359,
0.4756372571,
0.3299554586,
0.2364061475,
0.3521355093,
0.2676345408,
0.2099848241,
1.3224766254,
-0.5933158398,
0.1648991704,
0.9961924553,
-0.104355745,
0.7082585096,
0.8335918784,
0.067665115,
0.2393354028,
0.5733594298,
0.6053189635,
0.8012919426,
-0.0466537066,
-0.1455435306,
-0.0328951031,
-0.1550464779,
-0.1378823966,
0.5225067139,
0.2969279289,
-0.4239492416,
-0.5109723806,
0.1066861749,
0.149585247,
-0.0386866815,
-0.2481571138,
0.9564634562,
-0.0076617585,
-0.9858456254,
0.6827169061,
0.094691135,
0.2370114475,
-0.5955219269,
-0.0360390954,
-0.3257730305,
-0.1438647658,
0.2090981156,
-0.4875979125,
0.6655665636,
0.103546001,
-0.1333283633,
-0.084174566,
0.9749576449,
-0.360797286,
-0.3891811967,
0.2126171887,
0.6418634057,
0.0800690055,
0.0329020433,
-0.6967863441,
0.1205700785,
-0.1525724083,
-0.5912883878,
0.5092427135,
0.8242645264,
-0.002114269,
0.510990262,
0.5855052471,
0.2928852737,
0.3620124757,
-0.1616357416,
0.9489404559,
-0.4376374483,
-0.4542039633,
-0.8415362835,
0.6789079905,
0.0831567124,
-0.1416936666,
1.0132646561,
0.4778440893,
0.5592666864,
-0.0077025518,
0.4716100991,
0.1712377816,
0.8675993085,
-0.52018255,
0.559089601,
-0.7166885138,
0.3259029686,
-0.2214533091,
-0.9496892095,
0.1421282738,
0.1617577821,
-0.4568033814,
0.2427050173,
0.5275398493,
0.8173748851,
-0.167152971,
-0.3849216998,
0.4145379961,
-0.0640064552,
0.240350157,
0.1737165302,
0.6637499928,
-0.2856287658,
0.5075843334,
-0.2706586719,
-0.0439101197,
-0.2278550863,
-0.5666081905,
-0.8329139948,
-0.8144698739,
0.1754947156,
-0.3567681909,
-0.107000418,
0.4603092074,
0.4719160795,
-0.5096224546,
-0.3024907708,
-0.1906741858,
0.1582630277,
0.2816914022,
-0.2602398098,
0.3628326952,
-0.7441350818,
-0.6707932949,
0.2273972332,
0.3785864711,
-0.1750538498,
-0.4145597219,
0.0454044044,
-0.2335269898,
0.5822538137,
0.301813066,
0.2891345024,
-0.7131811976,
-0.2516053915,
0.2244063318,
-0.188048318,
-0.1720689088,
1.1233130693,
-0.7722561359,
0.3631652296,
0.8865568042,
0.9822685719,
0.3964121342,
0.0413522013,
0.5882551074,
-0.8989325166,
0.4948102832,
0.4162100255,
0.2761594653,
0.3036049008,
-0.404753238,
0.181491375,
0.1482899785,
-0.7151198387,
-1.049164176,
0.2964219153,
-0.4748624563,
-0.5127577782,
1.3015736341,
0.3149569333,
-0.4646005034,
-0.0619093776,
-0.2007261217,
0.2210640162,
0.0539345257,
0.6108497977,
0.652526319,
-0.2671940029,
-0.2782945335,
-0.8708729744,
0.8752378821,
0.3941193819,
-0.4280196726,
0.0669139698,
0.5502111316,
0.247636959,
0.1429784596,
0.688370049,
-0.0323913991,
0.1506476253,
-0.0295110587,
-0.702701211,
0.2080832273,
-0.4633414745,
-0.0476500206,
0.394911319,
0.2155103236,
-0.025012264
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12822v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12822v1 | Is It Good Data for Multilingual Instruction Tuning or Just Bad Multilingual Evaluation for Large Language Models? | 2024-06-18T17:43:47 | 2024-06-18T17:43:47 | Pinzhen Chen, Simon Yu, Zhicheng Guo, Barry Haddow | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large language models, particularly multilingual ones, are designed, claimed,
and expected to cater to native speakers of varied languages. We hypothesise
that the current practices of fine-tuning and evaluating these models may
mismatch this intention owing to a heavy reliance on translation, which can
introduce translation artefacts and defects. It remains unknown whether the
nature of the instruction data has an impact on the model output; on the other
hand, it remains questionable whether translated test sets can capture such
nuances. Due to the often coupled practices of using translated data in both
stages, such imperfections could have been overlooked. This work investigates
these issues by using controlled native or translated data during instruction
tuning and evaluation stages and observing model results. Experiments on eight
base models and eight different benchmarks reveal that native or generation
benchmarks display a notable difference between native and translated
instruction data especially when model performance is high, whereas other types
of test sets cannot. Finally, we demonstrate that regularization is beneficial
to bridging this gap on structured but not generative tasks. | [
-0.3027856052,
-0.7194345593,
0.0702209324,
0.2524472773,
-0.2635110617,
-0.0925595835,
-0.7467886209,
-0.5149406195,
-0.2557646334,
0.4096815586,
-0.3536449969,
-0.5687388778,
-0.4303764999,
0.0925701037,
-0.2384689897,
1.2590044737,
-0.1829913259,
0.3329354525,
-0.1628143787,
-0.2363964319,
-0.8280084133,
-0.5752815008,
-0.5642856956,
-0.253074944,
0.2902831435,
0.5733651519,
0.8051353693,
0.8452159166,
0.3526987135,
0.2649396062,
0.0953933597,
0.5758322477,
-0.6776840091,
-0.0219437126,
-0.1124924198,
-0.5512498617,
-0.3775925934,
0.2320765406,
0.8608871698,
0.8847970366,
-0.1710264534,
0.2238476425,
0.2841568589,
0.4740472734,
-0.6590951681,
0.4229797721,
-0.3361649513,
-0.0495604165,
-0.3258895278,
-0.0573813021,
-0.6034809351,
-0.4419489205,
-0.1470160484,
-0.4637132287,
0.3940201998,
-0.1049472615,
0.7737554312,
0.2126542181,
-0.5186742544,
-0.2600157857,
-0.8741668463,
1.1838984489,
-0.8915980458,
0.5664823055,
0.5687022209,
0.3029810786,
-0.0456176251,
-0.101552166,
-0.2099954933,
-0.2695408165,
-0.1475044042,
0.0421979763,
0.0826351494,
0.00234489,
0.2387565225,
0.5736030936,
-0.4816423655,
0.6053501964,
-0.5843181014,
-0.3870314956,
0.7428455949,
0.1572896093,
0.3272919655,
-0.0622468106,
-0.0269215778,
-0.2330972999,
-0.7515303493,
0.019824801,
0.686843276,
0.8023504019,
-0.4192804396,
0.4620681405,
-0.1512299925,
1.0941699743,
-0.3043526411,
-0.2524374425,
0.2133183926,
-0.6174317598,
0.1197894439,
0.0610312857,
0.5646014214,
0.5751507878,
0.8161356449,
-0.2874417305,
-0.4527050257,
0.1391299367,
0.0514425784,
-0.7148385048,
-0.1021975726,
-0.1800132692,
-0.2350996733,
0.1295326054,
0.1119277254,
-0.6806544065,
-0.037318185,
-0.5857823491,
0.1834393591,
-0.2362266332,
-0.089826487,
0.3286745846,
0.2918058932,
0.0713831633,
0.1208784282,
-1.0681592226,
0.2749430239,
0.6447147727,
0.537137866,
-0.2397627085,
-0.3902441561,
-0.6340691447,
-0.120158352,
-0.7364597321,
0.5076659918,
-0.7388603091,
-0.4578019381,
0.0415510461,
0.2325179577,
-0.4760864675,
-0.5649752021,
0.5723044872,
-0.4482449889,
0.2082662731,
-0.2650099099,
-0.4283118546,
-0.1188226491,
0.1152411997,
-0.6779693365,
0.8320291042,
0.0091596814,
-0.3514097929,
0.4809706211,
-0.3462530673,
-0.7532108426,
-0.2576743364,
0.0059751566,
-0.2813722193,
0.1817250699,
0.2113410383,
0.4367015362,
-0.254448086,
0.2024240047,
0.0119093396,
-0.7307451963,
-0.0054587168,
-0.6359276175,
0.4241313338,
0.2490808815,
-0.2596382201,
-0.1097531766,
-0.8044821024,
0.151158914,
-0.0961229727,
-0.5960213542,
-0.5219856501,
0.1421947032,
-0.0101767089,
0.1769229621,
0.1926015317,
-0.5464524031,
0.305482924,
-0.4882997274,
0.2230564058,
0.6460550427,
-0.0216550138,
0.3715108037,
-0.1541457772,
0.5585272312,
0.0374297835,
0.192681551,
-0.393494904,
-0.5508975983,
-0.8030683994,
0.204124853,
0.5907363296,
0.4411773682,
-0.6024039388,
-0.019999465,
-0.2759082615,
-0.3399533629,
-0.8032343984,
0.3931334317,
0.7752800584,
0.3373587728,
0.4184650481,
-0.177999258,
-0.1233755276,
-1.0392656326,
-0.1498111039,
0.2703022063,
0.0544113815,
0.2574411929,
0.3182428479,
-0.028927438,
0.2201244831,
-0.1856268793,
-0.0996466652,
-0.0828318447,
0.1531088054,
0.1707964689,
0.7973669171,
0.5354719758,
-0.5851441622,
-0.5731633902,
0.4415962994,
-0.5443408489,
0.1101669297,
-0.2420427203,
-0.0780376568,
0.3830610514,
0.3296065629,
-0.2863411605,
0.1833944023,
0.7444982529,
-0.1008023992,
0.5707114935,
-0.5221794844,
0.5759617686,
-0.8948144913,
-0.0681013688,
0.0477110222,
-0.0151838297,
-0.5988985896,
0.2466271073,
0.4503398538,
-0.103506662,
-0.2885188758,
0.4133102894,
-0.5237883329,
0.0456179976,
-0.1133731008,
-0.046789784,
0.1346719414,
0.2650457621,
-0.1751546711,
1.091983676,
0.3912265599,
-0.7188133597,
0.2141395956,
0.1625070125,
-0.7749038339,
0.3338110447,
-0.518801868,
0.2585285306,
-0.0701560676,
-0.2980639935,
-0.7147040963,
-0.4160812795,
-0.030173583,
-0.2760002911,
0.768420279,
-0.2537775338,
-0.7003369331,
-0.1382181495,
0.013941953,
0.3706955314,
0.28342399,
-0.5601540804,
0.0075933915,
-0.0281682871,
-0.0278565697,
-0.5155275464,
-0.7577702403,
-0.1120355055,
-0.1470741481,
-0.5586855412,
0.2258848548,
-0.0328893177,
-0.1984103024,
-0.2229212672,
-0.0992163494,
-0.0826583132,
0.1908255666,
-0.1820032895,
0.2488247752,
-0.616877377,
0.2690494061,
0.1916114241,
-0.0008995691,
-0.0573863685,
0.0060343635,
0.3541805148,
0.0512143485,
-0.4877007902,
-0.4161894619,
0.4305756092,
0.6448604465,
-0.7277616858,
0.7662702799,
0.4230390489,
-0.3757066131,
-0.2887376249,
-0.5470677018,
-0.0635634661,
-0.4297088087,
0.4943117201,
-0.4084848762,
-0.4951158762,
0.5170042515,
0.1710656881,
0.1793860942,
0.3124269545,
0.3771932125,
0.0936501473,
1.4172008038,
0.6172972918,
-0.1606695354,
0.3395471275,
-0.1819926053,
0.1627559811,
-0.6659224033,
-0.112424396,
-0.7483054996,
-0.3881851137,
-0.7671605349,
-0.3374113739,
0.2009402514,
0.2491988838,
0.0251018088,
0.1482314616,
-0.2683930993,
0.7318385243,
0.3347725272,
-0.096519202,
0.224365592,
0.0500550307,
-0.0841102526,
-0.370927006,
-0.8154323697,
-0.597502172,
1.0931457281,
0.0886032581,
1.0182968378,
0.0281797051,
0.3811121285,
-0.074524723,
0.3193977773,
-0.7819789052,
-0.0207330063,
-0.491904676,
-0.6305257678,
-0.1252160668,
-0.6362684965,
-1.1685433388,
0.1638544798,
-0.1061253771,
-0.6791547537,
0.1879020482,
0.2481752634,
-0.2617316246,
0.1507535875,
-1.2000818253,
1.2255483866,
-0.5077878237,
-0.4175939262,
-0.276679635,
-0.36456424,
0.4279675484,
-0.1647805423,
0.4055935442,
0.1264165491,
0.3168706596,
0.6947795153,
0.0067070345,
0.7425316572,
-0.1856821328,
-0.2776111066,
0.0262436867,
0.1112465784,
0.3167870045,
-0.0772044957,
-0.4236046672,
-0.0132381283,
0.1192630753,
-0.6152954698,
-0.6925900578,
0.8799695373,
-0.7242894173,
-0.5221582651,
0.0408828333,
-0.7335071564,
-0.5106559396,
0.2714386582,
0.1727196723,
0.6310561895,
-0.0161211286,
0.3068712354,
0.6759781837,
-0.4962838888,
0.1244086623,
0.6479830742,
0.0821038038,
0.1474432647,
1.4351820946,
0.3551728427,
0.6327192783,
0.138163805,
0.2291878313,
-0.1314321607,
-0.5919634104,
-0.9317451119,
0.2876051366,
-0.6916905046,
-0.1079834253,
0.1095694304,
0.0888134241,
-0.302126497,
0.1559496075,
-0.6594557762,
-0.0966815352,
-0.3169083297,
-0.1044043824,
-0.0344763175,
0.8310825229,
0.1451104581,
0.1816150248,
-0.9570467472,
0.0914309472,
-0.029922612,
0.5702779889,
0.0117420303,
-0.4924797118,
-0.7952602506,
0.4011695385,
-0.1717223376,
-0.6167799234,
0.1448683888,
0.4895621836,
0.7767577767,
0.4381281734,
-0.2179529518,
0.7565696239,
-0.5856482387,
0.6872696877,
-0.3534796834,
-0.706756711,
0.4923089445,
-0.2756756246,
0.5470132828,
0.5496092439,
0.5563796759,
-0.6621181369,
-0.3010298014,
-0.1148208231,
-0.5072855353,
0.8742668629,
-0.2085803747,
0.5104504824,
-0.0688772723,
0.3723622262,
0.3430487216,
0.1523065269,
-0.3642812371,
-0.2948216498,
-0.0796792358,
0.0084304223,
-0.576354146,
-0.1421636492,
0.0449023806,
-0.1472374499,
0.4089733958,
-0.1045673713,
-0.1493788511,
-0.3541141748,
-0.3069521785,
-0.2479565591,
0.369615525,
0.6897238493,
0.81769979,
0.0359183401,
-0.159317866,
0.0005542947,
-0.2628819942,
-0.0702036396,
0.015768569,
-0.2209925503,
-0.0144105647,
0.5179765224,
0.8085100055,
0.5633358955,
-0.5105583072,
0.3091111779,
0.0496477894,
0.1231507882,
0.3473729491,
0.2108777314,
-0.0270132422,
-0.1827432066,
-0.0371938534,
0.0529475808,
0.0101689296,
-0.6405389309,
-0.0184221659,
0.2423323989,
-0.2637360692,
-0.579444766,
0.4798454642,
0.1570606679,
-0.2200779766,
1.0317276716,
-0.1480178833,
-0.4623644054,
0.5906852484,
0.6706908345,
0.1911928356,
-0.6531561613,
0.1129634902,
0.5958095193,
0.6761626601,
-0.0973005518,
0.2248542756,
-0.0167250987,
-0.6855316758,
-0.7770811915,
-0.5819797516,
-0.1870996654,
0.173423931,
-1.0045953989,
0.2865660787,
-0.0592711791,
0.1479981691,
-0.0724328458,
-0.1698594391,
-0.7152074575,
0.3610648811,
0.2441983223,
0.7908141017,
-1.1635354757,
0.8341552019,
0.5811416507,
-0.2598000765,
-0.7990735769,
-0.2265915871,
-0.3217751086,
-0.5480536819,
0.5015557408,
0.1521105021,
0.108390227,
-0.1926504672,
-0.191146791,
-0.7858717442,
0.2826479971,
0.5909174085,
-0.608091414,
0.0356062613,
0.2528224289,
0.6372588277,
-0.0567036159,
-0.0014669711,
0.766274333,
0.7294518352,
-0.3128371239,
-1.1184067726,
-0.2939372361,
-0.3573759496,
-0.1546977013,
0.3762668371,
-0.6089808941,
1.0402590036,
-0.1101693884,
-0.3944767714,
-0.0519069508,
0.2584016919,
-0.1909101456,
0.0060239704,
0.1886926889,
0.2914387584,
0.6645438075,
-0.2799235284,
1.501655221,
-0.3605267406,
0.1399739087,
1.0921273232,
-0.059615992,
0.7068829536,
0.342862457,
-0.0570521057,
0.0822087154,
0.8892434835,
-0.0346847959,
0.3367166221,
0.2066101283,
0.1638573855,
-0.3781071007,
-0.1209279075,
-0.4797861576,
0.5561362505,
0.4199027121,
-0.1589473784,
-0.365793258,
0.1166522056,
-0.113356106,
0.3511238992,
-0.2968536019,
0.4780560434,
-0.0968001112,
-0.9056840539,
1.013679266,
0.3243559599,
0.5397520065,
-0.5942311883,
-0.2531985939,
-0.5050694346,
0.1542987525,
-0.2825404108,
-0.4148959816,
0.2969199419,
0.1511077285,
-0.2327506244,
-0.2488623708,
0.1616698951,
-0.5215683579,
-0.5981321931,
0.1311402917,
0.4449752271,
0.2676855624,
0.1799957454,
-0.5036768317,
0.2397411615,
0.0208908767,
-0.2202471942,
0.2917335331,
0.266446501,
-0.4772059917,
0.447897613,
0.4899825752,
0.2687552571,
0.2572036386,
0.4699671566,
0.5655706525,
-0.2933517098,
-0.2613916099,
-0.656688571,
0.4656604528,
0.1965598315,
-0.6424587965,
0.9819896817,
0.7791103721,
1.2992378473,
-0.0819555596,
0.3830687404,
0.4876865745,
0.4169745743,
-0.7739264369,
0.6274421811,
-0.67937392,
0.1146617606,
-0.0928525403,
-0.9761343598,
-0.2202296406,
0.5216552615,
-0.5726727247,
0.1998545676,
0.5452021956,
0.783082962,
-0.4378522933,
-0.1169294044,
0.439979434,
0.0582498796,
0.136321947,
0.4478496611,
0.761195004,
-0.5030135512,
0.3311815858,
-0.3607314527,
-0.2006052285,
0.0283579044,
-0.428499788,
-0.7969563603,
-0.3640071154,
-0.2243265659,
0.0674172416,
0.0413587913,
0.6323493123,
0.7243186831,
-1.0811212063,
-0.457588315,
0.2986283302,
0.182334736,
-0.3380185664,
-0.1544380784,
0.3395254016,
-0.6122820973,
-1.1673145294,
0.750015378,
-0.0440049022,
0.0957530662,
-0.3896085322,
-0.02504481,
-0.1141854674,
-0.1368983686,
0.4304059744,
0.154693082,
-0.541379571,
-0.2233452797,
0.1635281742,
-0.0887678936,
0.0362660699,
0.6773106456,
-0.3010055721,
0.9052703977,
0.1835858077,
0.7462846041,
0.4999758601,
-0.0405788161,
0.833958149,
-0.930293262,
0.2805982232,
0.1238653511,
0.2812228799,
0.6161532998,
-0.3007360101,
0.2759311795,
-0.170198366,
-0.4163763225,
-0.9933848381,
0.1361963749,
-0.3305133283,
-0.1400424689,
0.9893584847,
-0.3125386238,
-0.1388570815,
0.165278405,
-0.0492776819,
0.2672380507,
-0.0309834871,
0.83199054,
0.9766256809,
0.1448727846,
0.1735768765,
-1.1287132502,
0.3906984329,
0.5115321279,
-0.5545164943,
0.1151747331,
0.6175946593,
0.154111132,
0.1320112348,
-0.0665212646,
-0.1523342282,
0.5373030305,
-0.0873128846,
-0.0995615125,
-0.0582368299,
-0.3923922181,
-0.4591835141,
-0.2984178364,
0.2945563197,
-0.2442428023
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12814v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12814v1 | Adversarial Attacks on Multimodal Agents | 2024-06-18T17:32:48 | 2024-06-18T17:32:48 | Chen Henry Wu, Jing Yu Koh, Ruslan Salakhutdinov, Daniel Fried, Aditi Raghunathan | cs.LG | cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.CV | Vision-enabled language models (VLMs) are now used to build autonomous
multimodal agents capable of taking actions in real environments. In this
paper, we show that multimodal agents raise new safety risks, even though
attacking agents is more challenging than prior attacks due to limited access
to and knowledge about the environment. Our attacks use adversarial text
strings to guide gradient-based perturbation over one trigger image in the
environment: (1) our captioner attack attacks white-box captioners if they are
used to process images into captions as additional inputs to the VLM; (2) our
CLIP attack attacks a set of CLIP models jointly, which can transfer to
proprietary VLMs. To evaluate the attacks, we curated VisualWebArena-Adv, a set
of adversarial tasks based on VisualWebArena, an environment for web-based
multimodal agent tasks. Within an L-infinity norm of $16/256$ on a single
image, the captioner attack can make a captioner-augmented GPT-4V agent execute
the adversarial goals with a 75% success rate. When we remove the captioner or
use GPT-4V to generate its own captions, the CLIP attack can achieve success
rates of 21% and 43%, respectively. Experiments on agents based on other VLMs,
such as Gemini-1.5, Claude-3, and GPT-4o, show interesting differences in their
robustness. Further analysis reveals several key factors contributing to the
attack's success, and we also discuss the implications for defenses as well.
Project page: https://chenwu.io/attack-agent Code and data:
https://github.com/ChenWu98/agent-attack | [
-0.5641281009,
-0.8847674131,
0.1799155474,
-0.0650162324,
-0.1063222662,
0.2168707401,
0.1370333433,
-0.4260867536,
-0.0618007518,
0.7831940055,
-0.4007405937,
-0.0983343422,
-0.7871780396,
-0.058364369,
-0.5540648699,
1.0394991636,
0.1564160734,
0.0898517519,
-0.1177503914,
-0.3567170501,
-0.511063695,
-0.815920651,
-0.4066514969,
0.36601758,
0.7140962481,
-0.2941709161,
1.0653104782,
0.4537302256,
0.6823297739,
0.4256674349,
0.1391626447,
0.0639518499,
-0.3724140525,
0.2385431379,
0.0981642529,
-0.4386302829,
-0.3341559768,
0.0519765764,
0.3086372316,
-0.0188025106,
0.0763266981,
-0.175188154,
-0.1948426664,
0.4134033024,
-0.6784318686,
-0.0589511469,
-0.8614640236,
0.1185868531,
-0.3001197875,
-0.2005815953,
-0.3642841578,
-0.0335939638,
-0.0092417402,
-0.5295155644,
0.2868447602,
0.0541605577,
1.1339967251,
0.4980819225,
-0.5619336367,
-0.3050002456,
-0.3969190717,
0.5554429889,
-0.3491863906,
-0.0258193277,
0.0039673848,
0.4547822475,
-0.1962256432,
-0.7154182792,
-0.697956264,
-0.2722600102,
0.0243822876,
0.153908968,
-0.5999470353,
0.0848777518,
0.3750414848,
-0.0730602518,
-0.4241039753,
-0.0205080267,
-0.5458084345,
-0.3394846618,
0.4441705346,
0.1441149861,
0.5822505355,
-0.1866066903,
-0.9444873929,
-0.3535425067,
-0.6523171067,
0.1230978295,
0.5164952874,
0.0875553861,
-0.0173383001,
0.5522899628,
0.1303583235,
0.67776829,
-0.1753837764,
-0.0559882224,
-0.1079613566,
-0.4966206849,
-0.1284387708,
-0.2379684597,
1.0121990442,
0.5711237192,
0.4235343933,
-0.059624508,
-0.3210002482,
0.1837597191,
0.7657650709,
-0.5712398291,
-0.3202317953,
0.0561100952,
-0.0267547276,
-0.5456730127,
0.2472900003,
-0.9211443067,
-0.7333325744,
0.1258664429,
0.6053174734,
-0.3833737373,
0.1522549987,
-0.3223620653,
-0.3669261336,
0.3395792544,
0.3490771055,
-0.4635491073,
0.1116662323,
0.2518626451,
0.7940366268,
0.0029472751,
-0.523122251,
-0.7948791385,
0.1311786473,
-0.2734164596,
0.6562288404,
-0.1944076419,
-0.3645317554,
0.0476955883,
0.0230035949,
-0.1633805335,
-0.1694914103,
0.2166595012,
-0.8231717944,
-0.0031843539,
-0.1631720662,
0.0420637317,
-0.3879919648,
0.5620316863,
-1.1077195406,
0.257945776,
-0.1431212872,
-0.7892847061,
0.2277048975,
-0.6987937093,
-0.5592053533,
-0.0585252233,
-0.213732183,
-0.4338686466,
-0.008284566,
0.488421768,
0.3649197817,
0.0317462422,
-0.2985210121,
-0.3185849488,
-0.0946058109,
0.6566070914,
-0.7951264977,
0.8344094157,
0.1863374114,
-0.4056797922,
0.4688486755,
-0.4414986968,
-0.0751234144,
0.4305573702,
-0.1039215773,
-0.2190786153,
-0.0450539514,
0.0629465654,
0.2905116379,
0.1599867642,
-0.2992845178,
0.1897634119,
0.0617702901,
0.4899173677,
0.8855680823,
0.1859657615,
0.26072523,
-0.20041655,
0.7891431451,
-0.2292480916,
0.7127843499,
-0.2475890666,
-0.3954206109,
-0.4609520137,
-0.5368435979,
0.0646200925,
0.5787906051,
-1.4055902958,
-0.430857271,
-0.0201461427,
-0.424454838,
-0.3504889309,
0.2038589567,
0.6682349443,
0.1066433042,
0.3104450107,
-0.1524679661,
-0.2168563008,
-0.7678824067,
-0.0556766801,
0.0249859951,
0.1887063682,
0.1057837307,
0.5193363428,
-0.356528908,
0.6583120823,
-0.5328998566,
-0.3640734553,
-0.0641930029,
-0.0927936658,
-0.3427639604,
0.3072492778,
0.9659045339,
-1.2293715477,
-0.5441689491,
-0.133042112,
-0.8812336326,
0.3409844637,
-0.2108186185,
0.0053336234,
0.2341018468,
0.4587229788,
-0.836638391,
0.3855218887,
0.6212868094,
-0.133699581,
0.6058781147,
-0.2287536711,
0.1914761513,
-0.7517881393,
-0.2071435601,
-0.0804317817,
-0.2953033149,
-0.8005212545,
0.6114649773,
-0.0068398113,
-0.2071051747,
-0.886220634,
0.2454376072,
-0.4453083277,
0.0527786836,
-0.3059229851,
0.0258734114,
0.176035136,
0.6830173135,
-0.3393459618,
0.8306918144,
0.6956307888,
-0.419228673,
0.6856818795,
0.1787301749,
-0.0785655156,
0.587435782,
-0.6985300779,
0.2007252872,
-0.0938931257,
0.1417823434,
-0.8136782646,
-0.1623623818,
0.4068030119,
-0.5898347497,
0.4401735067,
0.0362486281,
-0.423368305,
-0.2016293555,
-0.7640997767,
0.055259984,
0.1437169611,
-0.5071768165,
0.6121385098,
0.404648602,
-0.014772838,
-0.9617587328,
-0.5568771362,
0.5638628602,
-0.3217883408,
-0.5602906942,
-0.0485031754,
-0.0721293837,
-0.2589395046,
0.0946748704,
0.0279801246,
-0.1192698926,
0.4160192609,
0.4341960549,
0.3399460018,
0.1260366738,
-0.2942211926,
-0.4534802139,
0.0345085599,
0.1600820124,
-0.0886411667,
0.4374256432,
-0.3555583358,
-0.532526195,
-0.1630624235,
0.4718774557,
1.1253675222,
-0.5520418286,
0.7013061643,
0.9025489092,
-0.1942447722,
0.0376879647,
-0.3487206101,
-0.1412903219,
-0.4744884074,
0.6328550577,
-0.3761074543,
-0.6169556379,
0.4269316792,
0.5265780687,
0.0420626849,
0.3436006308,
0.3575075269,
-0.1666375101,
1.1667830944,
0.4287060499,
-0.0943795741,
0.6439779401,
-0.3817260563,
-0.0985764861,
-0.7319331169,
-0.1896975785,
-0.152963981,
0.1093477458,
-0.546346128,
-0.416105926,
0.5251258016,
-0.244530648,
-0.0120525667,
0.4343541563,
-0.2608372271,
0.1707320511,
0.6373400688,
-0.0725266486,
-0.0771203116,
-0.0162921194,
0.0797567666,
0.1854757816,
-0.7475522757,
-0.4137055576,
1.0997642279,
0.4035176039,
1.0322067738,
0.4823805988,
0.1287491918,
0.8104496598,
0.2233548462,
-0.4214513004,
0.4606925845,
-0.0690735579,
-0.6764809489,
-0.3327020705,
-0.1432874948,
-0.9684238434,
0.783334434,
-0.3348502219,
-0.4637466967,
-0.0732111186,
0.1539342999,
-0.2675015628,
0.3103533387,
-0.7623762488,
0.9935141802,
-0.6519064307,
-0.4645685256,
0.051721964,
-0.8437077403,
0.3965411484,
-0.1386270672,
0.2893106639,
0.1015403047,
0.0098566879,
0.354867816,
-0.3659250736,
0.9875461459,
-0.2386877537,
0.0612622127,
0.4035113752,
0.0055699446,
0.7119569778,
-0.0437366888,
0.4907287955,
0.0668388754,
-0.0346587636,
-0.5692615509,
-0.6787541509,
0.4815489352,
-0.6965314746,
-0.8937295079,
-0.5680167079,
-0.4784998596,
0.083394371,
0.0703614727,
0.3592474759,
0.7187479734,
-0.0539702922,
0.1600003392,
0.6000384092,
-0.2712971568,
0.6609725952,
0.5672693849,
0.1367178112,
-0.7453589439,
1.2223210335,
0.0568481497,
0.7618530989,
0.281288594,
-0.2303733975,
-0.3095344603,
-0.6409239173,
-0.7792583108,
-0.1542706043,
-0.9301994443,
-0.3522987962,
-0.6202273369,
-0.0571549125,
-0.4414774179,
-0.0817659944,
-0.2531330884,
0.0252248142,
-0.067952916,
0.0307489932,
0.0962654352,
0.7843111157,
0.25628528,
0.2240985781,
-0.8424758315,
0.2205505818,
0.7050632238,
-0.3061565161,
-0.156230703,
-0.0728438944,
-0.2113708109,
-0.1084434316,
-0.4868092835,
-1.1107945442,
0.4181089699,
-0.0471366532,
0.729387641,
0.4622213542,
0.0632771105,
0.4557795823,
-0.5301732421,
0.8908472061,
0.3168401718,
-0.7899652719,
0.2201600522,
-0.3210324645,
0.3211034834,
0.2454992086,
0.0805631727,
-0.1903109103,
-0.589744091,
-0.4640517235,
-0.7245365977,
0.4582904875,
0.4848616719,
0.2411270589,
0.1603360474,
-0.1367441863,
-0.182663396,
0.5093081594,
-0.9709758759,
-0.3141076863,
-0.6821008325,
0.0920551196,
0.0694416538,
-0.2894712985,
-0.4556575716,
0.254111588,
0.3163052499,
-0.2914517522,
0.1974102557,
0.2894082367,
-0.4018981159,
0.1857781857,
0.333717674,
1.1393976212,
0.3317231238,
0.0430098474,
0.3456997275,
0.1400440782,
-0.515162766,
0.094802238,
0.3406226635,
-0.173915118,
-0.2326172441,
0.8216633201,
0.8924371004,
0.037190143,
-0.8777450323,
0.8358517289,
-0.3157540262,
0.0247303676,
-0.3704262972,
-0.1167528108,
-0.3901036084,
0.3911399841,
0.4074959755,
0.4828905165,
0.0471019298,
-0.4919553399,
0.194893077,
0.8438646793,
-0.81629318,
-0.2945844233,
0.7812193036,
0.1861829609,
-0.0358868763,
0.0716641471,
-0.242745176,
-1.0597374439,
0.8374531269,
0.3532444239,
0.6620092392,
-0.1888585687,
0.1856534034,
-0.3064061701,
0.866275847,
0.2155333906,
-0.1291415244,
0.1020948589,
-0.6424556375,
-0.1343508065,
-0.2358741909,
-0.4096795619,
0.0289826449,
-0.5218805671,
-0.0816586241,
-0.5795351863,
-0.1918052584,
-0.0378385521,
-0.4775086343,
-0.467410028,
0.1721206009,
0.2215453684,
0.2833842337,
-0.5362724066,
0.6456101537,
0.8691737652,
-0.5988807678,
-0.2653557956,
0.0116921682,
0.3227816522,
-0.6295714974,
0.5325605869,
0.1352651268,
-0.2077777833,
-0.3491461277,
-0.4846076369,
-0.8511972427,
0.8999729753,
0.4159276187,
-0.2101110965,
0.1330295503,
-0.133607462,
0.4426236153,
-0.0920282826,
-0.0279147942,
0.1226628721,
0.3472152054,
-0.1392493844,
-0.6896594763,
0.1434630752,
-0.2471770793,
-0.0839978382,
0.1539233476,
-0.7743602991,
1.1711915731,
-0.3524791598,
-0.3259925246,
-0.0587916709,
0.5145825744,
-0.056941554,
0.1266933531,
0.6557111144,
0.2244812697,
0.3550826609,
0.0786168054,
1.4722611904,
-0.1344286948,
0.138624087,
0.774631381,
-0.046086207,
0.562410295,
0.4488303661,
-0.0860813931,
0.1600103825,
0.0870569348,
-0.3432637751,
0.5930459499,
0.0562212467,
-0.157539174,
-0.0199316405,
-0.0570457131,
-0.2385291308,
0.4770066738,
0.0883764997,
-0.1167838722,
0.0716788694,
0.6608890891,
0.2849267125,
0.2280308157,
-0.1627284586,
0.5380014777,
-0.1307469904,
-0.4152899384,
0.5556054115,
-0.1184120253,
0.5830366015,
-0.7754326463,
0.093571797,
0.1742117852,
0.2060769796,
0.0080720093,
-0.5486246943,
-0.0477836914,
0.0743436366,
-0.0920545384,
-0.0062681809,
0.6089072824,
-0.2937375605,
-0.288641721,
0.3125437796,
0.1949046403,
-0.1976306885,
-0.33994326,
-0.6723273396,
0.2107304484,
0.137275368,
-0.2539352775,
0.3896697164,
-0.0919737294,
-0.1359212697,
0.8079627156,
0.6044788361,
-0.0901824757,
0.4201331437,
0.013213763,
0.9387101531,
-0.5415859818,
-0.3285664022,
-1.0099523067,
0.3390778005,
-0.3361259699,
-0.0273481011,
1.0536316633,
0.2252056897,
0.6076601744,
-0.2637201548,
0.9169713855,
-0.1079658791,
-0.1312842518,
-0.7676576376,
0.8575549126,
-0.5433120728,
0.2827052772,
-0.3793891966,
-0.5022636056,
-0.1760703772,
0.0521834865,
-0.0476836897,
-0.1546375751,
0.6823608875,
0.7108732462,
0.332605809,
-0.3061938882,
0.5100450516,
0.0342974588,
0.8477914929,
0.5322629213,
1.0944017172,
-0.4154287875,
1.192035675,
-0.1501422822,
-0.021562133,
-0.0991877392,
-0.6563827395,
-1.2660001516,
-0.4589568079,
-0.2425656319,
-0.2892498672,
0.2476478666,
0.4527700245,
0.6731104255,
-0.6202136874,
0.3055071831,
0.3264352679,
0.2050590813,
-0.2880503833,
-0.2349324822,
0.3139151931,
-0.1414853334,
-0.7137429118,
0.4322474301,
0.2133827358,
0.2856287658,
-0.5813163519,
-0.0214179438,
-0.1798700094,
0.1469372511,
0.5303134918,
0.3283689618,
-1.0237624645,
-0.330449909,
-0.1820189357,
-0.3425548077,
-0.1736833006,
0.5493057966,
-0.3694218695,
0.6396582127,
0.1074344143,
0.6419629455,
0.2036056668,
0.1731561869,
0.5408869982,
-0.7042799592,
0.274350673,
-0.0194616411,
0.4431402981,
0.4796806574,
-0.3775151372,
0.2620947659,
0.4846426547,
-0.1587965339,
-0.8442316651,
0.3024967015,
-0.9634842873,
-0.5321149826,
1.0594871044,
-0.3107346594,
-0.3797297478,
0.0309280064,
-0.6167393327,
-0.1205688566,
-0.3724538684,
0.5549716353,
0.5215518475,
0.2172518969,
-0.1341438144,
-0.8258692026,
0.5419105887,
0.076291196,
-0.7133625746,
-0.226098612,
0.421990335,
0.1411102563,
0.4579017758,
0.1799843907,
-0.0490925089,
0.4733697474,
0.3848977983,
0.0901123881,
-0.6665340066,
-0.4060872495,
-0.3261488676,
0.880376637,
-0.1084480956,
-0.7024837136
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12809v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12809v1 | Can Large Language Models Always Solve Easy Problems if They Can Solve Harder Ones? | 2024-06-18T17:25:47 | 2024-06-18T17:25:47 | Zhe Yang, Yichang Zhang, Tianyu Liu, Jian Yang, Junyang Lin, Chang Zhou, Zhifang Sui | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated impressive capabilities, but
still suffer from inconsistency issues (e.g. LLMs can react differently to
disturbances like rephrasing or inconsequential order change). In addition to
these inconsistencies, we also observe that LLMs, while capable of solving hard
problems, can paradoxically fail at easier ones. To evaluate this hard-to-easy
inconsistency, we develop the ConsisEval benchmark, where each entry comprises
a pair of questions with a strict order of difficulty. Furthermore, we
introduce the concept of consistency score to quantitatively measure this
inconsistency and analyze the potential for improvement in consistency by
relative consistency score. Based on comprehensive experiments across a variety
of existing models, we find: (1) GPT-4 achieves the highest consistency score
of 92.2\% but is still inconsistent to specific questions due to distraction by
redundant information, misinterpretation of questions, etc.; (2) models with
stronger capabilities typically exhibit higher consistency, but exceptions also
exist; (3) hard data enhances consistency for both fine-tuning and in-context
learning. Our data and code will be publicly available on GitHub. | [
-0.1240049675,
-0.9583745003,
0.8666974306,
0.3753814995,
0.1726868153,
-0.0159041993,
-0.6034799218,
-0.5053851604,
-0.3734549284,
0.2218021452,
-0.381318748,
-0.3119009435,
-0.844587028,
0.2204431444,
-0.2963439226,
0.8685318232,
-0.2501243353,
-0.0580419861,
-0.1809535027,
-0.373411566,
-0.6849768162,
-0.3661260605,
-0.6607407928,
-0.4737557769,
0.3521135449,
0.4939588606,
0.8300623298,
0.8435527682,
0.8832812309,
0.3753607571,
-0.0356020629,
0.1554302424,
-0.4858628511,
0.2846059799,
-0.2926914394,
-0.3278647065,
-0.3380478024,
-0.0552328043,
0.6584847569,
1.0301487446,
-0.5361903906,
-0.0850352645,
0.4215071201,
0.6000809073,
-0.181860581,
0.3526898026,
-0.848964572,
-0.3175757229,
-0.1228346974,
0.1123959199,
-0.1826742291,
-0.4687804282,
-0.0844875351,
-0.5304145813,
0.163566947,
0.0218561906,
0.9157613516,
0.3856783509,
-0.37528795,
-0.4214786887,
-0.6692042947,
0.7414240241,
-0.5498967767,
0.3855668604,
0.2017916441,
0.2039429396,
-0.4585781395,
-0.5057781339,
-0.5020216703,
-0.4050383866,
0.2066141218,
-0.226020053,
-0.140007019,
-0.1082551181,
0.613899231,
0.2836315632,
-0.6893277168,
0.0823766515,
-0.1200137734,
-0.0769597366,
0.5439575315,
0.4713586867,
0.2219035923,
-0.0614509024,
-0.1404821128,
-0.1479329616,
-0.8387671113,
0.2028711587,
0.1636783928,
0.3346723616,
-0.1778033376,
0.5193280578,
-0.3327096105,
0.55623281,
0.0707831606,
-0.0765199065,
0.2869817317,
-0.2750405371,
-0.0500068516,
-0.2848840356,
0.6560499668,
0.0899976566,
0.4001991153,
-0.0235822629,
-0.3215300143,
-0.0405433178,
-0.0159626212,
-0.5319033265,
-0.3826383352,
0.2959751189,
-0.0573901758,
0.2154401541,
0.0858891308,
-0.2386187166,
-0.3639913499,
-0.4957256913,
0.5759143829,
-0.5577004552,
-0.3158329427,
0.2656962574,
0.3197125793,
0.1807506233,
0.5093143582,
-0.7038701773,
0.425219208,
1.0569372177,
0.6969895363,
-0.2344194055,
-0.4266954362,
-0.5080816746,
-0.0615150779,
-0.4580498636,
0.590444386,
-0.3745472431,
-0.1632017493,
-0.1950552613,
0.2015237063,
0.0207367335,
-0.7857490182,
0.5762341619,
-0.1241757423,
-0.265399605,
-0.4844222963,
-0.8682442904,
0.1274804473,
0.6300997734,
-0.5550320745,
0.9357827306,
0.0299716517,
-0.4356656373,
0.1054613963,
-0.0738964826,
-0.1241171211,
-0.0285444688,
-0.3499462903,
-0.4680931568,
0.2681708932,
-0.2961389422,
0.2161832601,
-0.4010365903,
0.5970454216,
-0.372461319,
-0.547845304,
0.254607439,
-0.5235503912,
0.6200626493,
-0.0256333128,
-0.4715915024,
-0.1313480139,
-0.5349520445,
0.418192625,
0.2282520533,
-0.6073790789,
-0.1794020385,
0.0024790282,
-0.2363911867,
0.109578073,
0.4281051755,
-0.4423367977,
0.4163241088,
-0.0529574715,
0.2247620523,
0.8423520327,
-0.1978503913,
0.0746098012,
-0.46794945,
0.1869958639,
-0.0267884061,
0.0561868809,
0.038761463,
-0.5469979048,
-0.7739986181,
0.0431462452,
0.4229515791,
0.5166778564,
-0.4741624892,
0.2064645439,
-0.3136209249,
-0.6074854136,
-0.3660509288,
0.4881100357,
0.5758910179,
0.4736028016,
0.2580537796,
-0.2586435974,
-0.3677155674,
-0.8260717988,
-0.4577649534,
-0.2124064714,
-0.0174884312,
0.2428411096,
0.4558305144,
-0.0815997273,
0.5693469644,
-0.4105936885,
0.0484687947,
-0.1384303421,
0.1636680067,
0.4675368071,
0.7549310327,
-0.0060078357,
-0.6367821693,
-0.47419554,
-0.1547258347,
-0.8072491288,
-0.2122350782,
0.4415531158,
0.2428894043,
0.1738549322,
0.6499682665,
-0.724414289,
-0.0697456151,
0.6056300998,
-0.1482874304,
0.5777619481,
-0.5478700995,
0.2421261221,
-0.498360455,
-0.0299479291,
0.1830353737,
-0.2414909303,
-0.4461665452,
0.0496016741,
0.311691612,
-0.0064483616,
-0.2674580216,
0.440151304,
-0.2280412465,
0.183146283,
-0.0454970598,
-0.1007180065,
0.0313734934,
0.4336981475,
-0.2198205292,
0.5347285271,
0.2876170278,
-0.3852964938,
0.283187151,
-0.1414092481,
-0.6501407027,
0.5176071525,
-0.9488359094,
0.3272126019,
-0.112219505,
0.0721571296,
-1.2467821836,
-0.4906394184,
-0.0859097168,
-0.1042560339,
0.4695178866,
-0.0953949764,
-0.6408028603,
-0.052176673,
-0.1087991372,
0.5265567899,
0.3775283694,
-0.3151177168,
0.2103680372,
0.1652731001,
-0.2582080364,
-0.4801834226,
-0.3882213831,
-0.0956718102,
0.0223871395,
-0.5085246563,
0.2166193575,
-0.4248371124,
-0.4117973447,
-0.0200126618,
-0.0765513778,
-0.0515408292,
0.0396302044,
0.2319959551,
0.0777874663,
-0.244556427,
0.2988846302,
-0.4462134838,
-0.1282725334,
-0.081063889,
0.0150930146,
0.4643816054,
-0.5058690906,
-0.6020106077,
-0.3404558897,
0.3354220092,
0.4979026914,
0.05280542,
0.4004473984,
0.03033619,
-0.5140532851,
-0.0191912018,
-0.7936531305,
-0.0558504835,
-0.4882289767,
0.4036338031,
-0.6965776086,
-0.8825995326,
0.6095077395,
-0.0431372784,
-0.0610821247,
0.385786891,
0.2860427201,
-0.1853179634,
1.1902741194,
0.6057146192,
0.051144734,
0.0052826544,
0.0036383744,
0.0726831034,
-0.5202765465,
-0.24363029,
-0.6209324002,
-0.1706089377,
-0.9388845563,
-0.0615211427,
0.4679249227,
0.3999459743,
-0.7246938348,
0.2147554308,
-0.3008687198,
0.7505304813,
0.3443612456,
0.0320782661,
0.5340496302,
-0.1964122504,
-0.0743224025,
-0.2053824365,
-0.588265717,
-0.4518477619,
1.0198158026,
0.3911555707,
0.711784184,
0.3830595911,
0.5542399883,
0.0329325162,
0.490069896,
-0.5544083118,
0.4806894958,
-0.3131251633,
-0.70183599,
-0.3945015073,
-0.541526258,
-0.8685255647,
0.0382542759,
-0.0253835786,
-0.5748727918,
0.0429383107,
0.1376041621,
-0.1205868721,
0.0539594889,
-0.7910501957,
1.0894457102,
-0.3085520566,
-0.6106960177,
0.1877610683,
-0.4750087261,
0.4688883424,
-0.2419678122,
0.3193958998,
-0.4554178715,
0.0241009425,
0.4208226204,
-0.4492256045,
0.6274579763,
-0.0994446501,
-0.1744741052,
0.2263018638,
0.3734524548,
0.7110351324,
-0.0311032385,
-0.2677050233,
0.2235213369,
-0.019960681,
-0.515545547,
-0.8018988967,
0.8447680473,
-0.7244287133,
-0.8803296685,
-0.3408584297,
-0.5637825131,
-0.3738812506,
0.0270064548,
0.1027121842,
0.3770537674,
0.0403863676,
0.211024344,
0.8189272881,
0.0646892413,
0.3049220741,
0.7395112514,
0.0305745639,
-0.0792148784,
0.7580497861,
0.4059871435,
0.324242413,
0.0138952751,
0.2267399132,
-0.2828855217,
-0.6411236525,
-0.2573741078,
0.2312018126,
-0.8234954476,
-0.2664745152,
-0.301587224,
-0.1418038458,
-0.0875859782,
0.1228106618,
-0.4756638706,
-0.0814476684,
0.2017013282,
0.1343810707,
0.1799920648,
0.8554747105,
-0.0580397397,
-0.0543364808,
-0.6167798042,
0.1573924422,
0.4538817108,
0.5904800296,
-0.010661928,
-0.6673395634,
0.0681062341,
-0.0015548301,
-0.3539011478,
-0.454906702,
-0.0894393027,
0.0952753723,
0.2976587415,
0.1068495438,
-0.167603001,
0.6241655946,
-0.7050585747,
0.4970286787,
0.178017661,
-1.0739655495,
0.184930414,
-0.488124609,
0.4288277328,
0.7756537795,
0.380925566,
-0.5594647527,
-0.4755030274,
-0.5804521441,
-0.7387900352,
0.3807113171,
-0.0043282961,
0.2071452886,
-0.2325392514,
0.6609557271,
0.2470232397,
0.0908821598,
-0.753027916,
-0.1030218378,
0.0795986131,
-0.5070015192,
-0.2256504446,
-0.270672828,
0.0425962321,
-0.1609203219,
0.5065641999,
-0.0690116435,
-0.1044337973,
0.0025145323,
0.1113833711,
-0.2865666449,
0.3281759918,
0.6540593505,
0.9486871362,
-0.347586453,
0.343750596,
0.221062243,
-0.2906540334,
0.4440542758,
0.0427753404,
0.0582756028,
-0.142727524,
0.4217104614,
0.3202959895,
0.2658439875,
-0.7743496895,
0.6630354524,
-0.0417143591,
-0.2089455277,
-0.2391542494,
0.2869910598,
0.2869399488,
0.3440713882,
0.4606108963,
-0.1387335509,
-0.2413213402,
-0.8597310185,
0.1767905951,
0.5128737092,
-0.301581651,
-0.1447071135,
0.5339045525,
-0.0591017343,
-0.4978893399,
0.731143415,
-0.300337553,
-0.4192751646,
0.7700493932,
0.4465455413,
0.3845281899,
-0.4631907642,
-0.114623487,
0.1888924539,
0.434689343,
-0.636975646,
0.4946397245,
0.2717380524,
-0.6898903847,
-0.494443506,
-0.488421768,
-0.7513661981,
0.5038683414,
-0.3266862929,
0.3043987751,
-0.5844643712,
0.0533485301,
0.0949899852,
0.2590798736,
-0.7949892282,
0.4715431929,
-0.1638781577,
0.7454059124,
-0.7078099847,
0.8641697168,
0.4276824296,
-0.3585115075,
-1.170107007,
-0.1181902587,
-0.0601149164,
-0.672231555,
0.6187362671,
0.186507985,
0.0404199921,
-0.0347805321,
-0.7449505925,
-0.9251238108,
0.8054940701,
0.6565455198,
-1.0878484249,
0.2057150453,
0.2505523264,
0.5460185409,
-0.2623760998,
0.1277645379,
0.592680335,
0.5862637162,
-0.1279534698,
-1.1484458447,
0.2349471897,
-0.1954142153,
-0.284956634,
0.3365545273,
-0.6838282347,
1.1235814095,
-0.1844538003,
0.0233896021,
0.1782228798,
0.427267313,
0.448029846,
0.4627658129,
0.4517819583,
0.7071931958,
0.9018017054,
-0.4818866253,
1.019287467,
-0.2618162632,
0.5265793204,
1.3089716434,
-0.4935027957,
0.9918187261,
0.3511977196,
-0.2925359309,
0.2806501091,
0.5436233878,
0.0702719837,
0.3596199155,
0.4312231541,
-0.1932289898,
-0.4486845434,
0.0922893882,
-0.3812849522,
0.5435322523,
0.1793479621,
0.0479648225,
-0.1666655391,
-0.1752734482,
0.0472340323,
0.1863795221,
-0.2482484877,
0.511426568,
0.2352379858,
-0.7869848609,
0.8682231903,
0.1522596329,
0.3857614994,
-0.6572284102,
-0.1508563757,
-0.4860246181,
0.3356415927,
-0.1281364709,
-0.9900975227,
0.1729667634,
-0.0618766136,
-0.366502285,
0.1206285655,
0.3922538161,
-0.5801452398,
-0.3827246428,
0.0765397847,
0.7704616785,
0.2494068444,
0.0300642736,
-0.7632268667,
0.5095599294,
-0.2594032884,
-0.1230358407,
0.2839134932,
0.666473031,
-0.0705939084,
0.6945195198,
0.3938399255,
-0.0234810635,
-0.1483000815,
-0.0576144084,
0.5548878908,
-0.6573394537,
-0.0734291971,
-0.9418320656,
0.3184304535,
-0.0244356748,
-0.3443421721,
0.6709159613,
0.4747564793,
0.7828870416,
0.2550649345,
0.5960457921,
0.1384407878,
0.5505746007,
-0.4372111261,
0.3376564085,
-0.5958601832,
0.4397142828,
-0.2200486213,
-1.1788493395,
-0.3538560271,
0.3649234772,
-0.4577764869,
0.1254158765,
0.7688800693,
0.6883991361,
-0.1905168146,
-0.1324540675,
0.285818994,
0.3456498086,
0.3180431426,
0.9099011421,
0.7565538287,
-0.4502756596,
0.5308753848,
-0.0249010157,
-0.1242526844,
-0.0996304974,
-0.9788241386,
-0.3502580822,
-0.4243960381,
-0.5270046592,
-0.6309176087,
0.3500068188,
0.8708600402,
0.3237627745,
-0.7650191188,
-0.295514226,
-0.4030836821,
0.3077540398,
-0.1409213096,
-0.1738220602,
0.4470541477,
-0.4687069952,
-0.6997962594,
0.241659984,
0.2116069645,
0.0677351281,
-0.1157903075,
-0.1109834984,
0.024749836,
0.1992973089,
0.166377306,
0.3899230361,
-0.5866419077,
-0.6596335769,
-0.1373809576,
-0.5258466005,
0.1397717893,
0.6344414949,
-0.3825355172,
0.3055292368,
0.3046517372,
0.629406333,
0.2912629247,
0.0541011877,
0.2837572992,
-0.5363568664,
-0.1488631368,
-0.0000915703,
0.5178283453,
0.6410392523,
0.0336044058,
0.4703307152,
0.1990990043,
-0.6992380023,
-0.8536439538,
0.2914443314,
-0.8310415745,
-0.2904660404,
1.081374526,
-0.3586698472,
-0.1925634593,
-0.2535479963,
0.1297602952,
-0.0154165486,
-0.0135264173,
0.9875679016,
1.0472333431,
-0.1886875778,
-0.0653770119,
-0.7517651916,
0.5824361444,
0.7355078459,
-0.6319730878,
0.1845420152,
0.3730517626,
0.7516624331,
0.1402334571,
0.6683199406,
-0.0225724578,
0.2771386802,
-0.120590657,
-0.3128259778,
0.0822141171,
-0.3066994846,
-0.3916082084,
0.5176743865,
0.3247127533,
0.2911898196
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12793v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12793v1 | ChatGLM: A Family of Large Language Models from GLM-130B to GLM-4 All Tools | 2024-06-18T16:58:21 | 2024-06-18T16:58:21 | Team GLM, :, Aohan Zeng, Bin Xu, Bowen Wang, Chenhui Zhang, Da Yin, Diego Rojas, Guanyu Feng, Hanlin Zhao, Hanyu Lai, Hao Yu, Hongning Wang, Jiadai Sun, Jiajie Zhang, Jiale Cheng, Jiayi Gui, Jie Tang, Jing Zhang, Juanzi Li, Lei Zhao, Lindong Wu, Lucen Zhong, Mingdao Liu, Minlie Huang, Peng Zhang, Qinkai Zheng, Rui Lu, Shuaiqi Duan, Shudan Zhang, Shulin Cao, Shuxun Yang, Weng Lam Tam, Wenyi Zhao, Xiao Liu, Xiao Xia, Xiaohan Zhang, Xiaotao Gu, Xin Lv, Xinghan Liu, Xinyi Liu, Xinyue Yang, Xixuan Song, Xunkai Zhang, Yifan An, Yifan Xu, Yilin Niu, Yuantao Yang, Yueyan Li, Yushi Bai, Yuxiao Dong, Zehan Qi, Zhaoyu Wang, Zhen Yang, Zhengxiao Du, Zhenyu Hou, Zihan Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | We introduce ChatGLM, an evolving family of large language models that we
have been developing over time. This report primarily focuses on the GLM-4
language series, which includes GLM-4, GLM-4-Air, and GLM-4-9B. They represent
our most capable models that are trained with all the insights and lessons
gained from the preceding three generations of ChatGLM. To date, the GLM-4
models are pre-trained on ten trillions of tokens mostly in Chinese and
English, along with a small set of corpus from 24 languages, and aligned
primarily for Chinese and English usage. The high-quality alignment is achieved
via a multi-stage post-training process, which involves supervised fine-tuning
and learning from human feedback. Evaluations show that GLM-4 1) closely rivals
or outperforms GPT-4 in terms of general metrics such as MMLU, GSM8K, MATH,
BBH, GPQA, and HumanEval, 2) gets close to GPT-4-Turbo in instruction following
as measured by IFEval, 3) matches GPT-4 Turbo (128K) and Claude 3 for long
context tasks, and 4) outperforms GPT-4 in Chinese alignments as measured by
AlignBench. The GLM-4 All Tools model is further aligned to understand user
intent and autonomously decide when and which tool(s) touse -- including web
browser, Python interpreter, text-to-image model, and user-defined functions --
to effectively complete complex tasks. In practical applications, it matches
and even surpasses GPT-4 All Tools in tasks like accessing online information
via web browsing and solving math problems using Python interpreter. Over the
course, we have open-sourced a series of models, including ChatGLM-6B (three
generations), GLM-4-9B (128K, 1M), GLM-4V-9B, WebGLM, and CodeGeeX, attracting
over 10 million downloads on Hugging face in the year 2023 alone. The open
models can be accessed through https://github.com/THUDM and
https://huggingface.co/THUDM. | [
-0.2519461215,
-0.6652829051,
0.4075682461,
0.2101272345,
0.1656419486,
0.3329312503,
-0.2095591575,
-0.7486205697,
-0.3720740676,
0.470588237,
-0.3880741298,
-0.5024772286,
-0.4682002366,
-0.0855326131,
-0.3731310666,
0.9715225101,
0.0650931522,
0.1729331017,
-0.1573032141,
-0.1183218211,
-0.3250848055,
-0.8531111479,
-0.5376883149,
-0.3892284632,
0.582087934,
0.0260806829,
0.9483551383,
0.4582898319,
0.6628316641,
0.2872161269,
-0.0825710148,
-0.0433441363,
-0.6213806272,
-0.2197031677,
-0.0103126131,
-0.3182097077,
-0.7364056706,
0.1859657317,
0.5229528546,
0.6215270162,
-0.3002730906,
0.1398341358,
-0.0480457544,
0.5060967803,
-0.2999234796,
0.1993712932,
-0.7131922245,
-0.1347267181,
-0.2602492273,
0.1275029331,
-0.4487783313,
-0.4260607064,
0.1463440806,
-0.5516275167,
0.1455068886,
0.2000499219,
1.0735286474,
-0.0911933184,
-0.3705920279,
-0.3873258531,
-0.621411562,
0.9053282738,
-0.8948534131,
0.5487451553,
0.2513519824,
0.4347952604,
-0.3721265495,
-0.894259274,
-0.2099139094,
-0.179295361,
0.1502955705,
0.2791253626,
-0.1822464764,
0.1543606073,
0.3040922284,
0.4801177084,
-0.7748875618,
0.1026422232,
-0.593192637,
-0.3019266725,
0.5596158504,
0.24522686,
0.4950754046,
0.193799302,
-0.4137886763,
0.1953921318,
-0.9257755876,
-0.0951882079,
0.4538113475,
0.1933960766,
-0.2707193196,
0.3319436312,
0.0896948949,
0.89168185,
-0.2710118294,
-0.2074786723,
0.2744908333,
-0.6005294919,
-0.2347183675,
-0.3235214949,
0.8900672197,
0.2999791503,
0.2298247367,
-0.1392020136,
-0.2604335248,
-0.0968783721,
0.1237152293,
-0.9027786851,
-0.2947288752,
0.0657299235,
-0.4713071585,
-0.2418168038,
-0.1198668107,
-0.4965561628,
-0.1905538887,
-0.3440219462,
0.5153281689,
-0.5096053481,
-0.2535691261,
0.249259606,
0.0905026942,
0.6072762012,
0.6141079068,
-1.0445262194,
0.3941331506,
0.7477401495,
0.9954079986,
-0.2723017931,
-0.2883862853,
-0.5678508282,
0.0098108482,
-0.4993561506,
0.5304121375,
-0.6342966557,
-0.3315643966,
0.2395383716,
0.035018865,
-0.0576995164,
-0.4972288013,
0.320063889,
-0.4747002125,
0.6800174117,
-0.1374398917,
-0.6763575673,
-0.4938209057,
0.3786084354,
-0.6262623072,
1.0742543936,
0.2832726836,
-0.6033790112,
0.0275716372,
-0.6973621249,
-0.0419496335,
0.2176764011,
-0.0079948334,
-0.361143291,
0.036704082,
0.0647891536,
0.2949465811,
-0.5282328129,
0.236378938,
-0.5825362206,
-0.3644091785,
-0.1947179884,
-0.1714085788,
0.8975460529,
0.2179256976,
-0.1230289489,
0.5476142168,
-0.2209140509,
0.0863400772,
0.234426111,
-0.2461620122,
0.093893446,
-0.1566030979,
0.1169059426,
0.5773251057,
0.4623467624,
-0.391688168,
0.1897707731,
-0.4584616721,
0.7339370847,
0.6238167286,
-0.3044588268,
0.3293183446,
-0.2068767548,
0.7422741055,
0.028057225,
0.4605642259,
-0.4178546071,
-0.7544007301,
-0.559016645,
-0.0485716015,
0.2694887221,
0.4387779236,
-0.470066458,
0.1914115101,
-0.1404829919,
-0.5682682395,
-0.3545401394,
0.2206516862,
0.1773400307,
0.2818193734,
0.2222541422,
-0.2191993743,
-0.2669947147,
-0.7884220481,
-0.1460238546,
-0.3176570237,
-0.0882847533,
0.1359237731,
0.2656809986,
-0.3851580024,
0.8068065047,
-0.293931514,
-0.1046768352,
-0.3742389381,
-0.0479904562,
0.1860662252,
0.1451192796,
0.7507267594,
-0.6813696027,
-0.5637853146,
0.2770818472,
-0.6968690753,
0.0533239618,
0.1923500746,
-0.2513846457,
0.4189413786,
0.4287722111,
-0.5672893524,
0.0656355694,
0.9007337093,
-0.2337023169,
0.6333546638,
-0.1378361583,
-0.1879560053,
-1.087903142,
0.1683683544,
-0.0991411954,
-0.4272300899,
-0.7889975905,
0.0566038974,
0.2209859341,
-0.2287328094,
-0.5672052503,
0.817273736,
-0.6776462197,
-0.1974757314,
-0.1140048206,
0.2666790783,
-0.0653189272,
0.5344640613,
-0.163538903,
0.6474007964,
0.7137192488,
-0.1975539029,
0.5111322999,
0.1013492122,
-0.1913055927,
0.038184803,
-0.6013290286,
0.3307454884,
0.1353487819,
0.1681884378,
-0.7668844461,
-0.2474774718,
0.2309379727,
-0.3888609409,
0.2089418173,
-0.0429804735,
-0.4310330451,
-0.5754655004,
-0.3355519772,
0.1295977533,
0.7627311349,
-0.5144582391,
0.752574265,
0.3959627151,
-0.3237892091,
-0.4774035513,
-0.1730982959,
0.2572692335,
-0.3115172982,
-0.8343653679,
0.2144678533,
-0.2533225715,
-0.1116276681,
0.0491297767,
0.0040082717,
-0.0080290977,
0.157373473,
0.2376823127,
0.7171342969,
-0.2507289648,
0.0049921102,
-0.5625549555,
0.0919221342,
-0.0965231359,
-0.3369936943,
0.7309983373,
-0.5549061894,
-0.3936548531,
0.0674146935,
0.0575662442,
0.423065424,
-0.4223379493,
0.5289473534,
0.8539659977,
-0.4240728319,
0.1744920909,
-0.5935282707,
-0.0293860212,
-0.4905078709,
0.3729183376,
-0.2267948538,
-1.2136882544,
0.6852148175,
0.0785569549,
0.5309132338,
0.2312200218,
0.9035114646,
0.3227659166,
1.2638472319,
0.6549547315,
-0.4708020687,
0.5415306687,
0.0711533353,
0.1813347489,
-0.572498858,
-0.0322107226,
-0.293261677,
-0.0884313211,
-0.5986286998,
-0.412343502,
0.1032140702,
0.1758298725,
-0.281688571,
0.1406771541,
-0.3740999103,
0.3797996044,
0.5013677478,
-0.3100090325,
0.1557677388,
-0.1956158876,
0.1378486753,
0.2706378698,
-0.5968194604,
-0.5181213617,
1.1637129784,
0.5380167365,
0.7680274248,
0.1432527453,
0.4688986242,
-0.1176656932,
0.5668446422,
-0.8052268028,
0.3971408606,
-0.131468758,
-0.7022975087,
-0.1785215735,
-0.4164640009,
-1.0424964428,
0.2769904435,
0.1543652117,
-0.6742885709,
-0.4786875248,
0.2055853009,
-0.2819662392,
0.2744832039,
-0.6980224252,
1.0722726583,
-0.3867118657,
-0.3327417374,
-0.1029669493,
-0.7835498452,
0.6814389229,
-0.2881629467,
0.2001729459,
-0.5008893013,
0.0876579881,
0.4518234432,
-0.1533174068,
0.5127545595,
-0.1485242844,
-0.2543174028,
0.3105080724,
-0.1315621138,
0.3468016386,
-0.2817707062,
-0.0789326876,
0.5281376839,
-0.0156735033,
-0.4391751885,
-0.5055336356,
0.7087503672,
-0.8729245067,
-0.6642115712,
-0.4178358912,
-0.5674011111,
-0.1904877871,
0.4074168205,
0.1430349499,
0.6524449587,
-0.326272279,
0.2153707594,
0.2243654579,
-0.3859902918,
0.4514745772,
0.4452137649,
-0.9273686409,
-0.2523948848,
0.902184546,
0.0272903591,
0.57911551,
0.1170175076,
0.1740376055,
-0.4264137745,
-0.5028303266,
-0.4516553283,
0.3366839588,
-0.5682522655,
-0.116342403,
-0.5148175955,
-0.5300453901,
-0.4667542577,
-0.0492687561,
-0.1538670361,
-0.0940485522,
0.0168223474,
0.1748137325,
0.2680420578,
0.9069235325,
0.1521847248,
0.3048131466,
-0.8833334446,
0.1676579416,
0.2323731631,
0.3461728096,
-0.2351463139,
-0.379463613,
-0.3678020537,
0.1699044853,
-0.5855376124,
-0.4912109673,
0.3951386213,
0.2910624146,
0.5012599826,
0.3533218801,
-0.3888342977,
0.5176312923,
-0.7898880243,
1.048612833,
0.2982216179,
-0.9301402569,
0.1796342283,
-0.6956697702,
0.4154314101,
0.0248402543,
0.2790576816,
-0.9124712348,
-0.5339502096,
-0.5709552765,
-0.5557219982,
0.9209604859,
0.205845952,
0.2318647653,
0.1238919422,
0.2058783025,
0.0796768144,
0.17017515,
-0.6117245555,
0.0928266719,
-0.2707182169,
-0.3713937998,
-0.1102324575,
-0.057325352,
-0.0189158693,
-0.0247505885,
0.6535851359,
-0.3140514493,
0.1725627035,
-0.3618809879,
0.0134759657,
0.0111675151,
0.0109962896,
0.5943712592,
0.8297458887,
-0.2021298259,
0.0259558931,
0.1312613338,
-0.6253796816,
0.011169997,
0.0560984425,
0.1059758663,
-0.0747383386,
0.3549333215,
0.9977236986,
0.1877874136,
-0.6739811897,
0.5677178502,
-0.109285146,
-0.1898539513,
-0.3658809662,
0.1220054254,
0.5235829353,
-0.0034411228,
0.0588164441,
-0.2664803565,
0.1056280509,
-0.5540010333,
0.0495987535,
0.5445040464,
-0.3146330714,
-0.7128885388,
0.7172878385,
0.2919590771,
-0.115454264,
0.6508942246,
-0.1750878841,
-0.6520870924,
0.39064762,
0.5739252567,
0.7553600669,
-0.4962312877,
0.1407535523,
0.3367025852,
0.2493498772,
-0.3944758177,
0.2174502462,
0.4492515028,
-0.8059872985,
-0.4539014399,
-0.6362925172,
-0.6903271675,
0.293453604,
-0.4859344959,
0.668533802,
-0.4135657251,
-0.0660773963,
-0.0820845664,
0.0567306913,
-0.807338357,
-0.0104908273,
0.3309984207,
0.8617758155,
-0.4730177224,
0.9670000076,
0.7424958348,
-0.2737966478,
-0.8622066379,
-0.1883374155,
0.4595125914,
-0.9896993637,
0.4723688066,
0.4301822186,
-0.0431744754,
0.2509593368,
-0.7077889442,
-0.9813430309,
1.0190894604,
0.3643579185,
-0.5685440898,
-0.3408028483,
-0.0605690815,
0.3979475796,
-0.2445066124,
0.3810441494,
0.5141999722,
0.2701329291,
0.1653848141,
-1.1187697649,
-0.179219678,
-0.2862181962,
0.0565309487,
0.436894238,
-0.751134038,
0.9155872464,
-0.0852101892,
-0.2545103133,
0.1724616438,
0.4091503322,
0.2371905148,
0.0349375792,
0.4286477268,
0.2500352263,
0.6751681566,
-0.2681512237,
0.8587476611,
-0.4913163483,
0.3633741736,
0.9526606202,
-0.5303914547,
0.6704381108,
0.0704042539,
-0.2071275413,
0.3590087891,
0.8058356643,
-0.1265636086,
0.2124150991,
0.165321216,
-0.1850887984,
-0.2539616525,
0.0448883623,
-0.3490628302,
0.3589247763,
0.4635289311,
0.1054496691,
-0.3630227447,
-0.0622828268,
0.1686753035,
-0.3689648807,
-0.2378776222,
0.7035999298,
0.2348254621,
-0.5776765943,
0.6406203508,
-0.0463636033,
0.6494752169,
-0.8963481784,
0.2275582552,
-0.2478308082,
0.1472277641,
-0.0494429693,
-0.826356113,
0.1276044548,
-0.0905550048,
0.1708920896,
-0.1173305809,
0.8334313035,
-0.6164595485,
-0.4313822985,
0.4412257969,
0.5197537541,
0.2725448012,
-0.0608156882,
-0.7475291491,
0.304262042,
0.0766477808,
-0.3283688128,
0.402074486,
0.4640499651,
-0.1895599961,
0.7317436934,
0.6440384984,
0.0929225907,
0.2436638623,
0.2089235634,
0.7387234569,
-0.7826501131,
-0.2740944326,
-0.8024722934,
0.3435410857,
-0.1402428001,
-0.245334059,
0.8356260061,
0.6326057911,
0.733751595,
0.0949083567,
0.8970282674,
0.1169707999,
0.3898344338,
-0.3597618937,
0.5052813888,
-0.5872716308,
-0.1927067339,
-0.2082106918,
-1.1669090986,
-0.3909741342,
0.3139253557,
-0.313791275,
0.1884696633,
0.3783933222,
0.6338500977,
0.0760737807,
0.1967579126,
0.4971143305,
0.0724185482,
0.8080199361,
0.7119452357,
0.9398522973,
-0.1266296804,
0.6180761456,
0.0506562665,
-0.2746888995,
-0.3894148767,
-0.7687497735,
-0.9485782981,
-0.4274259508,
-0.1574539542,
0.0072904658,
-0.1689935923,
0.7836390138,
0.7624561191,
-0.6268551946,
-0.3277432621,
0.1478532702,
-0.1135842726,
-0.0139584439,
-0.1680394113,
0.1105933636,
-0.6523620486,
-0.8028632402,
0.2860378027,
0.5349053741,
0.0756541938,
-0.4497630298,
-0.278406769,
0.0339415222,
0.0252507627,
0.8076109886,
0.1479674727,
-0.9583467841,
-0.4944360256,
0.3475372791,
-0.2657649219,
0.1374066621,
0.5275651217,
-0.3742432594,
0.452686429,
0.3872747123,
0.5552365184,
0.4240743518,
0.0901828632,
0.8082011938,
-0.4145753682,
0.0624097772,
0.0718923286,
0.5280587077,
0.5656235814,
0.0003177244,
0.777418077,
-0.0174270198,
-0.9093049765,
-0.8508007526,
0.1846661121,
-0.90473032,
-0.1581615955,
1.1244311333,
-0.191830188,
0.0290826093,
-0.0872183144,
-0.3689531982,
0.051885996,
-0.2220576257,
0.5971679091,
1.0691148043,
-0.2202661037,
-0.1762797832,
-0.8622831702,
0.5133344531,
0.2024631798,
-1.0579369068,
0.1742393374,
0.6349714398,
0.2842464447,
0.1397110224,
0.580283761,
-0.3921442628,
0.1835600883,
-0.2492358834,
0.4003721774,
0.0640057474,
-0.1425325722,
-0.3100019395,
-0.0492236391,
0.2869440019,
-0.0238217916
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12787v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12787v1 | Generating Educational Materials with Different Levels of Readability using LLMs | 2024-06-18T16:55:10 | 2024-06-18T16:55:10 | Chieh-Yang Huang, Jing Wei, Ting-Hao 'Kenneth' Huang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.HC | This study introduces the leveled-text generation task, aiming to rewrite
educational materials to specific readability levels while preserving meaning.
We assess the capability of GPT-3.5, LLaMA-2 70B, and Mixtral 8x7B, to generate
content at various readability levels through zero-shot and few-shot prompting.
Evaluating 100 processed educational materials reveals that few-shot prompting
significantly improves performance in readability manipulation and information
preservation. LLaMA-2 70B performs better in achieving the desired difficulty
range, while GPT-3.5 maintains original meaning. However, manual inspection
highlights concerns such as misinformation introduction and inconsistent edit
distribution. These findings emphasize the need for further research to ensure
the quality of generated educational content. | [
-0.242930755,
-0.890824914,
0.5340454578,
-0.0739474446,
-0.385106355,
0.2339546978,
0.0330212452,
-0.4709134698,
-0.1933537275,
0.2031377554,
-0.6151809692,
-0.7405675054,
-0.6929391026,
0.3838273585,
-0.6103785634,
1.2116354704,
-0.3341094553,
-0.3361873031,
-0.0077142292,
0.2405311465,
-0.5494092107,
-0.2093998641,
-0.7570912838,
-0.4141060114,
0.8363296986,
0.8127070069,
0.5918850899,
0.9217668176,
0.5195465088,
0.1782452911,
-0.3777699471,
0.1121768802,
-0.6099666357,
0.4326319098,
-0.1700097471,
-0.5340915322,
-0.6827743649,
-0.1162973121,
0.827534914,
0.3424940705,
-0.0403563641,
0.2524409592,
0.4745650589,
0.6226353049,
-0.5704895854,
-0.1478848457,
-0.4578706622,
0.2995641828,
-0.3644771576,
-0.49381724,
-0.4604075253,
-0.1086751372,
-0.0157037098,
-0.9137282372,
0.4555366039,
0.0279247481,
0.6630989313,
0.1666039824,
-0.1185426563,
-0.598336637,
-0.5300279856,
0.8103890419,
-0.6991294622,
0.2075203657,
0.5200879574,
0.0760517791,
-0.1171528473,
-0.5974237323,
-0.7604929209,
0.1458385289,
0.1893278956,
0.4056184888,
-0.0735915676,
-0.0963786915,
0.3918764889,
0.4156899154,
-0.5733498335,
0.2069134414,
-0.6632714868,
-0.0945673659,
0.385969311,
0.4593476653,
0.4333927631,
-0.5766483545,
-0.2380234152,
-0.2286467105,
-0.9360567927,
-0.0278507639,
0.5908812881,
0.1812386215,
0.0843109712,
1.0746724606,
-0.3030378222,
0.3936853409,
0.0656882823,
-0.7419818044,
0.1928244978,
-0.5961747169,
-0.2659423947,
0.0060395277,
0.3374390304,
0.3670377135,
0.0648074374,
0.2538726926,
-0.4282135665,
-0.22824651,
0.2417092025,
-0.79398036,
-0.0380730666,
0.1711180955,
-0.5234866142,
-0.3640250862,
-0.1748071462,
-0.6145466566,
-0.4275302291,
-0.4996095002,
0.5668595433,
-0.6441754103,
-0.0910216644,
0.1439246386,
-0.1516556442,
0.2239508927,
0.7242820263,
-1.0373684168,
-0.1231950819,
0.4814368784,
0.8918529749,
-0.4379218817,
-0.1706871986,
-0.1663311571,
0.4898096621,
-0.2145316303,
0.8859480619,
-0.4178906381,
-0.6402902603,
0.0381800719,
-0.2479483336,
0.1422181726,
-0.6525956392,
0.4336113632,
-0.2527988553,
0.2727777064,
-0.1555566341,
-0.4920552671,
-0.0366398282,
0.4199813604,
-0.4919849634,
1.1920697689,
0.4062415957,
-0.7555436492,
0.6895441413,
-0.148558557,
-0.4544665515,
0.1817989647,
-0.041792728,
-0.3144768775,
-0.0087817386,
0.2180248499,
0.4010742605,
-0.0000751473,
-0.1776644886,
0.3386093378,
-0.5936914086,
-0.167832166,
-0.6485117078,
0.3124033213,
0.1326111555,
-0.4210641086,
-0.1005656123,
-0.8708944917,
-0.0607241802,
0.0205979701,
-0.9645251036,
0.0638801157,
-0.0219969433,
-0.1308870912,
0.2148704976,
0.366114527,
-0.4446156025,
0.2171875685,
-0.098856084,
0.004288137,
0.8711869121,
0.2549161613,
0.4835472703,
-0.605199337,
0.8180519938,
0.3196732104,
-0.0359439477,
-0.3949100971,
-0.6480125785,
-1.0514196157,
-0.1240253448,
-0.2038672715,
0.7143028975,
-0.9394669533,
-0.0587467067,
0.2106027305,
-0.449436903,
-0.4408170581,
0.6286806464,
0.527053535,
0.7135819197,
0.3386781216,
-0.1332528293,
-0.2068237066,
-0.6003676653,
-0.0596493557,
-0.0800683424,
-0.1212606654,
0.1773670316,
0.3901809454,
-0.1884418279,
0.640794754,
-0.6527550817,
-0.148925513,
-0.240007475,
0.2283825129,
0.2767077386,
0.4408905506,
0.3500260413,
-0.1459919214,
-0.6147511601,
-0.0649274811,
-0.7502852678,
-0.2007174194,
-0.1906081885,
-0.2844476402,
0.1577274352,
0.0955571085,
-0.3264682293,
0.5074088573,
-0.0090089887,
-0.0875268579,
0.3096639216,
-0.1601345241,
0.3802802265,
-1.0878289938,
-0.362791121,
0.0444323011,
-0.0438934267,
-0.5745598674,
-0.1063715965,
-0.0998083279,
-0.1276764572,
-0.7643758655,
0.3719571233,
-0.5017849803,
0.0078693526,
-0.3479332626,
0.7502425313,
0.2239912301,
0.1324552149,
-0.0364777632,
0.9611575007,
0.2820562124,
-0.524332881,
0.2035850734,
0.4325014353,
-0.2916876972,
1.0414030552,
-0.7808607221,
0.0814601779,
-0.5200318098,
0.1141515002,
-0.8500055671,
-0.350748688,
0.5743440986,
-0.2221308649,
0.4238715768,
0.3063319325,
-0.6179258227,
-0.1429069787,
-0.5070080757,
0.203682214,
0.5631554127,
-0.3609161973,
0.1267974526,
-0.2093794197,
-0.536429286,
-0.5944407582,
-0.684682548,
-0.0546454303,
-0.1270738542,
-0.5888804197,
-0.020916298,
-0.4315569401,
-0.0563620403,
-0.1944230199,
-0.3150811791,
0.1382509023,
-0.2477888316,
0.3909024596,
0.3827906251,
-0.4326760471,
-0.0150368232,
0.5550640821,
0.0464216545,
-0.2671303153,
0.0976661742,
0.2522576749,
0.168891862,
-0.3458047509,
-0.3753648996,
0.3940115869,
-0.1594908386,
0.2212762535,
0.643550992,
0.5296521187,
-0.3516601324,
-0.4672189057,
-0.2118373215,
-0.0230507869,
-0.5001477003,
0.1347850859,
-0.4732702374,
-0.8206769824,
0.3033708036,
0.2481201738,
0.2758718133,
0.4626214206,
0.6798087358,
-0.2392250896,
0.674253583,
0.4807330966,
0.5283574462,
0.6632771492,
-0.2409991771,
0.036071144,
-0.758867979,
-0.514030993,
-0.3968918324,
-0.5615931153,
-0.4683700204,
-0.5287031531,
0.2374905795,
0.2746451795,
-0.2082298845,
0.2159459889,
-0.7950800657,
0.7291464806,
0.6375573277,
0.3331479132,
0.7433319092,
0.2590219975,
0.0636445582,
-0.0541966483,
-0.5507419705,
-1.0026283264,
1.2298486233,
0.2478585988,
0.9565854669,
0.1926921606,
1.1689587831,
0.239438504,
0.4888928831,
-0.8372599483,
0.6210089922,
-0.0950366408,
-0.7397236824,
-0.3705251515,
-0.2382142395,
-0.8842070699,
0.1968681663,
-0.3563754857,
-0.5853682756,
0.1099417359,
0.0197405647,
-0.0609414242,
0.3053751588,
-0.5416771173,
0.3290772736,
0.0982233211,
-0.2186421454,
0.0567430444,
-0.5517210364,
0.3549032211,
-0.4270570278,
-0.0639231801,
-0.2369264364,
-0.3356539011,
0.6418060064,
-0.0270201508,
0.8459694982,
0.1811997145,
-0.6498125196,
0.6612008214,
0.2401899099,
0.2227971703,
0.0670029595,
-0.2387718856,
-0.1432698071,
-0.0174234733,
-0.4277310967,
-0.3983518481,
0.5256576538,
-1.0545158386,
-0.7832561731,
-0.4611262679,
-0.8702207208,
0.1400815845,
0.4554930329,
0.5270171165,
0.3711292446,
0.0374656245,
0.2104282379,
0.797721982,
-0.2609101832,
0.4822805524,
0.4186731875,
0.2343342155,
-0.3380337656,
1.0980491638,
0.3816385865,
0.5531921387,
0.3830930293,
-0.0839265436,
-0.0139888795,
-0.7946898937,
-0.5262914896,
-0.0651372224,
-0.9832373857,
-0.2575105429,
-0.227558732,
-0.389680773,
-0.1344927549,
-0.5202378035,
0.2146028131,
-0.5324396491,
-0.8626592755,
-0.3640419543,
0.0335645638,
1.3586575985,
-0.2215326875,
0.7410242558,
-0.7462030053,
0.5769316554,
0.1294184327,
0.2422130406,
-0.1302932501,
-0.7438662648,
-0.2000536174,
-0.0088898838,
-0.7147611976,
-0.8418408632,
0.0473639295,
0.2407925874,
0.4650806189,
0.3197221756,
-0.2019293904,
0.2837827802,
-0.4939312637,
0.9975355864,
0.1866544932,
-0.8798533082,
0.8338439465,
-0.5747730732,
0.358546555,
0.4513260424,
0.4335603118,
-0.1878941804,
-0.7161454558,
-0.5814087391,
-0.8621576428,
0.6990602612,
0.2654393911,
0.2450743169,
-0.0853820294,
0.4581133425,
0.4490855634,
0.2212602049,
-0.620241642,
-0.1130878478,
-0.5260518193,
-0.3539058268,
0.0768623278,
-0.5269114375,
-0.0444231965,
0.1585226357,
0.5968304873,
0.1615213901,
-0.2296949178,
0.0617630184,
-0.2078860551,
-0.2609599829,
0.653368175,
0.7589615583,
0.8070268035,
-0.2693542838,
0.2262846828,
0.1088949814,
-1.0370432138,
0.5320160985,
-0.3568318486,
-0.591807425,
-0.1080834493,
0.4295802414,
0.5431504846,
0.0106730871,
-0.4063459039,
0.1891735941,
0.210313499,
-0.4186353683,
0.2342161387,
0.5415192842,
-0.130280152,
0.2899789214,
0.3490122259,
-0.445478797,
-0.0576582514,
-0.4086278379,
0.2058530152,
-0.094251141,
0.2557534277,
-0.0204677563,
0.7600628138,
0.2760913968,
-0.2309079468,
0.7506477833,
-0.1342891306,
0.1789976358,
0.5219011307,
0.9905455709,
0.3386784494,
-0.0786099657,
0.6549798846,
0.4850439727,
0.5319062471,
-0.0110507971,
0.5285633802,
-0.1042340919,
-0.7116516829,
-0.0789235979,
-0.5870246887,
-0.8636752367,
-0.2540280819,
-0.6259518266,
0.0767015293,
-0.7277817726,
-0.1865697354,
-0.1867849827,
0.0953747183,
-0.5695810914,
0.6927788258,
-0.0212382972,
0.6300400496,
-0.7719249725,
0.2489146739,
0.5762302279,
-0.7900830507,
-0.95023036,
-0.1285487115,
0.0104888622,
-0.8093405962,
0.6020841599,
-0.0748925433,
-0.0519634373,
0.1370355785,
-0.457585752,
-0.7184559703,
1.5419324636,
0.2608030736,
-0.6308160424,
-0.2396518588,
0.4679370522,
0.4391672015,
-0.0909715444,
-0.0415804274,
0.5942491293,
0.4191096127,
0.374505192,
-0.3742409647,
-0.0023721543,
-0.1932201684,
-0.1565038264,
0.0191219412,
-0.3937842548,
0.8255887628,
-0.1455573887,
-0.3583281338,
0.0934189186,
0.7177962065,
0.7560836077,
0.4735962152,
0.14283517,
0.6483441591,
0.8683148623,
-0.0677507669,
0.8657282591,
0.0716051459,
0.029504614,
0.9462934136,
0.0466679558,
0.9591372609,
0.3937262595,
-0.092436932,
0.4741244614,
0.852165699,
-0.1359302402,
0.2367851585,
0.2325792313,
-0.670961678,
0.0638318285,
-0.2341884822,
-0.5017727613,
0.1719446331,
0.2303091735,
-0.3165364265,
-0.1163977757,
-0.1141184196,
0.2349341065,
-0.1348431706,
-0.4440181851,
0.5816064477,
0.3116504848,
-0.4018145204,
0.4788294435,
-0.0786937326,
0.5917901397,
-0.2407275587,
-0.123306796,
-0.4082158506,
-0.1870898604,
-0.6026198268,
-1.4536967278,
0.054601483,
0.3405119479,
-0.4169782996,
-0.4272486269,
0.9783807397,
-0.5227203965,
-0.4154427052,
-0.2101651579,
0.7050965428,
0.3896217346,
0.4875300229,
-0.3678375781,
0.0478140973,
-0.0890543461,
-0.6178439856,
0.3405683637,
0.7032334805,
0.2073823363,
0.425113678,
0.6317442656,
0.2615526617,
0.3286145926,
0.2485312968,
0.6922636628,
-0.5315467715,
0.0187197011,
-0.5037564635,
0.6864332557,
0.2489994168,
-0.5791376233,
0.7818797827,
0.4723450243,
0.8108617663,
-0.1681989133,
0.6827885509,
0.1514632404,
0.252322793,
-0.5182801485,
0.6190031767,
-0.5545356274,
0.0887967572,
-0.4264393449,
-1.3513387442,
-0.2457693666,
0.5296812654,
-0.0586523004,
0.0937732384,
0.7869032025,
0.5906193852,
0.1039777845,
-0.2141498327,
0.4026159644,
-0.1050141081,
0.2488451749,
0.6304568052,
0.7968793511,
-0.2903698981,
0.6550379992,
-0.0400713608,
-0.1972237974,
0.0455390699,
-0.858851552,
-1.0363156796,
-0.0726530552,
-0.2400366068,
-0.4628504813,
0.0336443894,
0.3063567281,
0.2631299496,
-0.3988483846,
0.0157437287,
0.0931440219,
0.2899279296,
0.3265303671,
-0.1979978383,
0.177654475,
-0.2411348522,
-0.8582476377,
0.4534858167,
0.3378954232,
0.4783712924,
-0.2540505528,
0.0708270445,
0.1755052805,
0.3449416459,
0.7379629612,
0.1957281679,
-0.4243555963,
-0.3624395728,
0.0743933842,
-0.384137392,
0.1928305179,
0.4273386598,
-0.3576979339,
0.3905300796,
0.8174316883,
0.5419939756,
0.4573499262,
0.1155565828,
0.3211974204,
-0.7835419178,
-0.0158754438,
0.039943479,
0.1573879272,
0.4495824575,
-0.4656530023,
0.6586683393,
0.1190136746,
-0.6720482707,
-0.6679931879,
0.2002052069,
-1.0990847349,
0.1885787994,
1.1475050449,
-0.1195348576,
-0.0371454246,
0.1601768881,
-0.6166263819,
0.5299338102,
-0.2674528658,
0.4770764709,
0.9365355968,
-0.2105190158,
-0.3445704281,
-0.750325799,
0.1757657379,
0.2380249798,
-1.1384942532,
-0.6169077754,
0.5255493522,
0.4099085629,
-0.066431649,
0.6861194968,
-0.1540112644,
0.2589073777,
0.3452148438,
-0.220001623,
-0.1346609443,
-0.4136480093,
-0.008602188,
0.1489890516,
0.0779238194,
0.0468492918
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12784v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12784v1 | UBENCH: Benchmarking Uncertainty in Large Language Models with Multiple Choice Questions | 2024-06-18T16:50:38 | 2024-06-18T16:50:38 | Xunzhi Wang, Zhuowei Zhang, Qiongyu Li, Gaonan Chen, Mengting Hu, Zhiyu li, Bitong Luo, Hang Gao, Zhixin Han, Haotian Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | The rapid development of large language models (LLMs) has shown promising
practical results. However, their low interpretability often leads to errors in
unforeseen circumstances, limiting their utility. Many works have focused on
creating comprehensive evaluation systems, but previous benchmarks have
primarily assessed problem-solving abilities while neglecting the response's
uncertainty, which may result in unreliability. Recent methods for measuring
LLM reliability are resource-intensive and unable to test black-box models. To
address this, we propose UBENCH, a comprehensive benchmark for evaluating LLM
reliability. UBENCH includes 3,978 multiple-choice questions covering
knowledge, language, understanding, and reasoning abilities. Experimental
results show that UBENCH has achieved state-of-the-art performance, while its
single-sampling method significantly saves computational resources compared to
baseline methods that require multiple samplings. Additionally, based on
UBENCH, we evaluate the reliability of 15 popular LLMs, finding GLM4 to be the
most outstanding, closely followed by GPT-4. We also explore the impact of
Chain-of-Thought prompts, role-playing prompts, option order, and temperature
on LLM reliability, analyzing the varying effects on different LLMs. | [
-0.329413414,
-0.85753721,
0.9105125666,
0.3319861889,
-0.1695575714,
0.170815751,
-0.4473421574,
-0.3459208012,
-0.2766637504,
0.3095332086,
-0.1999500245,
-0.1730401814,
-0.3782480359,
-0.0574469827,
-0.3335809708,
0.48853001,
-0.1219385862,
0.3337317705,
-0.380602181,
-0.2383148074,
-0.3798722923,
-0.5709913373,
-0.5778573155,
-0.4809916019,
0.3853841424,
0.2658443153,
0.8015357256,
0.3948138952,
0.4746740758,
0.3234135509,
-0.0168030113,
-0.2120274305,
-0.3226309419,
0.3111425936,
-0.3164277971,
-0.3692178428,
-0.2934215069,
-0.1111594588,
0.7739094496,
0.8130356073,
-0.4614887238,
0.2749814987,
0.0343851112,
0.3537786007,
-0.7394838333,
0.0667520538,
-0.650447309,
-0.1679301113,
-0.4291836619,
0.3479498327,
-0.3750868738,
-0.2358528078,
-0.2116050869,
-0.1806488484,
-0.1529498547,
0.277882427,
0.4588544667,
0.22589311,
-0.3134174347,
0.1602219045,
-0.7969723344,
0.9605408907,
-0.8627197742,
0.5737313032,
0.3909017444,
0.441955775,
-0.5375781059,
-0.6256170869,
-0.4721957743,
-0.4113902152,
0.293081373,
0.1496384293,
-0.1315308958,
0.0211154222,
0.1383399814,
0.1979359984,
-0.5864798427,
0.2392742187,
-0.084356159,
-0.3631320298,
0.4500393867,
0.1442365795,
0.2508703768,
-0.1915609539,
-0.3673784435,
-0.1975679249,
-0.3992963135,
0.0514517166,
0.4247438908,
-0.0414598621,
0.3378895521,
0.5383684039,
-0.2008745074,
0.7091171145,
-0.4573127627,
-0.0798843279,
0.1195202917,
-0.2382161617,
-0.1345860809,
-0.3227354586,
0.9683015943,
0.3006843626,
0.1500188857,
-0.2733276784,
-0.0370199606,
-0.1343875229,
0.1958522946,
-0.5185924768,
-0.1450015008,
0.4442501664,
-0.1469323039,
0.007748602,
0.0240099821,
-0.942486167,
-0.400013715,
0.0762513801,
0.2098985165,
-0.3189430833,
-0.3463878036,
0.079350926,
0.0164087936,
-0.0118228057,
0.2176569104,
-0.6547417045,
0.3149020672,
0.4177626967,
0.516273737,
-0.51089257,
-0.6669219136,
-0.5214388967,
-0.0576871671,
-0.3653950095,
0.9230765104,
-0.5288593769,
-0.4181243777,
-0.1927522421,
-0.1869182289,
0.0981681943,
-0.4446513653,
0.7245925665,
-0.4560826123,
-0.08915665,
-0.4124393165,
-0.5971516371,
0.0113836583,
0.3009017408,
-0.768270731,
1.4458858967,
0.2016729414,
-0.7379351258,
0.1602329612,
-0.2769326568,
-0.0808855146,
0.0585514568,
-0.3811057806,
-0.1935703009,
0.2947256565,
0.0240205545,
0.2420888543,
-0.7150389552,
0.4353770614,
-0.8184504509,
-0.3318772614,
0.7078110576,
-0.9012570381,
0.643053472,
0.0834612325,
-0.3181699216,
0.003697094,
-0.8614533544,
0.5391032696,
0.1436293274,
-0.5022752881,
-0.0952564701,
-0.0180585701,
0.1833626777,
0.2932766974,
0.181431666,
-0.5298090577,
0.0357492231,
0.0252937544,
0.1726125479,
0.7758656144,
-0.0499318689,
0.073649548,
-0.0953420252,
0.682624042,
-0.1975532472,
0.1187800989,
0.3430265486,
-0.4494200349,
-0.7036166787,
0.0470626503,
0.4148796201,
0.4833349288,
-0.5041485429,
0.1491380781,
-0.0505108275,
-0.5168543458,
-0.3431511223,
0.3275601566,
0.46896106,
0.3215005398,
0.4373263121,
-0.4381614923,
-0.3232367039,
-0.8326514959,
-0.3413707018,
-0.3711878657,
-0.0992689654,
0.1841275841,
0.4657284021,
-0.1502579153,
0.8313664198,
-0.3149664104,
0.2648275197,
-0.4012899399,
0.2239421159,
0.1109092906,
0.179012984,
0.2983570695,
-0.3407191336,
-0.235503763,
-0.2943251133,
-0.5431271195,
-0.0341515988,
0.0924829543,
-0.1439230889,
0.3319206834,
0.3266141713,
-0.6046518087,
0.1916133165,
0.8002963662,
-0.0769609138,
0.8215858936,
-0.4182172716,
0.1377609521,
-0.7774312496,
0.2775058448,
-0.2666451335,
0.042889636,
-0.3204650283,
-0.0255188141,
0.1238726228,
0.1101959869,
-0.4751830697,
0.7749282718,
-0.4200894237,
-0.4939088821,
-0.0412219055,
0.1754657924,
-0.1338889599,
0.1451583803,
-0.271472156,
0.7824372649,
0.3540054858,
-0.2827482224,
0.634947598,
-0.0799806863,
-0.6218798161,
0.7093065977,
-0.6384322047,
0.3314835727,
0.2670281529,
0.2762930989,
-1.0629526377,
-0.3262708187,
-0.0732592791,
-0.1219348386,
0.1448491216,
0.1360108554,
-0.6799283028,
-0.6738660932,
-0.1923516542,
0.2795031369,
0.2599612176,
-0.3869416118,
0.5862857103,
0.1711091399,
-0.1801127642,
-0.7664868236,
-0.5700604916,
0.1117565408,
0.0000195956,
-0.3895855546,
-0.1048382819,
-0.4162940979,
-0.4831841886,
0.0167135838,
-0.4802358747,
-0.2116057575,
0.4594320059,
0.1300278008,
0.108147569,
-0.0356290042,
0.2296247482,
-0.3109879792,
-0.1837058216,
0.0384102836,
-0.0393101163,
0.6863276958,
-0.4759823978,
-0.8345062733,
0.1421131194,
0.2660601437,
0.6020091176,
-0.2486142367,
0.4603877068,
0.447006911,
-0.1278633922,
-0.3305712938,
-0.7641420364,
0.0059845271,
-0.4448649883,
0.3705680966,
-0.3155502081,
-0.801890552,
0.6612349153,
-0.1839842796,
0.0025790231,
0.335524261,
0.4187744856,
-0.3479115069,
0.7808525562,
0.4049008787,
-0.2750244141,
0.1051092893,
0.2405643314,
-0.0953324735,
-0.6146730185,
0.086090073,
-0.5871597528,
-0.184670493,
-0.2491570264,
-0.6235385537,
0.336063832,
0.3530898392,
-0.4239946306,
0.032006599,
-0.0816455409,
0.6875601411,
0.6889774203,
-0.2464351356,
0.5755736828,
-0.1681649536,
-0.5471318364,
0.0687238947,
-0.5447511673,
-0.566455245,
1.2852687836,
0.1959374845,
0.8826970458,
0.2425877154,
0.5429241657,
-0.0330436006,
0.3089589775,
-0.2868545353,
0.6180588007,
0.1699485928,
-0.961341083,
-0.667838335,
-0.4640570879,
-0.8852469325,
0.4662620425,
-0.0452255756,
-1.1218788624,
-0.2200382501,
0.0426677316,
-0.4377411902,
0.5250837803,
-0.4235587716,
0.8148238659,
-0.8001376987,
-0.4250944555,
-0.076901637,
-0.6247212887,
0.332149446,
-0.2931300402,
0.273810178,
-0.2280585468,
0.0748836845,
0.4584483504,
-0.0957124308,
0.6180561781,
0.2290645689,
-0.0528194718,
0.2530479431,
0.2368966937,
0.3974024355,
0.1159846634,
-0.510016799,
0.292414993,
0.0511446409,
-0.409214288,
-0.5291106105,
0.7849473953,
-0.751049757,
-0.4579561949,
-0.6070296764,
-0.606310606,
-0.7142161727,
0.3287087679,
0.1977063417,
0.207366854,
-0.546577692,
0.235379681,
0.4334032238,
-0.2438952476,
0.6162683368,
0.6381670237,
-0.3855262995,
-0.4915327728,
0.6467498541,
0.210011974,
0.4747965932,
-0.0436814018,
0.1475910097,
-0.3375102282,
-0.6379063725,
-0.6049054861,
0.0208833311,
-0.8366069198,
-0.138916254,
-0.4350439608,
-0.1565278769,
0.1528842151,
-0.0310002808,
-0.6825612187,
-0.2986832857,
-0.0198857095,
-0.2631602883,
0.2238953859,
0.7734543085,
-0.0578828007,
0.1430372745,
-0.7144808173,
0.1972304881,
0.5366485715,
0.8873520494,
-0.0525751524,
-0.2782422602,
-0.0128859524,
-0.116906397,
-0.3014634252,
-0.7367625237,
-0.1238494515,
-0.039728757,
1.0275585651,
0.1904262453,
0.0782329813,
0.3961676657,
-0.3809369206,
0.7954973578,
0.1647643447,
-0.9507471919,
0.1865272075,
-0.3760385513,
0.3722302318,
0.9563310146,
0.2000834048,
-0.4547764957,
-0.4463879466,
-0.8090302944,
-0.8177450299,
0.386674881,
-0.022487741,
-0.1587192565,
0.0732684433,
0.1140683591,
-0.0293731373,
0.3023892045,
-0.5654096007,
-0.262747556,
-0.0176310837,
-0.0109941671,
-0.3864373565,
-0.3108772337,
-0.0669969767,
-0.1330466717,
0.4939047694,
-0.2289984375,
-0.0573867522,
-0.2169634402,
-0.1687414348,
-0.2423838377,
0.8053258657,
0.4351478219,
0.8669377565,
-0.469733417,
0.3532977104,
0.5525875092,
-0.198259443,
0.4059073925,
0.2220903784,
0.0399020799,
-0.1111210138,
0.2311935425,
0.4877474308,
0.5452318788,
-0.8110864162,
0.2274347097,
-0.1240549982,
0.0588585064,
-0.1610681713,
-0.0412309095,
0.456633687,
0.1390679032,
0.1525817066,
-0.1484007984,
0.0197060537,
-0.684148252,
0.2323929071,
0.4179819226,
-0.3382240534,
0.0263911244,
0.5110030174,
0.0781908259,
-0.0289054736,
0.6594877243,
-0.2150233835,
-0.4023198485,
0.508245945,
0.4898889959,
0.609782517,
-0.4296373129,
0.3496954441,
0.1293345541,
0.4637375772,
-0.563985467,
0.565078795,
0.4012339115,
-0.6825069189,
-0.42475003,
-0.6702156663,
-1.0380917788,
0.2934589386,
-0.5632991791,
-0.2546235323,
-0.3860053122,
-0.3519964218,
-0.34300825,
0.041763667,
-0.6924143434,
0.1156078279,
0.063167274,
0.7799654603,
-0.6941481233,
0.8058415651,
0.6815003157,
-0.372332871,
-0.9454579949,
-0.0899188817,
0.2575072646,
-0.696372211,
0.3171875477,
-0.027255198,
-0.2011783272,
-0.0670238957,
-0.3583321571,
-1.0874321461,
1.1224175692,
0.5676733851,
-0.7453805208,
0.3544435799,
0.2313541919,
0.5065626502,
0.0517189652,
0.6718419194,
0.9408273101,
0.6735563874,
0.0502806455,
-1.1237301826,
0.0630774796,
0.0015100887,
0.1268056035,
0.079109706,
-0.7815019488,
0.8411769867,
-0.3559415042,
-0.0300083403,
0.1469207406,
0.418800801,
0.4701840878,
0.0032565822,
0.5849744081,
0.6645220518,
1.0845971107,
-0.2026252598,
1.1115671396,
-0.2339415848,
0.3798848689,
1.4579073191,
-0.5988010764,
1.155243516,
0.4357742071,
-0.4532641768,
0.3799866438,
0.4587389529,
-0.082184203,
0.0762486309,
0.6213462353,
-0.1356759369,
-0.6507145762,
-0.0967950597,
-0.3232521117,
0.4789847732,
0.1468706876,
0.0623982362,
-0.4683966041,
-0.1649559587,
0.0105222939,
-0.1802790314,
-0.0270776358,
0.4776279628,
0.2395720482,
-0.6420047283,
0.439874351,
-0.1758957654,
0.4300828874,
-0.6753454804,
0.2344035506,
-0.3751274943,
0.3485711515,
0.1420250088,
-0.9584688544,
-0.2023210675,
-0.1076943651,
0.0634404421,
0.0159619953,
0.5998021364,
-0.2892948389,
-0.7306867838,
0.5353963971,
0.9482879043,
0.2174404711,
-0.0735267922,
-0.7443773746,
0.5014387369,
-0.2545260489,
-0.5314229131,
0.5641545653,
0.2468923032,
-0.02542229,
0.9473063946,
0.5459012389,
0.1250650138,
-0.0921231434,
0.2225405723,
0.6494361162,
-0.6939685941,
0.0668060333,
-0.7440466881,
0.4567611814,
-0.1200405136,
-0.4318437278,
0.8763250709,
0.3684449792,
0.7739582062,
0.2180045098,
1.0128887892,
0.130398199,
0.3274088204,
-0.3526111245,
0.6519289613,
-0.4532361329,
0.3031469285,
-0.4184224606,
-1.0403778553,
-0.2977696955,
0.4309622049,
-0.2234739661,
0.2434319407,
0.925596118,
0.4681088626,
-0.0628315285,
-0.0831586868,
0.523009479,
0.1569772065,
0.2766217291,
0.5284665823,
0.9814639091,
-0.1012892947,
0.7554000616,
-0.3447296917,
-0.1957774013,
-0.2167754918,
-1.0583658218,
-0.7318848372,
-0.3003200889,
-0.0830380991,
-0.2368108928,
-0.0671818033,
0.8533818722,
0.5215226412,
-0.8247919679,
-0.4347197711,
0.0822961926,
0.1756852269,
-0.3288045526,
-0.1211825013,
0.390914917,
-0.3842511773,
-0.2812761068,
0.4427728951,
0.2286383361,
0.1005829126,
-0.4327279329,
0.0953431502,
-0.0514991544,
0.1897456646,
0.3370619714,
0.3609843254,
-0.8434274793,
-0.4358353913,
0.0235080887,
-0.0832424909,
-0.1145648807,
0.5171054006,
-0.3133419752,
0.5424756408,
0.2923545837,
0.7020623088,
0.3298827708,
0.0688297004,
0.6822780967,
-0.4034865797,
-0.3064958453,
0.1721295714,
0.6980707049,
0.314868331,
0.1853028089,
0.5759236813,
-0.0393868834,
-0.7813321948,
-0.7292041183,
0.2199329287,
-0.8225345612,
-0.3805341423,
1.3552472591,
-0.2228984237,
0.0047520078,
-0.3823268116,
-0.2030250579,
-0.0710045546,
-0.415571034,
0.6463729739,
1.2535618544,
-0.2081173956,
-0.2108745277,
-0.892142117,
0.1762403101,
0.6010976434,
-0.9962286353,
0.3572652936,
0.6398198605,
0.5321147442,
0.1920022219,
0.7003833652,
0.0660375506,
0.1957147717,
-0.0361573398,
0.220424816,
0.1469508111,
-0.349145025,
-0.239414677,
0.2691529989,
0.5739545822,
0.3026626408
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12779v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12779v1 | Composited-Nested-Learning with Data Augmentation for Nested Named Entity Recognition | 2024-06-18T16:46:18 | 2024-06-18T16:46:18 | Xingming Liao, Nankai Lin, Haowen Li, Lianglun Cheng, Zhuowei Wang, Chong Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Nested Named Entity Recognition (NNER) focuses on addressing overlapped
entity recognition. Compared to Flat Named Entity Recognition (FNER), annotated
resources are scarce in the corpus for NNER. Data augmentation is an effective
approach to address the insufficient annotated corpus. However, there is a
significant lack of exploration in data augmentation methods for NNER. Due to
the presence of nested entities in NNER, existing data augmentation methods
cannot be directly applied to NNER tasks. Therefore, in this work, we focus on
data augmentation for NNER and resort to more expressive structures,
Composited-Nested-Label Classification (CNLC) in which constituents are
combined by nested-word and nested-label, to model nested entities. The dataset
is augmented using the Composited-Nested-Learning (CNL). In addition, we
propose the Confidence Filtering Mechanism (CFM) for a more efficient selection
of generated data. Experimental results demonstrate that this approach results
in improvements in ACE2004 and ACE2005 and alleviates the impact of sample
imbalance. | [
-0.4770391285,
-0.3545203805,
0.063658841,
0.1394805312,
-0.4187935889,
0.696143806,
-0.3545637131,
-0.7453289032,
0.1377706975,
0.2861091793,
-0.4615258873,
-0.6953191757,
-0.4785585999,
0.4190247357,
-0.0334409773,
1.0875397921,
-0.0181941818,
0.174357757,
-0.5253830552,
0.02745267,
-0.3546774387,
-0.5991882086,
-0.7605049014,
-0.4855505228,
0.582377851,
0.3799681962,
0.2291520834,
0.4296783507,
0.34755826,
0.2446939945,
-0.128740266,
0.4884353578,
-0.3873935044,
0.0935809985,
0.1505297273,
-0.6262010336,
-0.5167453289,
-0.2421229184,
0.7507889867,
0.8456645608,
0.0933598652,
-0.3274857104,
0.1455304623,
0.3446269035,
-0.905349493,
0.6227542758,
-0.5770334601,
0.2102174908,
-0.1460020691,
-0.1859105974,
-0.2850956321,
-0.1158040315,
0.1574192643,
-0.7806531191,
0.3491835296,
0.2497652471,
0.577945888,
0.1676204205,
-0.3544853032,
-0.2143822908,
-0.5953646302,
0.9179393053,
-0.5319328904,
0.6726148725,
0.1919104457,
0.0665636286,
-0.3312965035,
-0.629940927,
-0.7763761282,
-0.3424644172,
-0.3970110416,
0.2419019341,
-0.1280134171,
0.1454575956,
0.0678072646,
0.6834928989,
-0.3145966232,
0.4940796793,
-0.1788650155,
-0.1647460908,
0.5481114388,
0.1324463338,
0.1989687383,
-0.0167480614,
-0.6308205724,
-0.3272853494,
-0.4340492189,
-0.0773748457,
0.2038815767,
0.6337785721,
-0.0160580222,
0.4292526245,
-0.3013058305,
0.6155694127,
0.4637574852,
-0.0525426716,
0.4132365584,
-0.2059514225,
-0.3935742974,
0.522601068,
0.4451844394,
0.2279097438,
-0.1148214564,
-0.5706484318,
-0.3714626729,
0.2781560719,
0.052053567,
-0.7756578326,
-0.3629743457,
0.1920883805,
0.0559624434,
-0.4249607027,
0.4442526102,
-0.7483423948,
-0.1930650324,
-0.4735916853,
0.1273349822,
-0.3575037718,
-0.1638485491,
-0.1226149723,
-0.0723446831,
0.2525240779,
0.2667111754,
-0.7112833858,
0.640370965,
0.927444458,
0.6092562079,
-0.533208847,
0.0573175289,
-0.5163568854,
0.0921348706,
-0.290994972,
0.6980257034,
-0.7291196585,
-0.4342985749,
-0.1563230753,
0.0589450896,
-0.2702460885,
-0.7149228454,
0.515504241,
-0.8105846047,
0.4278960824,
0.0530587547,
-0.8645209074,
-0.1553764641,
0.5664265156,
-0.9906713963,
0.984125495,
0.0941414908,
-0.8695541024,
0.6026372313,
-0.4748726487,
-0.5322813988,
0.3815423548,
-0.3807992041,
-0.5653195977,
-0.0760916546,
0.479531765,
0.3214927912,
-0.1595706791,
0.2033498883,
-0.1461780071,
-0.2822158933,
0.1848511398,
-0.2671187222,
0.5751170516,
-0.2190004736,
-0.1355522424,
-0.1280127913,
-0.9839388132,
-0.0718517527,
-0.0934105217,
-0.7590869069,
-0.4781329036,
-0.3555993736,
0.3075123429,
0.0318812467,
0.16889368,
-0.750410378,
0.1419439167,
-0.7823756337,
0.2073659003,
0.3681337833,
0.2971023023,
0.6793949604,
-0.3625125587,
0.3524774611,
0.4894245267,
-0.1316561848,
0.1813229024,
-0.2414133549,
-0.7206178904,
-0.3200111091,
0.9154492021,
0.5110598207,
-0.9614428878,
0.5661929846,
-0.4971272647,
-0.4686470628,
-0.2010765225,
0.0084405253,
0.3363879025,
0.5784283876,
0.7237040997,
-0.4504758418,
-0.847045362,
-0.6183694005,
0.2088306248,
0.0917536393,
-0.0537560619,
0.4456249774,
0.4235834777,
-0.3487722576,
0.7961271405,
-0.4396315813,
-0.4887596071,
0.0542925298,
0.2538127303,
-0.0715010241,
0.6845865846,
0.2491402179,
-1.0948513746,
-0.3741091788,
0.0320334025,
-0.5042110085,
0.2055211663,
-0.0608520322,
-0.0211099852,
0.1029402167,
0.3456369638,
-0.6750157475,
0.2147223502,
0.2303647399,
0.3182190955,
0.4357705712,
0.0301717725,
0.0030129973,
-0.9637272358,
-0.3037300706,
0.0561355427,
-0.0255873688,
-0.5683371425,
0.0271403063,
0.0757383481,
0.1741293669,
-0.2104447633,
0.3854568005,
-0.8349164724,
0.003503683,
-0.4365599453,
0.2196968049,
0.2356666923,
0.348374337,
0.2638870776,
0.6220560074,
0.6425370574,
-0.6756302714,
0.1930886209,
0.3291805685,
-0.1568493843,
0.6831898093,
-0.2204220295,
0.026229484,
-0.2143820226,
0.6388236284,
-0.7988349199,
-0.2757946253,
0.4251502454,
-0.481216073,
0.7108407617,
-0.0926560238,
-0.4326272607,
-0.1671683639,
-0.1970283091,
0.4430674314,
0.0480194576,
-0.9086214304,
0.7887922525,
0.213979736,
0.0970758125,
-0.5496108532,
-0.9295817614,
0.1872541159,
-0.1824834794,
-0.3682003915,
1.1993560791,
0.1410803646,
0.0997608677,
0.3293104768,
-0.3396906257,
-0.3718798161,
-0.2194205523,
0.2965897322,
0.4811324179,
-0.5092958808,
0.3808228672,
0.0286181644,
-0.0841344148,
-0.0279476568,
-0.2219447345,
0.3444255888,
-0.0150616551,
0.0237050112,
-0.259688437,
0.2826651633,
0.3681951463,
-0.2915840447,
1.0226254463,
0.6036646962,
-0.8647712469,
-0.0819940716,
-0.4419952333,
-0.2797924876,
-0.3633223474,
-0.1768075824,
-0.3286158741,
-1.1265690327,
0.3139477074,
-0.1001394689,
-0.0545666665,
0.4901639223,
0.1996573061,
-0.0119772339,
0.6163941622,
0.3902624547,
-0.0490782857,
0.4503808618,
-0.2846505642,
0.3808774352,
-1.33680439,
-0.5597250462,
-0.2710225284,
-0.2007393241,
-0.7649551034,
-0.5346505642,
0.1081513986,
-0.0219020583,
0.1612310559,
0.3655498028,
-0.5179775357,
0.3188602924,
0.4469980001,
0.4636103809,
0.3117570579,
-0.0004757099,
-0.2242754698,
0.0578849725,
-0.6475098133,
-0.1904402524,
0.8498007655,
0.019908078,
0.4972812831,
0.0006583252,
0.7930505872,
0.0625769496,
0.2762681246,
-0.785582602,
0.3163864017,
-0.2246512473,
-0.2908640504,
0.0140878921,
-0.3928678036,
-1.0650322437,
0.2285635024,
-0.6662939191,
-0.5548952222,
0.6803423166,
0.1302493811,
-0.4248732626,
0.1987871975,
-0.4524450898,
0.2876017988,
-0.28479895,
-0.2496589422,
0.0959583819,
-0.5445292592,
0.5000342131,
-0.0793663785,
-0.0904601738,
0.4224264026,
-0.0828043371,
0.5437757969,
-0.3179775178,
0.7437981963,
-0.1157836542,
0.2493603528,
0.2050924748,
-0.4848939776,
0.5619273782,
0.0000015774,
-0.0558679551,
0.0566548854,
-0.4394659996,
-0.1072139591,
-0.8513105512,
0.9319526553,
-0.3130028248,
-0.2224832028,
-0.5696613789,
-0.3576761782,
-0.2066525668,
0.0651043057,
0.1298655421,
0.3942762613,
0.0091922283,
0.6223928332,
0.6124708056,
-0.036076013,
0.1451894492,
0.1269793063,
0.3103722632,
-0.62201792,
0.8061999679,
0.2990282178,
-0.0021495973,
0.8235249519,
-0.029055601,
-0.6263524294,
-0.5051106215,
-0.258038044,
-0.0322525948,
-0.4699866474,
-0.4256541729,
-0.802918613,
-0.4741530716,
-0.5126593113,
0.0711976737,
-0.1250175089,
-0.3894902468,
-0.5999604464,
-0.2820015252,
0.252527833,
0.2155768424,
-0.0432297401,
0.3805481195,
-0.4787199795,
0.2721813321,
0.224988997,
0.3141963482,
0.234701395,
-0.0098067671,
-0.061315883,
-0.0043653948,
-0.0039825803,
-0.7661614418,
0.0638325587,
0.413506031,
0.7837210298,
0.2918407321,
0.3673388064,
0.7146010399,
-0.1940852851,
0.4896474481,
0.0111385826,
-0.5202011466,
0.2503683865,
0.0698269904,
-0.0834875107,
0.5476912856,
0.425385803,
-0.0122875366,
-0.0614433065,
-0.7822196484,
-1.2010512352,
0.2677036822,
0.4034359753,
-0.0327238217,
-0.1141098589,
0.3370096982,
-0.0560042635,
0.4841893017,
-0.5519679189,
-0.2442977726,
-0.0054710107,
-0.222601831,
0.0593961962,
0.0234708153,
0.1174119636,
-0.2667437494,
0.8550772667,
0.0687349141,
0.2123293281,
0.2847070992,
-0.2622203529,
0.0855335072,
0.3604003787,
0.2873806953,
-0.0416763499,
-0.1960826963,
0.1697053611,
0.1907963455,
-0.3407221138,
-0.1267429739,
0.4300753176,
-0.291710943,
-0.0566838123,
0.2888372838,
1.0956082344,
0.7279118896,
-0.3986726701,
0.2746613622,
-0.0038412232,
-0.0877078399,
-0.4033236802,
0.2971074879,
-0.1123881117,
0.2350340933,
0.2857226133,
0.0386551805,
0.2743747532,
-0.3301162124,
0.4793514311,
0.4414337277,
-0.2820948362,
0.151059255,
0.4897983372,
-0.161198318,
-0.2042289823,
0.8305385709,
-0.2531901896,
-0.647814095,
0.5671572685,
0.716894269,
0.6729044318,
-0.0761500672,
0.0365277678,
0.5586377382,
0.1167448759,
0.1708789319,
-0.0193456151,
-0.4331324995,
-0.8613200188,
-0.2926946282,
-0.6365917921,
-0.5709363222,
0.3339222372,
-1.0347007513,
0.1368356794,
-0.4675313234,
-0.043132659,
0.2871617079,
0.1685513854,
-0.7725159526,
0.6825609207,
0.2267059982,
0.8444005251,
-0.7431522608,
0.4069304764,
0.733138144,
-0.4314576089,
-0.8469058871,
0.1187734231,
-0.2530123293,
-0.384927839,
0.4561228156,
0.4313263595,
-0.0031761769,
0.2727475762,
-0.3243513703,
-0.6190823913,
1.1785607338,
-0.0723424405,
-0.5177939534,
0.0515542142,
0.1307130456,
0.6576782465,
-0.7816448808,
0.0556462593,
0.4980027378,
0.6398324966,
0.399918884,
-0.4010313153,
-0.0376438871,
-0.3272370696,
0.0095765293,
0.0609950386,
-0.3743692338,
0.8551548123,
-0.1286215782,
-0.4175885022,
-0.060198836,
0.7452087998,
0.512762785,
0.554602921,
0.6894618869,
0.7205864191,
0.952385664,
-0.1790851802,
0.6965544224,
-0.1474684775,
0.2545292079,
1.5462248325,
-0.2924553454,
0.9745202661,
0.4474014342,
-0.0009841842,
0.84478724,
0.7016992569,
-0.4452343285,
0.4704249203,
0.2309479862,
-0.5893759727,
-0.1688622832,
-0.3850070238,
-0.2450789809,
0.5703245401,
0.6195414066,
-0.2325580567,
-0.2886685431,
0.0777016729,
-0.2997201681,
-0.1220555156,
-0.2537063062,
0.8972458243,
0.0970127434,
-0.4031472206,
0.2204523981,
0.1298481077,
0.6496320367,
0.0831735805,
-0.1973446906,
0.0424812436,
-0.0171493068,
-0.4647232592,
-0.574021101,
0.0490760505,
-0.1563616991,
-0.3371976316,
0.2908931971,
0.8865582347,
-0.6862344742,
-0.5329024792,
0.2847518325,
0.2445630729,
0.0135785723,
-0.3023839295,
-0.4928115904,
-0.1801836491,
-0.4497861564,
0.0702338368,
0.3074165285,
0.1666212827,
-0.1877447665,
0.3757695258,
0.9324240685,
0.0524201542,
0.3215634823,
0.0751025155,
1.0781950951,
-0.2692193091,
-0.7123680711,
-0.4980175793,
0.4730967283,
-0.2603947222,
0.0952041671,
0.558737278,
0.8777000308,
1.1262062788,
-0.1527799368,
0.6785804629,
-0.0229646433,
0.3951480091,
-0.5904209614,
0.2233727127,
-0.473613292,
0.1637232006,
-0.0745996311,
-0.9242039323,
-0.6802538633,
0.6298232079,
-0.3860040605,
0.19607611,
0.3728297055,
0.6995347738,
-0.2424039543,
0.1592003405,
-0.0029349313,
0.0503538772,
0.0152009614,
0.5794867873,
0.6703172326,
-0.7208542228,
0.2462875992,
-0.5733433962,
-0.059982799,
-0.3355627954,
-0.8515614867,
-0.7049081326,
-0.4704936445,
-0.6299856305,
-0.0544893555,
-0.0398395173,
0.86735636,
0.8031157255,
-1.0514291525,
0.4226225317,
-0.490447253,
0.0597634427,
-0.2004460096,
-0.3303833902,
0.4381666183,
-0.0819165036,
-0.8470004797,
0.5672426224,
0.1619163156,
0.2684576511,
-0.0781340152,
-0.014639738,
-0.2086281925,
-0.263366282,
0.4582565427,
0.2975414395,
-0.635974586,
-0.1260069907,
-0.0277971048,
0.0419315398,
0.3580052555,
0.5766596794,
-0.9452661276,
0.4316538274,
0.1972984076,
0.995871067,
0.4522316158,
0.4266714156,
0.1618896276,
-0.9921138883,
-0.1784950495,
0.3395628035,
0.1931968033,
0.6379778981,
-0.7640583515,
0.2860285044,
0.3282504976,
-0.2473406047,
-0.770093739,
-0.1277847141,
-1.2661123276,
0.181100443,
0.7230728865,
-0.1027895063,
-0.145107761,
-0.1611470431,
0.0233564507,
0.5602169037,
-0.3917382061,
0.5861971378,
0.5196130276,
-0.3124602437,
-0.5267338753,
-0.0634842813,
0.2121496946,
0.0032994237,
-0.8320233226,
-0.3490172029,
0.4817122519,
0.2299405038,
0.3017629087,
0.2704055309,
-0.0456877835,
-0.0466332063,
0.0933619365,
-0.1386771798,
-0.2405328602,
-0.5545091629,
-0.1413265616,
0.3591319025,
-0.1829861552,
-0.5200423598
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12775v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12775v1 | Hopping Too Late: Exploring the Limitations of Large Language Models on Multi-Hop Queries | 2024-06-18T16:44:13 | 2024-06-18T16:44:13 | Eden Biran, Daniela Gottesman, Sohee Yang, Mor Geva, Amir Globerson | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) can solve complex multi-step problems, but
little is known about how these computations are implemented internally.
Motivated by this, we study how LLMs answer multi-hop queries such as "The
spouse of the performer of Imagine is". These queries require two information
extraction steps: a latent one for resolving the first hop ("the performer of
Imagine") into the bridge entity (John Lennon), and one for resolving the
second hop ("the spouse of John Lennon") into the target entity (Yoko Ono).
Understanding how the latent step is computed internally is key to
understanding the overall computation. By carefully analyzing the internal
computations of transformer-based LLMs, we discover that the bridge entity is
resolved in the early layers of the model. Then, only after this resolution,
the two-hop query is solved in the later layers. Because the second hop
commences in later layers, there could be cases where these layers no longer
encode the necessary knowledge for correctly predicting the answer. Motivated
by this, we propose a novel "back-patching" analysis method whereby a hidden
representation from a later layer is patched back to an earlier layer. We find
that in up to 57% of previously incorrect cases there exists a back-patch that
results in the correct generation of the answer, showing that the later layers
indeed sometimes lack the needed functionality. Overall our methods and
findings open further opportunities for understanding and improving latent
reasoning in transformer-based LLMs. | [
-0.4505207241,
-0.8529507518,
0.933884263,
0.5257951617,
0.0777427927,
0.4492661357,
-0.0055363905,
-0.632242322,
0.2215741724,
0.7259854674,
-0.9319960475,
-0.0504340306,
-0.6062455177,
-0.2133720368,
-0.1053932235,
0.7006527185,
-0.0550922751,
-0.2218435854,
-0.1356334984,
0.0921217576,
-0.5467602611,
-0.2968176901,
-0.7919668555,
-0.2915482223,
0.490965873,
0.3865967691,
0.6515004635,
0.2536944747,
0.5553135872,
0.2162403911,
-0.4260247946,
0.0704517215,
-0.5357195735,
0.242073819,
0.0743274763,
-0.8273476958,
-0.5570117235,
0.1605166346,
0.694540441,
0.9420973063,
0.3016555011,
0.1211415231,
-0.0943702683,
0.7225466371,
-0.5172269344,
-0.0090618636,
-0.8239361048,
0.1197533682,
-0.4765734971,
-0.3106285334,
-0.5422774553,
-0.0857869834,
-0.2043174654,
-0.3546866179,
-0.0637467429,
0.0509568229,
0.6031113863,
0.4396748245,
-0.5282940865,
-0.2838727534,
-1.1060897112,
0.6685553193,
-0.5711685419,
0.5289438963,
0.3750261366,
0.4434279203,
-0.6151491404,
-0.454888165,
-0.6663856506,
-0.2712147236,
-0.189730987,
0.0212193727,
-0.2413864434,
-0.1884580404,
0.5911723971,
0.3905477226,
-0.5010669827,
0.201811254,
-0.2189491242,
-0.0815481618,
0.4568116069,
0.0701649562,
0.2851770818,
-0.0551184043,
-0.3268393576,
0.087674506,
-0.8338287473,
0.3132205904,
0.4427391887,
0.1594120413,
-0.0807856843,
0.6279002428,
0.1887455881,
0.7116735578,
0.0910096094,
-0.1703501344,
0.1877627671,
0.0314478613,
0.1489568353,
-0.3176138401,
0.7496910095,
-0.055892691,
0.1292888373,
-0.3655400276,
-0.3639807999,
-0.2412547469,
0.1047982797,
-0.4479401708,
-0.0985137671,
0.4562800527,
-0.3938423395,
-0.177349478,
-0.1443714201,
-0.7805726528,
-0.2180120349,
0.146170035,
0.5769011378,
-0.1599066854,
-0.4098822474,
-0.1525764167,
0.0098998453,
0.0999271348,
0.1743605584,
-0.4443181753,
0.2530376315,
0.8181564212,
0.9336827993,
0.0214283094,
-0.4510473907,
-0.7814266086,
0.1733173728,
-0.562043786,
0.6931462288,
-0.6294637918,
-0.3840689063,
-0.393651098,
0.1091790572,
-0.0563749336,
-0.3522604108,
0.4851377606,
-1.0637311935,
0.2656115592,
-0.1991556287,
-0.4961046576,
0.0115172295,
0.2524048388,
-0.9788361788,
0.9173298478,
0.0107110916,
-0.8132959604,
-0.1030230746,
-0.6755574942,
-0.3295610845,
-0.1337170154,
-0.2419005334,
-0.6300742626,
0.2955525219,
0.2954931259,
0.3021446764,
-0.2058214992,
-0.0225790087,
-0.2883771062,
-0.5359897614,
0.3639558852,
-0.2319351733,
0.9446025491,
0.0255499296,
-0.2054824531,
-0.2714650333,
-0.7824610472,
-0.0905625075,
0.5282325745,
-0.4318034053,
-0.2818917036,
0.0370797999,
-0.2759777904,
0.3304741681,
0.0833827779,
-0.8306876421,
0.3966805637,
-0.4996366501,
0.3481086493,
0.6605275273,
0.0446431339,
0.4602670372,
-0.3202408552,
0.7490627766,
0.0642134026,
0.1062001735,
-0.718144834,
-0.8067957163,
-0.5227089524,
0.175215736,
0.0391554199,
0.5404149294,
-0.6101142168,
-0.0050227614,
-0.371075809,
-0.5618407726,
-0.43305704,
-0.1333309114,
0.3565618992,
0.3419240713,
0.46384269,
0.12067388,
-0.4877267778,
-0.7356393337,
-0.5877168179,
-0.4352684617,
0.1023380756,
0.3975989223,
0.4129788876,
-0.2277300805,
0.8868198395,
-0.6727201939,
-0.2855269015,
0.0497884192,
0.0070630996,
0.6687155962,
0.5897955298,
0.3685544431,
-0.7618798614,
-0.3573883772,
-0.0776183233,
-0.4989844859,
-0.079146795,
-0.3654851615,
-0.0255816262,
-0.061478924,
0.720764637,
-0.7414491177,
0.2698429525,
0.7554554343,
-0.1220807359,
0.5510847569,
0.0034498838,
0.0289283451,
-0.8412060142,
-0.0713906884,
-0.4392355084,
-0.1638534218,
-0.4686276913,
0.1219039038,
0.1862777621,
-0.1082983389,
-0.0839937851,
0.3931673169,
-0.7618748546,
-0.3276114464,
-0.3550634086,
-0.0560986586,
0.0673990771,
0.4167549908,
-0.2620821893,
0.697945714,
0.4542115629,
-0.3461656272,
0.3731022477,
0.1327272803,
0.0747044086,
0.4265178442,
-0.5102128386,
0.6877285838,
-0.2933123112,
0.4706175029,
-1.2627096176,
-0.0720088631,
0.2324477583,
-0.6009501815,
0.5343726873,
-0.8418649435,
-0.3131819069,
-0.6835488677,
-0.0842771009,
0.6497293711,
0.2945871651,
-0.6037607789,
1.0043244362,
0.4344468415,
-0.0438882783,
-0.567309916,
-0.7199227214,
0.3603401184,
-0.130651474,
-0.9199172258,
0.5152558088,
-0.2229459584,
-0.1979129463,
0.1104369462,
-0.1070806608,
-0.0538518205,
0.0998887047,
0.1733267009,
0.2540084422,
-0.3708351254,
0.0607298575,
-0.0108800689,
-0.3446238935,
0.3209240437,
-0.4201489091,
0.5522980094,
-0.021723913,
-0.6942383051,
-0.0514484644,
0.6343255639,
0.7696685791,
-0.2544664145,
0.6492151022,
0.6028410196,
-0.4798921645,
-0.2237897664,
-0.7773602605,
0.0119680557,
-0.4355991781,
0.2010261267,
-0.8549636006,
-0.7558447123,
0.7947909236,
-0.2202949673,
0.2002961338,
0.5158509612,
0.2813532948,
-0.3149264455,
0.7396906614,
0.7685992122,
0.1424577981,
0.2569137812,
-0.2651462853,
0.2417043149,
-1.0731645823,
-0.5100741386,
-0.523663342,
-0.4144077897,
-0.7635493279,
-0.6164870262,
0.6261820197,
0.2832661569,
0.0643884614,
0.3314607739,
-0.0238986034,
0.6593312025,
0.3844887614,
0.0918548107,
0.4519968629,
-0.2541925907,
-0.2261938751,
-0.0296114367,
-0.4805155396,
-0.1152396053,
1.0503489971,
0.4076078832,
0.9067639112,
0.35291484,
0.7115863562,
-0.131264329,
0.0048983959,
-0.8443438411,
0.3861686587,
0.1054267436,
-0.7087234259,
-0.2918926775,
-0.6276254058,
-0.9237249494,
0.2353611141,
-0.0283754393,
-0.8656214476,
0.1854450405,
0.0990123451,
-0.325188905,
0.6559016705,
-0.5786156058,
0.5857986212,
-0.3509001434,
-0.2272292972,
0.0762827992,
-0.8825220466,
0.4704275727,
-0.3547069132,
0.522195518,
0.0945581198,
-0.0217843093,
0.7220484018,
-0.3763806522,
0.6180654764,
-0.1131810695,
-0.3023339808,
0.086715892,
0.3906369209,
0.8694847822,
-0.0694990158,
0.1535725296,
0.0437512249,
-0.1080445945,
-0.3811192811,
-0.7435922623,
0.7775554061,
-0.6081612706,
-0.6327186227,
-0.3537793756,
-0.3427150846,
-0.5487008095,
0.0972783044,
0.2912440598,
0.1079418585,
0.1340145767,
-0.0917107165,
0.6113105416,
-0.3870059252,
0.7061795592,
0.5251278281,
-0.521094203,
-0.1464690417,
0.5733029246,
0.3047848344,
0.1494020969,
0.4717946947,
0.3620119393,
-0.2352759838,
-0.4269367456,
-0.4059147239,
0.5684460402,
-0.687789619,
0.0132256886,
-1.0408439636,
-0.3538452983,
-0.1959032565,
0.2167854607,
-0.6831421852,
-0.3168527782,
-0.1216274127,
0.1906247288,
0.1019172668,
0.8766561151,
-0.1502029002,
0.4327971935,
-0.9995000958,
0.3964924514,
0.3205243945,
0.6426548362,
0.2453043461,
-0.607634306,
-0.3256731927,
-0.2817915678,
-0.1949276179,
-1.2943979502,
-0.0664161593,
0.1024001315,
0.6775695682,
0.0596501194,
-0.2280809581,
0.7669539452,
-0.7230938673,
0.7595999837,
0.0483778007,
-0.8207043409,
0.811098814,
-0.2178633511,
0.0378311239,
0.0729972124,
0.433786869,
-0.6334166527,
-0.2531279922,
-0.7795895934,
-0.991173625,
0.8148813248,
0.3414070606,
0.0824378654,
0.3368548453,
0.3690174222,
0.061189007,
-0.0514031388,
-0.9281939864,
-0.3634191453,
0.2194406092,
0.5348956585,
-0.1243096665,
-0.353934139,
0.0682379305,
0.122889787,
0.60311234,
0.0419917144,
0.3367028832,
0.0068958495,
-0.1257326752,
-0.5929583907,
0.276201576,
0.2772094011,
0.583530426,
-0.3248638809,
0.2122179121,
-0.0365148485,
-0.3669624627,
0.0020190978,
0.0528050438,
-0.0941332579,
0.099805221,
0.6659123302,
0.7695773244,
-0.0382434651,
-0.3987106383,
0.6869137287,
-0.0461699031,
0.3467175663,
-0.451684922,
-0.1198269203,
0.2635613084,
0.5172007084,
0.6559278369,
0.2992283404,
-0.1436377764,
-0.4908187091,
0.1902892143,
0.4658176303,
-0.3274385929,
-0.4020641744,
0.7214164138,
-0.3278024793,
-0.6829262376,
0.5227555633,
-0.0055896086,
-0.6637260914,
0.4214182496,
0.7232115865,
0.8387579322,
-0.2722866833,
-0.0609993972,
0.2449831218,
0.5276110768,
0.1214251667,
0.3340817392,
0.0015495215,
-0.6216371059,
-0.8768242598,
-0.5853466988,
-0.2790208161,
0.3711975217,
-0.4913997352,
0.103840895,
-0.0926490128,
-0.2143770605,
-0.0921540931,
-0.1265057474,
-0.7431936264,
0.0619732253,
0.1170923039,
0.7267759442,
-0.95550704,
0.4805298746,
0.6290860176,
-0.3284774423,
-0.966825068,
0.4134306312,
-0.0604544878,
-0.8224595189,
0.5968695879,
-0.0985851362,
-0.2385076284,
0.072393693,
-0.4496958554,
-1.0131306648,
0.7169272304,
0.3001776934,
-0.6609939337,
-0.2544852495,
0.0601386316,
0.3274076581,
-0.1631736755,
0.4628822803,
0.5033969283,
0.4465454817,
0.4750087857,
-1.0076115131,
0.0364823863,
-0.1548481882,
-0.1229818761,
0.3033106327,
-0.6021904945,
1.1874500513,
-0.5581339598,
-0.0440798998,
-0.0925987288,
0.3979330361,
0.1793073565,
0.308234483,
0.7569819689,
0.6765317321,
0.6953346729,
-0.0597250797,
1.0438871384,
-0.0477693416,
0.4579217434,
1.2131071091,
0.0838626772,
0.8684258461,
0.5942292809,
-0.5933731198,
0.3287286758,
0.6502830386,
0.2050739527,
0.2399082333,
0.186778754,
0.0504233763,
-0.1925189197,
0.325602591,
-0.5647178292,
0.6335722208,
0.3452422917,
-0.2714308202,
-0.1447116733,
-0.0350655206,
0.1232717931,
-0.3147408962,
-0.1742811054,
0.7482131124,
0.2341033071,
-0.7022446394,
0.3933344185,
-0.0376309343,
0.38284114,
-0.2977021337,
-0.0295733251,
-0.3769591451,
-0.1185028404,
-0.362225771,
-1.0193842649,
0.4652220607,
0.010411744,
-0.0887420997,
-0.0042855544,
0.4888452291,
-0.3064716756,
-0.5634968281,
0.6029062271,
0.9253586531,
0.3581132889,
-0.3431058526,
-0.4774162471,
0.2213817984,
-0.1617810726,
-0.3889410496,
-0.0176657848,
0.7464683652,
0.0279431157,
0.6775357723,
0.8140140772,
0.4725153446,
0.4178638756,
0.1334910989,
1.1280226707,
-0.7842962146,
-0.7181249857,
-1.0052536726,
0.5585859418,
0.2619563937,
0.0109308595,
0.5866317749,
0.5425536036,
0.7577614188,
0.1189729869,
0.5152352452,
0.2170765847,
0.6590480804,
-0.6924604774,
0.5036057234,
-0.8432530165,
0.8000666499,
-0.6055909395,
-0.9906874299,
-0.2623236179,
0.2629246712,
-0.3365870416,
0.1270611137,
0.6763341427,
0.7212498188,
-0.1942402869,
-0.0580877997,
0.3976115882,
0.5836498737,
0.5271218419,
0.7585566044,
1.3233339787,
-0.6155948043,
0.6769477129,
-0.1723928899,
-0.2824459076,
-0.1198037341,
-0.8982584476,
-0.6798482537,
-0.5612050295,
-0.1422766149,
-0.5975400209,
-0.1792860925,
0.6226656437,
0.6331863999,
-0.5826316476,
-0.0668952838,
0.124575153,
0.2856794596,
-0.1146511808,
-0.1555172801,
0.4525392354,
-0.3181615174,
-0.4999979734,
0.7443959713,
0.3369266391,
0.0877063349,
-0.4306288064,
0.1134866774,
-0.0844484866,
-0.1228167489,
0.4520162046,
0.1137966886,
-0.7382747531,
-0.1010312736,
0.1529750377,
0.1551277936,
0.3437337279,
1.0062556267,
-0.8845284581,
0.4774865508,
0.3016025722,
0.7506839633,
0.7870172858,
-0.1859765947,
0.2584571838,
-0.8024218082,
-0.1101196408,
0.4590812027,
0.2350680977,
0.2542349994,
-0.5731014013,
0.2994972765,
0.4179907441,
-0.5767727494,
-0.7824239731,
0.5678963065,
-0.9935324788,
-0.3095743358,
0.9334168434,
-0.1965609789,
-0.2195154428,
-0.2378656417,
-0.0437625237,
0.1367296427,
-0.0699656606,
0.6144618988,
0.4957838356,
-0.3304413259,
-0.3302733004,
-0.5338892341,
0.2264083326,
0.1640385389,
-0.4611458778,
-0.0912016407,
0.3049368858,
0.2841946483,
0.4408706129,
0.889711678,
-0.1135624275,
-0.1218246147,
0.0768555626,
-0.5230959654,
-0.0334637202,
-0.5360875726,
-0.1823362261,
0.3729493916,
0.1366360486,
-0.22580944
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12770v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12770v2 | Informatics & dairy industry coalition: AI trends and present challenges | 2024-06-18T16:39:21 | 2024-06-19T11:49:03 | Silvia García-Méndez, Francisco de Arriba-Pérez, María del Carmen Somoza-López | cs.AI | cs.AI, cs.CL | Artificial Intelligence (AI) can potentially transform the industry,
enhancing the production process and minimizing manual, repetitive tasks.
Accordingly, the synergy between high-performance computing and powerful
mathematical models enables the application of sophisticated data analysis
procedures like Machine Learning. However, challenges exist regarding
effective, efficient, and flexible processing to generate valuable knowledge.
Consequently, this work comprehensively describes industrial challenges where
AI can be exploited, focusing on the dairy industry. The conclusions presented
can help researchers apply novel approaches for cattle monitoring and farmers
by proposing advanced technological solutions to their needs. | [
-0.2390540838,
-0.6871712208,
0.2931370139,
-0.1100316867,
0.185153082,
-0.0426885597,
0.2918942571,
-1.1121965647,
-0.0874698609,
0.5125900507,
-1.0424218178,
-0.3027247488,
-0.8397393227,
0.3990011513,
-0.615131557,
0.7463873625,
-0.1251197159,
-0.0145081207,
-0.4394178987,
-0.3016565442,
-0.4025192261,
-0.6273471713,
-0.6295794249,
-0.2090615034,
0.2999201119,
0.4241679609,
0.6987564564,
0.6697177291,
0.8055183291,
0.5826349854,
0.3129456639,
0.1050515845,
-0.1800601482,
0.3445149362,
0.2156620175,
-0.5156737566,
-0.2767919004,
0.3025716245,
0.2758398652,
1.1232442856,
0.0776539445,
0.3589673042,
-0.3274505138,
0.8660396934,
-0.6061208844,
0.6012399793,
-0.4402242303,
0.3482444584,
-0.3959134817,
-0.1129326746,
0.0305406377,
-0.550250411,
0.1854472607,
-0.6069799662,
-0.034902554,
0.0710847527,
0.6615371108,
0.9055456519,
-0.3437086344,
-0.3956522346,
-0.8714759946,
0.7338701487,
-0.2755685151,
0.0456633307,
0.4003649652,
0.50184834,
-0.3032515347,
-0.9438456893,
-0.3715941608,
0.1033428833,
0.1518064886,
0.051283367,
-0.7027504444,
-0.310192287,
0.1515018493,
0.2262158692,
-0.1070324853,
0.5253739357,
-0.5143036246,
-0.2732983232,
0.5875043273,
0.5310214758,
0.2853405774,
0.7392174602,
-0.1335882694,
-0.2952764034,
-0.3461334109,
0.4830907881,
0.716388464,
-0.1085221693,
0.3072310686,
0.2978749871,
-0.6694046855,
0.5250782967,
-0.111450471,
0.1895421594,
0.3140279353,
-0.3525285423,
-0.1798705757,
0.0563803464,
0.5334531069,
0.2073337734,
-0.2327532321,
0.1727490872,
-0.1515951157,
0.5195109248,
0.1486397684,
-0.4983075261,
-0.2466659397,
0.4627948999,
-0.4018438458,
-0.4687037468,
0.2195987254,
-0.6344002485,
-0.5347041488,
-0.1837730557,
0.1378736049,
-0.0654365569,
-0.2671019733,
0.1679212898,
-0.6290971637,
0.4394333363,
0.3760007322,
-0.8106042743,
0.2108590603,
0.8167163134,
0.4120979607,
-0.1900334805,
0.0568989217,
-0.617038846,
0.2994114161,
-0.2588754594,
0.9280172586,
-0.5059165955,
-0.1909116358,
-0.2071382999,
0.110086605,
-0.097322315,
-1.0745102167,
0.0484839827,
-0.3875294924,
-0.1509064287,
-0.1023545861,
-0.1975333244,
-0.5533756018,
0.4650332034,
-0.963973701,
0.7035915256,
0.3225792646,
-0.5347493291,
0.5408308506,
-0.8069788814,
-0.5917876959,
0.0488115624,
-0.1493600756,
-0.8086604476,
-0.224123612,
-0.0680868402,
0.221743837,
-0.5042399764,
0.1464148164,
-0.4406060576,
0.2056607157,
0.7126740217,
-0.4593068659,
0.5164912939,
0.1757415533,
-0.3849085867,
0.4780608714,
-0.8350473046,
-0.1443108767,
-0.1173234507,
-0.0064456691,
0.1973434538,
0.0203980487,
-0.0118421093,
0.0013148217,
0.257537663,
-0.2390256971,
-0.1107165217,
-0.1003981978,
0.6145432591,
0.6242667437,
-0.0134319654,
0.0555353761,
-0.7554625273,
0.405839771,
0.3313757181,
0.299292922,
0.1649829298,
-0.4160321653,
-0.6253517866,
0.0918995962,
0.405582875,
0.8281438351,
-0.4148048759,
0.170323208,
0.2591819763,
-0.5123826265,
-0.7942028642,
-0.0630650148,
-0.2201392502,
0.7320246696,
0.1551110446,
-0.5743955374,
-0.5126753449,
-0.8459736705,
-0.0088902162,
-0.0544310473,
0.1232193261,
-0.0529725105,
0.3067830503,
-0.3696807325,
0.7087967992,
-0.3639123738,
-0.2719485462,
-0.0850311443,
0.4346809387,
0.5551036,
0.6133497953,
0.3948662281,
-1.1743847132,
-0.2847748697,
0.4170131981,
-1.1165800095,
-0.0868640468,
0.262601316,
0.2625355124,
0.3823946416,
0.4262570441,
-0.5787526965,
0.8022463322,
0.0742024928,
-0.2149278224,
0.9144659638,
-0.0772282854,
0.3601160944,
-0.3244562447,
0.0601028055,
0.2205000669,
0.0099698212,
-0.6848541498,
-0.5082222223,
-0.5860823393,
-0.1946166158,
-0.2592548728,
0.1824850291,
-0.1303595752,
-0.3070721328,
-0.3398095369,
-0.4430201948,
-0.2348359525,
0.0013893625,
-0.0233648662,
0.585979104,
0.7628154159,
-0.8247482181,
0.9528729916,
0.2120352387,
-0.3913458288,
0.6708801389,
-0.4256309569,
-0.2038808316,
-0.1211470738,
0.2079838514,
-0.7028082013,
-0.5942380428,
0.6311530471,
-0.4512161016,
0.3407532573,
0.4507544041,
-0.4505960941,
-0.616484642,
-0.2239127755,
0.275480777,
0.4758641124,
0.0003406812,
0.6632953882,
0.6206814647,
-0.2945806384,
-0.616894424,
-0.7015759945,
0.0274096597,
-0.5513058901,
-0.6782342196,
0.1453862935,
-0.1506341547,
-0.7716245055,
0.300147593,
-0.2604516745,
-0.1996666491,
0.3406743407,
0.2128065974,
-0.0713112727,
-0.2632054687,
-0.0293460041,
0.1188982874,
-0.6379252672,
0.3397510052,
-0.4728678763,
0.1436697096,
0.0458954945,
-0.251339823,
-1.3164806366,
0.6847600341,
0.6975077987,
-0.0617379434,
0.4447579086,
0.8969341516,
-0.4614448547,
0.0222104061,
-0.2113238126,
-0.2290797085,
-0.5908012986,
0.4344212413,
-0.2776425481,
-0.435646832,
0.3966907263,
-0.7690983415,
-0.0842669979,
0.6474726796,
0.4214865565,
-0.4703690708,
1.1577669382,
0.8347449899,
-0.3414877057,
0.1056562886,
-0.373470068,
0.1056115925,
-0.101027444,
-0.5692917109,
-0.9033694267,
-0.5659183264,
-0.6024334431,
0.2125896513,
0.6296693683,
-0.3093354702,
-0.3570907116,
0.0387961082,
-0.6123950481,
0.0086870138,
0.9632520676,
-0.1346510053,
0.3315799236,
-0.2592855096,
0.5432004333,
0.3802486956,
-0.8865132928,
-0.2718129754,
0.4995492399,
0.1307488978,
0.7368910313,
-0.0764119551,
0.1371178031,
0.7085584402,
0.1515734047,
-0.7712890506,
0.1587871313,
-0.02567943,
-0.2580594718,
-0.35616225,
-0.2358653098,
-1.1390397549,
-0.4696299732,
-0.2293911725,
-0.7481432557,
0.1910714656,
0.0017234626,
0.0202925373,
0.3401847184,
-0.7692186832,
0.7904168963,
-0.3179790974,
-0.2328931689,
-0.0924812704,
-0.7016063929,
-0.2268475443,
-0.0808765143,
0.4937488735,
-0.4175632298,
0.0064106961,
0.7865533233,
-0.6519331932,
1.2310202122,
0.0600320026,
0.1906625628,
0.6054233909,
-0.1577620804,
0.228823036,
-0.1133655533,
-0.388777405,
0.2147440165,
0.1859572977,
-0.3934693336,
-0.2569794953,
0.3114963174,
-0.8669772744,
-0.7775833607,
-0.7463161945,
-0.7263061404,
-0.3774980903,
0.0243865177,
0.1562348604,
0.0492153466,
0.023978306,
0.1101319566,
0.2707862854,
0.1477474868,
0.5792286992,
0.115201883,
0.4476351738,
-0.2976136804,
0.8409066796,
0.3216877282,
-0.2961060703,
0.1549473703,
0.0605110154,
-0.2456772923,
-0.6906192303,
-0.5370791554,
-0.2974846065,
-0.6167162657,
-0.521428287,
-0.4547480941,
-0.2072362155,
-0.3028963506,
-0.0152067263,
-0.1149074584,
-0.4011467695,
-0.6830605268,
-0.121885106,
0.339130044,
1.0771936178,
-0.2262163609,
0.3433592021,
-0.5273641944,
0.1071763635,
0.4023291469,
0.3435701132,
-0.1645888984,
0.4956490695,
-0.099940367,
0.0531723537,
-0.6086513996,
-0.8010351658,
0.2679760158,
-0.0751913488,
0.6386957169,
0.5032083988,
0.1230393648,
0.2527887821,
-0.0208936892,
0.6014188528,
0.2640673518,
-0.7384806871,
0.5769200325,
-0.1976149678,
0.2365110815,
0.320838511,
0.6959642768,
-0.2264931053,
-0.0140298801,
-0.4971124828,
-0.8912708163,
0.6126706004,
0.067203775,
-0.2730772495,
0.2494565547,
0.2375419289,
0.7217507958,
0.3544255793,
-0.2622809708,
-0.1953774691,
0.0936266258,
-0.3615379333,
0.4364415407,
0.3281861842,
-0.2380940169,
-0.4796768129,
0.7595207691,
-0.0724239349,
0.1243627667,
-0.082885623,
0.1092828289,
-0.4445115328,
-0.061377909,
0.0980647504,
0.8368318081,
0.1296329498,
-0.1155734062,
0.1572732627,
-0.1805795133,
0.1078514382,
0.3450624347,
-0.204704538,
-0.3294199407,
0.3417921662,
0.777682364,
-0.424360007,
-0.6633347869,
-0.0123964492,
0.1434932649,
-0.4877577126,
-0.5445348024,
0.4929986894,
-0.1376608163,
0.7383744121,
0.7166979313,
0.3802910149,
0.1632189602,
-0.6930289865,
0.2087327391,
0.306748718,
-0.7286592126,
-0.1842448264,
0.7412995696,
-0.0641352609,
-0.3602575958,
0.674290359,
0.1561537236,
-0.3704898655,
1.393279314,
0.6432355642,
0.2545648515,
-0.1321223825,
0.1816785187,
-0.2032895386,
0.0238503683,
0.2215205878,
0.1807675809,
0.2337039709,
-0.6272341609,
-0.1045467705,
-0.4094184339,
-0.8206845522,
0.0808480605,
-0.3863933086,
0.2448404133,
-0.2422261834,
-0.334335953,
0.6573682427,
-0.0734220743,
-0.8304078579,
0.3886780441,
0.0728474706,
0.6043561697,
-0.5021757483,
0.5286248922,
0.8325029612,
-0.2650440037,
-0.2286692858,
-0.4404189587,
-0.0030264002,
-0.7140617967,
0.4912948906,
0.4689874053,
-0.2351524681,
-0.0241610631,
-0.8568889499,
-0.6826360822,
1.0719850063,
-0.0069831279,
-0.1501360387,
0.5212097168,
0.4590214789,
0.3565271497,
-0.5984340906,
0.1147054285,
0.8078399301,
0.9967007041,
0.0790434182,
-0.6963537335,
-0.4017124474,
-0.3984089196,
-0.438062191,
0.2078903019,
-0.7699077725,
0.7191709876,
-0.0060023181,
-0.1337817609,
0.0322453007,
0.8285117745,
-0.0795603618,
1.1211390495,
0.5038271546,
0.3813063502,
1.0417259932,
-0.2728478909,
0.7240607142,
-0.1065691337,
-0.1094439849,
0.2861116827,
-0.415010184,
0.3221867085,
0.4030920565,
-0.356317699,
0.5854873657,
0.9042469859,
-0.2630550861,
0.3489562273,
0.2443582863,
-0.4132455587,
-0.1318742931,
-0.5802415013,
-0.4925941825,
0.8676468134,
0.9552257657,
0.1626211554,
0.0403000265,
0.3507864475,
-0.1778149307,
0.2303424627,
-0.6607378125,
1.0546255112,
-0.1967698932,
-0.4058879614,
-0.0531008244,
0.0441427119,
0.4779448509,
-0.6649264097,
-0.2932963371,
0.2139433026,
0.1911914051,
-0.1077839285,
-0.5534356833,
0.8076999784,
-0.2011632919,
-0.1842746288,
-0.1608524024,
0.8733747602,
-0.0937086567,
-0.449585408,
0.0598879792,
0.6685894132,
0.1258259714,
0.0928452387,
-0.531221807,
0.2622036636,
-0.1984704882,
0.2675200403,
0.2079365849,
0.5651156306,
-0.2589419484,
0.871573329,
0.5442728996,
-0.2969777584,
-0.0725657567,
-0.540871501,
1.0375519991,
-0.8677910566,
-0.5143222213,
-0.5491525531,
0.1815941781,
-0.2269928008,
-0.2143633813,
-0.0099026328,
0.3705496192,
0.8975371122,
-0.1560641527,
1.2888789177,
-0.2402896881,
0.0138565563,
-0.3315223157,
0.6642347574,
-0.3174387217,
-0.0770817548,
0.3006337583,
-0.4715964198,
-0.3593494594,
0.2032229751,
-0.337335825,
-0.0440302789,
0.558249712,
0.2329168171,
0.0418674238,
0.5573508739,
0.0484177135,
0.2466502488,
0.0102975825,
0.4519673884,
0.9101734757,
-0.2752916813,
0.5077465773,
-0.5547865629,
-0.3304589391,
-0.2821926773,
-0.7525295615,
-0.2506913245,
-0.5342795849,
-0.6783810854,
-0.0885053352,
0.059108153,
0.5607894659,
0.68392694,
-1.189571023,
-0.4733006358,
0.1156426743,
0.3074687123,
-0.8259512782,
-0.1822395772,
0.387109071,
-0.3980716467,
-0.8316407204,
0.2916638255,
0.5040305853,
0.0736951381,
-0.041550722,
0.2246026844,
-0.2394122183,
-0.1912359595,
0.3219516873,
0.491191864,
-0.095640257,
-0.2419882566,
-0.0232564267,
0.2041605264,
0.2233614773,
0.6105517149,
-0.864646852,
0.2072355747,
0.3689572215,
1.0247678757,
0.6696408987,
-0.051204484,
0.5519163609,
-0.2469720542,
0.279304564,
0.3383630216,
0.1380802095,
0.3284989595,
-0.693672955,
0.6273968816,
0.6819717884,
-0.3878368139,
-0.362719804,
0.4461680353,
-0.9055706859,
-0.3631158769,
0.3253111541,
0.0865400434,
-0.7328827381,
-0.4101039469,
0.1301796883,
0.5935718417,
-0.1790370196,
0.6913872361,
0.5723202229,
-0.7733861804,
0.1169825122,
-0.7988334298,
0.3711726367,
0.2509448528,
-1.0603016615,
-0.4383172691,
0.4016793966,
0.1037258357,
-0.076222457,
0.334864229,
0.0389462113,
0.2031276524,
0.3443707824,
-0.2687600851,
-0.1688885242,
-0.5201622844,
0.0405503474,
0.5528751612,
-0.1806201339,
-0.2491534203
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12754v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12754v1 | Chumor 1.0: A Truly Funny and Challenging Chinese Humor Understanding Dataset from Ruo Zhi Ba | 2024-06-18T16:22:05 | 2024-06-18T16:22:05 | Ruiqi He, Yushu He, Longju Bai, Jiarui Liu, Zhenjie Sun, Zenghao Tang, He Wang, Hanchen Xia, Naihao Deng | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Existing humor datasets and evaluations predominantly focus on English,
lacking resources for culturally nuanced humor in non-English languages like
Chinese. To address this gap, we construct Chumor, a dataset sourced from Ruo
Zhi Ba (RZB), a Chinese Reddit-like platform dedicated to sharing
intellectually challenging and culturally specific jokes. We annotate
explanations for each joke and evaluate human explanations against two
state-of-the-art LLMs, GPT-4o and ERNIE Bot, through A/B testing by native
Chinese speakers. Our evaluation shows that Chumor is challenging even for SOTA
LLMs, and the human explanations for Chumor jokes are significantly better than
explanations generated by the LLMs. | [
-0.0027440337,
-0.7110546231,
0.1804534644,
0.5308893323,
-0.7412741184,
-0.225938186,
-0.1694910973,
-0.3617395163,
0.1330912262,
0.3590416014,
-0.8902884722,
-0.0849268734,
-0.1798070967,
0.191635862,
0.0266695563,
1.2469418049,
0.3781839311,
0.3912275434,
-0.2027166337,
-0.0760521069,
-0.675227344,
-0.1776038706,
-0.4419058561,
-0.7399964333,
1.0063040257,
0.6793916225,
0.6841916442,
0.5626146197,
0.9167313576,
0.1630401015,
0.1817501187,
-0.0395042971,
-0.5990996957,
-0.1793708205,
-0.2238512933,
-0.4608865678,
-0.1824260503,
-0.5097370744,
0.0940331593,
0.6271526217,
-0.3825885653,
-0.0401795842,
-0.2775306404,
0.8179619908,
-0.1793989092,
-0.0536590032,
-0.5537241697,
0.2940529883,
-0.2157637328,
-0.3116633594,
-0.2213624567,
-0.6090046763,
-0.0006851644,
-0.6262385249,
0.0617141612,
-0.3279888332,
0.9846060872,
0.3194707036,
-0.4825055301,
-0.4055701792,
-0.5895203352,
0.8213112354,
-0.5187843442,
0.1945537776,
0.0856396407,
0.6670790315,
-0.2026847601,
-0.5590473413,
-0.620208919,
0.0173090715,
-0.0723184943,
0.1998471767,
0.0678521469,
-0.4325059056,
-0.1647247225,
0.4735007286,
-0.9503958225,
-0.1328515559,
-0.5552198291,
-0.1231888905,
0.8942810297,
0.3058665097,
0.2606300414,
-0.373800993,
-0.4879036546,
0.0501545221,
-0.4464828372,
-0.0701422989,
0.3362103701,
0.045920901,
-0.2934816778,
0.2098638862,
0.1629428118,
0.5878043175,
-0.2126228362,
-0.2517029941,
0.3323030174,
-0.1222242936,
-0.3151800632,
-0.0654247552,
1.0320254564,
0.439022243,
0.7745085359,
-0.0184810124,
-0.0257743485,
-0.2283378243,
-0.0813439414,
-0.3621888459,
-0.5767704844,
0.1751304865,
-0.4941558838,
-0.3473441303,
0.3685409427,
-0.5314227343,
-0.5564129353,
0.3266734779,
0.3343454003,
-0.5463126302,
-0.0795203969,
0.3572140932,
-0.3950224817,
0.5772247314,
0.4463454485,
-0.5008949041,
-0.227359131,
0.6578222513,
0.5842931867,
0.2612264156,
-0.1373656243,
-0.464066714,
-0.0203426182,
-0.3182593882,
0.8054369688,
-0.4475046992,
-0.2911916375,
-0.1409289986,
0.1640123129,
0.1348095685,
-0.5951135159,
0.8575037122,
-0.4621038735,
0.267292738,
-0.3788990974,
-0.1694072485,
-0.3375411928,
0.1875291318,
-0.4189390838,
0.703571558,
0.2988165617,
-0.8347924352,
0.2471318543,
-0.8244427443,
-0.8334376216,
0.5644138455,
-0.0030809734,
0.0535843,
-0.0465330184,
0.0596714541,
0.1427764595,
-0.2863386869,
0.1890349388,
-0.0121235484,
-0.6202767491,
0.5892652869,
-0.3080545962,
1.2077796459,
0.7855781913,
-0.0488646254,
-0.2541355789,
-0.5314198136,
0.1110253036,
0.6427087188,
-0.228410989,
-0.3415701985,
0.1887826324,
-0.0704769865,
0.2696496844,
0.369589746,
-0.3608278632,
0.006067473,
-0.2618352473,
0.7985877395,
0.5932732224,
-0.1685395539,
-0.2506059706,
-0.4882735014,
0.6689663529,
0.1926763058,
0.2311113626,
-0.7310541272,
-0.4183682799,
-0.8346225023,
-0.3080337942,
0.0694406256,
0.9582485557,
-0.5753988624,
0.4432539344,
-0.5540967584,
-0.5723090768,
-0.6337656379,
0.3449524045,
0.2790842652,
0.528511107,
0.1773074418,
-0.5044612885,
-0.3094057143,
-0.8891226649,
-0.4102266729,
-0.197308287,
-0.5067788363,
0.4078418016,
0.4775792062,
0.012992816,
0.6793122292,
-0.1028848588,
-0.2182484567,
-0.5269466639,
0.026595382,
0.3326308727,
0.2168858647,
0.4389571846,
-0.7650574446,
-0.5712359548,
0.4223730564,
-0.8908872008,
-0.2429055125,
-0.2320025116,
0.2845733762,
0.2156170011,
-0.0527456738,
-0.3192742765,
0.1466709375,
0.5205461383,
-0.1928109527,
0.3828577101,
-0.2093305588,
0.2038212717,
-0.6381182075,
-0.1804654896,
-0.150040254,
-0.2995878458,
-0.47197932,
0.1941596121,
-0.0167308766,
0.0642293096,
-0.6878026724,
0.6231437922,
-0.2466075867,
0.0572424307,
0.0831530467,
0.2697353661,
0.1462320387,
0.0784755275,
-0.3211683631,
0.5199998617,
0.4288858175,
-0.5468512177,
0.6343926191,
0.3156771362,
-0.4374935925,
0.3065064549,
-0.8166891932,
0.4197666049,
-0.1704579294,
0.2745500505,
-1.0255531073,
-0.5428907871,
0.5319720507,
-0.6329548359,
-0.0186199397,
-0.1849281341,
-0.4200132191,
-0.4406810701,
-0.4173466265,
0.2534227669,
0.6820418835,
-0.6331812143,
0.238267526,
0.13730371,
-0.1955003738,
-0.7951812148,
-1.1115829945,
0.2429181039,
-0.5014335513,
-1.0113245249,
-0.0817047209,
-0.2239202857,
-0.3749377728,
-0.1561819166,
-0.0759899169,
-0.0773255527,
0.0475665852,
-0.1140925959,
0.0298397467,
-0.3485710323,
-0.0718194991,
-0.4132591188,
0.0646805763,
0.2267796546,
0.1145441905,
0.4857384861,
-0.039460402,
-0.3973311484,
-0.5096697807,
0.0366131552,
0.2113535106,
0.0432544798,
0.486774385,
0.3755783141,
-0.1159542352,
-0.0791333467,
-0.4361216724,
0.0517618097,
-0.4675945938,
0.2385551482,
-0.4572797418,
-0.75878793,
0.7197441459,
0.4359419346,
-0.0011523276,
0.1552984864,
0.4936372638,
-0.1993680596,
0.7675077319,
0.3588711917,
-0.0250724182,
0.2747842968,
0.2350853384,
0.389945358,
-0.1904078722,
-0.416881144,
-0.3987354338,
-0.4444044828,
-0.6365301609,
-0.725120306,
-0.0021130492,
-0.1990982145,
-0.1882536113,
0.0701244473,
-0.2088343203,
0.8297705054,
0.3661211729,
0.038259998,
0.4414881766,
0.1319708973,
0.1988520026,
-0.1546840817,
-0.9075977802,
-0.4939267337,
0.4140859544,
0.4559893906,
1.2075443268,
0.0441361926,
0.3863467276,
0.3042050302,
0.266372472,
-0.8751501441,
0.5468840599,
-0.5187167525,
-0.6533046365,
-0.0420987979,
-0.7850187421,
-0.8704878092,
0.0278166551,
0.1684431732,
-0.5441706777,
-0.2818156779,
0.0484288298,
-0.0724506155,
0.1459709406,
-0.7130977511,
0.7812738419,
-0.5723338127,
-0.3673652709,
0.0634803772,
-1.0391532183,
0.5522404909,
0.0933030844,
0.6540963054,
0.0243473537,
0.1118649989,
0.4054414034,
-0.2049569935,
0.3935799301,
-0.0889221057,
-0.2137590945,
0.4611804485,
0.3597030342,
0.0518985316,
0.1976643503,
-0.3532057106,
0.6569817662,
-0.3516163826,
-0.6511660218,
-0.5727266073,
0.712977469,
-0.4876597822,
-0.5242356658,
-0.4204689264,
-0.833820045,
0.3884590268,
-0.0327437222,
0.2914973497,
-0.0138272177,
-0.0793044344,
0.5269505978,
0.3528777063,
-0.5456852317,
0.0011009824,
0.3557108939,
0.0239816159,
-0.2560886741,
0.826236248,
-0.0212887675,
0.0487476215,
0.3545856476,
0.4389906228,
-0.1284352243,
-0.0703953207,
-0.3782431781,
0.3887428939,
-0.9086952209,
-0.0043754783,
-0.5787425041,
-0.4380892515,
-0.2450906783,
-0.4284885824,
-0.0467348099,
-0.48919034,
0.1781735718,
0.0836144686,
0.2868948877,
0.655649066,
-0.3350584507,
0.2741455138,
-1.028298378,
0.2269725204,
0.2709147632,
0.2318202406,
-0.243626222,
-0.9032630324,
-0.1731406748,
0.1767990142,
-0.2869656086,
-0.8356648684,
0.4161013663,
0.4002104998,
0.4384418726,
0.9030891061,
0.0322777294,
0.9314850569,
-0.4702090025,
1.0343173742,
0.0446201898,
-0.6072723269,
0.7208787203,
-0.5435483456,
0.0944412276,
0.2450815737,
0.3645853698,
-0.7795889974,
-0.2097875923,
-0.4240302444,
-0.7417266965,
0.8124926686,
0.0975273848,
0.7447670698,
-0.3084963858,
0.5927780271,
0.5493904948,
-0.0104179159,
-1.1029909849,
-0.4252132773,
-0.4883195162,
-0.2917778492,
0.1056513041,
-0.1342353821,
-0.2224803865,
-0.1090002507,
0.5318849683,
0.0703233033,
0.067415908,
0.2594112158,
-0.1766275764,
-0.4625849426,
0.3144920766,
0.5960865021,
0.9515786767,
-0.3091597855,
0.0389938466,
0.1763011515,
-0.5020347834,
-0.273812592,
-0.1067568287,
-0.0857458785,
0.1233946308,
0.5847149491,
0.6577166319,
-0.136900112,
-1.199260354,
0.3696342707,
-0.28713274,
-0.2556677163,
-0.4320687354,
0.4439162016,
0.1245919764,
0.0011397154,
0.6722023487,
-0.5152601004,
-0.032264784,
-0.8181638122,
0.1474199742,
0.3587391675,
-0.6589106917,
-0.4474341571,
0.6778027415,
0.303368032,
-0.5694934726,
0.6284759641,
-0.259139806,
-0.7087935805,
0.8358053565,
0.6288211942,
0.5741388202,
-0.1453470886,
0.3373578787,
0.4310326278,
0.6361145973,
0.1213730425,
0.4439842701,
0.2451954782,
-0.6825533509,
-0.3954122066,
-0.2847089767,
-0.5073728561,
0.4468064904,
-0.4591701329,
0.7499994636,
-0.4244171083,
0.5066525936,
-0.2510635853,
-0.0638713017,
-0.4799779952,
0.3275690675,
0.0811845288,
1.0247300863,
-0.6606342793,
0.578188777,
1.0512062311,
-0.2604389489,
-0.4529981911,
0.2155032009,
0.0840964094,
-1.0268217325,
0.7086318135,
0.2568862438,
-0.0857703835,
-0.1546232849,
-0.6338794827,
-0.0673110187,
1.0610228777,
0.4287489951,
-0.5002968907,
0.4120925963,
0.1106275618,
0.6007925868,
-0.3809752166,
0.4896724522,
0.30684793,
0.5887692571,
0.2647124827,
-0.6747695804,
-0.2095034271,
-0.2412519455,
-0.403819859,
0.0345004015,
-1.0073314905,
0.9122893214,
-0.6259234548,
-0.2723428011,
-0.0477946848,
0.6068288088,
0.5860542059,
0.7745755911,
0.7865543365,
0.4177745581,
0.5283925533,
-0.0844017267,
1.1279605627,
-0.1200353429,
0.3238399327,
1.0541094542,
-0.4663107395,
0.2623183131,
0.5533667803,
-0.2564329505,
0.8562066555,
0.681995213,
-0.0428613424,
0.3596558869,
0.3453136086,
-0.0390423015,
-0.3483619392,
-0.216772005,
-0.4223202467,
0.4655048549,
0.0622897223,
0.0608254597,
-0.2455998063,
-0.2941852808,
0.1954320967,
0.1515470445,
0.0073364074,
0.4748769701,
0.2233844548,
-0.3707434833,
0.3167509735,
-0.128683418,
0.7231525183,
-0.8088982701,
-0.1354631037,
-0.7464683056,
0.0484275855,
-0.3621090651,
-0.8062425256,
0.2601386607,
0.3135837317,
0.2222785801,
0.2507972717,
0.7904292345,
-0.2161580473,
-0.5119234324,
0.430704087,
0.4857487679,
0.6292646527,
0.2558414638,
-0.7634974718,
-0.1214834005,
0.0084778005,
-0.422955811,
0.2127327323,
1.08852911,
-0.1321303099,
1.1586410999,
0.6161413193,
-0.0260145571,
-0.0274516493,
0.2297231853,
0.6593965292,
-0.9990753531,
-0.5109009743,
-0.8795423508,
0.6276518106,
0.0742167979,
-0.1589361876,
0.6685273647,
0.4329354167,
0.8629116416,
-0.3422237039,
0.956440568,
-0.5072082877,
0.4147328138,
-0.3054921925,
0.8107091784,
-1.1686953306,
0.3970144987,
0.0320477709,
-0.7220153809,
-0.3326660395,
1.1771273613,
0.1522331387,
0.2585189044,
0.669500351,
0.7240077257,
-0.1897141486,
-0.1853505373,
0.4885377586,
0.3053067029,
0.1313674152,
0.8775086403,
1.0548717976,
-0.5361594558,
1.0998934507,
-0.4980114102,
0.0058229882,
-0.3544664085,
-1.2282842398,
-0.9274252653,
-0.1896080524,
-0.2822682261,
-0.1671295017,
-0.0360223353,
0.91537112,
0.4670884907,
-0.6558775306,
-0.2035808861,
0.2152106017,
0.4716006517,
-0.1787263304,
-0.4124038219,
-0.1062961146,
-0.1691243201,
-0.6642228365,
0.4047112167,
0.2261358052,
-0.4865318537,
-0.129681468,
-0.3622106612,
-0.0068895244,
0.3566712439,
0.387304157,
0.2936957777,
-0.7314181924,
-0.6658703685,
0.2505250275,
-0.035998214,
0.2179669589,
0.6559467912,
-0.5390999913,
0.2909739912,
0.7525359392,
0.5280994177,
-0.0825098455,
0.1336149275,
0.2393044978,
-0.577773869,
0.1807858348,
0.1607709527,
0.1590982527,
0.7198573351,
-0.4518347681,
0.9590350389,
0.3443924487,
-0.6346834302,
-0.9362199903,
0.1815747768,
-1.2997068167,
-0.2734675109,
0.9554176331,
-0.3706875741,
-0.4182223082,
-0.2674748898,
-0.1041168347,
0.2463490814,
-0.1072072387,
1.1139265299,
0.931854248,
-0.2566275895,
-0.5177262425,
-0.854013443,
-0.134384647,
0.5206429958,
-0.7223907709,
0.0956671759,
0.3437225223,
0.6333705187,
-0.0552146323,
0.8505908847,
-0.2561224699,
0.6010791659,
-0.304314971,
0.2662842572,
-0.13718988,
-0.1641402692,
-0.4125597179,
-0.262467742,
-0.1655362695,
0.0609591827
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12753v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12753v1 | OlympicArena: Benchmarking Multi-discipline Cognitive Reasoning for Superintelligent AI | 2024-06-18T16:20:53 | 2024-06-18T16:20:53 | Zhen Huang, Zengzhi Wang, Shijie Xia, Xuefeng Li, Haoyang Zou, Ruijie Xu, Run-Ze Fan, Lyumanshan Ye, Ethan Chern, Yixin Ye, Yikai Zhang, Yuqing Yang, Ting Wu, Binjie Wang, Shichao Sun, Yang Xiao, Yiyuan Li, Fan Zhou, Steffi Chern, Yiwei Qin, Yan Ma, Jiadi Su, Yixiu Liu, Yuxiang Zheng, Shaoting Zhang, Dahua Lin, Yu Qiao, Pengfei Liu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The evolution of Artificial Intelligence (AI) has been significantly
accelerated by advancements in Large Language Models (LLMs) and Large
Multimodal Models (LMMs), gradually showcasing potential cognitive reasoning
abilities in problem-solving and scientific discovery (i.e., AI4Science) once
exclusive to human intellect. To comprehensively evaluate current models'
performance in cognitive reasoning abilities, we introduce OlympicArena, which
includes 11,163 bilingual problems across both text-only and interleaved
text-image modalities. These challenges encompass a wide range of disciplines
spanning seven fields and 62 international Olympic competitions, rigorously
examined for data leakage. We argue that the challenges in Olympic competition
problems are ideal for evaluating AI's cognitive reasoning due to their
complexity and interdisciplinary nature, which are essential for tackling
complex scientific challenges and facilitating discoveries. Beyond evaluating
performance across various disciplines using answer-only criteria, we conduct
detailed experiments and analyses from multiple perspectives. We delve into the
models' cognitive reasoning abilities, their performance across different
modalities, and their outcomes in process-level evaluations, which are vital
for tasks requiring complex reasoning with lengthy solutions. Our extensive
evaluations reveal that even advanced models like GPT-4o only achieve a 39.97%
overall accuracy, illustrating current AI limitations in complex reasoning and
multimodal integration. Through the OlympicArena, we aim to advance AI towards
superintelligence, equipping it to address more complex challenges in science
and beyond. We also provide a comprehensive set of resources to support AI
research, including a benchmark dataset, an open-source annotation platform, a
detailed evaluation tool, and a leaderboard with automatic submission features. | [
-0.5549191236,
-0.5743791461,
0.9837358594,
0.1628739089,
0.0427730381,
0.0580209941,
-0.3195518553,
-0.8100682497,
-0.2795290351,
0.2126732171,
-0.6063630581,
-0.3138281107,
-0.7827489972,
0.3136721551,
-0.2569106817,
0.7806038857,
-0.146941185,
0.3227481842,
-0.6133568287,
-0.4973622262,
-0.5947932601,
-0.3955953717,
-0.5261160731,
-0.5437628031,
0.2188698202,
0.4201538861,
0.3712328672,
0.4949714243,
0.604096055,
0.3862711787,
0.1480250061,
0.5406995416,
-0.0904506296,
0.1939026415,
-0.5373651385,
-0.792904377,
-0.2857641578,
0.0168921892,
0.1991405785,
0.3401760459,
0.1004621834,
0.2625330985,
-0.3127673566,
0.3595193624,
-0.5298950672,
0.5318303108,
-0.5940638781,
-0.0910087824,
-0.3532079458,
-0.0126548167,
-0.0378123783,
-0.1059296355,
0.0360317938,
-0.8746611476,
-0.077366367,
0.3022124469,
0.5158333182,
0.5787250996,
-0.2124025673,
-0.2207726836,
-0.7046809196,
0.8610450625,
-0.4689751863,
0.3178702891,
0.4312506616,
0.3668998778,
0.0672917888,
-0.5704692602,
-0.7314180136,
-0.5085937977,
0.7713932395,
0.508870244,
-0.2083413452,
-0.3439697921,
0.0749220997,
-0.0821573809,
-0.6462191939,
0.1229892075,
-0.5327558517,
0.102709353,
1.0153990984,
0.3420057595,
0.3757322133,
0.3200150132,
0.0816803724,
-0.0047720107,
-0.3908989131,
-0.1863180101,
0.4582569003,
-0.1771511137,
0.0962630659,
0.4540260732,
-0.32596457,
0.130801335,
-0.1782462299,
0.4437941015,
0.122253187,
-0.3256724477,
0.1829823554,
-0.0340353958,
0.7574991584,
0.2724736333,
0.240910247,
-0.4413049817,
0.226978898,
0.3335196972,
0.3310875893,
-0.464487642,
-0.2254946977,
0.5290901661,
-0.2350958586,
0.190244332,
-0.0557825714,
-0.5829850435,
-0.2082774341,
-0.4707219899,
0.2777170837,
-0.6963598132,
-0.0618407987,
0.2655995786,
-0.124708958,
-0.2050089389,
0.4250153303,
-0.6616757512,
-0.004545521,
0.8871864676,
0.5636631846,
-0.1279014498,
-0.6700677872,
0.0207149889,
0.003433336,
-0.4162267447,
1.089863658,
-0.6570973992,
-0.0027387284,
-0.2362625003,
-0.3858326972,
-0.2279029936,
-0.6082233787,
0.7313909531,
-0.5821260214,
-0.1556163877,
-0.1645080447,
-0.5146153569,
-0.2388387173,
0.3977600336,
-0.5720745325,
0.9425263405,
-0.3941294849,
-0.4098963141,
0.2641333044,
-0.9283282757,
-0.0916966125,
0.3066318035,
-0.260697037,
-0.1476583928,
0.1232495457,
0.3127318621,
0.0914267376,
-0.8575658798,
0.4204594195,
-0.4948447049,
-0.0412293449,
0.3842040002,
-0.2455228567,
0.6640928388,
0.3290352821,
-0.743626833,
0.1706835926,
-0.6012995243,
0.1706147939,
0.0457224324,
-0.0009963337,
-0.2846744657,
0.1635397822,
-0.1714797318,
0.2285469174,
0.371982336,
-0.6294039488,
0.1880183071,
0.1151656285,
0.805352509,
0.7113482952,
-0.2847264707,
0.0391501486,
-0.3102255166,
0.3919865191,
-0.1406804323,
0.5686514378,
0.0105409063,
-0.7299229503,
-0.4710727334,
-0.2946596146,
0.2157731801,
0.7593013048,
-0.8453991413,
0.3950119317,
-0.3174436688,
-0.8068854213,
-0.6456090808,
0.046155747,
0.5192115307,
0.4451443553,
0.5271138549,
-0.0594198853,
-0.1565618515,
-0.9720544815,
-0.41238603,
-0.0855977237,
0.2235124856,
0.4168121517,
1.0855026245,
-0.1977000087,
0.4457788765,
-0.0835914239,
-0.2153065205,
-0.2470107377,
0.4477047622,
0.025651833,
0.5927369595,
0.2549241781,
-0.752599895,
0.0407957956,
0.2128829956,
-1.3359729052,
-0.1318051666,
-0.0543595962,
-0.2476639301,
-0.1580483913,
0.4414674938,
-0.7212299705,
0.3535314798,
0.3816412687,
-0.3175322413,
0.7892361283,
-0.4350372553,
0.4704011381,
-0.5003138781,
0.2007815242,
0.0915537775,
0.200985238,
-0.419256717,
0.5322768092,
0.0292797871,
0.1709528416,
-0.2706610262,
0.4800005853,
-0.2820429802,
0.1380452067,
-0.1630956978,
0.1256195307,
-0.1470670253,
0.1945685893,
0.0370428637,
0.6121771932,
0.5584697127,
-0.4669526517,
0.5054739714,
0.2621955276,
-0.4128284156,
0.8196507692,
-0.6226292849,
0.2546815872,
-0.1472535878,
0.3473344445,
-0.5394650698,
-0.0889622718,
-0.1102004722,
-0.3713545203,
-0.2284511328,
0.3239328265,
-0.6531694531,
-0.4944444299,
-0.1861104071,
1.0133179426,
0.0129664214,
-0.3331541121,
0.6382952332,
0.2663958669,
-0.1538498551,
-0.3680324256,
-0.7228406072,
0.2959212959,
-0.1866855025,
-0.6619562507,
0.2785976231,
-0.4866304696,
-0.3087623417,
0.1660284996,
-0.0671981201,
-0.1513568163,
0.1274148226,
0.0358778723,
0.2311284989,
-0.1705233306,
-0.1266459078,
-0.0815554857,
-0.2393527925,
0.0491663963,
-0.4912287295,
0.3425343335,
-0.3439225256,
-0.4923627079,
-0.7687695026,
0.4810676277,
0.756131053,
-0.614082098,
0.7002660036,
0.4134435952,
-0.4500566423,
0.0929591134,
-0.6913691759,
-0.0247123409,
-0.2814180255,
0.5145606399,
-0.4356198013,
-0.5437268615,
0.7331805825,
-0.0631989613,
0.0561060794,
0.4713097215,
0.5702897906,
0.0377288312,
1.4613564014,
0.2089783698,
0.0430802889,
0.1970559359,
-0.5608994365,
0.1294063777,
-1.084782362,
-0.6710596085,
-0.6512380242,
-0.3819914758,
-0.1935573667,
-0.3736384213,
0.5617771149,
-0.0807074755,
-0.6331750154,
0.1423360705,
-0.3895563781,
0.5674182177,
0.8206402659,
0.2377444059,
0.4641508162,
-0.5268255472,
-0.104087539,
-0.0628660321,
-0.8361558914,
-0.4852834642,
1.3311421871,
0.0544486381,
0.4545498192,
0.0093600592,
0.4779353738,
0.2587471604,
0.4374295771,
-0.3256341517,
0.4406987727,
0.0061997417,
-0.9984163046,
-0.1033631712,
-0.5646882653,
-0.881988883,
0.2823436558,
-0.3328984976,
-0.9165586233,
0.1156451181,
-0.0557904243,
-0.4840297997,
0.331322521,
-0.3729234636,
0.852209866,
-0.5792966485,
-0.5653720498,
-0.520101428,
-0.4586005211,
0.5641592741,
-0.109850578,
0.4851601422,
-0.2815473676,
-0.0965780541,
0.7260761857,
-0.1885014325,
0.3823459148,
0.2801364064,
0.2814968228,
0.2152168602,
0.1452841312,
0.004844693,
0.3073912859,
-0.0817072019,
0.5538972616,
0.0355299413,
-0.4804619849,
-0.5256982446,
0.8335276246,
-1.0464510918,
-0.5729941726,
-0.4716007411,
-0.9052075148,
-0.258522898,
0.2577722371,
0.3144805729,
0.5128178596,
0.049396202,
0.1520818621,
0.6289970875,
0.100257434,
0.1743137389,
0.2188706845,
0.2811459899,
-0.452413857,
0.8631393313,
0.2310096323,
-0.2119961083,
0.0921686813,
0.0253199991,
-0.4737030864,
-0.9508567452,
-0.4901795685,
0.2254489064,
-0.5821467638,
-0.2260466963,
-0.4288383424,
0.1398612559,
-0.0627644286,
-0.0241707303,
-0.6643435359,
-0.4361612201,
0.0612185113,
0.0565462336,
-0.1199698299,
0.7518259883,
-0.1067365631,
-0.0898965001,
-0.5307005048,
0.3470679522,
0.1451974809,
0.1339168102,
0.0562914759,
-0.2067312449,
-0.1198367104,
-0.1663079709,
-0.4814771712,
-0.6641413569,
0.0016459749,
-0.0779173449,
0.8594744802,
0.3771800399,
-0.0022221962,
0.6173306704,
-0.469997257,
0.8545489907,
0.1138505563,
-0.909263432,
0.5019937754,
-0.1895889342,
0.2916820347,
0.6420317888,
0.415826112,
-0.1192414686,
-0.5609286427,
-0.7600410581,
-0.9506807923,
0.7457401156,
0.2933938205,
-0.2468050569,
-0.0821282566,
0.3874572814,
0.1322976202,
0.1247348115,
-0.3529672921,
-0.089842543,
-0.2118125707,
-0.4234705567,
-0.0982658565,
0.4364801049,
-0.4888444543,
-0.1973215193,
0.8125146627,
-0.1391303241,
0.0659470707,
0.3606597185,
-0.1997916996,
0.2913064063,
-0.0044147624,
0.590156734,
0.8164969087,
0.2603354752,
0.0899318233,
0.2764575481,
-0.3003374338,
0.0411658213,
0.3789324462,
-0.1818710864,
-0.6755037904,
0.8906369805,
0.4914281368,
0.1006211713,
-1.0966516733,
0.0528495796,
-0.2412323505,
-0.3661111593,
-0.1619087458,
0.0749714226,
0.0173737239,
0.8899001479,
0.582161963,
0.3586706519,
0.2602488995,
-0.7872826457,
-0.0912416205,
0.4144310057,
-0.0644623563,
-0.4103275537,
1.2789293528,
0.0397940688,
-0.085811004,
0.6157165766,
-0.0769752488,
-0.5841270685,
0.8795909286,
0.2639481127,
0.6792647243,
-0.1745609194,
0.0515019782,
0.1518302113,
0.4415775836,
-0.3594299555,
0.3146006167,
-0.0976300165,
-0.6939291358,
-0.1966423839,
-0.110390082,
-0.4743002057,
0.1318451464,
-0.5597450137,
-0.3420641124,
-0.3681267202,
-0.3328647017,
0.1166890934,
0.2250887752,
-0.8867204189,
0.1084310561,
0.2776491642,
1.1101558208,
-0.8157352209,
0.31823349,
0.7910274267,
-0.6182613373,
-0.2393612713,
-0.2920871377,
0.001183224,
-0.7100272775,
0.6993427277,
0.0462093614,
-0.0180596299,
-0.217398271,
-0.5938416719,
-0.6331733465,
1.1397805214,
0.5636273623,
-0.4067282081,
0.2126197964,
-0.0325183906,
0.5823655725,
-0.5146147013,
0.7325934768,
0.8393042684,
0.7967442274,
-0.1822496951,
-0.9081577063,
-0.1045883894,
-0.4209805131,
-0.0769619048,
-0.3547450304,
-1.0453618765,
0.7168983221,
-0.1292248219,
0.1979513168,
0.4268096685,
0.7072810531,
0.6091003418,
0.6378000975,
0.1977578104,
0.791492939,
0.8494997621,
-0.2310419977,
1.1375461817,
-0.3319811523,
0.0806972161,
0.7814673781,
-0.5774801373,
0.649166286,
0.2602016926,
0.0781899467,
0.4655768275,
0.4394529462,
0.2082947344,
0.391997993,
0.0499568954,
-0.181014806,
-0.548314631,
-0.2003627867,
-0.2284027487,
0.492526859,
0.3507672846,
0.2133767307,
-0.17599383,
0.2447465211,
0.1944278479,
0.2803916931,
-0.4231415093,
0.3554638922,
-0.0796548277,
-0.9859749079,
0.2694581151,
-0.0705265924,
0.3637761772,
-0.4503326714,
0.0230426174,
-0.3545437753,
0.451841712,
-0.0489269681,
-0.7355845571,
-0.0138122914,
0.2075806856,
-0.1023635417,
0.17715244,
0.0445734374,
-0.1497870237,
-0.5223334432,
0.3313902318,
0.5216220021,
0.1369818151,
-0.145848617,
-1.0014096498,
0.4063877463,
-0.3986660838,
-0.2219825387,
0.119367972,
0.5437504649,
-0.4812807441,
0.9490495324,
0.7112340927,
0.1022880822,
0.2152725309,
0.0356647149,
0.7149672508,
-0.4501093328,
-0.4427390993,
-0.7547390461,
0.2030104697,
-0.249138549,
-0.6921054721,
0.532553494,
0.6462402344,
0.7361646295,
0.0989742875,
1.0728898048,
0.0123369675,
-0.1507711112,
-0.5493294001,
0.4867435098,
-0.4844678342,
0.0596695468,
-0.0066827778,
-0.7651718259,
-0.5197370648,
0.5215213895,
-0.6628495455,
0.0800458118,
0.8008058071,
0.312563777,
-0.2252135873,
0.269075036,
0.1102136299,
0.3290649951,
0.5051585436,
0.9779385924,
1.0999268293,
-0.3094875813,
0.6292709708,
-0.0033445787,
-0.6768655181,
-0.2076610774,
-0.7569619417,
-0.8406559825,
-0.5729679465,
-0.5050920248,
0.1028352603,
0.4050875902,
0.6902769208,
0.9899424911,
-0.6804839373,
-0.0366660915,
-0.1678226292,
-0.1209183782,
-0.5410628319,
-0.1670278758,
0.3331925571,
-0.239786759,
-0.9217132926,
0.5404852629,
0.324172318,
-0.6004702449,
-0.2247681022,
-0.1238388792,
-0.2639219463,
0.4702916741,
0.3429946005,
0.5721231699,
-0.6638793349,
-0.2683490813,
-0.244181335,
0.32287696,
-0.2644342482,
0.5867620707,
-0.526209712,
0.42990762,
0.3473365307,
0.7243128419,
0.664006114,
-0.2077269107,
0.2834402323,
-0.0021762198,
0.0700351372,
0.4202469587,
0.6100133657,
0.0588689484,
-0.1348105669,
0.5581532121,
0.2618249655,
-0.8495846987,
-0.6669427156,
0.1370174885,
-0.6627494097,
-0.4711981118,
0.4826076329,
-0.2888266444,
-0.3309079707,
-0.2206148803,
-0.1493551284,
0.1536801457,
-0.289182812,
1.2159286737,
0.8202659488,
-0.7009922862,
-0.0631477162,
-1.070546031,
0.0149001423,
0.5675965548,
-0.9972423315,
-0.0482532382,
0.302169621,
0.110405758,
0.4426121116,
0.3828567863,
-0.2490300834,
0.5625258684,
0.0899664313,
0.0063756714,
-0.3930465281,
-0.7771960497,
-0.0912163258,
0.1582100093,
-0.2618741095,
-0.0061344891
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12746v3 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12746v3 | Rationale-based Ensemble of Multiple QA Strategies for Zero-shot Knowledge-based VQA | 2024-06-18T16:06:38 | 2024-06-23T03:06:42 | Miaoyu Li, Haoxin Li, Zilin Du, Boyang Li | cs.CL | cs.CL | Knowledge-based Visual Qustion-answering (K-VQA) necessitates the use of
background knowledge beyond what is depicted in the image. Current zero-shot
K-VQA methods usually translate an image to a single type of textual decision
context and use a text-based model to answer the question based on it, which
conflicts with the fact that K-VQA questions often require the combination of
multiple question-answering strategies. In light of this, we propose
Rationale-based Ensemble of Answer Context Tactics (REACT) to achieve a dynamic
ensemble of multiple question-answering tactics, comprising Answer Candidate
Generation (ACG) and Rationale-based Strategy Fusion (RSF). In ACG, we generate
three distinctive decision contexts to provide different strategies for each
question, resulting in the generation of three answer candidates. RSF generates
automatic and mechanistic rationales from decision contexts for each candidate,
allowing the model to select the correct answer from all candidates. We conduct
comprehensive experiments on the OK-VQA and A-OKVQA datasets, and our method
significantly outperforms state-of-the-art LLM-based baselines on all datasets. | [
-0.5978816152,
-0.9319287539,
0.93240273,
-0.0206321459,
-0.1946876496,
0.2127022743,
0.1039951667,
-0.2002800703,
0.1582599431,
0.408600688,
-0.991646111,
-0.453289777,
-0.0480778478,
0.3097380996,
-0.0716002434,
0.6100580096,
-0.2258901,
0.0749251246,
-0.4799111784,
-0.6240074039,
-0.7764626145,
-0.4638733566,
-0.3718056083,
-0.0941920877,
0.4172672033,
0.732806325,
0.2255090922,
0.4468849301,
0.1601211429,
0.2115511,
0.284383297,
0.077095367,
-0.2959785163,
0.6127660871,
-0.1696793437,
-0.447961092,
-0.0465390608,
-0.0070074731,
0.2962889075,
-0.0847519785,
-0.1608255655,
0.5211400986,
-0.6546813846,
0.3163535893,
-1.262966156,
-0.2905038297,
-0.8175677061,
0.0427895449,
0.3995234668,
-0.4649889469,
-0.5367893577,
-0.1635393798,
0.300054878,
-0.9093834162,
-0.1573918909,
-0.1724826097,
0.6783863902,
0.3727093041,
-0.7878087759,
-0.0589371584,
-0.7561802864,
0.8203669786,
-0.4302588701,
-0.0368160792,
-0.0103195123,
0.7876389027,
0.1314689964,
-0.4382303059,
-0.7382948399,
0.2796198428,
0.1915377676,
0.6563051343,
0.0933133364,
-0.0176573414,
0.1834918857,
-0.1396200359,
-0.5600768924,
-0.3178848028,
-0.1723641753,
-0.1606617123,
0.6781054139,
0.1079755649,
0.3005625606,
-0.0819778591,
-0.8468442559,
-0.4034526348,
-0.4749752879,
0.3007130027,
-0.2158396244,
-0.0269400384,
0.0878875703,
0.6711698771,
-0.8500357866,
0.7828841805,
0.2875672877,
-0.2231124043,
-0.083950676,
-0.5452967286,
-0.392696321,
0.1104125977,
0.667036891,
0.5085544586,
0.0385157019,
0.0099380026,
-0.0064889467,
0.3058294356,
0.2294100076,
-0.7442318201,
-0.0107432939,
0.5081182718,
-0.0409735888,
-0.6554073691,
-0.308894217,
-0.8801050782,
-0.1284122765,
-0.3732582033,
1.017734766,
-0.4466002882,
-0.155377835,
-0.1279010475,
-0.5746946335,
0.9769630432,
0.50127244,
-0.327026397,
-0.0137065239,
0.0331583284,
0.320605576,
-0.0891364366,
-0.226627484,
-0.7155031562,
0.1817245036,
-0.489266634,
1.0802098513,
-0.4849132597,
-0.1328525692,
0.0625665337,
-0.2255024761,
-0.2317908108,
-0.2007787526,
0.3586057127,
-0.9422885776,
0.4633494318,
-0.7285086513,
-0.4883660674,
-0.3324505389,
0.78454566,
-0.4275583625,
0.6500327587,
-0.0092278756,
-0.3726151586,
0.428085655,
-0.5576155782,
-0.1097407192,
0.1093940809,
-0.4969024062,
-0.1406895965,
-0.1597456634,
0.5699021816,
0.3995364904,
-0.1158994362,
-0.1927926838,
-0.3112457991,
-0.2431424707,
0.3597844541,
-0.4623830318,
0.5320366025,
0.2378960997,
-0.3758292198,
0.3617827594,
-0.7250936031,
0.5407589674,
0.2137035728,
-0.1535308659,
-0.1710254103,
-0.0743047744,
-0.4141841233,
0.5527461171,
0.0627288967,
-0.3909628689,
0.15448834,
-0.0362111405,
0.1885983348,
0.4848299921,
0.6220453978,
0.6031862497,
-0.5398226976,
0.8759812713,
-0.0264681168,
0.2052338421,
-0.4302866459,
-0.4819613099,
-0.3768862188,
-0.3917259276,
0.0648531467,
0.8695662618,
-1.5863649845,
-0.2153357416,
-0.0034525529,
-0.4331958592,
-0.2392949015,
-0.2885742784,
0.457272172,
0.8576157093,
0.5463354588,
0.1035069078,
-0.3306690156,
-0.8605056405,
-0.0836319476,
-0.3493520617,
0.2732170224,
0.4792678058,
0.4490445554,
0.3065727353,
0.9768212438,
-0.6153694987,
0.1499552876,
0.0007858268,
-0.0022488113,
-0.1185693666,
0.0301450584,
0.6464538574,
-0.9109844565,
-0.4223068953,
-0.1109415591,
-0.8700526357,
0.0582716949,
-0.3211680055,
-0.4943241775,
0.2998981476,
0.3832155764,
-0.6568442583,
0.408220619,
0.2164513618,
-0.2570409179,
0.9854152203,
0.233803317,
0.714736402,
-1.1923122406,
0.0186871849,
0.1111080945,
-0.0846169516,
-0.8083075881,
0.5630483031,
0.1179554239,
-0.0794337615,
-0.8055176139,
0.7270312905,
-0.1978894323,
0.2536713183,
-0.0581670888,
0.1212892607,
0.1498235166,
0.8170080781,
0.1626956016,
0.7547963858,
0.5802735686,
-0.4755409062,
0.457957387,
0.3483605981,
-0.0063588959,
0.9037535191,
-0.5467725992,
0.1110382974,
-0.313216418,
0.3108710945,
-1.3249533176,
-0.553673625,
0.37300542,
-0.5866370797,
0.0780152678,
-0.2296947986,
-0.0992868841,
-0.2633916438,
-0.4726134241,
0.7861925364,
0.5454402566,
-0.515845418,
0.8412329555,
0.0334249027,
-0.0686943457,
-0.9256137609,
-0.3384795487,
-0.2672468126,
-0.4517822266,
-0.7742679119,
0.1161551699,
-0.090905413,
-0.2595116794,
-0.0068230415,
-0.4614853263,
-0.3364859819,
0.032986749,
-0.0985314399,
0.528367877,
-0.2748007178,
0.1776226759,
0.147874549,
0.3392030597,
-0.0272013117,
-0.2152960151,
0.3310214579,
-0.0508600138,
-0.312477529,
-0.2313183993,
0.5751308799,
0.9421802163,
-0.4948500693,
0.6436215639,
0.4088765085,
-0.1861338168,
-0.3096368611,
-0.5964194536,
-0.4538315535,
-0.3934192657,
0.0202153791,
-0.3991858065,
-0.8644757271,
0.768527329,
-0.0468322933,
0.1234508604,
0.2497168481,
0.6142938733,
-0.2937166095,
0.9878097773,
0.0750445276,
0.3039449453,
0.1316975504,
-0.2204769254,
-0.0536155552,
-0.3871427774,
-0.2945285141,
-0.2650183439,
-0.255482614,
-0.3119967282,
-0.3088213503,
0.7734062672,
0.3030251563,
-0.3277036846,
0.1150013581,
-0.6807538271,
0.5094482303,
0.609744072,
0.0758383945,
0.1773889214,
0.1022570431,
-0.2099148482,
0.4345676899,
-1.0402263403,
-0.1603186876,
1.2721294165,
-0.1322013736,
0.4189761877,
0.1961352676,
0.7552734613,
-0.0238657426,
0.2140739113,
-0.9631181955,
0.6233549118,
0.5014755726,
-0.7256151438,
-0.631588161,
-0.3558518887,
-0.7037269473,
0.5194939375,
-0.6182490587,
-0.4810220301,
0.326533258,
0.3286390007,
-0.768251121,
-0.1345052719,
-0.7638470531,
0.8181980252,
-0.0433484428,
-0.3995321691,
-0.0336240046,
-0.7707782388,
0.7907589078,
-0.0652593076,
0.032931488,
0.1167636439,
0.0089804642,
0.5009204745,
-0.3364064991,
0.3868106008,
-0.1383741647,
0.054636091,
0.8015128374,
0.0260078553,
0.3922968209,
0.1531418413,
0.0547164828,
-0.2476358712,
0.565867126,
-0.5135586858,
-0.7639603615,
0.5392227173,
-0.6409546137,
-0.5416311622,
-0.4066058397,
-0.3896501064,
-0.439198941,
0.1503700614,
0.3615836799,
0.698009789,
-0.0690587834,
0.1735702604,
0.6858553886,
-0.2089003175,
0.4926675558,
0.485835582,
0.0302497931,
-0.7715556622,
0.7721577883,
0.0440004803,
0.457026124,
0.2721452117,
0.1054941043,
-0.5281162262,
-0.1432907134,
-0.8502300978,
-0.0827445239,
-0.6651871204,
-0.3490603566,
-0.288742125,
-0.1726063192,
-0.3126952052,
-0.3540886045,
0.1464419961,
-0.3422682285,
0.0278113782,
0.1079608425,
0.3600645959,
0.0573571175,
0.2405572832,
0.2586503029,
-0.767802,
0.6098208427,
0.8349366188,
0.0257523861,
-0.2286359668,
-0.0990475491,
0.1283401102,
0.1515894979,
-0.5414518118,
-1.4669359922,
0.0513161756,
-0.0383010283,
0.6217799187,
-0.064317137,
0.4577404559,
0.4970903993,
-0.386575073,
0.8100174665,
0.3285380304,
-0.5852059126,
0.6568357348,
-0.5554826856,
0.5192074776,
0.7165884972,
0.271440655,
-0.3569816053,
-0.1674711406,
-0.5350933671,
-0.79548347,
0.702963829,
0.2689441741,
-0.1964841187,
-0.0536055528,
0.4455910027,
-0.2846006751,
0.3497318029,
-0.5435190797,
-0.2585636377,
-0.3580686748,
-0.1340209693,
0.4599900246,
0.1412904859,
-0.6199936271,
0.0042148447,
0.7292244434,
-0.6615694761,
0.1900036782,
0.6266846657,
0.0136347571,
-0.1408496499,
0.4889956415,
0.6860111952,
0.5269275904,
-0.1299149245,
-0.1501305401,
0.3627952635,
-0.00642558,
0.5753930807,
-0.1261391044,
-0.5112456679,
-0.2941877842,
0.1744182706,
0.5385167599,
-0.2695902884,
-0.8462031484,
0.6794608831,
-0.1390130967,
-0.7162285447,
-0.3675718606,
0.2129379511,
-0.271122098,
0.3023396134,
0.5258330703,
0.3420444429,
0.0909246504,
-0.5720595121,
0.4352917373,
0.6216071844,
-0.2774973512,
0.0834303722,
0.3639344871,
0.0959180519,
0.0552333631,
0.1922960132,
-0.1499697715,
-0.3973484337,
0.9176478982,
0.135219872,
0.6994842887,
-0.2686114013,
0.7561768293,
0.3822869658,
0.0358350016,
-0.112384595,
0.7360603809,
-0.2297785729,
-0.9351344705,
-0.8876401782,
-0.3099461794,
-0.4195901752,
0.4071223438,
-0.6175473928,
0.2756013572,
-0.4787571132,
0.0680020824,
-0.0903546587,
-0.2343275249,
-0.5343229771,
0.4239858091,
0.1494013518,
0.8011488914,
-0.6844007969,
0.3005149961,
0.9670760036,
-0.4231206775,
-1.0361933708,
0.1937351227,
0.1726197302,
-0.7556062341,
0.1972497255,
-0.0272287372,
-0.122343719,
0.0965460539,
-0.9345994592,
-0.8518682718,
1.3857117891,
0.1910435557,
-0.150775373,
0.2183460593,
-0.290463537,
0.3402308524,
-0.3176155984,
0.3024106026,
0.2259844542,
0.4730278254,
0.6877302527,
-0.4785985649,
0.0308576915,
-0.2000807524,
-0.1654717177,
0.076609455,
-0.682790935,
0.337046206,
-0.1773549169,
-0.3299435377,
0.163009122,
0.3723512292,
0.8175418377,
0.4682177305,
0.5020642877,
0.6319645047,
0.335637629,
0.0675783679,
0.9074928761,
-0.3942239583,
0.0586976111,
1.028985858,
-0.3938788474,
0.8631199002,
0.4655588865,
0.3375576735,
0.3929124177,
0.3641731739,
0.1490375251,
0.6356858611,
0.1004613116,
-0.5646752119,
-0.6569191813,
0.0481169708,
-0.0564308576,
0.6837232113,
0.116090633,
0.1791698784,
-0.4604708254,
-0.0863370746,
-0.3118060231,
0.1183179915,
-0.2946744561,
0.9755845666,
-0.2253345698,
-1.1654022932,
0.6963631511,
-0.1343689859,
0.2880990207,
-0.4956180155,
-0.2173001021,
-0.0284067187,
-0.2959391177,
0.0204361305,
-0.8334438801,
-0.0291625578,
-0.2430704087,
-0.2527968585,
-0.0958914682,
0.9700460434,
-0.5061995387,
-0.3368068337,
-0.207656458,
0.9559713006,
-0.3456051946,
-0.0527853854,
-0.494019866,
-0.3371217251,
-0.0476279072,
-0.2087379247,
0.2310646027,
0.4863706231,
-0.2103239745,
0.6077030301,
0.6772458553,
-0.4340268373,
0.0864770114,
-0.2669882178,
0.7783980966,
-0.2799288332,
-0.3361484408,
-0.602545023,
0.8366626501,
-0.2249303609,
-0.3611167073,
0.5932757854,
0.1762802452,
0.5330189466,
-0.1103680879,
0.9464814663,
0.0916286036,
0.1316431612,
-0.492970705,
0.5195546746,
-0.7229136825,
-0.0801805034,
-0.233510226,
-0.7459463477,
-0.0881246477,
0.4316236675,
-0.1768296808,
-0.131663084,
0.4577411711,
0.733199656,
0.1597234458,
-0.0675617233,
0.4772160947,
-0.0916071758,
0.225958541,
0.6872515082,
0.9899250269,
-0.4714044034,
0.8078932166,
-0.1542123109,
-0.3805725873,
-0.1624781489,
-0.7718101144,
-0.6028668284,
-0.6094498634,
-0.4154495001,
-0.3232438564,
-0.1609083563,
0.7035840154,
0.7326610684,
-0.5878297687,
0.1251989603,
-0.051868476,
0.1198793203,
-0.3143786788,
-0.2869710326,
0.1086724028,
-0.445672214,
-0.110619612,
0.4889648557,
0.3171137869,
-0.0743684173,
-0.0425396636,
0.0087488443,
-0.3106015027,
0.5837757587,
0.8334447742,
0.5371876955,
-0.586476028,
-0.4965510666,
0.6277397871,
0.0539830588,
-0.1655097008,
0.4079521596,
-1.1891806126,
0.4423748851,
0.7154835463,
0.7894366384,
0.292963922,
0.2832708657,
0.7619104385,
-0.7875345349,
-0.3097853959,
0.3087362349,
0.0421930477,
-0.1167138815,
-0.2432716191,
0.3349117041,
0.3414415419,
-0.4722436666,
-0.6539592147,
0.4050145447,
-1.232008338,
-0.628303051,
1.3641219139,
0.1787258238,
-0.2839578688,
0.051757209,
-0.3474547565,
0.0703414604,
-0.4409455657,
0.5912983418,
0.7378855348,
-0.2420852631,
-0.5063729286,
-0.3964090049,
0.4750390351,
0.5981267095,
-0.9265858531,
-0.3838683367,
0.8946661353,
0.275662452,
0.3526123166,
0.658402741,
0.0156017896,
0.7813114524,
-0.158521086,
0.1068461761,
0.0627666265,
-0.4787435234,
-0.1939632595,
0.5954449773,
-0.3181182444,
-0.3667472899
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12742v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12742v1 | Benchmarking Multi-Image Understanding in Vision and Language Models: Perception, Knowledge, Reasoning, and Multi-Hop Reasoning | 2024-06-18T16:02:18 | 2024-06-18T16:02:18 | Bingchen Zhao, Yongshuo Zong, Letian Zhang, Timothy Hospedales | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | The advancement of large language models (LLMs) has significantly broadened
the scope of applications in natural language processing, with multi-modal LLMs
extending these capabilities to integrate and interpret visual data. However,
existing benchmarks for visual language models (VLMs) predominantly focus on
single-image inputs, neglecting the crucial aspect of multi-image
understanding. In this paper, we introduce a Multi-Image Relational Benchmark
MIRB, designed to evaluate VLMs' ability to compare, analyze, and reason across
multiple images. Our benchmark encompasses four categories: perception, visual
world knowledge, reasoning, and multi-hop reasoning. Through a comprehensive
evaluation of a wide range of open-source and closed-source models, we
demonstrate that while open-source VLMs were shown to approach the performance
of GPT-4V in single-image tasks, a significant performance gap remains in
multi-image reasoning tasks. Our findings also reveal that even the
state-of-the-art GPT-4V model struggles with our benchmark, underscoring the
need for further research and development in this area. We believe our
contribution of MIRB could serve as a testbed for developing the
next-generation multi-modal models. | [
-0.6931501031,
-0.6569930315,
0.8541707397,
0.1941063255,
-0.3930422068,
-0.2038321942,
-0.045682475,
-0.6592306495,
-0.4141788781,
0.4031482935,
-0.442230165,
-0.5637641549,
-0.5681396127,
0.0928616375,
-0.0729635656,
0.2836843431,
-0.0557120144,
0.4125419855,
-0.6082412601,
-0.7574525476,
-0.7069665194,
-0.1880910397,
-0.1390903592,
-0.0465848818,
0.5626184344,
0.2603885829,
0.7215550542,
0.4833066165,
0.9937731028,
0.2958099246,
0.1114635468,
0.2362394184,
-0.1972939372,
0.0719414577,
-0.1877218336,
-0.2488612235,
-0.1625023633,
0.0922661945,
0.7540236712,
0.4680988491,
0.2776963115,
0.3315985799,
-0.3886155784,
0.6724526286,
-0.8380522728,
0.3401817381,
-0.6859149933,
-0.074677296,
-0.1092308462,
-0.057209488,
-0.4602829516,
-0.2079007775,
0.011321784,
-0.4099122286,
0.1082681194,
0.2590758801,
0.9438365102,
0.3655796349,
-0.5282426476,
0.1695007533,
-0.3945180178,
0.7669906616,
-0.4709178507,
0.9547188878,
0.0536779985,
0.6364229918,
0.1690618545,
-0.6673876047,
-0.5261367559,
-0.2307564318,
-0.0153558468,
0.202278465,
-0.3026752472,
-0.1080872864,
0.26797539,
0.2097843438,
-0.6469353437,
-0.1475527585,
-0.2944123745,
-0.080997251,
0.1274584681,
0.0614562556,
0.0975110307,
-0.2026560605,
-0.7535114288,
-0.2258159071,
-0.6150836945,
0.0772124678,
-0.0894480497,
-0.0178134609,
0.0097095873,
0.5317658186,
-0.1352990866,
1.0175377131,
-0.5604878664,
-0.1477552354,
0.405698806,
-0.6966620684,
-0.426881969,
-0.6340113282,
0.7941869497,
0.6402345896,
0.1438111365,
-0.2086314559,
-0.0498214029,
0.2748591006,
0.2046566606,
-0.8933311105,
-0.1369859427,
-0.1886668652,
-0.6751063466,
-0.0505034886,
-0.1054466739,
-0.7524132133,
-0.3095847368,
-0.4299157262,
0.6466552019,
-0.6141286492,
-0.2343226075,
-0.0050606877,
-0.2620671391,
0.4723265767,
0.4391866028,
-0.388853997,
0.171297729,
0.5015084743,
0.9102942944,
-0.0409489423,
-0.8009842634,
-0.5861957073,
0.0302707944,
-0.3632243574,
1.1501021385,
-0.7059649229,
-0.0382299051,
-0.342397362,
-0.1515376121,
-0.1438470632,
-0.4625572264,
0.4502497911,
-0.5183023214,
-0.0077903997,
-0.4310964942,
-0.2720882893,
-0.4943044782,
0.5738019943,
-0.7555986643,
0.6901065111,
0.0137213655,
-0.7303537726,
0.6095899343,
-0.5621447563,
-0.2821083069,
-0.0190808363,
-0.5944564939,
-0.4539267123,
0.221101433,
0.5702700615,
0.491609633,
-0.7073549032,
0.3255949318,
-0.7518985271,
-0.3909817636,
0.2297321111,
-0.461399734,
0.4542119503,
0.1817041785,
-0.1389459968,
0.2931151986,
-0.7937069535,
0.1301944107,
0.2163296789,
-0.1140689179,
-0.2124449909,
-0.0288907979,
-0.0443815812,
0.4765840471,
-0.0368638001,
-0.3876598775,
0.1330001652,
0.2154493481,
0.2019270658,
0.7231123447,
-0.1806245297,
0.0998054445,
-0.0057728109,
0.3543468118,
0.3758707643,
0.4139872193,
-0.6085762978,
-0.7473422289,
-0.6824436784,
-0.4919531941,
0.0074028918,
0.2706432343,
-0.9155911803,
-0.23806642,
-0.375628531,
-0.4070405066,
-0.7879853845,
0.0732389092,
0.4897823036,
0.5500766039,
0.7095579505,
-0.3980875313,
-0.229535386,
-1.2225871086,
-0.4673354626,
-0.1312724799,
0.0688365251,
0.6600638032,
0.4665562809,
-0.3053074181,
0.67450881,
-0.2226097882,
-0.2148819268,
0.0580796897,
0.317502737,
0.1894510984,
0.133952722,
0.7259967923,
-0.9189752936,
-0.2224451005,
-0.0051056901,
-0.8638895154,
-0.0208000559,
-0.1429894567,
-0.2063076347,
-0.0019306727,
0.3519690633,
-0.4716107249,
0.6176717877,
0.7726881504,
-0.5981273651,
0.5871620178,
-0.0948536471,
0.646075666,
-0.6121625304,
0.0199565645,
0.1198946238,
-0.2334858626,
-0.4741841555,
0.2087014019,
0.4589844942,
0.0205069724,
-0.4588900208,
0.3966856599,
-0.7866296172,
-0.6295555234,
-0.1049363911,
0.0357906707,
0.3021246791,
0.440579325,
0.1121581346,
0.8969085813,
0.9582350254,
-0.3310090899,
0.3699459136,
0.1817758083,
-0.5501741767,
0.7679255605,
-0.6788392663,
0.0661116689,
-0.2120264918,
-0.1431252807,
-1.0316838026,
0.1352817416,
0.0709978491,
-0.3606357872,
0.0787686333,
-0.3564413786,
-0.5716589093,
-0.3247184157,
-0.1631979793,
0.3845669627,
0.3060337007,
-0.7344670892,
0.97438097,
0.0741505027,
0.2521599233,
-0.7166466117,
-0.6367949843,
0.302265048,
-0.0481680334,
-0.983528614,
0.1009505019,
-0.0671644583,
-0.2637833953,
0.2256059051,
-0.0734129846,
-0.169115141,
-0.0178090744,
0.314684242,
0.5489245653,
-0.5361241698,
0.0962481871,
-0.4194675684,
-0.062780261,
-0.0222313609,
-0.0932387784,
0.2064187676,
-0.7636870146,
-0.8106722236,
-0.1199218333,
0.2532617748,
0.8966853023,
-0.627121985,
0.816734612,
0.8458205462,
-0.0180775113,
0.1172461808,
-0.8276690841,
0.0783129632,
-0.3578003049,
0.299131155,
-0.7939091325,
-0.7657881379,
0.2662509978,
-0.1657162756,
-0.109927088,
0.2719623744,
0.5434280634,
-0.1067231819,
0.9006928802,
0.5451840758,
0.0832609534,
0.3393405974,
-0.0526733696,
0.1522366107,
-0.8322030902,
-0.2962804139,
-0.2686654031,
-0.2857323587,
-0.2534095347,
-0.9229121804,
0.4740491211,
0.126997456,
-0.113417685,
0.1927223057,
-0.2226807028,
0.6824961901,
0.7225462198,
0.0597285666,
0.500893414,
-0.1741851419,
-0.3755719662,
0.0689231828,
-0.5517822504,
-0.3172979355,
1.0083779097,
0.2386740446,
0.7940765619,
0.2552994192,
0.1998647898,
-0.1611555666,
0.4099881351,
-0.5756732821,
0.561665833,
-0.0592418574,
-0.546212554,
-0.0509077571,
-0.4981571436,
-0.6555603743,
0.9903250337,
-0.3089061975,
-0.5446674824,
0.2011216134,
0.1885586828,
0.1348241568,
0.5062099695,
-0.903339386,
1.2390635014,
-0.4929299951,
-0.6031837463,
-0.2185589969,
-0.7086371779,
0.7039214373,
0.1045406163,
0.4316495955,
-0.4347065985,
0.0407719351,
0.1481103003,
0.024016697,
0.4773560762,
-0.1818158478,
0.3798578382,
0.0862328187,
0.0723188072,
0.0992251188,
-0.0397652574,
0.164174974,
0.5296395421,
0.0326639488,
-0.268445909,
-0.372643292,
0.5604284406,
-0.6794432402,
-0.2645213306,
-0.2648267746,
-0.5151643753,
-0.3565101624,
0.2896832228,
-0.0092124837,
0.5207106471,
-0.1724058688,
0.3802423179,
0.4471406043,
-0.4294749796,
0.3338582516,
0.570093751,
-0.4637654126,
-0.4128324389,
0.6495313048,
-0.330899626,
0.3741285503,
0.2910695374,
0.1398692727,
-0.356358856,
-0.655413866,
-0.6597422361,
0.1853666157,
-1.1082979441,
-0.2749015987,
-0.6670084596,
0.1824620515,
-0.3543080986,
0.1531563252,
-0.3922640979,
0.0241500102,
0.0147760799,
0.2541145086,
0.2332931906,
0.7434226274,
-0.0552947968,
-0.058953017,
-0.917805016,
0.8466026783,
0.5061348081,
0.833265841,
-0.0911122411,
-0.3661949635,
-0.1276492923,
-0.3149753213,
-0.2346388251,
-0.8362601995,
0.0801640004,
0.0910751075,
0.8285759687,
0.3304436207,
-0.5053827763,
0.9969224334,
-0.70564574,
0.5686713457,
0.4486542046,
-0.8873771429,
0.5220347643,
-0.1674880385,
0.4871947467,
0.5366182923,
0.2291801125,
-0.4949732423,
-0.1674211621,
-0.3389441371,
-0.6015831232,
0.5059464574,
0.2262985855,
-0.4094134271,
0.1860443354,
-0.1417981684,
0.0915722623,
0.2226193845,
-0.8588585258,
-0.0838231891,
-0.3557706475,
0.092301622,
-0.0520530827,
-0.0204178579,
-0.0708321109,
-0.3703555167,
0.3105950058,
-0.3154245317,
0.3472335339,
0.0412247442,
-0.3709274232,
0.083340019,
0.254789114,
0.4994518757,
0.893094182,
-0.1341252923,
0.4769836068,
-0.003185903,
-0.197533533,
-0.0531792082,
0.1101216599,
0.1151614189,
-0.0447825566,
0.5713195801,
1.1291532516,
0.1254623532,
-0.619471848,
0.7816815376,
-0.4777221084,
-0.2387976646,
0.1625122279,
-0.1381410211,
0.3515765667,
0.4940552115,
0.0104980739,
0.5775988698,
0.2022420466,
-0.5780876875,
0.1475213617,
0.6039769053,
-0.0872955471,
-0.2116758823,
0.7231003046,
-0.0632336363,
0.0493068919,
0.6261345744,
-0.0874860659,
-0.4283962846,
0.5306274295,
0.2918915153,
0.590667963,
0.2002991885,
-0.0450122133,
0.3904912174,
0.5203219652,
0.0430541784,
0.460752219,
-0.1139498577,
-0.9085026383,
-0.5607705712,
-0.4813962579,
-0.5585517883,
0.0616613142,
-0.5577065945,
0.2102029175,
-0.2440463305,
-0.1322653741,
0.1608542502,
-0.609474659,
-1.1845427752,
0.0978187472,
0.4588903487,
0.8533645868,
-0.7472992539,
0.8493437767,
0.6734318137,
-0.5989086628,
-0.6064440012,
-0.2924648821,
0.1001334116,
-1.0559315681,
0.7774463296,
0.5122174025,
-0.410238415,
-0.2992368937,
-0.628890276,
-0.9003612399,
1.0452708006,
0.385822773,
-0.5155594349,
0.416356355,
-0.1578605771,
0.3366259634,
-0.3029580116,
0.3709661961,
0.5840920806,
0.6509305835,
0.1887770742,
-0.8167601228,
-0.1748622209,
-0.3305217922,
0.1293232143,
0.3082110882,
-0.6008166075,
0.995365262,
-0.4811204374,
-0.1230198815,
-0.1419723034,
0.3963212371,
0.3901293278,
0.3487768769,
0.5883992314,
0.7529283762,
0.4363179505,
-0.2170455605,
0.9361758232,
-0.1386638433,
0.3053138256,
1.2010946274,
-0.3005088866,
0.7987504601,
0.6087120175,
-0.2241023779,
0.3218262792,
0.3408537209,
-0.3245056868,
0.5634546876,
-0.0688429698,
-0.0775043443,
-0.4603117108,
0.0705039576,
-0.3263246417,
0.6251316071,
0.1521890014,
-0.3216302097,
-0.2234837711,
0.0653311238,
-0.5512771606,
-0.1992312074,
-0.2125477344,
0.7068644166,
-0.069946155,
-0.5953159928,
0.4228590727,
-0.1945052743,
0.5707888603,
-0.4231541157,
-0.1719638407,
0.0390743203,
0.2191147357,
0.054080151,
-1.0026817322,
0.1458058059,
-0.0472556911,
-0.0819607899,
-0.2225468457,
0.9622098207,
-0.2667492032,
-0.4433570802,
0.5398418307,
0.8072724342,
0.240109548,
-0.2954221666,
-0.770719707,
0.3756189048,
-0.1317355186,
-0.2503401637,
0.0943079442,
0.5032155514,
0.1414542049,
0.7887482643,
0.6389876604,
-0.0651079938,
0.2412455529,
0.4613606334,
0.9047118425,
-0.8779180646,
-0.1006732285,
-0.9799244404,
0.4330565333,
-0.1374225616,
-0.2514131367,
0.6427481174,
0.4565698206,
0.79360044,
-0.1468384713,
0.6736574769,
0.0577038527,
0.2195632011,
-0.5872787237,
0.397115171,
-0.830593586,
-0.0165730044,
-0.4331863821,
-0.8072446585,
-0.4526040554,
0.6576676965,
-0.1969128698,
-0.0343976803,
0.8830953836,
0.5881078243,
-0.2326688617,
0.0077808085,
0.6376989484,
0.0408290587,
0.3301230371,
0.5137723088,
1.151743412,
-0.2599943876,
0.6403160095,
-0.2361392826,
-0.1344404072,
0.0186087471,
-1.1919956207,
-0.8894163966,
-0.4495960176,
-0.0138493236,
0.0741974041,
-0.1472385377,
0.4372030497,
0.8319519758,
-0.539394021,
-0.0034706353,
0.0720666423,
0.1072922722,
-0.3534689844,
-0.1153766513,
0.1306812465,
-0.1864438355,
-0.3385705948,
0.4130226672,
0.8393482566,
0.0546399988,
-0.313293308,
-0.0368147194,
-0.3037812412,
-0.2277932018,
0.7776294947,
-0.1073753461,
-1.0167832375,
-0.2257889211,
0.0812302455,
-0.001127946,
0.507686615,
0.6977105141,
-0.8907929063,
0.7733297348,
0.428811729,
0.7115331292,
0.6805116534,
-0.0042895954,
0.3233578801,
-0.445366025,
0.0981398672,
0.140580073,
0.8233876824,
0.4894555807,
0.1140277982,
0.6422618628,
0.2922381163,
-0.5424123406,
-0.5651741028,
0.2376565933,
-0.9801449776,
-0.5379071832,
0.8843933344,
-0.1411331892,
-0.1345396489,
0.1480669677,
-0.0738577247,
-0.0016626465,
-0.0706346557,
0.2347336113,
0.7785388827,
-0.2670671344,
-0.7343668938,
-0.7685113549,
-0.1616840661,
0.2644272745,
-1.0739690065,
-0.0079874126,
0.9797228575,
0.2975085676,
0.0504427366,
0.6725872159,
-0.1053465009,
0.4273382425,
0.1950309575,
0.1601557881,
-0.2201960236,
-0.6937125325,
-0.2633242607,
0.142542094,
0.1145590767,
-0.3890706301
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12739v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12739v1 | Self-Distillation for Model Stacking Unlocks Cross-Lingual NLU in 200+ Languages | 2024-06-18T16:00:20 | 2024-06-18T16:00:20 | Fabian David Schmidt, Philipp Borchert, Ivan Vulić, Goran Glavaš | cs.CL | cs.CL | LLMs have become a go-to solution not just for text generation, but also for
natural language understanding (NLU) tasks. Acquiring extensive knowledge
through language modeling on web-scale corpora, they excel on English NLU, yet
struggle to extend their NLU capabilities to underrepresented languages. In
contrast, machine translation models (MT) produce excellent multilingual
representations, resulting in strong translation performance even for
low-resource languages. MT encoders, however, lack the knowledge necessary for
comprehensive NLU that LLMs obtain through language modeling training on
immense corpora. In this work, we get the best both worlds by integrating MT
encoders directly into LLM backbones via sample-efficient self-distillation.
The resulting MT-LLMs preserve the inherent multilingual representational
alignment from the MT encoder, allowing lower-resource languages to tap into
the rich knowledge embedded in English-centric LLMs. Merging the MT encoder and
LLM in a single model, we mitigate the propagation of translation errors and
inference overhead of MT decoding inherent to discrete translation-based
cross-lingual transfer (e.g., translate-test). Evaluation spanning three
prominent NLU tasks and 127 predominantly low-resource languages renders
MT-LLMs highly effective in cross-lingual transfer. MT-LLMs substantially and
consistently outperform translate-test based on the same MT model, showing that
we truly unlock multilingual language understanding for LLMs. | [
-0.2749707103,
-0.3712501228,
0.3989258409,
0.3452984989,
-0.308976233,
0.3903912306,
-0.1010776982,
-0.4145878553,
0.00931268,
0.6051955819,
-0.5263268352,
-0.3481300473,
-0.5795573592,
0.5176107883,
-0.2669531107,
1.0850845575,
-0.1458499283,
0.2233676761,
-0.3998829126,
-0.0229320116,
-0.3013445437,
-0.6317157745,
-0.3693504035,
-0.5310413837,
0.4765054286,
0.0093063004,
0.2714753747,
0.5937984586,
0.3121520877,
0.3364951015,
0.01769666,
0.4312680364,
-0.6594427228,
-0.0234718155,
-0.0617872477,
-0.6868056059,
-0.5804453492,
-0.0377572216,
0.5191216469,
0.6621360779,
-0.2037307471,
0.1532297581,
0.3977884352,
0.6090497375,
-0.5236035585,
0.038057588,
-0.810036242,
0.1712530404,
-0.101254873,
-0.1764567941,
-0.5654122233,
0.0072384956,
-0.0932336822,
-0.6050899625,
0.1221182272,
0.1848725379,
0.6082756519,
0.4890966713,
-0.4927918315,
-0.2613542974,
-0.6583118439,
0.9339283109,
-0.7183620334,
0.5205984712,
0.240175426,
0.313519001,
-0.0878473818,
-0.5172436833,
-0.4809707999,
0.0950850546,
-0.3767611086,
0.3229343891,
-0.3958805799,
-0.1486742944,
-0.1240237132,
0.6413523555,
-0.7123051286,
0.3570922911,
-0.5213527083,
-0.0243678298,
0.4521995783,
0.1502359062,
0.2207161933,
-0.4273989499,
-0.7495931983,
0.0144375479,
-0.719498992,
-0.1838642657,
0.2455103844,
0.2804305553,
-0.2188636512,
0.4201630652,
0.134622857,
0.5369796157,
0.3855502903,
-0.1095565557,
0.299311161,
-0.5426831841,
-0.4022478163,
0.0608148575,
1.0989553928,
0.0847524628,
0.1629624516,
-0.2968632877,
-0.1502378732,
-0.2016092241,
0.1851400137,
-0.8902802467,
-0.1436052024,
0.1710684896,
-0.287683934,
-0.2102614939,
-0.3981162012,
-0.6087645292,
-0.0703691915,
-0.2371254265,
0.2444863915,
-0.3192395866,
-0.353289187,
0.2013024986,
-0.0436370745,
0.0290681496,
0.0406376272,
-1.0164011717,
0.1575038284,
0.4408345222,
0.70330441,
-0.5351048708,
-0.3735332191,
-0.4386225939,
0.3134488761,
-0.327501148,
0.5581393838,
-0.1632590145,
-0.3932141066,
-0.2712509036,
0.0404788069,
-0.1851449758,
-0.7005197406,
0.261751771,
-0.533780098,
0.3931283057,
0.0052202339,
-0.3814921975,
-0.1156569645,
0.3964173794,
-0.587782979,
1.1809067726,
-0.2053087354,
-0.685752809,
0.1095310822,
-0.4653603733,
-0.3913670778,
-0.0138110425,
-0.0571440309,
-0.2483540326,
0.2961176336,
0.6171370745,
0.5741580129,
-0.3626333475,
0.261331141,
-0.3284544647,
-0.0389105044,
0.0438706167,
-0.5892682076,
0.8298814893,
0.4139239788,
-0.0422595702,
-0.0752420947,
-0.6746413708,
-0.1932006776,
0.1025505513,
-0.4126679301,
-0.7180867195,
-0.4001538455,
-0.1619483382,
0.3931311369,
0.3781221807,
-0.3861029446,
0.1865836531,
-0.2665523887,
0.3815512657,
0.6711441875,
-0.3811754882,
0.6552864909,
-0.103391543,
0.5603340864,
0.2026880234,
-0.0736368224,
-0.2028183192,
-0.1611564159,
-0.8063901067,
-0.4266214669,
0.4201550484,
0.6269239187,
-0.9298920631,
0.4888806045,
-0.5201401711,
-0.3567378223,
-0.9214884639,
0.5428917408,
0.4719308615,
0.559431076,
0.5944314003,
-0.1502408534,
-0.4691619277,
-0.9194195271,
-0.136119023,
-0.0679257214,
-0.1896104217,
-0.1319755316,
0.4219020009,
-0.2408246994,
0.7700349689,
-0.1970371604,
-0.3282812536,
-0.6088292599,
0.3060595393,
0.322855711,
0.4416110516,
0.4553748071,
-0.6813736558,
-0.5075645447,
0.082802102,
-1.0840981007,
-0.3047018945,
-0.1355571449,
-0.3172700703,
0.2375196218,
0.4230313897,
-0.3914457262,
0.0649566799,
0.9765054584,
0.0563921481,
0.3785187304,
-0.535172224,
0.0841482431,
-1.4262799025,
-0.0470187962,
-0.1439587474,
-0.3691165447,
-0.5690078139,
-0.0539089888,
0.2667266726,
0.1326444894,
-0.5256109238,
0.478420198,
-0.949601233,
-0.2057358474,
-0.2559464872,
0.3598468304,
0.4722943902,
0.5165643692,
0.0356756561,
0.6798718572,
0.307875663,
-0.6063890457,
0.1093313769,
0.166848436,
-0.2157475799,
0.6177345514,
-0.5178689957,
0.0803664252,
-0.1644192785,
0.3518821597,
-0.9794368148,
0.2763536274,
-0.0217710529,
-0.1691866219,
0.4259070754,
-0.3755334914,
-0.468534708,
-0.350946337,
-0.0351744406,
0.4829280078,
0.4686604738,
-0.8124074936,
0.9166827798,
0.3751139343,
-0.0179892574,
-0.780508697,
-1.1451010704,
0.0516501069,
-0.3705107272,
-0.5934140682,
0.4092755914,
-0.1897810549,
-0.0112987533,
-0.0031886979,
-0.1297111809,
-0.0008667,
0.0830957666,
0.0152175976,
0.3906781673,
-0.1308579147,
0.054886166,
0.2199879736,
-0.2281757295,
0.0453125462,
-0.553117156,
0.5259523988,
-0.0300522726,
-0.4656968117,
-0.2846985459,
0.3246190846,
0.5910265446,
-0.4139708877,
0.6495703459,
0.5824041367,
-0.2179884017,
-0.3045544922,
-0.62742275,
-0.0366327651,
-0.4558060765,
0.3051316142,
-0.8207473159,
-0.8810791969,
0.5802310109,
-0.1747261882,
0.2016677856,
0.4960568547,
0.5538802743,
-0.2342382222,
0.8772379756,
0.6079566479,
-0.2399532646,
0.147163257,
-0.3781790435,
0.1538428366,
-0.95516783,
-0.092535831,
-0.2099205256,
-0.3423298597,
-0.60923177,
-0.7790882587,
0.4313842654,
0.2599915862,
0.2599489689,
0.435662657,
-0.4137034416,
0.4853615463,
0.3160353601,
-0.1752541661,
0.6512060761,
0.1834873259,
-0.508874774,
-0.1536782235,
-0.9721736312,
-0.3115717173,
1.0013753176,
0.3120649755,
0.9443523884,
0.0494000539,
0.9727600813,
0.0849872753,
0.2317854911,
-0.5668839216,
0.2955684364,
-0.4549735785,
-0.54233253,
-0.1171026304,
-0.6057665348,
-0.8773522377,
0.7144716382,
-0.0034135515,
-0.2859502137,
0.2014591098,
0.1867219359,
-0.2662807405,
0.5083012581,
-0.5810654163,
1.0345016718,
-0.7753118277,
-0.3784631789,
-0.2116133273,
-0.4759860337,
0.5037067533,
-0.2676852942,
0.6070075035,
-0.1612879932,
0.0950745717,
0.3892128766,
-0.1930088997,
0.8895925879,
0.2059852779,
-0.4757371843,
0.0901705399,
0.3374528289,
0.3995239735,
-0.2181295156,
-0.073358573,
0.4615795314,
-0.0714128315,
-0.2460104674,
-0.7043417096,
0.7209960222,
-0.6921571493,
-0.6507623792,
-0.331899941,
-0.6339306831,
0.1048211753,
0.1185779944,
0.2802574337,
0.257327199,
-0.2126557827,
0.1066272631,
0.5865160227,
-0.1206185892,
0.38137272,
0.6090975404,
-0.5327242017,
-0.3460682631,
0.7569360733,
0.0162463188,
0.6659225225,
0.7510373592,
0.1999206543,
-0.5428500772,
-0.5570517778,
-0.8508485556,
0.2809416354,
-0.6999793053,
-0.199180603,
-0.834746778,
-0.0878991559,
-0.3711442351,
-0.0346234888,
-0.6613739729,
-0.3728970587,
-0.2204806656,
-0.2085554898,
0.1555964649,
0.683686614,
-0.3825155497,
0.0959070697,
-0.9868429303,
0.4266645908,
0.2969511449,
-0.096489273,
-0.1819483042,
-0.7854178548,
-0.3199153543,
0.1008939072,
-0.0260485392,
-0.6476891637,
0.7566293478,
0.0480959639,
0.6244931221,
0.2032749504,
0.1571677327,
1.0192693472,
-0.6349176764,
0.5451923609,
0.2634159029,
-0.8812773824,
0.3216068447,
-0.103595376,
0.4855630696,
0.5711233616,
0.6018694043,
-0.5087157488,
-0.4403060377,
-0.1451152861,
-0.8568158746,
0.4937260151,
0.132022351,
0.055944819,
-0.0096685542,
0.0562589243,
0.3045087159,
0.0941716805,
-1.0196230412,
-0.2501946092,
-0.2199721336,
-0.3300450444,
-0.1218530238,
-0.1292391866,
-0.1243904084,
-0.1541145891,
0.5531314015,
-0.2107167989,
-0.115120478,
0.158296138,
-0.5469568968,
0.0681096017,
0.3152670562,
0.167486757,
0.416988492,
-0.0963940471,
0.6329164505,
0.5247601271,
-0.1671710014,
0.1293819547,
0.1081873775,
0.0053254026,
-0.0333738662,
0.1751881689,
0.7901197076,
0.5055106878,
-0.3371669352,
0.1280829161,
-0.0501483679,
-0.0368190892,
-0.1719375104,
-0.2670893967,
0.414817661,
0.1145614535,
0.4994395077,
-0.1865856797,
0.1457027942,
-0.5041406751,
0.1430800706,
0.4197263718,
-0.1288312227,
-0.3281778693,
0.8051412106,
0.3362518251,
0.0364581943,
0.5361651182,
-0.2076052129,
-0.546292603,
0.3015699983,
0.8299608827,
0.8442900777,
-0.2866984606,
-0.0497359261,
0.4387373626,
0.3462609947,
-0.0322658829,
-0.1623767912,
-0.1333464235,
-0.7687051296,
-0.494614929,
-0.9591380954,
-0.2065044045,
0.0320580639,
-0.6145502925,
0.0835167989,
0.024814358,
0.0605338924,
-0.237809062,
-0.1913883537,
-0.643161118,
-0.0053149592,
0.3511421978,
0.7392374873,
-0.7807511687,
1.0450297594,
0.3080524206,
-0.2523865998,
-0.5366418362,
-0.3222523332,
0.0086643295,
-0.9079238176,
0.8896576166,
0.2042099535,
-0.4512012899,
0.0736623108,
-0.1226860508,
-0.8231033087,
1.2436207533,
0.4972200692,
-0.8446266651,
-0.1896418035,
0.4696910977,
0.5363125801,
-0.5305748582,
0.30534181,
0.4150975943,
0.319516331,
0.2311567664,
-1.0733370781,
0.0420879349,
-0.3479308486,
0.0706287622,
0.045123145,
-0.4254393578,
0.7779772878,
-0.1049767211,
-0.3936430812,
-0.2373876572,
0.6966690421,
0.4819263816,
0.0427258685,
0.5049241781,
0.6793181896,
0.6912107468,
0.053899169,
1.0843186378,
-0.413816452,
0.1948501766,
1.3425258398,
-0.2462230772,
0.9303165078,
0.590928793,
-0.1261642724,
0.5412910581,
0.5017259717,
0.0643067658,
0.5031207204,
0.1097169369,
-0.0827656835,
-0.5179955959,
0.0217492413,
-0.3427089453,
0.4777116179,
0.2731868327,
-0.2514493763,
-0.2975867987,
-0.0238525309,
0.0018711856,
0.132309407,
-0.2091716826,
0.7726255655,
0.3573879898,
-0.6482782364,
0.8717753291,
-0.1092271507,
1.1111249924,
-0.748973012,
0.1456812024,
-0.3553188145,
0.3025983274,
-0.1081162393,
-0.6243866086,
0.4811801016,
0.1677321494,
-0.1859176457,
-0.7797427773,
0.6000004411,
-0.8145876527,
-0.7266563177,
0.8274809122,
0.9108504057,
0.4179148376,
0.0376567282,
-0.6469837427,
-0.1249309406,
-0.0625204518,
-0.0296624042,
0.4978469908,
0.6749038696,
0.1612693369,
0.6909969449,
0.8092449903,
-0.016278429,
0.3541406691,
0.1152425334,
0.7124099135,
-0.3618283272,
-0.4038718343,
-1.0854645967,
0.571687758,
-0.0196610708,
0.0098315952,
0.9491375685,
0.790165782,
1.0206263065,
-0.0976478085,
0.7910914421,
0.1656335294,
0.1976273507,
-0.6247256398,
0.8874835372,
-0.840516448,
0.3073239028,
0.0533947274,
-0.6367985606,
-0.1083361804,
0.5018072128,
-0.2864942253,
-0.2381160408,
0.5828056335,
0.5602927804,
-0.2706455588,
-0.3581611514,
0.5187632442,
0.1626527309,
0.1673215479,
0.6679469943,
0.71941787,
-0.4654066563,
0.8294400573,
-0.2019114345,
0.0113883289,
-0.0393239856,
-1.03916502,
-1.1179360151,
-0.3706115484,
-0.159671396,
-0.0000934991,
-0.1100975499,
0.7918953896,
0.7995833158,
-0.7573944926,
-0.5844958425,
0.0607529618,
0.2389141172,
-0.1728558838,
-0.1637142748,
0.0815633535,
-0.4477091134,
-1.1027082205,
0.7698025107,
0.3640009165,
0.1383183599,
-0.6041992903,
-0.2263009548,
-0.2303098738,
-0.0895657465,
0.6074419022,
-0.0178821869,
-0.7863656878,
0.2068419904,
0.1625183076,
-0.3645128906,
0.3598850965,
0.5422506332,
-0.7863758206,
0.5478528142,
0.5754929185,
0.7233955264,
0.8144866824,
-0.1618854553,
0.9223712087,
-0.8456345201,
0.0913246423,
-0.0620021112,
0.5713896155,
0.5347158313,
-0.3059894741,
0.5399395823,
0.1066999286,
-0.2575270236,
-0.813197732,
0.1964665502,
-0.7990521193,
-0.3226980567,
0.8969649076,
-0.3163718581,
-0.3089450002,
-0.0063939183,
0.1629194319,
0.3965200186,
-0.1239241883,
0.7352902889,
0.5668181181,
0.007271341,
-0.3341169357,
-0.5007051229,
0.2560932636,
0.4609867036,
-0.8804782033,
0.181695804,
0.2591100633,
0.45208776,
0.3090316653,
0.5114852786,
-0.1675843149,
-0.2696501017,
-0.2174840271,
0.2725958526,
-0.2343365252,
-0.293053031,
-0.4065269828,
0.0758987665,
-0.2440802306,
-0.266749382
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12738v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12738v1 | Large Language Model as a Universal Clinical Multi-task Decoder | 2024-06-18T15:58:36 | 2024-06-18T15:58:36 | Yujiang Wu, Hongjian Song, Jiawen Zhang, Xumeng Wen, Shun Zheng, Jiang Bian | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The development of effective machine learning methodologies for enhancing the
efficiency and accuracy of clinical systems is crucial. Despite significant
research efforts, managing a plethora of diversified clinical tasks and
adapting to emerging new tasks remain significant challenges. This paper
presents a novel paradigm that employs a pre-trained large language model as a
universal clinical multi-task decoder. This approach leverages the flexibility
and diversity of language expressions to handle task topic variations and
associated arguments. The introduction of a new task simply requires the
addition of a new instruction template. We validate this framework across
hundreds of tasks, demonstrating its robustness in facilitating multi-task
predictions, performing on par with traditional multi-task learning and
single-task learning approaches. Moreover, it shows exceptional adaptability to
new tasks, with impressive zero-shot performance in some instances and superior
data efficiency in few-shot scenarios. This novel approach offers a unified
solution to manage a wide array of new and emerging tasks in clinical
applications. | [
0.1000367925,
-0.5882712603,
0.6032119989,
0.2794181108,
-0.361489892,
-0.3728189468,
-0.4915854633,
-0.1067036539,
0.0219854899,
0.5667129755,
-0.4046459794,
-0.6308941245,
-0.9989757538,
0.1512538344,
-0.1647501737,
0.9629340768,
-0.0309398901,
0.5020872951,
0.0272083301,
-0.1565976143,
-0.6822255254,
-0.7076367736,
-0.5329079032,
-0.3906259835,
0.5854842663,
0.3482372463,
0.3538411558,
0.6769510508,
0.5490942597,
0.2618351579,
0.4094056785,
0.0971181095,
-0.3308172524,
0.0952369273,
-0.1253340393,
-0.2828696072,
-0.7207945585,
-0.4990988374,
0.6067335606,
0.9437064528,
-0.3509324789,
-0.1332648098,
0.136216864,
0.3247404695,
-0.8979234099,
0.3286310732,
-0.7517908812,
-0.0212295782,
-0.1138334423,
-0.228530854,
-0.7404032946,
0.4398921132,
0.1836626381,
-0.6443737745,
0.1459614336,
-0.6408142447,
0.3146739602,
0.1564882696,
-0.6934588552,
-0.2978607714,
-0.6552317739,
0.6492110491,
-0.4574210942,
0.5362315178,
0.0670862868,
0.4525378048,
-0.1256714463,
-0.8296859264,
-0.3974590302,
-0.1524218172,
0.1365103573,
0.0654558092,
-0.1895735413,
0.1504728049,
-0.0746197402,
-0.1562876552,
-0.6367992759,
0.2259263843,
-0.0590525717,
-0.1315234452,
0.3343220353,
0.4178858995,
0.4167426527,
0.0871885866,
-0.0844529718,
0.0748578012,
-0.5895017982,
-0.2348376364,
-0.5001725554,
0.5716289878,
-0.1202342883,
0.2235704809,
-0.1433658898,
0.635876894,
-0.1641016752,
-0.3998105824,
0.1982727349,
-0.0217986777,
-0.5254038572,
0.0778190196,
0.8172547221,
0.0727055371,
-0.1524698138,
-0.2143949121,
0.2039997578,
0.2102383077,
0.6753686666,
-0.8157817125,
-0.1606440842,
0.2277450562,
-0.4910775423,
-0.0476339273,
-0.3080747426,
-0.6256320477,
-0.4040203691,
-0.3862729669,
0.2637129724,
-0.5990797877,
-0.261534512,
0.657949388,
0.3588567972,
-0.0184895732,
0.7178780437,
-0.8678445816,
0.2029436529,
0.6829465628,
0.5965813398,
-0.2653164864,
-0.4800946414,
-0.8497518897,
0.2961004078,
-0.2938478589,
0.5695399642,
-0.517670989,
-0.2171522677,
0.1573214233,
0.3307056427,
-0.350844413,
-0.2436158359,
0.534094274,
-0.2182698399,
0.0429530703,
0.0512949489,
-0.3517012894,
0.0291263796,
0.3497451246,
-0.4912255406,
0.283937484,
0.1794726998,
-0.5058197379,
0.3174030185,
-0.8950887918,
-0.5225625634,
0.3289572299,
-0.1644583046,
-0.3284557164,
0.2080738395,
0.3265341222,
0.8117870688,
-0.3974274099,
0.4965840876,
-0.333904475,
-0.1492158324,
0.0308564622,
-0.3376683593,
0.6613555551,
0.2673694789,
-0.1833921969,
0.278200984,
-0.7185845971,
-0.051646892,
0.1271345615,
-0.3212073743,
-0.1497624218,
-0.2689554989,
0.3610172272,
0.229850769,
0.128087759,
-0.5314492583,
0.2086995393,
0.0015406345,
0.4181362391,
0.2603726983,
-0.1963915974,
0.1583763957,
-0.2422945648,
0.7081244588,
0.0971595123,
0.165663898,
-0.576597929,
-0.2239842415,
-0.4822012484,
-0.6202805042,
0.1348358393,
0.6952990294,
-0.6156833172,
0.2715702355,
-0.3578920066,
-0.4620396495,
-0.5765498281,
0.1197371483,
0.4284127653,
0.3727914393,
0.4722038507,
-0.2075187266,
-0.5653395057,
-0.5977178216,
-0.0148905795,
0.3685269058,
-0.0987070054,
0.0708695501,
0.5457144976,
-0.7287067771,
0.2790290415,
-0.3782727122,
-0.4056028724,
-0.5601593256,
0.2439085096,
0.3128201365,
0.729817152,
0.2212710977,
-0.6605935693,
-0.4323158264,
0.1756536067,
-0.9949789643,
0.3533970714,
-0.4010686874,
-0.0806789771,
-0.0419555493,
0.4746750295,
-0.6204154491,
0.2030730993,
0.5206869841,
-0.0645396411,
0.5925034881,
-0.7350171804,
0.1172353327,
-1.3124032021,
0.1845964044,
-0.0633681118,
-0.1214490831,
-0.8885483146,
0.2215711921,
0.3912604451,
-0.2662829459,
-0.4172909856,
0.3670767248,
-0.4145254791,
0.418863982,
-0.5152667165,
-0.3387093842,
-0.1156297177,
0.2631107867,
0.2271472812,
0.2847296894,
0.9905157685,
-0.54602772,
0.2320504338,
0.3759720922,
-0.216353327,
0.6123461127,
-0.6628771424,
0.1095975339,
-0.5153321624,
0.5005723238,
-0.6997270584,
-0.4647319615,
-0.1840468198,
-0.2503427267,
0.5058553219,
-0.1309212595,
-0.4839134812,
-0.4165854752,
0.0768307522,
0.4063457251,
0.3303821683,
-0.2317116112,
0.6158707738,
0.3947941661,
-0.2817790806,
-0.7622153759,
-0.5424179435,
0.2559760511,
0.0244253781,
-0.2480467409,
0.3056569099,
-0.121677272,
0.1938867271,
-0.1952698529,
0.0064158645,
-0.3274345994,
0.1770223528,
0.3298524618,
0.4088779986,
-0.3846265376,
0.3363170922,
0.2133519799,
-0.2372451574,
-0.1705774218,
-0.4321114421,
0.643327415,
0.2021498382,
-0.4503165781,
-0.6245196462,
0.6701613069,
0.8614195585,
-0.3240943253,
0.738902688,
0.6947532296,
-0.5486810207,
-0.0599185638,
-0.3537740111,
0.008433505,
-0.39779073,
0.9537079334,
-0.4159196615,
-1.0050110817,
0.1297218204,
-0.2022480667,
0.1813282222,
0.2248941511,
0.9488569498,
0.0453181639,
1.1857028008,
0.7416985035,
0.0761727765,
0.1574859917,
0.0223810375,
0.092372857,
-0.7568608522,
-0.124149017,
-0.4032456279,
0.1239982396,
-0.1611385942,
-0.5874116421,
0.5778172016,
0.0668426976,
-0.3439163864,
0.1586124599,
-0.4988046885,
0.2347577512,
0.1898380965,
0.2680966854,
0.2224792689,
-0.1675880104,
-0.0231019985,
0.1175610349,
-0.6619472504,
-0.4262511432,
1.6464091539,
0.3158330321,
0.5379291177,
-0.1065358371,
0.6453841329,
0.2189600766,
0.585702002,
-0.5501465201,
0.2640147805,
-0.626594007,
-0.5017659664,
-0.3026613891,
-0.1765867174,
-1.3277601004,
0.6384996176,
-0.3872925937,
-0.8019663692,
-0.2778245211,
0.2864059806,
-0.4707441032,
0.2257918268,
-0.574947238,
1.3153340816,
-0.25677073,
-0.1812670082,
-0.2078453898,
-0.6266363859,
0.2572005093,
-0.2440606207,
0.3321253061,
-0.0060990201,
0.0156045463,
0.4884864092,
-0.0712769032,
0.8028015494,
-0.1352347583,
-0.1393262297,
-0.182384938,
0.0761599988,
0.2512046993,
0.1213047579,
-0.0447982363,
-0.0264877174,
0.213365078,
-0.6180232167,
-0.4746400714,
0.6060029268,
-0.6801895499,
-0.3608633876,
-0.3407934904,
-1.0491616726,
-0.5683868527,
0.4345771372,
0.2298676223,
0.718999207,
-0.5269076228,
0.2284513265,
0.5353543758,
-0.3598141074,
0.0310716908,
0.6930981874,
0.1867976338,
-0.29775244,
0.6508840322,
-0.447457999,
0.2841500044,
0.7019202709,
0.127818197,
-0.2188434303,
-0.9516352415,
-0.3762410283,
0.2186937034,
-0.6571794748,
0.008808868,
-0.9737821817,
0.1120837778,
-0.7437486053,
-0.199566856,
-0.3327175975,
0.1408183426,
-0.1939511299,
0.1948126704,
-0.0560701936,
0.5598877668,
0.1436856836,
0.4654099047,
-1.150769949,
0.441819489,
0.3119594157,
0.200033918,
-0.0030293276,
-0.3986199796,
-0.3122110367,
0.0809377432,
-0.2762275338,
-0.7924621105,
0.5072199702,
0.2187695354,
0.6092763543,
0.3877931833,
-0.0634260476,
0.5274162292,
-0.9059801102,
0.4563398063,
0.6967797875,
-0.842875123,
0.3348691761,
-0.5139009356,
0.6927723289,
0.4946021438,
0.5645142794,
-0.6656692028,
-0.1543331146,
-0.2947536111,
-0.5420269966,
0.6342051029,
-0.3812011182,
0.2354842871,
0.0481367186,
0.0963906944,
0.5160267353,
0.289334476,
-0.5739694238,
-0.0764172003,
-0.1416324079,
-0.5034112334,
-0.4063865244,
-0.0787142068,
-0.2788668275,
-0.3274624646,
0.1644813418,
-0.5536488891,
0.5489885211,
-0.0571907759,
-0.3830050826,
0.0825887844,
0.6584818959,
0.5912613273,
0.7798127532,
-0.0373733155,
0.1429608464,
0.1423244625,
-0.5504185557,
0.0511484519,
0.1898031235,
0.3384483457,
-0.0098052323,
0.6602243185,
1.0107190609,
0.3435330391,
-0.9466018677,
0.5329049826,
-0.0509634092,
-0.3791714311,
-0.1307827085,
-0.1482087225,
0.1313061118,
0.1254438758,
0.2048053592,
0.0704047978,
0.0902879611,
-0.6907875538,
0.4703004062,
0.2767971754,
-0.5026777983,
-0.3327719569,
0.6131052375,
0.010828848,
-0.0911207944,
0.3124496639,
-0.1899378598,
-0.4516324401,
0.4853711128,
0.9276199341,
0.6404567361,
-0.3755240142,
0.3691781759,
0.1417157501,
-0.028995743,
-0.3382062912,
0.3693769276,
0.0402206369,
-0.6606765389,
-0.6828273535,
-0.4799257517,
-0.2141599953,
0.3970505297,
-0.7768403292,
0.1511407644,
-0.3394702673,
0.0345325209,
0.2234824747,
-0.4714828134,
-0.8684517145,
0.3485172689,
0.3660098612,
0.6283255816,
-0.6079206467,
1.3400262594,
0.7834742665,
-0.0891358107,
-0.594383955,
-0.1213842928,
0.0984092504,
-0.9805746675,
0.5256617665,
0.2035610676,
0.2118487656,
-0.2510694265,
-0.1263050884,
-0.6372077465,
0.7706517577,
0.5944154263,
-0.5565494299,
-0.2824059725,
0.2076621205,
0.5867117643,
-0.7203046083,
0.2362799644,
0.384437412,
0.1193783283,
-0.021677345,
-1.2545471191,
0.2689479589,
-0.265095979,
-0.1676297933,
0.2842080295,
-0.1111733913,
1.021204114,
-0.3843079209,
0.1406565309,
0.1366344392,
0.2353319079,
0.1071721688,
0.2580089271,
0.4346745908,
0.3183518648,
0.7030106783,
0.1584040523,
1.0507893562,
-0.2992353141,
0.3193148971,
1.1663807631,
-0.6897861958,
0.7198828459,
0.2154171616,
-0.1311471611,
0.3785280883,
-0.0068963794,
0.1287215352,
0.4159728289,
0.0762090757,
-0.2967318892,
-0.6711070538,
-0.1025543213,
-0.3776748776,
0.6888772249,
0.5835316181,
-0.2693373859,
-0.4923717082,
0.6065639853,
-0.028994916,
0.0122622298,
-0.3864203095,
0.6357653737,
0.0380428843,
-0.6826182604,
0.823015511,
-0.1131622791,
0.659670949,
-0.9500119686,
-0.0749084726,
0.411074698,
0.5816084743,
0.0545565449,
-0.2654936612,
0.0760349259,
-0.1919099689,
-0.053507071,
-0.2555481195,
0.4558198154,
-0.5378394723,
-0.5549426079,
0.2396918833,
0.5170804858,
-0.1662053764,
-0.2523701489,
-0.7432550192,
0.2249825895,
-0.0232087839,
0.2766607106,
0.7004366517,
0.6191244125,
0.1196753532,
0.5991518497,
0.6243776083,
0.2327428609,
-0.0972702652,
0.1134201288,
0.6510035992,
-0.5925450921,
-0.7746470571,
-0.632768929,
0.4376142621,
-0.0037784877,
-0.4358269572,
0.4796105921,
0.2138686925,
0.4260356724,
-0.1970547736,
0.9740657806,
0.1621856689,
0.5071809292,
-0.3112882078,
0.5389300585,
-0.7482820153,
-0.1161525249,
-0.2822692096,
-0.2486111522,
-0.6161180139,
0.3273034692,
-0.1433365494,
-0.1685553342,
1.0422452688,
0.4218557477,
-0.1249469593,
0.1489858776,
0.517816186,
0.0860759467,
0.427108258,
1.0111322403,
0.3819106817,
-0.1628854126,
0.4468064606,
-0.0455580391,
-0.3760123551,
-0.2393356115,
-0.7700631022,
-0.8685308695,
-0.5540519953,
-0.3074251413,
-0.2693092227,
0.181179598,
1.1481852531,
1.1066867113,
-1.0174607038,
-0.2541785836,
0.0941538364,
-0.4365794957,
-0.4926949739,
-0.0807826072,
0.5185915828,
-0.5738859177,
-0.5981369019,
0.3947962523,
0.3848364055,
-0.2889893651,
0.0278072376,
-0.0541643314,
-0.0114608835,
-0.3037107289,
0.8642285466,
0.2967613339,
-0.5681327581,
0.2309122384,
-0.0047543151,
-0.2347798049,
0.0291372556,
1.1882940531,
-0.4709398448,
0.5889956951,
-0.0362367108,
1.0918027163,
0.5415599942,
-0.465087235,
0.6804692149,
-0.2901288271,
0.4265553355,
0.4884735942,
0.5243243575,
0.2223424613,
-0.3097824752,
0.0025745751,
0.1100000143,
-0.3252598643,
-0.8699153066,
0.3309955001,
-1.2000348568,
-0.582182765,
0.9017881155,
-0.3691105545,
-0.044907093,
-0.4312031865,
-0.1293488145,
0.2589339912,
-0.3017672002,
0.7500833273,
0.3901309371,
-0.1557208449,
-0.1139345318,
-0.6214967966,
0.2181890756,
0.4862107635,
-1.0381681919,
0.1410442889,
0.4822967947,
0.3929455578,
0.0780581683,
0.8821111321,
-0.2163097262,
0.5993605256,
-0.1425963938,
0.101658076,
-0.081305474,
-0.4776420593,
-0.357085228,
0.4823705256,
-0.1184452102,
-0.2775622606
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12725v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12725v1 | Can Large Language Models Code Like a Linguist?: A Case Study in Low Resource Sound Law Induction | 2024-06-18T15:46:04 | 2024-06-18T15:46:04 | Atharva Naik, Kexun Zhang, Nathaniel Robinson, Aravind Mysore, Clayton Marr, Hong Sng Rebecca Byrnes, Anna Cai, Kalvin Chang, David Mortensen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Historical linguists have long written a kind of incompletely formalized
''program'' that converts reconstructed words in an ancestor language into
words in one of its attested descendants that consist of a series of ordered
string rewrite functions (called sound laws). They do this by observing pairs
of words in the reconstructed language (protoforms) and the descendent language
(reflexes) and constructing a program that transforms protoforms into reflexes.
However, writing these programs is error-prone and time-consuming. Prior work
has successfully scaffolded this process computationally, but fewer researchers
have tackled Sound Law Induction (SLI), which we approach in this paper by
casting it as Programming by Examples. We propose a language-agnostic solution
that utilizes the programming ability of Large Language Models (LLMs) by
generating Python sound law programs from sound change examples. We evaluate
the effectiveness of our approach for various LLMs, propose effective methods
to generate additional language-agnostic synthetic data to fine-tune LLMs for
SLI, and compare our method with existing automated SLI methods showing that
while LLMs lag behind them they can complement some of their weaknesses. | [
0.1467373967,
-0.5834323764,
0.6769607663,
0.0371783711,
-0.0291518159,
-0.145380035,
-0.4943360686,
-0.4629685283,
0.301864624,
0.6212772131,
-0.6305488348,
-0.1407812238,
-0.322752893,
0.0878929421,
-0.5751240849,
0.708951354,
0.2270610929,
0.0041291728,
0.2436504215,
-0.2342562228,
-0.0659479201,
-0.4026679993,
-0.4711541533,
-0.4144491553,
0.0655400306,
0.0095572425,
0.5617527962,
0.6879778504,
0.031874422,
0.2848450243,
-0.3272519708,
-0.0212904904,
-0.4013977349,
-0.0507321209,
-0.1794500202,
-0.6720445752,
-0.2889408171,
-0.0362799503,
0.5250423551,
0.9121100903,
-0.4233531952,
0.1641399711,
-0.1178875193,
0.3608021736,
-0.635825336,
0.3175408244,
-0.859169066,
0.0700826347,
0.0402758606,
-0.3802667558,
-0.6314824224,
-0.4461657107,
-0.2827276587,
-0.6134106517,
0.0922134519,
0.0448063239,
0.4457974434,
0.5579790473,
0.0567874834,
-0.7406149507,
-0.8567875624,
0.9262337685,
-1.2863128185,
0.3224077821,
0.0958631486,
-0.0669866577,
-0.5888061523,
-0.3234111965,
-0.7866458297,
-0.3767207563,
-0.0101863574,
-0.1237874627,
-0.2170199454,
0.0983222201,
0.683157146,
0.2280175537,
-0.5596680045,
0.3157349825,
-0.4189631343,
-0.1537174731,
0.7090365291,
0.1944919527,
0.3544019759,
-0.126917854,
0.405136615,
-0.0065285778,
-0.8723801374,
-0.089159362,
0.4072974026,
0.6261539459,
-0.3185613751,
0.6396951079,
-0.198687762,
0.6125287414,
0.0471298993,
-0.5159209371,
0.3273615539,
-0.2882719934,
0.0324552394,
0.5742819309,
0.7189520597,
-0.152035892,
0.6490428448,
-0.1181311235,
-0.6216945052,
0.2091812789,
-0.0167864766,
-0.7144088149,
-0.0314392708,
0.2455989718,
-0.6134819984,
-0.2442787737,
-0.4951455295,
-0.3079091907,
-0.6731609106,
-0.5265533328,
0.253511399,
-0.3684242368,
-0.5016818047,
0.2370222956,
-0.0218910277,
0.5061503053,
-0.09577398,
-1.2058242559,
0.2087225765,
0.9197613597,
0.6736529469,
0.4386096895,
-0.3606657088,
-0.6025371552,
0.0923029557,
-0.4814968407,
0.3275354505,
-0.5688477755,
-0.523597002,
0.3429060578,
-0.2163912058,
0.2611657977,
-0.659491539,
0.27444309,
-0.2324315012,
-0.3163270056,
0.2920790613,
-0.4944445193,
0.3881593943,
-0.3062600493,
-0.5922152996,
0.5531561375,
0.2752990425,
-0.4177239239,
0.3727516234,
-0.6739711165,
-0.7107667327,
-0.0329361111,
-0.4418728054,
-0.3435741365,
0.4834044576,
-0.0337631144,
0.2416231036,
-0.2977798879,
0.5171140432,
-0.3754137158,
-0.6308040619,
0.259021312,
-0.3225234151,
1.0950491428,
0.3429986238,
-0.4405245781,
-0.1281954944,
-0.7547093034,
0.0619489476,
0.0902116969,
-0.5795897245,
-0.2541923523,
0.0729764476,
-0.1849546731,
-0.0201197751,
-0.1368639767,
-0.5795611143,
0.5766953826,
-0.6606729031,
0.8544163704,
0.5869863033,
-0.2540059388,
0.4574579,
-0.2890995741,
0.3282410502,
-0.197296083,
-0.2131109834,
-0.2817454636,
-0.2945075333,
-0.7333205342,
-0.0396343395,
0.284172982,
0.3871284425,
-0.6079452038,
0.1797719449,
-0.528568387,
-0.2245850116,
-0.8505929708,
0.2502282858,
0.2767044902,
0.1252211928,
0.0881115049,
0.1206510663,
-0.8877206445,
-0.7458451986,
-0.3457912207,
-0.4562751353,
-0.1312519163,
0.2449517548,
0.3970503211,
-0.2237351388,
0.596916914,
-0.2417511195,
0.084032245,
-0.3282916844,
0.4270866215,
0.7633393407,
0.4544683695,
0.5870841146,
-0.3125303984,
-0.029668441,
0.0221169945,
-0.7419846654,
-0.4877643585,
-0.2330231071,
0.1415177286,
0.2889540792,
0.6686725616,
-0.6215673685,
0.3278772235,
0.3471098542,
-0.1675756574,
0.9207426906,
-0.2578065693,
-0.0655668527,
-0.7583875656,
0.0549565032,
0.0419587232,
0.0780223534,
-0.8623462915,
0.2868218124,
-0.1904746592,
-0.3308263123,
-0.5178831816,
0.4024344981,
-0.407407403,
-0.2579833269,
-0.6821200252,
-0.3166018724,
-0.6016750932,
0.4090249538,
0.3164094388,
0.6400671601,
0.6546291709,
-0.6649366021,
0.3984589279,
-0.1079267934,
-0.4080196619,
0.2953642607,
-0.5577157736,
0.0740544051,
-0.102622129,
0.0726675317,
-0.3015033603,
-0.2313479334,
-0.0747933164,
-0.1039470658,
0.3303030729,
-0.4146545529,
-0.638182044,
-0.2908893526,
0.0268815961,
0.6736328006,
1.0717873573,
-0.5363357067,
0.6025613546,
0.4412437379,
-0.184306249,
-0.4912137091,
-0.5973325968,
0.1209036931,
-0.2259646505,
-0.4023351669,
0.0774328038,
-0.0799802393,
-0.7637504339,
-0.0144156488,
0.152110979,
-0.2251298279,
0.0930123255,
0.2216794193,
-0.1167802364,
-0.6243118048,
-0.0090316534,
-0.0889715478,
0.2024207562,
0.1639092267,
-0.6587525606,
0.588541925,
-0.0233206358,
-0.4277213216,
-0.5987867117,
0.2511651814,
0.9476621747,
-0.0831721947,
0.1820382327,
0.2478469014,
-0.3019296229,
-0.652001977,
-0.5378773212,
-0.2120414376,
-0.4846868217,
0.0850662366,
-0.3888050616,
-0.6943387985,
0.412093997,
-0.2476722747,
0.0680965409,
0.1707210988,
0.7963699698,
0.1334908456,
0.654717505,
0.6759149432,
-0.3854799271,
0.4457602203,
-0.2665952742,
0.2458028644,
-0.3842756152,
0.1178685427,
-0.6026400924,
-0.281965673,
-0.6202399135,
-0.3187507093,
0.2276135087,
-0.128997162,
-0.2581914663,
0.5570095778,
-0.3923232853,
0.6689792275,
0.6170585155,
-0.1269363165,
0.1167231873,
0.0433987789,
0.0538501665,
0.1979654282,
-0.8477181196,
-0.2338825762,
1.1103458405,
0.0610993616,
1.115016818,
0.0254009906,
1.1346007586,
0.411847502,
0.0991910622,
-0.9914491177,
0.5786640048,
-0.1529316306,
-0.3223529756,
-0.4157585502,
-0.4564025998,
-0.8018904328,
0.0023125827,
-0.2442945987,
-0.7532393932,
0.3838354051,
0.1998381615,
-0.40900442,
0.3201587796,
-0.4264340997,
0.4001123607,
-0.2262743264,
-0.3968442976,
-0.452295959,
-0.1865078062,
0.4599056542,
-0.3044431806,
0.5585361719,
-0.0286683291,
0.5690110326,
0.6666581631,
-0.716742754,
0.8826423287,
-0.3948715925,
-0.4963413179,
0.6714312434,
0.3874448836,
0.6431197524,
-0.2028408945,
-0.3131326139,
-0.0327921472,
-0.0364947878,
-0.2634717226,
-0.6281389594,
0.7890927792,
-0.5392071605,
-0.6686540246,
-0.1484790891,
-0.8396298289,
0.0605103523,
0.1483241022,
-0.0281158276,
0.5293379426,
0.1347603947,
-0.0865519643,
0.5246018171,
-0.2014517933,
0.7443859577,
0.7485448718,
0.1044121534,
-0.0273579918,
0.9837603569,
0.022271743,
-0.0919880718,
0.1207701936,
0.3852010071,
-0.1902380884,
-0.8008792996,
-0.295491755,
0.4070338309,
-0.5024188161,
0.1559191942,
-0.1475887299,
-0.2301803082,
-0.5192837715,
-0.2834252119,
-0.4131213129,
-0.321601361,
0.0818382576,
0.3680619299,
0.1331903934,
0.8431759477,
-0.1980280876,
0.0650412589,
-0.4435348511,
0.4359413087,
0.1311810613,
0.3216466904,
-0.0325409025,
-0.6891184449,
-0.1422110647,
0.1849630922,
0.13714239,
-0.4768308103,
0.2810320556,
0.4023424685,
0.6161363721,
0.3433050513,
0.1301821172,
0.7955226898,
-0.9301074743,
0.5789884925,
0.4001071751,
-1.1169551611,
0.6498333812,
-0.1770709008,
0.2587181628,
0.2772168219,
-0.1276389509,
-0.3911270201,
-0.7961457372,
-0.4679079056,
-0.5768880248,
0.6359780431,
0.0431990586,
0.2639654875,
0.1388361007,
0.5944213271,
0.0436914042,
0.1876152158,
-0.7331869602,
0.322745651,
-0.2039406151,
-0.2575567961,
-0.0162330214,
-0.1611219198,
0.0508855991,
-0.251871556,
0.6108984947,
-0.2103391439,
-0.0670435503,
-0.0351315551,
-0.3725661337,
-0.0506267846,
0.6518579721,
0.842458725,
0.6001784205,
0.1001074389,
0.1494566947,
0.1555124968,
-0.2673534155,
0.441744566,
-0.3383565545,
-0.3637892306,
-0.0088480879,
0.5827946067,
0.6091976166,
0.1727317125,
-0.8836066723,
0.5629670024,
0.3388579786,
-0.4166681468,
-0.5964027643,
0.1955862194,
0.0729198009,
0.4084220231,
0.2374198735,
-0.4026423991,
0.0803610831,
-0.9052932858,
0.1888705939,
0.5095282793,
-0.1643599272,
-0.4201579094,
0.9296737313,
0.1110930815,
-0.4506881535,
0.7794535756,
-0.2787946761,
-0.2377337962,
0.5212880969,
0.7854234576,
0.781655848,
-0.1313766092,
-0.2542809248,
0.3182998896,
0.4776833653,
-0.3458207548,
0.4513276219,
-0.0377642997,
-0.5800612569,
-0.9473446608,
-0.9216010571,
-0.2323571891,
0.484988749,
-0.465723604,
0.348264575,
-0.5160496831,
-0.0061233193,
0.3044609427,
-0.4583407938,
-0.4627054334,
-0.2072107494,
0.6614515185,
0.7734255195,
-1.0646687746,
0.9399549365,
0.5267229676,
-0.3799854815,
-0.7911558747,
0.0195480436,
0.0757796839,
-0.6976190209,
0.8968972564,
-0.1737863421,
-0.4120512009,
-0.2131454796,
-0.6962008476,
-0.5114681125,
0.674869597,
0.6296597123,
-0.6162352562,
-0.2003605366,
0.3421140909,
0.6873353124,
-0.3810688555,
0.0860870406,
0.8191391826,
0.3208782673,
-0.122878328,
-1.252278924,
0.1098188162,
-0.3640121222,
-0.0850780085,
0.1178120971,
-0.2256424129,
0.8049775362,
-0.4648798406,
-0.1766200364,
0.280323565,
0.5553570986,
0.3083112538,
0.2263602763,
0.4690120518,
0.5460212231,
0.6802478433,
-0.0065770177,
0.9894157052,
-0.7874616981,
0.1238594353,
1.0391190052,
-0.5866250992,
0.7589939237,
0.5778152943,
-0.2112400681,
0.5597773194,
-0.0115216197,
-0.2584587038,
0.3168981671,
0.8041199446,
-0.2766343355,
-0.3705042899,
-0.2498902231,
-0.019100219,
0.6840925813,
0.3392962217,
-0.4558771551,
-0.124163352,
-0.0081596803,
-0.1550416201,
0.0876129866,
-0.6132487059,
0.7654863,
0.2445406467,
-0.5755898952,
1.0802942514,
-0.1167612746,
0.749635458,
-0.4577963948,
-0.0973590687,
-0.097965911,
0.2024290711,
-0.3027531505,
-0.6635201573,
0.1406847239,
0.1085557193,
-0.2380344868,
0.0413475856,
0.5643401146,
-0.3240413964,
-0.4366822541,
0.0780292377,
0.3025963306,
0.5051907897,
0.3619602323,
-0.310025692,
0.082622543,
-0.1172033176,
0.107776843,
0.0747557878,
0.2894578576,
-0.0389809981,
0.8741880059,
0.661395669,
0.7445293665,
0.1752117425,
0.1563079059,
0.6315783858,
-0.7383409739,
-0.6799384952,
-0.9806744456,
0.1249255463,
0.0769488141,
0.0748143047,
0.3976911902,
0.6050727367,
0.7594137788,
-0.3270767033,
1.1184225082,
0.0646808445,
0.2184303999,
-0.7248315811,
0.7302801609,
-0.3783599138,
0.2867297232,
-0.1107794195,
-0.9374091029,
-0.1913914084,
0.3891327083,
-0.0569005273,
-0.4162083864,
0.478453517,
1.0850753784,
-0.3214286268,
-0.1169753745,
0.3780223727,
0.3441848457,
0.1102181897,
0.7308911085,
0.8909489512,
0.0692436621,
0.6280667782,
-0.0899997503,
-0.0433985144,
-0.2433421761,
-0.5264126062,
-0.6980905533,
-0.3568517864,
-0.5146340728,
-0.4445008636,
0.0462873355,
0.9323784113,
0.6259512305,
-0.9971469045,
-0.7203974128,
-0.1259759963,
-0.1227953434,
-0.2150625288,
-0.1473300755,
0.2920677662,
-0.3545787334,
-0.7884312868,
0.8242109418,
0.0818221793,
0.1280320585,
-0.4086822867,
-0.3794764578,
0.270068109,
0.2445641458,
0.624001205,
0.7466860414,
-1.0294040442,
-0.219275713,
-0.4196496606,
0.01530784,
-0.0462486036,
1.2680513859,
-0.6567118168,
0.3967085183,
0.4260461926,
0.475230366,
0.2664535344,
-0.2912954986,
0.5559204221,
-0.5343345404,
0.4454197884,
0.3314937651,
0.7404674888,
-0.0678315833,
-0.0821853057,
0.4196416438,
0.2565684319,
-0.5034583807,
-1.0931415558,
0.5762398243,
-0.7689115405,
-0.3877229393,
1.4526283741,
0.0187716987,
-0.5036201477,
-0.0659526587,
0.0863954872,
0.1759329736,
-0.2619137168,
0.7209712267,
0.3702054322,
-0.1158462986,
-0.0261848196,
-0.4860596359,
0.5503125191,
0.1781816483,
-0.2569315732,
0.3079098165,
0.4492173791,
0.3631388843,
0.4544015229,
0.6196268797,
-0.1338907182,
0.3026229739,
0.4749397039,
0.4135468006,
-0.0696501806,
-0.0583840981,
-0.544241488,
0.0242455006,
0.4029509723,
0.43747136
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12719v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12719v1 | On the Robustness of Language Models for Tabular Question Answering | 2024-06-18T15:41:15 | 2024-06-18T15:41:15 | Kushal Raj Bhandari, Sixue Xing, Soham Dan, Jianxi Gao | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Large Language Models (LLMs), originally shown to ace various text
comprehension tasks have also remarkably been shown to tackle table
comprehension tasks without specific training. While previous research has
explored LLM capabilities with tabular dataset tasks, our study assesses the
influence of $\textit{in-context learning}$,$ \textit{model scale}$,
$\textit{instruction tuning}$, and $\textit{domain biases}$ on Tabular Question
Answering (TQA). We evaluate the robustness of LLMs on Wikipedia-based
$\textbf{WTQ}$ and financial report-based $\textbf{TAT-QA}$ TQA datasets,
focusing on their ability to robustly interpret tabular data under various
augmentations and perturbations. Our findings indicate that instructions
significantly enhance performance, with recent models like Llama3 exhibiting
greater robustness over earlier versions. However, data contamination and
practical reliability issues persist, especially with WTQ. We highlight the
need for improved methodologies, including structure-aware self-attention
mechanisms and better handling of domain-specific tabular data, to develop more
reliable LLMs for table comprehension. | [
-0.0455213897,
-1.1748235226,
0.6852290034,
0.0446443371,
-0.1628693491,
-0.0146389259,
-0.0959310532,
-0.2835902274,
-0.4341961443,
0.5605060458,
-0.3107777536,
-0.5928237438,
-0.1557411999,
0.0290951636,
-0.5478314161,
1.088085413,
-0.1884958744,
0.1744638234,
-0.5434870124,
0.0228162073,
-0.6035909653,
-0.3629076481,
-0.2865089774,
-0.0875268504,
0.5143620372,
0.6165039539,
0.8511943221,
1.0215039253,
0.6009821296,
0.2726943195,
-0.0319964997,
-0.0346173905,
-0.6039903164,
0.4016830623,
-0.1201644763,
-0.6042857766,
-0.6741618514,
-0.233225584,
0.5872513056,
0.6194610596,
-0.5011407733,
0.3199776411,
0.1541008055,
0.7364915013,
-0.2361722589,
0.3803817034,
-1.1493631601,
-0.1764364243,
-0.0687150508,
-0.0471106991,
-0.5010862947,
-0.3417575657,
0.0964075327,
-0.6177257895,
-0.0221558474,
0.2180436403,
0.8758682013,
0.3642523289,
-0.437284261,
-0.224571377,
-0.6593950391,
0.5605838895,
-0.7885696292,
0.5101745725,
0.5912299156,
0.329949379,
-0.2095751911,
-0.8324661255,
-0.5279020071,
-0.4192416966,
0.0435476266,
-0.01786213,
-0.0351505727,
0.0134710027,
0.4571569562,
0.2670499086,
-0.7924620509,
0.2947358191,
-0.1695077866,
-0.0347598828,
0.1062489897,
0.2947233021,
0.4322431684,
-0.2407882661,
-0.3499840796,
-0.0379519872,
-0.806473434,
0.1673135757,
0.0354809016,
0.3102312684,
-0.1278635859,
0.52905792,
-0.2639167309,
0.9064775109,
-0.1969555318,
-0.3427867591,
-0.1829340905,
-0.2819834948,
-0.4604077041,
-0.4655143917,
0.4866898358,
0.1051624194,
0.4207052588,
-0.5442291498,
-0.1919190586,
-0.1579653472,
0.4636651278,
-0.4797699749,
-0.1557762027,
0.3323650956,
-0.2028154433,
-0.2548669875,
-0.0445411094,
-0.7187229395,
-0.1266584992,
-0.2900053263,
0.6104542017,
-0.2142387778,
0.2684437335,
-0.2611984015,
0.3128739893,
0.6300497651,
0.2857841849,
-1.0276832581,
0.2073480636,
0.7827879786,
0.4989049435,
-0.1966046095,
-0.3318000436,
-0.8228062391,
0.2978630662,
-0.5043711662,
0.8909749389,
-0.4381540418,
0.0240250025,
0.0314995386,
-0.0776979253,
-0.1511861831,
-0.5125510097,
0.4352939129,
-0.840616703,
0.0079284273,
-0.5962269902,
-0.4726776183,
-0.0389126539,
0.3796604276,
-0.8764785528,
0.7352127433,
0.3048817813,
-0.8311874866,
0.4586602449,
-0.2694399953,
-0.4025166631,
-0.0959834978,
-0.0643101931,
-0.4287577569,
-0.113188684,
0.4573739171,
0.4875776172,
-0.3119555712,
0.2010419667,
-0.5199511051,
-0.330673337,
0.6023336649,
-0.4838360548,
0.4547609687,
0.0465139411,
-0.1209109351,
0.0351757705,
-0.5523873568,
0.196639955,
-0.0297411159,
-0.4474176466,
0.1737884432,
0.0463137142,
-0.09244477,
0.0548047274,
0.0279563908,
-0.1011737213,
-0.0723169819,
-0.1894240677,
0.5212450027,
0.7563453317,
0.0220308155,
0.3615680337,
-0.5166651011,
0.8043859005,
-0.0144888535,
-0.0358146355,
0.0610016882,
-0.246961087,
-0.3276588619,
-0.0275467671,
0.5416603088,
0.7822535038,
-1.0445145369,
-0.0750561953,
-0.3930880725,
-0.3620597422,
0.0672469214,
0.3089248836,
0.2732033432,
0.9605647326,
0.3297942281,
0.049004402,
-0.1357355267,
-0.9750688672,
-0.3328819275,
-0.3170028925,
-0.1016655192,
0.35889709,
0.4093823731,
0.0869713873,
0.7051476836,
-0.1934698373,
0.0335746258,
-0.582364738,
-0.2599313557,
0.2635874152,
0.2128561884,
0.3245156407,
-0.6100032926,
-0.7257310152,
0.0175379626,
-0.6212018728,
-0.0185096487,
-0.0498166829,
-0.1547413617,
0.3594216406,
0.2912041545,
-0.6724253893,
0.2709513903,
0.3103468716,
-0.1613437235,
0.4671907127,
-0.045741193,
-0.0048719342,
-1.0568108559,
0.0994907767,
0.1267525852,
-0.2996181846,
-0.9956198931,
0.1879290044,
0.3152103424,
0.0169886015,
-0.4872850478,
0.2716828585,
-0.3739564717,
-0.3043915927,
-0.1198771819,
0.3037674725,
0.1784096807,
0.4303075671,
-0.1949326396,
1.0437657833,
0.4852157235,
-0.5126555562,
0.1314460933,
0.3949818611,
-0.5523096919,
0.5339761972,
-0.771325767,
0.1742507368,
-0.2117785364,
0.0002658133,
-0.9998235703,
-0.3511456251,
0.1508012116,
-0.3909535408,
0.7267612815,
-0.003047629,
-0.3884106874,
-0.274330169,
-0.354634881,
0.033355847,
0.2071608901,
-0.4521422684,
0.5795951486,
0.4425587058,
-0.2483792901,
-0.9581515193,
-0.7864436507,
0.1437426209,
-0.4766939282,
-0.4894758165,
0.0259429831,
0.0119386809,
-0.5006678104,
-0.2165408731,
-0.5196058154,
-0.358073622,
0.268322587,
-0.0309497155,
0.4734994173,
-0.2639935911,
0.157957986,
-0.1303566992,
0.163257584,
0.1880403906,
-0.0051969709,
0.3505906165,
-0.145043686,
0.0469755642,
-0.4127189815,
0.0570939109,
0.5165433288,
-0.1276278794,
0.9209148288,
0.4216015339,
-0.3511556685,
-0.3809342384,
-0.5568002462,
-0.1282358766,
-0.4853854775,
0.4704866707,
-0.3261221945,
-0.9165661931,
0.8139262795,
0.5205847621,
0.0366863646,
0.3674570918,
0.6169296503,
-0.4916119277,
0.4194455147,
0.2878400087,
-0.3053899407,
0.2807252109,
0.0646925271,
0.0082196957,
-0.7442253828,
-0.1253870428,
-0.8914860487,
-0.1786711216,
-0.6121254563,
-0.3175202906,
0.4479080141,
-0.2099891007,
-0.256284833,
0.0833261162,
-0.0591042228,
0.5470392108,
0.4087071717,
0.208245188,
0.3924601376,
0.2356447279,
0.2188225538,
0.021670036,
-0.8156311512,
-0.6121370792,
1.2599773407,
0.5013221502,
1.2357219458,
-0.061391376,
0.1467241645,
0.326036036,
0.3802068233,
-0.4358307421,
0.3482009172,
-0.0826109797,
-0.5582960844,
-0.7149769664,
-0.7859615088,
-0.8978537321,
0.1264892519,
-0.0474606641,
-1.063108325,
-0.0328626595,
0.2593158185,
-0.2476554513,
0.2332568765,
-0.6900678873,
1.0974503756,
-0.1516241729,
-0.5231642723,
0.2437872589,
-0.4518988431,
0.4302592278,
-0.1560552418,
0.2570005655,
0.0378541984,
-0.1073477045,
0.6419574022,
-0.2147894949,
0.6458224058,
-0.0261788573,
-0.3808807135,
0.3523006141,
0.2263117433,
0.6918054223,
0.4150903821,
-0.1130809709,
-0.1454188824,
0.3525473475,
-0.4278905392,
-0.6469393969,
0.7798380852,
-0.6507217288,
-0.8854137659,
-0.1183359697,
-0.9514166117,
-0.721472919,
-0.0935686082,
-0.015240822,
0.6203808188,
0.0061346963,
0.5574203134,
0.9178722501,
-0.105654195,
0.4089555442,
0.4118096828,
0.01088183,
-0.4167279005,
0.7246140242,
0.303797096,
0.2965550721,
0.7644419074,
0.0811054558,
-0.5989232659,
-0.8114455342,
-0.7475858927,
0.1176505461,
-0.7567328215,
-0.5514346361,
-0.4187062085,
-0.1122223511,
-0.0979941264,
0.2043864429,
0.0635776445,
-0.5157368183,
-0.3839137852,
-0.3915290236,
0.3548054695,
0.7213484049,
0.3671839237,
0.1930445284,
-0.7000629902,
0.5470012426,
0.612121582,
0.4782681167,
0.1096550971,
-0.799271822,
-0.3148264289,
-0.0098156016,
-0.0699079856,
-1.1986380816,
0.0619575642,
0.182335645,
0.6797217131,
0.1985903978,
0.0848004296,
0.3376284242,
-0.2942397892,
0.6287631989,
-0.4864341915,
-0.9617462754,
0.1286375523,
-0.70129776,
0.5145148635,
0.6863750815,
0.3202414513,
-0.2551793456,
-0.5138819218,
-0.1108617485,
-0.5839123726,
0.7433168888,
0.0060063135,
0.1134630814,
0.215469569,
0.8436567187,
0.2609332502,
0.2053248286,
-1.1970399618,
-0.0009478598,
-0.1281614006,
-0.237487942,
0.1746739745,
-0.3891156614,
0.1533289105,
-0.0728938952,
0.5918787718,
-0.1739967465,
-0.0433990583,
0.0362796858,
-0.2969925106,
-0.2580781281,
0.4995479882,
0.4982805252,
1.174803853,
-0.0138274617,
0.0704291835,
0.5165328979,
-0.5271903276,
0.0823564902,
0.0069564506,
-0.342681706,
-0.4749028087,
0.3825813234,
0.6183944345,
-0.0037825007,
-0.6477094293,
0.0876549482,
-0.228816852,
-0.1756089628,
0.0881018713,
0.2265428752,
0.1933791339,
0.2411977202,
0.4905408323,
-0.7136602402,
0.1093328521,
-0.6888110042,
0.224290058,
0.6744889617,
-0.2435694784,
-0.0408445001,
0.8168643117,
-0.3671307266,
-0.0732300654,
0.6093100309,
0.1621843129,
-0.4530304968,
0.7114409804,
0.617570281,
0.3628110588,
-0.151563853,
0.3589802682,
0.073416926,
0.6204981208,
0.0725082606,
0.5793868303,
-0.1127154976,
-0.482994467,
-0.4720777273,
-0.5914425254,
-0.6081290841,
0.4185939729,
-0.6480927467,
-0.2997016907,
-0.3062718809,
-0.1193525121,
-0.3206291199,
-0.0832639709,
-0.6580061913,
0.3462547362,
-0.0943520069,
0.8468305469,
-0.5674795508,
0.7543058991,
0.6227132082,
-0.099659726,
-1.1013622284,
0.1682635248,
-0.3692184687,
-0.5225114822,
0.1265159994,
-0.0887591243,
0.2150618285,
-0.0823050886,
-0.4950372577,
-1.0153816938,
0.9917982817,
0.4843417108,
-0.4716711044,
-0.1166410074,
0.492669791,
0.6160894632,
0.0655876771,
0.1241935268,
0.8128664494,
0.4365189373,
-0.1294167787,
-0.8696908951,
0.1603357643,
0.079288885,
-0.0711548552,
-0.0754121989,
-0.5776361823,
0.6252965331,
-0.1435124278,
-0.0246419888,
0.0314490497,
0.8698959947,
0.0927649438,
0.2149476558,
0.3377234638,
0.5287475586,
0.725762248,
-0.2041791826,
0.98183918,
-0.2171536982,
0.0710403845,
1.1473517418,
-0.3289462328,
1.0112489462,
0.3277956843,
-0.420266211,
0.4005497992,
0.582898438,
-0.0335623249,
0.2409857959,
0.1784992218,
0.1712950468,
-0.1988764107,
0.1361422986,
-0.233822763,
0.6273816228,
0.3341085911,
-0.1120049655,
-0.2196678519,
-0.2225855589,
-0.1019857824,
0.073559396,
-0.4141336977,
0.8622136116,
0.1203825548,
-0.6441649199,
0.5558615327,
-0.2161534429,
-0.0639703497,
-0.515963912,
0.1910590082,
-0.5785355568,
-0.2013016939,
-0.1249572486,
-0.7519804835,
0.127399683,
0.2252333313,
-0.115597114,
0.0810642913,
0.636454165,
-0.3282814026,
-0.4046727419,
-0.2785386145,
0.9502488375,
-0.138967067,
-0.0032506746,
-0.3269401491,
0.1734627187,
-0.0902287588,
-0.4447602332,
0.4624662101,
0.4771765769,
-0.0026125566,
0.9908034801,
0.3163158894,
-0.1172445938,
0.0626854226,
0.0033641832,
0.837198019,
-0.5477413535,
-0.4269131124,
-0.8117104173,
0.2448643744,
0.2614896297,
0.0623281449,
0.8298403025,
0.3862945735,
0.5703007579,
-0.1643299013,
0.4076662958,
0.3080193102,
0.4362853467,
-0.7805123925,
0.8777583838,
-0.4764373899,
0.3200015128,
-0.3256151974,
-1.1721431017,
-0.2279184312,
0.2974603176,
-0.3863070309,
0.3148418069,
0.6584951878,
0.6391987205,
0.0655353367,
-0.0348787829,
0.3714058399,
0.3958623409,
0.060513854,
0.3928905427,
0.8415368199,
-0.1163753569,
0.8671575785,
-0.1261758953,
0.0694066212,
0.0414074175,
-0.6713783741,
-0.9828346372,
-0.4681310952,
-0.081409052,
-0.3094303906,
0.0753082559,
0.4977877736,
0.3997692168,
-0.858582437,
-0.1766293198,
0.1047832891,
0.4071023762,
-0.0064510345,
-0.2416820079,
0.6781844497,
-0.4991996288,
-0.5374726057,
0.451877296,
0.1837148517,
0.0734885335,
-0.2208785713,
0.3468271494,
0.1410372108,
0.0916979536,
0.4333827496,
0.2031632513,
-0.5921778679,
-0.2935535908,
0.3321481049,
-0.1865693778,
0.2623476386,
0.5045095086,
-0.4968044758,
0.1428004056,
0.449998647,
0.8188873529,
0.3506295979,
0.4572075605,
0.4780335128,
-0.3060925305,
-0.3204272985,
0.1329758614,
0.3072191477,
0.43385005,
-0.4212885499,
0.2937131524,
-0.2198762,
-0.8302273154,
-0.9703753591,
0.0155165009,
-0.9966185093,
-0.188700214,
1.043612957,
0.0092681507,
-0.6300330758,
-0.1954148263,
0.0638429448,
0.1031649783,
-0.3331505954,
1.1037503481,
0.7160500884,
-0.0087886676,
-0.3696938753,
-0.8045149446,
0.5609161854,
0.425314784,
-1.20327878,
0.300989598,
0.571290791,
0.313480407,
-0.3999705315,
0.2943561673,
0.0420917943,
0.5673175454,
-0.0815994814,
-0.4507287741,
-0.1216270849,
-0.5832335949,
-0.2467825264,
0.385550797,
0.470702976,
0.1495692134
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12718v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12718v2 | AGLA: Mitigating Object Hallucinations in Large Vision-Language Models with Assembly of Global and Local Attention | 2024-06-18T15:38:41 | 2024-06-21T17:33:21 | Wenbin An, Feng Tian, Sicong Leng, Jiahao Nie, Haonan Lin, QianYing Wang, Guang Dai, Ping Chen, Shijian Lu | cs.CV | cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL | Despite their great success across various multimodal tasks, Large
Vision-Language Models (LVLMs) are facing a prevalent problem with object
hallucinations, where the generated textual responses are inconsistent with
ground-truth objects in the given image. This paper investigates various LVLMs
and pinpoints attention deficiency toward discriminative local image features
as one root cause of object hallucinations. Specifically, LVLMs predominantly
attend to prompt-independent global image features, while failing to capture
prompt-relevant local features, consequently undermining the visual grounding
capacity of LVLMs and leading to hallucinations. To this end, we propose
Assembly of Global and Local Attention (AGLA), a training-free and
plug-and-play approach that mitigates object hallucinations by exploring an
ensemble of global features for response generation and local features for
visual discrimination simultaneously. Our approach exhibits an image-prompt
matching scheme that captures prompt-relevant local features from images,
leading to an augmented view of the input image where prompt-relevant content
is reserved while irrelevant distractions are masked. With the augmented view,
a calibrated decoding distribution can be derived by integrating generative
global features from the original image and discriminative local features from
the augmented image. Extensive experiments show that AGLA consistently
mitigates object hallucinations and enhances general perception capability for
LVLMs across various discriminative and generative benchmarks. Our code will be
released at https://github.com/Lackel/AGLA. | [
-0.5161185265,
-0.9556037784,
0.4679366946,
0.0010124793,
-0.1416337341,
-0.1613081545,
0.1245303378,
-0.828217268,
0.3950973153,
0.5880650282,
-0.3002540767,
-0.1972730309,
-0.3611121178,
0.1145113036,
-0.4961113036,
0.5360131264,
-0.0611172542,
-0.0724547431,
-0.4450871348,
-0.3655755818,
-0.6333941221,
-0.783851862,
-0.555400908,
0.1229341626,
0.4110168219,
-0.0806743428,
0.8254874349,
0.551389873,
0.5653175712,
0.2800812125,
-0.0935449675,
0.5240975618,
-0.3484426141,
0.0481338128,
-0.1691285074,
-0.1108846292,
-0.4702719152,
-0.4077584147,
0.4296829998,
0.43789047,
-0.100269936,
0.0077813594,
-0.0316580087,
0.6165903807,
-0.9672544003,
-0.0499331616,
-0.8139225841,
0.489865154,
0.2818009555,
-0.1890358627,
-0.3199195564,
0.0169012807,
-0.0867617801,
-0.486952424,
0.7108274102,
0.1114525348,
0.7429199815,
0.5652570128,
0.0126359584,
-0.4313989878,
-0.5984953046,
0.5190839171,
-0.0904472098,
0.3715900481,
0.4075247347,
0.3228521049,
-0.1177068576,
-0.2489017695,
-0.5213083029,
-0.3918696046,
-0.1267456561,
-0.0167734586,
-0.1312371641,
-0.0007223408,
0.1225281879,
0.392642349,
-0.595004499,
-0.1818372756,
-0.5733684301,
-0.3807399869,
0.434645772,
0.0683364645,
0.348592937,
0.1279496551,
-0.3820762038,
-0.0000285217,
-0.6644783616,
0.0354065709,
0.0737513378,
0.392526269,
0.0319621153,
0.5233539939,
-0.1539835334,
0.8605927825,
0.1197556183,
-0.0774349496,
0.3224727511,
-0.0935596749,
-0.334710151,
0.3807556629,
0.4104957283,
0.4711498618,
0.2602895498,
-0.6335839033,
-0.0627947599,
0.6822650433,
0.4536189735,
-0.4751387537,
-0.0129499873,
0.2703922391,
-0.3103375435,
-0.1717293262,
-0.0369630158,
-0.9180412292,
-0.7278441191,
-0.5157518983,
0.5632160902,
0.0157057084,
0.0167568736,
0.2489230931,
0.3906795084,
0.3035586178,
0.258956939,
-1.018411994,
0.1410969049,
0.2510209382,
1.060103178,
-0.5044785738,
-0.3450329304,
-1.1987261772,
0.2640953064,
-0.4094486237,
0.9177821279,
-0.5188212395,
-0.2876832187,
0.115924418,
0.3125446439,
0.0065243347,
-0.8113616109,
0.2835698724,
-0.0618382916,
0.1118828878,
-0.0894550234,
0.0210632104,
-0.1740213335,
0.2665795684,
-0.5731759071,
0.6653828621,
-0.0798204914,
-0.5709529519,
0.0139025114,
-0.4106766284,
-0.4673188925,
-0.1437585801,
-0.3393734396,
-0.2811211348,
0.3523886502,
0.7035902739,
0.5109632015,
-0.011384666,
0.3084923923,
-0.2410044968,
-0.6944234371,
0.0238823555,
-0.1735494584,
0.3225965798,
0.1162583232,
-0.3932462335,
0.6171208024,
-0.8455102444,
-0.339725107,
0.2321451008,
0.1844170392,
-0.0596964061,
0.019129904,
-0.2538999319,
0.0250873622,
0.011701162,
-0.0506680273,
0.2426214516,
-0.5605704188,
0.1390419602,
0.6025570035,
0.0480733924,
0.5832559466,
-0.1088402048,
0.5396254063,
0.2079890668,
0.4204480052,
-0.382452786,
-0.3630787134,
-0.915263176,
-0.161600858,
-0.5108290911,
0.546395421,
-0.8826947808,
0.3481017053,
0.1408138871,
-0.0921414644,
-0.5332229733,
0.046826005,
0.3181172907,
0.5792751312,
0.5341965556,
-0.3545018137,
-0.5291424394,
-1.0355606079,
0.2519519329,
0.1985808611,
-0.1997125596,
0.1060366333,
0.3390274048,
-0.3778106272,
0.6510173678,
-0.3615443408,
-1.1216727495,
0.0653270185,
-0.2985146046,
-0.0874377489,
0.001894186,
0.5198569894,
-0.7606623769,
-0.2160325646,
0.3710583746,
-0.8858175278,
0.0814440548,
-0.2193613201,
-0.02854307,
0.5957155824,
0.4231061935,
-0.6889973283,
0.7310602069,
0.181113869,
-0.4583249688,
0.5371838808,
-0.3307272792,
0.1669267863,
-0.7681743503,
0.145528242,
-0.0810107067,
0.0485291965,
-0.6517904401,
0.4855820835,
-0.219269529,
-0.1920477301,
-0.6247700453,
0.7926545739,
-0.7833656073,
-0.394756943,
-0.3418411911,
0.2646366954,
0.1942925453,
0.6199602485,
0.1670298725,
0.887372613,
1.0696413517,
-0.4507796764,
0.5779207945,
0.3803165853,
-0.2690365016,
0.3487510085,
-0.4446525872,
0.388302356,
-0.3480765224,
-0.1777832657,
-0.694357872,
-0.4652912915,
0.711455524,
-0.254018873,
0.1126147807,
0.2996938229,
-0.1980415285,
-0.3078410327,
-0.3812905848,
0.1328316778,
0.306804508,
-0.5972695947,
0.9692864418,
0.330087781,
0.0258360729,
-0.6293135881,
-0.6370245218,
0.1135004759,
-0.1928629279,
-0.4009913504,
0.0629787445,
-0.1525136679,
-0.3055270314,
-0.0993964598,
-0.2227318883,
0.0816073269,
-0.0218486432,
0.2400709093,
0.2765994668,
0.0251420327,
-0.0027801238,
-0.4494841993,
0.003568351,
0.0929826722,
0.1175385863,
0.6716620922,
-0.243847847,
-0.5532960296,
-0.0812361091,
0.5047231913,
0.6638213396,
-0.4251098633,
0.5221294165,
0.6292269826,
-0.4628559649,
-0.0827457905,
-0.7031232715,
-0.3341579437,
-0.4798325598,
0.4851770997,
-0.3701600432,
-0.664611876,
0.8949909806,
0.5393943787,
-0.4011006355,
-0.0121263387,
0.7385393381,
0.3949571848,
0.9462090731,
0.4104553461,
-0.193768844,
0.1814863235,
-0.2297535241,
0.3966601491,
-0.874545157,
-0.482250452,
-0.2197535038,
-0.2555555403,
0.2348804623,
-0.752545476,
0.1133070812,
0.078822419,
0.0718328208,
-0.3017028272,
-1.1522405148,
0.9775878191,
0.4468971193,
0.0951345116,
0.1811089367,
0.4411194324,
0.0703386813,
0.0963670611,
-0.3253091872,
-0.1561764032,
0.5635962486,
0.1007436663,
0.7508830428,
-0.3279652596,
0.3056438565,
0.4859003425,
-0.117940627,
-0.7136369944,
0.8579108715,
-0.0567929335,
-0.1538931429,
-0.0981261209,
-0.1993062943,
-0.7713056803,
0.4273780882,
-0.0643418506,
-1.1888517141,
0.5174586773,
0.1869247556,
-0.4341565669,
0.3051741421,
-0.7308405042,
0.8483161926,
-0.3114732504,
-0.5073776841,
0.0668270811,
-0.5935977697,
0.4139222503,
-0.1438812762,
0.1562975943,
0.0898102894,
0.2724611759,
0.1196668893,
0.2474529296,
0.8513863683,
-0.1901027709,
-0.3431991339,
0.3888391554,
0.0996719226,
0.5444244742,
-0.030374866,
0.4392310679,
0.2795568109,
-0.5733195543,
-0.026274588,
-0.496017158,
0.7025508285,
-0.6029031277,
-0.7285865545,
-0.3366409242,
-0.8819606304,
-0.078684628,
-0.2005175948,
0.3516651094,
0.4767662585,
0.1756488532,
0.2033978701,
0.8162505627,
-0.2440125942,
0.4084580243,
-0.0096504781,
-0.7386277914,
-0.5978761315,
1.0929883718,
0.0505234003,
0.0946576521,
0.1849857867,
-0.1879852414,
-0.2083766758,
-0.4917801321,
-0.2703436911,
0.0346883833,
-0.9743059874,
-0.2379384637,
-0.7487318516,
-0.2979359031,
-0.4833844006,
-0.379912585,
-0.1843672693,
-0.0087201763,
-0.4839489758,
0.0718744844,
0.0485829078,
0.3411055803,
0.1400409937,
0.037593551,
-0.6029695868,
1.0112215281,
0.4460516572,
0.1114421487,
0.3685967624,
-0.4195335805,
-0.2702755034,
-0.1501841247,
-0.1525627077,
-0.6813916564,
0.5471299291,
0.2545903921,
0.6197806001,
0.5245482326,
0.0368169956,
0.7964519858,
-0.54272753,
0.6859968901,
0.3052491546,
-0.7963995337,
0.782856822,
-0.1181052998,
0.3856726289,
0.1775377542,
0.1325761676,
-0.2982740104,
-0.7712165713,
-0.2136692703,
-0.9408276677,
0.6517360806,
0.19683671,
0.0868647769,
-0.1092606038,
0.2509740591,
0.1479997933,
0.0621546693,
-0.9466692209,
-0.0078233015,
-0.2040716857,
0.0044558253,
0.1714569628,
-0.3531543016,
-0.3210651278,
-0.3827884197,
0.5056019425,
-0.3295986652,
0.43742764,
0.4303767979,
-0.1923152506,
-0.187559098,
-0.1417420506,
0.9141974449,
0.5802055597,
-0.2022244185,
0.1138172448,
0.1276148707,
-0.6233465075,
0.282076478,
0.0618710928,
-0.3942613602,
-0.0277597476,
0.2139972597,
1.1777861118,
-0.151956901,
-0.5948617458,
0.0629860088,
-0.0001560291,
-0.0325020254,
-0.1849398166,
0.3816439807,
-0.1841353029,
0.4436202645,
0.6762069464,
0.2655700743,
0.3188143373,
-0.5329554081,
0.1134228334,
0.4390877187,
-0.1875295043,
-0.3396140635,
0.8787667155,
-0.1255778223,
-0.4145303965,
0.1509356201,
-0.323473841,
-0.410718739,
0.7218831182,
0.5701325536,
1.0644230843,
-0.4085942209,
0.1972807944,
0.3068123162,
0.3514562547,
-0.1281755418,
0.2253624797,
0.0707951561,
-0.662586391,
-0.3557060063,
-0.6537389159,
-0.3439408541,
0.18982476,
-0.4924489856,
0.251187861,
-0.2864379585,
0.1331814229,
-0.3935834467,
-0.4545266032,
-0.3545137346,
0.1216157898,
0.5469709039,
0.2361548543,
-0.679520905,
0.6628544927,
0.7838851213,
-0.2393910885,
-0.4108519852,
0.1272360384,
-0.3637406528,
-0.7066754699,
0.4644569755,
0.8011472821,
-0.2516293228,
-0.125418961,
-0.3765396476,
-0.7687652111,
0.7086959481,
0.5436457992,
-0.5329335332,
-0.1813527644,
0.2020256668,
0.3165123165,
-0.5973163843,
-0.15794532,
0.3358618617,
0.1872248948,
0.4322272539,
-0.5831273794,
0.0439301059,
-0.2293294072,
0.0309346318,
0.1059163511,
-0.5621402264,
0.6240475774,
-0.4965960085,
-0.2749084532,
-0.0459390953,
0.5609149933,
0.362899065,
0.4650348723,
0.4268746376,
0.6475453377,
0.761998415,
-0.05162457,
0.7528038025,
-0.1970352232,
0.1807399839,
1.3024154902,
-0.6614438295,
0.6192730665,
0.5784563422,
0.025495844,
-0.0382357165,
0.2353714705,
-0.320186913,
0.9196664691,
0.0323691629,
-0.3152600825,
-0.1186055094,
-0.2846506238,
-0.688359797,
0.4659601152,
0.1712331474,
-0.0424939506,
-0.171138823,
0.7819235325,
-0.5156601667,
-0.073692292,
-0.5159134865,
0.6839849949,
-0.0587345064,
-0.4671345651,
0.949231863,
-0.7307034731,
0.571942687,
-0.4618859291,
-0.200931564,
-0.6816269755,
0.3554598987,
-0.035997849,
-0.3375779092,
0.5551908016,
-0.0045128833,
-0.3614259362,
0.2179831862,
0.9294018149,
-0.3657680452,
-0.6795790792,
0.5098630786,
0.0230255332,
0.239991799,
-0.4172304571,
-0.2147963345,
0.4610421956,
0.129074648,
-0.2258185446,
0.4302244186,
0.3382635415,
-0.194233641,
0.8023938537,
0.5532836318,
0.1080864668,
0.1022076383,
0.2261094302,
0.7817335129,
-0.4433860183,
-0.4458179772,
-0.8966656923,
0.5979267359,
-0.0251890384,
-0.0391343944,
0.3823747933,
0.3402117789,
0.6270896792,
-0.4964312613,
0.2129215002,
0.1234105751,
-0.0306489225,
-0.5634151101,
0.7118346095,
-0.7074492574,
0.0473258495,
0.0433082394,
-1.3965651989,
-0.6188634634,
0.9785047174,
0.0035037773,
-0.2143537551,
0.6091543436,
0.8302957416,
-0.0153431781,
-0.4536002278,
0.6686089039,
0.2506406009,
0.2180048078,
0.6526064277,
0.8339436054,
-0.2674629688,
0.5683964491,
-0.0657257065,
0.049415879,
-0.2768725157,
-0.7053249478,
-1.0644830465,
-0.4030839205,
-0.3761590421,
-0.0684192181,
0.1602000147,
0.5360153317,
0.4127858281,
-0.9653754234,
0.1395517141,
-0.1264276356,
-0.0451587625,
-0.017114589,
-0.2679789662,
0.6389608383,
-0.4318215251,
-0.6731918454,
0.4005541801,
0.6947023869,
0.2355777919,
-0.6238712072,
-0.1686390787,
0.0150023717,
-0.2540113926,
0.653339088,
0.1184027866,
-1.2777223587,
-0.3692187667,
0.2048472762,
0.0681855828,
0.3036137223,
0.2578246593,
-1.0896940231,
0.6692107916,
0.0635366589,
0.6142985821,
0.0537135378,
-0.0975766703,
0.1754983068,
-0.8906694651,
0.8383250237,
0.0820739046,
0.498506099,
0.4686236382,
-0.672796607,
0.785984695,
0.1615688503,
-0.6271563172,
-1.0612401962,
0.1158308312,
-1.0691003799,
-0.2056291401,
0.8781113625,
0.1535912156,
-0.3771374226,
0.0291470606,
-0.679602623,
0.0169044212,
-0.0907508209,
1.3817027807,
0.5621925592,
0.1573370844,
-0.4037996829,
-0.5396196842,
0.2689295709,
0.2595097721,
-0.8800697923,
0.3497341871,
0.7876805663,
-0.4687082767,
0.7127255201,
0.4205878377,
0.2008003294,
0.4314043224,
-0.0240060631,
0.4009763598,
-0.1898797154,
-0.8511765599,
-0.2898611724,
0.4594826102,
-0.3809255362,
-0.3361721635
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12708v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12708v1 | AgentReview: Exploring Peer Review Dynamics with LLM Agents | 2024-06-18T15:22:12 | 2024-06-18T15:22:12 | Yiqiao Jin, Qinlin Zhao, Yiyang Wang, Hao Chen, Kaijie Zhu, Yijia Xiao, Jindong Wang | cs.CL | cs.CL | Peer review is fundamental to the integrity and advancement of scientific
publication. Traditional methods of peer review analyses often rely on
exploration and statistics of existing peer review data, which do not
adequately address the multivariate nature of the process, account for the
latent variables, and are further constrained by privacy concerns due to the
sensitive nature of the data. We introduce AgentReview, the first large
language model (LLM) based peer review simulation framework, which effectively
disentangles the impacts of multiple latent factors and addresses the privacy
issue. Our study reveals significant insights, including a notable 37.1%
variation in paper decisions due to reviewers' biases, supported by
sociological theories such as the social influence theory, altruism fatigue,
and authority bias. We believe that this study could offer valuable insights to
improve the design of peer review mechanisms. | [
-0.1690903306,
-0.6716127992,
0.6628857851,
0.2243362814,
-0.0363293886,
0.2702712119,
0.1282831281,
-0.4337542653,
0.3699555993,
0.4397924542,
-0.4377846718,
-0.3696678281,
-0.6384881139,
0.1692275852,
-0.2282402217,
1.0465073586,
-0.0387618653,
0.5291012526,
0.0106288167,
0.113887623,
0.2126401365,
-0.4514017105,
-0.3913415968,
-0.6307526231,
0.8863003254,
-0.0140465423,
0.7241036296,
0.1684009135,
0.6022723317,
0.29172194,
-0.3948854208,
0.0990781412,
-0.748318553,
0.3218841255,
-0.3331725597,
-0.3080650568,
-0.7259862423,
0.5694214702,
0.8492569923,
0.5207062364,
-0.1724393815,
0.0554399081,
0.1990801841,
0.7672773004,
-0.2984237075,
0.4839866161,
-0.2452435195,
0.1559228897,
0.1948769242,
-0.2752902806,
-0.354259789,
-0.4258467853,
0.1705604941,
-0.3408095837,
0.3423856497,
0.0791034102,
0.622027576,
0.0772007629,
-0.6898877025,
0.0043809661,
-0.8260629773,
0.3931857646,
-0.2911378741,
0.3629923165,
0.3363901377,
0.1730906516,
-0.2912526131,
-0.6786118746,
-0.5726703405,
-0.4498749077,
0.1821844727,
0.0076735639,
0.1506810784,
0.317062676,
0.083993338,
0.083916761,
-0.2299117595,
-0.2362123281,
-0.2315954864,
-0.0908495113,
0.8804814816,
0.2787391841,
-0.1028691754,
-0.0579215065,
-0.1072883382,
-0.496576339,
-0.6448367834,
0.2654313743,
0.7141146064,
0.0760814548,
-0.0378841721,
0.4635716975,
-0.1966592371,
0.1364717633,
0.0432186015,
0.0837809518,
0.2849589288,
-0.6254321337,
0.0340724774,
-0.115643993,
0.7984840274,
0.525293529,
-0.0820856765,
0.1163967624,
-0.1634682566,
-0.2172927409,
0.36622563,
-0.9958385825,
0.0089745894,
0.3442245722,
-0.8908973336,
-0.7513962388,
0.1709899008,
-0.8758605719,
-0.9523406029,
-0.1509273052,
0.2474661767,
0.1834868193,
-0.4713768661,
0.0844945982,
0.0396478064,
0.0157420412,
0.8917648792,
-0.2067291439,
0.4010308385,
0.8828638196,
0.8924444318,
-0.4024886191,
-0.5413649082,
-0.5247415304,
0.0122150742,
-0.1996269077,
0.6510661244,
-0.6484520435,
-0.5847671628,
-0.1212370619,
0.2762750685,
0.1699473262,
-0.1020972282,
-0.0167801753,
-0.727350831,
-0.2151667774,
-0.2885935903,
-0.382240504,
-0.1154848039,
0.3934911489,
-0.8332996964,
0.5087543726,
-0.1706921756,
-0.6701630354,
0.3997403085,
-0.5586704612,
0.0028997525,
-0.2398881912,
-0.2466414124,
-0.5366470218,
0.1901259571,
-0.145923838,
0.305057615,
-0.213790983,
0.5062376261,
-0.4758449197,
-0.079774864,
0.5333305001,
-0.4373511672,
0.4459955096,
0.2360571325,
-0.1795027256,
0.2517532408,
-0.4538967609,
-0.1411165595,
-0.1044660583,
-0.1531120986,
-0.0381257124,
0.2226956487,
0.1290407032,
-0.1354151517,
-0.0593479164,
-0.7727888823,
0.4503567219,
0.0084946193,
0.3747748435,
0.840085268,
0.589204073,
0.5482463837,
-0.3743926883,
0.7753637433,
-0.2472564429,
0.4988972545,
-0.0701624379,
-0.5691558123,
-0.0140784569,
0.1537001729,
0.4909186363,
0.113421239,
-0.5453078151,
-0.4518971145,
-0.0103953145,
-0.5651443005,
-0.3051528633,
0.0932814181,
0.3987797797,
-0.1877786964,
-0.2195832729,
-0.5206625462,
0.0495299213,
-0.5824406743,
-0.3590275049,
-0.7282654047,
0.3211208582,
0.4557362199,
0.5458971858,
-0.2868401706,
0.728710711,
-0.3729391694,
-0.3487440348,
-0.1783129573,
0.2921519876,
0.0697780177,
0.4301232696,
0.2534016371,
-0.7819794416,
-0.1867227554,
-0.1103397459,
-0.6620972157,
-0.2870747447,
-0.1082128808,
-0.0494722575,
0.1732401699,
0.6717568636,
-0.5415582657,
0.4921227396,
0.5127459764,
-0.5370193124,
0.5527740121,
-0.2020327598,
0.181164816,
-0.6850219965,
-0.0147535726,
0.1826063395,
-0.2909027636,
-0.3592232764,
0.2471680492,
-0.0985698774,
-0.2358338833,
-0.4098425508,
0.4747082591,
-0.722484827,
0.0934466794,
-0.4224618375,
-0.0146620106,
0.2159724087,
0.1434302032,
0.149280116,
0.5665181875,
0.2809669077,
-0.2416197062,
0.13105461,
0.0626002774,
-0.2175160348,
0.087520726,
-0.9241318107,
0.1922481209,
-0.5054643154,
0.4609178305,
-1.0369184017,
-0.1371157467,
0.341897279,
-0.5831030607,
0.3909781873,
-0.2812824249,
-0.568253696,
0.1128908545,
-0.5469165444,
0.3425012827,
0.0581976771,
-0.0774612129,
0.9093056917,
0.7431807518,
-0.332534641,
-0.6543099284,
-0.1107694879,
0.2089525312,
0.2988360822,
-0.4162991941,
-0.0623390861,
-0.072993964,
-0.6949033737,
-0.0718156174,
-0.086455971,
0.1489368528,
-0.1444325596,
0.4317114055,
0.1436224133,
0.25600335,
0.0622505508,
0.1606146842,
0.095228143,
0.4219321609,
0.1475074142,
0.451271832,
-0.2476255447,
-0.4389457107,
-0.423039645,
0.1665935367,
0.6358601451,
-0.2369713634,
0.4323413372,
-0.0146483937,
0.050363563,
-0.3836660981,
-0.6395153403,
-0.5887516141,
-0.4634302855,
0.5532467961,
0.0114512974,
-0.7004247904,
0.5362267494,
-0.0396209322,
-0.0214339308,
-0.0513056479,
0.6903687119,
0.1203729957,
0.931881547,
0.733109951,
0.0637958869,
0.5493230224,
-0.3489299119,
-0.091846168,
-0.6748684645,
-0.5079145432,
-0.5910577178,
-0.4043170512,
-0.6120932102,
-0.8108856082,
0.5246864557,
-0.3385159969,
0.0905794725,
-0.1604684591,
-0.352994591,
0.5848754644,
0.1039075702,
0.2185902297,
0.5591766238,
0.03604405,
-0.1204095036,
0.047060024,
-0.440700382,
-0.6388342977,
1.2358734608,
0.6480458975,
1.3393598795,
-0.138636604,
0.7194992304,
0.5418192148,
0.6702076793,
-0.5164251328,
0.6989831924,
0.4250040948,
-0.6839749813,
-0.4696447849,
-0.2950867414,
-0.8553486466,
0.6551079154,
-0.1927074492,
-0.3347305357,
0.6719408035,
-0.0682275593,
0.0328725129,
0.3647042811,
-0.3731917441,
0.455884397,
-0.1428775489,
-1.0807911158,
-0.3792467415,
-0.7900788188,
0.1515708715,
-0.1360523999,
0.2601857483,
-0.088926509,
-0.124464646,
0.5690951943,
-0.6501063108,
1.185329318,
-0.3647568524,
-0.1884723306,
0.3642931581,
0.5070317984,
0.6859158278,
0.6814228296,
-0.1893470585,
0.1369329542,
0.2477198392,
0.0443060733,
-0.4743195474,
0.551482141,
-1.0358014107,
-0.70111233,
-0.9144772291,
-0.4930719435,
0.0144692026,
0.0351649895,
-0.115370281,
0.1006627157,
-0.3824528754,
0.1587975323,
0.5214601755,
-0.1193496734,
0.2515284419,
1.2161439657,
-0.6056523323,
-0.425612092,
0.3727958798,
0.1852414459,
-0.0226278361,
0.0304400977,
0.3081816733,
-0.2688723505,
-0.635941267,
-0.1529705077,
0.4650431573,
-0.3764151037,
0.0541665964,
-1.0577641726,
0.047520373,
-0.3291127682,
0.4626217484,
-0.4305383563,
-0.2773427069,
-0.0015573463,
-0.1314633489,
0.1451263577,
1.1621659994,
-0.2673285902,
0.2727324665,
-0.6821759343,
0.1356460303,
0.2385306656,
0.5816066265,
0.2503423989,
-0.2640039325,
-0.1222120225,
-0.2640599012,
-0.6066535115,
-1.1867107153,
0.3952438235,
0.0875106156,
0.6123371124,
0.537971139,
0.21320723,
-0.0410604738,
-0.5747483373,
0.807580471,
-0.2778386176,
-0.729095459,
0.3288898468,
-0.5978146791,
-0.098592408,
0.7076709867,
0.2897486091,
-0.3236190379,
-0.5375869274,
-0.4848690629,
-0.6503980756,
0.7395317554,
0.3106536567,
0.1345944554,
0.3491365314,
0.556458652,
0.2486262172,
0.6443015933,
-0.924002707,
-0.0765947253,
-0.0523220077,
0.5545284748,
-0.3222144842,
-0.3291787505,
-0.2931169569,
-0.0278607104,
0.568320632,
-0.034968365,
0.1705146581,
0.5493555665,
0.1577593535,
-0.5011075735,
0.0995924994,
0.6578233838,
0.7903678417,
-0.3883855045,
-0.0167846344,
-0.2996837199,
-0.9089725018,
0.360206157,
0.1456177831,
-0.3279074132,
0.0729201064,
0.1199465021,
0.3884200156,
-0.267259866,
-0.4222873151,
0.6516575813,
-0.4078211486,
-0.3408210278,
-0.299394995,
-0.2003642768,
-0.1905966252,
0.686152339,
0.4193455875,
-0.0898073986,
0.3354884684,
-0.5770303011,
0.2324865758,
0.517172277,
-0.4582715034,
-0.5633224845,
0.9255193472,
0.3471387029,
-0.4723543227,
0.1109081954,
-0.1212828159,
-0.4007238746,
0.8878253698,
0.0557150356,
0.9908151031,
-0.2345792651,
0.6469862461,
-0.0281050317,
0.610327661,
-0.2561095953,
0.2798377275,
-0.0342843384,
-0.5213627815,
-0.509663403,
-0.5788835883,
-1.2003493309,
-0.0191180184,
-0.5805333853,
0.1514566243,
-0.4696778059,
-0.599026978,
-0.0898537487,
0.2757345736,
-0.1276484579,
-0.2875066102,
-0.0519132838,
0.8739319444,
-0.7989738584,
0.7596349716,
0.9368121028,
-0.2160567045,
-0.6739909649,
0.1797080934,
0.2781547606,
-0.5439859629,
0.7031436563,
0.0167390238,
-0.5107368827,
-0.3191287518,
-0.9272558093,
-0.651910305,
0.8594299555,
0.2531485856,
-0.4847990274,
0.0846495032,
-0.0331520587,
0.9454820752,
-0.389867574,
0.3881466985,
-0.0373678692,
0.4648159444,
-0.0694637895,
-0.7850749493,
-0.0757779703,
-0.6825856566,
0.006996884,
-0.0288789514,
-1.1168814898,
1.0618293285,
-0.3489501476,
0.1538584232,
-0.1610434949,
0.4835065305,
0.5034658313,
0.8619888425,
0.379473418,
-0.0311371665,
0.3810146153,
0.2442887425,
1.0893367529,
-0.7290722132,
0.560195744,
0.908197701,
-0.9767615795,
0.524939239,
0.6909765005,
-0.1722142845,
0.3782495856,
0.4582632482,
-0.1649698019,
0.3053391874,
0.3529178798,
-0.0251003318,
-0.1231552139,
-0.3138392866,
-0.5076152086,
0.3571915925,
0.0307449177,
-0.4694484472,
-0.0112097636,
-0.1262335181,
0.116187118,
0.0791974366,
-0.3450489938,
0.8404347301,
0.209042415,
-0.5879123807,
0.049931325,
0.0355615094,
0.3383283019,
-0.7405739427,
-0.312677592,
-0.2153153121,
0.1064137444,
-0.0371540748,
-0.8347316384,
-0.1441491842,
-0.0837832093,
-0.1010291651,
-0.6687171459,
0.6575590968,
-0.1239867136,
-0.3953549266,
0.5144373775,
0.9704720974,
0.2277710736,
-0.0393247157,
-0.459782362,
0.2892588079,
-0.3722918034,
-0.7692506313,
0.4660652876,
0.5094533563,
-0.0007510778,
0.7768990397,
0.5409210324,
0.5061135888,
-0.1927070618,
0.081323497,
1.0571777821,
-0.480022788,
-0.7529247999,
-0.7382726073,
-0.0495470613,
-0.0847089514,
-0.0048867972,
0.6967619061,
0.4413664639,
0.5648007989,
-0.1150500327,
0.6527934074,
0.2702022791,
0.3794864118,
-0.3610529304,
1.3301753998,
-0.6586990952,
0.4091313481,
-0.577141583,
-0.9981270432,
-0.0984875262,
0.437256217,
-0.2824341357,
0.1980831623,
0.7526934743,
0.9437506795,
0.4450919628,
0.13679564,
0.0715143234,
0.3821411133,
0.4250432253,
0.1197479144,
1.0625455379,
-0.1649618447,
0.377176851,
-0.1949388385,
-0.1240610182,
-0.1444813758,
-1.0940070152,
-1.0708585978,
-0.3165220916,
-0.3342350721,
-0.7516900301,
0.2519021034,
0.979899168,
0.5885975361,
-0.6081218123,
-0.6014229059,
0.1318362504,
0.249860853,
-0.0417089425,
-0.1925074011,
0.2990245819,
0.0227330346,
-0.7078880668,
0.0495827906,
0.0956183597,
0.0211562701,
-0.60578686,
-0.1528676152,
-0.0053510461,
0.1010759324,
0.3609181046,
0.0941857398,
-0.3889147043,
0.0681911707,
0.0831764936,
-0.0941047892,
-0.1022928879,
1.0676115751,
-0.6639387608,
0.6047613025,
0.6800583005,
0.3183166385,
0.4351227283,
0.2128371596,
0.4983121157,
-0.1979795992,
0.0996701866,
0.2501618862,
0.0802178234,
-0.1881681234,
-0.4876917601,
0.5887696743,
0.3350792825,
-1.00697124,
-1.236261487,
0.0543628745,
-0.9917497635,
-0.0945821628,
1.3020713329,
0.088738434,
-0.3005653918,
-0.0652818829,
-0.3338980973,
-0.0205882769,
-0.9532651901,
0.9739904404,
0.6885348558,
-0.3185303509,
-0.3679721355,
-0.6482106447,
0.4173036218,
0.1652567536,
-0.6463995576,
0.1234491095,
0.5457689762,
0.2799209058,
0.0296978876,
0.8057988286,
-0.3875046968,
0.1829576641,
-0.172609657,
-0.0052405628,
-0.393055439,
-0.4908251762,
-0.7371146679,
0.5161254406,
0.2316378802,
0.455404371
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12707v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12707v1 | Talk With Human-like Agents: Empathetic Dialogue Through Perceptible Acoustic Reception and Reaction | 2024-06-18T15:19:51 | 2024-06-18T15:19:51 | Haoqiu Yan, Yongxin Zhu, Kai Zheng, Bing Liu, Haoyu Cao, Deqiang Jiang, Linli Xu | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SD, eess.AS | Large Language Model (LLM)-enhanced agents become increasingly prevalent in
Human-AI communication, offering vast potential from entertainment to
professional domains. However, current multi-modal dialogue systems overlook
the acoustic information present in speech, which is crucial for understanding
human communication nuances. This oversight can lead to misinterpretations of
speakers' intentions, resulting in inconsistent or even contradictory responses
within dialogues. To bridge this gap, in this paper, we propose
PerceptiveAgent, an empathetic multi-modal dialogue system designed to discern
deeper or more subtle meanings beyond the literal interpretations of words
through the integration of speech modality perception. Employing LLMs as a
cognitive core, PerceptiveAgent perceives acoustic information from input
speech and generates empathetic responses based on speaking styles described in
natural language. Experimental results indicate that PerceptiveAgent excels in
contextual understanding by accurately discerning the speakers' true intentions
in scenarios where the linguistic meaning is either contrary to or inconsistent
with the speaker's true feelings, producing more nuanced and expressive spoken
dialogues. Code is publicly available at:
\url{https://github.com/Haoqiu-Yan/PerceptiveAgent}. | [
-0.2761751115,
-0.7769811749,
0.8676675558,
0.3914391696,
-0.1532315165,
0.0669050589,
-0.3239983022,
-0.4307463765,
0.4554218948,
0.2530001402,
-0.7315779328,
-0.3422760963,
-0.2489989698,
0.165763557,
-0.0249271467,
0.4641507566,
0.352627039,
0.1310400963,
0.2434010506,
-0.0251640938,
-0.2259587944,
-0.4911417961,
-0.5826906562,
-0.803521812,
0.6740531921,
0.4229740798,
0.6683943272,
0.2083683461,
0.054493878,
0.4472682774,
0.1872680336,
0.1346500963,
-0.2084603012,
0.36727494,
-0.11911349,
-0.4926587045,
-0.7127373219,
0.0481056049,
0.3123138547,
0.3423729837,
-0.2851844132,
-0.1913050711,
-0.1007024273,
-0.0570377074,
-0.4849213064,
0.2981388271,
-0.3830454946,
0.3754121363,
0.0879382342,
-0.4689648449,
-0.3907991648,
0.2072315663,
0.1670749187,
-0.6362765431,
-0.4167160392,
-0.1923573464,
0.1921919137,
0.677720964,
-0.5699104071,
-0.0303577594,
-0.8823110461,
0.7587265372,
-0.6653453708,
0.5756264329,
0.5106397867,
0.2059112489,
0.1013580933,
-0.368714124,
-0.9185512066,
-0.4318909347,
0.1143865734,
0.3999893963,
-0.2052044123,
0.3436658084,
0.1102774069,
-0.0781404972,
-0.5010937452,
0.1114660725,
0.5088432431,
-0.2477328181,
0.5881021023,
0.4587260783,
0.2819167674,
-0.2813367248,
-0.2499099225,
0.0805282965,
-0.1998272687,
-0.1087376326,
0.4337955117,
0.2812196612,
-0.4421743453,
0.4181115925,
0.050229378,
0.6026465297,
0.3463475406,
-0.2837281823,
0.386069864,
-0.1354297549,
-0.3844406307,
0.2906532288,
0.6325207949,
0.1380604357,
0.1695680618,
-0.009131521,
-0.2263269871,
0.1050924808,
0.3001847565,
-0.62643677,
-0.0538591444,
0.4731862545,
-0.331540823,
-0.4066846669,
-0.157209456,
-0.4407664239,
-0.6214441657,
-0.5357196927,
0.3286688924,
-0.5402765274,
-0.4482385516,
-0.0362783931,
-0.0557910837,
0.4811839759,
0.6205828786,
-0.7034249306,
-0.0532573834,
0.6871756315,
0.5361174345,
0.3731940389,
-0.4942208529,
-0.4804575443,
0.1991710514,
-0.0313916095,
0.7588983178,
-1.0212748051,
-0.3718445897,
-0.3370337188,
-0.2442998141,
-0.1248149499,
-0.1489056051,
0.5788532495,
-0.2115445733,
-0.2138580084,
-0.1333879828,
-0.2411596626,
-0.1380366087,
0.4343373179,
-0.4018363059,
-0.0318913646,
-0.111753501,
-0.5731509328,
0.147087127,
-0.7222313285,
-0.2484924942,
0.2454952151,
-0.5604025126,
0.1336243302,
0.121857591,
0.012421974,
0.175429821,
-0.3191194832,
0.0310588907,
-0.0238618311,
-0.2824665904,
0.8604899645,
-0.9866970181,
0.4872902632,
0.2988213599,
-0.3559233844,
0.2386069596,
-0.5494017601,
-0.1731320918,
-0.0345903486,
-0.4185206592,
-0.1959476322,
0.0810976774,
0.1855802536,
0.2385284454,
0.2043139637,
-0.8123845458,
-0.06940189,
-0.378087312,
0.3918387592,
0.8738686442,
-0.0624692328,
0.5947290659,
-0.3528634012,
0.6237438917,
-0.0907454714,
0.3262435198,
-0.2766151428,
-0.2504749596,
-0.5565115213,
-0.4545328021,
-0.3385489881,
0.6765748262,
-0.6929727197,
0.5363755226,
-0.0521439761,
-0.4613948464,
-0.5876051188,
-0.1279068887,
0.6208922267,
0.4129499197,
0.027547786,
-0.1488763243,
-0.3331727087,
-0.6567602158,
-0.5744927526,
-0.1717275381,
-0.1842612773,
0.7155814171,
-0.0059602903,
-0.5102891922,
0.8253452778,
-0.3425223529,
-0.3243126869,
-0.2759902179,
0.0486024395,
0.04644702,
0.3172944188,
0.2102864087,
-1.0016665459,
-0.4304314852,
0.1960196793,
-0.7587587833,
-0.3137924969,
-0.212630868,
0.1992612183,
0.0781264976,
0.3552365303,
-0.6838896871,
0.4152978957,
0.7213646173,
-0.6350963116,
0.3604153693,
0.1381331533,
0.2579267323,
-0.9869586825,
-0.1512012184,
-0.245586887,
-0.1640576124,
-0.8768132329,
-0.319912374,
-0.3157797456,
-0.0136280535,
-0.6685752273,
0.669749856,
-0.3056044281,
0.0282089096,
-0.2242358923,
0.2098076791,
-0.0811611637,
0.5178753138,
-0.0838861316,
0.6450439095,
0.434099853,
-0.3919974566,
0.7844427228,
0.6683554649,
0.1625389308,
1.0103280544,
-0.4463350177,
0.4306971431,
-0.0255982764,
0.4010020792,
-0.9100732207,
-0.5240709782,
0.4289824963,
-0.7715144753,
0.2796009779,
-0.0219013039,
-0.0282005034,
-0.0844728127,
-0.153881371,
0.4820461273,
0.094726868,
-0.5112679005,
1.4083571434,
0.2389655113,
-0.3237612545,
-0.3903555572,
-1.0553504229,
0.1408005059,
0.0214690529,
-0.5186905265,
-0.165733695,
-0.2064789087,
-0.6208883524,
-0.3777450919,
-0.0755570158,
-0.0049308972,
-0.1532125175,
0.4986326396,
-0.079562135,
0.1406532824,
0.3640859127,
0.1510157138,
-0.2174539268,
0.1008332521,
-0.2490717173,
0.8312850595,
-0.2328008711,
-0.7136737704,
-0.8503264785,
0.238386482,
0.6700456142,
-0.2858168781,
0.2981124818,
0.7577648759,
0.0570667908,
0.0278728753,
-0.6058754921,
-0.5802990198,
-0.5321113467,
0.2611145377,
-0.7296520472,
-0.7174571753,
0.4863193631,
-0.1119028255,
-0.4027720988,
-0.1471758038,
0.5289621353,
0.1817061752,
1.0692722797,
0.1545351297,
-0.0657177716,
0.7875573635,
0.0521559156,
0.2809384763,
-0.9993535876,
-0.2944454849,
-0.2527686954,
-0.4033437967,
-0.4283558726,
-0.4066893756,
0.5189983845,
-0.7512657642,
-0.4762136042,
-0.1150165647,
-0.2440500706,
0.2304504812,
0.3483781219,
0.3213364482,
0.4407188892,
-0.0627544299,
-0.106566526,
-0.014328707,
-0.2604295909,
-0.6227030754,
0.7916348577,
0.3656748831,
1.0580568314,
0.437476635,
0.5272446275,
0.1748000234,
0.1239248663,
-1.0006313324,
0.5875341296,
0.1615122259,
-0.4997584224,
-0.5356317163,
-0.3543797731,
-0.9466193318,
0.3766512871,
-0.2390978485,
-0.9960532188,
0.3839520216,
-0.0060205357,
-0.4204172194,
0.1196457446,
-0.5355365276,
0.5446489453,
-0.3896127045,
-0.474847734,
-0.4211092591,
-0.7944898009,
0.025961116,
-0.1992646903,
0.0787888691,
-0.1952599287,
-0.2496561557,
0.3017400801,
-0.3310127258,
1.0989897251,
-0.2405826151,
-0.2904805243,
0.157514587,
0.3782410324,
0.3393628895,
0.1072053388,
-0.2154685855,
0.0693837702,
-0.4801702201,
-0.2713847756,
-0.6082565188,
0.6834306121,
-0.9601374865,
-0.5690506101,
-0.2292684913,
-0.7552831173,
-0.247751072,
0.0696719289,
0.0233525261,
0.5386579037,
-0.4881571233,
-0.12525855,
0.3856823742,
-0.3492336273,
0.4913249016,
1.0411621332,
0.0813270062,
-0.2220941186,
0.7796136737,
-0.271451354,
0.3034273088,
0.6846238971,
0.3174678087,
-0.1868733913,
0.1306975037,
-0.30843696,
0.3370754123,
-0.3793161809,
-0.0619786158,
-0.7843080759,
0.0971387774,
-0.2714956105,
-0.3293861747,
-0.2373359054,
-0.2022188008,
-0.2728337348,
-0.3233577907,
0.3453838527,
0.9023922086,
-0.2706904411,
0.4586258233,
-0.7411566973,
0.1069146395,
0.6646993756,
0.0394899957,
0.0931211486,
-0.578402102,
0.1502437592,
0.1806218028,
-0.4584458172,
-0.9364407659,
0.7610663772,
0.063009806,
0.4433718324,
0.908039093,
-0.0754681453,
0.29016608,
-0.2929245532,
0.6767101884,
0.1752074212,
-1.1692705154,
0.5245679617,
-0.6697797179,
0.5126075149,
0.3116385043,
-0.0004776797,
-0.5700293779,
-0.4826680124,
-0.5729398131,
-0.6291589737,
0.7529172897,
0.0336637534,
0.3016988933,
0.1525170356,
0.0940459222,
-0.0640741214,
0.4212294817,
-0.3621005416,
-0.0563240796,
-0.2399167717,
-0.2175178677,
-0.3124082386,
-0.076822482,
-0.3337655365,
-0.0456290357,
0.2250760198,
-0.2924546599,
0.6622436047,
0.4380390048,
-0.1744066477,
-0.4405018687,
0.5468577147,
0.5885588527,
0.4930867553,
-0.1515714377,
0.332503736,
0.1748261005,
-0.5425081253,
0.2551958561,
0.1713052243,
0.2561914027,
-0.2859271169,
0.5068378448,
0.6133128405,
0.1885590851,
-0.7470924854,
0.7286266685,
-0.2043782175,
0.1979332864,
-0.5525059104,
-0.1701519042,
0.1488828212,
0.7158224583,
0.3211808503,
0.1537459195,
0.3825235963,
-0.6643433571,
0.033311218,
0.313277036,
-0.7273782492,
-0.6659286022,
0.5613996983,
0.5962918997,
-0.7087513208,
0.5707890391,
-0.0363556147,
-0.810076952,
0.3304798901,
0.45310992,
1.0685396194,
-0.8075127602,
0.1829025298,
-0.3482218087,
0.0406777486,
0.61774683,
0.5443049073,
-0.2943841219,
-1.2082446814,
-0.1959870011,
-0.404974699,
-0.5619199872,
-0.3122401536,
-0.3874966204,
-0.2799581289,
-0.3821839094,
-0.3853064179,
0.0020278245,
-0.1376497298,
-0.7697179914,
0.0437666029,
0.2706150711,
0.6539430022,
-0.9690020084,
0.6946771741,
0.8387178183,
-0.6160090566,
-1.221572876,
0.1551185399,
0.4426720142,
-0.8535417914,
0.5612921715,
-0.0950228646,
-0.6013621092,
-0.0193458069,
-0.4815004766,
-0.3154485226,
1.1322538853,
0.4249740541,
-0.5874226093,
0.172359094,
0.0932465866,
0.5391246676,
-0.4482896328,
0.7471615076,
0.6966278553,
0.9077660441,
0.2475799024,
-1.3046504259,
0.1471028626,
-0.2235682905,
-0.3180806935,
0.0547854342,
-1.0511353016,
0.9167647958,
-0.221262455,
0.1201074049,
0.0638304949,
0.191906184,
0.1553682685,
0.5063960552,
0.4901329577,
0.2676226497,
0.6694535613,
0.1207293123,
1.0971435308,
-0.1517991275,
-0.1679671556,
1.0180836916,
-0.4710096419,
0.707562983,
0.5637031794,
0.0662498698,
0.4503899217,
0.0377163664,
0.4471461177,
0.0715480819,
-0.040118061,
-0.8864161372,
-0.5317041278,
-0.5883841515,
0.0803768039,
1.1546980143,
0.4745796323,
-0.2957940102,
0.1654172838,
0.2092842758,
-0.0041211708,
0.1463739723,
-0.2092568874,
0.8629177213,
0.3957260847,
-0.372941345,
0.2729086578,
-0.3882532716,
0.674593091,
-0.5139078498,
-0.0869988203,
-0.0326939374,
0.4259868264,
-0.4619808793,
-0.6594985723,
-0.1281528622,
-0.337931931,
0.1065889373,
-0.2405362278,
0.8028903008,
-0.4687532187,
0.0747795627,
0.619410038,
0.7852987647,
0.3132136464,
-0.3125327229,
-0.5957265496,
0.2849420011,
0.03161598,
-0.3252073824,
-0.0439024232,
0.6132316589,
0.170342043,
0.8309144378,
0.4510265887,
0.0198283251,
-0.2866662741,
0.5094801784,
1.0397933722,
-0.6463583708,
-0.4693428278,
-0.7343215942,
0.2834358513,
0.1532605439,
-0.1143441349,
0.7478069663,
0.1951791495,
0.3570629656,
-0.0918448195,
0.7385731936,
0.1443719268,
0.4288286865,
-0.0839143097,
0.6583536863,
-0.407592833,
0.1365717351,
-0.440359205,
-0.8180764914,
-0.1699844152,
0.906104207,
-0.5544458032,
0.1819421053,
0.4716947675,
0.8549484015,
0.0865645409,
0.2680939436,
0.7505954504,
0.6590812206,
0.4229420424,
0.6319055557,
1.3142083883,
0.1472246796,
0.3637419939,
0.356608212,
-0.3504947722,
-0.3514267206,
-0.5004444718,
-0.7771058083,
-0.350245297,
0.2112884223,
-0.0677722692,
0.0361803919,
1.3219422102,
0.6509551406,
-0.408162564,
-0.3493383229,
-0.0894388333,
-0.01820172,
0.1703945696,
-0.2580069304,
-0.1562697589,
-0.0553247333,
-0.9013031721,
0.6649215221,
0.5168548226,
0.1659444869,
-0.3178841472,
-0.4213713408,
-0.1142854914,
0.4978764653,
0.6384063363,
0.2739010751,
-0.7649175525,
-0.3246415257,
-0.0893827379,
0.0121186851,
-0.1586637497,
0.7313143015,
-0.6386522055,
0.5734474063,
0.2457939237,
0.2514422536,
0.3734535873,
0.0868292227,
0.7699279785,
-0.4483468831,
0.5369925499,
0.565024972,
0.0752067864,
0.3449980617,
-0.4395185411,
0.224666059,
-0.0008293184,
-0.6780085564,
-0.4444331825,
0.6344766617,
-1.1382318735,
-0.0703600794,
1.2311086655,
-0.0024808913,
-0.2723452449,
-0.2992129326,
-0.6278383732,
0.3062333763,
-0.9613465667,
0.2986474633,
0.2703481913,
-0.4666673839,
-0.1021240801,
-0.0540859737,
0.3940003514,
0.4350233674,
-0.5274603963,
-0.0553804077,
0.5326598883,
0.0951380953,
0.3792518973,
0.8392156363,
0.2406799942,
0.1362317502,
0.3727505803,
0.2033939809,
-0.0316676013,
-0.278716296,
-0.4752086401,
-0.1545716673,
0.2400223613,
-0.0767085627
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12702v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12702v2 | [WIP] Jailbreak Paradox: The Achilles' Heel of LLMs | 2024-06-18T15:14:35 | 2024-06-21T00:05:35 | Abhinav Rao, Monojit Choudhury, Somak Aditya | cs.CL | cs.CL | We introduce two paradoxes concerning jailbreak of foundation models: First,
it is impossible to construct a perfect jailbreak classifier, and second, a
weaker model cannot consistently detect whether a stronger (in a
pareto-dominant sense) model is jailbroken or not. We provide formal proofs for
these paradoxes and a short case study on Llama and GPT4-o to demonstrate this.
We discuss broader theoretical and practical repercussions of these results. | [
-0.1482927501,
-0.5590061545,
0.9786558747,
0.0813154206,
-0.1834219992,
0.528265059,
0.3642432392,
-0.7766568065,
0.1425966173,
0.6650443077,
-0.2488324344,
0.0172927957,
-0.8224560618,
0.1196168661,
-0.7396988273,
1.0492624044,
-0.2722165883,
0.0667989552,
-0.1872653514,
-0.3350537717,
-0.8968755603,
-0.5514294505,
-0.1932313442,
-0.5641331673,
-0.0797773898,
0.5751956105,
0.6403676867,
0.666565001,
0.5373953581,
0.2808422446,
-0.2188114077,
-0.5157075524,
-0.4121279418,
0.2150272578,
-0.1218043268,
-0.8469991684,
-0.2096333057,
0.2675935924,
0.099066861,
0.3392927349,
-0.1647308469,
-0.0280051678,
-0.3928326368,
1.0523376465,
-0.6040801406,
-0.529725194,
-0.9627513289,
0.1139625758,
-0.3713336289,
0.1092531309,
-0.0734049007,
-0.3561672568,
0.0209657233,
-0.1384947747,
0.337158978,
0.2209457755,
0.8723546863,
0.4519169331,
-0.4948934317,
-0.2756363153,
-0.7560985088,
0.5293521881,
-0.4430072606,
-0.0635413751,
0.3257727623,
0.7096710205,
0.1284577399,
-0.8470185995,
-0.4656630754,
-0.6242735982,
0.2909190953,
-0.3650203049,
-0.1214684993,
-0.1568683535,
0.3481291831,
0.9159787893,
-0.2212634236,
0.2118086666,
-0.4465153217,
0.0097816493,
0.286493212,
0.2631964087,
0.2725422084,
-0.0340404473,
-0.7931270003,
0.261523217,
-1.3285079002,
-0.1376315206,
0.7059091926,
-0.1147791445,
-0.2189164907,
0.5615425706,
0.1989043206,
0.5580140352,
0.1223568469,
-0.3145073056,
0.310074538,
-0.0936298221,
-0.2120675147,
0.1622496396,
0.4884175658,
0.3470608294,
0.2120566517,
-0.4765096307,
-0.4216937125,
0.2009268254,
0.2177817076,
-0.5833060741,
-0.0208386332,
0.5688176155,
-0.2816947401,
-0.8457876444,
0.2133849859,
-0.5810806155,
-0.6592553854,
0.2604344785,
0.4743651748,
0.1074870676,
-0.2175858021,
0.2389663309,
-0.3222452998,
0.3123201132,
-0.1113922,
-0.8097468615,
0.573212862,
0.6010736823,
0.9636877179,
0.0585972331,
-0.33273983,
-0.0422104523,
0.0495188721,
-0.239116028,
0.716139257,
-0.1863905489,
-0.4547899663,
-0.3232811391,
-0.1722326875,
0.1028815135,
-0.9202651978,
0.4207370281,
-0.3109815419,
-0.4194358587,
-0.439083755,
-0.6026050448,
0.0118122594,
0.2848977149,
-0.7022202015,
0.632838428,
0.112618424,
-0.8872815967,
0.0626839697,
-0.2947186232,
-0.428625524,
-0.4792098403,
-0.2106535286,
-0.6033634543,
0.2369371653,
-0.220053494,
0.4012154639,
-0.6674892306,
0.6640814543,
-0.5836814046,
-0.4816331863,
0.3415618241,
-0.0333191045,
0.8459338546,
0.2352840602,
-0.8678078651,
-0.2855997682,
-0.6308559775,
-0.5418943167,
0.8788874149,
-0.0480293594,
-0.2017336488,
0.4084709585,
-0.3048328757,
0.0606866591,
0.1961873472,
-0.5523027778,
0.4728758335,
-0.0772830769,
1.0163618326,
0.8639727831,
-0.1268843412,
0.2222834826,
-0.5848094225,
0.3320071399,
-0.0721239597,
0.0006452493,
-0.0306459479,
-0.3614972532,
-0.77408427,
0.111641258,
0.2943029404,
1.0241553783,
-0.4115715623,
-0.1365850568,
0.0404152125,
-0.5122335553,
-0.1229572296,
0.1432603747,
0.5613470078,
0.518990159,
0.2104867697,
-0.6391677856,
-0.5678495169,
-0.7877975106,
-0.6322495937,
-0.398616761,
0.3523643315,
0.4884331822,
0.7388158441,
-0.0906028077,
0.7877278328,
-0.3768837154,
-0.1975396425,
-0.3000195324,
-0.1843377054,
0.2808170915,
0.5935661793,
0.9754596949,
-0.8717368245,
0.0843696147,
-0.4327320755,
-0.9311323762,
-0.1380838752,
0.0252516959,
0.3532559276,
-0.1299005896,
0.4042656124,
-0.8590073586,
0.6811264753,
0.0425912142,
-0.4130195081,
1.1532396078,
0.1397161037,
0.1047208682,
-0.6585627198,
-0.2917820811,
-0.1450423151,
-0.0185834672,
-0.7043732405,
0.3680287302,
-0.0374564901,
-0.0131348586,
-0.4145694971,
0.3429620564,
-0.2056755424,
-0.6200679541,
-0.2545937598,
0.1284957975,
-0.2056324482,
-0.0157935843,
-0.3106962144,
0.7359238267,
0.4556888044,
-0.5645077229,
0.6446355581,
0.156947881,
-0.383269459,
0.4623323977,
-0.8518331647,
0.0734332427,
0.1656006128,
0.1688488275,
-0.9424439073,
-0.3267160058,
0.0462590195,
-0.2319679111,
0.4668903053,
-0.333722353,
-0.5189625025,
-0.5614997149,
-0.545550406,
0.3751294315,
0.4584757388,
-0.8440303206,
0.0342734754,
0.2968983352,
0.1397515833,
-0.8438690901,
-0.7307221293,
0.1675797552,
-0.6804414988,
-0.6659644246,
0.478256911,
-0.1032978669,
-0.6948124766,
0.0938800573,
-0.493165791,
-0.0538297258,
0.7780937552,
0.4643880725,
0.1756620556,
-0.1488121897,
-0.1466871798,
-0.1662221998,
-0.253939718,
0.2062363774,
-0.2344956398,
0.307921797,
-0.4918742478,
-0.6370005608,
-0.2789319754,
-0.0693046674,
0.8418488503,
0.0371120572,
0.3712742627,
-0.191796422,
-0.349365443,
0.2248435766,
-0.6504713893,
0.0800547376,
-0.4637263715,
-0.0316335149,
-0.4645225108,
-0.8893897533,
0.6848678589,
-0.3890048563,
-0.1205750033,
0.4975594282,
0.4906027317,
0.0853075385,
0.5031026006,
0.9702009559,
-0.6619782448,
0.2222000957,
-0.3913632035,
0.3448806405,
-0.8002800345,
-0.1091357544,
-0.6964455247,
-0.3541778922,
-0.6859968305,
0.3291029036,
0.1257681549,
0.6961050034,
-0.6006637216,
0.5916183591,
-0.2688993216,
0.934158802,
0.2769193351,
0.1069765016,
0.4215415418,
-0.1990772039,
-0.4132713974,
0.2980859876,
-0.6218110323,
-0.5161013603,
1.187702775,
0.5320962667,
0.624595046,
0.3614930809,
0.8665012717,
0.2813753486,
0.4168152809,
-0.5047169924,
0.343650043,
0.120585002,
-1.057094574,
-0.0282543283,
-0.2199168354,
-0.5605612397,
0.1444356441,
-0.0472927354,
-1.1392713785,
0.2891560793,
0.2122886479,
-0.2310217023,
0.7872595191,
-0.6297994256,
1.0560221672,
-0.6235287189,
-0.4882159829,
-0.0059046387,
-0.8769748211,
0.9379721284,
-0.2858321071,
0.3182227015,
-0.4536259174,
0.3186736107,
0.4339198172,
-1.0055910349,
0.8229209185,
-0.2213192284,
0.3512187004,
0.5053834915,
0.2805745006,
0.6137501001,
0.110207662,
0.2097130865,
0.0422175974,
-0.1164470017,
-0.5756726265,
-0.1648106873,
0.5985628366,
-0.9323918819,
-0.9514943361,
-0.6163404584,
-0.236268729,
-0.3994807005,
-0.1394729465,
0.6488338113,
-0.1058477536,
-0.1412101537,
-0.2076119483,
0.4824189246,
-0.040497046,
0.5217447281,
0.4769699574,
-0.2424421608,
-0.2544009686,
0.6932200193,
0.1401226372,
0.2339787483,
-0.0640183538,
0.3901250362,
0.1164012924,
-0.8196995854,
-0.3468794823,
0.2334382385,
-0.6324340105,
-0.2495271415,
-0.0106025916,
-0.2927680016,
0.1768381894,
-0.3089771569,
-0.4990353286,
-0.5949492455,
-0.0892836675,
-0.5627484322,
0.4789272845,
1.0210365057,
-0.222501725,
0.4960640669,
-0.4694558084,
0.3769136667,
0.4451395571,
0.179689914,
0.0818743631,
-0.5756987333,
0.165662691,
-0.4377329648,
-0.6968784928,
-1.3201434612,
-0.0359521806,
-0.0657420307,
0.4527910352,
0.6690739989,
0.0488529876,
0.4230757654,
-0.632799387,
0.7004675269,
0.505510807,
-1.0784094334,
0.6553305387,
-0.2001258433,
-0.555711329,
0.541371882,
0.4457748532,
-0.0529945493,
-0.3894782364,
-0.7948826551,
-1.0357811451,
0.2444393635,
0.150148809,
0.0289204288,
-0.0018369514,
0.7131335735,
0.1914283931,
0.4173412919,
-0.9544708729,
-0.5290060043,
-0.188685298,
0.2681844831,
0.0595516451,
-0.7158667445,
-0.15796341,
-0.1085342616,
0.5246203542,
0.566699028,
0.105144076,
0.1123592556,
-0.3130472302,
-0.0488941483,
0.1921071112,
0.5621935725,
0.8368437886,
-0.3618640304,
0.2105535418,
0.0694324225,
-0.4967492819,
0.7313531041,
-0.0590764321,
-0.2512675226,
-0.2267659754,
0.3752090931,
0.8571540117,
0.2875488997,
-0.6093560457,
0.7864344716,
0.0717928484,
-0.1628845483,
-0.3793202043,
0.0302854571,
0.0962955356,
0.5477301478,
0.4667562246,
0.0984928161,
0.0359534323,
-0.8166767359,
0.3583793342,
0.2886482179,
-0.12975429,
-0.1548669487,
0.9388474822,
0.1430597603,
-0.3926120996,
0.4748532474,
-0.1271128654,
-0.8925635219,
0.992503047,
0.6947519779,
0.8951756358,
-0.4153752327,
-0.1314698905,
-0.1347946078,
0.6483959556,
-0.4457503557,
0.0658042431,
0.0812435299,
-0.8537407517,
-0.153625831,
-0.2419340461,
-0.7151780725,
0.2660964131,
-0.7053197026,
0.0646924227,
-0.7716042399,
-0.2652504742,
-0.0147613715,
-0.0951454565,
-0.2577027977,
-0.0737106875,
-0.1812963635,
1.0321815014,
-0.9901753664,
0.7692483068,
0.4009903073,
-0.158382237,
-0.5378013849,
0.0559193939,
0.3640757501,
-0.7156691551,
0.4957974553,
0.3966181874,
0.1771832407,
-0.3320577443,
-0.9686763883,
-0.7326981425,
1.2355858088,
0.6130461693,
-0.7343087196,
0.2527261972,
-0.1291557252,
0.0581706353,
-0.2723773718,
-0.3138530552,
1.1298696995,
0.3639399111,
0.0509777777,
-0.8779603243,
-0.0060972301,
0.0140293548,
-0.287745595,
0.3475851417,
-0.6006546021,
1.0051158667,
-1.0217767954,
0.0527883731,
0.5858668685,
0.1875292361,
0.5504799485,
0.6556457281,
0.4802603126,
1.1870005131,
0.5619945526,
-0.3812339008,
1.287856102,
-0.4109504223,
0.5572385788,
0.9352774024,
-0.5427491069,
0.6081343293,
0.5639100671,
-0.4708274901,
0.3391574323,
0.8898677826,
-0.2320781648,
0.6615139842,
0.2674665451,
-0.3137032092,
-0.1081921905,
0.4608766437,
-0.4901370108,
0.3940669596,
0.22705625,
-0.1238850951,
-0.0917244479,
-0.1996802986,
0.3080239296,
-0.2662838995,
-0.3671948612,
0.349260956,
0.4918397069,
-0.1274974644,
0.4094279706,
0.4097206295,
0.3807680011,
-0.3451879919,
0.1898222119,
-0.3134552836,
0.1243644953,
-0.2960473597,
-0.5564767122,
0.2303505689,
0.3734963238,
-0.09412276,
0.4036643803,
0.902823925,
0.2845146358,
-0.0594969653,
0.5394659638,
0.5201945305,
0.1716396511,
0.019018108,
-0.795958519,
0.0404183045,
-0.2611119151,
-0.4231471419,
0.5369238257,
0.0127229989,
-0.1585745066,
1.0473854542,
0.441295445,
-0.1777621955,
0.087009348,
-0.5101583004,
0.9592225552,
-0.8884400129,
-0.2603408694,
-1.3246614933,
0.2846331894,
0.1875433773,
-0.1091696396,
0.5026032925,
0.3292931616,
0.7298930287,
0.0131162275,
0.7530866861,
-0.2008863091,
0.1456170678,
-0.6079239845,
0.529035449,
-0.4772751331,
0.8849067092,
-0.4147117436,
-0.7743861675,
-0.1133223325,
0.7206248045,
-0.4580123723,
-0.0462429598,
0.8765855432,
0.1865374446,
0.1578713506,
-0.0552386567,
0.1760666817,
0.4627410173,
-0.1417840719,
0.8390927315,
1.0433729887,
-0.4798738658,
0.4072836936,
-0.2443381548,
-0.1141770929,
-0.3778366446,
-1.0686036348,
-0.7793184519,
-0.1715087593,
-0.2041549981,
-0.6621822715,
0.2523209453,
0.262801826,
0.4662408829,
-0.6875995994,
-0.3727110326,
-0.199513793,
0.9411800504,
-0.0205922127,
-0.1142256558,
0.1104110554,
0.058695633,
0.027855143,
0.3845040798,
0.3739941716,
0.4108527303,
-0.0693604052,
-0.1875845641,
0.1759214848,
-0.0050614513,
0.2359222472,
0.6993709207,
-0.7637665272,
-0.375309974,
-0.5364395976,
0.0419223867,
0.1518052667,
0.9478708506,
-0.757668376,
0.0532853529,
0.0005144313,
0.7195150852,
0.6099500656,
-0.2005552948,
0.3377743661,
-0.6280630231,
0.3869217634,
-0.0103868274,
0.7183196545,
0.2849199474,
-0.2451009154,
0.8864375949,
0.9401437044,
-0.5593208671,
-1.1213243008,
0.6013779044,
-0.7387043834,
-0.5685650706,
0.5968101025,
-0.2054553479,
-0.0985375345,
0.0073734615,
0.227025494,
-0.2929542363,
0.2911475301,
0.8737150431,
0.7499940395,
-0.1889568567,
0.0284339692,
-1.0291982889,
0.2546882629,
0.0657883361,
-0.5498054028,
-0.270678401,
0.1586202979,
0.86266011,
0.1964824349,
0.5371900797,
-0.2393924594,
0.4529114366,
0.13903898,
-0.1920907348,
-0.2468606532,
-0.4259077907,
-0.4614012837,
0.1421581209,
0.4067237377,
0.1663702726
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12692v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12692v1 | MAGIC: Generating Self-Correction Guideline for In-Context Text-to-SQL | 2024-06-18T15:06:06 | 2024-06-18T15:06:06 | Arian Askari, Christian Poelitz, Xinye Tang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.DB, cs.HC | Self-correction in text-to-SQL is the process of prompting large language
model (LLM) to revise its previously incorrectly generated SQL, and commonly
relies on manually crafted self-correction guidelines by human experts that are
not only labor-intensive to produce but also limited by the human ability in
identifying all potential error patterns in LLM responses. We introduce MAGIC,
a novel multi-agent method that automates the creation of the self-correction
guideline. MAGIC uses three specialized agents: a manager, a correction, and a
feedback agent. These agents collaborate on the failures of an LLM-based method
on the training set to iteratively generate and refine a self-correction
guideline tailored to LLM mistakes, mirroring human processes but without human
involvement. Our extensive experiments show that MAGIC's guideline outperforms
expert human's created ones. We empirically find out that the guideline
produced by MAGIC enhance the interpretability of the corrections made,
providing insights in analyzing the reason behind the failures and successes of
LLMs in self-correction. We make all agent interactions publicly available to
the research community, to foster further research in this area, offering a
synthetic dataset for future explorations into automatic self-correction
guideline generation. | [
-0.064440757,
-0.7444496155,
0.348352015,
0.2678665519,
0.0339630507,
-0.1081962585,
-0.2259566337,
-0.0666861683,
0.3064178824,
1.1127383709,
-0.9572529197,
-0.3942534328,
-0.0794663429,
0.5885931253,
-0.1776633412,
1.3910256624,
0.0421380848,
0.1407071203,
-0.1260834783,
0.0424406379,
-0.8247294426,
-0.5064449906,
-0.331432879,
-0.2756910622,
0.5469484925,
0.8009035587,
0.7123824358,
0.7059657574,
0.5154995322,
0.3065804243,
0.5991147161,
1.0474017859,
-0.5527660251,
0.380125165,
-0.3534823656,
-0.4616155028,
-0.9634292722,
0.0365884453,
0.577593863,
0.2621815205,
-0.5160225034,
0.0915766507,
0.2344853133,
1.003749609,
-0.4384555817,
0.0492570922,
-1.093005538,
0.0281716399,
-0.4379775226,
-0.6394940615,
-0.4784497023,
-0.2539607584,
-0.322739929,
-0.720995605,
0.4985463917,
0.1472761333,
0.4306973517,
0.5305380225,
-0.5335155725,
-0.3236125112,
-0.9419568181,
0.3093597591,
-0.6353812218,
-0.1728492379,
0.3598660231,
0.5173726082,
-0.745111227,
-0.4905456305,
-0.8368494511,
-0.0662152246,
-0.1690410227,
0.0030638555,
0.3197015226,
0.1174227148,
0.0531660356,
0.0045066178,
-0.2496795058,
-0.5133771896,
-0.1916160882,
-0.0438558534,
0.9156762958,
0.434563905,
0.042475123,
0.1326707453,
0.0944503173,
0.0415658355,
-0.8245836496,
-0.6469271779,
0.4061180055,
0.5267804265,
0.4918287992,
0.5821641088,
-0.1105758026,
0.5096565485,
0.4137206376,
-0.4511102438,
0.0262949057,
-0.5901353359,
-0.1562151313,
0.2238056958,
0.8696875572,
0.6543822885,
0.3488203883,
-0.2693954706,
-0.315766871,
-0.3783791959,
0.5162349939,
-0.5610743165,
-0.2577401698,
-0.0284760054,
-0.0261600185,
-0.1747725308,
-0.2469200641,
-0.5415354371,
-0.7206792235,
-0.4039682448,
0.5458270311,
-0.1704714298,
-0.1453172863,
-0.1218425855,
0.1134507284,
0.0030884803,
0.6258122921,
-0.8259726763,
0.2340559512,
0.2770724893,
0.4829592109,
-0.1454710513,
-0.7637093067,
-0.4506214559,
0.621527195,
-0.7168052793,
1.0086538792,
-0.1709197164,
-0.4735209942,
-0.2255216241,
0.0026213625,
-0.094685711,
-0.5160635114,
0.3108231425,
-0.3937267959,
0.2549788058,
-0.2485315353,
-0.5097997785,
0.2713311017,
0.2237315476,
-0.4811350107,
0.8981460333,
-0.1520230621,
-0.4265132546,
0.42697981,
-0.8843163252,
-0.3141063452,
0.0325715765,
-0.1962860525,
-0.6132694483,
-0.1549687088,
0.0905437917,
0.2307560444,
-0.3786772788,
0.2007825673,
-0.1915598363,
-0.1729243696,
0.2993090749,
-0.5568166971,
0.3949798644,
0.1951474547,
-0.2650042474,
0.1319292188,
-0.8698427081,
0.1012531742,
0.223388359,
-0.2148669511,
-0.1407175064,
0.0940391123,
-0.2468665987,
0.3495660424,
0.2188701481,
-0.1266814619,
0.6609942317,
-0.2108296305,
0.1738245338,
0.8422733545,
0.0831390694,
0.4527435899,
-0.2280082256,
0.2769398689,
-0.258956939,
0.3272259533,
-0.4440195858,
-0.1768745631,
-0.5374270082,
0.0128773097,
0.1728627533,
0.5478701591,
-0.6933217049,
0.4370249212,
-0.1525295526,
-0.47867468,
-0.6560875177,
0.3840861022,
0.4175324738,
0.6344609857,
0.4951146841,
-0.0174550638,
-0.4133578539,
-0.7381490469,
-0.6355234385,
0.0694189668,
0.386839211,
0.1957258731,
0.4790914357,
-0.3426220715,
1.3687134981,
-0.3786881268,
-0.9424756765,
0.250338167,
-0.0762618855,
0.0814205185,
0.3933303952,
0.3070761561,
-0.3343298137,
-0.7144455314,
-0.0038825034,
-0.8363882303,
-0.2216792554,
-0.2502079308,
-0.3842059076,
0.6936539412,
0.3375214636,
-0.2103405148,
0.4524356723,
0.387857765,
-0.5996246338,
0.7480789423,
-0.735178411,
0.3983767927,
-1.1085840464,
-0.2172898352,
-0.2543039322,
-0.1006741002,
-0.5935057402,
-0.3081310987,
0.1021328121,
0.2716324329,
-0.0638625249,
0.5407893062,
-0.8065979481,
0.1329048276,
-0.4551372528,
-0.005050661,
-0.0247049127,
0.5498059392,
-0.239936322,
1.0070573092,
0.2366187871,
-0.6101706624,
0.5692471862,
0.3035750091,
0.4358628094,
1.0205457211,
-0.2755602002,
0.3793871105,
-0.025533231,
0.3383387625,
-0.855294764,
-0.2816012204,
0.4895042777,
-0.2888223827,
0.3451284766,
-0.3582469523,
-0.7503497005,
-0.2532510161,
-0.0451047011,
0.1699787825,
0.2212840915,
-0.3946588933,
0.8414916396,
0.4080140293,
0.1942035705,
-0.7427836061,
-0.7134678364,
0.625087738,
-0.0161428805,
-0.7304344177,
0.3505576253,
-0.391556412,
-0.1523740292,
-0.1728095114,
-0.0271923095,
-0.0957431123,
-0.1310993135,
0.1206930429,
0.0075253868,
0.2203969657,
0.2970786095,
0.1189642847,
-0.0480264053,
0.2827180624,
-0.1950938851,
0.1429199129,
-0.0715273842,
-0.461594373,
-0.2942323685,
0.374410212,
0.5008794069,
-0.2282484919,
0.7836360931,
0.2451263815,
-0.1883042604,
-0.4918560386,
-0.8067392707,
-0.4857495129,
-0.5019591451,
0.0035187353,
-0.4472738206,
-0.2954549193,
0.4623554945,
0.0552124195,
0.2592463195,
0.5807700753,
0.5999481678,
-0.0198254976,
1.1634937525,
0.5274423361,
0.5426009893,
0.2453812957,
0.018260343,
-0.0686436221,
-0.4842710793,
-0.3307264149,
-0.3649350405,
0.1379389912,
-0.5011242628,
-0.4098148942,
0.6434645653,
-0.0969068855,
-0.0445602052,
0.1462191343,
-0.8733829856,
0.6976822615,
0.4514482617,
-0.0122714983,
0.6774839759,
0.1196282133,
-0.189881146,
-0.2300110459,
-0.6178463101,
-0.6663302183,
1.2385516167,
0.0017828689,
0.9828822017,
0.0669785962,
0.8527498841,
0.6008490324,
0.4825356901,
-0.2812705934,
0.4433662593,
0.2085553408,
-0.7543941736,
-0.4828180373,
-0.3057179749,
-0.9176155329,
0.3052753508,
-0.488712281,
-0.0161985159,
-0.1130185947,
0.5988377929,
-0.2258579433,
0.197263509,
-0.8383439779,
0.8572769761,
-0.1705967635,
-0.5975481868,
-0.2812197804,
-0.5992513895,
0.2453758121,
-0.4564766288,
0.313018173,
-0.0422552973,
-0.0828287601,
0.4889230132,
-0.9833561182,
0.9506083131,
-0.1193599552,
-0.5331560373,
0.460664928,
0.2781223953,
0.9039302468,
-0.1032543331,
-0.1402479559,
0.0210636538,
-0.0022397293,
-0.1744120866,
-0.7642399073,
0.4520994723,
-0.6543697119,
-0.6116573811,
-0.544187665,
-0.4659851193,
-0.1517958343,
0.2103504539,
0.0619145408,
0.1889193803,
-0.0178993866,
-0.2113324106,
0.4655376971,
0.1881223023,
0.3976930976,
1.0548129082,
-0.2684830129,
-0.6841914058,
0.8899857402,
0.5893421173,
0.0183256269,
-0.1095048413,
0.072427623,
-0.3446047604,
-0.5012318492,
-0.6952511072,
0.4737069905,
-0.7875101566,
-0.2533965707,
-0.5292328,
-0.2128507495,
-0.5043309331,
0.0703568012,
-0.5263440609,
-0.134832859,
-0.3131893277,
0.2701970041,
0.6561582088,
0.991315186,
-0.2392411828,
0.3180109262,
-0.8574652076,
0.0858636573,
0.5726256967,
0.3760550618,
-0.3413626552,
-0.5245150924,
-0.3950048983,
0.1932335943,
-0.5365663767,
-1.2866152525,
0.512024343,
0.4867976904,
0.5491369963,
0.0458081402,
0.2150343359,
0.9867711663,
-0.9710332751,
0.5974798799,
0.1176377162,
-0.8825387359,
0.7648743391,
-0.5852853656,
-0.2116009295,
0.3657522798,
-0.2215181887,
-0.5962751508,
-0.4604367912,
-0.5536477566,
-0.5742520094,
0.7459082007,
0.3530029058,
0.1096648499,
-0.1657103598,
0.762178421,
0.0948191062,
0.3934618831,
-0.6190880537,
-0.6985035539,
-0.2025733441,
-0.0506142341,
0.1955019683,
-0.0592150167,
-0.4437385499,
-0.0805278867,
0.8034414649,
-0.6919924617,
0.2188356072,
0.489207238,
-0.1418653131,
-0.5482774973,
0.1645050049,
0.7305116057,
0.8753242493,
-0.0137542943,
-0.1090849191,
0.5422950387,
-0.2462926209,
0.0004448599,
0.0694322214,
0.0462652594,
-0.140815869,
0.1152325198,
0.2678768933,
-0.388794601,
-0.3928368986,
0.4056661129,
-0.3188754022,
-0.2529734373,
-0.5879334211,
0.2583793104,
-0.2606206834,
0.1152283028,
0.6336773038,
0.2328922153,
0.1678494364,
-0.514605999,
0.2428067327,
0.6226813197,
-0.1622260064,
-0.1109490991,
0.6568157077,
0.3815415204,
-0.5563052893,
0.378839165,
-0.5018026829,
-0.1934246421,
0.3303422034,
0.629974246,
0.6999871135,
-0.3869078755,
0.156997025,
0.1533655077,
0.3102127612,
-0.223255381,
0.2230787724,
0.1981090754,
-0.683234036,
-0.5764569044,
-0.185476169,
-0.5094871521,
-0.2786045372,
-0.2412712425,
0.3504547775,
-0.2730444372,
-0.1497134119,
-0.2835928202,
0.0890974924,
-0.3447004855,
0.110509485,
-0.1845369786,
0.5202263594,
-0.5004342794,
1.0029213428,
0.5008735657,
-0.4553632438,
-0.9363029003,
-0.0261063036,
0.0294622444,
-0.7942687273,
0.2510170341,
-0.1755608022,
-0.340690732,
0.0219007209,
-0.7647994757,
-0.7158765793,
1.2395581007,
0.5940537453,
-0.4938171208,
-0.2191319168,
0.1846998483,
0.8419557214,
-0.5631673932,
0.5338956714,
0.5312303901,
0.5813382268,
0.0990834311,
-1.0968222618,
0.0948149711,
-0.1852007061,
-0.1313948035,
0.2367762476,
-0.8354843855,
0.6488442421,
-0.3819884062,
0.0175909866,
-0.2352185249,
0.5870144963,
0.314047277,
0.2392628193,
0.4059856534,
0.1098579541,
0.9044232965,
0.054191377,
0.8377764821,
-0.5214398503,
0.2574031353,
1.2009726763,
-0.3399490118,
0.3627113104,
0.3381097019,
-0.0279604048,
0.6308426857,
0.4779746532,
-0.2403300256,
0.184525758,
0.1272475719,
-0.0866765603,
-0.3272820711,
0.0154627953,
-0.3768545687,
0.2054967731,
0.2880442739,
-0.2842428386,
-0.1209619865,
-0.2643841505,
0.2154263109,
0.352827549,
-0.4230433702,
0.9317747355,
-0.226085946,
-1.0441119671,
0.5645591617,
-0.0110158985,
0.5461522937,
-0.5802893043,
-0.4291146696,
-0.2855277658,
0.4278992116,
-0.468421936,
-0.7952340841,
0.5026328564,
-0.2032466233,
-0.3286384046,
-0.3398320973,
0.6337173581,
-0.8091244698,
-0.2689175606,
0.1096648127,
0.5349292755,
0.13413091,
-0.3355533183,
-0.9921545386,
-0.5209166408,
-0.1506866217,
-0.1620621532,
0.1540903449,
0.9213713408,
-0.1070341021,
0.7573594451,
0.6614544392,
0.0801493973,
0.1703737974,
-0.0008667353,
0.6207135916,
-0.6541642547,
-0.3381946981,
-1.0295128822,
0.4995905757,
-0.22098355,
-0.2043726891,
1.0229712725,
0.4129271507,
0.4714577794,
-0.135152936,
0.6928068399,
0.2884958982,
0.4374160767,
-0.4221681058,
0.8880139589,
-0.6721393466,
0.4017786086,
-0.2749657035,
-0.7732941508,
-0.2998075783,
0.4300555587,
-0.0323191583,
0.2382319421,
0.8911929131,
1.2701846361,
0.469304055,
-0.3453561962,
0.3306016028,
0.2288462222,
0.3533477485,
0.1358526796,
0.6441693902,
-0.4587684274,
1.0338584185,
-0.0316077657,
-0.0298478976,
-0.3275594413,
-1.1110314131,
-0.9859411716,
-0.6050758362,
-0.4029855728,
-0.8996763825,
0.3864550292,
1.4198559523,
0.7661504745,
-0.5961125493,
-0.3452902138,
-0.1958637536,
0.3608239591,
-0.4424606264,
-0.2066325992,
0.2490165383,
-0.6107851863,
-0.555670023,
0.3679179251,
0.2188128084,
0.1126497611,
-0.4790267944,
-0.3980890512,
0.0851981118,
0.3196895123,
0.2981633544,
0.1151778623,
-0.6674428582,
0.1080229133,
-0.1085509807,
-0.4575225413,
0.2495990098,
0.7823683619,
-0.595108211,
0.6867551208,
0.1470832676,
0.3087284565,
0.1571557075,
-0.273824513,
0.7700693607,
-0.906383872,
-0.578117907,
0.003143888,
0.1523100734,
0.3087440431,
-0.7052362561,
0.8150866628,
0.511588335,
-0.9846950769,
-0.732698679,
0.0519118942,
-0.6367665529,
-0.0702012628,
1.2729705572,
0.2348839194,
-0.4389155507,
-0.2247224003,
-0.7067089677,
0.227316007,
-0.6113305688,
0.9822621346,
0.4822759628,
-0.1613579541,
-0.0899896398,
-0.2088743448,
1.0134619474,
0.1350663453,
-0.9114555717,
0.4383224547,
0.6768807769,
0.5264924765,
0.1518755555,
0.8761319518,
0.097703658,
0.298447758,
-0.1138410866,
0.4799321294,
-0.2916642129,
-0.4277733564,
-0.2855496407,
0.0322294459,
0.0973555893,
0.3026475608
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12687v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12687v1 | Using LLMs to Aid Annotation and Collection of Clinically-Enriched Data in Bipolar Disorder and Schizophrenia | 2024-06-18T15:00:24 | 2024-06-18T15:00:24 | Ankit Aich, Avery Quynh, Pamela Osseyi, Amy Pinkham, Philip Harvey, Brenda Curtis, Colin Depp, Natalie Parde | cs.CL | cs.CL | NLP in mental health has been primarily social media focused. Real world
practitioners also have high case loads and often domain specific variables, of
which modern LLMs lack context. We take a dataset made by recruiting 644
participants, including individuals diagnosed with Bipolar Disorder (BD),
Schizophrenia (SZ), and Healthy Controls (HC). Participants undertook tasks
derived from a standardized mental health instrument, and the resulting data
were transcribed and annotated by experts across five clinical variables. This
paper demonstrates the application of contemporary language models in
sequence-to-sequence tasks to enhance mental health research. Specifically, we
illustrate how these models can facilitate the deployment of mental health
instruments, data collection, and data annotation with high accuracy and
scalability. We show that small models are capable of annotation for
domain-specific clinical variables, data collection for mental-health
instruments, and perform better then commercial large models. | [
-0.3449556231,
-0.7388136387,
0.9796881676,
0.3033994734,
-0.1853338778,
-0.0430264547,
-0.1858498305,
-0.5750687718,
0.5113955736,
0.5545511246,
-0.6452884674,
-0.7728431225,
-0.7551493645,
0.3073183596,
-0.4145584702,
1.2147784233,
-0.0303391274,
0.4167316854,
-0.0813454092,
0.0380317047,
-0.3432221413,
-0.6972450614,
-0.5503004789,
-0.2834829688,
0.9038498998,
0.3424921036,
0.8359811306,
0.4659127295,
0.9020556808,
0.0783362314,
-0.0597034879,
0.4720642567,
-0.3976812661,
0.2563167512,
-0.2691868544,
-0.291446805,
-0.8624136448,
-0.198589161,
0.5785710812,
1.0091519356,
-0.0913083181,
0.3293170035,
-0.1864624619,
0.4519132078,
-0.4593002498,
0.0817301199,
-0.0494562723,
0.15584822,
-0.3746824861,
-0.177376464,
-0.3682051003,
-0.1161129847,
-0.0597362332,
-0.5615965128,
0.0791131407,
0.0174493343,
0.5164305568,
0.2428150624,
-0.4044571221,
-0.2516286969,
-0.9111363292,
0.2660905123,
-1.0548472404,
0.1357962936,
0.6895381212,
0.0244676135,
-0.2678474784,
-0.7838997841,
-0.3581443429,
0.2579239607,
-0.1966597289,
-0.1172274724,
0.0358526185,
0.111648798,
0.6978162527,
0.2572713196,
-0.3348463178,
0.2264378816,
-0.4077386558,
-0.0084084552,
0.9897162914,
0.6299224496,
0.4908764958,
-0.2064903229,
-0.0122103635,
0.4132703245,
-0.6293873191,
-0.0953880548,
-0.2740260363,
0.5938053131,
-0.1681386083,
1.0338993073,
-0.0794348717,
0.7814563513,
0.0247946791,
-0.4756773114,
0.0627732649,
-0.3403547704,
-0.2690819204,
-0.0942649916,
0.6639665961,
0.5267993212,
0.0184569098,
-0.3926400244,
-0.1801677644,
-0.1366484016,
0.4244263172,
-0.6074554324,
-0.2797530293,
0.4096960723,
-0.2498422265,
0.1638463438,
-0.1650912613,
-0.5645381212,
-0.5664151311,
-0.554060936,
0.2182103395,
-0.2634430528,
-0.1009308547,
0.2811122537,
-0.0730856434,
-0.0764063224,
0.2676027119,
-1.0622563362,
0.579639852,
0.9843150377,
1.0011203289,
-0.3392661512,
0.1141756624,
-0.3436778784,
0.2907219529,
-0.3917518854,
0.7742372155,
-0.2914935648,
-0.3936626315,
0.0665919185,
0.1949500442,
0.155009076,
-0.4284395576,
0.2370045483,
-0.3181165457,
-0.125417918,
-0.5031384826,
-0.7249631882,
0.0939047784,
-0.0664144829,
-0.5271556973,
0.8549551964,
0.4022176266,
-1.0917639732,
0.2645530403,
-0.3048808575,
-0.6419620514,
0.3781605363,
-0.2161640674,
-0.1920523345,
0.3677005172,
0.1464502215,
0.8186680675,
-0.2710519135,
0.5234283805,
-0.5959066153,
-0.4625045955,
0.3614847362,
0.0691863,
0.6055019498,
-0.1270533502,
0.045080889,
0.1148444712,
-0.6894947886,
-0.3367539048,
0.0187920164,
-0.1995889097,
-0.5340521336,
0.2593883276,
0.1501650512,
0.1505426913,
0.0965656564,
-0.3875779212,
0.1282588392,
-0.3760544658,
0.3263629377,
0.2373073697,
0.3919526339,
0.1473531872,
-0.6902172565,
0.5569653511,
-0.0777006745,
0.0704764947,
-0.0647658259,
-0.6959133148,
-0.2357720584,
-0.9313495159,
0.0680229068,
0.8049355745,
-0.4806096256,
0.6529650092,
-0.3673071563,
-0.4578064978,
-0.6856854558,
0.0973168537,
-0.0523975417,
0.5095296502,
0.5744057894,
-0.3863868415,
-0.5615481138,
-0.821231544,
0.1378881037,
0.1350788772,
-0.1536067426,
0.2012717575,
0.2506168187,
-0.5803760886,
0.95182091,
-0.3634619415,
-0.0583393984,
-0.3424793482,
0.2134894431,
0.01995131,
0.2738156021,
0.1200929657,
-0.4310462475,
-0.2251902372,
-0.293055743,
-0.9726680517,
-0.3790354729,
-0.050737571,
-0.232243374,
-0.2120517343,
0.2305095643,
-0.6886603236,
0.2821280956,
0.3509902656,
-0.3625388145,
0.2806504667,
0.0130417617,
-0.1562447995,
-1.1869063377,
0.0440144427,
0.1580530554,
-0.427221626,
-0.8129736781,
-0.1729924381,
-0.1233265102,
0.1356586367,
-0.3637366295,
0.3707531989,
-0.1929739565,
-0.0577193983,
-0.2807039022,
0.3925662935,
-0.0471029133,
-0.0078069121,
-0.0522661991,
0.4603489041,
0.5289586782,
-0.3241979778,
0.4125132859,
0.2459365278,
-0.1929375827,
0.4994395971,
-0.3186623752,
-0.049413614,
-0.0993715152,
0.0422387421,
-0.9089412689,
-0.4819327295,
0.333232373,
-0.1234198213,
0.3792695999,
0.2934599221,
-0.8596615791,
-0.3745759726,
-0.2107285112,
0.3153437674,
0.3172058463,
-0.1186619252,
0.0819108561,
0.7849889398,
-0.4892720878,
-0.1973705143,
-0.751455307,
0.1176315472,
-0.4525680542,
-0.3871143162,
0.3410107195,
0.0623090379,
-0.4798232019,
-0.0653595701,
0.0778238773,
0.097423315,
0.27183339,
0.3592232168,
0.3957363367,
-0.2471737266,
0.5416442156,
0.0817319974,
0.0904275253,
0.2866321802,
0.2183880806,
0.400657326,
0.1307371557,
-0.3725329041,
-0.4343935549,
0.8236680031,
0.2463661134,
0.163684085,
0.7529901266,
0.3162809014,
-0.8338376284,
-0.0516174547,
-0.458207041,
-0.2701323628,
-0.3286682665,
0.2152608484,
0.0419786982,
-1.1290476322,
0.521489799,
-0.0303087234,
0.076656267,
0.2185970545,
0.71706599,
-0.2617574632,
1.2213954926,
0.6845299602,
-0.0848775283,
0.2830260694,
-0.0639410466,
0.541544497,
-1.0925481319,
0.0307128206,
-0.1176942885,
-0.1736943424,
-0.6249239445,
-0.5320833325,
0.2643605173,
0.2027833909,
-0.3306991458,
-0.0694456547,
-0.5345278382,
-0.1674635112,
0.1867438704,
0.4953757823,
0.4717239738,
-0.2044653296,
0.2653443217,
-0.4552079439,
-0.5996682644,
-0.7667993903,
1.1564507484,
0.4215106964,
0.6889375448,
-0.0810886398,
0.7041262388,
0.4553532302,
0.9401859641,
-0.8702287674,
0.4802494049,
-0.0215079598,
-0.5617391467,
-0.3020926416,
-0.1308711767,
-0.6655623913,
-0.0101837078,
-0.2942454517,
-1.0445822477,
0.2661026716,
0.0588737838,
-0.8497496247,
0.0830613673,
-0.2040417492,
0.5759857297,
-0.3016650975,
-0.2427738756,
0.0783463493,
-0.7514193058,
0.5770370364,
-0.4449691772,
0.4315768778,
-0.6298545599,
-0.2298150063,
0.7846856117,
-0.2773749828,
0.9042282701,
0.1636442691,
-0.1086394191,
0.037345767,
-0.1193233132,
0.1132661626,
0.292112112,
-0.0056925984,
0.0846041963,
0.3170758784,
-0.2200694084,
-0.6239249706,
0.4300991595,
-0.5607523322,
-0.7762278914,
-0.357766211,
-0.8957042098,
-0.3733673692,
-0.0309653282,
-0.0039039536,
0.4472158253,
0.065033637,
-0.2540650964,
0.531298995,
-0.0419951081,
0.1937305331,
0.5104843378,
-0.3574891984,
-0.4435674548,
0.4336714447,
0.1701879054,
0.2374126613,
0.0868010148,
-0.002930006,
0.1418134123,
-0.3901998103,
-0.0290970281,
0.7061476707,
-0.7387256026,
-0.4062024057,
-0.6333014369,
-0.2886256576,
-0.638100028,
-0.2882442474,
-0.1804914325,
-0.4264995754,
-0.3599936068,
-0.3651409149,
0.6669175625,
0.7905423641,
-0.2307190895,
0.3760208189,
-0.7203469872,
0.6099808812,
0.0049601342,
0.0814580396,
-0.0056484612,
-0.340008229,
-0.4902943373,
0.0461280309,
-0.0953400955,
-1.3034533262,
0.6634098291,
0.0051436084,
0.3470181525,
0.4076455534,
0.1096870825,
0.8817927837,
-0.578792274,
0.6806707978,
-0.0305396467,
-0.7279140353,
0.7252213359,
-0.3672639132,
0.1427091211,
0.5323175788,
0.8323584795,
-0.7613720894,
-0.6055594087,
-0.516410768,
-1.0468920469,
0.5950042009,
-0.1986000687,
-0.0091168201,
-0.4469206631,
0.8456031084,
-0.0401452482,
0.0597400032,
-0.5168256164,
-0.3230025768,
0.1956121325,
-0.5255293846,
-0.3061550856,
-0.4098106325,
-0.4866866469,
-0.493804127,
0.5078921318,
-0.0490996242,
0.4555934668,
0.5367471576,
0.0711921826,
-0.1743693799,
0.0639306083,
0.4582751095,
0.5008844137,
-0.2804779112,
0.2975417674,
0.0295180865,
-0.2870126665,
0.0626450777,
0.2021699697,
-0.2589850128,
-0.0440126769,
0.4987552166,
0.5277830362,
0.297151804,
-0.8656252623,
0.3129303157,
0.1938632131,
0.2134805769,
-0.2331819683,
0.0033019353,
0.5078154802,
0.5894001126,
-0.0300770532,
-0.5331298113,
0.4876059294,
-0.4985197484,
0.3637253642,
0.3731872439,
-0.3282999396,
-0.3621123135,
0.3545304537,
-0.1408386081,
-0.7455196381,
0.6249847412,
-0.0071183085,
-0.0525900647,
0.4245283604,
0.9201831222,
0.5362171531,
0.1069851592,
0.1040865704,
0.1646353602,
0.0673730224,
-0.5440664291,
0.5271391273,
-0.0458700284,
-0.7024359703,
-0.4166315496,
-0.470297575,
-0.5865412354,
0.0389812402,
-1.1209162474,
0.2835168839,
-0.4365360737,
-0.8840147257,
-0.0212509781,
-0.0639996901,
-0.5537990332,
0.1711045355,
0.680768609,
0.8087332249,
-0.9174915552,
0.7883099914,
0.7695941925,
-0.277209878,
-0.6189077497,
-0.1680409163,
0.0542301759,
-0.5658690333,
0.3807238936,
0.0939019471,
0.165482074,
-0.0246652607,
-0.4865300357,
-0.9922885299,
1.0255491734,
0.0677318275,
-0.4864698946,
-0.1846105158,
0.3278697729,
0.9269795418,
-0.7635981441,
-0.0788180307,
0.7160739303,
0.4286171198,
-0.2407115996,
-0.6943377852,
0.2345321476,
-0.2148913741,
0.0170461796,
0.0522873253,
-0.1061929762,
0.5852215886,
-0.3816657662,
-0.269595027,
-0.0466853753,
0.4989885688,
0.5530865788,
0.469307214,
-0.0680681989,
0.5149208903,
0.9530726075,
0.0392100178,
0.971204102,
-0.3543863893,
0.2668272555,
1.2843382359,
-0.4830150008,
1.0652645826,
0.3724961579,
-0.0523294322,
0.1930161417,
0.8761814237,
-0.1575668901,
0.459458828,
0.3668136895,
-0.4590784013,
-0.3051242828,
-0.1880896837,
-0.1180153638,
-0.1639350951,
0.8780654669,
-0.3879211247,
0.0318410024,
0.191807583,
0.2881771922,
0.0277038775,
-0.3442224264,
0.7789950371,
0.5887168646,
-0.3539809585,
0.1861345768,
0.0058161267,
0.5112661123,
-0.2968471944,
0.2096512765,
-0.1514222175,
-0.0090148048,
-0.2418410331,
-0.6869680882,
0.7023227215,
-0.0572351478,
-0.2611905634,
-0.2424958944,
0.6236559749,
-0.3894379139,
-0.840131104,
0.3809761107,
0.7431056499,
0.1819823831,
0.1335730404,
-0.2416145802,
-0.1951878816,
-0.4667490125,
-0.2192383707,
0.3048897982,
0.5222874284,
-0.2780488431,
0.6824990511,
0.289170444,
0.714312315,
0.0960197449,
0.0963647366,
0.6408776045,
-0.9883034229,
0.144210726,
-0.9231125712,
0.267499119,
0.0388373584,
-0.2696805894,
0.6675349474,
0.3243461549,
0.5784981251,
0.1979085952,
0.5898995996,
0.116015166,
0.7959933281,
-0.1072946787,
0.3803382516,
-0.5320772529,
0.1369297206,
0.0166155044,
-0.3090752363,
-0.7893998027,
0.5830380321,
-0.3850838244,
-0.2706006169,
0.4997823238,
0.6239930391,
0.2517584562,
-0.0041699377,
0.2165378034,
0.2194169164,
0.3343165517,
0.5428885221,
0.6555519104,
-0.2052438706,
-0.6306828856,
-0.483825326,
-0.1069990024,
-0.0638494641,
-0.6502282619,
-1.0213088989,
-0.3278155029,
-0.4338229597,
-0.1152760461,
0.1652547121,
1.1392505169,
0.5376994014,
-0.6403636336,
-0.1901983023,
0.3660108149,
0.1492503881,
-0.2942613959,
-0.1974605918,
0.1675537825,
-0.4279226661,
-0.1967135519,
0.1718250662,
0.5256835818,
0.0802005231,
-0.3286368847,
0.4359974861,
-0.2349469811,
0.2032976896,
0.7430637479,
0.1138928607,
-0.8316996694,
-0.201885134,
-0.0525628291,
-0.4510212541,
0.1860214621,
0.7938781977,
-0.5841159225,
0.076707691,
0.3531437218,
0.4699475467,
0.2701517045,
0.1910658479,
0.6993433237,
-0.2406964451,
-0.1423897147,
0.3803884685,
0.3967877924,
0.5583311319,
-0.5801917315,
0.4251483679,
0.2997616529,
-0.4516356289,
-0.8964577913,
-0.0578386635,
-1.2084612846,
-0.0479362532,
1.1679586172,
-0.2887865901,
0.0560225546,
-0.403427273,
-0.0965528637,
0.4060252309,
-0.0896252692,
1.0350817442,
0.7413055301,
-0.5612974763,
-0.1543814242,
-0.9128654599,
0.5205903053,
0.2110276073,
-1.0135649443,
0.0424656309,
0.3356305063,
0.2000614554,
-0.0277800262,
0.92468822,
-0.1663234532,
0.1217703745,
-0.3415401876,
0.1328474283,
0.2398444861,
-0.0753828511,
-0.3289936483,
-0.0079814335,
0.0182042867,
0.4624357522
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12680v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12680v1 | Measuring Psychological Depth in Language Models | 2024-06-18T14:51:54 | 2024-06-18T14:51:54 | Fabrice Harel-Canada, Hanyu Zhou, Sreya Mupalla, Zeynep Yildiz, Amit Sahai, Nanyun Peng | cs.CL | cs.CL | Evaluations of creative stories generated by large language models (LLMs)
often focus on objective properties of the text, such as its style, coherence,
and toxicity. While these metrics are indispensable, they do not speak to a
story's subjective, psychological impact from a reader's perspective. We
introduce the Psychological Depth Scale (PDS), a novel framework rooted in
literary theory that measures an LLM's ability to produce authentic and
narratively complex stories that provoke emotion, empathy, and engagement. We
empirically validate our framework by showing that humans can consistently
evaluate stories based on PDS (0.72 Krippendorff's alpha). We also explore
techniques for automating the PDS to easily scale future analyses. GPT-4o,
combined with a novel Mixture-of-Personas (MoP) prompting strategy, achieves an
average Spearman correlation of $0.51$ with human judgment while Llama-3-70B
scores as high as 0.68 for empathy. Finally, we compared the depth of stories
authored by both humans and LLMs. Surprisingly, GPT-4 stories either surpassed
or were statistically indistinguishable from highly-rated human-written stories
sourced from Reddit. By shifting the focus from text to reader, the
Psychological Depth Scale is a validated, automated, and systematic means of
measuring the capacity of LLMs to connect with humans through the stories they
tell. | [
-0.5659772754,
-0.5666450858,
0.9016594887,
0.7922425866,
-0.3148549497,
0.2176250219,
-0.2703851163,
-0.6326383948,
0.0908886641,
0.1272573173,
-0.4257556498,
-0.5526247025,
-0.6768557429,
0.2983304858,
-0.2942495942,
0.9404600859,
-0.0982040316,
-0.19214724,
-0.2760140598,
0.0047878744,
-0.0503744259,
-0.3955470026,
-0.361425668,
-0.3886238039,
0.7776215672,
0.1152242199,
0.8256859779,
0.5331110358,
0.6852806807,
0.2261978388,
-0.0381451137,
-0.1453420818,
-0.6429957747,
0.1199466661,
-0.2024057359,
-0.495705694,
-0.4636092484,
0.287922889,
0.4303483963,
0.9698322415,
-0.0381224453,
-0.0768905059,
0.1582586318,
0.7326641679,
-0.5010662675,
-0.1798246354,
-0.0182505529,
0.330252558,
0.0009436331,
-0.1660147607,
-0.3248342574,
-0.4528808594,
0.5220236182,
-0.2410022169,
0.2779692113,
-0.2004768401,
0.6623998284,
-0.0489747562,
-0.5948058963,
-0.3747496903,
-0.6341353655,
0.7851086855,
-0.6188352704,
0.1697313637,
0.4662318528,
-0.1425957382,
0.353489399,
-0.3219857216,
-0.6570935845,
-0.4435377717,
-0.2082930505,
0.1347045451,
-0.2584379315,
-0.011458504,
0.1371642351,
0.7657855153,
-0.6457944512,
-0.06643904,
-0.1284184605,
0.1511523426,
1.0112162828,
0.5245342255,
0.3598758876,
-0.1563746035,
-0.3170145154,
-0.2005257308,
-0.3619345129,
0.4264161885,
0.4723914564,
-0.1634469479,
-0.3836325407,
0.6497144103,
-0.0118239513,
0.3183239996,
0.130961746,
-0.475102067,
0.2634194493,
-0.2793526649,
0.0347949676,
-0.2168773413,
1.0435529947,
0.8481186032,
0.5355247259,
-0.1978827268,
-0.1404072046,
0.4038194716,
0.3638540804,
-0.7887123823,
-0.2070844322,
0.2155198455,
-0.3879110217,
-0.4050633609,
-0.0438277498,
-0.7018390298,
-0.9371905923,
-0.1138094589,
0.1486192793,
-0.5690641999,
-0.4699328244,
0.3917070925,
-0.2308259308,
0.3739810586,
0.244285062,
-0.9030559659,
0.5106520653,
0.5876319408,
1.0847343206,
-0.3601188362,
-0.4940982461,
0.1061457172,
-0.0591547079,
-0.7487344742,
0.8448542356,
-0.3081919849,
-0.5245276093,
-0.1346601844,
-0.4988490641,
0.3421117961,
-0.3146435022,
0.6023142338,
-0.0849771351,
0.4155521095,
-0.4665499926,
-0.4326507449,
0.0134253548,
0.3470420241,
-0.3095420897,
0.793876946,
0.2838671505,
-0.5791652203,
0.4996294081,
-0.4856579304,
-0.6335500479,
-0.0662646741,
-0.0539216921,
0.0228141826,
0.4440691173,
0.3104437292,
0.5132849216,
-0.4133087993,
0.3943991065,
-0.4480220973,
-0.3736945093,
0.4993387163,
-0.2934580743,
0.6749423742,
0.0151538355,
-0.1759464592,
0.1302804798,
-0.6931524277,
-0.065592356,
0.1111569628,
-0.3174326718,
-0.3636956811,
-0.1667784303,
-0.1404396594,
0.0973984599,
0.2991975546,
-0.6111435294,
-0.0448790379,
-0.7163201571,
0.2719212174,
0.6788542867,
0.1423993558,
0.6859792471,
-0.3220132291,
0.7346140146,
-0.2165252268,
0.06358549,
-0.1824117601,
-0.2844630778,
-0.4105788469,
-0.6648865938,
-0.2076176107,
0.3500005007,
-0.0889508873,
0.878474772,
-0.1415942758,
-0.9993553162,
-0.491350174,
0.0820129216,
0.2655387521,
0.4122601449,
0.016245164,
-0.7406938076,
-0.1547723562,
-0.7550671697,
-0.7530451417,
-0.3953439295,
-0.5450417995,
0.2948427498,
0.2268081605,
-0.0972798243,
1.0742710829,
-0.4347393513,
-0.1969267428,
-0.275701195,
0.4625894725,
0.2311760932,
0.2530145049,
0.5678454041,
-0.2951679826,
-0.5787332058,
-0.1946397126,
-1.0330580473,
-0.4663130939,
-0.0881704539,
0.0898099467,
-0.0710069314,
-0.0341455601,
-0.9050620794,
0.3570483029,
0.4789212942,
-0.6757257581,
0.5577602386,
-0.1758532673,
0.1472837925,
-0.6587089896,
-0.0349830166,
0.3893941939,
0.1603996605,
-0.4933827817,
-0.0741506889,
0.063227199,
0.0540081635,
-0.282620877,
0.670874238,
-0.4381938577,
-0.2120884359,
0.0754294246,
0.2832188904,
0.490800947,
0.4141478837,
0.0714880154,
0.3361305594,
0.5069812536,
-0.4309699833,
0.6811287999,
0.0236209612,
-0.4248298109,
1.0078845024,
-0.6623628736,
0.1896607876,
0.016535284,
0.3414883018,
-1.1470555067,
-0.2057333887,
-0.0258834511,
-0.4774969518,
-0.046901349,
0.3145165145,
-0.6873705983,
-0.2903189659,
-0.5546275377,
0.2264541686,
0.3885465264,
-0.3342093229,
0.6986808777,
0.2597304881,
-0.5023195148,
-0.1745314002,
-0.6560453773,
0.5062354803,
-0.507720232,
-0.8377100825,
0.2751911879,
-0.3436356783,
-0.6201913953,
-0.1585841477,
0.0062037022,
-0.0832166672,
-0.0225040559,
0.1706044823,
-0.0735841766,
-0.2055371702,
-0.0971419811,
0.2059085518,
0.0350563303,
0.6514167786,
0.4485951364,
0.5750232935,
-0.5612932444,
-0.3898765147,
-0.5699352026,
0.2598047853,
0.6382205486,
-0.2777403295,
0.6331031322,
0.6215938926,
-0.2684283555,
0.1438922137,
-0.5515326858,
-0.2426036596,
-0.4363971353,
0.3666508794,
-0.5928146839,
-0.6298266053,
0.6241514683,
0.1541346163,
-0.3017518818,
0.2236632854,
0.5717064738,
-0.2674160302,
1.1877572536,
0.6253169775,
-0.1123558581,
0.235163331,
-0.0944127515,
0.5683107972,
-0.792970717,
-0.1828886867,
-0.1813200861,
-0.5933713913,
-0.1480217278,
0.0657988489,
0.3490404785,
0.2970997989,
-0.264945507,
-0.1307133436,
-0.2706868052,
0.687741816,
0.3198229074,
0.1164021045,
0.5228156447,
-0.0913056508,
0.0975820795,
-0.4319883883,
-0.1712962091,
-0.7320551276,
1.0180488825,
0.8401050568,
0.9203336239,
0.2267282903,
0.6457605362,
0.2923745215,
0.5323801041,
-0.949074924,
0.6171330214,
0.426897198,
-0.4288806915,
-0.6154841781,
-0.312651068,
-0.8034545183,
0.3547228873,
0.1056245416,
-0.8126124144,
0.353970468,
-0.3016018271,
-0.456699729,
0.0049867951,
-0.6691690683,
0.7074754834,
-0.4765423238,
-0.3772808313,
-0.2087944001,
-0.5952787399,
0.3790695965,
-0.0551341027,
-0.0065276017,
-0.2707993388,
-0.4629665613,
0.6495549679,
-0.1224681437,
0.9063997269,
0.0075129215,
-0.6772579551,
0.1814389676,
0.7331630588,
0.1348497719,
0.2084997296,
-0.0680951253,
0.1897043586,
0.0094986223,
-0.4152704477,
-0.6937524676,
0.613237381,
-0.8932086825,
-0.4575751722,
-0.6095219254,
-0.9097296,
-0.5219666958,
0.117109932,
0.1712307483,
0.0443351418,
-0.4714854062,
0.2125164717,
0.4518632889,
-0.3609490693,
0.2580278814,
0.6568212509,
-0.2317299843,
-0.46459499,
0.6891713738,
-0.2945950031,
0.249150902,
0.2775474489,
0.5074825883,
-0.4889219701,
-0.3998038173,
-0.1519385278,
0.4800090194,
-0.61078614,
-0.0012895463,
-0.66298908,
0.0560794286,
-0.4378829002,
-0.4781585038,
-0.2408841252,
-0.0250344109,
-0.2682262659,
-0.6122376919,
0.3024402857,
0.853929162,
-0.3378261328,
0.2323226929,
-0.5876255035,
0.178621009,
0.1917588264,
0.5483007431,
0.0386621393,
-0.6703611612,
-0.0825959444,
-0.1285174191,
-0.5279750824,
-0.9116985202,
0.6969348192,
-0.0264081191,
-0.0376605317,
0.8225232959,
0.0490246639,
0.642829299,
-0.1614136994,
0.8809979558,
0.2960453331,
-1.2273203135,
0.3812415302,
-0.7012222409,
0.2151521593,
0.3475269973,
0.4516509175,
-0.7253171802,
-0.5863144994,
-0.5200505257,
-0.6882833242,
0.5354787707,
0.0385234207,
0.5409443378,
-0.074598223,
0.2873671949,
0.1262783259,
0.2516904175,
-0.8559189439,
0.1411232799,
-0.0689672828,
-0.4798160493,
-0.4677217305,
-0.460721612,
-0.1812208295,
-0.3291429877,
-0.0333248898,
0.1023692414,
0.0871059224,
0.268589288,
-0.0142928623,
-0.5010312796,
0.0366853364,
0.4618572593,
0.8616321087,
-0.440028578,
0.367983669,
0.0284492709,
-0.332893461,
0.2127593011,
-0.1649309993,
0.3945893049,
-0.3958368003,
0.779774189,
0.3751927316,
0.05102171,
-0.9614400864,
0.7379152179,
-0.1172627881,
-0.2237036377,
0.0109443637,
0.0389198586,
0.2984474301,
0.454898119,
0.1841769516,
-0.1007310972,
0.0630776137,
-0.7376338243,
-0.0967484489,
0.1660896838,
-0.2880862355,
-0.4725310802,
0.0334721915,
0.3880349398,
-0.4248979092,
0.4024073184,
-0.1374425143,
-0.2178142071,
0.4444527924,
0.3975601494,
0.8587731123,
-0.2097438127,
0.3374835849,
0.052683007,
0.4151422977,
-0.0663710237,
0.2527893782,
0.0717002898,
-0.8419977427,
-0.3141731322,
-0.7083194852,
-0.4493107796,
0.2674247324,
-0.7349033356,
-0.0982002318,
-0.5455515385,
0.0081046009,
-0.4496397674,
0.1705053151,
-0.5175011754,
0.3494714499,
0.1369685382,
0.7756570578,
-0.9595215321,
0.3671519458,
0.4432984293,
-0.4886592329,
-0.325455606,
0.1139292717,
-0.0281692483,
-0.6112067103,
0.4701878726,
0.0902733728,
-0.1444458514,
0.0084380293,
-0.2785210311,
-0.6913098693,
0.9547364712,
0.5030012727,
-0.2707767189,
-0.1231423393,
0.3572008312,
1.328279376,
-0.4578834772,
0.1669286042,
0.6838133931,
0.3395834863,
-0.4028006196,
-0.7888012528,
0.0434247367,
-0.2895455658,
0.0702995211,
-0.1659239233,
-0.4629581869,
0.7129606009,
-0.3828067482,
-0.2692058384,
0.2693973184,
0.5390973091,
0.4520615041,
0.3896971941,
0.4049738944,
0.6312382221,
0.7046461701,
0.1553839892,
1.3747389317,
-0.2708056271,
0.1901736557,
0.8642277718,
-0.5470569134,
0.6293385029,
0.4445781708,
-0.3776127398,
0.5802854896,
0.7729806304,
0.0853637755,
0.4963625073,
0.5611917973,
-0.349653095,
0.0412167236,
-0.0998939723,
-0.2344822586,
0.2274338007,
0.2948463559,
-0.5509551167,
0.1068768054,
0.0754663497,
0.0003506693,
0.4096283317,
-0.0914327726,
0.7422708869,
0.3928563297,
-0.5722896457,
0.3299178779,
0.036111787,
0.5088805556,
-0.4244128764,
0.3910464942,
-0.5519765615,
0.2818581462,
-0.100323312,
-1.3111311197,
0.1331384033,
0.3365931511,
-0.2478639483,
-0.4039211273,
0.5965825319,
-0.2658911347,
-0.4517474771,
0.5029908419,
0.771271944,
0.1437354535,
-0.4454324245,
-0.4496988356,
0.2319758832,
-0.4618600905,
-0.5888251662,
0.4142051339,
1.0505484343,
0.4005716443,
0.810839355,
0.5281033516,
0.17975685,
-0.2927185893,
0.2332226485,
0.5228446126,
-0.8511986732,
-0.6201642752,
-1.0353760719,
0.4214538336,
0.0131164007,
-0.5752933025,
0.7743779421,
0.4155756235,
0.5868305564,
0.0044671386,
0.784078002,
0.1935376376,
0.3942057192,
-0.1039470434,
0.7595632672,
-0.3992941976,
0.3833717108,
-0.6139514446,
-1.0291693211,
-0.3263360858,
0.8704559207,
-0.5995300412,
0.1103810221,
0.8149063587,
0.6394668221,
0.1766801924,
-0.0342675894,
0.3872957528,
0.3241180778,
0.3183273971,
0.4719016552,
1.2150526047,
0.0603246279,
0.3111550212,
-0.3180777133,
-0.5638932586,
0.0806032866,
-0.8462048769,
-1.1416238546,
-0.4047960639,
-0.1041038707,
-0.315674752,
-0.366925925,
0.3919805884,
0.3154110312,
-0.1740327626,
-0.5397814512,
-0.1263275594,
-0.1402215064,
-0.1897991151,
-0.3552137315,
0.1410596371,
-0.2315477133,
-0.4688498378,
0.1398750991,
0.5946424007,
-0.0959393084,
-0.7550153732,
-0.3572616875,
0.3239804506,
0.321657151,
0.9131498337,
-0.2347059101,
-0.9483247995,
-0.2320755124,
-0.0034806379,
-0.3923106194,
0.0451496132,
0.7449758649,
-0.4973064661,
0.3341482878,
0.5208224058,
0.4151384532,
0.2491656244,
-0.1295263171,
0.8948662281,
-0.715875864,
-0.2838429213,
0.4885436296,
0.2497529089,
0.4458584189,
-0.4666068554,
0.5287657976,
0.3466873169,
-0.3360054493,
-1.0514976978,
0.1992575675,
-0.9636814594,
-0.1783752143,
1.0471271276,
-0.1669579148,
0.078112945,
0.1806279868,
-0.420971632,
-0.1906433851,
-0.4120263457,
1.1809008121,
1.0822718143,
-0.4294165671,
-0.4799636006,
-0.059924379,
0.405389756,
0.3575868011,
-0.8404135704,
0.153682813,
0.3493859768,
0.2077811658,
0.2342856824,
0.7940189242,
-0.1563299447,
-0.0049372977,
-0.0040556779,
0.1256996542,
0.4130797088,
-0.1618556976,
-0.283572495,
0.2722750604,
-0.0243215188,
0.5452006459
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12679v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12679v1 | Vernacular? I Barely Know Her: Challenges with Style Control and Stereotyping | 2024-06-18T14:51:30 | 2024-06-18T14:51:30 | Ankit Aich, Tingting Liu, Salvatore Giorgi, Kelsey Isman, Lyle Ungar, Brenda Curtis | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large Language Models (LLMs) are increasingly being used in educational and
learning applications. Research has demonstrated that controlling for style, to
fit the needs of the learner, fosters increased understanding, promotes
inclusion, and helps with knowledge distillation. To understand the
capabilities and limitations of contemporary LLMs in style control, we
evaluated five state-of-the-art models: GPT-3.5, GPT-4, GPT-4o, Llama-3, and
Mistral-instruct- 7B across two style control tasks. We observed significant
inconsistencies in the first task, with model performances averaging between
5th and 8th grade reading levels for tasks intended for first-graders, and
standard deviations up to 27.6. For our second task, we observed a
statistically significant improvement in performance from 0.02 to 0.26.
However, we find that even without stereotypes in reference texts, LLMs often
generated culturally insensitive content during their tasks. We provide a
thorough analysis and discussion of the results. | [
-0.3734329045,
-0.8342722058,
0.3823467195,
0.3023668528,
-0.1560914963,
0.4299522638,
-0.222971499,
-0.561930716,
0.0564764664,
0.2097305804,
-0.2523607612,
-0.5239220858,
-1.1174702644,
0.4230865836,
-0.5675010681,
0.5597125888,
-0.0857368261,
0.1110436246,
0.1416088045,
-0.0025197864,
-0.6588190794,
-0.5651732087,
-0.4234017134,
-0.0941938534,
0.2385693938,
0.6138726473,
0.7509527802,
0.3735176623,
0.4179671109,
0.3213273883,
-0.5719850659,
0.0857578442,
-0.6078878045,
-0.0165201407,
-0.1597489864,
-0.2093703449,
-0.4887421429,
0.1444420666,
0.5437285304,
0.9511966109,
-0.0016273045,
0.2308076471,
0.0303737968,
0.7716637254,
-0.3461475968,
0.1695781797,
-0.6851208806,
-0.0241274294,
-0.3197381198,
0.2424682379,
-0.5048521161,
-0.3425657153,
0.0134285763,
-0.4413131177,
0.0321214311,
0.176346153,
0.981407702,
-0.0043083224,
-0.8943168521,
-0.5643260479,
-0.8447259068,
0.697236836,
-0.5561351776,
0.4602501988,
0.5568784475,
0.2496803254,
0.0938258469,
-0.5843633413,
-0.4359206557,
-0.2623292506,
-0.1462596655,
-0.0538856946,
-0.4112412333,
-0.1069267467,
0.1744756401,
0.1634198278,
-0.3125404119,
0.2024205774,
-0.8650140166,
-0.2038220018,
0.413579613,
0.3006770909,
0.1718218476,
-0.1364179552,
-0.3789773583,
0.2635769248,
-0.7641396523,
0.058470834,
0.1828549802,
0.3445624113,
-0.2889002562,
0.5476276278,
-0.2216199487,
0.7114690542,
0.1247226745,
-0.591438055,
-0.0858915523,
-0.2271195799,
-0.1184987426,
-0.3040460348,
0.312964797,
0.4439899921,
0.8090217113,
-0.1095429435,
-0.1812095046,
-0.3163053691,
0.1095521376,
-0.5864199996,
-0.1428397,
-0.2381028831,
-0.3053441644,
-0.2941801846,
-0.2679972053,
-0.4347784817,
-0.3893923461,
-0.5314587951,
0.4809375107,
-0.4787293077,
-0.1145082414,
-0.0821904242,
-0.1400255263,
0.2317649871,
0.6582528949,
-1.1835395098,
0.4737349451,
0.2553046048,
1.2880796194,
-0.2520791292,
0.0451367609,
0.1573409736,
0.0144447498,
-0.7530055642,
0.2561686635,
-0.5096959472,
-0.7000803351,
0.0131036397,
-0.1197511554,
-0.0960122496,
-0.5872591138,
0.020909192,
-0.4882173538,
-0.0972791016,
-0.3166134357,
-0.3701973557,
0.1864091009,
0.0793328285,
-0.5764871836,
0.8621671796,
0.3478870392,
-0.6098101139,
0.3848794699,
0.0623951741,
-0.3985256255,
-0.0398913398,
0.0210704356,
0.1831813306,
0.1096906513,
-0.0616952218,
0.476539731,
0.075052835,
0.289875865,
-0.2402785718,
-0.6331630945,
0.0578292198,
-0.4990444183,
0.6880843639,
0.2957259417,
-0.2682132423,
-0.0229255203,
-0.6659775972,
-0.366678834,
0.2609249949,
-0.448056221,
-0.6308845282,
-0.5094200969,
0.198041603,
0.2757418454,
0.2441570014,
-0.2199104279,
0.363599062,
0.0795612186,
0.4066910148,
1.0287749767,
-0.3038490415,
0.6227301955,
-0.5517359972,
0.686552465,
-0.3322480917,
-0.0548700988,
-0.0308260638,
-0.2264223248,
-0.5544061065,
-0.2033468485,
0.1987728477,
0.464538306,
-0.7315446734,
0.0484468974,
-0.1151257232,
-0.6190786958,
-0.2786954641,
0.4868056774,
0.394562155,
0.4153681099,
0.4446989298,
-0.0662771985,
-0.2819567621,
-0.8759307861,
-0.3759703934,
-0.029736951,
-0.1163423955,
0.0753638446,
0.4855517149,
0.1642177552,
0.8971180916,
-0.3953811824,
-0.26910761,
-0.4819482267,
0.0634006858,
-0.0755662099,
0.4416772127,
0.6358429193,
-0.59199965,
-0.5538327694,
-0.3649051189,
-0.397773087,
-0.2142415494,
0.1780619472,
-0.0157795139,
0.2021392286,
0.9054974914,
-0.0834433883,
0.2601315677,
0.6224623322,
-0.2903026044,
0.7679921985,
-0.1192907169,
-0.1312521547,
-0.9641207457,
-0.4204812646,
0.3807309568,
-0.1803895086,
-0.7910978198,
0.006530833,
0.1405168921,
0.1721188128,
-0.4751401544,
0.8293159008,
-0.5732925534,
0.2442218512,
-0.0187303163,
-0.0862281099,
0.0691781864,
0.2644562125,
0.409013629,
0.7576650381,
0.1711991429,
-0.564873755,
-0.0421801135,
0.1267935038,
-0.4257234931,
0.5282005668,
-0.7108874917,
0.275649935,
-0.1599022001,
0.1526026875,
-1.2404732704,
-0.517542541,
0.0249953102,
-0.0229967106,
0.6538852453,
-0.3027291596,
-0.4124599397,
-0.105371803,
-0.0079882005,
0.1984434277,
0.5070394874,
-0.4900178909,
0.4932227731,
0.2225656211,
-0.5766484737,
-0.3652687967,
-0.7103269696,
0.0760248229,
-0.305863589,
-0.4519121945,
-0.1233440265,
-0.2941893935,
-0.9379816651,
-0.6677939296,
-0.2968946695,
-0.3295930028,
0.1141265184,
0.0760696679,
0.2787362337,
-0.079711467,
0.1333020926,
0.3836236596,
0.337394774,
-0.1508294195,
0.2366203815,
0.5778739452,
-0.2739876807,
-0.265954107,
-0.1783156842,
0.1363508403,
0.7195830345,
0.060851749,
0.5535595417,
0.3165020049,
-0.0716186389,
-0.2398218215,
-0.5670833588,
-0.1590379179,
-0.5383464694,
0.4151236415,
-0.6226194501,
-1.1137032509,
0.3187938035,
-0.1143857017,
-0.0305649769,
-0.0669246018,
0.4451598823,
-0.2163237929,
0.6676817536,
0.7778013945,
0.0269530546,
0.4990899265,
0.1097418442,
-0.0500929803,
-0.5077958107,
-0.3147119284,
-0.4631481469,
-0.3996490538,
-0.6681606174,
-0.5305600166,
0.6557964683,
0.1197578609,
-0.4820095301,
-0.0317472145,
-0.1224908531,
0.4669886231,
0.6140589118,
0.0688884109,
0.7218205929,
-0.129792586,
0.1009713039,
-0.1837066263,
-0.6733900309,
-0.7923878431,
1.1083554029,
0.6314606667,
1.1443711519,
0.5874521732,
0.6126015186,
0.2148858458,
0.2927245498,
-0.839075923,
0.4531923831,
-0.2809104621,
-0.7664552927,
-0.4410835803,
-0.0372562967,
-0.4651887417,
0.364364922,
-0.019514557,
-0.8009975553,
0.2067596763,
0.3728637099,
-0.0603129342,
0.2890376449,
-0.8752664924,
0.6173161864,
0.0697849467,
-0.2644194961,
0.4421225786,
-0.6908903718,
0.8208465576,
-0.1732378155,
0.6901293993,
-0.2347720861,
-0.1381873041,
0.388240546,
-0.2485315204,
1.3022835255,
0.3694235682,
-0.209659189,
0.1454682499,
0.7408610582,
0.5147303939,
-0.1818460971,
0.1878183335,
0.3526344895,
0.1311767995,
-0.61962533,
-0.2289403379,
0.4610773325,
-0.6360814571,
-0.737011075,
-0.4034315944,
-0.7170261741,
-0.4017654955,
0.1608477682,
0.4540102184,
0.490363121,
-0.4015144408,
0.0714907944,
0.6435846686,
0.0627183691,
0.6109076142,
0.6434099078,
-0.2240545452,
0.1995543092,
0.7073990107,
0.4984405041,
1.0204933882,
0.0124907885,
0.250759691,
-0.1648325026,
-0.5836079121,
-0.5337125063,
0.1361518204,
-0.8409273624,
0.321439743,
-0.4403946698,
-0.0389576294,
-0.7370509505,
-0.3968676925,
-0.2101081014,
-0.3707371354,
-0.2272668779,
-0.0978548825,
0.1746076196,
1.3843698502,
0.18096295,
0.3988791704,
-0.425132364,
0.0019860237,
0.2482773811,
0.1530320346,
-0.1433484107,
-1.0288382769,
-0.1025551111,
-0.5206294656,
0.0519166812,
-1.1333447695,
0.4779384732,
0.0124378223,
0.0580216199,
0.5136364698,
0.012716312,
0.3381103575,
-0.4890790284,
0.8097510338,
-0.2136565149,
-1.0716956854,
0.1940657794,
-0.4682277143,
0.5910419822,
0.3546187282,
0.7124936581,
-0.6163798571,
-0.8306613564,
-0.5311173201,
-0.7862955928,
0.5532910824,
-0.0861129463,
0.560466826,
-0.0804202855,
0.0610215627,
0.0410405844,
0.4156593382,
-0.7482599616,
-0.3643043339,
-0.2965079546,
0.0765475482,
-0.1333562285,
-0.5159763098,
-0.1351608336,
-0.3823495805,
0.426133275,
-0.2321360409,
-0.3886551559,
-0.0833536461,
-0.1798442006,
0.1118937358,
0.631659925,
0.7294891477,
0.7519002557,
-0.2330631912,
0.3533170521,
0.3133853376,
-0.682420373,
0.0989048555,
-0.2143981606,
-0.3017755747,
0.2102366686,
0.7308972478,
0.4521750212,
0.3407147527,
-0.4197569788,
0.2605582178,
0.0829483569,
-0.1287431717,
-0.2832904458,
0.0726890862,
0.142988652,
0.0501297638,
0.1358345598,
0.0921425149,
-0.1158903241,
-0.6096403003,
-0.3366811574,
0.5153357387,
-0.3611341119,
-0.1703550667,
0.5082910061,
0.2051963508,
0.1168552935,
0.2148740739,
-0.1645497382,
-0.2742002606,
0.7055597901,
0.767239213,
0.3337418437,
-0.2906639576,
0.2447787374,
0.2613666058,
0.7782962918,
-0.0726065934,
-0.0534027815,
-0.1168821976,
-1.0463089943,
0.0721268654,
-0.7888894081,
-0.5258133411,
0.2144319117,
-0.5995419621,
0.180732742,
-0.7400936484,
0.0898280442,
-0.0512139648,
-0.2179633826,
-0.742690444,
0.1679159999,
-0.0030704017,
1.3225275278,
-1.3789138794,
0.7726352215,
0.7098311186,
-0.4650166631,
-1.1895810366,
0.1530323476,
0.6663036346,
-0.6631042361,
0.9702653289,
-0.3834701777,
-0.2069476098,
0.0837238804,
-0.4403772056,
-1.0073684454,
0.9856092334,
0.0403020866,
-0.9130835533,
-0.4218629897,
-0.1728085577,
0.4269215465,
-0.1977646649,
0.3198522925,
1.0743625164,
0.6849146485,
0.4991026223,
-1.3369042873,
-0.2369019091,
-0.0208846461,
0.1273493171,
-0.2616484165,
-0.921705246,
0.9938174486,
-0.3067071736,
0.0402900726,
0.2231676131,
0.6513628364,
0.1055316925,
0.4332253039,
0.2940095067,
0.0640418231,
0.7942621112,
-0.2266144156,
1.0575408936,
-0.1555111259,
-0.0272762198,
1.2407993078,
-0.0223128665,
0.6664580107,
0.4028713107,
-0.2582345605,
0.2141142786,
0.7047391534,
0.347928673,
0.086497575,
0.0539125353,
-0.4660323858,
-0.186375618,
-0.1544147581,
-0.386254251,
0.5905057788,
0.1807107627,
-0.489806205,
-0.0810174793,
-0.0038263088,
0.6156646609,
0.3695431948,
-0.4710472226,
0.66118747,
0.2107787579,
-0.1988135874,
0.6685772538,
0.0562712178,
0.8845664859,
-0.6732293367,
0.1186500415,
-0.4965537488,
-0.0696455911,
-0.0431572907,
-0.6185456514,
0.109310478,
0.1464427263,
-0.2370653152,
-0.2793322802,
0.7267922759,
-0.6213789582,
-0.6172795892,
-0.0980849043,
0.7188562155,
0.1352173984,
0.0954061672,
-0.10829404,
0.2887323201,
-0.1572858691,
-0.1934324801,
0.5428357124,
0.440690726,
-0.591175139,
0.759673059,
0.2155916244,
0.2141525,
0.2562147677,
0.1270459145,
0.7702543139,
-0.4447911978,
-0.146307677,
-0.6509851813,
0.1162119061,
0.2372311503,
-0.6732150912,
0.9069782495,
0.3092966676,
1.0150558949,
-0.3826255202,
0.8199371099,
0.0825439021,
0.3873744309,
-0.6748640537,
0.6393450499,
-0.4711590409,
0.2517591119,
-0.4685928226,
-0.6582584381,
-0.1396808326,
0.3470008969,
-0.4380939305,
0.4584903717,
0.5397794843,
0.7570982575,
0.0574743897,
-0.0392544828,
0.7277660966,
0.5367114544,
0.1572968364,
0.1140198559,
0.8494745493,
0.3947600126,
0.2607687116,
-0.4676041007,
-0.3188616633,
-0.1475728154,
-0.8050462008,
-1.0422998667,
-0.624763608,
-0.0072697615,
-0.3975233436,
0.2470117509,
1.2302422523,
0.8366919756,
-0.5030789971,
-0.3485847414,
0.3045928478,
0.2313629389,
0.1039295197,
-0.2177575529,
0.0310355034,
-0.3308182657,
-1.2242007256,
0.53052634,
0.0907596424,
0.452488333,
-0.2772001028,
-0.0537494645,
-0.0604232773,
0.2924287319,
0.7499732971,
0.2152883857,
-0.8947975636,
-0.2283855379,
-0.0365087762,
-0.3508495986,
-0.2777261734,
0.7745344639,
-0.3071041703,
0.5479471684,
0.0830009654,
-0.0374867469,
0.2343271524,
0.3308683932,
0.3638394773,
-0.9601460695,
0.1621595919,
0.1903099865,
0.3402729034,
0.3802655935,
-0.2364739478,
0.2834008932,
0.3400159478,
-0.2969315648,
-0.5293083787,
0.3532338738,
-0.7931889296,
-0.5148296952,
1.3105208874,
0.07685671,
-0.0918860957,
-0.3404588997,
-0.3495764434,
-0.033094231,
-0.3614828587,
0.6519625187,
1.0268106461,
-0.0857124627,
-0.1360561401,
-0.8091451526,
0.683296442,
0.3002649844,
-0.3472200632,
-0.0147682549,
0.6847207546,
0.8077586889,
-0.1367851347,
0.8964912891,
-0.0441591814,
0.0462764092,
-0.0667975023,
0.0266570412,
-0.2747544944,
-0.6387699842,
-0.4431860149,
0.2656336427,
0.4535372257,
0.2015891373
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12673v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12673v1 | Estimating Knowledge in Large Language Models Without Generating a Single Token | 2024-06-18T14:45:50 | 2024-06-18T14:45:50 | Daniela Gottesman, Mor Geva | cs.CL | cs.CL | To evaluate knowledge in large language models (LLMs), current methods query
the model and then evaluate its generated responses. In this work, we ask
whether evaluation can be done $\textit{before}$ the model has generated any
text. Concretely, is it possible to estimate how knowledgeable a model is about
a certain entity, only from its internal computation? We study this question
with two tasks: given a subject entity, the goal is to predict (a) the ability
of the model to answer common questions about the entity, and (b) the
factuality of responses generated by the model about the entity. Experiments
with a variety of LLMs show that KEEN, a simple probe trained over internal
subject representations, succeeds at both tasks - strongly correlating with
both the QA accuracy of the model per-subject and FActScore, a recent
factuality metric in open-ended generation. Moreover, KEEN naturally aligns
with the model's hedging behavior and faithfully reflects changes in the
model's knowledge after fine-tuning. Lastly, we show a more interpretable yet
equally performant variant of KEEN, which highlights a small set of tokens that
correlates with the model's lack of knowledge. Being simple and lightweight,
KEEN can be leveraged to identify gaps and clusters of entity knowledge in
LLMs, and guide decisions such as augmenting queries with retrieval. | [
-0.3008795381,
-0.7028089166,
0.9629470706,
0.002974896,
-0.2411068678,
-0.0294322167,
-0.6074746847,
-0.5243496895,
0.3959582448,
0.4432681203,
-0.453805238,
-0.5309284329,
-0.4616382718,
-0.2636595666,
-0.4549657702,
0.8098554611,
0.3465469778,
0.0025819016,
-0.4697254896,
-0.0478063785,
-0.4263790846,
-0.4954646826,
-0.4455031455,
-0.206793949,
0.2997107804,
0.4002766311,
0.2158451825,
0.2178028077,
0.461042136,
0.2949074507,
-0.2706668973,
0.1707492322,
-0.6827664971,
0.2275450826,
-0.411164403,
-0.8201729059,
-0.2144775093,
-0.0578762181,
0.9044600129,
0.7935211062,
0.1021298692,
0.3776450157,
0.0995684043,
0.418843925,
-0.7842173576,
0.2221112847,
-1.1703625917,
-0.1644897312,
-0.3899376988,
-0.0662091225,
-0.5296955109,
-0.0869366452,
0.382610321,
-0.3821195364,
0.2099978924,
0.0247824285,
0.7674283981,
0.2124035209,
-0.4782229066,
-0.069604896,
-0.6082862616,
0.7914237976,
-0.7158977389,
0.5376304984,
0.4331029654,
0.1245750263,
-0.087511465,
-0.6433683634,
-0.4836860001,
-0.5216494799,
-0.0752320066,
0.068238236,
0.0474321991,
-0.0119531462,
0.3018603623,
0.5843501687,
-0.0093508223,
0.0368338972,
-0.129017964,
-0.2963053286,
0.5211020112,
0.1570866406,
0.0187993329,
-0.3235476613,
-0.5285578966,
0.2034462094,
-0.7371599078,
0.1413095891,
0.1518271416,
0.2037271857,
0.0941672921,
0.8185231686,
-0.0952859968,
0.4785090089,
0.2761493325,
-0.0657443926,
-0.0392379686,
-0.4337089062,
-0.2597309351,
-0.097055532,
0.7554954886,
0.1401604712,
0.0731889829,
-0.4142257273,
-0.5926898718,
0.103372179,
0.2900972962,
-0.619053483,
-0.1122426838,
0.1037262976,
-0.179330349,
0.0346971042,
0.1292690337,
-0.5588904619,
-0.5281222463,
-0.230546087,
0.3857190907,
-0.349192977,
-0.3423040211,
-0.0905203223,
-0.0493763126,
0.2261721343,
0.1151829138,
-0.5927867889,
0.3938946426,
0.9109954834,
0.709387958,
-0.1823316813,
-0.3383409679,
-0.7235693336,
0.0816698074,
-0.3952929378,
0.8367142677,
-0.3043462038,
-0.4010992348,
-0.1714136004,
-0.1558611095,
-0.0658939481,
-0.3852400184,
0.4402666092,
-0.8560487628,
0.0044670282,
-0.5142582655,
-0.9364320636,
-0.199926585,
0.4409402013,
-0.6335453391,
0.9797590971,
-0.1423746198,
-1.0328528881,
0.8059474826,
-0.5313156247,
-0.2740817964,
0.1084359139,
-0.1940018535,
-0.1561148465,
0.423858583,
0.2459462434,
0.6182658672,
-0.5298941135,
0.4395371377,
-0.4736988842,
-0.3395077288,
0.4900687635,
-0.2988891304,
0.5465137959,
-0.2252558321,
-0.4307919741,
0.2140608728,
-0.6038889289,
0.0214205775,
0.0399882793,
-0.3822996914,
-0.4980316162,
0.0336853079,
-0.3452992141,
-0.2702747583,
0.3957590461,
-0.5536085963,
0.1316299438,
-0.7388580441,
0.1104920581,
0.8048434258,
0.3422693014,
0.4484386742,
-0.0858560279,
0.3462872207,
0.0148794651,
-0.0018775669,
-0.1490944922,
-0.5307224393,
-0.9334015846,
-0.282150507,
0.4806984365,
0.271535784,
-0.53622967,
0.1647583991,
-0.3263926804,
-0.5857478976,
-0.4339525402,
0.1011572555,
0.4865420461,
0.4568543434,
0.0852760971,
-0.2999968827,
-0.4354470968,
-0.8372977972,
-0.5045538545,
-0.3796087205,
0.0871522576,
0.4516485631,
0.3118991554,
0.0174356494,
0.928565681,
-0.6266052723,
0.0750292093,
-0.0235582851,
0.2364534736,
0.3394746482,
0.3812392056,
0.4172667563,
-0.6290504932,
-0.2779783607,
0.0786504,
-0.7388735414,
0.2251179516,
0.0810822845,
-0.3478669226,
0.1376413554,
0.3556842804,
-0.9310949445,
0.2082291245,
0.1882918775,
-0.4005011022,
0.6114847064,
0.014405583,
0.1191377416,
-0.8633148074,
0.3225152194,
-0.0346140228,
-0.3150653541,
-0.4881340563,
0.3217088282,
0.2119970173,
0.0737569481,
-0.2773714066,
0.951626718,
-0.7160405517,
-0.2735099792,
-0.1091972589,
0.3389882743,
-0.0538905449,
0.4134441912,
-0.0062835068,
0.918268621,
0.6917252541,
-0.8165560365,
0.0486188307,
0.058940202,
-0.8917730451,
0.4374514818,
-0.5461397767,
0.3942965865,
-0.1950868964,
-0.408991158,
-0.7790524364,
-0.238602519,
0.0643006787,
-0.5247493386,
0.3327438831,
-0.4169786572,
-0.2526361644,
-0.4363763332,
-0.0931590423,
0.2231598198,
0.3167850375,
-0.380985707,
0.5936906934,
0.5491071343,
-0.1392163038,
-0.7217117548,
-0.5274859071,
-0.0313342847,
-0.1630171537,
-0.6141311526,
-0.0174832195,
-0.0211589038,
-0.49235484,
0.1865822822,
-0.1548217237,
-0.1916259676,
0.3228306472,
0.2207348645,
0.4213658273,
-0.505374372,
0.5031787753,
-0.1034274027,
0.0576129779,
0.2955838144,
-0.4969395399,
0.4310423136,
-0.1642374992,
-0.653962791,
-0.1300407499,
-0.020489553,
0.6526818275,
-0.4479789138,
0.667881906,
0.2760416567,
-0.4841960073,
-0.2095939666,
-0.8839349151,
-0.350266099,
-0.3870899379,
0.2648633718,
-0.5299352407,
-0.7035012841,
0.6819354296,
0.1616445631,
0.0306778233,
0.6690649986,
0.6179910898,
0.3144667149,
0.7882885933,
0.8464164734,
-0.0727095455,
0.321926564,
-0.2711783946,
0.0459446535,
-0.7311352491,
-0.424490422,
-0.4439077675,
-0.0529152937,
-0.3195422888,
-0.4563263953,
0.5440772772,
0.2106470764,
-0.0850898325,
0.0250161327,
-0.1374494135,
0.4526537061,
0.8078391552,
0.2314975411,
0.370567441,
-0.2430410534,
-0.2808133364,
0.1002225727,
-0.6209905744,
-0.4597794712,
1.2912933826,
0.2488598675,
0.5045357347,
-0.0312531479,
0.5931209326,
0.0767294094,
0.7356475592,
-1.1144516468,
0.4796773195,
0.1305397749,
-0.8709564209,
-0.3488772511,
-0.6090146899,
-0.5724787116,
0.2566539049,
-0.3143987954,
-0.8193645477,
0.1556473225,
0.2369330823,
-0.4435886741,
0.3292707801,
-0.8370138407,
0.7716760635,
-0.2806557119,
-0.4762367308,
-0.2561849356,
-0.3517904282,
0.6949771047,
-0.2343264818,
-0.0696656257,
-0.2216768712,
-0.0218103882,
0.9120953083,
-0.3927230835,
0.7900485992,
-0.3506692648,
-0.0864850879,
0.5404903889,
0.172087431,
0.5727051497,
0.3541406095,
-0.4111537933,
-0.0186814927,
0.0834134519,
-0.3466468751,
-0.7023925185,
0.655924201,
-0.5014151931,
-0.9570257664,
-0.0652848333,
-0.2965475023,
-0.543974936,
0.4687209129,
0.139417544,
0.4243124127,
-0.3921151161,
-0.0543927178,
0.5752083063,
0.055312302,
0.2020021379,
0.5847200751,
-0.3344430923,
-0.3144431412,
0.6365235448,
0.0144062396,
0.1290638298,
0.4111032486,
0.3270073831,
-0.5107170939,
-0.4842261672,
-0.514002502,
0.4349114001,
-0.7935343385,
-0.2669140995,
-0.6463357806,
0.1433837563,
-0.2423105389,
0.2062845677,
-0.4741325974,
-0.1056838632,
-0.2810492516,
-0.175660044,
0.3842215538,
0.9657674432,
0.1699118614,
0.0809369385,
-0.9603891969,
0.0245031323,
0.4804908335,
0.5168213248,
0.1966370195,
-0.4521921277,
-0.3501301706,
0.1792687923,
0.176635772,
-0.8575171828,
0.0563514568,
0.0738757178,
0.6729520559,
0.6290064454,
0.0413503982,
0.6800375581,
-0.3072702587,
0.8140943646,
0.0681403503,
-1.2169134617,
0.390083313,
-0.178079024,
0.0898483694,
0.7006067634,
0.3372637033,
-0.2411302179,
-0.3973246813,
-0.4875541627,
-0.6041730046,
0.5948676467,
-0.1390098482,
0.1665767729,
-0.1111682281,
0.4559836388,
0.0897077695,
0.5247668624,
-0.6245570779,
-0.0707303584,
0.1591338068,
0.0722657517,
-0.174735114,
-0.5715562701,
-0.070209384,
-0.089243494,
0.7168408632,
-0.2606642544,
0.321413368,
0.0701027587,
-0.302149117,
-0.1016294956,
0.1515189558,
0.1865757257,
0.9352881908,
-0.2471336424,
0.3558467627,
0.2201759368,
-0.2560895085,
-0.1276982874,
0.0363206677,
-0.2353891432,
-0.073091723,
0.4407607019,
0.8702682257,
0.4754240811,
-0.8672713041,
0.741732657,
0.1335309148,
0.0922605544,
-0.1155650616,
-0.1517188251,
0.0820001885,
0.4849724472,
0.2284513563,
-0.0688995719,
0.1330940574,
-0.6254962087,
0.2046877295,
0.6526145339,
-0.4713943601,
-0.4548709095,
0.5695809126,
0.0659352019,
0.0510955229,
0.6635936499,
-0.2427774072,
-0.7780653238,
0.4892251194,
0.4425823092,
0.9405647516,
0.074490957,
-0.0190619696,
0.1962897629,
0.289037168,
-0.0132198185,
0.3259429038,
-0.135426566,
-0.862398982,
-0.7145692706,
-0.6827004552,
-0.3045430481,
0.0562863685,
-0.6298117042,
0.2270485461,
-0.3370672166,
-0.4208008349,
0.0007407172,
0.0356185846,
-0.8599319458,
0.1487669349,
-0.0145801511,
0.9934427738,
-0.5700198412,
0.5268086791,
0.9327925444,
-0.3922404945,
-0.9598821998,
0.2762999833,
-0.3270062208,
-0.9078019261,
0.7025337815,
0.1410535723,
-0.1743872762,
-0.0294071808,
-0.5055802464,
-1.0601475239,
0.7543279529,
0.4175709486,
-0.5139701366,
0.0927978233,
-0.3784116805,
0.3842214048,
0.0561002679,
0.2826004326,
0.3785598576,
0.4804961085,
0.0040049935,
-0.8737207055,
0.1022054404,
-0.1949604303,
-0.3486551642,
0.4443034828,
-0.5378342867,
0.8988761306,
-0.3577634692,
-0.5818781257,
-0.0229192302,
0.7953327298,
0.0140458327,
0.2739086449,
0.6050978303,
0.4899353981,
1.2526968718,
0.0576914102,
1.143347621,
-0.6771128178,
0.439334929,
1.0708144903,
-0.2476472706,
0.8053882718,
0.4425043762,
-0.1450291127,
0.1509186774,
0.473071903,
0.2671742141,
0.299016118,
0.1811269671,
-0.3570170701,
-0.593776226,
-0.0687679425,
-0.1463990808,
0.5619524121,
0.3255835176,
-0.1254923046,
0.1333023012,
-0.2028467655,
-0.0920998231,
-0.0436565951,
-0.46604684,
0.9267368317,
0.170595929,
-0.9642274976,
0.4575794339,
0.1555161029,
0.6146552563,
-0.4558846056,
0.2441818714,
-0.2401233613,
0.1204715073,
0.089862518,
-0.8090130687,
0.1461969763,
0.0028957736,
-0.3622221947,
0.202605471,
0.9988456368,
-0.3445672095,
-0.5815247893,
0.1674308777,
0.8210058808,
0.2143475562,
-0.4009765685,
-0.2622705996,
-0.2377289534,
-0.1314646602,
-0.4044179916,
0.0052319067,
0.6519991755,
0.0010590001,
0.7663690448,
0.5473564863,
0.1407750249,
0.1012396887,
-0.1071460694,
0.9117014408,
-0.6455965638,
-0.4025742412,
-0.8730956912,
0.4239928126,
-0.0799253881,
-0.2751286924,
0.8689697385,
0.5064836144,
0.682978332,
-0.0474462733,
0.763386488,
0.1250415593,
0.6406977177,
-0.7575821877,
0.6051278114,
-0.5944426656,
0.2289304882,
-0.0754263103,
-0.9060674906,
-0.0532092936,
0.2718262672,
-0.6203635931,
-0.1005510092,
0.5338219404,
0.715461731,
-0.1408075392,
0.0366674215,
0.3676540554,
0.4333769679,
-0.1064281091,
0.1640955359,
1.0807163715,
-0.0243163928,
0.1059057266,
-0.230552569,
-0.1353071928,
-0.111226581,
-0.7154701948,
-0.972709775,
-0.4776782095,
0.0392789394,
-0.1921279579,
-0.0453564003,
0.8354004025,
0.7028696537,
-0.6531713605,
-0.2101023793,
0.0981931537,
0.4486625791,
-0.0002958401,
-0.2042592317,
0.4300659299,
-0.4304963052,
-0.6677721143,
0.5982206464,
0.1553319544,
-0.0950276405,
-0.5157769918,
0.2800575495,
-0.1720383018,
0.0484757535,
0.7115361691,
0.0235879775,
-0.6151512861,
-0.3883071244,
0.2228783667,
0.1122906357,
-0.1283111125,
0.9812754393,
-0.8203856349,
0.4525984228,
0.3360155821,
0.8696938157,
0.6640359759,
0.0253545195,
0.57489115,
-0.7619276643,
0.0792740285,
0.3302597404,
0.4463220835,
0.335149169,
-0.5865492225,
0.2488145977,
0.2739002109,
-0.3705678284,
-0.7929896116,
0.1382641792,
-0.7376605272,
-0.1209348813,
1.0720478296,
-0.3540527821,
-0.2963308692,
0.1384243071,
0.0534810014,
0.2012445331,
-0.3408116698,
0.5703591704,
0.6049498916,
0.1929717809,
0.1097514108,
-0.3907893002,
0.2749367654,
0.5110638738,
-0.6485136151,
0.0428585187,
0.5666465163,
0.3882991672,
0.1251428127,
0.7069197297,
0.097445257,
0.0329708308,
0.0762171298,
0.1015535071,
0.127830863,
-0.3442268074,
0.0265313871,
0.2322385609,
0.5955659747,
-0.0893711224
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12665v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12665v1 | CollabStory: Multi-LLM Collaborative Story Generation and Authorship Analysis | 2024-06-18T14:35:12 | 2024-06-18T14:35:12 | Saranya Venkatraman, Nafis Irtiza Tripto, Dongwon Lee | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The rise of unifying frameworks that enable seamless interoperability of
Large Language Models (LLMs) has made LLM-LLM collaboration for open-ended
tasks a possibility. Despite this, there have not been efforts to explore such
collaborative writing. We take the next step beyond human-LLM collaboration to
explore this multi-LLM scenario by generating the first exclusively
LLM-generated collaborative stories dataset called CollabStory. We focus on
single-author ($N=1$) to multi-author (up to $N=5$) scenarios, where multiple
LLMs co-author stories. We generate over 32k stories using open-source
instruction-tuned LLMs. Further, we take inspiration from the PAN tasks that
have set the standard for human-human multi-author writing tasks and analysis.
We extend their authorship-related tasks for multi-LLM settings and present
baselines for LLM-LLM collaboration. We find that current baselines are not
able to handle this emerging scenario. Thus, CollabStory is a resource that
could help propel an understanding as well as the development of techniques to
discern the use of multiple LLMs. This is crucial to study in the context of
writing tasks since LLM-LLM collaboration could potentially overwhelm ongoing
challenges related to plagiarism detection, credit assignment, maintaining
academic integrity in educational settings, and addressing copyright
infringement concerns. We make our dataset and code available at
\texttt{\url{https://github.com/saranya-venkatraman/multi_llm_story_writing}}. | [
-0.3304794431,
-0.4980128407,
0.6385335922,
0.3241833746,
0.2288163304,
0.5364436507,
-0.333232224,
-0.4289774001,
0.2564256191,
0.6998516917,
-0.8347249031,
-0.7590734363,
-0.4125192165,
0.4224248827,
-0.2371547371,
1.0979633331,
-0.2724430859,
0.0061435406,
-0.9127027988,
-0.2143526375,
-0.5225244761,
-0.5870953798,
-0.1640225202,
-0.0228988007,
0.7051253915,
0.6464311481,
0.224457711,
0.2155174613,
0.6856167912,
0.3187898397,
0.3534604013,
0.283846885,
-0.7996743917,
0.340172559,
0.3754177094,
-0.2063115984,
-0.5888838768,
0.3318037093,
0.5439573526,
0.768666327,
0.0130783105,
0.2817388177,
0.2597334385,
0.5128524303,
-0.7552242875,
-0.0292462818,
-0.2022736073,
0.106900081,
-0.2848791778,
-0.1196263731,
-0.501599133,
-0.3171337247,
0.00401511,
-0.7570130825,
0.5800901651,
0.4012473822,
0.1130967885,
0.0910909846,
-0.0593722723,
-0.5822545886,
-0.3795423806,
0.8028392792,
-0.3493141234,
0.1095374301,
-0.0072045573,
0.0011368322,
-0.3886459172,
-0.9554188848,
-0.5776058435,
-0.1595917344,
-0.2531396449,
0.278275907,
0.0155138904,
-0.2037529051,
0.0489913449,
0.3562268615,
-0.4620848,
0.1735035032,
-0.3971024156,
-0.2740778923,
0.5796592832,
0.373120904,
0.4158580601,
0.1050944403,
-0.7797256708,
0.171511963,
-0.678951323,
-0.0287921503,
0.5851897597,
0.3123918474,
-0.1804047972,
0.7186082006,
0.1509500444,
0.3082275689,
-0.2967177331,
-0.0489045009,
0.173371464,
-0.9096891284,
0.1242819801,
0.3329091966,
1.0634032488,
0.3882265687,
-0.0390113033,
-0.3650788665,
0.1191907525,
-0.2144872248,
0.1513131112,
-0.6504546404,
-0.2936297059,
0.1483789086,
-0.1176812202,
-0.4763112366,
0.1080984846,
-0.7791409492,
-0.8858535886,
-0.4278256297,
0.0486310944,
-0.1323038638,
-0.1567932963,
-0.053252615,
0.0395728759,
-0.1618010551,
0.1934393197,
-0.6373433471,
0.6558431983,
0.711761415,
0.9666343927,
-0.6106576324,
-1.1012673378,
-0.5879833102,
0.2842597961,
-0.0323430449,
0.4536770582,
-0.1194716096,
-0.2730485499,
-0.1087746024,
-0.3384109139,
-0.1307863891,
-0.1752113402,
0.2472596318,
-0.2017781287,
0.4607931674,
-0.4972275496,
-0.6513934135,
0.3061870337,
0.1413689852,
-0.7386302948,
0.6607326269,
-0.074587293,
-0.8103493452,
0.3779774904,
-0.7372516394,
-0.1131962985,
0.185666576,
-0.2390047759,
-0.5551553965,
-0.078875728,
0.2775338292,
0.523788631,
-0.4800524712,
0.5451163054,
-0.3400628269,
-0.4480631351,
0.3818351626,
-0.0734268352,
1.0471827984,
0.0573460981,
0.2865618169,
0.0241439044,
-0.5929957628,
-0.2413099259,
0.1306471229,
-0.3522420228,
0.0080565671,
-0.281683594,
0.037563175,
-0.2043035328,
0.5608861446,
-0.7673689127,
0.2001700997,
0.2849183679,
0.09658923,
0.4958730638,
-0.0878589153,
0.5453122258,
-0.5089436173,
0.7169547677,
-0.3727123439,
0.0240875352,
-0.3051004708,
-0.466755867,
-0.3070034087,
-0.6441568136,
0.0568679906,
0.4902321398,
-0.3173477948,
0.1437847465,
-0.1154564545,
-0.3075457215,
-0.5883603096,
0.3770393431,
0.5384029746,
0.5021683574,
0.2681136131,
-0.2490690053,
-0.7714536786,
-0.5711404085,
-0.3568938971,
0.2360156178,
0.0719005838,
0.1372149885,
0.5092285872,
0.1215060577,
1.1578010321,
-0.6222448945,
-0.6209936142,
-0.3707142174,
0.359220922,
0.0877223685,
0.260445863,
0.5346747637,
-0.632651031,
-0.6476393938,
-0.3131268919,
-1.0351479053,
-0.482494086,
-0.0698569641,
-0.0914574638,
0.1830632836,
0.8367331028,
-0.4733591974,
0.0782252029,
0.7157353163,
-0.3122296035,
0.8058038354,
-0.1511342674,
0.2817577422,
-1.3587161303,
0.0659334958,
-0.1237642765,
0.0270489808,
-0.6302309036,
0.1663199961,
-0.1737984419,
-0.2160997689,
-0.3158377111,
0.3022857308,
-0.7362717986,
-0.3040593565,
-0.0022336449,
0.3324730098,
-0.0038979677,
0.4826077223,
-0.1930012405,
0.8882277608,
0.3334993124,
0.0609726608,
0.450776577,
0.4732277989,
-0.4667354226,
0.5279006362,
-0.3581608832,
0.2386368811,
0.0587869994,
0.3692066967,
-0.9234470129,
-0.2358266264,
0.204475075,
-0.3703857362,
-0.0039535528,
0.0638019517,
-0.9829134345,
-0.2065238357,
-0.5329042077,
0.1668951511,
-0.1202152446,
-0.6333586574,
0.3643462658,
0.2566781342,
-0.4724529088,
-0.6254906058,
-0.6426582932,
0.3699499369,
-0.2963296771,
-0.6666440368,
0.235837549,
-0.4549098611,
-0.3878914118,
-0.0473527014,
0.2949865758,
-0.1275125593,
-0.0510423034,
0.4327223599,
0.4547351599,
0.0891031623,
-0.0751273707,
0.1337689608,
-0.2196409702,
0.1047498658,
0.0934327319,
0.344683677,
-0.1879400909,
-0.2033935487,
-0.0894802138,
0.4396555722,
0.4160480201,
-0.0807403699,
0.7631573081,
0.7244374156,
-0.0302952565,
-0.0139498822,
-0.4828080237,
-0.1154536828,
-0.4520122707,
0.11479491,
-0.1778175831,
-1.1569459438,
0.5964876413,
-0.0842297301,
0.1994641423,
-0.0565357916,
0.6473557949,
-0.152447775,
0.2413732857,
0.5980095863,
-0.0036073483,
0.0623989552,
-0.1038434133,
0.2705174387,
-0.8883108497,
-0.3176976144,
-0.2425824255,
-0.4931673408,
-0.3959443569,
-0.1911722124,
0.5938333273,
0.0841731355,
0.0336038359,
0.406894207,
-0.4508287907,
0.8271736503,
0.6539267898,
-0.1021587178,
0.7439295053,
-0.1219597831,
-0.1123766601,
-0.2582986653,
-0.5872733593,
-0.357619822,
1.2243406773,
-0.0719694346,
0.3753617406,
0.1048064455,
1.1735548973,
0.2636058331,
0.262047559,
-0.3369736373,
0.6290412545,
-0.127983138,
-0.5653969646,
-0.3345596194,
-0.2854270339,
-0.7840880752,
0.2873945534,
-0.3467407227,
-0.7764488459,
-0.1326145828,
-0.2328960299,
-0.2415938228,
0.23391442,
-0.7909182906,
0.7731506228,
-0.1545313597,
-0.6716279984,
0.0855279043,
-0.7449046969,
0.6533589959,
-0.5082652569,
0.3328394592,
-0.0219250564,
0.0294218846,
0.7134586573,
-0.3858193457,
1.0004967451,
0.0615636148,
-0.0551297143,
0.3570851088,
0.186166808,
0.2178225815,
0.2379326224,
-0.0605428815,
0.2513411641,
-0.1763375998,
-0.2171287388,
-0.1544491947,
1.1174800396,
-0.7266175151,
-0.2259695828,
-0.3569048941,
-1.3060371876,
-0.2180211246,
0.2435635477,
0.458216399,
0.3078548312,
-0.1737485379,
0.1727905273,
0.2320137918,
-0.0191080384,
0.6251176596,
0.3940055668,
-0.2237267494,
-0.5755586028,
0.8560646772,
-0.0412271582,
0.0300539266,
0.2848801017,
0.1656741351,
-0.0719404817,
-0.6209270358,
-0.1939524114,
0.1312807649,
-0.4334272444,
-0.1219055578,
-0.5309179425,
-0.0000055877,
-0.3499473929,
-0.6461142898,
-0.2298790365,
-0.2215481251,
-0.4564020336,
0.0240701865,
0.3510706127,
0.7702588439,
-0.197524339,
0.2532969415,
-0.7965484858,
0.3162423074,
0.1132515892,
0.1916876584,
-0.1163969412,
0.0036424624,
-0.2507274449,
-0.2160205692,
-0.3561733067,
-0.5210505128,
0.3058520555,
-0.1032592952,
0.2808261514,
-0.1108935103,
0.1618441939,
0.5253803134,
-0.3547830284,
0.685336411,
0.546092391,
-0.7858460546,
0.1033898443,
-0.4554814696,
0.1563521922,
0.7679738402,
0.3385745585,
-0.3230406046,
-0.6156381369,
-0.2335506529,
-0.921462357,
0.9077016115,
0.490500778,
-0.0295626204,
0.413035512,
0.2466006875,
0.7466843128,
0.4550606012,
-0.8724524975,
-0.1772513837,
0.2834345102,
-0.2265613824,
-0.3040587902,
-0.162804395,
-0.3103034198,
-0.1331618428,
0.3610467315,
-0.1194445193,
0.0256787743,
-0.0895167217,
-0.1443325877,
-0.1272858083,
0.1017021537,
0.3429572582,
0.7330403328,
-0.2741113305,
-0.0245705396,
0.1096390188,
-0.5358420014,
-0.1813762784,
0.3727780581,
0.1601188183,
-0.4196112454,
0.6975367665,
0.5822240114,
0.321662724,
-0.5934358835,
0.7166687846,
-0.136207372,
-0.613650918,
-0.4419907331,
0.0037260791,
0.3287427127,
0.4578242898,
0.1773510426,
-0.1242070571,
0.0211708453,
-0.4162992239,
0.0916888267,
0.1855762601,
-0.0902867913,
-0.2376653105,
0.608556211,
0.1101808324,
-0.197183609,
0.683324337,
-0.2661260962,
-0.1022308916,
0.6016597152,
0.4988457561,
0.7986558676,
0.1358887702,
0.3075473309,
0.1128680259,
0.2184814513,
0.1304453462,
0.0727666914,
-0.0835857242,
-0.8117265105,
-0.3479093611,
-0.4828881919,
-0.7651750445,
0.0279738735,
-0.5315563083,
0.4112463593,
-0.1418142468,
0.4435614645,
0.0809730515,
0.3105941117,
-0.3507906199,
-0.3280189633,
0.1002086774,
0.2742571235,
-0.7370457649,
0.354973942,
0.661757946,
-0.293020457,
-0.2363827527,
-0.2754536867,
0.3196013868,
-0.6804370284,
0.2685029507,
0.2299255729,
-0.0949565619,
0.110786736,
-0.8181676865,
-0.4988739789,
1.6330989599,
0.4603492916,
-0.7840554714,
0.0484254546,
0.5300556421,
0.6667051315,
-0.5875833035,
-0.1957207918,
0.2918311357,
0.3651126921,
0.1061496586,
-0.6183848381,
0.0645766705,
-0.0155480644,
-0.4726909697,
0.1127441078,
-0.6081324816,
0.9755542278,
-0.6731677055,
0.1264302582,
0.3576462269,
0.2769448161,
0.8277706504,
0.8853759766,
0.1871629357,
0.6454299092,
0.7897956371,
0.0873423219,
0.915117979,
-0.2110896111,
0.3521693051,
1.5751684904,
-0.5651224256,
0.3385066986,
0.5715799332,
-0.2158789784,
0.2572337091,
0.1992948651,
-0.2939273715,
0.2976935804,
0.2861742377,
-0.3706263006,
-0.1563029736,
-0.1640102714,
-0.1144267097,
0.3276409209,
0.0756399855,
-0.188231051,
-0.2176438868,
0.0976551771,
0.1879679561,
0.2533415556,
0.156782344,
0.6040843129,
0.1932148635,
-0.3801781833,
-0.1081420481,
-0.4132741988,
0.4842056036,
-0.332993418,
0.1052926853,
-0.1014928371,
0.0184755232,
-0.2129535973,
-0.9768019915,
-0.0723714232,
0.1190646291,
-0.184035778,
-0.5588223934,
0.604059577,
-0.6279289722,
-0.4006591737,
0.3490082622,
1.0054494143,
0.1234728768,
0.1084980369,
-0.3219866753,
0.2606745064,
-0.2162574381,
-0.1445505917,
0.5036910176,
0.40113011,
0.1948275119,
0.4601282179,
0.7318783998,
-0.1025562584,
0.0197462272,
0.1171878576,
0.7101566792,
-0.3187432587,
-0.2442490309,
-0.7071432471,
0.4005579054,
-0.0638609454,
-0.3600157797,
0.8694168329,
0.9370909929,
0.7240892053,
-0.0387496091,
0.8635225296,
-0.0950762928,
0.4544930458,
-0.3606675565,
0.8759452701,
-0.4230912626,
0.3686380386,
-0.4137763083,
-0.9546203017,
-0.4276301563,
-0.1381382495,
-0.0669543743,
-0.1998452842,
0.9438084364,
0.5691379309,
0.0121130664,
0.4432078898,
0.1628314853,
0.0468950458,
0.2285133451,
0.5383110642,
0.8836487532,
-0.2077627033,
0.7285866141,
-0.5243065953,
-0.1482055187,
0.0616114773,
-0.9668967724,
-1.0460619926,
-0.7321332097,
-0.3437601328,
-0.0435881503,
-0.0379130691,
0.602538228,
0.1304664463,
-0.6002218127,
-0.4711232483,
-0.4759252965,
0.1068350673,
-0.010369326,
-0.2316572666,
0.1693965942,
-0.3120068908,
-0.8064280152,
0.4862472415,
0.0943730995,
-0.2242775112,
-0.3789473474,
-0.2075623572,
-0.0712951198,
-0.2210161239,
0.5418779254,
-0.0532374643,
-0.2514786124,
0.1836898625,
0.104678452,
-0.070704855,
-0.0684267581,
1.071534276,
-0.6046079993,
0.5634111166,
0.311201334,
0.3998746574,
0.4253898859,
-0.2101479918,
0.4041880071,
-1.0334489346,
-0.2528288364,
0.0966967121,
0.3840234876,
0.4057876766,
-0.3758462369,
0.6031783223,
0.3457278609,
-0.7946275473,
-0.8463721275,
-0.0595191196,
-1.049136281,
-0.2508938909,
0.9335368276,
-0.2599515617,
0.1974570304,
-0.0733414739,
-0.2398601025,
0.2274585068,
-0.4773540795,
0.8352147341,
0.9355713129,
-0.3708955944,
-0.2186321467,
-0.437215358,
0.1253106892,
0.0150290728,
-1.0294748545,
0.3684453368,
0.709993422,
0.0870766416,
0.284698993,
0.7566301227,
0.0380948558,
0.1418649554,
0.0762587562,
0.1722203791,
-0.6565694213,
-0.5435289145,
0.0130150942,
0.5637534857,
-0.2847361863,
-0.1825655252
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12651v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12651v1 | Transforming Surgical Interventions with Embodied Intelligence for Ultrasound Robotics | 2024-06-18T14:22:16 | 2024-06-18T14:22:16 | Huan Xu, Jinlin Wu, Guanglin Cao, Zhen Chen, Zhen Lei, Hongbin Liu | cs.RO | cs.RO, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC | Ultrasonography has revolutionized non-invasive diagnostic methodologies,
significantly enhancing patient outcomes across various medical domains.
Despite its advancements, integrating ultrasound technology with robotic
systems for automated scans presents challenges, including limited command
understanding and dynamic execution capabilities. To address these challenges,
this paper introduces a novel Ultrasound Embodied Intelligence system that
synergistically combines ultrasound robots with large language models (LLMs)
and domain-specific knowledge augmentation, enhancing ultrasound robots'
intelligence and operational efficiency. Our approach employs a dual strategy:
firstly, integrating LLMs with ultrasound robots to interpret doctors' verbal
instructions into precise motion planning through a comprehensive understanding
of ultrasound domain knowledge, including APIs and operational manuals;
secondly, incorporating a dynamic execution mechanism, allowing for real-time
adjustments to scanning plans based on patient movements or procedural errors.
We demonstrate the effectiveness of our system through extensive experiments,
including ablation studies and comparisons across various models, showcasing
significant improvements in executing medical procedures from verbal commands.
Our findings suggest that the proposed system improves the efficiency and
quality of ultrasound scans and paves the way for further advancements in
autonomous medical scanning technologies, with the potential to transform
non-invasive diagnostics and streamline medical workflows. | [
-0.1078730673,
-0.4787780046,
0.9410204887,
-0.3733218014,
-0.6522044539,
0.354747951,
0.0682993904,
-0.7020223141,
0.6464197636,
0.5220728517,
-0.6981810331,
-0.4877955914,
-0.8547620177,
0.046425391,
-0.4182707071,
0.6574649215,
-0.0129833613,
0.1937786341,
0.0244231708,
-0.4540395141,
-0.3017098308,
-0.1607193798,
-0.0578838438,
-0.2984099686,
0.4130767882,
-0.0721341968,
1.1272667646,
0.8307447433,
0.5491405725,
0.3464198709,
0.325932622,
0.8903009295,
0.0531145632,
0.0300272256,
-0.2193786651,
-0.2441380918,
-0.5540413857,
-0.2615813613,
0.3765438795,
0.9317349195,
-0.2783142626,
-0.1694023162,
-0.1663916558,
0.4547811449,
-0.4727885425,
0.0868071541,
-0.0618141033,
0.0911921412,
0.4895693958,
-0.6802758574,
0.0469481163,
-0.2745441496,
-0.0431210548,
-0.8021268845,
-0.2919998467,
-0.3309307098,
0.4000373185,
0.8932512999,
-0.498334825,
-0.3914754987,
-1.0880280733,
0.4251718521,
-0.5224333405,
0.77838099,
-0.2582149208,
0.2415408045,
-0.0225239173,
-0.7657173276,
-0.3455221355,
-0.103321895,
-0.1538034827,
0.372965306,
-0.1802947372,
0.3469473422,
0.1876532435,
0.0063983882,
-0.3468527496,
0.0945223644,
-0.2205751985,
0.1144569889,
0.5808961391,
0.4167267978,
0.5037019849,
0.2688368857,
-0.3630705476,
-0.2629928291,
-0.2593604624,
-0.1342445612,
-0.0264172982,
0.2683749497,
-0.183720991,
0.7655930519,
-0.1078331098,
0.6031289697,
0.0917638242,
-0.434869498,
0.2390018553,
-0.0650989488,
-0.1847938001,
0.2715976536,
0.6506255269,
0.1559402198,
-0.2933935523,
-0.0842111632,
-0.4409638047,
-0.0040376834,
0.7035992742,
-0.5610257983,
0.1404810846,
0.2713184059,
-0.6222908497,
-0.0545224324,
-0.0956581905,
-0.2500056922,
-0.7695661783,
-0.5194444656,
0.3998736739,
-0.3893000782,
-0.3005955517,
0.7001501918,
-0.0415651836,
0.2205521017,
0.5952161551,
-0.7911568284,
0.2299845666,
0.8432733417,
0.6003273726,
0.4067648649,
0.0773009211,
-0.3467583954,
0.5200957656,
-0.6525269151,
0.7269284129,
-0.5785099864,
-0.7027998567,
0.0546678714,
-0.0749570951,
-0.1849687397,
-0.6592963934,
0.352221489,
-0.3063535988,
-0.2278423905,
0.1296718419,
-0.4557931423,
-0.5441426039,
-0.029994918,
-0.6577410698,
0.5537030101,
0.2967624366,
-0.0235846303,
0.1222993881,
-0.7637887597,
-0.7514144778,
0.398090601,
-0.562730372,
-0.2534655333,
0.1721129119,
0.3752017617,
0.6742655635,
-0.4051725864,
0.2797679305,
-0.0571510419,
-0.6175851822,
0.1769096851,
-0.0575976409,
0.5084763169,
-0.2631782889,
-0.4818195403,
0.2279928178,
-0.3341776431,
-0.4467638135,
0.1951407939,
0.0789768845,
-0.0121557517,
-0.065668948,
-0.5979688168,
-0.0877644271,
0.4599202871,
-0.3498223126,
0.5662038326,
-0.7065570951,
0.0144444834,
0.3278636932,
-0.033035405,
0.5018066764,
-0.6875064969,
0.5948566794,
-0.4264743626,
0.3107772171,
0.1407210976,
-0.5414487123,
-0.6663173437,
-0.5614339113,
-0.3838849366,
0.7051295638,
-0.9405030608,
0.4100810587,
-0.2481746823,
-0.6990006566,
-0.7732725143,
-0.0578615479,
0.2843162119,
0.7963218689,
0.4006861746,
-0.1283465773,
-0.4644700587,
-0.6435967088,
0.0208241194,
-0.3991259336,
-0.1957738101,
0.738661468,
0.0847132802,
-0.3145443499,
0.1311874986,
-0.345700562,
-0.4219071269,
-0.2919885516,
0.3241155744,
0.8555648327,
0.4132856131,
0.3856410086,
-0.6080091,
0.256903857,
0.3595659435,
-1.1660358906,
0.0074174041,
-0.4773221016,
-0.0641739219,
0.2478156388,
0.5083901882,
-0.8497734666,
0.6426818967,
0.3168836534,
0.0558742695,
0.4005244374,
-0.4764450192,
0.4635724127,
-0.8285879493,
-0.0274362192,
-0.1748909205,
0.1493223011,
-0.4036749303,
0.2494385689,
-0.0095981238,
-0.0053209118,
-0.2964539826,
0.4798214734,
-0.4621096551,
-0.2320213169,
-0.3235485554,
-0.1708678305,
0.0723597556,
0.3550685048,
0.2311694175,
0.5916714668,
0.4258375764,
-0.5408527255,
0.6364874244,
0.3490631878,
-0.0589489378,
0.3989850283,
-0.5982429385,
0.389860034,
0.2763931453,
0.2470896095,
-0.5970062017,
-0.065062657,
0.2490085065,
-0.6660873294,
0.492193222,
-0.33021608,
-0.5538172722,
-0.4612902999,
-0.1972068995,
0.1436777264,
0.8779586554,
-0.5126553178,
1.520270586,
0.3306905627,
-0.1637359858,
-0.6788320541,
-0.3870327175,
0.1920336187,
0.0430727303,
-0.4013338685,
0.1715149134,
0.1137862876,
-0.1795521975,
0.0184600987,
-0.2207505107,
0.0548612513,
0.1775325835,
0.0626259297,
0.6492049694,
-0.1812135577,
0.1227122173,
0.726184845,
-0.1455069929,
0.1284719408,
-0.6467875242,
0.523209393,
0.3255836368,
-0.6676485538,
-0.9773846865,
0.2456472814,
0.8452340961,
-0.1998993754,
0.4808419049,
0.6470017433,
-0.32775563,
-0.1317480952,
-0.5890924335,
-0.7361280918,
-0.4918395281,
0.350897789,
-0.1852905899,
-0.6549779177,
0.3975923955,
-0.3805881441,
0.0908959135,
0.0032019559,
0.7326838374,
-0.6156187057,
1.3521912098,
0.4649972916,
0.1577465832,
0.1778677553,
-0.4704629481,
0.3594545424,
-0.9117279649,
-0.5506743789,
-0.3480778039,
-0.4610687494,
-0.471514225,
-0.7386274338,
0.8998336196,
-0.3774392605,
-0.2009452134,
0.0132819572,
-0.7612759471,
0.0196813624,
0.4120844901,
0.3793358207,
0.0294539314,
-0.2581169605,
-0.1017755121,
0.3586519957,
-0.7034098506,
-0.6187224388,
0.9563217759,
-0.0257416293,
0.8425419927,
-0.0402143151,
0.7095137835,
0.2370159924,
-0.1256056577,
-0.8952440619,
0.7354527116,
-0.4418162107,
-0.0571301356,
-0.2476326227,
0.0627297163,
-0.9823996425,
0.0296543762,
-0.390753597,
-0.3401860893,
0.1276182234,
0.1120695323,
-0.6683872342,
0.5680786371,
-0.2522356808,
0.062086951,
-0.4219376445,
-0.4965313971,
-0.5557305813,
-0.6787419319,
-0.1009068191,
0.0732157528,
0.2533903122,
-0.209992528,
-0.7049522996,
0.4699940979,
-0.3693849742,
0.8465601206,
-0.3842364252,
-0.3286000788,
-0.0545964167,
0.3475875556,
0.4047767818,
0.0339539647,
-0.1311522871,
0.3606468737,
-0.4890978336,
-0.0652294084,
-1.0217479467,
0.3767836094,
-0.5663651824,
-0.5647449493,
0.0240395758,
-0.8946306109,
-0.2954545617,
-0.0515856892,
-0.4277980328,
0.6044842601,
0.0853247792,
-0.1688331217,
0.5190113783,
-0.3297791183,
0.1888570189,
0.5459758639,
0.3344660997,
-0.168758139,
0.6923197508,
-0.0335210785,
-0.1880376786,
0.5778434873,
0.1943883896,
-0.5249899626,
-0.8158841133,
-0.8737471104,
0.5707877874,
-0.5522757769,
-0.2439801842,
-0.87220788,
-0.0094717676,
-0.591905117,
-0.7759222984,
-0.449183017,
-0.1806688309,
-0.4574086368,
0.0695410669,
0.2953545749,
0.8805290461,
-0.1518716812,
0.0106581096,
-1.1089949608,
0.6026489139,
0.3576940298,
0.0420575738,
-0.0996107385,
-0.5372187495,
-0.1349477172,
0.0053971508,
0.1825143546,
-0.6223954558,
0.4369195998,
-0.1266403049,
0.5498354435,
0.4358773828,
0.000476135,
0.7541543245,
-0.3086168766,
0.4436445534,
0.0885390416,
-0.6940553784,
0.3965097368,
-0.5009100437,
0.2589138448,
0.2747139037,
0.3712875247,
-0.1675685793,
-0.5730068684,
-0.41094473,
-0.7453010082,
0.499617517,
-0.3221938312,
0.1387997121,
0.3248929083,
0.5380074382,
0.1265735477,
0.3987661302,
0.1395059675,
0.0706495866,
0.1288613677,
-0.371617198,
0.2553190291,
0.1907645762,
-0.3834500909,
-0.5028247237,
0.7602872252,
-0.5469151139,
0.4361701012,
0.0149940755,
0.0847249329,
-0.0570356362,
-0.2825793624,
0.563446641,
0.3382007778,
0.0775545239,
-0.2230394781,
0.1687415987,
-0.4370523393,
-0.1116982549,
0.2015118152,
0.3055947423,
-0.2170003206,
0.6811035275,
0.542883575,
0.1716262698,
-0.8103992939,
0.3316740096,
-0.0333854631,
-0.1888513565,
-0.0944467485,
0.2044837475,
0.2716563046,
0.6635642648,
0.3838709891,
0.0282637868,
0.4617516696,
-0.2697480321,
0.1558785588,
0.4545452595,
-0.3033111691,
-0.2249478251,
0.537832737,
0.2734706402,
-0.1282275915,
0.6389658451,
0.0514299087,
-0.3443455398,
0.8242039084,
0.2029183656,
0.7397222519,
-0.5092484951,
0.0463840924,
0.1513076723,
0.5600140691,
0.4087977111,
0.6557956934,
-0.3711147606,
-0.8173425198,
-0.5286719203,
-0.2630100548,
-0.5839904547,
-0.2984874547,
-0.5547170639,
0.2576009035,
-0.6149150729,
0.2306437343,
0.047541935,
-0.2622997165,
-0.290081799,
0.3803980947,
0.4542300999,
0.4387459457,
-0.3738088012,
0.6462949514,
1.0383448601,
-0.143920809,
-0.9545086622,
-0.0715658665,
0.1771758348,
-1.4819332361,
0.2947978377,
-0.0044652908,
-0.9088587165,
-0.2355413735,
-0.4409120977,
-0.6365687847,
0.97955966,
0.4085774124,
-0.4393794537,
0.0840570778,
0.1860270202,
0.6505934596,
-0.2475830764,
0.3580477238,
0.524826169,
0.4821311533,
0.2570236623,
-1.161985755,
0.0664782152,
-0.2302062362,
-0.4578873515,
0.4398221374,
-0.3453147709,
0.2638475299,
-0.6314557791,
-0.0973381326,
0.2438571155,
0.4991135001,
0.202730462,
0.3345808983,
0.5563663244,
0.6034712195,
0.6839550138,
-0.0564069934,
1.0932773352,
-0.7394393682,
-0.2448942512,
0.5319386125,
-0.5633894205,
0.2324244231,
0.2641620636,
0.1369343251,
0.6152201295,
0.1425175369,
0.1518560201,
0.1956893653,
-0.2837718129,
-0.5235526562,
-0.452354759,
-0.5897548199,
-0.2616849542,
0.9892219901,
0.7057949901,
-0.1062665433,
0.1675793082,
0.3690623939,
0.0489535704,
0.094624266,
-0.3639423251,
1.2528891563,
-0.0385106914,
-0.4885550737,
0.6975235343,
-0.3199447393,
0.5435605049,
-0.7035370469,
-0.4634033442,
0.0102044689,
0.0732484832,
-0.1997007877,
-0.8168628216,
0.3852052391,
-0.3942177892,
0.3151460588,
-0.3237497509,
0.6963864565,
0.044090122,
-0.3708080351,
0.5032164454,
0.5975388288,
0.0297649615,
0.1471787095,
-0.7096469998,
0.1826613992,
0.0089348527,
0.140136987,
0.1376019418,
0.2213335484,
0.1890083402,
0.7995010614,
0.6584256291,
0.0459735766,
-0.5141233802,
0.1294645071,
1.0791555643,
-0.480181098,
-0.2486005872,
-0.4434520006,
0.4107063711,
0.1456435174,
0.0794576705,
0.253869772,
0.4553245306,
0.4717895985,
0.1426341683,
0.5693578124,
0.247788474,
0.5986174941,
-0.5281839967,
0.8371702433,
-0.9380335212,
0.1920764297,
-0.1355329752,
-0.2732003629,
-0.4320827723,
0.6250625849,
-0.1086950898,
0.2510184944,
0.4565452933,
0.7972761393,
0.0130256601,
0.0826721117,
0.4868428409,
0.1703776568,
0.1055625975,
0.2938373685,
0.7826826572,
0.1100236326,
0.0719715133,
-0.4767750204,
-0.399638474,
-0.3239662349,
-0.4819193184,
-0.4762181044,
-0.507486403,
-0.2702050209,
-0.048487626,
0.3588182628,
0.8394867778,
1.0654968023,
-0.1321367025,
-0.3608453274,
0.4414692521,
-0.0090630455,
-0.4086993039,
-0.0511799231,
0.3895399868,
0.0904493034,
-0.9101640582,
1.1467225552,
0.7900499701,
-0.060494896,
-0.0135375978,
0.0143984454,
0.0678333119,
0.2951208949,
0.3761930764,
0.1870101094,
-0.4982497096,
-0.1529984474,
0.1823378801,
-0.0221786182,
0.0468742736,
0.8054282665,
-1.1134287119,
0.6068590879,
0.1705800742,
0.7798030972,
0.1202103868,
-0.1666207463,
0.316316247,
-0.2018251568,
0.3691236079,
0.8695876002,
0.4588999152,
0.1362525374,
-0.8084965944,
0.5300028324,
0.2126892507,
-0.2949928045,
-0.5544921756,
0.0530402176,
-1.1474481821,
-0.3876792192,
0.7477319837,
0.1032593846,
-0.3114079535,
-0.2927233577,
-0.097693488,
0.5976042151,
-0.2977797687,
0.7096710205,
-0.2477654815,
-0.809884131,
-0.0624848306,
-0.2348442227,
0.0453538597,
0.5390834212,
-0.8061879277,
-0.4081024826,
0.3889113069,
-0.1695139706,
0.2083870322,
0.4518738985,
-0.3513128459,
0.7559211254,
-0.1433247775,
0.426694721,
-0.3659550548,
-0.3127857745,
-0.315387249,
-0.0170727745,
-0.3114123046,
-0.2477513552
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12645v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12645v1 | Evaluating Transparency of Machine Generated Fact Checking Explanations | 2024-06-18T14:13:13 | 2024-06-18T14:13:13 | Rui Xing, Timothy Baldwin, Jey Han Lau | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | An important factor when it comes to generating fact-checking explanations is
the selection of evidence: intuitively, high-quality explanations can only be
generated given the right evidence. In this work, we investigate the impact of
human-curated vs. machine-selected evidence for explanation generation using
large language models. To assess the quality of explanations, we focus on
transparency (whether an explanation cites sources properly) and utility
(whether an explanation is helpful in clarifying a claim). Surprisingly, we
found that large language models generate similar or higher quality
explanations using machine-selected evidence, suggesting carefully curated
evidence (by humans) may not be necessary. That said, even with the best model,
the generated explanations are not always faithful to the sources, suggesting
further room for improvement in explanation generation for fact-checking. | [
-0.4812930226,
-0.7873802781,
1.0863676071,
-0.059598878,
-0.3522495329,
-0.3275077641,
-0.079092972,
-0.5399173498,
-0.2131010592,
0.6080685258,
-0.570438385,
-0.2390680611,
-0.8475297093,
0.2637118399,
-0.4904571474,
1.1086735725,
-0.128468588,
0.0034823609,
-0.197156623,
0.1552807838,
-0.3881098032,
-0.3455784619,
-0.3722148836,
-0.7795283198,
0.5521732569,
0.4761389494,
1.030144453,
0.9800491929,
0.2722670734,
0.3819877207,
-0.0797052532,
0.4211693406,
-0.5273191929,
0.0304396674,
-0.5055776834,
-0.2686002553,
-0.1252362281,
0.4275529087,
0.626301527,
0.7021186948,
0.1194560379,
0.2568087578,
0.0277557448,
0.6765138507,
-0.746914506,
0.0126928864,
-0.5978280902,
-0.0441191383,
0.0506714508,
-0.2679969072,
-0.5334666967,
-0.5673020482,
0.4865137339,
-0.4675914049,
0.5332926512,
0.2869301438,
1.1897337437,
0.043687012,
-0.3104509413,
-0.5921033025,
-0.9600470662,
0.7857091427,
-0.3945869207,
0.3881779313,
0.4344718754,
0.4078672528,
-0.1489497125,
-0.7513607144,
-0.5842763782,
-0.2112788111,
-0.3450439572,
0.1373628378,
-0.1657292843,
-0.0030162982,
0.4927965999,
0.3712387681,
-0.5303319693,
0.0462313592,
-0.4192946553,
-0.7989690304,
0.8610085845,
-0.0329001024,
0.0146388616,
-0.3230864406,
-0.1639581174,
-0.2363402545,
-0.8014696836,
-0.094744496,
0.6194651723,
-0.2877865136,
0.0952996463,
0.6674441695,
-0.3104300797,
0.763915658,
0.0279240143,
-0.1844218522,
-0.2087735236,
-0.7035233378,
-0.3935436308,
0.4105202854,
0.8986080885,
0.4169560075,
0.0141572701,
-0.1318426728,
-0.2822955847,
0.1013739631,
0.0970364809,
-1.0171533823,
-0.1005566046,
0.4897789657,
-0.8771305084,
-0.3371077478,
0.5957229137,
-0.650521636,
-0.4723379612,
-0.3447687626,
0.4864747226,
-0.136038065,
-0.2792676091,
0.2725603878,
-0.5267625451,
-0.2116232812,
0.5478414297,
-0.7032014132,
-0.2286364287,
0.8222486973,
0.5409386158,
-0.0148791289,
-0.051770892,
-0.8494533896,
-0.0506068878,
-0.4552922249,
0.8854632378,
-0.3345379233,
-0.2877448499,
0.0182748139,
0.1253255606,
0.45116359,
-0.4705533981,
0.8084433675,
-0.481528312,
0.7993788719,
-0.5880812407,
-0.5829684734,
-0.5837904215,
-0.0479107574,
-0.835093379,
0.5209465623,
-0.1437768489,
-0.8771694303,
0.8828244805,
-0.9820644259,
-0.4265561402,
-0.0203864239,
-0.0758562163,
-0.6084395051,
-0.03870029,
0.3300049901,
0.3821238875,
-0.0932077244,
0.6617922187,
-0.0582311302,
-0.3248984218,
0.7742623687,
-0.5718500614,
1.2272849083,
0.485750109,
-0.5752813816,
0.171988979,
-0.5744920969,
-0.2293025255,
0.1250295937,
-0.4581397772,
-0.0479118042,
0.0705957338,
-0.3110355139,
-0.0277005546,
0.2633021474,
-0.6073787212,
-0.2690536678,
-0.1762281507,
0.3655213714,
0.7605527639,
0.1540432572,
0.3003125191,
-0.3642975688,
0.3612291217,
0.0805813298,
0.3528419137,
-0.5084784627,
-0.727778554,
-0.3666295409,
-0.1346292645,
0.6434334517,
0.1158217862,
-0.5069139004,
0.3096765578,
-0.0910590515,
-0.1674278229,
-0.7612155676,
-0.0119787436,
0.4662060738,
0.5257769227,
0.0330379978,
-0.1986590177,
-0.6085287929,
-1.0540091991,
-0.6330532432,
-0.3226447701,
-0.2872668207,
0.3113265634,
0.5928840041,
-0.1543967426,
1.1570150852,
-0.3167960942,
0.5519307256,
-0.0931926444,
0.4282909334,
0.0760231465,
0.1916669458,
0.3439987302,
-0.8373348713,
-0.1097269356,
-0.1057806835,
-0.8027070761,
-0.1609416604,
-0.3191770613,
-0.3300751746,
0.2735360265,
0.2198289633,
-0.8103091717,
0.4385176003,
0.5599675775,
-0.5152664185,
0.7582722306,
-0.2065839767,
0.3055759668,
-0.696960032,
0.2184462994,
-0.1616262048,
-0.4848020375,
-0.4638285637,
-0.0702618957,
0.0667907894,
-0.0292755701,
-0.3136500716,
0.2809685469,
-0.5055266023,
-0.1870592386,
-0.3791000545,
0.3450927436,
0.4094423354,
0.0706525743,
-0.1470669806,
0.5958384275,
0.4676584303,
-0.7170741558,
0.1006464586,
-0.0016570775,
-0.6112783551,
0.1822722852,
-0.6373098493,
0.0503408089,
-0.2377000153,
0.2390590459,
-0.8865976334,
-0.709436357,
0.2663943768,
-0.657730937,
0.1011441424,
-0.2372042835,
-0.6079576015,
-0.3615123928,
-0.3561478555,
-0.1357342005,
0.4935644865,
-0.8880258203,
0.4838919938,
0.1116270795,
0.152056247,
-0.5699107647,
-0.6188166142,
0.0479453504,
-0.242928043,
-0.825812161,
0.2311581224,
-0.1234801859,
-0.714651823,
-0.0052372171,
-0.4569987357,
0.1560392082,
0.4533326924,
0.3255591094,
0.1939906478,
-0.309034586,
0.1378756315,
0.1158131287,
-0.123566106,
0.4879235923,
-0.0447141044,
0.2326279134,
0.001022753,
-0.4637921751,
-0.7238897085,
0.404109925,
0.6551141739,
-0.1725833267,
1.0577315092,
0.6019643545,
-0.1573041677,
0.1045311689,
-0.7971999049,
-0.6484727263,
-0.4706436992,
0.1266384572,
-0.1772638708,
-0.9237082601,
0.4350914359,
0.0200476944,
0.3590485454,
0.7894898057,
0.6924238801,
-0.0269811079,
1.5974217653,
0.3511378765,
0.2708762586,
0.4229463339,
0.1137907878,
0.200306803,
-0.3807700574,
-0.2625696957,
-0.9301331043,
0.2542436123,
-0.9397529364,
-0.1044351235,
0.2040156275,
0.0702748001,
-0.1444306821,
-0.1302343309,
-0.5992991328,
0.6035934091,
0.6582053304,
0.1520699859,
0.6308729649,
0.2740408182,
0.2853233814,
0.3126781881,
-0.7996969223,
-0.7058771253,
1.0352265835,
0.5346364975,
0.5364888906,
0.0742737055,
0.5666102171,
0.3676991165,
0.4164111018,
-0.5229813457,
0.2685948014,
0.1497066617,
-0.8196608424,
-0.4941815734,
-0.48898682,
-1.2086616755,
0.3926238716,
-0.5148081779,
-0.4948395789,
-0.0570949875,
0.245159328,
-0.2294870317,
-0.1515663564,
-0.9684809446,
0.6076467633,
-0.1473019272,
-0.2792556882,
-0.4227995872,
-0.3753914535,
0.6512597799,
-0.0878060907,
0.2717479765,
0.208066687,
0.2850987911,
0.8606280684,
-0.5144967437,
0.4896016717,
-0.1467869431,
-0.216630742,
0.4372057021,
0.3196260333,
0.5677744746,
0.2338977605,
-0.4133681059,
0.4320932627,
-0.4491975009,
-0.4452243745,
-0.686149776,
0.2965540886,
-0.6821138859,
-1.1333440542,
-0.1030856818,
-0.473433733,
0.3015200794,
0.169552356,
0.4548577666,
0.330943048,
-0.0246995259,
0.328066051,
0.9033278227,
-0.286850363,
0.229355365,
0.7224829793,
-0.2402079105,
-0.0683168992,
0.6562187076,
0.0967536867,
0.1336040199,
0.0953056812,
0.7611482143,
-0.4783523679,
-0.803011775,
-0.8328126669,
0.2349737585,
-0.7605339289,
0.1011116728,
-0.5579451919,
-0.037170656,
-0.064361304,
0.1290115118,
-0.1131317988,
-0.5106056333,
-0.2037169486,
-0.2058350146,
0.3071110249,
0.9563294053,
-0.1263450533,
0.0132657913,
-0.6753347516,
0.5253096819,
0.4791477919,
0.3656908572,
-0.1727308929,
-0.5567630529,
-0.3668531775,
0.2929919064,
-0.3746840656,
-1.0693541765,
-0.1691070944,
-0.1267993301,
0.5781905651,
0.8221444488,
-0.0375389904,
0.4768695831,
-0.2142183334,
1.0610302687,
0.1460835934,
-0.9117128253,
0.8073676825,
-0.1686955541,
0.2580142915,
0.1858406067,
0.3402649462,
-0.0735925362,
-0.6606163979,
-0.8546264172,
-0.3494983912,
0.8379290104,
0.4070765674,
-0.1085173637,
0.1294833422,
0.4003000557,
0.6156945229,
0.0723786205,
-0.5865281224,
-0.1099753156,
-0.4045488238,
0.1760966927,
0.1951602399,
-0.4540380239,
-0.5717833042,
0.1339459717,
0.5773392916,
-0.0686384514,
0.2901180387,
0.4379723966,
-0.1765258461,
-0.6163975596,
0.3395045698,
0.958042264,
1.1208751202,
0.0339339674,
0.2450446934,
-0.2305243462,
-0.4243403077,
-0.3167864978,
0.021784557,
-0.4471192956,
0.3533901274,
0.667950213,
0.9539629817,
-0.4018469453,
-0.6465651393,
0.3854185343,
-0.0014720061,
-0.4880235493,
0.115066953,
0.376334697,
0.1089102775,
0.1034037471,
0.2386212945,
0.0463661477,
0.3383897841,
-0.7461845279,
-0.0734579414,
0.623401463,
0.0457459092,
-0.2286970764,
0.5797818899,
0.0167798195,
-0.3780640662,
0.7655405998,
-0.0831710771,
-0.6305285692,
0.5736894608,
0.2058907151,
0.8039339185,
-0.1382907033,
0.3430236876,
0.4611570537,
0.4507324994,
-0.2767160237,
0.0546778813,
-0.1411688775,
-0.6482928395,
-0.9381572604,
-0.2675429285,
-0.6271964908,
0.3447503746,
-0.5188446641,
-0.1102151126,
-0.1325742751,
-0.1827390641,
0.4040788412,
-0.0638705045,
-0.6594299078,
0.1836595386,
0.0058264034,
0.7643978596,
-0.8696386218,
0.4200976491,
0.4474619031,
-0.4278220832,
-0.8287228346,
0.2443770021,
-0.0339138322,
-0.7035768032,
0.5697515607,
0.2367729545,
-0.2727724612,
-0.6618553996,
-0.9987351894,
-0.6682946682,
0.9487712383,
0.6539936662,
-0.576816678,
0.6043868065,
0.0291548893,
0.6419946551,
-0.2447224408,
0.2735613585,
0.5665615797,
0.8431184292,
-0.0962162092,
-0.8806737065,
0.3139872849,
0.1230586171,
-0.1426824629,
-0.0299886931,
-0.306255281,
0.7170346975,
-0.3000070155,
-0.4261176586,
-0.2331442535,
0.6604848504,
0.3212392032,
0.5988734961,
0.6977222562,
0.2008434832,
1.0473086834,
-0.1597613692,
1.4036031961,
-0.2228206992,
0.2340632826,
0.7120179534,
0.0298518445,
0.3113082051,
0.5080504417,
0.0137448339,
0.9197068214,
0.9114667177,
-0.1432081461,
0.2786438763,
0.030626988,
-0.0677580535,
-0.4856440127,
-0.3816436827,
-0.1480344534,
0.3819472194,
0.1646401882,
-0.8107872009,
-0.0650954247,
-0.2796415985,
0.0893268883,
-0.0877931342,
-0.34670344,
0.8336495757,
-0.313883543,
-1.363048315,
0.7711436749,
0.0534756817,
0.1880563498,
-0.1518717259,
-0.2542495728,
-0.1240850613,
-0.2391700894,
-0.5661991239,
-1.1634728909,
0.1345990449,
0.3461296558,
-0.3871991336,
-0.3574211001,
0.8625167012,
-0.2398664206,
0.0220694467,
-0.1202708036,
0.6061706543,
0.5129719973,
-0.2681054175,
-0.5858919621,
0.137390092,
0.1892507523,
-0.6177803874,
0.1808331013,
0.5938532948,
-0.3418918252,
0.6264920831,
0.9472494125,
-0.2334616631,
-0.2324005663,
0.2011368573,
0.6684312224,
-0.3002911806,
-0.555314064,
-1.2046847343,
0.6763435006,
-0.3011835515,
0.2100277692,
0.7345896363,
0.625756681,
0.5722078085,
-0.1087827608,
0.852427721,
0.1369386613,
0.451466918,
-0.7769660354,
0.7786030173,
-0.4625324309,
0.2845046222,
0.0464921147,
-0.9004637003,
0.1162026599,
0.4691386521,
-0.1026326865,
0.1737286299,
0.9743949771,
0.8266112804,
-0.1153300628,
0.4073789716,
0.1778989732,
0.6218978763,
0.0773905963,
-0.1329304725,
0.862549603,
-0.1091787294,
0.6361956,
-0.0360990055,
-0.2716641426,
-0.4630515873,
-1.3369566202,
-0.9467726946,
-0.420276612,
-0.435744524,
-0.6518902183,
-0.0328587666,
0.4615384936,
0.9581164718,
-0.820094049,
0.1376230717,
-0.1760721058,
0.7760079503,
-0.2418948114,
-0.2481923848,
0.5185666084,
0.1252351403,
-0.5757482648,
0.3132588863,
0.1880528033,
-0.0786763281,
-0.5568336844,
-0.1585951447,
0.3480653167,
0.2254863381,
0.7908404469,
-0.0895306692,
-0.9904344082,
-0.6474789977,
-0.0943546072,
-0.0383718833,
0.0893541947,
1.0783826113,
-0.7189522386,
0.7129349709,
0.8192013502,
0.4493885636,
0.6115680933,
0.0908263326,
0.7203270197,
-0.3663879633,
-0.2535328865,
-0.1149898097,
0.3984591067,
0.4330272079,
-0.5356750488,
0.4145600498,
-0.0050919326,
-0.6593309641,
-0.9306102395,
0.3783328533,
-0.8528921604,
-0.4501623809,
1.2526750565,
-0.1537624002,
-0.2603904307,
-0.5074701309,
-0.2830967009,
0.3666348755,
-0.4917355478,
1.2910653353,
1.0707422495,
-0.2020485699,
-0.1876600683,
-0.6716148853,
0.5396139622,
0.3066862822,
-0.7717074752,
0.2880972028,
0.5514199138,
0.3441020548,
0.3021866977,
0.1610781848,
-0.1843514889,
0.807980895,
-0.0003241095,
-0.0772113875,
-0.2281420976,
-0.1382054687,
-0.3099299967,
0.1295325011,
0.1457492113,
-0.1235115901
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12644v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12644v2 | Hierarchical Prompting Taxonomy: A Universal Evaluation Framework for Large Language Models | 2024-06-18T14:12:27 | 2024-06-27T14:32:07 | Devichand Budagam, Sankalp KJ, Ashutosh Kumar, Vinija Jain, Aman Chadha | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Assessing the effectiveness of large language models (LLMs) in addressing
diverse tasks is essential for comprehending their strengths and weaknesses.
Conventional evaluation techniques typically apply a single prompting strategy
uniformly across datasets, not considering the varying degrees of task
complexity. We introduce the Hierarchical Prompting Taxonomy (HPT), a taxonomy
that employs a Hierarchical Prompt Framework (HPF) composed of five unique
prompting strategies, arranged from the simplest to the most complex, to assess
LLMs more precisely and to offer a clearer perspective. This taxonomy assigns a
score, called the Hierarchical Prompting Score (HP-Score), to datasets as well
as LLMs based on the rules of the taxonomy, providing a nuanced understanding
of their ability to solve diverse tasks and offering a universal measure of
task complexity. Additionally, we introduce the Adaptive Hierarchical Prompt
framework, which automates the selection of appropriate prompting strategies
for each task. This study compares manual and adaptive hierarchical prompt
frameworks using four instruction-tuned LLMs, namely Llama 3 8B, Phi 3 3.8B,
Mistral 7B, and Gemma 7B, across four datasets: BoolQ, CommonSenseQA (CSQA),
IWSLT-2017 en-fr (IWSLT), and SamSum. Experiments demonstrate the effectiveness
of HPT, providing a reliable way to compare different tasks and LLM
capabilities. This paper leads to the development of a universal evaluation
metric that can be used to evaluate both the complexity of the datasets and the
capabilities of LLMs. The implementation of both manual HPF and adaptive HPF is
publicly available. | [
-0.2260364741,
-0.8855093122,
0.4832004011,
0.7687290311,
0.0621118248,
0.1327883154,
-0.2555411756,
-0.0170267131,
-0.3098595142,
-0.0646296218,
-0.6601335406,
-0.5338338614,
-0.3864841461,
0.3723380268,
-0.1052685529,
0.8398020267,
0.0977054909,
-0.0249240492,
-0.3247223794,
-0.0207054336,
-0.6519038677,
-0.2776011825,
-0.5157666206,
-0.4812051058,
0.6291623712,
0.4042522311,
0.7178701758,
0.6497312784,
0.4609072506,
0.3379141092,
-0.3296560347,
0.1148786992,
-0.3330274224,
0.2305622548,
-0.3155074716,
-0.0270353854,
-0.5022597313,
-0.4524190128,
0.8491201997,
0.8030182719,
-0.1104367822,
0.3984838724,
0.4322525859,
0.4951578081,
-0.7007184029,
0.2566272914,
-0.5374369025,
0.0619482733,
-0.0858279169,
-0.528111279,
-0.355569303,
-0.167645067,
0.2001651973,
-0.5079152584,
-0.275395453,
0.1016085148,
0.3740620613,
0.1630196124,
-0.5051890016,
-0.3036566973,
-0.4360843003,
0.7828766704,
-0.414554894,
0.1535782069,
0.0870353132,
0.2262256444,
-0.2417657524,
-0.5082716942,
-0.2353634834,
-0.4457274377,
0.147750929,
0.1783597022,
-0.5135626793,
0.236408338,
0.3463368118,
0.4118489027,
-0.7798685431,
0.5219053626,
0.0607587211,
-0.2338089645,
0.1833166033,
0.5209634304,
0.3893424571,
-0.5046550632,
-0.3289529681,
-0.0499821045,
-0.5843635798,
0.1891627163,
0.1820599437,
0.5406293869,
-0.2180442959,
0.1364908367,
-0.2174498439,
0.6945582628,
0.1923822761,
-0.4687223434,
0.06122417,
-0.1309698969,
-0.4898117781,
-0.336904943,
0.9151656032,
0.1267427206,
0.1839234084,
-0.0815027654,
-0.2981643379,
-0.2239174098,
0.1471688747,
-0.5481805205,
0.1019190028,
0.1650038511,
-0.4924717247,
-0.2568200529,
-0.1646649539,
-0.9479950666,
-0.4807888567,
-0.1885803938,
0.6373561025,
-0.2377184927,
-0.102355063,
-0.0110685639,
0.1739567965,
0.3353016078,
0.327704072,
-1.1274739504,
0.4284259379,
0.7875225544,
0.7627711296,
-0.4970720112,
-0.5584803224,
-0.6454517841,
-0.1739666909,
-0.2857153118,
0.7246153951,
-0.4913105071,
-0.476688683,
0.1845316887,
-0.098846212,
-0.3372407556,
-0.6787737012,
0.7394309044,
-0.3037320673,
0.1934839934,
-0.4737156034,
-0.4145507216,
-0.1055255011,
0.4979745746,
-0.5347881317,
1.2263979912,
0.2880034745,
-0.7469890714,
0.283640027,
-0.6948185563,
-0.2558064461,
0.3767867982,
-0.0625525489,
-0.0345228128,
-0.0399360023,
0.4588490725,
0.4493305385,
-0.6980373263,
0.4546472132,
-0.1102835461,
-0.3721044958,
-0.1753698289,
-0.5860530138,
0.9179593325,
0.002248629,
-0.4310617745,
0.5642095208,
-0.5844632983,
0.0784772784,
-0.0404512361,
-0.5632166862,
-0.0410902239,
-0.1535423696,
0.0124831526,
-0.0142332762,
0.1723793298,
-0.1308923066,
0.2270868868,
-0.1418236196,
0.2306235284,
0.918032825,
0.0509033948,
0.233327359,
-0.6198613048,
0.9206369519,
-0.2759226263,
0.2533064783,
-0.4897297025,
-0.4599383771,
-0.4326970577,
-0.404944092,
0.2028120309,
0.7377491593,
-0.4358611405,
0.6563090086,
-0.2793258727,
-0.4394361675,
-0.3669751287,
0.1750808507,
0.4743427336,
0.6497275829,
0.2166490108,
-0.097311832,
-0.4773997068,
-0.6236338615,
-0.1745555699,
-0.4743356109,
-0.1638439149,
0.2738758922,
0.5464645624,
-0.2463942766,
0.5943604708,
0.2068638057,
-0.0051440177,
-0.1901151836,
0.1974377036,
0.311828196,
0.2627997398,
0.4218732119,
-0.4960765243,
-0.3628500998,
0.0167731438,
-0.5993905067,
-0.4052675366,
-0.1951589286,
0.1515195072,
0.1128060147,
0.2533921599,
-0.5221650004,
0.0451106802,
0.6674747467,
-0.2410483509,
0.9380323291,
-0.1787605584,
0.4503952861,
-0.7253658175,
0.1531365961,
-0.0668037906,
-0.0267750714,
-0.5243424773,
0.2850724757,
0.1206852943,
0.0975783467,
-0.4409161806,
0.697874248,
-0.4203113616,
-0.2177959234,
0.0809609964,
-0.0139696114,
-0.196274966,
0.4837364256,
-0.3379410505,
0.7082346678,
0.8399843574,
-0.5676898956,
0.6330908537,
0.0688425601,
-0.5271565318,
0.6908193231,
-0.7488008738,
0.0284225624,
-0.0227941684,
0.0894566923,
-1.2788159847,
-0.3268795609,
0.0937010273,
-0.265460968,
0.0454529338,
0.0750769153,
-0.6823239923,
-0.5492511392,
-0.323025167,
0.190587908,
0.619422853,
-0.7189601064,
0.4641962945,
-0.0857836977,
-0.3574174345,
-0.6718007326,
-0.3150432408,
0.1011346504,
-0.311145246,
-0.5251882672,
0.3806346953,
-0.3329332769,
-0.2449565381,
-0.2879936099,
-0.2801280916,
0.0740206093,
0.2760503292,
0.2738718092,
0.2772525251,
-0.3345995247,
0.1758626848,
0.0685919672,
-0.0095127281,
0.1249379367,
-0.2772931457,
0.4989978373,
-0.2762877047,
-0.5625309348,
-0.5412804484,
0.1775655001,
0.6756899953,
0.03324119,
0.3001183867,
0.4984043539,
-0.3614679277,
-0.123158209,
-0.3390505612,
0.0563237481,
-0.4720451832,
0.306596458,
-0.4512110651,
-1.1211707592,
0.5525753498,
-0.1536124349,
0.2567643821,
0.4306138456,
0.9861451983,
0.1401801407,
1.1448742151,
0.435238421,
-0.218285352,
0.154299289,
0.1900024414,
-0.0959316343,
-0.6819382906,
-0.2911131382,
-0.7179177999,
-0.121372439,
-0.4940023422,
-0.2730941772,
0.436694473,
0.1793792248,
-0.5367481709,
-0.1169548482,
-0.3714675903,
0.5338597298,
0.3127636909,
-0.1998910606,
0.3891913891,
0.0967362896,
-0.4475655556,
0.0826400742,
-0.7862838507,
-0.5684498549,
0.7640932202,
0.4752118587,
0.6627917886,
-0.0070286412,
0.4247554541,
0.3692788184,
0.3292887509,
-1.1649017334,
0.5145636797,
-0.032831654,
-0.3192353547,
-0.4270430207,
-0.5642337799,
-1.0719778538,
0.3847816586,
-0.1378758997,
-0.9205031395,
0.0058183661,
0.1222459674,
-0.5430339575,
0.1927249432,
-0.3635428548,
0.9336699247,
-0.3155120313,
-0.0398116745,
0.1159437075,
-0.4149125218,
0.2692928016,
-0.0849348679,
0.321411401,
-0.1106462255,
-0.2402167469,
0.6973822117,
-0.0400088653,
0.8410134315,
-0.0629010499,
-0.2726458907,
0.0365175307,
0.2443220764,
0.1933039278,
-0.1926089674,
-0.3213747442,
-0.1807753146,
0.1263462603,
-0.2961353362,
-0.6822746992,
0.6001600623,
-0.6437610388,
-0.6998240948,
-0.2375140786,
-0.8402685523,
-0.5320744514,
0.2772071064,
0.3078252077,
0.5483225584,
-0.3512046337,
0.2727608383,
0.5275406241,
-0.3029330671,
0.3526855707,
0.3732558489,
-0.2409426719,
-0.3234809935,
0.5859223008,
-0.1121630147,
0.2902794182,
0.5504517555,
0.5599827766,
-0.336942941,
-0.5194278359,
-0.4691667855,
-0.1423866749,
-0.7462081909,
-0.3789571822,
-0.4386668205,
-0.0189335681,
-0.5019667149,
-0.1345538348,
0.2596789896,
-0.1414263099,
-0.1720631123,
-0.0165142156,
0.2964846194,
0.8092563748,
-0.1448022574,
0.4264904857,
-0.7392988205,
0.317879945,
0.6246672869,
0.2415409535,
0.2981731594,
-0.7257788777,
0.2640431225,
-0.1740244031,
-0.2953776717,
-0.8398305178,
0.1955004781,
0.2633082271,
0.8262948394,
0.1878177971,
-0.1281021535,
0.7407828569,
-0.409024775,
0.7984520793,
0.2512570918,
-1.2318922281,
0.3886918724,
-0.6399029493,
0.7901275754,
0.4004345536,
0.6717846394,
-0.6838858724,
-0.1247472689,
-0.3354769647,
-0.7509174347,
0.5740457177,
-0.17689915,
0.1530165076,
0.0191408806,
0.2182063609,
0.1392599195,
0.0476692244,
-0.5691910386,
-0.1276227385,
0.1834393442,
-0.3341875374,
0.2839389443,
-0.2409068793,
-0.032863982,
-0.238297388,
0.3570885658,
-0.2948045135,
0.0856620818,
-0.0711570084,
-0.1054332405,
-0.2688809037,
0.6588037014,
0.046984423,
0.9121879339,
-0.0818689317,
0.0073678065,
0.357023716,
-0.2864867151,
0.2203660011,
-0.0628167465,
-0.2028829157,
-0.2114704996,
0.7921361923,
0.8166874647,
0.4207000136,
-0.6513782144,
0.4439359009,
0.0709501579,
-0.3448015153,
0.3820203841,
0.117853485,
0.0462059416,
0.0556985289,
0.4686374068,
-0.2631510198,
0.2113016695,
-0.6301333904,
0.1613259614,
0.1547691375,
-0.4324186444,
-0.1105223373,
0.1862811595,
0.0933507681,
-0.348682344,
0.4546528459,
-0.2695098519,
-0.4101555347,
0.6643611193,
0.7503246665,
0.7920698524,
-0.641001761,
0.4013738036,
0.36490044,
0.3807324767,
-0.0980907008,
0.3691519797,
-0.2733167112,
-0.4914283752,
-0.5606912971,
-0.7660552263,
-0.60151577,
0.2543162704,
-0.7758842111,
-0.1045862213,
-0.6325429678,
0.0172039047,
0.0357706435,
0.0151557224,
-0.4850346148,
0.1635326892,
0.0389776602,
1.1446640491,
-0.642813921,
0.41463992,
0.8051938415,
-0.0211530663,
-0.8653116226,
0.1455912143,
0.4435989559,
-0.9075068831,
0.609341681,
0.1268619299,
-0.1611508727,
-0.0810271278,
-0.4146842957,
-0.6387022734,
0.9483046532,
0.4561681747,
-0.5403004885,
-0.131390363,
0.0176768452,
0.6218557954,
-0.5240784883,
0.2880096734,
0.8856617212,
0.6772144437,
0.2431399375,
-1.1994085312,
0.0874662623,
-0.3502290845,
0.2134739906,
-0.1068283916,
-0.3016114533,
0.7148251534,
-0.2322150022,
-0.3372793198,
0.4560286403,
0.3806958795,
0.6259185076,
0.0014339878,
0.7125781775,
0.1953964233,
0.9550374746,
-0.1371002942,
0.906748116,
-0.057337869,
0.2713164687,
0.8619830608,
-0.2742912173,
0.7117913365,
0.1721909642,
-0.1626392901,
0.4276129007,
0.8065633774,
0.0288335346,
0.1503393501,
0.4738285244,
-0.1161805317,
-0.3157551885,
-0.2791986763,
-0.1821102351,
0.3740670979,
0.47626248,
0.0898303166,
-0.4531587064,
0.0707860589,
-0.0039492114,
0.0351266265,
-0.5807356238,
0.730914712,
0.0688886568,
-0.8033668399,
0.8439179063,
-0.0903833434,
0.7355715632,
-0.6287555695,
0.157095477,
-0.143076092,
-0.1875606477,
-0.3325666785,
-1.0102211237,
0.0123458663,
0.2506565452,
-0.1754560173,
-0.2925906777,
0.5373769999,
-0.2524642944,
-0.269580245,
0.4985540807,
0.5830914974,
-0.0894323662,
0.0804902539,
-1.0341331959,
0.2401705235,
-0.2645796239,
-0.261857897,
0.2292696983,
0.5426238179,
-0.1005549282,
0.7746812701,
0.5586974025,
0.057707984,
-0.1758371145,
0.4967620969,
0.5661184192,
-0.5000546575,
-0.4378380775,
-0.8028209805,
0.4334703684,
0.3004872501,
-0.5334058404,
0.8226904273,
0.0624374598,
0.4379084408,
0.05497602,
0.726099968,
-0.0151225086,
0.4286129475,
-0.4018479586,
0.3039729595,
-0.5997317433,
0.2810508311,
-0.4600221217,
-0.9413009882,
-0.504163146,
0.3821052313,
-0.2582470179,
0.2963502407,
0.7012411356,
0.7756178379,
0.0858575553,
0.0960279703,
0.4088361561,
0.2748858333,
0.0416889861,
0.6367643476,
1.1568572521,
-0.0107935537,
0.4838289917,
0.1300618947,
-0.5791869164,
-0.1540935487,
-0.9851152301,
-0.8355233073,
-0.5119898319,
-0.1601517051,
-0.1117774099,
0.183945328,
1.005697608,
0.6149232984,
-0.7833942771,
-0.5648809075,
0.1043966487,
0.2542489469,
-0.3404205739,
-0.1940017641,
0.434230417,
-0.5539569855,
-0.4690044224,
0.390796572,
0.5736079216,
-0.2238535434,
-0.3229725063,
-0.0810350329,
0.0649653673,
-0.049799297,
0.7243662477,
0.26423949,
-0.7500100732,
-0.197569102,
0.1637472957,
-0.1394320875,
-0.0411539823,
0.7640883923,
-0.5178474784,
0.3075963557,
0.7472699285,
0.7540765405,
-0.1606339812,
-0.1142188609,
0.4416797459,
-0.485483259,
-0.2010743916,
0.2729662955,
0.3462585807,
0.3810474873,
-0.2450828403,
0.229179129,
0.0700487942,
-0.6482902169,
-0.6610767245,
0.2270344496,
-0.9392086864,
-0.2249404788,
1.1509035826,
-0.1714667827,
-0.2368748933,
-0.1860230267,
-0.1819364429,
-0.1804194003,
-0.3214922249,
0.6880225539,
0.5904161334,
-0.0393179432,
-0.2055650651,
-0.3804652095,
0.4937602878,
0.5446859002,
-1.0053524971,
0.190460965,
0.4908628166,
0.1387629509,
0.0133904433,
0.7656692266,
-0.2742355168,
0.5496260524,
-0.2519384027,
-0.3277914524,
0.1702736616,
-0.4632365108,
-0.7994459867,
0.2657137215,
0.1457095146,
0.3714705408
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12641v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12641v1 | DetectBench: Can Large Language Model Detect and Piece Together Implicit Evidence? | 2024-06-18T14:08:01 | 2024-06-18T14:08:01 | Zhouhong Gu, Lin Zhang, Xiaoxuan Zhu, Jiangjie Chen, Wenhao Huang, Yikai Zhang, Shusen Wang, Zheyu Ye, Yan Gao, Hongwei Feng, Yanghua Xiao | cs.CL | cs.CL | Detecting evidence within the context is a key step in the process of
reasoning task. Evaluating and enhancing the capabilities of LLMs in evidence
detection will strengthen context-based reasoning performance. This paper
proposes a benchmark called DetectBench for verifying the ability to detect and
piece together implicit evidence within a long context. DetectBench contains
3,928 multiple-choice questions, with an average of 994 tokens per question.
Each question contains an average of 4.55 pieces of implicit evidence, and
solving the problem typically requires 7.62 logical jumps to find the correct
answer. To enhance the performance of LLMs in evidence detection, this paper
proposes Detective Reasoning Prompt and Finetune. Experiments demonstrate that
the existing LLMs' abilities to detect evidence in long contexts are far
inferior to humans. However, the Detective Reasoning Prompt effectively
enhances the capability of powerful LLMs in evidence detection, while the
Finetuning method shows significant effects in enhancing the performance of
weaker LLMs. Moreover, when the abilities of LLMs in evidence detection are
improved, their final reasoning performance is also enhanced accordingly. | [
-0.6732698679,
-0.9271810055,
1.1349081993,
0.0857568979,
-0.3377058506,
-0.2213679403,
-0.2193248272,
-0.7335229516,
-0.1755938828,
0.2242006958,
-0.4982215762,
-0.5828637481,
-0.5639939308,
0.2184406817,
-0.4622789323,
0.5129672885,
-0.0335484706,
0.2084114105,
-0.1489835829,
-0.2362660766,
-0.5846254826,
-0.3340042233,
-0.9119766355,
-0.2198571712,
0.2424771339,
0.4583747983,
0.1245720312,
0.4492933154,
0.0988885388,
0.3862628639,
-0.2908933759,
0.281190753,
-0.3617424071,
0.3308749199,
-0.4449898303,
-0.8974645138,
-0.3543460965,
-0.0991368517,
0.5531268716,
0.3439999521,
0.1547867656,
-0.0130386455,
-0.1308062226,
0.3751262426,
-0.7145491242,
-0.0713505149,
-0.5225616693,
-0.2144786865,
-0.3609910905,
-0.1147565469,
-0.5531086922,
-0.131750688,
-0.0972333774,
-0.3037902117,
0.2905078828,
0.1595200002,
0.4646522999,
0.278186202,
-0.5699163079,
-0.2016891092,
-0.348059237,
0.6499836445,
-0.6907528639,
0.2675733566,
0.2212147117,
0.404637754,
-0.4848214686,
-0.6468682885,
-0.5557942986,
-0.3275337517,
-0.223886475,
0.024539711,
-0.041140005,
-0.0953057036,
0.8650374413,
0.1803276688,
-0.5198872685,
0.2171349078,
0.0686277375,
-0.4712152481,
0.6181764007,
0.2919532657,
0.3167757988,
-0.1834531128,
-0.2755795121,
-0.1598274559,
-0.6994616985,
0.2032928169,
0.1632881165,
-0.015004769,
0.2059852332,
0.3787099421,
-0.5378249884,
0.471665889,
0.0983427316,
-0.2166480124,
0.0241165254,
-0.3783271313,
-0.0034689477,
0.5725563169,
0.565559566,
0.3934173286,
0.1131757125,
0.1723508686,
-0.1440595835,
0.2936868668,
-0.1810620427,
-1.1200882196,
0.1839170307,
0.4055294394,
-0.408585608,
0.0580543168,
-0.3458536565,
-0.5795120001,
-0.5709186196,
-0.2965924442,
0.1736126095,
-0.5506430864,
-0.2263091654,
0.2170567811,
-0.3008356988,
0.3519588411,
0.6902602911,
-0.4890584946,
0.4290678203,
0.8671740294,
0.6533465981,
-0.1773892194,
-0.1120087281,
-0.8316360712,
0.0386825614,
-0.3977402747,
1.2600607872,
-0.4064229131,
-0.2360879928,
-0.0864238292,
0.4630289376,
0.2842313349,
-0.5620424747,
0.9503177404,
-0.3683148921,
0.1919620186,
-0.543766439,
-0.727470994,
-0.1458390206,
0.5456684828,
-0.6861522198,
1.2083940506,
-0.2482313663,
-0.6089431643,
0.7502669096,
-0.5205026269,
-0.4950277507,
0.1430719346,
-0.2998452485,
-0.1619137824,
0.0092445565,
0.6494098902,
0.4569392502,
-0.162651673,
0.2770785987,
-0.389077574,
-0.7056539059,
0.2991055548,
-0.4959118366,
0.723698318,
-0.0416467264,
-0.70060426,
0.1806682348,
-0.8099595308,
0.0368526354,
0.0132645424,
-0.5597311258,
-0.4309970737,
0.2419949323,
-0.2836897373,
0.1725766808,
0.0858929083,
-0.7139094472,
0.0280287731,
-0.1903194934,
0.141052708,
0.769397378,
0.0151127083,
0.1593683362,
-0.2087446749,
0.2841673195,
0.1249912456,
-0.1799342036,
-0.2333460599,
-0.3581632078,
-0.8088212013,
-0.3751579225,
0.1651954055,
0.4794155955,
-0.4647458494,
0.4244944453,
-0.2210162878,
-0.0677258372,
-0.2419057637,
0.1254528463,
0.3072135746,
0.5119571686,
0.5218697786,
-0.009713429,
-0.5089639425,
-0.7839381099,
-0.3781009912,
0.1201498657,
-0.3224171698,
0.2046982199,
0.7782263756,
0.0318702459,
0.8768701553,
-0.2440724671,
-0.1206939295,
0.0039767879,
0.1456351131,
0.3626877069,
0.3976042271,
0.2943811119,
-0.4178317487,
-0.2166702896,
-0.2799963057,
-0.8719784617,
-0.2044948637,
0.0710206926,
-0.2271747142,
0.3242452145,
1.0295621157,
-0.643761754,
0.4016404152,
0.0020183895,
-0.5363640785,
0.6795953512,
0.0260143746,
0.1662591845,
-0.7099491358,
0.0638934523,
-0.1359127462,
-0.4619685709,
-0.3366145492,
-0.0168485846,
0.2267371714,
0.2535147369,
-0.4620346725,
0.799081862,
-0.5374102592,
-0.1424991935,
-0.364716053,
0.466499269,
-0.0699657798,
0.2924787998,
0.1770948917,
0.8149595261,
0.4826906919,
-0.5821455717,
0.4476195574,
-0.0414979644,
-0.8446211815,
1.1302957535,
-0.6430974603,
0.0474560522,
-0.1592757851,
0.5491275191,
-1.093162775,
-0.3665271997,
-0.126694411,
-0.1263678372,
0.2267344445,
-0.2402432859,
-0.5691229105,
-0.2516693771,
-0.316685915,
0.1942506284,
0.2595599294,
-0.8384145498,
0.6945891976,
-0.1029177159,
-0.1244503036,
-0.7236861587,
-0.5230132937,
0.1394920796,
-0.3578929007,
-0.8656121492,
0.2066475153,
-0.0793686211,
-0.4204654098,
-0.1325937212,
-0.3877605498,
0.3849821985,
0.2036148459,
0.191182822,
-0.0695150867,
-0.3508365452,
0.3012085557,
0.0254440103,
-0.1929201633,
0.3826576173,
0.0122048436,
0.4410989583,
-0.3936470747,
-0.6237999201,
-0.1493437886,
0.3638030589,
0.4335588813,
0.0421890914,
0.4686339796,
0.5884256959,
-0.2463172823,
-0.3909286261,
-1.0469406843,
-0.344928354,
-0.4865275919,
0.2731231451,
-0.6058444381,
-0.979668498,
0.6688595414,
-0.5842644572,
-0.2397474349,
0.3278715014,
0.5601725578,
0.1331865788,
1.3156788349,
0.0481677018,
-0.1017482877,
0.2399355173,
0.0344034173,
-0.0633958951,
-1.0199964046,
-0.1691094339,
-0.5119498968,
-0.2437612712,
-0.2578773499,
-0.3123805821,
0.3466755152,
0.3412149847,
-0.4228380024,
-0.0101556946,
-0.475926429,
0.6401263475,
0.619479239,
0.5179106593,
0.4718043208,
-0.2232247144,
-0.4334750772,
0.238047719,
-0.3639891148,
-0.5134918094,
0.9828896523,
0.2102513611,
0.4760586321,
0.3408432603,
0.4415626228,
0.1487756968,
0.1880767941,
-0.7000620961,
0.9702362418,
0.2582372129,
-0.9115549922,
-0.4273741841,
-0.0596949756,
-0.7681399584,
0.4634649158,
-0.0873432308,
-0.8639964461,
0.1707003266,
-0.3385498524,
-0.065102607,
0.0026360475,
-0.4288695455,
0.7728773952,
-0.4445251226,
-0.8743879795,
-0.3331175745,
-0.4343453348,
0.4590301514,
0.1062868387,
0.0886713192,
-0.315923959,
0.0718354136,
0.7991095185,
-0.4174364805,
0.6682060957,
-0.3197117448,
-0.1598923355,
0.3392961919,
0.2815306187,
0.8125484586,
0.3431938291,
-0.1711486727,
-0.219776541,
-0.0453600064,
-0.3631904721,
-0.5951700807,
0.6248577833,
-0.1315821707,
-0.9537730217,
-0.3372800946,
-0.4507799447,
-0.2356339097,
0.3835723102,
0.176831305,
0.4676836133,
-0.311432004,
0.2941995263,
0.7689312696,
0.0094244061,
0.4899629354,
0.7738859057,
0.0533562116,
-0.0199771188,
0.2890225053,
-0.2758764029,
-0.0888500214,
0.1956590265,
0.3304409981,
-0.5276774168,
-0.7579393387,
-0.3894544542,
0.070139043,
-1.1165372133,
-0.0514975488,
-0.4777533412,
0.080574736,
-0.1011986285,
-0.1099260151,
-0.116263926,
-0.0684188604,
0.1439003795,
-0.2334831953,
0.4212821722,
0.2763824463,
-0.0401435345,
0.1601952314,
-0.4391805828,
0.3600356877,
0.612442255,
0.2720853388,
-0.186020121,
-0.2859689593,
0.0744530037,
-0.0208877027,
0.1424159855,
-0.4771418571,
-0.015957471,
-0.2512786984,
0.8481757641,
0.6740114689,
0.0997251496,
0.6652430892,
-0.3680662811,
0.685906589,
-0.1360123008,
-0.9439871907,
0.7229492664,
-0.4354152381,
0.4328548014,
0.6397637725,
0.3731989264,
-0.1439319849,
-0.4440435767,
-0.3220144212,
-0.4938584864,
0.6528484225,
-0.1395532787,
-0.1953430772,
-0.0435930975,
0.1279891729,
-0.1967339665,
-0.1850730777,
-0.640553534,
0.2192918062,
0.1031637117,
-0.0670323372,
0.0830852464,
-0.423417598,
-0.4792957008,
-0.3470749557,
0.3596613407,
-0.4471049607,
0.2277640849,
0.4123420715,
-0.2665502131,
0.1360870451,
0.5373336673,
0.680113554,
0.6923245192,
-0.4258927703,
0.3620078266,
0.5930520892,
-0.2006898373,
0.2449320257,
0.1509979814,
0.0715824366,
-0.1016093045,
0.6998323202,
0.5489138961,
0.1602471322,
-0.9124532342,
0.5917599201,
-0.2230062038,
-0.2916438282,
-0.4504330456,
0.3840814233,
0.2105447799,
0.5687218904,
0.3430251777,
-0.221741572,
0.2234431654,
-0.7692235112,
0.1429147869,
0.538561523,
-0.1788522154,
0.3040050268,
0.4662409425,
0.0302237552,
-0.0375536866,
0.6780608892,
-0.2693110108,
-0.7464450598,
0.7305964828,
0.3900526166,
0.5259342194,
-0.1560659707,
-0.3017319441,
0.3285301328,
0.1322775781,
-0.4191915095,
0.3926935792,
-0.2481743246,
-0.7969045043,
-0.6677379012,
-0.2506746054,
-0.3026126921,
0.1566243917,
-0.4476423562,
0.2951411307,
-0.2988643348,
-0.0350220874,
0.1406080425,
0.1022750586,
-0.5904955268,
0.1166466922,
0.100710988,
0.9974857569,
-0.6692376733,
0.6408332586,
0.3142407238,
-0.1280790567,
-0.6571528316,
-0.2916195095,
0.3148955703,
-0.5776562691,
0.970931828,
0.5840514302,
-0.3337859809,
-0.4810463786,
-0.8210687637,
-0.6639232635,
1.1510751247,
0.1723657846,
-0.5485936999,
0.2802661657,
-0.1152995154,
0.5806030035,
-0.3917655051,
0.6665710807,
0.8754259348,
0.7158544064,
0.1418724656,
-0.639321208,
0.718978107,
-0.3125141263,
-0.369514972,
0.1341571212,
-0.3209547102,
0.8029908538,
-0.020195106,
-0.4339313805,
0.1109007969,
0.3482123911,
0.6453248262,
0.5270052552,
0.6725379229,
0.6062401533,
0.8502061963,
-0.3148070872,
0.9489656091,
-0.2101445496,
-0.0888677165,
1.3267660141,
-0.5435955524,
0.8086352944,
0.2848346829,
-0.1676981002,
0.9924580455,
0.5393108726,
-0.1434814334,
0.3096702695,
0.3378788233,
-0.5202409625,
-0.6318091154,
-0.1833650172,
-0.3437386453,
0.4372591376,
0.6958414912,
-0.1218085214,
-0.2258365601,
-0.0854481906,
0.1063952148,
-0.1080709994,
-0.3144205511,
0.6829799414,
-0.0396422781,
-1.0616220236,
0.6165111661,
-0.0132049089,
0.6928297877,
-0.4540336132,
-0.1650379151,
-0.3334853053,
0.493644774,
-0.2765648961,
-0.9056257606,
-0.1241691485,
-0.180806607,
0.0073988079,
0.119467102,
1.068915844,
-0.1137179211,
-0.2182433456,
0.5229921341,
0.5144894123,
0.2350313514,
-0.3700645566,
-0.4462481141,
-0.0721699223,
-0.3077560961,
-0.3997580409,
0.2942786515,
0.5423375964,
-0.3091868758,
0.7328297496,
0.8732694387,
-0.1301017851,
0.0254495088,
0.1412476599,
0.8641734123,
-0.6620571017,
-0.3812128603,
-0.9058718681,
0.3418374062,
-0.7126937509,
0.074009195,
0.8996786475,
0.5316329598,
0.7499271035,
0.182245031,
0.530667007,
0.0634135455,
0.6309392452,
-0.8146265745,
0.1891729087,
-0.4206719398,
0.3419832885,
-0.1418840587,
-0.8379841447,
-0.0675455406,
0.6393495798,
-0.4651359618,
0.1108455956,
1.0700101852,
1.0037481785,
-0.1964651793,
0.2418317646,
0.0257634241,
0.1436464489,
0.367489785,
0.7792342901,
1.0817391872,
-0.2679740489,
0.5037154555,
-0.0690131634,
-0.1961570233,
-0.2668637335,
-1.1078513861,
-1.2575194836,
-0.075836584,
-0.1329548508,
-0.4052852094,
-0.0742877051,
0.5141301751,
0.8705339432,
-0.848166585,
-0.0729785636,
-0.3730508387,
0.2841899991,
-0.2851091325,
-0.2802035809,
0.5418350697,
-0.2950365543,
-0.6403211355,
0.8851599097,
0.0736216083,
-0.1700220257,
-0.1735344827,
0.0618873164,
-0.4450710118,
-0.0644284785,
0.7573750615,
0.0649173334,
-0.6458696723,
-0.5276338458,
-0.180653125,
-0.0414659195,
-0.0753366947,
0.8211522698,
-0.9164805412,
0.4128632247,
0.7308577895,
0.3673946261,
1.049351573,
0.0250820629,
0.3919354379,
-0.7378299236,
0.3529909849,
0.0400299169,
0.7692029476,
0.0263028778,
-0.3789618909,
0.8433457017,
0.0565237291,
-0.6174503565,
-0.6933093667,
0.1825266778,
-0.9134377241,
-0.7792915702,
1.0439403057,
-0.1569116414,
-0.1724320352,
-0.4774101973,
-0.2638856769,
0.0753595531,
-0.3945423365,
0.5097548962,
0.9458786845,
-0.2657040954,
-0.2950039804,
-0.5995338559,
0.429184407,
0.5409303308,
-0.8602106571,
-0.1560389698,
0.7421833873,
0.5790817142,
0.2952243686,
0.4928632975,
-0.0751102194,
0.4654302001,
0.1629802734,
-0.2338290066,
-0.2617703974,
-0.1183563918,
-0.2188154906,
0.3208987415,
-0.0917340666,
0.1259334832
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12639v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12639v1 | Ask-before-Plan: Proactive Language Agents for Real-World Planning | 2024-06-18T14:07:28 | 2024-06-18T14:07:28 | Xuan Zhang, Yang Deng, Zifeng Ren, See-Kiong Ng, Tat-Seng Chua | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | The evolution of large language models (LLMs) has enhanced the planning
capabilities of language agents in diverse real-world scenarios. Despite these
advancements, the potential of LLM-powered agents to comprehend ambiguous user
instructions for reasoning and decision-making is still under exploration. In
this work, we introduce a new task, Proactive Agent Planning, which requires
language agents to predict clarification needs based on user-agent conversation
and agent-environment interaction, invoke external tools to collect valid
information, and generate a plan to fulfill the user's demands. To study this
practical problem, we establish a new benchmark dataset, Ask-before-Plan. To
tackle the deficiency of LLMs in proactive planning, we propose a novel
multi-agent framework, Clarification-Execution-Planning (\texttt{CEP}), which
consists of three agents specialized in clarification, execution, and planning.
We introduce the trajectory tuning scheme for the clarification agent and
static execution agent, as well as the memory recollection mechanism for the
dynamic execution agent. Extensive evaluations and comprehensive analyses
conducted on the Ask-before-Plan dataset validate the effectiveness of our
proposed framework. | [
-0.6962913871,
-0.9314361215,
0.7567293048,
0.1079809591,
0.0759715214,
-0.0243641995,
-0.3266165555,
-0.3226900995,
0.2004695684,
0.683219254,
-1.2348810434,
-0.2687368095,
-0.0573111847,
-0.2608307302,
-0.0385281444,
0.5692633986,
-0.1332290322,
-0.1965607107,
0.0747379586,
-0.0882491916,
-0.6580973864,
-0.2306401283,
-0.5341008306,
-0.3126593828,
0.5347594023,
0.7987422943,
0.9695385695,
0.2899357975,
0.2553052604,
0.3503388464,
0.1381016374,
0.561676383,
-0.169163391,
0.3843788207,
-0.2507328391,
-0.2622762024,
-0.6579042673,
-0.3444845974,
0.5180080533,
0.3759017289,
-0.1530625224,
0.1502822191,
-0.410287559,
0.2486488372,
-0.9009715915,
0.1952850223,
-0.6231514812,
-0.019658586,
0.0289357305,
-0.1866184771,
-0.2789136469,
-0.2039326429,
0.0417582989,
-0.7487276793,
0.0374163054,
-0.2989792824,
0.7159156799,
0.3756690323,
-0.1198247448,
-0.2293229997,
-0.8457022905,
0.3844110072,
-0.4467911422,
0.2983118892,
0.1386815608,
0.6633543968,
-0.4219011664,
-0.7586718798,
-0.8067111969,
-0.1451988071,
-0.0890098289,
0.0501518436,
0.0709453374,
0.1120985374,
0.2227771282,
-0.2598691285,
-0.7001256943,
-0.0221595,
0.1239359155,
-0.1110587567,
0.6018968225,
0.1266891658,
-0.0729514137,
0.4754686058,
-0.3860176504,
0.0051121712,
-0.7886764407,
-0.1228723004,
0.2335425615,
0.2548366189,
0.1738092452,
0.3246533275,
-0.5032867789,
0.5097975135,
-0.2025102079,
0.2766645849,
-0.0434551276,
-0.4287065864,
-0.0413128138,
-0.2380347997,
0.3306971192,
0.2222930342,
0.7341718078,
-0.0340362899,
-0.2188865989,
-0.0129362876,
0.2742325664,
-0.7497447133,
-0.014351611,
0.4226872027,
0.0125654936,
0.1257260442,
-0.2064335197,
-0.67817384,
-0.2446612269,
-0.4114910066,
0.3716546297,
-0.2940269411,
-0.5252312422,
0.2321997136,
0.2283592969,
0.3482520878,
0.3099949062,
-0.4653846025,
0.3164007962,
0.663915813,
0.3066930771,
0.3985919654,
-0.6260358691,
-0.5248590112,
0.251305908,
-0.2372467369,
1.1321084499,
-0.5592253208,
-0.3513904214,
0.2154455036,
-0.1192145422,
-0.058410693,
-0.39564538,
0.4600248635,
-0.6169324517,
-0.0163663719,
-0.5960190296,
-0.23860313,
-0.1094544753,
0.5713230371,
-0.4562188089,
0.745988965,
-0.1059819758,
-0.3376902342,
0.5356311798,
-0.7787169814,
-0.3178097308,
0.4214803278,
-0.3405067027,
-0.1713529825,
-0.3207058907,
0.3903254569,
0.4002130628,
-0.1505110711,
0.340482235,
-0.0485807732,
-0.3249533772,
0.1140361279,
-0.0698877126,
0.3274672925,
0.3438131809,
-0.3001201451,
0.5683532953,
-0.5671035647,
0.5270915031,
0.117068246,
-0.1382051408,
0.2901858985,
0.3062467277,
-0.3816246688,
0.3697291613,
0.540938139,
-0.0920822695,
0.2288614064,
-0.361669153,
0.1370031238,
0.6689834595,
0.1452471018,
0.3207553625,
-0.4875322282,
0.8325315118,
-0.4071758091,
0.4300755858,
-0.3543153405,
-0.2947957516,
-0.4877013564,
0.1205222979,
-0.1838059127,
0.8215615153,
-0.7262688279,
0.2637042999,
-0.1495771259,
-0.5477641225,
-0.1466699392,
-0.1696568131,
0.5970110297,
0.320433408,
0.5145215988,
0.1811901778,
-0.5110297203,
-0.7271971107,
-0.4045680463,
-0.3417411745,
0.2011343241,
0.1421179026,
0.3593280613,
-0.2317847162,
1.0252617598,
-0.5295352936,
-0.1160030439,
-0.796960175,
0.0316054709,
-0.0071615111,
0.1648947448,
0.3096897304,
-0.9178683758,
-0.3841108978,
-0.2730164528,
-0.1512317508,
-0.2902904451,
-0.2773492038,
-0.1349828988,
-0.1673914492,
0.4321276844,
-0.9453262091,
0.2340414375,
0.3137204051,
-0.3193712234,
0.820800066,
-0.5076528192,
-0.1723030657,
-0.7540225387,
0.1136793196,
-0.3396683633,
-0.1787793338,
-0.7697076201,
0.281668663,
0.1269974262,
-0.1008565798,
-0.6519152522,
0.9947496057,
-0.5213907361,
-0.0392791964,
-0.4839603305,
0.2626244128,
-0.1788600385,
0.6506151557,
0.2993137538,
0.8443223834,
0.3265032768,
-0.8601918221,
0.0794304907,
0.266156435,
-0.0021454992,
0.2439095974,
-0.4330504835,
0.1152915433,
-0.1205532104,
0.3980663419,
-0.5874208808,
-0.1671605259,
0.3106063008,
-0.2199969888,
0.026892405,
-0.1033942923,
-0.5057250261,
-0.3309968412,
-0.1500551403,
0.2882033587,
0.2371532023,
-0.2883834839,
0.7066117525,
0.3827303946,
-0.1734119505,
-0.6373033524,
-0.2540515661,
-0.1299005151,
-0.0245924108,
-0.7485193014,
0.5177100301,
-0.1940630078,
-0.4315686524,
-0.1309590936,
-0.1723869592,
-0.0060794698,
0.114738524,
0.1594667137,
-0.096931763,
-0.0039038539,
0.1229320839,
-0.3136442304,
-0.3089531958,
0.0889396966,
-0.0439213738,
0.6988079548,
-0.1448482275,
-0.3374430835,
-0.2223908007,
0.3208817244,
0.2504890263,
-0.5581724048,
0.3780817986,
0.3676525652,
-0.3339066803,
-0.3023277223,
-0.5357044339,
-0.2280403376,
-0.4991908669,
0.2102918327,
-0.6934764981,
-0.4321597815,
0.6658799648,
-0.4705795646,
0.4350783229,
0.1214484274,
0.5807138681,
0.1089783162,
1.1455823183,
0.4720821083,
0.4627449214,
0.4982840419,
-0.2948118448,
0.0361677036,
-0.3477187455,
-0.1049209833,
-0.444255352,
-0.3632044196,
-0.2811705172,
-0.5075289011,
0.1277086437,
-0.1162302718,
-0.0880507305,
0.5063427687,
-0.0446377248,
0.5982818604,
0.3854060173,
-0.2946212292,
-0.085405238,
-0.4395920038,
-0.2147824317,
0.2663189173,
-0.2840149701,
-0.7785143256,
0.7771539092,
0.049507346,
0.3330273032,
0.1014691368,
0.3971794248,
0.1164398342,
0.0767264739,
-0.4322468042,
1.0310972929,
0.29392156,
-0.6978248954,
-0.3924631178,
-0.0484317802,
-1.1632943153,
0.6066522598,
-0.0935121775,
-0.7433899641,
0.2568029165,
0.359023869,
-0.4810474217,
-0.0471419282,
-0.8354032636,
1.0831389427,
-0.5643586516,
-0.3708386421,
-0.4810978472,
-0.6219781637,
-0.1401710063,
0.0835254639,
0.3560146093,
-0.5077744126,
-0.2052420825,
0.2495027483,
-0.5691549778,
0.3938472271,
-0.7633875012,
0.0434850119,
0.5675054193,
0.1056097746,
0.964959681,
0.0775041059,
-0.1745264381,
-0.3872326016,
0.0263316873,
-0.3397112489,
-0.4919574559,
0.4099505544,
-0.3975481689,
-0.6805443168,
-0.0069383145,
-0.378860116,
-0.5055599213,
0.3706349432,
0.0052237515,
0.329642415,
-0.4630624056,
-0.2794322371,
0.2980384827,
-0.0628523454,
0.4193944335,
1.0425652266,
-0.2648559809,
0.0087589528,
0.6163905263,
0.1481446475,
0.1501946896,
0.4741095006,
0.1949794143,
-0.4255494475,
-0.8333160281,
-0.1961599141,
0.3353623748,
-0.7047228217,
0.0759502575,
-0.4482258558,
0.0359334983,
-0.4642013609,
-0.2383912951,
-0.30674088,
-0.1609706283,
0.0314984433,
-0.0250583868,
-0.0763901398,
0.4435100555,
0.0722466037,
0.540833652,
-0.5835589767,
0.3070479929,
0.0894753858,
-0.0710683614,
-0.5270422697,
0.0683343187,
-0.1258937269,
0.0854848847,
-0.4725530446,
-1.0565958023,
0.5028240681,
0.1868112683,
0.9204143882,
0.4426799119,
0.3375597596,
0.705555737,
-0.3799376786,
0.5721838474,
-0.4373884201,
-0.3924440444,
0.7847086787,
-0.2052522302,
0.6957253814,
0.7518860102,
0.2862495482,
-0.4048821032,
-0.4206080437,
-0.7465858459,
-0.8696097732,
0.7563413978,
0.1901756674,
-0.0932503268,
-0.030404944,
0.3100558519,
0.0009085379,
0.2352420539,
-0.4647229612,
0.0439631641,
0.1728955209,
0.1214874908,
0.0084752627,
-0.2685542703,
-0.0690851286,
0.1782075167,
0.5411860943,
-0.4050987959,
0.2000398338,
0.0722160041,
-0.3304865062,
-0.0784777924,
0.5847310424,
0.7473965287,
1.0872050524,
-0.2044227868,
0.0347938128,
0.4485653937,
-0.3483139277,
0.0100410879,
0.2960096002,
-0.0017209977,
-0.2375922203,
0.2690263093,
0.4361915886,
0.0798944607,
-1.182320714,
0.4006870091,
-0.3163149357,
-0.2715588212,
-0.7109315991,
0.3705824018,
0.0081620086,
0.4157036841,
0.0520679802,
-0.060726732,
-0.1388752013,
-0.4438891411,
0.0895516723,
0.31264925,
-0.3138902783,
-0.4680434167,
0.3757354319,
0.1751402617,
-0.5532999635,
0.320862174,
-0.5206016302,
-0.4575732648,
0.6226940155,
0.2678055465,
0.7693573236,
-0.2925453186,
0.2506642342,
0.0998369679,
0.2028476447,
0.0223907884,
1.0773791075,
-0.2362930179,
-0.8817950487,
-0.5237355828,
-0.2975069284,
-0.4626293182,
0.1330804974,
-0.0395888835,
0.5360116959,
-0.4858397245,
-0.241311565,
-0.3283188641,
0.2867033184,
-0.6829758883,
0.1681607366,
-0.1187893003,
1.0055854321,
-0.4615188241,
0.9090901613,
0.8594555259,
-0.2761258185,
-0.7034355402,
0.2382770926,
-0.0411378704,
-0.745495379,
0.3169411123,
0.3199678659,
-0.3782924712,
-0.0776061788,
-0.1481763273,
-0.8643152118,
1.0173114538,
0.4233104289,
-0.7176996469,
-0.3193771541,
0.0563537814,
0.4703991115,
-0.2479300797,
0.43686077,
0.5974032879,
0.7927126288,
0.1920534968,
-0.6979711056,
0.1288907081,
-0.0727213547,
-0.6177490354,
0.4897085428,
-0.5996430516,
0.7245604992,
-0.4399192333,
-0.4184210002,
-0.0673628077,
0.425778985,
0.3246003091,
0.3616782725,
0.7062638998,
0.2483393401,
0.7267459035,
0.0925404951,
0.8523458242,
-0.4174074531,
-0.270111084,
1.4061578512,
-0.5239716768,
0.8787645698,
0.1248523891,
-0.0120819183,
0.2968527675,
0.4793563783,
0.4465304017,
0.5227041245,
0.1543530375,
-0.2710410953,
-0.4904685915,
0.0856744722,
-0.3122537136,
0.3946743906,
0.6124269962,
0.1614106297,
-0.4134302437,
-0.2408551127,
0.1665101796,
0.208962366,
-0.1067059413,
0.7723577619,
-0.3492976427,
-1.1287202835,
0.3140823245,
0.0032014947,
0.2131769657,
-0.8508678079,
0.0952688754,
-0.0473071709,
0.4846117795,
0.0453965068,
-0.8491604328,
0.44648844,
-0.2956296802,
0.1735912114,
-0.5351772308,
0.8126834035,
-0.2630593777,
0.0281967726,
0.3957649469,
0.5473050475,
0.1242679432,
-0.4966311753,
-1.0241186619,
-0.1940502971,
-0.2655909956,
-0.3466978967,
0.0669968873,
0.4285429716,
-0.4143612087,
0.8411425948,
0.5069847703,
0.2489597946,
-0.0131853363,
0.138703987,
0.8734900355,
-0.4452367425,
-0.6734600067,
-0.6898220778,
0.4460503757,
0.0182220004,
-0.2699925601,
0.4107327461,
0.4450903833,
0.7420403957,
0.3100320697,
0.3914287984,
0.1634264141,
0.6195082068,
-0.4698211253,
0.2099034935,
-0.3884784281,
0.3817682564,
0.0910030901,
-0.8356795311,
-0.1116936952,
0.465095371,
-0.5491466522,
0.081888102,
0.5465949178,
1.0041251183,
0.2462422252,
0.0251562446,
0.1339413673,
-0.1365316361,
0.7430372238,
0.5361300707,
1.024625659,
0.2278008461,
0.7587466836,
-0.0229188427,
-0.0531889684,
-0.3617363274,
-0.8119980097,
-0.579138577,
-0.5143311024,
-0.1871486455,
0.2752343118,
0.3012787104,
1.0249803066,
0.8741854429,
-0.5512240529,
-0.1138777286,
-0.4681402445,
0.1569474638,
-0.5373775363,
-0.1238994524,
0.106822215,
-0.5702874064,
-0.3953560293,
0.8452556133,
0.0723419487,
-0.0895460472,
-0.3544031382,
-0.4172145724,
-0.4171811044,
0.2891583443,
0.2767799795,
0.6292969584,
-0.7138502598,
-0.0871396959,
-0.1195315644,
0.2660233676,
-0.1908833832,
1.1608248949,
-0.8645139337,
0.4461782277,
0.4791944325,
0.3780871034,
0.4505709112,
0.0902077928,
0.7531486154,
-0.9247425199,
0.3183039129,
0.4752623737,
0.2344925404,
-0.1789024919,
-0.3530464768,
0.3567456007,
-0.224690035,
-0.743674159,
-0.419816643,
0.6163074374,
-0.5492503643,
-0.6264650822,
1.1151192188,
-0.0056831297,
0.007201138,
-0.3507989943,
-0.6325133443,
0.0687093809,
-0.4068444669,
0.3179091215,
0.451801002,
-0.4037043452,
-0.3430810571,
-0.489518851,
0.6300356388,
0.4075563252,
-0.9358789921,
0.3848953247,
0.6539378762,
-0.2208656371,
0.1233226657,
1.1182309389,
0.2441241145,
0.2798178792,
-0.1342266053,
-0.0510392562,
-0.1969092339,
-0.8002473712,
0.2436560541,
0.32133618,
0.4352899194,
-0.1700258702
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.19413v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.19413v1 | Saliency Attention and Semantic Similarity-Driven Adversarial Perturbation | 2024-06-18T14:07:27 | 2024-06-18T14:07:27 | Hetvi Waghela, Jaydip Sen, Sneha Rakshit | cs.CR | cs.CR, cs.CL, cs.LG | In this paper, we introduce an enhanced textual adversarial attack method,
known as Saliency Attention and Semantic Similarity driven adversarial
Perturbation (SASSP). The proposed scheme is designed to improve the
effectiveness of contextual perturbations by integrating saliency, attention,
and semantic similarity. Traditional adversarial attack methods often struggle
to maintain semantic consistency and coherence while effectively deceiving
target models. Our proposed approach addresses these challenges by
incorporating a three-pronged strategy for word selection and perturbation.
First, we utilize a saliency-based word selection to prioritize words for
modification based on their importance to the model's prediction. Second,
attention mechanisms are employed to focus perturbations on contextually
significant words, enhancing the attack's efficacy. Finally, an advanced
semantic similarity-checking method is employed that includes embedding-based
similarity and paraphrase detection. By leveraging models like Sentence-BERT
for embedding similarity and fine-tuned paraphrase detection models from the
Sentence Transformers library, the scheme ensures that the perturbed text
remains contextually appropriate and semantically consistent with the original.
Empirical evaluations demonstrate that SASSP generates adversarial examples
that not only maintain high semantic fidelity but also effectively deceive
state-of-the-art natural language processing models. Moreover, in comparison to
the original scheme of contextual perturbation CLARE, SASSP has yielded a
higher attack success rate and lower word perturbation rate. | [
-0.5396862626,
-1.0036040545,
0.3948235512,
0.3807190657,
-0.4655580521,
-0.2411980033,
-0.1106231883,
-0.0742113069,
0.3596940935,
0.9708011746,
-0.6444030404,
-0.4990199506,
-0.7622129321,
0.1279753149,
-0.7178217173,
1.0459438562,
0.3674233556,
-0.0178475659,
-0.1699844748,
0.1052763164,
-0.2348671854,
-0.6397672892,
-0.4883440435,
0.0461353473,
0.581699729,
0.1512395293,
1.0231667757,
0.367102474,
0.9855024815,
0.300648421,
-0.3902300298,
-0.1599300057,
-0.6488662362,
0.369099766,
-0.1371851116,
-0.3425555825,
-0.003162394,
-0.0607459918,
0.6720294952,
0.2157837898,
0.3245286644,
-0.1490457803,
0.2049048841,
0.5368577242,
-0.8694402575,
-0.3183820844,
-1.066680789,
-0.0197565593,
-0.2722726464,
-0.2586458623,
-0.3594969809,
-0.1322771907,
0.1856019646,
-0.4689741135,
0.3550995886,
-0.1048527882,
1.0402140617,
0.6682679653,
-0.0633921474,
-0.1252119988,
-0.2451061159,
0.7711561918,
-0.5854972005,
0.0348855108,
0.2459707558,
0.2227885276,
-0.3754117489,
-0.7759189606,
-0.4946157634,
-0.460778743,
-0.098469995,
0.1476505399,
-0.2430815399,
0.0145648448,
0.4462014735,
0.1643665731,
-0.4513925612,
-0.2085799724,
0.1173097789,
-0.1787760109,
0.3135544062,
-0.0003550807,
0.3162205815,
-0.2983750105,
-1.0973514318,
-0.3574338555,
-0.6512642503,
-0.2885353267,
0.4056493044,
0.068120718,
0.1028382182,
0.5160041451,
-0.3627131581,
0.5200186372,
0.0587251969,
0.3131274283,
-0.1488673091,
-0.3674057424,
-0.1768597662,
0.1455812156,
0.6422688365,
0.3417556584,
0.1097188368,
-0.187505126,
-0.1533485204,
0.3389525414,
0.538828671,
-0.5111024976,
-0.3656502366,
0.0069616791,
-0.0791561231,
-0.6319755912,
-0.0370987691,
-1.1256840229,
-0.5372995734,
-0.092503652,
0.6191244721,
-0.7692360878,
0.3126006424,
-0.042224776,
-0.3261410296,
0.1635804772,
0.1485414058,
-0.8949905038,
0.451825887,
0.8125681281,
0.6743180156,
-0.2328470796,
-0.4417296648,
-0.5293248296,
0.4517969191,
-0.1741327941,
0.9892910123,
-0.6642161012,
-0.1774405837,
-0.2942042351,
-0.4103213251,
-0.0273810085,
-0.1989578605,
0.5442636609,
-0.6865162253,
0.137261644,
-0.4006111324,
-0.2285862714,
-0.1581247002,
0.3948794007,
-0.6966403127,
0.9322954416,
-0.0550701655,
-1.1711609364,
0.179210335,
-0.8199605346,
-0.41687572,
0.0537070185,
0.0344444029,
-0.5541904569,
0.059546601,
0.5127238631,
0.4042250812,
-0.1599633843,
-0.2968740165,
-0.3449769616,
-0.5251805782,
0.2910256088,
-0.5170525312,
0.4689097703,
0.0401285291,
-0.5730422139,
0.4333645105,
-0.5268369913,
-0.0378215685,
0.2449191958,
0.2012877464,
-0.668675065,
0.0004074674,
0.0415249057,
-0.0150581785,
0.4821168482,
-0.4785427451,
-0.1282619089,
-0.7896171212,
0.168807745,
0.567501545,
0.4491254389,
0.3139649332,
-0.0476160757,
0.2484819293,
-0.2653935552,
0.3118966818,
-0.0878360346,
-0.2000421286,
-0.6932846904,
-0.5105929375,
0.3554722071,
0.2997465432,
-0.7330594063,
0.2540102601,
-0.09145163,
-0.3121568263,
-0.4706449807,
-0.1004662663,
0.4983304143,
0.3261612952,
0.6620622873,
-0.1365667135,
-0.4720761478,
-1.0107892752,
-0.6217728853,
0.0803339183,
0.0878231153,
-0.0370784216,
0.4465360641,
-0.2211354226,
0.606479466,
-0.6970730424,
-0.3535038233,
0.0171819031,
0.0393301249,
-0.3323450983,
0.2171651572,
0.9054048061,
-1.1455993652,
-0.5171005726,
-0.2602644265,
-0.3482625186,
-0.1333673596,
-0.0869554281,
-0.3898019791,
-0.0343840383,
0.4464752078,
-0.3553137779,
0.4870143235,
0.2512248456,
-0.415284723,
0.3569669724,
0.0216999464,
0.4477289915,
-1.0009595156,
0.024033647,
-0.1907573342,
-0.166142568,
-0.7197680473,
0.4999192953,
-0.0101901712,
-0.2233610302,
-0.5970081091,
0.3279153407,
-0.2108510882,
-0.1508792192,
-0.4702261388,
0.3367164433,
-0.1071396098,
0.4622758925,
-0.1412193775,
0.6116778851,
0.4252388179,
-0.5261138082,
0.5460497141,
0.4210721552,
0.1564947218,
0.7268910408,
-0.6885530353,
0.0542446747,
-0.112518698,
0.0804378912,
-1.1384925842,
-0.2079744041,
0.2093546242,
-0.6439946294,
0.1642962545,
0.264089644,
-0.388011992,
-0.0861589387,
-0.7066823244,
-0.1976670027,
0.1451609731,
-0.560546279,
0.5217276216,
0.0177376792,
-0.2044098675,
-0.7460961938,
-0.783626616,
0.4596141279,
-0.2903797626,
-0.4330745935,
0.4518556595,
0.0788435638,
-0.1338064075,
0.0157109462,
0.009694092,
0.1818535179,
0.4400678575,
0.0553201362,
0.074901171,
0.126147598,
-0.1478598714,
-0.015056001,
-0.1369383782,
-0.0274697095,
0.0047994899,
0.7558563948,
0.0132595617,
-0.4660651982,
-0.6119983792,
0.4709913731,
0.6707933545,
-0.3040655553,
0.5683425665,
0.8111588955,
-0.2988481522,
0.1585941613,
-0.666783154,
-0.4051781297,
-0.470161438,
0.626006186,
-0.4337198734,
-0.6648600698,
0.2350637615,
0.2424478233,
-0.0737149715,
0.4285690188,
0.4384934902,
-0.0955948681,
0.8919591308,
0.4568823278,
-0.1735204458,
0.6133485436,
-0.0640383437,
-0.2222471535,
-0.9169576168,
-0.106108129,
-0.5523244143,
-0.3815287054,
-0.2013459504,
-0.1499900967,
0.2054799497,
-0.1275532693,
-0.4433196783,
0.644038558,
-0.5348914862,
0.3189447522,
0.4830187261,
0.2838672101,
-0.0791797265,
0.3937954307,
-0.2607017457,
-0.4219060838,
-0.5099577308,
-0.4406366944,
0.8719499111,
0.1842097938,
0.6854456067,
0.2672535181,
0.7059223652,
0.4746689498,
0.0320519134,
-0.3347620666,
0.8700822592,
-0.3894973099,
-0.1309290826,
-0.2009706199,
-0.1533536017,
-0.827067554,
0.4036080241,
-0.442569226,
-0.7880169749,
0.0632220432,
-0.0023718693,
-0.2580276132,
0.1302109212,
-0.547254622,
0.7758495212,
-0.1274716258,
-0.4374433756,
-0.3955529332,
-0.6875139475,
0.1035645232,
-0.0066575166,
-0.20944646,
0.1905228049,
-0.4616524577,
0.4718466103,
-0.1461903006,
0.8245893717,
-0.0198938586,
0.0592159592,
-0.0701443776,
0.0500902832,
0.7338215709,
-0.0760105997,
-0.0656128302,
-0.1506139636,
-0.218773216,
-0.5635187626,
-0.8921715617,
1.0420606136,
-0.607491374,
-0.9331988692,
-0.3555424809,
-0.4725030959,
-0.2222941816,
0.1508986503,
0.3016311228,
0.3352765441,
-0.2737266123,
0.4054256678,
0.784011364,
0.0582738556,
0.4215327203,
0.4094666243,
0.2812389433,
-0.7202979326,
0.7896355391,
-0.3283807337,
0.6364658475,
0.6127172112,
-0.0443745703,
-0.2459631711,
-0.4268716574,
-0.1313374788,
0.072717756,
-0.7154088616,
-0.1838791668,
-0.792299211,
-0.0112990262,
-0.6767172813,
-0.2634681463,
-0.0977586731,
-0.1575574577,
-0.3621983528,
0.5071760416,
0.4591998756,
0.4749078751,
0.3683012426,
0.445081234,
-0.381500572,
0.4874716997,
0.2243241519,
0.0338909775,
-0.1981248111,
-0.5317410231,
0.0624088682,
0.095219627,
-0.3709297478,
-1.2254790068,
0.3010114729,
0.0165066607,
0.5575841665,
0.3751344383,
0.280377686,
0.5199945569,
-0.2928851545,
0.9845343828,
0.1367180794,
-0.8783991933,
0.7558125854,
-0.167695716,
0.5963009596,
0.6519622803,
0.2904182374,
-0.2079272419,
-0.6285359859,
-0.7799206376,
-0.7091294527,
0.5467702746,
0.5272282958,
-0.0612873174,
0.0099039096,
0.2821700573,
-0.3439189494,
0.2451317608,
-0.4782928228,
-0.1643518955,
-0.2485818118,
-0.2511382103,
0.0059270184,
-0.333858937,
-0.0416113771,
0.3411586583,
0.7574387789,
-0.0373516083,
0.1818843633,
0.4363978207,
-0.0796882436,
0.1740915924,
0.2838854492,
0.5163111091,
0.0468317494,
0.0791215301,
0.2263994366,
0.5013404489,
-0.8377746344,
-0.0417441428,
0.304602176,
-0.4302514791,
-0.0466439277,
0.1982137412,
0.861412704,
0.7188273668,
-0.4805052876,
0.5881970525,
-0.1307688951,
-0.0137106599,
-0.0155885248,
0.0818467066,
-0.1988571882,
0.4731414914,
0.3402612209,
0.2688885629,
0.248117283,
-0.3365438282,
0.3375994563,
0.738761425,
-0.6348056197,
0.0402783789,
0.6446080208,
-0.076117605,
-0.2131183594,
-0.0655192584,
0.169977501,
-1.1602994204,
0.6147220135,
0.548192203,
0.7669122815,
-0.368588984,
-0.0357420444,
-0.07472305,
0.4627894163,
0.0678090677,
0.1814772487,
-0.1945839673,
-0.22798343,
-0.0301127322,
-0.523869276,
-0.3685741723,
0.2627800107,
-0.5757178664,
0.5343503952,
-0.6071834564,
-0.0777216554,
-0.0060816072,
0.1561622173,
-0.1274027973,
0.5752307177,
0.0153580951,
0.5024178624,
-0.6430300474,
0.4884568751,
0.9280781746,
-0.4868771136,
-0.2560407817,
0.6583653092,
-0.0492215566,
-0.3301576376,
0.4536355734,
-0.0357780233,
-0.3161699772,
0.0898110867,
-0.5258098245,
-1.112496376,
0.8640109897,
0.4746866822,
-0.270354867,
0.1257165819,
-0.0906052217,
0.5374521017,
-0.0745340511,
-0.0125359213,
0.4962596595,
0.3959123194,
0.2443817258,
-0.3050800264,
0.2614825666,
0.0188326053,
0.2000447661,
0.2481121421,
-0.7107175589,
0.5265377164,
0.0235951431,
-0.3193950951,
0.2989222407,
0.9899367094,
0.1061193421,
-0.0742087066,
0.4809814394,
0.5837798715,
0.2559605539,
-0.0506919362,
1.0049936771,
-0.3763738275,
0.1654211134,
0.9965457916,
-0.242715165,
1.015083909,
0.5526297092,
-0.0634346604,
0.2787525356,
0.3796163797,
-0.1898393333,
0.8655454516,
0.0328851044,
-0.2559426129,
-0.1246153042,
0.0026409016,
-0.441678375,
0.3576351702,
0.4322088659,
-0.4014318585,
-0.254055351,
0.312281698,
-0.0411237217,
0.5758846402,
-0.1940678507,
0.8886370659,
-0.276476264,
-0.5645375848,
0.6553934813,
-0.033028245,
0.7160798311,
-0.8543511629,
0.1093110219,
0.245060131,
0.3316292465,
-0.0561275147,
-0.5626198053,
0.2609592974,
0.0011665649,
-0.2410807759,
0.2250490785,
1.0627516508,
-0.3805289567,
-0.1706236005,
0.3224097192,
-0.3725448549,
0.010170782,
-0.2949379981,
-0.7556148767,
0.1305955499,
0.1646382213,
-0.1744278669,
0.5052917004,
0.1144561991,
0.1290099174,
0.4694536626,
0.525303781,
0.1723033786,
-0.1453733146,
0.0125084845,
1.0524590015,
-0.3817572892,
-0.7425180674,
-0.9209401608,
-0.0408877544,
-0.5884318352,
-0.2396634072,
1.0319131613,
0.2767243087,
0.3697510362,
0.0070389882,
0.6588168144,
0.3053867817,
0.4713563025,
-0.4595083296,
0.7535148263,
-0.377466619,
0.3472959101,
-0.7455438972,
-0.8844097853,
-0.4833284914,
0.4651505947,
-0.63164711,
-0.1664724648,
0.78538239,
0.8682534099,
0.1641824096,
0.2761385739,
0.3835908473,
0.2516693473,
0.0325982198,
0.4680936038,
0.594758451,
-0.5919030309,
0.6478824615,
-0.0388563871,
-0.3158259094,
-0.2829329967,
-0.7421944141,
-0.9195798635,
-0.4214190841,
-0.2887194455,
-0.3816455603,
0.7127968073,
0.5846209526,
0.1343480051,
-0.7789779305,
0.5124669671,
-0.033440575,
-0.0706327632,
-0.2463585287,
-0.2470868379,
0.5721647739,
-0.5440407991,
-0.6176621318,
0.372777462,
0.418430388,
0.0482930727,
-0.4288725257,
0.3286410272,
-0.6389996409,
0.3077793717,
0.4111186564,
-0.0893329158,
-0.8096254468,
-0.2496139556,
-0.1150508225,
-0.4649816751,
-0.3266439736,
0.5537930131,
-0.7726094723,
0.2206968516,
0.4430018961,
0.834725976,
0.2542345524,
0.2624149024,
0.3684754968,
-0.8330788016,
0.2946167588,
0.320076853,
0.1832636148,
0.5405665636,
-0.6973460317,
0.2089532167,
0.2362959832,
-0.3045859337,
-0.6657781005,
0.4401832521,
-0.6093472838,
-0.5008660555,
1.2496060133,
-0.2135721743,
-0.4067081213,
-0.0546145439,
-0.5240011811,
0.1458573788,
-0.314375639,
0.6110828519,
0.5152342916,
0.2426917553,
0.2288398445,
-0.0128707178,
0.6713703275,
0.8369482756,
-0.5985353589,
0.0110958386,
0.2579804957,
0.050616473,
0.3246702254,
-0.1006078124,
-0.1921090186,
0.5051134825,
0.0996781811,
-0.2135871053,
0.0821943656,
-0.2577083111,
-0.3900539875,
0.5109518766,
-0.4124410748,
-0.2631616592
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12629v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12629v1 | SeTAR: Out-of-Distribution Detection with Selective Low-Rank Approximation | 2024-06-18T13:55:13 | 2024-06-18T13:55:13 | Yixia Li, Boya Xiong, Guanhua Chen, Yun Chen | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV | Out-of-distribution (OOD) detection is crucial for the safe deployment of
neural networks. Existing CLIP-based approaches perform OOD detection by
devising novel scoring functions or sophisticated fine-tuning methods. In this
work, we propose SeTAR, a novel, training-free OOD detection method that
leverages selective low-rank approximation of weight matrices in
vision-language and vision-only models. SeTAR enhances OOD detection via
post-hoc modification of the model's weight matrices using a simple greedy
search algorithm. Based on SeTAR, we further propose SeTAR+FT, a fine-tuning
extension optimizing model performance for OOD detection tasks. Extensive
evaluations on ImageNet1K and Pascal-VOC benchmarks show SeTAR's superior
performance, reducing the false positive rate by up to 18.95% and 36.80%
compared to zero-shot and fine-tuning baselines. Ablation studies further
validate our approach's effectiveness, robustness, and generalizability across
different model backbones. Our work offers a scalable, efficient solution for
OOD detection, setting a new state-of-the-art in this area. | [
-0.4905878901,
-0.26393646,
0.1318756193,
-0.138191849,
-0.5691185594,
-0.0469640158,
-0.0215772036,
-0.3863711059,
0.2384888381,
0.6601784229,
-0.2406497598,
-0.1343354732,
-0.5500238538,
-0.2880438566,
-0.3655748665,
0.3709525466,
0.0157802049,
-0.1778510362,
0.2071564645,
-0.6809595227,
-0.4271568358,
-0.1820153594,
-0.6416293979,
-0.3993896842,
0.2176508904,
0.4643884897,
0.6869807839,
0.5116719007,
0.9953270555,
0.1404616237,
-0.4531514347,
0.3083410263,
-0.4970073998,
-0.1293786615,
-0.2236047536,
-0.5217425227,
-0.4703839123,
-0.2358211726,
0.7419394851,
0.4659293294,
-0.2960577607,
0.3234421313,
-0.2940820754,
0.80260396,
-1.3499981165,
-0.5521742702,
-0.7284834385,
0.327603966,
-0.2235695124,
-0.4923045039,
-0.462202996,
-0.2048890889,
-0.2142046839,
-0.4849324226,
0.077733621,
0.1057501286,
0.7196217179,
0.5218955278,
-0.0745212585,
0.0785358846,
-0.5534633994,
1.0188766718,
-0.6832880974,
0.3580832779,
0.4388488233,
0.7208924294,
-0.2124377638,
-0.3847963214,
-0.4099182487,
-0.2284932435,
0.5362761617,
0.121387206,
-0.3571974039,
-0.0610156395,
0.0439263545,
0.3943296373,
-0.2024305761,
0.1568728536,
-0.4538542628,
0.2642677426,
0.3711211085,
-0.2915868461,
0.1420618147,
0.1942942441,
-0.5381525755,
-0.1582184881,
-0.701703012,
-0.0358664431,
0.5416289568,
0.2843535244,
-0.1075866893,
0.6264575124,
-0.1175279841,
0.732773006,
0.427572459,
0.114837788,
0.2897821665,
-0.131635353,
-0.4901751578,
0.1020513922,
0.6637927294,
0.2814771831,
-0.0770227835,
0.0974550843,
-0.5126906633,
-0.0499711558,
0.2261613607,
-0.7055754662,
-0.093992658,
0.0468137488,
-1.0574730635,
-0.7834303379,
-0.1828863472,
-0.8180356622,
-0.5479569435,
0.179402858,
0.6357521415,
-0.4471975565,
-0.4685564935,
0.2875776887,
-0.3440288901,
0.1607535034,
0.1768987477,
-0.6205205917,
0.0622759685,
0.3926514983,
1.0563186407,
-0.3019983172,
-0.0753609613,
-0.9405581951,
0.016401872,
-0.8521394134,
0.8812914491,
-0.5815141201,
-0.0622256286,
-0.2273018509,
-0.1332385838,
-0.0066231918,
-0.9859776497,
0.3229087293,
-0.6123859286,
-0.2324076146,
0.0353137366,
-0.1002299264,
0.0009047435,
0.2140268236,
-0.5876152515,
1.233839035,
0.36019364,
-0.6515184641,
0.741992414,
-0.9271602035,
0.0397724286,
0.0941349193,
0.1014887169,
-0.3311251104,
0.2384760082,
0.3485589921,
0.26139009,
-0.0602477938,
-0.3200333416,
-0.6277397871,
-0.6005119681,
-0.185078457,
-0.2792288959,
0.7376366854,
0.2489291281,
-0.2777234018,
0.2848047614,
-0.832928896,
0.283308953,
-0.0593285859,
-0.1129707769,
-0.5752598047,
0.0128884101,
-0.1817647219,
0.2408155948,
-0.1103314161,
-0.8375774026,
0.0475289598,
-0.5655273199,
0.3612950742,
0.5388019085,
0.1198301911,
0.6433719397,
-0.2418019176,
0.6860510111,
0.1437806785,
0.4376723766,
0.0721718073,
-0.4289920628,
-0.3298047781,
-0.8042255044,
-0.1154645905,
0.4833030999,
-0.8765880466,
0.7068908811,
-0.0351730995,
-0.4963212311,
-0.3671671748,
0.1767357439,
0.4866317809,
0.604413867,
0.4124839306,
-0.2622989714,
-0.6274505258,
-0.5402672291,
0.2640359402,
0.1237524748,
0.3211176395,
-0.0499133281,
0.76168859,
-0.0434427559,
0.9913653135,
-0.5952301025,
-0.8197485805,
-0.3977222741,
-0.4831794798,
0.1873446256,
0.554031074,
0.9882603288,
-0.6047262549,
-0.3060042858,
0.2823775411,
-0.8671144247,
0.2451332361,
0.315802753,
-0.3007174432,
-0.098639898,
0.8193151355,
-0.1148886234,
0.9005755186,
0.5148342252,
-0.1693430692,
0.2194925845,
-0.5382168293,
-0.1625421345,
-1.0129032135,
0.2032598406,
-0.2008595169,
-0.2072857171,
-0.4995270967,
0.1959327459,
-0.0298376381,
-0.3829573393,
-0.7648053169,
0.5830721855,
-0.1399666071,
-0.1369087994,
-0.4683706462,
-0.1952507645,
0.0268797632,
0.2624281645,
0.0352440812,
0.9142926335,
0.583052814,
-0.4670575559,
0.2142567039,
0.4681606591,
-0.486910969,
0.6694052219,
-0.6815785766,
-0.1591961235,
-0.4257330298,
0.2046757638,
-0.6713939905,
-0.1102982536,
0.5917267799,
-0.1370622218,
0.0316644795,
-0.755681932,
-0.0402155593,
-0.241386503,
-0.6857309937,
0.6847519279,
0.7021107078,
-1.0417183638,
0.3574105799,
0.3977958262,
0.6566053033,
-0.9396224618,
-0.8722967505,
-0.3030164838,
-0.2216150463,
-0.4123333395,
0.3260026276,
0.0411576852,
-0.1232897714,
-0.0205964595,
-0.1656021476,
-0.6218659878,
-0.0537362918,
0.1510006487,
0.0237184223,
-0.2940689027,
-0.1228977367,
0.0287487246,
0.0491894484,
-0.5497163534,
-0.3037564158,
0.5529613495,
0.0447214432,
-0.5369648337,
-0.2216861099,
0.4828988314,
0.5705574155,
-0.3838138878,
0.6532282829,
0.4117775261,
-0.5304315686,
-0.6310257316,
-0.1072170585,
-0.0681625083,
-0.5532144308,
0.4677275419,
-0.0481712557,
0.0055989283,
0.6536892653,
0.2225173712,
-0.168829754,
0.0725678802,
0.2381991595,
-0.0233338494,
0.8130380511,
0.5975316763,
0.1057933122,
0.8990884423,
-0.5730938315,
0.138674438,
-0.9416165948,
0.0434929393,
-0.048907835,
-0.2646899819,
0.0853877589,
-0.4367815554,
0.4993171096,
0.3091573715,
-0.0411127545,
0.2435898781,
-0.7618153691,
0.7445470691,
0.5526313782,
0.4833537936,
0.0229560733,
0.2392875105,
0.2324481457,
0.4267585278,
-0.6682939529,
-0.0814704001,
1.1919717789,
0.265257895,
0.744843781,
-0.0309870541,
0.6262973547,
0.7216703296,
0.0662576109,
-0.7428304553,
0.5292929411,
-0.5125011802,
-0.4473294616,
-0.320140183,
-0.2375476211,
-0.7857354879,
0.2874398828,
0.0398829989,
-0.6334981918,
0.8897477984,
0.5705778003,
-0.4857708216,
0.790160358,
-0.5960555077,
0.6584678292,
-0.0442935973,
0.0752321854,
-0.0828047693,
-0.3937509358,
0.3773120642,
0.0271645151,
-0.2803826928,
-0.4156268537,
0.0204707924,
0.5864253044,
-0.8375096321,
0.5800943375,
-0.5777225494,
0.0166324098,
0.5314214826,
-0.2232336253,
0.4685104489,
-0.133328706,
-0.3566685021,
0.3307988048,
0.1054782569,
-0.3273510933,
-0.3948432207,
0.4586532116,
-0.4826179147,
0.2899553478,
-0.3791646063,
-0.4659975469,
0.1238371953,
0.3218905628,
0.7026850581,
0.6218192577,
0.1935120374,
0.1373983324,
0.5598778129,
-0.1831919998,
0.6682376862,
-0.0490344726,
-0.3349162042,
-0.5834902525,
1.1230150461,
-0.0774494335,
0.428177923,
0.2245482802,
0.3093189895,
-0.1746077985,
-0.9353905916,
-0.5951240063,
-0.0696524382,
-0.9340100288,
-0.5127894282,
-0.0763322264,
-0.0391982011,
-0.0844798163,
-0.3011338711,
-0.6726415753,
-0.1549784392,
-0.3068188727,
0.2696071267,
0.3345091045,
0.2200227231,
-0.31685251,
0.779663384,
-0.3472645879,
0.5659664273,
-0.0398886241,
0.6523293257,
-0.0157851223,
-0.7552283406,
0.0425200611,
0.1006473675,
-0.088784337,
-0.4491608143,
0.5403635502,
0.6908972859,
0.4433048666,
0.8664860725,
0.3175116181,
0.6237367392,
-0.1928915828,
0.3902078569,
0.3704101741,
-0.7380655408,
0.5341023803,
-0.2599093318,
0.0249025337,
0.7875612974,
-0.2454227209,
0.0222685449,
-0.0051356177,
0.0250463597,
-0.8219948411,
1.0170590878,
0.1599046588,
-0.1584831029,
0.0173301473,
0.2076139599,
-0.0015461197,
0.2086175978,
-0.2017140239,
-0.0874464437,
-0.1941580623,
-0.2847856879,
0.2253371775,
-0.167751953,
-0.2093141377,
-0.0271858573,
0.4746320844,
-0.310093224,
0.5430014133,
0.1686791182,
-0.2595670819,
-0.450394839,
0.0091708805,
0.5858488083,
0.7560756207,
-0.7846627235,
-0.1025898233,
0.140886724,
-0.8233249784,
0.1973245293,
-0.1792060286,
-0.4378027618,
0.0600733459,
0.1291944385,
0.7666022778,
0.1448280364,
-1.0096092224,
0.9382291436,
0.2119256556,
-0.2447199672,
-0.3523654938,
0.1630220115,
-0.7083012462,
0.361741662,
0.5235110521,
0.9119458795,
0.1393329203,
-0.3530203104,
0.1840667427,
0.5971919298,
-0.7179467082,
-0.3146634698,
0.6022552252,
0.0734282956,
-0.0180601291,
0.217731446,
-0.4359689951,
-0.2363841832,
0.8723751903,
0.4538118243,
0.8263077736,
-0.071892269,
0.273953259,
-0.2049280256,
0.324800849,
-0.5609614253,
0.7728305459,
0.1361204088,
-0.9976527095,
-0.3811320961,
-0.5183399916,
-0.2799470723,
0.1365156323,
-0.9062656164,
0.3477355242,
-0.8269769549,
-0.2217616141,
0.0029794252,
-0.5191790462,
-0.2191316187,
0.1398787349,
0.123716563,
1.07987535,
-0.6063198447,
0.6533563733,
0.796708107,
-0.3134105802,
-0.3686333895,
-0.0897090137,
-0.3694899678,
-0.7632648349,
0.602522254,
0.1578565985,
-0.2863246799,
-0.0492985174,
-0.332242161,
-0.9824151993,
0.7821772099,
0.8033884168,
-0.1254969984,
0.0680973902,
-0.2063160837,
0.2355211377,
-0.2229222655,
0.3978018463,
0.2718443573,
0.1810101718,
0.2354107797,
-0.8306306005,
-0.2212730795,
0.0006132859,
-0.0399904698,
0.6250730157,
-0.570720613,
0.8415203094,
-0.3049920201,
0.0699703097,
0.0379148088,
0.3497686386,
0.1720717251,
0.5950800776,
0.6625614762,
0.4747140408,
0.6380544901,
0.432749629,
0.815950036,
-0.0683927387,
0.2303912789,
0.8017454147,
-0.5825075507,
1.096097827,
0.7073969245,
0.1051100343,
0.0468163267,
0.3192870915,
-0.0879851952,
1.1677389145,
-0.034440767,
-0.2477551401,
-0.1568704098,
-0.1077237949,
-0.4698053896,
0.5142828822,
0.078318961,
-0.3966376483,
-0.3916551471,
0.514074266,
-0.3389219046,
-0.1584073007,
-1.0116214752,
0.2097432911,
-0.1965852082,
-0.3991977274,
0.8808689117,
-0.1294352263,
0.9140267968,
-0.5085636377,
-0.1806491315,
-0.1650697291,
0.8240599632,
-0.3454182744,
-0.4468870461,
0.4712590277,
-0.2842306793,
-0.2943572998,
0.0527907722,
0.8702008724,
-0.1932834387,
-0.5676417351,
0.3537580967,
0.1484135538,
0.0826004744,
-0.3831962645,
-0.2782242298,
-0.0949228257,
-0.2041340619,
-0.0262051728,
0.3711445034,
-0.0729739591,
-0.3795869946,
0.9362739921,
0.7821661234,
0.2170139849,
0.3800354302,
-0.1612735391,
0.7801581025,
-0.2624471188,
-0.6210327148,
-0.4232281744,
-0.0173226353,
-0.1486555785,
-0.6992546916,
0.1033856645,
0.3986251652,
0.5683804154,
-0.3427665532,
0.5508269072,
-0.2351546884,
0.3658049107,
-0.3076816201,
0.7569348812,
-0.7996274829,
0.0644192174,
-0.022103861,
-0.6306780577,
-0.3871008158,
0.4765862823,
-0.1607927233,
-0.0724058598,
0.4982580841,
0.7193302512,
-0.6749404073,
-0.4756508172,
0.5639485121,
-0.3815528154,
0.1606798619,
0.2855187654,
0.7555561662,
-0.6097041965,
0.9317590594,
-0.3319911957,
-0.3243249357,
-0.5323848724,
-0.9075121284,
-1.1383650303,
-0.0391578823,
-0.2826097906,
-0.1834919602,
0.3205410242,
1.0447075367,
1.2352845669,
-0.9041269422,
0.1456574649,
-0.2016818374,
0.0436353832,
-0.7573988438,
-0.1330281645,
0.4668830931,
-0.1603152305,
-0.3534379005,
1.0260429382,
0.4234468937,
-0.1700878143,
0.0667989105,
-0.118738398,
-0.1111592278,
0.2558592558,
0.3257702887,
0.6356514692,
-0.459269017,
-0.3984434307,
-0.1486314386,
0.2605011463,
0.2906380594,
0.5500541329,
-0.748131752,
0.4668341875,
0.5821992159,
0.3741586506,
0.1421379745,
0.0720864013,
0.3343886435,
-1.1187156439,
0.9112423062,
0.4282871485,
0.3256542683,
0.0409374535,
-0.3466968834,
0.5761717558,
0.1249957606,
-0.2916109562,
-1.4468560219,
0.2318174243,
-1.0503418446,
0.0605661608,
0.9254640937,
-0.2186685652,
-0.4406733215,
-0.1436547339,
-0.1027717069,
-0.1284402013,
-0.6795654297,
0.4633727372,
-0.1405953318,
-0.0010455012,
-0.1825137883,
-0.2940464914,
0.4056099057,
0.3502339125,
-0.7277468443,
-0.1206681654,
0.1005100012,
0.2932706475,
0.0087995641,
0.5315666199,
0.0892712548,
0.5605563521,
0.0039303475,
0.1613679081,
-0.5744879842,
-0.2386631668,
-0.4156271219,
0.3928231299,
-0.0108803855,
-1.0313842297
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12624v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12624v2 | Judging the Judges: Evaluating Alignment and Vulnerabilities in LLMs-as-Judges | 2024-06-18T13:49:54 | 2024-07-02T02:57:01 | Aman Singh Thakur, Kartik Choudhary, Venkat Srinik Ramayapally, Sankaran Vaidyanathan, Dieuwke Hupkes | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Offering a promising solution to the scalability challenges associated with
human evaluation, the LLM-as-a-judge paradigm is rapidly gaining traction as an
approach to evaluating large language models (LLMs). However, there are still
many open questions about the strengths and weaknesses of this paradigm, and
what potential biases it may hold. In this paper, we present a comprehensive
study of the performance of various LLMs acting as judges. We leverage TriviaQA
as a benchmark for assessing objective knowledge reasoning of LLMs and evaluate
them alongside human annotations which we found to have a high inter-annotator
agreement. Our study includes 9 judge models and 9 exam taker models -- both
base and instruction-tuned. We assess the judge model's alignment across
different model sizes, families, and judge prompts. Among other results, our
research rediscovers the importance of using Cohen's kappa as a metric of
alignment as opposed to simple percent agreement, showing that judges with high
percent agreement can still assign vastly different scores. We find that both
Llama-3 70B and GPT-4 Turbo have an excellent alignment with humans, but in
terms of ranking exam taker models, they are outperformed by both JudgeLM-7B
and the lexical judge Contains, which have up to 34 points lower human
alignment. Through error analysis and various other studies, including the
effects of instruction length and leniency bias, we hope to provide valuable
lessons for using LLMs as judges in the future. | [
-0.4022143781,
-0.4634779394,
0.919593215,
-0.0532502048,
-0.2791363895,
0.1809386313,
-0.3009948432,
-0.5664590001,
0.0302110873,
0.5663204193,
-0.073107399,
-0.453922838,
-0.8601541519,
0.017729722,
-0.5193685889,
0.8694646955,
0.0367748663,
0.525552392,
-0.4604495764,
-0.0814016387,
-0.5836032629,
-0.4991516173,
-0.3991493583,
-0.5599220991,
0.316854924,
0.5682612658,
1.0174487829,
0.7103949189,
0.7991802692,
0.2581360042,
-0.3395153284,
-0.1349093169,
-0.1356612295,
0.0286334939,
-0.437454313,
-0.7936889529,
-0.4563864172,
0.1697842032,
0.4242343903,
0.6839376688,
-0.2812964022,
0.2664095461,
-0.1515871137,
0.6366168261,
-0.6400696039,
-0.1939951628,
-0.6026356816,
0.0822454244,
-0.3999406397,
-0.0650904775,
-0.4022577405,
-0.7400681973,
0.1732144505,
-0.4850138724,
-0.163815394,
0.4305590689,
0.8368176222,
0.6839305758,
-0.7329965234,
-0.2293342054,
-0.5105069876,
0.6509968042,
-0.741830349,
0.2953879237,
0.4308819473,
0.5438528061,
-0.1471038312,
-0.4908230007,
-0.4736304879,
-0.4649020135,
-0.0327381268,
0.1096459106,
-0.0616828911,
0.1561721116,
0.4041757286,
0.3851635456,
-0.5095989108,
0.5410534143,
-0.3158827722,
-0.1493594497,
0.6114374995,
0.2506181896,
0.0774510577,
-0.3237170577,
-0.3431835771,
-0.0333926752,
-0.4877201915,
0.0746203288,
0.4936703742,
0.0184138007,
0.2475409806,
0.62710917,
-0.2657936513,
0.9416950345,
0.218247667,
-0.0832133889,
-0.047191713,
-0.1374820769,
-0.1985555887,
0.0791954622,
0.8145641685,
0.7029548287,
0.4640356898,
-0.1896644533,
-0.1024284586,
-0.0582542308,
0.6957172751,
-0.3965252638,
0.0665913448,
0.1107181087,
-0.4082656503,
-0.4715142846,
0.21705091,
-0.7370697856,
-0.8096679449,
-0.5384314656,
0.465508759,
-0.2274838537,
0.2620992362,
0.1994011104,
-0.0040111961,
0.5305504799,
0.3471890092,
-0.7294618487,
0.4124738276,
0.8845437765,
0.3734973967,
-0.2368281484,
-0.3988553584,
-0.6437005997,
-0.2372370362,
-0.3345941603,
0.5847798586,
-0.5110789537,
-0.2388291061,
-0.1923422664,
-0.4488867521,
0.0753279105,
-0.481769532,
0.9274091125,
-0.8061246276,
-0.0119289467,
-0.4364231527,
-0.7510840893,
-0.0950394049,
0.4819838107,
-0.5247780681,
0.9668508768,
-0.060005933,
-0.6587561369,
0.6040925384,
-0.3104788065,
-0.2583566308,
-0.0810689852,
-0.2084759772,
-0.3426873088,
0.230925262,
0.3081892431,
0.2296118587,
-0.5221802592,
0.4278321564,
-0.4423040152,
-0.7170587778,
0.3742788136,
-0.2219400853,
0.7074571848,
0.1335728317,
-0.4272176027,
0.1602154523,
-0.801158905,
0.0122886747,
-0.0920197591,
-0.278914392,
-0.1696448773,
0.163842231,
-0.3478451371,
0.1994005442,
0.0260869171,
-0.4627423882,
0.2412654012,
-0.2741488516,
0.3027805686,
0.8904570341,
0.0867993608,
0.3869162798,
-0.3472265303,
0.7171451449,
-0.2291893214,
0.5369105339,
0.333108753,
-0.409394592,
-0.8267629743,
0.1673382223,
0.7362724543,
0.5860708356,
-0.3932380378,
0.5172139406,
-0.4025667012,
-0.7455293536,
-0.662604332,
0.1871974766,
0.4835417867,
0.41779989,
0.107683368,
-0.6169175506,
-0.2124933153,
-0.995731771,
-0.6607246995,
-0.4976551533,
0.1666517407,
0.1264902353,
0.5622099042,
0.1269145608,
0.9091362357,
-0.2271716893,
0.1041226909,
0.1877622008,
-0.1492286623,
0.1115903184,
0.2788760662,
0.5923409462,
-0.4688399434,
-0.2023944557,
0.0617309287,
-0.7456903458,
-0.4052198827,
0.1237608343,
-0.2218184322,
0.0876099691,
0.5195251703,
-0.4405758083,
0.6004670858,
0.2703222632,
-0.5778734684,
0.8074555397,
0.0165220983,
0.2154722661,
-0.5949742198,
-0.1845918447,
-0.27260831,
-0.3647105098,
-0.4966693223,
0.2101868093,
0.1331907362,
0.2875169218,
-0.2101077735,
0.5512250662,
-0.3535560369,
-0.4693373144,
-0.1364942491,
0.4682545066,
0.0947296396,
0.2140927613,
-0.3174807131,
0.637229383,
0.2750381827,
-0.3967364728,
0.5067490339,
0.2096017599,
-0.7128585577,
0.9568434954,
-0.3959227502,
0.2430758327,
0.2179326415,
0.0984374434,
-0.7515709996,
-0.2312393636,
0.203661561,
-0.4207407236,
0.455453217,
-0.0835366026,
-0.6890873909,
-0.4864917696,
-0.3358100951,
0.2044950575,
0.2717140317,
-0.5719012022,
0.7267203331,
0.1534117758,
-0.0305037461,
-0.9002652168,
-0.4519779682,
0.2657759786,
-0.431286931,
-0.675401628,
0.0799781457,
-0.0503768064,
-0.6959186196,
-0.0363718718,
-0.3034788668,
0.2706934512,
0.5701147914,
0.3752630949,
0.2316355407,
-0.1472457051,
0.1371193826,
-0.1868461072,
-0.0239531733,
0.2689835429,
-0.1041849852,
0.3027042747,
-0.3216475844,
-0.8954570293,
-0.3414437473,
-0.0015844139,
0.6860979199,
-0.4071772695,
0.5009817481,
0.1964264661,
-0.0542930067,
0.1207354218,
-1.005521059,
0.085512124,
-0.3706876934,
0.2432640791,
-0.2701206207,
-0.9298408031,
0.4681332707,
0.2046656758,
0.0357552394,
0.3415651917,
0.7438156009,
-0.2411693186,
0.65656358,
0.2926251292,
-0.179721728,
0.487965405,
0.3648552001,
0.1702649146,
-0.9234057069,
-0.2350761592,
-0.5982838273,
-0.584189117,
-0.5664069653,
-0.3808487952,
0.3758553565,
0.2294168621,
-0.5962333679,
0.0413456857,
-0.3151575625,
0.6807153821,
0.7545673847,
-0.0140707623,
0.4333696365,
-0.4220366478,
-0.3763156235,
0.1885004193,
-0.2803553641,
-0.8689900041,
1.4541698694,
0.4055093527,
0.7517616153,
0.2196060717,
0.7970770597,
0.2057959884,
0.2952990234,
-0.801371932,
0.5787411928,
0.0009535992,
-0.8167993426,
-0.2007672787,
-0.2099789232,
-0.3819096088,
0.4713925421,
-0.1505723149,
-0.9153987765,
0.2166423053,
-0.0507414043,
-0.5817825794,
0.3746950626,
-0.7621383071,
0.8605080247,
-0.8266381621,
-0.3318236768,
0.0505350754,
-1.0603821278,
0.4098530114,
-0.1808379591,
0.2127127647,
-0.0908164531,
0.0003337802,
0.6194549799,
-0.3814058602,
0.7423834801,
-0.1694079936,
-0.0165165793,
0.1427886486,
0.2237483859,
0.2979868948,
0.0282288864,
-0.2638747692,
0.0185187589,
0.0936399251,
-0.2683373988,
-0.6394224167,
0.3896452785,
-0.8791739941,
-0.9881436229,
-0.5892674327,
-0.5007504821,
-0.555421412,
0.0813242495,
0.0129303169,
0.0283209346,
-0.2402492166,
0.1033967659,
0.4487359822,
-0.0497373231,
0.1407092363,
0.6025972962,
-0.4152888954,
-0.3867980838,
0.5553347468,
-0.0202810727,
0.4462203979,
0.2998494804,
0.1737921685,
-0.1333594173,
-0.7422658205,
-0.4071334302,
0.2349008918,
-0.8695909977,
-0.2528709769,
-0.1963229328,
-0.1279767752,
-0.0782766715,
-0.2232619822,
-0.1406677514,
-0.6488255262,
-0.1549907774,
-0.2859677076,
0.1347108483,
0.8623219132,
0.1926419288,
0.5615476966,
-0.4486894608,
-0.0340634324,
0.4289480448,
0.4828772247,
-0.0834918991,
-0.8249388933,
0.0456465408,
-0.4807729125,
-0.4295374453,
-0.7251229286,
-0.2103725374,
-0.1344406903,
0.6530584693,
0.572660625,
-0.1627866775,
0.7170068622,
-0.4309392869,
0.8084361553,
-0.0373986289,
-0.9847915173,
0.3912029266,
-0.0849100053,
0.0620128997,
0.9363475442,
-0.0463259779,
-0.4681735039,
-0.6016958356,
-0.3430539072,
-0.484307766,
0.9835916162,
0.0757453442,
-0.2412603199,
0.2022730559,
0.6504706144,
0.0817993209,
0.1891971529,
-0.6342459917,
-0.0556749925,
-0.0262608938,
-0.0893848166,
-0.0397185534,
-0.3919839561,
-0.1834134012,
-0.2635093629,
0.6369690895,
0.0189325977,
-0.2513539493,
-0.0318121649,
-0.2450976968,
-0.031794697,
0.6113240719,
0.6561486721,
0.6844949722,
-0.2888099253,
0.140235424,
0.3218608201,
-0.2449266613,
0.2015118003,
0.1612731218,
-0.0762178004,
-0.4476010501,
0.670776248,
0.8168373704,
0.4648537338,
-0.5954259038,
0.6091483235,
-0.2148870826,
-0.1520399302,
-0.1707794219,
0.150076896,
0.2118050307,
0.6068902016,
-0.0582392551,
0.024508344,
0.0032206448,
-0.3878720403,
0.1108410954,
0.3246003687,
-0.4752184749,
-0.07087221,
0.7880387902,
0.078771323,
-0.3349923491,
0.6683982015,
-0.2204474956,
-0.7654508352,
0.5697686672,
0.0855817273,
0.6119019985,
-0.1724156439,
-0.1716933995,
0.0299503319,
0.4953754842,
-0.1837296635,
0.1059005484,
-0.2219009846,
-0.7505395412,
-0.1454691142,
-0.8829448223,
-0.7846323848,
-0.4287902713,
-1.0026061535,
0.2443721443,
-0.4439837933,
-0.529237926,
0.0587257668,
0.2506070733,
-0.5735796094,
0.056121923,
0.3484091163,
1.0265520811,
-0.6816726327,
0.5281850696,
0.7582957745,
-0.2884857655,
-0.7997556925,
0.1852197796,
0.4100213349,
-0.9813767672,
0.655072391,
0.0286330823,
0.0580777042,
-0.3323607147,
-0.4557013214,
-0.719371736,
1.2806587219,
0.538820684,
-0.8002371788,
-0.213234067,
0.0831371099,
0.7081179619,
-0.1961495131,
0.4645314515,
1.0852556229,
0.6980711222,
0.064668566,
-1.145455718,
-0.1964601725,
-0.0618056208,
-0.0677442029,
0.2198101133,
-0.7820377946,
0.4970871508,
-0.1771033108,
0.2349552065,
0.1093820482,
0.440361619,
0.4480529726,
0.1826929003,
0.5443773866,
0.8705791831,
0.8716472983,
-0.2501241565,
1.2191668749,
-0.1780681163,
0.2226133347,
1.2903897762,
-0.5585369468,
0.6702129841,
0.6009463072,
-0.3543925881,
0.4867551029,
0.7127947211,
-0.1557272077,
0.0920962915,
0.420252949,
0.1562766731,
-0.5658438206,
-0.0144592514,
0.0331517719,
0.7601522207,
0.0386735313,
-0.308812052,
-0.1717384607,
-0.3433687389,
-0.0004280329,
0.1991235614,
-0.4890630543,
0.5784111023,
0.3169024885,
-0.861291945,
0.0108684897,
0.0462459177,
0.3890558779,
-0.3253426552,
0.2689040303,
-0.1458709538,
0.1955319047,
-0.2327177078,
-1.072040081,
0.0839509815,
0.3101792037,
-0.0895445123,
-0.0788276941,
0.4920653403,
0.1282871664,
-0.4487406313,
0.4950148165,
0.4430290461,
0.2265711427,
0.0216746293,
-0.4868523777,
0.0987633914,
-0.210314706,
-0.3199326992,
0.2810923159,
0.4067222774,
-0.452185601,
0.5898045301,
0.2204762101,
0.1692617238,
0.4241432846,
0.3886690438,
0.6710237265,
-0.7805688977,
-0.1768626869,
-0.9518251419,
0.2584373057,
-0.1444241256,
-0.3609925807,
0.7211099267,
0.4682843387,
0.7610763311,
0.2518661618,
0.3043493629,
0.1034258157,
0.4322715998,
-0.5981852412,
0.7060605288,
-0.6067481637,
0.4680225253,
-0.1363909245,
-0.7675087452,
-0.2810431123,
0.2210303992,
-0.6320090294,
0.2062265128,
0.6062776446,
0.5172870755,
0.1927597523,
0.1619340181,
0.3722388446,
0.2237723172,
0.3393858373,
0.6192340851,
1.2188706398,
-0.21131818,
0.5456746221,
-0.1622378528,
-0.0015341499,
-0.3727333844,
-0.7360308766,
-1.0507433414,
-0.0791633874,
-0.0644383654,
-0.0487048514,
-0.1316799968,
0.7274338603,
0.3841860294,
-0.7136849165,
-0.1774603426,
0.4592523873,
0.3502975106,
-0.0716000944,
-0.1687618196,
0.3616521955,
-0.2247879505,
-0.4739964306,
0.2199864537,
0.2446326911,
-0.4154162407,
-0.1282952279,
-0.1326037496,
-0.0702463463,
0.0130453529,
0.2820522785,
-0.0397946723,
-1.1494978666,
-0.6523565054,
-0.2160864621,
-0.1976469308,
0.0853464752,
0.4962976575,
-0.5836974382,
0.7131067514,
0.2913877666,
0.7261676192,
0.369550854,
0.3588447869,
0.4360229373,
-0.4782801867,
-0.3957930207,
0.237001732,
0.5019981265,
0.1883626133,
-0.1599796414,
0.6515373588,
-0.0093621109,
-0.9154119492,
-0.9359067678,
0.0915924385,
-1.1821094751,
0.0229599122,
0.9807292819,
0.1283726245,
-0.1682898551,
0.0039552893,
-0.0232540239,
0.0542011596,
-0.1524606645,
0.7188082337,
1.2472969294,
-0.2071731985,
0.1457971931,
-0.8806957603,
0.1337990761,
0.5735703111,
-0.6507465839,
-0.0117941238,
0.3891025484,
0.5712646246,
0.2310735583,
0.4163114727,
-0.3645027578,
0.4375169575,
-0.2847812474,
0.2495937049,
-0.0796890557,
-0.0540732406,
-0.8465698361,
-0.0270474125,
0.5412044525,
0.1993589848
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12621v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12621v1 | Growing Trees on Sounds: Assessing Strategies for End-to-End Dependency Parsing of Speech | 2024-06-18T13:46:10 | 2024-06-18T13:46:10 | Adrien Pupier, Maximin Coavoux, Jérôme Goulian, Benjamin Lecouteux | cs.CL | cs.CL | Direct dependency parsing of the speech signal -- as opposed to parsing
speech transcriptions -- has recently been proposed as a task (Pupier et al.
2022), as a way of incorporating prosodic information in the parsing system and
bypassing the limitations of a pipeline approach that would consist of using
first an Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR) system and then a syntactic parser.
In this article, we report on a set of experiments aiming at assessing the
performance of two parsing paradigms (graph-based parsing and sequence labeling
based parsing) on speech parsing. We perform this evaluation on a large
treebank of spoken French, featuring realistic spontaneous conversations. Our
findings show that (i) the graph based approach obtain better results across
the board (ii) parsing directly from speech outperforms a pipeline approach,
despite having 30% fewer parameters. | [
-0.3847923279,
-0.8985239863,
0.5272586942,
0.5297572017,
-0.2098225057,
0.3927762508,
-0.1203860492,
-0.876223743,
0.3182921708,
0.2958199382,
-0.43977198,
-0.2918077111,
-0.6648811698,
0.369361639,
-0.594717145,
0.4369631708,
0.2915837467,
-0.0418670587,
-0.1194767505,
-0.0962884203,
-0.5063121915,
-0.6477959752,
-0.9826951623,
-0.1400660723,
0.5551260114,
0.1998084038,
0.6439941525,
0.7701373696,
0.3109152317,
0.3930020332,
-0.5888610482,
-0.2337826043,
-0.1820675284,
0.2708802819,
0.0999302343,
-0.1637675762,
-0.2589198649,
-0.0169628728,
0.6159555912,
0.8452264071,
0.2036987841,
0.0796340629,
0.1941827983,
0.4977562726,
-0.2889343202,
0.3640474379,
-0.3809688985,
0.2469664812,
-0.2716070414,
-0.38726753,
-0.6473149061,
-0.1895212829,
0.3134736419,
-0.1268180758,
0.12013717,
-0.3559808135,
0.8343790174,
0.0724307299,
-0.4089436531,
-0.4505997598,
-0.9011962414,
0.4650952816,
-0.6068997383,
0.7761147618,
0.2809381485,
0.1429416388,
-0.1339881122,
-0.9898498654,
-0.0999226868,
-0.205424428,
-0.1726859957,
0.0554865785,
-0.3713873029,
0.4126961529,
0.5511806011,
0.360263139,
-0.3113697469,
0.0214237403,
-0.2440353483,
-0.1832826883,
0.3964924216,
-0.3946613371,
0.4142273962,
-0.2756410539,
0.0727040768,
-0.2830033004,
-0.4082487822,
0.6795526147,
0.4260719717,
0.7226722836,
0.0246289112,
0.5026158094,
-0.1279466301,
1.0167123079,
0.0204709545,
0.0189035907,
0.1846915334,
-0.3258752227,
-0.295427978,
0.3478222489,
0.7009257078,
0.1030559316,
0.3639561832,
-0.1331568211,
-0.1206766739,
0.436575979,
-0.2481672466,
-0.7469411492,
-0.5132286549,
0.2238198221,
-0.2381468117,
-0.134715423,
-0.3063063622,
-0.6551679969,
0.0064964932,
-0.5904696584,
0.0791767538,
-0.3783159554,
-0.0602620766,
-0.1800551862,
-0.3036108911,
0.0591826662,
0.2548629045,
-0.7983558774,
0.7260217667,
0.6772726178,
1.2705258131,
0.0914947763,
0.1787958741,
-1.1061863899,
-0.2340902537,
-0.2944207191,
1.1280635595,
-0.60309273,
-0.7102746367,
-0.115461953,
0.1537752748,
-0.0171943512,
-0.6990954876,
0.774745822,
-0.0527686141,
-0.0104367901,
-0.5241713524,
-0.4337241054,
-0.1846010536,
-0.1618478596,
-0.523720324,
0.844882071,
0.1954150647,
-0.6861239076,
0.4712159038,
-0.5279131532,
-0.6175009608,
0.063324824,
-0.5022987723,
-0.0690598711,
-0.0876405016,
0.0917967036,
0.1704444289,
-0.1912276596,
0.4700457752,
0.0044145607,
-0.0211411398,
-0.0795855597,
-0.4076422453,
1.2476180792,
0.1708593667,
-0.3482979536,
0.33569628,
-0.8817692995,
0.0427606143,
-0.0802217051,
-0.246710062,
-0.1505351514,
0.4287982583,
0.042229481,
0.2023232728,
-0.2410743982,
-0.81828475,
-0.1126790494,
-0.7980393767,
0.7796755433,
0.5860790014,
0.1130647361,
-0.0379924178,
-0.1321249157,
0.3131984174,
-0.0594912246,
-0.0339867957,
-0.5435414314,
-0.7626253366,
-0.6986244917,
-0.2462651283,
0.590141356,
0.644094348,
-0.0250311438,
0.5773225427,
-0.075814791,
-0.2284508348,
-0.1045155823,
-0.0902593806,
0.304214716,
0.5333994031,
0.2605086267,
-0.9828657508,
-0.822917223,
-0.712960422,
-0.222774595,
-0.3414901495,
-0.0397315137,
0.1976395994,
-0.0654674694,
0.1131533235,
1.3399319649,
-0.3424271643,
-0.1059380397,
-0.037120346,
0.107976079,
0.2019622326,
0.3705620766,
0.389994055,
-0.4512955248,
-0.647066772,
0.0338316374,
-0.6135934591,
-0.215163067,
0.2214596868,
0.4479493201,
-0.166809082,
0.5037727952,
-0.5001885295,
0.2145457566,
0.538086772,
-0.535867095,
0.3990983963,
0.090918459,
-0.1302200407,
-0.4867614806,
-0.0515266322,
0.0940127075,
-0.4618965387,
-0.9752271771,
-0.3834962249,
-0.5247794986,
-0.3377249241,
-0.4515827298,
0.125048846,
-0.5678714514,
-0.4697022736,
0.1019012928,
-0.0462786406,
0.019781094,
0.3254329562,
0.0465574823,
0.5726009607,
0.6078436971,
-0.2552331984,
0.3824630976,
0.1823601425,
-0.3050059676,
0.1107979417,
-0.8145254254,
0.4811182022,
-0.0994645879,
0.2228218913,
-1.3073582649,
0.0269686878,
0.1814176589,
-0.5081688166,
0.2887147367,
-0.453884542,
-0.478634119,
-0.281976223,
-0.0383871906,
0.2373836935,
0.6678397059,
-0.4014661312,
0.3985548019,
0.353187412,
-0.4167723656,
-0.0207779761,
-0.593639493,
0.288764596,
-0.2708409429,
-0.8454293609,
-0.0912467837,
0.2084179819,
-0.6559365988,
-0.0215372704,
-0.1647527367,
-0.0488963351,
0.0179902837,
0.3588084877,
-0.2743180096,
-0.3985353112,
-0.2101810127,
-0.1034811735,
-0.2467302531,
0.107911855,
-0.3315111399,
0.6376383305,
-0.0457580574,
-0.3340895176,
-0.4055152237,
0.3320242763,
0.3605527282,
-0.2785428762,
0.0733292922,
0.0355321504,
-0.1247361228,
0.0436676517,
-0.31337291,
-0.0856846347,
-0.5248702168,
0.1448297203,
-0.4668523967,
-0.8677724004,
0.3858979046,
-0.4958306253,
0.1219960451,
0.3135394454,
0.210771203,
-0.1214815155,
1.0101726055,
0.4251519144,
0.11075598,
0.5326363444,
-0.2363872677,
0.4583445489,
-0.5246081948,
-0.020075703,
-0.6759470105,
-0.2738673091,
-0.5695304275,
-0.5514160991,
0.0289652422,
0.2208785117,
-0.1158432886,
0.485947907,
-0.6470496058,
0.421795547,
0.4615286291,
-0.2051357627,
0.4855464995,
0.2716845274,
-0.1072935611,
0.0898800343,
-0.7250666022,
-0.35679847,
0.675694406,
0.4820179045,
-0.0573471673,
-0.1783637851,
0.393484503,
0.2397629023,
-0.003009344,
-1.1678981781,
0.6018647552,
-0.4110937715,
-0.0167502332,
-0.5167194605,
-0.2506840527,
-1.2189457417,
0.4074960053,
0.1273479611,
-1.0481197834,
0.5528233051,
0.1326817721,
-0.2350112647,
0.1930917352,
-0.7801439166,
0.878967762,
-0.2271652371,
-0.1461768001,
0.1864236444,
-0.734590292,
0.0381377079,
0.0712814331,
0.5119671822,
-0.211155653,
0.4338805079,
1.0004578829,
-0.336006552,
0.845344305,
-0.4573659599,
-0.0793805867,
0.7425810099,
0.1524100751,
0.5622552037,
-0.3189790249,
0.0796118081,
0.1347875744,
0.1322606802,
-0.2156146616,
-0.5586636662,
0.4861400723,
-0.7635881901,
-0.6695671678,
-0.3517389297,
-0.3572681546,
-0.6100639701,
0.0889167115,
0.1105938181,
0.8383927345,
-0.3110739291,
0.1048955992,
0.2062359005,
-0.1159204915,
0.5870744586,
0.2299185693,
-0.4668957293,
-0.4281747639,
0.8893663287,
0.5416807532,
0.3751855195,
0.0674026012,
0.4197297096,
-0.2962997854,
-0.3864418268,
-0.5638042688,
0.1414698958,
-0.6165239215,
0.1428503096,
-0.9667912126,
-0.4004884362,
-0.5741174221,
-0.0429808721,
-0.2768959999,
-0.5550845265,
0.1088034734,
-0.3372095823,
0.4236882925,
0.6921708584,
-0.1210846603,
0.3472433686,
-0.7359899282,
0.1183706149,
0.4605515301,
0.2001591921,
-0.1930366904,
-0.3369109035,
0.0867574885,
0.0505380929,
-0.304990083,
-1.2566285133,
0.4045767188,
0.2643516064,
0.1417103261,
0.4128466249,
-0.2869098783,
0.830078721,
-0.5474335551,
0.7544742823,
0.4206205606,
-1.093167305,
0.7521206737,
-0.4721968174,
0.2488694936,
0.4999170899,
0.2104087919,
-0.6367778182,
-0.4377225339,
-0.8828244209,
-1.1219427586,
0.6684474349,
0.3320239484,
-0.1564919949,
-0.0294880923,
-0.0642776564,
-0.3291579485,
0.0289134886,
-0.3024974763,
-0.1091978624,
-0.0280116741,
0.1293766499,
-0.3942732513,
-0.2740978301,
-0.1427904665,
-0.5906320214,
0.159597978,
0.0718787238,
0.2331649065,
0.4212356806,
0.216192767,
-0.388337642,
0.3192754388,
0.1037951857,
0.5048308372,
-0.2171034068,
0.4139773548,
0.1064202935,
-0.3412697613,
0.5019822717,
-0.1187687889,
-0.4373210967,
0.4522399902,
0.4925892949,
0.9866426587,
0.1237359643,
-0.7843779922,
0.387565732,
0.2079928368,
-0.3701070547,
-0.0473602675,
-0.0906873867,
0.4228330255,
0.035512507,
-0.1395819485,
0.2597630322,
0.3157216311,
-0.8892714381,
0.4944490492,
0.1888230145,
-0.7835164666,
-0.497770071,
0.2549426258,
0.2563940287,
-0.6992643476,
0.4757920206,
-0.1565326154,
-0.317815572,
0.7479202747,
0.7160688639,
1.0521948338,
-0.440361917,
0.0964112729,
0.4156028032,
0.1343135238,
-0.0420506299,
0.2616718113,
-0.3916863203,
-0.6679737568,
-0.8425691724,
-0.7376282811,
-0.4626678526,
-0.1074938625,
-0.5618758798,
0.3403166533,
-0.576864779,
-0.2779258192,
0.2299661189,
-0.2681899071,
-0.3970884979,
0.1812398136,
-0.1539430022,
0.8099147081,
-1.1007107496,
0.7932733297,
0.6773494482,
-0.0454735346,
-0.8687345982,
-0.1037430167,
0.144868508,
-0.4725984931,
0.8920254707,
0.1538237482,
-0.163413018,
0.2966126502,
-0.0249907281,
-0.9473192692,
0.6524968147,
0.4949816763,
-1.0184590816,
0.211134091,
0.2459865659,
0.689027667,
0.0126576498,
0.3534700871,
0.8151053786,
0.3928008974,
0.4075553119,
-1.1839575768,
-0.0580875203,
-0.2712197304,
-0.1261295229,
0.4179743528,
-0.5728452802,
0.6380186081,
0.0779318884,
-0.7022852898,
-0.429656744,
0.6223628521,
-0.029179642,
0.4140109122,
1.0331593752,
0.577750206,
0.7499839067,
0.0688325092,
0.7390825748,
-0.462372303,
0.1540299654,
1.2631686926,
-0.2825089395,
1.0270762444,
0.3311457634,
-0.7159938216,
0.3755599558,
0.8413414359,
0.1630128324,
0.2375941128,
0.6835260391,
-0.3647328317,
0.0312209688,
-0.5492864847,
-0.2012538016,
0.3748097122,
0.2973614931,
-0.2615588307,
-0.2530575991,
-0.0056340517,
0.0431481116,
-0.0112150609,
0.0211220216,
0.922015965,
0.3863698244,
-0.5496304631,
0.4864439368,
-0.3379810154,
0.1956848651,
-0.485714376,
-0.0647412166,
0.1616169363,
-0.0963189527,
-0.4006502032,
-0.6391637325,
0.6819003224,
0.1984148324,
0.127550289,
-0.5680308342,
0.7046257854,
-0.0998942181,
-0.4265160859,
0.800280273,
0.6209207177,
0.2350645363,
0.0434318148,
-0.4561428428,
0.2452920228,
0.0403577983,
-0.1220927462,
0.3572753668,
0.4115450978,
0.0273169205,
0.3237916231,
0.7359913588,
0.3293417096,
0.0424148738,
0.2955073118,
0.9020003676,
-0.4722925425,
-0.5349689722,
-0.9016650915,
0.3534613252,
0.1155572683,
-0.1193692461,
0.8937139511,
0.8727325797,
0.7179198861,
0.4227063656,
0.7527307272,
-0.1623050719,
0.3826693594,
-0.2464144677,
-0.0549908504,
-0.0922207683,
0.0961799175,
-0.442822665,
-1.2068090439,
-0.2458430529,
0.5534535646,
-0.2902337015,
-0.2720194161,
0.8072886467,
0.5142173171,
-0.0483883806,
0.3848656714,
0.40406093,
0.4497741461,
0.3568869233,
0.2267057747,
1.0554771423,
0.0000926929,
0.1914289296,
-0.2990839183,
-0.3331696987,
0.35024333,
-0.5508791208,
-0.4392359555,
-0.4838696718,
-0.3577483594,
-0.4291708171,
0.2221035659,
0.924233675,
0.5302844048,
-0.9988756776,
-0.6903835535,
-0.5847013593,
-0.2490774542,
-0.2522738576,
-0.22173208,
0.3460492194,
-0.481169641,
-0.5827596784,
0.9618698955,
0.5671547651,
-0.0337302536,
0.0031321906,
0.0481505245,
-0.15068762,
0.0135314846,
0.8236913681,
0.4536104202,
-0.6683769822,
-0.5070003867,
-0.0443127975,
0.4292866588,
0.5523154736,
1.1267299652,
-0.8586756587,
0.5893571973,
0.8433214426,
0.3621125817,
0.626912117,
0.3346091509,
0.6212927103,
-0.4616889656,
0.202037245,
0.3313893676,
0.2805371284,
0.2779267132,
-0.1798208952,
0.5953615308,
0.5772496462,
-0.5961504579,
-0.8622919917,
0.2933541238,
-1.0828902721,
-0.0847235173,
1.0499669313,
-0.3245633841,
0.0061393962,
-0.5469109416,
-0.3771647513,
0.4751955867,
-0.3978771567,
0.1237775385,
0.5874388814,
-0.6507350206,
-0.1458322853,
-0.6266287565,
0.5865322948,
0.4804587364,
-0.5253787637,
0.1983964145,
0.5116791129,
0.0935347304,
0.3768386841,
1.0463882685,
0.0256722402,
-0.2593795359,
0.3051550686,
-0.3452862203,
0.2601636052,
-0.4154410064,
-0.3883615732,
0.3861669898,
0.4051888287,
-0.0124119036
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12620v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12620v2 | What Makes Two Language Models Think Alike? | 2024-06-18T13:45:50 | 2024-06-24T06:34:35 | Jeanne Salle, Louis Jalouzot, Nur Lan, Emmanuel Chemla, Yair Lakretz | cs.CL | cs.CL | Do architectural differences significantly affect the way models represent
and process language? We propose a new approach, based on metric-learning
encoding models (MLEMs), as a first step to answer this question. The approach
provides a feature-based comparison of how any two layers of any two models
represent linguistic information. We apply the method to BERT, GPT-2 and Mamba.
Unlike previous methods, MLEMs offer a transparent comparison, by identifying
the specific linguistic features responsible for similarities and differences.
More generally, the method uses formal, symbolic descriptions of a domain, and
use these to compare neural representations. As such, the approach can
straightforwardly be extended to other domains, such as speech and vision, and
to other neural systems, including human brains. | [
-0.5500035286,
-0.5519962907,
0.5221884847,
0.1040695235,
-0.0766602457,
0.0802595764,
-0.1738014519,
-0.6387578249,
0.0568908378,
0.5025021434,
-0.4122287333,
-0.3371106684,
-0.7197733521,
-0.0118674273,
-0.1226105541,
0.6802257299,
0.0319514759,
0.4284747541,
-0.2095112205,
-0.3476456106,
-0.4066399336,
-0.6562079787,
-0.8119188547,
-0.6387808323,
0.3803558946,
-0.3903272748,
0.9068742394,
0.7215611339,
0.6943528056,
0.2874081433,
-0.1377377361,
0.18659769,
-0.2259714603,
0.0312258117,
-0.1178645641,
-0.5243797302,
-0.2373854965,
-0.0701707304,
0.5592876673,
0.8175836205,
0.0412667282,
0.4415718317,
0.3962804675,
0.6918268204,
-0.5042418242,
0.3233700097,
-0.8711183071,
0.2692424059,
0.1495951265,
-0.1021216288,
-0.4001039565,
-0.3531711996,
0.0190476347,
-0.3012861907,
0.1509134471,
0.047252167,
0.9929022193,
0.1334690005,
-0.2017423809,
-0.2646998465,
-0.7072921991,
0.7592971325,
-0.8432997465,
0.7296295166,
0.212956503,
0.3462155461,
-0.0450147539,
-0.1933733374,
-0.4760119319,
-0.2815967202,
-0.2899657786,
-0.1234411001,
-0.1904774904,
-0.1798391342,
0.1494958401,
0.0481787845,
-1.028524518,
0.326698035,
-0.4802780151,
-0.2869067788,
0.4493027329,
-0.1181778088,
0.2504544258,
-0.1342522651,
-0.3793654442,
-0.3201994002,
-0.8191629052,
-0.0210971404,
0.3636315465,
0.3333563805,
-0.0453301109,
0.3295467198,
0.2400053591,
0.4758504629,
-0.2714416087,
0.103168793,
0.4831392169,
0.2103665918,
-0.5081604719,
-0.1396803707,
0.6521344185,
0.4357377887,
0.4847429395,
-0.3444371223,
-0.3238586783,
0.183646962,
0.226311937,
-0.4802580476,
-0.2761772871,
0.091262199,
-0.7881017327,
-0.0528464392,
0.1165114343,
-0.4459704757,
-0.2856330276,
-0.6828889251,
0.6385353804,
-0.4056779742,
-0.3823842108,
0.0045724316,
-0.1831581593,
0.4900868237,
0.0756529868,
-1.0347150564,
0.5742785931,
1.2553416491,
0.8522443175,
0.0583646521,
-0.3853530586,
-0.07143379,
-0.0616536438,
-0.538787961,
0.5512459278,
-0.8748154044,
-0.2318391502,
0.0113847768,
-0.3189321756,
0.0987768173,
-0.9571940899,
-0.0484061837,
-0.4778566062,
0.1885647178,
-0.4403084517,
-0.6555094719,
-0.3662081063,
0.213635698,
-0.7116078138,
1.1584393978,
0.0734780431,
-0.7389369011,
0.5040415525,
-0.6524104476,
-0.181379348,
-0.3064653873,
-0.5872099996,
-0.4342711866,
0.3937185407,
0.2368914485,
0.654204905,
-0.1002310887,
-0.1858496964,
-0.396427393,
-0.3485760391,
0.1941601038,
-0.1163711101,
0.8191096783,
0.5422137976,
-0.2375394553,
-0.2276107073,
-0.8843670487,
0.0944601372,
0.3572132289,
-0.287089467,
-0.5427837968,
0.2661337852,
-0.2954306304,
0.202347517,
0.4714251161,
-0.4311489463,
0.2010742724,
-0.2312141955,
0.3758588433,
0.740596652,
-0.1908077896,
0.5353549123,
-0.2555424571,
0.2479755282,
0.2941033542,
0.1542249471,
-0.1272081286,
-0.6226251125,
-0.7924184203,
-0.0882189497,
0.2720026672,
0.6500102878,
-0.4034593999,
0.1444301307,
-0.1969253421,
-0.4682501853,
-1.0473217964,
0.0475450382,
0.6871497631,
0.1141160429,
0.396199286,
-0.6826803684,
-0.6183578968,
-1.2676440477,
-0.2682358921,
-0.2739328146,
-0.4265313447,
0.5575597882,
0.2662804425,
0.047121983,
0.5471554995,
-0.2303055078,
0.1570689082,
0.0074026133,
0.2905426025,
0.1552373767,
0.4201397896,
1.1740092039,
-0.5851763487,
-0.483581692,
0.4542571306,
-0.8864465952,
0.0249344166,
0.1037615314,
0.0975912511,
-0.0533295311,
0.4586816132,
-0.4272094369,
0.1786713898,
0.6399376988,
-0.0670393705,
0.3669727147,
-0.3603211939,
0.5015603304,
-1.0190412998,
-0.1781148612,
-0.1610701233,
0.0670429096,
-0.5984078646,
0.2665289342,
0.0340702869,
-0.1467905492,
-0.3879294097,
0.5587382317,
-0.6122401357,
-0.7284601331,
-0.1477355659,
0.0768152326,
0.1103739515,
0.726729691,
0.040640723,
0.848867476,
0.7423425317,
-0.6317843199,
0.0427695438,
0.071143426,
-0.6503587961,
0.3700733781,
-0.5283773541,
0.5432914495,
-0.2301656008,
-0.030147329,
-0.8538761735,
0.28266716,
0.1098324955,
-0.7973108292,
0.2179083228,
-0.1602854431,
-0.6084141731,
-0.2842094004,
-0.230170086,
0.257022202,
0.8554890156,
-0.2880319655,
0.610953331,
0.382381171,
-0.399751246,
-0.755392313,
-0.9985644817,
0.0043862737,
-0.1657772362,
-0.4909057021,
0.0403706059,
0.1942153722,
-0.4083138108,
0.1268573403,
0.1393618882,
-0.4047873914,
0.2240276635,
0.1985426694,
0.1769724637,
-0.8198392987,
0.1915990412,
-0.0113094477,
0.1820601672,
0.0584822446,
-0.5730369091,
0.5239307284,
0.1239878759,
-0.4605288506,
-0.481805861,
0.5808295608,
0.5198590159,
-0.513096571,
0.9339529872,
0.6644972563,
-0.1995849907,
-0.20608823,
-0.5149666667,
-0.3106028736,
-0.4224666357,
0.617572546,
-0.7570821047,
-0.8783178329,
0.7287642956,
0.0136078279,
0.4045220912,
0.2588888407,
0.8758304119,
-0.3828990757,
1.100723505,
0.9135665894,
-0.2722956836,
0.5555999279,
-0.1106194556,
0.2711651027,
-0.8864495754,
-0.2984627187,
-0.836989522,
-0.6777789593,
-0.3559843898,
-0.5257814527,
-0.0923203602,
-0.0917766839,
-0.3383049965,
0.7019907832,
-0.4942849278,
0.5873798728,
0.5144274831,
-0.1578413844,
0.0350730829,
0.1775405705,
-0.5494592786,
-0.1668507904,
-0.7802165151,
-0.8565002084,
1.215002656,
0.3761405647,
0.4473325312,
0.2066192627,
0.5534884334,
0.4106673598,
0.3475041389,
-0.3969300389,
0.5756616592,
-0.406667769,
-0.5759492517,
0.0849199444,
-0.4461093545,
-0.9180805087,
0.5218444467,
-0.3008098602,
-0.9047835469,
0.2076218724,
-0.0020458843,
-0.0486430787,
0.7769619823,
-0.824187696,
0.5671314597,
-0.10645926,
0.2657425702,
-0.3757856786,
-0.5517559052,
0.101482302,
0.0555489585,
0.2981691062,
-0.2613428831,
0.0803887546,
0.6512480974,
-0.0088684838,
0.5235807896,
-0.1165348589,
-0.0620470122,
0.2565765679,
0.4900102019,
0.0904193297,
-0.4867851436,
-0.3135344684,
0.5772989988,
-0.0738619938,
-0.5165629387,
-0.9164754152,
0.495528698,
-1.0885028839,
-0.4452517331,
0.1706600189,
-0.5932724476,
-0.1543880403,
-0.1406908333,
0.1150799692,
0.4349420965,
-0.4561206102,
-0.0360715576,
0.4255823195,
-0.1598541141,
0.2088041604,
0.4932587743,
-0.4754962325,
-0.0197091922,
0.5776199698,
-0.0223770253,
0.3927929103,
0.7359217405,
-0.1489603966,
-0.0711658299,
-0.6189442873,
-0.2926361859,
0.1929115951,
-0.7560561299,
0.1383094043,
-0.5513171554,
-0.3098723292,
-0.443787843,
-0.0678537264,
-0.4925977588,
-0.376401633,
0.0548783392,
-0.0211534761,
-0.0627514049,
1.181918025,
-0.0627082065,
0.2228064388,
-0.7257339358,
-0.0484431349,
0.3068535924,
0.1026576906,
0.28713274,
-0.670788765,
-0.4136923254,
0.1968888342,
-0.2400411814,
-0.7458224297,
0.1286824942,
0.3324912786,
0.7118238211,
0.5987468958,
-0.6369491816,
0.4013336003,
-1.00819242,
0.8456100821,
0.1135085523,
-0.8263702393,
0.4864266515,
0.1933820993,
0.0399971306,
0.3677911162,
0.5431135893,
-0.5631074905,
-0.5783830285,
-0.5727654696,
-0.1461848915,
0.3263984919,
0.3746934533,
0.3118856549,
-0.02352372,
0.422255367,
0.4289739728,
0.046206668,
-0.5812692642,
-0.2977415323,
-0.0027813036,
-0.202573061,
-0.0291722789,
-0.0813998654,
-0.0129723363,
0.074340418,
0.3398898542,
0.1556927115,
0.684181571,
-0.1216567457,
-0.1415247172,
0.1988644451,
0.2965450883,
0.4597146511,
0.5325989127,
-0.1605990529,
0.3302283585,
0.2158127725,
-0.260613203,
0.0486647151,
-0.4600027204,
-0.0502609611,
0.4776973724,
0.5646537542,
1.1114336252,
0.2228592634,
-0.3606460392,
0.3051057756,
0.0019119658,
-0.2979479432,
0.475068301,
0.2248941809,
0.1850467771,
0.5712300539,
0.0141688222,
0.3441831172,
0.0132926367,
-0.8536809683,
0.2630062997,
0.4026382864,
-0.3156088889,
-0.5361524224,
0.5465270877,
0.1339935213,
-0.655816257,
0.551392138,
-0.2460689098,
-0.531989038,
0.8917472363,
0.4293517172,
0.8997319937,
-0.3746220171,
0.0094065722,
0.3252213597,
0.4311730564,
0.1011517942,
0.1567051858,
-0.2370804995,
-0.9897467494,
-0.2559110522,
-0.6516404748,
-0.362873435,
0.0721727684,
-0.8132885098,
0.1618148237,
-0.6559429765,
-0.299615413,
0.3260796368,
-0.1984415948,
-0.8759747148,
0.0599534437,
0.6227651238,
0.7346228957,
-1.0587221384,
0.9172207117,
0.8028815389,
-0.1539404392,
-0.8034316301,
-0.0916625932,
0.1595859528,
-1.0995459557,
0.7920915484,
0.0189344715,
-0.0730778277,
-0.296851635,
-0.2549097836,
-0.7132460475,
0.9270429015,
0.574293673,
-0.6826612949,
0.0381793156,
0.2207623869,
0.6129405499,
-0.8604854345,
0.0830351636,
0.5289751291,
0.2115769684,
-0.1859318763,
-1.2051879168,
-0.3884350955,
-0.1155097336,
0.0998022035,
0.247566089,
-0.3914352953,
1.0415791273,
-0.3031745553,
-0.3411754072,
0.0686522871,
0.5332229137,
0.0509396419,
0.0486300066,
0.2747279704,
0.5517097116,
0.7746529579,
-0.0187375601,
0.9459175467,
-0.4054008126,
0.7186679244,
1.240224123,
-0.3490834534,
1.2060697079,
0.1689041704,
-0.7007175684,
0.650374651,
0.7002908587,
-0.2306539416,
0.5925225019,
0.0836603567,
0.2043158859,
-0.0178872123,
0.3276441991,
-0.5282128453,
0.4538955688,
0.1977523267,
-0.6214116812,
-0.2417650223,
-0.1084083915,
0.0845997408,
0.0643858463,
-0.331238687,
0.8308216929,
0.23844859,
-0.4819004834,
0.4911532402,
-0.0640549436,
0.4712280631,
-0.5427312851,
0.0866961554,
-0.2318935394,
0.0788128749,
0.0975988582,
-0.8924084306,
0.3379942179,
0.0962014794,
-0.2767733634,
0.0445403121,
0.4091405272,
-0.5003839731,
-0.4352166355,
0.6390438676,
0.700597167,
0.5069244504,
0.1014516875,
-1.1404883862,
0.1746930629,
-0.0261589438,
-0.0428452156,
0.2153367996,
0.4540390968,
0.0583058782,
0.6273972392,
0.3868454397,
0.3325177729,
0.400813967,
0.3560103476,
0.4166049361,
-0.4915424585,
-0.4338965118,
-0.9959099889,
-0.0076202806,
-0.0518911183,
-0.1444805861,
0.4775782228,
0.5851687789,
1.07987082,
-0.2200622112,
0.5701165795,
0.186542511,
0.4556015432,
-0.6843585968,
0.7623090148,
-0.6872999668,
0.3090664446,
-0.056252934,
-1.6108627319,
-0.2750083506,
0.7361300588,
-0.1549928635,
0.1745262891,
0.8343518972,
0.9900602102,
-0.3137490153,
-0.1355232894,
0.5872875452,
0.436022222,
0.1115208566,
0.796995461,
0.7633188367,
-0.2355777621,
0.228141129,
0.039011661,
-0.1203947663,
-0.1311414838,
-0.592872262,
-0.8939136267,
-0.7360303402,
-0.2979643345,
0.0686397925,
0.2166467011,
0.8368415833,
0.9124327898,
-0.9450230598,
-0.2019578367,
0.5051179528,
-0.0683183298,
-0.4406249821,
-0.0893359631,
0.4500055909,
-0.2448882163,
-0.7487886548,
0.182742551,
0.7517414093,
-0.0011659479,
-0.5809587836,
-0.0432822891,
0.0761112794,
0.6168970466,
0.5168634057,
0.0202038288,
-0.9146524668,
-0.5466396213,
-0.1682669669,
-0.3834736049,
0.5969461799,
0.995826602,
-0.7689297795,
0.2577376068,
0.4472129643,
0.7277772427,
0.1852718294,
-0.4606782496,
0.4101271331,
-0.6812999249,
0.4847744405,
0.0276822783,
0.5126613975,
0.4526708722,
-0.1051417589,
0.4852543473,
-0.0827852786,
-0.4581403136,
-0.469083637,
0.5268220901,
-0.9660039544,
-0.4834728241,
0.8437380791,
-0.3977499306,
-0.3006690443,
0.1167933047,
-0.0343769342,
0.0190935768,
-0.0457906425,
0.944319725,
0.9551489949,
0.0116044106,
-0.0128927436,
-0.6138203144,
0.2499141246,
0.4234851599,
-0.38119784,
-0.0962619931,
-0.0477687344,
0.5174623728,
0.1267215014,
0.2672837973,
-0.2224666774,
0.1843010932,
0.2917819023,
0.1609025151,
-0.0094127432,
-0.3087698817,
-0.2699962854,
0.0657621026,
0.0116156712,
-0.3047455251
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12618v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12618v1 | From Insights to Actions: The Impact of Interpretability and Analysis Research on NLP | 2024-06-18T13:45:07 | 2024-06-18T13:45:07 | Marius Mosbach, Vagrant Gautam, Tomás Vergara-Browne, Dietrich Klakow, Mor Geva | cs.CL | cs.CL | Interpretability and analysis (IA) research is a growing subfield within NLP
with the goal of developing a deeper understanding of the behavior or inner
workings of NLP systems and methods. Despite growing interest in the subfield,
a commonly voiced criticism is that it lacks actionable insights and therefore
has little impact on NLP. In this paper, we seek to quantify the impact of IA
research on the broader field of NLP. We approach this with a mixed-methods
analysis of: (1) a citation graph of 185K+ papers built from all papers
published at ACL and EMNLP conferences from 2018 to 2023, and (2) a survey of
138 members of the NLP community. Our quantitative results show that IA work is
well-cited outside of IA, and central in the NLP citation graph. Through
qualitative analysis of survey responses and manual annotation of 556 papers,
we find that NLP researchers build on findings from IA work and perceive it is
important for progress in NLP, multiple subfields, and rely on its findings and
terminology for their own work. Many novel methods are proposed based on IA
findings and highly influenced by them, but highly influential non-IA work
cites IA findings without being driven by them. We end by summarizing what is
missing in IA work today and provide a call to action, to pave the way for a
more impactful future of IA research. | [
-0.1553649604,
-0.5952814221,
0.3813036084,
0.4213907719,
0.103295289,
0.0695302039,
0.1248979792,
-0.9703173637,
0.6823058724,
0.3012065589,
-0.1376523972,
-0.1569910049,
-0.906052649,
0.2562153041,
-0.69030267,
1.0308494568,
0.1914077848,
-0.1492271572,
-0.2328420132,
-0.5275115371,
-0.573969543,
-0.4103490114,
-0.7382868528,
-0.2898795605,
0.7104687095,
0.1188352033,
0.5294860005,
0.3314552903,
0.6315851808,
0.1872522831,
-0.4671327174,
-0.0420358554,
-0.3426105678,
-0.0911321789,
-0.2930918634,
-0.6013706326,
-0.6594423056,
0.0599144734,
0.6391752958,
1.052811861,
-0.0357301496,
0.163932398,
0.2611704171,
0.5334817171,
-0.6279639602,
0.1666077673,
-0.3360454142,
0.0604297072,
-0.3159946203,
-0.4159592688,
-0.4217101634,
0.0678816587,
0.4314587116,
-0.4992804527,
-0.1531494409,
0.0918326154,
0.4068795145,
0.1989480108,
-0.5416665673,
-0.4807653427,
-0.9885119796,
0.9579489231,
-0.9152885079,
0.1052090079,
0.2408343554,
-0.0172060262,
-0.1537752599,
-1.1017259359,
-0.3484060764,
0.3135742843,
-0.5159447789,
0.1800986677,
-0.4749121368,
-0.145423308,
0.2416952699,
0.3297756314,
-0.1739962846,
-0.0117583396,
-0.5346862674,
0.2334013581,
0.6963108182,
0.2486804873,
0.3299874067,
-0.0050442582,
0.009259861,
0.0950399116,
-0.4338327944,
0.1887473762,
-0.0216186009,
0.1692264378,
-0.1261017919,
0.6687424183,
-0.0850955322,
0.4183394909,
-0.250097394,
-0.063148953,
0.1106640473,
-0.3533949256,
-0.1771395355,
-0.358745575,
0.5785861015,
0.1577953547,
-0.2370879501,
-0.3401494324,
0.0874662176,
-0.2801389098,
0.5192809701,
-0.4157435,
-0.2454248369,
0.4338278174,
-0.7105597854,
-0.0027302846,
-0.0446329936,
-0.920142591,
-0.5134190321,
-0.4799033403,
0.1771636307,
-0.2429955304,
-0.6707261205,
-0.1915246397,
-0.2656040788,
0.542694211,
0.4112565517,
-0.5398206711,
0.2540819347,
0.7828359008,
0.999322474,
-0.3238426745,
-0.2850404084,
-0.2633596659,
-0.2077550292,
-0.3286206424,
0.8363649249,
-0.6114336848,
-0.435303092,
0.1518693715,
-0.2222682685,
-0.4581288099,
-0.3645650744,
0.6412605643,
-0.5578804016,
-0.0596958995,
-0.045372162,
-0.5987936854,
-0.5199078321,
0.3346907198,
-0.6622263789,
0.7949929833,
-0.2105656415,
-0.7791009545,
0.4213635027,
-1.0503554344,
-0.3947292268,
0.1307142377,
-0.0302928574,
-0.105220437,
0.5211696029,
-0.0109268567,
0.15103513,
-0.1827014536,
0.2565994561,
-0.1924226284,
-0.1811764389,
0.3458462954,
-0.3025640547,
1.2013520002,
0.0166338608,
-0.4647253752,
-0.0295163244,
-1.1305869818,
0.1718284041,
-0.1214002818,
-0.1987687498,
-0.5464705825,
0.3369668424,
0.2954545021,
0.1337210834,
-0.0250684675,
-0.2437315732,
0.0465214178,
-0.5679083467,
0.2549023032,
0.3568857014,
0.0679328293,
0.4864687622,
0.0791561753,
0.9477207065,
-0.4799458981,
0.1546555609,
0.0948827341,
-0.670481205,
-0.9208695889,
-0.0862144679,
0.3443272412,
0.2959924936,
-0.5479127765,
0.3925109208,
-0.2099141777,
-0.6623573899,
-0.6128889918,
-0.1725191474,
0.2915919721,
0.4179902673,
0.5979405642,
-0.3983044028,
-0.6994984746,
-0.7575221658,
-0.7192946076,
-0.1957730204,
0.0862718523,
0.0401617698,
0.7701535225,
-0.2251285762,
1.0192112923,
-0.2707186341,
-0.4480557144,
-0.3145472407,
0.4533925951,
0.0107542537,
0.3277373612,
0.513207078,
-0.7706608176,
-0.5005791187,
-0.137791574,
-0.9264436364,
-0.0706421658,
-0.0802395493,
-0.0173035599,
-0.2614588439,
0.581653595,
-0.3094750047,
0.8716935515,
0.5962078571,
-0.6546682715,
0.4035767615,
0.2064908296,
-0.226770401,
-0.607165277,
0.7028951645,
-0.1113526896,
0.31468907,
-0.824429512,
0.1176227331,
-0.23791565,
-0.0196772609,
-0.2709516883,
0.6212595701,
-0.4014946222,
-0.1100969166,
-0.5157717466,
-0.2053678036,
0.1670276374,
0.2315643281,
-0.0733640119,
0.4460845292,
0.4882500768,
-0.6099927425,
-0.329095602,
0.3085322976,
-0.2495153248,
0.6387363076,
-0.8319945335,
0.1390516311,
-0.0145655945,
0.3379184008,
-0.4883874059,
0.0227079522,
0.3727726042,
-0.4520081878,
0.0493731499,
-0.1789954156,
-0.3134777546,
0.1881039888,
-0.0297850017,
0.5046550035,
-0.0267412122,
-0.3634335399,
1.322873354,
0.3907243013,
-0.0700504556,
-0.6992553473,
-0.6742036343,
0.2988850772,
-0.3410003185,
-0.4589415491,
0.1185563207,
0.0083220387,
-0.9547272921,
0.2414625883,
-0.1315172762,
-0.0656792074,
0.3810024261,
0.197218731,
-0.1552788764,
-0.1859680712,
-0.0092704026,
-0.0974992514,
-0.2758828402,
0.4476644695,
0.063740246,
0.2553634346,
-0.1972430348,
-0.317170471,
-0.3444855213,
0.6717219353,
0.291282475,
-0.4383125305,
0.9690212011,
0.3724602163,
0.001439343,
-0.2180721909,
0.1536584795,
0.142911911,
-0.3730325401,
0.155167833,
0.0256055463,
-0.4656454027,
0.4891650677,
-0.0529270619,
0.7467967272,
0.8140941858,
0.1006146297,
-0.2310514003,
0.8255636692,
0.9623891115,
0.3123682439,
0.5572072864,
-0.4531690478,
0.6102880836,
-0.9915809035,
-0.238436088,
-0.6900108457,
-0.5723817945,
-0.524061501,
-0.1999516785,
0.3316984177,
0.013402516,
0.5355822444,
0.0230308063,
-0.3752221465,
0.1366294175,
0.6003113985,
-0.2891732752,
0.5001994371,
-0.4387625754,
0.5756975412,
-0.1790068895,
-0.5152045488,
-0.3225403428,
1.3098797798,
0.3592692614,
0.3512995541,
0.2807780802,
0.4579238594,
0.4436610043,
0.5684772134,
-1.1779745817,
0.3249002695,
0.2573516369,
-0.7919226885,
-0.1019594893,
-0.3581110835,
-1.1650818586,
0.5523144603,
-0.344296068,
-0.5565698147,
0.4326911569,
0.0561493561,
-0.0920453519,
0.0367422625,
-0.7160716653,
0.4573954344,
-0.0856404379,
0.0506902225,
-0.2499604225,
-0.6589973569,
0.1585832685,
0.0984620303,
0.7102668285,
0.1472313404,
0.1266944855,
1.2190393209,
-0.2289499342,
0.9118798375,
-0.1823630631,
-0.0789332837,
0.3239307702,
-0.2221673727,
0.3404943049,
-0.0322074592,
-0.0437081866,
0.4868600667,
0.1441418082,
-0.4641010165,
-0.8050891161,
0.4084626734,
-0.2912380993,
-0.4378302097,
-0.8683325648,
-0.5145811439,
-0.316624999,
0.1894224137,
0.0147804748,
0.4510756731,
-0.06302654,
0.3668369055,
0.273437649,
0.0366567485,
0.4886628687,
0.384795934,
-0.1232751384,
-0.279212445,
0.6052998304,
0.3457682431,
-0.0917162746,
0.2851375639,
0.1360291392,
0.0181590859,
-0.8431190252,
0.0686732978,
0.168109566,
-0.699422121,
0.0239033252,
-0.7544870973,
0.0098907417,
-0.372962445,
-0.1111308187,
-0.4333939552,
-0.4434638619,
-0.2192151248,
-0.004720638,
0.1855400652,
0.7941166162,
-0.2769348621,
0.4554153383,
-0.5918117166,
0.0384673327,
0.0448664278,
0.2272700518,
0.4846818447,
-0.5196739435,
-0.749777019,
-0.1930961758,
-0.1508361399,
-0.5431147814,
0.4184303284,
0.1730819494,
0.3374097645,
0.3157509267,
-0.0241553802,
0.8183730841,
-0.2189672589,
0.7969391942,
0.1094611734,
-0.8446983099,
0.499209404,
0.0229605492,
0.1572438776,
0.7338851094,
0.272100389,
-0.4075176716,
-0.284570545,
-0.890517652,
-1.3364218473,
0.6734796762,
0.4081745148,
0.0098851556,
0.3300319016,
0.1192891002,
0.083575137,
-0.0568326935,
-0.787212193,
-0.5746894479,
0.1400143653,
0.0647849515,
-0.0280032698,
-0.0774987638,
-0.4271445572,
-0.3387367129,
0.5072994232,
-0.200162366,
0.2310539633,
0.0835253671,
0.0807486922,
0.1828123629,
0.2372530401,
0.1530031413,
1.1545848846,
-0.1955123991,
0.1212888807,
-0.1294535547,
-0.4582248032,
-0.4956242442,
0.1122573689,
-0.5196325183,
0.0645746365,
0.9730846882,
0.53425771,
0.1096941978,
-0.6953186989,
0.2247312665,
-0.1694688052,
-0.0049381382,
-0.5249698162,
-0.0437047333,
-0.1929107159,
0.2749527991,
0.6083006859,
0.4934572875,
0.5505865812,
-0.8024027348,
-0.10242825,
0.222488448,
-0.5632106066,
-0.5078786016,
0.3781176209,
0.1990675926,
-0.3082426488,
0.228158012,
0.2746573985,
-0.2135249823,
0.5831128955,
0.2720195651,
0.762442112,
0.366242826,
0.0500812419,
0.1747751832,
0.3187773824,
0.2029648274,
0.0702920407,
0.1366439462,
-0.328884095,
-0.7201138139,
-0.5720303655,
-0.541310966,
0.2880491018,
-0.9579529166,
-0.0538734756,
-0.2965085506,
0.0220478922,
0.3705708385,
0.0259220563,
-0.59595716,
0.3945785463,
-0.6447870135,
0.7781523466,
-0.850397706,
0.3493478894,
0.878625989,
-0.4865761101,
-0.5583201647,
0.4103700817,
0.2037928253,
-0.5705855489,
0.2397711724,
-0.0433231667,
-0.0510448404,
-0.0902873129,
-0.6863798499,
-1.0849992037,
0.8905339241,
-0.2133442611,
0.0211856682,
0.0795014203,
-0.2094886303,
0.9758320451,
-0.2481582314,
0.3141788542,
0.7489123344,
0.5381096601,
-0.1018037125,
-0.7034659386,
-0.1831496954,
-0.3712733388,
-0.3221949339,
0.2653350234,
-0.4814730585,
0.4196805954,
0.1591170132,
-0.2654410005,
-0.1729964465,
1.0028493404,
0.0207060091,
0.8526838422,
0.2841196358,
0.3681009114,
0.5522545576,
0.2191990018,
0.9994674921,
0.1484112591,
0.0942960829,
1.124475956,
0.1182023808,
1.0243241787,
0.8852875829,
-0.2763439119,
0.4255178571,
0.1509941816,
0.1449332386,
0.3820284605,
-0.2320697159,
0.0398271233,
0.186735034,
-0.3607873917,
-0.2736529708,
0.7335873842,
0.6215455532,
-0.3997316957,
0.052243568,
-0.1246865988,
0.1824852228,
0.1217288077,
-0.1917950064,
0.7830519676,
0.3689866662,
-0.6485689282,
0.1454628706,
-0.0908754319,
0.6417013407,
-0.5492397547,
-0.2410495132,
-0.2452656478,
0.0044048037,
-0.4696098864,
-0.919498682,
1.0523194075,
0.0463695899,
-0.0592953935,
-0.404592216,
0.6329420805,
0.1064259782,
-0.2608840466,
0.6249926686,
0.8478719592,
0.1412211508,
0.0507230721,
-0.4747977257,
-0.0052379942,
0.0793489367,
-0.3354272544,
0.5283368826,
0.5932552218,
0.2460924238,
0.338246733,
0.581523478,
0.2028316408,
-0.0716825128,
-0.1607125103,
0.6017410159,
-0.6501879692,
-0.0764693469,
-0.602235198,
0.7927291393,
-0.1775838137,
-0.90167135,
0.9162822962,
0.2740087211,
0.4370926917,
0.3133701086,
0.6922428608,
-0.7596981525,
0.6025381088,
-0.4152081311,
0.5906863213,
-0.7890954018,
0.3940404058,
-0.1748437881,
-0.7468747497,
-0.5395970941,
0.2575181127,
-0.2581832111,
-0.1018120199,
0.6988336444,
0.1115201563,
-0.0188899618,
0.1586239785,
0.0513385981,
0.2145229727,
0.4765483737,
-0.3399408758,
0.6996675134,
-0.5884665251,
0.630215466,
-0.329767704,
-0.4510574937,
-0.199336648,
-0.74887532,
-0.659362793,
-0.5651562214,
-0.2943170965,
-0.3645109534,
-0.354085356,
0.3804963827,
0.3310276568,
-0.8486213684,
-0.076717183,
-0.1762745231,
0.1724233627,
-0.660700202,
-0.3628347814,
0.6377899647,
-0.1693641096,
-0.7264783978,
0.5940194726,
0.1356819123,
-0.4570794404,
-0.0992937833,
0.1120665371,
-0.447366029,
0.1081767157,
0.8688485026,
0.6955697536,
-0.5647848845,
-0.101412341,
0.0430250987,
0.4118959904,
0.110662505,
0.8907607198,
-0.3482960761,
0.4920968711,
0.4253854156,
0.6696764231,
0.2727863193,
-0.1011504754,
0.7726735473,
-0.6892126203,
-0.2247445583,
0.6496232152,
0.3555252552,
0.0898284912,
-0.1082461476,
1.0386298895,
0.1416491717,
-0.5665938258,
-0.7421045303,
0.102876693,
-1.0427622795,
-0.2904860973,
1.0304000378,
-0.3568310738,
0.0445449315,
-0.5176447034,
0.0216031652,
-0.1438721567,
-0.3774526119,
0.9540907741,
0.6686552167,
-0.7809610963,
-0.2464980781,
-0.5293972492,
0.4788348377,
0.6494173408,
-0.9099724293,
-0.0445839502,
0.3588532507,
-0.2792512476,
0.7518280149,
0.6757250428,
-0.0890122876,
-0.0447037183,
0.291780293,
-0.0187137965,
0.4589134157,
-0.4352859557,
-0.2866240144,
0.1096367911,
0.2170138061,
0.2977043688
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12614v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12614v1 | EUvsDisinfo: a Dataset for Multilingual Detection of Pro-Kremlin Disinformation in News Articles | 2024-06-18T13:43:22 | 2024-06-18T13:43:22 | João A. Leite, Olesya Razuvayevskaya, Kalina Bontcheva, Carolina Scarton | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.LG | This work introduces EUvsDisinfo, a multilingual dataset of trustworthy and
disinformation articles related to pro-Kremlin themes. It is sourced directly
from the debunk articles written by experts leading the EUvsDisinfo project.
Our dataset is the largest to-date resource in terms of the overall number of
articles and distinct languages. It also provides the largest topical and
temporal coverage. Using this dataset, we investigate the dissemination of
pro-Kremlin disinformation across different languages, uncovering
language-specific patterns targeting specific disinformation topics. We further
analyse the evolution of topic distribution over an eight-year period, noting a
significant surge in disinformation content before the full-scale invasion of
Ukraine in 2022. Lastly, we demonstrate the dataset's applicability in training
models to effectively distinguish between disinformation and trustworthy
content in multilingual settings. | [
-0.2411090285,
-0.5860531926,
0.3745902181,
0.1884152442,
-0.542365551,
0.458247602,
-0.2153115124,
-0.1956316829,
0.0619735979,
0.1222857311,
-0.5515916944,
-0.7436254621,
-0.690843761,
0.2729120553,
-0.6161885858,
0.9930009246,
0.001955145,
0.5694125295,
-0.2335569263,
0.0070176655,
0.0104020257,
-0.3561482728,
-0.0266341809,
-0.0917454362,
0.1414274126,
0.6921956539,
0.2804248035,
0.470361203,
0.4250733554,
0.2260375321,
-0.0459657274,
-0.0675403103,
-0.4549493492,
0.1487834603,
-0.218297556,
-0.3692569435,
0.0730228201,
-0.0670723915,
0.5343142748,
0.2230359763,
-0.6152130365,
0.3089830577,
-0.0126073239,
0.6895807385,
-0.4463041723,
-0.167955786,
-0.5072140098,
-0.0145219965,
-0.5087791085,
-0.0624786876,
-0.4260540903,
-0.3388538361,
-0.0900183469,
-0.6775417924,
0.2270632982,
-0.3981988132,
0.5909591913,
-0.0346186124,
-0.6397600174,
-0.5595144629,
-0.7070356011,
0.7875928879,
-0.0823562294,
0.6909213066,
0.4425548017,
0.2197396755,
-0.2063979357,
-0.5257264376,
-0.5106160641,
0.1049121693,
0.0765918642,
0.2601335943,
-0.6092583537,
-0.5875657797,
-0.1405456662,
0.0567829125,
-0.7306630015,
-0.000692144,
-0.6300618649,
-0.5852065086,
0.4492493272,
-0.3317361772,
0.1283402145,
-0.2705267966,
-0.5494831204,
0.0642478615,
-0.8946313858,
-0.0629827976,
0.908283174,
-0.0249374602,
-0.358695209,
0.2866880298,
-0.4225970507,
0.6162542105,
0.0651713237,
-0.5437804461,
0.4216988087,
-0.5839819908,
0.0548882,
0.6140211225,
0.4426061213,
0.4850747883,
0.1014471799,
0.0084999735,
0.053530816,
0.0887281969,
0.2515557408,
-0.7724374533,
-0.2440676242,
0.1723939627,
-0.3198606968,
-0.5898582339,
0.3782971799,
-0.9984586835,
-0.4767128527,
-0.180136174,
0.0262810607,
-0.2544184625,
-0.3374975622,
0.3122212291,
-0.2089475393,
-0.5304227471,
0.1510353833,
-0.5518851876,
0.0471956469,
0.3919083774,
0.4845716357,
0.1791114509,
-0.1229529604,
-0.6952436566,
-0.0147654023,
-0.3277773857,
0.8158653975,
-0.6112372279,
-0.2114535123,
0.2579938471,
0.5857794881,
0.719414115,
-0.2424128503,
0.717063725,
-0.5824044943,
0.1605654955,
-0.3231800199,
-0.2516185641,
-0.1810186803,
0.2256589085,
-0.7445144057,
0.8340713382,
-0.0520367511,
-0.9177108407,
0.7757635713,
-0.3429320157,
-0.373935014,
0.0498096608,
-0.1448081732,
-0.4611831605,
-0.1715890467,
0.0561266989,
0.5611328483,
-0.0455251113,
0.3303478956,
-0.1966238618,
0.0317680798,
0.2632853389,
-0.509347856,
0.6692567468,
0.4902122617,
-0.2561741471,
-0.2525956631,
-0.9310161471,
-0.5884082913,
0.122972548,
-0.4147306383,
-0.8937937617,
0.0747969821,
-0.0533105284,
0.301833123,
0.2689446211,
-0.9471484423,
-0.0745900944,
0.1100075841,
0.2262650877,
0.4559038579,
0.2119918317,
0.4573260546,
-0.0447697267,
0.5350263119,
0.749135375,
0.4379486442,
-0.3192254603,
-0.1500977576,
-0.3521186709,
-0.1049109846,
0.2287080735,
0.5432580709,
-1.0422415733,
0.2228896022,
-0.0901472792,
-0.7055799961,
-0.3441380858,
0.0563344322,
0.2869436443,
0.5255396962,
0.1873438507,
0.2702053189,
-0.8606677055,
-1.0061426163,
-0.1043386534,
0.011440739,
0.3074064851,
-0.407319814,
0.6809575558,
0.1506667435,
0.4603771567,
-0.2478645444,
-0.0528336093,
-0.093027398,
0.1291210949,
0.1539332122,
0.3078559637,
0.6667833924,
-1.382973671,
-0.7889963984,
0.0007294867,
-0.4305326939,
0.3837628067,
-0.1083542556,
0.2057714015,
0.319108218,
0.4591830075,
-0.2246945798,
0.2662699819,
0.7877339721,
-0.5569518805,
0.3781409264,
-0.3260790408,
0.5882960558,
-1.5337657928,
-0.1051483378,
0.2145871967,
-0.3343115449,
-0.7456995249,
-0.4027225673,
0.3622317314,
0.1897129714,
-0.8438277841,
-0.0142484801,
-0.3966610432,
0.0546272881,
0.2554648817,
0.2424272299,
0.0208850224,
-0.2102947384,
-0.3014520407,
0.6294974685,
1.007784009,
-0.5535882711,
0.7225534916,
0.2493892908,
-0.8108923435,
0.8339318633,
-0.3259210289,
-0.3258831799,
-0.4089278579,
0.1165677235,
-0.875136137,
-0.271525085,
0.3083644509,
-0.5552675128,
0.0461307541,
-0.4730965793,
-0.7087523341,
-0.1492121071,
-0.369242996,
-0.0117546739,
0.2038320601,
-0.4494585097,
-0.2572482526,
0.6561053991,
-0.2422550619,
-1.0669841766,
-0.5439899564,
-0.042145092,
-0.453138262,
-0.1998490095,
0.3212169707,
-0.0372077264,
-0.4663017988,
0.1316058934,
-0.1527808607,
-0.1089784428,
0.1699548066,
-0.0033500078,
0.0369986296,
0.1670936942,
0.3610692918,
0.0008329423,
-0.0497665592,
-0.1652686298,
-0.1558908075,
0.4737523198,
-0.0121087581,
-0.3130876124,
-0.7290071845,
0.3503024876,
0.7528916001,
-0.2089569718,
0.8162423372,
0.6979748607,
-0.3048705757,
-0.1505385786,
-0.1817923039,
-0.1656657308,
-0.3614214957,
0.5288219452,
-0.1079012752,
-0.4507540464,
0.5274428129,
-0.0812044069,
0.0085498374,
0.5088137388,
0.404497236,
-0.1222351417,
0.8397964835,
0.7394611239,
-0.194637537,
0.3018528819,
-0.2792668343,
-0.1585728973,
-0.0521406569,
-0.7653315067,
-0.6103290915,
-0.1728282869,
-0.5822249055,
-0.2616358399,
0.0056246282,
0.0823064074,
0.1089725569,
0.3052204251,
-0.3499684036,
0.559884727,
0.1987134963,
-0.3482681513,
0.4173139036,
0.5030358434,
-0.1609547883,
-0.2660560906,
-0.4858178794,
-0.347361654,
0.9940925837,
0.294947654,
0.981167078,
0.344263047,
0.3310780227,
0.6925691962,
0.1101795435,
-0.4166387916,
0.0401835069,
-0.353282392,
-0.6774085164,
-0.3141110539,
-0.2029059231,
-0.8632980585,
-0.0997730643,
-0.0593644194,
-0.6618258953,
0.4174487293,
-0.0959580466,
-0.1207361519,
0.5524253845,
-0.1581217051,
0.5081425309,
-0.102474466,
0.0230803136,
-0.5460207462,
-0.3354460895,
0.2709289789,
-0.3075505793,
0.463278532,
-0.3529896438,
-0.1403956711,
0.6773056984,
0.1450698227,
0.622459054,
-0.2658638656,
-0.362616539,
0.1012942195,
-0.1178359613,
0.4426687658,
0.5378027558,
0.0273859147,
0.1938907504,
0.0352904871,
-0.3128082156,
-0.0162504856,
0.8413971663,
-0.6965113878,
-0.1188494638,
-0.5260465741,
-0.2080327123,
0.2290175557,
0.2833753526,
0.3717702329,
0.8080281615,
-0.7070143819,
0.7065216899,
0.8338884115,
-0.0146057,
0.502148807,
0.9604916573,
-0.2069073766,
-0.4976369143,
0.8649367094,
0.3587552905,
-0.0343335941,
0.4132012725,
-0.1784450412,
-0.4504711926,
-0.4213198125,
-0.8478470445,
0.017805405,
-0.800591588,
-0.2812357247,
-0.2493781149,
0.1142693013,
-0.1749689728,
0.2194470614,
-0.58766222,
-0.2717811465,
-0.2663463652,
-0.2674257159,
0.6264135838,
0.8905407786,
-0.3764819205,
0.1549773216,
-0.7095071077,
0.3867761195,
-0.0532792397,
0.3671872914,
-0.758605361,
-0.4678021669,
-0.670324564,
0.4086648822,
-0.4340491593,
-1.2512022257,
0.3115342259,
0.0590107515,
0.8757788539,
0.6093068719,
0.2332955301,
0.1927152872,
-0.462149173,
0.8783122897,
0.2251667678,
-0.6108427048,
0.5571699142,
-0.5919312835,
0.1373899728,
0.4990726709,
1.1246590614,
-0.6989321709,
-0.2280207872,
-0.8199884295,
-0.6080988646,
0.759999454,
0.0052668983,
0.1535091698,
-0.0156485941,
0.0768053383,
0.5058820248,
0.3112851083,
-0.4455524981,
-0.6369157434,
-0.2766774297,
-0.0871194005,
-0.1769683659,
-0.5076401234,
-0.5484215021,
-0.0937301144,
0.8597270846,
0.0240157042,
-0.0104325823,
0.3365062475,
-0.2901592255,
-0.1567283422,
0.3275702298,
1.0359524488,
1.1428409815,
0.0700537115,
0.2721943259,
-0.1251093,
-0.8770766854,
0.3986940384,
0.1106524318,
-0.1733798087,
0.6119084954,
-0.0835110396,
0.4484467208,
-0.0639432743,
-0.6095301509,
0.6418759227,
-0.2837534249,
-0.6559241414,
-0.7282995582,
-0.5974066854,
0.2072931975,
0.2532561421,
0.7208196521,
0.0363981687,
0.094964534,
-0.425080061,
0.5756543875,
-0.0070701269,
-0.6273707151,
-0.7579174042,
0.3420890868,
0.3392631114,
-0.0477324501,
0.2993095219,
-0.093811661,
-0.3861297667,
0.6170368791,
0.2491895258,
0.3593410552,
-0.6418555975,
1.0022563934,
0.3117925823,
0.3736966848,
0.0495674163,
0.607665658,
0.0657936335,
-0.6496661901,
-0.2434094846,
-0.3378509581,
0.108171694,
0.6886886954,
-0.816660583,
0.3196076453,
0.0125224078,
-0.0714576393,
0.0461323373,
0.0515016839,
-0.4267093539,
0.201732263,
0.317366004,
0.8667423725,
-1.1181966066,
0.8125343323,
0.8208806515,
-0.0285808183,
0.1274661422,
-0.0595090501,
0.4145227671,
-0.2359969765,
0.5408965349,
0.1386178732,
-0.0078132953,
-0.1675940603,
-0.1967523843,
-0.863758862,
0.9987610579,
0.6646050215,
-0.6344904304,
0.5625080466,
0.2725042105,
0.0809457377,
-0.302113384,
-0.5388854146,
0.5761817098,
0.5760393739,
-0.4396393597,
-0.7433900237,
-0.2459019274,
-0.2685231864,
-0.5935198069,
0.4518942833,
-0.7782289386,
0.5928496718,
0.0348581821,
-0.3076247871,
-0.2749121189,
0.2800463438,
-0.1979802102,
0.2872072458,
0.7278854847,
0.4731342793,
0.7049365044,
-0.1156452,
0.5205728412,
-0.5755397081,
0.2937996089,
0.8591088057,
0.1570514292,
0.6420584321,
0.6747016311,
0.0779099539,
0.5324600935,
0.7096365094,
-0.1362937093,
1.1043906212,
0.0088869352,
-0.4627534747,
-0.0890949517,
-0.3828614354,
-0.4311548173,
0.6898878813,
0.4551030695,
-0.296087116,
-0.6018790603,
0.3549945652,
0.2366910428,
0.3096594214,
-0.1014980078,
0.7078274488,
-0.3304314315,
-0.3213791847,
0.2879390419,
0.1744212657,
0.3797113597,
-0.6618099213,
-0.0921012983,
-0.1725304425,
0.3510271609,
-0.1368138343,
-0.9103396535,
0.3379897177,
0.17493774,
-0.2625072598,
-0.3745990694,
0.6525105238,
-0.5751540661,
-0.4976122975,
0.2807578146,
0.5982324481,
0.2209883481,
0.1196209863,
-0.6706027389,
0.0617195554,
0.1097421721,
-0.2348090112,
0.2865486443,
0.651615262,
0.0551401041,
0.5828000307,
0.6464152932,
0.2049682736,
-0.2355606705,
0.2172924876,
0.9343041778,
-0.1259256154,
-0.6032986045,
-0.9531292915,
0.7180966735,
-0.3487225473,
-0.3214551508,
1.1020362377,
0.8272849917,
1.1047619581,
-0.0649457872,
0.9307118058,
-0.0219263528,
0.6168782711,
-0.3593465984,
1.153788805,
-0.691465497,
-0.0620271564,
-0.0529155508,
-0.3713540733,
-0.1249187589,
0.1629255861,
-0.0297417454,
-0.4639818072,
0.4582875669,
0.7355583906,
-0.1889090687,
-0.0804595873,
0.4486175776,
0.2213747501,
0.0930743292,
-0.0258025061,
0.9679401517,
-0.2552359104,
0.8358056545,
-0.6555310488,
0.1487232596,
-0.3568327427,
-0.8604235649,
-0.6928866506,
-1.0642821789,
-0.1303819567,
-0.1021708325,
0.2104913741,
0.4761423469,
0.6763372421,
-0.7290537953,
0.046340812,
0.0952008143,
0.1650403738,
-0.0585389994,
-0.1071957052,
0.176318422,
0.0917337313,
-0.703407824,
0.4773228765,
0.171767965,
0.2145013064,
-0.6540313959,
0.0146801295,
-0.3464501202,
-0.0831597224,
0.3681356907,
0.0233849622,
-0.5294556618,
-0.1395729631,
0.1342216879,
0.0532450601,
-0.1422147155,
0.5923745632,
-0.5122330189,
0.567992568,
0.4400373995,
0.0684592575,
0.1884716451,
-0.1261259168,
0.4430742264,
-1.006865859,
0.7463825345,
-0.0325865373,
0.3826189041,
0.5516280532,
-0.5668719411,
0.1358929127,
0.3516685069,
-0.253552407,
-0.9259369373,
0.1480816305,
-0.4626103938,
-0.4059216976,
1.0131218433,
-0.2383181602,
-0.2440214306,
-0.6435924172,
-0.0128793633,
0.2252298146,
-0.6260236502,
0.8414154649,
1.016094923,
0.4761893153,
-0.0061558671,
-0.9209041595,
0.7613592148,
-0.0930148289,
-0.7512483001,
0.2005455196,
0.4824970067,
0.4718695879,
0.350718379,
0.1657189429,
-0.2094774991,
0.5934981704,
0.1897820979,
0.0157266911,
-0.1413255781,
-0.8651639223,
-0.2523288429,
0.0891289115,
-0.4969083071,
-0.3661454022
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12611v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12611v1 | Rapid Language Adaptation for Multilingual E2E Speech Recognition Using Encoder Prompting | 2024-06-18T13:38:58 | 2024-06-18T13:38:58 | Yosuke Kashiwagi, Hayato Futami, Emiru Tsunoo, Siddhant Arora, Shinji Watanabe | cs.SD | cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS | End-to-end multilingual speech recognition models handle multiple languages
through a single model, often incorporating language identification to
automatically detect the language of incoming speech. Since the common scenario
is where the language is already known, these models can perform as
language-specific by using language information as prompts, which is
particularly beneficial for attention-based encoder-decoder architectures.
However, the Connectionist Temporal Classification (CTC) approach, which
enhances recognition via joint decoding and multi-task training, does not
normally incorporate language prompts due to its conditionally independent
output tokens. To overcome this, we introduce an encoder prompting technique
within the self-conditioned CTC framework, enabling language-specific
adaptation of the CTC model in a zero-shot manner. Our method has shown to
significantly reduce errors by 28% on average and by 41% on low-resource
languages. | [
-0.2376678437,
-0.665004909,
0.2915592492,
0.3116911054,
-0.1537895054,
-0.1140994057,
-0.4085683525,
-0.238014102,
0.0750024244,
0.0675595328,
-0.5461761951,
-0.166476056,
-0.3533764184,
0.5942953825,
-0.0902385712,
0.6571859717,
-0.0686077401,
-0.0830007717,
0.0441578887,
-0.2792546153,
-0.8674173355,
-0.4309127033,
-1.3352293968,
-0.0217715297,
0.723667264,
0.5464403033,
-0.1076860353,
0.3415760696,
-0.3145926595,
0.2210682333,
0.0632892027,
-0.0205022935,
-0.1502089202,
0.3895989656,
0.0465083718,
-0.4730754197,
-0.1228764057,
-0.416452378,
0.5528935194,
0.393949151,
-0.2856130302,
-0.0253426172,
0.2532775104,
0.44617486,
-0.7731303573,
0.1780904979,
-0.557284236,
0.1200739294,
-0.0399385318,
-0.4910693467,
-0.8502525091,
-0.0281576142,
0.1649133712,
-0.460026443,
0.2465812415,
-0.2199225128,
0.2668693066,
0.290584743,
-0.3745193779,
-0.2230946571,
-0.5376279354,
0.4275953472,
-0.4070180058,
0.9098761678,
0.4598980248,
0.3592022359,
0.2347863764,
-0.3757335544,
-0.5556530356,
-0.2345365733,
0.1575074345,
0.588439405,
-0.114213869,
-0.0389255211,
0.325250417,
-0.5221498609,
-0.8708360791,
0.3815892935,
-0.3257478774,
-0.4342820644,
-0.014256807,
-0.1941164285,
0.2547592819,
0.085660331,
-0.1864718497,
0.0578753576,
-0.6720257998,
0.3894895017,
0.3117038906,
0.4260416329,
-0.4586152136,
0.1144624278,
0.0481443703,
0.8446718454,
0.4015815556,
0.1181248501,
0.2902287841,
-0.0991261154,
-0.0020430395,
0.7298861742,
0.4675952494,
0.14355506,
0.3734555244,
0.006048556,
-0.0178977791,
-0.1120854095,
-0.1725084484,
-0.7628894448,
-0.0048896139,
0.4040546715,
-0.1371389329,
0.3900847733,
-0.1727477163,
-0.6758660078,
-0.0774988458,
-0.1781836003,
0.2839030623,
-0.0104253925,
-0.2823019624,
0.1473304033,
-0.1608310789,
0.5407156944,
0.297499299,
-0.9876240492,
-0.0071327584,
-0.0213083606,
0.9323365092,
0.0075989738,
-0.3654415011,
-0.8528571725,
0.3009726405,
-0.366404891,
0.919485867,
-0.345494777,
-0.4707924724,
0.1874290258,
0.3252931237,
-0.3200058937,
-0.3762961626,
0.2252630293,
-0.5635533929,
0.3951341212,
-0.2923516929,
-0.1845547557,
-0.0777798966,
0.2282128334,
-0.4934350252,
0.8510279655,
-0.0387510657,
-0.5761809945,
0.3052881956,
-0.6340155005,
-0.4396986961,
0.1086220518,
-0.1297919154,
-0.0388177186,
-0.0569094792,
0.6378077865,
0.353472352,
-0.2315726876,
0.0683872551,
-0.1599405706,
0.0587442406,
0.0442116521,
-0.6506446004,
0.7901393771,
0.3934360147,
-0.1739717871,
0.0645020008,
-0.5583462715,
0.1643740237,
0.1876557171,
-0.3498673439,
-0.0634020269,
-0.2658416927,
0.126194492,
0.3481494486,
0.2837315202,
-0.4586470723,
-0.1071225554,
-0.4399819076,
0.5163401365,
0.6774905324,
0.0537753813,
0.325127095,
-0.0088718217,
0.5079604983,
0.1868756711,
-0.0404377542,
-0.7535684705,
-0.3998053968,
-0.8933188319,
-0.0923943743,
0.3020555377,
0.987260282,
-0.9462325573,
0.3828095496,
-0.0782221407,
-0.1036368161,
-0.4983053803,
-0.101738885,
0.4226932228,
0.4917671978,
0.3107880056,
-0.3058902025,
-0.5086733103,
-0.6572783589,
-0.1874830425,
-0.3437686563,
-0.167959854,
0.2158503085,
0.0347775593,
0.0830893293,
0.7819155455,
0.0774232298,
-0.1497477591,
-0.4264044464,
0.0292564873,
0.2739807069,
0.3835813999,
0.5586299896,
-0.5150063634,
-0.7671180964,
0.0254682414,
-0.6756919026,
-0.3474570513,
-0.4517810643,
0.2756299675,
0.4492972493,
0.7295427322,
-0.1550946236,
0.1616157293,
0.4761916697,
-0.2409608662,
0.2299991995,
-0.5869088769,
0.2669484019,
-1.1948059797,
-0.0567931011,
-0.0986887664,
-0.2079702318,
-0.966879189,
-0.4131973982,
0.2242836505,
-0.3009128273,
-0.7137778401,
0.6915752888,
-0.7051315904,
0.031044852,
-0.1767285019,
0.208234638,
-0.0796119943,
0.4450621605,
0.3570100367,
0.8634802103,
0.9105221629,
-0.7987511754,
0.1980050206,
0.2167262882,
0.1475814879,
0.7023653984,
-0.7800934911,
0.5962594151,
-0.4345287383,
0.1736248881,
-0.8372272253,
-0.1597391665,
0.1553178281,
-0.6245322824,
0.673636198,
-0.2404351234,
-0.21739842,
-0.2243198007,
0.0099560209,
0.6288200617,
0.4525936544,
-0.9948804975,
0.5497708321,
0.1282923222,
-0.4299439192,
-0.2178072482,
-0.753896296,
0.1392797083,
-0.0521868058,
-0.4454478621,
0.2254518718,
-0.3829353154,
0.3153452873,
-0.4074930549,
0.0281189363,
-0.2392295301,
-0.1871088296,
-0.1134128794,
0.0038503339,
-0.1236153096,
0.1346692592,
0.08303608,
-0.3588424921,
-0.1307594627,
-0.4371021092,
0.5348234773,
0.0883759037,
-0.3591138721,
-0.7973743081,
0.5593495965,
0.382959038,
-0.4743391275,
0.392143935,
0.6455222368,
-0.5508238673,
-0.1241893768,
-0.5541772246,
-0.4227848947,
-0.4521431923,
0.4926742017,
-0.5641142726,
-0.9062746763,
0.5658935905,
0.1602548063,
-0.0807403028,
0.1467182636,
0.776533246,
0.1996678263,
0.9894966483,
0.4668174982,
-0.1091387719,
0.63199085,
0.1450124532,
0.1959483027,
-0.7088834047,
-0.293413043,
-0.7524663806,
0.2443752289,
-0.4422816634,
-0.2872681618,
0.5243948698,
0.0840461627,
-0.311109215,
0.3705409467,
-0.3555981219,
0.521833837,
0.2918726206,
0.1237728745,
-0.1850202084,
0.164275825,
-0.1142502874,
-0.0265310314,
-0.9162958264,
-0.0047732131,
0.8165228963,
0.1917431206,
0.397326529,
0.1894105226,
0.6664530039,
0.1988448501,
-0.2432913035,
-0.7891035676,
0.1785982847,
-0.0189966131,
-0.4502744079,
-0.1861067116,
-0.1877883822,
-0.887521565,
-0.0163239427,
0.1126023531,
-0.8561369181,
0.5719985962,
0.2898895442,
-0.6899352074,
-0.044951126,
-0.8240617514,
0.8072469831,
-0.2680753469,
-0.246470511,
-0.0615620576,
-0.5992164612,
-0.21242401,
-0.2900652587,
0.2902775407,
-0.0547220446,
-0.0983054116,
0.702873826,
0.079119958,
0.8393368721,
-0.5188264251,
0.1054489762,
0.5848478675,
0.1191863269,
0.7114754915,
-0.0151084168,
-0.1128709614,
-0.0249414444,
0.0310972948,
-0.4400587678,
-0.6310665011,
0.478523016,
-0.6882982254,
-0.4585964978,
-0.2373114824,
-0.1806381643,
-0.3947295845,
-0.0914176553,
0.3426410854,
0.6721561551,
-0.0299004912,
0.0282418802,
0.6402187347,
-0.4381595254,
0.9269216657,
0.7578542233,
0.1868223846,
-0.5368469357,
0.8462098241,
0.1233265847,
0.3664672673,
0.4111473858,
0.2101176083,
-0.7082459331,
-0.4397950768,
-0.7919157147,
0.1240387782,
-0.797519207,
-0.0904257521,
-0.6215156317,
-0.1184482202,
-0.5344033837,
-0.3689917028,
-0.2329690754,
-0.2786819637,
-0.4346672893,
-0.0375015773,
0.3008874953,
0.2720231712,
-0.0141866682,
0.4278205633,
-0.9840307832,
0.1672162116,
0.4813045859,
0.1244505718,
-0.1861369759,
-1.0235378742,
-0.2572617233,
-0.2247026265,
0.119835563,
-1.2080930471,
0.3597362638,
0.6974859238,
0.6498267055,
0.3924758732,
0.1849372834,
0.7831527591,
-0.7674418688,
0.8376292586,
0.590904057,
-0.9686338305,
0.6866680384,
-0.1210958585,
0.6704315543,
0.2955570817,
0.2884761095,
-0.9045526385,
0.0793546811,
-0.1834352463,
-0.7622036934,
0.7698918581,
-0.1953224689,
0.1102895439,
-0.2559276521,
0.3504929841,
0.0243350584,
-0.2715784907,
-0.7197721601,
-0.0658540279,
-0.4078265727,
-0.3277903497,
0.0362807289,
-0.4021181464,
0.0700767264,
-0.0406566672,
0.5697866082,
-0.6021031141,
0.5034394264,
0.4663061798,
-0.2805862725,
0.0368829258,
0.702254355,
0.6213883162,
0.3388252258,
0.206790626,
0.0841756761,
0.7001750469,
-0.059431009,
0.4335352182,
0.0242618099,
-0.0507751368,
0.02539929,
0.2085103095,
0.9348935485,
0.0800907239,
-0.4030483067,
0.4223659337,
-0.0982543677,
-0.0513800532,
-0.3604738116,
-0.3293557465,
-0.0686512142,
0.0640155748,
0.2565216124,
-0.171010673,
0.0343148485,
-0.2664658129,
0.1432173848,
0.0120677622,
-0.6430304646,
-0.5733995438,
0.7114043236,
0.3961424828,
-0.2230987102,
0.5856409073,
-0.2690668106,
-0.4788708091,
0.6362987757,
0.9467898607,
1.2295644283,
-0.8888103962,
-0.0028190543,
0.8499822617,
0.244904846,
0.071390003,
0.4133606851,
-0.1598411202,
-0.8125772476,
-0.3629094958,
-0.3821152151,
-0.0949269086,
-0.236430198,
-0.7204771638,
0.3316092193,
-0.359122932,
0.0487285964,
-0.2984750271,
-0.6045132279,
-0.7261793613,
0.0478111394,
0.3715477288,
0.8022927642,
-0.6648554206,
1.1654495001,
0.4260891974,
-0.2214320004,
-0.7976169586,
-0.17279917,
0.2477876246,
-0.8025299907,
0.5983374715,
0.4085536897,
-0.2520015538,
0.2895844877,
-0.0939958692,
-0.6519713402,
0.8568847775,
0.4855269492,
-0.951399982,
0.2230712771,
0.0099749202,
0.2802605033,
-0.4333929718,
0.5792549849,
0.4623874724,
0.4938191772,
0.0512819961,
-1.1773602962,
-0.0113665937,
-0.081785053,
0.088631995,
0.0334905498,
-0.4302696884,
0.5148034692,
-0.5371764302,
-0.4522785544,
-0.2696008682,
0.4449394941,
0.1834873408,
0.2319598794,
0.7393522263,
0.1502134353,
0.592784524,
0.0764234439,
0.5362214446,
-0.6359416842,
0.0792514384,
1.0953714848,
-0.5304585695,
1.0247930288,
0.5393202305,
-0.1562003791,
0.2339279652,
0.9771844745,
0.2178425938,
0.6206822991,
-0.3180647492,
-0.5059627295,
-0.3897418678,
-0.4133650661,
-0.3892662823,
0.4991269708,
0.2883711755,
0.0156660732,
-0.3024410605,
0.20198448,
-0.0741435587,
-0.1852125078,
-0.359919697,
1.0195856094,
0.071368061,
-0.5921722054,
0.7528471947,
-0.2213842124,
0.5698478818,
-0.7027030587,
0.0401352383,
-0.0827083811,
-0.0986268371,
-0.1898929179,
-0.3513713777,
0.2192177773,
0.1394473016,
-0.283510983,
-0.2443158031,
0.4829749763,
-0.8510915041,
-0.1909144521,
0.5842870474,
0.6147561669,
0.2463577688,
-0.0977072939,
-0.7459949255,
-0.1644235551,
0.0505892932,
-0.0142290909,
0.2828783095,
0.3350358605,
0.0685208812,
0.4176680446,
0.8300912976,
-0.1361101717,
0.223715052,
0.6083482504,
0.4368804395,
-0.5716609955,
-0.7850933075,
-0.7047364116,
0.4505033493,
0.2959768176,
-0.155729562,
0.5218403935,
0.410387516,
0.9495677352,
-0.2345405072,
0.7781298161,
-0.0334958732,
0.2666945755,
-0.688380003,
0.6112008095,
-0.486938715,
0.0617971122,
0.3175416291,
-0.6074756384,
-0.2999920845,
0.4965679944,
0.1574027687,
0.1622055322,
0.8346301317,
1.0197074413,
0.3375805318,
-0.0035532825,
0.7122950554,
-0.0096528586,
0.2642112672,
0.7348420024,
0.6333471537,
-0.1842746139,
0.571698308,
-0.0151530951,
-0.2805039287,
-0.0026428935,
-0.9330729842,
-0.8023989797,
-0.7013547421,
-0.4018436968,
-0.3149678707,
0.3017156124,
1.3069957495,
0.6170844436,
-1.0945507288,
-0.2906239927,
0.0314530358,
-0.196840629,
-0.2891441286,
-0.1656170338,
0.2979623675,
-0.5460289717,
-0.7377943397,
0.7096543908,
0.4832946062,
0.2306758761,
-0.0264104661,
-0.3272763491,
0.0999572948,
-0.156908825,
0.6292677522,
0.5707457066,
-0.7769651413,
-0.40091905,
0.070513308,
0.3091963828,
0.2074413151,
0.8730837107,
-0.8008040786,
1.0110965967,
0.4802166522,
0.6234081984,
0.2939434648,
-0.5307698846,
0.4650110602,
-0.6528172493,
0.4657995403,
0.1169063076,
0.514667213,
0.4500118196,
-0.218056649,
0.0398796685,
0.2981423736,
-0.5120840073,
-0.4503288567,
0.4502469897,
-1.0257077217,
-0.0459059849,
1.0605401993,
-0.3618843257,
-0.3068069518,
-0.4724118114,
-0.321723491,
0.3290374279,
-0.6368560791,
0.3364598453,
0.4255556166,
-0.1439363062,
-0.6548326015,
-0.5488327146,
0.2161500007,
0.3173129857,
-0.8001067042,
0.1893231273,
0.3017612696,
0.3603928387,
-0.1350428909,
0.7808437347,
0.0357680619,
0.5394578576,
-0.0293363873,
0.3819662929,
-0.0899357945,
-0.579403162,
-0.9024580121,
-0.0325006954,
0.2502094507,
-0.2497110069
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12608v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12608v1 | Bridging Local Details and Global Context in Text-Attributed Graphs | 2024-06-18T13:35:25 | 2024-06-18T13:35:25 | Yaoke Wang, Yun Zhu, Wenqiao Zhang, Yueting Zhuang, Yunfei Li, Siliang Tang | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Representation learning on text-attributed graphs (TAGs) is vital for
real-world applications, as they combine semantic textual and contextual
structural information. Research in this field generally consist of two main
perspectives: local-level encoding and global-level aggregating, respectively
refer to textual node information unification (e.g., using Language Models) and
structure-augmented modeling (e.g., using Graph Neural Networks). Most existing
works focus on combining different information levels but overlook the
interconnections, i.e., the contextual textual information among nodes, which
provides semantic insights to bridge local and global levels. In this paper, we
propose GraphBridge, a multi-granularity integration framework that bridges
local and global perspectives by leveraging contextual textual information,
enhancing fine-grained understanding of TAGs. Besides, to tackle scalability
and efficiency challenges, we introduce a graphaware token reduction module.
Extensive experiments across various models and datasets show that our method
achieves state-of-theart performance, while our graph-aware token reduction
module significantly enhances efficiency and solves scalability issues. | [
-0.1953683943,
-0.760584712,
0.417222321,
-0.0271999296,
-0.173615247,
0.3230163455,
0.0815111771,
-0.7457267642,
0.2199625075,
0.2636566162,
-0.256883055,
-0.6812074184,
-0.4698831737,
-0.1345130652,
-0.2490981966,
0.9582518935,
-0.4166409671,
-0.2354176491,
-0.6191195846,
-0.2506369948,
-0.4411545992,
-0.6089673042,
-0.836574614,
-0.4549029768,
0.8832669258,
0.1966021657,
0.4102376699,
0.7698630095,
0.4302795529,
0.3242879212,
-0.2470070124,
0.5172145963,
-0.4201765358,
-0.0828875154,
-0.2557681203,
-0.2889648974,
-0.6678407192,
-0.0804447383,
0.9066306949,
0.9339247346,
0.2284613103,
0.1314100921,
0.1522311717,
0.2674980462,
-0.5444859862,
0.6304646134,
-0.4781131148,
0.0146786859,
-0.1591378003,
-0.041003786,
-0.5200306773,
-0.0514510274,
-0.0784328803,
-0.6849817038,
0.1179906279,
0.0912779048,
1.0502616167,
-0.0479040667,
-0.7464163899,
-0.2687494159,
-0.3142968118,
0.4104556441,
-0.4309725165,
0.047953546,
0.4003311992,
-0.0476061702,
0.1613609344,
-1.1137588024,
-0.1636344492,
0.2800571322,
-0.7553089261,
-0.0073934323,
-0.3754369318,
0.1850782186,
-0.1631323844,
0.4598474503,
-0.3447279632,
0.0302013662,
-0.2018949538,
-0.5466625094,
0.3241270781,
0.2232655436,
0.3494012952,
-0.6693075299,
-0.4053582251,
0.1994829327,
-0.40577811,
0.2497832328,
0.2627337277,
0.6289435625,
-0.2320096195,
0.1887841672,
-0.0644012764,
0.702057004,
-0.1551661789,
0.0949121863,
0.4295746982,
-0.5850387812,
-0.0891592056,
-0.0477409735,
0.7635202408,
0.0169460252,
-0.0491809845,
-0.6436793804,
0.021822162,
0.0874657929,
0.0247927383,
-0.973089397,
-0.1072746813,
0.2372190356,
-0.4151147902,
-0.2782438397,
0.133938998,
-0.2129910737,
-0.3138297796,
-0.1769707501,
0.3592576683,
-0.4911847115,
-0.0724305511,
-0.1306603998,
-0.4277777076,
0.0399004966,
0.2311292887,
-0.5988543034,
0.3074094951,
0.711578548,
1.3144843578,
0.0959045887,
-0.401365608,
-0.6447447538,
0.7133153677,
-0.0489477776,
0.7846992612,
-0.7869930863,
-0.3418096304,
-0.180934459,
0.1150951907,
-0.1632351875,
-0.2950134873,
0.3891964853,
-0.3691373765,
-0.1922770441,
-0.2742455006,
-0.389590323,
-0.2198011279,
0.4369047582,
-0.7908434272,
1.2203491926,
0.137528494,
-1.2402883768,
0.1960840076,
-0.6509699821,
-0.9009420872,
-0.0128021641,
-0.1424536258,
-0.3097304404,
0.0577725731,
0.4645369053,
0.6369432211,
0.1091407314,
0.1803368479,
-0.1114555076,
-0.406776458,
-0.1546748579,
-0.290247649,
0.404748112,
0.1441767663,
0.1779937297,
0.1935672164,
-0.6824687123,
-0.1839723289,
-0.045775,
-0.2797752917,
-0.633864522,
0.0394092388,
0.0257253721,
0.17692554,
0.2867681682,
-0.5761641264,
0.4066208005,
-0.4830439985,
0.9035949111,
0.7491740584,
0.0729648918,
0.7825201154,
-0.1341860145,
0.1265463978,
0.1981530637,
-0.0099317906,
-0.6011283994,
-0.4330764115,
-0.4101481438,
-0.395713836,
0.4601974487,
0.4562993646,
-0.8223097324,
0.1529602706,
-0.5510808229,
-0.4184411466,
-0.3285176754,
-0.0985648781,
0.2137017101,
0.6998869777,
0.3009412885,
-0.3102957904,
-0.4268826842,
-0.5793489814,
-0.404487133,
-0.2041402012,
0.0346353501,
0.5929806828,
0.5337535143,
-0.3765195012,
1.39584589,
-0.6340082288,
-0.4832609296,
-0.2404499948,
0.5430426002,
-0.0195203349,
0.5750802159,
0.4999468625,
-0.9557667971,
-0.504447341,
0.550280273,
-0.6260869503,
-0.0167911965,
-0.087750338,
-0.1810372025,
-0.1754234433,
0.4104980528,
-0.605209589,
0.6234140992,
0.4454255104,
-0.2913823128,
0.1819778681,
-0.3318607211,
0.0953041986,
-1.3246905804,
0.1633532345,
-0.1355196685,
-0.6267378926,
-0.5720123649,
0.0929947644,
0.1314270645,
-0.2871727645,
-0.0453668907,
0.80962497,
-0.5099347234,
-0.0349993035,
0.1517830491,
0.4898070991,
0.4074494541,
0.4346795678,
-0.2828862369,
0.7195119858,
0.5756140947,
-0.385828495,
0.2335813195,
0.1824380606,
-0.00109772,
0.6009138823,
-0.4897425473,
0.0596646219,
-0.4443944693,
0.4754271209,
-1.1471625566,
-0.4657545388,
0.1728687882,
-0.5909315944,
0.3223367631,
-0.262750715,
-0.5984838605,
-0.1989519745,
-0.2827294767,
0.7075589895,
-0.0611259304,
-0.5263211727,
1.2075090408,
0.3612627983,
-0.1369455904,
-0.5129060149,
-0.9067872167,
0.2755950689,
0.1332601458,
-0.75628227,
0.6889533997,
0.272513777,
0.0839921162,
0.2226434499,
-0.2316852212,
-0.180079028,
-0.06265641,
0.3482665718,
-0.0958110392,
0.0891024843,
0.4503201842,
0.2198008001,
-0.4070324004,
-0.0648261085,
-0.4753072262,
0.6483219862,
-0.1642980278,
-0.2611707449,
-0.3917382658,
0.5969776511,
0.1890582591,
-0.5549278855,
0.687759757,
0.8128550053,
-0.3732076287,
-0.0540281087,
0.0115407975,
0.2780939937,
-0.4626712203,
0.5114805698,
-0.4378455281,
-1.0931835175,
1.0019946098,
-0.4592215121,
-0.2063742876,
0.297819227,
0.0398662835,
-0.2561304867,
0.9262140393,
0.5310904384,
-0.249629274,
0.5810321569,
-0.586065948,
0.4469854236,
-0.8641418815,
-0.296698302,
-0.5081999302,
-0.4479896724,
-0.3501420617,
-0.7978569269,
0.1472320855,
0.197066918,
-0.2342766374,
0.1641939729,
-0.4335553348,
0.6201931834,
0.216649577,
0.2337106764,
0.4607176781,
0.0737442449,
-0.1882074475,
0.071274288,
-0.7803866267,
-0.1978234947,
0.683858335,
0.2255154848,
0.7272747159,
-0.0410411283,
0.684263289,
0.3861837089,
0.3854623735,
-0.8848549128,
0.4157334864,
-0.1796787083,
-0.3560144007,
-0.0096519934,
-0.8815068007,
-1.0126190186,
0.3347293139,
0.0713395774,
-1.0087981224,
0.0575668514,
0.0723938271,
0.179820627,
0.6318485141,
-0.8067514896,
0.9426982999,
0.2383815199,
-0.1878583729,
0.056116648,
-0.6078454852,
0.0349437669,
0.2143062651,
0.6329857707,
0.1042280421,
-0.1387143135,
0.4188679159,
-0.5604243279,
1.1010037661,
-0.0821974054,
-0.1474520266,
0.365039736,
-0.0755579546,
0.8029925227,
0.1578768194,
0.0461988524,
0.3396033943,
-0.3562749028,
-0.5300904512,
-0.4262071252,
0.771869421,
-0.7308036089,
0.0024693101,
-0.1778162122,
-0.9145824909,
-0.1176651493,
0.2862224877,
0.1268249601,
1.068066597,
-0.0365123004,
-0.0299521163,
0.3603493869,
0.1655320078,
0.572551012,
-0.3025844395,
-0.2915748954,
-0.7073882222,
1.0005013943,
0.3775418103,
0.2801273763,
0.6672520638,
0.0848132223,
-0.1393055618,
-0.3556596339,
-0.2497394532,
0.2731787264,
-1.0378917456,
-0.3594042063,
-0.6586121321,
-0.2453821898,
-0.3835355937,
-0.3528940678,
0.0585776828,
-0.2754816413,
-0.2829280198,
-0.245045498,
0.3327146471,
0.7282939553,
0.0110095246,
0.7530676723,
-0.753700316,
0.2023934871,
0.2011245638,
0.5654697418,
0.4676656425,
-0.044838313,
-0.5807322264,
-0.1789294332,
-0.0628415868,
-0.7320722938,
-0.1163920015,
0.078716889,
0.3891858459,
0.220664233,
-0.0152651845,
1.0648705959,
-0.5163676143,
0.6923214793,
0.1220648587,
-1.2344328165,
0.4344615638,
-0.4379933178,
0.3457981944,
0.3577999175,
0.2942386866,
-0.7052718401,
-0.4375160635,
-0.5397745371,
-1.2265053988,
0.7385538816,
0.2271663398,
0.3749015927,
0.0140954992,
0.6460072398,
-0.117954053,
0.1443872303,
-0.9983135462,
-0.2881584466,
-0.0222657453,
-0.3569546938,
0.342377156,
0.14274472,
-0.0577465184,
-0.5018669367,
0.3562102318,
-0.5132474899,
0.063867487,
0.2808520198,
-0.3860892057,
0.3349848986,
0.0690452904,
-0.09306667,
0.6705282927,
0.0235636644,
0.4631806314,
0.1600001901,
-0.5664439797,
-0.1754699647,
0.0358298048,
-0.2863228619,
0.1270106882,
0.799352169,
0.8387537003,
0.3518267572,
-0.162607789,
0.4780224264,
-0.0581272021,
0.0765658244,
0.4738592505,
-0.1765296906,
0.2865481973,
-0.0682181641,
0.350507468,
0.3345614374,
0.1033245474,
-0.5489695072,
0.1512167752,
0.4125059843,
-0.5224704742,
-0.256983608,
0.4753883779,
0.3637454808,
-0.1989016384,
0.1643070728,
-0.2938808501,
-0.4299857318,
0.5205096006,
0.6117872,
0.5950186849,
0.0936289877,
0.4715364873,
0.4456370473,
0.1988370568,
0.482619971,
0.0161454752,
-0.5512098074,
-0.532315731,
-0.6300028563,
-0.4562423527,
-0.2763751447,
-0.4964341819,
-0.5946189165,
-0.0598190166,
-0.3466433883,
-0.3452412486,
-0.06031055,
-0.0517117791,
-0.3603939414,
0.0100549208,
-0.0583438575,
0.8433977365,
-0.8776783347,
0.6198068857,
0.7990834713,
-0.5404675603,
-0.7632117867,
-0.0099506499,
-0.4883527756,
-0.6016307473,
0.492916882,
0.4641368687,
-0.256698519,
0.1738325506,
-0.5882425308,
-0.7402675748,
1.2205473185,
0.3925183117,
-0.0275519304,
-0.220148623,
0.3741185963,
0.149308756,
-0.4626014233,
0.1888689995,
0.3346039951,
0.4754299819,
0.2931630611,
-0.6764656901,
0.026184909,
-0.2023971975,
0.3382268548,
0.5609509349,
-0.6654574275,
1.1597582102,
0.0195497572,
-0.4246535599,
-0.149200663,
0.6462130547,
-0.1852663904,
0.3256962299,
0.1967600584,
0.7405818105,
1.1049021482,
-0.3343045712,
1.0448366404,
-0.2433157414,
0.7151118517,
1.0572189093,
-0.0429238752,
0.7127811313,
0.4380499423,
0.0151750492,
0.9521163702,
0.6191974282,
0.4722406566,
0.3183061182,
-0.0084178187,
-0.2472806275,
-0.3183450997,
-0.408230871,
-0.2537749112,
0.2081930041,
0.2713330984,
-0.2017828524,
-0.5962576866,
-0.1179315671,
0.3667085469,
0.0352615565,
-0.6839545965,
0.7828359008,
-0.1014571711,
0.0638780147,
0.1624292731,
0.0715542659,
0.4820162356,
-0.7757194042,
0.01029485,
-0.1571511477,
0.1830555499,
-0.4853030443,
-0.7998864055,
0.3419699073,
-0.140424937,
-0.4580312967,
-0.2807693779,
1.0065011978,
-0.3097712398,
-0.4688617289,
0.4794276655,
0.2067884207,
-0.2336248606,
-0.0734278932,
-0.3854033947,
0.0410930663,
-0.4256606698,
0.0841177851,
0.2689159214,
0.8762248158,
-0.1064906716,
0.4516082108,
0.6025284529,
0.0031107094,
-0.2383713126,
0.2162763923,
1.1639053822,
-0.6479278207,
-0.8351775408,
-0.8664007783,
0.7496342659,
-0.6215134263,
-0.2470019758,
0.7380123138,
0.7010800242,
0.8171610832,
0.4609233737,
0.8350752592,
-0.0668657944,
-0.1909520328,
-0.3687152565,
0.7792808414,
-0.566100955,
-0.0593148097,
-0.3721170127,
-0.5806886554,
-0.470135361,
0.4890230894,
-0.2951388061,
-0.0384865887,
0.6090102792,
0.3690346479,
-0.1699857712,
-0.1448405087,
-0.090378128,
0.2250863761,
0.3990235627,
0.516877234,
0.6052623391,
-0.6032301188,
0.5994957685,
0.1288328618,
-0.164766565,
0.1404169947,
-0.9977551699,
-0.8962169886,
-0.5312416553,
-0.0730278939,
-0.1524239928,
-0.4252467155,
0.3960354626,
0.7311384082,
-0.4622909725,
-0.0338911004,
-0.0579347014,
0.4854903519,
-0.0089836344,
-0.2252999097,
0.5515473485,
-0.5714297295,
-0.4637851119,
-0.0194100589,
0.7359600067,
-0.1501660347,
-0.1093118489,
-0.0425692983,
-0.2475968897,
0.1668609381,
0.736143291,
-0.1233874708,
-0.4866995811,
-0.5680986643,
-0.2764337659,
-0.1741279513,
0.515440762,
0.967572093,
-0.8689005375,
0.4150471687,
0.6608103514,
0.6680217981,
0.5570992827,
0.2728264332,
0.1639769524,
-1.4732090235,
0.3326087296,
0.0387122631,
0.4445640445,
0.4190544486,
-0.2520343065,
0.4234832227,
0.4135486782,
-0.2474537194,
-0.8452824354,
0.4504940212,
-0.8974663019,
-0.3672037423,
0.7972503304,
-0.2385769039,
-0.4410990179,
-0.1243380979,
-0.4222170413,
0.2876003981,
-0.2355680764,
0.1242338046,
0.7951600552,
-0.1063295305,
0.1654310971,
-0.1207927614,
0.0958521068,
-0.2295245081,
-1.0264728069,
0.3795392811,
0.4076224267,
-0.0575591736,
0.3922836483,
0.870842278,
0.0889070183,
-0.169844389,
0.2169289142,
-0.0535612181,
-0.1946420223,
-0.3659942746,
-0.1445491612,
0.4206480682,
-0.2548002005,
0.0127132498
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12606v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12606v1 | Low-Redundant Optimization for Large Language Model Alignment | 2024-06-18T13:34:40 | 2024-06-18T13:34:40 | Zhipeng Chen, Kun Zhou, Wayne Xin Zhao, Jingyuan Wang, Ji-Rong Wen | cs.CL | cs.CL | Large language models (LLMs) are still struggling in aligning with human
preference in complex tasks and scenarios. They are prone to overfit into the
unexpected patterns or superficial styles in the training data. We conduct an
empirical study that only selects the top-10\% most updated parameters in LLMs
for alignment training, and see improvements in the convergence process and
final performance. It indicates the existence of redundant neurons in LLMs for
alignment training. To reduce its influence, we propose a low-redundant
alignment method named \textbf{ALLO}, focusing on optimizing the most related
neurons with the most useful supervised signals. Concretely, we first identify
the neurons that are related to the human preference data by a gradient-based
strategy, then identify the alignment-related key tokens by reward models for
computing loss. Besides, we also decompose the alignment process into the
forgetting and learning stages, where we first forget the tokens with unaligned
knowledge and then learn aligned knowledge, by updating different ratios of
neurons, respectively. Experimental results on 10 datasets have shown the
effectiveness of ALLO. Our code and data are available at
\url{https://github.com/RUCAIBox/ALLO}. | [
-0.0586744808,
-0.4532680511,
0.5317854881,
0.0237571318,
-0.2087601423,
-0.1247642711,
-0.4279031157,
-0.2547543943,
0.3646464944,
0.2583502531,
-0.5716133714,
-0.483589083,
-0.5227764845,
-0.0922972485,
-0.1840098649,
0.8833035827,
0.0396043845,
0.1361831576,
-0.4445141852,
-0.3348672986,
-0.3807900548,
-0.1154297143,
-0.6060478091,
-0.6851953268,
0.6082884073,
0.6420548558,
0.4378501177,
1.069103837,
0.1538694799,
0.3620328009,
-0.3629030585,
0.2375630736,
-0.8528103232,
-0.107049413,
-0.1070424542,
-0.3318805397,
-0.6056679487,
-0.2363169789,
0.5866869688,
0.8108072877,
-0.4664120376,
0.197001189,
0.0950354263,
0.7576225996,
-0.9337783456,
-0.2618862987,
-0.978397429,
-0.1157578826,
-0.0819762275,
-0.183638677,
-0.2309330702,
-0.3886009753,
-0.120770745,
-0.726565361,
-0.1021902412,
0.0108690867,
0.8272094727,
0.5746878386,
-0.1921094656,
0.036666438,
-0.3903718889,
1.0262366533,
-0.5362868905,
0.3746285737,
0.2637477815,
-0.0944560394,
-0.2324490994,
-0.0327295549,
-0.5879314542,
-0.1287515163,
0.1177221015,
0.1806397587,
-0.0865213051,
0.1291514635,
0.0668264255,
0.0404434577,
-0.5716684461,
0.5506525636,
-0.1656806767,
-0.3171001673,
0.5027406812,
0.0058526844,
0.1647314429,
-0.0043078167,
-0.5555351377,
-0.0550097302,
-0.7961232066,
-0.1416054368,
0.4161527455,
0.151837796,
-0.0538533591,
0.5754065514,
-0.1285328269,
0.8562500477,
0.1671938896,
-0.238746956,
0.4395211637,
-0.1780084372,
-0.1599701941,
0.3525000215,
0.8649896979,
0.3248382211,
0.3446364403,
-0.3060397506,
-0.3014209867,
-0.0390472375,
0.4116336703,
-0.3016835451,
0.1454595476,
0.0646390393,
-0.3252309859,
-0.268050164,
-0.5209025145,
-0.4735537469,
-0.3122850657,
-0.5636004806,
0.2614192367,
-0.4519802034,
0.0690910742,
0.1629479229,
0.267452836,
0.1476623863,
0.3769211471,
-1.1837921143,
0.0476435497,
0.9150132537,
0.8564043641,
-0.3538725078,
-0.6509088278,
-0.5601741672,
0.1681817621,
-0.2712504566,
0.6160666347,
-0.3097922206,
0.0198883638,
-0.1078962088,
-0.2415071577,
-0.1928490251,
-0.4326215982,
0.7043263912,
-0.4648361802,
0.0014672412,
-0.2852921188,
-0.6727979779,
-0.0323671326,
0.3305009902,
-0.5761268139,
0.9436794519,
-0.0341003798,
-0.534732163,
0.1816884726,
-0.4599235058,
-0.3801523447,
-0.2242233455,
-0.1665135324,
-0.5580445528,
0.1356720477,
0.0852415487,
0.2530910671,
-0.4217502773,
0.3372427821,
-0.4451529384,
-0.5606765747,
0.0204117279,
-0.207998246,
0.7210839987,
0.1466964036,
-0.190647617,
0.3404591084,
-0.7876321077,
-0.0700074807,
0.0323798135,
-0.3344444036,
-0.34538728,
0.0874336213,
-0.1418468952,
0.0319051631,
0.476285398,
-0.5288804173,
0.3431125879,
-0.4644269347,
0.4380833805,
0.9723356366,
-0.3456780612,
0.8350896239,
-0.4771439731,
0.2691659033,
-0.0208228603,
0.2236285359,
0.1510275751,
-0.2879314125,
-0.8252686858,
-0.3068972528,
0.2979979813,
0.6384798288,
-0.3205924332,
0.9775906801,
-0.6256994605,
-0.335434258,
-0.6428835988,
0.4475134611,
0.3947616518,
0.6812573671,
0.231858328,
-0.2127936333,
-0.6444035172,
-1.0182627439,
-0.0227479935,
-0.0568205193,
0.0525057986,
0.1465805769,
0.3042436242,
-0.3346474469,
0.8659531474,
-0.4866359234,
-0.4294635952,
-0.0790548176,
-0.1455142349,
0.2106936276,
0.6133276224,
0.5640468001,
-0.2474380583,
-0.3054621816,
0.2588744164,
-0.6314017773,
-0.055346407,
-0.0803217515,
-0.4559296072,
0.2943443358,
0.3069632053,
-0.8237679005,
-0.1869910955,
0.5097545981,
0.4028093219,
0.0302322339,
-0.1215462685,
-0.0724808425,
-1.1767247915,
0.2988088429,
-0.1378233433,
-0.0949186087,
-0.563437283,
-0.3990516365,
0.1493148208,
0.019941844,
-0.3853022158,
0.7492755651,
-0.521274507,
-0.0544821732,
-0.1976538748,
0.3580886424,
-0.218326509,
0.7413865328,
-0.05737257,
0.5446171165,
0.639531672,
-0.3772217035,
0.3239673972,
0.3978009522,
-0.348146528,
0.3365390599,
-0.4099442065,
0.2914832234,
-0.3262690902,
-0.0546695478,
-0.9583137631,
-0.1561014503,
0.2424735874,
-0.4896785319,
0.4168596268,
-0.1799138039,
-0.3029697835,
0.0298913512,
-0.4134993255,
0.4927725494,
0.47918275,
-0.6222162843,
0.5420811176,
0.4826741815,
0.1038919017,
-1.1543579102,
-0.309789747,
-0.1632980853,
-0.2411837727,
-0.3867998123,
0.3177063167,
0.2053693533,
0.1530334055,
-0.1346686482,
-0.2506091595,
0.1466189772,
0.1843527108,
-0.0153479222,
0.4091701508,
-0.0599107929,
0.2768192887,
-0.1241832748,
-0.1473872215,
-0.3212451637,
-0.4714813828,
0.5984916687,
-0.0132895662,
-0.3547348976,
-0.4786665142,
0.0842432231,
0.6562586427,
-0.0248684045,
0.5139517784,
0.3343764842,
-0.4395495653,
-0.0624486804,
-0.6592088938,
-0.0497063063,
-0.4519406557,
0.6389322281,
-0.0281575341,
-0.7254035473,
0.5664733052,
0.032884188,
-0.0409987196,
0.1771342158,
0.4330261052,
-0.2248349041,
0.7894358039,
0.5136212707,
-0.709076941,
0.6423762441,
-0.034056738,
0.2293277383,
-0.8631460071,
-0.1394314915,
-0.3716916144,
-0.7013370395,
-0.3886145949,
-0.1314750463,
0.048733931,
0.4705268443,
-0.3283182681,
0.3300878108,
-0.5664764047,
0.6997463107,
0.6069923639,
0.0116044749,
0.1507152617,
0.2412582785,
0.0569436401,
0.0530411825,
-0.8738072515,
-0.3369195759,
1.0957775116,
0.1363634467,
0.9887835979,
-0.0052793692,
0.8965668082,
-0.0443883575,
0.3055567443,
-1.0722277164,
0.4956497252,
-0.1797918379,
-0.2391043156,
-0.4777272642,
-0.6514229774,
-1.0524485111,
0.1716765463,
-0.4088451862,
-0.9371825457,
0.1519099027,
0.4473330677,
-0.433205694,
0.3141589463,
-0.5946747661,
0.8492044806,
-0.538446486,
-0.4416811466,
-0.078147471,
-0.6227452159,
0.3672359586,
-0.1387715936,
-0.0742922276,
-0.0446259044,
-0.0619066805,
0.6979619861,
-0.1651843637,
0.8908137679,
0.1319480687,
-0.1154361516,
0.0992714241,
-0.1823887378,
0.6422237158,
-0.2741717398,
-0.1553477943,
0.3684937358,
-0.3867298067,
-0.4065052569,
-0.5105382204,
0.9866889119,
-0.9500778913,
-0.3475301564,
-0.369150281,
-0.5444497466,
-0.2780933678,
0.248439461,
0.3096362352,
-0.0652815476,
-0.2198102027,
0.0639064163,
0.5829882622,
0.0355192609,
0.4684168696,
0.1835567653,
0.2155904472,
-0.6463945508,
0.8306806684,
-0.0438917801,
0.2159966379,
0.5152971745,
0.1406074315,
-0.3219384551,
-0.6051364541,
-0.5690279603,
0.4388026893,
-0.6776502132,
-0.3949991465,
-0.4612683654,
0.0168131739,
-0.2869637907,
-0.2819131911,
-0.7036671638,
-0.4042666554,
-0.4719360471,
0.0490629114,
0.2303343713,
0.3105442226,
0.0524704903,
0.5716730356,
-0.9636790752,
0.0495664142,
-0.0179619417,
0.3663616776,
0.2228653282,
-0.3593320549,
-0.3036301136,
0.207269311,
-0.4762262404,
-0.623151958,
0.2174804658,
0.3297233582,
0.7709808946,
0.6916868091,
-0.1952264756,
0.8747725487,
-0.5111432076,
0.2617478967,
0.6272298098,
-0.9838760495,
0.4070841968,
-0.3026266694,
0.194862023,
0.7978892326,
0.4809833467,
-0.4999818504,
0.1648304909,
-0.4032221437,
-0.8303354383,
0.9180810452,
0.0718748271,
0.021394087,
0.084844701,
0.6114013791,
-0.0765862018,
0.267658025,
-0.8223661184,
-0.206127435,
0.1620607078,
-0.6004269123,
-0.0212559085,
-0.0487142727,
-0.4383049905,
-0.2466733009,
0.7072339058,
-0.3345562816,
0.191830039,
-0.2870981693,
-0.2869611681,
-0.3824431598,
0.1232907623,
0.7718375325,
0.5978015661,
-0.0788671672,
-0.1578601152,
0.3410420716,
-0.2334235311,
0.2814698219,
-0.2646751404,
-0.3696151078,
-0.2797538936,
0.484123826,
0.9885576367,
0.3201668859,
-0.5955650806,
0.7280296087,
0.3056401312,
-0.3170643151,
-0.2451300621,
0.1089624986,
0.1603676677,
0.1015403196,
-0.0048972648,
0.338213861,
-0.15704678,
-0.5199948549,
0.1457149833,
0.6798034906,
-0.3891333342,
-0.192404151,
0.5020288229,
0.2261610329,
-0.1800303459,
0.7496834993,
-0.0670981556,
-0.5373137593,
0.4794650674,
0.5083388686,
0.9240678549,
-0.1331749707,
-0.0582818724,
0.524533987,
0.2461602241,
-0.5215775371,
0.0773355141,
-0.1249304563,
-1.0157032013,
-0.6114740372,
-0.695975244,
-0.0680339932,
0.1068587452,
-0.5385696888,
0.5303335786,
-0.455653578,
-0.0616291724,
-0.1912902743,
-0.3422777951,
-0.2192825824,
-0.0519002825,
0.1649684012,
0.5102565289,
-1.0011247396,
0.9934542775,
0.6158981323,
-0.2007828951,
-0.4813587368,
-0.0869503766,
0.0973652899,
-1.1377688646,
0.7176423669,
-0.0211734548,
-0.3185218275,
0.0898214579,
-0.5799473524,
-1.2312889099,
0.9830853343,
0.5129284263,
-0.8761133552,
-0.1447857916,
-0.0153902294,
0.4093883336,
-0.3724521101,
0.1954165995,
0.4805059731,
0.3168604374,
0.4192014933,
-0.8683326244,
-0.0189910159,
-0.0499088541,
-0.019498501,
0.5449259877,
-0.7233458161,
0.6793519258,
-0.2672990859,
-0.199857831,
0.178164348,
0.3676493466,
0.2638168037,
0.0085009132,
0.6132414341,
1.0355941057,
0.8920640945,
-0.1504792273,
0.6701646447,
-0.2502164543,
0.5223101974,
1.295222044,
-0.4608725905,
0.895829618,
0.6231328249,
0.1153575182,
-0.0875553712,
0.6682859659,
-0.0507983752,
0.6432759166,
0.3652977347,
-0.0057595572,
-0.4355134666,
0.0461390093,
-0.0851609185,
0.4945497811,
-0.0208654627,
-0.0918822363,
-0.1695038974,
-0.1625774056,
-0.0426166765,
0.0000453461,
-0.2129472941,
1.0027519464,
-0.04608538,
-0.8602312803,
1.1881527901,
-0.2123830318,
0.8035299778,
-0.6971823573,
0.1810832024,
-0.3887112439,
0.3970030546,
-0.2863970399,
-0.4802588224,
0.120799236,
-0.251576215,
-0.2367538661,
-0.1919430345,
0.2822343111,
-0.6296659708,
-0.2081298232,
0.4771982729,
0.1833689064,
-0.0219424441,
0.0980136469,
-0.6307208538,
-0.01152921,
0.1850507706,
-0.0083751846,
0.4890111685,
0.187117815,
-0.1667864472,
0.7686949968,
0.6687309146,
0.3297794759,
0.0019952205,
0.1902579367,
0.7290967107,
-0.6404331326,
-0.2148375511,
-0.9342983365,
0.2822344601,
-0.1848477721,
-0.4873730838,
0.4180220068,
0.700519681,
0.9000149965,
0.0452471748,
0.4940103889,
0.2035969943,
0.2007906139,
-0.7125280499,
0.7409199476,
-0.8825538158,
0.2967292368,
-0.1719482839,
-1.2472720146,
-0.4005373418,
0.7305462956,
-0.0765950829,
-0.0876997635,
0.6791140437,
0.980054915,
-0.2151626796,
-0.1707360297,
0.3133538365,
0.109198235,
-0.1333629489,
0.7873806357,
0.8749814034,
-0.3955126703,
0.4736372828,
-0.1081385314,
-0.303483665,
-0.2794522643,
-0.8233911395,
-0.725682199,
-0.3678600788,
-0.220626682,
-0.074856393,
0.1613875031,
1.1923360825,
0.688384831,
-0.6832413077,
-0.4544203579,
-0.0348262377,
0.2071663886,
-0.1708397418,
-0.0424936078,
0.3568663895,
-0.402811259,
-0.8183367848,
0.3682250977,
0.2348343581,
0.0348687284,
0.176273793,
-0.2648836076,
-0.4468294084,
-0.2716249824,
0.5220640302,
0.2897362113,
-0.7702338099,
-0.2708286345,
0.1320576668,
-0.1928018779,
0.3088485003,
0.6418605447,
-0.2066138983,
0.2318658978,
0.7256048918,
0.89809829,
0.3335888982,
0.2348504961,
0.5119540691,
-0.8376276493,
0.1268058568,
0.1534307897,
0.6229686141,
0.3718791008,
-0.3967690766,
0.3285723925,
0.0760287568,
-0.659678638,
-0.658711493,
0.2001212239,
-1.1848083735,
-0.192139864,
1.1408925056,
0.1228644103,
-0.4785785973,
0.2296014875,
-0.0515736826,
0.2659426033,
-0.5196598172,
0.9560903311,
0.6314108372,
-0.1830523759,
-0.0922905132,
-0.221638456,
0.5090806484,
0.8166079521,
-0.6057965159,
0.1745841056,
0.5985527039,
0.3710823357,
0.280757755,
0.6018200517,
0.035313949,
0.0176995322,
-0.3839211166,
0.5663448572,
0.1145246997,
-0.2595631778,
-0.547300756,
-0.158513695,
0.0636018515,
-0.4598533511
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12593v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12593v1 | PromptDSI: Prompt-based Rehearsal-free Instance-wise Incremental Learning for Document Retrieval | 2024-06-18T13:25:18 | 2024-06-18T13:25:18 | Tuan-Luc Huynh, Thuy-Trang Vu, Weiqing Wang, Yinwei Wei, Trung Le, Dragan Gasevic, Yuan-Fang Li, Thanh-Toan Do | cs.IR | cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG | Differentiable Search Index (DSI) utilizes Pre-trained Language Models (PLMs)
for efficient document retrieval without relying on external indexes. However,
DSIs need full re-training to handle updates in dynamic corpora, causing
significant computational inefficiencies. We introduce PromptDSI, a
rehearsal-free, prompt-based approach for instance-wise incremental learning in
document retrieval. PromptDSI attaches prompts to the frozen PLM's encoder of
DSI, leveraging its powerful representation to efficiently index new corpora
while maintaining a balance between stability and plasticity. We eliminate the
initial forward pass of prompt-based continual learning methods that doubles
training and inference time. Moreover, we propose a topic-aware prompt pool
that employs neural topic embeddings as fixed keys. This strategy ensures
diverse and effective prompt usage, addressing the challenge of parameter
underutilization caused by the collapse of the query-key matching mechanism.
Our empirical evaluations demonstrate that PromptDSI matches IncDSI in managing
forgetting while significantly enhancing recall by over 4% on new corpora. | [
-0.2088148147,
-0.3264585733,
0.7427133918,
0.1746459305,
-0.2850278914,
0.1543818414,
-0.0922737569,
0.4128566086,
0.2638860643,
0.0246660262,
-0.9278348684,
-0.578050673,
-0.2582965791,
0.2500678003,
-0.2180930078,
0.5682507753,
0.045296248,
0.1349453032,
-0.4193306267,
-0.1893542409,
-0.6348494887,
-0.3616305292,
-0.83786726,
0.13150388,
0.8032410741,
0.6330798268,
0.1161148697,
0.5568615198,
0.0454090014,
0.2604828477,
-0.1094041914,
0.033276137,
-0.4265184999,
0.6048787832,
-0.0551980659,
-0.5953639746,
0.0415176973,
0.3766608238,
0.7771828771,
0.5848645568,
-0.328507781,
-0.3524813354,
-0.1528698057,
0.5526993871,
-0.6195326447,
-0.0667644292,
-0.7246043086,
0.0994980186,
-0.1933204234,
-0.5962042212,
-0.4958097041,
-0.4440358281,
0.0206935909,
-0.7710170746,
0.473416239,
-0.2589500844,
0.4400703311,
0.1586153805,
-0.2626488507,
-0.6110219359,
0.0120356586,
0.7308628559,
-0.4695349932,
0.5379385352,
0.3020965755,
0.177618891,
-0.0497714095,
-0.7719768286,
-0.5890715718,
-0.272480756,
0.0951298401,
0.2110620737,
0.3244032264,
-0.0341379791,
0.4746408761,
0.3508886993,
-0.6935740709,
0.1630214006,
-0.0316055231,
0.0415788628,
0.2621770203,
0.205131799,
0.3816150129,
0.0669269264,
-0.1822639853,
-0.2053659707,
-0.7657187581,
0.0364657342,
0.4359205365,
0.5814569592,
-0.0062273331,
0.1378350705,
-0.1412146688,
0.4097098708,
0.4600502551,
0.026150411,
0.314293772,
-0.2489792109,
0.2638398111,
0.1665131152,
0.1867468655,
0.1018957868,
-0.1401486248,
-0.4829307795,
-0.3425229192,
0.2238095254,
0.2553866804,
-0.9080024958,
-0.0086813662,
0.2022419572,
-0.1701432019,
-0.1565857828,
0.083370626,
-0.6662816405,
-0.3994974494,
-0.4613843262,
0.3188819587,
-0.7771209478,
0.085167177,
-0.3414158821,
-0.4021611214,
0.3058937192,
0.3708707988,
-0.9241421223,
0.1679686606,
0.7502889633,
0.8726312518,
0.0054140715,
-0.4943691194,
-1.307826519,
-0.167458564,
-0.5771147013,
0.6536386609,
-0.7541816235,
-0.724147737,
0.2181258649,
0.1531100869,
-0.435274452,
-0.4455042481,
0.6389715672,
-0.6861422658,
0.4461613894,
-0.4766518772,
-0.8801066875,
0.1919119358,
0.2459652573,
-0.4768571854,
0.9021801949,
0.0250743777,
-0.7054988742,
0.3860440254,
-0.414980799,
-0.3248023391,
0.2279030681,
-0.3712271452,
-0.1673248261,
0.1641866714,
0.0696131289,
0.1804122925,
-0.1569345742,
0.4303659797,
-0.1722564697,
-0.6276707649,
0.0994340107,
-0.4448971748,
0.4211146533,
0.3528072238,
0.0452648439,
0.4078912139,
-0.8794173002,
-0.0875672698,
-0.1059863269,
-0.2575633228,
-0.5145828724,
-0.1916853935,
-0.1428003013,
0.188801989,
0.040863052,
-0.447948426,
0.371551007,
-0.258253485,
0.47188887,
0.7368527651,
0.280883342,
0.5887503028,
-0.398304075,
0.4492637217,
0.1485402286,
-0.0008020401,
-0.8082498312,
-0.2854418755,
-0.568048656,
-0.3605347574,
0.1888964176,
0.4184111059,
-1.0041396618,
0.1352065951,
-0.2273265719,
-0.3918286264,
-0.6100481749,
-0.149085775,
0.1586138457,
0.6881716847,
0.2323466688,
-0.2668957412,
-0.2708542943,
-0.4797716439,
0.1382138282,
0.1364128888,
-0.1745235175,
0.3188803494,
0.1704542637,
-0.273488611,
0.799726963,
-0.2996814251,
-0.2138615549,
-0.0680925548,
0.5759236813,
0.2498873621,
0.6077212095,
0.4961948097,
-0.8924898505,
-0.404142946,
-0.6754036546,
-0.7152183652,
-0.1188507378,
-0.4230377376,
0.1277369559,
0.3082424998,
0.6611815691,
-0.6043856144,
0.1034818739,
-0.1036655679,
-0.3888375759,
0.1407656372,
-0.6625388861,
0.4565109611,
-0.9765546322,
0.2008227706,
-0.0257628281,
0.1183885336,
-0.4445024133,
0.0697437152,
0.5872004628,
-0.7451362014,
-0.4433542192,
0.6094119549,
-0.6144939065,
0.0041851439,
-0.1564638019,
0.4856140018,
-0.1277536303,
0.4609579444,
0.0821337402,
1.2152531147,
0.7285284996,
-0.8934048414,
-0.0882261992,
0.3512356877,
-0.1283050627,
0.797477901,
-0.4675402343,
0.4725842178,
-0.466584444,
0.0950397775,
-0.9352446795,
0.0909872502,
0.0468234308,
-0.230468452,
0.8609762192,
-0.1998219639,
-0.1999919266,
-0.156028837,
-0.7819389701,
0.2138455361,
0.2378974706,
-0.779356122,
0.3282228708,
0.1032243744,
-0.3778736889,
-0.4834364057,
-0.0387320332,
0.1785803735,
-0.1573728621,
-0.3528137803,
0.5705005527,
-0.4666183293,
-0.0172908977,
-0.1064545512,
-0.3428898156,
-0.1635112613,
0.3272526562,
0.0852765143,
0.0733227283,
-0.0218755305,
0.4144940674,
0.2531714141,
-0.491761446,
-0.5115462542,
-0.4321552217,
0.5068408847,
0.1483203173,
-0.2671114802,
-0.4739759266,
0.8163048029,
0.6565774679,
-0.2690286636,
0.453248173,
0.3184531033,
-0.3058129549,
-0.1141317785,
-0.595569551,
-0.2622151375,
-0.4564405382,
0.100754939,
-0.7385239005,
-0.7886919379,
0.3823494911,
-0.188926816,
-0.1794955581,
0.2480296046,
-0.0133257946,
0.0009139414,
0.5725835562,
0.740513742,
-0.0633004084,
0.637191236,
-0.3901806176,
-0.1834378392,
-0.8466273546,
-0.1082787365,
-0.6808781624,
-0.1139204204,
-0.3911987245,
-0.360501945,
0.11565952,
0.1183246896,
-0.2697020471,
0.1715065986,
-0.3262952566,
0.4227453172,
0.6917362213,
-0.1101891547,
0.0246160589,
-0.2514934838,
-0.2885958552,
-0.3135225773,
-0.6803295016,
-0.3026988804,
0.7948637009,
-0.0984985456,
0.5467720032,
-0.0807142034,
0.8825036287,
0.3446839154,
0.1617181748,
-0.6012589335,
0.5954079032,
-0.1355019808,
-0.0131648695,
-0.2301191986,
-0.4048873782,
-0.8676130176,
0.1001134738,
0.1395650655,
-0.4923912883,
0.625202477,
-0.2272862643,
-0.3612369299,
0.0347323976,
-0.710478127,
0.7207638025,
-0.1893066317,
-0.4681122899,
-0.3933636248,
-0.5507104993,
-0.3239220083,
0.0776492432,
-0.1687987745,
0.0553225763,
-0.3130141199,
0.6228559017,
-0.3102011085,
0.6780750751,
-0.5642604828,
0.0928710997,
0.2148079723,
-0.0241296906,
0.6286147833,
0.4254176915,
-0.4067732096,
-0.2269010693,
-0.1319308281,
-0.3013697267,
-0.792963326,
1.1315637827,
-0.5697144866,
-0.7152681351,
-0.6297952533,
-0.1419155896,
-0.1851523966,
0.1172295064,
0.3184803724,
0.8037845492,
-0.3159764707,
-0.0763013437,
0.9375453591,
-0.2393756807,
0.6842547655,
0.862848103,
0.3034785092,
-0.4534827769,
0.9597640038,
0.2265152782,
-0.3068178892,
0.5941096544,
-0.0893999189,
-0.5242438912,
-0.4288662374,
-0.3375202715,
0.3471445143,
-0.7161539793,
-0.0790168494,
-0.7830443978,
0.0378155261,
-0.4073316455,
-0.3270336986,
-0.1262910217,
-0.3294984996,
-0.6497778296,
-0.3032064438,
0.3415411711,
0.1356284916,
-0.1301971972,
-0.0149060162,
-0.6011458635,
0.2827808857,
0.5451726913,
0.6092458963,
-0.0424978435,
-0.5637286305,
0.0707412884,
-0.3904832304,
-0.0775802732,
-0.9483485222,
0.5643845797,
0.4085757434,
0.762206614,
0.3528631926,
0.3598010242,
0.4765911102,
-0.6361072659,
0.6095089316,
0.01236872,
-0.8917382956,
0.7966697812,
-0.224971801,
0.2637840509,
0.931697607,
0.6933687925,
-1.0008699894,
-0.0543632172,
-0.4491660595,
-1.0077799559,
0.9022268057,
-0.3121064305,
0.1493814439,
-0.5381265283,
0.7133294344,
0.4214192033,
0.4572930038,
-0.1119892001,
-0.0889309049,
-0.2049200982,
-0.3559087813,
-0.2092666626,
-0.7458273768,
0.0941974521,
-0.0118389977,
0.8269117475,
-0.3348179162,
0.438262403,
0.6191927791,
-0.341465354,
0.008754232,
0.4465917051,
0.4754422009,
0.4171514809,
-0.406827122,
0.0504007079,
0.0529117472,
-0.3347669542,
0.2732258141,
0.3186753988,
-0.3280019164,
0.1222469881,
-0.1073887944,
0.9275244474,
0.5019292831,
-0.6345819831,
0.4314084649,
-0.4552920461,
0.0785945952,
-0.3359417021,
-0.1544959247,
-0.061448589,
0.2014624923,
0.5252341628,
-0.0937032476,
0.0433381274,
-0.5372055173,
0.5351927876,
0.1297132969,
-0.6462888122,
-0.3561374843,
0.6034097672,
0.3253128231,
-0.510700345,
0.9581942558,
-0.4502878487,
-0.1141963601,
0.3299808204,
0.4470443726,
1.1714934111,
-0.2935992181,
0.4857653379,
0.3793565929,
-0.0166788176,
-0.0040409034,
0.4136176705,
-0.4917466938,
-0.417289257,
0.0668403655,
-0.257712245,
-0.4028340578,
0.0783247128,
-0.4463242888,
0.2038074285,
-0.4479522109,
0.2262400836,
-0.2791010439,
0.2393079102,
-0.5605912209,
0.0820072666,
-0.0311291162,
1.2343853712,
-0.509028554,
0.9836741686,
0.5937260389,
-0.7765955925,
-0.3947201967,
0.2663950026,
-0.0999990925,
-0.2340869308,
0.4293806851,
0.4945088625,
0.1251968294,
0.201660037,
-0.260528326,
-0.846934557,
1.2165888548,
0.3354641199,
-0.6543916464,
-0.038691286,
-0.6037677526,
0.4571728706,
-0.363748461,
0.5295224786,
0.1198691577,
0.198296085,
0.0707378685,
-0.190803349,
0.030183889,
-0.4516091943,
0.3102945089,
-0.0684465244,
-0.545284152,
0.8905991912,
-0.1389307231,
-0.7094388604,
0.4866418242,
0.455057174,
0.0994947553,
0.7097299099,
0.362233758,
0.51235044,
1.2056469917,
-0.1394227743,
1.1758648157,
-0.436376214,
-0.0451556183,
1.0362842083,
-0.5863856673,
0.7046014667,
0.4734168351,
0.2574582696,
0.2945689559,
0.7405273318,
0.2741179168,
0.9509965181,
0.0783363506,
-0.5482435822,
-0.1559879929,
-0.1488066465,
-0.3341672421,
-0.2635303438,
0.2025774121,
0.0617192313,
-0.228943646,
0.2938919365,
-0.1896307021,
0.4841223359,
-0.0704248697,
0.8599961996,
-0.0978526697,
-0.771289289,
0.5038743615,
-0.0190269724,
0.8899130821,
-0.8534368277,
0.099727042,
-0.7602810264,
0.0189002696,
0.2939608097,
-0.1771604121,
0.0926505998,
-0.071292907,
-0.4188054502,
-0.2579040527,
0.5648223758,
-0.6293743849,
-0.0876765847,
0.2291914821,
0.4415816963,
-0.0645224899,
0.0039299633,
-0.4851421118,
-0.0472062901,
-0.2833354473,
-0.0459613577,
0.6279327273,
0.8166804314,
-0.1103326455,
0.6568978429,
0.4602633119,
-0.3879681826,
-0.2233953178,
0.3832184672,
0.9437308908,
-0.8532603383,
-0.7644830942,
-0.2557439506,
0.2556738257,
-0.0192543995,
-0.2620587051,
0.5090610385,
0.4984434843,
0.6715826392,
-0.2953796089,
0.5412834883,
0.2847594023,
0.5816237926,
-0.5747637153,
0.6935293674,
-0.3774786294,
0.3261607289,
-0.1085044593,
-0.6194586158,
-0.0536445826,
0.3727493584,
-0.2545431256,
-0.1043888554,
0.740542531,
0.8628997207,
0.1328786165,
0.0343704708,
0.4249005318,
-0.0395563915,
0.2766127586,
0.2198981345,
0.8550654054,
-0.4730069637,
0.2430749536,
-0.0355356596,
-0.3028366864,
0.0192768462,
-0.7630153298,
-0.4228639305,
-0.904648006,
-0.6719518304,
0.1568115503,
0.5146311522,
0.9134104848,
0.4127970338,
-0.727694869,
-0.0259155929,
-0.3832342625,
0.3469062746,
-0.3501086831,
-0.2259026319,
0.4894118905,
-1.1057343483,
-0.806679666,
1.0554236174,
0.4014230967,
0.0676719248,
0.1846895665,
-0.047220733,
-0.5992272496,
0.2015825659,
0.30063802,
0.4207397103,
-0.1726772785,
-0.1217634007,
0.1228249893,
-0.1374744475,
0.0766418055,
1.1148794889,
-1.1524214745,
0.5031969547,
0.470533371,
0.7233737111,
0.4746772349,
-0.2108848095,
0.4324113429,
-1.0666018724,
0.5602816343,
0.2282323688,
0.4136891663,
0.5270661116,
-0.4659012258,
0.4458227158,
0.6173013449,
-0.2298284024,
-0.578365624,
0.1169835553,
-0.7670983672,
-0.4000552297,
0.6158403754,
-0.2934765816,
-0.0833316743,
0.0109698912,
-0.2660171092,
0.2762803137,
-0.7996833324,
0.8904915452,
0.2124633044,
0.5292522907,
-0.2774965763,
-0.066557236,
0.5773580074,
0.3472865522,
-0.29342556,
-0.0478045903,
0.5935845375,
0.0972310603,
0.1831583381,
0.9584817886,
-0.1383188516,
0.2817465663,
0.1506190449,
-0.1999056935,
-0.1603857428,
-0.5122576952,
-0.7838452458,
0.4064722955,
-0.0705882385,
-0.3654120564
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12585v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12585v1 | Breaking the Ceiling of the LLM Community by Treating Token Generation as a Classification for Ensembling | 2024-06-18T13:17:26 | 2024-06-18T13:17:26 | Yao-Ching Yu, Chun-Chih Kuo, Ziqi Ye, Yu-Cheng Chang, Yueh-Se Li | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI | Ensembling multiple models has always been an effective approach to push the
limits of existing performance and is widely used in classification tasks by
simply averaging the classification probability vectors from multiple
classifiers to achieve better accuracy. However, in the thriving open-source
Large Language Model (LLM) community, ensembling methods are rare and typically
limited to ensembling the full-text outputs of LLMs, such as selecting the best
output using a ranker, which leads to underutilization of token-level
probability information. In this paper, we treat the Generation of each token
by LLMs as a Classification (GaC) for ensembling. This approach fully exploits
the probability information at each generation step and better prevents LLMs
from producing early incorrect tokens that lead to snowballing errors. In
experiments, we ensemble state-of-the-art LLMs on several benchmarks, including
exams, mathematics and reasoning, and observe that our method breaks the
existing community performance ceiling. Furthermore, we observed that most of
the tokens in the answer are simple and do not affect the correctness of the
final answer. Therefore, we also experimented with ensembling only key tokens,
and the results showed better performance with lower latency across benchmarks. | [
-0.1935859174,
-0.7599255443,
0.5228821635,
-0.1427152753,
-0.4441413879,
0.4067093134,
-0.175161913,
-0.4006612897,
0.1910074055,
0.5172325969,
-0.2934700847,
-0.6360454559,
-0.7663709521,
-0.0812058151,
-0.4465983808,
0.814101696,
0.0591647141,
-0.2356355935,
-0.6182310581,
-0.0053633549,
-0.3673587143,
-0.8940726519,
-0.7210279703,
-0.1509129703,
0.3667588532,
0.560346663,
0.2803484499,
0.8578427434,
0.6784664392,
0.3070362806,
-0.3150890768,
0.4755290151,
-0.5128160715,
0.1010186076,
0.1330117285,
-0.6909258366,
-0.5277389288,
-0.0064508403,
0.5316399336,
0.5339891315,
-0.3613191843,
0.3472682834,
0.398619771,
0.4270327985,
-0.7708879113,
0.1840031296,
-0.9831630588,
-0.0126667209,
-0.7892400622,
-0.4110151231,
-0.7732716799,
-0.1779217869,
-0.6288939118,
-0.2614595592,
0.337176621,
0.2583348453,
0.6847305298,
0.2500168681,
-0.2602833807,
-0.3307924867,
-0.47315979,
0.7070108056,
-0.9349445105,
0.1290988773,
0.1332956254,
0.2286044806,
-0.148560822,
-0.5958206654,
-0.4716694355,
0.2129795104,
0.1673199385,
0.0370334797,
-0.0239128359,
0.301099509,
0.147891134,
0.1168514192,
-0.5105253458,
0.3755253553,
-0.5058457255,
-0.139077127,
0.4968571365,
0.2606122792,
0.089139916,
-0.200265035,
-0.415487498,
0.0272310488,
-1.0690114498,
0.0035454798,
0.4085683823,
0.4337875843,
0.3642157018,
0.7347123623,
0.0477368161,
0.6096466184,
0.084412612,
-0.0864562541,
0.3710555136,
-0.3401627243,
-0.2746193707,
0.1523770392,
0.6849085689,
0.1945074648,
0.094589375,
-0.392952621,
-0.2567024827,
0.0672617555,
0.2830736041,
-0.6754434705,
0.0466905721,
0.3984714448,
-0.4458894432,
-0.6273949146,
0.2351623476,
-0.745012641,
-0.2694208026,
-0.0660715699,
0.277813077,
-0.0494439602,
-0.0887707025,
-0.0056648022,
-0.0119062699,
0.049583409,
0.1678206176,
-0.8130617738,
0.3942113221,
1.2692524195,
1.1437559128,
-0.3171568811,
-0.2687081695,
-1.0258337259,
0.3315245807,
-0.3499681652,
0.6434500217,
-0.6743358374,
-0.2603368163,
0.1281874776,
-0.309289217,
-0.0792213455,
-0.6451531053,
0.3654364645,
-0.4712271988,
-0.1565959603,
-0.0064250831,
-0.7710502744,
0.1487979144,
0.1957949847,
-0.3909576237,
0.6975933313,
-0.3951356709,
-0.6809431314,
0.5158076882,
-0.5372136831,
-0.2588942051,
0.2471046597,
-0.2852412462,
-0.3102461398,
0.3624055088,
0.2394094318,
0.5518926382,
-0.132372126,
0.2902609706,
-0.3315628469,
-0.5379575491,
0.2813230157,
-0.5126953125,
0.5808615685,
0.323494494,
-0.1045485735,
0.0937187374,
-0.5378708839,
0.0832850114,
-0.1492219418,
-0.4647776186,
-0.199042514,
0.1423092782,
-0.3424500525,
0.2127871662,
0.2752070725,
-0.6850874424,
0.268114835,
-0.6732980013,
0.5316022038,
1.1435456276,
0.0229387078,
0.5065858364,
-0.3328870237,
0.4933289587,
0.2464504242,
0.16937612,
0.0610365421,
-0.6250287294,
-0.8996055126,
-0.1505007744,
0.4019092321,
0.3683713078,
-0.6118687987,
0.5053693056,
-0.3322193623,
-0.4936567843,
-0.6582738161,
0.2010191083,
0.2135182619,
0.3237278461,
0.1134680212,
-0.3039260805,
-0.4690533876,
-0.5081908703,
-0.2405167967,
-0.5326493979,
0.0734918714,
0.2475277185,
0.2324185222,
-0.0001035153,
0.8240281343,
-0.5265184641,
-0.2793699801,
-0.2130159736,
0.3089686036,
0.4275518358,
0.5437082648,
0.1148981303,
-0.3713563681,
-0.156321466,
-0.1411028057,
-0.6754450798,
-0.1019250602,
-0.09735246,
-0.2603860795,
0.3552357852,
0.7168986201,
-0.5995998979,
0.4560664594,
0.2855297029,
-0.2022643536,
0.5588513017,
-0.0765174851,
-0.0305346884,
-0.913195312,
-0.2416611016,
-0.2239982188,
-0.0060504018,
-0.626693964,
0.568207562,
0.0878695473,
0.1905270964,
-0.4708938301,
0.3241886199,
-0.4203829169,
0.1815357208,
-0.2490997314,
0.0806957036,
-0.2561540008,
0.3197748363,
-0.2574017942,
0.454490453,
0.5470420122,
-0.5441556573,
0.3356397152,
0.1627697796,
-0.362228781,
0.1350445449,
-0.4043880403,
0.5036938787,
-0.2410399765,
0.0272220783,
-0.9683701396,
-0.1220561936,
0.2237942517,
-0.6554556489,
0.3792228103,
-0.3030676246,
-0.7640639544,
-0.2920550406,
-0.141950354,
0.3805675507,
0.5935826302,
-0.7676395774,
0.4646283388,
0.3799710572,
-0.0947641656,
-0.7473276854,
-0.8250859976,
0.2207467556,
-0.4399306774,
-0.7232147455,
0.1568755805,
-0.0273917709,
-0.3039824367,
-0.137105003,
-0.2003996372,
0.0945267752,
0.2320409417,
0.3002575934,
0.2776909471,
-0.1015551612,
0.4002719223,
-0.1200006679,
-0.0940532461,
0.0302539449,
-0.1940657943,
0.7947446704,
-0.0870239511,
-0.8414281607,
0.1288049221,
0.2332000732,
0.4880069196,
-0.3674740791,
0.9906328917,
0.1977087706,
-0.3904221654,
-0.3745812476,
-0.6599122882,
-0.1726748943,
-0.5293741822,
0.361874789,
-0.4404163659,
-1.0059512854,
0.5452516079,
-0.086054422,
0.4924277663,
0.2245684564,
0.4437246919,
-0.0288631674,
1.1045386791,
0.55680722,
-0.0498542339,
0.0609958991,
0.1326453537,
0.3816270232,
-0.7277820706,
-0.2595849335,
-0.722314775,
-0.5002052188,
-0.3670523167,
-0.7557196617,
0.3501850069,
0.3523427546,
-0.2746579647,
0.1440242082,
-0.6882484555,
0.6261377335,
0.4324579537,
0.0269872006,
0.4550830126,
0.1437702179,
-0.1695257425,
0.102343455,
-0.8123186827,
-0.5128538013,
1.2485295534,
0.3706318438,
0.753723979,
0.2678307593,
1.3481982946,
-0.0813108087,
0.4922354519,
-0.6482552886,
0.7031137943,
-0.2916435599,
-0.3811452985,
-0.3781708181,
-0.7782493234,
-0.9331462979,
0.3689018786,
0.1259900331,
-0.8183798194,
0.2434809506,
-0.0445105657,
-0.2659410834,
0.6402787566,
-0.3393819332,
0.576672256,
-0.1242776215,
-0.0586026348,
-0.2166568935,
-0.3378165364,
0.5654417872,
-0.388171345,
0.5572731495,
-0.0272488538,
-0.2410132438,
0.7965235114,
-0.5792683959,
0.9092596769,
-0.1423664689,
-0.0513948537,
0.3591467142,
0.2219162881,
0.7383488417,
-0.1633582115,
-0.051279936,
0.2945612669,
-0.3382251561,
-0.2195840329,
-0.5508101583,
0.6519314647,
-0.6215157509,
-0.7938257456,
-0.2998862267,
-0.1342632174,
-0.1631738245,
-0.2243685275,
0.371822685,
0.4872249067,
0.1642094105,
0.2446713001,
0.4011792839,
0.0419902168,
0.4838568568,
0.297844708,
-0.2704150081,
-0.4145757556,
1.0738847256,
0.4309549928,
0.3246477544,
0.2034278661,
0.1110056564,
-0.1435235143,
-0.9639479518,
-0.2014226168,
0.1294124275,
-0.8293482065,
-0.4153946638,
-0.5044959784,
-0.5038353801,
-0.5398639441,
-0.1978025138,
-0.0972986221,
-0.4741353393,
-0.3795795143,
-0.4395518601,
-0.0141792996,
0.6024798751,
-0.1795759499,
0.2414936423,
-0.9118720889,
-0.1483908594,
0.2092129588,
0.3236891925,
0.402107656,
-0.6066848636,
-0.2304953039,
-0.1513774097,
-0.3200890422,
-0.8265405893,
0.258092165,
0.3139773607,
0.7054869533,
0.626857698,
0.1204186752,
0.8483794332,
-0.5851563811,
0.7658074498,
0.5052084923,
-0.9240459204,
0.5063728094,
0.042009484,
0.1221942976,
0.3989841044,
-0.1527546048,
-0.9037965536,
-0.8539047241,
-0.6682803631,
-1.2410216331,
0.6768062115,
0.1572827995,
0.0851192921,
-0.4912211597,
0.2945120931,
0.0723997504,
0.2409504801,
-0.6083983779,
-0.0815605223,
0.0717450231,
-0.3637468517,
-0.1417978704,
-0.1569963098,
-0.1324569136,
-0.0708753839,
0.6624311805,
-0.2560025156,
0.1388218701,
-0.1439543217,
-0.1887153536,
-0.2604005635,
0.2629883289,
0.1359258443,
0.5291934013,
0.0226361416,
0.3788716495,
0.1921612024,
-0.272408098,
0.2075311095,
-0.3904050589,
-0.1451183259,
-0.1090161577,
0.4981479049,
0.5101428032,
0.046261251,
-0.7153433561,
0.5152380466,
0.1733572334,
-0.3682309091,
-0.1211908087,
0.2736000717,
0.0307720918,
0.146179527,
0.5360256433,
0.2067948431,
-0.0370135792,
-0.499944061,
0.3889707327,
0.5313450098,
-0.1822980642,
-0.042955637,
0.696326673,
0.3466198146,
-0.3426485956,
0.7924391031,
-0.1748127639,
-0.4831671715,
0.7551713586,
0.4005839229,
1.0734077692,
0.1053612977,
0.2421734035,
0.3970644772,
0.4908483922,
-0.2029754668,
-0.0011980005,
-0.0568760708,
-0.9239254594,
-0.7543147802,
-0.8883143067,
-0.3343235254,
-0.0160089657,
-0.56228894,
0.0543783642,
-0.5255876184,
-0.1764085591,
-0.3353431821,
-0.2372203469,
-0.6087365746,
-0.3033179939,
0.4021145999,
1.0939532518,
-0.6843003631,
0.5839313269,
0.5240633488,
-0.3535868824,
-0.6654444933,
0.073786594,
0.0652256534,
-0.7142752409,
0.7164687514,
0.2962424457,
0.1974827498,
-0.1521848589,
-0.8307869434,
-0.8639155626,
0.899738133,
0.1488335878,
-0.8218913078,
-0.2259128839,
0.4207937121,
0.3300999999,
-0.3761215508,
0.119430393,
0.4915516675,
0.4435948133,
0.2743276954,
-0.8232065439,
0.0671501607,
-0.2964802086,
-0.2992359102,
0.3675890565,
-0.855107367,
0.7979848981,
-0.125030458,
-0.4656946957,
0.122067757,
0.584030509,
0.5920006037,
0.2489344329,
0.6421369314,
0.6943680644,
1.1802099943,
-0.2439846545,
0.6039198637,
-0.1205585971,
0.3130830228,
0.9246928096,
-0.3857627213,
1.0438789129,
0.5292114615,
-0.1796918511,
0.2295206487,
0.6357586384,
0.0007775012,
0.4589221179,
0.5179471374,
-0.2323554754,
-0.6474329829,
0.2967743576,
-0.0719914958,
0.5092755556,
0.3265846968,
-0.1057476699,
-0.242408663,
-0.018974876,
-0.1749774516,
-0.1832292974,
-0.4984614849,
0.9741581678,
0.1970410198,
-0.5298120975,
0.4963148534,
0.048695229,
0.9358600378,
-0.3195803463,
0.0617881641,
-0.1151808724,
0.2032097876,
-0.2653322816,
-0.6906252503,
0.2952098548,
0.2144021541,
0.1006071344,
-0.2624181509,
0.7572968006,
-0.3307085037,
-0.5636900663,
0.1098206118,
0.5786450505,
0.4959329367,
0.0822366625,
-0.2454220802,
-0.1118316948,
-0.01882568,
-0.179385215,
0.5431125164,
0.528259933,
0.1629832536,
0.7243170142,
0.8353347182,
0.2966565192,
0.2167783976,
0.0572854802,
0.7074584961,
-0.539283812,
-0.4866653681,
-1.1676666737,
0.4190499187,
-0.2050666064,
-0.3156595826,
0.7147266865,
0.635268271,
0.8391166329,
0.2593188584,
0.7052452564,
0.144601509,
0.2410242856,
-0.547347486,
0.7123184204,
-0.5886740685,
0.5413268805,
-0.0644413754,
-0.8311777711,
-0.2718351185,
0.3008636534,
0.016911855,
-0.2358807325,
0.5803471208,
0.7417870164,
0.2998349965,
-0.0409776904,
0.485670954,
0.2430172116,
0.5893340707,
0.6481291652,
0.8438271284,
0.0366929919,
0.8612838387,
0.0246896967,
-0.2458753586,
-0.2254665345,
-0.6233708262,
-0.8693788648,
-0.3019961417,
-0.2507182658,
-0.327457875,
0.1167226061,
0.8243968487,
0.5369395018,
-0.7423468828,
-0.1458185464,
-0.2042580545,
0.197719112,
-0.3760211766,
-0.2206403017,
0.2297634333,
-0.7519583702,
-0.6755746007,
0.4128553867,
0.244513765,
-0.2124548554,
-0.2757724524,
-0.1399351656,
0.2675205767,
0.2756349444,
0.3124512732,
-0.1471835971,
-0.732231915,
-0.4610063136,
0.0070327194,
-0.0068417946,
0.1534227431,
0.7162042856,
-0.7589259744,
0.3677096069,
0.6111978292,
0.6365020275,
0.3759041429,
0.0155079635,
0.3798879087,
-1.0748019218,
-0.2378442734,
0.3293541968,
0.475822866,
0.0182915498,
-0.4647704661,
0.6385051608,
0.2585667968,
-0.6636048555,
-1.1820521355,
0.1209987551,
-0.6347144246,
-0.4453767538,
1.1520180702,
-0.0026495547,
-0.3886913955,
-0.0889145508,
0.1287920177,
0.2516534328,
-0.3862903714,
0.8411109447,
1.0057150126,
0.0607598238,
-0.0389916711,
-0.3950004578,
0.0348562151,
0.1526778787,
-0.6479354501,
0.3238268495,
0.1698876172,
0.1212010458,
0.2540841103,
0.4991871715,
-0.2251654714,
0.1325612664,
0.0573996417,
0.069744803,
-0.179191038,
-0.3919318318,
-0.3381460309,
0.6746347547,
0.0959008485,
-0.1953292787
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12572v2 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12572v2 | Mathador-LM: A Dynamic Benchmark for Mathematical Reasoning on Large Language Models | 2024-06-18T13:02:12 | 2024-06-19T12:28:10 | Eldar Kurtic, Amir Moeini, Dan Alistarh | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, I.2.7 | We introduce Mathador-LM, a new benchmark for evaluating the mathematical
reasoning on large language models (LLMs), combining ruleset interpretation,
planning, and problem-solving. This benchmark is inspired by the Mathador game,
where the objective is to reach a target number using basic arithmetic
operations on a given set of base numbers, following a simple set of rules. We
show that, across leading LLMs, we obtain stable average performance while
generating benchmark instances dynamically, following a target difficulty
level. Thus, our benchmark alleviates concerns about test-set leakage into
training data, an issue that often undermines popular benchmarks. Additionally,
we conduct a comprehensive evaluation of both open and closed-source
state-of-the-art LLMs on Mathador-LM. Our findings reveal that contemporary
models struggle with Mathador-LM, scoring significantly lower than average 3rd
graders. This stands in stark contrast to their strong performance on popular
mathematical reasoning benchmarks. | [
-0.1791445762,
-0.7130427957,
0.5108408332,
0.5444877744,
-0.159828946,
-0.0224434528,
-0.3570322692,
-0.360563457,
-0.0552306697,
0.3270592988,
-0.6917488575,
-0.6345539093,
-0.5131574273,
-0.1554769427,
-0.3105248809,
0.643148005,
-0.3773795068,
0.2048783153,
-0.375400722,
-0.2834476531,
-0.6203378439,
-0.3365518153,
-0.6515841484,
-0.5993420482,
0.5966004133,
0.0840654597,
0.9659442902,
0.922667861,
0.7775427103,
0.3095543683,
-0.0655803978,
0.1519697756,
-0.4642473459,
0.3745468557,
-0.0767610371,
-1.0254422426,
-0.4429965615,
0.1002518386,
0.6169733405,
0.7336962819,
-0.4807402194,
0.0730069876,
-0.5367643833,
0.7447998524,
-0.5880186558,
0.5215027928,
-0.6805903316,
0.428507179,
-0.3702737689,
0.0876055136,
-0.3375050128,
-0.8333081603,
-0.017621737,
-0.7206912637,
-0.3280061185,
-0.1361379772,
0.4867273867,
0.4838111699,
-0.2367889732,
-0.4709171653,
-0.4915708303,
1.0605701208,
-0.5429022908,
0.3758628368,
0.2029720545,
0.7763100266,
-0.3338773549,
-0.5149737597,
-0.4006235898,
-0.2787187099,
0.3163744807,
0.0776149407,
-0.4806014895,
-0.3130630255,
0.5392932892,
0.2506959736,
-0.3366883695,
0.0842122436,
-0.1653349847,
0.1403161883,
0.5575437546,
0.3625437915,
0.096463576,
0.4179610908,
-0.0596104786,
-0.2164304107,
-1.0349036455,
-0.0074402457,
0.3689852059,
-0.0859995037,
0.0578590482,
0.4957894385,
-0.0249514561,
0.5236958861,
-0.295620054,
-0.1156463623,
0.2803927362,
0.2784627974,
-0.1547378451,
0.045984,
0.7793052793,
0.1746585369,
0.6002494097,
-0.106861338,
-0.362778455,
0.3032903969,
-0.1032872871,
-0.9100399613,
0.0396305993,
-0.0922891125,
-0.2499667257,
-0.5565688014,
-0.1894517839,
-0.7473238707,
-0.3989609182,
-0.2754256427,
0.4882834256,
-0.4795491397,
-0.079689011,
0.346590966,
0.0909751803,
0.3484723568,
0.7093577385,
-0.7608503103,
0.465061456,
1.109300971,
0.8217903376,
-0.1667237133,
-0.3788210154,
-0.8083202839,
-0.1940291375,
-0.6258711815,
0.7059978247,
-0.587387085,
-0.1802302897,
0.0686267838,
-0.3897810578,
0.0191943832,
-0.9752901793,
0.6165790558,
-0.5837490559,
0.0384570174,
-0.1075356603,
-0.4978898466,
-0.1112655625,
0.4957095385,
-0.7377098799,
1.2201989889,
-0.0726864189,
-0.2709220648,
0.1694534123,
-0.5219712853,
-0.4146758318,
0.0063081966,
-0.3845216334,
-0.2750937045,
0.289929986,
0.0084054423,
0.0620649047,
-0.8940426707,
0.3492618501,
-0.4966664612,
-0.4784208834,
0.4624220133,
-0.5567753911,
0.686852932,
0.215897575,
-0.4134004116,
-0.1423559189,
-0.6588541865,
0.1808498204,
0.3449572027,
-0.201121673,
-0.1915569901,
0.3443671167,
-0.7843536735,
0.1888480484,
0.4595671892,
-0.1347331852,
0.3223464787,
-0.1678339988,
0.1332594454,
0.903237164,
-0.4555384219,
0.0431434996,
-0.6244642138,
0.6079345942,
-0.357678175,
0.0897420421,
-0.3413073123,
-0.3743427396,
-0.7982156873,
-0.3180608153,
0.3955010772,
0.7169808745,
-0.5470234156,
0.1890068799,
-0.3456268311,
-0.886838913,
-0.2084609717,
0.12381915,
0.4071774483,
0.3234615326,
0.2032717168,
0.1126056314,
-0.1901324242,
-0.6350694299,
-0.5736436844,
0.038402956,
-0.0562742464,
0.3154995739,
0.5483111143,
-0.0064559793,
0.5298033357,
-0.5962985754,
-0.4688259363,
-0.205958128,
0.2845955789,
0.7809150219,
0.2179676294,
0.6534937024,
-0.578882575,
-0.5357726216,
-0.0027744533,
-1.1564276218,
-0.4677572548,
0.1766467541,
-0.178961575,
-0.2348447591,
0.498077035,
-0.6479187608,
0.1143517792,
0.5848758817,
-0.1356212348,
0.5684705973,
-0.1521497369,
-0.0575128607,
-0.6157034039,
-0.0772769749,
0.0317425542,
-0.0401953012,
-0.4102027714,
0.3203279078,
0.1071858555,
-0.1575368792,
-0.5844362974,
0.4688809514,
-0.2839985192,
-0.1307676882,
-0.0624512546,
0.0313871466,
-0.211185813,
0.3754077554,
-0.0834383443,
0.7740421295,
0.6578997374,
-0.3386272788,
0.8301246762,
-0.2068915218,
-0.6036022305,
0.7902683616,
-0.9738888144,
0.0543700531,
0.0051679029,
0.1720142215,
-0.4726911485,
0.1156050935,
-0.2256108224,
-0.2732932568,
0.0254393537,
-0.1973414868,
-0.7568493485,
-0.0930219889,
-0.3858534098,
0.5628854036,
0.7039806843,
-0.5456422567,
0.7171761394,
0.3890410662,
-0.047863517,
-0.4583325982,
-0.4743969738,
-0.0616802201,
-0.4248811305,
-0.8371266723,
0.2024768442,
-0.1588816196,
-0.717893064,
-0.087116085,
-0.2312938869,
-0.0880451426,
0.1969064772,
0.040067859,
0.2581934035,
-0.4257299304,
0.0767815337,
-0.0842897817,
-0.2653166056,
0.4063071311,
-0.0924929306,
0.7356109023,
-0.2872496545,
-0.4342397153,
-0.1135203987,
0.0875253081,
0.6720459461,
-0.3626435101,
0.5945535302,
-0.0159996636,
-0.6688219905,
-0.3826703429,
-0.4180921912,
0.2501265705,
-0.5043900013,
0.2707903981,
-0.6552234292,
-0.450017184,
0.5665044785,
-0.4697355926,
0.1521030068,
0.3630662858,
0.6000270247,
-0.0108737713,
1.1383171082,
0.0901908726,
-0.0085527683,
0.3029386103,
-0.1919270754,
-0.1555075943,
-0.3002179861,
-0.2171871513,
-0.6178911328,
-0.3824270964,
-0.3067404032,
-0.7161467671,
0.3965775371,
0.0701251179,
-0.2943636477,
0.1572892964,
0.040117342,
0.9004465938,
0.4341267049,
-0.1386214793,
0.373172164,
-0.1526923329,
-0.4192513227,
-0.4638935328,
-0.3424093127,
-0.2849973142,
0.9739889503,
0.3442079425,
1.1335403919,
0.5135259628,
0.5217640996,
0.371216625,
0.4910570383,
-0.8793196678,
0.7636195421,
-0.2182417363,
-0.4314689934,
-0.1464389116,
-0.8469276428,
-0.9952024817,
0.6353116035,
-0.1135848016,
-0.5335274935,
-0.2737753987,
-0.044470679,
-0.0394136682,
0.2210964859,
-0.2192528546,
0.8644016981,
-0.6406610608,
-0.5394177437,
-0.3767432272,
-0.0933836326,
0.4986129105,
-0.3483643234,
0.3966678679,
-0.5734409094,
-0.1622035801,
0.6926025152,
-0.7222502828,
0.4283511043,
-0.0870670229,
-0.3972351551,
0.0445547998,
0.544762671,
0.6837764978,
-0.002574434,
-0.325956732,
0.3486421704,
-0.1526679993,
-0.2099134177,
-0.8454495668,
0.8267660141,
-0.8127154112,
-0.5446563363,
-0.7754909992,
-0.6806633472,
-0.3350026309,
0.455088079,
-0.2320365012,
0.537257731,
-0.0757701397,
0.4049159288,
1.0032089949,
-0.2011339366,
0.1371175945,
0.6258898377,
-0.302552104,
-0.6215792298,
0.7579773664,
0.1036503315,
0.2042402327,
0.567092061,
0.4828880727,
-0.3770966232,
-0.427279681,
-0.4266467988,
0.379345268,
-0.7703647614,
-0.2095052749,
-0.0044213561,
-0.1953285635,
0.2063220888,
-0.0649238527,
-0.6762206554,
-0.3979496956,
0.236330539,
0.2743701339,
0.0893547237,
0.5643420219,
0.0671489611,
0.139649123,
-0.5452361107,
0.3359636664,
0.3690569997,
0.4595994353,
-0.0431507342,
-0.5008093715,
-0.0087603489,
0.0142299104,
-0.2755155563,
-0.620960772,
0.2382810712,
0.0351728462,
0.7182757854,
0.3781550527,
-0.0451288447,
0.6720308065,
-0.7719677091,
0.1866975278,
0.3233801425,
-0.9876003861,
0.4811163247,
-0.5649151802,
0.3060229123,
0.4128026068,
0.3295609951,
-0.6181759238,
-0.1366239041,
-0.3155953288,
-0.3998076916,
0.6419501901,
0.1991202682,
-0.0419813916,
0.2083203793,
-0.0451801606,
0.0189956576,
0.3656488955,
-0.7011554241,
-0.2802119255,
0.1482622176,
-0.377601862,
0.1222055182,
-0.0055348817,
-0.2117399573,
-0.2145577669,
0.4277895987,
-0.1058150381,
0.1269037127,
-0.4763256013,
-0.3107789457,
-0.2147847414,
-0.0881611928,
0.6906267405,
0.7653360963,
-0.1761803627,
0.2878009677,
0.3187597394,
-0.3972701132,
0.1358257681,
0.4060523212,
-0.1095411405,
-0.09015771,
0.5161610842,
0.5998119116,
0.5370628834,
-1.0222879648,
0.5874524713,
-0.209129557,
-0.4378398955,
-0.5613828897,
0.3006166518,
-0.0765086487,
0.2936746478,
0.4657295644,
-0.1303960681,
-0.3785057664,
-0.6119886637,
-0.0065656081,
0.3943153024,
-0.1410690397,
-0.2262465209,
0.7236093879,
-0.0126399724,
-0.3889580667,
0.3830683529,
-0.0640506223,
-0.5588933825,
0.7471430302,
0.5208837986,
0.471590966,
-0.0738390088,
-0.0174941141,
0.2420844585,
0.3449294269,
-0.331775099,
0.4125846326,
-0.0678488836,
-0.7284206748,
-0.5386247039,
-0.4205366373,
-0.7234925032,
0.1029831842,
-0.5202214122,
0.4896902442,
-0.6183960438,
0.20916453,
-0.0886813551,
0.1408106983,
-0.417122066,
0.0040025623,
0.1395528764,
1.2347447872,
-0.5067876577,
0.6776484847,
0.5225592852,
-0.1151816398,
-0.5354548693,
-0.3382905424,
0.1469168365,
-1.2488296032,
0.7234756947,
0.2588936687,
-0.1419360191,
-0.1917007267,
-0.3415846229,
-0.8599533439,
1.1523264647,
0.6561403871,
-0.5658218861,
0.1015211567,
0.5383269787,
0.5361103415,
-0.1340149939,
0.3848424852,
0.6162747145,
0.5246528983,
0.4219874144,
-0.8112854958,
-0.0641906112,
-0.4554044306,
-0.2729766667,
0.6504508853,
-0.9215061069,
1.0228813887,
-0.0371329449,
0.0667848215,
0.177902028,
0.5750234127,
0.679307878,
0.3042269647,
0.5982198119,
0.9940771461,
0.7676488161,
-0.5210475922,
0.7934381962,
-0.0719954297,
0.2466226965,
0.9123805165,
-0.5667499304,
0.7492513061,
0.0970647335,
-0.4510639906,
0.4245055318,
0.2936187387,
-0.0746981576,
0.4591637552,
0.6868476868,
-0.3588956296,
-0.2925842702,
0.0817100182,
-0.4922088385,
0.4828666449,
0.41604954,
-0.0389832519,
-0.5443584919,
-0.6231302023,
0.5183572173,
0.1662956923,
-0.4632928073,
0.387834847,
0.1148819029,
-0.863894999,
0.6425846219,
0.0624179281,
0.457100153,
-0.8123099804,
-0.1198675558,
-0.6132970452,
0.6403644085,
0.1070769504,
-0.7326456308,
0.0395933613,
0.2376343012,
0.1669230461,
-0.2514281869,
0.4965089262,
-0.3200166523,
-0.6194236875,
0.1100857854,
0.5067923665,
0.138897866,
0.0344289988,
-0.7454469204,
0.4284459054,
-0.3345305026,
0.0548815019,
0.3253718615,
0.925173223,
-0.1753056794,
0.8857288361,
0.8703014851,
0.2125882804,
0.2659375668,
0.2033794224,
0.6649145484,
-0.7689094543,
-0.3668759763,
-1.0796934366,
-0.0623791628,
-0.0343465805,
-0.3240263462,
0.7867307067,
0.6875617504,
0.6626887918,
0.1618840545,
0.4791061282,
0.2615628541,
0.2102643996,
-0.5951192975,
0.4762414396,
-0.5203542709,
0.4398047626,
-0.1649742275,
-1.0497398376,
-0.5254071951,
0.854551971,
-0.4153468609,
-0.0178129431,
0.681112051,
0.4569837451,
-0.0658081248,
0.0090041161,
0.4148930311,
0.0669201091,
0.6464207172,
1.0003955364,
1.3369846344,
-0.2541776597,
0.6807674766,
-0.2146119624,
-0.4150360227,
-0.0632209331,
-1.1680704355,
-0.9425455332,
0.1784713566,
-0.127354607,
-0.1724990457,
-0.0744539872,
0.8397051096,
0.3305521607,
-0.4337149262,
-0.5358909369,
-0.180968821,
0.2292407304,
-0.2675622106,
-0.1860652268,
0.1188994125,
-0.2980919182,
-0.8855810165,
0.2881004512,
0.2278507352,
-0.167187959,
-0.3230759203,
-0.1493279934,
0.1951740533,
0.22283943,
0.4491024017,
0.2626906037,
-0.2867216766,
0.1854529381,
0.1744292229,
0.0474922545,
-0.0290444754,
0.8937165141,
-0.6956742406,
0.1829438359,
0.3161915541,
0.8032069206,
0.5375223756,
-0.443593353,
0.6559652686,
-0.2229738235,
0.2123159766,
0.2262837738,
0.6186408997,
-0.0327733755,
0.3039237559,
0.7828502655,
0.293503195,
-0.2280250192,
-1.0674967766,
0.1159717143,
-0.6279549599,
0.122798048,
1.0640954971,
-0.1748895794,
-0.2768200934,
0.4347267449,
0.1106031612,
-0.2888125479,
-0.2746364474,
0.6957755089,
0.6951326132,
0.0802215114,
-0.0565032624,
-0.5092354417,
0.1344143003,
0.4667916596,
-1.0449342728,
-0.0265333634,
0.4694133103,
0.0570219755,
-0.0476319231,
0.2702102363,
-0.35939309,
0.5606017113,
-0.0365593582,
-0.2025907338,
-0.1507081538,
-0.3003993332,
-0.0674887672,
0.1430847496,
0.0633870065,
0.088839598
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15490v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15490v1 | Causal Discovery Inspired Unsupervised Domain Adaptation for Emotion-Cause Pair Extraction | 2024-06-18T13:01:30 | 2024-06-18T13:01:30 | Yuncheng Hua, Yujin Huang, Shuo Huang, Tao Feng, Lizhen Qu, Chris Bain, Richard Bassed, Gholamreza Haffari | cs.CL | cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, I.2.4 | This paper tackles the task of emotion-cause pair extraction in the
unsupervised domain adaptation setting. The problem is challenging as the
distributions of the events causing emotions in target domains are dramatically
different than those in source domains, despite the distributions of emotional
expressions between domains are overlapped. Inspired by causal discovery, we
propose a novel deep latent model in the variational autoencoder (VAE)
framework, which not only captures the underlying latent structures of data but
also utilizes the easily transferable knowledge of emotions as the bridge to
link the distributions of events in different domains. To facilitate knowledge
transfer across domains, we also propose a novel variational posterior
regularization technique to disentangle the latent representations of emotions
from those of events in order to mitigate the damage caused by the spurious
correlations related to the events in source domains. Through extensive
experiments, we demonstrate that our model outperforms the strongest baseline
by approximately 11.05% on a Chinese benchmark and 2.45% on a English benchmark
in terms of weighted-average F1 score. The source code will be publicly
available upon acceptance. | [
-0.2897671163,
-0.4982588291,
0.4709902108,
0.3568603992,
-0.2387446314,
-0.1555330902,
-0.0605426393,
-0.3467722237,
0.071581617,
0.1161167622,
-0.7026402354,
-0.3740353584,
-0.529027164,
-0.2320250273,
-0.1338220388,
0.8962652683,
-0.1693477482,
-0.0437509604,
-0.096457243,
-0.0959696621,
-0.3627193868,
-0.5403365493,
-0.5537778735,
-0.2832038105,
0.5639066696,
0.1218837202,
0.1146087646,
-0.0056970296,
0.5955262184,
0.1238188148,
0.2619749308,
0.1482265294,
-0.8203011155,
-0.1006526649,
-0.3707419932,
-0.2874023616,
-0.5156933665,
-0.0446768962,
0.2237474769,
0.5259262323,
-0.2366323769,
-0.1965282261,
0.1144871414,
0.9086892605,
-0.8316115141,
0.1611950099,
-0.533221066,
0.1617295742,
-0.0686706305,
-0.4494180381,
-0.3410604298,
0.0366758108,
0.1728432178,
-0.7709272504,
0.5511198044,
-0.0571391918,
0.7282537818,
0.4436362088,
-0.8210193515,
0.1233336404,
-0.6648510098,
0.4146276712,
-0.6111782193,
0.3255634904,
0.0668660924,
-0.0685082749,
-0.3601711094,
-0.5210809708,
-0.6356496215,
0.1825714856,
-0.01677333,
0.3373426795,
-0.6229963303,
-0.1657272875,
0.1427096575,
0.453800261,
-0.8399916291,
0.0859122127,
0.0205437187,
0.0751312971,
0.8428403139,
0.1957197636,
0.4254699051,
-0.2177052051,
-0.4615841806,
-0.119710885,
-0.8725336194,
0.1211288348,
0.2201680392,
0.0150989331,
-0.4296200871,
0.0887233838,
0.0456722043,
0.3005596697,
0.2875446379,
0.5131722093,
0.20630458,
0.0531796739,
-0.3763118982,
-0.1921721548,
0.847751379,
0.4979930222,
0.0423994958,
-0.1613425314,
0.0165418293,
0.0940008909,
0.2546161413,
-0.8991381526,
-0.5945882201,
0.0247773044,
-0.6226167679,
-0.2297205478,
0.2191779315,
-1.179330945,
-0.7650337815,
-0.4545387924,
0.5386190414,
-0.17771703,
-0.6152011156,
0.3188204169,
-0.0942531824,
0.3094544709,
0.3840792775,
-0.6782268286,
0.4331229031,
0.4589001834,
0.6032024026,
-0.587557137,
-0.0661298633,
-0.3958288133,
-0.0903567374,
-0.3302235603,
0.6522029042,
-0.2590402961,
-0.484851867,
0.0019892952,
0.2841921747,
-0.1769586802,
-0.341313839,
0.5251342654,
-0.7168812752,
0.2336246669,
-0.3634727001,
-0.5943437219,
-0.4026523829,
-0.2859353125,
-0.6850515604,
0.8454198837,
0.2275087237,
-0.7438223362,
0.3119456172,
-0.5159232616,
-0.5943948627,
-0.1775661111,
-0.0373582207,
-0.3621261716,
0.5090876818,
0.3239576519,
0.5687252283,
-0.7502496839,
0.4648241699,
-0.5163217783,
-0.0987521932,
0.0362715796,
-0.3217824996,
0.7088797092,
-0.0376229845,
-0.7270202637,
0.0703962371,
-0.8266532421,
-0.7125558257,
0.4696466625,
0.3412795067,
-0.8186559677,
0.0601122975,
0.0715540946,
0.4693528116,
-0.0285352413,
-0.2874149382,
0.2017470747,
-0.3323777616,
-0.0681318566,
0.9870585799,
0.5275884867,
0.5272356272,
0.0372425355,
0.3444920778,
0.4834814072,
0.1383596212,
0.1623309702,
-0.2702670693,
-0.7765224576,
-0.0329170153,
-0.0200983509,
0.4186787605,
-0.5651744604,
0.4853925109,
0.0765121356,
-0.3761700988,
-0.3998665214,
0.0276938248,
0.2654186189,
0.7419863343,
0.3910434544,
-0.4682985246,
-0.3809135258,
-0.5983684063,
-0.1798972934,
0.1225664243,
0.0056130365,
0.5938745737,
0.5217379332,
-0.3784351945,
0.6928498149,
-0.8839169145,
-0.182791397,
0.4969938993,
0.6131347418,
0.1291870326,
0.6459735036,
0.8811886311,
-1.0156575441,
-0.4191321135,
-0.0096318573,
-1.0121041536,
-0.1689965278,
-0.2425086945,
-0.3121204972,
-0.0753642991,
0.432009995,
-0.278820008,
0.5976328254,
0.3486517668,
-0.529304862,
0.4449822605,
-0.1684037745,
0.4318004549,
-1.0973008871,
0.1156232283,
0.2007191181,
0.0731504187,
-0.409499079,
-0.2907193303,
0.065190509,
-0.0646109805,
-0.2975916266,
0.6029218435,
-0.4412883818,
0.1568450928,
-0.2431383878,
0.0082884263,
0.088002719,
0.6387068629,
0.0225917082,
0.4074157178,
0.8483039737,
-0.6010546684,
0.4660339057,
0.3264408708,
0.0293785166,
0.818859458,
-0.4875294864,
0.1110469475,
-0.2009150386,
0.044209674,
-0.9627003074,
-0.2333769798,
0.1474859267,
-0.4909158945,
0.5093071461,
-0.1116465256,
-0.1244924739,
-0.1269150227,
-0.1464026123,
0.4111618996,
0.6592915654,
-1.0840597153,
0.6656083465,
0.2496436685,
-0.2265084833,
-0.2817495763,
-0.3983445764,
0.0356851965,
-0.3921377063,
-0.5984400511,
0.5860647559,
-0.3360544741,
0.0200656857,
0.2598798275,
-0.0893845633,
-0.1880320162,
0.1998520195,
0.3870411217,
0.1110213771,
-0.4349855185,
0.260635525,
0.2405993342,
-0.049725946,
0.3646472394,
-0.1449841857,
0.0442087986,
0.1799986213,
-0.2325098068,
-0.4778962731,
0.687335372,
0.4787169397,
-0.2942275703,
0.6546683908,
0.7969714999,
-0.7061840892,
-0.4228317738,
-0.3516684771,
-0.3937279582,
-0.4007351995,
0.28928262,
-0.3107086122,
-0.8733282685,
0.6383595467,
-0.5785539746,
-0.7001248002,
0.7692278028,
0.5460529923,
0.0429509208,
0.9627866745,
0.9134206176,
-0.384258002,
0.5322797894,
-0.1082666963,
0.3099677265,
-0.8701164126,
-0.2416666895,
-0.1146689281,
0.0620871074,
-0.6435430646,
-0.4646873176,
0.3289159834,
0.3077451289,
-0.2639233768,
0.0023546624,
-0.2417361587,
0.1481544524,
0.4232872128,
0.2363710701,
-0.0955850482,
-0.0542637743,
0.2170806676,
-0.2931371629,
-0.5907768011,
0.1631078124,
0.9385739565,
0.0199892633,
0.5956825614,
0.3299241364,
0.5557612777,
0.6677291989,
0.2198210508,
-0.4573673904,
0.0711940825,
-0.2894254625,
-0.2182321995,
-0.067547366,
-0.4578121006,
-0.9934660792,
-0.0019517514,
-0.3172463477,
-0.803247571,
0.8624885678,
-0.0732151046,
-0.0978754461,
0.0724743679,
-0.5574935675,
1.12961936,
-0.0746879354,
-0.5778026581,
-0.2491843253,
-0.7294073701,
0.6569452882,
-0.3432046175,
0.03771016,
0.0620461218,
0.5031155348,
0.817587316,
-0.3254718482,
1.090793848,
-0.3166746795,
-0.0155619821,
0.1895432919,
0.2159984261,
0.5987796187,
0.11020118,
0.1532281637,
0.0698444694,
-0.5614221692,
-0.397154659,
-0.9998304248,
0.787951529,
-0.9634820819,
-0.508076787,
-0.190155372,
-0.2870477736,
-0.2275551558,
0.0275344867,
0.1711297333,
0.1805450767,
-0.4701766074,
0.048838079,
0.8194221258,
-0.2480574548,
0.4499048889,
0.8594020605,
0.2801666856,
-0.3480752707,
1.0432760715,
-0.5452789664,
-0.1563939899,
0.5537918806,
0.3052504957,
-0.1446633041,
-0.2056375593,
-0.0880917087,
0.2308536619,
-0.6519025564,
-0.3469188213,
-0.5135942101,
0.0742212161,
-0.6809945703,
-0.2361150533,
-0.4367856085,
-0.0524436347,
-0.7222679257,
-0.1500764042,
0.4413424432,
0.6479072571,
-0.4333673418,
0.2619320154,
-0.6316126585,
0.3850737214,
0.4786441028,
0.1809271127,
0.0620734803,
-0.707341373,
-0.1263123304,
-0.3673201501,
-0.2183661163,
-1.1386018991,
0.6982856989,
0.1307387501,
0.4659840465,
0.5815477371,
0.4536336362,
0.4744324982,
-0.3372139931,
0.7325584292,
0.3499848247,
-1.2128521204,
0.6902891994,
-0.3847986758,
-0.4039838016,
-0.0526034869,
0.7052200437,
-0.426093787,
0.1848328263,
-0.878965497,
-0.9830340147,
0.5714641809,
0.196162194,
-0.198146075,
0.1215978265,
0.6573290229,
0.0638099238,
-0.0335703269,
-0.6375274062,
-0.4520119727,
-0.2146968395,
-0.3134242892,
-0.3209145367,
-0.4018548429,
-0.1479634941,
-0.1399184912,
0.6166799664,
-0.1155842319,
0.4966216087,
0.4853827059,
-0.2765188515,
-0.4260567725,
-0.1457015872,
0.5630818009,
0.0358293355,
-0.3280529678,
0.1819621772,
-0.065070197,
-0.0856545419,
0.2369450182,
0.5338106155,
0.3720165789,
-0.2372192591,
0.4842330813,
1.0990319252,
0.1888719946,
-0.3305250108,
1.1038110256,
-0.1758126318,
0.0689302534,
-0.020169517,
-0.1979597509,
-0.1032190844,
0.5347409248,
0.3972108066,
0.0229159426,
0.5606453419,
-0.2144349515,
0.5545543432,
0.1605534405,
-0.5072699785,
-0.7503957152,
0.8073934317,
0.3585855365,
-0.0628395677,
0.3598223925,
-0.3123081028,
-0.6077409387,
0.7561554313,
0.4620741904,
1.1701148748,
-0.6431763768,
0.0474949703,
0.3297883272,
0.0804530457,
0.1149586961,
0.1969310641,
0.0407334901,
-0.7983188033,
-0.3467133641,
-0.2329497039,
-0.2266023904,
0.1340492517,
-0.9450652599,
0.0588929802,
0.00086764,
0.2433466017,
-0.1783803999,
-0.1052468792,
-0.8082587719,
0.5539007187,
0.212175414,
0.4034300745,
-1.3783339262,
0.6584830284,
0.5333325267,
-0.4742252529,
-0.7256840467,
0.0258436389,
0.2092101723,
-0.5484730005,
0.8101752996,
-0.2323239446,
0.1456566602,
0.0529353805,
-0.4336489141,
-0.6431295276,
1.0188459158,
0.2696433663,
-0.5602864027,
0.3394280672,
-0.2144685686,
0.6065896749,
-0.5076234937,
-0.0319507197,
0.2703664601,
0.0809153691,
-0.0241183545,
-0.4271022081,
0.4679990411,
-0.4380364418,
-0.1737687886,
0.0651604608,
-0.6274961829,
0.7638260722,
-0.1777188629,
-0.0122604799,
-0.5709076524,
0.8171721101,
-0.0181071293,
0.5772953629,
0.344088316,
0.3921316266,
0.866404295,
0.1375904232,
0.9589520097,
-0.2600268424,
0.5305064321,
1.1354458332,
-0.4587138295,
0.634178102,
0.3898967803,
-0.1449011415,
0.6104657054,
0.8644029498,
0.1262557656,
0.7635779977,
0.1753952652,
-0.3735886216,
-0.2242796719,
-0.1452362388,
-0.3556491733,
0.2918559313,
0.3371290565,
-0.3175249696,
-0.0623902529,
0.0550702401,
-0.1027564183,
-0.172473833,
-0.1678128242,
0.7100585699,
0.1971494406,
-0.3331987858,
0.4094196558,
-0.3084479272,
0.3877776265,
-0.1676652879,
-0.1491472125,
-0.533409059,
0.1961755306,
-0.1557456255,
-0.2872249782,
0.1190410256,
-0.1180158332,
-0.5332911611,
0.0962862521,
0.8702748418,
-0.4670181572,
-0.1793426126,
0.7565119863,
0.5506950617,
-0.0879837945,
-0.4825847149,
-0.611068964,
-0.1517538577,
-0.0933831558,
-0.5630323887,
0.4173068106,
0.9617474675,
-0.102177918,
0.0908085406,
0.7256657481,
-0.0981721729,
-0.0821510404,
0.2252909243,
1.0385650396,
-0.840124011,
-0.3472859561,
-0.7179011703,
0.7990346551,
-0.1435944289,
-0.2379522473,
0.3558405936,
0.252258122,
0.489566654,
-0.401563555,
0.7376672029,
0.0964548886,
0.0710455999,
-0.4078292847,
0.5602981448,
-0.9352329969,
-0.0483212434,
-0.6659322381,
-0.5560017824,
-0.4004225135,
0.4471651912,
-0.1679686606,
-0.1433753669,
0.8069248199,
0.7109284997,
-0.0353487469,
-0.1657273024,
0.387737155,
0.4025682509,
0.5011439919,
1.0439466238,
0.5542054176,
-0.6801526546,
0.0011917898,
-0.1472204328,
-0.5910989046,
-0.4433879852,
-1.2141234875,
-0.8167289495,
-0.9468581676,
-0.837336123,
-0.2205756903,
0.125847131,
0.5379463434,
0.7051089406,
-0.7842245698,
0.1842490137,
-0.4610122442,
0.1551112682,
-0.1397909224,
-0.3347593546,
0.8172808886,
-0.1961922348,
-0.4166960418,
0.4363038838,
0.3914227784,
0.1369412988,
0.22634013,
-0.0980122089,
-0.0917382464,
0.1196428835,
0.5728842616,
0.3420026302,
-0.4254797101,
-0.2025670111,
-0.1652437001,
-0.0493207537,
-0.0446679667,
1.0188963413,
-0.5067732334,
0.4982755184,
0.4942310154,
0.780352354,
0.6646383405,
-0.1956335902,
0.7608001232,
-0.7944010496,
0.243053481,
-0.0189731494,
0.5709368587,
0.3498339951,
-0.7096996307,
0.5981272459,
0.8455286622,
-0.5970873833,
-0.6364142299,
0.1728676856,
-1.3068873882,
-0.3091038167,
1.0818407536,
-0.4458163381,
-0.1821355522,
0.2162872106,
-0.0774780586,
0.5862655044,
-0.2598146796,
0.9916677475,
0.3784233034,
-0.2983448207,
-0.1921291202,
-0.0595017038,
0.60349226,
0.4875308573,
-0.9221951365,
0.1673490703,
0.4476414323,
0.1980932653,
-0.1822240502,
0.4203909338,
0.0771052241,
0.4381982088,
0.0552098118,
0.552683413,
0.2722681761,
-0.2220222652,
-0.6527576447,
-0.0150912963,
-0.2347453237,
-0.0244240779
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12570v1 | http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12570v1 | Applying Ensemble Methods to Model-Agnostic Machine-Generated Text Detection | 2024-06-18T12:58:01 | 2024-06-18T12:58:01 | Ivan Ong, Boon King Quek | cs.CL | cs.CL | In this paper, we study the problem of detecting machine-generated text when
the large language model (LLM) it is possibly derived from is unknown. We do so
by apply ensembling methods to the outputs from DetectGPT classifiers (Mitchell
et al. 2023), a zero-shot model for machine-generated text detection which is
highly accurate when the generative (or base) language model is the same as the
discriminative (or scoring) language model. We find that simple summary
statistics of DetectGPT sub-model outputs yield an AUROC of 0.73 (relative to
0.61) while retaining its zero-shot nature, and that supervised learning
methods sharply boost the accuracy to an AUROC of 0.94 but require a training
dataset. This suggests the possibility of further generalisation to create a
highly-accurate, model-agnostic machine-generated text detector. | [
-0.1879162788,
-0.9281965494,
0.7762900591,
-0.2408640832,
-0.1348323375,
0.0732550398,
-0.1265824288,
-0.6867105365,
0.0724245459,
0.4257751703,
-0.3316725492,
-0.5142610073,
-0.7342330813,
0.2510153949,
-0.8224565983,
0.8865618706,
-0.0966893435,
-0.4453864694,
0.1286989748,
0.0069796238,
0.0163263138,
-0.5725455284,
-0.6942922473,
-0.2427096814,
0.2253697962,
0.2105610669,
0.198597461,
0.7115210891,
0.23346816,
0.2435833365,
0.1237195432,
0.2616045475,
-0.1548370272,
0.3206858933,
0.085128285,
-0.4995593429,
-0.2113824785,
0.100985162,
0.7261950374,
0.1529326737,
-0.0843430981,
-0.0047963453,
0.0453710891,
0.3578552604,
-0.8690542579,
-0.0372371376,
-1.0705802441,
0.0723925233,
-0.2519965172,
-0.3285630047,
-0.9124572277,
0.1138824373,
-0.2869493365,
-0.3487485051,
0.6599362493,
0.0371220224,
0.6704175472,
0.1790528446,
-0.3789223433,
-0.571616888,
-0.7701231241,
0.9799370766,
-0.7217456102,
0.1195428148,
0.3721227646,
0.2746525407,
-0.0133856339,
-0.3898797929,
-0.7506933808,
-0.1414548755,
0.0974160731,
0.4107787311,
-0.5626503825,
-0.0080933273,
0.1557073146,
0.383628875,
-0.7793881297,
0.4256669581,
-0.0752305388,
-0.3116768897,
0.7460595965,
-0.0809702575,
0.4093954861,
0.050909888,
-0.2554019392,
-0.0260336325,
-0.7215825915,
-0.2899970114,
0.7705680728,
0.3042072952,
-0.0479051359,
0.6597702503,
-0.2500970066,
0.9266657829,
0.1150554791,
0.1409159899,
0.0723412633,
-0.0498888828,
-0.3110308945,
0.4123290181,
1.1203758717,
-0.0390453003,
0.5409117937,
-0.2379621714,
-0.5262902975,
0.5762110353,
0.1400246024,
-0.6376392841,
-0.4516215324,
0.2326035202,
-0.3083581924,
-0.8999218941,
0.027122274,
-0.2556553781,
-0.1174883246,
0.0318340957,
0.4683216214,
-0.317591846,
-0.1413324028,
-0.089684464,
-0.1880548,
0.2018938065,
0.333981961,
-0.9455093741,
-0.0526410453,
0.4384410977,
0.6718582511,
-0.2070154995,
-0.129075408,
-0.8373160362,
0.1910707951,
-0.7000840902,
1.1236871481,
-0.6502595544,
-0.2811020315,
-0.0491071045,
0.0960959643,
-0.1175398231,
-0.4186137915,
0.8569382429,
-0.4384312332,
0.4844494164,
0.3901646733,
-0.7692645788,
-0.0382122695,
0.2804308236,
-0.4555347264,
1.0138058662,
-0.0355773307,
-0.959184289,
0.5866634846,
-0.4341424406,
-0.5654648542,
0.1113832816,
-0.1947443485,
-0.5732817054,
0.1161621362,
0.4714768529,
0.6482171416,
0.1584502012,
0.1999614388,
-0.2578598261,
-0.3552003205,
0.0328253396,
-1.0175486803,
0.7624755502,
0.3305889964,
-0.3063899577,
-0.1127270088,
-0.8933284283,
0.1820841134,
0.1123454645,
-0.4456882477,
-0.3461106122,
-0.032887809,
0.0395098999,
-0.1799335033,
0.2504652143,
-0.7804917097,
0.0918886513,
-0.2357689738,
0.3680187762,
0.6625011563,
-0.0571547784,
0.4441483915,
-0.1268411875,
0.4579541385,
-0.1425153464,
-0.4334316254,
-0.7138689756,
-0.5928044915,
-0.6672618389,
-0.4678895175,
0.5040947795,
0.7692081928,
-0.919200182,
0.7180739045,
0.0765656233,
-0.5248760581,
-0.3089515567,
-0.1342450082,
0.3205184937,
0.3505683541,
0.0394868329,
-0.1566240489,
-0.6229961514,
-0.7816798687,
-0.522982955,
-0.473164916,
-0.3925410807,
0.0407643542,
0.5601648092,
-0.2197097689,
0.6986314058,
-0.3400112092,
0.0603667758,
-0.2055338472,
0.411652565,
0.116615504,
0.5111296177,
0.5824517012,
-0.4731048346,
-0.6771347523,
0.3746533096,
-1.0786247253,
-0.3391691446,
-0.0153273623,
0.2061554492,
0.6332199574,
0.4490593076,
-0.5688479543,
0.4382889569,
0.518651247,
0.019017145,
0.5637413859,
-0.3013531864,
0.1747483909,
-1.1836841106,
-0.0913307369,
0.3350605965,
-0.4851701856,
-0.8659886718,
0.2964524329,
0.1889574826,
0.0888728797,
-0.1670535207,
0.47688061,
-0.4755556583,
-0.0207413603,
-0.577737689,
0.0258358587,
-0.1156213954,
0.18917647,
0.2552649677,
0.7467876673,
0.5788645744,
-0.6087011695,
0.1270300895,
-0.2474405617,
-0.3701065183,
0.5640889406,
-0.5421811342,
0.2496859133,
-0.1520867497,
0.1852296293,
-1.0682830811,
-0.552818954,
0.3080084622,
-0.8856275082,
0.4775950313,
-0.2725598812,
-0.5832486749,
-0.3058425784,
-0.0225312933,
0.2022204995,
0.6597216129,
-0.5717207193,
0.4158480167,
0.4449711442,
-0.0223093648,
-0.547080636,
-0.8120802045,
0.0467927009,
-0.1875240952,
-0.4244236052,
0.2802241147,
0.2109262198,
-0.2237790078,
-0.125036478,
0.0261404142,
-0.0715973377,
0.2101979703,
-0.1087965369,
0.1417024881,
-0.3162351847,
0.2867078781,
0.0122979945,
-0.1121217012,
-0.1524244994,
-0.5329854488,
0.6770560145,
-0.0399314649,
-0.5574489832,
-0.2994460166,
0.3243293464,
0.3977532983,
-0.1662427038,
0.490211904,
0.7558797598,
-0.512953639,
-0.355874598,
-0.346788615,
-0.2326205075,
-0.4332818985,
0.1745388657,
-0.1968565285,
-0.9336804748,
0.6658725142,
0.4098078012,
-0.0519403815,
0.7813326716,
0.6806623936,
-0.0144670047,
1.3162636757,
0.7951201797,
-0.1764303744,
0.2507906854,
0.2185190469,
0.3630922139,
-0.4264800251,
0.2029269785,
-0.6863262653,
0.0247943364,
-0.9206805825,
-0.1031613275,
0.1227996051,
0.0696243867,
-0.2418508083,
0.4812347591,
-0.7829221487,
0.5961602926,
0.6876277924,
0.0671511367,
0.4615744352,
0.1828281581,
-0.0115914838,
0.4426750839,
-0.7188757062,
-0.6166815758,
1.2864327431,
0.173659116,
0.6655739546,
-0.1416603923,
0.9071166515,
0.4098811448,
0.4275081158,
-0.7760783434,
0.3339770436,
-0.2502778172,
-0.6519573927,
-0.3074868023,
-0.4959380925,
-0.9798207879,
0.1792545766,
-0.1965724528,
-0.9713676572,
-0.1306726635,
0.3033578098,
-0.0889099911,
0.5056378841,
-0.7493823767,
0.5470825434,
-0.1068115905,
-0.1307498664,
0.1263583452,
-0.260756433,
0.5326399803,
-0.3075600863,
0.0817276686,
0.0422868766,
0.2103382051,
0.5978139639,
-0.1115492657,
0.7950634956,
-0.0002446926,
-0.4706555903,
0.8036240339,
0.3253606558,
0.7747035027,
-0.3899951875,
-0.0430505611,
-0.0073840432,
-0.3267132342,
-0.4910083711,
-0.3427331448,
0.5194507241,
-0.4463271797,
-0.5543370247,
-0.4444638789,
-0.5821725726,
0.1556956172,
0.2907781303,
0.7732374072,
0.3025517166,
-0.1474971473,
0.0732304826,
0.697373867,
-0.2847771049,
0.6093432903,
0.5634665489,
-0.3399767876,
-0.0508679971,
0.8945503235,
-0.0370071456,
0.2653467655,
0.575807333,
0.0309841037,
-0.1991360337,
-0.5825288296,
-0.8106534481,
-0.3227272928,
-0.5357670784,
-0.169519484,
-0.8236198425,
-0.3561525345,
-0.3687462211,
-0.166278407,
-0.1101675481,
-0.4196909666,
-0.2443901449,
-0.1089185327,
0.3583739102,
0.6047046185,
0.0214329287,
0.5314441919,
-0.7410191298,
-0.0249316171,
0.1163116395,
-0.0024395152,
-0.0226830188,
-0.6706257463,
0.023490103,
0.1290160567,
-0.3494319916,
-0.7464429736,
0.6518619061,
0.1562952697,
0.7119135857,
0.4639233053,
0.0749432072,
0.0222273506,
-0.5114962459,
0.7023606896,
0.0948001295,
-0.773111105,
0.6994507313,
-0.7745654583,
0.3357953727,
0.0459489413,
0.1646248996,
-0.3254562914,
-0.5708503723,
-0.765206337,
-0.4457568526,
0.5717800856,
0.4565165341,
0.139591828,
-0.1437283754,
0.0768891051,
0.1224166825,
0.1777809709,
-0.8421955705,
0.1839684099,
0.0781159624,
-0.5585396886,
-0.1900312454,
0.0903803185,
0.1937877536,
0.2788139284,
0.7223433852,
-0.371742785,
0.5212060809,
0.0240632519,
-0.1170943677,
-0.2416747957,
0.3244343996,
0.5219763517,
0.0557169057,
-0.0226573963,
0.3684256375,
0.1165384352,
-0.4066081643,
0.2456322461,
-0.0156097608,
-0.552347064,
0.1232733876,
0.6164761782,
0.5447940826,
-0.2457357198,
-0.5975884795,
0.3932205737,
0.3433108032,
-0.3557854593,
-0.248781547,
0.2410881966,
-0.2209365666,
0.042458605,
0.4504321218,
0.3229152262,
0.2850983143,
-0.5881059766,
0.4815564752,
0.8310690522,
-0.5635258555,
-0.2586797774,
0.7075250745,
-0.1198213324,
-0.3935768008,
0.3704078496,
-0.3531499505,
-0.7347734571,
0.9334369302,
0.6500893831,
1.0653889179,
-0.340953052,
0.3908757567,
0.1608760506,
0.5481491089,
-0.2571502626,
-0.0848428234,
-0.1516468674,
-1.1708725691,
-0.4737906754,
-0.620754838,
-0.3378756344,
0.1544640511,
-0.4677921534,
0.3370608389,
-0.1590262353,
0.0857695565,
0.2490589172,
-0.26132375,
-0.3043787479,
0.1180736646,
0.2519601285,
0.6710947752,
-1.0635333061,
0.7804588079,
0.6095842123,
-0.1980383247,
-0.6403256059,
0.3021858037,
0.1027495116,
-1.0891671181,
0.3245981038,
0.4257484078,
-0.144488737,
0.1460467279,
-0.8945925832,
-0.4785749018,
0.7784597278,
0.236871168,
-0.5364215374,
0.3164554834,
-0.1090551093,
0.6198660731,
-0.4326653779,
0.3128244877,
0.3478638828,
0.2390493155,
0.0245044101,
-0.8153973818,
-0.2244356275,
-0.228654623,
-0.3174319565,
0.4795908332,
-0.4005097747,
0.9732803106,
-0.0824744776,
-0.4794389009,
0.1783318371,
0.3829958737,
0.4874967039,
0.5594475865,
0.3164730072,
0.7967774272,
0.8270953894,
-0.0307607744,
1.1120774746,
-0.2802501619,
0.4749172628,
0.8259741664,
-0.4635865092,
0.8091737628,
0.1400880516,
-0.1729491353,
0.4071281254,
0.6200255752,
-0.1096863002,
0.3959939778,
0.0593173206,
-0.6087998748,
-0.4861632586,
0.1800293177,
-0.0306852031,
0.6443029046,
0.289960593,
-0.7484093308,
-0.3918623626,
-0.1180213764,
-0.080409579,
0.1504015476,
-0.4711307585,
0.6606988311,
-0.0161642935,
-0.7641997933,
0.5051062703,
0.2280418873,
0.9189383984,
-0.1962804347,
0.0705187395,
0.1161110029,
0.3706897199,
-0.1864120811,
-0.9544986486,
0.1187041625,
0.350922972,
-0.2215148658,
0.0681701675,
1.3938262463,
-0.4802284837,
-0.8659185171,
-0.0689418316,
0.6858594418,
0.4020751715,
-0.1923769861,
-0.1269485503,
-0.2640699446,
0.1552278697,
-0.0751966164,
0.3509548306,
0.6596084237,
-0.2573775947,
0.4987894297,
0.6129784584,
-0.2817595303,
-0.01226041,
-0.227566272,
0.4032664895,
-0.1780798584,
-0.4417544305,
-1.1921011209,
0.2108017355,
-0.0388950892,
-0.040972244,
0.7684066892,
0.5827829242,
0.9985826015,
-0.2709727287,
1.278808713,
0.0048003853,
0.5260796547,
-0.6535489559,
0.711040616,
-0.4140432179,
0.2656036019,
-0.2434961498,
-0.9058478475,
-0.3801040947,
0.8370723724,
-0.3472657502,
0.1228701696,
0.2831290066,
0.7216437459,
-0.2029825002,
0.2265774608,
0.52684021,
-0.0756923482,
0.1763702929,
0.4914608598,
0.8532581329,
-0.5958023071,
0.4742280543,
0.0791081786,
-0.247150436,
-0.1693831533,
-1.0221654177,
-0.8766362071,
-0.3514397144,
-0.31250301,
-0.138549,
0.0819934607,
0.306222558,
0.5312894583,
-1.0160412788,
0.0688761845,
-0.6320446134,
-0.0155104436,
-0.0489608124,
-0.2574157715,
0.1606025845,
-0.3239116669,
-0.819893837,
0.3296988606,
0.3496200442,
0.3845845461,
-0.223291412,
0.0531791337,
-0.0185575951,
0.087575078,
0.645858109,
0.2495073229,
-0.5407223105,
-0.5782427788,
0.1226405278,
-0.0032784715,
0.0199866686,
0.5232005715,
-0.9016413093,
0.216351226,
0.5828130841,
0.4955339432,
0.4728268385,
0.0150552979,
0.5987169147,
-0.9645656347,
0.1865073889,
0.1674198508,
0.3434256315,
0.2878194153,
-0.5022084713,
0.6127493978,
0.3253951669,
-0.6860279441,
-1.0394397974,
0.5343997478,
-0.6865406632,
-0.2958895862,
0.9336972833,
-0.2111868709,
-0.1965656132,
0.1050710455,
0.0300716013,
0.3507348299,
-0.4155495465,
0.5722121596,
0.6929190755,
-0.0877936035,
-0.4189317524,
-0.4754715264,
0.0847062916,
0.1522610039,
-0.7636407018,
0.0309559479,
0.3852317929,
0.1936205775,
0.3019679487,
0.4658228159,
-0.031471964,
0.1022045314,
0.3778856695,
0.1926534176,
0.2178828418,
-0.2919107974,
-0.0747383609,
0.1890299618,
-0.1059210673,
-0.155848369
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.